In 1942, Louis Newburgh explained weight gain with menopause as the result of bonbons at bridge parties.
His paper established the central dogma of obesity science.
Research from the 1980s on what sex hormones actually do to fat cells tells a different story.
My new Substack post:
Sex, Fat and Aging? uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/sex-fat-and-aging?r=…
Gary Taubes
Gary Taubes (born April 30, 1956) is an American journalist, writer, and low-carbohydrate / high-fat (LCHF) diet advocate. His central claim is that carbohydrates, especially sugar and high-fructose corn syrup, overstimulate the secretion of insulin, causing the body to store fat in fat cells and the liver, and that it is primarily a high level of dietary carbohydrate consumption that accounts for obesity and other metabolic syndrome conditions. He is the author of Nobel Dreams (1987); Bad Science: The Short Life and Weird Times of Cold Fusion (1993); Good Calories, Bad Calories (2007), titled The Diet Delusion (2008) in the UK and Australia; Why We Get Fat: And What to Do About It (2010); The Case Against Sugar (2016); and The Case for Keto: Rethinking Weight Control and the Science and Practice of Low-Carb/High-Fat Eating (2020). Taubes's work often goes against accepted scientific, governmental, and popular tenets such as that obesity is caused by eating too much and exercising too little and that excessive consumption of fat, especially saturated fat in animal products, leads to cardiovascular disease. More on Wikipedia
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I pointed this out in the epilogue of Good Calories, Bad Calories in 2007: if the then-ongoing $200 million LookAHEAD trial had included a low-carb diet arm, we might have resolved the controversy with that trial.
Instead, LookAHEAD was ended "for futility," as they say in the clinical trial business, and we're still hoping (@DrJBhattacharya) someone will step up and fund an RCT with hard endpoints that could settle this.
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Just imagine if this diet had been included for study in the (failed) Women's Health Initiative, the (failed) Sydney Diet Heart Study, the (failed) Minesotta Coronary Experiment, the (failed) Look AHEAD trial etc etc including the other studies reviewed by @garytaubes, @bigfatsurprise and @zoeharcombe amongst others.
The diet-heart debate would have been resolved already in 2-3 decades ago.
Ken D Berry MD
@KenDBerryMD
KETO CUTS HEART ATTACK RATE IN HALF
Dr. Baker is right. This is the study that should end the keto heart attack scare.
For 50 years doctors have warned that cutting carbs and eating more fat would give you a heart attack. This study checked what actually happened. 4,877 adults with type 2 diabetes or obesity cut their carbs with Virta. They were matched with 4,877 people on usual care.
Heart attack, stroke or death: 4.1 per 1,000 people a year on low carb. 9.3 on usual care.
Less than half.
Study:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42826005/
American Heart Ass’n CAVES on Low-Carb Diet! (KETO protects Heart)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=2VhFIRxbU_Q -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
That it's not an RCT but a retrospective study is a critical caveat here.
Another is the lack of balance between the two comparisons: one getting the telemedicine intervention, the other only usual care.
On the other hand, as @bschermd says,this is better evidence than what critics of carb restriction use to argue that it's harmful.
Bret Scher, MD
@bschermd
Most doctors believe keto diets or ketogenic therapy means elevated cardiovascular risk.
A new study in Cardiology and Therapy looked at that assumption in nearly 10,000 patients. And guess what? They found the exact opposite! 🧵 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As it says below, "I gave. Will you?"
Ken D Berry MD
@KenDBerryMD
People with type 2 diabetes do not have to "live with it."
The @OfficialADSOrg exists to teach that. Type 2 can go into remission with food and lifestyle. You don't have to manage it forever with more and more medication.
In 2021, the American Diabetes Association itself convened the expert group that defined remission: an A1C under 6.5% for at least 3 months after the usual diabetes drugs are stopped. That report is in ADA's own journal, Diabetes Care.
Type 2 is not a life sentence.
If you have type 2, start here:
americandiabetessociety.org
Introducing the American Diabetes Society [Diabetes Truth] 2026
www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPX_dvZDCls
Consensus Report: Definition and Interpretation of Remission in Type 2 Diabetes. Diabetes Care 2021:
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8929179/This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Food is Medicine isn't just a new book by Dariush Mozaffarian; it's a dominant theme in modern nutrition policy: chronic disease comes less from eating bad food than from not eating enough good food.
So telling folks to avoid sugar and white bread is always a good idea, but not as good as getting them to eat broccoli, salmon, and quinoa.
It sounds reasonable. But if food is medicine, it has to be tested like medicine.
When it is, the results are thin, and a ketogenic diet keeps winning.
Is Food Really Medicine? (If So, Which Foods?) uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/is-food-really-medic… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Is high LDL cholesterol (or apoB) harmful ONLY with poor metabolic health, characterized by low HDLc?
New study from preeminent lipidologist Sniderman:
"when HDL-C is high ... effect of changing apoB vanishes"
PS: A low-carb diet potently increases HDLc
academic.oup.com/eurjpc/advance-article/doi/10.1093/eurjp… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here are 2 ways to think of ketogenic and carnivore diets:
1. Potent therapies for a range of chronic diseases—from obesity and diabetes to schizophrenia and bi-polar depressive disorder. As @Hubermanlab says in his new book Protocols, the benefits can be “remarkable.”
2. Fascinating challenges to the conventional scientific thinking on the diet-disease relationship.
Huberman and the authors of a recent Science paper on "essential" sugars in human evolution will accept the first, but actively resist even considering the second.
The obvious question: where’s their curiosity?
Are they so trapped in conventional thinking that they can’t even entertain the notion that there might be something new to learn here?
Sugars in Evolution and Huberman’s Protocols uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/sugars-in-evolution-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
From @doctortro's clinical practice, use of a therapeutic ketogenic diet resulted in a dramatic improvement in CVD risk:
Using the AHA’s own PREVENT equations, estimated 10-year risk fell:
29% for ASCVD
28% for total cardiovascular disease
42% for heart failure
Median weight loss was 12.2%
Systolic blood pressure fell 10.7 mm
HgHbA1c fell 0.48 percentage points
Triglycerides fell 34 mg/dL.
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
Do you eat low carb and worry about your heart? The ADA recognizes lower-carb eating for people with diabetes or prediabetes. New federal guidelines say it may help some people with chronic disease. Yet the AHA puts keto in its lowest tier for diet-guideline alignment. We used its PREVENT calculator: in our paired cohort, calculated 10-year ASCVD risk fell 29% after one year. Watch what we found. Read the article: toward.health/real-food-keto-cuts-heart-risk-toward-health/
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Once upon a time, not all that long ago, medical authorities thought that the best way to resolve scientific controversies was to air them out, discuss the evidence on both sides, what was known and what was not, and so establish what research was needed to settle the issue.
Well, those days may be gone. Now researchers, influential authorities (and, of course, our friends the health reporters) have decided that given the opportunity to review a vitally important subject, their job is to advocate for what they believe, ignore the counterarguments and inconvenient evidence and hope for the best.
In my latest Substack, I discuss three very recent examples of this advocacy phenomenon, and compare it to how scientists used to discuss controversial science, back when they were more interested in getting the right answer than establishing their authority.

Discussing Controversy in Medical Science: Air It Out or Sweep It Under the Rug? uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/discussing-controver… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
The Endocrine Society has a new "scientific statement" on the gaps (or rather black holes) in obesity science.
@garytaubes shines cosmic light on the matter.
If you don't subscribe to his Substack, this essay alone is worth the price.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here’s a question from my latest Substack post. It's about obesity and obesity medicine and it should be rhetorical. Regrettably, it's not:
Q. If you were going to study a disorder of excess fat accumulation (i.e., too much fat in fat cells) and the action of the drugs that so spectacularly treat it, wouldn’t you be at least vaguely interested in the physiological mechanisms that determine how much fat those fat cells will store?
1. Yes?
2. No?
Common sense (and the history of obesity science) might suggest the answer has to be yes, but the expert authors of a recent Endocrine Society Scientific Statement on “Obesity science, research gaps, and opportunities in the new era of obesity medicines,” would claim otherwise.
They put the brain at the center of obesity science and GLP-1 action, then omit (ignore?) a century of science suggesting that since it's the fat cells that get fatter in obesity, the direct neuroendocrine regulation of fat storage in those cells must be relevant.
These expert authors include @kevinhallPhD and @danielJdrucker and a half dozen others, and we can assume they know more about obesity than anyone.
They’re the experts.
But if so, why do they ignore the fat cell itself when discussing why we accumulate excess fat in fat cells, and why GLP-1 drugs do such a remarkable job of reversing that process?
What are they missing with their conviction that obesity is an "appetitive behavior" disorder?
The Black Hole at the Galactic Core of Obesity and GLP-1 Drug Science uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/the-black-hole-at-th… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here’s a question from my latest Substack post. It's about obesity and obesity medicine and it should be rhetorical. Regrettably, it's not:
Q. If you were going to study a disorder of excess fat accumulation (i.e., too much fat in fat cells) and the action of the drugs that so spectacularly treat it, wouldn’t you be at least vaguely interested in the physiological mechanisms that determine how much fat those fat cells will store?
1. Yes?
2. No?
Common sense (and the history of obesity science) might suggest the answer has to be yes, but the expert authors of a recent Endocrine Society Scientific Statement on “Obesity science, research gaps, and opportunities in the new era of obesity medicines,” would claim otherwise.
They put the brain at the center of obesity science and GLP-1 action, then omit (ignore?) a century of science suggesting that since it's the fat cells that get fatter in obesity, the direct neuroendocrine regulation of fat storage in those cells must be relevant.
These expert authors include @kevinhallPhD and @danielJdrucker and a half dozen others, and we can assume they know more about obesity than anyone.
They’re the experts.
But if so, why do they ignore the fat cell itself when discussing why we accumulate excess fat in fat cells, and why GLP-1 drugs do such a remarkable job of reversing that process?
What are they missing with their conviction that obesity is an "appetitive behavior" disorder?
The Black Hole at the Galactic Core of Obesity and GLP-1 Drug Science uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/the-black-hole-at-th… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
In the past two years, 14 studies have exploited the same remarkable natural experiment: the end of sugar rationing in Britain in 1953.
All have come to essentially the same conclusion: greater exposure to sugar early in life is associated with more chronic disease decades later—diabetes, heart disease, cancer, depression, dementia, and more.
These studies aren’t appearing in obscure journals. They’re being published in Science, the BMJ, PNAS, the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Nature Communications, and elsewhere.
Meanwhile, @tamarhaspel of the @washingtonpost confidently tells us in a recent column: “The real problem with sugar is simply that we like it.”
So why the confidence? And what do we do with this remarkable body of new evidence?
Ultimately, the question is one we’ve been arguing about for decades: Should we treat sugar as a chronic toxin—or as a benign indulgence that becomes harmful only because it provides excess calories?
Is Sugar Toxic? Can It Cause Cancer? CHD? Frailty? Dementia?
Read the post on Uncertainty Principles
uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/is-sugar-toxic-can-i… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Do GLP-1 drugs work by inhibiting appetite or by prioritizing fat oxidation over storage--changing metabolic fuel partitioning, in the lingo?
Most researchers (and X influencers) will insist it's the former, but they'll do so because they don't think deeply about the alternative.
Maybe the new paper by Friedman & Lund will help. 🤞
Jens Lund
@jens_lund
Could Wegovy’s weight-lowering effect be caused by how the drug affects fuel metabolism? 1/16
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Well, this is nice to see.
And from Sam Klein of all people. He was a co-author on two major Atkins studies in the 00s, but seemed to be stumbling blindly over the results.
He seems to have his eyes open now.
Signs of a paradigm shifting?
Dr. Ann
@AnnChildersMD
When we were dating, my engineer now-husband was floored that I didn’t trust Scientific American’s take on nutrition.
After we were married my husband adopted Keto and lost his T2 diabetic dawn effect and fatty liver disease. On Keto, eventually his labs made him appear to be non-diabetic
Now, 14 years since I first objected to nutrition à la Scientific American it looks like the magazine is finally coming around 😊
I have @garytaubes to thank for the insights in his book, Good Calories, Bad Calories, that started my low carb journey. Nicely done, Gary Taubes 🌸
@sciam
www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-the-keto-diet-bette… -
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
Excited to see the evidence base for ketogenic therapies as a treatment for severe mental illnesses and neurocognitive disorders continue to advance!
This systematic review and meta-analysis includes 73 studies.
More are on the way!
www.nature.com/articles/s41398-026-04370-2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I've never been a fan of the American Heart Association's version of the diet-heart hypothesis.
But what if they're right?
Shouldn't we all work diligently to lower our LDL by diet?
Let's work through the numbers and see what we have to gain.
If you're curious about how a public health campaign acknowledging "negligible benefit" for most of us became the foundational proposition of our dietary wisdom, read on...
Lowering LDL: Surely, a “Heart-Healthy” Diet is Worth the Effort. Isn’t it? uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/lowering-ldl-surely-… -
gary taubes reposted
Coalition for Metabolic Health
@metcoalition
We recently hosted a Capitol Hill briefing on how nutrition can address chronic disease, improve health outcomes, and reduce healthcare costs in the era of GLP-1s.
Watch highlights featuring @RepDavids, Dr. Maya Maroto, @bschermd, @DoctorTro, and Dr. Caroline Roberts.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Question of the day: Why would you ever eat a fad diet?
1. Because you’re a frivolous person, and this is the kind of thing frivolous people do.
2. Because you lack the critical skills necessary to understand why our nutrition authorities don’t take such a diet seriously?
3. Because you’ve been living with an intractable diet-related health issue for far too long, and the conventional dietary approaches have failed you.
4. Because a relative, friend, co-worker, TikTok influencer, or maybe even (heaven forbid) your doctor suggested it might cure what ails you, and so, what the hell? Why not?
NY Times writers will invariably suggest 1 or 2. Maybe because I think conventional diets are doomed to fail, and I eat a fad diet, I’m going with 3 and 4.
Now RKF Jr and his Republican colleagues (or cronies, depending on your political affiliation) are eating a meat-and-sauerkraut diet.
Why would they do such a thing? And how do you think the Times reported it? How about the WSJ?
Blah Health Journalism: Meat, Sauerkraut and Politics Edition. uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/blah-health-journali… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
And please listen to this, too.
We tend to forget that treating the symptoms of obesity and diabetes does precious little or nothing to prevent their appearance.
Coalition for Metabolic Health
@metcoalition
At our congressional briefing, @RepDavids explains why the U.S. healthcare system must do more to prevent chronic disease before people get sick.
Watch to learn about bipartisan efforts to expand Americans' access to fresh produce, nutrition counseling, and more.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Please Listen. 5 minutes of your time.
Coalition for Metabolic Health
@metcoalition
We recently hosted a Capitol Hill briefing on how nutrition can address chronic disease and reduce U.S. healthcare costs.
Watch our executive director, Dr. Maya Maroto, explain how evidence-based nutrition approaches can improve Americans' health and complement GLP-1 treatment:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Obesity researchers believe the brain defends body weight by regulating how many calories we consume and expend. It monitors our fat stores, turning hunger up or down as necessary to keep them stable.
Decades ago, though, researchers in the field of physiological psychology, who actually study the physiological basis of hunger, reached a very different conclusion.
They concluded that the brain doesn't care about how fat we are, or how much we’ve just eaten, but is monitoring the energy status of our cells—whether they are producing energy or depleting it.
Remember ATP from high school biology? The “molecular unit of currency” for moving energy around the body? Unlike fats and carbohydrates, ATP cannot be stored. An animal deprived of food survives for days or longer; an animal whose ATP production is shut down by a toxin survives for seconds.
Both theory and evidence were compelling, but the obesity researchers knew nothing about it, and they still don’t. (They didn’t read the physiology journals, and the physiological psychologists—PhDs, not MDs—weren’t presenting at obesity conferences.)
If it’s true, though, it changes radically how we think about obesity, hunger, and, yes, food noise—and why the GLP-1 drugs so famously shut that down. It puts our livers at the center of the metabolic universe, not our brains.
(And even Karl-Anthony Towns comes into this story.)
Karl-Anthony Towns, Food Noise, and Why GLP-1 Drugs Quiet the Brain open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/karl-anthon… -
gary taubes reposted
LowCarbUSA®
@lowcarbusa
Gary Taubes — Science & nutrition journalist - @garytaubes
-
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
Mental health and metabolic health are deeply interconnected, and the science is advancing rapidly.
Join us virtually for this Harvard Medical School-accredited CME/CE course September 16–19, 2026.
We'll explore the latest research and practical clinical applications related to mental health, metabolism, nutrition, lifestyle interventions, and integrated care models.
Only 9 days left to take advantage of the early registration discount.
I hope you'll join us!
learn.hms.harvard.edu/programs/mental-health-and-metaboli… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm looking forward to LowCarbUSA in San Diego next month.
This year I'll be talking about why anyone would do a diet as extreme as keto or carnivore if it wasn't necessary.
The new code is 'JulySavings'.
Should be fun and informative, as always.
LowCarbUSA®
@lowcarbusa
There's a moment, for a lot of people, when the story they've been told about food, weight, and metabolic health stops making sense…
For many in this community, Gary Taubes is the person who lit the match.
The science journalist behind Good Calories, Bad Calories; Why We Get Fat; The Case Against Sugar; The Case for Keto; and Rethinking Diabetes has been part of LowCarbUSA from the very first San Diego event 11 years ago.
This August, he returns to the stage.
That shift — from a dozen physicians a quarter century ago to tens of thousands today — didn't happen because the theoretical debate was won.
It happened because clinicians and patients witnessed what changed:
- weight loss
- falling A1C
- lower blood pressure
- reduced hunger
In San Diego, Taubes is weighing two talks: the lost history of obesity science, or the clinical case for ketogenic diets — and why the popular "ultra‑processed" label may be too broad to explain what foods actually do to blood sugar, insulin, hunger, and fat storage.
Read the full story and join the movement.
www.lowcarbusa.org/gary-taubes-is-still-challenging-the-s…
2026 Symposium for Metabolic Health
📍 Wyndham San Diego Bayside
🗓️ August 13–16
Final days — use code SummerSavings for 10% off your full registration, only through July 4.
www.lowcarbusa.org/san-diego-2026/
#thesmhp #metabolichealth #mhp #neverstoplearning #symposiumformetabolichealth #garytaubes #evidencebasedmedicine #tcr -
gary taubes reposted
Shebani Sethi, MD
@ShebaniMD
Proud to share a study lead by PI Judy Ford which I was a co-investigator at @UCSF on: the first randomized controlled trial of ketogenic therapy in schizophrenia-spectrum and bipolar disorders, out now in Schizophrenia Bulletin.
Key results: keto was feasible, metabolic markers improved significantly at 1 month, and the 4-month extension showed significant psychiatric symptom reduction and better cognition.
58 participants at UCSF. 1-month RCT + optional 4-month keto extension.
Early evidence — but a real step toward metabolic treatments for serious mental illness.
Paper: doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbag082 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Does this make any sense to you? Evolution (or your deity of choice) goes through all that trouble to induce us to procreate and assure the survival of our genes and our species, and then it makes the actual act of giving birth so painful, prolonged, and dangerous that it can kill or disable both mother and child just for going through with it.
Now that a new study may have killed the conventional explanation of the Obstetrical Dilemma, maybe we should consider the unconventional. Dare we suggest diet matters?
Shouldn’t Giving Birth Be (Reasonably) Easy? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/shouldnt-gi… -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Results of the first-ever randomized controlled trial testing ketogenic therapy in people living with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder were just published in Schizophrenia Bulletin.
Here's what was found 🧵 -
gary taubes reposted
Gregory Mays, MD | Insulin Resistance Physician
@GregoryMaysMD
They expected to learn more about digestion.
What they found changed the history of diabetes.
In 1889, Oskar Minkowski and Joseph von Mering at the University of Strasbourg surgically removed a dog’s pancreas.
They were studying the pancreas’ digestive enzymes and their role in fat digestion.
What happened next surprised them.
The dog developed polyuria, and its urine contained glucose.
The experiment provided the first compelling evidence that the pancreas played a critical role in preventing diabetes, decades before insulin was discovered.
You can read more about it in @garytaubes’ excellent book Rethinking Diabetes. -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
The Futility of Calorie Counting:
“You could put sawdust into a bomb calorimeter and you would get basically 4 calories per gram.... If you’re a termite, yes, you’ll get calories from it. But humans won’t.”
apnews.com/article/calories-high-glycemic-ultraprocessed-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How do GLP-1 drugs cause weight loss?
If they work by suppressing appetite or increasing satiety (which I don't buy), the notion that they accomplish that by delaying gastric emptying doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.
At least not in the first actual test of the assumption. -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Erling Haaland is doing more to effectively dismantle the 1977 US Food Pyramid than @RobertKennedyJc and the entire global low-carb movement combined. (Well almost).
@bigfatsurprise @zoeharcombe @TheNoakesF @garytaubes @BenBikmanPhD @AKoutnik @sweatscience
Curiosidades Europa
@CuriosidadesEU
🇳🇴 A velocidade do Haaland.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
David Siegel
@PullNews
What I'm watching - a lecture by @garytaubes on the causes of obesity ...
videocast.nih.gov/watch/94fba9f4-47b9-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Question of the day: if science is thought of as institutionalized skepticism, what happens in a public health controversy when to be skeptical of the science, bad as it might be, is to be accused of manufacturing doubt? Playing by the tobacco industry's playbook?
This is an issue at the forefront of the latest incarnation of nutrition (sort of?) science: the war on ultra-processed foods.
I wrote about the (sort of?) science issues for The Atlantic and about those and the manufacturing-doubt issue in Uncertainty Principles, my substack.
"Bad Air" or the Tobacco Industry Playbook? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/bad-air-or-… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
NEW PAPER @AJCNutrition
Have CONTINUOUS GLUCOSE MONITORS been wrongfully discredited?
CGMs (used in diabetes) are now being applied to "Precision Nutrition"
Even without diabetes, high-carb foods can spike glucose—tending to make low-carb diets look good
Critics cry foul!
1/6 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here's one way to think about the ultra-processed food problem:
Does nutrition science benefit by losing the distinction? r and is unprocessed--a "healthy" whole food?-- or seaweed snacks, which are essentially sugar-free but ultra-processed?D
And does nutrition science benefit by losing the distinction?
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Ultra-processed foods have overtaken the healthy-eating debate—but the science behind the term is unresolved, @garytaubes argues. He reports on why deciding what to eat has become so confusing: www.theatlantic.com/health/2026/06/ultra-processed-foods-…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Arguably the most consequential debate in nutrition today— Ultra-Processed Food
👉Like the low-fat diet debacle of the late 20th century, are we building another house of cards?
The inimitable @garytaubes @TheAtlantic
Worth finding your way thru paywall
www.theatlantic.com/health/2026/06/ultra-processed-foods-… -
gary taubes reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
“Ultra-processed” in the world of nutrition circa 2026 is just the latest synonym for “unhealthy,” @garytaubes writes—but this vague new term may be leading people in the wrong direction. www.theatlantic.com/health/2026/06/ultra-processed-foods-…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Excellent article on the emerging field of metabolic psychiatry and the use of ketogenic diets for cognitive disorders.
It's nice to see this reported now without knee-jerk opinions about what's a fad diet and what's not.
If this kind of dietary therapy works to treat an intractable disease, then let's test it and, if it works, let's use it.
Scientific American
@sciam
Early research suggests that some mental health conditions could stem from metabolic disorders. If so, the findings could change how we treat mental illness
spklr.io/6018E3mEI -
gary taubes reposted
gary taubes
@garytaubes
One of the regrettable facts about obesity research and its implications for nutrition and public health is that the authorities do not know the history of their own science.
I'll try to rectify this at the NIH on Friday, explaining why the energy balance model of obesity--that overeating is the cause--was rejected prior to World War 2 as a "dead end" that explained nothing about why we get fat.
Jay Bhattacharya, MD, PhD
@NIHDirector_Jay
🧐Be sure to join me June 12 at 1:30pm ET for the next talk in the NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series, titled “Energy Balance or Fuel Partitioning? A History Lesson in the Science of Obesity Pathogenesis, and Its Implications.”
I’ll be joined by Gary Taubes, a science journalist and historian, to discuss how nutrition, fitness, and other factors like genetics influence obesity risk.
NIH staff can attend in person in the Masur Auditorium of NIH’s Building 10.
The public is invited to attend virtually via webcast. ➡️ videocast.nih.gov/watch/94fba9f4-47b9-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Echo Chamber of the Like-Minded?
18 new papers on ultra-processed foods in @AMJPublicHealth
As with prior series (eg @lancet), there is remarkably little diversity of opinion.
Perhaps inadvertently, the first paper on the TOC (Campos et al) reveals a crucial problem.
1/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
One of the regrettable facts about obesity research and its implications for nutrition and public health is that the authorities do not know the history of their own science.
I'll try to rectify this at the NIH on Friday, explaining why the energy balance model of obesity--that overeating is the cause--was rejected prior to World War 2 as a "dead end" that explained nothing about why we get fat.
Jay Bhattacharya, MD, PhD
@NIHDirector_Jay
🧐Be sure to join me June 12 at 1:30pm ET for the next talk in the NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series, titled “Energy Balance or Fuel Partitioning? A History Lesson in the Science of Obesity Pathogenesis, and Its Implications.”
I’ll be joined by Gary Taubes, a science journalist and historian, to discuss how nutrition, fitness, and other factors like genetics influence obesity risk.
NIH staff can attend in person in the Masur Auditorium of NIH’s Building 10.
The public is invited to attend virtually via webcast. ➡️ videocast.nih.gov/watch/94fba9f4-47b9-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is exciting and fascinating on many levels — therapeutically and scientifically.
These women with weight-normalized anorexia nervosa showed "less dietary restraint" without weight change on the ketogenic diet. So they ate more but weight didn't change?
Is it possible that anorexia is a fat-storage disorder, not an eating disorder (just as I and others have argued about obesity)?
If so, this observation is unsurprising.
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
New study offers hope for anorexia nervosa.
The first-ever pilot trial of ketogenic therapy for anorexia nervosa was just published.
Here's what @GuidoFrank and his research team at @UCSDMedSchool found. 🧵 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Warning: if you study the history of obesity science--specifically, where the energy balance/overeating thinking came from--you'll learn why the best medical scientists in the world rejected it as a failed hypothesis--"the dead end of the energetic view" as it was described in 1936.
By the 1930s, European scientists had collected a world of observations about fat storage that overeating couldn't begin to explain. But their thinking got lost with the Second World War, and so we've been living with the energy balance dogma ever since.
Shouldn't Where We Get Fat (and When) Tell Us Something About Why? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/shouldnt-wh… -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
What the post also shows is that no single dietary intervention has been shown, in a long term study, to improve long term human health. Not diets that substitute polyunsaturated fats for saturated fats; not diets that replace fat with carbohydrate.
Yet I doubt there is a single faculty teaching human nutrition anywhere in the world that ever makes this point.
Probably the most important study is the LookAhead study which tested dietary fat reduction in obese type 2 diabetes. After 9.5 years it was given up as a. hopeless failure. Which of course it was not. It was only a failure for those who, filled with cognitive dissonance, have and will continue to prescribe that diet in the hope that somehow their patients will respond differently.
Yet what diet does one think is prescribed by "evidence-based" doctors and dietitians, for most of the world's persons living with that condition?
On the other hand, the one diet that has yet to be properly investigated with long term trials is the low-carbohydrate high-fat diet.
Yet the reason most usually advanced by the "evidence-based" practitioners to explain why the low-carbohydrate diet should not be prescribed is "because there are no long term studies".
So instead the diets that are prescribed (because there are long-term trials - regardless of outcomes) are exactly those which long-term studies show are either harmful or without effect.
A strange situation is it not?
@garytaubes @bigfatsurprise @lowcarbGP @BenBikmanPhD @markkaplan20 @AKoutnik @LoreofRunning1
Chris S. Cornell
@BiggestComeback
Another great post from @ProfTimNoakes.
Reading it made me wonder whether we may eventually look back at GLP-1s with a similar kind of historical perspective.
Not because GLP-1s they “don’t work.” They clearly do many things powerfully.
But insulin also worked. Miraculously. Life-savingly. And then, decades later, the story became more complicated.
I don’t pretend to know where the GLP-1 story goes from here.
But I do wonder whether we’re asking enough long-term questions about appetite suppression, lean mass, nutrition quality, dependency, behavior change, metabolic health, and what “success” actually means beyond weight loss.
History doesn’t always repeat but it often rhymes…
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Thank goodness Gary Taubes @garytaubes chose physics over medicine and then came from there to science journalism. His latest book www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre… is another masterpiece. His ability to research the history of the medical topics that interest him and to present the material with novelty, accuracy and clarity in a most engaging way, is of the highest quality.
I learned two crucial facts from his deep dive into the historical evolution of the management of diabetes of both types.
First, when insulin was discovered in 1921, it produced an instant miracle cure by saving the lives of those who were unable to produce any insulin, those with type 1 diabetes. But the honeymoon period lasted just 15-20 years after which insulin-treated diabetics began to present with premature atherosclerosis.
By which time, the prevailing opinion had become that this was caused by a diet too high in fat. For the life-saving insulin had to be innocent - Remember Semmelweis and the doctor-caused disease that he decribed.
Thus the prescribed treatment for diabetics of both types became a low-fat high-carbohydrate diet, just as was being prescribed to cardiac patients to prevent disease progression.
Second, Taubes made the telling point, overlooked by many, that one of two diets is prescribed to prevent atherosclerosis in normal persons and in those with diabetes. There are the fat substitution diet and the low-fat diet - and they act quite different especially in persons with insulin-resistance or type 2 diabetes.
In the fat substitution diet, saturated fats are replaced with polyunsaturated fats. There have been numerous long-term multi-million $ trials of this dietary intervention. They have all failed miserably to show benefit and some have caused harm openheart.bmj.com/content/8/2/e001680.
