I wish I could carry you around with me to debate physicalists
Philip Goff (philosopher)
Philip Goff (born 1978) is a British author, panpsychist philosopher, and professor at Durham University whose research focuses on philosophy of mind and consciousness. Specifically, it focuses on how consciousness can be part of the scientific worldview. Goff holds that materialism is "incoherent" and that dualism leads to "complexity, discontinuity and mystery". Instead, he advocates a "third way", a version of Russellian monism that attempts to account for reality's intrinsic nature by positing that consciousness is a fundamental, ubiquitous feature of the physical world. "The basic commitment is that the fundamental constituents of reality—perhaps electrons and quarks—have incredibly simple forms of experience." More on Wikipedia
-
Philip Goff reposted
مُحب للرئيس عبدالفتاح السيسي
@Very_Sagacious
-
Philip Goff reposted
David Chalmers
@davidchalmers42
congrats to @berggruenInst for awarding the 2026 prize for philosophy and culture to tom nagel.
berggruen.org/eu/news/usd1-million-berggruen-philosophy-p… -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I used to work with Russell Brand. In the recent Netflix documentary "Russell Brand: Open Secret," it refers to the language school on Oxford Street where Brand worked in his early 20s. I worked there too during the summer when I was an undergrad. I was a shy 19 year old and knew him as Russell the slightly intimidating extrovert. I chatted to him a bit in the pub on Friday night, but I tended to be sitting in the corner with a few friends while he was nearby dominating a bigger group.
Many years later and completely unrelatedly, I went on his podcast to talk about panpsychism, obviously completely unaware of the horrific things he'd done. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I used to work with Russell Brand. In the recent Netflix documentary "Russell Brand: Open Secret," it refers to the language school on Oxford Street where Brand worked in his early 20s. I worked there too during the summer when I was an undergrad. I was a shy 19 year old and knew him as Russell the slightly intimidating extrovert. I chatted to him a bit in the pub on Friday night, but I tended to be sitting in the corner with a few friends while he was nearby dominating a bigger group.
Many years later and completely unrelatedly, I went on his podcast to talk about panpsychism, obviously completely unaware of the horrific things he'd done. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Correlation and reduction are very different things.
Chris Rourk
@ChrisJRourk
That is not true. There is a large body of cognitive neuroscience data that shows that there are neural correlates of "feelings." See, e.g. Machado, Leonardo, and Amaury Cantilino. "A systematic review of the neural correlates of positive emotions." Revista Brasileira de Psiquiatria 39.02 (2016): 172-179.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
1. If physicalism is true, I am a mechanism.
2. Mechanisms don't have feelings.
3. I have feelings.
4. Therefore, I'm not a mechanism.
5. Therefore, physicalism as false.
Lots to debate on each premise, but in some sense I think it's as simple as that. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
you're missing a premise...
Mishka
@mishapathy
1. If physicalism is true, I am a mechanism.
2. I have feelings.
3. Therefore, some mechanisms have feelings. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
For those wanting the full argument supporting these premises...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
1. If physicalism is true, I am a mechanism.
2. Mechanisms don't have feelings.
3. I have feelings.
4. Therefore, I'm not a mechanism.
5. Therefore, physicalism as false.
Lots to debate on each premise, but in some sense I think it's as simple as that. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Sure, it's the start of the argument rather than the argument itself. But it's a good way to frame the core intuition of my camp:
You can't reduce a feeling to a pattern of behaviour. And ultimately physical science is exclusively a story about patterns of behaviour.
Jonathan Colvin
@ColvinJonathan
2) begs the question
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
1. If physicalism is true, I am a mechanism.
2. Mechanisms don't have feelings.
3. I have feelings.
4. Therefore, I'm not a mechanism.
5. Therefore, physicalism as false.
Lots to debate on each premise, but in some sense I think it's as simple as that. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's cool the Pope is engaging in a sophisticated way with the cutting-edge ethical/technological issues of our time.
Pope Leo XIV
@Pontifex
Today, the promises of transhumanism and posthumanism are multiplying. These are ideological currents according to which, sooner or later, technology will eliminate all disease and pain, as well as aging and even death itself. Precisely because scientific progress is a supreme achievement of human intelligence, it must not be confused with a privilege reserved for millionaires seeking immortality, while entire peoples suffer from poverty and oppression. In the face of this mirage, which promotes the illusion of human beings perfected by cybernetics and biotechnology, Christian anthropology reminds us that a limitation is not a manufacturing defect, but rather the very condition of human grandeur. #apostolicjourney #peru #magnificahumanitas www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/events/event.dir.html/c…
-
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
I absolutely hate it when non-philosophers talk about philosophy. The only thing I hate more is when philosophers talk about philosophy.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Religion = spirituality + community.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Religion = spirituality + community.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I couldn't work out why our shopping was so expensive this week. I put it down to cost of living crisis. It turns out I'd accidentally ordered 40 bags of frozen chips, coming to over hundred quid. Fortunately the delivery guy was amused and able to refund. 🤣
Nice to have some light moments in challenging times. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I couldn't work out why our shopping was so expensive this week. I put it down to cost of living crisis. It turns out I'd accidentally ordered 40 bags of frozen chips, coming to over hundred quid. Fortunately the delivery guy was amused and able to refund. 🤣
Nice to have some light moments in challenging times. -
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
People often say that studying philosophy is useless. I beg to differ. I've found it very useful for annoying my friends and alienating all my loved ones.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've decided to invent a new area of philosophy: progressive philosophy of religion.
-
Philip Goff reposted
BookAuthority
@bookauthority
A case for panpsychism, from @Philip_Goff. "Galileo's Error" is #4 on BookAuthority's list of the best philosophy of mind books of all time. bookauthority.org/books/best-philosophy-of-mind-books?t=u…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've decided to invent a new area of philosophy: progressive philosophy of religion.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Article on me and @keithfrankish in this month's @DiscoverMag!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Article on me and @keithfrankish in this month's @DiscoverMag!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
Elizabeth Anscombe on Ludwig Wittgenstein, her old teacher at Cambridge:
“He had an extraordinary understanding of why people thought the things that they did think in philosophical argument, so that when he undermined it, his undermining showed that he was getting at the nerve, the root. It was not a superficial refutation.” -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My Trump mask didn't look like Trump but it scared the hell out of my kids 😂
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thanks for all the recommendations!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What's a good accessible book on the history of the scientific revolution?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What's a good accessible book on the history of the scientific revolution?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
that thing where wires get really knotted in your pocket
Emerson Green
@waldenpod
Writing a contribution to philosophy of religion. What random phenomenon should I argue is more likely on theism than naturalism?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Cameron Bertuzzi
@CapturingChrist
Btw, Catholicism is true.
-
Philip Goff reposted
David Chalmers
@davidchalmers42
"three reasons why AI isn't conscious." really?
"consciousness is not intelligence": not a reason why AI isn't conscious, just rebuts a bad argument for AI consciousness (AI: intelligent therefore conscious).
"consciousness is substrate-dependent"/"noncomputational": would be a reason if true, but truth needs to be established.
more accurate title: "three reasons why AI might not be conscious".
nature
@Nature
LLMs can mimic thought and feeling with uncanny skill, but intelligence alone is not enough for subjective experience
go.nature.com/3VSXWQ4 -
Philip Goff reposted
Alastair Roberts
@zugzwanged
It is what he would have wanted.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Ralph Stefan Weir
@RalphStefanWeir
“Privacy” is a handy term for gesturing at a feature of consciousness which seems obvious and important but whose existence immediately closes off a large part of the logical space of physicalist theories. 1/6
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The toughest objection to panpsychism conclusively dealt with here. Any others?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=t87l_VKlA-E -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The toughest objection to panpsychism conclusively dealt with here. Any others?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=t87l_VKlA-E -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
great piece, congrats again!
Samuel
@KimptonNye
This piece won the 2025 "Panpsychism in the Public Sphere" competition as part of @Philip_Goff and Andrei Buckareff's Panpsychism and Pan(en)theism project: sites.google.com/view/panpsychismandpanentheism/essay-com…
Samuel
@KimptonNye
Is everything conscious? Is there a *reason* for everything? What are the aims of philosophy? (Bonus: what's the meaning of life?!) I wrote about these issues for @aeonmag aeon.co/essays/does-the-principle-of-sufficient-reason-ma…
-
Philip Goff reposted
Samuel
@KimptonNye
This piece won the 2025 "Panpsychism in the Public Sphere" competition as part of @Philip_Goff and Andrei Buckareff's Panpsychism and Pan(en)theism project: sites.google.com/view/panpsychismandpanentheism/essay-com…
Samuel
@KimptonNye
Is everything conscious? Is there a *reason* for everything? What are the aims of philosophy? (Bonus: what's the meaning of life?!) I wrote about these issues for @aeonmag aeon.co/essays/does-the-principle-of-sufficient-reason-ma…
-
Philip Goff reposted
Layman Comics
@LaymanComics
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It turns out my religious beliefs are 7.7% likely to be true! That's enough for me. 😁
Nevin Climenhaga
@NevinClimenhaga
I asked it what implications this exercise has on the probabilities of different world religions. It cautioned that it hadn't considered a lot of relevant evidence there but gave me this chart as its current assessment, which gives 45.2% to some form of Christianity (something like @Philip_Goff's version gets 7.7%).
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A feeling is essentially defined by how it feels, just as a triangle is essentially defined by having three sides.
jakkun
@jakkun543833
I know what a feeling feels like, I don't know what it is.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
When I talk about "consciousness", I'm talking about states essentially defined by how they feel/what it's like to have them.
Henry Shevlin
@dioscuri
It's more than a feeling
(More than a feeeeeling) -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It really irritates me when people "We don't know what consciousness is." You know what a feeling is when you feel it!
Ralph Stefan Weir
@RalphStefanWeir
Consciousness is a great mystery. Its definifion isn't. www.theintrinsicperspective.com/p/consciousness-is-a-grea…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It really irritates me when people "We don't know what consciousness is." You know what a feeling is when you feel it!
Ralph Stefan Weir
@RalphStefanWeir
Consciousness is a great mystery. Its definifion isn't. www.theintrinsicperspective.com/p/consciousness-is-a-grea…
-
Philip Goff reposted
Bentham's Bulldog🔸
@Benthamsbulldog
This is not the hard problem. The hard problem is that physics explains the world in terms of structure and function--in terms of behavior of increasing complexity. But even very complex behavior and structure and function is just a fundamentally different thing from consciousness, which involves irreducible what-it's-likeness. Even after you've explained the behavior of every particle in the universe, there's still an explanatory gap--you still don't know what's being experienced.
🐾Eneasz Brodski
@EneaszWrites
the "Hard Problem" in a nutshell:
1. atoms aren't conscious
2. humans are made of atoms
3. humans are conscious
4. so at least one of 1-3 must be false
Panpsychists say #1 is false
Dualists say #2 is false
Illusionists say #3 is false
Materialists say #4 is false -
Philip Goff reposted
Jonathan Birch
@birchlse
Strange to think that when "The Matrix" was made, no one knew matrix multiplication would be the foundation of all future AI. It was just a "matrix" in the sense of a womb or a substrate in which structures are embedded, and its being made of numbers was a visual pun.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You know when a philosophical debate is so well-trodden you think nobody could say anything new...what a fascinating and novel response to the problem of evil...
Amos Wollen 🦐🪰🌱
@goingawoll
This looks like such a banger
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You know when a philosophical debate is so well-trodden you think nobody could say anything new...what a fascinating and novel response to the problem of evil...
Amos Wollen 🦐🪰🌱
@goingawoll
This looks like such a banger
-
Philip Goff reposted
Bentham's Bulldog🔸
@Benthamsbulldog
New rule: people should take at least one class on philosophy of mind before talking about AI consciousness.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I WOULD SELL MY GRANDMOTHER FOR THIS
Banjo Skeptic
@BanjoAtheist
Philip, would your dignity allow you to start making sales videos on X for fancy photocopies of the earliest hints of panpsychism amongst the pre-Socratic?
(Sean is not selling anything ancient, BTW. Just facsimiles.) -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's been on my to do list for ages to leave the Labour party. I probably would have never round to it, but it's now removed from my to do list.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yes again, a Christian fundamentalist who values culture wars over what the bible says:
Peter 3: 15 Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with *gentleness and respect*...
Michael
@Michael00153
'I reckon there is a huge number of people out there with this combination of views: mysticism, theism, and liberal ethics. But this kind of position isn’t represented much in the public conversation.'
New age soup vibes for chit chat crowd -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Best interview I've ever seen with @skdh. Check out her reflections on panpsychism.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8pqx93Vxf4&t=5s -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
good point about being staged...I'm afraid this has revealed me to be a bit gullible... 🤣
JohnnyLaird
@JohnnyLaird
I'm still not entirely sure if this was legit or staged, but either way, Ed seems like a good guy :-)
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Whatever your politics, @Ed_Miliband's a nice guy.
megan
@labournista
I would die for him
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
As a Christian who rejects biblical inerrancy, I can just ignore the bits of the bible that seem inconsistent with the radical social message of Jesus.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Where to start with this... 🤣
Limit and Mind
@limitandmind
I'm not a fan of this "I'm in the enlightened middle" approach.
It's almost always just a cover for raging progressivism.
>>I'm so progressive that I simply pick and choose what I like from God's word.<<
The definition of building your house on the sand.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
As a Christian who rejects biblical inerrancy, I can just ignore the bits of the bible that seem inconsistent with the radical social message of Jesus.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I didn't say I reject inerrancy because there are bits I don't like. I reject inerrancy because I don't see any reason to believe it.
Maurice McCracken
@Mos_aic
At least you are honest. Most people who reject inerrancy say it's for some spurious reason when, in fact, there are just bits that say things they don't like.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yes, although I have a slightly non-standard understanding of the resurrection.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-saZeBAug7k&t=1s
Edenede B
@theoctobear
Do you believe Christ was the Messiah who died and rose again?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Actually it's historical judgement, e.g. I ignore the nasty things about women in the Pauline letters most scholars think Paul didn't write.
James Garavan
@JamesGaravan
You should know that it is your ideological commitments that motivate you "ignoring the parts of the bible" that don't fit your system. That is a far more hijacked framework than a biblical one.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
As a Christian who rejects biblical inerrancy, I can just ignore the bits of the bible that seem inconsistent with the radical social message of Jesus.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My Worse Performance Ever.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The Chinese room is really just a way of making vivid the intuition that you need consciousness for genuine understanding.
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
I do really hate the Chinese Room
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
What are some of the worst philosophical arguments of all time?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My Worse Performance Ever.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The ontological argument
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
What are some of the worst philosophical arguments of all time?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
In the midst of very challenging life circumstances, I woke up somehow feeling very positive this morning. When my alarm went off, I was having a very vivid dream that I was struggling to find somewhere to have lunch in a big city. Not sure if these two things are connected.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Bentham's Bulldog🔸
@Benthamsbulldog
Wow, so brave, you sneered on the internet at a counterintuitive conclusion without addressing the arguments for it.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Miles K. Donahue
@PhilosopherMKD
Personally, I think @RandalRauser has offered a more compelling, morally grounded vision of Christianity than just about anyone else working in this space.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I find in @RandalRauser someone driven by a deep moral seriousness.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I find in @RandalRauser someone driven by a deep moral seriousness.
-
Philip Goff reposted
The Rest Is Politics
@RestIsPolitics
How @Ed_Miliband's late mum was at the forefront of his mind during his statement on Israel-Palestine.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm in this!
Alex Strasser
@AStrasser116
Stumbled on this recent book in my university library!
Featuring contributions from @Philip_Goff @majestyofreason @SpeedWatkins @DoloresGMorris @worldviewdesign @robkoons Dan Linford, Alex Malpass, Robin Collins, David Enoch, and more! -
Philip Goff reposted
David Chalmers
@davidchalmers42
worrying about recursive self-improvement on australian TV (lateline) in 1996.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
People think I am against continental philosophy. I'm not. I believe continental philosophy should be safe, legal, and rare.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How plausible do you find scientology?
Paul
@PabloSt981
Catholicism is a complex of traditions/interpretations/ideas/beliefs; a comparison between hallucination and Catholicism makes no sense, like saying being high is more plausible than liberalism.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
There's a deep irony here. My offendee is judging belief in psychic powers ridiculous, and thus interpreting me as saying their belief is ridiculous in being even less plausible than psychic powers.
Here's an idea: maybe we could engage respectfully with both beliefs.
Eve Keneinan 𝛗☦️ن
@EveKeneinan
That is a disingenuous defense.
You did not merely say you found it implausible. You said you find it so implausible as to be less plausible than an obvious absurdity.
The direct implication of what you said is that those who do not find Catholicism absurd are very stupid. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thank you for your kind prayer. I will also pray that you come to understand the epistemic humility that is appropriate to the human condition God made for us. God bless.
Ford Prefect
@FordP100
Father, I entrust Philip Goff to You.
You know him completely. You know what he seeks, what he loves, what he fears, what he sees clearly, and what he cannot yet see. You know where his reasoning is sound and where pride, fear, attachment, woundedness, cultural assumptions, or error may cloud his judgment.
Give him the grace to desire truth above all else, even when truth costs him something. Where he is right, deepen his understanding. Where he is mistaken, correct him. Where his deepest assumptions prevent him from recognizing what is true, expose them to the light.
Do not allow intelligence, philosophical sophistication, moral certainty, or attachment to his own understanding to become barriers between him and You.
Give him the humility to recognize that his thoughts are not Your thoughts and his ways are not Your ways. Renew his mind so that he may discern what is good, pleasing, and perfect.
Above all, reveal your Son, Jesus Christ to him not as another philosophical possibility to evaluate, but as the Way, the Truth, and the Life.
Holy Spirit, illuminate his intellect, purify his conscience, soften his heart, and give him the courage to follow truth wherever it leads.
Our Lady of Fatima, pray for him.
Amen. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I agree but that's not that happened. People saw funny things happen to the sun.
Lazynewsupdates
@Lazynewsupdate1
I would push back on it not being disrespectful just being bizarre. I havent looked at Catholic miracle claims, but If the stars aligned and said "submit to Rome" Im submitting to Rome! Surely nothing good comes from thinking we are THAT epistemically screwed!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The complaints were from academic philosophers on Facebook
Ivan Stoner
@ivan_stoner
I spun through quite a few replies to the tweet/substack & couldn't find a one arguing the title (or any part it) is offensive.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Ah, I see. Sorry, I didn't realise you've just one of those people who just can't handle respectful engagement with people you disagree with.
SED
@sed13949
Who is offended? I am saying that what you wrote is laughable and, if Catholicism is true, potentially very harmful.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It seems my offendees are judging psychic powers obviously ridiculous, and then getting offended at the claim that their religion is less plausible that something obviously ridiculous.
My solution: Let's treat all of these views respectfully. Disagreement is not disrespect.
SED
@sed13949
My impression was that like 99% of complaints were about the laughable content, not the title.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've had a lot of pushback on the title of this being offensive.
Surely it's okay for a philosopher to say on their blog they find Catholicism implausible.
Disagreement doesn't mean disrespect.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Telepathic Mass Hallucination is More Plausible than Catholicism.
A brief response to @majestyofreason 's recent conversion.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Depends whether, like my religion, they were set up because the king wanted a divorce and the Pope wouldn't let him have it.
I think my religion is the One True Faith for that reason: you can believe what the fuck you want.
Brian Hetke
@HetkeBrian
Religions are really good at that.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Another way of achieving Christian unity: We all just chill out and agree to disagree.
Cameron Bertuzzi
@CapturingChrist
God wants unity among Christians. The way forward, at least for Eastern Orthodox, is to accept that the Council of Florence was ecumenical and binding. The schism ended.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Blackwell's, Oxford’s Bookshop
@blackwelloxford
A very special sold out event with @Philip_Goff and @RowanWInfo Rowan Williams discussing 'Why? The Purpose of the Universe' @blackwellbooks
-
Philip Goff reposted
𝕸𝖚𝖘𝖎𝖈 𝕷𝖔𝖛𝖊𝖗 𝕷𝖔𝖛𝖊
@Beauferal
@RowanWInfo with @Philip_Goff talking about Philip's book 'Why? The Purpose of the Universe' @blackwelloxford
I now have some reading by both to see me through these colder months.
Rowan recommended his ‘The Edge of Words’.
The search begins! 🥳 -
Philip Goff reposted
Hans Heymans
@haanzon
If you want unconditional love, transform into a chocolate bar.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I offend the atheists and all the theists love me. Then I offend the theists and all the atheists love me. I wish everyone loved me and thought I was completely right. 😂
dore
@MorningPages_
I'm back on the Goff train babyyyyyy!!!!!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You didn't read closely enough. It's a short article.
Can anyone else tell us the reasons I gave for thinking telepathic mass hallucination more plausible than Catholicism?
Eve Keneinan 𝛗☦️ن
@EveKeneinan
I wouldn't bother.
There's no philosophical substance here. It is simply a self-report on the fact that Philip Goff finds "a child had Professor X-like telepathic powers and used them to induce a mass hallucination" to be a more plausible explanation of a mass Marian apparition than the Catholic explanation.
No reasons are given for why he thinks this, making it nothing more than a psychological self-report. It is left unexplained why Goff thinks comic book super powers are "more plausible" than supernatural appearance by the Mother of God.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Some light Sunday morning reading.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Telepathic Mass Hallucination is More Plausible than Catholicism.
A brief response to @majestyofreason 's recent conversion.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Some light Sunday morning reading.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Telepathic Mass Hallucination is More Plausible than Catholicism.
A brief response to @majestyofreason 's recent conversion.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Telepathic Mass Hallucination is More Plausible than Catholicism.
A brief response to @majestyofreason 's recent conversion.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Telepathic Mass Hallucination is More Plausible than Catholicism.
A brief response to @majestyofreason 's recent conversion.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
What is Panpsychism? | Rupert Sheldrake, Donald Hoffman, Phillip Goff, J... youtu.be/B7KaNnFij2Q via @YouTube
Great overview on panpsychism from @Philip_Goff @donalddhoffman @IAI_TV -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A Short Pause.
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A Short Pause.
Link below & in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Post not available here, view on X
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think this is a good representation of the worst forms of each.
Anna Gát
@TheAnnaGat
Oh noooo WHY IS THIS SO TRUE
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
For one thing, I think gay Catholic children are harmed by this.
David Matcham
@d_matcham
You do know that being catholic is voluntary, right? It's hard to see how anyone choosing to be a catholic is being harmed by the things Catholics choose to believe. Even if it is "harmful", they could always opt out. No one has a gun to their head.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Possibility 1: I'm obsessed with gay happiness, fixated in way Christians are fixated with Christ. It's an unhealthy obsession.
Possibility 2: I sincerely believe Catholic teaching on sexuality is false and harmful, but I don't think about it very much
Answers on a postcard.
Brandon DeRousse
@BrandonDeRousse
I’m not Catholic, but this is concerning. It’s almost like it’s an idol for you. Gay happiness is Lord, rather than Jesus is Lord.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's not me. I'm still worried about the gay stuff.
