Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use
corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens
shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content
published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts
of popular accounts freely available.
Read more.
Peter Suber
Peter Dain Suber (born November 8, 1951) is an American philosopher specializing in the philosophy of law and open access to knowledge. He is a Senior Researcher at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society, Director of the Harvard Office for Scholarly Communication, and Director of the Harvard Open Access Project (HOAP). Suber is known as a leading voice in the open access movement, and as the creator of the game Nomic. More on Wikipedia
Open research, metaresearch, academic culture, US politics, democracy. More active on #Mastodon.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This is the last month of activity for the Open Access Tracking Project ( #oatp, @oatp ). September 30, 2026, will be the last day of tagging and updates.
1/ Hamilton wrote Federalist No. 1 in 1787. He named exactly who would resist the new Constitution — and he was describing people who still exist today. A thread.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Ossoff: When he first announced the tariffs, you remember that? He called it Liberation Day, and it crashed the markets because it was clown policy. You remember that?
OK, so follow me through on this. He announces the tariffs on April 2 of last year. The markets tank nonstop for like a week because it’s a disastrous trade policy, and six days into the crash, April 8, Trump buys millions in stock. I’m talking Amazon, Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Berkshire Hathaway, and then the very next morning, April 9, he posts on Truth Social, quote, “This is a great time to buy.” Three exclamation marks.
OK, now listen to this. Three hours and 41 minutes after that post, one day after he bought millions in stock, he canceled the tariffs and triggered one of the biggest same-day rebound rallies in market history.
He’s trying to get money. And you saw, now he’s offering paid subscriptions to presidential announcements, right? Just understand what’s for sale here: The sitting president’s pronouncements on war and peace and economic policy delivered first to paying customers.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ I'm seeking expressions of interest from nonprofit orgs to take over the Open Access Tracking Project (#oatp, @oatp) and the open-source software on which it runs.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ If your org is interested but could not do the work on its own, consider doing it in partnership with some other nonprofit orgs. Several very capable ones have already expressed interest but are unable to take the lead.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
4/ Please share this call with your networks.
Contact me <peter.suber@gmail.com> if you have any questions or any level of interest.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Recall way back in March that Hegseth began “a sweeping overhaul of the judge advocate general’s corps as part of an effort to make the US military less restricted by the laws of armed conflict” www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/13/pete-hegseth-pent…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Hate speech that crosses the line into threats of violence is NOT protected by the First Amendment. It’s a crime. For far too long, we’ve watched the radical left normalize threats, call for assassinations, and cheer on political violence. That era is over.
Under 18 U.S.C. § 875(c), it is a federal crime to transmit “any communication containing any threat to kidnap any person or any threat to injure the person of another.” Likewise, 18 U.S.C. § 876 and 18 U.S.C. § 115 make it a felony to threaten public officials, members of Congress, or their families.
You cannot call for someone’s murder. You cannot swat a Member of Congress. You cannot dox a conservative family and think it will be brushed off as “free speech.” These acts are punishable crimes, and every single threat will be met with the full force of the law.
Free speech protects ideas, debate, even dissent but it does NOT and will NEVER protect violence.
It is clear this violent rhetoric is designed to silence others from voicing conservative ideals.
We will never be silenced. Not for our families, not for our freedoms, and never for Charlie. His legacy will not be erased by fear or intimidation.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm seeking expressions of interest from nonprofit orgs to take over the Open Access Tracking Project (@oatp) & the open-source software on which it runs.
New essay: "How to be a wise optimist about science and technology?"
Link in next post
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Are any profs using #preprints to teach grad students how to do #peer_review? If so, are any profs encouraging students to submit their reviews to open-peer-review journals?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Peer reviewing preprints would guarantee young researchers some concrete outputs that illustrate their ability to critique work, write about science and discuss subjects outside their immediate focus of research." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-00085-2
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Undergraduates can and should be trained in peer review to foster the interrelated development of their scientific literacy, scientific identity & sense of belonging in science.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "18 medical students enrolled in a peer review training course…where they served as actual peer reviewers for the Canadian Medical Education Journal. This presented a rare opportunity…to address a well-recognized gap in teaching peer review." journalhosting.ucalgary.ca/index.php/cmej/article/view/76489
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
My friend @petersuber has put together a handful of quotes from John #dewey about the nature of a "#public," if only to remind us that our ideas have histories. Dewey doesn't think of publics in terms of communications, as tend to these days. Interesting! suber.pubpub.org/pub/nnpkmt91/release/2
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
NEW! @TheRickWilson has a message for the media. You couldn't stop talking about Joe Biden's age. Are you going to start covering Donald Trump's failing cognition, insanity, psychosis, senility, lies, flubs, etc.? Be fair. America is watching.
🎉Open Science NL turns 1 year old today! Since our 16 partners signed the covenant, we’ve been developing innovative funding programmes to support the high ambitions we have for #openscience in NL. Curious for what we’ve done? Subscribe to our newsletter: www.openscience.nl/en/newsletter
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
It is with great sadness that I have to resign as @eLife editor and early-career advisor after @mbeisen was fired as editor-in-chief for making use of his freedom of speech to stand up – once again – for the people who were silenced. A brief statement here:
I have been informed that I am being replaced as the Editor in Chief of @eLife for retweeting a @TheOnion piece that calls out indifference to the lives of Palestinian civilians.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I stand with Mike. @eLife made a great move to hire him and support his creative reforms. It made a huge mistake to fire him.
I have been informed that I am being replaced as the Editor in Chief of @eLife for retweeting a @TheOnion piece that calls out indifference to the lives of Palestinian civilians.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Not quite sure what open access means? We've got you covered! @petersuber's Essential Knowledge book explains what open access is and isn't, how it benefits authors and readers of research, and more: mitpress.mit.edu/9780262517638/open-access/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: In the field of otolaryngology, journal impact factor (#jif) is a bad predictor of article-level citations. "Thus, the JIF should not be used to measure the quality of individual articles." doi.org/10.1177%2F01455613221119051
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Two yrs before #dobbs overturned #roe, #scotus overturned a precedent #alito liked. He dissented, protesting that the majority "casts aside an important & long-established decision w/ little regard for the enormous reliance the decision has engendered." supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/590/18-5924/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ PS: There are 𝘮𝘢𝘯𝘺 reasons to offer well-formatted HTML alongside PDF, or to stop PDF-only. Accessibility is first, followed closely by making work friendly to mobile users, users w low bandwidth, & users who need to text-mine, cut/paste, or use machine translation.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Just declined to participate in @TimesHigherEd Global Academic Reputation Survey. Results "will inform the outcome of the 2023 THE World University Rankings."
THE writes, "More than ever, reputation matters." Sorry, can't agree.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ "[I'm not assuming] that better access to knowledge translates easily or automatically into better understanding and use of that knowledge. #openaccess is compatible with all kinds of failure to act with intelligence and compassion."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ "I’m concerned here with the opposite error, the pessimism of thinking that OA is merely academic or that it makes no difference to real-world suffering."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "More than 90% of the scientific articles published by Colombian researchers are in English....Publishing in a 2d language creates additional financial costs...&...problems with reading comprehension, writing ease & time, & anxiety." journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ But be careful about concluding that most journals using weak English (in email solicitations or web pages) are predatory. Some could be honest journals published in English, for understandable reasons, by scholars whose first language is not English.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. An argument for "balanced multilingualism" & "taking language into account in all aspects of research assessment without prioritizing scholarly communication in any language over publications in other languages." repository.uantwerpen.be/docstore/d:irua:11895 (warning, forced download)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "African languages are barely represented in technology & research…@Lanfrica is a language-focused search engine that makes it fast & easy to find information on the Internet about resources relating to African languages." lanfrica.com/about
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Spanish and Portuguese together represent more than 800 million speakers…, 11% of the world’s population, but only 1% of globally indexed scientific output is published in these two languages." www.lodivalleynews.com/for-open-and-accessible-science/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Missed this one from 2018. The "anglophone publishing community should reconsider the ban on dual publication to allow the same research findings to be published in the local language for…local communities and in English for a wider audience." www.insidehighered.com/views/2018/03/13/domination-englis…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "We [@COKIproject] have mapped the 122 million objects in Crossref up to the end of May 2022 to languages (based on titles and abstracts, where available) and done an initial analysis. The results are a mix of the expected and surprising." openknowledge.community/language-diversity/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. We "investigate NLP & Machine Translation approaches…to foster multilingual access & discovery to SSH content across different languages…[We created an open dataset] of multilingual metadata concepts." www.lrec-conf.org/proceedings/lrec2022/pdf/2022.lrec-1.17…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Anecdote from piece above: "German scientists…identified a significant causal relationship between smoking & lung cancer in the…1930s, a finding ignored by the scientific community for more than three decades, until British & American scientists rediscovered this link."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Our research demonstrates that while EAL [English as an additional language] scholars are under significant pressure to publish in English, they are not provided with the necessary resources to bring their papers to publication." www.timeshighereducation.com/blog/we-must-end-linguistic-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update (missed this one from 2014): English-language journal editors said their journals provided clear instructions to authors more than twice as often as their non-English-speaking authors (76% v. 32%). blog.scielo.org/en/2014/05/19/non-native-english-speaking…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update from 2015. "A single shared language is useful for an endeavor as collaborative & universal as science. But if you are not a native speaker…how difficult it must be to reach a 'eureka' moment but feel that the words are inadequate to describe it." slate.com/technology/2015/01/english-is-the-language-of-s…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update from 2019: "There is…evidence for significant linguistic bias when journals receive a manuscript written in poor English…[creating] an impression that the research they discuss is also sub-standard." blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2019/08/16/the-hid…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Chinese incentives to publish in international English-language journals are causing Chinese research to be read and cited less by Chinese researchers. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-022-04537-w
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "We outline actions that individuals and institutions can take to support multilingual science and scientists, including structural changes that encourage and value translating scientific literature." academic.oup.com/bioscience/article/72/10/988/6653151
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. I second @karimjerbineuro's appreciation of "the extra work, time & energy that students + researchers around the world, whose native language is not English, need to put into writing academic papers + giving talks in English."