Thus we know that the fat substitution diet is a complete failure and may even be harmful.
In the low-fat diet, a large portion of the fat in the diet is replaced with carbohydrate. Whilst this diet may be acceptable for those who are not insulin-resistant, for those who are diabetic, it has to be the worst possible choice. Because, with time as the patient becomes progressively more insulin resistant, he/she will require ever larger doses of insulin to maintain blood glucose concentrations in a reasonable range. And didn't the problem of atherosclerosis first appear in middle-aged type 1 diabetics who had been treated with insulin for some decades?
Importantly there has never been a major multi-million $ trial of the effects of a low-fat high-carbohydrate diet on the development of atherosclerosis in otherwise health individuals. But there has been one such trial on weight loss and cardiovascular outcomes in diabetic patients - The LookAhead trial. The study was terminated after 9.5 years because it was considered "futile" to continue as there was no evidence that the diet produced any protection from coronary heart disease.
The point is that if you have diabetes, you're probably not best advised to adopt either a fat-substitution diet or a low-fat high-carbohydrate diet, since neither is likely to produce any health benefits and both could be harmful.
@BenBikmanPhD @zoeharcombe @bigfatsurprise @AKoutnik @LoreofRunning1 @sweatscience @drericwestman @markkaplan20 -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Thank goodness Gary Taubes @garytaubes chose physics over medicine and then came from there to science journalism. His latest book www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre… is another masterpiece. His ability to research the history of the medical topics that interest him and to present the material with novelty, accuracy and clarity in a most engaging way, is of the highest quality.
I learned two crucial facts from his deep dive into the historical evolution of the management of diabetes of both types.
First, when insulin was discovered in 1921, it produced an instant miracle cure by saving the lives of those who were unable to produce any insulin, those with type 1 diabetes. But the honeymoon period lasted just 15-20 years after which insulin-treated diabetics began to present with premature atherosclerosis.
By which time, the prevailing opinion had become that this was caused by a diet too high in fat. For the life-saving insulin had to be innocent - Remember Semmelweis and the doctor-caused disease that he decribed.
Thus the prescribed treatment for diabetics of both types became a low-fat high-carbohydrate diet, just as was being prescribed to cardiac patients to prevent disease progression.
Second, Taubes made the telling point, overlooked by many, that one of two diets is prescribed to prevent atherosclerosis in normal persons and in those with diabetes. There are the fat substitution diet and the low-fat diet - and they act quite different especially in persons with insulin-resistance or type 2 diabetes.
In the fat substitution diet, saturated fats are replaced with polyunsaturated fats. There have been numerous long-term multi-million $ trials of this dietary intervention. They have all failed miserably to show benefit and some have caused harm openheart.bmj.com/content/8/2/e001680.
Thus we know that the fat substitution diet is a complete failure and may even be harmful.
In the low-fat diet, a large portion of the fat in the diet is replaced with carbohydrate. Whilst this diet may be acceptable for those who are not insulin-resistant, for those who are diabetic, it has to be the worst possible choice. Because, with time as the patient becomes progressively more insulin resistant, he/she will require ever larger doses of insulin to maintain blood glucose concentrations in a reasonable range. And didn't the problem of atherosclerosis first appear in middle-aged type 1 diabetics who had been treated with insulin for some decades?
Importantly there has never been a major multi-million $ trial of the effects of a low-fat high-carbohydrate diet on the development of atherosclerosis in otherwise health individuals. But there has been one such trial on weight loss and cardiovascular outcomes in diabetic patients - The LookAhead trial. The study was terminated after 9.5 years because it was considered "futile" to continue as there was no evidence that the diet produced any protection from coronary heart disease.
The point is that if you have diabetes, you're probably not best advised to adopt either a fat-substitution diet or a low-fat high-carbohydrate diet, since neither is likely to produce any health benefits and both could be harmful.
@BenBikmanPhD @zoeharcombe @bigfatsurprise @AKoutnik @LoreofRunning1 @sweatscience @drericwestman @markkaplan20 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A new FDA-tracked pill promises to extend dogs' lives by improving their insulin sensitivity and lowering their insulin levels.
But if lower insulin is the key to a longer canine life, maybe our dogs shouldn't be eating carb-rich kibble in the first place.
The history of longevity trials — in Labrador retrievers, in rhesus monkeys — suggests that what they eat matters more than how much.
So why are we waiting for a drug to solve a problem that diet might already answer?
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/diet-or-dru… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Yes, we now have drugs for treating obesity, but are we making progress understanding it?
Is it really a "brain disorder," as Jeff Friedman of Rockefeller has said, a dysregulation of energy intake and expenditure?
Do we do the science any favors by burdening our thinking with the idea that calories-in, calories-out tells us anything about causality?
The History of a Very Bad Idea: Understanding Obesity Before Calories In and Out. open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/the-history… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The New Scientist article is the best I've seen yet on ketogenic diets for mental health conditions.
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
The ketogenic diet as a treatment for mental health conditions is getting even more attention from researchers, clinicians, and mainstream media!
New Scientist
@newscientist
You may think of the high-fat, low-carb eating plan as a faddish way to lose weight. But the keto diet is now being used to tackle conditions from severe depression to bipolar disorder and anorexia, with transformative results www.newscientist.com/article/2523421-why-the-keto-diet-co…
-
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
The ketogenic diet as a treatment for mental health conditions is getting even more attention from researchers, clinicians, and mainstream media!
New Scientist
@newscientist
You may think of the high-fat, low-carb eating plan as a faddish way to lose weight. But the keto diet is now being used to tackle conditions from severe depression to bipolar disorder and anorexia, with transformative results www.newscientist.com/article/2523421-why-the-keto-diet-co…
-
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Well, well, what do we have here? A study on carbohydrate fuelling before and during exercise is judged the 2025 research article with the best impact in the "elite" journal, the American Journal of Physiology, Cell Physiology. Now, why would the Editors choose, from amongst all the submissions to a world-leading journal publishing work on key advances in cellular biology, a publication from a usually peripheral (ie minor) discipline like sports science/sports nutrition for this prestigious award? Perhaps because we have shown, for the first time, the consequences of the existence of two separately-regulated glucose pools - the large and glucose pools - with different effects on human exercise performance.
Hopefully this recognition of the meaning of this paradigm shift for the understanding of glucose regulation in the human body, might slowly percolate into the discussion of how carbohydrates influence human exercise performance.
More science, less wrath (perhaps)
@PhilipPrins11 @akoutnik @PaulBLaursen @sweatscience @theplews1 @DrPhilMaffetone @TheNoakesF @Brady_H @drjamesdinic @zbitter @garytaubes @zoeharcombe @bigfatsurprise @LoreofRunning1 @lowcarbGP
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨 Boston Marathon carb fueling debates are raging: extremely high-carb intake? … or can minimal carb intake work?
Incredibly honored that our RCT on athlete fueling won @APSPhysiology 2025 BEST IMPACT PAPER (@AJPCellPhys) 🏆
We tested key scientific questions in Ironman-level athletes:
1️⃣ Does LCHF impair strenuous time-to-exhaustion performance?
2️⃣ Does just 10g/hr carbs (3.4g/20min — 6-12x below guidelines) improve performance? How?
3️⃣ What’s the keto-adaptation homeostasis timeline?
📜 Full article: journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/ajpcell.00583.2024
None of this happens without the incredible teamwork from @PhilipPrins11, @ProfTimNoakes, @DominicDAgosti2 & the whole crew who worked hard to push the evidence forward on how athletes should fuel. -
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
@garytaubes explains why he dislikes terms like "hyperpalatable" and that it is just used to complicate simple truths about nutrition.
Is it willpower or something more? Watch the full discussion. #nutrition #obesity -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
So my wife Jen has the highest cholesterol I have ever seen in 40 years of medicine (UK 19 USA>600) and features in this fab documentary #thecholesterolcode explains why I am not worried about this and why her cardiologist feels a statin is not needed WATCH THE FILM it’s on Amazon now!! @realDaveFeldman @nicknorwitz @janellison @ClareWilsonMed @ExpressGilo @RCGP
Dr Jen Unwin
@drjenunwin
Watched this tonight with @lowcarbGP !
So well done @realDaveFeldman and @wideeyetv
Proud to have been part of it.
Thanks to @DrScottMurray for the all clear too!
Love all the stories of hope and health @MichelleHurnRD @robynrdobbins @matthewbaszucki 🙌 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
In a Swedish study, meat consumption is associated with cognitive health in individuals with a genetic risk for Alzheimer's.
Does this mean eating meat protects against Alzheimer's?
Does it mean avoiding meat increases risk--i.e., should vegetarians worry that their diets are accelerating cognitive aging?
Another trip into the nuances of nutritional epidemiology and, particularly, the implications of the anti-randomization problem.
Brain Health vs. Heart Health? Is Eating Meat Good for Cognition but Bad for Our Arteries? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/brain-healt… -
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
Download, watch, share and review. Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
So inspiring and relatable. The medical gaslighting has to stop!
www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B0GS8ZFCYN -
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
🚨 🚨 🚨OUR DOCUMENTARY IS HERE 🚨 🚨 🚨
🎥 Our film The Cholesterol Code dropped on Amazon!
(Link next tweet)
🔥Personal stories of healing with keto
🔬New insights on Cholesterol
🫀Our groundbreaking study on heart disease
🙏 Please watch, share & leave an honest review! 🙏This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Conventional wisdom: GLP-1RA drugs cause weight loss by inhibiting appetite.
That assumption outruns the actual evidence.
An alternative hypothesis: GLP-1RAs reverse fuel-partitioning-- ↓fat storage, ↑ fat oxidation--& that inhibits appetite.
authors.elsevier.com/a/1mxcQ3jDgWxhOT -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
RFK Jr and the MAHA folks may have inverted the food guide pyramid, turning red meat and full-fat dairy back into health foods, but the @American_Heart is doubling down on the low-fat, plant-based advice it's been disseminating for decades.
Should we expect anything different from the organization that created the low-fat consensus 60+ years ago?
My latest Substack discusses the "one of us stinks" problem caused by challenging consensus science.
It also answers the question raised last week by @MaryanneDemasi, why won't the lipid hypothesis die?
The "One of Us Stinks" Problem: LDL, the Lipid Hypothesis, the AHA, and Humphrey Bogart open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/the-one-of-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
It is remarkable what happens when personal experience contradicts medical consensus.
Thanks, Chip.
Chip Joyce
@ChipActual
-
gary taubes reposted
Shebani Sethi, MD
@ShebaniMD
Our paper is now published in @NatMentHealth.
What began as curiosity in med school became a field I later named: metabolic psychiatry. 15+ years later, it's defining a new category of care.
@LabsMetabolism is translating this into patient care.
www.nature.com/articles/s44220-026-00609-5 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The @American_Heart is setting ever-lower LDL cholesterol limits and advocates testing at ever-lower ages.
If LDL is going up, diet is the first line of defense.
And what kind of diet? A diet that restricts saturated fat, of course.
60+ years into the diet-heart hypothesis, we're still living in an LDL-centric, SFA-restricted universe.
My skepticism is not about the nuances of the clinical trials but the history of the hypothesis and its competition.
LDL, Saturated Fat, and Heart Disease: Should We Worry? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/ldl-saturat… -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
To learn more about the clinical evidence discussed in this article and additional published research, visit our Foundational Clinical Trials page:
www.metabolicmind.org/resources/science/clinical-trials/ -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Big moment for metabolic psychiatry and ketogenic therapy for serious mental illness.
🔗www.nytimes.com/2026/03/17/well/eat/keto-mental-health-sc…
Today’s @nytimes piece highlights early research from Stanford University, The Ohio State University, and the University of Edinburgh — alongside the stories of individuals who have shared their lived experience here on Metabolic Mind.
This kind of visibility matters. It reflects years of work by researchers and clinicians like @ChrisPalmerMD, @ShebaniMD, and @IainCampbellPhD, research funded by @BaszuckiGroup, advocates like @janellison, as well as the many people who have been willing to share their personal stories.
Lived experience alone isn’t enough. Early data alone isn’t enough. But together, they point to something that must be tested, confirmed — or challenged — through high-quality science. That’s why we are excited about several RCTs currently completed or underway around the world.
We need to continue efforts to advance education, public awareness and research on a scale that will require public funding. That’s how medicine moves forward. And that’s the exciting work ahead. -
gary taubes reposted
Ankur Verma He/Him 🇮🇳
@anksv25
Was a pleasure to have @garytaubes on THE DESI EM PROJECT!
The full episode here - open.spotify.com/episode/2fndQSmzpcU8snSaWiKkHI?t=0&pi=Nr…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Prader-Willi syndrome is a rare chromosomal disorder characterized by pathological hunger and severe obesity.
150 years ago, John Langdon Down (the Down of Down's Syndrome) successfully treated the first recorded case of Prader-Willi Syndrome with an animal diet.
After years of weight gain despite calorie restriction and enforced exercise, his patient, E.C., lost 77 pounds in a year, eating (mostly) carnivore.
Can we learn anything from that about PWS?
PWS researchers assume, per the CW on obesity, that hunger causes the children afflicted to eat too much and that, of course, causes the fat accumulation.
But what if that's wrong, as the evidence has suggested since Down's experience?
If so, then the calorie-restricted diets considered standard of care for kids and adults with this syndrome may be doing more harm than good, as is the all-too-common assumption that all diets work by getting us to eat less.
Obesity researchers don't like to entertain the notion that they may be laboring under the wrong paradigm--energy balance--when they think about the cause of obesity. They find it boring, if not insulting, when we continue to suggest it. I can't entirely blame them.
In medicine, though, working from the wrong paradigm can have profound effects on therapy.
PWS is an extreme example.
Read more in my latest post on Uncertainty Principles.
Which comes first, Pathological Hunger or Obesity? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/which-comes… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Can a keto diet "cure" serious mental illness? Here's my piece published today in @sfchronicle.
"OPINION: Diagnosed with bipolar disorder, my son began a medically supervised ketogenic regimen — and it sent his symptoms into lasting remission, Jan Ellison Baszucki writes."
To read the full oped, just enter your email when prompted for the gift link:
www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/openforum/article/keto-diet-b…
In response to comments from HHS Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., I share our family's story about how after half a decade of illness, ketogenic therapy has kept my son's bipolar I disorder symptoms in remission since 2021. I include the latest on the emerging science and practice of this therapeutic approach.
"Has my son been 'cured'? It’s not a term we use in our work, and it’s also not the most important question. The more pressing concern is whether we are willing to rigorously test promising new treatment approaches when conventional care has failed far too many."
@Metabolic_Mind @ChrisPalmerMD @BaszuckiGroup @matthewbaszucki @DavidBaszucki @metcoalition @LWSchizophrenia -
gary taubes reposted
Ty Beal
@TyBealPhD
In this episode, Harvard professor and obesity researcher Dr. David Ludwig (@davidludwigmd) joins the show to discuss his new paper "Overcoming Impasse in Nutrition Science," published today in Cell Metabolism. Dr. Ludwig—author of the New York Times bestseller Always Hungry and one of the leading proponents of the carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity—uses the framework of science philosopher Thomas Kuhn to explain why paradigm clash in nutrition has stagnated into paralysis. We walk through the carbohydrate-insulin model versus the energy balance model, then dig into two highly cited clinical trials at the center of this debate: his group's 2018 BMJ feeding study and the 2021 Nature Medicine crossover trial—and why, despite publicly available data, the field has failed to resolve the competing claims from either study.
We then turn to what a path forward looks like: why ad hominem attacks poison the trust needed for collaboration, how professional societies and funders could incentivize adversarial collaboration between opposing researchers, and what a definitive long-term feeding study would need to look like to settle these foundational questions. Whether you follow the carbohydrate-insulin debate closely or just want to understand why nutrition experts can't seem to agree, this conversation is a candid call for humility, rigor, and scientific renewal.
Timestamps
00:00 Introduction to the Carbohydrate-Insulin Model
11:00 Debate and Polarization in Nutrition Science
17:28 Defining a Path Forward in Nutrition Research
25:40 Unraveling Scientific Discrepancies
33:50 Bridging Paradigms: The Need for Collaboration
39:39 The Role of Humility in Scientific Discourse
45:44 Towards Constructive Scientific EngagementThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The word paradigm has become devalued over the decades as every minor shift in thought is sold as a paradigm shift.
In this case, it's precisely the correct word. @davidludwigmd discusses the implications for nutrition science in Cell Metabolism
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Why do debates on critical questions in nutrition – from the harms of sugar to the cause of obesity – drag on for decades, leaving science at a standstill?
I explore this question through the lens of science philosopher Thomas Kuhn.
@Cell_Metabolism
Free article link below👇 -
gary taubes reposted
ExpedientFictioner
@PlaceboFoods
@garytaubes @bigfatsurprise not sure if you’re following but pretty solid vindication
-
gary taubes reposted
Coalition for Metabolic Health
@metcoalition
At the Coalition for Metabolic Health, we're working to address America's chronic disease crisis. Learn more about our mission to make metabolic health mainstream—and hear directly from some of our experts—in our new video:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
RFK Jr's new Food Guide Pyramid doesn't just flip the old one on its head--promoting red meat and dairy like they're, well, healthy 😬 -- but it embraces a different paradigm of nutrition.
No longer are saturated fats and cholesterol the focus, but refined carbohydrates, sugars, and blood sugar.
Larry Rifkin and I had fun discussing this.
Larry Rifkin's America Trends podcast 🎙
@trendspodcast
EP 945 The New Food Pyramid Differs in Significant Ways from the Previous One www.americatrendspodcast.com/2026/02/23/ep-945-the-new-fo… via @trendspodcast
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We've been hearing about the "replication crisis" in science for 20 years now, and NIH director Jay Bhattacharya describes it as a "disaster." He has a prescription for fixing it that involves incentivizing researchers to replicate the latest findings and making it easier to publish the results, positive or negative.
I think the world of Bhattacharya, but I think he's misunderstanding the fundamental nature of science here. Not that his solution might not help, a little, but I think the problem starts far upstream of the publications.
See my latest Substack for the details.
And if you like what you read and you want to support my work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber.
If Most Research Publications are Just Wrong, is that a Disaster? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/if-most-res… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Obesity Isn’t “Complex” If You Start With The Right Paradigm
Checkout my susbstack for more science and health insights: uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com
#nutritionscience #metabolichealth #obesityresearch #insulinresistance #sugar #healtheducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Chris Palmer sets the record straight.
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
When people hear “diet,” they often think of wellness influencers. When they hear "cure," they're even more skeptical.
Ketogenic therapies are not a wellness trend. They are medical interventions that alter core biology, including mitochondrial function, neurotransmitter activity, insulin signaling, inflammation, the gut microbiome, and brain energy metabolism.
The ketogenic diet has long been established as an effective treatment for epilepsy, capable of stopping seizures even when medications fail.
A growing body of research suggests that ketogenic therapies may also benefit some individuals with serious mental illnesses, including depression, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia—sometimes resulting in sustained remission of symptoms.
I personally do not describe this as a “cure”; the word "remission" is fine with me.
For those who achieve remission after years of suffering, it can feel like nothing short of a miracle—regardless of the underlying mechanism.
Let's work together to reduce the suffering and improve the lives of people living with mental illness. -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Recent @nytimes coverage of HHS Secretary Kennedy’s comments has brought renewed attention to the potential of ketogenic therapy for conditions like schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.
🔗Explore the current clinical evidence and ongoing trials: www.metabolicmind.org/resources/science/clinical-trials/
This conversation revolves around the quality of the evidence supporting keto as an intervention for serious mental illness.
The study and use of ketogenic therapy for these psychiatric conditions is rapidly expanding. Many living with serious mental illnesses report that the state of ketosis is associated with symptom improvement.
Published pilot studies from institutions like Stanford University (Bipolar and Schizophrenia), the University of Edinburgh (Bipolar), and The Ohio State University (Major Depressive Disorder) have shown that nutritional ketosis is associated with improvements across a range of psychiatric and metabolic measures.
And the research continues with anticipated results from completed randomized controlled trials from James Cook University in Australia and UCSF in California, later this year.
To be kept up to date on current and upcoming research and clinical developments in ketogenic and metabolic therapies for mental health, sign up at Metabolic Mind. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
For the past decade, @nytimes has been resolutely resistant (knee-jerk?) to reporting on the emerging science of the ketogenic diet.
But if RFK Jr gets behind it, then it becomes a story.
Now the paper of record can use keto and its potentially remarkable efficacy for treating cognitive disorders as more ammo against RFK Jr.
Vitally important research would have been damned by association, but luckily the story didn't stop there...
RFK Jr Gives the NY Times Reason to Write About Keto and Schizophrenia. Good News? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/rfk-jr-give… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The evidence linking salt to hypertension gets messy fast.
A real scientist doesn’t say “there’s no evidence” when the debate is still alive.
#nutritionscience #hearthealth #hypertension #saltintake #sciencecommunication #criticalthinking #healthdebate #evidencebased #medicalresearch #publichealth -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Obesity Question Science Keeps Dodging
One hypothesis keeps showing up across multiple fields: obesity is not just about eating too much. When researchers connect appetite, insulin, and metabolism, the old story starts to crack.
#nutritionscience #metabolism #insulin #obesityresearch #healthpodcast #evidencebased #sciencetalk #nutritionThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ultra-processed foods don’t affect everyone the same way.
If it’s not just “eating too much,” what is driving fat storage for some people?
#nutrition #metabolichealth #weightloss #fatloss #insulinresistance #processedfoods #healthscience #dietmyths #obesity #healthyhabits -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Carbs, Insulin, And Why Weight Can Shift Fast
The carb–insulin model says it’s not just “eat less.” It’s how carbs drive insulin, and how insulin influences fat storage vs. fat burning. That’s why some people drop weight quickly when they cut carbs.
#nutrition #weightloss #insulin #ketodiet #metabolichealth #lowcarb #healthscience #dietdebate #fatloss #wellness -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Isn’t The Carnivore Diet Studied More Seriously
A fair question: if a growing subgroup reports doing well on an all-meat approach, why isn’t it studied with the same curiosity as other diets? Good science should investigate anomalies, not dismiss them as “fad” by default.
#nutrition #carnivorediet #dietresearch #evidencebased #metabolichealth #scientificmethod #healthscience #foodscience #wellness #criticalthinkingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This should be interesting. 🤞
@camjenglish
Why do we get fat: overeating/no exercise? Does bacon cause heart attacks?
Join Dr. Whitfield Lewis @whitfieldlewis6 and me to break down @garytaubes Good Calories, Bad Calories. Bring your questions—and arguments. Friday, 5 pm eastern.
x.com/i/spaces/1BRJjgwomZoxw -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When isolated populations began consuming Western staples like sugar and white flour, chronic diseases like obesity, diabetes, and heart disease appeared to rise.
#nutrition #metabolichealth #ultraprocessedfoods #sugar #publichealth #chronicdisease #foodscience #healtheducation #wellness #dietquality -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
🧵@DavidLudwigMD & @GaryTaubes on the new Dietary Guidelines
The Dietary Guidelines for Americans just got an update, and for the first time, we’re seeing real movement on key issues.
Here’s what stood out most ⬇️ -
gary taubes reposted
Peter Ballerstedt
@GrassBased
One answer is biochemical, the other is budgetary.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Low Carb Beat Low Fat In Clinical Trials
Early head to head trials compared a carb restricted, higher fat “eat more” approach vs a low fat, calorie restricted plan.
The surprising result: the low carb group often lost more weight and improved several heart risk markers.
#nutrition #lowcarb #lowfat #weightloss #hearthealth #clinicaltrials #metabolichealth #healtheducation #evidencebased #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Calories In vs Out Explains “That” Weight Changed, Not “Why”
Energy balance is real, but it’s not a full explanation. Like saying someone got rich because they spent less than they earned, it’s true but misses the mechanism.
#metabolichealth #nutrition #weightloss #energybalance #calories #thermodynamics #healthscience #obesity #wellness #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Are Vegetables Healthy Or Just A Proxy?
#nutrition #healthresearch #evidencebased #publichealth #diet #healthyeating #metabolichealth #foodscience #criticalthinking #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ok, I admit, I love this...
Thanks @BumpkinNobody for the meticulous update. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Type 1 vs Type 2 Diabetes Explained Simply
#diabetes #type1diabetes #type2diabetes #insulinresistance #bloodsugar #metabolichealth #healtheducation #endocrinology #wellness #patienteducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Can Diet Play A Role In Diabetes Remission?
A growing conversation is exploring how nutrition may impact metabolic health and long-term outcomes. Individual needs vary, so any major dietary changes should always be guided by a qualified healthcare professional.
#diabetesawareness #metabolichealth #nutritionmatters #bloodsugarbalance #healtheducation #lifestylemedicine -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Before Insulin Changed Everything
Before insulin, high-fat, low-carb diets showed remarkable results for diabetes. Then medicine took a different turn. History matters when we rethink health.
#diabeteshistory #metabolichealth #lowcarb #ketoscience #nutritionscience #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Root Of Insulin Resistance
#insulinresistance #metabolichealth #bloodsugar #type2diabetes #nutrition #liverhealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Insulin Changed Diabetes Treatment Forever
Before insulin, diet was the treatment. After insulin, diet became secondary.
This shift still shapes how diabetes is managed today and why the debate around food, carbs, and medication never really ended.
#diabetes #type2diabetes #insulin #metabolichealth #bloodsugar #nutritionscience #lowcarb #keto #healthhistory #chronicdiseaseThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I don't know how I missed this Levels podcast with me, but it's one of my favorites.
Very much worth watching (or so I think, for what that's worth).
Why Nutrition Science Got It WRONG & the Case for the Carb-Insulin Model... youtu.be/74WAhHgEk_0 via @YouTube -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We know that nutritional ketosis can put type 2 diabetes into remission, as can a low-carb, low-calorie diet.
How about zero carbs and carnivore? Can that do better?
Can an all-meat diet cure type 2 diabetes?
More Tales from Carnivore History: the All-Meat Diet and Diabetes open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/more-tales-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Diabetes Went From Rare to Everywhere
Once uncommon. Now affecting tens of millions.
The rise of diabetes didn’t happen slowly and it shouldn’t be ignored.
#diabetes #publichealth #chronicdisease #metabolichealth #healthtrends #modernmedicine #medicalawarenessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Are We Really Treating Diabetes or Just Managing It
Longer lives. Higher costs. The same complications.
It may be time to question whether medication-first is really the answer for type 2 diabetes.
#diabetes #metabolichealth #healthcare #preventivemedicine #nutrition #chronicillness #medicalinsightThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Question That Exposes a Flawed Diabetes Model
If carbs drive the problem, why keep prescribing the antidote instead of removing the cause?
Sometimes progress starts with asking the obvious question medicine avoids.
#metabolichealth #diabeteseducation #nutritionscience #healthperspective #functionalmedicineThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The First Real Diabetes Breakthrough Was Dietary
#diabetes #metabolichealth #nutritionhistory #lowcarb #healthinsights #medicalhistory #functionalmedicineThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Our study published today academic.oup.com/edrv/advance-article/doi/10.1210/endrev/…
I began researching this topic of carbs and exercise performance 50 years ago. This study is the result of collaborations with @PhilipPrins11's team at @GroveCityCollege over the past 9 years. This article was 5 years in production. Sometimes it takes a bit of time to realise how wrong one has been for more than 3 decades. @LoreofRunning1 @AKoutnik @sweatscience @zoeharcombe @PaulBLaursen @theplews1 @CarynZinn @bigfatsurprise @grantsnz @DrAseemMalhotra @FructoseNo @garytaubes @lowcarbGP @TheNoakesF @BenBikmanPhD @drjasonfung
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨Our Landmark Sport Nutrition Analysis in Endocrine Reviews — spanning 100+ years & ~600 studies🔬— challenges the foundations of the sports nutrition industry & guidelines, exposing potential harm to athletes' health.
This is the most comprehensive pub on nutrition's impact on performance (5+ years in the making). What we found is critical to athletes, coaches, dieticians, and the scientists who write guidelines with FREE study link below:
1) 🍞"Carb-loading" is misguided?
Current sport nutrition guidelines (i.e., @ACSMNews, @IntSocietySN, @Gatorade Sport Science Institute) recommend 5–12 g/kg CHO/day and 60–90 g CHO/hour. What does that mean?
📈This can push some athletes to over 1000 carbohydrates/day. Multiple meta-analyses in the report revealed that sport nutrition guidelines have over-emphasized muscle glycogen and carbohydrate oxidation levels...yet these metrics didn't consistently align with performance... so what metric predicts performance?
See #2. 👇
2)🧠Primary performance driver? Sustaining total brain energy (glucose + ketones + lactate)—not muscle glycogen or carb oxidation.
In >160 sports performance studies, 88% showed that carb intake only benefits performance when blood glucose plummeted in the placebo group, triggering early fatigue in non-carb athletes due to brain energy deficit. Carbs maintained blood glucose and brain energy, and this out-predicted every other metric. Yet, the brain's role has been sidelined in sports nutrition, ignoring evidence since the 1920s of its pivotal impact on performance.
3)🔥High carbohydrate intake paradoxically accelerates glycogen breakdown and suppresses fat oxidation during exercise.
This contradicts many of the sports nutrition marketing claims promoting high levels of carbohydrate supplementation (60-120g/hour) to "spare" muscle glycogen AND evidence showing that higher fat oxidation correlates with better performance.
4)🫀Health risks of sports nutrition guidelines? Emergent evidence has demonstrated that high-carbohydrate intake can lead to prediabetes in a percentage of athletes. This analysis also reveals that current sport nutrition guidelines' carbohydrate intake levels create a metabolic environment during exercise analogous to diabetes:
-⬆️circulating insulin
-⬇️fat oxidation
-⬆️glycogen breakdown
-🔒forced reliance on glucose as fuel
This is critical. We show that athletes ARE NOT immune to the metabolic problems driven by the food environment.
