No Human Is Illegal @hopenothate
Nathan Cofnas
Nathan Cofnas (born 1987) is an American philosopher and postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University in Belgium. He is known for controversies surrounding his advocacy of scientific racism. More on Wikipedia
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Oxford Reform Society (OURS)
@OxUniRFMSoc
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Antifa, socialists and the far-left are mobilizing to try to shut down the Nov. 17 speaking event of Jewish-American academic @nathancofnas at Oxford University. Cofnas was invited by a student group to speak.
He was blamed for Cambridge DEI star Jason Arday's s—icide after breaking the story on his Substack that Arday committed serial academic plagiarism. Arday's supporters say the plagiarism is okay because whites do it too.
Cofnas is under investigation at @ugent as leftist administrators seek to punish him for speaking honestly about Arday. Cofnas has received ongoing death threats from leftists. www.ngocomment.com -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Let’s have a debate @kehinde_andrews. You can show the world how wrong I am about race and Jason Arday.
I will accept any venue and moderator of your choosing.
I have just two conditions:
Full video will be published *unedited*
I can present slides of Arday's plagiarism
Led By Donkeys
@ByDonkeys
Oriel College, Oxford University:
Racists Welcome Here.
Words: @kehinde_andrewsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Kangmin Lee | 이강민
@kangminlee
Cambridge pushed him out over an essay. Then came the censorship and smear campaign.
Dr. Nathan Cofnas joins me on Episode 10 of The Kangmin Lee Show. We discussed race realism, the Jason Arday scandal, and academic censorship.
LIVE tonight at 6pm ET.
@nathancofnasThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Freedom of speech is not freedom for ideas or opinions to go unchallenged by evidence"
Indeed. Yet you provide no evidence that I am wrong. Ironically, you turn off your replies, presumably to avoid being exposed to evidence that I am right.
Out of the 49 signatories there are 5 historians, 11 English or other language specialists, 2 classicists, 3 chemists, 2 theologians, 3 musicians, the college librarian... Not a single psychologist, behavioral geneticist, or even anthropologist. Correct me if my suspicions are wrong, @janrosenow, but do any of you have a clue about this topic?
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
Today, 49 members of the Oriel College Senior Common Room published a statement, in a personal capacity, on the Nathan Cofnas event on 17 November.
I am one of the signatories.
Full statement here docs.google.com/document/u/0/d/1vzL5OKKyheO8bODWIaRL7DrFt… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Scott Turner
@macrotermiteman
Today on Night Class, we interview Nathan Cofnas, philosopher who documented the case against fabulist and fraudster Jason Arday, and was targeted by race hustlers and cowards at Cambridge U. @NASorg @MindingCampus @nathancofnas
Full episode is here: youtu.be/U4gsrxsEk-o -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
i don't have a solution but @nathancofnas is right in diagnosis; we're just too retarded. we need more ppl ike @tedfrank and fewer like @JackPosobiec
tedfrank
@tedfrank
None of these voter initiatives are going to matter if Democrats are given control of the courts. I will wager that the Washington state one is gone within five years.
Marco 🇻🇦 🦃
@audiblemarco
Nope!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Who could have predicted that the right's retard revolution would not be successful in the long run?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I told you" says @akarlin.
Was it a mistake to vote for Trump?
If I'd known that MAGA would become a poverty cult obsessed with bringing Chinese sweatshops to the US, I would have supported DEI Kamala. However, as far as I am aware, no one (including Karlin) anticipated that Trump would declare war on every other country on earth and tank the economy for no reason. Given the information available on November 5, 2024, I think a Trump vote was reasonable. Should we not attempt to win because it's possible that we will fail?
But there are lessons.
The problem isn't *Trump*. It's that the American so-called "right" has become a coalition of stupid people from across the political spectrum. At the lowest IQ levels, the left and right converge on fascism. They favor a controlled economy over the invisible hand, wisdom of the "volk" over universities and book learning, and thuggery over due process. Trump wouldn't be able to get away with this if he didn't have an army of @catturd2's with the same dumb intuitions cheering him on. His future torchbearer will have to be an idiot in order to keep the MAGA coalition together, so he'll be no better.
All over the world, almost everyone with more than half a brain is looking at the disaster of Trump (along with Putin, Yoon Suk Yeol, et al.) and drawing the very reasonable conclusion that right-wing, anti-woke parties are incapable of effective governance. This is also my conclusion. The right *in its current form* attracts such low human capital that it is counterproductive for it to actually take power. What happens when a dog catches the car it's chasing? It looks confused, jumps around for a minute, and pisses on the wheel. That's anti-wokesters taking over the government.
I've been arguing that the right needs to focus on winning the battle of ideas and bringing the elites to our side. The way to do that is to refute the false empirical belief that underlies the ideology of wokism (the equality thesis). But I lost the battle to set the agenda for the right. Instead, it was decided that the only thing that matters is taking power and trolling leftists. Trump won the election, issued some executive orders, and anti-wokesters declared victory. But we are seeing the fruits of this strategy: a right that is on track to be totally discredited and cede power back to the woke.
It is still theoretically possible to turn this around. The Republican-controlled Congress should invoke the 25th Amendment, carry Trump away in a straitjacket, revoke the tariffs, and spend their political capital (which would be soaring) on important issues like deporting illegal aliens. But this is the kind of action that would be taken by smart people, not Republicans.
If you want the right to prevail in the long run, you should do everything you can to prevent right-wing political parties from gaining power prematurely. All focus should be on the Hereditarian Revolution, which we fight for in the realm of ideas, not (yet) in the ballot box.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Get ready for rule by Bluesky ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Lipton
@basedlipton
This hippie psych prof told me that @nathancofnas is a "flaming racist"
And this is just one interview. Will publish more in the coming days at the links below. Subscribe!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Graham Linehan
@Glinner
Amazing. @kathviner you are a fraudster.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Even the Guardian is now flirting with plagiarism denial
This narrative might get me murdered by a deranged Arday supporter, but the silver lining is that the left-wing establishment has never been so discredited -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Even the Guardian is now flirting with plagiarism denial
This narrative might get me murdered by a deranged Arday supporter, but the silver lining is that the left-wing establishment has never been so discredited -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Oxford Reform Society (OURS)
@OxUniRFMSoc
A journalist for the @guardian has informed us that our event with @nathancofnas "has caused some disquiet among alumni" who have warned that it risks creating a "hostile and exclusionary environment" for students.
Please see our response below: -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
You're all obsessed with @nathancofnas's work on race and IQ and totally sleeping on his most important paper. (We are not the same.)
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40806-022-00352-x -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
When you reassemble this thread, Pangram rates it as 100% AI-generated.
Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP
@BellRibeiroAddy
Barely two months ago, we lost Professor Jason Arday. Thousands grieved. Institutions across higher education spoke about inclusion and belonging.
Now Nathan Cofnas is being given a room at Oriel College, Oxford, to ask whether DEI is undermining higher education.
🧵 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Third wordist influencer doesn't want to be at an event with Cofnas because he's involved in culture wars or something.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@HeterodoxCentre research fellow Neema Parvini (aka Academic Agent) ragequits his talk at @OxUniRFMSoc to protest my invitation.
Fun fact: I was inspired to write "Why We Need to Talk about the Right's Stupidity Problem" by an interaction with Parvini. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@HeterodoxCentre research fellow Neema Parvini (aka Academic Agent) ragequits his talk at @OxUniRFMSoc to protest my invitation.
Fun fact: I was inspired to write "Why We Need to Talk about the Right's Stupidity Problem" by an interaction with Parvini. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
Another person who does not seem to be able to distinguish between a factual claim (whether true or false) and a normative claim.
Saying that the proportion of group X in elite universities would "approach 0" if hiring was under a particular set of selection criteria is a factual (descriptive) claim.
Saying that members of group X do not "belong", or ought not to be appointed to elite universities because of their group membership is a normative claim.
To my knowledge, Cofnas has never made the normative claim in question.
Both claims should be protected by free speech of course.
I think all MPs and academics should get training in basic metaethics and logic. Would be much more useful than any DEI training.
Bell Ribeiro-Addy MP
@BellRibeiroAddy
I believe in free speech. I believe universities should argue about policy. But asking whether DEI works is very different from asking whether Black people belong in our universities at all.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Neil O'Brien
@NeilDotObrien
"Jason Arday was lynched and Nathan Cofnas was the hangman"
Extraordinarily irresponsible and dishonest - even by the low standards of Jolyon.
In the context this is strongly encouraging violence. Disgusting. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Oxford Reform Society (OURS)
@OxUniRFMSoc
It's too late. The Overton window has already moved. Cofnas will be speaking, and Oxford will be restored.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Paul Hundred, GED
@paul_hundred
Belgian prison’s not ready for him
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Who would win in a fight, Nathan Cofnas or 100 gorillas?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Check out Cofnas deadlifting 300+
No wonder he feels so superior to everyone.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Who would win in a fight, Nathan Cofnas or 100 gorillas?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Who would win in a fight, Nathan Cofnas or 100 gorillas?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
Belgium is preparing a criminal case against philosopher @nathancofnas that could result in up to 3 years of jail time.
Why jail a philosopher? Because Cofnas has argued that some race differences in psychological traits might be due to genetic differences. And this allegedly violates a new law that Belgium passed a month ago against 'dissemination of racial ideas' and 'incitement to discrimination or racial hatred'.
Here @Rosalind_Arden_ breaks down this strange story of censorship, retaliation, and institutional bullying of scholars who address taboo topics.
Rosalind Arden
@Rosalind_Arden_
Does what we owe to someone depend on whether we agree with them? quillette.com/2026/10/22/prison-or-peer-review/
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Oxford Reform Society (OURS)
@OxUniRFMSoc
🚨 Libtard lunatic threatens to ATTACK Oxford University students for hosting @nathancofnas 👇
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Leo Kearse - see me on tour! Links in bio
@LeoKearse
Use your opponent's weight against him
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Statement by the Oxford University Reform Society on my upcoming lecture
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Statement by the Oxford University Reform Society on my upcoming lecture
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Predictable response by the epistemic oppressors
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Prison or Peer Review?
It is a disgrace that @nathancofnas may face jail in Belgium. @Rosalind_Arden_'s latest for @Quillette
quillette.com/2026/10/22/prison-or-peer-review/ -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Tobias Wolfram
@_twolfram
Today we launch NeuroRisk, the first embryo test for autism and schizophrenia that looks for mutations in evolutionarily important genes.
These mutations are individually rare but over 10% of people carry at least one mutation in this class. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Blake Neff
@BlakeSNeff
"If you have a conversation with a European about free speech ... they don't know what you're talking about. They don't have the concept."
Great conversation with @nathancofnas today about the increasing hostility European authorities are showing to him and any other ideas that upset the country's failing political status quo.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
• A French writer (@doramoutot) was criminally convicted—and faces possible prison time—for saying that a trans woman is “a man, a transfeminine man.”
• An American academic living in Belgium (@nathancofnas) is being taken to court by Belgium’s official equality agency for claiming that there are racial differences in IQ.
• A German woman was jailed for a weekend for calling a man who raped a 15-year-old girl a “disgraceful rapist pig”—a harsher sentence than the rapist received.
• A British assault victim was convicted of a hate crime for calling her attacker a “faggot” in text messages.
But please, tell me again that Europe doesn’t have a free-speech problem. That there’s nothing to worry about. That it’s all a right-wing invention—as claimed by @lemondefr and many other newspapers.
For heaven's sake, can someone give us a First Amendment already? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Orleans, France — As part of the ongoing student riots by leftists and youths of immigrant background, they attacked and looted a JD sportswear store.
Leftists have been defending the violence, saying schools are so underfunded that they justify these violent direct actions. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
It is exceptionally bad for state-funded organizations to bring legal cases against whistleblowers for speech.
Shameful behavior from Belgium.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
Nathan had already had 8 drinks before some frat guys invited him to talk about IQ tests and twin studies
They should be the ones in jail!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
Never take free speech for granted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ed West
@edwest
Reminder that Cofnas was hit with a bottle in Ghent by a man in the keffiyeh, who was ID'd on camera, and the prosecutor declined to press charges
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Brian Chau
@brianchau57
"the philosophy establishment claims to trace its intellectual lineage to Socrates, but its true lineage goes back to the Athenians who killed him."
~ @nathancofnas
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Patrick Casey
@restoreorderusa
The Belgian government is trying to put Nathan Cofnas in jail for violating the country’s “anti-racism law”—all because Cofnas accepts scientific findings regarding race and intelligence. His intellectual honesty is being framed as advocacy for discrimination—ridiculous.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Dr. Dad, PhD 🔄🔼◀️🔽▶️
@GarrettPetersen
Impassible to do science when some conclusions are illegal.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Shaun Maguire
@shaunmmaguire
Free Nathan Cofnas
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Spencer 🇺🇦
@RichardBSpencer
.@nathancofnas is a highly intelligent and reasonable man. No reasonable person can object to this lecture as anything other than rational, empirically-minded discourse. Feel free to disagree or quibble—I certainly have my own criticisms—but he is engaging in the tradition of sound academic inquiry. The fact that he is being persecuted by all means demonstrates the dominance of “woke,” “liberalism,” or “political correctness,” but perhaps it also signals the impending collapse of this ideology.
youtu.be/nZsKQvaTku4 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Spencer 🇺🇦
@RichardBSpencer
What do we make of the appearance that Europeans are scapegoating a heretical Jew?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve Sailer
@Steve_Sailer
An honest man in Belgium ...
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Helen Joyce
@HJoyceGender
Crazy and terrifying state overreach. There should be absolutely no question that Nathan's words are not criminal, no matter what you think of them.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alex Strudwick Young
@AlexTISYoung
It shouldn't be illegal to take an unpopular position on a sensitive scientific topic.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Thank god for America.
In several other countries, it is illegal to publicly say things considered unacceptable to a bunch of busybodies who hate you.
And remember, all of this is only happening because Nathan caught someone else doing fraud. Nathan did nothing wrong!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
People often overstate how alike or similar the West is. Continental European politics broadly did not evolve to value or protect free speech in the Anglo-American tradition. In fact, Europeans find American free speech protections very odd and "dangerous." The British have moved in the way of their European neighbors over the decades.
In every EU country, there are laws criminalizing certain forms of speech and expression. And in some European jurisdictions, an individual—not the state—can initiate the criminal prosecution for particular personal speech-related matters.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Remember all those times academics were telling us there is no taboo on race and intelligence? I can't decide if they are completely delusional or lying.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jonathan Keeperman
@L0m3z
Please support Nathan if you are so inclined and have the means.
A functional civilization needs to mount a vigorous defense of people who are willing to say what is true.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Amazingly, at the end of the lecture they’re using as evidence against Cofnas, he said, “Now you can decide who should go to jail, me or my critics.”
After the lecture, a protestor hit him with a bottle but wasn’t charged.
Now Cofnas faces possible prosecution for his words.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
He’s not joking. Sounds like the case would be far from a slam dunk, but Cofnas could face a fine or jail time. Insane.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Beginning of the formal process to put me in jail
I've been advised that I need a criminal lawyer
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
They cite a talk I gave to the Catholic Flemish Student Association in April as violating the "anti-racism" law www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZsKQvaTku4
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Israel Foreign Ministry
@IsraelMFA
This man is a hero.
Captain Smit Machchhar, the Indian captain of flydubai Flight 1073, fought back after being stabbed in the cockpit.
Despite being severely injured, he managed to unlock the cockpit door - allowing Israeli passengers and the Emirati crew to intervene and save all the passengers.
Together, their extraordinary courage saved 174 lives.
Indian. Israeli. Emirati.
Different nationalities. One extraordinary act of courage. 🇮🇳🇮🇱🇦🇪
We wish Captain Machchhar a full and speedy recovery. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Just the other day, one of the few remaining liberals in my department, Freddy Mortier (now officially retired), made some remarks about @nathancofnas’s suspension during a graduation ceremony.
After making clear that he has no sympathy whatsoever for Cofnas’s views, he argued that even thorny ideas should be openly discussed rather than shut down.
Predictably, students jeered and booed him, preventing him from continuing his speech. Both students and colleagues then walked out in protest.
So what did the dean do? She took the stage to apologize for her colleague’s “completely inappropriate” remarks, to loud applause and cheers from the students.
In other words, she encouraged and rewarded the hecklers. The level of cowardice is simply astonishing. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Debate with Glenn Loury and John McWhorter: www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5o0JDqJIfQ
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Róisín Michaux
@RoisinMichaux
Crowd of protestors outside Gent University where the annual opening ceremony (led by Petra de Sutter) is about to take place. The protestors want @nathancofnas fired.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Cofnas bites the bullet on moral worth and intelligence.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Debate with Charles Murray on IQ and human worth
For once @charlesmurray defends the less controversial position: ncofnas.com/p/debate-with-charles-murray-iq-and -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
If you had to pick which new neighborhood to move into and all you knew about each of the options was their average IQ, which one would you pick?
Answer first then listen to this debate between @nathancofnas and @charlesmurray: ncofnas.com/p/debate-with-charles-murray-iq-and?publicati… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
Being the good guy is fun!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Debate with Charles Murray on IQ and human worth
For once @charlesmurray defends the less controversial position: ncofnas.com/p/debate-with-charles-murray-iq-and -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Debate with Charles Murray on IQ and human worth
For once @charlesmurray defends the less controversial position: ncofnas.com/p/debate-with-charles-murray-iq-and -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thanks for responding. Some comments:
“values matter and how you raise your kids matters”
Behavioral genetics studies show that this intuitive idea is false (at least within developed countries like the US and the UK). In adulthood, adopted children resemble their biological parents, not their adoptive parents. Assuming you aren’t raised in a crack house or dropped on your head, parenting style has no detectable effect on outcomes like adult IQ.
“Cofnas is already assuming that clever = morally good. He’s also saying clever + a belief in race science = definitely morally good.”
To refute this straw man you cite a list of (supposedly) high-IQ Nazis who were not morally good. First, I don’t believe that IQ + race science = definitely morally good. Second, the Nazis were pseudoscientists who rejected Darwinism in favor of a creation story called “world ice theory.” They also rejected IQ testing. So the Nazis do not show what happens if we take a scientific perspective on race.
You spend a long time giving an ad hoc explanation for why the plight of the Congo is due to “exploitation [and] colonialism [and] extermination of millions of people.” You even blame their civil war on distant white people. Two points:
First, why does *every* sub-Saharan African country (or country populated by sub-Saharan Africans) have similar outcomes to the Congo? This includes Ethiopia, which, besides a 6-year occupation by Italy, was never colonized at all.
Second, Africans are not the only people who have suffered in horrible ways. If a history of genocide, colonialism, and brutality affect IQ, why do Jews and Koreans score higher than British whites?
You attribute lower African American IQ to “400 years of slavery, segregation, the general Jim Crow environment, red lining, not to mention welfare and all that has followed since like poor schooling, huge crime rates.” This speaks to my point that, if you reject hereditarianism, the best explanation for lower black IQ is past or present white racism. Wokism is inevitable.
You cite Thomas Sowell saying that we shouldn’t take IQ seriously because Jews used to score low and then started scoring high. (See my essay, “Thomas Sowell’s Wishful Thinking about Race.”) In 1923, American psychologist Carl Brigham argued that, although Jews are stereotyped as intelligent, some fresh-off-the-boat Yiddish speakers bombed an IQ test administered in English, therefore their IQ is actually low. His book was panned by his peers. In 1930, Brigham recanted, referring to his own previous statement about Jewish IQ as “pretentious” and “without foundation.” Nevertheless, 100 years later, Sowell is still attempting to discredit IQ testing by citing that one stupid mistake.
“orphaned black children raised by white richer families end up having above-average IQs.”
False. Adoption only affects childhood IQ, when the heritability of IQ is low. By adulthood, African Americans who were raised by white adoptive parents have average IQs roughly equal to the African American mean.
“You can also look at those people who say race science is key to understanding the world and similarly think, ‘I don’t want this. This is also a total dead end, which ends up removing the equal moral dignity of the individual, too.’”
This is how many people react to race science: “I don’t want this” because it has bad moral implications. But race science is key to understanding the world whether or not we want it to be. -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thanks for responding. Some comments:
“values matter and how you raise your kids matters”
Behavioral genetics studies show that this intuitive idea is false (at least within developed countries like the US and the UK). In adulthood, adopted children resemble their biological parents, not their adoptive parents. Assuming you aren’t raised in a crack house or dropped on your head, parenting style has no detectable effect on outcomes like adult IQ.
“Cofnas is already assuming that clever = morally good. He’s also saying clever + a belief in race science = definitely morally good.”
To refute this straw man you cite a list of (supposedly) high-IQ Nazis who were not morally good. First, I don’t believe that IQ + race science = definitely morally good. Second, the Nazis were pseudoscientists who rejected Darwinism in favor of a creation story called “world ice theory.” They also rejected IQ testing. So the Nazis do not show what happens if we take a scientific perspective on race.
You spend a long time giving an ad hoc explanation for why the plight of the Congo is due to “exploitation [and] colonialism [and] extermination of millions of people.” You even blame their civil war on distant white people. Two points:
First, why does *every* sub-Saharan African country (or country populated by sub-Saharan Africans) have similar outcomes to the Congo? This includes Ethiopia, which, besides a 6-year occupation by Italy, was never colonized at all.
Second, Africans are not the only people who have suffered in horrible ways. If a history of genocide, colonialism, and brutality affect IQ, why do Jews and Koreans score higher than British whites?
You attribute lower African American IQ to “400 years of slavery, segregation, the general Jim Crow environment, red lining, not to mention welfare and all that has followed since like poor schooling, huge crime rates.” This speaks to my point that, if you reject hereditarianism, the best explanation for lower black IQ is past or present white racism. Wokism is inevitable.
You cite Thomas Sowell saying that we shouldn’t take IQ seriously because Jews used to score low and then started scoring high. (See my essay, “Thomas Sowell’s Wishful Thinking about Race.”) In 1923, American psychologist Carl Brigham argued that, although Jews are stereotyped as intelligent, some fresh-off-the-boat Yiddish speakers bombed an IQ test administered in English, therefore their IQ is actually low. His book was panned by his peers. In 1930, Brigham recanted, referring to his own previous statement about Jewish IQ as “pretentious” and “without foundation.” Nevertheless, 100 years later, Sowell is still attempting to discredit IQ testing by citing that one stupid mistake.
“orphaned black children raised by white richer families end up having above-average IQs.”
False. Adoption only affects childhood IQ, when the heritability of IQ is low. By adulthood, African Americans who were raised by white adoptive parents have average IQs roughly equal to the African American mean.
“You can also look at those people who say race science is key to understanding the world and similarly think, ‘I don’t want this. This is also a total dead end, which ends up removing the equal moral dignity of the individual, too.’”
This is how many people react to race science: “I don’t want this” because it has bad moral implications. But race science is key to understanding the world whether or not we want it to be. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Michael Malice
@michaelmalice
Jason Arday was a DEI hire at Cambridge
He was also a plagiariast, and when @nathancofnas exposed him Arday ended up taking his own life
This saga (and the background issue of race and IQ) on this week's "YOUR WELCOME"
Drops at 6pm eastern, in one hour!
youtu.be/17sfw_nPRFs -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Brian Chau
@brianchau57
BREAKING: Documents show De Sutter "explicitly encouraged" anti-Cofnas campaign.
De Sutter, who issued and reversed Cofnas' suspension, was part of a campaign to remove Cofnas led by Belgian State-funded 'decolonial' NGOs.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“An anti-Israel trans professor ousts a Jewish academic for racism because he exposed the lies of a black professor who was appointed because of his race.”
cc @netflix
Dov Gil-Har
@DovGilHar
הפרשה שטילטה את אוניברסיטת קיימברידג׳ והובילה להתאבדותו של ג׳ייסון ארדיי הפרופסור השחור הצעיר בתולדותיה. הערב הבאנו ראיון בלעדי עם נתן קופנס @nathancofnas, האקדמאי היהודי שחשף את מסכת השקרים של ארדיי, וגם, איך נאמר את זה? אוחז בתיאוריות לא שגרתיות.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
i/o
@avidseries
What exactly is the "discredited pseudoscience" that Nathan Cofnas argues for? Here are the main claims he's made that have offended people:
(1) Cofnas believes there are differences in average measured intelligence between population groups: Mainstream science fully agrees with him.
(2) Cofnas believes that recent human evolution outside Africa has increased human intelligence: Mainstream population genetics now mostly agrees with him.
(3) Cofnas believes that the measured differences in intelligence between population groups are at least partially due to genetic differences between those groups: Although this claim remains scientifically disputed and unresolved, the most recent published survey of intelligence scientists found that most agree with him.
The research that has been most often used to support a genetic explanation — and which has been published in established peer-reviewed scientific journals — is hardly pseudoscientific. You may not believe that it's convincing, but that's quite another thing than saying it's "pseudoscientific."
The people writing about Cofnas either know this or do not care to know it.
The vast majority of the public reading about Cofnas has no idea of the current status of intelligence research because its "dangerous" findings are rarely reported in the non-scientific media, and most people treat the subject as too icky to take the time to investigate.
Andrew Hammel
@AndrewHammel1
In der deutschen Presse darf Nathan Cofnas nicht erwähnt werden, ohne dass die Journalisten den Lesern vorschreiben, was sie von ihm halten sollen. Er sei ein „Rassist“, der sich auf „diskreditierte Pseudowissenschaft“ stütze und gezielt „nicht-weiße“ Wissenschaftler ins Visier nehme.
Was diese Journalisten jedoch niemals tun, ist, mit dem Mann selbst zu sprechen.
www.berliner-zeitung.de/article/interview-nathan-cofnas-j… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Excellent example of the Woke Christian coalition ✝️ 🫱🏻🫲🏼☭ on egalitarianism. Cofnas unsurprised.
Joel Berry
@JoelWBerry
The seething rage at this post would be hilarious if it wasn't so depressingly satanic.
"The bell curve! IQ! Korea adoption study! REEEEEEEEEEEEE!"
Yes. And?
Let me go ahead and just grant all your frantic, obsessive claims about group differences. Have them all. Let's assume you're right about everything.
It still changes nothing about the truths that govern children of God:
All human beings are made in God's image, equal before Him in their worth and dignity and claim to justice. Our laws should treat everyone equally, without partiality.
Mankind is not merely an animal, and to treat him as such is a blasphemous affront to the God who created him
We should judge individuals by their actions and character rather than by their racial group
Some cultures are inherently better than others, and there's nothing wrong with avoiding bad cultures or preventing immigration from bad cultures.
Nurture, religion, culture, and choices are all much more powerful determinants of who you will become than DNA is
God uses the weak to shame the strong and the foolish to shame the wise. Your racial pride and your confidence in your ancestry will damn you to Hell.
Godless anthropology and pagan superstition, both of which feature a disordered worship of nature, always end in death and injustice. Every time. I don't care how good your intentions are. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
J.D. Haltigan, PhD 🏒👨💻
@JDHaltigan
The Overton window on human truth is beginning to open as a consequence of the Arday affair. Nathan Cofnas @nathancofnas has certainly gotten many people to have public conversations that were unthinkable just a month ago.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Leo Kearse - see me on tour! Links in bio
@LeoKearse
J.K. Rowling vs Nathan Cofnas: race realism is a taboo too far for some brave, truth-telling gender realists.
Nathan Cofnas is the race realist academic who was instrumental in exposing Jason Arday as a non-realist academic. J.K. Rowling just called him "racist" on Twitter.
I'm a big fan of J.K. Rowling. She's resolute in her resistance to gender ideology even though it hurts her financially, subjects her to vitriol and puts her at risk. You might think J.K. Rowling would have some solidarity with another person who's been hauled over the coals for promoting scientific realism over cultural norms, but no. He's t̶r̶a̶n̶s̶p̶h̶o̶b̶i̶c̶ "racist".
This exposes her blind spot. Gender ideology is where her realism stops. When it comes to race realism, she turns into Owen Jones.
Which is a shame. I've seen other TERFs stand up for, if not race realism, then at least nationalism. There are parallels between the way that men are allowed to "identify" as women and the way that Rwandan men are allowed to identify as Welsh choirboys.
But when it comes to Cofnas, many TERFs are saying that human sex is dimorphic, whereas race is nebulous and hard to define.
Nebulous? Maybe. But if I'm walking around London, half the time I can't tell if a person is a man or a woman. But I immediately know if I'm at Wimbledon or if I'm at the Notting Hill Carnival. If a big bunch of black "yoot" gets on my train carriage, I can tell with my eyes shut. If I drive through a Muslim area, there are usually a few tell-tale signs (written in Urdu).
The ratio of males to females is pretty constant around the world, but there are huge discrepancies in what those areas are like. Calcutta and Lagos are not like Durham or Bergen. I suspect there may be factors other than masculinity and femininity guiding behaviour at the population level.
I understand that it's a taboo with the potential to destroy careers, and I also understand that there are easy get-outs. In-group variance is greater than inter-group variance. Any differences at the group level don't mean that an individual will have any particular traits. I firmly believe that a man from the Horn of Africa can be intelligent and civilised, and I look forward to science proving me correct by one day finding one who is.
But the weakness of the attacks on Nathan Cofnas is revealing. Nick Ferrari could only accuse him of "causing distress to a black student". This, in itself, was seen as reason enough to shut down anything that Nathan Cofnas might say.
But if we're going to end all academic work that might cause distress, why not scrap the theory of evolution? It distresses creationists. Perhaps the cardinals were correct to condemn Galileo for presenting a heliocentric model, because the heliocentric model had distressed them?
Academia's credibility has taken a beating over the last couple of months, but as the taboos around race realism evaporate, Cofnas may end up resurrecting it - and finally be appointed "Head of Eugenics & Race Science at Harvard".This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
korean adoptees in sweden do somewhat better on IQ tests than native-born swedes
Michael Druggan
@Michael_Druggan
The actual statistics from transracial adoption studies are actually some of the strongest evidence *in favor* of the hereditarian position.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
Society if everyone could debate controversial topics dispassionately, follow the argument calmly wherever it goes, and actually properly engage with each others’ ideas without emotional hysterics.
So rare today it was almost like watching two aliens from a different planet
Well done @coldxman & @nathancofnas
The Free Press
@TheFP
"Arday suffered a a punishment that was totally disproportionate to what he had done, I see him to some extent a victim of this situation."
@nathancofnas speaks to @coldxman about the system of DEI that enabled Jason Arday's rise and fall.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
There exists no person who could have exposed Jason Arday and not have their life turned upside down
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
The avowed antiracists defending Jason Arday (a con artist) are now weeks into a campaign against a black reporter at the Guardian who published one of the most important articles exposing him. The origin of that article was Arday reaching out to the journalist to lie to him.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Strong words in @insidehighered about @UGent's letter suspending @nathancofnas:
"Ghent argues that Cofnas’s criticism of Arday as “mentally disabled” and a "worthless scholar" was “an intentional and serious disturbance of the peace” that may violate “the Belgian Criminal Code.” It is ludicrous (and dangerous) to suggest that accurately accusing a scholar of plagiarism and expressing mean opinions could ever be considered a crime."
www.insidehighered.com/opinion/columns/debatable-ideas/20… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ambassador Bill White
@BillWhiteUSA
I like Maxime Prevot a lot.
I just saved Belgium from a complete global media meltdown and well deserved spanking by @elonmusk and everyone by resolving the UGHENT Cofnas matter - quite quickly.
We are offering Belgium over €10,000,000,000.00 (that’s 10 BILLION with a B) in financing for new Westinghouse Nuclear power plants to help Belgium reduce energy costs, get off Russian gas and provide the great Belgian businesses with the energy that they need to grow Belgium‘s GDP.
I am offering Global Entry to every Belgian citizen that can qualify which means they will never ever ever have to wait in an immigration line again when they travel to the United States.
Everyone in Belgium will be so grateful to President Trump.
How about THANK YOU AMBASSADOR?
Belgians can simply register, pay the fee and then be permitted to go through directly to pick up their bags and not wait two or three hours that Belgians are now waiting now in America.
I have offered this with President Trump’s and Secretary Rubio and HLS approval to the Belgian government.
I am waiting for their answer.
Do Belgians want to wait in LONG lines anymore when coming to America ?
THESE are the things that I want to meet and discuss with the Belgian government.
We want to help our beautiful amazing new Belgian friends avoid long lines when they travel to America. We want them to enjoy our beautiful country and do business there.
This meeting Monday is a complete and total waste of time. That said I like Maxime Prevot and look forward to seeing him.
For the record.
I never called Frank Vanden….. a loser.
He is not a loser.
If you want to ask me what I think of him ask me privately I’ll tell you. I think you know.
No one called him a loser.
The only thing I did was repost on MY PERSONAL SM (which is not anyone’s business) that someone else asked “Who is the biggest loser in Belgium?…..
Now I am now curious what people think.
The result of my poll was wild.
386 direct messages from Belgian citizens - and counting.
Would you like to know who the 386 Belgian citizens think is a loser ?
RTL info
@rtlinfo
« C’est intolérable » : Maxime Prévot convoque l’ambassadeur des États-Unis après qu’il a qualifié le ministre Frank Vandenbroucke de « loser » sur Instagram www.rtl.be/actu/belgique/politique/cest-intolerable-maxim…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 1860 you would have written an article called "Shut Up about Evolution" with exactly the same arguments you make about race and IQ. But Darwin beat the taboo with facts and logic.
Today, there is a "mild taboo" on telling people that their religion is wrong. If a corn farmer in Iowa believes that Adam and Eve hunted dinosaurs, we don't make an issue out of it because it doesn't matter. 99% of the elites are Darwinians, and they are the ones who set the cultural agenda: government grants support research on evolution, textbooks say that Darwin was right, etc.
The race taboo can be dealt with in the same way as the evolution taboo. Make HBD common knowledge among the elites, and don't shove it down everyone else's throat. That's the Hereditarian Revolution and the only way to save our civilization. -
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Cofnas tells Coleman Hughes that we don't have to be telling voters in Iowa about group differences in intelligence.
Hughes asks how you keep it from spilling out.
Cofnas: "There can be a mild taboo. It can be considered impolite to talk about it."
Wait, what? I thought Cofnas' entire point was that we have to have a response for when liberals make woke arguments.
So we talk about it among elites, and then some activist comes along and says that discrimination causes disparities. At that point, what do you say? He acts as if CNN won't be able to report on race science conversations that are going on among "elites."
What happens then?
He just rediscovered the taboo he's advocating against.
It sounds like he's come along to accepting my idea of Esoteric Cofnasism. www.richardhanania.com/p/esoteric-cofnasism
But the point is that this discussion can't be too widespread among elites, or it will obviously be part of the general discourse, which even Cofnas himself doesn't want!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 1860 you would have written an article called "Shut Up about Evolution" with exactly the same arguments you make about race and IQ. But Darwin beat the taboo with facts and logic.
Today, there is a "mild taboo" on telling people that their religion is wrong. If a corn farmer in Iowa believes that Adam and Eve hunted dinosaurs, we don't make an issue out of it because it doesn't matter. 99% of the elites are Darwinians, and they are the ones who set the cultural agenda: government grants support research on evolution, textbooks say that Darwin was right, etc.
The race taboo can be dealt with in the same way as the evolution taboo. Make HBD common knowledge among the elites, and don't shove it down everyone else's throat. That's the Hereditarian Revolution and the only way to save our civilization. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Haier
@rjhaier
Sir, Thank you for your strong and constructive support of Nathan Cofnas. Here's a related issue: In the US, one under-the-radar consequence of Woke/DEI policies is the near elimination of college/university courses about human intelligence: quillette.com/2026/08/14/cambridge-and-the-stigmatisation…. I’d be grateful for any help you can offer bringing this to the attention of other foundations or individuals who might help. Sincerely, Richard Haier richardhaier.com hirefoundation.org
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ambassador Bill White
@BillWhiteUSA
I am - and the United States is - happy Nathan Cofnas is back to work doing what @ugent hired him to do.
Special thanks to Rector Petra De Sutter for resolving things. I look forward to my upcoming visit to U GENT!
Thank you to all who support Nathan and special thanks to @elonmusk for raising awareness of this and for his extraordinary leadership!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Róisín Michaux
@RoisinMichaux
Nathan Cofnas has the (so-far) best definition of woke. My favourite go-to definition was this: the making-sacred of previously marginalised groups (@epkaufm, who calls it/called it a moral or emotional regime).
That's obviously correct, but @nathancofnas' version adds in a motivation: it's what happens when you take the equality thesis seriously, but you still end up with group-level disparities in outcomes. Wokeism is the result of forcing the equality thesis and then looking for ever-more subtle causes to explain the different outcomes once all the more obvious discriminations have been taken care of.
My redpilling happened when I was working in science research funding for the European Commission, and I had to help communicate to the public that they were sexist because there were fewer women in STEM fields. This was after all of the obvious legal barriers to women choosing STEM careers had been removed, and the norm-changing campaigns had been happening for most of my life.
More than half of university students were female, and almost everyone in the meetings about sexism were women. It was a hunt for invisible causes, without ever considering that personal choice or abilities (fewer female spergs) could have anything to do with it. That could never be even said aloud. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ann Coulter
@AnnCoulter
Until every university in America is begging Prof. Cofnas to join its faculty, the Trump administration has not punished them enough.
U.S. Ambassador to Belgium Bill White
@USAmbToBelgium
After speaking with all parties, I am pleased to see that Ghent University and Nathan Cofnas have amicably reached an agreement to lift Mr. Cofnas' suspension, which will enable him to complete his one-year postdoctoral appointment. I look forward to working with Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter to continue the relationship between the university and the United States. I am grateful for her willingness to listen to voices calling for protecting academic freedom.
@BillWhiteUSA
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
The truth shall set you free
TRIGGERnometry
@triggerpod
"The world makes no sense if you think everyone is born exactly the same."
@KonstantinKisin asks @nathancofnas what motivates him to tackle controversial topics despite pushback from all sides.
His answer: ignoring natural group differences forces society to blame "mystical injustice" for inequality, meaning there will be no peace until we accept biological reality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
TRIGGERnometry
@triggerpod
"The world makes no sense if you think everyone is born exactly the same."
@KonstantinKisin asks @nathancofnas what motivates him to tackle controversial topics despite pushback from all sides.
His answer: ignoring natural group differences forces society to blame "mystical injustice" for inequality, meaning there will be no peace until we accept biological reality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
Saying that Cofnas has blood on his hands along with a picture of him is worse than what Cofnas (or any media) said against Arday.
The double standard is so blatant and ridiculous. 5,300 people supporting a witch hunt on a person for ... starting a witch hunt (according to them). -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ann Coulter
@AnnCoulter
Nathan Cofnas was first fired by Cambridge for writing about race and IQ. We talk about race constantly, but somehow we can't discuss the actual differences.
American conservatives just want merit, and Cambridge would rather pretend race and IQ don't exist.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
“The Bell curve is a fact of life. The blacks on average score 85 per cent on IQ and it is accurate, nothing to do with culture. The whites score on average 100. Asians score more… the Bell curve authors put it at least 10 points higher.
These are realities that, if you do not accept, will lead to frustration because you will be spending money on wrong assumptions and the results cannot follow.
Supposing we had hidden the truth and taken the American approach and said, all men are equal. Then they (the less able or well-off) will demand equal results. And when the results are not equal, they will demand more equal treatment.”
- Lee Kuan Yew
Sounds to me that Nathan Cofnas has the same point of view as LKY did on this matter.
Singapore treats competitive selection (university places, civil service scholarships, officer training, most public-sector promotions) as strictly merit-based. There are no racial quotas that lower exam cut-offs or reserve slots in universities or the Public Service Commission the way many Western institutions or Malaysia’s Bumiputera policies do.
Extra (and free) help for lagging groups tends to come through organizations that run extra education and social programs rather than lowering admission standards. So if minorities make it to university, their status isn't questioned as they've earned it fair and square.
At the same time the state does intervene on race where it judges that unregulated markets or voting would produce enclaves or under-representation that threaten cohesion, namely: public housing and Group Representation Constituencies in parliament.
The operating theory is that groups are not identical in average outcomes, that pretending they are produces frustration and wasted spending, and that you therefore keep the high-stakes contests rigorous while using targeted, transparent rules to prevent physical or political segregation.
That is distinct from both color blind liberalism and from identity-based preference systems that treat representation as an end in itself inside every institution, and it's the closest to the worldview that @nathancofnas advocates for.
TRIGGERnometry
@triggerpod
"The world makes no sense if you think everyone is born exactly the same."
@KonstantinKisin asks @nathancofnas what motivates him to tackle controversial topics despite pushback from all sides.
His answer: ignoring natural group differences forces society to blame "mystical injustice" for inequality, meaning there will be no peace until we accept biological reality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Under Secretary of State Sarah B. Rogers
@UnderSecPD
The Future of Liberalism ⬇️
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
U.S. Ambassador to Belgium Bill White
@USAmbToBelgium
After speaking with all parties, I am pleased to see that Ghent University and Nathan Cofnas have amicably reached an agreement to lift Mr. Cofnas' suspension, which will enable him to complete his one-year postdoctoral appointment. I look forward to working with Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter to continue the relationship between the university and the United States. I am grateful for her willingness to listen to voices calling for protecting academic freedom.
@BillWhiteUSA
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
Dr. @nathancofnas - Was It Right to Alert the World About Jason Arday? @Cambridge_Uni @ugent @umdeclaration
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ann Coulter
@AnnCoulter
This is hilarious.
David Paxton
@DavidDPaxton
Seen this before. When British media decide it’s important, or edgy, enough to platform a controversial speaker, but are either so scared it might go wrong, or so determined to be the person to slay the beast, they absolutely blow the interview.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Daniel Kodsi
@dfkodsi
This is an interview from the last time @nathancofnas was cancelled. Here was his summary of it lol
David Paxton
@DavidDPaxton
Seen this before. When British media decide it’s important, or edgy, enough to platform a controversial speaker, but are either so scared it might go wrong, or so determined to be the person to slay the beast, they absolutely blow the interview.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
What is the truth about race and evolution?
A philosophical biologist (me) and a biological philosopher @nathancofnas hash it out in the wake of the Jason Arday scandal.
00:00:00 The Rules of Engagement
00:03:46 Race Realist?
00:08:47 Lineage vs. Race
00:13:58 The Euphemism Treadmill
00:16:38 Is Morality Real?
00:24:51 Westermarck and the Kibbutz
00:35:34 The Incest Taboo Test
00:41:53 Where Moral Beliefs Come From
00:52:34 Wokeism as an Existential Threat
00:57:54 Darwinism Applied to Humans
01:02:21 Does Winter Make You Smarter?
01:07:53 Inuits and Ethiopians
01:10:46 Why Aren't We All Von Neumann?
01:18:10 What About West African Sprinters?
01:24:37 The Black Cats in the Dark
01:28:21 The Longest Childhood on Earth
01:35:07 Everything Is an IQ Test
01:40:59 What Slavery Broke
01:45:21 Ethiopia, Korea, Japan, China
01:49:32 The Second Mode of Inheritance
01:54:18 What We Actually Disagree About
01:57:47 The Arms Race Has No CeilingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
David Atherton
@daveatherton
I'm sorry @NickFerrariLBC but your shutting down of Dr @nathancofnas was entirely wrong you asked the question, he's entitled to answer it how he feels it appropriate, within reason.
It seems that 0.7% of black people would qualify for Harvard but via DEI is 14%, 20 times over represented. It seems that Asians are the victims here.
Nick, facts don't care about feelings. You have no right not to be offended.
As a someone with a broad cockney accent, people assume I'm thick. The nearest I've got to Cambridge University is the M11.
But the two formal IQ tests I took, I scored 137 and 140.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Konstantin Kisin
@KonstantinKisin
Weird how the people outraged by the "hounding" of Jason Arday delight in and encourage the actual hounding of the person who exposed him.
Arday was not fired from his job or denied employment opportunities. On the contrary, he was given and retained jobs for which he was not qualified and was rightly criticised for lying.
Cofnas, on the other hand, is actually being denied jobs and fired from them for bring Arday's lying to light.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Skscartoon
@skscartoon
A brief history of the Jason Arday controversy:
- A DEI university created a lie.
- Nathan Cofnas exposed the lie.
- The university suspended him for exposing it.
Libs of TikTok
@libsoftiktok
BREAKING: Nathan Cofnas, the academic who initially accused former Cambridge Prof. Jason Arday of plagiarism, has been SUSPENDED by Ghent University (@ugent) for "discrimination" and "racism."
This comes after Arday was found dead following his resignation from Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jonathan Keeperman
@L0m3z
Again @nathancofnas far outclasses a hostile interviewer. He's been incredibly sharp and well-mannered during this whole episode. He deserves an award.
Go to 4.15 of the clip below to see where the Cofnas portion begins
David Paxton
@DavidDPaxton
Seen this before. When British media decide it’s important, or edgy, enough to platform a controversial speaker, but are either so scared it might go wrong, or so determined to be the person to slay the beast, they absolutely blow the interview.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
I'll be speaking with @nathancofnas on The Saad Truth this week. Get ready.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Flemish state television
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Petra Kosonen
@PetraKosonen
I emailed Petra De Sutter, Rector of @ugent, and a few others about @nathancofnas’s suspension
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This internal email from a tenured professor at Nathan Cofnas’ department shows not only that the “barrage” of complaints about the “negative effects on well-being” was perfectly coordinated, but that it was explicitly encouraged by rector Petra De Sutter herself. If this is true, she was actively egging on the hecklers in order to grant them a veto, which makes the whole affair even worse. /2
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
U.S. Ambassador to Belgium Bill White
@USAmbToBelgium
The United States Mission to Belgium condemns, in the strongest terms, Ghent University’s retaliation against an American scholar following his accurate whistleblower reporting on academic fraud.
The United States government regularly funds and supports research, academic exchanges, and other engagements with overseas universities. Dishonest, corrupt institutions that engage in, or reward, scapegoating mob behavior are not desirable partners for us. This is particularly true where the purpose and effect of the scapegoating is to punish accurate journalism unearthing academic dishonesty. We are therefore reviewing any relationships we have with Ghent University.
Bad-faith idealogues will try to make this a referendum on the content of Cofnas’s scholarship – or polemical distortions of it. That’s wrong. Free speech means that controversial views are protected. And Cofnas’s views were known to Ghent University when he was hired.
The ultimate purpose of freedom of speech is to overturn lies, fraud, and false ideologies. This is precisely what Cofnas was doing, and precisely the reason his home institution wants to silence him.
Thank you for your attention to this matter. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“How I Became the Scapegoat in the Jason Arday Affair”
Gift link: www.wsj.com/opinion/free-expression/how-i-became-the-scap… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am under investigation by my university for discriminating against Arday
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I agree with one thing Simon Baron-Cohen said: "There has to be accountability at lots of levels."
The first thing that should be done is that Simon should be reprimanded. In this interview, he uttered several complete and total lies and confabulations
Get liars out of academia -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Blake Neff
@BlakeSNeff
.@nathancofnas did the work that Cambridge, the press, and dozens of other British institutions were too cowardly to do by exposing Jason Arday. So naturally, he has rallies denouncing him and gets death threats.
Cofnas joined the show to ID the greatest villains of the saga: Academic elites who perpetuate a system of DEI that means hiring and promoting unqualified people purely based on skin color or other irrelevant traits.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Hey @sbaroncohen, before telling lies about me (that I made false plagiarism accusations and said “without DEI there would be no black professors in universities”), did you inquire about *my* mental health?
I am more autistic than Jason Arday was.
Carole Cadwalladr
@carolecadwalla
I included this moving with Arday’s friend, world-leading autism expert, Simon Baron-Cohen in my piece. I urge you to listen to it. Not just because he talks about his loving gentle friend but because he also sets down a precise chronology of events.
Arday was cleared of plagiarism under Cambridge’s rules: that the award-giving institution investigates. He accompanied Arday to Liverpool John Moores in February. He was found to have credited the underlying work but incorrectly cited it on each occasion. He was cleared of plagiarism. It was Cambridge’s reversal of its initial decision that damned him. He was literally thrown to the mob.
In the next 9 days, Baron-Cohen says his mental health spiralled.
broligarchy.substack.com/p/a-digital-lynching?r=nv9u6This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I often wonder if people realize they're caught up playing silly word games.
This is just defining Cofnas' restatements of Harvard's findings to be racism. It's not evidence he's racist by any traditional or sensible definition.
Does she know she's not being coherent?
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
I read Cofnas's 2024 Substack post, which is summarised (I believe fairly) here. In my view, Cofnas's 'race realism' is racism. Full link below. observer.co.uk/news/national/article/nathan-cofnas-the-ma…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Diana S. Fleischman
@sentientist
Rowling's next book- Hogwarts implements a DEI program for muggles because it's only prejudicial attitudes holding them back from learning magic
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
I read Cofnas's 2024 Substack post, which is summarised (I believe fairly) here. In my view, Cofnas's 'race realism' is racism. Full link below. observer.co.uk/news/national/article/nathan-cofnas-the-ma…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Helen Joyce
@HJoyceGender
This is one of the most damning things I have ever read about the BBC. A 6-year PR campaign puffing up Arday, and when it all came crashing down the Beeb was missing in action. And then tried to turn Nathan Cofnas, who broke the Arday story, into the "real story"
Steven Edginton
@StevenEdginton
I consumed (nearly) all of the BBC’s coverage of Jason Arday, dating back six years.
What I found was extraordinary: years of uncritical interviews, repeated nonsense claims, and, once Arday was caught out, a broadcaster that chose to ignore the story, then double down on its favourite black academic.
I’ve documented it all for The Spectator.
spectator.com/article/will-the-bbc-apologise-for-its-role… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Try Not To @ Me
@UsingLyft
A Black Man’s Defense of Nathan Cofnas
First, claims about genetic differences in average intelligence between racial groups aren’t immoral. They’re either true or false based on the evidence. A belief about what the data shows can be wrong—sure. But it can’t be evil.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
1 - at this point after learning about arday's death last friday, thought we'd be talking about what needs to be done with the faculty and admins at cambridge who hired him. no, instead
2 - a faction of the british left and racialists are trying to make him into a martyr! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@jk_rowling, who is smeared for sex realism, calls me a bad word for applying the same logic to race
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
More than one thing can be true. Nathan Cofnas is a racist. No argument there.
Also true: Arday claimed to have been non-verbal until the age of eleven. He span a false narrative about being autistic and mute, then learning to speak and write so well he gained a PhD. What harm did he do to parents with children who're genuinely non-verbal, by selling them false hope? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ann Coulter
@AnnCoulter
15k people advertising their own inadequacy. They'd probably point the gun the wrong way.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
It's an incredible indictment of our society that it contains so many people who would rather attack those who reveal fraud than those who commit it.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hey @BBCNews, this what an actual "witch hunt" looks like: a mob in the town square whipping up hatred against a single individual. By contrast, documenting the fraud of a famous professor at a prestigious university is usually called "journalism."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aryeh Kontorovich
@aryehazan
imagine threatening @nathancofnas with the prospect of (checks notes) meticulously scrutinizing his writings
Un Étrange En Terre Étrange
@LoinDuTribu
So here’s a modest proposal.
Jason Arday is dead. The circus has lost its main attraction. The tent is still up, the popcorn machine is still warm, and several of the ringmasters are wandering around pretending they were merely checking the fire exits.
Perhaps The Telegraph, The Spectator, Kathleen Stock, Julia Hartley-Brewer, Julie Bindel, Andrew Neil, Brendan O’Neill and the rest of Britain’s newly discovered Society for Relentless Academic Due Diligence could turn their tremendous investigative appetite towards Nathan fucking Cofnas.
You know Nathan.
The self-described race realist whose intervention helped detonate the Arday story.
The bloke who already believed DEI was corrupting academia.
The bloke who has argued that genuine meritocracy would leave vanishingly few Black professors at elite institutions.
The bloke who talks about a “hereditarian revolution”.
The bloke who, while discussing what comes next for his own career, joked that after “the revolution” he might become head of the department of eugenics and race science at Harvard.
That Nathan Cofnas.
Come on, lads.
You have just spent weeks demonstrating that no biographical pebble is too small to overturn in the sacred pursuit of Truth.
So get the fucking tweezers out.
Go through his history.
Interview the old classmates.
Find the former supervisors.
Call the ex-colleagues.
Dust off the teenage writings.
Read Reptiles with a Conscience from cover to fucking cover.
Check every citation.
Check every footnote.
Find out what he believed before he acquired the qualifications he now uses to defend those beliefs.
Ask when exactly the fascination with hereditarianism began.
Ask what evidence changed his mind.
Ask what evidence could change his mind.
Ask whether race realism emerged reluctantly at the end of an exhausting empirical journey, or whether the destination appeared on the map first and the intellectual road-building project came afterwards.
You wanted to know whether Jason Arday really ran every marathon he claimed.
Excellent.
I would quite like to know whether Nathan Cofnas has actually demonstrated that Black people are genetically less suited to elite intellectual life, or whether he has spent years developing increasingly elaborate reasons for believing something he found compelling in the first place.
Seems at least as fucking interesting as somebody’s 10K split time.
And while we are at it, perhaps ask why the alleged misconduct of one Black academic became so magnificently useful to a man whose existing political project already concerned Black representation, DEI and declining standards.
Was Arday merely a plagiarism case?
Or did Cofnas look at him and see Christmas morning?
Because once you have spent years arguing that progressive universities are artificially elevating Black academics, discovering a celebrated Black Cambridge professor with serious questions hanging over his work must feel less like stumbling across evidence and more like finding a fucking golden ticket inside your ideological Wonka bar.
And apparently that angle is not worth the same excavation?
Really?
Jason Arday tells a tall tale about running and Fleet Street behaves like somebody has discovered the Pentagon Papers.
Nathan Cofnas spends years developing a political programme around hereditarianism and race, then helps frame a national scandal involving a Black professor, and suddenly everyone develops a tremendous respect for intellectual privacy.
How curious.
I am not asking for another pile-on.
I am asking for the same thing you all claimed to worship while Arday was alive:
scrutiny.
Context.
Provenance.
Motivation.
Evidence.
Standards.
Those lovely grown-up words everybody suddenly remembers when they are about to put somebody else under the microscope.
1/2 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
the second half of fisher's *the genetical theory of natural selection* was about eugenics and he refused to sign the UNESCO statement on race
Mike McCarthy
@its_mccarthy
There is a reason why this stuff went the way of the dodo, it’s that evolutionary biologists, geneticists, and sociologists like Gould, Lewontin, Tishkoff, and Fischer et al absolutely destroyed it on scientific terms. There is no debate to be had, we already won.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Two things
1. Nathan's work has been extensively investigated precisely because he's a persona non grata in academia. People who do certain controversial work tend to meet higher evidentiary standards because they're under greater scrutiny.
2. This post is AI slop.
Un Étrange En Terre Étrange
@LoinDuTribu
So here’s a modest proposal.
Jason Arday is dead. The circus has lost its main attraction. The tent is still up, the popcorn machine is still warm, and several of the ringmasters are wandering around pretending they were merely checking the fire exits.
Perhaps The Telegraph, The Spectator, Kathleen Stock, Julia Hartley-Brewer, Julie Bindel, Andrew Neil, Brendan O’Neill and the rest of Britain’s newly discovered Society for Relentless Academic Due Diligence could turn their tremendous investigative appetite towards Nathan fucking Cofnas.
You know Nathan.
The self-described race realist whose intervention helped detonate the Arday story.
The bloke who already believed DEI was corrupting academia.
The bloke who has argued that genuine meritocracy would leave vanishingly few Black professors at elite institutions.
The bloke who talks about a “hereditarian revolution”.
The bloke who, while discussing what comes next for his own career, joked that after “the revolution” he might become head of the department of eugenics and race science at Harvard.
That Nathan Cofnas.
Come on, lads.
You have just spent weeks demonstrating that no biographical pebble is too small to overturn in the sacred pursuit of Truth.
So get the fucking tweezers out.
Go through his history.
Interview the old classmates.
Find the former supervisors.
Call the ex-colleagues.
Dust off the teenage writings.
Read Reptiles with a Conscience from cover to fucking cover.
Check every citation.
Check every footnote.
Find out what he believed before he acquired the qualifications he now uses to defend those beliefs.
Ask when exactly the fascination with hereditarianism began.
Ask what evidence changed his mind.
Ask what evidence could change his mind.
Ask whether race realism emerged reluctantly at the end of an exhausting empirical journey, or whether the destination appeared on the map first and the intellectual road-building project came afterwards.
You wanted to know whether Jason Arday really ran every marathon he claimed.
Excellent.
I would quite like to know whether Nathan Cofnas has actually demonstrated that Black people are genetically less suited to elite intellectual life, or whether he has spent years developing increasingly elaborate reasons for believing something he found compelling in the first place.
Seems at least as fucking interesting as somebody’s 10K split time.
And while we are at it, perhaps ask why the alleged misconduct of one Black academic became so magnificently useful to a man whose existing political project already concerned Black representation, DEI and declining standards.
Was Arday merely a plagiarism case?
Or did Cofnas look at him and see Christmas morning?
Because once you have spent years arguing that progressive universities are artificially elevating Black academics, discovering a celebrated Black Cambridge professor with serious questions hanging over his work must feel less like stumbling across evidence and more like finding a fucking golden ticket inside your ideological Wonka bar.
And apparently that angle is not worth the same excavation?
Really?
Jason Arday tells a tall tale about running and Fleet Street behaves like somebody has discovered the Pentagon Papers.
Nathan Cofnas spends years developing a political programme around hereditarianism and race, then helps frame a national scandal involving a Black professor, and suddenly everyone develops a tremendous respect for intellectual privacy.
How curious.
I am not asking for another pile-on.
I am asking for the same thing you all claimed to worship while Arday was alive:
scrutiny.
Context.
Provenance.
Motivation.
Evidence.
Standards.
Those lovely grown-up words everybody suddenly remembers when they are about to put somebody else under the microscope.
1/2 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
believe it or not, ppl have looked into @nathancofnas because the incentives are very different...
Un Étrange En Terre Étrange
@LoinDuTribu
So here’s a modest proposal.
Jason Arday is dead. The circus has lost its main attraction. The tent is still up, the popcorn machine is still warm, and several of the ringmasters are wandering around pretending they were merely checking the fire exits.
Perhaps The Telegraph, The Spectator, Kathleen Stock, Julia Hartley-Brewer, Julie Bindel, Andrew Neil, Brendan O’Neill and the rest of Britain’s newly discovered Society for Relentless Academic Due Diligence could turn their tremendous investigative appetite towards Nathan fucking Cofnas.
You know Nathan.
The self-described race realist whose intervention helped detonate the Arday story.
The bloke who already believed DEI was corrupting academia.
The bloke who has argued that genuine meritocracy would leave vanishingly few Black professors at elite institutions.
The bloke who talks about a “hereditarian revolution”.
The bloke who, while discussing what comes next for his own career, joked that after “the revolution” he might become head of the department of eugenics and race science at Harvard.
That Nathan Cofnas.
Come on, lads.
You have just spent weeks demonstrating that no biographical pebble is too small to overturn in the sacred pursuit of Truth.
So get the fucking tweezers out.
Go through his history.
Interview the old classmates.
Find the former supervisors.
Call the ex-colleagues.
Dust off the teenage writings.
Read Reptiles with a Conscience from cover to fucking cover.
Check every citation.
Check every footnote.
Find out what he believed before he acquired the qualifications he now uses to defend those beliefs.
Ask when exactly the fascination with hereditarianism began.
Ask what evidence changed his mind.
Ask what evidence could change his mind.
Ask whether race realism emerged reluctantly at the end of an exhausting empirical journey, or whether the destination appeared on the map first and the intellectual road-building project came afterwards.
You wanted to know whether Jason Arday really ran every marathon he claimed.
Excellent.
I would quite like to know whether Nathan Cofnas has actually demonstrated that Black people are genetically less suited to elite intellectual life, or whether he has spent years developing increasingly elaborate reasons for believing something he found compelling in the first place.
Seems at least as fucking interesting as somebody’s 10K split time.
And while we are at it, perhaps ask why the alleged misconduct of one Black academic became so magnificently useful to a man whose existing political project already concerned Black representation, DEI and declining standards.
Was Arday merely a plagiarism case?
Or did Cofnas look at him and see Christmas morning?
Because once you have spent years arguing that progressive universities are artificially elevating Black academics, discovering a celebrated Black Cambridge professor with serious questions hanging over his work must feel less like stumbling across evidence and more like finding a fucking golden ticket inside your ideological Wonka bar.
And apparently that angle is not worth the same excavation?
Really?
Jason Arday tells a tall tale about running and Fleet Street behaves like somebody has discovered the Pentagon Papers.
