1 in 5 US LinkedIn users edit job descriptions well after leaving the position. In a new WP with @I_Am_NickBloom, Lisa Simon, & Caelan Wilkie-Rogers, we argue this contaminates work using profiles as employment histories—but enables us to track skill demand over time. 🧵 (1/16)
Nicholas Bloom
Nicholas Alexander Bloom (born 5 May 1973) is the William Eberle Professor in the Department of Economics at Stanford University, a courtesy professor at Stanford Business School and Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research, and a co-director of the Productivity, Innovation and Entrepreneurship Program at the National Bureau of Economic Research. More on Wikipedia
-
Nick Bloom reposted
Gideon Moore
@GideonMoore
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Nice piece in today's FT - productivity growth has been declining since the 1950s (albeit with a small recent uptick). What could this be? Fewer ideas, smaller ideas or worse use of new ideas?
It's not obvious, but the implications are huge for growth.
www.ft.com/content/72b96cb4-15f3-4bfc-a0b7-dabc31bbe1fa?a… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
From 1pm today (Weds May 27th) to 12:00 Friday May 29th hosting the Empirical Management Conference at Stanford Economics (579 Jane Stanford Way). Research papers on the cause, effect, measurement and theory of management. Welcome to any/all sessions.
docs.google.com/document/d/16yPGyazMfNkMhq-EDogKSL9uBBYLj… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Call For Papers: 2026 Remote Work Conference.
Noon Weds October 28th to noon Friday October 30th at Stanford. Submission due June 21st - submit here: wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/CallforPapers2… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
December 25th is the biggest holiday of the year according to Kastle Systems office swipe card data. But even then 800,000 people swipe into the office.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
*Call for papers for the 2025 Remote Work Conference*
Stanford, October 22 to 24 2025. In person presentations, and streamed if folks want to watch remotely.
Research papers on cause/effect of remote, WFH or hybrid please submit here: www.remoteworkconference.org/call-for-papers -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
CALL FOR PAPERS:
Brexit Conference, London, May 15, 2025.
Hosted at Queen Mary and Westfield College, London. Themes including labor markets, investment, innovation, trade and political economy.
Submit by March 30th here: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfcbnuXvQsxM53mik0w8ppy-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
At the American Economics Association I gave an overview on Working from Home trends, facts, figures and research. If anyone is interested here are the slides. Free to share, use for teaching, discussions etc.
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/m0d5rtg202t78ajg91vij/AEA_Jan2025.… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great to be joining the Roam panel.
Also a good way to try out a new hybrid and remote technology - Roam is a coordination and communication device for firms with WFH employees.
Roam
@roam
RTO has been capturing headlines but the latest data around distributed work might surprise you!
Join Fortune’s @thier_jane, Atlassian’s Annie Dean, Stanford’s @I_Am_NickBloom and Work Forward’s Brian Elliott for an exclusive discussion in Roam:
“Remote, Hybrid, or RTO? Headlines Versus Hard Facts”
When: Wednesday, November 20th, 1pm ET
Where: Virtual - The Willy Wonka Theater in Roam
Sign Up Now - docs.google.com/forms/d/1j5ZqDO0EKRjiR2Gb1HsBvz2VnEhZduL9… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Jean Chatzky
@JeanChatzky
Is remote work costing you money?
On this #hermoneypodcast, Stanford economist @I_Am_NickBloom and I are breaking down the data on remote work, plus how to succeed in a digital workplace.
Find the episode wherever you get your podcasts. 🎧This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hi everyone - the Empirical Management Conference call for papers is posted below. This will be at Harvard Business School in December (date and location chosen for the fantastically hot sunny weather :-).
Please submit your papers using the link below.
Raffaella Sadun
@raffasadun
Super excited to announce the 10th edition of the Empirical Management Conference, which will gake place at HBS on December 12/13 2024.
Please submit your papers at the link below.
worldmanagementsurvey.org/emc2024/
Cc @danielascur @renata__lemos @I_Am_NickBloom @johnvanreenen -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great event on management, AI and growth at the LSE on Thursday 13th June, 1-2pm.
Programme on Innovation and Diffusion
@POID_LSE
📢 Event: How much does management matter in an era of disruption? | 13 June, 1-2pm | Yangzte Lecture Theatre, LSE @danielascur @TeraPauliina @johnvanreenen
Registration
In-person forms.cloud.microsoft/pages/responsepage.aspx?id=_epnVXfn…
Online lse.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZMsdOygrj4sH9On13_BAydlwMtd…
Find out more ➡️ poid.lse.ac.uk/events/event.asp?index=9654 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Working from Home surged online shopping as a share of retail sales by about 2%, an extra $400bn a year.
We all need breaks, and being able to use these to shop while WFH is valuable. Indeed, I've already made one on-line order today :-)
WSJ story www.wsj.com/lifestyle/workplace/online-shopping-work-from… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Soumaya Keynes
@SoumayaKeynes
This week for the @FT I wrote about Labour's dullness dividend. The hope is that stability => investment => growth. But what does the evidence suggest about how big that effect could be?
1st 300 clicks free to read:
enterprise-sharing.ft.com/redeem/cf99a3af-bb36-4c3d-ac31-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In the SWAA survey with Gable we discovered many RTOs are struggling, with frequent RTO reruns. Amazingly 6% of employees have had five or more attempts. In the US alone that's almost 10 million employees. Imagine having 5, 6 or even 7 RTOs :-(
Data hello.gable.to/rto-2.0-return-to-in-person -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Join me at Stanford for "the Future of the Indian Economy" with Megha Patnaik, Rohini Chakravarthy and Naushad Forbes.
Wednesday May 22nd from 4:30-5:45 followed by a food and drinks reception in the beautiful Gunn SIEPR building
Registration: kingcenter.stanford.edu/events/lectures-discussions/speak…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
-
Nick Bloom reposted
Cevat Giray Aksoy
@cevatgirayaksoy
Our new NBER working paper is out!
NBER
@nberpubs
A study of 34 countries finds that, culture — in particular individualism — is the biggest factor explaining international differences in working from home, from @PabloZarate98, Dolls, Davis, @I_Am_NickBloom, @Jose_MariaRD, and @cevatgirayaksoy www.nber.org/papers/w32374
-
Nick Bloom reposted
Soumaya Keynes
@SoumayaKeynes
A great piece from @TheEconomist's @alice_fulwood a few weeks ago mentioned the rise of the remote husband, ie men working fully remote with spouses working in person. I asked @I_Am_NickBloom if he could help me put some numbers to the trend...
(thanks also to @MertAkanEcon) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Conference on Remote Work
Stanford CA, from October 9-11
Please submit papers on the measurement, cause and effect of hybrid and remote work. Conference will be in person with a live Zoom broadcast.
Submission: forms.gle/1X22U224hEgCup3F6
Call: wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/RWCCallforPape… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Some folks claim "working from home is bad for mental health". We surveyed 4,000 people to find out.
The data shows people are very different. It appears choice and flexibility are best for mental health (and not 5-day return to office mandates). -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
London Underground - known as "the Tube" to locals - has just defined Friday as off peak all day. Offices and the Tube are how half empty on Friday as we WFH :-)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Americans are moving away from the office. Employees hired in 2023 now live 35 miles from office, up from 10 miles in 2019.
So firms now are hiring in a much bigger area.
Which is why RTOs are now so hard - folks don't live near the office anymore.
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/00tqwffwrl1vcdz4jb6p9/DistanceToWo…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hi all - here is the Excel file to replicate these figures if anyone wants to reproduce them (we had a few requests for the underlying data for the figures).
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/1tmkjitwnp3kdco1n2ou6/mean_distanc…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Just saw this from Torsten Slok showing the rising office Vacancy rate. All part of the same trend - as folks move further away and come into the office less vacancy rates keep rising.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fantastic to see @nealemahoney taking over as Director of SIEPR. Super to have him leading @SIEPR , a hugely important and influential research and policy institute. Many thanks to @markduggan_econ for his outstanding leadership before :-)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great British humor - fun piece in the Financial Times on working from home productivity, trends, wages etc.
www.ft.com/products
Just reading the comments and came across this gem :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
CEOs and CFOs predict WFH is here to stay.
Data from a top quality survey: 2,274 managers were polled, over 90% are CEOs or CFOs. The survey is run by the Bank of England, UK and US universities. It was founded in 2016 and funded by the @ESRC independent research foundation. It samples firms balanced by size, age, industry and region.
Recently, it asked about WFH practices 5 years ago, today, and 5 years from now. Company leaders report WFH has stabilized, with predicted 2028 levels the same as 2023 levels.
So the RTO debate should end. There is no RTO and leaders confirm this. Yes some firms are going back. But yes others are leaving the office. The data say these two groups are *balanced*.
To find the truth focus on data not anecdotes :-)
FT Piece: www.ft.com/products
Article: cepr.org/voxeu/columns/managers-say-working-home-here-stay -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Important paper showing the gains to mothers and society from WFH. A 10% increase in WFH is shown to increase mothers employment by 1%. This is particularly true in professions which are more family unfriendly, like finance and marketing. Two implications:
1) WFH is driving faster economic growth by increasing the labor-supply of mothers. This is a huge benefit to society, and likely one reason for the post-pandemic surge in US economic growth.
2) WFH supports children's development by allowing parents to spend more time with them. This provides individual family benefits, and also wider social and economic benefits.
So the big-name CEOs and Politicians claiming WFH is damaging growth have got it 100% wrong. WFH is likely powering the current economic boom by increasing labor supply and productivity, while also improving personal and family time.
Paper: drive.google.com/file/d/1Z1J2GHZjqkWzRV5ygA02yzSemwkAmzne…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Realize I forgot to link to the two authors, my fantastic friends and colleagues Emma Harrington (@emma_k_h) and Matt Kahn (@mattkahn1966).
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks to everyone who reported my twitter Doppelganger account.
It was ruthlessly impersonating me. Relentlessly posting boring WFH tweets, punctuated with the odd Brexit, football and bad British teeth posts.
But there was only room for one of us. So I had to shut it down. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fantastic game with a big crowd fueled by free beer :-)
Against all predictions the faculty held on for a 3-3 draw. We didn't deserve it but rode our luck . With three players 50+ (including one Nobel prize winner) amazing we completed the full 90 minutes.
Stanford Economics
@StanfordEcon
Stanford Econ inaugural student/faculty soccer match! 3-3! Everyone's happy!
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Very cool - fantastic work on CEOs by @orianabandiera @raffasadun @andreapratnyc @StephenEKHansen and Renata Lemos, and love the Klopp connection.
Imran Rasul
@ImranRasul3
What do @orianabandiera and Jurgen Klopp @lfc have in common?
- top man management skills
- high energy
-enjoy saying gegenpress
- both feature in this @TheEconomist piece on superstar CEOs....
www.economist.com/business/2024/01/29/jurgen-klopp-and-th…
@raffasadun @I_Am_NickBloom -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper studying the impact of 137 Return to Office mandates on S&P500 firms from 2020-2023. Three key results:
1) RTO mandates are more likely in firms with poor recent stock performance, and in those with powerful male CEOs.
2) Glassdoor data finds RTO mandates significantly reduce employee ratings for job satisfaction, work-life balance and senior management.
3) There is no significant impact of RTO mandates on either firm profitability or firm stock-returns.
My interpretation is that RTO mandates are often a response to poor recent company performance, perhaps adopted by under-pressure CEOs. These RTO mandates upset employees, but do not appear to yield performance benefits in return.
Paper: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4675401 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I gave a talk at CoreNet Global on the impact of WFH on Real-Estate. Summary:
1) WFH is here to stay - since 2023 it is "Flat as a Pancake"
2) Impact on office real-estate is negative, but less so than the 50% drop in days due to the "Hybrid Squeeze" - days are squeezed into Tues-Thurs
3) Impact on residential is strongly positive - increasing overall demand, particularly in the suburbs due to the "Donut Effect"
4) Impact on retail is positive - increased overall demand for leisure activities, particularly in suburbs from the "Donut Effect"
5) Industrial real-estate is relatively unimpacted
6) WFH longer-run will gradually grow - the direction of travel is upwards
Slides: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/tiz3vslxaz7zoe9kn9yar/CoreNet.pptx… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
What do you think is the biggest societal problem we are facing right now? Climate change, war, fractured politics, nuclear proliferation or perhaps global poverty?
According to a big office real-estate developer it's work from home. Yes really. See the quote below and watch the CBS interview. You can't make this stuff up.
As the Upton Sinclair quote goes: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
CBS interview: www.cbsnews.com/news/real-estate-owners-saddled-with-half… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New data on WFH and grooming. Interesting, scary and smelly:
1) Average grooming time saved by WFH is 5 minutes for men and 12 minutes for women - for women on a hybrid schedule that's a day per year
2) For women the big time saving is less make-up, for men it's less shaving
3) Folks get more sleep when they WFH - a big health benefit
4) Teeth brushing is down for folks that WFH - so be nice to your dentist :-)
5) Surely the best reason to WFH - only 95% of people brush their teeth, 89% wear fresh clothes, and 88% use deodorant when they come to work :-(
Full gory details: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/4op0agncnxjwuz098b9m7/grooming.ppt… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Catherine Rampell
@crampell
It's well-known that remote workers get time back that they might have otherwise spent commuting. But on days they work from home, workers also save time on other things, such as grooming.
Chart via @I_Am_NickBloom /SWAA data. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Prize for the most unexpected figure goes to this.
Media sentiment ranks Cheese>WFH>Beards. Who would have known? And so many questions. If you are Lionel Messi - who has a beard and eats cheese - how do you rank? Why do beards score so badly?
Report: drive.google.com/file/d/1wZT37vtHchP24qpZBZiaszqr5jqXFOgB… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This is a great paper, but it is *massively* misunderstood.
It does not show that WFH reduces innovation. This paper and its follow-up actually suggests by 2023 that WFH increases innovation. To explain:
1) This paper is about *collocation* not *WFH*. They are completely different. If two people share the same office address - even if they are both hybrid or remote - they would be classified as collocated. For example, my co-author Steve Davis and I both work a hybrid schedule at Stanford, coming to the office maybe 2 days a week. We both have a Stanford office address on papers. So, for this paper we would count as being *collocated*. Indeed, almost all hybrid WFH teams would count as collocated.
2) Co-author teams are becoming more dispersed. The paper reports the average distance between team members offices has increased from 100km to 1,000km over the last 60 years. This reveals that tens of thousands of scientists are choosing to work in more global teams, presumably to access a wider network of experts. I co-author with researchers across five continents because it lets me work with great people. If teams of elite scientists, whose entire careers are focused on cutting-edge innovation, are becoming more dispersed it suggests it has major benefits.
3) The results do not hold after 2010. This is critical as Zoom and Dropbox cloud file sharing emerged after 2010. Indeed the follow-up paper by Carl Frey (one of the co-authors) and Giorgio President from Oxford shows innovation is *higher* for remote collaboration after 2010! drive.google.com/file/d/1vLk_GrG_b7XxKoOCZEfPyGqu6AO0zSu3…
So a fantastic paper - it deserves to be published in Nature. But to understand it you need to read beyond the title. You can't judge a book by its cover, nor a Nature paper by its 6 word title.
And please forward this to any mangers or CEOs claiming this implies WFH reduces innovation. It does not - indeed points (2) and (3) suggest exactly the reverse.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Indeed, the latest research by the Oxford research team Carl Frey and Giorgio Presidente shows that remote collaboration *increases* innovation after 2010 (so in 2023 for sure). See figure.
Full paper: drive.google.com/file/d/1vLk_GrG_b7XxKoOCZEfPyGqu6AO0zSu3…
Presentation (at 8:00 mins): www.youtube.com/watch?v=uSGmmcmPPas&t=9380s&ab_channel=Re… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Really interesting - WFH led to a big increase in cafes and eating out (spending time at home leads you to want to go out for lunch/evening). Also a drop in spending on cars (less need to commute).
I feel like that Sixth Sense quote "I see WFH everywhere" :-)
Tera Allas CBE | @teraallas.bsky.social
@TeraPauliina
COVID-19, #inflation, the energy cost crisis, and muted economic growth have shifted consumers' spending patterns, but some trends (more on education, IT; less on tobacco, newspapers) are also persistent. #wfh shows up clearly in big drop in transport and "canteen" consumption.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New Harvard Business Review article on WFH.
Summary: Levels of WFH are highly unequal - common among professionals and managers, but rare for front line staff. Business leaders worry this divide could hurt staff morale, and risk longer-run WFH progress.
Four possible steps to address this:
1) Leaders should recognize concerns about "them and us" - this is real (I hear these worries frequently from executives).
2) Reduce gaps in managers and front-line schedules. This means in some industries - like food service, accommodation and manufacturing - managers may have more in-person time to connect with employees.
3) Improve front-line flexibility - for example consider shifts of four days at 10-hours rather than five days at 8-hours.
4) Allow pay adjustments to compensate for the highly uneven benefits associated with remote work.
There is no perfect solution, but within firms and at the national scale a big WFH "them v us" divide will threaten progress.
Article: hbr.org/2023/12/research-the-growing-inequality-of-who-ge… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New research from University of Chicago randomized job attributes – including salary – for 1200 on-line applicants in Brazil. They use the number of applications per job-posting to calculate the implied valuation employees placed on these attributes. For example, if 10% higher salary generates as many job applications as WFH, this would be valued at +10% of salary.
They found work from home was the single most valuable attribute they considered, worth the same as +15% more salary. This was more valuable to job-seekers than a private pension (worth +8%), meal allowance (worth +8%), dental assistance (worth +7%) or an in-office gym (worth +6%).
This valuation may be high as WFH is less common in Brazil. But the same logic provides a strong incentive for firms in regions where WFH is less common - like Asia, South America and Africa - to offer this to attract top employees.
Paper: bfi.uchicago.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/BFI_WP_2023-1… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The Bureau of Economic Analysis data shows a 50% surge in US corporate profits after 2020. At the same time the SWAA data shows US WFH levels increased 6x. Connecting these is hard as many other things changed at the same time. Inflation, government spending, interest rates, lockdowns, labor markets, supply-chains, pandemic mortality etc. However, most of these were negative, so lowered profits.
