Just published early access: "Political Unfriending on Facebook: Evidence from over 180 Million Users." www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1... We track daily unfriending patterns on FB during the 2020 US presidential election to understand patterns of political homophily 1/n
Neil Malhotra
Neil Malhotra is an American political economist. He is the Edith M. Cornell Professor of Political Economy in the Graduate School of Business at Stanford University, where he is also the Louise and Claude N. Rosenbrg, Jr. Director of the Center for Social Innovation. He studies the politics of the United States, survey methodology, and voter behavior in elections, including work on retrospective voting and disaster preparedness and relief politics. More on Wikipedia
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
AI has saved me hundreds of dollars in handyman bills. Not sure if the "learn to plumb not learn to code" mantra is going to pan out. Lots of the high margin low skill handyman work might be disrupted. The tough, dirty jobs will always be there.
Lewis 🇺🇸
@ctjlewis
Plumbers “pretty clearly” will experience a noticeable decrease in demand because people will do it themselves with ChatGPT.
I have to deal with this, not a single other person is going to bother? Surely it was “pretty clear” to at least one other person that Teno doesn’t know what we hire plumbers for, or really what plumbing is. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Seth Hill
@seth_j_hill
Just published @ScienceAdvances Field experiment delivering messages to 147K Houston-area conservatives aiming to increase trust in elections. @namalhotra @ThadKousser www.science.org/doi/epdf/10.1126/sciadv.aec8703
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Um..."Coat of Many Colors" is about being poor. It's about not being able to buy new clothes, and having to wear repaired old clothing, and she ties it to the story from the Bible.
Robert P. George
@McCormickProf
Gosh. This gets Dolly Parton's message in "Coat of Many Colors" exactly wrong. Has Dr. El-Sayed bothered to listen to the song? (It's a truly great song, by the way. Not much use for politics, though.)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We should give the AAUP credit when they defend academic freedom and focus on their core mission. The AAUP has joined FIRE and the ACLU in defending threats to academic freedom in Texas.
DogeFather🚀
@_Musk6x
The @AAUP is suing Texas A&M University System over their censorship policy that prohibits faculty from discussing topics & viewpoints related to race, sexual orientation, & gender.
www.aclutx.org/app/uploads/... -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Andy Guess
@andyguess
This important paper on exposure to & effects of untrustworthy info on FB/IG from the Meta collab is finally out!
TL;DR: Very low (but concentrated) exposure; experimental reduction on platform had no impact on a range of beliefs and attitudes, including about the 2020 election
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
🚨New in Science Advances🚨
Untrustworthy sources on Facebook and Instagram in
2020: Concentrated exposure but no attitudinal effects
-Exposure very low but highly concentrated
-Reducing exposure by ~70% for months had no measurable effects *even among high-volume consumers* -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
🚨New in Science Advances🚨
Untrustworthy sources on Facebook and Instagram in
2020: Concentrated exposure but no attitudinal effects
-Exposure very low but highly concentrated
-Reducing exposure by ~70% for months had no measurable effects *even among high-volume consumers* -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Terraforming Mars, Brass Birmingham, and Catan take longer than Monopoly and people view them as really fun board game nights with friends.
Fire Justin Tucker
@MVPatty15
The length is quite literally the first criticism anyone ever brings up when someone asks “who wants to play monopoly”
Literally the first thing every single time -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The length is not why people don't like Monopoly. The main problem is that there is no skill, and there are too many moments in the game where the player does nothing. There is a reason why Catan/Carcassone/Ticket to Ride reset the board game industry in the 1990s.
Luke Winkie
@luke_winkie
I’m fascinated by the fact that nobody plays Monopoly by the printed rules in the rulebook — which allegedly make the game much faster. Talked to some Monopoly heads about it and played a round myself to see if we’ve been treating the world’s most hated board game unfairly.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Luke Winkie
@luke_winkie
I’m fascinated by the fact that nobody plays Monopoly by the printed rules in the rulebook — which allegedly make the game much faster. Talked to some Monopoly heads about it and played a round myself to see if we’ve been treating the world’s most hated board game unfairly.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
To be rich without a 4 year college degree usually involves being a small business owner. In this article, we do one of the most in-depth surveys of the political preferences of small business owner and why they lean right: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of-politi…
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
The most left wing people in America are people with post graduate degrees who are financially strapped and the most right wing are people without 4 year college degrees who are rich.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Vladimir Kogan
@vkoganpolisci
.@MichaelTHartney and I wrote about this in 2024 -- noting that "working class" based on education vs. income vs. "blue collar" occupation almost completely uncorrelated. And that UAW has as many grad student/postdoc UC members as MI auto workers.
archive.ph/KwbKq -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's true. Probably the three best movies made about 9/11 are: "United 93," "Munich," and "The Dark Knight."
Armand Domalewski
@ArmandDoma
Nolan can deny it to his grave, but Batman in The Dark Knight is clearly George W. Bush
♱ Teresa S. Bosworth ♱ 🐇🍂
@sofiartworks
what I find funny about Christopher Nolan is that he is still a very conservative guy who often makes movies with an almost fascist messaging, but because he's vaguely progressive about individual freedoms and doesn't openly hate minorities he's now denounced as Woke by the right
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Armand Domalewski
@ArmandDoma
Nolan can deny it to his grave, but Batman in The Dark Knight is clearly George W. Bush
♱ Teresa S. Bosworth ♱ 🐇🍂
@sofiartworks
what I find funny about Christopher Nolan is that he is still a very conservative guy who often makes movies with an almost fascist messaging, but because he's vaguely progressive about individual freedoms and doesn't openly hate minorities he's now denounced as Woke by the right
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
Many, many smart people at The Atlantic but the cover story hot takes they produce are insufferable:
The End of {thing that is not ending}
Is X Solely Responsible for {major social trend that does not have one cause}? -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Narrator: "The email was, in fact, not sent from "Yale University." But this demonstrates an issue with universities. People will often attribute language/study from an individual scholar/professor/etc. to say "Harvard University study" or "Princeton University said..."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I still find it baffling that Berkeley gave up its cheat code of admitting really smart, hardworking students who couldn't play the Ivy admissions game. The theme of California public institutions seems to be: Try to kill the golden geese!
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
In University of California admissions, up is down:
“Today, the more successful a public high school is at preparing its students, the lower its graduates’ chances of getting into top UC campuses like Berkeley and San Diego” -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Robb Willer
@RobbWiller
Climate change impacts are here, but public support for action remains polarized. Which climate messages move people?
In a ~13,500-person megastudy, we tested 10 of the most-cited messages. Six increased pro-environmental attitudes in the U.S.—but only by 1–4 percentage points. 🧵 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's fairly shocking (and concerning) that a former major California politician is so easily swayed by completely made up misinformation on this website.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you want to learn about how philanthropy has changed across American generations, the best work being done is by the esteemed sociologist Woody Powell: www.youtube.com/watch?v=xM-mbFexvRw
Mark R. Yzaguirre
@markyzaguirre
Stanford University, Rice University, and Vanderbilt University are named after Gilded Age captains of industry (I prefer that term over robber barons) who decided to do some good intellectual things with their wealth. Why haven’t today’s billionaires done much in that regard?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Ashish K. Jha
@ashishkjha
Yes -- somewhere in between -- but a lot of influential public health voices signed this letter and so, closer to the first end
I thought it was a terrible move and have said often that it was a turning point for a lot of reasonable Americans' trust in public health -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is really a good paper and it helps put the election admin literature in good perspective. Early papers had no causal inference, showed huge effects, placed well. New paper are often empirically awesome, show small well-identified effects, and can't get placed in top-3.
Justin Grimmer
@JustinGrimmer
How do we measure the cost of voting? In a new paper @seanjwestwood , @eitanhersh , and I document serious problems with current measurement strategies and address those problems with a new methodology to elicit citizens' perceived costs. Our elicited measures reveal a surprising fact: citizens perceive deciding who to support as more difficult than logistical steps, like registering to vote or casting a ballot in person.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We published a paper on this. Besides educational polarization and gender, part of is that being a doctor has changed from being an entrepreneurial profession to a PMC position: www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/closer-look-small-business-… Dentists (still mainly small business owners) remain Republican.
Kevin Bass
@kevinnbass
According to publicly available political contributions data:
In 2000, 60% of physicians supported Republican candidates.
In 2020, 80% of doctors supported Democrat candidates.
From 60% Republican to 80% Democrat.
What happened? -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Maya Sen
@maya_sen
One of the arguments @namalhotra Jessee and I develop in our forthcoming book on the Supreme Court & public opinion is that it’s strategic for the Court to agree to hear cases that give it an easy public opinion “win” - easy slam dunks
This has the potential to be such a case
The Associated Press
@AP
BREAKING: The Supreme Court will decide whether President Trump's birthright citizenship order violates the Constitution. apnews.com/article/supreme-court-trump-birthright-citizen…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Good thread. I think the opt-in survey panel had a very good 20 year run, but the paradigm may need to change. Much of my recent work has built custom sampling frames: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of-politi…
Sean Westwood
@seanjwestwood
What do we do about AI contamination in survey research?
Some thoughts on going forward:
1) @YouGov and @Prolific are working to ensure high quality responses. (Disclosure: I have no personal financial relationship with either firm, but have used both to collect data.) Others like @pewresearch maintain panels that are deeply vetted.
2) Panel providers with proprietary collection tools have a major advantage. YouGov, for instance, can directly monitor response patterns in ways that firms relying on third-party platforms like Qualtrics cannot.
3) Qualtrics has become a vulnerability (in my opinion). Their bot detection is weak--it flagged me (a human) as a bot while missing my actual bot. The platform also lacks the flexibility researchers need to implement custom bot-detection protocols without jumping through complex hoops. For a premium-priced product that has barely evolved in recent years, the value proposition is increasingly questionable.
4) Opaque reseller networks undermine quality. When panels simply broker the cheapest available respondents from unknown sources, how can researchers verify data integrity?
5) Consider more secure sampling methods: Student samples, custom panels built through SMS recruitment, address-based sampling, and voter file matching offer greater respondent verification.
6) We should learn from comparativists who have long accepted that rigorous data collection often requires time-intensive, face-to-face fieldwork.
7) We cannot expect early-career scholars to build careers on simple experiments using dirt-cheap convenience samples. Our standards for dissertations, hiring, and tenure must evolve to reflect the true cost of quality data collection. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If only someone could invent an "aptitude" or "assessment " test --- a scholastic one at that --- to measure basic analytical skills *before* admission.
Joshua Loftus
@joftius
If you read the report, you'd know that the problem is UCSD cannot administer the math placement test *before* admission. They don't know who is going to need remedial math. They can't make decisions based on knowledge they will get in the future
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Two weeks ago I spent election night in NYC in a room with traders betting on real elections. Normally obscure off-cycle election races saw $400M in volume. Markets swung wildly on social media rumors. Prices became “proof” that candidates won.
Today I'm publishing what I learned about how to design and govern prediction markets that make us smarter about politics—and launching my newsletter, Free Systems. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One of my core lessons in my business ethics class to MBAs is that the socially optimal level of ground insect matter in coffee pods is not 0%.
Edward A. Perin - Psychologist
@DoctorPerin
So it turns out the little allergy I started having to drinking coffee pod coffee is a cockroach allergy! Apparently the FDA allows a certain percent of ground insect matter into coffee pods and that percentage isn't zero!
Grind your own beans folks -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What are people's predictions for the San Diego County Credit Union Prize in Political Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to be awarded Tuesday?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Maria Corina Machado wins the fifth and final Nobel Prize.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
Democracy is a precondition for lasting peace. However, we live in a world where democracy is in retreat, where more and more authoritarian regimes are challenging norms and resorting to violence.
Maria Corina Machado – awarded the 2025 #nobelpeaceprize – has spent years working for the freedom of the Venezuelan people. The Venezuelan regime’s rigid hold on power and its repression of the population are not unique in the world. We see the same trends globally: rule of law abused by those in control, free media silenced, critics imprisoned, and societies pushed towards authoritarian rule and militarisation. In 2024, more elections were held than ever before, but fewer and fewer are free and fair.
#nobelprize -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sean Westwood
@seanjwestwood
We have measured support for partisan murder for the last 3 years. Following Kirk's assassination support dropped to ~*1%* from around 3% in the weeks before. True for Democrats, Republicans and even MAGA Republicans. Americans reject political violence.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sean T at RCP
@SeanTrende
Why is it so hard to say "you know, that was a really bad, illiberal idea? Biden shouldn't have done that" and leave it at that. Because people doing stuff like that is the only potential way we get out of this mess.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I think it's sort of crazy that two former hosts of "The Man Show" will go down in the history books as key figures in explaining the politics of the 2020s.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I guess when it comes to headcount you can have too many Ns.
fortune.com/2025/09/16/opendoor-chairman-keith-rabois-lay… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Can someone explain why the journalists misquoted Kirk when his actual quotation is extremely horrible as well? Sort of reminds me of the Charlottesville "fine people on both sides" misquote, even though the real quote was really bad as well. Seems to help the far right.
Matt Van Swol
@mattvanswol
I offered a Pulitzer-Prize-winning-journalist $10,000 if she could find video evidence of the exact quote she was attributing to Charlie in her post, word for word.
She couldn't find it.
This is Pulitzer Prize winning journalist... -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sean Westwood
@seanjwestwood
The American public overwhelmingly rejects political violence. The more we misrepresent that fact, the more we risk emboldening the very few who do not.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This quote from Roberts actually comes from Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1, not Shelby.
Norman Ornstein
@NormOrnstein
I remember when John Roberts talked a good game, saying the way to stop discriminating by race is to stop discriminating by race. That was his rationale for blowing up the voting rights act. Now he is unmasked fully. It was not about stopping discrimination, but enforcing racism
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Here's the history. David Swensen (Yale) was the outlier and the greatest endowment manager of all time. Everyone copied Swensen. Consulting firms sprung up by people who worked for Swensen, who then advised and joined other endowments.
Dan Rasmussen
@verdadcap
What strikes me is the group think. Why are there no outliers among the large endowments? No one who resisted the herding into privates? A huge correlated mistake by the smartest minds in the investing business
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
"America isn't easy. America is advanced citizenship. You've gotta want it bad, 'cause it's gonna put up a fight." - Andrew Shepherd, "The American President" (screenplay: Aaron Sorkin)
Lakshya Jain
@lxeagle17
Just 17% of people said everyone should be allowed to speak.
But let's ignore Putin and Netanyahu for a second. The percent who thought a white supremacist, a trans activist, an anti-gay speaker, and an anti-Israel activist should ALL be allowed to speak was just 21%. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
For the record, you need to treat all these results like "Americans think 40% of people are transgender!" with a grain of salt. This is just survey response / innumeracy where all answers are biased toward 50% (don't know): www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2413064122
G Elliott Morris
@gelliottmorris
as clear an example of the Fox News Effect as you're gonna get
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Can somebody explain to me why wokism is so fixated on the falsehood that slavery is good for economic growth? Isn't it actually a pretty awesome finding from economic history that slavery is bad for the economy?
Josh Olson
@joshuarolson
As if anyone needed a reminder that Yglesias is a world-class ignoramus.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A classic chicken/egg debate. Are men illiterate because no one writes book for them, or does no one write books for them because they are illiterate? Crazy that there used to be books written explicitly for men both low art (Clancy, Chrichton) and high art (Pynchon, Ellis).
A-100 gecs
@PinstripeBungle
the pearl-clutching about no young white men being published in The New Yorker is so funny like men, writ large, are basically a sub-literate population in the US. men do not read literary fiction. if you have even a passing interaction with publishing you realize this.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Broke: Baker v. Carr Bespoke: We need to move beyond Baker v. Carr
Jake M. Grumbach
@JakeMGrumbach
Single member districts are such a bad system. Maybe they were good when all politics was local (like a decade in the late 18th century), but just totally the wrong institutional design for a modern democracy
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What academic/media/PMC members of the left often don't realize is that tech center-left has immense respect for Elon Musk. I think this is an opportunity to rebuild the Obama coalition. www.nytimes.com/2022/11/13/opinion/democrats-are-blowing-…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Olivier Bergeron-Boutin
@obboutin
Really excited to share that I'll be joining UC Berkeley in the fall to begin my PhD in political science! Looking forward to this move across the Bay and the start of a new chapter.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In case people are salivating over the idiotic tariff formula for research papers, @JakeJares and I took advantage of another simplistic formula for the 2018 farm bailout: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
College admissions generally have a bias that they can take people with mediocre skills but strong personal qualities and help them, but can't improve those with mediocre pers. qualities but excellent skills. Both types of improvement are unlikely, but this asymmetry is a bias.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
Oh hey, finally some good news about scientific publishing! The file-drawer problem in the social sciences seems to be decreasing over time
(in the figure, "Persevered" are those whose proposals were rejected by TESS)
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2426937122 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We are hiring a pre-doc at Stanford to work on (among other things) a project called Public Pulse, which will provide reports on public opinion in the US, and potentially fill the void of things like 538. Please share with your undergrads. iriss.stanford.edu/predoc/2025-26-projects
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
FIRE
@TheFIREorg
Donald Trump’s nominee to lead the National Institutes of Health, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, suggested using FIRE’s College Free Speech Rankings to assess grant money applicants. While it’s gratifying to know Dr. Bhattacharya finds CFSR valuable, they should not be used for this. 👇
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Zelensky/Trump blow-up reflects the core moral question behind the "America First" debate: Do you think that immigration/foreign aid/etc. is a favor or a moral duty? This unanswerable question colors the way people view everything.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My experience has been that STEM students are actually also the best at reading and writing. One of the biggest psychological fallacies people have is that skills are negatively correlated. In fact, they are positively correlated (e.g., better researchers are better teachers).
Randal Hendrickson
@RandalHendrick9
We prioritized STEM, and now people can't read and won't read. Did we get something cool in exchange for mass illiteracy?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
After 2016, people were most concerned with racial polarization since we have seen numerous countries where ethnic cleavages have undermined democracy. We have depolarized racially. But ten years ago, the pernicious effects of educational polarization were underestimated.
Matt Blackwell
@matt_blackwell
Educational polarization really undermines the grand bargain of industry-academia-government
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Good luck to the Fed chair in 2050 who wants to raise rates aggressively when the federal government spends 8% of GDP on interest.
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
This chart from @Brian_Riedl really makes it clear that unless there is major fiscal reform, fiscal dominance is inevitable. Source: manhattan.institute/article/2024-chart-book-examines-spen…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I wrote this paper a few years ago on how direct flight availability affects Congressional careers. Potentially relevant today in that Congress has a authority over DCA airport, and it's fairly well known they push for lots of flights in and out of it. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/lsq.12339
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Another @aletheia_tweets paper in the APSR. This project is on haitus right now, but has a lot of potential, so if anyone is interested in taking it over let me know.
Yiqing Xu
@xuyiqing
1/ Our meta-analysis of 49 top political science publications using two-way fixed effects (TWFE) models w/ panel data is conditionally accepted at American Political Science Review. [arxiv.org/pdf/2309.15983] w/ @itsalbertchiu @liuziyi233 @Lan1Xingchen 🧵
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Skip Lupia's famous paper on information and voting is actually about Proposition 103 in CA. In 1988, voters were asked to decide on a series of extremely complicated insurance reform mechanisms brought on the ballot by interest groups. www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
California taxpayers are now on the hook for a large share of losses from the fires in LA because private insurers were not allowed to accurately reprice insurance in light of changing risks. 👇
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Vivek tweet flopped because it fundamentally misunderstood American culture. The US values neither slackers nor nerds. The heroic archetype was Ferris Bueller: intelligent, entrepreneurial, rebellious, hard working, confident, carpe diem. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
All of the other characters mentioned (Zak Morris, The Fresh Prince) are really just ripoffs of the Ferris character. Ferris is not lazy, but his hard work and intelligence are channeled to being disruptive. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I watched the movie again recently and it surprised me that the real hero/center of the film is Cameron Frye, the nerd who is best friends with the cool kid. The point of the film is Ferris teaching Cameron to enjoy a full, confident life while succeeding. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Biden is credited with being a great president because of the IRA, but its impact has been limited by NIMBYism. The next successful Dem presidential candidate must embrace "abundance"---not only passing laws, but deregulating to implement them.
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
Doesn't seem great.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In case people are interested, we wrote the first study of preferences for H1-B visas in 2012. Tech workers are uniquely against H1-B visas over economic threat, but not broadly racist. Broad cultural concerns are actually there among non-tech workers: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ajps.12012
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I think this explains a lot of the twitter discourse. You see two kinds of posts: (1) people from tech who raise economic concerns about the structure of H1-Bs; and (2) people not from tech (or pretending to be in tech) who are just extremely racist
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If college education is actually causally predictive of voting Democratic, then the Covid culture of "school is optional" and the FAFSA f.up are going to be viewed as "own goals" for Democrats.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
It remains underreported how significant Dept of Ed resources got reallocated from FAFSA implementation to student loan foregiveness, with the result being a material decline in low-income college enrollment this year.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I don't think people understand how insane this is. This is the neighborhood where kids have SAT books piled up while helping at their parent's dry cleaning store or delivery restaurant.
Siddharth Khurana
@SidKhurana3607
Big swing in this 89% Asian (mostly Chinese) precinct in Flushing, Queens:
2016: D+41
2020: D+21
2024: R+8 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's a very strange feeling to be living in the middle of a political realignment.
Siddharth Khurana
@SidKhurana3607
Grosse Pointe Farms, Michigan (90% white Detroit suburb):
2012: R+29
2016: R+13
2020: R+0.1
2024: D+0.5 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I recently asked this question on a survey. Do you consider the following person to be working class: "Has a graduate degree but is in the bottom 25% of the income distribution." 51% of Democrats agreed and 38% of Republicans agreed.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
I am honored and humbled by President @realDonaldTrump's nomination of me to be the next @NIH director. We will reform American scientific institutions so that they are worthy of trust again and will deploy the fruits of excellent science to make America healthy again!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
#1. Filing a police report for a property claim is basically useless. #2 Filing an insurance claim (which requires a police report) will make you show up on the CLUE report, raises your premiums, and makes you uninsurable.
Caitlin Flanagan
@CaitlinPacific
In your opinion what accounts for the divergence between the statistical evidence that crime is down, and the huge # of people reporting that their lived experience tells them that it’s gotten a lot worse in their own neighborhoods?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I find it kind of amusing that these sorts of comments used to be "DC + Puerto Rico statehood" and now after 2024, it's just "DC statehood."
Bring Back The Sax Solo
@eardoc71
DC statehood
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Twenty years after he defeated Senate Minority Leader Tom Daschle, John Thune becomes Senate Majority Leader. When I started as a political scientist, Democrats had a hold on all four Dakota Senate seats.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
In every election from 1952-2004, what voters said they liked most about the Democrats (in open-ended ?s) was it was the party of the working class. Also in every election, what voters said they liked least about the Republicans was that they were the party of the upper class.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is a method that Wolfers and Rothschild (@JustinWolfers) had touched on over a decade ago. The Polymarket Trump whale was roundly mocked as a clown, but he ended up using social science principles about learning from local estimates.
Matt Bateman
@mbateman
The French Polymarket whale commissioned polls with a specific alternate methodology, the “neighbor method”
1. What a baller
2. What a killer example of how betting markets can surface contrarian, high quality signals -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
My big-picture explanation for Trump’s crushing victory is this:
This wasn’t the 1st post-pandemic election. It was the 2nd COVID presidential election.
You can’t explain Trump’s across-the-board romp without seeing the ways—obvious and subtle—that the pandemic haunted 2024 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jon Cooper 🇺🇸
@joncoopertweets
The Trump-Vance campaign is collapsing before our very eyes, and it’s a beautiful thing to see.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sarah Longwell
@SarahLongwell25
This should be a campaign-ending debate for Trump.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Polling USA
@USA_Polling
The mouth breathers are going to be very confused when Democrats are showing up on election day to vote because there's no active pandemic going on
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
🇺🇦BostonBrian🇺🇸🦅
@BostonBrian23
Guys, he’s gone.. it’s over.. call it a day.. that’s a wrap.. bon voyage.. sayonara.. that’s the ball game..
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Harry Sisson
@harryjsisson
Wow. This is the line for Kamala Harris’s rally in Las Vegas *4 hours* before it’s supposed to start. The momentum surrounding the Harris campaign is real and Trump should be terrified!