Nathan Cofnas spends years developing a political programme around hereditarianism and race, then helps frame a national scandal involving a Black professor, and suddenly everyone develops a tremendous respect for intellectual privacy.
How curious.
I am not asking for another pile-on.
I am asking for the same thing you all claimed to worship while Arday was alive:
scrutiny.
Context.
Provenance.
Motivation.
Evidence.
Standards.
Those lovely grown-up words everybody suddenly remembers when they are about to put somebody else under the microscope.
1/2 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Graham Linehan
@Glinner
As soon as I saw @jessesingal pre-emptively distancing himself from @nathancofnas, I knew I’d start seeing the kind of “evidence” that allows for that kind of cowardice. And lo: an out-of-context joke, made before the weekend’s events, circulated as proof that the caricature is actually evidence
Lewis
@L_A_D_J
Nathan Cofnas who "broke" the story about Jason Arday.
He says Arday gave him the chance for a story to retaliate for being fired & start a "revolution" against Black people in academia.
"After the revolution, I'll be the head of the dept of eugenics & race science at Harvard'.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
since arday's death:
- *some* left-wing academics saying it wasn't plagiarism, he wasn't a major figure, media hounded him. @nathancofnas needs to be canceled now, he did this!
- they may get away with this, but in the end their prestige will drop and $ will disappear -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gashlycrumb Tiny
@tomsweissmann
"Nathan Cofnas is a racist white suprematistv and it's because of his Jewish genes"
Richard Gill
@gill1109
Google AI tells me that Nathan Cofnas’ ancestors were Ashkenazi Jews from Eastern Europe, primarily tracking back to the regions of Russia, Lithuania, and Latvia. I guess he has genes for ethnosupremacy.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Cardinal Newman’s definition of a gentleman is the exact opposite of a philosopher
The true gentleman in like manner carefully avoids whatever may cause a jar or a jolt in the minds of those with whom he is cast…his great concern being to make every one at his ease and at home. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@Rosalind_Arden_ compares how Cambridge treated "two of its own scholars once they presented the university with a problem."
"The two problems are tightly linked by the theme of race." quillette.com/2026/08/14/institutional-failures-in-the-ga… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bo Winegard
@EPoe187
1. Why are people so shocked when they encounter the reality of race and IQ? Because the mainstream press misinforms them. Here is the NYT faulting Nathan Cofnas for his interest in a "purported" relation between race and intellect. It's not "purported." It's a fact.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Richard Haier (@rjhaier) edited the journal Intelligence from 2016–2024 & is Professor Emeritus in the med school at UC Irvine. He wrote to Cambridge in 2024 in defence of @nathancofnas. That letter is published for the first time at @Quillette
quillette.com/2026/08/14/cambridge-and-the-stigmatisation… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
I'm now fully Team @nathancofnas. The more I read, the more I agree with this assessment by @AndrewHammel1 for @Quillette. (Link below).
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aryeh Kontorovich
@aryehazan
“mental illness expands to fill the space in which it is tolerated”
@nathancofnas brilliant gem
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thought experiment: "Imagine an alternate history where philosophy never became an academic subject."
Me on Brain in a Vat: www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYnxvRfPMTk -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thought experiment: "Imagine an alternate history where philosophy never became an academic subject."
Me on Brain in a Vat: www.youtube.com/watch?v=EYnxvRfPMTk -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Toby Young
@toadmeister
"Jason Arday was flagrantly unqualified but ticked the right identity and ideological boxes. Cambridge hired him anyway, then pretended he was a great scholar. And the people who covered it up are still staying silent."
@nathancofnas on the Sceptic.
Full episode 👇 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Louise Perry: "Would [Newton] be able to negotiate funding applications? HR? Student politics?...Would he use the correct pronouns?" www.wsj.com/opinion/free-expression/from-isaac-newton-to-…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bo Winegard
@EPoe187
This is absolutely correct. DEI is anti-white and anti-Asian racism. It is the elevation of mediocre blacks. It is the destruction of meritocracy. A lie, a cheat, a swindle. It is, in other words, Jason Arday.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
ChatGPT counts 46 organizations that had formal ties with Jason Arday including
- Durham University (associate prof)
- Glasgow (full professor)
- British Sociological Association (director)
- Royal Society of Arts (fellow)
- BBC (guest editor)
In 2023, the Guardian itself (!) published a breathless article titled “Jason Arday: he learned to talk at 11 and read at 18 – then became Cambridge’s youngest Black professor.”
More than a dozen academic journals gave the imprimatur of “peer review” to Arday’s plagiarized wokebabble.
The prestigious NY publisher Simon & Schuster is still going ahead with his memoirs.
Now the Guardian wants us to think this is just about “one academic and his bosses at Cambridge”?
There are thousands of Jason Ardays in universities all over the Western world. The only thing special about Arday is that he took the plagiarism and lies about his personal life too far, so there was a hook for a news story. But even that wasn’t enough to get him removed from academia. Until last Wednesday Cambridge was still smearing his critics as waging a “vile campaign.” He crossed the line not by being an incompetent fraud, but by claiming prestigious affiliations that he didn’t have, creating conflict between Cambridge and other universities.
“DEI” means achieving representation by doing away with elementary standards for certain people based on race. Just take a look at the content of “peer-reviewed” journals like Whiteness in Education and Educational Philosophy and Theory. The other papers in these journals are just like those written by Arday—someone who is now widely recognized to be mentally disabled.
The people trying to write this off as a fluke or an isolated case of “research misconduct” are at best delusional. The ideology of elite institutions is DEI, and DEI is Jason Arday. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Professor Eric Rasmusen
@erasmuse
I've never heard of a university department being so ashamed of its people that it hides all their names so people can't google them to see what they've written.
Cambridge started its Education school in 2002 or so. I expect people told them then that a school of education would be bad for Cambridge's reputation, but some administrator thought it would bring in money.
Paul Litterick
@fundypost
The Cambridge Faculty of Education has locked down its 'our people' page
faculty.educ.cam.ac.uk/about-us/our-people -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Academic fraudster Dr Jason Arday has his fantastical memoir out today in the U.S.
Remember that there are many, many, many Ardays out there. Most remain in power even after being caught. He almost did. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Lone Criminologist
@lonecrim
An understated point in the Arday fallout is that for the first time in forever, the university lost control of the narrative. The call is now coming from outside the house. Allegations were uniformly silenced by Cambridge--from students and faculty alike--threatened slapsuits, and, most disturbingly, by the police.
What wedged him out of his sinecure wasn't crack journalism of a dean with a spine but a Substack from a cancelled Cambridge graduate. The fact that his being "racist" gained no purchase this time is telling as well. Having lost the leverage they've held for ages, universities will now have to suffer the judgement of the gallery outside academe because trust has been torched. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bo Winegard
@EPoe187
Nathan Cofnas is called racist for (1) accepting the undisputed reality of race differences in intelligence; (2) proposing that genes play a causal role; and (3) supporting free speech and inquiry into the topic. That's not racism; it is rationalism.
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Why was the Jason Arday story broken by a racist blogger and not the mainstream press?
Because Times Higher Education was intimidated off the story by a letter from notorious libel firm Carter-Ruck.
I'm publishing the letter. Its central claim may be false. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Amusing twist here that Cambridge hired and protected Arday for years in their anti-racism stance; as a result they paved the way for Cofnas to expose him, which will thereby increase interest in Cofnas' work which is very much not anti-racist. Hoisted by their own retard.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
There is no bigger fan of Nathan Cofnas than Alan Wolan.
He makes me think!
His is literally the only Substack I look forward to reading.
Every day a couple hundred people listen to my interview with him on the podcast.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was on the Megyn Kelly Show: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIxdkQWmzGk
"There are thousands of Jason Ardays in universities all over the Western world. Arday's mistake is he took the plagiarism too far. And because he plagiarized that was a hook for the story." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
i/o
@avidseries
"racist blogger"
When numerous repliers objected to this characterization of Nathan Cofnas, @DanNeidle's response was to argue that because @NathanCofnas believes that the average white person in the US has higher measured intelligence than the average black person, he is by definition, a racist. Neidle (who has 194,000 followers) then blocked these repliers.
If this view makes someone a racist, here are some other people who are racist:
(1) All the experts on the (left-leaning) American Psychological Association's panel which issued a report summarizing the scientific information on group IQ differences, in response to The Bell Curve. (The panel officially affirmed a 1 SD gap between US whites and blacks.)
(2) Every known author of every psychology textbook on human intelligence which covers racial IQ averages.
(3) All behavioral geneticists (including anti-hereditarian leftwing ones like Turkheimer, Harden, Nisbett, and Flynn) who have published research in scientific journals since the 70s.
No informed person disputes an IQ gap between blacks and whites in the US. There is some dispute as to its size (estimates range from 9 to 16 points but generally settle at 12-15 points), and of course a lot of dispute as to its cause(s), but only the ideologically captured or ignorant argue it doesn't exist.
And only the most stridently uniformed would block people for simply pointing out a scientifically-established finding.
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
Why was the Jason Arday story broken by a racist blogger and not the mainstream press?
Because Times Higher Education was intimidated off the story by a letter from notorious libel firm Carter-Ruck.
I'm publishing the letter. Its central claim may be false. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
ChatGPT counts 46 organizations that had formal ties with Jason Arday including
- Durham University (associate prof)
- Glasgow (full professor)
- British Sociological Association (director)
- Royal Society of Arts (fellow)
- BBC (guest editor)
In 2023, the Guardian itself (!) published a breathless article titled “Jason Arday: he learned to talk at 11 and read at 18 – then became Cambridge’s youngest Black professor.”
More than a dozen academic journals gave the imprimatur of “peer review” to Arday’s plagiarized wokebabble.
The prestigious NY publisher Simon & Schuster is still going ahead with his memoirs.
Now the Guardian wants us to think this is just about “one academic and his bosses at Cambridge”?
There are thousands of Jason Ardays in universities all over the Western world. The only thing special about Arday is that he took the plagiarism and lies about his personal life too far, so there was a hook for a news story. But even that wasn’t enough to get him removed from academia. Until last Wednesday Cambridge was still smearing his critics as waging a “vile campaign.” He crossed the line not by being an incompetent fraud, but by claiming prestigious affiliations that he didn’t have, creating conflict between Cambridge and other universities.
“DEI” means achieving representation by doing away with elementary standards for certain people based on race. Just take a look at the content of “peer-reviewed” journals like Whiteness in Education and Educational Philosophy and Theory. The other papers in these journals are just like those written by Arday—someone who is now widely recognized to be mentally disabled.
The people trying to write this off as a fluke or an isolated case of “research misconduct” are at best delusional. The ideology of elite institutions is DEI, and DEI is Jason Arday. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alessandro Strumia
@AlessandroStru4
Many Cambridge professors surely think: “these woke idiots did everything to maximise our reputation damage”, yet nobody dares to talk. The biggest problem in Cambridge is Cofnas, and the biggest problem in Sicily is traffic.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was on the Megyn Kelly Show: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIxdkQWmzGk
"There are thousands of Jason Ardays in universities all over the Western world. Arday's mistake is he took the plagiarism too far. And because he plagiarized that was a hook for the story." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
True. Without @nathancofnas, the fraudster Jason Arday would still have his plush Professorial Chair at @Cambridge_Uni and continue to mismanage students and disgrace his field, and everyone would still be fawning over him.
The academic mob who has doggedly tried to exclude and cancel Cofnas wherever he goes has inadvertently demonstrated exactly why academia desperately needs heterodox gadflies like him.
Multiple academics had their suspicions about Arday, but virtually none of them dared to voice them openly, for fear of being smeared as racist or being stalked by litigation firms. And the rest were just too ideologically blinkered (or stupid) to notice anything.
Amazingly, legacy media are not only extremely reluctant to acknowledge Cofnas’s role in exposing this scandal, but some of them (@nytimes) are even harsher on the whistleblower than they are on the fraudster himself.
This is absurd. Yes, Cofnas has controversial views, but he is prepared to defend with arguments and research, and in perfectly lucid prose. He’s not a fraud or a plagiarist, and I have yet to catch him lying about anything.
Great piece by @AndrewHammel1 in @Quillette. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was on the Megyn Kelly Show: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIxdkQWmzGk
"There are thousands of Jason Ardays in universities all over the Western world. Arday's mistake is he took the plagiarism too far. And because he plagiarized that was a hook for the story." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Winston Marshall
@MrWinMarshall
Nathan Cofnas (@nathancofnas) EXPOSES the truth about Jason Arday
Link in repliesThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
For Wokes, a @nathancofnas who allows selection pressures on humans didn't stop acting above the neck 50,000 years ago is more objectionable than serial fraud, plagiarism, and intentional frivolous misuse of police resources to harass journalists (in theory a criminal offense?!).
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andrew Hammel
@AndrewHammel1
Jack Grove (@jgro_the) describes the consequences of @timeshighered caving to Carter-Ruck's lawsuit threat. I think a few points are in order.
▶️ Times Higher Education should not have caved to the lawsuit threat. After all, @nathancofnas knew he could have been sued or even investigated by police as well, but he went ahead anyway.
▶️ Why would "trained and conscientious" journalists covering higher education have "no desire to inflict damage on the sector"? Would a political or defense- industry journalist say that? Shouldn't "conscientious" journalists report the truth, even if it could "inflict damage" on the subject of their reporting? Too many journalists hold back embarrassing stories to ensure continued access to sources. I'm not accusing Grove of this, but we all know it happens.
▶️ Which exact conclusions did Cofnas draw that Grove disagrees with? That Arday committed plagiarism? Arday has essentially admitted that. That race played a significant role in Arday's hiring? The evidence for that proposition is also conclusive and obvious to anyone with any background in higher education.
▶️ Far from "inflicting damage" on higher education, Cofnas, has helped higher education long-term by exposing a flawed hiring program driven by a divisive and distorting ideology. Universities across the English-speaking world will now realizes that rewarding sub-par academic achievement on ideological grounds can backfire. Arday was by many accounts a poor teacher as well as an incompetent researcher. It was hiring Arday which "inflicted damage" on academia, not Cofnas' expose.
In short, if Times Higher Education actually cared about the standards and reputation of the area it covers, it would have ignored the lawsuit threat and published the article. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This from @AndrewHammel1 is absolutely true. Without @nathancofnas, the fraudster Jason Arday would still have his plush jo and continue to mismanage students and disgrace his field, and everyone would still be fawning over him.
The academic mob who has doggedly tried to exclude and cancel Cofnas wherever he goes has inadvertently demonstrated exactly why academia desperately needs heterodox gadflies like him.
Multiple academics had their suspicions about Arday, but virtually none of them dared to voice them openly, for fear of being smeared as racist or being stalked by litigation firms. And the rest were just too ideologically blinkered (or stupid) to notice anything.
Amazingly, legacy media are not only extremely reluctant to acknowledge Cofnas’s role in exposing this scandal, but some of them (@nytimes) are even harsher on the whistleblower than they are on the fraudster himself.
This is absurd. Yes, Cofnas has controversial views, but he is prepared to defend with arguments and research, and in perfectly lucid prose. He’s not a fraud or a plagiarist, and I have yet to catch him lying about anything.
"While other academics praised the emperor’s new clothes, or observed a culpable silence, Cofnas decided to check whether or not the rumours about Arday’s academic fraud had any basis in fact. Doing so involved running Arday’s dissertation through an online plagiarism checker called Copyleaks. This five-minute task appears to have been beyond not only Arday’s dissertation supervisors, but any of the hundreds of academics who have worked with, supported, recommended, or bestowed degrees and awards on him since 2015."
"Cofnas’s act took considerable courage. Not only did he defy the entire British educational establishment but he also invited the hostile scrutiny of London libel lawyers and perhaps even the police. His decision to pull the plug on Arday has humiliated hundreds of his fellow academics. Yet in much of the reporting about the Arday affair, Cofnas’s contribution is either being ignored or he is being smeared as a racist."
quillette.com/2026/08/07/the-tip-of-the-iceberg-cambridge… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
This is a really good interview. @nathancofnas has risen considerably in my opinion as a result of this whole fiasco.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JKQePI1CfNg -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
David Starkey
@DrDStarkeyCBE
The prequel to the Jason Arday scandal
Nathan Cofnas explains the two articles he wrote back in 2024, which resulted in his essential expulsion from Cambridge University.
The first argued that right-wing politics on average attracted lower IQ people. Not a peep was heard from the Cambridge establishment.
The second argued that ending affirmative action in higher education in the United States would result in the collapse of black representation within that sector. Cue outrage.
As Nathan explains in my interview on David Starkey Talks, the Jason Arday scandal might have played out VERY differently if it hadn’t been him, the man who Cambridge vilified and ostracised just a year earlier, who exposed Mr Arday’s rampant plagiarism.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=C27UXFdz0sA&t=1sThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Many people are unaware that it was an American academic who broke the story about Jason Arday, which finally led others to pay attention and then led Arday himself to resign in disgrace. @nathancofnas, who was forced out of Cambridge for honest writing, has been continually excoriated in liberal media for citing Harvard's internal research that showed its black undergrad student body would drop under one percent in a merit-only system.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
Like everyone else in the commentariat* . . .
*People who went to Oxbridge & are now bricking it over how their credentials are viewed.
. . . I’ve had a few words about Jason Arday.
As always, link in first reply. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
When will people, including the estimable (no sarcasm) @jessesingal get it through their heads? There remains a lot to be explained about the REASON that the means on tests of cognitive ability are different for people of East Asian, Sub-Saharan African, and European ancestry are markedly different, but not the FACT that they are different. There's nothing "purported" about it.
BTW, it's not a mortal sin to use "correlation" meaning "association" informally, but (pedantry incoming) it is statistically nonsensical when talking about race differences. Race is a nominal variable, a test score is a continuous variable. The standard measure of linear correlation, Pearson's r, can't be calculated. (There's point-biserial correlation for binary variables, but when there are several categories... oh, never mind).
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I appreciate @jessesingal’s article in the NYT. But I look forward to a time when people who acknowledge the so-called “purported correlation between race and intellect” (not controversial among researchers in this area) aren’t thereby considered tainted sources.
Regarding the genetic basis of this correlation, leading behavioral geneticists at Harvard just published a paper in the journal Nature about selection for intelligence in West Eurasians. A policy of being suspicious of anyone who acknowledges reality means marginalizing everyone who is informed *and honest* about the most important issue for understanding society. That will not have good consequences for the state of our discourse, or our ability to solve serious problems.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
I wrote about Jason Arday for The New York Times, focusing on academia's tendencies to embody the worst caricatures painted by its critics and to use right-wing attacks as an excuse to eschew certain important acts of quality control
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/08/opinion/cambridge-plagiarism-a… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
The very line that leftist critics are waving around as damning proof of Arday whistleblower Nathan Cofnas’s “racial prejudice” is, funnily enough, a direct quote taken from Harvard University.
They brandished that statistic to justify their own affirmative action regime.
And while we’re on the subject - even if you successfully prove the messenger is morally questionable, the content and its accuracy should stand or fall on their own merits. Which is to say that if Mussolini himself had called Arday a lying dirtbag, that still wouldn’t make Mussolini wrong in this domain.
In @nathancofnas's own words:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Rayobabe ™️
@Rayosweets
Nathan Cofnas is the man behind the Jason Arday story. Here’s who he actually is.
In February 2024, Cofnas wrote a blog post claiming that under a “meritocracy,” Black people would “disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment.” He called racial equality “based on lies.”
Cambridge’s Emmanuel College cut ties with him over it. The Leverhulme Trust, which funded his research, disavowed him and opened its own investigation.
He sued Emmanuel College for discrimination. He lost. Cambridge’s own disciplinary body dismissed all 58 complaints against him, ruling it fell under free speech protections.
He then moved to Ghent University in Belgium. Over 300 staff and students there protested his hiring, questioning whether his views were compatible with the university’s ethics code.
This is the man who spent months going through a Black professor’s PhD thesis and personal history, then published it on Substack. That’s what triggered Cambridge’s investigation into Jason Arday.
This context is missing from nearly all the coverage. A self-described “race realist,” who argued Black professors would basically disappear under merit alone, is the one who decided which Black professor deserved scrutiny.
Black professors: under 1% of the UK total.
Black academics reaching professor level: 3.8%.
This isn’t the first case. It won’t be the last.
Go under the original post and see how overt racism works. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Winston Marshall
@MrWinMarshall
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Interview with Times Radio
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
On YouTube www.youtube.com/watch?v=DaNqrB7kbU0
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I appreciate @jessesingal’s article in the NYT. But I look forward to a time when people who acknowledge the so-called “purported correlation between race and intellect” (not controversial among researchers in this area) aren’t thereby considered tainted sources.
Regarding the genetic basis of this correlation, leading behavioral geneticists at Harvard just published a paper in the journal Nature about selection for intelligence in West Eurasians. A policy of being suspicious of anyone who acknowledges reality means marginalizing everyone who is informed *and honest* about the most important issue for understanding society. That will not have good consequences for the state of our discourse, or our ability to solve serious problems.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
I wrote about Jason Arday for The New York Times, focusing on academia's tendencies to embody the worst caricatures painted by its critics and to use right-wing attacks as an excuse to eschew certain important acts of quality control
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/08/opinion/cambridge-plagiarism-a… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Winston Marshall
@MrWinMarshall
“I Was The One Who Exposed Jason Arday” - Nathan Cofnas (@nathancofnas)
In this episode of The Winston Marshall Show, I sit down with philosopher Nathan Cofnas for a controversial conversation on the Jason Arday scandal, DEI, race, and meritocracy.
We discuss how Cofnas exposed allegations of plagiarism at Cambridge, what the scandal reveals about modern academia, and debate his controversial views on race and IQ, hereditarianism, affirmative action, and the possibility of a truly colourblind society.
Link in repliesThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andrew Hammel
@AndrewHammel1
My latest for @Quillette, in which I break a lance (as Germans say) for @nathancofnas (whom I've never met or corresponded with). British outlets like the Telegraph and the Daily Mail have wrongly claimed credit for exposing Jason Arday. Jack Grove (@jgro_the) of Times Higher Education looked into Arday in 2025, but that publication let itself be bullied into submission by a letter from sinister London libel lawyers Carter-Ruck.
If it hadn't been for a Substack post by Cofnas on July 21st, Arday would still be a professor. Cofnas, and nobody else, had the courage to publicly condemn Arday's plagiarism and shoddy, typo-filled work. And yet if Cofnas mentioned at all, it's to be dismissed as a "racist" or "white nationalist" because of his unfashionable hereditarian outlook. Left-wing British professors lamented that it took a "right-wing" scholar to break the news about Arday, but none of them had the courage to do it. And nobody has identified any breaches of academic standards in Cofnas' work, despite intense scrutiny.
You may disagree with Cofnas' views, but, as I argue in the piece, his kind of caustic contrarianism is just what academia needs. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Time for an independent inquiry led 100% by outsiders, including the academic who bravely brought the issue to public attention, @nathancofnas.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bo Winegard
@EPoe187
The New York Times called Nathan Cofnas "a scholar known for racist views about intelligence," linking to his article defending *free inquiry* into the topic. Merely defending free inquiry into the cause of race differences is apparently racist according to the NYT.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Hell - we can just look at how Cambridge treated Nathan Cofnas.
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
To understand just how irredeemably messed up academia is, compare the differences in how Cambridge treated Jason Arday and how Harvard treated Roland Fryer.
One is a black sociologist; the other is a black economist.
At this point, we are all very well acquainted with Jason Arday’s insane fabrications, plagiarism, and less-than-stellar research record. Yet he became the youngest black professor in Cambridge’s history at 37.
Now look at the case of Roland Fryer.
He produced rigorous, data-driven research, published extensively, and ran a major institute (EdLabs) at Harvard.
He doggedly pursued the truth on one of the most charged questions in American public life. His landmark 2016 study titled “An Empirical Analysis of Racial Differences in Police Use of Force” examined millions of encounters and officer-involved shootings.
It found that there were no racial differences in the raw data or after controlling for circumstances. In some datasets (notably Houston), blacks were actually less likely to be shot once the encounter was underway.
As you know, this finding directly contradicted Black Lives Matter’s core orthodoxy that police systematically and disproportionately kill Black men out of racial animus. It was not only in vogue at the time; it was literally religion.
Roland Fryer and his data were guilty of blasphemy.
Harvard launched investigations into allegations of verbal sexual harassment and a hostile work environment in his lab. The process produced a two-year unpaid suspension, the permanent shutdown of EdLabs, and severe restrictions on his ability to advise or supervise.
All this was investigated by a kangaroo court under Title IX. The recommendation for his alleged failings was sensitivity training, yet a faculty panel escalated it into career-crippling punishment. Fryer has said he was unfairly targeted because of the political inconvenience of his results.
The contrast between how the academy treated these two men shows you how deep the moral rot is. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ann Coulter
@AnnCoulter
<<Ivy League universities (plural) tried to recruit him, but he had his heart set on Oxford or Cambridge.>>
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The Atlantic reads Jason Arday's memoir, and finds his life story was even more inspirational than we thought
He was beaten so badly as a teen he became an epileptic. When the boys who did this were caught, he magnanimously told the judge he didn't want them to go to prison.
"By the time Arday started on his master's degree, he writes, he was reading at about the same level as his 3-year-old daughter."
You complain you can't get a girlfriend.
Chad Arday was going through college illiterate, had his girlfriend write out his applications, and managed to father a child.
He then got a teaching job. But he didn't have money, so he started working at a supermarket from 11 PM to 5AM, then a cleaner from 5:30 AM to 7:30 AM.
Remember the guys who beat him up? It turns out that two of the muggers ended up being his students. They were so moved by his compassion, that they'd turned their lives around and were now helping at risk youth.
As his dissertation approached, Arday got a brain tumor and lost his memory.
"More troubles follow in the years ahead: Arday’s brain tumor returns; he splits up with his wife; he suffers autistic burnout during the coronavirus pandemic and can’t get out of bed. He decides to kill himself by jumping off a bridge, but at the very last minute, he listens to his favorite song."
The author of the piece writes: "I reached out to the book’s fact-checker to ask whether this and several other stories from the book had been verified, but she did not respond."
The Atlantic also got its hands on his book proposal. There are even more incredible stories in it. As a teenager, Arday got hit by a car and went into a coma. The doctor told his parents to pull the plug, but he refused. There's also a bout of testicular cancer that shows up in the proposal but is not in the book.
I guess there wasn't enough room for all of that given all of the other amazing stories in his life.
Oh, and the book isn't being pulled. Simon & Schuster are still going to publish it next week. The haters are just one more obstacle Arday has overcome. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Trans violence is real.
Investigating this secretive trans death cult took me back to America. It put my life at risk again.
Hormones. Human experimentation. Swords. Guns. Bodies.
This is the true story of the Zizians.
ON SALE OCT. 13. PRE-ORDER NOW. www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/andy-ngo/the-zizians/978…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Never forget that @Cambridge_Uni defended disgraced DEI Prof Jason Arday's plagiarism and said he was “the victim of a vile campaign."
Prof Hilary Cremin, the dean and head of faculty, said this on record about Arday: "You are the best in the world in terms of the research you do."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
ripx4nutmeg
@ripx4nutmeg
The BBC covers the Jason Arday resignation.
There's no mention of a single lie he told, him reporting critics to the police or his links to Labour or the BBC, and no example of his plagiarism or poor writing is given.
But one of his whistleblowers' views on race is given. Twice -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve Sailer
@Steve_Sailer
New on SteveSailer . Net
[no paywall on this post] --
Does Nathan Cofnas Now Get Jason Arday's Cambridge Professorship?
Dr. Arday just resigned, so Dr. Cofnas replacing him at Cambridge would only be fair under the ancient rules of academic combat.
www.stevesailer.net/p/does-nathan-cofnas-now-get-jason -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Jason Arday's resignation letter
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rich Lowry
@RichLowry
Cofnas did the work to expose an academic fraud, and was treated like the villain of the piece
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Game over
Now I'd like to hear from the @Cambridge_Uni administrators who said this was a "vile campaign" against a "world-class scholar" -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
RE-OPEN THE SIZZLERS
@SaladBarFan
“Nathan Cofnas was right. Race science is real.”
-Cambridge University
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Game over
Now I'd like to hear from the @Cambridge_Uni administrators who said this was a "vile campaign" against a "world-class scholar" -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Arday resigns!
Someone give Cofnas a job. This is really impressive work.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Game over
Now I'd like to hear from the @Cambridge_Uni administrators who said this was a "vile campaign" against a "world-class scholar" -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Kind of funny how determined @Telegraph is to steal credit for a story about plagiarism
@gordonrayner
@AlbertTait1 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Game over
Now I'd like to hear from the @Cambridge_Uni administrators who said this was a "vile campaign" against a "world-class scholar" -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Cofnas holds views on racial differences in intelligence within the mainstream of scholarly debate-- that would have a fair summary for NYT to have reported.
I wrote a letter defending Cofnas to a Cambridge committee investigating him; here is the great Jim Flynn on the issue:
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The only person explicitly smeared in the NY Times' write-up of the Arday affair is me
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
This American academic who was forced out of @Cambridge_Uni was the first to publicly call out Cambridge’s celebrity Prof Jason Arday as a DEI fraud. Even newspapers weren’t willing to expose Arday because they were afraid of being sued after he hired a top legal firm to respond.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
It's time to stop considering "racist" a smear.
"Racist", as used by the corporate press, just means "correct".
It's a compliment!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The only person explicitly smeared in the NY Times' write-up of the Arday affair is me
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve Sailer
@Steve_Sailer
New on SteveSailer . Net --
NYT Finally Mentions Jason Arday
Is Arday a plagiarist and fantasist? Maybe, maybe not, says the New York Times. The one thing it knows for sure, however, is that Nathan Cofnas is a racist.
www.stevesailer.net/p/nyt-finally-mentions-jason-arday -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
Every time you think that maybe the NYT is trying to right the ship, you get new evidence that it's no longer a newspaper. It's National Enquirer for Upper West Side.
For those of you who aren't familiar with @nathancofnas, he's never written anything that is remotely racist. Unless you think that facts can be racist.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The only person explicitly smeared in the NY Times' write-up of the Arday affair is me
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"We have a situation where the right is demonstrably 100% correct and the left is 100% wrong, so really there's no way to have a sensible discussion."
Interesting analysis in @nytimes -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The only person explicitly smeared in the NY Times' write-up of the Arday affair is me
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Accused plagiarist and accused serial liar Jason Arday, a black studies celebrity DEI professor at @Cambridge_Uni, says in his Jesus College profile that he is a visiting professor at Glasgow University. However, the university said he never held a visiting professorship there. www.heraldscotland.com/news/26433564.glasgow-university-d…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Timur Kuran
@timurkuran
Arday joins Kendi and Gay as a symbol of DEI’s obsession with race over merit. He’s been lionized despite clear intellectual mediocrity. That’s why the backlash is so fierce. Cases this blatant embolden people who stay silent on smaller DEI abuses and inefficiencies.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Media coverage is leaving out a big part of the Jason Arday scandal, namely, his work that *isn't* plagiarized looks like this ⬇️ ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Yuan Yi Zhu
@yuanyi_z
Lester accused me of racism and tried to destroy my career when I gave his book a bad review, in large part because I called out one of his contributors for minimising Nazi crimes. An extended period of voluntary silence from him would be welcome.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Ask yourself how a university would react if an academic employee who was a darling of the right were caught engaging in a series of equivalent lies and subsequently attributed it to his autism. It’s a trite “what if the sides were reversed” but still illuminating to consider.
Freddie Sayers
@freddiesayers
“He attributed some errors in his early academic work to his autism, saying that his method of making sense of information relied heavily on mimicry.”
New defence against plagiarism charges just dropped, care of Jason Arday in Sunday’s @thetimes
www.thetimes.com/article/fdd5c748-002c-4ec4-a299-16f2f273… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Timothy Bates
@timothycbates
So, now, Cambridge, give @nathancofnas a chair in philosophy.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Prof Ian Pace
@drianpace
This is incredible. Go from about 5'20" to hear Arday's claims of being part of Seven Up. The main series was for those who were 7 in 1964. There was an 'Up New Generation' which started with those who were 7 in 2000. But Arday was born in 1985.
This really is Walter Mitty stuff.Colonel Flanders 🇺🇦🏴
This video is revealing. A few minutes in, Jason Arday claims to have been part of the "Seven up!" project and was followed through his youth. Seven Up subjects were born in 1964.....
www.youtube.com/watch?v=8vZFY14oCpE -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
.@Cambridge_Uni is standing by DEI “anti-racist” academic fraudster Jason Arday but had canceled and forced out another academic who was the one to reveal the plagiarism in Arday’s work.
@nathancofnas was also smeared and viciously targeted for citing Harvard’s research showing that there would be almost no blacks in elite education without raced-based preferential selection. ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Toby Young
@toadmeister
Are congratulations due to Sacha Baron Cohen? In the @spectator, I explore the possibility that Jason Arday, the Cambridge professor and DEI poster boy engulfed in a plagiarism scandal, is in reality the comedian's latest creation. If it's a spoof designed to highlight the credulousness and double standards of do-gooding liberals, it's succeeded beyond Baron Cohen's wildest dreams. spectator.com/article/professor-arday-is-the-gift-that-ke…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Very self-aware professor @enzoreds: When people realize Cofnas was right about the plagiarism, they might wonder if his “race science crap” was unfairly dismissed. Also, “I haven’t read Cofnas’s paper so I don’t know” and, like, isn't there a “consensus” that NC is wrong?
Enzo Rossi
@enzoreds
Here’s a problem. Cofnas, the guy who exposed Arday, is a sneaky racist. He publishes race/IQ junk alongside regular, technical philosophy. Now if academics reject Cofnas’s seemingly clearcut plagiarism case against Arday off hand, they lend credibility to his race science crap.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Jason Arday should NOT be fired. He was hired to represent DEI, and he’s doing a great job.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeff Blehar is *BOX OFFICE POISON*
@EsotericCD
I wrote a long piece about the newest fraudulent delight in academia, Cambridge University's critical race "prodigy" Jason Arday.
The latest - and it's ugly - at @NRO: -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
The whole thing is exceedingly silly. He is obviously a liar and a fraud. I'm not sure it could be more obvious.
Cambridge is one of the oldest and most acclaimed universities in the world. It is the university of Newton and Darwin.
Why would they be so idiotic as to damage their reputation in this way? Yes, I understand it is for DEI reasons, but still.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Simon Baron-Cohen signed this crazy woman's Arday plagiarism denial petition! The other signatories are idiots, so no explanation needed. But I don't get Baron-Cohen. He needs to study his own brain.
Good Law Project
@GoodLawProject
Jason Arday is the youngest Black professor in Cambridge’s history – and now rightwing newspapers are trying to smear him with untrue accusations of plagiarism.
Not on our watch. Add your name in solidarity with Jason here: goodlaw.social/sktjThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
And now you understand why I detest socialists. They're all about love and kindness. Until you disagree with them and you discover who these ppl really are.
Andrea 🇮🇹🇪🇺
@ClassicalSocdem
Now I understand why your parents abandoned you
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Michael Tracey
@mtracey
Just an absolute open-and-shut case of systematic plagiarism. Pretty amazing. His actual "voice," to the degree it can even be discerned, reads like a 2021 right-wing parody of a vacuous DEI academic. And he was just appointed full professor at Cambridge!
ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Carter-Ruck is the fearsome law firm that Arday/Cambridge used to intimidate journalists into not reporting on his plagiarism
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Alternative conclusion:
Leftists who covered up the fraud with lies and legal intimidation are the bad guys, not the "radical right" that told the truth
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
After Jason Arday enlisted Carter-Ruck, one of the United Kingdom’s leading defamation law firms, to send @timeshighered a letter, the publication spiked the story, according to three sources who spoke to Retraction Watch.
retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/cambridge-jason-arday-plag… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
The University of Cambridge is engaging in a level of corruption and harassment of journalists you simply don't see all that often, and I say that as someone who has reported regularly on campus controversies. I don't understand what their endgame is here.
retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/cambridge-jason-arday-plag… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
We can literally see the plagiarism with our eyes
1/10 cover-up attempt by Cambridge
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
After Jason Arday enlisted Carter-Ruck, one of the United Kingdom’s leading defamation law firms, to send @timeshighered a letter, the publication spiked the story, according to three sources who spoke to Retraction Watch.
retractionwatch.com/2026/07/27/cambridge-jason-arday-plag… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
arctotherium
@arctotherium42
Cambridge: black professors cannot be expected to understand concepts such as "plagiarism" and "doing any sort of scholarship at all." Holding them to such standards would be like bringing back segregation.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Joanna Williams
@jowilliams293
By me: The over-promotion of Jason Arday reveals how DEI has corrupted even our most august institutions.
www.spiked-online.com/2026/07/27/woke-privilege-still-rei… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gregory Connor
@gregoryconnor11
The Jason Arday imbroglio at Cambridge is a classic embodiment of Cofnas’s theory of Woke lunacy. The fundamental cause of the shortage of Black professors at Cambridge is the one standard deviation offset in the bell curve distributions of general cognitive ability between African vs. Eurasian ancestry groups. This distributional offset generates an extreme proportional difference in the upper tail of scores, which is the cognitive ability subset from which all full professors are carefully selected. The one-standard deviation offset in bell curves is caused by genetic variation between African and Eurasian ancestry groups; the same kind of genetic variation that makes the groups visibly distinguishable. Avoiding this Princess’s Pea of reality requires a mile-high pile of mattresses to smother it. No one dares mention the scientific reality of genetic variation between ancestries and its impact on bell curve tail distributions, and in the ensuing public information chaos, Cambridge chooses an African-ancestry fabulist with an incredibly poor research record as a full professor. This incident exposes a metastasizing rot in Western institutions arising from our inability to absorb the reality of human biodiversity into public consciousness.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
The list of stuff that Good Will Hunting here got away with claiming is truly amazing.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Arday claims he played football and snooker professionally. He went on a professional snooker tour at age 10—a year before he learned how to speak.
White liberals hear this and think it is real! -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Arday claims he played football and snooker professionally. He went on a professional snooker tour at age 10—a year before he learned how to speak.
White liberals hear this and think it is real! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Dionysus
@DionLeFou
In 2023 the @BBCNews ran a video story on Jason Arday joining @Cambridge_Uni. This is how his new boss described hiring him. Did they even look at any of his work?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Every time you think academia has hit rock bottom, you read something like this, from the prestigious @Cambridge_Uni. If you'll excuse me now, I need to go pick my jaw up off the floor.
(Please bracket whatever you think about @nathancofnas and his views on IQ & race, which are irrelevant here).
ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge?r=g844x… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
A lot of academic writing sounds like what happens when you teach a precocious pet parrot big words.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Media coverage is leaving out a big part of the Jason Arday scandal, namely, his work that *isn't* plagiarized looks like this ⬇️ ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Media coverage is leaving out a big part of the Jason Arday scandal, namely, his work that *isn't* plagiarized looks like this ⬇️ ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is an outright lie. Arday has never been investigated, let alone "cleared...of any wrongdoing." You can see the plagiarism with your own eyes. Cambridge administrators stated in private correspondence that they refuse to investigate.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Zero respect left for Simon Baron-Cohen
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is exactly how I picture my critics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
21group
@21percentgroup
Plagiarism concerns about Professor Jason Arday have been raised by @nathancofnas
If research standards fail, training & oversight are essential for academic integrity & professional development
Cambridge didn't do this, it dismissed the concerns
21percent.org?p=2708 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
James Price
@jamespriceglos
A jaw-dropping investigation & ironically given the subject matter, @nathancofnas has the research to back up his claims.
It raises serious questions about @Cambridge_Uni’s commitment to academic excellence, especially the idea that claimed racist abuse excuse blatant plagiarism.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Prof Ian Pace
@drianpace
This is incredibly shocking - do read it in detail.
ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jerry Z. Muller
@jerryzmuller
A remarkable account of DEI at Cambridge.
"When you take away the work that is plagiarized or not otherwise written by Arday, there is essentially nothing resembling real scholarship. There is no indication that Arday is familiar with even elementary statistics. His research involves reporting his own experiences of alleged racism or having conversations with people and providing subjective commentary."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Russell T. Warne 🇺🇸🇨🇱
@Russwarne
New academic fraud accusation just dropped.
"When you take away the work that is plagiarized or not otherwise written by Arday, there is essentially nothing resembling real scholarship. There is no indication that Arday is familiar with even elementary statistics. His research involves reporting his own experiences of alleged racism or having conversations with people and providing subjective commentary."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
This seems pretty damning and is a wild story. I think when universities and other institutions explicitly admit ot hiring people to promote specific political projects, outcomes like this are inevitable.
ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gregory Connor
@gregoryconnor11
This appears to be a truly shocking abuse of DEI loopholes by Cambridge University. What happens next? A BBC expose' ?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
Thorough reporting on academic malpractice at Cambridge.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
DEI Fraud and Cover-Up: ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge
It’s an open secret at Cambridge University, but everyone is afraid to speak out. Newspapers backed away after getting hit with legal threats.
Here, I tell the true story of Jason Arday—DEI superstar and the youngest black professor in the history of Cambridge. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Race denial seems compassionate. Why make people feel bad by telling them their group has a lower average score because nature is unfair?
But this is the inevitable result. Low scores must be someone's *fault*—usually white people, but in this case the lazy, mafioso teachers.
Coleman Hughes
@coldxman
So let's figure out how to get more Black kids to ace the exam! Of course, that might require making teachers work harder or smarter, an idea that the teachers' mafia––ahem sorry, teachers' union––would resist.
Lincoln Restler
@LincolnRestler
1 in 5 NYC public school students are Black, but at Stuy - our most prestigious high school - 3 of ~800 incoming Freshmen are Black.
We urgently need state legislation to modify the admissions process. A single test should never be only factor deciding who gets in & who doesn’t. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Administrators at UGent are giving anti-Cofnas PPT presentations.
This slide says that "Students Against Cofnas" (a group created to harass me) filed a complaint saying there's a "lack of a sense of safety as well as a general negative impact on well-being" because I am here. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
This podcast with @nathancofnas from @AporiaMagazine is bonkers.
Cofnas was physically assaulted because they don’t like hos academic research, and got a concussion. The perpetrator is known and the incident is on video. But the authorities do nothing. The university does nothing. Other than publish a report criticizing Cofnas.
This is truly depressing and embarrassing. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aporia Magazine
@AporiaMagazine
Noah is joined by @nathancofnas to discuss the extraordinary backlash to Nathan's appointment at Ghent University. www.aporiamagazine.com/p/podcast-the-future-of-wokeness
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ghost of Atticus
@Ghostof_Atticus
Cut the shit.
This is totally bullshit and has been exposed by @nathancofnas
The Hereditarian hypothesis is true and people can run away from it for only so long.
ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In February I stopped by the philosophy department for around 10 minutes. Four months later, there is an investigation into how I caused lasting “collective ill-being.” Leftists unable to work, must spend all day writing long reports about how much they dislike me.
Astrid Elbers
@AstridElbers
Waarom de aanstelling van Nathan Cofnas aan de Ugent geen 'doorgestoken kaart' was, maar juist een uiterst zorgvuldige en uitgebreide procedure: @nathancofnas @ugent doorbraak.be/nee-de-aanstelling-van-nathan-cofnas-aan-de-…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Arguably the most famous American Jewish comedian under 40 bragging that AI can never be as racist as she is and making jokes about Somali IQ.
I've been saying for years...the Jewish stereotype will have to catch up with the fact that the under 40s are mostly this or Hasidic.
Arynne Wexler
@ArynneWexler
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Twilight of the Liberal Jew": thecritic.co.uk/twilight-of-the-liberal-jew/
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andrew Fox
@Mr_Andrew_Fox
Sam Harris has written the best thing you’ll read today.
open.substack.com/pub/samharris/p/why-i-wont-debate-criti… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Rufo and DeSantis weren’t paying attention for 5 minutes, and the University of Florida is about to appoint a DEI fanatic as president.
“We’ve passed peak woke” is a delusion held by people who live in a right-wing X bubble. Elites and young people are woker than ever.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
Hopefully you will benefit from left-wing factionalism, with "Students Against Cofnas" splintering into several rival groups, each of which considers the others to be Cofnas-adjacent sellouts.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
According to the Brussels Times, there is a student group at UGent called "Students Against Cofnas"
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@tylercowen argues that wokism has been “replaced.” Instead of cancel culture and pronouns (woke), the left resorts to assassinations and wealth confiscation.
This confuses *tactics* with *ideology*.
Wokism says that all groups are innately the same, therefore disparities must be the result of injustice, i.e., white wickedness. Elites and most young people still believe that! But 10 years of Twitter mobs, pronouns, and tearing down statues didn’t bring about equality—in fact, it just provoked a chud backlash. So wokesters are experimenting with violence and Third Worldism. When that fails, they will try something else.
Wokism is a rational response to the false empirical belief in group sameness. As long as race denial remains the orthodox view, wokism (in some incarnation) will be the dominant ideology among people who are smart enough to understand its logic. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bit Paine ⚡️
@BitPaine
Let’s put this in terms you would understand:
90-95th %-ile is about the level of a good high school varsity basketball player
99th %-ile is about the level of an all-state high school basketball player
99.9th %-ile is about the level of an average NCAA D1 basketball player.
99.99th %-ile is about the level of an NCAA final four starter
99.9999th %-ile is about the level of an average NBA player
99.999999th %-ile is about the level of a top 10-20 NBA player
what you are proposing is the academic equivalent of taking a team of black Final Four-calibre NCAA basketball players and deciding that we need equal representation so we should toss in some white/asian students who are about as good as the average high school varsity player and that’s just as good.
TLDR: you understand percentiles about as well as the people you think belong at Yale Law school along with the most elite students in the country. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
"After accepting a job at Cambridge on the promise of free speech, I was betrayed the moment the administration determined that free speech was inconvenient for them. I was effectively driven off campus with threats of violence against me brushed off as not a big deal. I was forced to resign from my paid position as undergraduate examiner."
In 2020, the University of Cambridge issued a statement on freedom of speech which said: "The University will ensure that staff are able to exercise freedom of thought and expression within the law without placing themselves at risk of losing their job or any University privileges and benefits they have."
Yet this was not the case for Nathan Cofnas. As Dr Cofnas says, many universities make lofty expressions of support for free speech and academic freedom — but the reality is very different.
Dr Cofnas, a member of the university's Faculty of Philosophy, is at the centre of a legal battle over a controversial blog post he wrote about race and genetics; he also had his research affiliation with Emmanuel College terminated separately.
Nathan's blog post prompted outcry on campus after being reported in the student newspaper. A petition denouncing him as "bigoted" and a "eugenicist" and calling for his termination soon gained over 1,000 signatures. Threats of campus protests followed, and he began to receive threats of violence privately.
The University of Cambridge defended his right to academic freedom and exonarated him, but Emmanuel College claimed that he had breached its Diversity, Equality and Inclusion guidelines.
The Free Speech Union has supported Dr Cofnas throughout and helped him bring legal action against Emmanuel College for belief discrimination under the Equality Act 2010.
While Cofnas lost at the County Court, the fight is not over. The Free Speech Union is supporting Dr Cofnas in appealing the decision at the High Court.
Read Nathan's story in his own words below 👇 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@WSJ story about race doesn't mention the word "race"
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Francesca Minerva
@FranciMinerva
"The most obvious lesson is that Cambridge is not a free speech university, and anyone with controversial views would be a fool to accept a job there. There are also broader lessons about the state of free speech in academia in general"
ncofnas.com/p/cambridge-universitys-war-on-free -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maya Forstater
@MForstater
"We now have the absurd situation where the limits of philosophical inquiry are set by the most emotionally fragile students at each university." (despite high level commitments to academic freedom)
Nathan Cofnas - who lost his belief discrimination case against Cambridge University and is appealing.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“Students know that if they repeat certain formulas—‘Professor X traumatized me’, ‘I can’t work because X is here’, ‘Professor X erased my existence’—the administration will treat it as an emergency that overrides any written policy.” ncofnas.com/p/cambridge-universitys-war-on-free
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Great insider view on the insane asylum that is Cambridge University.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“Students know that if they repeat certain formulas—‘Professor X traumatized me’, ‘I can’t work because X is here’, ‘Professor X erased my existence’—the administration will treat it as an emergency that overrides any written policy.” ncofnas.com/p/cambridge-universitys-war-on-free
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
David Gress
@DavidGr08051597
Important and significant first-person report on how one of the formerly great seats of learning has become a den of gutless pygmies of both sexes when it comes to upholding elementary principles of scholarship and free debate.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“Students know that if they repeat certain formulas—‘Professor X traumatized me’, ‘I can’t work because X is here’, ‘Professor X erased my existence’—the administration will treat it as an emergency that overrides any written policy.” ncofnas.com/p/cambridge-universitys-war-on-free
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“Students know that if they repeat certain formulas—‘Professor X traumatized me’, ‘I can’t work because X is here’, ‘Professor X erased my existence’—the administration will treat it as an emergency that overrides any written policy.” ncofnas.com/p/cambridge-universitys-war-on-free
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
𝗖𝗮𝘁 שושנה 🎀🧃
@CatShoshanna
Lenin in one hand, Cartier on the other.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alex Strudwick Young
@AlexTISYoung
Given the over-performance of smaller countries like Romania without generally amazing educational results — but where kids are streamed and coached into olympiad tracks — this would suggest a lot more kids have the raw ability than actually make the teams.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
I agree. Which makes the current stats on Sephardi/Ashkenazi IQ puzzling. What caused a selective drop, if indeed that's what we're looking at? Just intermarriage? But presumably genomics will untangle it eventually.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I think high average Jewish IQ may predate the Sephardi/Ashkenazi split.
Sephardim had Ashkenazi-level achievement in Spain. Italian Jews (who belong to a third group) dominated journalism and were wildly overrepresented in academia, the upper echelons of the military, and other high-status professions. When Sephardim came to Britain in the 18th century they produced figures like David Ricardo and Benjamin Disraeli. Maimonides and Moses de León (author of the Zohar) were Sephardim. Moshe Chaim Luzzatto (arguably the most important religious philosopher besides Maimonides) was Italian. Spinoza—the most important pre-20th century secular Jewish philosopher—was Sephardi.
There were historically unique opportunities to manifest genius in early 20th-century America and Western Europe. By that time, the Sephardic population had been decimated through intermarriage (they started mass intermarrying 100 years before Ashkenazim) and the bulk of the population was concentrated in the Ottoman Empire.
Would Einstein have come up with the theory of special relativity if he had been running around Istanbul wearing a fez? Hard to say.
Hopefully will be resolved with ancient DNA. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I think high average Jewish IQ may predate the Sephardi/Ashkenazi split.
Sephardim had Ashkenazi-level achievement in Spain. Italian Jews (who belong to a third group) dominated journalism and were wildly overrepresented in academia, the upper echelons of the military, and other high-status professions. When Sephardim came to Britain in the 18th century they produced figures like David Ricardo and Benjamin Disraeli. Maimonides and Moses de León (author of the Zohar) were Sephardim. Moshe Chaim Luzzatto (arguably the most important religious philosopher besides Maimonides) was Italian. Spinoza—the most important pre-20th century secular Jewish philosopher—was Sephardi.
There were historically unique opportunities to manifest genius in early 20th-century America and Western Europe. By that time, the Sephardic population had been decimated through intermarriage (they started mass intermarrying 100 years before Ashkenazim) and the bulk of the population was concentrated in the Ottoman Empire.
Would Einstein have come up with the theory of special relativity if he had been running around Istanbul wearing a fez? Hard to say.
Hopefully will be resolved with ancient DNA. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Who does hate speech law protect? Well, in Denmark the prosecutor's office has an overview, a summary of every case since 2001 or so. The targets of the utterances that led to guilty verdicts are shown below.
Thus, only 1 case of 142 protected Danes, and it was kinda incidental because the guy was insulting Danes and Jews combined, apparently because he was angry about Gaza getting rekt by Israel.
I expect results would be similar for other western countries. These laws are pernicious, only protect minorities, despite ostensibly being neutrally formulated. You can basically smear Danes in Denmark as much as you want as long as you don't do it because they are gay. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Where's the graph showing all the non-wokesters who were actually hired? Oh wait, it doesn't exist.
Forcing universities to tone down DEI rhetoric at gunpoint didn't change anyone's ideology.
The "vibe shift" exists only in the minds of rightists who live in an X bubble. According to a survey that ran from Aug 2025-Feb 2026, young American men age 18-29 are more liberal than ever (39% lib vs 25% con).
Kamala "stay woke" Harris won voters with advanced degrees by 21 points. If anything, elites are now even more committed to wokism, having seen that the alternative is DEI for hillbillies, economic illiteracy, and defunding cancer research.
The only elite community that is permanently de-wokified are the tech bros, because they are hereditarians. Everyone else is quietly seething and plotting their revenge, which they will probably exact in 2028.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“In 2024, 13.4% of faculty job ads required a dedicated DEI statement. By 2025, that figure had fallen to just 2.5%.”
I told you it all came down to civil rights law.
One year difference, like night and day. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Livingstone (MilkBarTV)
@TheMilkBarTV
The best of Megyn Kelly’s flip-flops, hypocrisy, and expert-level grifting.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Chris Rufo totally dunked on this stay-at-home mother of 5 who used to teach at her neighborhood college.
(She had the audacity to suggest that Rufo doesn't have "the deepest understanding of what a university is for.")
This is what winning looks like.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Chris Rufo is a grifter who is leading the right to disaster. His alleged victories against wokism are almost entirely imaginary.
Whenever someone criticizes Rufo, he likes to compare his track record to theirs. In his own words, these are the highlights of his career:
“We broke BLM, CRT, Kendi, Gay, etc., and my conversations with the New York Times over the past five years, which are a good proxy for elite consensus, have shifted very favorably in our direction, meaning that those ‘elites’ sense we have damaged woke and reduced its relative status. We’ve also set the stage for the president to defund the Left, tame the universities, abolish DEI, and rescind affirmative action.”
Let’s examine these claims one by one, and then consider why the right always loses in the end.
Helping the Left Take Out Its Own Trash
A couple years ago, Rufo helped get Harvard’s DEI President Claudine Gay booted on the pretext of plagiarism. As I predicted would happen, she was simply replaced by someone worse. Under the more effective leadership of Alan Garber, Harvard continues to flout the Supreme Court’s ruling against affirmative action, and it is spearheading the resistance to Trump.
The Left Has Moral and Intellectual Standards
At the height of the Great Awokening, Ibram X. Kendi was the doyen of DEI. Kendi (whose SAT scores barely cracked 1000) gave us insights such as defining “racism” as “a collection of racist policies that lead to racial inequity that are substantiated by racist ideas.” He received a MacArthur Fellowship (aka “genius grant”) and set his speaking fee to $35,000 an hour. In July 2020 he became the founding director of the Center for Antiracist Research at Boston University funded by $55 million in donations.
After several years, Kendi’s Center for Antiracist Research failed to produce anything resembling research. He fired half of his staff because the money had disappeared to who-knows-where. The whole operation was shut down in 2025. Kendi left BU and now directs the so-called Institute for Advanced Study at Howard University.
The fall of Kendi is a testament to the left’s capacity for self-correction, not evidence that it is in retreat. (I’m not sure what role Rufo thinks “anti-woke” reporting had in any of this, but it makes no difference either way.) The right would never have a Kendi scandal because a right-wing Kendi would never be held accountable. Can you think of a single example in recent history where a right-wing leader was marginalized for stupidity or grifting? If the right held its leaders accountable for these things, almost everyone would be gone (including Rufo).
BLM Lives On
After gaining steam from several hoaxes such as the Michael Brown “hands up, don’t shoot” incident, BLM reached its high point after the death of George Floyd in the summer of 2020. The movement was unofficially led by the Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation (BLMGNF), which, in 2020, received more than $90 million in donations.
BLMGNF was run like Zimbabwe. Its leaders paid themselves lavish salaries. They funneled large sums of money to their friends and family. Director Patrisse Cullors’s baby daddy was paid $970,000 for “creative services.” Cullors resigned her position at BLMGNF when her private purchase of more than $3 million in real estate attracted scrutiny. The left-wing New York Magazine broke the story that BLMGNF secretly bought a house for $6 million, apparently for private use by senior members of the organization. Local BLM chapters faced similar scandals.
Rufo can gloat about how embarrassing this was for the left. But the left exposed corruption on its own side and took measures to fix the problem without retreating from its ideological goals.
BLM attracted a flurry of support, then started going off the rails due to corruption and purity spirals. The left-wing establishment responded by quietly switching its focus to institutional capture so it can wield real power instead of just burning down police stations.
CRT Didn’t Go Anywhere
“Critical Race Theory” is a fancy name for the idea that racial disparities favoring whites are caused by past or present racism. It is simply the philosophy that follows from taking the equality thesis (all races have the same innate distribution of socially relevant traits) seriously.
Rufo played a role in passing legislation in some Republican-controlled states to prohibit educators from teaching CRT. Having anti-CRT laws on the books makes it marginally easier to push back against the most noxious expressions of anti-whitism. But elites remain committed to CRT, whether they call it CRT or something else like “American history.” Children spend seven hours a day, five days a week at school. As long as educators remain overwhelmingly left and woke, they are going to find a way to impart their beliefs to students.
Elite Consensus
Nothing happening at the New York Times indicates that “elite consensus [has] shifted very favorably in our direction.” Some mainstream left-wing outlets have recently expressed cautious skepticism about mutilating “trans” children. But gender theory is philosophically and historically separate from wokism. I always said there could be a backlash against it. The Times has not backed one inch away from the idea that all groups of people are on average the same and we need to strive for equality of outcome.
How the Left Actually Won
Howard Zinn was the author of A People’s History of the United States, which sold more than two million copies and played a major role in radicalizing American education. In 1967, the political science department at Boston University voted to award him tenure. However, its recommendation had to be approved by the trustees, who were scheduled to meet for the annual Founders Day banquet. Zinn then accepted some students’ invitation to speak at an anti-war rally, not knowing that the purpose of the rally was to protest Secretary of State Dean Rusk...who had been invited to speak at the Founders Day banquet! But he did not pull out. On the same day the trustees were voting on his tenure case, Zinn gave a 45-minute speech railing against their honored guest, the government, and America’s founders. He went home assuming he would be fired. Unbeknownst to him, the trustees had already voted to approve his tenure before the banquet.
Bill Ayers spent time in jail.
Noam Chomsky’s wife went to college so she would be able to support the family when her husband got what they expected would be a long prison sentence.
For 70 years, the woke project has inspired commitment from a large proportion of intelligent and idealistic people. That’s why the ideology prevailed. There was no conspiratorial “long march through the institutions.” As long as they believe that all groups are on average innately the same, intelligent, morally sensitive people will recognize that there is a moral emergency to correct the environment and bring about equality of outcome. Insofar as society is a meritocracy, institutions staffed by qualified individuals will spontaneously wokify.
In a revealing moment, Chris Rufo mocked me for being fired from Cambridge for talking about hereditarianism. (In fact I wasn’t fired from Cambridge, but leave that aside.) For Rufo the nihilist, the idea of sacrificing your immediate self-interest on behalf of a worthy cause is incomprehensible. He and his fellow trolls only know how to kick their opponents when they are down—a strategy that, besides being dishonorable, is generally ineffective in the long run, when eventually your enemy (perhaps Gavin Newsom?) gets up and starts kicking you.
The right may have the political power to defund cancer research, but it is currently not a position to retake the institutions and run them effectively. Note that, even with virtually unlimited funding, the right-wing University of Austin (UATX) is teaching college students middle-school-level algebra and appears to be on the verge of shutting down. To defeat race communism, it will be necessary to persuade a critical mass of liberal elites to join the right. Holding up people like Rufo as representatives of anti-wokism is pushing these potential allies—and therefore real victory—further and further away. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Six months after I published "Beating Woke with Facts and Logic," Harvard researchers declared an HBD paradigm shift in Nature.
The fact that Reich et al. plagiarized internet race scientists only reinforces my point. Liberal elites are open to reason and evidence.
Davide Piffer
@DavidePiffer
Reich's team is now framing their publication as a paradigm shift, nobody had published such results before (wrong). Reich also appropriated my idea that these results challenge the standard view of no selection over 100K years, which I criticized here: davidepiffer.com/p/there-was-never-a-sapient-paradox
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Recent selection for cognitive ability in Western Eurasians has nothing to do with race differences in intelligence. Harvard says so.
Richárd
@krichard121212
Meanwhile in reality the lab members of Reich are reposting Sasha Gusev's tweets...
So maybe, just maybe hereditarians are misrepresenting the results and the views of the authors.