Add to this the research finding WFH increases profitability by cutting recruitment, retention and office costs, and the evidence nods to WFH boosting profits. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Big WFH losers
1) City center office and retail real-estate owners
2) Mass transit rail systems
3) Big cities, with falling tax revenues
Big WFH winners are
1) WFH employees
2) Environment
3) Firms
Importantly, maybe >10x as many winners as losers
www.wsj.com/lifestyle/workplace/work-from-home-impact-rev… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
First and last TikTok post. The New York Times has opinion piece writers shoot a video for their TikTok site. The fact it took me 2 months to do this tells you how many retakes & edits were needed. Also provided much entertainment for my teenage kids :-)
www.tiktok.com/@nytopinion/video/7311413586939923758?lang=en -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tomorrow until Friday we are hosting the Empirical Management Conference in Stanford. Any local academics are welcome to attend. Rapid fire set of papers on management and related themes.
Schedule: drive.google.com/file/d/1zg4qjQSgZr1xkeGFV5Uj6sa71cVW6kt4…
Registration: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeAsVnvjAc4c84RnRgIMwj7A… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Rolando Rosas
@TheRoRosas
🚀Why going back to the office might full time not be the best idea productivity-wise! Does working remotely truly reduce productivity? Nick reveals that the evidence overwhelmingly supports hybrid work's productivity. Surprisingly, employees working at least two to three days a
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Not everyone believes WFH is here to stay. I suspect quite a few people are against this, but stay quiet because it's an unpopular view. I get this kind of email regularly. I reply and discuss when it is not offensive. Maybe this is the hidden resistance to hybrid and remote WFH?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Examining air travel data and found something surprising. US passenger miles are back to pre-pandemic *levels* at 88bn miles a month. But they are 12bn miles below the pre-pandemic *trend*. Travel grows as people get richer and population grows, so the trend is the real benchmark
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Interestingly as Torsten Slok just showed this morning it's not happening in private jet travel, which looks to have rebounded above levels and trend.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH levels have become "flat as a pancake". The latest Census, SWAA and Kastle data all show the same thing. Levels of WFH were falling throughout 2020 to 2022, and office occupancy was rising. That trend ended in 2023, with both now pancake flat. Return to the Office is dead.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A few questions on the source for this data. It comes from www.wfhresearch.com on the data page (you can get this anytime).
For this chart here is a simple replication file as well: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/gkddn3pcl1l3vi9lvdamg/WFHtimeserie… -
Nick Bloom reposted
David McKenzie
@dmckenzie001
What prevents Indian housewives from local flexible work opportunities? Today's job market post is a nice experiment by @suhani_jalota that randomizes offers to work at home vs work in an office & wage rates. blogs.worldbank.org/impactevaluations/what-prevents-india…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A driver of WFH productivity - the flexibility to deal with the unexpected. Everything from a freeway shut-down to a snow dump, a metro strike, or the Olympics in town. If you are hybrid it's easy to switch to remote for a few days.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Our paper the "Evolution of Working from Home" just published pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.37.4.23 overviewing the latest WFH data, trends, and research. Summary points:
1) WFH levels dropped in 2020-2022, then stabilized in 2023
2) Self-employed and gig workers are 3x more likely to be fully remote than salary workers (if you are your own boss you WFH a lot more)
3) Huge variation by industry, with IT having 5x WFH level of food service
4) WFH rises with density, and is 2x higher in cities than rural areas
5) WFH levels peak for folks in their 30s and early 40s (kids at home), those in their 20s have lower levels (mentoring, socializing and small living spaces)
6) Similar WFH levels by gender pre, during and post-pandemic
7) Much higher levels of WFH for graduates with kids under 14 at home
8) Productivity impact of hybrid WFH about zero. Productivity impact of fully-remote varied, dependent on how well managed this is.
9) Future will see rising levels of fully remote (the Nike Swoosh). -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
It is frustrating hearing anecdotes from a few high-profile CEOs and politicians about the end of WFH. If we look at the data instead we see it is the Return to Office died in early 2023. Since then office occupancy and WFH have been flat across the US.
www.nytimes.com/2023/10/16/opinion/office-work-home-remot… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
www.nytimes.com/2023/10/10/business/remote-work-effects.html
NYT overview of WFH research from the Remote Work Conference www.hoover.org/events/implications-remote-work
Emma Goldberg attended the conference and had a great write-up. Key points include:
- Productivity: Remote work can be positive if it's well managed, and negative if it's done at speed during a pandemic with poor training, equipment and software.
- Cities: WFH shifted retail spending from city centers to the suburbs. Longer-run positive impacts on affordability as WFH allows folks to live further away, expanding housing land supply.
- Crime: WFH can cut suburban burglaries a lot (30%) as more folks are at home with "eyes on the street". In reverse, possibly rising crime in some now emptier city centers.
- Working women: Positive effects from increased labor supply, but possibly less feedback when working remotely. Also bias in implicit assumptions about where missing employees are - women more likely to be presumed attending to family duties, men presumed more likely to be playing golf. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Videos and papers from last week's 2023 Remote Work Conference have been posted. This is a fantastic resources of papers, presentations and discussion. Much of this will come out in the media in the next few weeks as we had several journalists attending, but you can see it here first :-)
www.hoover.org/events/implications-remote-work
Big themes include:
1) Productivity - evidence showing a positive impact of WFH, especially with offsites and good performance management
2) Gender - the unequal impact on women, both negatives (greater suspicion of not working) and positive (increased labor supply)
3) Cities - continued movement from city centers to the suburbs, and its impact on spending, office-buildings, tax-revenues and crime.
4) Taxes - if I WFH in CA for a NY firm whose state tax do I pay (answer: currently both - 2x tax). Why firms and people might move to cut tax bills. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Updated exec WFH slides (free to use and share) www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/kvh0jghr61ago7qm63t7m/September202….
Summary thoughts:
1) WFH levels: stabilized, with North America, UK & Australia highest, then Europe and South America, and Asia lowest.
2) Demographic variations by education (graduates about 2x levels of WFH) and age (highest for folks in 30s and early 40s).
3) Strategy: Hybrid popular for employee retention and recruitment. Fully-remote saves on office costs and enables national/global hiring
4) Management: Coordinate days together for hybrid, make in-person valuable for in-person activities, focus on good performance evaluations, and software to coordinate effective space and office use
5) Impact: Donut effect emptying city-centers, less commuting is speeding up the morning commute, and golf has taken off midweek :-)
Feedback is helpful thanks - these are continuously updated -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
It is frustrating reading articles on the productivity impact of WFH based on anecdotes from CEOs and politicians. These policies impact millions of employees, so should be grounded in data and research.
I summarized for The Hill what we know, covering the three main sources. These show mostly positive productivity impacts of WFH:
1) Micro-economic studies: these find small positive impacts of hybrid WFH on productivity, and mixed impacts of fully-remote WFH (negative when it's badly managed, positive when its well-managed).
2) Macro data: this shows US productivity growth accelerated as levels of WFH have jumped, suggesting a positive impact
3) Market data: this reveals massive adoption of WFH by firms globally and mostly favorable feedback from managers, suggesting a positive impact.
thehill.com/opinion/technology/4228100-does-working-from-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
An important new paper in the Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences. www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/hvnu4vsvfdjw6h6dg3k64/tao-et-al-20…
This calculates the impact of WFH frequency from 0 to 5 days a week on carbon emissions. It combines commuting, non-commuting travel (e.g. driving to buy lunch if you WFH), office energy, home energy and ICT energy.
It finds moving to 2 days a week reduces carbon use by 11%, 4 days by 29% and 5 days a week by a staggering 58%. This mainly from by less commuting and closing offices. We know commuting is energy intensive, but only after reading this did I realize offices are also huge energy users.
For firms this highlights how a supportive WFH policy can deliver progress on climate objectives. Indeed, these effects are so large that WFH policies are likely to be one of the most powerful tools for companies trying to reduce their carbon footprint. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Reminder the Remote Work Conference is running *today* until Friday. We start with a video welcome from Jack Nilles to celebrate the 50th anniversary of his pioneering work on Telecommuting.
Schedule www.remoteworkconference.org
Zoom broadcast sign-up stanford.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_aYikA_NIQtW2wRM_CCLL2A -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Being Friday we thought we would look at the latest www.wfhresearch.com data. We find that Friday continues to consolidate it's grip as "the" WFH day. And the 4-day week is becoming reality, at least in terms of folks being in the office.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Should firms set pay fully remote workers on a local, national or global pay scale? Local pay can cause problems. One manager told me an employee complained that another's pay did not match their location. They noticed "the beach in their Zoom background" for somebody claiming to live in an inland city. This caused a team split and disciplinary investigation.
Time editorial: time.com/6313745/remote-work-compensation/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Least surprising news of the week: "Firm forces remote employees back to the office - almost half quit within 2 weeks"
This is predictable. The chart below shows that 30% of Americans want to be fully remote. Grindr had been operating like this for 3 years. So presumably their current employees had grown to like this. They had presumably grown to like this really quite a lot.
So when they got the news cancelling this, requiring many of them to move across the country, the predictable happened. A mass quit.
Presumably Grindr managers were aware of this? So was this just a quick downsize? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Will the surge in #wfh media end? I used to think so, but looking at total daily US newspaper data coverage not so sure. WFH newspaper media has stabilized at 5x it's 2019 level. That is very similar to actual WFH days, which have also stabilized at 5x their 2019 level. So maybe this is permanent.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The 2023 Remote Work Conference, September 27th to 29th. Program here: www.remoteworkconference.org
Conference will be broadcast live on Zoom. Sign-up for the Zoom link here: stanford.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_aYikA_NIQtW2wRM_CCLL2A -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Some good news for labor day.
Labor force participation for Americans with a disability is up almost 5% vs trend (trend defined as pre-pandemic average or those without a disability). This implies 1.7m more working Americans. WFH is likely a driver by removing the commute, which can be harder for those with a disability. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Car commuters benefit from #wfh employees making their drives faster. The surge in WFH has halved the level of city rush-hour traffic, speeding up driving speeds by 13%. For the average 5-day commuter this is over 30 minutes of time saved.
Washington Post www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/08/28/return-to-offi… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Maybe the best evidence that #wfh is here to say - CEOs and CFOs say so. The SBU polled leaders at 500 US firms in July 2023 asking them about 2018, 2023, and 2028 future working. As the chart shows, executives expect hybrid and fully-virtual to grow.
HBR hbr.org/2023/08/survey-remote-work-isnt-going-away-and-ex… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This is a push for data >>> spin.
First, amazing job by Smucker - this is one of the best media hits I have seen for a while. Their PR department and CEO have scored a home-run.
But while the WSJ is fantastic this news story is problematic. The title is particularly misleading (which in fairness to the journalist they don't choose). Who knows if the employees like this WFH policy? Maybe they do. Maybe they don't. Probably there is a mix. It appears the WSJ just talked to the CEO, a couple of senior execs and some (almost surely hand-picked) employees. This group are obviously going to say the company is the best, and by the way here are some nice photos of our delicious products that you might want to buy :-)
I'm going to use this as a call to avoid basing WFH policy on spin pieces like this or the Zoom ones from two weeks ago claiming "Zoom cancels WFH".
We should focus on data and research - five good resources below:
Flex Index: www.flex.scoopforwork.com
What the Flex: www.bcg.com/publications/2023/flexible-working-models
Future forum: futureforum.com
WFH Research: www.wfhresearch.com
Kastle: www.kastle.com/safety-wellness/getting-america-back-to-work
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
By the way the article itself is interesting - it's a good read, lively discussions and some nice photos. It is just the title is completely disconnected. The sub-editor who put this in should have been fact checked. The WSJ fact checks articles regularly - they are a great source of news that I read every day - but it seems nobody fact checked the title. That's pretty odd as it's the most read part.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid WFH employees spend 50% of their day in meetings, 2x that of fully in person or fully remote. One explanation might be job difference, but this data is for employees with at least a 4-year degree. Not sure why, or even which I would prefer?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Gave a summary talk on measuring uncertainty today at the great Swedish House of Finance Conference. Here are the slides if these are of any use.
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/snkzd6w0c0k5wn0z0de5r/Stockholm3.p… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Big debate over paying remote workers on a local or global salary scale. I advise firms to move to a global scale - everyone gets paid the same wherever they live. Four advantages:
1) Easier to manage - no-body wants to be checking on employees locations.
2) Flexible for employees - they can move without worrying about pay.
3) Profitable - economics has long suggested paying employees the "marginal product of labor" to maximize profit (see Wikipedia), basically pay for the job.
4) Simpler - avoids HR having to manage multiple pay scales.
The one challenge is transitional. During the pandemic many employees were sent to work remotely in a rush, but kept their local pay rates (which made sense at the time). But the pandemic is passing and WFH has stabilized, so now is the time to adopt a global pay scale.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
As an anecdote to motivate this in an Exec Session last week one manager said that regional pay was creating major headaches for their remote team. One employee was supposed to be in a wealthy Northern European country capital but was instead in a holiday resort in Southern Europe. They were doing their job well, no problems, but the manager was in a quandry as the pay-scales in the Southern European location were a lot lower and another employee had just complained to her. What to do - ideally you would ignore it, but now another employee formally complains so you can't?
Hence this post - this topic comes up a bunch talking to execs and this region varying pay scales always create these kinds of headaches.... -
Nick Bloom reposted
Jena McGregor
@jenamcgregor
The war over work from home rages on. Thanks to @I_Am_NickBloom, @brianpelliott, @prithwic and more for helping us sort through what the data says on remote work amid all the opinions and debate. @Forbes www.forbes.com/sites/jenamcgregor/2023/08/19/the-war-over…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid WFH has blurred the weekday/weekend boundary. About 50% of hybrid employees are working full-days on Saturday/Sunday. In reverse almost 10% are not working on a given week day. This could be good by exploiting WFH flexibility, or bad if work-life boundaries have collapsed.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
And yes posting this on Saturday was reflective of this - the level of Twitter use on weekends is pretty stunning. For some it is leisure surfing around on Twitter, but for some I think is breaks from work (Twitter is part of work).
And yes for me it's it is still called Twitter -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A key reason why #wfh will grow over time - cohort effects. Young firms are much more remote. As they grow some of them will turn into the medium and larger firms of the future. This cohort effect is slow but steady, driving WFH levels up in the next few years.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Kastle US office occupancy data is down for the last 4 weeks straight. Employees are not returning to the office - they are leaving the office. Maybe holidays, heat, or the women's world cup?
A disconnect between the "Everyone is back to the office" news headlines and the data. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Steve Roth, chairman of real estate giant Vornado said Fridays are "dead forever" for office use. It looks like he was right - Friday has become the day to #wfh. There is now a 3-part week:
Monday to Thursday - the office is open and half-full
Friday - the office is open and empty
Saturday and Sunday - the office is closed
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
To note this is a sample of hybrid workers working 4+ days a week, and only considers days they are working. So fully-remote, fully-in-person and part-time employees are not included.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is the raw data is anyone wants to plot the figure www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/ojeo9k5hp1invyrfjnjuc/wfh_by_day_d…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Also accidently tagged the wrong Mert Akan, should be my collaborator @MertAkanecon
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
After the debate about Zoom "returning to the office" remember this is just one firm. The latest Kastle data out today shows office occupancy down for the last two weeks. The SWAA data out yesterday shows July WFH levels up (in part due to July 4th). More importantly both series are flat over 2023. So yes some US firms are returning to more office time, but others are leaving, and the total is flat.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A lot of media about Zoom calling employees "back to the office". Three points as this has been hugely misunderstood:
1) This is only back to the office for 2 days a week. Only for employees within 50 miles of an office. So what they have said could also be stated as "you can WFH 3 days a week if you live nearby, more if you live far away".
2) They have been operating like this for a long-time. I had lunch with Eric Yuan at Zoom HQ in September 2022 and most employees were already hybrid then. So this is just formalizing a long-existing operating practice.
3) This is a sensible decision - they own a lot of office space and have local employees. If you are paying for office space and high Bay Area salaries it makes sense to operate on a hybrid schedule (see slide 25 www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/jyh4nm6a6g1uhg61qzkv3/Exec_Aug2023…). They are formalizing this to make it easier to operate and coordinate.
Power Lunch
@PowerLunch
With video-conferencing company Zoom calling its workers back to the office, the fight for work from home seems like a lost cause. But career strategist @JulieBauke and Stanford's Nick Bloom @I_Am_NickBloom says the opposite is true.
#wfh #employmentThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Another benefit of #wfh - sick employees are more likely to stay home. In our July survey 633 employees reported being sick or injured the prior week. We asked them what they did. Worryingly even if they could WFH 39% came to work. Worse, if they could not WFH 76% came to work.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WSJ investment tip. Short companies cutting WFH and long companies increasing WFH. Managers that see growth slowing care less about attrition so cut WFH, managers that see growth picking up need to hire so expand WFH.
www.wsj.com/articles/need-to-hire-workers-in-a-hot-job-ma…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
By the way there is no implication of causality here. WFH may or may not cause higher growth. But it is a useful indicator. Kind of like saying "buy companies whose managers have a big smile".....
Basically firms looking to cut employees reduce WFH, and that's informative :-)
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
And here is the underlying report the WSJ took the chart from www.flex.scoopforwork.com/reports/job-growth
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I analyzed the latest European and US productivity data, finding productivity growth accelerated after 2020. This is surprising given the impact of the pandemic and lockdowns. So what could have caused this productivity boost? Perhaps the global surge in working from home?
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
US source data for Productivity: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/n571zjcbjqfi6h6928p54/OPHNFB.xlsx?…
US source data for WFH: wfhresearch.com/data/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Call for papers - Empirical Management Conference - in Stanford Dec noon 13th to noon Dec 15th. Please submit empirical research papers on management practices. Organized with Renata Lemos, Raffaella Sadun, Daniela Scur and John Van Reenen.
worldmanagementsurvey.org/emc2023/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Kastle office-use data is great, and the text sometimes makes me chuckle. Rises in office-use are part of normal activity, but falls are just some extraordinary event. Like company jargon - good news is normal, bad news is some extreme one-off excuse...
www.cnbc.com/2015/10/09/10-worst-corporate-excuses-ever.html -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
City centers have seen the "donut effect" of hybrid and fully-remote WFH employees moving to the suburbs. San Francisco has also been hit by a tech slow down, and high business taxes. It's a big challenge, and unclear how to respond.