I think the scientific community should sometimes take a minute to acknowledge/appreciate the extra work, time & energy that students + researchers around the world, whose native language is not English, need to put into writing academic papers + giving talks in English. 👇🧵 1/7
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "US researchers do not build as readily on the [English-language] work of Chinese researchers, relative to the work of other foreign scientists, even in a setting where Chinese scientists have long excelled." www.nber.org/papers/w30772
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Although the publishing patterns of CEE…journals in the field of language and linguistics are international, multilingual publishing in languages other than English ensures the continuity of local research traditions." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-022-04595-0
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. I just gave an interview in which I spoke at length about #multilingualresearch. "The dominance of one language creates obstacles, stress, expense & rejection for excellent scholars whose first language happens not to be the lingua franca." dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/37373947
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The cognitive sciences have been dominated by English-speaking researchers studying other English speakers…However, English differs from other languages in ways that have consequences for the whole of the cognitive sciences." www.cell.com/trends/cognitive-sciences/fulltext/S1364-661…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Rooryck’s message was clear: 'Funders and universities should value multilingual publication in the same way as publication in English. We should convince PhD students of this too. Publication in English should not be associated with prestige.'" vastuullinentiede.fi/en/news/publication-english-should-n…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The Organization of Ibero-American States… reported that, in 2020, 95% of all articles published in scientific journals were written in English and only 1% in Spanish or Portuguese." www.scielo.br/j/ts/a/zwPRYVhkQLp5RTJzTXMrqky/?format=pdf&…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "While English is only the native language of 7.3% of the world's population and less than 20% can speak the language, nearly 75% of all scientific publications are English." journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/14550725221102227
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Case study of the two-year transition to fully bilingual publication (Spanish and English) by the Chilean medical journal, @Medwave_cl. doi.org/10.1002/leap.1533
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Journals & publishers have made little progress toward beginning to recognize or reduce language barriers. Counter to our predictions, journals associated w/ scientific societies did not…have more inclusive policies [than] non-society journals." academic.oup.com/iob/article/5/1/obad003/7008844
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "By ignoring non-English-language science, international assessments may overlook important information on local and/or regional biodiversity." www.nature.com/articles/s41893-023-01087-8
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In the humanities, when Russian funders evaluated grant proposals using quantitative metrics, like publications & citations, "non-journal publications among new grantees decreased, while the share of English-language journal articles increased." sciendo.com/article/10.2478/jdis-2023-0010?tab=article
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Scientific knowledge is mostly communicated in English, which may pose a barrier for non-native English speakers…However, scientific communication can be improved by following some simple rules and by taking advantage of new and existing tools." www.nature.com/articles/s44222-023-00073-1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Non-native English speakers, esp #ecrs, spend more effort than native English speakers in conducting scientific activities, from reading & writing papers & preparing presentations in English, to disseminating research in multiple languages." doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3002184
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Good summary of study above. "Non-native English speakers…take 2x as much time as native speakers to [do their science] & their papers face higher rejection & revision rates. One-third…forego attending int'l conferences & half avoid presenting." neurosciencenews.com/language-barrier-science-research-23…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Sec. 552 of the House CJS bill shuts the door on #taxpayeraccess to research! Tell Congress to remove Sec. 552 to ensure the American public can benefit from the research they fund.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Advocacy groups & institutional shareholders are chiding Pfizer for arguing that its intellectual property is a human right & would be violated if the Dominican Republican govt issues a compulsory license for its #covid19 pill." #paywalled www.statnews.com/pharmalot/2022/04/20/patent-pfizer-covid…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Funders of biomedical research could require recipients to commit to licensing subsequent products to the #mpp [Medicines Patent Pool], as could universities when they license their early-stage products to external partners." www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Early in the pandemic, Moderna said it would not enforce its #patents to help other drug companies develop their own jabs, particularly for low- and middle-income countries." Time's up. @Moderna_tx is now suing @Pfizer. www.bbc.com/news/health-62691102
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "#moderna has refused to hand over to China the core intellectual property behind the development of its breakthrough Covid-19 vaccine, leading to a collapse in negotiations on its sale there." www.ft.com/content/a481c129-c5aa-4972-84a8-3a45bb000098
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. From the article above: "Charles Gore, executive director of the Medicines Patent Pool (@MedsPatentPool)…says: 'The silver lining of Covid is that it has focused people’s attention on access. The tragedy is that a lot of people died to get that focus.' "
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From 2024 all ROAPE’s work will be available on a single platform with no paywalls and equal access for researchers, activists, and readers, wherever they are based. We passionately believe that the future for radical publications is genuine open access. roape.net/2023/03/21/roape-in-2024-an-end-and-a-new-begin…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Wow! Huge congrats @judegreen, @lindsayamclaren and colleagues: mass resignation of the Critical Public Heath board, to leave the "corporate control" of Taylor & Francis and start a new diamond OA journal! A truly game-changing move for our disciplines: cphn.net/breaking-news/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Mixed feelings about open peer review. Yes to all the benefits cited by others. But anonymity has benefits too. 1. It protects women, minority, & young/unknown authors from referee bias. 2. It protects the same scholars as referees when criticizing weak work by senior scholars.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "There is reasonable evidence that gender bias may exist in scientific publishing and that double-blinding can mitigate its impact." www.ajog.org/article/S0002-9378(22)00068-0/pdf
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. The J of Human Nutrition & Dietetics (@JHNDEditor) adopted open peer review, voluntary for both authors & referees, found some reluctance to break anonymity, & wrote an editorial to urge more participation. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jhn.13007
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. This is a case of a biased review article (authors not anonymous), not biased peer review (often anon). Supporters of referee anonymity (like me, half the time) must ack that anonymity would have hidden the bias rather than protecting against it. www.insidehighered.com/news/2022/11/14/journal-investigat…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. New study finds "that authors from high-income and English-speaking countries benefit when reviewers know their identities, and that they lose those benefits when their identities are hidden." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01772-w
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. A new survey shows that "a vast majority of participants favor anonymizing author identities in some form." But anonymization makes it harder to detect author conflicts of interest. journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Let's scale it up & make it systematic. Many more subject areas & many more AI tools. Repeated periodically to track progress. Good role for scholarly #societies.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Good question. Please help @melhagemann collect answers.
Question: Since the WHO ended the global emergency status for COVID-19 on May 5th, does anyone know of any journals that have reimposed paywalls? Thanks!
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Twitter just it much harder for academics to use Twitter data to study e.g. election interference, disinformation, extremism, bullying, bots, and other trends and abuses on the platform. The data was formerly free. Will now be $42,000/month. inews.co.uk/news/twitter-researchers-delete-data-unless-p…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Since the pandemic shutdown began, journal submissions of co-authored papers, with women among the co-authors, are slightly up, and solo-authored papers by women are significantly down. www.insidehighered.com/news/2020/04/21/early-journal-subm…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Idea building on prev tweet: @ORCID_Org could add fields for self-identified gender & ethnicity. With user consent, the fields could be public, e.g. for research just like that in this thread. No need to guess gender from names or trust (upcoming) publisher method of labelling.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "We compared self-identified demographics with name-based imputation [tools]…We found substantial inequalities in how these tools misgender & misrecognize the race/ethnicity of authors. www.nature.com/articles/s41562-023-01587-9
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "In multiple academic disciplines having a perceived gender of 'woman' is associated w a lower than expected rate of citations…We show that…the tendency of people to interact w others…like themselves…is sufficient to reproduce observed biases." arxiv.org/abs/2204.12555
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Women [authors are] under-rep'd…in JAMA (at its peak, 38.1% of articles had a female 1st author in 2011) & NEJM (peaking at 28.2% in 2002)…Rate of increase…so slow that it will take more than a century for both journals to reach gender parity." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40615-022-01280-z
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In veterinary science journals, "females [are] underrepresented in the group of managing editors (32.2% females vs 67.2% males), editors (34.5% females vs 65.1% males) and others (33.3% females vs. 65.4% males)." #paywalled www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0034528822…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. At @BrainComms "the representation of women authors and reviewers decreased…in the months following COVID-19 restrictions, suggesting a possible exacerbating role of the pandemic on existing disparities in science publication." academic.oup.com/braincomms/article/4/3/fcac077/6554271
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "We review gender bias in scholarly publications and discuss examples of #openaccess research publications that highlight a positive advantage for women." www.mdpi.com/2304-6775/10/3/22
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Gendered differences in the productivity and prominence of mid-career researchers can be largely explained by differences in their coauthorship networks…Collaboration networks represent an important form of unequally distributed social capital." www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-32604-6
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Journals that require reporting of methods used to determine sex and/or gender have a significantly higher IF [#jif] and a significantly greater proportion of EIC positions held by women." jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2795802
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In the #mena region, "men publish on average between 11% and 51% more than women, with this gap increasing over time." arxiv.org/abs/2208.13520
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update: The Journal of Bone & Mineral Research studied itself. "The acceptance rate [2017-2019] was highest when the first & last authors were of different genders & lowest when both authors were men. Reviewer gender did not influence the outcome." asbmr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/jbmr.4696
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "We identify gender disparities in the patterns of peer citations and show that these differences are strong enough to accurately predict the scholar’s gender." www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2206070119
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "We find a global bias wherein [physics] papers authored by women are significantly under-cited & papers authored by men are significantly over-cited…[These disparities depend on] who is citing, where they are citing & what they are citing." www.nature.com/articles/s41567-022-01770-1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Female scholars are…significantly underrepresented [among prolific scholars in communication] in all…analyzed regions. Furthermore…female scholars’ papers are systematically more viewed, yet significantly less cited than male scholarship." www.researchgate.net/profile/Manuel-Goyanes/publication/3…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Women have traditionally participated in intellectual property creation at depressed rates relative to men. Book authorship is now an exception. In 1970, women published a third as many books as men. By 2020, women produced the majority of books." www.nber.org/papers/w30987
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Women's share of [highly-cited researchers] would need to increase by 100% in health & social sciences, 200% in agriculture, bio, earth, & enviro sciences, 300% in math & physics, & 500% in chem, CS, & engineering to close the gap with men." direct.mit.edu/qss/article/doi/10.1162/qss_a_00218/113322…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Study of the 57 @IOPPublishing journals: "Contrary to our hypothesis, we did not find that manuscript submissions from women decreased during the pandemic, although the rate of increased submissions evident prior to the pandemic slowed." www.nature.com/articles/s41599-022-01365-4
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Publications by women are cited less by @Wikipedia than expected…& less likely to be cited than those by men…Gender- or country-based inequalities varies by research field & the gender-country…bias is prominent in math-intensive STEM fields." asistdl.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/asi.24723
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In psychology, "relative to ratios as students and faculty, women are underrepresented as editorial-board members (41%) and…as editors-in-chief (34%)." journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/17456916221117159
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Women’s share of HCRs [highly cited researchers] would need to increase by 100% in health & social sciences, 200% in agriculture, bio, earth & env sciences, 300% in math & physics, & 500% in chemistry, CS & engineering to close the gap with men." doi.org/10.1162/qss_a_00218
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. For male authors, the presence of an author photo and bio in an article does not affect citation rates. But "there was a small citation disadvantage of 5% for female authors when they provided a photograph and biography." doi.org/10.1162/qss_a_00219
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "I find that (i) female-authored papers are 1%–6% better written than equivalent papers by men; (ii) the gap widens during peer review; …(iv) female-authored papers take longer under review." academic.oup.com/ej/article/132/648/2951/6586337
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Women account for less than one in three peer reviewers of medical journals. Women’s representation as peer reviewers is higher in journals with higher percentage of women as editors or with a woman as editor-in-chief." bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/5/e061054.abstract
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The gendered effect observed in [research] production may be related by differential engagement in parenting: men who serve in lead roles suffer similar penalties for parenting engagement, but women are more likely to serve in lead roles." www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-26258-z
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In a database of "81,000 editors serving more than 1,000 journals and 15 disciplines over five decades" only 14% were women and only 8% were editors in chief. Male editors published in their own journals more often than female editors. www.nature.com/articles/s41562-022-01498-1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The objective of the current study was to assess the level of gender and geographic inequalities affecting influential researchers, based on the lists of Highly Cited Researchers (HCRs) published annually by Clarivate." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11739-023-03240-9
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Of the 3m submissions to major…medical journals in the 1st half of 2020, just 36% were from women. This gender gap applied…across all authorship positions, in…top tier & lower impact journals & was esp pronounced among younger…female authors." www.bmj.com/content/381/bmj.p788
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Our meta-analysis…found only small, statistically insignificant gender differences in the journal acceptance process…This does not mean that there was gender parity in every field, time period, and journal." journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/15291006231163179
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Parents have a right to know what’s happening to undermine kids' education.
Governor Newsom is demanding records from publishers and Florida to find out whether any of the companies designing California’s textbooks are the same ones kowtowing to Florida’s extremist agenda.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ Friends, academics, journalists, officials: If you're dismayed by the direction of #twitter, but stay because so many people you follow & follow you are on Twitter, then I'm sorry to say you're part of the problem. You're giving your network the same reason to stay on Twitter.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Create an account on another platform & post there even if you keep one foot in Twitter.
It's a small investment in time. But it's an investment in a better platform & experience.
If I follow you on Twitter & you come to #mastodon, I'll follow you there too.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This article objects to #pdfs for many of the reasons I do. It wants to use #ai to make them more #accessible. I find that promising in light of the scandalous fact that even tho PDF is a NISO standard complex PDFs still resist perfect text extraction. arxiv.org/abs/2303.14334
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Since the pandemic shutdown began, journal submissions of co-authored papers, with women among the co-authors, are slightly up, and solo-authored papers by women are significantly down. www.insidehighered.com/news/2020/04/21/early-journal-subm…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ But none of them captures the whole thread, probably because it's so long.