5)🥵Ketogenic athletes CAN "bonk" too...but not if they fuel correctly.
Contrary to claims, athletes on ketogenic diets can and do bonk—like on high-carb diets—due to dropping blood glucose. The lack of strategic carbohydrate placement was a mistake many keto-athletes made when trying to reach their peak performance. Small targeted brain-fuel supplements (10g/hour) during exercise boost peak performance without high-carb loads.
After 4-week adaptation, ketogenic performance equals high-carb performance...but BOTH high and low-carb athletes benefit from ~10g/hour carbs to maintain glucose/brain energy for exercise >60 minutes in duration, improving performance 22%. It will be interesting to see how other brain fuels can also assist (ketones and lactate).
🔗FREE Study Link: doi.org/10.1210/endrev/bnaf038
📣CONCLUSIONS: This landmark analysis challenges over half a century of scientific assumptions in sports nutrition—and explains how they became embedded in official guidelines—with implications reaching beyond elite athletes to public health and chronic disease prevention.
Please share this widely with athletes, coaches, dietitians, and scientists to help optimize not just peak performance, but lifelong health. 🤝 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Obesity Theory That Shaped Everything
For over a century, obesity has been framed as a simple “calories in vs calories out” problem. But that assumption shaped decades of blame, bias, and oversimplification. What if the root issue was never that simple?
#nutrition #obesityscience #metabolichealth #healthmyths #medicalhistory #hormonalhealth #publichealth #wellnesseducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Diet Advice We Forgot (And Paid For)
For decades, carbs were already known to drive weight gain...then we rewrote the rules.
#nutritionscience #diethistory #lowcarb #metabolichealth #healtheducation #foodtruth #wellnessconversation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why “Calories In vs Calories Out” Falls Apart Over Time
Even a tiny daily imbalance adds up over years and no human can track calories with that level of precision. The math exposes the flaw in the energy balance model.
#metabolism #weightscience #healtheducation #nutritionmyths #caloriemyth #longtermhealth #humanbiology -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Fat Gain Isn’t Random. It’s Hormonal.
Calories don’t explain where fat shows up.
Hormones do. Puberty proves it.
#hormones #metabolism #fatlosstruth #healtheducation #endocrinology #weightscience #humanbiologyThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Fat Was Blamed for the Wrong Problem
#nutrition #metabolichealth #insulinresistance #lowcarb #healthscience #dietmyths #functionalmedicine #wellness #healtheducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Funding Shapes the Outcome
Progress requires testing ideas honestly, even when the evidence says no.
#scienceintegrity #researchbias #evidencebased #criticalthinking #nutritionscience #scientificmethodThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Failed Hypotheses Don’t Make Headlines
That’s a real problem for scientific progress.
#scienceintegrity #diabetesresearch #criticalthinking #evidenceovernarrative #medicalresearch #scientificmethod #healthscience -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Science Can’t Be Fully Tested
#science #criticalthinking #nutritionscience #researchbias #evidencebased #medicaldebate #dataintegrity -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Nutrition Studies Get It Wrong
Big health studies often confuse correlation with cause. Who you are matters just as much as what you eat. Understanding the data changes everything.
#nutritionscience #healthresearch #evidencebased #wellnesstruth #medicalstudies #datamatters #functionalmedicine #metabolichealth #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Consensus Silences Better Science
When dissent is ignored, progress stalls. Real breakthroughs happen when questioning is allowed, not punished.
#sciencedebate #criticalthinking #innovation #scientificintegrity #questioneverythingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What do membership in a fringe religious cult, stress-reduction, and RFK Jr.'s new Dietary Guidelines for Americans have in common?
Maybe not what you think.
My latest Substack should clarify.
MAHA's New Dietary Guidelines, Pluribus, and the "Moonie Steve" Thought Experiment -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Are We Solving Diabetes With an Incomplete Puzzle?
#diabetes #healthscience #medicalhistory #nutritiondebate #criticalthinking #healthpolicyThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Science Becomes Dogma
When careers, funding, and guidelines reward one narrative, real scientific debate disappears.
Progress requires intellectual honesty, not conformity.
#nutritiondebate #scienceandpolicy #healthguidelines #criticalthinking #medicalethics #dietscienceThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Long before modern drugs, diabetes was managed through strict diet, and it worked. History reminds us that treatment didn’t always start with medication.
#diabeteshistory #metabolichealth #nutritionmatters #medicalhistory #healthinsights #functionalmedicineThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Great science starts with humility. Question your assumptions, hold your ideas lightly, and remember how easy it is to fool yourself.
#science #criticalthinking #intellectualhumility #scientificmethod #learning #truthseeking -
gary taubes reposted
Coalition for Metabolic Health
@metcoalition
Today, @HHSGov and @USDA released the 2025-2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans, returning to a diet based on whole foods from plant and animal sources. The new pyramid opens the door to a revolution in American nutrition. Read our reaction: coalitionformetabolichealth.org/news/coalition-for-metabo…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When Treatment Replaces the Root Cause
When medication is used to offset diet, short-term fixes can create long-term consequences, especially in children. A conversation worth having.
#metabolichealth #insulin #diabetesawareness #nutritionmatters #rootcausemedicine #preventivehealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Treat The Symptom Instead Of Removing The Cause?
#diabetes #metabolichealth #nutritiontruth #healthdiscussion #insulin #chronicdisease #functionalmedicine -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Ultra-Processed Food and Obesity
How robust is the definition?
How reliable are the clinical trials?
My coauthors and I address these questions in two new papers.
Free Share Link access:
@Cell_Metabolism authors.elsevier.com/a/1mOs85WXUlaZ0F
@NatureMedicine
rdcu.be/eXM4A -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Better Diabetes Tech Isn’t Fixing The Problem
#diabetes #metabolichealth #healthcare #chronicdisease #medicaltechnology #publichealth #healthinsightsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Nutrition Science We Chose to Ignore
Groundbreaking nutrition and medical research existed long before WWII but history decided what science we kept and what we buried.
#nutritionscience #medicalhistory #healthtruth #sciencedebate #criticalthinkingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Weight Gain Isn’t Just About Overeating
Excess weight isn’t always explained by how much someone eats. Once fat accumulation crosses a threshold, it becomes a metabolic disease with real physiological consequences, not a moral failure.
#metabolichealth #obesityscience #healtheducation #medicalinsight #nutritiontruths -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Just because two things move together doesn’t mean one caused the other. Observation is not explanation and good science knows the difference.
#criticalthinking #sciencecommunication #correlationvscausation #researchliteracy #dataanalysis #medicalthinking -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Interesting and not surprising.
Are there other RCTs, though, that reproduce or show the opposite?
Alex Leaf
@Alexleaf
Per Table 3, the fruit group had a 3-unit increase in BMI and 4-cm increase in waist circumference over the 6 month intervention, compared to 2-unit and 7-cm decreases in the control group. The fruit group gained 7 kg of body weight while the control group lost 6.5 kg.
So, no, not same calories or same BMI. This study showed that weight gain worsens liver and metabolic markers. This study absolutely did not isolate an effect on fruit. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Long before modern diet debates, low-carb was mainstream medicine.
History matters when we talk about obesity today.
#nutritionhistory #metabolichealth #lowcarb #healtheducation #obesityscience #medicalhistoryThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Two people can eat the same and look completely different. Biology isn’t one-size-fits-all.
#metabolichealth #bodydiversity #nutritionscience #genetics #healtheducation #humanbiology -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Both the semi-starved ob/ob mouse and the once "Not Thin Peter" Attia teach us a lot about what it means (if anything) to overeat, and how fat tissue is regulated independently of how much we eat (the mouse) and exercise (@PeterAttiaMD).
This is a post I've put off writing for awhile, but...
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/whats-it-me… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What Spinal Injuries Reveal About Fat Storage
#metabolichealth #neuroscience #humanbiology #healthscience #obesityresearch #medicaleducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Fat Distribution Isn’t Just About Calories
Nerve signaling plays a bigger role in fat storage than most people realize. Biology matters more than assumptions.
#metabolichealth #neuroscience #obesityscience #healtheducation #humanbiology #medicalinsightsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What Happened When He Cut One Food
Sometimes change isn’t about willpower. It’s about removing the right variable and letting biology do the rest.
#nutritionscience #weightlossjourney #lowcarb #metabolichealth #healthinsights #dietarychoices -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Hunger Isn’t Always The Cause Of Weight Gain
Sometimes growth drives appetite, not the other way around. When biology leads, behavior follows.
#metabolichealth #nutritionscience #hormonesandhealth #obesityscience #healtheducation #rootcauseThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why “They’re Overeating” Is A Flawed Assumption
Weight gain isn’t proof of overeating. When we confuse outcomes with causes, we miss the real problem.
#metabolichealth #nutritionscience #healthmyths #criticalthinking #weightstigma #medicalinsights -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Before Insulin, Diet Was The Treatment
Long before insulin, doctors treated diabetes by removing the carbs.
#diabeteshistory #nutritionscience #metabolichealth #lowcarb #medicalhistory #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Sugar Went From Luxury To Health Crisis
As sugar became cheap and everywhere, diabetes followed the same curve. History matters.
#publichealth #diabetesawareness #nutritionhistory #sugarconsumption #healtheducation #foodindustry #metabolichealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Two Paths Most Patients Are Never Shown
Comfort now or responsibility first. Both have consequences.
#metabolichealth #type2diabetes #healthchoices #preventivemedicine #nutritioneducation #longtermhealth #lifestylemedicineThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Treating Carbs Like An Allergy Changes Everything
If you can’t metabolize something safely, managing the symptoms isn’t the solution.
#metabolichealth #nutritionscience #diabetesdiscussion #lowcarb #healtheducation #preventivehealth #foodandhealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If carbs create the problem and insulin treats it… why not remove the carbs?
Sometimes the simplest question changes everything.
#metabolichealth #insulinresistance #nutritiontruth #healtheducation #chronicdisease #preventivehealth #functionalmedicine #healthperspectiveThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Historic hospital records show a time when diabetes was nearly nonexistent. Today, it affects millions.
The question isn’t if things changed, it’s what did.
#diabetes #publichealth #medicalhistory #chronicdisease #healthtrends #metabolichealth #healthcareinsights #preventivehealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The American Diabetes Association still thinks MDs should be cautious about using low carb/keto diets even for type 2 diabetes.
Why trust anyone who argues otherwise?
Diet or Drugs for Diabetes? Which Comes First? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/diet-or-dru… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How “Low-Fat” Foods Quietly Became Sugar Bombs
When fat was labeled the enemy, the food industry replaced it with sugar to keep products tasty, turning “heart-healthy” foods into high-sugar traps. A reminder that nutrition trends can mislead, and labels don’t always tell the full story.
#nutritionfacts #foodindustry #healthmyths #lowfatdiet #sugartruth #dietculture #metabolism #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Two Diet Theories Everyone Gets Wrong...Here’s What Actually Matters
Most diets boil down to two ideas: eat less to burn more… or lower insulin to change how your body stores fat. Same goal, completely different biology. Understanding the difference is the first step to choosing what actually works for you.
#nutritionscience #metabolism #insulinresistance #dietmyths #healtheducation #weightlossscienceThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
It's exciting to see this important research underway at @ClevelandClinic. Adding metabolic health markers to the Cleveland Clinic Brain Study could open new avenues for understanding and treating neurological conditions.
Baszucki Group
@BaszuckiGroup
Cleveland Clinic Neurological Institute and Baszucki Group Team Up to Advance Landmark Brain Study with Metabolic Health Markers: The collaboration seeks to study gut-brain connections in neurological disorders.
Baszucki Group today announced an expanded commitment to the landmark @ClevelandClinic Brain Study. Launched in 2022, this ambitious longitudinal study plans to follow healthy individuals over a 20-year period with the goal of identifying early disease markers and therapeutic targets needed to prevent and ultimately cure neurological diseases. The commitment from Baszucki Group brings their total donation to the study to $450,000.
Baszucki Group’s support has expanded the scope of the Cleveland Clinic Brain Study to include biomarkers from stool samples–a key assessment that could reveal the relationship between the gut and brain and how this connection influences disease risk. This data will help researchers explore how metabolic health relates to brain function, an area of priority for Baszucki Group.
“By including these additional assessments, the Brain Study is taking a critical step towards understanding the brain within the context of the whole body,” said @janellison, co-founder and president of Baszucki Group. “This broad, holistic approach to data gathering is key, as it maximizes the possibility of revealing the underlying factors that contribute to neurological dysfunction and uncovering potential treatment options.”
Learn more or enroll in the study: cle.clinic/4rHltyF
Read the full press release: bwnews.pr/4pvFoiF -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
A new meta-analysis of 174 randomized controlled trials on “carbohydrate-restricted diets” found consistent benefits for body composition, blood pressure, inflammation, and more. But instead of highlighting the metabolic benefits, most of the headlines focused almost entirely on a small bump in LDL.
In this video, @bschermd breaks down why that reaction misses the point, and how biases in nutrition reporting are holding back real progress in improving metabolic health.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What If Obesity Isn’t About Eating Too Much at All?
We’ve been taught to blame overeating, but what if the real issue is hormonal regulation, not willpower? Rethinking obesity means rethinking the entire story we've been told for decades.
#metabolichealth #hormonehealth #obesityresearch #wellnesseducation #healthfacts #nutritionscience -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Diabetes Guidelines Drifted Away From Diet Science
For decades, diabetes guidelines shaped behavior without properly testing diet itself. When beliefs replace evidence, millions pay the price.
#diabetes #nutritionscience #metabolichealth #healthpolicy #medicalresearch #evidencebasedmedicine -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
But, Nina, "experts recommend" against it.
Along these lines, a far more thoughtful editorial, by Danish nutritionist Arne Astrup, just appeared in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
I'd trust Astrup on the state of the evidence before the NYT. He cares that he's been wrong before. NYT reporters, not so much.
ajcn.nutrition.org/article/S0002-9165(25)00675-6/abstract
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
I talked to this reporter for an hour. I explained that the most rigorous data on saturated fats are long-term clinical trials showing NO effect of these fats on total mortality, cardiovascular mortality.
I also sent this reporter via email all the systematic reviews and meta-analyses on these fats, which overwhelmingly vindicate them or at the very least suggest the science is completely unsettled. This strongly suggests that population-wide guidelines are not warranted, as nearly 2 dozen systematic reviews have concluded over the past decade.
The only way to continue to condemn these fats is to ignore the long-term, most rigorous evidence on them. If you see this evidence and still ignore it, what is the excuse? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
You Can’t Pill Your Way Out of a Carb Problem
If the issue is how the body responds to carbs, no pill can fix it without consequences. Sometimes the simplest solution is the hardest one to accept.
#nutrition #metabolichealth #lowcarb #healtheducation #wellness #sciencebasedThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Uhhmm, did somebody say "no starches, no sugar?"
Now that's interesting.
Andrew D. Huberman, Ph.D.
@hubermanlab
Lifts 2hrs a day, 5am start, 7 days a week. Before work begins… and no starches, no sugar, 84 years old, cognitively and physically strong… the Mighty Twyla Tharp.
On the Huberman Lab podcast out now. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Insulin Changed the Way We Eat... and Not Always for the Better
The history of diabetes shows how treatment shaped diet itself.
#diabeteshistory #nutritionscience #metabolichealth #publichealth #medicalhistory #healtheducation #wellnessinsightsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Original Diabetes Treatment Was Basically Keto
Sometimes history already had the answer.
#diabetes #keto #lowcarb #healthhistory #nutritionscience #metabolism #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
I simply do not understand how the most strident lipidologists on X simply ignore these data as if they do not exist. Perhaps it's because the key treatment for managing type 2 diabetes is dietary change; whereas the treatment for a "raised" cholesterol is a lucrative drug, the sale of which makes the lives of many lipidologists immeasurably happier. @LDLSkeptic @DrAseemMalhotra @MaryanneDemasi @zoeharcombe
Robert Lufkin MD
@robertlufkinmd
Diabetes and smoking
rather than cholesterol
are the biggest risk factors
for heart disease. -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
A new meta-analysis published in JAMA Psychiatry examined 50 different keto studies, totaling over 40,000 participants, that included depression and anxiety outcomes.
The results?
Modest improvement in depression symptoms across different populations and diagnoses in both controlled and real-world scenarios
Greater symptom improvement was observed in trials that included ketone monitoring.
A larger effect was seen in “very low carbohydrate” diets compared to just “low carbohydrate” diets.
Improvements in anxiety were also observed in most studies, but with less consistency than depressive symptoms.
In this video, @bretschermd breaks down findings from this study and what the results mean for psychiatry.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Thanks so much Martin @MartinJames888. I've been richly rewarded for taking the stands I have. Our physiological research since 2017 with @PhilipPrins11 and @AKoutnik has produced what I think will be our most significant legacy showing that exercise performance is not carbohydrate-dependent. So the push to have all athletes eat high carbohydrate diets on a daily basis has been proved to be inappropriate and unnecessary advice. Our proof is presented in the review article shortly to be released by Endocrine Reviews, sometime this month. @PaulBLaursen @BenBikmanPhD @davidludwigmd @garytaubes @zoeharcombe @bigfatsurprise @CarynZinn @sweatscience
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Diabetes Guidelines Ignore the Only Diet That Consistently Works
Is it time to rethink what “standard of care” actually means?
#diabetes #healthscience #nutrition #lowcarb #keto #healthfacts #wellness #diettipsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Cutting Carbs Can Lead to Rapid Weight Loss
Carbohydrates impact fat gain differently than calories alone.
For people who gain weight easily, removing carbs often leads to weight loss because fat and protein don’t trigger the same metabolic response.
How you replace those calories matters.
#weightloss #nutrition #lowcarb #metabolism #healthtips #fitness #fatloss -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Wild History of Diagnosing Diabetes
#diabetes #medicalhistory #healthfacts #endocrinology #wellnesseducation -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Proud to highlight this partnership with @ProfDeannaK, a Metabolic Mind Clinical Advisor, and the work being done to build capacity for metabolic therapy in mental health treatment.
Watch our video to learn how this initiative will empower practitioners: www.youtube.com/watch?v=bzpSQop4Mhw
Baszucki Group
@BaszuckiGroup
Baszucki Group is proud to announce a partnership with @UMmedschool for an innovative training initiative that will build capacity for delivering ketogenic metabolic therapy in mental health care.
Led by @ProfDeannaK, this initiative aims to educate and empower practitioners by guiding them in adopting the intervention themselves. The aim is to prepare a variety of healthcare professionals to safely and confidently incorporate this promising personalized metabolic treatment framework in both clinical and research settings.
This program is part of a continued commitment by Baszucki Group to expand access to metabolic therapies for patients with serious mental illness by supporting key research and capacity-building projects. “Our hope is that the information gathered from this model will be used to shape the future development and expansion of similar programs globally,” said Julie Milder, PhD, Director of Neuroscience at Baszucki Group.
Read the full press release: bwnews.pr/4pNrfNu -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Calories Aren’t the Whole Story, Insulin Controls Fat Storage
#metabolism #insulin #weightlossscience #hormonalhealth #diabeteseducation #fatlosstips #healthscience #nutritionfacts -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Fat storage isn’t controlled by willpower or workouts alone.
#metabolism #weightlossscience #hormones #insulinresistance #fatlosstips #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Our world is full of agents that may (or may not) kill us prematurely or inflict grievous harm: cell phones, vaccines, chemical toxins, pick your poison.
But the evidence that fuels our anxieties manifests a familiar pattern: It look like exactly what you'd expect from pathological science, or "the science of things that aren't so."
It's why some of us remain hopelessly skeptical that these are legitimate fears.
Signs of Bad Science open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/signs-of-ba… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Danger Behind Lowering Blood Sugar Too Fast
Understanding the difference between Type 1 and Type 2 insulin needs is critical.
#diabeteseducation #healthfacts #insulinresistance #medicaltruths #bloodsugarhealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Old Diabetes Tests Missed the Real Problem
Understanding these gaps changes everything about how we view diabetes today.
#diabetesawareness #healtheducation #metabolichealth #bloodsugarscience #functionalmedicineThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Diabetes Breakthrough That Saved Millions… and the Myth It Accidentally Created
#diabeteseducation #healthfacts #type2diabetes #medicalhistory #insulin #healthawarenessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
GuyNAustin©
@GuyNAustin
Delighted to find this on Audible. Some of my favorite points in @garytaubes' _The Case Against Sugar_ were direct quotations of Mintz.
www.audible.com/pd/Sweetness-and-Power-Audiobook/B071G1VPGH -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Diabetes Pioneer Who Proved Fat Could Heal
#diabetescare #metabolichealth #nutritionscience #lowcarblifestyle #healtheducation #wellnessfacts #bloodsugarcontrol #functionalhealth -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Insulin Advice Went Wrong for 90% of Patients
Understanding the difference between insulin resistance and insulin deficiency can change everything.
#nutritionfacts #metabolichealth #diabetesawareness #healtheducation #insulinresistance #lowcarblifestyle #bloodsugarcontrol #functionalmedicineThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
T1D vegan study with no glucose control outcome???
Yes...you expect low carb and vegetarian/vegan to reduce insulin requirements from standard diet approaches (for opposite reasons).
HOWEVER, the MAJOR limitation of a vegetarian/vegan approach are that carbs glucose kinetics DO NOT match injectable insulin kinetics. Carbs are 3-4x faster than the most rapid injectable insulin....and it just so happens that this study doesnt report glycemic control?!?!
Glycemic control is the #1 risk factor...
bmcnutr.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40795-025-011… -
gary taubes reposted
The Broken Science Initiative
@broken_science
Gary Taubes joins the Trust Issues crew this Tuesday at 4:30PM EST on The Broken Science Initiative YouTube Channel. (Plus, special guest Bob Kaplan!)
-
gary taubes reposted
د. صالح بن سعد الأنصاري
@SalihAlansari
"يُقال لمعظم مرضى #السكري من النوع 2؛ إن الأدوية ستعالج كل شيء، لكن الواقع أكثر تعقيدا
يبقى #النظام_الغذائي العامل الحاسم في تغيير النتائج على المدى البعيد، وبإمكان خيارات بسيطة أن تغير مستقبلك بالكامل"
@garytaubes
مؤلف كتاب "إعادة التفكير في السكري"
#المشي_للصحه
#الصحة_الأيضية
#التوعيه_الصحيه
#الصيام_المتقطع
#خفض_الكربوهيدرات
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Most type 2 diabetes patients are told drugs will fix everything, but the reality is far more complicated. Diet remains the lever that actually changes long-term outcomes. Simple choices today can shift your entire future.
#type2diabetes #bloodsugarcontrol #metabolichealth #diabetesawareness #healtheducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Cutting Carbs Changes Everything
The science has been showing it for 20+ years...maybe the simplest answer is the right one.
#type2diabetes #lowcarblifestyle #metabolichealth #carbintolerance #healtheducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Most type 2 diabetes patients are told drugs will fix everything, but the reality is far more complicated. Diet remains the lever that actually changes long-term outcomes. Simple choices today can shift your entire future.
#type2diabetes #bloodsugarcontrol #metabolichealth #diabetesawareness #healtheducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We’ve known since 1960 that type 2 diabetes isn’t an insulin deficiency… yet we still treat it like one. It’s time to rethink the root cause and the therapies that truly help patients move toward metabolic health.
#diabetestruth #metabolichealth #insulinresistance #healthfacts #wellnesstips #functionalmedicine -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
LOW-CARB DIETS
Start of my career: "They don't work for wt loss"
Then: "You'll be a lean corpse"
Now: versus higher carb, IMPROVED
* Body comp
* BP
* TG
* VLDL
* ApoB-A1 ratio
* endothelial markers
* inflam markers
* overall CVD risk
(yes LDL up)
1/2
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00029165250052… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Two Levers That Actually Control Blood Sugar
Most people think blood sugar is only managed with medication, but diet is the other lever we’ve ignored for decades. It’s time to look at what truly works.
#bloodsugarcontrol #diabeteseducation #metabolichealth #nutritionfacts #healthinsightsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
MetFix
@MetFixByBSI
In this 2012 lecture, science journalist Gary Taubes examines the two dominant explanations for obesity: the traditional energy balance model—“calories in, calories out”—and the carbohydrate–insulin hypothesis, which views obesity as a disorder of fat storage and hormonal regulation. fects, showing that most “low-calorie” studies also inadvertently restricted carbs.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How One Man Discovered the Key to Perfect Blood Sugar Control
#diabeteseducation #bloodsugarcontrol #lowcarblifestyle #healthinsights #type1diabetes #metabolichealth -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Insulin Is Powerful! Here’s How It Can Affect Your Body
Understanding how insulin actually works is essential for anyone managing diabetes.
#insulinsafety #diabeteseducation #healthawareness #bloodsugar -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Diet by Hypothesis vs. Diet by Experience: Which Should You Trust?
#nutritionscience #lowcarblife #healthinsights #ketogenicdiet #wellnesstalk #evidencebasedhealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
In 1994, Jeff Friedman of Rockefeller University famously cloned the gene for the ob/ob mouse and named it leptin.
That discovery launched the modern era of obesity research, led to "an explosion of information about the neural circuits that regulate appetite,” and to the revelation, as Friedman says, “that obesity is a brain disorder.”
The only problem: Friedman misinterpreted leptin's action. That evidence is unambiguous.
Lessons From the Original (Very) Fat Mouse open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/lessons-fro… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Are Weight-Loss Drugs Solving the Problem?
#metabolichealth #obesitydiscussion #rootcausemedicine #healthinsights #wellnessscienceThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Truth About ‘Heart-Healthy’ Foods
It’s time to rethink what “heart-healthy” really means.
#nutritionfacts #healthyeating #sugarawareness #hearthealth #metabolichealth -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Not All Calories Are Created Equal
#nutritionscience #healthfacts #metabolichealth #sugarawareness #healthylivingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Sugar Quietly Took Over Our Diet
The rise of sugar mirrors the rise of diabetes. Coincidence?
#healthfacts #sugaraddiction #nutritionawareness #metabolichealth #diabetesprevention #healthyliving -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
From 1797 to 1914, doctors treated diabetes with a simple, powerful approach: fatty meats and boiled vegetables. Turns out, history might have had it right all along.
#diabetesawareness #nutritionfacts #metabolichealth #lowcarblifestyle #healthhistory #wellnesstips -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Forgotten Truth About Insulin and Hypoglycemia
#healthscience #insulinresistance #diabetesawareness #metabolichealth #nutritionfactsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The issue with keto isn’t that it fails...it’s that it actually works. Here’s why that matters.
#ketodiet #metabolichealth #nutritionfacts #healthtips #lowcarblife #fatlossjourney -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
"If we want to abolish or massively reduce coronary disease need to find other targets that are much higher yield".
We could, for example, start with insulin resistance/type 2 diabetes which is relatively cheap to reverse/put into remission. @lowcarbGP @drjasonfung @garytaubes @bigfatsurprise
Anish Koka, MD
@anish_koka
Case in point.
For the longest time, LDL target in this patient population (high risk, no prior heart attack or stroke) was < 100.
This was actually done pretty well for majority of the population with statins.
New class of lipid lowering agents (pcsk9 inhibitors) comes out and are remarkably effective at lowering LDL.
The small problem is that lowering LDLs to very low levels doesn’t abolish heart disease. LDL is part of the story, but not the whole story when it comes to coronary disease. The amount of benefit seen in the pcsk9 trials show that the amount of cardiovascular benefit is lower as your baseline LDL gets lower (the law of diminishing returns appears to be inviolable in biology as well)
Pcsk9inhibitors are ~$12000/ year .. statins are $50/year.
The trial just published shows a 25% relative risk reduction, a 2% absolute risk reduction in the composite of death from heart disease, stroke, or a heart attack over 5 years. But all of it is driven by heart attacks. No difference in death from heart disease or stroke.
So these folks ran a 12,000 patient trial over 5 years, and showed 80 fewer people had a heart attack. Cardiologists are apparently so good at dealing with acute heart attacks that this did not even translate to more deaths in the group not on the pcsk9i.
As a Cardiologist , happy to offer this to patients, but as a citizen watching families struggling with sky high premiums and out of pocket costs from deductibles, etc. , does it make sense to pay $1000/ month for the universe of people with an LDL of 90 who have a coronary calcium score of 100?
Message to me is that the LDL story is low yield as a target for reduction once you’ve achieved relatively low LDL.
If we want to abolish or massively reduce coronary disease need to find other targets that are much higher yield.
Caveats abound - curves keep separating, so perhaps younger patients at higher risk, may make sense.. but to take these results as wunderbahr and amazing- not so much. A little disappointing. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The truth is, there isn’t just one “keto diet.” The difference between success and struggle often comes down to how it’s formulated.
#ketodiet #nutritionfactsِ #metabolichealth #healthyfats #lowcarblifestyle #healthscience -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We’ve been told fat gain is just about calories in vs. out...but the science says otherwise. It’s time to question what we’ve been taught about metabolism and fat cells.
#metabolism #healthscience #nutritionfacts #fatlossmyths #endocrinology -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Biggest Diet Myth Finally Exposed
#dietmyths #nutritionfacts #healthtips #wellnessjourney #mindfuleating -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If your diet makes you hungry, it’s doomed to fail. Sustainable health isn’t about restriction, it’s about nourishment and balance.
#nutritiontips #healthyliving #ketolife #wellnessjourney #sustainablehealth -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
New: Ketogenic Diet Associated with Reduced Depression Scores in @JAMAPsych
New meta analysis show ketogenic diet improves psychiatric scores compared to high carb diet.