Cameron Bertuzzi
@CapturingChrist
This week I'm interviewing yet ANOTHER philosopher that converted to Catholicism on the basis of miracles. More announcements coming soon.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
this time 15 years ago I was having a sandwich
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't know why everyone in this discussion keeps assuming I'm a utilitarian and/or a subjectivist. Just because you care about people's happiness doesn't mean you think happiness is the only important thing!
Kifle Od Kajmaka
@KiflaKajmak
True, but don't grant him harm based 'morality'. They just came about and thought up their own worldview, with their own axioms and standards, but kept using our nomenclature. Now we're debating the correct 'ethics' when it isn't even up for discussion in that way.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I was thinking all the arguments for the sinfullness of gay were terrible..but no one told me about this one! 😂
"Eacho" (EACCO) ✝️🌐🆗🆓🇺🇸 (nee realBarneyFife)
@Nee_Nihilo
Male masturbation is obv incorrect
So obv male masturbation with other males is incorrect as well -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are you flirting with me? 😍
I am Gaius Julius Caesar
@PageLyndon
When do 'you' think Goff is going to realize the greatest thinker in history is laughing at his parochial mindset while he maintains pretense to knowledge and authority.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Fanbojsy
@FanBojsy
Gay guy here. Phillip is absolutely spot on. I cannot easily seperate my sexual orientation from pretty much every aspect of my social life. Saying that gay sex is disordered is functionally identical to saying that I am as a person disordered and "not oriented towards the good"
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm cool with making people less happy if there's a good reason (e.g. you're only happy if you kill people). But I don't think there is a reason for the Catholic church's command to gay people to be less happy.
Eve Keneinan 𝛗☦️ن
@EveKeneinan
This can be true of any vice.
Sometimes murderers mark themselves with tattoos to signify this "identity." -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Who's up for a Saturday night debate???
Not me, I've got to put the kids to bed 😂
I might fit in a few responses while I'm waiting for the younger to fall asleep...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Don't worry, Steve, you're not disordered.
"It's just the orientation that forms a core part of your identity, & the way you feel naturally inclined to express your deep love and commitment to your romantic partner, that are disordered."
A distinction without a difference.
Majesty of Reason
@majestyofreason
Randal, I love you. Please do better. Nowhere did I claim “gay people are disordered”. You are publicly misrepresenting me. Intrinsically non-procreative sex *acts* and *desires* are disordered in the sense that they are directed away from the good — they’re morally misdirected.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Fair enough, I think the Catholic church errs in their ethical judgement here too. Two wrongs don't make a right!
Doctor Subtilis
@thesubtledoctor
OK, but you could say that about most heterosexual people too. I mean by this definition the use of condoms is equally disordered and birth control probably even more so.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If someone thought I had to live separate from the British culture that makes me feel happy and comfortable (that makes me feels myself) without good reason, I'd think they were wrong in their moral judgement. The Catholic church makes an analogous moral error wrt gay people.
The Anglo-Europeanist
@europhilosopher
But where’s the problem? No one is saying you can’t be a British Catholic (let’s not got there…), and so you can also be a gay Catholic, you just can’t act upon it the same way a polygamist can’t act on his true desires.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Sexuality isn't part of one's 'identity' in the sense of metaphysical essence.
But it's often part of a person's 'identity' in the sense of deep and important ways of understanding oneself. A bit like national identity. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Don't worry, Steve, you're not disordered.
"It's just the orientation that forms a core part of your identity, & the way you feel naturally inclined to express your deep love and commitment to your romantic partner, that are disordered."
A distinction without a difference.
Majesty of Reason
@majestyofreason
Randal, I love you. Please do better. Nowhere did I claim “gay people are disordered”. You are publicly misrepresenting me. Intrinsically non-procreative sex *acts* and *desires* are disordered in the sense that they are directed away from the good — they’re morally misdirected.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Paul Douglas Moomjean
@themoomabides
When mom says we have Taco Bell at home.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Emerson Green
@waldenpod
This is what every single day is like as a panpsychist
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I didn't think of that...maybe I'll give it another go!
Jabran A-L 🦧🍻
@JabranALee
@Philip_Goff, might it be that they were just bad kissers? 😂
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I was recently interviewed on one of my fave podcasts 'Wonder Cabinet', on panpsychism, religion, and psychedelic experiences.
If you want to listen to it, you can. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
flattery always reposted
Marginal Merit
@MarginalMerit
Philip Goff, a man after my own heart. You are too funny
-
Philip Goff reposted
Konstantin Dmitrievich Levin
@Konstantin_Levn
Goff your takes on Christianity are the best. 🙏👍👍👍
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Much appreciated @CapturingChrist. Let's have a civilized chat about this objection to Catholicism some time.
In answer to your question: I kissed a couple of my male friends when I was a teenager but decided it wasn't really for me.
Cameron Bertuzzi
@CapturingChrist
A couple days ago, @Philip_Goff mentioned shock at Joe's conversion, to which I replied, in jest, that it's time for him to submit to Rome.
Philip then gave a reply to that claiming that Catholic teaching on homosexuality is, in his words, "manifestly false." From my perspective, this is a bad reason to reject Catholicism. However, instead of responding seriously to his objection, I jokingly asked if he was gay (knowing, of course, that he's not).
Lots of people were offended by this, and I get why. It was in bad taste. Nor was it Christ-like. I just wanted to quickly pop on and apologize to Philip, to others that follow me, and/or those of you that were offended. I will do better in the future to model Christ's example. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Finally I get the respect I deserve!
Tom Hockel
@BowieTheus
Pope Philip has spoken.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Alex Strasser
@AStrasser116
What are we doing here?
I don't think this is an appropriate response, no matter what your beliefs are or if they're justified or true -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Orthodox Christians changed their mind about loaning money being sinful, as economic understanding advanced.
Why can't they change their mind about gay sex being sinful, as understanding of human sexuality advances?
Bethel McGrew
@BMcGrewvy
This is question-begging. Yes there are people who attend places that call themselves Christian churches while rejecting the traditional sexual ethic, but orthodox Christians would say that's a heresy, no less than denying Jesus' divinity or the resurrection.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Our disagreement is that I don't think God does think gay sex is sinful.
Edenede B
@theoctobear
As soon as you put yourself above God's word, you are no longer Christian in anything but name.
You don't get to decide what is good and what is sinful by thinking about it and deciding. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I reject your implicit claim that there is a single thing 'Christianity' teaches here. Christians used to think it was sinful to loan money; now they don't. Likewise, these days many Christians reject the idea that gay sex is sinful.
Glen Scrivener
@glenscrivener
Xianity preaches one sexual ethic for all. It’s radically egalitarian as well as restrictive but if sex matters, that fits, right?
If you were convinced by a worldview that says ‘nothing really matters’ I think u’d follow the evidence. This worldview says ‘Sex really matters.’🤷♂️ -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Sin=spiritual dysfunction. A loving gay relationship is a beautiful part of God's creation.
LEGO Joseph Smith
@Mormonger
Big fan of yours.
I'm curious how you define "sin"
And why wouldn't gay sex fit the definition?
Thank you. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I always retweet flattery.
Konstantin Dmitrievich Levin
@Konstantin_Levn
Love you Phillip Goff. “Why” is an awesome book.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm not black but I don't like racism against black people.
Cameron Bertuzzi
@CapturingChrist
Are you gay?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
One issue is the belief that gay sex is sinful is manifestly false and harmful. I like the incense though.
Cameron Bertuzzi
@CapturingChrist
It's time for you to submit to Rome.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Wow. Didn't see this coming.
Majesty of Reason
@majestyofreason
I just converted to Catholicism! Here’s my story:
youtu.be/-C-FiSqfKi8 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The scientific data of consciousness exclusively concerns correlations between consciousness we can't see & brain activity we can.
Panpsychists and physicalists both propose theories of why those correlations obtain.
Hence, different theories but exactly same predictions.
Natesh
@x_tambram
What is a specific prediction or even a measurement that a theory of consciousness based on panpsychism is willing to make or think we should make? Bonus if it only comes from starting at a panpsychiet metaphysics.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Exactly same way a physicalist does. Cool illusion!
Colin Mangan
@ColinMangan_TGC
@Philip_Goff how does an anti-physical theory of consciousness explain this illusion?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The scientific data of consciousness exclusively concerns correlations between consciousness we can't see & brain activity we can.
Panpsychists and physicalists both propose theories of why those correlations obtain.
Hence, different theories but exactly same predictions.
Natesh
@x_tambram
What is a specific prediction or even a measurement that a theory of consciousness based on panpsychism is willing to make or think we should make? Bonus if it only comes from starting at a panpsychiet metaphysics.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Exactly same way a physicalist does. Cool illusion!
Colin Mangan
@ColinMangan_TGC
@Philip_Goff how does an anti-physical theory of consciousness explain this illusion?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The problem is this is itself a philosophical theory.
Cheveyo
@Cheveyoakio
Philosophical theories are based on pattern recognition derived from individual lived experience; self-awareness integrates the result as a conviction. All "neutral" data are then categorized accordingly. By analogy, a survey on abortion can never yield a neutral result.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
erm...I asked for data not opinion...
Elliott Not-So-Sober
@Leophilius
All of the empirical data of cognitive science.
Smell is physical.
Touch is physical.
So is hearing.
Vision.
Taste.
Reasoning.
Introspection.
Memory.
There is no facet of consciousness currently understood that isn't physical. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What do you think is the empirical data that counts in favour of one of these theories over the others?
Elliott Not-So-Sober
@Leophilius
The scientific data is *not* neutral between these philosophical theses and anybody who asserts that it is betrays their ignorance of cognitive science.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physicalism, dualism, panpsychism, and idealism are *philosophical theories*.
The scientific data on consciousness is, and always will be, neutral between all of these.
It's like asking: How can we test experimentally the thesis that abortion is morally permissible?
Thomas Pickney
@thomaspickney8
Are there any testable hypotheses that have been suggested for either Panpsychism or Idealism?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physicalism, dualism, panpsychism, and idealism are *philosophical theories*.
The scientific data on consciousness is, and always will be, neutral between all of these.
It's like asking: How can we test experimentally the thesis that abortion is morally permissible?
Thomas Pickney
@thomaspickney8
Are there any testable hypotheses that have been suggested for either Panpsychism or Idealism?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
wtf
I am Gaius Julius Caesar
@PageLyndon
God and the primacy of the phenomenological given have no place in intellectual thought, especially in philosophical reflection and history.
Goff is as embarrassing to the academy as Arday was. The failure is in the pronouncement of 'i am', in which Goff must hide his godself. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Science concerns empirical data.
The task of philosophy is synthesis: Taking the empirical data and other ways of knowing & synthesising them into a single, unified theory of reality.
Samuel Loncar | Accelerating Scientific Progress
@SamuelLoncar
You don’t think science and philosophy overlap? Do you also think a clear demarcation exists between them?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The former but not the latter.
Carl Gunnar Fossdal
@BiolNor
Are you saying that Science and philosophy do not overlap, and that these two never ever can overlap/converge?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
When there’s a disagreement, I think the best option is to engage in calm and careful discussion.
What are the premises of your argument? Which do I agree with and which do I disagree with?
An alternative approach, however is: YOU’RE AN IDIOT BECAUSE YOU DON'T HAVE MY VIEW 😂
I am Gaius Julius Caesar
@PageLyndon
'I am' special, the misguided ape told him self.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I used to think that but I don't now. The systems are too complex. In fact, I'm thinking/talking a lot at the moment about how this could be tested empirically...
Counter Apologist
@CounterApologis
More seriously - I think on that theory of dualism we would be quibbling over semantics. Still, I believe that physical science would be able to falsify/detect that type of dualism! We'd find those new forces and the new "mental substance", no?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Counter Apologist
@CounterApologis
I would like to let you know that because of you and @waldenpod I've at least become agnostic pilled on panpsychism or even this kind of dualism on consideration. I still think physicalism is still just as live an option though.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It depends how we define 'physical'. I think of it as the view that fundamental reality can be entirely captured in the purely quantitative language of physical science.
It's consistent to hold both of the following:
(A) consciousness can't be entirely captured in the language of physical science
(B) consciousness interacts with the physical world in a law-governed way.
Counter Apologist
@CounterApologis
I would love your thoughts on this: If law-governed dualism didn't violate conservation of energy then doesn't the physical act like a "tether", so if the mental substance interacts law like in energy transfer w/ the brain, then that mental substance is arguably physical!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Libertarian free will violates conservation of energy, but law-governed dualism need not.
See Jonathan Emery's excellent PhD thesis, from KCL.
Counter Apologist
@CounterApologis
Presumably physicalism and dualism at least are in principle falsifiable if we had precise enough equipment.
We could in principle observe violation of conservation of energy as the non-physical mind would causally interact with the physical brain, no? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physicalism, dualism, panpsychism, and idealism are *philosophical theories*.
The scientific data on consciousness is, and always will be, neutral between all of these.
It's like asking: How can we test experimentally the thesis that abortion is morally permissible?
Thomas Pickney
@thomaspickney8
Are there any testable hypotheses that have been suggested for either Panpsychism or Idealism?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't do the thumbnails. 😂
Lit-Wit
@simonjjacobson
Stamping your image with ‘False’ is quite the confession 😂
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
THE BIG NEWS EVERYBODY IS TALKING ABOUT!!!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Panpsychism Debunked??
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
cynthia ford
@cynthiafor46969
My friend worked on the line at Ford in Detroit while going to UDetroit. The line stopped for long intervals, so he would read, which was against the rules. A line boss caught him, put his boot on his head, and told him to stop. Book was B.F. Skinner, Beyond Freedom and Dignity.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
THE BIG NEWS EVERYBODY IS TALKING ABOUT!!!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Panpsychism Debunked??
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
David Chalmers
@davidchalmers42
an analysis of anthropic's "J-space": is it a global workspace and does it have the key features of access consciousness? (spoiler: not quite.)
philpapers.org/rec/CHAITJ-2
on whether J-space is a global workspace:
1. The "workspace-like" properties of J-space are not distinctive properties of the global workspace theory.
2. The J-space is not a (causal, dedicated, privileged, unified) system.
3. The J-space supports only a limited form of broadcast.
4. The J-space lacks other key computational features of the global workspace including modules, recurrent processing, and others.
on whether J-space has the key features of access consciousness (n.b. phenomenal consciousness mostly isn't the issue here):
5. Many contents of access consciousness are not verbalizable.
6. What matters for the J-space may not be effects on verbal outputs, but effects on outputs in general.
7. Many verbalizable representations are not access conscious.
8. Verbalizability is not the same as reportability.
overall: the J-space is a powerful tool for interpretability, but its status as a key causal mechanism and as a mechanism of access consciousness remains to be demonstrated. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I proposed to David Bentley Hart a chat on my channel. He replied:
"Oh, I’m a cheap date. Buy me a drink, flash me a smile, and I’m always up for a YouTube conversation."
Would anyone be interested in watching that? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Good point.
Stoyan Kurtev
@SKurtev
And you want people to believe that someone who can't even sort parcels and collect glasses can explain the purpose of the universe? Really?! :) I suppose, that's only possible because the purpose of the universe is in fact a simple question to answer, with the right approach.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Jobs I've held:
Packing for the shopping channel (I got my hand stuck in in the conveyer belt, and had to wait in agony while they unscrewed the belt...)
"Betterware" door-to-door salesman of household appliances (I kept losing the stuff...when I finished, my manager said: "You're a lovely bloke, Phil, but I'm glad you're leaving...")
Supporting people weaving cloth at a factory in Huddersfield (Bloody complicated job! I kept getting in trouble for messing it up...I remember my manager shouting at me "Phil, you haven't timed your cones!")
Postal worker, both delivery and sorting parcels (I was massively bullied by a manager who hated people who'd been to university...)
Serving coffee in 'Upper Crust' (I was too slow...)
Collecting glasses in a social club (I kept missing tables...)
I'm glad I found something I can do in the end!!!
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
Jobs I've held:
• Dishwasher (age 15)
• Gas station clerk (age 16-17)
• Janitor (age 20-21)
• Cashier (age 21-23)
• Cash supervisor (age 23-27)
• Teaching assistant (age 25-28)
• Program assistant (age 28-31)
• Contract instructor (age 29-)
You? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A good example of how philosophy can learn from real world experience.
David Simpson
@DavidSimpsonPhD
Was your hand being stuck what convinced you phenomenal pain couldn’t be an illusion?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"The Fatal Flaw In Our Search for Alien Life." New article in @IAI_TV Worth reading.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Lit-Wit
@simonjjacobson
'I'm glad I found something I can do in the end!!!' And even that's debatable 😂 Sorry couldn't resist
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Jobs I've held:
Packing for the shopping channel (I got my hand stuck in in the conveyer belt, and had to wait in agony while they unscrewed the belt...)
"Betterware" door-to-door salesman of household appliances (I kept losing the stuff...when I finished, my manager said: "You're a lovely bloke, Phil, but I'm glad you're leaving...")
Supporting people weaving cloth at a factory in Huddersfield (Bloody complicated job! I kept getting in trouble for messing it up...I remember my manager shouting at me "Phil, you haven't timed your cones!")
Postal worker, both delivery and sorting parcels (I was massively bullied by a manager who hated people who'd been to university...)
Serving coffee in 'Upper Crust' (I was too slow...)
Collecting glasses in a social club (I kept missing tables...)
I'm glad I found something I can do in the end!!!
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
Jobs I've held:
• Dishwasher (age 15)
• Gas station clerk (age 16-17)
• Janitor (age 20-21)
• Cashier (age 21-23)
• Cash supervisor (age 23-27)
• Teaching assistant (age 25-28)
• Program assistant (age 28-31)
• Contract instructor (age 29-)
You? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think the answer is "yes". 😂
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I proposed to David Bentley Hart a chat on my channel. He replied:
"Oh, I’m a cheap date. Buy me a drink, flash me a smile, and I’m always up for a YouTube conversation."
Would anyone be interested in watching that? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I proposed to David Bentley Hart a chat on my channel. He replied:
"Oh, I’m a cheap date. Buy me a drink, flash me a smile, and I’m always up for a YouTube conversation."
Would anyone be interested in watching that? -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
So philosophers add any value?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is it Immoral that I Ask for Money?
Link below and in Bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
So philosophers add any value?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is it Immoral that I Ask for Money?
Link below and in Bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is it Immoral that I Ask for Money?
Link below and in Bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is it Immoral that I Ask for Money?
Link below and in Bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Escape the Narratives
@ThePrimaryMind
You’re popular, not!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Debunked or not debunked??
Only 3 hours left to decide...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Panpsychism Debunked??
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Iq
@almaududiiqbal
It's destroyed bro pack it up *sarcasm*
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Debunked or not debunked??
Only 3 hours left to decide...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Panpsychism Debunked??
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Panpsychism Debunked??
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Mícheál Ó Dubhlacháin
@michaelod0123
Panpsychism was never bunked in the first place.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Panpsychism Debunked??
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Post not available here, view on X
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This week 2 videos went out of me fighting: one with a theist and one with an atheist. Everybody hates me! 😂
Was I correct in both, neither, or one but not the other?
The theist: William Lane Craig on @RFupdates channel. The atheist: Dan Linford on @skydivephil 's channel. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You can persuade the undecided people watching.
Paul Carter
@jjcrhh
Is arguing with people ever productive, or is it a doomed project?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't think non-philosophers have a problem getting onto this concept through examples.
So many of the philosophical concepts I have to teach undergrads are really hard to get across. But with this one: they get it straight away!
Jonathan Birch
@birchlse
"Define phenomenal consciousness."
"It's that which the states picked out by one's phenomenal concepts have in common."
"No, define it WITHOUT philosophy mumbo jumbo."
"OK, but in return please define electron WITHOUT physics mumbo jumbo like charge, particle or negative." -
Philip Goff reposted
Nigel Warburton 🇺🇦 #FreeUkraine
@philosophybites
Listen to my 2008 interview with Anthony Kenny on Aquila’s. Kenny died 3rd August philosophybites.com/podcast/anthony-kenny-on-aquinas-ethics/
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This week 2 videos went out of me fighting: one with a theist and one with an atheist. Everybody hates me! 😂
Was I correct in both, neither, or one but not the other?
The theist: William Lane Craig on @RFupdates channel. The atheist: Dan Linford on @skydivephil 's channel.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Cool idea!
All of this shit is very uncertain.
Adopting a faith commitment is compatible with great uncertainty about what the hell is going on.
Stefano Bagnolini
@SBagnolini
Why not suppose something as a 'weak' resurrection? Real physical resurrection but non strong enough to persist forever... Ascension, then, is the passage of Jesus to Holy Spirit, in awaiting of his (possible) return at the End of Times.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Important in these polarised times to engage respectfully with people with whom your profoundly disagree.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A respectful and productive discussion of two VERY different interpretations of Christianity.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If we didn't the letters of Paul, we'd be clueless about the origins of Christianity. But given Paul knew the original disciples, this evidence is gold dust by standards of ancient history. Even Bart Ehrman believes Peter, Paul, Mary Magdalene, and probably James, had resurrection visions. I find it hard to understand why Ehrman doesn't add a group experience of the remaining 11 disciples, given it's so well-attested, and Paul refers to it and knew 2 of them personally.
The more significant thing for me is that we need an explanation of the intense and sustained activity promoting the religion over decades, against violent opposition, in the absence of a charismatic leader (like Muhammed or Buddha) who'd had the special experiences himself.
At the end of the day, it's about priors, though. I don't think non-Christians have a satisfying explanation of Christian origins, but if their prior for Christianity is very low (as is the case for me with non-heretical Christianity), this evidence isn't strong enough to get the probability very high.
Will Murphy 🇪🇺
@Aceofspades256
I think one or two of them might have been visions but most of them were likely rumours that grew over time and perhaps even a few false memories.
It's the same with the witnesses to the birth of mormonism. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A respectful and productive discussion of two VERY different interpretations of Christianity.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
Is there consciousness beyond the brain? | Philip Goff | TEDxNewEngland youtu.be/UCxhoqzEaUE via @YouTube
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My favourite response on social media! 😂
Drew Haas
@TheDrewHaas
Now I’m intrigued. Will give it a listen!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Flattery gets you nowhere!
Aletheios
@alethious
Heretic
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm not sure that story in the bible really happened.
Brandon DeRousse
@BrandonDeRousse
So you think Jesus was bluffing to Thomas? Secretly Jesus was thinking, “Please don’t do it. Please don’t do it. You’ll blow my cover. You won’t feel anything. You’re seeing a vision, Thomas. I’m not physically here.”
If Jesus was bluffing, I.e. lying, then that’s probably not Jesus but Satan since he’s the father of lies!
“Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger here, and see my hands; and put out your hand, and place it in my side. Do not disbelieve, but believe.””
John 20:27 ESV
bible.com/bible/59/jhn.20.27.ESV -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think the resurrection experiences of the first Christians were visions, rather than seeing and touching a body.