Are there any unrolling tools that will capture a very long thread?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Only snag is that I can't back these up to @internetarchive or @permacc, probably because reSeeIt sells an #nft version.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Correction: I succeeded in making a @permacc copy of the @reSeeIt HTML file. It just took so long that I thought it timed out. Here it is. perma.cc/NA5Q-3ZAH
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
10% of medical patients with access to their doctors' notes (#opennotes) "reported feeling judged or offended by something they read in an outpatient note due to the perception that it contained errors, surprises, labeling, or evidence of disrespect." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11606-020-06432-7
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "There is a growing movement for increased patient access to their notes. The language used in medical narratives therefore has the potential to affect patients in new ways." www.bmj.com/content/377/bmj-2021-066720
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Will some doctors "stop noting their 'soft concerns'" — the ones most likely to elicit patient questions and anxieties? www.bmj.com/content/377/bmj.o1570
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Scholars spend 68,500,000 hours/year performing peer review. www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06602-y The US federal minimum wage is $7.25/hour. Scholars deserve more than that, but take it as a starting point. That's a gift to publishers of at least $496,625,000/year in free labor.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The cost of peer review was estimated at $US1,272 per person, per year…or US$1.1–1.7 billion for the scientific community per year. The global cost of peer-review was estimated at US$6 billion in 2020." researchintegrityjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.11…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I don't have the data for my topic (#openaccess to research) but my experience matches your description — "Fewer active [participants], fewer tweets, fewer likes per tweet, fewer retweets per tweet, and less likely to go viral." Much more activity on #mastodon.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
4/ OATP aims to capture OA-related news & comment on every OA subtopic & in every academic field, country, region, & language. To do this, we need volunteer taggers in every niche. Please consider joining us. Help us become even more comprehensive.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Wow, look at this note on the PDF of the 1986 PNAS paper. Paper covered by a page charge "must therefore be marked 'advertisement.'" I never noticed this before. Maybe you have, @petersuber ?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
We've successfully converted the first fifteen journal volumes of the year to #openaccess using #subscribetoopen resulting in substantial increases in readership.
Libraries lend. Publishers want to stop that, and they always have. Our own @KyleKCourtney and @jziskina provide a history of publisher pushback and library perseverance in their new paper “The Publisher Playbook.” /1
Florida House Republicans just passed a bill that allows people to conceal carry without a background check or ANY training whatsoever…
HB 543 is a dangerous step backwards and makes our state less safe.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm with you. I'm a book author (x5) who supports free lending libraries, including free digital lending and #cdl. I not only support what you do and have done with my books. I support your legal arguments.
Hachette v. Internet Archive is many things—a case about for-profit companies suing a nonprofit devoted to advancing research and culture, a case about who copyright is meant to serve, and, above all, a case about what is a library is and what it can be. /1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
QUESTION: I don't know if this is a stupid one. Does LLM in the form of ChatGPT use information in research papers that are behind a paywall? If yes, what is the technology going on there to provide access? If no, is this a huge argument for OA?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Universities can't stop states determined to prohibit the teaching of accurate US history. But they can make it easy for students to find more of the missing chapters.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If a successful replication boosts the credibility a research article, then does a prediction of a successful replication, from an honest prediction market, do the same, even to a small degree? www.replicationmarkets.com
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. It turns out that crowd-sourced human forecasters are pretty good at predicting whether preprints will be published within a year and whether the the publishing journal will have high citation impact. royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.220440
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. #ai is now pretty good at using article abstracts to predict the journal impact factor (#jif) and #eigenfactor of the journals in which they are published. www.jmir.org/2023/1/e42789
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Much research that could advance the #sdgs is "inaccessible, locked behind expensive publisher #paywalls…or simply not shared at all (in the case of all other products of research such as protocols, data, and working papers or reports)." library.usask.ca/news/2023/Open-Science-is-Critical-for-A…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
"Implementing the #nelsonmemo via an #apc model is antithetical to the equity goals so clearly articulated in the…memo & the values of our institutions."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Another excerpt: "Locking in a norm where an author, funder, and/or institution must pay an opaque & often costly fee for the right to publish…risks locking out scholars from less resourced institutions."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
It’s fascinating, isn’t it - how digital information is so far-reaching and accessible, and yet so utterly precarious and temporary at the same time. People say once something is on the internet it’s there forever, but that couldn’t be further from the truth.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I just thought to add my #mastodon account to the @InternetArchive. But it was already there, along with my @Twitter account. Very nice surprise. Does anyone know whether IA is doing this systematically? How much of Twitter and Mastodon is it capturing? Ditto for other platforms.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Are any people or bots scoring #publishers on their success in resisting #linkrot? Could score publishers based on the average half-life of their links. Could have separate categories for links to their own publications and links within their publications to outside sources.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Google drives traffic to news sites. Publishers push for laws requiring it to pay to use snippets in search results. G stops covering them. They lose traffic & beg G to come back. Tried in France, Germany, & Spain. Now Australia is trying it too. www.reuters.com/article/us-australia-media-regulator-idUS…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"The @NIH may own intellectual property that undergirds a leading coronavirus vaccine being developed by Moderna....[This matters] because the federal government...could try to make the vaccine a free or low-cost public good with wide distribution" www.axios.com/moderna-nih-coronavirus-vaccine-ownership-a…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm proud of this book I coauthored with @CarrieElise, @MelanieKowalski, and @SarahNQuigley. It focuses on workflows for rights reviews when digitizing and sharing (or not) archival works online. Of course, it's #openaccess, so checked it out & share widely!
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Question: Do any publishers of #openaccess journals or books try to block #search engine crawlers?
I have no reason to think that any publishers do this. But I don't want to assume without inquiry that no publishers do it. Has anyone seen studies on this question? Anecdotes?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
As #ai tools for writing become more common, let me throw one more worry into the mix: that students who write well without AI assistance may be falsely accused of #plagiarism by teachers using imperfect tools to detect AI-assisted writing.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update: Very glad to see farmers *win* the suit to repair their tractors. It's a win for consumers against bogus IP objections from manufacturers. www.bbc.com/news/business-64206913
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "In Colorado, the legislation is largely being pushed by Democrats while their Republican colleagues [are] torn between right-leaning farming constituents asking to be able to repair their own machines & the mfg businesses that oppose the idea." apnews.com/article/farm-equipment-repairs-d5ea466725328d9…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If one of my cloud apps is misbehaving and the company tells me to clear my #cache, I can do that. But it's a pain in the neck to log in again at all the sites that logs me out of. Is there a way (in #chrome) to clear my cache *surgically* for just the one app that's misbehaving?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
In the 21 years since I helped to define #openaccess through @TheBOAI, more has been achieved to make research openly available than the 16 of us who met on those cold Dec days in Bp could have imagined.Yet to realize the promise of OA we envisioned when we launched the BOAI...
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
After Volvo engineer Nils Bohlin invented the three-point seatbelt, the company opened up the patent because "it had more value as a free life-saving tool than something to profit from." Learn more: www.historydefined.net/nils-bohlin/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Whoa. Manuscript sent to @ScienceDirect's International Journal of Hydrogen Energy gets desk-rejected because it did not have enough citations from its own journal. That is one way to get an impact factor of 7.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
For a journal to manipulate its citation count and then brag about its citation count as a measure of quality is #deception, #selfdeception, or both.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
“The recipient of the produce contained in this package agrees not to propagate or reproduce any portion of this produce, including ‘but not limited to’ seeds, stems, tissue, and fruit." www.vice.com/en/article/proprietary-grapes-come-with-drac…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Thanks to @haymarketbooks. "We know that books can be dangerous to those in power, especially when they are in the hands of folks who are organizing to fight for liberation. That’s why we publish them [now #openaccess]. That’s why [Florida is] trying to ban them."
@Twitter's plan to revoke its free #api will obstruct public interest projects worldwide, including those to monitor Twitter's role in boosting #misinformation.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I just realized that this old tweet has a dead link (because Google shamelessly deleted all Google+ posts, even after heroically preserving Usenet posts). Here's a preservation copy. web.archive.org/web/20180312230315/https://plus.google.co…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"RAISE [Research Analysis Identifier System] brings the processing algorithm (small size) to the dataset (large size) instead of downloading the dataset to the computer where the processing algorithm is." www.openaire.eu/raise-project-a-game-changer-for-os
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If prediction markets could predict a person's IQ, would we say they measure "intelligence" or something like "the IQ model of intelligence"? If prediction markets could predict the #ref score of a research article, would we say they measure "quality"? www.researchinformation.info/analysis-opinion/look-predic…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Here's a paywalled editorial recommending #openaccess, #opendata, and #openscience. The authors/editors could easily have made it OA, but they put it behind a paywall instead.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Three Oregon universities didn't renew their #elsevier subscriptions at the end of 2022. Alicia Salaz: "In the long term…students, researchers & scholars everywhere will benefit from a system that doesn't exploit academic labor for excessive profit." www.dailyemerald.com/news/pressing-pause-on-elsevier-subs…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"With the recent increase in book banning, districts where books are challenged are staying away from acquiring newly published books that deal with controversial topics, particularly books about #lgbtq characters and issues." www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/what-book-bans-are-doing…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ I was the director of the Office for Scholarly Communication. When I stepped down (semi-retired) last yr Harvard restructured the office & this ad shows the results. It's a plum job for anyone who wants to work at the cutting edge of #openaccess, #opendata, & #scholcomm.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
🔔 Job Opportunity: CC is hiring an Open Climate Data Manager to facilitate the creation of a community-supported, long-term solution for the #bettersharing of large, distributed open climate datasets.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"These [works] were…supposed to enter the public domain in 2003, but…'before this could happen, Congress hit a 20-year pause button & extended their copyright term to 95 years.' The mechanism by which this legal heist was implemented was the 1998 Copyright Term Extension Act."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ "He draws on the legal strategy of statutory licensing to set out the terms and structures by which the [US] Copyright Act could ensure that publishers are fairly compensated for providing immediate #openaccess."
The book itself is OA. Thanks, John and @MITPress.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ "In 2023…the [14] journals in the #jama Network will…permit authors of original research investigations to deposit their accepted manuscript in a public repository of their choosing…on the day that the manuscript is published by the JAMA Network." jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ This looks like anticipatory compliance with the US federal agency #openaccess policies that will require #unembargoed#green OA.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I try not to show surprise at what people choose to track. (#glasshouses.) But I admit that I'm surprised that a govt agency is tracking science and engineering research in the US *by the square foot*. ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsf23308
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Just amazing that the Ukrainian government has developed a National Open Science Action Plan this year! Huge congratulations to @irynakuchma and all involved.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society@BKCHarvard
If you are a current JD candidate with an interest in the intersections of tech, law, and social justice, apply now to @cyberlawclinic's summer 2023 internship!
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"If Twitter were to fail entirely, all of this could disappear from their site in an instant. This is an important part of our history. Shouldn’t we be trying to preserve it?"
If you care about how copyright law can be used to undermine fundamentals like due process and democratic self-government, you should read on... /1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
An excellent critique of #apcs and #transformative (read-and-publish) agreements, building up to an excellent set of recommendations, including #rightsretention.
For every day in December read a different misunderstanding of open science, objection to it, or excuse for not living up to it. Click through for the YERUN response.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Using a random sample of 300 English language #openaccess journals, we assessed author guidelines to understand image requirements…While over half the journals had required parameters for image submission, none of them required alt text." osf.io/preprints/metaarxiv/zsjqw/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
✨ Some big news: we are re-launching the #openknowledgenetwork today! You can now get in touch with people from 25+ countries speaking 15+ languages, and learn more about 40+ projects covering 20+ categories from #civictech to #opendata, and more. 🧵
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
📢Interested in changing research culture? We are seeking self-nominations from individuals in Africa to fill an open position for an at-large member on the Steering Committee! 📚Find more info & the form to self-nominate: sfdora.org/2022/11/29/interested-in-changing-research-cul…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From Simon Linacre: "One issue I wanted to put to bed in the book is the complete lack of any necessary tie between #openaccess and predatory journals."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I plan to stay on @Twitter as long as a critical mass of valued friends and colleagues stay. If you're reading this, I hope that gives you one small reason to stay a while too.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I've criticized Twitter in the past and expect to be at least as critical in the future. I also expect to block and mute more. But I've found good people, good orgs, good info, and good comments here, and don't want to give them up.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm exploring other platforms and so far see nothing that comes close in *net* pleasure and usefulness.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
My explorations are slow, but I've already ruled out many platforms. Here's how to find me at the ones I haven't yet ruled out.
