Will cancer be cured in 10 years?
Does an AML vaccine improve survival from 14.7 to 24 months?
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Vinay Kashyap Prasad is an American hematologist-oncologist and health researcher, who served as the director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research from May 2025 to April 2026 at the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). He is a professor of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF), and is the author of the books Ending Medical Reversal (with Adam Cifu, 2015), and Malignant (2020), both from Johns Hopkins University Press. More on Wikipedia
Does an AML vaccine improve survival from 14.7 to 24 months?
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/does-an-aml-vaccine-improve-survival
Will cancer be cured in 10 years?
Lipoprotein (a)
Calley Means' Explosive Revelations
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Perfect summation of recent statin trials in folks over age 70 by @VPrasadMDMPH:
Evidence is consistent that these reduce chanced of CVD complications
Still primary prevention is highly preference sensitive
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/should-a-70year-…
Cornell's bad PR/ Calley Means/ Lp(a)
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Who is more of a problem in medicine today, the cheerleaders or the skeptics? open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/who-is-more-of-a-prob…
A few thoughts on recent interviews by @calleymeans
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Such a good post by @VPrasadMDMPH today!
open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/lpa-talk-about-stone-…
I fact checked @Papa_Heme
"What I find fascinating about dementia articles is that the people who conduct the research, and tout the research, are obviously, by definition, interested in brain function. They want to avoid a failing brain. And yet, by embracing these studies, they reveal a brain that has already failed."
Don't second guess a trial? And other dangerous advice.
AI researchers take up smoking; You can see everything; Moderna hazard ratio
Founder Mode: People who cure their own cancer
8 questions to ask
Phase 1 trials for medical AI
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
During her talk at Rutgers, @TracyBethHoeg highlighted a scandal that has received no media attention. The FDA approved Avacopan (Tavneos) based on manipulated clinical trial data. The drug has been linked to 8 deaths. Just 18 days after Høeg moved to withdraw its approval, she was fired and the drug remains on the market.
🚨 Upcoming Event 🚨
When Scientific Evidence and Political Agendas Collide: Lessons From the COVID-19 Pandemic and the FDA
Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg - physician, epidemiologist, and former FDA drug center head
Tuesday, October 13
1:00–2:30 PM
Waksman Institute, Rutgers University
Terrance Tao's Cancer/AI analogy
Pope Leo's Cancer - 3 possibilities
Pope Leo's lung cancer
Thoughts not reflected in media reports
My review of You Can See Everything
Interview between @AlexBerenson and @VPrasadMDMPH
Can AI 'hack' a cancer phase 3 trial - Terrance Tao Part 2
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
For many drugs understanding of mechanism is limited or much after clinical efficacy is established
@VPrasadMDMPH is right, mechanism helps us feel better & sometimes to iteratively improve but has little impact on uptake if ph3 results are good
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/terrence-tao-does-not-understand
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
A GREAT READ! This pro-con debate on COVID vaccination among pregnant women is outstanding. Data-driven, respectful disagreeent. This is how doctors should properly debate medical topics. open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/the-covid-vaccine-for…
Berenson interviews Prasad
youtu.be/SoOmevpjl1I
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
@dmrind calls out @VPrasadMDMPH for his answer to a frequently asked question and Dr. Prasad responds. Enjoy!
The COVID Vaccine for Pregnant Women www.sensible-med.com/p/the-covid-vaccine-for-pregnant-wom…
"...some people were left out who should have been included. Ed Boyden. Feng Zhang (snubbed also for crispr). The Wayne State University professor who actually did everything first... I forget his name—that’s how bad he was screwed over."
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Two recent cancer drug trials successfully extended patients' lives, but were a reminder that curing most cancers is still out of our reach.
Dr. Vinay Prasad @VPrasadMDMPH takes a deep dive into recent medical advances, and contemplates the “Grand Canyon” between trial efficacy and real-world effectiveness (link in replies)
The primary, pre-specified outcome is negative, but what about this interesting secondary outcome?
Multicancer early detection tests
What we know/ What we don't
Access vs Payment
Are Blood-Based Cancer Screening Tests Ready for Primetime?
www.amjmed.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0002-9343(24)00694-6
What do you think about 95% CI presented for many endpoints/ particularly when alpha is split
Full video on ZD's Youtube
Crossroads
New members on the USPSTF
Congrats @venkmurthy
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Moderna ripped as much as 177% in a day on its melanoma vaccine data. The FDA's former vaccine chief @VPrasadMDMPH says the details that matter are the ones not in the press release.
"Melanoma is a very unique cancer. I think this has not been in the news enough."
"There's a lot of failure in this field of cancer therapeutic vaccines."
"They didn't announce overall survival. They didn't give any numbers, but apparently Merck never gives numbers in their press release. So we'll see."
"Merck is very smart because now whoever gets the shot's gonna have to get the Merck product. They're gonna get Coke and not Pepsi."
Moderna and @Merck today announced positive topline results from the Phase 3 INTerpath-001 trial evaluating adjuvant treatment with intismeran autogene, a novel investigational mRNA-based individualized neoantigen therapy jointly developed by Merck and Moderna, in combination with KEYTRUDA® (pembrolizumab), Merck's anti-PD-1 therapy, in patients with completely resected Stage IIB-IV melanoma.
Read more:
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
High praise from @VPrasadMDMPH
"Venk Murthy— a smart man— joins the team"
"Venk is a great pick"
🙏 👍
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/hiring-specialis…
Fauci did support lockdowns
Fauci on Lockdowns at Georgetown
Will AI kill us all? Cure all cancers?
Non randomized data to settle debates
Will AI engineer a virus that is both highly lethal and highly transmissible? Will it kill us all? And, at least, will it cure all cancer first?
I discuss today
Moderna/ Merck/ Revolution
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Nature's Editorial/ Measles and More
On looksmaxxing and a rare disagreement with @arthurbrooks
Nature's Editorial/ Measles and More
Full interview
www.youtube.com/watch?v=deACJov184I
Just out
10 reasons we don' t have more cancer cures
Beyond the NYTimes
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Safety and efficacy aren't the same thing. And the FDA still struggles with the harder of the two.
Dr. Vinay Prasad, breaking down drug safety like a car:
"When you turn the ignition and the car starts... that's a type of safety. The car didn't detonate."
Efficacy is driving it a few miles down the road.
But real safety — knowing a new heartburn medicine doesn't raise heart attack risk by 4% over the old one — that takes massive, unbiased data.
"That is actually something that the FDA, to this day, struggles with."
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Vinay Prasad: COVID, the FDA, and Why Journalism Keeps Getting Medicine Wrong
Dr. Vinay Prasad joins the Doctors Lounge in a recorded in person conversation that moves from his time at the FDA to bigger questions about evidence, incentives, and trust in medicine. The discussion focuses on how regulatory agencies actually function, why public health debates have become so politicized, and whether the current healthcare funding model rewards good care or just expensive care.
Timestamps:
00:16 - Why the FDA conversation matters now
02:49 - Why Vinay accepted the DC job
04:02 - What can actually change inside the FDA
05:39 - The Exondys approval and commissioner authority
07:22 - Do appointees really steer regulatory decisions?
09:48 - Should the FDA regulate safety or efficacy?
10:31 - Safety, efficacy, and the car analogy
13:04 - Could COVID vaccines have been released earlier?
14:04 - Challenge trials versus large community trials
16:32 - Rolling out vaccines by age and risk
18:05 - Why post COVID myocarditis comparisons are flawed
22:36 - The danger of elite stamped misinformation
24:06 - When medicine became political
26:24 - Why institutions may be too captured to trust
27:24 - The measles death story and missing context
30:17 - Buchanan, Tullock, and the logic of bureaucracy
33:17 - How healthcare swallows trillions with mixed value
35:02 - Why low back surgery is hard to centralize
37:27 - ICD placement and gray zone medicine
39:07 - Who should pay for marginal cancer drugs?
41:10 - Demand subsidies and distorted prices
43:34 - Innovation before large welfare programs
46:53 - Does more money always mean more innovation?
48:48 - Why journalism misses what matters at FDA
51:21 - The No Surprises Act and who really pays
55:42 - Vinay’s broader career path and what comes next
57:34 - Why active clinical practice still matters
Co-Host Handles
@anish_koka and @DrDiGiorgio
Show Handle
@DRsLoungePod
Subscribe Links
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/44vw8eirsKKnjgNIrdDvrR
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-doctors-lounge/id183209…
YouTube: www.youtube.com/@TheDoctorsLoungePod
Dr. DiGiorgio's project "Off Label Ideas"
www.offlabelideas.com
Dr. DiGiorgio's on Substack
substack.com/@drdigiorgio
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Two deaths are a reminder that on vaccines, coercion is no match for trust, writes Dr. Vinay Prasad. www.thefp.com/p/vinay-prasad-measles-pennsylvania-vaccines
Should government fund mRNA vaccines (in 2026)?
Josh Shapiro is in trouble
"Governor, if your goal is not to be dragged down by the extreme wing of your party— remember that also applies to public health, which is one and the same."
Understanding the measles deaths in PA
"A drip-drip-drip strategy for informing the public shreds trust."
www.thefp.com/p/vinay-prasad-measles-pennsylvania-vaccines
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
NEW - Fmr. FDA CBER Director Dr. Vinay Prasad: “Is it the case that kids died of myocarditis from the COVID-19 vaccine? Yes, absolutely it is the case … It was a really bad idea to vaccinate healthy kids for COVID and force them to do it.”
A classic 'natural experiment' where Table 1 shows 2 completely different groups of people...
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Is @sapinker right that although the arts have been captured, the sciences are not yet full of "woke ideologues with contempt for truth, evidence & common sense"?
Is @sapinker right that although the arts have been captured, the sciences are not yet full of "woke ideologues with contempt for truth, evidence & common sense"?
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
What did Vinay Prasad learn inside the FDA? @VPrasadMDMPH talks with @TheAbridgedZach about his controversial tenure at the agency, Fauci’s diaries, and why working for the government made him “a bit more libertarian.” reason.com/podcast/2026/08/26/vinay-prasad-public-health-…
Great to be back on @reason
Check out this interview
www.youtube.com/watch?v=deACJov184I
"Signing the letter feels like asking a kidnapper to keep your child safe. I guess, yes, sure, but what about letting them go? and can we arrest the kidnapper?"
I signed, but I have 3 problems....
Conversation worth your time
.@VPrasadMDMPH sits down for the first time since leaving the Trump administration’s @FDA
The WSJ called him the FDA’s Grim Reaper, he says it’s dishonest. This week we talk about why.
He talks to @Getthecheckpod about Moderna’s shares skyrocketing 170%, what the public doesn’t understand about rare disease drugs, and if he identifies as right wing (the answer might surprise you).
00:00 Introducing Vinay Prasad, the FDA's former vaccine chief
04:19 Vinay’s words are moving public markets (a few times!)
10:25 Society weighing education years vs COVID deaths
12:49 How do you run experiments mid-epidemic
17:32 Do masks work
23:38 The ethics of a medical study
26:34 Does Vinay believe in vaccines
37:58 Can a parent say no to cancer treatment for their child
41:27 Lobbyist money in FDA decisions
49:31 What's the FDA's conflict of interest
49:58 Vinay's controversies: WSJ calls him the grim reaper
53:13 The former FDA vaccine chief on @Kalshi’s clinical trial markets
01:00:08 Why is American healthcare so broken
01:01:19 Peptides
01:05:10 Who do patient advocacy groups represent
01:08:49 Vinay supports universal healthcare?!
Pleasure to appear on @Getthecheckpod
www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzXWX6KiYJI
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Jason Arday, Nathan Cofnas, Cambridge, Ghent, NEJM Voices "They are killing us" and should Universities have their funding cut
Should we ban medical student research?
From 2020
I think @sapinker is asking the right question about science and medicine at universities. I reach a different answer, and support that with 20 points.
Cambridge is the Villain in the story
Jason Arday, Nicholas Cofras, Cambridge, Ghent, NEJM and why we should stop funding Universities
youtu.be/lW204fzHcIc
Jason Arday, Nathan Cofnas, Cambridge, Ghent, NEJM Voices "They are killing us" and should Universities have their funding cut
The New England Journal publishes an article about Jason Arday with astonishing woke claims & more
Today's post
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Watch now | The Fauci diaries expose a stark gap between what Anthony Fauci said publicly—and what he really believed. www.thefp.com/p/vinay-prasad-reckoning-anthony-fauci?taid…
Should the elderly take a statin?
Should we run a new randomized trial that costs 90 million dollars?
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is a must watch from @VPrasadMDMPH. It’s ostensibly about an OSHU heart case where the mitral valve was implanted upside down, but it goes much deeper to explain groupthink and anchoring as common causes of serious medical error. Way too often, incorrect information is written in the chart then passed on and on and on. A huge source of risk to patients. Learn to spot this and you will save lives. youtu.be/hDfhIIr8yDA
"I haven't seen doctors this angry since they were called providers"
What if Fauci retired at 78?
Red Flags
Biologic evidence vs intelligence
We already allow betting on some clinical trials; Is Kalshi different?
Covid Czar says it was lab leak
Fauci Diary
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Another three opinions!
open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/name-an-article-that-…
Lab leak and who is responsible politicians or scientists
A loophole for bribery
Who is accountable: political leaders or the scientists who advise them?
Anthony Fauci
White House Covid Czar Says He thinks it was Lab Leak
Fauci's error
Anthony Fauci
Fauci's diary and pleading the fifth: a balanced perspective www.youtube.com/watch?v=oRj_aORF-v8
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I am totally, really completely, biased here, but this is a great series. I only hope everyone else learns as much from the conversations as I did.
How Not To Get Fooled by the Medical Literature open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/how-not-to-get-fooled…
Does the Shingles Vaccine Reduce Dementia?
What sport is safe enough for your kid to play?
The AHA guidelines on coffee and heart disease
Caloric restriction in monkeys-- low value, cruel, animal research
The literature that Shingles vaccine reduces dementia is extremely poor, and almost surely wrong-- it is disappointing how badly the media has covered this topic. I covered this last month
Does the (live) shingles vaccine protect against dementia? We provide important evidence in a new preprint using hospital data from the whole of England in a regression discontinuity design where we *don't* show strong evidence of a causal effect +
AHA Coffee and the Heart Guidelines
1 Useful randomized trial
6 Uninteresting ones
40 Unreliable observational studies
youtu.be/Hf0j9p98d6U
A new AHA scientific statement says up to 5 cups is good for the heart. That is not good science. I explain here.
Here is what they should say
Extreme public health advice
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med
Our second 9 part series on How Not to Be Fooled by the Medical Literature
@adamcifu @drjohnm
@Sensible__Med today
"Don't eat fresh produce" and other ridiculous public health advice
Extreme public health advice around cyclosporiasis
youtu.be/za5WEZJB20o
Extreme public health advice
Today on @Sensible__Med we (@drjohnm @DrJMarine ) consider a recent @nature paper that uses AI to identify patients who should have an ICD placed.
We have 5 considerations 🧵
1. You have to find shockable arrhythmias. authors train AI using sudden cardiac death on a death certificate. But that includes non shockable VT, such as MI presenting with VT and death (often cant be saved with shock alone). The authors link their algorithm to VT but this still leaves this problem open of whether the VT is de novo
5. In order for the algorithm to save lives, people identified by the algorithm can't develop an ICD indication (and get one) later. You don't save lives if you would have identified the person for ICD later in course of illness, but before SCD.
learn more here
www.sensible-med.com/p/5-considerations-for-a-new-nature
Should you get a CAC scan, Echo, BP check, eat fatty fish?
My review of Theo Baker's book: How to Rule the World
AKA - how much fraud is there in science
What can medicine learn from the World Cup?
When doctors say "I have seen it work"
Is that evidence based?
learn more today on @Sensible__Med
SSRIs for 40+ years according to JAMA?
Three real clinical questions submitted to AI
Three real questions submitted to AI
youtu.be/trPqbi6IntE
How do we measure progress in oncology?
Re-analyzing a viral post and graphic
"There is no canonical “right” answer to many, perhaps most, questions in medicine; instead there are many wrong answers and a shorter list of defensible choices."
"Perhaps the right question is the existential question. Wake up doctor— are you sure this patient needs more chemo?... As a wise oncologist told me... “It is easy to give more chemo, it is hard to be honest.”
"AI is wonderful, but AI can’t jump out of the screen and ask you all these things. AI can’t lay hands on the patient and look them in the face. And touch their legs, and listen to their heart and lungs."
Is AI better at reading EKGs than your doctor?
A new NY Times story and Nature Medicine paper unpacked
I review Theo Baker's book: How to Rule the World
Thoughts on Science, Stanford's Former President, and more.... (link in replies)
Thoughts on Midjourney (link in replies)
3 universal lessons about medical error
Shingles vaccine(s) and dementia: the only medical intervention to work faster than Tums
Do you believe in magic? (link below)
Thoughts on a recent @jamaim paper
If you want to read my publications, there are 3 places.
This website will allow you to search by thematic area
profiles.ucsf.edu/vinayak.prasad
This will allow you to search by citations
scholar.google.com/citations?user=ym4rwk0AAAAJ&hl=en
And this should have free links to all the papers
www.vkprasadlab.com/publications
Some of my most popular educational videos
thread
www.youtube.com/watch?v=W5tDrP2mGLA
Some of my most popular writing on medicine
www.sensible-med.com/p/eulogy-versus-resume-virtues
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/when-the-patient-is-in-the-room-stop
Some of my most popular reviews of books/ film
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/book-4-the-story-of-the-lost-child
My latest is a film review that is worth your time
Everything Marty says is spot on in this clip.
Dr. Marty Makary is Calling for More Data Before Approving More COVID Shots
“Should a 12-year-old, thin, healthy girl get a seventh Covid shot this year? I don't know the answer to that because we don't have good clinical data. We can get that data.”
Our new paper is out now!
Fact check: false.
It's a cruel practice with poor human predictive value that tortures animals with little to show for it.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
‘Does the routine application of a (new) diagnostic test improve health outcomes?’
I suppose lay folk don’t ask since vivid anecdotes of results are conflated with definitive proof. Perhaps, clinicians are immune to the availability heuristic :)
Lecture 1 of our 9 part series is out now on @Sensible__Med
All the other parts will come every other week and available to subscribers
This is the best course on critical appraisal you will ever see
@adamcifu @drjohnm
Subscribe now!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Awesome to see this topic being discussed. Critical appriasal of studies is one of the most important skills in modern practice. We learn too much if X do Y in medicine. My best teachers could cite the literature from memory, knew all the studies in detail, and taught me what applied to which patients.
Episode 1 of our 9 part series is out!!
@Sensible__Med
Lecture 1 of our 9 part series is out now on @Sensible__Med
All the other parts will come every other week and available to subscribers
This is the best course on critical appraisal you will ever see
@adamcifu @drjohnm
Subscribe now!
Vivek took a few hundred k from Netflix, Carnival cruises and Airb&b and pushed harmful COVID policy that destroyed a generation of kids. Somehow I missed the NEJM perspective on all that.
The current crisis in the United States is bigger than politics, and it deeply affects the health and lives of our patients and communities, argue the authors of a new Perspective. Now is the time for physicians to harness their power and act. Read the Perspective by Alice T. Chen, MD (@atychen), and @vivek_murthy, MD, MBA: www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2502493
Big win for @DrJBhattacharya
Finally a policy that's fair to tax payers!
NIH Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya has announced that the NIH Public Access Policy, originally slated to go into effect on 12/31/25 will now be effective 7/1/25. Read more in his statement: www.nih.gov/about-nih/who-we-are/nih-director/statements/…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
PRICELESS!!!
NEJM literally is in the business of commissioning tik tok videos to distill their research into as little scientific detail as humanly possible
Scientific papers funded by NIH will publish online for free at the same time as in paywalled scientific journals. The grift of charging people to read the results of studies they already paid for is over. Interesting to read which journals lobbied against this: The trade group for JAMA; NEJM; Elsevier.
NIH Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya has announced that the NIH Public Access Policy, originally slated to go into effect on 12/31/25 will now be effective 7/1/25. Read more in his statement: www.nih.gov/about-nih/who-we-are/nih-director/statements/…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Scientific papers funded by NIH will publish online for free at the same time as in paywalled scientific journals. The grift of charging people to read the results of studies they already paid for is over. Interesting to read which journals lobbied against this: The trade group for JAMA; NEJM; Elsevier.
NIH Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya has announced that the NIH Public Access Policy, originally slated to go into effect on 12/31/25 will now be effective 7/1/25. Read more in his statement: www.nih.gov/about-nih/who-we-are/nih-director/statements/…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Definitely worth reading this-Good advice...
Probably one of my most important essays
In an era of complete media bias, 6 things you can do as a reader to try to get the truth
Probably one of my most important essays
In an era of complete media bias, 6 things you can do as a reader to try to get the truth
Just a reminder that complete and total incompetence gets rewarded
There is no balance at universities. They lost the plot and the trust of the American people, deservedly.
Wow. First, the statistic he cites is implausibly large (bs model)
Second he lied about the origin, masking, distancing, and silenced lockdown opponents. He did nothing of value during the pandemic. Could have been replaced with a mannequin and we would have had better outcomes
"When you mix politics and science, you just get politics."
Former NIH director Francis Collins talks about the effects of polarization and misinformation on public health:
What did I say..
Step 1. Garber 'fights' Trump so Harvard woke studs/faculty don't revolt
Step 2. Start and intensity layoffs to soften the wokesters resolve
Step 3. Start to capitulate
Step 4. Capitulate fully
Step 5. Garber remains in power.
Episode 1 of our 9 part series is out!!
@Sensible__Med
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Francis Collins with his colleague Fauci failed when it mattered most, during the biggest medical science crisis in our lifetimes, and shares responsible for the loss of trust and credibility of science. Yet, still pontificating.😔
The former NIH director Francis Collins tells @JeffreyGoldberg he fears the U.S. is losing a generation of scientists.
“We have depended so heavily on being the place that everybody wanted to come to to do research," Collins says. "And now we’re driving those people away.”
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"Folks who think COVID-19 vaccines should continue to roll out without randomized trials are anti-vaccine, anti-science, and pro-corporate." - Dr. @VPrasadMDMPH
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/5-reasons-why-the-covid-19-vaccine
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Pro tip for navigating Med Twitter: if an MD or PhD has retweeted Eric Topol, run. That’s not a red flag — that’s a siren. 🚨
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Must to watch by oncologist and non oncologist ( industry and analysts) both.
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med
Is there a rule that says the Atlantic cannot ask him tough questions. Why won't the Atlantic have him debate anyone?
"When you mix politics and science, you just get politics."
Former NIH director Francis Collins talks about the effects of polarization and misinformation on public health:
Marty is right.
Finding cancer, even interval cancer, does not mean you make people better off. You have to find cancer that isn't over diagnosis, hasn't spread already, and is only curable today not tomorrow. The quality of these studies is abysmal. Check out my podcast on AI in healthcare.
Performance of Two Deep Learning-based #ai Models for Breast Cancer Detection and Localization on Screening Mammograms from BreastScreen Norway doi.org/10.1148/ryai.240039 @AACR #aacr25 #aacr2025 #cancer #oncorad #oncology
See also www.drvinayprasad.com/p/francis-collins-retires-from-the
The former NIH director Francis Collins attributes "tens of millions" of saved lives to the efforts of Anthony Fauci over the course of his career.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins caused a pandemic that killed 20+ million and cost $25+trillion...and they did so by repeatedly and flagrantly violating US-government policies implemented to protect the public from lab-generated pandemics.
They need to be held accountable.
The former NIH director Francis Collins attributes "tens of millions" of saved lives to the efforts of Anthony Fauci over the course of his career.
Finding cancer, even interval cancer, does not mean you make people better off. You have to find cancer that isn't over diagnosis, hasn't spread already, and is only curable today not tomorrow. The quality of these studies is abysmal. Check out my podcast on AI in healthcare.
Performance of Two Deep Learning-based #ai Models for Breast Cancer Detection and Localization on Screening Mammograms from BreastScreen Norway doi.org/10.1148/ryai.240039 @AACR #aacr25 #aacr2025 #cancer #oncorad #oncology
It's strange to see CBS take such an anti science stance. Disappointing and dishonest article.
Some news from @MajorCBS's intv of @DrMakaryFDA
- sounds like @US_FDA now looking at whether will still approve updates to COVID shots for next winter
- "really excited" to have @TracyBethHoeg in process, when asked about her role in @Novavax approval
www.cbsnews.com/news/fda-covid-booster-shots-marty-makary/
Another California failure. Newsom's kids are in private school so he doesn't care.
The state is spending $500M on electric buses while rural schools have sinkholes in bathrooms, no running water and power failures.🫠
Thanks @GavinNewsom! 🙄
New @nih policy. These programs engaged in such dubious activities. Every faculty member has stories. It was clearly illegal.
Just when I thought medical journals had hit rock bottom, they want to wade into this debate 🤣
Call to End Daylight Saving Time: Implications for Public Health
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2833363 via @kimdavidmd et al
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
“Other nations do not give COVID shots annually to all babies over 6 months old. This is not the practice across Europe. It is hard to fully capture just how absurd such a policy is. Taking the lowest risk individuals in a society and exposing them to an absolutely unproven, injected novel medical product. Under Joe Biden, America was a demented outlier.” - @VPrasadMDMPH
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med
🤔
This article bothered me so much because of its' basic errors of fact and logic, I have written a rebuttal. Make sure accurate messaging prevails over the fearmongering by RT'ing widely
I just want to point out how dishonest this article is
COVID-19 cases rise at several time points in the year
Thus, trials can be run in the air-conditioner season well in time for the fall season
Not wanting trials to see if these products work is anti-vax, anti-science, pro-corporate propaganda
Can contrast with influenza
Explained here
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/5-reasons-why-the-covid-19-vaccine
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Not wanting trials to see if these products work is anti-vax, anti-science, pro-corporate propaganda
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med
A 9 part series on how to read and appraise evidence
Or... How @adamcifu, @drjohnm and I spent 9 hours on a Saturday
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
EXCLUSIVE: The Trump administration just launched multiple probes of Harvard University and the Harvard Law Review, citing allegations that the flagship law journal discriminates based on race.
The Education Department and HHS will each conduct separate investigations.🧵
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Critical appraisal, a must-have skill to prevent being fooled by misleading information. Evidence-based medicine is the best medicine to practice. The quality of the evidence matters. I can't wait to learn from this dynamic team! 👌🔬🩺
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med a 9+ part video series on critical appraisal called How Not To Get Fooled by the Medical Literature. Taught by @adamcifu @drjohnm and me.
We think it will be the single best resource to improve your EBM skills
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I cannot wait to watch these!
@Sensible__Med @drjohnm @adamcifu @VPrasadMDMPH
Just finished a weekend together recording these. They are so much fun. I learned a ton and we had some great conversations about the content—all captured on video. We can’t wait to share.
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med a 9+ part video series on critical appraisal called How Not To Get Fooled by the Medical Literature. Taught by @adamcifu @drjohnm and me.
We think it will be the single best resource to improve your EBM skills
Yes. We have been advocating for this for years. escholarship.org/uc/item/9rn4n0x9
Nice slide to show Benifit of IO in dMMR pts across the Tumor types
Check the different magnitude of benifit across different tumors types .
All dMMR are not same. @OncoAlert
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
There is a mass psyop happening.
This drug has not been subject to a clinical test.
The FDA is asking for science - for the drug to be tested before it is recommended.
Apparently conducting science qualifies as “anti-vax” at this point.
The “experts” have lost their minds.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Among the reasons this is nauseating: Last night’s episode featured a segment on NIH cuts that did not mention NIH’s connection to the Wuhan Institute of Virology, Francis Collins’ role in the coverup, and the fact that the likely lab-born pandemic was a boon to its advertiser.
60 Minutes directly calls out its parent company, Paramount, following the resignation of executive producer Bill Owens
It's important to remember that the professor's most prominent paper of the last 5 years was completely false. The media pushed it because they lack critical appraisal skills and liked the politics of the paper.
Nice to see Jama onc viewpoint critical of social media biases cite two of our papers documenting how ASCO features voices tweet more selfies and photos than thoughts about science and how conflicted docs rarely tweet criticism, even when trials totally flawed
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Just finished a weekend together recording these. They are so much fun. I learned a ton and we had some great conversations about the content—all captured on video. We can’t wait to share.
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med a 9+ part video series on critical appraisal called How Not To Get Fooled by the Medical Literature. Taught by @adamcifu @drjohnm and me.
We think it will be the single best resource to improve your EBM skills
Coming soon to @Sensible__Med a 9+ part video series on critical appraisal called How Not To Get Fooled by the Medical Literature. Taught by @adamcifu @drjohnm and me.