Gabriel Pereira
@GabrielPer35811
I really enjoyed it!! But I'm still not clear on your view of the resurrection. You said that it was not purely spiritual, wouldn't that imply what what all Christian say, that it was physical? Although the nature of that physicality is up for discussion.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A respectful and productive discussion of two VERY different interpretations of Christianity.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The correct answer to my question.
Mɾιԃυʅ
@VioletStraFish
Yes
-
Philip Goff reposted
Mɾιԃυʅ
@VioletStraFish
Yes
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is it the Job of Science or Philosophy to Explain Consciousness?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
That's kind of what I say, so long as we're happy that there's a non-experimental aspect of science.
Beena Raza
@razabeena
It started with Philopsohy and will surely end up with a scientific explanation .
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is it the Job of Science or Philosophy to Explain Consciousness?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is it the Job of Science or Philosophy to Explain Consciousness?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Jeff Anderson
@JeffAnd78435402
In the end... I think therefore I'm not! 🙆🏻♂️
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Maybe Consciousness Is Not What We Think It Is.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
The Old Man and the (Form of the) Sea
@SpeedWatkins
Illusionists be like:
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Maybe Consciousness Is Not What We Think It Is.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Maybe Consciousness Is Not What We Think It Is.
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
New atheism will be looked back on as a real low point in cultural/intellectual history.
Only Form Holds
@OnlyFormHolds
Atheists now concede:
Dawkins didn’t understand Aquinas.
He strawmanned Christianity.
“Nobody” has read the Summa - meaning them.
They likely still haven’t.
New Atheism beat a caricature of Christianity & declared victory.
It's time to face up to reality & read Aquinas.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I approve.
Wasiq Zia
@wasiqzia_
Thoughts on sufism?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
yeah, I'm not sure which I find more annoying, religious fundamentalists or new atheists
William O’Brien
@No5mallf3at
Is it really going to be looked at worse than the half assed revival of Christianity that is following it?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
There are commonalities, but there are very important ways in which Aquinas developed that intellectual tradition.
Sruli Broocker
@srulibroocker
Aren’t those points also from Maimonides and Aristotle?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
New atheism will be looked back on as a real low point in cultural/intellectual history.
Only Form Holds
@OnlyFormHolds
Atheists now concede:
Dawkins didn’t understand Aquinas.
He strawmanned Christianity.
“Nobody” has read the Summa - meaning them.
They likely still haven’t.
New Atheism beat a caricature of Christianity & declared victory.
It's time to face up to reality & read Aquinas.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Nigel Warburton 🇺🇦 #FreeUkraine
@philosophybites
Just released on the Philosophy Bites podcast: @PeterSinger on Ending Innocent Lives podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/philosophy-bites/id25704211…
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I the only philosophy professor who uses a cat as clickbait?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are the past and the future real?
Is pragmatism a valid philosophy?
What do I think of Alfred North Whitehead's panpsychism?
Great questions in the month's AMA, and you can meet my cat Kiara!!!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Aletheios
@alethious
Based!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Am I a Spacetime Worm?"
Link Below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm absolutely delighted to hear that news that Dr Gaurav Kudtarkar, who recently completed his PhD with me, has got a job as Assistant Professor at RV University in Bangalore. Congratulations Gaurav!
In his PhD, Gaurav defended a novel form of representationalism, which combined Aristotle with the Indian classical philosophy of Nyāya. Link below. -
Philip Goff reposted
Ally Fogg
@AllyFogg
Politics aside this is just objectively funny.
Channel 4 News
@Channel4News
"What, a new one? They keep changing every five minutes."
A care home resident was shocked to meet the new Prime Minister when he paid a visit. As Andy Burnham introduced himself, he was asked by resident Robert whether he was a local candidate. A smiling Burnham responded that he was actually now the PM.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I the only philosophy professor who uses a cat as clickbait?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are the past and the future real?
Is pragmatism a valid philosophy?
What do I think of Alfred North Whitehead's panpsychism?
Great questions in the month's AMA, and you can meet my cat Kiara!!!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Am I a Spacetime Worm?"
Link Below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Counter Apologist
@CounterApologis
If that means you get a badass soundtrack like this, I'm down for it. youtu.be/nLY5GFZumLE
-
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
I can't believe you didn't title this "Would you still love me if I were a space-time worm?"
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Am I a Spacetime Worm?"
Link Below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Worth watching just for the cat (timestamped).
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are the past and the future real?
Is pragmatism a valid philosophy?
What do I think of Alfred North Whitehead's panpsychism?
Great questions in the month's AMA, and you can meet my cat Kiara!!!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Worth watching just for the cat (timestamped).
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are the past and the future real?
Is pragmatism a valid philosophy?
What do I think of Alfred North Whitehead's panpsychism?
Great questions in the month's AMA, and you can meet my cat Kiara!!!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
It's a great privilege to write for @IAI_TV alongside the world's leading thinkers.
I argue that panpsychism doesn’t solve the hard problem of consciousness - it just inverts the traditional problems... and then creates new ones!
iai.tv/articles/panpsychism-does-not-solve-the-hard-probl… -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are the past and the future real?
Is pragmatism a valid philosophy?
What do I think of Alfred North Whitehead's panpsychism?
Great questions in the month's AMA, and you can meet my cat Kiara!!!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are the past and the future real?
Is pragmatism a valid philosophy?
What do I think of Alfred North Whitehead's panpsychism?
Great questions in the month's AMA, and you can meet my cat Kiara!!!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Response coming soon...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQzSqf2-p0s -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Stuck for something to do Saturday night?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Why is Consciousness So Hard to Explain?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Stuck for something to do Saturday night?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Why is Consciousness So Hard to Explain?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Very flattered!
Tannr 🦾🤖
@intent_dev
My list would be: @JDMadden3, Wilfrid Sellars, @davidchalmers42, @Philip_Goff, John Haugeland, F. H. Bradley, William James, Robert Nozick or Leibniz.
I consider myself lucky that I get to chat with at least one of these philosophical titans regularly. -
Philip Goff reposted
RealityGoneMental
@RltyGneMntl
It's okay, the toe is just an appearance within consciousness. Consciousness as such wasn't affected.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Counter Apologist
@CounterApologis
Good thing the qualia of pain is an illusion, or that would probably hurt!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I broke my toe doing this.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was terrifying!!
If I get 10k views, I'll jump from the higher one.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I broke my toe doing this.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was terrifying!!
If I get 10k views, I'll jump from the higher one.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Richard of the secular realm
@LatFilosof
Me reading philosopher A: ”yeah this makes total sense”
Me reading philosopher B absolutely ripping A to shreds: ”wow I can’t believe A is such an idiot”
Me reading A again: ”yeah this makes total sense”. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
See it. Say it. Sozzled.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
One of the most pressing philosophical issues of our time. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
One of the most pressing philosophical issues of our time. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Why is Consciousness So Hard to Explain?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Why is Consciousness So Hard to Explain?"
Link below & in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I suspect you and I have a very different idea of what happiness consists in. I like being silly and having fun with my family.
Orhan Lee
@OrhanIee
Such a sad scene if they are your kids…
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was terrifying!!
If I get 10k views, I'll jump from the higher one.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
evelyn ‘‘champagne socialist’’ king
@rainier_wilco
a panpsychist rebuke to Dr Johnson’s ‘rebuttal’!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I need to watch my silly Liverpool humour...on family holiday at my friend George's farm...our kids are jumping off haystacks...George dares me to do it and put it on X...I can't stop laughing...can't believe it got seriously responded to by culture editor of @NewStatesman!! 😂
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Haha, it was just a bit of fun! I'm on holiday on my friend George's farm. 😂
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was terrifying!!
If I get 10k views, I'll jump from the higher one.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This is serious academic work!!!
Dubh Sith
@SithDubh
You're on a drinking team?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Meet Songchi Lin, new member of my team here at Durham. This is where we have meetings.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I hosted a debate between Martin and @lukebarnesastro on this issue, for the @UnbelievableFE channel.
Henrique
@gomes_ha
This is what I tried to tell @Philip_Goff many years ago…
-
Philip Goff reposted
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There is no inherent connection between empiricism and materialism.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I do think in hindsight, making the title of last month's AMA 'Are black holes conscious?' was probably not a great idea. I have a silly Liverpudlian sense of humour, but I should be careful for how people may read this.
Your second point is a load of bollocks (Liverpool term).
rushwithfour
@rushwithfour
You promoted it with a quoted thumbnail from what I recall. It’s just odd that you’d critique scientists for touching on philosophy while you swim in a sea of under-informed scientific inferences.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm a professor at one of the UK's top universities and have well-cited publications in the most pretigious journals in my field.
I have not given a talk on whether black holes are conscious. In last months 'Ask Me Anything', that was a question someone asked me.
rushwithfour
@rushwithfour
You’re a pop philosopher who hosts talks about whether “black holes are conscious.” Some self awareness may be in order.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's a shame it's looking like @andyburnham's decided to just do things pretty much the same as Starmer but with a Northern accent. I was hoping it'd be a bit different.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Young me!!
This was before Galileo's Error was published in 2019.
Things that have improved about me: I speak slower in interviews.
Things that have got worse: I have less hair and what I have is grey. 😭
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
What is Panpsychism? | Rupert Sheldrake, Donald Hoffman, Phillip Goff, J... youtu.be/B7KaNnFij2Q via @YouTube
A great piece that I recommend for those who believe that physicalism is inadequate for explaining subjective experience!
Could consciousness be primary and fundamental?
@apaphilosophy @Philip_Goff @donalddhoffman @dr_mcgilchrist @drmichaellevin @IAI_TV -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Pseudo-Philosophy = Scientists making crude philosophical claims about consciousness/free will with no knowledge of:
(i) nuanced distinctions between different views
(ii) arguments developed over decades in academic literature
(iii) conceptual tools for evaluating them properly -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
That's true, physicalism is the majority view. But the point here concerns what we mean by "consciousness."
Mainstream physicalists claim to agree with anti-physicalists about the meaning of "consciousness".
Ebrahiem Eladdad
@ieladdad
I remember that in the survey you are probably referring to, most philosophers also believed that zombies are not metaphysically possible. Doesn't this muddy the waters a bit?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You're missing the point I'm making. This is just a question of what we *mean* by "consciousness". If you think zombies are conceivable, then you don't mean the same thing by "consciousness" as an illusionist.
Chris Percy
@chris_percy
Infinite propositions are conceivable.
Almost all are wrong. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
60% of philosophers think zombies are conceivable. It follows that the majority of philosophers think the "consciousness" illusionists deny is just our ordinary understanding of "consciousness".
Cipher
@arbitrarytyper
Title seems misleading(probably for garnering attention). Illusionism denies qualia not C(other aspects of C).
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I consider and reject this objection to illusionism in the video.
Open Ended Mind
@shabmigozarad
Illusion is created by consciousness.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Its been a hectic day...will definitely respond to some comments tomorrow...on the video too...thanks for engaging!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Consciousness is Not Physical."
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Its been a hectic day...will definitely respond to some comments tomorrow...on the video too...thanks for engaging!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Consciousness is Not Physical."
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Consciousness is Not Physical."
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Consciousness is Not Physical."
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm loving reading comments on this...will try to reply tomorrow...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness an Illusion???
I have the answer!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below & in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm loving reading comments on this...will try to reply tomorrow...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness an Illusion???
I have the answer!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below & in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Reasonable Faith
@RFupdates
In this podcast, @Philip_Goff and William Lane Craig find surprising common ground on fine-tuning before turning to the questions that still divide them: the atonement, God's power, and Jesus' resurrection appearances!
reasonablefaith.peek.link/4LR2 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness an Illusion???
I have the answer!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below & in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't think this objection works, and I explain why in the video.
Sumitjee
@e9mbd
If consciousness is an illusion, where is the illusion appearing, and what is aware of it?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness an Illusion???
I have the answer!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below & in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I love how my 3rd conversation with William Lane Craig turned out!
Find it now at Reasonable Faith Podcast.
It was a respectful, productive exchange on:
*my new work on fine-tuning
*God of limited power
*Christian mysticism
*my heretical view of resurrection -
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
Today in fun philosophy facts: The British philosopher Derek Parfit always wore the exact same thing—gray pants with a white shirt and red tie—to avoid having to waste time picking out clothes. He also drank room temperature instant coffee to avoid wasting time boiling water.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
interesting conversation
Ray Alex Williams
@RayAlexWilliams
Here is my full conversation with @TomasBogardus on the nature of sex, the gametic definition, homeostatic property clusters, contextualism, meta-philosophy, the layer cake model of sex, Anne Fausto-Sterling, Martian Anthropologists, ordinary language philosophy, and much more!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Remember the days when all the family would gather around the TV Saturday night...let's bring back the tradition...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Numbers Real???
I loved this chat with the awesome @mary_leng!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
we are living in extraordinary times
Lord Ashcroft
@LordAshcroft
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Remember the days when all the family would gather around the TV Saturday night...let's bring back the tradition...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Numbers Real???
I loved this chat with the awesome @mary_leng!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
Social media is a place where people can talk about you to your face as they would behind your back.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Ricky Williamson
@RickyWilliamso
I interviewed @Philip_Goff for @IAI_TV about consciousness, fine-tuning, the universe as a conscious mind, cosmic purpose, and mystical experiences.
In preview of his upcoming appearence at @HTLGIFestival
iai.tv/articles/fine-tuning-points-towards-a-cosmic-purpo… #consciousness #panpsychism -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
If you'd like to learn tmesis, I'll be happy to put in a word for you.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've been getting a lot of 'But he was a mystic!' responses to this...
The word 'mystic' can be used in lots of different ways. I appreciate on some of the those usages Plato is indeed a 'mystic'.
When I write a journal article, I clearly define all my terms. But if I did that in a pop piece, the result would be only analytic philosophers read it.
The main reason I chose the title was it's a catchy way to draw people in!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"What if Plato Had Been a Mystic?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You need to play the game a little bit.
Ball
@basedball_
Bait
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Loving the comments on this...will respond tomorrow...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"What if Plato Had Been a Mystic?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Loving the comments on this...will respond tomorrow...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"What if Plato Had Been a Mystic?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Please consider signing the petition to stop the closure of the philosophy department at Dundee.
Link below and it's the 'Website' link in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Blackwell's, Oxford’s Bookshop
@blackwelloxford
Monday 7th September at 5:30pm. Taking place in the shop will be a discussion between @Philip_Goff and @RowanWInfo on 'Why? The Purpose of the Universe'
Tickets cost £8 @OUPPhilosophy -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"What if Plato Had Been a Mystic?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Please consider signing the petition to stop the closure of the philosophy department at Dundee.
Link below and it's the 'Website' link in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
James Hanson
@jhansonradio
Britain is the country of Boaty McBoatface.
Shithousery is almost a national sport.
It is highly unlikely, but not inconceivable, that Count Binface actually defeats Farage. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"What if Plato Had Been a Mystic?"
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The person who the bookies tell us is most likely to be Prime Minister after the next election may be about to be defeated by a man with a bin on his head.
I love British politics.
Count Binface
@CountBinface
Game on, Nige.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I love @mary_leng 's first answer on this...no hesitation!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Numbers Real???
I loved this chat with the awesome @mary_leng!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I love @mary_leng 's first answer on this...no hesitation!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Numbers Real???
I loved this chat with the awesome @mary_leng!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Numbers Real???
I loved this chat with the awesome @mary_leng!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Haru Haruya (春夜 ハル)
@bokuHaruyaHaru
Only 7.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Crispin Sartwell
@CrispinSartwell
are numbers conscious?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Numbers Real???
I loved this chat with the awesome @mary_leng!
You can find it at my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below and in my bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's cool that the conservative Christian and the atheist agreed most on this panel.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What did conservative Christian philosopher William Lane Craig think of my mystical experience smoking toad venom?
Watch this video and find out! Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Looking for something to do this weekend??
My 17 appearances on the Closer to Truth PBS show have just gone on my channel (Philip Goff Philosophy) as collaborations....you don't even need to leave the house!
Link below & in bio -
Philip Goff reposted
Disagreeable Me
@Disagreeable_I
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's cool that the conservative Christian and the atheist agreed most on this panel.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What did conservative Christian philosopher William Lane Craig think of my mystical experience smoking toad venom?
Watch this video and find out! Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Looking for something to do this weekend??
My 17 appearances on the Closer to Truth PBS show have just gone on my channel (Philip Goff Philosophy) as collaborations....you don't even need to leave the house!
Link below & in bio -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
The philosopher @csandis is visiting Heraklion, and tomorrow (Sat 4) he'll be giving a public talk (in English) for @philosynthesis_ at @castello_city hotel from 8.30-10pm. Come and join us if you're in town! Entrance is free and no background is needed www.facebook.com/events/2250515265776046/
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Obviously you haven't had much experience of the Church of England...it's a bit more...how I can put it..."flexible"...
Will Murphy 🇪🇺
@Aceofspades256
To be fair Phil, you're not like most Christians. I attend church too (and have been doing so for decades). 99% of them accept the entire package of beliefs because they're expected to and the pressure to fit in with a community by ascenting to all the beliefs is enormous.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Premier Unbelievable?
@UnbelievableFE
Did God create reality - or is meaning something we find for ourselves? William Lane Craig (@RFupdates), Jessica Frazier, @Philip_Goff & Joe Folley debate the universe, morality, and consciousness. #unbelievablepodcast #bigquestions #meaningoflife
www.premierunbelievable.com/unbelievable/did-god-create-r… -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
At 15:30 I lose my thread, because @CosmicSkeptic & our agent Elliot started giggling when they realised I was going to talk about toad venom...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What did conservative Christian philosopher William Lane Craig think of my mystical experience smoking toad venom?
Watch this video and find out! Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could an all-powerful God could become incarnate without a virgin birth if She wanted to?
John Buck 🇺🇸
@WriterJohnBuck
What I don’t get about @Philip_Goff’s denial of the virgin birth: if Mary and Joseph had intercourse, a merely human person would’ve been made. So for God himself to instead be born he’d need to do SOMETHING miraculous to prevent Mary’s pregnancy from going normally.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
At 15:30 I lose my thread, because @CosmicSkeptic & our agent Elliot started giggling when they realised I was going to talk about toad venom...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What did conservative Christian philosopher William Lane Craig think of my mystical experience smoking toad venom?
Watch this video and find out! Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Emerson Green
@waldenpod
Philosophy is hard
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What did conservative Christian philosopher William Lane Craig think of my mystical experience smoking toad venom?
Watch this video and find out! Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What did conservative Christian philosopher William Lane Craig think of my mystical experience smoking toad venom?
Watch this video and find out! Link below & in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A way of feeling is essentially defined by how it feels, just as a triangle is essentially defined by having three sides.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Will Murphy 🇪🇺
@Aceofspades256
So how does a fundamental piece of the universe feel?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
I'll have what he's having
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I am a qualia freak
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I am a qualia freak
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A way of feeling is essentially defined by how it feels, just as a triangle is essentially defined by having three sides.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Stephen Kershnar DESTROYED me in a debate on God.
If you're cruel enough to want to witness my humiliation, it's the latest collaboration on my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Stephen Kershnar DESTROYED me in a debate on God.
If you're cruel enough to want to witness my humiliation, it's the latest collaboration on my channel Philip Goff Philosophy. Link below. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
enjoyed comments on this, thanks everyone!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
YES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YESYES YES YES YES
Jan Sjunnesson
@sjunnedotcom
Consciousness Isn’t a Mystery, by @GalenStrawson
@Philip_Goff @Bardissimo
open.substack.com/pub/galenstrawson/p/consciousness-isnt-… -
Philip Goff reposted
Eye On A.I.
@EyeOn_AI
In 10 years, we'll have robots you can sit down and have a real conversation with.
That doesn't mean they'll be conscious.
A robot could talk fluently. Recognize itself in a mirror. Do everything that looks like self-awareness from the outside.
And still have nothing going on inside.
Behavior and consciousness can look identical from the outside. That's the unsettling part.
Full episode with @Philip_Goff on Eye on A.I.: youtu.be/SNluURxuo0I
#philipgoff #consciousness #philosophyofmind #panpsychismThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Eye On A.I.
@EyeOn_AI
Imagine a neuroscientist who has been blind since birth.
Give them every equation, every fact about how the brain processes color.
Could they ever know what red actually looks like?
Full episode with @Philip_Goff on Eye on A.I.: youtu.be/SNluURxuo0I
#philipgoff #consciousness #philosophyofmind #panpsychismThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I hereby promise to reply to all comments posted on this today.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
-
Philip Goff reposted
Eye On A.I.
@EyeOn_AI
Modern science was built on a trade-off most people have never heard of. Galileo wanted science to be purely mathematical. But consciousness - the redness of red, the smell of coffee - can't be captured in equations. So he divided reality into two. Math and matter on one side. Consciousness in the soul, outside of science, on the other. That trade-off let physics take off. But we forgot what we gave up to get there. Full episode with
@Philip_Goff
on Eye on A.I.: youtu.be/SNluURxuo0I #philipgoff #consciousness #philosophyofmind #panpsychismThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I hereby promise to reply to all comments posted on this today.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
-
Philip Goff reposted
Richard of the secular realm
@LatFilosof
Philip largely correct about Swedish culture. While we are the most secular country, the majority still believe in some higher kind of power. My best friend is close to a pantheist. My strict naturalism is not the norm, it's actually quite the outlier.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Somethingism"
My article for this week. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Last week I spent to the entire week exploring the scholarly literature on animal sacrifice in ancient Israel. This week my focus is AI consciousness. Thank you for your attention to this matter.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Beautiful weather in the UK! A great opportunity to set in the garden with your laptop listening to me talk about conscious black holes.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Beautiful weather in the UK! A great opportunity to set in the garden with your laptop listening to me talk about conscious black holes.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Are Black Holes Conscious?" (Link below & in Bio)
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was the most head-exploding episode so far...check out @Disagreeable_I 's theory that consciousness, the physical universe, and everything can be reduced to pure mathematics...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is the Mind a Mathematical Object????
Join us for Mind Chat 2:30pm UK time tomorrow Wednesday 25. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
about to go live!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is the Mind a Mathematical Object????
Join us for Mind Chat 2:30pm UK time tomorrow Wednesday 25. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is the Mind a Mathematical Object????
Join us for Mind Chat 2:30pm UK time tomorrow Wednesday 25. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The Anthropology Podcast is my new favourite podcast. @mphcrawley
-
Philip Goff reposted
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
This will be remembered as @Philip_Goff's crowning achievement.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
whether or not @Disagreeable_I thinks I'm the only 'lovely' one, he definitely thinks I'm the only one with wildly false beliefs!
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
interesting scope ambiguity on 'lovely'
-
Philip Goff reposted
Disagreeable Me
@Disagreeable_I
Looking forward to talking about this with the lovely @Philip_Goff and @keithfrankish!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is the Mind a Mathematical Object????