Donut Effect Paper: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8vyuxrmfqfmh5ew53fofb/Paper2022.pd…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
On trend since 2019Q1 sales taxes might have increased about 2% a year with real economic growth and another 5% from inflation fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL So 2023Q1 nominal sales taxes might have been up about 25% since 2019Q1, but are instead down 11%.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Maybe the biggest indicator WFH is permanent is that online shopping, eating out, sports attendance, travel and most other activities are back to pre-pandemic trends. WFH - and related activities like office occupancy and public transit use - appear to have permanently changed.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The pandemic created a jump-up in remote tech jobs, particularly in less common languages like TypeScript, GraphQL and Postgres, suggesting more global hiring of unusual tech skills. For many technical jobs labor markets are becoming global. blog.spatial.chat/tracking-hackernews-shifting-preference…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Golf is booming. Given strong productivity this is good: US employees are taking leisure in the day when it is light and making-up work in the evening.
Also reshaping the economy: spreads golf, gym, shopping and other leisure asset use more evenly.
Data www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/0veejuzo6ylm7oqx18rmc/GolfingFromH… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece on how technology is allowing more jobs to go remote. Includes drive-through, receptionists, fast-food, laundry and tow-truck dispatchers. This technology impact is why WFH days flatlined in 2023 (see SWAA data) and should be rising by 2025.
www.usatoday.com/story/money/2023/07/25/blue-collar-remot…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is the monthly WFH data for the US showing how this has been flat through 2023.
Source wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/WFHResearch_up…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is Kastle office occupancy - also flat over 2023.
Source: www.kastle.com/safety-wellness/getting-america-back-to-work/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Nice WSJ piece, key points
1) People take breaks at the office and home
2) Breaks taken at home are more valuable: you choose what and when
3) There can be benefits of in-person office interactions, although a mix may be best (eg www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/4hkbpq5r8w229j0ixbrzn/pnas.1802407…)
www.wsj.com/articles/how-workers-really-spend-their-days-…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Ungated version www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/runrj2uicqkyjhitftdh3/wsj.com-How-…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New @roam data on meetings with video+audio or audio only, finding
1) Audio is preferred in small quick meetings: like a phone call
2) Video is preferred in larger longer meetings: like a Zoom call
3) Video is popular mornings, audio in afternoons
Slides www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/dz27as5apiaqmbqcyde2i/VideoOn.pptx…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
To note the sample size is 160,000 meeting participations across a range of firm sizes, ages and industries.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Quantification of average WFH gains:
1) Commute time, saving 1 hour a day
2) Commute costs, saving $20 a day (& less pollution)
3) Flexibility, part of the 8% WFH pay valuation
4) Less grooming, saving 10 minutes a day
Source: www.linkedin.com/posts/nick-bloom-86b79510b_approximate-q…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
To the great @DianeSwonk question the time saved on less grooming comes from this....not sure you want to look at this figure too closely.....
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
To @techversality thanks for the question - the figure is time saved, here broken down by gender
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Spent the day at beautiful Glasgow University, and saw the Adam Smith statue (with Anton Muscatelli) on Smith's 300th anniversary.
Visiting Glasgow's Adam Smith statue was free, while visiting London's Karl Marx's grave cost £4.
Capitalism v Communism in practice and theory :-)
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Also the university has the most unique offices for Econ (about to go as they are moving to a sparkling new building for the Adam Smith business school). They have pillars in some offices as it sits in a charming old Victorian building, which was cool.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here with @ProfGraemeRoy, @UofGVC and
@BaskayaSoner in our Adam Smith mini-festival.
Turned out Graeme is a world class bagpiper, formerly of Field Marshal Montgomery band (the current world champs). Like meeting a pipping David Beckham. Cool as my kids bagpipe :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Employees in their 30s have the highest work from home levels, in part from childcare demands.
One major gain from WFH are the benefits to parenting. So Governments concerned about fertility - e.g. much of Europe and Asia - should support WFH. Source: stanford.io/3JHqfrQ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Firms with more WFH grow faster.
Data on 3,600 US firms finds those requiring 0 days in the office see 5.6% growth. Those requiring all 5-days see only 2.6% growth.
My take-away is WFH increases recruitment and retention, which fuels company growth.
www.flex.scoopforwork.com/reports/job-growth -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There is a debate on the impact of #brexit. Brexit reduced UK GDP by 6% to 11% vs Europe and North America. This is a loss of £2,000 to £3,500 per person per year. In comparison the UK spend just £3,477 on the NHS per person in 2021.
Source: updated www.nber.org/papers/w26218
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
And yes this means if we had not had Brexit we could have used the extra growth to raise doctors and nurses salaries, expand capacity to reduce waiting times, and purchase more drugs and equipment.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
2023 Global Report on Working from Home wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/GSWA-2023.pdf
Summary
1) WFH about 1 day per week global average
2) English speaking countries highest levels, Asian countries lowest
3) Gap of about 1 day between average what employees want (2 days) and what firms offer (1 day) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Updated Exec Ed report on WFH. Key updates include:
1) US and international data through June 2023
2) Strategy on fully-in-person vs hybrid vs fully-remote
3) The hybrid-remote 2x2 matrix (stay on the diagonal)
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/e2rfwfnb3chvxjqw8xwr6/Exec_July202… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
What is the impact of WFH on productivity?
Hard to measure, so try US macro data:
1) WFH days rose 5-fold after 2020
2) Productivity growth rose 10% after 2020
Not conclusive - many many other things happened - but this at least suggests WFH is not some big productivity killer.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is WFH over the same period. Yes, the big 2020 surge occurred around the same time as the early pandemic productivity surge, and the drop from late 2020-2023 at the same time as the productivity drop. However, again, many many other things happened then as well.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The Economist highlights perhaps the biggest WFH issue - the battle between firms and employees. Globally employees want to WFH about 1 day a week more than firms, and that gap is not shrinking.
Long-run I think employees will win, with WFH rising.
www.economist.com/business/2023/07/10/the-fight-over-work… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New NBER research by Ben Cowan showing that working from home increases child-care. This highlights another WFH benefit - parents spend more time with their children. www.nber.org/papers/w31439
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Work from Home has seen an image overhaul. Screen shots of image searches from 2013 and 2023, showing:
1) Cartoons and naked people are gone, now mostly work themed images
2) Related searches go from "funny", "comics" and "underwear" to "make money", "jobs" and "business ideas" -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New SWAA data looks at the evolution of WFH locations. During 2020/21 WFH mostly meant "at home" because of COVID risks. By mid-2023 WFH has become shorthand for a broader set of places, like cafes, co-working spaces, and friends or family.
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/WFHResearch_up… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great charts from @biancoresearch showing
1) City transit use matches Kastle office use and SWAA WFH data.
2) They all show a 40% drop in office/transit use, matching 2 days WFH per week
3) WFH has been flat through 2023 - the return to office push seems to have died. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Asked about this. It is right, but can be misinterpreted:
1) Fully remote reduces average productivity in studies, but comes with large cost reductions.
2) Hybrid (which the article does not focus on) is flat on productivity, but improves retention.
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2023/06/28/the-wo… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New Stanford paper on working from home stanford.io/3JHqfrQ
Some key points:
1) WFH is up 500% since 2019
2) Fully-remote is much cheaper, but can lower productivity
3) Hybrid improves retention, with no productivity loss
4) WFH will keep growing as technology improves -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Co-Yurting spaces are here according to CNN edition.cnn.com/2023/07/01/business/coworking-spaces-rent…
SWAA data reveals 5% of days are worked from each of Public Places (Starbucks etc.), Co-Working Spaces and Friends Homes.
One is a Co-Yurting space in Portland at $350 per day from radious.pro :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Days WFH rose from 5% pre-pandemic to 28% today. Given an average US commute of 16 miles each way this saves Americans about 6 billion commuting miles a year, the same as 25 journeys to the moon.
It also saves about 12 billion hours commuting and 0.5 billion gallons of gas :-)
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Another way to see this (thanks to @2x4caster). This looks at vehicles miles travelled in the US from all sources. It suggests it is about 20 billion miles down vs trend, presumably mostly from WFH.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In our www.wfhresearch.com data we see folks working from home are not taking more or less breaks overall, but doing different things. WFH employees take more breaks for exercise, childcare and home chores. Office employees more breaks for phones, reading and gossip.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid workers - those with a mix of WFH and in person each week - have the most porous work-home boundaries. Each week they responded to almost 6 calls, messages and emails in evenings and weekends.
Maybe one downside of WFH is the blurring of work/non-work boundaries?
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great question from @Caleb_Parker
Flexibility is a major benefit of WFH (third after no-commuting and saving on travel costs). So more out-of-work communication could be employees flexing working time. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH employees use more electronic communications. Unsurprisingly they use more email, Teams, Zoom and Slack. Interestingly, they also make more office and personal phone calls.
As electronic communications are easier to monitor and record will WFH change the management of work? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
70% of fully-remote employees meet their co-workers at least once a year, and 45% at least once a month. So for start-ups and firms with fully-remote teams the norm is regular meet-ups, typically every one or two months.
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/WFHResearch_up…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
By the way pay varies a lot across these groups - the lowest paid never meet (so we think are more likely to be hourly paid data entry, call centers etc.). Higher paid employees tend to meet more regularly.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Free Stanford webinar on managing hybrid and remote teams on Wednesday June 28, 2023, 9:00-9:30 am PDT. Latest data, trends and management tips.
Sign-up below:
learn.stanford.edu/managing-hybrid-and-remote-workplace-w… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There have been claims by tech and finance folks that WFH is over, usually based on "my friends/clients/investors tell me......"
If you look at representative US data - like Census, SWAA or Kastle - WFH is flat from Jan to May 2023
For analyzing WFH trends big data >> anecdote -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Stanford Economics PhD student @LaurenH007 doing a fantastic job talking on Bloomberg TV about how there are finally more female S&P500 CEOs than those called John (updating the 2015 NYT piece on this).
www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2023-06-15/bloomberg-equali… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Huge variation across countries in WFH. Asia is almost back to pre-pandemic levels of office occupancy, while the US is still at about 50% of 2019 levels.
How will this evolve - maybe global convergence to a midpoint, with more WFH in Asia and less in the US? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The growth of WFH has been uneven across the US.
Biden voting parts of the country have more tech, finance and law jobs, so have seen a surge in WFH jobs. Trump voting places less so, so saw far less WFH job growth.
This risks a political divide in support for WFH.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Full data from www.wfhmap.com
Project with @StephenEKHansen, @pj_lambert, @raffasadun, @Bledi_Taska, @yabra_muvdi and Steve Davis -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH is shifting city centers activity from daytime to nighttime. WFH employees are heading into town after work, particularly on Friday and Saturday night.
For example, New York financial district restaurants have doubled night-time spending share since 2019.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Link to the underlying Mastercard report www.mastercardservices.com/en/reports-insights/economics-…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid is twice as common for employees in their 20s and 30s as 50+. Not sure why? Probably not education or industry as these are broadly similar across these age ranges. Maybe income or seniority? Maybe preferences, although as one data point I'm 50 and I like hybrid :-)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
More mentoring happens in person, particularly from senior managers. In the 50+ age group we see more than twice as much mentoring is provided when they work in person vs working remotely.
Source: www.wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
One factor behind the drift from all-remote to hybrid and fully in-person work is the ebbing of infection fears. By April 2023 less than 10% of US residents aged 20 to 64 were planning continued social distancing.
Source: www.wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There is a large difference in WFH levels across industries. Tech is high. Perhaps surprisingly finance, insurance and business services (e.g. law, accounting and marketing) are also high. In these industries WFH Monday and Friday is common for managers and professionals.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The gap between what employees want and what employers offer on WFH is closing, but not closed. On average employees want about 3 days WFH a week while employers are offering 2.5 days. Given this gap, offering generous WFH is still an effective recruitment and retention policy.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
About 10% of people WFH in a "third place" - a cafe, friends or family, or co-working space.
My favorite example is the London "Pub Desk".
Enjoy a pint of Guinness with your Zoom meeting (just remember to use the blur background). -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Just gave the @TheIFS annual lecture which was a fantastic event. Lovely personally as the IFS was my first job and the reason I ended up in academia. Also, being in London my parents aged 80 were able to come along, so very sweet.
Here are the slides: www.dropbox.com/s/srp50hvykd9plt2/IFS_Annual_Lecture.pptx…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The video kindly posted by the IFS if anyone is interested youtu.be/p0eQrP9YSe0
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Elon Musk has gone from business genius with Tesla and Space-X, to collapsing Twitter and spouting WFH insults.
He is now the favorite for the 2023 Rudy Giuliani Prize, awarded annually to the personality with the largest drop in public opinion.
www.cnbc.com/2023/05/16/elon-musk-work-from-home-morally-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In Afghanistan the Taliban have banned women from working. So some NGOs are switching to WFH wherever possible. This highlights how WFH can provide partial access to work in places where doing this in person is impossible.
www.voanews.com/a/can-online-education-work-bypass-taliba… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Within firms IT workers have the highest WFH levels. They have more WFH days than the average office worker, and more WFH days even than top execs.
Tech workers and the tech industry really seems to be the center of Working from Home.
www.ivanti.com/lp/solutions/assets/s1/2023-everywhere-wor… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New 2023Q2 Flex Report, summary
- Firms are moving towards anchor days so teams are all in on the same days
- 3 days on Tuesday to Thursday is most popular
- Large firms are particularly focused on anchor-day hybrid, smaller firms more on flexible hybrid
www.flex.scoopforwork.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Employees and managers think having a camera on during online meetings increases engagement. They are tend to have their cameras on, particularly during smaller meetings (although surprisingly many had cameras off even in small meetings).
Pack: www.atlantafed.org/-/media/documents/datafiles/research/s… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Even optimistic forecasts of US office occupancy predict it will take until after 2030 to recover. This is incredibly slow - few economic shocks take over a decade for markets to adjust. This highlights just how large and unexpected this pandemic surge in WFH has been.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Totally agreed great to repurpose empty office space to residential :-)
On recover I meant get back to pre-pandemic fill rates, and yes it's possible that never happens if some (many) offices are mainly used Tues-Thurs. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Call for papers: Remote Work Conference 2023
Stanford is hosting the second conference on remote and hybrid working. Please submit a paper by June 15th. The conference will also be Zoom broadcasted for those that cannot make it in person.
Submission:
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/RWC_CallforPap… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great to see this work from Stanford PhD student Lauren Harris out in Bloomberg. The number of CEOs named "John" has been finally surpassed by the number of female CEOs.
Lauren Harris
@LaurenH007
So excited to see some of my classwork featured in Bloomberg this morning!
Check out my version here: sites.google.com/stanford.edu/laurenjharris/research/bloo… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
US cities are down 32% in activity versus pre-pandemic, with office employees WFH about 50% of days. This is cutting city center retail spending, office use and public transit journeys.
But what city centers lost suburbs gained. Suburbs are booming as activity shifts to them. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Was Feb 2023 peak Return To Office?
The three best indicators of Return to Office (or its inverse, Working From Home) all show drops in office occupancy and rises in WFH in March 2023.
It looks increasingly like RTO has finally stalled out. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Summary of our new paper measuring the rise of hybrid and remote work in the US, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand at www.wfhmap.com
With @raffasadun, @pj_lambert, @StephenEKHansen, @Bledi_Taska and Steve Davies
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
Nick Bloom Raffaella Sadun etal @voxeu !
•
Uses a large-language model to flags remote work in 250 million job postings. The results show a rise in remote-work offerings since spring 2020, with tremendous heterogeneity @I_Am_NickBloom @raffasadun
cepr.org/voxeu/columns/using-job-postings-quantify-remote… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Younger companies have higher levels of #wfh, with many start-ups fully-remote. This is a key force driving higher levels of WFH. Todays start-ups will mature into tomorrows larger firms spreading this WFH focus through the economy.
Report: www.flex.scoopforwork.com/company-founding-year -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Conference on the Macroeconomics of Uncertainty and Volatility, September 6-8 at Stanford University
Looking for recent papers on the cause and effect of uncertainty and volatility, ideally with substantial empirical component.
Please submit by June 5th: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc56nogL1Gbo1meVa8UoZuAE… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The rise of hybrid #wfh. In a survey of Californian firms coming to the workplace 3-days a week is the most common choice. Amazingly this is now more frequent than 5-days a week (fully-in person) or 0-days a week (fully-remote).
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Survey data suggests by April 2023 almost 80% of California firms see themselves as in the new normal.
This means current levels of commuting, office use, city center retail, weekday leisure and other activities impacted by #wfh are likely to be permanent. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Mentoring is easier in person. It is possible to mentor remotely, but it takes deliberate effort.
This is one of the key reasons for hybrid. Office days for mentoring, innovation and building culture. Home days for quiet, deep work and no commute.
Source wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/WFHResearch_up… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I visited the IMF and @tavares_mm shared a figure showing a weak #wfh and labor force participation correlation. The hope is WFH makes it easier for some folks to work - those with young kids, the disabled, folks near retirement - which expands the labor force, raising growth.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh jobs are concentrating in college towns. They have many start-ups, an educated labor market, and strong university links. This is driving a local economic (and housing) boom. Indeed, college towns will likely see some of the fastest growth in the US in the next decade.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes - sorry and yes this list also includes big cities like SF, Boston, DC and Chicago. We've long known these are fully of lots of WFH jobs.
What is new - at least to me - is how many college towns are also here too.
Also an incredibly "Blue" list - Democrats love #wfh jobs -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New Pew data. The big positives of #wfh are balancing work and family life, and meeting deadlines. The big negatives are mentoring and connecting to co-workers.
Organized hybrid - 2 or 3 days in a week for the whole team/firm - can help mitigate negatives and provide positives.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Sorry - here is the link to the research piece www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2023/03/30/about-a-third-of…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece on the importance - and challenges of - measuring WFH. The best data on this shows WFH is up about 4x to 5x from pre to post pandemic.
Emma Goldberg
@emmabgo
I wrote about why it matters to measure how many people are working from home — and why the Labor Department might be getting it wrong, per @I_Am_NickBloom @ModeledBehavior and other experts www.nytimes.com/2023/03/30/business/economy/remote-work-m…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tomorrow I will be in a status and future of WFH discussion with Dan Bladen (Kadence) and Kevin Delaney (Charter).
kadence.zoom.us/webinar/register/4116776680181/WN_nMQx482…
Kadence
@KadenceOS
Last chance to grab a spot 👋
Join us tomorrow for a conversation with our hybrid expert panel - @danbladen, @I_Am_NickBloom and @delaney, we'll be looking at recent data and trends, and discussing all things #hybridwork
RESERVE YOUR SPOT HERE 👉 kadence.zoom.us/webinar/register/4116776680181/WN_nMQx482… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New piece from Bloomberg - the full data on the share of WFH job postings by month from 2017 to Feb 2023 for the largest 200 US cities is here: wfhmap.com/data/
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-25/work-from-home… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A new BLS survey claims 72.5% of establishments have no WFH, far lower than any other data.