⯀ @petersuber@fediscience.org at Mastodon ⯀"Peter Suber" at wt.social and Tribel ⯀"petersuber" at Diaspora and HASTAC
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In the four days since the Musk takeover, I've lost 26 @Twitter followers and gained 110 #mastodon followers.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. #mastodon is pulling ahead of the other platforms I'm exploring. As a sign of seriousness, I just added my M handle (@petersuber@fediscience.org) to my Twitter bio. Please join the #oa, #os, and #scholcomm community there, even if (like me) you keep one foot in @Twitter.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update from 10/31/22 above ("In the four days since the Musk takeover, I've lost 26 @Twitter followers and gained 110 #mastodon followers"): 20 days later, I've lost 102 Twitter followers and gained 2,202 Mastodon followers.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. When I post on #twitter and #mastodon, I find that I get more engagement (likes, boosts, replies) on #mastodon. And I get them faster. The energy is moving away from Twitter even while people hold on to their accounts.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Good line: "The truth is, I’m just a girl, standing in front of an academic community, admitting I don’t have a university email address."
Annie Berke-but call me @sayanniething.bsky.social@sayanniething
Hey, before you all jump board, #academictwitter, do the field a favor, and read my latest for @chronicle! ;)
MBIE is the largest public funder of research in NZ.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Zoom tip: Presenters should share Google docs instead of slides. (Put the URL in the chat.) It's better than sharing slides. Users can click on the links. Users can go back to reread or copy anything. Presenters can highlight the part they want to emphasize at a given moment.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I've been doing this in Zoom talks for 2+ yrs & usually take a min in the talk to explain why. But that steals time. So I just put the explanation online & link to it from my main doc.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Scholars' productivity is more a function of where they work now than where they were trained. Evidence against common view that high-output institutions have high-output scholars because a competitive job market identified already-productive scholars. www.pnas.org/content/early/2019/04/24/1817431116
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The disproportionate scientific productivity of elite researchers can be largely explained by their substantial labor advantage [thru grad students and postdocs] rather than inherent differences in talent." www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.abq7056
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Please spread the word. Help wonderful people learn about this wonderful opportunity.
Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society@BKCHarvard
NEW: The @BKCHarvard annual fellowship is now accepting applications for the 2023-2024 academic year! This call is for multi-disciplinary scholars & practitioners to join the Center’s vibrant, collaborative research community.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From Amanda Rinehart: "I don’t have to solve the world’s problems to help solve the world’s problems."
Director, National Library of Medicine@NLMdirector
This blog by @OSULibrary's Amanda Rinehart focuses on how librarians help researchers share/manage data. Amanda discusses the joys of engaging w/ data & "becoming one of the research team," guiding researchers to resources & helping close knowledge gaps. nlmdirector.nlm.nih.gov/2022/11/16/the-intangible-rewards…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Do you find yourself answering objections that open educational resources (#oer) can't be as good as their priced counterparts? Here's a datapoint for your quiver.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: There is "a significant positive correlation between the article #twitter mention and citation score." Authors also provide "further evidence that social media engagement can be beneficial to the dissemination of academic information." www.cureus.com/articles/119888-association-between-twitte…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm re-upping these questions in light of the latest wave of inaccurate polls.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From a naif: After elections, do pollster-watchers evaluate pollsters on their accuracy? Do less-accurate pollsters use the results to change their methods? If so, is there some kind of evolution toward best practices? If so, why do different pollsters still disagree so widely?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
"Dutch universities published 82% of their peer-reviewed scientific publications #openaccess in 2021. This is an increase of nine percentage points compared to 2020."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
One hour ago, I posted the Dutch news above (previous item in this thread) at the same time to my personal accounts on #mastodon and #twitter. Here's what happened in that hour: * Mastodon, 23 favorites, 12 boosts * Twitter, 12 likes, 6 retweets
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
That's nearly twice as much engagement on Mastodon. But I have more than 23 times more followers on Twitter.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I joined @TwitterBlue ($4.99/month) three weeks ago, primarily for the option to edit my tweets. I cancelled it today.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Equally important is the RSC’s commitment…to develop new Open Access models…that do not rely solely on authors paying processing or publication charges."
BIG NEWS: www.rsc.org/news-events/articles/2022/oct/rsc-oa-commitment/ The Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) aims to make all fully RSC-owned journals Open Access within five years, making it the first chemistry publisher and one of the first society publishers to commit to a fully Open Access future.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Related question: How many people are eligible for verification now, when it's free, and haven't bothered to apply?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: When different research teams use the same data to test a shared hypothesis, "results varied greatly" and "choices made by the research teams in designing their statistical tests explain very little [less than 5%] of this variation." www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2203150119
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Another thread, since there's nothing even nearly uniform about OA. Let's look at fees and counts in three subject segments, this time from 2017 to 2021 (2015-2016 are somewhat anomalous in DOAJ):
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
It should be easy for #republicans to condemn what this guy did. It should be irresistible, if only to help answer the objection that they incite and endorse political violence. But how many will do so?
CNN reports that the man who attacked Nancy Pelosi's husband Paul Pelosi frequently posted Trump's Big Lie about the election being stolen and went after the January 6th Committee
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
Elon Musk is again claiming that he’s all about free speech. So let’s look at the record. Here’s thread with just a few of the countless examples showing he couldn't care about it less (🧵)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ "Of the [US] researchers who had paid APCs (n=170) most reported it being very difficult…or difficult…to obtain funds to pay APC's."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ Thanks to Paula C. Johnson and Ellen Dubinsky for their good article: "The Challenging State of University Campus and Library Open Access Policies." www.iastatedigitalpress.com/jlsc/article/id/13049/
It focuses on university #openaccess policies in the US, especially those that cover #librarians.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
4/ The article says that our guide lists all US university OA policies. But the list is limited to policies "of the kind recommended in the guide" — a much smaller list. It also goes beyond the US to policies in Europe, Africa, Asia, & Australasia. cyber.harvard.edu/hoap/Additional_resources
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
5/ At Harvard, librarians are not faculty, and the school-level OA policies cover faculty alone. Given the focus of the article, I want to add how we cover librarians.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From #boai20: "Outsiders cannot tell whether an #apc is based on the publisher's production costs…; whether it charges a premium for prestige or impact factor; or whether it charges what the publisher believes the market will bear." www.budapestopenaccessinitiative.org/boai20/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"New documents show that the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics invested in food stocks and accepted donations from junk food, sugar and soda makers, even as it trained the dietitians who teach us how to eat." www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2022/10/24/nutrition-acad…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"(a) Any justice, judge, or magistrate judge of the United States shall disqualify himself in any proceeding in which his impartiality might reasonably be questioned." 28 U.S. Code § 455. Example: A justice married to an insurrectionist must recuse from insurrection cases.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The project Open Editors collects data about academic journal editors on a large scale and structures them into a single dataset. It does so by scraping the websites of 7,352 journals from 26 publishers." academic.oup.com/rev/advance-article/doi/10.1093/reseval/…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "There is little available info about aggregate patterns of scholarly journal editorships. This may change soon…thanks to a novel dataset…that provides new insights into the landscape of journal editing." blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2022/10/18/the-dre…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ Here's another article saying, "OA may exacerbate existing inequalities in the publication system" when it means "#apc-based OA may exacerbate...." arxiv.org/abs/2208.08221
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ I'm aware that the paper focuses on a different topic (the effect of APC waivers & discounts). But I plead for precision even in asides
The problem in question is caused by APCs, not by OA as such. Green & diamond OA completely avoid the problem. It's not hard to say that.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
High travel can increase citation impact (thru exposure) or high citation impact can increase travel (thru visibility & invitations). Either way, "evaluation through bibliometric indicators favors individuals who adopt practices that are less sustainable." iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ac9b51
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"The science that preoccupied [James Lovelock] during his career came from what he’d gleaned as an ‘SBN’ or ‘small bespectacled nerd’ (his term) in the museum and in libraries, not in school science lessons or homework, which he found tedious." #sbn aeon.co/essays/james-lovelock-the-death-of-scientific-ind…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
One Q asks for the year OA launched, and all 3 options are wrong. (It's hard to know the right answer here but easy to know some wrong ones.)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ One Q asks for the first "Open Research Publishing Platform", using the proper noun to specify a T&F property. Another Q asks for the names of "the two different types" of OA as if there were just two. One Q is just an ad for its own F1000 Research.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"The reliability of data reported in preprints is…high…The amount of change to articles during peer review is small & expert opinions of article quality are not significantly different for preprints that are pub'd versus preprints that are not pub'd." www.thelancet.com/journals/langlo/article/PIIS2214-109X(2…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"We agree that climate data…should be interconnected globally, but caution against putting [it] into corporate hands…[We recommend open infrastructure from] an open community of tech entrepreneurs, climate-data providers, researchers & non-profit orgs." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-03123-7
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"#wiley removed these books from already-subscribed services without making any efforts to inform academic libraries that pay hundreds of thousands of Euros from public funds per year to ensure students have access to the books they need."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Wiley withdraws more than 1,300 titles from a large multidisciplinary ebook collection for libraries as fall classes begin, hindering students’ access to affordable learning materials." www.insidehighered.com/news/2022/09/28/publisher-blocks-a…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "By unexpectedly withdrawing these electronic titles from…library collections, Wiley has…shifted the financial burden of…access solely onto students, making it impossible to access course materials without paying—or…being automatically billed." sparcopen.org/news/2022/library-futures-sparc-statement-w…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. From @blendedlib: "A day late and a dollar short. It may be too late for our faculty colleagues to now insert these materials back into their courses, and some librarians [and students] have already gone out and purchased copies." www.insidehighered.com/news/2022/10/06/publisher-reinstat…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. UK libraries join their Irish and American counterparts in condemning Wiley's removal of 1,300+ textbooks from a library subscription package, on short notice, increasing the cost of access for libraries and/or students. www.sconul.ac.uk/sites/default/files/documents/Joint_Wile…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Political affiliation has emerged as a potential risk factor for COVID-19, amid evidence that Republican-leaning counties have had higher COVID-19 death rates than Democrat- leaning counties." www.nber.org/papers/w30512
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
An excellent call that should not limit itself to Europe:
"Knowledge Rights 21 believes that European countries should introduce secondary publishing rights in respect of publicly funded research."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ The UN's António Guterres wants "a structure that fills gaps in existing scientific advice [to policymakers], translates science to policy effectively, & is truly relevant to decision-making." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-03200-x
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Good idea. But please don't stop there. Policymakers and their staffs need #openaccess to primary sources.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
These early railway carriages are a good illustration of how much old stuff gets dragged along into the first versions of new things. At first even the inventors of trains couldn't think of them as more than sequences of linked horse carriages.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This recognition underscores the urgent need to reform the patent system. Life-saving medication should be affordable and accessible to everyone who needs it.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
.@AAAS "strongly supports" the @WHOSTP policy guidelines. "We will soon provide immediate public access to all taxpayer-funded research through a policy [allowing] Science authors to post their 'author accepted manuscript' without" #embargo or #apc. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ade8028
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "The pub of…Science will…allow authors…to make public an almost-final version of their MS in a repository…immediately on publication, w/o paying any fees. This approach differs to that taken by…similarly high-impact journals Cell & Nature." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-03128-2
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ If the guide helped your institution adopt or think about a rights-retention OA policy, or if you have suggestions on how we could improve it, please let us know. (Email link on the front page of the guide.)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"The results far exceeded expectations. In less than two months, from 6 May to 24 June, #sues raised 73,000 Euros - enough money to support all 45 journals."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"The Right to Read Act reaffirms that first amendment rights apply to school libraries in response to the alarming trend of book banning, and it protects school librarians and other educators in carrying out their duty to protect students’ right to read." www.reed.senate.gov/news/releases/reed-and-grijalva-intro…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Call for "coopetition" in #openaccess, by analogy to seatbelts: "Car makers compete vigorously for market share…[But with] seatbelts they…collaborate…to develop an agreed & clearly defined set of safety specifications, principles & practices." chronoshub.io/media/pmlc4nop/oa-community-survey-report.pdf
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Working for a political party significantly correlates w/ knowingly sharing disinformation…& participating in violent political activities significantly correlates w/…actively participating in combat against disinformation." (#paywalled) www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/OIR-05-2020-0…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Thanks to @Auths_Alliance for the good questions and conversation.