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Heath Mayo
@HeathMayo
I think folks are discounting the possibility that Dems have the enthusiasm edge over Republicans and win all of PA, GA, AZ, NV, MI, WI, and NC. That would be devastatingly embarrassing for Trumpism and a clear message that it has no winning future in presidential politics.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Anthony Scaramucci
@Scaramucci
VP Harris will win the Blue Wall (MI, PA, WI) and NV. You can book mark this.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Adam Carlson
@admcrlsn
If Trump loses this election, I will look back fondly on this as the moment that sealed his fate
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Anthony Scaramucci
@Scaramucci
Trump will lose PA. The Harris registrations are growing exponentially.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Peter K. Enns
@pete_enns
My 2024 election forecast published in @ps_polisci @CUP_PoliSci with @JuliusLagodny, @jcolner99, and Anusha Kumar correctly forecasted 45/45 called states 100 days before the election using @verasight_data: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/ps-political-science-and-….
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In 2022, I wrote this article warning the Democratic Party that alienating tech could be problematic. I was thoroughly roasted by many readers. www.nytimes.com/2022/11/13/opinion/democrats-are-blowing-… The Democratic Party needs to reclaim itself as the party of innovation, discovery, and (space) exploration.
Alex Roy
@AlexRoy144
Biden’s failure to invite @elonmusk to the 2021 White House Electric Vehicle Summit was one of the dumbest - and most consequential - unforced errors of the 21st century.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Rick Wilson
@TheRickWilson
You know Trump is losing because Jared, Ivanka, and Melania are nowhere to be seen. If he was really ahead, they’d be all over the Campaign like jackals on a two day old gazelle corpse.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
BeshearStan
@BeshearStan
The real truth nuke is that Kamala is running away with this, but right wing polls are flooding the zone like 2022
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Tristan Snell
@TristanSnell
This election is now over, folks.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
For the last two weeks I've been bookmarking dozens of tweets opining (with zero uncertainty) that Harris would win, based on polls/early vote/rallies/etc. The social world is an extremely complicated place that is difficult to predict/understand.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Interesting to revisit this.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
How will Joe Biden's one-term presidency best be remembered?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
How will Joe Biden's one-term presidency best be remembered?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Harris is listed on the top of the majority of the seven battleground states (because of strong Democratic performance in the 2018 and 2022 gubernatorial races). Ballot order effects are usually between 1-2 pp. www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/presidentia…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is one of the most courageous things I've seen someone do in a while. She did not "p-hack/herd" and staked her reputation on this. If Trump wins Iowa by 5 or something, I hope she is not punished in any way.
umichvoter
@umichvoter
IOWA POLL by Des Moines/Selzer
🔵 Kamala Harris 47%
🔴 Donald Trump 44% -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Free final exam question...
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
They did it again. Interesting they did not engage at all with Floyd Zhang's research: www.nature.com/articles/s41562-023-01537-5 Whereas many non-profit universities are moving to institutional neutrality, for-profit publishers like Nature are not.
nature
@Nature
The risks of a second Trump presidency continue to mount go.nature.com/3UmEwiX
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is a fallacy in interpreting that data. This is more akin to the Fenno Paradox. People like/trust their doctor/Congressman, but not medicine/Congress in general. Nonetheless, this is still a major problem as medicine used to be one of the most trusted institutions.
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
31% of people trust their doctor
Pathetic -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is fantastic transparency, showing unweighted results and how they change based on reasonable weighting criteria.
Joshua Clinton
@joshclinton
Do you want to see how much the margin in a pre-election poll can vary based on "reasonable" decisions by a pollster? Check this out: disq.us/t/4rd8rfy
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
People make fun of Rabois, but I actually think most humans suffer from the Keith Rabois fallacy. It's why strengthening critical thinking via logic/math/stats should be done in HS/college, and why these fields should be considered "liberals arts."
Stuart Stevens
@stuartpstevens
Polls have sample sizes of hundreds or a couple of thousand. Early voting has sample size of millions. It’s not theoretical or speculative.
All polling is based on modeling from past elections. There has never been a gender gap like this in turnout. If Harris wins by a surprising number, this will be why pollsters didn’t see it coming. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It seems like campaigns may be mattering; in the places where people are seeing no ads/campaign Trump seems to be doing better. I could definitely see him doing well in popular vote and poorly in electoral vote as a result.
politicalwire.com/2024/10/26/harris-running-behind-biden-… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I think one reason why Rogan is the most successful interviewer in modern American politics is because he's like the modern-day Larry King: a dumb guy who asks simple questions but is perceived to be an honest broker by non-political people.
Justin Grimmer
@JustinGrimmer
But @joerogan does continue to show why he is the best interviewer in the business. Gives guests room to speak and lets them make their own best case. If the guest fails, it is because they don't have a good argument.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
CA voters are generally clueless about ballot propositions.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dan Hopkins
@dhopkins1776
I learned a lot from this article & think it pairs well with my 2023 book "Stable Condition."
* It shows that major differences in compensation across crops produce only modest impacts on turnout, contributions.
* Echoes what I find for the ACA for a GOP-enacted policy.
Jake Jares
@JakeJares
Thrilled my paper with @namalhotra is out at @apsrjournal! Have you always been captivated by the impacts of trade policy on political behavior, applications of causal machine learning, and shocks to soybean prices? Ok well regardless this is still the paper for you! A thread 🧵
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is insane. I think there are a lot of reasonable people who want a sober assessment of how/why the public health establishment failed during covid, so we don't repeat the same mistakes. 1/2
IDSA
@IDSAInfo
Congratulations to @RWalensky, the recipient of IDSA’s 2024 Anthony Fauci Courage in Leadership Award.
By asking hard questions, and speaking scientific truth with integrity and perseverance, Dr. Walensky inspires not only her colleagues but rising generations considering careers in infectious diseases and public health.
Learn more: www.idsociety.org/news--publications-new/articles/2024/id… #idweek2024
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Public health and medicine are at dangerously low levels of trust among the public, and the response by public health establishment is give each other awards. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
While there are a lot of garbage takes on early voting, there are several excellent people commenting on it (not just one). One example is @mieuque from NBC Decision Desk. This is a dense article but worth reading: www.nbcnews.com/politics/2024-election/weeks-early-voting…
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Here is the comprehensive list of people who add more signal than noise from analysis of early voting data:
@RalstonReports
That is all. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I remember in 2022 people discussing how buying Twitter would bankrupt Elon Musk. It's funny how people in 2022 were gleefully talking about Musk being forced to buy Twitter, and now in 2024 so scared that he controls such a major information platform.
G Elliott Morris
@gelliottmorris
$220m is just 1/1,000th of Musk's estimated net worth. As a point of comparison this is like if the median person sent Trump 100 bucks. Musk has a lot left to give
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
For more on the decline of "deliverism"/"clientelism" in a polarized era, see this paper we recently published on how the Trump farm bailout didn't save Republicans in 2018: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
Jake M. Grumbach
@JakeMGrumbach
The Teamsters thing is another hit to 'deliverism,' the idea that if you deliver economic goods to people through policy, you'll get their vote.
The ARP literally bailed out 350k Teamsters pensions. But today's politics is the culture war.
democracyjournal.org/arguments/the-death-of-deliverism/ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In his dissertation, my graduate student showed that political endorsements by scientific publications: (1) don't convince anyone about politics; (2) make people less likely to believe scientists when it comes to vaccines, health advisories, etc. www.nature.com/articles/s41562-023-01537-5
Dr Adam Rutherford
@AdamRutherford
Scientific American endorse Harris. Which is good and obviously a pro-evidenced based and scientific stance.
Cue: all the data bros going eeeuuuhh science isn’t political and meeeeeh science shouldn’t take sides waaaah. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
To be honest, if you're doing things right, your department's Manski bounds on this should be fairly uninformative.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Suppose Kamala Harris increases her lead by 2-3 points in the post-debate polls. What is the best explanation for why? Partisan non-response (Rivers et al) or preference change among marginal voters?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What's the best way to get from Newark Airport to midtown Manhattan?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is an important point. NYT is one of the few pollsters that makes sure not to weight on things that are potentially "post-treatment."
Nate Cohn
@Nate_Cohn
We're the only national pollster, afaik, that's a) *not* weighting on either recalled vote or party identification (which historically is very dangerous!) *and* b) weighting on party registration/a fixed measure of partisanship
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Harris
@mattysmoof
Grimmer: it's impossible to assess the accuracy of election forecasting models given the limited number of elections
Silver: let's bet on this one election
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Unfortunately this offer doesn't apply now because the forecast is so close to 50/50, but always happy to bet for real $$$ against boring academics who can't model for shit and say stuff like that election forecasting is impossible.
www.politico.com/news/magazine/2024/09/03/election-foreca… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The political economy group at the Stanford GSB is hiring this year: www.gsb.stanford.edu/jobs/faculty-recruiting/political-ec… We recruit on both the poli sci and econ markets, and encourage folks with training in either discipline to apply.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Which of the following two people better fits the description of "working class"?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I don't learn anything from the donut or ice cream shop visits. What I really want to see is politicians frustratingly asking a teenage Home Depot employee where the tap and die sets are or attempt to return a modem to 1990s-era Fry's Electronics.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's really a mind bug how people conflate states and people, and underestimate variance. 1 out of every 3 Californians voted for Trump, and these are the people according to migration data most likely seeding TX, NV, ID, AZ, etc.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
People don't believe data (whether it's election data or economic data or climate data) if they don't trust the institutions who produce the data. No one "knows" or "verifies" any data; it's all *mediated* through institutions that depend on social trust.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Interesting. I better search and click for Maureen Dowd and...oh wait. Anyways, I also learned that Fluxx is a great piece of grants management software and I should consider Fisher Investments for my retirement needs.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There's a lot of truth to this double standard. Plus, many of Kamala's silly policies will never get through pivots in American institutions whereas Trump can unilaterally do things like implement tariffs.
Paul Graham
@paulg
One disadvantage Kamala has relative to Trump is that we take her seriously. So when she suggests dumb policies like focusing on grocery prices, everyone criticizes her, whereas when Trump suggests much dumber things, we just ignore him.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Good thread. A question we should debate in a small-l liberal society is: "Is inequality of outcome at a group level a necessary and sufficient condition for establishing inequality of opportunity?" Disagreeing with someone on this hard ? doesn't make them a communist or racist.
Jason Abaluck
@Jabaluck
At any rate, when Kamala Harris says, "equitable treatment means we all end up in the same place", does she mean:
a) Confiscate private property and have state ownership of all industries
b) Fair rather than formal equality of opportunity
c) Luck egalitarianism -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The problem is that the GOP is synonymous with Trump. If Trump dropped out, they would not be able to coordinate effectively on a replacement. Unlike with Dems, it would be ceding the election.
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
This is the kind of performance from Trump that, if the Republican party was still a functioning institution, would have a lot of people panicked and wondering about how to get him to drop out.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
NEW w @j_kalla at @mattyglesias' "Slow Boring":
What's better than calling Trump weird? Convincing voters Harris is normal
In survey testing 76 messages w >100k people, we find:
- anti-Trump messages doesn't work
- pro-Harris messages do, especially "typical" Dem messages 🧵 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
In my work with @namalhotra we find tech entrepreneurs agree with this point of view which @mattyglesias defines as neoliberalism: let the market work and redistribute after doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12408
Leah Libresco Sargeant
@LeahLibresco
Interesting definition of neoliberalism from @mattyglesias:
"Taxes & the safety net are the primary means of addressing the distribution of income & that regulatory policy should be geared towards growth, rather than bank shot efforts at redistribution"
www.slowboring.com/p/neoliberalism-and-its-enemies-part -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Great summary by @JakeJares of our paper on the effect of Trump's agricultural bailout on the '18 midterms . We cast doubt on the canonical view that in a modern polarized electorate, distributive payments can easily buy turnout, even when voters appreciate the program. 1/2
Jake Jares
@JakeJares
Thrilled my paper with @namalhotra is out at @apsrjournal! Have you always been captivated by the impacts of trade policy on political behavior, applications of causal machine learning, and shocks to soybean prices? Ok well regardless this is still the paper for you! A thread 🧵
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
@JakeJares is a rising star in the fields of political economy, public policy, and the politics of agriculture and rural America. He is starting at TAMU soon; look out for his work! 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
Next paper from our cash transfer experiment is available today! 👇
AlexBartik
@AlexBartik
How do households change their consumption and household balance sheets in response to large, but time-limited, unconditional cash transfers? We study an experiment that provided $1000 a month for 3 years to 1000 young, low-income households. 1/
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Mandalorian : I was not born on Mandalore.
Greef Karga : But you're a Mandalorian.
Cara Dune : Mandalorian isn't a race.
The Mandalorian : It's a Creed.
Josh Merfeld
@Josh_Merfeld
I know this is a joke but this is the U.S.’s biggest strength. It’s one of a few countries where, no matter where you’re from or what you look like, you can become “one of them.”
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There's such an easy playbook to respond to this stuff: you own it and embrace it. In 2016, the Trump campaign printed shirts of "Deplorable Me" and "Les Deplorables." In 2022, the Democrats printed shirts of "Dark Brandon."
Jon Cooper 🇺🇸
@joncoopertweets
It’s really weird that Trump doesn’t realize the more he complains about Democrats attacking the Trump-Vance ticket as "weird,” the more Democrats will attack them as weird.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
American Political Science Review
@apsrjournal
Just published on APSR First View: “Policy Impact and Voter Mobilization: Evidence from Farmers’ Trade War Experiences”, by Jake Alton Jares and Neil Malhotra. www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Cambridge University Press - Politics
@CUP_PoliSci
#firstview from @apsrjournal -
Policy Impact and Voter Mobilization: Evidence from Farmers’ Trade War Experiences - cup.org/4d8mYOK
- JAKE ALTON JARES (@Stanford) & @namalhotra -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
These statistics are not meaningful without considering the challengers. In 2022, Walz beat an extremely qualified moderate Republican. In 2022, Shapiro beat a terrible, extremist candidate.
(((Harry Enten)))
@ForecasterEnten
Mark Kelly wouldn't be a bad VP pick, but, from an electoral perspective, Josh Shapiro is clearly the best. He greatly outperformed the baseline in PA in 2022 & now has a 61% favorable rating.
IMPT: the chance PA determines the presidential winner is higher than any other stateThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Shor
@davidshor
If you actually calculate it out the over-representation of states like WY is cancelled out by coastal states getting more weight from their non-citizen population.
There is literally no pro-rural bias to the electoral college! -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My favorite Alan Lichtman story is when he chose Al Gore in 2000, he said "I meant the popular vote so I was right." And then he also took credit for "correctly" predicting Trump in 2016.
Collin Rugg
@CollinRugg
There are many "experts" who disagree with this assessment.
I would do your own research.
But anyone on either side who thinks "we have this in the bag" is wrong. Anything can happen. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Justin Grimmer
@JustinGrimmer
Allan Lichtman claims his 13 keys offer definitive predictions on who will win the presidential election.
Lichtman cannot possibly have the data to back up these claims. He is (at least) 11,988 years away from having enough evidence to support his most basic predictions.
Thread -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I know people dunk on this guy all the time, but can't a lot of the same criticisms be directed at overfitted prediction models from political science (he's doing n=59, k=13; I see a lot of stuff that's n=59; k=6).
Allan Lichtman
@AllanLichtman
Biden’s withdrawal cost Democrats the Incumbency Key on my 13 Keys to the White House prediction system. But the excitement generated by his endorsement of VP Harris makes it very likely that they retain the Contest Key as she becomes the consensus nominee.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Elon is weird. The Democratic Party gave him lots of taxpayer money for rich liberals to buy Teslas and forced GM/Ford/etc. to give him gobs more money in permits. He doesn't get invited to one White House event because of union pressure, and he gets redpilled.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
Today we released the first papers from OpenResearch's Unconditional income Study, which gave 1k ppl $1k/mo for 3 yrs & had a N=2k control group
This 🧵 is for RCT nerds: how did we measure the cash's fx? Learn about 96% response rates, blood draws, changing a state law & more.. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
How will Joe Biden's one-term presidency best be remembered?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Lots of discussion about "the politics of Silicon Valley." As far as I know, @dbroockman and I are the only ones ever to systematically collect survey data on the political leanings of this industry, which goes against lots of conventional wisdom: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/ajps.12408 1/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Here is a video summary we did of the paper: www.youtube.com/watch?v=XIIwLtrEQic 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I find it strange when people say that this means that Biden is "not serious about winning the general election." According to polling data, these are both extremely popular suggestions (although constitutionally dubious).
The Spectator Index
@spectatorindex
BREAKING: President Biden is preparing to propose major Supreme Court reforms including term limits for justices and an enforceable ethics code
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I find UK electoral politics very fascinating. Labour has always put up a white male as their candidate; Conservatives have put up non-white males five times (and their next leader is also likely to be a non-white male).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The lesson that many politicians have taken from Trump/Kavanaugh is never give in / new cycles are short / people move on / the mob gets bored / things revert to steady state soon enough.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Do people think it's telling that the GOP has not started to talk about impeachment? It may suggest: (1) They know it is politically best for Biden to be the nominee; and (2) They don't believe the country is under any real threat due to Biden's cognition. 1/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The GOP has floated impeachment rhetoric for many ludicrous things (and actually impeached a Cabinet member) and they are not mentioning it for the one perhaps legitimate thing that might warrant impeachment. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It was this kind of stuff that was so weird. The response was never "He does not have dementia. That is offensive and has no basis." but rather "The man is a genius!" for a politician for whom analytical intelligence was never his valence characteristic.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Has anyone seen any data on what predicts desire for Biden to drop out among Democrats? Doesn't seem like ideology would be a strong predictor.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
@aspaglayan on bsky
@aspaglayan
Just finished reading the first review by @Andrew___Baker and learned so much from reading it!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
New article by @xuyiqing et al. on TWFE models just posted to @aletheia_tweets . Check it out! aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/chiu_et_al_2024… Also, some @aletheia_tweets success stories with articles by @EfrenPoliPsy et al published in APSR and @GabeLenz et al in NHB (with 50+ citations already) 1/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Thank to @xuyiqing and team, as well as excellent reviews by @Andrew___Baker and @a_strezh
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
68% of the American public agreed with the Court's ruling to not revoke mifepristone. Some argue that with extreme judges in the district and appellate courts, the SC has good fodder to accept cases that make them appear moderate to the public. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/05/09/us/supreme-court-m…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
67% of Americans (incl 56% of Repubs and 77% of Dems) disagreed with the Court's ruling here, believing that South Carolina engaged in a *racial* gerrymander, not just a *partisan* gerrymander. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/05/09/us/supreme-court-m…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jae-Hee Jung
@jung_jaehee_
Forthcoming at APSR! We categorize the variety of values that have been of interest in polisci and psych in terms of their cooperativeness. We argue that more cooperative values tend to be more moralized in the general public. (1/2) jaeheejung.com/research/
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
55% of Americans DISAGREED with this decision. 63% of Republicans, 61% of Independents, and 39% of Democrats. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/2024-survey-results
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Efrén Pérez
@EfrenPoliPsy
I want to highlight that an early version of the paper below was reviewed and is archived @aletheia_tweets, which @namalhotra created. The platform helped us iron out some snags in our early thinking and analyses.
Think about using @aletheia_tweets for your own work 👍🏽
Efrén Pérez
@EfrenPoliPsy
Excited that “Partisans of Color: Asian American and Latino Party ID in an Era of Racialization and Polarization” was conditionally accepted @apsrjournal.
Authors: Me, Jessica Lee (UCLA PhD, Poli Sci) + Gustavo Mártir (UCLA PhD student, Psych).
cc: @grown_simba95
A short 🧵 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Biden campaign makes the claim that late-in-cyle debates are bad for democracy because early voters cannot incorporate information. @mieuque and I showed empirical evidence for this claim during the 2008 primaries: www.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/elj.2010.0088
Sahil Kapur
@sahilkapur
Biden campaign: “The purpose of this letter is to provide notice that the President will not be participating in the Commission on Presidential Debates’ announced debates in 2024.” They float a different schedule: one debate in late June, one in September; VP debate in late July.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The largest social media deactivation RCT was just published in PNAS: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2321584121
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The @nytimes has published the results of 2024 SCOTUSPoll, the annual survey I do with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee on how people would decide on the major cases before the Court. You can follow along as the Court issues its opinions throughout the summer: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/05/09/us/supreme-court-m…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I am very honored to receive this fellowship and look forward to putting together a research team. If anyone has candidates at all levels (post-doc, pre-doc) who would be interested in working with me, please send them my way: www.carnegie.org/awards/honoree/neil-malhotra/
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Ryan Miller
@DrDRMiller
This paper by @christian_fong, @namalhotra, and Yotam Margalit is the only contemporary piece I'm aware of on this topic, and I think there is a lot more to be done.
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/ps-political-science-and-… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In case people are not educated on this, it is illegal in the state of California for Stanford to take disciplinary action. You would need to bring this up with Gavin Newsom and the CA legislature.
iphas 💙🎗️🟧🤘
@ialiphas
Happening at Stanford tonight. Students calling for the genocide of jews. Does this violate Stanford’s code of conduct?
The administration needs to take disciplinary action or Richard Saller should answer @RepStefanik questions just like Claudine Gay did -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Understanding the relationship between religious beliefs and support for political violence is a legitimate and important scientific question, but it has to be handled with care and skill. This is a paper we published in 2012: academic.oup.com/poq/article/76/4/688/1909497 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We try to conceptually define what exactly people mean when they claim that "Islam contributes to political violence," and go through various potential operationalizations. We mainly find null effects---very little relationship between behaviors and beliefs. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The one exception that explains variability is how an individual defines the word "jihad." Those who define it as an external military struggle are more supportive of political violence than those who define it as an internal struggle for righteousness. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One thing I don't understand is when somebody makes an honest mistake on Twitter and they start getting ratioed quickly, why do they keep the tweet up?
Chris Cillizza
@ChrisCillizza
It just didn't happen.
And, again, no journalist said "learn to code." And neither did Biden. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Since the menswear guy has given us so much good advice over the years, I'll share with him Bob Shiller's first rule of housing: A house is a box that definitely depreciates sitting on a piece of land that may or may not appreciate.
derek guy
@dieworkwear
not my aesthetic but it's crazy to me that this 6,000 sq ft home in Saint Joseph, MO is on the market for just $595k
🔗: blst.to/MzLUCzM -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What weirds out a lot of high-SES Democrats about Biden is that he is the first Democratic nominee since LBJ for whom analytic intelligence is not their primary trait / valence characteristic. They have been socialized into thinking that Jed Bartlett is the ideal, not Truman/LBJ.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ackman going full Ralph Cifaretto from "The Sopranos" was highly unexpected.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The best definition of "equality of opportunity" I have heard comes from the movie "Ratatouille": "Not everyone can cook, but a great cook can come from anywhere."
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Marc Meredith
@mieuque
I am excited to be the new Editor-in-Chief of the @ElectionLawJrnl. I encourage you to submit your best elections scholarship to ELJ, no matter what your country of focus is. email.liebertpub.com/q/17GKomZ1hpGSKVR8UmRjgS/wv
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When elites dump on bad actors because they went to community colleges or night school, they don't realize they are not just dumping on the bad actor but everyone who went to community colleges or night school.
Emmanuel Acho
@EmmanuelAcho
Jimmy Kimmel just scorched earth on Aaron Rodgers!
“A guy who went to community college, then got into Cal on a football scholarship & didn’t graduate… Aaron Rodgers got two A’s on his report card, and they were both in the word, ‘Aaron’.”
@jimmykimmel -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This website will never die because only here can you get truly stupid takes like "The way you can tell someone is poor is by their SAT score."
Jon Boeckenstedt
@JonBoeckenstedt
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This whole thread is really statistically bad. If you follow its logical conclusions, Vigdor is arguing that top undergraduate institutions should only be recruiting students from Exeter/Andover/Harvard-Westlake/etc., which would be horrible.
Jake Vigdor
@JakeVigdor
Much respect for @DLeonhardt's journalism, but this thread is going on my quant syllabus as an example of how to mislead (not lie! but mislead) with statistics. SAT/ACT are way less of a deal than is implied here.
Strap in, because we're going into the weeds on this thread... -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Possibly similar to VC investment success percentage.
