I had not realized until this moment that Japanese judges are serving as the presidents of both the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court.
David Bosco
David L. Bosco is an American journalist, author and academic who writes on the subject of international relations with a focus on the United Nations, international courts, and the law of the sea. Currently, he is the interim dean of Indiana University's Hamilton Lugar School of Global and International Studies. More on Wikipedia
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Trump administration is preparing to impose sweeping sanctions on the International Criminal Court, according to officials www.wsj.com/politics/policy/trump-administration-prepares… via @WSJ
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The House Judiciary Committee is holding a session on the threat posed by the International Criminal Court with two experts who seem to have quite limited background in the ICC. judiciary.house.gov/committee-activity/hearings/internati…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As Trump squeezes the International Criminal Court, more countries are leaving apnews.com/article/icc-trump-sanctions-international-cour…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Mongolia is another likely candidate for the exits given its location between Russia and China, its desire to maintain strong links with the US, and the criticism it received from ICC member states for welcoming Vladimir Putin in 2024.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
What was the last international crisis in which the UN Secretary General played a meaningful mediation role?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
One of the more interesting takes I've read on the ICC-Trump administration clash, by @zacharykaufman www.jpost.com/opinion/article-907138
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The International Criminal Court finds itself snared in geopolitical conflicts after targeting the leaders of Israel and Russia www.wsj.com/world/the-icc-tried-to-take-on-the-worlds-big… via @WSJ
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In my 2014 book on the ICC, I argued that the court had in its first decade (2003-13) forged a fragile accommodation with the big powers who were not members. Over the next ten years, that accommodation has unraveled in fits and starts. a.co/d/00IgEP0b
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
From the Strait of Hormuz to the state of Hormuz.
i24NEWS English
@i24NEWS_EN
🔴 Trump declares Strait of Hormuz is a 'new US territory' in provocative post to his TruthSocial account
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm very excited that registration is now open for the third annual Hamilton Lugar/ILSA international moot court for undergraduate students. This year's competition will be held at Indiana University's brand new Washington, DC building. Spots are limited so register soon!
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Still quite unclear who is contributing troops to the International Stabilization Force
The White House
@WhiteHouse
Today, the Board of Peace reached a HISTORIC agreement for the COMPLETE DISARMAMENT of Hamas and all other armed groups in Gaza.
A monumental step toward lasting PEACE and SECURITY. -
David Bosco reposted
-
David Bosco reposted
Ryan Goodman
@rgoodlaw
The Future of the International Criminal Court: What Follows After Removal of the Prosecutor
By my terrific colleagues @bechamilton and Alex Whiting
www.justsecurity.org/149478/future-international-criminal… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Venezuela notifies UN of withdrawal from ICC www.reuters.com/world/americas/venezuela-notifies-un-with…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Not only does Ukraine have cards, it turns out, it now has MAGA-adjacent influencers.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm hearing that Karim Khan has been removed as ICC prosecutor.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's an important day for the International Criminal Court as its member states meet to consider whether to remove the current prosecutor, Karim Khan.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Where does all this end? I really don't know. Having a permanent criminal court is important but it has to reconnect in some more reasonable way with the realities of state power.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
One positive step in my view would be for the court's member states to somehow limit or remove jurisdiction over non-member state nationals. These cases are not viable for the court and they embroil the court in political struggles it cannot win.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's very hard to know what's going on behind the scenes and whether there's any plan to do that. Restructuring an institution already in existence is extremely difficult and any kind of push like this will normally succumb to more pressing issues.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Absent some kind of fundamental change, the ICC will stumble on as a kind of lost institution, battered by the realities of international politics from which its creators did not adequately shelter it.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
BREAKING: NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani to release plan for the reform of the UN Security Council after consulting with city lawyers.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The New York Times ran another story recently inquiring into the legality of strikes in Iran on dual-use facilities. This has been a recurring area of interest for major Western media outlets. www.nytimes.com/2026/07/11/world/middleeast/iran-steel-pl…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
To my mind, the answer is straightforward: the interest of the media, scholars, and the broader public in the legality of particular tactics in warfare is almost inextricably linked to their judgements on the justness of the underlying conflict.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The view (which I share!) that Ukraine is fighting a just and necessary war of self defense against aggression--and the more implicit view that Russian civilians have been complicit in aggression--seems very much to be influencing the level of interest in the law of armed conflict.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Adding to this thread in light of a major Ukrainian strike on civilian delivery warehouses. www.cnn.com/2026/07/18/europe/eight-killed-in-ukrainian-d…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm amazed that New York city's legal team hasn't definitively disabused Mamdani of this idea www.nytimes.com/2026/07/18/nyregion/mamdani-netanyahu-int…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I just do not see colorable arguments that New York City police arresting Netanyahu would be either required by international law (given that US is not an ICC member); or permissible under US law (given the primacy of the federal government in international relations).
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Mamdani's refusal to back off this idea strikes me as both dishonest legally and institutionally reckless, given the confrontation between local and federal authority that it would create.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In light of the renewed US campaign against the ICC, re-upping this (likely quixotic) proposal for a ceasefire that involves an end to sanctions but also a more restrained court that gives up on the idea of prosecuting non-member nationals www.lawfaremedia.org/article/court-in-a-storm--israel--th…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
US Secretary of State Rubio announces a new campaign against the International Criminal Court www.state.gov/releases/office-of-the-spokesperson/2026/07…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's not clear how many of the announced measures are really new however. A lot will depend on the scope of the sanctions that are mentioned.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The US announcement comes at a very delicate moment for the ICC, as the court's membership decides whether to jettison the current prosecutor over allegations of sexual misconduct.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
President Trump’s peace plan for Gaza envisioned a 20,000-strong force of international peacekeepers. Now, the ISF is struggling to deploy even an initial group of about 10 to 20 troops. www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/trump-wanted-20-000-peaceke… via @WSJ
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
England has a chance today to finally avenge Norway's victory in the 1951 Anglo-Fisheries case at the International Court of Justice. The excessiveness of Norway's maritime baselines rankles in England to this day.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Shouldn't the US-Bosnia game be played in Dayton, Ohio?
-
David Bosco reposted
Freedom House
@freedomhouse
Join Freedom House and the Hamilton Lugar School of Global and International Studies for a discussion on “Defending Democracy, Countering Authoritarianism, and the Future of U.S. Global Leadership” this Monday, June 8 in Chicago.
Freedom House CEO @Jamiemfly and Hamilton Lugar School Interim Dean David Bosco (@multilateralist ) will examine the state of global freedom, the rise of authoritarian influence, and how governments, institutions, and civil society can respond to democratic backsliding.
events.iu.edu/hls/event/2293105-the-chicago-briefing-stre… -
David Bosco reposted
Leslie Vinjamuri
@londonvinjamuri
Terrific opportunity. Please share with your networks.
Senior Editor/Writer, Executive & Editorial Communications - Job opening at The Chicago Council on Global Affairs jobs.localjobnetwork.com/j/87239103 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In light of the Strait of Hormuz crisis, worth reposting this thread on my recent book about the fragility of "freedom of the seas" and how its golden age is now well past.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This week was the official publication of my new book, The Poseidon Project, by Oxford University Press. A brief thread on my central argument: www.amazon.com/dp/0190265647 via @amazon
-
David Bosco reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
Member states of the International Criminal Court voted on Wednesday to move ahead with disciplinary proceedings against Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan, officials familiar with the vote said. www.wsj.com/us-news/law/icc-moves-ahead-with-disciplinary…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Assessing the ICC’s Impact in Ukraine at www.justsecurity.org/130832/assessing-the-iccs-impact-in-…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It will be interesting to see what (if any) international law argument the US government makes about the Venezuela incursion.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The simpler (but least convincing) argument would be to shove the whole operation into the self-defense framework, which is what countries tend to do when they put forward arguments on the international stage.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If memory serves, the US used all of these arguments to some extent in justifying the 1989 invasion of Panama, which has a lot of parallels.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
GOP lawmakers want to bring back privateers www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/12/19/us-privateers-pir…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For anyone needing a refresher on the history of piracy, privateering, and the law of the sea, please consider my recent book: The Poseidon Project 😉 a.co/d/d93BrnY
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
More ICC judges added to the US sanctions list.
Secretary Marco Rubio
@SecRubio
Today, the Trump Administration is sanctioning two International Criminal Court judges directly engaged in politicized and illegitimate actions against Israel. The United States has been clear: we will continue to respond with significant and tangible consequences to protect against the ICC’s lawfare, abuse of power, and blatant disregard for the sovereignty of the U.S. and Israel.
-
David Bosco reposted
SC Procedure
@SCProcedure
This is what the Security Council horseshoe table will look like as of January 2026!
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
With tension between the United States and Venezuela mounting, it's worth remembering that there are longstanding disagreements between them over maritime rights.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If open conflict does break out, it may well be because of an incident related to maritime rights. As in the South China Sea, disagreements about maritime zones and rules could easily provide a spark to conflict.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
(One oddity of the US-Venezuela confrontation is that neither country is a member of UNCLOS, the main treaty regulating maritime affairs.)
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
China has launched a new grouping at the UN, called the Group of Friends of Global Governance. I can't find a list of member states but China is claiming about 40.
Chinese Mission to UN
@Chinamission2un
Today, the Group of Friends of Global Governance held its inaugural meeting at UN Headquarters in New York. Launched at China’s initiative, the Group will serve as an open, inclusive platform to mobilize collective efforts for better global governance. #ggi
-
David Bosco reposted
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sprouting shoots of normal accountability functions: (i) an IG report critical of Sec Def; (ii) serious congressional engagement with the Venezuela boat strikes; (iii) a change in DOD protocols, presumably sparked by internal legal concerns, to rescue rather than kill first-strike survivors.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
At the moment, two likely contributors to a Gaza peacekeeping mission (Indonesia and Pakistan) are explicitly saying that their forces will not disarm Hamas.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In its recent broadsides against Japan over Taiwan, China has made several references to the UN and the Security Council in particular. First, Beijing has emphasized that Japan is "totally unqualified" to hold a permanent Council seat. (Securing permanent Council membership has been a key Japanese goal for several decades.)
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
China is citing these clauses--treated as a dead letter by most international law experts--to support the idea that it would be lawful for China to use force against Japan, even without Security Council approval.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
See below for a good primer on the drafting history and meaning of the "enemy states clauses" opil.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/la…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
NYC Mayor-elect Mamdani doubles down on Netanyahu arrest pledge www.foxnews.com/politics/nyc-mayor-elect-mamdani-doubles-… #foxnews
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
UN Security Council backs US Gaza plan bbc.com/news/articles/c0rpkgq4wllo
-
David Bosco reposted
U.S. Mission to the UN
@USUN
The United States thanks Qatar, Egypt, the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Indonesia, Pakistan, Jordan, and Türkiye for backing our Security Council resolution on Gaza that advances President Trump’s historic 20-point Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict.
With firm regional endorsement secured at Sharm El-Sheikh on Sept 29, this plan delivers a credible path to lasting peace and stability for Israelis, Palestinians, and the region. We call for swift adoption.
usun.usmission.gov/joint-statement-on-the-un-security-cou… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Notable how much emphasis the Trump administration is putting on getting UN Security Council blessing for its Gaza plan. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/11/14/united-nations…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This is obviously because other key countries want it, not out of any belief in the importance of the UN imprimatur. But still, it does require the Trump team to actually negotiate at the UN and try their hand at persuasion rather than bullying.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
My review of Ardi Imseis's new book on the United Nations and Palestine, published in the American Journal of International Law www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-journal-of-inter…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Indonesia says it's ready to send up to 20,000 troops to Gaza, but with a focus on health and reconstruction (not, presumably, disarming Hamas) www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/indonesia-says-its-gaz…
-
David Bosco reposted
Ricardo Arredondo 🇦🇷
@arredondos
The ICJ faces a growing crisis of authority. Compliance with its rulings has fallen from 80% to ~50%. As states increasingly defy the Court, the legitimacy of the entire international legal system is at risk. www.theguardian.com/law/2025/nov/11/willing-states-must-a…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Haaretz has a report on some of the provisions in the draft UN Security Council resolution on Gaza.
www.haaretz.com/us-news/2025-11-12/ty-article/.premium/u-… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A good examination of the Gaza peacekeeping dilemma by @anchalvohra foreignpolicy.com/2025/11/06/the-desperate-search-for-gaz…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An update on the state of play for a UN-authorized international security force in Gaza. www.axios.com/2025/11/03/gaza-security-force-board-of-pea…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The reporting suggests the international force will have authorization much more robust than a traditional peacekeeping force. That may be, but lots of skepticism is in order that any of the countries likely to contribute forces will want their troops performing those functions.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As the US seemingly moves toward military conflict in Venezuela, worth remembering that Venezuela is an International Criminal Court member state and that the court has an investigation underway in the country. www.icc-cpi.int/venezuela-i
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
John Bolton is more profligate in the use of exclamation points than I would have expected.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Countries I've seen mentioned as possible contributors to a Gaza peacekeeping force: Turkey, Egypt, Qatar, Malaysia, Indonesia, Ireland.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
ICC judges disqualify ICC prosecutor Khan from Duterte case, court document shows www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/icc-judges-disqualify-…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Putin visits ICC member Tajikistan despite arrest warrant apnews.com/article/russia-putin-tajikistan-summit-central…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This trip comes just over a year after Putin's trip to Mongolia, also an ICC member state.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
ICC staff print files and prepare for blackout as US sanctions loom www.ft.com/content/d4fc9e72-c45b-4f46-82dc-9a5b1829c1e1 via @ft
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The only mention of a United Nations role in the Trump administration's Gaza peace plan relates to humanitarian aid distribution. www.nytimes.com/2025/09/29/world/middleeast/gaza-israel-c…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Could a Security Council resolution freezing the ICC's Palestine investigation be part of a peace deal? www.israelhayom.com/2025/09/29/israel-seeks-legal-protect…
-
David Bosco reposted
Emmanuel Macron
@EmmanuelMacron
Photo de famille !
Avec tous les États qui ont permis la ratification du Traité sur la haute mer dit BBNJ. Tous réunis et engagés pour protéger les océans et la diversité biologique marine. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I do wish that President Trump had banged his shoe on the podium at the UN.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Reported withdrawals from the ICC www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2025/09/23/burkin…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The 12-pack of centrifuges was the problem.
Seung Min Kim
@seungminkim
The U.S. is barring Iranian diplomats from shopping at Costco apnews.com/live/donald-trump-news-updates-9-22-2025
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If you know undergraduate students interested in international law, make sure they check out the international law moot court competition @hamiltonlugar
David Bosco
@multilateralist
We are so excited to partner with the experts at the International Law Students Association in making this competition a reality. It's a fantastic opportunity for undergraduates to sharpen their international law skills. @The_Jessup
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Exclusive: US could hit entire International Criminal Court with sanctions soon www.reuters.com/world/europe/us-could-hit-entire-internat…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Given the importance of keeping the US on board regarding Ukraine, European leaders may be reluctant to fight about the ICC by working to circumvent the potential US sanctions.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A few months ago, I proposed a way out of this confrontation that would involve an ICC with narrower (but, to my mind, more viable) reach. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/court-in-a-storm--israel--th…
-
David Bosco reposted
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
The UN Security Council has reached a historic milestone – its 10,000th meeting since 1946.
The session focuses on the Middle East, underscoring the Council’s core mission: upholding international peace and security. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@MikeFroman joins the long line of observers arguing that the rules of the "rules-based international order" are fraying badly on.cfr.org/46jU8ZH via @CFR_org
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But arguments like this lean heavily on an implicit assumption that there was a period when the rules were mostly followed on the use of force--and that seems really hard to square with the historical record.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Are the violations of the Charter and the Geneva Conventions today really more grave and more frequent than during the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s (which included the Cambodian genocide, several major Middle East wars, the Soviet invasions of Czechoslovakia and Afghanistan, and the US invasions of Grenada and Panama)
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm very surprised that Mamdani is doubling down on the idea of arresting Netanyahu www.nytimes.com/2025/09/12/nyregion/mamdani-arrest-netany…
-
David Bosco reposted
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
#breaking
UN General Assembly ADOPTS resolution endorsing the New York Declaration on the Peaceful Settlement of the Question of Palestine and the Implementation of the Two-State Solution
Voting result
In favor: 142
Against: 10
Abstain: 12 -
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
The United Nations Security Council on Thursday condemned recent strikes on Qatar's capital Doha, but did not mention Israel in the statement that was agreed by all 15 members, including Israel's ally the United States.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Former Israeli foreign minister and prime minister and current opposition leader @yairlapid publishes a call @FoxNews for democracies to abandon the UN www.foxnews.com/opinion/un-stage-hypocrisy-its-time-democ… #foxnews
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But the UN Charter does not actually make a democratic form of government a requirement for membership. Instead it says the organization is open to "peace-loving states which accept the obligations...in the present Charter."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
More importantly, one of the core political functions that the UN has served over the years is to provide a forum and a vehicle for interactions between very different and sometimes very hostile states.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The US Coast Guard recently queried two Chinese research ships operating in the Arctic www.news.uscg.mil/Press-Releases/Article/4293164/us-coast…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Chinese vessels were operating in waters over what the US claims is its extended continental shelf in the region.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Those targeted by US sanctions related to the ICC now include the court's prosecutors, several judges, a UN special rapporteur, and now these NGOs. No moves yet against corporations that provide services to the court.
Secretary Marco Rubio
@SecRubio
Today, the Trump Administration is sanctioning three NGOs—Al Haq, Al Mezan, and the Palestinian Centre for Human Rights— for assisting in the ICC’s illegitimate actions against Israel. The United States will continue to protect our own sovereignty and the sovereignty of our allies from the ICC’s overreach.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Two important additions to the world's multilateral architecture were made in the mid-1990s: the World Trade Organization and the International Criminal Court. Both are in dire straits today.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's exceedingly unlikely that Karim Khan will return to his role as ICC prosecutor. What's the plan for member states? www.theguardian.com/law/2025/aug/28/second-woman-accuses-…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I very much enjoyed talking with Helen Dewar about The Poseidon Project newbooksnetwork.com/the-poseidon-project
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Landlocked Moldova pushes the new oceans treaty to 140 signatures.
