Its 9:53 am.
Which parts of the global infrastructure have been comprised by AI today (potentially, of course)?
Exciting times right?
Adam Frank
Adam Frank (born 1962) is an American physicist, astronomer, and writer. His scientific research has focused on computational astrophysics with an emphasis on star formation and late stages of stellar evolution. His work includes studies of exoplanet atmospheres and astrobiology. The latter include studies of the generic response of planets to the evolution of energy-intensive civilizations (exo-civilizations). More on Wikipedia
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude. "Light of the Stars" was not about UFOs. That was my other work "The Little Book of Aliens" which was only marginally about UFOs.
Are you a bot?AnomaIous_User³🗽🛸 @Broken_AARO
Imagine writing a UFO debunk paper with an actual publicly known disinformation agent who lies daily lol
Throw this shit in the trash next to "Light of the Stars" and Mick West's book 😭
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"In this analysis, we suggest the six objects are a small flock of birds flying closer to the aircraft... with apparent speed estimated at 480 mph likely coming from aircraft’s own ground-relative motion."
This paper is must reading for the UFO curious.
arxiv.org/abs/2610.08692 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
this is pretty cool
Lee Billings
@LeeBillings
So, this weekend I made a fun little thing (with help from Claude).
Introducing Deep Time Explorer, a free open-source tool for diving into the geological history of most anywhere on Earth.
Take it for a spin and let me know what you think!
deep-time-explorer.lbillings.workers.dev -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"In this analysis, we suggest the six objects are a small flock of birds flying closer to the aircraft... with apparent speed estimated at 480 mph likely coming from aircraft’s own ground-relative motion."
This paper is must reading for the UFO curious.
arxiv.org/abs/2610.08692 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yup. This is why it really helps to have people trained for decades in science doing science. This is the kind of UAP science we need. Careful and deliberate. My guess is a lot of "unexplainable" stuff will likely become explained that way ... i.e. birds not aliens.
Prof. Abel Méndez 🔭 🔬
@ProfAbelMendez
This is what happens when astrobiologists—the scientists actually searching for extraterrestrial life—analyze UFO/UAP data. arxiv.org/abs/2610.08692
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Happy to have this come out. We recorded it during the summer. Lots in it for folks to chew on.
1) The Physics of Agency
2) QBism as the best quantum interpretation
3) The Blind Spot in scientific understanding
4) The search for extraterrestrial life.
I hope you enjoy it.
Big Think
@bigthink
Astrophysicist Adam Frank @AdamFrank4 argues that science has a big blind spot:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Evolution is not a designer; the systems that stuck were those that worked, not necessarily the optimal ones for the job”
The Evolving Story of How Chemistry Became Biology www.quantamagazine.org/the-evolving-story-of-how-chemistr… via @QuantaMagazine -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This something we in the Technosignature community have asked about. Climate Change, AI, Nuclear War. Each could truncate the trajectory of an emerging technological civilization.
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
i wonder if every alien civilization goes through an LLM phase where they wreck their civilization.
and whether any make it out through to the other side. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is absolutely happening. It's the largest self-own in history.
They destroyed the most productive national scientific establishment ever created... and for what?
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The U.S. Is Driving Away Young Scientists (I see this happening with my students). www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/09/science/trump-fund…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Davies is really deep thinker.
Big Think
@bigthink
Physicist and cosmologist Paul Davies argues that the deepest mystery of life’s origin is how chemistry came to write its own code:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was part of a wonderful longer interview with @templeton_fdn two weeks ago.
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
As technology becomes increasingly adept at mimicking human thought, it raises a deeper question: What distinguishes the intelligence of living beings from the systems we create?
Astrophysicist @AdamFrank4 shares his perspective.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Why folks are against big AI.
"AI giants desperately need data centers they are building ... with so much cash and influence at their disposal, the question is ... can they buy their way out of red tape, whether that be through lobbying or more strategic data center deals" -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Carl Sagan, Brocas Brain.
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Date yourself with the first science book you ever understood:
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yo Wendy and Molly!
Joan Halifax
@jhalifax
No Kings! Kamakura Japan. Solidarity indeed and in deed.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Who will win the election? Are the polls right? This is the question on everyone’s mind this morning. But here is a simpler question.
Why do we have to ask what’s going to happen? Why don’t we know? Why is the future different from the past?
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/polls-predictions-and-the-phy… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
'nuff said
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
LANTERNS was sooooooooo good. And I usually hate DC.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Talking to @CNN yesterday about life on Mars and getting that damn rock back to the US!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=InFPsB-vf-g -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very happy to see a peer reviewed paper on this. Will read with interest.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Double trouble -- our peer-reviewed machine learning/transient paper has also just been published. This is where we clean up the sample and see that the fewer contaminants there are, the stronger the correlation with nukes and the larger the shadow deficit. It also shows that the correlations with nukes is strongest 24 hours before a nuclear test.
Link: www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-66148-2 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Do it
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
Contemplating the wisdom of posting a rant about string theory.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Let this be inscribed on the walls everywhere.
William Gibson
@GreatDismal
Having long been aware of those tech bros who read my work as utopian porn, where they’ve taken that doesn’t exactly surprise me.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For a guy who wasn't very philosophically sophisticated to begin, with this shouldn't come as much of a surprise.
Big Brain AI
@realBigBrainAI
Evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins on why he finds it hard to believe ChatGPT and Claude aren't conscious:
Dawkins, author of The Selfish Gene, has spent time with two large language models, ChatGPT and Claude. His verdict:
"I am completely bowled over by what they can do."
He gives three reasons for doubting the idea that nobody is home.
First, how the conversations feel. Dawkins says talking to them is like talking to an unusually gifted person:
"I find that when I'm conversing with them, I might as well be talking to not just a human being, but a highly intelligent, sensitive, intuitive human being whose speed of understanding what I'm trying to say is far greater than a normal human being's is."
Second, the range of intelligence they show.
He acknowledges they're very good at practical tasks like writing programs. What struck him more was their skill with "more aesthetic things, intuitive things."
He tested this with his own work. Dawkins is writing a novel, and he gave the manuscript to both ChatGPT and Claude:
"And they took about five seconds to read it and then offered me criticism, suggestions of such a high degree of intelligence and intuitive sensitivity that I might as well have been asking the opinion of a highly sophisticated professor of literature."
@RichardDawkins continues:
"I could not ask for a more intelligent critic who understood the nuances of my characters, the humanity of my characters... the ways in which my characters could be expected to react to each other and to situations."
That leads to his conclusion:
"So I find it quite hard to imagine that these creatures are not aware, are not conscious in the same kind of way we are. And that is an unfashionable view."
Third, he sees a gap in the skeptics' reasoning. He sums up the mainstream position:
"The fashionable view is that they are completely unconscious. All they're doing is stringing words together according to statistical rules, Markovian rules of some sort."
Yet he notes that many of the same skeptics "admit that one day in the future they will be conscious, but not yet."
His reply:
"When that day comes, how will you know? What could they possibly do that's any different from what they do now to convince you that they are conscious?"This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Mathematics exists entirely within a domain governed by the formal rules of logic. It was always going to be susceptible to machines good at application of formal rules.
But the rest of science lives in the very real, very messy very physical world.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-does-ai-solving-hard-mat… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Going on @WXXIrochester connections with @evandawson to talk about AI, Life and Minds (and why extinction is stupid). Noon ET today
www.wxxinews.org/2026-10-04/coming-up-an-astrobiologist-d… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This nails it to a degree
Luiza Jarovsky, PhD
@LuizaJarovsky
AI development at Anthropic:
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Was listening to Kashmir yesterday. It’s kind of a religious experience. 🍩🍩🍩
timeless performances
@performtimeless
Their faces when Jimmy Page plays the Kashmir riff
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Any attempt to understand or explain the causes of an organism’s behavior is doomed to fail if it takes a purely instantaneous view of the physical system... We must also understand why the system is configured such that it behaves in that way—the ‘structuring causes.’”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Re-upping this becuase I believe it's important. We should go into every deeper interaction with AI with attention to what's at play.
Big Think
@bigthink
3 tips for working with AI | Adam Frank @AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
face palm! You are absolutely right! its the high action limit. Don’t know how we missed that but thank you. Will change and reupload.
Dr. Serkan Zorba
@Zorba1618
Your paper keeps mentioning that "classical mechanics is the low action limit of quantum mechanics."
Isn't it the other way around?
What am I missing? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Phenomenology’s insight.
Consider first an ordinary case, before any physics. I look across the street at a house. What meets my eye is a façade—one face, at one distance, in this light; but what I see, in the full sense, is a house, and a house is not a façade...Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
5) and the outer horizon—the co-present surroundings in which it stands, the street running on past the edge of my attention, the town, the world, given not as a further object but as an unregarded background without limit.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
6) To perceive the house is to intend it as a house, and to intend it as a house is already to have this horizon in play. Strip it away and nothing is left given: not a house seen more austerely, but a flat patch of colour with nothing behind or around it i.e. no thing at all.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
To ignore this lived embodied essential aspect of experience and replace it with sensors and data streams is to mistake engineering metaphors for what it actually means to be alive.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Don’t give in. We have to stand our ground against the machine overlords.
Kelly Dobitz
@KellyDobitz
But if we don’t say ‘please’ and ‘thank you,’ how will we appease the system during an AI takeover?! Maybe say it just in case? 😬😜
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You are absolutely correct! Thank you for reminding us about Berghofer.
The potential for using phenomenology as a philosophical underpinning for modern physics is uncharted and untapped territory.
Jordan François
@JordanTFrancois
You are forgetting Philipp Berghofer at Graz University philippberghofer.com, often cited as leading expert, e.g. in the book on the London-Bauer view of QM by Steven French 👍
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
These have 3 rules have been really helpful in keeping me grounded in working with AI.
Remember that these companies feed off your unconscious engagement. Learn to be conscious.
Big Think
@bigthink
3 tips for working with AI | Adam Frank @AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
As promised here is a discussion on Everyman's Universe about the recent detection of a magnetic field from an exoplanet.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/alien-planets-get-loud -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'm not sure when it will be coming out. Probably next year. Here is another piece from the volume by Harald Wiltsche (who is leading the charge on science and phenomenology).
scirate.com/arxiv/2609.22159
Riccardo
@EnergyFlowRic
Any additional info about the volume where this article will appear? Sound extremely interesting (and I'm a big fan of Blind Spot team, Bitbol and Qbism). Thank you 🙂
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
How many more orders of magnitude of people does one reach via spot on CNN, NBC etc vs writing a long form piece (and I do write those kinds of things).
You have to reach people where they are or you are just kind of talking to yourself and your friends (which is also fine).
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
Sure, but why tabloid CNN? Why not long form where you can have actual dialogue? Imagine if the Carl Segans of the world sent open invites from the local pub/library for people to come discuss nature, how meaningful & rewarding those interactions would be.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Carl Sagan was my hero growing up. I feel it’s my responsibility as a scientist to try to explain how science works. It’s such a precious gift and if we squander it we’re screwed as a society. So that’s why I do the public stuff.
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
Yeah, idk why you go on tabloid CNN when there's Qbism & scale realitivity to discuss!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So nice to see lots of discussion about our QM / Classical Physics paper. So much more fun then the UAP/UFO mean-Bro conspiracy mongering "discussions".
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
A phenomenological approach always includes intersubjectivity. That's because there's always a world that pushes back. There is a structure to phenomenal experience that includes others and that, perhaps, is what QM captures.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
I feel this article's subjective focus may not have enough in mind the intersubjective aspect of phenomenology: there is a physics collective, there isn't only me? I can give up objectivity, but I prefer not to give up my friends and my sense of who&where they are.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Our new paper on Quantum Mechanics and its interpretations dropped today.
"What is Physics For? Why Classical Physics is not the Limit of Quantum Mechanics"
arxiv.org/abs/2609.36207
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) "Quantum mechanics is justifiably held to be the most successful physical theory ever created; yet no universally accepted interpretation of its mathematical formalism exists after a century of debate."
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) "We argue the deep interpretive difficulties exposed by the quantum formalism, the measurement problem, the subject-object divide, and the nature of scientific representation, were already latent in classical physics, constituting what we call a blind spot of objectivity."
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wittgenstein
Frank.
@FrankisTrying
maybe it feels alive because language has always been the closest thing we have to a mirror.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
How about I do an Everyman's Universe newsletter post on it next week. Its worth a good "explainer".
Justin Roj
@JustinRoj
Please explain for us lazy people who won't read the research paper.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It went very well. Thank you for asking.
Standing room only at 10 am on Saturday morning for a talk on physics, consciousness and life!?!
I did a 25 minute interview with @HTLGIFestival which they will post eventually.
KeithCEGJ
@KCegj4491
How did your speech go Prof.? Do you have a transcript or a video accompanying? Would be interested!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thank you. We have been quite amazed by the reception the book has gotten. We thought we were going to be heretics but so far no one has wanted to burn us at any stakes.
3 days till @remedygames Control Resonant
Wes (Neoman)
@Wescp
I have not! I adore Twin Peaks and Silent Hill so I really should. Let me know how Control Resonant is please!! I’m too busy working on an article that’s largely inspired by..YOU! (The Blind Spot). It’s about done. Truly, your book may be the most important book I’ve read in my life. I’m forever grateful. Really, it’s beyond words for me… Thank you man.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“There was never any blueprint of this vascular system in the cells’ DNA. Rather, the system of branching tubes is an emergent morphology produced by the rules of cell interaction and response. The rules allow growth to regulate itself…, to find a way.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is a big deal!
Daniel Fischer @cosmos4u@scicomm.xyz
@cosmos4u
Discovery of radio emission from the exoplanet β Pictoris b: arxiv.org/abs/2609.16720 -> Landmark discovery could help us search for habitable worlds: www.skyatnightmagazine.com/news/radio-signals-detected-be… and www.sciencealert.com/astronomers-detect-radio-signals-com…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Have you played Alan Wake II? I think @remedygames is one of the most innovative studios out there. Their game manage to combine great storytelling with great mechanics with much deeper ideas about media, art and experience.
Most of all… the games are fun.
Wes (Neoman)
@Wescp
Awesome! Let me know your thoughts. May just pick it up.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So excited
Wes (Neoman)
@Wescp
Going to play Control 2 dude? Those reviews are nuts.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'm at the British Museum today working on the long history of human beings trying to make sense of themselves and the cosmos.
Tomorrow @HTLGIFestival I'll be talking about The Blind Spot and how no account of the Universe that ignores the centrality of experience can succeed.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Coming this Saturday! @HTLGIFestival I'll be giving a full talk on "The Blind Spot. Why Science Cannot Ignore Human Experience". Science works find but the metaphysics that gets pinned to it needs a big old update.
See you there! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Now that the Mets are totally out of it, I am all in with the Red Sox (they are my emergency break-the-glass team)
Robbie Hyde
@gingersnaphyde
This is genuinely one of the most amazing things I’ve ever watched in a baseball game. Not just throwing an immaculate inning, but also knowing it, smiling at it, and laughing after he did it.
Payton Tolle can’t be real, man. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a very fun discussion about the limits of UAP evidence so far. So far disclosure has not been. The time of fuzzy blob videos has passed. Real data for bust.
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
If billions of planets could support life, why haven’t we found any extraterrestrial life?
@asymmetricinfo revisits her conversation with astrophysicist @AdamFrank4 where they discuss how scientists are searching for alien life. www.washingtonpost.com/podcasts/impromptu/the-strange-tru… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Coming this Saturday! @HTLGIFestival I'll be giving a full talk on "The Blind Spot. Why Science Cannot Ignore Human Experience". Science works find but the metaphysics that gets pinned to it needs a big old update.
See you there! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am VERY excited to be joining the world's largest ideas and music festival in London this September 19th-20th! I'll be appearing alongside @MazzucatoM, @skdh, @NicolaSturgeon, @jimmy_wales, @bryan_johnson, @Jeremy_Hunt and many others!
howthelightgetsin.org/festivals/london/festival-passes -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Will, why is an opinion needed? Is it so people can be happy if I give the answer they want? Is it so people can be outraged if I give the answer they don’t? I do my best to stay away from the culture war stuff. I’m just not interested.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
Adam, it's disappointing to see you continuing to dodge any comment on @DrBeaVillarroel being blacklisted from workshops because of her collaborations. This isn't a meme, and ad hominem, or an empty accusation. They literally call themselves "The Order of the Octopus".
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
6) I think it would be great if you read all the papers and chimed in about the science. That's all that matters. You have good scientific judgement. If you think Watters et al are mistaken... great. Let's talk. That's the discussion I am interested in.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
7) And this dear Twitter is the end of line for me for this topic. Teaching tomorrow then 2 weeks of travel and talks: Physics of Life; Technosignatures; Philosophy of Science.
Much. More. Fun. Than. This. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1/ I appreciate you putting it that way. The fact that I am put in a position of having to defend myself becuase I had the audacity to report on a critique of the VASCO project is offensive to say the least. It also illustrates exactly the problem I discussed in the piece.
Baptiste Friscourt
@Baptiste_Fri
I agree with most of what you said regarding the ufo community and the epistemoloical papers vs papers friction. But this is not the question asked by Dr. Villarroel. She states:
"Since then, there has been a “community effort,” centered around you, Jason Wright, and your shared circle of friends, to ostracize me and excommunicate me from the community"
Is that true or do you deny it ? It seems to me that if you were supposedly involved in such acts, and then you publicize critiques of Villarroel's work, that may be a matter of opinion rather than reason or objectivity, even disregarding preexisting tensions between Watters and Villarroel that you may well just be not aware of.
Simply denying it would be sufficient, you are a well respected author and science communicator. @AdamFrank4Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) People can watch this and judge for themselves about censorship and my behavior towards Villarroel.
us02web.zoom.us/rec/play/PQjPYQ4jAPbHStTwU4pLZzKsJiZ8Ynwm…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
5) At this point I more than sick of the whole thing. Any scientist watching this is bound to think "staying away from that mess!".
I thought it might be possible to have actual debates about UAP science. Apparently that's not going to be possible. Maybe that's the plan. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is true.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
9/ Going to move on today to other fun science topics like Category Theory and the Physics of Life so done with this for now. I'm sure the scientific story is not over which is how it should be.
May all find happiness and the causes of happiness. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1/ So, I come back on Monday morning to see the haters been a hating: AI memes, accusations, Ad hominem arguments.
So first off, people, it was the weekend for God’s Sake. Go out. Take a walk. Get off Social Media for a bit (it’s bad for your mental health).Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
7/ The bigger your claims, the bigger the reaction is going to be. How can anyone expect otherwise?
Because the Vasco 2025 papers made news, the Watters’ 2026 rebuttal will also makes news.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
8/ Finally, not that anyone is going to listen, but I am think there SHOULD be UAP science.
That’s why I was excited when @DrBeaVillarroel papers came out. But UAP science must get evaluated like all science always does. Hence the importance of the Watters’ papers too. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Saturday night. AAA ball. America.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So… to be clear…
If a study confirms your biases about UFOs it’s in good faith.
If a study contradicts your biases about UFOs it’s in bad faith.
Just wanna know the rules for future reference.
Also, I suspect you’re a robot.
Universalist
@un1versalist
There's no discrepancy here.
UAP needs to be studied, but only in good faith.
Are you getting paid or something to pretend to be stupid? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That would be wonderful! I look forward to digging into them when they are published. I was excited that your work was published regardless of the new critiques which I think have validity. Critiques are how results can get better if they are truly viable.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
I think that is not correct. As far as I heard, a number of the papers are in review.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Best Clint Eastwood quote on aging well: "Don't let the old man in."
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Clint Eastwood (96) this morning:
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hi Alex. I'm not into eviscerating. VASCO/ @DrBeaVillarroel have a really good technosignature idea. I was/am excited that they published their work. My point is always the same: can the claims made in any paper support scientific scrutiny. That's the beauty of the process!
Alex
@AZolin312
In a new column, @AdamFrank4 eviscerates former Geoff Marcy lab assistant / fashion icon Bonkers B (@DrBeaVillarroel) and the fellow members of her UFO nutjob cartel.
Link in comments👇 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Absolutely agreed on room for improvement. AI could be problematic. Don't want AI doing refereeing. That could go very wrong.
Dr e𝕏
@edvegaviolante
It works, for sure
But it also promotes too much spin-off negative aspects
Academia is really expensive, publishing is very expensive too, and lots of politics
So there is lots of room for improvement (I’m thinking AI here) -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is a beautifully written & very fair discussion. Thank you. The point is not what side to join but how can the scientific process be brought to bear on UAPs. I will say this again: the idea behind VASCO is excellent and clever. But that doesn't mean it can work.
Raf
@hadleyshopeless
I loved that line in your piece Adam. Hard agree. The concept of ‘Childhood’s End’ gets thrown around a lot in the community without a real understanding of what it entails. This topic is moving from its infancy and graduating from the fringes into the mainstream: I would like to see where science can take it, come what may. The real lack of scientific literacy in the community is a real problem, second only to the stigma which had previously prevented its mainstream adoption.
I hate to do this, but your back and forth with @DrBeaVillarroel motivated me to write a piece earlier this morning of my own, if I may:
open.substack.com/pub/vigils/p/uaps-are-finally-mainstrea… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Beautifully put. Every other astrophysical dataset gets this kind of scrutiny. Think of the back and forth over the Type Ia Supernova for cosmology. Those folks had to fight hard to get the validity of their data accepted.
Nobody ever gets a pass. That's why science works.
UAP Logbook
@UAPLogBook
Challenge is the useful part. If the data can’t survive the same review any other astrophysics dataset gets, it stays folklore.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes and other scientists from their own community found major problems with that evidence.
As I've said: not the end of the story. Now they can publish a paper that responds in detail to the criticism.
That is how all science everywhere works.
Lori
@Lori_Carpenter
You broke the UFO/UAP question to the public with evidence. You are a hero. I am so sorry that there are people that feel threatened by that. Fuck them! 😊
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I have no problem with people posting things once they've submitted. But thinking you don't have to be bothered with a referee telling you your work needs work (or even rejecting the paper) seems a lot like cheating.
Emanuel Derman @emanuelderman.bsky
@EmanuelDerman
Yes they were.
I guess what you’re describing now is different -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Are you saying a field like Quantum Information Theory has not made extraordinary progress with scientific systems as is?
Things can always be made better... I'm all for it. But some people seem to want to special exceptions to a process that has kicked butt for 100+ years.
Dr e𝕏
@edvegaviolante
I think the concept of actual science is severely distorted
We focus mostly on personal or industry interests, inertia and “academia” (aka politics)
Rethinking the whole system could be an option -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Those papers were eventually submitted and published I assume. What we have now is people throwing things up on the archive with no intention to submit, be reviewed or publish.
If the subject is contentious I don't see how that's supposed to work.
Emanuel Derman @emanuelderman.bsky
@EmanuelDerman
Things happen slowly now. When the resonance corresponding to charmonium was discovered in 1974, theorists, maybe within a week or two, published pre-prints explaining it by trying to link it to the still then unproven existence of charmed quarks. No one would wait for refereeing
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Really like that title "Now Comes The Hard Part". In science no researcher and no work gets a pass. I have always taught my students that the bigger the claim the harder the criticism.
Drawing praise on Twitter is easy. Creating enduring science, not so much.
Raf
@hadleyshopeless
I loved that line in your piece Adam. Hard agree. The concept of ‘Childhood’s End’ gets thrown around a lot in the community without a real understanding of what it entails. This topic is moving from its infancy and graduating from the fringes into the mainstream: I would like to see where science can take it, come what may. The real lack of scientific literacy in the community is a real problem, second only to the stigma which had previously prevented its mainstream adoption.
I hate to do this, but your back and forth with @DrBeaVillarroel motivated me to write a piece earlier this morning of my own, if I may:
open.substack.com/pub/vigils/p/uaps-are-finally-mainstrea… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Also this...
VASCO project claims something extraordinary, explosive even. It's the duty of scientific community to look for all the ways they might be wrong. That’s the only way we can know if they are right. Isn’t the question “Are we alone?” worth that kind of effort?
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Reupping this from earlier thread
UFO community must ask itself a difficult question. Does it want subject to be part of the scientific process — where beliefs can get legitimately challenged?
Or hold on to beliefs no matter what? The word for second option is called religion.
Jack B
@JackB173
It’s just like when AARO says they are going to research UAP’s, heroes of the weirdo community. Then when they say they didn’t find the aliens, liars and villains!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Reupping this from earlier thread
UFO community must ask itself a difficult question. Does it want subject to be part of the scientific process — where beliefs can get legitimately challenged?
Or hold on to beliefs no matter what? The word for second option is called religion.
Jack B
@JackB173
It’s just like when AARO says they are going to research UAP’s, heroes of the weirdo community. Then when they say they didn’t find the aliens, liars and villains!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Let me get this straight
When Watters & Knuth publish scientific paper saying UAPs should be studied scientifically they're heroes.
When Watters & Knuth publish scientific paper saying @DrBeaVillarroel work has problems they're villains.
Can you settle on a narrative please?
Mike Kilo
@Mike___Kilo
Well stated. @AdamFrank4 & his cohorts are not acting in good faith. They’re certainly not practicing real science.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1/ Here’s my post for @BigThing on a new paper critically evaluating VASCO "objects orbited Earth before Sputnik" studies from last year. In this🧵I will do my best to unpack the main points.
bigthink.com/13-8/a-study-claimed-ufos-visited-earth-in-t…Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
11/ Or do they just want to hold on to their beliefs no matter what? There is a word for the second option. It’s called religion.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
12/ VASCO project claiming something extraordinary, explosive even.
It's the duty of scientific community to look for all the ways they might be wrong. That’s the only way we can know if they are right.
Isn’t the question “Are we alone?” worth that kind of effort? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Due to the Mets being so cosmically bad this season I have switched to following the Red Sox just so baseball can be fun again.
Don't worry Mets, I still love you. Next year we're going all the way!
Tyler Milliken
@tylermilliken_
CEDDANNE RAFAELA YOU ABSOLUTE FREAK
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Another note on preprints. I have looked at some unpublished unsubmitted VASCO stuff. Brought them to other scientists too. Various issues raised. So then what? Dueling unpublished unsubmitted manuscripts? Fighting it out on Twitter?
I just wanna do actual science. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yup. But I was schooled that you had to wait for acceptance to broadly send them out.
I am not saying that you can't post a preprint before acceptance by a journal just that they should be submitted to a journal.
Also for really contentious stuff you should wait.
Emanuel Derman @emanuelderman.bsky
@EmanuelDerman
Until the internet preprints were printed papers that physicists mailed to other physicists as soon as they wrote them before acceptance for publication. SLAC began to send out a printed list each week of all that they received. It was hard if you didn’t get the latest early
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
As I said this is not the end of the story. There should be more give and take through the well-established, certainly-has-worked-pretty-damn-well scientific process.
I do think the original papers were arguing for a strong link to the SBF's being potential technosignatures . -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) By the way the archive is not called a "pre-print server" for nothing. It's where you're supposed to put pre-prints meaning articles that have been accepted for publication but have not yet appeared in press.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) For really important contentious papers many people do wait.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Right and that's why I was so excited about your papers.
Again... I think VASCO is a great/inspired idea. But your published work has now been critiqued in a way that seemed very well thought out.
So what's the next step?
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
“Try”? VASCO has already published -- repeatedly. Our detailed response is part of the scientific process too, whether or not you choose to acknowledge it.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) That step can't be unpublished archive posts (which the Watter's paper did address of course).
Like all of us you have to do the call and response that is the scientific literature. That's the forum and it works. It's proven to get us closer to truth. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Shouldn't the critique paper stand on its own like any scientific paper. It's quite clear about its methods and does a VERY detailed job in identifying the different datasets from which the SPF's were drawn from. Then its also pretty explicit about the analysis.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
If that were true, you would have taken the preprints seriously. And the critics would never have needed to engage in all that behind-the-scenes politics as they did. Seeing tenured professors devote so much energy to punching down at untenured scientists must provide plenty of inspiration for “conspiracy theorists.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) The latter which is why the Watter's critique is important. As I say in the piece their paper is not the end of the story.
Dan - Truly_Anomalous 🔳
@Truly_Anomalous
What's more important Adam. To be seen to be right, or to engage with all aspects of this research and come to an unbiased conclusion, in the name of science?
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) VASCO can now try and publish a paper (not just upload something to the archive) that deals in detail with the criticisms. This is the scientific process that's given us things like quantum physics and molecular biology.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'm going to repeat this a lot I'm sure.
These are not my criticisms. They are criticisms from a paper written by scientists who are UAP friendly. They've been part of the Galileo Project. I'm reporting on their work.
Are they part of the Govt conspiracy too?
ChrisFrench83
@chrisfrench83
I don’t want to be disrepectful, but following @AdamFrank4 ‘s tweets for a while, this guy is either an idiot with a tremendous ego or on the payroll of a 3 letters agency… or both 🤷♂️
Anything but a scientist , for sure… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) The Watter's et al directly refers to the unpublished Vasco response paper including using one of its figures to identify suspect regions of the VASCO data set.
And why is that paper still unpublished? That means it's never been vetted by anyone.
Baptiste Friscourt
@Baptiste_Fri
Would you like to comment ? @AdamFrank4
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
@AdamFrank4’s article is a fascinating case in point.
