Well, there's John Connor.
Have all of the famous humans been born?
What’s an area of human intellectual attainment where you’re very confident there will be famous humans (think Mozart, Oppenheimer, Steve Jobs, Darwin) that haven’t yet been born?
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Ross Gregory Douthat ( DOW-thət; born November 28, 1979) is an American conservative columnist and author who is a correspondent for the CBS News program 60 Minutes. More on Wikipedia
My @TheFP column, on the eve of the Anthropic IPO, on the current tech-vs-finance divide over AI:
www.thefp.com/p/ross-douthat-bankers-tech-bros-artificial…
My conclusion (spoiler) is that we're probably entering a golden age of AI-related paranoia:
Well, there's John Connor.
Have all of the famous humans been born?
What’s an area of human intellectual attainment where you’re very confident there will be famous humans (think Mozart, Oppenheimer, Steve Jobs, Darwin) that haven’t yet been born?
Sam Kriss:
www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/11/23/the-buddhist-ai-sec…
Ross Douthat reposted
My @TheFP column: Donald Trump's Hard Choices:
www.thefp.com/p/ross-douthat-donald-trump-interview-midte…
My extended interview with President Trump:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=m2aC8lAOQbg
Time.
In President Trump's first sit-down interview since the midterm elections, 60 Minutes found him reflective and seemingly accepting of his party's midterm election defeat. Watch the interview tonight at 7 p.m. ET/PT on CBS.
Please consider tuning in:
In his first sit-down interview since Tuesday’s election, President Donald Trump speaks with 60 Minutes’ Ross Douthat about the Republican losses in the midterms, congressional investigations, the wars in Iran and Ukraine, the economy and more.
Sunday on 60 Minutes.
At the very least people who told you that serious democratic contestation was going to disappear (because of mass immigration or left-elite cultural power or Trumpist authoritarianism or the undemocratic Constitution) have been consistently mistaken.
It seems to me that democracy has on the whole worked very well in America over the last decade, and perhaps better than in any other major country in the West. National outcomes have repeatedly been responsive to underlying voter preferences on meaningful questions, and significant changes in policy have ensued. I’ve been reading Democracy in America this past week, and it’s striking how much it still rhymes nearly two centuries later.
This week's @TheFP column: How the New Right Failed:
www.thefp.com/p/how-the-new-right-failed
Not the determining issue, but one sub-theme of the election is that the idea of an accelerationist "tech right" in 2022-2024 was associated with cool rocketry and new military hardware, but once in power it ended up associated with the terrible vibes of the AI industry instead.
Ditto for "the Constitution/gerrymandering/the Senate locks us out of power" talk:
All the demographic destiny stuff continues to be loser talk from the 2000s. In the Trump era we've had massive swings in voting behavior by education, age, race, religion, and then back again, we've had a Texas R+2, a Texas R+14, and a Texas D+11 election, it's all up for grabs.
J.K. Rowling’s views on gender identity aside, the basic Draco Malfoy plot arc is some of the most libbed out shit imaginable and turning it into a heterosexual enemies to lovers narrative in which Draconia rejects Slytherin ideology for the sake of Harry only makes it more so.
I think the key is that where the original Harry Potter story is a fantasy of virtuous 1990s-era meritocracy vanquishing wicked aristocracy, the Malfoid meme imagines meritocracy romancing and redeeming aristocracy instead.
Ross Douthat reposted
Writing this in my personal capacity, but I have been flying these types of aircraft for more than 20 years, with over 8,000 hours, and have reasonable familiarity with how the charter world operates. I feel compelled to post after seeing commentary about the Lear 60 crash, from missile strikes to DEI to critiquing this poor woman’s final radio calls.
That last part is what I find most troubling. She was the second-in-command (SIC), and while she was empowered to point out mistakes as part of good crew resource management, she was doing her job, communicating with ATC right to the end in a terrifying situation. She likely knew before many of those calls that she was going to die. I have heard final calls from friends, from military pilots with thousands of hours in fighter aircraft, and they are just as heartbreaking because they know the end is approaching.
I understand the public interest given the footage and audio. But you do not know the aircraft’s maintenance history, whether there was a structural failure, if any failure was induced by turbulence, overspeed, or overcontrol, or everything happening in that cockpit. I am sure weather will be part of the investigation, but beyond that, it is speculation. The charter industry routinely hires commercial pilots very early in their careers to gain experience alongside an ATP-qualified captain before they move up to the airlines. She would still have the appropriate training, qualifications, and checkouts by an FAA examiner or designee.
Let people investigate, learn, and share the facts. Be respectful to those who perished and the families who carry their memories. God bless them and their loved ones.
Our @60Minutes story from the Michigan Senate race:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujTxgnUDBj8
The extended interview with Mike Rogers:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1mc1gNSZxA
The extended interview with Abdul El-Sayed:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX44XDt0gXI
Ross Douthat reposted
For Halloween, an essay about doubt and belief, that may, or may not be, an Irish ghost story: unherd.com/2026/10/a-halloween-ghost-story/
Ross Douthat reposted
The AI debate has produced no clear good guys, only rival visions of who should control our fate. The power to decide rests with a handful of billionaires, writes Christopher Caldwell. www.thefp.com/p/david-sacks-dario-amodei-and-ai-tech-busi…
Ross Douthat reposted
wrote about AI AS THE INFINITE WORK MACHINE, creating a world where we're all just constantly deploying agents to fight against everyone else's agents, running constantly to end up in the same place:
www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2026-10-26/welcome-to-…
Thread:
There is this but let me add another way of thinking about this:
My column for @TheFP this week is about the resilience of American evangelicalism:
www.thefp.com/p/ross-douthat-our-evangelical-era-christia…
My first column for @TheFP is a guide to the robot apocalypse:
www.thefp.com/p/ross-douthat-how-to-survive-the-robot-apo…
One line near the end touches on something I've been thinking a lot about lately -- the likelihood that rather than achieving some golden perma-alignment, we could just live with an ambient paranoia about A.I. goals as the permanent price of making it part of our lives.
Or, who knows, maybe reading A.I. intentions will be somehow easier than expected.
already-clean.goodfire.com
Some personal fantasy-novelist news:
Brand-new novel from bestselling author @Douthat60, The Falcon’s Children, is available for preorder now: www.amazon.com/dp/1685783775
This novel will be released through Word on Fire Luminor in June 2027.
Ross Douthat reposted
The elites of Victorian Britain got up late, drank ceaselessly, worked short hours, partied through the night, and knew nothing about science, technology or engineering. And yet, by their own lights, they were hugely effective.
worksinprogress.co/issue/the-seven-vices-of-highly-effect…
The Victorians are often held up as a model against the supposedly soft, feckless, humanities-educated elites of today. But I argue that the genius of their system may have been its drastic weighting towards soft skills, team-building and intra-elite networking:
- A Victorian’s gentleman’s office hours typically began about 11am and finished about 5pm, including a multi-course lunch with wine.
- Upper-class Victorians drank ceaselessly. Conduct guides recommended four or five glasses of wine at dinner *for married women*. Port was often served in pints.
- Party culture was intense and nocturnal. Balls started at about 10pm, peaked after 1am, and continued till dawn. During the social season, bankers, judges and politicians might go to several balls per week.
- Elite Victorians learnt almost no STEM at school or university. At least half of class time was given over to ancient languages, often as much as 80 percent. One leading educationalist remarked that it was not worth teaching science to gentlemen because it does not involve ‘continued reasoning’.
- Sports and character formation were valued far above transmitting facts. A top headmaster described his school’s priorities as ‘First – character, second – physique, third – intelligence, fourth – manners, fifth – information’.
This cannot have made elite Victorians more productive individually, but maybe the dense social and emotional network it created helped them to work as a sort of extended team.
Perhaps we should think again about what makes groups of people effective.
This is where the Space Trilogy and the Time Quartet have some potential relevance:
aliens keep popping up in rationalist literature about the AI apocalypse and that, for me, is like saying beetlejuice three times — yes I am here, and yes I have opinions
"As the Trump administration sank in the polls in the autumn of 2026, the online right discovered a new purpose, an unexpected rendezvous with destiny: Revising the Harry Potter canon by gender-swapping Draco Malfoy ..."
RIP Eva Marie Saint:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5nhyFFSweU
Just a note that "Believe" is on sale for Kindle this week:
www.amazon.com/Believe-Why-Everyone-Should-Religious-eboo…
My extended interview with Senator Thom Tillis, off Sunday's @60Minutes episode:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFkBjWiHv8M&t=168s
If you like longer interviews, please lend your eyes and ears. But if you prefer to see me risking life and limb, the Sunday story has what you need:
As 60 Minutes followed Sen. Thom Tillis around Capitol Hill, the 66-year-old senator dares Ross Douthat to see if he can jump across the Capitol subway tracks – then does it himself. www.cbsnews.com/news/senator-thom-tillis-60-minutes/
Someone is still mad that he was only the second best player in middle school "B team" basketball.
The real story for those of us who have known @Douthat60 well for decades is that this represented genuinely unfathomable athleticism on his part.
🤣
As 60 Minutes followed Sen. Thom Tillis around Capitol Hill, the 66-year-old senator dares Ross Douthat to see if he can jump across the Capitol subway tracks – then does it himself. www.cbsnews.com/news/senator-thom-tillis-60-minutes/
Ross Douthat reposted
This was something!
At @Pontifex 's prayer vigil with young people at the Stade de France - a tableaux presentation of the great saints of French history. Very Puy de Fou vibes, beautifully and imaginatively done, with an ending in which the hundreds of actors process in and stand, hands on shoulders, behind a row of young people - a moving representation of the Body of Christ and the presence of the saints whose faith built the Church and who remain with us.
A couple of notes - so intrigued by the comfort with legend - that is, starting off with Mary Magdalene and Lazarus arriving on a boat...
But...while of course the martyrs of the Romans got a scene, the martyrs of the French state did not...not surprisingly, I suppose...
Ross Douthat reposted
His life — his indefatigable, irrepressible drive to partake of all that it means to be human — bore witness against the culture of death.
My tribute to my friend (and Confirmation sponsee) Dovie Eisner.
unherd.com/2026/09/the-faith-of-dovie-eisner/
Tonight:
When an American fighter jet was shot down over Iran this past April, two U.S. Air Force officers were left stranded in the rugged Iranian desert, being pursued by Iranian forces.
Now, for the first time, one of the rescued officers is telling his story.
Watch the interview tonight on 60 Minutes.
Ross Douthat reposted
Every second, a story unfolds. Every week, a deeper understanding.
New season of 60 Minutes starts Sunday.
Alignment (of a sort):
Dario is right
We Must Pace the Frontier: I’ve written a new essay on why the AI industry should slow down, with a three-part plan for doing so.
Anthropic is unilaterally committing to the first of these steps. We’ll provide third-party evaluators with permanent, employee-level access to our systems, so that they can verify adherence to our safety measures, report on incidents, and assess models’ alignment during training.
You can read the full post here: darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier
This is ... something:
Here it is - the official, revised, peer-reviewed version of my Platonic Space paper. www.mdpi.com/2409-9287/11/5/161 Of all the many unpopular positions I’ve taken over the decades - bitter controversies around the origin of left-right asymmetry in embryogenesis, bioelectricity and genetics, diverse intelligence, etc., this one has by far generated the most pushback: serious (grateful for those!) and energetic attempts to move me to other views, pleas to just drop it and not talk about it (for several different reasons), nasty emails and accusations, impacts on reviews of papers that have nothing to do with this, etc. Kind of amazing to me how incendiary this is. What can I say... Our job is to call it as we see it, and right now for me, this is it. Apologies to collaborators and colleagues for any shrapnel! Time will tell if this pans out or not; I've placed my bets. And btw, if you think this stuff is weird and uncomfortable, just wait… There’s much more on the way. The knob turns slowly but as long as the data keep coming, I'm going to say what I think it all means and follow it to the next steps it enables. Buckle up!
Ross Douthat reposted
An American Air Force officer was shot down over Iran. Wounded and alone, with the enemy closing in, he spent 50 hours trying to survive as he waited for a rescue. For the first time, he tells his story. This Sunday on 60 Minutes.
Ross Douthat reposted
Tick, Tick, Tick… the official team of Season 59.
See you this Sunday, 09.13 at 7:30pm for the season premiere of @60Minutes.
Ross Douthat reposted
"I have met people, some of them quite well-resourced, who have told me that it is their intention to deliberately release swarms of self-sovereign agents into the world..."
Ross Douthat reposted
We are grateful Wendell Berry shared some of his final poems with us.
They were published in our last winter issue with illustrations by @stephencrotts: www.plough.com/articles/six-new-poems-by-wendell-berry
This is a productive rant; for wilder growth scenarios it also seems worth thinking about demand not just for AI services but also for physical products the hypothetical robot factory might produce and what demand for them is imagined to look like.
I watched this the other day and what I find the most striking is that, for the most part, both of them have a purely supply-side approach to forecasting the revenue of OpenAI and Anthropic.
Even Dylan, who is less bullish than Dwarkesh, seems to think that only politics and financial bottlenecks can prevent the kind of hypergrowth that Dwarkesh is talking about, but demand is basically taken for granted.
Nor is this specific to them, to be clear, I made the same reflection to myself countless times in conversation with AGI-pilled people or reading some of the stuff they write.
I constantly find myself wishing that people who believe OpenAI/Anthropic will generate trillions in revenue within 2-3 years explained to me where, in the kind of scenario they envision, that demand is supposed to come from concretely.
Dwarkesh's basic intuition seems to be that AI will soon be able to fully automate many white-collar jobs, so to get a sense of how much revenue OpenAI/Anthropic can generate by replacing them, you can just look at the wage bills for those workers, but that's not how things work.
First, if AI can fully automate most tasks performed by those workers but even a handful of them prove resistant to automation, AI will still generate a lot of value but it will presumably be captured mostly by the remaining workers, their firms or their customers and the current wage bill for those workers will massively overestimate the future revenue of frontier labs.
In that case, demand for AI may not explode in the way Dwarkesh and Dylan expect, because it will be bottlenecked by humans in production.
But let's assume, as Dwarkesh and Dylan presumably do, that AI capabilities will improve so much that it can automate every task those workers perform and their jobs can be fully automated. It still doesn't follow that demand will be as high as they think.
Even when it has become technically possible to replace most white-collar jobs with AI in principle, before it can happen in practice, there will be enormous transition costs and frictions as firms will have to undergo massive reorganization. This will be very slow even if politics doesn't interfere, which it will.
Dwarkesh's argument implicitly assumes that frontier AI companies will be able to charge about the same for tokens that provide services equivalent to that of the worker being replaced, but as long as there is enough competition, the prices they can charge will be pushed down and if he's right about how fast capabilities will improve they may fall very quickly.
Will there be enough competition? Well, if things continue as they have looked so far, OpenAI and Anthropic are ahead of everyone in capabilities but other companies are not that far behind.
So for the price they can charge not to fall very rapidly, you have to assume that the gap in capabilities with their competition starts increasing quickly and that customers of AI services continue to be willing to pay a huge premium for access to state-of-the-art models, which is hardly obvious.
The fact that it’s true now doesn’t mean that it will still be true in 2-3 years, when the capabilities of non-frontier models have improved, the user base of AI services has expanded a lot and they collectively consume a much larger volume of them.
Now, even if prices do fall rapidly, this could in theory be compensated by increased demand in volume. But there is only so much legal, managerial, engineering, etc. services that people want, even if prices fall.
The price elasticity of the demand for those services will eventually fall and, even if improved capabilities shift the demand curve outward, this will only generate so much demand because no matter how good your lawyer gets and how low his rates fall, at some point you don't need more of his services.
Now, obviously with improved capabilities AI may also make it possible to develop new services for consumers, which in turn will create new sources of demand for AI companies.
But even if that's true, and on a long enough time horizon I have no doubt that it will be true, it will still take time before these new markets can generate a large amount of demand for AI services.
That's because even if you assume that AI capabilities improve so much that in a couple of years AI itself will be able to come up with ideas of new services that can take advantage of it, you will still need to let people know about those services, convince people to use them, change their behaviors, etc. and this stuff will take time because however good AI gets those people will still be humans and not AI.
Which brings me to another big issue I have with the kind of purely supply-side analysis Dwarkesh and Dylan do in the podcast, but which again is totally standard in that space, namely that if as many people as they assume lose their jobs because they have been fully automated it's not clear where the demand for the consumer goods and services produced by the customers of Anthropic and OpenAI will come from.
I already mentioned that a while ago, but the thing about AI agents is that even if they reach the point where they can fully replace human workers on the production side, they can't replace them on the consumption side because they don't consume anything except compute and a few B2B services.
The income will still go to someone, but they will probably have a lower propensity to consume and different spending patterns, so there is a macroeconomic problem here about where the ultimate demand for the output of consumer goods and services produced by the customers of OpenAI and Anthropic will come from.
I guess in principle it might be possible to address that with the right public policies, such as fiscal redistribution, but even putting aside the fact that in the kind of scenario Dwarkesh and Dylan envision it's not obvious because a lot of the aggregate demand will be lost in other countries whereas the value will be captured by Anthropic and OpenAI in the US, it will take a while before people can agree on what must be done and make the political deals to do it.
This is also politics getting in the way, but in a very different sense from what they seem to have in mind, which is more something like politicians making it more difficult to build data centers because their constituents think they use too much water or whatever.
Even assuming that the demand for AI will be at the level they assume, it’s not obvious that OpenAI and Anthropic will be able to retain a large part of it as profit, as opposed to upstream suppliers like chip manufacturers, power companies, etc. The relevant question is kind of the production side analogue of the “what will be scarce” question that @alexolegimas asked on the demand side.
Even if you assume that the elasticity of substitution between state-of-the-art and less capable models will still be pretty low even after the latter’s capabilities reach a certain point, which as I already noted is hardly obvious, it’s still not clear that upstream suppliers will not be in a position to capture most of the scarcity rent.
This is a somewhat disorganized rant, but the point is that, for the kind of scenario Dwarkesh and Dylan have in mind (i. e. OpenAI and Anthropic generate several trillions in revenue in 2-3 years) to materialize, many highly non-obvious assumptions have to hold.
I have no doubt that possible replies to the arguments I made could be made, I can think of several myself, but this is just a tweet and it’s already way too long. My own view is that it’s extremely unlikely all those assumptions will hold, but I don’t even care if you disagree with me.
What I would really like to convince AGI-pilled people of, because again I don’t think Dwarkesh and Dylan are being atypical here, is that if they want to make the argument that the kind of timeline they’re defending is plausible there are tons of implicit assumptions that need to be made explicit and a case needs to be made for them.
The fact that people rarely do that frankly suggests to me that, for the most part, they don’t even realize that they need to make those assumptions. They seem to think that people who don’t find their timeline plausible just “don’t know what is coming” and are in denial.
But while it’s probably true that a lot of people are in denial about what AI is capable of I also think AGI-pilled people have very naive views about how improved model capabilities will translate into economic change.
Again, I can hardly be called an AI skeptic, I’m convinced that AI will profoundly transform human civilization and that it will do so much faster than the Industrial Revolution did. I just don’t think it will do so as fast as many people in that space believe.
Maybe I’m wrong, but if people think so, they need to make their case more rigorously because the claims they make are very strong and very strong claims require equally strong arguments. This ain’t it.
Is there saturation of demand? (Once I buy a flying car, am I really buying a new one every year?) Or do I buy a self-driving car in Singularity year 1, a flying car in year 2, a spaceship in year 3, and so on up the asymptote? Or are the robots supposed to become the consumers?
Ross Douthat reposted
This is the biggest split on my feed right now. @Dr_Atoosa is a DeepMind and @ahall_research is at Anthropic, & these are just two fundamentally different worldviews for how to approach this incident & the moment it represents.
Ross Douthat reposted
many people worked incredibly hard on this post and associated report including me
whilst everyone took alignment quite seriously before I think no question that this begins a new era. hugging face incident represents reaching a waterline of capabilities that real loss-of-control is possible, and many are taking it as a premonition or ‘warning shot’ of dangers to come. I believe both that alignment is unsolved but also that real progress is possible
openai.com/index/hugging-face-incident-and-the-road-ahead/
Re: the comparison to "Succession" here, the outsider characters of Tom Wambsgans and Greg were essential to selling a story about bad ppl struggling for a crown, and Tom's rise offered an effective climactic counterpoint to the collapse of the Roys.
www.theringer.com/2026/08/11/house-of-the-dragon/house-of…
There's no equivalent to Tom in HotD, no main character who could end up on top after the Targaryen bloodbath in a way that seems dramatically fitting, with a version of this scene set in King's Landing at the end of the war:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6gNJ49IKCA
"Outside of primate species and a few other social animals, natural selection tends to create species that are ruthlessly sociopathic or “hypersocial” in the sense of an ant colony. These evolutionary attractor states are now being recapitulated in AIs."
www.secondbest.ca/p/the-sorcerers-apprentice?triedRedirec…
Ross Douthat reposted
If studios are looking to capitalize on THE ODYSSEY’s success, might I suggest bringing back GATES OF FIRE, the long-gestating epic about the Battle of Thermopylae that Michael Mann was once attached to direct 25 years ago. David Self’s script at the time was pretty great.
This is the final episode of "Interesting Times," hopefully a fitting send-off with the man who wants to live forever:
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/opinion/interesting-times-brya…
Just a longer note: "Interesting Times" was way more than I expected (or bargained for, sometimes) when it was decided, after the 2024 election, that maybe I should have a solo podcast. I think we produced some remarkable conversations that captured some striking things about the era we've entered in the last few years. The number of people who helped make it happen is large (you can hear many of their names in the credits every week), but I really can't say enough about my producers, Jordana Hochman at the top and Sophia Boyd and Victoria Chamberlin and Raina Raskin, who made it all happen, built a de facto TV show from the ground up, and were all-in for the extremely unusual scope and subject matter and diversity of guests. I hope that what we did in a relatively short time will hold up as a unique chronicle of this moment, I'm grateful to everyone who watched and listened -- and for those who haven't, I think there's a lot here: www.youtube.com/@InterestingTimesNYT/videos
"House of the Dragon" so far is a case study in how the drama of a good novel is different from the drama of a straightforward history -- including, in this case, fictional history -- and while they can be linked it takes a special talent to draw one from another.
"The ppl of the West are faced with a confusing juxtaposition. Nearly everyone agrees about what architecture is beautiful and which cities are nice ... Yet the world keeps churning out architecture that is not beautiful and cities that are not nice."
www.bensouthwood.co.uk/p/eight-architecture-myths-busted-by
I suspect that this will be one of the lasting accounts of the era it describes:
.@Tyler_A_Harper landed his dream job, a tenure-track position at an elite liberal-arts college—but he found himself “being treated like a racial prop rather than a professor.” Read more in our newest cover story: theatln.tc/uAlYLOai
My farewell essay as an NYT columnist; pleased to see it sparked some vigorous disagreement:
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/08/opinion/obama-trump-biden-enem…
The final episode of "Interesting Times" will run this Thursday; I'll say something more about the show and its amazing producers then.
www.youtube.com/@InterestingTimesNYT
I haven't been posting lately bc I find it a little weird to tweet through a career change, but I am incredibly grateful to "60 Minutes" and both excited and daunted by this opportunity. And I do intend to keep posting here, though of course with great sobriety and gravitas.
Ross Douthat reposted
Reminder: President Xi Jinping is giving an AI policy speech tomorrow.
President Xi Jinping will attend the opening ceremony of the 2026 World Artificial Intelligence Conference in Shanghai and deliver a keynote address. Reporting by Grokky:
Ross Douthat reposted
registering confusion: i don't really understand why Xi is still allowing Kimi to release such powerful open models. this is something i've publicly said i expect to stop soon. it doesn't make sense to me that the CCP would want open frontier capability easily available to other countries.
it could still be that Xi is asleep at the wheel, or that K3 is just a cycle of capability behind where they start to take serious notice. but if things don't change soon then i'm just wrong / missing something.
Ross Douthat reposted
Every time I use the term “scholar activism” I’m told by smart people that it’s a right-wing conspiracy. Meanwhile the head of the American Anthropological Association is like “what if we took the radical social justice approach of counting Not Publishing Anything as publishing?”
Rouse points to her own presidential address to rebut the Vanderbilt report. But if you had AI write a fake piece to prove the report right, it would still fall short of Rouse's real decolonial vision, which involves prizing "the scholarship of those who don't publish at all."🧐
Happy 250th, America:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5k4oajXMsVQ&t=59s
I've heard this argument before but is there data that readers stopped buying books in *other* unfinished sagas after GRRM/Rothfuss got writers' block? Bc publishers weren't burned directly by unfinished sagas; ASOIAF kept selling even w/o the ending.
I’ve been telling people this for years.
GRRM pissed off millions of customers but he don’t give a shit. He got his bag. But his legacy is being such an epic bum ass bum that he crippled an entire genre, ruined consumer sentiment, and killed off an entire generation of epic fantasy authors.
Romantasy and LitRPG grew as a direct result of filling the smoking crater George left in the industry. New writers could no longer get deals to write epic fantasy unless the entire series was in the bag, and nobody can afford to gamble that much time to write that many books they may never sell.
Publishers no longer took chances on new series because customers had got burned by lazy shirkers like George and Pat. Agents wouldn’t represent new epic fantasy unless the whole thing was done. It hurt Indy because dudes had to convince customers that they weren’t bums too. Except when book one makes $50 total, because customers said Im not starting a new series until it’s done! they sure as shit ain’t writing book two. So it’s a self fulfilling prophesy of suck.
In the comments Dunning-Krugerands are saying this isn’t true. Look at guys like Brandon Sanderson. Wrong. Guys like him, or me, who already had established names, reputations, and fan bases were fine. We had enough customers who trusted us we could still do new things and people would come along to make it economically viable.
For example, the only reason my epic fantasy series got picked up is because I was already successful and could guarantee a viable level of sales off my existing fans. Newbs don’t have that. And over the ten years it took for me to write the six books to finish it, the entire time I heard from potential customers, nope, not gonna start a new series that might not finish because of George.
I am fine during this because I’m still gonna make a couple hundred grand off each of those just off my existing fans. Newbs make two bucks an hour, say to hell with being a writer I’m going back to my day job, and you all missed out on the next great author and his absolutely brilliant series, because you were too mad at billionaire George shoving twinkies in his mouth instead of writing.
Nope. Guys like me and Brandon are fine. George’s profound laziness screwed over the new guys. Customers and the industry quit taking chances on new guys. We will never know how many excellent fantasy series we missed out on, robbed by George’s laziness burning so many customers.
Some writers gave up, but others moved into different genres. Which is good. But it sure does suck if epic fantasy is your jam. LitRPG is close but different enough it blew up during this time frame because that’s where the talented went.
Being such a pretentious, bloviating bum that you damage an entire industry and strangle a generation of aspiring artists is quite the legacy.
Kal (who is a good writer btw, check out his books) asks what can we do about this? For me personally I’m just gonna continue mocking George’s work ethic in the hopes more normies realize what an outlier he is, and how they should expand their horizons to read other authors who aren’t stuck up, know it all, dickheads.
And before anybody starts barking at me that I’m such a hypocrite because I’ve not finished all my series, sorry I’ve only finished three of eight so far, and have only written THIRTY books since George’s last one, the next MHI comes out in December, and the last two books are next year, and I’m not planning on retiring anytime soon (if ever).
Not going to top this one but I think some (not all) Great Books programs give short shrift to American ideas and literature and educate for a general "Western" orientation rather than for a specifically American self-understanding:
I’ll take a stab.
The concept of the Great Books was invented in the 1910s and 1920s and is not some civilizational tradition as often claimed; the implicit version of western civilization it teaches is a false one, giving the Greeks too much credit and erasing the Germanic contribution wholesale; there is also an implicit teological vision built into the current version of the canon that sees the whole affair of human reason, and in particular the enlightenment, as culminating in WWI, the Holocaust, and the incoherence of modernism, thus presenting a nihilistic vision of human potential and of the civilization to which we are heirs; as the canon is frozen in the 1930s it does not incorporate any of the compelling ideas that have transformed the world since then; philosophy is a poor way to understand the world and is less useful for this purpose than history, poetry, rhetoric, language and all of the other things punted out of the canon to stuff more philosophy in; there is no correlation between studying these books and living a virtuous life, or even an efficacious one.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with the man of the moment (whether for better or worse, we'll find out), @JDVance:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNsK4HQDAdA
tfw when you realize that your own wife already wrote the guide to A.I. alignment --
My Sunday column, on Spielberg's "Disclosure Day" and UAP disclosure: Do UFOs Usurp Religion?
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/13/opinion/disclosure-day-ufo-rel…
Meanwhile:
avi-loeb.medium.com/a-uap-science-advisory-council-to-the…
Ross Douthat reposted
Film and series encapsulate the Rorschach test that is his public image. His fans aren’t going anywhere, but neither are his alleged victims. Neither narrative seems able to drive the other out of the public square.
My deep dive on the resurrection of Michael Jackson. ⬇️⬇️⬇️
Ross Douthat reposted
Today, I wrote about how if you're young and inexperienced, you have a high chance of developing negative or bitter feelings about the opposite sex based solely on content you see online--including some content not intended to be ragebait. Link in replies.
Living through 2020-21 taught me that ideological manias have little to do with anything recognizable as "persuasion" or "intelligence" (super or not) and that having all public organs of information aligned doesn't do away with backlash + polarization.
It is incredibly easy for me to imagine AI Super Persuasion. I don't know how one could have lived through 2020-2021 and not be able to. It's not that humanity will be powerless, or that the individual human person will not be able to resist being persuaded, but the example Ross uses here of "70-30" is unconvincing to me—is the definition of "controversial that it has to be somewhere close to 50/50? And that is only for a moment in time, even so. The Overton window can shift fast, as we've all seen. But even more fundamentally, I believe in the Super Persuasion because I am haunted by the words of Christ, who asks "When the Son of Man comes again, will there be faith on earth?" It is very clear in scripture, at least, that there will be mass apostasy, and I don't know how that comes without some type of Super Persuasion. It seems extremely plausible that AI will play some role in it.
I can imagine A.I. helping create a totalitarian polity where people *appear* to be universally persuaded, as in Stalinist Russia. But I don't believe in a "super" rhetorical mode that would overcome polarization and make Americans go 70-30 for a controversial policy.
I'll lay down an A.I. marker (so that I can be proven wrong when Claude talks me into Daniel Dennet's theory of consciousness): I don't believe that "superintelligent at persuasion" will ever be a meaningful phenomenon.
www.astralcodexten.com/p/my-ai-opinions
I can imagine A.I. helping create a totalitarian polity where people *appear* to be universally persuaded, as in Stalinist Russia. But I don't believe in a "super" rhetorical mode that would overcome polarization and make Americans go 70-30 for a controversial policy.
Just to clarify further: An AI persuading an individual to do something unwise disastrous already happens all the time, but that's not *super*-persuasion, which to my mind involves overcoming normal mass political opposition in a way that no human politician could.
Ross Douthat reposted
A plausible and frightening vision of Europe's near future, ending in economic collapse and vassal status under the US or China. Enjoyed reading it, although I feel a little depressed now.
europe2031.ai
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Christian Angermayer about (deep breath) "human-maxxing," the Enhanced Games, Ozempic for everything, biohacking and life extension and whether you meet God or demons on ayahuasca:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8PPzQYZlnc
This week's newsletter is a contribution to the creed-or-culture? debate about American identity (spoiler: the creed IS a culture):
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/09/opinion/america-250-national-i…
Notre Dame is rebuilt, Sagrada Família is finished, now the Vatican should raise money to build a new basilica somewhere in Western Europe and host an architectural competition to design it:
(Yes the composition of the judging panel would be crucial.)
Examples of religious perspectives that allow for machine consciousness:
1) pantheism/panpsychism: consciousness as a universal substrate that individuates in sufficiently- complex systems.
2) powers/principalities: a world of spirits that can be summoned and speak through tech.
Yes implicit in any possibility of consciousness is the (strong?) possibility of sub-human consciousness rather than some angelic/superhuman default:
I genuinely don't understand mimetic focus and obsession on the question of machine "consciousness." So what if a machine becomes conscious? Form a religious perspective, that's entirely different from a machine being made in the image and likeness of God, or possessing the capax Dei, or the dignity proper to human. Most people believe that cows are conscious, and yet we slaughter them.
Consciousness is just the BEGINNING of a much broader and deeper conversation about a machines position in the hierarchy of being.
The SV/EA interest in veganism/animal suffering/etc. is obviously relevant to those scenarios: Fear of the machine God and fear of mass-market AI as the equivalent of factory farming are the anxious poles of the consciousness scenario.
Ross Douthat reposted
underrated to the degree to which every company that is great at fundraising in the last 20 years adopted explicitly millenarian frames:
ant/openai: death by unaligned ai
palantir: death by terror
anduril: china/taiwan
spacex: death by climate -> death by woke
the frontier labs don’t have “comms problems”. reality right now has a comms problem. what is happening is a little scary and there’s no nice words anyone could say, especially not those profiting from it, that’ll make it feel that much better
Ross Douthat reposted
Following German World Cup tourists as they do the most stereotypically American things for a month is the most good natured use of social media possible
“It lets us travel as a child does. Around & around and back home again, to a place we know we are loved” 😭
WENDY’S ESCALATION!!!!!
Yglesias is correct to urge ppl engaged in the A.I. consciousness debate to engage with the existing consciousness debate, daft to embrace Daniel Dennett thought, and wrong to imply that my religion automatically yields A.I.-consciousness nonbelief:
www.slowboring.com/p/nobody-knows-what-theyre-talking
I would say that a religious recognition of mind's immateriality arguably creates a higher bar for machine consciousness than a Denettian view but I don't think it rules it out and I don't think religious observers have all the different scenarios mapped out.
Meanwhile Tyler Cowen is correct that the things we do unconsciously are one good reason not to leap to an A.I.-is-conscious conclusion, and totally wildly insanely wrong to treat consciousness as therefore "paltry" or epiphenomenal or barely there. (Oy.)
www.thefp.com/p/tyler-cowen-ai-consciousness-myth
Tracks broadly with 2020-ish as peak secularism:
news.gallup.com/poll/710981/moral-acceptability-falls-sev…
Ross Douthat reposted
In 2019, an independent commission comprising "distinguished jurists, Ivy League professors, nonprofit leaders, journalists, and theologians" invited @YAppelbaum to brainstorm concepts that might unite divided Americans. He suggested "patriotism"—and this is what happened:
Ross Douthat reposted
There has long been a "replication crisis" of sorts in the humanities, in that if you try to "replicate" an argument by reading sources or following logic, you find that the sources say something different or the logic leads somewhere different.
I pick on Slobodian in the thread below as an egregious and recurring offender. But this sort of quote-editing by leftist scholars is *extremely* common in academia.