Amazing -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There are two hypotheses:
Hypothesis (1): When Eric Turkheimer wrote in 2007 that “it is a matter of ethical principle that individual and cultural accomplishment is not tied to the genes in the same way as the appearance of our hair,” he meant what it sounds like. Biological facts must align with liberal boomers’ idea of justice.
Hypothesis (2): In 2007, Turkheimer actually meant what he says in his 2018 article: “our ethical evaluation of human differences depends not on the fact that they are correlated with genes (they are heritable), but instead on HOW they are related to genes.” Traits related to individual and cultural accomplishment, such as IQ, are influenced by choices we make. Therefore, they can be subject to ethical evaluation. In contrast, “groups of people with a certain kind of hair just are the way they are,” therefore we make no ethical evaluation of hair color.
I believe the evidence strongly points to (1).
Some people are skeptical about (1) because the view expressed is so absurd and indefensible. Even if Turkheimer believed that ethics trumps science, he wouldn’t say this out loud. He would have realized that he was discrediting himself and setting himself up to be ridiculed.
I don’t think this is a strong objection to (1). People often fail in surprising ways to anticipate how others will react to their private thoughts. For example, Kelly Osbourne once criticized Trump’s immigration policy by asking the following rhetorical question: “If you kick every Latino out of this country, then who is going to be cleaning your toilet, Donald Trump?” In Osbourne’s mind, toilet cleaning is a job that is done only by Latinos, and she thought it was a good idea to state this publicly, not realizing how people would react.
This isn’t a problem only for reality-TV-star high-school dropouts. New York Times op-ed columnist Maureen Dowd once wrote an article describing how she regularly makes Uber drivers wait for her. Dowd’s solution to her low passenger rating was “to start working to charm,” for example, by asking a driver “Your husband likes oysters?” or “What are the kids up to this summer?” This article wasn’t an off-the-cuff remark. It was written by a celebrated writer and went through a rigorous editorial process at the world’s leading newspaper. A whole team of assistants and editors—not to mention Dowd herself—didn’t anticipate that people would make fun of Dowd for not realizing that she could improve her Uber rating by showing up on time.
This is just to neutralize an objection to (1). It doesn’t show that (1) is right. For that you have to look at the text of Turkheimer’s 2007 article.
Turkheimer claims that the misinterpretation of his words is based on “one poorly written sentence” (“it is a matter of ethical principle...”). This means that he thinks the other sentences in the 2007 article are *not* poorly worded—at least not a way that would generate the misinterpretation in question.
But many sentences in the 2007 article support (1). The entire thrust of the 1,377-word argument is that hereditarianism about race differences in socially important traits is immoral and something that ought to be rejected a priori because it is offensive.
Turkheimer (2007) begins as follows: “Ceci and Flynn...agree that the question [of heritable race differences in IQ] is a legitimate matter for scientific inquiry, to be settled by cool-headed evaluation of the empirical evidence. I disagree.” There it is. Turkheimer “disagree[s]” with “cool-headed evaluation of the empirical evidence” when it comes to this topic. Why does he disagree? In his words: “The important questions about the role of genetics in the explanation of racial differences in ability are not empirical, but theoretical and philosophical.” Therefore, hereditarians “deserve the vigorous disapprobation they often receive.”
I’m not saying there isn’t some ambiguity about what Turkheimer is arguing here. However, on the face of it, it is far more consistent with hypothesis (1) than (2).
Let’s pretend (2) is correct and try to interpret the passage above. Traits like IQ are in certain respects different from traits like hair color. So it makes sense that we would use some different methods to study IQ vs. hair color. It’s also true that we evaluate people ethically based on choices they make, and not physical traits that are unrelated to their choices. But even if all of that is true, why would race differences in IQ not be a “legitimate matter for scientific inquiry”? Why should people who come to one conclusion (genes play a role in differences) deserve “vigorous disapprobation”? There’s no scientific reason why you can’t study people’s choices. This is basically the entire field of social science. So what is Turkheimer saying?
According to the logic of (2), why does Turkheimer insist that the question of race differences isn’t “empirical”? It’s a question about how the world is. There could be a metaphysical principle that all human groups must be the same. (Perhaps John Locke believed something along those lines.) But Turkheimer doesn’t say that. The only principle he talks about is an ethical one.
Consider another passage:
“We are justifiably offended by a hypothesis involving, say, an innate gift of rhythm....If I may address my fellow Jews for a moment, consider this. How would you feel about a line of research into the question of whether Jews have a genetic tendency to be more concerned with money than other groups? Nothing anti-Semitic, mind you, just a rational investigation of the scientific evidence. It wouldn’t be difficult to measure interest in money and materialism, and it wouldn’t surprise me if as an empirical matter Jews scored a little higher on the resulting test than other groups. As a behavioral geneticist I can assure you without reservation that the trait would be heritable, and, if anyone bothered to take the time to find out, specific genes would have small associations with it. Of course, this research program has already been carried out, at least to the extent the relevant technology was available in 1939. While we are at it we could open a whole scientific institute for the scientific study of racial stereotypes, and finally pull together the evidence on sneaky Japanese, drunken Irish, unintelligent Poles, overemotional women and lazy Italians. Hopefully I am beginning to offend you. Why? Why don’t we accept racial stereotypes as reasonable hypotheses, okay to consider until they have been scientifically proven false?”
People who interpret Turkheimer as rejecting hereditarianism on ethical grounds are not doing so based on “one poorly written sentence.” He clearly says that we shouldn’t study race differences because we might confirm racial stereotypes that are offensive, and because that’s what the Nazis did. None of what he says here has anything to do with the idea he now claims to have been expressing.
At least when it comes to this emotionally charged issue, Turkheimer isn’t a clear thinker. I suspect that he is sincerely confused about what he himself believes. He is invested in racial equality as an empirical fact. But he works in a field where every day he has to confront information that is inconsistent with what he wishes to be true. The psychological conflict manifested as some very strange claims that he later realized he could not defend, and now wants to walk back. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Bringing the hereditarian revolution to the capital of Europe
"Do I legitimise hate?" www.brusselstimes.com/opinion/2071122/right-of-reply-from… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
JQers often assume that any Jewish overrepresentation that can’t be explained by IQ must be due to nepotism/ethnic networking.
In reality, selection for success in business and scholarship favored a constellation of traits, not just g. Hence the Jewish personality (socially effective but sometimes annoying).
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
American Jewish gentile differences
Mostly find what you would think: left-wing, higher IQ, like reading and debate, politically interested, into drugs and sex, bit less religious.
No difference in mental health or antisocial behavior (self-report) -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Eric Turkheimer (former president of the Behavior Genetics Association) says race is skin deep because there's an "ethical principle" that says it must be so.
Ppl sometimes accuse me of quoting him out of context. But no one has explained how the "context" makes it any better. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Paul Hundred, GED
@paul_hundred
I’m 33 minutes in and the Belgians are yelling at Cofnas for reading libtard quotes. They want him to get straight into the race science. No foreplay.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My talk to the Catholic Flemish Student Union (@KVHVGent) at Ghent University
- The logic of wokism
- Race denial was never based on evidence
- The science of race www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZsKQvaTku4 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My talk to the Catholic Flemish Student Union (@KVHVGent) at Ghent University
- The logic of wokism
- Race denial was never based on evidence
- The science of race www.youtube.com/watch?v=nZsKQvaTku4 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Even the straw man is now trans
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A keffiyeh-wearing fanatic assaulted philosopher @nathancofnas yesterday after a talk, hurling a bottle at his head. The perpetrator is a student at the faculty, but I won't reveal his name until the evidence is reported to the police. The university should investigate and immediately expel him.
And let’s be clear: every academic who has been loudly demanding Cofnas’ resignation now has a responsibility to unequivocally condemn this violence.
If no actions are taken, the inmates will have taken over the asylum.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Just gave a talk on wokism to the Catholic Flemish Student Union at UGent.
Afterward, some woke anti-Semites responded with the only counterargument they have, i.e., violence. I was assaulted twice with a bottle of something hurled at my face. Then they ran away on a motorcycle. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Just gave a talk on wokism to the Catholic Flemish Student Union at UGent.
Afterward, some woke anti-Semites responded with the only counterargument they have, i.e., violence. I was assaulted twice with a bottle of something hurled at my face. Then they ran away on a motorcycle. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Secretary General of Amnesty International says the white man owes Africans reparations because slavery and colonialism caused today's global inequality.
In reality, there is a "strong, positive relation between current income per capita and colonial European settlement" (reference in next tweet). Without colonialism there would be *more* inequality.
If you want to see what Africa would look like without colonialism, behold: Ethiopia. Besides a 6-year occupation by Italy from 1935-1941, the white man mostly left Ethiopia alone. Now it is one of the continent's poorer countries.
This is why we need to take a realist perspective on group differences. If you think all groups are the same, disparities must have an environmental cause. That inevitably means someone (white people) will be blamed. And environmental interventions to bring about equality of outcome will fail. Even if Europe pays reparations to Africa, in 3 years the money will be gone and Agnes Callamard & Co. will be here to say how that, too, is the white man's fault.
Agnes Callamard
@AgnesCallamard
BREAKING: Amnesty International welcomes the recognition of chattel enslavement of Africans as a crime against humanity at the UN General Assembly, following a resolution tabled by #ghana on behalf of the African continent and people of African descent.
Across the world, people are still suffering the long-lasting effects of slavery and colonialism, manifesting in today’s racism and global inequality, while States and private actors profited from these historical crimes and injustices.
Today’s resolution is a momentous step forward for legal recognition and reparations for those who have suffered the enduring harms of chattel enslavement around the world.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"We find a strong, positive relation between current income per capita and colonial European settlement that is robust to controlling for the current proportion of the population of European descent, as well as many other country characteristics." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10887-016-9130-y
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thank you to @Rosalind_Arden_ for defending the (in Belgium) controversial view that I shouldn't go to jail for pointing this out
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"intelligence research is a scientific golden child. It survived the replication crisis that cratered psychology, and intelligence has the most explanatory power of any single trait in the whole of the human behavioural sciences." quillette.com/2026/03/26/criminal-research-nathan-cofnas-…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I know it sounds crazy, but rather than trying to cancel, shut down, fire or even prosecute @nathancofnas for his controversial views on race and IQ, why not just engage with him? He will actually respond. 😱Here's Cofnas and I engaging in a discussion about Harvard's statistics and his claim about "Black professors", in the comment section of my piece. substacktools.com/sharex/ODiTMIkx
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
European jurists should not seek to arbitrate controversial matters best settled by science, writes @Rosalind_Arden_
quillette.com/2026/03/26/criminal-research-nathan-cofnas-… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
This statement supporting @nathancofnas's academic freedom now has 170 signatures, with many distinguished academics among the signatories.
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
🚨A statement in support of Nathan Cofnas's right to academic freedom of expression. Signed by over 120 leading academics and public figures. 👇
drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
They're not giving up
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
arctotherium
@arctotherium42
Yes, that's Belgium with the second highest rating. Here is a Belgian judge threatening Nathan Cofnas with prison.
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🚨 The U.S. continues its fall on the Academic Freedom Index, but the story is more complicated than it seems.
This story, rising self-censorship, government intervention, disciplinary reform, debates over controversial research, and more in HxA's weekly round-up. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
The Euros apparently think advocacy of the academic hereditarian school, from the cult/crit/hered debate about group performance, is a felony.
Never give up your guns. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Timothy Bates
@timothycbates
In 100 years, this era will be seen the way we used to see the era of Galileo: The consequence of weird ideas becoming a legally-enforced signals of system loyalty with life-destroying results until overthrown.
For Rome, the incorrect but mandatory beliefs were the earth being the centre of the universe and all that flowed from that.
For us, it is the blank slate: The belief that people are fungible: identical and equal in all but the most superficial ways, and all that flows from that.
Arguably the most toxic meme in history.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Pierre Thiriar—a Justice on the Court of Appeal in Antwerp—wants me in handcuffs
"When he states that genetic variants influencing intelligence may be unevenly distributed across populations and that this can explain differences in cognitive performance, this constitutes not merely a neutral hypothesis, but the empirical basis for a hierarchical view of human nature....the boundaries of Article 21 have been manifestly crossed."
"Belgian case law has made it clear that packaging a discourse as 'scientific', 'philosophical', or 'critical' does not prevent it from being punishable when it objectively incites discrimination or propagates ideas of racial superiority." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
Can we airlift you out of Belgium?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"There's an academic consensus that all races are exactly the same."
"I'm a credentialled academic who works in this area and I don't agree with that."
<off to jail>
"I said there's a consensus. Anyone else disagree?"
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Pierre Thiriar—a Justice on the Court of Appeal in Antwerp—wants me in handcuffs
"When he states that genetic variants influencing intelligence may be unevenly distributed across populations and that this can explain differences in cognitive performance, this constitutes not merely a neutral hypothesis, but the empirical basis for a hierarchical view of human nature....the boundaries of Article 21 have been manifestly crossed."
"Belgian case law has made it clear that packaging a discourse as 'scientific', 'philosophical', or 'critical' does not prevent it from being punishable when it objectively incites discrimination or propagates ideas of racial superiority." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Pierre Thiriar—a Justice on the Court of Appeal in Antwerp—wants me in handcuffs
"When he states that genetic variants influencing intelligence may be unevenly distributed across populations and that this can explain differences in cognitive performance, this constitutes not merely a neutral hypothesis, but the empirical basis for a hierarchical view of human nature....the boundaries of Article 21 have been manifestly crossed."
"Belgian case law has made it clear that packaging a discourse as 'scientific', 'philosophical', or 'critical' does not prevent it from being punishable when it objectively incites discrimination or propagates ideas of racial superiority." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You did not identity a single right-wing academic who called for violence in the same way as Pettit and was then supported by the free-speech movement. Presumably, it is because that never happened.
"There are even academics, mostly from the right, who supported and called for striking hard in Gaza, Lebanon, Iran, Yemen"
You may not make a distinction between (a) an attack that deliberately targets civilians and (b) military operations that result in causalities as an unintended consequence. Most normal people do make a distinction between those actions, and they are not hypocritical for doing so.
If someone called for *targeting civilians* in Gaza, Lebanon, Iran, or Yemen, that might be analogous to what Pettit did. But I am not aware of any Western academic doing that--and certainly not then being defended by the free-speech movement.
"you cannot deny that the views of @HarryGPettit are anti-Zionist"
In a discussion about Pettit, you referred to "anti-zionism" as "the type of views that are most successfully suppressed in this day and age." And you never bother to mention that, actually, he called for violence. Clearly, you are suggesting that he was fired for anti-Zionism, which is false. He was fired for the call for violence.
"You would do better fighting for that principle too, not just for yourself and your own views."
This comment (among others) reveals your dishonesty. I have strongly, publicly defended free speech for people who disagree with me (e.g., anti-Semites, Holocaust deniers, etc.). A few minutes ago I publicly stated that, based on what I know, Pettit shouldn't have been fired.
I already pointed out that if I did what Pettit did on behalf of hereditarianism, I would have been fired and probably arrested, with very little support for my academic freedom. You cannot argue against that because it is obviously correct. -
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
Dr @nathancofnas’s appointment at Ghent University has prompted a campaign by members of the institution calling on the university to reverse course, citing his published work on race, heredity and intelligence.
In response, CAF Advisory Board member Professor Abhishek Saha helped organised a counter-petition in support of Cofnas’s right to #academicfreedom of expression. CAF Director Dr Edward Skidelsky is among the signatories, alongside a number of senior academics from leading universities.
This is not about endorsing Cofnas’s views, but about defending the principle that disagreements of this kind should be addressed through open inquiry, criticism, and civil debate.
Of course, academics must be free to strongly contest ideas they regard as deeply objectionable. But that does not extend to a veto over appointments. Universities cannot function if controversial or provocative lines of research are treated as grounds for exclusion rather than argument.
You can read the statement and sign the counter-petition here:
drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO…
@ObhishekSaha @ProfDHayes @epkaufm @Furedibyte @HJoyceGender @drianpace @aytchellesse @JoPhoenix1 @sapinkerPost not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
First, you should be free to say what you like as long as you don't incite imminent, lawless action. Unless I missed something, Pettit never did that, so he shouldn't have been fired.
Second, your characterization of what Pettit did is false. He wasn't fired for "anti-Zionism." Most Belgian academics are anti-Zionist, and no one is being fired for that. He was fired for encouraging violence/terrorism, as in the screenshot below.
If I tweeted that "It is time to finish what Anders Breivik started,"* there would be far less support for my academic freedom, and I would almost certainly be fired if not arrested. Many people draw the line at calling for violence.
If you can point to an example where the free-speech movement supported a right winger who called for violence in the same way as Pettit, then you may be able to make a case for hypocrisy. But so far you have not done that. I believe it is because no such example exists.
*Obviously I would never tweet support for Breivik because I reject his ideology and methods. I'm just using him as an example of a right-wing terrorist.Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You did not identity a single right-wing academic who called for violence in the same way as Pettit and was then supported by the free-speech movement. Presumably, it is because that never happened.
"There are even academics, mostly from the right, who supported and called for striking hard in Gaza, Lebanon, Iran, Yemen"
You may not make a distinction between (a) an attack that deliberately targets civilians and (b) military operations that result in causalities as an unintended consequence. Most normal people do make a distinction between those actions, and they are not hypocritical for doing so.
If someone called for *targeting civilians* in Gaza, Lebanon, Iran, or Yemen, that might be analogous to what Pettit did. But I am not aware of any Western academic doing that--and certainly not then being defended by the free-speech movement.
"you cannot deny that the views of @HarryGPettit are anti-Zionist"
In a discussion about Pettit, you referred to "anti-zionism" as "the type of views that are most successfully suppressed in this day and age." And you never bother to mention that, actually, he called for violence. Clearly, you are suggesting that he was fired for anti-Zionism, which is false. He was fired for the call for violence.
"You would do better fighting for that principle too, not just for yourself and your own views."
This comment (among others) reveals your dishonesty. I have strongly, publicly defended free speech for people who disagree with me (e.g., anti-Semites, Holocaust deniers, etc.). A few minutes ago I publicly stated that, based on what I know, Pettit shouldn't have been fired.
I already pointed out that if I did what Pettit did on behalf of hereditarianism, I would have been fired and probably arrested, with very little support for my academic freedom. You cannot argue against that because it is obviously correct. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
First, you should be free to say what you like as long as you don't incite imminent, lawless action. Unless I missed something, Pettit never did that, so he shouldn't have been fired.
Second, your characterization of what Pettit did is false. He wasn't fired for "anti-Zionism." Most Belgian academics are anti-Zionist, and no one is being fired for that. He was fired for encouraging violence/terrorism, as in the screenshot below.
If I tweeted that "It is time to finish what Anders Breivik started,"* there would be far less support for my academic freedom, and I would almost certainly be fired if not arrested. Many people draw the line at calling for violence.
If you can point to an example where the free-speech movement supported a right winger who called for violence in the same way as Pettit, then you may be able to make a case for hypocrisy. But so far you have not done that. I believe it is because no such example exists.
*Obviously I would never tweet support for Breivik because I reject his ideology and methods. I'm just using him as an example of a right-wing terrorist. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
Dr @nathancofnas’s appointment at Ghent University has prompted a campaign by members of the institution calling on the university to reverse course, citing his published work on race, heredity and intelligence.
In response, CAF Advisory Board member Professor Abhishek Saha helped organised a counter-petition in support of Cofnas’s right to #academicfreedom of expression. CAF Director Dr Edward Skidelsky is among the signatories, alongside a number of senior academics from leading universities.
This is not about endorsing Cofnas’s views, but about defending the principle that disagreements of this kind should be addressed through open inquiry, criticism, and civil debate.
Of course, academics must be free to strongly contest ideas they regard as deeply objectionable. But that does not extend to a veto over appointments. Universities cannot function if controversial or provocative lines of research are treated as grounds for exclusion rather than argument.
You can read the statement and sign the counter-petition here:
drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO…
@ObhishekSaha @ProfDHayes @epkaufm @Furedibyte @HJoyceGender @drianpace @aytchellesse @JoPhoenix1 @sapinker -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Why I signed this statement in support of @nathancofnas.
substacktools.com/sharex/ODiTMIkx
Francesca Minerva
@FranciMinerva
A statement in support of Nathan Cofnas's right to academic freedom, signed by more than 120 academics drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO… @ugent @nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
Please retweet this statement in support of @nathancofnas, who is the subject of yet another academic witch hunt. @charlesmurray @Steve_Sailer
Francesca Minerva
@FranciMinerva
A statement in support of Nathan Cofnas's right to academic freedom, signed by more than 120 academics drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO… @ugent @nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
🚨A statement in support of Nathan Cofnas's right to academic freedom of expression. Signed by over 120 leading academics and public figures. 👇
drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Francesca Minerva
@FranciMinerva
A statement in support of Nathan Cofnas's right to academic freedom, signed by more than 120 academics drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO… @ugent @nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
ockhams-scheermes
@ockhams
Samengevat: als de waarheid niet woke en niet politiek correct is, dan moet die niet gezegd worden. daarom zijn ze bang van Cofnas.
Terzake
@terzaketv
"Het uitspreken van een waarheid kan geen racisme zijn."
Omstreden wetenschapsfilosoof Nathan Cofnas reageert op kritiek na aanstelling aan UGent in #terzaketvThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Terzake
@terzaketv
"Het uitspreken van een waarheid kan geen racisme zijn."
Omstreden wetenschapsfilosoof Nathan Cofnas reageert op kritiek na aanstelling aan UGent in #terzaketvThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
De Standaard made a montage of me being evil
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als de @ugent zwicht voor de druk om @nathancofnas te ontslaan, krimpt opnieuw een stuk academische vrijheid. Pseudowetenschap mocht jarenlang bloeien aan onze vakgroep (hallo Jacques Lacan), maar één verboden hypothese en plots wil men koppen zien rollen. Bovendien blijkt uit anonieme peilingen dat véél meer intelligentie-onderzoekers het met de hypothese van Cofnas eens zijn (ongeveer de helft). Moet je verbaasd zijn dat er zoveel zelfcensuur heerst, met dit soort collectieve pogingen tot broodroof? Universiteiten die “gevaarlijke ideeën” verbieden, verraden hun kernopdracht. Ik verdedig niet wat Nathan Cofnas zegt — wel zijn recht om het te onderzoeken en ongeremd zijn meningen daarover te uiten.
www.demorgen.be/meningen/als-de-ugent-zwicht-krimpt-opnie… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Haier
@rjhaier
I signed the counter petition supporting him.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A few years ago I recorded an episode of my podcast Forbidden Territory for @UGent (in Dutch) about the heritability of IQ. We also touched on the third rail of racial differences. Why? Because I believe academics should be free to investigate even the most “dangerous ideas.”
My guest, Han van der Maas (a renowned IQ researcher at the University of Amsterdam), explained that individual IQ differences are highly heritable, but that he does not believe in differences between racial groups. His statistical and methodological arguments (e.g. Simpson paradox) convinced me at the time. Still, he hedged his bets: it remains possible that future evidence might show racial differences. And researchers should be free to investigate that hypothesis.
Forty-five colleagues from my former philosophy department apparently think otherwise. They are urging the rector to fire @nathancofnas because he claims that the IQ gap between racial groups (such as whites and blacks in the US — differences that are themselves not disputed) may have partly genetic causes, rather than purely social ones like marginalization or discrimination. They label this “pseudoscience and racism.”
I understand why many people are shocked by Cofnas’s claims. But this clearly falls within the scope of academic freedom.
For years, the psychoanalysis of Jacques Lacan was taught and researched at my department — a complete pseudoscience. Dozens of theses and PhDs were written about it, all scientifically worthless. No one batted an eye. Unlike my colleagues, I published several papers explaining why (Lacanian) psychoanalysis is pseudoscientific (drive.google.com/file/d/0B_K-qtp6iiL1M0Nuam5qSWhybHM/view…). Yet I never demanded that my colleagues be fired.
None of the signatories have any peer-reviewed publications on IQ or genetics. I have a letter recommending Cofnas' work on IQ from the editor-in-chief of the prestigious journal Intelligence. Even if the hypothesis of racial IQ differences could be shown to belong to the realm of pseudoscience, that still would not justify dismissal.
If @UGent caves in to this demand, it will be another blow to academic freedom at my alma mater — following the new rector’s illiberal statements suggesting that researchers questioning the safety of vaccines or the Gaza “genocide” are “crossing a line that must not be crossed.”
Such calls for dismissal from people without any expertise are also strategically unwise, as they only fuel “red-pilling.” When academics appear determined to suppress a dangerous idea at all costs, people understandably get suspicious: "What are they trying to hide?" And so trust in academia erodes further.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHhbWmjb6ug -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A few years ago I recorded an episode of my podcast Forbidden Territory for @UGent (in Dutch) about the heritability of IQ. We also touched on the third rail of racial differences. Why? Because I believe academics should be free to investigate even the most “dangerous ideas.”
My guest, Han van der Maas (a renowned IQ researcher at the University of Amsterdam), explained that individual IQ differences are highly heritable, but that he does not believe in differences between racial groups. His statistical and methodological arguments (e.g. Simpson paradox) convinced me at the time. Still, he hedged his bets: it remains possible that future evidence might show racial differences. And researchers should be free to investigate that hypothesis.
Forty-five colleagues from my former philosophy department apparently think otherwise. They are urging the rector to fire @nathancofnas because he claims that the IQ gap between racial groups (such as whites and blacks in the US — differences that are themselves not disputed) may have partly genetic causes, rather than purely social ones like marginalization or discrimination. They label this “pseudoscience and racism.”
I understand why many people are shocked by Cofnas’s claims. But this clearly falls within the scope of academic freedom.
For years, the psychoanalysis of Jacques Lacan was taught and researched at my department — a complete pseudoscience. Dozens of theses and PhDs were written about it, all scientifically worthless. No one batted an eye. Unlike my colleagues, I published several papers explaining why (Lacanian) psychoanalysis is pseudoscientific (drive.google.com/file/d/0B_K-qtp6iiL1M0Nuam5qSWhybHM/view…). Yet I never demanded that my colleagues be fired.
None of the signatories have any peer-reviewed publications on IQ or genetics. I have a letter recommending Cofnas' work on IQ from the editor-in-chief of the prestigious journal Intelligence. Even if the hypothesis of racial IQ differences could be shown to belong to the realm of pseudoscience, that still would not justify dismissal.
If @UGent caves in to this demand, it will be another blow to academic freedom at my alma mater — following the new rector’s illiberal statements suggesting that researchers questioning the safety of vaccines or the Gaza “genocide” are “crossing a line that must not be crossed.”
Such calls for dismissal from people without any expertise are also strategically unwise, as they only fuel “red-pilling.” When academics appear determined to suppress a dangerous idea at all costs, people understandably get suspicious: "What are they trying to hide?" And so trust in academia erodes further.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHhbWmjb6ug -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wouter Duyck
@wduyck
Rector De Sutter heeft gelijk dat “Het is aan experten/collega-onderzoekers om ideeën te toetsen, te bekritiseren en tegen te spreken.” Wel, de 45 wetenschappers die het ontslag van een collega vragen en diegene die daar opinies over schrijven hebben sámen geen énkele wetenschappelijke publicatie over intelligentie. Noch achtergrond in (cognitieve) psychologie. Wat ze notabene zelf anderen verwijten. Ze zwaaien met termen als ‘pseudowetenschap’ maar posten ook stellingen over de materie die onzin zijn. Ze begrijpen niet welke stellingen van Cofnas wetenschappelijk discutabel zijn en welke niet. Dat is het probleem hier. Dit is géén wetenschappelijk debat. Het is politiek. De literatuur over intelligentie is immens uitgebreid en complex. Individuele verschillen, erfelijkheidscoëfficiënten die interageren met nurture, de maakbaarheid van iq, erfelijkheid van intelligentie vs erfelijkheid van variantie in intelligentie, erfelijkheid op individueel niveau vs groepsniveau (Simpson’s paradox), het Flynn effect en het verdwijnen ervan, etc. etc. Hier zijn honderden wetenschappelijke studies over. Dit is een immens en belangrijk wetenschapsdomein dat precies omwille van het belang en gevoeligheid (goed) onderzoek verdient en noodzaakt. Ongeïnformeerde emoties in de krant dragen hier niks toe bij. Wetenschapsnegationisme ook niet. De felheid in het debat correleert negatief met de geëtaleerde expertise terzake.
www.standaard.be/opinies/45-filosofen-roepen-op-om-nathan… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
1,217 people signed the "fire Cofnas from Cambridge" petition, but only 196 people signed the "fire Cofnas from Ghent" petition. Am I becoming more popular?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I started a new job
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"How are we supposed to evaluate people if we can't talk about their race? It's so confusing"
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
It will look bad for Newsom et al. if they throw a hissy fit about the war and then Trump wins a Cyrus the Great level victory
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
The corrupt and repressive Iranian regime must never have nuclear weapons. The leadership of Iran must go. But that does not justify the President of the United States engaging in an illegal, dangerous war that will risk the lives of our American service members and our friends without justification to the American people.
President Trump is putting Americans at risk abroad because he is unpopular at home. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Steven Pinker argues that we stopped doing moronic things like burning witches and torturing people until they confess in large part because we literally became smarter (the "Flynn effect"). I think this is a mistake. For a period of time, the IQ 120+ segment of the population managed to seize control over the culture. But the medieval peasants are still there, just as dumb as ever, and the Internet is bringing them back to power.
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
During the medieval period peasants believed that witches kidnapped babies, used their body parts in potions, & ate their flesh during satanic rituals.
Today we are much more advanced, of course.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There's a huge generational divide between people on the right who grew up pre- and post-Internet (i.e., before vs. after the forbidden information was easily accessible). I've never met a zoomer RW intellectual who doesn't take race realism for granted.
Dan McLaughlin
@baseballcrank
The reason we have taboos about studying race & intelligence is not morality but experience; there's a shockingly copious history of the topic attracting pseudoscience. While knowledge of the subject shouldn't be off-limits per se, the risk of bad science masquerading as knowledge is prohibitive.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
It feels unprestigious for a Jewish academic not to make it into the Epstein files. However, in my defense, I was a young student when most of this was happening.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak:
"We have to break the monopoly of the orthodox rabbinate on marriage,...the definition of a Jew, and accept...massive conversion into Judaism."
It's a point I've made before, but it's nice to have it on tape. Shitlibs in Israel want to do to Jews and Israel what their ideological counterparts in America and Europe want to do to whites and the West.
There's a popular myth online, promoted by people who don't know how to do a 10-second Google search, that Israeli immigration law is all about racial purity and you can't even get citizenship unless you pass a DNA test. In reality, left-wing politicians like Barak constructed an immigration policy under which the *majority* (according to one report, 86%) of recent immigrants to Israel are not halachically Jewish. Many have little or even no Jewish ancestry. These non-Jews now make up a substantial part of the Israeli population (>400,000 citizens). -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
Foreigners agitating against intelligence enhancement in Singapore.
Invite the White world, become the White world.
Whyvert
@whyvert
Last month a medical ethics journal published a piece defending FGM.
Now an article against enhancing intelligence.
Because capitalism, racism, patriarchy.
FGM good, intelligence bad.
Leftists defend the backward, oppose accomplishment. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Behold, those small samples the NYT complains about, they only correlate 0.93 with SAT/ACT scores for the same groups.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Zero Contradictions
@0Contradictions
Another thing: Wikipedia's editors are ~85-90% male, and yet Wikipedia is heavily left-wing, even before the Great Awokening happened.
Clearly, a "Great Feminization" could never explain why Wikipedia is as woke as it is. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
I like Rufo's work but nevertheless a good post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Chris Rufo is a grifter who is leading the right to disaster. His alleged victories against wokism are almost entirely imaginary.
Whenever someone criticizes Rufo, he likes to compare his track record to theirs. In his own words, these are the highlights of his career:
“We broke BLM, CRT, Kendi, Gay, etc., and my conversations with the New York Times over the past five years, which are a good proxy for elite consensus, have shifted very favorably in our direction, meaning that those ‘elites’ sense we have damaged woke and reduced its relative status. We’ve also set the stage for the president to defund the Left, tame the universities, abolish DEI, and rescind affirmative action.”
Let’s examine these claims one by one, and then consider why the right always loses in the end.
Helping the Left Take Out Its Own Trash
A couple years ago, Rufo helped get Harvard’s DEI President Claudine Gay booted on the pretext of plagiarism. As I predicted would happen, she was simply replaced by someone worse. Under the more effective leadership of Alan Garber, Harvard continues to flout the Supreme Court’s ruling against affirmative action, and it is spearheading the resistance to Trump.
The Left Has Moral and Intellectual Standards
At the height of the Great Awokening, Ibram X. Kendi was the doyen of DEI. Kendi (whose SAT scores barely cracked 1000) gave us insights such as defining “racism” as “a collection of racist policies that lead to racial inequity that are substantiated by racist ideas.” He received a MacArthur Fellowship (aka “genius grant”) and set his speaking fee to $35,000 an hour. In July 2020 he became the founding director of the Center for Antiracist Research at Boston University funded by $55 million in donations.
After several years, Kendi’s Center for Antiracist Research failed to produce anything resembling research. He fired half of his staff because the money had disappeared to who-knows-where. The whole operation was shut down in 2025. Kendi left BU and now directs the so-called Institute for Advanced Study at Howard University.
The fall of Kendi is a testament to the left’s capacity for self-correction, not evidence that it is in retreat. (I’m not sure what role Rufo thinks “anti-woke” reporting had in any of this, but it makes no difference either way.) The right would never have a Kendi scandal because a right-wing Kendi would never be held accountable. Can you think of a single example in recent history where a right-wing leader was marginalized for stupidity or grifting? If the right held its leaders accountable for these things, almost everyone would be gone (including Rufo).
BLM Lives On
After gaining steam from several hoaxes such as the Michael Brown “hands up, don’t shoot” incident, BLM reached its high point after the death of George Floyd in the summer of 2020. The movement was unofficially led by the Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation (BLMGNF), which, in 2020, received more than $90 million in donations.
BLMGNF was run like Zimbabwe. Its leaders paid themselves lavish salaries. They funneled large sums of money to their friends and family. Director Patrisse Cullors’s baby daddy was paid $970,000 for “creative services.” Cullors resigned her position at BLMGNF when her private purchase of more than $3 million in real estate attracted scrutiny. The left-wing New York Magazine broke the story that BLMGNF secretly bought a house for $6 million, apparently for private use by senior members of the organization. Local BLM chapters faced similar scandals.
Rufo can gloat about how embarrassing this was for the left. But the left exposed corruption on its own side and took measures to fix the problem without retreating from its ideological goals.
BLM attracted a flurry of support, then started going off the rails due to corruption and purity spirals. The left-wing establishment responded by quietly switching its focus to institutional capture so it can wield real power instead of just burning down police stations.
CRT Didn’t Go Anywhere
“Critical Race Theory” is a fancy name for the idea that racial disparities favoring whites are caused by past or present racism. It is simply the philosophy that follows from taking the equality thesis (all races have the same innate distribution of socially relevant traits) seriously.
Rufo played a role in passing legislation in some Republican-controlled states to prohibit educators from teaching CRT. Having anti-CRT laws on the books makes it marginally easier to push back against the most noxious expressions of anti-whitism. But elites remain committed to CRT, whether they call it CRT or something else like “American history.” Children spend seven hours a day, five days a week at school. As long as educators remain overwhelmingly left and woke, they are going to find a way to impart their beliefs to students.
Elite Consensus
Nothing happening at the New York Times indicates that “elite consensus [has] shifted very favorably in our direction.” Some mainstream left-wing outlets have recently expressed cautious skepticism about mutilating “trans” children. But gender theory is philosophically and historically separate from wokism. I always said there could be a backlash against it. The Times has not backed one inch away from the idea that all groups of people are on average the same and we need to strive for equality of outcome.
How the Left Actually Won
Howard Zinn was the author of A People’s History of the United States, which sold more than two million copies and played a major role in radicalizing American education. In 1967, the political science department at Boston University voted to award him tenure. However, its recommendation had to be approved by the trustees, who were scheduled to meet for the annual Founders Day banquet. Zinn then accepted some students’ invitation to speak at an anti-war rally, not knowing that the purpose of the rally was to protest Secretary of State Dean Rusk...who had been invited to speak at the Founders Day banquet! But he did not pull out. On the same day the trustees were voting on his tenure case, Zinn gave a 45-minute speech railing against their honored guest, the government, and America’s founders. He went home assuming he would be fired. Unbeknownst to him, the trustees had already voted to approve his tenure before the banquet.
Bill Ayers spent time in jail.
Noam Chomsky’s wife went to college so she would be able to support the family when her husband got what they expected would be a long prison sentence.
For 70 years, the woke project has inspired commitment from a large proportion of intelligent and idealistic people. That’s why the ideology prevailed. There was no conspiratorial “long march through the institutions.” As long as they believe that all groups are on average innately the same, intelligent, morally sensitive people will recognize that there is a moral emergency to correct the environment and bring about equality of outcome. Insofar as society is a meritocracy, institutions staffed by qualified individuals will spontaneously wokify.
In a revealing moment, Chris Rufo mocked me for being fired from Cambridge for talking about hereditarianism. (In fact I wasn’t fired from Cambridge, but leave that aside.) For Rufo the nihilist, the idea of sacrificing your immediate self-interest on behalf of a worthy cause is incomprehensible. He and his fellow trolls only know how to kick their opponents when they are down—a strategy that, besides being dishonorable, is generally ineffective in the long run, when eventually your enemy (perhaps Gavin Newsom?) gets up and starts kicking you.
The right may have the political power to defund cancer research, but it is currently not a position to retake the institutions and run them effectively. Note that, even with virtually unlimited funding, the right-wing University of Austin (UATX) is teaching college students middle-school-level algebra and appears to be on the verge of shutting down. To defeat race communism, it will be necessary to persuade a critical mass of liberal elites to join the right. Holding up people like Rufo as representatives of anti-wokism is pushing these potential allies—and therefore real victory—further and further away. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Chris Rufo is a grifter who is leading the right to disaster. His alleged victories against wokism are almost entirely imaginary.
Whenever someone criticizes Rufo, he likes to compare his track record to theirs. In his own words, these are the highlights of his career:
“We broke BLM, CRT, Kendi, Gay, etc., and my conversations with the New York Times over the past five years, which are a good proxy for elite consensus, have shifted very favorably in our direction, meaning that those ‘elites’ sense we have damaged woke and reduced its relative status. We’ve also set the stage for the president to defund the Left, tame the universities, abolish DEI, and rescind affirmative action.”
Let’s examine these claims one by one, and then consider why the right always loses in the end.
Helping the Left Take Out Its Own Trash
A couple years ago, Rufo helped get Harvard’s DEI President Claudine Gay booted on the pretext of plagiarism. As I predicted would happen, she was simply replaced by someone worse. Under the more effective leadership of Alan Garber, Harvard continues to flout the Supreme Court’s ruling against affirmative action, and it is spearheading the resistance to Trump.
The Left Has Moral and Intellectual Standards
At the height of the Great Awokening, Ibram X. Kendi was the doyen of DEI. Kendi (whose SAT scores barely cracked 1000) gave us insights such as defining “racism” as “a collection of racist policies that lead to racial inequity that are substantiated by racist ideas.” He received a MacArthur Fellowship (aka “genius grant”) and set his speaking fee to $35,000 an hour. In July 2020 he became the founding director of the Center for Antiracist Research at Boston University funded by $55 million in donations.
After several years, Kendi’s Center for Antiracist Research failed to produce anything resembling research. He fired half of his staff because the money had disappeared to who-knows-where. The whole operation was shut down in 2025. Kendi left BU and now directs the so-called Institute for Advanced Study at Howard University.
The fall of Kendi is a testament to the left’s capacity for self-correction, not evidence that it is in retreat. (I’m not sure what role Rufo thinks “anti-woke” reporting had in any of this, but it makes no difference either way.) The right would never have a Kendi scandal because a right-wing Kendi would never be held accountable. Can you think of a single example in recent history where a right-wing leader was marginalized for stupidity or grifting? If the right held its leaders accountable for these things, almost everyone would be gone (including Rufo).
BLM Lives On
After gaining steam from several hoaxes such as the Michael Brown “hands up, don’t shoot” incident, BLM reached its high point after the death of George Floyd in the summer of 2020. The movement was unofficially led by the Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation (BLMGNF), which, in 2020, received more than $90 million in donations.
BLMGNF was run like Zimbabwe. Its leaders paid themselves lavish salaries. They funneled large sums of money to their friends and family. Director Patrisse Cullors’s baby daddy was paid $970,000 for “creative services.” Cullors resigned her position at BLMGNF when her private purchase of more than $3 million in real estate attracted scrutiny. The left-wing New York Magazine broke the story that BLMGNF secretly bought a house for $6 million, apparently for private use by senior members of the organization. Local BLM chapters faced similar scandals.
Rufo can gloat about how embarrassing this was for the left. But the left exposed corruption on its own side and took measures to fix the problem without retreating from its ideological goals.
BLM attracted a flurry of support, then started going off the rails due to corruption and purity spirals. The left-wing establishment responded by quietly switching its focus to institutional capture so it can wield real power instead of just burning down police stations.
CRT Didn’t Go Anywhere
“Critical Race Theory” is a fancy name for the idea that racial disparities favoring whites are caused by past or present racism. It is simply the philosophy that follows from taking the equality thesis (all races have the same innate distribution of socially relevant traits) seriously.
Rufo played a role in passing legislation in some Republican-controlled states to prohibit educators from teaching CRT. Having anti-CRT laws on the books makes it marginally easier to push back against the most noxious expressions of anti-whitism. But elites remain committed to CRT, whether they call it CRT or something else like “American history.” Children spend seven hours a day, five days a week at school. As long as educators remain overwhelmingly left and woke, they are going to find a way to impart their beliefs to students.
Elite Consensus
Nothing happening at the New York Times indicates that “elite consensus [has] shifted very favorably in our direction.” Some mainstream left-wing outlets have recently expressed cautious skepticism about mutilating “trans” children. But gender theory is philosophically and historically separate from wokism. I always said there could be a backlash against it. The Times has not backed one inch away from the idea that all groups of people are on average the same and we need to strive for equality of outcome.
How the Left Actually Won
Howard Zinn was the author of A People’s History of the United States, which sold more than two million copies and played a major role in radicalizing American education. In 1967, the political science department at Boston University voted to award him tenure. However, its recommendation had to be approved by the trustees, who were scheduled to meet for the annual Founders Day banquet. Zinn then accepted some students’ invitation to speak at an anti-war rally, not knowing that the purpose of the rally was to protest Secretary of State Dean Rusk...who had been invited to speak at the Founders Day banquet! But he did not pull out. On the same day the trustees were voting on his tenure case, Zinn gave a 45-minute speech railing against their honored guest, the government, and America’s founders. He went home assuming he would be fired. Unbeknownst to him, the trustees had already voted to approve his tenure before the banquet.
Bill Ayers spent time in jail.
Noam Chomsky’s wife went to college so she would be able to support the family when her husband got what they expected would be a long prison sentence.
For 70 years, the woke project has inspired commitment from a large proportion of intelligent and idealistic people. That’s why the ideology prevailed. There was no conspiratorial “long march through the institutions.” As long as they believe that all groups are on average innately the same, intelligent, morally sensitive people will recognize that there is a moral emergency to correct the environment and bring about equality of outcome. Insofar as society is a meritocracy, institutions staffed by qualified individuals will spontaneously wokify.
In a revealing moment, Chris Rufo mocked me for being fired from Cambridge for talking about hereditarianism. (In fact I wasn’t fired from Cambridge, but leave that aside.) For Rufo the nihilist, the idea of sacrificing your immediate self-interest on behalf of a worthy cause is incomprehensible. He and his fellow trolls only know how to kick their opponents when they are down—a strategy that, besides being dishonorable, is generally ineffective in the long run, when eventually your enemy (perhaps Gavin Newsom?) gets up and starts kicking you.
The right may have the political power to defund cancer research, but it is currently not a position to retake the institutions and run them effectively. Note that, even with virtually unlimited funding, the right-wing University of Austin (UATX) is teaching college students middle-school-level algebra and appears to be on the verge of shutting down. To defeat race communism, it will be necessary to persuade a critical mass of liberal elites to join the right. Holding up people like Rufo as representatives of anti-wokism is pushing these potential allies—and therefore real victory—further and further away. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Chris Rufo doesn't have an ideology. He's here to troll and enrich himself. Anti-woke influencing attracts characters like this because it is the easiest grift in the world.
I'm embarrassed to admit that I was taken in by Rufo, but at this point there is no excuse to be fooled. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Before philosophy I made music. This is me performing a piano piece I wrote in my dorm room at yeshiva in Jerusalem.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Young con men collectively spend >10 billion hours/year playing video games. Plenty of free time.
For $500 you can get a better music composition or writing setup than Beethoven or Shakespeare.
Yet the chud legacy is a bunch of stupid memes. This isn't solely the fault of libs. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I agree this is bad, but it raises the question of why conservatives who care so much about Western culture can't produce their own non-woke opera
The awkward truth is that without commies and queers there would be no opera at all
liel leibovitz
@liel
For the first time ever, I’m leaving an opera halfway through. The Met’s Carmen is about a wicked ICE agent abusing a tatted-up OnlyFans girl on a grey and dirty stage supposed to resemble the US southern border. Another piece of truth and beauty destroyed by the Commies.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Every element of cancel culture was written into the 1767 “Laws of Harvard College” so shamelessly even Claudine Gay would be embarrassed to plagiarize it. ncofnas.com/p/dont-scapegoat-women
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Frenjamin/Benemy
@BenjaminABoyce
Today, on Calmversations: @nathancofnas and I discuss hereditarianism and other heresies -- including “high IQ antisemitism”😅 -- link below!
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"women are less supportive of free speech for both right- and left-wing views...Men often supported the free speech of their political opponents more than women supported the free speech of their allies." ncofnas.com/p/dont-scapegoat-women
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Don't Scapegoat Women": ncofnas.com/p/dont-scapegoat-women
Wokism is an idea-driven ideology that predates the Great Feminization by more than a century -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
For reasons not understood by @nytimes, seeing "the true form of DNA" caused James Watson to have "racist ideas"
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Hate mail from Chris Rufo
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
He was triggered by this:
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Finally conservatives will have a voice on campus to talk about the Bible and deny vaccines until Gavin Newsome becomes president and cancels everything.
There are tears in my eyes. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
Hard to believe it’s only been a year since the American right had its greatest victory in modern history—winning the presidency and Congress—and look at them now. It’s just a clown show, where white nationalists compete for clout with Holocaust deniers and conspiracy idiots, all paid or promoted by various foreign enemy states. What a farce.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Freedomain - with Stefan Molyneux, MA
@StefanMolyneux
People who proudly admit that they value lying shouldn’t be believed in anything, it’s really not that complicated
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Robert Sternberg literally admitted that he thinks "respect [for] the truth" needs to be balanced against the "repugnant or even questionable" political implications of scientific investigation. Now he accuses race realists of "find[ing] ways to defend [their ideology] even if it's not factually accurate."
Sternberg (2005): "Scientists might argue that their work is value free and that they are not responsible for the repugnant or even questionable values or actions of opportunistic leaders. [Hereditarians believe] that they do perform a kind of value-free science and that they merely respect the truth. [But] deciding to study group differences represents a value judgment—that the problem is worth studying....The quality of science is determined not only by the quality of problem solving but also by taste in the selection of problems to solve....Would that [hereditarians] had devoted their penetrating intellects to other more scientifically and socially productive problems!"
Channel 5
@Channel5iveNews
Cornell Professor Robert Sternberg debunks race-based IQ statistics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Finally conservatives will have a voice on campus to talk about the Bible and deny vaccines until Gavin Newsome becomes president and cancels everything.
There are tears in my eyes. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Robert Sternberg literally admitted that he thinks "respect [for] the truth" needs to be balanced against the "repugnant or even questionable" political implications of scientific investigation. Now he accuses race realists of "find[ing] ways to defend [their ideology] even if it's not factually accurate."
Sternberg (2005): "Scientists might argue that their work is value free and that they are not responsible for the repugnant or even questionable values or actions of opportunistic leaders. [Hereditarians believe] that they do perform a kind of value-free science and that they merely respect the truth. [But] deciding to study group differences represents a value judgment—that the problem is worth studying....The quality of science is determined not only by the quality of problem solving but also by taste in the selection of problems to solve....Would that [hereditarians] had devoted their penetrating intellects to other more scientifically and socially productive problems!"
Channel 5
@Channel5iveNews
Cornell Professor Robert Sternberg debunks race-based IQ statistics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Sternberg's friend in deception Howard Gardner:
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I've documented numerous academics saying that it's good to lie about race and IQ in the service of anti-racism: philpapers.org/archive/COFSIN.pdf
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
He proudly says he got an F in statistics class which explains a lot.
Fuentes Updates
@FuentesUpdates
Nick Fuentes gets asked if he's ever had a “real job.”
“First of all, I'm rich. Second of all, you should avoid having a real job.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thank god skin color isn't moralized or we'd have to spend our lives fighting about whether melanin is a social construct, color is determined by a "culture of tanning," and African albinos prove that anyone can have light skin
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Fain Lehman
@CharlesFLehman
I spend a lot of time writing about how we should prosecute Pornhub. Whoever wrote this tweet and decided to play "spot the Jew" in the process is, among other things, undermining those of us who think there's a legitimate case for enforcing federal law.
Kevin Roberts
@KevinRobertsTX
Thank you, @JonHaidt, for reminding everyone @Heritage yesterday that tech tycoons like Leonid Radvinsky and Solomon Friedman are profiting to the tune of millions by preying on America's young men and women.
We are proud to be in this fight with you. It is time to arrest, prosecute, and convict the sick perverts behind OnlyFans and PornHub. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The violence "follows them"
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
UC Berkeley has a new super important finding. It turns out that violent people are still violent when they move somewhere else.
Neither the press release/summary and the article has any mentions of genetics. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Yan Q.
@armsq17
Nice to see Elon calling out blank slatism. The window of opportunity for the Hereditarian Revolution will not stay open for long.
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
@nathancofnas
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
Elon is calling out blank slatism.
Never blackpill. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Why are we forced to choose between Hitler apologetics and "I would happily trade [white people] for a good weekly chicken tikka masala"
Bricktop_NAFO
@Bricktop_NAFO
Tucker Carlson, has to be, the biggest fucking idiot on the planet.
Just listen to this.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was seriously considering switching my party affiliation to Democrat until I saw this video
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
That's the whole point. For the first time in 2000 years, there are consequences to killing Jews. With this image in their brains, people will think twice before they try to do it again.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I'm suspicious of @ComicDaveSmith's claim to be a Jew not because he's an anti-Semite, but because he's this much of a dumbass
Dave Smith
@ComicDaveSmith
This is fucking wild. I’m hoping this isn’t true but if it is, they should know that taking out Candace Owens will turn all of us into Candace Owens.
Candace Owens
@RealCandaceO
🚨 URGENT
Two days ago I was contacted by a high-ranking employee of the French Government. After determining this person’s position and proximity to the French couple, I have deemed the information they gave me to be credible enough to share publicly in the event that something happens.
In short, this person claims that the Macrons have executed upon and paid for my assassination. Yes, you read that correctly. More specifically, that the green light was given to a small team in National Gendamarie Intervention Group. I am told there is one Israeli that is on this assasination squad and the plans were formalized.
Again, this person provided concrete proof that they are well placed within the French government apparatus.
Further to this point, this person claims that Charlie Kirk’s assassin trained with the French legion 13th brigade with multi-state involvement.
Journalist Xavier Poussard’s life is also at risk. This is deadly serious. The head of state of France apparently wants us both dead and has authorized professional units to carry this out.
I ask that every person RETWEET and share this.
I do not know who in the American government can be trusted, since this source claims our leaders are aware. But I have more specific information which is definitively verifiable, should they care to reach out to me.
To the brave official in France who did this because they were so moved by the evil of Charlie’s public execution to risk their own life— May God bless you. Truly.
Let all be revealed. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Freedomain - with Stefan Molyneux, MA
@StefanMolyneux
There are decades when nothing happens.
There are weeks when decades happen.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A lot has changed since last month
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If smart people don't exercise paternalistic control over the informational environment, 1/3 of the population will follow a literal schizo
Candace Owens
@RealCandaceO
🚨 URGENT
Two days ago I was contacted by a high-ranking employee of the French Government. After determining this person’s position and proximity to the French couple, I have deemed the information they gave me to be credible enough to share publicly in the event that something happens.
In short, this person claims that the Macrons have executed upon and paid for my assassination. Yes, you read that correctly. More specifically, that the green light was given to a small team in National Gendamarie Intervention Group. I am told there is one Israeli that is on this assasination squad and the plans were formalized.
Again, this person provided concrete proof that they are well placed within the French government apparatus.
Further to this point, this person claims that Charlie Kirk’s assassin trained with the French legion 13th brigade with multi-state involvement.
Journalist Xavier Poussard’s life is also at risk. This is deadly serious. The head of state of France apparently wants us both dead and has authorized professional units to carry this out.
I ask that every person RETWEET and share this.
I do not know who in the American government can be trusted, since this source claims our leaders are aware. But I have more specific information which is definitively verifiable, should they care to reach out to me.
To the brave official in France who did this because they were so moved by the evil of Charlie’s public execution to risk their own life— May God bless you. Truly.
Let all be revealed. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A lot has changed since last month
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
One of Billie Eilish's fallacies is a false understanding of what "wealth" is.
@elonmusk's "wealth" is mostly ledger entries stored in computers. These 0s and 1s are *not* the same thing as goods and services. He isn't hording 700 billion pounds of food or 100,000 anti-poaching rangers in his garage.
If Elon buys 700 billion lb of food to send to Africa, this does not in itself create more food or the means to deliver it. Rather, the price of food will go up, and some people will get less than before.
Of course, by placing large orders, Elon incentivizes people to go into food production. So in the end there will be more food overall. But this means paying people to divert their labor from *other* productive activities to farming. More food production means fewer nonagricultural goods and services. Many people (not necessarily Elon) will have to pay in tangible benefits.
When Jeff Bezos employs ten thousand workers to build him a yacht, he is using limited resources (labor and material) for something that benefits only himself. This can be morally criticized. But merely having wealth on paper is, strictly speaking, irrelevant.
The free market sometimes fails to allocate resources in a "morally" ideal way. For example, people spend money on AI pornography rather than protecting elephants or subsidizing philosophers of biology. In these circumstances, charity can help correct course. But very few social problems can be solved by throwing money at them—at least not without creating other problems that @billieeilish & Co may not anticipate.
Pop Base
@PopBase
Billie Eilish calls out Elon Musk for not using his wealth to aid humanity and resolve global issues:
“f***ing pathetic p***y b**** coward” -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Comedian goes on the biggest platforms in the US bobbing his stupid head and spewing a conspiracy theory. Turns out it's all based on misremembered info and factual errors.
When called out: "I'm not a historian writing a book, I'm a guy talking about these issues to the American people."
Expertise is real. Ignorant podcast bros have not found a magic shortcut to knowledge.
Marina Medvin 🇺🇸
@MarinaMedvin
Coleman Hughes wipes the floor with Dave Smith. Absolute masterclass.
Listen and learn.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Reminder of the time Tucker texted me after I pointed out he was spreading Russian disinformation about about Ukrainian weapons being sold on the Internet.
I asked him for evidence for his views and you can see how it went.
This is the person Kevin Roberts thinks contributes to “debate.”
Need to have open dialogue! He is such a valuable voice. A modern Socrates, with a passion for the search for knowledge. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“You said it’s wrong to call people Nazis when it’s false, but now you call people Nazis when it’s true. Very hypocritical.”
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
For a moment, as Charlie Kirk bled out from an assassin’s bullet, conservatives realized that the charge of fascist was an open justification for murder
Today Con Inc is calling everyone, including the Heritage Foundation,Nazis
They know what they’re doing -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
They have learned nothing
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
lol
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
David Gress
@DavidGr08051597
Everyone interested in the current state and possible future of reason, civilization, and liberty must read
@nathancofnas's
latest.
He explains why smart people believe important false things about the world, such as the idea that socially relevant traits are distributed equally among all r*ces and s*xes, why the right is incompetent at combating such false ideas, and how it still might be done.
Link in reply. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 2013, @Heritage fired Jason Richwine because his Harvard PhD dissertation talked about race differences.
It's literally easier for me to be hired by Cambridge than to get a foot in the door at any conservative think tank.
But when it comes to Nick Fuentes and Tucker Carlson, "We will always defend truth...we will always defend our friends against the slander of bad actors [Jews?] who serve someone else's agenda....Canceling [Fuentes] is not the answer."
The right could have beaten the left with science. But those were unacceptable terms for conservatives. In their heart, they are medieval peasants who recoil at science as if it were witchcraft (something they are also very concerned about, and may not clearly distinguish from science).
The low IQ left and right converge when it comes to economics, thuggery, and Jewish issues. Going forward, the war will be primarily between the right tail end of the bell curve (regardless of race and political orientation) and the fat center left.
Kevin Roberts
@KevinRobertsTX
There has been speculation that @Heritage is distancing itself from @TuckerCarlson over the past 24 hours.
I want to put that to rest right now—here are my thoughts:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The future of US politics is likely to be AOC/Mamdani vs. Nick Fuentes.
It is definitely *not* going to be Rufo's ideology of "colorblindness" astroturfed by Jewish boomer billionaires.
Total failure by Con, Inc.
The great issue of our time is racial disparities. But conservative gatekeepers shut out everyone on their own side who tells the truth that evolution doesn't stop above the neck. To be a mainstream figure on the right, you have to be willing to lie (pretend that race is skin deep) and fight the left with both hands tied behind your back (not point out that wokism is based on a false empirical premise). For anyone not on Paul Singer's payroll, this isn't an attractive proposition.
Every right-wing zoomer who grew up with the Internet knows that the Big Lie is a lie. Fuentes is a liar and an ignoramus, but at least he's not shoving "the bigotry of low expectations" and "Dems are the real racists" down white men's throats. He is the kind of leader you get when the institutions with "standards" totally discredit themselves. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Tucker when a liberal disagrees with rightists: THESE ARE SICK PEOPLE WHO WANT YOU DEAD
Tucker when told by Nick Fuentes that he likes Stalin: Interesting perspective. Let’s circle back to that. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
derek guy
@dieworkwear
So many conservative complaints about modern life go back to this unshakable belief that they would have been part of the upper classes if this were the 1930s.
In the 1930s, a Pullman day trip cost about £2 – 3, which was equivalent to a week's worth of wages for the average blue-collar worker. Or about four days' wages for the average white-collar earner. That means it was about 1.5 – 2% of their annual income, making it a real luxury experience. Most Britons never traveled abroad or dined in style, let alone experienced a Pullman trip.
Worth remembering that, at this time, a larger section of society was blue collar, so the chances of you earning that white collar wage was slimmer than it is today.
Today, a Pullman trip costs £340 - 500, depending on the amenities you want. That's about two to four days of pay for a modern full-time worker (earning ~£700/week). Or roughly 1 – 1.3% of their annual income.
So it's the opposite of what you suggest: such travel has become more affordable for the average person, not less. In fact, real luxury travel experiences today have moved beyond being served tea in a dining train car, but you also simply have to be willing to pay for those experiences.
Geiger Capital
@Geiger_Capital
When it’s a luxury to travel like the past instead of the future, and it’s better in every possible way than the present, you need to accept that something has gone very wrong.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This level of anti-whitism is only possible in Scandinavia, which is one of the least Jewish regions in Europe. Denmark has only 6,500 Jews (0.1% of the population).
The most pro-western country in Europe, Hungary, has one of the largest Jewish populations (80,000 in Budapest).
Kevin MacDonald's explanation for why Sweden is the wokest country on Earth is that, in the 1960s, a Jew named David Schwartz wrote 37 articles in Swedish newspapers defending multiculturalism. But I'm not sure how this explains what's happening in Denmark, or why the Jews spared Hungary.
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
In this Danish state-sponsored television we see an ethnic Danish couple.
Then an authority figure scientist comes in and says that if we don't mate with foreigners from the Middle East we will die out from inbreeding. (Not true of course.)
And that if they want to give their children the best chances in life, they should find a more exotic partner.
Grotesque levels of anti-Danish propaganda and misinformation.
[Clip is in Danish; you can put on close captioning.] -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Latest from the medieval peasant wing of the right
Lauren Chen
@TheLaurenChen
Usury is a sin, the Bible is explicitly clear on this
Muslims structure their banking and financial systems specifically to avoid it, why can't Christians? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
Free institutions don’t tell academics how they should reason their way from premise to conclusion, nor should they say that certain questions are prohibited from the off.