High Seas Alliance
@HighSeasAllianc
👏 Congratulations to the Republic of Moldova🇲🇩 @UNMoldova for adding its signature to the #bbnj Agreement.
🎊 So far, 1️⃣4️⃣0️⃣ countries have now officially committed to its ratification!
We look forward to their ratification at the UN soon.
#raceforratification -
David Bosco reposted
High Seas Alliance
@HighSeasAllianc
👏 Congratulations to the Republic of Moldova🇲🇩 @UNMoldova for adding its signature to the #bbnj Agreement.
🎊 So far, 1️⃣4️⃣0️⃣ countries have now officially committed to its ratification!
We look forward to their ratification at the UN soon.
#raceforratification -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
You can indict a ham sandwich, but not he who threw it. www.nytimes.com/2025/08/27/us/politics/trump-sandwich-ass…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Does anyone know if the Chinese report on US freedom of navigation operations referenced here has been published in English yet?
sc.mp/2n3xx via @scmpnews -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The arc of history is long but it bends toward John Bolton being a hero of the resistance
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But the circle of John Bolton will not be complete until he testifies against Trump at the International Criminal Court.
-
David Bosco reposted
Kevin Jon Heller 🇺🇸🇩🇰
@kevinjonheller
Apparently the US has now sanctioned both #icc Deputy Prosecutors, Khan and Niang, as well as Judge Guillou of France and Judge Prost of Canada. sanctionssearch.ofac.treas.gov
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Switzerland ready to host Putin for Geneva peace talks despite ICC warrant, minister says www.reuters.com/world/europe/switzerland-ready-host-putin…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Egypt willing to support peacekeeping force in Gaza but wants a UN Security Council resolution f24.my/BNK9.X via @FRANCE24
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A realist interpretation of the recent ICC debate about jurisdictional limits for the crime of aggression www.ejiltalk.org/how-the-icc-assembly-of-states-parties-f…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
UN report finds United Nations reports are not widely read www.reuters.com/world/un-report-finds-united-nations-repo…
-
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
A White House official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the U.N. post would not be cabinet-level.
www.reuters.com/world/china/trumps-un-envoy-pick-waltz-sa… -
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
Quick take on @michaelgwaltz remarks to @SenateForeign just now:
* UN insiders will be mightily relieved.
* There was the standard @GOP criticism of @UN, but the general theme was "make the UN work (for the U.S.)" not "we are walking away".
[1/3] -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The special rapporteur system seems like a real mixed bag for the United Nations. You get experts operating at low cost on vital issues, often doing important work. But you also have dozens of individuals running around the world with varying degrees of judgement and skill who the public perceives to be representing the UN but over whom the UN leadership has little control.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Would Germany allow Netanyahu to visit despite ICC arrest warrant? www.politico.eu/article/germany-frank-walter-steinmeier-a…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For those trying to keep track of where some key players stand on the legality of the Israeli/US strikes:
NATO chief: strikes not illegal
Germany: no reason to criticize the attacks
France: strikes lacked a legal basis
UK: no comment on legality -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Has anyone seen the full statement in which Macron said that the US strikes were "not illegal"?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The assertions that US strikes on Iran are obviously unconstitutional is hard to square with the long record of interventions launched without Congress's approval, including Libya (under Obama), Kosovo (under Clinton), Panama (GHW Bush), and Grenada (Reagan).
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I don't think this practice is good, but the president's practice of claiming power to use force without Congressional approval is longstanding and cuts across party lines.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Trump is going for the Kissinger route to the Nobel
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Very good explainer by @amandataub on the jus ad bellum in the context of Israel-Iran conflict (but it does suggest that the Caroline standard relates to the use of force overall, rather than specifically to the concept of self-defense). www.nytimes.com/2025/06/20/world/middleeast/iran-israel-a…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I also disagree with claim that the US relied on preemptive self-defense as legal basis for the 2003 Iraq War. I think US position was that the UNSC had authorized force in 1990 and that Iraq's material breach of the ceasefire provisions kept that authorization operative.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There was certainly US rhetoric about preemption but the formal argument, as distilled in the letter to the Security Council of March 20, 2003, relied on existing UN resolutions. digitallibrary.un.org/record/490434?v=pdf
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Some thoughts on whether the International Criminal Court should be viewed as a political actor iccforum.com/politics
-
David Bosco reposted
Kevin Jon Heller 🇺🇸🇩🇰
@kevinjonheller
The PTC issued an important decision today concerning prosecutorial discretion. The decision involves an attempt by @amnesty to force the OTP to open a formal proprio motu investigation in #nigeria. By majority, the PTC held it did not have the authority to issue such an order.
-
David Bosco reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Lawfare is hiring!
We are looking for a new full-time senior editor. Responsibilities of the role include contributing analysis of key issues in national security law and policy and more. The ideal candidate will have a professional background in journalism, law, policy, or academia. -
David Bosco reposted
DavidKenner
@DavidKenner
My latest story is about lawlessness on the high seas.
In 2023, the Med Sea Eagle was abandoned off the coast of the UAE, and conditions grew so dire one crew member attempted suicide.
In 2024, the cargo ship delivered military equipment to a warlord in eastern Libya. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The head of the International Seabed Authority pleads with the United States to engage on deep seabed mining regulations. www.economist.com/by-invitation/2025/06/10/the-deep-sea-n…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Exclusive: David Cameron threatened to withdraw UK from ICC over Israel war crimes probe www.middleeasteye.net/news/david-cameron-threatened-withd…
-
David Bosco reposted
Hümeyra Pamuk
@humeyra_pamuk
BREAKING: Trump administration just imposed sanctions on four ICC judges, an unprecedented retaliation over the war tribunal's investigation into alleged war crimes by U.S. troops in Afghanistan and over the court's issuance of an arrest warrant for Israeli PM Netanyahu.
-
David Bosco reposted
Kevin Jon Heller 🇺🇸🇩🇰
@kevinjonheller
The US has sanctioned four #icc judges, PTC and AC, connected to the Netanyahu and Gallant arrest warrants: Hohler (Slovenia), Alapini-Gansou (Benin), Carmen del Luz (Peru), Bossa (Uganda). Notably, Guilou (France) and Tomoki (Japan) were not sanctioned. sanctionssearch.ofac.treas.gov
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Microsoft didn’t cut services to International Criminal Court, its president says www.politico.eu/article/microsoft-did-not-cut-services-in…
-
David Bosco reposted
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
⚡️Statement from ICC Deputy Prosecutors:
"Deputy Prosecutors Nazhat Shameem Khan and Mame Mandiaye Niang have assumed leadership, management and administration of the Office, following Prosecutor Karim A.A. Khan KC’s decision to take a leave of absence."
www.icc-cpi.int/news/icc-deputy-prosecutors-work-office-c… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Big ICC news www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2025/05/16/karim…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Associated Press details the impact of sanctions on the ICC apnews.com/article/icc-trump-sanctions-karim-khan-court-a…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
And this is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of the sanctions that could be coming. I think it's time for the court's member states to think seriously about an alternative path. One idea from a few months ago:
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/court-in-a-storm--israel--th… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Watching the Trump administration's trade policy, I keep thinking of the Curious George stories. George creates enormous chaos in processes that he doesn't understand but then figures out how to undo some of the damage done and ends up receiving general acclaim.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Sovereignty wins the Kentucky Derby, as Supranationalism fades
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
We are several weeks past the date by which the Treasury Secretary, in consultation with the Secretary of State, was to have identified additional individuals to be targeted for sanctions related to International Criminal Court activity.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The new Trump administration executive order on seabed mining www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/04/unleashin…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It instructs the secretary of commerce and other cabinet officials to examine the "feasibility of an international benefit-sharing mechanism for seabed mineral resource extraction and development that occurs in areas beyond the national jurisdiction of any country."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Why odd? Because one of the key objections that the US has had to joining UNCLOS is the role of the International Seabed Authority and its own benefits sharing structure.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Bretton Woods institutions have largely steered clear of Trump's wrath; the latest IMF report will test that pattern
www.cnbc.com/2025/04/22/imf-slashes-us-growth-forecast-by… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A difficult birthday for the World Trade Organization.
Germany UN Geneva 🇩🇪🇺🇳
@GermanyUNGeneva
Congrats on 30 years of the WTO!
At WTO’s anniversary, EU Commission President Von der Leyen reaffirmed the WTO’s vital role at the core of a rules-based, transparent & open trading system. In times of uncertainty, Germany remains firmly committed to a strong WTO. #wtoat30 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Belgian PM says he would ignore Netanyahu ICC arrest warrant, cites 'realpolitik' www.jpost.com/israel-news/article-849231
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Trump administration's moves on seabed mining are worth highlighting. In short, there are signs that the US is ready to link up with commercial partners to mine areas of the deep seabed (beyond EEZs and territorial waters)
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The apparent US plans to consider deep sea mining outside UNCLOS are a throwback to the Reagan administration's early days. The Reagan team also saw the international seabed mining apparatus as anathema and wanted US companies to pursue opportunities independently.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Many of the hard questions about seabed mining and how it will be regulated have been delayed for decades because commercial projects were not economically viable. That is starting to change and it's causing significant strain both inside the UNCLOS framework and outside.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Exclusive: ICC prosecutor Khan accused of retaliation for sexual misconduct allegation, sources say www.reuters.com/world/europe/icc-prosecutor-khan-accused-…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Not good for a court in the midst of a potentially existential struggle with the United States.
-
David Bosco reposted
Szabolcs Panyi
@panyiszabolcs
🚨BREAKING: HUNGARY QUITS THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT ON WEDNESDAY—just as Netanyahu, wanted by the ICC for war crimes & crimes against humanity, arrives in Budapest for a multi-day visit.
First reported by RFE/RL, confirmed to me at @VSquare_Project by diplomatic sources. -
David Bosco reposted
The Metals Company
@themetalsco
We’re encouraged by the growing recognition in Washington that nodules represent a strategic opportunity for America, and the world. Great to see U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio note how responsible deep-sea mineral exploitation can strengthen national security and prosperity during a recent visit to Kingston, Jamaica—with the nearby ISA Council session ongoing.
$TMC #deepseamining -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The registration deadline for the first ever undergraduate international law moot court competition is fast approaching! www.ilsa.org/ihl/
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Duterte reportedly on his way to The Hague www.cnn.com/2025/03/11/asia/rodrigo-duterte-philippine-ar…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Struggling for historical analogies to today's Oval Office scene: It wasn't nearly as public, but the feuding between FDR's team and Charles de Gaulle during WWII was epic, with FDR deriding the resistance leader as a "prima donna" who thought he was a modern-day Joan of Arc.
-
David Bosco reposted
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
The International Criminal Court has confirmed the death of Mohammed Diab Ibrahim Al-Masri (‘Deif’) and terminated proceedings against him.
The ICC charged Deif with war crimes and crimes against humanity committed on 10/7 and against hostages in captivity. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Thinking about the death of the ICC and what comes next www.justiceinfo.net/en/141309-thinking-about-death-icc-wh…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@justiceinfonet I think (and hope!) it's premature to talk about the death of the court, but there's no doubt that hard times are ahead and that court members face some difficult choices. My thoughts on a possible path through: www.lawfaremedia.org/article/court-in-a-storm--israel--th…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Text of the Executive Order imposing new sanctions on the International Criminal Court and those assisting it. www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/02/imposing-…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
That language would seem to cover all sorts of companies that provide services to the court. It's left up to the Secretary of State to determine who fits into this category.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Here's my argument for how (even against the backdrop of this sanctions threat) there might be a path forward. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/court-in-a-storm--israel--th…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Notable, given the tensions in the South China Sea.
AMTI
@AsiaMTI
U.S. defense secretary Hegseth reassures the Philippines that Washington remains “ironclad” in its commitment to the Mutual Defense Treaty. www.scmp.com/week-asia/politics/article/3297661/philippin… @SCMPNews
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Argentina to withdraw from World Health Organization, following Trump www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/02/05/milei-argentina-w…
-
David Bosco reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
"[T]he ICC’s problem is architectural: The court has jurisdiction that is unmanageably broad. There remains a narrow but viable pathway toward an approach that both addresses U.S. concerns and yields a more effective form of international justice," writes @multilateralist.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A semi-serious point about the law of the sea and the Trump administration, given what we're seeing about Trump's expansionist instincts (in Greenland, Panama, and now Gaza).
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But if what we're seeing from Trump in terms of expansionism somehow materializes on ocean affairs, we could be in a position where the two leading powers are both pushing against the compromise represented by the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The "Gulf of America" episode, coupled with Trump's longstanding desire to control resources, suggest that there is potential tinder for unilateral moves on ocean space and resources.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Given the futility of so many Security Council resolutions, there is something fitting--even poignant--about the Council members sitting around their table and looking at the world through virtual reality goggles.
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
UN Security Council members experience a virtual reality (VR) showcase of the vital work of the @UNPeacekeeping Mission in #southsudan @UNMISSmedia
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A sign that US resistance to China's claims in the South China Sea will remain consistent across administrations www.reuters.com/world/philippines-us-joint-air-patrol-exe…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This news is almost reassuringly normal for an incoming Republican administration www.npr.org/2025/02/03/nx-s1-5285696/trump-un-human-right…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It just occurred to me that Denmark and Panama are both on the UN Security Council.
-
David Bosco reposted
Claudia Sheinbaum Pardo
@Claudiashein
Sostuvimos una buena conversación con el presidente Trump con mucho respeto a nuestra relación y la soberanía; llegamos a una serie de acuerdos:
1.México reforzará la frontera norte con 10 mil elementos de la Guardia Nacional de forma inmediata, para evitar el tráfico de drogas de México a Estados Unidos, en particular fentanilo.
2.Estados Unidos se compromete a trabajar para evitar el tráfico de armas de alto poder a México.
3.Nuestros equipos empezarán a trabajar hoy mismo en dos vertientes: seguridad y comercio.
4.se ponen en pausa los aranceles por un mes a partir de ahora. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Our nine-year old wanted to ask me some riddles but she wanted them to be age appropriate. So she landed on riddles for senior citizens. I would say that I will never forget this slight, but I probably will.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A wise approach for the Trump administration on the ICC sanctions would be to keep them in reserve while trying to negotiate a more fundamental change to how the court operates.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The UN Security Council could also play a role by potentially freezing investigations into non-member state nationals while a broader diplomatic process plays out.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The ICC's fundamental problem is not anti-American animus or antisemitism. It simply has too much jurisdiction and its involved in situations where it has no prospect of success.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Doomsday Clock moved one second closer to midnight today on fears that no one would pay attention to the Doomsday Clock if it didn't move.
-
David Bosco reposted
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists
@BulletinAtomic
Today, the Bulletin’s Science and Security Board sets the #doomsdayclock at 89 seconds to midnight.
"The world depends on immediate action."
Read the full statement: thebulletin.org/doomsday-clock/2025-statement/ -
David Bosco reposted
Just Security
@just_security
Reupping this piece from September 1, 2020:
“The Int’l Criminal Court Executive Order: Global Reactions Compiled”
Beth Van Schaack collected global reactions to President Trump’s first Executive Order introducing sanctions against the ICC.
www.justsecurity.org/72256/the-intl-criminal-court-execut… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's time for the International Criminal Court's member states to give some hard thought to whether the court is on a sustainable trajectory.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It seems quite plausible that Israel will simply annex most of the West Bank during Trump's term.
Barak Ravid
@BarakRavid
🚨The Department of Treasury announced on Friday that all sanctions against Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank that were imposed by the Biden administration have been lifted after Trump signed executive order earlier this week
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Compliance with ICC arrest warrants is showing some cracks within Europe. Hungary and Poland have already suggested they might not comply in the case of arrest warrants against Israeli officials. Now Italy seems to have ignored an arrest warrant related to Libya.
FIDH
@fidh_en
🚨 Italy must urgently explain its failure to comply with the Rome Statute by releasing Osama Elmasry Njeem, wanted by the ICC for war crimes and crimes against humanity, just days after his arrest in Turin.
Such egregious non-cooperation from an EU State Party not only obstructs the ICC’s ability to hold perpetrators accountable, it also denies thousands of Libyan victims access to justice.
@fidh_en joins Libyan, Italian, and international human rights organisations in this joint statement: www.fidh.org/en/issues/international-justice/internationa… -
David Bosco reposted
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
.@IntlCrimCourt Prosecutor Karim Khan announces applications for warrants of arrest in the situation in #afghanistan for the Supreme Leader of the Taliban, Haibatullah Akhundzada, and the Chief Justice of the 'Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan', Abdul Hakim Haqqani.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
While the Trump administration is renaming bodies of water, could it also please break the system of flags of convenience at sea? Ships should fly the flag of the country where they are owned, not random flags designed to evade regulation.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Did Italy just flout an International Criminal Court arrest warrant? apnews.com/article/italy-libya-ossama-almasri-icc-arrest-…
-
David Bosco reposted
Oliver Stuenkel 🇧🇷
@OliverStuenkel
Nigeria is admitted as a partner country of the BRICS bloc abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/nigeria-admitted-p…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I feel like there's something to be written about Jack Smith, his background in international prosecutions, and the realities of law and politics.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A Trump Nobel Prize speech would be epic. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/01/16/trump-nobel-pe…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Yikes, this story confuses the ICC and the ICJ www.israelnationalnews.com/news/402332 via @ArutzSheva_En
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
House Democrats call on ICC to rescind arrest warrants for Israeli leaders thehill.com/policy/international/5077262-democrats-urge-i…
-
David Bosco reposted
Josh Kraushaar
@JoshKraushaar
NEW @jewishinsider via @emilyfjacobs: "Thune preparing to bring up ICC sanctions bill"
"The Senate majority leader says the Senate, which is taking up Laken Riley Act this and next week, will proceed on the ICC legislation shortly"
jewishinsider.com/2025/01/thune-preparing-to-bring-up-icc… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The phrase we need at this strange moment in international relations: uti possidetis
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Hearing that the Trump administration will move to change the name of the South China Sea to Freedom Sea.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A Hammarskjöld is back in the upper ranks of the UN bureaucracy www.un.org/sg/en/content/sg/personnel-appointments/2024-1…
-
David Bosco reposted
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@hamiltonlugar is very excited to be working with the International Law Students Association on the first ever International Law Moot Court competition for undergraduate students!