We think it will be the single best resource to improve your EBM skills
Marty is absolutely correct. New products require new clinical trials. The American people aren't research subjects for an uncontrolled experiment.
FTR: there is no question if NEJM is politically biased against Rs: it is! On @Sensible__Med a week ago, I document how bad it has gotten. (see reply for link)
NEJM, JAMA, Lancet, Nature, Science (tnx Holden) are devoid of alternative points of view
In my essay, I am not arguing against publishing ultra left wing ideas, I am arguing against exclusively publishing those perspectives
After NEJM published a pro-kids masking paper, we tried to reproduce it. We found it fell apart like a sand-castle. NEJM refused to publish the correct analysis, we had to go to annals
www.acpjournals.org/doi/full/10.7326/M23-2907
It's not just journals @medrxivpreprint which is funded by @ChanZuckerberg is also hopelessly biased. It has repeatedly suppressed truthful science that does not fit the left wing narrative
www.sensible-med.com/p/preprint-servers-have-repeatedly
I've made all 540+ publications from @vkprasadlab freely available on this website in accordance with grant and university policies. Please check it out for PDFs of 15 years of our work. Email us (via the website) if something is missing or incorrect.
www.vkprasadlab.com/publications
Appreciate the 16,000 citations to date, and glad these papers have allowed others to extend the methods in different ways, and confirm many of our findings.
Very sad. Entirely predictable.
Dutch researchers 👇
“The researchers found the children who grew up during the pandemic were unable to distinguish between a frightened and a happy face. Happy faces were particularly difficult to process, Van Boomen said.”
This is false. All through the spring of 2020, Fauci lobbied against desantis. He wanted impossible standards to be met for schools to reopen. He kept chanting MIS-C, which was completely overblown. The New York Times continued to fearmonger about risks to kids. We have even analyzed corrections to their news stories, demonstrating the bias. The CDC's statistics were erroneous. In short, I disagree with Matt's take below.
My tweet is so true that they won't even say WMD anymore. They say, we never said to go into Iraq
School closure is like the Iraq war
Didn't make us safer
We embarked on it due to inaccurate info
Millions of children were harmed
Public sentiment will shift
Many will on the wrong side of history
It was a mistake
The Washington Post on July 23, 2020.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is very misleading.
Among other limitations, the study was only of kids who had covid *and* interacted with the healthcare system. It's a completely skewed sample. Obviously those kids are different from kids––the vast majority––who had Covid and didn't get medical care.
“Here we show that children and adolescents with prior SARS-CoV-2 infection are at a statistically significant increased risk of various cardiovascular outcomes, including hypertension, ventricular arrhythmias, myocarditis, heart failure, cardiomyopathy…” www.nature.com/articles/s41467-025-56284-0
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Piano teacher: "Your son is playing too much at home, please have him practice less; what's the rush?"
Soccer coach: "Your son is dribbling too much at home, please have him practice less; what's the rush?"
Math teacher: "Your son is learning too much math at home, please slow down; what's the rush?"
Two of these things would *never* happen. The third is commonly heard.
Why does our culture allow it? (And what can we, politely, do to counter it? Besides ignoring the "advice"...)
Live now!
youtube.com/live/No3lai5qYMw
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Insightful perspective from @VPrasadMDMPH - similar process likely happening in CV medicine and other fields with loosening standards of endpoints in clinical trials. May be leading to more expense on drugs/devices of marginal efficacy without benefit to population health. @drjohnm @AndrewFoy82 @US_FDA @DrMakaryFDA
Now out @NatRevClinOncol
🤔
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
. . .
DeepMind CEO believes all diseases will be cured in about 10 years
ACCELERATE
Of course, Jay is right. There are lots of ways to advance the health of minority patients, but current dei is not that. It's poster after poster of garbage buzzwords that help no one besides the authors. Like the debunked PNAS White docs kill black babies paper
NIH director calls Trump’s anti-DEI orders ‘misunderstood,’ downplays reorganization plans
www.statnews.com/2025/04/21/nih-director-jay-bhattacharya…
Smoking cessation is the big win
Prostate cancer screening is the big loss; It doesn't improve all cause mortality & makes more men impotent & incontinent
There are also concerning trends for pancreas and stomach and throat and liver that warrant exploration
Now out @NatRevClinOncol
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I have complete confidence in @DrMakaryFDA’s leadership to return @US_FDA to its rightful role—as an independent, ethical, and radically transparent agency. The American people deserve a regulatory body free from corporate influence and perverse incentives that have compromised its mission for far too long.
Under @DrMakaryFDA’s leadership, the FDA is taking bold steps to restore public trust – removing pharma conflicts on advisory committees, refocusing on root causes of chronic disease, and charting a path back to gold-standard science.
AI will beat the world's most incompetent doctor
For the first time, I truly believe AI might replace doctors.
I felt dizzy every morning when standing up from bed, and even worse after moving to a hill in SF, the dizziness hit me every time I climbed.
Visited my primary care doctor twice; both times, they said it's normal, just exercise more. I assumed I was just getting older and perhaps overworking.
Out of curiosity, I asked ChatGPT. It said the symptoms could be "orthostatic hypotension" and recommended electrolyte water. Skeptical, but I tried it anyway.
Amazingly, the dizziness vanished after just two drinks. It's been weeks, and I've been totally fine.
I feel kind of dumb for not asking ChatGPT earlier, the problem has troubled me for over 1 year!
From now on, I'll be saying "thank you" to AI a lot more often.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Winning
Christopher Rufo, Richard Hanania, and Bari Weiss likened themselves to dissidents against a woke elite, but now anti-woke ideology is official U.S. government policy. nymag.com/intelligencer/article/anti-woke-christopher-ruf…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Maybe if you didn’t lie about Covid people would listen to you
🚨 HOTEZ: “I'm really concerned that [RFK Jr] is so fixed on these false links between vaccines and autism … that this is going to jeopardize our entire vaccine ecosystem … We may have another coronavirus illness coming online.”
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Honesty at last
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
What if it were the other way around: Universities were overwhelmingly conservative and shut down liberal ideas & faculty for years www.sensible-med.com/p/what-if-it-were-the-other-way-arou…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
SCOOP: Fauci misled Congress about the date of his government retirement, new docs show.
He said he retired in December 2022, right as the GOP was poised to control investigative committees. In fact he retired in January 2023, overlapping with new Congress, which could have subpoenaed him as the head of NIAID.
What he is saying about corruption is so spot on. Former CDER director is now CMO at Pfizer. It's disgusting
.@DrMakaryFDA: “I cannot tell you how many lobbyists, former members of Congress - The Swamp - reached out to me. I was in the operating room, and the next day I discovered what The Swamp was... This is how it happens: ‘We want to help you with your confirmation. We want to write a letter on behalf of our company to the senators on your committee. We know these senators, we’re going to talk to them, if it’s okay with you.' You know what I said? ‘Don’t talk to the senators. I don’t want your letters. They’re not for free.’”
FULL show:
youtu.be/R4mojSYOTnQ
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Vinay asks the very essential question.
Great piece
As a pro school person, I faced nothing but headwinds in 20/21/22 and interestingly colleagues who were experts in child development said nothing, while taking NIH $
Why do we fund universities if they are cowards and sheep when it matters?
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2025/04/school-closure…
Great move!
MAKARY: "Today we are announcing we are removing pharma members from FDA advisory committees ... We are going to be inviting pharma companies to send representatives to the advisory committees, but they can sit with the rest of the public and watch and pose questions"
🎥 @MartyMakary @megynkelly
+1 million
- 2000 million
Good thing Harvard now offers remedial math!
In the 24 hours after Harvard President Alan Garber announced that he would not comply with the White House, Harvard received more than $1 million in online donations, according to a person familiar with the matter.
@dhruvtkpatel & @graceunkyoon report.
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/18/garber-trump-harvard…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
FAVORITE NOVELS OF THE 21st CENTURY
1. Philipp Meyer, THE SON
2. Roberto Bolaño, 2666
3. Denis Johnson, TREE OF SMOKE
4. Helen DeWitt, THE LAST SAMURAI
5. Peter Carey, PARROT & OLIVIER IN AMERICA
6. Benjamín Labatut, WHEN WE CEASE TO UNDERSTAND THE WORLD
Do you have a list of favorite books of the 21st century?
Do you have a list of favorite books of the 21st century?
One journal takes 20% of ghost written reviews. What a disaster!
What is going on at Harvard? What will happen?
Thesis: Garber has to navigate this so that he doesn't get himself fired, and eventually agrees to Trump's terms.
Prediction: First he has to show that he's going to fight like hell. Lots of rhetoric, and litigation. Then he has to gradually change the views of the woke people he governs. To do this, you start with some layoffs. And then gradually those layoffs deepen. Eventually the morale will shift, and the people below you will also support some capitulation. That's when you capitulate, but with negotiation, so that you save face. And eliminate any internal inconsistencies in the requirements. And try to make deliverables more objective.
Challenge: Harvard has no leverage over Trump in any way shape or form.
Challenge 2: Universities have pissed away any support from average Americans.
Endgame: Garber still Harvard president, still respected by most faculty, and Trump demands largely met. The ultimate test of a president of a university's political skill. Columbia university's president completely misjudged the challenge, and agreed to all the demands, getting herself fired.
BREAKING: HMS leadership told employees an hour ago that layoffs and program cuts were impending as a result of the White House's recent actions including a $2.2 billion freeze.
SCOOP in @thecrimson w/ @avaniiiirai
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/16/trump-hms-cuts/
Great piece
As a pro school person, I faced nothing but headwinds in 20/21/22 and interestingly colleagues who were experts in child development said nothing, while taking NIH $
Why do we fund universities if they are cowards and sheep when it matters?
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2025/04/school-closure…
Indeed
As a pediatrician, it is difficult to communicate the extent to which adding yearly COVID boosters to the recommended childhood vaccine schedule damaged many parents’ trust in the rest of the schedule. It increased vaccine hesitancy to a degree I have not seen in over 20 years of practice. @CDCgov
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Holy smokes, @SarahHuckabee signed the bill that bans PBMs from owning pharmacies, gutting one of the most significant conflicts of interest that permeates the prescription drug supply chain. Wow.
www.statnews.com/pharmalot/2025/04/16/pbm-cvs-unitedhealt…
Just a reminder, the PNAS paper on infant mortality was cited by the KBJ of supreme court
It was totally flawed at outset. Attribution a disaster
When they re-analyzed adjusting for birth weight it collapsed
Basically, the lowest form of scholarship used as propaganda
SCOOP: Star researcher behind an infamous infant mortality study is OUT and her academic antiracism center is in jeopardy amid plagiarism charges
We cure some. For others, we extend how long & how well they live, and for others we provide comfort and advise in a moment where it is needed. Sometimes you know that if it weren't you that day, things would have played out differently, far worse. So yes, it is an honor and a great job and what medicine should be about, but which too often falls short of. In contrast, there are fields where outcomes are often great. Usually there is rampant over treatment and over diagnosis there, but no one seems to care or notice.
Amen! In 10 years, I don't think I have gone a single week without fielding some question/ phone call/ etc. Time zones do not apply/ often woken up at night around the world. But also why the job is wonderful. You are not replaceable. Judgement varies & AI can go to hell.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Pretty logical behavior. He will eventually fold to "save" jobs. His critics from Harvard will be silenced after they face possibility of losing job. As a result he will save face, but will concede.
Yes. People who choose to get vaccinated also test differently than people who don't. So I cannot draw firm conclusions from the study. As we published elsewhere, the evidence for the annual flu vaccine is extremely poor, and test negative case control has variable effectiveness. But this is a poor methodology. There are better analyses by Cochrane, but these span products. With my colleagues we have suggested improved methods in this space. Everyone should support those better methods.
Unrelated, but have you had a chance to look at that healthcare worker flu vaccine study? Always appreciate your analysis.
Thesis: Garber has to navigate this so that he doesn't get himself fired, and eventually agrees to Trump's terms.
Prediction: First he has to show that he's going to fight like hell. Lots of rhetoric, and litigation. Then he has to gradually change the views of the woke people he governs. To do this, you start with some layoffs. And then gradually those layoffs deepen. Eventually the morale will shift, and the people below you will also support some capitulation. That's when you capitulate, but with negotiation, so that you save face. And eliminate any internal inconsistencies in the requirements. And try to make deliverables more objective.
Challenge: Harvard has no leverage over Trump in any way shape or form.
Challenge 2: Universities have pissed away any support from average Americans.
Endgame: Garber still Harvard president, still respected by most faculty, and Trump demands largely met. The ultimate test of a president of a university's political skill. Columbia university's president completely misjudged the challenge, and agreed to all the demands, getting herself fired.
BREAKING: HMS leadership told employees an hour ago that layoffs and program cuts were impending as a result of the White House's recent actions including a $2.2 billion freeze.
SCOOP in @thecrimson w/ @avaniiiirai
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/16/trump-hms-cuts/
He's going to pull their tax exempt status.
Everyone knows that Harvard has “lost its way.” They hired, from New York (Bill D) and Chicago (Lori L), at ridiculously high salaries/fees, two of the WORST and MOST INCOMPETENT mayors in the history of our Country, to “teach” municipal management and government. These two Radical Left fools left behind two cities that will take years to recover from their incompetence and evil. Harvard has been hiring almost all woke, Radical Left, idiots and “birdbrains” who are only capable of teaching FAILURE to students and so-called “future leaders.” Look just to the recent past at their plagiarizing President, who so greatly embarrassed Harvard before the United States States Congress. When it got so bad that they just couldn’t take it anymore, they moved this grossly inept woman into another position, teaching, rather than firing her ON THE SPOT. Since then much else has been found out about her, but she remains in place. Many others, like these Leftist dopes, are teaching at Harvard, and because of that, Harvard can no longer be considered even a decent place of learning, and should not be considered on any list of the World’s Great Universities or Colleges. Harvard is a JOKE, teaches Hate and Stupidity, and should no longer receive Federal Funds. Thank you for your attention to this matter!
From Donald Trump Truth Social 04/16/25 07:05 AM
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"The Wizard of Oz Revealed" >>> www.sensible-med.com/p/i-learned-about-medicine-from-that… In @Sensible__Med I add to @VPrasadMDMPH's "I Learned About Medicine From That" series by telling the story about how I first learned how evidence-based medicine and public health actually work, and how that insight began with working in the tobacco fields and watching television:
Indeed
www.sensible-med.com/p/does-the-shingles-vaccine-stop-dem…
It's sad that this study is getting promoted so much when it was clearly identified as "not credible" when it came out as a preprint.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Read this excerpt from my forthcoming book, An Abundance of Caution: American Schools, the Virus, and a Story of Bad Decisions.
The health establishment—aided by the media—ignored or dismissed what was clear: lengthy school closures had zero benefit and were harming kids.
When most of the media turned its back on its core obligation to question authority, @davidzweig was one of the few journalists who kept asking for proof. His reporting revealed what officials didn’t want to admit. www.thefp.com/p/david-zweig-covid-lies-school-lockdowns-d…
Important article on tumor treating electrical fields
"LUNAR: Full Moon or Eclipse? An exploration into tumor treating fields in lung cancer"
Check out our analysis with @VPrasadMDMPH
Open-access article here: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1936523325001287
See the visual abstract below!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
🧵Thread🧵
I’m not sure people realize just how egregious some of NPR’s “journalism” has been. Amid the debate about defunding the network, I wanted to walk down memory lane to revisit some of its worst coverage.
There’s a lot. ⤵️
I still think Garber is playing the tactical move. If he agrees quickly he would be fired like Columbia's prez. He needs to look to Harvard peeps like he is fighting, but also IMO, he wants to agree to Trump's terms. The battle is entirely one-sided. Harvard has zero leverage on Trump. Trump can punish them in 20 different ways. And, the court will be no remedy. Delayed payments of 9 billion dollars will cripple Harvard. Trump admin has framed this as a case of discrimination by Harvard. In many ways, DEI has constituted discrimination based on protected categories. I suspect Harvard will capitulate soon, but Garber needs to do so in a way that saves face. Can he pull it off? IDK
NEW: A day after Garber rejected his demands, Trump wielded a new cudgel in his attack on Harvard, threatening to revoke its tax-exempt status — a move that would hit impact financial aid, faculty hiring, and university research hardest.
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/16/trump-threatens-harv…
The journalists I know at @NPR and @PBS are among the best in the business -- smart, open minded, independent and totally professional. Trump made clear in the Oval today that what he wants are journalists who will tell him his policies are "wonderful," not ask tough questions.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Maybe that one isn’t the hill to die on.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
🔥
“The last few weeks have highlighted that universities are a giant welfare program funded by the taxpayer. Instead of trying, even a little bit, to represent the views of Americans, they went completely insane, and preferentially, almost exclusively, represent the views of a deranged minority on the far left.”
- @VPrasadMDMPH
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I think you are giving Garber too much credit.
But I agree that the ultimate outcome will be capitulation by Harvard and by every other major research university. It is a matter of simple arithmetic. No major research university can survive without federal funding.
Garber is a tactical genius. If he didn't do this, he would be fired. Now that he has saved himself, the university can move forward with agreeing to eliminate dei and encourage viewpoint diversity etc, which I fully expect they will.
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/harvard-will-not-comply-well-at-l…
#breaking: Harvard will not comply with the Trump administration’s demands to dismantle its diversity programming and limit student protests in exchange for federal funding, University President Alan Garber announced.
@dhruvtkpatel & @graceunkyoon report.
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/15/harvard-denies-trump…
"Garber is smart enough to know that he can't look like he agrees too easily."
Link in replies
#breaking: Harvard will not comply with the Trump administration’s demands to dismantle its diversity programming and limit student protests in exchange for federal funding, University President Alan Garber announced.
@dhruvtkpatel & @graceunkyoon report.
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/15/harvard-denies-trump…
Think about it: Garber had to do this. If he agreed right away he would be fired as the woke Harvard faculty attack him. So initially he goes with a strong statement. But then, very soon, they will capitulate to all the demands. They have to. Here's why.
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/harvard-will-not-comply-well-at-l…
#breaking: Harvard will not comply with the Trump administration’s demands to dismantle its diversity programming and limit student protests in exchange for federal funding, University President Alan Garber announced.
@dhruvtkpatel & @graceunkyoon report.
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/15/harvard-denies-trump…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Astounding article. This demands a correction @nytimes
@apoorva_nyc says it is “inaccurate” to say scientists who advise the CDC on vaccines have conflicts.
Apoorva - You might want to check the CDC’s own website: www.cdc.gov/acip/disclosures/by-member.html
@Sensible__Med my latest
Genius idea 💡
I was so pissed at how slow Larry Summers spoke on the @theallinpod i cancelled all my Saturday plans and wrote an app that adjusts the speed of individual speakers in a podcast.
Try it out, link in replies
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is why I am ultimately bearish on academia: the PhD is not attracting smart, talented people, and hasn't for a while. Moreover, smart, talented people can't rise up the ranks of an ideologically poisoned faculty who will refuse to admit, let alone tenure such people.
Admitting unqualified students is an utterly minor problem compared to what occurred (and still is) in hiring. Students fail or graduate (so leave). The wholesale militant wokification of entire academic departments who are now in charge of all future hiring is the timebomb.
Great piece by Adam. The people praising the Shingles-Dementia paper might need a shingles shot.
Shingles vaccine and reduction in dementia risk
open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/post-herpetic-churnal… via @adamcifu . Hi Prof Cifu, @FrijtersPaul and @EpiEllie have already pointed out the huge methodological flaws in this study @VPrasadMDMPH @drjohnm
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"How to appraise the control arm in oncology trials, in 10 minutes!"
From a recent virtual session I had the pleasure of giving at IOSI, Ticino, Switzerland.
Watch and subscribe !
www.drugdevletter.com/p/how-to-appraise-the-control-arm-in
Katrina Armstrong either lied to Trump or her peers. Telling one that she would ban masks, which are used to shield identify and telling the other, they would not ban masks.
Wow — the federal government wants to place Columbia University under a consent decree.
It sounds like this is because former Interim President Katrina Armstrong failed to convince the government that Columbia is serious about change.
“The Trump administration is planning to pursue a legal arrangement that would put Columbia University into a consent decree, according to people familiar with the matter, an extraordinary step that could significantly escalate the pressure on the school as it battles for federal funding.”
“A consent decree, which can last for years, would give a federal judge responsibility for ensuring Columbia changes its practices along lines laid out by the federal government. If a consent decree is in place, Columbia would have to comply with it. If a judge determines they are out of compliance, the school could be held in contempt of court—punishable by penalties including fines.”
“In order for a consent decree to take effect, Columbia would have to agree to enter it. It is unclear whether the university board has discussed the possibility.”
“Columbia could fight the move in court; the Justice Department would need to prove that the arrangement is warranted. But a court case could take years, and Columbia would likely lose federal funding in the interim—and might ultimately lose. Fighting the move would also open the school up to required depositions and legal fact-finding, which could keep the school’s campus politics in the spotlight.”
“The task force is aiming at the consent decree, people familiar with the matter said, because it doesn’t think Columbia is a good-faith actor willing to make the significant changes on campuses necessary to curb what it believes are civil rights infractions against Jewish students.”
This is a much overdue initiative
Animal testing is overused and often uninformative
I have been saying this for years and it's great to see FDA action here
Great move by Marty!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Pragmatism is not our strong suit. I think you wrote as much in sensible medicine recently. Everyone go read the last portion. That level of decision making for grades applies to how drugs are brought to market too! open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/i-learned-about-medic…
This is terrific. Nabokov lectures on literature is also amazing.
Vladimir Nabokov's opinions on various writers, culled from 'Strong Opinions'
It's disappointing that the Washington Post does not note this clinical trial of nature medicine has a 7% response rate. Which is poor.
It's incredibly cumbersome and costly to generate this product. And the FDA has never approved a product of the response rate this low on that basis.
Rosenberg has been doing this for 40 years. It's worth considering if there are better strategies we should be employing rather than griping about cuts.
www.washingtonpost.com/science/2025/04/06/nih-firings-can…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Lessons from the Children's hospital @VPrasadMDMPH
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
UPDATE: The CEO of the AHA was compensated over $4M in 2023.
This puts Nancy Brown as one of the highest-paid non-profit CEOs in the country, and it's all from within the AHA — not from related or outside organizations.
Contributions & grants makes up $677.8 million of the AHA's revenue stream.
A huge portion of these funds come from public donations, fundraising, and corporate partnerships.
This means that a chunk of our donations towards research efforts end up in her salary.
On top of that, 13 executives earn $500K–$1.1M (excluding Brown).
Despite claiming to be the largest funder of cardiovascular research outside government, AHA spends just ~$227M on research, or about 19% of their total outlay.
I am disgusted.
The American Heart Association just sent an employee to TEXAS to fight a bill that would stop food stamps from covering candy & soda—a bill to reduce heart disease.
Why? Because the AHA takes money from Kellogg’s & Pepsi, whose profits would tank if it passed.
Thank you, @LoisKolkhorst, for standing up for Texas kids against this corrupt "heart health" org.
Here are the 5 topic areas that NIH is cutting funding in
Thoughts that never occur over 20 years of practicing medicine, "If only I spent more time dissecting that cadaver...."
It is a sad, uninformative rite of passage
Medical schools are eliminating the use of cadavers, and that’s a shame: Technology is no substitute for learning from a real human body
www.statnews.com/2025/03/31/medical-school-cadaver-lab-bo… via @nadir_alsaidi
Media coverage of HHS cuts is off the mark
The book is entitled "the racialization of print"
Of course, it should not be subsidized by US taxpayers!
It probably could not survive the free market imo.
Americans voted for Trump precisely because the left funds things like this.
If Topol account starts accurately reporting medical science, it has been hacked!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is Oregon public school performance under progressive leadership:
I know Oregonians believe in public education, for every child. Trump's attempt to dismantle the US Department of Education is a dereliction of duty. Let’s say no and stand up for all kids.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The value based care movement needs lots of admin units that don’t actually add any value.
Discussion of cuts to HHS should consider that this is the size of HHS over time
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This event was co-sponsored by a pharmacy that received billions in taxpayer funding for administering COVID vaccines. They don’t view COVID as a failure.
Discussion of cuts to HHS should consider that this is the size of HHS over time
It's even worse than this. Universities breached the social contract during the pandemic. They lied, repeatedly and punished faculty who disagreed. Including folks like the now NIH director. Reforming them is needed.
Trump is hurling earth-shaking threats at America’s universities. The response from elite opinion leaders has been fascinating, if you read between the lines.
The pattern is: denounce Trump’s actions, but also, in a way, vindicate them. The New York Times is a good example.
🧵
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The plane has already crashed @Atul_Gawande
These people talk as if we don’t spend three times more on healthcare for the privilege of having the sickest kids in the developed world.
What numbers are you looking at, Atul?
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Beth Cameron - a @Brown_SPH prof who was a cheerleader for the 2020 BLM protests, but critical of those who opposed lockdowns - is now upset about the changes being made at HHS.
Taking a sledgehammer to HHS is dangerous. In @just_security me & @spsaki write about why cutting, changing, and chaotically destabilizing a critical part of our nation’s biodefense isn’t smart for national security, and it weakens our biological deterrence. (1 of 3)
I think Calley is fundamentally right that there has been widespread leadership failure at FDA, CDC, and NIH institutes. Misplaced priorities, cronyism with Pharma and worse. Dramatic change is needed. Meanwhile the media coverage is pure propaganda.
Here is 8 straight minutes of Calley Means calling out corrupt lobbyists to their faces.
Enjoy 🍿
Agree
Residency programs should cover disability insurance.
If hospitals are benefiting from cheap labor then doctors also need to be protected.
Challenges with the paper: it only works in women, and it works better if you didn't get a flu shot.
I'm not very confident in the conclusion.
A new study serves as a crucial reminder that there isn't always a clear separation between infectious diseases and chronic illnesses.
Getting the shingles vaccine lowered the likelihood of developing dementia, according to a new article in Nature.
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-08800-x
Fact check: true
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
It's proper to take ppl in good faith. But once someone has shown you they're a partisan hack over and over again it's ok to ignore them. @ashishkjha is the poster boy for partisan hack. He is as much a scientists as I'm the pope.
We have a crisis of obesity, and poor nutrition but Ashish focused on boosting 6-month-old babies who already had covid with boosters that didn't have randomized data.
His boss campaigned on school closure, and his CDC director coordinated with the teacher's Union to keep schools closed.
The Biden administration forced 2-year-olds to wear masks at Head start. Except when they nap.
Ashish recommended people who already had covid and had been vaccinated, receive paxlovid. Which has no evidence in this population.
Instead of tackling any of the core problems in American medicine, Ashish made a career of going on cable news and saying what was politically expedient. I would not trust him here. @SecKennedy
So much of what is in here is incorrect
Americans are NOT getting sicker every year
After a devastating pandemic, life expectancy is beginning to rise again
Cancer mortality rates have fallen substantially
Cardiovascular mortality is down
Opioid related deaths are down
Even obesity rates have plateaued and are beginning to turn down
Yes, these gains are fragile
Yes, we have more work to do
But we were making progress
Gutting our public health system will not help
This is a difficult moment for all of us at HHS. Our hearts go out to those who have lost their jobs. But the reality is clear: what we've been doing isn't working. Despite spending $1.9 trillion in annual costs, Americans are getting sicker every year. In the past four years alone, the agency’s budget has grown by 38% — yet outcomes continue to decline.
We must shift course. HHS needs to be recalibrated to emphasize prevention, not just sick care. These changes will not affect Medicare, Medicaid, or other essential health services.
This overhaul is about realigning HHS with its core mission: to stop the chronic disease epidemic and Make America Healthy Again. It’s a win-win for taxpayers, and for every American we serve.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
based on what i'm seeing, no one seems to think it possible that fda will continue to work, or that new leaders (makary etc) could build upon the progress that's been made in recent years... eg by increasing the use of technology, tackling new review bottlenecks etc. call me crazy but i personally think progress might even be more likely than significant backsliding.
Some thought on this topic
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26957620/
The NIH is cutting funding to brain & pancreatic cancers; two of the most deadly malignancies with the fewest diagnostic and treatment options. It seems these deserve more funding, not less. There is ample waste in medical research, but these cancers deserve attention.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Peter Marks lost his way a long time ago. @us_fda is better off without him.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
It’s impossible to rebuild a high-trust society if this is how we treat people who actually need the assistance of said society and are willing to go on a limb to trust that people will do the right thing.
This is insane. Let the man free and give him a damn job.
A 24-year-old Augusta man was arrested for leaving his children—ages 1, 6, and 10—alone at a McDonald's while he attended a nearby job interview.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Welcome @US_FDA Commissioner Dr. Martin Makary and @NIH Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya. Let’s restore @HHSgov health agencies to their rich tradition of gold-standard, evidence-based science to tackle the chronic disease epidemic and Make America Healthy Again. The revolution begins today!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
In 2020, then director of the National Institutes of Health, Francis Collins, called him a “fringe epidemiologist” and pushed for a “devastating takedown.”