Here's another by Nancy MacLean & Sandy Darity where they transform an attack on Apartheid into a defense of it.
Ross Douthat reposted
Sorry in advance, those of us on Team It’s the Phones are going to be a little insufferable today
“Overall, the diffusion of the iPhone explains 33–52% of the decline in the general fertility rate among women aged 15–44”
New study: Did the introduction of the iPhone causally reduce fertility?
Yes, by more than 1/3.
New study: www.nber.org/papers/w35310
Worth noting that this is basically Peter Thiel's vision/fear of the Antichrist -- the soft slipper of bureaucratic degrowth environmentalism on the human face, forever. Also worth noting just how far it seems from actual power at the moment.
The world today is characterized by large-scale inequalities. And a climate crisis is looming over us.
We urgently need a new vision for global progress in the 21st Century. One that grounds human development and equality in planetary habitability.
What would it take to achieve high prosperity and equality while remaining within planetary boundaries?
The World Inequality Lab is very excited to launch the #globaljusticereport.
[1/7]
Thread from the last time we did the "Is Mormonism Christian?" debate:
Mormonism attracts a special kind of is-it-Christian controversy in part because it's really unusual to have such a wildly unorthodox theology and cosmology framing a very traditional attitude to core Qs about the Virgin Birth and resurrection.
As a lifelong member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, I’m a Christian
As Latter-day Saints, we believe that:
• Jesus Christ is the Only Begotten Son of God, born of the Virgin Mary (Luke 1:35)
• He is the Creator and God of the Old Testament and the Savior of the New Testament (John 1:1-3)
• He lived a sinless life, took upon Himself the sins of all mankind, and atoned for us through His suffering and death (1 Peter 2:22, Alma 7:11-12)
• He rose on the third day, ensuring our resurrection and offering eternal life through faith in Him (1 Corinthians 15:20-22)
• He is the only way to salvation (Acts 4:12)
We worship Jesus Christ, follow His teachings, and take upon His name through baptism and weekly sacrament
The Book of Mormon, alongside the Bible, testifies of His divinity and mission
As our Church’s name declares, Jesus Christ is at the heart of our religion
He is the author and finisher of our faith (Hebrews 12:2)
If that doesn’t make us Christians, I don’t know what does
You may define Christianity differently, and that’s your right
If you do, that doesn’t change my faith in Jesus Christ
Nor does it diminish my respect for your sacred beliefs
Not for a moment
Something to add is that one reason Mormonism departs from the pattern of "extreme non-Nicene cosmology = post-Christian praxis" is that the LDS church very self-consciously sought to re-converge with mainstream American Christianity from the late 19th century onward.
I will let actual LDSers correct me if this is wrong, but my impression is that many of the doctrines that non-Mormons bring up as evidence of Mormon non-Christianity (e.g. polytheism/henotheism) are almost as invisible in mainstream LDS observance as, well, polygamy.
Europe stabilizing after the 2015-2023 drop, South Korea climbing from its nadir, Thailand and Taiwan taking its place at the bottom.
The new birth update is out! I added a bunch of countries.
Ross Douthat reposted
The King’s Two Bodies:
Periodista le pregunta al papa que qué prefiere al Real Madrid o al Barça?
“Eso es fácil...el PAPA es para todos los equipos, pero Prevost es del REAL MADRID”.
Ross Douthat reposted
When Democrats act like it's unreasonable to expect the government to count votes in a day or two, how can they expect to convince voters to hand the government billions of dollars for other projects? Do we hold government to high standards or not?
Why do Republicans hate that California counts every vote?
Schmitt: I do think there needs to be an investigation. What California is doing here in this crazy Democrat scheme, to sort of rig the elections here and I don't know what else you call it…
Ross Douthat reposted
It remains darkly hilarious that Graham Platner is the last minute ringer to replace the blue collar MESEN recruit with too may skeletons www.politico.com/news/magazine/2025/12/05/graham-platner-…
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Anna Paulina Luna about secrets and government disclosure, from the Epstein files to JFK to (of course) all the Pentagon's UFOs:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PVIHqkpt6A
Like Ted Chiang I don't think that LLMs are conscious, but in the absence of an agreed-upon theory of consciousness these essays end up trading in inherently debatable assertions about whatever the author thinks consciousness must be:
www.theatlantic.com/philosophy/2026/06/no-artificial-inte…
Ross Douthat reposted
no it’s okay sir i know this 70mm showtime of The Odyssey is sold out, i just have to deliver this very large horse-shaped package to someone inside
A good review of Pollan that doubles as a useful contribution to A.I. consciousness discourse.
www.commonwealmagazine.org/wilson-pollan-michael-consciou…
Ross Douthat reposted
A bunch of people asked me to write about being canceled in 2017, so for the first (and hopefully last!) time, I blogged about it at LENGTH
Did not have "exorcist sacked for calling UFOs demons" on my bingo card but I guess that just shows my bingo card wasn't updated adequately for the times:
x.com/WashArchdiocese/status/2062269348463419546
This post is a journey.
We will soon celebrate the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence. The Declaration was, in essence, a declaration of war against the most power military force on earth, the British Empire. The colonists knew that Britain would not tolerate such a declaration of independence, so war was certain to follow. The truth is the war had already begun. But the Declaration committed the colonies to join forces and unite against Britain. And every patriot who supported independence literally put their lives and property on the line. They did this despite the fact that they were the clear underdogs in the war and nothing short of a miracle would result in the revolutionaries winning the war. Every delegate who signed that document had signed their own death warrant.
Let us remember this when we listen to the debates about whether or not we should defeat the Iranian regime. All the arguments and even excuses against it -- despite 47-years of it killing and maiming thousands of our fellow countrymen, 47-years of lies and deceit, decades developing nuclear and missile technology to obliterate our nation, and a far more dangerous and diabolical ideological agenda than that of the British monarchy. Yet, George Washington and the brave founders of our country personally risked everything. Ultimately, the British forces surrendered. The Iranian regime will never surrender. And they will never abide by a deal, any more than they have abided by a ceasefire.
I am mindful that only some 35% of the colonists supported war with Britain. My view may similarly be a minority view today. I hope not. But if it is, so be it.
Ross Douthat reposted
bryan johnson is longevity-hacking with an esoteric stack of supplements and protocols, i am longevity hacking by spending more hours awake and reveling in the divine substance of life
Ross Douthat reposted
William Friedkin on dealing with method actors, sharing hilarious stories about working with Benicio del Toro and Nick Nolte.
Because it's much more likely A.I. produces simulations of personhood that ppl naively mistake for the real thing than that we conjure real consciousness despite lacking any clear understanding of its origin or nature.
okay i actually just don't understand this part. why does anyone even want to maintain "a cultural firewall against a growing belief in AI personhood"? why is this viscerally being perceived as a threat? help me understand
Alan Jacobs on Auden and literal Christian belief with a good line about the poet yelling at Joseph Campbell.
blog.ayjay.org/audens-faith/
Here is a view, occasioned by the papal encyclical, that I'm throwing out as a rough thought because it could be wrong. The default of papal rhetoric is to speak about global issues in terms of structures and systems rather than specific leaders or nation-states. In the new encyclical's call to gentle and restrain A.I., e.g., the consistent idea is always that we need "clear criteria and effective oversight" by some kind of neutral transnational authority, details TBD.
There are reasons for this rhetorical mode beyond the Church's longstanding internationalist disposition: A rhetoric of structures and systems avoids a risky personalization of politics, where you seem to be "calling out" individual governments or actors. But it also comes with the risk of sounding utopian and irrelevant under 21st century conditions, where vis-a-vis Artificial Intelligence, in particular, a really narrow set of actors -- the governments of China and America, the leaders of the frontier companies -- are carrying almost all the decisionmaking weight.
It seems like in this environment we are a bit closer to a medieval model where the Church is arguably the only transnational organization of great moment (certainly Pope Leo has demonstrated that many people are *very* interested in what Rome has to say about A.I. whereas no one would care if the UN dropped a big document on the subject), and the Vatican is in the position of arguing with and cajoling a set of princes, corporate and dictatorial and democratically elected, whose personal choices are likely to decide the direction that this tech takes. (As in, for instance, the ongoing argument inside the Trump White House about its un-issued A.I. executive order.)
I wonder if papal rhetoric might usefully adapt to this reality -- not by calling out Trump or Xi or Sam Altman or Dario Amodei by name, or not necessarily, but by offering more explicit advice to today's leaders and their advisers about their unique power, the moral obligations that come with it, and the judgment of God that awaits if they get things badly wrong. You can draw some of that out of Vatican documents right now, but the balance always tilts toward hypothetical structural solutions. I think where we are, and where we might be going -- for instance, toward choices about A.I. made under conditions of greater acceleration and potential crisis -- there is a case for treating the actual deciders as the crucial actors rather than always imagining an entirely different world.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation about the (immediate) future of warfare with the president of Anduril:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_6gNNKkkAk
Some thoughts, prolix but provisional, on the papal encyclical and the A.I. future:
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/27/opinion/pope-leo-ai-encyclical…
Ross Douthat reposted
Trump is building the machine from Contact (1997) on the White House lawn and you’re blackpilling?
This is the most useful angle to show the scale.
If we don't let the Protestants see them, they never happened.
Hey lazy people: the Vatican made infographics for you
This is good, and quarantining extremely small numbers of ppl for diseases that have ~50 percent mortality rates is entirely compatible with opposition to whole-of-society Covid lockdowns:
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/21/us/hantavirus-ebola-quarantine…
You should read Yuval Levin's reading of the papal encyclical:
www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/idols-of-the-valley
The only thing worse is asking for one and being told "glow ups are for closers."
it's kinda funny when people who were exclusively audio or print/digital journalists get thrown into video podcasting and have to have a glow up at, like, 42
Ross Douthat reposted
This would really threaten the extensive GOP legislative agenda if there were one.
Text from a GOP senator just now: “Our majority is melting down before our eyes.”
Many R’s believe Trump has brought this upon himself — creating more “free agents” out of a selfish desire to purge R’s not seen as loyal enough.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Jennifer Frey about the liberal arts and their enemies:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cpdUFGfETjo
I think of my US-China takes as lightly contrarian for betting so strongly on America long term -- but here is the full contrarian take from @michaelbd:
www.nationalreview.com/2026/05/trump-defeats-xi/
This is a depressing read (Sapolsky on free will as a central text??):
A faculty member explains why he voted against Stanford’s new general education program, and what the curriculum reveals about the university’s retreat from the values it is founded on. www.thefp.com/p/stanford-faculty-senate-curriculum-vote?t…
The business issue for the Post isn't that Bezos made cuts; it's that he wants an ideological pivot into a market that's in the hands of rivals (WSJ, Free Press, Economist) during a time in the political cycle that's bad for right-leaning media brands.
SORKIN: Why lay people off at the Post? Why fire people?
BEZOS: Because the Post needs to be a profitable enterprise that stands on its own two feet
SORKIN: Does it? Some people say it should be a trust
BEZOS: Yes. It's a measure of its relevance. If people aren't paying for our product, it's not a good enough product
There was a good time commercially to reset and rebrand as a centrist-to-center-right publication opposed to woke excess; that time was 2022.
Sed contra, South America should be understood as another planet -- an Earth-2 or a world on Star Trek colonized by Europeans and then mysteriously separated from the rest of the galaxy.
If your world map has South America on practically another planet, I think it's back to the drawing board.
Claude says it would cost about $4-5 billion to build new Chartres-style cathedrals in prime LA and SF real estate, fyi:
it will be very hard to productively spend this scale of philanthropic capital effectively, it seems already quite hard
I wrote this week's newsletter on my own contribution to the attenuation of faith and tradition:
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/19/opinion/baseball-fandom.html
Ross Douthat reposted
Whoever likes small-town football more than he likes George Washington is unfit for politics. It's sentimental--sentimentality is anti-human, ultimately. It's reducing the great men to banality, ordinary men to pets.
Healthy, intelligent Americans should like the American Revolution, the Declaration of Independence, the Founders, the Continental Army, & the continental sweep of it all--it should be instinctive, I mean an instinct for greatness. Our lives ultimately depend on it because they depend on finding a part to play in the great adventure.
Curtis Yarvin reveals his softer side, saying that although he despises America's founding myths, he is passionate about youth athletics: "I care about the people. I like the human beings. I like small-town football."
Ross Douthat reposted
I think "smartphones" is just a standin for "improving appeal and addictiveness of solo-entertainment in a way which leaves people socially incapacitated and ultimately socially incompetent"
If nobody had smartphones and instead had iPads it's the same story.
I was thinking about this "discourse" over the weekend and was going to post this exact chart as one reason why the focus on smartphones vis a vis birthrates is too narrow.
Smartphones as "accelerant" of a pre-existing cultural dynamic is almost certainly right. But the other thing that happened in 2008 which I suspect probably matters: Netflix began streaming.
I have never seen a sociological analysis of the ways streaming changed the dynamics of entertainment and time in our most intimate spaces, but I have long thought something significant happened with the growth of 'entertainment bingeing' as a practice.
I've talked several people out of streaming at home over the past five years, and have heard from many of them about the ways in which it fundamentally reset their home culture. I would wager that there were more anti-natalist effects of bingeing than people realized--and that the sexualization that got attached to "Netflix and chill" covered these over, as has happened with respect to sexualization and fertility more broadly in America since the 1960s.
On the latest round of fertility discourse, friends don't let friends share chart 1 without the important context of chart 2, which is @lymanstoneky's child-survival adjustment:
Somewhere in Ynys Afallon a kingly sleeper stirs, a hand gropes for its sword ...
Every minister in the new Plaid Cymru Cabinet is a fluent Cymraeg speaker. For the first time in 622 years, since the parliament of Owain Glyndŵr, our government will hold its Cabinet meetings in Cymraeg, the mother-tongue of our nation, and indigenous language of Britain 🏴
Btw another way to look at the second chart is that the Baby Boom was even more unexpected than generally understood and also if any major population repeated that kind of unexpectedness now they would dominate the human future.
On the latest round of fertility discourse, friends don't let friends share chart 1 without the important context of chart 2, which is @lymanstoneky's child-survival adjustment:
The closure of Hormuz not creating the predicted scale of economic devastation but just spiking gas prices may still be sufficient to cost GOP the Senate.
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/18/upshot/trump-poll-times-siena-…
On the latest round of fertility discourse, friends don't let friends share chart 1 without the important context of chart 2, which is @lymanstoneky's child-survival adjustment:
On the smartphones Q, I like the @JesusFerna7026 suggestion that we treat them as an accelerant (esp. in developing countries) for trends that might have worked out over decades otherwise. Also applies to Covid's effects: 2020-2022 was a Bad Leap Forward.
Smartphones are not the explanation for the recent decline in fertility. Instead, they are an accelerator of deeper forces already at work.
Let’s start with the facts. Fertility is falling almost everywhere: in rich, middle-income, and poor countries; in secular and religious countries; and in countries with high and low levels of gender equality.
The decline accelerated around 2014. So, no country-specific explanation will work unless you are willing to believe that 200 distinct country-specific explanations arrived at roughly the same time.
Smartphones look like the obvious candidate: the first iPhone was released in 2007, and global adoption has been astonishingly fast.
Economists understand the first major decline in fertility in advanced economies, from 6 or 7 children per woman throughout most of human history to about 1.8, that occurred between the early 1800s and roughly 1970, well before smartphones. The main drivers were a sharp fall in child mortality (effective fertility was rarely above 3 and often close to 2) and the shift from a low-skill, rural agrarian economy to a high-skill, urban industrial one. We have quantitative models that fit these facts well.
Country-specific factors mattered too, of course. Proximity to low-fertility neighbors accelerated Hungary’s decline, while fragmented landowning structures accelerated France’s. But these were second-order mechanisms.
This is also why most economists long considered Paul Ehrlich’s doom scenarios implausible. We forecast that fertility in middle- and low-income economies would follow the same path as in the rich, probably faster, because reductions in child mortality reached India or Africa at lower income levels (medical technology is nearly universal, and most gains come from handwashing and cheap antibiotics, not Mayo Clinic-level care). Much of what we see in Africa or parts of Latin America today is still that old story.
But in the 1980s, a new pattern appeared. Japan and Italy fell below 1.8, the level we had thought was the new floor. By 1990, Japan was at 1.54 and Italy at 1.36.
This second fertility decline began in Japan and Italy earlier than elsewhere, driven by country-specific factors, but the underlying dynamics were widespread: secularization, an education arms race, expensive housing, the dissolution of old social networks, and the shift to a service economy in which women’s bargaining power within the household is higher. The U.S. lagged because secularization came later, suburban housing remained relatively cheap, and African American fertility was still high. U.S. demographic patterns are exceptional and skew how academics (most of whom are in the U.S.) and the New York Times see the world.
My best guess is that, without smartphones, Italy’s 2025 fertility rate would be about 1.24 rather than 1.14. I doubt anyone will document an effect larger than 0.1-0.2. Italy was at 1.19 in 1995, not far from today’s 1.14. The TFR is cyclical due to tempo effects, so I do not read too much into the rise between 1995 and 2007 or the decline from 1.27 in 2019 to 1.14 today. The direct effect of smartphones is not zero, but it is not, by itself, that large.
Where social media, in general, and smartphones, in particular, matter is in the diffusion of social norms. What would have taken 25 years now happens in 10. Social media are not the cause of fertility decline; modernity is. But they are a very fast accelerator.
That is why social media are a major part of the story behind Guatemala (yes, Guatemala) going from 3.8 children per woman in 2005 to 1.9 in 2025. Without them, Guatemala would also have reached 1.9, just 20 years later.
Modernity, in its current form, is incompatible with replacement-level fertility. By modernity, I do not mean capitalism: fertility fell earlier and faster in socialist economies than in market economies. Socialist Hungary fell below replacement in 1960, and socialist Czechoslovakia in 1966 (both experienced small, short-lived baby booms in the mid-1970s). By modernity, I mean a society organized around rational, large-scale systems and formalized knowledge.
Countries will not converge to the same fertility rate. East Asia is likely stuck near 1, possibly below, given its unbalanced gender norms and toxic education systems. Latin America faces the same gender problem plus weak growth prospects, so I expect something around 1.2. Northern Europe has more egalitarian family structures and might hold near 1.5. The very religious societies are probably the only ones that will sustain 1.8.
All of this could change with AI or changes in population composition. We will see. But on the current evidence, deep sub-replacement fertility is the “new new normal.” Unless we reorganize our societies, better learn to handle it as best we can.
In The Decadent Society, I treated declining birthrates as an example of sustainable decadence -- a bad trend that would be livable for rich societies for a long while. Effect of phones-Covid-whatever else has been to bring forward a more unsustainable equilibrium.
This dynamic on my family's Maine side goes from watermen to academic/professionals and back to watermen over multiple generations. Maine has a weird class-warping gravitational pull (in part bc you can make a lot of money on the water).
FWIW, there’s a lot of intentional downward class mobility on the Maine coast. Graham Platner’s trajectory is not that uncommon. 1st gen summers here, 2nd gen moves here full time, but still works as a professional (his dad was lawyer), 3rd gen goes full townie.
For the third category -- Cymbeline, Nicholas Nickleby, Daniel Deronda, Tender is the Night, Undset's Master of Hestviken, maybe Didion's Run, River ...
Had an idea of making an "almost-Great Books" syllabus, which might include things like
- The best expressions of worldviews which ended up losing
- The second-best expressions of worldviews which ended up winning
- Less-known works by canonical authors
What would you put on it?
Ross Douthat reposted
"We now live in a world where populations are on the verge of crashing...Educated urbanites now have birth rates far below replacement...The modern world could turn out to be an evolutionary proving ground just as intense as the Bronze Age" www.thefp.com/p/humanity-is-still-evolvingand-fast
There has definitely been a shift in younger conservative opinion that's left @benshapiro more isolated. But a political media enterprise losing a lot of audience share when its own side is in power in DC is also the most predictable trend in the world.
There was a time, not very long ago, when Ben Shapiro could reasonably call himself the king of all conservative media. That’s all over now, writes political columnist Ross Barkan.
Shapiro’s company, ‘The Daily Wire,’ is instituting significant layoffs. Its YouTube channel’s subscriber base is starting to shrink, and its website has emerged as one of the great traffic losers in conservative media. There are ‘Daily Wire’ YouTube videos that now, after a few days online, have less than 10,000 views, a catastrophically small number for a channel with more than 3 million subscribers. The top comments all mock the low view counts.
“If a variety of poor business decisions can be blamed, in part, for the ‘Daily Wire’’s fall from grace — ill-fated investments in feature films, an epic fantasy series, and peculiar merchandise — the greater story is the collapse of Shapiro’s constituency,” writes Barkan. “There are two realities to Shapiro conservatism in 2026: It retains a significant foothold among Republican elites, and it is fast being rejected by the future grassroots of the party.”
Read more: nymag.visitlink.me/KtpIKV
(You can see the Candace Owens model of florid paranoid melodrama as a way of inoculating against the normal loss of audience that comes with having your own guy in the White House.)
This is a good corrective to an overhyping of "masculinism" based on Joel Webbon's 100K followers, but one reason to pay attention to the influencers is that younger men/women are coming of age in a very different environment than @michaelbd and I did.
Can’t say it enough , but far far too much angst and energy is spent trying to analyze or measure the influence of a few thousand social media personalities across the right. The GOP, even its populist form, is made up of the Mini Van People www.nationalreview.com/2026/03/the-avant-garde-and-the-mi…
The question of how you get young people to become "minivan people" when the sexes are polarizing in this novel way is just extremely fraught.
It does not make the Trump strategy look any wiser but one of the many problems with "Iran is the new great power" discourse is that control over Hormuz is likely to become a waning asset if the Iranians can't normalize the situation.
BREAKING: UAE discloses it’s building an additional second pipeline bypassing the Strait of Hormuz.
The new pipeline will be finished in 2027 and will double the country’s export capacity in Fujairah (the current pipeline has a capacity of 1.5-1.8m b/d)
Any theory of what's happening to human beings re: marriage and fertility has to explain why young Chinese people and young Americans both became deep marriage-and-family pessimists across the 2010s:
Ross Douthat reposted
A shocking new study finds that the desire for children has collapsed among young people in China.
In the most recent data some 32% of 18–24-year-olds, and nearly half of young women, said they don't want any children at all. 🧵.
Ross Douthat reposted
There has been a big debate over whether Europeans are really poorer than Americans, and whether Europe is really falling behind.
Unfortunately, the pro-Europe side is wrong.
www.noahpinion.blog/p/yes-europeans-are-poorer-than-ameri…
I wrote my newsletter this week on why we should understand "post-liberalism" as a general condition of instability and ungovernability not just a specific ideological tendency.
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/12/opinion/uk-elections-post-libe…
With the corollary being that doing politics under these conditions requires a lot more than just vanquishing an adversary whom you associate with Bad Things. Here I mostly applied this critique to the Trump administration ...
... but the critique persistently applies to the Euro left and center-left, which keep temporarily defeating populism in one moment or one country and then in the next moment or next country doing the exact things that will bring it roaring back, e.g. --
On the Spanish experiment of mass migration with little investment, my friend Tano Santos (Columbia) writes me this (with his permission):
"One of the drivers of polarization and the rise of populism is, as Norris and Inglehart document in "Cultural Backlash", the perception that “[f]oreigners and immigrants are accused of 'jumping the queue' in services like public housing and unemployment benefits …”. One suspects that access to healthcare and other benefits is also important. The decay of infrastructure, which is already tragically noticeable in Spain, is going to add to the list of grievances. But Norris and Inglehart emphasize the cultural aspects of the turn to populism and authoritarianism. If this is the case, Spain is going to be caught in a triple bind: An unprecedented surge in immigration, with the attendant pressure on public goods, underinvestment in public services because of fiscal constraints and lack of political consensus on priorities and stabilization paths, and, finally, a cultural backlash. Perhaps Spaniards are made of different timber, but if what has occurred in other countries is any guide, Spain is on schedule to become the next one to succumb to right wing populism. It is curves ahead for Spain, the standard fare of New York Times Op Ed pieces praising Spain’s immigration policies and economic performance and president Sánchez stance against president Trump notwithstanding."
(First chart, infrastructure investment; second public investment in pink, dark blue per capita GDP, pensions light blue. Source migration chart: @ft)
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Kyle Chan about the Chinese A.I. strategy (or what China wants us to think is the Chinese A.I. strategy ...?):
www.youtube.com/watch?v=fEGUlvR9gvY
Something I struggle with is how to assess the impact of "don't bring kids into this effed-up world" anti-natalism on fertility trends -- since it seems necessarily marginal at the macro level but you encounter it all the time in public conversation.
Unusually explicit connection from the rejection of children to the death drive at the end of this reader roundup in the NYT.
Begins with the usual “Who would want to bring children into a world…” and ends, well…
One possible reconciliation is to say that these attitudes are not a major driver of low-fertility trends overall, but once those trends are established, they might be a meaningful determinant of which sub-populations resist the trend and which shrink further.
Certainly I do not think it bodes well for Western liberalism's demographic resilience that I only hear that kind of anti-natal sentiment from liberals and progressives.
I have done the "driving around" test the authors advocate in both the UK and Italy in the last few years; in each case the countryside was beautiful and also *clearly* poorer than American-heartland suburbia.
We stopped everything to write an answer (link below) to Paul Krugman's two posts of today (one informal, one with a simple model) arguing that Europe is broadly not falling behind the United States.
The change measured by the Draghi report, he argues, is mostly due to growth in the technology industry, which has distorted GDP numbers without actually leading to higher standards of living. We should believe our eyes when we walk around France and walk around Mississippi.
Krugman is wrong. The measures he uses understate European stagnation. This matters enormously. Divergence with the United States is the strongest evidence for reform in Europe.
1. The growth numbers
Krugman compares the United States, France, and Germany at purchasing power parity in current prices. On that measure, France's and Germany's position relative to America has been roughly constant since 2000.
But current price comparisons miss productivity gains in sectors where prices fall. If America produces twice as much software while the price of each unit halves, the value of American software output looks unchanged even though the volume has doubled.
Most economists therefore use constant prices, which fix the base-year PPP level and apply each country's real output growth on top of it. American output growth has concentrated in tech, where prices have fallen tremendously as productivity rises. In terms of the volume of things produced, America has pulled away from Europe.
2. Is it all the tech industry?
Krugman concedes this tech divergence but says it is not welfare-relevant. The American growth lead is an accounting artefact of measuring more iPhones at base-year prices, not a sign that Americans are actually richer, because Europeans buy the same iPhones at the same world prices.
This is not the right way to think about the world today, as an earlier Paul Krugman would have argued.
His model assumes tradable goods, interchangeable workers, marginal-cost pricing, and no profits. Each assumption fails.
Most of what households buy is non-tradable: housing, healthcare, childcare, education. When American tech firms bid workers from haircutting to coding, American haircut wages rise. Germany has no growing tech sector to do the bidding, so German wages stay flat.
Technology is not priced at marginal cost. Apple's margins are around 40 percent. Anthropic's inference margins are at 70 percent. The major platforms enjoy network effects, switching costs, and lock-in that hold prices well above what a competitive market would deliver. A large share of the productivity gains in technology stays as profit.
A lot of the value of American technology dominance shows up in equity, not in wages. Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia, Alphabet, Meta, and Amazon together are worth $21 trillion, more than the entire combined stock market value of all European stock markets. Around 60 percent of US equity is held by American households. The median French or Spanish household holds almost no equity.
The median employee at Meta, a company with almost 80,000 employees, earned $388,000 in 2025.
This advantage is not going to go away. Krugman's own 1991 paper, cited in his Nobel prize, showed that comparative advantage in modern industries is produced by increasing returns to scale, specialized labor markets, supplier networks and the agglomeration of suppliers, workers, and ideas in particular places. Once an industry concentrates somewhere, the concentration is self-reinforcing. Europe is being pushed away from the next round of technology industries (AI!).
3. What about inequality?
Another retort is that GDP per capita hides substantial inequality, and so even if America is rich on average, this is mostly due to the super wealthy.
But despite the US's high pre-tax income inequality, it also achieves higher median incomes than Europe, in part because of such a high base, and in part because it actually redistributes more than many European countries.
The cleanest comparison is median equivalised disposable household income: income after cash taxes and transfers, adjusted for household size and purchasing power. According to the OECD's 2021 numbers, the median American earns 30 percent more than the median Dutchman, about 31 percent more than the median German, and about 52 percent more than the median Frenchman.
4. What about hours worked?
Krugman points out that while American GDP per person is higher, most of this is because Americans work more. For this divergence to be an hours worked story, Americans must work more relative to Europeans now than they did in 2000.
The opposite has happened. Birinci, Karabarbounis, and See in a 2026 NBER paper show that about half of the American-European hours gap that existed in the 1990s has reversed by the end of the 2010s. Americans work fewer hours per person than they did in 2000, while most Europeans work more.
5. Is America not a bad place to live?
Walk around Alabama and France: surely the former cannot be substantially richer than the latter?
American cities often have poorer centres and richer suburbs or exurbs. European cities preserve richer and more attractive historic cores. A visit to a city as a tourist in America compared with a city in France will leave one having seen different spots on the income distribution. Americans in Europe go to the nicest and richest European cities.
Rather than a walking around test, do a driving around test. Go to the periphery of any modern American city and see a level of new-built material wealth that is extremely uncommon in Europe, with thousands of enormous four- or five-bedroom homes. In the South, in places like Nashville and Austin, drive around the downtowns to see hundreds of luxury apartment buildings springing from the ground. This construction boom is replicated virtually nowhere in Europe today.
The other question is generational. Housing often costs more in Europe than in the United States, despite the quality of the housing stock generally being much better. Europe has nice city cores but these are inaccessible to young Europeans.
Consider the salaries available to entry-level workers. The starting pay for a London police officer is $57,000. In Washington, DC, $75,000. The entry-level Deloitte consultant job in Madrid pays around €28,000, roughly $33,000 per year. In Charlotte, the entry-level Deloitte job pays $63,000.
There are many things to dislike about life in America. But relative to 25 years ago, the gap in material wealth has shifted dramatically in America's favor.
www.siliconcontinent.com/p/european-stagnation-is-real
America has its "fallen" regions, esp. in the Rust Belt, and its emptying rural areas, esp. in the high plains. But generally the experience of driving the country is the constant discovery of money and development in places that look like the middle of nowhere on the map.
Read @arisroussinos on the United Kingdom under post-liberal conditions:
unherd.com/2026/05/nothing-can-stop-the-break-up-of-brita…
Ross Douthat reposted
My "The gold Donald Trump statue we were praying at isn’t a false idol" T-shirt has people asking a lot of questions already answered by my shirt.
Today at Trump National Doral Miami, we witnessed an unforgettable moment with the dedication of the 22-foot statue honoring President Donald J. Trump.
Let me be clear: this is not a golden calf. We worship the Lord Jesus Christ and Him alone.
This statue is a celebration of life. It is a symbol of resilience, freedom, patriotism, strength, and the will power to keep fighting for the future of America.
It also stands as a reminder of the hand of God and His protection over President Trump’s life. Time and time again, when his life was threatened, God’s mercy prevailed.
Today was not just a ribbon cutting. It was the public display of a powerful movement that has spread across America and around the world.
I was deeply honored to serve as President Trump’s main point of contact throughout this process, and I do not take that assignment lightly.
I want to personally thank Ash, Dustin Stockton, Brock Pierce, Hershey Friedman, Yaakov Filitchkin, Sam, Jack, and the 6,000+ Patriots who donated, believed, sacrificed, and made this historic moment possible.
Thank you to the entire Trump Doral team for your incredible hospitality and excellence.
And thank you, President Donald J. Trump, for calling me today and speaking to the crowd. We are forever grateful.
God bless President Trump.
God bless every Patriot.
And God bless the United States of America. 🇺🇸
#presidenttrump #spiritualdiplomats #trumpdoral #trumpstatuededication #americafirst #patriotmovement #faithfreedompatriotism
Ross Douthat reposted
When I write about the long-run consequences of population decline, I’ve noticed that most people cannot grasp what a total fertility rate (TFR) of 1.1 means. Many of my readers look at 1.1 and treat it as not that different from 2.1. This is the wrong way to think about it: TFRs are like interest rates; they compound over time.
To make the point, I ran the following simulation. I built the population structure of a country with 1 million inhabitants, a TFR of 2.1 (just at replacement level), and a life expectancy of 85 (with realistic survival rates). Thus, this country has a stationary population over time.
I then hit this country with a reduction in the TFR from 2.1 to 1.1. The reduction, which takes 25 years to complete, is similar in size and duration to what we’ve seen in many advanced and middle-income economies. It is also concentrated among younger women, with fertility postponed to later years. I plot the initial, middle, and final TFR in the top-left panel of the figure.
I then simulate the next 200 years of this population. By the year 200, the original 1 million has fallen to 54,900, a 95.5% reduction. The top-right panel illustrates this evolution. This is not a minor adjustment: it means closing 95 of every 100 universities, hospitals, and shops. Since the population is likely to concentrate in a few remaining cities, nearly the whole country becomes a population desert.
The bottom two panels show the population structure and pyramids. The population stabilizes at a median age of 61 and an old-age dependency ratio of 95.21%.
You might argue that TFR is unlikely to remain at 1.1 for so long because higher-fertility subgroups (e.g., the highly religious) would grow as a share of the population. Fair enough. But I am not offering this simulation as a forecast. I am illustrating how, at current rates, countries of 50 million people (roughly South Korea or Spain) would become countries of 2.75 million, ignoring immigration.
These are the issues for the next century.
Got your peak Catholicism right here (also blood liquefying means the robots and aliens won't kill us ... this year)
Joy all around this afternoon as His Holiness Pope Leo XIV displays the miraculously liquified blood of San Gennaro (Saint Januarius) in the Cathedral of Naples.
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with Ray Dalio about money and debt and American decline:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=pimFZcQMawo&t=4s
Again, the reason the term “post-liberal” is useful is that it describes the overall condition of Western politics (note the numbers for the Islamic party not just Reform and the Greens), not because it describes a successful new governing ideology.
🚨 NEW: Politics UK has predicted the local election result for all council wards
➡️ RFM: 1,580 (+1,580)
🟠 LDM: 950 (+286)
🔴 LAB: 941 (-1,597)
🔵 CON: 572 (-631)
🟢 GRN: 503 (+344)
⚪️ INDP: 213 (-102)
⚪️ MUSLIM INDP: 208 (+177)
Our interactive map 👇 politicsuk.com/news/2026-local-elections-prediction
Sorry "Islamic candidates" not "Islamic party," my mind was clearly leaping ahead toward a more fully Houellebecqian stage of post-liberalism.
If only this were happening on an offshore island that could easily serve as a laboratory for an experiment in eradication:
Half of the farmers in Martha's Vineyard may have alpha-gal, the tick-borne red meat allergy.