PS: This piece addresses one publisher. But have any publishers met this need? I don't think I've ever seen such a policy.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"This is what the censors refuse to grasp: Librarians are not trying to force your children to read material you don’t want them to read. They are…upholding the constitutional promise of access to information for all." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/10/02/jamestown-patm…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
This is a terrible idea and must be stopped! There is an effort in France to introduce (as part of the discussion of the 2023 budget) to introduce a 1% tax on profits derived from the use of works in the #publicdomain.
[ils ont osé] Et voilà. La copie privée ne suffisait pas. Les lobbys ont bien travaillé. Un amendement a été déposé vendredi visant à taxer de 1% les bénéfices tirés de l'utilisation commerciale d’une œuvre du domaine public, notre commun culturel à tous. www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/16/amendements/0273A/CION_…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ Love the idea of a "new framework for recognizing ‘public goods’ within the @WTO trade rules, whereby govts can make voluntary but binding offers to supply such goods to other WTO trading partners – inc…public health products, investments & know-how.." healthpolicy-watch.news/a-push-for-public-goods-to-fight-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ More examples from @jamie_love: "#opensource distance education tools. Digital libraries for education & research. Creating DAISY (@accessibledaisy) format versions of books for persons who are blind or have other disabilities. Funding of basic science in all fields."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "We present a new approach to semi-automating normalized, #openaccess data tables from pub'd clinical trials…Machine learning models…built on combined & normalized patient data…demonstrate automated discovery of…biomarker relationships." www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frai.2022.984836/full
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Scholars in all disciplines & countries, we invite you to sign this open letter to @WHOSTP calling for equitable access & participation in research for all
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If you're building an AI-powered chatbot, build in some ethical rules. But which ones? @Google made a good start with #sparrow (see Table 13): no medical advice, no financial advice, no legal advice, no sexual aggression, no threats… What would you add? storage.googleapis.com/deepmind-media/DeepMind.com/Author…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: A survey of scholars who posted #preprints during the pandemic suggests that many will continue after the pandemic. They got useful feedback, but often in private. The authors argue that open feedback would be even more useful. osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/d96yj/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"a national infrastructure for the storage, discovery, access, analysis, and preservation of practice research assets: which may include text, but also image/video/audio/software, and other less common mediums" #wropenah
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
In states where a supermajority favors abortion rights (or legal marijuana, medicaid expansion…) & the unrepresentative Republican legislature opposes them, citizens are turning to direct referenda. So Republicans are turning against direct referenda. apnews.com/article/2022-midterm-elections-voting-rights-a…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Republicans are extending their war against referenda to Arizona and Arkansas. Note that "of the two dozen states that allow citizen-initiated ballot measures, 11 have laws prohibiting most abortions." www.politico.com/news/2022/09/10/the-lefts-best-chance-fo…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Drugmakers filed more than 140 patent applications on average per drug; on average 66% of patent applications were filed after the FDA approved the drug…On average, four times as many patents are granted on the top ten drugs in the U.S. compared to Europe."
Initiative for Medicines, Access & Knowledge@IMAKglobal
🚨BREAKING: We investigated the 10 top selling prescription drugs in the U.S. and revealed how drugmakers across the pharmaceutical industry are exploiting the U.S. patent system to keep drug prices high. www.i-mak.org/overpatented/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "We found a robust association between #openaccess & increased diversity of citation sources by institutions, countries, subregions, regions, & fields of research…[Green OA] showed a stronger effect than [gold OA]." zenodo.org/record/7081037
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Good point: The 2018 Principles of Transparency & Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing say that journals "should not guarantee…very short peer review times" but ignore "the converse, namely that a journal should not take an excessive amount of time." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12109-022-09891-4
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I hope that other publishers will follow suit ASAP. It would be in the spirit of the project for PLOS and DataSeer to share the code needed to do so.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
What's wrong with this picture? #climate science has grown rapidly for 50 years. So has climate activism. "Yet, greenhouse gas emissions and other indicators of adverse climate change…rise year upon year." amp.abc.net.au/article/101357920
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"When I led the Cancer Moonshot as Vice President…we made federally funded cancer research more available to any patient, to any doctor anywhere for free. And today, as President, we’re making sure that transparency applies to all federally funded science beyond just cancer."
In his remarks just now on the Cancer Moonshot, @POTUS raised research sharing as "one of the biggest issues" necessary to speed discovery and highlighted his administration's work to ensure "transparency applies to all federally funded science." #oaintheusa
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
There will be other powerful uses for this tech not mentioned here. Two that occur to me: 1. Discovering prior art & blocking bad patents 2. Comparing research publications for topical overlap, esp when from different fields using different terminology ai.googleblog.com/2022/08/announcing-patent-phrase-simila…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2021 #einsteinfoundationaward winner Paul Ginsparg, Professor of Physics + Information Science @Cornell, received the award for developing arxiv.org, the first platform to make scientific preprints immediately available globally▶️bitly.ws/u6iY 1/3
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
These are excellent recommendations. They address European policymakers, but I hope they are taken up globally. One reason = their merits. Another = deep copyright reforms must modify treaties, not just national statutes.
Explore COMMUNIA’s 20 new Policy Recommendations on our website! Click through and discover additional content relating to the Recommendations.📃 Stay tuned: we’ll share the favorite Recommendations of our team over the next couple of days.♥️ communia-association.org/policy-recommendations/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Electric utilities on climate: "Before 1980 [their] messaging…generally [followed the science]…From 1990-2000 [they] funded front groups that promoted…doubt & denial. After 2000 [they closed] these front groups…& shifted to arguing for delayed action." iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ac8ab3
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: @Twitter had less misinfo about #covid19 than mainstream news. But Twitter's most popular misinfo accounts "had reshare volumes comparable to many mainstream sources & larger volumes than authoritative sources such as the @CDCgov & @WHO." arxiv.org/abs/2209.01675
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "A majority of [US] voters (83%) agree that federally funded research should be freely available for taxpayers to read & access. This includes 86% of Democrats, 80% of Independents, and 82% of Republicans." www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2022/9/8/voters-overwhelming…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Consensus statement on how journals should evaluate "helicopter research" or "manuscripts that report research conducted in low- or middle-income countries by collaborations including partners from one or more high-income countries." associationofanaesthetists-publications.onlinelibrary.wil…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "As part of @PLOSMedicine's commitment to address parachute science, we now require that local researchers be first or last authors of publications based on global research." doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1004099
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "We estimate that globally authors [& author sponsors] paid the oligopoly of academic publishers $1.06 billion in publication fees in the 4-year period [2015-2018]." That comes to an avg $265 million/year in #apcs for just 5 publishers. zenodo.org/record/7057144
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ With Darrell Issa, Maloney co-sponsored the wretched Research Works Act (2011), which would have repealed the OA policy at the @NIH and prevented other agencies from adopting similar policies. cyber.harvard.edu/hoap/Notes_on_the_Research_Works_Act
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ She was heavily funded by Elsevier, which also supported RWA. When Elsevier withdrew its support for RWA (Feb 2012), Maloney did too.
I wrote more about the rise and fall of RWA, and Maloney's involvement, in this piece from March 2012. dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/10059024
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Peer review in journals w higher #jif [is] more thorough in discussing…methods…but less helpful in…suggesting solutions…Differences were modest & variability high, indicating that…JIF is a bad predictor for the quality of peer review." arxiv.org/abs/2207.09821
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "This case illustrates the benefits of open peer review in detecting fraud." psyarxiv.com/2yf8z/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: 74.5% of junior medical scientists in French-speaking Africa use Sci-Hub. 64.7% face financial barriers in publishing their research and 56.5% face language barriers. assets.researchsquare.com/files/rs-1991468/v1/d50ecf3f-ef…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Most [surveyed Turkish] academics indicate that their awareness of #openaccess… increased during the pandemic period…75% of the academics use articles in OA journals for their own research and 51%…do not publish any articles in OA journals." europepmc.org/article/PMC/PMC8689098
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Missed this at the time: "The Trump…Admin advised hospitals to send data on SARS-CoV-2 & ICU capacities to a private company, bypassing the US @CDCgov. [Later] a relationship was exposed between the private contractor & the Trump family's corporation." www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(2…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Science journalists need support, esp on social media. "'To be very honest, the harassment works to a degree,' said one reporter, who added that she has become less inclined to cover topics that she feels are likely to draw the ire of online trolls." blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2022/05/13/polaris…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I created this list and welcome suggestions to make it more comprehensive. Thanks to @OADirectory for approving it.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Open letter to @pfizer & @moderna_tx: "In…2020, before results from the trials were announced, vaccine mfgrs were criticized for keeping the trial protocols secret. In response, the protocols were released. Yet the same did not happen for the trial data." www.bmj.com/content/378/bmj.o1731/rr-0
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From Martha Whitehead: "#openaccess increases research use & reuse, helps readers find & read the research they need & helps authors maximize their audience & impact. It…decreases [costs] & by exposing research to more people from more perspectives, increases trust in research."
I never want to tweet to a subset of those who follow me. But I often want to read a subset of those I follow. In work time I'd read those who tweet on my work topics. Other times I'd read other topics & news.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
To implement the better kind of circles, let us tag the accounts we follow with user-defined tags. Then give us the option to see just the timeline for a given tag (or boolean combination of tags).
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: Content on deposit in #openaccess repositories is not equally available to all online users. Some users are blocked by geopolitical or infrastructural problems. Authors made good use of VPNs to identify these access barriers. www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/frma.2022.912456/full
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Comment: It doesn't *have* to be this way. So why *is* it this way? I ask with one eye on other sectors in which for-profit orgs are replacing or taking over nonprofit orgs.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ This is big. @WHOSTP is calling on all federal research funding agencies to adopt #openaccess policies. If they already have OA policies, they must strengthen them to meet the new guidelines. I'll add some summary points in a thread below.
White House Office of Science & Technology Policy@WHOSTP
How is the Biden-Harris Admin working to ensure taxpayer-funded research data & publications advance innovation for ALL Americans?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
15/ From the new @WHOSTP memo: "The insights of new and cutting-edge research stemming from the support of federal agencies should be immediately available —not just in moments of crisis, but in every moment." [more in next]
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
16/ "Not only to fight a pandemic, but to advance all areas of study, including urgent issues such as cancer, clean energy, economic disparities, and climate change."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
18/ The headline & 1st paragraph of this @nytimes story are misleading. The new fed policies will not regulate journals or publishers. They will regulate grantees (by modifying the terms of fed research grants). www.nytimes.com/2022/08/25/us/white-house-federally-funde…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
19/ It's important to distinguish what the agency policies will require from what publishers will do to respond or adapt.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
It's one thing to make your data open at the time of publication. How about keeping it available for the long term? Steps that help: * deposit in a data repository * give the dataset a #doi * share the DOI and repository URL journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ Worth watching: US fed law & guidelines from 2021 permit emergency rooms to give abortions in certain cases of obstetric emergency, regardless of any state law to the contrary. www.acep.org/federal-advocacy/federal-advocacy-overview/r…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ When Jeffrey Davis of @ACEPNow asked the @CMSGov whether its guidance would change in light of #dobbs, it didn't say but "did point me to [the 2021 pre-Dobbs] guidance…as a place to start."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. The #doj won its suit against #idaho. Emergency abortions must remain legal in Idaho for now. The ruling is based on the supremacy clause. Emergency abortions are protected by federal law and the Idaho ban is state law. storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.idd.50547/go…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"UNESCO has reported that 152 cultural sites have been damaged since the Russian invasion of Ukraine even though both countries are signatories to the 1954 Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict." www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=7ed28c69-01cd-45ab…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "The avg researcher…is unwilling to incur additional costs (in time, effort or expenditure) that are currently needed to use #code sharing tools…We need different models for funding and producing interactive or executable research outputs." peerj.com/articles/13933/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Yes to this point, which is rarely part of our discussions. Academics who think access to scholarship needn't be mobile-friendly are unaware of how many academics are limited to mobile devices.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ Zooming out a bit: By design, infrastructure for repositories and publishing platforms should be friendly to mobile users, visually impaired users, users with low bandwidth, and users who need to cut/paste or text-mine.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. ARC official statement is brief: "Feedback during consultation [on ERA] was overwhelmingly supportive of not including preprints as an eligible research output type in ERA 2023. As a consequence, preprints will not be eligible for ERA submission." www.arc.gov.au/evaluating-research/excellence-research-au…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
When you publish peer-reviewed articles, do you have a duty to referee articles by others? Regardless of your rank, tenure, compensation, schedule, and so on? I don't think I've ever seen an argument for 'no'. But FYI, here's an argument for 'yes'. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022399922002823
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Dems need more of the @JohnFetterman instinct. For example when: * GHW Bush asked an aide, "What is takehome pay?" * GW Bush told clueless FEMA director he was "doing a heckuva job" w Hurricane Katrina * TFG tossed paper towels to Hurricane Maria survivors in Puerto Rico
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ That's the descriptive Q. I'm also interested in the normative Q. When a preprint is later published, perhaps w changes, which version should you cite, when the two versions differ in a way that matters to you and when you read and relied on the preprint for your own work?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ New study: Helping other scientists use newer, larger neural networks "needs more than publication — it requires new tools that are publicly available, easy to use, and efficiently handle large data." www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fninf.2022.896292/full
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Same: "Preprints worked exactly as intended, with data inquiries & [text] downloads starting immediately after pre-print publication…Many readers are more interested in our data than in our analysis of our data, suggesting that data-only papers can be well appreciated."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"We…might be seeing a fundamental shift in academic attitudes – arising from…rankings – away from the… reputation among peers [as] the ‘gold standard’ of academic status, to a…model where the status of the journal…is equally (or even more) prized." blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2022/01/19/at-what…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Well-argued by @michelleinbklyn. Trumpist "caterwauling…is designed to intimidate [prosecutors] & such intimidation helped him become president in the first place. Trump shouldn’t be prosecuted because of politics, but he also shouldn’t be spared because of them."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The Corbevax approach "stands in stark contrast to that of Pfizer & Moderna,…pharmaceutical giants that are fiercely guarding their vaccine recipes—and reaping massive profits—as billions of people in low-income countries remain without access to the lifesaving shots."