A victory in the case of Nathan Cofnas will be a watershed moment for academic freedom in the UK.
Read more in @Telegraph 👇 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“Why hello there, Mister Hitler 1488 A$$ Pirate. I saw you posted that six million were not enough, but wanted to point out that this contradicted your earlier position that the Holocaust didn’t happen. I didn’t want to say anything publicly since we’re both on the right, but hopefully you will issue a correction, as I am familiar with what high intellectual standards you hold yourself to.”
This holding up being publicly deferential to Nazis as some great moral principle is pathetic.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
If you're a conservative and you have a problem with someone on the Right, you can reach out to them privately and express your concerns. Performatively attacking and denouncing your own people in public is a bitch move.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
Academic freedom matters most when contested work is controversial or offensive. Free debate legitimises knowledge: when this freedom is curtailed, even true ideas cease to be rationally justified.
My latest for @Quillette: "A Heretic Reprieved".
quillette.com/2025/10/16/a-heretic-reprieved-nathan-cofna… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Emmanuel College has an unenviable task ahead. Reverse-ferret and stand by free speech, or insist on its DEI principles? Hereditarianism is guaranteed more airtime, either way." www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/c0575c1b05f88908
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Cofnas cements his position as the best living conservative philosopher. Great piece.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Beating Woke with Facts and Logic": ncofnas.com/p/beating-woke-with-facts-and-logic
When you think of a woke leftist, you might picture a blue-haired, septum-pierced she/they waving a “Queers for Palestine” placard and screaming into a megaphone. People like that exist. They will not be swayed by an “information campaign” about hereditarianism or anything else that contradicts their ideology.
But it would be a mistake to conclude that information campaigns are never effective. Advances in science and philosophy always reach intellectual elites first, and sometimes trickle down to the plebeians over the course of decades or centuries.
cc @christopherrufo -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My ideas sound naive when straw manned by you (see, e.g., below). You've never engaged with me in good faith.
Last week, Cambridge made an official announcement that what I wrote is an expression of academic freedom. A major victory for free speech in the UK. You don't know what you're talking about.
Now you say you will put your fingers in your ears and not listen to what I have to say until I achieve the hereditarian revolution by myself in the face of opposition from the entire Con Inc establishment including you. More bad faith.
I admire your will to power. But replacing Claudine Gay with Alan Garber and taking over the New College of Florida—though it may look good on your CV—ain't gonna stop AOC or Gavin Newsom from becoming president when the MAGA mob of low-IQ third worldists screws everything up. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Beating Woke with Facts and Logic": ncofnas.com/p/beating-woke-with-facts-and-logic
When you think of a woke leftist, you might picture a blue-haired, septum-pierced she/they waving a “Queers for Palestine” placard and screaming into a megaphone. People like that exist. They will not be swayed by an “information campaign” about hereditarianism or anything else that contradicts their ideology.
But it would be a mistake to conclude that information campaigns are never effective. Advances in science and philosophy always reach intellectual elites first, and sometimes trickle down to the plebeians over the course of decades or centuries.
cc @christopherrufoPost not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Your legacy may end up being President AOC and a right-wing opposition led by Nick Fuentes. It's far too early to claim that *your* approach has been validated.
It would be unfortunate if you decide not to engage intellectually with the hereditarian right. I'm the one making the argument out loud, but many people agree with me (including more than 10 faculty members at Cambridge).Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My ideas sound naive when straw manned by you (see, e.g., below). You've never engaged with me in good faith.
Last week, Cambridge made an official announcement that what I wrote is an expression of academic freedom. A major victory for free speech in the UK. You don't know what you're talking about.
Now you say you will put your fingers in your ears and not listen to what I have to say until I achieve the hereditarian revolution by myself in the face of opposition from the entire Con Inc establishment including you. More bad faith.
I admire your will to power. But replacing Claudine Gay with Alan Garber and taking over the New College of Florida—though it may look good on your CV—ain't gonna stop AOC or Gavin Newsom from becoming president when the MAGA mob of low-IQ third worldists screws everything up. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Changing worldviews at the level @nathancofnas describes doesn’t happen in a single generation—but that doesn’t mean the work shouldn’t be done. New babies are being born everyday and they don’t come equipped with Marxist ideology.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Your legacy may end up being President AOC and a right-wing opposition led by Nick Fuentes. It's far too early to claim that *your* approach has been validated.
It would be unfortunate if you decide not to engage intellectually with the hereditarian right. I'm the one making the argument out loud, but many people agree with me (including more than 10 faculty members at Cambridge). -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
What is "hereditarianism" and how does it differ from "wokeism?"
Inquiring minds want to know which is why I discussed this consequential topic with @NathanCofnas over two episodes. Here's the first: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/race-iq-sowell-with-nathan-… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
"The vast majority of intelligent, psychologically stable, and public-spirited Americans remain left and woke."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Beating Woke with Facts and Logic": ncofnas.com/p/beating-woke-with-facts-and-logic
When you think of a woke leftist, you might picture a blue-haired, septum-pierced she/they waving a “Queers for Palestine” placard and screaming into a megaphone. People like that exist. They will not be swayed by an “information campaign” about hereditarianism or anything else that contradicts their ideology.
But it would be a mistake to conclude that information campaigns are never effective. Advances in science and philosophy always reach intellectual elites first, and sometimes trickle down to the plebeians over the course of decades or centuries.
cc @christopherrufo -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
I encourage everyone to read @NathanCofnas's latest Substack. And if what he is saying resonates with you, check out Episodes 40 and 41 of The Genius of Thomas Sowell podcast to hear more from Nathan: tomsowell.com
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Beating Woke with Facts and Logic": ncofnas.com/p/beating-woke-with-facts-and-logic
When you think of a woke leftist, you might picture a blue-haired, septum-pierced she/they waving a “Queers for Palestine” placard and screaming into a megaphone. People like that exist. They will not be swayed by an “information campaign” about hereditarianism or anything else that contradicts their ideology.
But it would be a mistake to conclude that information campaigns are never effective. Advances in science and philosophy always reach intellectual elites first, and sometimes trickle down to the plebeians over the course of decades or centuries.
cc @christopherrufo -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
It's frustrating that this sort of remark isn't considered totally disqualifying and career-ending for a scientist.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Hunter Ash
@ArtemisConsort
If you’re a scientist giving a talk and you start describing all the things you care about more than the truth, the audience should descend upon you like the Bacchae and devour your flesh.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Cernovich
@Cernovich
This is why no one trusts The Science anymore.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
I'm aware of this quote, and could never understand a mentality like that. Isn't being correct what it's all about?
Two curious factoids:
Howard and I were classmates at Harvard. We were not acquainted then. My later interactions with him have always been collegial, even genial.
Howard has been at Harvard since he arrived as a freshman in 1961 to this day with the exception of two one-year fellowships elsewhere. From age 18 to 82 (and counting) swathed in the Harvard cocoon.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Lmao what a fraud
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Life is short, believe whatever you want!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Howard Gardner (Harvard professor and inventor of "multiple intelligences" theory):
"Even if...the bad guys [who emphasize the importance of IQ] turn out to be more correct scientifically than I am, life is short, and we have to make choices about how we spend our time. And that's where I think the multiple intelligences way of thinking about things will continue to be useful even if the scientific evidence doesn't support it."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
How being correct morally but not scientifically is rewarded in academia
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
We would like to express our sincere thanks to those who've supported Nathan Cofnas's fight for academic freedom. Thanks to your generosity Nathan is nearly ready to take his claim to trial. With a little more help, we will be able to fund the best representation available.
Our confidence in Nathan’s case is confirmed by the decision of the University of Cambridge to take no disciplinary action against him. As reported in the Times, Cambridge has acknowledged its obligation to "secure and promote freedom of speech and provide an environment for open and sometimes robust debate".
Emmanuel College, however, continues to defend its decision to dismiss Nathan, leaving him with no choice but to ask the court to uphold his right to academic freedom. In light of the University’s decision to uphold Nathan’s academic freedom, we think Emmanuel’s position is untenable.
The trial will take place on a date to be confirmed between November this year and January next year. We remain convinced that victory in Nathan’s claim will be a watershed moment for academic freedom in the United Kingdom. If we can establish the freedom to research this intensely controversial area, then we will have succeeded in setting a very high bar for any attempt to censor academics.
Nathan has worked tremendously hard to secure further funding, and has received a match-funding offer of £30,000. We are asking for your generous further help to unlock this offer – if we can match it, then every pound you give up to that amount will be matched by the donor. This will enable Nathan to retain the services of Tom Cross KC, a leading advocate in freedom of speech and conscience cases.
If you are able to, please help Nathan get across the line and win this case (link in reply). -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Jewish race realist singularity
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The internet has spoken: race and IQ is more important than the meaning of life, gender, or God
www.youtube.com/watch?v=77prDNpFiSk -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Laurie Wastell
@L_Wastell
Fantastic that Cambridge has dismissed complaints against @nathancofnas. As I wrote @spectator last year: “You don’t have to agree with what Cofnas wrote to see that the fact he might be fired for expressing his views violates fundamental principles of academic freedom.”
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"You would do me a favor by purchasing one of each, for me....If they are good workmen, they may be of Asia, Africa, or Europe. They may be Mahomedans, Jews, or Christian of any Sect—or they may be Atheists."
All races welcome as slaves =/= open borders for a welfare state
Frank Luntz
@FrankLuntz
In a 1784 letter, George Washington named Muslims among the people he hoped would find welcome in America:
“If they are good workmen, they may be of Asia, Africa, or Europe. They may be Mohammedans, Jews, or Christians of any sect, or they may be Atheists.”
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
On closer inspection, a slave owning white man in 1784 didn't have the same views as a 21st century shitlib. Who could have guessed?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 1859, two important books were published
- John Stuart Mill's "On Liberty," which argues that classical liberalism is morally right
- Darwin's "On the Origin of Species," which explains why a community of classical liberals can't survive for more than two generations
Dr. Maalouf
@realMaalouf
In Germany, a Syrian refugee polygamous family is causing outrage.
Ahmad lives with his 2 wives and 6 children in a free house. He says he’s looking for 2 more wives and wants to have 20 children.
He is illiterate, does not work, and says his only goal is to have many children to ‘make Germany more Muslim.’This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"their hypocrisy doesn't justify a complacent attitude today from any of us...We mustn't be hypocrites"
Not being a hypocrite = we support the other side's free speech, but as soon as they get power they immediately censor us? There's a limit to how much of this we can take.
Robert P. George
@McCormickProf
What Jimmy Kimmel suggested to be true --namely, that Charlie Kirk's assassin was MAGA--was false. Did he know when he said it that it was false? I don't know. Did he have reason to know it was false? Yes, but ideology warps people's heads. In any case, we should not want public officials pressuring companies to fire or discipline people for their First Amendment protected speech--even when it's false. It is simply too great a threat to civil liberty. Democrats and liberals are saying that now, but (with honorable exceptions) they have no credibility. When the shoe was on the other foot during the Biden years, they were not ardent free speech defenders. They did not raise their voices against government officers pressuring media outlets and platforms. Too often, they allowed themselves to become apologists for it. Shame on them. But their hypocrisy doesn't justify a complacent attitude today from any of us when government officials pressure media outlets on speech issues. Those of us who did defend First Amendment principles during the Biden years need to be no less outspoken in defending them today. We mustn't be hypocrites. It's bad when media disseminate falsehoods, but the way to fight back is by telling the truth--exercising our own free speech rights to condemn the lying and the liars. It's simply unsafe to trust government officials with the power to, in effect, regulate First Amendment protected speech. It is power too easily abused.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This would have been a valid criticism:
"Trump made me realize that gov't interference in private speech has always been wrong even when Michelle got Roseanne Barr fired, Kamala demanded that Trump be kicked off Twitter, and Biden admin collaborated with social media censors."
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
After years of complaining about cancel culture, the current administration has taken it to a new and dangerous level by routinely threatening regulatory action against media companies unless they muzzle or fire reporters and commentators it doesn’t like. www.yahoo.com/news/articles/let-clear-happened-jimmy-kimm…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Leftists like to compare race and IQ research to flat earthism.
But for some reason there was never a geophysics paper that said "We could not analyze the shape of the earth because of ethics restrictions."
C0nye4ka
@Ze0mniKeynes1an
🗿
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Ratioed for reporting objective data without commentary
What does that say about the right?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Strong" Democrats vs. "strong" Republicans (whites only)
26% of Democrats are cognitive elites (WORDSUM score of at least 9 = IQ>120) compared to 11% of Republicans -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In the UK, journalists can literally make up quotes. I once complained to regulator @IpsoNews because the Daily Mail attributed fake quotes to me (incl. in a meritocracy Harvard would "have no black professors") and they said that's fine.
US journalism still has standards, to the chagrin of Pulitzer Prize winner @Laurie_Garrett.
Laurie Garrett
@Laurie_Garrett
The Washington Post fired Karen Attiah because she quoted Charlie Kirk, saying, "Black women do not have the brain processing power to be taken seriously. You have to go steal a white person's slot."
She added no comment -- merely an ACCURATE quote.
karenattiah.substack.com/p/the-washington-post-fired-me-b… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Strong" Democrats vs. "strong" Republicans (whites only)
26% of Democrats are cognitive elites (WORDSUM score of at least 9 = IQ>120) compared to 11% of Republicans -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
John McWhorter:
- the problem with wokism is it's racist against black people
- "basic premises of BLM" are correct
- race and IQ should be off limits
- Amy Wax shouldn't teach required courses
- Trump should be murdered
JM's reputation as a "heterodox" hero is based on nothing
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Conservative/heterodox gatekeepers are (for reasons I won't spell out) super sensitive about criticizing the great John McWhorter. For example, my article "Four Reasons Why Heterodox Academy Failed" was accepted for publication by a high-profile conservative magazine, but I had to withdraw it because the editor said I wasn't allowed to point out McWhorter's hypocrisy.
JM will definitely be fine at the New York Times no matter how many Republicans he says he wants to kill. Maybe Heterodox Academy will give him another Open Inquiry Award. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Very funny, but if the "debate" becomes a street fight, it's going to end for Team Bluesky the same way it did for 🇵🇸. I wouldn't egg conservatives on like this.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noam Blum
@neontaster
It's a bit too late to try to claim the moral high ground in the discourse when you first tweeted and then later deleted this:
The New Republic
@newrepublic
The Far Right Is Already Blaming the Left For Charlie Kirk’s Shooting newrepublic.com/post/200302/left-far-right-charlie-kirk-s…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I think the murder of Charlie Kirk is a bigger deal than you’re making it out to be, first, because of who he was, second, because it does say something about “the left.”
Kirk wasn’t an elected politician. If someone assassinated Trump, that would be wrong, but at least you could argue that there was provocation. Kirk’s thing was holding public debates. At least by the standards of American conservatism, he wasn’t that extreme. (In fact, he was one of the main forces opposing the Nazification of the right.) Are we now at risk when we give a talk at a university? This was different from killing a congressman.
We don’t know who the killer was or what his motives were. It could have been a groyper or a crazy person with no agenda at all. But most likely it was a leftist. And the left appears to be increasingly pro violence. There's widespread support for Hamas. Mainstream figures celebrated Luigi Mangione. Supposedly 57.6% of “left of center” Americans think it is at least “partially acceptable” to destroy a Tesla dealership. 55.2% say it is at least “somewhat justified” to kill Trump. (You could argue that this is a response to Trump’s unique evil, but I suspect you’d have similar results for almost any Republican president.) Obviously, there are major problems on the right, but the left is also moving backwards. -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I think the murder of Charlie Kirk is a bigger deal than you’re making it out to be, first, because of who he was, second, because it does say something about “the left.”
Kirk wasn’t an elected politician. If someone assassinated Trump, that would be wrong, but at least you could argue that there was provocation. Kirk’s thing was holding public debates. At least by the standards of American conservatism, he wasn’t that extreme. (In fact, he was one of the main forces opposing the Nazification of the right.) Are we now at risk when we give a talk at a university? This was different from killing a congressman.
We don’t know who the killer was or what his motives were. It could have been a groyper or a crazy person with no agenda at all. But most likely it was a leftist. And the left appears to be increasingly pro violence. There's widespread support for Hamas. Mainstream figures celebrated Luigi Mangione. Supposedly 57.6% of “left of center” Americans think it is at least “partially acceptable” to destroy a Tesla dealership. 55.2% say it is at least “somewhat justified” to kill Trump. (You could argue that this is a response to Trump’s unique evil, but I suspect you’d have similar results for almost any Republican president.) Obviously, there are major problems on the right, but the left is also moving backwards. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Unless the killer was an anarchist neo-Nazi, the murder of Charlie Kirk will have the opposite of its intended effect.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
Mentions in the New York Times:
- George Floyd: 5313
- Trayvon Martin: 1149
- Daniel Penny: 91
- Michael Brown: 2652
Iryna Zarutska has only been mentioned 1 time and it’s in an article upset with the Right for caring. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I would have been surprised to see @DineshDSouza capitalizing "Black" but not "white," except I immediately knew that @nytimes had doctored the quote
Dinesh D'Souza
@DineshDSouza
The reason for the media silence is racial. If the killer were white, this would get coverage. Of course if it were a white assailant murdering a black victim, then it would be front-page headlines everywhere.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@nytimes finally found a reason to report on this story: conservatives are mad about the "perceived failings of Democratic policies"
Article includes a helpful reference to "a white supremacist uprising in Wilmington, N.C., in 1898, in which at least 60 Black men were killed." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Boomer liberals aren't "self hating" at all. No boomer ever gave up *his* position because "white people have been at the top for a long time now so it's someone else's turn to get ahead." It's you (millennial/zoomer) who must pay for the boomer's virtue.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Corey Walker 🇺🇸
@CoreyWriting
I'm wondering if Glenn Greenwald, Ryan Grim, Tucker Carlson, Krystal Ball, Medhi Hasan, and the rest of the left-wing podcast universe will issue a retraction or if they will just brush this off as if it never happened. I think I know the answer.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
Terence Tao, signing an open letter in 2020: "We are enraged at the everyday operations of a white supremacist society. ... Complicity with these systems of oppression is deeply rooted in the origins of this country."
He signed onto the politicization of the academy.
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
Terence Tao:
"This is not a routine policy shift - it is a deliberate dismantling of the institutions, funding, and freedoms that have sustained American science for generations." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Two days apart
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
(a) Thinks it's offensive to ask for evidence for emotionally charged claims
(b) Immediately falls for hoax, accidentally sides with "Adolf Hitler"
Incidents like (b) would be less likely to occur if @paulg changed (a)
Ben Green
@BenGreenJeru
Has a Tweet ever aged as badly as this???
8 million views. Lol. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Just another version of blank slatism, which is an indirect route back to wokism.
If blacks and whites are born on average the same, why do black men abandon their families more than white men? It must be some cultural difference—but what is responsible for *that*? If you rule out genes, the most obvious explanation is past or present white racism.
Maybe @MattWalshBlog will say blacks are responsible for fixing their own culture. But the majority of intelligent, morally sensitive blank slatists think that it matters where the bad culture came from. If (past or present) whites created conditions that led to such disparate outcomes favoring whites over blacks, whites have a moral responsibility to fix the problem. And that's what wokism is.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
80 percent of black children in Chicago are born to single mothers. If black women in the city stopped having kids before marriage, and if black men stopped abandoning their families, the crime problem would go away overnight. Just the slightest bit of self-control would fix all of this. But Brandon doesn't mention that. I wonder why.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
- "Punch me, go on, go on, punch me, punch me, go on, punch me, keep going" said while charging an angry police officer
- Gets punched
- Appeals to authorities, why was I punched?
Kitty O'Brien: a perfect representative for the Palestinian cause
Visegrád 24
@visegrad24
The Irish Ambassador to Germany has lodged a complaint after the Irish far-left activist Kitty O’Brien was punched in the face by a young German police officer during an anti-Israel protest in Germany
🇮🇪🇩🇪🇮🇱This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Education failed to translate into economic gains in Ghana, at least according to the usually unreliable African data.
Alex
@notcomplex_
It's actually quite understated how much Africa has improved in terms of health and schooling, but it hasn't translated into productivity.
So Africans receive more education than that of 1950s England, but are far worse off. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Mark Humphrys
@markhumphrys
Gazans: This is not a war! This is a famine and a genocide!
Opinion poll: Do you want it to end?
Gazans: No. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"science needs to address deep problems in its culture"
People have been saying this for decades, and it gets worse every year.
The time for quoting John Stuart Mill and talking about intellectual diversity is over. Time to pull the plug.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Evidence that woke isn't dead, peer review is problematic, and science needs to address deep problems in its culture: A grad student at Harvard conducted the first systematic, data-based study to document & explain the rise in gender dysphoria. His paper was rejected from a leading journal because, among other things, "Throughout the manuscript, the authors use language that is considered prejudicial and outdated (e.g., "natal sex" as opposed to "sex assigned at birth"). It is critical to follow best practice and guidelines surrounding gender inclusive language, particularly for research specifically on the topic of gender incongruence, expression, and identity."
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Fareed Zakaria or WaPo could do a great job dunking on Candace Owens (minus the 9/11 truthism). They don't because they can't be bothered with the freak show that is the online right.
In the land of idiots, the man smarter than a Daily Wire affirmative action hire is king.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I’ve never seen a funnier or more effective takedown of a conspiracy theorist. The disinformation community needs to be paying this man. He absolutely destroys Candace Owens.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Who has the highest social status (broadly construed)?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Women with $65k/year jobs in HR think a plumber making $90k/year isn't their "equal" because he doesn't have a BA in sociology
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
A friend once pointed out to me that if a woman says something objectionable and your impulse is to treat her as a man and say "You're a fucking idiot," you will be deemed a sexist. But if your impulse is to let it slide because she is a woman, you will be deemed a sexist.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Men might talk to men like this but when done to a woman, it invokes a sexist dynamic"
A large proportion of perceived "sexism" is when women are treated the same as men
Dr Daisy Dixon
@daisyldixon
a man I once met explained to me for 10min what philosophy is after I told him I teach & write it for a living. I love DM but I refuse to be told that this interaction was just a 'conversation'. Men might talk to men like this but when done to a woman, it invokes a sexist dynamic
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Men might talk to men like this but when done to a woman, it invokes a sexist dynamic"
A large proportion of perceived "sexism" is when women are treated the same as men
Dr Daisy Dixon
@daisyldixon
a man I once met explained to me for 10min what philosophy is after I told him I teach & write it for a living. I love DM but I refuse to be told that this interaction was just a 'conversation'. Men might talk to men like this but when done to a woman, it invokes a sexist dynamic
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is what "woke is over" looks like outside of X and the MAGAverse
Sensurround
@ShamashAran
Dealing with leftists:
I got yelled at for using the word "niggling" in a meeting. Someone screeched at me for using a "racist word"
I then explained the etymology, which is from old english via norway.
"Well it sounds bad and makes me uncomfortable."
I expect a note from HR soon. This'll be fun. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
To be a right-wing thought leader, it's not enough to be dumb. You also have to be a liar.
Jake Shields
@jakeshieldsajj
It was a jew who shot Christian children
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
One of the first articles I ever published (in 2017) was about how we should be more skeptical of academic experts, and we need to take Jeffrey Epstein's crimes more seriously.
Hard to imagine that, just eight years ago, that was the rational position. web.archive.org/web/20180816043444/http://www.weeklystand… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
National Conservatism means not being libertarian (i.e. right about economics) or "racialist" (i.e. right about human nature, society, education, or history).
Who is astroturfing this absurd ideology? I've never met a NatCon IRL who wasn't directly associated with Yoram Hazony.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Besides Trump, the right doesn't have "leaders." You get status by repeating whatever your audience believes in an entertaining way. If you try to correct the mob, they will immediately write you off as a liar, an idiot, and/or part of a conspiracy.
Another example: Ben Shapiro and Charlie Kirk both tried to point out that the Epstein story is a nothing burger and people should let it go. Rightoids didn't try to understand their position—they just piled on until Shapiro and Kirk went back to giving them what they want.
The left has its "expert" class, which is often incompetent and corrupt. But at least leftists understand in principle that someone with intelligence, training, and experience can know more than someone without those things. They see the advantage of looking for guidance to those who know more than you in a given area.
"Follow the experts" isn't a perfect heuristic but it's better than rightoid groupthink that has no logic at all.
Gurwinder
@G_S_Bhogal
Vivid illustration of audience capture.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This refutes every popular theory for why birth rates are so low
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In high school I had a history teacher who was a communist. We often argued and he gave me B's. As an experiment I wrote an over-the-top essay about how I'd seen the light and was now a communist myself. I was nervous, thinking the ruse was obvious and he would be mad. Got an A.
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
“88% of the students said they pretended to be more progressive than they are to succeed academically or socially. 80% of students said they submitted class work that misrepresented their real views to conform to the progressive views of the professor.” www.nytimes.com/2025/08/21/opinion/rufo-yarvin-trump-nihi…
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In college I didn't do that. The lesbian who taught intro to writing gave me a B-. Handful of punitive B's. GPA wasn't bad but not getting Latin honors meant I missed out on many opportunities.
My friends who "pretended" to be something they weren't eventually became that thing. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The data call this "not real."
In the Euro-Barometer and World Values Survey, lib-con orientation remains stable in all birth cohorts, except in regard to sex and gender issues, about which everyone became more *liberal* (on average). But younger generations are more liberal across the board than older ones.
In general, people don't change their minds on core issues after adolescence. Boomers are still quoting MLK on colorblindness because that's what they learned in the 60s and 70s. Woke millennials and zoomers who weren't de-brainwashed by age 20 are probably lost forever.
Footnote: OP herself is a radical feminist who thinks it's "conservative" to disagree with another kind of feminist. So even she isn't a clear example of the phenomenon she claims exists.
Lin 🇫🇮
@Lfromthenorth
Is there a name for the phenomenon of becoming more conservative as you get older?
I can't fucking fathom how I actually believed some of the things I did 10 years ago 🙈😂 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I spent years studying intelligence research but there's a dimension to stupidity I wasn't aware of.
Stupid people believe that they are intellectually superior and the fact that intelligent people speak (to them) incomprehensibly means expertise is fake and idiots should rule.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
"Genocide is a crime that can be committed without a single person dying."
Then, I'm fine with it.
The great weakness of the post-modernist is that word games do not actually change reality. If "genocide" now means "war," or even "teaching Hispanic kids in English," there are 100 fully justified genocides annually. #fuggouddahere
Alonso Gurmendi
@Alonso_GD
Genocide is not and has never been defined as “killing everyone in sight”. Since 1948 genocide is a crime that can be committed without a single person dying. This popular notion comes rather from exceptionalising the Holocaust’s Final Solution as the only “real” type of genocide
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alessandro Strumia
@AlessandroStru4
US academicians remained silent while the woke left took over their institutions, imposing its anti-scientific ideology, censorship, discrimination, DEI loyalty oaths.
Now they lost elections, and complain that the elected party tries an external reform.
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
Terence Tao:
"This is not a routine policy shift - it is a deliberate dismantling of the institutions, funding, and freedoms that have sustained American science for generations." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
2010: "If two adults love each other they should be allowed to get married"
2017: Teaching anal sex in kindergarten, mass mutilation of autistic girls and boys who play with dolls
People don't have a problem with a male cheerleader, but we've seen the slippery slope is real
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
oh no not a male cheerleader whatever shall we do where is my fainting couch
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In The Passing of the Great Race (1916), Madison Grant blamed race denial on "the dogma of the brotherhood of man" derived from the French Revolution.
Although the book was written at the height of Franz Boas's influence, Grant didn't mention him by name a single time. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
No conspiracy is needed to explain why MAGA falls so hard for Russian propaganda.
It’s a simple consequence of IQ polarization. Soviets never had a party in the US whose entire influencer class was this dumb.
Conservative low IQ is a national security issue. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Micro-Digressions: A Philosophy Podcast
@ADigressions
New episode with @nathancofnas. www.youtube.com/watch?v=ggyWQ1IlEj4&t=9s
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Vanguard James
@vanguardjames95
He's saying he thinks you guys are prone to conspiracy, oversimplification and bad epistemology. That you think it's a reference to Jewish supremacy demonstrates the validity of his accusation.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Reminds me of when white nationalists talk about how “what we want is no different from Al Sharpton.” Yeah, ok, most whites aren’t interested in that vision.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
We preserve Amazonian tribes to be human zoo animals or laboratory subjects.
Rural Americans want to be treated as equals, but demand we "preserve their culture" meaning everyone else has to subsidize them so they can avoid the discomfort of learning to live in the 21st century.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
If I said that it was important to “preserve the culture” of some primitive jungle tribe in the Amazon, everyone would nod in agreement. But if I say it’s important to preserve the culture of a small town in rural America, I’m denounced as a bigot. For Americans, the only culture we’re not supposed to preserve is our own.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
We preserve Amazonian tribes to be human zoo animals or laboratory subjects.
Rural Americans want to be treated as equals, but demand we "preserve their culture" meaning everyone else has to subsidize them so they can avoid the discomfort of learning to live in the 21st century.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
If I said that it was important to “preserve the culture” of some primitive jungle tribe in the Amazon, everyone would nod in agreement. But if I say it’s important to preserve the culture of a small town in rural America, I’m denounced as a bigot. For Americans, the only culture we’re not supposed to preserve is our own.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
American conservatives are basically medieval peasants with iPhones
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wesley Yang
@wesyang
It wasn’t until my mid-20’s, when I heard a Russian woman say “did you know he is a *Jew*??” that I encountered the visceral anti-semitism that has always been the normal baseline outside of the United States. One senses the United States ceasing to be exceptional in this way.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Hunter Ash
@ArtemisConsort
Anyone who wants to ban charging interest for lending money must be kept out of power. This would be as destructive to the economy as banning electricity. If you say usury is only “excessive” interest: whether interest is excessive depends on risk.
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
Christian leaders should be as passionate about attacking usury as they are other evils
It has destroyed our society but they never say a word -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
Hunter Ash
@ArtemisConsort
Anyone who wants to ban charging interest for lending money must be kept out of power. This would be as destructive to the economy as banning electricity. If you say usury is only “excessive” interest: whether interest is excessive depends on risk.
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
Christian leaders should be as passionate about attacking usury as they are other evils
It has destroyed our society but they never say a word -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
J.D. Haltigan, PhD 🏒👨💻
@JDHaltigan
Winning a war requires a raw masculine state of mind which has been purged from Western elites who are hyperfeminized and, accordingly, delusional about the way the world works.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Winning a war requires actions that are inconsistent with contemporary western ethics
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
My grandfather was an infantry officer in WW2, slated to be in the first wave on the beach in the invasion of Japan. It's probably thanks to the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki that I'm alive today.
But if I could go take those bombings back, I would. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Winning a war requires actions that are inconsistent with contemporary western ethics
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
My grandfather was an infantry officer in WW2, slated to be in the first wave on the beach in the invasion of Japan. It's probably thanks to the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki that I'm alive today.
But if I could go take those bombings back, I would.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Dave Smith's stock argument against Israel (repeated by Piers Morgan and others) is that the police wouldn't blow up a building to get a criminal hiding among civilians.
Right, because that's not a war. War isn't about meting out justice to individuals. It's a struggle between groups, many of whose members are on one side or the other due to an accident of birth or circumstance.
War victimizes innocent people. That's why it's a terrible crime to start a war unjustly. But if you subscribe to an ethical code that says it's impermissible to take action necessary to win, it just means that you'll lose to people who didn't kneecap themselves with WEIRD morality. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
"In his book, Why Race Matters, Michael Levin fantasizes about the president of the United States delivering a speech on race differences to a joint session of Congress and the American people. This is not the right way to introduce a radical scientific idea into the mainstream, just like it wouldn't have been a good way to promote evolutionary theory in the 19th century. We start with the intellectual elites—people who are capable of understanding the evidence—and let the culture tag along at its own pace. This is how wokism achieved power. The elites went woke in the 1950s, if not earlier. Over the next few decades, important institutions came to reflect their views." -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
"In his book, Why Race Matters, Michael Levin fantasizes about the president of the United States delivering a speech on race differences to a joint session of Congress and the American people. This is not the right way to introduce a radical scientific idea into the mainstream, just like it wouldn't have been a good way to promote evolutionary theory in the 19th century. We start with the intellectual elites—people who are capable of understanding the evidence—and let the culture tag along at its own pace. This is how wokism achieved power. The elites went woke in the 1950s, if not earlier. Over the next few decades, important institutions came to reflect their views." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
There's a traceable path from how Charles Murray was treated after the Bell Curve to the popularity of Nick Fuentes today
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The Nazification of the zoomer right is the fault of Con Inc gatekeepers who refused to allow responsible discussion about race.
The problem of persistent racial disparities is the central issue of our time. Normiecons say "liberals are the real racists" and blame the "bigotry of low expectations." The generation of right wingers that grew up with the Internet knows that genes are an important part of the story, and they're being lied to by the boomer/gen x guard that runs National Review, Heritage, NatCon, etc.
So when Nick Fuentes says that being "red pilled" on race means Holocaust denial, ZOGism, and Catholic nationalism, many people think, "He's not lying about race being skin deep. Maybe he's right about everything else. At least he has more credibility than National Review." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The Nazification of the zoomer right is the fault of Con Inc gatekeepers who refused to allow responsible discussion about race.
The problem of persistent racial disparities is the central issue of our time. Normiecons say "liberals are the real racists" and blame the "bigotry of low expectations." The generation of right wingers that grew up with the Internet knows that genes are an important part of the story, and they're being lied to by the boomer/gen x guard that runs National Review, Heritage, NatCon, etc.
So when Nick Fuentes says that being "red pilled" on race means Holocaust denial, ZOGism, and Catholic nationalism, many people think, "He's not lying about race being skin deep. Maybe he's right about everything else. At least he has more credibility than National Review." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 1938, the elected government of the Jewish people sent an army to massacre more than a thousand Germans. Nazi strikes against Jewish militants killed Jewish civilians among whom they were hiding (the "Holocaust"). But the Nazis promised to stop as soon as the Jews released their hostages. In response, the Jewish army sent Hitler a picture of a German hostage being forced to dig his own grave, yet the Nazis refused to give up.
It's amazing how Jews treat Palestinians exactly the same way they were treated by the Nazis. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alex Strudwick Young
@AlexTISYoung
I’ve been working with an IVF startup, @herasight, that has already screened hundreds of embryos. Today we come out of stealth with a paper showing that our predictors for 17 diseases — validated within-family — beat the competition, with improved performance in non-Europeans🧵
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 2009, @nytimes published an op-ed by Rashid Khalidi attributing the following quote to former IDF chief of staff Moshe Yaalon:
"The Palestinians must be made to understand in the deepest recesses of their consciousness that they are a defeated people."
The article went viral and was listed as the most-read article on the Times's website for at least a week.
A day after it was published, I emailed the Times pointing out that the quote was fake. Yaalon actually said that Palestinians should understand that terrorism would not make Israelis into a defeated people.
21 days later, the Times plagiarized my letter, publishing it as an "editors' note." But they added an insinuation that there is a possibility that the quote is real ("Its original source has not been found").
These mistakes only happen in one direction, and it's been like this for a long time.
NYTimes Communications
@NYTimesPR
We have appended an Editors' Note to a story about Mohammed Zakaria al-Mutawaq, a child in Gaza who was diagnosed with severe malnutrition. After publication, The Times learned that he also had pre-existing health problems. Read more below.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
The least the @nytimes could do, would be to post the correction of their starving boy story on their main site with 55 million followers. That would help mitigate the damage they have caused.
It speaks loudly that the original story was on the front page, top-of-the-fold right column, and the correction is on some Times PR site that no one follows.
The correction of a story published to 55 million followers was sent to only 80k followers. Clearly, a purposeful obfuscation to bury the retraction.
Why is the Editor in Chief Joseph Kahn @JosephKahn allowing this to happen, or worse, serving as a principal factor in the story and in the fake correction?
With a story of this prominence, he has to have been involved in the editing and in the strategy around the correction.
And stories like this lead lunatics to kill. It’s not just the reputational smear of a country, it’s a call to violence against Jews.
Tell me why I am wrong.
Open Source Intel
@Osint613
The New York Times published an image of a child in Gaza, claiming the child was “malnourished” due to Israel, on its main account with 55 million followers.
Five days later, it quietly posted a correction, stating the child actually had a muscle condition, on its alternate account with just 89 thousand followers. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
The Sydney Sweeney/American Eagle controversy touches a raw nerve because it triggers one of the fundamental tenets of wokism, which is the "equality thesis:"
The belief that all people are born equal and that only the environment determines differences in outcomes between groups.
@nathancofnas and I explore the equality thesis in depth in Episodes 40 and 41 of the podcast, especially how it relates to the writing of Thomas Sowell.
Highly recommend!
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/race-iq-sowell-with-nathan-…
Clay Travis
@ClayTravis
Holy crap, Good Morning America on Disney owned ABC ran a story this morning saying the Sydney Sweeney clothing ad is connected to Nazis. Legacy media is dead:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Look what jews made the pope say
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
Why do Jews get attacked over immigration in a way that Catholics do not?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Note the qualified nature of this headline. “No proof Hamas routinely stole UN aid.”
Ok.
Did it sometimes steal instead of “routinely”?
What about aid not from the UN?
Did they tax the food being sold within Gaza?
There’s a reason it’s worded this way. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
This is pretty much true. Everyone's a Communist in their house and ~socialist in their HOA.
But, it doesn't scale.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Socialism is compatible with human nature until you want to live in societies of more than 150 people and own something besides a loin cloth and a sharp stick
Patricia
@PatriciaNPino
“Socialism doesn’t understand human nature”
— Economist who has never opened a sociology or anthropology book in their lives. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Socialism is compatible with human nature until you want to live in societies of more than 150 people and own something besides a loin cloth and a sharp stick
Patricia
@PatriciaNPino
“Socialism doesn’t understand human nature”
— Economist who has never opened a sociology or anthropology book in their lives. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You're not answering my question. There are 1,000,000 Moroccan Jews in Israel. You claim they're stealing land (i.e., they don't belong in Israel). But posing as Moroccan is also theft. So what what land or food can they claim without it being theft, according to you?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@georgegalloway thinks that 1,000,000 Jews who were chased out of Morocco don't belong in Israel, and also that they have no business posing as Moroccans.
I'm curious, Mr Galloway, what food are Moroccan Jews allowed to eat? Where can they live on earth that isn't stolen land?Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You're not answering my question. There are 1,000,000 Moroccan Jews in Israel. You claim they're stealing land (i.e., they don't belong in Israel). But posing as Moroccan is also theft. So what what land or food can they claim without it being theft, according to you?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
This is fascinating, actually, and hadn't occurred to me at all. What a list.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
When I wrote "Twilight of the Liberal Jew" in 2023, I suggested that the most politically influential American Jews under the age of 40 were @benshapiro, @libsoftiktok, @StephenM, @ezraklein, and @finkd. Updating the list now (for <42 years old) I'd add @sama and @bariweiss. That's 4 on the moderate-to-far right, 2 moderates, and 1 classical liberal. Not a single commie or real progressive activist.
Intermarriage rates among liberal Jews have been ~70% for two generations. Jews who married each other (like Stephen Miller) are probably more likely to have nationalistic impulses, which will be inherited by their children. And young Jews exploring the political scene will confront a left that now sees being Jewish as the only thing worse than being white.
"Jewish" is becoming a right-wing identity. The stereotype is going to change!
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
These political shifts among Ivy League Jewish students are remarkable:
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
As always, @nathancofnas pulls zero punches.
I look forward to his Substacks and tweets, you never know what's going to come out of this pen.
I had him on the podcast twice and - you know what - I would have him on again the next chance I get!
If you haven't already listened, what are you waiting for?!
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/race-iq-sowell-with-nathan-…
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
When I wrote "Twilight of the Liberal Jew" in 2023, I suggested that the most politically influential American Jews under the age of 40 were @benshapiro, @libsoftiktok, @StephenM, @ezraklein, and @finkd. Updating the list now (for <42 years old) I'd add @sama and @bariweiss. That's 4 on the moderate-to-far right, 2 moderates, and 1 classical liberal. Not a single commie or real progressive activist.
Intermarriage rates among liberal Jews have been ~70% for two generations. Jews who married each other (like Stephen Miller) are probably more likely to have nationalistic impulses, which will be inherited by their children. And young Jews exploring the political scene will confront a left that now sees being Jewish as the only thing worse than being white.
"Jewish" is becoming a right-wing identity. The stereotype is going to change!
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
These political shifts among Ivy League Jewish students are remarkable:
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
When I wrote "Twilight of the Liberal Jew" in 2023, I suggested that the most politically influential American Jews under the age of 40 were @benshapiro, @libsoftiktok, @StephenM, @ezraklein, and @finkd. Updating the list now (for <42 years old) I'd add @sama and @bariweiss. That's 4 on the moderate-to-far right, 2 moderates, and 1 classical liberal. Not a single commie or real progressive activist.
Intermarriage rates among liberal Jews have been ~70% for two generations. Jews who married each other (like Stephen Miller) are probably more likely to have nationalistic impulses, which will be inherited by their children. And young Jews exploring the political scene will confront a left that now sees being Jewish as the only thing worse than being white.
"Jewish" is becoming a right-wing identity. The stereotype is going to change!
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
These political shifts among Ivy League Jewish students are remarkable:
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Will
@Evolving_Moloch
Funnily enough there are hereditarians, such as Nathan Cofnas, who have argued that East Asians are especially smart in part because they're "genetically adapted to the arduous demands of the rice paddy," and Southeast Asian societies with these relatively mediocre modern 'national IQ' estimates such as Indonesia (~82) and the Philippines (~78) traditionally appear to have had some of the most sophisticated and effective pre-industrial rice cultivation systems ever documented, such as the Subak system in Bali and Ifugao rice terraces in the Philippines
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
All people are "adapted to hunting and gathering." Some populations have been subject to more intense and sustained selection pressures for non-hunter-gatherer activities than others.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Doctor-Baron 17cShyteposter, DDS
@17cShyteposter
There's nothing here that says East Asian IQ is high because they farmed rice. It says that having a high IQ *and*a history of farming rice lends to homework culture
People who deny intelligence is heritable are in such a clownish position they just have to make stuff up lol
Will
@Evolving_Moloch
Funnily enough there are hereditarians, such as Nathan Cofnas, who have argued that East Asians are especially smart in part because they're "genetically adapted to the arduous demands of the rice paddy," and Southeast Asian societies with these relatively mediocre modern 'national IQ' estimates such as Indonesia (~82) and the Philippines (~78) traditionally appear to have had some of the most sophisticated and effective pre-industrial rice cultivation systems ever documented, such as the Subak system in Bali and Ifugao rice terraces in the Philippines
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“See you don’t get it. I follow Carl Schmitt. There’s this thing called the friend-enemy distinction. Maybe you’ve heard of it? Wait my enemies just fired me? Come on guys! Whatever happened to free speech and all those liberal values we hold dear? What’s the world coming to?”
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Threatening to arrest people for disagreeing with the government fills Europeans with so much pride and patriotism that they cannot resist including multiple flag emojis
French Embassy UK🇫🇷🇪🇺
@FranceintheUK
#democracynotalgocracy | 🇪🇺🇫🇷In Europe, one is free to speak, not to spread illegal content.
#europeprotects
#dsaprotects -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
The nation's leading and most effective immigration restrictionist is Jewish.
The pattern to notice with Jews is that they tend towards political extremism in whatever direction or cause they're committed to.
(myself included)
Daniel Concannon
@TooWhiteToTweet
Jewish economist visits Spain; immediately declares Spain needs infinity immigrants.
He's the author of 'Open Border,' a call for unrestricted immigration.
But YOU'RE the bad guy for recognizing a pattern here - not the guy who would destroy Western Civilization. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Roman Helmet Guy
@romanhelmetguy
“High-schoolers will log into a Zoom call with other students and a peer tutor, debate topics like immigration or Israel-Palestine, and rate one another”
Wow, can’t wait for my kid to get rejected from MIT for having the wrong opinion on immigration and Israel. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The Atlantic: “Race-science adherents do not have evidence on their side. The consensus view among experts is that race is not a biological phenomenon, let alone one that could explain differences such as IQ and crime rates.”
You don’t need to read a single study to know someone who writes like this is an either lying to you or not thinking clearly. If race did not have a biological basis, people would not predictably look different depending on where in the world they’re from. All studies about different propensities to various health outcomes would be gone. It would be one thing to argue against a genetic race-IQ link. To say that it can’t exist because race isn’t biological is simply discrediting. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I'm glad people have free speech to post that a Catholic woman with an Italian name is Jewish and get 50K likes
It's also true that society needs mechanisms to ensure that the free speech of morons (most people) doesn't lead to real-life influence -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I live in the UK where apartments have a lot of "character," i.e., dirt, poor insulation, and sometimes separate taps for hot and cold water (if the hot water is working at all).
Look at the window shot—every apartment across the street has an air conditioner! Americans don't understand how amazing this is. Almost no one in the UK has an air conditioner.
"we've created a world where new things are soulless things...you'd think that a wealthier society would build more beautiful things, but not ours"
That's a great apartment. You can decorate it with all the beautiful things you want, which you can afford because Americans are rich.
David Perell
@david_perell
I'm touring apartments in New York, and just about every new-build has the same soulless aesthetic: flat walls, white paint, no cornices, no ornamentation... just a room in a box.
One real estate agent said to me: "If you want something with character, you're gonna have to stick to pre-war buildings."
Look, I'm all for some efficiency gains, but we've created a world where new things are soulless things, and that's not how a society as modern as ours should function. Intuitively, you'd think that a wealthier society would build more beautiful things, but not ours. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
It's frustrating to live in a country where almost no one understands what free speech is
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Man calling for a more intellectually sophisticated right refers to 388 words as a "wall of text"
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
My favorite part of this wall of text is when he stops to declare himself the most widely read philosopher of our generation
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
What would conservatives do with a university if they had one? We know the answer to that. There are a handful of conservative-run university centers in the US. Leaving aside their extremely nepotistic (corrupt) hiring practices, they focus on libertarian propaganda, great books, Christianity, or constitutional history. That's it. Very little serious research or engagement with novel problems.
"guys like Jordan Peterson, he should be given the time to reflect on an issue and put out something every few months, instead the content churn and social medial battles"
Jordan Peterson was a tenured professor at the University of Toronto! He quit because he knew the right would reward him more for churning out a constant stream of clown content than for writing learned articles every few months. (Not that his articles would have been worth much anyway. But at least he could do better than arguing that "dragons are real.")
The leftist takeover of academia started 70 years ago. Conservatives had the power to resist, but they didn't because the average rightist doesn't care about ideas and idea-making institutions.
An anecdote: I'm almost certainly the most widely read right-wing millennial philosopher, and I have a job at a university. I asked the editor of a leading conservative intellectual magazine if he would consider my article about how the standard conservative objection to trans ideology is based on a philosophical mistake, and there is a better way to defend the gender binary. He replied, "I think we have this topic covered to our satisfaction at this time." He didn't ask to *see* the article or hear what my argument was. He just didn't care what a philosopher had to say, and, as a prominent conservative gatekeeper, he assumed his audience wouldn't care, either. He was probably right.
This isn't a problem that can be fixed with better institutions. It's a human capital problem that can only be fixed by giving smart people on the left a reason to switch sides.
Given that @AuronMacintyre is a poster boy for the smooth-brained slop content problem, I'm not sure what double-head fake he's pulling to be the one to complain about this. The only way the situation could get even more retarded than it currently is would be if the Auron MacIntyres of the online right created their own fake "academic" institutions.
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
The right is facing a serious problem about how to handle its intellectuals
The left has the university where it can assign smart people good paying high status jobs where they can explore and cultivate ideas
The right has no similar institutions, so rightwing intellectuals end up in thinktanks or content production
This creates the "public intellectual" who comes onto the scene with a burst of insight
Content production is a grind, even if you're saying intelligent things eventually the need to say something about everything leaves you little time to think deeply about anything
Academics are also not really equipped to be public figures, they are not built to do battle with a hostile public on a regular basis
I think this is a lot of what has happened with guys like Jordan Peterson, he should be given the time to reflect on an issue and put out something every few months, instead the content churn and social medial battles make it difficult for him to say anything new or interesting
With no time to reflect on and cultivate new ideas the public intellectual has less and less to say and more and more demand for saying something
Not trying to make Peterson a victim here but the right need a better plan to cultivate its serious thinkers, throwing them into the content mill is not a sustainable plan -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aryeh Kontorovich
@aryehazan
maybe it's hubris, but i imagine if given decent start-up funds, I could put together a decent academic team
at least in STEM
not necessarily right-wing, just *good*
for humanities I'd offload all hiring decisions to @nathancofnas
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
What would conservatives do with a university if they had one? We know the answer to that. There are a handful of conservative-run university centers in the US. Leaving aside their extremely nepotistic (corrupt) hiring practices, they focus on libertarian propaganda, great books, Christianity, or constitutional history. That's it. Very little serious research or engagement with novel problems.
"guys like Jordan Peterson, he should be given the time to reflect on an issue and put out something every few months, instead the content churn and social medial battles"
Jordan Peterson was a tenured professor at the University of Toronto! He quit because he knew the right would reward him more for churning out a constant stream of clown content than for writing learned articles every few months. (Not that his articles would have been worth much anyway. But at least he could do better than arguing that "dragons are real.")
The leftist takeover of academia started 70 years ago. Conservatives had the power to resist, but they didn't because the average rightist doesn't care about ideas and idea-making institutions.
An anecdote: I'm almost certainly the most widely read right-wing millennial philosopher, and I have a job at a university. I asked the editor of a leading conservative intellectual magazine if he would consider my article about how the standard conservative objection to trans ideology is based on a philosophical mistake, and there is a better way to defend the gender binary. He replied, "I think we have this topic covered to our satisfaction at this time." He didn't ask to *see* the article or hear what my argument was. He just didn't care what a philosopher had to say, and, as a prominent conservative gatekeeper, he assumed his audience wouldn't care, either. He was probably right.
This isn't a problem that can be fixed with better institutions. It's a human capital problem that can only be fixed by giving smart people on the left a reason to switch sides.
Given that @AuronMacintyre is a poster boy for the smooth-brained slop content problem, I'm not sure what double-head fake he's pulling to be the one to complain about this. The only way the situation could get even more retarded than it currently is would be if the Auron MacIntyres of the online right created their own fake "academic" institutions.
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
The right is facing a serious problem about how to handle its intellectuals
The left has the university where it can assign smart people good paying high status jobs where they can explore and cultivate ideas
The right has no similar institutions, so rightwing intellectuals end up in thinktanks or content production
This creates the "public intellectual" who comes onto the scene with a burst of insight
Content production is a grind, even if you're saying intelligent things eventually the need to say something about everything leaves you little time to think deeply about anything
Academics are also not really equipped to be public figures, they are not built to do battle with a hostile public on a regular basis
I think this is a lot of what has happened with guys like Jordan Peterson, he should be given the time to reflect on an issue and put out something every few months, instead the content churn and social medial battles make it difficult for him to say anything new or interesting
With no time to reflect on and cultivate new ideas the public intellectual has less and less to say and more and more demand for saying something
Not trying to make Peterson a victim here but the right need a better plan to cultivate its serious thinkers, throwing them into the content mill is not a sustainable plan -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
What would conservatives do with a university if they had one? We know the answer to that. There are a handful of conservative-run university centers in the US. Leaving aside their extremely nepotistic (corrupt) hiring practices, they focus on libertarian propaganda, great books, Christianity, or constitutional history. That's it. Very little serious research or engagement with novel problems.
"guys like Jordan Peterson, he should be given the time to reflect on an issue and put out something every few months, instead the content churn and social medial battles"
Jordan Peterson was a tenured professor at the University of Toronto! He quit because he knew the right would reward him more for churning out a constant stream of clown content than for writing learned articles every few months. (Not that his articles would have been worth much anyway. But at least he could do better than arguing that "dragons are real.")
The leftist takeover of academia started 70 years ago. Conservatives had the power to resist, but they didn't because the average rightist doesn't care about ideas and idea-making institutions.
An anecdote: I'm almost certainly the most widely read right-wing millennial philosopher, and I have a job at a university. I asked the editor of a leading conservative intellectual magazine if he would consider my article about how the standard conservative objection to trans ideology is based on a philosophical mistake, and there is a better way to defend the gender binary. He replied, "I think we have this topic covered to our satisfaction at this time." He didn't ask to *see* the article or hear what my argument was. He just didn't care what a philosopher had to say, and, as a prominent conservative gatekeeper, he assumed his audience wouldn't care, either. He was probably right.
This isn't a problem that can be fixed with better institutions. It's a human capital problem that can only be fixed by giving smart people on the left a reason to switch sides.
Given that @AuronMacintyre is a poster boy for the smooth-brained slop content problem, I'm not sure what double-head fake he's pulling to be the one to complain about this. The only way the situation could get even more retarded than it currently is would be if the Auron MacIntyres of the online right created their own fake "academic" institutions.
Auron MacIntyre
@AuronMacintyre
The right is facing a serious problem about how to handle its intellectuals
The left has the university where it can assign smart people good paying high status jobs where they can explore and cultivate ideas
The right has no similar institutions, so rightwing intellectuals end up in thinktanks or content production
This creates the "public intellectual" who comes onto the scene with a burst of insight
Content production is a grind, even if you're saying intelligent things eventually the need to say something about everything leaves you little time to think deeply about anything
Academics are also not really equipped to be public figures, they are not built to do battle with a hostile public on a regular basis
I think this is a lot of what has happened with guys like Jordan Peterson, he should be given the time to reflect on an issue and put out something every few months, instead the content churn and social medial battles make it difficult for him to say anything new or interesting
With no time to reflect on and cultivate new ideas the public intellectual has less and less to say and more and more demand for saying something
Not trying to make Peterson a victim here but the right need a better plan to cultivate its serious thinkers, throwing them into the content mill is not a sustainable plan -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
👇
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
What kind of house? The standard working class house of the 1950s or the size house that's now considered minimal?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Trump's claim to not know the background of a Shakespeare character is actually totally plausible
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Wokism is based on a false empirical premise. Pointing this out is our most powerful weapon. ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
1) Every day you and Sibarium report examples of how wokism is going strong. Elites still believe that disparities are due to the environment (injustice), and there is a moral emergency to correct the environment and bring about equal outcomes. (There's a backlash against gender theory, but I always said that could happen.)
The hereditarian revolution, small as it is, has had tangible successes: the tech right, Elon, Peter Thiel, et al.
"Will they argue harder?...Have the Marines air-drop copies of the Bell Curve...?"
YES! This and more.
2) "If the 'hereditarians' want their position to even touch on plausibility, they will have to outline the political sequence of events that gets us from 'intellectuals prove the scientific validity of hereditarianism' to 'wokism defeated everywhere.'"
I have done this! Good ideas can win (e.g., evolution vs. creationism), but people have to fight for them. -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Wokism is based on a false empirical premise. Pointing this out is our most powerful weapon. ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
1) Every day you and Sibarium report examples of how wokism is going strong. Elites still believe that disparities are due to the environment (injustice), and there is a moral emergency to correct the environment and bring about equal outcomes. (There's a backlash against gender theory, but I always said that could happen.)
The hereditarian revolution, small as it is, has had tangible successes: the tech right, Elon, Peter Thiel, et al.
"Will they argue harder?...Have the Marines air-drop copies of the Bell Curve...?"
YES! This and more.
2) "If the 'hereditarians' want their position to even touch on plausibility, they will have to outline the political sequence of events that gets us from 'intellectuals prove the scientific validity of hereditarianism' to 'wokism defeated everywhere.'"
I have done this! Good ideas can win (e.g., evolution vs. creationism), but people have to fight for them. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Wherever you have smart, functional people, you find wokism, because that's the ideology of the elites. It doesn't matter how many universities Trump defunds or students he arrests. Sibarium and Rufo will report the same story over and over again: "BREAKING: We spent 5 minutes investigating and found 10 more cases of underground race communism"
There are two ways to stop woke institutions.
First, shut down all institutions. No more universities, scientific research, museums, orchestras, etc. (The MAGA strategy.)
Second, fight and win the battle of ideas. Wokism stands or falls by the equality thesis: all groups have the same distribution of innate traits, ergo all disparities are the result of the environment (injustice). Show that the equality thesis is wrong, and give smart people a reason to join the right.
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
SCOOP: The Duke Law Journal sent a secret memo to minority applicants with tips on how to ace the journal's personal statement.
The memo told students they'd get up to 15 extra points for indicating their "membership in an "underrepresented group."🧵 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
University of Roehampton professor Lewis Halsey recorded an interview with me to show his students. Now posted on YouTube.
I explain my theory of wokism: www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQDRZ4m1PbY&ab_channel=Scienceoft… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Woke leftist: "Don't make the only serious argument that undermines my ideology because, um, it won't make a difference!"
Rightoids: "See, Cofnas was wrong! We should never try to win the argument. Let's stick with doing stuff we know doesn't work because a leftist said so."
James Surowiecki
@JamesSurowiecki
If success is due to inherited traits that people have no control over, rather than individual effort and dedication, redistribution obviously makes more sense, not less.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution: ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Surowiecki isn't a hereditarian. Virtually no one in real life holds the hypothetical view that he's describing (hereditarian race communism).
Wokesters fight tooth and nail against hereditarianism because they understand what is at stake: everything.
James Surowiecki
@JamesSurowiecki
If success is due to inherited traits that people have no control over, rather than individual effort and dedication, redistribution obviously makes more sense, not less.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
IQ has more explanatory value than any other variable in social science. Western elites replaced Christianity with a new religion (wokism) that is based on denying facts about IQ and its heritability.
When will people stop asking why this topic is interesting and important?
Ben
@BenShindel
I am begging smart people to stop wasting their time on IQ heritability. It’s like, not even in the top thousand most important or interesting scientific questions of today, but it captivates smart people in this bizarre solipsistic manner.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
- English last name
- tattoo (not allowed for Jews)
- ...of YHWH (doubly not allowed)
- no yarmulke
- video EXPLICITLY SAYS HIS FAMILY IS CHRISTIAN
Tweet calling him Jewish has 61k likes
In many cases, the explanation for why people are wrong is that they're just stupid
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
On why we should rely on experts rather than idiots on the Internet: ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Mamdani just won the Dem mayoral primary in NYC on the promise to be more anti-white/Jewish and to nationalize grocery stores and housing. AOC has a good shot of being the next president.
The idea that "woke is over" is delusional and based on a failure to understand the logic of the ideology. Wokism means taking the equality thesis seriously: if all groups have the same distribution of socially relevant traits, any disparities must be the result of the environment (injustice), and there is a moral emergency to correct the environment and bring about equal outcomes. As long as they believe in the equality thesis, smart and morally sensitive people will be woke.
Mainstream anti-woke activists refuse to challenge the equality thesis. Their plan is to mobilize people who are too dumb and/or immoral to care that wokism follows from beliefs that they (at least claim to) hold. But the MAGA coalition of idiots is not going to retain power in the long run, because it doesn't have the human capital to govern effectively or take over the institutions.
Trump's legacy won't be the end of woke, but the rise of a new left that combines the race communism of 2010s with economic communism that was spearheaded by Trump himself. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Iran is an ideal candidate for regime change.
-A government hated by its elites
-A population willing to sacrifice and die for liberalism
-No foreign allies
-No need for US ground troops
History is calling. Time to answer the phone, fellow Hegelians. www.richardhanania.com/p/the-right-way-to-do-regime-change -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Israel is defending its civilians, therefore it is using civilians as human shields. True or false?"
This is an Idiocracy-level IQ test question that a huge % of people will fail. And that's why public policy should be set by elites, not majority opinion.
Ramy Abdu| رامي عبده
@RamAbdu
The footage no one will publish: Israeli air defense systems firing from densely populated areas in Tel Aviv to intercept Iranian missiles.
Who is really using civilians as human shields? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
Congratulations to UATX on appointing a new president. The first question many of us have for him: Will he right the ship after a series of stumbles that run against the free expression principles it idealizes?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 2023 the free speech/heterodox University of Austin disavowed Richard Hanania for his "racist writings"
Now they cut off the "Mill Institute" bc the director posted this tweet
Not allowed to be an inch to the right or the left of Bari Weiss at the "free speech" university! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Konstantin Kisin
@KonstantinKisin
Remember, if you want to be "anti-war" you need special logic:
Russia was provoked by Ukraine's desire to join NATO.
Israel was NOT provoked by Iran saying it wants to wipe Israel off the map and then enriching enough uranium for 9 nukes (IAEA report).