Surprised I looked at the key question (below). This would include WFH as one employee doing work email once for 10 minutes at home.
So how did 72.5% say no?
www.bls.gov/news.release/brs1.nr0.htm -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest Executive pack on #wfh. Organizations now stabilizing into three groups of employees
A) Fully in person: retail, service and other front line staff,
B) Fully remote: payroll, benefits, IT-support, call centers
C) Hybrid: managers and professionals
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/phwmqp3aclyprkf0y4l7v/Exec_March20… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Innoscape has a set of great videos on topics like AI, Innovation and growth. I recorded two sets of videos with them on WFH (from my house, hence the big picture of the Queen in the background :-) )
innoscape.ch/de/publikationen/nicholas-bloom-innoscape-ta…
innoscape.ch/en/publications/nicholas-bloom-innoscape-tal… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The pandemic has twisted the economy.
Office use, public transport and city center retail has shrunk into Tue-Thurs, generating peak-load problems.
Leisure, sport and suburban shopping has spread out to the whole week, easing their pre-pandemic Sat-Sun peak-loading.
Emma Goldberg
@emmabgo
New research from @I_Am_NickBloom shows a 278% (!!!) increase in Wednesday afternoon golfing. This afternoon fun could be helping drive America's economic rebound —because historically service sector productivity has been constrained by the 9-5 grind www.nytimes.com/2023/03/16/business/afternoon-fun-economy…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Econofact, which is a great website and podcast, just posted a short memo on uncertainty. With the SVB meltdown many measures of uncertainty are spiking again, so hopefully this is a useful overview.
econofact.org/understanding-and-measuring-uncertainty -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest SWAA data. The economy - like most firms - have employees that are fully on-site (security, catering, nursing etc), hybrid (managers and professionals ) and fully-WFH (some IT, payroll etc).
So firms typically combine all three types.
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/WFHResearch_up… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fully remote #wfh is declining. Some jobs are going hybrid as bosses drag employees back 2 or 3 days a week. Other jobs are moving abroad, or getting automated (e.g. call centers or payroll).
Long-run I see hybrid WFH will be 50% of jobs, fully in-person 40% and fully-remote 10% -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Anyone know how to deal with fake accounts - I have this account pretending to be me. They are using the handle "lam_nickbloom", just an underscore less than my "I_am_nickbloom"
I have reported this to twitter - anything else I should do?
Thanks Nick -
Nick Bloom reposted
Peter John Lambert
@pj_lambert
New paper "Remote Work across Jobs, Companies, and Space" is OUT, along with accompanying data and visuals at wfhmap.com. Here is a short 🧵 about what we found. First, as expected, share of job ads explicitly offering #wfh exploded! #econtwitter (1/9)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Text-to-data
In www.wfhmap.com we found defining WFH job postings using keywords is tricky. Many started including terms like "work remotely" from April 2020, but followed by "no" or "not possible". So we human read 5k articles used it to train a BERT NLP called WHAM. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Figure from @biancoresearch showing CEOs winding down discussing #wfh in earnings call. This was a huge topic in 2020 and 2021. But by 2023 firms have settled on:
- hybrid for managers
- in-person for front-line employees
- fully-remote for some support staff like IT & payroll -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data from a new project analyzing over 50 million job-postings a year for hybrid and fully-remote jobs.
We find #wfh postings grew 5-fold across after 2020, but are now stabilizing. This, and other data, suggest we have now reached the new normal.
Data: www.wfhmap.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
We surveyed 4,200 WFH employees about online meetings. Half of them reported substantially higher engagement when their cameras are on. This benefit was greatest in smaller (<10 people) meetings. This suggests a "cameras on norm" is helpful for productive video meetings.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
If you are interested here is the slide deck with more details www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/76i4c7j355kax0axzlmge/VideoCalls.p…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
January 2023 data shows people have their video on in meetings less than half the time. Even in small 2 to 4 people meetings only 48% have their video on. This is despite the same survey respondents reporting people (like themselves) are far more engaged with their video on :-)
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
If you are interested here is the slide deck behind this www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/76i4c7j355kax0axzlmge/VideoCalls.p…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This is a striking announcement - as @biancoresearch notes the Amazon HQ beauty pageant was a huge process. One of my former PhD students even examined this in their job-market paper.
Now #wfh has killed the project
Jim Bianco
@biancoresearch
I remember when Amazon had its "beauty pageant" where cities worldwide vied for HQ2. It was arguably the most prominent corporate HQ contest ever.
Now it looks like remote work might have killed it!
@I_Am_NickBloom @drorpoleg
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-03-03/amazon-hq2-pau… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
NYT piece confirming what I hear: hybrid is dominating for professionals. Hauling folks back 5 days a weeks is very unpopular, chilling productivity and raising quits. Fully remote is tough on mentoring, creativity and culture. So hybrid is winning out.
www.nytimes.com/2023/03/02/business/hybrid-work-from-home… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating piece by Torsten Slok arguing that declining survey response rates are making data more volatile. More volatile data is making markets more volatile. This is raising uncertainty, and may damage growth.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great points by @AlexMasPton and others that other datasets - like administrative data - partly take up the strain. Indeed collectively there may be more information. It is striking, however, how much survey response rates have fallen.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is the link to the full report
apolloacademy.com/unreliable-economic-data-is-a-source-of…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great Bloomberg piece on this by @readep www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-02-15/us-economic-da…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great FT piece by @TimHarford on why #wfh has stuck. For example, this graph shows we are back to pre-pandemic trend in shopping in person but not working in person.
Tim Harford
@TimHarford
Lockdowns are over. WFH isn't. Why?
(With shoutsout to @I_Am_NickBloom and @planetmoney.)
www.ft.com/content/627b1712-9c77-49dd-841d-edfe4b022703 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The self-employed are the biggest WFH workers. They work 61% of days at home compared to 24% for regular employees. That is a massive difference.
It suggests #wfh can be good for productivity. People who manage themselves mostly WFH :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In the UK there is now rationing of fruit and vegetables. This last happened in World War II.
The BBC reported Brexit supporters claiming it has nothing to do with leaving the EU, but is entirely due to bad weather in Southern Europe :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating #wfh paper - shows the gap between employees and employers is closing. But it varies a lot across employees - higher income folks in cities are getting WFH levels close to what they want, while poorer rural folks have a big gap.
Another factor dividing the US.
Jason P. Brown
@JasonPBrownPhD
The gap between them has narrowed over time, but the gap differs across worker characteristics and location.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I started researching uncertainty in 1996 when I began my PhD. Since then is has risen a lot, most notably in 2008 (financial crisis), 2016 (Trump and Brexit) and 2020 (COVID)
I talk about measuring and responding to uncertainty in this 22 minute podcast
econofact.org/podcast/understanding-uncertainty -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The plain vanilla version of hybrid #wfh is Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday in the office. Lets employees WFH on Monday and Friday - the popular home days - and gives three solid days in the office.
Like vanilla ice-cream not everyone's favorite, but a simple popular compromise. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tech is the #wfh outlier
This is changing with some tech firms shifting from fully flexible to hybrid with usually 2 or 3 office days per week
No large tech firms I know are going to fully on site - this is just too costly for retention and productivity
www.flex.scoopforwork.com/stats -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Wide spread in #wfh city flexibility
Top 5 are Portland, Boulder, Austin, Seattle and San Jose - all tech focused cities
Bottom 5 are Memphis, Riverside, Virginia Beach, Jacksonville and New Orleans - focused on entertainment, retail and transport
www.flex.scoopforwork.com/stats
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Sorry - with legend!
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating - Musk is closing some offices to cut costs. Walmart just closed 3 offices as some IT folks are now permanently remote.
This is why a recession may *increase* #wfh. Several firms have told me they are reducing office space to save costs.
www.forbes.com/sites/glebtsipursky/2023/01/23/elon-musk-i… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fun podcast with @Rbaltman on the future of #wfh, including discussion of impacts on productivity, long-run trends and the challenges for cities.
engineering.stanford.edu/magazine/nicholas-bloom-home-whe… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Really interesting piece from @Andre_Spicer on WFH using new ONS data for the UK. He argues the winners are high-earning graduates in big cities.
I think this is why populist politicians are against WFH - they see it as a form of "Elite bashing".
André Spicer
@andre_spicer
Who has benefited from the working from home revolution? I take a look at the new ONS data for the Guardian www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/feb/14/working-fro…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Interesting WSJ article on finding your dream #wfh town to live in. I ended up with Davis, CA which is impressive as I've always thought it would be a lovely place to live.
www.wsj.com/articles/remote-workers-great-place-to-live-1… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Coming to work on Friday feels very 2019.
Only 6% of firms with a hybrid #wfh schedule now come in on Fridays.
That makes Friday a great day for an easy commute, no lunch line, and a quiet office :-)
Report: www.flex.scoopforwork.com/stats -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great tool for comparing WFH policies in your own organization vs others. I looked up Stanford University and looks about right :-) www.flex.scoopforwork.com
Jena McGregor
@jenamcgregor
A new tool is making employers' remote work policies searchable for job seekers, researchers and CHROs. Much data needs to be verified—and policy can differ from practice—but the 'Flex Index' could help track hybrid work trends. My latest for @Forbes: www.forbes.com/sites/jenamcgregor/2023/02/07/a-new-flex-i…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data on 4,000 US firms #wfh policies
1) 50% of firms are fully on-site, like food-service, accommodation and retail
2) 40% combine #wfh and in person days in various ways: min-days, anchor days, employee choice etc
3) 8% are fully remote
Detailed data www.flex.scoopforwork.com/stats
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
You can look up your own or other organizations here.
I just checked out Stanford University and looks about right :-)
www.flex.scoopforwork.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh saves 72 minutes a day on average, and 90+ minutes in China, India, Japan and Singapore.
This is a win-win:
Employers gain 30 minutes (40%) more work a day, boosting productivity.
Employees gain 42 minutes for leisure, caregiving and housework.
www.nber.org/papers/w30866 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
It took 2.5 years for employers to settle into post-pandemic #wfh patterns. This long process reflects the massive changes involved. Hybrid-WFH is now the dominant scheme for professional and managers, most commonly MF at home and TWT in the office.
Data: wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/WFHResearch_up… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest trip.com experiment results on #wfh
Non-managers loved hybrid WFH from the beginning. Managers, however, were negative initially. After the 6 month experiment they changed their minds from negative to positive.
Paper: www.nber.org/papers/w30292 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh has changed in mentoring in many US firms. The reduction in face-to-face time has swiveled attention to greater communication by phone and videocall, more frequent check-ins, and a greater use of collaboration tools like Asana and Slack.
Full report: www.atlantafed.org/-/media/documents/datafiles/research/s… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest survey of US firms shows they are still planning small reductions in office space: just 1.5% on average.
From talking to 100s of companies the reason is hybrid #wfh works best if employees are in at the same time, so hard to shrink space.
Report www.atlantafed.org/-/media/documents/datafiles/research/s… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I recorded a podcast with Bloomberg (@erickazatsky and Karen Altamirano) on Friday and just out. Focuses on impact of WFH on cities, transit, offices and muni bonds. Summary - #wfh is mostly a huge social gain, except for big-city budgets and mass transit
podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/ficc-focus/id1589459799 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Any firms in the San Francisco Bay Area interested in sharing office space to save rent?
A Stanford MBA team are building a company to help firms on a hybrid #wfh schedule to share space and save on rent.
Details: www.projectpair.org -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The Census has also started putting out #wfh data and gives an identical picture to our SWAA data.
Indeed, BLS, Census, Google and SWAA all have WFH data series. All show similar patterns, confirming the US trend of 30% of days WFH post-pandemic.
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Benchmarking_S… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Early preview of the data through December 2022 showing WFH days stabilized at 30%
Matches this New York Times piece "Getting Rid of Remote Work Will Take More Than a Downturn" by @SarahFKessler
www.nytimes.com/2023/01/07/business/dealbook/remote-work-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
HBR piece finding managers and employees often don't agree on #wfh. Managers are more likely to think it harms productivity while employees think it boosts it. Clearer communication and policies are important, alongside WFH-hybrid with anchor days.
hbr.org/2023/01/research-where-managers-and-employees-dis… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Friday is the most popular day to #wfh. Perhaps surprisingly Thursday is next, with Monday third. Wednesday is the least popular WFH day.
This pattern has been shifting over time - in 2020 employers pushed for midweek WFH days - so I am intrigued how it will evolve over 2023. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A major surprise of 2022 was the continued surge in start-ups. After an initial Spring 2020 drop business creation rebounded to 20%+ above trend through 2022.
One factor is #wfh reduces the costs of startups, as does cloud compute, software as service and fractional exec time.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This link replicates the graph (data and Stata code). The Census gets rapid access to the EIN applications from the IRS and classifies these into high-growth start-ups, so great underlying data.
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8hcaq325qw1pi8qg3zx4l/StartUp.zip?…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
As background entry rates are usually lower after a recession. Here is data going back to 1978 from the Census for establishment entry rates. In a regression with a trend control the year after a recession is associated with 0.8% (significant) lower rates of establishment entry.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Another indicator that #wfh is permanent: public transit journeys stabilizing at 35% below 2019 levels.
This raises concerns over the survival of public transit systems. Costs are heavily fixed - think train and subway networks - but revenue is way down with 35% less journeys.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks for great comments.
Yes shopping (see figure), eating out and entertainment are almost back at pre-pandemic levels. So commuting must have dropped >35%.
Yes this is big cities - 30% NY, 30% DC, Chicago etc - so a heavy office commuting skew. So aligns with Kastle data.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Replying to @p_ganong on city variations. Below is NY which shows about at 50% drop adjusting for seasonality.
Generally you see transit systems with more rail and subway have bigger drops as more office commuters. Transit systems that are more bus focused have smaller drops.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Many people have asked about social distancing as a factor deterring the return to public transport. That is absolutely right - in our monthly survey 24% of respondees state they definitely would avoid this and another 30% likely would.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Most public transit is in cities, and these have seen the largest increases in post pandemic WFH.
Cities tend to have more tech and finance, more graduates and more office jobs, all of which drives higher rates of WFH.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Making this harder for public transit agencies is the increasing peak loading on Tuesday and Wednesday, which have become the popular office days.
Long-run public transit may need a 3-tier pricing scheme:
High - Tue/Weds
Medium - Mon/Thur/Fri
Low - Sat/Sun
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A number of questions on international data - I would think this is a global issue (or at least for large cities in high-income countries). Our survey data shows substantial post-pandemic levels of WFH amongst professionals around the world.
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/qpfo0ce5kyf9eemba9lm1/Exec_Briefin…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In response to a question on the UK (my homeland)
it appears that the UK, as well as Canada, have had very similar increases in WFH. Possibly the best time-series data on this is from Google Workplace Mobility which tracks journeys to work and back (using phone location data).
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I thought it could help to provide a replication file for the figure which is in the link below. There is a ton of great data from the NTD website.
Any corrections, further results for different cities, modes, periods etc post as a reply here thanks
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/tcqp79wrpogz7po3na62b/Transit.zip?…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data thanks to @emre_ozdenoren
Car journeys back to pre-pandemic, while rail, bus and tube 15% to 25% down. Since the majority of travel is for activities like shopping, eating out and entertainment (which are back to pre-pandemic levels ) suggests commuting substantially down. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Employee average pay by work status:
Fully in person (e.g. retail, food, travel and essential services) are lowest paid at $55k
Fully remote (e.g. IT, call-centers and payroll ) are mid-paid at $75k
Hybrid #wfh (e.g. professionals and managers) are highest paid at about $85k -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating.
Hard to get good data on the office market (this paper is one exception papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4124698 ). So Real-Estate-Investment-Trusts (REIT) valuation data is helpful
The drop in Office REIT values suggests investors see permanent reductions in office use from #wfh
Jim Bianco
@biancoresearch
Office REITS (red) are still BELOW their March 2020 COVID lows and way behind all REITS (green) and the SPX (blue).
I'm aware of no other Index still BELOW its panic March 2020 low, not even the ARKK!
The market message here is the office property market is a total disaster. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The #wfh Donut Effect has pushed down real (inflation adjusted) city center house prices.
From Feb 2020 city house prices have risen by about 10% and suburban ones by 35%. But since then inflation has been 15%, so real city center prices are down.
Paper www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8vyuxrmfqfmh5ew53fofb/Paper2022.pd… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Maybe the best data showing the permanent rise in #wfh
Online shopping has returned to its pre-pandemic trend, as has eating out, leisure travel and sports attendance. But WFH has stabilized at 20% above its pre-pandemic trend
WFH has stuck because firms and employees both gain
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Jumana - thanks for the great comment, and yes that figure makes it hard to see stabilization because of the scale
The figure below - which is monthly - shows this better. Also Kastle and Google Workplace mobility show similar stabilizing trends
Source www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/qpfo0ce5kyf9eemba9lm1/Exec_Briefin… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Time piece on #wfh benefits for four groups
1) Employees: value WFH at about 8% higher salary
2) Firms: recruitment, diversity and productivity gains
3) Families: more space with suburban living
4) Environment: 6 billion driving miles saved weekly
time.com/6243148/working-from-home-is-the-trend-of-the-ye… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great from @skgreen
1) Managers are mostly aligned with employees, except a few outliers with 30+ years of in person experience
2) Experimentation is critical to develop best practices
3) Senior leaders should not come in 5-days as it undermines hybrid
www.washingtonpost.com/business/what-we-learned-about-hyb… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Four predictions from Stanford Economists on 2023 - covering #covid, #wfh, #crypto and #california
As a tea-drinker I'm intrigued to see how these compare to reading the tea leaves - can our predictions outperform a pot of Darjeeling?
siepr.stanford.edu/news/top-economic-policy-challenges-2023 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Popular hybrid #wfh schemes stack home days next to the weekend. This gives employees the flexibility to travel over the weekend
This has been a huge change from 2020 when firms first started offering hybrid schemes. Back then firms offered mid-week days to avoid "long weekends"
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Peter - sorry and these are the days WFH, so "Thursday-Friday" means you WFH on those days - so steeped in this stuff easy to lose sight of this.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The rise of #wfh led almost 1 million people and businesses to leave large US cities for smaller cities and rural areas.