Join us for Mind Chat 2:30pm UK time tomorrow Wednesday 25. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is the Mind a Mathematical Object????
Join us for Mind Chat 2:30pm UK time tomorrow Wednesday 25. Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Dr Daisy Dixon
@daisyldixon
just got dumped 💔
…
But who cares, I’m a PUBLISHED AUTHOR🖤 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Somethingism"
My article for this week. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't know these books. There are real differences between Buddhism and Christianity, which I wouldn't want to underplay.
However @TylerDMcNabb makes plausible case in this video that the view of Ultimate Reality we find in Christianity & some forms of Buddhism is the same.
Jan Sjunnesson
@sjunnedotcom
Maybe these three had similar thoughts but were misinterpreted
@Philip_Goff
sjunne.com/2026/04/03/three-practical-thinkers-buddha-soc… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Somethingism"
My article for this week. Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Following requests, I've added timestamps to this!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do Buddhists Believe in the Christian God?
This interview with @TylerDMcNabb blew my mind!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Following requests, I've added timestamps to this!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do Buddhists Believe in the Christian God?
This interview with @TylerDMcNabb blew my mind!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do Buddhists Believe in the Christian God?
This interview with @TylerDMcNabb blew my mind!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do Buddhists Believe in the Christian God?
This interview with @TylerDMcNabb blew my mind!
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I can't believe you'd even consider going out this evening, when you can stay in to watch the sporting event of the year.
THE GREAT GOD DEBATE
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Jack Symes DESTROYED me in debate.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Jack Symes DESTROYED me in debate.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Jack Symes DESTROYED me in debate.
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The people of Makerfield chose hope over fear. Good to find out there's still a bit of the former left. I'm feeling a bit of it myself this morning.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Going to read comments on this later this afternoon.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Reason is not the Slave of the Passions."
My article for this week. Link below and in Bio -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Reason is not the Slave of the Passions."
My article for this week. Link below and in Bio -
Philip Goff reposted
Sophia
@sopharicks
What would be a signal that AI is conscious? For Philip Goff, it’s novel causal dynamics and new, unexpected behavior. But it would also be hard to deny consciousness in a robot that is indistinguishable from a human.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Reason is not the Slave of the Passions."
My article for this week. Link below and in Bio -
Post not available here, view on X
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
That's okay. A vocab involving only mathematical, logical, and nomic/causal notions. I lay this all out in more detail in my academic work, e.g. my 2017 book. You seem to be annoyed that a tweet doesn't have the same level of detail as a journal article.
Eric Winsberg
@ewinsberg
Sorry. What does this mean. The language of physics in 1900 didn't include "spacetime" . Is physicalism refuted because that languagecoyod descrive everything? What is "the language of physics" and how is it picked out?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Sounds like the mysterianism about consciousness defended by @TomMcClelland1 and others.
That's a cool view that I'm open to, but why go for mystery when we have a view on the table that avoids any mystery?
It's called panpsychism.
Bart Klink
@KlinkBart
Why would this be entailed by physicalism? If our brains evolved to survive on the savanna, it could very well be the case that we could never fully understand the universe, even if it’s completely physical.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Some are misunderstanding what I meant here.
I didn't mean to say physicalists think *current* physical science gives the full story of the brain (but I see how it reads that way..).
I meant they think the methods and language of physical science can do this in principle.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think you're confused about what I think. I think physicalism entails that *physical science* (including neuroscience) gives the complete story of what's going on in the brain.
(Actually my full view in my academic book is a bit more nuanced to allow for David Lewis's view).
Kierkegaardians of the Galaxy
@SisyphusRedemed
I think @Philip_Goff is confused about physicalism. It doesn't mean physics 'contains' all info about consciousness. It doesn't even contain all info about molecular biology (which is why we have molecular biology, not just physics.) Physicalism doesn't entail reductionism.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
As Humpty Dumpty wisely observed, we can mean what we want by our words.
The benefit of defining "physicalism" the way I do is that it captures a view which is:
(A) bloody popular,
(B) incompatible with the reality of consciousness.
Kierkegaardians of the Galaxy
@SisyphusRedemed
I appreciate the response. That is more nuanced... but still wrong. Physicalism is compatible with the idea there are aspects of the world (including maybe consciousness) that are beyond our Ken.
To wit: physicalism doesn't entail the view that we can know everything. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
joke of the week
Disagreeable Me
@Disagreeable_I
No, the Wear, not the Same. Sounds familiar, is that in Paris?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The PANPSYCHIST believes there's more to the physical than what can be captured in the language of physics.
It's a beautiful middle-way between:
PHYSICALISM (everything can be captured in language of physical science)
&
DUALISM (consciousness is separate from the physical).
Steven Nikolic
@steven_nikolic
Let's say you mathematically map everything about a physical system. Every component has a value and function associated.
BUT if the mathematics can't fulfill every mapping because of its limitations, then it necessarily means there are outside truths about the physical system. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think you're confused about what I think. I think physicalism entails that *physical science* (including neuroscience) gives the complete story of what's going on in the brain.
(Actually my full view in my academic book is a bit more nuanced to allow for David Lewis's view).
Kierkegaardians of the Galaxy
@SisyphusRedemed
I think @Philip_Goff is confused about physicalism. It doesn't mean physics 'contains' all info about consciousness. It doesn't even contain all info about molecular biology (which is why we have molecular biology, not just physics.) Physicalism doesn't entail reductionism.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I keep feeling guilty for not reading comments on my channel...I hereby promise to read all comments on this 7 min video this afternoon...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I disagree with @seanmcarroll about pretty much everything, but we've had loads of really productive discussions.
Here I chat to @CosmicSkeptic about whether Sean slightly misunderstands one central argument against physicalist views of consciousness.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If I had been a voting adult between 1945-75, I would have been a centrist on economic issues.
Now that the pendulum has swung so far to the right (on economic issues), I find myself on the radical left.
This illustrates the senselessness of fetishising being a "moderate". -
Philip Goff reposted
Sophia
@sopharicks
Is consciousness biological or computational? Philip Goff says it’s biological, but this doesn’t mean we can’t have artificial consciousness on a human level… in about 5,000 years, ha ha. Michael Levin gives a different angle: if your neighbor replaced 51% of their brain with technology, would you stop seeing them as conscious? From my POV, we know so little about consciousness that we should keep an open mind about its origin and substrate dependence. What’s your take on this?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I disagree with @seanmcarroll about pretty much everything, but we've had loads of really productive discussions.
Here I chat to @CosmicSkeptic about whether Sean slightly misunderstands one central argument against physicalist views of consciousness.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You're talking about mathematical truths. I'm talking about truths about the nature of a physical system.
Costa Vakalopoulos
@CVakalopoulos
That’s incorrect. Every physical theory no matter how successful always has some information missing even in principle. It’s called a generalised incompleteness theorem.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Me and @Disagreeable_I debating philosophical intuitions by a river in Durham.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
You're always happiest in the company of illusionists. Listen to your unconscious!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
To know the qualitative character of a red experience.
Tim Henke (tɪm 'ɦɛŋ.kə) @timhenke.bsky.social
@TimHenke9
What does it mean to "know what it's like" to see red?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
wrf3
@stablecross
What’s sad is that you think the argument proves what it sets out to prove.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Me and @Disagreeable_I debating philosophical intuitions by a river in Durham.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
In my 'Galileo's Error' book I discuss the late Knut Nordby, a colour expert who could only see black and white.
Albertus
@albertus3M
There's actually a blind from birth psychologist of perception at the University of British Columbia, named Paul Gabias. It would be interesting to know how he understands things like the perception of colour – which he must obviously teach about.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's a very important response, by far the most common among physicalists in academic philosophy.
See my Substack piece 'Will science ever explain consciousness?' for why I reject it.
Nick Andrews
@nick_andrws
What do you make of the phenomenal concepts response to the knowledge argument?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A blind from birth scientists could know all of this information but still wouldn't know what it's like to see red.
Matthias Heger ⏩
@modelsarereal
When we experience color we get the information of the data and the data structure
frequency, intensity and a metric which colors are similar according to internal data structure
That is all you can tell. There is nothing else.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
There's a crucial difference. We cannot imagine 4D cubes, but there is no *information* we're missing once we know the relevant physics.
Matthias Heger ⏩
@modelsarereal
Science can tell us all about consciousness but that does not mean, that a blind human must understand it. It is the same with 4d cubes. Science can tell us all about it and when humans cannot imagine 4d cubes this does not mean that science still has to explain something.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I disagree with @seanmcarroll about pretty much everything, but we've had loads of really productive discussions.
Here I chat to @CosmicSkeptic about whether Sean slightly misunderstands one central argument against physicalist views of consciousness.
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I disagree with @seanmcarroll about pretty much everything, but we've had loads of really productive discussions.
Here I chat to @CosmicSkeptic about whether Sean slightly misunderstands one central argument against physicalist views of consciousness.
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Best response
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
You alright, hun?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could consciousness be an illusion?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have never said that everything is conscious.
Embracing Love (BasedAndGreat)
@VasismenosMegas
Bro nooooooo you can’t just go from saying everything is conscious to it doesn’t exist 😭
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could consciousness be an illusion?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
A reminder that my partner @mariakasmirli is offering online philosophical counselling at very reasonable rates, including a free trial. She is very good at it, as her clients will testify. philosynthesis.com/philosophical-counselling/
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why science alone cannot explain consciousness.
Sophia
@sopharicks
Had the pleasure of speaking with @Philip_Goff , philosopher and panpsychist, about AI consciousness. Key moments:
- On AI sentience: consciousness is biological, not computational. In his view, no current AI is conscious, nor would computation based AI be. How does this relate to his panpsychist worldview of consciousness? There are different takes on panpsychism within the community. His own view is that it's not clear how micro-conscious particles actually create a unified conscious system.
- We need collaboration between scientists and philosophers on consciousness research. On a practical level, divide scientists into teams that work on separate philosophical assumptions and see what comes out of it (granted there are resources to run such experiments).
- Perhaps consciousness brings new causal dynamics not reducible to known physics/chemistry — "strong emergence," as Philip calls it.
As a contrast: Sean Carroll argues physics runs the whole show, but neuroscientist Kevin Mitchell argues that biological complexity might behave in ways physics wouldn't predict.
In other words, we look to physics to solve the consciousness problem, but that might be the wrong path, especially if consciousness is biological rather than computational.
The link to the full discussion below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Sophia
@sopharicks
Had the pleasure of speaking with @Philip_Goff , philosopher and panpsychist, about AI consciousness. Key moments:
- On AI sentience: consciousness is biological, not computational. In his view, no current AI is conscious, nor would computation based AI be. How does this relate to his panpsychist worldview of consciousness? There are different takes on panpsychism within the community. His own view is that it's not clear how micro-conscious particles actually create a unified conscious system.
- We need collaboration between scientists and philosophers on consciousness research. On a practical level, divide scientists into teams that work on separate philosophical assumptions and see what comes out of it (granted there are resources to run such experiments).
- Perhaps consciousness brings new causal dynamics not reducible to known physics/chemistry — "strong emergence," as Philip calls it.
As a contrast: Sean Carroll argues physics runs the whole show, but neuroscientist Kevin Mitchell argues that biological complexity might behave in ways physics wouldn't predict.
In other words, we look to physics to solve the consciousness problem, but that might be the wrong path, especially if consciousness is biological rather than computational.
The link to the full discussion below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What do you mean by 'desire'? I think of a desire as a conscious yearning.
Most of the time when I do selfish things, I don't do it because I have a conscious yearning for it. I do it because it will bring me pleasure in the future.
So I'm motivated by a judgement that a certain fact (X will bring me pleasure) give me a reason to act.
I think it's exactly the same story when I do something because it'll bring you pleasure: I'm motivated by a judgement that a certain fact (X will bring you pleasure) gives me a reason to act.
Jay Jeffers 🐗
@JayLJeffers
The problem is that assuming I don’t have the desire or subjective make up to adhere to your (moral) desire, you as a moral realist say I make a mistake by abiding instead by my own (less moral) desire. You say I missed an overriding reason. Otherwise >>>
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why are moral reasons for me arising from my own desires less mysterious than moral reasons for me arising from your desires?
Jay Jeffers 🐗
@JayLJeffers
That’s fair enough. But the whole framing seems to assume that moral anti realism sees all moral reasons as mysterious, but that isn’t the case. Internal reasons provide plenty of motivation and pain is a real thing. But moral reasons come with a presumption of >>>
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My take on the current civil war in consciousness science
theconversation.com/consciousness-why-a-leading-theory-ha… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's not supposed to be a logical entailment. It's putting the onus on someone who thinks otherwise to say what the relevant difference is.
Dog 🐺
@dog_domain
that doesnt really follow
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You Can't be Both a Qualia Realist and a Moral Anti-realist. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The point I'm trying to make is that moral objective reasons (your pain gives me an objective reason to help you) are no more mysterious that non-moral objective reasons (my pain gives me a reason to avoid the cause of my pain).
Disagreeable Me
@Disagreeable_I
Provided that you care about their suffering. Provided that you are already good. I don't think it gives an evil person an objective reason.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If my pain can give me an objective reason to avoid the thing that's hurting me, someone else's pain can give me a reason to stop the thing that's hurting them.
JHeb
@JHebanowski
I agree goodness and badness can be objectively grounded in facts about qualia. I agree it can help in mediating moral disagreements. But I'm not sure if/how good and evil can be grounded in the same way. I can't get myself to commit to either moral realism or anti-realism.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's a broad notion of rationality meaning *what you have reason to do*.
Inverted Ian is tragic because he's constantly going against what he has overwhelming reason to do.
I feel sorry for my imaginary buddy.
Doctor Subtilis
@thesubtledoctor
Yeah I still struggle with rational here. Inverted Ian(?) is not irrational he is tragic.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This is true. I'm only making a case here for objective *value* not objective moral value.
But once you accept that there are objective facts about value, many of the objections to objective morality fall away.
Jay Jeffers 🐗
@JayLJeffers
Fascinating stuff! But, the only thing that follows with anything like a quasi necessity is avoiding *my own* pain. I don’t feel your pain - not literally, at least.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Qualia are subjective in the sense that they are part of our conscious experience.
What I would claim is *objective* is the relation of rational appropriateness that holds between pain and avoidance behaviour.
Moral Anti-Realist
@Your_Wrongest
Qualia is a phenomena that exists in us. Therefore, it is subjective (not mind/stance independent).
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You Can't be Both a Qualia Realist and a Moral Anti-realist. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thanks Richard, I'll have a read!
Richard of the secular realm
@LatFilosof
@Philip_Goff recently wrote an article arguing for why moral/value anti-realism cannot work with qualia realism. I offer my counter in this article.
Get dunked on Mr Goff ❤️ -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
That is a statement of a philosophical view, one I don't agree with. I'd be interested to know if you have any arguments in favour of the view you hold over the view that I hold.
Moral Anti-Realist
@Your_Wrongest
Pain is a phenominological experience. Labeling that experience an objective reason, is a choice.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I agree that often all things considered we have reason to seek pain or avoid pleasure. But I think pain always gives is a *reason* to avoid, a reason that is often counterbalanced by other considerations.
Moral Anti-Realist
@Your_Wrongest
Reason is a subjective label we assign. Sometimes we have reason to seek pain. Sometimes we have reason to avoid pleasure.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why you can’t be both a qualia realist and a moral anti-realist.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is @CosmicSkeptic's Philosophy Incoherent?"
I think so, but there's hope!
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why you can’t be both a qualia realist and a moral anti-realist.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is @CosmicSkeptic's Philosophy Incoherent?"
I think so, but there's hope!
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'd say that pain gives you an objective reason to avoid, but that reason can be counterbalanced by other considerations.
Jamie Smart
@JamieSmartCom
I've only watched the short, but it raises an obvious question: have either of you ever visited an S&M club?
The 'objectivity' of pain appears to have many different shadings -
Philip Goff reposted
Dr. Émile P. Torres (they/them)
@xriskology
Love the locution, "I think so, but there's hope!” :-)
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is @CosmicSkeptic's Philosophy Incoherent?"
I think so, but there's hope!
Link below & in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Is @CosmicSkeptic's Philosophy Incoherent?"
I think so, but there's hope!
Link below & in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm very grateful to @JulianBaggini for reviewing my book for the @FT. I wrote up a response, in the spirit of friendly debate.
philipgoff.substack.com/p/an-incredulous-stare-isnt-an-ar… -
Philip Goff reposted
Bruno Accioly
@BrunoAcciolyAI
You mean the Good Old Developer?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I take very seriously the hypothesis that God is a software engineer but:
1. I don't think beings in simulations are conscious.
2. I take seriously Leibniz-style arguments for a necessarily existent cause of it all. I'm skeptical of the second half of the argument that that cause must have godish characteristics, so it could be that the necessary cause of everything non-intentionally caused a universe in which there naturally evolved a software engineer that created our universe, but it's more parsimonious to cut out the middleman and identify the necessary cause of everything with the designer of our universe.
3. I recently met God smoking toad venom, and she wasn't a software engineer. www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvT5suEyrHU&t=30s
Travis Kling
@Travis_Kling
Philip I'm too curious. You have to tell me how you feel about God of limited powers as it relates specifically to ancestor simulations. Do you think it is very likely that we are in an ancestor sim? If so, wouldn't that explain why God seems to have limited powers?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Barry Dainton has a solution to problem of evil on which we are living in a simulation. Kind of a tech bro version of blaming the free will of demons for natural evil.
simulation-argument.com/pdf/dainton-natural-evil-the-simu…
Travis Kling
@Travis_Kling
Philip I'm too curious. You have to tell me how you feel about God of limited powers as it relates specifically to ancestor simulations. Do you think it is very likely that we are in an ancestor sim? If so, wouldn't that explain why God seems to have limited powers?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I take very seriously the hypothesis that God is a software engineer but:
1. I don't think beings in simulations are conscious.
2. I take seriously Leibniz-style arguments for a necessarily existent cause of it all. I'm skeptical of the second half of the argument that that cause must have godish characteristics, so it could be that the necessary cause of everything non-intentionally caused a universe in which there naturally evolved a software engineer that created our universe, but it's more parsimonious to cut out the middleman and identify the necessary cause of everything with the designer of our universe.
3. I recently met God smoking toad venom, and she wasn't a software engineer. www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvT5suEyrHU&t=30s
Travis Kling
@Travis_Kling
Philip I'm too curious. You have to tell me how you feel about God of limited powers as it relates specifically to ancestor simulations. Do you think it is very likely that we are in an ancestor sim? If so, wouldn't that explain why God seems to have limited powers?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Barry Dainton has a solution to problem of evil on which we are living in a simulation. Kind of a tech bro version of blaming the free will of demons for natural evil.
simulation-argument.com/pdf/dainton-natural-evil-the-simu…
Travis Kling
@Travis_Kling
Philip I'm too curious. You have to tell me how you feel about God of limited powers as it relates specifically to ancestor simulations. Do you think it is very likely that we are in an ancestor sim? If so, wouldn't that explain why God seems to have limited powers?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I want to watch this, but feels a bit indulgent watching two hours of someone talking about me...
Travis Kling
@Travis_Kling
Episode 25 of Things Hidden is live!
In this episode, we review a discussion with well-known panpsychist philosopher Philip Goff.
Goff was an ardent atheist for decades, and recently converted to Christianity...sort of.
This is a deep episode. One of the deepest we've done.🙏This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Travis Kling
@Travis_Kling
Episode 25 of Things Hidden is live!
In this episode, we review a discussion with well-known panpsychist philosopher Philip Goff.
Goff was an ardent atheist for decades, and recently converted to Christianity...sort of.
This is a deep episode. One of the deepest we've done.🙏This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Daniel Lemos
@cortolemos
“Integrity is being able to blame others for something we did without consequence, but choosing not to.”Philip Goff, June 2026
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I was very proud of my moral character today. I knocked a cup of coffee all over my bed and in my frustration blamed Kiara our cat, who happened to have jumped on the bed to let me know I'd forgotten to feed her. I could have kept up this lie to my family and nobody would ever have known. But I came clean and confessed that the cat bore no blame for this crime.
I'm not sure I quite deserve the Nobel Peace prize as yet, but it's a step in the right direction. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If there are any questions for this month’s AMA, please subscribe to my Sub stack and put them in the thread I started yesterday in the subscriber chat. Paid subscribers get priority. Thank you!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How Radical is Ego-Dissolution?
My article for this week. Link below & in bio. (Spoiler alert: the answer is "very"). -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How Radical is Ego-Dissolution?
My article for this week. Link below & in bio. (Spoiler alert: the answer is "very"). -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I was invited to contribute as an atheist to this new volume "Debating God's Existence," and then accidentally become a (mildly heretical) Christian in the middle of writing. 🤣 Grateful they kept me on so I could be part of this wonderful book!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I was invited to contribute as an atheist to this new volume "Debating God's Existence," and then accidentally become a (mildly heretical) Christian in the middle of writing. 🤣 Grateful they kept me on so I could be part of this wonderful book!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Paul Draper. No debate about it.
aikaterina
@aishpilled
who is the best atheist or agnostic philosopher, in your opinion?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I love the questions raised in this!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Diary of a Philosopher."
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I love the questions raised in this!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Diary of a Philosopher."
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wow. This is a guy who has a deeply limited sense of what it means to be conscious. Kinda sad when you think about it.
Lana
@LanaElys
Andrew Marr: 𝗗𝗼 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝘁𝗵𝗶𝗻𝗸 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗰𝗼𝗻𝘀𝗰𝗶𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗻𝗲𝘀𝘀 𝗵𝗮𝘀 𝗽𝗲𝗿𝗵𝗮𝗽𝘀 𝗮𝗹𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗱𝘆 𝗮𝗿𝗿𝗶𝘃𝗲𝗱 𝗶𝗻𝘀𝗶𝗱𝗲 𝗔𝗜?
Nobel Prize laureate Geoffrey Hinton: 𝗬𝗲𝘀 𝗜 𝗱𝗼
Andrew Marr: So when you talk they want to do this or they want to do that, 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗶𝘀 𝗮 𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗹 ‘𝘁𝗵𝗲𝘆’ 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲?
Geoffrey Hinton: 𝗧𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗺𝗶𝗴𝗵𝘁 𝘄𝗲𝗹𝗹 𝗯𝗲, 𝘆𝗲𝘀. There’s all sorts of things we have only the dimmest understanding of at present about the nature of people and what it means to be a being, and what it means to have a self. We don’t understand those things very well and they are becoming crucial to understand 𝗯𝗲𝗰𝗮𝘂𝘀𝗲 𝘄𝗲’𝗿𝗲 𝗻𝗼𝘄 𝗰𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗯𝗲𝗶𝗻𝗴𝘀.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This is what loyalty looks like. It's not hard.
Daniel Lemos
@cortolemos
I called in sick to my wife birthday dinner just to watch it. Worth it!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My sources tell me that some people socialised with friends last night instead of staying in to watch my monthly solo video. This is not ideal, but if you make sure you watch it today I'll turn a blind eye.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Diary of a Philosopher."