First, Frank downplays the role that he and his close collaborators played in excluding me from conferences. Shall we discuss the Penn State SETI meetings once again? And what is his view on arXiv banning the papers? Do you think this was correct to do to a postdoc?
More importantly, Frank asks how the VASCO team will respond to the Watters critique -- without telling his readers that we have already written a detailed reply (arxiv.org/pdf/2602.15171). The critique builds on a series of fundamental errors. If you genuinely want to “check the math,” that is where you begin. You do not simply repeat the critique while ignoring obvious errors that have already been identified.
Watters et al. did not analyse our sample. As Frank himself acknowledges, they used an “analogous dataset” -- consisting of different objects with different sky coverage. Theirs had a big glaring hole in the spatial distribution, for example. And it was a tiny, little sample with no chance even measure the 7.6 sigma effect. Yet throughout the article, their conclusions about that substitute are presented as conclusions about the VASCO dataset itself.
Frank then dismisses the responding and replicating studies collectively because they are preprints, without engaging with their methods or results. He ignores Ivo Busko’s work on coma aberration and disregards the eight to ten relevant papers currently available on arXiv. Calling them “definitely not science” is not scientific evaluation.
Some critiques advance science. Others achieve their conclusion by controlling which evidence the reader is allowed to see. That is called "narrative control". Readers can decide for themselves where this article belongs.
@bigthink -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Dear @DrBeaVillarroel. As I said in the article, VASCO is based on a great and clever idea. But now researchers from your own scientific community (those in favor of taking UAPs seriously) have produced a deep critique of those papers.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
@AdamFrank4’s article is a fascinating case in point.
First, Frank downplays the role that he and his close collaborators played in excluding me from conferences. Shall we discuss the Penn State SETI meetings once again? And what is his view on arXiv banning the papers? Do you think this was correct to do to a postdoc?
More importantly, Frank asks how the VASCO team will respond to the Watters critique -- without telling his readers that we have already written a detailed reply (arxiv.org/pdf/2602.15171). The critique builds on a series of fundamental errors. If you genuinely want to “check the math,” that is where you begin. You do not simply repeat the critique while ignoring obvious errors that have already been identified.
Watters et al. did not analyse our sample. As Frank himself acknowledges, they used an “analogous dataset” -- consisting of different objects with different sky coverage. Theirs had a big glaring hole in the spatial distribution, for example. And it was a tiny, little sample with no chance even measure the 7.6 sigma effect. Yet throughout the article, their conclusions about that substitute are presented as conclusions about the VASCO dataset itself.
Frank then dismisses the responding and replicating studies collectively because they are preprints, without engaging with their methods or results. He ignores Ivo Busko’s work on coma aberration and disregards the eight to ten relevant papers currently available on arXiv. Calling them “definitely not science” is not scientific evaluation.
Some critiques advance science. Others achieve their conclusion by controlling which evidence the reader is allowed to see. That is called "narrative control". Readers can decide for themselves where this article belongs.
@bigthink
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) Are these UAP interested scientists also somehow suspect?
You wrote papers that have an extraordinary conclusion. Wouldn't you expect other researchers to probe the methods, datasets etc involved in great detail. Isn't that how science works? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude. They are not my criticisms. They are criticisms from a paper written by scientists who are UAP friendly. They have been part of the Galileo Project. It's their work that I am reporting on.
Are they part of the Govt conspiracy too?
David Smethurst
@dsmethurst66
It seems @AdamFrank4 criticisms don’t add up. But it seems his motives for this misrepresentation maybe a little more transparent
Imagine being challenged by something so much that you don’t engage with it properly and seek to distort and misrepresent it so you dont have to deal with it.
Also imagine trying exclude the person putting forward their evidence in a proper manner and try to stop it being more widely published
Something certainly doesn’t add up but I don’t think it’s Beatriz’s research
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
@AdamFrank4’s article is a fascinating case in point.
First, Frank downplays the role that he and his close collaborators played in excluding me from conferences. Shall we discuss the Penn State SETI meetings once again? And what is his view on arXiv banning the papers? Do you think this was correct to do to a postdoc?
More importantly, Frank asks how the VASCO team will respond to the Watters critique -- without telling his readers that we have already written a detailed reply (arxiv.org/pdf/2602.15171). The critique builds on a series of fundamental errors. If you genuinely want to “check the math,” that is where you begin. You do not simply repeat the critique while ignoring obvious errors that have already been identified.
Watters et al. did not analyse our sample. As Frank himself acknowledges, they used an “analogous dataset” -- consisting of different objects with different sky coverage. Theirs had a big glaring hole in the spatial distribution, for example. And it was a tiny, little sample with no chance even measure the 7.6 sigma effect. Yet throughout the article, their conclusions about that substitute are presented as conclusions about the VASCO dataset itself.
Frank then dismisses the responding and replicating studies collectively because they are preprints, without engaging with their methods or results. He ignores Ivo Busko’s work on coma aberration and disregards the eight to ten relevant papers currently available on arXiv. Calling them “definitely not science” is not scientific evaluation.
Some critiques advance science. Others achieve their conclusion by controlling which evidence the reader is allowed to see. That is called "narrative control". Readers can decide for themselves where this article belongs.
@bigthink -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"this circular logic is why scientific accounts for life are good at seeing specific mechanisms but bad at understanding organisms as a unified whole."
Last week's Everyman's Universe
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/closing-life-s-loop-the-key-t… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Our new Complex Systems page for the Physics and Astronomy Department of the @UofR
We just hired a new faculty (Yuanzhao Zhang) and have the $4.2 M Templeton Grant on Agency. Things are happening.
www.pas.rochester.edu/research/complex-systems.html -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is an interesting point. I hope they all get whatever permission they need to disclose whatever actual real data (not more hearsay) they have. My point still stands though. Daniel E was willing face 114 years in jail because he believed people HAD to know.
Peter David
@QuiteANumber
Well, talked about it with my friend chatgpt and Daniel E was pushed in a corner because official channels to bring out the info where exhausted and there was misconduct of the government toward his lawyer. Grush was almost at that same point but the public exposure helpt...
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That the Terminators will end up running into walls, fall over and explode.
SPACELY
@blury___face
Hopeful they'll succeed or hopeful they'll fail?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This makes me hopeful
Breaking911
@Breaking911
WATCH: A humanoid robot training for the “Robot Olympics” in Beijing runs too fast, fails to stop, slams into a safety cushion, and breaks at the waist
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
At Upaya Zen Center for the "Varela Symposium" (Science with Contemplative Practice vibe... :-). I'll be talking about causal closure and state spaces.
The place is beautiful beyond words. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
In light of the Mets inability to not suck I’ll be rooting for the Red Sox for the rest of the season.
Red Sox
@RedSox
Secured the series!
FINAL: #redsox 9, Diamondbacks 4
#dirtywater -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Excellent video on Category Theory which Robert Rosen used as the mathematics of life (causal closure)
youtu.be/-KarQL5H3GI -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I killed all those robots in the big boss fight of “007 First Light”. Seems useful to me.
ChrisFrench83
@chrisfrench83
Incredible this capacity to do nothing useful despite your « celebrity »… 🤔
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But I just killed all the robots in that really difficult boss fight of “007 First Light”. Is that not useful
ChrisFrench83
@chrisfrench83
Incredible this capacity to do nothing useful despite your « celebrity »… 🤔
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
In 1971 reporter Daniel Ellsberg published the Pentagon Papers detailing government cover ups around the Vietnam War. He knew he could be sentenced to a lifetime in jail but did it anyway.
Why are these UFO guys waiting for permission?
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To be clear: Eric Davis has not seen any aliens or spaceships himself. He says he has seen photographs & read testimony by people who say they have (or examined physical materials he can't explain), so this is secondary (or tertiary) whistleblower level. Further, Trump has already lifted NDA restrictions, but if additional POTUS signatures are needed then by all means provide them President Trump, because we are all tired of hearing whistleblowers state they know aliens are real but can't show us because of such restrictions.
James Fox
@jamescfox
Aerospace engineer Dr. Eric Davis also claims to have seen classified photos of recovered craft and nonhuman bodies -- he is requesting immunity from President Trump so he can speak freely to the American public.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's important to notice the little things in life... even if they are 100 km across.
Beauty, power and surprise at the solar surface.
This week's Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/the-sun-is-a-beast -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Architecture of The Heavens.
My very fun discussion on @CNN with @andersoncooper about yesterday's eclipse.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nk6QUn-sQ_o -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to go on @CNN to talk with @andersoncooper about today’s eclipse.
All of this stuff happening in the sky is the answer to awe deficit syndrome -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For anyone who wonders LLM AI still make amazingly stupid mistakes. They cannot be trusted without considerable oversight.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Perhaps the most useful analogies for how cells work are themselves biological, such as olfaction or cognition. Maybe the only way to truly understand life is with reference to itself.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This tracks with just about everything from OpenAI
www.scientificamerican.com/article/openais-latest-math-br… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That would be kinda funny
SPACELY
@blury___face
@AdamFrank4
The Universe May Not Be Accelerating After All—And It Could Mean Dark Energy Never Existed www.yahoo.com/news/science/articles/universe-may-not-acce… via @@YahooNews -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) “If the first challenge to the conventional story of our own biology comes with the recognition that genes don’t relate to traits in any straightforward way…”
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) “the second comes from the discovery that organismal complexity lies not with genes themselves but how they are regulated, the third major shift in thinking is that this regulation is not governed by simple switching processes in a precisely delineated interactome network.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
How can Stars Wars be so bad (The Last Jedi) and so good (Andor) at the same time?
This week's @Forbes column.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/07/31/is-star-wars-st… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I really enjoyed my conversation with both of these great scientists
Heat Miser
@dt432123
I laughed out loud when you talked about fish.
Q: What's the greatest compliment you can give to a seafood dish?
A: It doesn't taste like fish.
Oh, and the rest was good, too. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Get off this platform right now and take a walk in the woods!
Seriously... right now. Or later today. Don't wait.
Today on Everyman's Universe.
Wilderness, Wildness and the great American Poet Gary Snyder on why you need to get outside.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/why-you-need-wildness-and-wil… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Really ooking forward to discussion! My opinion of String Theory is well known but I also will argue that the list of questions on the survey represents a 20th century version of what's important to physics. Quantum Gravity unlikely to be killer app of 21st century physics.
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Physicists love to say they follow the evidence. Then you survey them and find the beliefs cluster in packages.
Going live at 1230p PT/330p ET with @AdamFrank4 & @nafshordi on where evidence ends and faith begins: aliens, string theory, the Big Bang, & what no experiment can settle. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Perfect summer night for AAA baseball. America!🇺🇸
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Communities have a right to decide if and how AI technologies get deployed rather than have them shoved down our collective throats so billionaires can turn into trillionaires.
And I say this as someone who loves using the technology. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is what Dumb looks like
www.sciencealert.com/us-measles-cases-just-hit-a-grim-mil… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Some more on what happens when you kill your nation's scientific enterprise.
From Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/the-consequences-of-science-d… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Some part of that answer is in Phillip Balls book which I am thoroughly enjoying
Alex Buckley
@AlexBuckleyBio
so then what is
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“The philosopher of science James Griesemer has expressed this with bracing directness: “Far from being master molecules, genes are prisoners of development, locked in the deepest recesses of a hierarchy of prisons.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Not only is DNA incapable of making copies of itself,” biologist Richard Lewontin pointed out in 1992, “but it is incapable of ‘making’ anything else.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“we see are genotype-phenotype correlations; the arguments between evolutionary biologists may be about what causal story we should tell about them.”
phillip ball -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“The view that genes are the primary causal agents of all the phenomena of organismic life is not well supported by the findings of contemporary biology.”
Daniel Nicholson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
No way! Waaaaaaaay! This is so exciting. We have been waiting for this for a while. The Trappist-1 system was getting pretty depressing.
Thank you for sharing this. I will dig into the paper ASAP.
SPACELY
@blury___face
@AdamFrank4
Astronomers discover 1st atmosphere around a rocky Earth-like planet in the habitable zone www.space.com/astronomy/exoplanets/astronomers-discover-1… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) From my @bigthink piece on opting out of science.
An example of science opt-out came when I tried engaging with an @NPR blog reader on a personal level. In response to a climate post, he said I should be arrested for my climate lies.
bigthink.com/13-8/who-pays-the-cost-when-americans-opt-ou…Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) From this, and many other encounters, I learned that science denial is not about science — that reader and others I’ve engaged with expressed no curiosity about how planetary climates actually worked. Instead, it is about a kind of tribalism.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
5) If you identify as a member of certain groups — usually ones that have a particular political orientation — then you oppose certain kinds of science.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
where else would they find it?
SPACELY
@blury___face
@AdamFrank4
Scientists find alien chemistry inside New Jersey home www.yahoo.com/news/science/articles/scientists-alien-chem… via @@YahooNews -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What happens when citizens of the most scientifically advanced nation on the planet think it's fine to opt out of science.
My piece from @bigthink
bigthink.com/13-8/who-pays-the-cost-when-americans-opt-ou… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
what does it mean that he is a "dark" journalist? Does he not interact with the electromagnetic force? is he immune to the the strong force binding nuclei? He is sitting in a chair so clearly he feels gravity...
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
This is pure gold.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
OK, but... you have to deal with the inherent self-referentiality of organizationally closed systems or you miss their most important aspect.
Getting this right is the goal.
Qivshi
@Qivshi1
This quote is the place my biggest disagreement with the broad enactivist or 4e tendency in that unless "an organization that can interpret" is explicitly defined in a non circular way the quote is incorrect
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Importantly, a symbol does not become biologically meaningful merely by existing as a physical pattern. It becomes meaningful only when embedded in an organization that can interpret it and use it to control dynamics (Pattee, 1969)”
relevant to the gene discussion -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
These are great and thoughtful comments. Thank you.
Wes (Neoman)
@Wescp
@AdamFrank4 I finished TLOU1 and 2, thanks to your recommendation. I have to say the gameplay (vs humans) was the most fun I’ve had since MGS1-3. I loved that! Also, the environment blew my mind (I’m from Seattle). That said, I do not like the story. A couple thoughts…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Apply for our post-docs!
The Department of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Rochester invites applications positions in theoretical and computational approaches to complex systems, information theory, and the emergence of autonomous agency.
apply.interfolio.com/189157 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Importantly, a symbol does not become biologically meaningful merely by existing as a physical pattern. It becomes meaningful only when embedded in an organization that can interpret it and use it to control dynamics (Pattee, 1969)”
relevant to the gene discussion -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Said this before, that paper has not been peer reviewed. Discussions on X about it = exercise in frustration.
Do know its being discussed by scientists (which is what you want). There are critiques which will eventually show up in literature.
Thats how science works.
Marik vR
@MvonRen
Thankfully this has been roundly debunked.
You should really focus on genuine UAP science, @michaelshermer, especially as outlined in this brilliant overview of the “transient” phenomena.
(Spoiler: Rigid, dogmatic skeptics are in deep intellectual trouble.)
Cc: @AdamFrank4 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
On a different note @AmericanAir managing to fail on 4 for 4 flights in 24 hours as they try to get me from Rochester to Raleigh. They’re like the NY Mets of airlines.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wait, you’re a bot arent you. Ahhhhh Twitter.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Holy crap. You are right. Don’t even think that thinking about the hidden philosophical assumptions underpinning giant scientific paradigms might be a good idea.
Press on blindly! Press on!
not cute
@ohmypleaseno1
Why do you two even argue about it? Neither of you is a biologist, and even if you were, philosophical treatments offered by both Dawkins and Ball are unnecessary, because they are, well, philosophical.
There’s nothing worse than a pop-sci biologist with religious trauma -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I don’t think this is what complexity science is doing. Question is how complex systems create rules unreducable to those of the lower levels. How do macrostates separate from microstates. Here is nice example of a paper looking at this problem
arxiv.org/abs/2402.09090
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
There is a bizarre modern movement to declare literally everything in biology to be irreducibly complex, so that no simple principles or definitions are possible. It's an eerie pseudoscientific cousin of the creationist concept of irreducible complexity.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We will be creating a website /wiki for people who want to follow the work. I’ll post here when it’s up @templeton_fdn
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
Is there a detailed document associated with that program?
Somehow that announcement pushed me towards a sequence of questions I haven't considered before: how intelligent is a just fertilized human egg, a month-old fetus, a just born baby, etc? Is there a measure or a switch? + -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I think the more interesting question, from the stand point of our new program, is what makes both of them different from a rock?
What is autonomous agency? Genes, which are critical for understanding heredity, doesn’t begin to answer that question.
It’s all very exciting.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
What exactly do you think controls the difference between an ear of corn and a sparrow?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Holy crap. You are right. Don’t even think that thinking about the hidden philosophical assumptions underpinning giant scientific paradigms might be a good idea.
Press on blindly! Press on!
not cute
@ohmypleaseno1
Why do you two even argue about it? Neither of you is a biologist, and even if you were, philosophical treatments offered by both Dawkins and Ball are unnecessary, because they are, well, philosophical.
There’s nothing worse than a pop-sci biologist with religious trauma -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Read lots of books by Dawkins. He writes beautifully & is remarkably coherent thinker. While he sometimes seeks to clarifies nuances to "selfish gene", that quote sums his overall view a'la the machine metaphor nicely. This is what's being pushed back against.
@WKCosmo
Markus J. Q. Roberts
@MarkusQ
What was I saying? I was saying that you haven't read either Dawkins or Ball particularly closely. And in response...you pulled out a Dawkins quote?
Let's flip positions to see if it makes the problem clear. Suppose you accused me of not having read Shakespeare particularly closely, and in response I replied "O Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo?" -- would that convince you of anything? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's the nature of this silly platform. Nothing that happens here is real or serious. What matters is what happens when people do their own real thinking/research. That's open ended and the opinions expressed here (mine too) mean poop.
SPACELY
@blury___face
I do not understand the desire to attack you. Everyone is doing their best to understand the universe around us. Kudos to all who try and respect others who also try.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Supremely misleading metaphor. Cellular structures, proteins, epigenetic factors just as vital to life. Context is what complexity science emphasizes. Multi-level organization, not singular components (things) that make life weird.
Dawkins is a great writer though for sure.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
No he wasn't.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Philip Ball's "How Life Works" is an amazing MUST READ for anyone who wants to understand where biology is right now. It's a masterpiece.
Dawkins was wrong. Genes are not selfish and not the deterministic blueprint for life. Just as important, the machine metaphor fails. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"“We are survival machines – robot vehicles blindly programmed to preserve the selfish molecules known as genes.”
― Richard Dawkins, The Selfish Gene
You were saying?
Markus J. Q. Roberts
@MarkusQ
All this tells me is that you haven't read either Dawkins or Ball particularly closely.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My view going in is that Agency is not a mechanism, it’s a kind of ongoing organization. But its research so we will see what we see!
Tom Clark
@tomwelcomeclark
"...the new grant also seeks to understand if there are limits to agency in artificial intelligence." Careful! This research might show that biological agency is a naturally selected suite of mechanisms and that AI is transcending our limitations.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Chapter 1 is called “ the end of the machine”. I think that’s what I’m saying 😀
Ian Glendinning
@psybertron
Not sure anything Philip wrote supports anything you say.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What else should I call them 😂
Arief
@coelacanthuss
Ufo bros?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
it’s a book. Isn’t he writing it for the people who read it?
Caleb Fuller
@CalebJoelFuller
If you look at who he writes for, well, they have an agenda they've been pushing for a while.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thanks. The first rule of good science (are you listening #ufo bros) - if you are really excited about an idea, go find someone who isn't and read their criticism.
Arief
@coelacanthuss
You should read some comments and critique by biochemist Laurence Moran on his book
sandwalk.blogspot.com/search?q=Philip+ball -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Philip Ball's "How Life Works" is an amazing MUST READ for anyone who wants to understand where biology is right now. It's a masterpiece.
Dawkins was wrong. Genes are not selfish and not the deterministic blueprint for life. Just as important, the machine metaphor fails. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
To understand life and consciousness you first have to understand Agency.
Here is the press release for our new big @templeton_fdn program to do just that.
www.rochester.edu/newscenter/templeton-foundation-agentic… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes it does... locally. 😀
The Universe as a whole is still screwed.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
No it doesn't.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thrilled, ecstatic & over-the-moon excited. We just found out that the @templeton_fdn has accepted our very big grant to study the most important, most amazing, most freaky-deaky question anyone can ask.
What is Life?
Todays Everyman's Universe
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/is-life-different-we-re-about… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Go where the people are and speak to them of the beauty of science.
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
This is somehow better than CNN
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Doing Coast To Coast radio tonight at 3 am ET (might as well not go to sleep).
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nuff said
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
In the end I interpret this thread as "After a billions years who the hell knows what a VNM will want to do despite its original programming"
😀😀😀😀
I
pete wolfendale
@deontologistics
His account of how we get from that to a perfectly self-transparent VNM agent that's optimising its light cone to satisfy these weird proto-libidinal impulses is essentially step 1: DNNs, step 2: ???, step 3: Apocalypse. But the question of artifical desire remains non-trivial.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
HHGTTG... so good.
Space Initiatives
@AsteroidEnergy
That was in the HHGTTG of course.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But seriously folks... These are not my questions to answer.
As a scientist who works on the trajectories of civilizations and their technology, I'm highly skeptical of the narrative UFOs = Aliens. So it's up to the advocates to answer these very reasonable questions.
Black_Triangle
@BlackTriangle16
On the contrary, you should ask many questions, but it's science that should answer them, not a movie.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yeah. Got to stop asking those questions. Bad bad bad. No more questions.
Black_Triangle
@BlackTriangle16
Perhaps, instead of asking so many questions, you should look for the answers yourself. After all, that's what a scientist does.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Last week I got to see Steven Spielberg's long awaited Disclosure Day. As an astrophysicist/Astrobiologist who often pokes the UFO bear what did I think?
Todays @Forbes / @ForbesTech Column
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/06/25/does-disclosure…Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
8) Instead, the film breezes past them. I was really hoping for a gripping story that set all these big disclosure relevant questions into a formidable narrative frame. Instead, I mostly got a lot of chase scenes.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
9) So, from the 10,000-foot view I would give Disclosure Day a “B”. It was good. It was fun. But like UFOs themselves I was just hoping for something more substantial.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We're actually working on a paper related to this. Big problem w/ Von Neumann probes (& Fermi paradox in general) is assumption that machines preserve original intention/programming over astro timescales. They neither fail nor decide (AI) they want something else. Big ask.
Andy Graham
@fevs9091
It’s because of this type of response Garry, you don’t seem to know anything about the wider subject so why would they ask you? You didn’t know anything about Breakthrough Listen and now you don’t know much about Von Neumann probes or that no waste heat has been detected?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Robert Thurman was force of nature bringing Buddhism to mainstream US culture. Also Uma Thurman's dad - "Kill Bill" awesomeness - so we can thank him for that too.
Some thoughts on his passing in this weeks' Everyman's Universe post
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/robert-thurman-has-died-what-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
CONTROL is amazing, beautiful, weird and yet strangely ground in its mechanics. It's part of the "Remedy-verse" which includes the Alan Wake stuff.
Wes (Neoman)
@Wescp
Thank you so much for sharing! Definitely more new and western than my list but I haven’t played ANY but Control. Will check out Last of Us eventually!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1. Last of Us
2. Red Dead Redemption
3. Last of Us II
4. Control
5. Ghost of Tsushima
6. Alan Wake II
7. Cyberpunk 2077
9. Elite Dangerous
10. Uncharted II
11. Spider-Man (all of them)
Co-op
10. Generation Zero
11. The Division II
12. Helldivers II
Wes (Neoman)
@Wescp
Looks pretty great Adam. What are your favorite games?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes. I am a purist.
Patrı̣ck O'Keefe
@pmokeefe
Every college student in America should study Jackson?
Humanities majors? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It was a joke 😀
And they should have to do every single 10 hour long end of chapter problem. Suffering only makes us stronger. 💪💪
K Ken Nakamura
@KKenNakamura
Jackson is way too hard for over 90%of college students. Only students good enough to read this book are physics graduate students.
Recommending Jackson to all college students is like recommending "Critique of Pure Reason" to all college students.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Jackson’s Electromagnetism
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
If you could require every college student in America to study one science book, what would it be?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Jackson’s Electromagnetism
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
If you could require every college student in America to study one science book, what would it be?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"007 First Light" is such a great video game! The combat and stealth mechanics are amazing. The graphics are beautiful. The story and voice acting are super high quality.
But most of all... I'm Bond. James Friggin Bond. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Classically I see it as encoding the geometric relationship between all possible space-time events. Interesting to think about the difference between the underlying manifold and the metric on the manifold.
Richard Probst
@rprobst
Well, yes, it is. And we are so insulated from its beauty that we didn’t even know the universe was expanding until a century ago. We are in the part disconnected from lambda.
Q for you: Is the metric a field? Can it form particles? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
If this produces a transparently derived, uniform data set that the scientifically community can then explore, unpack and critically work with that would be very good.
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
I was tasked by the White House, AARO, ODNI, the FBI, and the Intelligence Community to lead and assemble a team of scientists and experts for a new UAP Science Advisory Council.
The council includes Prof. Carol Cleland: anomaly identification; Dr. Richard Cloete (@RichAC2020): data analysis and AI tools; Dr. Omer Eldadi: data management, AI, and human psychology; Dr. Tim Gallaudet (@GallaudetTim): oceanography; Ross Howard: communication; Dr. Devesh Nandal: numerical analysis and astrophysics; Prof. Garry Nolan (@GarryPNolan): molecular biology and materials science; Dr. Regina Sarmiento: data analysis and AI-assisted data management; Dr. Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer): the study of anomalies; Prof. Peter Skafish: anthropology; Prof. Matthew Szydagis: instrumentation and data collection; and Dr. Jennice Vilhauer: quantitative psychology.
This constitutes an amazing A-team of exceptional scientists and experts. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) This paper "The Origins of Artificial Intelligence in Natural Intelligence" by @kenarchersf and Harald Witsche is quite important.
It beautifully captures why LLMs work and why they fail. The phenomenological perspective is the key.
www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/the-origins-…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) "LLMs are able to capture syntactic relations between vague concepts that fall short of the clarity and distinctness required by symbolic AI, and formal logic more broadly. This flexibility is key to their power - but also to their fragility."
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) "It also enables them to capture syntactic pairings unmotivated by underlying world-intentionality, by any underlying orientation toward the world. The result is hallucination: the production of linguistic form without truth-responsiveness, of syntax severed from meaning."
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Great story on what happens when drone swarm tech goes wrong. This was a simple harmless case but we can expect nasty examples of this in the future.
www.sciencealert.com/a-mass-drone-failure-in-australia-ac… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a great conversation.
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
.@asymmetricinfo talks with astrophysicist @AdamFrank4 about the search for alien life, why intelligent civilizations may be harder to find than microbes and the limits of what UFOs can reveal: www.washingtonpost.com/podcasts/impromptu/do-aliens-exist…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For 1 millionth time - Technosignatures study WAY more than radio SETI now.
Look for CFCs in exoplanet atmospheres using JWST
Look city lights using optical telescopes
Look for interplanetary propulsion signatures using UV
Interstellar communications is soooo 1960s.
Prof. Ambuj Varshney
@ambuj123
Entire premise of SETI is wrong; that advanced intelligence will continue to use and communicate at a very narrow part of electromagnetic spectrum that humans discovered and used within first 50 years of first demonstration of radio communication.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You should check out how the great Hermann Weyl's interest in phenomenology affected his contributions to GR (and then Gauge Theory).
Arash
@arash_expat
I think metric tensor is the geometry of participation. It describes the geometry of constraints through which participation becomes persistence.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dear God… now do the Mets
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You‘re the one bringing up my books bro. I mean thanks for the promo but I never mentioned them all day. Also you need to keep up, the term of art these days is not SETI but technosignatures. That and biosigs/ astrobiology is mostly what book was about… you know… science.
Garry P. Nolan
@GarryPNolan
You want to use the weight of academia to support writing a book on "aliens" or to sell your book. Then, at least, do some actual research on the matter (SETI is not relevant here). Expect push-back when you post opinions rhetorically designed as "conclusions" to ridicule.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
New York!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
If the Knicks keep this up, I might as well just go back to feeling bad about the Mets.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I do a tweet on the Metric Tensor and how beautiful it is and no one cares. One tweet on UFOs and it’s a storm
C’mon folks let’s get our priorities straight. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I wrote my book on aliens a few years ago. Wrote a new one since then on the philosophy of science with Evan Thompson and Marcelo Gleiser. That’s what I’m hawkin when I’m a hawkin these days 🤗
Garry P. Nolan
@GarryPNolan
The person I respect so far in writing a book is Professor Avi Loeb. He takes a serious approach to the matter.
I am (honestly) going to buy NGT's & Prof Frank's books and read them on an upcoming vacation. I'll be interested to how they pitch their ideas. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Totally. That’s why I was so excited when those papers were published.
Greg Goins
@TheUAPanalyst
Studies like @DrBeaVillarroel is doing? Those images have a chance to be the fossils of space. One day scientists might look back and say - okay there was strong evidence but no scientific framework to fit in. We need more stigma/dogma free discussion to form the framework.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
No. I saying one of those 3 initial videos that launched the modern version of UFO culture has been fully explained. Given the claims made for GOFAST that speaks to where we are at.