The Jessup
@The_Jessup
The International Law Students Association is pleased to announce the launching of the ILSA / Hamilton Lugar International Law Moot Court Competition!
Learn more at www.ilsa.org?page_id=29977.
#ihlmoot2025 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@hamiltonlugar is very excited to be working with the International Law Students Association on the first ever International Law Moot Court competition for undergraduate students!
The Jessup
@The_Jessup
The International Law Students Association is pleased to announce the launching of the ILSA / Hamilton Lugar International Law Moot Court Competition!
Learn more at www.ilsa.org?page_id=29977.
#ihlmoot2025 -
David Bosco reposted
The Jessup
@The_Jessup
The International Law Students Association is pleased to announce the launching of the ILSA / Hamilton Lugar International Law Moot Court Competition!
Learn more at www.ilsa.org?page_id=29977.
#ihlmoot2025 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
At the moment, it looks like Argentina, Germany, and Hungary are the ICC member states most clearly breaking with the court over the Israel arrest warrants.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
More attention needed to this development
Visegrád 24
@visegrad24
BREAKING:
The Chinese vessel Yi Peng 3 has been chased, intercepted, and boarded by Danish Navy vessel Y311 Søløven after the Chinese vessel destroyed 2 undersea telecom cables linking Finland-Germany and Sweden-Lithuania.
The vessel sailed from Russia & the captain is Russian -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Russia Issues Warrant For International Criminal Court Judge www.rferl.org/a/russia-arrest-warrant-icc-judge/33199206.…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Bipartisan group of US Senators demands that ICC investigate harassment accusations against prosecutor Karim Khan before deciding on Israel arrest warrants. www.foreign.senate.gov/press/dem/release/chair-cardin-bip…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Let the speculation begin.
-
David Bosco reposted
Widad Franco
@widadfranco
UNGA members voted to keep Saudi Arabia off the Human Rights Council.
Results for the Asia-Pacific slate, the ONLY competitive one:
Thailand 177
Cyprus 167
Qatar 167
RoK 161
Marshall Islands 124
Saudi Arabia 117 ❌
louis charbonneau
@loucharbon
🚨 #breaking - The UN General Assembly just gave a big thumbs down 👎 to #saudiarabia's candidacy for the Human Rights Council -- it lost the election! @hrw's reaction 👏🥳 follows in a short thread 🧵
Background here: www.hrw.org/news/2024/10/03/un-reject-saudi-bid-human-rig… -
David Bosco reposted
Brian Whitaker
@Brian_Whit
Prosecutors in the Netherlands are considering a request to open a criminal case against senior Israeli intelligence officials for allegedly interfering with an investigation by the international criminal court (ICC). www.theguardian.com/law/2024/oct/08/dutch-prosecutors-mul…
-
David Bosco reposted
Int'l Criminal Court
@IntlCrimCourt
Statement of #icc Prosecutor @KarimKhanQC on the unsealing of six arrest warrants in the situation in #libya⤵️
www.icc-cpi.int/news/statement-icc-prosecutor-karim-aa-kh… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The article makes an important point about the (understandable) risk aversion of the companies doing cable repairs. Even if China's claims to the South China Sea have little legal merit, the existence of a dispute makes companies operating in the area wary.
Rebecca Tan
@rebtanhs
New! Contest over the South China Sea is disrupting operation of vital subsea cables that keep Asia online. Our reporting found bigger challenges than prev known, including a confrontation (!) between Chinese forces and a cable ship in Vietnam's waters:
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/10/03/south-china-sea-u… -
David Bosco reposted
Justin Sandefur
@JustinSandefur
Remember the Doing Business Index?
Welp, it's baaaaaaaaaack. Ok, sort of, not really.
4 years after Doing Business was suspended amidst scandal, today the World Bank launches its successor, the "Business Ready" (B-READY) report. Before diving into the new report, a recap.
🧵 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Russian oil tankers taking advantage of "flags of convenience" www.nytimes.com/2024/10/03/world/europe/russian-oil-tanke…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In my view, @swiss_un has the right position on Security Council reform: they support an "intermediate" reform that would grant certain states elected by the General Assembly longer terms and the chance for immediate reelection.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Here's my argument from back in 2015 as to why that plan is the most viable (and why the US should put its weight behind it) foreignpolicy.com/2015/09/29/the-united-states-doesnt-wan…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Is there much we can say with certainty about whether the Iranian missile strikes were aimed at military targets?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
With the ascension of Mark Rutte as @SecGenNATO, the Netherlands has nudged ahead of the UK as the member state having provided the most alliance leaders. Four for the Netherlands, three for the UK. Belgium comes next with two.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
11 of the 13 NATO secretaries-general have come from countries that were members of the alliance when it was founded in 1949. Spain and (West) Germany are the only other states to provide a secretary general.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Original NATO members that have never provided a secretary general include Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Luxembourg, Portugal, and the United States.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For those wondering whether the International Criminal Court could consider the unfolding conflict in Lebanon, it's important to note that Lebanon is not an ICC member state and so there would likely not be any basis for jurisdiction.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Lebanon's government could, however, file a declaration as a non-member state giving the ICC jurisdiction (this is the mechanism that created jurisdiction in Ukraine and several other situations).
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There was reporting in the spring that Lebanon might be moving in that direction, but the government appeared to backtrack and I haven't seen any recent indications it is considering doing so.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A great chance for practitioners to join @hamiltonlugar!
jobs.chronicle.com/job/37718837/professor-of-practice-in-… -
David Bosco reposted
Barbara Slavin
@barbaraslavin1
one of the problems is that the UN has ceded peacekeeper to intelligence agencies... www.stimson.org/2024/with-israel-palestine-and-lebanon-on…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A thoughtful look at the state of the UN, and the Security Council in particular by @ishaantharoor www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/09/23/un-summit-russia-…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But in my view the piece tiptoes to the edge of magical thinking regarding the abolition of the Security Council veto.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Let's do a thought experiment: imagine there is no veto power. What changes regarding Ukraine or Gaza? Would the ability of the Council to pass a resolution mean anything in terms of the conduct of those conflicts?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Does anyone have clarity in whether there actually was an incursion into territorial waters in this case that did not constitute innocent passage? news.usni.org/2024/09/06/chinese-russian-ships-sail-near-… via @withemes
David Bosco
@multilateralist
My understanding is that Japan has intentionally limited its territorial sea in this area in order to preserve space for international navigation.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
And Japan (and Japanese media sources) do have a tendency to treat foreign military activities in the contiguous zone and EEZ as problematic in ways that don't comport with the US understanding of freedom of navigation.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Week in Multilateralism, by @multilateralist open.substack.com/pub/davidbosco/p/the-week-in-multilater…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
My recollection is that no head of state with an ICC arrest warrant has attended a General Assembly. Does anyone recall differently? I know there was drama about whether Bashir would attend but I think he never did. And Putin hasn't post-arrest warrant.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It seems quite possible to me that the ICC prosecutor might request arrest warrants for regime officials in Venezuela.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Making sense of the latest US position on reform of the UN Security Council open.substack.com/pub/davidbosco/p/washingtons-new-twist-…
-
David Bosco reposted
columlynch
@columlynch
For all those of who who thought Kamala Harris might address UN leaders at high level week, it looks like it ain't going to happen. Antony Blinken scheduled to speak at Future Summit, and President Biden will deliver his farewell address to UNGA on Tuesday
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Washington's New Twist on Security Council Reform, by @multilateralist open.substack.com/pub/davidbosco/p/washingtons-new-twist-…
-
David Bosco reposted
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
Another week has gone by without an ICC Pre-Trial Chamber's decision on the Prosecutor's applications for the arrest warrants re #netanyahu, #galant, #sinwar. Friday will mark 4 months since the filing of the requests.
Compare: it took PTC 3 weeks to issue the Putin/MLB warrant. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Many thanks to the estimable @charlicarpenter for including The Poseidon Project on her vacation reading list! www.worldpoliticsreview.com/international-law-reading-books/
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It will be interesting to see if Mongolia puts together a legal argument for why welcoming Putin didn't violate its legal obligations to the ICC.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Week in Multilateralism, by @multilateralist open.substack.com/pub/davidbosco/p/the-week-in-multilater…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Vladimir Putin headed to Mongolia, an ICC member state with a legal obligation to arrest him upon arrival.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's a bold steppe.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
{Apologies for the awful pun).
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Week in Multilateralism, by @multilateralist open.substack.com/pub/davidbosco/p/the-week-in-multilater…
-
David Bosco reposted
Human Rights Watch
@hrw
Ukraine’s parliament voted today to become a full member of the International Criminal Court.
This is a welcome advance in building a global system for accountability; however, limitations in the law risk shielding perpetrators from justice. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Week in Multilateralism, by @multilateralist open.substack.com/pub/davidbosco/p/the-week-in-multilater…
-
David Bosco reposted
Kevin Jon Heller 🇺🇸🇩🇰
@kevinjonheller
The Pre-Trial Chamber has authorized the OTP to file a consolidated response to all of the observations on the arrest-warrant applications. The response is due August 26 and cannot exceed 53 pages. www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/CourtRecords/0902ebd1…
-
David Bosco reposted
lucy.gaynor
@lucyjgaynor
An ongoing 🧵of submissions to the #icc (@IntlCrimCourt) regarding the 'Situation in #palestine': 1/X
-
David Bosco reposted
Mark MacKinnon
@markmackinnon
Two of three Hamas commanders that @IntlCrimCourt prosecutor Karim Khan had sought to arrest for war crimes have been confirmed dead in the past 36 hours…
BBC Breaking News
@BBCBreaking
Israel's military says it killed Hamas military chief Mohammed Deif in an air strike in Gaza on 13 July www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cpv3gpy74ydo?at_bbc_team=edit…
-
David Bosco reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
"[S]ifting the mountain of evidence he has compiled, Kardon concludes that China has been far more successful at weakening the maritime legal order than at substituting its own version."
@multilateralist reviews “China’s Law of the Sea” by @IBKardon. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/china-is-reshaping-the-marit… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Which is worth more? An International Court of Justice advisory opinion that is non-binding or a contentious case decision that is binding (but unenforceable)
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Just a reminder that we’re still waiting on the International Criminal Court judges to decide whether to issue Israel/Palestine arrest warrants
-
David Bosco reposted
Aaron Connelly
@ConnellyAL
The second half of this, as I have heard it from one Chinese interlocutor in the past few months, is that the rest of the world needs to help them roll it back by not publicly challenging them on it so often. Genuine plea for an off-ramp, or cynical ploy to quiet opponents?
Stephen Dziedzic
@stephendziedzic
Singapore’s Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen at Aspen, discussing the South China Sea. He says Chinese officials tell him privately that they don’t ***actually*** claim all the waters behind the nine-dash line (despite constantly pronouncing publicly that they in fact do)
-
David Bosco reposted
Adam Wren
@adamwren
A Young spokesman says this selection doesn’t change his lack of support for Trump.
Senator Todd Young
@SenToddYoung
Congratulations to my Senate colleague and fellow Marine JD Vance on becoming the GOP nominee for Vice President. I have found JD to be a thoughtful legislator with a deep understanding of the Midwest and our priorities.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Alternative name: Don't Go Fish
Sebastian Bae
@SebastianBae
"At Any Cost" is an educational & analytical game exploring #iuu fishing and fishing policy - designed for @pewtrusts @pewenvironment. This is one of my favorite designs at @CNA_org.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Countries not meeting the 2 percent defense spending goal will be sent over the falls in effigy.
National Defence
@NationalDefence
Niagara Falls was lit up in @NATO blue on Tuesday night, marking the Alliance's 75th anniversary year and coinciding with the Leaders' Summit in Washington, D.C. The illumination was made possible by the @NiagaraFalls Illumination Board. #1nato75years #natosummit #wearenato
-
David Bosco reposted
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
On 10 June, the UK requested leave to file amicus curiae observations on ICC's jurisdiction in #palestine (www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/RelatedRecords/0902eb…).
Today it was granted: www.icc-cpi.int/sites/default/files/CourtRecords/0902ebd1….
This means further requests and a delay. Unprecedented at this stage, and a troubling development. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
What is the International Criminal Court? www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/nightlife/international-cr… via @ABCaustralia
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Pierless
Gregg Carlstrom
@glcarlstrom
The pier took two months and $320m to build, lasted 12 days, and delivered less than 60 trucks' worth of food (most of which was stolen after it reached Gaza) before it broke and had to be towed away for repairs. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-05-28/us-pier-for-ga…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Our fifteen-year old son has picked up the Bible for the first time after being intrigued by a passage quoted in Pulp Fiction. The Lord moves in mysterious ways!
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Has somebody systematically examined the CIA director's role in diplomatic negotiations? I'm always curious about when and why administrations choose to put an intelligence director in a negotiating role.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@marcthiessen lays out some of the thinking in GOP circles about how the US might respond to the International Criminal Court www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/24/icc-israel-us-…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In short, we are presented with a caricature of the court's actual record that leaves no room for complexity and doesn't even attempt to give the prosecutor the benefit of the doubt.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
(I say this all as someone who has deep reservations about the wisdom of the court pursuing the citizens of non-member states.)
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Biden administration has been quietly working to dismantle the World Trade Organization's court, so it actually wouldn't be a radical shift for it to set its sights on the International Criminal Court.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Nein dash line
Samuel Ramani
@SamRamani2
BREAKING: Russia deletes its draft decree to change Baltic Sea maritime borders
-
David Bosco reposted
Politics and International Law
@PoliticsIntlLaw
Israel always does domestic investigations after every military action. This is standard operating procedure. So I would put this at 100%. What is somewhat silly is that the ICC didn't simply wait for this process to occur, as they did in Colombia.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There is a significant divide between the way that international lawyers see the world and the way that normal people do.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
And so international lawyers are genuinely puzzled when the ICC is accused--as it has been by US and Israeli leaders--of creating a moral equivalence between Hamas and the Israeli government.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
From the legal perspective, the ICC's mission is simply to identify serious abuses over which it has jurisdiction, investigate them, and prosecute if warranted.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The question of adjudicating "equivalence" in some broader sense is simply beyond the court's remit and not part of their job.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But international lawyers often fail to appreciate how counterintuitive and downright strange that view is to normal people. It's entirely natural to see the conduct of fighting as very much embedded in the broader context.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
What are the odds that an Israeli prosecutor announces a domestic investigation that mirrors the one the ICC prosecutor is conducting?
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Doing so would complicate things in complementarity terms for the judges on the pre-trial chamber as they consider whether to approve arrest warrants.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There is a tendency sometimes to act as if the International Criminal Court is a "world court" and that it is on par with the International Court of Justice in terms of reach and universality.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This is a serious mistake. The ICC has 124 member countries, so it represents slightly less than two-thirds of the total UN membership.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Just in terms of overall membership, it is far less universal than the UN obviously, but also than the World Bank (189 countries), the International Monetary Fund (190 members), and the World Trade Organization (164)
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Leaving that legal debate to one side, I think there are important prudential questions for the ICC about exercising jurisdiction over non-member state nationals.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Put simply: the ICC is very unlikely to be effective when it is confronting states that have never signed on and have no legal obligations to it. Back in 2019, I tried to think through how the court's members could address this issue www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2019/04/12/iccs-conflict-…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A good rule of thumb at moments when the ICC is all over the news is that the court will be far less consequential than the headlines suggest.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's so frustrating how simplistic this analysis is. @AmbJohnBolton is a smart guy and knows the picture is so much more complicated.
John Bolton
@AmbJohnBolton
The ICC's foundational bias was anti-American, an effort to constrain US power. It's an illegitimate institution with no accountability, checks, or oversight. Israel is the canary in the coal mine for the U.S. - the ICC has gone after Israel, and you can be sure America is next.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For example, if the ICC is anti-American and the prosecutor is desperate to get Americans, why would one of his first moves be to shelve the investigation of US torture in Afghanistan?
-
David Bosco reposted
Mother Jones
@MotherJones
Today, the ICC announced that they're seeking arrest warrants for Hamas and Israeli leaders for alleged war crimes.
@JulianneMcShane sat down with @multilateralist to learn the significance of this pivotal development: www.motherjones.com/politics/2024/05/why-the-icc-arrest-w… -
David Bosco reposted
Alonso Gurmendi
@Alonso_GD
Tracking State reactions to the arrest warrants issued by the ICC OTP against Israeli and Hamas leaders, a thread 🧵
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As the ICC prosecutor's moves in Gaza reverberate, it's important not to lose sight of one potentially important multilateral actor: the UN Security Council.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
France and the UK, as the only P5 members of the ICC, would be the members who might balk at an Article 16 freeze but I'm thinking they might live with it if it were paired with some kind of binding ceasefire language.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The elected members of the Council at the moment are mostly ICC members and might also balk (even if the P5 were somehow on board). By my count, 8 of 10 elected Council members are ICC member states.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Germany is going to be very interesting to watch on the ICC-Israel issue. They are one of the ICC's biggest funders.
Karl Nehammer
@karlnehammer
We fully respect the independence of the ICC. The fact however that the leader of the terrorist organisation Hamas whose declared goal is the extinction of the State of Israel is being mentioned at the same time as the democratically elected representatives of that very State is non comprehensible.
Karl Nehammer
@karlnehammer
Wir respektieren die Unabhängigkeit des IStGH. Dass die Anführer der Terrororganisation Hamas, deren erklärtes Ziel die Vernichtung des Staates Israels ist, in einem Atemzug genannt werden mit demokratisch gewählten Vertretern eben dieses Staates, ist nicht nachvollziehbar.