This is the "Donut effect" of WFH employees leaving big cities for areas with more affordable housing.
Paper: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8vyuxrmfqfmh5ew53fofb/Paper2022.pd… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
OECD conference on remote work on 27 January. Three interesting papers, including @cevatgirayaksoy presenting our data on #wfh around the world.
Sign-up link to view remotely meetoecd1.zoom.us/meeting/register/tJctcuisqTooEtaFmU-dYq… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
From Christos - my friend and co-author - and as long at it's hybrid #wfh and they are delivering presents on the in-office days that's fine with me.
Even Rudolph deserves hybrid-WFH :-)
Christos Genakos
@CGenakos
#wfh #christmas This is for you @I_Am_NickBloom...
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Is Twitter "doing a Brexit" - a self inflicted stagnation?
I started WFH posts on Twitter and LinkedIn in December 2021. Both grew at identical rates until October 2022.
After the Musk takeover Twitter growth stagnated while LinkedIn kept growing. I fear Musk Brexited Twitter. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Highlights a policy I am hearing more about:
1) Giving employees two to four weeks of WFH time, allowing them to visit family or travel
2) Coordinating this for the entire firm or division
As Fraser states the key to success is managers can evaluate WFH employee performance
Matthew Boyle
@bizboyle
Citigroup told employees they can work from anywhere for the final two weeks of the year, as CEO Fraser bucks a trend among rivals to get office workers back to their desks full time: "We know if they’re doing a good job or not.” www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-15/citi-s-employe… @thefuture @jennysurane
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest #wfh deck
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/qpfo0ce5kyf9eemba9lm1/Exec_Briefin…
Summary
1) WFH stabilized at 30% in the US and 10% to 20% in Europe and Asia
2) Hybrid is common for professionals, with rising coordination on days
3) Firms are mostly sticking with offices, but re-modelling to support collaborative work -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks and highlights long-run #wfh impact:
1) Labor force participation: more retirees, parents and students working if they WFH?
2) Globalization: will WFH offshore more services?
3) Cities: will WFH residents keep leaving city centers?
4) Fertility: will WFH raise birthrates?
Matthew Boyle
@bizboyle
Nicholas Bloom, the go-to academic on remote work whose data and insights are sought after by organizations around the world, has made the annual @BW Bloomberg 50 list of the people who defined global business in 2022. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-14/nicholas-bloom… via @BW @I_Am_NickBloom @WFHResearch
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Call for papers:
NBER's Productivity, Innovation and Entrepreneurship Program, in person at the NBER, Cambridge, MA on Friday March 10, 2023.
Upload submissions here thanks:
conference.nber.org/confsubmit/backend/cfp?id=PRs23
Deadline January 8, 2023 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid #wfh has become the leading policy for employees that can work remotely. It is also the most popular choice of employees (50% want hybrid, 35% fully remote and 15% fully in person) and firms.
The next 5 years of WFH evolution will focus on improving this hybrid experience -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Most firms are finally stabilizing their long-run plans for #wfh, after 2 years of rising WFH generosity.
Usually this is 3 office days (typically Tues-Thurs) and 2 home days (typically Mon and Fri) each week.
Great to finally settle on this. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great to be involved with Kadence on developing software to coordinate teams days in and out of the office and the future of hybrid-WFH. TechCrunch covered their new funding round today.
Kadence
@KadenceOS
We could not be more excited to announce a new $10m round of investment - helping us to build the tools we all need to make the future of work, work for everyone.
Let's go!
techcrunch.com/2022/12/06/how-chargifi-pivoted-to-kadence… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh has reduced commuting time, making it easier to live in the outer suburbs. This makes building housing in big city suburbs more profitable for developers. A new paper estimates this could deliver 100,000s of new homes.
Paper: www.kansascityfed.org/research/economic-review/hybrid-wor… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A challenge of #wfh is different views on its productivity impact. Managers think it lowers productivity by 3.5% while employees think it raises it by 7.4%
I hear this gap arises from different metrics, short-vs-long run, visibility of home work, and how to value commuting time.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The best guess at the true productivity impact - for organized hybrid when the team/firm has anchor days to be in together on the same days - is zero or small positive
This randomized control trial of 1600 employees in hybrid #wfh found this
www.dropbox.com/s/fcotbjogf1kwrul/w30292.pdf?dl=0 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hi all - just to say if anyone wants the monthly #wfh data updates here is the link. No spam (we are academics and not selling these lists etc). Survey goes in the field mid-month and we post latest data by end of month.
wfhresearch.com/sign-up-for-regular-results-updates/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
November data: #wfh stabilized at 30% of days in the US, and is looking permanent.
I get asked if a recession will lower this. Not much. The advantages of hybrid-WFH - happier employees, productivity, DEI and saving space - matter just as much in recessions. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Start-ups are big adopters of #wfh. Firms founded in 2022 had 40% of days worked from home.
Fully remote saves on space costs, facilitates hiring and increases flexibility. As they grow many will go hybrid.
For monthly data updates: wfhresearch.com/sign-up-for-regular-results-updates/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Agreed with Alan, @Richard_Florida and @mattkahn1966. Big cities are damaged but not doomed. Using USPS address data with @arjun_ramani3 we find US city centers lost about 1% of population post pandemic.
Painful, but not an apocalypse
So I would bet on NY & SF in the long-run -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The pandemic rise in #wfh and low interest rates led to surging rents. These have now stopped rising as the economy cools
Rents rose most in the suburbs due to the "Donut effect" of people moving out of city centers when they can #wfh -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Kadence data confirming that most graduates and professionals are stabilizing into hybrid-#wfh.
There was a pre-pandemic period of almost no WFH, an early pandemic period of fully remote, and now hybrid-WFH is dominating post-pandemic.
Kadence
@KadenceOS
After a few months, we decided to revisit the data to see if that behaviour has changed🧐
The verdict? As @I_Am_NickBloom has predicted, the #hybridwork patterns are stabilizing, and remain consistent with most people #wfh or going into the office 1-2 times/week👩💻 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There can be different views on #wfh from employees and managers. Employees love the lack of commuting, but some managers say it can be harder to run teams.
In the trip.com RCT experiment the reduction in quits from WFH comes all from employees, not managers. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Market forces even apply to Musk.
Tech employees value the ability to #wfh about the same as 10% more pay. Musk cut WFH and required more hours in a "hardcore" schedule.
Facing massive hourly wage cuts employees quit.
Would you expect anything else?
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-17/musk-softens-r… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The value of #wfh has been highlighted by the problems at Twitter. Musk banned WFH and many key employees quit. This week I have seen three polls asking if Twitter will survive. Here is a summary of thoughts on WFH from CNBC.
www.cnbc.com/video/2022/11/11/hybrid-work-is-here-to-stay…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
As @drorpoleg said it's reasonable for Twitter to push for more office time for 6 months while they do a radical overhaul.
But that does not appear to be the plan. Musk is saying permanent 100% in the office, aiming to exit the less committed.
Certainly people are exiting -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Call for papers
Conference on: Management and Decision Making
Location: Venice in June 2022 :-)
Submission deadline: January 31st 2023
Details: www.cesifo.org/en/event/2023-06-21/venice-summer-institut…
CESifo
@CESifoNetwork
Call for papers: Venice Summer Institute 2023: Decision Making in #firms – #bigdata and Management Practices 21–22 June 2023 - scientific organizers: @I_Am_NickBloom @FlorianEnglmai1 #vsi @univiu www.cesifo.org/en/event/2023-06-21/venice-summer-institut…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Sorry - should be June 2023 (too excited by the thought of going to Venice - last time I went was 30 years ago and really incredible)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Paper by Aakash Kalyani showing that while US patenting is rising fast the creativity of these patents is declining. Patents are becoming more derivative, slowing growth.
Less clear why - he provides evidence this is partly due to the aging of inventors.
www.aakashkalyani.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Musk bans remote work at Twitter. Impacts will be
1) Upset employees with many quits
2) Lower productivity
3) Negative impact on DEI
4) Higher office costs
This reverse of the benefits of Hybrid WFH outlined in the exec pack here www.dropbox.com/s/jp5yarqzve0d7cs/Exec_Briefing_Nov2022.p…
www.ft.com/content/899bb401-1ab0-43aa-8ab1-102111b49568 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper on "Miss-Allocation" by Stanford Job Market candidate Rachel Schuh stanford.edu/~schuhr/
Massive US survey finds striking differences across genders in co-worker preferences. Women, particularly those aged 50+, display a strong preference for more female workplaces. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Paper on minimum wages and outsourcing by Beatriz Pousada, Stanford Job Market Candidate web.stanford.edu/~bpousada/
Finds higher minimum wages
A) Increase outsourced workers earnings
B) Cut outsourced employment
Topical with #wfh increasing outsourcing and minimum wages spreading -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper finds *fully remote* work (not hybrid) reduces employee "mobilization" to request better pay and hours docs.google.com/presentation/d/1j34QE8wdUl0lL-Sz0m2cbKtNA…
Interesting as suggests fully remote could reduce trade-union coverage, collective bargaining and industrial action.
Thoughts on this? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Perhaps the biggest reason to #wfh?
It's not the 9 minutes a day you save from less grooming.
It's avoiding a day at work where 15% of people have not showered, 7% have no deodorant, 6% are in dirty clothes and 5% have not even brushed their teeth.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Some great responses here - thanks. Indeed the most commonly picked benefit of #wfh in the SWAA survey is no commute, followed by a flexible work schedule (e.g. you can go to the dentist, gym or pick-up your kids more easily if you WFH).
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Managers and employees disagree on how tough their firm is on people who #wfh on "in office" days. Employees say often nothing happens, while managers say infractions often lead to termination threats.
Who is right - I suspect employees as some managers are not enforcing this?
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes - i agree this is not great. A well managed hybrid-system has everyone agreeing on when they should and should not be in, and sticking to it.
As the saying goes "a bad law is a hard law to enforce"
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This should be a better figure with a white background
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fun paper on digital nomads showing how footloose and travel focused they are. Some great quotes too like: "I was watching waves crashing on one of the best surf breaks in the world while I was taking calls on the roof. How can it get better than that?”
drive.google.com/file/d/1l0r8yzgk5WO6a8OVfM7OFuwDjWfoAbOl… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Folks have asked if the interesting Washington Post article (below) shows #wfh reduces productivity?
No.
Productivity growth (plotted quarterly below from 1947) is very noisy. Indeed, this averaged 0.2% post-pandemic vs 0.2% the year pre-pandemic.
www.washingtonpost.com/business/2022/10/31/productivity-d… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I'm a fan of the Freaknonomics podcast and regularly listen to them out walking, running or driving. So very happy they did a #wfh episode in which they interview several economists (including me), plus their own employees on the impact and future of #wfh
freakonomics.com/podcast/the-unintended-consequences-of-w… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper: proximity supports feedback.
A big tech firm had two buildings on one campus. Pre-pandemic employees got more feedback if they were in the same main building as their team. @WFH no difference: feedback for all employees was the same as being in the auxiliary building.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes - two takeaways for me:
1) Building layout matters a lot - i talk to folks in my building much more than the next door building
2) WFH is like being in a different building. Not terrible but not as good as in person for feedback, but noting WFH has offsetting upsides -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Start-up rates surged post-pandemic. One driver is founding a #wfh business avoids the need for office space. With cloud computing, software as a service, and fractional staff this has slashed the investment needed to start a firm.
This should boost long-run growth rates.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great question from George - these could all be "side hustles". Folks starting second businesses while WFH on their main job. If they keep up performance on their main job while doing this that's great - shows WFH can increase productivity, allowing folks to start new businesses
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Venture Capital firms are funding start-ups further away. One driver is greater comfort doing business remotely post-pandemic. Another driver is many start-ups are #wfh outside big cities, so VCs have to travel further to find the best investments.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is the link to the paper, slides and video of the talk - it is the 10:30-11:00 talk on Friday (last day)
www.remoteworkconference.org -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great to see www.wfhresearch.com and Kastle data line-up so well. Both show WFH levels surged in 2020, dropped back in 2021/22, and are now stabilizing with offices about 50% of 2019 occupancy rates.
This matches 3-2 #wfh hybrid: typical US office workers WFH half the week.
Kastle Systems
@KastleSystems
ICYMI: @Bloomberg @CityLab shared more info on our #backtoworkbarometer and notes similar trends in other data sources. As @wfhresearch’s @I_Am_NickBloom notes, our numbers line up, giving him “confidence in the accuracy of their data.” www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-13/will-remote-wo…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The 2022 Remote Work Conference just finished in Stanford. The entire program, with all 22 papers, slides and recordings of the presentations is available below. This is the current state-of-the-art research on remote work.
www.remoteworkconference.org
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks all - we were incredibly happy with the event. Extremely high quality of papers throughout, super interesting insights and discussion, and great opportunities to talk to everyone whose work you've been reading for so long :-)
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hi all and thanks again for the kind words and yes the plan is to do this annually, so we have penciled in another event for Fall 2023 (and will post the call on twitter). It seems like the amount of great research on remote work is now so high we can run annual conferences :-)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I started research on #wfh 20 years ago while working on management practices. Good management is critical for effective WFH as employees are out of the office out of sight.
This blog highlights key WFH management steps of measure, review and incentivize.
blog.asana.com/2022/10/measure-review-incentivize/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tracking twitter shows three key results:
1) Tweets on all #wfh topics surged in March 2020, and are still 3x pre-pandemic levels
2) "Work from home"/"WFH" is the most common term
3) "Hybrid" is rising fast as it becomes popular with firms
Details: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/0j1ra192vvo1x3bqmfl4u/WFH_Oct_11_M… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Stanford have just opened a new course on managing hybrid #wfh teams, combining the latest research and organizational experience.
online.stanford.edu/courses/xlfh110-managing-remote-and-h…
Co-taught with Pamela Hinds, @work_matters, @huggyrao, @MaggieNeale, @jonathanlevav
and Frank Flynn -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Our remote work conference is next Weds 12th to Friday 14th October and will be streamed live (see conference program link below). There are 22 research papers on #wfh measurement, causes and impact. Each paper has 20 mins talk then 10 mins Q&A.
www.remoteworkconference.org
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks and yes - some activities are best face-to-face and some best remote. I think research meetings and presentations generally work best in person, hence this is in person with zoom broadcast. Data work, reading and tweets are quiet work, best done at home where I am now :-)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The #wfh debate is very office focused. But only a third of people work in offices. The other two thirds work in factories, stores, schools, hospitals, restaurants and sites. These locations offer the greatest opportunity to extend #wfh through better management and technology.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks for the questions.
Yes this is US workers, although similar I think to Canada and Northern Europe. For other places offices are probably an even smaller share
The reason to extend #wfh is employees typically want this 2 to 3 days a week, and outside offices that is rare -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest SWAA data shows no change in #wfh in September 2022, suggesting the Labor-day return to the office push had little impact.
I think WFH levels over the next 5 years will be a Nike swoosh - small drop with the recession then a bigger long-run increase as technology improves -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This is part of the trend I am see towards organized hybrid #wfh
Uber had let employees choose their WFH days, but now wants to coordinate office days so employees are in together
They picked Tue and Thurs anchor days, which is the most common option
www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/uber-asks-e… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest Exec pack on #wfh. Key points
1) WFH is here to stay: most professionals are now hybrid-WFH
2) Hybrid needs coordination so teams are in/out on the same days
3) Offices are not disappearing, but are changing to support social collaborative work
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/6h8t36t83n0r3c9ft5jq6/Exec_Briefin… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating report from @ModeledBehavior mapping #wfh across the US. Striking facts:
A) Dominance of big cities: every dark spot is a big city
B) High WFH levels in the West
C) Low WFH levels in the South
Even in the US geography matters a lot for WFH
eig.org/the-uneven-geography-of-remote-work/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Since 2015 there have been five major “uncertainty shocks”, driven by rising global political fragmentation and extremism.
We discuss how firms can cope by paying for flexibility, contingency planning and paying more attention to politics.
hbr.org/2022/09/visualizing-the-rise-of-global-economic-u… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data question :-)
Kastle data is fantastic, but does anyone know what the y-axis is? I thought this was "Percent of February 2020 occupancy" but it does not say. @caliyost and I were talking and could not find guidance on their website - anyone know thanks? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh is impacting firms in many ways, including more
A) Part-time employees
B) Outsourced and offshored employees
C) Employment of the physically challenged
This is generating many benefits, and a few challenges, for companies and labor markets. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Interviews are shifting from in person to online, with 27% of early rounds and 11% of late rounds now conducted online.
This is likely contributing to higher job-churn. It is easier to search and interview for new jobs online while #wfh -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Predictable impact of Tesla's ending #wfh
1) Many remote workers will not relocate and quit
2) Some hybrid workers quit citing inflexibility
3) DEI worries over loss of minority, female & disability employees
4) Morale falls as a #wfh perk is withdrawn
www.cnbc.com/2022/09/14/tesla-struggles-with-elon-musks-s… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There's a myth that all employees want to be fully remote. Some do - 31% on average in the US - but the majority want hybrid #wfh, coming to work usually two to three days a week. Age 20-29 employees are the least keen on fully-remote, valuing in-person mentoring and socializing
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
We analyze 100 years of Harvard Business Review articles finding a surge of interest in Strategy and Marketing. Interest in Human Resources has been flat, but I suspect the pandemic induced #wfh spike will change that as HR becomes central to management
hbr.org/2022/09/visualizing-a-century-of-management-ideas -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Working patterns are stabilizing with a wide mix from fully remote to fully in person. This variation is often across teams because of the benefits of coordinating within teams. This working pattern - in-person, hybrid #wfh or remote - is now a key part of any job description.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Our 2022 Remote Work Conference has just posted the sessions with links to preliminary papers
www.remoteworkconference.org
Co-organized with @Jose_MariaRD @prithwic Steve Davis, @NataliaHEmanuel and @emma_k_h -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh data shows a trend towards 30% of days at home
This 30% combines two groups
(I) 15% of people working fully remotely, and
(II) 30% of hybrid-WFH people working 1/2 time at home
SWAA data www.wfhresearch.com
Google data www.google.com/covid19/mobility -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fantastic conference on uncertainty and volatility
economics.stanford.edu/events/site-2022-conference-schedu…
Highlight was balancing 17 people on one bike :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Cities dominate #wfh activity. Tech, finance and creative industries which lead on WFH are city focused.
This highlights the opportunities in suburbs and rural areas for firms and managers to adopt WFH.