Marc Andreessen 🇺🇸
@pmarca
The academic paper quality funnel:
1. # of total papers written
2. % of 1 whose results replicate
3. % of 2 that are read
4. % of 3 that are cited
5. % of 4 not consumed by radical politics
6. % of 5 not plagiarized
7. % of 6 whose results matter
What is the final count? -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My favorite line from "The Departed":
Colin: I'm also getting my law degree.
Madolyn: Suffolk, nights?
Colin: They don't run Harvard Law at night last time I chcked.
Madolyn: When was the last time you checked?
Colin: Before I went to fucking Suffolk. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My main takeaway from the last month is that Twitter is still an incredibly important platform that can change the world (often for the worse), and that Threads/Bluesky/the elephant one are completely irrelevant in media/business/academic/etc.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is not inconsistent with the fact that Twitter has become a bad business model.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What's the deal with these Bill Ackman tweets? How are they so well written? I have to assume there is a staff of multiple people putting these together, and it's not just random musings on his phone.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The president of the university is the CEO, managing an academic operation, endowment, semipro sports team, hospital, etc. The provost is the chief academic officer (runs the most important part of the org, like the CMO at Procter/Gamble or CTO at Microsoft).
Tristan Cunha
@cunha_tristan
Does the president actually do anything?
Besides fundraising I mean. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In 2008, many conservatives criticized/made fun of both Obama and Hillary for liking this book. Then some of them actually read it and realized, "Wow, this is some good stuff."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I rewatched "The Fugitive" last night and am unclear what supposed to happen to Kimble at the end. He is arrested, but then his cuffs are removed. He is exonerated for killing his wife, but committed many other crimes (breaking out of jail, forgery, theft, breaking and entering)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When you get that piece of mail from Vanguard/Fidelity/TIAA/etc. that says "IMPORTANT SHAREHOLDER INFORMATION. OPEN IMMEDIATELY!," what do you usually do with it?
Christopher Phelan
@ChrisPhelanEcon
Question for my economist and finance friends: Do index fund managers vote their shares? If they do, then there might actually be something to this since there is a temptation to do so for goals other than acting in the interest of the fund's shareholders.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There is an interesting psychological paradox to elite university admissions. The lower the admissions rate, potentially the less valuable the degree because the admissions decisions are more likely to be viewed as capricious rather than meritocratic.
Josh Dean
@josh_t_dean
This viral 1460 SAT video highlights how crazy it is that top colleges haven't expanded supply to meet demand.
- 1460 is 96th percentile of SAT takers
- But 1.9 million SAT takers means 76,000 scored better
- Ivys collectively enrolled 22% of that (16,801) -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Ivy presidents' response to Stefanik reminds me a lot of Dukakis' answer to the death penalty question in 1988. Intellectual response to an unfair question without a clear understanding of how it would land in the court of public opinion. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yhc816_wR6Q
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Chelsey Clark
@chelseysclark
Last year, the US Supreme Court reversed the constitutional protection of abortion rights
Our new paper ‼️ in Nature Human Behaviour looks at the effect of the leaked and official rulings on public opinion (attitudes & norm perceptions) regarding abortion and the Court itself -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is why I roll my eyes when people call climate change an "existential threat." They don't really mean it. If something is an *existential* threat, you don't prioritize interest groups/convenience/etc. If you do, it's just a regular threat with tradeoffs.
U.S. Senator John Fetterman
@SenFettermanPA
Pennsylvania’s dairy farmers are at the heart of our community and critical to our economy.
In Congress, I’m fighting to pass the DAIRY PRIDE Act. This bill will protect our dairy farmers by prohibiting non-dairy products from using dairy names. 💯 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
NEW PAPER w @benlauderdale
A recent APSR article, "Moderates", argues Americans with a mix of liberal & conservative views are actually centrist.
We show that it relies on a flawed method & its conclusions are therefore unreliable.
We welcome feedback!
osf.io/ma2fs/ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Recent poll shows Biden approval rating on Israel is 41%: abcnews.go.com/Politics/americans-favor-continued-support… In our polarized era (where party cues will drive assessments of performance), 80% would have been very unlikely in the absence of an attack on US soil.
G Elliott Morris
@gelliottmorris
while we’re registering predictions, mine is that Biden’s best issue approval over the next few weeks will be on foreign policy/Israel, as compared to economy/inflation, abortion, guns control, health care, immigration & crime: i am not certain but fairly confident — maybe 80%
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Check out the peer reviews at @aletheia_tweets : aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/ . Because the reviews are public, they are BOTH *high-quality* and *professional*. People intellectually engage with the work.
Yusaku Horiuchi
@YusakuHoriuchi
One of the reviewers referred to our argument as "insane." Is this a word a professional reviewer in a top political science journal would typically use? 🤔 #academicwriting
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The normal practice of cumulative research is to say: "Scholar (XXXX) argued X, and their methods were flawed." A typical practice in economics is to ignore the existence of Scholar (XXXX).
Jason Abaluck
@Jabaluck
We also (correctly) treat work in economics from 25 years ago this way. It is a naive fiction that research is "done" or that claims about social policy are definitively established. By the standards of today, most research 25 years ago has serious holes. @doc_thoughts
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
@JakeJares and I are happy to announce a new paper posted to @aletheia_tweets by @jj_naddeo and colleagues on "De-Prosecution and Death": aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/kaplan_naddeo_s… 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The paper is a replication/critique of Hogan (2022a), which examines the relationship between de-prosecution and homicides in Philadelphia. @aletheia_tweets is a great platform for publishing replications quickly, which sometimes trad. journals eschew. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Check out this great paper and please consider submitting your work to @aletheia_tweets. It's a pre-print server with peer reviews; it's a great way to get feedback on your work before submitting to a peer-reviewed journal. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
CASBS
@CASBSStanford
Check out this special issue of @ScienceMagazine on social media & elections
Current CASBS fellow Young Mie Kim & former fellows @namalhotra, @jenjpan & @sgonzalezbailon among the coauthors of all the research articles contained in the issue... 😏
Science Magazine
@ScienceMagazine
A new special issue of Science investigates social media’s impact on elections through a pioneering collaboration between independent academics and Meta researchers.
Learn more: scim.ag/3vL #socialmediaandelections -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Have any education experts weighed in on economists' consensus that proofs should be taught in public middle school math? I have a suspicion this would not go well for the typical US student.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Proud of graduate student Saikun Shu presenting our research on the politics of small business ownership at #apsa2023 featuring data from Connect @CloudResearch and @RachelXHartman.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Saikun Shi*
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
"Rich Men North of Richmond" ideology
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Won a World Series with the Phillies in 2008 and the Giants in 2010.
Codify
@CodifyBaseball
What happened to your high school's best baseball player?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Talia Stroud
@TaliaStroud
It’s been an honor to work with @j_a_tucker and a team of academic and Meta researchers on a project about Facebook and Instagram during the 2020 elections. The first four papers (more to come) were published and they reveal:
(1/10) -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
New @nature: Like-minded sources on Facebook are prevalent but not polarizing
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06297-w (open access!)
Our key findings:
-Median FB user gets 50.4% of content from like-minded sources
-But reducing exposure by ~1/3 for 3 months had no measurable effect on attitudes -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Andy Guess
@andyguess
Today is publication day for the first 4 papers resulting from a unique collaboration between Meta researchers and outside academics to study the political effects of Facebook and Instagram in the 2020 U.S. election! 🧵 1/N
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jennifer Pan
@jenjpan
Today, 2 papers I coauthored w/ @andyguess @namalhotra @p_barbera are out in Science. These papers, about the role of social media in American democracy, are based on pre-registered experiments with consenting participants conducted w/ @Meta #socialmediaandelections
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The reason MIT gets away with not having legacy admissions is because if your mom/dad went to MIT and you suck at math, there's sort of universal agreement it's not a good fit. But if your mom/dad was an engineering major at Harvard, you can major in gov and get a job at Goldman.
Aaron Carr
@aaronAcarr
The argument that legacy status in college admissions is wholly necessary to keeping endowments high, really falls apart when you consider the fact that MIT doesn't have legacy admissions but, at a whopping $25 billion, has the 6th largest endowment in America.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Given how mild Omicron is, I think people forget how dangerous Delta was and that the vaccines came at the perfect time to deal with the variant. Sad that there was so much unnecessary loss of life due to partisanship/ideology.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
"Our study found evidence of higher excess mortality for Republican voters compared with Democratic voters in Florida and Ohio after, but not before, #covid-19 vaccines were available to all adults in the US."
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
People don't get enough credit for writing good book reviews, so I want to acknowledge both @JakeMGrumbach 's great book and @dhopkins1776 's great review for jointly producing an excellent scholarly exchange. Put both on your syllabus!
Jake M. Grumbach
@JakeMGrumbach
Appreciate this insightful, critical review of my book from a scholar whose work I've admired for a long time
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Will Supreme Court opinions provoke public backlash?
New #scienceofpolitics podcast/transcript with Joe Ura & Stephen Jessee
We look at how misaligned Court opinions are with public opinion & how the public reacts to liberal & conservative decisions
www.niskanencenter.org/will-supreme-court-opinions-provok… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Lots of discussion of Martin-Quinn scores. For the past few years, our SCOTUSPoll project has been producing ideal point estimates that are easier for the public to understand because we use our public opinion survey as an anchor. Here are our preliminary '23 results: 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
All of this produced a Court that slightly moderated compared to the '21 and '22 terms. Hopefully, this is more helpful than seeing a figure with the Court median at "0" and Sotomayor at "-2." 4/4
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Here is the academic paper with our methodology: www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2120284119
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My sincere advice to universities would be to pick a value--diversity or social justice--and go all-in while staying within the law. If you believe in diversity, build a real diverse class (not on 1 or 2 dimensions). If you believe in justice, actually help the disadvantaged 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
But this is a good chance for a reset. Figure out what you want to do. If you care about diversity, recruit a truly diverse class from around the world. If you care about justice in the U.S., help the poorest and most marginalized citizens 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One whole chapter of my book is devoted to DEI policies, and explaining which types of policies are consistent with which types of values. www.amazon.com/Leading-Values-Strategies-Decisions-Busine… 4/4
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Supreme Court's rulings this term were much more moderate and consistent with public opinion compared to the previous two terms. I have a hard time believing that public pressure---including protests outside justice's homes---did not influence the marginal justices.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's hard not to say that the Court moderated after the blowback from Dobbs. In 2021 and 2022, the Court was much more conservative that the public on many issues, not just abortion. These patterns are much more consistent with a Court that cares about politics 4/4.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Now that most of the decisions are in, you can compare public opinion against the Supreme Court's decisions in our survey here: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/06/07/us/major-supreme-c… We still have to compute our ideal point estimates, but it does seem like the Court has moderated its position 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In previous years, it almost always sided with Republicans on divided issues in the public, but in this term is sometimes sided with Democrats (e.g., redistricting, election administration). 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's hard not to say that the Court moderated after the blowback from Dobbs. In 2021 and 2022, the Court was much more conservative that the public on many issues, not just abortion. These patterns are much more consistent with a Court that cares about politics 4/4.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Lots of talk about responding to reviewer comments etc. Just a reminder that if you submit to @aletheia_tweets, you can respond to whichever comments you view as most valuable. It works because everything is transparent (reviews and r&r memo posted). 1/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you check out the website, you'll see the reviews are intelligent, helpful, and cogent. Part of this is due to the high quality of reviewers, but also because when you have to sign your name publicly, you do a great job, and authors take your advice. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Gabriel S. Lenz
@GabeLenz
Aletheia was helpful in ultimately publishing our paper, so I wanted to describe our experience and encourage you to post your papers to it.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Another @aletheia_tweets paper by @AliaBraley, @GabeLenz et al. on "The Subversion Dilemma" was a huge success: aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/braley_et_al_20… 4/n
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
New @aletheia_tweets paper by @YamilRVelez: "Tradeoffs in Latino Politics." aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/velez_2023_trad… Peer reviewers were Asya Magazinnik and @Ivelongui 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you are interested in posting a peer-reviewed working paper, please reach out to @aletheia_tweets. It is a way to disseminate peer-reviewed research quickly, and you can also get feedback for journal publication in a traditional outlet later 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Highly encourage everyone to check out @YamilRVelez 's paper, and you can see the whole transparent research production process: reviews, r&r memo, etc.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
@aletheia_tweets is pleased to announce the release of "Partisans of Color" by @EfrenPoliPsy, Jessica HyunJeong Lee, and Gustavo A. Mártir Luna. The reviewers of the paper were @m_levendusky and @YamilRVelez . aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/perez_et_al_202… 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Another @aletheia_tweets paper by @AliaBraley, @GabeLenz et al. on "The Subversion Dilemma" was a huge success: aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/braley_et_al_20… 4/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It won a polarization research competition and was published in @NatureHumBehav . Please check out "Partisans of Color" and support new, complementary models of sharing our findings and research.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Denver is first non-CA / non-TX Western Conf team to win the NBA finals since 1979. Those teams have been 0-8 in finals since.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
CA teams: 15-8; TX teams: 8-4
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Every year we survey the public in the spring about their views of the upcoming Supreme Court decisions. Here are this year's results, with interesting bipartisan majorities on issues like environment, affirmative action, and Section 230: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/06/07/us/major-supreme-c…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
New preprint: An Inception Cohort Study Quantifying How Many Registered Studies are Published. We look at how many research studies are performed but remain unpublished after at least 4 years, and estimate this is 42% of registered studies. psyarxiv.com/5hkjz
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Invest in stamina early on, not hearts. It's tempting to invest in HP because the combat might be hard. But stamina makes *both* combat and exploration easier.
Zelda Universe
@ZeldaUniverse
What are some early game tips you can share about The Legend of #zelda: #tearsofthekingdom?
Let’s help each other out! -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Most open world games suck because it's just moving from one main quest marker to another main quest marker. Zelda is so brilliant because the quest marker is just a nudge to get you to move so that you can explore, immerse, and get distracted from the quest marker.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The left on profit-maximizing companies in 2000: "Crap, Lindblom was right."
The left on profit-maximizing companies in 2023: "Awesome, Lindblom was right!" -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Unfortunately, a lot of page space in scientific journals is taken up by "op-eds," "letters," etc. A lot of content in Science is not "science." It would be better to separate out functions (like poli sci does to some extent with APSR and PS) so it's clearer to public.
Rafe Meager (they/them)
@economeager
increasingly convinced that a lot of the commentariat think scientific journals are just the places where scientists get to post their hot takes, as if they're just the opinion columns for people with PhDs.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Political/cultural pundits trying to parse the success of the Mario Bros movie aren't aware of two simple things: (1) Video games are by far the most popular entertainment medium (dominating film/music handily); and (2) Mario Bros is arguably the most valuable IP in the medium.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Mario Kart 8 by itself has made more money than any movie in history.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Tali Mendelberg
@TMendelberg
Come work with us at CSDP as our new Research Director! puwebp.princeton.edu/AcadHire/apply/application.xhtml?lis…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Keith Rabois
@rabois
i am going to make my exam on how to succeed on how to ignore all of your advice.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm starting to get the feeling we're not getting this equation.
Keith Rabois
@rabois
can write a simple equation to prove this. not rocket science.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Keith Rabois
@rabois
can write a simple equation to prove this. not rocket science.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I agree that Dean Martinez wrote a fantastic letter. I also agree with her decision to not punish students. One of the purposes of school is to instill values of liberalism into students, and not assume that they enter educational institutions with those values. 1/2
Nicholas A. Christakis
@NAChristakis
Fantastic letter from Dean Jenny Martinez of @Stanford @StanfordLaw defending fundamental principles of a university and addressing the wrong-headed means of protest employed by lawyers-in training at her school a few weeks ago. Bravo. law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Next-Steps-on…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Students will err (they are students after all), and they should have room to have learning experiences and to grow. 2/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I also have a lot of sympathy for the DEI admin. She is not a faculty member and is not socialized into the values of academic freedom. She also does not have the privileges of a tenured faculty member and has to deal with numerous stakeholders.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ideology clouding sound scientific judgment seems to be most acute when it comes to collider bias. Per Jon Bendor, I think this is because collider bias is really complicated, and therefore ideology has a more powerful effect.
Jonathan Ladd
@jonmladd
I'm not advocating for or against admissions tests, necessarily. There might be other evidence to consider. But there is just no convincing evidence either way that can come from research designs like this. This has been in our textbooks for decades. People should know better.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
So proud of @FloydZhang93; his paper has been one of the most important topics of discussion today, eliciting responses from pundits and the most prestigious scientific journals. Although he entered industry, it's so amazing to see his dissertation make an impact.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Great research from my former grad student @FloydZhang93 showing that scientific journals endorsement of Biden did not affect political attitudes, but reduced trust in science among Republicans.
nature
@Nature
In 2020, Nature endorsed Joe Biden in the US presidential election. A survey finds that viewing the endorsement did not change people’s views of the candidates, but caused some to lose confidence in Nature and in US scientists generally go.nature.com/3FysaN1
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Ethan BdM
@ethanbdm
I don't agree with this thread.
Scientists are entitled to political and policy views. But calling those views scientific is confused.
Scientist's political & policy views, like anyone's, reflect facts and values.
They don't have any special claim to deference wrt values.
1/ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
GameStop market cap is $5.6 billion.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Great research from my former grad student @FloydZhang93 showing that scientific journals endorsement of Biden did not affect political attitudes, but reduced trust in science among Republicans.
nature
@Nature
In 2020, Nature endorsed Joe Biden in the US presidential election. A survey finds that viewing the endorsement did not change people’s views of the candidates, but caused some to lose confidence in Nature and in US scientists generally go.nature.com/3FysaN1
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm increasingly thinking that Elizabeth Warren was right about Jay Powell all along.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
~700 people liked this shade on Hoxby/Card. Do people even know what they are "liking" on Twitter?
Wojtek Kopczuk 🇵🇱🇺🇦 and 🇺🇲
@wwwojtekk
You should not control for "all relevant variables" in the wage gap regression and you should not do it when studying bias in admissions to Harvard.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
People forget how good Trump was in the debates, mainly due to his authenticity. Cruz tried to criticize Trump for being from Manhattan and Trump absolutely owned him: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TM6qRl3dSME
mindy🌷
@mindyisser
genuinely made me LOL
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
PoIiMath
@politicalmath
My understanding is the SVB collapse was due to:
1) leveraging "safe" treasury bonds that became less valuable as the fed increased rates
2) a good old fashioned bank run
Is that close enough that I can ignore both "DEI caused this" and "deregulation caused this"? -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Blackwell
@matt_blackwell
Tech industry learning they are deeply unsympathetic politically, as an academic I wouldn’t know anything about that…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Hilary Hoynes
@HilaryHoynes
I agree that this piece has blatant, factual errors on depicting the trends in poverty.
Oddly, in the body of the article the Times steers you to their article on "a sharp drop in child poverty" -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Of all the figures I've made in my life, I always thought this was one of the most interesting.
David Broockman
@dbroockman
With today's SVB news, thinking of my research with @namalhotra finding that tech founders support redistribution and are otherwise quite liberal---but oppose regulation. Many are about to appreciate the benefits of the FDIC and banking regulations...
doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12408 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Almost nobody in economics or political science academia is talking about Silicon Valley Bank?
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
David Broockman
@dbroockman
With today's SVB news, thinking of my research with @namalhotra finding that tech founders support redistribution and are otherwise quite liberal---but oppose regulation. Many are about to appreciate the benefits of the FDIC and banking regulations...
doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12408 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
With today's SVB news, thinking of my research with @namalhotra finding that tech founders support redistribution and are otherwise quite liberal---but oppose regulation. Many are about to appreciate the benefits of the FDIC and banking regulations...
doi.org/10.1111/ajps.12408 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
"America First"
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Now that a private equity bro has discovered this finding, good opportunity to point people to this excellent paper by Huber and Paris showing that this experiment has confounds: academic.oup.com/poq/article/77/1/385/1816687
Steve Rattner
@SteveRattner
71% of Americans think the US should spend more on "assistance to the poor"
... but call it "welfare" and that number drops to 30% -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Rex Woodbury
@rex_woodbury
Most people don't realize the scale of video games:
Hogwarts Legacy just grossed $850M in its first two weeks. Biggest launch ever for Warner Bros Games.
By comparison, Warner Bros's biggest *movie* ever, the last Harry Potter movie, brought in $295M in its first two weeks. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
chris
@chrisdadeviant
THEY DID THE MAGAZINE SCENE MY LIFE IS COMPLETE #thelastofus
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I really hate to write the "dear white people" tweets, but the following are a list of INDIAN names: Nikki, Neil, Monica, Shawn, Jay, Vik, Anya, Alisha, Anita, Bella, Lela, Leena, Marissa, Maya, Nina, Sonya, Tara, Harry, Nick, Sam....
brutal south
@Paul_Bowers
I'll go ahead and say this: Calling Nikki Haley "Nimrata" as an insult has the same energy as saying "Barack HUSSEIN Obama." There are a thousand reasons to oppose her, but that ain't one of them.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Is San Francisco the next Detroit?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The way you know a lot of "America First" nationalism has racist undertones is that immigrant parents actually have a lot of the non-racial 1950s values that MAGA is trying to reclaim (e.g., patriotism, family, hard work, etc.).
Brad Wilcox
@BradWilcoxIFS
Today’s parents are prioritizing Money & Work > Marriage and Parenthood for their own kids. Spells real trouble long-term for the future of the family. New from @pewresearch: pewrsr.ch/3j8J5xI
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
American Political Science Review
@apsrjournal
#tuesdaytip: Recommending emerging scholars when you submit an article or decline a reviewer invitation can be a great way to grow the reviewer pool.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Some feedback. The audience for this should also be the people of Florida, because the University of Florida belongs to *them*, not the faculty. The bullet points should explain how they, as stakeholders, are affected by these actions.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Some feedback. The audience for this should also be the people of Florida, because the University of Florida belongs to *them*, not the faculty. The bullet points should explain how they, as stakeholders, are affected by these actions.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
fOLLoW tHe SCieNCE
Market Urbanism
@MarketUrbanism
New Los Angeles mayor Karen Bass says that economists' findings that new market-rate construction prevents displacement rather than causes it are: "false. That’s completely false. I’m sorry." calmatters.org/housing/2023/01/california-housing-podcast…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
All public education is subject to political control. As @ZaidJilani has said this is sort of the left's version of "Get the government's hands off my Medicare." Universities need to convince the people why it's in their best interest to delegate control to them, not politicians.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The University of Florida does not belong to the faculty or the students. It belongs to the people of Florida. Ultimately, you need to convince and explain to them why the *value* of academic freedom is important. Universities have done a very poor job of this recently.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's unclear whether this is a reason that DeSantis is popular. He had a good record on economy/covid and these are probably first-order voter concerns. But his culture war agenda at least did not appear to cause him to lose a lot of votes.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The pitch I would make is: "Academic freedom makes your life better. It facilitates the discoveries that cure disease, build smartphones, and raise your wages. While we believe in the scientific method around facts, universities of course should reflect a diversity of values."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
PhD student was one of the best jobs I ever had; untenured professor was one of the worst.
dean
@deanarnoldultra
phd student is one of the best jobs ever if we’re being honest
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Who will be the Speaker of the House?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm on the kid's side here.
Usman - SKizzle
@SKizzleAXE
He wanted PS5 and got Xbox got in return 😂
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Real-life Moops/Moors:
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Is it commonly understood that Elon wants to lose that poll? Would not be totally surprised if it was cooked to make sure he "lost."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It seems like Biden has positioned the Democratic Party at the location of the median voter on this issue: "The pandemic is over" BUT "get your vaccines and here are some free tests."
Maggie Haberman
@maggieNYT
DeSantis reverses himself on coronavirus vaccines, moving right of Trump - The Washington Post www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/12/17/desantis-vacci…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Telling me to leave Twitter is like telling me to go by Mike Bolton instead of Michael Bolton. Why should I change? He's the one who sucks!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Joe Lacob getting booed at Chris Mullin's retirement ceremony. After he decided to keep Steph and trade Monta for Bogut.
Steven Hyden
@Steven_Hyden
Trying to think of instances of a person getting soundly booed and coming out of it looking awesome.