Today, @DrJBhattacharya is the new director of the NIH. And Collins has apologized. thefp.pub/4lbEAhd
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Who's the asshole that called the cops?
A 24-year-old Augusta man was arrested for leaving his children—ages 1, 6, and 10—alone at a McDonald's while he attended a nearby job interview.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
When I was a kid I would be presented with adult topics and asked to debate them --- by my father in the single room of our trailer, by senior citizens socializing in the lobby of our church, and teachers who themselves lacked much formal education and whose best hope was to work in a mill or drive a truck. It baffles me elites have deprived young people of this most valuable lesson when like you say it was plainly obvious to us in backwood hillbillies that are supposed to be the intellectual punchline.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
In contrast @DrJBhattacharya accepted all debate invitations. Proof in the photo.
But let's not lose sight of the bigger issue: When I speak, I do not learn. When I debate, I learn.
I have attended a single modern health conference where a debate took place. I have not seen a single debate on my medical campus in the last 5 years.
In contrast, I grew up with debate. It was an essential part of training--to have your research and ideas challenged in a public forum. So much that I was trained to have someone pick a public health topic and a position for me to then debate for.
An entire generation of public health professionals will never learn to debate or gain insights from debate and this will materially harm public health outcomes!
Sorry @Cornell
Your current dean, Bob Harrington, told @DrJBhattacharya & Elan Bendavid to stop speaking to the press w/ their lockdown criticism (2020)
You held zero debates on school closure, lockdowns, toddler masking
You are anti-debate; you didn't do it when it mattered.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Yes. Most specialists are white, so the most at risk babies were treated by white doctors. This was pointed out at the time by EBM experts like @VPrasadMDMPH. It was stupid study that was obviously confounded if you critically examined it even a little bit.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
An influential study on infant mortality omitted a data point that undermined the pro-DEI narrative, according to FOIA docs obtained by @donoharm
This is 70% of science. Remember I dismantled this paper on my podcast years ago.
Researchers are manipulating their data all the time to claim discovery or to reach convenient 'truths'
No University has ever used NIH grants to audit their own research. They don't care.
Notable reporting from Emily Kopp. A study purported to show that mortality is higher for black infants seen by white doctors. By now, the issues with this study are widely known.
FOIAed notes show how the authors in fact cut points that they said "undermined the narrative."
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Journalists should read this before reporting on the Peter Marks dismissal.
This is a mediocre scientist who fired the top two vaccine scientists at the FDA when they raised concerns about mandating the COVID vaccine to soldiers. @VPrasadMDMPH
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/the-same-media-that-lied-about-all
Peter and Ashish are the reason why public health recommends that a 4 year old kid who had covid last month gets a booster next month.
Both represent the pro-Pharma anti-science movement in the Democrat party.
One of the very best examples of "America can still do hard things" was Operation Warp Speed
It's chief scientific architect was Peter Marks
Peter was pushed out of the FDA by RFK Jr. yesterday
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Where was this level of outrage in media from the loss of experienced FDA staff when Krause and Gruber resigned? They had ~30 yrs EACH at FDA. BOTH were virologists by training. There was some coverage but no meltdown about total destruction of FDA and anti-science catastrophe.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
In light of Marks' resignation remember when he tried to steer the FDA vaccines committee away from taking what he expected would be negative vote on the booster for all but Marion Gruber came in like a badass to stand up for voting on the question as planned? Timing for clip below. I've clipped it a few times and it seems that YouTube deletes it, so instead here's the full link with timing.
I'm just circling back to give details about the exchange I mentioned before between former FDAer Dr Gruber pushing for a vote on the first Pfizer booster for ages 16yrs+ rather than what FDA's Dr Marks angled for, which was first getting a sense of the committee in order to reword the vote to a narrowed use, presumably to avoid a negative vote
6:49:11-6:51:34
youtu.be/WFph7-6t34M
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
.@VPrasadMDMPH just pantsed the Big Pharma media.
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/the-same-media-that-lied-about-al…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Some people are bending themselves into pretzels to present Peter Marks as someone who made no fire-able errors in judgment that negatively impacted the public perception of FDA but rather someone who might've had a few decisions they might not have made but was otherwise amazing
Marks
Lied about Paxlovid
Lied about boosters
Made Gruber and Krause resign
Worked w Biden to push unethical mandate
Overrode 3 reviewers to approve gene therapy that kills more boys that it saves
Peter Marks circumvented FDA’s advisors on COVID boosters, spurred the resignations of top vaccine regulators, and unilaterally approved a Duchenne muscular dystrophy drug that just killed a teenager. Many will sanitize his record for political purposes, but I have a long memory.
Just remember that the media's spin on an event is not the truth
@calleymeans
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
🚨 Fmr. FDA Official Dr. Philip Krause Says COVID Vaccine Mandates Were 'Based Solely on Speculation'
"We didn't have the good data at that point that really suggested that vaccinating one person would protect the unvaccinated also. So mandating a vaccination to protect other people was really based solely on speculation. And to me, that was not a strong enough reason to mandate the vaccine."
Full Episode: @Ravarora1
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
What he lacks in intelligence, Ashish makes up in world-class deviousness and naked political partisanship.
Which is why you'll never hear him talk about the Sept 25, 2020 letter signed by over 60 scientists asking COVID vaccine rollout be delayed.
(Elections were a month away)
One of the very best examples of "America can still do hard things" was Operation Warp Speed
It's chief scientific architect was Peter Marks
Peter was pushed out of the FDA by RFK Jr. yesterday
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Do we have a Polymarket bet on how long it takes for Marks to get to Pfizer or Moderna?
Marks ignored all the data and is utterly incompetent and bought off.
He is responsible for the childhood shot approval.
Gross little man.
💥FDA’s top vaccine chief Peter Marks is out the door amid vaccine safety disputes and looming legal challenges💥
Read about his troubled legacy at the FDA 👇
blog.maryannedemasi.com/p/fdas-top-vaccine-chief-peter-marks
@Jikkyleaks @MdBreathe @nicksortor @RobSchneider @MikeBenzCyber
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
COVID-19: The Evidence Lopsidedly Favors a Lab Leak
by @AndrewNoymer
"Studying the origin of COVID is crucial to preventing the next pandemic. We cannot pretend we “have the tools” if we do not understand its origins. "
@ScienceMagazine @sudipsparikh
www.realclearscience.com/articles/2025/03/28/covid-19_the…
Real science is when you conduct an unscientific survey
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Dr. Peter Marks should have been fired long ago at the FDA.
He was known for routinely overruling advisory opinions of actual experts - including firing the agency’s top two vaccine scientists and calling them “intransigent” for raising concerns about the COVID vaccine.
He also over-ruled FDA consensus opinion on ELEVIDYS - a muscular dystrophy drug that was warned to cause significant toxicity and was recently linked to a liver failure death.
While Dr. Marks self-proclaimed himself as “the nation’s top vaccine scientist,” he had no training in vaccine biology. His main expertise appears to be public relations and having lunch with pharmaceutical executives.
His disrespectful statements against @SecKennedy and pre-prepared media campaign to slander the man who has galvanized a movement to combat the chronic disease crisis only shows how vital this dismissal is.
The media and HHS staff should be receiving a clear message that anyone who is not dedicated to reversing the chronic disease crisis is not welcome at HHS.
.@SecKennedy and Commissioner @MartyMakary have the responsibility to build their own team at @US_FDA to move our nation forward. It was extremely disappointing to see Dr Peter Marks’ vindictive comments towards Secretary @RobertKennedyJr in his resignation letter. I firmly believe RFK will be the most consequential Health Secretary in our nation’s history.
Peter was the best ally of Pharma!
He did more for Sarepta than the CEO
Peter deserves a lot of Moderna stock
If he didn't force the resignation of Gruber and Krause they would have lost billions
He did kill that boy with Duchesne's but Sarepta still profits
A hero, per STAT
An initial reaction story from us. I’ll have more tomorrow…
Ouster of FDA’s Peter Marks alarms a biopharma industry that saw him as an ally www.statnews.com/2025/03/29/fda-peter-marks-ouster-alarms… via @statnews
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
AMBASSADOR: ADJ pembro, no OS benefit (for now)
NIAGARA: NEO+ADJ durva, announced OS benefit
(later today #esmo2024 #esmo24)
Why such a difference ?
post-recurrence care may be the answer, we will see 👇
x.com/Timothee_MD/status/1835239165190922376
+background here:
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaoncology/fullarticle/2820214
AMBASSADOR ➡️ADJ pembro in bladder #esmo2024
Congrats to the investigators & @ALLIANCE_org for a non-global trial answering the Q of
anti-PD1 earlier for all vs later only for those who reccur.
➡️DFS benefit, no OS benefit
facilitates real decision-making
Some thoughts🧵
1/8
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Notice Eric's priorities: Not public health, not principles, not discovery, it's all about business. Who wants science and health getting in the way of $$$ 🤡
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
worth reading our analysis, which is still accurate I think :
www.drugdevletter.com/p/should-the-laura-trial-change-our
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I don’t believe there’s much evidence vaccines cause autism, either. But when a supposedly non-partisan news organization runs THIS headline, all it does is fuel vaccine critics who say the media is in Big Pharma’s pocket. This falls very much on the “doth protest too much” side
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
.@SecKennedy’s cuts at HHS send a clear message:
Less power to administrators.
More power to scientists and doctors.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The story also reports that there is no funding for an orderly closeout of trials that are being canceled. Also not true.
media.nature.com/original/magazine-assets/d41586-025-0095…
media.nature.com/original/magazine-assets/d41586-025-0095…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This story implies that the NIH is terminating all of its clinical trials. I'm re-posting a list of the topics for which trials are being canceled. We can debate about those, but let's debate from a place of reality. The most unethical health and science reporter out there, and there's stiff competition.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
A Blueprint for NIH Reform
publichealth.realclearjournals.org/perspectives/2025/03/a…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
There was a time when I thought Dr. Welch was a jackass. No longer. I’m much wiser, partly because of him.
Highly recommend
@VPrasadMDMPH starts on page 2 with the story of BMT in BC. It’s not a good story with a happy ending.
7 things the new CDC director should do immediately
@SecKennedy
Eric takes screenshots with lots of highlighting, but he doesn't actually accurately critically appraise articles
Dear dr @EricTopol,
At the end of November last Yeah, you retweeted a systematic review that claimed that CBT and a mental and physical rehabilitation program are moderately effective for #longcovid
Our reanalysis shows that that is not correct
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
An ET endorsement may have a C-statistic below 0.5
This means it is predictive, but just in the opposite direction :)
Dear dr @EricTopol,
At the end of November last Yeah, you retweeted a systematic review that claimed that CBT and a mental and physical rehabilitation program are moderately effective for #longcovid
Our reanalysis shows that that is not correct
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
7 things the CDC Director should do immediately www.drvinayprasad.com/p/7-things-the-cdc-director-should?…
If we change reimbursement and paid pediatrics and primary care more we would get more interest in these fields and better match the needs of Americans
Really sad. The trial was taxpayer funded and used a placebo control when there are established treatment options.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=3WKqxRHwPKo&t=421s
#cabozantinib is now @US_FDA approved based off #cabinet study for previously treated pNET or epNET.
- ⬆️ PFS in both subsets
- mPFS pNET 11.4mos Vs 3mos and epNET 8.5mos Vs 5.6mos
- SE: HTN, Diarrhea, Fatigue
#onctwitter #medtwitter @NANETS1 @LACNETS #gism @OncoAlert
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I Learned About Medicine From That: the first patient I cared for who died www.sensible-med.com/p/i-learned-about-medicine-from-that…
The vote for Jay Bhattacharya -- straight down partisan lines-- proves that they have not reconsidered their mistakes.
Five years after covid struck, liberals have reconsidered their mistakes, while conservatives have done the opposite.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Just out in @NatRevClinOncol my latest on Surrogate Endpoints from the patient's perspective
Despite writing on this topic for 15 years, hope to offer new ideas in this piece
@vkprasadlab @Sensible__Med @Plenary_Session
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
There’s plenty to be worried about but the 💯 partisan vote on @DrJBhattacharya for NIH ranks high on the list.
If you want to heal science, how can 47 thinking humans vote against a proven academic and a Stanford professor?
Science should be apolitical. Come on, you all.
I would have terminated this grant too. There is no need for a better antiviral. Covid is now a cold. If this is so valuable, then secure private sector investments.
Our NIH grant to discover coronavirus antiviral meds was terminated today.
With this grant, we had developed a better SARSCoV2 inhibitor than Paxlovid, and we recently discovered an improved drug that looks better than Pfizer's own second-generation inhibitor.
It's crazy to see Democrats vote against Jay. Such naked partisanship. He is clearly qualified and the best candidate
What is the p-value that if a person was being assessed totally on merit-politics had no effect—that 53 R vote + and 47 D vote negative? I bet it’s quite low.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"Surrogate end points in oncology: the speed-uncertainty trade-off from the patients' perspective"
open.substack.com/pub/developdrugs/p/surrogate-end-points… via @VPrasadMDMPH
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Interesting piece from @VPrasadMDMPH on surrogate endpoints and their (potential) impact on efficiency and the cancer drug pipeline.
Good to see our study discussed in context!
Just out in @NatRevClinOncol my latest on Surrogate Endpoints from the patient's perspective
Despite writing on this topic for 15 years, hope to offer new ideas in this piece
@vkprasadlab @Sensible__Med @Plenary_Session
If it stays on the schedule then the CDC has failed.
I think it’s safe to say the COVID vaccine will be staying on the CDCs Childhood Vaccine Schedule for the foreseeable future.
It is my opinion this move by the CDC in 2022 was a massive contributing factor to the vaccine hesitancy we are seeing today.
Forbes 30 under 30 is overrepresented with fraud and scam because a lot of big ideas are bullshit.
A Forbes 30 Under 30 recipient did WHAT???
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
A big pharma company acquired a couple of years ago a company that promised to replace control arms of RCTs with observational data.
At the end of the day they ended up wasting 200 mil USD and jeopardized their epi team.
Just out.! Led by Mariana Barosa we revisit target trial emulation. We show, under a variety of scenarios, real world evidence is actually MORE EXPENSIVE to generate than randomized evidence
See tables & figures in thread
@vkprasadlab
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Very interesting study. Not true that trial emulation studies are less expensive. The costs are real and fall on patients, taxpayers, and insurance companies. And the outcome is lower quality data.
Just out.! Led by Mariana Barosa we revisit target trial emulation. We show, under a variety of scenarios, real world evidence is actually MORE EXPENSIVE to generate than randomized evidence
See tables & figures in thread
@vkprasadlab
So dramatic. Not every NIH dollar is well spent. When I read the grants that are cancelled I usually conclude they ought be cancelled. Using aura ring to track sleep impacts from climate change. Endless disparities work that doesn't actually improve things. NIH is a leaky bucket
NIH funding is important, but investments today factor in years and decades down the road. Meanwhile, the U..S. is ceding important ground to China today for reasons that are not a money problem. Does anyone want to address that.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Great points in this essay.
The bar for approval - and therefore the endpoints being accepted - is shaping the entire research clinical trials agenda...
Great figure Vinay !
Just out in @NatRevClinOncol my latest on Surrogate Endpoints from the patient's perspective
Despite writing on this topic for 15 years, hope to offer new ideas in this piece
@vkprasadlab @Sensible__Med @Plenary_Session
Just out.! Led by Mariana Barosa we revisit target trial emulation. We show, under a variety of scenarios, real world evidence is actually MORE EXPENSIVE to generate than randomized evidence
See tables & figures in thread
@vkprasadlab
Just out in @NatRevClinOncol my latest on Surrogate Endpoints from the patient's perspective
Despite writing on this topic for 15 years, hope to offer new ideas in this piece
@vkprasadlab @Sensible__Med @Plenary_Session
In the essay I describe the fact that there is some relationship between incentive and developing new and innovative drugs, but the precise nature of this relationship is unknown
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
North Carolina allows mom to sue school for vaccinating her 14 yo son for COVID-19 without parents consent
North Carolina allows mom to sue school for vaccinating her 14 yo son for COVID-19 without parents consent
NIH funding is responsible for 99.4% of all drugs and....
If Covid did come from a lab accident, it is probably the deadliest single mistake in all of human history, and it means China and the US may be jointly responsible for 7,000,000 deaths. Unsurprising neither government wants to know.
www.currentaffairs.org/news/2021/05/the-stakes-of-finding…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Sue them into oblivion. Anyone who even dares to think of violating parental rights and informed consent with such impunity should have the result of this lawsuit be their very next thought.
BREAKING: North Carolina Supreme Court has given a family the green light to sue their school district after their son was allegedly vaccinated with a COVID mRNA injection without parental consent.
Tanner Smith, 14, went to a clinic for a COVID-19 test after a football team outbreak, not expecting a vaccine. He told workers he didn’t want the vaccine and lacked parental consent. When they couldn’t reach his mother, a worker allegedly instructed another to administer the vaccine anyway, mother Emily Happel and Smith allege in legal briefs.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
One of my favorite @ASlavitt moments:
HIS HANDS ARE COLD TO THE TOUCH!
Looooong Covid is truly the stupidest fake disease grift ever, it makes fibromyalgia look like smallpox
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
😳😳😳
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Just few months ago they were still accumulating genomic data from patients know fully well that they will go bankrupt soon
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Malignant and medical reversals gave me a perspective beyond oncology /oncologist
World best critiques
An entirely useless company and emblematic of how genomics was over-hyped.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Healthcare jobs have grown 2x faster than the overall labor market since 1980
Healthcare overtook retail to become largest industry by employment in 2009
New working paper with @GottliebEcon, @kevinrinz, and @UdalovaVictoria w/ key facts on the rise of healthcare jobs
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
In 2020, NIH’s Collins & Fauci worked to shut down dissenting scientists.
When he gets confirmed by the Senate this week to lead the NIH, as is expected, one COVID wrong will be righted. Many more remain.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
well, the USA set the precedent for how things were handled worldwide imo.
i agree with vinay prasad in that fauci knew the virus leaked from a lab he funded and did whatever he could to minimize infection, even if it meant subverting previous public health advice
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This guy never misses. Always love a tweet from Vinay.
Defund bad science before funding good science
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Nobody denies that NIH research leads to drugs. The question is how quickly? And how effective are the drugs? The incentive created by NIH is to parrot the dominant hypothesis in scientific journals to secure the next grant, not to find a breakthrough.
From 2010 to 2016 (latest data I have ), NIH research contributed to EVERY drug approved by the FDA
"mRNA vaccines" not "mRNA"
A huge difference
Senior scientists with NIH grants fear the Trump administration will abandon all work on mRNA, a promising field of medical research for flu, AIDS, cancer, and more.
@ArthurAllen202 reports. ⤵️ kffhealthnews.org/news/article/nih-grants-mrna-vaccines-t…
Defund bad science before funding good science
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/first-defund-bad-science-then-invest
Interesting how much quieter Match day was on X than just a few years ago. Lots of programs have done this.
Lecture to the California Hospital Association on AI in rural settings (Mar-2025)
Lecture to the California Hospital Association on AI in rural settings (Mar-2025)
Really interesting study. Would love to see a version of this not funded by diet soda makers.
Drinking diet soda leads to greater weight loss and weight loss maintenance than drinking water.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26708700/
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Motorcycles are dangerous but somehow putting a child on an e-bike that goes 30 mph is completely safe . 😬
Motorcycles are dangerous
I once had a neurosurgeon tell me if you ride one, don't wear a helmet because you will wish you were dead.
I wrote 3. Heard from all 3. 70 letters is insane.
I wrote 70 letters of recommendation for medical students only one single person connected with me to tell me where they matched
Good idea
POTUS should have a salary of like $20m a year. Senators should make $5m. House members maybe $2m. And in return they should be subject to all insider trading laws, not be allowed to do any lobbying for 10 years after leaving office.
You would get better people overall - those who cannot be so easily bought. Not nearly as subject to temptation.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Peter Hotez reposts a post by Peter Hotez that includes a picture taken by Peter Hotez of a newspaper with a picture of Peter Hotez. Just in case you hadn’t heard the news!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
20 years ago, only 25% of our class went to lecture. All watched videos on 2x speed at home.
Cant imagine what statistics are now
Completely agree-- test into third year is genius.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Malevolent liar. Documents show she successfully lobbied the Biden CDC **the following year** to alter the “science,” creating further obstacles to school reopenings. In places where Weingarten and her ilk were most powerful, kids were locked out of classrooms the longest.
🚨RANDI WEINGARTEN: THE IDEA THAT WE WANTED SCHOOLS TO REMAIN CLOSED IS A "REPUBLICAN TALKING POINT!"
"COVID was a terrible time for us...I wanted schools to be reopened as early as April of 2020."
"This has been a Republican talking point for a long time."
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Never forget that renowned psychology professor Yoel Inbar lost out on a job at @UCLA because he questioned the efficacy of diversity statements on a podcast once.
The University of California system announced today it will remove “stand-alone diversity statements” from its hiring process to avoid evaluating applicants on issues outside their expertise. As FIRE has long argued, requiring applicants to pledge allegiance to a specific interpretation of DEI too often becomes an ideological litmus test, stifling debate on inherently politicized concepts.
This is an important shift in practice for much of the UC system. Its most prestigious campus, Berkeley, used diversity statements to eliminate over 670 candidates from a pool of 893 in 2018.
While faculty should not have to endorse DEI, it would be equally bad to mandate they affirm values like “patriotism” or “capitalism,” or to demonstrate opposition to DEI initiatives.
Focusing on candidate qualifications over ideological commitments is a massive step forward for one of America’s premier public university systems.
Universities are charged with fostering the free exchange of ideas and producing knowledge. For that to happen, faculty must be judged on their academic merit, not on whether they align with popular sentiment.
FIRE will continue to monitor academic freedom and the rights of faculty members to express themselves across all of the system's campuses.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
“This is an important shift in practice for much of the UC system. Its most prestigious campus, Berkeley, used diversity statements to eliminate over 670 candidates from a pool of 893 in 2018.”
The University of California system announced today it will remove “stand-alone diversity statements” from its hiring process to avoid evaluating applicants on issues outside their expertise. As FIRE has long argued, requiring applicants to pledge allegiance to a specific interpretation of DEI too often becomes an ideological litmus test, stifling debate on inherently politicized concepts.
This is an important shift in practice for much of the UC system. Its most prestigious campus, Berkeley, used diversity statements to eliminate over 670 candidates from a pool of 893 in 2018.
While faculty should not have to endorse DEI, it would be equally bad to mandate they affirm values like “patriotism” or “capitalism,” or to demonstrate opposition to DEI initiatives.
Focusing on candidate qualifications over ideological commitments is a massive step forward for one of America’s premier public university systems.
Universities are charged with fostering the free exchange of ideas and producing knowledge. For that to happen, faculty must be judged on their academic merit, not on whether they align with popular sentiment.
FIRE will continue to monitor academic freedom and the rights of faculty members to express themselves across all of the system's campuses.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Uber driver told me SFPD officers make $600k/year for “driving in circles & sleeping in their car on graveyard shifts”
I was like “oh I bet it’s tough” & he was like “nah cops don’t do shit in SF.” he's joining the police academy bc his cop friend just bought a Lambo
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Brilliant outside the box thinker Dr I !
Stanford's chair Bob Harrington asked Eran Bandavid and Jay B to stop talking to the press saying lockdown was the wrong solution.
Bob was rewarded and is now Dean at Cornell.
The public still trusts universities too much
Prof. Ioannidis: "Both I and every member of my family were attacked in ways I could never have imagined.[including death threats] When we needed them most, the best epidemiologists just stepped down. Most of the people who dictated the narratives had no clue about epidemiology"blog.bastian-barucker.de/covid-19-policies-john-ioannidis/
This dude:
Forced the resignation of Gruber and Krause because he wanted to push a mandate
Overturned 3 reviewers to approve a duchesne's gene therapy that seems to be killing children and blowing their livers up
Lied about Paxlovid
His provax rhetoric has nothing to do with his incompetence
Was just thinking how interesting it is to hear FDA's Peter Marks speak about benefits of vaccination publicly right now when he makes a joke about how he'll be quiet now so he can come back to his desk tomorrow.
I agree. Rochelle is the reason no one trust science and the average person wants to cut funding
Rochelle Walensky, who once said that vaccinated people do not carry the virus and don’t get sick, supported masking toddlers and published misinformation to support her claims, is worried about undermining science
And this is why no one will ever trust The Science ever again
Great thread about how the folks who lied about covid, or crafted the horrific response have been rewarded.
🧵1/ Cover up #originofcovid, receive rewards!
Summary of scientists who lied or deceived wrt #originofcovid and subsequently got rewarded.
Anthony Fauci: Stearne Medal, April 17 2024 www.irishtimes.com/ireland/2024/04/17/dr-anthony-fauci-ho…
MRNA technology is so promising and everyone wants it!! 🥳
Incompetent FDA commissioners love Marks
Califf loved him too. He's the only person who made a bigger blunder than Exondys.
Maybe they have a contest for who can approve ineffective products for kids with dmd
Mark McClellan (Bush FDA, CMS head) says he is glad Marks is in that seat.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Let me translate this for the lay public. 1. John is the most cited (aka influential) MD of our generation. 2. Rather than guessing how much Covid had spread, he did a seroprevalence study in early 2020. 3. But the results were against the narrative. He found far more ppl than thought had been previously infected with Covid and therefore the case fatality rates were wildly exagerated. 4. For this he was subjected to death threats.
For those of you saying "but that was 2020, we were panicked", consider this: I was threatened with being fired for writing in 2022 that kids shouldn't be forced to mask and should be allowed to go to school. @VPrasadMDMPH just today had a post removed from @LinkedIn for violating their medical misinformation policies. In many ways society's ability to tolerate science hasn't improved much in the centuries since Galileo was forced to recant that the earth orbits the sun or be burned at the stake.
Prof. Ioannidis: "Both I and every member of my family were attacked in ways I could never have imagined.[including death threats] When we needed them most, the best epidemiologists just stepped down. Most of the people who dictated the narratives had no clue about epidemiology"blog.bastian-barucker.de/covid-19-policies-john-ioannidis/
Each year only 15% of PhD students who are admitted get a faculty position. Most subsequently burn out or fail. To succeed, you have to spend all your time writing grants and not doing science. The status quo is already a lost generation. Enough TDS. Just be honest.
"We have to recognize that for all intents and purposes, we are looking at a lost generation of researchers" says health researcher and consultant Jonathan Jackson. "Even if everything goes away today, we are looking at probably a period of upwards of 10 years before we can fully recover our scientific workforce" #statbreakthrough
Rochelle Walensky colluded with teachers unions to manufacture unproven recommendations. (6ft distancing) Which ensured schools would be closed. Disgraceful
Not a single student can read at grade level in 30 Illinois schools.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Are there any other great powers where elite institutions have largely abandoned meritocracy in the service of antiracism?
Harvard is denying admission to students with perfect SAT scores and AP calculus credit, while also admitting students who need remedial math.
In a really clever paper, John Ioannidis compared the risk of dying from driving in a car to getting covid. If you were at a young age, the car was worse. He tried to show we were acting irrationally towards young people. But they just deleted his YouTube videos and crucified him.
Sometime in 2020, after we got all the age-stratified Covid risk data, I compared my annual death risk from Covid vs. the same for riding my Vespa.
Vespa was higher! Despite the very few miles, all non-freeway, I was riding.
I haven't ridden the Vespa since 😞
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Why does @LinkedIn (owned by @Microsoft /@BillGates) continue to censor excellent scientists? Bill only wants junk science?
Wtf @LinkedIn removed my post with 5 reasons why mRNA vaccines technology should be deprioritized for NIH funded
This censorship of academics by idiots continues. @MartinKulldorff
Motorcycles are dangerous
I once had a neurosurgeon tell me if you ride one, don't wear a helmet because you will wish you were dead.
American Heart Association is a corrupt organization. Supporting soda for snap is the tip of the iceberg. They will do anything their donors wish. Their endorsement of drugs with low quality trials is just as rotten.
For years, the American Heart Association accepted millions from food companies and pushed policies like supporting food stamps for soda.
Advocates like @travelingenes shined a light and @joerogan called out.
Now, AHA is reversing course.
This is the power of MAHA activism.
Vaccines are like drugs, each one has different bodies of evidence.
The evidence for hep b at birth if the mother is negative- shitty
The evidence for MMR - great
The evidence for covid boosters- shitty thanks to Peter Marks, FDAs rubber stamp
I'm curious what others make of this statement as it almost seems to imply we need more evidence when we do have this kind of solid evidence for vaccines.