They also showed that ketogenic diet showed greater improvement than just going "low carb." -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Truth About Hunger and Fat Storage No One Talks About
#metabolism #nutritionscience #fatloss #healthinsights #wellness -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If I Were RFK Jr., Here’s How I’d Fix America’s Health Crisis
#healthpolicy #nutritionscience #rfkjr #wellnesstalk #publichealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Austin Dudzinski, PharmD, BCACP
@ApoDudz
“In the Michigan’s Hypertension, Diabetes, and Obesity Education Research Online (MHERO) trial, we randomized adults with this triple multimorbidity using a 2 × 2 diet-by-support factorial design, comparing a…
👉🏻VLC [very low carb] diet 🥩🧀🧂
vs
👉🏻a DASH [dietary approach to stop hypertension] diet 🥗🌾🍗❌🧂❌
…as well as comparing results with and without multicomponent extra support...” -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Are Ultra-Processed Foods Really the Problem?
A deeper look at what’s really behind the health divide.
#nutritionscience #healthtalk #wellnessinsights #foodforthought #healthyliving -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Obesity therapy may be experiencing a golden age with the GLP-1 drugs, but obesity science never has.
Why? In obesity science, the researchers who entered the field when it was young were supposed to be mentors and teachers. Instead of passing on a culture of critical thinking and rigorous standards, they passed on one that happily tolerated second rate research.
Obesity Science Has a Leadership Problem open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/obesity-sci… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why ‘Healthy Eating’ Doesn’t Work for Everyone
#nutritionfacts #healthmyths #wellnesseducation #sciencebasedhealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Cutting Fat Made America Sicker
Maybe it’s time to rethink what “healthy” really means.
#healthfacts #nutritionscience #wellnesstips #healthylivingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Diet That Beat the “Healthy” Guidelines
The data says it all.
#healthfacts #ketodiet #nutritionscience #wellness #hearthealth #obesityawareness -
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
Had a great time meeting @garytaubes and @samiinkinen from @virtahealth
We are going to change the world and reverse chronic disease worldwide… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Truth About Saturated Fat
Decades of research and still no solid proof that saturated fat causes heart disease. Maybe it’s time to rethink what we’ve been told.
#healthfacts #hearthealth #nutritionmyths #wellness #cholesterol #saturatedfat -
gary taubes reposted
Country_Bumpkin
@BumpkinNobody
I screenshot this slide from a presentation @garytaubes gave at OSU several years.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Big Fat Lie About Heart Disease
#healthfacts #nutritionmyths #hearthealth #diabetesawareness #metabolichealth #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What Doctors Got Wrong About Diabetes
#diabetesawareness #healthfacts #insulinresistance #metabolichealth #nutrition -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
NEW CLINICAL TRIAL
Ultra-processed food (UPF) PREVENTS obesity ...?😱
I've previously argued existing trials are biased by unfair diet comparisons medium.com/@davidludwigmd/ultra-processed-food-retold-by-…
For example – Is it fair to compare a burger & fries vs salmon & a massive portion of green beans?
🧵1/9 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Forgotten Doctor Who Treated Diabetes with Diet
#healthhistory #diabetes #ketodiet #medicine #nutrition #healthfactsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Diabetes Is America’s Silent Epidemic
#diabetesawareness #healthcrisis #publichealth #medicine #healthcaresystem #wellness #healtheducation #medicalnewsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The truth about sugar was buried for decades...and we’re still paying the price today.
#healthfacts #nutritiontruth #wellnesseducation #sugarindustry #healthylivingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Link Between Cavities, Obesity, and Diabetes 🍬
#healthfacts #wellnesstips #nutritionscience #healthyliving #guthealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Some People Gain Weight More Easily Than Others
#metabolism #weightlossscience #functionalhealth #nutritionfacts #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Does it help to struggle with your weight to actually understand obesity?
If so, then why is it the lean people who are always telling us the disorder is caused by eating too much, a dysregulation of the brain not the body?
As for bodybuilders...
The BodyBuilder Bias, or Why Lean People Can Be Clueless about the Nature of Obesity open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/the-bodybui… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Link Between Sugar, Insulin, and Cancer
#cancerresearch #metabolichealth #wellness #insulinresistance #healtheducationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
From obesity to heart disease...here’s how fructose impacts your body’s chemistry more than you might think.
#healthscience #nutrition #insulinresistance #metabolichealth #wellness -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How Sugar Changed Everything
From zero diabetes cases in the 1800s to a global epidemic...it all began when sugar became part of everyday life.
#nutritionfacts #healthhistory #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Can diabetes really go into remission?
#healthtalk #nutritionscience #diabetesawarenessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ozempic and Pregnancy: What We Still Don’t Know
#healthtalk #ozempic #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why More Insulin Isn’t Always the Answer
Understanding insulin resistance could change how we treat it.
#healthinsights #diabetesawareness #wellness #insulinresistance #holistichealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ozempic: The Wonder Drug With Unknown Risks
It’s changing lives, but what happens after 20 or 30 years of use?
#ozempic #healthnews #medicalresearch #wellness #weightlossThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What Really Happens on the Carnivore Diet
#carnivorediet #nutritionfacts #metabolichealth #lowcarb #healtheducation -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Everything You Know About Fat Gain Is Wrong
It’s not just what we eat, it’s what our body does with it.
#healthfacts #metabolism #insulinresistance #nutritionscience #weightlossmyths -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Traditional diets kept populations healthy for centuries...until sugar and refined grains changed everything.
#nutritionscience #healthawareness #obesityepidemic #diabetespreventionThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sometimes the simplest logic changes everything.
#diabetesawareness #healthfacts #wellness #nutrition #bloodsugar #metabolichealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
For 40 years we’ve been told what should work. But real health comes from what actually works...when symptoms go away and life gets better.
#nutritiontruth #healthtips #longevity #wellnessjourney #dietbyexperienceThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Is Obesity Really Just About Eating Too Much?
#healtheducation #obesityawareness #medicalhistory #wellnessfactsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Truth About Keto They Never Told You
#ketodiet #lowcarblifestyle #diabetesresearch #nutritionscience #healthtruthsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Will targeting "ultra-processed food" make Americans (and the rest of the world) healthier?
👉I argue there is a better way.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/10/06/maha-ultra-pro… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Cost of Western Diets
When traditional diets shift to sugar and refined carbs, rates of obesity, diabetes, and heart disease skyrocket. The evidence has been clear for decades.
#healthfacts #nutritionmatters #diabetesprevention #hearthealth #sugarfreeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Let's call this the podcaster problem: Does interviewing a single "expert" on your podcast make you an expert as well? How about interviewing sources from only one side of a controversy? I'm skeptical.
In the case of @hubermanlab and @DKThomp, this is how they determined the "boring truth" about the obesity epidemic.
Maybe they should have done a few more interviews.
Is There a Boring Truth About Obesity? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/is-there-a-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Keto Works: The Simple Science Behind It
#ketolife #lowcarbliving #fatlossscience #metabolichealth #ketodietThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Want to burn fat efficiently? Your body needs low insulin levels...this is why ketosis works.
#insulinresistance #fatlosstips #ketogenicdiet #healthfacts #nutrition -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why Insulin Resistance Keeps You from Burning Fat
#insulinresistance #fatlosstips #metabolichealth #bellyfatThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Biggest Myth About Obesity
It’s not just about eating too much. Our bodies are wired differently, and the real cause goes deeper than calories.
#obesitymyth #healthtruths #metabolismmatter #nutritionfacts -
gary taubes reposted
SDA · Real Food
@CarneAdventist
Ahhh 😌 such good wisdom from @garytaubes
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Cost of Obesity & Diabetes: $1 Billion a Day
#healthcrisis #obesity #diabetes #healthcarecosts #wellness -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
Sometimes really good scientific papers simply get forgotten because they are ahead of their time. This is one of them: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8646265/
In it Jean-Pierre Flatt makes the point in 1996 that :
Fat oxidation by the body is NOT determined by fat intake.
So what does determine the rate of fat oxidation at rest and during exercise? Well its pretty well established now in the exercise sciences although not yet in the nutrition sciences: "...not all individuals (or animals) become obese when presented with diets high in fat. Adaptations to diets with a high fat content without excessive increase in the fat mass depends on mechanisms allowing fat oxidation to rise as dietary fat content increases. The simplest phenomenon able to explain this behaviour is maintenance of lower glycogen levels with a high fat diet is consumed".
In other words a low-carbohydrate diet determines whole body rates of fat oxidation even when fat provides a large proportion of the daily energy consumption.
At the World Nutrition Summit in October thenoakesfoundation.org/wns2025/ I'll be presenting all the evidence supporting this statement and what are its implications for weight control and the problem of de novo lipogenesis when body carbohydrate balance is challenged by high-carbohydrate diets (associated with low rates of daily exercise). It's more important that I originally realized.
@drjasonfung @bigfatsurprise @LoreofRunning1 @TheNoakesF @garytaubes @AKoutnik @PaulBLaursen -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sugar: The Silent Killer of Your Liver
Sugar isn’t just sweet, it’s silently damaging your liver and fueling global health epidemics.
#sugarfacts #liverhealth #nutritiontips #healthawareness #metabolichealth #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Silent Epidemic: Fatty Liver Disease in America
Millions are developing fatty liver disease without ever drinking alcohol and it’s linked to insulin resistance and chronic illness.
#fattyliver #healthawareness #wellness #insulinresistance #metabolichealth #liverhealthThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Hidden Link Behind Diabetes, Obesity & Alzheimer’s
#diabetes #health #wellness #insulinresistance #obesity #alzheimers #healthylivingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sugar Is Always at the Scene of the Crime
#health #diabetes #obesity #sugar #nutrition #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Can we believe that obesity is caused by overeating and willpower or bad choices have nothing to do with it?
Simple logic suggests one those assumptions must be wrong.
I don't think it's the second one.
The Willpower Paradox and the Roots of Fat Shaming open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/the-willpow… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
TV shows like Rocky and Bullwinkle weren’t just for kids...they were marketing tools to push sugar and cereal.
#sugaraddiction #obesitycrisis #healthtruths #nutritionfacts #foodindustryexposed #wellnesstips #diabetesawarenessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sugar wasn’t always everywhere. The rise of candy, soda, and processed foods fueled today’s diabetes crisis.
#health #diabetes #sugarfacts #nutrition #wellnessThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
More on the ketogenic diet trial from Metabolic Mind. Per @BroChillerman's comment, I, too, hope an RCT is already in the works.
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
New Research: Ketogenic Diet Associated with Improvements in Depression in College Students
The first ever peer-reviewed pilot trial of ketogenic diet for depression was published today in Translational Psychiatry. The study was conducted in college students with a primary diagnosis of major depressive disorder at The Ohio State University.
All 16 students who completed the study saw improvements in depression, with an average reduction in symptoms of 70% across scales. Metabolic health markers also improved.
The video below includes perspectives from the research team and students who participated in the study.
Read the full study in Translational Psychiatry: doi.org/10.1038/s41398-025-03544-8
Read @OhioStateNews announcement: news.osu.edu/keto-diet-linked-to-reduced-depression-sympt…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A KD Pilot trial for depression. The results are exciting but inconclusive:
100% of 16 students who completed the study showed improvements in depression; ~70% average reduction across scales. Metabolic health markers also improved.
Why only an association per the OSU post?
As Decker et al say in the limitations, without a control group and randomization, "it is not possible to isolate the effects of the WFKD from counseling and/or medication or to know how time alone would alter depression symptoms or cognitive performance."
Ohio State News
@OhioStateNews
A new @OhioState study shows an association between at least 10 weeks of following a well-formulated ketogenic diet and a roughly 70% decrease in depression symptoms among a small group of college students. @OSUehe news.osu.edu/keto-diet-linked-to-reduced-depression-sympt…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
If you have 50 min (33 min on 1.5x) ...
The investigative journalist @garytaubes and I discuss (argue about):
👉Ultra-processed foods
👉State of nutrition research
👉Inching toward truth when paradigms collide
Thanks @Metabolic_Mind for hosting
www.youtube.com/watch?v=PfObMIuSV8U -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Are ultra-processed foods really the villain, or is the story more complicated? In this lively, no-nonsense conversation, endocrinologist Dr. David Ludwig (@davidludwigmd) of Harvard and Boston Children’s Hospital and journalist Gary Taubes (@garytaubes) unpack why “UPF” is an enticing label but a blunt tool for science, policy, and everyday guidance.
They cover:
- Why defining “ultra-processed” is messy, and how lumping diverse packaged foods into one bucket can mislead.
- How high-profile trials are interpreted (and misinterpreted), from short study durations to dropout bias and carryover effects.
- The role of bias and confirmation bias in nutrition research and media narratives.
- Where the debate should go next: moving beyond slogans toward mechanisms like how carbohydrate processing affects blood sugar and insulin.
- What to do in the meantime: clearer study design, healthier discourse, and pragmatic takeaways people can use now.
In this conversation, you’ll hear sharp disagreements, candid critiques, and concrete suggestions for doing better science. Plus a spirited back-and-forth on what “good evidence” should look like and how individuals, clinicians, and policymakers can each act on different standards of proof.
What’s at stake isn’t academic nitpicking; it’s policy decisions, headlines, and, ultimately, what lands on your plate.
👉 Stay for the debate, and subscribe to Metabolic Mind for more conversations at the intersection of metabolism and mental health.
Expert Featured:
Dr. David Ludwig
- X: x.com/davidludwigmd
- Dr. Ludwig's UPF Study: www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2508694
Gary Taubes
- x.com/garytaubes
- uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com
Free CME Clinician Trainings:
Are you a clinician who would like to learn more about the science behind these therapies and how to implement them in practice? Earn CME with our growing library of courses from some of the top experts in the field including Dr. Chris Palmer, Dr. Georgia Ede, Dr. Matthew Bernstein and Dr. Bret Scher with more coming soon.
Our courses have been made FREE by grants from Baszucki Group, so we can spread these powerful therapies as widely as possible. Earn CME/CNE credits: www.metabolicmind.org/for-clinicians/trainings-courses/
Follow our channel for more information and education from Bret Scher, MD, FACC, including interviews with leading experts in Metabolic Psychiatry.
Learn more about metabolic psychiatry and find helpful resources at metabolicmind.orgThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
Regarding GLP-1 @garytaubes - "You hear people talk about these drugs as appetite suppressant drugs, which makes them sound very benign.
They float into your head, and they make you eat less.
It's like, 'What could be better?' And they might be benign... we'll find out..."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
🚨New Episode🚨
This is part 2 of 2 - #feldmanprotocol featuring @garytaubes – multiple best-selling author on #lowcarb & #keto
We cover:
📄 Peer review flaws
💸 Career stakes
🥩 Carnivore myths
💊 GLP-1 secrets
And it gets a little 🌶️🌶️🌶️ at times... www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1C51__cLag -
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
🚨New Episode🚨
This is part 2 of 2 - #feldmanprotocol featuring @garytaubes – multiple best-selling author on #lowcarb & #keto
We cover:
📄 Peer review flaws
💸 Career stakes
🥩 Carnivore myths
💊 GLP-1 secrets
And it gets a little 🌶️🌶️🌶️ at times... www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1C51__cLag -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This should be interesting. I can't recall what I said, but...?
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
Tomorrow we're dropping #feldmanprotocol Part 2 of my interview with @garytaubes
It's a bit more... colorful -- than Part 1. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sprite has 25 grams of sugar in 8 ounces.
Grandma's homemade lemonade has 38 grams of sugar.
Sprite is an ultra-processed food.
Grandma's lemonade is not.
Which is the healthier?
Ultra-Processing Is the Bathwater. What About the Baby? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/ultra-proce… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨BIG NEWS: $50M Investment to End America's Health Crisis!🚨
🔬I'm Andrew Koutnik, PhD in Nutrition, Metabolism & Diabetes—and a patient living with an irreversible chronic metabolic disease.
Thrilled to advise the NEW Coalition for Metabolic Health, LAUNCHED to REVERSE our chronic disease epidemic!
Our 4 BOLD objectives:
1⃣Push policy shifts for science-based nutrition guidelines, research, screenings & insurance.
2⃣Fund unbiased research to empower docs & public with real metabolic insights.
3⃣Educate providers, policymakers & YOU on metabolism's power to prevent/reverse disease.
4⃣Incorporate therapeutic nutrition in everyday care via key partnerships.
👉Join the revolution: coalitionformetabolichealth.org/news/coalition-for-metabo…
#metabolichealth #reversechronicdisease
@Metabolic_Mind @janellison @bschermd @davidludwigmd @DominicDAgosti2 @BenBikmanPhD @DoctorTroThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Should national nutrition policy target "Ultra-Processed Foods" (UPF) as many advocate?
I consider concerns in a @NEJM Perspective
Like 'The Emperor's New Clothes'
👉We're rolling out a red carpet, but the evidence is threadbare!
LINK: www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2508694
1/21 🧵👇 -
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
Clip from TFP #2 - @garytaubes: Fat accumulation isn't just about energy balance; it's heavily influenced by hormones and the central nervous system. Anomalous cases, like progressive lipodystrophy, challenge the simple 'eat too much, exercise too little' explanation for obesity.
-
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
The second episode of the #feldmanprotocol podcast features the @garytaubes – multiple best-selling author on #lowcarb & #keto
This is part 1 of 2 where we discuss:
🔬 Bad science
⚗️ Physics vs food
🚫 Energy balance
💰 Funding bias
🧪 Hypothesis trap
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FP_MTXT4W-0 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Talking about bad science. A favorite subject.
And, yes, cold fusion and modern nutrition/obesity science have much in common.
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
Tomorrow we're dropping a new #feldmanprotocol with the towering @garytaubes - Part 1 of 2.
We discuss:
🧬 Flawed science
🔬 Physics vs nutrition
🚫 Low-fat diet fails
📊 Epidemiology issues
🧪 Testing hypotheses
💰 Funding biasThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nothing to add.
Ok, one addition: anyone who wants to understand how the ADA got to this point, the history of this misguided thinking and the oh-so-limited evidence on which it was based, might read my book Rethinking Diabetes.
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨New Review On Advancing Diabetes Management
💊 Drugs/Tech: 24
🍽 Nutrition: 0
🗣"There is heavy reliance on technology-assisted insulin delivery and glucose monitoring. Yet, people living with type 1 diabetes still face dysglycemia, weight gain, vascular complications, ketoacidosis and severe hypoglycemia, and psychological distress."
...sorry but we are not serious about normalizing the complications of this disease if mention diet ZERO times.
No this isn't DIET TRIBE crap...this is serious evidence-based reality. Carbohydrates have the most potent impact on glucose levels 24/7. Insulin don't match the glucose impact. They are not fast enough. Period. Discussing diet zero time illustrate where STANDARD OF CARE has been and will continue to be.
Every. Single. Patient. Is expected to get atleast one complication and lose 11-18 years off their life on average. Time to have real and uncomfortable conversations.
diabetesjournals.org/care/article/doi/10.2337/dci25-0015/… -
gary taubes reposted
justasking
@justask66054535
Really great discussion w @garytaubes and @drmarkhyman. Hyman says he’s a slim guy and loses too much weight in ketosis. He’s a brilliant man and likely a great doc but he undoubtedly has his own filters. Lotsa men just don’t like being small? youtu.be/qdBrksj36o4
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If you fail to lose weight trying to eat less and exercise, are your best options surgery or drugs?
The editors of the New England Journal of Medicine seem to think so, assuming, that is, that they are giving it any meaningful thought at all.
My latest Substack newsletter, which includes a tricky question about whether you store the fat you eat even when you're losing weight (or at least whether mice do).
Fighting Obesity? The New England Journal of Medicine Has a Calorie Fixation open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/only-calori… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Yes, he's confirming my biases, but @davidludwigmd makes some good points.
Now because of my bias, don't take my word for it.
Read Ludwig et al's LTE. Then read the response from @kevinH_PHD . Then read the original LTE again.
Ask yourself whether Hall addressed the issues raised or deflected and distracted.
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Do low-carb diets make people overeat & gain weight versus low-fat diets?
That's the upshot of a 2-wk crossover study in @NatureMedicine 2021 by an @NIH team
In a new paper, my coauthors & I show why a huge “carry-over effect” invalidates the trial
1/10
www.nature.com/articles/s41591-025-03909-y -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Agreed.
Although this is the WSJ, which is open-minded (i.e., unbiased) on these diet, nutrition issues.
Had it been the NYT, I'd have been gobsmacked.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
This is the lowest level of snark I've seen in a mainstream media article on carnivore.
Usually it's all: toxic masculinity, gym bros, raw-meat and liver gorging...
Times are changing--fast -
gary taubes reposted
Robb Wolf
@robbwolf
If you dig into the recent research on Ultra Processed Foods, the researchers actually report findings contrary to what their own data suggest: that folks tend to eat more UPF than less processed options.
I'm sure you have seen the news piece that goes something like "Scientists say UPF's can be good for you and good for the planet!"
We talked a lot about the later point in Sacred Cow. Both assertions are a flavor of gaslighting that is honestly, impressive.
The UPF topic is complex and highly politicized via funding conflicts and is plagued with poor critical thinking and I guess just dumb luck in some cases. For example, a can of baked beans is considered an UPF, while a plate of home baked cookies is not, becasue, well, it's made at home.
I'm not sure how precisely to tackle all off this. Gutting subsidies of food would be a great start, but is a pipe dream. Similarly, a strong firewall between academia and industry would also likely be a smart move, but would be remarkably difficult to implement.
This ship will likely right itself at some point if by no other mechanism than the burden of disease costs will cripple the nations that engage in these shenanigans.
Hat tip @garytaubes
Bing Crosby Science: Ultraprocessed Food edition. open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/bing-crosby… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
In the longest, largest clinical trial done to date on ultraprocessed foods, British researchers refute the core assumption of the field.
A scientist's dream result!
What do they do?
Ignore it.
Bing Crosby Science: Ultraprocessed Food edition. open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/bing-crosby… -
gary taubes reposted
Benjamin Bikman
@BenBikmanPhD
This newly published report by @IainCampbellPhD is worth reading (www.nature.com/articles/s41380-025-03123-9). I appreciate their rigorous approach to revealing the metabolic foundation of bipolar disorder, including not only the seasonality of the disorder, but also some traditional and effective treatments (i.e., lithium affects brain insulin signaling).
The more we learn about metabolic health, the more we understand its role in so many health disorders. -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Credit here goes to Metabolic Psychiatry pioneers like @ChrisPalmerMD @ShebaniMD @GeorgiaEdeMD for leading the charge, the army of people like our son, @BaszuckiMatt, @LWSchizophrenia and @Radiantbeasting who are speaking out about how ketogenic and metabolic therapies have changed their lives, and our team @BaszuckiGroup for many months of meetings with lawmakers to get this critical language drafted.
We are so grateful for the open minded lawmakers who have helped get this language into the report. Wouldn't it be amazing to see NIMH take on this important research?
It's not official yet, but this is a critical first step in government funded research focusing on metabolic approaches to mental health treatment. Next step: working with lawmakers in the house to ensure this language gets into the final report.
@KevinBardosh
@NIHDirector_Jay
#metabolicpsychiatry
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
Fantastic news! The US Senate supports funding research on the metabolic theory of mental illness and metabolic therapies!
"Serious Mental Illness—The Committee encourages NIMH to expand research into metabolic interventions for serious mental illnesses, including bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder, and schizophrenia. The Committee encourages NIMH to investigate the fundamental link between metabolic function and psychiatric illness, as well as the study of the prevention, treatment, and reversal of serious mental illness through metabolic therapies. This includes support for large-scale clinical trials investigating nutritional ketosis, with a focus on identifying predictive neurobiological and metabolic biomarkers, optimizing patient stratification, and developing best practice clinical guidelines. Research should encompass multimodal data collection, including neuroimaging, genetics, and cellular biology, with an emphasis on translational science that informs personalized treatment and advances understanding of underlying disease mechanisms." -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My latest Substack post: nutrition/health reporters have a critical supply and demand problem: Huge demand and a very limited supply.
So should we care that genes can be used to predict coming obesity in those who are still lean? How about the role of inactivity in making us fatter? Sugar vs. high fructose corn syrup: which is healthier?
Finally, my single favorite conflict of interest statement ever. For all who think that industry funding implies an authority cannot and should not be trusted.
Can Obesity Be Predicted? Does Inactivity Cause It? And What About Corn Syrup? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/can-obesity…? -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
GLP-1 medications like Ozempic and Wegovy are changing how the medical system approaches obesity and metabolic disease. But are they a replacement for dietary intervention? Or are dietary interventions a replacement for these medications? Could they be used together for even better outcomes?
In this conversation, Dr. David Ludwig (Harvard, Boston Children’s Hospital) (@davidludwigmd) and journalist Gary Taubes (@garytaubes) explore the science behind GLP-1s, their impact on insulin, weight loss, and chronic disease, and where dietary strategies like low carb or ketogenic therapy fit in.
They break down:
- The overlap between GLP-1 drugs and low carb diets
- Why long-term use of these drugs may come with hidden costs
- How shared mechanisms open the door to combination therapy
- What current studies are missing and the urgent need for better trials
- Why metabolic health (not just weight loss) should be the focus
This conversation challenges the idea that the answer is either medication or nutrition therapy. The reality is that every individual is different, and for many, the most effective path to healing may involve a thoughtful combination of both. Rather than choosing one over the other, we should focus on tailoring care to the unique needs of each individual with the goal of getting the best outcomes.
Expert Featured:
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Gary Taubes
@garytaubes
uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com
Follow our channel for more information and education from Bret Scher, MD, FACC, including interviews with leading experts in Metabolic Psychiatry.
Learn more about metabolic psychiatry and find helpful resources at metabolicmind.org
Timestamps:
- Introduction to Dr. David Ludwig and Gary Taubes and the intricacies of GLP-1 medications.
- What are GLP-1’s? Where do they come from? How can we use them?
- Are GLP-1’s a long term solution? Will they revolutionize the obesity epidemic?
- Can you stop taking GLP-1’s?
- The power of metabolic health throughout the body. How does this work mechanistically?
- Will weight loss drugs end any and all focus on diet?
- GLP-1 adherence vs diet adherence, and the mechanisms of each.
- Where to hear more from Gary and David.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
reason
@reason
How good is RFK Jr.'s nutrition advice? According to @garytaubes, it's much better than some of his medical advice. reason.com/podcast/2025/07/24/gary-taubes-maha-ultra-proc…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
While trying to write a Substack post about nutrition journalism I came upon these two stories from the Washington Post, a decade apart.
They say pretty much all you need to say about the nature of the daily press (i.e., telling time by the second hand). -
gary taubes reposted
Vincent S Artale Jr
@VincentArtale
The Curious Lessons of Calorie Restriction by @garytaubes
What can we learn about aging well from the "potential downsides" of living hungry?
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/calorie-res…
Whether or not calorie restriction extends our lives, do we want to be perpetually hungry while it does so? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why is it that calorie restriction makes us hungry and carbohydrate restriction doesn't, and yet they both induce weight loss?
There's a simple answer and then there's a thoughtful answer. Which is right has profound implications.
The Curious Lessons of Calorie Restriction -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What a famous NBA basketball player, his imaginary fraternal twin, and two English bulldogs from a century ago tell us about the illogic of the idea that we get fat because we eat too much.
Of Course Overeating Makes Us Fat... Except When It Doesn't? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/of-course-o… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm confused.
When @KevinH_PhD starts sounding like me publicly--suggesting the primary problem with the American diet is the sugar content--I have to consider the possibility that finally we're both right. www.wsj.com/business/food-agriculture-leaders-sound-warni… -
gary taubes reposted
Stewart Knoepp
@woundedhealer
Excellent article, thanks. Just read both of these books. Georgia Ede's book is a critical read for everyone, not just those struggling with mental illness.
-
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
If I'd read an article like this when our son had his first manic episode back in 2016, I would have immediately offered to help him try a ketogenic diet. But there were no articles like this, then, and there were no clinical trials.
Now I get to curl up on an outdoor sofa listening to the waters of Lake Tahoe lap the shore, and read an article that has videos from my own son embedded in it. That's a heck of a lot better than what I did during those five years when he was so unwell, desperately surfing the internet in search of something, anything, that might help him.
I hope any moms out there tonight who are desperately searching will stumble upon this article....ketogenic therapy gave our son his life back. It's worth a try.
#newbipolartreatment
@ChrisPalmerMD
@GeorgiaEdeMD
@ShebaniMD
@LWSchizophrenia
@BaszuckiMatt
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is a terrific article by @GordySlack on using ketogenic diets for mental illness.
@Metabolic_Mind
mindsitenews.org/2025/06/16/can-a-ketogenic-diet-treat-me… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
See the note from Kevin Fontaine at UAB. There's little I can add, other than my request that we all contribute.
Join me and make a gift to Dr. Sarah Hallberg Endowed Scholarship for Diabetes Research and Prevention www.givecampus.com/ot0l3i -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is a terrific article by @GordySlack on using ketogenic diets for mental illness.
@Metabolic_Mind
mindsitenews.org/2025/06/16/can-a-ketogenic-diet-treat-me… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How did American explorers get by in the early 19th Century? They lived, unsurprisingly, on mostly meat.
Here's General William Ashley on the experience of his explorations in the 1820s: "the circumstance of the uninterrupted health of these people who generally eat unreasonable quantities of meat at their meals, proves it to be the most wholesome and best adapted food to the constitution of man."
Tales from the History of Carnivore Diets open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/tales-from-… -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Are low carb and ketogenic diets being misrepresented by flawed nutrition studies?
In this video, @bschermd breaks down a controversial NIH-funded study that compared low fat and low carb diets that, like many nutrition research studies, was deeply flawed and designed to fail.
In this video, you’ll learn:
- How the study’s two-week timeline and lack of a washout period distorted results
- What the calorie trends really show when examined week by week
- Why the “carryover effect” undermines the study’s conclusions
- How this reflects broader problems in nutrition research
- Why new NIH leadership offers hope for more rigorous, clinically useful studies
Listen to our interview with @davidludwigmd and @garytaubes, further breaking down this study, the flaws of nutrition science, and how we can better allocate research funding to get results that can better inform public health policy.