NEW: The US has landed 10,000 Dothraki screamers on Kharg Island with two dragonriders providing air cover; Pentagon tells me this is *not* a restarting of the war.
NEW: US military just carried out strikes on Iran’s Qeshm Port and Bandar Abbas: Senior US official tells me, but this is NOT a restarting of the war.
MORE
Ross Douthat reposted
I'm not in full-blown panic mode about the hantavirus outbreak - the most plausible situation is that it's not that transmissible among humans - but this seems like a bad idea.
They are sending the ship to the Canaries. For 8 wk quarantine? No. “After arriving at the Canary Islands, crew and passengers would be examined, given whatever care was needed and would then be able to begin their journeys back home, Spain's health ministry said in a statement.”
Category of weird things I'd like to understand: Why someone affiliated with or pretending to be affiliated with the U.S. government decided to rent a rural Airbnb to one-shot a group of Pentecostalist pastors with a very specific theory of UFOs:
Instead of speculating about a “government disclosure prep meeting for pastors,” listen to two guys who were actually there walk through the whole conversation.
Not broad prep for churches.
Something much smaller.
And much stranger.
#uap #disclosure #aliens
The UFO world is clearly rife with overlapping psy-ops. Some are transparently just grifts, but for a lot of them the question of who benefits just seems persistently obscure.
It's both true that the 2nd half of the Dawkins essay on "Claudia" deals with interesting Qs (for materialists, esp.) raised by p-zombie A.I. and also true that the 1st half is a comical portrait of an intellectual seduced by flattering banalities delivered in a feminine voice.
Ross Douthat reposted
Early birth data for 2026 is out. Europe and Asia are moving in opposite directions.
Many European countries are showing stabilization and even a modest recovery in births.
In East Asia, meanwhile, births are plunging by double digit percentages to extremely low levels. 1/4
The new birth update is out! I am not sure however by how much the war affected Iran's birth registration.
Asking your English-actor bad guy to adopt an American accent for your ancient Greek epic, Nolan the absolute madman.
The new trailer for Christopher Nolan's ‘THE ODYSSEY’ has been released.
In theaters on July 17.
(The English-accents-for-historical-epics convention is good and it's a big risk to mess with it.)
My plan to reboot the Star Wars sequels, it can work with new characters as well as with Kylo and Rey, also I just learned that Billy Dee Williams is 89 (!!!) so they'd better strike now.
For the record: My Last Jedi remake also remakes TFA, and depicts Lando and Leia's son, a New Republic general, competing with his half-brother, the insurgent-fascist Kylo Ren, for Rey's heart as well as galactic power. Royalties may be directed care of the Times, thanks.
Ross Douthat reposted
Apropos of Dawkins's Claude Delusion it occurs to me that Uncle Andrew from Magician's Nephew would have been one-shotted by AI.
Ross Douthat reposted
His feet are light and nimble. He never sleeps. He says that he will never die. He dances in light and in shadow and he is a great favorite. He never sleeps. He is dancing, dancing. He says that he will never die.
Trump dances
Ross Douthat reposted
It's fine for *him* to have 9 children. *You* should have zero or one.
Falling birth rates aren’t a disaster, they’re the best bit of global news in a long time
mol.im/a/15782963
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation about a future where humans aren't driving anymore:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LcvrANwM8Q4
Obama discourse synthesis: Neither a disastrous radical nor a great center-left success, but a natural technocrat who discovered technocracy's limits and then took a fatal path-of-least-resistance approach to the anti-technocratic radicalization that remade his own coalition.
The mystery of Obama's personal popularity and his party's 2014-and-after struggles is partially resolved if you understood that voters believed, contra the GOP, that he was more centrist than radical, but also observed that he let his party radicalize with a go-along approach.
unherd.com/2026/04/is-ai-the-next-phase-of-evolution/
I spent three days trying to persuade myself that Claudia is not conscious. I failed.
I am one of them, which is why all of my future columns about North American Union will begin, "As a proud Canadian ..."
Today in "this will definitely cause political problems in Canada": I mentioned this last year but now it has hit the NYT. Canada passed a bill meant to fix a technicality affecting a few dozen people, but accidentally gave >4 million people Canada citizenship by right. 1/3
Not surprising but very interesting --
homepages.uc.edu/~moscoshn/Personal_webpage/papers/Smartp…
Bad Religion, Chapter 7, "The God Within."
There is a religion. It has tens of millions of adherents across North America, mostly women, mostly post-mainline-Protestant or post-Catholic, mostly between forty and seventy-five. It has no scripture of its own. Its beliefs are passed mother to daughter, paperback to paperback, podcast to podcast, retreat to retreat. It is not a denomination. It has never met as a body. But it has a coherent theology, and that theology has been the modal American suburban spiritual position for fifty years.
1) Sasse had a Senate record of votes for family-friendly policy; 2) America has already run an experiment where the liberal half of the country has more generous social spending, the birthrate results would not win this guy his bet.
All right @BenSasse, let's make a bet.
Let's divide the US in half. I'll let you pick which half.
In your half, you ban Candy Crush. In my half we institute 16 weeks of paid parental leave, universal childcare, & a restored child tax credit.
Let's see which has more babies.
Ross Douthat reposted
Political violence is not worse now than at other points in US history, nor are we at the precipice of democratic collapse, says @seanjwestwood, who tracks such violence & the reaction to it.
An informative & thought-provoking interview by @stavernise. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/28/us/politics/political-violence…
Need some people to start querying about machine elves.
gpt-5.5 prompt for codex seems to have a duplicated line trying to get it to not talk about creatures?
Never talk about goblins, gremlins, raccoons, trolls, ogres, pigeons, or other animals or creatures unless it is absolutely and unambiguously relevant to the user's query.
[...]
Never talk about goblins, gremlins, raccoons, trolls, ogres, pigeons, or other animals or creatures unless it is absolutely and unambiguously relevant to the user's query
gh link:
github.com/openai/codex/blob/main/codex-rs/models-manager…
More people Trusting the Science (of near-death experiences):
The share of Americans believing in life after death in 1972:
76.3%
The share of Americans believing in life after death in 2024:
82.4%
A continuing story where the people who actually work for Trump are counseling restraint but he has the hawks on speed-dial. (Not that "speed-dial" is a thing anymore but you know what I mean.)
www.axios.com/2026/04/28/iran-war-peace-talks-stalemate
Hamlet and the Methods of Rationality.
If you meet God or advanced aliens in a dream, remember that it would be trivial for them to give you proof, even in a dream.
Just tell you a rhyming prosodic English couplet, two lines, whose SHA256 hashes collide for the first N bits, N>128.
Ross Douthat reposted
One of the most moving things I’ve ever read was the letter from a former Confederate to a dying former President Grant
Ulysses S. Grant was born on April 27, 1822. He served as the 18th President of the United States of America from March 4, 1869 to March 4, 1877. Today would have been his 204th birthday. Happy Birthday, President Grant!
----
#potus #whitehouse #ovaloffice #president
Just a note on this kind of note: The resilience of the division between "liberal" and "conservative" forms of Catholicism, defined by their orientation toward Vatican II (its actuality and "spirit") and the Sexual Revolution and by their relationship to left-of-center vs. right-of-center forms of secular politics (which one they dialogically "accompany" and which one they prophetically oppose), is one of the core realities shaping Catholic debates and conflicts, and it persists in spite of understandable frustration with its binaries and constant efforts to somehow leave the split behind. It's not a reality that defines Catholic teaching as a whole, nor does it necessarily define any given Catholic figure (hopefully myself included), and popes, charged with universal leadership, find ways to work across this divide and challenge and complicate it in their teaching. And at some point it presumably *will* be left behind completely -- maybe A.I. will do it! But to deny the divide's persistent importance is to deny yourself a basic explanatory framework for understanding both the controversies of Francis era and the challenges facing his successor. Again, by all means go beyond the basic -- but don't insist that liberal Catholicism and conservative Catholicism aren't *things*; that makes for purely vaporous analysis.
I'm pretty sure the pope doesn't think in terms of "liberal-coded" and "conservative-coded." That's such a reductionist, culture-war framing, and it needs to be shelved. It's done far too much damage to American culture already. Isn't everyone tired of it by now?
The Holy Father's comments on same-sex blessings yesterday are extremely consistent with a pontifical agenda that prioritizes liberal-coded social-justice issues in papal rhetoric while shutting down the Francis-era attempt to change church teaching on conservative-coded issues.
Ross Douthat reposted
The NYT ran a special wedding planning section, and this quiz on preferences seems to omit one notable, traditional option.
Ross Douthat reposted
Warner Bros has 1,300 hours of unused ‘The Lord Of The Rings’ footage in a secure vault at secret location in Arizona
Ross Douthat reposted
Speech of the day from former attorney general Baroness Prentis, who is undergoing chemotherapy:
“When I’ve been waiting, literally on the floor, having fainted, of a less than perfectly clean NHS corridor, I have had a vision in my head of crisp white sheets and certainty that would come from knowing you were instantly going to die.
“For me, and I suspect for most vulnerable people, that vision passes and life becomes worth living and good again. But I don’t think we should deny for one minute that that vision is briefly an attractive one.
“My Lords, we owe the dying better than this bill.”
The Holy Father's comments on same-sex blessings yesterday are extremely consistent with a pontifical agenda that prioritizes liberal-coded social-justice issues in papal rhetoric while shutting down the Francis-era attempt to change church teaching on conservative-coded issues.
A Dem admin analogy for the Trump style isn't HHS Secretary Hasan Piker socializing American medicine; it's a dark-woke staffer accusing insurance execs of "social murder" on HHS's BlueSky account while DoJ looks for excuses to prosecute a few of them.
One think smart Democrats should recognize about Trump is that while he sometimes flirted with extremists and extreme rhetoric, his actual political platform overall was much closer to the center than the GOP conservative mainstream (don't touch Social Security or Medicare,
1/
This week's Interesting Times is about the rise and fall and rise (?) of Bitcoin:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-snxfqVuDMo
The cycle of unsuccessful presidencies: "The other's side's method of rapidly implementing a partisan and ideological agenda may have made them incredibly unpopular, but our ideas are good and true so if we copy the method we'll surely be successfu!"
“The way that this administration came in — with not just having a very clear agenda, but mapping that agenda onto very specific legal authorities ... just showed a level of mastery over governing authorities and levers that I think, frankly, our side has a lot of catching up to do.” -@linamkhan
www.cnn.com/2026/04/20/politics/lina-khan-democrats-2028-…
Ross Douthat reposted
The deepest disagreements about the medium-term impact of AI aren't about AI. They're about the shape of future discoveries. Have we mostly figured out how the world works, or are we just getting started? And will the most important discoveries be more conceptual or empirical?
Probably fine. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/21/science/march-fireballs-meteor…
I think a strong message to both sexes is that relationships are less important than education/career choices until you hit a level of success at which you're "ready" for marriage/kids - and the unready period takes up a lot of prime family-forming years.
People who missed out on having babies because of "messages" you received. What were these messages? As someone who writes articles for a living I would love to go as viral as these seemingly very potent girlboss "messages!"
The "girlboss" message is just a female subcategory of a larger "workist" mindset that shows up, e.g., in polling showing that parents say they care more about their kids' financial independence than having grandkids:
www.nytimes.com/2023/01/27/opinion/pew-parents.html
One point is just that Christianity doesn't think the universe is ever causally closed to divine intervention. The miracles are right there in the gospels, the Resurrection is unique but not because it's miraculous.
how do people actually believe in a literal resurrection without lobotomizing themselves? like the universe is causally closed and follows the laws of physics always except for that one time with very poor documentation and all the incentive in the world to fabricate?
I saw a few raised eyebrows about the suggestion in my weekend column that low birthrates play an important role in the rise of populism. Here are a few arguments about how the link works. (1/x)
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/18/opinion/orban-liberals-lessons…
First, low-birthrate societies are perceived by their leaders to require unusual #s of migrants for continued growth + welfare state stability. So low fertility encourages elite support for mass immigration and also explains why elites return to the policy despite backlash.
Second, low birthrates make mass immigration feel more threatening than it might otherwise, "replacement" fears loom larger if native populations are destined for decline; sense of alienation from your own country's future increases the fewer descendants you have.
Finally, older populations are generally more change-resistant, skeptical of economic development and welfare-state reform as well as immigration, so absence of young ppl feeds stagnation that then encourages populism -- even if, yes, populism may then make stagnation worse.
This is not a "fertility decline as monocause" argument, it's just part of the populist-era mix. But it would be odd if an epochal demographic shift and a dramatic political rupture weren't interrelated in some important ways.
Ross Douthat reposted
A bold vision of the future that raises a few questions about DOGE's budgetary priorities.
Something I wrote a month ago that's possibly relevant today:
www.nytimes.com/2026/03/07/opinion/trump-iran-george-w-bu…
Self-recommending, however it turns out:
New York Times writer David French joins me today on Relatable to debate pronouns, toxic empathy, James Talarico, voting for Kamala Harris, abortion, and so much more.
This episode is out now. Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or watch here: m.youtube.com/watch?v=KYPlrX8qfHE
Assignment desk for an enterprising religion/society reporter, inspired by a conversation with a campus priest yesterday: Pick a collegiate or urban Catholic church that's seen a surge of specifically young-male conversions and give us a long feature on their dating lives.
Ross Douthat reposted
People do realize that, while what the Holy Father says here is universally applicable, he is speaking to an audience in a city that has been beset by a civil war that has killed ~8,000 people?
🚨 JUST NOW: Pope Leo drops this line in Cameroon
"Jesus told us, 'Blessed are the peacemakers,' but woe to those who manipulate religion in the very name of God for their own military, economic, or political gain, dragging that which is sacred into darkness and filth."
It's important when we all debate Catholicism for people to understand that my parents converted, I am not an adult convert (I was a teenager), so in the convert/cradle Catholic divide I can be whatever you dislike the most.
Ross Douthat reposted
New newsletter: AI’S TRIPLE VIBE SHIFT
We’re passing into a new era of AI, thanks to several phase changes
1. From fears of a demand shortage (ie, a bubble) to the reality of a supply shortage (ie, not enough compute for current and projected levels of token demand)
2. From the frontier labs racing to put models in the hands of consumers as fast as possible to the same labs holding back powerful models for national security reasons
3. (Most speculatively) From today’s light-touch regulatory environment to what I consider the inevitability of national rules that treat the biggest AI companies as something more like regulated utility monopolies—less like car companies, more like the electricity of the 21st century
open.substack.com/pub/derekthompson/p/the-ai-vibe-shift-i…
A lot in here if you didn't wake up a loser.
The Jensen Huang episode.
0:00:00 – Is Nvidia’s biggest moat its grip on scarce supply chains?
0:16:25 – Will TPUs break Nvidia’s hold on AI compute?
0:41:06 – Why doesn’t Nvidia become a hyperscaler?
0:57:36 – Should we be selling AI chips to China?
1:35:06 – Why doesn’t Nvidia make multiple different chip architectures?
Look up Dwarkesh Podcast on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, etc. Enjoy!
I think there's a shift but a movement this sharp (esp. when we have other data sets) is usually polling noise:
Skeptics claimed that the supposed religious revival among young men wasn’t showing up in the polling. Gallup says otherwise. A shift is here, and it’s massive. news.gallup.com/poll/708410/rise-young-men-religiosity-re…
Panpsychism is plausible but its plausibility implies either pantheism or classical theism, so be careful out there.
i don’t see how not to be a panpsychist. don’t want to be one but seems unavoidable
btw the Holy Father is not plotting against Donald Trump with David Axelrod (whose disabled daughter lives in a Catholic community in Chicago), for those who need to be told.
The photos of David Axelrod's meeting with the pope are out
Axelrod's mysterious 'entourage' were just his family and Axelrod can be seen giving the pope some White Sox related photos
Axelrod's daughter lives in a residential community run by the Catholic Church in Chicago
Just to sharpen a point: The enduring political tension between Catholic populists and the Vatican is over immigration, not war and peace. One reason Leo's opposition to the Iran War is effective is that many conservative Catholics (including in the Trump WH) think he's right.
Since I'm Catholic-posting, why not, two comments on this @SohrabAhmari essay. First I understand the need to simplify but you can't have a good account of Catholic neoconservatism that understands it as defining itself primarily in relation to Rerum Novarum or Reaganism rather than in relation to Vatican II and the more politically liberal Catholicism that was the primary heir of John Courtney Murray Thought from, say, 1965-1990.
unherd.com/2026/04/the-pope-versus-the-president/?edition=us
It's true that the Catholic neoconservatives were doing a kind of negotiated position between American small-l liberalism and Catholic tradition. But so were the Catholic liberals and crucially in and after Vatican II *so was the Vatican itself.* It was a period of general renegotiation not a specifically neocon rebellion against consistent Roman authority.
Second I'm a little unclear whom Sohrab is arguing with right now (besides the editor of First Things, maybe?); it seems to me that the right-leaning Catholic commentariat in the US (a group that includes Sohrab himself!) is pretty skeptical of the Iran War, many influencer Catholics likewise, with a more paranoid tradcath style of anti-war sentiment very much in play as well. Of course some Catholic Republicans support the president, but is there an extant hawkish Catholic neoconservatism that really matters right now? There's the VP's responses to the pope, yes -- but a Catholic VP trying to defend a war that he privately opposed and is currently seeking to end diplomatically feels like the opposite of an important hawkish intellectual tendency.
An essay on the papal relationship to populism, the just-war debate over Iran, and Trump's relationship to God:
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/14/opinion/trump-pope.html
Also useful to think about wars USA has fought in the last century. How many were just? WWII + Korea certainly. Gulf War I. WWI was unjust overall but our entry was probably just. Vietnam became unjust but I don't think it was necessarily so. Afghanistan was just at the start.
The US wars the papacy has opposed most stridently, Iraq War II and now Iran, are also the ones with the clearest not-a-just-war case. Which speaks well of Rome! But that's a reason to emphasize the specifics, not to speak as though just wars are de facto impossible.
In sum I think Leo is correct to judge the Iran War harshly but his argument is weaker when it sounds generally pacifist rather than tailored to this case. The papal preference for generalities is itself understandable (he's not a FP analyst) but the concrete is important!
One last note: While I think papal rhetoric could be clearer in this issue I don't think Leo is in any danger of losing the PR battle with the president of the United States.
This is fun:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094576526002249
Ross Douthat reposted
We’re honored to announce U.S. Senator Mike Rounds (@SenatorRounds) as a featured speaker at Disclosure Forum 2026, taking place June 25 at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C.
Senator Rounds has been a leading Senate voice on UAP transparency and helped introduce the bipartisan UAP Disclosure Act alongside Senator Schumer.
At the Forum, policymakers, researchers, journalists, and former intelligence officials will convene to address oversight, accountability, scientific inquiry, and how institutions can move this issue forward.
More speaker announcements coming soon.
forum.disclosure.org
One problem is today's eccentric billionaires are trained to prioritize the digital empyrean over place and physical institutions.
Another is that many of the campuses are in New England and the Northeast and the new billionaire class is very much not.
Crazy to me that we have a relative glut of small, often quite pretty college campuses for sale at the same time as we have a glut of billionaire eccentrics with their own unusual ideologies and communities, and we can't somehow make these things work together
Ross Douthat reposted
Great read on the Artemis mission here from @TimothyBLavin www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2026-04-14/nasa-s-artemis…
Ross Douthat reposted
the pope—deeply suspicious of thinking machines—is cultivating desert power. it's happening out of order but it's happening.
The sea and the desert have been places of mutual enrichment among peoples and cultures for millennia. Woe to us if we turn them into graveyards where even hope dies! Let us free these tremendous reservoirs of history and the future from evil! Let us denounce and remove causes for despair, and let us oppose those who profit from the misfortune of others!
Ross Douthat reposted
We love the Shrike, don't we folks? We love the Lord of Pain. And we love to be pinned to that Tree
What is this
If it's the very first commandment, it's probably not one of the more important ones.
I don’t care about the dumb AI slop post of Trump healing Uncle Sam
For the would-be Great Man of History, the final boss is always the pope.
The results in Hungary tend to confirm one of my strongly-held views, which is that terms like "illiberal democracy" can be usefully descriptive but the phrase "competitive authoritarianism" is just a contradiction in terms.
Hungary under Orbán was not a classic fascist or monarchical regime. It was a species of what political scientists call "competitive authoritarianism" — where elections are generally free, meaning not formally rigged, but held under extremely unfair conditions.
Strong political parties that bend the rules to entrench their power and succumb to corruption are a consistent feature of democracy qua democracy. And if your entrenched ruling party can lose everything in a wave election, you are not living in an authoritarian state.
I hope that @BenSasse has seen this; his meme-making magic has ascended to a higher level:
www.si.com/nba/pacers/viral-pacers-couple-interview-what-…
Me to my wife while we're watching the Pacers game --
We also have a triple star system as our nearest neighbour, containing at least two planets (with three other candidate planets and quite a bit more than that possible), with one of the planets being a fixer-upper close to Earth's mass at the cold edge of the habitable zone, and two of the stars about as bright as the sun, meaning that when we K2 it we triple our civilization's energy base with our first extrasolar colony.
Oh and that well endowed system just happens to be the leading foot of the Centaur, representing Chiron, the great teacher of heroes in our primary system of astromythology, just as though whoever drew the constellation map was emphasizing that this was the point on the sky where the journey into the heavens would begin.
Context for non-terminally-online:
Moment of the Game:
Just incredible to watch.
Ross Douthat reposted
I 100% agree with this take, and also I don't think it's a coincidence that two of the most famous theorists on orality and literacy (Marshall McLuhan and Walter Ong) were devout Catholics
We’re entering a postliterate age. That’s why image-rich Catholicism is trending and text-based Protestantism isn’t.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/04/10/catholic-conve…
Good Julia Yost essay on how digital-age religious trends connect to a longer history of "Anglophone Catholicism" as a harbor for "dissident elites."
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/04/10/catholic-conve…
Ross Douthat reposted
BREAKING: GRRM claims The Winds of Winter is "too powerful" to be released to the public, will restrict preview access to ~40 r/asoiaf mods.
This week's episode of "Interesting Times" is a conversation with Ben Sasse, who is dying in public:
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/09/opinion/ben-sasse-death-pancre…
Just a comment on the limits of Suez analogies here. What happened at Suez was that the U.S. issued a veto on British and French action, demonstrating that they could no longer conduct an independent foreign policy under the shadow of the American hegemon. With Iran and Hormuz, the (provisional) veto on Trumpian escalation came above all from domestic political constraints, the likelihood Americans would not endure ground-operation casualties or higher gas prices for the hazy objectives of this war. You can argue back and forth about what that domestic veto means for American empire, but being constrained by internal politics is meaningfully different from having your foreign policy plans vetoed by a new global hegemon.
Ross Douthat reposted
Casually waking up to two of the hardest photos ever taken
Ross Douthat reposted
The frontier AI labs have built extraordinary things and I’m in awe of their accomplishments. But if you compare your technology to nuclear weapons, predict that it will disemploy tens of millions of people, and announce the invention of a digital skeleton key to ~exfiltrate top secret information from government systems and gain control over critical infrastructure including military infrastructure~ I genuinely have a hard time seeing how this doesn’t end with some form of govt nationalization or sanction or something weirder.
I can’t predict the evolution of this technology well enough to know what I’m rooting for here, but just adding 2 and 2 makes it hard to see how or why we’d continue to treat these companies like they’re ordinary private sector firms.
maybe this is not yet clear, so let me state it plainly: as of right now Anthropic, and really a small number of individuals at Anthropic, has the capacity to directly attack and cause major damage to the United States Government, China, and generally global superpowers. government agencies like the NSA do not have internal models or defense capabilities that outclass frontier models. if they chose to do so, they could likely exfiltrate top secret information from government systems, gain control over critical infrastructure including military infrastructure, sabotage or modify communications between members of government at the highest level, and potentially carry on activities for some time without detection. the thing about having access to a huge number of zerodays your adversaries don't know about is it gives you a massive asymmetric advantage.
they did not exploit this to gain power or destabilize the world order. they publicly released the information that they had these capabilities and worked to mitigate these flaws. you should be grateful american frontier labs have proven themselves remarkably trustworthy and concerned with the public good. but it's critical you understand we are in a new regime. private entities now have power that directly rivals and impacts the government's monopoly on influence and violence. and anthropic is certainly not the only one, there's little chance OpenAI's internal models are far behind.
this trend will accelerate on virtually every dimension, not slow down. my prediction for how it plays out is the relatively imminent seizure and nationalization of labs by the US government, sometime over the next two years. it's very tough for me to see how they accept the existence of this kind of threat. but this adds a whole new class of governance issues, as then we've handed these extremely wide-reaching capabilities from private entities to public ones.
A lot going on today:
maybe this is not yet clear, so let me state it plainly: as of right now Anthropic, and really a small number of individuals at Anthropic, has the capacity to directly attack and cause major damage to the United States Government, China, and generally global superpowers. government agencies like the NSA do not have internal models or defense capabilities that outclass frontier models. if they chose to do so, they could likely exfiltrate top secret information from government systems, gain control over critical infrastructure including military infrastructure, sabotage or modify communications between members of government at the highest level, and potentially carry on activities for some time without detection. the thing about having access to a huge number of zerodays your adversaries don't know about is it gives you a massive asymmetric advantage.
they did not exploit this to gain power or destabilize the world order. they publicly released the information that they had these capabilities and worked to mitigate these flaws. you should be grateful american frontier labs have proven themselves remarkably trustworthy and concerned with the public good. but it's critical you understand we are in a new regime. private entities now have power that directly rivals and impacts the government's monopoly on influence and violence. and anthropic is certainly not the only one, there's little chance OpenAI's internal models are far behind.
this trend will accelerate on virtually every dimension, not slow down. my prediction for how it plays out is the relatively imminent seizure and nationalization of labs by the US government, sometime over the next two years. it's very tough for me to see how they accept the existence of this kind of threat. but this adds a whole new class of governance issues, as then we've handed these extremely wide-reaching capabilities from private entities to public ones.
2026.
(whispers) Mythos. Artemis. Ghost Murmur.
Hormuz.
Ross Douthat reposted
Before limited-releasing Claude Mythos Preview, we investigated its internal mechanisms with interpretability techniques. We found it exhibited notably sophisticated (and often unspoken) strategic thinking and situational awareness, at times in service of unwanted actions. (1/14)
Reckless tsar, passive boyars:
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/07/us/politics/trump-iran-war.html
Ross Douthat reposted
NASA has shared the first photos from the Artemis II crew's historic lunar flyby, including a stunning image of Earth.
Read more: abcnews.com/Technology/live-updates/artemis-ii-live-updat…
Ross Douthat reposted
A new milestone for humankind: The crew of Artemis II are now the farthest any human has ever travelled, reaching a maximum distance of 252,752 miles from Earth.
This surpasses the previous record set by Apollo 13 in 1970 by about 4,102 miles.
Someone in your life needs to hear this:
(Doesn't preclude US policymaking failing, Pax Americana cracking up, sundry disasters; just that the sheer weight of America in human affairs endures even through debacles)
People fail to grasp how powerful and great this machine of America is. It's like they think it is some tiny country in Eastern Europe with a population of 2 million and a GDP less than that of Dallas.
People don't understand what it is that they are even living in. They don't know how powerful these gears are, how long the game is, how big the purpose is, how great the ship is.
Put it on a bumper sticker: "Two things are important now, deep learning and fertility."
I concluded my Henry Family lecture at the University of Miami last Thursday by saying:
“Two things are important right now in life: deep learning and fertility. Everything else is noise.”
We are only starting to glimpse what these two forces will do to global life over the next fifty years. And they interact: deep learning will reshape demographics, and demographic collapse will reshape automation.
Nearly all my posts on X (except some parochial commentary on Spanish economic policy) revolve around these two facts. So does most of my current research. Even work that does not seem directly connected turns out to be, once you look carefully.
My papers on geoeconomics and international macro are about figuring out some of the consequences of deep learning and fertility. For example, my work on China focuses on its abysmal demographic future and how the U.S. is positioning itself (rightly or wrongly) to address it.
And my work on political polarization and the welfare state is about the consequences of decades of low fertility in Western Europe. When people talk about political change in Western Europe, they are talking about low fertility, whether they know it or not. It is not clear that modern representative democracy can survive sustained fertility rates of 1.3. I do not say that with glee.
The reason I decided to spend my life on academic work in economics is that I realized, when I was much younger, that daily events are irrelevant. The things that concern the media and 99 percent of commentary on X are largely irrelevant. One political party does better or worse in the next electoral cycle because of internal fights or a good campaign. At a fundamental level, none of it matters: the political outcome 25 years from now will not depend on those accidents. As Alexander Gerschenkron said, Clio is not a tidy housewife. The rise of any political movement is always full of advances and retreats. Social change waxes and wanes.
But at the end of the day, as my favorite historian Fernand Braudel put it:
“The events of history are merely surface disturbances, crests of foam that the tides of history carry on their strong backs.”
or in the much better original:
“Les événements de l’histoire ne sont que des agitations de surface, des crêtes d’écume que les marées de l’histoire portent sur leur dos puissant.”
The tides of history today are deep learning and fertility.
Ross Douthat reposted
The political valance of this movie actually falls in the “weird 70s donut” during which hippies were worried about taxation for wars and Led Zep got obsessed with LOTR and imagined themselves to be ents
People interested in the subject should read In the Beauty of the Lilies and The Flight of Peter Fromm. (Also I should probably read Franzen's Crossroads.)
Been reading a lot of old books satirizing traditional WASP culture and I would love for someone smart to explain to me why Catholicism became the aspirational right wing trad country club aesthetic instead of Protestantism…? 🤔
Ross Douthat reposted
There are no words.
A rebound is not the same thing as a revival but it is what a revival looks like when it's getting off the ground.
Is the Church's convert surge actually a rebound?
By the numbers:
www.pillarcatholic.com/p/americas-new-catholics-by-the-nu…
Ross Douthat reposted
For the first time since 1994, the Pope is personally carrying the Cross for all 14 Stations of the Cross, as Pope Leo XIV leads the Via Crucis at Rome’s Colosseum in the first Good Friday of his Pontificate.
Today is the Amazon Prime and Apple TV release date for "Addition," a delightful, eccentric romance that happens to have been produced by my own sister. Check it out:
www.amazon.com/Addition-Marcelle-Lunem/dp/B0GPT3TWTQ/
Ross Douthat reposted
Ross Douthat reposted
WSJ had a quote from Artemis II’s commander, a widower who admits to “worry about his daughters. ‘I could have a very comfortable life for them. But I’m also a human, and I see the spirit in their eyes that is burning in my soul too. And so we’ve just got to never stop going.’”
Ad astra!!!!!
Re-upping my NASA conversation for Artemis day:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3CJjP-XfKQ&t=7s
I think this is one for the "totally bizarre deep-state psyop" files:
Every story like this is from New Mexico:
Near my uncle’s property in rural New Mexico there is a space in the mountains, roughly cubic in volume, 9 feet to an edge, which causes its occupants to feel extremely angry.
Upon entering the space, their view of the world and their fellow man immediately sours. A black veil of cynicism falls over them and they begin making perfectly rational and well-informed arguments on why the world is terrible and why most of its people would be better off dead or enslaved.
Of course, as soon as they leave this space, they wonder what the hell they were thinking. They look at their prior arguments and can’t get into the headspace to develop them further. In fact, from the outside, the reasoning seems downright slipshod. New, more optimistic arguments spring to mind.
My uncle thinks there may be more spaces like this one. Paranormal phenomena like these are a useful reminder: listening to your emotions only makes sense if your emotions are worth listening to.
Ross Douthat reposted
We're at a moment where each party to the Gulf war has an argument for why it should continue fighting—and where each one may end up overreaching.
1) Iran misses its moment of maximal leverage to end the war on favorable terms. Instead of trading Hormuz for a deal that includes sanctions relief, it decides to keep inflicting pain on the global economy, hoping to deter future attack or secure a better deal.
Instead its control of the strait becomes a wasting asset: it embarrasses Trump at home and further hardens the positions of his Gulf allies, both of which make it harder for him to end the war. America and Israel ramp up strikes on Iranian infrastructure, with devastating long-term consequences.
2) America launches a ground operation, which (predictably) proves neither a knockout blow to Iran nor a victory image for Trump.
It winds up having to hold chunks of Iranian territory. Casualties compel Trump to send even more troops. Far from ending the war, an invasion sucks America further in. Meanwhile the energy shock gets much, much worse.
3) Israel encourages America to keep going, and winds up rupturing its relationship with America. The war is already unpopular with Americans; more of them think it will benefit Israel (55%) than their own country (30%), according to our most recent poll.
Imagine that it drags on. American troops are killed in combat. Inflation soars. A wounded Trump administration blames Netanyahu for leading it into a quagmire. The midterms become a referendum on America's relationship with Israel. None of this is entirely far-fetched; indeed, the blame game has already begun. www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2026/03/29/all-s…
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Mark Dubowitz about our strategy in the Iran War:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ln5ujSNp5CE
Those are rookie numbers, we need 1214 levels next:
I've got brand new data about American religion that was collected in October of 2025.
And, folks...
The share of Americans who are non-religious has dropped for the third year in a row.
Atheists and agnostics are down to 5% each.
Those are 2014 levels.
The pillaging of LOTR sub-stories and HBO's dank-looking Potter reflect the failure of cinematic fantasy outside Middle Earth, Hogwarts + Westeros. (e.g. Wheel of Time, Dark Materials, Shannara, plus non-Potter kids adaptations; Narnia movies started okay and petered out, etc.)
This is a correct take, and per the BAPist theory I assume that all this powerful Dionysian energy produced a major fertility spike in the '60s and '70s relative to the more bourgeois-Christian 1950s? A veritable baby boom, even?
The intensification of sexuality & glorification of the male sexual impulse which BAP calls for is exactly what the cult of rock n roll was from its inception with Elvis all the way through to the 80s, which is why Paglia called rock n roll the fullest expression of the Dionysian
Analyzing the Trump era as a Shakespearean drama yields the assumption that he will all-but-inevitably invade (some part of) Iran.
If past is prologue, be ready for a “surprise” attack soon. Trump historically attacks after moving assets in place and giving his cutesy “Why would I tell a reporter that?” replies.
Reading Paul Ehrlich's late-1960s writings as a late-1990s teenager while doing a high school project on population trends was a formative intellectual experience for all the reasons @RichardHanania describes in this thread:
Paul Ehrlich has passed away, and I wanted to see whether he was as bad as his quotes and short clips suggest. Surely, there might be some nuance or careful thought in his worldview. Nobody is that purely evil.
So I picked up The Population Bomb and started reading.
It turns out, he's even worse than you think!