-
David Bosco reposted
Karl Nehammer
@karlnehammer
We fully respect the independence of the ICC. The fact however that the leader of the terrorist organisation Hamas whose declared goal is the extinction of the State of Israel is being mentioned at the same time as the democratically elected representatives of that very State is non comprehensible.
Karl Nehammer
@karlnehammer
Wir respektieren die Unabhängigkeit des IStGH. Dass die Anführer der Terrororganisation Hamas, deren erklärtes Ziel die Vernichtung des Staates Israels ist, in einem Atemzug genannt werden mit demokratisch gewählten Vertretern eben dieses Staates, ist nicht nachvollziehbar.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Interesting that ICC prosecutor made request for arrest warrants on Gaza public before they had been approved by the judges on the pre-trial chamber. In the Ukraine case, the announcement came after approval by judges.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This puts the focus squarely on the judges as they consider whether to grant the prosecutor's application.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
My sense is that Israeli officials have been quietly engaging with the court over the past months and they will no doubt want to ensure that judges understand well their arguments as to why charges are not justified.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As I understand it, the three judges on the pre-trial chamber for the Palestine investigation (all women) are from Romania, Benin, and Mexico.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Biden administration took its time lifting sanctions on the ICC when it came into office. Will it end up reimposing sanctions?
-
David Bosco reposted
Dhruva Jaishankar · ध्रुव जयशंकर
@d_jaishankar
Replug: Why has UN Security Council reform been stalled?
@samirsaran @RichardGowan1 @ruchirakamboj
orfamerica.org/newresearch/unsc-reform-p5-ign -
David Bosco reposted
Kjell Anderson
@Kjell_Anderson
The International Criminal Court is hiring a number of Hebrew language positions right now, including field interpreters (who would very likely be used for interviews in Israel or involving Israelis). #icc #gaza
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It wasn't dead to a number of GOP folks in Congress who celebrated the charges filed against Vladimir Putin.
John Bolton
@AmbJohnBolton
The ICC is lawless and unaccountable. The court has been dead to us for decades.
-
David Bosco reposted
Mark Kersten
@MarkKersten
“Any crimes committed on the territory of Palestine by any party” fall under the jurisdiction of the court.
What is the #icc, the global court Israel fears may indict Netanyahu?www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/04/29/icc-israel-warran… Always nice to be quoted alongside @multilateralist -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Very interesting analysis of Gaza, Ukraine, and the laws of war by the estimable @oonahathaway www.foreignaffairs.com/ukraine/war-unbound-gaza-hathaway via @ForeignAffairs
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In short, the period between the adoption of the Geneva Conventions and the 9/11 attacks is almost entirely elided in the article. And that period included numerous conflicts in which the laws of war were badly flouted and in which the civilian toll was enormous.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If we incorporate those decades into the analysis, it seems to me that the overall pattern is not so much a post 9/11 decline in compliance with humanitarian law as a legal system that was almost from the outset struggling hugely to make the law meaningful.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
US, allies said worried ICC arrest warrants for Israelis could sink Gaza truce deal www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/us-allies-said-worri… via @timesofisrael
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As they try to head of ICC charges against Israeli officials, Israel and the US have every incentive to emphasize the potential peace versus justice dynamic.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Lots of speculation in here about what the ICC may do vis-a-vis senior Israeli officials. My money is still on initial charges for a small number of West Bank settlers linked to violence against Palestinians. www.jpost.com/international/article-797820
-
David Bosco reposted
columlynch
@columlynch
U.S. vetoes UNSC resolution extending full
UN membership to Palestinians. Vote was 12 in favor, two abstentions and one vote against -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
With the UN Security Council set to consider Palestine's UN membership again, worth remembering that UN membership and statehood are two separate legal issues with distinct criteria (although the issues are often intertwined)
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Article 4 of the UN Charter makes clear that there can be "states" that do not meet the threshold for UN membership. In particular, states must be "peace-loving" and able to carry out the obligations of UN membership.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The all but assured US veto of Palestinian membership would be the Biden administration's fourth use of the veto power and Washington's second this year.
-
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
The United States will on Thursday vote against a Palestinian request for full United Nations membership, a U.S. official told Reuters, blocking the world body from effectively recognizing a Palestinian state.
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
The U.N. Security Council is due to vote on Thursday on a Palestinian bid for full U.N. membership, a move that Israel ally the United States is expected to block because it would effectively recognize a Palestinian state.
Vote at 5 pm EDT (2100 GMT).
www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/un-security-council-vot… -
David Bosco reposted
Kristen Saloomey
@KSaloomey
Latest on negotiations to allow Palestine full membership in the United Nations. Spoiler alert, US opposed.
Gabriel Elizondo
@elizondogabriel
The US position against Palestine's full membership remains unchanged. Robert Wood, deputy U.S. ambassador to UN, said this morning:
Wood: "The product of a two-state solution needs to come from bilateral negotiations. This has been our position for quite some time. Many other countries share that position as well. So we’ll just have to see how things result. But pushing toward a vote on a Security Council resolution at this point I think is unfortunate if that is what happens. But that certainly is the discussion we understand is going in."
(He was talking about a resolution on full UN membership for Palestine)
@sherwiebp follow up: "And unfortunate means veto?"
Wood: "I am not going to get ahead of all of this. Just to say our position has not changed on this question." -
David Bosco reposted
Josh Rudolph
@JoshRudes
🎓Know anyone who's graduating from college this year or last year and may want to come work with me at @gmfus in Washington, DC?
Please encourage them to consider applying for the job here: gmfus.org/about/careers (Program Assistant, Alliance for Securing Democracy). Thank you! -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Nice naval April Fool's story, riffing off Hunt for Red October www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2024/04/u-s-navy-submarine-f…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm puzzled by the US position that the Security Council resolution is non-binding. Is it an established US approach that only resolutions explicitly adopted under Chapter VII are binding?
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I see that @RichardGowan1 has already made the point that, for the US, the key factor may be the terminology: "demands" is nonbonding but "decides" is binding
David Bosco
@multilateralist
*nonbinding
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
China and Russia challenge US right to an extended continental shelf www.ft.com/content/0e550c72-c6b1-42ac-876b-22aa49c2057b via @ft
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For the most part, this is simply a good opportunity for Moscow and Beijing to needle the US about not being an UNCLOS member.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But it will be worth watching how many other states pick up these arguments and whether they influence the broader international reaction to the US extended continental shelf announcement.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Very excited to work with our new dean at @hamiltonlugar! www.youtube.com/watch?v=qBEXI-KRAqM
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Why the U.S. hasn't joined the race for deep sea mining in international waters www.cbsnews.com/news/why-the-us-hasnt-joined-the-race-for… via @60minutes
-
David Bosco reposted
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
#breaking
Security Council ADOPTS resolution demanding an immediate ceasefire in Gaza for the month of Ramadan leading to a lasting sustainable ceasefire, and the immediate, unconditional release of all hostages
IN FAVOR: 14
AGAINST: 0
ABSTAIN: 1 (US)
⤵️
news.un.org/en/story/2024/03/1147931?reload1 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Thanks so much to @alexbward for a great discussion with faculty and students at @hamiltonlugar about his new book, The Internationalists a.co/d/70CwUDM
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The deadlocked Security Council reform debate appears no closer to becoming unstuck.
Dhruva Jaishankar · ध्रुव जयशंकर
@d_jaishankar
As no holds barred approach to the UFC at the UN
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@USAmbUN at one point had ambitions of galvanizing the process but there's little sign this is happening. And the Israel-Hamas conflict (and US isolation) is probably not making the US any more enthusiastic about an expanded Council.
-
David Bosco reposted
Eric Martin
@EMPosts
SCOOP: Kristalina Georgieva is interested in a second 5-year term as head of the IMF and poised to secure sufficient support, people familiar with the matter tell @v_dendrinou @KowalczeKamil @flaviajackson and me.
Germany now coming on board after France
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-03-07/imf-chief-geor… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Notable if confirmed: Indiana Senator Todd Young says he will not support Trump in 2024 www.wthitv.com/news/senator-todd-young-says-he-will-not-s… via @WTHITV
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
With the United States apparently set to launch a maritime aid operation into Israeli-occupied Gaza, just a reminder of this episode from the 1967 war. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Liberty_incident.
-
David Bosco reposted
Coalition for the ICC (CICC)
@ngos4justice
Tomorrow, the six newly elected #icc judges will be sworn in.
🔜 Friday 8 March at 10h30 (Hague time/CET), watch LIVE on the ICC website: www.icc-cpi.int/streaming-all-displays?CR=Courtroom 1&lan…
More info on #iccelections🧵⬇️ -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Land mines return to Europe as front-line states fear Russian invasion www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2024/02/23/russi…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
"Policymakers in all three Baltic nations — Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia — have had conversations in recent weeks about whether to pull out of the international convention that bans anti-personnel mines."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There was a lot of treaty-drafting in the 1990s that is under strain in today's world.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I still think first International Criminal Court charges against Israelis will come in the West Bank settlement context, and the news about new settlement activities may make that even more likely.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
He should appeal his dismissal into the void.
Camille Gijs
@CamGijs
💥Big news from Geneva
Marco Molina, the Guatemalan official leading the World Trade Organization's dispute settlement talks, has been fired — jeopardizing already frail talks.
"Just today I was notified that I was removed from office," he told @tradereporter
More on POLITICO -
David Bosco reposted
Camille Gijs
@CamGijs
💥Big news from Geneva
Marco Molina, the Guatemalan official leading the World Trade Organization's dispute settlement talks, has been fired — jeopardizing already frail talks.
"Just today I was notified that I was removed from office," he told @tradereporter
More on POLITICO -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The US has now cast as many Security Council vetoes in the Biden administration as it did during the Trump administration.
-
David Bosco reposted
Giovanni Cremonini
@cremogi
🇪🇺 launches its first #naval operation with an executive mandate to protect merchant vessels: Operation #aspides.
#redsea #maritimesecurity
EU Council Press
@EUCouncilPress
Red Sea: @EUCouncil is launching today a new 🇪🇺 #csdp defensive operation. ASPIDES 🛡️, the EU maritime security operation to safeguard freedom of navigation in the #redsea, will protect commercial vessels from Houti attacks.
Read more 👇
europa.eu/!64nhqx -
David Bosco reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
NEW: In my latest essay, I argue that opposition to seabed mineral harvesting too often grossly exaggerates enviro impacts, while seeking to ban a promising technology that could help reduce impacts from battery metals sourcing.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/sparing-the-land-by-col… -
David Bosco reposted
Peter Ungphakorn (also @coppetainpu.bsky.social)
@CoppetainPU
This is like eavesdropping on one side of a telephone conversation
WTO talks on reforming dispute settlement are secret, as is the 50-page draft. Now 5 WTO members have circulated a response publicly
Fascinating
Thanks to the person who first shared it
docs.wto.org/dol2fe/Pages/SS/directdoc.aspx?filename=q:/J… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Thanks very much to @StephenSCody for a very thoughtful and generous review of The Poseidon Project mlawandsociety.org/2023/08/18/review-of-david-boscos-the-…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
One of the odd things about this article is that most of it is written as if the ICC hasn't already charged Putin with war crimes! www.theguardian.com/law/2024/feb/06/icj-ukraine-russia-pr…
-
David Bosco reposted
CIJ_ICJ
@CIJ_ICJ
PRESS RELEASE: Judge Nawaf Salam (#lebanon) was today elected President of the #icj by his peers, for a term of three years www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/press-releases/0/000-…
-
David Bosco reposted
krzysztof pelc
@KrzPelc
🔍 New paper, fun findings:
The MPIA is a unique attempt to circumvent the US in global governance. Is it working? The evidence suggests it might be: I look at who joins, and whether it deters harmful barriers between members. 🌍 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It seems odd that the EU would launch a whole new operation for the Red Sea, with a new command center, when Operation Atalanta (started to deal with piracy in the region) already exists @EUNAVFOR @cremogi www.stripes.com/theaters/europe/2024-02-05/houthi-red-sea…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If the International Criminal Court ever does move toward charges in Palestine , I wonder if the prosecutor wouldn't as an initial matter pair charges against several Hamas military commanders with some against key West Bank settlers implicated in violence.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Curious to hear international law folks on now to think about the boundaries of the current "armed conflict" in Israel-Palestine. Obviously there's an armed conflict in Gaza, but does it extend to all Palestinian territories?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Good article by @drewhinshaw and @DanMichaelsWSJ on the current threates to "freedom of the seas" www.wsj.com/world/on-the-high-seas-a-pillar-of-global-tra… via @WSJ
David Bosco
@multilateralist
They build off the current threats to ocean shipping in the Red Sea to argue that freedom of the seas is threatened in new and unique ways.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
They do make points I'd contest. First, they say this: "For much of maritime history from Columbus onward, pirates, privateers and powerful navies set the rules on whose ships could sail where. The alternative concept--'freedom of the seas'--dates back to at least the 1600s..."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This is not a helpful way of thinking about the history. The fact is that "freedom of the seas" IS itself a set of rules (and not just the absence of rules), and it is one that very powerful states and navies have at various points tried to impose by force.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
What's more, there is a strategic logic to freedom of the seas for powerful states that the article glosses over: The doctrine means that countries with ocean-going navies can more or less go where they please, something that often makes lesser naval powers uncomfortable.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
(Just ask India how it feels about US navy ships conducting exercises in its exclusive economic zone, for example)
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Second, the article presents freedom of the seas as something that only became a reality after World War II. That is highly debatable.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's really too early therefore to say that the resources, coordination and will aren't there to respond to the Red Sea threat. The fact is that international responses to threats like this usually take a while.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But these differences aside, it's a good article and it's great to see more journalists engaging with the history of freedom of the seas and ocean rules.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It seems like this deserved more attention than it got: US appeals court revives Mexico's $10 bln lawsuit against gun makers www.reuters.com/world/us/us-appeals-court-revives-mexicos…
-
David Bosco reposted
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I really struggle to see the ICJ ruling in the Israel-South Africa case as impactful. It more or less takes the same line that the UN (including the Security Council) have already taken about protecting civilians and humanitarian assistance.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The timing of the UNRWA announcement of its investigation into whether some of its employees participated in the Oct. 7 attack is notable.
-
David Bosco reposted
Kaitlan Collins
@kaitlancollins
Wow. The State Department “has temporarily paused additional funding” to UNRWA amid allegations that 12 of the UN agency’s employees were involved in the Hamas attack, per States spokesman Matt Miller. “Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken spoke with United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres on January 25 to emphasize the necessity of a thorough and swift investigation of this matter."
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The ICJ ruling is quite cautious and hews closely to what the UN as an organization has said through its various organs: that more care should be taken to avoid civilian harm and to facilitate humanitarian aid.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
My guess on what the ICJ will say in its ruling tomorrow: no firm determination of genocide but concern about the potential. Provisional measures will focus on increased measures for protection of civilians and humanitarian assistance.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Unprecedented? More dangerous than the early 1980s when the US and Soviets were on high alert for nuclear strikes?
Sky News
@SkyNews
BREAKING: Doomsday Clock set at 90 seconds to midnight - amid 'unprecedented level of risk'
Read more ⬇
news.sky.com/story/doomsday-clock-set-at-90-seconds-to-mi… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
EU states agree on military operation in Red Sea news.yahoo.com/eu-states-agree-military-operation-1757249… via @YahooNews
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As India increases its naval profile, it's worth recalling that its view of maritime law is distinct from the US view--particularly regarding whether foreign military forces can operate in another country's exclusive economic zone. news.yahoo.com/india-flexes-maritime-muscles-boosting-024… via @YahooNews
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
India flexes maritime muscles by boosting Arabian Sea force news.yahoo.com/india-flexes-maritime-muscles-boosting-024… via @YahooNews
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The US strikes on Houthi targets to protect shipping in the Red Sea connect with a deep current in American military and diplomatic history: a vigorous defense of "freedom of the seas."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In his letter to Germany protesting the sinking of the Lusitania, Woodrow Wilson described freedom of the seas as "sacred." Franklin Roosevelt insisted in 1941 that "all freedom depends on freedom of the seas."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For an in-depth look at how freedom of the seas has been defined, defended, and disputed over the years, please consider my book, published last year by Oxford University Press. a.co/d/dlCQaYc
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There's a lot at stake institutionally for the International Court of Justice in the way that it handles the South Africa-Israel case.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The court also takes a very long time to issue final rulings, meaning that the public and political impact of its rulings is often quite limited. For that reason, other international judicial or quasi-judicial alternatives are sometimes more attractive to countries.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Given all this, it's possible that the ICJ itself has at least at much at stake in how this case proceeds as Israel does.
-
David Bosco reposted
Stefan Talmon
@StefanTalmon
BREAKING: Germany will intervene in the case concerning the Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip (#southafrica v. #israel) before the @CIJ_ICJ under Article 63 of the ICJ Statute.
Statement here:
"On 7 October 2023, Hamas terrorists brutally attacked, tortured, killed and kidnapped innocent people in Israel. Hamas’ goal is to wipe out Israel. Since then, Israel has been defending itself against the inhumane attack by Hamas.
In view of Germany’s history and the crime of humanity – the Shoah, the Federal Government sees itself as particularly committed to the Convention against Genocide. This Convention is a central instrument of international law to implement ‘Never Again’. We firmly oppose a political instrumentalization of the Convention.
We know that different countries assess Israel’s operation in Gaza differently. However, the Federal Government firmly and expressly rejects the accusation of genocide that has now been levelled against Israel at the International Court of Justice. This accusation has no basis whatsoever.
The Federal Government supports the International Court of Justice in its work, as it has done for many decades. The Federal Government intends to intervene as a third party in the main hearing." (my translation)
www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/aktuelles/ueberschrift-kor… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Very thoughtful post on South Africa's International Court of Justice case against Israel
Itamar Mann
@itamann
My analysis of South Africa's litigation strategy at the ICJ is up on @Verfassungsblog.