When he had the opportunity, Peter Mark's never once made the company's conduct randomized studies for boosters. Instead, he just gave them tremendous market access based on his gut opinion. He poisoned public faith in vaccines because he didn't make them generate evidence and obviously giving boosters to people who just had covid strikes the average person as pretty stupid.
FDA's Marks: "I know we have this incredible bent for the individual right now but ...we have to try to make the case [for vaccines] by a combo of showing how safe we can make them and" by gathering evidence to show how they help entire communities.
This guy
Forced resignation of Gruber and Krause so that he could ram through mandates
Overturned 3 FDA reviewers to approve gene therapy that seems to be killing kids with Duchesne's & destroying their livers
Lied about Paxlovid
His vaccine quip is not why he's incompetent
Was just thinking how interesting it is to hear FDA's Peter Marks speak about benefits of vaccination publicly right now when he makes a joke about how he'll be quiet now so he can come back to his desk tomorrow.
You could replace Peter Marks with a bobblehead doll that just stamps approval and you would have the same outcome at FDA with lower administrative fees.
Maybe something DOGE should consider.
Incompetent FDA commissioners love marks
Califf loved him too. He made Exondys look like less of a screw-up when he approved gene therapy that doesn't work but kills kids for DMD
Both against the advice of reviewers
Maybe there's a competition for most incompetence?
Mark McClellan (Bush FDA, CMS head) says he is glad Marks is in that seat.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Kicked off the day with an amazing YO session: 'Mentorship as a catalyst for success' lead by the most inspiring speakers. Great talk and insights from @Timothee_MD and, of course, the most breathtaking views 🇨🇭🏞️!!
#esmorarecancers25
Stanford's chair Bob Harrington asked Eran Bandavid and Jay B to stop talking to the press saying lockdown was the wrong solution.
Bob was rewarded and is now Dean at Cornell.
The public still trusts universities too much
Prof. Ioannidis: "Both I and every member of my family were attacked in ways I could never have imagined.[including death threats] When we needed them most, the best epidemiologists just stepped down. Most of the people who dictated the narratives had no clue about epidemiology"blog.bastian-barucker.de/covid-19-policies-john-ioannidis/
Wtf @LinkedIn removed my post with 5 reasons why mRNA vaccines technology should be deprioritized for NIH funded
This censorship of academics by idiots continues. @MartinKulldorff
Spread the word to screw over Microsoft
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/yes-mrna-vaccine-science-should-be
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
If these NIH funding cuts undermine the same scientific research community that advocated - like Rochelle Walensky did - for insane COVID measures such as lockdowns, masking toddlers, social distancing, school closures & vaxx mandates, then, by all means, keep cutting.
Viewpoint: Recent disruptions and funding cuts at the @NIH undermine the infrastructure and stability of US scientific research, threatening the nation's global leadership and scientific productivity. jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/10.1001/jama.20…
As a senior in high school, my English teacher would give me extra books to read and meet with her once a month before school to discuss. Faulkner, Tim O'Brien, Shakespeare, Kesey, Stein, Tolstoy, Foster Wallace, etc. Teaching someone to love literature is a special indebtedness
Didn't find my gateway to Literature until I was 21 (before that, I was chasing girls and playing guitar). Then I happened to rent Franco Zeffirelli's Hamlet and read Beowulf in a community college Lit class. Those two texts, and the King James Bible, led me to where I am now.
I do worry, that in a few years from now this will happen. These universities are just stopping the most visible symbols of what goes on underneath the surface. But really reforming the system is not in their interest.
HUGE NEWS: The University of California Board of Regents just ended the use diversity statements in faculty hiring throughout the system.
“To be clear, stand-alone diversity statements will no longer be permitted in recruitments,” the system’s provost said in a letter today.
Wow
HUGE NEWS: The University of California Board of Regents just ended the use diversity statements in faculty hiring throughout the system.
“To be clear, stand-alone diversity statements will no longer be permitted in recruitments,” the system’s provost said in a letter today.
So much medical research is animal abuse. If you use an animal and it has poor ability to recapitulate human biology, what are you doing? Why are you killing a mouse? Why are you torturing a monkey?
Francis Collins probably has some emails on his Gmail server that explain.
Some early-career researchers report feeling pressure to use animal models to meet journal and grant requirements, even in disciplines and projects that don’t require them.
go.nature.com/4iDshYY
People use data like this to say: That's why in the randomized studies there's poor post protocol use. But that's not a fair thing to say because the patients in the randomized studies are not like real world patients. They're the fittest ones. They're the ones that should be getting the most postprotocol care.
Just in @JAMANetworkOpen👉@flatironhealth Real world Rx data from >8500 pts w/ mRCC #kidneycancer 👉After 2018, only 38% & 14% of pts received 2nd & 3rd line Rx respectively👇jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2831749
Thanks to my mentors @umangtalking @montypal @neerajaiims Cc @OncoAlert @urotoday
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Are Pharma Companies ready to yield the narrative to Oncology Key Opinion Leaders? How will digital KOLs impact #asco25? #lcsm Do you agree with Dr. Prasad's criticisms?
👉ASCO23 Flashback: Dr. Prasad's Video Criticisms of ADAURA kolpulse.com/uptempo-blog/dr.-prasad-video-criticisms-of-… @VPrasadMDMPH @JackWestMD
I love cannon beach but it must only be a safe spot for spring break because it's literally the worst place to go for spring break.
Peter Marks turned off his pager for these alert values
They are sequencing cats and trying to link it to owners surveys of how the cats are acting around the house.
I pray this isn't NIH funded.
This is a sobering article. Hospitals discouraged care and possibly withheld treatment when there WAS NO SHORTAGE
A few US cities were overwhelmed in March 2020 but most hospitals were quiet. Entire Fauci led response was a failure.
One more for the “now it can be said” five year pandemic retrospectives. @dbongino and @FBIDirectorKash, we need criminal charges against medical staff who deliberately killed disabled patients to save supplies for non-disabled COVID patients.
www.npr.org/2020/12/21/946292119/oregon-hospitals-didnt-h…
Rochelle coordinated w teachers unions & pushed the made up 6ft distancing to ensure schools were closed
She made toddlers mask
She lied about myocarditis risk
She ran zero RCTs
She undermined science more than any changes in grant funding
Her incompetence led to loss of trust
Viewpoint: Recent disruptions and funding cuts at the @NIH undermine the infrastructure and stability of US scientific research, threatening the nation's global leadership and scientific productivity. jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/10.1001/jama.20…
Look at the difference between the ASCO guidelines and our review of the evidence!!
ascopubs.org/doi/abs/10.1200/OP.23.00468
Just published in @JCO_ASCO the updated @ASCO guidelines on fertility preservation in people with #cancer: a must read for all colleagues involved in cancer care to increase awareness on #oncofertility issues
@OncoAlert @AnnPartridgeMD @oncofertility
Link:
ascopubs.org/doi/10.1200/JCO-24-02782
Wonder if this has anything to do with public trust
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Those who lied were rewarded with positions, promotions, publications, grants, academy memberships, and awards.
Those who told the truth were penalized with pariah status and denial of positions, promotions, grants, publications, funding, academy memberships, and awards.
All informed persons--without exception--knew by early 2020 that SARS-CoV-2 likely entered humans through a research incident.
But most chose to lie or to stay silent.
I think if you were a college student and had covid and Biden forced you to get an unnecessary shot.
If you were a high school kid and Dems pushed school closure/ colluded with teachers unions
I imagine it will get worse as realization of what occured grows
The impacts of COVID school shutdowns was to turn a generation of young people against the democrats?
The scientists whose work is impacted were silent when their institutions shredded public trust by
Hospital visitor bans
Masking kids
Masking pregnant women (vid -) during labor
Censuring and silencing faculty
Permitting protests
Went all in on DEI insanity
Lied about origins
In 2025 USA scientists discovered that even if the work they are doing in their labs is important, that the communication failures & decisions of the institutions that fund them are not a separate matter… and the $ flow for research can & has stopped. What’s the way forward?
The idea it was the humanities that earned public ire but biomedicine pays the price is false. Biomedicine destroyed trust in experts. Vaccines. And their own funding
At SFO the regular line is faster than TSA pre and Clear!!!
This is really the truth, and if you add in irreproducible it goes to 80%. We can debate how but there has to be some reform
This is why 40-60% of NIH grant making is dross. Not worthwhile; poorly conceived; weak research design (even if topic is worthy).
NIH decision making needs complete reengineering.
🙄🤨
I think the saying is there is a $2000 bill in the cecum, you just have to go get it
There’s a famous saying in GI..
There’s a $1,000 inside everyone’s rectum… you just have to dig it out 😅
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
It’s nice when people outside medicine spend the day with you because they usually see only the good parts of the job and it’s a nice reminder that the good parts are always there.
If this is the grant in question, I find the premise insane
More carbon in the air will change how much we sleep and drink booze? Given the million other factors that drive sleep and booze-- this work will most likely end up analyzing noise rather than signal.
The public doesn't appreciate how much of NIH money is like paying a painter to paint a painting except you don't even get a painting
There are days in life that shake you.
I’m shattered 💔 to share that I just found out that the US Government terminated my 2024 NIH Director’s Early Independence Award (~$2 million), threatening my long-promised assistant professor job at @Columbia & academic career... 1/🧵
More carbon --> temperature warmer --> sleep less --> more booze --> bad health
Ergo, a reason to lower carbon.
Probably will completely settle all the debates on the topic and change all minds because they were waiting for these data to act
or more carbon--> run the AC harder--> temperature colder--> sleep more --> drink less
Noooooooooooo!!!! Unacceptable answer.
Every time I see someone complain about losing an NIH grant, and I read it, it reminds me that the NIH grant funding process is broken.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Why shadowing Vinay Prasad convinced me to become an oncologist www.sensible-med.com/p/why-shadowing-vinay-prasad-convinc…
Appreciate Colton visiting SF and writing this about his day for @Sensible__Med
A lot of NIH grants involve this kind of favoritism and bribery.
The explanation for the fraud is simple:
1) Fauci made it clear he wanted them to lie.
2) Andersen and Garry had a pending $8.9 million grant proposal in NIAID post-council administrative review--literally in Fauci's office awaiting Fauci's signature.
3) They lacked ethics.
Remember DeSantis, taking advice from people like Jay, reopened in April 2020.
Fauci was on TV saying that this was dangerous.
You didn't need to do anything to reopen school safely. Just open the door.
This quote is so perplexing. There in fact was the "alternative scenario" right at hand: all the schools that opened in the fall of 2020, not only in other countries but in many parts of this country.
Pre-pandemic I went to things like the ODAC in person, and parking was always like this
FDA’s White Oak still struggling with parking (photo via FDAer)
Now that a 16 year old is dead, worth revisiting that we were extremely critical of this approval on the drug development letter
When Peter isn't recommending toddlers get boosters without data, pressuring Gruber and Krause to give Pfizer BLA so Biden can ram a mandate through, and picking the COVID annual strain based on a childish analogy to buying milk, he is overruling 3 teams of FDA staff to approve a bullshit gene therapy product
His errors have consequences
Peter Marks is the Apoorva Mandavilli of the FDA
It is rare that you can blame a single person for a regulatory failure, but Peter Marks at FDA overruled 3 review teams and pushed this product on the market despite a failed trial.
He is also the reason why Biden mandated vaccines b/c he rammed a full approval thorugh, even as Gruber and Krause resigned.
Yes, the NIH should deprioritize mRNA vaccine science
5 reasons why
If you think this product shows the promise of mRNA
then you should read about CENSORING in kaplan meyer plots
Impressive data for @Moderna mRNA-4157 vaccine in 157 pts with melanoma stage IIIB-D/IV randomized to vaccine+pen to vs or bro alone. RFS HR 0.56 (p=0.03) and DMFS HR 0.35 (p=0.006)! So impressive that there is almost no need for phase III 🍾🍾🍾@ASCO #asco23 #melsm
First they leave to bloosky then they leave the country.
Some scientists in the United States have told Nature that they are considering leaving the country in the wake of widespread disruption to research brought in by the Trump administration
Are you thinking about leaving?
go.nature.com/41sQ470
Sure traditional cultures can identify plants that might be worth considering for medicinal properties but there is only one research method (science) and it applies whether you believe in it or not.
Scientists around the world are recognizing that their research method isn’t the only way
go.nature.com/3DCnx7c
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I had to check the calendar: it’s St Patrick’s Day, not April Fools Day.
Did @Nature really run an article decrying unpaid labor in academia?!🤪
“First take the plank out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother's eye.” Matthew 7:5
It can be hard to say no to service requests in academia.
We sought advice on how to ensure researchers don’t get stuck doing unpaid labour
go.nature.com/4bUX6WN
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
As I explained to Anthony Fauci who was wearing 3 masks, mask wearing was theater and had no measurable effect on transmission, a fact most public health doctors understood before the COVID pandemic allowed groupthink to overwhelm the scientific method
Studies show mask mandates in schools had zero effect on COVID transmission rates. $68M wasted on useless cloth masks while kids' mental health plummeted 47%. Politics over science.
Lol. Hyperbole.
1 The NIH works for the American people. Like it or not, huge numbers of Americans will not accept this product.
2 There's not much in biology you can't achieve with alternative means.
3 Cancer therapeutic vaccines are a dead end
The NIH has reportedly advised scientists to remove references to mRNA vaccine technology from grant applications, signaling a potential shift away from this research field.
As a reminder mRNA vaccine technology is one of the most groundbreaking advancements in modern medicine.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
My advice to researchers: Don't get stuck doing unpaid labor by writing free peer reviews for @Nature and other for-profit journals. Instead, get paid to review for our non-profit Journal of the Academy of Public Health (@RCJAPH).
It can be hard to say no to service requests in academia.
We sought advice on how to ensure researchers don’t get stuck doing unpaid labour
go.nature.com/4bUX6WN
Kennedy is already looking into this. AMA must lose the CPT monopoly
DOGE should examine the monopoly code book contract the AMA has with their sugar daddy, Uncle Sam. GKS
Nature pays $0 for doing reviews and wants to give advice on how to avoid unpaid labor. Hahaha
It can be hard to say no to service requests in academia.
We sought advice on how to ensure researchers don’t get stuck doing unpaid labour
go.nature.com/4bUX6WN
90% of scientists lie in every NIH grant application. They are trained to make extraordinary claims about how their work will make a difference. You have to play that game to be funded. So I am not surprised these guys just went a little harder at it when baited by Lord Fauci
“…my take as a scientist was never to lie…That sounds so basic, doesn't it – but now we know lots of scientists do lie and spread misinformation. Who could have known there was a real conspiracy among very powerful scientists to bury the lab leak hypothesis?”
This lab does good work but cancelling these taxpayer funded trips is good! Many cancer researchers spend each weekend at a different fancy hotel in a groupthink meeting. And these days, you can share science online. I think it's good funding cuts lowers travel.
With regret, I canceled my in person participation in #aacr25 in Chicago. The #eldeirylab has been very active in AACR meetings for 30 years. Difficulties & uncertainties with research funding have led to cost saving measures for travel expenses. Will miss seeing my colleagues.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
«La herramienta antivacunas más eficaz jamás creada fue permitir que la salud pública estuviera dirigida por idiotas» @VPrasadMDMPH
La simplicidad de mensajes para idiotas como "las vacunas salvan vidas" (y no "las vacunas evitan algunas muertes y mejoran la calidad de vida").
"The greatest anti-vax tool ever created was allowing public health to be run by idiots."
The difference between mRNA for covid and mRNA for a cancer therapeutic vaccine is this will be a bigger flop. You can inject a cancer patient with their own tumor antigens but nothing happens. We've tried it for 40 years. Not a single product works. Changing the mechanism of delivery won't change the fundamental biology constraint.
Cancer will finally be defeated in the next few years
Breakthrough in cancer research: mRNA technology opens up new horizons
The mRNA technology perfected during the COVID pandemic is on the verge of revolutionizing cancer treatment. British oncologist Lennard Lee describes this unexpected development as the “silver lining” of the pandemic. “Before COVID, cancer vaccines weren't really an area of research. Almost every clinical trial had failed,” explains Lee.
Unlike standardized vaccines, these cancer vaccines are developed individually for each patient. After a biopsy, the tumor tissue is sequenced and a customized vaccine is produced that gives the immune system precise instructions on how to fight the cancer cells. “It's like science fiction,” says Lee.
Progress has been remarkably fast. Lee and his team set up the Cancer Vaccine Launch Pad initiative after the pandemic. An NHS trial to prevent skin cancer recurrence was even completed a year earlier than expected - “completely unheard of” in medical research.
The results of this landmark trial are expected in late 2025 or early 2026. If successful, the first approved personalized mRNA vaccine against cancer would be available, just a few years after the technology was first used on a large scale during the pandemic.
The new generation of cancer vaccines could soon fundamentally change oncology and bring new hope to millions of patients worldwide.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Where to even begin? From CDC, I'd like honesty, accountability, apologies, removal of mask and Covid vax recommendations for kids, separation of data-gathering and policy-making divisions... And really, I want someone there to talk to me about this. 👇papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
What's healthier Seed oil or Butter?
I breakdown a new @jamaim paper
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Perspectives on evidence based cooking, way to go Vinay Prasad!
How I like to cook
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The New York Times now acknowledges that many university professors and administrators have been liberal ideologues rather than seekers of truth. When will they admit that their own reporters and editors have been too?
In an editorial in @nytopinion today correctly criticizing the Trump admin attacks on universities, the editors make a remarkable admission: "many professors and university administrators acted in recent years as liberal ideologues rather than seekers of empirical truth. 1/
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Fixed the headline for you, @zeynep
💯
Yes, I'm glad Zeynep is helping to explain the lab leak cover-up to NYT readers. But it's hard not to see her name and recoil at the dishonesty around her mask advocacy, and I doubt she'll ever admit to misleading the public on that.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
How I like to cook
If you think that I am going to check my records and get a measles booster in 2025 you are pretty fucking stupid
Yes, MMR should be recommended on the childhood schedule (not COVID)
No, we shouldn't create a culture where adults are paranoid & get boosters
slate.com/technology/2025/03/measles-outbreak-vaccine-boo…
letting fucking morons run public health is the greatest anti-vaccine movement imaginable
She knew nothing about medicine. Nothing about public health. And said everyone should wear a cloth mask. And don't forget long covid. She just parroted what the work from home, coastal New York Times staff wanted to hear.
Ironically, the writer who published this article also “badly misled” the public during Covid by repeatedly saying masks worked when they didn’t, and then tried to undermine the Cochrane Library when their review proved her wrong
A miracle has happened. The NY Times ran an oped acknowledging not only that the covid virus likely originated in a lab, but that government officials and scientists conspired to keep the substantiating evidence secret. The lab leak theory was censored on social media because of "pressure from the administration ... we shouldn't have done it."
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Ironically, the writer who published this article also “badly misled” the public during Covid by repeatedly saying masks worked when they didn’t, and then tried to undermine the Cochrane Library when their review proved her wrong
A miracle has happened. The NY Times ran an oped acknowledging not only that the covid virus likely originated in a lab, but that government officials and scientists conspired to keep the substantiating evidence secret. The lab leak theory was censored on social media because of "pressure from the administration ... we shouldn't have done it."
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I followed your writing closely. Pretending at moderation, you were not objective on the issue of lockdowns and covid restrictions, more broadly. Masking absurdity specifically. Here from 2023.
And why not call out your own newspaper for dereliction of duty on the lab leak?
Zeynep was too busy misleading the public about the efficacy of cloth masking to have time to investigate the origins of the virus!
It's easy to be mislead when you have your hands full misleading!
Please @zeynep. Journalists (like you) failed to interrogate the issue. You are responsible too. Your job is to investigate and hold power to account. You didn't. Instead you publish this poor me account of being "badly misled." Shame on you. Admit you failed.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
started ---------> going
"The greatest anti-vax tool ever created was allowing public health to be run by idiots."
We were badly mislead, by Zeynep
Not only did Zeynep claim based on very weak evidence that universal cloth masking was needed to stop asymptomatic spread, she also insisted that masking had no plausible harms.
checkyourwork.kelleykga.com/p/where-us-mask-rhetoric-went…
For a minute I thought she was writing about her dishonest push to mask adults and even children with homemade cloth masks despite the fact community masking doesn't work @KelleyKga
Only one of these has RCT evidence of a reduction in colon cancer death AND all-cause mortality
But you would never know which one reading this document
"Any screening is good" is a inaccurate message
We should encourage the one with the best evidence
How I like to cook
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
No. Jake Auchincloss is an authoritarian who advocated for censorship & deplatforming of people with views on COVID that he opposed. He also felt schools needed mass testing & surveillance programs in order to reopen. He was no champion for open schools.
Jake Auchincloss is an authoritarian who advocated for censorship and deplatforming of people with views on COVID that he opposed. He also felt schools needed mass testing and surveillance programs in order to reopen. Consider his opinions accordingly.
I told them that at the time. Too bad morons were running the show
Studies show mask mandates in schools had zero effect on COVID transmission rates. $68M wasted on useless cloth masks while kids' mental health plummeted 47%. Politics over science.
Everyone knows that Leana fucked up every single decision during the pandemic so naturally she won't be terrific at the post mortem
DR LEANA WEN: “In public health, there is always going to be a tension between individual liberties and what's best for the group.”
Ashish was on TV saying kids need to wear masks and get vaccines. They needed literally nothing to reopen schools. Ashish was wrong but doesn't even have the decency to admit his errors. Shameless shill. Meanwhile @GovRonDeSantis got it done in April.
Of all the leaders in Massachusetts, @RepAuchincloss was among the most vigorous proponents of getting schools open to in-person education in the fall of 2020
We knew by September that we could open schools safely
That stance wasn't always popular -- but it was right
My day-one issue after I was elected in fall of 2020 was helping to re-open the schools. I engaged everywhere across three dozen cities & towns in the district, and invited one of my partners in this work, a superintendent, as my guest to the State of the Union that spring.
But it took too long to get the schools open, and students are still struggling.
Democrats must rebuild trust with parents & students by delivering excellence in education. One example in my own district: 1:1 tutoring for students behind on math & reading.
NEW: 5 years later, what did we learn about school closures for the next pandemic? We interviewed over a dozen education, health and political leaders about where they now stand, any regrets, and what should happen next time. Gift link 👇
HEPA filter makers want all schools retrofitted with theie machines. But these proponents have never run a cluster RCT showing this intervention helps.
I would rather pay for better school lunches made with real food than a fucking HEPA filter. This a stupid policy.
"While many priorities compete for attention in school construction and renovation, few have a more profound and lasting impact than improving indoor air quality."
Great piece by @ashishkjha and @Natalie_C_Kopp making the case for healthy schools in RI
⬇️student absenteeism
⬆️performance
⬆️teacher retention
⬇️respiratory infections
⬇️burden from chronic illnesses
⬇️missed school days
⬆️math and reading scores
⬆️concentration
⬆️cognitive function
⬆️ mental health
Biden ran campaign ads saying reopening schools would kill kids
Dems said that 2 yo kids should wear cloth masks -- only a moron would think this
Dems purposefully delayed school reopening bc they didn't want to piss off teachers unions
Jake is fighting an uphill battle. His party screwed kids.
My day-one issue after I was elected in fall of 2020 was helping to re-open the schools. I engaged everywhere across three dozen cities & towns in the district, and invited one of my partners in this work, a superintendent, as my guest to the State of the Union that spring.
But it took too long to get the schools open, and students are still struggling.
Democrats must rebuild trust with parents & students by delivering excellence in education. One example in my own district: 1:1 tutoring for students behind on math & reading.
NEW: 5 years later, what did we learn about school closures for the next pandemic? We interviewed over a dozen education, health and political leaders about where they now stand, any regrets, and what should happen next time. Gift link 👇
Apoorva and Fauci are in the finals for who did the most harm to children in the 21st century. A fearmongering, incompetent reporter vs a political savvy, deceitful scientist.
Apoorva's lies about a South Korean government report were the pivot point that resulted in widespread school disruptions to start the 2020-21 school year. It was obvious she was lying at the time. She is still lying. The New York Times is an evil institution.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The American Academy of Pediatrics reversed its open-the-schools guidance in a literal joint statement with Becky Pringle's teachers union.
Her lesson learned is: "listen to the fake experts I control."
Five years later:
Guy who recommended people would wear shitty chinese plastic masks worried about seabirds.
What's healthier Seed oil or Butter?
I breakdown a new @jamaim paper
Here is a frequency chart of corrections in the @nytimes from our analysis
Guess who is #1, and the red means that her shitty articles falsely overstated the risk of COVID, leading parents to panic and pull their kids from school or cover little toddlers mouths with cloth
The fact that Apoorva Mandavilli still has a job at the New York Times tells you all you need to know about what level of accountability there’s gonna be for our elite class.
I don't know why the newspaper is asking the people who were literally wrong about every decision what went wrong. If we never funded these pandemic experts, we would have been better off!
I agree with Anthony. Sorry, @mtosterholm, but it wasn't the "force of the pandemic" that shut down the economy.
I traveled to Panama City Beach in July 2020, and there was lots of activity at our hotel, the pool, stores, ice cream shops, beach-side bars...
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
😅Poor "scientists"...
“EcoHealth became the subject of conspiracy theorists about the origin of COVID”
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-00681-4?linkId=13441816
Today's SF standard
A potent reminder of what happens when you listen to hysterical "scientists"
NIH cuts is the 2025 hysteria
SCOOP: Tomorrow's NYTimes will ask the greatest scientific experts why trust in Science has hit rock bottom
Spoiler alert: His name is JOSEPH JAMES ROGAN! 🤣🤣🤣
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
In an editorial in @nytopinion today correctly criticizing the Trump admin attacks on universities, the editors make a remarkable admission: "many professors and university administrators acted in recent years as liberal ideologues rather than seekers of empirical truth. 1/
Two things are true
1. Science rarely leads to huge advances!
2. The NIH is a 47 billion dollar leaking bucket, a mess of irreproducible science, buzzword funding & no accountability bc it keeps pointing to the fact it still moves a little water successfully
Too many people take biomedical innovation for granted.
I am a strong believer the majority of NIH funded projects are of low quality or irreproducible but even I can't believe they funded this. How is that possible?!
A Columbia professor’s NIH-funded study linking historical lynchings to negative cognitive health outcomes for black people fails to meet basic scientific standards of rigor and validity.
@jaypgreene reports ⬇️
www.realityslaststand.com/p/the-quackery-of-columbias-rac…
I haven't seen Fauci scrubbed like that since the House requested his emails!
1) A couple weeks ago I got a tip: NIH had pulled down a mural of Dr Fauci, this person had heard.
I found sources who confirmed, yes, *something* had been removed from a wall.
But they couldn’t quite agree on what hung there before — a masked Fauci? — or when it came down.
Today's New York times is quoting "experts" who did things like this. I don't think we will learn from our mistakes by listening to the same mistaken people.
Yes. I wore a mask while running earlier.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is a good point. Hanage is saying we couldn't open schools in the fall because we didn't have what we needed to do it "safely." Meanwhile, many schools DID open, proving it absolutely could be done. The "experts" are just unwilling to accept that fact.
The Hanage quote, and the very fact that this same insular list of "experts" is always referenced, is infuriating. The same old narrative
Good essay
At the 5 year anniversary of lockdowns & covid madness, no one has said: you were right, we were wrong, and we are sorry to have put you through hell.
So forgive me, I'm pissed off still. For all of the children who were harmed. And myself, too.
This is what happens when you take top science and try to replicate the basic finding.
It's dishonest not to admit that there is a huge problem in science.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
@nature is missing one figure about how the NIH is doing a perfect job, and that is the rate of taking the an experiment and replicating it by a different team.
Wonder why this chart didn't make the cut?
How the @NIH dominates the world’s health research — in charts. Great comments by @MiriamMerad www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-00754-4
@nature is missing one figure about how the NIH is doing a perfect job, and that is the rate of taking the an experiment and replicating it by a different team.
Wonder why this chart didn't make the cut?
How the @NIH dominates the world’s health research — in charts. Great comments by @MiriamMerad www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-00754-4
I dont think using an opaque modeling study funded by conflicted groups (ppl who want NIH funding) is a good way to "fight" for NIH funding.
Why not ask Haliburton if the Iraq war generated good ROI?
NIH Grants Fueled $95 Billion In FY 2024 Economic Activity, Finds New Report www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2025/03/12/nih-grant…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
We shouldn't be funding scientific grants based on buzzwords: Whatever is in fashion today, will not be in fashion in 5 years.
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/easy-come-easy-g… via @VPrasadMDMPH
It's better than the usual NYT but imo still not honest about reproducibility and fraud and toe fearmongering. But it is nice to see the times admit unis messed up. But follow up with a quote by the lunatic liberal Holden Thorpe is not good. Holden harms science daily.