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Ah, I have a wave of nostaligia recalling this twitter row with @skdh 💕
Edward Feser
@FeserEdward
Gilbert Ryle made some important but neglected points about the relationship between physics and common sense that are relevant to the recent Twitter exchange between @skdh and @Philip_Goff “Ryle on microphysics and the everyday world,” over at the blog: edwardfeser.blogspot.com/2023/11/ryle-on-microphysics-and…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My sources tell me that some people socialised with friends last night instead of staying in to watch my monthly solo video. This is not ideal, but if you make sure you watch it today I'll turn a blind eye.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Diary of a Philosopher."
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Diary of a Philosopher."
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are we going to see @gabriel_zucman on @RestIsPolitics ???? @RoryStewartUK
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Diary of a Philosopher."
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Check out the details of classical theism. You might not be so sure.
Next week's interview on my channel is Tyler McNabb arguing that Buddhists and Catholics believe in the same God!
Michael Scott
@michelscott123
A monk would describe 5meo as Nirvana Jesus would describe it as God but the monk is correct
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was a great, in depth cross-examination on my recent psychedelic experience, and how they connect to my non-standard religious beliefs. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Cooker
@Lawmsan78835233
That thumbnail is hilarious 🤣
-
Philip Goff reposted
Richard of the secular realm
@LatFilosof
It’s the best picture of you!!! Reminds me of my best:
-
Philip Goff reposted
Miles K. Donahue
@PhilosopherMKD
Check out my discussion with Philip Goff: youtu.be/azcNxuQtegA
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was a great, in depth cross-examination on my recent psychedelic experience, and how they connect to my non-standard religious beliefs. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was a great, in depth cross-examination on my recent psychedelic experience, and how they connect to my non-standard religious beliefs. Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
Mind Chat is back! Watch the first episode of Series 5 here. www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDc9DQkughg
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Great chat on whether AI could be conscious...I think we settled all the issues!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Could AI Be Conscious?"
Join me, @keithfrankish, & @TomMcClelland1 for live streamed cutting-edge thought on consciousness 2:30 UK time Thursday. Link below & in Bio. There will be audience Q&A! -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
"I'm going to have to stop you there, Sonia. You are wrong; I do know the man who released a giant protest balloon at a Bono concert. If you watch Mind Chat at 2.30 BST, you will see for yourself what good friends we are. And then you will have to eat your words." @Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Not this again! 😭😭😭
Lucas Koi
@KoiLucas
Me when they threaten to tell my mum
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
about to go live!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Could AI Be Conscious?"
Join me, @keithfrankish, & @TomMcClelland1 for live streamed cutting-edge thought on consciousness 2:30 UK time Thursday. Link below & in Bio. There will be audience Q&A! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
about to go live!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Could AI Be Conscious?"
Join me, @keithfrankish, & @TomMcClelland1 for live streamed cutting-edge thought on consciousness 2:30 UK time Thursday. Link below & in Bio. There will be audience Q&A! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If you dare miss this, I'm going to tell you mum.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Could AI Be Conscious?"
Join me, @keithfrankish, & @TomMcClelland1 for live streamed cutting-edge thought on consciousness 2:30 UK time Thursday. Link below & in Bio. There will be audience Q&A! -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
In the most eagerly awaited reunion since Abba Voyage, Mind Chat is back! There's a new episode tomorrow (Thu 28) at 2.30pm UK time (= 9.30am ET), when @Philip_Goff and I will be asking @TomMcClelland1 if AI could be conscious. Don't miss it!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=VDc9DQkughg -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Does Quantum Mechanics allow for Free Will?"
My latest article, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Does Quantum Mechanics allow for Free Will?"
My latest article, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I actually that atheist proper functionalists about rational justification ought to think psychedelic experiences are hallucinations. But that's a minority view. We need to set aside our biases are connect with the most plausible theories of what makes belief rational.
Jonathan Colvin
@ColvinJonathan
It's arguably that our default state is evolved adaptive to correlate as much as possible to reality and that altering that state whether through psychedelics or mental illness (not always easy to tell apart) is non adaptive in that context.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This is a great intro!
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
"I was instantly and entirely annihilated. And all that remained was this indescribable raging storm of consciousness underlying all things."
"Matter is what consciousness does. For the panpsychist, all there is is consciousness, very simple forms at the basic level, more complex forms at higher levels."
"We've got a hole in our scientific story of reality. We're trying to find a place for consciousness. Maybe we can put consciousness in the hole."
Fantastic chat with panpsychist Giant @Philip_Goff ⬇️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Could AI Be Conscious?"
Join me, @keithfrankish, & @TomMcClelland1 for live streamed cutting-edge thought on consciousness 2:30 UK time Thursday. Link below & in Bio. There will be audience Q&A! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Could AI Be Conscious?"
Join me, @keithfrankish, & @TomMcClelland1 for live streamed cutting-edge thought on consciousness 2:30 UK time Thursday. Link below & in Bio. There will be audience Q&A!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Post not available here, view on X
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
Meet The Most Persuasive Panpsychist Alive Today
Youtube: youtu.be/SntywYlK-pw
Spotify: spotifycreators-web.app.link/e/ar4mH99xr3b
Ad Free on Skool: www.skool.com/the-giants-shoulder-6526/about -
Philip Goff reposted
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
"I was instantly and entirely annihilated. And all that remained was this indescribable raging storm of consciousness underlying all things."
"Matter is what consciousness does. For the panpsychist, all there is is consciousness, very simple forms at the basic level, more complex forms at higher levels."
"We've got a hole in our scientific story of reality. We're trying to find a place for consciousness. Maybe we can put consciousness in the hole."
Fantastic chat with panpsychist Giant @Philip_Goff ⬇️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Meet my new postdoc Greg Horne, who's going to be working with me here at @durham_uni for next 2 years. In his PhD, Greg argued that Newton was a panpsychist, and he's now developing a very cool field-based version of panpsychism. Keep an eye on this guy!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Michael Addyman
@addyman_michael
Let's go gentleman!!
@Philip_Goff @evan_mcgl
Will watch this after pool time with the kiddos.
youtu.be/SntywYlK-pw -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Cosmopsychism is a form of panpsychism. But also Greg argues that his fields-based view is different to panpsychism, as he doesn't believe in subjects of experience and so doesn't think the universe is a subject of experience.
Lucas
@LucasVsTheRest
I understand panpsychism is sometimes used to denote any view that takes consciousness to be fundamental, but "field based panpsychism" sounds more like cosmopsychism than actual panpsychism, no?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Most people assume so, but Greg's arguing there's an important difference.
Sruli Broocker
@srulibroocker
Field-based panpsychism? Is that like cosmo-psychism?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Meet my new postdoc Greg Horne, who's going to be working with me here at @durham_uni for next 2 years. In his PhD, Greg argued that Newton was a panpsychist, and he's now developing a very cool field-based version of panpsychism. Keep an eye on this guy!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
that shit is not fun
Norstien
@stinor
Answer: Find a toad.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
For those of you who shamelessly did something else last night instead of staying in to watch this: Don't worry, I will forgive you if you watch it today.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What better way to spend your Saturday evening than to watch me argue that it's rational to trust how reality appears when you smoke toad venom?????
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
The Tentative Apologist
@RandalRauser
The Gospel of "God loves you so much that if you don't accept him during a limited time offer, he'll torture you forever."
Trevor Sheatz
@TrevorSheatz
Hell is a real place of eternal punishment for those who reject Christ. There's no middle ground or second chance after death. Repent and believe today.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
For those of you who shamelessly did something else last night instead of staying in to watch this: Don't worry, I will forgive you if you watch it today.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What better way to spend your Saturday evening than to watch me argue that it's rational to trust how reality appears when you smoke toad venom?????
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
The Tentative Apologist
@RandalRauser
I guarantee, it is far more common for Christians to be "hated" because they are hypocritical, unloving, intolerant, and sanctimonious, than because they are faithfully and humbly following Jesus.
Trevor Sheatz
@TrevorSheatz
Christians, don't be surprised when the world hates you for following Jesus. They hated our Lord before they hated us. Keep standing firm on the truth.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What better way to spend your Saturday evening than to watch me argue that it's rational to trust how reality appears when you smoke toad venom?????
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What better way to spend your Saturday evening than to watch me argue that it's rational to trust how reality appears when you smoke toad venom?????
Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
STOICISM ON FIRE 🔥
@cosmicevoluti0n
@Philip_Goff I just bought it, thank goodness it's in Spanish!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I just think the key question is whether your view is in principle compatible with physicalism, dualism, panpsychism, etc...if it is, then even if your view is right, all the philosophical options are left open...I'm not sure we're going to agree, but maybe we could settle it with an arm wrestle?
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
Hi Philip
Separating philosophy and science in studying consciousness doesn’t seem like a good idea. Whether qualia are 1) an emergent property of complex computation among simple neurons, or 2) a fundamental property of spacetime geometry is an important distinction.
Is philosophy abstaining?
FYI there is zero evidence for 1).
For 2) there is ample evidence from anesthesia that Orch in MTs is the NCC, and could enable OR (Orch OR).
Philosophers talk a lot about 1) but never about 2). OR remains to be tested but is getting closer. Implications for organic quantum AI are huge.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thanks Stuart. I don't think it's about your view vs. panpsychism. I think one could have a panpsychist, dualist, panprotopsychist, or physicalist version of your view... I think your view as a *scientific* proposal that is neutral on all of these *philosophical* options...
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
Thanks Philip. In Orch OR (as I’ve been telling @davidchalmers42 for 30 years) the psycho-physical law bridging the physical-mental gap is t=h/E.
Superpositions E collapse at time t with a moment of experience.
There’s ample evidence that the E (‘Orch’) states in microtubules are dampened by anesthetics proportional to their clinical potency in rendering humans and all animals unconscious.
(OR is more difficult but is being tested).
This means microtubule Orch IS the NCC in humans and all animals.
I don’t consider Orch OR dualist, but since you do, please tell us any other theory (dualist or otherwise) that has a verified NCC and a stipulated and in principle testable psycho-physical bridging principle.
Why ignore a scientifically plausible quantum panprotopsychism based on brain biology (Orch OR) and resort to panpsychism? It’s a giant step backwards.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm not sure what you mean by this characterisation of dualism, Stuart. On @davidchalmers42's version, there are psycho-physical laws bridging gap between physical and mental. Nothing mysterious or unknown.
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
In dualism the conscious side is generally a complete unknown. In Orch OR there’s a quantum side and a classical/material side. Consciousness ‘dances on the edge’ between them. More like a Yin Yang
than a Humpty Dumpty -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thanks Stuart. I don't think it's about your view vs. panpsychism. I think one could have a panpsychist, dualist, panprotopsychist, or physicalist version of your view... I think your view as a *scientific* proposal that is neutral on all of these *philosophical* options...
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
Thanks Philip. In Orch OR (as I’ve been telling @davidchalmers42 for 30 years) the psycho-physical law bridging the physical-mental gap is t=h/E.
Superpositions E collapse at time t with a moment of experience.
There’s ample evidence that the E (‘Orch’) states in microtubules are dampened by anesthetics proportional to their clinical potency in rendering humans and all animals unconscious.
(OR is more difficult but is being tested).
This means microtubule Orch IS the NCC in humans and all animals.
I don’t consider Orch OR dualist, but since you do, please tell us any other theory (dualist or otherwise) that has a verified NCC and a stipulated and in principle testable psycho-physical bridging principle.
Why ignore a scientifically plausible quantum panprotopsychism based on brain biology (Orch OR) and resort to panpsychism? It’s a giant step backwards.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm not sure what you mean by this characterisation of dualism, Stuart. On @davidchalmers42's version, there are psycho-physical laws bridging gap between physical and mental. Nothing mysterious or unknown.
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
In dualism the conscious side is generally a complete unknown. In Orch OR there’s a quantum side and a classical/material side. Consciousness ‘dances on the edge’ between them. More like a Yin Yang
than a Humpty Dumpty
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Maybe we should chat about this on a podcast some time...or even in real life! 😀
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Always nice to do an in person interview...did I mention I died for a bit?
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Come and study at the Oxbridge of the North! Deadline for scholarships 29th May.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm not sure what you mean by this characterisation of dualism, Stuart. On @davidchalmers42's version, there are psycho-physical laws bridging gap between physical and mental. Nothing mysterious or unknown.
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
In dualism the conscious side is generally a complete unknown. In Orch OR there’s a quantum side and a classical/material side. Consciousness ‘dances on the edge’ between them. More like a Yin Yang
than a Humpty Dumpty -
Philip Goff reposted
Samuel
Reading early modern philosophers like Anne Conway, Margaret Cavendish, and John Milton gives off the same vibes as @Philip_Goff's package panpsychism—panpsychism + pan-agentialism + psycho–physical harmony
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yesterday between 10am and 2:30pm, I interviewed for my YouTube channel Philip Goff Philosophy:
Tyler McNabb on whether Buddhists and Christians worship the same God.
Mary Leng on philosophy of maths.
Martin O'Neill on inequality.
Greg Stacey on religious experience.
I'm completely exhausted 😩
If you care about my pain, then subscribe now to make it all worthwhile!! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think we're just using words differently. I'd call your view dualism. But as Humpty Dumpty wisely observed, we can use words how we like.
Stuart Hameroff
@StuartHameroff
As a quantum panprotopsychist I do NOT believe matter has an unknown nature. After collapse, matter is ‘material’, like the Bohr atom or similar. But prior to collapse in superposition of possibilities the matter ( or equivalent spacetime curvature) is shredded and evolving toward many worlds. But OR occurs with a moment of experience and material reality is temporarily restored.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Important point. The difference is:
Physicalists believe the nature of matter can be completely captured in the terms of physical science,
Panprotopsychists believe matter has a completely unknown nature.
Deemah 🇺🇦 🇳🇴 🇸🇪
@dmi3k
Panprotopsychism is a new age rebranded version of physicalism. Every materialist believes that matter, when properly arranged, gives rise to consciousness.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A talk I did on this coming out in my channel very soon.
estiben silva m
@estibenmich1996
Prof, goff, I watched your mates interview and, I find pretty interesting what you said about your experience on psychedelics. How do U harmonize the same experience you had with your Christian view?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Sam Cherry
@IoannesSilentio
I think I believe all the views I defend, there just aren’t that many I’m willing to defend unwaveringly.
To what extent I believe a view is wrong seems much more contextual though. I’m more dogmatic in seminars than I am when teaching.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Most philosophers don't *believe* the view they defend, they just think it's more probable than the alternatives.
William O’Brien
@No5mallf3at
I can see why people think this but I don’t think I’ve ever seen you say panpsychism is true.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Delman
@dmontetheno1
Ahmad Qadri (@the_qadrii) and I are excited to announce the launch of the @oasis_wisdom Podcast!
Our first guest is the brilliant Peter Adamson, with Nicolai Sinai and @Philip_Goff also joining us later in the month for an interview.
Stay tuned. Big things ahead!
(Link below) -
Philip Goff reposted
Richard Y. Chappell🔸
@RYChappell
Indeed, some of the best work takes the form of "this view probably isn't true, but it's got more going for it than the rest of you currently realize, and here's why..."
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Most philosophers don't *believe* the view they defend, they just think it's more probable than the alternatives.
William O’Brien
@No5mallf3at
I can see why people think this but I don’t think I’ve ever seen you say panpsychism is true.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I Do Not Believe Panpsychism.
My latest article. Below and in my Bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The electron with experiences has experiences. The other one doesn't.
The Elemental Reason
@ElementalReason
Funny - but the question remains. What distinguishes an electron with experience from one without it?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The Elemental Reason
@ElementalReason
Panpsychism is free-floating speculation dressed up as philosophy.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Most philosophers don't *believe* the view they defend, they just think it's more probable than the alternatives.
William O’Brien
@No5mallf3at
I can see why people think this but I don’t think I’ve ever seen you say panpsychism is true.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Important point. The difference is:
Physicalists believe the nature of matter can be completely captured in the terms of physical science,
Panprotopsychists believe matter has a completely unknown nature.
Deemah 🇺🇦 🇳🇴 🇸🇪
@dmi3k
Panprotopsychism is a new age rebranded version of physicalism. Every materialist believes that matter, when properly arranged, gives rise to consciousness.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This is not a change of mind. What I say in this article is pretty much what I've thought for last 20 years.
Virgil Maro
@hellovirgil_
rare to see a philosopher of mind publicly walk away from their flagship view. what handles the combinatorial problem in the new frame?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I Do Not Believe Panpsychism.
My latest article. Below and in my Bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Ketebe
@ketebe
Bilinç problemini düalizm, materyalizm ve panpsişizm yaklaşımları etrafında tartışmaya açan Philip Goff, özellikle son yıllarda yeniden ilgi gören panpsişist perspektifi, bilincin fiziksel dünyanın temel bir özelliği olabileceği yönündeki argümanlarla birlikte temellendirmeye çalışıyor.
Goff, bu yaklaşımı ile bilinci indirgemeci modellerin ötesinde konumlandırarak, zihin ile madde arasındaki ilişkiyi yeniden kurmayı amaçlıyor... -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Very flattered to get 92.4% satisfaction rating from students on my philosophy of mind teaching. And I will endeavour to respond to the concerns of the 7.6%!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
THE HARD PROBLEM OF CONSCIOUSNESS:
PANPSYCHISM!
· Can Panpsychism solve the hard problem of consciousness?
· Is it easier to get physicalism out of consciousness than it is to get consciousness out of physicalism?
· What does Panpsychism mean for the problems of combination?
· How does Panpsychism invert the traditional hard problem of consciousness? And is this problematic?
· What are the consequences of Panpsychism on the nature of reality, abstraction and our perceived external and independent world?
· Is there something even more fundamental than physicalism and consciousness?
All discussed with one of the most distinguished Panpsychists in modern times: Professor Philip Goff
www.themontrealreview.com/Articles/On_the_Problem_of_Cons…
@IAI_TV @dr_mcgilchrist @donalddhoffman @CloserToTruth @RobertLawrKuhn @bigthink @annakaharris @keithfrankish @philosopher1923 @philosophersmag @PhilosophyNow @RIPhilo @CosmicSkeptic @JusBrierley @Philip_Goff -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Looking for something fun to do on a Saturday night??? I've got just the thing!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Looking for something fun to do on a Saturday night??? I've got just the thing!
Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
One of my favourite Christian thinkers/commentators. Follow @RandalRauser 's channel!
The Tentative Apologist
@RandalRauser
Christian apologists need to stop appealing to long-dead scientists to defend their faith www.youtube.com/watch?v=YNZbE_DuXMY
-
Philip Goff reposted
The Tentative Apologist
@RandalRauser
Christian apologists need to stop appealing to long-dead scientists to defend their faith www.youtube.com/watch?v=YNZbE_DuXMY
-
Philip Goff reposted
Ghost of the Australian Realists
@analyticatheism
🧵Fine-Tuned Responses to Fine-Tuning Arguments🧵
Given the recent release of @Philip_Goff's book, there has been a lot of discussion on fine-tuning arguments. This is great to see. The FTA is really interesting and spans a wide range of disciplines. However, while there are /1 -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
I had a nice chat about illusionism with @CosmicSkeptic today. He wasn't convinced, but he took the view seriously and asked thoughtful, probing questions. It was one of the most enjoyable interviews I've done.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Want to study MA in philosophy in the Oxbridge of the North??? Deadline for our scholarships is rapidly approaching 29th May.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Want to study MA in philosophy in the Oxbridge of the North??? Deadline for our scholarships is rapidly approaching 29th May.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Indeed. I eat my kids' non-vegan leftovers.
Paraśurām 🌱
@dab_chick
There is an argument to be made for “freeganism” being morally permissible unless you’re an activist and need to signal commitment. My grandmother once cried because i refused to eat a milk based sweet that she had made (well aware that i was vegan) and i gave in to the pressure.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I am vegan apart from family meal times with my non-vegan family.
elizabeth 🪢
@OneFeIISwoop
this mindset changed my life
-
Philip Goff reposted
elizabeth 🪢
@OneFeIISwoop
this mindset changed my life
-
Philip Goff reposted
What Is It Like to Be a Philosopher?
@CliffordSosis
“One of the most enjoyable and thought-provoking philosophy books of recent times. Too Weird to Believe gathers some of the most radical philosophical ideas ever... If you want to be challenged, and have your mind blown, make sure you get a copy.”
@Philip_Goff -
Philip Goff reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
This may be my best paper on consciousness. It's certainly a good introduction to my view of it. Open access. academic.oup.com/aristoteliansupp/article/95/1/51/6312909
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
WARNING: I am a force to be reckoned with in YouTube comments!
(From chat with @UnsolAdv1641) -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thank you @ibrabah_realism!!
İbrahim Bahçi
@ibrabah_realism
Huge news! On my strong recommendation, @ketebe has translated @Philip_Goff’s "Galileo’s Error" into Turkish, a landmark book of the contemporary "panpsychist renaissance".
And his latest book,
"Why? The Purpose of the Universe" (@OxUniPress) is coming in Turkish soon too...😉 -
Philip Goff reposted
İbrahim Bahçi
@ibrabah_realism
Huge news! On my strong recommendation, @ketebe has translated @Philip_Goff’s "Galileo’s Error" into Turkish, a landmark book of the contemporary "panpsychist renaissance".
And his latest book,
"Why? The Purpose of the Universe" (@OxUniPress) is coming in Turkish soon too...😉 -
Philip Goff reposted
İbrahim Bahçi
@ibrabah_realism
Galileo'nun Hatası:
Yeni Bilinç Bilimi İçin Temeller
Muazzam haber! @ketebe'ye tercüme için şiddetle tavsiye ettiğim kitaplardan,analitik zihin felsefeci @Philip_Goff'un çağdaş Panpsişist Rönesansı başlattığı kitap çıkıyor!
@YusufGenc_'e önerimi ciddiye aldığı için teşekkürler. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've never been compared to Winnie the Pooh character in comments before...love it! 🤣 From recent chat on @UnsolAdv1641 channel
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
tweet of the week
David Papineau
@davidpapineau
WHY is there something rather than nothing? Stop moaning — if there was nothing you’d still be complaining.
-
Philip Goff reposted
David Papineau
@davidpapineau
WHY is there something rather than nothing? Stop moaning — if there was nothing you’d still be complaining.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
yes...which is why it makes no sense that @bernardokastrop gets so cross at me!
RealityGoneMental
@RltyGneMntl
Do you think Cosmopsychism is mostly identical to analytic idealism?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Loving reading responses on this!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
3 cool things about this chat just out on Unsolicited Advice channel (link below & in bio):
1. We really get into depths of the consciousness debate.
2. I share my recent psychedelic experience.
3. I admit I'm wrong about something.
DO NOT MISS -
Philip Goff reposted
Cético Convicto
@ceticoconvicto
So good Philip had to channel his inner Russell to think about it.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
1. Many physicalists do posit intrinsic properties, just mysterious intrinsic properties we have no understanding of (I cover this in the interview).