1. Dylan on the 65-66 tour
2. Bill Burr in Philadelphia in 2006
Is that the list? -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When students ask me for an example of "corporate social responsibility," I tell them about Hobby Lobby not providing contraception to its employees. My new example may be what Musk is doing to this website. 1/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you're confused by this tweet, check out Chapter 5 of our book: www.amazon.com/Leading-Values-Strategies-Decisions-Busine… 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
And, of course: www.nytimes.com/1970/09/13/archives/a-friedman-doctrine-t… 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Musk's behavior is exactly what Milton Friedman warned against.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Musk's behavior is exactly what Milton Friedman warned against.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is not an accurate understanding of the Silicon Valley elite (capital/entrepreneurial class, not PMC workers). Musk's support may be slipping a little bit among this elite, but it still high. Fauci (covid hawkism) was not popular in SV capital class.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Bernie Sanders has never ran as a member of the Democratic Party, and for every election to Congress stretching back to 1988 ran as an Independent .
Wojtek Kopczuk 🇵🇱🇺🇦 and 🇺🇲
@wwwojtekk
So Sinema is an independent now. I haven't seen a lot of people complaining that so is Sanders.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
And many people did complain that the participated in the Democratic presidential primaries in 2016 and 2020, noting that he was not a member of the party.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
REAL ID taking a cue from MPSA and delaying the deadline once again. The UX on this is terrible. Offering one driver's license for driving and another for driving and flying is not going to logistically work. States need to offer one compliant license.
TSA
@TSA
NEWS: DHS announces extension of REAL ID full enforcement deadline. Learn more at: www.tsa.gov/news/press/releases/2022/12/05/dhs-announces-…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Both Zuckerberg and Dorsey admit they made mistakes w.r.t. Hunter laptop story (and the platforms continue to pay for those mistakes to this day), but I think people vastly underestimate the agonizing decisions they faced in Fall 2020. Easy to monday morning QB.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I have always had a lot of respect for @RoKhanna. He disagreed with how I characterized him in a media interview, and reached out to me to have a civil and intellectual discussion. Some will say he should have blown the whistle, but he showed a lot of courage.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ummm...so what? This is the exactly the kind of capitalist economy we want...where externalities are born by the market.
Patrick S. Tomlinson
@stealthygeek
Thread time. Here's the thing about @tesla. It's not a car company. Tesla is a company that has to make cars in order to sell its real product: Emissions Credits.
Let me explain. Back in 2012, the EPA put out new, strident emissions standards for new vehicles fleetwide. 1/ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One issue with "Election Week" is that the early narratives leave out those of us in the West. So, what explains why the GOP did so well in CA? Good, sane candidates? Abortion less salient than Midwest because no threat of GOP takeover of state gvnt?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I worked with Josh when he was an undergraduate RA at Stanford, and so proud to see him bringing the opportunity/dynamism of Silicon Valley to the Central Valley.
Political Polls
@Politics_Polls
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Check out this important project, and participate!
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Ryan Brune
@BruneElections
Light red means Republican ripple. Dark red is Republican wave. Light blue is Democratic ripple, dark blue is Democratic wave.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Here are the ten seats (out of all 33 Class I seats) the GOP has to defend in 2024 Senate elections: FL, IN, MS, MO, NE, ND, TN, TX, UT, WY
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Democrats need to hope a nutjob is nominated in IN and NE.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Tried my hand writing an op-ed on the tense relationship between Silicon Valley and the Democratic Party: www.nytimes.com/2022/11/13/opinion/democrats-are-blowing-… (based on research with @dbroockman and @ferenstein)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It looks like this will be around ~40% and the Republicans still did badly. Wow.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to exit polls, what percentage of the Asian/Latino vote will Republican House candidates get in 2022?
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Overall, I think racial depolarization is going to be a good thing for American politics. It's good that the GOP is going to have to face a more diverse base electorate, and good that the Dem party is getting better at winning white voters.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
True. Another good example was Dem pickups after Gingrich wave in 1996-1998-2000 (and then Bush acing his midterms in 2002). It is very hard to pick up House seats in 4 consecutive elections.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Dems have not even made back all the House seats lost in 2010 yet (they will be about ~40 short?).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Who will be the Speaker of the House?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One fantastic thing about Google Scholar, no matter the prestige of your institution or your number of your citations or whether Google subjectively thinks you're an important person, is that there is a mechanism for you to be verified.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dan Hopkins
@dhopkins1776
Shoot @namalhotra this tweet totally scoops my forthcoming book... ;)
But for those who want to read an extended version of @namalhotra's tweet over 322 pages, stay tuned. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Elite institutions such as Harvard and Princeton claim to be "global institutions" @LeahLitman, should they look like the world, which is 60% Asian, 15% African, and minority white? Or should we look at this from an "America First" angle?
Robert P. George
@McCormickProf
Prof Decosimo raises an important challenge. Our elite and other university faculties and often student bodies really don't much reflect American identities. Should they? That's a question worth debating. Should they in some respects but not in others? Why these and not those?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Lakshya Jain
@lxeagle17
uh, just to clarify though, as cool as this is...I wouldn't call FiveThirtyEight a partisan polling average!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Harvard's discrimination of Asian applications in favor of white applicants (echoing the anti-Semitic practices of decades ago), coupled with the bunding of the Harvard and UNC cases, could jeopardize broader affirmative action practices.
kang
@jaycaspiankang
Alito asks Waxman (harvard lawyer) why Asians got consistently lower personal scores than any other group. Points out that its either there's something wrong or Asians really are lame. This is really the core question. Waxman says a bunch of nonsense.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is also true of title insurance. There are plenty of rent-seeking industries in the important business of verification, and it seems normal from a business perspective that Twitter would want to collect rents on an important function.
Katie Mack
@AstroKatie
The point of Twitter verification is that for certain individuals/organizations it’s useful to be able to verify their statements are coming from them. (This is why so many journalists/reporters are verified.) It’s supposed to help combat disinformation, not be a status symbol.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sean Westwood
@seanjwestwood
Yes, that is exactly right.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What do people think about gubernatorial coattails? @mieuque Kemp/Lake/Shapiro/DeSantis/Sununu look like they are going to win big; how will that affect the competitive Senate races? www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What is a better explanation for why the Democrats are doing so well in the polls (compared to historical standards) given the terrible state of the economy?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It sort of depends on how you define a "tax expenditure." I may be wrong but I read somewhere that well over 50% of the mortgage interest deduction goes to CA.
James Surowiecki
@JamesSurowiecki
Interesting piece on how rural voters' total misperception of reality helps drive resentment. Rural voters feel, or at least say, that they're underrepresented in Washington and that too many federal dollars go to urban/coastal areas. The reality is exactly the opposite.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There are also symbolic/visible things regardless of how the full accounting works out. It seems pretty crazy that we gave millionaires in CA thousands of dollars to buy Teslas.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Brown-Cameron-May-Johnson-Truss. Yikes. Is this the UK's version of Johnson-Nixon-Ford-Carter, or Taylor-Fillmore-Pierce-Buchanan?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
👇👇👇
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's cool/interest how social science concepts like "pre-registration" have entered the common journalistic lexicon.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you like this idea, please consider submitting to @aletheia_tweets . Your paper will get published, and because it is a pre-print server, you can publish in a traditional peer reviewed journal if you'd like as well.
Matt Blackwell
@matt_blackwell
Or to get rid of the publish/not publish decision and just have public peer review
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Jacobson hypothesis is that Ronald Reagan created a generation of Republican supporters during a key period of political socialization. One thing I explain to Gen Y/Z students is that Alex P. Keaton was a major heartthrob, and materialism was a cool and rebellious reaction.
Kurt Andersen
@KBAndersen
Why are Gen-Xers, uniquely among the age groups, so strongly Republican and weakly Democratic? BTW, this new @nytimes poll is not unique in showing this.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jacob Montgomery (@jacobmontgomery.bsky.social)
@Jacob_Montg
As an American, I’m just jealous to see the public respond rationally to poor governance.
World Elects
@ElectsWorld
🇬🇧#uk, Prime Minister Truss (Conservatives) approval rating poll:
⏬Approve: 9 % (-5)
⏫Disapprove: 70 % (+8)
Among 2019 Conservative Voters:
⏬Approve: 12 % (-9)
⏫Disapprove: 67 % (+9)
Redfield & Wilton Strategies, 16/10/22 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Would anyone like to submit a commentary on this paper (what is adds to extant knowledge, what it replicates) to @aletheia_tweets ? It seems like people have passionate thoughts, but there is not a traditional publication venue for it.
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
Incredible. Almost art. Did no one at PNAS take a class on surveys? What is happening?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
On @CNN this morning discussing the politics of natural disasters. @smerconish www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2022/10/01/smr-politics-of-di…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Judge hits 61* in Game 155.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One thing I like about @aletheia_tweets is that the R&R memos are public. This is where many analyses requested by reviewers can be housed. This creates the balance of reviewers providing oversight but not being co-authors on that paper. Please consider submitting!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Unfortunately, my anecdotal experience seems to have been telling: low takeup of bivalent boosters www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/updated-covid-booster-… Hopefully, the trend changes as we get more into flu season. One area where it would be better if the real world was like twitter.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Are the numbers suggesting that the bivalent booster rollout was a dud? Seems like no one wants it in the Bay Area, which makes me think it's even less in demand elsewhere.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is consistent with the predictions made in this paper by @maya_sen and @stephenjessee: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2120284119 The reason why support for court expansion was low is that Democrats and Independents misperceived the Court as being more liberal than it was. Dobbs changed that.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is exactly correct and a theme of our recent book: www.amazon.com/Leading-Values-Strategies-Decisions-Busine… A major mistake public health authorities made over the last 3 years was not understanding the difference between *facts* and *values*. It's why liberal arts education needs to be combined with STEM.
Newman Nahas
@NahasNewman
Let’s be very clear. When the pandemic is over is NOT an empirical question over which “experts” have any epistemic authority.
It’s a value-laden question about how we weigh the current risks against competing purposes for life.
Do NOT let Jha answer that question for you. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Aletheia
@aletheia_tweets
The @aletheia_tweets platform provides exactly the model to do this. If you want to publish a comment on a paper (but the original journal doesn't accept comments/replications), you want to update the time series for yours of others' work, consider submitting to @aletheia_tweets
John Horton
@johnjhorton
Idea: If you publish a paper in a journal, the journal should let you add public comments about that article in a very low-cost way, so future readers can contextualize that work. It would extend the useful life of old papers.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Aletheia
@aletheia_tweets
If you submit to @aletheia_tweets, we will post your peer-reviewed paper in about a month or two. And you can always submit to a traditional publication outlet later (and share the reviews with the editor).
Lucas Amaral
@luclauriano
Remember this? Now it's my turn to expose the rotten system. Rejected after 3,5 years. Ridiculous! I completely blame the editor. So much wasted time and resources.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Are the numbers suggesting that the bivalent booster rollout was a dud? Seems like no one wants it in the Bay Area, which makes me think it's even less in demand elsewhere.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm not buying this. I think the GOP is in legitimately bad shape for 2022. One thing that a lot of media elites don't want to believe is that Trump is actually very good for the GOP. When he's not on the ballot, a lot of people are demobilized. 1/2
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Okay good @Nate_Cohn said it — nobody seems to have fixed the giant polling errors from 2020.
I know some people are heartened that the GOP internal polls seem in line with the public media ones, but that was true two years ago too.
www.nytimes.com/2022/09/12/upshot/polling-midterms-warnin…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A lot of media elites ask "Why can't the GOP just give up Trump?" Well, without him, you're left with a bunch of unpopular economic policies and inauthentic fake populist candidates. Trump very much activates a portion of the electorate that doesn't respond to surveys. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Aletheia
@aletheia_tweets
If you agree with @giladfeldman, consider submitting to @aletheia_tweets, the new research platform with open and identified reviews. You can always submit your paper to a traditional journal later, and use the reviews to improve your work.
Gilad Feldman
@giladfeldman
Very surprised that most of the reactions to this are that this shows we need to blind authors & even less openness.
I disagree. Strongly. Very strongly.
We must open up the peer review system. Open and identified are important for accountability & learning.
Reasons below 🧵👇 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Aletheia
@aletheia_tweets
The peer review process is characterized by massive status bias. What is the solution? Transparency, openness, and the elimination of gatekeeping. Please consider submitting to @aletheia_tweets, a new way of sharing your research. You can ALSO submit your paper to a trad. journal
Brian Nosek (@briannosek@nerdculture.de)
@BrianNosek
Massive status bias in peer review.
534 reviewers randomized to review the same paper revealing the low status, high status, or neither author. 65% reject low status, 23% reject high status.
Amazing work by Juergen Huber and colleagues. #prc9 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Aletheia
@aletheia_tweets
Unable to attend conferences like APSA due to cost or visa restrictions? You can get amazing feedback from @aletheia_tweets. Check out the high-quality reviews others have received without shelling out thousands of dollars: aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Aletheia
@aletheia_tweets
Looking for a publishing platform with efficiency and transparency? Considering submitting your work to @aletheia_tweets aletheia-platform.netlify.app/how-it-works/article-submis… You can submit it to another journal later as Aletheia is a pre-print platform.
Sander Wagner
@sanderwagner
Today i got a reject on round 2 of r&r after over 2 and a half years of review.
The two reviewers that recommended publication after r&r round 1 were not on it any more in round 2. The new reviewer that was added wrote 3 sentences, for a second round that took 17 months.
🙆♂️ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The last time the political science job market was this good Justin Timberlake was bringing sexy back. It's been a while.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Political Economy group at the Stanford GSB is hiring this year. We are open to different fields (economics, poli sci, etc.) and different research approaches (empirical, theoretical). You don't have to study "business" to apply. www.gsb.stanford.edu/jobs/faculty-recruiting/political-ec…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Under the status quo, the top 11 states in the electoral college can choose the president. Although the electoral college is slightly gerrymandered, the main issue is that it privileges close states, some of which are large (FL) and some which are small (NH).
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Sorry, *malapportioned* not *gerrymandered*
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Andy Guess
@andyguess
Judging by the smoothness of the review process for this first (great) submission, @aletheia_tweets is off to an auspicious start. Based on this and my experience so far at @journalqd, there's clearly an appetite for trying new ways to evaluate and publish peer-reviewed research.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The first paper on the new peer-evaluated pre-print platform @aletheia_tweets is now live. It is called "The Subversion Dilemma" by @AliaBraley @GabeLenz Dhaval Adjodah, Hossein Rahnama, Alex Pentland aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/braley_et_al_20… 1/6
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Robb Willer
@RobbWiller
This is a terrific new initiative, and a great first paper to feature. The reviews of it are really interesting. This offers a rare perspective we don't get when we only view final versions of papers in journals, rarely with commentary from others in the field.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The first paper on the new peer-evaluated pre-print platform @aletheia_tweets is now live. It is called "The Subversion Dilemma" by @AliaBraley @GabeLenz Dhaval Adjodah, Hossein Rahnama, Alex Pentland aletheia-platform.netlify.app/publication/braley_et_al_20… 1/6
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I encourage everyone to read the paper, the reviews, and response memo, and let us know what you think. If the paper is relevant to your research, the website has citation instructions. 5/6
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Because of the efficiencies of the @aletheia_tweets platform, the authors were able to get reviews back in a couple of weeks (compared to several months), and distribute peer-evaluated research to the world in a timely fashion. You, too, can submit to @aletheia_tweets ! 6/6
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I am excited to announce the launch of Aletheia, a new platform for communicating peer-evaluated research. My collaborator on this project is @JakeJares. aletheia-platform.netlify.app 1/14
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A traditional peer-reviewed journal achieves credibility through gatekeeping. Aletheia achieves credibility through transparency. All the reviews are public. You can read the papers and reviews yourself to make up your own mind about paper quality. 7/14
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Who should use Aletheia? There are multiple use cases. It’s a great platform for getting feedback on papers, particularly for scholars not at R1s in the networks of the seminar circuit. You may be even to send the package to editors for submission later. 8/14
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you are a supporter of open science, or are interested in new models of academic publishing, please retweet this thread. It would help get Aletheia off the ground. 13/14
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Tagging some folks who have posted about publishing, open science, research transparency, etc. in the past: @BrendanNyhan @JohnHolbein1 @AmandaMurdie @dandekadt @hjghassell @drsteveu 14/14
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Whenever I see this graph, I'm reminded that Super Mario Bros. 3 cost $50 (in 1990 dollars) when it came out. And Super Mario Odyssey cost $60 in 2017 dollars. I can't believe my parents spend so much money on that.
MikeCrespin
@MikeCrespin
I'm seeing a lot of responses to the student loan relief executive order putting blame on colleges and universities for costing too much. Lots of times this chart is given for evidence. I'll assume the underlying numbers are correct, but they don't tell the entire story.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One of Springer's business ideas was to use the "Nature" name to sell a bunch of adjacent journals to libraries. @ZaidJilani seems to conflate Nature with Nature Human Behavior. The consultants at Springer were quite smart I think!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Rorscach Test of professional baseball: Is it a feature or a bug that a game is so boring that the announcers can spend 10 minutes talking about something completely unrelated to the events at hand?
KNBR
@KNBR
Dave Flemming spent an entire half inning explaining Wordle to Jon Miller.
Here are the highlights:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Is Fetterman getting too close to the line: "This dude is not one of us." - Fetterman politicalwire.com/2022/08/17/quote-of-the-day-3299/
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
Reminder that two things can be true:
-Dr Oz is a charlatan running a deeply cynical & hilariously inept campaign
-We should be nervous about the appeal of running a "You're not from here" campaign against a Muslim whose family is from the Middle East & sentiments it could spark -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I generally agree with this, but even well-intentioned liberals look askance at you sometimes in Column A. "I'm from the Bay Area." "Oh, uh..., yeah."
Jake M. Grumbach
@JakeMGrumbach
Where are you from? Where are you from?
Cleveland Cleveland
Nice ✅ No where are you
really from?❌ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I don't think this is correct. Perot had a clear set of populist policy prescriptions orthogonal to the neoliberal trends of the two major parties. It laid the groundwork for America First taking over the GOP. Yang's party seems to have no policy ideas.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Robb Willer
@RobbWiller
🚨Results are in for the Strengthening Democracy Challenge. Winners will be announced this week!🚨
ITT we announce the 25 submissions we selected to test. We think these submissions are awesome & hope you do too.
But first, how we got here…👇🧵 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Chris Warshaw
@cwarshaw
It’s pretty clear that Trump was perceived as a moderate in 2016, which helped him beat Clinton. I think it’s under-appreciated that his more extreme stances today would probably hurt him in 2024.
Philip Rucker
@PhilipRucker
Trump has begun outlining a second-term agenda in his speeches. Here are six drastic plans. via @IArnsdorf
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/08/16/trump-speeches… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I recently responded to a telephone survey (I always participate given my use of survey data). I can totally understand why conservatives don't participate in these things, and the challenges of weighting and adjusting for non-response.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Will the carried interest loophole die within the next 20 years?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Gabriel S. Lenz
@GabeLenz
In recorded history, the public has never experienced a fall in their spending power like they have in the last year or so. We're even well below the trendline on spending power, as measured by RDI (income after taxes, transfers, and inflation). 1/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Very sad. I also mourn the loss of Nestle Alpine White chocolate bars and Jello 1-2-3. Unilever did bring back Vienetta though after a multi-year absence.
AP Fact Check
@APFactCheck
Twitter users are sharing a fabricated People magazine headline to spread the false claim that Klondike’s Choco Taco was discontinued due to "cultural appropriation" concerns. The outlet confirms the image is fake. Here are the facts. apne.ws/x2HmTFX
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
AP Fact Check
@APFactCheck
Twitter users are sharing a fabricated People magazine headline to spread the false claim that Klondike’s Choco Taco was discontinued due to "cultural appropriation" concerns. The outlet confirms the image is fake. Here are the facts. apne.ws/x2HmTFX
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Class actions are mainly about paying out the attorneys, then secondarily the class representative (who is a confederate of the attorneys), and lastly the class.
James McLeod
@jamespmcleod
Ok so Tim Hortons spent more than a year silently and illegally tracking users through their mobile app, and the proposed class action settlement is ... a free coffee and a donut.
I swear to fucking god. This is real. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Larry Summers being shut out of the Biden Administration but then being the most influential economist in American public policy was not on my bingo card.
Jonathan Chait
@jonathanchait
If you were certain last year that Larry Summers was obviously wrong and could only be trying to hurt Biden, you should be rethinking some things now nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/07/inflation-reduction-act-b…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jonathan Chait
@jonathanchait
If you were certain last year that Larry Summers was obviously wrong and could only be trying to hurt Biden, you should be rethinking some things now nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/07/inflation-reduction-act-b…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I once interviewed at a business school that didn't really hire political scientists. So I had a bunch of awkward interviews with finance, marketing, operations research, accounting folks. Their first question: "Oh, you're a political scientist. Do you know Howard Rosenthal?"
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Giants (best ballpark in MLB, public transportation, good team) at $39 is probably the best value in baseball. The A's (worst ballpark, bad team) at $33 is easily the worst.
Mark J. Burns
@markjburns88
$204.76: average cost for a family of 4 to attend a MLB game, via @TheHustle:
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dan Hopkins
@dhopkins1776
Since wolves seem to be on political scientists' minds, this may be of interest...
In 2012, I did a survey in Idaho and western Montana, asking about support for wolf hunting. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
People are comparing this to shark attacks but there is a very different logic. This paper is forwarding a rational economic voting story. As I have written about informally (and Ashworth et al. have formalized), voters can get signals from these sort of relevant events.
Josh McCrain
@joshmccrain
ALERT political scientists studying elections and partisanship, I've found another omitted variable for you
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2202224119 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In case people are interest, this is the paper from @dbroockman and myself that @jonathanchait cites on this: escholarship.org/uc/item/7gk9n3h8
Nick Riccardi
@NickRiccardi
Key insight from @jonathanchait on the ramifications of the new Democratic timidity on tax hikes for the rich nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/07/joe-manchin-didnt-kill-bi…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to exit polls, what percentage of the Asian/Latino vote will Republican House candidates get in 2022?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A general trend globally is that conservative elites are economically out of step with their voters, and liberal elites are socially out of step with their voters. Which one of these disconnects is more salient drives the political environment.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What do you think is more likely: (1) bad theory (the macroeconomy is just extremely complex); or (2) bad empirics (our data cannot measure these constructs well and we are being misled)?