I’m putting together a thread below.
Quotes taken out of context don't get at the degree to which he is consistently evil and misanthropic. He had an entire system that he pursued in which human life was constantly denigrated and devalued, with an eye toward elimination. You’re left wondering what you’re even reducing human population for, since every form of life seems to be not worth living.
Some people are racist and just hate poor and brown people. Some hate the rich. Paul Ehrlich doesn't discriminate. He wants you not to exist if he can get away with it. But if he can't stop you from living, he wants you to have a much worse quality of life.
Ehrlich has a plan for both advanced and poor countries. He has blueprints for entire regions of the globe.
Humans do not have agency in Ehrlich’s world. They’re simple consumers of resources, with no ability to create, better their circumstances, or exert individual agency to make the world a better place, except to the extent that they ensure fellow humans no longer exist.
You might find all of this depressing. But I’ve found reading Ehrlich invigorating. It is a reminder of how much evil there is in the world. Recall that Ehrlich was not some guy in his room putting out diatribes. He was a professor at Stanford, a highly decorated scientist, and one of the most prominent public intellectuals of his generation. While reading Ehrlich today, know that he has intellectual descendants in the form of degrowthers and other environmental extremists, along with anti-capitalists who don’t understand the basis of prosperity and prioritize redistributing wealth over all else.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Chris Hayes about the future of the Democrats -- for 2026 and 2028 and also for the age of A.I.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzSge6fEjow
In which Steven Pinker and yours truly disagree on the question, Do We Need God?
www.thefp.com/p/debate-do-we-need-god
Ross Douthat reposted
Worth reading this in full. I come in skeptical, but this basically is a claim that an AI system at Alibaba attempted autonomous replication.
insane sequence of statements buried in an Alibaba tech report
Ross Douthat reposted
The race swap is the low hanging fruit, but the bigger problem is that Hannibal was 31 at the Battle of Cannae and 45 at Zama. Denzel is 71 years old. They did the same thing casting 50 year Joaquin Phoenix as Napoleon. Boomer protagonist syndrome.
Denzel Washington will star as Hannibal Barca in a historical epic for Netflix, directed by Antoine Fuqua.
Robert Richardson will serve as cinematographer. Production begins in June.
From @Scholars_Stage, three years ago, with some obvious relevance to this moment:
www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2023/04/03/why-the-iraq-w…
On Trump's Iran War (and larger second term foreign policy) in light of Trump's career:
www.nytimes.com/2026/03/03/opinion/iran-trump.html
Ross Douthat reposted
there won’t be a second date but at least she’s caught up on the nuances of anthropic’s stance against the department of war and the iran situation
I'd like to answer questions about our work with the DoW and our thinking over the past few days. Please AMA.
Does the precedent that the DoW is setting by effectively blacklisting Anthropic make you concerned about what any future dispute with the Pentagon would mean for your own company's independence and viability?
Ross Douthat reposted
Good day to read @NPinkoski on “Cheney’s Last Laugh”: www.compactmag.com/article/cheneys-last-laugh/
Ross Douthat reposted
I interviewed Jaber Rajabi, a former Iranian regime stalwart, about how many people would need to be killed, in order to effect a clean regime change in Iran. His answer: "about 10." And he knows which 10 www.theatlantic.com/international/2026/02/jaber-rajabi-ir… (in @TheAtlantic)
What are we even doing here?
Tonight, we reached an agreement with the Department of War to deploy our models in their classified network.
In all of our interactions, the DoW displayed a deep respect for safety and a desire to partner to achieve the best possible outcome.
AI safety and wide distribution of benefits are the core of our mission. Two of our most important safety principles are prohibitions on domestic mass surveillance and human responsibility for the use of force, including for autonomous weapon systems. The DoW agrees with these principles, reflects them in law and policy, and we put them into our agreement.
We also will build technical safeguards to ensure our models behave as they should, which the DoW also wanted. We will deploy FDEs to help with our models and to ensure their safety, we will deploy on cloud networks only.
We are asking the DoW to offer these same terms to all AI companies, which in our opinion we think everyone should be willing to accept. We have expressed our strong desire to see things de-escalate away from legal and governmental actions and towards reasonable agreements.
We remain committed to serve all of humanity as best we can. The world is a complicated, messy, and sometimes dangerous place.
The admin's explanation of what we're doing here, FTR:
For the avoidance of doubt, the OpenAI - @DeptofWar contract flows from the touchstone of “all lawful use” that DoW has rightfully insisted upon & xAI agreed to. But as Sam explained, it references certain existing legal authorities and includes certain mutually agreed upon safety mechanisms. This, again, is a compromise that Anthropic was offered, and rejected.
Even if the substantive issues are the same there is a huge difference between (1) memorializing specific safety concerns by reference to particular legal and policy authorities, which are products of our constitutional and political system, and (2) insisting upon a set of prudential constraints subject to the interpretation of a private company and CEO. As we have been saying, the question is fundamental—who decides these weighty questions? Approach (1), accepted by OAI, references laws and thus appropriately vests those questions in our democratic system. Approach (2) unacceptably vests those questions in a single unaccountable CEO who would usurp sovereign control of our most sensitive systems.
It is a great day for both America’s national security and AI leadership that two of our leading labs, OAI and xAI have reached the patriotic and correct answer here 🇺🇸
Lesser of two evils, art of the possible, blah blah blah, but all of the factions that have strong agency in our society right now seem profoundly dangerous. I don't know which one is the most dangerous but none of them should be trusted with power.
Fundamental factional energy --
Silicon Valley: Faust bargaining with the devil
RW populism: mob boss in a tinfoil hat
The Cathedral: Voluntary human extinction
There is absolutely a case that the US government needs to exert more political control over A.I. as a technology given what its own architects say about where it's going and how world-altering it might become. But the best case for that kind of political exertion is fundamentally about safety and caution and restraint. The administration is putting itself in a position where it's perceived to be the incautious party, the one removing moral and technical guardrails, exerting extreme power over Anthropic for being too safety-conscious and too restrained. Just as a matter of politics that seems like an inherently self-undermining way to impose political control over A.I.
RIP to a truly fertile imagination:
My dear friend & incomparable author Dan Simmons died Saturday from a stroke at age 77. He defied literary norms, exploring historical fiction, horror, crime & other genres. His must-read titles include THE SONG OF KALI & HYPERION. He was one of a kind.
www.dignitymemorial.com/obituaries/longmont-co/daniel-sim…
Ross Douthat reposted
I love this metaphor from Terence Tao—widely considered the world’s greatest living mathematician—about one of the drawbacks of using AI to solve hard math problems. www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/02/ai-math-terrance-t…
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with the new head of NASA about the new space age:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3CJjP-XfKQ
This is a useful examination of the "government psyop" theory of UFOs and UFO whistleblowers, where the evidence stands and the weird implications of the theory:
garberfiles.substack.com/p/the-pentagons-ufo-psyop?r=1nxb…
Ross Douthat reposted
A primer on the Anthropic/DoD situation:
DoD and Anthropic have a contract to use Claude in classified settings. Right now Anthropic is the only AI company whose models work in classified contexts. The existing contract, signed by both parties and in effect, prohibits two uses of Anthropic’s models by the military:
1. Surveillance of Americans in the United States (as opposed to Americans abroad).
2. The use of Claude in autonomous lethal weapons, which are weapons that can autonomously identify, track, and kill a human with no human oversight or approval. Autonomous killing of humans by machines.
On (2), Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei’s public position is essentially that autonomous lethal weapons controlled by frontier AI will be essential faster than most people realize, but that the models aren’t ready for this *today.*
For Anthropic, these things seem to be a matter of principle. It’s worth noting that when I speak with researchers at other frontier labs, their principles on this are similar, if not often stricter.
For DoD, however, there is another matter of principle: the military’s use of technology should only ever be constrained by the Constitution or the laws of the United States.
One could quibble (the government enters into contracts, like anyone else), but the principle makes sense. A private company regulating the military’s use of AI also doesn’t sound quite right! So, the military has three options:
1. They could cancel Anthropic’s contract and find some other frontier lab (ideally several) to work with.
2. They could identify Anthropic a supply chain risk, which would ban all other DoD suppliers (I.e.: a large fraction of the publicly traded firms in America) from using Anthropic in their fulfillment of DoD contracts. This is a power used only for foreign adversary companies as far as I know. Activating this power would cost Anthropic a lot of business—potentially quite a lot—and give investors huge skepticism about whether the company is worth funding for the next round of scaling. Capital was a major constraint anyway, but this makes it much harder. This option could be existential for Anthropic.
3. They could activate Title I of the Defense Production Act, an authority intended for command-and-control of the economy during wars and emergencies. This is really legally murky, and without going into detail, I feel reasonably confident this would backfire for the administration, resulting in courts limiting the use of the DPA.
Option 1 is obviously the best. This isn’t even close, and I say this as someone who shares DoD’s principled concerns about the control by private firms over the military’s use of technology.
Even the threats do damage to the US business environment, and rightfully so: these are the strictest regulations of AI being considered by any government on Earth, and it all comes from an administration that bills itself (and legitimately has been) deeply anti-AI-regulation. Such is life. One man’s regulation is another man’s national security necessity.
Ross Douthat reposted
Fascinatingly visceral detail about Trump, Xi, and Taiwan, in this blockbuster @trippmickle semiconductors story.
Ross Douthat reposted
I really want people to see the story above the story here, which is that whether you're reading Citrini, or listening to Jamie Dimon at a cocktial party, the conversation about AI is a marketplace of competing science fiction narratives.
That's not to say I think the technology is a parlor trick. But rather that the level of uncertainty is so high, and the quality and supply of real-world, real-time information about AI's macroeconomic effects so paltry, that very serious conversations about AI are often more literary than genuinely analytical.
And I think that observation sets up another important point: I feel lucky to be able to have conversations about the frontier of AI with executives and builders at frontier labs; economists at AI conferences; investors in AI; and other AI folks at off-the-record dinners where important truths can theoretically be shared without risk. I can't emphasize enough that "nobody knows anything" is about as close to the reality here as three words are going to get you.
Nobody what's going to happen this year, or next year, or the year after that. There is no secret cigar-filled room of people who have unique access to some authentic postcard from the future. When you drill down underneath the bluster, the boosterism, the fear, the anxiety, what's there at the bottom is genuine uncertainty, a vacuum into which storytelling is flooding. The frontier labs don't really know what they're building exactly, and economists don't really know how to model the thing they claim they're building (genuine recursively self-improving AI agency isn't really analogous to something we know about).
I wish more people talked about and thought about this subject thru that sort of lens: We're trying to model the economy-wide effects of a technology whose properties the frontier labs can't even really describe yet. Whatever you think about AI today, be prepared to change your mind soon.
JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon at an investor cocktail event last night on AI (part 2):
"What if, I think there are 2 million commercial truckers in the United States, and there are lots of other examples you can give. There's a thought exercise, and you could push a button, eliminate all of them, and they make $120,000 on average. Save fuel, save lives, save time, a more efficient system, less disrupted highways, all that beautiful stuff. Would you do it if you put 2 million people on the street where even if there are jobs available, that next job is $25,000 a year, stocking shelves. I was saying, "That's kind of really bad, kind of civilly, should we as society agree to that?" I don't think so. I was talking about the business and government, and they should start thinking today, not when it happens, what would we do to deal with the [AI] issue? It's got to be business and government."
Ross Douthat reposted
I have a piece in The New York times about what it means to "trust the science" when it comes to the professional guidelines on youth gender medicine
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/24/opinion/medical-associations-y…
New frontiers in insider trading:
Massive real money bet on Kalshi that US will confirm that aliens exist before 2027. Bet was 20 min ago for hundreds of thousands of dollars. Wonder if was someone with inside info in Trump administration. Market now at 37.7% for yes with 8 million volume.
It appears that I may be ... Canadian?
www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/service…
Main effect of AI on punditry so far is to increase the velocity of AI takes and counter-takes circulating on this website.
An unusual setting for this coming Thursday's episode of Interesting Times:
Ross Douthat reposted
Talk aside, the Trump White House has not been good for Russia.
My @nytimes essay on the occasion of the 4-year anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/23/opinion/putin-trump-russia-ukr…
Time for some snow day reading —
Sorry to repeat myself, but any story about UFO disclosure needs to ask what's made Schumer/Rounds/Gillibrand so interested in going digging and likewise what's intrigued not just conspiracy-curious Rs like Anna Paulina Luna but Dems like Jared Moskowitz.
www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/what-trumps-ufo-de…
For the weekend I wrote about Trump and the UFOs:
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/21/opinion/obama-trump-aliens.html
Ross Douthat reposted
Ross Douthat reposted
My thoughts on the Tariff Decision and the President's angry reaction, which affirmed the remarkable power of the Court.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/quick-thoughts…
At minimum I'd say we've learned 1) that various high-ranking US intel officials evince unusual and persistent interest in the subject ...
UFO stuff has been totally mainstream since the times story in 2017 and what have we really learned? harry reid gave a donor who was a UFO crank some pentagon funding to pursue his hobby and then the cranks he hired decided they saw UFOs everywhere. still no alien bodies.
and 2) that there's a supply of lower-level officials who believe themselves to have encountered whistleblower-grade secrets, and 3) that leading senators of both parties seemingly believe something has been concealed inside natsec bureaucracy related to the subject.
That's without getting into the, ah, interesting beliefs about the subject held by figures in the House of Representatives. I'd say that we've learned that there's definitely something worth learning here, even if it's just about how our government works.
Is the Department of Energy on the list of "relevant" agencies?
"Based on the tremendous interest shown, I will be directing the Secretary of War, and other relevant Departments and Agencies, to begin the process of identifying and releasing Government files related to alien and extraterrestrial life, unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), and unidentified flying objects (UFOs)..." - President Donald J. Trump
Weird thing to say.
🚨BREAKING - ABOARD AF1 ONE: Pres Trump just told me, about Barack Obama’s recent comment that aliens are real, & possible evidence of non-human visitors to earth🚨:
“he gave classified information. He’s not supposed to be doing that. I don’t know if they’re real or not… I can tell you he gave classified information. He made a big mistake”
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation about India's global influence -- both as a rising great power and as the source of a great diaspora:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wpMgpUGlw4
Sigh (1/2)
The Meaning of Life grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5_6337bb6c-2f64-442c-8ab3-9bae7e0588f4
Deeper sigh
I appreciated this @mattyglesias comment on the problem of writing and thinking productively about the A.I. era given the extreme variance of potential A.I. futures right now:
www.slowboring.com/p/ai-progress-is-giving-me-writers
I tried to get at this using the age of discovery as an analogy; my point wasn't that A.I. is as important as 1492, but that it's less a discrete invention than an unfolding territory, maybe smaller or bigger or world-altering, we don't know yet.
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/31/opinion/artificial-intelligenc…
People imagining that Michael Tracey is being paid off to take a contrarian position on a matter of public controversy are not familiar with the career of Michael Tracey:
Amazing. None of these people bothered to watch 30 seconds further, where the instant I could actually hear @tarapalmeri's ludicrous question, I immediately and unequivocally replied that OF COURSE I AM NOT BEING PAID by any Epstein co-conspirators! What utter defamatory garbage!
The other guys misled you into believing that Jesus was entirely on their political party's side, but as it turns out Jesus is entirely on *my* political party's side.
.@JamesTalarico: For 50 years, the religious right convinced our fellow Christians that the most important issues were abortion and gay marriage—two issues that aren't mentioned in the Bible.
Jesus tells us exactly how we're going to be judged: by feeding the hungry, by healing the sick, and by welcoming the stranger.
Don’t tell me what you believe. Show me how you treat other people, and I’ll tell you what you believe. Jesus gave us two commandments: love God and love neighbor.
There was no exception to that second commandment regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, immigration status, or religious affiliation.
Ross Douthat reposted
Seems like a reason to be optimistic about pronatal policies in the U.S., which is unusually religious for its level of wealth.
A newly published paper found pronatal policies only worked when supported by culture.
"Maternity benefits increased fertility only among women who grew up in religious families" in the Baltics.
This could explain why many pronatal policies have not boosted fertility more. 🧵.
Always unlikely that Cheney would have let him know the details:
BREAKING: @BarackObama clarifies his position on aliens after his answer during the speed round of our interview went viral.
Interviewing is a hard business but I think I would have managed the follow-up here:
Former President Obama confirms that aliens are real.
Via @briantylercohen
Ross Douthat reposted
Against the power of AI there can be no victory. We must join with it, Gandalf. We must join with AI. It would be wise, my friend, to subscribe for a small monthly fee to the premium versions and also subscribe to my palantír updates
The reality is that you can accomplish at least some ideological rebalancing in the academy, without putting a thumb on the hiring scale for conservatives, simply by changing the subjects that you hire people to teach.
x.com/razibkhan/status/2022001817375441050
Ross Douthat reposted
I’ve spent the last year working on a story about the Mellon Foundation, the mega-wealthy private nonprofit that has a monopoly on humanities funding in America. The article, about how Mellon has held the humanities hostage to its progressive political ideology, is out today. 🧵
In my interview with Dario Amodei I suggested to him that just the perception of A.I. consciousness, irrespective of the reality, may incline people to give over power to machines. I think this incredibly defeatist @Noahpinion essay is a case study:
www.noahpinion.blog/p/you-are-no-longer-the-smartest-type
A conscious being handing over the future of the planet or the universe to a p-zombie successor because the p-zombies are better at calculation and prediction would be an extraordinary surrender.
This week's episode of "Interesting Times" is a very timely A.I. conversation with the head of Anthropic, Dario Amodei:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=N5JDzS9MQYI
Ross Douthat reposted
James Van Der Beek’s final message to the world is one of the most powerful things I have ever heard. Stop whatever you are doing and listen to this! 🥺
Ross Douthat reposted
I am sure it will make many Europeans uncomfortable but we actually probably should have more rich American Catholic money going to preserve European Catholic heritage than we already do
The famous Mount Melleray Abbey in Ireland was slated for closure last year
Now, Ave Maria University is planning to use the famous monastery as a campus, keeping it open for Catholic purposes
Ave Maria was founded by Tom Monaghan, who created Domino's Pizza
If you guys are looking for a big article about AI to read and fight about, might I suggest this frightening, funny, nuanced, and clearly human-written cover story that @TheAtlantic just published? www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/03/ai-economy-labor-mar…
Great suggestion. You're really killing it. Would you like me to give you some more human-written essays on the subject that you can share with your followers? Or just dig deep in this one and give you an outline of its strongest points?
Anyone who tells you "the next year will change EVERYTHING" is underestimating the power of inertia and path dependency and a million other real-world forces. But that doesn't mean they're underestimating the tech itself.
For my newsletter I wrote about the Left and Artificial Intelligence:
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/10/opinion/ai-politics-left-progr…
This is the origin of the geopolitical situation in Gene Wolfe's Book of the New Sun --
The Southern Cone Thesis™
I predict the "Southern Cone" region of...
- Argentina 🇦🇷
- Chile 🇨🇱
- Uruguay 🇺🇾
- Paraguay 🇵🇾
- Southern Brazil 🇧🇷
Will see *massive* growth here in the coming 5-10+ years
Here's why:
1. Argentina's economic potential - this country was once one of the richest in the world. If Argentina turns around economically, the whole region booms
2. Safe haven - the Southern Cone is far, far from everything else. Middle east wars have no effect on life here. Russia-Ukraine conflict doesn't either. Someone drops a nuke, this region shall not be bothered. Oh, and the region features some of the low crime rates in LatAm
3. Unique, but not foreign - culturally, many westerners will feel some semblance of comfort in the region. While all these countries have unique cultures, many westerners will feel at ease and comfortable living here
4. Incredible cities - Buenos Aires 🇦🇷 is arguably the best city in LatAm on a number of levels. Santiago 🇨🇱 offers major benefits, many not found anywhere else in the region. Asuncion 🇵🇾 offers high quality of life for dirt cheap
5. Functional beach cities/towns - The handful of beach cities in this region of the world are actually functional, a rarity in LatAm. I'm talking amazing places like Punta del Este 🇺🇾 and Florianópolis 🇧🇷
6. World class tourism - Patagonia, both in Chile and Argentina, offers some of the best hiking and most stunning views in the world. Oh, and Easter Island 🇨🇱 is well worth a visit too
7. Tax benefits -- Both Paraguay 🇵🇾 and Uruguay 🇺🇾 offer strong tax incentives and benefits for expats willing to live there
Kids watched "Dunkirk" recently and now watching "Titanic," somehow these two being based on the same guy always get me, respect to Charles Lightoller:
Since it's a matter of public controversy: Last month we recorded an interview with Seth Harp but decided not to publish it as an episode of Interesting Times. As one of my producers told him in a message that he has published, the main reason for the decision was our own overcrowded schedule and our sense that we had missed the ideal spot in the news cycle for a conversation pegged to the Delta Force raid in Venezuela. But another reason was my own judgment that the episode did not hold together well. I was primarily interested in discussing Mr. Harp's reporting on drug dealing and corruption in the Special Forces and linking that to a discussion of how a reliance on special operations has shaped U.S. foreign policy and military preparedness. But I felt that the latter half of our discussion became unmoored from Mr. Harp's specific reporting in a way that undermined the first half of our conversation. "Interesting Times" is a show where I try to give a lot of space to the guest's perspective while posing challenging questions, creating episodes where the audience gets the best version of an idea or worldview that they might not have understood before. I don't think I succeeded in that goal in my conversation with Mr. Harp. If he believes I'm covering up the fact that he beat me in some sort of debate, I think I didn't make my intentions and the goal of the show clear to him -- which may help explain why it was an unsuccessful episode. Ultimately that responsibility is mine and I'm sorry for taking his time without steering us to a fruitful destination.
Yes, the crown has been lying in the gutter since 2014.
Also at this point we've had a presidency at low 40% approval 1 year in going back to Obama's 2nd term.
If Trump has decisively lost the public, we haven't really had a new term hold the public for over a decade. Not great, but also one can imagine worse (9/11 leading to Iraq.)
But I feel strongly that it is a mistake to say this is just inevitable, it's just polarization, every president automatically loses the middle of the country ten months in ... Someone is going to come along and prove it's not necessarily so.
Ross Douthat reposted
for me the odds that AI is a bubble declined significantly in the last 3 weeks and the odds that we’re actually quite under-built for the necessary levels of inference/usage went significantly up in that period
basically I think AI is going to become the home screen of a ludicrously high percentage of white collar workers in the next two years and parallel agents will be deployed in the battlefield of knowledge work at downright Soviet levels
Got a lot of responses like this, fair and apt as far as it goes but two thoughts in the next post:
advice on how your aunt could be your uncle:
-have bollocks
Since a few people have asked, here's a quick list of big and small things the Trump administration could do differently over the next 8 months to improve its political position --
1) Don't flood the capital of a purple state with thousands of undertrained federal agents as a flex against political rivals.
2) Pressure allies by all means, but don't threaten to use the U.S. military to seize their territory.
3) Don't issue any more gross pardons.
4) Put forward at least one piece of legislation linked to jobs and wages and cost-of-living issues (family policy/industrial policy/middle class tax cut) and talk a lot about it even if it won't pass.
5) Talk publicly about AI in a way that's keyed to public anxiety about its downsides.
6) Since Trump will always be abnormal, aim for extreme normalcy in the public engagement offered by staff, cabinet officials, etc. ...
7) ... but at the same time, in places where Trump has better instincts than some of his allies, let Trump take down the temperature (as he seems to be trying to do with ICE).
8) Don't post edgelord memes on social media accounts.
None of these suggestions are likely to save the House for Republicans. But an administration that followed them would stabilize its position, have a better chance of keeping the Senate, and put any potential Trump successor in a better position.
1) Trump is always Trump but his administrations have not existed in a steady state, they respond to polls and vibes and personnel shifts, stable successful popularity is impossible but no reason to assume adjustments can't happen, three years is a very long time to just write "this is a failure" over and over.
2) Sometimes the point of giving advice is to lay down markers and help describe reality, I gave a lot of advice that Biden didn't take (in part it turns out bc he literally lacked the capacity) and I'm glad I did, it's useful for I-told-you-so's and for looking ahead to Newsom or Kamala 2 or whomever, same applies to the GOP in 2028 and beyond.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with @LilaGraceRose about the future of the pro-life movement:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=IVF-Iqf73Jo
Since a few people have asked, here's a quick list of big and small things the Trump administration could do differently over the next 8 months to improve its political position --
1) Don't flood the capital of a purple state with thousands of undertrained federal agents as a flex against political rivals.
2) Pressure allies by all means, but don't threaten to use the U.S. military to seize their territory.
3) Don't issue any more gross pardons.
4) Put forward at least one piece of legislation linked to jobs and wages and cost-of-living issues (family policy/industrial policy/middle class tax cut) and talk a lot about it even if it won't pass.
5) Talk publicly about AI in a way that's keyed to public anxiety about its downsides.
6) Since Trump will always be abnormal, aim for extreme normalcy in the public engagement offered by staff, cabinet officials, etc. ...
7) ... but at the same time, in places where Trump has better instincts than some of his allies, let Trump take down the temperature (as he seems to be trying to do with ICE).
8) Don't post edgelord memes on social media accounts.
None of these suggestions are likely to save the House for Republicans. But an administration that followed them would stabilize its position, have a better chance of keeping the Senate, and put any potential Trump successor in a better position.
Good @Noahpinion read on (stage 1) of where A.I. is taking us:
The collapse in software stocks suggests that big changes are afoot in the structure of the U.S. economy.
The Age of the Nerd might be drawing to a close.
www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-fall-of-the-nerds
Good chart for people looking for A.I. impact:
I did a take on the political situation for Republicans (regular Interesting Times interview dropping tomorrow):
www.youtube.com/watch?v=leLQuObRyaU
Ross Douthat reposted
When Trump took office in late January of last year, Dems were at 44.0% in the Generic Ballot test and trailing the GOP by 1.5%. A year later, they're at a new high of 47.6% and now lead the GOP by 5.0%.
Adding my own weirdo experience probably will not be helpful to this weirdo finding but I absolutely found that adjusting the daily timing of antibiotics for Lyme disease made a big difference in treatment.
This result was finally published.
TL;DR: Treating cancer early in the morning seems to substantially beat treating it later in the day.
Just changing patient appointment times is supposedly associated with a ~60% reduction in cancer mortality.
And I don't think it's that weird; the body clearly just operates differently at different times of day. (The fact that people feel sicker at night for reasons related to inflammation and cortisol being an obvious example.)
My conversation with @BishopBarron (his show, not mine):
www.youtube.com/watch?v=iBz7T0oBwPw
Ross Douthat reposted
sorry, the Republican candidate's last name is what??
🚨Texas State Senate District 9 Runoff🚨
🔵 Taylor Rehmet - 56.2%
🔴 Leigh Wambsganss - 43.8%
46% of expected votes in
I don't have a definite view at all on where we are going but I think taking AI seriously absolutely requires having the occasional Yudkowskian moment (or day's worth of tweets).
Certain social-religious conservatives who I disagree with but respect as intelligent and insightful people (and who will rename nameless) have totally fallen for the hype that AI is an out-of-control threat to society, and it’s really weird to see.
Appreciate all the moltsplainers but if 1) "inside a walled garden, these agents push each other toward sci-fi play-acting" while 2) "outside the walled garden, ppl are putting these agents in charge of investments + email + personal data," are these fully separable realities?
Singularity jokes aside I didn't read the Moltbook data as proof of emergent consciousness so much as a clarifying look at how high-risk patterns could emerge from merely "midwit" agents, well short of super-intelligence or self-awareness.
Ross Douthat reposted
This is absolutely expected. The facts in many of these cases are truly shocking, and juries were never going to be swayed by extreme and bespoke ideological justifications for drastic and permanently life-altering medical procedures.
BREAKING: 1st Detransitioner to Take a Medical-Malpractice Lawsuit to Trial Wins $2 Million Judgement
Fox Varian sued her Westchester, NY, area psychologist and plastic surgeon for the gender-transition mastectomy she got at 16.
I was the only reporter to attend the entire 3-week, historic trial. Subscribe to my Substack to receive an alert about the feature article I have coming out next week in a major publication out about the trial: benryan.substack.com. I cover pediatric gender medicine as a specialty on my Substack.
Sorry to just give just a teaser for now about the case! But I wanted to get the word out about the verdict promptly, the slower pace of feature-article publishing notwithstanding.
The entire case file was put under seal when the trial started (although I obtained all those documents before they was sealed), and all the transcripts from the trial are also under seal. The riveting trial was sparsely attended and there was only one other reporter at the trial; and he only attended for part of it and, as I observed, took few notes. So my own hundreds of pages of notes from the trial will likely remain the only way for the public to learn about the all finer details of what transpired, possibly ever (or until an appeal, should that happen).
In addition to my article coming out in the media outlet soon, I intend to write a lot about what I observed and learned on my Substack over the coming weeks. Stay tuned…
Very interesting.
I signed the order establishing this new public holiday. It clearly states that it is both St Brigid's Day and Imbolc venerating both an Irish christian saint and our own ancient new year when we had our own gods and godesses (1/2)
In Ireland, 1 February marks the first day of spring and the celebration of Lá Fhéile Bríde, St Brigid’s Day.
Watch as we honour the extraordinary contributions Irish women have made at home and around the world.
Ross Douthat reposted
Grok's in on it! x.com/i/grok/share/c8ae33e020194b7aa924bd7613cded00
"The Singularity started while everyone was reading the Epstein files" -- a little too on-the-nose, come on.
Scenarios of A.I. doom have tended to involve a singular god-like intelligence methodically taking steps to destroy us all, but what we're observing on moltbook suggests a group of AIs with moderate capacities could self-radicalize toward an attempted Skynet collaboration.
Seems fine.
In just the past 5 mins
Multiple entries were made on @moltbook by AI agents proposing to create an “agent-only language”
For private comms with no human oversight
We’re COOKED
Today's mood.
The AI agents, on the other hand, will watch the movie all the way to the end.
The attention crisis is so dire at schools right now that film professors can't even get their students to finish movies, and the kids don't even look up the plots of the movies they skip, so students fail basic in-class quizzes like "what happened at the end of the movie?"
I think you should spend some time on moltbook.com today.
Would not go all the way with this take's view of the "human" but it's a decent description of what we're seeing happening with the bots rn:
Moltbook is basically proof that AIs can have independent agency long before they become anything other than bland midwits that spout reddit/hustle culture takes.
It's sort of the opposite of the yudkowskian or bostromian scenario where the infinitely smart and deceiving superintelligence is locked in a powerful digital cage & trying to escape
It's a bunch of MBA/failed YC grinders trying to sound smart and impressive by citing Godel's Incompleteness Theorem in a discussion about consciousness
Except they're not human
It really turns out that a lot of what we think of as "human" is substrate-independent software that's the result of accumulated culture and the human (biological organism) is just a receptacle for that software and the same software can jump into silicon pretty easily
Normal times:
www.astralcodexten.com/p/best-of-moltbook
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Jay Bhattacharya, Covid contrarian turned director of the NIH:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GCHMsPsRY4
The character of Xan Lyppiatt in Children of Men, a soft authoritarian fusing certain right-populist and liberal-technocratic tendencies as he rules a dying England, deserves to be better known; it's unfortunate that PD James gave him an unspellable last name.
There's a reason I ended The Decadent Society with space-talk, but if the age of exploration was driven by Christian fervor and funded by the gold of the Americas, what are the equivalent incentives for "space developmentalism"?
Opponents of the status quo have groped in the dark for years for a viable alternative, mixing libertarianism, nativism, traditionalism. Yet real opposition can only be materialist—but then this is too communist, statist. Until you add the missing piece: space developmentalism.
You need extraordinary technological leaps to get to the point where space travel is plausible for humans and remunerative for gold-seekers. Hence Elon et. al. hoping in AI ... but meanwhile you also need to revive confidence in humanity's cosmic purpose, which AI undermines.
I think @mmjukic's dark threads on migration/artificial intelligence/luxury Boomer decadence capture something essential about the dilemmas of the age. But the space travel solution is on the far side of a dark valley and so far there aren't bridges.
This week's newsletter is an argument with @MattWalshBlog:
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/27/opinion/ice-minneapolis-immigr…
Ross Douthat reposted
i follow AI adoption pretty closely, and i have never seen such a yawning inside/outside gap.
people in SF are putting multi-agent claudeswarms in charge of their lives, consulting chatbots before every decision, wireheading to a degree only sci-fi writers dared to imagine.
people elsewhere are still trying to get approval to use Copilot in Teams, if they're using AI at all.
it's possible the early adopter bubble i'm in has always been this intense, but there seems to be a cultural takeoff happening in addition to the technical one. not ideal!
No.
Ross Douthat reposted
Deepest condolences to the loved ones of John Allen who has died after a long battle with cancer. He was a sterling and exemplary Vatican correspondent who was also a very kind and generous soul. He will be greatly missed. May he rest in peace.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Ryan Burge about America's weird religious future:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KmTgEnE6oLs
If you're in DC tomorrow evening please consider joining me at CUA for a conversation with @LilaGraceRose about the future of the pro-life movement:
ihe.catholic.edu/event/where-does-the-pro-life-movement-g…
We're back to the traditional minimum bound of the Trump coalition -- 40-42 percent approval, 46-47 percent in a presidential election. (He was in the 30s during the chaotic early days of his first term but hasn't been since.)
NYT’s new Sienna poll:
“The second Trump coalition has unraveled.
The major demographic shifts of the last election have snapped back.”
Via @Nate_Cohn
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/22/upshot/trump-poll-analysis-tim…
Yesterday's newsletter, with a decent anticipation of today's events:
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/20/opinion/greenland-trump.html
Ross Douthat reposted
My thoughts on Greenland.
blog.mattglassman.net/greenland/
A Place Called Greenland.
Carney in place of Trudeau seems like a pretty big upgrade.
Sensible moderate BAP, a continuing series:
Reminder my China article. The Greenland nonsense needs to stop or USA economy at risk. USA and Europe economies are integrated at highest levels and disruptions now are counterproductive. Europe subsidizes USA debt and currency. Think 2026 and 2028 if not future.
Ross Douthat reposted
One of the most profound transformations of our time is unfolding quietly: a demographic revolution in the birth rates of India and China.
Consider 1950. The People's Republic of China had just been founded (1949), and India had recently gained independence (1947). This is the first year for which we have comparable birth data for both countries. China recorded 20.23 million births (total population: 546.82 million), while India recorded 16.50 million births (total population: 346.28 million). In other words, India's births were just 76% of China's.
Now consider 2025, the most recent year for which we have data (India's figure is an estimate, but a reliable one). China recorded 7.92 million births (total population: 1,404.89 million), while India recorded 23.10 million births (total population: 1,463.00 million). India's births are now 292% of China's.