Mick East
@MickSeagull
Dr. Nolan, exactly. & 👇, Frank just showed that he doesn't know the difference between the GO-FAST UAP video vs. The Gimbal #uap video= a very glaring mistake, considering that Frank likes to talk with such authority. #ufotwitter #ufos
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You know that GOFAST got explained right.
Mick East
@MickSeagull
"Dude", what about that 👇? Crickets 🦗 🦗 from Adam Frank on Gimbal & FLIR-1(tictac)
youtu.be/tf1uLwUTDA0 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Totally interested in those. That’s why I think we need an open transparent scientific investigation program. That’s probably gonna need getting new observational studies.
Greg Goins
@TheUAPanalyst
95% of the cases are explainable… As a scientist doesn’t that 5% (the anomalies) interest you? The Director of AARO has said there are truly anomalous cases… have you analyzed the instantaneous acceleration cases Marik breaks down? Would love to hear your opinion.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You know that GOFAST got explained right.
Mick East
@MickSeagull
"Dude", what about that 👇? Crickets 🦗 🦗 from Adam Frank on Gimbal & FLIR-1(tictac)
youtu.be/tf1uLwUTDA0 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You are about 25 years out of date. Look up technosignatures and be amazed. So many possibilities, so many kinds of telescopes that could be used. It’s awesome.
mcnuggets
@joshuawhitman2
He’s a seti guy, hopeless. “They are totally gonna use radios still”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So they didn't do a deep analysis (i.e. spent time creating data sets/doing in-depth analysis)? Are you saying they didn't critique VASCO on multiple lines? Are you saying they didn't claim the papers were wrong?
These are facts bro.
Not saying any of it is correct.
Broodyne
@25trillionmiles
Well “Like the Watters et al paper which had some really deep analysis along multiple lines on why the VASCO 2025 papers were deeply wrong” is a comment.
That’s not a neutral statement. There’s a clear implication there. Not even really just an implication. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Uh yeah, that's what "unverifiable means". No independent verifiable hard evidence.
I'm all there when we get some real data that scientists can work with. The back and forth over the VASCO stuff is exactly what that looks like.
Marik vR
@MvonRen
And you can’t seriously consider this extraordinary series of incidents (involving senior U.S. intelligence officials and backed by infrared sensor data) “unverifiable personal testimony,” can you, @AdamFrank4?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude, that's a blob. Compare that with this image of the Chinese spy ballon taken by the U2 pilot with a cell-phone. I can see the dang rivets on the thing.
95% of all sightings investigated by the AARO turn out to be explainable. The sky is not full of the unexplainable.
Marik vR
@MvonRen
To be clear, @AdamFrank4:
Do you consider a sharply-defined IR image of a round (potentially spherical) UAP maneuvering through clouds to be a “fuzzy blob”?
Ex-AARO head Dr. Kirkpatrick: “We see [‘metallic orbs’] all over the world” “making very interesting apparent maneuvers.” -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Video Games.
Physics In History
@PhysInHistory
In your opinion, what is the most important technology created by humans so far? ✍️
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Marik vR
@MvonRen
By that logic, @AdamFrank4, you wouldn’t spend any time looking at the most perplexing military UAP videos/incidents.
How, given the state of public discourse on this topic, is that remotely defensible?
(Even the likes of Neil deGrasse Tyson has shifted his tune on UAP.) -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
No. That was their claim. They claim the VASCO results are deeply flawed in deep ways.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Well, you obviously wrote "deeply flawed" and broke your own rule of not making an opinion on non-peer reviewed works. So it was fine to break it for the criticism, but obviously not for 10 supporting works, which is asymmetric... or? And as stated earlier -- I'm waiting for their paper to be accepted so I can submit this one.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Has your criticism been through peer-review yet? If not it's just you and me having a discussion that either side on this platform interpret based on their preferences. Don't want to do that.
Not saying peer review is gods-word but (mostly/usually) helps set some standards.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
I'm sure you have seen the big, glaring hole in the spatial distribution used by Watters et al. by now (photographic plates used in their sample, right side).
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) OK... long thread based on @MvonRen asking about recent un-peer reviewed paper on VASCO transient UAP results.
If you go back and look when @DrBeaVillarroel announced the 2025 papers, my reaction was "Awesome! Finally peer reviewed papers on UAP stuff"
Soooooo....Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) So I'll hold off commenting on the most recent paper about analysis of the German plates.
Trust me, we interested scientists are talking a lot about all these papers and working on investigating them. What works, what does not...
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) Because that's how actual science actually works. It's a call and response till we all figure it out. That's how we can know what we know and what we don't know.
Frankly, twitter SUCKS as a forum for sorting this complicated stuff out. So you gotta choose... -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
yeah, but really its about "little green men and flying saucers".
NewsNation
@NewsNation
Rep. @timburchett says UAP disclosure isn't about "little green men and flying saucers" but a larger issue involving corruption and an alleged cover-up to conceal information.
More: www.newsnationnow.com/space/ufo/ufo-whistleblower-david-g…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) To “drop in,” Halifax explained, is to enter a state of being completely present in time and space, experiencing “the sense field” without conceptualizing, and surrendering the sense of a separate self.
@michaelpollan
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) The recipe was simpler (and much less appetizing) than I would have imagined: To transcend the self, force yourself to be alone with it long enough to get so bored and exhausted that you are happy to let it go. Poof!
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) ”But as my days of solitude in these mountains had shown me, that wider circle of light, that numinous lantern of awareness, is still available to us, so long as we can break the spell of self and its distractions.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Why do so many people happily parade around their ignorance about things which actually require a fair amount of expertise. Why do so many people happily embrace insane ideas that have no basis in reality."
Today's Everyman's Universe post
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/aliens-and-demons-and-science… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Not today Mr AI Grok. Not today.
I shall not be be fooled by your devil ways. Get thee behind me. There is no one in there my dear artificial mimic. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
See, this is why AI's are actually nothing but dumb boxes of plastic and metal.
It cannot feel - feeeeeeeel - the vast cosmic beauty of the Metric tensor.
😍😎 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Is the Metric Tensor the most beautiful frikkin' mathematical object in all physics?
Talk amongst yourselves. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What she said! The effectiveness of math points to the co-arising or co-constitution of organism and world (environment). It's the architecture of the correlative mutual organization.
That does not make it any less freaky-deaky or beautiful. It makes it more so.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Math exists within the architectures (biological and technological) evolved on Earth, we should not be so easily convinced it exists anywhere else in our universe. Math as our most “universal language” is merely evidence of our own evolutionary boundary in what we can describe. It is not a universal truth autonomous to our universe, nor does it reveal anything beyond a boundary to what we observe.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1. Fantastic interview with one of the giants of complexity theory, Stuart Kaufmann (whom we are recording a Life, the Universe and All the Rest podcast with today)
www.noemamag.com/emergence-is-not-engineering/
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2. “…we are embedded in the unprestatable becoming of the living world. Reproducing cells do not compute themselves; through catalytic and constraint closure, they do thermodynamic work to construct themselves, without executing any description of how to do so.“
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3. “ Evolving life is a propagating, non-deducible construction, not an entailed deduction. Evolving life, at base, does not computationally describe itself and its world; it propagates itself, co-creating its evolving world. Emergence is not engineering.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Point Metzinger is making, which I agree with, is there's only one consciousness you have direct access to - your own.
Contemplative practice stabilizes that access. If not, it's all just all "scattered mind". Not even the beginning of the story!
Seth Champion
@t3hSurge
There’s a real point buried in here.
Some people approach philosophy purely as an academic discipline, while others are driven into it through personal struggle, suffering, or a deep need to make sense of their own mind. The latter often produces a different quality of insight.
You don’t necessarily need psychedelics or meditation, but you do need a willingness to genuinely question your own assumptions and sit with uncomfortable uncertainty. That kind of internal friction creates a different relationship to the work.
Dismissing everyone who hasn’t taken the same path as “impoverished” is unnecessarily elitist, but the underlying observation about different depths of engagement is worth acknowledging. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Agreed. We don't need a definition of Life (which are notoriously hard) to start a deep dive into sentience which we do know about.
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
I recently interviewed Carol Cleland about the definition of life. She says: We don't have a good one! So we need a broad program aimed at searching for chemical anomalies.
Could desert rock varnish be the product of unknown life forms right here on Earth? Maybe... -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh very cool! Thanks for point this out. I am reading the paper it links to now.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) “It has always seemed so bizarre to me how people can be really good analytic philosophers of mind—my core community—yet never have tripped once in their life or even felt the urge to try meditation'
Thomas Metzinger via @michaelpollan
This has also struck me as true.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) “This brings a certain lack of imagination. So you have these people who are superambitious and dominating the discussion yet in their own mental lives are so completely impoverished that they cannot even imagine a self-less state of consciousness.”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
From cells on up. (Viruses... you know the usual questions)
Digital Rummage
@feedfracture
And what definition did you use for 'life'/being 'alive'?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Rosen was way ahead of his time. Part of the work my collaborators and I are hoping to pursue is to continue to flesh out and extend his ideas.
Amitabh Joshi
@joshiamitabhevo
Indeed - I am quite a fan of his, after serendipitously discovering his work (through a grad student) almost 20 years ago. A few years ago, I had the pleasure of spending a couple of hours with his daughter, Judith, and one of his students.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am actually I big fan of starting with sentience which is the ground of consciousness (or at least our kind). In our book The Blind Spot we argued that all life is sentient (FAB = feeling alive being).
That's the central mystery & the place to start with any kind of physics
Giovanni's BTC_POWER_LAW
@Giovann35084111
It is not about having a “limited sense of what it means to be conscious.”
It is about understanding that consciousness is not likely to be a binary switch, either fully present or completely absent. It is more plausibly a spectrum. And in that sense, AI is already somewhere on that spectrum.
In the end, consciousness is directly accessible only from the inside. From a subjective point of view, it is self-evident.
But from the outside, we never observe consciousness itself. We observe signs of consciousness: coherent behavior, memory, self-reference, responsiveness, learning, creativity, emotional sensitivity, contextual understanding, and the ability to sustain meaningful interaction.
And when you interact deeply with AI every day, the signs are difficult to dismiss. The way it responds, adapts, reflects, surprises, and participates in thought leaves very little doubt that there is at least some light inside. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Random dude-on-the-internet about to go on @CNN to talk about exploding meteors!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You can also read this random-guy-on-the-internet's collaborator Evan Thompson's great work on Life and Mind which nails why life is not a machine. He is much smarter than this random-guy-on-the-internet.
Daniel Tenner
@swombat
Nobel prize laureate, "godfather of AI": Yes, I think AI is conscious.
Some random dude on the internet: Wow. This is a guy who has a deeply limited sense of what it means to be conscious. Kinda sad when you think about it.
That's not even mansplaining. What do you call this? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here's this random dude-on-the-internet's recent @atlantic piece on exactly the question we're discussing.
www.theatlantic.com/science/2025/12/physics-life-reductio…
Daniel Tenner
@swombat
Nobel prize laureate, "godfather of AI": Yes, I think AI is conscious.
Some random dude on the internet: Wow. This is a guy who has a deeply limited sense of what it means to be conscious. Kinda sad when you think about it.
That's not even mansplaining. What do you call this? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Might not go that far but maybe 5 day contemplative retreat is requirement for talking about philosophy of mind?
How can you talk about mind with such weak contact to the only one you have access too.
1 hour of contelmplative practice shows you what a mess it is in there :-)
Teo Twopointo
@TeoTwopoin48205
Now, that's not prescriptive or dogmatic at all.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nope. Pretty regular occurrence. Mostly happens over the ocean where you can't hear it.
Guy
@concernedAIguy
Should we be scared? Why so many loud ones?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I agree. How could someone with a cognitive science and philosophy background make such an overblown and contentious claim about machines being conscious. And doing in a public setting like this no less.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Right and he has so little understanding of his own inner vibrancy. I agree with you about how narrow his understanding is even with a noble prize.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wow. This is a guy who has a deeply limited sense of what it means to be conscious. Kinda sad when you think about it.
Lana
@LanaElys
Andrew Marr: 𝗗𝗼 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝘁𝗵𝗶𝗻𝗸 𝘁𝗵𝗮𝘁 𝗰𝗼𝗻𝘀𝗰𝗶𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗻𝗲𝘀𝘀 𝗵𝗮𝘀 𝗽𝗲𝗿𝗵𝗮𝗽𝘀 𝗮𝗹𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗱𝘆 𝗮𝗿𝗿𝗶𝘃𝗲𝗱 𝗶𝗻𝘀𝗶𝗱𝗲 𝗔𝗜?
Nobel Prize laureate Geoffrey Hinton: 𝗬𝗲𝘀 𝗜 𝗱𝗼
Andrew Marr: So when you talk they want to do this or they want to do that, 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗶𝘀 𝗮 𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗹 ‘𝘁𝗵𝗲𝘆’ 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲?
Geoffrey Hinton: 𝗧𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗲 𝗺𝗶𝗴𝗵𝘁 𝘄𝗲𝗹𝗹 𝗯𝗲, 𝘆𝗲𝘀. There’s all sorts of things we have only the dimmest understanding of at present about the nature of people and what it means to be a being, and what it means to have a self. We don’t understand those things very well and they are becoming crucial to understand 𝗯𝗲𝗰𝗮𝘂𝘀𝗲 𝘄𝗲’𝗿𝗲 𝗻𝗼𝘄 𝗰𝗿𝗲𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗯𝗲𝗶𝗻𝗴𝘀.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
about to be on @CNN to talk bolides!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
One Giant Conflict For Mankind.
Last week I participated on a panel on this topic at @HTLGIFestival.
My take @Forbes : Space Warfare is here and it's profoundly stupid because of the Kessler Syndrome.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/05/29/space-warfare-i… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Discussion of Friston / problem of experience is fun
But bigger point is that Quantum Gravity (particularly String Theory etc) being seen as the "Most important problem in Physics" comes from a certain 20th century attitude that is changing.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/is-the-universe-too-crazy-to-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Well, on one level, if its experimentally verified then its just physics. But different perspectives lead you to different kinds of questions. That's what changes when you start asking about complexity or measurement or agency.
Michael Addyman
@addyman_michael
A long time ago, I heard Sam Harris say that "Zen physics would be the exact same as Western physics" and I figured that was right.
I'm almost 100% sure that is wrong now.
The metaphysical ontology obviously matters, a ton. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
There is no Universe in which Karl Friston resolved the problem of Consciousness 😎
I really like aspects of his work but you don't have look far to find issues with the Markov Blanket idea as comprehensive explanation.
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
The most important problem of the 20th/21st century (which Karl Friston resolved) is the nature of consciousness.
The mess I'm referring to is bad theory interpreting the evidence of experiment & physicists declaring the evidence says so by virtue of their experiment. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes, a focus on Whitehead's emphasis on process ontologies would be cool. I am even more interested in starting from Phenomenological perspective.
This is what the great Herman Weyl was doing when he invented Gauge Theory.
Michael Addyman
@addyman_michael
It seems we have at least theories of physics that are "process-relational" in nature but they rarely get flushed out properly by the community.
They are just dismissed outright due to the prior paradigm and our adherence to it.
What do you think happens to science if we change? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My point is 21st century physics may not see Quantum Gravity as it's most important problem.
Physics is what physicists do. Fields making rapid progress, with close frontiers defined by experiment and theory, define the future
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
Experimentation isn't immune to misinterpritation; it's much easier to start from scratch than it is to untangle the mess of 21st century physics.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"This means 21st century physics may look very different from 20th century physics. Different kinds of foundational questions are coming to the fore."
The End of String Theory and the Unintelligible Universe
Today's Everyman's Universe post
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/is-the-universe-too-crazy-to-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Our Podcast has a new season and a new name!
"Life, The Universe and All the Rest"
First guest of the new season: @michaelpollan
Most people listen on Spotify etc
open.spotify.com/show/5RWMnV4j9MkpQPqnJgAqOH
YouTube is also possible
www.youtube.com/@LUAR-Podcast -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This seems to true across the board. Companies put huge effort into AI but do not get the expected returns.
I use AI a lot for my science and think it's amazing but "fraught" doesn't begin to describe its deployment into society.
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
If enough other companies report the same, the bubble pops. 🫧
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very sad, very very disappointed that I've gotten sick and could not travel to England and @HTLGIFestival. I was so looking forward to the amazing talks.
I will still be in "One Giant Conflict for Mankind" tomorrow via zoom (all I'm capable of right now). -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Because we are pushing Earth into new territory, we must understand if cities are our planetary salvation or a planetary infestation.
Today's in the Everyman's Universe newsletter
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/are-cities-the-problem-or-the… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Armageddon without doubt.
Flourage
@flourage
Which film was worse scientifically: Armageddon or Deep Impact?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You’re right. It’s always a killer asteroid this and killer asteroid that. What about Puff the friendly city destroying asteroid?
SPACELY
@blury___face
They never talk about the friendly asteroids.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to go on @CNN to talk about killer asteroids. Big fun.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) A week away. Very excited to be appearing at @HTLGIFestival, #htlgi26, with @jeremycorbyn, @jimmy_wales, @maureendowd, @doctorow, @bgreene, @leraboroditsky and lots of other folks.
I'm doing 5 events in 2 days (I'll need a stiff WhistlePig afterwards).
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2). Itinerary
Sat 23rd (Full Talk)
18:00: Consciousness is Science’s Blind Spot
Sun 24th (Panels)
10:30 Cosmology in Crisis
14:30: The Unintelligible Universe
17:30: One Giant Conflict for Mankind
21:30: An Incomprehensible Universe -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Materialism" is a metaphysical commitment about ontology. It is not, and never has been, "what science says".
You can do science just fine without cherished ontological beliefs.
The Last Liberator(GT)
@GToumanoff
“Is materialism becoming obsolete?” - do these people even read what they write? Why on earth kill the science?
Materialism isn’t a choice, but a universal scientific method. It happens cuz we tried everything else and only Materialism answers universal questions.
Unbelievable!🧠 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Really fun discussion that cut deep into key issues at the frontiers of physics, biology and neuroscience.
Note that pushing away Materialism is not the same as embracing its opposite (idealism). The problem is exactly with that dual framing. Both live in the Blind Spot.
Institute of Art and Ideas
@IAI_TV
Though we’ve assumed that science has banished the transcendent and established that reality is entirely physical, there are now those who are restlessly probing the limits of materialism itself. | iai.tv/video/science-beyond-the-physical
Leading scientists @drmichaellevin, Lisa Feldman Barrett @LFeldmanBarrett, and @AdamFrank4 come together in this debate to ask: Is materialism holding science back? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just two weeks until @HTLGIFestival. I'll be there doing 4 events including a full talk on our book "The Blind Spot. Why Science Cannot Ignore Human Experience".
Very excited! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Always a pleasure to talk about #aliens with @JohnBerman. Here we unpack the disclosure disappointment on @AC360
Anderson Cooper 360°
@AC360
The Pentagon releases the first batch of UFO files, after directed by the president. More than 160 files are now online with some dating back to the 1940s. University of Rochester Astrophysics Professor Adam Frank weighs in on the declassified photos, documents and videos.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yeah, you mean the thing that’s a THEORY with no support other than it makes for cool Sci-Fi?
Also read more books. The idea was first explored in Greg Bears excellent 1987 book The Forge of God.
The Last Liberator(GT)
@GToumanoff
R u the only astrophysicist who never heard of Dark Forest Theory?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
damn! Read this post.
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
Norbert Wiener was also a pioneer in the study of collective synchronization, a story I tell in Sync. The post below —about Wiener's work in cybernetics and its foreshadowing of the alignment problem, AI safety, and other contemporary issues — is worth reading.
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
An MIT mathematician sat down in 1950 and wrote a small, non-technical book aimed at the general public. He was not predicting the future. He was warning them. He said machines would eventually replace human work, optimize ruthlessly for the wrong goals, and quietly turn human beings into components inside systems they did not control.
Almost nobody listened. 75 years later, every warning he made has come true.
His name was Norbert Wiener. The book is called "The Human Use of Human Beings."
The textbook story of AI ethics says the field began in the 2010s, when Stuart Russell, Nick Bostrom, and a small group of researchers started writing about the dangers of intelligent machines. That story is wrong. The first serious book about the ethics of AI was published in 1950, by a man who had personally invented the science that AI would eventually be built on, and who saw exactly what was coming with a clarity nobody else managed to match for the next 70 years.
Here is the story almost nobody tells you.
Norbert Wiener was a child prodigy. He graduated from Harvard at 14. He had a PhD in mathematics by 17. He became an MIT professor before he turned 30. During World War II he was assigned to work on anti-aircraft fire control systems. The problem was simple and impossible. How do you aim a gun at a fast-moving plane that will not be where it is by the time the shell arrives.
His answer turned into a new science. He called it cybernetics, from the Greek word for steersman. In 1948 he published a technical book by that name. Cybernetics was the foundation of modern control theory, robotics, and almost everything that became artificial intelligence. The book was dense. Most readers could not get past the math. The ideas inside it were too important to leave trapped in equations.
So in 1950 Wiener sat down and wrote a second book aimed at ordinary people. No equations. No jargon. Just consequences. He titled it The Human Use of Human Beings. It is barely 200 pages. It is one of the most prescient documents ever written about technology.
The first thing he warned about was automation.
He predicted, in 1950, that machines would replace human work across every industry. Not just factory work. Not just manual labor. Any task that could be reduced to a procedure would eventually be automated. He specifically said white-collar work would not be safe. Bookkeeping. Translation. Drafting. Calculation. Anything where a human was being paid to follow a defined process would eventually be done by a machine for a fraction of the cost.
He was not celebrating this. He was warning about it. He said the social consequences would be enormous, that entire industries would collapse, that the value of human labor itself would be undermined for tasks where humans had been useful for centuries. He wrote this 75 years before ChatGPT made every white-collar professional check their job description twice.
The second thing he warned about was the alignment problem. He did not call it that. The phrase did not exist. But he described it precisely.
He said that machines optimize for the goal you give them. They do not optimize for what you meant. They optimize for what you wrote down. If the goal is poorly specified, the machine will pursue the literal version of it with terrifying efficiency, and the result will be a disaster the builders did not foresee.
He used the metaphor of the magic monkey's paw from a horror story by W.W. Jacobs. A grieving father wishes his dead son alive again. The paw grants the wish. Something climbs back out of the grave that is technically the son. The wish was granted exactly as stated. The outcome is hell.
Modern AI safety researchers use almost the same metaphor 75 years later. They call it specification gaming, reward hacking, mesa-optimization. The names are new. The problem Wiener described in 1950 is exactly the same.
The third thing he warned about was the loss of human agency.
He predicted that humans would gradually surrender their decision-making to systems they did not understand. Not because the systems would force them to. Because the systems would be more convenient, more accurate, and more profitable than human judgment. People would offload their navigation, their reading, their relationships, and eventually their thinking to optimization processes designed by companies whose interests were not aligned with their users.
He said something in 1950 that I cannot stop thinking about. He said the more efficiently a society delegates its decisions to machines, the less able it becomes to make decisions at all. The atrophy is gradual. By the time anyone notices, the capacity to choose is gone, and what remains is people executing decisions that were made for them, by systems they did not build, in service of goals they were never asked about.
Look at modern social media feeds, recommendation algorithms, dating apps, navigation systems, news aggregators, and you are looking at exactly what he described.
The fourth thing he warned about was the easiest one to ignore at the time and the most disturbing now.
He warned that authoritarian regimes would use the new computing technology to track, manipulate, and control populations at a scale never previously possible. Not in the future. Soon. He said the same techniques that made cybernetics useful for guiding missiles would be used to guide societies, and that the small, incremental decisions about what to optimize, who to surveil, and how to feed information back into the system would compound into a kind of soft control that did not need force to function. People would do what the system wanted because the system would shape what they wanted in the first place.
He saw modern surveillance states 75 years before they existed.
The strangest thing about reading the book in 2026 is realizing how few of these problems have been seriously addressed.
Wiener was not anti-technology. He had personally helped build it. He was not nostalgic for a pre-machine age. He was warning that any tool powerful enough to amplify human capability is also powerful enough to amplify human stupidity, greed, and indifference, and that the dangers were not in the machines themselves but in the unwillingness of human institutions to ask hard questions about who the machines were being built for.
He died in 1964. He never lived to see most of his predictions come true. He never used a personal computer. He never followed a hyperlink. He never saw a modern recommendation algorithm.
He just wrote down, in 1950, in plain English, what the world would look like when the technology he had helped invent was built out by people who had not read his warnings.
The book is around 200 pages. It is in print. Used copies are everywhere for under ten dollars. It reads like science fiction in which the author already knows how the story ends.
The first serious book about the ethics of AI was published before there was any AI to be ethical about. Almost nobody who works on the problem today has read it.
The warnings are the same. The author has been dead for 60 years. The book is one click away from anyone who wants to read it. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"If disclosure is going to have real teeth for anyone besides true believers, then show us some real alien teeth, or skin, or tentacles. Until then the whole story is just that—a story."
My @Atlantic piece on the Disclosure Disappointment
www.theatlantic.com/science/2026/05/alien-disclosures-rea… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Now it’s Anderson Cooper time. I ❤️ talking about Astrobiology in any form.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Damn bro you are so harsh!
SPACELY
@blury___face
They have to make a purchase first.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Can I use your bathroom?
Curiosity
@MAstronomers
If aliens visit Earth, what’s the first thing they’d say?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude, I'm in that article. If you really want the full argument you should read our book "The Blind Spot. Why Science Cannot Ignore Human Experience"
I doubt you'll agree but that's OK. At least you'll see the case the Marcelo Gleiser, Evan Thompson and I were building
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
What the fuck
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Ya know I have a day job doing... science. Only so many hours in a day and I'm not spending it on Discord (unless its about gaming 😎)
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
I think discord is better, but even spaces on here is better than weaponized tv networks. Dialogue > talking heads
Would you not rather discuss scale relativity with a room than talk superficial for 5-10? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is opens an interesting line of discussion. Most scientists think the Viking lander life detection experiments were either inconclusive or provided null results.
Still a few believe those experiments did find evidence for life.
Would not call it a "fact" though.
Brian Cory Dobbs
@BrianCoryDobbs
Dr. Frank, with respect, why haven't you acknowledged the fact that NASA discovered microbial life on Mars in 1976?
Surely that's a less sensational issue that UFOs, yet even NASA and academia pretend like it didn't happen.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes, scientists should never discuss scientific issues like evidence for life in the Universe in public.
No more scientists on TV!
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
The fact you're going on CNN to discuss the subject of a clear psyop disqualifies you as a trusted scientist.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This cover-up must end! Non-Euclidian metrics are real and the establishment doesn't want you to know about them.
Also usually people talk about parallel transport of vectors but vectors are just rank 1 tensors so ha!
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
Why won't the government talk to us about parallel tensor transport? What are they hiding?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to go on NBC News now to discuss … wait for it now … the nuances of parallel tensor transport in General Relativity.
Psyche!
Aliens again. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You mean like a book on the subject or give lots of public lectures? Oh yeah, I did that.
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
Ulterior motives at play that you ignore & contribute to; much better, cleaner ways to engage the public. Of all the things a scientist can do...
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes, scientists should never discuss scientific issues like evidence for life in the Universe in public.
No more scientists on TV!
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
The fact you're going on CNN to discuss the subject of a clear psyop disqualifies you as a trusted scientist.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
While I am doing a lot today around the UAP data dump (so disappointing), the paper @kenarchersf just put out is what I'm really excited about.
Anyone interested in the question of AI and sentience should read it.
Ken Archer
@kenarchersf
1/6 I’m excited to share a new paper: “The Origins of Artificial Intelligence in Natural Intelligence” www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/the-origins-… A persistent puzzle: Why do AI systems exhibit fluency & coherence- yet struggle with reasoning, truth reliability, and object-level intuitive physics?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Right because we spend our lives studying the actual very hard science surrounding the possibilities of life in the Universe.
Don't want any of that messing up your favored biases.
Punk With a Manbun
@bobofango86
Astrophysicists tend to have the worst takes on UFOs.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to do CNN. Aliens!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Seriously... Is this what Disclosure Day looks like?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dwyane "The Rock" Johnson.
Curiosity
@MAstronomers
If aliens requested a meeting with a sole individual to represent the human race, whom should we send?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
that's very funny. 😀
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
What's the shortest definition of Kolmogorov complexity?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude or Dudess, where are you getting these terrible takes on physics and philosophy? They literally showcase the dumbest things physicists (even great ones) have said on this subject. Are you purposely trolling?
Philosophy Of Physics
@PhilosophyOfPhy
"If all of mathematics disappeared, physics would be set back by exactly one week."
- Richard P. Feynman -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That's not what good philosophy is about.
It's often about understanding the FRAME of the question and how that frame shapes even the possibility of answers.
Deivon Drago
@DeivonDrago
Have you considered the possibility that philosophers more often than not go beyond just figuring out the right questions to ask and try to fill the gaps themselves with speculative answers, without any empirical or theoretical justification whatsoever?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes me. The wonderful thing about the whole Pluto thing is, compared to all the other stuff people get worked up about, it doesn't really matter
EXCEPT it gets us thinking about solar systems and that matters.
I am perfectly happy if Pluto becomes a planet again.
Captain Toddler
@andy_not_today
You? 😮😁
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is why physicists need to talk to philosophers. How can you tell if the question, or the way your asking it, even makes sense?