Excellent, well-balanced editorial comment by @nytopinion . University leaders should see the present turmoil as a pivotal moment to defend their values and value to society while also engaging in fundamental reform to enhance their value to society and recommit themselves to those values. 1/4 @VPrasadMDMPH @adamcifu @DrJBhattacharya @kevinnbass @drjohnm @mroth78 @GeBaiDC
www.nytimes.com/2025/03/15/opinion/trump-research-cuts.ht…
Tragic, each year someone dies from a baseball hitting the chest. Of course, no one's going to (nor should) stop baseball. These risks are meaningless unless you quantify them.
Dad took his 12-year-old for a cold plunge. A bit of bonding thru wellness. The kid had just warmed up in the hot tub. He jumped in, gasped, and went under
By the time they pulled him out, his heart had stopped. I coded him for over an hour before I told his dad he was dead.🧵👇
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is astonishingly bad reporting and so absurd for an "expert" to say, it's almost unreal.
Tens of millions of kids were in school in Europe (and, later, in mostly red parts of the US).
The lack of effect was known AT THE TIME.
My book–out 4/22–destroys this myth and more
Apoorva out with a new article in which she defends the Spring 2020 school closures necessary, but, "Ideally, schools would have reopened that fall. " And she cites Jeffrey Shaman, an epidemiologist at Columbia University, who says "we don't have the counterfactual...to see how it really would have played out" if schools had opened sooner. 🤦🏼♀️
My latest
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I really like that once a buzzword now a liability description.
Important article in today's @Sensible__Med
If you're forced to have a vaccine, and injured by it, the system for compensation is broken.
Not all Columbia's NIH grants were cancelled
My best guess is that this type of rhetoric in the grant led to the cancellations
Ironically, this rhetoric was likely instrumental in slipping a grant through the NIH under Biden
Tip: remove this language from future grant proposals
Probably many of the cancelled grants mentioned diversity or equity-- which were buzzwords used to get favorable reviews under Biden, and now are liabilities used to decide what to cut. If anything it speaks to how broken the system is. Buzzwords get you funded. Europeans often stunned these grants needed to fund salaries as universities pocket indirects and don't provide security.
🚨This week, many Columbia scientists lost grants that funded over half their annual income. Others will no longer be able to do research that helps treat thousands of sick patients across the US.
"It hurts," they told me.
My story for @Nature 🧪
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-00812-x
Just fyi. Not all Columbia grants were cancelled. Probably 1/3. How did they pick? See above
Lung cancer screening takes many people who just want to be left alone and forces them into a endless torture of biopsies and treatment. All without a survival benefit. I wrote about one person in one of my most popular articles on sensible medicine
www.sensible-med.com/p/i-just-want-to-work-on-my-car
Just a reminder, if you do an empirical analysis of covid-19 corrections, there's only one reporter that's off the charts in getting things wrong to serve an agenda
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.08.02.24311424v1
Apoorva's lies about a South Korean government report were the pivot point that resulted in widespread school disruptions to start the 2020-21 school year. It was obvious she was lying at the time. She is still lying. The New York Times is an evil institution.
Who better than the most incompetent New York Times reporter quoting the most incorrect "experts" to tell us what we got wrong!
Apoorva out with a new article in which she defends the Spring 2020 school closures necessary, but, "Ideally, schools would have reopened that fall. " And she cites Jeffrey Shaman, an epidemiologist at Columbia University, who says "we don't have the counterfactual...to see how it really would have played out" if schools had opened sooner. 🤦🏼♀️
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Apoorva's lies about a South Korean government report were the pivot point that resulted in widespread school disruptions to start the 2020-21 school year. It was obvious she was lying at the time. She is still lying. The New York Times is an evil institution.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
“Hey can you put a quick order in?”
The process 👇
It's a 3-10 minute process.
1. wake up computer
2. type password
3. 2 factor auth via phone app
4. Click clinic EMR button
5. password
6. password again
7. Click inpatient EMR button
8. password
9. click Cerner.
10. click xray tab
11. password
12. slowly die inside
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
To all the physicians & scientists who are complaining about grant cuts at big universities, how come no one is asking for cuts in admin , bureaucracy which take up the indirect cost
Those dollars can fund so much science
@VPrasadMDMPH @anish_koka
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
University leaders are going to find it difficult to defend their institutional values when they betrayed them so egregiously during the covid fiasco.
@Stanford censured public policy expert @ScottAtlas_IT for being right about lockdowns and school closures.
@Harvard pushed out vaccine expert @MartinKulldorff for being right about covid vaccine policy.
@UCIrvine fired medical ethics expert @AaronKheriatyMD for being right about natural immunity and defending the principle of informed consent.
Universities can lead the process of public reconciliation by apologizing publicly to these courageous leaders and everyone else injured by their erroneous covid policies. @VPrasadMDMPH @DrJBhattacharya
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/3/14/enos-levitsky-harvar…
Closing schools for years - Hopkins sat down
Masking toddlers - Hopkins sits down
Vaccine mandates - Hopkins sits down
Cutting their admin budget - Hopkins stands up for 'science '
Scientists, researchers, and advocates recently gathered in Washington, D.C. for the Stand Up for Science rally. Voices from Johns Hopkins and across the globe spoke on the importance of continued investment in scientific progress. hub.jhu.edu/2025/03/10/stand-up-for-science-2025/
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Johns Hopkins could have Stood Up for Science by opposing mask and vaccine mandates or by acknowledging the lab leak as a legitimate possibility and not a conspiracy theory, but of course they’d never do that because their institutional ideology wouldn’t allow for it
Scientists, researchers, and advocates recently gathered in Washington, D.C. for the Stand Up for Science rally. Voices from Johns Hopkins and across the globe spoke on the importance of continued investment in scientific progress. hub.jhu.edu/2025/03/10/stand-up-for-science-2025/
It takes real courage to work at a university and oppose Trump! Almost heroic. Second only to the soldiers at D-Day. I don't know how they find the strength!
Is Johns Hopkins University the first university that used its official account to report the rally? My respect to the leadership! These are brave people at JHU.
Scientists, researchers, and advocates recently gathered in Washington, D.C. for the Stand Up for Science rally. Voices from Johns Hopkins and across the globe spoke on the importance of continued investment in scientific progress. hub.jhu.edu/2025/03/10/stand-up-for-science-2025/
I know JamaIM wants to "resist" Trump
But publishing extremely flawed research to try to validate safflower seed oil, doesn't actually help anyone.
This paper is bad.
It's important to retain scientific standards
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/is-seed-oil-better-than-butter-a
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
At early or mid stage startups it is not unusual for the engineers to be the highest paid employees in the company. In some casss the top 10 highest paid employees will be working on products. In that scenario the c-suite will get rich if the vision they have is executed and works - so they invest in execution and have a vision.
In academia the c-suite gets rich, have no vision, and spend nothing on execution.
I personally know many 7-figure academic managers, and honestly even if I like many of these ppl, the truth is if they lost their job they'd have to take a 75% pay cut to find another job outside academia in the private sector and some couldn't find any job. Make it make sense?!
Universities punished faculty who opposed lockdowns, mandatory DEI training, masking toddlers, & mandating a vaccine that didn't stop covid. Now, they are trying to suppress folks who say indirects are too high.
The public response, via election, is predictable & justified.
Interesting article that misses the mark. The backlash against American universities is largely self-inflicted. They have allowed political and intellectual monocultures to develop on their campuses, stifled free speech, and failed to stand up for the principles that made them great. They are increasingly run as profit-oriented multinational corporations and not as communities engaged in the search for truth and beauty.
They are largely run by uninspiring grey-mouse corporate bureaucrats unable or unwilling to articulate their foundational principles. We need Bart Giamattis, but they are nowhere to be found.
The full measure of their failure is shown by how easily they all caved to govt-directed covid tyranny, locked down their campuses, enforced censorship, and marginalized anyone who spoke out against it all.
It is unfortunate, but they are reaping what they have sown. They should be looking inward and correcting their failures, engaging in fundamental reform. Instead, they will likely blame it all on one orange man.
Trump is launching America’s version of the Cultural Revolution @FareedZakaria @PostOpinions @VPrasadMDMPH @kevinnbass @DrJBhattacharya @MartinKulldorff www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/03/14/trump-colleges…
That's right. Many NIH grants should be terminated for addressing topics of no value to the American people, using methods so poor, you cannot advance knowledge, hiding data & even engaging in analytic manipulation/ fraud. Not policing this is the issue!
Amazing quote. Yes, that's the problem!
Emily is 100% correct. Universities do not randomly sample experiments with their logo and check if they can be reproduced. They refuse to share data. When presented with fraud, they cover it up
And they need 67% indirects to make sure they maintain this 'research integrity'
Nobody suffered consequences other than CEO Laurie Glimcher being demoted to a different job at Dana Farber. All of the other implicated scientists still have their jobs, @OxygenIvan tells me. Our current system incentivizes fraud. Being dishonest is a competitive advantage.
Very interesting. Did not know this.
1/ Most people still don’t realize that Psilocybin Therapy is LEGAL in Oregon. You don’t have to wait the years that it will take for psilocybin to get rescheduled at the federal level.
So how are mushrooms legal in Oregon?🧵👇
Admin making 1 mil plus believe indirects are just fine at 65%
Hospital admin will be making $1 million a year, pushing back compensation on primary care physicians working 50 hours a week, making $220,000/year.
My essay shows why Jama IM paper on plant oil vs butter is irredeemably flawed. I think it's bad when journals publish low quality science to push political arguments.
LinkedIn scaring me with this average career is 42 years long business. Seems long!
Adam's essay today in @Sensible__Med is very good. When journals get sloppy
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
A new @JAMAInternalMed paper claims that plant based oil is healthier than butter
It's part of JAMA's fight against #maha & Trump
But is it a miscalculation?
Is the paper: solid, NIH funded science?
Or is it: politically motivated, low credibility propaganda?
@calleymeans
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Vinay Prasad critiques a new JAMA paper claiming that seed oils are healthier than butter.
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/is-seed-oil-better-than-butter-a
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
It's ironic that billions of dollars are poured into AI cancer detection systems worldwide, yet the current screening methods they rely on don't actually improve overall mortality.
Breast cancer screening doesn't improve overall mortality. OR 1.01 in Cochrane. The acceptable rate is whatever women want. Silly article.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The analogy between school closures and the Iraq war is a somber reminder of the consequences of misguided policy. As a healthcare professional, I'm deeply concerned about the long-term impact on our children's well-being and the erosion of trust in public health decisions.
Yes! And NIH spends more money to coerce people to accept interventions that don't have clear evidence of improved survival. That is a problem.
The NLST and Nelson studies reveal a troubling pattern: we're funding interventions with uncertain benefits on overall survival. As healthcare professionals, we must champion evidence-based medicine that prioritizes clear, life-extending outcomes for our patients.
One of the big problems of NIH funding is that it increases the uptake of medical interventions that don't have evidence they improve outcomes. Lung cancer screening failed to improve all cause mortality in NLST and Nelson. see Pinsky JTO. It's a feel-good intervention that doesn't make people better off. Cause specific mortality suffers from attribution bias. And it does not include off-target harms. It is a poor endpoint.
Lung ca screening uptake is already low due to multilevel barriers. This type of misleading rhetoric isn’t helpful. The purpose of ca screening is to ⬇️ ca-specific mortality by detecting ca at early stage when more amenable to treatment, & in case of lung adenoCA, potential cure
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Reminds me of this
This is a good policy
For far too long, ingredient manufacturers and sponsors have exploited a loophole that has allowed new ingredients and chemicals, often with unknown safety data, to be introduced into the U.S. food supply without notification to the @FDA or the public. Eliminating the GRAS loophole will provide transparency to consumers, help get our nation’s food supply back on track by ensuring that ingredients being introduced into foods are safe, and ultimately Make America Healthy Again. Learn more:
www.hhs.gov/about/news/2025/03/10/hhs-secretary-kennedy-d…
Universities routinely publish research that cannot be reproduced, is fraudulent, or is of low societal value. Administrators take too much money. They turn a blind eye to these issues, and think they'll win in court. It will be a Pyrhic victory. Universities should be having debates on how they can do better rather than keep fighting this. The indirects are not going to stay at this rate forever. Only a fool thinks they'll be able to fight this in court and achieve victory. A smart person would realize that it's time to negotiate and we need to be constructive in how we have reform. Science did this to itself. It forfeited trust during the pandemic. Its approval rating is worse than Congress.
Can NIH overturn a court order blocking it from slashing overhead payments? Unlikely, one expert says | Science | AAAS www.science.org/content/article/can-nih-overturn-court-or…
This is the same groupthink that led many people to embrace lockdowns and school closure. The NIH cuts have been modest and many of these reforms are long overdue. Much of NIH research is silly or can’t be reproduced. The media coverage has rotten the brain of many scientists. US science will be fine. And the greater worry is if the status quo continues.
Just got the following message from a scientist at a top 25 school. He was one of a handful of scientists at his university who voted for Trump, and reports they're all now completely ashamed of it.
I am an NIH-funded biomedical scientist with conservative leanings. I know at least a dozen scientists (a small closeted minority) who voted for Trump, largely because of frustrations with DEI and extreme wokeness that had permeated every aspect of University life. Each one of us deeply regrets their vote for Trump and are utterly ashamed of it.
We are absolutely horrified at how mindlessly destructive this admin has been to scientific institutions. They are single-handedly destroying the STEM dominance US established over decades.
Average Americans simply do not realize that we are now on the verge of a precipitous decline in STEM. We all admit that the warnings about Trump/MAGA were on target, and the thing we argue about now is whether the damage is even reversible. All the Lefty overreach was annoying as hell but the MAGA disdain for science is 100X worse.
MAGA was already anti-intellectual, but many educated conservatives still held their noses and voted for Trump. DOGE just turned things up to 11, went beyond hostility to wokeness and turned into hostility to science and rational thought more generally. The way that fake news dominates this platform is simply another manifestation of this contempt for the mind.
What a tragedy this has been.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Is seed oil better than butter? A new paper says YES, but is the paper any good?
@JAMAInternalMed publishes anti-MAHA research, but is it good science or dirty politics?
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/is-seed-oil-bett… via @VPrasadMDMPH
Breast cancer screening doesn't improve overall mortality. OR 1.01 in Cochrane. The acceptable rate is whatever women want. Silly article.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"This paper is not science; It is closer to propaganda. And given the political overtones, it may be considered politically motivated or a form of campaigning. It is like the cloth masking studies that were used in the pandemic to justify absurd policy."
A new @JAMAInternalMed paper claims that plant based oil is healthier than butter
It's part of JAMA's fight against #maha & Trump
But is it a miscalculation?
Is the paper: solid, NIH funded science?
Or is it: politically motivated, low credibility propaganda?
@calleymeans
Four years later: How do you think this prediction has aged?
School closure is like the Iraq war
Didn't make us safer
We embarked on it due to inaccurate info
Millions of children were harmed
Public sentiment will shift
Many will on the wrong side of history
It was a mistake
BMJ used to be a good journal, but during COVID they screwed up and preferentially published zero COVID propaganda by fearful epidemiologists who had the luxury of WFH while ordering Uber eats
Shameful performance documented in this new paper
bmjopenquality.bmj.com/content/14/1/e003131
A new @JAMAInternalMed paper claims that plant based oil is healthier than butter
It's part of JAMA's fight against #maha & Trump
But is it a miscalculation?
Is the paper: solid, NIH funded science?
Or is it: politically motivated, low credibility propaganda?
@calleymeans
You are about 3-4 years too late to help anyone with this research
Too many authors
Completely outdated
Really exemplifies how research can be so distant from actually helping people, and can be a jobs program for upper-middle class people
Good news!!!!
NOW — The Senate HELP Committee advances Trump’s FDA & NIH nominees, @MartyMakary and @DrJBhattacharya, to a full senate vote 🔥
I found this interesting
Semiglutide on weight (bottom) vs drinking (top)
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
on a related note, we can basically just 3d print oil paintings now? with texture accuracy down to 4μm? it's pretty neat.
i asked my dad, longtime full-time professional oil painter, if he was worried about ai art and he said that was the stupidest thing he'd ever heard because the ai isn't making physical oil paintings & has nothing to do with him. fair points
I analyzed the data for the critic's claim - that unprofessional students become unprofessional docs-- a few years ago. It was very bad data.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10401334.2011.611780…
Most reviews of my novel The Gunner have been positive, but one person did not like that I poked fun at medical school professionalism enforcement. He/she wrote: "It's true, professionalism and wellness activities aren't always the best, but the literature continues to show unprofessional students are likely to become unprofessional physicians." Read this entire review for yourself and let me know if you agree or disagree. www.amazon.com/gp/customer-reviews/R1LLT8VPZ5LADV?ASIN=19…
No. None of these authors understand the key issue. Car T was first developed in myeloma in 2014. The first report of Parkinson's disease was 2021. If you use this endpoint, you're going to be approving nonsense in the front line that's going to cause neurological disease and paralyze people and you will do it to people who have a median survival of 15 years. Parkinson's disease is not something you can sweep under the rug.
Accelerating Myeloma Drug Development: Will Minimal Residual Disease Replace Progression-Free Survival as an Intermediate Surrogate End Point? | Journal of Clinical Oncology ascopubs.org/doi/full/10.1200/JCO-25-00048?bid=470058004&…
Stupid
Lung cancer screening doesn't actually improve all cause mortality. Long-Term follow-up of nlst is negative as is Nelson. This grant should have been terminated for different reasons. The media doesn't appreciate how bad the NIH funding system is.
Really a super analysis of the law
"Anyone who says the law is obvious here is not telling the truth," writes @Jed_Rubenfeld on the case of Mahmoud Khalil.
Everything you need to know about the legality of that case is right here in @TheFP:
www.thefp.com/p/both-left-and-right-are-wrong-about
Least useful things to do:
3 Put a half drunk can of soda in the fridge for use later
2 Sign a petition
1 Call your congressperson
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
If the cuts include a similar 15% cap on indirects to NIH , then the actual $$ spent on research would not change .
Catastrophic research funding cuts continue - this time w/ the DoD’s proposed reduction of the Congressionally Directed Medical Research Programs by $859 million (57%). These programs are critical for rare cancers,TBI, spinal cord injuries & disorders affecting service members.
Yes! Take the L
This is my advice. Universities should take the lead on admitting that indirects are too high. They're suppressing debate on campus and suing they're going to lose
NEW: Many at Columbia want to sue over the cancelled NIH grants, but an internal source says it’s possible the university will “take the L to stop the bleeding.”
Reports are that the administration is preparing a “plan forward” that will respond to the government’s concerns.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Totally agree. “while we have great confidence for some products, for others there is massive uncertainty.”
This is truly important. Not all vaccines are equal and each has different sets of data. So there’s the importance of proper education rather than blanket statements
Ffs They look at four time points 2,6,9 and 12 mos
It's only significant at two time points
No adjustment for multiple testing
Before you pop the champagne, better to run a replication study with adequate sample size.
HPV vaccination reduces the risk of a range of cancers (cervical, genital, oropharyngeal)
This randomised trial found that HPV vaccination also reduces the burden of actinic keratoses, a precursor of the skin cancer, squamous cell carcinoma
(The trial only ran for 12 months, so whether this actually translates to reduced skin cancer isn't yet clear)
And the end point I would like to look at is cumulative procedure volume, And maybe include an arm where a person is just followed by an internist.
Also the control arm should be both saline to figure out the side effects and then any other vaccine to see if it's just a non-specific response to immune stimulation.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The ban by Big Tech on debating or questioning the origins of COVID -- based on that fraudulent and corrupt Lancet letter organized by Fauci labeling the lab leak theory racist disinformation, as well as due to Biden Administration coercion -- was shameful and grave repression:
german foreign intelligence: 80-90% likelihood covid-19 accidentally released from china’s wuhan institute of virology
Our new paper out now analyzes the risk, benefit and outcomes of 10 years of vemurafenib studies
@vkprasadlab
www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/20450885.2025.2463830
Lol, so true
never met a man who hates costco. it transcends race, class, and creed. i’d trust a costco hospital with my life. i’d send my kids to costco daycare. i’d be laid to rest in a kirkland signature casket
In my post today I pull up nih-funded papers on defunded topics in reverse chronological order, and review them. They suck.
Media is confusing "Is this topic important" with "Is this research helping?" they're different questions.
It was great to talk AI yesterday with rural hospital CEOs
AI has potential to flatten the rural-urban divide
On Today's @Sensible__Med we discuss how
Peter Marks picked the COVID-19 fall target with an analogy to buying milk
Who should decide what the targets are?
Agree with this analysis
I was simply not familiar with Newsom’s game until this podcast.
Watch how he handles a direct hit on one of his top political weaknesses.
At 0:19, Charlie Kirk interrupts Newsom with a jab: “You canceled school for like two years!”
Newsom gamely laughs - not a fake laugh - and comes back with a compliment, “The point is, you are making a damn dent.”
Kirk smiles, says, “Thank you” and adds a conciliatory, “I’m kidding.”
The exchange ends with Kirk inviting Newsom’s son to a Turning Point event as they both chuckle.
If you don’t know him, Charlie Kirk is one of the top right wing activists in the country and an extremely gifted debater.
I was initially derisive of this podcast but clearly Newsom has off the charts political instincts. Now he’s rightwashing his past as he moves to the middle.
If he spends the next few years sparring, honing his arguments, and deploying his charm with opponents the way he does here, all while building a larger audience, he will be a menace on the presidential debate stage.
Honestly, better than I would have guessed
In other news doctors actually still enjoy doing pediatrics, because they’re not doing it for the money.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Bar School on Monday with @VPrasadMDMPH was a hit!!
The people love lectures 🫡😎
Each year ~85% of science PhD students don't get PI jobs and have to pivot to other types of work/ careers. That is because we train too many. Bc they are cheap labor for labs. Similarly, many of these workers will also need to pivot.
This is the definition of garbage in, garbage out. People who drink are different than those who don't, and these studies can't separate those differences from alcohol's effect. Vivek Murthy made enough mistakes with covid, but he wasn't happy. He wanted to make one last one.
Alcohol cancer risk . What u need to know. Nice article in @Nature by @hcpearson .
Must to know for all those who drink 🍸 alcohol ( I anyways don't drink 😀 ) www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-00729-5
We have no idea if moderate drinking is helpful, harmful, or neutral. And we should have the humility to say we don't know. Not issue fear-mongering warnings.
Great to speak last night at the After Work Bar. Packed house.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Not many medical and public health experts had courage to write un 2020 about how unscientific was "follow the science" stuff. It was dangerous for one's carrier then, now it's fashionable and easy to do so.
Nov 2020
www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/89856
"Follow the Science" is a good candidate for the worst marketing slogan in history. Should be a case study at @HarvardHBS @StanfordGSB @Wharton
Nov 2020
www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/89856
"Follow the Science" is a good candidate for the worst marketing slogan in history. Should be a case study at @HarvardHBS @StanfordGSB @Wharton
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Mifepristone and abortion
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"Trump cuts Columbia's grants over handling of student protests: Should he include universities that violated academic freedom?" www.drvinayprasad.com/p/trump-cuts-columbias-grants-over?…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
“Fauci and his ilk didn’t follow the science, they betrayed it.” Five years too late, after so much damage done, the media is finally starting to tell the truth.
It took five years from the initiation of covid lockdown for this to appear in the Boston Globe. Now that the dam has finally broken, in another 5 years, I expect that Dr. Fauci will be as popular as bubonic plague. Time to go short on Fauci bobbleheads... archive.ph/GFxWf
. @JohnWAyersPhD told me "it will ruin other cars for you"
A few months later I knew what he meant
The acceleration
Comfort
Handling
Center of mass
Quiet
Full auto drive
One pedal driving
Navigation
And phone app
Ruined the ability to drive another car
I’m very happy with my Tesla. I recently upgraded my model 3 to a model Y.
Last week I drove 8 hours to Tennessee and we only had to stop four times for ten minutes each. It wasn’t out of the way or inconvenient because we needed to use the bathroom, eat, and switch drivers anyway.
I might even buy Starlink Internet next. I will continue to support good companies.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I am giving a lecture at a Bar tonight in SF
There are a few tickets left
Proceeds go to charity
Sign up!
lu.ma/1jmiav2j
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
From Vinay Prasad, MD, MPH, professor of Epidemiology and Biostatistics and Medicine, and a practicing Hematologist Oncologist at San Francisco General Hospital.
And the NIH director is.... Jay Bhattacharya! What to expect in his con... youtu.be/sPm8IbdwDaM via @YouTube
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I recommend reading this. It's a concise explanation of Vinay Prasad's 5 Takeaways from the hearings on our new FDA commissioner. Sounds like a fantastic pick, and someone whose viewpoints have been needed at the top of the FDA for a long, long time. Now he just has to execute them!
And the new FDA commissioner is.... Marty Makary www.drvinayprasad.com/p/and-the-new-fda-commissioner-is-m…
I am giving a lecture at a Bar tonight in SF
There are a few tickets left
Proceeds go to charity
Sign up!
lu.ma/1jmiav2j
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is an advert to all students hoping to match into Baylor pediatrics: Don't Go!
Also isn't it strange while they were investigating this student a literal "Dr Death" was practicing at Baylor maiming and killing one patient after the other www.dmagazine.com/publications/d-magazine/2016/november/c…
New video on Marty coming soon (you know where)
This is a clip of the last few minutes
Thanks to @jbcarmody
I got the journal wrong, but the points still valid & funny!
@adamcifu @TheEpiExpert
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
New video on Marty coming soon (you know where)
This is a clip of the last few minutes
Thanks to @jbcarmody
I got the journal wrong, but the points still valid & funny!
@adamcifu @TheEpiExpert
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
What’s breath of fresh air! Fauci and Collins are gone. Vinay Prasad on the new FDA Commissioner
And the new FDA commissioner is... Marty Makary. Funny, smart, and hone... youtu.be/Q8gZVEdCHHQ via @YouTube
No one took away more opportunities from public school kids than Randi. She demanded that school teachers get vaccines first just so that they could evade working.
Randi Weingarten just had a total MELTDOWN on MSNBC over Trump’s plan to abolish the Department of Education.
"I'M REALLY ANGRY ABOUT THIS!"
"I'M REALLY ANGRY!"
Mifepristone and abortion
Complete agree. In 2021 I wrote that children shouldn't wear cloth masks in the Atlantic magazine, and many people wanted me to be fired. The pendulum will swing so hard on this stupidity, it will hit you in the face.
It took five years from the initiation of covid lockdown for this to appear in the Boston Globe. Now that the dam has finally broken, in another 5 years, I expect that Dr. Fauci will be as popular as bubonic plague. Time to go short on Fauci bobbleheads... archive.ph/GFxWf
Fauci, Collins and most universities worked to silence faculty. They threatened you like the mafia. It was despicable behavior.
If you want to feel entirely defeated and crazy, read this @BostonGlobe piece that repeats everything you said 5 years ago and were hated, spit upon, shouted at, fired, canceled, sidelined, and defriended for doing so.
archive.ph/GFxWf
Agree. This is the real lesson
It sounded like the student wanted to engage anonymously but was “unwilling to do a video conference”.
There is a serious criticism here: med students have no way to give anonymous feedback without fear of retribution, such as what is demonstrated here.
Hahaha what happens is: over the years. Different attendings complain the note is missing x or y or z
The only outcome is to include anything
It is now unreadable
Whoever told/tells students and residents to write these long monstrosity system based notes is wrong and guilty of war crimes.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The people upset about about this had nothing to say about tenured Penn law professor being suspended for voicing unpopular opinions.
The Trump admin is going after students who have used their first amendment, Constitutional rights.
This is unacceptable. Deporting legal residents solely for expressing their political opinions is a violation of free speech rights. Who's next? Citizens?
apnews.com/article/columbia-university-mahmoud-khalil-ice…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Bizarre all around — on all levels.
Is the public supposed to accept this is the work product of academic medicine?
How much did they pay the journal to publish this dismal article?
And not sure of the cautionary tale— the student was wouldn’t rank their program!!
Both the students behavior and the team investigating this strike me as bizarre. Writing this up with 6 authors and making a figure?!? 6 authors? A figure?
They tell the story like how they caught Dahmer!
Med-ed has too much time on their hands.
Why an applicant would use a pseudonym to send a complaining email, 9 days before rank lists were due, to a residency program at which they’d done an away rotation and a research project (and at which they were ranked highly) is beyond me.
But anyhow, now they’re on PubMed.
Fauci violated federal policy & routed money to Wuhan through ecohealth
then when the pandemic hit, he panicked
recommended closing schools, lockdowns and masking toddlers
tried to silence dissent
ran zero rcts on npis
pushed remdesivir
hid his emails
buddied up to Ds for pardon
For anyone who was cancelled during covid — and yes I mean really cancelled … bullied, threatened, lost friends and family and jobs — this is infuriating.