I try to make several points and open a basic question about the nature of this procedure. The piece is titled The Missing Party.
verfassungsblog.de/the-missing-party/ -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This approval is for mining within waters under Norwegian jurisdiction and so is distinct from the international process being led by the International Seabed Authority. But Norway's process is likely to be watched closely as the international debate continues.
Adam Vaughan
@adamvaughan_uk
Norway's parliament has just voted in favour of allowing deep sea mining
The vote was basically a formality after the minority govt made a deal with opposition parties before Xmas
Companies will still have to apply for an exploration licence and, later, an exploitation permit -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It seems to me that one of the clear beneficiaries of the Gaza war has been the government of Azerbaijan, which has seen international scrutiny of its policies in Nagorno-Karabakh all but vanish.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I would join a parents class action lawsuit against the manufacturers of "slime" for kids.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Here's hoping possible ICC membership isn't any significant part of Taiwan's deterrence strategy www.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/31/taiwan-considers-jo…
-
David Bosco reposted
Ambassador Majed Bamya 🇵🇸
@majedbamya
South Africa institutes proceedings against the State of Israel before the International Court of Justice under the Genocide Convention and requests provisional measures
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The G20 should consider a system of relegation based on what kind of year the member countries had.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
For several years, there has been a debate within the US government about whether to file its extended continental shelf determination with the UN Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I argued here that it was worth doing. www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-03-24/if-the-u-s-…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This week, the US made public its extended shelf determination and there's no sign it will be filing with the UN Commission.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Big maritime news from the US
www.state.gov/the-us-ecs/ -
David Bosco reposted
Iryna Matviyishyn
@IMatviyishyn
A high-ranking Russian military official fled to the Netherlands and is willing to surrender to the ICC and testify about Russian war crimes in Ukraine, gulagu.net reports. He is identified as Igor Salikov, a former GRU officer and senior Wagner instructor.
-
David Bosco reposted
Collin Koh 🇸🇬🇺🇦
@CollinSLKoh
An insightful thread on the origins of archipelagic states regime under UNCLOS. 👇🏼
damos agusman
@damos_agusman
1/10 Today, 63 year ago, Prime Minister Indonesia, Mr. Djuanda, declared unilaterally the use of archipelagic baselines, for joining the outmost islands. The waters enclosed was then declared as internal waters (Deklarasi Djuanda 1957).
-
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
The US decision to veto #gaza ceasefire resolution is not a surprise.
But context very different to first U.S. veto on the war in October.
Then, UNSC members were keen to find common ground with @USUN on compromise language (and came close to doing so).
[1/3] -
David Bosco reposted
Ambassador-at-Large for Global Criminal Justice
@StateDept_GCJ
Congratulations to @TheJusticeDept for this historic step--the first ever charges under the U.S. #warcrimes statute as part of our whole-of-government effort to hold those responsible for atrocities accountable. Our tireless march toward justice must continue.
U.S. Department of Justice
@TheJusticeDept
Four Russia-Affiliated Military Personnel Charged with War Crimes in Connection with Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine
www.justice.gov/opa/pr/four-russia-affiliated-military-pe… -
David Bosco reposted
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Invoking Article 99 of the UN Charter would be a bigger deal if the Secretary General's baseline posture were that of a neutral, apolitical administrator. In that context, an explicit SG statement that the Council needs to consider something might carry some weight.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Invoking Article 99 of the UN Charter would be a bigger deal if the Secretary General's baseline posture were that of a neutral, apolitical administrator. In that context, an explicit SG statement that the Council needs to consider something might carry some weight.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I get the buzz among UN observers; formal invocations are unusual. But in the current context of constant and public SG involvement, Article 99 really doesn't add that much to the mix.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's also worth recalling as a historical footnote that the first and most consequential invocation of Article 99--that by Dag Hammarskjold in the Congo context--ended up producing an enormously traumatic set of events for the organization.
-
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
This is the first time that a UNSG has explicitly cited Article 99 since 1989. @FortiD has a 🧵 coming up.
Rami Ayari
@Raminho
NEW: In Letter to #unsc, @antonioguterres invokes article 99 of the #un Charter to bring the situation in #gaza to the attention of the council. He warns that he expects public order to completely break down soon due to ongoing Israeli bombardment leading to desperate conditions and rendering even limited humanitarian assistance impossible.
"The situation is fast deteriorating into a catastrophe with potentially irreversible implications for Palestinians as a whole and for peace and security in the region. Such an outcome must be avoided at all cost," the #unsg says. -
David Bosco reposted
Silvia Fernandez de Gurmendi
@PASPFernandez
After a fourth round of voting, elections for new judges to the @IntlCrimCourt continue at @UN. Follow live at @UN WebTV
📖 webtv.un.org/en/asset/k1g/k1gdjczo7y -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
First ever visit by an ICC prosecutor to Israel?
Int'l Criminal Court
@IntlCrimCourt
#icc Chief Prosecutor @KarimKhanQC is visiting #israel at the request and invitation of survivors & the families of victims of the 7 October attacks.
The Prosecutor will also visit #ramallah, State of #palestine, meeting w/ senior Palestinian officials. -
David Bosco reposted
Int'l Criminal Court
@IntlCrimCourt
#icc Chief Prosecutor @KarimKhanQC is visiting #israel at the request and invitation of survivors & the families of victims of the 7 October attacks.
The Prosecutor will also visit #ramallah, State of #palestine, meeting w/ senior Palestinian officials. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
'Tis the moment for Kissinger anecdotes, so a couple from my history of the UN Security Council. One of my favorite is the record of a meeting between Kissinger and China's newly named UN ambassador at an East Side apartment in New York.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Kissinger essentially tries to tutor the PRC's new ambassador on the workings of the Security Council and the UN more broadly. But there's also extended discussion of how the Chinese delegation should contact Kissinger if they want to discuss UN policy in the future.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There were technical problems getting the text sent from the US embassy in Moscow, apparently leading to a volcanic outburst from Kissinger.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The message finally got through, leading to the passage of what became Resolution 338. But the very close US-Soviet cooperation on the Middle East peace resolutions produced an outburst from China's new delegation--and a near fistfight between Soviet and Chinese diplomats.
-
David Bosco reposted
EUNAVFOR Operation ATALANTA
@EUNAVFOR
OFFICIAL STATEMENT ON THE ALLEGED PIRACY INCIDENT INVOLVING A FISHING BOAT OFF THE COAST OF SOMALIA
Full statement: eunavfor.eu/news/official-statement-alleged-piracy-incide…
@eu_eeas #morethanships #maritimesecurityprovider -
David Bosco reposted
Lara Seligman
@laraseligman
Just in: DOD’s initial assessment is the 5 armed individuals who attacked the Central Park yesterday are Somali. Incident “piracy related,” says @PentagonPresSec.
Ryder also notes there were 3 PLA Navy vessels in the vicinity, but they did not respond 59 distress calls. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The incipient rapprochement between Beijing and Washington doesn't seem to extend yet to the South China Sea.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I don't want to incite panic, but Amazon only has ten copies of The Poseidon Project left in stock. If maritime law and history are on your holiday list, act with dispatch. a.co/d/4Is1lka
-
David Bosco reposted
Silvia Fernandez de Gurmendi
@PASPFernandez
Congratulations to Armenia for joining the Rome Statute, a welcomed recognition of the ICC crucial role in bringing perpetrators of worst crimes to justice. Armenia will become the 124th State Party. We look forward to working with them at the ASP
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It must be satisfying for @USUN to see Russia lose its traditional International Court of Justice judgeship. But probably also a bit unnerving.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The "P5 privilege" that all but guaranteed ICJ seats to permanent Security Council members is dying, and who knows how long the US will hold onto its own privilege?
David Bosco
@multilateralist
To many UN members, there is no doubt a certain oddity to the US always getting a judgeship when it doesn't accept the court's compulsory jurisdiction and, more broadly, has worked hard in recent years to insulate itself from the ICJ's reach.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
!!
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
Five @CIJ_ICJ judges were elected today in the 🇺🇳 Security Council and General Assembly:
-@BogdanAurescu 🇷🇴
-Hilary Charlesworth 🇦🇺
-Sarah @ClevelandICJ 🇺🇲
-@DireTladi4ICJ 🇿🇦
-@JMGomezRobledo 🇲🇽
VP/Judge Kirill #gevorgian 🇷🇺 has not been re-elected. Russia has lost its ICJ seat.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
There are now two P5 members without International Court of Justice judgeships. Times are changing
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Oof
Karim Wafa-Al Hussaini
@DrKarimWafa
international law
Youssef Cherif
@Faiyla
Is there something more useless than decaffeinated coffee?
-
David Bosco reposted
Karim Wafa-Al Hussaini
@DrKarimWafa
international law
Youssef Cherif
@Faiyla
Is there something more useless than decaffeinated coffee?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The eyes of the world are on Gaza, but this may be the greater danger in terms of major-power conflict.
Duan Dang
@duandang
Recent aggressive actions in the South China Sea by China:
- Oct 22: Ramming a Philippine supply vessel near Second Thomas Shoal.
- Oct 24: Flying within 10 ft of a B-52.
- Oct 29: Firing flares in front of a Canadian military helicopter. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I've got to think that the proliferation of UN "special rapporteurs" on human rights, often viewed by the media and public as speaking for the organization, is a real public relations challenge for UN leadership.
-
David Bosco reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
The international order.
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
UN General Assembly ADOPTS resolution “necessity of ending the economic, commercial and financial embargo imposed by the United States of America against Cuba”
IN FAVOUR: 187
AGAINST: 2 (Israel, US)
ABSTAIN: 1 (Ukraine)
LIVE COVERAGE ⤵️
news.un.org/en/story/2023/11/1143112?reload5 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An interesting statement from one of the companies proposing to engage in commercial seabed mining.
The Metals Company
@themetalsco
Today, we’re calling on those NGOs willing to sit down with us to hear about what we have learned through more than a decade of ocean #exploration, the issues we are still working on and how we intend to mitigate our future impacts.
metals.co/open-letter-to-ocean-conservation-community/ -
David Bosco reposted
Roland Paris
@rolandparis
I took the time to read all the reports, statements and press releases produced by the UN's commission on Israel-Palestine, two members of which spoke at @uOttawa on Monday. Here's what I found (blog post): www.cips-cepi.ca/2023/11/01/the-uns-problematic-commissio…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In both Gaza and Ukraine, the focus in the not-too-distant future will likely turn toward post-conflict mechanisms, including ceasefire monitoring, peacekeeping, international administration, observers, etc.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A UN Security Council that has mostly been sidelined during the fighting may well find new life during this next stage.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
One difficult question in both contexts will be what happens in the post-conflict phase to the investigative processes underway at the International Criminal Court
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Those declaring the current moment one of the most dangerous since the Second World War need to remember moments like this www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/soviet-nuclear-w…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
After the trick-or-treating comes the sorting-and-trading. And it seems like the kids are as excited about the latter as the former.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Question for international law folks: has there ever been a conviction at an international court or tribunal for an attacking military targets in ways that caused too much civilian harm?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Blinken cracks open the door to discussions of an international administration of Gaza, at least until the Palestinian Authority can assert control. www.al-monitor.com/originals/2023/10/blinken-sees-palesti… via @AlMonitor
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Any post-conflict planning is obviously rudimentary, but some relevant multilateral players would include the Arab League. And then there's the question of whether any international force would have a UN mandate.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Only tricks for the World Trade Organization's Appellate Body though.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, @KarimKhanQC, spoke to the press this week near the Gaza Strip. A few thoughts on this comments:
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The prosecutor did try to remind Israeli forces that they face the legal burden of showing that any civilian facilities attacked had lost their "protective status"--i.e., that they were being used for clearly military purposes.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Khan said relatively little about the cutting off of communications and supplies to Gaza. He did insist that aid needs to flow into the territory, but he did not engage directly with the question of whether the restrictions Israel has put in place might constitute a war crime.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The prosecutor also mentioned the situation in the West Bank and specifically the reported attacks by Israeli settlers on Palestinians there.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
What he did not mention--and this is a notable omission--is Israeli settlements policy itself, which is part of the ICC's preexisting investigation and which creates the most legal exposure for Israeli leaders.
-
David Bosco reposted
Int'l Criminal Court
@IntlCrimCourt
🎥 The Minister of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates of the State of #palestine, H.E. Dr. Riyad Malki, visited the #icc. @pmofa
-
David Bosco reposted
columlynch
@columlynch
Russia vetoes U.S. draft resolution condemning Hamas bloody Oct 7 attack on Israel, and calling for a humanitarian pause for the delivery of aid.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's more likely that the US would join the law of the sea convention--and that's not very likely at all.
Foreign Affairs
@ForeignAffairs
“The long-standing fear that joining the International Criminal Court would expose U.S. citizens to unfair prosecution is likely a boogeyman.” Read @kelly_zvobgo’s case for why it is time for Washington to formally join the court:
www.foreignaffairs.com/ukraine/time-america-join-internat… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Belt-tightening
The China-Global South Project
@ChinaGSProject
The number of leaders attending each of the past three Belt and Road Forums has fallen steadily since the first one in 2017.
-
David Bosco reposted
Fred Carver
@Arbeider4Fred
Quick q for @LiechtensteinUN @telegramwriter or anyone else who knows or can simply remember what happened last year better than I can...
Could the veto initiative meeting triggered by the US veto & the ESS-10 meeting Russia triggers (assuming it does) be combined into one? -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Brazil's star turn on the UN Security Council is a good reminder that it was one of the few countries given serious consideration for permanent membership during the 1943-44 negotiations about the shape of the UN.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Roosevelt administration pushed for Brazil's inclusion as a permanent member, but it wasn't able to convince the British or the Soviets.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
By my count, the United States has cast 20 Security Council vetoes since January 1990. 17 of them have been related to the Israel-Palestine conflict.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A reminder that the US did not use the veto for the Council's first twenty-five years of operation; Washington cast its first Council veto on March 17, 1970.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
First Biden administration veto on the Security Council.
-
David Bosco reposted
The UN Times
@TheUNTimes
The US vetoes Security Council resolution calling for “humanitarian pauses” to deliver lifesaving aid to millions in #gaza:
- Favor: 12 (Albania, Brazil, China, Ecuador, France, Gabon, Ghana, Japan, Malta, Mozambique, Switzerland,UAE)
- Against: 1 (US)
- Abstain: 2 (Russia, UK) -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Is somebody keeping track of how many special envoys there are now in the @statedept?
-
David Bosco reposted
PassBlue
@pass_blue
#unsc vote on #gaza draft rez:
Russia text, backed by Palestine, calls for a "ceasefire" (to which US objects)
5 yes (inc #uae); 4 no; 6 abstentions
Fails to get 9 votes -
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
After vote on Russia's #israel/#gaza resolution, UNSC members are pretty consistently criticising Russian lack of respect for due process on negotiating text.
If Russia's goal was to push the U.S. or P3 into an unpopular veto, it feels like it annoyed SC members instead. -
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
RUSSIA'S DRAFT UN SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION ON ISRAEL, GAZA FAILS TO GET MINIMUM NINE VOTES NEEDED
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
Vote on the Brazilian draft resolution will be Tuesday at 6pm EDT/2200 GMT, say diplomats
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Remember how the ICC indictment of Putin changed the course of the Ukraine conflict? That's how much ICC charges against Palestinians/Israelis would change this conflict.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
(I understand, of course, that there are arguments for ICC action not based on any expectation that there would be an immediate impact)
-
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
UN Security Council will vote later on Monday on rival draft resolutions on Israel and Gaza, diplomats said. The draft texts - submitted by Russia and Brazil - largely focus on the humanitarian situation. A resolution needs at least nine votes in favor, and no vetoes to pass.
-
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
Given recent UK statements, the other difference might be that the UK could join the US in a veto (depending on text)?
-
David Bosco reposted
PassBlue
@pass_blue
Brazil is circulating among #unsc members its updated draft rez on humanitarian pause/corridor. No request for a vote yet. Only #russia has called for a vote, for its own draft rez
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Genuinely curious what the @USUN posture is about a Security Council role in the Gaza crisis. I'm assuming there's little appetite for Council being involved now but that could likely change if Washington becomes convinced that israel is heading into a morass @RichardGowan1
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Watching the commentary on the Israel-Gaza conflict, I’m struck again by the divide between how the NGO and human rights community sees the laws of war and how national militaries view them.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The law professor Kenneth Anderson wrote a very good article on this divide almost twenty years ago.
www.nytimes.com/2003/04/13/magazine/who-owns-the-rules-of…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The “NGO/human rights” interpretation of the rules leans heavily in the direction that any military action producing significant civilian casualties or suffering are illegal, while national militaries have a quite different understanding.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
From the NGO/human rights perspective, the rules of war are one part of a much broader human project to get rid of war. From that perspective, all military conflict should be viewed as suspect and the rules of war should therefore lean heavily in the direction of prohibition.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An important side point is that the media tends to rely heavily on the views of the NGO world and the human rights community, sometimes without understanding that their interpretations are out of step with how major national militaries (often with good reason!) see the rules.
-
David Bosco reposted
Ian Urbina
@ian_urbina
In the past several days since our investigation was published by @NewYorker there has been a lot of follow-up coverage and activity. This thread offers some highlights: 🧵
-
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
Russia on Friday proposed a draft United Nations Security Council resolution on the Israel-Hamas conflict that calls for a humanitarian ceasefire and condemns violence against civilians and all acts of terrorism, according to a draft text seen by Reuters.
www.reuters.com/world/russia-proposes-un-security-council… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As I understand the comments here, the prosecutor <may> be suggesting that Israel's policy of requiring civilians to leave a targeted area is actually compliant with rather than in tension with the law of armed conflict.