🎥 youtu.be/L39nTrxhBeo
Expert Featured:
Dr. Bret Scher
@bschermd
Resources Mentioned:
Effect of a plant-based, low-fat diet versus an animal-based, ketogenic diet on ad libitum energy intake
- pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33479499/
Gary’s Substack Article
- uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/nih-has-a-nutrition-…
Follow our channel for more information and education from Bret Scher, MD, FACC, including interviews with leading experts in Metabolic Psychiatry.
Learn more about metabolic psychiatry and find helpful resources at metabolicmind.orgThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thought experiment: assume for the moment that ultra-processed food is a scientific-sounding rebranding of the concept of junk food.
Now imagine that the nutrition research community is dedicating its research to determine why people eat so much junk food, as though it was all the same...
Would we think the world had gone crazy?
Are Ultra-Processed Foods the Problem? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/are-ultra-p… -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Is nutrition research getting the support it needs to inform public health policy?
Despite the rise in chronic diseases related to lifestyle factors like diet, nutrition research only receives $2.2 billion of the $30 billion NIH budget.
At first glance, this may seem like a lot of money, but its utilization is spread thin, and, as Dr. David Ludwig (@davidludwigmd) and Gary Taubes (@garytaubes) highlight in this interview, it’s primarily used to fund misleading short term trials that confirm existing nutrition biases.
However, if we want to actually address the chronic disease epidemic, we must increase the resources allocated to nutrition research AND the quality of that research.
In this video, journalist Gary Taubes and Harvard endocrinologist Dr. David Ludwig expose the core problems in today’s most cited nutrition studies and offer a bold new path forward.
In this conversation, you’ll learn:
- Why short-term feeding studies can’t tell us much about chronic disease
- How confirmation bias shapes which nutrition studies get funded, published, and accepted by the medical community and policy makers
- The major flaws in NIH-funded research comparing low-carb vs. low-fat diets
- Why the focus on ultra-processed foods is only part of the solution
- How we could design better long-term studies that actually help people get healthier
It’s time to question the status quo and demand better utilization of research funds to inform public health policy in a way that can impactfully improve the health of our population.
We encourage you to share this interview so more people can understand the flaws in existing nutrition science and what we can do to fix it.
Expert Featured:
Gary Taubes
uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com
@garytaubes
Dr. David Ludwig, MD
www.linkedin.com/in/davidludwigmd/
@davidludwigmd
Resources Mentioned:
Studies
doi.org/10.1136/bmj-2024-082963
doi.org/10.1101/2023.10.03.23296501
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2673150
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1212914
doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.008
Short-term diet trials are designed to fail
- www.statnews.com/2025/04/22/nutrition-precision-health-sh…
Gary's Substack Article
- uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/nih-has-a-nutrition-…
CMEs Mentioned:
Managing Major Mental Illness with Dietary Change: The New Science of Hope
- www.mycme.com/courses/managing-major-mental-illness-with-…
Brain Energy: The Metabolic Theory of Mental Illness
- www.mycme.com/courses/brain-energy-the-metabolic-theory-o…
Follow our channel for more information and education from Bret Scher, MD, FACC, including interviews with leading experts in Metabolic Psychiatry.
Learn more about metabolic psychiatry and find helpful resources at metabolicmind.orgThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Krisna Hanks 😄
@Square1Wellness
Super video with @garytaubes and @ifixhearts I don't know about you but I prefer the "diet by health" and not the "diet by consensus" ......just sayin. www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFBmd1QhWKs
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
I live with an IRREVERSIBLE metabolic disease.
I was invited to Washington D.C., to share my 17-year journey with chronic disease and our research to confront America’s chronic disease epidemic. 👨💼📢
Here’s what I shared & 5 policies outlined (see substack) to reverse this epidemic.
You may not agree...but I hope you listen.
🧵👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nicely summarized and worth a read.
Whitfield Lewis, MD 🇦🇬🇺🇸
@whitfieldlewis6
🧵1/
Excuse me, what gives?
We’re eating less red meat per capita than decades ago.
🍗 Poultry replaced beef
🌽 Seed oils replaced butter/lard
🥗 Ultra-processed plants dominate
So why are colorectal cancer rates rising in young adults?
📉🥩📈🧠
🔗 ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-meat-usa
2/
Let’s talk “processed meat.”
Nobody's defending nitrate-laden deli slices — but “processed” is a vague term.
Processed with what?
➡️ Nitrites? Sugar? Seed oils?
If that’s the issue, let’s blame the processing, not the meat.
3/
Now red meat.
It’s often lumped into “processed” as a rhetorical sleight of hand.
If the additives are harmful (sugar, flour, seed oil), let’s name those — not demonize the meat itself.
And let’s be honest:
The “red meat causes cancer” claim rests on observational data, not RCTs.
4/
Public health messaging has discouraged red meat for 70+ years.
So people who avoid it also tend to:
✅ Exercise
✅ Eat vegetables
✅ Avoid smoking
✅ Get screened
✅ Follow guidelines
That’s classic healthy-user bias — and ignoring it isn’t scientific rigor.
5/
We told the public red meat was unhealthy.
Then decades later, we notice meat avoiders are healthier…
…but they also smoke less, eat less sugar, and follow all health advice.
And we blame the meat?
That’s not rigorous — it’s narrative-driven inference.
6/
Let’s look at actual RCTs:
🔹 Polyp Prevention Trial (8 yrs)
Low-fat, high-fiber, fruit/veg diet vs. higher meat intake
No benefit. HR = 1.09 [95% CI: 0.98–1.22]
📎 PMID: 17855692
➡️ Large sample. Long follow-up. Still no signal.
And that HR? Trending in favor of higher meat consumption.
7/
🔹 WHI Trial
Low-fat, plant-heavy diet in postmenopausal women
No reduction in colorectal cancer incidence.
📎 PMID: 16467232
➡️ Once again, trend favors the meat-eaters. I posted the table — go see for yourself.
8/
🔹 CAPP2 Trial (Lynch syndrome)
Tested aspirin + resistant starch (fiber)
➡️ Fiber: No effect
➡️ Aspirin: Reduced cancer risk
📎 PMIDs: 22727205, 32534647
Denis Burkitt would be disappointed with these results.
9/
So if red meat causes cancer…
Where’s the signal?
Three large RCTs — two in average-risk, one in high-risk — show no benefit from reducing meat or increasing fiber.
In fact, some trends point in the opposite direction.
10/
Historical accounts also challenge the narrative.
📜 Samuel Hutton (1902):
“The Eskimo is a meat eater... European diseases were rare. The most striking is cancer.”
Cancer appeared only with settler foods: molasses, biscuits, tea.
11/
🪶 Isaac Levin (1910), Columbia pathologist:
“They consume a great deal of food [rich in nitrogen—i.e., meat], frequently to excess.”
Surveyed 107 reservation doctors treating 115,000 Native Americans.
📊 Only 29 cancer cases reported over decades.
12/
🦴 Ales Hrdlička (1908), Smithsonian anthropologist:
“Malignant disease, if it exists at all… must be extremely rare.”
“I have not… found a single unequivocal example of a malignant growth” in Indian remains.
📚 Smithsonian Report
13/
These quotes appear in Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes — a book I own. @garytaubes
But for transparency, here are the original sources:
🧾 Hutton, Among the Eskimos of Labrador (1902)
🧾 Levin, Cancer Among the N.A. Indians (1910)
🧾 Hrdlička, Physiological and Medical Observations… (1908)
14/
Even modern data challenge the anti-meat narrative.
🇯🇵 Okinawa: Post-WWII centenarians ate more meat and animal fat.
📎 PMID: 1407826
📎 Meat positively linked to longevity even after adjusting for SES (PMID: 35228814)
15/
Let’s be honest:
The case against red meat relies on:
🐭 Rodent models
🧪 Mechanistic speculation
🔬 Confounded cohort studies
That’s not strong evidence — that’s plausibility dressed up as certainty.
16/
We need better standards in nutrition science:
✅ RCTs with hard endpoints
✅ Context over correlation
✅ Less ideology, more rigor
Red meat isn’t the problem. Ultra-processed modernity is.
17/
Adding fiber to a diet overloaded with seed oils and refined carbs won’t reverse chronic disease.
The better move?
Remove novel foods — not the ones we’ve thrived on for millennia.
18/
Until strong RCTs prove otherwise, red meat remains:
🥩 Nutrient-dense
🌍 Evolutionarily consistent
📚 Not a proven carcinogen
Let’s raise the bar on public health claims.
👨🏾⚕️🥩📉🧠
#nutritionscience #cancerepidemiology #rct -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
“Pathological” science?
To solve the chronic disease epidemics, we need to get the research right.
@garytaubes on the failure of nutrition science to correct fatally flawed diet trials … and avoid these blunders in the first place.
substack.com/home/post/p-164269527 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Signs that the paradigm is shifting (i.e, we've made progress):
The 90-y-o's working out at the Y are breakfasting on sausage and eggs in a spinach wrap.
The longevity influencer is urging his clients to cut back on sugar.
Amy Dockser Marcus
@AmyDMarcus
My essay today in @wsj is part of our ongoing look at the pursuit of longevity. www.wsj.com/health/wellness/americans-in-their-80s-and-90… We also held a Live Q and A with @EricTopol about living longer/healthier. That conversation is still available to read here: www.wsj.com/health/wellness/live-q-a-longevity-and-youask…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
NIH Nutrition Research Takes it on the Chin
Last month, @KevinH_PhD, the "top" nutrition researcher at NIH, took early retirement, citing censored by the MAHA folks.
A week later, the BMJ and STAT publish articles by @davidludwigmd and collaborators asserting that the NIH research was fatally flawed and making the same accusations--"designed to fail"--about the $170 million Nutrition for Precision Health Initiative. The timing was probably a coincidence, but the criticism is damning.
Part 1 in a 2 (maybe 3) part post on what constitutes influential research in nutrition these days and its many (many) limitations.
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/nih-nutriti…? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nice to see that the KD demonstrate efficacy in kids (not that I particularly doubted it) but it would have been nice to see a control group and randomization.
Maybe any weight loss diet would achieve the same effect?
MEATrition.com 🥩 - Travis Statham M.S. Nutri-Sci
@MEATritionCom
#keto4kids shows great results from Faculty of Medicine in Bulgaria...
The 58/100 patients who completed the study with follow-up assessments ranged in age from 8 to 18 years (mean 13.79 ± 0.34) at the start of the diet, including 35 (60.34%) boys and 23 (39.66%) girls. They were distributed into three age groups: 8 (13.79%) children in the age range 8–10 years, 25 (43.10%) children 11–15 years old, and 25 (43.10%) 16–18 years old
Patients with good compliance (strictly adhering to the diet) numbered 26 (44.82%), those with moderate compliance (following the diet with some deviations and exceeding the recommended carbohydrate intake) numbered 15 (25.86%), and those with poor compliance (frequent violations of the diet and multiple consumptions of inappropriate foods) numbered 17 (29.31%).
The 58 patients who completed the study underwent follow-up examinations to assess the effects of the diet on anthropometric, clinical, and laboratory markers of metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance, cardiovascular risk factors, and certain hormone levels. Compliance with the diet, common difficulties in adhering to it, side effects, and positive changes in the patients’ health were analyzed.
Gastrointestinal complaints were reported in 15 (25.8%) of the patients. Seven (12%) had constipation, most commonly in the first 2–3 weeks after starting the diet. It was noticeable that these were mainly children with improper dietary habits before the diet, disliking almost all vegetables. These patients were advised to increase the amount of fiber consumed in the form of low-carbohydrate vegetables, as well as the amount of fluid intake. Four (6.88%) reported short episodes of diarrhea, and four (6.88%) reported abdominal pain—one of whom was a girl with dysmenorrhea. Only five (8.6%) of the children reported feeling hungry, more commonly in the first month of starting the diet. One of the girls (1.72%) reported a lengthening of the intervals between menstrual cycles.
Results:
* At the end of the study, the average weight loss for the entire group was 6.45 kg, with a reduction in BMI of 3.12 kg/m2.
* Significant improvements were also observed in insulin resistance indicators, including fasting insulin levels, HOMA-IR index, QUICKI (p < 0.0001), and adiponectin (p = 0.04).
* The cases of hepatosteatosis decreased twofold, the number of patients with arterial hypertension was significantly reduced, as well as the number of children receiving antihypertensive therapy.
* Additionally, the number of patients meeting the criteria for metabolic syndrome decreased threefold.
Conclusions:
A well-formulated short-term ketogenic diet is effective in treating obesity, metabolic syndrome, and related comorbidities, and can be part of a comprehensive approach for these patients.
Free Full Text:
www.mdpi.com/2079-9721/13/4/94
@drjasonfung @bigfatsurprise @FructoseNo @garytaubes @TuckerGoodrich @SecKennedy @SBakerMD -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Conventional thinking on GLP-1 drugs is that they target the brain to inhibit appetite. We eat less and so we lose weight.
But do they?
A new study in Cell Metabolism suggests something far more profound.
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/why-do-we-l… -
gary taubes reposted
David Diamond
@LDLSkeptic
What if all doctors were made aware of the small absolute risk benefit of statins.
What if all ads were required to display the absolute risk benefit?
Would docs be as enthusiastic about prescribing them to their patients?
@ethanjweiss @bschermd @KenDBerryMD @ifixhearts -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Some large proportion of folks who use GLP-1 drugs for weight loss are going to stop, either from choice or necessity.
What do we know about post-GLP-1 diet therapy?
I.e., what to eat to maintain weight loss?
Diet or Drugs 3? First Wegovy, Then What? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Also worth sharing.
Dave did something no one had ever done, observed a phenomena that couldn't be explained by conventional thinking on lipids, and then continued thinking about it critically and doing what was necessary (so far) to test his thinking.
Doing good science doesn't come with a PhD. (H/t the Wizard of Oz for his speech to the Scarecrow.) It comes with critical thinking and the persistence to do what's necessary to establish reliable knowledge.
Bret Scher, MD
@bschermd
Regardless of the study results, one thing that deserves notice is how Dave, a “non-scientist”, made this whole thing happen - came up with the idea, recruited the team, helped design the study, crowdfunded it, and helped bring it to publication. Beyond impressive!
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is a study worth sharing.
The interpretation is limited, but the observation is very promising for those of us who prefer ketogenic diets with elevated LDL to ketogenic diets with statin therapy.
Dr Shawn Baker 🥩
@SBakerMD
People with super high LDL cholesterol on a ketogenic diet showed no association with heart disease! 🤔-this is a study worth sharing!!
-
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
New Free Metabolic Psychiatry CME Courses Now Live!
Two AMA PRA Category 1 CME offerings by top metabolic psychiatry experts @ChrisPalmerMD and @GeorgiaEdeMD are now live on mycme.com:
🎓 Brain Energy: The Metabolic Theory of Mental Illness – Dr. Chris Palmer
🎓 Managing Major Mental Illness with Dietary Change – Dr. Georgia Ede
These sessions guide clinicians in understanding and applying metabolic therapies to treat mental disorders.
We look forward to seeing the impact these courses make in raising awareness of the benefits of metabolic therapies for individuals living with mental illness.
Huge kudos to Dr. Palmer and Dr. Ede for their hard work in making these resources available!
Learn more 👇
www.mycme.com/courses/brain-energy-the-metabolic-theory-o…
www.mycme.com/courses/managing-major-mental-illness-with-…
#medicaltraining -
gary taubes reposted
LowCarbUSA®
@lowcarbusa
check out the latest speaker list: www.lowcarbusa.org/san-diego-2025/
Gary Taubes
Robert Cywes, MD, PhD
Dr. Ben Bocchicchio
Annette Bosworth, MD
Dr. Brian Lenzkes, MD
Roshani Sanghani, MBBS, MD, MHP
Dr. Peter Ballerstedt
Robert Kiltz, MD
Tony Hampton, MD
Csilla Ari D’Agostino Ph.D.
Belinda Fettke has confirmed she is coming from Australia!!
Michael Hoffman, MD, PhD, FCP(SA), FAAN - Neurologist with a fascinating resume listed in his bio on the event page - will be heading up the special dedicated neurological session planning.
@garytaubes @carbaddictiondr @drbenbo @AnnetteBosworth @BrianLenzkes @GrassBased @doctorkiltz -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Ketogenic therapy is emerging as a promising intervention for bipolar disorder, offering new hope through a metabolic approach to mental health.
This #worldbipolarday, we're sharing powerful stories and insights about how targeting brain energy and metabolism can support mood stability and overall well-being.
In this video, individuals with lived experience and experts in the field explain how ketogenic therapy has helped reduce manic episodes, improve emotional regulation, and restore a sense of calm.
By addressing the root causes of brain dysfunction, metabolic strategies are transforming lives and challenging how we think about mental health treatment.
It's more than a diet. It's a movement toward treating the whole person.
Check out the new Bipolar Disorder Resource Hub at metabolicmind.org/bipolar-disorder.
⭐️Featured: @GeorgiaEdeMD @ChrisPalmerMD @IainCampbellPhD @StevenTrunce @LWSchizophrenia @BaszuckiMatt @OliverSeligman @MsMiaMendez @JourneyofHope4UThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm less confident than @EricTopol that this Harvard nutritional epidemiology is meaningful. When it's been tested in clinical trials, it failed the tests.
Part 3 in my substack series on nutritional epidemiology begins with this same Harvard study.
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/whats-a-hea…
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Only 9% of >105,000 people with 30-years of follow-up reached age 70 without chronic diseases.
Our diet and healthy aging, a review of the new report this week, and placing it in context.
In a new edition of Ground Truths, link in my profile
open-access -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If a single clinic can do this in the UK, imagine what a nation-wide program could accomplish?
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
Our 151st case of drug free T2D remission 🥳Just look how high his blood sugars were and yet he avoided drugs. He is so proud and feels properly well😊 This is how we did it nutrition.bmj.com/content/early/2023/01/02/bmjnph-2022-00… Remember starch is ‘soon to be sugar’👍
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How did we get to a place where out dietary beliefs (and the latest news) are based almost entirely on the most unreliable research?
And why, of course, don't the nutritionists care?
Less Butter, More Plant Oils? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/less-butter… -
gary taubes reposted
Baszucki Group
@BaszuckiGroup
Can ketogenic therapy ease the symptom burden of youth diagnosed with bipolar disorder?
Baszucki Group is excited to announce the launch of two new initiatives across multiple sites exploring the effectiveness of ketogenic therapy for children and adolescents with bipolar disorder. The participating groups include a family resource center and four academic research institutions offering specialty programs devoted to treating serious mental illness in children and adolescents. These projects aim to develop ketogenic therapy programs for youth populations and establish pilot data to fuel future randomized control trials.
“Our family's experience with bipolar disorder gave us a deep understanding of the helplessness parents feel when conventional treatment options don’t work fully,” said @janellison, co-founder and President of Baszucki Group. “We are proud to support research that aims to expand those options and provide families with the resources and education they need to integrate ketogenic therapy–which gave our son his life back–into their care plans.”
Read the news: bwnews.pr/4hvGvdf -
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
Really take a moment and consider this...
To borrow from @garytaubes -- imagine if diabetes were an infectious disease spreading across the world as a multi-decade pandemic... would we seek to resolve its spread more than we do now?
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨🚴♂️World-class triathlete Lionel Sanders just dropped a bombshell: he’s pre-diabetic.
...true BRAVERY by Lionel, but shocking? Not to us.
In 2023, we uncovered "very fit" runners—⬆️VO2Max & ⬇️Body Fat—silently battling the same.
☹️Skeptics laughed. Yet...docs and athletes DM’d us: 'We’re seeing it too.'
We ran an analysis on 24-hour glucose data in athletes? Eye-opening at the incidence of level >100mg/dL.
📊🧑🍳We re-ran another analysis on what predicted elevated fasting glucose values in athletes. Shockingly, BMI and fitness level (VO2Max) DID NOT predict basal glucose metabolism/health over time. What did? Daily nutritional patterns.
Twitter/X diet discussions can often be hyperbolic, irrational, and frankly unpleasent—but this isn’t noise. It’s evidence.
🌎We know the incidence of pre-diabetes in the US in those >20 y/o is >50%. 80% of people don't know they have pre-diabetes.
🔬We saw it in our studies. Now, elite athletes are publicly disclosing they are seeing the same. So proud of Lionel's bravery as he catalogs the steps he has taken, which has improved his numbers and symptoms.
📈Living with Type-1 Diabetes, I know all too well the symptoms Lionel experienced (fatigue, lethargia, impaired recovery) with elevated glucose (& likely elevated insulin) values. I applaud his bravery, and I am cheering him on as he catalogs his journey to optimal health.
🔗Links to studies are below. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Diet or Drugs 2? The Eating-Less Question.
Wegovy and Ozempic will curb your appetite. Is that why they cause weight loss?
Let's talk about some evidence to the contrary.
open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/drugs-or-di… -
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
In his substack @garytaubes asks “Diet or Drugs?”
He discusses GLP1 drugs in a fair way also pointing out that lifestyle therapies need more attention and more support considering the results from @virtahealth and @gotowardhealth
uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/diet-or-drugs?public… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Media reporting on the GLP-1 drug revolution is a never-ending stream of articles on the efficacy of these drugs, and the potential benefits.
But shouldn't dietary therapy always be the context? Which is better? Which is safer?
Diet or Drugs? open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/diet-or-dru… -
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
🚨 NEW PAPER 🚨
Making America Healthy and reversing obesity, without drugs & injections
By focusing only on metabolic health, patients lost 15.5% of their weight while STOPPING unnecessary medications
👇🏻👇🏻
50 patients
⬇️43lbs on average ‼️
💥~15.5% weight loss at one year💥
🤔 Majority of patients KEPT losing weight even after stopping GLP1
🤔 Even at 1 year, 76% of patients were STILL losing weight - BUSTING THE MYTH that “patients can’t adhere to diets longterm”
I’ll walk you through why some of this is REALLY important
This paper looks at the 1 year weight loss results from our virtual metabolic health program with CGMs, smart equipment, an app and virtual coaches.
Paper linked:
www.frontiersin.org/journals/nutrition/articles/10.3389/f…
Please RT, bookmark & share this link 🔗 to spread awareness so doctors know the power of metabolic health and lifestyle changes NOT only pushing medications 💊
🧵/THREAD -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
After a lengthy run of wonderful publicity from the media, @thedanbuettner and his @bluezones ran into a storm of criticism. A good thing?
Criticism is always good, but it misses the point.
Life Lessons from the Blue Zones? Maybe Not. open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/life-lesson… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This could be a mental health revolution.
Watch this video.
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
We are thrilled today to introduce THINK+SMART, a new community-inspired tool from Metabolic Mind designed to help individuals take control of their mental health.
THINK+SMART is an acronym that describes a metabolic approach to mental health. THINK stands for therapeutic integration of nutritional ketosis. SMART stands for sleep, move, avoid, rebuild, and track. Together, these provide a framework for implementing personalized ketogenic and metabolic therapies to combat mental illness.
Imagine being in the driver’s seat of your mental well-being, guided by cutting-edge clinical expertise and research from experts like @ChrisPalmerMD, @GeorgiaEdeMD, @KetoCounselor, @IainCampbellPhD, and @MitoPsychoBio and inspired by stories of resilience from those who’ve walked this path like @MsMiaMendez, @LWSchizophrenia, @bright_har6612, @DrEricRodgers, @Carobeckwith, @JourneyofHope4U, @iam_emilyanne, @BaszuckiMatt, @robynrdobbins, Steven T, Wesley Braden, Donika Hristova, and more. This is what THINK+SMART provides!
Whether you’re a practitioner or someone living with a psychiatric disorder, we hope THINK+SMART will serve as a resource for improving metabolism to improve your overall physical and mental health.
Visit metabolicmind.org/think-smart to learn more.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Interesting, but I'm less confident than @davidaSinclair that reverse causality isn't the answer.
The longitudinal studies tell us that healthier people are physically active, not that the physical activity makes them healthier. It might (hope so) but these studies don't say.
David Sinclair
@davidasinclair
A 50-year-long study of twins finds exercise may not be as important for longevity as we think
A thread...🧵 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Best article I've read on nutrition in the NYT in years.
Unsurprisingly, an essay written by a researcher from London who did much of the work, not an NYT reporter.
Sorry, No Secret to Life Is Going to Make You Live to 110 www.nytimes.com/2025/01/20/opinion/extreme-longevity-flaw… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The concept of ultraprocessed food has always struck me as more pseudoscience than science.
Why don't other journalists share my skepticism?
Bad Health Journalism: ultra-processed edition open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/bad-health-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Fascinating research. Important implications.
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🧵Very-low carb (ketogenic; LCHF) vs high-carb diet (HCLF):
-Ironman triathletes (n=10)🚴♂️
-"Hitting the Wall"🥵
-Homeostasis monitoring ("Keto-Adaptation")📈
Our hypothesis was wrong...again
🔍CRITICAL QUESTIONS:
1) Does adopting an LCHF diet impair strenuous time-to-exhaustion performance?
2) Does carb supplementation (3.4g/20min) during exercise, 6-12x lower than current CHO fuelling recommendations, improve time-to-exhaustion on LCHF? If so, how?
3) Keto-adaptation homeostasis timeline?
🔏KEY CONTROLS:
1) Randomized & Controlled
2) ❎Crossover Design
3) ↔️Calories
4) ↔️Physical Activity Load
5) Dietary Compliance:⬆️BHB + CGM
What did we see? 1/n
🔗Detailed study breakdown below -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My conversation with Jason Fung for the Fasting & Longevity Summit drops tomorrow!
Don’t miss this chance to hear from 40+ experts diving deep into fasting and longevity.
Watch our interview & register here: drtalks.com/summit/fasting-longevity?uid=828&oid=87&ref=4367 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Congratulations to Dr. Unwin and his patients.
If this were a competition, my guesstimate at the current score:
Unwin 150
American Diabetes Association 0.
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
AT LAST 🥳 tonight 6 minutes of low carb magic on prime-time National TV to celebrate 150 yes ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY cases of drug-free remission of T2 Diabetes in a single UK NHS clinic (mine!) Just choose foods that don’t put your blood sugar up! www.itv.com/news/2025-01-03/doctor-cures-type-2-diabetes-… @DiabetesUK @Oliviaguthrietv @bigfatsurprise @drjasonfung @SBakerMD
-
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Check out the New York Post's article highlighting ketogenic therapy for mental illness, sharing @BaszuckiMatt story and the incredible work of individuals like @ChrisPalmerMD, @GeorgiaEdeMD, @IainCampbellPhD, and @garytaubes
Nora Kenney Mittiga 🤍🪩☀️☕️🇻🇦✨
@NoraKenney_
Often dismissed as "bro science," the keto diet is making strides to address serious mental illness. It deserves attention as part of @RobertKennedyJr's encouraging #maha initiative to explore the critical link between diet and health.
Me in @nypost: nypost.com/2024/12/28/opinion/how-the-controversial-keto-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ever wonder why the USDA’s famous Dietary Guidelines for Americans keep promoting variations on the same mostly-plant diets, as the population it serves just gets ever fatter and more diabetic?
uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com/p/as-obesity-rates-sky… -
gary taubes reposted
Krisna Hanks 😄
@Square1Wellness
Keep your eye on the hat trick! If you don't ask the right questions you will get more of the same. Great piece by .@garytaubes "As obesity rates skyrocket, Dietary Guidelines go from being pro-vegetable to anti-meat. How'd that happen?" open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/as-obesity-…
-
gary taubes reposted
Shebani Sethi, MD
@ShebaniMD
As we close the year, I’m humbled to learn that our research work made it into Stanford’s top scientific advancements of 2024. May we continue to harness the transformative power of metabolic science in 2025 to drive lasting change! #metabolicpsychiatry med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2024/12/top-scientific-adv…
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Congratulations to @ShebaniMD whose pilot study of ketogenic diet for serious mental illness was named one of Stanford's top 10 scientific advances of 2024.
med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2024/12/top-scientific-adv…
"Pilot study shows ketogenic diet improves severe mental illness: Research led by Shebani Sethi, MD, an associate professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences, has found that dietary interventions can help treat severe mental illness such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. She and her colleagues learned that a ketogenic diet not only addresses common metabolic side effects from antipsychotic medications, but it also improves patients’ psychiatric conditions." -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
New @AmDiabetesAssn guidelines for #obesity in T2 #diabetes. Once again:
"500–750 kcal/day energy deficit is recommended" (hasn't this been tried for a century???)
Regarding diet, "no single way is best"
👉Low-carb diet mentioned exactly ... zero times
diabetesjournals.org/care/article/48/Supplement_1/S167/15… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nice to see researchers who understand that fat storage is mediated by fat uptake and release (lipolysis) by the fat cells, not just (if at all) by how much we eat.
They do the right experiment--i.e., fix calories.
The result is consistent with a fuel-partitioning hypothesis.
Scott Isaacs
@scottisaacsmd
Shortened sleep duration blunts adrenergic stimulation of lipolysis which may potentiate fat gain independent of caloric intake.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/oby.24162 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Damning observation:
The "expert" authors of this report--"scientists," as @andreaapetersen repeatedly calls them in the WSJ--apparently do not care enough to check the references supporting their recommendations to make sure they do.
What else will they do in their lives that is more important?
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
My take on the just-released scientific report for the US Dietary Guidelines
-only 17% of clinical trials listed support claims that these guidelines will promote better health (# is preliminary)
-Reducing poultry, meat, eggs will make the guidelines more nutritionally deficient and harm health
(next tweet has link. No paywall) -
gary taubes reposted
Maryanne Demasi, PhD
@MaryanneDemasi
🥂The finale of a landmark libel case against a British tabloid
blog.maryannedemasi.com/p/the-finale-of-a-landmark-libel-…
Public vindication for health experts @malcolmken and @zoeharcombe in open court.