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
If you're not a little confused about the economy you're not paying attention. Three of many historically large disconnects in the data:
1. Jobs growing & GDP contracting
2. Price growth rising & wage growth falling
3. Consumer sentiment plummeting & consumer spending rising -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's only one poll, but this is absolutely insane. Many talked about racial depolarization as a key to preserving institutions. Does it matter that it is replaced with educational/geographic polarization?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Across 21 countries, the left has lost most support among low education, high income voters. Left gained most among high education, high income votes, but only reached parity there. So left support is now concentrated among high education low income voters
journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/00323292221100220?ca… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Does anybody else find it weirdly incestuous, and emblematic of multigenerational privilege, that the Court ruled in favor of Neil Gorsuch's mother in Chevron (1984)?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The American public was very closely divided on this (like many cases), but in this instance, the Court went with the liberal position. 49% of Americans agreed with the Court's decision (77% of Ds, 20% of Rs, 44% of Is)
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
The Supreme Court ALLOWS the Biden administration to terminate the controversial Trump-era asylum policy known as "remain in Mexico." Red states argued that Biden was obliged to keep the policy, but SCOTUS says in a 5-4 ruling that the administration can end it.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to #scotuspoll, the American public disagreed with this decision. 59% of the public believes the EPA can regulate emissions across the entire sector (not just individual plants). The partisan breakdown: 73% of Ds, 47% of Rs, 55% of Is. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/2022-survey-results
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
The Supreme Court sharply curtails the authority of the EPA to regulate greenhouse-gas emissions that cause climate change. In a 6-3 ruling, the court sides with conservative states and fossil-fuel companies in adopting a narrow reading of the Clean Air Act.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
66% of Americans AGREED with this ruling allowing state prosecution of non-Natives on Native American reservations. Unlike many cases this term, there was little partisan disagreement (68% Ds; 70% Rs; 63% Is). projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol…
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
The Supreme Court rules that states CAN prosecute crimes against Native American victims committed on Native American reservations if the defendant is non-Native. The decision limits the scope of the 2020 ruling in McGirt v. Oklahoma (which involved a Native American defendant).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Unknown but great article on FDR court packing: spia.uga.edu/faculty_pages/carson/pc02_ck.pdf
2/5/37: FDR announces extreme plan
2/10/37, 2/26/37: House and Senate pass moderate plan on Supreme Court pensions (76-4 vote in Senate)
3/29/37: Roberts switches in W. Coast Hotel and the New Deal is saved
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Court packing failure happened *after* it accomplished its objective: the switch in time that saved nine.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Liberals on twitter (and other elite circles) should think hard about whether they think the Court's function is to reflect public opinion (majoritarianism). School prayer is very popular in polling and affirmative action is very unpopular. www.nytimes.com/2022/06/27/briefing/supreme-court-abortio…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
56% of Americans agreed with the Court's decision that the high school was wrong to suspend the praying coach (74% of Rs; 59% of Is; 38%s of Ds). #scotuspoll asks about less-salient cases like these as well projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol…
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
SCOTUS sides with a high school football coach in a First Amendment case about prayer at the 50-yard-line. In a 6-3 ruling, SCOTUS says the public school district violated the coach's free speech and free exercise rights when it barred him from praying on the field after games.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
As a preview for the EPA case coming out next week, 59% of the public believes the EPA can regulate emissions across the entire sector (not just individual plants). The partisan breakdown: 73% of Ds, 47% of Rs, 55% of Is. projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Democratic donors are much more pro-choice than Democratic voters, whereas Republican donors match their voters’ abortion positions
calgara.github.io/PolS5310_Spring2021/Broockman & Malhort… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
CBS News finds *post*-decision that 59% of Americans disagree with overturning Roe. Our #scotuspoll survey showed *pre*-decision that 60% of Americans disagreed. Few data points, but not much evidence so far for Supreme Court persuasion. www.cbsnews.com/news/americans-react-to-roe-v-wade-overtu…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Although it's intellectually correct, all this piling on RBG just rubs me the wrong way. People leave complicated legacies that are not one-sided. Ralph Nader saved thousands of people from car crashes; his actions also led to thousands of deaths in war.
Julia Ioffe
@juliaioffe
I would like, one more time, to thank all the RBG fangirls out there and all the RBG merch you all bought. Hope it brings you comfort today.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When John Yoo said the same thing a few years ago, many "small-l" liberals (rightfully) pushed back. This kind of thinking gets you "saving" and "redeeming." It also gets you suspending habeas corpus, and putting racial minorities in concentration camps.
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
Our two greatest presidents - Lincoln and FDR - were great precisely because they both recognized there’s something precious and worth fighting for in America’s institutions, but that saving and redeeming those institutions sometimes requires truly radical action.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Kathleen Dolan
@KathyDMKE
Maybe @BarackObama and the 111th Congress shouldn't have slept on codifying Roe back when they had unified government and a filibuster-proof majority. Can't do two big things at once in this country, clearly.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What's sad about today is that oppressed minorities (race, sexual orientation, etc.) have often appealed to the Supreme Court because there is nowhere else in the democratic system. If the Supreme Court loses its legitimacy, where will minorities go to ensure their civil rights?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One month ago, we published this paper in @PNASNews showing that in 2010 (Kennedy median) and 2020 (Roberts median) the Court's decisions were close to public opinion. In 2021, when the median shifted to Kennedy, the Court drifted markedly right. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2120284119 1/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It seems like 2022 is showing the same trend. Whereas Roberts and Kennedy were very concerned with balancing opinions and keeping the Court in step with public opinion, this does not seem to be the case with the Kavanaugh court. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to our #scotuspoll survey, 62% of Americans disagreed with the Court's decision to overturn Roe (including 41% of Rs). On the other hand, 49% of Americans agreed that MS's 15-wk law was constitutional. projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol… 1/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Court's decision strongly goes against public opinion. Robert's preferred choice (to keep the MS law but not overturn roe) is very close to the preference to the median voter. 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This shows that the Court has undergone a major shift since the median changed from Roberts to Kavanaugh, suggesting that the replacement of RBG can be directly linked to the overturning of Roe. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Results from #scotuspoll on the 6-3 gun control decision announced today. Like many of the Supreme Court issues before the term, the public is divided 50-50, but if the Court takes a systematically conservative direction, it will end up to the right of the public. 1/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Our ideal point estimates for 2022 will be released toward the end of the summer, so we can compare the public to the Court. 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In 2010 (Kennedy median) and 2020 (Roberts median), the Court was very close to the median voter. In 2021 (Kavanaugh median), it shifted right. We will see if that trend continues. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Suppose that there was a right to access a public gym in America. In some rural places the government couldn't efficiently operate a public gym but gave people gym vouchers. Could they use the voucher to go to YMCA or JCC or would they have to go to 24 Hour Fitness?
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Many people tweeting about this case don't really understand what it was about. The issue was that in rural ME there are not public schools to serve students so the state gives them vouchers. It's not "all over Maine." The question is whether this is a slippery slope.
Wajahat Ali
@WajahatAli
Private Islamic schools and Jewish schools should open up all over Maine. The state has to fund you now so take advantage of it. Move your communities there as well. Let's see what the Supreme Court says...
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Many people tweeting about this case don't really understand what it was about. The issue was that in rural ME there are not public schools to serve students so the state gives them vouchers. It's not "all over Maine." The question is whether this is a slippery slope.
Wajahat Ali
@WajahatAli
Private Islamic schools and Jewish schools should open up all over Maine. The state has to fund you now so take advantage of it. Move your communities there as well. Let's see what the Supreme Court says...
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
For the last few years, I have been running the #scotuspoll project with @maya_sen and Stephen Jessee, tracking public opinion on issues before the Supreme Court before they are decided. See @nytimes coverage of #scotuspoll out today: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/06/21/us/major-supreme-c… 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
You can learn more about #scotuspoll here: projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll And our open-access academic article on joint scaling of the views of the Court and the public is available at @PNASNews : www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2120284119 Data for 2020-2021 is available for download 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Today, the Supreme Court rejected Maine's ban on providing tuition assistance for religious schools on the standard 6-3 vote. The public was very divided on this: 49% agreed with the Court's decision (32% of Ds; 50% of Is; 68% of Rs). 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'll be posting more on other recently-decided issues. Many of these don't receive a lot of media coverage. And, of course, stay tuned for upcoming decisions on abortion and gun control. 4/4
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The two most popular answers are journalists and professors. How much do you think the red state turn against academia is directly the result of social media activity that is generally unrepresentative of academia? 1/2
Jake Anbinder
@JakeAnbinder
What profession has lost the most prestige as a result of its members having access to twitter?
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Prior to twitter, red state politicians seemed to begrudgingly accept the tradeoff between humanities/social science against STEM/business/medicine and the economic gains of having good universities in your state.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Flores (Mexico) becomes the fifth Republican foreign-born naturalized citizen in Congress (Democrats have 9), joining Kim and Steele (Korea), Spartz (Ukraine), and Gimenez (Cuba).
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
I've seen enough: Mayra Flores (R) defeats Dan Sanchez (D) in the #tx34 special election, flipping an 84% Hispanic Rio Grande Valley seat red.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Many people comment on how the Dem. Party has to deal with a complex coalition. I don't think the GOP has a real governing plan for a party composed of business elites, Evangelicals, the secular Rogan tech bro, Hispanics/Asians, and working class whites.
Sean T at RCP
@SeanTrende
This is sort of how I felt seeing some of the shifts in Appalachia in 2010, or blue collar areas in 2016. Except this I genuinely didn't think I'd see for another 20 years or so. Just astonishing.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Income and education are not perfectly correlated. Many people who make more than $100k are swinging hammers. And many people who make under $50k have PhDs and don't swing hammers. Key insight of recent poli sci research that would be good for adjacent fields (history) to know.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Has anybody seen any data on whether covid hawks in the Biden base will punish him for loosening restrictions (i.e., not turning out in 2022)? It does not seem obvious that Biden is making the correct electoral play, even though the median voter is clearly a covid dove.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Finally getting some long Covid data after 2 years. Thanks to the scientists who did this. Very good news about low prevalence of long covid (given current wave), but as always, more data and replication needed.
Adam Gaffney
@awgaffney
An important new study is out. Baseline findings from the NIH's longitudinal, intramural Long COVID study — perhaps the most detailed, controlled, comprehensive investigation of multiple health metrics in this setting thus far conducted — were just published in @AnnalsIM
A🧵
1/ -
Neil Malhotra reposted
American Political Science Review
@apsrjournal
What is the relationship between government assistance and political attitudes? Check out this article by @SarahAnzia, @JakeJares and @namalhotra, now in #apsrfirstview. #apsr #polisciresearch
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
For people concerned about research budgets (e.g., grad students, others), there is a lot of freely available, *unpublished* data sitting around the Internet in the public commons: www.tessexperiments.org www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1255484
Nick Jacobson
@NC_Jacobson
Open Science Poll
For research purposes (e.g., publishing an article), if a de-identified dataset is posted publicly (e.g., osf), one can use the data: -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I know I'm two years too late, but "The Last of Us 2" was amazing and the people that review bombed it are lame.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Business elites (who know a lot about business and not much about democratic theory) are gen. pro-Musk. Academic/media elites (who know a lot about democracy but not much about business) are anti-Musk. Is there anybody who is expert in both business/investing and soc. science?
benahorowitz.eth
@bhorowitz
2/We invested, because we believe in Ev and Jack’s vision to connect the world and we believe in Elon’s brilliance to finally make it what it was meant to be.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One of the best (and relatively unknown papers on this) is this amazing field experiment by @PoliPsyProf / Krosnick: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1467-9221.2004.…
Lee Drutman ⚙️🏛
@leedrutman
The real winner today? Democratic party fundraising efforts.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Much of the Twitter debate over the last few days has conflated *public* politics with what Dave Baron introduced and called *private* politics. Highly recommend reading about it: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1430-9134.2003.…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We unfortunately don't have NOMINATE scores for private politics really, but would be a game-changing dissertation.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Interesting Pew survey. The groups most against legacy admissions are whites and Republicans. 59% of black respondents and 62% of Democrats are against the use of race as a factor in college admissions. Consistent with '20 CA ballot initiative.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The issue that divides these two parts of the elite left is support for government regulation and intervention in the economy (and explains why attitudes toward figures like Musk or Elizabeth Warren divide the left): onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ajps.12408
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Tech bro culture and academic/media culture compete for cultural hegemony in liberal spaces (emphatically including Twitter!) and he has all the markers of tech bro culture.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sarah Anzia
@SarahAnzia
So pleased to share this new article coauthored with the amazing @JakeJares and @namalhotra. We examine the political attitudes of beneficiaries of government programs that reach a more conservative, rural population than those usually focused on in policy feedback research.
Cambridge University Press - Politics
@CUP_PoliSci
#firstview from @apsrjournal -
Does Receiving Government Assistance Shape Political Attitudes? Evidence from Agricultural Producers - www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
- @SarahAnzia, JAKE ALTON JARES (@Stanford) & @namalhotra -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Very happy to share this new paper, written with the fabulous @SarahAnzia and @JakeJares (amazing grad student you should keep your eye on!). We conducted an original survey leveraging administrative data on U.S. farmers to explore mechanisms of policy feedback. 1/2
Cambridge University Press - Politics
@CUP_PoliSci
#firstview from @apsrjournal -
Does Receiving Government Assistance Shape Political Attitudes? Evidence from Agricultural Producers - www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
- @SarahAnzia, JAKE ALTON JARES (@Stanford) & @namalhotra
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Hope it is of interest to scholars of policymaking, policy feedback, political behavior, rural politics, public opinion. Also, such a wonderful experience with the @apsrjournal team. An extremely professionally run, efficient journal. 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Particular shoutout to Dragana Svraka for her amazing help throughout the process! 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Cambridge University Press - Politics
@CUP_PoliSci
#firstview from @apsrjournal -
Does Receiving Government Assistance Shape Political Attitudes? Evidence from Agricultural Producers - www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-scienc…
- @SarahAnzia, JAKE ALTON JARES (@Stanford) & @namalhotra -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Obamacare exchanges did not open until late-2013. If you have a theory about the electoral effects of "delivered direct benefits," you need to be careful about coding when the benefits are actually delivered.
Nicholas Grossman
@NGrossman81
Obama was popular with young voters, and in 2010 passed a big healthcare reform, his biggest promise as a candidate, which delivered direct benefits to young people.
In that year’s midterms, the GOP won big.
I think some of your theories of what decides midterms may need revising -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When I'm asked by journalists why Asian American voters moved to the Republicans in 2010/2014/2022? "Um, they're voters."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
FYI, I think there's a lot of easy papers to be written expanding/revising/refining traditional theories/models of "expressive political donations."
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Yes, but I think the actual written down version of expressive theory is stronger than that since a donor with a fixed budget constraint would be looking at *all* the races in the country and allocating.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Yes, but I think the actual written down version of expressive theory is stronger than that since a donor with a fixed budget constraint would be looking at *all* the races in the country and allocating.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jonathan Robinson
@jon_m_rob
I see we’re doing this again. Doesn’t seem like the worst idea if the funding for it doesn’t lapse in the future (which would cause confusion), but I’d probably do other things first before this
www.reuters.com/world/us/biden-proposes-15-bln-election-f…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Not many people know about this paper, but it's very relevant now to states moving to pre-paid postage. Our main takeaway is that disruptions to routines/habits can adversely affect turnout, and that policy changes need to be made clear and explicit to voters.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Three of the four "public" high schools: Miami Palmetto, Hunter College High, and Lowell.
Aya Gruber
@ayagruber
The first line is the most telling. Alito is the only conservative justice who attended public school, and Sotomayor is the only liberal justice who attended private school.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm very happy to announce the publication of a new book with Cambridge University Press that I wrote with Ken Shotts, political economist extraordinaire, on leadership and values, based on the course we have taught for the last decade: www.cambridge.org/us/academic/subjects/management/busines… 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Here's a short YouTube video on some key takeaways: youtu.be/bB98b_O9-XY 4/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
And we just recorded a podcast with Matt Abrahams on the book: www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/leadership-ethics-how-commu… 5/5
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Thanks to @SSIReview for making an excerpt from "Frontiers in Social Innovation" available. Check out this piece from Paul Brest & Colleen Honigsberg of Stanford Law School on ESG measurement.
Stanford Social Innovation Review
@SSIReview
“The field of impact measurement is often characterized by hand waving & greenwashing.” Paul Brest & Colleen Honigsberg (@StanfordLaw) lay out solutions for better impact metrics in an excerpt from “Frontiers in Social Innovation” @namalhotra @StanfordGSB. ssir.org/books/excerpts/entry/you_cant_manage_what_you_ca…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Stanford Social Innovation Review
@SSIReview
“The field of impact measurement is often characterized by hand waving & greenwashing.” Paul Brest & Colleen Honigsberg (@StanfordLaw) lay out solutions for better impact metrics in an excerpt from “Frontiers in Social Innovation” @namalhotra @StanfordGSB. ssir.org/books/excerpts/entry/you_cant_manage_what_you_ca…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm happy to announce the publication of "Frontiers in Social Innovation," my edited volume from Harvard Business Review bringing together thought leaders from nonprofits, philanthropy, impact investing, and social entrepreneurship. 1/3
Harvard Business Review
@HarvardBiz
The world’s most complex issues require creative solutions. Frontiers in Social Innovation is your handbook for making the world a better place.
www.amazon.com/Frontiers-Social-Innovation-Essential-Sust…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is a terrific resource for anyone interested in using the power of enterprise to make a social impact. For political scientists, many of our students go into the social sector (e.g., nonprofits, etc.), and this book will equip them with the frameworks... 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
and tools needed in the space (e.g., theory of change, logic models, additionality). Also great for those seeking alternative academic careers where social science knowledge can help address social problems. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Bernadette
@Bernadette
Introducing "Frontiers in #socialinnovation", the Center for Social Innovation's first ever handbook to bring the essence of the @StanfordGSB #impact curriculum to the world's #changemakers!
#socialentrepreneurship #impactinvesting #socialchange
www.gsb.stanford.edu/faculty-research/books/frontiers-soc… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I hope people understand how much life changed for people of South Asian and Middle Eastern descent after 9/11, and the systemic racism and discrimination they have faced over the last 20 years.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Political Economy group at the Stanford GSB is hiring (open rank). PE scholars from a wide range of disciplines (political science; economics; management; public policy; etc.) are encouraged to apply. www.gsb.stanford.edu/jobs/faculty-recruiting/political-ec…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is a totally false slur. This professor was not involved with CA. You can just say anything on this site.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I edited this paper. I thought it was a good experiment. Back-and-forth replications often read like two lawyers arguing that leave readers confused. This approach tries to encourage replication, pre hoc theorizing, and scientific consensus.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Interesting approach to replication @The_JOP.
Article 1: there's a relationship between X (LGB population) and Y (bills advancing gay rights).
Submitted replication: there's no relationship.
Editors to both authors: team up and do a multiverse analysis.
Thoughts on this? -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Governor Kathy Hochul
@GovKathyHochul
Why waste a perfectly good jacket? 🤷
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The two biggest lessons from the AIDS epidemic: (1) encourage safety and risk reduction (condoms, testing); (2) abstinence-only mandates are ineffective and counterproductive.
Kimberley Johnson
@AuthorKimberley
When AIDS was a bigger threat, how many parents encouraged their offspring to have unprotected sex because condoms were an infringement on their sexual liberty?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Interesting story from the world of opt-in samples. Prolific went viral on Tik Tok. The sample became 80% female, and the average age is 21.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Every week the number of children who die in car accidents is equivalent to two Sandy Hooks. Please be careful: (1) wear masks / get vax; (2) don't text and drive; (3) avoid highways as much as possible; (4) don't drive after it gets dark and when you're tired (9 pm) if possible
Obi Wan Cannoli
@ObiWanCannoli10
A 0.03% mortality rate amongst children may sound good, but what it really means in a nation of nearly 60 million largely unvaccinated children is that we’re gonna see a Sandy Hook and a Parkland every week in the US as COVID rips through our schools.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Only one member of Congress (out of 535) voted against the Afghanistan War resolution in 2001: Barbara Lee of Oakland/East Bay
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This was cool, you should try it.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Very proud of @jkwillenbring! She was featured yesterday on PBS News Hour with Judy Woodruff. Starts at 50:20 here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uSTPcAFBM74
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I have noticed this too recently, and similar thing happened in poli sci after the Brambor et al. interactions terms article came out. I often had to put pre-emptive footnote in paper: "This term is not included in the model, because with fixed effects, it drops out..." etc.
Analisa Packham
@analisapackham
referees who keep suggesting Calloway and Sant'Anna (2019) and Goodman-Bacon (2019) when the treatment happens to everyone in the same year:
plz stop it -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Congrats to @jkwillenbring , who will be featured on @PBS @NewsHour soon!
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
I ❤️ the #briefbutspectacular segment on @NewsHour on @PBS and I got to do one about harassment in STEM. Check it out! It’ll be on the @NewsHour sometime soon. #metoo
Steve Goldbloom
@stevegoldbloom
"He told me, if I said anything about it, that I would never have a job again in science."
Jane Willenbring offers this courageous #briefbutspectacular on being sexually harassed in the field. And in doing so, she's created a space for others to speak up as well. #womeninstemThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
As Amir Sufi explains here, the problem is not that billionaires spend a tiny bit of their money on ridiculous stuff (although that fuels populist outrage). It’s that billionaires don’t spend (ie *hoard*) assets. review.chicagobooth.edu/economics/2021/article/how-1-perc…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If, as expected, Biden appoints Kentaji Brown Jackson to replace Breyer, over the last 55 years, Democratic presidents will have appointed one white male (out of 6 appts) vs. Republican presidents appointing 12 white males (out of 15 appts).
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
*Ketanji
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Suns could be the first non-CA non-TX Western Conference team to win the NBA Finals in over 40 years. cc: @RobertNLupton @jaj7d
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The last Western conference team not from CA or TX to win the NBA championship was the Sonics in 1979. Will this be the year?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to #scotuspoll, the majority of Americans DISAGREED with this decision on donor disclosure. 60% thought the disclosure rules were lawful (74% of Ds; 44% of Rs; 61% of Is).
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
In its second ruling of the day (and final opinion of the term), SCOTUS rules in favor of two groups that brought a First Amendment challenge to a California policy requiring nonprofits and charities operating in the state to provide the state with a list of their largest donors.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This was probably the most divided issue in our #scotuspoll data with big partisan divisions. On the provisional ballot discarding, 51% thought it was unlawful (67% of Ds, 35% of Rs, 44% of Is). On "ballot harvesting" 50% thought it was OK (70% of Ds, 27% of Rs, 46% of Is).
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
BREAKING NEWS: Supreme Court issues ruling in Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee, major voting-rights case out of Arizona. www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-1257_g204.pdf
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This was a very important decision and I see little to no coverage/discussion of it. Apparently a broad interpretation of the “takings” clause.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to #scotuspoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee), 52% of Americans agreed with this anti-union decision with strong partisan divisions (69% of Rs agreed; 35% of Ds; 54% of Is).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Court sort of punted this but according to #scotuspoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee), 52% of Americans thought that police should not be able to enter someone's home without a warrant after hot pursuit (60% of Ds; 43% of Rs; 50% of Is).
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
The Supreme Court issues its opinion in the "hot pursuit" case -- a case about when police can follow a fleeing suspect into a home without a warrant. In an opinion by Kagan, the court declines to adopt a bright-line rule on "hot pursuits" of people suspected of misdemeanors.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to #scotuspoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee), 55% of Americans DISagreed with this pro-executive decision with small partisan divisions (59% of Ds disagreed; 49% of Rs; 56% of Is).
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
In the second Supreme Court opinion of the day, the court holds that the structure of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (which regulates Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac) is unconstitutional because of the limits on the president's ability to remove the agency's director.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to #scotuspoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee), 52% of Americans agreed with this anti-union decision with strong partisan divisions (69% of Rs agreed; 35% of Ds; 54% of Is).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to #scotuspoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee), a bipartisan majority of Americans agreed with this decision upholding students' free speech rights (71% of Americans; 64% of Ds; 78% of Rs; 72% of Is).
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
BREAKING: In major First Amendment case on student speech, the Supreme Court rules 8-1 in favor of a former high school student who was disciplined by her public school after sending a vulgar message on Snapchat complaining about the school's cheerleading squad.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to our (@maya_sen @stephenjessee) #scotuspoll, the public was evenly divided (50%-50%) on this issue. Some partisan division. 60% of Rs believed NCAA can restrict compensation, 42% of Ds, and 51% of Is.
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
NEW: In a victory for college athletes, SCOTUS unanimously invalidates a portion of the NCAA's "amateurism" rules. The court says the NCAA can no longer bar colleges from providing athletes with education-related benefits such as free laptops or paid post-graduate internships.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Very cogent and well-written thread. Suggests the response of "But that's not what CRT actually is"/"Can you actually define CRT as in the academic literature?" is likely to be strategically ineffective.
Omar Wasow | @owasow@bsky.social
@owasow
The current panic over ”critical race theory” is mostly an elite project of think tanks, elected officials and media figures to gin-up fear. That said, it’s also useful to consider why there’s an appetite for anti-”CRT” in part of the mass public.👇🏽
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
An important lesson that political science professors can communicate to their students. A common misconception by many is that American democracy is automatic and inevitable.
kirby goidel
@Polling_Station
Joe Biden: “what I got taught by my political science professors and by the senior members of the Senate that I admired when I got there — that every generation has to reestablish the basis of its fight for democracy.”
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Court rules in favor of Obamacare based on an issue of standing. In our #scotuspoll survey, 56% of Americans believed the mandate is unconstitutional, but 53% of Americans believe the rest of the law should stand.
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
BREAKING: The Supreme Court rejects the constitutional challenge to Obamacare in 7-2 opinion. The court tosses the lawsuit because the challengers do not have legal standing to sue. www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-840_6jfm.pdf
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Supreme Court unanimously rules in favor of a Catholic agency that refused to certify same-sex couples for fostering. According to our #scotuspoll, 52% of Americans agreed with this opinion (65% of Rs, 57% of Is, 39% of Ds).