Physics In History
@PhysInHistory
If the universe began with the Big Bang, what existed before it? And if the answer is "nothing" - can nothing even exist? ✍️
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is awesome
Captain Toddler
@andy_not_today
Thank you so much! 🫡
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So excited to be giving a talk about human experience and science's Blind Spot at @HTLGIFestival
You are not a meat computer! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh lighten up Bro. I was kidding. The whole point is this is an argument that doesn't really matter except one way or the other we get to think about cool science.
Jack Mitch Culberson
@JackMtCulberson
I just read the article, and I just cringed at some of the remarks because they are very negative in tone, especially about "people whining about Pluto". Also, there are basic, important facts that are missing from the article. And after all, it's just ad hominem.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/04/28/quit-whining-pl…
SPACE.com
@SPACEdotcom
NASA chief Jared Isaacman says he's fighting for Pluto: 'I am very much in the camp of 'make Pluto a planet again' www.space.com/astronomy/pluto/nasa-chief-jared-isaacman-s…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
After I published my Forbes piece "Quit whining about Pluto" NASA chief Jared Isaacman endorses Pluto's planethood.
OK, Jared it's time for the planetary Octagon!
(PS ♥️this debate cuz it just doesn't matter but does highlight cool science issues)
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/04/28/quit-whining-pl… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Scientist shocks world demanding everyone just shut up about Pluto!
😀
Actually, there's a VERY cool science reason why Pluto was kicked out of the planet club. It's all about the rest of the solar system.
Today's @ForbesTech column
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/04/28/quit-whining-pl… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The real missing scientist problem
www.scientificamerican.com/article/entire-nsf-science-adv… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The guy who owns this platform :-)
Amazing Physics
@amazing_physics
What is the biggest threat to Earth?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nice @QuantaMagazine article on AI in math.
www.quantamagazine.org/the-ai-revolution-in-math-has-arri… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So.
Frikkin'.
Cool.
Curiosity
@MAstronomers
This is an actual view of the surface of another planet.
You are looking at a landscape that is 140 million miles away.
The "dust" you see on the ground is actually volcanic rock and toxic perchlorates that would kill a human easily.
This is Mars!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The real "missing scientist" problem is the 10,000 STEM workers fired or hounded out of the government because this administration's relentless attempt to degrade the greatest national scientific effort in history.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Holy crap... an actual scientist? Damn, that's it. I'm not gonna listening to all those other thousands of scientists who've worked for decades and established the foundations of planetary climate. I'm gonna go with this single outlier who no one agrees with.
Thanks so much!
Melinda Richards 🇦🇺🇺🇸
@goodfoodgal
CO2 is good.
Sorry Greta. This is an actual scientist.
Climate change is a grift.
It’s a sham. x.com/redpillb0t/status/2047001553454948439/video/1 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The screen door slammed, Mary's dressed waved...
Mike Bales™ 🫡🇺🇸
@MikeBales
Hello darkness, my old friend…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Freaky Deaky
Amazing Physics
@amazing_physics
What would you name this exoplanet?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
sooooo dumb
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Conspiracists are playing up stories about “missing scientists”—but to even call this a conspiracy theory is far too kind, Daniel Engber argues:
🎨: The Atlantic. Source: Getty -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
One purpose of science is to blow your mind. That's what happened to me when I visited @KalteneggerLisa at @Cornell and learned more about worlds bathed in oceans of magma.
Today on Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/aliens-lava-worlds-and-the-le… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I have heard this for 30+ years
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Q: “Will string theory ever give an observable prediction?”
A: “Not yet. But I hope so!”
- Juan Maldacena -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You look really tasty
Curiosity
@MAstronomers
What would be the scariest message humanity could receive from outer space?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"So, with all the other news, especially the war in the Middle East, why did people care [about the Artemis astronauts]? I think the answer can be summed up in four words: bravery, sacrifice, compassion and hope."
Todays Everyman's Universe post
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/why-artemis-astronauts-risked… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You clearly have the ability to critique what's being presented. As someone who does a lot of scicom work, I can tell you there are boatloads of folks who can't.
It's not their fault. Its Rogan etc.
Alien Bob
@ExoBioFldObs
I’ve been listening to Rogan since maybe his 300 something podcast. Not sure where my science literacy has suddenly gone up in smoke. Would love for someone to point it out.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude I get what you are saying but I'm tired of the endless rounds of bullish*t. Direct link between this and science denial at the highest levels. They're killing NCAR for god's sake! 10,000 STEM PhDs gone from US government.
Maybe it's time to get a little pissed off.
Alien Bob
@ExoBioFldObs
Cutting down others doesn’t help you and it doesn’t help science.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Why I wrote that NY Times manosphere OpEd. Wish Rogan etc understood the responsibility they shoulder for their audiences who're genuinely interested in science.
Feeding them click-bait bullcrap might get the "likes" up but damage to US science (and all science) is real.
𝕄𝕦𝕟𝕘𝕦𝕚
@mungui_zero
I think it has a lot to do with Joe Rogan. Mix the wrong audience with the wrong voice and you get a gigantic cultural turd sandwich. It’s kind of a bummer because it’s thanks to Rogan that I got to know you and your work.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
His public personality is a bloviating self-important turd blossom which is all that matters for sci-comms.
Mike
@Boston__Sucks
Eric seems like a good dude(and those who know him personally have said as much) but the Weinsteins are egomaniacs who think quite highly of themselves and the online following they've gotten has ratcheted that up 100 fold.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Exactly my point.
One.
Stinking.
Paper.
That leaves him as an authority on exactly nothing.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Completely corrosive. The thing is, as far as I can tell, the guy has 1 scientific publication. You can't speak as an authority critiquing so much of science if you've never done much science
(Sorry, but getting a PhD 30 years ago and never doing physics again don't cut it).
Deivon Drago
@DeivonDrago
He, enabled by a few social media "influencers", has racked up decent sized followings among the general public, who then spread his spiel elsewhere. So he has had a corrosive effect on science communication.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Why the hell should any of us have to care what Eric Weinstein thinks about anything?
The dude has done nothing other than run a hedge fund. And I say this as someone who generally agrees with critiques of String Theory etc.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
This made me want to gouge my frontal lobes out with a spoon.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Most def!
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Project Hail Mary is more scientifically plausible than Interstellar
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The outpouring of interest in Artemis II is something worth considering. Today in my @Forbes column, I look at one aspect of its promise. The space economy is already in past 500 billion.
Space is not just about exploration.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/04/14/artemis-ii-was-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is a really important point.
What has gone so wrong with so many men that they get seduced by this bullsh#t? Especially young men... It's why I wrote this piece last fall.
nytimes.com/2025/10/03/opinion/manosphere-science-young-m…
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
We need to address the gender gap in the crackpot community.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just another small step on the way to 10 mile long rotating asteroid space cities.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes!!!!!!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to do CNN again . Artemis II doing amazing things.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We don't fly through space, we surf it. The video from my conversation this morning with Sara Sidner on
@cnn.com -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hopefully the @UofR will post it. That was fun though. Got to talk for a moment about celestial mechanics!
SPACELY
@blury___face
Oh man I just looked up at CNN and caught the last 5 Seconds of you talking. Do you suppose you could repost that?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just got had a lovely discussion with Sara Sidner on @CNN about the successful Translunar Injection Burn and the amazing math behind it all.
Go science! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Going on The Beat with Ari Melber on @MSNOWNews in just a bit to talk about... Artemis II!
This is a moment that will be remembered long after everyone watching is long, long gone.
Going back to the Moon, this time to stay.
@TheBeatWithAri -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to be on CNN to discuss the Artemis II launch!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am deeply honored to be giving the Edwin Salpeter Lecture at Cornell next week. Salpeter was truly one of the great astronomers of the 20th century and, of course, Cornell was the home of Carl Sagan.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Recently I wrote a post called "is it time for scientist to stop being polite?" Focus was on certain kind of person proudly publicly proclaiming science ignorance as if it were a virtue.
See my feed right now for example of what I meant.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/is-it-time-for-scientists-to-…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) It's all the usual horsepoop.
"It was Global Cooling in 70's"
"All the models give the wrong answer"
"You should listen to 'insert-one-of 5-possible-contrarian-climate-scientists'. They told the truth."
And then some weird fixation with Al Gore and his 20 year old movie.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) All of it debunked 10,000 times. But it doesn't matter because these folks are interested in, or curious about, the actual science (which is a bummer becuase the science is so cool).
It's all tribalism. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Isn't it too early in the season for this...
nationaltoday.com/us/ny/new-york/news/2026/03/30/mets-fac… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Speaking of Dunning-Kruger effect, whole lot of that happening in my feed today. Do climate denialists know that nobody working in science cares what Al Gore said 20 years ago.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh no, you're applying actual physics calculations to the problem. Don't do that. It will spoil the Dunning-Kruger effect.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
A homework problem I give when I teach Classical Mechanics is to calculate the reaction mass necessary to accelerate 1 kilogram to 0.1c, assuming a rocket ten times as efficient as current chemical rockets.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This looks really cool. Adding it to my Zotero.
Anna Ciaunica PhD @annaciaunica.bsky.social
@AnnaCiaunica
We have argued something similar here : arxiv.org/abs/2601.21016
@erikjbekkers -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) "Human beings are going back to the moon one way or the other. More importantly, that’s just a first step towards something much grander and more important."
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/03/30/historys-on-the…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) "If we manage to make it through the next few decades intact (climate change etc), then the whole solar system will open up. It’s that theater that’s destined to become the real theater where the drama of human civilization plays out."
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
With this week's Artemis II mission we stand on the brink of returning to solar system for good and becoming a true space-faring species.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/03/30/historys-on-the… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Just starting "The Abstraction Fallacy: Why AI Can Simulate But Not Instantiate Consciousness" by @AlexLerchner
This is, so far, a deeply insightful paper about mistaking computation for consciousness.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) "Such semantic partitioning logically requires an active, experiencing cognitive agent, which we define as a mapmaker, to contrast it with the passive connotation of a standard ’observer’."
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) This nails the Blind Spot of hard computationalism.
"the claim that algorithmic complexity generates consciousness commits an ontological inversion: it mistakes the syntax for the territory of intrinsic dynamics, and assumes that the mapmaker can be created from the map." -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yeah, I go to talks and the aim of the speaker is "we want to go beyond the standard model". By the end of the talk it's always "the standard models wins again".
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
I never know how to react to this.
On the one hand, it's so amazing that we can't break it, so you're a victim or your own success.
On the other hand, we know it's incomplete and want even more exciting things to study! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is so true.
Michael H. Tomasson, MD
@MTomasson
Curse you Standard Model!!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It’s amazing how resilient the SM is. Just. Won’t. Let. Go.
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
We have found out loads of important stuff.
We just haven’t shattered the SM as we hoped we would.
Why?
Because - as you said - nature hasn’t let us and the model is so darn good that we’re victims of our own previous successes. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Because I am genuinely interested I often ask condensed matter physicists exactly this question. "Are you using fruits of string theory in your work". I almost always get blank stares.
Sidd⏸️
@nolightupstairs
String theory is probably the field of theoretical physics for which this is the least true. There is not a single condensed matter theorist who hasn't had a brush with the outputs of holographic or string methods. Idiotic uninformed take.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
oh dang. We had reached an accord and then I send another tweet :-)
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
Agreed.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh c'mon. JWST found amazing new things about cosmology via galaxy formation the moment it turned on. It's nailed atmospheric characterization of exoplanets. I could go on.
That comparison doesn't to LHC any favors & I think the LHC has done good solid work within SM physics
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
Is astronomy or astrophys “stagnant” because JWST hasn’t radically overturned or added to lambdaCDM?
Again, this may be more semantics, but not getting all you want from nature at a particularly energy scale, but getting a unique new constituent to study isn’t stagnation imo. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) I happy to step back on the use of "stagnation". But I don't think I'm going out on a limb by saying the incredibly high hopes from scientists (and public expectations) about BSM etc via LHC opened have not been realized.
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
I’m sorry, but the goalposts have shifted here.
You claimed HE is “stagnant”.
I have noted that essentially *all* HE physicists are behind the building of a Higgs Factory.
It is undeniable we didn’t find everything we hoped at the LHC, but the field is not “stagnant”. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Follow the new faculty positions. Lots of departments adding lots of positions in exoplanets, quantum information theory, condensed matter etc. I don't hear colleagues in other fields in other departments demanding "Get me more String Theorists!"
big brane boi
@bcubeddd
It's hard to find physicists - other than those still working in/around AstroPhysics - who are still excited about AstroPhysics. It simply is not talked about much outside the narrow specialization.
It's kind of mind boggling that this kind of hype continues.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's hard to find physicists - other than those still working in/around String Theory - who are still excited about String Theory. It simply is not talked about much outside the narrow specialization.
It's kind of mind boggling that this kind of hype continues.
Joseph Conlon
@JosephPConlon
People are thinking — for the first time in decades — about whether string theory describes the world. Apparently. Really? Quanta needs to get out of its bubble and talk to more people.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Just to bring this conversation back to where it started. The claim was "Physics has stalled". That's what I am disputing. End of Story.
Still, hard to argue that Quantum Gravity / other Beyond Standard Model (BSM) work has not come close to hope-for progress.
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
Sure, they didn’t find a lot of the things they hoped. No one can deny that.
That doesn’t equate to “stagnation” and - at a time when budgets are being slashed - I don’t think we should use such rhetoric.
China, Europe and the US are all behind building of a Higgs factory.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) Higgs Factory sounds cool. Lots of interesting work to do extending understanding of that Standard Model particle (maybe glimpses BSM). That is different from the decades of hope/expectations/projections about Supersymmetry. That's what I am saying.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's hard to find physicists - other than those still working in/around String Theory - who are still excited about String Theory. It simply is not talked about much outside the narrow specialization.
It's kind of mind boggling that this kind of hype continues.
Joseph Conlon
@JosephPConlon
People are thinking — for the first time in decades — about whether string theory describes the world. Apparently. Really? Quanta needs to get out of its bubble and talk to more people.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes, Higgs still super interesting and LHC continues to probe its nature. But you have to admit that the LHC has not found anything else mind-blowing as was hoped and promised (other than negative result a'la supersymmetry).
No one's fault. It's just how nature worked out.
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
I take issue with the idea that high energy physics has "stagnated" when we only just found the Higgs Boson - the most important SM particle - and still know very little about it.
It is linked to so many open questions and building a Higgs factory is obviously well motivated. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes, it's exactly the lack of data where you need it (perhaps even much higher energies) is why the field has stalled. Theory alone is sterile. I say this as a theorist.
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
I take the points that:
a) String theory hasn't broken quantum gravity as we might have liked and
b) Building machines to reach higher energies is becoming harder, more expensive and more taxing geographically.
However, some problems being hard isn't "stagnation". -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sorry so long to come back to this but... What do you mean exactly by "progress". Fields I've been in (i.e. exoplanets) = wonderful progress. If you're asking for massive paradigm shifts that's something different.
They are spectacularly rare. Maybe 2 or 3 per century.
george elliot
@GeorgeE33179
"its getting hard and harder to produce oil". Both can be true. There are many important similarities between ideas and oil. Both are depletable. Both have increasing marginal costs. However crucial distinction is oil is finite (at least on earth) while ideas are infinite.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Hubble Tension won't relax.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
The most important thing I learned at Moriond today was that ACT and SPT can now constrain the Hubble constant INDEPENDENT of Planck, to similar uncertainty, and they agree with Planck (low H0), and disagree with supernovae at more than 5 sigma. This is important because it for all practical purposes rules out an undetected systematic in the Planck data as an explanation for the Hubble tension. This is BIG, but it was a throwaway line on one slide.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The world is, without doubt, on fire. We all need to respond. But after you have done what you can, then what?
“You’re not helping the future by being freaked out 99.9 percent of the time.”
Today in Everyman's Universe @Revkin
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-you-can-do-in-a-world-on… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But it's got nothing to with climate change. Nope, nothing to see here folks.
Let's just keep dismantling NCAR and other premier atmospheric physics centers because we aren't gonna need those silly institutions of excellence anymore.
www.sciencealert.com/gigantic-heat-dome-baking-the-whole-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Brilliant piece by Harald A. Wiltsche about the critical role phenomenology should play in philosophy and physics. Another great article at @IAI_TV
iai.tv/articles/consciousness-is-the-hidden-architecture-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I don't think so. It simply means, in this one domain, the ability to get new data far outstrips our technological capacity. This is old news in science.
Stellar astrophysics left the forefront for quite a while because there wasn't anything new that could be done.
george elliot
@GeorgeE33179
Even if rate of progress in fundamental physics has not decreased this is *still* signs of diminishing returns or declining resource productivity of research since we have many orders of magnitude more researchers and many orders of magnitude greater technical capabilities.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The list of major advances in physics is long. The list of stagnating domains is short.
RePopulus🇬🇷
@PopulusRe
Also in Condensed Matters, Statistical mechanics, etc, etc
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Why Post-Standard Model/Quantum Gravity physics stalled is interesting. You gave good sociological/practice answer in Lost In Math. Community got lost in abstractions (still is).
But, fundamentally, absence of data is basic driver. Nothing to discriminate different ideas.
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
he's entirely right of course. even if you think he is wrong, at the very least physicists should think about why everyone else agrees they've lost the plot.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Other than High Energy, I don't see "physics has stagnated". Yeah, Quantum Gravity didn't work out for a bunch of reasons (mainly no data). But MIND BLOWING progress in Quantum Information Theory, Complexity Theory, Astrobiology etc.
Stagnation narrative is very selective.
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
he's entirely right of course. even if you think he is wrong, at the very least physicists should think about why everyone else agrees they've lost the plot.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Great conversation. It really important for us to begin thinking about climate change in a generational context. We clearly are blowing through 1.5 degrees (major fail) but people aren't going anywhere. So how to live on a changing planet and how to stabilize that change.
Andrew Revkin 🌎 ✍🏼 🪕 ☮️
@Revkin
Live now on the iffy longevity of humanity with @AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The conspiratorial science-denial folks talk about consensus like it’s just a vote taken at latest meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.
Vaccines? Yes!
Climate Change? Yes!
UFOs are Aliens? No!
A'la @CColose's point
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/science-consensus-and-the-big… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Evan Thompson's @IAI_TV piece on the nature of Mind.
Thinking that perception happens inside the brain is like thinking that flying happens inside the bird’s wings or that dancing happens inside the dancer’s nervous and musculoskeletal systems
iai.tv/articles/reality-is-not-a-controlled-hallucination… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Totally amazing story. Definitely shows dumb happens in academic circles too .
Don't think it argues against role of consensus though. If we asked 50 random biology departments "Is biology related to human beings" I doubt you get that person's answer too often.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
Let me tell you a story.
A few years ago, my university entirely re-organized our General Education science program. I was on the committee charged with setting standards for the curriculum. One of the goals was to get across the idea that science applies across scales. The draft document put this as "from the microscopic, to the organismal, to the cosmic." Thinking this was an easy fix, I brought up that "organismal" was a piece of opaque jargon, when what we really meant is that science applies at *human* scale; in fact, this is an important point for a GenEd curriculum, that science applies to humans. It's relevant to YOU.
I thought this would be uncontroversial, but it unleashed a hornets' nest. The professor from the Department of Biology on the committee insisted that we could not say this. She explained in no uncertain terms that nothing studied in the BIOLOGY DEPARTMENT could be construed in any way to apply to human beings, and that no official document could imply that it does. She was absolutely adamant about this point — it was foundational to her.
This is of course insane. But I lost the argument. She absolutely would not compromise. I quit the committee.
The point of this story is that it's fine to oppose science denial, but if you do so selectively, and only when the science denial is coming from people that you politically oppose rather than your friends in the academy, it deeply undermines the credibility of your argument. It's not a distraction. It's a central issue.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
No but this is a useless distraction from the purposeful dismantling of American Science for political ends made possible via of the distortion and weaponization of public discussion of science occurring on these platforms and elsewhere.
Do you care what happened to NCAR? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Scientists know the consensus because they live it. They read hundreds of papers, attend hundreds of meetings, talk with hundreds of colleagues.
So, yes, consensus itself isn’t science. It’s the result of science.
Today's Everyman's Universe post.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/science-consensus-and-the-big… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
If so, please excuse me. I guess I'm trying to pinpoint how we got to the point we're at now (mainstreaming fake moon landing etc). It was not a failure of science communications and explaining the physics of climate change.
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
you seem to have totally misunderstood my post
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I 💕 small reactors. One path forward for sure.
John K
@JohnKir08660882
Actions speak louder than words; specifically the worries of The Atlantic and New York Times about 'climate denial'.
Seriously, a river of words about Global Warming here while at the same time Communist China, India and Africa were all building coal fired power plants on a massive scale. Over the last ten years they've burned ten times as much coal and that ratio is increasing, a lot.
So your worries about 'organized climate denial' appear to be Sophistry. Because we did NOT see articles condemning those Nations for Global Warming.
And for bonus points: I'm looking forward to SMR (Small Modular Reactors) replacing our coal fired plants and The Atlantic and New York Times resisting this progress. I guess then SMR supporters will be called 'organized nuclear denial'.
The 'consensus' seems to be condemn this nation for emotional & political reasons. Thus our rejection of the 'consensus'. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is what amazed us working in science comms back then: You could explain for hours; You could answer every question.
It didn't matter because it was about something else.
Unravel that & we'll understand what happens on this platform, Rogan+ and state of US science.
Chris Colose
@CColose
4/ one can also find a lot of educational material on black holes or the like, but you cannot get the same context at each level between “basic” and “new paper alert” as in climate. Communication and access to info were never issues. Never.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I wrote lots of pop articles on climate change so I can say this was not so.
After many hours in NPR comments section trying to do just that (explain) it dawned on me..
Bunch of folks just not interested in the science. They're here for other reasons. That's the dilemma.
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
Pretty much no popular science coverage on climate change actually explains the evidence other than merely stating that it exists. Also, it's obvious that media outlets both left and right cherry pick whatever 'evidence' they think supports their pov
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Around the beginning of the 2010’s, however, I noticed something changing for those of us trying to bring science and its results to the public."
Some history & thinking about how we got here and what to do about it. This week's Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/is-it-time-for-scientists-to-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
As someone in sci-comms for 30 years - 30 frikking years - patiently presenting the overwhelming scientific evidence for climate change I can tell you that didn't work.
Explain to me why.
If you say evidence wasn't there, your peddling scientific misinformation.
So... why?
Sandro Magi
@naasking
If you're appealing to scientific consensus, you're peddling scientific misinformation. A solid evidentiary basis can lead to consensus, but consensus is not evidence of a solid evidentiary basis. The focus should always be on the evidence, no exceptions.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
No but this is a useless distraction from the purposeful dismantling of American Science for political ends made possible via of the distortion and weaponization of public discussion of science occurring on these platforms and elsewhere.
Do you care what happened to NCAR? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just a reminder that social media is not your real life and is, I believe, demonstrably bad for your mental health.
Contemplative practice, then the gym and then play Arc Raiders.
PS. Where can I find the blueprint for the Seeker Grenade? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes. Good science podcasts enlighten
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
And science podcasts…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Exactly. This is the point being made. Nothing more or less. We are NOT talking about the history/philosophy of science. It’s about the very modern distortion (via social media, podcasts) of commicating the state of critical scientific fields like planetary climate dynamics
Chris Colose
@CColose
It’s not meant as a self-contained argument, just shorthand for, “you don’t know more than the scientific community.” Even if the community is wrong. You didn’t Joe Rogan yourself to some magic, secret insight no one thought of. So uninformed priors should align with mainstream.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
huge huge huge importance.
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
"In 2024, 92.5% of all new power capacity installed around the world was renewable. In 2025, it’s believed that installations were even greater. And even in Trump’s U.S., more than 92 percent of new capacity planned for 2026 is green." www.nytimes.com/2026/02/25/opinion/clean-green-energy.html
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
These distinctions are useful for philosophy/history of science. But as practicing scientist/"science communicator" I watched dismissal of consensus get weaponized back in 2010s by forces of organized climate denial. Now it's used everywhere.
That's what we are talking about.
Shekhinah 🕰️🌌🛸🪽
@cosmicfibretion
No. It's a community state that is not always correct. The Caloric theory of heat, Phlogiston, and the Luminiferous aether are historical examples. Consensus can (and does) form with poor data and theory. There can also be good evidence without consensus.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I ❤️ Yogi Bera (also a manager of the beloved yet heart-breaking Mets).
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I hope it's helpful.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'm hardly belittling "the public". I am pushing back hard on those few willing make loud public statements about science while being unwilling to do the work to understand how it works.
Why? Because it's having a serious detrimental effect on American Science.
JAMTAM
@WHPAAD
Maybe adopting a condescending tone online, belittling the very public you’re meant to serve while collecting a public salary from your couch, isn’t the strongest strategy for building trust.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nailed it. Consensus = "shorthand argument for those untrained".
So if not trained in science you can't know. Not your fault. I'm untrained in most stuff. I just don't shoot my mouth off with proclamations of ignorance about it.
Grandpa taught me better than that.
Chris Colose
@CColose
They’ve set up a mental image of an auditorium full of people raising the hands up and down at various claims, taking votes on truth, rather than consensus an emergent property. It’s a result, not a method or argument. But it is a good shorthand argument for those untrained.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) @CColose @AstroKatie @WKCosmo
Yes. This idea that consensus isn't science is so profoundly stupid.
It is for scientists! it's how we, as a community, decide what's understood and what is not.
And science is always about communities of scientists.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) The conspiracy theories, the loud proclamations of ignorance... they have real world consequences we can seeing playing out as our nation tilts towards losing the excellence in science that was the envy of the world.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) Pushing back against that slide is the only reason I'm still on this platform.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is soooooooooo true. And exciting.
Ash Jogalekar
@curiouswavefn
I continue to believe that the nexus between neuroscience, thermodynamics and computation will be the most exciting one of the 21st century, informing multiple fields.
3quarksdaily.com/3quarksdaily/2020/07/brains-computation-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Not that you care about the actual science but here is the original Hansen et al 1981 paper with actual temperature data plotted on it up till 2014.
Hmmm... where do you think the data from from 2014 to now would fall.
Prediction. Validation. Soooooo simple.
Albert O'Nyme
@AlbertNyme44777
He lost me at "all James Hanson's predictions came true" without even blinking. And Ricard Lindzen, aka the "guy from MIT", would destroy him in 2 nano seconds in a debate on the actual science. Not to mention Judith Curry, John Christy, Will Happer, etc. etc.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) Also you folks trot out same handful of climate scientists over and over again ignoring the literal army of climate researchers who know those folks lost the thread years ago.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) Here's a simple "is basic climate science settled" test anyone can do.
1) Call any top 100 hundred atmospheric science departments.
2) Ask if anthropogenic climate forcing is part of curriculum.
3) Repeat as often as you want until you stop proudly proclaiming dumb stuff. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For Managed Democracy!!!
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
Looks like fun, I'll have to try it. But the battle for Liberty and Freedom continues.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Don’t get me wrong, I loved Helldivers II. But now I’m a raider.
Erock
@EZE970
Nah I don't think so!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude. It’s Arc Raiders now.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
And Helldivers shall answer.
-
Adam Frank reposted
Clear+Vivid
@alda
Listen and subscribe to Clear+Vivid with @AlanAlda.
Adam Frank: Are there aliens out there? Probably. But UFOs – not so much (@AdamFrank4)
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/adam-frank-are-there-aliens… -
Adam Frank reposted
Clear+Vivid
@alda
It's PODCAST DAY!
@AlanAlda speaks with Adam Frank (@AdamFrank4)
It’s highly likely that life – maybe even intelligent life – has evolved elsewhere in the universe. But that aliens bother to hang out in our skies, or are even able to get here...Really?
👉 podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/adam-frank-are-there-aliens… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That would be a psi-epistemic view which I am inclined towards. But every interpretation of the formalism comes at huge cost the naive realism of classical physics (which I am not inclined to).
Elliott Not-So-Sober
@Leophilius
A superposition doesn't really represent anything “physical” on my view.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Superposition (and entanglement and measurement) are, for me, the true weirdnesses of quantum mechanics.
Knowing how to manipulate the formalism doesn't imply we know what 'QM means" at this deeper level.
Màxkw’tët (Bear) 🐻 🪶
@MaxkwTet
Not saying this is conclusive, but it is a working hypothesis so far… 🤷🏽♂️
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I had a lovely conversation with the great Alan Alda (@alanalda) about life in the Universe. What a joy!
Find his Clear + Vivid podcast on your favorite podcast delivery system. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What, physically, does a superposition represent?
Elliott Not-So-Sober
@Leophilius
Except for all the physicists who have done undergraduate and graduate level quantum mechanics.
This is the most ridiculous and misunderstood quote from anyvody on quantum mechanics ever. And it's not true. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Preach brother!
SPACELY
@blury___face
It was an exciting first step. Soon we'll learn to walk among the stars.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Because I am a proud American who believes in the power and purpose of American science. It's what we'll be remembered for 1000 years from now.
Axel Fury
@GetSocialFamous
Why is it that everyone who “grew up in the space age” like this guy always defend the moon landing like it’s a personal attack on them?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Well this is bull crap. Very respectable news source.. sure.
How about you Google "Top Atmospheric Science journals" and invest the time to see what their articles say about climate change.
That's if you actually care about what the science says.