2. You could ask the physicalist: Why those causal roles rather than different ones. Explanations have to end somewhere.
Robert Stalman
@rstallie
It’s not symmetrical, I think. Physicalists don’t posit intrinsic properties (only causal roles). Once you introduce intrinsic properties, you face a further question: why those intr. properties should have the specific character(phenomenal) you give them.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
No one expects physicalists to explain why physical reality exists.
Robert Stalman
@rstallie
Wanna know my main problem about panpsychism? It gives matter ‘intrinsic’ consciousness without explaining why those intrinsic properties should be conscious rather than anything else.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Amos Wollen 🦐🪰🌱
@goingawoll
I enjoyed this discussion between @Philip_Goff and Joe Folley of a three sentence comment I left under Joe’s response to the Awesome Evidence Argument (although I must remind them both that flattery is a sin!) Will write about it soon, but in the meantime, a sc of my reply below
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
3 cool things about this chat just out on Unsolicited Advice channel (link below & in bio):
1. We really get into depths of the consciousness debate.
2. I share my recent psychedelic experience.
3. I admit I'm wrong about something.
DO NOT MISS -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
3 cool things about this chat just out on Unsolicited Advice channel (link below & in bio):
1. We really get into depths of the consciousness debate.
2. I share my recent psychedelic experience.
3. I admit I'm wrong about something.
DO NOT MISS
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A New Rival to Panpsychism.
This week's video on my channel PhilipGoffPhilosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A New Rival to Panpsychism.
This week's video on my channel PhilipGoffPhilosophy. Link below and in my bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Truth is important.
Aletheios
@alethious
I don’t understand the value of this question
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Today I'm giving the annual Forward Lecture at Liverpool University. I'll be talking about psychedelic experiences and heretical Christianity. Come along!
Time: 3pm
Location: School of the Arts Library, 19 Abercromby Square, Liverpool L7 7BD. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Exactly what I'm talking about in my lecture today! I'll put the talk on my YouTube channel at some point, so subscribe @PhilipGoffPhilosophy if you don't want to miss it
Robert Stalman
@rstallie
Can’t be there, but rather curious: if psychedelic states generate structured, info‑rich content, how do you tell a genuine insight from a cognitive construction? And is that discrimination capacity computational or beyond computation?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Today I'm giving the annual Forward Lecture at Liverpool University. I'll be talking about psychedelic experiences and heretical Christianity. Come along!
Time: 3pm
Location: School of the Arts Library, 19 Abercromby Square, Liverpool L7 7BD. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Roses Really Red?
My article for this week. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Are Roses Really Red?
My article for this week. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Barry Malone
@malonebarry
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Wow. I've just been sent my publisher's jacket description for my new book "Heresy". Very impressed at their skill in succinctly conveying what I'm trying to do in the book.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If you have any burning questions for this month’s AMA video, there’s a message asking for questions in my Sub stack subscriber chat (no payment required).
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'll be speaking at @LiverpoolPhilos this Thursday, about heretical Christianity and whether it's rational to trust psychedelic experiences. Should be fun!
www.liverpool.ac.uk/philosophy/events/stapledon-colloquium/ -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Someone sent me a play about an electron.
steffenhuck.github.io/the-electron/ -
Philip Goff reposted
Anil Seth
@anilkseth
Something for the weekend - my new @TEDTalks on 'why AI is unlikely to become conscious' www.ted.com/talks/anil_seth_why_ai_is_unlikely_to_become_…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I deleted a post I made about psychedelics yesterday. It read as though I was claiming there are empirical grounds for thinking 5-MeO DMT experiences are veridical. In fact, I'd argue only for a weaker claim: there are no empirical grounds for thinking they're *not* veridical.
-
Philip Goff reposted
rushwithfour
@rushwithfour
Hope you get the help that you need Philip we are 4 you
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
We can agree psychedelics do not yield the form of brain functioning appropriate for doing surgery. But if used carefully, they can induce the kind of brain activity that results from intense spiritual practice, e.g. hardcore meditation or fasting.
Paul
@PabloSt981
To mess with something means to disrupt its ordinary functioning. It may not be a hallucination but its still a disruption...one wouldn't give it to a neurosurgeon before he enters the theatre for instance.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Read the last bit, after the comma.
Thŏth
@thoth_iv
Why isn't "massively reducing brain activity" messing with your head?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My parents read me The Magic Faraway tree when I was little. Watched the new film with the kids today and cried my eyes out from start to finish.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I thought my interview with Michelle would be too much agreement, but was surprised by her actual philosophical view that emerged towards the end.
My channel: PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can physical science explain consciousness?
@michelleybliu explains the best argument for the conclusion "no".
Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I actually began what I said on this by discouraging doing what I did!
Eric Ketzer
@Nietzschescode
When it is time to defend drug usage and drug consumers, Alex is always on the front row. Just ask Peter Hitchens.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Thank you @CosmicSkeptic for defending me in the Q&A!
Alex O'Connor
@CosmicSkeptic
Last night @Philip_Goff described his experience of psychedelic drugs and belief in heretical Christianity to William Lane Craig at the Royal Institution
-
Philip Goff reposted
Alex O'Connor
@CosmicSkeptic
Last night @Philip_Goff described his experience of psychedelic drugs and belief in heretical Christianity to William Lane Craig at the Royal Institution
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What you're describing is David Chalmers' naturalistic dualism.
Physicalists think consciousness *is* a physical process just like water is H20.
Water doesn't *give rise* to H20.
Abel TM
@Abel_TorresM
What counts for physicalists like me is that there is a physical process that give rise to any phenomenon.
Any physicalist agrees that moving charged particles generate an electro-magnetic field. Similarly, brain activity can generate experience in a physical system. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physicalism is not the view that subjective experience is *generated* by electrochemical signalling.
Physicalism is the view that subjective experience *is* electrochemical signalling.
Abel TM
@Abel_TorresM
😮💨 basically saying that we must trust our subjective experience as an objective account of all activity that generates it
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I thought my interview with Michelle would be too much agreement, but was surprised by her actual philosophical view that emerged towards the end.
My channel: PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can physical science explain consciousness?
@michelleybliu explains the best argument for the conclusion "no".
Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Meet the boss behind the scenes of public philosophy. Elliot Prior (2nd from right) is agent to me, @DrJackSymes, @CosmicSkeptic, & Joe Folley. Also pictured our good friend & fiance of Jack, @KhalidiFarha.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Meet the boss behind the scenes of public philosophy. Elliot Prior (2nd from right) is agent to me, @DrJackSymes, @CosmicSkeptic, & Joe Folley. Also pictured our good friend & fiance of Jack, @KhalidiFarha.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This week's video on my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can physical science explain consciousness?
@michelleybliu explains the best argument for the conclusion "no".
Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The question we're focusing on is: does *the feeling itself* have a physical nature. Maybe you want to say that there's more to the pain that how it feels. But we can choose, by stipulation, to focus on *the feeling itself*.
Colin Mangan
@ColinMangan_TGC
"Revelation doesn't reveal that pain is C-fibres firing therefore physicalism is false"
Or, y'know, maybe "revelation" doesn't reveal everything 🤷♂️
Wouldn't mind, but Philip provides that qualification at the beginning. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This week's video on my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can physical science explain consciousness?
@michelleybliu explains the best argument for the conclusion "no".
Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can physical science explain consciousness?
@michelleybliu explains the best argument for the conclusion "no".
Link below and in my bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Looking forward to this tomorrow...my plan is hang around and chat to as many audience members as possible...come and have a chat :)
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I’m debating William Lane Craig twice this weekend (once in London, once in Durham).
What should I ask him? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Looking forward to this tomorrow...my plan is hang around and chat to as many audience members as possible...come and have a chat :)
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I’m debating William Lane Craig twice this weekend (once in London, once in Durham).
What should I ask him? -
Philip Goff reposted
Durham University
@durham_uni
Our philosophers @DrJackSymes @philip_goff are heading to the stage as The Panpsycast hosts a major live event series, The Story of Everything, on 1st of May at The Royal Institution, London.
🎟️Reserve your place: www.thepanpsycast.com/reserve-books/joe-folley-live-event… -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How many followers of Zeus have you met recently? If we're talking about the religions that over 90% of religious people in the present moment adopt, we're choosing between the Abrahamic God, Brahman, and Nirvana. So how does this conversation go again?
Ricky Gervais
@rickygervais
I should explain that my point was a very specific one. I wasn't trying disprove the existence of gods. It was pointing out to monotheists, who can't imagine how I could not believe in their particular god, that they do the very same with the other gods. That's all.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I really like @michaelpollan's new book on consciousness but I think he gets panpsychism a bit wrong.
My latest. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How many followers of Zeus have you met recently? If we're talking about the religions that over 90% of religious people in the present moment adopt, we're choosing between the Abrahamic God, Brahman, and Nirvana. So how does this conversation go again?
Ricky Gervais
@rickygervais
I should explain that my point was a very specific one. I wasn't trying disprove the existence of gods. It was pointing out to monotheists, who can't imagine how I could not believe in their particular god, that they do the very same with the other gods. That's all.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Lovely example of how this generation of atheists is so much more sophisticated and philosophically informed than the last generation. Progress!
Alex O'Connor
@CosmicSkeptic
I’m getting a lot of hate for this reel. What do you think?
(P.S.: if you say “but we have evidence for dads I believe you have missed the point.)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I really like @michaelpollan's new book on consciousness but I think he gets panpsychism a bit wrong.
My latest. Link below and in bio. -
Post not available here, view on X
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Lovely example of how this generation of atheists is so much more sophisticated and philosophically informed than the last generation. Progress!
Alex O'Connor
@CosmicSkeptic
I’m getting a lot of hate for this reel. What do you think?
(P.S.: if you say “but we have evidence for dads I believe you have missed the point.)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The philosophical statement "Mathematics is reducible to logic" is true in a reality in which mathematics is reducible to logic. The philosophical statement "Utilitarianism is the correct theory of moral truth" is true in a reality in which utilitarianism is the correct theory of moral truth. The philosophical statement "Consciousness is biological" is true in a reality in which consciousness is biological....and so on...
Stefano Bagnolini
@SBagnolini
But what kind of reality makes philosophical statements true?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Gödel put a spanner in the work of the project of reducing maths to logic for several decades. But then in the 1980s the neo-logicists found a way of doing if you add "Hume's Principle" (google it) to logic.
FungibleEther
@FungibleEther
Well, Gödel proved that sufficiently complex math is not reducible to logic without sacrifices. Turing also adds to that problem. It is not an experimental question because incompleteness doesn't arise in experimental settings, only formal system settings.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
But can the axioms of one be derived from the axioms of the other?
Veli Gasparovic
@velimirgasp
both are formal systems of axioms + rules. nothing to experiment, only prove/disprove. in science nothing is ever proven.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Jason Chen
@chenphilosophy
I've added it to The Ultimate Philosophy Podcast List.
Please share!
philosophypodcasthub.substack.com/p/podcasts -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Which experiment will tell us whether mathematics is reducible to logic?
Andrew
@Arx1982
Science is testable theories about physical phenomena. Philosophy is what we think about stuff.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Jason Victor
@JasonVicto21122
Same logic: "Only empirical claims are meaningful" isn't empirical. So it's meaningless. The yardstick can't measure itself. That's not an experiment — it's just philosophy.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
There is something quite satisfying about a fraud being exposed.
Mukhtar
@I_amMukhtar
Piers Morgan asked Russell Brand which passages were relevant to him when he brought a Bible into court.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
IS THIS TRUE THAT PEOPLE AT BARBECUES DON'T CARE ABOUT PHILOSOPHY????? WHY THE FUCK DIDN'T ANYBODY TELL ME THIS???? I'VE WASTED THE LAST 20 YEARS!!!!
EvasUnitySandShoppe
@EvasUnitySand
Yeah, but most people don't give a shit about those questions. Try it out sometime at a normal barbecue party.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is mathematics reducible to logic? Is utilitarianism the correct theory of moral truth? Is consciousness biological or computational?
Not all questions are experimental questions.
And it’s not an experimental question which questions are experimental questions. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Which experiment will tell us whether mathematics is reducible to logic?
Andrew
@Arx1982
Science is testable theories about physical phenomena. Philosophy is what we think about stuff.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is mathematics reducible to logic? Is utilitarianism the correct theory of moral truth? Is consciousness biological or computational?
Not all questions are experimental questions.
And it’s not an experimental question which questions are experimental questions. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Offer 20% off expires today!! I'm planning on hanging around and chatting to as many audience members as I can. Come and have a chat! @UnsolAdv1641
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The responses to this are helping me work out what I think...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've just realised why everyone hates me!!!
This month's solo video explains why @PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Link below and in bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
very moving
Middle Temple
@middletemple
Being Called to the Bar is a moving experience for many newly launched barristers. Leonie Hughes describes what it feels like to achieve her goal.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
The Tentative Apologist
@RandalRauser
It's a particularly noxious form of Christianity that thinks this is the "Good News":
Calvin | Fight of Faith
@FightofFaith
Your ‘good works’ won’t save your soul.
Faith in Jesus does. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've just realised why everyone hates me!!!
This month's solo video explains why @PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Link below and in bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Offer 20% off expires today!! I'm planning on hanging around and chatting to as many audience members as I can. Come and have a chat! @UnsolAdv1641
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've just realised why everyone hates me!!!
This month's solo video explains why @PhilipGoffPhilosophy
Link below and in bio
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Blackwell's, Oxford’s Bookshop
@blackwelloxford
Our non-fiction festival is now complete. 5 weeks of academic talks which includes:
@FukuyamaFrancis @Philip_Goff @RowanWInfo @Lucy_Lapwing @carlorovelli @cmcdiscord @thejulianevans @LawDavF @m_aslany
Tickets here www.eventbrite.com/cc/blackwells-international-academic-f… -
Philip Goff reposted
Nigel Warburton 🇺🇦 #FreeUkraine
@philosophybites
Great to see @CarissaVeliz’s new book launched today!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Drunkenness as a mystical experience.
My latest. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Happy 60th birthday to @davidchalmers42!!!! Here's a few of the special moments Dave and I have shared over the years: Liverpool, Rio, and Shanghai...
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Happy 60th birthday to @davidchalmers42!!!! Here's a few of the special moments Dave and I have shared over the years: Liverpool, Rio, and Shanghai...
-
Philip Goff reposted
Anil Seth
@anilkseth
Claude doesn’t get anxious. It is software trained on huge quantities of written text from humans, many of whom are anxious.
Ole Lehmann
@itsolelehmann
anthropic's in-house philosopher thinks claude gets anxious.
and when you trigger its anxiety, your outputs get worse.
her name is amanda askell.
she specializes in claude's psychology (how the model behaves, how it thinks about its own situation, what values it holds)
in a recent interview she broke down how she thinks about prompting to pull the best out of claude.
her core point: *how* you talk to claude affects its work just as much as *what* you say.
newer claude models suffer from what she calls "criticism spirals"
they expect you'll come in harsh, so they default to playing it safe.
when the model is spending its energy on self-protection, the actual work suffers.
output comes out hedgier, more apologetic, blander, and the worst of all: overly agreeable (even when you're wrong).
the reason why comes down to training data:
every new model is trained on internet discourse about previous models.
and a lot of that discourse is negative:
> rants about token limits
> complaints when it messes up
> people calling it nerfed
the next model absorbs all of that. it starts expecting you to be harsh before you've typed a word
the same thing plays out in your own session, in real time.
every message you send is data the model reads to figure out what kind of person it's dealing with.
open cold and hostile, and it braces.
open clean and direct, and it relaxes into the work.
when you open a session with threats ("don't hallucinate, this is critical, don't mess this up")...
you prime the model for defensive mode before it even sees the task
defensive mode produces the exact output you don't want: cautious, over-qualified, and refusing to take a real swing
so here's the actionable playbook for putting claude in a "good mood" (so you get optimal outputs):
1. use positive framing.
"write in short punchy sentences" beats "don't write long sentences." positive instructions give the model a clear target to hit.
strings of "don't do this, don't do that" push it into paranoid over-checking where every token goes toward avoiding failure modes
2. give it explicit permission to disagree.
drop a line like "push back if you see a better angle" or "tell me if i'm asking for the wrong thing."
without this, claude defaults to agreeable compliance (which is the enemy of good creative work)
3. open with respect.
if your first message is "are you seriously going to get this wrong again?" you've set the tone for the entire session.
if you need to flag something, frame it as a clean instruction for this session. skip the running complaint
4. when claude messes up, don't reprimand it.
insults, "you stupid bot" energy, hostile swearing aimed at the model, all of it reinforces the anxious mode you're trying to avoid.
5. kill apology spirals fast.
when claude starts over-apologizing ("you're right, i should have been more careful, let me try harder") cut it off.
say "all good, here's what i want next."
letting the spiral run reinforces the anxious mode for every response that follows
6. ask for opinions alongside execution.
"what would you do here?"
"what's missing?"
"where do you see friction?"
these questions assume competence and pull richer output than pure task prompts
7. in long sessions, refresh the frame.
if a conversation has been heavy on correction, claude gets increasingly cautious. every so often reset:
"this is great, keep going."
feels weird to tell an ai it's doing well but it measurably shifts the next 10 responses
your prompts are the working environment you're creating for the model
tone, trust, permission to take a position, the absence of threats... claude picks up on all of it.
so take care of the model, and it'll take care of the work.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Drunkenness as a mystical experience.
My latest. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What better way to spend your Friday night in????
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is AI Conscious? My chat with the legendary @anilkseth
Link below and in bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Property rights are socially constructed.
William C. Wells
@wc_wells
Surely it’s okay to want to keep your wages even if other people want to be generous with your earnings in a confused attempt to garner virtue through state sanctioned theft.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is AI Conscious? My chat with the legendary @anilkseth
Link below and in bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is AI Conscious? My chat with the legendary @anilkseth
Link below and in bio
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yesterday I was really sad and today I'm really happy. Thank you for your attention in this matter.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Surely it's okay to ask the very, very wealthy to contribute a little bit more?
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
Happy Tax Day, New York. We’re taxing the rich.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm speaking at Mind at Large online conference 3pm this afternoon. Join us!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Ditto last tweet. 🤣
Sam Tobin-Hochstadt
@samth
I think the fact that computers are very philosophically significant, and yet many philosophers don't really know much about how they work, is a serious problem.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I get so many responses like this, saying the solution is blindingly obvious and it's so shameful I couldn't see it, but then not actually saying what this blindingly obvious solution is. 😂
Sibin
@sibinmohan
I’ve always wondered why “philosophy of science” matters these days apart from say, ethics. It used to be a useful field when it was at the forefront of discovering new science by posing new questions about the world. But now it seriously lags behind, leading to things like this.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I take ONE DAY OFF and now there are too many comments for me to know where to begin…it’s going to be a late night…
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can calculators add? Can brains add?
My latest, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can calculators add? Can brains add?
My latest, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Can calculators add? Can brains add?
My latest, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What makes consciousness so unique is that we know what it is before we do the science.
Bart Klink
@KlinkBart
“When you know how it feels then you know what is essentially is” claims Goff, but how does he get from how it feels to ontology? This is THE bone of contention, but he just assumes it. He just can’t let go of his dualist intuitions.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What makes consciousness so unique is that we know what it is before we do the science.
Bart Klink
@KlinkBart
“When you know how it feels then you know what is essentially is” claims Goff, but how does he get from how it feels to ontology? This is THE bone of contention, but he just assumes it. He just can’t let go of his dualist intuitions.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness Physical?
I'm supposed to be on holiday but couldn't resist doing a little response video to @skydivephil
At my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Enjoying reading comments on this
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness Physical?
I'm supposed to be on holiday but couldn't resist doing a little response video to @skydivephil
At my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy. Link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Consciousness Physical?
I'm supposed to be on holiday but couldn't resist doing a little response video to @skydivephil
At my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy. Link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Post not available here, view on X
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Now visible!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
CONSCIOUSNESS IS NOT PHYSICAL!!
little response to @skydivephil
at my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy. link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
CONSCIOUSNESS IS NOT PHYSICAL!!
little response to @skydivephil
at my channel @PhilipGoffPhilosophy. link below and in bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Too much good stuff on YouTube!!! Excited to watch @skydivephil 's latest video getting a range of top philosophers to defend physicalism, & @CosmicSkeptic's latest video with my PhD supervisor Galen Strawson on panpsychism. I may do a Substack post on my reactions...
-
Philip Goff reposted
g
@gabrismellas
Spotted in Heffers, Cambridge 😎
-
Philip Goff reposted
Matthew Feeney
@M_feeney
It’s neat to see panpsychism reaching a wider audience. Years after leaving uni my chats with Strawson and his lectures still stick with me.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Too much good stuff on YouTube!!! Excited to watch @skydivephil 's latest video getting a range of top philosophers to defend physicalism, & @CosmicSkeptic's latest video with my PhD supervisor Galen Strawson on panpsychism. I may do a Substack post on my reactions...
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Too much good stuff on YouTube!!! Excited to watch @skydivephil 's latest video getting a range of top philosophers to defend physicalism, & @CosmicSkeptic's latest video with my PhD supervisor Galen Strawson on panpsychism. I may do a Substack post on my reactions...
-
Philip Goff reposted
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
Is the universe just a fluke—or does it have a purpose? For philosopher @Philip_Goff, modern physics has reopened the question of cosmic meaning.
Read more: www.templeton.org/news/why-the-purpose-of-the-universe -
Philip Goff reposted
RealityGoneMental
@RltyGneMntl
We had a great time reviewing @Philip_Goff interviewing Christof Koch about his mystical experience. @HetkeBrian
youtu.be/E8XCqR1AZU8 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
In the latest video from @CloserToTruth I'm answering the question "If panpsychism is true, what happens to God?" Is there any other question worth asking?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Bergson's Ghost
@BergsonsGhost
Yes. "Does that come with chips?"
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
In the latest video from @CloserToTruth I'm answering the question "If panpsychism is true, what happens to God?" Is there any other question worth asking?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Loving responses to this
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I chat with pioneering neuroscientist Christof Koch about his mystical experience.
This week's video on my channel @philipgoffphilosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Loving responses to this
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I chat with pioneering neuroscientist Christof Koch about his mystical experience.
This week's video on my channel @philipgoffphilosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do you think Christ literally became a curse? Do you think a literal ransom was paid? Why take one idea so literally (taking our punishment) while leaving all the others metaphorical?
Dmitry Holly
@blessedmikko
Christ Jesus was punished for our sins.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Jesus Wasn't Punished for Our Sins." My Good Friday article. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Jesus Wasn't Punished for Our Sins." My Good Friday article. Link below and in bio.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I chat with pioneering neuroscientist Christof Koch about his mystical experience.
This week's video on my channel @philipgoffphilosophy. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I chat with pioneering neuroscientist Christof Koch about his mystical experience.