@ClareCraigPath @KenDBerryMD @BrianLenzkes @CollinRugg @MailOnline -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Write about the sad state of health reporting, as I did on Uncertainty Principles, and readers will ask for your opinion on other articles.
In this case, @TheAtlantic on why we stopped cooking with tallow.
Bad Health Journalism, an addendum open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/bad-health-… -
gary taubes reposted
Sam Feltham
@SamFeltham
Donations are open for one week only! Go, go, go 🙏🙏🙏
@DrRobgalloway @DoctorChrisVT @ExpressGilo @lowcarbGP @drjenunwin @JimBethell @NutritionNetwrk @GeorgiaEdeMD @bigfatsurprise @garytaubes @janellison @IainCampbellPhD @BenBikmanPhD @RobertLustigMD @drjasonfung
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
The Rebellion Begins Today!
Join us for the Real Food Rebellion Big Give’s Christmas Challenge (@biggiveorg). For one week only, every £1 you donate will be matched, turning £15,000 into an incredible £30,000!
www.phcuk.org/biggive -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
🚨New consensus statement for people with T1 diabetes.
A very low-carbohydrate diet is an evidence-based way to maintain a healthy A1c. While reducing dependence on medication.
Important for patients and practitioners! @TheSMHP @DoctorTro @drericwestman 👏
journalofmetabolichealth.org/index.php/jmh/article/view/1… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I've started my own Substack, Uncertainty Principles.
Ever wonder why, in the midst of a public health crisis (ob/db epidemics), health reporters have such unconditional faith in the authorities?
Aren't reporters supposed to be skeptical?
U.P. 1: In Defense of Bad Health Journalism open.substack.com/pub/uncertaintyprinciples/p/up-1-in-def… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
I hope you will all subscribe to @garytaubes' new Substack "Uncertainty Principles"
Most of us would not even know about lowcarb/keto were it not for his seminal book, Good Calories, Bad Calories (2007) and earlier NYT article (1998?), which propelled this idea (back) into the spotlight. His incredibly rigorous, comprehensive review of the science is what made this revolution possible.
substack.com/@garytaubes -
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
The Ketogenic Diet as a Transdiagnostic Treatment for Neuropsychiatric Disorders: Mechanisms and Clinical Outcomes
I'm delighted to share this new systematic review from our team including 53 publications representing 1,906 individuals!
🧵 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Very nicely done and very much worth reading.
@chrismasterjohn not only does an excellent job of discussing the seed oil evidence rationally, but he manages to get in a quick masterclass on the major issues with nutritional epidemiology.
Chris Masterjohn
@ChrisMasterjohn
Now that @realdonaldtrump and @RobertKennedyJ have launched a national discussion about the role of seed oils in health, and now that Kennedy has been hazed into the presidential cool kids club by eating seed oil fries on Trump Force One, it’s time to talk about SEED OILS.
🧵👇
cc @SwipeWright @jeremykauffman @calleymeans @CaseyMeansMD -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Just out: My op-ed in @thehill on the US Dietary Guidelines: the problems and how to fix them. Please share!
"The current guidelines have likely spawned a chronic disease crisis that has caused millions of premature deaths and accounts for the vast majority of America’s $4.5 trillion annual healthcare spending.
Fortunately, merely fixing the guidelines could reverse our chronic disease epidemic, without the need for any new programs or new spending."
@RobertKennedyJr @NicoleShanahan @MAHAalliance
thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/4997878-trump-health-nutri… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As always, @nsbarsky is a must read.
Please read his latest in The Guardian on the enormous good that RFK Jr could do if he leaves his conspiracy theories behind.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/nov/21/can-rfk-tra… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The military has a term for it: reinforcing failure.
Is the problem with nutrition education in med school one of quantity (not enough) or quality?
& economists (not nutritionists) find a clever way to study early life effects of sugar consumption. open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/a-substack-updat… -
gary taubes reposted
John Schoonbee
@john_schoonbee
I wish everyone in the US would read this
(Absolute kudos to the bravery and accountability of Janet King and Cheryl Achterberg for putting their names on this opinion piece.)
Before reading it and the highlights below, consider who they are:
Janet C. King, PhD, is Professor Emeritus of Nutritional Sciences at UC Berkeley, and CHAIR of the 2005 Dietary Guidelines Advisory (DGA) Committee. Cheryl Achterberg is a former Dean at The Ohio State U and was a member of the 2010 DGA Committee.
A handful of quotes/points raised in the letter:
1. Referencing the chronic disease crises in the US : "As former members of the expert committee that oversees the science for the U.S. Dietary Guidelines, we can tell you that these chronic diseases are PRIMARILY driven by poor diet, and our guidelines are part of the problem.
2. They mention that the guidelines were controversial to start with, and that already in 1980 the National Academy of Sciences president warned of potential unintended consequences from implementing recommendations with such scant evidence.
3. That poor evidence told us "to fear fat and instead consume about half of all calories as carbohydrates". The current guidelines recommend up to 10 percent of calories as added sugar!
4. As they write, "This advice fundamentally misunderstands metabolism."
5. Finally they state that "national nutrition policy … no longer reflects the best or most current science."
6. And they reflect on conflicts of interest of the DGA members, the lack of transparency, the cherry picking of evidence, the refusal to comply in full with any of the 11 concrete recommendations of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine made in 2017 to improve rigour in the guideline process.
Mea culpa if ever there was one.
Good on them, and may the farm bill they highlight be passed. That a bill "mandating greater transparency and adherence to rigorous scientific standards" be at all controversial is mind-blowing.
Guiding principles: How US dietary guidelines contribute to obesity (thehill.com)
@DoctorTro @bigfatsurprise @garytaubes @lowcarbGP @CampbellMurdoch @virtahealth @level2_health @KetoMojo @GeorgiaEdeMD @Metabolic_Mind @GroHealth #lowcarb #metabolichealth #nutrition -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
Our #jcem @TheEndoSociety paper Efficacy and Safety of Long-term (10-Year) Ketogenic Diet Therapy in a Patient With Type 1 Diabetes
🥇🥳Selected by @TheEndoSociety Thematic Issue: Diabetes 2024 (academic.oup.com/endocrinesociety/pages/diabetes-2024)
Exciting to see so much interest on the potential utility of this therapeutic strategy for managing metabolic disease.
Full description and video about this study below👇
@Joseph_Watso @AusRob_PhD @sa01singar @fsucehhs @FSUResearch @FSUISSM @REV_Insulin_Res @Metabolic_Mind @IainCampbellPhD @diaTribeNews @BeyondType1 @MCRiddell1 @BenBikmanPhD @KenDBerryMD
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨🚨10-Year Longitudinal Data On Ketogenic Diet Adverse Events, Bone Mineral Density, Thyroid Function, and Kidney Function: PART 2🚨🚨
NEW DATA OUT TODAY: academic.oup.com/jcemcr/article/2/7/luae102/7710382
We (@Joseph_Watso/ @AusRob_PhD/ Samuel Klein) just published our PART 2 paper looking at long-term safety and clinical efficacy of ketogenic diet on:
☠️Adverse Events
🦴Bone Mineral Density
🔥Thyroid Function
🫘Kidney Function
...in part 1 we measured advanced cardiovascular health profile in an adult with elevated cardiovascular risk (type 1 diabetes) who followed a ketogenic diet for 10 years and sustained euglycemia (10-Year HbA1c 5.5%). See paper here: journals.physiology.org/doi/abs/10.1152/ajpcell.00694.2023
PART 2: What did we find?
👉PLEASE WATCH 📷 VIDEO ABSTRACT here (<3 min): youtu.be/hamiuTMGZFU
☠️1) Adverse Events: Many research and clinicians have raised concern over the potential of a ketogenic to elevated the risk of severe adverse events (e.g., hospitalization due to ketoacidosis). Over a 10 year period following a ketogenic diet, we observed no hypoglycemic or hyperglycemic events requiring medical attention (60 Day CGM Data: 0% time <54mg/dL & >180mg/dL). Patient also presented with intact hypoglycemic awareness.
🦴2) Bone Mineral Density: Prior data suggests that short term ketogenic diet may impair markers of bone modeling/remodeling. However, most of these report are short in nature. People with type 1 diabetes are at HIGH risk for lower bone mineral density and fracture (hyperglycemia is risk factor). Here, we observed no negative impact on bone mineral density (using GOLD STANDARD DXA) on a ketogenic diet, despite 10 years of aging with type 1 diabetes.
🔥3) Thyroid Function: Concerns have been raised on how reducing carbohydrates may shift thyroid hormone status and metabolism. However, most of these studies are </=7 days in length. Following a ketogenic diet over a 10-year period, here we observe no negative impact on thyroid function with a 10-year ketogenic diet.
🫘4) Kidney Function: Microvascular disease is a very common complication of type 1 diabetes as hyperglycemia damages the small blood vessel in the kidneys. Adverse structural kidney changes are observed in children with type 1 diabetes as early as 1.5-5 years post diagnosis with eGFR declining over time. We did not observe any deterioration of kidney function in patient with type 1 diabetes over a 10-year period while achieving 10-Year 5.5% HbA1c following a ketogenic diet.
🚨⚠️9) LIMITATIONS: Reminder on limitations. This is an individual case. The importance of this data is in the sheer absence of short or long-term data, hypothesized risk of a KD, and popularity and use of KD which we hope help generate future research questions.
🗒️CONCLUSIONS: In the longest known longitudinal report of a ketogenic diet in a patient with type 1 diabetes, we observed no severe adverse events or negative impacts on bone, kidney, or thyroid health. We in our PART 1 paper, we observed above average cardiovascular disease health. These initial findings should provoke further research into interventions like ketogenic diets to reduce the long-term health risks faced by those living with T1D while closely monitoring both traditional and advanced cardiovascular risk markers. Especially considering that currently available therapies do no reliably allow patients to achieve <7% HbA1c, let alone <5.7% HbA1c.
@Joseph_Watso
Cardiovascular & Applied Physiology Lab
caplaboratory.com
Studying how health behaviors (e.g., diet, exercise, etc.) affect cardiovascular health and physiology
@SansumDiabetes
sansum.org
Studying how lifestyle, tools, and medicine affect people with diabetes.
@fsucehhs @FSUResearch @FSUISSM @AJPCellPhys
@diaTribeNews @BeyondType1 @MCRiddell1 @nicknorwitz @Metabolic_Mind @DominicDAgosti2 @BenBikmanPhDThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Interesting natural experiment: compare disease rates in folks born in the UK before and after the end of WW2 sugar-rationing.
Those born in a sugar-poor world had less Db & hypertension and stayed disease-free longer. 👍
Being Sugar-Deprived Had Major Effects on These Childrens’ Health www.nytimes.com/2024/10/31/health/sugar-rationing-britain… -
gary taubes reposted
Tara Henley
@TaraRHenley
This week on the Lean Out pod, I'm thrilled to be joined by author and award-winning journalist @garytaubes, for a wide-ranging conversation about obesity, the dangers of falling in love with a hyopthesis & the state of science journalism. To stream episode, click link in bio.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Time for a conversation about the anti-aging pill that's in the news (if not all the rage). Thoughts on the risk and benefits of taking rapamycin to slow the aging process.
Oh... and I'm starting a new Substack. uncertaintyprinciples.substack.com
News! & Longer Living Through Chemistry open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/news-and-longer-… -
gary taubes reposted
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
Happy to announce that we've launched a new round of the @GoodSciProject - JHU MA in Science Writing Fellowship. advanced.jhu.edu/good-science/
👉$5,000 Reporting Grants
👉Open to all journalists! -
gary taubes reposted
Jess Apple
@jessapple
It was an honor to launch the Metabolic Revolution with the world’s best team of volunteers and esteemed speakers. Watch out, dietary guidelines… the people are done with you. 💪🎉🙌 @MetRevolution @bigfatsurprise @oneofonebillion
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Proud and honored to emcee the first-ever rally for metabolic health, in Washington, DC on the grounds of the Washington Monument yesterday. Such a fantastic group of speakers, super-committed volunteers. And the leadership of @jessapple--what a star!
#metrev #metabolicrevolution
@MetRevolution -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thanks, Matthew. We've been there. (I'd definitely include Robert Whitaker @Mad_In_America .)
Particularly this from Kate's Grist article, which seems to be the first step down into the rabbit hole.
Matthew C. Nisbet
@mcnisbet
1) @grist's @katemyoder writing in the tradition of @horganism, @voosen, @CharlesCMann, @revkin, @garytaubes & Emma Marris uses a profile of @BTI's @PatrickTBrown31 to reveal for readers how "science really works" as #sts scholar Steve Shapin might put it. grist.org/science/patrick-brown-profile-climate-scientist…
-
gary taubes reposted
Jess Apple
@jessapple
It's time for change, and we're taking the metabolic health conversation from X to Washington, D.C. Join us! We need your voice! metabolicrevolution.org
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Precisely the right question.
If the answer is yes and more than a few, then that clinical/anecdotal evidence can motivate randomized trials.
Caveat: we need to see health improvement disassociated from carb restriction also.
Yes, that makes this tricky, but otherwise an obvious interpretation is "it's the carbs."
We do think we have copious examples, including RCTs, of carb restriction independent of seed oils.
HumanX
@TheDataAP
So do we have stories of people whose health improved (cured) after stopping seed oils?
-
gary taubes reposted
trikomes
@trikomes
New podcast with @garytaubes:
"Bad Science, Nutrition Epidemiology, History of Obesity Research, Diet & Metabolic Health"
Link in bio.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Here's the NYTimes with the "latest" from the American Heart Association (AHA)
Advising food > drugs is always a good idea, so that's good.
However, lowering LDL-C via diet has been shown in clinical trials to have little-to-no effect on longer-term 'hard outcomes' incl. cardiovascular events, cardiovascular mortality or total mortality. This fact has been found in ~2 dozen systematic reviews. So lowering LDL-C w/ diet is not effective for reducing the events that matter--heart attacks and death.
The Times then recommends the "Portfolio Diet," which seems to be a rebranding of the National Cholesterol Education Program diets along with some culling of clinical trials using the word "portfolio" to describe a selection of foods. The principal study to support the "Portfolio Diet" (published in an AHA journal cited by the Times is on data from Harvard's epidemiological studies, which can only show association, not a cause-and-effect relationship. And again, the outcome measured is LDL-C, which is not linked in diet trials to hard outcomes such as heart attacks and death.
To raise your "good" HDL-C, the Times again cites AHA advice, to exercise. Although a far more efficient way to raise your HDL-C is to eat saturated fat.
The pharma-and-food funded AHA has been giving out misguided (wrong) advice to the public on heart disease since 1961, when it told Americans to swap out saturated fats for seed oils (for decades prior, it had been funded by Procter & Gamble, maker of Crisco Oil--and when I last checked, it still was). The @nytimeswell might consider some critical reporting on this group. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Neil Barsky's latest in The Guardian is once again required reading.
What the next president should do to solve the diabetes epidemic in America and the crisis in metabolic health.
Please read and share.
www.theguardian.com/global/commentisfree/article/2024/sep… -
gary taubes reposted
Benjamin Bikman
@BenBikmanPhD
The impact and relevance of this case study shouldn't be overlooked. IBS (inflammatory bowel disease) is often a lifelong struggle, filled with various failed attempts to improve the disease. Most people would never think that a primary trigger for their IBS is the plants they eat. As indicated in the report, the more the patients removed plants and focused on animal-sourced nutrition, the better they got. @nicknorwitz @AdrianSotoMota @SBakerMD @reverohealth www.frontiersin.org/journals/nutrition/articles/10.3389/f…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr Shawn Baker 🥩
@SBakerMD
www.frontiersin.org/journals/nutrition/articles/10.3389/f…
I NEED YOUR HELP an new scientific paper on the Carnivore Diet diet healing inflammatory bowel disease was just released -We need to get this link shared as widely as possible-Please retweet AND also make YOUR own post with this link! Thanks-this is how we fight against the “eat the bugs/soy narrative” -
gary taubes reposted
trikomes
@trikomes
Talking with @garytaubes next week on the podcast about insulin resistance, modern human diet patterns, and the carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity (among other things).
Post questions here if you have them. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The latest chapter in the CIM – EBM debate is out today in Nature Metabolism: “On the pathogenesis of obesity: causal models and missing pieces of the puzzle” rdcu.be/dRqT7.
In short, tales of the CIM's demise/refutation were greatly exaggerated.
The paper is the product of a September 2023 invite-only workshop hosted by the Novo Nordisk Foundation in Copenhagen. The attendees were aa small group (including yours truly) representing the two viewpoints plus several other perspectives on obesity pathogenesis. @KevinH_PhD was in attendance as was @JohnSpeakman4 and both are co-authors on the paper (as am I).
In effect, the paper level-sets the debate by presenting the two models side-by-side. It discusses differences and implications for testing them and solving the problem of obesity.
Interestingly, consensus was reached concerning a critical feature of the EBM, per the first sentence of the abstract:
“Application of the physical laws of energy and mass conservation at the whole-body level is not necessarily informative about causal mechanisms of weight gain and the development of obesity.”
These physical laws have been a major justification of the EBM practically from its get-go, more than 100 years ago. Many still evoke them as somehow reason that the CIM cannot be considered seriously.
Consequently, the focus is on differences in how the two models view the underlying metabolic physiology involved in obesity development. Additional context for the CIM (if not the debate given its new footing) is provided by our recent publication in Obesity Reviews (onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/obr.13795), which is cited in this new paper.
Kudos to Arne Astrup of NNF for bravely assembling the experts on either side of the debate, and to Faidon Magkos for herding them together to produce the paper. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Did a ketogenic diet really do no better (and possibly worse) than a diet restricted only in sugary foods and beverages?
Wouldn't it be nice if that were true, but was it?
Burying the Lede (and the Data) open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/burying-the-lede… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm not an RFK Jr enthusiast, but he's right about the chronic illness crisis and about the likely reasons.
He's certain right about @bigfatsurprise and her exceptional book.
You can get more of Nina's cutting-edge journalism (and mine as well) at unsettledscience.substack.com
Robert F. Kennedy Jr
@RobertKennedyJr
Chronic illness is sapping our nation’s vitality. If you include obesity, 60% of Americans have a chronic illness today.
Every American has a family member or friend with one or more chronic illnesses. The Medicare and Medicaid budgets are now 5 times larger than our military budget.
At least 1 in 5 children are diabetic or pre diabetic.
Cancer, Alzheimers, dementia, and autoimmune disorders are on the rise, while heart disease persists as the leading cause of death in Americans.
In the past I’ve pointed to many factors that might be driving this surge in chronic disease: toxic pollution of our soil, air, and water, pesticide residues and “forever chemicals” like PFAS in our food, the childhood vaccine schedule, and electromagnetic pollution. All of these possible causes deserve further study. But here I want to point to one more key factor: the rise of processed foods and the replacement of saturated fat in our diets with highly processed seed oils.
Saturated fat found in animal foods was demonized for decades, the result of flawed science and massive PR campaigns by companies purveying seed oils, food additives, and high fructose corn syrup. Corporations like Procter & Gamble corrupted the American Heart Association, universities, and government agencies.
Today, finally, people are waking up to the fact that we were lied to. If you want to understand this classic example of corporate capture, government malfeasance, and the corruption of science, read the NYT bestseller The Big Fat Surprise, by Nina Teicholz. This exhaustively cited book exposes a health scandal that has contributed enormously to this nation’s chronic disease epidemic. Ironically, Nina was a vegetarian for over 20 years prior to writing this book.
Thanks in part to this book, and the tireless work of alternative health practitioners and researchers over the last 50 years, doctors, dieticians, nutritionists, and the general public are waking up to this issue despite the continued effort by big business and the USDA to keep the lid on it. To this day, the USDA recommends keeping saturated fats to only 10% of caloric intake. Meanwhile people continue to become ill and die because of this lie.
The same lie has been one of the biggest contributing factors to wiping out small family farms and ranches. The dramatic drop in fat consumption over the last 60 years has driven families off the land into the towns and cities. This ripple effect rolled through small feedlots and packing houses with the same damage. Once productive land for our land and communities was sold and covered with subdivisions and septic tanks.
Three generations of the farm and ranch communities have been driven off the land. We are only one generation away from all agriculture being controlled by megacorporations, foreign interests, and institutional investors.
We need to get off of processed foods and get back on real food and get strong again!
#kennedy24 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Our expertise crisis in a nutshell: Harvard's absurd study 'showing' that red meat causes diabetes.
Type 2 diabetes is DEFINED as high blood sugar. What spikes blood sugar? CARBOHYDRATES (sugars, starches). What doesn't spike blood sugar? MEAT
Why did Harvard even bother to do a weak, associational study looking at iron and diabetes, when we already know what causes diabetes? Moreoever, there are multiple randomized, controlled clinical trials showing that T2 diabetes can be reversed, within weeks, by reducing carbohydrates. Have the Harvard experts not read the scientific literature on diabetes?
As I've reported, Harvard is conflicted by multiple financial and ideological conflicts of interest. See next post.
nypost.com/2024/08/13/lifestyle/reduce-red-meat-intake-to… -
gary taubes reposted
LowCarbUSA®
@lowcarbusa
The 9th Annual San Diego Symposium for Metabolic Health will be held August 15-18, with a full day of presentations dedicated to metabolic therapies for mental health.
Register here - www.lowcarbusa.org/san-diego-2024/
This is shaping up to be one of our best Symposiums ever—just take a look at the presenter list! Learn more & register today!
@garytaubes @drbenbo @carbaddictiondr, @AdrianSotoMota @dr_ericberg @DrPaulMason @GeorgiaEdeMD @anthony_chaffee @drmclphillips, @BrianLenzkes @DrEades @drtonyhampton @AKoutnik @DominicDAgosti2 @realDaveFeldman @TamzynMurphyRD @bschermd @GuidoFrank, @loricalabresemd @KetoCounselor -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Congratulations. Your podcast is terrific!
Cynthia Thurlow, NP
@_CynthiaThurlow
Huge milestone for the podcast was achieved earlier this week
8 million downloads and on track to hit 10 million by the end of 2024
THank you to all my amazing guests including @drjasonfung @bigfatsurprise @SBakerMD @KenDBerryMD @garytaubes @mindpumpsal @drgabriellelyon @CaseyMeansMD @dr_mosconi @TonyYounMD @LaraBriden @realDaveFeldman @nicknorwitz @louisanicola_ @Drlipid @darrencandow @calleymeans @drwillcole @drcateshanahan @DrDavidRabin @DoctorTro @LDLSkeptic @Theholisticpsyc @DrGaborMate @ShawnModel @maxlugavere @martykendall2 @chriskresser @TuitNutrition @ChrisPalmerMD @ifixhearts @JeffryGerberMD
And so many others!
The goal is to be one of the most accessible and influential podcasts -
gary taubes reposted
Neil Barsky
@nsbarsky
Amputations are what happens when big Pharma, big food and a health care system that cares more about $ than people run the show.
And racism definitely plays a role.
Huge thank you to the amputees and doctors who trusted me with their stories.
www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2024/jul/25/di… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is a national disgrace. Let's get that outcry going!
Neil Barsky
@nsbarsky
Imagine if each year, 150,000 white, male execs had amputations as the result of type 2 diabetes – and that the operation was avoidable.
Would there not be an outcry?
www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2024/jul/25/di… -
gary taubes reposted
Neil Barsky
@nsbarsky
The solution to the diabetes epidemic is so close...yet so far.
The @AmDiabetesAssn doesn't get it.
The @US_FDA almost gets it.
My latest in the series Death By Diabetes: America's Preventable Epidemic, for @guardian
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/jul/24/dia… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
If a woman in a homeless shelter can turn around her health by restricting carbohydrates, it's possible for anyone.
South Bronx patients are also reversing diabetes and other endocrinological disorders through diet. Via @DrMarielaGlandt 👏
@TheEndoSociety @AmDiabetesAssn
LInk in next tweet -
gary taubes reposted
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
5/5) FULL Fuel Partitioning VIDEO: youtu.be/9KbxdzPK8W0
Associated “Trapped Fat” paper: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/obr.13795
ht/ @davidludwigmd @garytaubes et al.
And please check out my Substack tomorrow morning for an associated digestion on New Science related to GLP-1 agonists and newer generation weight loss drugs
(Subscribe here to get notified: staycuriousmetabolism.substack.com)
A tiny “spoiler” … I’ll begin to unpack metabolic mysteries, like why Tirzepatide outperforms Ozempic for weight loss....And guess what…
🔥FUEL PARTITIONING!🔥
And, I’ll also be releasing – this weekend – part 1 of 2 on Continuous Glucose Monitors #cgm and The Future of N = 1 Medicine! @Levels @DominicDAgosti2 -
gary taubes reposted
Doug Reynolds, MHP
@DougieReynolds
The 9th Annual San Diego Symposium for Metabolic Health will be held August 15-18, with a full day of presentations dedicated to metabolic therapies for mental health.
Register here - www.lowcarbusa.org/smhp-symposiums/sd-2024/
This is shaping up to be one of our best Symposiums ever—just take a look at the presenter list!
Learn more & register today! Save 10% off tickets, low-carb meals, and optional CME credits with code "July10"!
Expert speakers include:
@garytaubes, @drbenbo, @carbaddictiondr, @AdrianSotoMota, @dr_ericberg, @DrPaulMason, @GeorgiaEdeMD, @anthony_chaffee, @drmclphillips, @BrianLenzkes, @DrEades, @drtonyhampton, @AKoutnik, @DominicDAgosti2, @realDaveFeldman, @TamzynMurphyRD, @bschermd, @GuidoFrank, @loricalabresemd, @KetoCounselor -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨🚨10-Year Longitudinal Data On Ketogenic Diet Adverse Events, Bone Mineral Density, Thyroid Function, and Kidney Function: PART 2🚨🚨
NEW DATA OUT TODAY: academic.oup.com/jcemcr/article/2/7/luae102/7710382
We (@Joseph_Watso/ @AusRob_PhD/ Samuel Klein) just published our PART 2 paper looking at long-term safety and clinical efficacy of ketogenic diet on:
☠️Adverse Events
🦴Bone Mineral Density
🔥Thyroid Function
🫘Kidney Function
...in part 1 we measured advanced cardiovascular health profile in an adult with elevated cardiovascular risk (type 1 diabetes) who followed a ketogenic diet for 10 years and sustained euglycemia (10-Year HbA1c 5.5%). See paper here: journals.physiology.org/doi/abs/10.1152/ajpcell.00694.2023
PART 2: What did we find?
👉PLEASE WATCH 📷 VIDEO ABSTRACT here (<3 min): youtu.be/hamiuTMGZFU
☠️1) Adverse Events: Many research and clinicians have raised concern over the potential of a ketogenic to elevated the risk of severe adverse events (e.g., hospitalization due to ketoacidosis). Over a 10 year period following a ketogenic diet, we observed no hypoglycemic or hyperglycemic events requiring medical attention (60 Day CGM Data: 0% time <54mg/dL & >180mg/dL). Patient also presented with intact hypoglycemic awareness.
🦴2) Bone Mineral Density: Prior data suggests that short term ketogenic diet may impair markers of bone modeling/remodeling. However, most of these report are short in nature. People with type 1 diabetes are at HIGH risk for lower bone mineral density and fracture (hyperglycemia is risk factor). Here, we observed no negative impact on bone mineral density (using GOLD STANDARD DXA) on a ketogenic diet, despite 10 years of aging with type 1 diabetes.
🔥3) Thyroid Function: Concerns have been raised on how reducing carbohydrates may shift thyroid hormone status and metabolism. However, most of these studies are </=7 days in length. Following a ketogenic diet over a 10-year period, here we observe no negative impact on thyroid function with a 10-year ketogenic diet.
🫘4) Kidney Function: Microvascular disease is a very common complication of type 1 diabetes as hyperglycemia damages the small blood vessel in the kidneys. Adverse structural kidney changes are observed in children with type 1 diabetes as early as 1.5-5 years post diagnosis with eGFR declining over time. We did not observe any deterioration of kidney function in patient with type 1 diabetes over a 10-year period while achieving 10-Year 5.5% HbA1c following a ketogenic diet.
🚨⚠️9) LIMITATIONS: Reminder on limitations. This is an individual case. The importance of this data is in the sheer absence of short or long-term data, hypothesized risk of a KD, and popularity and use of KD which we hope help generate future research questions.
🗒️CONCLUSIONS: In the longest known longitudinal report of a ketogenic diet in a patient with type 1 diabetes, we observed no severe adverse events or negative impacts on bone, kidney, or thyroid health. We in our PART 1 paper, we observed above average cardiovascular disease health. These initial findings should provoke further research into interventions like ketogenic diets to reduce the long-term health risks faced by those living with T1D while closely monitoring both traditional and advanced cardiovascular risk markers. Especially considering that currently available therapies do no reliably allow patients to achieve <7% HbA1c, let alone <5.7% HbA1c.
@Joseph_Watso
Cardiovascular & Applied Physiology Lab
caplaboratory.com
Studying how health behaviors (e.g., diet, exercise, etc.) affect cardiovascular health and physiology
@SansumDiabetes
sansum.org
Studying how lifestyle, tools, and medicine affect people with diabetes.
@fsucehhs @FSUResearch @FSUISSM @AJPCellPhys
@diaTribeNews @BeyondType1 @MCRiddell1 @nicknorwitz @Metabolic_Mind @DominicDAgosti2 @BenBikmanPhDThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Please read the letter by @janellison and @DavidBazucki and sign the petition.
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
1/2 www.baltimoresun.com/2024/07/09/herrera-scott-schizophren…
Today, the @baltimoresun published a letter co-authored by my husband, @DavidBaszucki, founder and CEO of @Roblox, and me, asking for a reversal of a puzzling decision by the State of Maryland to shut down promising food as medicine research for schizophrenia.