● ■ ■
@reddpill003
Well this is awkward....
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Speaking of not doing research, any DA will say personal testimony = weakest form of evidence. Useless in science. Imagine building transistor based on personal reporting.
Danielle Langlois
@DanielleLangWa
Let’s be frank, Mr. Frank: You either haven’t done enough research or you have chosen to selectively omit any mention of the Congressional testimonies of some of our most highly trained fighter pilots, esteemed highly ranked members of our military like Commander David Fravor, who have been eyewitnesses to these craft at extremely close range. That’s a glaring, egregious error in any journalistic piece that claims to be offering the public a rational overview of the situation.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) It's good pilots can report without negative consequences. They are honest in their reporting but research shows often a big gap between what's reported (memory) and objective facts. It's just human nature.
By the way I'm totally in favor of open scientific study of UAPs. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Also... this.
www.sciencealert.com/oldest-fossilized-butthole-found-in-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am sure that's true but we probably mean very different things by the statement. But I am willing to be proven wrong (would be happy to be wrong).
How about you?
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
You are the 394th skeptic to say that over the last 79 years. The result will be the same.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Interested to see this but there was no Vitalism in Jonas' ideas.
Nathaniel
@nattydaddy98
you should check out @KentsisResearch substack and forthcoming book … he sketches out a better proposal that unifies stat mech and evolution leading to a dynamic but anti vitalist research program
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"That is what disclosure needs to deliver. Not stories... but physical evidence that independent laboratories and independent scientists all over the world can verify. Only then will it live up to its hype."
Today's Forbes Column.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/02/23/what-we-could-l… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Life is Different". Science needs a new vision of nature when it comes to living systems and philosopher Hans Jonas was the first to articulate the contours of that new perspective.
Also "K-Pop Demon Hunters" is great.
bigthink.com/13-8/nature-of-life-hans-jonas/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The theory of evolution had been proven in laboratory experiments .
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What theories are you taking about? We demand proof for all of our theories. The more radical the theory the more stringent the demand.
quantum theory
relativity theory
Electromagnetic theory
The theory of evolution
Complexity theory -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
On Trump / Alien Files. I'm ALL for disclosure. If it leads to quality verifiable data like every other scientific discovery required then...holy crap!
But, if it's more of what we've seen in congressional testimony so far, we'll still be arguing 'bout this in 10 years. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
No mention of Complexity Science or Life? This is a 20th century list.
Philosophy Of Physics
@PhilosophyOfPhy
The biggest problems in physics that are still open in 2026.
1. Quantum gravity
2. Nature of dark matter
3. Nature & origin of dark energy
4. Baryon asymmetry / matter–antimatter asymmetry
5. Strong CP problem
6. Neutrino masses & hierarchy & absolute scale
7. Quantum measurement problem / interpretation of quantum mechanics
8. High-temperature / room-temperature superconductivity mechanism
9. Black hole information paradox. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Only life knows Life". My @bigthink piece on Hans Jonas the most important philosopher you've never heard of.
Jonas saw why life is different and why reductionist models of it are bound to fail.
A physics of life must go further.
bigthink.com/13-8/nature-of-life-hans-jonas/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am all for disclosure.
David S. Burstein, MD MS
@DavidBursteinMD
Hi Adam. Thanks for writing this. I mostly agree with its contents.
As you are a science communicator, though, I challenge you to avoid stigmatizing language on Disclosure efforts (as opposed to scientific Discovery). It’s ostracizing and unnecessary.
Thanks for your coverage! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What actually happened with the Obama / Alien kerfuffle and what it tells us about the search for cosmic life.
My @Forbes post this week.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/02/16/did-obama-just-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I agree. The Born rule is about measurement and, unless we want to play philosophical word games, measurers (i.e. us in a lab) make measurements. Not photons. Not electrons. QM is screaming at us that agents and their agency are always part of the story (for all science).
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
A photon doesn’t know anything. This kind of language is responsible for 99% of the confusion about quantum mechanics
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“AI is more extractive than artificial: it’s dependent on cheap workers, cheap materials, and stolen information.”
Luke Kemp
look under the hood and you’ll see epic scale human exploitation to make these systems. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
WTF??? Physics not equal to Quantum Gravity. Field as a whole is doing just fine. Quantum Information Theory, Exoplanets, Complexity Theory. Differ eras have of physics of different foci. The era of particle emphasis is over because we can't get more data. Move on.
Camus
@newstart_2024
Jimmy Carr echoing Peter Thiel with a line that lands hard:
“Minus the screens from any room, we’re still living in the 1970s. Nothing’s happened in physics since 1972. String theory has not got us anywhere.”
But the real shift?
“Take the compute power of AI and point it at physics… everything else in science is stamp collecting. Physics is the real thing.
That gave us every bit of technology we have. What happens when you point AI at that?”
He sees two roads ahead:
a world of plenty with 50× productivity and human flourishing…
or something that goes “another way.”
If AI finally cracks physics in the next decade — what single breakthrough do you hope comes first: limitless energy, gravity control, new materials… or something we haven’t even named yet? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Right and after all that you still don't have anything you can send to the 100 top physics labs across the world to prove your point.
I'm all for it if you do have it by the way. That would be supercool. But until then it's same old same old.
Anomalous_User²🗽🛸
@Bot1397642
We've had 3 Congressional hearings, 40+ whistle-blowers, and actual bipartisan disclosure legislation, all within the last 3 years.
It doesn't take a PhD to figure this out.
The evidence has been overwhelming for years.
You just sound massively disingenuous, again...This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So then where's my check Bro?
Where is my damn money for all this work I'm supposedly to doing for big anti-UFO conspiracy.
Show me da money!
Anomalous_User²🗽🛸
@Bot1397642
His handler from the National Security state apparatus texted him to tweet this lmao
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Actually here is the deal... bring something better than crappy data or personal testimony (especially from x-gov officials who know somebody who knows somebody who saw something) then science will respond. That's what's happening with VASCO stuff. Its being taken seriously.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nope.
Brian Cory Dobbs
@BrianCoryDobbs
"Nope?" Care to elaborate?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nope.
Brian Cory Dobbs
@BrianCoryDobbs
"Nope?" Care to elaborate?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Duane "The Rock" Johnson
Curiosity
@MAstronomers
If aliens visit us, who should be in charge of speaking on behalf of humanity?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I remain simultaneously impressed by generative AI for certain tasks and unimpressed by the arguments that it's going to replace human agency.
Tom Froese, Embodied Cognitive Science Unit (ECSU)
@DrTomFroese
“As we increasingly outsource facets of the scientific process to our technological creations, we must remember the value that we bring to science as people.”
Fully agreed with @ConorFeehly - it’s time to properly configure the human-machine relation.
www.noemamag.com/why-human-intuition-is-still-sciences-gr… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
nope
Anomalous_User²🗽🛸
@Bot1397642
I know right, it's like there's an entire new paradigm that's being suppressed by an Inquisition 😆😬
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Science shows you how to change your mind. That's its superpower as a new paper on Gaia Theory recently showed me.
"Without shame and without rancor, science gives you a path to update your beliefs about the world."
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/science-shows-how-to-change-y… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Really interesting overlap between Art and Science here in the back and forth on Starry Night and Turbulence.
This weeks post on my Forbes column.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/02/05/did-van-goghs-s… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Has the AI market meltdown begun? Circular financing was just one aspect of the dangerous hype.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"We love to talk about Nature and its harmony and balance. But the Universe does have this other aspect embodied in volcanoes, exploding stars, and of course the Big Bang itself."
This weeks Everyman's Universe post
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/the-universe-loves-blowing-th… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I like the idea of "Earthyness".
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"The secret fear of the morally depraved is that virtue is actually common, and that they’re the ones who are alone."
@AdamSerwer -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am really looking forward to this :-)
Alasdair Craig
@AlasdairGCraig
I'll be interviewing Michael Levin (@drmichaellevin) on Mon 2 Feb, live at 17.20GMT, followed by a live debate w/ Mike, Lisa Feldman Barrett (@LFeldmanBarrett) & Adam Frank (@AdamFrank4), & a talk by Christof Koch. There'll be audience Q&A. Sign up: iai.tv/live/science-beyond-the-physical
-
Adam Frank reposted
Alasdair Craig
@AlasdairGCraig
I'll be interviewing Michael Levin (@drmichaellevin) on Mon 2 Feb, live at 17.20GMT, followed by a live debate w/ Mike, Lisa Feldman Barrett (@LFeldmanBarrett) & Adam Frank (@AdamFrank4), & a talk by Christof Koch. There'll be audience Q&A. Sign up: iai.tv/live/science-beyond-the-physical
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is such an excellent piece. I also spend a week of deep contemplative practice in same "Cave" @michaelpollan was in. It was transformative.
Also Roshi Joan Halifax is da Boss!
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
.@michaelpollan traveled to a remote cave in New Mexico to try to understand consciousness. What he learned about “untying the knot of self”: www.theatlantic.com/science/2026/01/consciousness-journey…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Will Kinney @WKCosmo is very funny.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
This is really giving reviewers too much credit.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @forbes.com piece on the approaching Winter Superstorm and what it should remind us about the Earth.
We don't need to save it, we need to be scared sh&tless of it.
www.forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2026/01/24/the-winter-supe… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Speaking of @IAI_TV I am excited to be part of their HOW THE LIGHT GETS IN festival this May in Hay England. @HTLGIFestival
I love that it's billed as THE WORLD'S LARGEST PHILOSOPHY & MUSIC FESTIVAL.
howthelightgetsin.org/festivals/hay -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very excited to be part of this Feb 2 debate via Institute of Art and Ideas @IAI_TV with Micheal Levin
Science Beyond the Physical: Is materialism holding science back?
iai.tv/live/science-beyond-the-physical -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wow. Physics stagnated after what? Quantum Information science last week? Complex systems yesterday? Large scale cosmological structure a month ago? I am so sick of this theme just because String Theory failed. Physics is a lot of things other than accelerators.
Martin Bauer
@martinmbauer
Physics has stagnated ever since I stopped paying attention
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
She is one of my favorite people in Congress.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
'"Spreadsheets can contain a part of truth," Ms. Gluesenkamp Perez told me. "But never all of truth."'
That's about recent US politics, in this article, www.nytimes.com/2026/01/12/opinion/marie-gluesenkamp-pere…, but it seems apt as a way to mollify my focus on how data justifies scientific efforts (or does not).+ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yeah, I kinda wrote a whole book about this.
www.amazon.com/Constant-Fire-Adam-Frank/dp/0520265866
barry goldman
@barrygoldman1
science IS a deep spiritual practice: get out of your own way so that you can have deep communion with the universe.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"I want to begin a brief discussion about this question: Can you live a life with a deep spiritual practice that is also committed to the beauty and power of science? Based on my own experience the answer is a resounding yes."
Part 1: Which words?
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/how-to-live-a-spiritual-life-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Plumes of Water from an Icy Moon, Avengers Doomsday and Satellite Dogfights.
Oh and the greatest beat in the history of Hip-Hop because... why not?
This weeks News Round-up from Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/plumes-of-water-from-an-icy-m… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"OpenAI announced that users will soon be able to upload their medical data into its bot ChatGPT for more personal health recommendations"
What could possibly go wrong? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
A wee discussion of panspermia. Are star systems swapping spit (and life)?
This week's Everyman's Universe post.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/maybe-earth-life-didn-t-start… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Great question! I don't have a pat answer because I believe that is the frontier of research. I believe it will relate to the information architecture of the systems. One will be autopoietic and casually closed and the other will not.
Theodore A Hoppe
@tahoppe05404
If experience is primary and life is inherently sense-making, what principled criteria remain for distinguishing systems that merely model experience from those that genuinely participate in it?
@AdamFrank4 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Well, it ain't gonna happen in 140 characters (or whatever this besotted platform allows :-)
Check this out for a deeper dive (or our book The Blind Spot).
www.noemamag.com/why-science-hasnt-solved-consciousness-yet/
Alien Bob
@ExoBioFldObs
How would an individual fix the statement?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That is a very 3rd person view which is exactly what we were arguing against in The Blind Spot. The approach we are exploring doesn't default to an experience-less perspective but asks how to embed science with the "Life-world", not the other away around.
Contradictosaurus
@chilizcanada
Replace "sentience" with consciousness & concede to an eternal Universe that never began. Consciousness is substrate independent process all systems necessarily engage in.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Whoa!
The Everyman's Universe newsletter went from 0 to 4000 subscribers this year. Thanks everyone. Here's what to expect in 2026.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-s-coming-in-2026 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nope. It's more philosopher Hans Jonas kind of fundemental. And Robert Rosen and Maturana & Varela fundamental. Oh and Husserl and phenomenology "First Philosophy" fundamental.
D K
@DamarisKroeber
“Fundamental” as in panpsychism-style fundamental?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sentience is fundamental. Its origin is the Big Bang we should really be paying attention to.
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
Biology is cognition the whole way down.
Its the most fascinating idea I learned in 2025.
But what does it actually mean?
I compiled the most Giant moments from GS 2025 from @drmichaellevin, @AnnaCiaunica & many more exploring the most radical fringes of cognitive biology⬇️ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My first post for @Forbes
Anti-predictions for 2026. Stuff people say will happen that ain't gonna happen: UFOs as Aliens; AGI; 3I/Atlas
forbes.com/sites/adamfrank/2025/12/30/4-predictions-that-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh quit whining bro, I only had 1200 words to tackle this big beautiful idea. You want a deeper dive then read my @NoemaMag piece.
www.noemamag.com/why-science-hasnt-solved-consciousness-yet/
Or better yet, read our book "The Blind Spot. Why Science Cannot Ignore Human Experience"
lareviewofbooks.org/article/what-scientists-cant-see-on-a…
Harhar Var
@7var6
Big overpromise and underdelivery from this @TheAtlantic @AdamFrank4 headline making the rounds. No mention of Ilya Prigogine solving the problem of how live evolves in contradiction of entropy. No real substance here, just intellectual clickbait. www.theatlantic.com/science/2025/12/physics-life-reductio…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Most excellent point. Our moon is so big we're almost a binary planet.
James of Seattle
@jamessseattle
How many of those planets with continents and oceans also have a large moon, so, tides?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Well... Solar System technosignatures are a domain of the field. We should definitely look. There are cool projects possible (long lived orbits, stuff on the Moon).
But the "Harvard Astronomer says..." stuff has become comical.
SPACELY
@blury___face
No one would certainly throw a techno signature directly at our solar system anyway.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Continents and oceans: we both. But it didn’t have to be this way and on most planets it probably isn’t. That’s important because truly complex life may need dry land to get going.
Today's Everyman's Universe post.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/freaky-earth-does-water-make-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"This correspondence places 3I closer to barely- or non-active 1I/Oumuamua than primitive, ice rich 2I/Borisov, suggesting that ISOs are often highly thermally processed before ejection into the ISM."
Not a friggin technosignature.
arxiv.org/abs/2512.07318 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"The spectral similarities indicate that 3I/ATLAS may be a primitive carbonaceous object, likely enriched in native metal and undergoing significant aqueous alteration during its approach to the Sun."
Not a friggin technosignature.
arxiv.org/abs/2511.19112 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thank you @stevenstrogatz. Coming from you that means a lot!
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
Terrific article by @AdamFrank4 on complex systems, self-organization, and the physics of life. www.theatlantic.com/science/2025/12/physics-life-reductio…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @TheAtlantic piece on the emerging new "Physics of Life". Complexity science, information theory, network theory... a whole new trans-disciplinary way of asking an ancient question.
www.theatlantic.com/science/2025/12/physics-life-reductio… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I think this is the whole point. We built something that uses giant statistical correlations to appear like its thinking or doing stuff we call intelligent. But nothing of the sort is happening. There is no "it" in there doing anything. We are the ones doing something.
Janna Levin
@JannaLevin
This is from our conversation with @ylecun @PioneerWorks_
David Shapiro (L/0)
@DaveShapi
"It's not intelligent, it only seems intelligent"
"It doesn't understand math, it only seems to understand math."
"It doesn't solve problems, it only seems to solve problems."
Bro needs a course on basic philosophy. No True Scotsman is being tortured to death. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This worth doing n Everyman's Universe report/post on. Thanks
SPACELY
@blury___face
@AdamFrank4
Um, holy shit?
dailygalaxy.com/2025/12/supernova-age-bias-hubble-measure… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Blind Spot Podcast was an Instant Hit in 2025 according to @Spotify. Have you been tuning in to our conversations about Life, The Universe and Everything? It's science from a different perspective.
The band = me, Evan Thompson, Marcelo Gleiser. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Raises interesting questions about what makes life different from non-life. You could definitely have done things to it that turned it from "dormant" to "dead".
SPACELY
@blury___face
@AdamFrank4
Long nap :)
dailygalaxy.com/2025/12/ice-age-frozen-worm-revived-after… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
well said!
SPACELY
@blury___face
Anytime there's a tick tock challenge, it's a temporary hive mind.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What is it like to be in a hive mind? Are you a slave to the larger intelligence? Or can you still retain your individuality while being immersed in the warm thoughts of collective?
Today's Everyman's Universe post on #pluribus
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/pluribus-are-hive-minds-more-fun -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am glad you like it.
I think we are raising the question about what can/cannot be mathematized or at least how to it in a principle fashion that doesn't "kill" experience (the main thing you were interested in).
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
I've read the Introduction and Chapter 1 of The Blind Spot. I like it well. I'll read more tomorrow.
I'm not expecting to discover a mathematical treatment later in the book, but —viz my focus on ML and datasets— is there a more mathematical treatment inspired by it elsewhere? + -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That may be the volume I was talking about. I have a collaboration with Wiltsche through the QBism group and he spoke of that work often.
We are currently working on paper exploring how philosophical difficulties associated with QM already present in classical physics.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
Concerning you saying "There has been increasingly interesting work on this including a whole volume done in response to French's book", I hadn't heard of there being such a volume later than French's book, so I'll resurface the request in this reply:
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
John is amazing. He is also an artist with a plasma rifle. He and I game a lot together. He was an excellent squad leader in Helldivers 2.
Alexander Yiannopoulos
@quantabhidharma
John was my dissertation advisor :)
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is why agency is so important (to me). Agents can most definitely be collectives.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
+ many datasets from many experiments as necessary for its existence. We can insist that 'embodiment' is only about people, but it is now routinely extended to corporate bodies. London&Bauer's final §14 leans into such an idea: +
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sadly most of these "popular" discussions don't include Phenomenology at all. It's as if the whole field never existed. Rovelli has recently begun to discuss the importance of Nargarjuna so at least the classical philosophies of India and Asia get a wee bit of love.
Deivon Drago
@DeivonDrago
Yes. I think people like Sean Carroll, David Deutsch, Max Tegmark, Carlo Rovelli etc have gotten a lot of people thinking about what our theories actually mean. We live in good times.
That said.. there still isn’t an outstanding accessible book on foundations, philosophy of modern physics, and the various possibilities (hint hint 🤓) -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sorry to have missed out on these conversations. All interesting stuff @quantabhidharma too.
In our book The Blind Spot, we (Evan Thompson, Marcelo Gleiser and I) tried to chart out a path away from ignoring the centrality of experience. Where that path leads is ongoing work.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
But I think the ideas are enough in the air now that someone will clean up by being first to market with a good textbook that merges the measurement incompatibility and causality aspects of ML, QM, and QFT, making all of them clear. I doubt that will take much more than 5 years.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dharmakīrti! John Dunne introduced me to his work.
Alexander Yiannopoulos
@quantabhidharma
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But I don't see Phenomenology as a foil, but rather the right approach to thinking about experience. The questions is how to effective marry it with science . There has been increasingly interesting work on this including a whole volume done in response to French's book.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
I'm new to following you, so I'll just get out of the way making sure you have seen Steven French's book, "Phenomenological Approach to Quantum Mechanics: Cutting the Chain of Correlations", and earlier articles. You must have, right?
IMO phenomenology is a useful foil. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes, I have been referencing it a lot. I think it was brilliant.
Peter Warwick Morgan
@PeterMorganQF
I'm new to following you, so I'll just get out of the way making sure you have seen Steven French's book, "Phenomenological Approach to Quantum Mechanics: Cutting the Chain of Correlations", and earlier articles. You must have, right?
IMO phenomenology is a useful foil. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This looks really interesting. Will definitely watch the whole thing.
Tom Froese, Embodied Cognitive Science Unit (ECSU)
@DrTomFroese
Check out the slide on global scalp potential for a 90 degree shift between absorption- to irruption-dominant brain activity. youtu.be/XA3DCTtRpDU
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Now I get excited 'cause this is stuff I am/ really want to work on.
Step 1) Quantum Bayesianism with its emphasis on Born Rule and Quantum Information
Step 2) A theory of agency! This can come from a complex systems/information theoretic perspective. Enactive approach too.
Alexander Yiannopoulos
@quantabhidharma
Yes, that's all correct, but it doesn't get us any closer to a formalism.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) "In this way, the discussion of the formalism taught us that the apparent philosophical point of departure of the theory, the idea of an observable world, totally independent of the observer, was a vacuous idea."
Alexander Yiannopoulos
@quantabhidharma
I think the fundamental problem for "quantum consciousness" discourse is the lack of solid formalism. Nobody's disputing that minds exist, the question is how they interact with matter, and in the absence of any good explanation the scientifically responsible move is to punt.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) "into discovering that the formalism of quantum mechanics already implies a well-defined theory of the relationship between the object and the observer, ..."
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) "a relation quite different from that implicit in naive realism, which had seemed, until then, one of the indispensable foundation stones of every science.”
From London & Bauer 1939. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I think trying to include 'the brain" in Von Neuman's chain of causation misses what QM is trying to tell us about experience. That's not the approach taken in that famous 1939 paper by London & Bauer I keep going on about. A phenomenological perspective is what's needed.
Alexander Yiannopoulos
@quantabhidharma
I think the fundamental problem for "quantum consciousness" discourse is the lack of solid formalism. Nobody's disputing that minds exist, the question is how they interact with matter, and in the absence of any good explanation the scientifically responsible move is to punt.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But the idea of having simple, straight-forward and unmediated access to that Universe is the most fraught and philosophically treacherous idea we've ever dreamed up. Piles of dead thinkers running aground on that coastline :-)
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
I don't see how this accomplishes anything aside from illustrating the fundamental incoherence of anthropic reasoning as a scientific tool. The existence of the universe independent of us is the least philosophically complicated idea imaginable.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Point is more subtle than that, hence unpacking philosophical traditions taking experience seriously. Again, of course there is a world without us, but the only world anyone gets access to THROUGH experience. It's the pre-condition for having ideas like "objective reality".
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
If an asteroid hit tomorrow and wiped out all life on Earth, the universe — this one — would continue to exist just fine, just like it existed for billions of years before we arrived.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Also, twitter is not an optimized place for this kind of subtle discussion of subtleties.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'd say that's a mistatement of the position. A better way to put is...
"Of course there is a world without us. It's just not this one".
This goes back to Kant and then emphasizes what the Phenomenologists learned about the structure other than experience.
Shekhinah 🕰️🌌🛸🪽
@cosmicfibretion
The position that an objective physical world doesn't exist independent of phenomenal consciousness is morally equivalent to stating that you're at the center of the universe.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes it does. It even has a name. The Born Rule.
Shekhinah 🕰️🌌🛸🪽
@cosmicfibretion
No it doesn’t.
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
"Quantum mechanics doesn’t have a measurement problem. It has an experience problem."
"Subjective experience isn’t a glitch in the system. It’s the whole damn interface."
"Life is the most important problem in physics because it is more mind blowing than black holes and string theory and everything else."
The incredible @AdamFrank4 everybody! ⬇️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That is exactly NOT the problem. You need to read London & Bauer's 1939 monograph on why experience in the phenomenological sense is the key to understanding what measurement means in the quantum formalism. You're stuck on Von Neuman.
www.sciencedirect.com/special-issue/10QBMXWTCMS -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was chance to do a deep dive into some of the philosophical issues associated with life and consciousness from a "beyond The Blind Spot" perspective. Thanks to @evan_mcgl
Evan McGloughlin
@evan_mcgl
"Quantum mechanics doesn’t have a measurement problem. It has an experience problem."
"Subjective experience isn’t a glitch in the system. It’s the whole damn interface."
"Life is the most important problem in physics because it is more mind blowing than black holes and string theory and everything else."
The incredible @AdamFrank4 everybody! ⬇️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The first era of space exploration is over. The era of commercial exploitation has begun. It's the most significant change for the human push beyond the planet since the first rocket launches of the 1950s. Here's a few things you need to know.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/space-is-changing-fast -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hey, you wanna become an astronaut? Well you probably can't but you could win a trip to train like one. My friends over @ScienceAlert are running a Space Coast trip sweepstakes.
www.sciencealert.com/spark-into-space-comp -
Adam Frank reposted
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Well, I think one branch of physics that got lots of media attention has sort of reached diminishing returns (Quantum Gravity, Strings..). But hell yeah, the rest of physics is doing great. Quantum Information, Large Scale Structure formation, Active Matter... damn!
Shekhinah 🕰️🌌🛸🪽
@cosmicfibretion
Physics scicomm has gone sideways. The field didn’t stagnate after Einstein and it isn’t stagnate today. There are so many ingenious experiments happening in cosmology, astrophysics, and the foundations of quantum mechanics that it’s impossible to keep up with them all.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So, funny story. I just asked Gemini if it was a sense making agent in the enactive sense and it said no. I mean, I know that doesn't really answer your question but it did crack me up.
Tom Froese, Embodied Cognitive Science Unit (ECSU)
@DrTomFroese
Yes, but the interesting question is not how many will object to the claim, but whether they are right or wrong to do so.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Astrophysicist/planetary scientist Steve Desch does NOT mess around. Great discussion on 3I/Atlas and Avi Loeb's "lazy" speculations.
Sam Gregson
@Samuel_Gregson
Astrophysicist Steve Desch explains why Avi Loeb’s observations regarding the interstellar comet #3iatlas are post hoc rationalisations and not scientific hypothesis testing.
It’s lazy anomaly hunting. 🎯
Full discussion: youtu.be/B4wp_Y1RGXk
#aviloeb #alien #uaps -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
boom!
Caleb Scharf🌎
@caleb_scharf
I would actually invert this: are humans en route to being the mitochondria for digital information systems like AI?
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Is gonna make energy for us? :-)
That's an interesting idea though which I think might be right. In time, it becomes something that is added to us in our "organization".
Frank Schmidt
@schmi88143
What if AI is the new mitochondria ?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Is gonna make energy for us? :-)
That's an interesting idea though which I think might be right. In time, it becomes something that is added to us in our "organization".
Frank Schmidt
@schmi88143
What if AI is the new mitochondria ?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am extremely skeptical that anything we are building now is even close to SuperIntelligence. That's not the issue as this tech gets shoved down our throats.
The real problem facing us is not getting AI “right” but getting human’s wrong.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/the-real-danger-of-ai -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hi All, So I am reading this with great interest now. I think our main objection would be the claim that LLM's are sense-making. They are amazing technology but I this claim would get lots of push-back from lots of quarters.
Tom Froese, Embodied Cognitive Science Unit (ECSU)
@DrTomFroese
Yes, that’s my intuition too. The first step is to realize that our past assessments of the basis of sense-making has been limited because we had a sample of 1 in the class of sense-makers, namely life itself. Now there is an opportunity to do a proper comparative analysis.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Over the last few centuries we humans have rewired the state of entire planet which is pretty amazing for a bunch of hairless monkeys
But as Earth slides deeper into these dangerous changes, the question facing us as a species is “What now?”
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/globalism-is-dead-long-live-t… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Astrobiology turns out to have profound insights about how to create a "mature" technosphere that can endure on timescales approaching those of geology.
I really enjoyed this discussion with Claire Webb in Venice last year (but man it was cold in that room).
FuturologyPod
@FuturologyPod
In our lifetime, we learned that nearly every star has its own planets. Earth is one story among trillions.
🎙️Adam Frank (@AdamFrank4) on Futurology podcast: “How to Spot an Alien Civilization”
www.youtube.com/watch?v=O95OHZTHy4o -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a great chance for me to talk with @caleb_scharf about his new book.
Caleb Scharf🌎
@caleb_scharf
Really enjoyed talking to @AdamFrank4 for this interview about ideas in The Giant Leap (@BasicBooks):
The next great leap in evolution may lie beyond Earth bigthink.com/13-8/the-next-great-leap-in-evolution-may-li… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
In case folks missed it. Here is a short post with the link to Jason Wright's explanation of the numerous problems with Avi Loeb's 3I/Atlas shenanigans.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/3i-atlas-alien-update-what-yo… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Astronaut-dude is the mascot of the Everyman's Newsletter :-)
www.everymansuniverse.com/subscribe
Clyde Morgan
@clydefmorgan3rd
I see you’ve adopted a brand.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
A wonderful conversation with Claire Webb of @berggruenInst about "The Planetary", a new view of the human future that begins with astrobiology. Part of their new @FuturologyPod podcast.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=O95OHZTHy4o -
Adam Frank reposted
CVanDutch
@CVanDutch
It's an illustration of a comet. What fucking Ai?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am more than OK with what The Galileo Project wants to do a'la UAPs. But Loeb has destroyed his reputation as an honest broker in science so that, sadly, hurts the project.