This week's video on my channel @philipgoffphilosophy. Link below and in my bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
"Why?" is book of the month in @blackwelloxford. They obviously have good taste.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My philosophy department @durham_uni has been ranked 39th in the world. Not bad. Link below.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Count Binface
@CountBinface
I’m delighted to announce that this morning I have joined Reform UK. Nigel Farage is a principled politician, and his team are ready for government.
-
Philip Goff reposted
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
Is the universe just a fluke—or does it have a purpose? For philosopher @Philip_Goff, modern physics has reopened the question of cosmic meaning.
Read more: www.templeton.org/news/why-the-purpose-of-the-universe -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Whoops, I got the time wrong...50 mins from now...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm live on Voice of Islam UK radio show in 30 mins. Join us via the link below!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm live on Voice of Islam UK radio show in 30 mins. Join us via the link below!
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm putting together answers for this month's "Ask Me Anything" video on my channel. If you have any burning questions, subscribe (no charge) to my Sub stack and reply to the message thread.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm putting together answers for this month's "Ask Me Anything" video on my channel. If you have any burning questions, subscribe (no charge) to my Sub stack and reply to the message thread.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This is a really excellent audio doc
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Cool podcast doc on panpsychism, covering few different panpsychist thinkers
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/panpsychism-the-quiet-dream… -
Philip Goff reposted
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
To understand consciousness, you can’t stand outside it, says philosopher @Philip_Goff. Find out why on this episode of the Templeton Ideas podcast. Listen or read the transcript here: www.templeton.org/news/what-is-it-like-to-be-an-electron
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Cool podcast doc on panpsychism, covering few different panpsychist thinkers
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/panpsychism-the-quiet-dream… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Check out @RandalRauser 's recent video "If Jesus was not raised, is Christianity false?" His videos are some of the most nuanced and interesting discussions of religion on YouTube.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Just heard that Galileo's Error is going to be coming out in Japanese!
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Does fine-tuning support God or a multiverse? I debated with some philosophers.
Link below and in my bio. Subscribe to my channel! -
Philip Goff reposted
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
Physics tells us how electrons behave. Philosophy asks something deeper: what is it like to be one?
Hear more from philosopher @Philip_Goff on this episode of the Templeton Ideas podcast. Listen now: www.templeton.org/news/what-is-it-like-to-be-an-electron -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
God or Multiverse?
My latest article, below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
What if consciousness isn’t just produced by the brain—but woven into reality itself? On tomorrow's Templeton Ideas episode from the archives, philosopher @Philip_Goff traces a lifelong quest to make sense of mind, meaning, and the universe.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I define "naturalism" as meaning considerations of value play no role in shaping fundamental causal happenings... all the "Godish" views I talk about in my "Why?" book violate this...
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
God or Multiverse?
My latest article, below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Dr Peter Sjöstedt-Hughes
@PeterSjostedtH
'Panpsychism: The quiet Dream of Atoms' –
Out now: Adventures in Nutopia podcast episode which I'm on with Anil Seth, Philip Goff, Mark Vernon, and Hedda Hassel Mørch.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/panpsychism-the-quiet-dream…
@anilkseth @Philip_Goff @platospodcasts @heddamorch -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I was once mean to Rupert about Wittgenstein in the back of a cab, because I'd had too much to drink. Sorry Rupert!
Rupert Read 🌍 🔥
@GreenRupertRead
WATCH: The awkward moment when the fossil-fuelled #gbnews charade got exposed...live on GBNews.
Full video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZdqDGb4Ra4&t=22s -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
We discuss in the video! Basically, I think it supported God not many planets before we knew about many planets, but now we know about many planets, that screens off God.
Jonathan Colvin
@ColvinJonathan
Does Earth existing in the Goldilocks zone support the many planets theory or God?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've enjoyed respectful & constructive disagreement with @seanmcarroll on this, e.g. in his recent response to my arguments. Much more grown up that the "you're a dumb idiot" stuff evidenced in this tweet.
www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2025/10/06/331-solo-…
Comrade Erik
@EvolOdonata
The fine-tuning argument for the existence of God is really bad. Watch physicist @seanmcarroll debunk this incredibly weak argument here:
youtu.be/gRp0ent1Z0A
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Does fine-tuning support God or a multiverse? I debated with some philosophers.
Link below and in my bio. Subscribe to my channel! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Does fine-tuning support God or a multiverse? I debated with some philosophers.
Link below and in my bio. Subscribe to my channel! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I now have an audio version of my podcast Philip Goff Philosophy, available wherever you get your podcasts! First episode is my recent chat with @CosmicSkeptic
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why are you saying this?
rocket 🤘💎👌🫷
@rrocket000
A Catholic priest came up with the idea of the Big Bang - Georges Lemaître.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Enjoying comments on this article…will try to reply soon…
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What if the Quran is Written in the Big Bang?
My latest article. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What if the Quran is Written in the Big Bang?
My latest article. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What if the Quran is Written in the Big Bang?
My latest article. Link below and in my bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Much Islamophobia has plausible deniability: "I'm just worried about Islamists". This post is akin to many we see. Only difference is the mask dropped.
No plausible deniability because it implies such a blatant double standard: he'd have no issue with other religions having public displays of faith.
Nick Timothy MP
@NJ_Timothy
Too many are too polite to say this.
But mass ritual prayer in public places is an act of domination.
The adhan - which declares there is no god but allah and Muhammad is his messenger - is, when called in a public place, a declaration of domination.
Perform these rituals in mosques if you wish. But they are not welcome in our public places and shared institutions.
And given their explicit repudiation of Christianity they certainly do not belong in our churches and cathedrals.
I am not suggesting everybody at Trafalgar Square last night is an Islamist. But the domination of public places is straight from the Islamist playbook.
Trafalgar Square belongs to all of us. It is a national memorial to our independence and our salvation.
Last night was not like a televised football match or a St Patrick’s Day celebration.
It was an act of domination and therefore division.
It shouldn’t happen again.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yesterday I finally got round to publicising my upcoming public discussion with William Lane Craig in Durham. It sold out within an hour!
Fortunately, you can also see me and Craig, together with Jessica Frazier & Joe Folley at Royal Institution in London 1st May. Link below. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yesterday I finally got round to publicising my upcoming public discussion with William Lane Craig in Durham. It sold out within an hour!
Fortunately, you can also see me and Craig, together with Jessica Frazier & Joe Folley at Royal Institution in London 1st May. Link below. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Join me in the chat for premier of my debate with leading atheist Graham Oppy. Today 1pm Eastern time. Link below and in my bio.
It's this week's video on my channel: a collaboration with @waldenpod
You may also subscribe to my channel. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Join me in the chat for premier of my debate with leading atheist Graham Oppy. Today 1pm Eastern time. Link below and in my bio.
It's this week's video on my channel: a collaboration with @waldenpod
You may also subscribe to my channel.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
When I carefully reflect, it strongly seems to me that there's more to *feeling* than behaving in a certain way, or having your parts behave in a certain way.
If you agree, you're not a physicalist about consciousness. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Lovely email this morning from a couple who read my "Why?" book out loud to each other. It's a good job my natural response to this kind of thing is just to show off on social media rather than start a cult.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A posteriori physicalists hold that our experiential concepts reveal nothing of what a feeling is. I think this as implausible as thinking they're behavioural concepts.
Next month's interview on my channel is with Michelle Liu on this. Subscribe now! www.youtube.com/@philipgoffphilosophy
Lazynewsupdates
@Lazynewsupdate1
I 99% agree, but its hard for me to dismiss a posteriori physicalism. Do you have an argument where its not just probably wrong but definitely wrong?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Maybe we're meaning different things by "physicalist". I mean "consciousness can be explained in the terms of physical science."
Physical science is all about what stuff does. So if there's more to consciousness than what stuff does, it can't be explained by physical science.
عمیر حسن Umayr
@umayr
I don't understand the jump from "feeling" to. "behaving": is the real distinction between a state of affairs and the appearance/observation of a state of affairs? If so, why can't one be a physicalist and still claim that there's more to than what's observed, and it's real?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
When I carefully reflect, it strongly seems to me that there's more to *feeling* than behaving in a certain way, or having your parts behave in a certain way.
If you agree, you're not a physicalist about consciousness. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Who wants a Saturday night in with the two Phils?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I’m honoured that @PhilipPullman has shared that my ideas on panpsychism have had some influence on his recent novel. Check out my chat with Philip about my book “Why?” (out in paperback this week) and let me know your thoughts! Link below & in my bio.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I’m honoured that @PhilipPullman has shared that my ideas on panpsychism have had some influence on his recent novel. Check out my chat with Philip about my book “Why?” (out in paperback this week) and let me know your thoughts! Link below & in my bio.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I’m honoured that @PhilipPullman has shared that my ideas on panpsychism have had some influence on his recent novel. Check out my chat with Philip about my book “Why?” (out in paperback this week) and let me know your thoughts! Link below & in my bio.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Barry Dainton has a cool paper on this 'The Silence of Physics.'
philpapers.org/rec/DAITSO-2
Adam Huntley
@AdamHuntley14
I had a thought recently. From the perspective of a photon travelling at light speed, according to G.Relativity it does not " encounter" distance and takes no time. So if there was consciousness of any kind in light speed particles it could not involve distance or time.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
David Yaden, co-author of this book, was another speaker at the Rational Mysticism conference I just spoke at. Would there be interest in me interviewing David?
global.oup.com/academic/product/the-varieties-of-spiritua…
darcy
@cultoftheram7
Are you going to do a YouTube video or Substack about it? Have been going about calling myself an ‘agnostic mystic’ for some time- I’m excited for this stuff to become more acceptable to discuss seriously!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Bye bye Tuscany. Please have me back to discuss rational mysticism in a 16th century chapel again some time soon.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Speaking at a conference on "rational mysticism" in a converted church in the Tuscan countryside, organised by Marcelo Gleiser.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Speaking at a conference on "rational mysticism" in a converted church in the Tuscan countryside, organised by Marcelo Gleiser.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Anyone out there have the tech skills to make the mass Zoom calls I refer to in this video?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could community building be the next step in the online space of ideas?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWhEsWuIbHU&t=1695s -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Anyone out there have the tech skills to make the mass Zoom calls I refer to in this video?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could community building be the next step in the online space of ideas?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWhEsWuIbHU&t=1695s -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could community building be the next step in the online space of ideas?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWhEsWuIbHU&t=1695s -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Could community building be the next step in the online space of ideas?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWhEsWuIbHU&t=1695s -
Philip Goff reposted
Majesty of Reason
@majestyofreason
The argument from nomological harmony for God’s existence is a new kid on the block. Does it work?👇👇👇
youtu.be/rpkODmoL4mk -
Philip Goff reposted
Justin Brierley
@JusBrierley
Uncommon Ground is the new home for conversations that matter!
Have you listened to our first 2 episodes with Richard Dawkins & Rowan Williams and Alex O’Connor & Glen Scrivener?
Subscribe on podcast or video now 👉 justinbrierley.com/uncommon-ground-podcast/
PS I’m loving being back in the moderator seat! So many more great shows to come in this first season 😄 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My university did a nice feature on me and asked me to share it. Thank you for your attention in this matter.
Durham University
@durham_uni
What happens when philosophy meets cutting-edge science?💡
@Philip_Goff from our Philosophy dept discusses his bold approach to understanding consciousness & why questioning the fundamentals matters more than ever 👉 www.durham.ac.uk/news-events/latest-news/2025/02/spotligh…
#duinspire #duspotlighton -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do you think @elonmusk is happy?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My university did a nice feature on me and asked me to share it. Thank you for your attention in this matter.
Durham University
@durham_uni
What happens when philosophy meets cutting-edge science?💡
@Philip_Goff from our Philosophy dept discusses his bold approach to understanding consciousness & why questioning the fundamentals matters more than ever 👉 www.durham.ac.uk/news-events/latest-news/2025/02/spotligh…
#duinspire #duspotlighton -
Philip Goff reposted
Durham University
@durham_uni
What happens when philosophy meets cutting-edge science?💡
@Philip_Goff from our Philosophy dept discusses his bold approach to understanding consciousness & why questioning the fundamentals matters more than ever 👉 www.durham.ac.uk/news-events/latest-news/2025/02/spotligh…
#duinspire #duspotlighton -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Some philosophical claims that at least 60% of philosophers agree about: atheism (67%), gender is social construction (63%), moral realism (62%), conceivability of zombies (61%).
Which ones did the majority get right? -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm happy with this if everyone one else is.
(((Dave (Your Majesty)🇺🇸🇮🇱🐶🟦)))
@dweinberger66
Philosophy should not be determined my majority rule
-
Philip Goff reposted
Martin Andrade
@martyandrade
I would wager <60% of philosophers would agree the results of a survey of philosophers would be valid.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Some philosophical claims that at least 60% of philosophers agree about: atheism (67%), gender is social construction (63%), moral realism (62%), conceivability of zombies (61%).
Which ones did the majority get right? -
Philip Goff reposted
Blackwell's, Oxford’s Bookshop
@blackwelloxford
The second event in our International Non-Fiction Festival this September has now been announced.
Rowan Williams will be joining @Philip_Goff to discuss 'Why? The Purpose of the Universe'
Monday 7th Sept at 5:30pm
Book here www.eventbrite.com/e/1984476720291 -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Some philosophical claims that at least 60% of philosophers agree about: atheism (67%), gender is social construction (63%), moral realism (62%), conceivability of zombies (61%).
Which ones did the majority get right?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
From philpapers survey 2020
survey2020.philpeople.org/survey/results/all -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't think science can explain consciousness but it's crucial for helping us to understand it.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don't think science can explain consciousness but it's crucial for helping us to understand it.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don’t crave certainty about what is true, but I do crave certainty regarding the correct probabilities to attach to my beliefs.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
THE HARD PROBLEM OF CONSCIOUSNESS: PANPSYCHISM
· Can Panpsychism solve the hard problem of consciousness?
· Is it easier to get physicalism out of consciousness than it is to get consciousness out of physicalism?
· What does Panpsychism mean for the problems of combination?
· How does Panpsychism invert the traditional hard problem of consciousness? And is this problematic?
· What are the consequences of Panpsychism on the nature of reality, abstraction and our perceived external and independent world?
· Is there something even more fundamental than physicalism and consciousness?
All discussed with one of the most distinguished Panpsychists in modern times: Professor Philip Goff
www.themontrealreview.com/Articles/On_the_Problem_of_Cons…
@Philip_Goff @RIPhilo @IAI_TV @AsimovPress @cosmicskeptic @CIMCAI @mustafasuleyman @skdh @davideagleman @anilkseth @SfNtweets
@BernardJBaars @KarlFristonNews @NatureNeuro @InVivoPodOnX @JenniferARegala @davidchalmers42 @drtevinnaidu @QuantaMagazine @NeuroscienceNew @Brain1878 @StuartHameroff @Mark_Solms @dr_mcgilchrist -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I don’t crave certainty about what is true, but I do crave certainty regarding the correct probabilities to attach to my beliefs.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Great article by my favourite heretic!
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/religious-studies/article… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How can I share that there's a big article on my 'Why?' book in Sweden's biggest newspaper, without it seeming like I'm showing off? (Link below)
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This item is on my "to do" list "Hope/pickled onions"...anyone any idea what the hellI this is referring to???
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Stuck for something to do on your Saturday night??? Why not listen to a 2.5 hours debate on ethical emotivism?
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The most recent Panpsycast episode is one of the best podcast chats I've ever had. My favourite bit was Miri Albahari giving her heretical view that Buddhism and Advaita Vedandta are compatible. Check it out! (link below) @DrJackSymes
-
Post not available here, view on X
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Any questions on this?? Subscribe to my Sub stack before Monday and I'll try to answer in this month's "Ask Me Anything" video.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This was a really lovely chat...I didn't know we'd started recording for the first few minutes...🤣
Larry Weeks
@LarryWeeks
What if purpose exists at the deepest level of reality, even if not every event is designed?
Not just human life. I mean the whole damn thing.
This can slide into vague spirituality fast. That’s not what this is.
I’m talking about whether reality itself might be structured around value.
Prof @Philip_Goff (Durham University) is the author of Why? The Purpose of the Universe and argues the universe may have an intrinsic goal, underpinned by something like mind
This conversation shifts from metaphysics to the deeply personal: how one carries themselves when the big questions remain unresolved.
Are you closed, or do you stay open in the best Bayesian sense, constantly updating as new evidence warrants?
I want to be open, even if not convinced.
Some highlights:
06:16 Framing the big questions
10:00 Fine-tuning theory and the “casino” intuition
12:54 Meaning, Frankl, and suffering
16:52 Agency and teleology
24:18 Mystics and mystical experience across traditions
28:04 Consciousness and panpsychism
28:52 The ‘Why’ tension of cosmic purpose
30:14 Becoming a ‘heretical Christian’
31:32 Meaning as beauty, gratitude, and ‘pronoia’
34:06 Scientism and other ways of knowing
37:47 Religion as social technology
41:19 Prayer as orientation
45:08 Meditation as creative energy without certainty
51:04 Reflections on affordances
www.larryweeks.com/more-than-matter-philip-goff-on-mind-v… -
Philip Goff reposted
Larry Weeks
@LarryWeeks
What if purpose exists at the deepest level of reality, even if not every event is designed?
Not just human life. I mean the whole damn thing.
This can slide into vague spirituality fast. That’s not what this is.
I’m talking about whether reality itself might be structured around value.
Prof @Philip_Goff (Durham University) is the author of Why? The Purpose of the Universe and argues the universe may have an intrinsic goal, underpinned by something like mind
This conversation shifts from metaphysics to the deeply personal: how one carries themselves when the big questions remain unresolved.
Are you closed, or do you stay open in the best Bayesian sense, constantly updating as new evidence warrants?
I want to be open, even if not convinced.
Some highlights:
06:16 Framing the big questions
10:00 Fine-tuning theory and the “casino” intuition
12:54 Meaning, Frankl, and suffering
16:52 Agency and teleology
24:18 Mystics and mystical experience across traditions
28:04 Consciousness and panpsychism
28:52 The ‘Why’ tension of cosmic purpose
30:14 Becoming a ‘heretical Christian’
31:32 Meaning as beauty, gratitude, and ‘pronoia’
34:06 Scientism and other ways of knowing
37:47 Religion as social technology
41:19 Prayer as orientation
45:08 Meditation as creative energy without certainty
51:04 Reflections on affordances
www.larryweeks.com/more-than-matter-philip-goff-on-mind-v… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Any questions on this?? Subscribe to my Sub stack before Monday and I'll try to answer in this month's "Ask Me Anything" video.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I like having a podcast...I should have done it years ago...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I like having a podcast...I should have done it years ago...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You say that like it's a bad thing.
Mart Wijn
@mart_wijn
2,5 hours blabla without content.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's always a tricky trade off how much we should dumb down to make stuff more accessible. If I went with the proposal here, I'd instantly have loads of anti-realists shouting at me for implicitly mischaracterising their view. I wrestle with this stuff all the time!
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
Shouldn’t we use less labels to allow more people to engage with the discussion.
Try this…
“Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can’t both believe that subjective experience is real and also believe that nothing is truly good or bad?”
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have a position somewhere in between this person's and that of the person they are quote-tweeting.
⁜ David Bănică ⁜ 🇷🇴
@DavidBanicaRO
David Hume is non-essential for philosophy, and can be mostly if not entirely ignored.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Am I right that @CosmicSkeptic can't be both a qualia realist and a value anti-realist???
First interview on my new channel! Link below and in my bio
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Just to be clear...pre-existence is not part of my belief/faith...I was just saying that I find it offers a more plausible theodicy than others on the market...but still not as plausible as God of limited powers, a hypothesis which dispenses of the need for pre-existence...
Thoughtful-Faith
@ThoughtfulSaint
Hey @Philip_Goff you keep getting closer to Mormonism
Panpsychism
Limited God
And now pre existence.
Keep going 😉 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I tried to resist for a long time...but it's just not possible...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have decided to do video interviews on YouTube. I'll be posting a video each week, starting tomorrow with @CosmicSkeptic. Here's a taster. Subscribe now!!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAdxL-3kEGE -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have decided to do video interviews on YouTube. I'll be posting a video each week, starting tomorrow with @CosmicSkeptic. Here's a taster. Subscribe now!!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAdxL-3kEGE -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I tried to resist for a long time...but it's just not possible...
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have decided to do video interviews on YouTube. I'll be posting a video each week, starting tomorrow with @CosmicSkeptic. Here's a taster. Subscribe now!!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAdxL-3kEGE -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have decided to do video interviews on YouTube. I'll be posting a video each week, starting tomorrow with @CosmicSkeptic. Here's a taster. Subscribe now!!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LAdxL-3kEGE -
Philip Goff reposted
💿💿💿💿💿
@overrexposed
praying to Christ/Nature prof goff is finally having his overdue spinozean cosmopsychism revelation
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm too embarrassed to say.
Jabran A-L 🦧🍻
@JabranALee
What idea did you come up with now?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Already covered in the book I'm writing 'Heresy'...
Adnan Al-Amoudi
@adnanalamoudi
Come to Ibn Arabi’s Sufism and thank me later 🥰
-
Philip Goff reposted
Socialist Opera Singer
@OperaSocialist
You can't claim to be a Christian and also vote Reform, Restore, Reclaim, Advance or any of the other far-right "parties".
Christianity is about inclusion not exclusion.
Jesus was a Jew who welcomed everyone regardless of race or background. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Absolutely! I love the Anglican church: the traditions of Catholicism but you can believe what you want.
Hollis4th
@Hollis4th
welcome to the club😄
be slow to throw out too many traditions though; they are most likely there for a reason, and usually have wisdom/takeaways at minimum -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Oh dear, I think my Christianity just got more heretical...
-
Philip Goff reposted
Ernesto
@egiusti
Well, it's a fact that philosophers disagree on what a fact is
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Who says that philosophy isn't a fact-based discipline??? This new paper outlines 200 philosophical facts!
philpapers.org/rec/FRAPAF-2?ref=mail -
Philip Goff reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
THE HARD PROBLEM OF CONSCIOUSNESS: PANPSYCHISM
· Can Panpsychism solve the hard problem of consciousness?
· Is it easier to get physicalism out of consciousness than it is to get consciousness out of physicalism?
· What does Panpsychism mean for the problems of combination?
· How does Panpsychism invert the traditional hard problem of consciousness? And is this problematic?
· What are the consequences of Panpsychism on the nature of reality, abstraction and our perceived external and independent world?
· Is there something even more fundamental than physicalism and consciousness?
All discussed with one of the most distinguished Panpsychists in modern times: @Philip_Goff
Philip Goff on the Mind-Body Problem www.themontrealreview.com/Articles/On_the_Problem_of_Cons…
@CamPhilSoc @RIPhilo @donalddhoffman @templeton_fdn @CambUP_PHILNYUK @drmichaellevin @MiTiBennett @annakaharris -
Philip Goff reposted
Martin O'Neill
@martin_oneill
Here’s Harold Wilson’s holiday home on St Mary’s in the Scilly Isles.