"Considering the scarcity of federal funding for mental health research, privately funded studies like Kelly’s are a lifeline—not a line item. Among the dozen ketogenic diet trials for serious mental illness undertaken to date, Kelly’s work was uniquely valuable as the only study of ketogenic therapy for schizophrenia being offered to inpatients, who are often the most severely ill. As a rule, these patients cannot afford a dietitian, let alone a private metabolic psychiatrist. If Herrera Scott stands by her decision to prevent them from participating in this trial, it is unlikely they will ever have access to this potentially life-changing therapy again."
Please sign the petition, above, by @ChrisPalmerMD asking Dr. Herrera Scott @MDHealthDept to reinstate this important trial led by veteran researcher Dr. Deanna Kelly @ProfDeannaK
And please share this post widely so we can get the petition to 20,000 signatures. We're nearly there.
Here is my original post with additional details, including a link to the Baltimore Sun's article breaking the story: twitter.com/janellison/status/1807914827572301996.
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Should government be able to shut down a privately funded clinical trial without cause?
Urgent plea: If you care about people battling mental illness, please help us by signing this petition to keep a government official from shutting down a landmark privately funded inpatient trial of medical keto for schizophrenia in Maryland.
Those of you who know our family's story know how personal this is for us. Our son might not be here today without medical keto therapy, and we desperately want others to have access to trials of this important treatment option. You can imagine how alarmed we are by this news as reported in @baltimoresun today:
www.baltimoresun.com/2024/07/01/maryland-health-spring-gr…
In summary, Maryland’s Secretary of Health Laura Herrera Scott, MD, has halted a foundational ketogenic diet study among schizophrenia inpatients at the Spring Grove Hospital Center. The study is being conducted in conjunction with the Maryland Psychiatric Research Center at the University of Maryland. It is led by Professor Deanna Kelly, who has conducted more than 25 NIH and foundation-sponsored trials.
Notably, this landmark trial is the only inpatient study of ketogenic therapy for serious mental illness in the United States. Halting this trial needlessly slows the progress of metabolic psychiatry research and begs the question of who has the authority to decide what science should be pursued and on what grounds.
According to the Sun, the patient population at Spring Grove is “a vulnerable group of people, who often have a history of homelessness and untreated or treatment-resistant mental illnesses. Roughly 70% are Black. Many are from economically disadvantaged families or have fallen from higher socioeconomic levels due to illness or drug use.” We have to ask ourselves whether the Maryland Health Department should have the right to prevent these consenting patients from accessing new treatments through clinical research.
Before the Secretary’s action, repeated attempts were made to discuss the study and its potential with Secretary Herrera Scott. Advocates, patients, caregivers, and legislators also appealed to the Secretary, asking her to reconsider the decision. The Maryland Psychiatric Society, representing 775 psychiatrists in the state of Maryland, formally requested that the research be allowed to continue:
“The prospect of discontinuing essential research programs not only threatens the rights of patients but also undermines the efforts of dedicated healthcare professionals striving to provide the best possible care. The ramifications of such a decision extend far beyond the confines of these centers, impacting disadvantaged and disabled individuals across Maryland who rely on the benefits of esteemed and reliable research and clinical programs for access to innovative treatments and specialized care.”
mdpsych.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/MPRC.pdf
After a 16-week review, the Health Department found no health and safety concerns and confirmed the keto trial decision was not based on human subject concerns. It was described as a “procedural” decision and appears without clear cause.
I urge you to share this tweet widely and to sign the petition authored by @ChrisPalmerMD which calls on Secretary Herrera Scott to immediately reverse her decision: www.change.org/p/help-us-protect-a-landmark-research-stud…
You can also contact the Secretary directly and ask her to immediately reverse her decision:
Social media: Fundin
Email: laura.herrerascott@maryland.gov
Phone: (410) 767-4639, 1-877-463-3464 (toll-free, Maryland), tdd: 1-800-735-2258 (toll-free)
Together, I hope we can persuade the secretary to overturn this decision and protect the rights of patients to access cutting-edge research. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why challenge the dogma about why we get fat?
Because the idea that we get fat because we overeat -- consciously or unconsciously- explains little to nothing.
How about a century-old perspective instead?
Nutrition & Health News This Week open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he… -
gary taubes reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Challenging dogma: The evidence that obesity is not an energy balance problem but rather a primary metabolic disorder—fuel-partitioning onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/obr.13795
-
gary taubes reposted
Jeffry Gerber, MD
@JeffryGerberMD
From authors @garytaubes, @davidludwigmd et. al. "The first comprehensive review in 80+years of the idea that obesity is an intrinsic disorder of fuel partitioning: a fat-trapping disorder, not an energy balance disorder." onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/obr.13795
-
gary taubes reposted
Christoffer Clemmensen
@ClemmensenC
"Trapped fat: Obesity pathogenesis as an intrinsic disorder in metabolic fuel partitioning" a new review by Mark Friedman, Thorkild Sørensen, @garytaubes, @jens_lund and @davidludwigmd onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/obr.13795
-
gary taubes reposted
Jens Lund
@jens_lund
1/15 Is obesity caused by trapping of fuels in our fat? Led by Mark Friedman @MonellSc, this new article summarizes more than 80 years of research which collectively suggest that faulty fuel partitioning might be a primary driver of obesity!
Open Access 👇
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/obr.13795 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Is "overeating" the cause or consequence of getting fat?
Human studies are too short to provide an answer. So we reviewed the animal research.
👉In almost every case, evidence shows an underlying metabolic problem driving the positive energy balance
#cim
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/obr.13795 -
gary taubes reposted
MedShadow | Medication Safety
@medshadow_org
For the millions of Americans who live with diabetes, “Rethinking Diabetes” by @garytaubes is a must-read. Here's our review.
medshadow.org/rethinking-diabetes-by-gary-taubes/ -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is a must watch. And please sign the petition!
Lauren Kennedy West
@LWSchizophrenia
I'm angry and need your help - please watch this, and sign and share the petition below!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
URGENT: Keep government from closing a landmark clinical trial for schizophrenia
As reported by the @baltimoresun yesterday, the Maryland Health Department @MDHealthDept, led by Dr. Laura Herrera Scott, has halted the only U.S. inpatient trial on ketogenic therapy for schizophrenia. After a 16-week review that revealed no health or safety concerns, the decision to shut down the study was based solely on the funding sources.
Given the limited availability of federal funding for mental health research, studies like Dr. Kelly’s, funded by private foundations, are crucial. Among the dozen trials investigating ketogenic diets for serious mental illnesses, Dr. Kelly’s research stands out as the sole trial of ketogenic therapy for schizophrenia available to inpatients, who typically suffer the most severe symptoms.
Roughly a dozen patients who had already volunteered were not allowed to participate after the study's closure. Isn't this a violation of patients' rights?
Three patient advocacy organizations, including one representing 750 Maryland psychiatrists, wrote to the health department to protest the decision. These pleas asking that the keto trial continue were ignored.
Help us get this decision reversed! Please sign and share Dr. @ChrisPalmerMD's petition – it takes less than 30 seconds. Sign here:
www.change.org/p/help-us-protect-a-landmark-research-stud…
Read and share the story from the Baltimore Sun:
www.baltimoresun.com/2024/07/01/maryland-health-spring-gr…
Watch and share our interview with the researcher leading the study, Deanna L. Kelly, PharmD, BCPP:
youtu.be/tzPlQ6dJwe8
Let's advocate for innovative science and better #mentalhealth treatments. Join us in ensuring patients get the choices they deserve. -
gary taubes reposted
Cynthia Thurlow, NP
@_CynthiaThurlow
One of my favorite episodes I have recorded this year with science writer @garytaubes
It is also one of our most downloaded of 2024 👇🏻👇🏻👇🏻 podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/everyday-wellness/id1435214… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My favorite sports story of the year, maybe the decade.
Courtesy of @jasongay and the incomparable Willie Mays.
Jason Gay
@jasongay
I wrote about Willie Mays, who I was fortunate to meet in 2009, and I've never forgotten the experience.
www.wsj.com/articles/willie-mays-will-be-forever-a8853906 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I just read @scottsayare's article. A great story (I'm a bit envious) and a terrific piece of science journalism!
Scott Sayare
@scottsayare
The world is awash in useful and important information of all sorts, if only we can see it. For this week's @NYTmag, I wrote about the extraordinary Joy Milne (@stumpw0rk50), who sees disease where others can't, and sees it with her nose.
www.nytimes.com/2024/06/14/magazine/parkinsons-smell-dise… -
gary taubes reposted
Roxana Soetebeer, MPHC NNP MHP PFC
@REV_Insulin_Res
Anyone want to meet these guys in person? @DrPaulMason, @garytaubes, and all the other great people in the image? They will be at the Symposium for Metabolic Health in San Diego this August.
Here's the great news: use code "CoachRoxana" for 20% off the price.
Can't wait to meet you all there! 🤗
www.lowcarbusa.org/smhp-symposiums/sd-2024/ -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
The Ozempic lawsuits have begun...
This week's health and nutrition news by @garytaubes and me
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he… -
gary taubes reposted
Johnathan Edwards MD
@johnedwardsmd
@garytaubes and @ninateicholz get it right calling out @elonmusk and @MattWalshBlog about how calories in calories out isn't the right way to explain obesity. Consider reading their substack to find out more.
-
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
If you do one thing today, go to substack and support Unsettled Science with @bigfatsurprise and @garytaubes
unsettledscience.substack.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Musk solves the obesity crisis?
Dean Ornish claims he can reverse Alzheimer's
and other stories in
Nutrition & Health News This Week
by @garytaubes and me. Link follows
@elonmusk @MattWalshBlog -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I got a chance to talk all things diabetes with @MarkHyman on his Doctor's Farmacy Podcast.
We cover diabetes history, food vs. drugs to control blood sugar, ketogenic diets, my anxieties about the Ozempic revolution.
More than anything, the need to reassess our approach to diabetes management.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/interview-the-evolution-of-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
An occupational hazard in the nutrition world is to speculate about the lessons that can be learned when the promoter of a particular dietary philosophy has died.
Is this ever appropriate? And, if so, what can we learn?
Life Lessons from the Recently Departed? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Science quote of the day (from Sinclair Lewis's Arrowsmith):
"...he was having an agreeable time massacring the opsonin theory, and that cheered him. `No, I have done nothing except be unpleasant to people that claim too much, but I have dreams of real discoveries some day.'" -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Johann Hari's new book, Magic Pill, does a good job on the benefits and risks of taking a drug like Ozempic.
It goes off the rails when he gets around to discussing the science of obesity.
Consider this the Satiety Problem Problem.
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/magic-pill-and-t… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Can't wait.
Steve Bennett
@SteveBennettMhP
Only 4 days to go to what promises to be our best health Confrence ever. With the best brains in preventing chronic disease and reversing metabolic conditions, still a few spaces available- phcuk.org/phc-conference-2024/ - I look forward to you all there - we also have online attendance available @lowcarbGP #fibrefirst #healthresults
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The scientist activist problem.
What nutrition and climate science (regrettably?) have in common. open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/the-scientist-ac… -
gary taubes reposted
Low Carb Health Doctor | LCHD | Dr. Don Agcopra
@LowCarbHealthMD
LOW CARB KETO Diet is BEST for DIABETICS!
Dr. MARIELA GLANDT, HARVARD-trained DIABETES SPECIALIST (ENDOCRINOLOGIST) DECREASES/STOPS DIABETES MEDS and puts patients into REMISSION with the LOW CARB KETO DIET!
WATCH THIS SoundByte! youtu.be/nCHGwooqGSI
👉www.lowcarbhealthmd.com/about/metabolicsyndrome -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
What do school lunches and fattening pigs for market have in common?
...and other news in this week's Nutrition & Health News by @garytaubes and me
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/this-weeks-nutrition-and-… -
gary taubes reposted
Ken D Berry MD
@KenDBerryMD
People deserve correct & helpful information about Diabetes!
Introducing the American Diabetes Society. It will offer info & recipes that actually lowers blood sugars and A1c's.
The ADS will NEVER take money from big-food or big-pharma and will be financially transparent to all!
If that sounds great to you then please donate what you can to get this non-profit going as quickly as possible.
Donate: gofund.me/58af7e2a
Sharing this post will spread the word and help us keep more grandparents from being taking from us prematurely, save legs from amputation, save eyes from blindness and save kidneys from failure! -
gary taubes reposted
For The Sake of Argument
@ForthesakeofA
@garytaubes, it was great talking to you about Ozempic, Low-Sugar vs Low-Calorie diets, and also how you respond to critics.
Thanks for dealing with my barrage of questions!!
Here's our interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFTP9pzhzfg
#ozempic #diabetes @PeterAttiaMD
@4_TheSakeofArgu -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Not just gripping, one of the best articles I've ever read capturing the essence of Feynman's first principle of science: "that you must not fool yourself and you are the easiest person to fool."
@amandaknox gives a master class in how to proceed once you think that you have.
Anna Bross
@AnnaCBross
This is gripping from start to end. Amanda Knox spent years investigating this case and advocated for Jens Söring’s release. Now, she reopens questions about his guilt:
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/05/jens-soring-ama… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Did Stone Age Humans Eat Less Meat Than We Thought? @garytaubes weighs in on the 'we got paleo wrong' headlines this week.
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/nutrition-and-health-news… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
While I'm on the subject of headlines. How about this from The Independent:
"Cavemen ate mostly vegan, debunking Paleo diet."
I'm stumped by the "mostly vegan" concept?
If it's got meat, it's not vegan right?
Maybe our #vegan friends can help us out here, but isn't a diet either vegan or not?
A binary thing, no?
www.independent.co.uk/life-style/study-paleo-diet-stone-a… -
gary taubes reposted
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
CONFERENCE NEWS! We’ve lifted the deadline for our scheme for students from around the world to gain sponsored places at #phc2024, courtesy of Metabolic Health Malta. Remaining places will now be filled on a first come, first serve basis. Please share! www.metabolichealthmalta.com/conferences-1
-
gary taubes reposted
Paula
@DietScold
@garytaubes 10:41 "INSULIN is discovered in 1921 & [what we call 'keto'] is thrown out & suddenly you have this very powerful drug so good at lowering blood sugar that it CREATES...LOW BLOOD SUGAR...so the patient is REQUIRED TO EAT CARBS so the drug itself doesn't kill them."🤦♀️
Abel James
@AbelJames
As Hollywood, influencers, and the media tout the seemingly miraculous benefits of weight loss "wonder drugs," let's examine the long-term risks of heavy-handed pharmaceutical interventions. Full interview with Award-Winning Author and Journalist, Gary Taubes @garytaubes
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Headline of the week, from Discover Magazine:
“Ancient Teeth and Bones Show Stone Age People Consumed a Paleo Diet”
😐
I mean, what else would Stone Age people consume?
Nouveau cuisine? Sushi?
What am I missing here?
www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/ancient-teeth-and-b… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Harvard Health newsetters persistently report on the 'dangers' of keto. But the science on this is scarce...
The latest Harvard item on keto relies entirely on a lone solo Polish practitioner as its authority. Why?
@garytaubes reports (3rd item)
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/this-weeks-nutrition-and-… -
gary taubes reposted
Abel James
@AbelJames
Did you know that doctors were treating diabetic patients with high-fat low-carb diets all the way back in the 1700s?
Though high-fat ketogenic diets were found to effectively treat diabetes for over a century, they were largely abandoned due to the rapid adoption of insulin in the 1920s, which was considered then to be a miracle cure.
Prioritizing drugs over lifestyle with insulin therapy, however, led to unexpected long term complications in patients, including damage to large and small blood vessels that results in heart disease, strokes, kidney damage, neuropathy, amputations, blindness, dementia, and a decrease in life expectancy.
The diabetes story is a metaphor of the rapid adoption of a wonder drug without knowing the long term consequences.
And in an age when Hollywood influencers in the media are touting the seemingly miraculous benefits of our latest weight loss wonder drugs GLP-1 agonists like Ozempic, it’s worth examining the long term risks and consequences of heavy handed pharmaceutical interventions.
Today, we’re back with our friend Gary Taubes, an award-winning investigative science and health journalist and bestselling author of “Why We Get Fat” and “Good Calories, Bad Calories,” as well as his new book “Rethinking Diabetes.”
You’re going to dig this one. (Link is below.)
CC: @garytaubes -
gary taubes reposted
Abel James
@AbelJames
As Hollywood, influencers, and the media tout the seemingly miraculous benefits of weight loss "wonder drugs," let's examine the long-term risks of heavy-handed pharmaceutical interventions. Full interview with Award-Winning Author and Journalist, Gary Taubes @garytaubes
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Anti-meat science at UN Food Summit is "agenda-driven," not evidence-based, says a participant with front-row seat to the process.
unsettledscience.substack.com/publish/post/144058017 -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Symptoms of obesity, Type 2 diabetes and Alzheimer's have been shown to be reversible with low carbohydrate and ketogenic nutritional interventions.
T2D patients can often get off insulin within weeks of beginning low carb therapies. Low carb nutrition works as well as GLP1s for obesity, costs no more than food already being purchased, requires no prescriptions, and has no scary unknown short and long-term side effects. Symptoms of Alzheimer's, or type 3 diabetes as it is often called, can be mitigated with MCT oil or ketone supplements and ketogenic diets by providing an alternate fuel source for brains that can't use glucose effectively.
Yet in a Stat+ newsletter that brings to light problematic news related to the pharmaceutical industry, I read this morning about:
1) the high costs and shortages of insulin for type 2 diabetes,
2) how spending on GLP1s like semaglutide for obesity and type 2 diabetes by the US government and health systems "doubled to $38.6 billion, making the drug the top-selling medicine in 2023" and how spending is expected to continue to increase, and
3) the woes of the drug company pushing a new Alzheimer's drug that physicians aren't prescribing enough of because they believe it's futile to treat this condition.
Imagine if we had a lobby as large as all the drug companies' combined to push whole foods low carb nutrition and ketogenic therapy to policy-makers, health systems, insurance companies and families. We could radically improve health without shortages, without bankrupting the healthcare system, and without giving up on patients.
Oh, and then there's the piece about how research at Harvard is largely fueled by pharma:
"As Harvard Medical School research increasingly leans on funding from biopharmaceutical companies to supplement government funding, faculty are grappling with the benefits and harms of private interests in science..."
Philanthropy MUST step up with funding not motivated by future profits.
#citizenscience
@realDaveFeldman
@davidludwigmd
@bigfatsurprise
@garytaubes -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The media runs articles on scientific misconduct regularly. Fraud is news.
Maybe so, but bad science is the problem.
How do you stop bad scientists? Hope they committed fraud. open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/how-do-you-stop-… -
gary taubes reposted
Melanie Avalon
@MelanieAvalon
Friends!! It is such an honor to have acclaimed journalist @garytaubes back on The Melanie Avalon Biohacking Podcast for a paradigm-shifting deep dive into “Rethinking Diabetes.” 🥹 (Prepare to have your mind blown!) podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-melanie-avalon-biohacki…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
For those in the SF Bay Area, @KellyClose of Close Concerns is hosting me for a discussion of Rethinking Diabetes and the history of diabetes research and treatment.
Wednesday the 24th at 6 pm
Still some spots open.
Click here to register: www.eventbrite.com/e/in-person-cps-161-gary-taubes-on-ret… -
gary taubes reposted
Paula
@DietScold
An endocrinologist's Amazon review of @garytaubes 'Rethinking Diabetes' - "A true masterpiece that has the power to change an entire field of medicine."
-
gary taubes reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
The invention of Ozempic may be as transformative as the development of insulin therapy was a century ago, writes @garytaubes. That should make us very nervous: www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2024/04/ozempic-mounja…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Great conversation with Melanie Avalon and her biohacking project.
Apple Podcasts link: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-melanie-avalon-biohacki…
Melanie’s Instagram/Twitter: @MelanieAvalon
Shownotes, including full transcript: www.melanieavalon.com/diabetes -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
-What diet is best for IBS? New clinical trial results
-Nestlé coca-colonizes poor countries w/ sugar
-A clinical trial asks if plant-based meats are healthy
...and more Nutrition & Health News This Week
by @garytaubes and me
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/nutrition-and-health-news… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Do we need congressional hearings?
They would be an excellent start.
Neil Barsky
@nsbarsky
If you're one of more than 100 million Americans with diabetes or pre-diabetes, this story will shock.
Our diabetes epidemic is a national disgrace - hiding in plain sight.
Do we need congressional hearings?
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/apr/18/splenda-dia… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Important piece! Low-carb diets work. Why does the American Diabetes Association push insulin instead? | Neil Barsky | The Guardian www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/apr/17/ada-america…
-
gary taubes reposted
Public Eye
@publiceye_ch
“The only reason why @Nestle does it is basically because they know that kids like #sugar and they will come back and want their product,” says @LGaberell @TIME about #nestlé|s unjustifiable and harmful double standard. “It's just to increase the sales.”
time.com/6968112/nestle-sugar-baby-milk-cereal-poorer-nat… -
gary taubes reposted
Public Eye
@PublicEyeSuisse
NEW INVESTIGATION - Two of the best-selling @Nestle’s baby-food marketed in low- and middle-income countries are packed with added sugar, while such products are sugar free in its home country CH. Read now👉 stories.publiceye.ch/nestle-babies/ #health #sugar #nestle
-
gary taubes reposted
Troy Gomm
@tgomm
This is excellent. We need more pointed commentary like this. My favorite part is this
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
RT @PHCukorg: CONFERENCE NEWS! We’ve just launched a fantastic scheme for medical and healthcare students to gain sponsored places at #phc2…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
It's time someone challenged the @AmDiabetesAssn directly. We have @nsbarsky to thank for stating the obvious.
We didn't have the evidence before to make this case. Now, thanks to @virtahealth and others, we do.
Neil Barsky
@nsbarsky
We have a diabetes epidemic and guess what? It's preventable. My latest for @guardian
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/series/death-by-diabete… -
gary taubes reposted
unSILOed Podcast with Greg LaBlanc
@UnsiloedPodcast
In this episode, Gary Taubes joins host Greg to unpack the hallmarks of bad science, debunk modern misconceptions about obesity and its causes, and delve into the surprising impact of World War II on obesity research. Check the full episode at link.chtbl.com/Sj-6eiYd
-
gary taubes reposted
unSILOed Podcast with Greg LaBlanc
@UnsiloedPodcast
Join Gary Taubes and Greg as they delve deep into the fascinating history of diabetes and obesity research and explore centuries of scientific inquiry, including major breakthroughs like the discovery of insulin. The full episode is available at link.chtbl.com/Sj-6eiYd
-
gary taubes reposted
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
The invention of Ozempic may be as transformative as the development of insulin therapy was a century ago, writes @garytaubes. That should make us very nervous: www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2024/04/ozempic-mounja…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Is insulin therapy for diabetes a cautionary tale for GLP-1 drugs and obesity?
I hope not. But I'm not an optimist by nature.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
The invention of Ozempic may be as transformative as the development of insulin therapy was a century ago, writes @garytaubes. That should make us very nervous: www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2024/04/ozempic-mounja…
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
The 'diet wars' are vicious
Read the latest: Harvard vs. NIH. Harvard researchers suggest a retraction of NIH study is the only solution.
At issue? Low-carb vs. low-fat diets--which is better for weight loss/prevention of weight gain
@garytaubes has the rundown.
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he… #nutrition -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
MDs just need more nutrition education in med school, right?
@garytaubes and I suggest that sometimes, less education is better.
Also-->read about the latest Diet Wars battle between NIH and Harvard
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he… -
gary taubes reposted
Bolinda audio
@Bolindaaudio
@garytaubes, award-winning author, digs into the history of diabetes treatment, challenging conventional wisdom and advocating for a diet-centric approach – a compelling and groundbreaking exploration reshaping our understanding of diabetes and its care.
#bolinda
@arthurmorey -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We didn't need reasons to be skeptical of nutrition science, but here's another one we can't avoid
No End to Parallel Universes in Nutrition open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/no-end-to-parall… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
How low should you go with LDL-cholesterol? The Amer. Heart Assoc. says <100 mg/dL for healthy people (and lower for those post MI/stroke). Yet studies consistently show that somewhat higher LDL is associated with fewer heart attacks. Latest paper says 100-189 mg/dL looks ideal. Read this and more here:
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he…
@garytaubes -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
Dr Sarah Hallberg’s final plea. Her ground breaking work demonstrated so clearly that the pandemic of type 2 diabetes was not a mystery. It was a problem we had eaten our way into, and one we could eat our way out again! Read this book to find out more!
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Censorship coming to nutrition:
Anyone who criticizes the US Dietary Guidelines for Americans (our nation's most influential nutrition policy) is now peddling "misinformation," says USDA-HHS in a new paper. For this and other news:
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he…
@garytaubes -
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
I would love for people to READ A BOOK OR SCIENTIFIC ARTICLES instead of getting all of their information from tweets. Once they understand the myriad causes of mental health conditions AND the solutions, we can actually begin to help people heal.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The world is changing. Nice to see Stanford Med fully on board.
Stanford Medicine
@StanfordMed
A small clinical trial led by Stanford Medicine found that the metabolic effects of a ketogenic diet may help stabilize the brain. Read more: stan.md/49jeMZa
#bipolar #mentalillness #newtreatmentThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Very exciting. Now let's see more of these trials!
Shebani Sethi, MD
@ShebaniMD
I’m proud to share the results of my pilot trial investigating the therapeutic effects of a #ketogenicdiet on bipolar and schizophrenia, published in @PsychiatryResJ.
📈 We found promising improvements in BOTH metabolic and psychiatric outcomes: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S01651781240015… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
-> Supermodel Gisele is no longer vegan; now she eats animal protein...including steak?!
-> First 1,000 days of life are critical for a child's development. Which diets are dangerous?
-> Does exercise mitigate sleep deprivation?
And more in This Week in Nutrition & Health News by @garytaubes and myself
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/nutrition-and-health-news… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Andrew Koutnik | Metabolism Scientist
@AKoutnik
🚨 @AmDiabetesAssn Keto Diets in Diabetes: Evidence in Type 1 & Type 2 Diabetes?
I will be presenting the EVIDENCE on carbohydrate restriction in diabetes in ADA Nutrition Webinar (FREE).
👇 Please SHARE for all to attend!
professionaleducation.diabetes.org/Public/Catalog/Details… -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
-
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
"Long story short, this last ditch effort saved my life."
-- Mia Mendez, #worldbipolarday
Ketogenic Therapy (medical keto) is helping people around the world with even severe bipolar illness reclaim their mental and physical health. On World Bipolar Day 2024, all of us at our non-profit are grateful to the five generous, resilient individuals who've shared their stories of #bipolarremission in this 6-minute video.
Psychiatric medications have their place, but for some people, #ketogenictherapy is a helpful complement, or even a replacement, over time, for pharmaceutical treatments. As the results of the first clinical trials of ketogenic therapy for #bipolardisorder are being published, we take this day to celebrate the clinicians, researchers and individuals who are making this new #bipolartreatment a reality.
Thank you to so many, including @DyaneHarwood, @MsMiaMendez, @robynrdobbins, @Chloe_mrng, @ChrisPalmerMD, @GeorgiaEdeMD, @ShebaniMD, @IainCampbellPhD, @KetoCounselor, @EllenhornPACT, @loricalabresemd and @KaniaZupec!
Visit our website and YouTube channel for free resources at the intersection of metabolism and mental health, including Hannah Warren's latest blog post: www.metabolicmind.org/resources/library/blog/perspectives…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Keto is more than just "a diet." It drives a physiological state called ketosis. If someone tells you it's all about bacon and butter and is bad for your heart, that's likely anti-keto bias. But pro-keto bias is a thing, too.
@bschermd addresses both: youtu.be/FWVinguULy8 -
gary taubes reposted
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
CONFERENCE NEWS! Livestream tickets are now available for sale! And we have a special Earlybird Livestream price, so no reason not book now to be part of the #phc2024 action wherever you are! phcuk.org/conference
-
gary taubes reposted
Wide Eye Productions
@wideeyetv
Thanks to all who participated in #fatfiction and for helping people understand that #type2diabetes can be reversed. Change begins with the #hope that you CAN heal your body and your mind!
@drjasonfung @bschermd @garytaubes @DrSarahHallberg @lowcarbusa @zoeharcombe @drmarkhyman @bulletproofexec @bigfatsurprise @ProfTimNoakes @andrewmente @drericwestman @BrianLenzkes @RobertLustigMD @lowcarbGP @KenDBerryMD @jonnybowden @ProfTimNoakes @4dietaryreform
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
For the @amdiabetesassn community that doesn't yet know how type 2 diabetes can be reversed (often within just weeks), this movie is a great place to start your educational journey
fatfiction.movie -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A heroic book that we all need to read.
Let's move this up the charts.
www.amazon.com/Status-Thinking-Harming-Your-Health-ebook/…
Status Quo Thinking Is Harming Your Health: A Physician's Final Plea Kindle Edition
by Sarah Hallberg (Author), Nina Teicholz (Foreword) -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
* Oprah is liberating...for whom, exactly?
* Intermittent fasting: Best data show it probably protects against heart disease (despite the headlines)
* The great statin debate: should young people start early on these pills-or not?
This week's news by @garytaubes and myself -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Oprah joins the weight loss revolution;
The AHA takes a (cheap) shot at Intermittent Fasting and the media piles on....
And statins for the young and healthy!
Nutrition & Health News This Week on Unsettled Science open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-and-he… -
gary taubes reposted
Beth Akeson
@bethakeson
Keto or carnivore will save people’s metabolic health. It is a way of eating for a lifetime- NOT a temporary diet/fix. It is a easy, delicious and inexpensive strategy.