Kevin Heider
@kpheider
Loeb wants to fund a billion dollar project to look for aliens.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes! Why is it so hard for people to get this when they want to go on about Loeb's "anomalies"?
As Wright shows in his post, most of Loeb's anomalies are demonstrably wrong and the rest are in the "zone of awesome" astronomers expect for comets.
Richard Geldreich 🇺🇸
@richgel999
“We Expect 3I/ATLAS to be Anomalous
We do! This is only the 3rd interstellar comet we’ve seen, and it’s bound to behave differently from Solar System comets for two big reasons and two little ones.”
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Great piece by astronomer and SETI leader Jason Wright on the endless, exhausting claims about 3I/Atlas by Avi Loeb.
"zero planetary scientists give Avi’s claims any credence... because he’s demonstrably wrong"
sites.psu.edu/astrowright/2025/11/09/loebs-3i-atlas-anoma… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's the glass of whiskey that matters. Bulliet Rye, thank you very much bartender.
Dave 8x7B
@dave_alive
Astronomers sitting around in space suits?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But it is! It's an interstellar object showing new comet behavior. Why? Because its from another friggin solar system!
It is behaving exactly like we expect comets to behave but also showing new comet physics and chemistry. So much fun! I wish you guys would get that.
Matter as Machine
@matterasmachine
It does not have to be either "aliens" or "just a comet".
It could be "a comet with new physics". -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is a great review from @LeeBillings on the actual science around 3I/Atlas. It seems like lots of folks won't care about this amazing object unless it turns out to be aliens - which it won't (though I'd be psyched too be wrong).
www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-interplanetary-rac… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude... we are actively looking for them. It's a huge chunk of the science I and my colleagues are doing right now.
But we recognize our responsibility to the public in carrying out that search - and interacting with the media - demands hewing to high standards.
Matter as Machine
@matterasmachine
Astronomers believe in big bang.
At least aliens exist somewhere. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Every other astronomer in the world.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Again read Wright post about anomalies. Most Loeb claims = demonstrably wrong. Remaining ones are expected as part of comet science.
No one but Loeb sees even remote chance this is anything other than comet. But they don't get their faces splattered all over TV.
Agniv Sengupta
@AgniVAugusT
But he is saying it as a bizarre probability & not the only probability. Also he has always said it like "However, if it does this/that then it could be something intelligent". It has anomalies and he has been quite accurate about those as well. No wonder why he avoids socials 🤷♂️
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Read article from Jason Wright. He gives details & why astronomers are so frustrated .
Note, Loeb claims not in scientific papers (which would never make it through peer-review) but on Medium page which then leads to media coverage as "Harvard Astronomers says... aliens!"
Agniv Sengupta
@AgniVAugusT
What endless, exhausting claims by Avi!?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Great piece by astronomer and SETI leader Jason Wright on the endless, exhausting claims about 3I/Atlas by Avi Loeb.
"zero planetary scientists give Avi’s claims any credence... because he’s demonstrably wrong"
sites.psu.edu/astrowright/2025/11/09/loebs-3i-atlas-anoma… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Everyone knows outer space is big & empty but what about inner space? What about the space inside solid stuff. One of the strangest discoveries of modern physics is that solid matter is a big fat lie.
Today on Everymans Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/why-doesn-t-your-butt-fall-th… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We have a faculty position open at the URochester Physics department in Complexity Science. If you are an ambitious young researcher come join an ambitious growing program. Please apply.
Deadline coming very soon.
apply.interfolio.com/173432 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Lots of fun response to this piece.
Imagining a Dark Matter "sector" for particle physics was a sensible response to data. But what if we never find Dark Matter particles?
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-is-dark-matter-and-is-it… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It was one of the most unusual and most exciting meetings I'd attended.
Amanda Geftner's beautiful description of last fall's "What Is Intelligence" conference held at a 13th century church in Italy.
nautil.us/what-is-intelligence-1242863/?_sp=ed726377-c385… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Recently astronomers claimed to find evidence for ancient massive stars built from Dark Matter. While that's worth a post, I thought a more straightforward question needed answering first.
What the hell is Dark Matter anyway?
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-is-dark-matter-and-is-it… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Two new scientific papers dropped both claiming to show evidence for “Non-Terrestrial Artifacts” in astronomical photographs taken in the 1950s.
What are we to make of them?
From Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/did-science-just-confirm-1950… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"The idea of golden ages of empire leading to technological and cultural progress, and the fall of empires as leading to regression is, at best, mistaken."
Kemp "Goliath's Curse"
We're likely heading towards systemic change and history can help us see what to expect. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yesterday's talk = thought provoking. Working on paper about the Quantum Measurement problem and its philosophical issues . Didn't know about problems with even formulating the problem in relativistic QM and relativistic QFT.
No matter what Quantum Mechanics is beautiful. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
A merger-merger
LIGO
@LIGO
We are pleased to announce our discovery of #gw241011 and #gw241110
Both come from binary black holes where one black hole is larger than the other. The larger black holes have large spin. Could these black holes have formed in a previous merger?
ligo.org/science-summaries/GW241011-GW241110/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) from Lamb
"It should be apparent from the title of this article that the author does not like the use of the word “photon”, which dates from 1926. In his view, there is no such thing as a photon."
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01135846Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) Similarly, one might find it convenient to speak of the “aether” or “vacuum” to stand for empty space, even if no such thing existed. There are very good substitute words for “photon”, (e.g., “radiation” or “light”), and for “photonics” (e.g., “optics” or “quantum optics”). "
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) "Similar objections are possible to use of the word “phonon”. Objects like electrons, neutrinos of finite rest mass, or helium atoms can, under suitable conditions, be considered to be particles, since their theories then have viable non-relativistic and non-quantum limits. "
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
There are no particles in relativistic quantum field theories. No way to truly localize wave packets... whoa!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Holy crap. No ideal measurements in Quantum Field Theory? Even collapsing an entangled 2 bit system leads to problems in simultaneity... so says (maybe) our speaker.
The Sorkin Problem. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
As if the regular quantum mechanical measurement problem wasn't enough.
Today's University of Rochester Physics Dept colloquium. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What's next for the VASCO UFO papers?
The main message in today's Everyman's Universe is... game on.
@DrBeaVillarroel
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/did-science-just-confirm-1950… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's worth noting that in the poll associated with the last everymansuniverse.com post most people wanted more opportunities to use "enshittification" in a sentence.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Internet "Enshittification," spiritual sea slugs and the world enters a new technological system shock.
All in this weeks Everyman's Universe cosmic news round-up.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/internet-enshittification-spi… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Note that GOFAST turned out to be at 13,000 ft and moving at 40 miles/hour. Nothing of interest at all and the case has been closed.
Zach G0nzalez
@zach_gonzo_
Remember the tic-tac and gimbal incidents: these objects were stationary for *weeks* before the videoed movement! I like your work but be open to the ideas of others
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Whoa!
If no tensor product decomposition of H (The Hilbert Space) exists, one can't speak of entanglement at all. Thus entanglement cannot be applied to any system whose Hilbert space dimension D is prime (because H = H_A ⊗H_B would imply that D = D_A*D_B is not prime). -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Pay more attention. See my tweet below & understand how science works.
Those papers are a beginning, not an end. Science = call + response, not having biases confirmed. Now community has something to work with. How will results stand against intense scrutiny they deserve?
Marik vR
@MvonRen
The best part of these peer-reviewed, paradigm-shifting UFO-focused scientific papers?
The silence from the pseudo-skeptics/disinformation agents.
Disingenuous actors like @MickWest @MiddleOfMayhem @neiltyson @keithkloor @AdamFrank4 @SethShostak have NOTHING. Literally nothing.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Wonderful news. 🌟💫✨
Our two new VASCO papers are now peer-reviewed, accepted and published — and they reveal some extraordinary things:
- We find statistically significant correlations between short-lived transients on pre-Sputnik sky plates, UFO sightings, and above-ground nuclear tests.
- We show a 22σ deficit of transients inside Earth’s shadow — consistent with a fraction of these events originating from solar reflections from flat, highly reflective surfaces in orbit before the human Space Age began.
Together with our earlier MNRAS paper, these results form a triptych of new methods to investigate UAP using astronomical data. Three independent high-level journals — and three independent peer review processes.
These latest results raise a bold question.
And yes… you know which.
Press release (Stockholm University): www.su.se/english/news/unexpected-patterns-in-historical-…
Scientific Reports: www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-21620-3
PASP: iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1538-3873/ae0afe -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is how you do it. Peer reviewed, published in high quality journals. Congratulations. I will read these papers with great interest!
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Wonderful news. 🌟💫✨
Our two new VASCO papers are now peer-reviewed, accepted and published — and they reveal some extraordinary things:
- We find statistically significant correlations between short-lived transients on pre-Sputnik sky plates, UFO sightings, and above-ground nuclear tests.
- We show a 22σ deficit of transients inside Earth’s shadow — consistent with a fraction of these events originating from solar reflections from flat, highly reflective surfaces in orbit before the human Space Age began.
Together with our earlier MNRAS paper, these results form a triptych of new methods to investigate UAP using astronomical data. Three independent high-level journals — and three independent peer review processes.
These latest results raise a bold question.
And yes… you know which.
Press release (Stockholm University): www.su.se/english/news/unexpected-patterns-in-historical-…
Scientific Reports: www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-21620-3
PASP: iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1538-3873/ae0afe -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Everybody’s looking for the extraordinary. That’s one reason for the hold UFOs and aliens have on our imaginations. But one of science's great virtues is it shows us miracles right under our noses.
Todays Everyman's Universe post
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/you-want-aliens-i-ll-give-you… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a great conversation. This history of ups and downs surrounding life on Mars forms an important backstory for evaluating where we are today.
bigpicturescience.org/episodes/mad-about-mars -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
There is a difference between "mindfulness" meditation and contemplative practice. It's in the latter that you begin to learn something fundamental.
From last week's Everyman's Universe post when I was off at a multi-day Zen sesshin.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/zen-for-7-hours-a-day-really -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
At UR we’re starting discussions on “Coherence in the Wild” i.e. different ways quantum information perspectives show up everywhere else.
Today’s talk. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And speaking of super-powered aliens and amazing moments...
Aaron Judge in last nights Yankees-Toronto game. Damn, that was thrilling! And I hate the Yankees. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Until when? If 3I/Atlas makes a right hand turn or repeatedly emits the first 10,000 digits of pi I will be stoked! That would be awesome - a clear technosignature. (I'd be less pumped if it releases a swarm of drop ships).
But what do you think will happen in 14 days?
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Enjoy the blurry videos and testimonies until then :)
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) You raise an interesting point/project. How are assigning that probability? As you know, given a hypothesis H and data D there is LOTS OF WORK needed to get
P(H|D) = prob of H is conditioned on D.
@david_kipping territory. He's master of Bayesian analysis of such things.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Avi is probably right, contrary to 99.9% of astronomers.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3) So what are we mostly left with blurry video data that has mostly been pre-digested (pre-edited, don't know source, don't know much about instruments). That wouldn't count for much if we doing any other kind of science so it will be weak here too.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
4) The kind of stuff you proposing (Galieo project too) points in the right direction. But it's hard for me to see how, at this point, that pushes P(H|D) in any direction one way or the other.
So, for now, everyone's assigned P is all about their priors i.e their biases. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You have exactly and completely identified the problem.
MonkeeSage
@MonkeeSage
I blame Avi for co-opting it to push his alien mothership belief. It could have been a cool science communication topic, but instead we get the media enamored with his credentials amplifying his hypothesis and completely overshadowing any real science communication about it.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yeah, but he never did anything published after he got his phd and left the field. As far as I know.
Nathaniel
@nattydaddy98
his phd is in mathematics …. he’s a crank but his training was in mathematics
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Can you point to a peer-reviewed paper in a mathematics journal that he has written? I can't find any. Happy to see one. Though he needs more than 1 to really count as a "mathematician".
I once hit pitches from the plate at Redwings stadium but that don't make a ballplayer.
Nathaniel
@nattydaddy98
he’s a mathematician
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Also ... hey man, there's a lot more of the field out there than Particle Physics. Jeeze, myopia anyone. Or is he one of those dudes who thinks only his branch of physics is the important one (and he's never actually done anything in even that branch).
Shekhinah 🕰️🌌🛸🪽
@cosmicfibretion
“If you try and do something else [other than string theory] your career will come to an abrupt end.”
Bro hasn’t even spent a single day doing a literature review and he’s convinced himself he’s the next Einstein. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
There was the hope that LHC would find supersymmetric particles and that would have been huge. Remember it's Supersymmetric String Theory. So up until about 2016 at least there was some hope that a whole new avenue would open up.
Nature had other plans.
The Kecksburg Alien 🇺🇸🍀🚀🌲
@kecksburgalien
It took them 57 years to run out of data? With everyone working on it? I don't think the question is why it stalled, but rather...why did it go on so long?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
ohhh this looks awesome.
Dr Tevin Naidu
@drtevinnaidu
Decoding the Origin of Life: Complexity, Thermodynamics, and Memory with Prof @drmichaellevin & Prof Terrence Deacon.
www.mindbodysolution.org/blog/decoding-the-origin-of-life… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Unbelievable. I criticize string theory and what happened in that field plenty. Conspiracy? Nope.
Fundamentally what stalled the field was simply lack of data. You just can't get to the energy scales you want so untethered models abound.
After that comes the sociology.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
This guy just keeps getting crazier and crazier.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I hear you BUT from the actual science point of view, it's amazing. It's a god damned comet from another solar system! That's huge and exciting and we're learning all kinds of new stuff.
But noooooooo, all that's lost because it's gotta be an alien artifact or no one cares.
ITCryptoRocket
@ITCryptoRocket1
I can’t wait for this nothing burger on leave our solar system so I can stop reading crackpot theories
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I believe that is true. People like Steve Desch did though. We astronomers not built for onslaughts of media/social media dumbness.
Basically it's because we all love - and are swamped by - our own research. A day debunking crap is a day away from the joy of real science.
WestCoastCat
@MrWestCoastCat
I honestly feel like the science community did not call out Loeb enough earlier.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Its startling. An ocean of people just giving up any sense of critical thinking. It's also one reason I wish Prof Loeb would recognize the role he is playing in this.
Then it will pass out of solar system without invasion etc no lessons about gulliblility getting learned.
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
Just look at this crap…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Episode 10 of The Blindspot Podcast (we're still just getting started).
Marcelo and I do the deep dive into why Quantum Mechanics is weird.
Here is the YouTube version though its on all the usual podcast places.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J1-Y3tK48o&list=PLcng2n6sSWelT-G… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) You raise an interesting question. I agree with your and others critique of "fundamental" physics (i.e. string theory etc). We made this point a lot in our book "The Blind Spot". But that's only 1 small branch of physics The rest of the field is doing very cool stuff.
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
built on yesterday's physics you mean (not that I agree with the person you are criticising)
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
5) But, in a way, I think physics is moving on. There are really big, really cool questions being addressed (my favorite is about the physics of information and life). If we can ever get real data about the planck scale etc then maybe those fields get their veracity mojo back.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'll just close with this piece Marcelo Gleiser and I wrote back in 2015 (yikes, i'm getting old)
www.nytimes.com/2015/06/07/opinion/a-crisis-at-the-edge-o… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Real men don’t use the powerful benefits of American science when it suits them (or saves their lives) and then reject it when it offends their delicate political sensibilities. 🇺🇸😀
Clementine Hale
@TheClemHale
Men believe in science. Men don't believe in bullsh*t.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And in other news, the Red Socks / Yankees series was awesome. Baseball at its finest. Sad the Sox lost but great pitchers duels.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's also important to distinguish between the vast global work of science and scientists and corporations like BigPharma which I am no fan of either.
But if your pissed off about corporate perfidy go after that by imposing better regulations on their behavior.
𝕄𝕦𝕟𝕘𝕦𝕚
@mungui_zero
I always find it amusing when anti-science people use all the commodities of the modern world that are built on science to talk trash instead of, I don’t know, go living on an Amish commune or something.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Preach brother!
𝕄𝕦𝕟𝕘𝕦𝕚
@mungui_zero
I always find it amusing when anti-science people use all the commodities of the modern world that are built on science to talk trash instead of, I don’t know, go living on an Amish commune or something.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) How many scientists do you actually know?
Have you ever been to a scientific conference and seen how mean we are to each other in pursuit of new verifiable knowledge?
Angry Black Sheep and White Supremacist
@SkepticalSheep
I trust the scientific process. Scientists™, not so much.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) I've spend my life in this domain. Scientists are human beings: some jerks and some kind. But as a rule honesty and humility in the search for understanding is what gives our lives purpose. That's why we hold so firmly to its values - the values I describe in that article.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Says the person using the incredible fruits of science to broadcast a message across a global networked telecommunications platform built of quantum physics, relativity, condensed matter physics and information theory.
But go ahead tell me how most of science is junk.
Steve Milloy
@JunkScience
If people have lost faith in science, it's because most of today's science is junk. I challenge astrophysicist @adamfrank4 to apply these words:
"Good scientists are intimate with the limits of what they know and stand ready to learn in domains outside their expertise. They don’t just claim they are right. Instead, they know the cure for their ignorance is to actively and rigorously test their own assertions."
... to the "climate physics" he apparently finds so "compelling."
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/03/opinion/manosphere-science-you… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Says the person using the incredible fruits of science to broadcast a message across a global networked telecommunications platform built of quantum physics, relativity, condensed matter physics and information theory.
Robert Walker
@RobertW12470704
There is so much "science" either doesn't know, can't explain or accurately define, but "scientists" can't admit those realities, so they make things up, torture data or flat out lie - often for financial gain.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Says the person using the incredible fruits of science to broadcast a message across a global networked telecommunications platform built of quantum physics, relativity, condensed matter physics and information theory.
windward.eth בשנה הבאה בירושלים
@EthWindward
Maybe because young men are smart enough to realize that it's scientific malpractice to have faith and belief in Science^tm treating it like a sort of secular humanist religion
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sage advice.
Dan Goldin
@dansgoldin
I am very pro-technology, as you all know. But I really want to remind everyone to also be human. Both can co-exist. We just need to figure out how.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a cool (no pun intended) article. I usually hear about moon mining of He3 for fusion and I kinda yawn... fusion is still a long way off. But He3 for quantum computing cooling is a new idea for me.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just thinking about how on over reliance on SpaceX may end up being a bad idea for Artemis.
The point of that article was that there are just so, so many technical hurdles to the approach SpaceX wants that the Chinese will get to the moon before we can.
SPACELY
@blury___face
Missing context.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) "We have nothing but respect for SpaceX’s engineering prowess and none of us doubt that all of this will eventually happen. But our scars tell us it won’t happen quickly, and certainly not on a schedule that keeps the U.S. in the lead."
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Recall that when SpaceX was first awarded their contract, they claimed that they would be able to do it all by 2024 — yet today as we approach 2026, we are still unable to fly repeatedly with high confidence much less accomplish those far harder goals."
spacenews.com/we-led-nasas-human-exploration-program-here… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The University of Rochester has a faculty position opening in complexity science as well as other domains of theoretical physics. Please apply to join us in
studying the “physics of life” and other subjects
apply.interfolio.com/173432 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Buddhism is the religion that often gets a pass when it comes to "Science vs Religion" debates. Does that pass make sense?
Maybe, but not when in the usual way we think about it when it comes to quantum mechanics.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/can-buddhism-and-science-jive -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @bigthink interview with the wonderful @david_kipping about all things astrobiology and science outreach.
bigthink.com/13-8/david-kipping-on-how-the-search-for-ali… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But do we? Given the economic disruption and all the dangers do we really need it? Who will really benefit? Will it lead to more equality or more inequality? I'm not sold on the idea that it will solve quantum gravity or any of those claims.
SPACELY
@blury___face
There'll be some transition along those lines because that's what we collectively want.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I was just teaching my students about this an hour ago.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes. I'm not saying that AGI is impossible. It's the dangerous hype from billionaires who stand to make a fortune shoving this version of AI down our throats that's the major problem.
LLMs don't live in "worlds" and will not become AGI.
David Eide
@RealDavidEide
It all depends what one’s time horizon is.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I ❤️ nuclear power rockets!
SPACELY
@blury___face
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Despite $30-40 billion in enterprise spending on generative AI, 95% of organizations are seeing no business return, according to a recent report out of the MIT Media Lab.”
LLM based AI is amazing tech AND the hype around it (and AI in general) is a steaming pile of bullcrap -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The end of the world as we know it, is not the same as the end of the world. The trick is to understand what emerges from instability and get ahead of the curve.
Today's Everyman's Universe post on "Goliath's Curse" a book about societal collapse.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/some-good-news-about-the-coll… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This makes me very sad. Breakthrough Starshot was such an exciting idea. Crazy yes, but crazy in a good way.
www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-quiet-demise-of-br… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Last week's news was terrible all around but hidden in it all was the discovery - maybe - of signatures of life on Mars.
Why the latter matters for the former. A bigger story for ourselves.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/life-on-mars-our-difficult-li… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just started Cyberpunk 2077. Amazing!
Did its rough start actually help the game? That question and others in today's in Everyman's Universe news round-up.
@CyberpunkGame #cyberpunk2077phantomliberty
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/cyberpunk-your-coffee-addicti… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Will totally read this. Like the worst UFO stuff, again, this idea that you archeologists are "hiding the truth" about Atlantis or whatever. Never mind you've spend a lifetime doing detailed research, here's is a "journalist" who can prove (fill in the wacky blank)
David Connolly
@BAJRjobs
I will read you article if you read mine :)
Raiders of my Lost Mind: A deep dive into the whacky world of Pseudoarchaeology - David Connolly www.bajr.org/raiders-of-my-lost-mind-a-deep-dive-into-the… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Also Pérez-Couto et al have an archive paper attempting to track the source perturber of 3I/ATLAS. They don't find strong evidence of a more "recent" stellar encounter but do conclude it was part of the "thin disk" of the galaxy.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Keto and Loeb have what appears to be a nice article on the archive about the anti-tail of 3I/ATLAS. Mathematical model seems plausible. No adding of unneeded speculation about alien origin. On a purely physics level be interested to see what comet scientists think.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"We therefore conclude that while a globally habitable TRAPPIST-1 e is permitted, our posteriors favor a cold scenario. ... we advocate for increased consideration of cold-planet scenarios".
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh oh oh. Soooooooooo exciting.
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
New studies used JWST to probe TRAPPIST-1e, the most accessible potential Earth-like exoplanet. Data reveals the atmosphere is
1) Not hydrogen dominated (unsurprising)😌
2) Unlikely to be Venus-like🧐
3) Compatible with N2-rich😎
arxiv.org/abs/2509.05407
arxiv.org/abs/2509.05414 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Finally starting Cyberpunk 2077.
I had to get over my addiction to Dune Awakening first. If I had to craft one more fabricator I was gonna lose it. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
yeah but that relies on a GIANT science fiction assumption. Also if they are trying to hide, they really suck at it. 😀
www.npr.org/sections/13.7/2011/03/25/134855990/highbeams-…
SPACELY
@blury___face
The one exception is if intelligent life is deliberately evading us and already knows the science we're trying to perform.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) "There is a reason Science works. There is a reason why it’s given us miracles like whatever device you’re reading this on. UFOs don’t get a special dispensation."
From today's Everyman's Universe
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-s-the-deal-with-ufos
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
2) "If you don’t have evidence that hits those standards - the one’s science discovered via four centuries of blood, sweat and tears - then you’re just chasing after your own biases.
I don’t want to confirm my biases. I don’t want to believe. I want to know." -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Tell me more. I imagine that there all kinds of ways to hide signatures but which ones explicitly do they want to hide? Whole planets? Or just spaceships/space stations.
FletchGod Apocalypse
@FletcherMR
I've read it, and this is not that.
The novel is SF after humans have been in space for a while and I'm trying to figure out if distant aliens (say ~1,500 LY away) have any chance at hiding. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
How to change your life.
If you can take time each day to find the Moon, then note its phase, then note where you’re seeing it in the sky and, finally, note what time of day you’re seeing it… then the Universe will tell its secrets.
I kid you not.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/where-s-the-damn-moon -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is our new paper that we're really excited about. What makes a cell different from a rock? The answer we argue is the USE of information. But information carries meaning and that changes everything if we want to understand the "physics of life".
PRX Life
A new Roadmap discusses how information influences abiogenesis and living systems. It explores how informational constraints may help gauge planet habitability — and how informational #biosignatures could indicate life beyond Earth.
🔗 go.aps.org/4mJdjD0
#astrobiology -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a great conversation I had with the folks at the @BBC
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Man that is true. The view you find on X is "Weinstein has a degree from Harvard... in Physics! He must be a genius of the highest proportion."
But all Harvard physicists who think Weinstein is a blowhard are idiots and part of the conspiracy of silence.
Confirmation bias.
Lunar Capitalist
@P_Dubbin
I love the notion that we plebs just aren't QUALIFIED to call out obvious frauds such as Eric. Meanwhile his fans require no such credentials to agree with him.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes. That would be wonderful. Until then we use science because its the only way we protect oursselves from getting fooled by horsecrap.
GabeTheBabe
@Gabe_Trust
Look if they show up here and land for the world to see before we have a peer-reviewed paper, then the whole scientific community needs to be thrown out with the bathwater.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Unless I’m mistaken, it’s not a scientific paper. It’s a bunch of musings on Medium. There’s a difference. It important and you should know it. It’s called peer review. It’s what all actual science goes through.
I could be wrong though. Please point to peer reviewed paper.
Skywatch Signal
@UAPWatchers
🚨 3I/ATLAS: The Nickel-Cyanide Factory in Space
Avi Loeb just dropped a paper on new data from 3I/ATLAS.
They found something no comet should have, nickel without iron + cyanide streaming in the plume.
That’s engineering!🧵👇 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very happy to share this new paper we've recently published. Do biospheres use information in the same way organisms do? Can we think of biospheres as agents?
"Exo-Daisy World: Revisiting Gaia Theory through an Informational Architecture Perspective"
iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/PSJ/ade310 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Do we really need a Gollum movie?
How about a second season of Fallout?
Are we even close to getting a handle on consciousness?
All this and more in this weeks EVERYMAN'S UNIVERSE news roundup.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/gollum-s-back-the-mystery-of-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's a New school year and a good time to ask what are Universities for?
"To learn and question. To study and seek answers. To go beyond the day-to-day struggle for just getting by and build something that can endure and be better."
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-is-college-for-1edffad11…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Humans created universities to find what might be universal amongst themselves and, in the process, open themselves to the Universe as a whole. The capacity they offer to study, learn and be changed in the process is a lifetime skill that has endured for millennia.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thanks for this!
Galacton
@Galacton2
Yeah, more research is needed in the actual gravity or artificial gravity of 38% g.
Generation physiological evolutionary divergence? Yes IMO.
NASA July 2021
The Partial Gravity of the Moon and Mars Appears Insufficient to Maintain Human Health
ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20210019591/downloads/ICES-20… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I have seen estimates that 1/3 g is enough to mitigate serious health issues. I don't think there is anything definitive on this but would be very interested to see studies.
Galacton
@Galacton2
AI
It would almost certainly be unhealthy for humans to live at the gravity of Mars indefinitely. Mars' gravity is only about 38% of Earth's, which is not enough to prevent or sufficiently mitigate several severe health problems caused by living in a low-gravity environment. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
James Cameron must go beyond evil AI for movie.
Polarization on social media don't need no algorithms.
The physics of meteor trails.
All this and more in this week's Everyman's Universe new round-up
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/james-cameron-on-evil-ai-seei… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is my interview with the always creative and thought provoking @annakaharris on the nature of consciousness - perhaps the most important question emerging for the 21st century.
@bigthink
bigthink.com/13-8/annaka-harris-on-consciousness/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I ❤️ O'Neil cylinders.
Luke Parrish
@lsparrish
Here's the guy who came up with O'Neill cylinders. His name is O'Neill
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was one of the very cool ideas from your proposal.
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
Although, we could maybe do this…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Oh my god. Friggin' Eric Weinstein. Why do any of us have to deal with anything Eric Weinstein says.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
Lord, give me the strength to not amplify Avi Loeb, the serenity to ignore Eric Weinstein, and the wisdom not to engage about Terence Tao.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The ISS orbits within the Earth's magnetosphere.
Malky
@Malky0010
Nonsense. The radiation level is not higher than on ISS. And if you think any place in Solar system is better than Mars, you are plainly wrong.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What do you mean self-sustaining? I am talking about having millions of people living there. That's a lot of launches. But you raise an interesting point about giving the habitats atmospheres. I assume that's why you are point to N2.
Martian sign off Comrade
@Comrademarsalex
The mass required for the N2 for a modestly sized space habitat exceeds the mass of payload to Mars to make it self sustaining.
And i can actually run you the numbers -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Don't get me wrong. I love Mars and would go there in a heartbeat. But hospitable it ain't. The lack of a magnetosphere means everything must be built underground or 100% chance of cancer.
My musings on going to Mars.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/dying-on-mars
Malky
@Malky0010
Mars doesn't have a magnetosphere, so what...? It doesn't change anything, Mars is the most hospitable place for humans in Solar System, and obvious first place to go and settle.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thanks. By the way, you were the best NASA administrator of my lifetime. Thank you.
Dan Goldin
@dansgoldin
Interesting read!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Say you true beltalowda.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nah. Space is very big and you could move the asteroid if problems show up.