Here’s our official announcement from @TexasChildrens@BCM_TropMed on our partnership with @biological_e to vaccinate the world beginning with this EUA in India 🇮🇳
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ New study: "On average, low-income countries are publishing and citing #openaccess at the highest rate, while upper middle-income countries and higher-income countries publish and cite OA articles at below world-average rates." doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0272730
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Trump is raising hell, accusing Dems of "weaponizing" DOJ for political purposes. This goes without saying, but here's a reminder: Trump was the king of politicizing DOJ during his presidency. Here's a list of 25 political opponents that he publicly said should be investigated.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Fascinating history: The Italian news media initially treated the journal impact factor (#jif) "as a 'justice device' to promote meritocracy in academic recruitment, as an objective remedy to the persistent clientelism of academic careers in the country." blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2022/07/04/bibliom…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org) reposted
This is the right move, just as it was for COVID-19, but why wait for the next crisis? @POTUS@WhiteHouse We need a national open access policy to make ALL federally funded research immediately available to the public. #oaintheusa#openscience#openaccess
White House Office of Science & Technology Policy@WHOSTP
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Today, the @WHOSTP announced a coordinated call to action with science and technology leaders and advisors from [19 other countries], asking scholarly publishers to make all #monkeypox-related research and data immediately available to the public." www.whitehouse.gov/ostp/news-updates/2022/08/04/a-call-fo…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
“His work frames the law as the foundation for advancing the mission of all libraries, archives, and cultural institutions to acquire, preserve, maintain, and share the world’s culture.” Congrats to our own @KyleKCourtney on his win from @publicknowledge! publicknowledge.org/ip3awards2022/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
When @Twitter shows me tweets or topics I dislike, I click "not interested". That used to make them disappear. But that feature has been broken for 2+ days. Broken on web version, still works on #android.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm willing to give up some privacy and teach @Twitter what I like and dislike. Even willing to put some time into it. But in exchange I need it to act on what it's learning, clean up my timeline, and remove the items and topics I dislike.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Kudos to @bmj_company: Press releases in advance of supporting documentation are a "brazen and dishonest" tactic that ask news media to take the announced claims "on trust". Hence #bmj "will no longer report" on unsupported press releases. www.bmj.com/content/378/bmj.o1878
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Fascinating examples from biodiversity and climate science on digitizing and making use of historic analog (pre-digital) data. Good guidance through the complexities and recommendations that other disciplines follow suit datascience.codata.org/article/10.5334/dsj-2022-014/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Make a donation. (I just did.) Make it easier to protest school-board censorship of school libraries.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"All 200+ million structures will also be available for bulk download via Google Cloud Public Datasets, making AlphaFold even more accessible to scientists around the world."
Today we're freely sharing the predicted structures of all 200M+ proteins known to science - almost the entire protein universe!
It's our gift to humanity, and a demonstration of the benefits AI can bring to society dpmd.ai/AF-22-LI
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Another reason experienced advocates don't always welcome evaluations: They know the reach of misunderstandings. They've seen govt evals done w poor info, false assumptions, compromised memberships & fear of strong conclusions. "Good" evals always welcome but rare & contestable.
A few immediate impressions to follow, very loosely held and non-expert!
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Academic libraries increasingly recognize the importance of scholarly communication. But scholcomm librarians generally learn their work on the job, and do not feel well-prepared by their grad schools. jlsc-pub.org/articles/abstract/10.7710/2162-3309.2328/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update from @ces43: "In contrast [to librarians with research degrees], those from within the LIS sector do not feel that their formal qualifications have prepared them for working in [scholarly communication]." dx.doi.org/10.17613/gk63-v687
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I love this from Barbara Mikulski (@SenatorBarb): "Any rich nation can build a space telescope, but only a great nation gives its information away to the world to be used for the common heritage and betterment of mankind." github.blog/2022-01-18-how-open-source-is-supporting-nasa…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ New study: Only 38% of preprints (on trauma & orthopaedic surgery) posted 2014-20 were later published in peer-reviewed journals. The highest rates of non-publication were seen for preprints from Africa, Asia/Middle East, and South America. online.boneandjoint.org.uk/doi/full/10.1302/2633-1462.37.…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ This study didn't get into explanations but did suggest two possibilities: More authors from these regions were blocked by APCs or language barriers at English-language journals.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This is the kind of loss we suffered repeatedly during the #trump administration. In fact, this is a loss of resources posted precisely to repair Trump-admin damage. "We need the @EPA's archive to be improved, not retired."
If the EPA discontinues its online archive as planned, the public will lose access to "information about critical environmental issues, and past and present agency activities, policies, and priorities," according to the co-founder of @EnviroDGIact.ucsusa.org/3ilivgS
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. The @EPA archive will stay online at least until June 2023. The agency will "transition key content" (note, not necessarily all content) to its main website. archive.epa.gov
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Study on peer review in the medical and life sciences finds that the journal impact factor is a bad predictor for the quality of peer review of an individual manuscript.
JIF and peer review thoroughness and helpfulness: A supervised machine learning study arxiv.org/abs/2207.09821
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From a raft of CEOs: "Nearly 2/3 of high-skilled immigration [to the US] is for computer scientists, & every state is an importer of this strategic talent. The USA has over 700,000 open computing jobs but only 80,000 computer science graduates a year." www.ceosforcs.com
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Thanks to @BKLYNlibrary, both for helping and for showing that digital lending can bypass censorship.
The Brooklyn Public Library is offering a free library card to anyone in the U.S. aged 13 to 21 who wants to check out books digitally.
Called Books UnBanned, the program was created in response to a nationwide wave of book bans and restrictions.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If Rs worry about the backlash when a 10 year old rape victim has to travel to another state for an abortion, they should start to worry about the backlash when a 10 year old rape victim *cannot* travel to another state for an abortion. It's just a matter of time.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ "Younger faculty are more open to…#openaccess… than their older peers: 70% of faculty ages 22-44… would be happy to see an OA publication system replace the traditional subscription-based system, followed by 63% of faculty ages 44-54, 61% ages 55-64, & 57% ages >65."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ "Larger shares of contingent faculty (55%) rate a journal making its articles freely available on the internet highly important compared to their tenure-line colleagues (38%)."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Confession that I'm part of #academictwitter: If @Twitter added a button that meant "important if true", I'd use it more than the heart button.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Carmakers are learning from publishers. Recurring payments are better than one-time payments. Renting is better than selling. Ability to shut off service is better than giving control to consumers.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Overall, #openaccess articles grew from "56.5% in 2015 [to] 61.8% in 2020…[Academic Social Networks grew fastest] (44.4% in 2015 & 56.0% in 2020), followed by Subject Repositories (35.0% in 2015 & 39.6% in 2020) & Gold (24.1% in 2015 & 37.4% in 2020)." journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
More and more schools & libraries will face this harassment: "Craft admitted he has not read many of the books on his list. He also told ABC7 said he did not compile the list himself, but found it on the internet. 'I can't remember where,' he said." www.mysuncoast.com/2022/07/08/sarasota-county-school-boar…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ About 20 yrs ago I remember seeing early signs of interactive charts in digital texts, allowing readers to do spontaneous what-if analysis. Uptake was sadly slow & scarce. Here's hoping it's gaining momentum. It's one of the best ways to take advantage of the digital medium.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
A recommendation worth considering, marred by this false statement: "At present, the vast majority of OA content is still being funded by the authors themselves." The recommendation doesn't depend on this false statement and could easily drop it. www.igi-global.com/newsroom/archive/crowdfunding-approach…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Academic age" (years since first publication) predicts biological age better in STEM fields than SSH, and better in scientifically "advanced" countries than in scientifically "developing" countries. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-022-04363-0
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
An important step in validating journal-independent peer-review as such. Among other benefits, "these innovative developments turn attention away from the prestige of the journal or platform to focus on the intrinsic value of the peer-reviewed article itself."
Good as far as it goes. But should have mentioned that #rightsretention lets authors overcome publisher-imposed obstacles like embargoes and non-permission for green OA.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: For a large sample of preprints on #covid19, "we are unable to find markers of either open data or open code for 75% of those on arXiv, 67% of those on bioRxiv, and 79% of those on medRxiv." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-022-04418-2
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
It's early days for this initiative, but yes: research funders and performers have been invited to discuss with @EUScienceInnov the possibility of @OpenResearch_EU evolving into a multi-country or pan-European platform beyond 2026 #openaccess#diamondoa#openscience
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
EU made a mistake to give the ORE contract to proprietary software. Now is the time to fix the problem, not double down on the mistake.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Does any basic research need to be classified? NSF wants the National Academies to take a fresh look at a Cold War-era directive (NSDD-189) that sees openness as a boon, not a bane, to national security. Will Congress listen? www.science.org/content/article/when-should-u-s-research-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From the US @CopyrightOffice: "The challenges of funding #journalism in the internet era do not appear to be copyright-specific…The Copyright Office does not recommend adopting a new ancillary copyright to bolster press publishers' protections." www.copyright.gov/newsnet/2022/970.html
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This is what's at stake in the imminent #scotus decision on whether the @EPA can regulate greenhouse gas emissions.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Excellent @charlie_savage take on how WVvEPA accelerates long-term Republican goal to weaken agencies that "ensur[e] that the air & water are clean, that food, drugs, vehicles & consumer products are safe, & that financial firms follow the rules." www.nytimes.com/2022/06/30/us/supreme-court-epa-administr…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Answering a question I've heard from a few people: All my consulting in this new role will be pro bono (no charge to the client). More detail on my "conflicts" page — written for my old position but applicable to my new one as well. cyber.harvard.edu/~psuber/wiki/Conflicts
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
NEW: Justice Breyer has sent a letter to President Biden informing him that his retirement will be effective 24 hours from now: at noon on Thursday, June 30.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If this helps @w3c survive and thrive, I'm all for it:
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Another example of text-mining #openaccess articles (because non-OA articles are unavailable for mining) and excluding #pdfs because they are unfriendly to mining. www.jmir.org/2022/6/e37324
Short lesson: To facilitate research, always make new work OA and never publish PDF-only.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Congress can codify abortion rights nationwide. Part of fighting back against #dobbs is voting for fed-level Dems (House & Senate).