I recommend not reading this if you were an early covid dissenter. You won’t be able to contain your anger.
New video on Marty coming soon (you know where)
This is a clip of the last few minutes
Thanks to @jbcarmody
I got the journal wrong, but the points still valid & funny!
@adamcifu @TheEpiExpert
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Read the paper, they were mad bc he was critical of their program! So instead of doing anything about that they made "getting this kid to shut the hell up!" their goal. Kinda reminds you of those Tony Fauci and F Collins guys, doesn't it? Maybe we have a larger cultural problem.
Both the students behavior and the team investigating this strike me as bizarre. Writing this up with 6 authors and making a figure?!? 6 authors? A figure?
They tell the story like how they caught Dahmer!
Med-ed has too much time on their hands.
Why an applicant would use a pseudonym to send a complaining email, 9 days before rank lists were due, to a residency program at which they’d done an away rotation and a research project (and at which they were ranked highly) is beyond me.
But anyhow, now they’re on PubMed.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Hosting a talk tomorrow with @VPrasadMDMPH lecturing on paradoxes in human health!
Sign up here: lu.ma/1jmiav2j
We did a video on this and wrote about it. This trial has big problems
DYNAMIC out now with 5 year data
Stage II colon cancer using ctDNA adapted strategy @NatureMedicine
❗️Non-inferior statistically, but should note a clinically significant difference in outcomes among T4 patients (81% vs 70% RFS and 90% vs 80% OS). Have to question those NI margins…
Looks great on paper, but challenging to translate into clinical practice…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Ironic that people now, all of a sudden, care about these institutions.
Where’s the uproar about 340B? Quality metrics? EHR mandates? Medicare conditions of participation? The physician owned hospital ban? Certificate of need laws? DSH payments?
The federal forces targeting independent hospitals and clinics have been active for decades.
But now, all of a sudden, we care?
🚨🚨
Few seats remain. If you are in SF Monday. Come to my talk
Want to hear a lecture from a doctor who will tell you the truth about medicine? Come to Bar School next Monday and hear from @VPrasadMDMPH
Register here: lu.ma/1jmiav2j
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Our new paper w/ @VPrasadMDMPH is out in JCP today!
19th St Gallen starts in 3 days!
Couldn't be more timely!
A hot Q was raised at 18th Conf – likely a similar Q will come up again:
"Should we combine adjuvant drugs that were tested in isolation in phase 3 trials?"
🧵1/9
Anyone in San Francisco is welcome to my talk this Monday. Sign up. Only a few spots left.
Want to hear a lecture from a doctor who will tell you the truth about medicine? Come to Bar School next Monday and hear from @VPrasadMDMPH
Register here: lu.ma/1jmiav2j
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Want to hear a lecture from a doctor who will tell you the truth about medicine? Come to Bar School next Monday and hear from @VPrasadMDMPH
Register here: lu.ma/1jmiav2j
This is interesting.
New research shows bigger animals get more cancer, defying decades-old belief
theconversation.com/new-research-shows-bigger-animals-get…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Bruh, if I wanted to rummage through random personal shit, I could have done that at PAYPAL. Hello???
Having tens of millions of people marked in Social Security as “ALIVE” when they are definitely dead is a HUGE problem.
Obviously.
Some of these people would have been alive before America existed as a country. Think about that for a second …
I want to save billions of your money and make our government more efficient.
Rummaging through your personal shit is *not* that.
A party of chaos loses—always.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
There should be a limit on the age of PI, similar to air traffic controllers (56), FBI (57), pilots (65), etc. where these older PIs move away from vacuuming the resources into a supporting role.
I don't think outsiders understanding how perverse the incentives are for older PIs. The norm is for PIs to leverage the labor of others and suck all the credit. At best they have an abstract understanding of the actual science. Worse they are clueless. Regardless the junior faculty and postdocs working with them aren't mentored on the fundamentals of science and the work is low quality, irreproducible, junk science.
An age limit handles the above. And the great PIs don't need to leave to obscurity. They can transition to mentoring roles that supports the logistics of novel innovations from rising talents. That is actually how I perceived my role in my 30s and now my initiation to the 40s. It is more rewarding to be a mentor.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
As someone whose youngest daughter was born during the COVID lockdowns and who was repeatedly blocked from seeing his dying father at the hospital *in 2022*, these policies were infuriating.
I'm still not over it.
New Paper Just out
We revisit the draconian and unethical patient visitor restrictions during the pandemic
How did it become so widely accepted to let people die alone?
scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://escholarship.o…
In 20 years, NIH leadership and universities have done literally nothing to address this issue.
If you just try to recreate experiments. You can only do it 10 -40% of the time.
No one stood up for reproducible science
Read this debate on indirects ICYMI
Are Trump’s NIH cuts a sensible way to make research more efficient? Or will they threaten the development of cures that could save millions of lives? We asked two oncologists we trust—David Andorsky and @VPrasadMDMPH—to debate this important issue: thefp.pub/4bwnu9y
Also look at all these NIH grants to fund this low-credibility nutritional epidemiology paper
Fascinating how people can't admit the NIH funds bad work. This is a great e.g.
@calleymeans
People who CHOSE to eat butter were DIFFERENT 👇in other ways (less health conscious)
It is interesting when BS/ low-credibility science is published to support 1 side when the argument has taken on political notes (see also Masking kids)
@calleymeans, the rot is deep in medicine
People who CHOSE to eat butter were DIFFERENT 👇in other ways (less health conscious)
It is interesting when BS/ low-credibility science is published to support 1 side when the argument has taken on political notes (see also Masking kids)
@calleymeans, the rot is deep in medicine
also lumping olive oil with soybean oil is odd
My essays on Marty and Jay explore what they actually said during the hearings-- not the over simplified summaries in the media
now read by 100,000+ people
Links in replies
The big breakthroughs happen 70-75
A lot of US scientists I know who run labs who are 60 or older are talking about retiring now/soon. The tradition in this country has been for labs to remain running until lab heads were in their 70s-80s... It will be interesting to see how this impacts the younger generation.
Just out on @Sensible__Med I review a new web-tool that shows all the conflicts at the CDC's vaccine advisory committee meeting
@SecKennedy must reform this space to regain trust
Stand up for science....
Sit down for:
Reproducibility
Stopping fraud
Data sharing
Academic freedom
Truth telling
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/what-stand-up-for-science-rallies
Stanford censured Scott Atlas for saying:
Schools should be open
Kids shouldn't mask
Lockdowns were bad misguided policy
Should schools receive Federal funding if they don't allow faculty to engage in policy debates? If faculty can be censured for holding correct positions?
The majority of science is conceptually flawed, does not reproduce, is not useful, or worse: the product of fraud.
Multiple empirical and theoretical analyses show this rate is upwards of 50%
Easy to stand up for your salary, harder to stand up for science
My latest (see link)
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Breast oncology!
In a few days is the 19th St. Gallen Conf
A hot Q was raised during the 18th conference – likely a similar Q will come up again:
"Should we combine adjuvant drugs that were tested in isolation in phase 3 trials?"
Our take w/@VPrasadMDMPH… think about it!
Ironically. These sell outs let Martin go for the crime of being correct.
Members of @CDCgov's vaccine advisory board (ACIP) have been funded by / worked with @pfizer, @moderna_tx, @AstraZeneca, @JanssenUS, @TakedaPharma, @Merck, @sanofi, @Seqirus, @BavarianNordic, @Novavax, @GSK, @Novartis
and other vaccine manufacturers.
www.cdc.gov/acip/disclosures/by-member.html
Universities cancelling PhD programs and pausing pilot grants
But the Dean is still paid 2 mil
That's why we need indirects @dailypenn
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
100% agree
In 20 years, NIH leadership and universities have done literally nothing to address this issue.
If you just try to recreate experiments. You can only do it 10 -40% of the time.
No one stood up for reproducible science
Single best publication on drug development. For industry insiders. We don't dumb things down here.
Founded by @VPrasadMDMPH, co-edited by me.
Regular insights on pharmaceutical drug development–from early phase to FDA approval. Cancer drugs & beyond.
Exclusive content you won’t find anywhere else!
📩 Join thousands of subscribers.
Subscribe to the Drug Dev Letter today!
Just a reminder that Harvard has not apologized for this
Just a reminder that universities did this and have never apologized or paid any price
His job: medical ethicist
When @Amgen tried to replicate 53 papers, they could only do this 11% of the time
Stand up for science would mean addressing this
But everyone is incentivized not to care
Over the last 5 years, universities broke the social contract in many dimensions
Firing and marginalizing faculty who disagreed with Lord Fauci
Handling Protests poorly
Stiffling debate on topical issues
I suspect many in the public share Fetterman's view
Columbia let antisemitism run amok to cater to lunatic fringe and paid provocateurs.
Leadership allowed those assholes to take over the campus and terrorize Jewish students.
Now, Columbia pays for its failure and I support that.
If I travel for business, and submit my receipts, can I add on a 65% indirect rate to cover wear and tear on my suitcase and clothes and shoes & to hire a travel assistant and make them complete training modules? Actually make it 90%, Tnx
Stand up for science doesn't just mean asking for more money
It means
Transparently communicating where the money is spent
Ensuring research is reproducible
Protecting academic freedom
Assessing grant giving with RCTs
Status quo is abject failure on these points
I misread this! For a second I thought Frances Collins was warning that funding the Wuhan lab put us all at severe risk. But I guess he was saying that cutting the funding would. Got that backwards!
At ‘Stand Up for Science’ rally, Francis Collins warns major NIH research programs ‘at severe risk’ www.statnews.com/2025/03/07/stand-up-for-science-francis-… via @statnews @AnilOza16 Katherine MacPhail
Stand up for science doesn't just mean asking for more money
It means
Transparently communicating where the money is spent
Ensuring research is reproducible
Protecting academic freedom
Assessing grant giving with RCTs
Status quo is abject failure on these points
In the epilogue of my book Malignant, which I wrote in 2018, I explained how broken the NIH is, and called for a randomized control trial of NIH Grant giving. This was my schematic. My views on this topic have been the same for the last decade.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Incredible how so few could harm so many. One day the truth will come out ..”It’s not a conspiracy if it’s true”.. coming soon.
Beyond satire.
The administrators who want to keep the unaccountable indirects at 65% to fund their salary.
Who was responsible for putting those restrictions in place?
Congrats to @MartyMakary on a great hearing
Here are my 5 TAKE AWAYS
These panelists are all working with Pharma (often with grant support) to bring vaccines to market. They are incentivized to lower the bar at ACIP, which is what they have done.
It's not hard to find methods experts who haven't taken any money from pharma; Conflicted people can testify, but should not be voting.
CDC launched a new web tool today to increase the transparency of conflicts of interest for current and past ACIP members.
Learn more here ⬇️ www.cdc.gov/acip/disclosures/by-member.html
He claims to be standing up for science, but during the pandemic, even though he controlled the nation's grant funding, he conducted zero randomized studies of any non-pharmacological intervention.
That's an anti-science NIH director.
🚨 Former NIH Director Francis Collins is SINGING at an anti-Trump rally.
Wow! These corrupt doctors are the ones who decided that babies need covid shots.
If you run vaccine trials for Pfizer, the conflict doesn't go away when the trial ends, because you're going to run another one after you ram through their garbage products.
CDC launched a new web tool today to increase the transparency of conflicts of interest for current and past ACIP members.
Learn more here ⬇️ www.cdc.gov/acip/disclosures/by-member.html
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
It is hard to overstate the harsh cruelty of these restrictions , leaving so many to die alone and denying loved ones a chance to say goodbye.
New Paper Just out
We revisit the draconian and unethical patient visitor restrictions during the pandemic
How did it become so widely accepted to let people die alone?
scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://escholarship.o…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
His prior refrains:
"This proposal from three fringe epidemiologists ... seems to be getting a lot of attention. There needs to be a quick and devastating takedown of its premises."
"This EcoHealth grant and its connections to Wuhan have presented one of the most difficult and wrenching situations of my 11 years as NIH director. Most of that is not appropriate for email."
"Surely that wouldn't be done in a BSL-2 lab?"
"Wondering if there is something NIH can do to help put down this very destructive conspiracy."
🚨 Former NIH Director Francis Collins is SINGING at an anti-Trump rally.
He hides behind a religious 'folksy' 'nice guy's facade, but his conduct during the pandemic was deeply despicable. Damaging countless lives by smearing scientists who disagreed and creating a false consensus for the media. It un-does any of his accomplishments 100 times.
🚨 Former NIH Director Francis Collins is SINGING at an anti-Trump rally.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is really good 🙏
To let people die alone in the name of "protecting them from Covid" is one the most ridiculous and inhumane features of the Covid management. I'm fuming to this day...
New Paper Just out
We revisit the draconian and unethical patient visitor restrictions during the pandemic
How did it become so widely accepted to let people die alone?
scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://escholarship.o…
New Paper Just out
We revisit the draconian and unethical patient visitor restrictions during the pandemic
How did it become so widely accepted to let people die alone?
scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://escholarship.o…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Yeah but some will say "thats a stupid test." The real question that matters is "How intelligent is research at the highest level?" We reviewed a random sample of studies appearing in JAMA, NEJM, Lancet, AM J of Public Health.... Most don't bother to even interpret their statistical results but when they do 57% WRONGLY interpret the statistics (not the meaning of the study, the factual statistics). Taken together about 10% of studies in the top journals provide an accurate interpretation of their findings when using the most common statistic in medicine: Odds ratios. The @NIH should be addressing this as their number priority. Soon in @Sensible__Med I will be providing a roadmap to make science more public, accurate, and reproducible. ebm.bmj.com/content/26/4/184
4 out of 5 doctors at Harvard cannot answer a question from introductory statistics
This is a cancer therapeutic vaccine. Over 40 years we have trialed dozens of them. All* failed. This is in early phase trials. When tested in a large randomized trial, It will also fail.
*Provenge deprived control arm pts of docetaxel ftr
Here is Vinod Balachandran, the lead researcher on a team that just created an mRNA vaccine for pancreatic cancer, which has a 90% death rate.
His study showed that within five years, 75% of patients were both alive and cancer free, a miraculous result. mRNA technology for covid was of course pioneered by Katalin Karikó, a woman from rural Turkey.
We debate immigration and ideas, numbers and data. What gets me is the overwhelming gap between the accomplishments of scientists like this and the lives that they're saving on the one side, and the sense of mediocrity you get from immigration critics that is so overwhelming it's offensive. One guy is unlocking the mysteries of the cell and giving those who were doomed to a painful death more time on this earth with friends and family. The other is whining "I want whites to own the local 7/11."
For me, it's sometimes easier to be motivated by hate than a positive vision. Many people are like that. But if that's you, it's good to direct your hate at the right targets. Immigration restrictionists hate people because of what they look like or where they were born. That's wrong, and should be replaced by a feeling of hatred towards those who would deny humanity its ability to move forward because they need reasons to feel superior to others.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"...trust in science is at rock bottom in part because the NIH leadership worked to discredit and censor its critics... government should not fund research that could cause a pandemic... American people don’t trust universities with a blank check [with indirect costs]..."
Duh
Paxlovid May Offer Little Benefit for Vaccinated Older Adults www.drugs.com/news/paxlovid-may-offer-little-benefit-vacc…
Some thoughtful but sobering perspectives from members of the BUSPH community on the myriad ways a second Trump administration can harm the health and well-being of the public. But as the article says, “There’s no way through this but forward.”
www.bu.edu/sph/news/articles/2024/theres-no-way-through-t…
Amen
After years of Anthony Fauci and his partners immediately shutting down any dissent and refusing to update their views after being proven wrong, it’s unbelievably refreshing to hear Jay Bhattacharya and Marty Makary say that science needs to be conducted with an open mind
If only they’d have been in charge during COVID
Calling a point of view Fringe implies that there's a study that shows what the majority of people think.
During the pandemic there was no such study so I'm not sure he is fringe. I think he is mainstream.
The cuts aren't to the grant but the indirects. Universities, especially those in Pittsburgh, are abusing the indirects.
Fifty thousand people have read this essay. Check it out.
Agree
.@MartyMakary has the medical experience, policy expertise, and independent mind the FDA desperately needs. Let’s get him confirmed!
It's strange to see the NIH trying to save money. Wasting money and failing to study their methods was the defining aspect of Collins' NIH
NIH is centralizing peer review of all applications for grants, cooperative agreements and research and development contracts within the agency’s @CSRpeerreview. This is expected to save NIH more than $65 million annually & make the review process more efficient. go.nih.gov/iGmUyfH
Much of this research is simply no good. Not useful
Not control arms
No adjustments for wealth
Documenting problems that have already been documented
No solutions
No randomization
Dear @Nature, you can move to the US and officially become a politician if you want.
I like this neurosurgeon 👇
He's the chief at an institution thriving on indirects, but he still has the courage to say the truth.
He has the same courage Jay and Marty has, and he's also right.
Capping indirect payments to university administrators at 15% (currently as much as ~70%) would ⬆️ funds for actual research on childhood cancer. These caps defund the bureaucracy, not the research. www.wsj.com/opinion/the-nihs-15-cost-cap-isnt-strict-enou…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Gavin Newsom says his son wanted to meet Charlie Kirk, but he wouldn’t let him miss school. Kirk replies, “Well, you cancelled school for like two years—what’s one day going to do?”
Newsom just laughs.
That laugh means, “My kid went to private schools that stayed open while I forced millions of public school children to suffer.”
That laugh means, “I haven’t faced accountability and am betting I never will.”
Maybe this illustrates why a governor shouldn’t become a talk show host. A governor isn’t allowed to casually laugh off serious issues like this.
It is not surprising
Paxlovid is a 10 billion dollar scam offered by the Biden administration with lead propagandist Ashish Jha
How could @jnmafi and the other study authors have possibly been *surprised* by these results, which are consistent with virtually every other study of Paxlovid in vaccinated people?!? 🥴
Paxlovid May Offer Little Benefit for Vaccinated Older Adults www.drugs.com/news/paxlovid-may-offer-little-benefit-vacc…
The FDA approved a sickle cell drug that increased hemoglobin 1 point
Later found to kill kids & increase VOD
The FDA's current efficacy standard has nothing to do with making people better off
Either the FDA has an efficacy standard or it's just honest and says it doesn't.
Viewpoint: Proposals to lower or eliminate the @US_FDA's preapproval effectiveness requirements for drugs are unnecessary and dangerous, as they undermine patient safety and public health.
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/10.1001/jama.20…
The @DrJBhattacharya hearing basically shows that in the COVID-19 debates, Jay has won. Pretty much all of his policy positions are now accepted by both political parties.
Just out
The new NIH director is.... @DrJBhattacharya
FIVE TAKE-AWAYS from yesterday's hearing
My latest is out @Sensible__Med
Already it's getting a lot of discussion!
Of all the lay media coverage of this topic, this is probably the most informative debate that actually gets into the issues.
Will NIH cuts boost public health—or destroy it?
Oncologist David Andorsky believes that these cuts will be disastrous.
@VPrasadMDMPH argues the cuts could force the agency to make better choices. thefp.pub/4bwnu9y
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
“In many ways, universities and academic medical centers brought reforms down on themselves. Their leadership forfeited public confidence, which has set the stage for long-overdue reforms.” @VPrasadMDMPH in The FP: thefp.pub/4bwnu9y
Saskatchewan based researcher who didn't know the difference between blood clots in your brain resulting in brain herniation and a DVT in the leg thinks Jay isn't a great choice for NIH director.
Jay really is a shoe in!!!!!!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Only the very worst people oppose Dr. J.
Well my old friend Jay Bhattacharya is having his Senate confirmation hearing today so time for a quick refresher on who this guy is.
A mass infection proponent who never met a contrarian position he wouldn’t take for personal gain.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Are Trump’s NIH cuts a sensible way to make research more efficient? Or will they threaten the development of cures that could save millions of lives? We asked two oncologists we trust—David Andorsky and @VPrasadMDMPH—to debate this important issue: thefp.pub/4bwnu9y
Check out this debate in the Free Press about @DrJBhattacharya
Cancer doctors David Andorsky and @VPrasadMDMPH debate whether President Trump’s slashing of billions to the National Institutes for Health will boost public health—or destroy it. thefp.pub/4bwnu9y
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Did you know?
Up to 1 in 3 newly diagnosed breast cancer patients – the most frequently diagnosed cancer – could be impacted by CDK4/6 inhibitors!
In Cambridge @CUOncSoc, I shared my concerns & questions!
An excerpt👇 (full talk available, see previous posts) @vkprasadlab
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Could not be happier to see @VPrasadMDMPH taking SSRIs on. Subscribe to Vinay's Substack and also check out clinical psychologist Dr Roger McFillin's pod - Radically Genuine. @DrMcFillin
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/anti-depressants…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Thought-provoking editorial on external validity of heart failure therapy from @Wil_Ward_ @VPrasadMDMPH in @CircOutcomes
Clinical translation of HF evidence is hugely challenging. And 100% PARADIGM HF should be replicated w equivalent doses of valsartan
Link in replies
More smears
1 It's irrelevant whether he did residency, I never saw Collins rounding.
2 Economist is the best training to figure out the way to maximize impact from giving money
3 Watch my video on YouTube instead
They're running a phase 1 trial making pancreas cancer patients swallow a gel cap with someone else's feces in it.
Stool transplant works for c diff. But it's not going to slow cancer growth. What a crazy idea. So much cancer research money is just flushed down the toilet. @AaronGoodman33
It was just "an email or two"
See thread. He talks about preventing Congress from "connecting the dots" between his NIH funded research and the COVID pandemic
francis collins is an absolute psycho.
Hospitals and medical centers claim to be non-profits, but they act more predatory than even the most onerous for-profit companies. It's time to tax them
As lawmakers look for additional tax revenues, they should consider expanding the federal tax base to include business-like income earned by tax-exempt nonprofit organizations.
taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/501c3-nonprofit-or…
Is fraud rare? Obviously photoshopping a western blot is fraud But what about: you run an experiment/analysis 12 ways and report 3? Not the first 9 which weren't significant. That is considered acceptable, but imo is fraud. What about if you look at a dataset of EHR data and it is a mess of missing data and incorrect coding, but you publish anyway. Again, I think this is fraud too. Sadly, these 2 behaviors, running multiple analytic plans, using low credibility data are rampant in biomedicine. Many behaviors that result in a reproducibility rate that is painfully low. To me fraud can be the result of ineptitude and carelessness, does not have to be wanton. Many people doing retrospective chart review are fraud factories.
fraud is bad & should be punished. fortunately its rare
more common is ineptitude & carelessness
if you get papers & grants no one cares if methods are lousy, both the seen & the unseen (poor data collection & analyses)
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Impact of Early Censoring Explained, and more on Kaplan-Meier... Full talk available on drugdevletter!
Re Jay in @statnews @EricBoodman
Says he misrepresented Bangladesh rct
Pls check clintrials there's a fourth endpoint that's never been reported. Random sero prevalence. Where is it?
& study has huge imbalance in population due to concealment bias
Jay is right to 💩 on it
Unfair to take the judge's opinion who doesn't know jack s*** about studies. Moreover, the greatest misrepresentation of the study was the authors in their op-ed who scaled up the effect size as if it could magically happen to everyone.
Two op-eds in WSJ argue that indirects should be 0%
Others want the status quo
Trump proposed 15%
Universities should be holding discussion of this topic, but are not
I explore these issues
In our new paper we examine reports of cancer in public figures in the lay media
Some cancers still have stigma
I explore our new paper and some of the questions people have raised about withdrawal effects and discontinuations studies
Check it out!
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Thanks Vinay ! Here is the link
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-nihs-15-cost-cap-isnt-strict-enou…
Two good WSJ op eds on why the indirect rate should be 0
Two good WSJ op eds on why the indirect rate should be 0
Eli Lilly the makers of Lartruvo ran an Oscar ad saying believe in real medicine and not podcast bros
Look up lartruvo….
This is how corruption is rationalized
The truth is doctors who take payments have been shown in meta analysis to be more likely to prescribe low value treatments. I stand by my statement.
Doctors who receive money from industry are often receiving it because they are viewed as experts in their field. They will be involved with multiple companies and studies & have a good, broad perspective on the field. I can’t think of any respectable oncologists that would push a treatment because they got a consulting fee. People have all kinds of conflicts. Some people may be conflicted because of incentives related to seeking power/fame/subscriptions/followers.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Collins went on TV and told parents to mask at home because their children were disease vectors (I'm not kidding, here's the video)
He then called for a "devastating takedown" of Jay Bhattacharya for questioning Collins and Fauci's unscientific idiocy.
Vinay: I don’t remember him on TV during the pandemic making public health policy decisions. He is a respected physician-scientist who contributed much to humanity. It’s shameful to degrade him although he should be accountable for any COVID origin coverup that may have occurred.
This fucking guy was writing parody songs instead of debating the policy issues of the day. It's irrelevant that he sequenced the genome. He is just another asshole who fucked up the most consequential policy decisions of a generation bc of incompetence. Millions of kids lost education bc of him.
His Puff the Magic Dragon cover now seems like intentional disinformation…as crazy as that sentence sounds…youtu.be/jBopklQUzPQ
Yes and this time ACIP should ban
Anyone who took money from a vaccine company
Anyone with patents on vaccine products or parts
@SecKennedy
I think that an urgent ACIP meeting should be scheduled to discuss this. The meeting should include relevant guest speakers/participants and temporary members (if CDC does temporary members like the FDA does). This should occur in time for a decision ASAP, and no later than fall.
It should be taken down ASAP @SecKennedy
Why is the Covid shot still on the childhood schedule?
My Spotify playlist
His Puff the Magic Dragon cover now seems like intentional disinformation…as crazy as that sentence sounds…youtu.be/jBopklQUzPQ
See also
Vinay: I don’t remember him on TV during the pandemic making public health policy decisions. He is a respected physician-scientist who contributed much to humanity. It’s shameful to degrade him although he should be accountable for any COVID origin coverup that may have occurred.
This fucking guy was writing parody songs instead of debating the policy issues of the day. It's irrelevant that he sequenced the genome. He is just another asshole who fucked up the most consequential policy decisions of a generation bc of incompetence. Millions of kids lost education bc of him.
His Puff the Magic Dragon cover now seems like intentional disinformation…as crazy as that sentence sounds…youtu.be/jBopklQUzPQ
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
I appreciate much of what the Christians in Francis Collins orbit are trying to do from a faith/science perspective... it is very unfortunate that, seems to me, from a desire to be respected by the cool kids, they also make rather critical failures.
My latest is out
Collins retires from the NIH!!
This fucking guy was writing parody songs instead of debating the policy issues of the day. It's irrelevant that he sequenced the genome. He is just another asshole who fucked up the most consequential policy decisions of a generation bc of incompetence. Millions of kids lost education bc of him.
His Puff the Magic Dragon cover now seems like intentional disinformation…as crazy as that sentence sounds…youtu.be/jBopklQUzPQ
Francis Collins
Number of COVID parody songs written to the tune of Puff the Magic Dragon - 1
Number of randomized trials of masks - 0
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/francis-collins-retires-from-the
He was just another shitty director.
He allowed for sadistic animal torture and championed a subset of virology research that may be connected to 1 million American deaths. The portrayal of Collins as some sort of saintly figure has played a major role in the lack of oversight at NIH & perpetuation of a stagnant status quo.
My latest is out
Collins retires from the NIH!!
When you don't have a control arm, you can't lose!! 🎉
Lenalidomide combined with R-CHOP (R2-CHOP) in the treatment of newly diagnosed double-expressor diffuse large B-cell lymphoma: a prospective phase II clinical trial @BloodCancerJnl
www.nature.com/articles/s41408-025-01229-5
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Remember when people say SSRIs work, what they actually mean is they work based on an 8-week RCT.
The truth is, we don’t have solid evidence for whether they work after 5–10 years, except for observational and relapse studies, which overestimate long-term efficacy since they’re often confounded by withdrawal symptoms.
It’s pretty astounding considering how confidently they are promoted for long-term use—especially given growing indications that extended use can be harmful.
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
In 2023, the FDA approved escitalopram for pediatric GAD despite a concerning increase in suicidal ideation. The trial duration was typical: 8 weeks
SSRI RCTs lasting more than 12w are rare.
Yet, tens of millions of people take antidepressants chronically (2y+) in the US
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
It's a good paper. Even though I am biased.
Antidepressant Trial Duration versus Duration of Real-World Use: A Systematic Analysis
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2025.02.27.25323057v1 via @Wil_Ward_ et al
That's right SSRIs are of poor quality. Almost as if the regulators were planning careers in Pharma
"Few trials monitored for withdrawal symptoms (3.8%) or included taper protocols (18.9%), and only 1.9% reported depression or anxiety outcomes during the post-treatment period." @markhoro @taperclinic
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
If I had cancer, I would search if my doctor has taken money from Pharma companies that make cancer drugs in the last 3 years on open payments. And if so. I would find a new doc
Just a pro tip.