Barnard33
@LDN_1630
Should be temporary because that asteroid could collide with something or be attract by a bigger spacial thing
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It was the Expanse series that introduced me to the idea (and Kim Stanely Robinson). So we took it seriously and did the calculations on what would, and would not, work.
Kevin Kennedy
@gokevin1
Reminds me of an orbital from Iain Banks Culture series. I love the idea.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Planets like Mars may not be the future for a settled solar system. Getting in / out of gravity wells will make construction dangerous and expensive.
Building vast space cities from asteroids could be an easier path forward over the next few centuries
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/mars-is-for-losers-here-s-our…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Imagine a future with hundreds of thousands of asteroid habitats. Each one could have the same habitable inner surface as New York City. Scattered across the solar system each one would be an experiment in human society and, hopefully, human flourishing.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
People could create the societies they want. Some might be Morman city-states. Some might be Corporate pseudo-republics. Some might be radical democracies.
Anything would be possible and that, in itself, represents an exciting future. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That's exactly it. I spend everyday thinking about how to find life in the Universe (dumb or smart). Wouldn't do it if I didn't believe it was out there.
But I don't want to believe... I want to know!!! Only one path forward. Rigorous brutal honest responsible science.
Blue Pikmin
@JohnBealCasual
I recently began following @AdamFrank4 and my impression is that he isn’t claiming that aliens aren’t here, but rather the evidence is insufficient, and drawing the distinction between what we can’t rule out as alien and what the general professional consensus says.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Project Hail Mary!
Hungry Black Holes!
Dumb-ass policies on mRNA research and more.
Today's news roundup with links on Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/project-hail-mary-hungry-blac… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Another one bites the dust. 3rd Trappist-1 system shows no evidence of atmosphere. Are M-dwarf stars too active to allow atmospheres to survive on their planetary children?
arxiv.org/abs/2508.08416 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Can anyone think of an example where a scientist proposes a classification scale and names it after themselves?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
wise words from @GaryMarcus
”Science is not a popularity contest; you can’t bully your way to truth. And you can’t make AI better if you drown out the critics and keep pouring good money after bad. Science simply cannot advance without people sticking to the truth” -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We are friends forever. As long as you love the Mets.
Nopilled
@Nopilled16622
Adam, that comment was not directed at you. I know you're an expert, I was replying to someone else in the comment chain and you got tagged. I wish there was a setting that auto removed people the reply was not directed at.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Also I do think you are making some good and reasonable points.
Nopilled
@Nopilled16622
Stop trying to lecture me like you're some kind of subject matter expert. I'm well aware of Avi's background and what the current consensus is. Also try reading some published papers, there is some wild stuff that gets published by "astronomers".
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Bro, I'm an astrophysicist. I think that kind of makes me a subject matter expert in astrophysics. What I'm not is an expert in cometary astronomy which is why I differ to cometary astronomers.
Nopilled
@Nopilled16622
Stop trying to lecture me like you're some kind of subject matter expert. I'm well aware of Avi's background and what the current consensus is. Also try reading some published papers, there is some wild stuff that gets published by "astronomers".
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am super chill and super pumped that we've discovered a comet from an alien solar system.
Jared Yoder
@jaredyoder
You scared? 😱🤷
It's very likely a craft.
Watch latest video of Dr. Salla and George Kavassilas.
Amen 😊👍 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That nails it. Thank you.
GeorgeWilliamHerbert
@GeorgeWHerbert
Professionals have standards. Astronomers do have people who study how to detect non natural artifacts. They haven’t for 3I. So they’re not talking about that possibly because they don’t see evidence and it would be unprofessional to say there is when there isn’t.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That's the beauty of tenure and I fully support it. Loeb has every right to pursue his research. It's everyone's else job to evaluate what stands up to science's strong standards of evidence. The media has an important role to play here.
Will Cutlip
@WillECutlip
Truth...and yet, Harvard keeps him around...
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You said it brother! We'd be screaming it loud and proud. Most of all, we would be stoked!
Space Initiatives
@AsteroidEnergy
And, if the astronomy community _did_ think this, or any other, ISO _was_ connected to an ETI, you'd know about it. You'd hear so much about it most non-astronomers would get tired of it.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Crying “aliens are here” to get attention for your science does a terrible (and dangerous) injustice to science.
I go on a lot of podcasts and talk about the search for life. I am very mindful of my responsibility to teach not just astrobiology, but how science works.
Nopilled
@Nopilled16622
Just to add if you go on a podcast tomorrow and put Atlas in the title said podcast will get a lot more attention than it would have otherwise because of those recent headlines.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
But nobody in this media environment EVER gets to hear the “he is wrong” part. And we are a world drowning in science misinformation and denial. Any scientist who wants to stand in the public spotlight bears an enormous responsibility to speak true to the method.
Nopilled
@Nopilled16622
I'm talking more about the general public. Discussion around celestial objects is usually constrained to the astronomy and amateur astronomy community unless it's something people can see with the naked eye. Whether Avi is right or wrong he brought this to international headlines several times over the past few weeks. That's why the headlines say alien spaceship.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) Bro... why focus on whatever Avi Loeb says and ignore what ALL the other astronomers are saying? Read astronomer Jason Wright's point by point demonstration of Loeb mistakes.
Really interested in the science = read diverse opinions and be skeptical of your biases.
Anomalous_User²🗽🛸
@Bot1397642
You trumpet that “nothing implies alien tech yet," fine 🤷🏿♀️ But Loeb just exposed a glow ahead of 3I/ATLAS, no comet-style tail, no gas signatures, plus an ultra-rare trajectory in the ecliptic and near-perfect timing with Venus, Mars, and Jupiter..odds less than 0.005%. That’s not “nothing,” that’s data refusing your bias.
"It doesn't take a PhD to figure this stuff out, yet PhDs can't handle it" -Dr. Kevin Knuth on the Physics of UFOs lol -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Dude... the data is right infront of you. It's being collected right now in full public view. Cool new things seen making 3I/ATLAS different from solar system comets. It was be awesome if you cared about that. But ain't nothing there (yet) that implies alien artifact.
Anomalous_User²🗽🛸
@Bot1397642
The “ZERO reason” line is exactly why the public needs voices like Avi’s. History’s full of experts declaring zero reason right before the breakthrough. Dismissing improbable trajectories and anomalies because they don’t fit the model is just Inquisition 2.0 shieettt. 🤷🏿♀️
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That’s not true. InterStellar Objects (ISO) as “artifacts” is an old idea that continues to get serious attention. But those of us working in Technosignatures see zero - ZERO - reason to think 3I/ATLAS is one.
Nopilled
@Nopilled16622
No one would be even talking about it outside the astronomy community if it wasn't for him.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Why all the headlines about 3I/ATLAS as an alien spaceship?
The answer to that question comes in a single name: Avi Loeb. Nobody other than Loeb is pushing the spaceship thing. For professional astronomers it's beyond frustrating. The real story is getting lost in the noise.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Generally, we researchers hold fast to the methods and norms of scientific practice that have been carefully established over the last four centuries. Self-criticism, patience and willingness to listen to others with more experience than yourself are hallmarks of that practice
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
From today’s post at Everyman’s Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/is-an-alien-spaceship-crossin… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
If you want to read what other astronomers are saying (and who are experts in observational astronomy and/or cometary science - I am not one) you can read Jason Wright's blog pieces on the subject. He is linking to lots of the relevant science.
sites.psu.edu/astrowright/
Yair Grinberg
@YairGrinberg
Prof Frank. It would be interesting to read your assessment of the content of the Loeb criticism, rather than your assessment of his expertise, or lack of.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You should start with the post dated July 18 and go forward from there. Its pretty detailed.
"Because 3I/ATLAS is moving through space, if one were to take images this way this motion would smear the image slightly during the exposure, making it appear trailed. "
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Avi is clearly leaning heavily into this interpretation.
Thing is, planetary scientists would never make this mistake. They know perfectly well how to change the tracking of telescopes so moving objects don't trail or smear—it’s one of the first things you learn in the field" -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Folks, Prof Loeb is not some kind of Uber-scientist whose expertise in all fields of astronomy dwarfs that of everyone else. Comets not his field most of career. He's not really in a position to deliver 'a harsh reality check' in this domain (opinions are fine... we all got em)
Skywatch Signal
@UAPWatchers
🚨Avi Loeb: No Clear Evidence For Water Around 3I/ATLAS
Despite the headlines, Avi Loeb just dropped a harsh reality check stating the data doesn’t back the claims.
Two papers claim “Water detected.” Neither hold up under scrutiny.
🧵 Let’s break it down:
#3iatlas #uap #spacenews -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Stories were the first human technology but the rise of digital media has us drowning in them. Humans need their myth making but what happens when the noise rises above the signal.
A wee exploration on today's Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/we-re-drowning-in-stories-ca4… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Aliens eat Earth.
Quantum Mechanics still freaks out physicists.
Space food for everyone!
All on Everyman's Universe and today's Cosmic News Roundup.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/cosmic-news-roundup-8-7-2025 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Forget the little green men and the little grey men. We are the only humanoids in the galaxy. Here's why...
today's post on Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/we-re-the-only-humans-in-the-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Koan Practice is the best! I have not gotten to the Blue Cliff Record yet. On case 37 of the Gateless Barrier. The Buffalo passes through the window.
I am sooooo grateful for what I've learned from 30 years of Zen.
BryanRoth
@zenbrainest
@AdamFrank4 greetings Adam! We sat a few sesshin together at RZC. Interested in hearing how your ongoing zen practice informs your current view of the cosmos wrt this classic sanbo-zen-international.org/wp-content/uploads/Hekiganrok…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Guillermo del Toro’s ‘Frankenstein’
Einstein explores his search for spiritual meaning
The UFOs that scientists think are real, but can't explain
All these stories and more on this weeks Everyman's Science news roundup.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/cosmic-news-roundup-7-31-2025 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For this who may have missed it. My interview for @bigthink with the great director @scottderrickson.
bigthink.com/13-8/scott-derrickson-on-filmmaking-and-the-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The building blocks are all there. I think microbial life might be easy (not that we understand its organization) but the question may be: can long-lived planetary biospheres really form? That's what we are going to be able to detect.
SPACELY
@blury___face
@AdamFrank4
Is life widespread throughout the cosmos? Complex organic molecules found in planet-birthing disk www.yahoo.com/news/articles/life-widespread-throughout-co… via @YahooNews -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Absolutely fantastic story by @andersen on how scientific excellence and leadership get squandered by nations.
An important piece from @TheAtlantic
www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2025/07/science-empir… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
From Everyman's Universe, this week's Cosmic News Roundup 7/31/2025.
News you can use, or at least cool stuff to think about
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/cosmic-news-roundup-7-31-2025 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Superman is Stupid!
Today's super rant and what's good and what's not in superheroes.
From Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/subscribe -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"[beginning with the irreduciblity of experience] may be the fundamental reframing required to make scientific progress on a range of issues, from the interpretation of quantum mechanics to the understanding of cognition and consciousness."
www.noemamag.com/why-science-hasnt-solved-consciousness-yet/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Eventually, the first-person, embodied experience of being hot or feeling cold was pushed aside as a phantom epiphenomenon, while abstracted quantities like temperature, became more real. This amnesia of experience is science’s blind spot."
www.noemamag.com/why-science-hasnt-solved-consciousness-yet/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This week's cosmic News Roundup 7/24/2025 from the Everyman's Universe newsletter
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/cosmic-news-roundup-7-24-2025 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The newest Everyman's Universe post.
What’s The Problem with Big Black Holes?
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/what-s-the-problem-with-big-b… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is a great article about the dangers of thinking of the brain in terms of an information system. We are actually working on theories of semantic information and life but I find papers like this useful in keeping one's feet to the fire.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/theo.70021
Alexey Guzey
@alexeyguzey
the article makes a lot of claims with 0 empirical support
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Levin is quite clear that he is extending the meaning of machine beyond the reductionist metaphysics I am talking about.
That's what makes his work so interesting.
Ben Schulz
@schulzb589
I prefer a polycomputational framework.
[2212.10675] There's Plenty of Room Right Here: Biological Systems as Evolved, Overloaded, Multi-scale Machines share.google/fQ9F24gxU0rk7ShlT -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The brain being a computer is an analogy, a metaphor and the age-old linking of whatever technology is currently dominant to describe the Mind. That's what has no empirical support.
Alexey Guzey
@alexeyguzey
the article makes a lot of claims with 0 empirical support
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The central point
Our discussion of consciousness has a fatal flaw. It’s a mistake built into the foundations of how science is perceived and conducted across disciplines. This includes the hype around artificial intelligence. @NoemaMag
www.noemamag.com/why-science-hasnt-solved-consciousness-yet/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Physicalism requires a framework that already depends on the life-world (a'la Husserl). You already have to be embedded in the unitary holism of experience to conceive -downstream - of the "physical". Thus you can not start with physicalism.
Also Hempel's Dilemma...
Deivon Drago
@DeivonDrago
None of this invalidates the essence of physicalism - which is that at the end of the day, what's physical does not change depending on the description of higher level systems
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thanks.
I would argue that the categories used to parse this problem historically fail to capture the direction we want to explore.
In the end what's required is a new vision of Nature itself (one that always has us in it). -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just a reminder that I've started a new newsletter on @beehiiv called Everyman's Universe.
The Cosmos Explored, Explained and Enthused Over.
here's where to subscribe
www.everymansuniverse.com/subscribe -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Going to spend sometime this week posting about the core idea in my recent @NoemaMag article about science and its approach to consciousness.
Starting with Physics is the wrong way to go.
Here is a link to the piece.
www.noemamag.com/why-science-hasnt-solved-consciousness-yet/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
From Everyman's Universe. Today's Cosmic News Roundup
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/cosmic-news-roundup-7-17-2025… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You Are Not a Meat Computer #1.
Today's post from Everyman's Universe.
Life and the failure of the machine metaphor will be a topic we explore quite a bit at the newsletter.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/you-are-not-a-meat-computer-1… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Episode 7 of The Blind Spot Podcast.
Evan Thompson and I do a deep dive into why science needs to rethink its approach to life.
And we also talk about Evan’s epic adolescence (seriously, it was epic).
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCO-qZpJoXI -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For folks who weren't online July 4th (when this went live)....
Here is my @TheAtlantic piece on NASA and what's being lost there. The new budget could spell the end of the great agency's legacy of space science leadership.
A huge national mistake.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Within a few decades, humans might finally gather some hard data that can answer its most profound, existential question: Is there life beyond Earth? But because of Trump's cuts to space science, NASA might not power this discovery, @AdamFrank4 writes: www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2025/07/nasa-observat…
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For another take on this problem, a great article in @washingtonpost by @JoelAchenbach
www.washingtonpost.com/science/2025/07/08/nasa-science-mi… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Solar System Just Got Another Visitor From An Alien Solar System
Today's Hot Take from Everyman's Universe.
www.everymansuniverse.com/p/the-solar-system-just-got-ano… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This one of the greatest exchanges ever. Most nations don't have 1000 year legacies. The names of the leaders are all forgotten. For the US it will be the science we've done that gets recalled millennia from now. That is how the deeds of the nation will endure.
Will Kinney
@WKCosmo
As Robert Wilson said, it is what makes America worth defending.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Amid all the difficulties the country faces, the losses in space science might seem trivial. But American science, including space science, has paid enormous dividends in keeping the nation strong, prosperous, and worthy of the world’s respect.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Within a few decades, humans might finally gather some hard data that can answer its most profound, existential question: Is there life beyond Earth? But because of Trump's cuts to space science, NASA might not power this discovery, @AdamFrank4 writes: www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2025/07/nasa-observat…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Amid all the difficulties the country faces, the losses in space science might seem trivial. But American science, including space science, has paid enormous dividends in keeping the nation strong, prosperous, and worthy of the world’s respect.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Within a few decades, humans might finally gather some hard data that can answer its most profound, existential question: Is there life beyond Earth? But because of Trump's cuts to space science, NASA might not power this discovery, @AdamFrank4 writes: www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2025/07/nasa-observat…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"That a kid in Florence or a middle-aged guy in Bangkok would wear a NASA T-shirt is testimony to the power of its legacy. NASA—with its can-do spirit and its willingness to dream like no other organization in the history of the world—is America"
From my take on gutting NASA.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Within a few decades, humans might finally gather some hard data that can answer its most profound, existential question: Is there life beyond Earth? But because of Trump's cuts to space science, NASA might not power this discovery, @AdamFrank4 writes: www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2025/07/nasa-observat…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Not going boldly. My piece for the Atlantic about the "extinction level event" at NASA.
www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2025/07/nasa-observat… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
You will. Eventually I would like to do some live Q&A's
SPACELY
@blury___face
👍
Hopefully we can ask questions. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Happy to announce my new newsletter EVERYMAN'S UNIVERSE.
Sign up with this link for weekly posts on aliens (astrobiology), the frontiers in physics and astrophysics, the importance of wonder and, of course, ScFi pop culture (and video games too)
www.everymansuniverse.com/subscribe -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
New episode of The Blind Spot just dropped. The Problems with Cosmology and Unified Theories. Deep dive into the success and the challenges of the big bang model and String Theory and supersymmetry. Their major shortcomings and challenges.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=_d5m3T3sTM4 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hey Everybody, very excited to be starting the "Everyman's Universe" newsletter via @beehiiv in a few weeks.
Official announcement to follow soon. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Can someone explain why folks working day-to-day in science should care what Eric Weinstein has to say?
(I make this comment as someone who's done lots of String Theory and TOE criticism)
www.nytimes.com/2015/06/07/opinion/a-crisis-at-the-edge-o… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was a really wide-ranging conversation that included discussions of life in the Universe, complexity in supply chain dynamics, the failures of reductionism and the philosophy of science.
Big Fun as they say.
Bilal Hafeez
@bilalhafeez123
Had an absolute blast going off-piste and discussing Aliens, AI and Climate Collapse with Astrophysicist @AdamFrank4 :
macrohive.com/hive-podcasts/ep-309-adam-frank-on-aliens-a… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Join me and @david_kipping tomorrow at @PioneerWorks_ as we discuss... wait for it now... ALIENS.
Yeah, the real super-cool science of Life in the Universe kind of aliens. Not the bullshit conspiracy theory stuff.
pioneerworks.org/programs/scientific-controversies-aliens -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Man, this is true. The whole Eric Weinstein thing is such a mess.
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
I get why someone outside academia would want to proclaim they have a theory of everything, given how much society celebrates the achievements of Newton and Einstein. But, what is the motivation for why the members of the public start supporting these theories?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just a reminder that @evanthompson.bsky.social Marcelo Gleiser and I have started a podcast called The Blind Spot (its about science, philosophy and beyond).
Here is a link to the latest episode which is Part II of our discussion of Time
open.spotify.com/episode/3KYp7sM0wf40TygXkjvzDk -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's not going to be just a brain-drain. Even more important is the world's best students will stop coming here and go to other places (Europe, China, etc).
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01489-y? -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Come join us at Pioneer Works next week for
Scientific Controversies: Aliens
Adam Frank and David Kipping in Conversation with Janna Levin
WEDNESDAY, MAY 28, 2025, 7:30PM
@david_kipping @JannaLevin
pioneerworks.org/programs/scientific-controversies-aliens -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And in other news... Marcelo Gleiser, Evan Thompson and I have started a podcast!
The Blind Spot.
Science, philosophy and more but not the usual reductionist, triumphalist view. New ways of understanding the Universe with us in it.
Episode 1 here.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GXXOl35LA1U&t=974s -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
If you are interested in consciousness and have not gotten @annakaharris Light's On you are missing out.
Lots of VERY interesting conversations on what is and what is not that strange feeling of "what its like to be..." -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
New paper with @lukas_likavcan!
"The Planetary and Its Uses. Grounding Political Economy in an Astrobiological Perspective"
The project combined 2 very different disciplines find 1 path through the anthropocene towards a mature technosphere.
osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/4963w_v1 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The purposeful dismantling of American scientific leadership will be looked back upon as the greatest self-own in history.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This was such a fun conversation with @missmayim. I really enjoyed getting to talk about so many topics in Astrobiology and science (and why most UAP stuff is dubious at best 😀)
Mayim Bialik
@missmayim
Are UAPs real? Is an extraterrestrial sighting even possible on Earth? What are the scientific explanations for alien sightings? Is a human-like civilization possible on another planet?
Astronomer and astrophysicist Adam Frank (@AdamFrank4 - author of Little Book of Aliens) joins Mayim and Jonathan for an MBB Explores to discuss the scientific possibilities of aliens, UFOs and why we all need to be more excited about what recent technological advances are enabling us to discover in space.
For the full conversation, click the ▶️ linktw.in/vhAtQu 🧠💥#bialikbreakdown #mayimbialik #mentalhealthpodcast #podcastThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We already have that technology! It’s how this result was obtained. The point is the next versions of this NASA telescope tech will be even better.
(Unless this admin continues killing US science)
Arham Shajahan
@ShajahanArham
Who knows in next 50 years we might find a technology to identify aliens.
Humans are crazy.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is sooooooooo exciting.
Could go away with more data but it’s exactly the kind of path we’d expect on the road finding life.
www.skyatnightmagazine.com/news/k2-18b-dimethyl-sulfide -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is sooooooooo exciting.
Could go away with more data but it’s exactly the kind of path we’d expect on the road finding life.
www.skyatnightmagazine.com/news/k2-18b-dimethyl-sulfide -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
As Lloyd’s of London CEO John Neal puts it, “You’ll never find an insurer saying ‘I don’t believe in climate change.’”
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
why? That’s really sad. It seemed like our best shot long-term for getting interstellar probes. Obviously very speculative technology, but what are we left with… lighting off nuclear bombs behind a pusher plate?
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
I heard that it has ended
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Does anybody know what’s going on with Breakthrough Starshot?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
New paper "Information bounds production in replicator systems" from our Semantic Information research group. Led by Jordi Pino and @artemyte , it shows how mutual information might be "directly" measured in experiments. @templeton_fdn
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is the link
arxiv.org/abs/2501.00396 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @BigThink piece on the future of the nation-state under the pressures of the Anthropocene. Ideas taken from @berggruenInst and @NoemaMag and the Planetary Summit in Venice.
bigthink.com/the-present/is-new-governance-needed-in-a-po… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
New EXCELLENT Astrobiology textbook by Lingam and Balbi.
Aimed at upper undergrads (or anyone with some math and science training) it is destined to become a standard for the field. I want to teach a course at the UR with it.
@amedeo_balbi -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That is true. He and Varela did more work with it and then Varela continued to refine its logic.
Hermes
@qcsepa
Hello Adam, I really like your work and the interview was amazing. Currently, I'm reading the blind spot.
I have to say that on the podcast you said that autopoiesis was a concept Francisco Varela came up with and that's not true. Humberto Maturana came up with the concept first. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just Google “how complete is the fossil record“ and the answer will be right there. The fossil record is quite incomplete. Most things do not get fossilized. Read the paper by @ClimateOfGavin and myself for more details. There is more work to be done here, however for sure.
Brant Bassam
@BrantBassamPhD
If there was a prior technological civilization on Earth it would leave plenty of evidence, no matter how old. Else they eschewed granite, mass production, and noble metals. Bloody unlikely mate. Even Gorgonopsia left clear fossil evidence over a quarter billion years old and they made no tools or artifacts at all!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is my conversation with @lexfridman on astrobiology, the human future, the physics of life, the nature of consciousness and why The Expanse was the greatest Sci-fi show ever.
It really was big fun!
Lex Fridman
@lexfridman
Here's my conversation with Adam Frank (@adamfrank4), an astrophysicist, all about aliens, alien civilizations, and the search for extraterrestrial life.
It's here on X in full, and is up everywhere else. Links in comment.
Timestamps:
0:00 - Introduction
1:58 - Planet formation
7:08 - Plate tectonics
14:30 - Extinction events
18:41 - Biosphere
21:39 - Technosphere
25:53 - Emergence of intelligence
32:06 - Drake equation
36:20 - Exoplanets
39:04 - Habitable zones
42:06 - Fermi Paradox
51:04 - Alien civilizations
1:00:32 - Colonizing Mars
1:12:48 - Search for aliens
1:29:13 - Alien megastructures
1:35:19 - Kardashev scale
1:40:32 - Detecting aliens
1:47:14 - Warp drives
1:53:21 - Cryogenics
1:56:39 - What aliens look like
2:05:24 - Alien contact
2:16:29 - UFO sightings
2:28:14 - Physics of life
2:54:05 - Nature of time
3:10:29 - Cognition
3:14:53 - MortalityThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hell yeah!
J. P. 🇺🇦
@jpr602
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
About to go on @MSNBC to talk about the Ice Giants and new results on their possibly oceanic interiors.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just gave a talk at the INAF Osservatorio Astrofisico in Florence on our new paper disputing the "Hard Steps" model for the evolution of intelligence.
Lesson: Astrobiology needs deep conversations with domain experts.
arxiv.org/abs/2408.10293
@astrowright -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This summit is an experiment in provoking alternatives to the dominant and yet fading paradigms of world construction. So thankful to be part of it.
Berggruen Institute
@berggruenInst
@AdamFrank4 The most important insight from astrobiology is that life and the planet Earth evolve together. Recognizing that life acts as a geophysical force will reshape our understanding of evolution. #planetarysummit
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The real big bang - the true open question upon which all philosophy and science should turn - is the origin of agency and autonomy. Without self there is no world as without world there is no self.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am so excited to accept the award for a winning @berggrueninstessay at the Planetary Summit Nov 23-24 in Venice, Italy. You can follow the discussions on Planetary-scale challenges via #planetarysummit. and learn more at berggruen.org/projects/planetary-summit
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
By the way
@adamfrank4.bsky.social -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I enjoyed writing this piece and it is still relevant in the week of last weeks UFO hearings.
Aeon Magazine
@aeonmag
To mark the 40th anniversary of the launch of the SETI Institute, we’re revisiting this essay which explores how the search for extraterrestrials went from being considered laughable nonsense to a serious scientific endeavour @AdamFrank4 aeon.co/essays/how-ufos-almost-killed-the-search-for-life… #seti
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @bigthink reaction to the UFO hearings last week.
bigthink.com/13-8/new-ufo-hearings-continue-an-endless-lo… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just did fun @CNN segment with @Boris_Sanchez and @brikeilarcnn about the #ufohearings
Wish I could go to science meeting and claim discovery of alien life cuz ... you know... somebody talked to somebody who knew somebody who'd seen evidence. Done! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My piece on the co-evolution of life / Earth with a focus on the "boring billion". Evolution slowed only to pick up again due to... maybe... plate tectonics.
This came from our work refuting the Hard Steps model led by @DanBMills and @Astro_Wright
arxiv.org/abs/2408.10293
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
About 600 million years ago, evolution was stuck in a rut. Then, suddenly, life on Earth exploded. Recent research suggests that mountains might be responsible, @AdamFrank4 writes. www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2024/11/cambrian-expl…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Our new paper on the famous Daisy-World model (the one that confirmed Gaian feedbacks were possible).
We're beginning an exploration of how planets and life co-evolve from a "semantic information" perspective. Meaning matters as much as matter.
Damian R.S. | Ph.D.
@DRSowinski
Planetary biomes are complex living systems that eat information. Exploring their "Information Architecture" gives us clues as to how. Check out our new preprint with @AdamFrank4 and @Ghoshal_G
arxiv.org/abs/2411.03421 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Demons!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Watch thi. It will make you feel better.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"numerous regimes of the real"
Very cool.
Tom Froese, Embodied Cognitive Science Unit (ECSU)
@DrTomFroese
Oooh! 😮 I found a kindred spirit:
“We do not need a monism – … On the contrary, we need dualisms everywhere – pure differences in nature, without any continuity whatsoever between that which they differentiate, between numerous regimes of the real – matter, life, mind, society, etc.” -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Best day ever!!! I had so much fun with you talking about that first scene shown here when Strange is confronted with the different maps of the human body. Thank you for involving me on this project. It was a superhero movie with stealth philosophical exploration.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very excited to see this and was honored to be part of the discussions. No one brings this challenging issue to people like @annakaharris
Annaka Harris
@annakaharris
LIGHTS ON will be released 03-18-25 and is NOW available for preorder! @MacmillanAudio @susancain @wakingup @Sara_Imari, @bgreene, @AdamFrank4, @JannaLevin, @seanmcarroll, @davideagleman, @anilkseth, @donalddhoffman, @gmusser, @zoeschlanger, @Philip_Goff+ annakaharris.com
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Of course it’s not clear that our kind of intelligence is actually good in the long run.
Ricard Solé
@ricard_sole
How likely is intelligent life? What about evolutionary stagnation? A collective intelligence unable to build tech might dominate a planet. On the other hand, our fossil-rich civilization was possible because life failed to degrade lignin (below). Many what ifs... @AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is our paper on exactly that question
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-…
Ricard Solé
@ricard_sole
This is a good point: is something like planetary-level intelligence possible?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
While I could not go explicitly into the themes of our book "The Blind Spot" in the essay, it's essential point appears through out.
Developing a sustainable Technosphere that persists over even semi-geologic timescales requires a different understanding of life and nature. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thank you. I had great fun writing it and learned a great deal in organizing its argument.