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
BREAKING: The court rules in favor of a Catholic social services organization that sued Philadelphia after the city excluded it from a foster-care program due to the organization's refusal to certify same-sex couples as foster parents. www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-123_g3bi.pdf
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is incorrect. Political philosophers have debated extensively about what constitutes the “general will” (see Rousseau eg). It’s not just “50% + 1.” The twitterless Keith Krehbiel has a great formal theory paper on this topic.
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Another paper by Michael peress above. As people who have been involved in faculty hiring (or any collective decision making know), majoritarianism attempts to balance many things when deciding changed from status quo: consensus, timeliness, continuation value, etc.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Even more amazed by Serena Williams’ many slams given that she had to play 3 set matches and not 5 set matches. Elite players can be beaten in 3 sets, much harder in 5 sets.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
“Breath of the Wild” is like “Hamilton.” Even if you don’t like musicals/video games, it’s a work of art all humans should experience. Many consider it to be the greatest video game ever made. It’s worth getting a Switch for this game alone.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Cool paper on "FoLLoW tHe SCienCe"(tm)
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
In 3 preregistered experiments (N = 644) conducted across two continents, people were more likely to believe #science when its conclusions aligned with their identity--because it made them feel good about themselves.
A de-biasing intervention failed: journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1368430221996818?jou… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When I have attending weddings, I have often donned clothing on my face/body/head to be respectful of the cultural/religious context. I’ve abstained from eating pork/beef/etc at meals. And it’s not a big deal, it’s OK to follow social cues.
Josh Marshall
@joshtpm
This is Scott Gottlieb, Trump's FDA commissioner until 2019 with the best, low drama, high empathy explanation of why he still wears a mask.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Supreme Court (with a mixed ideological majority) went strongly AGAINST public opinion here. From our #scotuspoll, 68% of Americans thought law enforcement should have been punished. There was NO partisan divide (68% of Ds, 67% of Rs, 69% of Is). 1/2
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
NEW: SCOTUS adopts narrow reading of a key phrase in the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (specifically, the definition of "exceed authorized access" on a computer). Court tosses the conviction of a police officer who searched an official police database for personal purposes.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Continue to follow along with #scotuspoll at @nytimes as more of these major cases are decided: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/06/01/us/major-supreme-c… 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Results from 2021 SCOTUSPoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee are now out. Thanks to @nytimes for the coverage! As the decisions come out in June, you can follow along and compare them to people's views on the issues. 1/2
Adam Liptak
@adamliptak
As the Supreme Court enters the term’s homestretch, here’s a cheat sheet of cases to watch along with public opinion data, with @aliciaparlap
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/06/01/us/major-supreme-c…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
So far, the Court's decisions mapped on to the divided public on COVID restrictions. The Court issued a ruling much more conservative than the public's view on juvenile sentencing. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I have a forthcoming book on ethics/values, and my perception is that the main debates are not about things like tax rates or gay marriage. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Rather, things like: (1) the complex relationship between equality of opportunity and equality of outcome; (2) color blindness vs. color consciousness; (3) the mismatch hypothesis; (4) the relative weight of individual vs. structural factors/variables 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My take is that even if some of these conservative/centrist ideas (e.g., less focus on equality of outcome, color blindness, individual factors, etc.) end up being "wrong," the university should be one of the institutions where we can debate them. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Why do people care so much about things that don’t affect them? Many rituals and cultural traditions stem from crises and public health issues. If certain societies are grappling with ritual in the wake of crisis and trauma, let them.
Steven Bacio 🚀
@sbuss
The weirdest phenomenon in San Francisco right now is people dining indoors without masks, then putting their masks on when they leave and keeping them on while walking around outside. I'd love to understand what's going on in their brains.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Great thread. Key takeaway: public universities are owned by the people of those states, not the faculty. For academics who say we should not engage with the political right, are you willing to throw your colleagues who teach in public schools in red/purple states under the bus?
Lindsay Ellis
@lindsayaellis
A thread: I can’t stop thinking about Nikole Hannah-Jones’s tenure denial. It appears to show the natural endpoint of politicized college governance at public universities, a topic @jackstripling @danbauman77 and I dug into for @chronicle here: www.chronicle.com/article/the-new-order
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Welcome to the new members of the Academic Freedom Alliance, including some great political scientists. The events of the last week have hopefully created newfound energy for a cross-ideological coalition to protect academic freedom. academicfreedom.org/members/
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I agree with the broader thread but this is not true for business schools. Since the transition to management science, the terminal degree in business fields (accounting, marketing, op research, economics, org behavior) is a PhD.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In the most recent #scotuspoll, we found that court expansion was generally unpopular (32% support including only 53% support among Dems) whereas term limits were more popular (51% support including 43% support among Reps).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Universities are sort of company towns. A big portion of my graduate student stipend went back to the university as rent, health insurance premiums, and eating at on campus cafes.
Associate Deans
@ass_deans
Good news! We decided to start our own cryptocurrency. We will now pay all faculty salaries in our university currency, redeemable at the food court, bodega, and book store! Just wait until ucoin catches on!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The problem is that the true policy solutions---true integration of schools and neighborhoods, inclusive zoning/housing---are absolutely unacceptable to the wealthy liberal elite.
Elizabeth Nolan Brown
@ENBrown
“Trying to fight educational inequality by getting rid of the SAT is like trying to fight climate change by getting rid of thermometers.” freddiedeboer.substack.com/p/you-arent-actually-mad-at-th…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Has anyone’s public reputation had more ups and downs than Bill Gates? Even including presidents (Nixon, Carter, W, Clintons)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My preregistered prediction: Brett Kavanaugh will be the deciding vote to save Roe v. Wade.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'd like to introduce you to one of the most important yet unknown people in history: Inky Clark, who was Yale's director for admissions in the late 1960s. A thread. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
He left behind a complex legacy. He was involved in a horrific sexual abuse scandal at Horace Mann. But he was also instrumental in changing the way elite universities handled admissions. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Before Inky took over, Yale basically just admitted elite prep school kids from the Northeast, many of whom were academically mediocre. They also used "character" and "personality" as code words to exclude Jews, racial minorities, etc. 3/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
As you might expect, the Yale alumni and trustees were livid. But Inky and Brewster held firm. Because they believed that attracting the best students from around the country---and the world---was more important that protecting an elite incumbent class. 8/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Pretty soon, many of Yale's peers copied this approach, and made their classes more diverse and with higher quality students. 9/9.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This appears to be a joke. He means “political science” like Saul Goodman means “criminal lawyer.”
Warren Davidson 🇺🇸
@WarrenDavidson
Eventually science defeats political science...
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
“We accept the reality of the world with which we're presented. It's as simple as that.” - “The Truman Show” (1998)
Steven Ross Pomeroy
@SteRoPo
Is wine-tasting BS? In a now infamous study, researchers dyed a white wine red and gave it to 54 oenology (wine science) students. The supposedly expert panel overwhelmingly described the beverage like they would a red wine. They were completely fooled. www.realclearscience.com/blog/2014/08/the_most_infamous_s…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Very nice to see the papers I edited at @The_JOP finally coming out in print!
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
New @mvinaes in JOP: evidence that voters "take personal responsibility for positive changes in personal welfare and hold the government responsible for negative changes"
static1.squarespace.com/static/5fb3974fee5f4e6e91c1fef1/t… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
That this happened and the 2020 election was not a blowout in the electoral college should be concerning for the Democratic Party.
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Turnout was up substantially in 2020, especially among younger voters
New Catalist estimates:
catalist.us/wh-national/ -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
As NY state politics experts would tell you this is unlikely, but there have been cases where redistricting targeted members in leadership: David Bonior (MI) and Martin Frost (TX) come to mind.
Matthew Chapman
@fawfulfan
I wonder if Republicans have given any thought to the fact that Elise Stefanik is in a congressional district New York Democrats could wipe out at the stroke of a pen.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Swensen is one of the most unknown yet important historical figures. Completely revolutionized how nonprofits/foundations/endowments managed their money. Also probably took 1% of the salary he could have made in the private sector because he believed in the mission.
Judy Chevalier
@judy_chevalier
So sad for Yale and the world to lose David Swensen. I had the privilege of working in his office for most of my time as an undergraduate and every summer in the mid-80s. I took his investments class the first year he taught it as endowment manager. A really warm human being.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Wow feeling very old. AOL and Yahoo, two dominant tech brands from my youth, just sold for a paltry $5B combined, about 7% of the market cap of Snapchat. finance.yahoo.com/news/apollo-acquire-verizons-media-asse…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jonah Goldberg
@JonahDispatch
I have no skin in this game. But I'm just loving how this tweet has generated a lot of shade from poli-sci nerds.
Sam Wang is at samwang.bsky.social
@SamWangPhD
New from me and @ari_gold_helz - we show that the filibuster rule creates a Zone of Legislative Death, from which no bills can emerge. Historical evidence suggests that as long as we have the rule and remain polarized, we are doomed: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/04/zone-legislativ…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In other news, they are remaking “The Truman Show” (1998)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Is it just me or is this argument really poor and unrigorous? It’s like the trolls who criticize people seeking police reform by saying “Then don’t call the police when you’re being robbed.” Big Tech is open to criticism and you can use your iPhone to do it.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Per Kitchelt and Rehm, the core base of the Democratic Party is high education but low income. This is not the Democratic Party that made James Carville a star and he knows it.
Anthony Michael Kreis, FRHistS
@AnthonyMKreis
Can we all stop listening to James Carville and acknowledge thar the era for his brand of Democratic Party politics is over?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Tamar Haspel
@TamarHaspel
I'm no political scientist, but it seems to me that using the "faculty lounge" objection to ignore the substance of the criticism is an example of what Carville's talking about.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Savings bond? What was the second choice, a Bing Crosby cassette? Just give people a $20 visa gift card they can immediately take to Starbucks.
The Recount
@therecount
Gov. Jim Justice (R-WV) announces a new vaccine incentive program for residents 16 to 35:
“We’re going to give a $100 savings bond to every single one that steps up and takes their vaccine.” -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In case people are interested, Roy Elis, @mieuque (Marc Meredith), and I wrote this paper in 2009 on apportionment cycles as natural experiments: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/political-analysis/articl…
Nolan McCarty
@Nolan_Mc
Is 89 close enough for RDD? Asking for a friend
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Journal of Quantitative Description: Digital Media
@journalqd
❗️ Announcing Volume 1, the inaugural batch of articles in the Journal of Quantitative Description: Digital Media❗️
Thanks to our authors, reviewers, editorial staff and financial supporters who made this possible.
Read 18 open-access articles here!
journalqd.org/issue/view/214 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability
@stanforddoerr
“People have this idea that #asbestos is all covered up,” says @jkwillenbring. “But this is still a lingering legacy pollutant and might be dribbling out pollution,” that may increase the likelihood of exposure to the cancer-causing mineral. #mesothelioma stanford.io/3azzhFQ
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Supreme Court made it easier today to sentence juveniles to long terms. With @maya_sen and @stephenjessee, we have conducted the 2021 edition of #scotuspoll (coming soon). The vast majority of Americans (71%) DISagreed with the decision (77% of Ds; 64% of Rs; 69% of Ind).
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More info on case: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/supreme-court-…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Really excellent paper. Well deserved placement at a leading journal. Would be great to teach this alongside Orr/Huber in a seminar.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Pfizer charged $20/each for doses 1 and 2. They’ll charge $200 for dose 3.
Monica Gandhi MD, MPH
@MonicaGandhi9
Pfizer CEO said boosters may be needed. Unlikely
1) T cell immunity from vax (and Abs) work against variants; 2) T cells last long time- 34 y & counting after measles vax; 3) 1st SARS recovered have T cells 17 yr later; 4) Covid Vax generate memory B cells (lymph node biopsy) -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
“Would like to see a serious poli-sci analysis.” - man who does not follow the Poli sci literature
Paul Krugman
@paulkrugman
The difference from 2009, when Republicans managed to demonize everything Obama did, is amazing. Would like to see a serious poli-sci analysis. I can think of several stories 1/
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Is anyone concerned with how little legitimacy the CDC has right now? Basically, no interest group (teachers unions, airlines) cares what they think. Has it always been this way? www.businessinsider.com/airlines-reject-cdc-report-middle…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
As Rehm/Kitschelt have also shown, the core base of the GOP is white high-income but low-education. Do we consider these people "working class"?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Follow up hot take. We should rely on experts to provide us with facts. But how we translate those facts into *values* is the responsibility of all citizens in a democracy, not the experts. The experts need to better understand this and not conflate facts and values.
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
Hot take: Experts are neither always right nor always incompetent fools.
They (often) get things wrong. They are affected by incentives. Etc.
But they are typically not blithering idiots who are unable to grasp your armchair cost-benefit analysis. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The difficulty with covid is that there are multiple lanes: science/medicine, economics (cost/benefit), ethics (utilitarianism), psychology/communication (vaccine hesitancy). Unfortunately, nobody is an expert in all lanes (including CDC/FDA). People (like Fauci) cross lanes.
Dr. Danna Young🇺🇸✌🏻
@dannagal
WOW. There are a LOT of shitty takes on here from folks who they they are experts in ALL THINGs wrt the J&J news.
I never use this expression.. cause I'm a proponent of blendings and hybridity and all, BUT... in this instance: "Stay in your lane folks. Stay in your lane." -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
LOL. Neighbor reaction:
Gbenga Ajilore
@gbenga_ajilore
This is a new one. (cc: @graykimbrough)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There’s actually pretty limited evidence that mass consumers care about ethical issues (see Devinney et al’s “Myth of Ethical Consumer”). Rather, there are more elite groups of stakeholders the CEOs I have interacted with mention (elite workers, suppliers, investors).
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More on this (aka the airline industry is built on treating consumers like crap because non-FFs select on price — so it’s not consumers who are motivating)
AmyBee
@AmyBeePhoenix
Both Coca-Cola and Delta had significant external activist pressure to make statements.
Multiple pension fund representatives signed this letter and they have significant power as shareholders.
These are publicly funded pensions being used to implement a corporate agenda -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The modern ACLU is a *very* different organization than the one that argued NSPA v. Skokie in the 1970s. www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/the-disintegrati…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In the NCAA case, it seemed like the liberal justices (and liberal lawyer Seth Waxman) took the side of an ingroup (universities) over labor, while conservatives took the side of labor against an outgroup. And this will probably flip with other labor cases. Am I misunderstanding?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Joseph Allen
@j_g_allen
For a year, cases sadly perfectly predicted future hospitalizations and deaths
As highest risk are vaccinated, case counts will decouple from severe disease, becoming less reliable indicator of population risk
Going to take time to update our collective mental frame on this -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Yiqing Xu
@xuyiqing
A student asked me: What are the first things to check when conducting observational research in PoliSci? I compiled this super-basic 10-point checklist: yiqingxu.org/public/checklist.pdf. Hope it will be helpful.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is a cool paper, but so many people have been tweeting about relative risk today it’s always good to give the baselines. This 4.4x is from 0.7 citations to 3.1 citations.
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Twitter really does help academics! For 14 days, four random articles a day from leading heart journals were summarized in tweets by journal editors (with a total of 52k followers).
A year later, those articles had 4.4x more cites & 9.1x higher altmetric scores than the control. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
This is going on soon! I told my daughter I'm going to be talking to a bunch of people online soon and asked her how I look. She said "happy, nervous and a little tired"!
So true! 🤣
Scientific American
@sciam
Join us for a conversation on advancing diversity and inclusion in STEM, inspired by the award-winning documentary "Picture a Scientist."
Register to attend this virtual event: www.choice360.org/webinars/when-you-picture-a-scientist-w… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Can someone explain to me the difference between markets for NFTs and markets for art/baseball cards/collectibles? Because they seem exactly the same.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
“Did you just pay $1 million for a .jpeg?” “Did you just pay $1 million for a few dollars of oil paint on a $50 canvas?”
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Michael Li 李之樸
@mcpli
Re-upping this thread 🧵on the *long* history of discrimination and violence toward Asian Americans in the United States based on the sense that we are too foreign, too ‘other,’ too perpetually alien. It is important that people know this history.
Michael Li 李之樸
@mcpli
Today, May 6, is the anniversary of signing of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 into law - the first broad targeting of ethnic group in US immigration law (but not, alas, the last). 1/
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Interestingly, less than 1/2 of the coaches in the March Madness tournament even played Div I men's basketball; some didn't even play *high school* basketball. Seems like great coaches can come from very diverse backgrounds---race, gender, experience, etc. www.espn.com/mens-college-basketball/story/_/id/30930562/…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Reminds me of the great lesson from the movie "Ratatouille": Not everyone can cook, but a great cook can come from anywhere.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
At the age of 31, Taylor Swift tied Frank Sinatra, Paul Simon, and Stevie Wonder for most Album of the Year awards (3).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If I was an EU resident I would be livid. But tbh, in almost every Western society since March ‘20, leaders have not properly applied cost-benefit analysis, discounting, etc.
Johan Norberg
@johanknorberg
Why have I not been vaccinated yet? A short Q&A.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Well, looks like this is happening.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What is your prediction on whether Newsom faces recall?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The last Western conference team not from CA or TX to win the NBA championship was the Sonics in 1979. Will this be the year?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
David Shor's political analysis is setting the debate right now (agree with him or not).
So riddle me this: What did Civis Analytics gain by firing him for tweeting a peer-reviewed article by a leading academic (@owasow)? They lost a rock star and gained...what exactly? -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
David Shor's political analysis is setting the debate right now (agree with him or not).
So riddle me this: What did Civis Analytics gain by firing him for tweeting a peer-reviewed article by a leading academic (@owasow)? They lost a rock star and gained...what exactly? -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I booked a flight and cannot wait to buy a Cinnabon and pick up someone's discarded copy of USA Today.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Newman Nahas
@NahasNewman
Have ye not read what Ding did? How he entered into the Austrian house of Rona, and did eat of the schoolbread, which is not permitted unto Covidians and of which Ding had deprived the brethren?
Yet it was accounted righteousness unto him, for he is a Ding after Rona's heart🙏 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I am generally supportive of Biden's zero tolerance policy on collegiality in the White House, but Major deserved a second chance.
Jordan Fabian
@Jordanfabian
There’s a dog bed leaning against a wall outside the White House
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It would be nice if they reported confidence intervals in these tiny subgroup analyses.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jake Tapper 🦅
@jaketapper
That “CNN pundit” is Dr. Paul Offit, a widely-respected pediatrician specializing in infectious diseases, vaccines, immunology, and virology who just happens to be co-inventor of a rotavirus vaccine.
If you disagree, fine, but let’s frame these discussions honestly. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Annie Karni
@anniekarni
That makes sense.
What never made sense to me was Chris Cuomo covering him when things were going well for Andrew Cuomo.
Brian Stelter
@brianstelter
>> @ChrisCuomo at the top of @CuomoPrimeTime tonight: "Obviously I am aware of what is going on with my brother. And obviously I cannot cover it because he is my brother. Now, of course CNN has to cover it. They have covered it extensively and they will continue to do so."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
As many political scientists and political economists could tell you, politicians usually do not have incentives to just "FoLLoW tHe SciEnCE" regardless of partisan affiliation: www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-02-27/gavin-newsom-…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I think one can have legitimate disagreements on the value of different kinds of research, but studies of "beetles having sex" is actually core to many of the American agricultural infestations and crises of the last 150 years.
The Chronicle of Higher Education
@chronicle
State Sen. Brad Zaun doesn't like "all the sabbaticals and all the ridiculous things that we grant for a study of a beetle having sex or whatever, or a bicycle.” chroni.cl/2NHNfws
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Daniel Dale
@ddale8
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Philip Bump
@pbump
Two quotes:
“An ounce of prevention would be far more efficient than a pound of cure, but voters seem interested only in the cure.”
“This is a broader problem than just in Texas.”
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/02/18/texas-is-remin… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It becomes depressing tweeting out this article after every instance of government failure ("voters reward the incumbent...for delivering disaster relief spending, but not for investing in disaster preparedness spending"): citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.463.940…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
"These inconsistencies distort the incentives of public officials, leading the government to underinvest in disaster preparedness, thereby causing substantial public welfare losses...$1 spent on preparedness is worth about $15 in terms of the future damage it mitigates."
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Todd N. Tucker
@toddntucker
Nice piece by @billscher on how there is a majoritarian play open to the GOP if they want it. Continuing on the minoritarian path leads to a grim future.
washingtonmonthly.com/2021/02/08/making-it-easier-to-vote… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
These are the days that explain why people put up with living in CA.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is 20/20 hindsight because at the time, Rubin and his protégés (including Summers) were considered geniuses. The Rubin tree still dominates center-left economic policy making even as some policy Choices (eg repeal of glass-steagal) haven’t looked good in retrospect.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Again, if you are going to count 15 justices, you need to put 1968, 1972, 1980,1984, 1988 in the right column. You can make the same point without being unethical and deceptive. Otherwise, just say “5 out of the last 9 justices”
Brian Fallon
@brianefallon
And yet Republican presidents have picked 15 of the last 19 Supreme Court justices.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If a reviewer ever tells you that a political psych survey experiment is not externally valid...
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
“Soldiers are paid to fight. Rebels aren’t.” - Michael Corleone “What does that tell you?” - Hyman Roth “They can win.” - Michael
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jake M. Grumbach
@JakeMGrumbach
Human civilization’s survival depends on red meat becoming a lot more expensive. I say this as somebody who loves red meat.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sarah Binder
@bindersab
Minority parties thrive on dividing the majority. In that sense, McConnell secured what he sought: Manchin and Sinema's commitment to preserving filibuster undermines (for now) the credibility of Democrats' threat to abolish the filibuster should GOP block everything in sight.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
LOL. In all fairness, my brilliant colleague Kate Casey, who is one of the inventors of the concept/acronym, pronounces it "PEE-AY-PEE."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Maybe this is good general advice, but I'm very glad the many people who collectively discovered the covid vaccines---including future Nobel laureate Katalin Kariko---did not take this approach.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Feeling pretty relieved to not be editing a journal for the first time in 6 years.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What is your prediction on whether Newsom faces recall?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
“You don’t need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” - Robert Zimmerman, Nobel Laureate
Sarah Binder
@bindersab
Tom Rice (R-SC) voted to reject BOTH the Arizona and Pennsylvania electoral votes, but today voted to impeach ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Isaac Chotiner
@IChotiner
Seems quite possible that Trump getting to stay on Twitter for four years cost him re-election, and getting banned last week saved him from getting impeached and convicted this month.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
You really can't make this up. NBC News article comparing Hawley's raised fist photo to the Dukakis tank photo. www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/sen-josh-hawley-becomes…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is such an inappropriate comparison that simultaneously trivializes what Hawley did and continues to unfairly denigrate Dukakis.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Hans Noel
@ProfHansNoel
My point here is not that banning Trump was bad, but that a world in which unaccountable corporations unilaterally make these decisions might not be the best we can do. And that it's therefore worth having a policy discussion about it.
Hans Noel
@ProfHansNoel
Possibly unpopular opinion: Twitter and Facebook are now important public spaces. It’s too facile to just say they're private companies, so the First Amendment doesn't apply and they can do what they want. At the same time, First Amendment law is also not simple. 1/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I've been studying corporate self-regulation for about a decade, and am very skeptical of it. Much of what I've seen recently confirms the finding that modest self-regulation by tech companies depresses support for meaningful and stronger gvnt regulation: tomz.people.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiybj4711/f/mmt-a…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This isn’t the question though. It’s: (1) would public regulation have shut it down *sooner*?; (2) will private regulation ban speech only because it goes against shareholder interests?
Jodi Beggs
@jodiecongirl
honestly not sure why people think public utilities wouldn't also shut down this behavior
Josh Kalla
@j_kalla
We need to stop conceiving of social media companies as just ordinary private corporations. I agree with Neil — treat them like public utilities.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ok I am worried about the infinite regress here. A power company can’t turn your lights off if you write a blog post about climate change. Hopefully, there is bipartisan support for regulation of tech as public utilities.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Josh Kalla
@j_kalla
We need to stop conceiving of social media companies as just ordinary private corporations. I agree with Neil — treat them like public utilities.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ok I am worried about the infinite regress here. A power company can’t turn your lights off if you write a blog post about climate change. Hopefully, there is bipartisan support for regulation of tech as public utilities.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Amir Goldberg
@amirgoldb
As much as I enjoy Trump being silenced, this is not how it should work. Zuckerberg and Dorsey can't be the deciders on free speech, even if they made the right decision.