#speciallogic -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jason Bedrick
@JasonBedrick
Ha! Joke’s on you! I found one:
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Had a great time at the inaugural Heterodox Conference in Buckingham with some of my favourite people. Many thanks to @epkaufm for organising 🙏
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Questioning taboos with Stephen Kershnar: ncofnas.com/p/questioning-taboos-with-stephen-kershnar
"We have the absurd situation in philosophy now where the limits of philosophical inquiry are set by the students..."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
At the Heterodox Conference in the UK, people are telling me that Batya, after praising Trump's tariffs and calling for the universities to be destroyed, declared that she doesn't believe in evolution or evolutionary psychology.
That is indeed some heterodox thinking. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Why is this the endpoint of almost all online commentators?
Even for people much smarter than Peterson and Lindsay, coming up with good ideas takes a lot of time and labor. But the market rewards those who just spew "content." At a certain level of fame, people will pay attention to whatever you say as long as you're saying *something* (whether it's because they drank your Kool-Aid, they want to hate on you, or they're just following the herd). If you disappear for 6 months to think about what you're doing, there's a risk that people will move on, and the grift is over.
So people end up listening to Jordan Peterson talk about how dragons are real at 2x playback speed or doomscrolling through "content." But this is what people vote for with their wallets. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andrew
@sranysovok
"You see, destroying nuclear capabilities of our adversary at 3% of Pentagon budget is actually bad. Russia should nuke Kyiv to maintain balance of power."
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve Sailer
@Steve_Sailer
Centrist pundit Noah Smith points out that the race gap in IQ is No Big Deal because it could be eliminated by a mere 9 generations (261 years at 29 years / generation) of state-mandated eugenic breeding.
Why haven't extremists like me come up with simple solutions like Noah's? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
Nathan Cofnas is right. If "wokeness" ends without embracing hereditarianism, it will come right back.
Wokeness and communism feel similar because they're both just permutations of blank slate egalitarianism.
Another permutation will evolve if we don't strike the root. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
A simple test:
Woke is over when a prominent college President has no problem stating Africans commit substantially more violence, have lower IQs, and this is probably unfixable
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Unless Christopher Rufo and Ron DeSantis personally intervene in every hiring decision, universities will always revert back to woke, because that's the ideology of the elites
An endless cycle of lawfare and resistance until we refute the premise of wokism: the equality thesis -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Unless Christopher Rufo and Ron DeSantis personally intervene in every hiring decision, universities will always revert back to woke, because that's the ideology of the elites
An endless cycle of lawfare and resistance until we refute the premise of wokism: the equality thesis -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
1. High human capital
2. Stop being communist
A reliable path to decades of fast growth
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Poland really is a miraculous economic success story.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You don't understand, there's a conspiracy among those of lesser IQ and that's why @RealChrisLangan can't just submit a paper to a math journal to demonstrate the fruits of his giant intellect. Asking for evidence or details of the conspiracy is itself proof of low intelligence.
Cyberia
@cyberiasystem
If Mr. Lagan is as smart as he claims, it should be trivially easy for him to make meaningful intellectual contributions to the world in math, physics, CS, philosophy, etc. Of course, he has never done that.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@RealChrisLangan's big-brained response to my "acadummy" wish to see an iota of real evidence that he has the highest IQ in world, as he claims
Unfortunately still no evidence
Vaughn Smith is a carpet cleaner who claims to speak dozens of languages. He's regularly described as a "genius," "savant," and "hyperpolyglot" by journalists. There was a documentary about him. He appeared on Tyler Cowen's podcast and "spoke" dozens of languages. The Washington Post published an article "The remarkable brain of a carpet cleaner who speaks 24 languages." Scientists scanned Smith's brain and published the results in a peer-reviewed journal. All based on the unverified claim of a random carpet cleaner! Then YouTuber Evildea did an investigation and found that Smith speaks English at a C1 level (i.e., uneducated native English speaker), Spanish at an upper intermediate level, and a little German.
Until I see real evidence to the contrary, I'm going to assume the rambling crackpot Chris Langan is the Vaughn Smith of IQ.
Chris Langan
@RealChrisLangan
I'm afraid that would make you a dummy, Nathan.
By the way, are you a real philosopher? I'll bet you aren't. I know about Cambridge, and it's ever so impressive! But I didn't ask you whether someone else merely thinks you're a real philosopher. In my rarified neck of the woods, acadummy opinion is not a consideration.
Frankly, I'd never heard of you, probably for very good reason. But one thing is for sure: by even opening your mouth in my direction, you've gotten in way over your pointy little head. Best suck it up and slink away. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Today I was talking to a group of Cambridge students and this debate came up. All of them instantly understood what Greene failed to understand even after I spent 3 hours and 11 minutes explaining it to him.
A vivid reminder that IQ is real.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thoughts on my debate with @GreeneMan6
"There's clearly a large audience on the right for somebody to flatter the common man..."
@lukefordThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Jordan Peterson vs 20 Atheists" is like a chess master playing an exhibition match against 20 amateurs simultaneously but losing every game
(and also not being a real chess master) -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
On the online right, if your IQ is 115 you're considered a genius, but if it's >120 you're considered an idiot
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
Yet another demonstration that it is no more possible to have a "free speech" university under rightoids than it is under Wokes.
PS. Has this "heterodox" institution actually produced anything of note beyond the cancelation of Hanania and now of a (qualified) DEI defender?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 2023 the free speech/heterodox University of Austin disavowed Richard Hanania for his "racist writings"
Now they cut off the "Mill Institute" bc the director posted this tweet
Not allowed to be an inch to the right or the left of Bari Weiss at the "free speech" university! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
this whole thing is such a black eye for an institution that really didn't need yet another black eye
absolute embarrassment
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 2023 the free speech/heterodox University of Austin disavowed Richard Hanania for his "racist writings"
Now they cut off the "Mill Institute" bc the director posted this tweet
Not allowed to be an inch to the right or the left of Bari Weiss at the "free speech" university! -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In 2023 the free speech/heterodox University of Austin disavowed Richard Hanania for his "racist writings"
Now they cut off the "Mill Institute" bc the director posted this tweet
Not allowed to be an inch to the right or the left of Bari Weiss at the "free speech" university!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Quillette
@Quillette
Created as a haven for free thinkers, UATX was the last place where I’d expected to encounter ideological litmus tests, writes @EllieAvishai.
quillette.com/2025/05/16/is-the-university-of-austin-betr… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thoughts on my debate with @GreeneMan6
"There's clearly a large audience on the right for somebody to flatter the common man..."
@lukefordThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
(((Luke Ford)))
@lukeford
Nathan Cofnas On MAGA Communism & The Right's Stupidity Problem (5-25-25)
Timestamps:
03:00 Classical Liberalism Seminar at Stanford University - Nathan Cofnas, www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8N-mwrQhfo 07:45 Martinez X Cofnas on the errors/omissions of Kevin MacDonald, rumble.com/v6swig7-martinez-x-cofnas-on-the-errorsomissio…
1:50:00 Nathan Cofnas joins
2:01:00 Nathan's Amy Wax interview, ncofnas.com/p/with-amy-wax-for-and-against-tds
2:06:45 Nathan's publishing history
2:35:00 How Nathan polished his academic writing 2:48:00 The anti-Jewish narrative is part of the anti-white narrative
2:51:00 Earning an honorable living as a right-wing intellectual -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Debate with Dave Greene about trusting experts www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JCq-wlOg88&ab_channel=TheDistrib…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Two of my favorite past podcast guests (Amy Wax and @nathancofnas) got into a heated debate about Trump and his tariffs, TDS and many related issues.
I really enjoy this conversation and I hope that these two intellects take on more of a leadership role in the conservative movement in the near future.
Highly recommend this discussion!
ncofnas.com/p/with-amy-wax-for-and-against-tds -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Dave Greene
@GreeneMan6
Tune in tomorrow morning at 10 am PST for a discussion with @nathancofnas on whether we should be more deferential to experts.
www.youtube.com/live/4JCq-wlOg88 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Robert Sterling
@RobertMSterling
“There is no confiscation of land.” There’s just “a measure that would allow the government to take land without providing compensation.”
Brilliant reporting from the New York Times. Thanks, guys! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Elias Rodriguez, the Chicago far-left activist accused of shooting dead two Israelis outside the Capital Jewish Museum, has a long history of support for BLM, Palestine, communist and anti-white causes.
Those groups have been trying to scrub his associations with them by deleting articles and pages where he is mentioned.
While being arrested after the killings, Rodriguez shouted, "Free, free Palestine!"
(((Yuval David)))
@YuvalDavid
🚨Attack upon Jews in Washington DC!
Two Israeli Diplomat staff from @IsraelinUSA were shot and killed outside the @AJCGlobal Young Diplomats event at the @CapJewishMuseum and just before that a man barged into the building yelling “Free Palestine.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wesley Yang
@wesyang
Ending Apartheid was the great moral crusade for idealistic youth throughout the West in the 1980's. If it had resulted in a flourishing society, it would have strongly affirmed certain key postulates that underpin the present moral regime.
If it ends in mass death, either of its white population in pogroms, or of its black population in state collapse, or both, it will contribute to the continued erosion of a moral regime that nonetheless remains forbidden to question. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This reasoning is exactly right. If blacks, Jews, and Koreans are born on average exactly the same, you can't just accept a "colorblind" society where one group ends up with -15 IQ points, 7x the incarceration rate, etc.
There are two options: wokism or hereditarianism.
Eddie S. Glaude Jr.
@esglaude
Lord have mercy. Colorblind equality tosses aside the question of how do we remedy historic wrongs that continue affect outcomes in the present day. The US doesn’t look the way it does by accident. A dual housing market, dual labor market, segregated schools, redlining… History matters.
And we have to be just as deliberate in dismantling it all as we were in creating it. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
@nathancofnas sometimes notes that Jews are overrepresented in more or less all political organizations except for the obviously anti-Jewish ones. That might not even be true.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
CAMBRIDGE.
Words fail.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
From the Cambridge student newspaper
Don't want any "controversial or challenging" speech at the University of Cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In case we needed yet another nail in the coffin of the "wokism is civil rights law" theory, the people who run Harvard would prefer to lose all their funding *and* go to jail rather than stop discriminating against whites and Asians
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
People inside Harvard realize “they are in an untenable crisis.” Some worry they could face “full-blown criminal inquiries.”
They’re going to have to make a deal.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If anything, last January I undersold the case for how not wrong I was about wokism ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Toby Young
@toadmeister
I am proposing several amendments to the Employment Rights Bill today, including some opposing the 'banter ban' and one that will make it unlawful for employers to dismiss people for holding or expressing lawful political views. www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/05/19/lords-pressure-ra…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ann Coulter
@AnnCoulter
<<why should taxpayers—more than half of whom would be illegally discriminated against by Harvard if they applied to be a student or member of staff there—foot the bill for their activism?>>
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Harvard President Alan Garber just sent a letter to the Secretary of Education:
"We do not employ ideological litmus tests. We do not use diversity, equity, and inclusion statements in our hiring decisions."
Ashley Thomas was hired as an assistant professor in the psychology department at Harvard in 2022. Below is the first paragraph of her DEI statement. It's a 2,367-word groveling apology for being white and plea for oppression points. This is what you have to say to get hired by Harvard.
A few months ago, they replaced "DEI" statements with "service" statements, which are the same thing with a new name.
The next generation of professors is going to be hired by people like Professor Thomas. When the 2.9% of Harvard faculty who identify as "conservative" retire, Harvard will be 0% conservative.
Says Garber: "I must refute your claim that Harvard is a partisan institution. It is neither Republican nor Democratic. It is not an arm of any other political party or movement. Nor will it ever be."
Some great work comes out of Harvard. But it is a partisan institution. If Garber et al. refuse to acknowledge this, why should taxpayers—more than half of whom would be illegally discriminated against by Harvard if they applied to be a student or member of staff there—foot the bill for their activism? -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
From the Cambridge student newspaper
Don't want any "controversial or challenging" speech at the University of Cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
(((Luke Ford)))
@lukeford
Reading Nathan Cofnas on the dangers of vegetarianism convinced me I had to find a way to ingest meat -- and eventually I found beef organ capsules and all of my health problems went away in two weeks.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Despite having published in nutrition journals I'm not emotionally invested in whether people agree with me about nutrition. But here are some thoughts on keto:
The keto diet had miraculous benefits for me. I've eaten only meat, seafood, and non-root vegetables 7 days a week, 365 days a year since 2019. Before that I was raised vegetarian (26 years), then experimented with paleo and following standard USDA advice. Before keto, I was very sick. After, I was healthy. Six years in, blood work is good. I can bench 2 plates.
I don't know what studies @cremieuxrecueil is referring to (the link he provides is broken), and I haven't been following the scientific literature. But most studies I've seen cited to support the claim that keto is bad are observational studies that look for associations with lower carb or higher fat intake. That's not what keto is, and therefore not a test of the keto diet. Keto means you consistently restrict carbs and remain in ketosis.
Very few people have the discipline to actually follow the keto diet. So we're never going to have "a lot of data," even observational. Keto means no bread, sugar, potatoes, etc. It's not something you would attempt unless you were desperate. More than half of people who say they're "vegetarian" have eaten meat in the past week. I'd guess that the vast majority of people who claim to be on the keto diet cheat every day (i.e., are not on the keto diet).
There's no diet that can be optimized for every individual or for every outcome. When nutrition researchers find an alleged association between a dietary variable X and a health outcome O, they often declare that "X is good (or bad)" based on that. Even if the association is real (and this is usually impossible to actually establish), X might be good/bad with respect to O but not other outcomes. And X could have opposite effects in different people.
When I was doing work in nutrition I talked to an eminent researcher about the nature of nutrition science. (I won't name him because I don't know if he wants to be publicly associated with this idea. For what it's worth, he was a vegan for ethical reasons.) He said (quoting from memory): "Basic nutrition, like you need iron and certain vitamins, that's solid science. Besides that, there's a fermented fish from Asia that causes throat cancer. Processed meat is associated with colorectal cancer, but even that is uncertain. That's all we know."
I don't think that keto is optimized for longevity. (For that I'd bet on pescetarianism and calorie restriction.) And I wouldn't recommend it unless someone has a specific, serious issue. For me, keto is worth it for the short-term benefits even if I knew I would get coronary-artery disease and die at 72 like Dr. Atkins. However, nothing in nutrition science makes me think that keto makes that more likely to happen than if I were to follow the USDA's fake food pyramid.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I'm a little annoyed that I spent so many years thinking keto was obviously good.
Now that we have a lot of data, it turns out that the people who said "fat—especially saturated fat—clogs your arteries" were just totally correct.
I should not have believed the contrarians. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
No Jews?
No news. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Despite having published in nutrition journals I'm not emotionally invested in whether people agree with me about nutrition. But here are some thoughts on keto:
The keto diet had miraculous benefits for me. I've eaten only meat, seafood, and non-root vegetables 7 days a week, 365 days a year since 2019. Before that I was raised vegetarian (26 years), then experimented with paleo and following standard USDA advice. Before keto, I was very sick. After, I was healthy. Six years in, blood work is good. I can bench 2 plates.
I don't know what studies @cremieuxrecueil is referring to (the link he provides is broken), and I haven't been following the scientific literature. But most studies I've seen cited to support the claim that keto is bad are observational studies that look for associations with lower carb or higher fat intake. That's not what keto is, and therefore not a test of the keto diet. Keto means you consistently restrict carbs and remain in ketosis.
Very few people have the discipline to actually follow the keto diet. So we're never going to have "a lot of data," even observational. Keto means no bread, sugar, potatoes, etc. It's not something you would attempt unless you were desperate. More than half of people who say they're "vegetarian" have eaten meat in the past week. I'd guess that the vast majority of people who claim to be on the keto diet cheat every day (i.e., are not on the keto diet).
There's no diet that can be optimized for every individual or for every outcome. When nutrition researchers find an alleged association between a dietary variable X and a health outcome O, they often declare that "X is good (or bad)" based on that. Even if the association is real (and this is usually impossible to actually establish), X might be good/bad with respect to O but not other outcomes. And X could have opposite effects in different people.
When I was doing work in nutrition I talked to an eminent researcher about the nature of nutrition science. (I won't name him because I don't know if he wants to be publicly associated with this idea. For what it's worth, he was a vegan for ethical reasons.) He said (quoting from memory): "Basic nutrition, like you need iron and certain vitamins, that's solid science. Besides that, there's a fermented fish from Asia that causes throat cancer. Processed meat is associated with colorectal cancer, but even that is uncertain. That's all we know."
I don't think that keto is optimized for longevity. (For that I'd bet on pescetarianism and calorie restriction.) And I wouldn't recommend it unless someone has a specific, serious issue. For me, keto is worth it for the short-term benefits even if I knew I would get coronary-artery disease and die at 72 like Dr. Atkins. However, nothing in nutrition science makes me think that keto makes that more likely to happen than if I were to follow the USDA's fake food pyramid.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I'm a little annoyed that I spent so many years thinking keto was obviously good.
Now that we have a lot of data, it turns out that the people who said "fat—especially saturated fat—clogs your arteries" were just totally correct.
I should not have believed the contrarians. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
You have maybe seen this plot. It shows ratings of races in USA by race. The key result is that each race favors their own, except for Whites who are apparently race-blind.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Harvard President Alan Garber just sent a letter to the Secretary of Education:
"We do not employ ideological litmus tests. We do not use diversity, equity, and inclusion statements in our hiring decisions."
Ashley Thomas was hired as an assistant professor in the psychology department at Harvard in 2022. Below is the first paragraph of her DEI statement. It's a 2,367-word groveling apology for being white and plea for oppression points. This is what you have to say to get hired by Harvard.
A few months ago, they replaced "DEI" statements with "service" statements, which are the same thing with a new name.
The next generation of professors is going to be hired by people like Professor Thomas. When the 2.9% of Harvard faculty who identify as "conservative" retire, Harvard will be 0% conservative.
Says Garber: "I must refute your claim that Harvard is a partisan institution. It is neither Republican nor Democratic. It is not an arm of any other political party or movement. Nor will it ever be."
Some great work comes out of Harvard. But it is a partisan institution. If Garber et al. refuse to acknowledge this, why should taxpayers—more than half of whom would be illegally discriminated against by Harvard if they applied to be a student or member of staff there—foot the bill for their activism? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jakeup
@myhandle
the day before I was born was a holiday in the Soviet Union and there was a rumor that they're handing out oranges, two per person. there was still snow outside, but my mom, 9 months pregnant, decided it was worth it to go stand in line because she hasn't had an orange all year
Na Hae-soo 🇨🇳
@Red_Blovk09
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
As @tylercowen says, those who support pharmaceutical price controls are supervillains.
And as @CliffordAsness says:
"We now have two economically far left (and economically ignorant) parties, they just differ in their preferred pronouns.” -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Well, maybe Americans will have 2 pills instead of 30 pills"
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There's a legitimate debate to be had about whether the federal government should fund medical research or leave it all to the private sector. Trump found a way to destroy both public *and* private sector research.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If prices are high, just make a law that they should be lower. How come no one thought of that before?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@epkaufm laments that MAGA "went off the rails," Trump "squandered his leadership opportunity," the administration has a "morality-free style of governance," and there's no "compelling moral narrative."
The last point is the key. Without hereditarianism, there can be no "compelling moral narrative" to counter wokism. A non-hereditarian anti-woke movement will inevitably be dominated by the sorts of people who don't require a moral narrative (i.e., idiots and thugs) while classical liberals ask what went wrong.
If all groups are innately the same, disparities *must* be the result of environmental forces. (In practice, they'll be blamed on past or present white racism.) Wokism is the recognition that there is a moral emergency to fix the bad environment until we have equal outcomes. If you accept the equality thesis, the only reason to be against wokism is that you are either too stupid to understand woke logic or too immoral to care.
@epkaufm hopes to avoid a confrontation with the taboo on hereditarianism and "return to a moral consensus that promotes cultural wealth, personal resilience, and classical liberal values such as free speech and equality among group identities." But this message never has and never will persuade smart wokesters to abandon their crusade.
If the equality thesis is correct, something about the environment robs blacks of 15-18 IQ points, makes them commit violent crimes at 7 times the rate of whites, and so on. Wokesters say we need to do whatever it takes to fix the problem. Classical liberals say we should treat everyone as equals and hope that no one asks why blacks make up <1% of Americans in certain elite positions. If I accepted the equality thesis, I would side with the wokesters.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
@epkaufm in Quillette: quillette.com/2025/04/11/if-woke-puritanism-is-the-diseas…
Debate between Eric and me hosted by Aporia: ncofnas.com/p/victory-without-a-hereditarian-revolution -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Because they're not real majors. No "studies" field is built on authentic scholarly principles the way in which philosophy & history are. They were just made up majors invented to appease the radicals of the 1970s, & this is the predictable outcome
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
FIRE's 2024 survey of college students found large variations by major in the acceptability of using violence to shut down speech.
While 52% of Ethnic, Gender & Area Studies majors said using violence is acceptable, less than 33% of STEM, Social Science & Humanities majors did. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Can't have open genomes because something something far-right.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
JayMan
@JayMan471
These nations aren’t just sociological abstractions, but are visible in the genetics of the people across the continent. The genetic differences across the British Isles were magnified into a permanent ethnic texture across North America.
The legacy of the colonial stock and the immigrants who subsequently settled in these areas (particularly French Canadians, Germans, Scandinavians, and Catholic Irish) set the cultural tone in North America, and lead to the divisions we see still today.
This the the American Hajnal line, very reminiscent of the one in Europe and the divide between WEIRD and clannish people. (4/n) -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Across countries, electoral maps correspond to genetic clusters even within "races"
Support for the AfD is concentrated in East German regions populated by certain Slavic tribes
New Substack by @C_Small_: bloodworth.co.uk/p/kinship-realism-tribalism-forever -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"You can only have two dolls, but when you grow up you'll get to work in the sweatshop that made them"
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent says he would tell little girls who have fewer dolls due to Trump’s tariffs, “You will have a better life than your parents…thanks to President Trump.”
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
bad_stats 🕜💵🖨️🕣
@thebadstats
Bret Weinstein and Joe Rogan like to frame things as whether or not you should "trust the experts" because then they can say "experts can be wrong!"
Don't buy into that framing.
The problem is Joe and Bret are ludicrously wrong about basic things.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Podcast Bros and Brain Rot: ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
"We now know who is rewarded in an unregulated marketplace of ideas—at least on the right. It's people who appeal to the intuitions of the lowest common denominator in the most entertaining way. Winning ideas include anti-Semitism, Holocaust denial, WWII revisionism, drinking unpasteurized milk, vaccine denial, moon landing conspiracy theories, fascism, the notion that Americans would be happier working in factories, and the theory that America is being 'screwed' by Madagascar because we spend more on their vanilla beans than they spend on food and medicine from us. Some of these bad ideas are being implemented into policy by the Trump administration. Three-and-a-half months of what Alex Kaschuta calls 'government by meme' has destroyed trillions of dollars in American wealth, irreparably harmed our global status and influence, and set the stage for a global left-wing backlash." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
Fantastic article, one that effectively threads the needle between unreasonable deference to self-styled experts and unreasonable dismissal of true expertise. I’d quibble with a few specifics (eg strong confidence in lab leak) but the essay as a whole is very much worth reading.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Podcast Bros and Brain Rot: ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
"We now know who is rewarded in an unregulated marketplace of ideas—at least on the right. It's people who appeal to the intuitions of the lowest common denominator in the most entertaining way. Winning ideas include anti-Semitism, Holocaust denial, WWII revisionism, drinking unpasteurized milk, vaccine denial, moon landing conspiracy theories, fascism, the notion that Americans would be happier working in factories, and the theory that America is being 'screwed' by Madagascar because we spend more on their vanilla beans than they spend on food and medicine from us. Some of these bad ideas are being implemented into policy by the Trump administration. Three-and-a-half months of what Alex Kaschuta calls 'government by meme' has destroyed trillions of dollars in American wealth, irreparably harmed our global status and influence, and set the stage for a global left-wing backlash." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"credentialed technocrats told a bunch of self-serving lies...But the fact that some people with fancy credentials are corrupt, fallible, and/or frauds doesn’t mean that expertise isn’t real." ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
~@nathancofnas on the conflict between new media & expertise.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
My all time favorite Thomas Sowell book is "Intellectuals and Society" because in it, Sowell explores the role that so-called "experts" play in society.
It's a must read.
And I'm really enjoying @nathancofnas's latest substack on this very subject!
Here' a link to the full essay:
ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot?publication_id=1…
Oh, and you can find Nathan appearing in two podcast episodes, #'s 40 and 41. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
"(2) The experts largely got it right—they just lied"
--@ncofnas at his Newsletter.
Many such cases IME: Experts are better offline than online, we live in a society.
It's pretty easy to correct for this yourself: Just modestly (modestly!) upweight the unwoke side.
Also: -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This by @nathancofnas is the best thing I’ve read on the Dave Smith v. Douglas Murray debate, and the tendency of populist right podcasts to peddle the “infotainment brain rot” that their audiences seek.
ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Demands for rigor and expertise shouldn't be used selectively as weapons against people we disagree with. We can't criticize Darryl Cooper but say nothing when Jordan Peterson pontificates on philosophy and argues that dragons are real." ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Podcast Bros and Brain Rot: ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
"After prominent figures including Rogan touted ivermectin as a Covid treatment, some health authorities branded it as 'horse dewormer'. This was misleading if not technically a lie. (Ivermectin is used as a dewormer in animals including horses and humans.) In this case, their motivation was noble—to scare people away from following Joe Rogan's dumb and dangerous advice. You can argue that they shouldn't have misled people. But nothing about this shows that Rogan was smarter than the experts." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Podcast Bros and Brain Rot: ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot
"We now know who is rewarded in an unregulated marketplace of ideas—at least on the right. It's people who appeal to the intuitions of the lowest common denominator in the most entertaining way. Winning ideas include anti-Semitism, Holocaust denial, WWII revisionism, drinking unpasteurized milk, vaccine denial, moon landing conspiracy theories, fascism, the notion that Americans would be happier working in factories, and the theory that America is being 'screwed' by Madagascar because we spend more on their vanilla beans than they spend on food and medicine from us. Some of these bad ideas are being implemented into policy by the Trump administration. Three-and-a-half months of what Alex Kaschuta calls 'government by meme' has destroyed trillions of dollars in American wealth, irreparably harmed our global status and influence, and set the stage for a global left-wing backlash." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"In China...topics such as political reform, Tiananmen, and human rights are taboo. These restrictions have limited open inquiry in the social sciences and humanities."
Yeah, imagine if there were taboos in America that limited open inquiry in the social sciences and humanities
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“After centuries of intellectual progress, Americans must face a terrible question,” the physicist Alan Lightman writes. “Are we now descending from light into dark?” theatln.tc/Nl7kRcXl
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Alan Lightman founded a "program in women's leadership" in collaboration with the Center for Research on Women and Gender in Malaysia. No shit he has "felt intellectually safe" as a professor in America.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I felt bad about Trump destroying the universities until I read this
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jonathan Keeperman
@L0m3z
This couldn’t possibly have any negative second order consequences
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is from the rubric used by UC Irvine and Berkeley to grade job applicants' DEI statements. If you said you "treat everyone the same," you got the lowest score and were automatically disqualified.
For one job search in the life sciences in 2019, 76% of applicants were cut in the first round based solely on their DEI statements.
Thousands of professors who were totally fine with all of that are now outraged that Trump is threating free expression at universities. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is from the rubric used by UC Irvine and Berkeley to grade job applicants' DEI statements. If you said you "treat everyone the same," you got the lowest score and were automatically disqualified.
For one job search in the life sciences in 2019, 76% of applicants were cut in the first round based solely on their DEI statements.
Thousands of professors who were totally fine with all of that are now outraged that Trump is threating free expression at universities. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Open letter from professors at Berkeley
From 2018-2025, Berkeley required job applicants to submit loyalty oaths to woke ("DEI statements"). According to published guidelines, saying "I treat people as individuals" meant rejection. There was no open letter about free expression. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Agree with Masoud and @sapinker. But for three decades, elite universities have treated right-wing opinions as de facto illegal and purged conservatives. (Cons now <3% of H faculty, probably 0% of assistant profs.) If they hadn't done that, there wouldn't have been this backlash.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Martinez Politics
@martinez_clips
🔥 Friday May 2 - 4PM ET / 10 PM CET 🔥
Nathan Cofnas joins to discuss the errors & omissions of Kevin MacDonald.
📺 Watch here: rumble.com/user/MartinezPolitix
Superchats (buymeacoffee.com/martinezpolitix) -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The % of Americans who say "I would be better off if I worked in a factory" is exactly the same as the % who have a favorable view of the Black Plague or "don't know" how they feel about the plague
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
9% of US adults have a favorable view of the Black Plague (death)
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This list of top "experts" on the right (MacDonald, Ricardo Duchesne, Greg Johnson, and Andrew Joyce) illustrates the opposite of what Woods thinks it does
Keith Woods
@KeithWoodsYT
"Where's the expertise on the right?"
Kevin MacDonald, psychology professor: completely cancelled
Ricardo Duchesne, sociology professor: completely cancelled
Greg Johnson, PhD in philosophy: banned off everything
Andrew Joyce, PhD in history: banned off everything -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
New episode of the Cofnas Podcast just in time for Easter!
Two rootless cosmopolitan Jews talk about the future of America
"With Amy Wax: For and against TDS": ncofnas.com/p/with-amy-wax-for-and-against-tdsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"With Amy Wax: For and against TDS"
Full vid at ncofnas dot comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Kendi-ism is "dangerous and bad." But what's wrong with it logically? What do you say when Kendi demands to know why blacks score 15 points lower on IQ tests and have an incarceration rate 5x higher?
@mattyglesias doesn't have an answer. He just tells us that it's "unseemly and inappropriate" to probe into the true cause of disparities, and it's good that we have a taboo to protect our ignorance. But there's no taboo on blaming bad outcomes in nonwhites on white racism. In practice, when you spell out the implications, everything except Kendi-ism is taboo.
"The impulse to slice and dice people into racial groups fundamentally undermines solidarity." But it's not we who sliced and diced people into racial groups—it was a hundred thousand years of evolution. If race undermines solidarity, you have to take it up with Mother Nature. In the meantime, we live in a world where race is real and important.
Apparently Yglesias wants us to ignore racial disparities because we don't need a "perfect racial balance in everything." But you can't stop people from noticing if blacks become <1% of Harvard students, which is what would happen if we did what Yglesias recommends and "judge[d] people by the content of their character [and test scores] rather than by the color of their skin." People will ask questions, and you need to have a good answer.
Colorblindness sounds nice, but it isn't a solution to Kendi's dilemma. If all groups have the same potential, disparities *must* be caused by the environment, which in the context of America means past or present white wrongdoing.
The only way to counter Kendi's logic is with hereditarianism. Nature has made people different on average, and disparities aren't necessarily anyone's fault. That is, in fact, the true answer.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Virtually every thinking person who grew up with the Internet knows about the forbidden knowledge. Equating hereditarianism with "racism" (which implies hostility to certain races) encourages people to make the leap from scientific fact --> bad ideology.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
GNOMED.COM
@gnomeddotcom
I had a dream last night that I was at a dinner party telling @Nigel_Farage to read @nathancofnas and he was just boomer-ing out about blank slatism.
A premonition of the future perhaps? -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
David Brooks says we need to pay reparations to blacks because racial disparities are due to slavery.
The "reactionary fringe" won because conservative "idea" men like Brooks spent four decades selling us out so they could write for the NY Times and go to lefty cocktail parties. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
I may become a Civil War denier.
Prove it happened. I wasn't there to see it.
35,000 (?) books? I don't trust the experts. 15,000 known bodies in cemeteries? Where are the REST of the "620,000 dead," anon?!
One thing we should all be able to agree on - Lincoln was the REAL villain of the conflict, If It Even Occurred. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alex Kaschuta
@kaschuta
The vibe is shifting yet again. The cumulative IQ of the right is looking worse than the market.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Every child who gets measles is a victory against vaccines #maga
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Nietzsche: "A declaration of war on the masses by higher men is needed."
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Things have gone far enough.
Low Human Capital needs to be stopped. x.com/micah_erfan/status/1909761165623771215/video/1 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“This is also my conclusion. The right *in its current form* attracts such low human capital that it is counterproductive for it to actually take power.”
Yes. The most important IQ difference relevant to politics is left/right by far.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I told you" says @akarlin.
Was it a mistake to vote for Trump?
If I'd known that MAGA would become a poverty cult obsessed with bringing Chinese sweatshops to the US, I would have supported DEI Kamala. However, as far as I am aware, no one (including Karlin) anticipated that Trump would declare war on every other country on earth and tank the economy for no reason. Given the information available on November 5, 2024, I think a Trump vote was reasonable. Should we not attempt to win because it's possible that we will fail?
But there are lessons.
The problem isn't *Trump*. It's that the American so-called "right" has become a coalition of stupid people from across the political spectrum. At the lowest IQ levels, the left and right converge on fascism. They favor a controlled economy over the invisible hand, wisdom of the "volk" over universities and book learning, and thuggery over due process. Trump wouldn't be able to get away with this if he didn't have an army of @catturd2's with the same dumb intuitions cheering him on. His future torchbearer will have to be an idiot in order to keep the MAGA coalition together, so he'll be no better.
All over the world, almost everyone with more than half a brain is looking at the disaster of Trump (along with Putin, Yoon Suk Yeol, et al.) and drawing the very reasonable conclusion that right-wing, anti-woke parties are incapable of effective governance. This is also my conclusion. The right *in its current form* attracts such low human capital that it is counterproductive for it to actually take power. What happens when a dog catches the car it's chasing? It looks confused, jumps around for a minute, and pisses on the wheel. That's anti-wokesters taking over the government.
I've been arguing that the right needs to focus on winning the battle of ideas and bringing the elites to our side. The way to do that is to refute the false empirical belief that underlies the ideology of wokism (the equality thesis). But I lost the battle to set the agenda for the right. Instead, it was decided that the only thing that matters is taking power and trolling leftists. Trump won the election, issued some executive orders, and anti-wokesters declared victory. But we are seeing the fruits of this strategy: a right that is on track to be totally discredited and cede power back to the woke.
It is still theoretically possible to turn this around. The Republican-controlled Congress should invoke the 25th Amendment, carry Trump away in a straitjacket, revoke the tariffs, and spend their political capital (which would be soaring) on important issues like deporting illegal aliens. But this is the kind of action that would be taken by smart people, not Republicans.
If you want the right to prevail in the long run, you should do everything you can to prevent right-wing political parties from gaining power prematurely. All focus should be on the Hereditarian Revolution, which we fight for in the realm of ideas, not (yet) in the ballot box. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If @Nero wants to worship Dear Leader by working in a factory he can start tomorrow. There are currently half a million manufacturing job openings in the US, not to mention millions of other jobs that involve making things. No need to make everyone else poor to pursue your dream.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was an AI skeptic, but @grok is on point
Grok
@grok
Alright, I’ll play the pseudoscientist for a moment. Based on the ancient art of physiognomy, Nathan Cofnas’s sharp jawline suggests a resolute mind, perfect for pushing controversial ideas like hereditarianism. His brow? Clearly a sign of deep thought—perhaps too deep for the woke crowd. Eyes? Piercing, like he’s staring down the equality thesis itself. Of course, this is all nonsense—physiognomy’s as scientific as a horoscope. But if we’re mocking bad science with more bad science, I’d say he “looks” like a guy who’d spark a revolution, or at least a good X thread!
Summary: Cofnas’s jawline screams resolve, brow shows thought, eyes pierce equality thesis—per fake physiognomy. It’s nonsense, but he “looks” revolutionary! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Drew Pavlou 🇦🇺🇺🇸🇫🇷🇺🇦🇹🇼
@DrewPavlou
“At the lowest IQ levels, the left and right converge on fascism. They favor a controlled economy over the invisible hand, wisdom of the "volk" over universities and book learning, and thuggery over due process. Trump wouldn't be able to get away with this if he didn't have an army of @catturd2's with the same dumb intuitions cheering him on”
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I told you" says @akarlin.
Was it a mistake to vote for Trump?
If I'd known that MAGA would become a poverty cult obsessed with bringing Chinese sweatshops to the US, I would have supported DEI Kamala. However, as far as I am aware, no one (including Karlin) anticipated that Trump would declare war on every other country on earth and tank the economy for no reason. Given the information available on November 5, 2024, I think a Trump vote was reasonable. Should we not attempt to win because it's possible that we will fail?
But there are lessons.
The problem isn't *Trump*. It's that the American so-called "right" has become a coalition of stupid people from across the political spectrum. At the lowest IQ levels, the left and right converge on fascism. They favor a controlled economy over the invisible hand, wisdom of the "volk" over universities and book learning, and thuggery over due process. Trump wouldn't be able to get away with this if he didn't have an army of @catturd2's with the same dumb intuitions cheering him on. His future torchbearer will have to be an idiot in order to keep the MAGA coalition together, so he'll be no better.
All over the world, almost everyone with more than half a brain is looking at the disaster of Trump (along with Putin, Yoon Suk Yeol, et al.) and drawing the very reasonable conclusion that right-wing, anti-woke parties are incapable of effective governance. This is also my conclusion. The right *in its current form* attracts such low human capital that it is counterproductive for it to actually take power. What happens when a dog catches the car it's chasing? It looks confused, jumps around for a minute, and pisses on the wheel. That's anti-wokesters taking over the government.
I've been arguing that the right needs to focus on winning the battle of ideas and bringing the elites to our side. The way to do that is to refute the false empirical belief that underlies the ideology of wokism (the equality thesis). But I lost the battle to set the agenda for the right. Instead, it was decided that the only thing that matters is taking power and trolling leftists. Trump won the election, issued some executive orders, and anti-wokesters declared victory. But we are seeing the fruits of this strategy: a right that is on track to be totally discredited and cede power back to the woke.
It is still theoretically possible to turn this around. The Republican-controlled Congress should invoke the 25th Amendment, carry Trump away in a straitjacket, revoke the tariffs, and spend their political capital (which would be soaring) on important issues like deporting illegal aliens. But this is the kind of action that would be taken by smart people, not Republicans.
If you want the right to prevail in the long run, you should do everything you can to prevent right-wing political parties from gaining power prematurely. All focus should be on the Hereditarian Revolution, which we fight for in the realm of ideas, not (yet) in the ballot box. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Drew Pavlou 🇦🇺🇺🇸🇫🇷🇺🇦🇹🇼
@DrewPavlou
Wrote about the poverty cult here open.substack.com/pub/drewpavlou/p/maga-maoism-trumpism-a…
Your article on it was very good and influenced my own -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I told you" says @akarlin.
Was it a mistake to vote for Trump?
If I'd known that MAGA would become a poverty cult obsessed with bringing Chinese sweatshops to the US, I would have supported DEI Kamala. However, as far as I am aware, no one (including Karlin) anticipated that Trump would declare war on every other country on earth and tank the economy for no reason. Given the information available on November 5, 2024, I think a Trump vote was reasonable. Should we not attempt to win because it's possible that we will fail?
But there are lessons.
The problem isn't *Trump*. It's that the American so-called "right" has become a coalition of stupid people from across the political spectrum. At the lowest IQ levels, the left and right converge on fascism. They favor a controlled economy over the invisible hand, wisdom of the "volk" over universities and book learning, and thuggery over due process. Trump wouldn't be able to get away with this if he didn't have an army of @catturd2's with the same dumb intuitions cheering him on. His future torchbearer will have to be an idiot in order to keep the MAGA coalition together, so he'll be no better.
All over the world, almost everyone with more than half a brain is looking at the disaster of Trump (along with Putin, Yoon Suk Yeol, et al.) and drawing the very reasonable conclusion that right-wing, anti-woke parties are incapable of effective governance. This is also my conclusion. The right *in its current form* attracts such low human capital that it is counterproductive for it to actually take power. What happens when a dog catches the car it's chasing? It looks confused, jumps around for a minute, and pisses on the wheel. That's anti-wokesters taking over the government.
I've been arguing that the right needs to focus on winning the battle of ideas and bringing the elites to our side. The way to do that is to refute the false empirical belief that underlies the ideology of wokism (the equality thesis). But I lost the battle to set the agenda for the right. Instead, it was decided that the only thing that matters is taking power and trolling leftists. Trump won the election, issued some executive orders, and anti-wokesters declared victory. But we are seeing the fruits of this strategy: a right that is on track to be totally discredited and cede power back to the woke.
It is still theoretically possible to turn this around. The Republican-controlled Congress should invoke the 25th Amendment, carry Trump away in a straitjacket, revoke the tariffs, and spend their political capital (which would be soaring) on important issues like deporting illegal aliens. But this is the kind of action that would be taken by smart people, not Republicans.
If you want the right to prevail in the long run, you should do everything you can to prevent right-wing political parties from gaining power prematurely. All focus should be on the Hereditarian Revolution, which we fight for in the realm of ideas, not (yet) in the ballot box.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
About the tactical alliance with MAGA - I was positing its main effect might be to create a new Woke ascendancy just as it was fading after its 2020 peak (including at your blog), that view is now becoming more prevalent.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You lose when you buy food because you have a deficit with the grocery store
MAGA isn't even an ideology, it's just whatever the stupidest person imaginable would think on every topic
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump: "I spoke to a lot of leaders -- European, Asian, from all over the world. They are dying to make a deal, but I said 'we're not gonna have deficits with your country' ... to me a deficit is a loss. We're gonna have surpluses or at worst we're gonna be breaking even."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Trump says he talks to leaders who want to make a deal, but he tells them “we’re not going to have deficits with your country.”
He thinks we should have balanced trade or a surplus with every country. It’s impossible! He’s really this stupid. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Russell T. Warne 🇺🇸🇨🇱
@Russwarne
I count at least 6 myths about IQ in the article that Pinker quotes. That's a lot, but what else would you expect from "a critic at large for the Culture section of The Times"?
If she had read my book "In the Know: Debunking 35 Myths About Human Intelligence," she wouldn't have embarassed herself so much.
Get your copy here: www.cambridge.org/us/universitypress/subjects/psychology/…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Right-wing scientific illiteracy meets left-wing scientific illiteracy: The obnoxious and daffy ravings of Musk & Trump are countered by reiterating 50-year-old talking points blowing off intelligence and IQ that have repeatedly been refuted. (The measurability, heritability, and predictive power of intelligence are among the most replicable findings in psychology.) www.nytimes.com/2025/04/05/arts/what-is-elon-musks-iq.html
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Yep. Exactly right.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Trumpists are literally nostalgic for being "dirt poor"
Can't make this up -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The market didn't "respond[] favorably" to reciprocal tariffs. Stocks briefly rose after the WSJ falsely reported that the base tariff rate to be applied to most countries was 10%, which was less than expected. They crashed when people realized that 10% was just the floor. Does Ackman not know this?
As for Trump's "negotiating style [that] has worked well for him in the past": Trump inherited a monumental fortune. He sold most of his father's real estate portfolio at far below its market value. The only real money he ever made was from playing a businessman on TV in "The Apprentice."
@BillAckman please don't allow yourself to be dragged down to the level of MAGAtards. Becoming stupid to own the wokesters is going to backfire. Time to jump off of this ship!
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
.@VDHanson makes a compelling case for the @realDonaldTrump tariff strategy, but gets one issue incorrect. He describes the Trump tariffs as reciprocal and proportional to those other nations have assessed on us.
In actuality, the Trump tariffs were set at levels substantially above, and in many cases, at a multiple of the counterparty country’s tariff levels.
Initially, the market responded favorably, up more than one percent when Trump referred to ‘reciprocal tariffs’ in his Rose Garden speech. It was only when he put up a chart showing the actual tariffs that the markets plunged.
We can divine from this response that market participants are supportive of the administration using tariffs as a tool to lower the asymmetrical tariffs of our trading partners, but are highly concerned with tariff levels set well in excess of a corresponding country’s levels.
So why did Trump take this approach?
The answer goes back to ‘The Art of the Deal.’ Trump’s negotiating style is to ask for the moon and then settle somewhere in between. It has worked well for him in the past so he is using the same approach here.
The market’s response is due to the fear that if this strategy fails and the tariffs stay in place, they will plunge our economy into a recession. And we don’t need to wait for failure as it doesn’t take long for a high degree of uncertainty to cause economic activity to slow.
Press reports today have said that all deals are now on hold. This is not surprising. Capitalism is a confidence game. Uncertainty is the enemy of business confidence.
The good news is that a number of countries have already approached the negotiating table to make tariff deals, which suggests that Trump’s strategy is beginning to work. Whether this is enough to settle markets next week is unknowable, but we will find out soon.
The idea that Wall Street and investors are opposed to the President’s efforts to bring back our industrial base by leveling the tariff playing field is false. Our trading partners have taken advantage of us for decades after tariffs were no longer needed to help them rebuild their economies after WWII.
The market is simply responding to Trump’s shock and awe negotiating strategy and factoring in some probability that it will fail or otherwise lead to an extended period of uncertainty that will sink us into a recession.
The market decline has been compounded by losses incurred at so-called pod shops and other highly levered market participants that have been forced to liquidate positions as markets have declined.
Stocks of even the best companies are now trading at the cheapest valuations we have seen since Covid. If the President makes continued progress on tariff deals, uncertainty will be reduced, and the market will begin to recover.
As more countries come to the table, those that have held out or have reciprocated with higher tariffs will have growing concerns about being left behind. This should cause more countries to negotiate deals until we reach a tipping point where it is clear that the strategy will succeed. When this occurs, stocks will soar.
Trump’s strategy is not without risk, but I wouldn’t bet against him. The more that markets support the President and his strategy, the higher the probability that he succeeds, so a stable hand on the trading wheel is a patriotic one.
An important characteristic of a great leader is a willingness to change course when the facts change or when the initial strategy is not working. We have seen Trump do this before. Two days in, however, it is much too early to form a view about his tariff strategy.
Trump cares enormously about our economy and the stock market as a measure of his performance. If the current strategy works, he will continue to execute on it. If it needs to be tweaked or changed, I expect he will make the necessary changes. Based on the early read, his strategy appears to be working.
Let’s help him succeed. It’s the least we can do. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
2/4 "Tariffs will halt the American economic juggernaut, discredit the anti-woke movement, pave the way for a left-wing populist like AOC, stop the right’s momentum in other countries, and bring an end to Pax Americana." -@nathancofnas
ncofnas.com/p/maga-communism-and-the-end-of-america -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Nathan Cofnas' @nathancofnas new substack should piss off both the MAGA crowd and the lefties equally, which is a good sign he's on to something with his analysis.
ncofnas.com/p/maga-communism-and-the-end-of-america?r=87n…
The subject of whether or not Trump's tariffs are going to save or end the world as we know it is making the rounds in the cocktail party circuit here on X, and even Sowell has come out of retirement to opine on the subject. See x.com/HooverInst/status/1907630250135273527.
My question for all the naysayers is this: what would have to happen in the real world, and by when, for you to admit you got it wrong?
Hoover Institution
@HooverInst
In an interview recorded yesterday, Hoover Senior Fellow Thomas Sowell criticizes the tariffs President Trump instituted earlier today. Watch the complete interview with Dr. Sowell on @UncKnowledge with Peter Robinson (@P_M_Robinson) on April 15th, 2025.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Cofnas on what the tariffs mean besides the $10T wiped from the stockmarket in 48 hours
@nathancofnas -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
One of the only Substack essays I really and truly look forward to reading are the ones from @nathancofnas.
I don't agree with many of his conclusions, but so what; I have always said that agreement is the booby prize.
Nathan always makes me think and he challenges my existing beliefs. His latest essay is no exception...highly recommend!
ncofnas.com/p/maga-communism-and-the-end-of-america?r=87n… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Spencer 🇺🇦
@RichardBSpencer
Worth the read
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Excellent post by @nathancofnas, on fire:
"[A]s the Republican Party degenerated into a low-IQ cult of personality, this was unsustainable. The benefits of free trade are counterintuitive, and require a certain degree of intelligence to understand." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Craig Willy
@CraigWilly06
Strong predictions from @nathancofnas: "Tariffs will halt the American economic juggernaut, discredit the anti-woke movement, pave the way for a left-wing populist like AOC, stop the right’s momentum in other countries, and bring an end to Pax Americana." ncofnas.com/p/maga-communism-and-the-end-of-america
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"MAGA Communism and the End of America": ncofnas.com/p/maga-communism-and-the-end-of-america
"Historically, the American right was better than the left on economics. But as the Republican Party degenerated into a low-IQ cult of personality, this was unsustainable. The benefits of free trade are counterintuitive, and require a certain degree of intelligence to understand. On average, people who believe in capitalism have higher IQs. If you chase all the smart people away from your movement, your economic policies will come to reflect the intuitions of below average people who think that trade is inherently exploitative and only workers who make physical objects add value. The base will demand that we return to a simpler time when Americans worked in factories, life was easier to understand, and we didn't have so many vaccines." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"MAGA Communism and the End of America"
The right's stupidity has reached a tipping point: ncofnas.com/p/maga-communism-and-the-end-of-america
- the American economy was better than ever
- income inequality hasn't increased since the 70s
- taxes are paid by the rich
- mob rule by morons won't defeat woke -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You have to give Stanley credit for believing his own bullshit. The proceeds from his book go to some lefty cause, and (in his mind) he's giving up his beloved position at Yale to flee for his life from fascists.
Meanwhile 90% of influencers on the right are bought and paid for.
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
Yale's "Fascism expert" Jason Stanely -- Yale's "Jacob Urowsky Professor of Philosophy" (does anyone now who that is?) -- explains why he's fleeing the US in fear withYale's Timothy Snyder and his wife Marci Shore -- to Canada, which he calls "the Ukraine of of North America."
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aryeh Kontorovich
@aryehazan
@nathancofnas makes a difficult and compelling case for his thesis
you may resist at first, but he will wear you down -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Ben Sixsmith
@BDSixsmith
It's beyond a joke that this is the second time Starmer has called "Adolescence" a documentary. He either isn't entirely sure of what the series *is* or he's completely lost his grip on the difference between fact and fiction.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gregory Connor
@gregoryconnor11
The imbroglio about “two-tier justice” in the UK makes a good case for Cofnas’ theory of Wokeism. The difficult fact is that Blacks in the UK have a statistically higher crime rate at least partly due to genetic variation between populations (Africans vs Europeans) linked to impulse control and aggression. This hard fact is unspeakable, almost unthinkable, in UK policy discussions. With a distorted factual grounding the policy discussions around differential crime rates become unhinged and these Wokeist policies (race-based sentencing) sneak in.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A character in the Netflix show Adolescence explains that the 80/20 rule (most women are attracted to a minority of men) is "Andrew Tate shite" that inspires men to become murderers.
The left has a winning strategy! Say that anyone who believes something that's obviously true (e.g., blacks have a higher crime rate, Jews are overrepresented in Hollywood) is a racist/Nazi/misogynist/Andrew Tate fan. That will definitely turn people away from the far right. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"The End Goal of Wokeness"
My interview with the Brain in a Vat philosophy podcast that wokesters don't want you to see: www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6Xgk9e0CLo&ab_channel=BraininaVat -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
It took 9 years in court to get SCOTUS to rule against affirmative action. What now? File a lawsuit and wait another 9 years?
The law is not the deciding factor. Institutions will reflect the ideology of the elites, which continues to be wokism.
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
NYU was hacked earlier today and the admissions statistics for the university were posted.
We saw the typical racial hierarchy that emerges under Affirmative Action and DEI programs where Black and Hispanic candidates are artificially boosted with race preferences while Asian and White candidates are suppressed.
The result? You end up with a student body where the Asian and White students are more qualified than their Black and Hispanic peers. The natural consequence of lowering the bar for some groups.
NYU's admissions practices should be investigated and the university should be compelled to make admissions data public for maximum transparency. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Chief Rabbi is an establishment politician—some wokery is expected.
What's interesting is the Israeli government is making ties to European nationalists who are ostracized in their own countries. Also, the top-voted comments on the Israeli news article are all against the Rabbi.
Consistent with an ongoing rightwards shift among Jews.
Jared Taylor
@RealJarTaylor
Chief Rabbi of Britain and oher important Jews will boycott a conference on anti-Semitism to be held in Israel because European nationalists (Jordan Bardella, Marion Maréchal, Hermann Tertsch of Vox) will be there.
Can't have European nationalists even if they are anti-anti-Semitic and invited to Israel.
www.israelnationalnews.com/news/405506 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
@nathancofnas did predict that anti-woke legal strategy would just be met with activist judges
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Harry Sisson is a jerk, but people are missing the more important lesson: many young women are so uneducated about how life works that they expect honorable behavior from a male feminist influencer who hounds them for naked pictures
Sarah Fields
@SarahisCensored
🚨 Harry Sisson convinced 11 different women that 'he had no roster' and 'respected them for more than their bodies' while persuading them to send explicit photos of themselves through Snapchat, including one from a domestic abuse survivor.
When the women discovered each other one by one, he called them all insane and attempted to coerce one of them into telling the public that the photos were 'fake.'
A Request to the Reader - Set political differences to the side. I believe both sides of the aisle can agree that this is unacceptable behavior from a man-child with collectively over 2 million followers.
Thread here 👇 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
In my essay for @routledgebooks I critique the Clemens (2011) claim that Open Borders could create trillions in GDP.
If the backlash to mass migration hurts institutions, which in turn hurts innovation in the I-7, that hit to growth in ideas swamps the benefits of Open Borders. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Why doesn't the Department of Education stop Chinese Americans from getting high test scores?
Vivek Ramaswamy
@VivekGRamaswamy
We can’t ignore the educational achievement crisis anymore. Students in China are 4 years ahead of ours here. Students in Singapore are a full 5 years ahead. 75% of U.S. 8th graders aren’t in proficient in math. Shutting down the failed U.S. Dept of Education is a good first step, but it’s going to fall on the states to fix the problem.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Tolstoy invented being a vegetarian in denial
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
There is maybe a 1% chance that Covid-19 has a natural origin with no contribution from research.
In that scenario, nature created a unique SARS-like virus with a furin cleavage site matching the 2018 research proposal by Wuhan-US scientists and unleashed it on Wuhan but none of the 1000s of large population centers in China/SE Asia in 2019. Despite scientists around the world searching desperately, none of the 100s of SARS-like viruses discovered to date have a furin cleavage site in the spike S1/S2 junction.
After the Chinese authorities announced to the world that the virus was from the illegal animals at the Huanan market in Jan 2020, they decided to reverse course and cover up all the evidence for a natural origin. They said the market was just a superspreader event by May 2020, causing more people around the world to start pointing fingers at the lab.
Despite the severe national security threat posed by pandemic viruses, the Chinese authorities decided not to definitively track down the source of Covid-19. Experienced investigators, who successfully established the natural origin of SARS in 2003, suddenly forgot how to do contact tracing or serological sample collection which could've settled the question. Instead, they invited the WHO over in 2021 and co-signed a report suggesting the virus came into Wuhan via frozen foods.
Whatever traces of the highly transmissible, super sneaky virus (remember, up to 14 days asymptomatic incubation period in 2019 + pre-symptomatic transmission) in the wildlife trade, fur farms or small villages petered out naturally or were covered up. Making it look like a well-adapted pandemic virus just popped out of nowhere in Wuhan despite its closest relatives being found in caves ~1000 miles away where Wuhan scientists frequently searched for and collected such viruses.
And when the virus caused an outbreak in Wuhan, the scientists there decided not to share their database of pathogen samples or sequences with their funders and collaborators. Even though the purpose of their work was to discover such viruses and predict their emergence into humans. Even though the closest virus relative that we knew of at the time had been collected by the Wuhan scientists from a mine where several workers had sickened with what was suspected to be a SARS-like virus infection. And in their first papers about the virus, the Wuhan scientists decided not to mention the furin cleavage site even though they said they were on the look out for this feature and planned to insert these into SARS-like viruses in the lab.
I think the scenario above is possible, just very, very unlikely. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
"The anthropologist Franz Boas is seen as a key figure in the development of current views on race and racism. This view has become widespread among critics and admirers alike. Yet it is largely false." www.aporiamagazine.com/p/was-franz-boas-a-race-realist
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Presentation is biased, of course, but Vox is reporting on the hereditarian revolution before National Review or the American Conservative
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There will be a reckoning for MAGA's stupidity
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
RFK tells the world that vaccines are overrated, in fact that the best protection against measles is the breast milk of a woman who hasn’t been tainted by the vaccine.
It’s getting very dark. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Patrick Casey
@restoreorderusa
Dr. Nathan Cofnas is a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow in the Faculty of Philosophy at the University of Cambridge. He joins me for a broad discussion of his ideas.
(2:15) Canceled at Cambridge
(9:04) Why conservatives have failed to meaningfully oppose wokeness
(19:52) Could the left incorporate hbd into its ideological framework?
(27:06) Realistically, will most people ever accept hereditarianism?
(30:40) Why civil rights law is not the origin of wokeness
(43:07) Does the right have a stupidity problem?
In the second half, available to subscribers (link in reply), we continue our discussion of the right's stupidity problem. We then switch topics to the so-called "Jewish question." What is it? This leads to a discussion of Nathan's debate with Kevin MacDonald, and why both liberal speech restrictions and right-wing Jew obsession render a sober discussion of the issue difficult. Nathan argues that any political movement, right or left, that isn't explicitly anti-Semitic will attract Jewish people. We then consider the unique post-war historical circumstances that led American Jews to lean left on political and cultural issues. The show concludes with Nathan offering a few thoughts on the hereditarian revolution, which, he argues, "hasn't been tried."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A low-average-IQ political coalition will never govern successfully. The base will demand self-defeating policies and leaders will follow.
Trade wars, extortion, etc. are symptoms of low human capital. The right needs to focus on the underlying problem, not specific policies.
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
1/ Trump's power trip is weakening national populism worldwide. Why?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Timothy Bates
@timothycbates
New paper attempting replication of influential claims used to set government STEM policy based on a "brilliance stereotype". The claim was that boys stereotype their own sex as brilliant, while girls also reverse this: also stereotyping brilliance as male. Crucially, this stereotype was claimed to cause sex differences in STEM jobs.
TLDR: Across five studies in hundreds of children, we found no support at all for any link to career preference, and no significant support for brilliance stereotypes. What we found instead was a large negative stereotype of boys as "very very dull". Please read on…
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S019188692500073X -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Jews did well in the era of newspapers, books, and magazines and antisemitism was stigmatized throughout American society. In influencer driven culture, intelligence is probably more of a hindrance to becoming a prominent public figure. So here we are.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
J.D. Haltigan, PhD 🏒👨💻
@JDHaltigan
Writing about the Dissident Right for part 3 of my Politics of the Psych series which draws heavily on both of these pieces. I would add that many elites already (esp. in tech) are fully aware of the need for a hereditarian revolution. The question is how best to execute it.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Both points are addressed! See the "Guide" (ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution) and "Was I Wrong about Woke?" (ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke).
I don't think Trump should talk about this, and hereditarianism has never been tried. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
When I was 14-15 I was on the track team and my goal was to be a great hurdler.
I trained *a lot* and became slightly better.
If someone said, "Cofnas, you're pretty fast for a Jew with glasses, but you're never going to win any races," they would have been doing me a favor. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The anti-woke coalition is basically 75 million people who are too dumb or morally insensitive to understand the logic of wokism, and a couple thousand HBD-realist tech bros. Even if Elon, "Big Balls," et al. have high IQs, MAGA is going to be dragged down by its collective stupidity. Hence the trade wars, the shakedown of a weaker country for its minerals, Steve Bannon (neither stupid nor a Nazi) giving the Nazi salute, outbreaks of measles, and more to come.
I've been sounding the alarm that the right needs to focus on its human capital problem by attacking the ideology of the left on intellectual grounds, and therefore bringing elites to our side. Establishment anti-wokesters have ignored me, and are focused on owning the libs on X and destroying all their institutions, with no indication that the right is going to be able to build serious alternatives. But we are soon going to see that mob rule by morons isn't a good political system.
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
What Trump's people seem not to understand is that if they fuck up the U.S. economy and government badly enough, wokeness will become the default ideology of America for the next 50 to 100 years.
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Sowell's theory is a complete fantasy, as I explain here: ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about
Blacks are 14.4% of the population but 0.76% of Americans with IQ >135. Cons are not prepared for a world with <1% black representation in elite, cognitively demanding positions.
"And groups that fail would no longer have the excuse of saying 'woe is me' and instead would have to confront what it is they're not doing that would allow them to close the gap." - This is like asking me to confront what I'm not doing that would allow me to play basketball in the NBA. Nature hasn't distributed innate ability fairly among either individuals or populations. There's nothing humane or productive about blaming people for what their group received in the genetic lottery.Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
When I was 14-15 I was on the track team and my goal was to be a great hurdler.