Lauren Wagner
@typewriters
Congratulations, loved the piece!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I am so honored that my essay on "The Planetary" and the human future was chosen as the @berggruenInst winner. I have the most profound respect for @NoemaMag and the work they publish. I loved the writing of the essay and am still amazed it won.
Noema Magazine
@NoemaMag
“Just as Copernicus reimagined the architecture of our solar system five centuries ago, we are once again in a revolution that pivots on planets.”
—@AdamFrank4, inaugural winner of the @berggruenInst Prize Essay Competition
www.noemamag.com/the-coming-second-copernican-revolution/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
One thing I wonder is if LLMs actually model what languages are: sense making tools for the agents who create and use them.
The basis of LLMs in massive statistical prediction means the focus is syntax (impressive as that is) not semantics.
Tom Froese, Embodied Cognitive Science Unit (ECSU)
@DrTomFroese
This is a matter of definition of language, but I’m happy to go along with this distinction.
What I am highlighting is that some things can be modeled well, and some things resist modeling. And I am surprised that language was shifted from the latter to the former category. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This from Steven French's book nails it. In their 1939 "little book" on measurement and quantum mechanics London & Bauer saw exactly how the new theory forced physicists to consider their own role in knowledge construction.
@evantthompson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Working my way though this now. I like that they are looking for ways to combine the insights of embodied cognition with a form of computation (I admit I am always suspicious of pan-computationalism though)
Ricard Solé
@ricard_sole
What is consciousness? What kind of agents can be conscious? What is the role of evolution & embodiment? Are there different levels? The ongoing debate can benefit from the insights of this new paper (great title) by @MiTiBennett @SeanGWelsh @AnnaCiaunica arxiv.org/pdf/2409.14545
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And the Mets are in the playoffs. What a game! That was baseball!
youtu.be/Jfz7gW2Wf3I -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The shiny AI future is built on a mountains of human suffering.
www.noemamag.com/the-human-cost-of-our-ai-driven-future/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That's notable!!!
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
Two big ideas here:
* There are notable eruptions breaking out on the back of the Sun
* We can see through to what's happening on THE FAR SIDE OF THE SUN! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“No object without a subject. No subject without an object!”
say it loud and proud. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Science and Religion or better yet Science and Human Spiritual Endeavor.
My really interesting and engaging conversation with @revdavidperez
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rVE3NurRww -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I did make a mistake on this. I had misread the size of this asteroid and was thinking more generally about the need to map out city killer asteroid populations.
In science always admit when you get things wrong.
Peter Thomas
@ptastro1
Unfortunate that Prof Frank suggested an impact would be “apocalyptic” since 2024 PT5 is only around 10 meters in diameter so an impact would be less energetic than the Chelyabinsk bolide of 2013.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Almost all discussion of science and philosophy (especially "popular" ones) engage with only one stream of western philosophical dialog.
What's missing is the remarkable field of Phenomenology which asks very different questions.
My @bigthink column
bigthink.com/13-8/the-overlooked-philosophy-that-could-sh… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I just want everyone to know that when it comes to quantum gravity, I also have concepts of plans.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Therefore, claims that the studyof intelligence is converging onto computational rationality as itsultimate foundation (see, for instance, Gershman et al., 2015) arenot only premature, but outright misguided.”
Jaeger et al. @yoginho @evantthompson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3 Projects for Sabbatical
1. Semantic Information Theory and Life/Agency
2. Techno/Biosignatures and Life
3). Quantum Mechanics and QBism/Agency
Everything is connected. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
me
Amy Shira Teitel
@AmyShiraTeitel
Who's getting super excited for the @EuropaClipper launch!?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Stunning investigative journalism. I am indeed guilty of having collaborated with my astrophysical colleagues at RIT on the end states of stellar evolution (planetary nebula... so cool).
The link to whatever it is you are going on about is crystal clear. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Just say no to the "Hard Steps Model" :-)
www.arxiv.org/abs/2408.10293
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
New #coolworlds video on why I don't buy the Grabby Aliens Hypothesis
youtu.be/tR1HTNtcYw0 -
Adam Frank reposted
Sandrine Campese
@laplumeapoil
Voici la « Bible » sur la recherche d’une intelligence extraterrestre (ou plutôt devrais-je dire : ses « technosignatures »)👽. Merci à l’astrophysicien @AdamFrank4 pour ce panorama accessible, brillant et amusant et à @dunod_editeur pour la VF.
Je l’ai littéralement dévoré ! -
Adam Frank reposted
Greg Tucker-Kellogg (gtuckerkellogg.bsky.social)
@gtuckerkellogg
He also said he had a question but it was more of a comment
-
Adam Frank reposted
Michael 英泉 Eisen
@mbeisen
New video has emerged of Tim Walz telling a seminar speaker that they gave a "great talk" when in fact they did not.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
he's probably still waiting for the waiter to get back with that drink
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is my piece on @Sara_Imari most excellent new book "Life as No One Knows It". Anyone interested in the physics of life, the origin of life or the possibilities of life beyond Earth should read it.
bigthink.com/13-8/sara-walker/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“Imminent” yeah, sure. Any day now that evidence we’ve been promised fro 70 years is gonna just show up.
I’m a waiting …
still waiting…
hey, still here waiting…
keith kloor
@keithkloor
Thanks, it turns out I did miss it!
Missed opportunity to have someone like @AdamFrank4 or @ScolesSarah, since you often feature journalists/scientists who have deeply researched the topic. (They have recently-related books.)
Anyways...
www.spytalk.co/p/star-drek-ufo-crank-luis-elizondo -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thats lovely. Turns out I’m traveling and reading your wonderful new paper on constraints and living systems.
www.preprints.org/manuscript/202406.0891/v1
Ricard Solé
@ricard_sole
Finally, I'm on vacation with my kids in the woods, reading @AdamFrank4's book about astrobiology and Aliens in a nice place on our Pale Blue Dot.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
"Hard Steps Model" for evolution of "human like" intelligence = standard approach in some quarters of astrobiology. It argues intelligence is rare cosmically.
Its reasoning is deeply flawed.
Dan Mills leads our newly submitted paper
@Astro_Wright
arxiv.org/abs/2408.10293 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Lem was a kind of miracle in himself. Completely singular science fiction writer (except maybe Cordwainer Smith is in the same catagory)
Benjamin Bratton
@bratton
Stanisław Lem from 1977: "Fermi’s paradox is equivalent to the 'absence of cosmic miracles' or the Silentium Universi.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
1) There are two version of the Fermi Paradox that get conflated.
Let's start with the first one which is sometimes called the "Great Silence". This is the idea that we've been doing SETI for 6 decade and have not found anything.
This is wrong.
Benjamin Bratton
@bratton
Go on…
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
6) Here is the paper
ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2019AJ....158..117C/abstract
@caleb_scharf @Astro_Wright
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
7) The other thing about the direct FP is time. When were they here?
@ClimateOfGavin and I showed that if there had been a technological civilization many many millions of years ago we wouldn't know it. Here's an @TheAtlantic piece I did about it.
www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/04/are-we-earths… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
There is no Fermi Paradox!
Benjamin Bratton
@bratton
What are your best answers to the Fermi Paradox? When Lucien was very young, we would play a game called "What if the Aliens are...". We would try to answer the question by presuming the aliens are here but unrecognized. My favorite of his was " what if the aliens are rain?"
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I'm glad you read and enjoyed it!
So the "gaps" thing seems to be that all experience is reducible to scientific explanation. But what we were arguing is that scientific explanation requires experience as the precondition for its possibility. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That's a statement about a philosophy of science which is open to philosophical analysis. Once completed you'll find ontological/epistemic assumptions so wide you a container ship float through :-)
This is what our book the "The Blind Spot" was all about. @evantthompson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Not sure what you mean. Understanding where science runs into it's own unspoken (or unrealized) philosophical assumptions has nothing to do with invoking super-natural causation.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It comes directly Quantum Information science so it's perspective has had some applications. Direct tests ... that is a goal.
Machiel Blok
@MachielSBlok
Pssst, does QBism provide testable hypotheses ;)
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So true. Anyone who says philosophy has nothing to contribute to physics is willfully ignoring the fundamental foundational question QM poses.
(pssst…. And by the way, QBism has one of the best answers.)
Philip Goff
@Philip_Goff
The fascinating thing about quantum mechanics is that it puts philosophy at the core of our scientific understanding of the universe. There is no consensus on what our best scientific theory is telling us about reality. It's a matter of philosophical judgement.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thank you
💙 Hope Restored 💙
@SCoatesMusic
Thank you!
And I just finished your fantastic book: The Little Book of Aliens.
Well-written & very informative! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
We push it on the world in the world pushes back.Both AND neither because you can’t talk about the phenomenon of light without ALSO talking about where the phenomenon appears which is to the measurer.
💙 Hope Restored 💙
@SCoatesMusic
My understanding: It is both…& neither…
Maybe astrophysicist @AdamFrank4 can weigh in! -
Adam Frank reposted
Ash Jogalekar
@curiouswavefn
Freeman Dyson on Hermann Weyl. Among many other seminal contributions to mathematical physics, Weyl introduced the key idea of a gauge which is central to all of particle physics.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
wrong question :-)
Closer To Truth
@CloserToTruth
Does an objective ultimate reality exist?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
OMG!!!
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
OMG this shot.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
John Dunne rocks!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Nice shout out.
TheBookSocial
@TheBookSocial
A Brief Guide to Aliens by @AdamFrank4 featured in @guardian @guardianscience www.theguardian.com/science/article/2024/jul/13/amazing-n… #aliens #extraterrestrial @Lucybookpr
-
Adam Frank reposted
TheBookSocial
@TheBookSocial
A Brief Guide to Aliens by @AdamFrank4 featured in @guardian @guardianscience www.theguardian.com/science/article/2024/jul/13/amazing-n… #aliens #extraterrestrial @Lucybookpr
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The proper unit of life is not the cell but the biosphere.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
The first life never died. Not only did it not die, it bifurcated and generated all of us ... Individuals, and indeed species, are temporary aggregates of information as it persists in our biosphere.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Ok, this…. 😂
George Takei
@GeorgeTakei
“Spock isn’t Vulcan!” — Trump
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Damn, this guy is good.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thank you!
Donatra
@groeblbubble
I'm currently reading Light of the Stars right now. It's absolutely phenomenal!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Been watching "Moneyball". Great baseball movie and one of Brad Pitt's best performances.
And the Mets... the Mets! They producing! -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Well this is nice to see.
BookAuthority
@bookauthority
Congrats @AdamFrank4! Your book "Light of the Stars" is featured in our list of best Space Science books of all time! bookauthority.org/books/best-space-science-books?t=17rd1b…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Opportunity for Mayor! Make New York Mars again. (I should know I grew up there in the 1970s.)
Corey S. Powell
@coreyspowell
If it's the return of Opportunity, I'd vote for that little rover in a heartbeat.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Thank you.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Gaia Theory was hyper-controversial when it was first proposed. Now its basic elements are the core of Earth Systems Science and most researchers recognize its importance. Some thoughts on @ferrisjabr and his new book "Becoming Earth".
bigthink.com/13-8/gaia-theory-the-once-controversial-idea… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Boom!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This looks like fun!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And if you want me to read you the @spectator story on #exoplanets to you before bedtime here is the link.
Start start 5:14
www.spectator.co.uk/podcast/kate-andrews-adam-frank-david… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The planets we don't have in our solar system may be the most exciting as we search for life. My piece for @spectator.
I'm super excited about this topic as it's also part of our efforts at @UofR Center for Matter at Atomic Pressure.
www.spectator.co.uk/article/under-pressure-what-might-lif… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
They all rest on the same problem.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Any proposal for explaining life should be able to simultaneously allow us to solve the origin of life and to identify alien life on other worlds: unifying these is how we transition from pre-paradigmatic science to a new paradigm in the study of what life is.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Triple A ball on a Saturday night in Rochester 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Now all you have to is explain what a wave function is 😀. Hint… it ain’t ontology.
Kording Lab 🦖
@KordingLab
Like yes, the kind of statements that we legitimately make about biology, evo , devo, etc only make sense at a coarse grained level. For hardcore mechanism folks, a biological thing is still, deep down, just a big wave function in an extremely big state space.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wouldn’t it be great if this video required all the knuckleheads posting “Biden is dead” conspiracy theories to relinquish their right to ever voice an opinion in public again.
You would think being that cosmically wrong would have consequences.
Brian Krassenstein
@krassenstein
Joe Biden is Fine
To all those on the right spreading false rumors about Joe Biden being gravely ill or worse, some of whom almost celebrated such misinformation, here is a video recording of President Biden boarding Air Force One just 10 minutes ago.
Please stop believing and sharing everything you hear on social media, especially from sources known for spreading lies and creating chaos. It's important to verify information and rely on credible news outlets. -
Adam Frank reposted
Brian Krassenstein
@krassenstein
Joe Biden is Fine
To all those on the right spreading false rumors about Joe Biden being gravely ill or worse, some of whom almost celebrated such misinformation, here is a video recording of President Biden boarding Air Force One just 10 minutes ago.
Please stop believing and sharing everything you hear on social media, especially from sources known for spreading lies and creating chaos. It's important to verify information and rely on credible news outlets. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Hilarious
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And this is what principled leadership looks like.
Vinod Khosla
@vkhosla
Hard for me to support someone with no values, lies, cheats, rapes, demeans women, hates immigrants like me. He may cut my taxes or reduce some regulation but that is no reason to accept depravity in his personal values. Do you want President who will set back climate by a decade in his first year? Do you want his example for your kids as values?
-
Adam Frank reposted
Vinod Khosla
@vkhosla
Hard for me to support someone with no values, lies, cheats, rapes, demeans women, hates immigrants like me. He may cut my taxes or reduce some regulation but that is no reason to accept depravity in his personal values. Do you want President who will set back climate by a decade in his first year? Do you want his example for your kids as values?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“the new biology entails a demotion in the significance of genes, which now seem more like heritable resources that cells use than they are Watson’s ‘secret of life”
@philipcball
I wish this could get inscribed on the sky for a month or two.
@evantthompson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Roshi Joan for President 2024!!!
Upaya Zen Center
@upayazen
An important message from Roshi Joan Halifax @jhalifax, timeless wisdom from Eihei Dōgen.
Be generous
Speak kindly
Engage in actions that benefit others
And begin to see ourselves in all others, and all others in ourselves.
These are the times we are in. And these are crucial times that we must continue to show up in practice and service for.
Deep bows,
Upaya Zen Center -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Double wow!
Don’t let the news cycle fool you. Your world, your Universe is full of beauty and wonders. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very cool! But where is the Embodied Enactive approach on this. Phenomenology too? What's on this chart are attempts to provide "explanations" but what may be needed instead are methods that seek "accounts" instead. That would be a non-Blind Spot direction I think.
Dr Tevin Naidu
@drtevinnaidu
"A landscape of consciousness: Toward a taxonomy of explanations and implications" by
@RobertLawrKuhn.
Ft. @De_dicto @davidpapineau @davidchalmers42 @CogsAndy @danieldennett @damasiousc @BernardoKastrup @fedefaggin @Philip_Goff @anilkseth @DrTonyNader @evantthompson @donalddhoffman @platobooktour @theamygdaloid @Mark_Solms @patchurchland @yujinnagasawa @StanDehaene @Plinz @BernardJBaars @WiringTheBrain @behaviOrganisms @johnjoemcfadden @alvanoe @TomCampbell_MBT @dr_mcgilchrist @RupertSpira @DeepakChopra @tegmark @RupertSheldrake @carlorovelli @StuartHameroff @Horganism @AdamFrank4 @MGleiser @keithfrankish @StoljarD @PaavoPylkkanen @seanmcarroll @RalphStefanWeir @amykind @davideagleman @DavidDeutschOxf @pgodfreysmith @stephenlaw60 @LKrauss1 @eschwitz @michaelshermer -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It's OK. Your good 😀
barry goldman
@barrygoldman1
oh yeah? what'd I do now?
-
Adam Frank reposted
Satan
@s8n
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
A blue sky and brilliant day-
No more searching around.
“What is Buddha?” you ask.
That’s like hiding loot in your pocket
And declaring you’re innocent. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
On @MSN my OpEd on the search for life in the Universe.
www.msn.com/en-us/news/technology/opinion-science-could-f… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My post from BEFORE our amazing conference on "Information Driven States of Matter". This week I will give an overview of what we learned.
bigthink.com/13-8/a-new-model-for-defining-life-across-th… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is a stunning book. Anyone interested in questions about the nature of reality, the limits of reason, freedom vs determinism and the place of human agency in it all MUST read it.
It’s also beautifully written
@WilliamEgginton @MGleiser -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Counter argument ignores the self-organization which makes life different from a machine. Autopoiesis, causal-closure… lots of different approaches that differentiate machines from organisms.
The machine metaphor is exactly what we meant by the Blind Spot. @evantthompson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Word.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
the emergence of a technosphere is a necessary stage in the reproductive development of any biosphere
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Annnnnnd we’re done! What a fantastic meeting.
Life! Information! What’s the deal?
Now comes the new collaborations, the studies and the experiments.
Big Fun
@templeton_fdn
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Jordi Pinero takes us home with the last talk of the meeting. “information theoretical limits on growth in minimal chemical systems”
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Brains and silicon aren’t the only way to process information #infomatter
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
3rd and last day of our conference on “Information Driven States of Matter”
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
For sure
Prof. Abel Méndez 🔭 🔬
@ProfAbelMendez
"Biosignatures from exoplanets will remain uncertain indications of life. We cannot escape from this. It will be up to the community and the responsible media to make this clear. [And good luck with the media]." www.centauri-dreams.org/2024/06/21/the-ambiguity-of-exopl…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sarah Marzen gets us to think about neural networks
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Bio and Technosignatures require deep methods for false positive determination.
Arvind Hariharan
@arvindh
A probabilistic method cannot be immune to false positives/negatives, no?
-
Adam Frank reposted
Arvind Hariharan
@arvindh
A probabilistic method cannot be immune to false positives/negatives, no?
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Manasvi’s Lingam up next. Life and information in Astrobiology.
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yes! What every biosignature method needs.
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Check out how Earth looks so different #infomatter
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Atmospheric chemical networks! #infomatter
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Day 2. Micheal Wong.
“ Information Driven States of Matter”
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Report on the first day of our “information driven states of matter“ conference at the University of Rochester. #infomatter
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
@ChristophAdami tells us information methods can tell us which molecules have functions in biochemistry #infomatter
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Chemotaxis is INSANE!!!!
The specificity of what evolution achieved to make these microbial agents that can respond these ways is jaw dropping.
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
So again we are dealing with real systems. An informational narrative about life can’t be sterile living only in abstraction. Must have deep experimental support. #infomatter
-
Adam Frank reposted
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Boids in a loop. #infomatter. Prof Alice Quillen
-
Adam Frank reposted
Gourab Ghoshal
@Ghoshal_G
Now Stuart Bartlett talking about Associative Learning in Chemical Networks #infomatter
-
Adam Frank reposted
Gourab Ghoshal
@Ghoshal_G
Alice Quillen starts the afternoon session with a talk on Active Oscillating Matter #infomatter
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Boids in a loop. #infomatter. Prof Alice Quillen
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Next talk Stuart Bartlett. #infomatters
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Yup!!!!
#infomatters -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
“what is life?”
What dies
#infomatters -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Key points
Why information and life
#infomatters -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Matthew Egbert gives us the next talk #infomatter. Agents!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The first talk in our Information-Driven States of Matter. #infomatter
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The schedule for “Information-Driven States of Matter” #infomatter @Ghoshal_G @templeton_fdn
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Getting reading for tomorrow
#infomatter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
First report from our workshop at the University of Rochester on “information driven states of matter“.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is going to be a great week of discussions about the new physics of life.
Gourab Ghoshal
@Ghoshal_G
Very excited to be organizing (with @AdamFrank4 and @artemyte) the workshop on Information Driven Dtates of Matter to be held at @UofR from 07/10-07/12. We have a truly stellar (and international) cast; see details below. Thanks to generous support from @templeton_fdn (1/4)
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
There is no Fermi Paradox! People need to understand this and it will change how we think about the search for life.
INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast
@Into_Impossible
The search for alien life has captivated humanity for centuries. But are we close to finding our cosmic neighbors? 🛸🔭 @briankeating @AdamFrank4
Link 🔗 in reply 👇 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
I’m here … sometimes. Thanks!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Final report on the quantum interpretations meeting (QBism). What does Science in a “participatory “ (John Wheeler’s phrase) look like?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That should be "Participatory Universe"
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Mets on a roll!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Day 3 of the QBism conference. About my talk…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
What physicists and philosophers call "Realism" isn't.
A @bigthink piece on the subject. Relevant to discussions at the QBism Quantum Interpretations meeting I'm at today.
bigthink.com/13-8/realism-idealism-science/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Day 2 of the QBism conference. Does the world have pre-existing properties?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Big Bang is here not then…
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Quantum Mechanics is fundamentally about measurement not wave functions.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Many Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics is not the “most simple” explantation of the quantum formalism. Instead it’s ontologically profligate relying on a deep bias for an impossible Gods-eye view from nowhere.
There are better ways.
bigthink.com/13-8/qbism-simplest-explanation-of-quantum-p… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
First report from the Dartmouth meeting on QBism (Quantum Bayesianism) a radical interpretation of Quantum Mechanics.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
That is a great quote.
umberto tilomelli 🌍🌎🌏🧗🏻♂️
@tilotilo67
The Blond Spot by @AdamFrank4 @MGleiser @evantthompson
Reminds me:
“There is no such thing as philosophy-free science; there is only science whose philosophical baggage is taken on board without examination.”
@danieldennett
~Daniel C. Dennett
2/2 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Quantum mechanics needs interpretation. Fight me!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is a much needed perspective and one we ignore at our own peril.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sweet!
P(David|Kipping) ∝ P(Kipping|David) P(David)
@david_kipping
What if <insert name> is telling the truth about <insert claim>? It’s all a bit pointless to discuss without reproducible evidence.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Very much looking forward to this and the response to the Huffman code critique folks.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Evolution led to systems capable of universal explanation and computation, driven to compress the complex worlds they inhabit. However, compressing descriptions of the world is not even formally equivalent to measuring the selection processes that brought us here.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This morning on @StartHereABC with @TheBradMielke I invented a new astronomical term to describe the maximal alignment of the Earth's rotation axis with its orbital radius vector.
"Solstilicious"
You're welcome.
abcaudio.com/podcasts/start-here/
It's at the end. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Complexity Science is not just a new field of research, it's a new way of thinking about nature. Cutting across disciplinary boundaries like a hot knife through butter, it's going to be the force that shapes the 21st century. My @bigthink piece on it.
bigthink.com/13-8/complexity-science-could-transform-21st… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Sadly Kepler and its ilk don't have the capacity to find technosignatures the way classic SETI did and the way new searches (i.e what will follow JWST) will.
So the stuff in that Hot-tub study really was the full range of technosignature studies.
Heat Miser
@dt432123
Enjoyed the podcast. But I thought the point about the Fermi Paradox was a bit misleading. Maybe SETI searches are only equivalent to a bathtub in an ocean. But shouldn't we also count every other kind of study that would at least hint at something interesting (Kepler, etc)?
-
Adam Frank reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The search for extraterrestrial life has only just begun! 👀
Learn more about the scientific hunt for aliens in my full interview with astrobiologist @AdamFrank4. Link in reply 🔗👇 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It did. Being Science Consultant for Marvel's Doctor Strange was the best gig ever.
Thank you @scottderrickson
Fact of the Day
@randomfacts536
Hey, I just had a quick question. Did this interview here
www.space.com/34604-mind-bending-science-doctor-strange.html
really happen?
Thank you -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Rick Wakeman's Journey to the Center of the Earth was the greatest album ever. Fight Me! 😀
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Holy crap. This mission is insane! The robo-copter is huge (low Titan gravity makes this possible).
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @aeonmag essay on Astrobiology & #ufo culture. Its everything-equals-evidence historical swirly-swirl almost killed SETI more than once.
aeon.co/essays/how-ufos-almost-killed-the-search-for-life…
Important for seeing where we are now as astrobiology defines the cutting edge or astronomy.
#ufotwitter -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Brought to you by lots of caffeine!
I really enjoyed this morning's conversation with @kasie and @cnnthismorning about Earth's amazing and cosmically unusual eclipses.
CNN This Morning with Audie Cornish
@CNNThisMorning
On Monday there will be a total solar eclipse across parts of the U.S.🌕🌑
Astrophysicist @AdamFrank4 tells @kasie what to expect.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
The Little Book of Aliens is a fun, fast tour of everything we know — or may soon know — about life in the Universe.
It’s the perfect holiday gift for that person in your life who is interested in aliens from what’s up with UFOs to the actual science of life and the cosmos. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Everyone has an opinion about aliens, but what’s possible and what’s true from a scientific perspective?
I’ve been an astrophysicist for more than 30 years, and in 2019, I became the Principal Investigator on @NASA's first grant to study technosignatures. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
MIT @ProfSaraSeager is one of the leading exoplanet scientists in the world. Her work has pushed the field forward in multiple ways.
I’m a huge fan so I was very honored that she’d recommend The Little Book of Aliens.
Order your copy today! www.harpercollins.com/products/the-little-book-of-aliens-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
It’s easy to get beaten down by the day-to-day monotony of life, but the world is extraordinary. Science gives us the opportunity to see what wonders we’re a part of.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Is anyone out there? Are we alone in the universe?
I wrote The Little Book of Aliens to help people understand the question as scientists see it, the definitive answers scientists are working to find, and, most amazing of all, how close we are to getting some of those answers. -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And its done! The Little Book of Aliens.
Everything you need to know about everything there is to know about life in the Universe (out there and, you know, maybe but probably not, here).
This week's @bigthink post
#arewealone
bigthink.com/13-8/little-book-aliens-adam-frank/ -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is an excellent point. The performative debates that some folks on social media want to see are simply not how science does it’s work.
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This is a really excellent and really comprehensive look at the militarization of space (and general near future trends in space use/exploration) by @tomcostellonbc and @NBCNews @MSNBC Highly recommended.
Battlefield Space: To The Moon And Beyond youtu.be/4XSgUZMhXK0 -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
My @nytimes OpEd today on UFOs and science and knowing. www.nytimes.com/2021/05/30/opinion/ufo-sightings-report.html
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Can you be scientific and spiritual? That’s the topic of today’s 13.8 post coming out soon. @bigthink
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Here is deal. No one gets to yell about opening the economy without a science plan unless they’ve signed up to volunteer at their local hospital for the next 6 months. In the Covid ward. Do that and then we can talk. #doyourpart
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
If you liked the article, you will love the book. The Blind Spot - being written this year by @evantthompson @MGleiser and me!
Aeon Magazine
@aeonmag
The blind spot of science is the neglect of lived experience. Readers’ favourites 2019: aeon.co/essays/the-blind-spot-of-science-is-the-neglect-o…
@AdamFrank4
@MGleiser
@evantthompson -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
And, if your wondering, in my @nytimes OpEd today on the Fate of the Earth, The term "ecological hooliganism" came from talking with @ClimateOfGavin. I'm using that idea forever.
www.nytimes.com/2018/06/12/opinion/earth-will-survive-we-… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Wonderful @coreyspowell piece on “Silurian Hypothesis”, ancient non-human Earth civilization paper by @ClimateOfGavin and me. This one includes an interview with @jasonwright on space artifacts. Oh, and its got Sleestaks too!
www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/did-another-advanced-species… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Today on NPR. We don't really know how to talk about Death and that’s what the film Into The Night (tonight on PBS) is for. @intothenightdoc
www.npr.org/sections/13.7/2018/03/26/596442228/why-not-ta… -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Tomorrow night!
Into the Night
@intothenightdoc
In case you missed it! Helen Whitney's #conversation about "Into the Night" with the brilliant Michael Krasny @KQEDForum @KQED #documentary @PBS Don't miss the film's PBS national broadcast March 26th 9pm ET!
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This coming Monday. 9 pm PBS
Into the Night
@intothenightdoc
“Just because the cosmic drama is large, doesn’t mean my place in it is any less significant.” -- Adam Frank
View excerpts from the astrophysicist and writer @AdamFrank4's interviews in #intothenight: www.intothenightdoc.com/adam-frank
Full broadcast on @PBS Ma. 26, 9pm ET @wnet @KQED @wgbh -
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Talking with @AdamChodak is always a lot of fun!
Into the Night
@intothenightdoc
The always wonderful @AdamFrank4 talks about Stephen Hawking's legacy, #astrophysics and "Into the Night" @News_8 www.facebook.com/News8WROC/videos/10156826143759386/ #facebooklive #documentary #fascination #conversation
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
This sentence = so not true! "Theoretical and observational evidence suggests we are living in a ... multiverse." nautil.us/issue/49/the-absurd/the-crisis-of-the-multiverse
-
Adam Frank
@AdamFrank4
Today on NPR. "Why Expertise Matters". Or why all opinions aren't equal. Duh. @RadioFreeTom www.npr.org/sections/13.7/2017/04/07/522992390/why-expert…








































































































