Boo hoo hoo
Now I have to use the better search engine Google scholar
And now I don't have to worry about the next pandemic caused by US government funded research
Boo hoo hoo
Happy retirement!!
The "pre-emptive pardon" of Fauci did not include Fauci's criminal co-conspirators--not even former NIH Director Collins.
This sets the stage for prosecution of Fauci's co-conspirators and for full exposure of Fauci's crimes through prosecution of his co-conspirators.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"Few trials monitored for withdrawal symptoms (3.8%) or included taper protocols (18.9%), and only 1.9% reported depression or anxiety outcomes during the post-treatment period." @markhoro @taperclinic
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
Haters will judge him bc he funded EcoHealth alliance who funded the lab that caused a global pandemic killing 20 mil
But fans will remember he said in 2015 everyone will get gene sequencing to figure out what antihypertensive to take as initial treatment of high blood pressure
Our new paper explores the gap between real world practice and the evidence base
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2025.02.27.25323057v1.ful…
In the past decade, SSRI prescriptions for teenagers have increased by 40%. For children under 12, the rate has doubled. Yet during this same period, youth mental health has dramatically worsened. How did we reach a point where chemically altering developing brains became our default response to adolescent struggles?
You can be a shitty drug regulator and then work for Pfizer
But the good news is the press will attack @SecKennedy instead and give you a total pass
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/fda-approves-pfizer-drugs-with-in…
I love 200 k a year drugs that have never improved clinical outcomes in an RCT. The FDA should block these agents but good news is that if they approve them then they can work at CMO at Pfizer
Luspatercept for the treatment of anemia in allo-HSCT for patients with hematological diseases @BloodCancerJnl
www.nature.com/articles/s41408-025-01218-8
The standard for vaccine approval are complete horse shit. Low regulatory bar so companies can get rich and later hire the shitty FDA workers. Just like Pfizer. The status quo is corrupt. Hopefully @SecKennedy can clean up this swamp of corruption.
The @CDCgov is now probing "several hospitalizations for cardiac or neurologic events" in seniors, after receipt of @valnevaSE's chikungunya travel vaccine
Topic was supposed to be discussed at ACIP meeting, per update to @CDCtravel's health alert
wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/notices/level2/chikungunya-reunion
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is a really pertinent observation. Same with treatment of ADHD in children.
The equivalent in cancer would be a randomized trial of eight weeks between two therapies and then we go with the better one at eight weeks.
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This is really important.
We live in an increasingly medicated, numbed-out society hooked on doctor-prescribed pharmaceuticals which don’t address the root cause of pathology and illness.
People take SSRIs like chewing gum - with very little concern of risks.
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
Once again I agree with Richard. This is a corrupt organization swallowing public funds
Congress should revoke the Congressional charter to the @NASEM.
At absolute minimum, Congress should terminate federal funding to the @NASEM.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
👇Critical point from @VPrasadMDMPH. We should test the effects of medications for the way they're actually used, not approve based on very short trials only.
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Really important point, not only about SSRI, but lots of other meds. Good paper.
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
His work did help millions and then he killed 20 million people by funding gain of function research in Wuhan and lying about it, so he is only down 17 million.
Francis Collins and a team of researchers identified the cystic fibrosis gene over 30 years ago, and because of people like him I’m alive today with kids of my own (and able to enjoy a weekend trip to my favorite place on earth… Alta… and am healthy enough to enjoy it).
After 32 years of service, former @NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins retires from NIH.
Real problem is the Mayo clinic makes money from selling false hope. They routinely recommend treatments that other people don't, that are not supported by evidence. That's how American medicine works. The more nonsense you recommend the more you make from rich pts, including saudis
Holy…. this is government grant pass along and salary grift on a mind-blowing level.
This is a thread 🧵 you are going to want to read all of. Thank you @DataRepublican for the search tool
Mayo Clinic Group passed through $2.2 billion to its sister company Mayo Clinic with both entities passing on billions more.
Billions in overseas grants, millions in overseas travel grants.
Our new paper shows Randomized trials of SSRIs run for 8 wks but people take them 8 years. This is an evidence based disaster. We have no idea what the effect is 8 yrs later. @SecKennedy
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
He’ll rightfully be remembered as an utter failure.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Francis Collins violated federal policies on gain-of-function and enhanced potential pandemic pathogen research, committed felony conspiracy to defraud and felony perjury, used federal funds to commit crimes, and caused a pandemic that killed 20+ million and cost $25+ trillion.
Absolutely. By this important metric he also failed.
Francis Collins should be judged by how many RTCs the NIH was able to run on the biggest health crisis of our lifetimes, the COVID pandemic.
By that measure, the NIH was a sclerotic and expensive behemoth that did not adapt to the modern era.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
While I should expect absurdity to continue to come from the guy who said "I really believe this is why God gave us two arms — one for the flu shot and the other one for the COVID shot" it's still shocking. The denial of the significance of these emails is pathetic. The deification of public health figures like Collins, Fauci, Hotez, and more, based on their good contributions at the exclusion of all else is bizarre.
Just a small email saying we shouldn't allow discussion of school closure and lockdown and maybe another saying wait, did we fund the virus' development. In other words. No biggie.
The extraordinary Francis Collins is leaving NIH
As I told @robsteinnews for @NPRHealth
Francis helped usher in an era of genomic medicine whose fruits we are just beginning to reap
Yeah, haters will find some email or two of his from the pandemic to smear him
But history will judge him as a legend who helped transform American medicine
www.npr.org/sections/shots-health-news/2025/03/01/g-s1-51…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
"The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine has raked in hundreds of millions of dollars of taxpayer funds in recent years while doling out hefty salaries to its top brass and bankrolling...left-wing initiatives."
www.foxnews.com/politics/structural-racism-top-taxpayer-f… #foxnews
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
The corruption and perverse incentives that plague NIH just got a little easier to tackle.
After 32 years of service, former @NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins retires from NIH.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
He allowed for sadistic animal torture and championed a subset of virology research that may be connected to 1 million American deaths. The portrayal of Collins as some sort of saintly figure has played a major role in the lack of oversight at NIH & perpetuation of a stagnant status quo.
Conan's show was iconic and a league of his own
Sadly Leno screwed him with the handoff
Fortunately his travel segments once again showed he is a comedy genius.
Conan O’Brien helped bury both of his parents, then his home was evacuated during the LA fires.
Now he’s been living in a hotel — with a sentimental letter taken from his home on the wall — as he prepares to host the Oscars.
This is an example of good reporting. This is despicable behavior on the part of hospitals. They are throwing away organs just as much as ever, and giving organs to their friends. It's like China where you can buy an organ. Smells like corruption.
“We have violated our own principles. We have violated transparency, trust in the system."
Organ Transplant System ‘in Chaos’ as Waiting Lists Are Ignored www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/02/26/us/organ-transplan…
I got an email from someone arguing that the current process actually stifles flu vaccine innovation by forcing all the companies to hit the same targets. I totally agree. The media is so ill-equipped to cover this administration.
Right now the FDA has delayed the meeting to pick vaccine strains
Baroso, Ioannidis and I proposed a better idea last year
Media refuses to look up to see the forest
Is the selection process we use evidence based?
From our paper link in replies
He is right. These authors should not do mask reviews. It was just like the NEJM paper where they host a change.org petition and then they study the topic. Also it's a meta joke this journal published it. Bc we already know what they think.
I checked the authorship before I read and guessed correctly what the main conclusions, and the DEGREE OF CERTAINTY, would be.
Can we just stop waisting everyone’s time. The people doing these type of “review”, the journal admin/peer reviewers, academic peers and the public.
If you are doing something where there is a colossal advantage to being first and there are many rivals pursuing the same goal, then yeah he is correct.
Whole article is whiny and doesn't understand that somethings actually do take work.
I agree with Joseph. Like many medical leaders he began with a great discovery
Sadly this didn't make him a good policy maker. He bungled the most important decisions of a century and forfeited public trust.
I remember an inspiring lecture that Dr. Collins gave shortly after he discovered the CFTR gene in 1989. He should have stuck to molecular genetics and avoided opining in epidemiology, public policy, foreign relations, and pandemic management. Weighed against his great accomplishments in his own field will be his negligent oversight of gain-of-function research and poor leadership of NIH during covid.
He could have promoted evidence-based medicine, funded more RCTs to test countermeasures, and sponsored diverse panels of experts to publicly debate elements of the covid response. Instead, he promoted govt propaganda, dogmatism, and censorship over science.
If the NIH is going to recover from the covid debacle, it will need to sweep out the entire old guard and replace them with younger leaders who recognize how profoundly the US biomedical establishment failed during the pandemic and who are committed to fundamental reform. www.nytimes.com/2025/03/01/us/politics/francis-collins-ni…
Accomplishments:
Exaggerated the promise of sequencing
Funded GOF research
"Swift and devastating" take down of those who wanted schools to reopen and focused protection of elderly
Used Gmail after NIH funded monkey abuse study to evade FOIA
Does not have a pardon
I agree this should be the flu vax effectiveness
Note. It doesn't happen
Agree there should be reform in choosing targets for flu vaccination, but of course meetings are needed to discuss this. Maybe that should in fact be the goal of the meeting. Target efficacy imo should be at least 70%.
My latest is now out
on 6 topics we miss the forest for the trees
1 - picking flu strains
2- PhD spots
3- Indirects
4- Study sections
5- Halting oral covid vax trial
6- Resignations in research integrity institutes
This is what the media has ignored
NIH researchers upset over study section delays is like being upset your hostage taker is not giving you a daily phone call.
The problem in the system is study sections!
Scientists spend all their time writing and not doing science. WTF!
Right now the FDA has delayed the meeting to pick vaccine strains
Baroso, Ioannidis and I proposed a better idea last year
Media refuses to look up to see the forest
Is the selection process we use evidence based?
From our paper link in replies
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
when i get called into my department chair’s office expecting a raise and the dean + provost are waiting for me
Great news. The NYTimes voice who kept his cool and covered the pandemic with nuance. Unlike some of his correction factory colleagues.
Per a note to New York Times staff this morning, David Leonhardt will become the new editorial director for Opinion.
Doctors also happy to help
Just a reminder that @jaketapper was far from alone in the epic media gaslighting about Biden’s senility
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Good question at #wafib2025
Has finerenone been compared to spironolactone?
No. Guess why? Hint: industry dominates our research enterprise
cc @AndrewFoy82
Nobody has failed more than these organizations. Research integrity? We're drowning in a sea of fraudulent research, irreproducible science, and data hoarding and they don't do anything about it.
It's like a person who does the rain dance in the Sahara desert quitting.
Exclusive from @RetractionWatch: U.S. federal research integrity teams take hits with departures retractionwatch.com/2025/02/27/exclusive-us-federal-resea…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
What have these research integrity offices been doing all these years amid rampant unchecked fraud, leaving the real work to amateur sleuths? This office likely creates the pretense the govt cares about scientific integrity while doing very little. The HHS integrity office was alerted to Lesne’s 2006 amyloid paper being bunk by Jan. 2022 and passed the buck. It wasn’t retracted until June 2024. In the intervening years patients died on lecanemab.
Exclusive from @RetractionWatch: U.S. federal research integrity teams take hits with departures retractionwatch.com/2025/02/27/exclusive-us-federal-resea…
I agree humanities is more woke than med but med is hostile to Rs
1 lab leak was denied
2 masks were pushed on toddlers
3 90+ docs sign petition to delay Pfizer vax so Trump loses 2020
4 ok to protest BLM but not go to trump rally
5 vaccine mandates not questioned
6 mask mandates not questioned
7 schools were kept closed to screw Trump in 2020 (see AAP flip)
Schools censured and punished faculty who disagreed.
Trump's aim is correct imo
Why Trump's attacks on science funding will backfire. STEM fields are/were most friendly to Republicans!
See my post in next tweet for more.
'Contrarian' is a label used by people who have never conducted an empirical study of what scientists thought ergo they don't know what options are contrary to the majority
Sweden/ tegnell was the wisest
Anthony is right
I don't consider myself a contrarian, but I do think Sweden handled the pandemic better than most. Anders Tegnell said that Swedes limited social contacts as much as people in other countries, but he did not suggest the "country's approach was [similar] to the rest of the world."
1 Universities should fire admin not students
2 But we train too many PhD students in biology
3. We do that b/c they are free labor
PhD programs are pausing admissions to graduate school due to NIH indirect cost cuts. See the growing number of programs here: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1FLlILMkKFHgKwUawLqdwW2o84…
How is science supposed to advance with fewer trainees, less $ for research? This is devastating.
NEJM has a pro con debate
Not only do I think its wrong to boot a child
A violation of a docs oath
I think this will increase vax hesitancy
NEJM should debate when pediatricians should apologize for masking kids and giving them covid shots, at the start or end of visit
It is kinda bullshit that he didn't win the nobel prize too
And I say that as a skeptic that the award should even exist
www.nytimes.com/2015/10/03/opinion/the-folly-of-big-scien…
We are excited to report the discovery of TIGRs, a widely-occurring RNA-guided system found in bacteria and their viruses. TIGRs consist of a peculiar repeat region which is transcribed into RNA and processed into multiple guide RNAs to direct TIGR-associated proteins to their DNA targets. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adv9789
People who do what doctors tell them do better
But that doesn't mean doctors advice is correct
Compliant people are often richer/ better educated/ less sick/ otherwise destined to do better
Higher overall compliance with enhanced recovery after surgery guidelines was associated with improved postoperative outcomes for individuals undergoing major head and neck free flap reconstructive surgery. jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaotolaryngology/fullarticle/1…
The trees - NIH study section reviews delayed/ so much time wasted writing/ reviewing
The forest - we have no idea if writing insane long apps and getting rando reviewers to grade it is better than giving out money by lottery, yet blindly accept wasteful status quo
#nih study section I serve on got cancelled, reviews from everyone were in on time. Do not regret one bit completing all reviews. It is our collective responsibility to keep moving the science forward even in difficult times.
Exercise is good for you; I do it
But this study is not causal
Doing it won't reduce your risk of dementia by 41%
People who are developing dementia probably exercise less before the diagnosis
I still do it, but I don't believe this effect size
Just five min of daily exercise reduces dementia risk by 41%
New study: 35 minutes a week of exercise reduced dementia risk by 41%, more activity further reduces the risk.
0/ A new study with 89,667 participants (mean age=63 years, 56% women) showed that physical exercise reduces the risk of developing dementia within an average follow-up period of 4.4 years.
1/ The “first 35 minutes/week” of moderate and vigorous activity were correlated with the steepest risk-reduction of 41%, with 35-70, and 70-140 min/week correlating to larger risk reductions of 60 and 63% respectively.
2/ Beyond 126 min/week, every additional 30 min of exercise a week was correlated with 4% additional risk reduction.
3/ Significance&implications
i. This result emphasizes the importance of maintaining a minimum physical activity as a non-negotiable aspect of your health and longevity routine.
ii. The return on investment for your health, wellbeing and longevity, of your initial 10-15 minutes of daily exercise is unlikely to be matched by any other activity, with an earlier study also concluding that 75 minutes of weekly moderate-to-vigorous physical activity was correlated with 23% mortality risk reduction.
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
“Notably, the media never discussed these people. They were unemployed, thrown out of the military, and forced to seek other employment. I don't recall a single interview with a person like this on MSNBC.”
@VPrasadMDMPH is spot on here.👇🏻
My latest
Dollar for dollar probably the intramural program is the least productive part of NIH. It was originally meant to do what no University would do, but increasingly that is an empty set. We have to be open to reforms that include downsizing intramural branch.
Friends, I am at a loss of words for how devastating it would be to lose the entire intramural #nih program. Some of the biggest medical and scientific breakthroughs have come from scientists in the NIH Intramural program. #savethenih
www.science.org/content/article/nih-ban-renewing-senior-s…
😂who would have guessed people would rather take a pill than edit their liver genome (sloppily)😂
I said this 10 years ago in Nature
Many phone calls that I be fired
Now people pivoted to immunotherapy and think we forget
Despite the vast amount of multimodal clinical data currently available for each patient in modern healthcare, the promise of personalized medicine has yet to be realized. www.nature.com/articles/s43018-024-00891-1
Being hyperbolic will backfire
There is no collapse
A small delay in an unproven, cronyist process
A tiny fraction of grants slow to go out the door
A dent in the car thats been leaking oil and antifreeze for years
It needs to be in the shop
I bet 40-80% of successful drugs owe their success to NIH
But also the NIH is full of fraud, irreproducible results and worse
We owe it to the public to reform the NIH
I think you can both appreciate a farm and also try to improve the crop yield and fire the manager who is embezzling
Did you know - the medicine that President Trump takes each day to lower his risk of having a heart attack is a direct result of NIH funding? Let me explain -
Funding should be pulled
Moderna has hundreds of billions of dollars
If this is a good investment they should invest that
That is literally the business decision
Even if this vax is successful, and even if bird flu dominant, I bet only 9% of Americans will take an mRNA vax.
The Trump administration confirmed it's reviewing whether to pull $590 million in funding that Moderna received in the final days of the Biden administration to develop an mRNA vaccine for bird flu in people. www.axios.com/2025/02/27/moderna-bird-flu-vaccine-funding…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
@VPrasadMDMPH on “the inherent dishonesty of the media” open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/federal-workers-…
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
This absolute travesty from the media never seizes to appal me.
My latest
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
He knows much about viruses. His lab provided funding to the Wuhan Institute of Virology through a sub-award of NIH grant 4R01AI098775-05, "RBD recombinant protein-based SARS vaccine for biodefense" from 2012 to 2017.
Not sure there is a better or smarter voice to listen to on vaccines and viruses than Dr. Hotez. Sure hope the new folks at HHS get out of their misinformation bubble and try to save some lives.
India doesn't give mRNA COVID shots to every kid annually starting at 6 months old-- a vaccine policy that Ashish Jha invented in America, which accelerated vax hesitancy. It's weird to not take any responsibility for vax hesitancy when you equated needed vax (MMR) w COVID 4 kid
I am currently in India meeting with health and education leaders
A question I've asked repeatedly: what are people's attitudes towards vaccines?
The response? There's almost none of the anti-vaccine nonsense that permeates too much of US dialogue
Why?
Because Indians live through the scourge that is infectious diseases
They know that vaccines save kids' lives
And I've found no one discussing what kind of placebo was used in the clinical trials as RFK Jr and his supporters like to do
I think the pandemic changed this. The biomedical arm of universities-- the juggernaut of funding-- was the worst offender taking sides on issues (masking 2 yo/ closing schools), suppressing debate. Even as these issues became political. They made big bets that blew up.
Our paper is out: I found this interesting
Some cancers celebs are more likely to admit to having than others. Above the line is over represented reporting in media.
Does reading an article about a public figure with cancer leave you with more uncertainty than clarity?
In @myESMO Real World Data and Digital Oncology, we review news articles about public figures with cancer from 2010 to 2020.
Our study found that most articles lack pertinent details (e.g. type, prognosis, treatment, etc.) on cancer care. Understandably, public figures may choose not to disclose personal aspects of their cancer care.
The lack of details and general uncertainty about cancer in these public figures may ultimately lead to more fear and anxiety among readers.
CC: @VPrasadMDMPH @vkprasadlab @ArashRezazadeh6
Link (full text): www.esmorwd.org/article/S2949-8201(25)00008-6/fulltext
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Does reading an article about a public figure with cancer leave you with more uncertainty than clarity?
In @myESMO Real World Data and Digital Oncology, we review news articles about public figures with cancer from 2010 to 2020.
Our study found that most articles lack pertinent details (e.g. type, prognosis, treatment, etc.) on cancer care. Understandably, public figures may choose not to disclose personal aspects of their cancer care.
The lack of details and general uncertainty about cancer in these public figures may ultimately lead to more fear and anxiety among readers.
CC: @VPrasadMDMPH @vkprasadlab @ArashRezazadeh6
Link (full text): www.esmorwd.org/article/S2949-8201(25)00008-6/fulltext
School closures 2020
School closures 2020
My latest
People want this data to tell them how many steps they should aim to take a day, but it's not exactly that. It doesn't tell you whether you live longer if you adjust your behavior. If you take 7,000 steps a day, do you really lower mortality by taking it up to 10,000? And the types of people who don't walk that much, include a bunch of people who are sick.
ever since we found out the whole 10K steps thing was a made up number, I've wondered what the actual step count number is that matters
For mortality - It seems like the number is between 5-7K depending on smoking status/weight, and after that it's marginal.
From a life insurance analysis that looked at UK biobank data
Experts on my salary say I am underpaid and should be paid more
They also think I don't get enough vacation and that we would have more cures if I flew Business class.
Experts on research policy told @AnilOza16 it’s unfair to compare what NIH and nonprofits pay for overhead: Why NIH pays universities far more for indirect costs than private foundations www.statnews.com/2025/02/27/why-nih-pays-universities-far… via @statnews
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Trump vs universities. PhD programs And RFK Jr cuts a vaccine trial that HHS should never have funded
youtu.be/iTduJqBqTtA
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Vinay Prasad MD MPH reposted
Just out. 3 hours ago. Link in replies. Worth your time. File too big to upload here.
This is so bad
I have said for years. A huge chunk of animal research is pointless. But this is entirely a new level of abusive deranged stuff. Francis Collins was evading detection by using Gmail. Note: unlike Fauci, he wasn't pardoned.
Great reporting!
I joined @JeffAngeloRadio to discuss my story about Francis Collins's govt waste and abuse
whoradio.iheart.com/featured/jeff-angelo-on-the-radio/con…
dailycaller.com/2025/02/21/ex-nih-director-concealed-prob…
ACIP should return with a new rule
Anyone who received money from any Pharma company in the last 5 yrs is off ACIP.
ACIP has fucked up too much recently. And is reponsible for vaccine hesitancy.
Until then a delay is good.
You'll recall that @CDCgov announced this month that it was postponing ACIP meeting
"to accommodate public comment in advance of the meeting"
www.cdc.gov/acip/index.html
After Califf completely screwed up Paxlovid and boosters for his entire tenure, making outlandish and unproven claims, like they prevent long covid, he finally endorses what his critics said all along, pretending he didn't do a poor job when he had the chance.
"As the majority of US residents are declining the opportunity for COVID vaccination..., COVID vaccine uptake is now low enough that large RCTs are feasible to evaluate the efficacy and safety of new updated boosters."
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2829500
Trump vs universities. PhD programs And RFK Jr cuts a vaccine trial that HHS should never have funded
youtu.be/iTduJqBqTtA
I keep seeing the figure each dollar of NIH funding brings back 2.34 dollars
But....
If you factor in that NIH funded the lab in Wuhan and 20 million are dead as a result it becomes .74 cents.
Here is how it works
FDA rubber stamps Pfizer drugs & vaccines even when the evidence is poor
FDA even pushes these products on children (voxeltor)
Califf lies about Pfizer products
Voxeltor kills
Then, you leave FDA and get paid by Pfizer
This is corruption
@RobertKennedyJr
In the epilogue of my book Malignant, which I wrote in 2018, I explained how broken the NIH is, and called for a randomized control trial of NIH Grant giving. This was my schematic. My views on this topic have been the same for the last decade.
Over the last 3 weeks you've heard countless scientists say that if we have budget cuts at NIH it will stop cancer cures and clinical trials. This study was funded by the NIH. The control arm should be getting active anti-cancer therapy, many did not get it, and many got it only after the trial, when their disease was worse. The government is funding a study that lets cancer patients die slowly without getting appropriate care. It's unethical. It's disgusting. And worst of all it's an abuse of taxpayer money. Many of the defenders of the current system do not actually understand just how pervasive the rot is. Scientists lost your trust during the pandemic, but the truth is in many fields they didn't deserve it in the first place. This is the kind of stuff they're doing. Side note: this trial also has inappropriate use of crossover. You can learn more about its errors in my book Malignant written in 2020 #doge
This article is worth your time.
Hospital visitor policies set by universities were unethical. These policies continue to this day. They have no scientific basis.
HHS should penalize hospitals that continue them.
Out now in Monash Bioethics Review 👇👇
During Covid, patient visitor policies left patients dying alone, kept hospitalized children from their parents & even separated newborn infants from their mothers. Perhaps these or related restrictions affected you personally.
@VPrasadMDMPH, @BenKnudsen31 & I discuss the extent, details, ramifications & what we know about the (lack of supportive) evidence for these policies. We also consider how we together can protect patients' rights and ensure more ethical, holistic policies in the future.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40592-025-00230-9
To me this is one of the reasons @Sensible__Med exists
A collumn by @FSBuchholzer, who is an epidemiologist & vaccine researcher, who is largely SUPPORTIVE of @RobertKennedyJr, even on vaccines.
How is that possible?
link in replies
What will be the role of AI in oncology?
There is still not enough spots
AND applications are down
Why? Because braindead administration makes medicine unbearable
Useless annual training. No compensation for thinking. RVUs pulled straight from AMAs ass.
I agree with RFK Jr to bust AMAs CPT code racket & ABIM must go
Let me be clear: the ENTIRE health care system is broken not merely HEALTH INSURANCE
Online influencers create scapegoats
Assassins are not heroes, they are "assholes who are going to die in prison" as @JohnFetterman says
My latest for @Sensible__Med
www.sensible-med.com/p/the-entire-healthcare-system-is-br…
I see people are retweeting this in the wake of the assassination. That's in poor taste. Glaucomflecken is not actually a student of health policy. He doesn't understand insurance. Denying coverage does not increase their profits. That idea may have gotten someone murdered. Sad
How to Ace your United Healthcare Interview @UHC
On @Sensible__Med We publish a reply to a recent article on Pediatric Gender Medicine by Lipfert and the response by @benryanwriter
This is why you should read SM. We publish debates and dialog that journals have been too scared to publish for years.
www.sensible-med.com/p/pediatric-gender-medicine
A pleasure to write this for @TheFP
My favorite news source!
An excellent, and sober piece from @VPrasadMDMPH in @TheFP:
A Simple Litmus Test for RFK Jr.’s Ideas
The media describes the new HHS chief as a conspiracy theorist. But how many of his ideas are actually used in Europe? More than you’d think.
www.thefp.com/p/rfk-jr-health-human-services-flouride-vac…
Dear Media,
A simple litmus test for if RFK Jr is:
Do other nations do it that way?
If he is suggesting something that half of Europe is already doing, you cannot call him a conspiracy theorist for holding that view, and we should be able to discuss it
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/do-other-countries-do-it-a-simple
I have a new piece on the University of Chicago becoming the Abbvie Cancer Center
"Finally, it does not escape me that the University of Chicago is not only a prostitute, but a cheap one at that..."
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/medicine-is-becoming-more-corrupt
Public health deans gleefully promoted the Cowger paper (below), which we have shown fails to replicate.
They don't equally promote the correct conclusions (there is no proof masking kids helps)
That's because public health has replaced critical thinking with partisanship
The most dangerous type of misinformation is when government officials like Mandy make false statements. There is no evidence that this fall booster will lower the rate of long covid. The CDC has failed to demand randomized studies. Disgraceful conduct
Two thoughts
1 Someone should pull the last 100 politicians Menswear guy has criticized and sort by political party. I will bet you will find a net vector of bias.
2 Criticizing arbitrary aesthetic preferences comes across as petty and bullying imo
I think @nejm should issue a retraction to the Cowger paper that claimed falsely masking kids works
We prove they only get their result when you choose purple controls and based on a limited time span. The authors were signing petitions to mask kids prior to their 'research'.
Just OUT. Game over for masking kids
Led by @TracyBethHoeg
We show @NEJM kid masking paper fails to replicate
Paper should be retracted if NEJM has any scruples
Read the paper. Masking kids prob doesn't work and we don't know bc no RCTs
www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M23-2907
I read a meta-analysis that downplayed a drug safety concern and I looked up one of the authors and this was their conflict of interest.
I am sure there is no one better to get the bottom of a safety signal
Can someone explain to me how a placebo arm is ethical in 2024? So patients with cancer were just vomiting and taking placebo? And doctors enrolled? @AaronGoodman33
That's because it is true.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3665046
Gavin Newsom - French laundry
Neil Ferguson - violated lockdown
Boris Johnson - partygate
Nancy Pelosi - hair salon visit
Deb Brix - Thanksgiving
Pls add to list
Is there a full list of covid hypocrites?
Science magazines and journals should endorse more politicians. When I open up a science journal, I want politics, goddamnit. @NEJM, who should I vote for for mayor? Pls advise.
Just out
Led by @mmb03966692 Mariana B
We argue that annual flu shots and covid shots have a VERY WEAK evidence base and there are TONS of things we can do better.