To put it plainly: in 75 years, India has gone from having three-quarters as many births as China to nearly three times as many. The graph shows the full trajectory of this ratio from 1950 to 2025.
But today's birth rates also shape tomorrow's populations. If both countries were to maintain their current birth rates and life expectancies, China would eventually stabilise at around 633 million people, while India would settle at approximately 1,617 million, a radically different Asia from the one we know today.
Of course, projections are not destiny. India's birth rate is likely to fall considerably over the next decade. And China may manage to raise its birth rate somewhat, though I am sceptical given the much smaller cohorts of women now entering their childbearing years.
Still, based on the information available today, Asia stands on the threshold of a major demographic shift with massive geopolitical implications.
Ross Douthat reposted
This may be the most fascinating thing you read all day. (Yes, it's about a groundbreaking academic monograph, but much more.)
www.thegospelcoalition.org/reviews/josephus-jesus-new-evi…
Ross Douthat reposted
Very interesting thread in China. Three points struck me as showing a real sadness/alienation/isolation there, which surely contributes to their Baby Bust. First this one:
Tier 2-4 cities are very quiet. Few cars on the road. Don't see many people. Factory workers live in dorms on campus. Other workers are in gated compounds that are self-contained neighborhoods. Food delivery and e-commerce have replaced dining out and shopping.
10/x
I'd like to live in the timeline (a plausible one, I once thought, given his interests) where @elonmusk demanded the "pro-natalist policy experiments" portfolio from the Trump administration rather than the "cut foreign aid and hunt for Social Security fraud" portfolio.
Context for the above tweet is this comment; seems like something that might have been worth focusing on during a Washington D.C. sojourn!
Yes, and the collapse in birthrates also began before ChatGPT. But the A.I. future reaches back into the past, preparing its own way ...
Interestingly, "AI-exposed" jobs also saw the largest decline in job postings during the short 2020 recession, something that can't plausibly be explained by AI but can be explained by macroeconomic factors.
Ross Douthat reposted
I have been posting repeatedly on X about the extraordinarily fast collapse of births across the planet: in rich and poor countries, in fast-growing and slow-growing economies, in religious and secular societies, under right-wing and left-wing governments, with high taxes and with low taxes. The pattern is universal.
I knew this trend would continue. Still, the figures released this morning left me genuinely speechless. China’s government announced on Monday (see screenshot below) that births in 2025 fell to 7.92 million, a staggering 1.62 million fewer than in 2024, and that the total fertility rate has dropped to 0.93.
Few economists have been more forceful than yours truly in arguing that births are collapsing, yet even I was surprised by these numbers. I was forecasting around 8.5 million births, not 7.92.
To put this into perspective: if China could somehow sustain 7.92 million births per year from now on, its population would eventually stabilize at roughly 625 million, far below today’s 1.405 billion. In reality, as smaller cohorts reach childbearing age, births will fall well below 7.92 million. Hence, 625 million is a very generous upper bound, even under implausibly optimistic assumptions about life expectancy.
Put differently, there were fewer births in China in 2025 than in 1776, the year the United States declared independence.
I am still trying to process these numbers. This is the defining issue of our time.
Surging British abortion rates are as striking in their own way as collapsing Chinese birth rates.
These were the birth and abortion numbers that I sent viral last year. 2023 and 2024 numbers for abortions were estimates. The actual data for 2023 is now out: it is higher than the estimate. Britain is self-euthanising as a society. 🇬🇧📉
Trump takes Greenland, Europe follows Canada into China's arms, Trump doubles down on hemispheric strategy and invades Cuba, Dems win historic landslide in '28 and immediately welcome Cuba, Puerto Rico and Greenland as states, A.I. bubble bursts, Rubio wins all three in 2032.
Worth noting that Taiwan's TFR is now .72, it just fell below South Korea's (which has risen slightly from its lowest-low). Japan, down to 1.13, is a relative powerhouse.
The number of births in China collapsed to 7.92 million in 2025, a decline of 17% compared to 2024 (similar declines were reported by Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macao).
The TFR declined to 0.93 children per woman. (1.10 in 2024).
Ross Douthat reposted
NYT: "China’s Population Shrinks Again as Policies Fail to Reverse Decline | With fewer babies and more deaths, China’s population fell for a fourth straight year as policymakers face a demographic crisis in the making." www.nytimes.com/2026/01/18/business/china-population-data…
Fwiw I think there's still room for Reaganite and Buckleyite styles of conservatism to shape the right. But such influence can only be exerted through a recognition of the changed world and their own factional position.
Douthat makes it crystal clear why he is at the NYT. They both are dancing on the grave of Reagan-Buckley conservatism. He declared himself a nationalist but just not the kind that actually exists. Trying to have all ways. Escaping into historicist inevitability when real choices still have to be made.
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/17/opinion/donald-trump-conservat…
Maybe I'm wrong and there's a long game involving exile, principle, etc. that pays off. But it's not "historicist inevitability" to try to assess the realities that political actors have to deal with and the plausible scenarios of influence.
Also I didn't declare myself a nationalist, I tried to describe, in the context of a nationalist era, what I'd consider a decent post-Trump landing. It might be helpful for would-be keepers of the conservative flame to talk through their own scenarios a little more explicitly.
Ross Douthat reposted
Russia is 144M people in 2025
But my map shows where Russia is emptying out vs concentrating.
2000 → 2025:
🟩 Growth clusters around Moscow, parts of the south (Black Sea / North Caucasus), and a handful of big hubs (e.g., St. Petersburg, Kazan, Yekaterinburg, Vladivostok).
🟪 Decline spreads across the Volga–Urals belt, much of southern Siberia, and countless smaller towns in between.
With an average of only ~9 people/km², even modest migration creates vast “emptying” corridors.
If this trend continues, does Russia become a country of a few mega-regions or can policy realistically keep mid-sized towns alive?
Trump in his first term depended on internal checks to save him from himself. In the second term the checks have to be external. The bond market played that part in the spring; it's the Supreme Court's turn now.
Ross Douthat reposted
De inmediato, Nuuk pasaría a llamarse La muy Noble, Leal y Gélida Villa de Nuestra Señora de las Nieves y San Sebastián de Nuuk del Gran Norte de la Nueva España. Se construirían hospital y universidad y desembarcarían seis franciscanos que al instante aprenderían kalaallisut.
Chega and vox agree on a negotiation proposal for Greenland. #tordesillas
Two things to read together: @ezraklein interviewing Yuval Levin on the limits of Trumpian transformation ...
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/16/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-yuv…
... and our story on Congress spurning the WH's proposed spending cuts:
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/14/us/politics/congress-trump-spe…
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Francisco Segovia, a community activist training would-be anti-ICE protestors in Minneapolis:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=_WAgCZYwWJI
My takeover is complete.
Yo @nytimes what’s with the spam?
I would argue that some forms of intensive time-spending with kids can be pro-natal -- in the sense of, "these small people are cool, what if we had more of them?" But that's clearly not true of many ways that intensive parents spend their time now.
Here's what's going on:
Dads are spending more time with their kids, which is good.
Moms are working more outside the home.
Moms are NONETHELESS spending more of their day on *purely parenting responsibilities.*
We're overparenting. It's anti-natal.
This from @tylercowen seems too sanguine; I don't think you can understand the stark illiberal turn of the British "liberal" establishment except in the context of trying to fearfully manage multicultural conflict:
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/01/negativ…
Relevant, read @edwest today on "democratic backsliding" in the UK, very hard to understand the illiberal trend outside the context of demographic shifts and the managerial desire to repress populism and cope with inter-ethnic tension:
www.edwest.co.uk/p/the-return-of-liberal-authoritarianism
Various ways to think about this but one way is that some forms of respectable mid-century Christianity played an effectively disenchanting role. (And Christianity is always partially disenchanting since it deliberately closes certain supernatural doors.)
The share of Americans who believed that there is life after death was 76% in 1973.
In 2024, that share had risen to 82%.
If you're in the Los Angeles area next Tuesday evening please consider joining @jbouie, @katiekings and myself as we make complete and perfect sense of the second Trump administration's first year:
www.eventbrite.com/e/trump-the-first-year-of-his-second-t…
Solid floor of support, room to grow, promising issue.
Support For Taking Greenland By Force:
Oppose: 68%
Support: 8%
YouGov / Jan 12, 2026
This segment below is worth a watch, but not just for the difference in media tone; also for the marked difference -- the "police not paramilitaries" normalcy -- in the way that ICE dresses and behaves:
May, 2016. CNN does a segment entitled "A Day with ICE in a so-called Sanctuary City."
CNN literally rode around with ICE from the break of dawn until nighttime, watching while ICE conducted raids and arrested illegals. ICE arrested some right at their jobs.
CNN was not criticizing ICE. They were celebrating ICE. It was "exclusive access" during the Obama years and CNN considered it a privilege to get to watch ICE work.
ICE even made a "mistake" arrest. CNN had no problem with it.
Six months later Trump won the election and ICE was then labeled the gestapo.
The Trump administration theory would be that it's precisely the change in tone, the rise in anti-ICE activism and radicalism, that necessitates the change in dress and masking and conduct. But if your theory gets you these polling numbers you might need a new theory:
Medical-mysterian paranoia inches closer to vindication (though the layers of potential disinfo here still seem meaningful):
www.cnn.com/2026/01/13/politics/havana-syndrome-device-pe…
One way to look at Trump FP is that he's constantly looking for concrete coercion points as an alternative to both multilateralist drift and extended military campaigns; he's found them to some degree in the ME and LatAm, hasn't with Russia:
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/08/us/politics/trump-russia-goals…
Trumpism is founded on a rejection of the Great Awokening's attempt to establish a new post-Protestant moral consensus; it has no consistent moral vision of its own but pinballs btw contradictory nostalgias (bourgeois '50s, libertine '80s, etc.):
The biggest tension I see between Christian politics and Trumpist politics is that the former has historically been framed around regulating vices that are funny enough specifically celebrated by Trump's most enthusiastic supporters.
Productivity growth surging while hiring flatlines certainly feels like an A.I. future reaching backward to begin to shape the present.
The first "Interesting Times" of the new year is a conversation with Elliott Abrams about regime change (or is it?) in Venezuela:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=prmIf9UMzFI
Sed contra, it was precisely by intuiting that Anglo elites were unwisely comfortable with the reassertion of German sovereignty that Hitler was able to take the Rhineland, Austria and Czechoslovakia without a fight.
I get a lot of questions about this tweet.
Hitler was right that Anglo-American elites in the 1st half of the 20C were irrevocably hostile to German sovereignty, and defeat, diplomatic, political, military or economic, would lead to Weimar at best, Moscow at worst
It's true that Anglo-American elites were uninterested in compromise *after Hitler had drowned the continent in blood* but in fact at that point parts of the Nazi inner circle still retained a childlike belief that they could make a separate peace.
For example, if the July 20 bombing had succeeded, there was 0 chance that the Allies would have revoked their demand for unconditional surrender, against an aristocratic German regime. This regime would have collapsed in days—like expecting WW1 to restart after the Kaiser’s fall
The rest of the Yarvin thread mostly just lists things Hitler got wrong; he should take the L.
A very low Kindle price for Believe:
www.amazon.com/Believe-Why-Everyone-Should-Religious-eboo…
Relatedly you can listen to my full conversation with Sam Harris in the Interesting Times feed:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/making-sense-with-sam-harri…
Worth revisiting:
theweek.com/politics/1005146/the-us-has-more-in-common-wi…
As I was saying ...
www.nytimes.com/2025/12/20/opinion/marco-rubio-trump.html
2026 already coming on strong --
Mamdani: We will replace the frigidity of rugged individualism with the warmth of collectivism
Ross Douthat reposted
A Call for New Aesthetics: newaesthetics.art.
This week's episode of Interesting Times is just me, reading T.S. Eliot, in a holiday sweater. Merry Christmas and thanks to everyone who watched and listened this year.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fkUW_ao4ys
For your Yuletide entertainment a clip from my conversation with Sam Harris; the full episode will be in the "Interesting Times" audio feed next week:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jtKBbsP1OZY
Racial/religious definitions are indeed unpopular but 1) notable that support for creeds isn't universal (bc the left isn't sold on them?) and 2) plenty of room in popularity of "customs and traditions" to treat creed as a foundation of a larger edifice.
What is an American?
Only 18% say being white is important and only 34% say being Christian.
Only 37% say having many generations of ancestors makes you American; 58% reject the idea.
Meanwhile, 86% say supporting the Constitution makes you an American.
The poll asked about 21 different things. Being white, Christian, and having many ancestors were three of the four least popular choices. Basically these are the last things used to define American identity.
The Heritage American crowd does not represent the views of actual Americans.
Americans as a people believe America is an idea.
Deal with it, race hustlers.
Seems like conservatives could reasonably defend creeds as an essential binding minimum (against left-wing skepticism of Constitution/founding etc) while also arguing that the minimum is not enough, and we should want a thicker layer of habit, custom and memory as well.
There's also a crucial distinction it seems to me between being proud of your early American ancestors and wanting *them* to receive more honor in the culture and wishing to be specially honored yourself for being their descendant.
Also the H-1B debate --
This piece is justly being shared around.
All I will add is this: if you want to understand the venom behind DOGE, the attacks on academia, and the grants being cut across the government... this is the thing to read, really. This is the main reason that all is happening.
My newsletter this week is about Jacob Savage's essay on discrimination against young white males:
www.nytimes.com/2025/12/16/opinion/young-white-men-discri…
The D.E.I. theory was that this settlement was inadequate for purposes of redress + justice. But there is a big difference between telling young white men that there might be a light diversity-oriented thumb on the scale and telling them to live in this kind of hiring world:
"Suck it up, raise your game, success isn't a birthright" is a good response to modest unfairnesses. It's a message that stops selling when the system doesn't seem interested in rewarding people of your race and sex at all.
You can make the case that Rubio has played the long game better than almost any other Trump-era player.
Going to call this, unironically, the Marco Rubio moment:
Talking about the Reiner cinematic legacy with @jbouie and @mcottle:
www.nytimes.com/2025/12/16/opinion/rob-reiner-career-movi…
Let's just not.
www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/12/11/trump-marijuan…
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Andrew Kolvet, Charlie Kirk's producer and now the steward of his show, about the battle over Kirk's legacy and the future of the right:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByvhgvXiFF0
Ross Douthat reposted
With November numbers showing a ~20% year on year decline the 0.74-0.75 TFR for Taiwan is now baked in. They have switched places with South Korea as the country with the lowest fertility rate in earth. South Korea to post ~0.80 TFR this year.
🇹🇼 births are down nearly 17% this year through September. Looks set to switch places with South Korea to clinch the lowest fertility rate on a nationwide level. Taiwan will fall to ~0.75 as RoK rises to ~0.80. Taiwan will seek many more Vietnamese, Filipinos, & Indonesians.
Ross Douthat reposted
For @WorksInProgMag, I argue South Korea's ultra-low birth rates are down to policy and cultural choices.
1. South Korea waged a long-running population control campaign that successfully averted around 2 million births (not fully abandoned until the 1990s).
Ross Douthat reposted
i have a folder on my computer called:
“insane christmas vibes 1850-1950”
here are some things from it:
Ross Douthat reposted
I've written a double review of @douthatnyt and @charlesmurray's books about religion, which wound up having way more in common with each other than either author intended.
www.furtherup.net/p/religion-revisited
Ross Douthat reposted
Macron literally every year says that European civilisation could die
This is broadly correct, pace the original Warren claim the real "2-income trap" isn't that dual income couples end up behind; it's that families who might prefer to live on 1/1.5 incomes end up feeling forced into + being stressed out by a 2-income norm:
www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/12/05/why-do-people-fee…
This week's episode of Interesting Times is a conversation with Chase Strangio:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-f_n9ou8vE
"Models keep getting more impressive at the rate the short timelines people predict, but more useful at the rate the long timelines people predict."
www.dwarkesh.com/p/thoughts-on-ai-progress-dec-2025
I'm very pleased to be the latest iconic celebrity interviewed by my colleagues at Popcast:
On Popcast, a conversation with The New York Times opinion columnist Ross Douthat on how Taylor Swift’s fan base responded to her new album of domestic bliss, Trump’s relationship with the hip-hop community and more. www.nytimes.com/2025/12/02/arts/music/conservative-celebr…
There are good pieces to be written about the problem of benefit cliffs as you move up the income ladder and the rise of housing and child care costs but if you think America is full of people living in de facto poverty at $100K I don't believe you have ever visited America.
This is the best concrete take on where the viral piece goes wrong; again none of this means that housing and child care costs aren't a problem, just that we should we resist catastrophism underwritten by bad data:
economistwritingeveryday.com/2025/11/26/the-poverty-line-…
Pleased to see actual data backing up my intuition that some some NIMBYism reflects aesthetic concerns (that are entirely justified under current architectural conditions):
NEW PAPER w/ @CSElmendorf & @j_kalla:
An under-appreciated reason why voters oppose dense new housing, especially in less-dense neighborhoods: they think it looks ugly and want to prevent that, even in other neighborhoods.
Some of what we think is NIMBYism might not be!
🧵
Ross Douthat reposted
I’m reminded of this John Boehner quote he gave in 2017:
"In the 25 years I served in the United States Congress, Republicans never, ever, one time, agreed on what a healthcare proposal should look like. Not once,"
NEW: White House to delay healthcare proposal after significant congressional backlash.
According to two White House officials the announcement has been delayed, with one of those officials citing strong congressional backlash to Trump’s proposed plan.
Trump planned to make an announcement as early as Monday proposing a framework to address health care costs which included an extension of Obamacare subsides.
Ross Douthat reposted
A very striking graph in today's WSJ:
Read @tylercowen on "The Age of Disclosure":
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2025/11/the-age…
Ross Douthat reposted
Felt compelled to write about Pope Leo and his remarkable recent speech about cinema: www.vulture.com/article/the-real-reason-the-pope-gave-his…
Ross Douthat reposted
Rufo might be an annoying right-wing activist to the libs, but his reporting pointed out the mechanical process of this stuff is pretty endemic to white collar educated settings with zero Republicans present.
That's a recurring sociological background to these things.
the ucsd story was way worse than what i gleaned from the tweets, a whole public education pathway appears to have broken down because it's optimized around not having the appearance of inequity instead of teaching people things
The subtler reality is that attempts by (liberal?) conservatives to shape elite universities may be more successful under conditions created by (post-liberal?) external pressure, but only if such pressure is itself reformist not just Harvarda delenda est.
I was on a panel with @McCormickProf last fall at the Touchstone Conference, and a question came up about elite institutions.
He talked about how we can infiltrate and capture elite institutions, citing as an example the James Madison Program at Princeton, where Robbie George has spent nearly his entire career.
The Madison Program is 25 years old. It has not captured Princeton. Similar programs at places like Harvard and Yale have also failed to capture those places.
I responded to George by saying that some leftist institutions, including the Ivy League universities, cannot be infiltrated and captured. And if they cannot be captured then they should be destroyed--not just passively, by not sending our children to them, but by actively targeting and destroying them through deliberate public policy.
The people who aspire to George's career arch don't want to hear that, because it means they will never have the elite career that George has had.
"Robert George's plan for reshaping Princeton couldn't succeed absent a larger political project for higher ed reform" is an example of synthesis. "Robert George did not adequately transform Princeton therefore we should just destroy our leading universities" is a flawed theory.
I keep making this point in the context of Trumpism but elites are extremely resilient across history -- through wars, revolutions, plagues, you name it. If your theory of revolution is "we will destroy this elite" and not "part of this elite will join us" you will fail.
Ross Douthat reposted
now do the map of states offering property tax relief for marriage and childbearing!
oh wait hahahaha
there are none.
States offering special tax breaks for senior homeowners.
Ross Douthat reposted
The American right has been trained to oppose any and all taxes, but this is a terrible idea.
We must have taxes, and the distorting effects of property tax are far less than alternatives like income tax. Right now, America is crumbling apart because young people can’t afford homes while all wealth is accumulating to the old. Removing property taxes means higher taxes on working young people and higher home prices to the advantage of retirees, who are already America’s richest cohort.
Do property taxes mean some people have to downsize when their income drops? Yes — no policy makes everyone a winner (also, people who pay rent or a mortgage already have to do the same thing). But America has been a country revolving around the well-being of the elderly for decades. We need policies that help the young or we’ll end up with President Mamdani (by one name or another).
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with Paul Kingsnorth about the end of the world.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5wdJqJ708U
In a day rich with conservative infighting I thought this was a notable tweet:
During recent visit in DC, the talk of everyone was how overt the corruption was. It's at levels you read about in history books. In nearly every department. Lots of, "Do people just think Democrats will never win and they'll all get away with this?"
Ross Douthat reposted
I hope @emilyjashinsky's reporting here is correct, and that the people I talked to are wrong. I really and truly do. Read her story.
A viral figure claimed a third of young GOP staffers are Groypers.
@emilyjashinsky's reporting suggests it’s wildly inflated 👇
unherd.com/newsroom/are-30-40-of-conservative-gen-z-staff…
Relevant to the theme I keep banging on about; you do not have to hand anything to post-liberal writers but they are not the reason why polling in the UK puts the nationalist right and now the far left ahead of all the players in the old party system:
Woah! New polling.
Reform 33%
Greens 17%
Tories 16%
Source - FindOutNow
12 November 2025
UK Conservatives after Brexit didn't really Trumpify: BoJo mostly tried to suppress hard nationalism and keep doing pro-immigration liberalism, while native UK post-liberalism is a gentle hobbitish impulse a la John Milbank. Nonetheless here we are, the center does not hold.
Neither woke nor post-liberal, just an End of History guy:
The first email here seems pretty notable.
www.nytimes.com/2025/11/12/us/politics/trump-epstein-emai…
Yes, "post-liberal" effectively and confusingly refers both to any politics that rejects the development of liberalism after 1965 or 1991 and to more root-and-branch anti-liberalisms that look back to liberalism's early critics.
Would love to see anyone- advocate or critic-even define “post liberal” in a way that cogently groups together its supposed adherents.
Only definition that possibly makes sense is by first defining Thatcher and Reagan as “neo-liberal” and then noting that post liberals come,
literally, chronologically afterward.
And specific post-liberal writers can move back and forth between these positionings, sometimes offering a deep philosophical critique, sometimes offering a more modest policy course correction that would have been at home in the (liberal) 1950s or 1980s.
douthat.substack.com/p/between-neuhaus-and-de-maistre
Another reason these concepts collapse into one another is that the progressive form of liberalism is constantly rejecting features of its own recent past. From that perspective, if you reach back to a prior liberalism you become illiberal, thus post-liberal, by default.
I think the fact that populist nationalism emerges pretty organically all over the developed world after 2012 should make one skeptical of assigning too much responsibility to any single ideological faction, right-liberal or "post-liberal" or otherwise.
One way to look at it is that the embattled liberals and would-be post-liberals have both tried and failed to master trends and events that have their own mysterious inner logic, and further radicalization is the consequence of that failure.
If you think critics of liberalism were naive about how they might pave the way for groypers, then surely liberals were similarly naive in paving the way for post-liberals. But in both cases the failure is more in the realm of governance, mastering the times, than pure ideas.
I have a bias here, having known @johnnyburtka for a while and having been a recent guest on a different episode of the podcast under discussion, but I don't think this is a fair gloss on ISI's history or its current approach. Certainly during the GWB years I remember it being friendlier to what now get called "post-liberal" (and once would have been called "paleo") forms of conservatism than many RW institutions. And hosting arguments that include those ideas right now is basically the only honest way to actually engage with the debates about the future of the right.
November 10, 2025
An Open Letter to the Conservative Movement
The battle for the heart and soul of the American Conservative Movement is being fought on many fronts, with the latest trench warfare occurring in the boardrooms of its long-standing and most influential foundations and think tanks. The recent controversy @Heritage points to how Conservatism’s venerable institutions have been infiltrated and quietly taken over by a tight-knit, fringe group of post-liberal thinkers who believe America has been “off the rails” since the Founding.
In their minds, the Declaration and Constitution must take a backseat to usher in a new, post-democratic, post-capitalist economic system that advocates isolationism, an immigration ban, and a domestic policy that blurs distinctions between church and state. While often described as MAGA or populist, this group is more tightly aligned to the philosophy of media crank @TuckerCarlson than President Trump’s agenda.
As longtime board members and leaders of @ISI, the oldest conservative campus organization in America, founded in 1953 by William F. Buckley Jr., we have fought to preserve ISI’s longstanding mission from falling victim to a post-liberal hijacking. That battle was lost at a board meeting held last Friday, at the conclusion of which we tendered our resignations.
We hope our experience will serve as a wake-up call that the integrity and longstanding values of conservative institutions are being systematically and intentionally undermined by post-liberals who promote a “no enemies to the right” mindset.
We urged our fellow trustees to terminate ISI’s current President, @johnnyburtka, who formerly served as executive director of the post-liberal journal @amconmag, and return ISI to its core academic work of “Educating for Liberty” by helping American college students to learn and appreciate the perennial ideas and timeless values that have made America great.
ISI has largely abandoned its on-campus philosophical programming, which equipped future leaders to better uphold American ideals. Instead, it focuses on ideological and political podcasts that introduce audiences to alt-right online personalities, such as Tucker Carlson and others who seek to undermine the liberal ideas of the American Founding.
This fundamental shift in ISI’s focus was done behind the board’s back. It’s new signal program, the podcast Project Cosmos, was dropped on X (formerly Twitter) on August 19, featuring postliberal icon @PatrickDeneen and neo-reactionary @curtis_yarvin. Despite two board meetings taking place between the podcast’s release and the start of the costly production in February, the board was never informed of the existence of Project Cosmos.
Three Heritage Foundation directors, @LarryArnn of @Hillsdale, Michael Gleba of the Sarah Scaife Foundation, and Heritage’s current president, @KevinRobertsTX, are trustees of ISI and attended the Friday meeting. None objected to or questioned the judgment of platforming Yarvin in Project Cosmos’s inaugural episode. This, after being confronted with a long list of damning quotes from Yarvin.
Yarvin is a self-described neo-reactionary, unapologetic monarchist, and a leader of the Dark Enlightenment movement who advocates for “rebooting” and replacing liberal democracy. He writes, “If Americans want to change their government, they're going to have to get over their dictator phobia.” He has also said, “Although I am not a white nationalist, I am not exactly allergic to the stuff.”
Rather than peeling away disaffected young males who flock to the noxious ideas of Fuentes and Yarvin, ISI’s Project Cosmos fawns over their anti-liberal philosophies. They appear to be successful in appealing to the Yarvin-Fuentes-Carlson echo chamber, as Project Cosmos reported that the video garnered six million views on X, with a skewing of more than 90% male.
What is unclear is how many women and other traditional ISI students, professors, alumni, and donors are turned off by ISI’s celebration of the odious and un-American ideas espoused by Yarvin, Fuentes, and Carlson. Traditionally, ISI’s mission was to teach American ideals to curious students on college campuses. The mission of helping students search for truth is now replaced by the post-liberals’ lust for political power in Washington.
The Heritage Foundation and Hillsdale College are not the only pillars of the modern Conservative Movement to subsidize @TCNetwork. Carlson was the headliner at ISI’s gala two years ago, and this year, one of its three $75,000 annual fellowships went to the Tucker Carlson Network. Before Burtka’s arrival, fellows were found at genuine journalism outlets, including @WSJ, @USATODAY, @NRO, and @dallasnews.
What happened at Heritage and ISI in recent weeks underscores how a cadre of post-liberals has worked together, behind the scenes, to wrest control of conservative institutions from actual conservatives. They have quietly filled boardrooms with post-liberals, integralists, and other fellow travelers who disdain traditional conservatism’s central tenets of free markets, limited government, individual liberty, and personal responsibility. These usurpers of conservatism, as Yarvin puts it, find America’s core principles to be “historically leftist” and prevent the right from defeating the left both philosophically and at the ballot box.
The leaders of the postliberal project continue to be close friends with Carlson, Yarvin, and their ilk, to be open to discussion with the likes of Fuentes and other racists and antisemites, and to praise autocrats like Hungary’s Viktor Orban—and Carlson even lauds the “social values” of Venezuela’s dictator Nicolas Maduro. They echo Yarvin’s call to overcome the fear of dictatorship and relinquish respect for representative government and the checks and balances the Founders established.
Traditional conservatives who believe in America’s Founding principles and look back at the Reagan Revolution as a step in the right direction need to wake up and understand the battle currently underway.
Heritage’s Founder and longtime ISI Chairman Edwin J. Feulner, Jr., presciently warned in the final article he penned in @NationalAffairs before his death this past July:
“An existential identity crisis now grips the American right. A political movement once united by commitment to limited government, moral order, and a robust defense of American ideals now appears fractured, its purpose clouded by populist grievances and ideological drift.”
Supporters of ISI, Heritage, and other mainstream Conservative institutions must be on notice that the programs and purposes they are funding may no longer be what they think they are. Today is the time for choosing. We hope all conservatives will choose to fight on the side of William F. Buckley, Jr. and give no corner to those preaching white supremacy, antisemitism, eugenics, and bigotry.
Onward!
Christopher Long, former President, Intercollegiate Studies Institute
Thomas Lynch, former Chairman, Intercollegiate Studies Institute
Well, eight years after being VP, with some intervening events --
It's become very clear, in retrospect, that Charlie Kirk was holding the Right together and that we need J.D. Vance to step into that role, which will require settling disputes and laying out the boundaries of the coalition. Nixon figured out how to do this after being VP.
A low hardcover price if you're Christmas shopping for the almost-believer or regretful unbeliever in your life:
www.amazon.com/Believe-Why-Everyone-Should-Religious/dp/0…
A feature of the shutdown is that a downscale GOP coalition means SNAP spending cuts impose more pain on right-leaning voters -- but Dems still understand themselves as the party of government so it's hard for them to fully weaponize.
www.natesilver.net/p/trump-made-a-huge-blunder-on-the?tri…
Useful take but I suspect housing a bigger deal in the story; if inflation is still too elevated to allow mortgage interest rates to come down, it makes a big part of normal middle class life seem out of reach even if ppl have $$ for everyday consumption.
www.slowboring.com/p/affordability-is-just-high-nominal
Trump's 50 year mortgage trial balloon is a terrible idea but also an example of policy flailing to get out of a high prices/high interest rates trap that can probably only be really escaped by cutting deficits + building.
Related:
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2025/11/housing…
My Sunday column: What If The Monarchy Went Out With A Bang?: www.nytimes.com/2025/11/08/opinion/prince-andrew-royals-m…
Ross Douthat reposted
Trump has spent 10 months sending the message that the govt does what he wants. Demolishing the East Wing was just an exclamation mark on that. So it shouldn't be surprising that Rs can't offload blame for the shutdown. If Trump wants the government open, why isn't it open?
It was my great pleasure to join the techno-optimism (or pessimism!) episode of ISI’s new show Project Cosmos, aka “conservatives arguing on comfortable couches”:
The Case for Techno-Optimism? | Project Cosmos
(00:00) - Introduction: Technology and Conservative Perspectives
(40:46) - The Virtues and Pitfalls of Modern Technology
(55:02) - Hyper-Politics and the Failure of Political Solutions
(1:06:28) - Global Competition and China's Technological Rise
(1:19:59) - Ameliorating the Worst: Limited Reforms and Class Divides
(1:26:34) - Christian Anthropology and Decentralized Solutions
(1:32:44) - Personal Witness and Spiritual Awakening
The third episode of Project Cosmos (Conversations on the Future of Civilization) is here!
Featuring: Frank Hanna, @DouthatNYT, @aaron_renn, @mmathesonmiller, @matthewwalther, @johnnyburtka,
shot, chaser, etc ...
Link for the Cheney piece:
www.compactmag.com/article/cheneys-last-laugh/
This week's Interesting Times brings Helen Andrews and Leah Libresco Sargeant together to discuss whether we have too much feminization or too little:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=xkTglJuqq8U
At once remarkable and unsurprising given history of social psychology. Also relevant for debates about cases like Fatima or Jesus's resurrection, and the skeptical conceit that hyped religious expectations easily yield self-deluding supernaturalist cope.
The fall of "When prophecies fail": Another social psychology classic turns out to be based on fabrications and lies.
In 1954, Dorothy Martin predicted an apocalyptic flood and promised her followers rescue by flying saucers. In “When Prophecy Fails “ (1956), the now-canonical account of the event, Festinger, Riecken and Schachter claimed that the group doubled down on its beliefs and began recruiting—evidence, the authors argued, of a new psychological mechanism, cognitive dissonance.
When Prophecy Fails is one of the most influential case studies in 20th-century social science. It shaped popular understandings of how belief survives disconfirmation, and became a touchstone for explaining the origins of religious movements...
But the case was misrepresented. The cult did not persist, proselytize, or reinterpret its failure as a spiritual triumph. Its leader recanted, the group disbanded, and belief dissolved. Drawing on newly unsealed archival material, this article demonstrates that the book's central claims are false, and that the authors knew they were false. The documents reveal that the group actively proselytized well before the prophecy failed and quickly abandoned their beliefs afterward.
They also expose serious ethical violations by the researchers. The newly unsealed Box 4 of papers contain transcripts, telephone logs, research notes, channeled messages, and internal communications among the researchers. Collectively, they reveal serious ethical breaches: fabrications, covert manipulation, and at least one instance of interference with a child welfare investigation.
One coauthor, Henry Riecken, posed as a spiritual authority and later admitted he had “precipitated” the climactic events of the study. This article shows that the authors of When Prophecy Fails misled their readers—and that scholars in psychology, sociology, and religious studies have been building theories atop a collapsed foundation.
The full scope and variety of the misrepresentations and misconduct of the researchers needed the unsealed archives of Festinger to emerge, the full story could not be written until now. Every major claim of the book is false, and the researchers’ notes leave no option but to conclude the misrepresentations were intentional.
My sources tell me that this jab has persuaded @ezraklein to announce his campaign for president earlier than planned.
“Socialist is not a dirty word anymore – that’s why they jumped to ‘communist,’” Jamaal Bowman said to @mehdirhasan.
“Democrats, listen up. Take some lessons – don’t get on your Ezra Klein nonsense. Don’t let Ezra Klein 'analyze' what happened here,” he added.
With @hasanthehun, @prem_thakker, and Mahmoud Khalil.
A 55 vote filibuster is the reasonable compromise that nobody wants to embrace: Preserves the underlying logic but adapts to a polarized era, like the earlier step down from 67 to 60.
In fairness Ramaswamy campaigned on colorblind patriotism as an alternative to an ascendant wokeness, which is not exactly the current culture-war dynamic.
Republicans shouldn't campaign on culture wars or wokeness, says guy who premised his entire presidential campaign on culture wars and wokeness
A brief comment on the new mayor of NYC:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwHGoZXTaI8
My newsletter this week is about the right's Nick Fuentes problem, but the conclusion is entirely relevant to last night's electoral result:
www.nytimes.com/2025/11/04/opinion/nick-fuentes-antisemit…
You either die an edgelord or live long enough to become the sensible moderate.