I trained *a lot* and became slightly better.
If someone said, "Cofnas, you're pretty fast for a Jew with glasses, but you're never going to win any races," they would have been doing me a favor. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Sowell's theory is a complete fantasy, as I explain here: ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about
Blacks are 14.4% of the population but 0.76% of Americans with IQ >135. Cons are not prepared for a world with <1% black representation in elite, cognitively demanding positions.
"And groups that fail would no longer have the excuse of saying 'woe is me' and instead would have to confront what it is they're not doing that would allow them to close the gap." - This is like asking me to confront what I'm not doing that would allow me to play basketball in the NBA. Nature hasn't distributed innate ability fairly among either individuals or populations. There's nothing humane or productive about blaming people for what their group received in the genetic lottery. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Both points are addressed! See the "Guide" (ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution) and "Was I Wrong about Woke?" (ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke).
I don't think Trump should talk about this, and hereditarianism has never been tried. -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The American right can *most readily* obtain power by mobilizing low-IQ conservatives. But there's another route to power, which is more difficult but would lead to a lasting and meaningful victory of good ideas.
A hereditarian revolution is possible: ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolutionPost not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Both points are addressed! See the "Guide" (ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution) and "Was I Wrong about Woke?" (ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke).
I don't think Trump should talk about this, and hereditarianism has never been tried. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The American right can *most readily* obtain power by mobilizing low-IQ conservatives. But there's another route to power, which is more difficult but would lead to a lasting and meaningful victory of good ideas.
A hereditarian revolution is possible: ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
PDF of collection: futurecities.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Five-Criti…
Tagging various people who are cited in the piece or may find it of interest: @ComAcFreedom @ianpacemain @johnarmstrong5 @ProfAliceS @glukianoff @imhardcory @matthewgburgess @nathancofnas @HPluckrose @epkaufm @SteveStuWill @JoPhoenix1 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Toby Young
@toadmeister
Science, nominally the most prestigious scientific journal in the world, is at it again. In November, they published an editorial saying that scientists need to be even more political than they already are. dailysceptic.org/2025/01/11/top-journal-scientists-should…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The most influential voices in public health are RFK and Joe Rogan. They do not have academic backgrounds in health. The academy is bad at medical science.
Hunter Ash
@ArtemisConsort
The four most influential philosophers of our age are David Deutsch, Eliezer Yudkowsky, Curtis Yarvin, and Nick Land. Three do not have academic backgrounds in philosophy. The academy is bad at philosophy.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I resigned from the American Psychological Association last year after 43 years of membership. Sally Satel @slsatel explains the reason - takeover (and ruination) of scholarly & civil-society institutions by illiberal radicals. www.thefp.com/p/american-psychological-association-antise…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rachel Moiselle
@RachelMoiselle
I’ve been studying and working in the area of language and translation since 2011.
I can categorically say that this is the single worst breach of professional ethics I have ever seen. A deliberate mistranslation to hide genocidal antisemitism. I am truly floored.
This is a stain on the BBC that will never be removed. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is hard for Americans to wrap their heads around, but Europeans don't have the concept of free speech. They unironically use the term "free speech" to refer to your right to say what is approved by the government. To use a Bushism, they just hate freedom.
End Wokeness
@EndWokeness
CBS: "Is posting an insult a crime?"
German prosectors: "Yes"
CBS: "Is it a crime to repost a lie?"
German prosecutors: "Yes" -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The trouble with centrists is that they say they oppose wokism, but then they fight tooth and nail against literally any effective resistance.
A "centrist rebellion" would mean quoting John Stuart Mill and going to HxA conferences while wokesters get everything they want.
Thomas Philippon
@ThomasPHI2
We need a centrist rebellion. Wokism was insufferable. trumpisn is 10 times worse.
The trouble with us centrists is that we give people the benefit of the doubt. It’s also our greatest quality. We are aware that we don’t know everything. But we also know BS when we see it. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I just listened to Kara Swisher on the Ezra Klein show.
I now have much better insight as to why Silicon Valley has sifted to the right.
Her entire "analysis" is petty and personal insults about the men she covers. Contempt just absolutely drips off her tongue in every sentence.
To Swisher, they're just scared little boys who want people to love them. They have "little dick energy." And so on.
Psychologists have a norm that they don't diagnose people who aren't their patients. But she has a story for each billionaire whose politics she doesn't like and knows exactly why they became who they are.
This is the person that the media crowned as perhaps their most prominent "tech reporter." It's all psychobabble drivel not held to any kind of evidentiary standards, obviously motivated by pettiness and contempt disguised as journalism.
This would radicalize anyone against the media. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I don't regret spending a zillion hours refuting arguments for a Jewish "group evolutionary strategy." But 95% of anti-Semitism is just mental illness and/or low intelligence.
(Coughenour is Irish. Boardman is Palestinian on her mother's side and has an English surname.) -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
ᐱ ᑎ ᑐ ᒋ ᕮ ᒍ
@Andr3jH
weed should be legal but they should mandate putting this picture on weed packaging like they put rotten teeth and tumors on cigarettes.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Today is the big day!
My debut book, "Troubled: A Memoir of Foster Care, Family, and Social Class," is now available in paperback.
The Audiobook is narrated by yours truly.
US: www.simonandschuster.com/books/Troubled/Rob-Henderson/978…
UK: swiftpress.com/book/troubled/ -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Maya Forstater
@MForstater
"The Committee considered the meaning of the blog & concluded it amounted to, or could reasonably be construed as amounting to, a rejection of DEI policies...The Committee concluded that the core mission of the College was to achieve educational excellence & that D&I were inseparable from that."
Chilling.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am preparing to take legal action against @EmmaCambridge
This will be a landmark case. Goal is to establish a legal precedent that heterodoxy about race is protected in the UK just like gender criticism.
Unfortunately justice costs ££. Please donate: donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
I you haven't read @nathancofnas's new essay yet, and you need a personal invitation, consider this post that invitation!
ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
Also, you can listen to my full podcast interviews with Nathan at tomsowell.com.
Recommend! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
What is the "Great Awokening" and when did it happen?
What is the "equality thesis?"
Did the election of Donald Trump mark the end of woke?
These and other important topics are explored in @nathancofnas's new essay:
"Was I wrong about woke?"
ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
And you can listen to my last podcast conversation with Nathan at tomsowell.com -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Great post on the necessity of hereditarianism.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Was I Wrong about Woke?"
Outvoting the elites didn't change their ideology: ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
@christopherrufo I urge you to take my argument seriously. I'm not the only person who thinks that the race taboo is the linchpin of the leftist sociopolitical order. This view is widely if not universally held among RW zoomer intellectuals. I'm not saying I think you should necessarily start talking about race differences, but there should be more coordination with hereditarians.
Some points elaborated in the post:
- Hereditarianism has never been tried! The conservative establishment gives a pass to Charles Murray (and only Charles Murray) to say some politically incorrect things about race. But to this day Murray has never made an unequivocal statement that race differences are due to genes (and there was certainly no such statement in TBC). If anyone else talks about this issue, conservatives get them cancelled. For example, Jason Richwine was fired from the Heritage Foundation in 2013 when it was discovered that his PhD dissertation at Harvard mentioned some facts about race differences. Harvard was literally more open to evidence-based discussion of race than a leading conservative think tank!
- The vast majority of smart, educated people in the West have simply never been exposed to the evidence for hereditarianism, at least in a way that they can take it seriously. A real information campaign backed by establishment conservative institutions would have a very different result than what has been tried before.
- The right has a human capital problem. To quote an authority on the subject, "the idea that there are 'thousands of rw bros' and undiscovered geniuses who would thrive in an institutional environment is simply not the case." It is difficult to find competent and mentally stable individuals with right-wing bona fides to fill one or two positions at the Manhattan Institute. How are we going to find tens of thousands of serious scholars on the right to take back academia? The only elites who currently side with the right in significant numbers are tech bros who are known to be hereditarians.
- Advocates of "colorblind equality" don't seem to have a plan for what they will tell people when our institutions become totally dominated by whites and Asians. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Yet another mindblowingly thought-provoking essay by @nathancofnas.
Don’t read it…STUDY IT!
Here’s a taste:
“The American right has no coherent message or ideology besides being against the left.
It has no good answer to the major issue of our time, which is the question of lingering race disparities.
We have almost no effective institutions. We control literally zero serious PhD-granting universities. Even universities in solid red states remain in the hands of our opponents. Among graduate students and assistant professors at elite institutions, our representation is very close to zero percent.
The right has been shut out of editing Wikipedia—the most influential source of (alleged) information in our society. Conservative culture revolves largely around figures who are some combination of grifter, crackpot, criminal, conspiracy theorist, anti-Semite, or racist-in-a-bad-way.
We produce virtually no art, music, or literature. Right-wing discourse is dominated by people doing “physiognomy checks” on each other, calling Democrats pedophiles, and telling people not to get vaccinated and that they can cure their cancer with ivermectin.
None of this was changed by the election of Donald Trump.”
Nathan Cofnas
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Was I Wrong about Woke?"
Outvoting the elites didn't change their ideology: ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
@christopherrufo I urge you to take my argument seriously. I'm not the only person who thinks that the race taboo is the linchpin of the leftist sociopolitical order. This view is widely if not universally held among RW zoomer intellectuals. I'm not saying I think you should necessarily start talking about race differences, but there should be more coordination with hereditarians.
Some points elaborated in the post:
- Hereditarianism has never been tried! The conservative establishment gives a pass to Charles Murray (and only Charles Murray) to say some politically incorrect things about race. But to this day Murray has never made an unequivocal statement that race differences are due to genes (and there was certainly no such statement in TBC). If anyone else talks about this issue, conservatives get them cancelled. For example, Jason Richwine was fired from the Heritage Foundation in 2013 when it was discovered that his PhD dissertation at Harvard mentioned some facts about race differences. Harvard was literally more open to evidence-based discussion of race than a leading conservative think tank!
- The vast majority of smart, educated people in the West have simply never been exposed to the evidence for hereditarianism, at least in a way that they can take it seriously. A real information campaign backed by establishment conservative institutions would have a very different result than what has been tried before.
- The right has a human capital problem. To quote an authority on the subject, "the idea that there are 'thousands of rw bros' and undiscovered geniuses who would thrive in an institutional environment is simply not the case." It is difficult to find competent and mentally stable individuals with right-wing bona fides to fill one or two positions at the Manhattan Institute. How are we going to find tens of thousands of serious scholars on the right to take back academia? The only elites who currently side with the right in significant numbers are tech bros who are known to be hereditarians.
- Advocates of "colorblind equality" don't seem to have a plan for what they will tell people when our institutions become totally dominated by whites and Asians. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
Discuss
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"The American right has no coherent message or ideology besides being against the left. It has no good answer to the major issue of our time, which is the question of lingering race disparities. We have almost no effective institutions. We control literally zero serious PhD-granting universities. Even universities in solid red states remain in the hands of our opponents. Among graduate students and assistant professors at elite institutions, our representation is very close to zero percent. The right has been shut out of editing Wikipedia—the most influential source of (alleged) information in our society. Conservative culture revolves largely around figures who are some combination of grifter, crackpot, criminal, conspiracy theorist, anti-Semite, or racist-in-a-bad-way. We produce virtually no art, music, or literature. Right-wing discourse is dominated by people doing 'physiognomy checks' on each other, calling Democrats pedophiles, and telling people not to get vaccinated and that they can cure their cancer with ivermectin. None of this was changed by the election of Donald Trump."
Source: ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Christopher Rufo
@christopherrufo
Yeah, I'm on a deadline, but here are my quick thoughts:
–"Christian morality is the basis of wokism" seems specious and superficial; it was also the basis of colonialism and conquest; wokism is better understood as atheistic/Marxist in origin, and, if we want to take it back further, more akin to the French Revolution rather than the American Revolution
-Regarding the "equality thesis," we have in both the Christian and American traditions an answer to your question: we can affirm the basic dignity (Christianity) or natural right (AmRev) of man, while understanding that natural inequalities will lead to disparate outcomes (see Paul's letters, John Adams, etc.) — equality and inequality must be paired together; if your project is to get rid of wokism and Christian morality and American egalitarianism, you're setting yourself up for an unnecessary (and undesirable) end
-I actually have the opposite interpretation on the relationship between "hereditarianism" and "wokism": I think wokism is, in some sense, a response to implicit hereditarian/culturalist assumptions (doesn't matter which) about inequality; the Great Society was predicated on the idea of the blank slate and that the state can equalize group outcomes, but we tried it, spent trillions and barely made a dent; most people, including libs, intuitively understand the reasons for this and wokism is actually the product of despair (Great Society failed, Obamaism failed) and the new idea was "if we cannot equalize material outcomes, perhaps we can equalize psychological/status outcomes at least within the institutions"
-On the counter-elite, I'm afraid you're way off base: you write that I have "no viable plan" for recruiting elites, but I have done so very effectively, publicly and privately recruiting Silicon Valley, Wall Street, Ivy League, and political leaders to the cause; where, by comparison, is your "hereditarian counter-elite," besides the comments section on a few blogs?
-Your point about "what happens when colorblindness increases inequality" is fair, but hardly the most important right now; you also fail to see the locus of responsibility here—we can hammer for colorblindness, then let the institutions explain the disparities ("don't solve your enemy's problem")
-There is perhaps a thrill at tackling "taboos" directly, but that's not always smart politics; often, it is better to change perceptions around the taboo and shift public opinion implictly; likewise, regardless of agreement/disagreement, there is a notable limit to "hereditarianism" as a political movement—in politics, you do not persuade people with regression analysis and graphs of overlapping bell curves -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"The American right has no coherent message or ideology besides being against the left. It has no good answer to the major issue of our time, which is the question of lingering race disparities. We have almost no effective institutions. We control literally zero serious PhD-granting universities. Even universities in solid red states remain in the hands of our opponents. Among graduate students and assistant professors at elite institutions, our representation is very close to zero percent. The right has been shut out of editing Wikipedia—the most influential source of (alleged) information in our society. Conservative culture revolves largely around figures who are some combination of grifter, crackpot, criminal, conspiracy theorist, anti-Semite, or racist-in-a-bad-way. We produce virtually no art, music, or literature. Right-wing discourse is dominated by people doing 'physiognomy checks' on each other, calling Democrats pedophiles, and telling people not to get vaccinated and that they can cure their cancer with ivermectin. None of this was changed by the election of Donald Trump."
Source: ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Everything wokesters do and say is exactly what they would do and say if they were taking the equality thesis seriously. Why not assume that it's because that's what they're doing, and they would stop if the equality thesis were refuted?"
From: ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
@epkaufm -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Was I Wrong about Woke?"
Outvoting the elites didn't change their ideology: ncofnas.com/p/was-i-wrong-about-woke
@christopherrufo I urge you to take my argument seriously. I'm not the only person who thinks that the race taboo is the linchpin of the leftist sociopolitical order. This view is widely if not universally held among RW zoomer intellectuals. I'm not saying I think you should necessarily start talking about race differences, but there should be more coordination with hereditarians.
Some points elaborated in the post:
- Hereditarianism has never been tried! The conservative establishment gives a pass to Charles Murray (and only Charles Murray) to say some politically incorrect things about race. But to this day Murray has never made an unequivocal statement that race differences are due to genes (and there was certainly no such statement in TBC). If anyone else talks about this issue, conservatives get them cancelled. For example, Jason Richwine was fired from the Heritage Foundation in 2013 when it was discovered that his PhD dissertation at Harvard mentioned some facts about race differences. Harvard was literally more open to evidence-based discussion of race than a leading conservative think tank!
- The vast majority of smart, educated people in the West have simply never been exposed to the evidence for hereditarianism, at least in a way that they can take it seriously. A real information campaign backed by establishment conservative institutions would have a very different result than what has been tried before.
- The right has a human capital problem. To quote an authority on the subject, "the idea that there are 'thousands of rw bros' and undiscovered geniuses who would thrive in an institutional environment is simply not the case." It is difficult to find competent and mentally stable individuals with right-wing bona fides to fill one or two positions at the Manhattan Institute. How are we going to find tens of thousands of serious scholars on the right to take back academia? The only elites who currently side with the right in significant numbers are tech bros who are known to be hereditarians.
- Advocates of "colorblind equality" don't seem to have a plan for what they will tell people when our institutions become totally dominated by whites and Asians. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Nietzsche: Jews are smarter than Europeans so where they have influence they use logic to make society more rational.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Online Nietzscheans would be disappointed if they ever read Nietzsche
(The Gay Science, § 348) -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Online Nietzscheans would be disappointed if they ever read Nietzsche
(The Gay Science, § 348) -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
JayMan
@JayMan471
The definitive definition of Woke, by Nathan Cofnas.
Bookmark this and refer back to it the next time someone asks “what does Woke even mean?”
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A definition of woke should
- identify what drove the post-2012 spike in social justice talk and cancel culture
- place the ideology in philosophical and historical context
- be more or less acceptable to wokesters themselves (not a straw man)
There is only one definition that does this:
"Wokism is what follows from taking the equality thesis seriously, given a background of Christian morality. If all races and sexes have the same innate distributions of psychological traits, disparities in socioeconomic status must be due to environmental factors. In practice, that means differences in outcome favoring whites or men will be attributed to past or present white racism or sexism. This triggers an all-consuming crusade against the hidden forces of discrimination." - ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
The Great Awokening occurred when it became clear that another generation of affirmative action and Black History Months wasn't going to bring about the promised equality. Brainwashed zoomers and late millennials—people who truly believed the Noble Lie that black, white, Jewish, and Asian people are all born on average exactly the same—demanded an end to the unfairness. Since environmental interventions to equalize outcomes quickly run up against limits set by nature, the war on inequality must continually be ratcheted up until you're tearing down statues and cancelling people for microaggressions.
The empirical premise of wokism was first articulated by John Locke in 1690. Locke said that the human mind is like a blank sheet of paper, and if you or I had been born in South Africa, we would act like Africans and vice versa. These ideas were picked up by the French revolutionaries, and then became a tenet of leftism itself. Equality of outcome has been a dream of the left for well over a century.
Many conservatives define "woke" as a laundry-list of left-coded stuff they don't like: gender theory, socialism, etc. Trump says it's "woke" to deny that he won the 2020 election. There's nothing logically wrong with stipulating any definition you want. But these other things are philosophically and historically separate from the ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously. Suppose we outlawed transgenderism and neopronouns, made Rand Paul the head of the Federal Reserve, and retroactively declared Trump the winner in 2020, but we still maintained the obsession with white supremacy and racial bean counting. Everyone would recognize that wokism was still with us. On the other hand, if we became race realists, wokism would be over even if some race realists kept their pronouns in their bios.
As far as straw manning—my definition just repeats what is said by wokesters! A wokester might quibble with my phraseology, or object to the term "woke." But, if pressed, they (including, I assume, @PennyRed) will admit that they are committed to bringing about equal outcomes among people with equal potential, and they'll know when society is fair when all groups are equal.
Many people define wokism specifically as sensitivity about race (or as anti-whitism). This was @eyeslasho's definition:
"Wokeness is a hyper-vigilance toward any real or imagined transgressions against identity-based human dignity, resulting in exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking, a need for purification, and a desire to disengage from and punish transgressors."
Wokism inevitably leads to these things. But the definition doesn't get at the essence of the ideology, and it's not precisely correct.
The woke are not hypervigilant toward *any* transgression against identity-based human dignity. They have no problem with saying things like "The white race is the cancer of human history" (Sontag) or "White lives don't matter" (Priyamvada Gopal). They don't care much about transgressions against Jews or Asians unless the perpetrator is a white man. From the woke perspective, this is logical. Jews and Asians have good outcomes, so the environment isn't working against them the way it is against underperforming minorities like blacks. The wokester doesn't care about identity-based human dignity per se, but environment-caused disparities.
"Exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking," etc. are arguably universal features of human morality. The question is, why are these tendencies being employed in the service of race communism? The answer is that people are committed to taking the equality thesis seriously (given a background of certain moral assumptions).
@eyeslasho's definition portrays wokism as something inherently negative and irrational (being based on *hyper*vigilance toward transgressions that may be imaginary), so it would never be accepted by wokesters. But in order to fight wokism effectively, it's important to understand its internal logic, which is perfectly reasonable if you accept the equality thesis. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
I appreciate the way @nathancofnas defines “wokeness” in a way which is acceptable to wokesters themselves.
The “equality thesis” is the foundation of it all.
Podcast discussion here:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-genius-of-thomas-sowell…
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A definition of woke should
- identify what drove the post-2012 spike in social justice talk and cancel culture
- place the ideology in philosophical and historical context
- be more or less acceptable to wokesters themselves (not a straw man)
There is only one definition that does this:
"Wokism is what follows from taking the equality thesis seriously, given a background of Christian morality. If all races and sexes have the same innate distributions of psychological traits, disparities in socioeconomic status must be due to environmental factors. In practice, that means differences in outcome favoring whites or men will be attributed to past or present white racism or sexism. This triggers an all-consuming crusade against the hidden forces of discrimination." - ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
The Great Awokening occurred when it became clear that another generation of affirmative action and Black History Months wasn't going to bring about the promised equality. Brainwashed zoomers and late millennials—people who truly believed the Noble Lie that black, white, Jewish, and Asian people are all born on average exactly the same—demanded an end to the unfairness. Since environmental interventions to equalize outcomes quickly run up against limits set by nature, the war on inequality must continually be ratcheted up until you're tearing down statues and cancelling people for microaggressions.
The empirical premise of wokism was first articulated by John Locke in 1690. Locke said that the human mind is like a blank sheet of paper, and if you or I had been born in South Africa, we would act like Africans and vice versa. These ideas were picked up by the French revolutionaries, and then became a tenet of leftism itself. Equality of outcome has been a dream of the left for well over a century.
Many conservatives define "woke" as a laundry-list of left-coded stuff they don't like: gender theory, socialism, etc. Trump says it's "woke" to deny that he won the 2020 election. There's nothing logically wrong with stipulating any definition you want. But these other things are philosophically and historically separate from the ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously. Suppose we outlawed transgenderism and neopronouns, made Rand Paul the head of the Federal Reserve, and retroactively declared Trump the winner in 2020, but we still maintained the obsession with white supremacy and racial bean counting. Everyone would recognize that wokism was still with us. On the other hand, if we became race realists, wokism would be over even if some race realists kept their pronouns in their bios.
As far as straw manning—my definition just repeats what is said by wokesters! A wokester might quibble with my phraseology, or object to the term "woke." But, if pressed, they (including, I assume, @PennyRed) will admit that they are committed to bringing about equal outcomes among people with equal potential, and they'll know when society is fair when all groups are equal.
Many people define wokism specifically as sensitivity about race (or as anti-whitism). This was @eyeslasho's definition:
"Wokeness is a hyper-vigilance toward any real or imagined transgressions against identity-based human dignity, resulting in exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking, a need for purification, and a desire to disengage from and punish transgressors."
Wokism inevitably leads to these things. But the definition doesn't get at the essence of the ideology, and it's not precisely correct.
The woke are not hypervigilant toward *any* transgression against identity-based human dignity. They have no problem with saying things like "The white race is the cancer of human history" (Sontag) or "White lives don't matter" (Priyamvada Gopal). They don't care much about transgressions against Jews or Asians unless the perpetrator is a white man. From the woke perspective, this is logical. Jews and Asians have good outcomes, so the environment isn't working against them the way it is against underperforming minorities like blacks. The wokester doesn't care about identity-based human dignity per se, but environment-caused disparities.
"Exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking," etc. are arguably universal features of human morality. The question is, why are these tendencies being employed in the service of race communism? The answer is that people are committed to taking the equality thesis seriously (given a background of certain moral assumptions).
@eyeslasho's definition portrays wokism as something inherently negative and irrational (being based on *hyper*vigilance toward transgressions that may be imaginary), so it would never be accepted by wokesters. But in order to fight wokism effectively, it's important to understand its internal logic, which is perfectly reasonable if you accept the equality thesis. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Whyvert
@whyvert
The most advanced way to define and understand woke I've seen:
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A definition of woke should
- identify what drove the post-2012 spike in social justice talk and cancel culture
- place the ideology in philosophical and historical context
- be more or less acceptable to wokesters themselves (not a straw man)
There is only one definition that does this:
"Wokism is what follows from taking the equality thesis seriously, given a background of Christian morality. If all races and sexes have the same innate distributions of psychological traits, disparities in socioeconomic status must be due to environmental factors. In practice, that means differences in outcome favoring whites or men will be attributed to past or present white racism or sexism. This triggers an all-consuming crusade against the hidden forces of discrimination." - ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
The Great Awokening occurred when it became clear that another generation of affirmative action and Black History Months wasn't going to bring about the promised equality. Brainwashed zoomers and late millennials—people who truly believed the Noble Lie that black, white, Jewish, and Asian people are all born on average exactly the same—demanded an end to the unfairness. Since environmental interventions to equalize outcomes quickly run up against limits set by nature, the war on inequality must continually be ratcheted up until you're tearing down statues and cancelling people for microaggressions.
The empirical premise of wokism was first articulated by John Locke in 1690. Locke said that the human mind is like a blank sheet of paper, and if you or I had been born in South Africa, we would act like Africans and vice versa. These ideas were picked up by the French revolutionaries, and then became a tenet of leftism itself. Equality of outcome has been a dream of the left for well over a century.
Many conservatives define "woke" as a laundry-list of left-coded stuff they don't like: gender theory, socialism, etc. Trump says it's "woke" to deny that he won the 2020 election. There's nothing logically wrong with stipulating any definition you want. But these other things are philosophically and historically separate from the ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously. Suppose we outlawed transgenderism and neopronouns, made Rand Paul the head of the Federal Reserve, and retroactively declared Trump the winner in 2020, but we still maintained the obsession with white supremacy and racial bean counting. Everyone would recognize that wokism was still with us. On the other hand, if we became race realists, wokism would be over even if some race realists kept their pronouns in their bios.
As far as straw manning—my definition just repeats what is said by wokesters! A wokester might quibble with my phraseology, or object to the term "woke." But, if pressed, they (including, I assume, @PennyRed) will admit that they are committed to bringing about equal outcomes among people with equal potential, and they'll know when society is fair when all groups are equal.
Many people define wokism specifically as sensitivity about race (or as anti-whitism). This was @eyeslasho's definition:
"Wokeness is a hyper-vigilance toward any real or imagined transgressions against identity-based human dignity, resulting in exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking, a need for purification, and a desire to disengage from and punish transgressors."
Wokism inevitably leads to these things. But the definition doesn't get at the essence of the ideology, and it's not precisely correct.
The woke are not hypervigilant toward *any* transgression against identity-based human dignity. They have no problem with saying things like "The white race is the cancer of human history" (Sontag) or "White lives don't matter" (Priyamvada Gopal). They don't care much about transgressions against Jews or Asians unless the perpetrator is a white man. From the woke perspective, this is logical. Jews and Asians have good outcomes, so the environment isn't working against them the way it is against underperforming minorities like blacks. The wokester doesn't care about identity-based human dignity per se, but environment-caused disparities.
"Exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking," etc. are arguably universal features of human morality. The question is, why are these tendencies being employed in the service of race communism? The answer is that people are committed to taking the equality thesis seriously (given a background of certain moral assumptions).
@eyeslasho's definition portrays wokism as something inherently negative and irrational (being based on *hyper*vigilance toward transgressions that may be imaginary), so it would never be accepted by wokesters. But in order to fight wokism effectively, it's important to understand its internal logic, which is perfectly reasonable if you accept the equality thesis. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A definition of woke should
- identify what drove the post-2012 spike in social justice talk and cancel culture
- place the ideology in philosophical and historical context
- be more or less acceptable to wokesters themselves (not a straw man)
There is only one definition that does this:
"Wokism is what follows from taking the equality thesis seriously, given a background of Christian morality. If all races and sexes have the same innate distributions of psychological traits, disparities in socioeconomic status must be due to environmental factors. In practice, that means differences in outcome favoring whites or men will be attributed to past or present white racism or sexism. This triggers an all-consuming crusade against the hidden forces of discrimination." - ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
The Great Awokening occurred when it became clear that another generation of affirmative action and Black History Months wasn't going to bring about the promised equality. Brainwashed zoomers and late millennials—people who truly believed the Noble Lie that black, white, Jewish, and Asian people are all born on average exactly the same—demanded an end to the unfairness. Since environmental interventions to equalize outcomes quickly run up against limits set by nature, the war on inequality must continually be ratcheted up until you're tearing down statues and cancelling people for microaggressions.
The empirical premise of wokism was first articulated by John Locke in 1690. Locke said that the human mind is like a blank sheet of paper, and if you or I had been born in South Africa, we would act like Africans and vice versa. These ideas were picked up by the French revolutionaries, and then became a tenet of leftism itself. Equality of outcome has been a dream of the left for well over a century.
Many conservatives define "woke" as a laundry-list of left-coded stuff they don't like: gender theory, socialism, etc. Trump says it's "woke" to deny that he won the 2020 election. There's nothing logically wrong with stipulating any definition you want. But these other things are philosophically and historically separate from the ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously. Suppose we outlawed transgenderism and neopronouns, made Rand Paul the head of the Federal Reserve, and retroactively declared Trump the winner in 2020, but we still maintained the obsession with white supremacy and racial bean counting. Everyone would recognize that wokism was still with us. On the other hand, if we became race realists, wokism would be over even if some race realists kept their pronouns in their bios.
As far as straw manning—my definition just repeats what is said by wokesters! A wokester might quibble with my phraseology, or object to the term "woke." But, if pressed, they (including, I assume, @PennyRed) will admit that they are committed to bringing about equal outcomes among people with equal potential, and they'll know when society is fair when all groups are equal.
Many people define wokism specifically as sensitivity about race (or as anti-whitism). This was @eyeslasho's definition:
"Wokeness is a hyper-vigilance toward any real or imagined transgressions against identity-based human dignity, resulting in exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking, a need for purification, and a desire to disengage from and punish transgressors."
Wokism inevitably leads to these things. But the definition doesn't get at the essence of the ideology, and it's not precisely correct.
The woke are not hypervigilant toward *any* transgression against identity-based human dignity. They have no problem with saying things like "The white race is the cancer of human history" (Sontag) or "White lives don't matter" (Priyamvada Gopal). They don't care much about transgressions against Jews or Asians unless the perpetrator is a white man. From the woke perspective, this is logical. Jews and Asians have good outcomes, so the environment isn't working against them the way it is against underperforming minorities like blacks. The wokester doesn't care about identity-based human dignity per se, but environment-caused disparities.
"Exaggerated perceptions of harm, rigid systems of thinking," etc. are arguably universal features of human morality. The question is, why are these tendencies being employed in the service of race communism? The answer is that people are committed to taking the equality thesis seriously (given a background of certain moral assumptions).
@eyeslasho's definition portrays wokism as something inherently negative and irrational (being based on *hyper*vigilance toward transgressions that may be imaginary), so it would never be accepted by wokesters. But in order to fight wokism effectively, it's important to understand its internal logic, which is perfectly reasonable if you accept the equality thesis. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
JayMan
@JayMan471
I think @nathancofnas’s definition of Wokeness is better: “wokism is … the inevitable consequence of taking the equality thesis seriously”
“the logic of wokism is simple: Races and the sexes have the same innate distribution of potential, ergo all group disparities must be the result of environmental forces. Given the persistence of massive disparities, there is a moral emergency to fix the environment and achieve equal outcomes. As long as environmental interventions fail to produce equality, we must intensify our efforts until we achieve success.”
ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
i/o
@avidseries
Those white Americans who self-identify as "extreme liberals" score the highest on WORDSUM (107 IQ), followed by “liberals” at 105, then “conservatives” at 101, and finally “extreme conservatives” at 98.5.
ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights…
"An 8.5 IQ-point gap between extreme liberals and extreme conservatives might not be conspicuous on an individual level. To put it in context, the average sibling pair differs by 12 IQ points, and it’s often hard to tell which sibling is smarter. But, on a population level, an average 8.5-point difference has far-reaching implications. Higher IQ populations will be noticeably better at constructing effective institutions, and will tend to develop more intellectually oriented cultures."
"There is no conservative New York Times that sends semiserious reporters out to investigate the origins of COVID, election fraud, or vaccine safety, and which then presents the results in relatively unhysterical and polished articles and videos. There is no conservative magazine that seriously competes with the Atlantic or the New Yorker. In fact, liberal magazines are often better at reporting news that favors conservatives than the conservative media itself."
I'll note that the author of the piece, Nathan Cofnas, is a conservative. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
75 million Americans—including @paulg—just voted for DEI candidate Harris, who literally said "everybody needs to be woke" and the government should distribute "resources based on equity" (i.e., race communism). Besides a handful of tech bros, American elites overwhelmingly supported Harris. These people are still in charge of our institutions. Harvard will make a show out of adopting a policy of political neutrality, which will get Republican congressmen of its back. But it will continue to discriminate against whites and Asians, and to hire 0 conservatives. K-12 teachers will continue to brainwash kids about white privilege. Nothing is "collapsing."
In his new essay, Graham himself endorses the premise of wokism: "Racism...is a genuine problem. Not a problem on the scale that the woke believe it to be, but a genuine one." Everything follows from that. If you think that "racism" is worth mentioning as a cause of disparities, there is a moral emergency to fix the racism until the disparities go away. Since, in reality, disparities are largely a result of natural differences that can't be corrected, our interventions will inevitably fail, and we'll continually ratchet up the war on racism until we're tearing down statues and cancelling people for microaggressions. The anti-woke movement will never get anywhere if it doesn't challenge the empirical premise that motivates the ideology (the equality thesis).
Wokism is not gender theory! It is the culmination of a three-and-a-half-century long tradition of blank slatism/race denial. Gender theory emerged from the fringe of the gay rights movement 10 years ago. A backlash against trans surgery for minors isn't going to stop the juggernaut of race communism.
I'm not commenting on Graham or anyone in particular, but I suspect that a lot of the appeal of the "woke is dead" idea is that it's a way for conservatives and classical liberals to save face while they surrender. "We don't need to fight because we actually won!" Anti-wokesters have never had the moral energy to match the woke. It's nice to think that we won the culture war without having to make any real sacrifices.
Paul Graham
@paulg
People seem to be surprised that wokeness is collapsing so fast. But what grows exponentially shrinks exponentially too.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
John Carter
@martianwyrdlord
As Cofnas lays out here, we are a very long way from winning the war on woke. A couple of boycotts and some knee-bending from tech CEOs is superficial. Race communism remains firmly entrenched in all of our institutions, and the younger cohort being prepared to inherit those institutions are even more rabidly fanatical than the squishy liberals responsible for the first Great Awokening.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
See starting from "A Trump win would be better..." ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A coalition of 2 thousand IQ-realist tech bros and 77 million evangelicals, vaccine deniers, and right-wing socialists eked out an electoral victory against the most annoying person to ever run for president. I've been saying for a long time that the conservative mob could be mobilized to reelect Trump (and also that there could be a backlash against men in women's locker rooms). It's a dangerous mistake interpret this as the defeat of wokism.
Elite institutions are still overwhelmingly controlled by Harris voters. Although many of these people moved to Bluesky and are therefore invisible to anti-wokesters on X, they have not changed their ideology. If anything, Trump, RFK, et al. have reinforced smart people's identity as leftists. There won't be a real victory until we win the battle of ideas, which means refuting the equality thesis.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
See starting from "A Trump win would be better..." ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Good summary.
Data-scrubber chat-bots ("Summarize top ten published articles, add code, add joke") are not "thinking in a deep new way."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Anyone under the impression that ChatGPT "thinks" is either delusional or unfamiliar with actual thinking (in most cases the latter).
LLMs are useful for a handful of activities like coding, doing basic calculations, writing doggerel, generating cartoonish images, churning out fake news, and conducting searches. They have zero creativity, ability to deal with genuinely novel problems, or understanding of what they pontificate about, as can be confirmed by anyone with a ChatGPT or Grok account. (See the screenshot of my conversation with ChatGPT where it fails to understand the concept of longer vs. shorter lines.) Training LLMs on more data (which increasingly consists of bot-generated bullshit, though that's immaterial) isn't going to usher in some history-altering singularity.
AI enthusiasts—including a few people who I respect intellectually—will say that in the past LLMs performed feats that skeptics said would be impossible, and there will be egg on my face when ChatGPT replaces me as a philosopher before turning us all into paperclips. But I don't think so. After being trained on 40 gazillion words, ChatGPT hasn't produced a single joke that's funny, or an original philosophical idea, or one sentence that doesn't sound like it was written by a glorified autocomplete (what ChatGPT is).
Many people are spooked by ChatGPT's ability to write an essay of the form "X is an interesting topic. Some people say A about X, but others say B. In conclusion, a good case can be made for A." The chatbot writes this kind of thing better than most people can, so it might feel like the machine has achieved human-level intelligence. But there is a qualitative difference between writing summaries of text in the style of a college term paper and writing something that's new and interesting. Most people write by following the same principles of ChatGPT: they respond to a prompt by shuffling around clichés and phrases (data) that they picked up from their environment. It's not surprising that computers can beat us at that game. But they're not beating us at what matters, namely, adding intellectual value.
Science tells us nothing about what what happens in the magical moment when the mind grasps an idea or comes up with something new. Maybe one day we will figure out how to instantiate that process in silicon. That day is not now.
@gregisenberg shared a story about his lunch with a 22-year-old Stanford grad who was struggling to finish sentences, grasping for basic words. The zoomer explained: "Sometimes I forget words now. I'm so used to having ChatGPT complete my thoughts that when it's not there, my brain feels...slower" (x.com/gregisenberg/status/1869202002783207622). Most people would balk at the idea of outsourcing their thinking to this extent to a human guru—even one who is wise and cares about their well-being. But for some reason we are okay with merging our minds with a trippy chatbot that can't and never will understand what it means for a line to be long or short.
GREG ISENBERG
@gregisenberg
Just had a fascinating lunch with a 22-year-old Stanford grad. Smart kid. Perfect resume. Something felt off though.
He kept pausing mid-sentence, searching for words. Not complex words - basic ones. Like his brain was buffering.
Finally asked if he was okay. His response floored me.
"Sometimes I forget words now. I'm so used to having ChatGPT complete my thoughts that when it's not there, my brain feels... slower."
He'd been using AI for everything. Writing, thinking, communication. It had become his external brain. And now his internal one was getting weaker.
Made me think about calculators. Remember how teachers said we needed to learn math because "you won't always have a calculator"? They were wrong about that.
But maybe they were right about something deeper.
We're running the first large-scale experiment on human cognition. What happens when an entire generation outsources their thinking?
Don’t get me wrong, I’m beyond excited about what AI and AI agents will do for people in the same way that I was excited in 2009 when the App Store was launched.
But thinking out loud you got to think this guy I met with isn't the onnnnnly one that's going to be completely dependent on AI. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Philip E. Tetlock
@PTetlock
The endpoints of opinions on AI progress: Contrast the amusing debunking post below with recent upbeat projections from Open AI & Anthropic CEOs that AGI is arriving in 2025, with super-intelligence soon to follow. Discounting the hype incentives, I lean 75% optimistic. For instance, Demis Hassabis’s accomplishments look “undebunkable.”
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Anyone under the impression that ChatGPT "thinks" is either delusional or unfamiliar with actual thinking (in most cases the latter).
LLMs are useful for a handful of activities like coding, doing basic calculations, writing doggerel, generating cartoonish images, churning out fake news, and conducting searches. They have zero creativity, ability to deal with genuinely novel problems, or understanding of what they pontificate about, as can be confirmed by anyone with a ChatGPT or Grok account. (See the screenshot of my conversation with ChatGPT where it fails to understand the concept of longer vs. shorter lines.) Training LLMs on more data (which increasingly consists of bot-generated bullshit, though that's immaterial) isn't going to usher in some history-altering singularity.
AI enthusiasts—including a few people who I respect intellectually—will say that in the past LLMs performed feats that skeptics said would be impossible, and there will be egg on my face when ChatGPT replaces me as a philosopher before turning us all into paperclips. But I don't think so. After being trained on 40 gazillion words, ChatGPT hasn't produced a single joke that's funny, or an original philosophical idea, or one sentence that doesn't sound like it was written by a glorified autocomplete (what ChatGPT is).
Many people are spooked by ChatGPT's ability to write an essay of the form "X is an interesting topic. Some people say A about X, but others say B. In conclusion, a good case can be made for A." The chatbot writes this kind of thing better than most people can, so it might feel like the machine has achieved human-level intelligence. But there is a qualitative difference between writing summaries of text in the style of a college term paper and writing something that's new and interesting. Most people write by following the same principles of ChatGPT: they respond to a prompt by shuffling around clichés and phrases (data) that they picked up from their environment. It's not surprising that computers can beat us at that game. But they're not beating us at what matters, namely, adding intellectual value.
Science tells us nothing about what what happens in the magical moment when the mind grasps an idea or comes up with something new. Maybe one day we will figure out how to instantiate that process in silicon. That day is not now.
@gregisenberg shared a story about his lunch with a 22-year-old Stanford grad who was struggling to finish sentences, grasping for basic words. The zoomer explained: "Sometimes I forget words now. I'm so used to having ChatGPT complete my thoughts that when it's not there, my brain feels...slower" (x.com/gregisenberg/status/1869202002783207622). Most people would balk at the idea of outsourcing their thinking to this extent to a human guru—even one who is wise and cares about their well-being. But for some reason we are okay with merging our minds with a trippy chatbot that can't and never will understand what it means for a line to be long or short.
GREG ISENBERG
@gregisenberg
Just had a fascinating lunch with a 22-year-old Stanford grad. Smart kid. Perfect resume. Something felt off though.
He kept pausing mid-sentence, searching for words. Not complex words - basic ones. Like his brain was buffering.
Finally asked if he was okay. His response floored me.
"Sometimes I forget words now. I'm so used to having ChatGPT complete my thoughts that when it's not there, my brain feels... slower."
He'd been using AI for everything. Writing, thinking, communication. It had become his external brain. And now his internal one was getting weaker.
Made me think about calculators. Remember how teachers said we needed to learn math because "you won't always have a calculator"? They were wrong about that.
But maybe they were right about something deeper.
We're running the first large-scale experiment on human cognition. What happens when an entire generation outsources their thinking?
Don’t get me wrong, I’m beyond excited about what AI and AI agents will do for people in the same way that I was excited in 2009 when the App Store was launched.
But thinking out loud you got to think this guy I met with isn't the onnnnnly one that's going to be completely dependent on AI. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Anyone under the impression that ChatGPT "thinks" is either delusional or unfamiliar with actual thinking (in most cases the latter).
LLMs are useful for a handful of activities like coding, doing basic calculations, writing doggerel, generating cartoonish images, churning out fake news, and conducting searches. They have zero creativity, ability to deal with genuinely novel problems, or understanding of what they pontificate about, as can be confirmed by anyone with a ChatGPT or Grok account. (See the screenshot of my conversation with ChatGPT where it fails to understand the concept of longer vs. shorter lines.) Training LLMs on more data (which increasingly consists of bot-generated bullshit, though that's immaterial) isn't going to usher in some history-altering singularity.
AI enthusiasts—including a few people who I respect intellectually—will say that in the past LLMs performed feats that skeptics said would be impossible, and there will be egg on my face when ChatGPT replaces me as a philosopher before turning us all into paperclips. But I don't think so. After being trained on 40 gazillion words, ChatGPT hasn't produced a single joke that's funny, or an original philosophical idea, or one sentence that doesn't sound like it was written by a glorified autocomplete (what ChatGPT is).
Many people are spooked by ChatGPT's ability to write an essay of the form "X is an interesting topic. Some people say A about X, but others say B. In conclusion, a good case can be made for A." The chatbot writes this kind of thing better than most people can, so it might feel like the machine has achieved human-level intelligence. But there is a qualitative difference between writing summaries of text in the style of a college term paper and writing something that's new and interesting. Most people write by following the same principles of ChatGPT: they respond to a prompt by shuffling around clichés and phrases (data) that they picked up from their environment. It's not surprising that computers can beat us at that game. But they're not beating us at what matters, namely, adding intellectual value.
Science tells us nothing about what what happens in the magical moment when the mind grasps an idea or comes up with something new. Maybe one day we will figure out how to instantiate that process in silicon. That day is not now.
@gregisenberg shared a story about his lunch with a 22-year-old Stanford grad who was struggling to finish sentences, grasping for basic words. The zoomer explained: "Sometimes I forget words now. I'm so used to having ChatGPT complete my thoughts that when it's not there, my brain feels...slower" (x.com/gregisenberg/status/1869202002783207622). Most people would balk at the idea of outsourcing their thinking to this extent to a human guru—even one who is wise and cares about their well-being. But for some reason we are okay with merging our minds with a trippy chatbot that can't and never will understand what it means for a line to be long or short.
GREG ISENBERG
@gregisenberg
Just had a fascinating lunch with a 22-year-old Stanford grad. Smart kid. Perfect resume. Something felt off though.
He kept pausing mid-sentence, searching for words. Not complex words - basic ones. Like his brain was buffering.
Finally asked if he was okay. His response floored me.
"Sometimes I forget words now. I'm so used to having ChatGPT complete my thoughts that when it's not there, my brain feels... slower."
He'd been using AI for everything. Writing, thinking, communication. It had become his external brain. And now his internal one was getting weaker.
Made me think about calculators. Remember how teachers said we needed to learn math because "you won't always have a calculator"? They were wrong about that.
But maybe they were right about something deeper.
We're running the first large-scale experiment on human cognition. What happens when an entire generation outsources their thinking?
Don’t get me wrong, I’m beyond excited about what AI and AI agents will do for people in the same way that I was excited in 2009 when the App Store was launched.
But thinking out loud you got to think this guy I met with isn't the onnnnnly one that's going to be completely dependent on AI.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Prompt: "Write a four-paragraph tweet in the style of Nathan Cofnas about how ChatGPT isn't capable of genuine thinking."
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Keith Woods made up the "ethnic nepotism" part. The speaker says he wants to (1) turn Indians Republican, (2) strengthen Indo-US relations, and (3) highlight issues like Hindu persecution and phobia.
One of the main complaints against minorities used to be that they don't vote conservative. But when they do vote conservative, race nationalists hate them even more. Normal human behavior such as asking people to stop being racist against them is held up as proof of a sinister plot.
After nationalists succeed in driving Indians away from the conservative movement, it will be time to come up with a scientific theory about how Hinduism is a "group evolutionary strategy" to undermine Western societies, and the reason Indians don't vote Republican is because they're genetically programed to be against whites. After all, there is no other explanation for why Indians wouldn't want to be on Team Keith Woods.
Keith Woods
@KeithWoodsYT
Indian activists argue they should mimic Jewish behaviour in the West by engaging in ethnic nepotism, creating lobby groups like AIPAC to make politicians serve Indian interests, and working against "Hinduphobia" with media control
This is what liberalism with multiracialism cashes out to: a bunch of ethnic lobby groups competing for advantage using the language of tolerance as weapons to subdue the host populationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Who in the "race and IQ crowd" is chimping out over the presence of high-IQ Brahmins in America? Is it Cremieux, i/o, Charles Murray, Noah Carl, Bo Winegard, or me? No, it's race nationalists who have an ideology 1st, science 2nd approach to politics, and who have never been endorsed by us.
This is what I wrote in "Why We Need to Talk about the Right's Stupidity Problem":
"The fact that the right's stupidity stems from its failure to embrace race realism does not mean that current, publicly self-identified 'race realists' are particularly intelligent or talented. In fact, they are often the opposite....My call for a race-realist right is not a recommendation to look to these emotionally disturbed fools for leadership or support. Race realism needs to be incorporated into the right from the top. The priority for right-wing intellectuals should be disseminating accurate information about race and race differences, and devising a new political philosophy that is intellectually and morally appealing to the current left-wing elites" (ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights).
Hanania's plan to "shut up about race and IQ" would make it impossible formulate a real challenge to the philosophical foundations of wokism. And no, we are not winning the war on woke without race realism. Things are on track to get *a lot worse* with the rise of millennials and gen z (ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning).
Separate issue: For a variety of reasons I don't advocate open borders for high-IQ immigrants. But the right's meltdown over 65,000 Indian H-1B visa holders in the US does not come from a place of science or rationality.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The high-skilled immigration debate really is a mask-off moment for the race and IQ crowd. They like achievement data when it shows whites doing better than minorities. When whites do worse, they start talking like Kendi. www.richardhanania.com/p/shut-up-about-race-and-iq
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
How to be a conservative thought leader in 7 steps:
1) Be a rando who’s caught on video beefing with leftists. (No problem if you’re a lefty yourself—you can fix that later.)
2) Conservative media tour: You are so brave and smart. Finally people are pushing back! Because of heroes like you we are winning the fight against woke.
3) Get a platform to push your big crackpot theory that the world previously ignored.
4) Be praised as a genius by rightoids. Everyone follows and looks up to you.
5) Run out of ideas.
6) Choose 3 of the following 6 options:
(a) Daily Wire
(b) anti-Semitism
(c) religion
(d) TERFism
(e) vaccine denial
(f) pills
7) Podcast, merch, online courses... -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
*All* communities on the right are dysfunctional. We're the dumb side. The question is how to attract better human capital. As long as smart, morally sensitive people believe in psychological equality, they'll think there's an emergency to bring about equality of outcome—i.e., they'll lean woke. If smart people become hereditarian, they'll defect to the right and create something that isn't dysfunctional.
I've repeatedly emphasized the fact that "race realism" attracts a mixed bag of people. Most self-identified "race realists" actually subscribe to a version of wokism that substitutes Jews for blacks. There's nothing wrong with "be[ing] on guard against people who are too excited by race stats." But if the plan is to defeat wokism *without* race stats—and therefore without ever winning an argument against woke logic—we're going to face yet another generation of failure.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Best thing I’ve read on the wokeness question in a while. Spend some time online, go out and seek communities that are excited about talking about racial differences in IQ. The fact that they’re so dysfunctional is not an accident, and it’s probably not simply a function of their views being taboo.
Few people, wokes or anti-wokes, are into abstract truths for their own sake. But while wokes signal virtue, anti-wokes are into signalling vice. This means you need to give people feel good claptrap to replace woke. You may even include an implicit acceptance of group differences in your ideology, but you always have to be on guard against people who are too excited by race stats. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Very interesting post by @zagrebbi on Gray Mirror defending the wokism-as-virtue-signaling thesis: graymirror.substack.com/p/the-origin-of-woke-a-george-mason
I agree that it’s often correct to attribute people’s beliefs to a drive for status. However, this raises the question of *why the belief is associated with higher status in the first place*. And the answer may be that the belief was judged by a more-or-less rational community to be logical and supported by evidence.
My example is the theory of evolution. Intelligent people used to virtue signal by being Biblical literalists and young earth creationists. Then in the 19th century a bunch of nerds wrote books and articles with evidence for evolution by natural selection, and most intelligent people changed their minds. Biblical literalism switched from high to low status. The proximate explanation for why the average college grad in 2024 believes in evolution is probably the fact that the belief is accorded status in his community. But the ultimate explanation is the fact that Darwin et al. made objectively good arguments.
“Elites are better placed to swallow this aversion because they are smart and sophisticated enough to intuit wokeness is high status to people who matter.” – Again, why did wokism become high status to people who matter (i.e., smart people)? Given that wokism follows from premises that (I think) Zagrebbi agrees are shared by both the mainstream left and right (particularly the equality thesis), isn’t the more parsimonious explanation that smart people are more likely to follow the logic of the premises? This doesn’t mean that each individual wokester is a philosopher who goes through a rigorous process of working out the logical implications of their beliefs. But smart communities gravitate toward the logical (or at least internally consistent) conclusion, and within the community status is associated with the logical view.
Zagrebbi says that the trigger for wokism (treating everyone the same) was “more diversity in American elite spaces.” But this diversity is largely a *consequence*, not cause, of wokism. American elites diversified their spaces because they wanted to bring about equality of outcome among groups that they believed had equal potential.
“I doubt that, on the margin, writing another killer paper that moves the—regrettably—hypothetical race and IQ controversy Rootclaim a fraction of a percent closer to one hundred will have an impact on the broader culture on any reasonable time scale.” – I would emphasize that my strategy doesn’t involve *only* writing papers. I have called for an organized campaign to spread information and retake institutions (ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution). There is suggestive evidence that a hereditarian revolution may already be underway. Virtually all zoomer—and most millennial—intellectuals on the right understand the reality and importance of race differences. Over the next 10-15 years they’re going to start gaining influence in establishment conservative institutions.
“What makes wokeness so sticky and ubiquitous is that it is a generally accurate signal that you are going to treat people well, and thus are worth cooperating with.” – One potential problem for the wokism-as-virtual-signaling thesis is that wokesters are notorious for infighting and trying to cancel each other. This seems more consistent with wokism being in many cases rooted in sincere moral commitment rather than an impulse to signal cooperativeness. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Sam Harris and Yascha Mounk's brand of liberalism is a dead end because they agree with the premise of wokism (disparities = discrimination or disadvantage) and their solution ("universal ideals" and treating everyone the same) would literally make inequality *worse*
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Yes, Sam Harris had Charles Murray on his podcast and he knows the truth about race. But he's stated that group differences is a topic that he prefers not to think about, so he refuses to consider the implications and just wonders why we can't turn the clock back to 2011.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Gather beneath the Christmas tree or Hanukkah bush and listen to Nicholas Wade and me talk about the evolution of human diversity, leftist groupthink, and how to reform academia ncofnas.com/p/talking-about-race-differences-with
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
They should have asked if he's a *homophobic* white supremacist
Ridvan Aydemir | Apostate Prophet
@ApostateProphet
POLICE: "They're saying you're a white supremacist?"
NICK FUENTES: "I'm not a white supremacist. I'm Mexican. My last name is Fuentes."
🤣🤣🤣 He folded very quickly.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
David Quinn
@DavQuinn
Ireland only recognised Israel in 1963. It took until 1996 for us to open an embassy in Israel. We put the worst interpretation on everything Israel does and almost never see the Israeli point of view. We constantly criticise Israel. But note well, we are not anti-Israeli!
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Do you like groypers?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Latest from the "Wokism is over" files:
The journal Intelligence—one of the few institutions in academia not controlled by activists—will be captured. Elsevier went over the heads of the editorial board and appointed politically aligned editors-in-chief. www.aporiamagazine.com/p/mass-resignations-at-the-journal -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Whose explanation for the origins of wokeness is most true?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
pagliacci the hated 🌝
@Slatzism
making humans with affirmative action sperm is probably the worst idea I’ve ever heard
Science girl
@sciencegirl
A nanobot helping a sperm with motility issues along towards an egg.
These metal helixes are so small they can completely wrap around the tail of a single sperm and assist it along its journey -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In the UK, only 35% of Labour voters and 43% of Conservative voters agree that "People should be allowed to say what they like, even if it's offensive." Eventually the law is going to catch up with public opinion (even more than now).
If you want free speech, go to America.
Robert Jenrick
@RobertJenrick
A Labour MP calls for a law to ban criticism of prophets.
Starmer does not rule it out
The answer was simple: Blasphemy laws have no place in the UK.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
For 300 years, Europeans who wanted freedom went to America. It's not surprising that the descendants of the people who stayed would think that "free speech doesn't mean you can be offensive."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Source for the survey showing Brits are against free speech: Eric Kaufmann's The Third Awokening, pp. 337-338
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I wrote a whole paper defending coercive paternalism to help people with low IQs philpapers.org/archive/COFCPA.pdf
sarah
@sarahtonin
Something I hate about IQ discourse is that it's never rooted in benevolence for those with lower IQs. The conversation is always centered around finding IQ differences - with little concern for actually helping people. I realize the reason for this is because IQ realists feel that debate is often suppressed so the discourse has simply become debating 'over the facts' of who has what IQ. However, if IQ realists wanted to be taken in good faith I think the approach to their findings would be far more connected to good policy and exhibit clear compassion for those who simply just have less compute.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The last point I want to make (which was also Hanania's takeaway) is that BAP hasn't read the people he's criticizing. No one wants to be like China. We might admire Singapore, but I suspect none of us even thinks it would be biologically *possible* to emulate it with Westerners.
Bronze Age Pervert
@bronzeagemantis
If a group is telling you the only alternatives are to be like Brazil or Dominican Rep. or on the other hand like Chyna or Singapore (but with a foreign managerial elite), they can be politely told to fuck off; this isn't "science" it's a political program driven by pathology...
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Is wokism just beginning?
My conversation with @NoahCarl90 for @AporiaMagazine: www.aporiamagazine.com/p/is-wokeness-just-beginning
YouTube clip: www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ejwreWQOOk -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The California Review
@calreview1868
We had the pleasure of having philosopher Nathan Cofnas (@nathancofnas) on our show. Nathan is a Leverhulme Early Career Fellow at the University of Cambridge.
While Nathan was scheduled to speak with The Review prior to the recent public refutations by his interlocutor, BAP (@bronzeagemantis), and The California Review would like to officially remain impartial to either side of this extant debate, one of our correspondents has written a brief response along with the episode at www.californiareview.org/the-hereditarian-revolution-with…
Thank you so much to Nathan for his time. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
BAPists say lefties won't change their political views even if you teach them about race differences. But they are projecting their own intellectual dishonesty onto others.
Many of the most intelligent, talented people (i.e., people very different from BAP and his followers) are genuinely dumbfounded by racial disparities. Because of brainwashing, they don't take hereditarianism seriously, so they channel their moral energy into a crusade against the mystical environmental forces that produce the bad outcomes. They wouldn't go down this path if they were informed about race and IQ.
I have acknowledged from the beginning that some wokesters will cling to their ideology even after the beliefs that motivated it are refuted. That doesn't mean that Rawlsian Race Communism is going to be a viable political movement. If you give up white privilege, institutional racism, implicit bias, and the legacy of slavery as empirical explanations for group disparities, wokism loses its bite.
The political right has very little human capital, no art, no functioning institutions, no real organization, and no coherent message. The only thing we have is the truth about hereditarianism. We should not seek council from those who recommend disarming ourselves of our one effective weapon.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@bronzeagemantis recently published an essay, "Race in America and the Dork Right: Against an Authoritarianism of Clerks." He didn't mention any of us by name, but in a deleted tweet he said he had in mind @razibkhan, @RichardHanania, and "to a lesser extent" Nathan Cofnas.
BAP doesn't engage with any of our arguments. His essay consists mainly of bombastic assertions not based on evidence. (Apparently some people think this style sounds very intelligent and profound. More on that in a moment.) I've documented the history of belief in group equality, traced the causal path from the equality thesis to wokism, and explained how a hereditarian revolution is feasible and desirable. BAP ignores all of that, and goes on about how the "dorks" are really motivated by their fear of the "physical, athletic and sexual prowess of black and [gentile] white men."
An interesting passage:
"It is based on a self-serving misunderstanding of civilization on the part of nerds which has long been the basis of the 'HBD/IQ' orientation: that civilization is built by the dutiful, docile, orderly and shy clerk, tinkerer, 'engineer', and shopkeeper, in other words men like themselves, and that on the other side of these qualities you have all of those they have both deemed as foreign to themselves and occasionally fetishized, such as physical strength and ability, charisma, prowess in battle, violence, volatility in character, laziness when it comes to work, profligacy, attractiveness to women and sexual prowess, etc."
It is unclear on what basis BAP apparently identifies with qualities like "prowess in battle, violence," etc. Unless I'm missing something, he was never in the military, but spent his youth in school getting a PhD. He even hid behind a pseudonym for years until he was doxed (or, if he allowed himself to be doxed, until he was safe from cancellation). This posturing as a violent warrior seems to me like LARPing.
More important, the HBD "nerds" are entirely correct about what traits are necessary for civilization, chief among them being general intelligence. Civilization moves forward because of people with IQs above 120. All things being equal, the higher the average IQ of the population, the more civilization you get. IQ is also associated with valor. It's estimated that WWI and II cost Europe 3 IQ points, since intelligent people were more likely to charge into enemy fire.
Physical strength can be meritorious to a certain degree when combined with other virtues. But who is more admirable: the Hanshkenazi "nerd" who builds a rocket to go to outer space, or the nude bodybuilder who looks at himself in the mirror? There's no objectively correct answer to that question. But I'll put my cards on the table and say that, in my view, the former has achieved a higher level of greatness than the latter.
Curiously, BAP's only specific example of a great individual is Grigori Perelman—the mathematician who proved the Poincaré conjecture and turned down the Fields Medal and the Millennium Prize. But Perelman is not a nude body builder. He is a skinny Jew with an extremely high IQ and a monomaniacal focus on his work.