For e.g.... 🧵
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/eci.14286
Doctors and professors at Harvard and Yale think that Biden's debate performance was "stuttering" or caused by cold medications. 🤔
I explain why partisan bias is a problem and show how it is linked to outdoor masking & school closure @Sensible__Med
www.sensible-med.com/p/some-doctors-and-professors-claim
Why doctors should get the patient the cup of coffee when asked and other 'thats not my job' comments I find troubling
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/thats-not-my-job-an-attitude-i-find
Less than half of cancer drugs approved based on a surrogate endpoint are ever found to improve survival in their entire lifecycle.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC11043668/
Ashish Jha was inaccurate and Tracy is correct. Schools did not need anything to reopen. The Biden administration invented guidelines that prevented reopening bc it was working, in secret, with teachers unions. 👇 See thread and FOIA'd emails.
There was 1 point in my conversation w/@ashishkjha on @OnPointRadio that I wanted to discuss:
It's not true that the Feb 2021 @CDCgov reopening guidelines under the Biden admin facilitated school reopening. 90% of the country was in "red" and, per CDC, shouldn't open full time🧵
Blood test for colon cancer screening makes companies rich at the expense of people.
Consider you still need a colonoscopy
Consider the company has not shown it lowers cause specific mortality
Very likely could erode benefits of screening
I will make a video on this
Public lecture at MIT on Monday
Open to all in Boston area
Sign up here
We have written a dozen papers together but this might be first photo @TracyBethHoeg
Just out: Our new paper on pitfalls of using observational data to infer that COVID vax works for kids 5 to 11
@TracyBethHoeg
Free link here:
urldefense.com/v3/__https://doi.org/10.1017/S095026882400…$
Just out in @BMJ_PO we analyze tweets by public health "experts" during the Monkeypox outbreak in 2022
Led by brilliant med student @BenKnudsen31
Many falsely claimed the epidemic would reach schools or could be curbed by masking kids
bmjpaedsopen.bmj.com/content/8/1/e002236.full
If you have to write this in your paper
Don't submit it
Delete it
Not sure why they say "link is unclear".
It is clearly linked. It is causally linked.
Whether the benefits outweigh the risks can be debated vs alternatives like bites.
Many quotes on this topic from people with conflicts w car t makers.
FDA alters warning label for Carvykti CAR-T, although link to secondary cancers is unclear. #mmsm www.statnews.com/2023/12/22/myeloma-fda-warning-label-car… via @statnews
Probably the majority of people we train in medicine walk away without having any tools to critically appraise medical science. That makes them extremely vulnerable to peer pressure and political sentiment. In this particular case, politics has driven the issue. Patients should be more critical of doctors generally. It has always been a problem. We try to give some advice in our books.
Just OUT @TracyBethHoeg and I argue that testing when you feel sick for COVID19 is an UNPROVEN strategy and worse may even result in MORE respiratory virus spread
Check it out
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S26665352230009…
This is a really good article by @MartyMakary
It strikes me as completely accurate
Peter Mark is acting strange to say it should not matter to women that there is no actual randomized data
www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/was-covid-vaccin…
The only positive data for paxlovid was in people who were unvaccinated, high risk, did not have covid previous, & against older strain
No data for quadruple boosted, I had covid, low risk people w/ 2023 strains of covid
A sensible medical system would not even give the Rx
ALL mask studies in @CDCMMWR
Evidence is weak
0% randomized controlled trials
75% concluded "masks work"
Despite only 15% being significant
CDC does not follow the science, they contribute to low quality science noise @vkprasadlab
www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343(23)00580-6/fulltext
Just out on my website I catalog (some) errors made by the NYTimes Science reporter that consistently exaggerate the risk of COVID
Long COVID research has been of extremely poor quality and highly misleading
Tends to exaggerate prevalence and often lacks control groups
Public understanding is severely compromised
Our article discussing this is widely popular
ebm.bmj.com/content/early/2023/08/10/bmjebm-2023-112338
Nice to see coverage of our article
The risk of contracting long COVID may have been exaggerated due to flawed research, leading to unnecessarily high levels of anxiety about suffering from it, a new study has suggested news.sky.com/story/long-covid-risks-are-distorted-by-flaw…
With the exception of anosmia, I have seen no good evidence that short or long term consequences of Covid are any worse than any respiratory virus *adjusted for how sick you get* (e.g. ards/ vent is never good). The whole research space is dominated by horrifically bad work, and poor thinking. The worst work comes from a single group doing VA data set work that is repeatedly published in nature medicine and covered widely in the news, but absolutely threadbare in methods. Of course, the most parsimonious answer is that it is no worse adjusted for severity of illness. Now that severity of illness is a non-issue, it is a non issue.
Giving three lectures next week in Copenhagen. If anyone wants details talk to Marco Donia. I am sure you can come.
Rochelle Walensky testified in front of Congress that we did not have Equipoise to run trials of masking kids
We show how that was absolutely false in our new piece
She failed the American people by recommending masking 2 year olds without data.
Sad
authors.elsevier.com/sd/article/S2666-5352(23)00074-5
Yes. I think the video is accurate. And on many other issues his story is inconsistent. He did recommend school closure. In fact he criticized DeSantis for reopening. He recommended cloth masking, at a population level, which he denies. Media won't cover it honestly.
An amazing @CNN clip, posted by @TheEliKlein where an anchor confronts Fauci with Cochrane's report showing no proven benefit to community masking
Fauci says it works for individuals not populations
Yet, this is also a lie. How? I explain
open.substack.com/pub/vinayprasadmdmph/p/anthony-fauci-co…
Here are my recommendations for the fall booster based on the 0 data that the Biden administration has asked from Pfizer
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/the-fall-covid19-shot-is-…
Disgraceful. Scaring people from sending kids to school is the hallmark of mainstream media. The years of life lost from their colossal stupidity will someday be fully counted and catastrophic. Turning journalism into liberal political pr machine was a big error.
A short list of errors in the JAMA Network Open paper on misinformation
At least 4 things they call misinformation are demonstrably true. Its a sad showing for JAMA.
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/jama-network-open-paper-p…
@DrJBhattacharya @TracyBethHoeg @ericweinstein @EWidera @AnilMakam @DrToddLee
Safety data will be available in 2 years
Efficacy data will never be available
(except for confounded observational data)
Why does the CDC work for Pfizer?
The newest version of the COVID-19 vaccine will be available by the end of September, according to the CDC. wb.md/47wII4n
Today's video explores how Preprint Servers are censoring COVID19 manuscripts they disagree with
I prove they have no consistent scientific standard
They also refused to post our analysis of their conduct... weird youtu.be/RvE4kyu35Lw via @YouTube
After a long break, I am back on Youtube
Today, I am talking about our NEJM paper that shows the Booster analyses that FDA relied upon were flawed
Check it out
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1MJWgaYfWgA
The Johns Hopkins Center for Talented Youth is not run by Talented People 👇
They are still masking kids in JULY 2023
Imagine, being both incapable of reading evidence AND incapable of looking around at your peers.
"stop the spread" -- PS: it is not possible
This week in @NEJM, @TracyBethHoeg, RD & I prove that Israeli Studies, which FDA relied upon, are CONFOUNDED.
Boosters reduce non covid deaths far too much to be true.
Israeli authors concede this in reply
Wow!
Millions got unproven boosters
FDA failed
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2306683
Observational studies to justify boosters have strong evidence of reducing non COVID death, which is not possible.
This is selection bias. Basing widespread vax campaigns on selection bias is problematic.
We need RCTs of boosters.
Our correspondence is out in @njem written w @VPrasadMDMPH & Ram Duriseti
We show v strong evidence of healthy vaccinee bias in an Israeli study of Pfizer booster vs covid death, which wasn't disclosed
Could explain ALL reported benefit of the booster🧵
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2306683?query=featured…
In a new preprint by Sarah Miller and I, we analyze what predicted hospitals keeping masking mandates in Q1 2023
Covid cases? nope
Covid hospitalizations? nope
How many people voted for Biden? yes!
Masking policy at hospitals is political
Sad!
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.07.11.23292518v1.ful…
How poorly does your brain have to work to actaully think reducing ice in cocktails will help climate change?
Scientific America has become a rag run by zealots lacking basic critical thinking skills. www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-friendly-cockt…
Public health experts in the US in 2020 literally said a 2 year old has to wear a cloth mask in daycare, except when they nap, & if they don't comply on an airplane, throw the whole family off.
That degree of stupidity is inexcusable, unforgivable; no matter what ancestors did
I think this is well said. He gets why RFK has massive appeal 👇 More politicians have to be honest about the oversized role of Pharma. Basically running the FDA.
The @joerogan / @RobertKennedyJr bruhaha shines light on the most important issue in America.
Pharma companies have given us the opioid crisis, lockdown policies, and 50% prediabetes rates.
We're bullied to blindly trust them, but they deserve ZERO benefit of the doubt.
There is a reason RFK has the highest approval rating of any candidate from either political party.
It is because pharmaceutical companies and public health leaders have systematically let us down in spectacular fashion - yet continue to slur anyone (with government support) who dares ask questions.
This speech policing is enforced by the government, where the FDA Is literally funded by Pharma and regulatory agencies and pharma board rooms are a revolving door (just look at @ScottGottliebMD going directly from FDA to Pfizer).
It is an indisputable fact that the more we have spent on medical interventions over the past 40 years (and gotten away from basics like healthy food and movement), the worse our health has gotten.
Americans have gotten sicker, fatter, more depressed, and more infertile at the same time we have outsourced more trust to pharma companies and the public health industrial complex.
As a country, we have not even come close to grappling with the fact that the COVID response was the worst public policy disaster In modern American history.
Our country is being brought to its knees by preventable lifestyle conditions (rising rates of cancer, heart disease, dementia, autoimmune conditions, and other chronic diseases) that account for 80% of deaths and healthcare costs and are almost entirely preventable by de-poisoning our food supply.
Then comes COVID, which almost exclusively killed metabolically unhealthy people.
But not once did Dr. Fauci urge for a national reckoning on shifting our food supply to regenerative agriculture and incentivizing movement and sunlight. No, we spent two years of the government microphone almost exclusively devoted to articulating that a pharmaceutical product would be our savior. This was a lie - and one of the most consequential lies In American history.
LEADERSHIP would have been directing the trillions we spend on lockdowns to transforming the metabolic health of America, which is possible.
Losing our way on how we think about health is the most important issue facing America. We need to completely unwind the system that siloes heart disease, diabetes, obesity and dementia Into different categories with different pills to "manage" them. They are the same thing - and are reversible through metabolic habits.
It will bankrupt us and destroy our human capital if we don't get It right.
Around the kitchen table In America - THIS is what matters. Our parents are getting sicker and living more miserable lives In their old age due to chronic diseases. Our kids are walking Into a buzzsaw where 30% of teens have prediabetes. The vast majority of personal bankruptcies in the US are due to medical costs.
But at this time when the corruption and moral bankruptcy of the pharma and public health communities has been laid naked, RFK and Rogan are called the crazy ones for asking questions?
The American people - on both sides - innately see through this.
RFK might very well be wrong on many of his points - but the attacks on him are largely on the fact that he Is asking questions at all (with slurs that he Is "putting lives at risk" and "anti-science) and not on the content of what he is actually saying.
The truth is that public health leaders think vaccines are so important that we should limit any speech or discussion about them because the American people are too stupid to process "misinformation." They do not deserve this benefit of the doubt, particularly in an area where they make hundreds of billions In revenue buttressed by government guidelines that every child should receive over 60 shots.
If some issues are too important to discuss, Congress should pass a law to that effect. It should not be decided by pharma execs and the public health bureaucrats they will eventually employ.
Vaccines most likely have brought a lot of good. But that should be open to discussion. No topic should be off limits, especially if the arbiter of that speech Is pharmaceutical companies.
The societally important point about this moment is that we will be okay if we lean into debate and long-form dialogue - especially around the topics we're told are off limits.
Honestly, Peter Hotez is not the person for the task. The man is a steady stream of incorrect COVID-19 policy, and naked partisan politics.
The truth will be entirely undefended.
Peter, if you claim what RFKjr is saying is “misinformation” I am offering you $100,000.00 to the charity of your choice if you’re willing to debate him on my show with no time limit.
Spotify Has Stopped Even Sort of Trying to Stem Joe Rogan’s Vaccine Misinformation. It’s really true @annamerlan just awful. And from all the online attacks I’m receiving after this absurd podcast, it’s clear many actually believe this nonsense www.vice.com/en/article/k7zz9z/spotify-rogan-rfk-vaccine-…
AstraZeneca had a drug that could have prolonged the lives of control arm patients after they progressed. Outside of the study they marketed it.
But they didn't give them the drug. They just counted their deaths so they could get a win. #asco23
And you celebrate?
#inthenews: New lung cancer study shows taking osimertinib once a day after surgery reduces chance of patients dying by 51%. This demonstrates the importance of dedicated lung cancer research & how it can save lives and give hope for a brighter future. www.theguardian.com/science/2023/jun/04/lung-cancer-pill-…
I am just shocked that this is not a bigger story. @DrMJoyner is an expert on exercise and performance in sports. He made comments in @nytimes about fairness when trans-athletes compete in women's sports and Mayo Clinic punishes him.
INSANE!
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/mayo-clinic-suspends-a-do…
It's amazing that reporters don't want to cover this 👇. It's a real scandal. Almost looks like FDA is working for Pfizer
FDA released Pfizer from studying lower doses. Based on what? They did this before receiving results from the subclinical myocarditis study in this group.
Jay has been 100% vindicated. The burden on PH was to prove that massive disruptions to life have a net health benefit. Not only did they fail to do that. The net outcome for young people has been catastrophic. PH failed to test nearly everything it implemented by force|sick
I saw this tweet today courtesy of @vkoganpolisci
Best single tweetorial I have seen
Hey RDDers, it turns out that it is very difficult to see an effect visually that is significant at the 5 percent level. Perhaps we should stop using RD plots to make statistical inference.....
I made a gif (based on simulated data) to illustrate this point.
I still find it odd that the FDA director says misinformation is #1 cause of death without any data. I might even call such a claim.... misinformation.
🔥 🔥 🔥
So awesome that the @US_FDA director has chosen combating public misinformation as his priority
Important essay w @TracyBethHoeg & @sgdambrauskas @vkprasadlab on the USA's bizarre decision to KEEP recommending masking to 2 year olds
This wartime act of desperation risks being codified in permanent guidelines, further embarrassing public health
authors.elsevier.com/c/1h3o15Q-0lthA0
Mammography: A detailed analysis of the evidence
Does it save lives?
youtu.be/-9hQO7X1bmU
This is a superb thread. Accurate
I wrote a piece on Walensky and scored her just as a scientist
She was 0 for 4
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/walensky-steps-down-at-cd…
Agree w/@MartyMakary & maybe now that she's stepping down we can interview @CDCDirector re:
1. Why 3ft of distance was okay for her own kids but she wanted 6ft in schools as CDC director
2. Why @CDCgov didn't alter their vax recs when they learned about post-vax myocarditis
🧵
I was reading an article on @AnnalsofIM that was funded by government and about remdesivir for COVID and the PDF is still paywalled
Come on, do better.
odd to watch Fauci downplay & misrepresent his position on schools; When DeSantis reopened Apr2020, he did tons of media to fearmonger, and persuaded unions to fight reopening.
Data were clear from Sweden by Q2 2020, & Germany Q3;
Ok to admit your wrong
www.dossier.today/p/dr-flip-flop-a-timeline-of-faucis
It was a human rights violation against children. Their risk of bad covid outcomes was ~0. They sacrificed for scared, cowardly adults. Ultimately nearly nothing was gained (no change in transmission). The full harms have barely been appreciated.
School test results are still lagging behind pre-#covid levels - only 20% of the decline in pass rates have been recovered @TheEconomist
econ.st/3H27jTi
Great article but @DLeonhardt, one missing detail is that swedish data from the spring of 2020 showed that teachers were not at elevated risk. Unions were not acting in teachers best interest either. They were just setting impossible demands not 2 work.
www.nytimes.com/2023/04/28/briefing/pandemic-school-closu…
Near all of the changes in this thread lack randomized data. Giving one bivalent booster to unvaxd person who already had COVID. Lol. No data support this.
This is just making things up.
Today, FDA amended the EUAs of the Pfizer-BioNTech and Moderna COVID-19 bivalent mRNA vaccines to simplify the vaccination schedule for most individuals. www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavirus-c…
What you need to know. 🧵👇
This morning I interviewed Tom Jefferson and @carlheneghan
A great summary of EBM
Cochrane Mask Controversy | Tom Jefferson, Carl Heneghan Interview | Wil... youtu.be/P_JTBftjQuA via @YouTube
Its amazing that US hospitals have run ZERO! randomized trials to justify this policy which is ongoing into year 3
It's not science, it is a religion
Mask mandates at a large London hospital during the first 10 months of Omicron (Dec 2021- Sept 2022) had no discernible effect on hospital-acquired Covid cases, a new study finds.
drive.google.com/file/d/1oZ29hRam4CXGqUFxe-Lh-_l-VCqQwXFT…
US FDA is leaking to the press that we may soon be headed for 7 COVID shots for older people.
Why 7? not 9 or 6?
Evidence based medicine is getting kicked in the face by Peter Marks at FDA. It's amazing how weak their principles are.
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/7-covid-19-shots-5-wuhan-…
1000+ downloads so far
I would highly suggest anyone at all interested, download a copy of these CDC errors (shown in table)
In a future substack post, I will explain why
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
Just OUT @SSRN
By @KelleyKga, AH, @TracyBethHoeg @vkprasadlab
An Analysis of Statistical and Numerical Errors Made by the US @CDCgov
The errors are damning. Basic counts of dead kids, causes of childhood death.
Unacceptable incompetence 👇
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
see 🧵
These are not errors of interpretation or preference but demonstrably false numbers
Horrific that the CDC has made these errors and in some cases still not issued correction, and even repeated the errors
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4381627
Just out on my stack:. Can colleges mandate Ozempic?
It sounds crazy, but let's think through the precedent!
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/can-colleges-mandate-ozem…
Brand new post to our Drug Development substack on a new @vkprasadlab paper by @96_lumos
Subscribe to this substack for free if you follow me for cancer trial interpretation/ drug development perspectives. We will post all content on these themes there
developdrugs.substack.com/p/psma-pet-scans-just-because-i…
4. As the head of NIAID, he conducted ZERO randomized trials of NonPharmacologic interventions
Not 1 of distancing, cohorting, testing, kids masking, adult masking, literally zero
I don't think anyone can say 0 was the right number
The @nytimes that recommends we all mask
Says there is strong evidence masking helps
Click on the word 'evidence' and it leads to a cluster RCT that was.... wait for it...
Negative.
It Failed to show a benefit of masking
The strongest evidence they can find is negative! 🤣🤣
Someone texted me that they're graduating from @Yale but their children can't watch them graduate, because children haven't gotten three doses of mRNA. (A fine decision btw)
Commencement speaker Fauci.
That's a double dose of #thescience
Shame on Yale
China's Protests Should Remind Us that Many American Academics WANTED Zero COVID
Full video on Youtube
youtu.be/sRzfmuAmGKc
Throughout 2021, US states like CA, and Washington have made kids <=5 mask in speech therapy class.
@apsmunro @R_Hughes1 @ShamezLadhani @MAbsoud
EXCLUSIVE: Washington state STILL requires 5-year-olds to mask in speech therapy
My latest for @TPostMillennial
thepostmillennial.com/exclusive-washington-state-still-re…
The key part of this skepticism is the age of the hypothetical patient: Paxlovid probably has only tiny benefits -- maybe rounding to zero -- for a vaxxed 25-year-old because the Covid risks are already so low to that person.
David, it's not just the absolute gain that may be smaller. With low risk sometimes drug safety twarts benefit and there is even harm.
If this weren't COVID, and we were talking about risks of this magnitude, no doctor nor the FDA would even permit it
@DrToddLee @walidgellad
2-4 year olds should never has been asked to mask
There is no convincing evidence on this planet, and the WHO advised against it
This is a shameful pandemic legacy
Between paying $5 billion dollars without randomized data for this pill
And approving bivalent boosters no one wants (3% uptake) based on mouse data
I would prefer my pandemic policy not be brought to you by Pfizer
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/if-you-are-in-charge-of-w…
Throughout the pandemic, with unproven, useless, often harmful, restrictions-some wondered why profs at Stanford, Harvard, UCSF, Oxford, et. would disagree with prevailing wisdom. Isn't it amazing how one possibility never entered their mind: Smart people thought we were wrong
Everytime you modify spike, you could get less myocarditis or you could get more. Novavax shows it's spike not mRNA that's the issue. As such, of course novel boosters need better safety and efficacy testing than mice data. Particularly in young men.
This interview is brilliant
@ZDoggMD is doing a public service with his Paul Offit interviews; Historians will watch these
Offit has had 3 doses of vax & infection (like so many) & he is not inclined to get Bivalent Booster Jha & co are pushing
Wisdom 👇
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q794f__8ZgI
When will we be able to collectively admit that the most ardent proponents of #zerocovid were perhaps not in a good place to think clearly about risks and benefits of sweeping societal restrictions?
An annual COVID19 mRNA not is *NOT AT ALL LIKE* an annual flu shot, a small list of differences
🧵
1. It is far more reactogenic
More people take a day off work/ way more AEs than flu
2. Flu vax tries to predict FUTURE North America strains, BA4/5 are PAST strains...
I can't tell the difference between public health and the Onion
This is spot on 👇
If someone demands a conference mandate masks, you can rest assured their Instagram is full of maskless indoor photos.
If someone thinks toddlers should mask for Phili headstart, they probably just got home from the clubs 👇
Though CDC has aligned COVID guidance to meet where most Americans are, there are some who promote continued restrictions.
Are they consistent themselves, always masking indoors, forgoing indoor events/dining, etc? If not, hypocrisy fuels further distrust in public health.
Burden is on critics
It's a parachute
Unethical to test
How could you even do it?
These are inaccurate and harmful ideas, and are part of the reason CDC failed to run any trials of any NPIs. A staggering failure of leadership 👇👇
I am going to explain why this pair of tweets is both:
- Antithetical to the scientific method
- One of the biggest dangers to medical science
This is very important, so bear with me
1/ 🧵
Honored to assist A. Iness & team in review of Hospital Visitor policies 👇
"Blanket hospital visitor policies were associated with failure to address the unique needs of patients, their visitors, and healthcare providers in various clinical environments"
www.amjmed.com/article/S0002-9343(22)00338-2/fulltext
Fake news (noun) - information that helps Democrats win
Misinformation (noun) - information that helps Republicans win
Politicians are wrong to say big tech needs more content moderation and censorship, It will only be abused to reinforce power.
vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/president-obama-wants-big…
Everyone tweeting that new Pediatrics study proving masks slow spread in school.
It's really bad people.... Really bad.... Come on, we can do better no matter what policy you favor. My take
Some Oncology drug approvals are so problematic that they are best thought of as financial products.
They transfer massive wealth from society to shareholders and, as used in the real world, offer not net gain for human health
After 2 yrs where at some point natural immunity, vax induced myocarditis, & the possibility vax'd people transmit virus were all considered misinformation
Seems reckless to think White House should have access to this info, and it will surely be misused
www.nytimes.com/2022/03/03/technology/surgeon-general-cov…
Vaccine passports at restaurants separate people who can spread covid from those who can spread covid
All I know is: if you read the studies they are publishing, the reason they aren't sharing this data is absolutely not that they want to get the analysis right.
The C.D.C. Isn’t Publishing Large Portions of the Covid Data It Collects www.nytimes.com/2022/02/20/health/covid-cdc-data.html
I offer 10 take away lessons from covid 19
It's not too late to avert the course we are on
bariweiss.substack.com/p/how-to-save-science-from-covid-p…
Enjoyed this article by @fayeflam
Only thing I disagree with is that mask mandates should be present above & not below some prevalence threshold
We never studied that, so any such # is just made up
www.washingtonpost.com/business/mask-mandates-didnt-make-…
If we took the energy spent on boosting young adults/ booster mandates, and launched a program to document natural immunity (NI), and kindly encouraged those without any NI to at least just get 1 dose of vax, we would save far more lives, and the policy would actually make sense.
Instead of mandating vaccines for 5 to 11-year-olds, why don't we encourage boosters for 65-year-olds?
I guess I'm an old fashioned doc who likes to do things that offer the largest returns.
Everything done to keep kids "safe" has been delusional, unproven, harmful mitigation that is not proportionate to the risks they face, harmful to their language and development, and has hurt a generation more than any other insult this century.
The left failed kids
End of story
What if: when societies make unprecedented, sweeping policy decisions, different smart experts view the tradeoffs differently?
Imagine if universities & media held debates w/ different scholars & views, instead of pushing a single 'truth' which inevitably errs
On @karaswisher's podcast, @ashishkjha says the pandemic has given way to too many wannabe experts who fool the public because they have fancy job titles.
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/24/opinion/sway-kara-swisher-emil…
And kids in Flint abandoned one more time...
www.mlive.com/news/flint/2022/01/flint-schools-extends-vi…
Important comment 👇👇 from Catherine Sarkisian, Professor UCLA on the JAMA news & views critical of parents who are taking it slow to vaccinate kids 5 to 11
How Democracy Ends
COVID19 policy provides a roadmap to a future leader...
by @VPrasadMDMPH vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/how-democracy-ends?r=cz87q
Bangladesh RCT - encouraging adults to wear surgical mask slows covid spread among older people
Cloth masks do not work
USA has spent 18 months pushing the wrong mask mandates.
Kids mask in schools untested, & now DESPERATELY NEEDS CLUSTER RCT
NPIs are the most divisive issue
Falling along political lines
But no one knows
CDC could have saved us by running trials which no intelligent person could argue with
They didn't so
Polarization grows
Arguing about lousy evidence
CDC failed us all
www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/93803?trw=no
Follow the science....
....
....
....
Eventually!
School closure is like the Iraq war
Didn't make us safer
We embarked on it due to inaccurate info
Millions of children were harmed
Public sentiment will shift
Many will on the wrong side of history
It was a mistake
Closing schools in March 2020 - IDK tough call
Keeping schools closed Sept 2020 to present - a catastrophic error that should not have happened
Entire departments in universities will study this error
The difference between the NYTimes models and reality (blue) 👇👇
Reality is better than the best case
This model ran on Jan 24 2021 and aids school closure.
No more models. Let's report data
Many sacrificed over the last year, but none more than public school children
They lost learning, upward mobility, socialization, well being, a hot meal, someone to detect child abuse & all for a virus with risk of bad outcomes on par with flu for ages 4-15
In 10 years someone is going to draw a line from fear mongering on this website to the policy choice that resulted in 3 million US children having no outside contact since March of 2020.
History will be the ultimate judge, but my prediction is it won't be kind.
It's amazing that we're going to go the entire pandemic, and finish having learned nearly nothing about which non-pharmacologic interventions are beneficial, neutral, detrimental in well done studies.
The difference btw these 2 tweets tells you everything you need to know about social media and covid
Totally opposite messages about what vaccination means
Hope vs. fear
Optimism vs. pessimism
Opportunity vs. prohibition
Empowering vs judging
Of course, Monica is right
Let me be perfectly clear: children DO NOT NEED a sars-cov-2 vaccine before they are permitted to return to normal activities, such as school and visiting loved ones.
Any claims to the contrary are demoralizing and counter to common sense and medicine
Here is why [thread]
My view on schools-- they ought be open in all but rarest instances-was reached from late summer to fall, when I spent considerable time examining the risk of virtual schools to kids vs. the risk of in person schools to kids, teachers, community
Here is my journey
[thread]
One of the best articles written about schools in US vs UK
Political opposition to Trump, and the unions, and not any infrastructure were the key barriers, and remain so.
This is a similar conclusion to the one I have reached after examining this www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/12/why-british-kid…
This makes as much sense to slow the spread of sars-cov-2 as slaughtering a goat
Here was my 2c on the trial
www.medpagetoday.com/blogs/vinay-prasad/89778
No, it does not
One ref here: jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle…
And several more in here:
www.amazon.com/Malignant-Policy-Evidence-People-Cancer/dp…
I know tensions r high
Just today someone said the santa clara study "caused more deaths"
Today in pre-print, Ioannidis summarizes all IFR estimates n>500 and this is Santa Clara
Its still worth reading folks you may disagree with👇
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.13.20101253v1.ful…
Didler Raoult is salt in the coronavirus wound
Here's why [thread]
1. The gentleman's comments reveal he does not understand why RCTs are important in medicine
🤦♂️This attitude is harmful
This by Didier Raoult (who originated the uncontrolled, poorly peer reviewed #hydroxycloroquine and #azithromycin study) telling us that a control group in current study would violate the Hippocratic Oath. Nonsensical and irresponsible. #covid19 @ArthurCaplan #idtwitter #ethics