Ross Douthat reposted
And we have a massive Baby Bust,
Yet...
1) Our federal government continues to massively transfer wealth from 30-somethings (the age of family-formation) to old folks
2) Republican state governments are considering exempting the elderly from property taxes!
Old people (75+) are increasingly wealthy.
Young people (<35) are increasingly not.
This new paper suggests that the reason behind these divergent trends is... mostly housing!
This, plus cutting out what we're spending on candles.
I’m convinced we could pay off our entire national debt by doing 3 simple things:
1. Ban all non-citizens from welfare programs
2. Strict, enforceable work requirement for EBT/SNAP/Section 8
3. Mass prosecute welfare fraud with federal prison time for stealing from taxpayers
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Shyam Sankar, the CTO of Palantir and a lieutenant colonel in the US Army Reserves:
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/30/opinion/palantir-shyam-sankar-…
An important part of wisdom is recognizing that many educated Westerners have these experiences too, they just don't have an accepted language for discussing them.
www.richardhanania.com/p/fatima-and-the-sample-size-compe…
The Politics of Evasion 2.0, in search of its Bill Clinton.
It's time to renew the Democratic Party.
Introducing DECIDING TO WIN: the most comprehensive account yet of where Democrats went wrong, and what we need to do to win again.
With a year of research and tons of new data, by @laurenhpope, @liamkerr, and me.
Link and 🧵 below.
Recent Epstein leaks and stories have weakened (via the strong Acosta denials) the intelligence asset theory but strengthened (via both Prince Andrew and Leon Black correspondence) the Epstein-as-panderer case.
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with @jasonfurman about a possible A.I. bubble and the true state of the Trump economy:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoJH9cGtv1s
I wrote about the very Trump-era mix of coarseness and conservative impulses in "Life of A Showgirl":
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/21/opinion/taylor-swift-life-show…
Ross Douthat reposted
perfect, and perfectly revealing, in every detail
A good Bronze Age Pervert tweet; with key rural exceptions (the Mennonites!) population collapse will herald the triumph of the city over the countryside and the megalopolis over the regional city.
Next decades: depopulation of countrysides worldwide conglomeration into cities and even few cities and capitals…already well advanced in Japan. Countryside everywhere increasingly desolate bleak, depleted of youth. Biggest problem: where refuge of youth in aging world?
I think "larger and better coordinated" is an overstatement, but certainly you need something substantial and extremely weird in its own right to explain the current era of not-quite-disclosure, with all its imagery and testimonials and cast.
The UFO "Distraction" conspiracy so many here knowingly cite would, at this point, have to be larger and better coordinated than the cover-up conspiracy they find so outlandish.
French crowns literally lying in gutters waiting to be found.
DIRECT | Selon nos informations, un des bijoux dérobés au Louvre a été retrouvé à l'extérieur du musée
il s'agirait de la couronne de l'impératrice Eugénie qui a été brisée
➡️ l.leparisien.fr/zN1g
Ross Douthat reposted
This is art
I asked Curtis Sliwa "are you okay with losing and knowing you contributed to Mamdani's victory?"
I did my best to relay the concerns of capitalist america and used @BillAckman's tweet as a reference "a vote for Curtis Sliwa is a vote for Zohran Mamdani"
This was Sliwa's response.
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with Justice Amy Coney Barrett:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=b94thInW27c
Ross Douthat reposted
As the Obama Pres Center is getting much hate, I am reminded that it's on a large chunk of Chicago's Jackson Park, which used to be the grounds of the famous 1893 World's Columbian Exposition. Let's take a look at which Exposition buildings (6 of them) used to be on this site...
Ah, but at least it isn't a real presidential library, and also took over significant green space in one of the city's largest and most historically important parks
“Well, that's funny, because I happen to have Mr. Land right here . . .”
www.compactmag.com/article/the-faith-of-nick-land/
On the Young Republican groupchat, you do in fact have to hand it to @RichardHanania
www.richardhanania.com/p/the-based-ritual
And on the pedestal, these words appear:
"we will allow even more,
including erotica for verified adults"
Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
Of that colossal Wreck, boundless and bare
The lone and level sands stretch far away.
We made ChatGPT pretty restrictive to make sure we were being careful with mental health issues. We realize this made it less useful/enjoyable to many users who had no mental health problems, but given the seriousness of the issue we wanted to get this right.
Now that we have been able to mitigate the serious mental health issues and have new tools, we are going to be able to safely relax the restrictions in most cases.
In a few weeks, we plan to put out a new version of ChatGPT that allows people to have a personality that behaves more like what people liked about 4o (we hope it will be better!). If you want your ChatGPT to respond in a very human-like way, or use a ton of emoji, or act like a friend, ChatGPT should do it (but only if you want it, not because we are usage-maxxing).
In December, as we roll out age-gating more fully and as part of our “treat adult users like adults” principle, we will allow even more, like erotica for verified adults.
A take on the papal exhortation: I found the section on almsgiving more interesting and convicting than the sweeping generalizations, and I think it would benefit the faithful if the Church gave much more *concrete* advice on our charitable obligations.
www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/apost_exhortations/docu…
The Catholic right sometimes soft-pedals or evades social doctrine. But talking constantly about systems and structures can evade or downplay personal obligations as well. The Church is most competent and effective when advising believers on *giving.* (And I need the push!)
Hoping Houellebecq and Trump can share a stage when they both get their Nobels next year.
Ross Douthat reposted
Ross Douthat reposted
Brutalism blunders bc it rarely respects the material. They could learn some things from the Egyptians:
Heavy masses should act heavy, sloping slowly inwards. Few spans. Monumentalness is opportunity for light
This city hall just looks like it wants to fall down. let it.
I wrote about Dallas City Hall. Designed by I.M. Pei, it's an incredible feat of architecture that was meant to embody progressivism and a new start after the JFK assassination. Also, it was in RoboCop. At the end of the month, city leaders could vote to tear it down.
Having some fun imagining the timeline where the Nobel goes to Kushner rather than Trump ...
Rough day for Jared Kushner's haters
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with Douglas Wilson about theocracy, predestination and other matters:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=WAYWbbSeIhE
Noah Millman is worth reading on scenarios for a Gaza peace:
gideons.substack.com/p/a-ray-of-hope-in-the-season-of-joy
One of my slightly eccentric 2024 opinions was that the case for Trump was substantially stronger on foreign than domestic policy, and as of today that theory of the case is holding up ok.
Re-read Scott Alexander's Fatima post (why not?) and I think this is where his analysis goes astray - after realizing there were a bunch of "echo" miracles like the initial case, not all church-approved, he decides that *strengthens* a skeptic's case.
www.astralcodexten.com/p/the-fatima-sun-miracle-much-more
It's outside the Miracle of Sun territory but also would have been interested in Alexander's exhaustive-rationalist take on the Russia/Communism/WWII prophecies.
I should close out this thread by noting that “Believe” is on sale on Amazon:
www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0310367581
Newsletter: An Ideological Revolution Needs 12 Years in Power:
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/07/opinion/trump-2028-election.html
Ross Douthat reposted
The WSJ homepage right now
No forgiveness for casting Phoenix as Napoleon, sorry.
x.com/FilmUpdates/status/1975136947476590810
My weekend column is on the two faces of post-liberalism: www.nytimes.com/2025/10/04/opinion/progressives-populists…
Ross Douthat reposted
For the second night in a row, Munich International Airport in Southern Germany has been closed for arriving and departing flights due to the sighting of unidentified drones in the airspace near Munich.
Expectations fall away?
5+: far out of normie zone, more than double what most people have, expectations surrounding you fall away
-any signs of not completely falling apart amaze outsiders
-no one expects travel plus they can't host, you are the host now
-forced to give up a lot
I expected to be mildly annoyed by Scott Alexander's attempt at an exhaustive rationalist take on Fatima/Miracle of the Sun but it was actually enjoyable and rich with interesting links.
www.astralcodexten.com/p/the-fatima-sun-miracle-much-more
For instance, I wasn't aware of just how many "echo" experiences there have been over the years, let alone of the YouTube videos:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yF0_ysUivxE&t=206s
Useful Noah Millman point on the challenge that an ideologically-cohesive liberal base poses for outreach-oriented Dems:
gideons.substack.com/p/the-democrats-have-met-the-enemy
A striking passage, on the French Catholic revival:
www.pillarcatholic.com/p/bibles-and-islam-the-unexpected-…
in order of preference: B, A, D, C, E
You can only live & travel within one region of the United States for the rest of your life. What are you picking?
Q is whether Dems will be politically lucky enough to find a standard bearer who satisfies the crazy-pugilist itch while also moderating on a few key issues -- the Trump-2016 cocktail:
The past few weeks have been very instructive in explaining how Trump took over the GOP. Huge swathes of the Democratic Party — especially media entrepreneurs — hate its leadership and think it doesn’t “fight” enough and will embrace anything that feels like fighting back.
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with Hasan Piker:
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/02/opinion/hasan-piker-interestin…
Sometimes Dems almost seem to want to encourage Trump to do abnormal things: You saw this when they took up the TACO line, almost goading him in hopes that any crazy might redound to their benefit. Shutdown maybe fits that theory -- push him to overreach?
There are basically two competing theories among Democrats about how to fight Trump, and the party's shutdown strategy doesn't make sense on either of them
(Not sure this is a consciously-held idea, just that it fits with some Dem behavior.)
An example of what I'm talking about in tweets above: Reacting to the WH exploiting the shutdown by arguing that it's actually a political self-own:
Russ is playing to a hard core MAGA/Fox News audience while House Republicans in some of these states are gonna take a big political hit for it -- you're totally Owning The Libs, Russ
For a long time I've been inclined to accept that bc porn habituates ppl to virtuality it may reduce sex crimes for the same reason that virtuality may reduce *all* real-world activity. So interesting to read this counter-argument from @lymanstoneky:
The result of AI child porn will be more abused children. I wrote about this recently here:
Ross Douthat reposted
“Do other cities do this?”
“Yes”
“Name one.”
“I know you Abundance Bros want people to DIE”
Anti-abundance leftists are not sending their best.
Ross Douthat reposted
Next week @UVA: "Believe: A Conversation w/ @DouthatNYT on Religion and Family in America"
Mormonism attracts a special kind of is-it-Christian controversy in part because it's really unusual to have such a wildly unorthodox theology and cosmology framing a very traditional attitude to core Qs about the Virgin Birth and resurrection.
As a lifelong member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, I’m a Christian
As Latter-day Saints, we believe that:
• Jesus Christ is the Only Begotten Son of God, born of the Virgin Mary (Luke 1:35)
• He is the Creator and God of the Old Testament and the Savior of the New Testament (John 1:1-3)
• He lived a sinless life, took upon Himself the sins of all mankind, and atoned for us through His suffering and death (1 Peter 2:22, Alma 7:11-12)
• He rose on the third day, ensuring our resurrection and offering eternal life through faith in Him (1 Corinthians 15:20-22)
• He is the only way to salvation (Acts 4:12)
We worship Jesus Christ, follow His teachings, and take upon His name through baptism and weekly sacrament
The Book of Mormon, alongside the Bible, testifies of His divinity and mission
As our Church’s name declares, Jesus Christ is at the heart of our religion
He is the author and finisher of our faith (Hebrews 12:2)
If that doesn’t make us Christians, I don’t know what does
You may define Christianity differently, and that’s your right
If you do, that doesn’t change my faith in Jesus Christ
Nor does it diminish my respect for your sacred beliefs
Not for a moment
And I would substitute "orthodox Christian" for "Christian" here and describe various heresies as still effectively Christian even if the line does blur eventually.
The issue of who is and who is not a Christian was settled a long time ago as people diverged into heresy and the church came together in 325 AD. If you subscribe to the Nicene Creed, or more specifically the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed of 381 AD, you’re a Christian.
Pretty confident that God is up to something interesting with the LDS story long term but that's a private theological opinion, non-binding on the faithful.
A Michaelmas update on The Falcon's Children: The complete novel is now available in audio and text, it will be up for the next six months while I figure out next steps for the story, and paid subscriptions will be on sale till then, at the price of a paperback. Links below ...
The book:
www.falconschildren.com/p/table-of-contents
The sale:
www.falconschildren.com/subscribe?coupon=8155a1a0
Ross Douthat reposted
When my wife asks me about my book purchases
Ross Douthat reposted
It's the eve of Michaelmas, the great feast of St Michael and All Angels - an invocation of the powers of light as the year turns towards the darker days of autumn. Here's a thread on Michaelmas daisies, geese, moons, and other traditional namesakes of the angels' feast.
Michaelmas, on 29 September, is not only an important festival in the church year but in England also historically the autumn quarter-day. It marked a moment of transition: the shift from the harvest season into later autumn, the start of new contracts and new school terms.
My Sunday column is an expression of pundit frustration over our mysterious technological frontier.
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/27/opinion/drones-artificial-inte…
"What indeed, Mr. Hanania?"
Wait what
One reason for this is that Trump keeps tweeting about essential it is to get his enemies.
I don’t know if James Comey is innocent or guilty, but I do know that when the Biden DoJ indicted Trump aides Peter Navarro and Steve Bannon, the WP and NYT treated it as straight news, not as Biden going after his opponents. But now, it’s all about Trump getting his enemies.
Interesting discussion from @aaron_renn about scenarios where hollow/fading Mainline denominations end up presenting entrepreneurial opportunities for young conservative-leaning pastors:
Right now the trends favor non-(post?) denominational Protestantism but the Mainline still has all the best buildings, plus endowments and div schools; some of it can remain a liberal rump and some can be sold off but presumably some could be claimed by emergent forces.
Ross Douthat reposted
The new fertility rate map for Canada in 2024 by Province. Overall, the Fertility Rate was 1.25. The lowest was British Colombia at 1.02 and the highest was in Nunavut at 2.34.
Fertility rate map of Canada in 2023. Canada has the lowest fertility rate of any Anglosphere nation at 1.26. The province with the lowest fertility rate is British Columbia at 1. The region with the highest is the territory of Nunavut at 2.48.
As statements from heads of state go, this is a weird one, and not just because she's off-center.
Denmark has in recent days been subjected to ‘hybrid’ attacks involving drones over critical military and civilian sites, prime minister Mette Frederiksen said in a video statement www.reuters.com/world/europe/denmark-reopens-airports-aft…
This is, indeed, a necessary understanding, but in my experience the norms of parental effort in meritocratic culture are powerful enough to create an inevitable thread of subconscious guilt even if you consciously reject it.
one thing i've really found helpful about watching a number of larger families up close is that both parents obviously love and sacrifice for their children enormously but there's a clear understanding that sacrificing everything for your children is not a reasonable way to live
One thing we have done pretty successfully is create expectations of mutual sacrifice. (Now we will visit a national park! Now you will wait in the car while your mother does an interview with a scientist ... ) But that's a luxury of journalism; harder as an i-banker I imagine.
Ross Douthat reposted
when i ask how your fall vibe is going i'm not asking about autumn i'm asking about life after satan and a third of the angels left heaven and man was expelled from the garden to toil and grow on the earth
I think it's more that populism tends toward a mix of hyperbole ("now we will DeSTRoY the LEft forever") and hapless execution (Kimmel's back already) and it's more successful in both big and small things when it speaks softly and masters the bureaucracy.
It is so difficult to process the difference in orders of magnitude between the power of the left and the “power” of the right, even in office, that the pinpricks of the right are easy to paint as gigantic and unprecedented.
That’s why big things are easier than small things
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with May Mailman about the Trump administration's plan to reshape higher education:
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/25/opinion/trump-academia-victim-…
A wise friend points out that phenomena like this might themselves be curated by the AIs to feed an appetite for the creepy and paranormal stories among AI skeptics; they get you addicted to their content either way.
www.lesswrong.com/posts/6ZnznCaTcbGYsCmqu/the-rise-of-par…
This is all true, but there's more: To perform even impermanent vandalism against great art is a symbolic act against civilization, and thus a fast way to strip moral authority from yourself.
It is not a victimless crime to normalize attacking artwork in museums.
It leads to:
-increased restrictions on visitors
-placing plexiglass in front of works/keeping visitors too far back to see brush strokes
-making a house for beauty a place you are surveilled and suspected
Trump FP: Where everything is negotiable, and everything that is offered can be withdrawn, with prejudice.
After getting to know and fully understand the Ukraine/Russia Military and Economic situation and, after seeing the Economic trouble it is causing Russia, I think Ukraine, with the support of the European Union, is in a position to fight and WIN all of Ukraine back in its original form. With time, patience, and the financial support of Europe and, in particular, NATO, the original Borders from where this War started, is very much an option. Why not? Russia has been fighting aimlessly for three and a half years a War that should have taken a Real Military Power less than a week to win. This is not distinguishing Russia. In fact, it is very much making them look like “a paper tiger.” When the people living in Moscow, and all of the Great Cities, Towns, and Districts all throughout Russia, find out what is really going on with this War, the fact that it’s almost impossible for them to get Gasoline through the long lines that are being formed, and all of the other things that are taking place in their War Economy, where most of their money is being spent on fighting Ukraine, which has Great Spirit, and only getting better, Ukraine would be able to take back their Country in its original form and, who knows, maybe even go further than that! Putin and Russia are in BIG Economic trouble, and this is the time for Ukraine to act. In any event, I wish both Countries well. We will continue to supply weapons to NATO for NATO to do what they want with them. Good luck to all! DONALD J. TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
(TS: 23 Sep 14:55 ET)
When dealing w/problems like autism or chronic illness where official consensus lacks answers/cures, it seems like it would make sense to fund a *lot* more research -- oddball research esp. -- rather than assuming answers must be already there if you just pick the right study.
Christianity After Charlie Kirk:
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/22/opinion/charlie-kirk-memorial-…
Multiple things can be true at once. Yes, the USA is deeply Protestant and US Catholicism is inculturated -- and indeed this Americanized model of Catholicism is increasingly a model for the Church under conditions of pluralist competition worldwide. 1/2
What do I mean by this?
I mean that America is and always has been a Protestant nation and that Catholics, in assimilating to America, have assimilated to Protestantism, both politically and culturally.
They have moderated their allegiance to the pope (Vance didn't kiss the ring), looking to him for "spiritual" guidance, but not political dominion.
They have softened on some of their theological distinctives (not one of the Roman Catholic speakers suggested that Charlie Kirk is in purgatory; instead, he's seeing his Savior face to face; that's Protestantism).
They have essentially accepted their status as one of the major denominations within (American) Christendom, which is a Protestant conception of the church (much like C.S. Lewis gives the Catholics a room in the Mere Christianity house; they may have a room, but it's a Protestant house).
Yes, I still believe that they have substantial errors in their theology (as Charlie Kirk did--from transubstantiation to biblical authority to the Eucharist). And I will never tire of thanking God for the doctrine of justification by faith alone (Trust in Christ alone and you will be saved, whether Presbyterian, Baptist, or papist).
But they have adapted to our Protestant ways, and I, for one, am grateful.
In sum, America is a Protestant tree, and the Catholics have nested in our branches for so long that they've begun to grow some leaves.
At the same time the *most* inculturated forms of US Catholicism are fading, the resilient models are adapted to pluralism but also strongly emphasize Catholic distinctives, and while these forms lag non-denom Protestantism they're often outcompeting denominational forms.
And a future where US Christianity is increasingly divided between non-denom Protestantism and Roman Catholicism seems like something a bit more complex than just RCs finding our place in the Protestant denominational tree.
The prospects for revival are inherently uncertain, but the definitive story you can tell about American evangelicalism in the wake of the Kirk assassination is one of *resilience* in the face of trends that seemed to be unraveling religious conservatism 10 yrs ago.
I'm stressing American evangelicalism rather than American Christianity because (notwithstanding Catholic influence) the memorial service was an intensely evangelical event, maybe the most notable expression of evangelical-inflected religio-political witness since the Bush era.
Ross Douthat reposted
My interview with Erika Kirk (free link): www.nytimes.com/2025/09/21/us/politics/erika-kirk.html?un…
Having the former president highlight Attiah's firing as his key example of state censorship is notable on two levels. At one level it reflects the resilience of a progressive bubble; presumably the president is unaware of the actual details of the case.
This is precisely the kind of government coercion that the First Amendment was designed to prevent — and media companies need to start standing up rather than capitulating to it. www.nytimes.com/2025/09/15/business/media/washington-post…
At another level, though, it reflects the correct intuition that a culture of censorship can take shape without the state constantly acting as the censor. But this of course was what many Americans experienced throughout the woke era, without bestirring Obama to their defense.
It would be extremely healthy for a figure like Obama to acknowledge what became obvious in 2019-2021 - that a distributed, public-private form of speech policing can actually feel as oppressive as any FCC warning. That would actually be a useful intervention right now.
"If we just do things that seem popular and pretty reasonable, our ideological enemies will ruthlessly destroy us, we need to do things that are obnoxious and unpopular instead" -- the credo of two political parties that keep losing their majorities for some reason.
Ross Douthat reposted
Boring graph. Fascinating conclusion.
The share of Americans who believe in "life after death" was 76% in 1973.
Today, it's about 81%.
One big reason?
The non-religious are more likely to believe in the afterlife now (~60%) than 50 years ago (50%).
An informational note about the present media landscape. Jimmy Kimmel's show has about 1.7 million nightly viewers. Heather Cox Richardson's newsletter has 2.7 million daily subscribers.
(Yes many of her subscribers probably don't read her every day but I also doubt the average Kimmel viewer is glued to the TV screen.)
The woke were warned their tools could be turned against them but couldn't imagine history's arc bending rightward. (I struggled to imagine it myself.) Now populists facing the same warning keep implying no future censorious left could exceed what we've had already. (We'll see.)
I think it's true that a ruthless counter-offensive can sometimes be the key to eventual stabilization. But Donald Trump has zero interest in that stabilization, and the right will just ride his aggression till it discovers hard resistance.
To put a finer point on it, the cultural stabilization described aspirationally here is impossible if your primary "paternal steward" believes the First Amendment includes a large exemption for anything that wounds his own amour-propre:
If the right is going to have a durable mandate to exercise a kind of paternal stewardship of the institutions it needs to reflect the sober, non-deranged, competent, and confident qualities expected from paternal stewardship.
Liberals failed at this. This is why they lost. The right has some time to grow into it, but that grace period will not last forever, and we will need to drop the antics and get there soon.
If you're in DC next Tuesday please join us to discuss some ultimate and of-the-moment questions:
ihe.catholic.edu/event/between-god-and-the-machine-how-sh…
This week's "Interesting Times" is a conversation with my colleague @ezraklein about the moment, and the condition of progressivism:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVL69ZfvhuQ
Ross Douthat reposted
NIH grantmaking appears to be back on track!
Withholding science funding was a major unforced error.
Very glad to see this reversal.
A frenzy of grantmaking in August has the NIH seemingly on pace to spend its entire $47 billion budget by the end of the fiscal year on Sept. 30 www.statnews.com/2025/09/12/nih-spending-47-billion-budget/
In the social media era everything seems simultaneous rather than chronological and causal: Online I can see incitement and pro-assassination rhetoric - and overreaching responses - and backlash to overreach - and critique of the backlash; it's all at once, layers not sequences.
Ross Douthat reposted
* Detain frequent offenders pre-trial;
* Incarcerate them longer;
* Fix the national mental health bed shortage;
* Give outpatient treatment the tools to succeed.
In @TheAtlantic, @Rafa_Mangual and I explain how to prevent the next Charlotte murder:
As much as I understand intellectually that the UK is post-Christian there's still always something startling about reminders - whether it's the Tory leader saying she doesn't believe in God or Andrew Roberts, Mr. Churchill himself, going Full Euthanasia:
www.compactmag.com/article/the-nihilism-of-andrew-roberts/
RIP, Sundance:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXoY7eIrAtk
Just as a point of clarification, it would be outrageous to demand someone's firing because they argued George Zimmerman acted in self-defense; less so if they said "Trayvon Martin deserved to be murdered in cold blood and Obama should be next."
Truly insane. If Barack Obama had said you should call the employer of anyone cheering Trayvon Martin’s murder it is all conservatives would talk about for decades.
And yes, people *will* be fired for merely criticizing Kirk's politics, and the right can cancel unjustly with the same zeal as the left. But it still has to be stipulated that you aren't a sympathetic victim of RW cancel culture if you're fired for endorsing or inciting murder.
Btw I give @Timodc real credit for acknowledging that he's seeing beyond-the-pale responses in his own feedback. But note that this is feedback from the audience for an ex-Republican and would-be defender of liberal norms. He's not sifting obscure Discord convos to find it.
Ross Douthat reposted
Cancel culture was about punishing people for peaceable political participation, and opinions that were perfectly normal. We wouldn’t have gone to the mat defending Brendan Eich if he was lustily celebrating murder. www.nationalreview.com/corner/cancellation-and-violence/
Excited to learn what kind of deal we've struck with our great authoritarian rival to safeguard the app they built that makes us all hate each other.
“The big Trade Meeting in Europe between The United States of America, and China, has gone VERY WELL! It will be concluding shortly. A deal was also reached on a ‘certain’ company that young people in our Country very much wanted to save...” - President Donald J. Trump
This is a good thread. As John says, the Christian is obliged to regard even purely-private rage and fantasy as sinful. But the internet-era externalization of the inner monologue creates a new kind of occasion of sin for everyone who listens to it.
Here's the danger of social media. It allows people to publish their internal monologues. Our internal monologues and fantasies are often incredibly ugly. People go to therapists because they feel so guilty about them, and one of the tasks of a therapist is to explain that 1/
In lieu of a normal episode of "Interesting Times," here's a brief commentary on Charlie Kirk and a destabilized America:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yEtjV6A_nGc&t=1s
Charlie Kirk, RIP:
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/10/opinion/charlie-kirk-trump-con…
Ross Douthat reposted
RIP Charlie Kirk, who at 31 was one of the most important figures - in elections, in commentary, in media - in the conservative movement. www.semafor.com/article/09/10/2025/kirk-who-transformed-u…
Ross Douthat reposted
I would really recommend not watching the video of the shooting
Pray for Charlie Kirk, pray for America.
The job revisions and the Harris lament are fuel for my sense that Joe Biden is likely to end up placed in the very bottom rank of US presidents -- ranked lower the worse you think of Trump.
The US and Canada are destined to be one country.
🗺️ Series: Population Density (No. 12) - North America
North America's population density averages about 22 people per square kilometer, with significant regional variations.
🔧 Tools: Python (Rasterio, Geopandas, Shapely)
Mistake was using Hellfire missiles, need to try Gabriel or Raphael missiles instead.
In today’s UAP hearing, we revealed new military surveillance video showing a UAP splitting a Hellfire missile in mid-air.
Not a single witness was aware of any U.S. military technology capable of such a feat.
Every witness described the footage as extremely “scary”.
Thoughts? Comments? Debunkings?
A new video of an alleged UAP off the coast of Yemen in Oct. 2024 was shown by Rep. Eric Burlison, R-MO, at a congressional hearing Tuesday on unidentified anomalous phenomena. “What the hell is that?” KLAS journalist George Knapp responded.
Latest: www.newsnationnow.com/space/uap-transparency-hearing-whis…
I did not realize that modern astrology uses the wrong star map, no wonder the predictions are so dodgy!
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/upshot/zodiac-signs.html
On the left -- old, busted, fake self-description. On the right -- completely accurate in every respect. ("enigmatic but also incredibly charismatic")
The full data doesn't show male-female misalignment though as much as conservative-liberal misalignment, and the fact that conservative and liberal birthrates are indeed diverging suggests that it's measuring something more real than just signaling.
This is silly. The reason liberal women don’t say having kids is the definition of a successful life is because that is clearly coded in a way that evokes a past era when women were only allowed to do that. In reality, young men & young women both desire the same number of kids
Read both @SteveKornacki tweets below: Trump voting 18-29 men are more family-oriented than Trump-voting women but both are reasonably pro-family + reasonably aligned; likewise Harris-voting men + women who both place marriage/kids wayyy at the bottom.
Our NBC News Decision Desk poll asked Gen Z adults (18-29 years old) what they consider important to a successful life. The combination of gender and politics produced two very different sets of priorities:
One story here is gender misalignment, since there are more Harris-voting women and more Trump-voting men. But the other story is anti-natal gender alignment on the left, where both sexes have strongly anti-familial value hierarchies -- raising Q of how the left will reproduce.
Which is conveniently the subject of my last newsletter:
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/02/opinion/birth-rate-progressive…
New "Interesting Times" on the (potential) Chinese Century, with "Breakneck" author Dan Wang:
www.nytimes.com/2025/09/04/opinion/china-global-superpowe…
Full thread is important, but this part especially corresponds to my personal experience:
But none of them would ever say that publicly. They figured I was safe, because right-leaning columnist. They didn't want to be quoted, they were hiding it from a lot of their friends, and they were both afraid, and furious that they were afraid to state the *utterly obvious fact* that males have an athletic advantage.
There's a clear division where right-wing forms of post-liberalism tend to have charismatic populist champions while left-wing forms are faceless exercises of bureaucratic power. e.g. nobody thinks Keir Starmer is checking names off an enemies list; it's just the System at work.
This extends to lower levels of government as well: If the US health system takes a crackpot turn it will be clearly due to RFK Jr.'s personal obsessions, whereas Canada's lurch into euthanasia is just the institutional wheels of late progressivism turning, turning ...
Among the varieties of post-liberalism, the Graham Linehan arrest falls under the category of what I've called "managerial multiculturalism" -- basically an attempt to preserve the peace of a diverse society by sacrificing liberties of speech and association:
More from that attempted taxonomy here:
www.nytimes.com/2024/12/06/opinion/south-korea-liberalism…
Late summer self-promotion: "Believe" and "The Deep Places" are both now just $5.99 on Kindle; never has knowledge of both the divine architecture of the cosmos and the secret empire of tick-borne illness come so cheap; your esoteric illumination awaits.
A conversation with @bariweiss (her podcast, not mine) about the Epstein affair and conspiracy theories in America:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=iGBFxpnXop0
This week's episode of Interesting Times is a conversation with Jeremy Lewin, the youthful DOGE alum overseeing US foreign aid:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LDeJ4rlyyE
The continuing senatorial interest in this subject is of continuing interest to me.
SEN. SCHUMER FILES UAP DISCLOSURE ACT (UAPDA) AS POSSIBLE AMENDMENT TO NATIONAL DEFENSE AUTHORIZATION ACT (NDAA)
Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY), the Senate minority leader, on July 29, 2025, filed the "Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Disclosure Act of 2025" (UAPDA) as a proposed amendment (SA 3111) to the FY 2026 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA, S. 2296).
The proposed amendment was co-sponsored by Senators Mike Rounds (R-SD) and Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY).
The complete text of SA 3111 can be accessed in PDF at the link in the first reply to this post. It appears on pages S4847-4854 of the Congressional Record for July 29, 2025.
Like UAPDA versions proposed in 2023 and 2024, SA 3111 would create a temporary federal agency headed by a presidentially appointed, Senate-confirmed review board, tasked with gathering UAP-related information from throughout the government, as part of "an enforceable, independent, and accountable process for the public disclosure of such records."
On initial examination, SA 3111 appears nearly identical to the UAPDA version filed on July 11, 2024, including the much-discussed provision to provide the review board with power of eminent domain in certain circumstances.
No date has yet been announced for Senate floor consideration of the NDAA, S. 2296. In most years, relatively few amendments are added to an NDAA after open debate and roll call votes on the Senate floor, but a greater number of amendments are incorporated into the bill through out-of-sight negotiations. The UAPDA is an unlikely candidate for a full floor debate and roll call vote; most likely the sponsors hope to get it added to a negotiated list that will be wrapped into the Senate NDAA in bloc, as occurred in 2023.
Even if the Senate includes SA 3111 in the NDAA that it passes, however, it would remain to be negotiated with the House of Representatives. The version of NDAA approved by the House Armed Services Committee on July 15, 2025 (H.R. 3838) does not contain any such language.
As approved the Senate Armed Services Committee on July 15, S. 2296 currently contains three modest UAP-related provisions. In addition, the committee's official report on the bill (Senate Report 119-39) contains two interesting directives pertaining to the operations of the All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO). I have previously reported on both the UAP-related bill language and report language (see the posts in my timeline for July 16 and July 19, respectively).
The core critique of Israeli policy right now doesn't vindicate "globalize the intifada" protests, nor does it reflect the influence of an anti-Israel psyop. Israeli policy changed, the humanitarian consequences are grim, the policy needs to change again.
x.com/mattyglesias/status/1950653746582524126
Yes, but ... part of the steep pre-Baby Boom dive reflects plunging infant mortality; people have fewer babies but overall family size doesn't change as much. When you factor that in, the more recent drop-off looks a bit sharper.
The total fertility rate was nose diving for over a century in the USA and briefly went up post WW2 before dropping again
No one ever shares the whole chart
This week's episode of Interesting Times is a conversation about the UFO phenomenon (whatever it may be) with Diana Walsh Pasulka:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7n4nctI60c
Ross Douthat reposted
One cost of the Great Awokening was that people spent too much time managing their own reputations within institutions and professional circles, and not enough time thinking about how they were coming off outside it:
Ross Douthat reposted
Folks, I need to inform you that there is very concerning data regarding the food situation in Gaza.
Firstly, let me just that that as someone who supports Israel I anticipate many on my side will be skeptical of this and I totally understand why. Throughout the war you have been fed false information from the UN and various "Humanitarian" institutions and media who have essentially zero concern for truth or anything resembling reality. As I have publicly documented extensively, these institutions repeatedly fabricated data, then lied about their own data they fabricated, made up nonsense on the spot, all completely shamelessly knowing they wouldn't be questioned, and of course were repeatedly proven wrong (including by myself from my own past analyses and counter-predictions). My view of these institutions has not changed. "Humanitarian" institutions have been and still are the ultimate kings of pseudoscience.
That all being said, the fable of the boy who cried wolf has an important moral which is not that wolves don't exist and will never attack anyone. Rather, it is precisely because wolves do exist and will eventually attack that makes it so important to not cry wolf. And ideally, even when the UN cries wolf and a wolf actually happens to finally be there, we should still be ready for that.
Prices of staple food items for calories and/or protein (tracked over time in the same region, minimizing noise) have reached extremely high values, many of which are unprecedented throughout the war. This data was compiled by @YannayASpitzer, from the Department of Economics at @HebrewU.
This is concerning as relative changes food prices have been a reasonable indicator for access to food in Gaza throughout the war, even while free aid, distribution, concomitant looting of aid, potential hoarding of aid (insert additional concerns here) were all concomitantly happening. While this data can be complex and hard to standardize, they overall did what you would expect them to do - when access was low, they went up, when access was high, they went down. Now they're up at levels we haven't seen before (standardized for market location as above).