Details: wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Another Labor-Day return to office deadline passes and no apparent drop in #wfh levels. Indeed, the three Labor Day RTO deadlines since 2020 have been 3-0 to Employees vs Employers
Kastle data is below, Google Workplace Mobility data shows no impact either. SWAA data out soon -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Survey data finds employees value #wfh about the same as 5% more pay www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/bbkojgfazap7jkp5jluhb/w30446.pdf?r…
RCT research finds WFH can increase productivity by about 5% www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/6lowitde7lsu7j85yxh6c/w30292.pdf?r…
So hybrid WFH allows managers to improve recruitment and retention while raising productivity :-) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Monday and Friday dominate for #wfh days
This generates trade-offs
Coming in on Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday means a a lively social office with colleagues around
Coming in on Monday and Friday means less traffic, easier parking, and more space in a quieter office -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Europe and America are stabilizing at about 25% fewer workplace trips, due to #wfh rising from about 5% to 30% of days. Our survey data suggests this increase in remote work is permanent
Developed Asia has a smaller 5% drop in workplace trips, due to its more modest rise in WFH -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great hybrid-WFH summary: "Zoom believes that offices have become a place to be social. They are no longer for doing good work so much as making good work possible, facilitating collaboration and fostering camaraderie. The office is now like an off-site."
www.wsj.com/articles/zoom-offices-hybrid-remote-work-1166… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The shift to WFH is the largest shock to labor markets in decades. Pre-pandemic WFH was trending towards 5% of days by 2022. Now WFH is now stabilizing at 30%, a 6-fold jump.
In America alone this is saving about 200 million hours and 6 billion miles of commuting a week.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Some questions on how to see this is stabilizing - this comes from higher frequency data. For example:
A) The monthly plot (below)
B) Kastle weekly office occupancy data www.kastle.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/Kastle_dashboar…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data for the chart is here in the first data tab:
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/WFHtimeseries_… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Empirical Management Conference call for papers
December 14-15, 2022 at the International Finance Corporation in Washington DC
Submissions due by September 20
worldmanagementsurvey.org/emc2022/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh has stabilized into three groups
No WFH: 55% of employees, mostly in face-to-face jobs in retail, manufacturing, foodservice etc
Hybrid-WFH: 30% of employees, typically better paid managers and professionals
Fully-WFH: 15% of employees in support roles like IT and payroll
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Note: fully-remote group is "mostly" in support roles. With 15% of the US labor force this is about 25 million people. There are many hi-tech employees from firms like AirBnB and Yelp that are fully remote, but they are less than 1 million employees, so less than 5% of this group
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
City center home prices are 10% above their pre-pandemic levels. Suburban home prices are about 40% above pre-pandemic levels.
This is a combination of the donut effect of #wfh employees moving to the suburbs, and low interest rates raising all asset prices (including housing). -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The donut-effect is far larger in big cities, but is almost gone by the time you get to cities outside the top 50 (something like Wichita Kansas or Tampa Florida).
So New York and San Francisco have seen major population flows to the suburbs, while smaller cities have not. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The Pret Index from Bloomberg nicely captures the #wfh impact on retail. City centers sales are down at 80% of pre-pandemic levels while suburbs are up at 120%
WFH Office workers are lunching from home in the suburbs, cutting city center spending and boosting suburban spending -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The outflow of businesses from city centers has a slowed but not reversed. It looks like there will permanently fewer retail, food and entertainment outlets in city centers.
This is a combination of the donut-effect of residents moving to the suburbs, and office workers #wfh -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Shake Shack reported lunchtime traffic in New York is 40% below 2019 levels, with no expectations of an imminent rebound.
This is being driven by the average US office worker #wfh about 50% of the time
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-05/work-from-home… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Really enjoyed talking with Nirvikar Singh on the Ideas for India podcast about the past, present and future of WFH. They are very fast on editing this so it's extremely topical (recorded only about two weeks ago).
rb.gy/uagba9
Ideas for India
@Ideas4India
Listen to Nicholas Bloom talk about the findings of his seminal RCT on working from home, and highlight how #workfromhome reduces quit rates and helps companies retain or recruit employees, in the 11th edition of the I4I Conversations series: rb.gy/uagba9
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great chart pointing to a long-run benefit of #wfh - higher labor force participation
Many groups - those with disabilities, older employees, folks with young kids, students etc - will find it easier to work part/full time with #wfh
This could boost growth and reduce inflation
Julia Pollak
@juliaonjobs
Want to see an encouraging labor market chart? This shows labor force participation for people with disabilities—way up in a tight labor market where remote work has become the norm in many industries, not the exception.
fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU01374597 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The “Donut effect” - workers who can #wfh moving from city centers to the suburbs - led city-center rents to collapse in 2020
City rents have now completely recovered
Suburban and exurban rents have surged up 30% on 2020 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New RCT on 1612 employees, finding hybrid #wfh
1) Reduced quit rates by 1/3
2) Shifted hours from WFH days to office days & weekends
3) Increased messaging and video calls (even in the office)
4) Generated a small productivity increase
Paper: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/6lowitde7lsu7j85yxh6c/w30292.pdf?r… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New job marketplace data from Linked-In showing
1) #wfh is important for job-seekers - the top of the factors they polled
2) WFH jobs have a 4x apply rate of in person
For employers this implies WFH jobs may offer a better skill/wage ratio
More www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/vlcnuqq2ou1p5rxeybjtf/WSDM2022-jou… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Information (which includes Tech) has the highest level of #wfh with Finance next - both industries are computer focused (so good for WFH)
Manufacturing, Retail, Transport and Hospitality are lowest - these are more person or equipment focused
The surprise for me is Wholesale? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Surprisingly 14.6% of respondees report not "engaging in person or by video" with any coworkers, customers or clients in a typical day.
These jobs are often suitable for remote working, and indeed these employees report they #wfh 70% of days.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Matt - thanks and maybe we should have tweaked the question to include audio as didn't mean to exclude it. We had in mind jobs which are often very technical but do not involve a lot of direct interaction so are suitable for remote - maybe some coding, data work, writing etc
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Two key measures of #wfh
(1) All Americans: 30% of days are WFH
(2) Americans who can WFH: 50% of days are WFH
The latter group includes most professionals, managers and office workers. For them WFH is stabilizing at 2.5 days per week on average. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In late 2020 there was a big gap between how many WFH days workers wanted (3 days) and how many employers were planning (1.5 days)
That gap has mostly gone, mainly from employers offering more WFH days. Employers did this because of the performance and retention gains from #wfh -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
My co-author Mihai is presenting our paper on entrepreneurial forecasting on Monday.
The punchline is it is hard for businesses to forecast their future sales. Good data helps, but only a little.
Mihai Codreanu
@m_codreanu
So excited to present Monday 3pm EDT (Boston time) at the @nberpubs #si Entrepreneurship my paper "Rationalizing entrepreneurs' forecasts" (joint with @I_Am_NickBloom and Robert Fletcher). The event will also be live streamed: www.youtube.com/nbervideos
🧵My first thread🧵 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great chart showing how the desire for fully remote work rises with age
Younger employees often focus on mentoring, which is easier in person
Older employees tend tend to have partners and children, which makes remote work more appealing
WFH raw data: wfhresearch.com/data/
Aki Ito
@AkiIto7
This chart shows the share of people who prefer a full-time remote work setup, by age.
Only 24% of 20-somethings want to WFH all the time – vs. 41% of people in their 50s and early 60s. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
One indicator of the type of roles that are more suitable to #wfh is limited social interaction at work
Jobs in, for example, coding, research, writing or data analysis that involve a lot of individual focused work are a good fit for WFH
Details: wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper showing large variations in wages for similar remote workers based on country of location
This explain what I hear some firms saying - that they are considering offshoring fully remote jobs to save on wage costs
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/s7nf7rdkfctb1runxumqu/Cavallo_Albe… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating data from @annatonger on the impact of #wfh on the demand for San Francisco office space
Given tech trends 20 years ahead of other business service industries this is a striking omen
Full story: sfstandard.com/business/how-techies-fueled-boom-and-bust-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New data showing UK firms providing greater #wfh have slower wage growth
The size is material - increasing WFH by 50% is associated with 1% lower yearly wage increase
A bit more evidence that WFH could help mute inflation
Details www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/ze0nyehkq62yzxxf4g44u/Decision-Mak… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece out today by Adam Ozimek showing the impact of #wfh on US cities
The 40 year bull-run of US cities - which saw incredible growth from early 1980s to 2019 - seems to have ended
For big cities this could be good in terms of trying to tame runaway rent inflation
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
**New report day** my first report at @InnovateEconomy. I look at the county population changes for 2021 and ask: does this have remote work's fingerprints on it? The answer is yes, remote work is having an effect on economic geography <thread> eig.org/news/how-remote-work-is-shifting-population-growt…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH is a bigger city trend
Our July 2022 www.wfhresearch.com update finds higher #wfh in big cities like NY, SF, DC, Chicago, Dallas and LA than in smaller cities and towns
This reflects industry mix - big cities have more tech, finance and management, jobs that can WFH
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Eric - interesting and yes WFH is very widespread and common. I was just surprised at the big-city skew as, like you, not immediately obvious to me. But even outside major cities we see 25% of days so still a very high level.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The Great Resistance: employees are refusing to return to the office. Two steps to address this:
1) Calculate how many in-person days the team needs - say two days per week
2) Set team anchor days to achieve this - say Tuesday, and Thursday - and encourage #wfh on other days
Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research
@SIEPR
SIEPR's July policy brief weighs return-to-office demands and #wfh desires. Read more from SIEPR's @I_Am_NickBloom about how businesses can can inch toward a connected, pre-pandemic work experience – without sacrificing remote work. siepr.stanford.edu/publications/work/great-resistance-get…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest #wfh discussion pack from exec education
Contains updated data and thoughts
Please share and provide advice and feedback - the best way to improve this is to open source this
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/uj22zlepbjex3reifqqd7/Exec_Briefin…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Bidjan - many thanks. The data on outsourcing/offshoring I know is the figure I tweeted about a week ago. This trend (particularly offshoring) is only just starting due to pandemic travel restrictions.
Great take on equity - domestic politicians put this very differently :-)
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks for the methodology questions - the monthly results pack here have the details. And correct to ask as details matter in surveys
wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/WFHResearch_up… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Rates of #wfh are converging to 40% of days for graduates, so about 2 days per week
For non-graduates the rate is half that at 20% of days
This is the education divide in WFH - in firms I talk this often shows up as managers WFH while workers do not -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data showing the continuing rise in new innovations to support #wfh
Economists call this "directed technical change": when the market for something grows firms swivel their innovation to support this
This tells us WFH will rapidly improve with better hardware and software -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Free #wfh data
The Survey of Workplace Attitudes and Arrangements has been surveying 5,000+ people a month since May 2020
This SWAA data underlies much of our WFH research
It is updated monthly and free to use on the link below
wfhresearch.com/data/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Why IT is ground-zero for #wfh
The top-5 ways people get IT help are phone, email, web, messaging and chatbot
These can all be done remotely by WFH employees
This is similar for functions like HR, benefits and accounts
Details: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/s5978ui6mhmntk45x8omy/ivi-2700-202… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh has large effects on firms and workers. New data highlights the expansion of three practices
1) Part-time working
2) Contract working
3) Outsourcing and offshoring
This is weakening the links between employees and firms, making jobs more gig like
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/h7wx9j4kfvo6jnlv6wbyp/The-Shift-to… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh has led firms to moderate wage inflation by about 2%. This is critical given surging inflation.
So promoting WFH is one way for firms and policy-makers to combat inflation and moderate interest rates.
Maybe Jerome Powell should be promoting WFH :-)
www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/h7wx9j4kfvo6jnlv6wbyp/The-Shift-to… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Morning Consult's July Labor Reports finds that WFH increases productivity intel.morningconsult.com/mc-content
Reading dozens of these types of surveys, experimental studies and natural experiments it is clear that organized #wfh increases productivity on average -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece. I would emphasize commandment 1 for hybrid-WFH - "thou shalt coordinate"
Surveys show the key reason people return to the office is to work in person with colleagues
This happens when we coordinate coming in on the same days
www.inc.com/jessica-stillman/adam-grants-7-commandments-f… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The pandemic has made verbal greetings the most popular option when meeting people at work.
This is due to infection risks, and because #wfh has shifted the norm to verbal greetings on video-calls.
Will our future holograms return to shaking hands? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh has promoted rural job growth, reducing the economic polarization between rural and urban areas
By spreading white-collar job growth into rural areas WFH may even help moderate our polarized politics
Bledi Taska
@Bledi_Taska
Job postings in rural areas between 2019-2021 increased significantly more than job postings in urban areas, which reverses the trend that existed before 2019. Of the top 10 counties with the highest growth in posting share from 2019 to 2021, nine of them are rural.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Returning all WFH employees to the office 5-days-a week looks almost impossible
- Firms pushing 5 day returns see <50% compliance
- Firms pushing 4 days or less see >80% compliance
Firms should aim for something moderate and succeed, rather than aim for a 5-day return and fail
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes I agree the compliance at higher numbers like 3 or 4 days is surprising, although this is partly a selection effect. Some firms that would love a 4 day return are not even trying as they know the employees would never accept it.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great write-up of this
qz.com/work/2175691/only-49-percent-of-workers-asked-back… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh levels are converging to about 30% of days
Most of us - 80% of employees - are now in their post-COVID working arrangements
This means the pandemic generated the largest shock to working life since World War II: a six-fold increase in remote working in just two years
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Simon - thanks and on www.wfhresearch.com we do post the microdata that has the state so you could create regional measures. I can ask @Jose_MariaRD if we could also provide these ready made - good idea.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Wise words as always from @AdamGrant, highlighting why hybrid-WFH has become so popular.
Adam Grant
@AdamMGrant
You don't need people in the office every day.
The evidence is clear: hybrid work boosts productivity, creativity, well-being, & retention.
Great collaborations don't involve constant contact. They alternate between deep work and bursts of interaction.
tedtalks.social/WLAdam -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
About 20% of employees are not returning to the office as frequently as their employer wants
Managers tell me they are struggling to deal with this
Over 40% are ignoring it, while the rest are taking a range of approaches
What is Tesla's plan for employees that don't return?
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes it could be the plan is to use this as a cheap way to downsize. Although the people they will lose because they refuse to come to the office will mostly be people they might want to keep. Research generally finds hybrid-WFH is associated with higher performance.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks - not everyone wants to WFH, but almost 80% do at least 1 day per week, so they will not be happy with a full return (see slide 14 of www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/c1qdq7vkfxh0sf9n6j0zc/Rock.pptx?rl…)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper - the pandemic cut office values by 30%. Low quality office space fell even more, much of which is likely to be converted to residential
Uncertainty has also cut lease renewals - firms are trying to figure out #wfh before signing new leases
See papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4124698 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Talking about latest WFH trends, including Tesla comments )-:
Link below, starting in about 10 minutes -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tesla told employees to be at work 40 hours per week or quit
Our survey of 20,000+ Americans suggests about
1) 60% of employees will return
2) 30% will return but look for another job
3) 10% will quit
Or Tesla could raise pay 10% to compensate
(slide 8 stanford.io/3iBXRcD) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Call for Papers for a #wfh Conference
October 12-14, 2022, in Stanford
Please share, thanks (www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/22wg8cuao9pno8s8b11dy/RemoteWork.p…) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Offices are converging on a post-pandemic occupancy level of about 60% of Feb 2020 levels
But could a recession cut WFH levels?
Not much: firms I talk to adopt WFH for four reasons
1) Keeping employees happy
2) Saving space
3) DEI
4) Productivity
These are not that cyclical -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
My favorite #wfh graph: intuitive and important
Implications
1) Calculate how many in-person days each team needs per week
2) Coordinate on *anchor days* - days employees all come to work to be together in person
For example: Tues & Thurs in the office, Mon, Weds & Fri WFH -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Interesting new paper arguing rising #wfh is pushing up house prices
WFH workers spend more time at home so spend more money on housing
So unless we build more housing this pushes up prices (more money chasing the same number of houses)
So rising WFH will push up house prices -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
About 1 in 30 #wfh employees moonlights with two jobs at the same time, 4x the rate of in person workers
This seems fine if they are doing both jobs well
Indeed, a larger labor supply means more goods and services at lower prices -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Conference call for papers:
"The Macroeconomics of Uncertainty and Volatility"
September 14-16, 2022, in Stanford
Please share, thanks
economics.stanford.edu/paper-submission
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thankyou for the question. Research papers from anywhere are excepted - this is not US based - although travel funding is limited unfortunately, thanks. We also only take papers (so not abstracts) thanks Nick
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fantastic piece by @juliahobsbawm on that well known combination of cheese, mice and working from home
Some politicians are attacking #wfh, ignoring the evidence that this increases productivity and employee wellbeing.
www.theguardian.com/business/commentisfree/2022/may/15/le… -
Nick Bloom reposted
John Van Reenen
@johnvanreenen
There's still time to apply for working with me & amazing WMS team to do a new wave of management interviews this summer in Europe & US! Apply here worldmanagementsurvey.org/current-jobs/ @I_Am_NickBloom @raffasadun @danielascur @renata__lemos Come join the community! worldmanagementsurvey.org
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great to see Goldman mandating three weeks holiday. This is important for ensuring employees take breaks.
One group in particular that benefit is #wfh employees who can worry about office facetime
www.ft.com/content/d3787365-aba4-4002-b564-6c14e7f3c350 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Our April 2022 survey showed twice as high masking rates indoors for work as indoors for leisure
Maybe this is part of the #wfh split between work and leisure activity. Office footfall is still less than half its pre-pandemic level, while leisure activities are almost fully back -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New data showing distributed research teams have become increasingly innovative since the 1980s
Technologies like Zoom, Dropbox, Teams, Slack & Asana have improved remote collaboration
This progress has been accelerating in the pandemic, so #wfh will get even better in future -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Could #wfh be driving record quit rates?
Interviewing for a new job while working from home is easy - a discrete video call
Interviewing while working at the office can be hard - several hours away under some dubious excuse
Indeed, WFH may permanently increase job switching
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There a lot of implications. One is for macroeconomics.
As an economist the ability to search and match for new jobs is a critical factor shaping our understanding of labor markets. This clearly changes this, and hence the likely dynamics of macro policy and business cycles. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
In June 2021 Apple announced #wfh hybrid 3-2, in line with big-tech norms
Now firms are moving to 2-3, and a few firms like Airbnb and Quora have gone fully remote
Apple is now under pressure to allow WFH on Monday.....