Int'l Criminal Court
@IntlCrimCourt
On @BBCRadio4, #icc Prosecutor @KarimKhanQC addressed the current situation in Israel and State of Palestine.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Although he also seems to be suggesting that there are potential conflicts between international humanitarian law and human rights law at play.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
What the questioner did NOT ask him (at least in this clip) is whether Israel's policy of cutting off supplies to the whole Gaza Strip is a likely war crime
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Certain influential voices on both the Palestinian and Israeli sides are questioning the fundamental international legal/ethical premise that civilians are necessarily "innocent."
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The ICC prosecutor breaks his silence on the Israel-Palestine situation. At least as reported, his comments are entirely about Hamas crimes. www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/hamas-attack-would-fall…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Duly noted.
Chinese Mission to UN
@Chinamission2un
China 🇨🇳 is re-elected as #hrc member today! We sincerely appreciate the valuable support of member states and warmly congratulate other newly elected members!
China will continue to work closely with HRC members and contribute our efforts to the work of HRC! -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Russia denied a UN Human Rights Council seat, but China secures one.
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
#breaking: UN General Assembly has elected 15 members of the Human Rights Council (@UN_HRC):
Albania;
Brazil;
Bulgaria;
Burundi;
China;
Côte d'Ivoire;
Cuba;
Dominican Republic;
France;
Ghana;
Indonesia;
Japan;
Kuwait;
Malawi;
Netherlands
news.un.org/en/story/2023/10/1142112 -
David Bosco reposted
Stéphanie Fillion
@Fillionsteph10
Results are in: Bulgaria: 160, Albania: 123, Russia 83
@RussiaUN does not get a seat on the @UN Human Rights Council @UN_HRC -
David Bosco reposted
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
One more day has passed, and still nothing. Silence.
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
Will there be a statement on #palestine/#israel from the ICC Prosecutor this week by analogy with the one issued on Ukraine in February 2022? www.icc-cpi.int/news/statement-icc-prosecutor-karim-aa-kh…. The current events are squarely within the ICC's jurisdiction; the Situation in Palestine is under investigation.
-
David Bosco reposted
Stéphanie Fillion
@Fillionsteph10
This morning, the #unga votes as @RussiaUN is trying to get its seat back on the @UN Human Rights Council @UN_HRC; Russia is competing with @AlMissionUN & @Bulgaria for 2 seats.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Was this originally designed as a G7 statement--but one that couldn't secure support of Canada and Japan?
Brett McGurk
@brett_mcgurk
Joint Statement on Israel | The White House 🇺🇸🇬🇧🇫🇷🇩🇪🇮🇹🇮🇱 www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2023…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
More remarkable oceans reporting from @ian_urbina
-
David Bosco reposted
Kenneth Roth
@KenRoth
The Asian group at the UN has allowed China to run for a seat on the Human Rights Council unopposed. Last time, with opposition, Beijing almost lost. Still, governments can vote No. It needs a majority of Yes votes to gain a seat. genevasolutions.news/human-rights/un-faces-key-vote-as-ru…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As evidence emerges of Iranian involvement in the funding and planning of the attack, it seems to me that an Israeli strike on Iran is increasingly plausible.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In the past is any indication, this moment of international solidarity with Israel will pass quickly once the militants operating in Israel are subdued and the Israeli response in Gaza gets rolling. The focus will shift to civilian deaths produced by Israeli strikes.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A lot of comparisons being made to the 1973 war, and it's worth remembering that the UN Security Council ended up playing a significant role in the negotiations to end that conflict.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An interesting footnote to the 1973 Council diplomacy on the Middle East is that China became highly resentful of US-Soviet coordination on the text and ultimately abstained on the vote.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
(There was also a screaming match between the Soviet and Chinese ambassadors on the sidelines of a Council meeting that outsiders had to try to break up)
-
David Bosco reposted
Lokman Karadag 盧克曼
@DrLokmanKaradag
Canada's engagement in the region is becoming increasingly visible.
"Canada will give the Philippines free access to state-of-the-art satellites that will allow maritime enforcers to surveil, almost in real time, vessels within the Philippines’ EEZ." globalnation.inquirer.net/220080/ph-allowed-to-use-canadi… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As news of large-scale violence and likely atrocities emerge from Israel and Gaza, a reminder that the International Criminal Court has an ongoing investigation of the situation in Palestine.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If there are documented cases of Hamas massacres of civilians (or executions of captured soldiers) there may be strong pressure on the ICC prosecutor to reinvigorate what appears to be a somewhat latent investigation.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But Israel will oppose any ICC role, and a more active investigation would also complicate the rapprochement between the ICC and the US that has emerged since the court froze its probe of US personnel in Afghanistan and brought charges against Putin regarding Ukraine.
-
David Bosco reposted
Mark MacKinnon
@markmackinnon
Massive, massive intel fail...
Haaretz.com
@haaretzcom
Senior IDF officers and officials in Israel's security establishment assessed last week that Hamas wishes to avoid a full-fledged war with Israel www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-10-07/ty-article-live/is…
-
David Bosco reposted
Giovanni Cremonini
@cremogi
The EU 🇪🇺 and 🇮🇳 India will conduct new joint activities at sea. Watch this space!
EUSecurityDefence
@EUSec_Defence
At their 3rd #maritime Security Dialogue on 5 October, 🇪🇺 and 🇮🇳 discussed common challenges, concrete initiatives & new joint activities at sea.
@EUNAVFOR @CrimarioII @ESIWA_EU @EUAmbIndia @IndEmbassyBru -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's hard to be optimistic about the Kenya-led police mission that the UN Security Council appears set to authorize for Haiti.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
US monitoring large Serbian force along Kosovo border -White House www.reuters.com/world/us-monitoring-large-serbian-force-a…
-
David Bosco reposted
ian bremmer
@ianbremmer
philippines says china installed a floating barrier near scarborough shoal in south china sea
petty (and illegal) -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Some universities are backing away from languages and global studies. Not @hamiltonlugar @IUBloomington
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Interesting piece from @GavinBade on a new Biden administration push regarding WTO reform. But the article and the headline downplay somewhat the Biden administration's own role in kneecapping the WTO's adjudication system @snlester www.politico.com/news/2023/09/22/tai-targets-china-climat… via @politico
David Bosco
@multilateralist
To put the issue more directly: the Biden administration has, of its own volition, held up the appointment of Appellate Body members for more than two years. That policy could have been changed early in the administration, but a conscious decision was made not to.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Do any law of the sea folks know whether the United States government is treating the new high seas agreement as a treaty in need of ratification or as some kind of other agreement? @JamesKraska @Dr_Mendenhall
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Prospects for ratification?
State Department Spokesperson 2013-2025
@statedeptspox_a
Yesterday, the U.S. was among the first countries to sign the High Seas Treaty to conserve and sustainably use biodiversity of areas beyond national jurisdiction. This is an important step forward in the global goal to conserve 30% of our ocean by 2030. www.state.gov/signing-of-the-high-seas-treaty/
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Hamilton Lugar School of Global and International Studies at Indiana University is looking for a new dean! provost.indiana.edu/about/exec-searches/hls-dean.html
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A thoughtful, historically conscious article on the role of the Security Council in today's world www.ft.com/content/ffa99120-8551-4c8c-b351-1f974ba269e3
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The history of the Security Council cautions against a view that the institution is either "dead" (as it has been declared multiple times, wrongly) or asymptotically approaching irrelevance.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The complicated and unsatisfying reality is that it is going to be highly relevant in certain specific circumstances and quite marginal in others.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Thanks to the International & Comparative Law Quarterly for a very thoughtful review of The Poseidon Project @ICLQ_jnl @hamiltonlugar www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-and-compara…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Should have noted that the review was written by the estimable @camillejgoodman, who has worked on ocean governance issues at highest levels of government.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Grrrr
columlynch
@columlynch
if you were wondering why President Macron couldn't make it to UNGA...
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
We are a long way from Trudeau's 2018 trip to India
www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-43151115 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Biden doubles down on Security Council reform in this year's UN speech, says US has "undertaken serious consultation with many member states" on the issue.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A whole host of other multilateral institutions and initiatives got name-checked, including ECOWAS, the G7, the Summit for Democracy, the Quad, and the Pacific Islands Forum.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Interestingly, given the emphasis placed on Ukraine, there was no mention of NATO, the International Court of Justice, or the International Criminal Court--all of which are relevant to the Ukraine war.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
And on the Ukraine justice question, there was no explicit call for Russian leaders to be prosecuted for aggression--only a more oblique call to stand up to and deter "naked aggression."
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Untied Nations
UN Spokesperson
@UN_Spokesperson
.@antonioguterres warns world leaders:
Our world is becoming unhinged.
Geopolitical tensions are rising.
Global challenges are mounting.
And we seem incapable of coming together to respond.
#unga -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Wall Street Journal goes deep to uncover how the Barbie movie got in trouble over China's nine-dash line www.wsj.com/business/media/barbie-movie-banned-vietnam-b8… via @WSJ
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The conclusion: Barbie had no intention of endorsing China's position on the South China Sea.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Four of the five permanent Security Council members will not be represented by heads of state at this year's UN General Assembly meeting. Outside of COVID, has that happened before?
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The British and French absences seem particularly striking.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Macron is reportedly not attending because he's meeting King Charles. Seriously?
-
David Bosco reposted
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
Ukraine plans to sue Poland, Hungary and Slovakia at the WTO over their refusal to drop a ban on Ukrainian agricultural products, Ukraine’s Trade Representative Taras Kachka told POLITICO.
www.politico.eu/article/ukraine-will-sue-poland-hungary-a… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Confusing phrasing from the Attorney General: The ICC can't prosecute the crime of aggression in Ukraine.
Ambassador-at-Large for Global Criminal Justice
@StateDept_GCJ
"We are investigating Russia's crime of aggression. As exemplified by my recent trip to meet with the ICC’s Chief Prosecutor at the Hague, this includes cooperating with the ICC’s investigation of foreign nationals for atrocities in Ukraine." - Attorney General Garland
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Hamilton Lugar School at Indiana University is seeking a new dean provost.indiana.edu/about/exec-searches/hls-dean.html
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Tenure Track/Tenured Professor of Cyber Security and Governance, Open Rank jobs.chronicle.com/job/37523337/tenure-tracktenured-profe…
-
David Bosco reposted
james gibney
@jamesgibney
If the US makes weed a Schedule III controlled substance, its international law problem will get worse. (Mind you, it should be Schedule III.) Here's why it's a weird global governance issue: www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2018-01-10/jeff-sessions-… via @opinion
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Argentina, Iran, Ethiopia and the United Arab Emirates have been invited to join the BRICS group www.wsj.com/world/iran-saudi-arabia-others-invited-to-joi… via @WSJ
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The best minds around the world are working on a new acronym
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Russia's scorecard this week:
Moon landings: 0
Russian planes shot down over Russian territory: 1 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
India is the first country to land on the moon without having a permanent UN Security Council seat.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But non-ratification is the norm among spacefaring nations: US, China, Russia have also not ratified. (Pakistan has, interestingly)
David Bosco
@multilateralist
India, like other major powers, HAS ratified the 1967 Outer Space treaty. treaties.unoda.org/t/outer_space
-
David Bosco reposted
Duan Dang
@duandang
As a US military surveillance plane circled overhead, eight Chinese ships chased and briefly blocked four Philippine boats on a resupply mission to a tiny garrison in the hotly contested South China Sea.
www.france24.com/en/live-news/20230823-chinese-ships-chas… -
David Bosco reposted
Duan Dang
@duandang
Here comes the US Navy: A US Navy P-8 Poseidon patrol and reconnaissance plane circles a Chinese coast guard ship during the resupply mission to Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea on Augus 22. Image: AFP
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Drama at the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank www.economist.com/by-invitation/2023/08/17/the-aiibs-form…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The AIIB’s former communications chief on why he blew the whistle www.economist.com/by-invitation/2023/08/17/the-aiibs-form…
-
David Bosco reposted
Giovanni Cremonini
@cremogi
Further strengthening EU🇪🇺-🇺🇸 U.S. operational cooperation for 🌊#maritime security in the #indian Ocean.
@EUNAVFOR @US2EU @EUintheUS
EUNAVFOR Operation ATALANTA
@EUNAVFOR
The 🇪🇸 ESPS #navarra received the visit of 🇺🇸 @USArmy colleagues on board.
It was an opportunity to improve cohesion between those committed to Maritime Security in the Gulf of Aden and the Western Indian Ocean
📍Port of Djibouti, 10th of August.
@Armada_esp
#gofurthertogether -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I would like to watch the women’s World Cup final at a bar in Gibraltar
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Former UK prime minister Gordon Brown wants the ICC to prosecute Taliban leaders for denying girls an education www.voanews.com/a/un-envoy-to-icc-prosecute-taliban-for-b…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But if the denial of education can be construed as such an attack, one of the specific acts listed in the Rome Statute is "persecution against any identifiable group or collectivity on political, racial, national, ethnic, cultural, religious, gender..." grounds
David Bosco
@multilateralist
And Brown's call for prosecution of Taliban leaders is a good reminder that the ICC has an open investigation of the situation in Afghanistan
-
David Bosco reposted
NORI - Nauru Ocean Resources Inc.
@NORI_Nauru
Following the July 2024 meeting of the International Seabed Authority, NORI intends to submit what we expect will be a world-first application for a commercial #nodule license.
Learn more about the ISA process in this short video: vimeo.com/845081517 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Kenya’s Police Are No Match for Haiti’s Urban Warfare Nightmare www.worldpoliticsreview.com/haiti-gangs-crisis-corruption…
-
David Bosco reposted
The Ocean Cleanup
@TheOceanCleanup
This week we had our largest ever extraction from the Great Pacific Garbage Patch: 11,353 kg of plastic out of the ocean for good.
As we transition to System 03, we see that increasing system size leads to bigger catches.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The product of an Indiana shipyard is a major flash point in the South China Sea.
Chris Cavas
@CavasShips
In 1999 the Philippine Navy deliberately grounded an old US Navy ship on Second Thomas Shoal/Ayugin Reef in the Spratly Islands and kept it manned year-round as a South China Sea sentinel. It's been annoying China ever since and now China is upping ... www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/3230347/why…
-
David Bosco reposted
Chris Cavas
@CavasShips
In 1999 the Philippine Navy deliberately grounded an old US Navy ship on Second Thomas Shoal/Ayugin Reef in the Spratly Islands and kept it manned year-round as a South China Sea sentinel. It's been annoying China ever since and now China is upping ... www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/3230347/why…
-
David Bosco reposted
Giovanni Cremonini
@cremogi
New EU🇪🇺-🇮🇳 India joint naval exercise! Similar exercises took place in June 2021 (www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/eu-india-joint-naval-exercise-0_en) and in August 2022 (eunavfor.eu/news/joint-activities-indian-navy). Together for #maritime 🌊security and rule of law under UNCLOS in the #indopacific .
EUNAVFOR Operation ATALANTA
@EUNAVFOR
On 6 August 🇮🇹 ITS #delapenne conducted a sea joint training activity with 🇮🇳 INS #visakhapatnam. The interaction was an opportunity to strengthen cooperation with India regarding maritime security.
Read more about it 👉 eunavfor.eu/news/operation-atalanta-joint-activity-india
@EU_in_India @IndiannavyMedia -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Concur. Terms like "provocative" to describe exercises in international waters mirror Chinese language about US operations in the South China Sea.
Peter Dutton
@peter_dutton
Four U.S. destroyers monitored Russian and Chinese ships on a naval patrol near Alaska
… I don’t think it’s in our interest to use terms like ‘provocative’ and ‘aggression’ in relation to this exercise. We support freedom of the seas…or we don’t. www.wsj.com/articles/russia-and-china-sent-large-naval-pa… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
From everything I've read the Russian and Chinese vessels have remained in international waters. I'm not sure why Sen. Murkowski describes them as having been in US waters
Sen. Lisa Murkowski
@lisamurkowski
We have been in close contact with leadership from Alaska Command for several days now and received detailed classified briefings about the foreign vessels that are transiting U.S. waters in the Aleutians.
www.murkowski.senate.gov/press/release/murkowski-sullivan…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
So long as the Russian/Chinese vessels did remain in international waters, US politicians should be careful about protesting, lest they undercut the basis of US freedom of navigation exercises.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
(And of course even if those vessels did conduct innocent passage through US territorial waters, that's permissible under international law)
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It might be advisable to improve the functioning of existing international courts before creating new ones www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/08/07/wolf-internati…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The ICC is struggling to enforce its arrest warrants; the International Court of Justice is rarely used by major powers; and the WTO's adjudication system is on life support.
-
David Bosco reposted
Gideon Rachman
@gideonrachman
My latest argues that the Trump admin made radical changes in US approach to globalisation, trade and China that the Biden administration has built upon, not rejected www.ft.com/content/f43f0e63-0fa4-4771-8eb4-b5d61f87ada4
-
David Bosco reposted
Ray Powell
@GordianKnotRay
End-of-mission: 🇵🇭#philippines Coast Guard BRP Malabrigo & Cabra departing resupply area. 🇨🇳#china’s ships used gray zone tactics of blocking, bow-crossing, swarming & AIS-dark ops while harassing escort. @coastguardph’s post-mission report should have more details when released.
Ray Powell
@GordianKnotRay
1115L - 🇵🇭BRP Malabrigo stopped short of the shoal. Visible 🇨🇳ships include 2 coast guard + 4 militia, but 1-2 CCG ships are AIS-dark—CCG 4203 plus maybe CCG 5305 which went dark 30 July & prob. replaced 5204.
I speculate one or both of the dark vessels may be blocking Malabrigo. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Who lost Vanuatu?