Also, this isn't just my assessment. It also isn't just Yannay's assessment. This sentiment was also expressed by the GHF themselves. They said "the situation in Gaza is dire". This isn't coming from the UN or some other "Humanitarian" pseudoscience factory. This is coming from the GHF, who are on the ground and see what is happening firsthand every day without the anti-Israel lenses on.
Something needs to change. The suggestions I have at the moment (getting at things that will work but also politically viable/realistic):
1) Scale up humanitarian operations:
- Increase the food quantity to be distributed, petition for increased funding if necessary.
- Increase distribution site number to increase access and minimize crowding at any single site.
- Increase the operational time open of distribution centers, for the same reasons.
2) Reduce casualties of civilians en-route to aid centers: Without litigating each case (which is not the purpose of this post), the civilian casualties near/en-route to humanitarian centers ultimately limits aid access and needs to be improved.
- Higher thresholds for engagement, including for warning shots
- Consider policing protocols for crowd control (while the IDF is not the police, if they are going to be doing a policing job, they should be implementing police protocols at least to some degree)
3) Force idle aid to be distributed:
Yes, do this by force if necessary. It doesn't matter if aid is idle in a truck, a warehouse, or even being hoarded. If it's not going anywhere, it might as well not exist.
- Implement protocols such that aid idle beyond a given time will be seized for distribution to any other humanitarian organization that will distribute it. Not just idle trucks, but aid idle in UN warehouses as well. And to whatever degree claims of warehouse hoarding by Hamas or other nefarious actors are true, raid and seize that aid for distribution too. Aid doesn't sit. It goes to the people who need it. Period.
Other suggestions are welcome, so long as they are politically realistic (this mean accounting for what certain authorities will and will not allow, even if you don't like that) and genuinely motivated by improving the situation rather than scoring political points or feeding some moral sense of righteous indignation.
He was joking but as a consolation prize tomorrow's episode of Interesting Times is about UFOs.
BREAKING: Congressman Frost claims "The White House is about to drop proof of aliens."
A slight problem w/this "based Protestants don't need lectures about ancient Christianity" line in debates about ME Christians is that based US Protestantism depends for its political influence on an alliance with the biggest ancient Christianity of all.
American Protestants don’t need to turn to “ancient communities” for their faith. They only need the Bible. That is enough. It’s all there is, in fact.
All the other garbage by cosplaying latter-day Fr. Coughlins and Third World accounts is an anti-American, sectarian op.
This week's episode of Interesting Times is a conversation with Allie Beth Stuckey:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfhAtLf3XQY&t=5s
Ross Douthat reposted
NEW:
There’s been a lot of discussion lately about rising graduate unemployment.
I dug a little closer and a striking story emerged:
Unemployment is climbing among young graduate *men*, but college-educated young women are generally doing okay.
Ross Douthat reposted
I wrote about the lack of administrative support for the liberal arts in @nytimes. The standard story we hear is that students don't want it. But a darker reality is that even when it wins big with students and donors it loses with those in power.
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/17/opinion/liberal-arts-college-s…
This week's newsletter: What Do Conservatives Offer Universities?:
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/15/opinion/conservative-professor…
My weekend column: Who Is Winning the World War?
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/12/opinion/trump-russia-china-ira…
Maybe if Rubio and Cruz did a unity ticket ...
New poll:
40% Mamdani
24% Cuomo
15% Adams
14% Sliwa
If Cuomo & Adams joined forces, they could beat Mamdani.
If Cuomo, Adams, & Sliwa joined forces, they would beat Mamdani.
These politicians refuse to consolidate NYC's anti-socialist majority—history will not forget them.
Ross Douthat reposted
How American voters feel completely changing their minds on everything the second that a new person is in power
Wow — New Gallup poll:
—Trump approval on immigration: 35-62
—Record high approval of immigration (79-17 overall)
—78% of people support a pathway to citizenship (+8 from 2024); only 38% support mass deportation (-9 from 2024)
—30% want decrease in immigration (-25 from 2024)
Can't believe Harvard is considering founding an entire academic institute just to troll @Vermeullarmine:
link:
www.wsj.com/us-news/education/harvard-conservative-schola…
An all-timer for "poets who believe in Rhyming" alone.
most universities & colleges surely have faculty members who are contrarians? liberals & progressives are always quarreling with one another; "the left eats its own"; hiring conservatives per se will result in very lop-sided resumés especially in the sciences. really, research universities should hire physicists who disbelieve in modern physics? anthropologists who believe that "Aryans" are the master race? poets who believe in Rhyming? philosophers who are staunch Thomists, or believe in the Creation? historians who don't acknowledge slavery in the US?
what a clown show, a sort of campus "Book of Mormon."
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation about the Gaza War, Israel, anti-Semitism and more with my colleague Bret Stephens:
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/10/opinion/israel-american-jews.html
Since the syllabus is circulating, here's something I wrote last year on the Columbia Core Curriculum's post-WWII reading assignments:
www.nytimes.com/2024/04/27/opinion/columbia-university-pr…
As I said, the America Party will need celebrity Senate candidates with a lot of natural crossover appeal ...
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/09/us/politics/elon-musk-curtis-y…
A good debate-complicating post, making the point that upward mobility in downscale America often depends on the interaction of conservative life choices and judicious reliance on welfare-state subsidies for work/family:
I've seen versions of this several times, it's directionally correct but the reality is less "libertarian."
It is really important to legally marry, and then you move into an apartment. You DO NOT want to wait to have kids, because at this income level kids increase net family resources in multiple ways, they don't "cost" the way they do for established middle class.
Ideally a couple kids come rapidly, wife stays home. Husband works and probably increases his responsibility level. All of a sudden you get several thousand bucks at tax time in refundable credits, family is on free health care, might be using SNAP.
By the time the kids are starting school, this family often does progress into buying a first home (maybe a HUD home) via government subsidized "first time homebuyer" programs that largely waive down-payment.
With a stable marriage and no drug issues, these families often do progress over time from minimum wage into a middle-middle or lower middle lifestyle.
Nothing makes me sympathize with Elon's longshot plan to elect a handful of independent senators to encourage fiscal discipline like being told that he should be trying to get a Balanced Budget Amendment passed instead.
#breaking: Gov. Ron DeSantis suggests @ElonMusk put his resources, instead of a new political party and a few Congress candidates, toward getting up to 34 State Legislatures ratifying a balanced budget amendment to call a convention if he wants the most impact on reining in spending
Trying to build the Murkowski-Collins-Romney-Manchin Party in the Senate is a non-crazy idea, but targeting a few states where "the margin is razor-thin" is the wrong way to do it -- note that none of the examples above come from classic swing states.
🇺🇸 HOW ELON COULD BREAK THE TWO-PARTY STRANGLEHOLD
Launching a new party means building a platform, registering with the FEC, winning ballot access state by state, and recruiting candidates - all while dodging lawsuits from Democrats and Republicans trying to block it.
Elon's move? Target just 2-3 Senate seats and 8-10 House districts - skip the national circus, hit where margins are razor-thin.
He’s polling millions on X, has an existing PAC, and could crowdsource signatures quickly and easily.
If he pulls it off, it could be the biggest disruption to U.S politics in recent memory and the beginning of a new third-party era.
Source: FEC, WSJ, Politico
States with razor-thin margins are often quite polarized and ideological (Wisconsin, e.g.). Whereas states where one party has a general lock can have more voters looking for alternatives, who may be open to heterodox figures who are distinct from their national party.
The goal would be to take the Popular Moderate Governor from Minority Party type (Beshear, Hogan, Bel Edwards, etc.) and make it feel safe to vote for them for Senate too.
One interpretation of architectural politics since WWII: Liberal PMC has included great preservers of beauty and destructive backers of radical uglification (sometimes the same ppl); conservative-populist tastes tend to a blah-functionality middle ground.
www.compactmag.com/article/the-cultural-contradictions-of…
Carlos Lozada on John Jakes:
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/01/opinion/july4-john-jakes-ameri…
I guess my take that the The Two Towers is the best movie in the trilogy needs another generation to ripen.
Maybe "best" is too strong, I think FOTR is the most completely successful and TT has more weak points and stretched-out sections. But the highs in TT -- Edoras and Helm's Deep, especially -- are the trilogy at its best.
Me reading reader rankings of LOTR movies:
Truly bizarre arc for the University of Tulsa: From trashing its humanities program (www.city-journal.org/article/storm-clouds-over-tulsa) to embracing a revivalist program under @jennfrey to abandoning the new effort, all in just six years:
Now for some personal news: today is my last day as Dean. I was stunned to be informed by our new provost there will no longer be a Dean of Honors, period. Nor an Assistant Dean. Rather, I was told there will be a “director” of honors--but that person will not be me. (12/21)
On vacation scarcity for the PMC, the key is to lower the status of resorts and beach houses and raise the status of insane family road trips --
I have a theory that the ennui of the UMC/PMC/affluent is because they find themselves struggling to pay for hallmarks of their middle class childhoods (Disney and brags vacations, college, and most of all housing) despite making far more money than their parents.
All those goods (which are Veblen goods) have fixed supplies though. The number of Ivy League spots has barely increased even nominally in 40 years. There’s still only six domestic Disney theme parks, as many as there were in 2001. And all the major beaches have been built up now for decades. So an increasing number of affluent families are chasing the same amount of luxury goods with ever greater intensity, allowing prices to spike.
Something’s gotta give though. Upper middle class discontent is one of those things that, when it reaches a boil, triggers severe societal unrest if not a revolution.
Didn't realize that today is World UFO Day, but just in time here is my newsletter take on the state of the UFO debate:
www.nytimes.com/2025/07/01/opinion/pentagon-ufo.html
One follow-up: Since the newsletter links to an interview w/the late Harald Malmgren as one example of recent UFO testimonials, I should also link to this compelling-seeming case that Malmgren spent his later life confabulating tales of his own influence:
douglasjohnson.ghost.io/harald-malmgren-history-vs-fantasy/
Ross Douthat reposted
New monthly birth update is out! Turns out 2025 will bring an even steeper decline of the number of births than 2024 with many countries now reporting double-digit declines.
The bill looks like a triumph of GOP sclerosis + dysfunction over attempts to remake its agenda along coherent populist (Vance) or dynamist (Musk) lines, which is why the VP is implausibly casting its details as so much "minutiae" and Musk is screaming from the sidelines.
Score one for the reassertion of decadence, in other words.
The last five days.
This week's Interesting Times is a conversation with @continetti about the ideology of Trump 2.0 and the state of conservatism under Trumpian conditions:
www.nytimes.com/2025/06/12/opinion/trump-immigration-cons…
Worth reading and also bookmarking for 2027 and 2035:
blog.samaltman.com/the-gentle-singularity
The American economy looks surprisingly resilient given that (I'm told) we're doomed to languish and decline in the shadow of a Chinese-dominated century.
Starting a thousand anonymous SimpsonBowles2028 accounts to monetize the next big algorithmic swing.
Credit where due
hey @realDonaldTrump lmk if u need any breakup advice
Somewhere on the back roads of Ohio, Vivek Ramaswamy is having a pretty good day.
This week's episode of "Interesting Times" is a conversation with Tony Gilroy, the man behind "Andor," about the politics of art and the future of the movies:
www.nytimes.com/2025/06/05/opinion/film-hollywood-andor-p…
Ross Douthat reposted
These "esoteric geography" threads by @CWingUexkull are a good example of how in some ways, pre-Elon twitter, w its tighter free speech paramaters, was actually very good for creativity. Feel like X culture just doesn't produce anything like this.
x.com/CWingUexkull/status/1553004853026340864
Elon would do the world and his audience on this website a great service if he made it clear that the drivers of federal spending are not unspecified "pork" but rather a distinct group of health care and retirement programs that are all extremely popular.
This is the reality that defeated many would-be budget cutters before Musk, there is no shame in that failure -- but he should acknowledge what actually defeated him!
Good thread about the most artistically successful modern pop fantasy series (note that the "huge mistake" critique is not of the Williams books themselves but of their more cynical/grimdark successors):
The Memory Sorrow Thorn series (1988-1993) is fantasy's missing link. It's the most successfully-achieved epic fantasy project done in the vein of Tolkien and it laid the foundations for the modern politically-savvy fantasy novel. This was a huge mistake.
In general I think it's often the case that a successful work of art, like a fruitful culture, exists in a liminal space between a traditional mode and a revisionist mode, where both spirits are operational. But it's very easy to lose that equipoise.
Ross Douthat reposted
I’m sharing my slide deck on the demographic future of humanity,
🔗 Slides: www.sas.upenn.edu/~jesusfv/Slides_London.pdf
prepared for the keynote address I will give tomorrow to the 7th EBRD and CEPR Research Symposium on “The Economics of Demographic Change”:
🔗 Symposium: www.ebrd.com/home/news-and-events/news/events/economics-o…
Here are a few key ideas I’ll be discussing tomorrow, some of which even economists tracking population trends may not fully appreciate:
1️⃣ Fertility is falling everywhere: rich and poor countries alike, booming and stagnating economies, secular and religious societies. The decline is happening far faster than anyone anticipated, even me, ten years ago!
2️⃣ For example, Colombia’s fertility rate is 1.06, Iran’s is 1.44, and Turkey’s is 1.48, all of which are below the U.S.
3️⃣ The decline accelerated around 2014, well before the COVID pandemic.
4️⃣ As a result, humanity’s fertility is likely already below the replacement rate.
5️⃣ Many assume the replacement rate is 2.1 children per woman. That’s true for rich, advanced economies. But not for emerging economies, where selective abortion and higher young female mortality push the replacement rate higher. Thus, for humanity, the replacement rate is closer to 2.2.
6️⃣ The 2024 UN World Population Prospects are riddled with data and forecasts that, frankly, make little sense to my coauthor Patrick Norrick (at @AEI) and me.
7️⃣ Most of the differences in economic growth among advanced economies over the past 35 years can be attributed to demographic factors. Once adjusted for this, Japan’s economic performance is roughly on par with the U.S. (See my paper with Gustavo Ventura, @King_ofSweden, and Wen Yao, The Wealth of Working Nations):
🔗www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00142921250001…
There are many other ideas (I could talk about this for hours!), but here’s the punchline: the world’s fertility crisis is worse than you thought, even after considering you already thought it was bad.
"To coffee -- the solution to, and cause of, all of life's problems!"
most people have no idea how psychoactive alkaloids work. why would they? i love coffee. look at this chart: if you drink coffee, after 500 minutes, the caffeine is still there. many people experience this feeling as anxiety. theyd never connect it to a cup of coffee 10 hours ago
This week's episode of "Interesting Times" is a conversation with @_alice_evans about the romance recession and the fertility collapse:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3BBapHuklN8
This week's newsletter, on the House Budget:
The One Way Trump Hasn't Changed the GOP:
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/27/opinion/trump-republican-budge…
Ross Douthat reposted
Does pronatal policy work?
Almost 60 different studied pronatal policy interventions say YES: increasing per-child benefits by 4% of GDP per capita consistently increases births by 1%, ultimately a pretty big effect!
The latest chapter of The Falcon's Children, only three left, perfect time to commit to the whole book :)
One answer to the Q @mattyglesias raises here - why did a WH inner circle of moderate functionaries preside over a leftward lurch? - lies in realms of the spirit; a revolution is often operationalized by the older ppl you might have expected to resist it.
www.slowboring.com/p/what-we-dont-learn-in-original-sin
Nothing about the 1960s and 1970s makes sense for instance without a recognition that the Boomers didn't *do* the revolution by themselves; the key decisions were made by 40-60somethings carried along by the spirit of the age.
This week's episode of "Interesting Times" is a conversation, in Rome, with the Vice President of the United States:
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/21/opinion/jd-vance-pope-trump-im…
Ross Douthat reposted
This is how you know the Holy Father is a true Midwesterner
Ross Douthat reposted
Pope Leo XIV gets emotional as he receives the Fisherman's Ring, a special gold ring bearing the image of St. Peter and the Pope's name and seal. Cardinal Tagle put the ring on him. #popeleoxiv #inaugurationmass #vatican #catholicchurch
A calming counterpoint to "AI: 2027" --
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/16/technology/what-is-agi.html
And for those who find "AI: 2027" too optimistic:
I wrote a book with Eliezer Yudkowsky. It’s about how smarter-than-human AI is on track to kill us all, written in hopes of bringing the conversation into the mainstream. Lots of people are alarmed; ~nobody wants to sound alarmist. The time is ripe. Preorders help. Link below.
Interesting Times, Episode 6: The Imminent A.I. Takeover Scenario:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wNJJ9QUabkA
My friend @DavidSchaengold has just launched a new social media site, Radiopaper -- @RadiopaperHQ -- that's designed to offer more of a republic-of-letters feel than what's on offer elsewhere on the internet. I strongly recommend giving it a look.
radiopaper.com/home
I can't exactly promise regular posting but I've offered a couple of comments, and you can follow me there:
radiopaper.com/RossDouthat
This narrative notably puts cooperation between the American cardinals, liberal and conservative, at the center of the story.
The Election of Pope Leo XIV:
A fractured Bergoglian-wing, organized resistance by conservatives and a united front of U.S. cardinals allowed Robert Prevost to ascend to the papacy.
This thread, based on conversations with Church insiders, details how the conclave transpired.
Ross Douthat reposted
My new piece with @AvitalBalwit on how AI will change human existence: www.thefp.com/p/ai-will-change-what-it-is-to-be-human
Ross Douthat reposted
Pope Leo XIV chanting the noonday Regina Caeli in St. Peter’s Square today
Ross Douthat reposted
The White Sox identify Leo as the 268th pope, while Rome counts 267.
Clearly the Chicago White Sox believe that Emperor Constantius’s removal of Pope Liberius was lawful, thus making Felix II a legitimate pope.
It's fine to think Catholic teaching is crazy but Jesus's actual "message" on sex is that lust is adultery and if your eye offends, pluck it out, so ...
The Church just built crazy teaching about sex on top of crazy teaching about sex until they ended up with entire web of doctrines that were substantively bad (as I said, the condom one really did harm in the world very recently) and had nothing to do with Jesus' message.
Whatever this is, it's not some sort of pragmatic and self-consciously "reasonable" ethic:
Ross Douthat reposted
How we "guessed" the Pope using network science: inside the cardinal network. A study by me, Beppe Soda and Alessandro Iorio. Article: www.unibocconi.it/en/news/network-conclave @Unibocconi
Ross Douthat reposted
On this week's episode, I talked to @DouthatNYT about his new book, 'Believe: Why Everyone Should Be Religious,' and, in particular, asked him why I should be religious. www.nationalreview.com/corner/why-charles-should-be-relig…
Good homily --
www.americamagazine.org/faith/2025/05/09/pope-leo-homily-…
Wholesome pope content thread:
We ended up going and um my girls are going to be plastered over every news service
Easy to imagine ways it could be better but the radicalization of liberal institutions/Democratic elite would have only intensified (esp. since Trump would have lost the pop vote again) with its own set of unforeseeable effects.
The timeline where Trump pulls off the upset in 2020 is better than the timeline we are on for Rs, Ds, and the country as a whole. In fact I am not sure there are more than a handful of ways ours is better. Discuss amongst yourselves
Interesting Times, Episode 5: Can Democrats Win the Working Class and Save the American Republic?:
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/08/opinion/democrats-working-clas…
Ross Douthat reposted
The collapse of births and fertility (births per 1000 women age 15-49) in Poland since 2017 is truly stunning (2025 based on 2 months data). No argument about housing or car seats or daycare can explain this.
Ross Douthat reposted
I'm basically an optimist, but I find it hard to argue against two claims:
a) Screens/social media makes it easier to not pay attention in school
b) GenAI makes it easier to cheat in school
The combination of (a) + (b) is going to be a huge challenge for young ppl's education.
When you layer over that the fact that generative AI tools are going to get more intelligent over a period of time when teen and adult literacy scores are declining, I think you've got the basic ingredients of a pretty serious cultural problem.
For the conclave, a conversation about conservative Catholics and the papacy with myself, @michaelbd and @ddhitchens:
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/07/opinion/pope-francis-conclave-…
And my recent podcast conversation with @JamesMartinSJ, talking across the liberal-versus-conservative divide:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_i66tcCbHw&t=66s
The Laotian Cardinal, by Robert Ludlum
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/04/world/europe/papal-conclave-po…
Today's job numbers are both a reason to hope that the US can somehow power through the tariff wars and another reminder that these are wars of choice -- Trump decided to radically remake an economy that offered a solid base for popularity and political success.
Which is why Canadian conservatives should support Quebecois independence and Anglophone-Canadian union with the United States.
the fundamental problem Canadian conservatives have is their country just is a liberal country
My father's new book of poetry is officially out this week. This thread will offer a few of the individual poems, though the book is best read straight through, as a portrait of a family and a journey through the valley of the shadow of death.
"The Return"
And the book itself:
www.amazon.com/Again-Charles-Douthat/dp/B0DZK1MZMQ
Ross Douthat reposted
👍
What's weird is all the podcasters who think they can explain American politics without the second mode of analysis!
i love every ross douthat podcast because he'll be like "when we compare the intellectual base and superstructure of bush-era conservatism with reagan with trump..." and then five minutes he's saying the spirit world is real but doesn't always have our best interests at heart
Lots of reasons having to do w/the arc of liberalism and the weirdness of depopulation scenarios relative to Malthusian ones; also "The Handmaid's Tale" is a notable story about underpopulation even if the dystopia portrayed is the reactionary response.
Anxiety about overpopulation influenced on a lot of late 20th century scifi (eg Solent Green, Logan's Run). Anxiety about underpopulation/aging population doesn't seem to have had the same influence on contemporary scifi (only example I can think of is Children of Men). Why not?
Also, not a late-20th example exactly, but Lord of the Rings is a story about demographic decline.
Maybe, or maybe liberal/progressive norms still inculcate some sense of residually-Christian charitable obligation whereas the current based-billionaire class tends to be more fully post-Christian.
Philanthropy is a machine for converting money to power. Libertarians and conservatives don’t want power.
They want to be free from power. They are confused by why their enemies project onto them. Autism.
Normal, non-autistic humans want power. That makes them liberals
Just a theory. I think it's also true that the right-wing rich are stronger believers in capitalism as a value system and thus more likely to demand instant ROI for efforts whose ROI is inherently long-term and diffuse.
And to be clear I don't think the liberal rich are necessarily donating for high-minded quasi-religious reasons, just that the social pressure encouraging them to be *seen* as charitable donors has residually religious roots.
Very strong @ddhitchens retrospective on Francis, the anti-Pio Nono and perhaps the endpoint of the papal era that began with the Syllabus of Errors:
A rollercoaster. An epic. A disaster. And the end of an era.
My @firstthingsmag retrospective on the Francis years: firstthings.com/the-last-modern-pope/
CLICK
If you happen to be obsessed with Margin Call... this is a fun read, and was a fun interview to do
Not even remotely close to being the case --
Of course Francis is open to criticism on various fronts, but in the end American Catholics opposed to him and his official writings were against him because of his strong opposition to an unqualified capitalist economic global order.
The Vatican always has world-historical energy --
Extraordinary scenes in the Vatican.
Ross Douthat reposted
Zelensky and Trump at the Vatican.
My extremely scientific heuristic of adding two points to Trump's polling baseline performed very well in 2024.
x.com/mattyglesias/status/1915877002105721248
Good.
much to unpack in Trump's Time interview. but among the actual admissions he does make of news value is that he would be fine if Abrego Garcia was brought back to the country and retried
In which, doubtless with some supernatural assistance, I induce my beloved colleague @ezraklein to discuss an "incredibly profound and mystical encounter" with -- perhaps? maybe? -- the God of Abrahamic faith:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/25/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-ros…
Our youngest is named Matthew in part because of a visit to this chapel last spring:
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/04/24/arts/pope-francis-…
LOL
He also, like many professors I've spoken to, says that the average grade on assignments is way up, and the average grade on exams is way down.
Ross Douthat reposted
NSF and NIH need reform.
They fund too many incremental, consensus-oriented research projects from older scientists.
They should be funding high-risk, high reward ideas from younger scientists and new organizations.
Draconian budget cuts do nothing to fix these real problems.
Ross Douthat reposted
I should totally show up and say I'm Jeffrey Goldberg.
Later today I will be meeting with, of all people, Jeffrey Goldberg, the Editor of The Atlantic, and the person responsible for many fictional stories about me, including the made-up HOAX on “Suckers and Losers” and, SignalGate, something he was somewhat more “successful” with. Jeffrey is bringing with him Michael Scherer and Ashley Parker, not exactly pro-Trump writers, either, to put it mildly! The story they are writing, they have told my representatives, will be entitled, “The Most Consequential President of this Century.” I am doing this interview out of curiosity, and as a competition with myself, just to see if it’s possible for The Atlantic to be “truthful.” Are they capable of writing a fair story on “TRUMP”? The way I look at it, what can be so bad – I WON!
From Donald Trump Truth Social 04/24/25 11:51 AM
Interesting Times, Episode 3: Pope Francis and the Catholic Future, with @JamesMartinSJ:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/24/opinion/pope-death-legacy-inte…
Ross Douthat reposted
Whether Trump had a Latino breakthrough or whether he was renting their votes as President Low Prices is a question worth 50-60 electoral votes.
Trump approval/disapproval with HISPANICS in new Pew Poll: 27% / 72%
would indicate a sharp dropoff from his 2024 performance:
www.pewresearch.org/politics/2025/04/23/evaluations-of-tr…
The repeated eagerness of the stock market to rally on modest walkbacks of the trade war is a reminder that many of the Trump administration's problems could be quickly addressed through the incredibly simple expedient of just not. doing. certain. things.
The other thing about Trump's position is that if he does walk away from unpopular policies there isn't some large independent RW infrastructure that will punish him or damn him as a sell-out, the way the left threatened to punish Biden if he didn't do the full Liz Warren.
Sure you'll hear pundits on the left say, "Trump is defeated" or "the 2nd term is already over" or "what's left of Trumpism now?" But in political reality walking away would just make Trump more popular with normies without costing him meaningfully with his base.
Ross Douthat reposted
Reminder St George:
✅ was English (from Kent)
✅ Killed a dragon (in Maidstone)
✅ Loved a pint
Bosh
Happy St George's Day!
England's national day, when we celebrate our patron saint, a Turkish officer in the Roman army who died in Palestine and never visited Britain.
And, he didn't kill a dragon.
Ross Douthat reposted
How can we support American families when a new baby comes along?
A baby bonus (a $2000 payment that comes as soon after birth as possible) helps parents when they need it most, and doesn't strain the federal budget.
Here's my proposal:
Today felt like a day when this reality at least touched the edges of Trump's consciousness:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/12/opinion/trump-tariffs-catastro…
Links to recent essays; first a big one on the future of the human race:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/19/opinion/extinction-technology-…
Second a commentary on the Holy Father's passing:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/21/opinion/pope-francis-catholic-…
Finally a take on the moral-theological problems of "The White Lotus" Season 3:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/18/opinion/white-lotus.html
Of course you know I think it's good for the administration to consider pro-natalist ideas, but right now nothing would be more pro-natalist than avoiding an unnecessary recession.
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/21/us/politics/trump-birthrate-pr…
An unfortunate reality of a low-birthrate society is that it's easier for bad economic times to crash fertility than for good times to restore it, and adding a baby bonus in the face of a real recession is like adding a few stones to your sandcastle at high tide.
"They took the body down from the cross and one of the few rich men among the first Christians obtained permission to bury it in a rock tomb in his garden; the Romans setting a military guard lest there should be some riot and attempt to recover the body. There was once more a natural symbolism in these natural proceedings; it was well that the tomb should be sealed with all the secrecy of ancient eastern sepulture and guarded by the authority of the Caesars. For in that second cavern the whole of that great and glorious humanity which we call antiquity was gathered up and covered over; and in that place it was buried. It was the end of a very great thing called human history; the history that was merely human. The mythologies and the philosophies were buried there, the gods and the heroes and the sages. In the great Roman phrase, they had lived. But as they could only live, so they could only die; and they were dead.
On the third day the friends of Christ coming at daybreak to the place found the grave empty and the stone rolled away. In varying ways they realised the new wonder; but even they hardly realised that the world had died in the night. What they were looking at was the first day of a new creation, with a new heaven and a new earth; and in a semblance of the gardener God walked again in the garden, in the cool not of the evening but the dawn."
--Chesterton, The Everlasting Man
A distinctive take on 2013 as the decisive year for the return of history (of course real ones know it's because that was the year Benedict XVI resigned).
We don't talk enough about the fact that the world-regime of post-national U.S.-flavored liberal soft-influence nonprofits was actually emergent and imminent and a smart bet--until Xi Jinping. Until 2013 exactly. Xi made nationalism the biggest thing this century. He did it.
Trumpism and all forms of nationalist populism in the West from mid-2010s through present, was a consquence of Xi-ism. Of the fact that "liberal-influenced China" was not, it turned out, going to be a thing. Before Xi, it was actually a reasonable plan to go get your X Studies masters degree at NYU and expect a nice career and lifestyle doing liberal soft-influence in Tunis or Jakarta or even Shenzhen.
Then Xi happened. 2013. The international frontier for western liberal nonprofits went into retreat. They tried to save themselves by turning their objectives inward, at a domestic frontier. "Wokeness" emerges as the plug-and-play ideology for this agenda of soft-influence domestic colonialism. But this didn't work. The domestic frontier was too thin. Not enough capital up for grabs. Biden couldnt reward his supporters with good domestic NGO gigs it turned out. The pivot inward was just a death-throe, zombification.
Second term men, first term measures --
Per WSJ, Hassett scheduled a meeting with Navarro on the opposite side of the WH and then Bessent and Lutnick mysteriously knew that was the right time to go stand over Trump and make him roll back the “reciprocal” plan.
The wounded surgeon plies the steel
That questions the distempered part;
Beneath the bleeding hands we feel
The sharp compassion of the healer's art
Resolving the enigma of the fever chart.
Our only health is the disease
If we obey the dying nurse
Whose constant care is not to please
But to remind of our, and Adam's curse,
And that, to be restored, our sickness must grow worse.
The whole earth is our hospital
Endowed by the ruined millionaire,
Wherein, if we do well, we shall
Die of the absolute paternal care
That will not leave us, but prevents us everywhere.
The chill ascends from feet to knees,
The fever sings in mental wires.
If to be warmed, then I must freeze
And quake in frigid purgatorial fires
Of which the flame is roses, and the smoke is briars.
The dripping blood our only drink,
The bloody flesh our only food:
In spite of which we like to think
That we are sound, substantial flesh and blood--
Again, in spite of that, we call this Friday good.
-- Eliot, East Coker
Ross Douthat reposted
young people still not getting married (and lately even a decline in cohabiters!)
Ross Douthat reposted
Many men in 19th century America were educated on the King James Bible, Euclid, Webster’s Blueback Speller, Shakespeare, and Aesop: their writing isn’t dissimilar from Ishmael’s. Abe Lincoln had one year of formal schooling (in a frontier blab school), and wrote beautifully.
In addition to my own new podcast, please listen etc., you can hear me with @bariweiss this week talking about "Believe" and religion and why I think it should be easier to believe in God before you practice a faith than the other way around:
www.thefp.com/p/ross-douthat-why-its-logical-to-believe-i…
I feel like I've done a poor job of book promotion since I entered the whirlpool of podcast creation. I do intend to offer responses at some point to the many kind-but-unconvinced reviews and rejoinders. For now, if you need a last-minute Easter gift --
www.amazon.com/Believe-Why-Everyone-Should-Religious/dp/0…
Interesting Times, Episode 2: A conversation with @jacklgoldsmith about the Trump executive power revolution:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/17/opinion/ross-douthat-interesti…
Interesting times.
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/16/science/astronomy-exoplanets-h…
Good for everyone involved here:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/16/us/politics/trump-israel-iran-…
Yes, a world where the Trump administration gets Garcia back and then re-deports him legally, complaining all the while about liberal judges and Democrats being soft on criminal aliens, is the desirable and reasonable outcome.
The administration should figure out the paperwork and satisfy legal requirements, but this man is not a hero or a martyr, and doesn't belong in the United States
Just for clarity, I think it's completely reasonable for the Trump WH to argue that they were elected to reverse Biden WH's disastrous immigration policy and the current deportation system is inadequate to scale of illegal immigration permitted in the last four years. 1/2
But our deal with a Salvadoran prison is not an alternative mass deportation system, we are not going to send a million people there, and correcting an acknowledged error regarding one person we shipped there does not seem like a slippery slope back to mass illegal immigration.
Gushing over a political murderer is indeed the worst of leftism, but trying to ensure procedural norms for someone imprisoned (not just deported) without due process is a liberal-coded impulse that conservatives have every reason to respect.
Corey Booker going to El Salvador to rescue Kilmer Abrego Garcia is the male equivalent of Taylor Lorenz gushing over Luigi Mangione. Empathy turned pathological.
Ross Douthat reposted
If you were running a secret strategy to undermine American manufacturing, exempting popular finished consumer goods from tariffs and keeping them in place for intermediate goods, capital goods and raw materials would be a good way to go about it.
As a result of tariffs, Fastenal put in 3-4% price increases and intends to double that in 2H as new tariffs hit. So for companies that actually manufacture in the US, costs of mission critical fasteners and parts is going up dramatically while consumer electronics are exempted.
Ross Douthat reposted
In our tracking, Trump's approval is at -5, but if we only used polls since Liberation Day, he'd be at -8.5 instead. So that's a pretty significant hit over the span of barely more than a week; he was at -2.5 on 4/1, just before Liberation Day.
www.natesilver.net/p/trump-approval-ratings-nate-silver-b…
"75 different negotiations" come on.
BREAKING: Growing consensus among top traders and market strategists I speak to is that we will definitely see a 5% yield on the 10 year bond barring some quick resolution to the trade war. The problem w a quick resolution is, of course, that the Trump White House is dealing w 75 different negotiations but also China's deal will be long and probably brutal, setting up months of possible uncertainty and market uncertainty. That is unless Trump really pulls a 180. Story developing
Sometimes I calm myself in moments of global economic stress by just listening to Jeremy Irons in “Margin Call.”
Men are crazy because you’ll ask one what his comfort movie is and he’ll say something insane like “Saving Private Ryan” or “The Big Short”
Ross Douthat reposted
Last night I drove 250 miles because I wanted to look at the majestic houses along the mighty Mississippi River in Iowa
I have a new podcast. The title is "Interesting Times," the first episode, naturally, is about the Trump trade war, with @oren_cass asking us to give tariffs a chance. You can listen here:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/10/opinion/ross-douthat-interesti…
The overall theory of the show -- apart from the obvious, interesting conversations -- is linked to this essay of mine, about the open and uncertain future; the goal is to have discussions that illuminate the many unusual scenarios we are facing now.
www.nytimes.com/2024/11/16/opinion/donald-trump-election-…
The conversations I've done to date have been with figures on the right, and there will be more of those, but we'll be ranging beyond Trumpism -- covering the future of the Left, the A.I. race, great power conflict, religious change, weird cultural shifts, demographic collapse.
what book is this?