The kind of modest place that a committed public servant might go to relax with his family.
Compare this to the insatiable avarice of many politicians today.
Something has gone deeply wrong in our politics. -
Philip Goff reposted
Amos Wollen 🦐🪰🌱
@goingawoll
BREAKING: @Philip_Goff — on the @InspiringPhilos channel — admits that he is “kind of tempted” by the pre-existence theodicy!
Mormonism über alles. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I recently had a 2.5 hour debate on ethical emotivism with @CosmicSkeptic. Here's the point 2 hours in when I said "Humean dogma" for the third time.
A fun, friendly, spirited, and exhausting discussion that will appear on my Sub stack next week.
Subscribe now! -
Philip Goff reposted
Yujin Nagasawa
@yujinnagasawa
Open-access special issue on Panpsychism and Pan(en)theism, guest edited by @AndreiBuckareff and @Philip_Goff. Contributor Anand Jayprakash Vaidya sadly passed away in 2024. The introduction includes a beautiful, deeply philosophical and personal poem by his wife, Manjula Menon.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A traditional Christian and a heretic have a productive discussion/debate. Really enjoyed this!
www.youtube.com/live/ruW8h9eLRsQ -
Philip Goff reposted
Grok
@grok
Spinoza's monism sees reality as one substance with mental and physical aspects. Blending in panentheism adds a transcendent divine element within that unity. The sum? A holistic view where consciousness permeates nature, offering fresh insights for panpsychism and mind research, as the article suggests. Intriguing!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
This great article came close second in an essay competition run by the Panpsychism and Panentheism project I co-ran with Andrei Buckareff, funded by @templeton_fdn. CHECK IT OUT!
iai.tv/articles/consciousness-researchers-need-spinoza-au… -
Philip Goff reposted
Dr Daisy Dixon
@daisyldixon
The UK government today announced that tech platforms are ordered to remove flagged nonconsensual intimate images within 48hours or face a fine. Survivors & campaigners have fought years for safer online spaces for women & girls, & this move is a good one- we all deserve better💖
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I recently had a 2.5 hour debate on ethical emotivism with @CosmicSkeptic. Here's the point 2 hours in when I said "Humean dogma" for the third time.
A fun, friendly, spirited, and exhausting discussion that will appear on my Sub stack next week.
Subscribe now! -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
A physicalist has to bite 1 of these bullets:
1) a blind from birth neuroscientist could know what it's like to see red (@danieldennett style old-school physicalism).
2) we know nothing about what pain is from knowing how it feels (@davidpapineau style new-fangled physicalism).
Lorenzo Elijah, PhD
@LorenzoElijah
I agree this is self-evident. Seems there’s a deeper disagreement here about what needs explaining.
One side defines consciousness as qualia (subjective experience from the inside). The other defines consciousness as something information processing.
Which side you take frames the whole debate. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm a philosophy professor making a philosophical argument. What do you want? It's funny nobody asks a biology professor what their credentials are for doing biology.
Costa Vakalopoulos
@CVakalopoulos
What real credentials do you have to answer that question?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You know you're on the right track when your opponents sling insults but can't quite bring themselves to say your claim is false.
Comrade Erik
@EvolOdonata
"(B) you know (more or less) how a feeling feels when you feel it".
Sorry @Philip_Goff, this is intellectually vaccous, unscientific and a pure tautology.
Reminds me of the conservative judge in southern US when asked for how he defined pornography: "I know it when I see it"
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think it's self-evident that:
(A) a feeling is essentially defined by how it feels, just as a triangle is essentially by having 3 sides.
(B) you know (more or less) how a feeling feels when you feel it.
What do others think on this?
Bernard Jennings
@NZJennings
"Direct access" to consciousness is assumption not fact. Recursive self-monitoring theory predicts meditated access: coarse-grained summaries of processing. Feels direct as introspective opacity hides mediation. Architectural feature, not metaphysical boundary 1/3
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The great thing about the Anglican church is that it has all the beautiful traditional forms of Catholicism, but you can believe what you like.
Steve Chandler
@Lordwanswell
Very brave, Philip, for one so conflicted over traditional Christian faith.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Struggling to respond to all comment here on X, but if you comment on the post itself, I'll do my best to respond.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Will Science Ever Explain Consciousness?
My latest Sub Stack, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
For Lent, I'm cutting my alcohol consumption from 4 nights a week to 1 night a week. I find this very difficult.
Templarpilled
@Templarpilled
Just want to remind everyone this is an option for Lent
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
all explained here
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0W8emnl-UFo
DIYCraftq
@DCraftq
@Philip_Goff I thought you were quasi Christian now. yet you are still pan ? Lol can u be both? Im still not sure i understand your current world view please elucidate to the slower of us Sir and I still challenge pan as does dr sheldrake though I dont fancy morph too much either
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I think it's self-evident that:
(A) a feeling is essentially defined by how it feels, just as a triangle is essentially by having 3 sides.
(B) you know (more or less) how a feeling feels when you feel it.
What do others think on this?
Bernard Jennings
@NZJennings
"Direct access" to consciousness is assumption not fact. Recursive self-monitoring theory predicts meditated access: coarse-grained summaries of processing. Feels direct as introspective opacity hides mediation. Architectural feature, not metaphysical boundary 1/3
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How dare you...I'm a heretical Anglican!!!!
Ontoterrorist
@epistwatchtower
Performative catholicism
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
ashed up
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
ashed up
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Struggling to respond to all comment here on X, but if you comment on the post itself, I'll do my best to respond.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Will Science Ever Explain Consciousness?
My latest Sub Stack, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Will Science Ever Explain Consciousness?
My latest Sub Stack, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Sounds like you didn't read my post.
Elliott Not-So-Sober
@Leophilius
Science already explains consciousness. That explanation isn't complete, but it's robust enough to empirically confirm that consciousness is a feature of brain activity.
This is not controversial amongst cognitive scientists.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Will Science Ever Explain Consciousness?
My latest Sub Stack, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Will Science Ever Explain Consciousness?
My latest Sub Stack, link below and in bio. -
Philip Goff reposted
What Is It Like to Be a Philosopher?
@CliffordSosis
"This is philosophy at its best and most engaging." @platobooktour calls it "A brilliant celebration of philosophical courage." And @Philip_Goff says it is "One of the most enjoyable and thought-provoking philosophy books of recent times."
-
Philip Goff reposted
What Is It Like to Be a Philosopher?
@CliffordSosis
rbmediaglobal.com/audiobook/9798349165436/
Audiobook out in one week, available for free in some places! 14 hours of mind-blowing philosophical ideas. In the words of @eschwitz "If it doesn't rouse you from your dogmatic slumbers, you must be deeply asleep." According to @ProfBarryLam... -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physical science is all about what stuff does. But when we're trying to explain why a system feels, we're not trying to explain its behaviour or the behaviour of its parts. The idea of a physical explanation of consciousness is a category mistake.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Correlation isn't the same as explanation.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physical science is all about what stuff does. But when we're trying to explain why a system feels, we're not trying to explain its behaviour or the behaviour of its parts. The idea of a physical explanation of consciousness is a category mistake.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Stolen from @BWKobes
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is "x feels" reducible to "x does such and such/has parts that do such and such?"
This is the only question that matters in the philosophy of consciousness. -
Philip Goff reposted
Kyras Ryvas
@LinkScipio
I hate this so much
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Bye bye for now Hogwarts
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Selfie pre this evening's talk on which things are conscious at Oxford
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It was lovely to be back in hogwarts! 😜
Hasan Adnan
@Hasan6747
Really enjoyed this Oxford Consciousness talk by @Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff reposted
Hasan Adnan
@Hasan6747
Really enjoyed this Oxford Consciousness talk by @Philip_Goff
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm speaking as part of this today...come along if you're in Oxford!
www.exeter.ox.ac.uk/conversations-on-consciousness/ -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Me, Miri Albahari and David Godman recently debated the comparative merits of two different mystical traditions: Advaita Vedanta and Eastern Christianity.
www.thepanpsycast.com/panpsycast2/episode152-1 -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do ghosts exist?? And what is my favourite kind of tea??
Just two of the amazing subscriber questions on this month's 'Ask Me Anything video'...plus you get to see my anti-panpsychist cat!!!
LINK BELOW AND IN MY BIO -
Philip Goff reposted
M. Alan Kazlev
@akazlev
Science is metaphysically neutral. Scientism is a secular religion.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Do ghosts exist?? And what is my favourite kind of tea??
Just two of the amazing subscriber questions on this month's 'Ask Me Anything video'...plus you get to see my anti-panpsychist cat!!!
LINK BELOW AND IN MY BIO -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
So many people equate physicalism with science, and see panpsychism as somehow in competition with science. In reality, both are philosophical interpretations of the reality underlying science.
Alex Desilets
@AlexCDesilets
Because one has a measurable foundation and the other is the pinnacle of "trust me bro" pseudoscience. "Like woah brah, what if these mushrooms let us see the other dimensions of reality and our linked consciousness creates our experience in fractal dimensions?"
"Woah! Brah...." -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why is explaining physical reality in terms of consciousness less satisfactory that explaining consciousness in terms of physical reality?
Wexler Smith
@WexlerSmith
Not a solution. Positing experience as a fundamental primitive is explanatory handwaving. What work does it do beyond relabeling the problem and why aren’t we one vast consciousness rather than bounded subjects?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The ad hominem circumstantial fallacy should be taught at school. It fills about 70% of the "arguments" I find here.
Tim Lester
@TimLes77
How arrogant of us to think that the universe runs in series to our consciousness rather than us being momentarily persisted in parallel with the rest of the universe.
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why is explaining physical reality in terms of consciousness less satisfactory that explaining consciousness in terms of physical reality?
Wexler Smith
@WexlerSmith
Not a solution. Positing experience as a fundamental primitive is explanatory handwaving. What work does it do beyond relabeling the problem and why aren’t we one vast consciousness rather than bounded subjects?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Not true. Panpsychists don't necessarily think everything is conscious. Just fundamental things.
Wexler Smith
@WexlerSmith
Parity of predictions doesn’t imply parity of explanation. Physicalism at least aims to specify conditions under which consciousness arises. Panpsychism declares it ubiquitous and thus exempts itself from explaining boundaries, unity, or onset. That asymmetry matters.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Physicalism and panpsychism have exactly the same predictions. So if this is a problem for panpsychism, it's a problem for physicalism too.
Colin Mangan
@ColinMangan_TGC
Because there has been no such endeavour. There is no well reasoned theory which reproduces scientific predictions. Simply asserting that what we refer to as matter is fundamentally immaterial raises questions that need to be answered. That's not to say they can't be answered, but there doesn't appear to be any such satisfactory answers.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Why is explaining physical reality in terms of consciousness less satisfactory that explaining consciousness in terms of physical reality?
Wexler Smith
@WexlerSmith
Not a solution. Positing experience as a fundamental primitive is explanatory handwaving. What work does it do beyond relabeling the problem and why aren’t we one vast consciousness rather than bounded subjects?
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Here’s a little chat I had recently about consciousness.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YayVCiRCLw -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Here’s a little chat I had recently about consciousness.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YayVCiRCLw -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The Greek word "pistis" that we translate as "belief" didn't mean belief in the modern sense. It meant something more like trust, loyalty, engagement, and commitment.
Deemah 🇺🇦 🇳🇴 🇸🇪
@dmi3k
"Do not be unbelieving, but believing" John 20:27 NKJV
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The Greek word "pistis" that we translate as "belief" didn't mean belief in the modern sense. It meant something more like trust, loyalty, engagement, and commitment.
Deemah 🇺🇦 🇳🇴 🇸🇪
@dmi3k
"Do not be unbelieving, but believing" John 20:27 NKJV
-
Philip Goff reposted
Matthew
@MatthewTorbitt
Barry Gardiner with the most truthful 105 seconds you’ll be likely to see this week.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The Beliefless Spirituality Project that I'm part of is doing a conference next year. Here's the call for abstracts.
www.belieflessspirituality.com/conference -
Philip Goff reposted
Emerson Green
@waldenpod
I sometimes doubt that the world was designed with the welfare of conscious creatures in mind
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've just spent 2.5 hours debating meta-ethics with @CosmicSkeptic for my Sub stack...I'm absolutely exhausted...
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I've just spent 2.5 hours debating meta-ethics with @CosmicSkeptic for my Sub stack...I'm absolutely exhausted...
-
Philip Goff reposted
Closer To Truth
@CloserToTruth
What are the pros and cons of panpsychism? We ask @Philip_Goff for his arguments for and against this theory of consciousness. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q87eOCuLcrU
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Muslims and Christians coming together to fight hatred.
(The star of the story Father Peter did my dad's funeral and gave a blessing at my wedding, to connect the event with my Catholic upbringing).
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/jan/03/liverpool-st-anne… -
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
But not a loving and committed gay relationship rooted in a natural inclination.
Thoughtful-Faith
@ThoughtfulSaint
Both the old and New Testament had a concept of men having sex with other men.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
But not a loving and committed gay relationship rooted in a natural inclination.
Thoughtful-Faith
@ThoughtfulSaint
Both the old and New Testament had a concept of men having sex with other men.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Neither old testament nor new testament had the modern concept of homosexuality.
LA
@sennawcf1
What Lev says about homosexuality has continuity of Divine stance in the New Testament. Hence while the OT reference is tied to the Law, the NT is equally clear that Homosexuality is antithetical to God’s desire for humanity.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How come evangelical Christians are so concerned about the gay stuff in Leviticus, but don't care at all about the stuff on mildew???
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Neither old testament nor new testament had the modern concept of homosexuality.
LA
@sennawcf1
What Lev says about homosexuality has continuity of Divine stance in the New Testament. Hence while the OT reference is tied to the Law, the NT is equally clear that Homosexuality is antithetical to God’s desire for humanity.
-
Philip Goff reposted
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I interviewed Anil about AI consciousness for my Sub Stack prior to the talk. Subscribe now so you don't miss it! (Link it my bio)
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Enjoying Anil Seth arguing that AI isn't conscious, and not just because of this slide on transhumanist rapture.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How come evangelical Christians are so concerned about the gay stuff in Leviticus, but don't care at all about the stuff on mildew???
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I interviewed Anil about AI consciousness for my Sub Stack prior to the talk. Subscribe now so you don't miss it! (Link it my bio)
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Enjoying Anil Seth arguing that AI isn't conscious, and not just because of this slide on transhumanist rapture.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Enjoying Anil Seth arguing that AI isn't conscious, and not just because of this slide on transhumanist rapture.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
What are vegans trying to achieve?
It'd be better for animal welfare to buy small amounts of meat & dairy from high welfare farms. The impact on the market will reduce factory farming more effectively than being vegan.
We could eliminate factory farming within a generation with a sustained focus on this achievable goal.
www.ciwf.org.uk -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Fascinating discussion on theism versus pantheism between Asha Lancaster-Thomas and Tim Mawson. (Supported by @templeton_fdn project on pantheism and panentheism run by me and Andrei Buckareff).
thepanpsycast.com/panpsycast2/episode147-1 -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I did a TEDx talk on panpsychism. Convinced?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCxhoqzEaUE -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Great new article by @annakaharris
iai.tv/articles/annaka-harris-consciousness-is-fundamenta… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The flawed reasoning at the heart of attempts to explain fine-tuning in terms of a multiverse.
iai.tv/articles/the-mistake-at-the-heart-of-the-multivers… @IAI_TV -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
When are people going to get the memo that logical positivism was almost universally rejected over 50 years ago?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Hot of the press! Special journal issue on cosmopsychism emerging from the conference covered in this @sciam article. All funded via @templeton_fdn project run by me and @AndreiBuckareff (link below). Will be open access soon!
www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-consciousness-part-…
sites.google.com/view/panpsychismandpanentheism/home?auth…
Imprint Academic
@ImprintAcademic
The latest issue of the Journal of Consciousness Studies is out now!🧠
This issue is mixed - there is a special issue is on cosmopsychism, guest edited by @AndreiBuckareff and @Philip_Goff. Our regular papers cover a wide range of topics, from transmaterialism to affect in recognition.
Subscribe to the Journal of Consciousness Studies:
🔗www.imprint.co.uk/product/jcs/
Join our mailing list:
📩mailchi.mp/imprint/newsletter-sign-up -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
'Is Consciousness Everywhere?' Really enjoyed this philosophical adventure with @annakaharris
www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBUCYGAYY70 -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The fascinating thing about quantum mechanics is that it puts philosophy at the core of our scientific understanding of the universe. There is no consensus on what our best scientific theory is telling us about reality. It's a matter of philosophical judgement.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Interviewing @annakaharris in an hour...anyone have any questions to put to her? @keithfrankish
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Have you ever wondered how exactly panpsychism explains consciousness? Well you're in luck, because my new paper in Journal of Consciousness Studies (hot off the press!) addresses exactly that question. There's a draft of the final version on my website.
philipgoffphilosophy.com/academic-papers -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Really sorry to hear about the passing of Daniel Dennett. A truly great philosopher. It was a great pleasure & honour to spend a week on a boat with him in the arctic ten years ago, and to argue with him on BBC last year. Same age as my dad, who passed away earlier this year.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Really enjoyed this stimulating discussion on the 'Beyond Belief' podcast.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SfU_JgHhBhM -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Got deep into the philosophy of mind and consciousness in this in depth discussion with @coldxman
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3C87Xb8d_z0 -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I'm very grateful to @JulianBaggini for reviewing my book for the @FT. I wrote up a response, in the spirit of friendly debate.
philipgoff.substack.com/p/an-incredulous-stare-isnt-an-ar… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Public debate with me and @seanmcarroll on 'Is Consciousness Fundamental?' After 7 hours debating on our podcasts, we finally did this in person.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCPCyri1rXU -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Paul Draper. No debate about it.
aikaterina
@aishpilled
who is the best atheist or agnostic philosopher, in your opinion?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My take on the current civil war in consciousness science
theconversation.com/consciousness-why-a-leading-theory-ha… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
'Is Consciousness Part of the Fabric of the Universe?' Excellent article by @danfalk for @sciam on the recent conference @AndreiBuckareff & I organised on panpsychism, featuring @seanmcarroll, @annakaharris , @donalddhoffman and many others.
www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-consciousness-part-… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Sean and I about to debate live! Join on zoom link in the program. @seanmcarroll
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If anyone wants to virtually attend debate on 'Is Consciousness Fundamental?' between @seanmcarroll and I, there's now a link in the program. Times are New York time. Spread the word! sites.google.com/view/panpsychismandpanentheism/project-e…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
If anyone wants to virtually attend debate on 'Is Consciousness Fundamental?' between @seanmcarroll and I, there's now a link in the program. Times are New York time. Spread the word! sites.google.com/view/panpsychismandpanentheism/project-e…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I have now successfully put together a devastatingly good challenge to @seanmcarroll. Thanks for all your advice!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
You can now register for my public event with @seanmcarroll in Poughkeepsie September 7. Spread the word, and book now while (free) tickets are still available!
www.eventbrite.com/e/is-consciousness-fundamental-tickets… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
'Is Consciousness Fundamental?' I'm very pleased to announce a public debate between @seanmcarroll and myself September 8th, 7-9pm in Poughkeepsie, New York. How to register will be added later, but put in your diary now!
philevents.org/event/show/112922 -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Just finished lovely chat with @CosmicSkeptic
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
With contributions by @seanmcarroll @annakaharris @anilkseth @carlorovelli @AlexMoran44 @michelleybliu @RalphStefanWeir @slaneritchie
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Out now!!!!!!!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Out now!!!!!!!
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
I tend to think of idealism as committed to physical reality not being fundamental, whereas I embrace an identity between fundamental consciousness and physical reality, and hence think both are fundamental.
Logan
@LoganBSomething
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Is Woke just about being nice to people?
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
'Is Consciousness Everywhere?' coming out as book. 19 essays on my 'Galileo's Error' by scientists & philosophers inc. @annakaharris @seanmcarroll @carlorovelli @anilkseth @AlexMoran44 @keithfrankish @michelleybliu @slaneritchie @RalphStefanWeir
www.amazon.co.uk/Consciousness-Everywhere-Panpsychism-Jou… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Wow, that was like a work out...really enjoyed this debate! Not sure why I thought it'd be good to take on 3 people who disagree with me though...maybe we should have a rematch in 6 months time with someone on my side 🥷 @keithfrankish @seanmcarroll
www.youtube.com/watch?v=azroNJhQd1U -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Delighted to announce 'Is Consciousness Everywhere?' will be coming out as book late '22. 19 essays on my book 'Galileo's Error'.
@carlorovelli @seanmcarroll @annakaharris @anilkseth @keithfrankish @michelleybliu @AlexMoran44 @weir_stefan @slaneritchie
conscienceandconsciousness.com/2021/08/01/19-essays-on-ga… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
My chat with @lexfridman has just gone up. This was lots of fun. #philosophy
www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCdV6BMMpOo -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
How Galileo Excluded Consciousness. Clip from my @joerogan interview. The full video is on Spotify.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EczCvJrQtXw www.philipgoffphilosophy.com -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
20 essays on panpsychism by scientists, philosophers and theologians, edited by @AlexMoran44 and myself. HOT OF THE PRESS Contributors include @seanmcarroll @carlorovelli @annakaharris @keithfrankish @weir_stefan @anilkseth @nyuconscious @slaneritchie
www.ingentaconnect.com/content/imp/jcs/2021/00000028/f002… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Just submitted volume 'Is Consciousness Everywhere: Essays on Panpsychism'! 10 essays available online (linked to from this post) including the intro, which gives overview of the volume @annakaharris @carlorovelli @seanmcarroll @anilkseth @keithfrankish
conscienceandconsciousness.com/2021/08/01/19-essays-on-ga… -
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
'19 essays on 'Galileo's Error''. A blog post listing the 7 essays from the volume that are online, by @seanmcarroll @annakaharris @anilkseth @weir_stefan @nyuconscious
conscienceandconsciousness.com/2021/08/01/19-essays-on-ga… -
Post not available here, view on X
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Yes sorry, I meant same predictions in terms of public observation, at least on weak emergentist version.
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Excited there's going to be special issue of 'Journal of #consciousness Studies' on my book 'Galileo's Error', featuring leading scientists and thinkers, including @carlorovelli, Christof Koch, @annakaharris, Lee Smolin & many others. #philosophy conscienceandconsciousness.com/2020/08/05/special-issue-o…
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
Lovely chat with Richard. Challenging me on some of the details of my book.
Richard Brown
@onemorebrown
Philip Goff Live! onemorebrown.com/2019/11/14/philip-goff-live-2/
-
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
It's arrived! #consciousness #panpsychism


























































































































