CSIS Southeast Asia
@SoutheastAsiaDC
News from #vanuatu | Vanuatu, at the centre of strategic rivalry between China and western countries in the Pacific Islands, has plunged into political crisis, with its prime minister to face a no-confidence vote in parliament next week: www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/vanuatu-prime-minister…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Ukraine understandably insists that it recover all territory occupied by Russia, and that insistence has merged with the powerful argument that aggression must not be rewarded, lest it be encouraged elsewhere
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
From the standpoint of deterring aggression internationally, it seems to me that the most important test is what lesson other would-be aggressor states take from the Russia experience.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Do other states look at what Russia has gained and lost and see an attractive model? I have to think that the answer is a resounding no already (even if Russia holds onto some territory)
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It seems like the attention being paid to a possible aggression tribunal for the Ukraine war has subsided significantly.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
If so, this shift would not be that surprising. The absence of a Ukrainian military breakthrough is putting new emphasis on the possibility of peace talks.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In that environment, a major push to create a tribunal aimed at prosecuting Russian leaders (particularly when there is already an ICC indictment) may strike many governments as a poor use of resources.
-
David Bosco reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
So I just asked Niger's ambassador in the United States if he would welcome an intervention from the French and U.S. forces already stationed in the country, and he didn't exactly say no.
-
David Bosco reposted
UN Media Liaison (MALU)
@UNMediaLiaison
The #unga adopted by recorded vote draft resolution L.82: “Agreement under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Marine Biological Diversity of Areas beyond National Jurisdiction” #bbnj 🔗 docs.un.org/A/77/L.82 @UN_PGA
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
David Bosco on the struggle to govern the world’s oceans blogs.iu.edu/hamiltonlugar/2023/08/02/david-bosco-on-the-…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An ECOWAS military intervention to restore constitutional rule in Niger without UN Security Council authorization would spawn dozens of law review articles.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Notable new role for the US Coast Guard in Pacific waters www.straitstimes.com/asia/australianz/us-coast-guard-to-s…
-
David Bosco reposted
Ambassador Barbara Woodward
@BWoodward_UN
Gang violence has ravaged Haiti for two years.
🇬🇧 commends Kenya’s offer to lead a multinational force to help restore order, answering the Haitian government’s call for international security support.
We will support necessary next steps in @UN Security Council.
@AmbMKimani -
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
Kenya is ready to lead a multinational force into #haiti, which is experiencing a surge in violence between police and gangs, its foreign minister said on Saturday.
www.reuters.com/world/kenya-ready-lead-multinational-forc… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
ECOWAS floats possibility of military intervention to restore constitutional order in Niger
cnb.cx/3rOPQJl
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The full communique is here. ecowas.int/final-communique-fifty-first-extraordinary-sum…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
No mention in the communique of the UN Security Council or its potential role in authorizing the use of force.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I somehow missed this report that Russia is putting International Criminal Court judges on a wanted list. www.themoscowtimes.com/2023/07/27/russia-places-second-ic…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I finally saw Barbie and missed a whole chunk of dialogue because I was staring at the dashed line near the South China Sea.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Our eight-year old asked me whether I’m still considered a parent now that my kids are so old.
-
David Bosco reposted
Sarah H. Cleveland
@clevelandICJ
The Secretary General’s full list of candidates to the @CIJ_ICJ and co-nominations can be found here: undocs.org/en/A/78/98
-
David Bosco reposted
Andrew Desiderio
@AndrewDesiderio
Senate votes 65-28 to approve Kaine/Rubio amendment that would prevent a president from pulling U.S. out of NATO without congressional review.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Barbie map of Asian waters has deeper levels of meaning than have been acknowledged. There are eight dashes rather than nine, and there appear to also be a set of dashes in northern European waters.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Personally, I see that second set of dashes as a subtle endorsement of controversial European extended continental shelf claims but I acknowledge that there is ambiguity.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Does anyone know if there is an image or clip out there of the Barbie nine-dash line that is causing such a stir?
-
David Bosco reposted
Peter Dutton
@peter_dutton
Russia Lays Mines in Black Sea to Block Ukrainian Ports
…”the Kremlin declared all cargo ships traveling to Ukrainian ports as potentially carrying military cargo in support of Kyiv” and Russia has the right to ‘visit and search’ says @JamesKraska news.usni.org/2023/07/19/russia-says-all-ships-in-the-bla… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Customary international law on blockades and interference with commercial shipping leaned heavily on the concept of neutrality, an idea that has largely disappeared in today's world.
-
David Bosco reposted
Douglas Guilfoyle
@djag2
Not how you run a blockade, unless you mean by “potential carriers” you intend to stop and search such vessels, but the intention seems to be to block grain exports not military imports. Which reminds me, has Russia bothered to declare a formal blockade? @aurelsari ?
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — Russia says all ships sailing in the Black Sea to Ukrainian ports will be considered as potential carriers of military cargo beginning in midnight tonight
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This is a significant victory for the International Criminal Court and for the international justice movement more broadly.
Sherwin Bryce-Pease
@sherwiebp
South Africa’s Presidency confirms (by mutual agreement) that Russian President Vladimir Putin will NOT attend the BRICS summit in SA in August. Russian delegation to be led by Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.
Full statement here:
#sabcnews -
David Bosco reposted
Bloomberg
@business
UPDATE: Putin won’t attend next month’s summit of BRICS leaders in person, South Africa says
The decision means South African authorities will avoid having to execute an international warrant for the Russian leader’s arrest www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-07-19/putin-won-t-at… -
David Bosco reposted
The Economist
@TheEconomist
Should companies be allowed to mine the deep sea for metals? Listen on this week’s “Babbage” econ.st/46Iop3T
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
ChatGPT is studiously noncommittal on Security Council reform. chat.openai.com/share/df5c25f3-cee9-44d4-8b48-75afa7ab5e28
UK at the UN 🇬🇧🇺🇳
@UKUN_NewYork
#breaking
The first ever UN Security Council meeting on artificial intelligence is starting now.
Experts @jackclarkSF, @yi_zeng and UN Secretary-General @antonioguterres will brief on the opportunities and risks for global security.
🇬🇧Chaired by @JamesCleverly
Watch here: -
David Bosco reposted
UK at the UN 🇬🇧🇺🇳
@UKUN_NewYork
#breaking
The first ever UN Security Council meeting on artificial intelligence is starting now.
Experts @jackclarkSF, @yi_zeng and UN Secretary-General @antonioguterres will brief on the opportunities and risks for global security.
🇬🇧Chaired by @JamesCleverly
Watch here: -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The American Revolution is now complete.
British Embassy Washington
@UKinUSA
Tonight we are turning the British Ambassador's residence into a #barbie dream home!
@barbiethemovie is just one example of the incredible UK-US collaborations in film. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This is one possible interpretation, but certainly not the only plausible one.
Karim A. A. Khan KC
@KarimKhanQC
As violence envelops Sudan again, we must be honest: We could see this coming.
The collective failure to deliver accountability in Darfur for almost 2 decades sowed the seeds for the crimes of today.
This time, we must ensure meaningful accountability www.cnn.com/videos/world/2023/07/15/exp-sudan-war-crimes-…Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's true that most individuals charged were not brought to trial, and one can therefore argue that accountability was never given a real chance.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But another possible interpretation is that international judicial intervention is going to have a very marginal impact in most situations.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Philippines/China experts: any explanation for why Xi would be meeting with Duterte?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
International Criminal Court prosecutor (there's no prosecutor at the International Court of Justice)
The Spectator Index
@spectatorindex
International Court of Justice Prosecutor says South Africa should arrest Putin if he attends BRICS summit, given international arrest warrant.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Accounts like this demonstrate the substantial military value of land mines in certain situations. www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/07/15/ukraine-war-russi…
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But it's important to note that the balance on land mines depends heavily on the circumstances. They may be most valuable (and also most morally acceptable) in conflicts between organized armed forces.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
At the moment, minefields are working to the benefit of the aggressor as it fends off a counteroffensive, but they might just as easily be an effective part of a country's defense against aggression
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Week in Multilateralism davidbosco.substack.com/p/the-week-in-multilateralism-4e8…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Interesting that France seems to be holding the line against NATO setting up an office in Japan. www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2023/07/13/national/nato-japan-…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
When it comes to EU security deliberations, my sense is that France is one of the most eager to see the EU taking on functions in Asia, including maritime patrols
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Superb analysis of current Security Council dynamics by @RichardGowan1
Crisis Group
@CrisisGroup
NEW COMMENTARY | The UN Security Council between Rifts and Reform
Talks of reforming the #unsc are gaining traction, but the obstacles are many.
@RichardGowan1 writes about how a more modest vision of what the body should be might be best for now.
www.crisisgroup.org/global/un-security-council-between-ri… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Threads doesn't (yet) seem to be a functional replacement for Twitter, unless I'm missing important functionality. All sorts of random stuff in my feed and no ability to limit feed to those I follow.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The US and EU members of the UN Human Rights Council opposed a resolution sparked by Quran burning. It passed without them. aje.io/r32gqu via @AJEnglish
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Interestingly, UN Human Rights commissioner seemed to speak in favor of the resolution, saying "International law was clear on these kinds of incitement."
David Bosco
@multilateralist
He specifically cited Article 20 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which calls on states to prohibit “any advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence”.
-
David Bosco reposted
Mark Kersten
@MarkKersten
Indeed, and over successive Prosecutors, the OTP has bent over backwards to accommodate Museveni + seek his cooperation and goodwill, even as he pilloried the institution for being biased.
-
David Bosco reposted
Coalition for the ICC (CICC)
@ngos4justice
🌍17 July marks #internationaljusticeday, the day the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court was adopted. This year, we commemorate its 25th anniversary.
#romestatute25
Thread⬇️ -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As NATO prepares to welcome Sweden as its 32nd member, it's worth remembering that the organization is a consensus-based organization and that every new member effectively means a new capital with a veto over alliance action.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In terms of how a South China Sea shooting war might start, a China-Philippines altercation is not a bad bet.
AMTI
@AsiaMTI
The Armed Forces of the Philippines says its aerial and naval presence in the South China Sea dramatically increased in 2023 to maintain a presence 90% of the time, up from 30 percent last year. @inquirerdotnet globalnation.inquirer.net/216388/afp-cites-greater-presen…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
With today's Security Council veto, Russia/USSR extends its lead as the most veto-prone permanent member.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In terms of Moscow's resort to the veto power, we're still a fair distance from the Council's early days. In the Council's first five years (1946-1950), the USSR vetoed an average of nearly nine resolutions per year. In 1947 alone, there were 13 nyets.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Indeed, until 1956 the USSR was the only country to veto Council resolutions (responsible for the first 57 vetoes). Britain and France finally broke that streak with joint vetoes of a US-sponsored resolution during the Suez Crisis.
-
David Bosco reposted
Peter Dutton
@peter_dutton
Japan's Senkaku Islands "Coast Guard Security System"
- 10, 1k-ton patrol boats on Ishigaki
- 12 vessels, including 2 large patrol boats with helos, on Okinawa
- new law allows CG to use weapons against foreign ships that do not comply with orders to stop
www3.nhk.or.jp/news/html/20220911/k10013812941000.html -
David Bosco reposted
Simon Lester
@snlester
Can the WTO dispute system work in the face of "appeals into the void" due to the AB appointments crisis? The EU has a workaround and is thinking about using it for the first time:
ielp.worldtradelaw.net/2023/07/a-wto-ds-workaround-for-ap…
In a sense, they want to declare that "appeals into the void" are void. -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
With the International Seabed Authority about to meet, re-upping this new paper on whether the ISA is ready for its role as an international resource regulator. dlc.dlib.indiana.edu/dlc/handle/10535/10897
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Week in Multilateralism davidbosco.substack.com/p/the-week-in-multilateralism-d73…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
At the moment, Threads seems to lack the ability to view only posts from those one follows, which seems like a major drawback. Fingers crossed that gets remedied!
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A very smart piece by @SuzanneNossel on a viable path to Security Council reform www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/how-america-can-win-… via @ForeignAffairs
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I think @GermanyUN could be won over. I'm much less sure about @IndiaUNNewYork and @JapanMissionUN
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@SAMissionNY would also be a real challenge, and the broader African Group has been very insistent on permanent seats for Africa.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm also not sure whether the Biden administration is convinced of the logic of this semi-permanent tier of seats. The previous commitments to backing permanent status for Germany, Japan, and India are going to be hard to navigate away from.
-
David Bosco reposted
hal 👾
@halhod
in case you hadn’t seen it, this accompanying piece goes into more details on the science, David
www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2023/07/02/deep-…
and here are some of the sources i relied on if you’re interested in seeing the science news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36597642 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Momentum seems to be growing again for some kind of multinational force in Haiti abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/blinken-multinational-force-n…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The Economist makes an environmental case for getting seabed mining going. www.economist.com/leaders/2023/07/06/the-world-needs-more…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I don't understand the science well enough to fully evaluate the arguments, but I do think those resolutely opposed to seabed mining tend to minimize the environmental impact of mining on land.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Too often for the anti-seabed mining campaign, the question is simply whether seabed mining will harm the marine environment rather than how the environmental damage from seabed mining compares to alternative methods.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An International Center for the Prosecution of the Crime of Aggression against Ukraine has just been opened at the headquarters of Eurojust in The Hague. www.eurojust.europa.eu/news/history-making-international-….
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But I’m curious as to how much work it will actually have: the case for aggression against senior Russian leaders would seem to be pretty straightforward and based on the UN Charter, key treaties recognizing Ukraine’s borders, and public statements.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
My instinct is that the Center is probably more important as a placeholder and a signal of continuing intent to prosecute than as an actual evidence-gathering mechanism.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm on Threads @themultilateralist
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A new US statement on the broken World Trade Organization dispute resolution system docs.wto.org/dol2fe/Pages/SS/directdoc.aspx?filename=q:/J…
-
David Bosco reposted
Peter Ungphakorn (also @coppetainpu.bsky.social)
@CoppetainPU
A short piece on the US paper⬇️
Why publish it at this stage? Who is the intended audience?
The US tries to be positive (what it wants, rather than what it opposes) but positions eg on security make consensus elusive
#wtoreform #disputesettlement
2/2 tradebetablog.wordpress.com/2023/07/05/us-new-paper-dispu… -
David Bosco reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
Can the creaky UN Security Council be reformed, and how?
My colleague @StewartMPatrick collected 15 short essays on this question from 15 national perspectives, from Nigeria to Brazil to Japan.
carnegieendowment.org/2023/06/28/un-security-council-refo… -
David Bosco reposted
Chatham House
@ChathamHouse
"We want to see reform of the @UN Security Council, with permanent membership for African voices, India, Brazil, Germany and Japan"
Foreign Secretary @JamesCleverly (@FCDOGovUK) addresses the opening session of our London Conference, with @bronwenmaddox.
#chlondon -
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
If you like #unsc reform, you'll *love* this:
@StewartMPatrick got a bunch of @UN experts to write about differing national views on how to change the Security Council @CarnegieEndow (featuring me on 🇬🇧). carnegieendowment.org/2023/06/28/un-security-council-refo… -
David Bosco reposted
Sergey Vasiliev
@sevslv
The ICC judges authorize the Prosecution to resume investigation in the Situation in #venezuela I. Investigations by Venezuelan authorities do not sufficiently mirror the scope of ICC OTP investigation and target alleged direct or lower-level perpetrators. www.icc-cpi.int/news/situation-venezuela-icc-pre-trial-ch…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Despite opposition, the Norwegian government opens door for deep-sea mining in its waters www.wsj.com/articles/norway-opens-door-for-deep-sea-minin… via @WSJ
-
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
If you have been crying out for a WHOLE HOUR of in-depth discussion of #unsc reform, @S_R_Anders and I have got you covered @lawfarepodcast 👇
www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-richard-gowan-us-push… -
David Bosco reposted
Collin Koh 🇸🇬🇺🇦
@CollinSLKoh
Updated table on reported Taiwan Strait transits by U.S. (and allied) maritime forces, following latest by U.S. Coast Guard cutter Stratton. Highlight being the 1st reported solo transit by a USCG cutter since 2017, if not earlier, unlike previous 2 instances with Navy involved.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The smoldering embers of the Security Council reform process have gotten a few puffs of air recently, but my read is that the process remains fundamentally stuck.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In any case, I think it might take some kind of diplomatic realignment like this for the reform process to show real signs of life.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The fact that the process has been stuck for this long reflects an often unspoken truth: many countries that clamor for reform and thunder about the anachronistic Council would prefer the Council of today to a reformed version that doesn't fulfill all of their dreams.
-
David Bosco reposted
Nicolas de Rivière
@NDeRiviere
Historic adoption of the #bbnj Treaty by the UN: the international community united in protecting the oceans and marine biodiversity. #multilateralismmatters
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Years ago, I wrote a book arguing just this about the UN Security Council
Paul Poast
@ProfPaulPoast
Unwritten Rule of the United Nations: for some key members, the written rules don't apply.
[THREAD] -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
An important new podcast by my @hamiltonlugar colleague @ClemencePinaud
the-g-word-a-podcast-on-genocide.simplecast.com -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
As noxious smoke from Canada wafts across the United States, I hope that all my international law students are thinking of the Trail Smelter arbitration.
-
David Bosco reposted
louis charbonneau
@loucharbon
🚨 🧵 Great news!! UN General Assembly members rejected #belarus in Security Council elections for 2024-2025 seat, choosing #slovenia instead.
👏
@hrw's reaction: “Today’s General Assembly vote shows why competition in UN elections is essential." 1/x -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
On China's view, "innocent passage" can only be judged by looking into the heart and mind of the country that has sent the vessel.
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
About yesterday's near collision in Taiwan Strait, Li says that these vessels are not there for "innocent passage" but purposes of "hegemony" #sld23
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Given the constant discussion of war crimes in Russia-Ukraine conflict, there's been relatively little commentary about Ukraine apparently targeting civilian areas of Moscow.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The recent remarkable strides in institutionalizing international criminal law have in some ways cramped and empoverished our ability to talk about ethics and conflict.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
[merciful end of rambling and quite possibly half-baked thread]
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
South Africa mulls options on ICC arrest warrant for potential visitor Putin www.reuters.com/world/africa/south-africa-mulls-options-i…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
South Africa could host the BRICS summit on a high-seas vessel flagged by another nation.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A high-seas summit of convenience.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The op-eds urging that Russia be booted from the UNSC have appeared routinely since the invasion of Ukraine. (@BHL at least adds the twist that Ukraine should take its place!) But the idea is legally dubious, impractical politically, and simply unwise. www.wsj.com/articles/put-ukraine-on-the-u-n-security-coun…
-
David Bosco reposted
Naval News
@navalnewscom
The @ItalianNavy (Marina Militare) is currently deploying 11 vessels outside of the Mediterranean Sea (Mare Nostrum). An all time record 🇮🇹
www.navalnews.com/naval-news/2023/05/record-commitment-fo… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Which will come first: A final South China Sea code of conduct or UN Security Council reform?