.....this seems inevitable to me
www.engadget.com/apple-criticized-by-employees-over-worki… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New paper shows #wfh win-win for employees & firms
1) 1/3 of time saved from less commuting goes on personal activities, 2/3 on work
2) WFH gives flexibility to visit the dentist, get exercise, pick up the kids etc, and work more later to make up
Paper cep.lse.ac.uk/pubs/download/dp1844.pdf -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
How will rising mortgage payments - from higher interest rates and house prices - impact #wfh?
Usually when housing gets more expensive people move further from city centers to balance budgets.
So I think this will drive greater demand for WFH days. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Nature experimental paper finds in person meetings raises innovation by about 15%
Randomized Control Trial paper finds WFH 2 days a week reduces employee quits by 35%
Hybrid #wfh can deliver both
3 office days for better innovation
2 home days for better employee retention
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
To be precise WFH hybrid 3-2 or 2-3 would likely both achieve this, and they are now about equally popular with organizations in the US and UK I talk too.
So not trying to promote either scheme - just the idea of some time each week in the office and some time each week at home.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Links for both studies:
Nature paper: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/xdcghlu2eqkjvztu1d0cu/s41586-022-0…
RCT paper: stanford.io/3je2FVS
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece from @AdamMGrant suggesting the evidence is not so clear cut on video vs in person. This is an area where more research would be great given the importance to organizations, employees and urban geography.
adamgrant.bulletin.com/no-you-don-t-have-to-meet-in-person/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Airbnb is going fully remote, with quarterly in person retreats. This full-remote + occasional retreat option is popular in tech: e.g. Airbnb, Upwork, Quora & Automattic
In other industries #wfh hybrid 3-2 or 2-3 dominates
The 5-day return to the office seems have died in 2021
Brian Chesky
@bchesky
Today, we’re announcing that Airbnb employees can live and work anywhere.
Our design for working at Airbnb has 5 key features: -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Ongoing growth of WFH for professionals
I see two margins
-Extensive: firms relenting from forcing employees back 5 days a week to typically hybrid 3-2
-Intensive: firms moving from 3-2 to 2-3 or 2-2-1 (where the 1 is a choice, but in practice is 2-3)
www.wsj.com/articles/the-optimal-workweek-is-two-days-in-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tightly monitoring employees to force them back to the office is a bad sign
Organized hybrid gets entire teams in on the same days and rewards performance. Then employees are fine to return a few days per week to see colleagues and work together in person
www.nytimes.com/2022/04/22/business/hybrid-work-attendanc… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A factor driving #wfh is employees' desire to "long social distance"
Almost 30% of US adults plan to partially or fully social distance post-pandemic
How will firms react - will they let employees that want to long social distance WFH forever? Not sure
Question + data below -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
March 2020 data shows yet again employers increasing their post-pandemic WFH plans
This has risen so much that hybrid 3-2 (3 office days and 2 home days) is being replaced by hybrid 2-3 in many firms I talk to. A few are going permanently remote
Slides wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/WFHResearch_up…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes sorry it should be March 2022 - thanks for spotting
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is the source: wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/WFHResearch_up…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Long Social Distancing is boosting #wfh
In our monthly survey of 5,000 Americans 10%+ claim they will continue to socially distance post-pandemic
They do not want to return to work in person, and forcing them could lead them to quit
Research wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/LongSocialDist… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Tania Babina 🇺🇸 🇺🇦
@TaniaBabina
Demand US #housebacktowork from recess to pass the Land-Lease Act now! Senate passed it 100-0 (wow!) last week to get military equipment to Ukraine fast, but House then went to 2 week recess #notimetorest
@SpeakerPelosi @LeaderHoyer @GOPLeader #househelpukraine #econtwitter -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New randomized control trial on 3-2 hybrid #wfh vs 5-days in office
Finds hybrid WFH
1) Lowers quits by 35%
2) Raises employee satisfaction
3) Has no negative effect on performance or promotions
Results so good the firm allowed WFH in all divisions
See stanford.io/3je2FVS
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Yes - ideally we would run 2 RCT experiments. One (this one) comparing 5-days at work vs 3-2 hybrid, and another comparing 5-days at home vs 3-2 hybrid.
After that trial different versions of hybrid as (in the US) most organizations see hybrid as the future. But not all.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Some replies:
- Randomization was a coin flip on even v odd. Odd won so birthdays on 1, 3, 5, 7 etc of the month got to WFH
- We would love to trial 5 days WFH vs 3-2 hybrid. Any offers :-)
- Difference in quit rates signif. at 4% level, so CIs almost half the gap between bars -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Holograms & VR are enabling greater #wfh so within 10 years these could
1) Increase WFH days so 1-4 hybrid is the norm
2) Encourage more migration from city centers
3) Reduce demand for city center commercial space
Related paper stanford.io/3dsXazL
www.wsj.com/video/series/in-depth-features/amid-zoom-fati… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#wfh is cutting city center retail spending
Impacts could include
1) Retail spending down 10% to 30%
2) Retail rents down similar amounts
3) City centers emptier and cheaper
Losers: retail property owners
Winners: employees who get to WFH
More stanford.io/3iOOlmF -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Just to follow-up WFH share is falling - so the BLS trend is right. We also find that wfhresearch.com as does Kastle & Gallup
The problem with the BLS data is
A) The level is wrong (WFH is about 30%)
B) It is getting more wrong over time (the downward trend is too steep)
Bhushan Sethi
@bhushansethi1
That might be true - but can we also acknowledge that number has been steadily falling and is now at a pandemic low of 10%?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
BLS WFH data is misleading. They ask
"At any time in the last 4 weeks, did you telework or work at home for pay because of the coronavirus pandemic?"
This excludes people that
1) WFH but not because of the pandemic
2) WFH pre-pandemic
Most data shows current WFH at 25% to 35% -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great conference today about future of New York
1) Hybrid WFH is creating a "donut effect" - employees moving to the suburbs
2) City center real-estate and retail are soft
3) NY still has a bright future, but a bit less bright than pre-COVID
Full slides stanford.io/3iOOlmF
Matthew Boyle
@bizboyle
New Yorkers who worked from home during the pandemic plan to cut their time in the office by half going forward, research from @I_Am_NickBloom shows. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-31/new-yorkers-pl… via @citylab w/@livrockeman
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
You can read this data two ways to support #wfh
1) If you WFH you save 9 minutes a day on less personal grooming (the red bars)
2) If you go to work a few colleagues will less than fully "groomed" (the blue bars)
Full slides stanford.io/3iBXRcD -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Universal high-speed internet could boost US GDP by 1%, which is $200bn a year
This is important for policy - broadband in all rural areas will drive development
Firms may also want to pay for broadband for #wfh employees - it is hard to WFH without it
www.chicagobooth.edu/review/why-universal-high-speed-inte… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Market forces are driving #wfh
WFH has increased 500% so firms are ramping up R&D spending to support this
Big WFH use = big profits for better WFH products
So patents for WFH hardware and software are surging (updated figure from stanford.io/3dsXazL with @m_codreanu) -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid WFH is here - offices are still only 40% full while leisure activities have returned
Office occupancy will eventually flatline at about 60% once the return to office is complete (3-2 hybrid for the average employee)
My thoughts on managing hybrid stanford.io/3qmDPXZ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New global survey of #wfh
Initial results are here stanford.io/3NbvWyk
Summary:
1) WFH perceptions have improved globally
2) WFH raises productivity by about 5%
3) Employees want 2 days per week WFH, employers offering 1 day
4) Employees value WFH at about 5% of earnings -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I developed some slides from discussing #wfh with many organizations stanford.io/37x51fQ
Key points
1) Try something low risk like 3-2 hybrid for 2022
2) Acknowledge this is a six month plan
3) Survey and collect feedback in late 2022
4) Update to a longer-run plan for 2023 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Econofacts is a great podcast I have been listening to for many years - about 25 minutes focused on one topic each week.
I interviewed this week on #wfh - overview of trends, productivity and some thoughts on the future.
econofact.org/podcast/remote-work-in-the-post-pandemic-era -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Tweeted yesterday that rents up 20% in big city suburbs
Up 30% in smaller city & town suburbs from #wfh
Only the centers of big cities like NY, SF and DC have not seen above trend rent growth. Reversing history - these big city centers saw the fastest rent growth from 1980-2019 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Long social distancing
In our survey data over 10% consistently claim they will keep socially distancing post-pandemic
Respondees are paying attention: we have three attention checks and drop anyone who fails any of them
Another long-run driver of #wfh?
www.nytimes.com/2022/03/19/world/researchers-find-an-ongo… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest rents data: by January 2022 city center rents are back to their pre-pandemic trend.
Suburban rents are way up at 20% above trend.
#wfh is increasing the demand for space, and since the supply of real-estate is fixed in the short-run, rents have surged.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thanks and definitions are: High density = top 10% zip codes , suburb = 50-90th %, exurb = 0-50th %. City center zipcodes with centroids within 2 km of Central Business District coordinates from Holian (2019).
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data from 20k respondees in Australia. In summary:
1) Employees mostly want hybrid - mix of home & office
2) Productivity is slightly up with WFH
3) People are happier when they WFH
4) People go out less when they WFH
Matches data I've seen from US, UK and Europe.
Tom Crowley
@TomisCrowley
New data alert! I'm excited about this. Asked our audience about attitudes to wfh. I've been frustrated with patchy data on wfh preferences, esp the lack of data asking young people **why** they have the prefs they do. Very interesting results imo, check em out and pls share ⬇️
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
If you have students that are interested in working on a management research project zoom interviewing firms please have them apply.
It's a fully remote job, working with the team from Cornell-Harvard-LSE-MIT-Stanford. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Face time with colleagues dominates the benefits of being in the office
There is little perceived value coming to work to:
A) Be on a computer all day.
B) Have face time with your manager
For a return to office to be a success colleagues need to come in together to be together
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I would combine factors one and two together to call them - "spending time in person with colleagues"
Doing this makes it clear people mostly come into work to be in person with colleagues and co-workers
This is why coordination on days in is key for hybrid -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This matches www.wfhresearch.com - we find 23% want a full return to the office, 32% want full remote, but 45% want hybrid
Employees value the saved commute and flexibility of WFH, but often like 2 to 3 days with colleagues at work
WFH in moderation
www.forbes.com/sites/jenamcgregor/2022/03/15/two-years-in… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The Economist is fantastic, but less so this piece
Argues against hybrid WFH, but
1) Names one source - from a firm selling office services
2) Focuses on anecdotes not data
3) Attacks fully remote - but hybrid (WFH part of the week) is not fully remote
www.economist.com/business/2022/03/12/is-hybrid-work-the-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The hybrid #wfh battle of choice vs coordination
70% of workers want to choose WFH days. But 76% want the same WFH days as colleagues
This is hard to square - you can't have the same in-person days if everyone chooses days
I suspect coordination will eventually dominate -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The booming housing market may slow the return to office.
The 30% increases in rent and property prices since Feb 2020 is pricing many workers out of cities, forcing them to remain working fully remotely.
time.com/6156751/remote-work-office-housing-market/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Goldman is forcing employees back 5 days a week. Two predictions
1) 80% of employees will return, the rest will leave
2) This will damage diversity - people who are minorities by gender, age, race & politics at work want more WFH
GS is making a mistake
www.yahoo.com/video/goldman-sachs-ceo-demanded-employees-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great paper - highlights how #wfh is extremely pervasive at around 50% of all US employees.
Also notes the challenges of measuring this, and how the BLS government is problematic.
Their Gallup data aligns very well with our www.wfhresearch.com data
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
How Many Americans Work Remotely?
@johnjhorton, Christos Makridis, @AlexMasPton, @ModeledBehavior, @danielrock, @ocolluphid & I find that gov't stats underestimate remote work.
The actual share is ~50% working remote at least 1x/week.
#econtwitter #wfh
digitaleconomy.stanford.edu/publications/how-many-america… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Fascinating new book examining the impact of the surge in remote work.
Highlights how the focus on #wfh has expanded from working conditions in 2020 to the broader effects on firms, cities and labor markets by 2022.
Matthew E. Kahn
@mattkahn1966
My 2022 book explores the new economic geography (in the year 2025) of the rise of Work from Home. My Going Remote book can be thought of as a sequel to Enrico's New Geography of Jobs. As I get ready for many public interviews, here are my talking points.
books.google.com/books/about/Going_Remote.html?id=kt-izgE… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Key benefits of #wfh:
1) The 70 minutes saved per day (60 minutes from no commute, 10 minutes from less time getting ready)
2) More flexibility to set your own schedule
This is particularly valued by women, highlighting how WFH can promote workforce gender balance
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great points.
Any suggestions @jessiehandbury @erimbau @HR_Gem on what would be the best policy by firms and organizations (on twitter or directly thanks)? It is complicated and not so obvious to me what to advise executives on this, so advice/thoughts would be helpful. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Just heard the best phrase from @johnvanreenen which is "working from work"
We know #wfh has truly arrived when people start talking about "working from work" -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece on #wfh driven relocation - people moving out from city centers to the suburbs (hybrid WFH) and away (fully remote)
1980-2019 was the era of urbanization as educated people moved into city centers
2020+ will be the era of de-urbanization driven by WFH
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
*REPORT*: The New Geography of Remote Work
Is remote work changing where people live? Yes, and its not just to the nearby suburbs. www.upwork.com/press/releases/the-new-geography-of-remote… <thread> -
Nick Bloom reposted
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
*REPORT*: The New Geography of Remote Work
Is remote work changing where people live? Yes, and its not just to the nearby suburbs. www.upwork.com/press/releases/the-new-geography-of-remote… <thread> -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Suburban home prices have risen 30% during the pandemic - the same as the S&P500 - and far more than the 5% for city centers.
The continuing rise of #wfh is driving this.
Many people who can now WFH 2 or 3 days a week are moving to the suburbs for more space and a home office -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The US has lost about 5m workers vs the pre-pandemic trend. This is hurting growth and inflation. #wfh can help by increasing labor supply.
54% of unemployed respondees cite WFH as an enticement to return to work
www.wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest data - #wfh levels are dropping, but very slowly.
Firms mention two reasons:
1) Variants - employees still concerned, so full RTO not until Summer 2022
2) WFH works well - we are approaching the post-COVID norm, and that norm is *a lot* of WFH
www.wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Latest data - firms' post-COVID #wfh levels just keep rising. Two key reasons
1) Learning - improved WFH processes, management and equipment
2) Hot labor markets - employers are having to offer ever more WFH to compete for talent
www.wfhresearch.com -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Sharing data on the future and impact of #wfh for the NASA Sigma series today (1st March 2022) at 7:30pm Eastern, which is free to join online.
vasc.org/sigma-series/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
During the pandemic #wfh days have been similar by gender (top slide). But post-COVID women have about a 50% larger gap between WFH desires and employer plans (bottom slide).
www.wfhresearch.com
This relates to concerns over WFH equity across employees I often hear in firms. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
A benefit of the #wfh revolution is flexible time. Flexitime and flexiplace have long gone together.
Moving away from the 9-5 shift will impact many things - business hours, retail hours, school hours, doctors hours, transport schedules etc.
This may be as revolutionary as WFH -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Nice @lkatz42 point: fully remote work eases job hopping. Hybrid WFH should reduce turnover.
"When the office becomes a group chat punctuated by Zoom meetings, switching jobs is practically as easy as logging out of one Slack account and into another"
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/02/work-from-home-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Interesting - fully remote professionals in firms I talk to have regular retreats. Often one week each quarter to help employees bond.
Is that better than commuting 2 days a week? Less time away, but big blocks on an irregular schedule that is maybe harder for shared childcare.
Nathan Taylor
@ntaylor963
One of Matt Mullenweg's key points on getting to full remote is you *must* pair it with having an annual face-to-face grand meetup.
I think this idea of having planned face-to-face meetups is insufficiently appreciated in remote work discussions.
ma.tt/2018/10/the-importance-of-meeting-in-person/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Really great advice from Anna/Larry/Richard
I particularly love 5 (which is often pretty fun too)
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Going through slides from @lkatz42's unparalleled PhD Labor class this morning as I prep my own teaching, and was reminded of this gem - Richard Freeman's 5 rules for empirical work in labor economics
(inc "quarks can't speak but humans can tell you what they think is going on") -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
trip.com are rolling out 3-2 hybrid WFH. In a 6-month randomized control trial on 1600 employees we saw:
- employees happier
- quit rates down a third
- sick leave down 30%
- employees reported increased efficiency
www.scmp.com/tech/tech-trends/article/3167150/chinas-larg… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Our survey data on 3,000 firms finds the pandemic lowered the quality of goods and services that is not reflected in the price by 1.3%. This implies true inflation was likely about 1.3% higher over the period.
www.nber.org/papers/w28233 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Desires to #wfh varies by party. Democrats want one third more days than Republicans. This gap is similar after controlling for education, income, demographics, location and occupation.
So politics seems to play a surprisingly large role in explaining Americans WFH preferences. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Thoughtful piece by an OECD team examining data on 20+ countries, arguing WFH is here to stay in a mostly hybrid form.
Highlights the importance for hybrid-WFH of:
(I) coordination over days
(II) good equipment, and
(III) managerial training
voxeu.org/article/teleworking-here-stay-and-may-raise-pro… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
An impact of #wfh is the collapse in public transport ridership. BART is projecting a permanent 30% fall. Given high fixed costs of subway systems this could lead to bankruptcy.
Maybe redirect some of the tax subsidies for roads towards saving subways?
www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/BART-faces-its-most-c… -
Nick Bloom reposted
John Van Reenen
@johnvanreenen
Economists discuss the impact of working from home on productivity, job satisfaction, and women’s career progression blogs.lse.ac.uk/businessreview/2022/02/01/economists-disc… @econromesh on @cep_lse work cep.lse.ac.uk/pubs/download/dp1194.pdf
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Contentious WFH topics:
1) Should employees come in a few days each week (hybrid) or go fully remote?
2) Under hybrid should employees choose their WFH days or firms coordinate on the same day?
3) Will WFH continue to grow and improve after COVID?
I think: Yes, No, Yes
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
Talking to @I_Am_NickBloom today at noon ET about remote work, it should be fun.
What % will Nick and I disagree versus agree on the future of remote work? -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
New BLS survey: sectors with high WFH levels had high business relocation rates. We often think WFH lets employees move, but businesses can move too!