But don't stop there. #scotus didn't ban abortion; it permitted states to ban abortion. Part of fighting back is voting for state-level Dems too.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This is what's at stake in the imminent #scotus decision on whether the @EPA can regulate greenhouse gas emissions.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
White nationalist Vincent James says overturning Roe does "not go far enough" and we need to start "rolling back the 'rights' of women over the past 100 years" because "there is a true rise of Christian nationalism in this country."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Kudos to #quebec for strengthening its #openaccess policy to require open licenses and unembargoed OA.
Bureau du scientifique en chef du Québec@SciChefQC
The just-announced U.S. Supreme Court decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization represents a stunning reversal of precedent that inserts government into the personal lives and health care of Americans. www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMe2208288
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
We Americans hardly believe it ourselves. The difference is that we're dismally aware of the makeup of the Supreme Court.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Five of the current conservative justices (all but Roberts) were nominated by presidents who lost the popular vote, confirmed by senators representing a minority of the electorate, or both. www.snopes.com/news/2022/05/06/conservative-supreme-court…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Great news for diamond open access. The open scholarly search engine @TheLensOrg in its latest release has introduced a filter that allows to restrict to output published in journals flagged as not charging APCs in @DOAJplus. Another step towards fair open access.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Thanks to @DOAJplus for moving the key info about no-fee or #diamond journals to the front page. Here are today's numbers: * Total OA journals listed in DOAJ = 17,862 * No-fee or diamond OA journals listed = 12,414 (69.5%). www.doaj.org
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Five of the current conservative justices (all but Roberts) were nominated by presidents who lost the popular vote, confirmed by senators representing a minority of the electorate, or both. www.snopes.com/news/2022/05/06/conservative-supreme-court…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
They just repealed a fundamental right and permitted states to make it a crime.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm reupping this question from six months ago. Inspired in part by the #jan6 hearings and in part by a conversation this morning with a roomful of excellent French students on #openaccess in an age of denialism and disinformation.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Some Trumpist zealots sincerely believe that the 2020 election was stolen and some cynical opportunists utter the same assertions without conviction. Is anyone trying to measure or estimate their ratio? Social scientists, pollsters, journalists, anyone?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Donald Trump: "I hope [Biden] has recovered, because as you know, he fell off his bicycle. No, I'm serious. I hope he's okay. Fell off a bicycle. I make this pledge to you today – I will never, ever ride a bicycle."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Anticipating what I'll say next year: No, it wasn't a political prosecution & shouldn't deter future candidates who have evidence of election fraud from using legal channels to press their claims. It should only deter those who don't have evidence, or choose violence, or both.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From @DeltaThink: 70.7% of scholarly journal publishers publish just one journal each and together account for 9% of published articles. 0.06% of publishers publish more than 501 journals each and together account for 47% of published articles. deltathink.com/news-views-publishers-and-market-consolida…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The @EUCouncil calls for "action…to move towards a renewed approach to research assessment, including incentive and reward schemes" and "emphasizes that applying #openscience principles should be appropriately rewarded in researchers’ careers." www.consilium.europa.eu/media/56958/st10126-en22.pdf
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Given the usual limits on library funding, librarians may find…offers [of free content during the pandemic] almost irresistible. But while there can be advantages to accepting such content, it can be a double-edged sword." www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0361526X.2021.1943106
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. From @EIFLnet & @IFLA: "Temporary expanded access [from] pubs…was a welcome gesture, [but] either didn’t last long enough or…usage conditions were too complicated to allow the content to be meaningfully integrated into teaching and research." www.eifl.net/blogs/copyright-and-covid-libraries-take-stock
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Open Access Tracking Project @oatp@fediscience.org@oatp
.@OATP is delighted to send public thanks to @OA_Works and @McArthur_Joe for helping us (1) fix our email feed, which was accidentally omitting some items, and (2) expanding our twitter feed, which was formerly abridged, by providing a premium IFTTT account.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Another aspect of this. OA benefits from custom that pubs don't pay authors or referees for their work. Unis generally cover it thru salaries, in effect paying profs to give it to pubs/public. But this is undercut by the ongoing conversion of profs to adjuncts.
It took me many years to come to a similar conclusion. OA activism that devalues labour does not have the characteristic of socialistic sharing that is often uttered in the same breath. However, this devaluation of labour is also not unique to OA activism.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I just realized that this old tweet has a dead link (because Google shamelessly deleted all Google+ posts, even after heroically preserving Usenet posts). Here's an archived copy of the post to which I was linking. web.archive.org/web/20190119214350/https://plus.google.co…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
In a pilot project, we are considering first-author refereed preprints to be eligible for our @EMBO Postdoctoral Fellowship Programme. With this, we emphasise progress in research, rather than accumulating publications.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study confirms everybody's hunch: Academic men self-promote their work on social media more than academic women, and the disparity increases with the impact factor of the journals in which they publish. arxiv.org/abs/2206.05330
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "The pandemic [proves] that much greater access to medical literature is possible. The green road may be the best way to bring #openaccess rates of peer review of other major diseases closer to that of #covid19." informationr.net/ir/27-2/paper929.html
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ "Our North Korean defector partners determine what goes on the drives. Content ranges from South Korean soap operas and Hollywood films, to Korean-language versions of Wikipedia and interviews with North Korean defectors."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ I wrote about the basic idea in May 2011: "Swapping thumb drives of OA' [OA Prime or 'free offline'] literature bypasses censors and surveillance in oppressive countries." dash.harvard.edu/handle/1/8715025
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Data sharing practices are rare in surgical journals despite the #icmje policy [that RCTs must share their data]…Most RCTs published in these journals lack transparency…may not be reproducible by external researchers. jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2792858
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The @Jerusalem_Post published a "promo content" piece reviewing a supplement promoted by Joe Rogan. "Joe Rogan has tons of credibility and has been a self-experimenter for years. Surely, he would not put his name on something that did not work?" www.jpost.com/promocontent/alpha-brain-review-does-this-n…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I just learned about Gun Violence Archive, which is better. Both are #nonprofit & #openaccess. GVA has more reports, visualizations, data breakdowns, & lets you download datasets in CSV. www.gunviolencearchive.org
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Even when authors indicate in their manuscript that they will share data upon request, the compliance rate is the same [about 7%] as for authors who [make no such statement]." (#paywalled) www.jclinepi.com/article/S0895-4356(22)00141-X/pdf
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Kudos to Sen @RonWyden: "After years of fighting Congressional efforts to make #pacer free, it is great to hear that the courts are now embracing the idea that members of the public shouldn't be gouged to access public court records." www.reuters.com/legal/government/fed-judiciary-says-yes-f…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
An exciting project from @arcadiascience (not to be confused with @arcadiafund, both committed to #openscience). "We’re treating our publishing project like an experiment — we’re not sure where we will land, but we can only learn if we try."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Simplistic citation metrics boost "scholarly bullshit" articles that "engage with the latest academic buzzwords…tend to accumulate significant citations, & are thus welcomed by many journal editors." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43615-022-00175-9
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ This is hard-won knowledge — and not only because the data points are shootings that kill or maim. For >25 years, Republicans have blocked publicly-funded research into gun violence in the US. ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/full/10.2105/AJPH.2018.304450
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
If baseball teams can risk alienating fans by deploring gun violence & calling for change, then so can R members of Congress. "We cannot become numb. We cannot look the other way. We all know, if nothing changes, nothing changes." mlb.com/rays/news/rays-issue-statements-about-gun-violence
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The world sees the problem. Most Americans see the problem too.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This article is paywalled and outside my field. But when I read the title, I had to read more. I'm not surprised that acrobatic training is neuroprotective. (Exercise is neuroprotective.) But what's acrobatic training for rats? doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2022.113935
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Kudos to @BrianNosek: "The possibility that the [reproducibility] work might illuminate something embarrassing only reinforced my view of the importance of doing the research. If it revealed something embarrassing, all the more important that we know about it to fix it."
Reflecting on the history, one might think I was hard done by. Precisely the opposite. The last 10 years has been a gift. The stressors are hugely overshadowed by gratitude and joy for collaborators and supporters making improving science a shared mission. news.virginia.edu/content/after-10-years-many-labs-comes-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
This case report describes a patient in Sweden who had an out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and received defibrillation with an automated external defibrillator delivered by a drone (shown in a video). www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2200833
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Which political candidates were the pioneers in posting long-form, evidence-based policy positions to their web sites? I associate this practice with Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren. Were there earlier examples? Better ones? (For something I'm writing.)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Conservative Republicans running for school boards in North Carolina & New York [on platforms to ban books and censor curricula] overwhelmingly lost their elections Tuesday night." www.huffpost.com/entry/school-board-elections-conservativ…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Overall, the scale and reproducibility of text mining studies will be hindered until scientific articles are considered a public good and made open and freely accessible." royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2021.2721
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ A new tool analyzes context to guess what a medical acronym stands for in clinical notes --where for example, IVF could be Intra-Venous Fluids or In-Vitro Fertilization. The tool is trained on a corpus of #openaccess articles. (How else?) www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1386505619312122
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. " A new…report from @theNASEM calls for urgent actions by federal agencies, Congress, journals, and others to improve the representation of racial and ethnic minority groups and other underrepresented populations in clinical trials and research." www.nationalacademies.org/news/2022/05/lack-of-equitable-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Just inserting an older tweet into this thread.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"African Americans...represented...2.74% of all patients in oncology trials...& only 4% of patients enrolled in trials for the oncology drugs approved in 2018....The disparity...highlights the stark lack of appropriate representation in clinical trials." www.massbio.org/news/blog/yes-virginia-digital-health-can…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From @TorstenReimer: "Research libraries provide and support crucial infrastructure for knowledge sharing globally, and we enable #openaccess to an ever-growing number of scholarly publications."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Report on a project to harness "the power of open publishing [on #covid19] to organize…technical and non-technical scientists to aggregate and disseminate information in response to an evolving crisis." www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9093051/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Good point: "Unless we take steps to ensure that measurement units are routinely documented for easy, unambiguous exchange of data, information will be unusable or, worse, be misinterpreted." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01233-w
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ The Alito #scotus isn't the first example of judges politicizing their own courts and then protesting when observers point it out. It's just a recent high-stakes example.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ For a study more than 60 years old, see Stuart Nagel, Political Party Affiliation and Judges' Decisions, American Political Science Review, pp. 843-850, Dec 1961 (#paywalled). www.jstor.org/stable/1952531
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ Nagel compared Democratic and Republican state supreme court judges in cases from 1955. Their decisions differed in 15 kinds of cases. In 9 of those 15 the differences were statistically significant.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
4/ His summary describes the D positions but could easily be flipped to describe the R positions. Here are the 9 categories on which their differences were statistically significant:
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
5/ "Democratic judges…were more prone [than Republican judges] to favor (1) the defense in criminal cases, (2) the administrative agency in business regulation cases…(4) the claimant in unemployment compensation cases…"
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
6/ "…(6) the finding of a const'l violation in criminal…cases, (7) the govt in tax cases…(10) the tenant in landlord-tenant cases…(13) the consumer in sales-of-goods cases, (14) the injured party in motor vehicle accident cases, & (15) the employee in employee injury cases."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. Here's another #openaccess dataset so large that #torrent is the most practical way to gain full access. It's a sign of progress that people are now sharing datasets this large, even if many users still find torrent difficult and intimidating. www.crossref.org/blog/2022-public-data-file-of-more-than-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Thank you to @TheLancet for its editorial defending Roe v. Wade. "Alito utterly fails to consider the health of women…[His opinion is] a judicial endorsement of state control over women —a breathtaking setback for the health and rights of women." www.thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0140-6736(22)00870-4
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Animal welfare [is] another important reason for…#openscience practices in animal science… Increased transparency of reporting research protocols & findings could lead to a significant reduction in the number of individual animals tested." www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fvets.2022.810989/full
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ "Follett, which provides books & library management systems to [most] American school districts, said it would add a feature allowing parents to track & limit what their children check out from the library. Then it disavowed the idea after receiving backlash on social media."