The decision should be made by legislators - another reason to break up tech.
www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/01/08/twitter-trum… -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We as a society have to make a fundamental decision about our public square. Do the people have a say, or is it solely up to multinational corporations, whose primary purpose is maximizing profits for shareholders?
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We as a society have to make a fundamental decision about our public square. Do the people have a say, or is it solely up to multinational corporations, whose primary purpose is maximizing profits for shareholders?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Of course, power companies can restrict access if you do things like illegal wiring. But those restrictions have regulatory/democratic oversight, precisely because they are utilities.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ok I am worried about the infinite regress here. A power company can’t turn your lights off if you write a blog post about climate change. Hopefully, there is bipartisan support for regulation of tech as public utilities.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ok I am worried about the infinite regress here. A power company can’t turn your lights off if you write a blog post about climate change. Hopefully, there is bipartisan support for regulation of tech as public utilities.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
So instead of immediately impeaching, we have ceded civilian control over the military? Such a broken democracy.
Mike Balsamo
@MikeBalsamo1
WASHINGTON (AP) — AP Source: Pelosi tells Dems that top military official assured her steps are in place to prevent Trump nuclear launch.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I think people underestimate how deep this goes. I personally know n>1 finance executives who believe the election was stolen.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
But because of the 50-50 split, McConnell wouldn't be Minority Leader until 1/20?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In a sign of how much football has changed over the years, Matt Schaub (who retired today) has more career passing yards than Joe Theismann, Bob Griese, Bart Starr, and Roger Staubach.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Christian Grose
@christiangrose
Senators on Jan. 6 may vote however they please w/ few electoral ramifications. How they explain vote could matter big time. @namalhotra , Rob VH & I found voters reward position taking & not the actual vote position. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/ajps.12164
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I tweeted this 9.5 months ago, and sadly I think it aged OK.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I believe some claim that pandemics (unlike wars, natural disasters) do not build social capital, altruism, and heroism. And one reason we have swept the 1918 flu under the rug is that we were ashamed at many of the things we did.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Was an honor working under the leadership of @jaj7d, one of the best EICs of a leading ps journal we've had. Thanks to all the great reviewers; many put so much time into those. And thanks to all the great authors; I got several nice notes even from people who got rejected. 1/2
Jeff Jenkins
@jaj7d
Last day as EIC of the JOP -- 6 full years! (Thread with some thoughts below.)
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Thanks to the fantastic grad assts (@JoeySaraceno @whitney_hua @NicholasNapolio). My main takeaway is that poli sci is filled with really terrific people, not just great minds, but also people with good hearts. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Calvin and Hobbes Fan Account
@Calvinn_Hobbes
On this day 25 years ago. “A new year… a fresh, clean start!” 🛷#letsgoexploring #bye2020 #calvinandhobbes
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I highly recommend “Soul.” It’s basically the complete opposite of “Inside Out” (same director). That’s also a great movie but “Soul” IMHO is much more appropriate for young children. The genius of Pixar is that they make movies for adults that children also happen to like.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I know a fair bit about TV. I spent a fairly large part of my life watching TV. And I'm a good TV watcher---it's part of my job. I'm not writing any screenplays on my own. The problem is that they should never have had Rachel get back together with Ross.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The amount of sexism that woman endure on this hell site is so horrible. Dole was a Nixon official and member of the FTC. Temporal causality: it's possible that women can meet their partners as part of their work networks, and not just get jobs because of their spouses.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
ICYMI: @OurWarmRegards podcast has listener data stories. Their last (excellent, as always) episode featured my daughter’s climate strike memory. 🥰 Check it out!
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/climate-data-climate-activi… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Dude (probably) to woman: What are your qualifications? Didn't you just get the job because you're someone's wife?
Woman: I was director of the Fed. Maritime Commission, and Secretary of Labor for eight years.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I also think it's hilarious that out of complete s-show that was the Trump Cabinet, this guy picks out the woman of color who was clearly the most competent, successful, experienced, and professional person.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
👇👇👇👇
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'm gonna have to channel my inner Allen Iverson. We're talking about South Bend? We're not talking about Indianapolis. South Bend? Are we talking about Ft. Wayne or Evansville? We talking about South Bend?
David Karol
@DKarol
Obama also gave this job to a Mayor, if one from a somewhat larger city. Biden has given experience more weight than any President I can think of (GHW Bush's DOT Sec was a former prosecutor) but cabinets are political institutions and that's OK.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
TBH this kind of has echoes of the Carson pick. I don't think running a quasi-successful presidential campaign (even if you're bright) qualifies you to run a massive federal agency. In the absence of a presidential campaign, wouldn't PB be a Deputy secretary?
Taegan Goddard
@politicalwire
Biden Picks Buttigieg as Transportation Secretary politicalwire.com/2020/12/15/biden-picks-buttigieg-as-tra… via @politicalwire
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
In hindsight, Trump probably could have lost by ~6 million votes nationally and still prevailed in the Electoral College. www.nbcnews.com/politics/2020-election/how-trump-could-lo…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
Fact: in 2016, Hillary Clinton won the popular vote by 2.9 million and came within 77,744 votes of winning the presidency.
In 2020, Donald Trump lost the popular vote by 7.1 million and came within 65,009 votes of winning reelection. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The 2000 election was VERY different from 2020. It was a *tie* in the electoral college (because our counting methods were not sufficiently precise). But many people thought *morally* the tie should have gone to Gore because: (1) pop vote win; (2) butterfly ballot; (3) Nader
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Omar Wasow | @owasow@bsky.social
@owasow
For democracies that like to gamble, the choice is clear.
Popular vote: boring definitive winner
Biden: 81,282,376 (51.3%)
Trump: 74,222,576 (46.9%)
Electoral College: exciting like a coin toss
In WI, GA & AZ, Biden defeated Trump by 42,918 votes
42,918/(155,504,952)=0.000276 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Time POTY is a win-win marketing exercise more than journalism. I think it speaks well of Biden that they embraced the Harris inclusion. Reports that Time offered POTY to Bush/Cheney jointly in 2003, but the WH declined because they didn't want to make Cheney seem too powerful.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Seems like I haven't been reading much on how all of this House GOP activity is going to affect IA-2. Lofgren and Pelosi have smartly been tight-lipped, but I think the House Dems are in a tough position on this one.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Again, I don’t understand why people just make up fake data and spread it, when the truth itself is horrifying. Long-term, spreading misinformation is counterproductive.
Dr. Tom Frieden
@DrTomFrieden
1 in 3 South Dakotans has now been infected with Covid. Stunning.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Nolan McCarty
@Nolan_Mc
Given that 6000 a day died in US from the Spanish Flu in October 1918, this is very misleading
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I see this "deadliest days" thing floating around social media, but it is clearly false. Isn't it counterproductive long-term to be spreading false information as a means of changing behavior during a pandemic?
Taegan Goddard
@politicalwire
The Deadliest Days In American History politicalwire.com/2020/12/09/the-deadliest-days-in-americ… via @politicalwire
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This would actually not be a bad exam question for undergraduates. For instance, is this relationship driven by Biden doing better in Cracker Barrel counties, Cracker Barrell opening locations in Biden counties, etc.?
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
In this context, it's a remarkable achievement that Biden was able to reverse some Dem erosion in Cracker Barrel counties (i.e. places that tend to decide Midwest swing states).
There's no guarantee a future Dem w/ a different profile could hold the line in Erie, Saginaw, etc. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Does anybody have any predictions on what will happen with IA-2? Will House Democrats have stomach to overturn a state certified result given Trump? Harkens back to IN-8 in ‘84, which some claim was root of GOP’s turn from Michel to Gingrich.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I’ve been studying publication bias for 15 yrs. We define publication bias always as *conditional* on research quality. This makes the research designs difficult. Here’s an example of one that addresses the issues in this thread: science.sciencemag.org/content/345/6203/1502 (still very large effects)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In case people are interested, this is what it looked like for political science circa-2005 (from Gerber and Malhotra 2008, QJPS):
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In 2008, McCain won Kansas by 15 pp and Missouri by 0.1 pp.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Kansas (Trump +14.7) now less red than Missouri (Trump +15.4)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Wait a minute there’s an NFL game going on right now? It’s Wednesday at lunch.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Ryan Autullo
@RyanAutullo
Austin mayor stressed residents 'need to stay home.' He was vacationing in Cabo at the time. From @tplohetski
www.statesman.com/news/20201202/austin-mayor-stressed-res… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Some professional/personal news. According to Spotify, I am in the top 3% globally of Taylor Swift listeners.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Nice teaching example about estimating (causal) effects and *interpreting* effects
Lady_Pora
@Comtesse_Leia
🚨🚨 NEW WORKING PAPER ALERT 🚨🚨
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Alexander Agadjanian
@A_agadjanian
Analyses of 2020 polling error often find that error was largest in the most Republican states, but it may not be too informative. The problem is that polling avg's in the most R (& most D) states are worse off in terms of 1) volume of polls behind the avg and 2) quality of polls
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Newsome, Cuomo, this, etc. all needs to stop. Such poor leadership.
9NEWS Denver
@9NEWS
After warnings to avoid travel, Denver Mayor Hancock flies to visit family for Thanksgiving www.9news.com/article/news/health/coronavirus/denver-mayo…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dan Hopkins
@dhopkins1776
A. Biden's current popular vote margin: 6.2 million votes
B. Biden's total vote margin in decisive states (WI+AZ+GA): 43,673
B/A = 0.007 -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The Midwest is getting absolutely hammered in all states, even those with restrictive policies. Be careful out there everyone.
Youyang Gu
@youyanggu
Last week, Illinois reported 15,415 cases in a single day, more than Florida ever did in a single day. This is despite Illinois' population being 40% lower.
Many of you probably did not know the dire situation in Illinois. That's because no mainstream media chose to report it. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The GOP does indeed have the multiracial working class coalition open to them if they want it. The problem is that the elite/donor class of the party don’t really believe in many of the policy ideas necessary to solidify this coalition.
Ryan Lizza
@RyanLizza
“The joke is that the GOP is really assembling the multiracial working-class coalition that the left has always dreamed of,” says David Shor, a Democratic polling and data expert who developed the Obama 2012 campaign’s internal election-forecasting system. www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/11/12/2020-election-a…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Given how underrepresented Asian Americans are in Hollywood, I would just have to pick the four actors that look nothing like me.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Whenever I had to do this icebreaker in the various education, professional, and business settings in my life, it always made me feel excluded and awkward.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
America's only been a stable, real democracy since the 1960s, with the passage of the Civil Rights and Voting Rights acts. The roots are shallow.
The idea that its survival is assured, that the political forces that fought democracy for so long are gone, was fanciful. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
The gap between the popular vote & the tipping point state could get to ~4 points, more than doubling from 2016. Since Biden likely over-performed generic Democrats in the Midwest, that could mean long-term problems for Democrats.
www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/11/joe-biden-wi… -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sam Rosenfeld
@sam_rosenfeld
Trump ran in 2016 as a right-populist deviationist from conservative economic orthodoxy, putting himself in the top-left quadrant of this Voter Study Group figure.
He then governed (excepting trade) as a top-rightist, turning over fiscal policy to Cong, gutting regulations, etc. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Lots of votes yet to be counted, but 2020 election will likely be closer in the electoral college than 2016 election.
Taegan Goddard
@politicalwire
Biden’s Electoral Edge Was Very Narrow politicalwire.com/2020/11/12/bidens-electoral-edge-was-ve… via @politicalwire
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
When I first read this, my immediate thought was the "Seinfeld" episode where Elaine thought the original title of "War and Peace" was "War, What is it Good For?" and then I felt really old because no millennial or Gen Z person would get that reference.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Lots of liberals on Twitter not quite understanding how close this election was in the EC (similar to how conservatives thought 2016 was an EC landslide). Big difference though is that Biden will win popular vote.
Lee Drutman ⚙️🏛
@leedrutman
Let's say Trump had won the same narrow Electoral College victory as Biden had, and Biden won the popular vote. Biden would have conceded by this point, right?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Despite a comfortable pop vote win (similar to 2004, 2016, 1976), another nail biter in the electoral college. We’ve avoided many of these inversions recently (could have been 5 in last 12 elections).
Matt Blackwell
@matt_blackwell
The minimum number of votes currently needed to flip the election is a bit over 84,000 (GA+AZ+WI+NV, subject to change). It was roughly 77,000 in 2016 (WI+MI+PA).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Lots of votes yet to be counted but this could end up again not being close in the popular vote, but very close in the Electoral College. Though probably not like 2000/2004/2016 where Gore/Kerry/Clinton were less than 100k swing away from presidency.
Dan Hopkins
@dhopkins1776
My latest on the @FiveThirtyEight live-blog: fivethirtyeight.com/live-blog/2020-election-results-cover…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you are part of the corporate wing of the GOP, is there any luckier sequence of events than: (1) Biden somehow winning that primary; (2) Biden beating Trump; (3) having 6-3 Court majority; (4) GOP keeping Senate; (5) keeping state legislatures.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Excluding those who inherited the presidency (Truman, LBJ), the ages of Democratic presidents upon election/ inauguration over last 100+ years: Obama (47), Clinton (46), Carter (52), JFK (41), FDR (50), and...Biden (78)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is also wrong since the Electoral College doesn’t meet for a while. “President elect” is not an office enshrined in the constitution. Society (media, citizens) will call Biden “president elect” because he is the duly elected president.
Jake Tapper 🦅
@jaketapper
No it isn’t.
Whoever wins 270 electoral votes becomes the president-elect.
The US Constitution doesn’t demand that the loser concede, or be gracious, or even remotely mature.
Just the 270 electoral votes. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ben Rhodes
@brhodes
Stacey Abrams should have been Governor but for voter suppression. A lot of people would have been turned off politics. Instead she went back to work and here we are.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
With the Sunbelt shift, the Dems could be equaling out the electoral college bias. Biden could end up with a similar popular vote margin as Obama in 2012 with somewhat lower electoral votes.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If OH (and FL) don’t vote for the winner this year, which state now has the longest track record for voting for the pres election winner?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Among the worst arguments among political pundits is “demographics is destiny.” It assumed a static, simplistic model of the world.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It’s time for the Jedi to end.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It's very possible that Susan Collins could become the most important person in the U.S. government soon.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The U.S. has the most uniquely welcoming immigration system in the world. The divide is that some people view this as the source of why the US has been the most successful country over the last 60 years, whereas others view it as a liability.
Noah Bierman
@Noahbierman
Stephen Miller, in a call with reporters called Biden immigration plan “a radical outlier in the whole of human civilization."
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is what they did to Jewish applicants in the early 1900s.
Steve Miller
@SteveMillerOC
Espenshade found an Asian American had to score MUCH higher than a white student on the ACT to have equal chance of admission.
But, as an advocate of race-based admissions, he denied this proved a racial bias against Asians because Asians might be inferior on “soft variables”. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Screaming into pillow....
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The R-squared is 0.73. "You can predict about 73% of the variability in state-level covid symptoms prevalence by knowing how often people wear their masks" @_cingraham
www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/10/23/pandemic-data-… with @CarnegieMellon data -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It’s amazing what goes viral on Twitter (even among academics) which would be desk rejected by journals.
Andy Slavitt
@ASlavitt
We don’t need a high tech miracle as much as we need some people to believe in simple cause and effect.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This aged OK.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is most likely correct. In two weeks there will be a rally where Trump says: “It was a couple of sniffles. No big deal. Of course I’m the most healthy president of all time, but still...Just some sniffles.”
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
I don't know about you, but I'm pretty sure this election is actually turning on Michelle Wolf's 2018 White House correspondent's dinner monologue
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jake M. Grumbach
@JakeMGrumbach
This is an important point. Democracy, and also liberalism and capitalism, are, for most, means to "the good life." And if the good life doesn't come, appeals to democratic, liberal, or capitalist values won't save these institutions.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
American Politics scholars are dunking on this, but authoritarianism is extremely intoxicating. For many, things like democracy and science are means, not ends themselves. American democracy is not sustainable unless it creates a good life for all Americans, not just the wealthy.
Mike Lee
@SenMikeLee
Democracy isn’t the objective; liberty, peace, and prospefity are. We want the human condition to flourish. Rank democracy can thwart that.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
American Politics scholars are dunking on this, but authoritarianism is extremely intoxicating. For many, things like democracy and science are means, not ends themselves. American democracy is not sustainable unless it creates a good life for all Americans, not just the wealthy.
Mike Lee
@SenMikeLee
Democracy isn’t the objective; liberty, peace, and prospefity are. We want the human condition to flourish. Rank democracy can thwart that.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I think these extreme statements ("Trump is bad at politics.") are too crude. It's like saying John Daly is bad at golf. He won two majors, and also shot 20 over par and threw his driver into the sea. Trump is very good at some aspects of politics, and terrible at many others.
b-boy bouiebaisse
@jbouie
finally wrote out something i have been saying for awhile: trump is bad at politics! www.nytimes.com/2020/10/07/opinion/trump-2020-covid-polit…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I don’t have any comments on this case, but I’ll just note that for *everyone* if the texts between you and your significant other were made public, in almost every case people would say they were cringey and embarrassing. Real life is not a Nora Ephron script.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is most likely correct. In two weeks there will be a rally where Trump says: “It was a couple of sniffles. No big deal. Of course I’m the most healthy president of all time, but still...Just some sniffles.”
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Asian Americans are a very complex political group that deserve more research attention. It’s clear that this broad categorization masks diversity. One fascinating thing is the negative relationship at the group level between income and Republican voting.
Steven White
@notstevenwhite
Who do Asian American voters support in the presidential election? Some numbers from the 2020 Asian American Voter Survey: aapidata.com/2020-survey/
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Congratulations @jkwillenbring for winning this award for mid-career scholarship!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The “W-2 class” is a core base of the Democratic Party, and they are likely livid tonight.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is nothing insightful but I am constantly shocked by the sexist and racist things some people say publicly when it suits their ideology. I shudder to think what they say in the privacy of their own homes when it doesn't suit their ideology.
Vanessa Grigoriadis
@vanessagrigor
I guess one of the things I don't understand about Amy Comey Barrett is how a potential Supreme Court justice can also be a loving, present mom to seven kids? Is this like the Kardashians stuffing nannies in the closet and pretending they've drawn their own baths for their kids
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A paper I published with @stephenjessee in 2013: We jointly scale ideal points of the public and the Supreme Court. Key finding: People are much more likely to misperceive the Court as more liberal than them than more conservative. academic.oup.com/poq/article/77/2/619/1872512
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
It’s unclear how many “lost seats” there were for the right post-Warren (nominated by GOP Pres and confirmed by GOP senate). O’Connor had a solid center-right record. Dem senates approved Scalia, Thomas, Burger, Harlan, Rehnquist, etc...
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is an interesting article explaining each sides’ problems: unreliable conservatives for right and bungled retirements for left. But it fails to mention that Souter/Stevens/Blackmun were confirmed by Democratic senates and part of a compromise process. www.nytimes.com/2020/09/21/briefing/ruth-bader-ginsburg-c…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Sorry not Scalia.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is an interesting article explaining each sides’ problems: unreliable conservatives for right and bungled retirements for left. But it fails to mention that Souter/Stevens/Blackmun were confirmed by Democratic senates and part of a compromise process. www.nytimes.com/2020/09/21/briefing/ruth-bader-ginsburg-c…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
At the time, all three were not considered uber-liberal, and Stevens in particular was seen as business friendly. And all three seem like fair compromises between a GOP president and Dem senate (whose median was a moderate Southern Dem).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
No one loves the “law of 1/n” anymore. :(
Stephen Pettigrew
@pettigrew_stats
With all the talk about expanding the Supreme Court and adding new states, why no discussion of adding a couple hundred seats to the House? We did it nearly every decade for 150 years. It'd also make it less likely that the electoral college picks the popular vote loser
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
My interpretation of the Collins/Murkowski comments is that they would vote to confirm a justice in November/December if Trump won but the GOP did *not* retain the Senate. That seems to be the key distinction between “before Election Day” and “lame duck.”
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
People also don’t quite understand how serious the flu is. There are “long haulers” with influenza. It doesn’t get enough research money and attention given how serious it is.
Craig Spencer MD MPH
@Craig_A_Spencer
If your friends or family think #covid19 is “just the flu” or want it to rip through society to get to herd immunity, consider sharing my piece on #longhaulers with them. I outline the growing body of research & highlight why many still struggle months after an initial infection.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
These kind of weird truncations are what crappy baseball hall of fame analysts do (most wins between 1985-1993). Why not just say twice in ~32.5 years given that one of the 6 justices is Thomas. You still make the point and come off as less of a hack.
Steve Koczela
@skoczela
We're looking at the possibility that Republicans will have nominated 6 of the 9 Supreme Court justices, despite winning the popular vote just once in 32 years.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Lee Drutman ⚙️🏛
@leedrutman
A good reminder that the randomness of human lifespans is not a great way to decide a national system of justice.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
(1) RBG lived an extraordinary life: (2) If I had to bet right now, I think Biden will select her successor (although the chances of that may be higher if many Senate races were not already so lopsided).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I’m thinking of muting a few words on Twitter, but first I need to figure out how to convince someone to come to my weekly poker game.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We published a field experiment in 2012 where we partnered with a county election office to randomize free postage for ballots. Postage did not affect overall turnout, but disrupting routines affected behavior. www.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/elj.2012.0150
Taegan Goddard
@politicalwire
Ohio Won’t Cover Postage for Absentee Ballots politicalwire.com/2020/09/15/ohio-wont-cover-postage-for-… via @politicalwire
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
watched @PictureaSciFilm last night (without fast-forwarding through my parts this time). So grateful to those who came before me who fought against gender discrimination and harassment and were forced out of the academy. I stand on the shoulders of invisible giants!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I just served as a discussant for an iposter and it worked really well. I think the participants got better (as good?) feedback than they would have if it was in person. I know the @APSAtweets staff has had a tough week, but just wanted to point out a success. Congrats!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Is it just me or is the coverage of this bordering on anti-Muslim racism?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
Opportunity to watch @PictureaSciFilm with @500womensci (or more) coming up if you missed the theatrical release.
500 Women Scientists
@500womensci
The weekend of events which will consist of:
✅ FREE virtual access to the film for 48 hrs on 09/12-13
✅ Panel on harassment in STEM on 09/12
✅ Wikipedia Edit-a-thon on 09/13
🔗 Registration and details: 500womenscientists.org/calendar/2020/9/12/picture-a-scien… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There are Wall Street analyst jobs where you make tons of money to do terrible political science research.
Carl Quintanilla
@carlquintanilla
JPMORGAN: “Trump’s re-election chances are rising, .. due to two effects: 1) the impact of the degree of violence in protests on public opinion and voting patterns and 2) a bias in polls due to Trump voters being more likely to decline or mislead polls.” - @MarkoKolanovic4
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Wow this is truly a terrible research design: To assess the “shy Trump effect,” a private sector marketing firm just asked people online whether they would be shy about sharing their Trump support by phone.
Sean Healy
@SeanHealyPR
A new study by CloudResearch, a Healy Corp client, shows Republicans are more reticent than Democrats and Independents to share their voting intentions in phone polls. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-08-28/new-study-sugg… via @BW
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I'll try to give some advice on this from the persp. of someone who has edited manuscripts at 3 journals. As with tenure letters, short/uninformative reviews are often bad for the candidate/paper. Rather, you should make an affirmative case for why the paper is high quality. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A good approach is to use the "sh*t sandwich." The first part of the review explains why the paper is among the best. The middle part explains the limitations and why they are either not critical or can be addressed. The last part reiterates the first part. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Why is a short review "bad"? Because social science research is inherently messy and almost all research has some limitations or involves some tradeoffs. Most likely, other reviewers (including the negative ones) are going to bring these up. 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
If you don't bring them up, and instead write a short, perfunctory review, then your review will not be perceived of as careful. So it will not receive the weight it deserves in the ultimate decision. 4/4
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
OK, zoomer.
Heather Long
@byHeatherLong
This gets to the heart of what is so bizarre about the pandemic recession: Quite a few Americans are doing well financially right now.