So WFH makes businesses more footloose, raising the importance of states improving business conditions to retain/attract firms.
Mike Dalton
@WhereTheJobsAt
[Thread 2] Telework and Relocation
The three sectors that had highest % w/ increase in telework were also 3 most likely to relocate during pandemic.
Food services had lowest % increase in telework & least likely to relocate.
.@ModeledBehavior .@I_Am_NickBloom -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Figuring out #wfh will take time as company leaders have been struggling to deal with the daily challenges of the pandemic.
The average CEO in our 3,000 firm survey spent 12 hours a week dealing with the pandemic.
www.bankofengland.co.uk/error/404.html -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Op-Ed in the LAT arguing hybrid WFH is the new normal for professionals. This is a key benefit for employees, valued on average the same as an 8% pay increase. But much is still unknown about the details, so CEOs need to keep an open mind, and experiment.
www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-02-08/remote-work-pand… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH desires vary widely: 22.7% never want to, 32% always want to, and 45.3% want a hybrid mix. Two implications:
1) Hybrid 3-2 WFH is a good initial "vanilla" choice if your firm is unsure
2) Managers should poll employees before finalizing as individual views can be outliers -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Amusing Forbes piece on the 10 minutes of daily time savings when #wfh by skimping on personal grooming.
www.forbes.com/sites/jenamcgregor/2022/02/02/less-deodora… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
How is the 70 minutes saved each day by #wfh (60 from less commuting, 10 from less personal grooming) used? About 30 minutes (40%) on work, 25 minutes (35%) on leisure, and 15 minutes (25%) on chores and childcare.
So employers, individuals and families should all gain from WFH -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Employees spend 28 minutes getting ready when they travel to work vs 19 minutes when they work from home. This #wfh time saving arises in every industry, occupation, education, location, race, age and gender - for example:
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH saves employees about 70 minutes a day on average. Most (about 60 minutes) from no commute, and the rest (about 10 minutes) from less preparation in the morning. About 1/2 of this saved time goes to working more and 1/2 to leisure/tasks, so employers and employees benefit.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH allows greater flexibility over working hours, including for wake-up times. We find 10.2% less people use an alarm clock when #wfh. Maybe one reason why WFH employees have higher average productivity - they are less tired, or they can work late and then get up late?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great piece on remote onboarding which can be tricky with #wfh. Key points include:
1) Set-up introductory 1:1s to meet people, before you need to ask for their help.
2) Share screens to provide "over the shoulder" learning
3) Set-up regular feedback
www.linkedin.com/pulse/how-onboard-remotely-15-lessons-fr… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Views on why office space demand has held up so well during the pandemic. I thought it would collapse in 2020 due to WFH, but talking to firms and seeing the survey data it looks like office space demand will remain roughly flat.
hbr.org/2022/01/why-companies-arent-cutting-back-on-offic… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Interesting piece raising the issue of flexitime alongside flexiplace (WFH). With WFH a major benefit employees report is timing flexibility - the ability to take time out to pick up your kids, go to the gym, visit the dentist etc.
Katie Bindley
@katiebindley
Flexibility, both w respect to hours and location, is increasingly a top priority for knowledge workers and the majority are ready to quit if they don't get it:
www.wsj.com/articles/workers-care-more-about-flexible-hou… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Surveillance software sales exploded during the pandemic. This is bad - it is intrusive and demotivating. But, rigorous performance evaluations of WFH employees is important. This frees them to organize their time knowing they are rewarded for their performance not clock watching
Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research
@SIEPR
How would you feel if your employer monitored your work from afar? Here, @latimes' @GustavoArellano shines a light on the emergence of employee surveillance tech & discusses what it could mean for the #futureofwork w/ help from SIEPR's @I_Am_NickBloom: lat.ms/3ruGWwx
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Online meetings are seen as particularly efficient by more educated employees. Perhaps BA/MsC/PhD employees have a better home office or internet, or value screen-sharing to analyze data, code or documents? Suggests the benefits of #wfh are dependent on many factors.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Small meetings are preferred online - no travelling between meetings. Large meetings are preferred in person - no muting, no tiny zoom boxes, and chatting before/after. This is a benefit of coordinating office days under hybrid #wfh - large meetings can always be in person
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The surge in #wfh is linked to less business travel as we are more comfortable interacting remotely. The average US firm forecasts a 30% reduction. As an academic I already see this - many more events and meetings in future will be online (but certainly not all).
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Around a quarter of people report being less efficient #workingfromhome. The major constraints are fixable with some quiet space, better equipment and reliable childcare. As we recover from the pandemic we should push for progress on these, so that WFH can continue to improve
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Preferences to work from home vary by demographic. This risks a mismatch if WFH days are set by senior managers without consulting employees.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Here is the cut by respondee age (left) and age of their youngest child (right). Employees with young kids at home prefer more WFH days, and this accounts for much of the age profile.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Survey reported WFH efficiency has increased from about 5% to 8% during the pandemic. Firms report this is due to investment, learning and adaptation - better equipment, management practices and home-organization.
The economics of adapting to and improving a new technology. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
An impact of #wfh on city centers is reduced retail expenditure, hotel stays and residency of high-earners, which will all cut city tax revenues. Cities can resize public services to address this, but this could be painful (e.g. New York 1975) @Richard_Florida
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
To be clear we are certainly not going back to New York in 1975, but that was driven in part by a public-sector budget crisis which surging WFH raises the risk of. See
www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-night-new-york-saved…
and
www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/blackout-gal… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Boston and LA - like most large US cities - saw about 15% of population leaving the city center during the pandemic. This is the classic donut-effect as #wfh employees move to the suburbs for more space. This has dramatically increased rents and home prices in the suburbs.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Sick days fall with #wfh - we found sick-days fell 1/3 with WFH stanford.io/3JOxnkB. Sick days can be employees caring for a sick child, emergency plumber call-out, doctors appointment etc - so they WFH rather than miss a day if they can.
www.wsj.com/articles/for-remote-workers-the-sick-day-is-o… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Google is spending $1bn on new offices - this is what we would expect with hybrid-WFH. This requires 3 busy days each week in person, so the office needs to be central, high-quality and set-up for meetings and social interactions.
www.wsj.com/articles/google-doubles-down-on-the-office-bu… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Post-COVID we predict 55% jobs in person, 30% hybrid #wfh and 15% fully-remote. Hybrid and fully-remote should make employees happy since most want 2 to 5 days WFH per week. But fully-remote jobs are exposed long-run to outsourcing & offshoring. @ModeledBehavior @Richard_Florida
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great post - jobs seen at risk of offshoring have ended up shifting to remote instead. Post-pandemic, however, I think these jobs may end-up offshoring.
The pandemic will generate a 2020s service sector globalization, like manufacturing did in the 2000s.
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
At the AEA meeting and in the week since I have heard several mentions of Alan Blinder's paper from mid 2000s predicting that 25% of jobs would be offshored. Makes me realize that the economics field is very unaware of my 2019 paper, so a quick thread....
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Nice piece in the Economist on the rise of #wfh, and suggestion by @ModeledBehavior this reduces the cost of starting firms. Many friends in Silicon Valley are now founding fully remote firms.
Could this reverse the long-run fall in US business creation?
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2022/01/15/will-r… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
#workingfromhome has become a critical hiring tool given how tight US labor markets are – firms not offering this risk having high-performing employees poached by rivals. This has pushed firms I've talked to into increasing their #wfh generosity.
voxeu.org/article/let-me-work-home-or-i-will-find-another… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Research data usually finds hybrid #wfh improves employee productivity. We asked employees why, finding "saved commuting time" and "quieter" the most common explanations. Fewer meetings, more efficient meals and less stress were also important.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
This was the cleaned up figure - somehow the old one was tweeted (obviously nothing to do with working from home :-) )
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The big battle for hybrid #wfh after COVID will be choice vs coordination. Choice allows employees flexibility over days, while coordination lets employees work together in person. About 1/3 of US firms are choosing choice and 2/3 team or firm coordination
www.atlantafed.org/blogs/macroblog/2022/01/12/hybrid-work… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Presenteeism bias - whereby #wfh employees miss out on promotions - is found in research studies (e.g. stanford.io/3JOxnkB and @emma_k_h). Employees are concerned by this, particularly younger ones. Training and monitoring can help address presenteeism bias.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Agreed - great paper showing:
(I) remote work increased productivity; but
(II) remote workers suffered presenteeism bias lowering promotion; and (likely due to this)
(III) remote workers were negatively self-selected
I hope post-COVID outcomes (II) & (III) will change.
Julia Pollak
@juliaonjobs
Hey, #econtwitter, what was your favorite paper of 2021? Mine was 'Working' Remotely? Selection, Treatment, and Market Provision of Remote Work by @emma_k_h & @NataliaHEmanuel, and I find it even more important after watching @emma_k_h present it & Alex Bartik discuss #assa2022
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Survey data shows the handshake has slumped in popularity during COVID. Suggests some employees may use #wfh to avoid forced personal contact at work (handshakes offered by senior managers and clients that are hard to refuse).
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Neat piece showing the switch to online seminars increased: (1) the share of presentations by elite academics; (2) the share of presentations by female academics; and (3) the distance between host and speaker institution. Implications for WFH I think?
blogs.lse.ac.uk/covid19/2021/12/08/which-speakers-will-be… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid work from home can only succeed if mangers work remotely on their team’s home-days. If managers come into the office on home-days this pushes employees, particularly younger employees, to come in too.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
I love the FT, but not this article. The title makes a claim against "Hybrid" but the text talks about "fully remote", which are different. It also misrepresents the research literature: causal research designs find positive productivity impacts. @emma_k_h
www.ft.com/content/d0df2f1b-2f83-4188-b236-83ca3f0313df -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Firms are increasing their plans for #wfh as the pandemic drags. They have adapted their management, organization and IT to operate better with #workfromhome employees.
So the return-to-office delay to Spring 2022 will further increase post-COVID WFH.
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The relentless rise of working from home figure was missing a source - here it is with a source
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
We have been collecting data across countries on #workingfromhome and really interesting that the desire to #wfh is similar across countries in both the mean - average of about 2 days a week - and the spread - lots of variation across people.
Cevat Giray Aksoy
@cevatgirayaksoy
Delighted to have been awarded King’s Together funding to collect our own data to track the incidence of working from home in both developed and developing countries w/ @I_Am_NickBloom, Steve Davis, @MathiasDolls, @Jose_MariaRD & @PabloZarate98
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
There will be a post-pandemic divide of employees into three groups - all on-site, hybrid-WFH and all remote - which will be about 50%, 40% and 10% of employees. The all remote group are very exposed to outsourcing and offshoring in the long-run.
www.inc.com/bill-murphy-jr/a-stanford-economist-who-studi… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Jose Maria Barrero
@Jose_MariaRD
Earlier on Friday I participated in a great @ASSAMeeting panel organized by @business_econ
I talked about The Work-From-Home-Outlook in 2022 and Beyond based on our work at @WFHResearch
Slides here: www.jmbarrero.com/s/Barrero-AEA-NABE-Jan22.pdf -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
When firms return to the office by (hopefully) Summer there are likely to be battles over the execution of hybrid-WFH. Hybrid WFH is a great policy, but details matter - like who chooses which days to WFH, and should these be mandatory?
www.cnbc.com/2022/01/07/stanford-professor-expect-huge-ba… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Managers should try to stick to hybrid WFH schedules.
If managers come in to the office work on WFH days it pressures their employees to do the same. This can be hard for those with commitments, like children, who cannot as easily come in to work on extra days. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
San Francisco lost 20% of its city-center population from the "donut effect" - tech and finance workers moving to the suburbs to work remotely. How many will come back, and what is best for the city? stanford.io/3IjAekD
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Working from home has become a critical hiring tool in tight US labor markets – firms not offering this risk having high-performing employees poached by rivals
www.marketwatch.com/story/firms-not-offering-this-are-mis… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Predictions on the future of working-from-home, and implications for firms, employees and real-estate.
www.barrons.com/articles/ive-been-studying-work-from-home… -
Nick Bloom reposted
Arjun Ramani
@arjun_ramani3
The 2021 rental surge has started to show in official inflation data with more to come in 2022. One reason for the lag: Zillow looks at listed rents whilst official data look at paid rents which update infrequently. See my note @TheEconomist for more: www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2021/10/16/anothe…
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The WFH “Donut effect” - workers moving out from city centers to the suburbs - caused city-center rents to collapse. They have now returned to pre-pandemic levels. Rents in the suburbs are up 20% and still rising – inflation in action
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The WFH donut effect is a big city issue. In the middle and smaller cities commutes are shorter and space more affordable, so fewer workers moved to the suburbs during the pandemic.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The WFH “Donut effect” - workers moving out from city centers to the suburbs - caused city-center rents to collapse. They have now returned to pre-pandemic levels. Rents in the suburbs are up 20% and still rising – inflation in action
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Data shows small 2-4 person meetings are better by videocall (no travelling to meet people), but large 10+ person meetings are better face-to-face (no muting, no tiny faces in videocall boxes).
So for hybrid WFH hold large meetings on in-person days.
voxeu.org/article/comparing-online-person-meetings -
Nick Bloom reposted
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
When are virtual meetings better?
•
“findings of a survey of over 2,000 UK working adults, which suggest that online meetings are more efficient for gatherings of 2 to 4 people, while in-person meetings are preferred for gatherings of 10 or more”
voxeu.org/article/comparing-online-person-meetings -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Great interview of Adam Ozimek on remote work @ModeledBehavior
thebrowser.com/notes/adam-ozimek/ -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid WFH is valued more by employees with pre or elementary school children at home – so firms wanting to retain and recruit younger employees should consider offering hybrid WFH
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Hybrid WFH is valued most by Tech and Finance employees – the job works well with WFH, and employees have enough income for good home-internet and space (thanks to @MariannaKudlyak for the question)
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Goldman has delayed an office return - but will that eventual return be full time or hybrid WFH? Since Morgan Stanley, Lazards, Citi, Merrill's etc all offer hybrid WFH, I think Goldmans will eventually do the same to avoid heavy attrition of employees
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/02/business/goldman-sachs-return-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Employees value Hybrid WFH about the same as a 10% pay rise on average. Firms not offering this are missing out on a highly effective way to retain and recruit staff.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH and diversity: survey data finds workplaces are less enjoyable for employees in a minority by age, gender, politics, race or religion. They report WFH days are particularly valuable.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Home prices in city suburbs have risen 25% with the pandemic WFH “Donut effect” - workers moving from city centers to the suburbs stanford.io/3IjAekD
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The future of work has never been more unpredictable
www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220104-future-of-work-2022 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH days were doubling every 13 years pre-pandemic.
In 2020 they jumped over 12-fold - equivalent to almost 50 years of pre-pandemic growth. Has there been a bigger work-life balance shock?
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Good point - about 1/3 of jobs can be done *fully* WFH (see @TradeDiversion @BrentNeiman), but about 2/3 can be done *hybrid* WFH. These are jobs with some activities - reading, email, expenses, reports, writing - that can be done on WFH days in.
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Looking back to an early pandemic blog.
One prediction was right: WFH hybrid is the future (it is @ModeledBehavior).
One prediction was wrong: cities will decline (they are doing fine @Richard_Florida @Cutler_econ).
siepr.stanford.edu/publications/policy-brief/how-working-… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH is creating an IT spending boom, and a land & buildings spending slump
voxeu.org/article/covid-19-and-structural-change -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Speaking to hundreds of firms none of them is planning a full 5-day return to the office. Even Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan have apparently given-up. Employees strongly want hybrid WFH - so forcing a full return risks mass quitting.
hbr.org/2021/08/dont-force-people-to-come-back-to-the-off… -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH has made national broadband very valuable - worth about $160bn a year - as only 41% of Americans have internet good enough to run uninterrupted videocalls. wfhresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Internet-Acces…
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Research from @megonomista and @danielascur shows that better managed firms had superior performance during the pandemic.
One reason is well-managed firms can handle change
NBER
@nberpubs
Better-managed firms are able to make more accurate micro and macro predictions; management practices are critical to helping firms deal with change and unpredictable events, from @I_Am_NickBloom, Kawakubo, Meng, Mizen, Riley, Senga, and @johnvanreenen www.nber.org/papers/w29591
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
2 days a week in the office and 3 days a week WFH is the middle ground of what employees want
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Discussed WFH with Delphine Strauss at the FT
www.ft.com/content/c3ada896-c7df-46a0-bb23-10aa723fd1e9 -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Before COVID WFH had a negative stigma.
No longer - WFH is now what managers and CEOs do. -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The return-to-office date is dying cnb.cx/3IX3gXI
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Monday and Friday are the popular days to WFH: which days would you choose?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH is supported by tight labor markets: 43% of employees would leave if forced to come back full-time
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
The future of the hybrid office - collaborative spaces
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH on Monday/Friday makes it hard to cut space
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Will people ever return to pre-pandemic activities?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
What are Americans doing with the 50 million commuting hours saved each day when WFH?
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
20 months on has WFH been a success?
Absolutely -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
What is the biggest reason people are quitting their jobs right now?
WFH
For more see wfhresearch.com and follow #wfhresearch -
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
WFH will get better. The WFH boom is leading to a WFH technology boom. Updated graph from paper with Steve Davis and Yulia Zhestkova stanford.io/3dsXazL
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
Will Omicron stall the return to big cities - the center of New York and other US cities have lost 15% of their population since Feb 2020 stanford.io/3IjAekD
-
Nick Bloom
@I_Am_NickBloom
What's happening




























































































































































































































































































































































