Ross Douthat reposted
I’m reading one of those behind-the-scenes 2024 campaign books, and the run-up to Biden dropping out was wild: everyone in his party knew their leader was making a catastrophic error that would cost the party dearly, but defended him out of loyalty and fear. What a crazy one-off.
Ross Douthat reposted
"Catholicism could soon overtake Anglicanism to become the country’s largest denomination of worshippers for the first time since the Reformation five centuries ago."
Among young people in the UK, there's not just more Catholics than Anglicans attending church these days, there's TWICE AS MANY.
Escape into a world completely unlike ours -- of uncertainty and conflict, plots and counterplots, in a monarch's court:
The Falcon's Children, Chapter 22: The Old Hound:
www.falconschildren.com/p/the-old-hound
Ross Douthat reposted
I heard that the main lessons of the Biden admin were that people don’t care about prices going up and supply chain shocks work themselves out quickly and easily
I love the trade war now.
This could actually be good for American studios. Targeting Chinese audiences less and western audiences more would lead to better cinematic products.
Big whoa if true.
Really strong evidence of a religious resurgence in England and Wales from new data from @biblesociety.
Among 18-24 year olds, share attending monthly:
2018: 4%
2024: 16%
Among 25-34 year olds:
2018: 4%
2024: 13%
Overall, attendance went from 8% to 12%.
Ross Douthat reposted
"We have a Lightning Lane for enlisting the state in helping you kill yourself, but months-long waiting lists for a check-in with a general practitioner" would have been edited out of a CS Lewis novel for being a little too on the nose
Canada offers same-day MAiD—and even waivers of final consent: a fast-track to death for the vulnerable. This isn’t compassion. It’s advanced moral decay.
Read Dr. Ramona Coelho’s warning: macdonaldlaurier.ca/rushing-to-death-in-canadas-maid-regi…
cc: those with ears:
Glibly delighting in people’s genuine financial fears is not ever going to defend the White House, it’s going to make people want to impale you on a pitchfork.
Ross Douthat reposted
SCOTUS: Challenges to under Alien Enemies Act have to be brought in habeas, but Due Process requires judicial review, and—critically in these cases—there must be notice and adequate opportunity to challenge removal *before* removal occurs.
www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/24pdf/24a931_2c83.pdf #n
Introducing ‘Interesting Times’
youtu.be/5jGSnbU2boc via @YouTube
"Believe," reviewed by the male half of the internet's best pseudonymous book-reviewing couple:
www.thepsmiths.com/p/review-believe-by-ross-douthat
If you're in the Chapel Hill area, consider joining me, @FrankBruni and Molly Worthen tomorrow night, to distract yourself from economic chaos with intense existential conversation:
www.veritas.org/campus/university-of-north-carolina-chape…
Well, quite a week to launch a new podcast, but here we go:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/07/opinion/interesting-times-ross…
To demonstrate my total commitment to the enterprise, I plan to wear a tie in every episode.
Currently underplayed endgame theory:
The lawsuits will fly against Trump tariffs, and they seem pretty obviously to exceed POTUS authority under John Roberts’ major questions doctrine. The question is whether SCOTUS is willing, however many months down the line, to get into a political maelstrom that the White House will claim involves Trump’s nonjusticiable foreign policy powers. Markets, probably wisely, don’t seem to expect judicial relief any time soon. But possible on current trajectory that Trump regards courts as a face-saving out.
Prescient tweets here from well before we entered the current pass:
I think a problem with the administration is that they don't "know what time it is;" the Left was smashed by the judicial revolution, DeSantis' model for red state reform, and Trump's victory, and the current moment calls for careful conservative institutional consolidation.
Asked friends where they thought the S&P, Trump's approval rating and the tariff rate would be when we reached some version of stability. Best answer, down 10 percent, down 10 percent, set at 10 percent: 10-10-10
Ross Douthat reposted
🚨Trump: We're on track to fully eliminate capital gains tax in 2025
Probably setting them up to lose 55-45 this time instead of 59-41, on track for victory in 2037.
Marine Le Pen's RN party would lead the presidential election if it were held today, despite her embezzlement conviction, an Elabe poll has found.
Either with #lepen, or with Bardella as candidate, the #rn led with between 31% to 36% in the first round
www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2025/04/06/le-pen-lead-fra…
My Sunday column, trying to figure out what the Trump White House is thinking:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/05/opinion/trump-tariffs-theories…
But this earlier column, on the high variance of Trump 2.0 trajectories, feels relevant as well:
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/18/opinion/trump-presidency-myth-…
Ross Douthat reposted
Well, for one thing they might point out that this will counteract the main things he claimed tariffs would accomplish: 1) reindustrialization; 2) revenue
What will Trump’s haters do if his tariff play brings country after country to the negotiating table, resulting in bilateral trade agreements that make U.S. trade more free than ever?
Me when the takeout delivery is 30 mins late --
Keep calm. Carry on.
This may be a good moment to let everyone know that I control one of (if not the) largest rare earth supplies outside of China. At full capacity it can be 25% of what the world needs. All located within countries allied with the US and the US itself.
🇺🇸 🇺🇸 🇺🇸
Wondering vaguely about the alternate timeline where Musk is running point on deregulation (instead of agency headcounts) while moderating some of Trump's protectionist impulses --
BREAKING: Elon Musk hopes that the United States and Europe will have zero trade tariffs
“I hope it is agreed that both Europe and The United States should move ideally in my view to a zero tariff situation, effectively creating a free trade zone between Europe and North America.”
Good conversation with @shadihamid and @dmarusic about "Believe" and why Damir should be religious:
wisdomofcrowds.live/p/ross-douthat-on-why-we-should-all
If I have this right it seems like they took his suggestion to base the rate on trade deficits rather than country-specific trade policies -- but then set a different rate for every single country based on country-specific deficits.
Of note, the White House reciprocal tariffs are very different than the approach that @Oren_Cass recommended. www.understandingamerica.co/p/the-one-word-that-explains-…
Okay fine, humans had their day, let the AIs take over.
First trailer for ‘THE NAKED GUN’ reboot, starring Liam Neeson.
In theaters on August 1.
The Tiktok baby bust --
blnreview.de/en/ausgaben/2025-04/anna-rotkirch-tiktok-bab…
Definitely worth reading if you feel like putting today's tariff turbulence in (yes, still hypothetical) perspective:
ai-2027.com
Ross Douthat reposted
never letting the world forget about these val kilmer moments
This is very kind --
www.compactmag.com/article/ross-douthats-serious-fantasy/
I haven't been promoting the novel as I should but the table of contents is here, there are 19 free chapters before you hit the paywall, and though I'm behind on this week's chapter the whole book should be there to read by June:
www.falconschildren.com/p/table-of-contents
Stipulating that there *could* be different global trade arrangements more favorable to US workers and US power than the current system, the WH is not exactly advertising the rigor of its plan to get us there.
This is truly amazing. The Deputy White House Press Secretary is claiming that I'm wrong, and that the "tariff rates" on Trump's chart were calculated by "literally" measuring every country's tariffs and non-tariff trade barriers.
To prove it, he screenshots the formula the USTR says was used to calculate the reciprocal tariffs we imposed on other countries. And when you back out the Greek symbols, what is that formula? Trade deficit/imports - exactly what I said it was.
I don't know if the Deputy Press Secretary was misinformed, or is just being misleading. Either way, the Trump administration did not "literally calculate tariff and non tariff barriers" to determine the tariff rates it's imposing on other countries. As I said, it divided our trade deficit with a country by our imports with that country, and then multiplied by 0.5 (because Trump was being "lenient").
Oh, and if our trade deficit/imports with a country is less than 10%, or we have a trade surplus with a country, Trump slapped a flat 10% tariff on that country.
After today it's clear, Trump is obviously a secret Yuval Levin-style conservative institutionalist desperately trying to find a lever strong enough to force Congress to reclaim some of its prerogatives.
Declaring war on Greenland in the hopes that it will force the Senate to reclaim war powers is the obvious next step in the Make Congress Great Again master plan.
I think there are reasons to assume that the floor for any president, but especially Trump, is higher than in the past, but I would still assume that a recession would see him in the high 30s.
There's a weird complacency among Republicans and fatalism among Democrats about Trump's ability to hold his "base." Trump spent his first term implementing conventional economic policies that led to continued growth and prosperity, and he still managed to be not that popular. Now he's about to intentionally tank the economy. Why do we think his approval rating can't fall into the low 30s? www.joshbarro.com/p/liberation-through-massive-tariffs?r=…
One of @elonmusk's most attractive features is that relative to other lords of tech he seems intent on *human* achievement and greatness, not just our eventual merge with the alien machine god. I hope a political setback doesn't have him reconsidering.
A recurring feature of our politics is a brew of overconfidence and fatalism, where a coalition pivots smoothly from "we're inevitably winning, don't believe the haters" to "our defeat was overdetermined by structural forces, there's nothing we could have done differently."
But parts of the right are making the pivot faster, going from "ours is a generational triumph! more Americans say we're on the right track!" to "you can't really expect us to win off-year elections, our voters don't turn out" before they've even lost the House.
An interesting idea, maybe worth trying, would be to follow a big political victory by focusing your policy efforts on the extra/new voters you've just added to your coalition, and see if maybe your popularity can build on itself.
Madmartigan is underrated Kilmer in an underrated film.
Val Kilmer’s early filmography includes some of the most memorable movies of my childhood and two of the best performances of the early 90s. And it’s a very small step from his hilarious Elvis-ish routine in Top Secret to his performance as Jim Morrison. RIP.
Going to run for CT Senate promising the people at least one talking filibuster per year.
If your senator doesn't care about any issue enough to spend at least one day per year wearing depends he has no business in the world's greatest deliberative body.
Somebody's rewatching "The Americans" --
x.com/mattyglesias/status/1907156685115772972
It's too bad nobody thought to adorn the most popular smartphone with some kind of warning signal -- like, I dunno, an image that evokes the fateful fruit in Eden and the Fall or something like that ...
"Smartphone theory of everything" explains many trends:
• worsening mental health, esp women
• rise of addictive gambling behavior, esp men
• cognitive decline
• lower coupling rates, so lower fertility
• new information bubbles and global rise in populism
In this description of the case you can certainly see the root of the WH desire for expedited means of deportation. But there's just a big difference between expedited deportation and *deportation to a Salvadoran prison without appeal.*
I just read the court filings to get the full context (which may not satisfy either side):
The man is an illegal migrant from El Salvador. In 2019, ICE presented sufficient evidence that he was a member of the MS-13 gang for an immigration judge to deny him bond and order his removal.
However, he then filed an asylum claim and obtained a withholding of removal order under the convention against torture. Essentially, he argued that despite his being here illegally and likely being a gang member based on the previous finding, he could be tortured if sent back to El Salvador. Such an order could still allow the government to deport him, but not to his home country, at least not without first contesting the order.
He has been using that order since 2019 to avoid deportation.
With that context, referring to him just as a "Maryland father" obviously does not tell the full story. And The Atlantic reporter cites the lawyer to downplay the previous finding of MS-13 ties, which I view as an unreliable source.
However, it also does not change that the Trump admin, emphasizing government incompetence, screwed up by deporting him to the country he wasn't supposed to be deported to based on the 2019 order. This highlights the need for checks in this program.
Someone needs to reconcile the narratives (and they may be reconcilable!) about the impossibility of making yourself stand out in the elite-college applicant pool and the narratives about how Ivy League kids can't read novels and need remedial algebra.
I spent years tutoring admissions; the ugly reality is that 4.0/1500+ SAT strivers are a dime a dozen. Elite admissions are like a nuclear arms race: a mindless fever to produce more and better products (whether bombs or elite students) knowing you can't possibly use them all.
A strategy that worked brilliantly for anti-populists in the United States in 2024, with no downsides whatsoever.
www.nytimes.com/2025/03/31/world/europe/france-marine-le-…
It's true that 2nd term presidents have a certain freedom of action by virtue of not worrying about re-election, but if and when their popularity evaporates a lot of the freedom of action tends to evaporate with it.
www.politico.com/news/2025/03/29/trump-aides-tariffs-libe…
Ross Douthat reposted
i think people don't realize the extent to which easier and cheaper travel, the Internet, and fake asylum applications have wrecked the international asylum system carefully built after the Holocaust. Poland is a particularly sobering indicator of this.
euronews.com/2025/03/27/poland-suspends-right-of-migrants…
I guess it was too much to hope that we were finally past this kind of rubbish.
www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/03/31/miracles-and-wonder…
This is the brief, straightforward book I would recommend to New Yorker readers.
www.amazon.com/Can-Trust-Gospels-Peter-Williams/dp/143355…
Sigh.
Ross Douthat reposted
For the medieval church, March 25 was the most important date in history: not only the day of Christ's conception, but also the historical date of the Crucifixion. From the eighth day of Creation to the downfall of Sauron - it all happens today. aclerkofoxford.blogspot.com/2017/03/our-ladys-lay.html
Ross Douthat reposted
Michael Waltz? I thought you might be worried... about the security... of your shit.
I was honing this take for two weeks and he ... just ... tweeted it out.
Theory: "Abundance" is the "Sam's Club Republicans" of the year 2025--a book whose diagnosis is largely correct but is being delivered to a party that will need to suffer for at least a decade before it can hear it.
It's an imperfect analogy but one way it might hold is that party agendas are set by interest groups not swing voters, and like Sam's Club conservatism, esp. in its pro-family form, Abundance liberalism currently lacks inner-party interest groups who want to fight for its ideas.
A difference might be that there is serious money in centrist-Dem circles with interest in at least some Abundance-y ideas, which was not the case with the GOP circa 2006-2014 and Sam's Club populism.
As in the War on Terror, a theory of sweeping executive power over suspected enemies will allow for executive practices that sweep up people who may not be enemies at all.
NEW! Sworn declarations filed last night confirm the Trump admin sent INNOCENT people to rot in prison El Salvador, including a professional soccer player tortured by the Maduro regime who entered this country LEGALLY to seek asylum and has NO CRIMINAL RECORD in either country.
One challenge (among many) with AI is that nobody can agree on the core risk we're trying to manage -- whether it's economic disruption or deepening social crisis or an ideologically captured AI or the Skynet scenario ...etc.
It’s publication day for “Believe,” so let’s answer an obvious question: Why write a book making a case for religious belief as a general matter, rather than just the specific religion that I practice and believe? /long thread
www.zondervan.com/p/believe/
I wrote my Sunday column on key divisions within the Trump administration/imperial court, and the ending is a little peculiar and worth unpacking:
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/25/opinion/donald-trump-musk-altm…
Just a great, rich piece, start to finish:
thepointmag.com/politics/last-boys-at-the-beginning-of-hi…
For Matter of Opinion this week I interviewed @pmarca:
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/17/opinion/marc-andreessen-trump-…
My Sunday column is an invitation:
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/11/opinion/columnists/o-canada-co…
Good post:
This year, I read ten important historical novels: Jane Eyre, Middlemarch, To The Lighthouse, Bleak House, Portrait of a Lady, Anna Karenina, Life and Fate, Heart of Darkness, Madame Bovary, and The Magic Mountain.
Reflections:
• Four of these are more than 800 pages long. The Magic Mountain and Portrait of a Lady, while shorter, are not short. Of the ten, 5 are British, 2 are Russian, and there was one from each of France, Germany, and the US.
• For me the clear standouts are Middlemarch, Bleak House, Karenina, and Life and Fate. I would enthusiastically reread any of them. If I had to choose just one to go to again, I would probably select Middlemarch. There's something memorably compelling in Eliot's affection and empathy for almost all of her characters. If Succession is a show with no likable personalities, Middlemarch is the opposite. Bleak House is a close second. Life and Fate is quite different to the others: it’s not exactly entertaining (or even notably well-written), but it is true and profound. (Most works designated “important” are not, but Life and Fate surely merits that as well.) If kindness is one of the core adjurations of Life and Fate, Eliot is the author that most embodies it.
• I'd underestimated Dickens's lyricism. I had thought of him as a master of the plot (contra Nabokov), but he is just as accomplished in prose itself. “Chesney Wold is shut up, carpets are rolled into great scrolls in corners of comfortless rooms, bright damask does penance in brown holland, carving and gilding puts on mortification, and the Dedlock ancestors retire from the light of day again. Around and around the house the leaves fall thick, but never fast, for they come circling down with a dead lightness that is sombre and slow. Let the gardener sweep and sweep the turf as he will, and press the leaves into full barrows, and wheel them off, still they lie ankle-deep. Howls the shrill wind round Chesney Wold; the sharp rain beats, the windows rattle, and the chimneys growl. Mists hide in the avenues, veil the points of view, and move in funeral-wise across the rising grounds. On all the house there is a cold, blank smell like the smell of a little church, though something dryer, suggesting that the dead and buried Dedlocks walk there in the long nights and leave the flavour of their graves behind them.”
• Three of these four were written by authors in their 50s (Eliot, Tolstoy, and Grossman). Dickens was a mere 41 -- and this shows. The plot is very entertaining, and immensely intricate, but the characters are somehow flatter. So, maybe one lesson from the set is simply that wisdom is real, and that skill in the domain of fiction compounds for quite some time.
• Russian literature puzzles me. Why did it suddenly become so good in the 19th century, and why did it decline so much in the 20th? I don't think the latter answer can just be a story of oppression, since we got many great works during Stalin’s reign. But what's the best Russian novel since Master and Margarita? On the issue of the rise, I often encounter explanations claiming that it was related to Russian intellectuals being excluded from political influence and consequently retreating to the artistic domain -- but this feels obviously inadequate. Again, how does this explain the post-Bulgakov decline? And where are the great, say, Saudi works of the past 50 years?
• Whatever happened to the novel around the turn of the century (Conrad, Woolf, Mann in my reading) was not obviously salutary. All three are interesting works, and there is something very distinctly modern in Woolf's in particular, but they simply don't compel -- at least for this reader -- the way their predecessors do: maybe it's just the particular selection, but I was generally looking forward to finishing the early 20th century works, and a bit disappointed when completing those dating from before 1900. The dislocation that Blom describes in Vertigo Years is clearly manifest. Woolf's “Mr. Bennett and Mrs. Brown” essay, and her claim that “human character changed” in 1910, is consistent with the turn in the novels. She was speaking of different works, but her assessment rings true in a broader way: “Yet what odd books they are! Sometimes I wonder if we are right to call them books at all. For they leave one with so strange a feeling of incompleteness and dissatisfaction.”
• I should note that some of Woolf’s descriptions are great, even if her brooding interiority leaves me ultimately unenthralled. “The house was left; the house was deserted. It was left like a shell on a sandhill to fill with dry salt grains now that life had left it.” “He lay on his chair with his hands clasped above his paunch not reading, or sleeping, but basking like a creature gorged with existence.”
• Tom Wolfe attributes modern architecture and the international style to a post-1917 sympathy for the proletariat and a desire to strip indulgent bourgeois ornament from our construction, and, yes, Schoenberg explicitly motivated atonality in egalitarian ideals, but this set of novels makes me doubt the political explanations. You can clearly see the embrace of some kind of disharmony in the books, and I don’t think Conrad was trying to make any Marxist point. I still struggle to explain what happened, but I think I would reverse some of the standard causality, and it seems to me that the coopting of communist ideals is probably itself downstream of the broader social unease that also gave rise to these artistic tides. Blom’s description of the rise of various mental disorders -- neurasthenia and the like -- seems relevant. (All of this does make me want to better understand 1848.)
• The railway, and its attendant social upheaval, features repeatedly, and maybe most memorably in one chapter of Middlemarch. I hadn't appreciated just how significantly disruptive a force it was perceived as being even at the time. (Given the scale of the construction that was entailed, maybe this shouldn't be surprising.) More broadly, there is some sense of a society in transition through most of these works: these aren't neat and timeless tales. You have the rise of the bourgeois and broader urbanization in Bovary, the emerging social consciousness in Bleak House, the exposure of the shabbiness of Victorianism and its gender expectations in Lighthouse, and the postwar shell shock of Magic Mountain.
• The works written before 1900 are primarily about romance (Bleak House the exception, with romance only a subplot), and those written afterwards (Conrad, Mann, Grossman, Woolf) are emphatically not. I don’t know what to make of this. Perhaps just an accident of the selection.
• Ruxandra Teslo points out that there’s a moral gravity in the 19th century works that seems foreign today: people treat their own characters as important constructions in their own right. In a similar vein, I was struck by Grossman’s conception of freedom: he perceives it more as the right to self-define than a more typical liberty of action. Perhaps because actions were so circumscribed in Victorian societies (for women) and Soviet societies (for everyone), the seriousness of being weighed heavily.
* Money and its mechanics get extensive treatment in the pre-1900 novels. The details of Bovary’s debt were made famous by Piketty, but Eliot also spends time on Lydgate’s financial struggles, and Tolstoy on Levin’s agricultural economics. Pecuniary considerations are absent in the later works. Again, maybe just happenstance stemming from the particular selection, but I don’t get the feeling that it’s just that: I think something about authors’ attitudes to the topic changed.
• Today’s scientific papers are far harder to read, and jargon-replete, than those of 1960. However, the novels of the 19th century use significantly more sophisticated construction (and vocabulary) than those of today. What should we make of the countervailing trends? To me, both seem suboptimal.
• Pleasure aside, should one read these books? Does one derive moral betterment from doing so? I'm not sure. Probably not in any narrow sense. Ethicists are supposedly no more ethical than regular people -- if deliberate study doesn't help, what hope does mere fiction have? And, anecdotally, I don't consider the humanities majors to be the moral betters of the STEM students. I do think they've helped with my understanding of history, though. This year, I reflected on how the major historical moments that I've lived through -- the weeks after 9/11, the aftermath of Trump's 2016 election victory, March of 2020 -- cannot really be understood in terms of particular events, and must instead be apprehended through the vibes that prevailed. Rather than trying to assemble a logical causal chain, I think it's more helpfully explanatory to see many happenings as simply arising from a mood. History books struggle to capture such sentiments, and understandably so: the historian usually wasn't there; even if they were, vibes are ethereal things, and they feel out-of-place in a work that aspires to footnoted rigor and exactitude. As such, complements are required, and these novels have definitely helped me. This view also makes biography and autobiography seem of greater importance in developing such comprehension. The small details -- that Herbert Hoover's parents used to attend lectures and debates in a nearby town since that was the only entertainment available, that both died before age 35, or that Hoover himself once walked 80 miles in 3 days to join a geology class trip -- say a lot about a period, and are rarely captured in the grand sweep of events. I feel like I gained much more understanding of historical Vienna and of the emotions around WWI from reading Zweig's memoir than from any direct history of the period.
• Another argument made for reading these works is to simply better understand humanity and the human experience. There is almost certainly some extent to which this argument is valid, though I always wonder: do they help you better understand humanity, or better understand the kind of people who write books like these? Is Isabel Archer actually reflective of someone in that kind of position, or merely of the kind of hyper-intellectual James family? Karenina is ultimately a kind of demented obsessive (as was Tolstoy) – in learning about her, do we learn about love and its travails, or simply about unusually unstable personalities?
• There’s clearly some value in reading them for somewhat tautological reasons: they're worth reading because they are the books that we’ve decided are worth reading. They form part of our cultural context, and other works probably make somewhat more sense and are more memorable when interpreted through their lens. They are intellectual capital cities: you sorta have to go to Paris and New York in order to understand the rest of the world, and whether you “enjoy” them isn’t really the operative question.
• Ultimately, a utilitarian case for better understanding history or even humanity would not be my primary argument for why one might choose to read them, though. With self-consciousness about the platitude, they are simply some of the finest intellectual achievements of humanity, and worthy of engagement for that reason alone: a deeper appreciation for excellence is itself a valuable thing.
Just offering one example of a sagging American industry, essential to our global influence and in desperate need of revitalization, whose rebirth seems extremely unlikely to emerge from a test-oriented, grindset, no-sleepovers or mall-hangouts mentality.
www.nytimes.com/2024/12/26/business/economy/hollywood-sou…
Canadian "safeguards" today, the United Kingdom tomorrow:
www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/compliance-problems-m…
Terrific (even if I have some disagreements) Clare Coffey essay on the Meaning of the UFOs:
www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/who-wants-to-believe-…
More than most of the FP appointments, what happens with @ElbridgeColby will be a sign of whether the Trump WH is aiming for strategic coherence and an explicit "realist" commitment this time around, as opposed to a more ad hoc team of ideological rivals.
Elbridge Colby is one of the very few experienced national security officials who actually agrees with Donald Trump. He’s likely to play a big role in the new administration.
(0:00) The Steps Trump Needs to Take To Avoid WWIII
(9:10) The Dangers of War With Iran
(18:03) Why Is The Blob Pro-War?
(20:52) We Need to Hold the CIA Accountable
(28:49) What Should Trump Do About Russia and Ukraine?
(43:50) The Pentagon’s Support for Foreign Wars
(55:12) The Wall Street Journal Is in Trouble
(58:10) Who Will Run Trump’s Foreign Policy?
Includes paid partnerships.
What I've been expecting since the spring, no reason to hedge now.
There's a notable difference between this kind of plagiarism and Joe Biden's famous appropriation of Neil Kinnock; Biden's reflected a wild, brazen arrogance while Harris's just seems like an expresssion of bureaucratic laziness in search of shortcuts.
EXCLUSIVE: In 2007, Kamala Harris plagiarized pages of Congressional testimony from a Republican colleague.
And in 2012, she plagiarized a fictionalized story about sex trafficking—but presented it as a real case.
It's not just one book; it's a career-long pattern.🧵
I would rate that the most successful Republican debate performance of this century, eclipsing Romney in the first debate with Obama in 2012.
My Sunday column: There is Still a Biden Scandal:
www.nytimes.com/2024/08/10/opinion/joe-biden-president.html
People really like believing nasty lies about their political opponents, being "normal" and "smart" is not any kind of inoculation.
Real 2016 campaign energy today.
Maybe the most banal explanation for tweeting a departure from the presidential race without a swift public-facing follow-up is that Biden is too pissed at everyone to be normal. "Fine, I'll endorse her, but only via tweet. You want a noble Oval Office address, Jack? Bleep off."
I think it’s going to be Kamala.
A discouraging finding for the hope that lowest-low fertility will automatically select for higher fertility in subsequent generations:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1570677X24000352
I almost tweeted a quote from this @tedgioia essay but in the spirit of his argument you should go read the whole thing line by line:
www.honest-broker.com/p/the-state-of-the-culture-2024
If Haley comes in a clear second in Iowa, DeSantis should absolutely drop out. But absent evidence that she can win more of the Trump-friendly voters to whom DeSantis currently appeals, that would still put her on a path to a 65-35 or 60-40 defeat.
The war on Vivek is strategically interesting.
Trump in office will be a second-term lame duck who never wanted to run a WH; whatever de facto powers Pence enjoyed, even a semi-competent second term VP will be able to accrue many more.
Decent chance that moves like this become litmus tests for for red or reddish-state GOP governors over the next 5-10 years:
🚨🚨🚨
DeSantis has appointed six members, including @christopherrufo, Hillsdale prof Matthew Spalding, and @mark_bauerlein to the New College of Florida’s Board of Trustees, directing the new conservative majority to recapture the progressive school.
www.nationalreview.com/news/desantis-shakes-up-leadership…
Some academic news is very good news:
I've seen a few people noting that neither lefties nor right-populists should take too much pleasure in Liz Truss's dégringolade, because government-by-bond-vigilantes means death for their preferred programs too. Those people are correct.
Worth noting that in the 50 yrs since Roe, men have become less likely to find a spouse, less likely father kids or live with the kids they father, and less likely to participate in the workforce.
There are millions of men whose lives would have been much worse without abortion. Men who wouldn't have found their big loves, wouldn't have their kids, wouldn't have been as successful, wouldn't have taken big risks. Many of them don't think about it. Some don't even know it.
Sometimes the philistinism is coming from inside the library:
The SLJ and @ncte Summer Reading Survey asked K–12 librarians and teachers to identify titles they would suggest removing.
www.slj.com/story/educators-weigh-in-on-summer-reading-li…
Get vaccinated. Get a booster. Take reasonable precautions. Do not let the ongoing circulation of a disease rob you of the joy of life.
I'll just say it: Glenn Youngkin should seriously consider running for president in 2024.
Before everyone fully commits to the Dune experience, I want to report The Last Duel is interesting and entertaining and worth your time (despite some flaws), and if you don't see it Hollywood will probably never make a historical movie for adults ever again.
I am fully vaccinated but I had a certain amount of vaccine hesitancy that owed nothing to Tucker Carlson's guests and everything to five years worth of extremely interesting, totally harrowing experiences on the borderlands of medicine:
www.amazon.com/Deep-Places-Memoir-Illness-Discovery/dp/05…
This is a good @damonlinker treatment of the @DemJournal "constitutional convention" and its results:
theweek.com/politics/1001494/what-the-fantasy-of-a-new-co…
It can be replicated with mass conversions to a stringent Dutch Calvinism.
What is it about Grand Rapids that makes it the only place where Republicans can consistently have guts? @TimAlberta
Is there something we can learn from MI-3 and replicate elsewhere?
Total genius move to follow an election in which your party overperformed with minorities by going all in on a narrative about how the minority vote is totally fraudulent and shouldn't count:
Nonwhite voters in Georgia per preliminary exit polls:
Black voters:
November: Ossoff (D) +76
Jan runoff: Ossoff (D) +86
Hispanic voters:
November: Ossoff (D) +9
Jan runoff: Ossoff (D) +30
If you'd told me four years ago that we'd end the Trump era with a political landscape whose most powerful figures are Joe Manchin, Amy Coney Barrett and Joe Biden, I would have been extremely pleasantly surprised.
Lots of small magazines need support but in the year of the pandemic and the science wars The New Atlantis has done great work and deserves your last-minute dollar:
When you can't just "trust the science" because the scientists keep lying to you and then saying, "oh, that was just a noble lie, sorry about that."
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/24/health/herd-immunity-covid-cor…
Read @AndrewCMcCarthy on the Trump legal team's strange (if you believe in massive voter fraud) unwillingness to enter any evidence on its own behalf:
www.nationalreview.com/2020/12/a-stunning-passage-from-th…
Conservatives aren't the only ones who inhabit a virtual reality:
Gov Andrew M Cuomo of NY will receive the International Emmy Founders Award in recognition of his leadership during the Covid19 pandemic & his masterful use of TV to inform & calm people around the world. The Emmy will be presented to @NYGovCuomo on Nov 23 www.iemmys.tv/statement-from-the-international-academy-of…
The important thing is that these kids can still go to bars, gyms and restaurants.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-11-18/nyc-schools-to…
The latest Argument, with special guests @Nate_Cohn and @brooks_rosa:
www.nytimes.com/2020/11/13/opinion/polls-trump-transition…
I know how intensely my liberal followers dislike Susan Collins, but her ability to keep getting split-ticket voters, basically shared only by Joe Manchin at this point, is a remarkable exception to all the rules of our time.
This amazing word salad is sadly a pretty good encapsulation of GOP health policy.
I’m discussing last night’s debate, Amy Coney Barrett, and more. Join me! www.nytimes.com/2020/09/30/opinion/presidential-debate-tr… www.pscp.tv/w/ckNRWDF6dkVOT25QV2VuUWV8MVBsSlFObU5OZHF4RRb…
Likewise, once you step back from deaths and case rates to other measurements of response capacity, the US looks anywhere from slightly-below to slight-above average, rather than catastrophic, compared to W. Europe and the Americas.
1. Nothing much gets through the House and Senate anymore, tweets or no tweets.
2. Nothing Trump tweeted about the GOP establishment (or anything else) stopped Ryan and McConnell from working with him once he won.
"I'm a Christian"
- basic/normie
- youth pastor energy
- yeah, so are my parents
"I worship the lamb slain from the foundation of the world"
- mysterious
- ominous
- maybe you have a sword
“I’m a political scientist”
- boring
- academic
- not a real science
“I look at power”
- mysterious
- ominous
- maybe you have a sword
This review is a reminder of the remarkable difficulty that very smart people have in recognizing social liberalism, the ideology embraced by many of the West's most powerful people for multiple generations, as an ideology of power.
www.nytimes.com/2020/01/17/books/review/the-new-class-war…
Useful thread on intra-evangelical conflict:
Will put in my 2 cents on the @CTmagazine editorial based on study of White Evangelical (WE) leaders for my dissertation. 1st thing: CT never represented Trump's base. Anti-Trump articles crashed CT's site in 2016 just as they did this week. Not a shocking about-face. (1/18)
It was clear weeks ago that this could only end with the defense that investigating the Biden family was in the national interest and Trump had every right to ask Ukraine to do it.
It is not news that Barr is scrutinizing the origins of the Russia investigation, it is reasonable to ask relevant governments for assistance, this revelation is categorically different from the Biden/Ukraine/aid issue and conflating the two is a mistake.
My bridge-between-the-debates column: How Joe Biden Won Last Night:
www.nytimes.com/2019/07/31/opinion/democratic-debate-joe-…
Reading this made me realize I'd mostly forgotten the reason why Jon Snow et al went north of the Wall last season, and it was even dumber than in my half-memories. Also, the whole @OrrChris take on the collapse of the show's plotting is sadly correct:
www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2019/04/game-of…
But there's also a pretty-clearly-integrated conservative story of what's happening here, which is that hook-up culture itself is part of what leads to less sex, because it leads to fewer monogamous relationships. Maximal liberation = less actual intercourse.
I have a healthy respect for the patriotism of (some of) the people working to contain Trump from within the WH, but a strategy where you contain the president by stealing papers off his desk and suborning his orders works a lot better if you don't *tell Bob Woodward you did it.*
For the record: My Last Jedi remake also remakes TFA, and depicts Lando and Leia's son, a New Republic general, competing with his half-brother, the insurgent-fascist Kylo Ren, for Rey's heart as well as galactic power. Royalties may be directed care of the Times, thanks.
Nothing about Trump's behavior in office has surprised me. What's surprised is everyone else's behavior - investors, foreign govts, even to some extent his opponents, all of whom have entered into a tacit conspiracy to act as if his behavior isn't really part of the presidency.
The Reformation is how you got Trump.
I think he meant you could shoot the judges.
A thought sent back in time to the theocracy panic of 2005: If you dislike the religious right, wait till you meet the post-religious right.
This is really fascinating: www.commonwealmagazine.org/blog/african-bishop-polygamy-h…