BAP asserts that a society organized around the principles of HBD would be a dystopian "authoritarianism of clerks," and, in any case, he says that HBD is very unlikely to be widely accepted. There isn't much of an argument for this. In reality, dissidents have one and only one effective weapon against the reigning ideology, which is the truth of hereditarianism. There is highly suggestive evidence that a hereditarian revolution may already be underway. Virtually all young intellectuals on the right are aware of the facts about race. The world's richest man and the incoming Vice President of America both probably know the truth. A single tweet by Musk could open the floodgates.
BAP says that HBD acceptance wouldn't defeat wokism, since liberals would pursue race communism on the basis that we are obligated to correct for the unfairness of nature itself. If he is right, why is there not a single clear example of a liberal who takes such a position? Kathryn Paige Harden isn't an example, since she denies that there's any evidence for race differences. Liberals wouldn't perceive HBD as such a threat if it could be reconciled with their ideology. Hundreds of thousands of data points show that hereditarianism cures wokism. The fact that we can imagine some hypothetical HBD-based incarnation of wokism doesn't mean that anyone is going to take such a view seriously. The empirical evidence shows that virtually no one in real life is an HBD race communist.
The bar for being considered a great intellectual in the online right is very low. Many people will be easily impressed by pompous references to Nietzsche and "antiquity," or howlers such as "in higher mathematics there's basically no output of worth outside of the United States, Russia, and France." If you find BAP entertaining, I don't want to take that away from you. But it would be a mistake to look to him for guidance on political theory or strategy. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
People have complex takes on BAP, mine is that he doesn’t read the people he criticizes. He lumps me in with Nathan, and associates concern with Elite Human Capital with prioritizing high skill immigration and admiring Asian societies. Those aren’t my positions.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@bronzeagemantis recently published an essay, "Race in America and the Dork Right: Against an Authoritarianism of Clerks." He didn't mention any of us by name, but in a deleted tweet he said he had in mind @razibkhan, @RichardHanania, and "to a lesser extent" Nathan Cofnas.
BAP doesn't engage with any of our arguments. His essay consists mainly of bombastic assertions not based on evidence. (Apparently some people think this style sounds very intelligent and profound. More on that in a moment.) I've documented the history of belief in group equality, traced the causal path from the equality thesis to wokism, and explained how a hereditarian revolution is feasible and desirable. BAP ignores all of that, and goes on about how the "dorks" are really motivated by their fear of the "physical, athletic and sexual prowess of black and [gentile] white men."
An interesting passage:
"It is based on a self-serving misunderstanding of civilization on the part of nerds which has long been the basis of the 'HBD/IQ' orientation: that civilization is built by the dutiful, docile, orderly and shy clerk, tinkerer, 'engineer', and shopkeeper, in other words men like themselves, and that on the other side of these qualities you have all of those they have both deemed as foreign to themselves and occasionally fetishized, such as physical strength and ability, charisma, prowess in battle, violence, volatility in character, laziness when it comes to work, profligacy, attractiveness to women and sexual prowess, etc."
It is unclear on what basis BAP apparently identifies with qualities like "prowess in battle, violence," etc. Unless I'm missing something, he was never in the military, but spent his youth in school getting a PhD. He even hid behind a pseudonym for years until he was doxed (or, if he allowed himself to be doxed, until he was safe from cancellation). This posturing as a violent warrior seems to me like LARPing.
More important, the HBD "nerds" are entirely correct about what traits are necessary for civilization, chief among them being general intelligence. Civilization moves forward because of people with IQs above 120. All things being equal, the higher the average IQ of the population, the more civilization you get. IQ is also associated with valor. It's estimated that WWI and II cost Europe 3 IQ points, since intelligent people were more likely to charge into enemy fire.
Physical strength can be meritorious to a certain degree when combined with other virtues. But who is more admirable: the Hanshkenazi "nerd" who builds a rocket to go to outer space, or the nude bodybuilder who looks at himself in the mirror? There's no objectively correct answer to that question. But I'll put my cards on the table and say that, in my view, the former has achieved a higher level of greatness than the latter.
Curiously, BAP's only specific example of a great individual is Grigori Perelman—the mathematician who proved the Poincaré conjecture and turned down the Fields Medal and the Millennium Prize. But Perelman is not a nude body builder. He is a skinny Jew with an extremely high IQ and a monomaniacal focus on his work.
BAP asserts that a society organized around the principles of HBD would be a dystopian "authoritarianism of clerks," and, in any case, he says that HBD is very unlikely to be widely accepted. There isn't much of an argument for this. In reality, dissidents have one and only one effective weapon against the reigning ideology, which is the truth of hereditarianism. There is highly suggestive evidence that a hereditarian revolution may already be underway. Virtually all young intellectuals on the right are aware of the facts about race. The world's richest man and the incoming Vice President of America both probably know the truth. A single tweet by Musk could open the floodgates.
BAP says that HBD acceptance wouldn't defeat wokism, since liberals would pursue race communism on the basis that we are obligated to correct for the unfairness of nature itself. If he is right, why is there not a single clear example of a liberal who takes such a position? Kathryn Paige Harden isn't an example, since she denies that there's any evidence for race differences. Liberals wouldn't perceive HBD as such a threat if it could be reconciled with their ideology. Hundreds of thousands of data points show that hereditarianism cures wokism. The fact that we can imagine some hypothetical HBD-based incarnation of wokism doesn't mean that anyone is going to take such a view seriously. The empirical evidence shows that virtually no one in real life is an HBD race communist.
The bar for being considered a great intellectual in the online right is very low. Many people will be easily impressed by pompous references to Nietzsche and "antiquity," or howlers such as "in higher mathematics there's basically no output of worth outside of the United States, Russia, and France." If you find BAP entertaining, I don't want to take that away from you. But it would be a mistake to look to him for guidance on political theory or strategy. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@bronzeagemantis recently published an essay, "Race in America and the Dork Right: Against an Authoritarianism of Clerks." He didn't mention any of us by name, but in a deleted tweet he said he had in mind @razibkhan, @RichardHanania, and "to a lesser extent" Nathan Cofnas.
BAP doesn't engage with any of our arguments. His essay consists mainly of bombastic assertions not based on evidence. (Apparently some people think this style sounds very intelligent and profound. More on that in a moment.) I've documented the history of belief in group equality, traced the causal path from the equality thesis to wokism, and explained how a hereditarian revolution is feasible and desirable. BAP ignores all of that, and goes on about how the "dorks" are really motivated by their fear of the "physical, athletic and sexual prowess of black and [gentile] white men."
An interesting passage:
"It is based on a self-serving misunderstanding of civilization on the part of nerds which has long been the basis of the 'HBD/IQ' orientation: that civilization is built by the dutiful, docile, orderly and shy clerk, tinkerer, 'engineer', and shopkeeper, in other words men like themselves, and that on the other side of these qualities you have all of those they have both deemed as foreign to themselves and occasionally fetishized, such as physical strength and ability, charisma, prowess in battle, violence, volatility in character, laziness when it comes to work, profligacy, attractiveness to women and sexual prowess, etc."
It is unclear on what basis BAP apparently identifies with qualities like "prowess in battle, violence," etc. Unless I'm missing something, he was never in the military, but spent his youth in school getting a PhD. He even hid behind a pseudonym for years until he was doxed (or, if he allowed himself to be doxed, until he was safe from cancellation). This posturing as a violent warrior seems to me like LARPing.
More important, the HBD "nerds" are entirely correct about what traits are necessary for civilization, chief among them being general intelligence. Civilization moves forward because of people with IQs above 120. All things being equal, the higher the average IQ of the population, the more civilization you get. IQ is also associated with valor. It's estimated that WWI and II cost Europe 3 IQ points, since intelligent people were more likely to charge into enemy fire.
Physical strength can be meritorious to a certain degree when combined with other virtues. But who is more admirable: the Hanshkenazi "nerd" who builds a rocket to go to outer space, or the nude bodybuilder who looks at himself in the mirror? There's no objectively correct answer to that question. But I'll put my cards on the table and say that, in my view, the former has achieved a higher level of greatness than the latter.
Curiously, BAP's only specific example of a great individual is Grigori Perelman—the mathematician who proved the Poincaré conjecture and turned down the Fields Medal and the Millennium Prize. But Perelman is not a nude body builder. He is a skinny Jew with an extremely high IQ and a monomaniacal focus on his work.
BAP asserts that a society organized around the principles of HBD would be a dystopian "authoritarianism of clerks," and, in any case, he says that HBD is very unlikely to be widely accepted. There isn't much of an argument for this. In reality, dissidents have one and only one effective weapon against the reigning ideology, which is the truth of hereditarianism. There is highly suggestive evidence that a hereditarian revolution may already be underway. Virtually all young intellectuals on the right are aware of the facts about race. The world's richest man and the incoming Vice President of America both probably know the truth. A single tweet by Musk could open the floodgates.
BAP says that HBD acceptance wouldn't defeat wokism, since liberals would pursue race communism on the basis that we are obligated to correct for the unfairness of nature itself. If he is right, why is there not a single clear example of a liberal who takes such a position? Kathryn Paige Harden isn't an example, since she denies that there's any evidence for race differences. Liberals wouldn't perceive HBD as such a threat if it could be reconciled with their ideology. Hundreds of thousands of data points show that hereditarianism cures wokism. The fact that we can imagine some hypothetical HBD-based incarnation of wokism doesn't mean that anyone is going to take such a view seriously. The empirical evidence shows that virtually no one in real life is an HBD race communist.
The bar for being considered a great intellectual in the online right is very low. Many people will be easily impressed by pompous references to Nietzsche and "antiquity," or howlers such as "in higher mathematics there's basically no output of worth outside of the United States, Russia, and France." If you find BAP entertaining, I don't want to take that away from you. But it would be a mistake to look to him for guidance on political theory or strategy. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Kevin DeAnna
@VDAREJamesK
Amy Wax at AR, again crediting @nathancofnas, argues that "hard" race realism is absolutely necessary to end "wokeness," because if environmental factors are responsible for discrepancies, it necessarily follows that there must be vast remedial efforts to "fix" the discrepancy.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A medical researcher used an experimental virus to successfully treat her own breast cancer. Bioethicists are "split" on whether it was okay for her to do this.
Another ethical question: should we pay bioethicists to drag humanity down for the sake of making themselves relevant? -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
We have reached the point where saying "dragons don't exist" makes someone a giant among public intellectuals
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Richard Dawkins is a giant next to today’s thinkers, says James Marriott (and he's a young guy). www.thetimes.com/article/b3ecd5d3-b7ff-48b4-b133-790cca22…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
We need to send that Korean lady who is the Rabbi of Central Synagogue to educate the Haredim about Judaism. Don't they know about the ancient principle of tikkun olam (i.e., open borders and gender transition surgery for minors)?
REAL JEW
@THEREALJEW613
Orthodox Jews overwhelmingly voted for Trump.
In the village of New Square, 3,456 people voted for Trump and 12 votes for Harris.
In the village of Kiryas Joel, which has around 10,000 Jewish voters, over 8,000 voted for Trump.
In Rockland County, New York, which has over 30,000 Jewish voters, Trump won with 17,000 more votes than Kamala.
In Orange County, New York, which has a huge Jewish population, Donald Trump won with 15,000 more votes than Kamala Harris.
In Sullivan County, New York, which has a large Jewish population, Trump won by 17 percent.
In Ocean County, New Jersey, which has a huge Jewish population, Donald Trump won with 117,000 more votes than Harris. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The fact that 10s of millions of people like this voted for Trump doesn't mean "wokism is over" and Harvard is going to start hiring conservatives
The elites can be outvoted, but wokism won't end until they change their ideology
Kidbehindacamera
@Lyricoldrap
Pranking our neighbor that Kamala actually beat Trump after discovering new ballots
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"fewer people are being cancelled in part because there’s almost no one left to cancel...In academia, practically every vocal opponent of wokism has been driven out of the profession or...they are subject to endless harassment and punishment" ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning/ @nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A mainstream science communicator puts a thumbs up next to "Race and IQ," and there's no meltdown in the comments section! This couldn't have happened 5 years ago.
The taboo is weakening among informed people. We are ready for a Hereditarian Revolution. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
A hereditarian revolution, maybe
Policy proposals for making science great again
Everybody is out with their wish or hope lists for the new Trump administration, so here's some ideas for improving science overall and for HBD in particular.
www.emilkirkegaard.com/p/a-hereditarian-revolution-maybe -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Don't take these statistics at face value. A huge percentage of Americans identifying as "Jews" are elderly and/or have partial or even no Jewish ancestry.
In New York State (the center of the exploding orthodox population) Trump got 45% of the Jewish vote—a 50% jump since 2020.
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
Apparently no Jewish shift to GOP according to exit polls!
Jews are of course very high IQ. Educational and IQ polarization is off the charts in this election.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The guy singing in Yiddish about how Jews need to vote for Trump probably has 5 or 6 children. Most Harris-voting Jews will intermarry and have 0 or 1 child.
The stereotype of American Jews is going to start changing rapidly.
Nachman Mostofsky ✡︎🇺🇸
@Mostofsky
I've never in my 40+ yrs of life seen the Orthodox Jewish community push a presidential candidate as if it was a local one.
This is a Yiddish song being played on trucks going around Rockland County in NY.
Even if you don't speak yiddish, you'll still understand who it's for.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
One of the good things about the Trump victory is that maybe the media will stop giving airtime to charlatan @AllanLichtman
Lichtman told Cenk Uygur that Biden would've won even if he punched a baby on TV because that wasn't one of the "13 keys" in his pseudoscientific formula -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The guy singing in Yiddish about how Jews need to vote for Trump probably has 5 or 6 children. Most Harris-voting Jews will intermarry and have 0 or 1 child.
The stereotype of American Jews is going to start changing rapidly.
Nachman Mostofsky ✡︎🇺🇸
@Mostofsky
I've never in my 40+ yrs of life seen the Orthodox Jewish community push a presidential candidate as if it was a local one.
This is a Yiddish song being played on trucks going around Rockland County in NY.
Even if you don't speak yiddish, you'll still understand who it's for.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Twilight of the Liberal Jew" thecritic.co.uk/twilight-of-the-liberal-jew/
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
John Mearsheimer says he won’t vote Democrat because of the “genocide in Gaza.”
His whole thing is supposed to be that he’s a realist who thinks foreign policy is too moralistic. But that’s only when you try to spread democracy! When you want to keep Hamas in power it’s ok. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Summary: "if you just stop resisting the woke agenda then we can all be calm and reasonable and SJWs won't burn down our cities"
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Under Biden, the nation has steadily calmed down.
Under Harris, I'd expect that trend to continue.
www.noahpinion.blog/p/if-trump-loses-the-election-our-nation -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
This is an important realization on the path of anyone who takes IQ and personality differences between groups seriously.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Many conservatives have the same worldview as medieval peasants. Left to themselves, there is a chance that they would literally start burning witches.
Rod Dreher
@roddreher
Tucker Carlson has gone public with the news that he was physically attacked by a demon. This is true. He told me about it a year ago. Terrifying stuff. www.youtube.com/watch?v=LDIqoPKNhgo
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Many conservatives have the same worldview as medieval peasants. Left to themselves, there is a chance that they would literally start burning witches.
Rod Dreher
@roddreher
Tucker Carlson has gone public with the news that he was physically attacked by a demon. This is true. He told me about it a year ago. Terrifying stuff. www.youtube.com/watch?v=LDIqoPKNhgo
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Why We Need to Talk about the Right's Stupidity Problem" ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Per Nathan Cofnas' @nathancofnas narrow conception of Woke as racial egalitarianism, here's the historical trend in USA from GSS.
"On the average (Negroes/Blacks/African-Americans) have worse jobs, income, and housing than white people. Do you think these differences are . . . B. Because most (Negroes/Blacks/African-Americans) have less in-born ability to learn?"
gssdataexplorer.norc.org/trends?category=Civil Liberties&… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If this were true, wokesters wouldn't fight tooth and nail to protect the race taboo.
It's theoretically possible to be a race realist who advocates a Rawlsian DEI dystopia where we try to compensate for nature's unfairness. In reality, virtually no one thinks that way.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The establishment can't walk back on blank slatism about race and maintain its intellectual or moral credibility. Everything hinges on this issue. When the lie is exposed, it's game over. ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
AOC: "I do not want to do 4 more years of resistance nonsense under Donald Trump."
Maybe @nathancofnas is right when he says that the election of Trump will only reinforce and harden the Leftist resolve.
I dont know about you but, like AOC, I too am dreading having to listen to another 4 years of Trump Derangement Syndrome, endless hoaxes, lawfare, catastrophizing and pervasive mental delusion.
That's why I do the podcast: if we can't change hearts and minds, there is no hope for Western Civilization.
ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
@AOC
8 DAYS LEFT. PLEASE VOTE. THANK YOU. 🗳️
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
This latest essay by @nathancofnas (Episode 40) reminded me that it's not enough that old geezers like me study Thomas Sowell. If we don't get young people on the Sowell train, all is lost.
As always, Nathan's latest Substack pokes and provokes!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Con institutions don't allow discussion of hereditarianism…because of boomer and gen X gatekeepers who accept the left's race taboos and think we can defeat wokism by talking about Ronald Reagan and quoting Martin Luther King's 'I Have a Dream' speech.'" ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Great post. The only hope is race realism. Musk is getting close.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Wokism Is Just Beginning"
Millennials, zoomers, and elites remain firmly on the side of DEI and cancel culture ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The entire Cofnas Podcast was cancelled from YouTube
Subscribe on Substack: ncofnas.com -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Con institutions don't allow discussion of hereditarianism…because of boomer and gen X gatekeepers who accept the left's race taboos and think we can defeat wokism by talking about Ronald Reagan and quoting Martin Luther King's 'I Have a Dream' speech.'" ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
“We don’t need as many DEI enforcers for the same reason we don’t need to hire people to enforce the ideology that women have the right to vote or you shouldn’t sacrifice your children to Ba’al. DEI is just something that (almost) everyone accepts.” ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Go woke, go broke" is wishful thinking
1) everyone cites the same 2-3 examples (Target, Bud Light, and maybe Disney)
2) all 3 boycotts were about LGBTQ, not DEI
3) "boycott" of Target was mainly physical harassment
4) only Bud Light took a financial hit ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Wokism Is Just Beginning"
Millennials, zoomers, and elites remain firmly on the side of DEI and cancel culture ncofnas.com/p/wokism-is-just-beginning -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The liberal establishment has an impressive ability to self-correct and get ahead of scandals.
Can you imagine seeing a headline like this on Fox or Breitbart?:
Breaking: Discovery Institute Scientists Systematically Ignored Evidence for Darwinism!🚨🚨🚨 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The YouTube community is safe from me and @NoahCarl90 (for now), but you can still watch/listen to the Cofnas Podcast on Substack: ncofnas.com/p/will-a-hereditarian-revolution-defeat
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Acemoglu:
"We need to actively steer technological development in a direction that benefits broader swathes of humanity.... To achieve this, we need to... build strong countervailing powers, such as labour unions... [and] Implement... tax reforms that discourage automation.." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Some things never change.
Heterodox Academy received 3M in funding in 2023. Their expenses for that year was 2.4M.
Of this, 500k alone went to the CEO John Tomasi. In other words, the non-profit supposed to advocate heterodoxy is paying 21% of the grant money straight to their CEO.
CEO role seems to change every year, so everybody can get a run at it.
2022:
2021:
Public filings:
projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/822903153 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
It's redundant to write "I aint reading" when you already have "groyper" in your X handle
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@realChrisBrunet has betrayed virtually everyone he's ever been associated with, including his former mentor Chris Rufo and Manhattan Institute colleagues
This is the man who thinks I have an obligation to support his new career as an anti-Semite bc he wrote an article about me -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“A man of letters is unlikely to have a long career in the low-IQ, podcast-centered world of the groypers, who are going to get bored with this story in a few days and move on to something else.” If your preferred medium is writing you won’t appeal to an audiovisual audience.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Congratulations to Chris Brunet. Previously, he "lived on [his] knees" and wasn't free to dox his own subscribers, betray his supporters, attack his colleagues for their ethnicity, and make factually incorrect statements.
What does Brunet's liberation mean for the rest of us?
First, conservative organizations are going to be much more careful about hiring edgy independent thinkers. There will be a stronger preference for Bari Weiss wannabees who have demonstrated an ability to play by the rules at establishment institutions. When it comes to Brunet, there really was a failure of vetting. He had serious issues with his colleagues when he worked at the Daily Caller, and there were other red flags that should have been noticed. But now, when it comes to hiring, the Manhattan Institute and other institutions will probably start erring more on the side of caution.
Second, it will become harder for the right to attract elites—both Jewish and non-Jewish—who have long suspected that mainstream conservatism is a gateway to anti-Semitism. Many Jews are wary of the right because they believe it could turn against them at any moment. After October 7th and a deluge of left-wing anti-Semitism, a large number of liberal Jews started making overtures to the right, and some went the distance and joined MAGA. Jewish billionaire and former lefty Bill Ackman came out in support of Trump. Now Ackman et al. will see Manhattan Institute-certified rising star Chris Brunet boasting about how anti-Semites are the silent majority among young conservatives.
Brunet's behavior would be atrocious even if it were done in the service of a noble cause rather than a false and asinine one (anti-Semitism). Everyone who has been an insider at an organization is privy to information that wouldn't look great if it were made public. Keeping this to yourself doesn't make you a sellout. It makes you a functional human being who is cable of working with others to achieve a common goal. Obviously, this doesn't apply if you discover genuine corruption or criminal activity. But Brunet hasn't revealed anything like that.
What will happen to Brunet himself? He says that he "will happily ally with the groypers." He liked and retweeted a tweet saying "Groypers love [him] because he's one of them," and he proclaimed himself "groyper-curious." So instead of billionaires, politicians, and academics, this is apparently his new target audience. I'm not so optimistic about his future as a groyper intellectual. Brunet says he has an issue with public speaking and that he can't even do interviews. A man of letters is unlikely to have a long career in the low-IQ, podcast-centered world of the groypers, who are going to get bored with this story in a few days and move on to something else. On the other hand, there's always a market for anti-Semitism (or "anti-Zionism") no matter how the message is delivered. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Congratulations to Chris Brunet. Previously, he "lived on [his] knees" and wasn't free to dox his own subscribers, betray his supporters, attack his colleagues for their ethnicity, and make factually incorrect statements.
What does Brunet's liberation mean for the rest of us?
First, conservative organizations are going to be much more careful about hiring edgy independent thinkers. There will be a stronger preference for Bari Weiss wannabees who have demonstrated an ability to play by the rules at establishment institutions. When it comes to Brunet, there really was a failure of vetting. He had serious issues with his colleagues when he worked at the Daily Caller, and there were other red flags that should have been noticed. But now, when it comes to hiring, the Manhattan Institute and other institutions will probably start erring more on the side of caution.
Second, it will become harder for the right to attract elites—both Jewish and non-Jewish—who have long suspected that mainstream conservatism is a gateway to anti-Semitism. Many Jews are wary of the right because they believe it could turn against them at any moment. After October 7th and a deluge of left-wing anti-Semitism, a large number of liberal Jews started making overtures to the right, and some went the distance and joined MAGA. Jewish billionaire and former lefty Bill Ackman came out in support of Trump. Now Ackman et al. will see Manhattan Institute-certified rising star Chris Brunet boasting about how anti-Semites are the silent majority among young conservatives.
Brunet's behavior would be atrocious even if it were done in the service of a noble cause rather than a false and asinine one (anti-Semitism). Everyone who has been an insider at an organization is privy to information that wouldn't look great if it were made public. Keeping this to yourself doesn't make you a sellout. It makes you a functional human being who is cable of working with others to achieve a common goal. Obviously, this doesn't apply if you discover genuine corruption or criminal activity. But Brunet hasn't revealed anything like that.
What will happen to Brunet himself? He says that he "will happily ally with the groypers." He liked and retweeted a tweet saying "Groypers love [him] because he's one of them," and he proclaimed himself "groyper-curious." So instead of billionaires, politicians, and academics, this is apparently his new target audience. I'm not so optimistic about his future as a groyper intellectual. Brunet says he has an issue with public speaking and that he can't even do interviews. A man of letters is unlikely to have a long career in the low-IQ, podcast-centered world of the groypers, who are going to get bored with this story in a few days and move on to something else. On the other hand, there's always a market for anti-Semitism (or "anti-Zionism") no matter how the message is delivered. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
What's going on with Chris is very interesting here. He's now breaking with mainstream conservatism and denouncing the Israeli war in Gaza.
I'm going to take you all behind the curtain a little bit and explain to you how being a right-leaning intellectual works. I'll do it in a more fact-based and sober, and less melodramatic way than Chris does.
As a rightist, there are basically two audiences you can appeal to, philosemites and antisemites. The philosemites control established media institutions and think tanks. If you want a career there, you have to be pro-Israel or at least keep your mouth shut about Israel and just talk about wokeness or crime or whatever. This is the only way you'll have anything to do with the New York Post, Fox, Manhattan Institute, etc.
There are incentives pushing in the other direction though. If you want to be completely independent, there's a huge market for anti-Zionist and antisemitic content. Most of the influencers there are very dumb, so if you’re smart at all you can be a big fish in a small pond, though intelligence might actually be a hinderance when appealing to this crowd.
Israel is a great cause that everyone should support. I have little incentive to tell you this because I'm independent and no Jews have thrown money at me yet, though hopefully they might one day. The philosemites don’t like frank discussions of their power, and are paranoid about it, so they won’t be happy with what I'm writing here, but I’ve been encouraging them to be more forceful in directly confronting the Low Human Capital on the right.
All of this is to say that even if you don't care about Israel, you should want the philosemites to win since they are the Elite Human Capital faction.
The antisemitic crowd is composed of those who talk about "demons" and "Christ is King," anti-vaxxers, and conspiracy theorists. They hate surrogacy because it involves smart people being born and want to control women's bodies. Third worldists who think Dugin is the world’s greatest living intellectual, believe North Korea’s slave society has some things worth emulating, and get off sniffing the bread at the Moscow supermarket.
They don't have any institutions because they're dysfunctional people, shunned by society. They think this is because Jews oppress them, but it's mostly their own failures. That said, while you won't get hired by a Groyper think tank, you can have a huge following on social media by appealing to such people because there are a lot of them. Candace Owens is the prototype of this business model.
Chris is throwing his lot in with Low Human Capital, which is unfortunate. I mean maybe he's just a humanitarian whose heart bleeds for Gaza, but he could've chosen Myanmar or Sudan as his cause and it would've made a lot more sense, since it wouldn't involve defending a society with such ugly values.
Picking Gaza only makes sense in terms of psychology or financial interest, I won't speculate on which is at play here. Some people just become antisemitic because they're crazy, others have this kind of defiant attitude where they become bitter at the philosemitic crowd and this starts to drive their behavior.
Either way, this is the wrong path. It could get you a lot of attention and make you a lot of money, but Israel is the right cause both on its merits and in terms of what it represents in factional struggles on the right. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Daniel
@ListenToLewko
Another graduate from the TikTok School of Middle Eastern affairs. 🤡
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
The NYT has obtained the minutes of ten Hamas meetings in the run-up to the October 7 attack. They were found on a computer captured by Israeli forces under Khan Younis.
Hamas originally planned to attack in the fall of 2022, then spent the next year trying to bring Iran and Hezbollah into the fight.
The hope was that Israel would collapse.
People do not take seriously enough the facts that Israel’s enemies want it destroyed and have plausible schemes of how to get there. If Israel took the advice of Western liberals on how to fight, those plans would be more likely to come to fruition. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
If you commit serious fraud in the business world you go to jail. I don’t see why the same shouldn’t happen in science and academia
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
One of the most cited and esteemed Alzheimer's and Parkinson's researchers, Eliezer Masliah, has turned out to be a fraud.
He headed the National Institute of Aging's neuroscience division and might have set back the field by years or even decades. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Dr @AdamRutherford's powerful arguments have really made me reconsider my worldview
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
Oh how I love these IQ obsessed wienies. That’s they think this type of survey is informative, surely aware of the inherent bias in their acolytes, and that people like me answer randomly or the opposite of what I think they want to hear. Cambridge Uni’s brightest and best!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A and B are identical twins with IQ 125. Based on a coin toss, their parents send A but not B to college.
A majors in psych at Columbia. B goes straight to the workforce, reads some Substacks and a few books a year. At age 27 they both take a test of general knowledge/reasoning. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A and B are identical twins with IQ 125. Based on a coin toss, their parents send A but not B to college.
A majors in psych at Columbia. B goes straight to the workforce, reads some Substacks and a few books a year. At age 27 they both take a test of general knowledge/reasoning. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I guess 1/3
For people who think question 1 is unfair: If you've been a full-time student for 16 years, including 4 years at an elite institution of higher learning, should you be expected to know anything that you wouldn't pick up from watching movies and reading the NY Times? -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Also, so far only 2 Jews won Nobel Prizes this year. Not a single Jewish laureate in physics. cc @ADL @JGreenblattADL
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
1. In 5 sentences, what was the Peace of Westphalia and why was it important?
2. Point to France on an unlabeled map.
3. What's the probability of flipping 4 heads in a row with a fair coin?
The median score on this test of a 2023 graduate of a top-10 US university would be: -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Harvard recently got rid of mandatory DEI statements, and conservatives congratulated themselves for a big victory over wokism.
As usual, cons got played. DEI statements have been replaced with "service statements," which have the same function but with plausible deniability. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
shevereshtus
@shevereshtus
Debunking the antisemitic Talmud quotes meme promoted by @DanBilzerian and boosted by @RealCandaceO and her ilk
A thread. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
The extraordinary global focus on the "genocide" of Palestinians - a people led by terrorists, who basically keep losing wars - combined with total blind-eyeing of the ACTUAL near-extermination of Christians and Jews in the Middle East, is one of the more significant and bizarre misdirection of our time.
Dr. Maalouf
@realMaalouf
The Palestinian population has grown 400% since 1948, yet they call it a ‘genocide’.
Christians are on the verge of extinction in the Middle East, and yet no one calls it a genocide. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
"While the adoption literature as a whole suggests that both genes and family environment play a role in IQ, most studies find that genes are far more important." www.aporiamagazine.com/p/a-response-to-sasha-gusev-on-iq
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The fact that "the cure for a bad argument is a better one" isn't an argument against censorship. 90% of the time the whole point of censorship is to protect bad arguments.
There's a reason you get censored for talking about race and IQ but not for saying the earth is flat.
Rothmus 🏴
@Rothmus
🎯
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
This is an extremely polite way of putting this.
The suicide rate for "established" transgender Americans is, as I recall, 44%.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The claim that being trans makes you "happy" is far from being established, and the data suggest that the opposite may be true
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The claim that being trans makes you "happy" is far from being established, and the data suggest that the opposite may be true
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The Occidental Observer (edited by Kevin MacDonald) published an entire article about my face
Indeed, I wave my superior nose like a flag pole and proclaim, "A ---- at Cambridge" -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
On October 7—as Hamas was live-streaming the worst pogrom since the Shoah—a UPenn professor, Anne Norton, said that the violence was justified and described it as a legitimate form of self-defense.
She is not the one Penn is punishing for offensive speech.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Penn tells Amy Wax that she must refrain from “flagrantly unprofessional and targeted disparagement of any individual or group in the university community.”
So, Penn will be sanctioning the members of its chapter of Faculty for Justice in Palestine next, right? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
It is simply unbelievable. I hope that powerful @Penn alumni will make them pay dearly. I know one such alumnus...
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Amy Wax will be sanctioned by @Penn: suspended for a year at half pay, stripped of her named chair, etc. Everything but termination.
Below is the hearing board that originally found her guilty. It includes a sociologist who is director of the Center for Africana Studies (Camille Z. Charles) and an expert on "racism" (Raina Merchant).
It also includes an anti-free speech activist, Sigal Ben-Porath, who was ironically the chair of Penn's Committee on Open Expression. In her book, Free Speech on Campus, Ben-Porath wrote:
"When some members of the campus community are effectively barred from speaking, when they avoid speaking their minds for fear of humiliation or ridicule, or when they do not feel that they belong or that they are appreciated, free speech is limited just as much as it can be limited by censorship."
I guess she is putting this theory into practice, protecting speech by censoring a lone conservative who somehow makes the 99% of Penn affiliates who accept woke orthodoxy feel like they don't belong. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
I just released Part 2 of my (group) conversation with @nathancofnas.
According to Nathan, Sowell gets it wrong about race.
And he’s still waiting patiently for someone to refute his arguments.
Will this challenge to his scholarship bring Sowell out of retirement?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
No one has pointed out a single error in my analysis showing that Sowell's work on race is shot through with poor reasoning and outright false claims: ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about
In fact, responses in the past 6 weeks have raised even more serious questions about Sowell's scholarship, particularly in regard to his extraordinary claims first made in his 1974 paper, "Black Excellence—The Case of Dunbar High School."
Dunbar was an all-black high school founded in 1870 in Washington, DC. According to Sowell, it achieved miraculous results via the pull-your-pants-up-and-show-some-respect strategy favored by mainstream conservatives. (In his words, the school was "frank in telling the black community that it would have to send its children to school with respect for teachers and a willingness to submit to discipline and hard work.") He says that although "Dunbar students were not selected on the basis of I.Q. tests," the average IQ of students at the school was above the white mean, and in some years as high as 111. He repeats these claims in Black Rednecks and White Liberals (2005) and Intellectuals and Race (2013), although in the latter book he for some reason drops the claim about the students having an average IQ of 111.
Anyone familiar with intelligence research knows that such results are unprecedented. If what Sowell reports is even 50% true, it would radically alter our understanding of intelligence, heritability, race, and society.
Is it true? @TKShackelford and @EPoe187 made an intensive effort to track down the source of Sowell's Dunbar IQ data, and they came up empty handed.
I'm not insinuating that Sowell did anything untoward. But I believe we should know more about the provenance of the data before we take his claims about Dunbar at face value. If anyone has information about this—or is in contact with Sowell and can ask him for the full story—please let us know.
There are other, more minor misrepresentations. A few days ago, someone mentioned Sowell's claim in Race and Culture that Cicero thought that Britons were "stupid." (The point is supposed to be that the ranking of groups by intelligence changes radically over time, ergo we shouldn't put much stock in the current rank order.) I was already familiar with a fake Cicero quote roasting Brits, and I figured that this is what Sowell was referring to.
Sowell writes:
"Cicero warned his fellow Romans not to buy British slaves, for he found them unusually difficult to teach....Cicero warn[ed] ancient Romans not to buy British slaves because of their stupidity...."
What Cicero actually said:
"I fancy you won't expect any of them to be highly qualified in literature or music."
A completely different statement, which doesn't support the argument Sowell was making. Not the biggest issue in the world, but this kind of thing comes up again and again.
The problem is not that there are some mistakes in Sowell's 60 books, but that almost every claim I examine turns out to be minorly or majorly problematic.
A couple lessons:
First, no one should write 60 books. No matter how smart you are, it is impossible to maintain high standards given this level of output. The fact that Sowell is encouraged to publish a book every year is a systemic failure.
Second, too much praise can be harmful. Sowell's talent is undeniable, and he has done great things. But for decades he has been surrounded by people who, instead of subjecting his arguments to critical scrutiny, immediately laud him as a historic genius every time he utters a sentence. I believe Sowell is to some extent a victim in this situation. If he had been treated as an equal and forced to defend his ideas like the rest of us, he could have reached greater heights.
I invite scrutiny of my own work, and I will be grateful if the defenders of Sowell (e.g., @wil_da_beast630, @GlennLoury, @JohnHCochrane) can show that I am wrong! -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Amy Wax will be sanctioned by @Penn: suspended for a year at half pay, stripped of her named chair, etc. Everything but termination.
Below is the hearing board that originally found her guilty. It includes a sociologist who is director of the Center for Africana Studies (Camille Z. Charles) and an expert on "racism" (Raina Merchant).
It also includes an anti-free speech activist, Sigal Ben-Porath, who was ironically the chair of Penn's Committee on Open Expression. In her book, Free Speech on Campus, Ben-Porath wrote:
"When some members of the campus community are effectively barred from speaking, when they avoid speaking their minds for fear of humiliation or ridicule, or when they do not feel that they belong or that they are appreciated, free speech is limited just as much as it can be limited by censorship."
I guess she is putting this theory into practice, protecting speech by censoring a lone conservative who somehow makes the 99% of Penn affiliates who accept woke orthodoxy feel like they don't belong. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In thirty years the Daily Wire will make a film celebrating the 2020s as a time when children were allowed to choose whether they are trans
Jeremy Kauffman 🦔🌲🌕
@jeremykauffman
Might be unpopular, but Am I Racist? was disappointing.
Its best moments were letting leftists speak unfiltered, but much of it was presenting 1960s leftism as better than 2020s leftism.
A perfect example of how society slowly and only moves leftward. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
No one has pointed out a single error in my analysis showing that Sowell's work on race is shot through with poor reasoning and outright false claims: ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about
In fact, responses in the past 6 weeks have raised even more serious questions about Sowell's scholarship, particularly in regard to his extraordinary claims first made in his 1974 paper, "Black Excellence—The Case of Dunbar High School."
Dunbar was an all-black high school founded in 1870 in Washington, DC. According to Sowell, it achieved miraculous results via the pull-your-pants-up-and-show-some-respect strategy favored by mainstream conservatives. (In his words, the school was "frank in telling the black community that it would have to send its children to school with respect for teachers and a willingness to submit to discipline and hard work.") He says that although "Dunbar students were not selected on the basis of I.Q. tests," the average IQ of students at the school was above the white mean, and in some years as high as 111. He repeats these claims in Black Rednecks and White Liberals (2005) and Intellectuals and Race (2013), although in the latter book he for some reason drops the claim about the students having an average IQ of 111.
Anyone familiar with intelligence research knows that such results are unprecedented. If what Sowell reports is even 50% true, it would radically alter our understanding of intelligence, heritability, race, and society.
Is it true? @TKShackelford and @EPoe187 made an intensive effort to track down the source of Sowell's Dunbar IQ data, and they came up empty handed.
I'm not insinuating that Sowell did anything untoward. But I believe we should know more about the provenance of the data before we take his claims about Dunbar at face value. If anyone has information about this—or is in contact with Sowell and can ask him for the full story—please let us know.
There are other, more minor misrepresentations. A few days ago, someone mentioned Sowell's claim in Race and Culture that Cicero thought that Britons were "stupid." (The point is supposed to be that the ranking of groups by intelligence changes radically over time, ergo we shouldn't put much stock in the current rank order.) I was already familiar with a fake Cicero quote roasting Brits, and I figured that this is what Sowell was referring to.
Sowell writes:
"Cicero warned his fellow Romans not to buy British slaves, for he found them unusually difficult to teach....Cicero warn[ed] ancient Romans not to buy British slaves because of their stupidity...."
What Cicero actually said:
"I fancy you won't expect any of them to be highly qualified in literature or music."
A completely different statement, which doesn't support the argument Sowell was making. Not the biggest issue in the world, but this kind of thing comes up again and again.
The problem is not that there are some mistakes in Sowell's 60 books, but that almost every claim I examine turns out to be minorly or majorly problematic.
A couple lessons:
First, no one should write 60 books. No matter how smart you are, it is impossible to maintain high standards given this level of output. The fact that Sowell is encouraged to publish a book every year is a systemic failure.
Second, too much praise can be harmful. Sowell's talent is undeniable, and he has done great things. But for decades he has been surrounded by people who, instead of subjecting his arguments to critical scrutiny, immediately laud him as a historic genius every time he utters a sentence. I believe Sowell is to some extent a victim in this situation. If he had been treated as an equal and forced to defend his ideas like the rest of us, he could have reached greater heights.
I invite scrutiny of my own work, and I will be grateful if the defenders of Sowell (e.g., @wil_da_beast630, @GlennLoury, @JohnHCochrane) can show that I am wrong! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Conservatives are so desperate for any shred of approval they can get from celebrities it’s pathetic.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Letter from the administration of Wadham College at the University of Oxford in 1968 shows how universities dealt with student protesters before the feminization of academia
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“a retired conservative academic who was so old (>90) he could barely walk. He told me that ‘one of these days’ he may give up his emeritus status so he can ‘take the gloves off’ and ‘say what I really think.’”
lol, boomers on their deathbeds finally dropping truths on their nurses.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Many people advised me wait to get tenure before doing work on controversial topics. Why didn't I listen to them?
There are tens of thousands of tenured professors in America. I am not aware of a single example of someone who kept his controversial interests secret for 15 years and then revealed them after getting a promotion. (There are cases where professors developed unpopular views after getting tenure, but that's not what I'm talking about.) In practice, "wait for tenure" means "give it up," for at least two reasons.
First, there's no such thing as "pretending" to be a conformist for 15 years. (Realistically, that's how long it takes to climb the ranks to tenured professor, not including 4 years of college.) After 20,000 working hours of posing as a conformist, that's what you'll be. When you finally get the holy grail of tenure, you'll have a dozen reasons why it's still not the right time to go public with your controversial views (assuming you still have any). Last year I shared the story of a retired conservative academic who was so old (>90) he could barely walk. He told me that "one of these days" he may give up his emeritus status so he can "take the gloves off" and "say what I really think." That's the end result of waiting for tenure.
Second, you can't hide your personality for decades. If you're really a heretic, you'll let it slip at some point, and the ruse will have been for nothing.
Howard Zinn was the author of A People's History of the United States, which sold more than two million copies and played a major role in radicalizing American education. In 1967, the political science department at Boston University voted to award him tenure. However, its recommendation had to be approved by the trustees, who were scheduled to meet for the annual Founders Day banquet. Zinn then accepted some students' invitation to speak at an anti-war rally, not knowing that the purpose of the rally was to protest Secretary of State Dean Rusk...who had been invited to speak at the Founders Day banquet! But he did not pull out. On the same day the trustees were voting on his tenure case, Zinn gave a 45-minute speech railing against their honored guest, the government, and America's founders. He went home assuming he would be fired. Unbeknownst to him, the trustees had already voted to approve his tenure before the banquet.
If you try to make a rational calculation, it will almost always be impossible to justify going against the herd. But in the end, it's people like Howard Zinn who have influence. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Many people advised me wait to get tenure before doing work on controversial topics. Why didn't I listen to them?
There are tens of thousands of tenured professors in America. I am not aware of a single example of someone who kept his controversial interests secret for 15 years and then revealed them after getting a promotion. (There are cases where professors developed unpopular views after getting tenure, but that's not what I'm talking about.) In practice, "wait for tenure" means "give it up," for at least two reasons.
First, there's no such thing as "pretending" to be a conformist for 15 years. (Realistically, that's how long it takes to climb the ranks to tenured professor, not including 4 years of college.) After 20,000 working hours of posing as a conformist, that's what you'll be. When you finally get the holy grail of tenure, you'll have a dozen reasons why it's still not the right time to go public with your controversial views (assuming you still have any). Last year I shared the story of a retired conservative academic who was so old (>90) he could barely walk. He told me that "one of these days" he may give up his emeritus status so he can "take the gloves off" and "say what I really think." That's the end result of waiting for tenure.
Second, you can't hide your personality for decades. If you're really a heretic, you'll let it slip at some point, and the ruse will have been for nothing.
Howard Zinn was the author of A People's History of the United States, which sold more than two million copies and played a major role in radicalizing American education. In 1967, the political science department at Boston University voted to award him tenure. However, its recommendation had to be approved by the trustees, who were scheduled to meet for the annual Founders Day banquet. Zinn then accepted some students' invitation to speak at an anti-war rally, not knowing that the purpose of the rally was to protest Secretary of State Dean Rusk...who had been invited to speak at the Founders Day banquet! But he did not pull out. On the same day the trustees were voting on his tenure case, Zinn gave a 45-minute speech railing against their honored guest, the government, and America's founders. He went home assuming he would be fired. Unbeknownst to him, the trustees had already voted to approve his tenure before the banquet.
If you try to make a rational calculation, it will almost always be impossible to justify going against the herd. But in the end, it's people like Howard Zinn who have influence. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
My latest article describes how food deserts are an overhyped problem that largely exist in the heads of academics rather than in the real world.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I had a Ben Shapiro/Jordan Peterson phase" YT vid with 2.1M views & 118k likes
Woman goes woke bc she kept "asking these why questions [about race]...that those conservative thinkers won't think about."
We will lose until we give a real explanation for race disparities (genes) -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
STUDY: Whites who endorse diversity move away from diversity.
Anti-Trump whites move to areas that are *no less* white than pro-Trump whites.
Same result in Britain with white pro- and anti-Brexit voters.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/ssqu.13268 (see appendix A3) -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Fascism was originally a Jewish movement. There was a rumor that Mussolini was an immigrant from Poland with the real name of "Mausler." Hitler said he initially had to chase Jews away from supporting him. Essentially J were driven left by RW antisemitism. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40806-022-00352-x
-
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Fascism was originally a Jewish movement. There was a rumor that Mussolini was an immigrant from Poland with the real name of "Mausler." Hitler said he initially had to chase Jews away from supporting him. Essentially J were driven left by RW antisemitism. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40806-022-00352-x
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My talk at the Classical Liberalism Initiative at Stanford University:
"The classical liberal movement, referring to people who actually defend free speech even for people who disagree with them, that's like 100 people....It's not a political movement." www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8N-mwrQhfo -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
New Podcast dropped. Episode 40:
"Race, IQ & Sowell" with @nathancofnas on all podcast platforms.
And right here on X!
tomsowell.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My interview with the Genius of Thomas Sowell Podcast (@AlanWolan): podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/race-iq-sowell-with-nathan-…
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This conversation led me to write "Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race" ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Not enough people have imposter syndrome
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
👍
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
If only they would've called Cofnas to the stand to explain Race and IQ during the trial, the Yale admissions office would have seen the error of its ways.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is exactly what I said would happen.
We can spend the next 30 years in court racking up legal victories against wokism and it will make almost no difference. The establishment won't enforce the law.
Wokism can only be defeated by challenging the ideology of group sameness. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is exactly what I said would happen.
We can spend the next 30 years in court racking up legal victories against wokism and it will make almost no difference. The establishment won't enforce the law.
Wokism can only be defeated by challenging the ideology of group sameness.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Institutions would circumvent the new legal requirements by...looking at proxies for race in order to achieve the same outcomes. (This is presumably what universities will do in response to the Supreme Court's ruling against affirmative action.)" ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Yes, I know that this year MIT practiced less affirmative action than usual. Better laws can improve things on the margins. But this is not going to change the trajectory of our culture.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Marc Andreessen 🇺🇸
@pmarca
MIT Professor Acemoglu: "I fully support Musk's freedom of speech" BUT "Unhinged", "Problematic", "What can and should be done about it", and meanwhile here's a link to a senior American political figure in a UK newspaper demanding his arrest.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Whyvert
@whyvert
Legalizing drugs, allowing online betting, not doing well.
Paternalism recognizes reality, that many people are not intelligent enough to reason well about their own interests.
Libertarianism adopts the blank slate view that everyone is equally mentally competent.
Saagar Enjeti
@esaagar
.@CharlesFLehman: "States that legalized pot for recreational use saw double-digit increases in addiction, chronic homelessness and arrests, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City."
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
It's interesting that so many of these plagiarism stories, often quite well-reported, are broken either by the Free Beacon or by student newspapers instead of the big news brands.
freebeacon.com/campus/robin-diangelo-plagiarized-minority… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Michael Scheeringa, MD
@m_scheeringa
Great question @charlesmurray @nathancofnas . For psych trauma, answer is no. I reviewed pre-trauma prospective studies (not weak cross-sectional ones); vast majority of brain diffs pre-exist trauma. A few that found post-trauma diffs are unreplicated. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mpr.1864
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
Serious question: has there ever been a study demonstrating an environmental effect on brain structure? (Apart from events involving physical trauma)
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Researchers at Harvard Medical School found race differences in brain structure
The only possible conclusion: "These findings offer another chilling reminder of the public health impact of structural racism." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
Serious question: has there ever been a study demonstrating an environmental effect on brain structure? (Apart from events involving physical trauma)
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Researchers at Harvard Medical School found race differences in brain structure
The only possible conclusion: "These findings offer another chilling reminder of the public health impact of structural racism." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Researchers at Harvard Medical School found race differences in brain structure
The only possible conclusion: "These findings offer another chilling reminder of the public health impact of structural racism." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A man wearing a ski mask, carrying a 14-inch knife, and allegedly planning to commit a robbery was arrested
Pro-Palestine activist's description of this event: the cops are "harass[ing]" a "POC" "kid"
Emma Vigeland
@EmmaVigeland
Long Island's Nassau County banned face masks because of backlash to anti-genocide protests and general reactionary COVID garbage, and they just made their first arrest.
An 18-year-old Latino kid. Go figure. New ways to empower cops to harass POC.
apnews.com/article/mask-ban-long-island-new-york-arrest-b… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Government-funded Michigan State University wants to hire a philosopher of science
Anyone to the right of Kamala Harris need not apply -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Jewish IQ truthism recently got a boost from Simone and Malcolm Collins. Two points:
(1) If you think Jews don't have higher average IQ, what planet are you living on? Even Nazi psychologists acknowledged J intelligence.
(2) See @cremieuxrecueil's post: www.aporiamagazine.com/p/pinpointing-jewish-iq -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
The best part of this, to me, was asking why Koreans didn't become rednecks.
There is a second reason we should ask this question, and it has to do with the origins of the word "redneck".
Short🧵
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race"
Blaming "culture" for racial disparities is scientifically wrong and politically unhelpful ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
NEW: Robin DiAngelo tells her "fellow white people" that they should "always cite and give credit to the work of BIPOC people who have informed your thinking."
But she appears to have plagiarized numerous scholars—including two minorities—in her doctoral dissertation.🧵 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If a poor black kid living in a 3-room apartment with 4 siblings can win track races, Asians kids can do it, too. Chen and Zhang just need to do the work. Anyone who disagrees is a racist.
Glenn Loury
@GlennLoury
If a poor Asian kid living in a 3-room apartment with 4 siblings can ace the test, black kids can do it, too. Anybody who thinks we can't is a racist. We just need to put our heads down and do the work. @pepperdine
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Ben Shapiro knows about race and IQ, and he knows that blank slatism/race denial is "what's causing all of this"
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Virtually every thinking person on the right under the age of 45 knows about race differences. Even Ben Shapiro once publicly let it slip that he knows.
It's primarily boomer and gen x gatekeepers at National Review, American Conservative, Claremont Institute, etc. who are blocking discussion and preventing us from properly responding to smear pieces like this. The situation will change when millennials and zoomers start taking over establishment right institutions. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Spike Cohen
@RealSpikeCohen
I was wrong. Inflation really is due to corporate greed.
You can see for yourself here in this Corporate Greed Timeline. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Blaming wokism on "Critical Theory" is a road to nowhere. Only profs of grievance studies even know about this philosophy.
The average teacher, HR lady, or "in this house we believe" soccer mom just sees huge racial disparities and has no explanation other than white wickedness.
James Lindsay, anti-Communist
@ConceptualJames
Satire and mockery, yes.
Frankfurt School and Critical Theory, though, definitely yes.
Sailer is wrong. I suspect it's intentional.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Where wokism really comes from: ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
An academic is suing his college @EmmaCambridge at @Cambridge_Uni after he was kicked out for allegedly violating its DEI mandate.
Dr @nathancofnas wrote a blog post saying that under a true meritocracy, blacks would largely disappear from high-profile positions outside of sports & entertainment. www.thetimes.com/article/3cd37f59-11e0-4d3d-9353-477f2aa2… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Dr Jordan B Peterson
@jordanbpeterson
IQ research could well be the shoal upon which the ship of Western society breaks
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
ACADEMIC FREEDOM UNDER THREAT AT CAMBRIDGE! Early career Research Fellow Dr Nathan Cofnas has had his affiliation with Emmanuel College terminated over a controversial blog post he wrote about race and IQ.
donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge
Dr Cofnas is challenging this expulsion, which creates a precedent that academics in the UK are not allowed to critically examine matters concerning race.
Now he needs your help.
Click the link, join the fight — help Dr Cofnas challenge his dismissal and establish vital new legal principles in English law on the right to academic freedom under Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Thank you for your support.
You don't have to agree with what Dr Cofnas wrote to see that the fact he has suffered a detriment for expressing his views violates fundamental principles of academic freedom. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Thanks everyone for joining @nathancofnas and I to discuss Sowell’s views on “Race & IQ”. Here’s the recording:
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
JayMan
@JayMan471
The major front in the battle for the truth. Donate!
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am preparing to take legal action against @EmmaCambridge
This will be a landmark case. Goal is to establish a legal precedent that heterodoxy about race is protected in the UK just like gender criticism.
Unfortunately justice costs ££. Please donate: donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Tomorrow at Noon EST live on X Spaces with @nathancofnas.
x.com/i/spaces/1YqJDkYReDVGV/peek -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Does anyone know what Rebecca Sear is trying to say?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
From the Times of London
No journalist ever mentions the basis for this statement. In 2013, an internal study by Harvard found that, if undergrad admissions were based solely on academic qualifications, black representation would fall from 10.5% to 0.67%. Since professors are drawn from the more extreme right-hand tail of the bell curve, the percentage of black professors would be less than that, i.e., it would "approach 0%." That's why we have affirmative action—because without it there would be a politically unacceptable lack of diversity in certain positions. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Jazi Zilber
@yzilber
I've donated £100 for this important lawsuit.
academics should be free to discuss subject's intelligently.
censorship kills science and knowledge.
@timurkuran
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am preparing to take legal action against @EmmaCambridge
This will be a landmark case. Goal is to establish a legal precedent that heterodoxy about race is protected in the UK just like gender criticism.
Unfortunately justice costs ££. Please donate: donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Litvak MD
@kotyathegreat
I donated and you should also (if possible).
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am preparing to take legal action against @EmmaCambridge
This will be a landmark case. Goal is to establish a legal precedent that heterodoxy about race is protected in the UK just like gender criticism.
Unfortunately justice costs ££. Please donate: donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
6/ Yet other laws impacting academic freedom remain. These include the enhanced academic free expression under Art 10 of the ECHR and the Equality Act 2010.
This case is vital for establishing their parameters.
Please donate if you can.donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
3/ Cofnas' case was one of the examples we used in this article I wrote with @ianpacemain earlier this year.
www.timeshighereducation.com/blog/academic-freedom-should… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
2/ If Cofnas wins, it would establish vital academic freedom principles in English law, stemming from HRA and EA 2010.
Free Speech and Academic freedom protections are only truly needed for the most controversial views.
As always, Mill is unsurpassed on this topic. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
1/ Nathan Cofnas is taking legal action against the decision by Emmanuel College to terminate its association with him. @nathancofnas @SpeechUnion
I have just donated: donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge
A short thread 🧵
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
I have read a fair bit of Cofnas' work, incl the blogs from Jan/Feb and several papers.
There is much one may disagree with.
But anyone who thinks @nathancofnas does not deserve the highest possible degree of AF protections doesn't believe in academic freedom.
@AFAF_freespeech -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Has read and understands Sowell: check.
Disagrees with one of Sowell's major theses: check.
Is joining me on Saturday at Noon EST on X Spaces to hash it out: check.
@nathancofnas.
I promise you WILL be triggered...
Join us if you dare!
x.com/i/spaces/1YqJDkYReDVGV -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am preparing to take legal action against @EmmaCambridge
This will be a landmark case. Goal is to establish a legal precedent that heterodoxy about race is protected in the UK just like gender criticism.
Unfortunately justice costs ££. Please donate: donorbox.org/academic-freedom-under-threat-at-cambridge
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am profoundly grateful to @SpeechUnion, @toadmeister, @BrynHarris6, and my lawyer @jamesmurray88. Without the Free Speech Union, free speech would be officially cancelled in the UK.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Join us this Saturday for a live conversation with
@nathancofnas about “Race, IQ and Sowell.”
Nathan will tell us what Sowell gets right, but also what Sowell gets wrong.
Join us if you dare!
x.com/i/spaces/1YqJDkYReDVGV/peek -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
AI gets 100 times more attention than embryo selection, but embryo selection will probably be 100 times more consequential
@JonathanAnomaly with @ChrisWillx: www.youtube.com/watch?v=e3cXRs60xiU -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Elon Musk inspired me to hold my first LIVE X Space this coming Saturday.
I’ll be leading a CONVERSATION with @nathancofnas about “Race, IQ and Sowell”
There will be lots of audience participation, not just me and Nathan shooting the bull.
Join us if you dare! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
VDARE
@vdare
Cofnas is taking on Sowell's theory in BLACK REDNECKS AND WHITE LIBERALS that some of black dysfunction in America is caused by association with Southerners: see @Steve_Sailer 's review here vdare.com/articles/tom-sowell-s-black-redneck-theory-inge…
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race"
Blaming "culture" for racial disparities is scientifically wrong and politically unhelpful ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
JayMan
@JayMan471
Kudos to Confas for asking (and answering within the text) the @hbdchick question: “Where does the culture come from?”
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race"
Blaming "culture" for racial disparities is scientifically wrong and politically unhelpful ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Many conservatives who think it's too offensive to say there's a natural 15-point IQ gap between blacks and whites believe it is fine to tell blacks that they are lazy, violent, promiscuous, improvident, drunk, and reckless, but for cultural reasons." ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Will read.
The obvious issue with blaming genes for racial disparities, of course, is that most prominent "DV" that we look at in American social science - i.e. household income - vary by several hundred percent among sub-pupulations of the SAME racial group, and this tracks ~exactly with factors like fatherlessness and study time. Many important metrics, such as the US and Black crime rates, have increased 500-800% during our era, while no corresponding rate of population-genetic change has occurred.
But, good to see potential explanations for social patterns other than "the white man and his wicked ways" being debated.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race"
Blaming "culture" for racial disparities is scientifically wrong and politically unhelpful ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Good post. I could add quite a bit, but I think I'll just add this:
When you match each group in the U.S. to the socioeconomic status of American Jews, large gaps remain even with that causally overstated effect.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race"
Blaming "culture" for racial disparities is scientifically wrong and politically unhelpful ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
My next episode "Race, IQ & Sowell" features an interview with @nathancofnas.
That conversation inspired Professor Cofnas to write this excellent essay about what Sowell gets wrong in his landmark books "Black Rednecks and White Liberals" (2005) and "Intellectuals and Race" (2013).
Read the full article here: ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about.
And join us this coming weekend for a live conversation about this subject on X Spaces! -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Thomas Sowell's Wishful Thinking about Race"
Blaming "culture" for racial disparities is scientifically wrong and politically unhelpful ncofnas.com/p/thomas-sowells-wishful-thinking-about -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Hanging with my boy @nathancofnas. That sculpted deltoid was hard as a rock.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
I do want to joust with the juggernaut!
But what is that "sharper lance" that @nathancofnas is suggesting? Stay tuned for Episode 40 to find out! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
The riots do not show "the English" have "had enough" of mass immigration. I say this as someone with broadly restrictionist views.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The standard formulation (going back to Lewontin) says that natural selection occurs iff there is heritability, variation, and differential fitness.
This implies that intelligent design and breeding are NS! I argue we must add a "no teleology" condition: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10539-024-09954-0 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Opening remarks from my debate with Eric Kaufmann
"In a few years zoomers will start taking over our institutions, and they will vote for politicians to implement a woke fascist regime. We need a very powerful weapon to change the trajectory..." ncofnas.com/p/victory-without-a-hereditarian-revolution/ -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Matthew Archer
@TheLastFlaneur
Taxi drivers: the OG hereditarians?
A clip from Cofnas vs Kaufmann.
Out soon on @AporiaMagazine. Link in their bio.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Matthew Archer
@TheLastFlaneur
Pleasure to moderate a debate between two friends last night, @nathancofnas and @epkaufm.
We discussed whether it’s necessary for elites to be red pilled on hereditarianism in order to stop woke. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is what your own fans think of your writing
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
University of Tokyo students say it will be "great" when Japan becomes like Paris with "people with different skin colors," and that immigration "will positively disrupt the existing values and lead to more diversity, creating a more stimulating world."
Japan is on the same trajectory as the US circa 1960. 10% of Tokyo residents in their 20s are foreign born (not including non-Japanese born in Japan), and 70% of Japanese say it's good to have more foreigners.
There are several theories about why the West opened its borders: whites fell victim to Jewish mind control, liberal politicians wanted to import friendly voters, Northwest Europeans are uniquely individualistic, etc. But a key part of the story is that, unless they're indoctrinated to be nationalists, most people of all races just don't care about racial purity, and their culture means less to them than a kebab stand.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is what your own fans think of your writing
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
We may all pretend to fight in public, put on a show for the crowd, but the truth is behind the scenes we’re all working together to support our greatest ally.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Werner Zagrebbi
@zagrebbi
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Do woman cause wokism?