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From Peter Hornby: "Rapid [& open] communication of clinical trial results has likely saved lives during the COVID-19 pandemic & should become the new norm…I cannot envisage a future without such rapid dissemination of new evidence." www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01812-4
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ I like Google docs when I need the input or collaboration of colleagues. But the security stakes are low for me. I don't mind (much) that G can see my drafts & don't worry (much) that someone might hack G. What do people do who want the convenience of Gdocs + higher security?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
BTW, here's what I mean by security. If you want the convenience of Gdocs and happen to be Secretary of State, then what would you use? Is there anything suitable at any price? Or does the security constraint doom you to clunky software?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
What software did they use? I assume not Zoom or the common alternatives. Is there a very secure platform for this purpose? If so, is it feature-rich or clunky?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Of the 70 journals for which we have info [in the field of health professions education], 53 (76%) will review/accept preprinted manuscripts [#preprints]; 11 (16%) do not, and 6 (9%) are unclear or make decisions on a case-by-case basis." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40037-022-00710-2
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Parthasarathy [@ShobitaP] says that although #llms [large language models] could strengthen efforts to understand complex research, they could also deepen public scepticism of science." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01191-3
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "We find that half of all [@theNASEM] report downloads are used for non-academic purposes, inc to improve…services by medical professionals, local & regional planners, public health workers, & veterans’ advocates, to name just a few." blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2022/05/05/who-use…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
A 2013 study showed that the retraction rate at high-JIF journals (Nature, PNAS, and Science) was 9.6 times higher than the background retraction rate. www.nature.com/articles/srep03146
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. In dentistry, low-JIF journals have higher retraction rates than high-JIF journals, the reverse of the findings above. www.hindawi.com/journals/ijd/2020/8881352/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Update. "Articles from prestigious journals contained a higher percentage of potentially HARKed hypotheses… [&] were associated with more QRP [questionable research practices] than less prestigious journals." onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/job.2623
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
A must-read article by @petersuber: 1⃣scholarly journal publishers don’t need exclusive rights & should stop demanding them 2⃣publishers could gain submissions by dropping the demand 3⃣authors should favor publishers who drop the demand & adopt open license #retainyourrights
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I just published this.
"Journal publishers don’t need exclusive rights. Or, they don’t need them for publishing. They don’t need them to make a work public or to add value…[or] to make enough money to pay their bills and grow." doi.org/10.3998/jep.1869
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From @IFLA report: "While many publishers offered expanded access to…content during the early months of the pandemic, these offers usually did not last for sufficient time for libraries to meaningfully integrate them into teaching & research activities." www.ifla.org/news/research-report-how-well-did-copyright-…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ I'd be interested in a new #scotus leak on the effect of the last leak.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
2/ Did the May 2 draft-opinion leak reinforce the prior leanings of the other justices? Turn up the heat that breaks bonds and forges new alliances?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ Did it jack up pressure on Alito to revise his text? To drop or try to strengthen weak arguments? To prevent the loss of the majority? To protect his reputation with the general public?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
5/ Is it changing the procedure for moving from the first draft to the final vote?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
6/ Is there angry uncertainty about which side caused the leak? Or are the justices pretty much agreed on which side caused it?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I just published this.
"Journal publishers don’t need exclusive rights. Or, they don’t need them for publishing. They don’t need them to make a work public or to add value…[or] to make enough money to pay their bills and grow." doi.org/10.3998/jep.1869
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Exactly. My take: "If one of your past articles is paywalled & a reader asks for a copy by email, send one. But [also] deposit a copy in an OA repository. That will help all who need access, not just the tiny subset willing to hunt you down, write, & ask." poynder.blogspot.com/2017/12/realising-boai-vision-peter-…
Academics: You think this is friendly and inclusive but it's clubby and exclusive. Free papers get hundreds of downloads - how many emails do you get? Don't make excuses for failing to make your work freely available. It's easy to do and it should be considered part of your job.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The Budapest Open Access Initiative (@TheBOAI) just released its 20th anniversary recommendations. #boai20
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Some Trumpist zealots sincerely believe that the 2020 election was stolen and some cynical opportunists utter the same assertions without conviction. Is anyone trying to measure or estimate their ratio? Social scientists, pollsters, journalists, anyone?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"We [@OpenAlex_org] now have much better coverage of #openaccess than MAG [Microsoft Academic Graph] ever did. Not only can we tell you where the [OA] copies of any particular article live…we can also tell you the licence & the version of that article." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00138-y
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
.@TUDelft comments on Dutch national plan: "The goal of #openaccess must emphasise more the need for ‘cost-constrained’ OA. There should be much more done to encourage non-[APC] forms of OA, eg national & international collaboration around Diamond OA." openworking.wordpress.com/2022/01/03/response-from-tu-del…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
.@earlham1847 had a water wilderness program for canoeing in NW Ontario & a mountain program for backpacking in the Uinta Mountains. I'm grateful to have led the water program twice in the early '80s. Thx to all alums who donated photos for this video. www.youtube.com/watch?v=SUnasSTKSG0
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
CC BY = 7,990 (48.4%) CC BY-NC-ND = 3,714 (22.5%) CC BY-NC = 3,097 (18.7%) CC BY-NC-SA = 1,544 (9.3%) CC BY-SA = 1,162 (7.0%) CC0 = 271 (1.6%) CC BY-ND = 254 (1.5%)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From @brewster_kahle: "The libraries I grew up with would buy books, preserve them, & lend them for free…In the shift from print to digital, many commercial publishers are declaring each of these activities illegal." time.com/6108581/internet-archive-future-books/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From @JelteWicherts: "Much of the [progress] has been driven by early-career researchers [#ecrs]…Preregistering studies, replication, publishing negative results, & sharing code, materials & data can…empower the self-corrective mechanisms of science." www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02421-w
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From Paul Ginsparg: "I do not claim that preprint distribution is a universal panacea for delays and biases of peer-reviewed journal publication but, rather, I would suggest that with proper context the benefits can far outweigh the risks."
Did you know that @arxiv turns 30 this month?! 🎂🥳 In a new Comment, Paul Ginsparg, its founder, discusses how academic experience with online preprints can still inform information sharing more generally
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The new EU model grant agreement requires #openaccess, zero embargoes, rights retention, open licenses for texts, public domain for metadata, FAIR data, and bars funder-paid APCs at hybrid journals. See esp pp. 152ff. ec.europa.eu/info/funding-tenders/opportunities/docs/2021…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I'm looking for good examples of public-interest campaigns that #backfired. I'm especially interested in those that are well-documented, notorious, or extreme. If scholars have already created good collections, I'd welcome citations/links. Thanks.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study by Mario Pagliaro: "Preprints are now regularly cited in peer reviewed journal articles, books, and conference papers." www.mdpi.com/2304-6775/9/3/26
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
CC BY = 7,990 (48.4%) CC BY-NC-ND = 3,714 (22.5%) CC BY-NC = 3,097 (18.7%) CC BY-NC-SA = 1,544 (9.3%) CC BY-SA = 1,162 (7.0%) CC0 = 271 (1.6%) CC BY-ND = 254 (1.5%)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I share these objections to APC-based gold OA. Unfortunately the headline is misleading. #openaccess doesn't exclude authors from the south; on the contrary. APC-based OA does. Headlines like this are a step backward even if the article is a step forward. www.scidev.net/global/features/open-access-excludes-devel…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "The number of #preprints has exponentially increased 63 times in 30 years….Preprints reach an audience 14 months earlier on average and associate with five times more citations compared with a non-preprint counterpart." arxiv.org/abs/2102.09066v1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"With time…journals [may cease] being the primary provider of original research, [& instead] will curate, interpret, & prioritise research data released elsewhere, & package it for delivery to their consumers in different formats on multiple channels." neuron.mefst.hr/docs/CMJ/issues/2020/61/6/cmj_61_6_MacAul…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "The 'early-view' and 'open-access' effects of preprints contribute to a measurable citation and readership advantage of preprints." arxiv.org/abs/2011.11940
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"Tobacco’s deception is 'the greatest' because it paved the way for other kinds of scientific fraud. If Big Carbon today claims that 'we need more research' to find out whether the climate is warming, that’s a trick learned from Big Tobacco." gizmodo.com/what-is-the-biggest-scientific-fraud-of-the-p…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
I support #openaccess because it "accelerates research and all the goods that depend on research, such as new medicines, useful technologies, solved problems, informed decisions, improved policies, and beautiful understanding." archive.org/stream/9780262517638OpenAccess/9780262517638_…
I support #openaccess because even as a researcher at a well-equipped university you often do not have (official) access to the required scientific literature (e.g. from another discipline). I nominate @EllenEuler and @petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From a naif: After elections, do pollster-watchers evaluate pollsters on their accuracy? Do less-accurate pollsters use the results to change their methods? If so, is there some kind of evolution toward best practices? If so, why do different pollsters still disagree so widely?
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From @internetarchive's court filing (p. 3): "Contrary to the publishers' accusations, the IA and the hundreds of libraries and archives that support it are not pirates or thieves. They are librarians, striving to serve their patrons online." archive.org/details/internet-archive-answer/page/3/mode/1up
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
The Christian right opposes the separation of church and state, until we ask whether the freedom of religion includes the freedom to endanger public health. Then it cites the separation of church and state as a principled reason for the state to butt out. thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/490871-roy-moore-to-advi…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New survey: "Only 14% of researchers agree that current metrics have had a positive impact on research culture, and 43% believe that their workplace puts more value on metrics than on research quality." #reimagineresearch wellcome.ac.uk/reports/what-researchers-think-about-resea… (Lots of other impt findings too.)
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
1/ Many of the new publisher lobbying statements use the standard rhetoric that government #openaccess policies interfere with the market. Many go a step further and assert that the market is working well.
For example:
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "We found that articles with a preprint had, on average, a 49% higher Altmetric Attention Score and 36% more citations than articles without a preprint." elifesciences.org/articles/52646
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New studying trying to measure publishers' added value: "Our analysis revealed that the text contents of the scientific papers generally changed very little from their pre-print to final published versions." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00799-018-0234-1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
"African Americans...represented...2.74% of all patients in oncology trials...& only 4% of patients enrolled in trials for the oncology drugs approved in 2018....The disparity...highlights the stark lack of appropriate representation in clinical trials." www.massbio.org/news/blog/yes-virginia-digital-health-can…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study (now pub'd, already influential as a preprint): "Of the institutions that mentioned the JIF, 87% supported its use in at least one of their RPT documents, 13% expressed caution about its use, and none heavily criticized it or prohibited its use." elifesciences.org/articles/47338
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
3/ Researchers, librarians, universities, and funders, esp in Europe: Please press the EC to insist that ORE be open infrastructure. Developers: Please submit at least one bid that would make ORE open infrastructure.
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
New study: "Peer-reviewed articles w/ a preprint on bioRxiv tend to have higher Altmetric Attention Scores & more citations than those without. The difference in citations...appears robust across...various fields of research [and other variables]." www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/699652v1
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Good analogy: "Climate scientists often resemble Sarah Connor of the Terminator..., who knows of a looming catastrophe but must struggle to function in a world that does not comprehend what is coming &, worse, largely ignores the warnings of those who do." www.motherjones.com/environment/2019/07/weight-of-the-wor…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
From new @IthakaSR faculty survey: "Approximately 64% of respondents in 2018 indicated they would be happy to see the traditional subscription-based publication model replaced entirely by an #openaccess system compared to 57% in 2015." sr.ithaka.org/publications/2018-us-faculty-survey/
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Today is the 17th birthday of the Budapest Open Access Initiative (@TheBOAI) <www.budapestopenaccessinitiative.org/read/> & the 7th birthday of its 10th anno update <goo.gl/7fqDYT>. I'm proud of my association with both. Happy Valentines Day to all who are working for OA worldwide!
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
100 days after Swedish universities cancelled Elsevier subscriptions, no regrets. "All...Vice-Chancellors collectively stand behind the recommendation to terminate the contract." Unis spend the savings on #openaccess and doc delivery. openaccess.blogg.kb.se/2018/10/11/100-days-post-cancellat…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber
Another reason to make #climate research #openaccess (apart from access, quality, transparency, reproducibility, & informed policy): Putting it behind paywalls feeds the conspiracy theory that the consensus is just the result a scientific echo chamber. www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/99narx/climate_change_d…
Peter Suber (@petersuber@fediscience.org)@petersuber