“About half of Americans say they have either saved more or paid down debt since the outbreak began.”
apnews.com/15cd7d2d54286d7b0a895ba116fb99ef -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
Check the date:
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
On many issues that align with their self-interest or ideology (eg housing, this), elite liberals sometimes let the mask slip and reveal their racism/xenophobia.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
John Kasich, Susan Molinari, Christie Whitman? Is this the 1996 GOP convention?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Ralph Nader getting rightfully dunked on recently. But I think it is worth pointing out that many of the environmental and safety regulations we take for granted exist because of him. Like many important historical figures, Nader will leave behind a complex, mixed legacy.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
⑆Luke Stein⑈
@lukestein
We did it, y’all
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
R. Michael Alvarez
@rmichaelalvarez
Our "Blue Shift" paper (with @yimenglipolisci and Michelle Hyun) gets a shout-out in this Atlantic article, www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/08/brace-blue-shif…. Also the work of @cstewartiii and Edward Foley discussed, with great commentary from @OCRegistrar!
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I have to admit, growing up, I never imagined an Indian American would be on a national presidential ticket.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Results of a field experiment I ran with colleagues investigating the effects of postage amounts on turnout: www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/elj.2012.0150 Little direct effects of 🔻postage (we didn’t test 🔺postage) but did find treatment disrupted routine (which can affect turnout).
Catherine Rampell
@crampell
"Postal Service has informed states that they’ll need to pay first-class 55-cent postage to mail ballots to voters, rather than the normal 20-cent bulk rate. That nearly triples the per-ballot cost at a time when tens of millions more will be delivered." prospect.org/coronavirus/unsanitized-federal-benefit-exte…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There's an interesting mix of Rust Belt and Sun Belt in the states that are currently close (TX GA OH IA) and the states that are not as close but pivotal (MI WI PA AZ FL NC).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I don't have time to watch this Jonathan Swan thing, and am just going to wait for the Sarah Cooper version.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dana Schwartz - on hiatus
@DanaSchwartzzz
OKAY. This is a thread, but it’s worth it I promise.
On Reddit today, user u/NoNoNo_OhOhOh posted a page from acclaimed Irish novelist John Boyne’s latest book, ‘The Traveller At the Gates of Wisdom.
Note the ingredients. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
1993 throwback: Herman Cain as random guy in the audience at Bill Clinton town hall. One of the few times I saw Clinton not do well in a debate: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptrTa8C_Pl4
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
How Donor Opinion Distorts American Parties
Donors are more economically conservative than Rep voters, more socially liberal than Dem voters
& candidates are most responsive to donors
New #scienceofpolitics podcast/transcript @namalhotra & Jordan Kujala
www.niskanencenter.org/how-donor-opinion-distorts-america… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The new Taylor Swift album is amazing. Many people only know about her pop schlock singles, but all of her albums have terrific songs that reveal her brilliance as a singer-songwriter (e.g. "All Too Well"). "folklore" is just 100% that.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Gorsuch intros are amazing. He knows that the mass public will only ever read the first paragraph anyway, and he explains his position using clear writing (short sentences) without legalese. It's a model that all justices should follow.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
266 days between Major League baseball games being played, the longest in modern baseball history. As a point of comparison, the 1994-95 strike created a gap of 232 days.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Gambling.
Ana Samways
@AnaSamways
What’s considered trashy if you're poor, but classy if you're rich?
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
⑆Luke Stein⑈
@lukestein
Today’s close, in case you care (you shouldn’t):
- Equity market at its highest since COVID crash
- VIX at its lowest "
We’re 3% off peak, and any buy-and-hold investment from before January 13 is in the money -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Terrific coverage of our SCOTUSPoll project (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee) from @FiveThirtyEight , @ameliatd , and @wiederkehra. Great commentary from @maya_sen and @RadioFreeTom to contextualize results.
Amelia Thomson-DeVeaux
@ameliatd
Sometimes I write a story for @FiveThirtyEight where the words are just dressing for a fantastic chart. The Supreme Court's opinions were *very* in line with Americans' views this term, as @wiederkehra's gorgeous graphic shows fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-supreme-courts-big-rulin…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
From 1969-1993, Republican presidents made 10 straight Supreme Court appointments. The GOP only controlled the Senate for 2 of these. The appointments (roughly) produced 7 conservative justices and 3 liberal justices. All 3 liberal justices when Dems controlled Senate.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Another amazing Gorsuch intro.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Ubadah Sabbagh
@neubadah
Universities filing amicus briefs/lawsuits against new ICE regs by my count:
- Cornell
- Dartmouth
- Georgetown
- Harvard
- Hopkins (forthcoming)
- Michigan State
- MIT
- Northeastern
- Northwestern
- Penn
- Princeton
- Purdue
- Stanford
- U of California
- UMich
- USC
- Yale -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Court decided differently in Vance and Mazars. Whereas the Court is sensitive to these institutional differences between Congress and prosecutors, the mass public is not.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Last result from SCOTUSPoll. The majority of Americans agreed with the Court's opinion in Vance, although there was partisan division. The public did not see much difference between New York prosecutors and Congress; we'll see if the Court does.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Supreme Court sided with public opinion on almost everything this term:
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/15/us/supreme-court-m… -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Last result from SCOTUSPoll. The majority of Americans agreed with the Court's opinion in Vance, although there was partisan division. The public did not see much difference between New York prosecutors and Congress; we'll see if the Court does.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Only one case in SCOTUSPoll (which covered the major, salient cases) went against policy views of American people: CFPB (which I assume most people have already forgotten about or never read about to begin with)
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Gorsuch has had a much better record on indigenous rights than Kavanaugh. Was a major reason that Murkowski supported Gorsuch and not Kavanaugh (along with CBF).
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Not many people know about this paper, but it's very relevant now to states moving to pre-paid postage. Our main takeaway is that disruptions to routines/habits can adversely affect turnout, and that policy changes need to be made clear and explicit to voters.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
So, there needs to be some language in the election materials explaining to voters that the postage is pre-paid, and this might be different from what they've experienced before.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Thank you @daveamp for your service to the profession! And thanks to everyone who volunteered their time during this crisis when I sent out a call in March. Although time to decision has increased, you have all helped a lot.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Yet another decision where the Supreme Court ruling is in line with the policy preference of a majority of Americans. 53% of Americans believed that the employers should not be forced to cover contraceptives. projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol… 1/3
Steven Mazie
@stevenmazie
BREAKING: another 7-2 religion decision in Little Sisters of the Poor
Trump administration may offer employers full religious and moral exemptions from Obamacare's contraceptive mandate www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/19-431_5i36.pdf
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Partisan breakdown (D/R/I): 34%/69%/58%. Partisan divide by Independents side with conservative position. 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Now, in every single case SCOTUSPoll asked about except one, the Supreme Court ruling was in line with the policy views of Americans. The exception was the CFPB case, which was relatively obscure. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The partisan breakdown (D/R/I) was 65%/59%/60%. There is broad disapproval of "faithless" electors. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More from SCOTUSPoll (projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results). In Chiafolo, the Court unanimously ruled that states can require electors to vote for the popular vote winners in their states. The majority of Americans agreed with the Court's position. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This marks yet another major decision where the Court's ruling is in line with Americans' policy preferences (CFPB case is only exception so far). 61% of Americans believe that states can require electors. There was little partisan division over this issue. 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The partisan breakdown (D/R/I) was 65%/59%/60%. There is broad disapproval of "faithless" electors. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to SCOTUSPoll, 63% of Americans agreed with this decision, including 54% of Democrats. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
#scotus rules 5-4 that Montana’s exclusion of religious schools from state scholarship program funded by tax credits violates federal Constitution
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
You can follow more SCOTUSPoll results at @nytimes
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to SCOTUSPoll, 63% of Americans agree with this decision, including 54% of Democrats. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results 1/2
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
#scotus rules 5-4 that Montana’s exclusion of religious schools from state scholarship program funded by tax credits violates federal Constitution
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
You can follow more SCOTUSPoll results at @nytimes www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/15/us/supreme-court-m…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
According to SCOTUSPoll, 63% of Americans agree with this decision, including 54% of Democrats. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
#scotus rules 5-4 that Montana’s exclusion of religious schools from state scholarship program funded by tax credits violates federal Constitution
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
You can follow more SCOTUSPoll results at @nytimes : www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/15/us/supreme-court-m…
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Sorry small correction. 3 for 4 (CFPB case was not in line with public opinion).
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More from SCOTUSPoll. In this case, the Court had a conservative majority in Espinoza AND the ruling is in line with public opinion. This is now 4 for 4 in SCOTUSPoll where the Court decision is in line with policy preferences of mass public. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results 1/n
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More from SCOTUSPoll. In this case, the Court had a conservative majority in Espinoza AND the ruling is in line with public opinion. This is now 4 for 4 in SCOTUSPoll where the Court decision is in line with policy preferences of mass public. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This case was about whether students can use taxpayer-subsidized scholarships to attend religious schools. 63% of the public believed that scholarships can be used for this purpose. Partisan breakdown (D/R/I): 54%/75%/64%. Even a majority of Democrats agree with Court ruling. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The position of the median justice (Roberts) is again in line with the policy view of the median American. Religious freedom is one of the few issues in SCOTUSPoll where the majority of Americans take the conservative position. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There was another under-the-radar SCOTUS decision today on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau that we asked about in SCOTUSPoll (projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results). On this issue, the Court decision was not in line with Americans' views. 1/n
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is the first case of the four where the majority opinion is not in line with Americans' views. @leedrutman argues that Court is in line on social issues, but not economic issues. Could also be because this case was not salient. Wait for more SCOTUSPoll results! 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Predictions about the case were divided. 50% of Americans predicted the Court would retain the current CFPB structure, 50% predicted it would overturn it. D/R/I: 64% retain / 34% retain / 50% retain. 4/4
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More results from SCOTUSPoll (with @maya_sen and @stephenjessee) on today's ruling overturning the LA abortion restriction law. For the third time, the Court's ruling was in line with public opinion. projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll/survey-results 1/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
57% of Americans believed that the Louis. law violates women's constitutional rights. The partisan breakdown of D/R/I was 73%/39%/56%. For the third straight time in our poll, the position of the median justice (Roberts) is in line with the policy view of the median American. 2/3
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
48% of Americans predicted that the Court would overturn the law; 52% thought the Court would not overturn. Partisan breakdown of D/R/I: 53%/41%/48%. 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In the 2000 presidential election, Bush and Gore basically tied among all age groups, mirroring the tied national vote. The generation gap in 2016 was quite striking.
NYT Politics
@nytpolitics
No Democrat has won or broken even with voters over 65 in two decades. But seniors’ dismay about President Trump could change that. www.nytimes.com/2020/06/28/us/politics/trump-approval-old…
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
Last day to rent - BUT you have 48 hours to watch it (for you procrastinators out there 🙋🏼♀️).
Dr. Dara Goldberg
@dara_berg_
Whatever you are doing now, stop, and rent this film on Vimeo before it’s unavailable (today is the last day)! Insightful, heartbreaking, infuriating, and inspiring. #womeninstem (and impressed, as always, by @jkwillenbring)
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
Check out the @StanfordEarth summer reading lists for some awesome book suggestions including my picks: Superior by @AngelaDSaini and
The Story of More by @HopeJahren
earth.stanford.edu/news/summer-reading-illuminating-our-p… -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
I’m doing a @GrowingUpInSci chat online tomorrow if you’re like to join us!
9:30 am Pacific/12:30 pm eastern
NYC Postdoc Coalition
@NYC_Postdoc
Tomorrow the fascinating story of @jkwillenbring at @GrowingUpInSci #growingupinscience A story of ups and downs, a story of finding your dream job while overcoming obstacles. Don't miss it. Read her story 👇 and sign up! #scicomm #phdlife
Friday June 26th 2020, 12.30 EDT -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
A rule on twitter should be that you need to state a trade off.
Kevin J.S. Zollman
@KevinZollman
Consensus on my TL seems to be that universities should:
1. Not have in person classes
2. Charge reduced tuition for online classes
3. Not fire anyone
4. Provide extra money for development of online teaching
I don't think all these are possible. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
On two major Supreme Court decisions in a row, our SCOTUSPoll project has found that the Court's decisions are in line with the majority of Americans' attitudes. Roberts' vote as Court median matches the country median. The majority of Americans correctly predicted outcomes. 1/2
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More results from SCOTUSPoll (with @stephenjessee and @maya_sen) related to today's DACA ruling. 61% of Americans believe that DACA should remain, in line with the Court ruling. projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol… 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Stay tuned to see how the Court rules on eight more major issues this summer (and what SCOTUSPoll reports on Americans' views). Upcoming issues: abortion, contraceptives, religious freedom, Trump tax returns, CFPB, electoral college, Obamacare. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
More results from SCOTUSPoll (with @stephenjessee and @maya_sen) related to today's DACA ruling. 61% of Americans believe that DACA should remain, in line with the Court ruling. projects.iq.harvard.edu/files/scotus-poll/files/scotuspol… 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Unlike with LGBT rights, there is a partisan divide on this issue. D/R/I breakdown in support of DACA: 85%/30%/61%. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
54% of Americans correctly predicted that the Court would uphold DACA. Partisan breakdown in predictions between D/R/I: 65%/42%/54% 3/3
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Some additional interesting data on this from SCOTUSPoll. We asked respondents to predict how the Court would rule. 81.3% correctly predicted that the Court would rule that discrimination based on sexual orientation was illegal. 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
There were no partisan gaps in prediction. D/R/I breakdown was 80.5%/80.0%/82.8%. For transgender rights, 76.8% correctly predicted the Court's decision. D/R/I breakdown: 75.9%/79.1%/76.1%. 2/2
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
PICTURE A SCIENTIST Film Q&A tonight @ 5PM PST
Can't wait to hear more from @DrRubidium, Nancy & directors @SharonShattuck1 & @iancheney!
Did I mention Molly Webster from @Radiolab is moderating this? I didn't realize I had so many #lifegoals until this film came out.
Coolidge Corner Theatre
@thecoolidge
Tonight at 8pm EST! Join us for a conversation with PICTURE A SCIENTIST directors @SharonShattuck1 and @iancheney, along with subjects @DrRubidium, @jkwillenbring, and Nancy Hopkins: youtu.be/4i33BXH3zM4
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Travis Clow
@clowgeo
Can’t recommend strongly enough for you to watch this new doc on sexual harassment and discrimination in STEM @ www.pictureascientist.com. So thankful that @jkwillenbring @DrRubidium & Dr. Hopkins shared their experiences for all of us to learn and grow from. #pictureascientist
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Whatever you think of Neil Gorsuch, he is a fabulous writer.
Scott Lemieux
@LemieuxLGM
Gorsuch's introduction is a model of how to introduce an opinion -- states the issue clearly, and points to the obvious conclusion. d2qwohl8lx5mh1.cloudfront.net/8hVHe52Cq4sPdF0wEaTaCQ/content
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The @nytimes will be reporting on results from SCOTUSPoll (projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll) as it tracks major Supreme Court decisions this term: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/06/15/us/supreme-court-m…
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We found that 83.3% of Americans agreed with the Supreme Court's decision in Bostock that it should be illegal to fire employees based on their sexual orientation. 78.8% said it should be illegal to fire based on transgender status. 3/n
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Sarah Binder
@bindersab
On the 2019 House vote to update the 1964 Civil Rights act to explicitly protect LGBT individuals, just 4% of House Republicans joined every Democrat in support.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The majority of Republican respondents supported LGBT rights. For the sexual orientation item, the D/R/I support was 90%/74%/84%. For the transgender item, the D/R/I support was 86%/69%/79%. The SC Court's decision today is very much in line with Americans' attitudes. 4/4
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Frank Luntz
@FrankLuntz
Today’s SCOTUS decision reflects how Americans feel about equal rights protection for LGBT people.
There were folks outraged at the Obergefell decision in 2015, but they also didn’t represent the majority opinion – of the court or the American population.
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We found that 83.3% of Americans agreed with the Supreme Court's decision in Bostock that it should be illegal to fire employees based on their sexual orientation. 78.8% said it should be illegal to fire based on transgender status. 3/n
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Brian Schaffner
@b_schaffner
In the 2019 CCES, 69% of Americans favored prohibiting discrimination on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation, including 67% of independents and 46% of Republicans.
The Associated Press
@AP
BREAKING: Supreme Court rules gay and lesbian people can sue for workplace bias under landmark civil rights law. apne.ws/R8kvRKR
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jonathan Robinson
@jon_m_rob
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We found that 83.3% of Americans agreed with the Supreme Court's decision in Bostock that it should be illegal to fire employees based on their sexual orientation. 78.8% said it should be illegal to fire based on transgender status. 3/n
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Maya Sen (@maya_sen), Stephen Jessee (@stephenjessee), and I have launched the Supreme Court Public Opinion Project, or SCOTUSPoll (projects.iq.harvard.edu/scotus-poll) 1/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
In April/May, we conducted a nationally representative survey of American adults on their views of Supreme Court decisions in the 2019-2020 term. 2/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We found that 83.3% of Americans agreed with the Supreme Court's decision in Bostock that it should be illegal to fire employees based on their sexual orientation. 78.8% said it should be illegal to fire based on transgender status. 3/n
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
The majority of Republican respondents supported LGBT rights. For the sexual orientation item, the D/R/I support was 90%/74%/84%. For the transgender item, the D/R/I support was 86%/69%/79%. The SC Court's decision today is very much in line with Americans' attitudes. 4/4
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
AND I get to chat with MOLLY WEBSTER from @Radiolab !
x.com/SharonShattuck1/status/1271481565252661249 -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
Yay @PictureaSciFilm is “out” in US “theaters” today! You can buy tickets to watch it online!
Let me know what you think in the comments. #virtualcinema #metoo
@500womensci #womeninstem
Picture a Scientist
@PictureaSciFilm
Today is the day! #pictureascientist open in select U.S. theaters as part of #virtualcinema. Check out the theaters here to watch the film: www.pictureascientist.com Let's get this conversation going! #womeninscience #diversitymatters w/ @SharonShattuck1 @iancheney @manettepottle
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Congratulations to @ceciliamo and @dbroockman! I’ve been very lucky to have you both as a major part of my career!
Elections, Public Opinion, and Voting Behavior
@epovb
First up: the Emerging Scholar in Elections, Public Opinion and Voting Behavior Award.
The co-recipients are @dbroockman and Cecilia Mo (both of Berkeley).
Congratulations! -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Dillon Amaya
@DillonAmaya
Just a reminder that map projections can be extremely misleading. Each of these red circles have a 500 mile radius.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I don't know if these facts are accurate, but IF true, this shows the importance of tenure as a mechanism for finding the truth. Personally, I will not really trust any future findings from @CivisAnalytics . tldr: someone (maybe) was fired for sharing @owasow 's impressive APSR.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Alert: the economists are discovering social construction.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
“In hindsight, after seeing the film, Hopkins says, “We believed so much in meritocracy. That you cannot keep merit down. False.” “
www.wbur.org/artery/2020/06/10/documentary-picture-a-scie…
@PictureaSciFilm -
Neil Malhotra reposted
Picture a Scientist
@PictureaSciFilm
#pictureascientist aims to amplify the voices of women & people of color in science, to effect change in the culture of science. To help amplify the voices of black scientists, we will donate the proceeds of our June 12th theatrical release to @BlackAFinSTEM & @BlackGirlsCode
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
⑆Luke Stein⑈
@lukestein
Re-upping this after a week of heartbreak, with the S&P only 5.1% off its all-time peak and only 0.3% off in calendar 2020
⑆Luke Stein⑈
@lukestein
Close your eyes.
Take a deep breath.
Clear your mind.
𝘕𝘰𝘸 𝘵𝘳𝘺 𝘵𝘰 𝘦𝘯𝘷𝘪𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘢 𝘤𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘳𝘧𝘢𝘤𝘵𝘶𝘢𝘭 𝘚&𝘗 500 𝘪𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘸𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘯𝘰 𝘊𝘰𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘷𝘪𝘳𝘶𝘴. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is a tour de force. I would encourage everyone in the discipline to read it, and it should be required reading in graduate school. You can disagree with parts of it, but it lays out all of the issues with publishing with clarity.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jonathan Mummolo
@jonmummolo
Militarized police highly visible in this moment, but their deployment is routine, especially in black communities. Rationales for militarization--lowering crime, making police safer--are not supported by the data. Experiments show militarization may harm perceptions of police.
Jonathan Mummolo
@jonmummolo
My latest research out today in @PNASNews. “Militarization fails to enhance police safety or reduce crime but may harm police reputation.” (thread)
Article (open access): www.pnas.org/content/early/2018/08/14/1805161115
[Photo credit: Shutterstock/JPL Designs] -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I came into this meeting wanting to support the resolution, but unfortunately the proponents made analytically poor (and often illogical) arguments. I also asked for data in advance, and was not provided it. Let's try again next year; and let's prepare in advance this time.
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
⑆Luke Stein⑈
@lukestein
Close your eyes.
Take a deep breath.
Clear your mind.
𝘕𝘰𝘸 𝘵𝘳𝘺 𝘵𝘰 𝘦𝘯𝘷𝘪𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘢 𝘤𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘳𝘧𝘢𝘤𝘵𝘶𝘢𝘭 𝘚&𝘗 500 𝘪𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘸𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘯𝘰 𝘊𝘰𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘷𝘪𝘳𝘶𝘴. -
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
This is an ad to get boomers to invest their money with the Vampire Squid. Are people really thinking they were going to get Mo Fiorina to discuss the spatial model?
Goldman Sachs
@GoldmanSachs
Why has political polarization increased in the US in the last 20 years? Pulitzer Prize-winning author of “Upheaval” Jared Diamond discusses in a new episode of Talks at GS: click.gs.com/ehex
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Isn’t getting pissed about this sort of like getting pissed that Guy Fieri is doing a Masterclass on fine cuisine?
Goldman Sachs
@GoldmanSachs
Why has political polarization increased in the US in the last 20 years? Pulitzer Prize-winning author of “Upheaval” Jared Diamond discusses in a new episode of Talks at GS: click.gs.com/ehex
-
Neil Malhotra reposted
Jane Willenbring 🌱
@jkwillenbring
Release date for virtual screenings of @PictureaSciFilm is June 12!
Love this premiere model that supports local, independent theaters.
Picture a Scientist
@PictureaSciFilm
A new feature documentary about bias and discrimination against women scientists, Picture a Scientist is from award-winning directors @iancheney and @SharonShattuck1. Be among the first to see it: www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2020-05/ss-pas052220.php Brought to you by @SloanFoundation @HSFdn #scienceonscreen
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Jerry West easily won this one but some trivia. Larry Bird is the only person who has won all these awards: Rookie of Year, MVP, Finals MVP, All Star MVP, Coach of the Year, Executive of the Year
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Who is the greatest overall NBA talent in terms of three facets of the game (playing, coaching, executive)?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Who is the greatest overall NBA talent in terms of three facets of the game (playing, coaching, executive)?
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
What do people think are the chances of a grand bargain: state/local aid for some liability protection?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
I believe some claim that pandemics (unlike wars, natural disasters) do not build social capital, altruism, and heroism. And one reason we have swept the 1918 flu under the rug is that we were ashamed at many of the things we did.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Just to clarify, Stanford attempted to expand undergrad enrollment but local NIMBYs wouldn’t allow it.
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
Over 43% of white admitted students at Harvard are legacies, athletes, donors, or faculty/staff children. “Our model of admissions shows that roughly three quarters of white ALDC admits would have been rejected if they had been treated as white non-ALDCs.” public.econ.duke.edu/~psarcidi/legacyathlete.pdf
-
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
One reason people love @TheBradOwen & @andrewneeme 's videos is that they are as much about life as about strategy: (1) life is often a grind, keep grinding; (2) never judge decisions based on outcomes; (3) friends/family are the source of happiness, not upswings/downswings
Brad Owen
@TheBradOwen
Two and a half years, lots of all nighters working on videos, and one cat later... I’m in the 100k sub club! Thanks for sticking around through the good and bad decisions.



































































































































