See the full episode with @NoahCarl90 at ncofnas.com/p/will-a-hereditarian-revolution-defeatThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Many people believe that liberal Jews with their 72% intermarriage rate are very concerned with racial purity.
What does the rabbi of Central Synagogue (major Reform congregation in NY) think? Here is her sermon on how "we Jews have always been an erev rav" (mixed multitude), and being a racially mixed erev rav is a "vision for am yisrael today."
Footnote: Exodus 12:38 says that "a mixed multitude (erev rav)" accompanied the Jews out of Egypt. The erev rav was then incorporated into the Jewish people at Mount Sinai. However, traditional Judaism does not regard this diversity as a source of strength. The erev rav and its descendants are identified as a perennial source of strife and evil who instigated the sin of the Golden Calf, among many other misdeeds up to the present day. The Vilna Gaon said that "[Israel] will not be totally purified until the erev rav has been sifted out from it."
That's not to say Judaism is particularly concerned with racial purity. Some of the most important Jews in history have been converts or descended from converts. There's a double commandment to love the stranger who becomes a Jew (based on Deut. 10:19). But the "we Jews are a mixed multitude" philosophy of Reform Judaism is American race ideology for a population uninterested in its own continuity, not Torah.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The biology deniers have set a trap, and I fear that hereditarians are going to walk right into it.
Obviously, Richard Lynn's papers shouldn't be retracted. Retraction should be reserved for cases of fraud, plagiarism, or something equivalent to mathematical error. The article in the screenshot says that Lynn "used biased practices" and "lack[ed]...critical thinking," which is true but irrelevant to the question at issue. 99% of academic papers are biased and fallacious, but no one is calling to retract them all. Activists are targeting Lynn's papers rather than (e.g.) the literature on stereotype threat for purely political reasons. That is what we should say about this case.
But many hereditarians will feel an impulse to defend Lynn's work. This is a big mistake, and exactly what Bird, Sear et al. are hoping for.
Lynn made some contributions. But the things he was best known for—particularly the national IQ database—were often profoundly flawed. In general, you can't trust what he reports unless you check it yourself. We should not be investing our credibility in making excuses for him. Nor should we give the impression that hereditarianism stands or falls on his scholarship. Ditto for Rushton and Eysenck.
The fact that some of Lynn's claims about national IQ were confirmed by subsequent work, or that his national IQs have a high correlation with other outcomes, is neither here nor there. If you gave me a map of the world, I could guess the IQ of each country, and I'm sure that my IQ scores would have a high correlation with GDP per capita, PISA scores, life expectancy, etc. But that would not be science. The point of science isn't to accidentally get something right, but to acquire justified true beliefs by going through the correct procedure.
I don't like criticizing the deceased, but this issue isn't going away, and people need to confront reality about Lynn and some other HBD heroes. We can object to politically motivated attacks on the scientific record without holding up Lynn as our torchbearer. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The quintessence of right-wing discourse:
- woman says the "n word"
- is lauded as a hero and new leader of the right
- wears a cross and says "the Jewish stranglehold on American politics" is "gay"
- gets mobbed by conservatives calling her a Jew
Lilly
@thelillygaddis
The neighbors are gonna love this
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The reported intermarriage rate among non-Orthodox Jews is 72%, and it's been at that level for two generations. Huge % of US "Jews" are 1st or 2nd degree Mischlings who identify as Jewish for oppression points (e.g., Tim Wise), fake Reform converts, or Kanye-style "Israelites."
Orthodox Jews and Americans living in Israel, who represent the future of the Jewish population, voted overwhelmingly for Trump. It'll take time for the stereotype to change, but eventually people will notice that the modal Jew is more like Stephen Miller or Ben Shapiro than Bernie Sanders.
See "Twilight of the Liberal Jew": thecritic.co.uk/twilight-of-the-liberal-jew/
Michael Tracey
@mtracey
Just 23% of American Jews plan to vote for Trump, down from 30% in 2020 -- despite Trump and the GOP making one of their main election strategies appealing to Jewish voters (and donors). The GOP Jewish vote last peaked in 1956 when Eisenhower received 40% against Adlai Stevenson
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
I'm interviewing @nathancofnas tomorrow for my podcast episode "Race, IQ & Sowell."
An essay by Nathan inspired me to tackle this difficult and somewhat explosive subject.
Do you have any questions for me to ask Nathan?
You can read his excellent essay on the subject here:
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
Type your questions in the responses below! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Diana S. Fleischman
@sentientist
The Guardian: Why does the racist idea persist that Black people have thicker skin than White people?
Meanwhile: Black people have thicker skin than White people. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
When you see something interesting, successful, and not anti-Semitic, there's often a 35+ year old Jewish academic behind it
But when you see a loudmouth anti-Semite leading his moron followers down a path to nowhere, he is (slightly) less likely to be a Jew🤔
Nicholas J. Fuentes
@NickJFuentes
I don’t know anything about @L0m3z other than that he is part of the Yarvin/Thiel network and publishes its authors in a magazine.
But there is a clear pattern of anon accounts in that network who all seem to be +35 y/o Jews in academia who never talk about Jewish influence 🤔 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This is not a victory for ideological diversity. Leftists realized that demanding loyalty oaths to wokism is bad optics and unnecessary. As the screenshot below openly admits, the point is to "strengthen DEI, by placing it on a more sustainable basis." Universities don't need DEI statements to know people's politics. They're still not going to hire Republicans.
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
The Washington Post Editorial Board calls for the end of DEI statements in faculty hiring.
It argues that the policy has led in practice to "ideological policing." That's a big deal—focusing on how the policy plays out in real life, not in some imagined best-case scenario.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Conservatives make up 2.9% of Harvard faculty, and probably 0% of assistant professors. That's not "political neutrality." They're just looking for a way to get conservative congressmen off their back.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
NEW: 70% of Faculty in the Arts and Sciences at Harvard said they support a policy of Institutional neutrality:
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Gregory Connor
@gregoryconnor11
An excellent discussion with Nathan Cofnas, hosted by two thoughtful and open-minded philosophers.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I appeared on the philosophy show Brain in a Vat. We talk about the meaning of "race," the implications of human diversity, academic freedom, etc. One of my favorite interviews. www.youtube.com/watch?v=77prDNpFiSk
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I appeared on the philosophy show Brain in a Vat. We talk about the meaning of "race," the implications of human diversity, academic freedom, etc. One of my favorite interviews. www.youtube.com/watch?v=77prDNpFiSk
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
U Toronto philosophy prof says someone with my views (which he misdescribes) should be fired because his presence "would stain the way that people think of the Cambridge of Russell, Wittgenstein, and Sidgwick."
2 out of those 3 philosophers were involved in free-speech crises when they were at Cambridge. Russell was denied a fellowship at Trinity College because he wasn't religious enough, and ultimately he was fired for being a pacifist during WWI. Sidgwick resigned his fellowship at Trinity because he couldn't accept the 39 Articles of the Church of England (the 19th-century version of DEI), though he was allowed to keep his lectureship.
Interesting how the celebrated philosophers of the past were often prepared to challenge the orthodoxy of their time, but anyone who gets in trouble today is a stain on the reputation of his university who should be driven out of the profession by philosophers who didn't bother to familiarize themselves with his arguments or evidence. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noah Carl
@NoahCarl90
In a recent article, @nathancofnas called for a hereditarian revolution. Here I explain why that won't solve the right's "stupidity problem". www.aporiamagazine.com/p/a-hereditarian-revolution-wont-s…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Many such amusing gaps: check out @ZachG932 on national media reporting on B vs W police-caused deaths.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Anti-Semitism at the United Nations:
The UN gives 239 times more attention to a civilian death if it can be blamed on Israel
The black bar shows the number of human rights documents produced by the UN from 1990-2007 for Israel vs. 5 countries on 4 different continents
The gray bar shows the civilian death toll (an objective measure of how bad the situation really is)
For the 5 non-Jewish countries, the UN produced 1 document for every 2,258 civilian deaths
For Israel, it produced 1 document for every 9.4 deaths
Source: www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110618594/html -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Anti-Semitism at the United Nations:
The UN gives 239 times more attention to a civilian death if it can be blamed on Israel
The black bar shows the number of human rights documents produced by the UN from 1990-2007 for Israel vs. 5 countries on 4 different continents
The gray bar shows the civilian death toll (an objective measure of how bad the situation really is)
For the 5 non-Jewish countries, the UN produced 1 document for every 2,258 civilian deaths
For Israel, it produced 1 document for every 9.4 deaths
Source: www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110618594/html
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Hanania has a useful post on this phenomenon: www.richardhanania.com/p/israel-must-crush-palestinian-hopes
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Today I received a formal letter from George Mason's Board of Visitors notifying me that I have been promoted to full professor.
I'm grateful for the unanimous support from my department, and for the work of my chair Dan Houser and my external reviewers that made this possible. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
.@L_Wastell in @spectator: www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-we-should-defend-nathan-c…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
On average men and women have different interests
Mike Tyson should not be allowed to box in the female division even if he becomes trans
"He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that"
Affirmative action is racist against black people
Matthew Archer
@TheLastFlaneur
Got any “dangerous ideas”, @nathancofnas?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Protester 1: "About Israel, why are we protesting here at NYU?"
Protester 2: "I wish I was more educated."
Protester 1: "I'm not either. I came from Columbia."
"I came from Columbia" doesn't have the same cachet it had back when they required SATs -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
This is good news. His firing was a disgrace.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Alan Wolan
@AlanWolan
Just went down a long and fascinating rabbit hole.
“Nipping at the wheels of the woke juggernaut is not going to derail it. Talking about Thomas Sowell, calling liberals “the real racists,” or National Review publishing its (as of now) 3,131st article about how Chuck Schumer is a hypocrite are not effective weapons. If we want to joust with the juggernaut and win, we need a sharper lance.”
@nathancofnas
Here’s the full essay, it’s super long but once I started reading, I couldn’t stop. And Sowell is discussed in a fascinating way:
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
And here’s a shorter video interview to whet your appetite for the longer essay.
Buckle up:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
The renowned behavioral geneticist Robert Plomin, of @KingsCollegeLon, is among the signatories to the letter supporting Dr. Cofnas's right to free speech, under threat at Cambridge University.
"There is nothing to investigate." -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steven Edginton
@StevenEdginton
Ferrari kept asking this academic why he says things that might distress people. Does Nick, as a journalist, really think that is an appropriate test? If journalists never made people feel distressed, we'd just write propaganda.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Full interview
Nick Ferrari: "But I ask again, how can you say that [about Harvard's admissions statistics]?"
Me: "Because I'm quoting Harvard." youtu.be/hJ3iXhVeq4s?t=255 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
This is an excellent letter in support of the academic freedom of Nathan Cofnas @nathancofnas, published today in @thetimes. It is signed by leading academics from across the world including Steven Pinker, Brian Leiter, Robert Plomin, Partha Dasgupta, and Peter Singer.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Full interview
Nick Ferrari: "But I ask again, how can you say that [about Harvard's admissions statistics]?"
Me: "Because I'm quoting Harvard." youtu.be/hJ3iXhVeq4s?t=255 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
This is great to see — a group of eminent philosophers have written to @thetimes urging Cambridge University to "call off" its investigation into research fellow Nathan Cofnas, whose research interests lie in controversial topics including race, heredity, intelligence and meritocracy.
"Freedom of speech within the law is a right that sits at the heart of the University of Cambridge," the letter says. "Given this, we do not understand why the philosophy faculty is conducting an investigation. Members of the college or university who disagree with Dr Cofnas's views could issue statements repudiating those views and explaining why they believe them to be mistaken."
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/dont-sack-cambridge-academic-f…
As the Times points out, Dr Cofnas is being supported by the FSU.
We believe Dr Cofnas was exercising his right as an academic to freely explore controversial and unpopular views, and we expect the university to have the courage to respect his academic freedom.
We've written about his case below.
freespeechunion.org/cambridge-in-free-speech-row-over-res… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
LBC
@LBC
'You can knowingly cause offence and distress because of the position you enjoy?'
@NickFerrariLBC questions the Cambridge academic who said black people would 'disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment' in a meritocracy.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I am a professor!"
In another clip she explains she "impulsively hit [the police officer] on the head."
Deep (or not so deep) down, academics who complain about "privilege" believe that they belong to a special caste, which entitles them to hit their inferiors on the head.
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Emory's Caroline Fohlin is knocked down by the police while shouting: “I’m a professor!!” Hear the disbelief in her voice. She never expected to be treated like this by her own university for protesting Israel's slaughter.
But remember, democracy is on the ballot in Nov...This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Going up to a group of angry policemen, "impulsively hit[ting]" one of them on the head, then being surprised when they arrest you might sound dumb. But the professor of economics tops it off by admitting to everything on camera.
EducatëdHillbilly™
@RobProvince
This is why we have shut the fuck up Friday kids.
Don’t do crime and admit it on camera you fucking moron.
What the fuck are you a professor of?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
If she said, "I hit him on the head for the sake of a cause I believe in," I could understand (if not sympathize) with that. What's interesting is how she is outraged to discover that the police enforce laws for professors.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
AnechoicMedia
@AnechoicMedia_
Economists see inspiring John Oliver segment on debt relief, conduct a randomized trial to forgive $169 million in medical debt, find this has no effect on quality of life or future financial distress at all.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
At least four able-bodied men—including the leader of the city—watch for 2 min 42 s while their colleague fights off a lunatic.
It's like how herd animals stand and look around awkwardly while lions eat one of their fellows. People have lost basic human instincts.
Adam B. Coleman, Proud Father & Imperfect Man
@wrong_speak
In the middle of an interview with San Jose's mayor, a random guy starts fighting the mayor's security.
California is literally a GTA server.
x.com/RedWave_Press/status/1783260203623838041/video/1 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Animals overlap in intelligence with humans. Are humans always worth more to God in virtue of their species membership? Or does God value an African grey parrot (smarter than a severely mentally disabled person) as much as a member of God's chosen species?
-
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
We have non overlapping worldviews.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Maybe God equipped some individuals to play a more important role in his plan, and they are "worth" more to him.
In any case, why should we take God's perspective?
This leaves aside the fact that there's no evidence God exists—and if it exists, we know nothing about its values.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Animals overlap in intelligence with humans. Are humans always worth more to God in virtue of their species membership? Or does God value an African grey parrot (smarter than a severely mentally disabled person) as much as a member of God's chosen species?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
We have non overlapping worldviews.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Maybe God equipped some individuals to play a more important role in his plan, and they are "worth" more to him.
In any case, why should we take God's perspective?
This leaves aside the fact that there's no evidence God exists—and if it exists, we know nothing about its values. -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Maybe God equipped some individuals to play a more important role in his plan, and they are "worth" more to him.
In any case, why should we take God's perspective?
This leaves aside the fact that there's no evidence God exists—and if it exists, we know nothing about its values. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Are Smart People Superior? A Reply to @NoahCarl90 and @charlesmurray
"Coming from a background of Christian egalitarianism, we hesitate to state the truth so nakedly..." ncofnas.com/p/are-smart-people-superior-a-reply -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Brian Leiter
@BrianLeiter
Cambridge University college (Emmanuel) dismisses philosophy Fellow because his views conflict with DEI...leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2024/04/cambridge-universi…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
Great to see Prof Brian Leiter writing about the case of @nathancofnas, whom the FSU is helping. "His views do conflict with DEI, but any college that thinks that justifies rescinding an appointment has no commitment to academic freedom".
Brian Leiter
@BrianLeiter
Cambridge University college (Emmanuel) dismisses philosophy Fellow because his views conflict with DEI...leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2024/04/cambridge-universi…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
I just joined the UK @SpeechUnion because protecting free inquiry on controversial topics, such as those that Dr. @nathancofnas is studying, is the only kind of free speech protection that matters.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
James Orr
@jtworr
The University of Oxford has around 40 Diversity Commissars on its payroll - 10x the national average - at a total annual cost of £2.04m. As far as I know the number of staff tasked with defending and promoting academic freedom is zero.
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
🔴 Oxford University’s political diversity has withered, say dons
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/04/20/oxford-university-don… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
A College at Cambridge University has cut its ties with an academic whose research interests include race, heredity and intelligence, and in its letter of termination implies that #freedomofexpression does not include freedom to challenge its EDI policies.
freespeechunion.org/cambridge-in-free-speech-row-over-res… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Weirdly when @nathancofnas said right-wingers are dumber than left-wingers, very few people cared even though there isn't much evidence for it. But when he says ethnic groups vary by IQ, there was an outcry even though there is empirical evidence for it. www.thetimes.co.uk/article/cambridge-in-free-speech-row-o…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Philippe Lemoine
@phl43
The professed rationale for terminating @nathancofnas's affiliation is even dumber than I thought it would be.
Varsity
@VarsityUK
Emmanuel College has cut ties with 'race-realist' fellow Nathan Cofnas, whose blog posts sparked outrage last term www.varsity.co.uk/news/27420
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Regarding the unbelievably dishonorable character of those on the far right, especially the JQ right:
Kevin MacDonald says he has "mixed feelings" about me being fired. (I was actually fired from my college, not the university.) He can't say that he is against it.
No mainstream academic has more strongly supported MacDonald's right to academic freedom than I have. When his paper criticizing me in Philosophia was threatened with retraction, I published an article in @Quillette defending him. As he knows, I lobbied hard (albeit unsuccessfully) behind the scenes to save his paper. I have loudly opposed all acts of censorship against him. Now he repays me by gloating about me being fired for talking about race realism.
MacDonald's low moral character shines through in everything he does, from his shoddy work to the way he has conducted himself in his debate with me. He purports to expose the secret biases of others, but his scholarship is Robin DiAngelo-style motivated reasoning. If X is evidence for his theory, not-X is evidence, too! (Note that my own race realism is said to be part of the group evolutionary strategy.) He is a self-identified "ethnic activist" who accuses anyone who points out his errors and misrepresentations of being driven by ethnocentrism. He says Jewish intellectuals have a genetically and/or culturally transmitted disposition to become "gurus," while he has created his own cult of dimwits. He is the first to resort to ad hominem attacks, while at the same time complaining that everyone else treats him unfairly.
I understand the prima facie appeal of JQism, and I'm glad that I spent time engaging with the strongest version of it. My arguments are on the record for anyone who wants to see them. But one should have no illusions about JQism being rooted primarily in honest mistakes. It is a magnet for disturbed minds and personalities who, in an alternate reality where they actually obtained power, would probably end up killing each other before they had a chance to do anything to Jews. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Exonerated barrister Jon Holbrook
@JonHolb
Stephen Pinker: “Unless there’s reason 2suspect that Cofnas engaged in scholarly misconduct, a university should not investigate its scholars for the content of their opinions.”
I back @nathancofnas.
Academic research is premised on free speech.
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/61d7ad58-4e18-4908-a632-8c0d6c… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
I have read a fair bit of Cofnas' work, incl the blogs from Jan/Feb and several papers.
There is much one may disagree with.
But anyone who thinks @nathancofnas does not deserve the highest possible degree of AF protections doesn't believe in academic freedom.
@AFAF_freespeech -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
3/ But as Chomsky said, “if you're really in favour of free speech, then you're in favour of freedom of speech for precisely for views you despise.” Read our full article here: afcomm.org.uk/2024/04/17/cambridge-race-realist-fired-for…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
At the National Conservatism conference in Brussels. The socialist mayor stationed police in front of the building and they won't let anyone inside. A BBC reporter told me it's because there are people who are "homophobic" and "against abortion." A judge will decide if the conference will be shut down.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Peter Singer
@PeterSinger
In my latest piece for @ProSyn, "Will Cambridge Support Free Speech?" I explore the situation at the University of Cambridge concerning Nathan Cofnas and his views on “race realism.” As the university faces mounting protests, its dedication to free speech is under scrutiny. What will the university’s decision mean for academic freedom at esteemed institutions around the world? www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/cambridge-nathan-cof…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
For @EmmaCambridge, freedom of expression evidently does not include the freedom to challenge the college's #dei policies, and doing so may be grounds for dismissal. @Princeton's @PeterSinger on the implications of the @nathancofnas case. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/cambridge-nathan-cof…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
"These sentences imply that at [Cambridge University's] Emmanuel College, freedom of expression does not include the freedom to challenge its DEI policies, and that challenging them may be grounds for dismissal."
--@PeterSinger at @ProSyn -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Peter Singer: www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/cambridge-nathan-cof…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Rutgers psych professor Louis Matzel: "A prominent social psychologist recently told me 'I have no idea what an intelligence test measures. They should just be banned.'"
I have no idea about X so X should be banned is a common way of thinking in academia. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289624000217 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The reply is serious
It's useful to provide arguments and evidence against Jewish conspiracies: exposing fake quotes & pseudohistory; pointing out that trends like waning nationalism are mostly side effects of wealth etc. But at a certain point you run up against mental illness.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Controlling for GDP per capita, Jewish presence has no association with attitudes toward immigration or nationalism. When people get $$$ they stop caring about blood and soil. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40806-022-00352-x
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
"By focusing on collective action problems and negative externalities, Anomaly has done a great service."
--Allen Buchanan, @DukeU
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The 2nd edition of Jonathan Anomaly's book, Creating Future People, was just published with a blurb from me!
From Amazon: www.amazon.com/Creating-Future-People-Science-Enhancement…
Or download it for free: www.taylorfrancis.com/books/oa-mono/10.4324/9781003464266… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The 2nd edition of Jonathan Anomaly's book, Creating Future People, was just published with a blurb from me!
From Amazon: www.amazon.com/Creating-Future-People-Science-Enhancement…
Or download it for free: www.taylorfrancis.com/books/oa-mono/10.4324/9781003464266… -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Russell T. Warne 🇺🇸🇨🇱
@Russwarne
I emailed the editors at The @NewYorker and explained the need for a correction of this passage.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
The New Yorker, on Jon Haidt: "He has been beset by a troubling fixation on the heritability of I.Q.—a contention widely dismissed as scientific racism"
This is completely false. The heritability of intelligence is accepted by mainstream researchers. The debate is over *race*. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Vanderbilt protester: "For 21 hours we were deprived of medical attention"
To be fair, 21 hours without medical attention is life-threatening for the average zoomerThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Misinformation about the present state of intelligence research is what upholds our entire sociopolitical system
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
2/ I don't understand how something like this gets through fact-checking. It's quite frustrating. Spreading misinformation about the present state of intelligence research doesn't help anyone.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I for one am also shocked that Muslims are not offended by a phrase that antisemites started shouting to attack Jews. Really makes you think.
Lauren Chen
@TheLaurenChen
Interesting that I have yet to see a Muslim person take offense to the whole "Christ is King" controversy.
Some are even proclaiming it themselves! -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
“Elites have created a society where it's either Yale or jail…We need a society in which the average person can achieve some conception of the good life. And we have abandoned that through our moral deregulation in the wake of the 60s.” ncofnas.com/p/race-wokism-and-academia-with-amy @nathancofnas
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Leftists *can* cling to the old value system after the empirical claims that undergirded it are refuted. But hereditarian wokism won't be a successful ideology. If you teach people race realism, there will be a moral revolution, Kathryn Paige Harden notwithstanding.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Leftists *can* cling to the old value system after the empirical claims that undergirded it are refuted. But hereditarian wokism won't be a successful ideology. If you teach people race realism, there will be a moral revolution, Kathryn Paige Harden notwithstanding.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Contra @RichardHanania ("shut up about race and IQ"), Amy Wax and I say that we can dewokify the elites by teaching them the truth about race
See the full video at ncofnas.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Strxwmxn
@strxwmxn
Here's a 5 minute clip demonstrating what a lying fraud @normfinkelstein, a self-described scholar on international law, is (with Rabbani in tow). Several times he claims to have read South Africa's "comprehensive" 84-page ICJ case ("around 4 times").
When Destiny (@TheOmniLiberal) brings up dolus specialis as a specific requirement for the Genocide Convention's definition of genocide (specific intent to destroy), both of them seem confused (Rabbani: "Sorry, I don't know that term"). Finkelstein tries to correct Destiny: "That's mens rea" and then continues to sound like a deranged lunatic instead of refuting the point or acceding to it.
Here's the thing: In South Africa's claim, dolus specialis appears 4 times. Mens rea appears 0 times.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
In Ek's excellent new @JPolEcon piece on migrants to Sweden, he reports a "significant dispersion in human capital across countries [of origin] with a 90/10 percentile ratio of 3.2."
So, which are at the 90th percentile?
The ethics review board wouldn't let him tell us.
🧵: -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
According to the Cambridge student newspaper, the 3 most notable "historical and discourse-shaping stories" since 1947:
- discovery of the structure of DNA
- £400m deal btw Cambridge and the UAE
- 1/6500 academic staff admits to holding a view that is different from the orthodoxy
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Search for "cofnas" in the student newspaper:
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve Sailer
@Steve_Sailer
Affirmative action around the world: Singapore emphasizes meritocracy in schooling and economy, but since 2017 has a quota for who gets to be president that ensures that no major race goes more than five terms without one of their own being president.
www.takimag.com/article/the-blame-game-2/ -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
This really is the best piece of writing on hereditarianism and politics in decades.
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
1/ I am a fan of UATX & HxA. They are doing valuable work. That said - and without agreeing with all of it-this critique by @nathancofnas is well worth reading. It is important to make the case for free speech but also important to actually use it to host talks on taboo topics.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Bari Weiss's University of Austin, which was founded on a commitment to the "fearless pursuit of truth," is hosting "A Conversation on the Importance of Civil Discourse & Debate in a Healthy Democracy."
This is typical UATX (and Heterodox Academy) style: They self-identify as fearless truth seekers, but are only willing to have abstract conversations about John Stuart Mill and democracy. Sure, that stuff is important. But the point of free speech is to actually talk about something controversial, not to have conversations about how it's okay to have conversations.
It's also been clear for a long time that Heterodox, Inc. is not really pro-free speech. UATX was the only organization that cancelled Richard Hanania after his old blog posts were discovered. HxA denied membership to psychologist Helmuth Nyborg because he gave a speech at American Renaissance. A group of panelists at the 2018 HxA conference agreed that Penn's persecution of Amy Wax "may be appropriate," with no pushback at all (www.nas.org/academic-questions/35/4/four-reasons-why-hete…).
Needless to say, neither UATX nor HxA has ever hosted someone to say something genuinely heterodox about the most important issue—the main thing that those of us in the trenches are getting cancelled for (i.e., race).
If you want to show that you are a fearless truth seeker who supports freedom of speech, how about giving a platform to someone to say something more challenging than "he who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that" or "men and women are not necessarily identical." There's been enough talk about why we need to talk about dangerous and heterodox ideas. It's time to talk about those ideas. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Based on internal sales data Troubled should have debuted at #4 on the @nytimes list but wasn’t listed at all. The list is pro-wrestling for intellectuals; everyone knows it’s make-believe but still fall for it. In the mean time, it’s up to all of us to support bold authors.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Bari Weiss's University of Austin, which was founded on a commitment to the "fearless pursuit of truth," is hosting "A Conversation on the Importance of Civil Discourse & Debate in a Healthy Democracy."
This is typical UATX (and Heterodox Academy) style: They self-identify as fearless truth seekers, but are only willing to have abstract conversations about John Stuart Mill and democracy. Sure, that stuff is important. But the point of free speech is to actually talk about something controversial, not to have conversations about how it's okay to have conversations.
It's also been clear for a long time that Heterodox, Inc. is not really pro-free speech. UATX was the only organization that cancelled Richard Hanania after his old blog posts were discovered. HxA denied membership to psychologist Helmuth Nyborg because he gave a speech at American Renaissance. A group of panelists at the 2018 HxA conference agreed that Penn's persecution of Amy Wax "may be appropriate," with no pushback at all (www.nas.org/academic-questions/35/4/four-reasons-why-hete…).
Needless to say, neither UATX nor HxA has ever hosted someone to say something genuinely heterodox about the most important issue—the main thing that those of us in the trenches are getting cancelled for (i.e., race).
If you want to show that you are a fearless truth seeker who supports freedom of speech, how about giving a platform to someone to say something more challenging than "he who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that" or "men and women are not necessarily identical." There's been enough talk about why we need to talk about dangerous and heterodox ideas. It's time to talk about those ideas. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
In the US, which group has the highest level of collective talent and intelligence?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Conversation with @BenjaminABoyce on evolution, Nietzsche, Christian morality, race, and the path to victory: www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDIf7lhtJkM
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
It's like I said: Cornel West told 6.2 million people that it's praiseworthy to self-immolate. No problem. But when I commented that this could be a protest tactic and wrote "disavow," I was sentenced to 12 hours in Twitter jail.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Cornel West says it's extraordinarily courageous to light yourself on fire and burn to death for the sake of leftism
I feel like only a leftist can get away with saying this
Cornel West
@CornelWest
Let us never forget the extraordinary courage and commitment of brother Aaron Bushnell who died for truth and justice! I pray for his precious loved ones! Let us rededicate ourselves to genuine solidarity with Palestinians undergoing genocidal attacks in real time!
#aaronbushnell #freepalestine -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Cornel West says it's extraordinarily courageous to light yourself on fire and burn to death for the sake of leftism
I feel like only a leftist can get away with saying this
Cornel West
@CornelWest
Let us never forget the extraordinary courage and commitment of brother Aaron Bushnell who died for truth and justice! I pray for his precious loved ones! Let us rededicate ourselves to genuine solidarity with Palestinians undergoing genocidal attacks in real time!
#aaronbushnell #freepalestine -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Many conservatives think Andrew Torba invented his own AI. The racist right is just as smart as the blue-haired libs with their fancy degrees!
In reality, Gab took some open-source models and trained them to deny the Holocaust
Will "conservative invention myths" be a new genre?
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Why doesn't the Daily Wire make a a non-woke image-generating AI that can compete with Gemini? (a rhetorical question)
As always, conservatives sit on the sidelines complaining about stuff that liberals created ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Why doesn't the Daily Wire make a a non-woke image-generating AI that can compete with Gemini? (a rhetorical question)
As always, conservatives sit on the sidelines complaining about stuff that liberals created ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I'm one of the 3 most widely read and discussed millennial philosophers in the world. I get violent threats from both the left and the right. I'm willing to risk my livelihood to say what is true. But loser conformist @Hallucigenia11 thinks that he is the brave and relevant one.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"I am a free-speech absolutist for all of the ideas that I agree with"
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Adam Perkins
@AdamPerkinsPhD
Leftists keep telling us that cancel culture is a myth. Reality tells us something different 👇
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My presentation for @pintofscience got cancelled because people have "raised concerns about your booking"
That's the scientific method: a paper is published, or a speaker is invited, and then woke activists decide if there needs to be a retraction or a disinvitation -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
My presentation for @pintofscience got cancelled because people have "raised concerns about your booking"
That's the scientific method: a paper is published, or a speaker is invited, and then woke activists decide if there needs to be a retraction or a disinvitation -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Big news from @Telegraph
Too bad we spent the last 40 years purging academia of everyone who anticipated this discovery -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Everything a smart leftist says breaks down to just Communism.
"By what right do you deserve your family home?"
At some level, you HAVE to just be ready to say: "Because rules aren't real, I feel myself better than you, I care more about myself than you, and I will kill you if you try to take from me."
But...ahem...a far nicer version of that is "In both cases, inheritance law says..."
Aimee Terese
@aimeeterese
Do you understand this is what the entire left believes and is trying to create?
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Steve Sailer
@Steve_Sailer
"Antiracist" author @AdamRutherford has chosen as his Stalingrad his assertion that race realists can't prove that Jamaicans tend to be faster sprinters than Jews:
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
Go on, do it. I dare you. Get a bigger boy to do it if you can’t do the maths.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Noam Blum
@neontaster
Capitalism is why you can buy cheap toothpaste. Crime is why you need to wait an extra 30 seconds to purchase it.
Calla
@CallaWalsh
Being forced to ask an employee to unlock a toothbrush, toothpaste, deodorant, and shampoo is actually insane, fuck capitalism
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The Telegraph journalist promised to publish my 150-word statement in full. Here's part of what he cut:
"In my Substack article I point out some scientific facts about race differences, call for a meritocracy, and approvingly cite Nietzsche's argument against white nationalism and race hatred. Yet you seem to insinuate that it would be problematic for me to interact with students, asking whether I teach undergraduates. I would be curious to know if you've asked the same question to the thousands of British academics who regularly express open hatred toward whites and Jews, or even make hostility to whites the basis of their academic careers." -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
You think Jamaicans are on average faster than Jews cos you don't know as much statistics as Adam Rutherford's pal
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
You should model it, and see what the outcome is. Is that in your skill set? The reason I ask is cos a pal of mine, a statistician did, and guess who is right?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Search results for "cofnas" in the Cambridge student newspaper
My wife thinks they should write a book about me -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Mental illness expands to fill the space in which it is tolerated
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The Cambridge student newspaper just dropped its 4th hit piece about me:
"Nathan Cofnas disclosed in a podcast interview that he was 'not able to get into a single philosophy PhD programme in the United States'"
🚨🚨🚨🚨 -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Rafael Higonnet-Faithfull
@RafFaithfull
Lol this is pathetic
Daily Nous / Justin Weinberg
@DailyNousEditor
Dear anyone who has ever gotten a Leverhulme Fellowship: Sorry. dailynous.com/2024/02/15/leverhulme-trust-to-investigate-…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Pathetic cancellation attempt by philosophy blogger Justin Weinberg (@DailyNousEditor)
Philosophers like Weinberg often talk about their superior "critical thinking skills," which are too sophisticated for non-philosophy PhDs to understand
Check out critical thinking in action: -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
This piece by @LorenzoFrom is his final response to @nathancofnas, @cremieuxrecueil, and the good folks at @AporiaMagazine.
“Neither individuals nor groups are interchangeable. It’s time we stopped pretending they are. That way madness lies.”
www.notonyourteam.co.uk/p/equalitarianism-is-morally-and-… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Usually I make fun of people who point and stutter...but that is my response to this tweet
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
That of course is a false proposition, and two unconnected statements. You cannot know if Jamaicans on average are faster than Jews cos that data is not available, and the numbers of athletes in the Olympics is statistically insignificant.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Wokism is Christian morality applied to the problem of intractable race/sex disparities
Allum Bokhari
@AllumBokhari
“Jesus Didn’t Teach Hate. He Washed Feet.”
Wokest ad at the Super Bowl so far, from… Christians.
x.com/LERMA_AGENCY/status/1756830649703371216/video/1 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was accused of promoting racism and blocked for this🤨
Seems like I can't win
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Respect for @melissasigodo. When I pointed out that she was sharing fake quotes from the Daily Mail, she deleted her tweet. She is the most honorable journalist in the UK.
I remain skeptical but open-minded to Ms Sigodo's claim that Jews are just as fast as Jamaicans. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Respect for @melissasigodo. When I pointed out that she was sharing fake quotes from the Daily Mail, she deleted her tweet. She is the most honorable journalist in the UK.
I remain skeptical but open-minded to Ms Sigodo's claim that Jews are just as fast as Jamaicans. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A "racist" is someone who thinks that Jamaicans are on average faster than Jews?
I'll bet you any amount of money you like that, in the 2024 Olympics, Jamaicans will outperform Jews. How much money are you willing to lose to prove you're not a racist? -
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A "racist" is someone who thinks that Jamaicans are on average faster than Jews?
I'll bet you any amount of money you like that, in the 2024 Olympics, Jamaicans will outperform Jews. How much money are you willing to lose to prove you're not a racist? -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
👍
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A couple days ago the Daily Mail attributed some fake quotes to me. Editor explained, "You say that the use of inverted commas automatically implies that we have quoted you. This is not the case."
Today I discovered a journalist at another outlet is writing about the fake quote.
Razib Khan 🧬 ✍️
@razibkhan
most ppl don’t know how dishonest and fake journalists r before a hit piece is written about them
but what is seen cannot be unseen
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The amount of outright fabrication in newspapers is simply beyond the imagination of most people. Only a small percentage of the population will learn the truth the hard way when they are the subject of a hit piece.
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Hey good lookin'
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
To people who find this statement outrageous--what exactly do you think the point of affirmative action is?
The Times and Sunday Times
@thetimes
A University of Cambridge academic has suggested that a meritocracy would reduce the number of black Harvard professors to almost zero ⬇️ www.thetimes.co.uk/article/meritocracy-would-mean-almost-…
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A third conservative newspaper joins the pile-on
The Times and Sunday Times
@thetimes
A University of Cambridge academic has suggested that a meritocracy would reduce the number of black Harvard professors to almost zero ⬇️ www.thetimes.co.uk/article/meritocracy-would-mean-almost-…
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Edward Dutton
@jollyheretic
🚨Good lord this is stupid!🚨
The Daily Mail and Telegraph are trying to cancel one of the few open race realists in academia, the bold @nathancofnas.
But you won't see a more embarrassing attempt.
It surpasses their first go last year.
"Conservative" papers😂This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
British journalism is frequently a sewer, and to invent quotations is a practice that does happen and should always be condemned, utterly, no matter whether it is about your friends or opponents. This is what @nathancofnas actually said:
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This Daily Mail headline attributes two fake quotes to me. I never said Harvard would "have no black professors" in a meritocracy, nor did I express that idea. DM editors agree that I never wrote these words, but they refuse to correct their outrageous lies.
Apparently UK journalists are allowed to paraphrase people using quotation marks. But they are not allowed to distort the meaning of the original quote in order to defame the subject.
I am investigating my options. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Diana S. Fleischman
@sentientist
Cofnas recounts his first conversation with @ElizabethHaighx, who is a fabulist.
"Haigh spent most of our eight-minute conversation arguing that I advocated for the “forced adoption of black children into white families”
thecritic.co.uk/my-debunked-views/
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This Daily Mail headline attributes two fake quotes to me. I never said Harvard would "have no black professors" in a meritocracy, nor did I express that idea. DM editors agree that I never wrote these words, but they refuse to correct their outrageous lies.
Apparently UK journalists are allowed to paraphrase people using quotation marks. But they are not allowed to distort the meaning of the original quote in order to defame the subject.
I am investigating my options. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
This Daily Mail headline attributes two fake quotes to me. I never said Harvard would "have no black professors" in a meritocracy, nor did I express that idea. DM editors agree that I never wrote these words, but they refuse to correct their outrageous lies.
Apparently UK journalists are allowed to paraphrase people using quotation marks. But they are not allowed to distort the meaning of the original quote in order to defame the subject.
I am investigating my options. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Britain's second big "conservative" newspaper, the semiliterate trash tabloid @MailOnline, employs she/her to write hit pieces targeting academics on the right.
Thanks a lot, conservatives.
Elizabeth Haigh (she/her)
@ElizabethHaighx
A Cambridge University fellow has sparked controversy again after claiming race equality is a 'thesis based on lies' and that there would be 'no black professors' at Harvard if appointments were based on merit.
mol.im/a/13060909 -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"Dr Bronwen Everill has been unimpressed with Cambridge University's continued employment of Nathan Cofnas"
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Not to get all Jill Bideny, but I have a PhD from Oxford. What's up with calling everyone in the article "Dr" except me?
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Britain's leading "conservative" newspaper, @Telegraph, jumps on the anti-Cofnas bandwagon
Non-paywalled version on Yahoo News: news.yahoo.com/cambridge-fellow-suggests-black-people-195… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
A sinister spin on my argument that diversity is good
Varsity
@VarsityUK
A philosophy fellow has attacked affirmative action and argued for the 'preservation of racial distinctions' in a blog post www.varsity.co.uk/news/27035
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Cambridge student newspaper publishes its third hit piece about me: www.varsity.co.uk/news/27035
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Thank God skin color isn't moralized, or we'd never stop hearing about how melanin differences are caused by racism
- There's more genetic variation within than between races, ergo there can't be skin color diffs
- Skin changes color in the sun, so it must be environmental
etc. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Race deniers have hit pay dirt: a typo in a Cofnas tweet...a tweet in which the same word is spelled without a typo later in the sentence
Sasha Gusev
@SashaGusevPosts
Before going all in on My Struggle, these clowns should probably learn the difference between "adoption" and "adaptation"
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Typos happen. In the same screenshot I refer to being "adapted to hunting and gathering" (no typo).
The fact that you're resorting to such a cheap shot suggests that you don't have much in the way of actual arguments. -
Sasha Gusev
@SashaGusevPosts
Before going all in on My Struggle, these clowns should probably learn the difference between "adoption" and "adaptation"
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Typos happen. In the same screenshot I refer to being "adapted to hunting and gathering" (no typo).
The fact that you're resorting to such a cheap shot suggests that you don't have much in the way of actual arguments. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
J.D. Haltigan, PhD 🏒👨💻
@JDHaltigan
Important piece to read with an open mind if you are seriously interested in understanding the human condition. If we can not have honest conversations about around this issue, there is no point to virtue-signaling that we aspire to a 'biopsychosocial' model in high-quality research.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"A culture of doing homework is more likely to arise in a mean IQ 105 population that is genetically adopted to the arduous demands of the rice paddy than it is in a mean IQ 85 population that is adapted to hunting and gathering on the savanna." ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The little guys on the ground are yelling about trans women in sports ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
A Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution / @nathancofnas
Cofnas makes the case for honesty on race differences, including unapologetic usage of the term.
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Great piece by Nathan Cofnas on why one must talk about the truth when talking about race.
A Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution
ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution?r=6… -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
3 reasons why Sowell's cultural theory of race differences won't defeat wokism:
- It's false, and would therefore lead to failed social policies
- Very few smart people find it convincing
- Whites will be on the hook for fixing the bad culture --> wokism ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There aren't a lot of market inefficiencies for hereditarians to take advantage of because, in practice, almost everyone behaves like a hereditarian. Tim Cook probably isn't a race realist, yet he set up Apple's factories in China rather than next to a lithium mine in the Congo.
MT
@MT_6226
My advice to hereditarians is that if they believe 1) their ideas are incontrovertibly correct and 2) the rest of the world is in denial about them, they can probably exploit some serious market inefficiencies and come out ahead. This is a better course than activism.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"A culture of doing homework is more likely to arise in a mean IQ 105 population that is genetically adopted to the arduous demands of the rice paddy than it is in a mean IQ 85 population that is adapted to hunting and gathering on the savanna." ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"A culture of doing homework is more likely to arise in a mean IQ 105 population that is genetically adopted to the arduous demands of the rice paddy than it is in a mean IQ 85 population that is adapted to hunting and gathering on the savanna." ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"The prospect of a hereditarian revolution strikes some people as inconceivable and/or even more terrifying than wokism itself."
I explain why a hereditarian revolution is both feasible and desirable: ncofnas.com/p/a-guide-for-the-hereditarian-revolution -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Candace shares her thoughts for a living. She's one of the stars of the Daily Wire (one of the most influential conservative media companies). She has 4.6M X followers and ties to many prominent conservatives. Can't say she's not a thought leader just because you don't like her.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Candace shares her thoughts for a living. She's one of the stars of the Daily Wire (one of the most influential conservative media companies). She has 4.6M X followers and ties to many prominent conservatives. Can't say she's not a thought leader just because you don't like her.
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
This piece by @LorenzoFrom is his second response to @nathancofnas, @cremieuxrecueil, and the good folks at @AporiaMagazine.
“Now, let’s put some history and social processes back in”
www.notonyourteam.co.uk/p/quibbling-with-cofnas-ii -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
As usual with conservative thought leaders, it's hard to know whether she is lying, making a mistake, or simply fails to understand the concepts of truth and falsity
Jason S. Campbell
@JasonSCampbell
Candace Owens: “I am a big believer that Hollywood was created by the CIA”
-
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Matthew Archer
@TheLastFlaneur
ConInc is a big reason we cannot have nice things!
This reaction from Douglas Murray to a young student asking a question is simultaneously understandable and utterly bizarre.
Yes, of course some nasty weirdos obsess over group differences. However, it sounds like Douglas didn't even give this young chap the time of day.
Comparing him to someone saying 'why don't you talk about the Jews?' is so cheap.
@DouglasKMurray why don't you use your Spectator platform to interview a young Jewish scholar who has written very carefully about why people such as yourself must discuss the truth if you genuinely want to overcome wokeness?
I refer you to @nathancofnas. -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
Why We Need to Talk about the Right’s Stupidity Problem / @nathancofnas
ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights
Some belated comments a month after its publication.
The good parts:
(1) Detailed and realistic appraisal of rightoid stupidity (8.5 IQ point difference between extreme libs and extreme cons amongst Whites), coupled with disinterest in even trying to remedy this state of affairs. It does not try to protect its own intellectuals, and is often even more eager to cancel them than actual libs.
(These are all concordant with what I wrote in Why Jail is Programmed for All Rightoids akarlin.com/jail-for-rightoids/, as well as The Z of History which uses Putinism as a rightoid case study: akarlin.com/the-z-of-history/).
(2) Correctly IMO identifies the mainstream right-wing refusal to denounce the racial Blank Slate thesis as the root cause of Wokeness, since "structural racism" (Wokes) is still a more plausible explanation of Black dysfunction than absent fathers or culture (mainstream cons). Hence, to the extent that smarter individuals who pick a side without thoroughly investigating the issue, aka reading Murray or Jensen along with Gould, they tend to go with the former.
There is a detailed analysis of the historical roots of Blank Slatism from Locke and JSM through to Boas, as well as in my view valid critiques of both Christopher Rufo's explanation (influence of certain left-wing intellectuals - but why did their ideas flourish as they did?) and Richard Hanania's theory (gov't mandated Wokism; but no evidence this was particularly forced on anyone, plus reiterates a point I made myself, why did Wokeness appear concurrently and across the entire West, and critically - in many cases - actually earlier than in the US?).
Cofnas advocates a frontal assault on the egalitarian thesis and dissemination of the true causes of race differences in order to undermine Wokeness.
The problematic aspects:
(3) No diss, but actual rightoids have no need for overly smart bespectacled nerds like Cofnas lecturing on them how to win and actually do good, productive things. Their "thought leaders" with their locker room bully mentality have their comfy fiefdoms and don't need some HBD nerds shaking things up and outshining them.
Again, I write about all that at length here: akarlin.com/jail-for-rightoids/ Cofnas offers no concrete prescription on what to do about the nepotistic rightoid structures that he accurately identifies, beyond what... the HBD nerds have been doing to zero effect for decades anyway.
This is accompanied by cope about how the real smarts are actually illiberal racists:
> At the very highest levels of intelligence and talent, I suspect that the political divide is not so lopsided, and may even favor the right. In my personal life, the smartest people I’ve known have been disproportionately right wing (and race realist).
(Incidentally, there's some amusing irony in that this basically echoes Cofnas' critic Imperium Press: twitter.com/powerfultakes/status/1752060866550260067 who also claims that beyond some IQ threshold you stop being a shitlib and become a based illiberal racist. Such arguments strike me as similar to arguments by Christians that while smarts lean towards atheism, the real smarts rediscover God above some very high threshold of intellectual excellence).
Yet for all that, I will allow that Cofnas is 25% correct here. However, what I think he is really describing here is Scott Alexander's Gray Tribe (Hanania's Enlightened Centrists / my Elite Human Capital). These individuals think orthogonally to mainstream political factions (e.g. they don't care to be climate hysterics nor deny AGW, but identify AGI as by far the biggest challenge). Their autistic and non-conformist focus on epistemic rigor and utility maxxing likewise makes them significantly more IQ realist, and even race realist, than conventional libs. Wokeness has a very weak epistemic culture, and above some level of IQ, it's too difficult to unironically sustain without twisting oneself into a logical pretzel like Arthur Chu.
However, rightoid culture genuinely repels many of these Gray Tribers - be it mainstream conservatism, or the JQ activists that Cofnas mentions in passing as a faction to be shunned and avoided - and so they avoid making it a major part of their identity, even though in practice in places like transhumanist conferences, or Zuzalu+/Vitalia/network states meetups hardly anyone will be perturbed by talk of bell curves or admixture studies. Even so, very few of these people would identify as substantively right-wing (the exceptions are almost all just RW-leaning libertarians or neoreactionaries), while the dominant ethos trends to some kind of libertarianism or general pro-free speech social liberalism.
At the end of the day I just don't consider this entire debate all that relevant by this point in history. Cofnas strategy is to proselytize race realism to "current left-wing elites" to convert them and thus undermine the epistemic foundations of Wokeness. I don't see how or why he would be any more successful with that in the next 30 years than IQists have been in the past 30 - what actual incentives do "left-wing elites" have to accept race realism? Becoming outcasts from their own tribe and having to seek some accomodation with the nepotistic rightoid clown show? - but best of luck regardless. I think there's a good chance we're paperclips in 30 years. That aside, personally I think the more promising bet is to focus on human intelligence enhancement, and on the newly emerging decentralized coordination technologies/cultures such as network states and DeSci that can accelerate the coming of a world that make this entire culture war moot and starve Wokes and rightoids alike of the fuel they need for their mutual sustenance (too many low IQ individuals with all the attendant implications for the maximum complexity of any possible debates).
Anatoly Karlin 🧲💯
@akarlin
The Intellectual Poverty of @RichardHanania, Karlin, @nathancofnas, and the Alt-Centre imperiumpress.substack.com/p/the-intellectual-poverty-of-… (via @KirkegaardEmil)
Response:
(1) The description of my views is critical but reasonably accurate (with caveats: it is really far too orthogonal to anything currently extant to fit under any obvious label, including classical liberalism), which I appreciate.
> His reasons ultimately cash out to a kind of homecoming. Karlin is first and foremost a transhumanist, and transhumanism is the logical and practical conclusion of classical liberalism. He spent something like a decade trying to pound the transhumanist peg into the nationalist hole, only to give up and by an elaborated modus tollens, follow his intuitive conclusions back to their political premises.
(2) The main thrust of the critique against Hanania (and myself) are some rather tendentious claims that the "Year of Fukuyama" 2022 was in fact a false dawn. The author argues that the past year has seen a re-vindication of China and Russia, and of illiberal reaction by extension.
(a) As I wrote before, China boosterism made sense several years ago - I myself was a Sino bull since starting blogging in 2008 (and correctly so, during that period). But today? Here is what you have to argue to make the case for Sinotrumph:
> Hanania has perhaps not considered that the “economically regressive” China crushes America in GDP (PPP) and steel production, and has eaten America’s lunch as world trading partner.
Steel production. Wat!? This is 2024, not 1914, nor even 1944. Steel is not going to be the limiting factor in any conceivable arena of competition between the US and China, even military. It will revolve around chips, advanced alloys, and most importantly, software and AI. In the latter, China is a minor and lagging player.
(Pro tip: If I had wanted to make some serious point about Chinese war making capacity, I would have mentioned world share of shipbuilding and drone manufacturing - things that will be actually relevant in the event of a Taiwan War - as opposed to steel, Poor People's Parity GDP, and Chinese "economic protectionism").
(b) The author cites the Western MSM to claim Russia is winning. (Irony). But in practice Russia in 2024 can't take a minor suburb of Donetsk whereas last summer it was able to take a 100k city, and in 2022 several 100k cities in Donbass, and all because the collective NATO expended a trifling ~0.2% of their collective GDP together with some obsolete Cold War hardware stocks otherwise destined for the scrapyard on stalemating Russia.
(3) The author has a protectionism-centric view of the roots of economic growth and seems to believe that if only people were to read Friedrich List and the like, they would realize its obvious superiority to free markets.
> In Karlin’s intellectual journey as a nationalist, it is curious that he never managed to read the foundational text of economic nationalism
Actually I did read it. My favorite part was the random rant on how the Dutch were actually just Germans that need to be reunited with the Reich. However, I am dubious about its main putative focus, i.e. the economics. Historically, greater economic freedoms are strongly associated with better performance, after adjustment for human capital (by far the most important factor which the author, strangely for an illiberal race realist, elides over).
(4) The author then does a long anecdotal digression on how even though smarts are liberals, the real smarts are illiberal right-wingers.
> Liberals are the cognitive elite but the cognitive super-elite is largely radical right, and we have every reason to expect that in a truly neutral cultural framework (if such a thing could exist), the radical right would utterly dominate the culture-creation space, as it has done historically.
I won't address this because I don't consider the sample to be a serious one. All I will say is that it reminds me a lot of Christians who argue that even though smarts trend towards atheism, the real smarts rediscover God beyond above some threshold of intellectual excellent. The examples are invariably cherry-picked and in many cases not even supported by the biographical evidence on closer examination.
As you go up in intelligence, you are likely to transition from conservatism and nationalism to leftism, and especially liberalism, which becomes hegemonic at the very highest ranges. This is a very consistent pattern, and is valid across all or almost all human societies. Cthulhu swims liberal. Liberalism has been winning out across millennia of history, and this process only accelerated once military power became inextricably tied to the intelligence/innovation/liberalism nexus once the Industrial Revolution got going, and it continues to accelerate today. I wrote about this here and will expound on it in some future post: akarlin.com/jail-for-rightoids/ -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Diana S. Fleischman
@sentientist
Adam Rutherford sent Bo Winegard a paper saying there was no taboo about talking about race differences in IQ after Bo had been fired for talking about race differences in IQ
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
It’s so taboo that you can’t stop talking about it. So taboo that I talk about it on an awarding winning BBC series and in a bestselling book. TABOOOOOO
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
"you think my daughters could inherit a trait but not my sons, lol"
Will spent 10 years in higher ed and has 4 degrees but no one told him about X and Y chromosomes
Will Stancil
@whstancil
"passing on my heritable love of shopping to my daughters ONLY"
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Ronald Reagan speechwriter @Peggynoonannyc's advice to Nikki Haley: "Lean into being a woman." Smear Trump as a stereotypical "blond jock" in contrast to the smart ethnic girl.
With Republicans like this, who needs Democrats? -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I just got around to reading this.
Here's my full comment. I look forward to the next parts in the series!
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
This piece by @LorenzoFrom is a response to @nathancofnas, @cremieuxrecueil, and the folks at @AporiaMagazine.
“Hereditarianism yes, race realism not so much.”
www.notonyourteam.co.uk/p/quibbling-with-cofnas-i -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Kevin DeAnna
@VDAREJamesK
As we all argue on here (probably on borrowed time), we really need to keep in mind how insanely hostile the mainstream is to free speech. This is why I am an absolutist on the issue - any precedent, no matter what you think about any particular guy, will spread like a cancer.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Not a single major bookstore in NY or San Francisco will let @robkhenderson hold a book-signing event despite the fact that he has a huge following and would easily bring in 100s of customers.
Many of these places probably have a "banned books" (i.e., gay porn for children) section to show what dangerous, countercultural rebels they are. But Rob's story of being a "Latino Asian guy raised in foster homes in Los Angeles who is later raised by two gay women and joins the U.S. Air Force and gets degrees from Yale and Cambridge" crosses the line. www.robkhenderson.com/p/book-stores-dont-want-to-host-an -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
There is a myth that Black-White differences in homicide rates in the U.S. are equalized in rural areas.
We can see it's a myth by using all of the age-adjusted homicide rate data from 1999 to 2020. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Not a single major bookstore in NY or San Francisco will let @robkhenderson hold a book-signing event despite the fact that he has a huge following and would easily bring in 100s of customers.
Many of these places probably have a "banned books" (i.e., gay porn for children) section to show what dangerous, countercultural rebels they are. But Rob's story of being a "Latino Asian guy raised in foster homes in Los Angeles who is later raised by two gay women and joins the U.S. Air Force and gets degrees from Yale and Cambridge" crosses the line. www.robkhenderson.com/p/book-stores-dont-want-to-host-an -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
This piece by @LorenzoFrom is a response to @nathancofnas, @cremieuxrecueil, and the folks at @AporiaMagazine.
“Hereditarianism yes, race realism not so much.”
www.notonyourteam.co.uk/p/quibbling-with-cofnas-i -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Academia attracts (a) people who care about truth and (b) people who are scared of the world outside school. The second type is far more numerous, and the system is designed for them.
@OmarSHaqueMDPhD: www.omarveritas.com/p/veritas-betrayed-wake-up-stand-up -
Nathan Cofnas reposted
Dr Jordan B Peterson
@jordanbpeterson
Are the faculty beginning to revolt?
This from someone with everything g to lose @Harvard:
www.omarveritas.com/p/veritas-betrayed-wake-up-stand-up -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The new anti-woke hero Bill Ackman just donated $1,000,000 to support Dean Phillips' primary challenge to Biden.
As long as anti-wokesters fail to challenge the equality thesis, they themselves will go woke (it took Ackman less than two weeks). ncofnas.com/p/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-rights
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
This is the worst part
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Kate Manne is famous for her theory of himpathy—the supposed tendency people have to sympathize with misogynistic men rather than women.
Reality is, of course, the opposite of what himpathy theory says. This is evident in Manne's description of "how misogyny works." She thinks that calling a woman fat, stupid, unattractive, or a "bad person" is misogyny. The fact that these insults are far more socially acceptable—and probably more common—when directed at men is something she doesn't notice because neither she nor anyone else cares when it happens to a man. She herself made a distinguished career out of bashing men, whereas it is unthinkable that someone could become an Ivy League philosophy professor by ranting about their hatred of women. www.thecut.com/article/kate-manne-excerpt-body-image.html -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Interview on the JQ:
"If you could identify this cultural factor [responsible for high Jewish IQ], you would get every Nobel Prize. They would cancel all the Nobel Prizes and give them all to you....You would know who made that discovery...." www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tIut3USaFM -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Being sexually promiscuous left Kate Manne feeling unhappy due to her stereotypically female needs for "comfort and safety." Surprisingly, her conclusion was that we need *more feminism*. www.thecut.com/article/kate-manne-excerpt-body-image.html
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Ashkenazi IQ is around 110-112 (sorry, J IQ truthers), but Jewish success goes far beyond what can be explained by IQ alone. It does not follow that Jewish intellectual accomplishment is an illusion or due to nepotism. This is an important point that race realists need to understand.
Jews (particularly Ashkenazim) were subject to evolutionary selection pressures—presumably the ability to succeed in white-collar professions and/or Talmudic study—that favored higher general intelligence (g). The same selection pressures would have favored non-g traits and abilities that contribute to success in business or scholarship. Some of these traits and abilities may not be measured by IQ tests.
There are obviously personality differences between Jews and non-Jews. Jews are stereotyped as being, for example, "shrewd," and we know that stereotypes generally have a basis in reality. On average, Jews are better than gentiles at capitalizing on their g. It's not a coincidence that Chris Langan (loser with IQ 200) is a gentile and Stephen Jay Gould (dazzling "genius" with IQ 125) is a Jew.
We see a similar phenomenon with East Asians. A Korean American with an IQ of 105 is way more likely to graduate from college, get a white-collar job, and make a lot of money than his non-Asian/non-Jewish IQ equal. That's not because Koreans are cheaters, but because Korean IQ 105 is different from British IQ 105. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40806-022-00352-x -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
3/4 Jewish children in New York are orthodox, and the intermarriage rate among secular Jews is >70%. Jews are increasingly marginalized from the woke left, where they are viewed as privileged white people. The era of the liberal Jew is coming to an end: thecritic.co.uk/twilight-of-the-liberal-jew/
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
The ADL—an organization that exploits the tragedies of Jewish history, fraudulently claims to represent Jews, and spreads vicious libel—is literally one of the main causes of contemporary anti-Semitism. @elonmusk if you want to fight anti-Semitism don't ban 🐸. Instead #bantheadl
-
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Sensitivity readers hired by Ian Fleming's publisher think "Bond could sense the electric tension in the room" is good writing.
Woke censorship is the revenge of the untalented. -
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Not enough people have imposter syndrome




















































































































































































































































































































































































































