M. Taylor Fravel
@fravel
Four years after the first reading in 2019…
www.scmp.com/news/china/diplomacy/article/3220974/beijing… -
David Bosco reposted
Mark Kersten
@MarkKersten
According to staff at the #icc, the investigation into #palestine is ‘minimally staffed and has largely stalled’. 👇🏼
This fits what I’ve heard, that diplomats have been told not to expect much from the Court. Esp w 🇺🇦 situation & need for “pragmatic” cooperation from West & US.
Alice Speri
@alicesperi
So many people have put much hope in the ICC's Palestine investigation.
But even though Khan has indicated that he hopes to “visit Palestine,” people at the court told me recently that the investigation is minimally staffed and has largely stalled.
theintercept.com/2023/05/04/international-criminal-court-… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Very glad to see this contribution to the debate on an aggression tribunal by @StephenPomper and @BCFinucane. This dimension of the discussion has been badly neglected.
Foreign Affairs
@ForeignAffairs
Read @StephenPomper and @BCFinucane on the geopolitical costs and practical challenges of creating a special tribunal to prosecute Putin and other senior Kremlin officials for initiating the war in Ukraine.
www.foreignaffairs.com/ukraine/russia-ukraine-justice-thw… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
US statement regarding its defense pact with the Philippines: "An armed attack in the Pacific, including anywhere in the South China Sea, on either of their public vessels, aircraft, or armed forces – which includes their Coast Guards – would invoke mutual defense commitments"
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This statement comes just days after a near collision between ships from the Philippines and China near Second Thomas Shoal apnews.com/article/philippines-dispute-south-china-sea-pa…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The customary US hold on the World Bank presidency continues.
World Bank Group
@WorldBankGroup
The Executive Directors of the @WorldBank today selected Ajay Banga as the President of the World Bank. Mr. Banga begins his five-year term on June 2, 2023.
Read the news release: wrld.bg/8IQq50OeSrl -
David Bosco reposted
World Bank Group
@WorldBankGroup
The Executive Directors of the @WorldBank today selected Ajay Banga as the President of the World Bank. Mr. Banga begins his five-year term on June 2, 2023.
Read the news release: wrld.bg/8IQq50OeSrl -
David Bosco reposted
stephanie vandenberg @svdberg.bsky.social
@vdbergstephanie
A very adamant Zelenskyi in The Hague today that he would not work wirh any form of hybrid tribunal for aggression. Suggesting it would be too easy to dismantle. What will United States and @StateDept_GCJ make of that?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Will President Zelensky be dropping off accession papers while he visits the International Criminal Court?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Stories like this are a good reminder that discussions about the costs and consequences of seabed mining cannot be considered without reference to the human costs of terrestrial mining.
www.washingtonpost.com/world/interactive/2023/ev-battery-… -
David Bosco reposted
Giovanni Cremonini
@cremogi
BBC News - 'Dangerous manoeuvres' in China and Philippines' cat-and-mouse sea chase
www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-65421115 -
David Bosco reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
As distasteful as it might be, those responsible for the war and for war crimes, including Putin, will need to be able to participate directly or indirectly in the diplomatic process if it is to have any chance of success, argues @RichardHaass. on.cfr.org/3LmKxIq
-
David Bosco reposted
Mark Kersten
@MarkKersten
So far, all signs point to Putin travelling to South Africa this August.
If that’s the case, I’m curious what his flight pattern might look like and whether other ICC member states tell him not to use their air space…
Geoffrey York
@geoffreyyork
South Africa continuing to defy the ICC arrest warrant for Putin for his war crimes. Putin and other BRICS leaders are "looking forward to attending the summit in person in South Africa in August," says a South African BRICS official. www.wionews.com/world/exclusive-russian-president-vladimi…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Excited to release a new working paper on seabed mining and the International Seabed Authority, co-authored with @AlineJaeckel and Pradeep Singh.
dlc.dlib.indiana.edu/dlc/handle/10535/10897
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The working paper is being released via the @Ostrom_Workshop at @IUBloomington, which will be hosting a new working group on seabed mining.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Grateful for the support of @pewenvironment in making this project happen.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Key takeway from US espionage: the UN Secretary General is grumpy. www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/04/15/unite…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The fact that US intelligence agencies apparently spend time and effort spying on the UN Secretary General is a challenge to the realist worldview.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A look at the state of the multilateral system based on the premise that the Biden administration has embraced multilateralism www.stimson.org/2023/red-cell-is-the-us-getting-multilate…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Which is largely true--with the very notable exception of the international trade world.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
South African officials acknowledge that Putin's ICC arrest warrant is a "spanner in the works" for the upcoming BRICS summit f24.my/9OoC.T via @FRANCE24
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Interesting nugget from the article: "[L]eftist parties, including the South African Communist Party -- a close ally of the ruling African National Congress -- have urged the government to welcome the Russian leader and pull out of the ICC instead"
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A Communist Party spokesperson argued that the ICC arrest warrant is part of a Western attempt to undermine the BRICS www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfoHHbo66a4
-
David Bosco reposted
Alina Papanastasiou
@alinapapan
The secret life of Olympian gods in international law 🧵
I grew up reading & loving Greek mythology. So references to Olympian gods in names of international agreements/projects, or to their stories in int’l decisions and scholarship, always hit a nostalgic nerve. 1/20 -
David Bosco reposted
Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala
@NOIweala
Great to celebrate today the USA’s ratifications of the Fisheries Subsidies Agreement! The 1st large fishing nation to ratify. Thank you to @AmbassadorTai & the USTR fisheries team for making this early ratification happen. Hope others will follow suit. Let’s get it done by MC13!
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Yevgeny Vindman makes a fairly standard case for why the US should join the International Criminal Court. But strange to do so without grappling with the ICC's investigation of US conduct in Afghanistan and what it says.
Foreign Policy
@ForeignPolicy
The United States has called for accountability for Russia’s war crimes, yet it refuses to join the court of last resort for genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity.
foreignpolicy.com/2023/04/11/russia-putin-ukraine-war-icc… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
"I imagine the UN as a great football team"
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
Top athletes including #football great @javierzanetti were @UN Headquarters Thursday, pushing for a more level playing field, on World #sportday - Full story below⚽ 🏀🎾news.un.org/en/story/2023/04/1135452
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A very interesting examination by @JeffDColgan of whether a decades old treaty could allow international justice to play a bigger role in climate change foreignpolicy.com/2023/04/05/united-nations-icj-vanuatu-c…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I think the sign I wore to a January 2017 protest holds up pretty well
-
David Bosco reposted
Michelle Nichols
@michellenichols
#russia's commissioner for children's rights, who is wanted by the International Criminal Court on war crimes charges, is likely to brief an informal meeting of the U.N. Security Council on #ukraine on Wednesday, according to a note seen by @Reuters.
www.reuters.com/world/europe/russian-charged-with-war-cri… -
David Bosco reposted
Ambassador-at-Large for Global Criminal Justice
@StateDept_GCJ
Come work with us! The application for the first of two international criminal law specialist positions, this one focused on Ukraine, closes next week.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm guessing there will be some changes in the @IntlCrimCourt process for screening interns
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/03/29/russian-spy-brazi… -
David Bosco reposted
Stephen Pomper
@StephenPomper
There has been a great deal of discussion about the different options for an aggression tribunal, especially in light of the US gvt's announcement that it will support an "internationalized" (read: hybrid) tribunal to prosecute Russia's illegal war. 1/x
www.crisisgroup.org/global-ukraine/new-court-prosecute-ru… -
David Bosco reposted
Barrie Sander
@Barrie_Sander
📢 We're hiring a new Assistant Professor of International Justice! 📢
Apply to join our International Justice team at Leiden University @fggaleiden - we're looking for someone with a particular passion for international migration law & law of the sea👇
www.universiteitleiden.nl/vacatures/2023/q1/13566-assista… -
David Bosco reposted
International Seabed Authority
@ISBAHQ
Do you have a minimum of 5 years of progressively responsible experience in project/programme management, training, capacity-building, law of the sea, ocean policy/governance, or blue economy?
@ISBAHQ is hiring a Prog Mgmt Officer!
Apply by 21 Apr! careers.un.org/lbw/jobdetail.aspx?id=205092&Lang=en-US -
David Bosco reposted
Dr. Beth Van Schaack
@BethVanSchaack
The Office of Global Criminal Justice is hiring! This is one of two international criminal law expert positions. Application period for the position with our Ukraine work is closing soon… g.co/kgs/oHcGSA
-
David Bosco reposted
Ambassador-at-Large for Global Criminal Justice
@StateDept_GCJ
Spoke @CatholicUniv at the @NuremburgAcadem Principles Conferences where I outlined the U.S.'s support for accountability in Ukraine, including for a Tribunal dedicated to the Crime of Aggression. I noted:
-
David Bosco reposted
Richard Gowan
@RichardGowan1
Interesting sign of #brazil's apparent tilt towards #china and #russia @UN under Lula, after the sheer confusion of the #bolsonaro era.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The US indictment inaccurately refers to the International Criminal Court as a "United Nations Organization"
The Guardian
@guardian
US indicts alleged Russian spy who tried to infiltrate ICC in The Hague www.theguardian.com/world/2023/mar/26/us-indicts-alleged-…
-
David Bosco reposted
Giovanni Cremonini
@cremogi
First-ever EU🇪🇺-🇺🇸 U.S. joint naval exercise 'to support freedom of navigation and other internationally lawful uses of the sea in the Indo-Pacific'.
Joint press release: www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/us-first-ever-joint-naval-exercis…
#eudefence -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A new UN treaty looks to govern maritime resources on the high seas www.marketplace.org/2023/03/24/a-new-un-treaty-looks-to-g…
-
David Bosco reposted
Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus
@DrTedros
No country will cede any sovereignty to @WHO. Countries will decide what the #pandemicaccord says, and countries will implement the accord in line with their own national laws. Any opposite claim is quite simply false.
-
David Bosco reposted
david_mcnair
@David_McNair
Does China support Ajay Banga to lead the World Bank?
Here's what Wang Wenbin of the Chinese Foreign Ministry said yesterday 👇 -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I would guess that the story of whether South Africa will host Putin for the upcoming BRICS summit will have lots of twists and turns both domestically and internationally.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The South African government made a bid in the wake of the Bashir imbroglio to leave the ICC but that country's highest court ruled that doing so required legislative approval
www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-39204035
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I don't know the makeup or inclinations of the parliament now but it doesn't seem beyond the realm of possibility that the government could make another bid to leave the ICC
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Wow
Mark Kersten
@MarkKersten
South Africa confirms it has invited Vladimir Putin to its BRICS conference in August.
It is not just #icc law that South Africa will violate if it hosts and does not arrest Putin. It is *South African* law that it will break: www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2023-03-23-russias-vladimir-… cc @geoffreyyork -
David Bosco reposted
Douglas Guilfoyle
@djag2
Important piece. Lots of nervousness in the region about nuclear subs and whether their transit could legally be prohibited. Commentators in archipelagic and straits states are flirting with that idea in the name of "neutrality" but the law ... 1/
www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/could-indonesia-leg… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
One question in light of the ICC's charges against Vladimir Putin is whether some of the air will go out of the movement for a special aggression tribunal. @kevinjonheller @oonahathaway @StephenPomper
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But my guess (and it's only a guess!) is that for some governments the ICC charges will dampen their enthusiasm for new institution-building. Putin now bears the stain of being a wanted war criminal: mission accomplished.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I'm curious how others following this debate more closely see the dynamic here.
-
David Bosco reposted
@hayesbrown.bsky.social
@HayesBrown
"The impact of the ICC’s move will almost certainly be less in the courtroom than in the diplomatic realm. That’s because Vladimir Putin is exceedingly unlikely to end up in The Hague." - @multilateralist
www.msnbc.com/opinion/msnbc-opinion/putin-arrest-warrant-… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Thought-provoking thread on the rationale behind the Iraq War but the performative refusal to link to arguments the author disagrees with (as if they're too dangerous to spread!) undercuts its persuasiveness. @ahsanib @Max_Fisher
Ahsan Butt
@ahsanib
The claim, often self serving (the Haass tweet or Frum oped, neither of which I will link), is that the Bush admin did not deliberately mislead the country and the world about WMD. That the intelligence could have reasonably been read one way or the other.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Medvedev is a clown--but given the history of regime opponents being poisoned and falling out of windows, there really is an element of personal bravery in the actions of the ICC prosecutor and judges.
Visegrád 24
@visegrad24
Dmitri Medvedev has threatened to strike the International Criminal Court in The Hague with a hypersonic Kinzhal missile.
He finished his Telegram post with the statement:
“judges, look carefully at the sky…” -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In light of the charges against Putin, re-upping this curious story about a Russian attempt to infiltrate the International Criminal Court www.rferl.org/a/russian-spy-international-criminal-court/…
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
Very thoughtful thread here by @StephenPomper, who has worked on justice dilemmas at the highest level
Stephen Pomper
@StephenPomper
This excellent piece by @bechamilton @justsecurity lays out with great clarity and economy the logic behind the new ICC arrest warrants for Putin and Maria Lvova Belova. If you haven’t already looked, I strongly recommend it. 1/x
www.justsecurity.org/85529/the-icc-goes-straight-to-the-t… -
David Bosco reposted
Stephen Pomper
@StephenPomper
This excellent piece by @bechamilton @justsecurity lays out with great clarity and economy the logic behind the new ICC arrest warrants for Putin and Maria Lvova Belova. If you haven’t already looked, I strongly recommend it. 1/x
www.justsecurity.org/85529/the-icc-goes-straight-to-the-t… -
David Bosco
@multilateralist
It's not just Putin. Other senior Russian officials are going to have to weigh the risks of travel to many countries. There is always the possibility of sealed arrest warrants.
-
David Bosco reposted
Daniel Krcmaric
@DanKrcmaric
Now that we’ve had a few hours to digest the ICC arrest warrant for Vladimir Putin, it’s time to think about the political implications. A long 🧵... www.nytimes.com/live/2023/03/17/world/russia-ukraine-puti…
-
David Bosco reposted
Mark Kersten
@MarkKersten
Some reflections from me on the big news of the #icc's arrest warrant against Vladimir Putin and Maria Alekseyevna Lvova-Belova: justiceinconflict.org/2023/03/17/straight-to-the-top-the-… #russia #ukraine
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The charges against Putin should make Israeli leaders with responsibility for policy in the West Bank a bit nervous.
Post not available here, view on X
David Bosco
@multilateralist
In Israel's case, the potentially illegal activity is bringing population (settlers) to the occupied territory rather than taking population from it.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But perhaps the key point is the way in which occupation policies like these can be connected more readily to high levels of government than many battlefield crimes
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The issue of whether the United States will actively support the International Criminal Court’s investigation in Ukraine is nowr resurfacing as a significant one. A few thoughts about the debate and the overall context (channeling my inner realist/contrarian!)
-
Jonathan Tepperman
@j_tepperman
1/2: Would the ICC indicting Putin make any difference? On the one hand, the court will never get custody, and Putin has already stopped traveling to countries that would enforce the court’s writ. And remember how long Sudan’s Bashir swanned around the world after he was indicted
The New York Times
@nytimes
The International Criminal Court prosecutor opened an immediate criminal investigation of possible war crimes in Ukraine.
The investigation will be fast-tracked after requests from 39 member countries, an unprecedented move for the court.
www.nytimes.com/2022/03/03/world/europe/war-crimes-russia…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
A couple points to keep in mind regarding possible ICC indictments. First, these need to be legal cases that can be prosecuted in court and evidence can be very hard to gather, particularly connecting top officials to actual crimes on the ground
David Bosco
@multilateralist
The other point is that we have to remember that not all ICC crimes can be prosecuted in this situation. Specifically, the crime of aggression is not available to the prosecutor and that would be the easiest to pin on Putin.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
But the broad point about rendering Russian leaders and commanders as pariahs is a really important one that deserves attention.
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
This week was the official publication of my new book, The Poseidon Project, by Oxford University Press. A brief thread on my central argument: www.amazon.com/dp/0190265647 via @amazon
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
I think contemporary accounts of the UN's founding tend to overemphasize human rights and deemphasize the UN Charter's focus on militarily crushing any new aggressive powers.
UN News
@UN_News_Centre
75 years ago on Friday, the @UN Charter was first signed, underscoring:
👉🏿Human Rights
👉🏽Equality + Dignity
👉🏻International Law
👉🏾Peace
The ideals laid out then in are even more relevant today.
#charterday #un75charter
news.un.org/en/story/2020/06/1067242 -
Antony Blinken
@ABlinken
Actually I said China is asserting itself as leader of world order — but an ILLIBERAL one of its making — in the face of US retreat from post WW2 leadership of liberal order.
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@ABlinken says China is embracing liberal world order AND that US retreat risks new illiberal world order. www.nytimes.com/2017/11/08/opinion/trump-china-xi-jinping…
David Bosco
@multilateralist
You describe a China embracing climate change, UN peacekeeping, scientific innovation, free trade, and multilateralism more broadly. How's that illiberal?
-
David Bosco
@multilateralist
@ABlinken says China is embracing liberal world order AND that US retreat risks new illiberal world order. www.nytimes.com/2017/11/08/opinion/trump-china-xi-jinping…
































































