Hats off to:
.@KenDBerryMD
.@drjasonfung
.@bigfatsurprise
.@homesteadhow
.@garytaubes
Carol M. Swain, PhD
@carolmswain
Here’s my public health warning about weight loss drugs. There seems to be an aggressive campaign to push #ozempic and other weight loss drugs on the public. I’m concerned because of the potential for dangerous side effects. I was on #ozempic during the summer of 2022. I lost 8 pounds, became deathly ill, and ended up in the hospital for four days with life threatening complications. Every system of my body was affected. I came off the drug and quickly regained the lost weight, plus 5 pounds more. It took me a year to get back to my pro-Ozempic weight. I guess I could have been the skinniest corpse in the cemetery. I am now on a low-carb Keto diet. It works for me.#weightloss #weightlossjourney
-
gary taubes reposted
Richie Allen
@Richie_Allen
The latest episode of Rallen's Rant is out now with @garytaubes who's an American Author who focuses on health & diet.
In this episode we talk Keto diets, diabetes, problems with Science & more.
Available on Spotify, Soundcloud etc too.
#science #diet
www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZcS-YQUeiM -
gary taubes reposted
Sean Watkins
@hxcsean
Investigating Diabetes with Gary Taubes – Episode 2462 vinnietortorich.com/2024/03/investigating-diabetes-gary-t… via @VinnieTortorich
And @garytaubes 🕵🏻♂️🤨 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
RT @bigfatsurprise: This weeks nutrition & health news:
- David Sinclair: Long Life, Shortened Career?
- First-ever outside scrutiny of… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We don't forget. We think the study of the mechanisms of atherosclerosis were derailed from that point on by feeding herbivores high-cholesterol diets they'd never eat in nature.
This was a criticism made at the time but already couldn't stop the cholesterol bandwagon.
MacroFour
@MacroFour
The same people who dismiss animal studies (usually because they say they don't apply) seem to forget that the foundational experiments that established the whole field of cholesterol & ASCVD was feeding rabbits their 'natural diet' of cholesterol. 🤷♂️ www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3793599/
-
gary taubes reposted
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
Chair of our Scientific Advisory Committee, the wonderful Dr David Unwin, has put on his best bow-tie to invite YOU to come to our conference!
Book at phcuk.org/conference and see you at #phc2024! -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Some researchers want to formalize a new mental-health disorder:
"ultra-processed foods" addiction
Are these foods really addictive? More than home-baked goods?
I review the science, and why we need Taylor Swift's Pop-tart recipe to answer that question
unsettledscience.substack.com/.../are-ultra... -
gary taubes reposted
Reads with Ravi
@readswithravi
14) Good Calories, Bad Calories by Gary Taubes
“Read it twice, once for the diet, once for the rich document in the history of science.”
― Nassim N. Taleb -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Fat Dogs
Yogurt May Prevent Type 2 Diabetes (says FDA 🥴)
and other Nutrition News this week,
by @garytaubes and myself
shorturl.at/coq57 -
gary taubes reposted
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
We’ll be rethinking how we turn the Diabetes epidemic around at #phc2024. Don’t miss out, book at phcuk.org/conference
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Do We Care Why Mice Get Fat?
Answering the question of whether mouse experiments on obesity are relevant to humans
by @garytaubes
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/do-we-care-why-mice-get-fat -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A new article in the journal Obesity, courtesy of @JohnSpeakman4, suggests mice get fat from high-fat diets because they prioritize the pleasure of eating over maintaining a healthy weight.
It raises an obvious question:
Do We Care Why Mice Get Fat? open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/do-we-care-why-m…
(Apologies to Dr. Speakman. A test of our Copenhagen declaration.) -
gary taubes reposted
justasking
@justask66054535
I have loved ones who might benefit from the insights in @GeorgiaEdeMD’s book about nutrition and mental health. They are not open to hearing about it from me, alas. But maybe one day they will catch her in the mainstream press, tv or radio! 🔥🔥❤️❤️🔥🔥
Georgia Ede MD
@GeorgiaEdeMD
Senior medical reporter @LorieCBN invited me on the @CBNNews Healthy Living program to talk about the dangers of insulin resistance and how controlling blood sugar and insulin levels may be the single most powerful thing you can do to improve and protect your mental and physical health.
More than 50% of adults in the U.S. have insulin resistance, which is also called "pre-diabetes" because every year, 10% of those people will progress to type 2 diabetes if they don't change course— but type 2 diabetes is just the tip of the iceberg!
Persistently high insulin levels and insulin resistance secretly set the stage for most of the diseases we dread, so It would be just as accurate to think of insulin resistance as "pre-fatty liver," "pre-obesity," or "pre-heart attack."
Watch the replay ➡️ www2.cbn.com/video/stories/healthy-living-february-20-2024 -
gary taubes reposted
Next Big Idea Club
@NextBigIdeaClub
Keep in mind all that we don’t know. Here are a few key insights from Rethinking Diabetes: What Science Reveals About Diet, Insulin, and Successful Treatments, by @garytaubes.
nextbigideaclub.com/magazine/diabetes-tells-us-medical-bl… -
gary taubes reposted
Cynthia Thurlow, NP
@_CynthiaThurlow
Rethinking diabetes management with @garytaubes
www.youtube.com/watch?v=J59Jr-TeoF0 -
gary taubes reposted
Paula
@DietScold
“Running them sweet” is INDEED a thing! "Read" @garytaubes new book on Audible rb.gy/gmxv9o You will know MORE about diabetes & our insane group-think medical community THAN ALMOST ANYONE ELSE IN THE WORLD. This book will change the world. Read GT's pinned tweet!
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
How 'bout a drink that blows up into a sponge in your stomach and absorbs the sugar you eat? Yum?
Or a never-published study that the Amer. College of Cardiology (ACC) press released 1 year ago, resulting in a rash of anti-keto headlines? Why, ACC?
➡️This weeks news on Nutrition & Health by @garytaubes and myself
substack.com/home/post/p-142196946 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sugar sponges (??), the UK advocates 50-year-old diet advice (!!), and an update on anti-keto research lacking, well, the research (??!!)
The week in review from Unsettled Science h/t @bigfatsurprise
TGIF: Nutrition & Health News, by @bigfatsurprise open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/tgif-nutrition-a… -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Can #keto cause hypomania?
Transitioning to a ketogenic diet for a psychiatric disorder may come with uncommon temporary side effects like depression, anxiety, insomnia or even hypomania. But should this deter people from trying ketogenic therapy for its often profound therapeutic benefits?
Just like other powerful medical interventions, attention must be paid to potential emerging symptoms. Experts @GeorgiaEdeMD and @KetoCounselor share guidance on how to evaluate and mitigate risks.
Full video: youtu.be/F11ZBvCjVNk -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Talking with @drgabriellelyon about diet, diabetes, health, good science and bad science.
A terrific conversation.
dr-gabrielle-lyon.captivate.fm/episode/gary-taubes -
gary taubes reposted
Joseph Sirven, MD
@jsirven
Our Sat 3/2 4 P E
@WJCTJax
@WJCTNews
best Health books show:
@penguinrandom
@garytaubes
@simonschuster
@aliontas
@VikingBooks
@uche_blackstock
Join us as we talk to the authors!
@folkispeople @FCConair
@heatherschatz
@DavidLuckin
@pubmediaman -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A sign of paradigms shifting?
When the director of the National Institute for Drug Abuse gives a lecture on the potential for keto-therapeutics in alcohol use disorder, you know we're making progress.
That's today. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Can't wait to talk to Kevin Morris and his UK-based diabetes patient group. That 7 pm is GMT. Tickets are free.
Online on Wed 28 Feb 2024 at 7:00PM. Click the link for further information and to secure your tickets now! www.ticketsource.co.uk/whats-on/online/online/rethinking-… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
I'm super excited about this RCT of ketogenic therapy for bipolar. As these top neuroscience researchers point out, the field has often focused on mechanism at the expense of evaluating treatments that might actually help patients live better lives. This study provides the opportunity for both.
It will build on the current scientific literature to learn more about the who, what and when's of ketogenic therapy and will dive deep into brain metabolism in these disorders using state-of-the-art imaging and other modalities.
We're thrilled to be able to partner with such an incredible team. And it's a huge bonus that as @ChrisPalmerMD has already announced, @McLeanHospital is launching a metabolic and mental health program in the same department under his leadership.
#metabolicpsychiatry
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
Harvard's @McLeanHospital has launched a $2M clinical trial funded by @BaszuckiGroup to test ketogenic therapy for early phase bipolar and schizoaffective disorder.
Chief of McLean's Division of Psychotic Disorders Dr. @dost_ongur, and the lead investigator, Dr. Virginie-Anne Chouinard, believe this study is unique in that it combines testing a new treatment intervention with the potential for directly improving clinical care with a deep mechanistic exploration of brain energy metabolism.
"The best kinds of studies provide some mechanistic insight while also providing clinically relevant information about what clinicians should be offering their patients and how we should be thinking about treatment. Here we have a really unusual opportunity to study an intervention which gives us a window into brain mechanisms of energy metabolism and how the biochemical processes support neuronal function, but also it's directly clinically applicable." -Dr. Dost Öngür
They share all the details with @bschermd in our latest video at youtu.be/Ydx4_JPvB-w or learn more about the study at clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT06221852. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
TGIF: Nutrition & Health News by myself and @garytaubes open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/tgif-nutrition-a…
-
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
On @TODAYshow w/ @tvkatesnow Matt Baszucki & his mom @janellison share the family's story of how with help from Harvard psychiatrist @ChrisPalmerMD, a #ketodiet helped Matt get his life back after 5 yrs of symptoms of treatment resistant #bipolardisorder.
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
A groundbreaking course on T2 diabetes REVERSAL using nutritional approaches. >900 people signed up already. Join us! It's FREE. CME credit offered.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Please consider this live, virtual course on how to "reverse" type 2 diabetes. Faculty will present the evidence-based strategies, both the science and the "how-to"s of practice, as well as answer Qs like: is this sustainable? What is "reversal?" A groundbreaking course!
CME credit offered. If you can't come Feb 24, it will remain online at least 1 year.
T2 diabetes does not need to be a life-long intractable disease!
@Diabetescouk
@youngdiab
@diabetessisters
@DiabetesUK
@ABCDiab
@IntDiabetesFed
@DiabetesTimes
@diabetesdaily
@ADA_DiabetesPro
@JoslinDiabetes
@NHSDiabetesProg
@FreeStyleDiabet
@ADCESdiabetes
@AusDiabetesEd
@CDOEofRI
@deupdate
@Hopkinsdiabetes
@tdcpak
@BeFreeOfT2D
@TheEndoSociety
@EndocrineToday
@endocrineweb
@MayoClinicEndo -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Does believing in the health benefits of plant-based diets require a leap of faith?
Less Meat, More Plants: A Rules of Evidence Controversy (Part 1) open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/less-meat-more-p… -
gary taubes reposted
Alan Watson
@DietHeartNews
"Dietary fat, whether saturated fat or not, is not a cause of obesity, diabetes, heart disease or any other chronic disease of civilization."
-- science writer @garytaubes -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I am still trying to wrap my head around this:
In the midst of an obesity epidemic w/all its associated chronic disease issues, the NIH spends $190 million on two-week interventions that can say nothing meaningful about weight regulation.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
TGIF: Nutrition News, by @bigfatsurprise & @garytaubes
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/tgif-nutrition-n… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
TGIF: Nutrition News, by @bigfatsurprise & @garytaubes
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/tgif-nutrition-n… -
gary taubes reposted
Ally Houston
@MrAllyHouston
I'll be in London in May exhibiting everything metpsy.com has to offer for metabolic mental health support!
Can't wait to meet @garytaubes, @realDaveFeldman, and @KenDBerryMD in person, and to catch up with the other fantastic speakers again!
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
Don't miss our Earlybird price...or this line up! Book now at phcuk.org/conference #phc2024
-
gary taubes reposted
Randy Woodward
@TheBondFreak
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Love this! It's got nothing to do with nutrition, which makes it even more fascinating and delightful.
These ancient papyrus scrolls went unread for 2,000 years. Then came the AI geeks competing for $1 million. www.wsj.com/tech/ai/vesuvius-challenge-ai-herculaneum-scr… via @WSJ -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Want some real news on nutrition & health?
Check out "Unsettled Science," a Substack by @garytaubes & myself.
This week, we go behind the headline of the WashPost story claiming that pasta is good for health and find... 2/3 of studies cited are funded by....Barilla pasta. 🙄
And other news most media are missing.
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/tgif-nutrition-and-health… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Great talk with @DrPeterBrukner in Australia about diabetes therapy and where it may have gone off the rails.
Defeat Diabetes Au
@DefeatDiabetes_
Has diabetes treatment all been a big, fat, lie? x.com/i/broadcasts/1dRJZEVbVnNGB
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
A very long lament in the NYTimes about the failure of the lab meat industry ~$3B spent.
The delusion of these lab-meat futurists is that we should abandon holistic, proven ways of raising food, practiced for 1000s of yrs. for factories, and that this would be better for the planet.
www.nytimes.com/2024/02/09/opinion/eat-just-upside-foods-… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
This is the very first time in my life anybody has ever texted me to tell me they heard me being quoted on the radio. Thank you @WStoneReports and @NPR @NPRATC for airing the story of keto for mental illness and #metabolicpsychiatry on All Things Considered.
This ground-breaking piece of reporting is opening up an important conversation to a broader audience.
Georgia Ede MD
@GeorgiaEdeMD
Just aired today on @NPR All Things Considered (@NPRATC). Thank you @WStoneReports for this 6-minute audio piece introducing the nation to ketogenic diets for mental health--the science of hope.
www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2024/01/27/1227062470/k… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Cannot wait.
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
Thanks for following all our Speaker Announcements! What do you think of the line-up so far? Please share if you can! This weekend is a great time to get booking to catch our Earlybird discount 👍🏼
phcuk.org/conference #phc2024 #metabolichealth -
gary taubes reposted
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
A few words from Investigative Journalist @garytaubes !
Book now to get our Earlybird price for a limited time at phcuk.org/conference
#phc2024 #metabolichealth #t2d #insulinresistance #realfood -
gary taubes reposted
Preventive Health Collaboration
@PHCukorg
SPEAKER ANNOUNCEMENT! We're so delighted to announce that the one and only @GaryTaubes will be speaking about T2D at our May conference. Don't miss the unique insights he'll share! Book our Earlybird now at phcuk.org/conference #phc2024 #t2d #metabolichealth #realfood
-
gary taubes reposted
Erica Hauver
@EricaHauver
What do diabetes and mental illness have in common?
A metabolic treatment that can restore health to body and brain.
Check out the two most important health books of 2024 by @garytaubes and @GeorgiaEdeMD -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Speaking with @DrJBhattacharya about my new book was a delight. "Illusion of consensus" almost perfectly captures the first 60 years of diabetes and the insulin era.
As for the last 40, regrettably, the consensus is real, but may have done more harm than good.
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
New Illusion of Consensus podcast on @x!
I spoke with Gary Taubes about his new book "Rethinking Diabetes." @garytaubes makes the case that the way doctors manage diabetes has been based on shoddy science. His book is a tour de force of science history and medical writing.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes reposted
RD
@RRDDDDDDDDDD
@garytaubes is correct.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thank you @BenBikmanPhD for making this simple point.
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
BYU professor @BenBikmanPhD discussing insulin’s role in metabolic health. “Every weight loss study is an insulin lowering study” it’s a pervasive confounding variable, although with greater lowering with low carb. #mhs2024
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thanks to @WStoneReports for the single best article I've ever read on using ketogenic diets as therapies for metabolic disorders. No condescension, no knee-jerk dismissals, just good reporting, and an unbiased assessment. This is must reading.
Daniel Smith
@ProfDanielSmith
A very nice summary of our work on keto for #bipolardisorder and the work of the metabolic psychiatry research community around the world. Also a great photo of @IainCampbellPhD! @EdinUniMentalH @EdinUniMedicine www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2024/01/27/1227062470/k…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I can't wait to talk to @drpeterbrukner about diabetes therapy and how we've gone off the rails.
This is 5 pm Pacific time on Wednesday the 7th, 8 pm Eastern.
Defeat Diabetes Au
@DefeatDiabetes_
For 150 years, diet alone has been proven to reverse #type2diabetes. So why are doctors still pushing drug therapy? Join us for a groundbreaking discussion with best-selling author @garytaubes and @DrPeterBrukner as they challenge the current treatment approach. 👉
-
gary taubes reposted
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
A lot of harrowing statistics in this important new book by @garytaubes. In this passages, Taubes reminds us that diabetes is widespread among lean people as well.
-
gary taubes reposted
Frank Stajano Explains
@FrankStajano
"I’ve attempted #keto a few times with very limited knowledge and immediately followed advice from spotlight keto influencers. Turns out ghee in my coffee is not my thing…. What single resource would you recommend for STARTING keto?"
Easy. "The case for keto" by @garytaubes -
gary taubes reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The head of the World Health Organization says we are doomed to rising rates of diabetes, but we're not, argues science journalist Gary Taubes in his major new book, "Rethinking Diabetes." We just have to radically rethink the role of diet in creating overweight, obesity, and diabetes in the first place.
-
gary taubes reposted
Literary Hub
@lithub
Beef tea and rancid meat: @garytaubes on the history of diet-based diabetes treatment. lithub.com/more-and-more-meat-how-doctors-treated-diabete…
-
gary taubes reposted
Eric Rodgers
@DrEricRodgers
I love @garytaubes long term perspective on how we got where half of adults are prediabetic or diabetic. It’s sorta horrifying to grasp what has happened but it is important and helps to guide a way out of this epidemic.
Cynthia Thurlow, NP
@_CynthiaThurlow
📖 Book Recommendation: Gary Taubes new book Rethinking Diabetes is a must read for anyone looking to thoroughly understand the trajectory that has brought us to our current type 2 diabetes epidemic and standard of care and how new research is telling us we need to change!
-
gary taubes reposted
City Journal
@CityJournal
.@garytaubes joins @JohnTierneyNYC to discuss his book Rethinking Diabetes: What Science Reveals About Diet, Insulin, and Successful Treatments. cityjourn.al/48IWGjT
-
gary taubes reposted
Penguin Random House Audio 🎧 📚
@PRHAudio
.@garytaubes
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr Zoe Harcombe, PhD
@zoeharcombe
Are we treating diabetes all wrong?
David Cox wonders if @garytaubes is right.
Why not ask "could he be right?"
We must rethink our approach to this epidemic.
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/7cd3b8c0-44b3-40f5-ae98-b67da0… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Alert: @KenDBerryMD tells me his X account has been hacked/hijacked.
Please ignore any further tweets from his account until X can restore it and we let you know it's back in his control. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Unholy Trinity is a new book, #1 on Amazon currently.
By a lay person, entrepreneur Daniel Trevor, who was eating right, exercising reulgarly, normal weight yet still had a heart attack.
His research led him to revelation that advice to eat fruits, veg, whole grains, vegetable oils, which he'd followed was in fact all wrong. Great interview w/ @KenDBerryMD
Ken D Berry MD
@KenDBerryMD
Interview with Daniel Trevor x.com/i/broadcasts/1BRJjPoqbnBKw
-
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
I'm excited about some new podcasts and media events that will be dropping soon - at least 6 over the next couple of months that will reach millions of people each!
@melrobbins will be dropping our first episode tomorrow!! -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My latest substack column (h/t to @lowcarbGP): which evidence do we trust when deciding on nutritional therapy for patients with obesity and diabetes?
Nutrition Researchers Say It’s the Doctors Who Are Fooling Themselves – Are They? open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/nutrition-resear… -
gary taubes reposted
Institute for Optimum Nutrition
@ion_nutrition
Virta Health has a free conference Sparking a Revolution in Metabolic Health January 23–25, 2024
Gary Taubes fireside chat on the 23rd with @samiinkinen1
moonshots.virtahealth.com
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Join me at Virta Health’s Moonshots for Health conference – 2024's premier virtual conference on the future of metabolic health.
I'm doing a fireside chat on the 23rd with @samiinkinen 1 pm ET.
The conference is fully virtual and free to attend. Register here: -
gary taubes reposted
Amrita
@amrita418
Excellent new interview with @garytaubes Rethinking Diabetes | Healthy Living - January 16, 2024 youtu.be/OimzLqQuWPM via @YouTube
-
gary taubes reposted
P. Jeffrey Ungar, PhD
@pjungar
Reposting this way since it appears X has mysteriously messed up the thread post ordering. Maybe.
P. Jeffrey Ungar, PhD
@pjungar
Getting beyond cartoon philosophy versions of what science is and its methods are, these quotes capture its essence as a human activity designed to establish reliable information 🧵
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Join me at Virta Health’s Moonshots for Health conference – 2024's premier virtual conference on the future of metabolic health.
I'm doing a fireside chat on the 23rd with @samiinkinen 1 pm ET.
The conference is fully virtual and free to attend. Register here: -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
This is how I'll be spending the morning of the first day of my 58th year (Yikes -- so much still to get done in this life.). Join us at 9am tomorrow, January 19th, for what is certain to be an inspiring and informative conversation with three heroes of the metabolic mental health movement. @bschermd @Radiantbeasting @DominicDAgosti2 @Metabolic_Mind @MetabolicSummit
Metabolic Health Summit
@MetabolicSummit
Join us for an enlightening Live Q&A with Dr. @bschermd and @Radiantbeasting on the Metabolic Initiative.
This event, scheduled for January 19th at 9am PT/12pm ET, offers a rare chance to interact with leading experts in metabolic therapy for mental health. You can participate for free when you claim your 7 day free trial.
Dr. Bret Scher is the Director of @Metabolic_Mind, a non-profit providing resources and education in the emerging field of metabolic psychiatry, including the use of ketogenic therapy for mental disorders. He is a board-certified cardiologist, lipidologist, and leading expert in therapeutic uses of metabolic therapies, including a ketogenic diet.
Hannah Warren, an artist and social entrepreneur, shares her personal journey of managing bipolar disorder with ketogenic therapy. She joined Baszucki Group and its initiative, Metabolic Mind, in November 2023 as the Mental Health Communications and Advocacy Manager.
This session, hosted by @DominicDAgosti2, promises to be an invaluable learning experience for anyone interested in the role of metabolism in mental health. Don't miss this opportunity to gain insights from these pioneers in metabolic therapy. Register now at membership.metabolicinitiative.com/bret-hannah to secure your spot in this live, interactive session. -
gary taubes reposted
RD
@RRDDDDDDDDDD
T1D Facts:
-
gary taubes reposted
Georgia Ede MD
@GeorgiaEdeMD
Come celebrate the launch of my new book with me at a special LIVESTREAM gathering Tuesday, January 30th at 5 pm ET! 📚
I’ll be hosting an interactive Q&A session, sharing exclusive sneak peeks into the book’s chapters, and even giving away signed copies to a few lucky attendees. 🎁
Got a burning #brainfood question? Drop it in the comments below, and I might just answer it live! 🎥
➡️ www.eventbrite.com/e/dr-georgia-edes-book-virtual-launch-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This should be interesting.
Abby Schwartz, VP of disease management at Mt Sinai, will be talking to me about Rethinking Diabetes.
I'm wondering whether we'll agree and the level of contention if we don't.
www.92ny.org/event/rethinking-diabetes -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is heartbreaking. And in a capital of diabetes research.
Perhaps they should rethink their approach to counseling and therapy. That carbs and sweets are part of the dietary culture does not mean that eating them is worth the loss of a limb.
www.nytimes.com/2024/01/16/us/diabetes-san-antonio-texas-… -
gary taubes reposted
Frank Lipman MD
@DrFrankLipman
Via @garytaubes: We’ve known since the 19th Century how to reverse type 2 diabetes with diet alone.
How and why was this knowledge lost? Why did MDs insist on drug therapy instead? Why do they still?
I explain the history & science in my new book, Rethinking Diabetes. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Talking diabetes and my new book with @KenDBerryMD
Ken D Berry MD
@KenDBerryMD
Rethinking Diabetes with Gary Taubes x.com/i/broadcasts/1eaKbgyjDBRGX
-
gary taubes reposted
Cynthia Thurlow, NP
@_CynthiaThurlow
The brilliant and thoughtful @garytaubes and his latest book podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/everyday-wellness/id1435214…
-
gary taubes reposted
Donald Phillips
@phillipsdo
This should have been publicized at least as much as the original that was favorable to big food/pharma. But of course it will not. #abc #nbc #cbs #fox #cnn #nyt @garytaubes @bigfatsurprise @SBakerMD @ifixhearts @KenDBerryMD
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002231662372806X -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The @WSJ reviews my new book, Rethinking Diabetes today.
The message/argument, James S. Hirsch writes, "is important and should be heard."
www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/rethinking-diabetes-review… via @WSJBooks -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
... @lowcarbGP asks a critically important question.
Should physicians defer to epidemiologists and poorly done RCTs for suggesting dietary advice to patients, or rely on reproducible clinical experience?
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
1/3 Published today my first ever editorial 😊Are we getting good value from all the money spent on research into nutrition and obesity ?? Obesity rates are climbing ++so perhaps not. I suggest an alternative nutrition.bmj.com/content/early/2023/12/14/bmjnph-2023-00…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
So my first book for The New Year, the brilliant @garytaubes unpicking how we ended up with the drug centric paradigm of T2 diabetes with so little interest in prevention Just lifelong medication I love many of the historical quotes Gary!
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
More signs of paradigms shifting and, perhaps more importantly, the opening of the clinical mind in medicine.
Fad diets cease to be fads when MDs accept clinical benefits from them.
Adherence will improve if health improves.
www.cedars-sinai.org/discoveries/fasting-as-next-step-in-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We’ve known since the 19th Century how to reverse type 2 diabetes with diet alone.
How and why was this knowledge lost?
Why did MDs insist on drug therapy instead? Why do they still?
I explain the history & science in my new book, Rethinking Diabetes.
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Perfect for a rainy winter day in 2024.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm going to 2nd Mark's take.
The LookAHEAD study showed precious little benefit from weight loss.
It's probably the method that matters. Carb restriction, via the Virta Health approach, will lower A1C more and, yes, weight as a side effect.
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa1212914
Mark Gossage
@bulkbiker
Not true.
Blood glucose control is way more important than 'weight loss"...by not spiking your blood you'll do way better. Weight loss may or may not be a side effect but lowering your HbA1c will assist your health far more.
A link to the ViRTA study would be helpful. -
gary taubes reposted
Simulation brought to you by Pfizer
@zerocarbage
“Of course”. 🙄
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Calling diabetes therapy "paradoxical" is a kind way to put it, but we can start there.
Ignoring this paradox amid an out-of-control diabetes epidemic is inexplicable.
My essay in @time is online.
My new book, Rethinking Diabetes, is available now. www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
time.com/6551555/diabetes-treatment-diet-essay/
#diabetes #wefightdiabetes #rethinkingdiabetes
@diabetesdaily
@ADA_DiabetesPro
@IntDiabetesFed
@JoslinDiabetes
@diaTribeNews
@Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1
@DiabetesCanada
@ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI
@martymakary
@samiinkinen
@bretschermd
@davidludwig
@lowcarbgp
@robbwolf
@drjasonfung
@KenDBerryMD
@SBakerMD
@drmarkhyman
@shellenberger
@DrJBhattacharya
@bigfatsurprise -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Does Diabetes Therapy Need a (Serious) Course Correction?
My book, Rethinking Diabetes, is out today.
A Q&A with the author on Unsettled Science.
open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/does-diabetes-th…
@diabetesdaily
@ADA_DiabetesPro
@IntDiabetesFed
@JoslinDiabetes
@diaTribeNews
@Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1
@DiabetesCanada
@ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI
@martymakary
@samiinkinen
@bigfatsurprise
@bretschermd
@davidludwig
@lowcarbgp
@robbwolf
@drjasonfung
@KenDBerryMD
@SBakerMD
@drmarkhyman
@shellenberger
@DrJBhattacharya -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thank you, Georgia. And I'm anxiously awaiting Change Your Diet, Change Your Mind. www.diagnosisdiet.com/full-article/all-about-my-new-book-…
Georgia Ede MD
@GeorgiaEdeMD
And this shocking figure likely doesn't include the cost of managing all of the mental health conditions fed by persistently high insulin and glucose levels including "Type 3 Diabetes" aka Alzheimer's disease. Congratulations and thank you for this important new book @garytaubes.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Dr. Bernstein was patient #1: the first to ever check his blood sugar multiple times a day. He proved patients w/ T1D could maintain healthy blood sugar.
He changed diabetes practice forever. But not enough.
My new book, Rethinking Diabetes, is out Jan 2.
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
#diabetes #wefightdiabetes
@DikemanDave
@diabetesdaily
@ADA_DiabetesPro
@IntDiabetesFed
@JoslinDiabetes
@diaTribeNews
@Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1
@DiabetesCanada
@ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI
@martymakary
@samiinkinen
@bretschermd
@davidludwig
@lowcarbgp
@robbwolf
@drjasonfung
@KenDBerryMD
@SBakerMD
@drmarkhyman
@shellenberger
@DrJBhattacharya
Dr Shawn Baker 🥩
@SBakerMD
Dr Richard Bernstein is an icon in the world of diabetes management and still going strong at 89 years of age! youtu.be/2UZXv8HAn70
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
1960: < 2 million Americans with diagnosed diabetes
Today: 30 million*
Is this a problem that can be solved by drug therapy?
There must be a better way
My new book, Rethinking Diabetes, is out Jan 2
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
#diabetes #wefightdiabetes
* www.cdc.gov/diabetes/data/statistics-report/
@diabetesdaily
@ADA_DiabetesPro
@IntDiabetesFed
@JoslinDiabetes
@diaTribeNews
@Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1
@DiabetesCanada
@ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI
@martymakary
@samiinkinen
@bretschermd
@davidludwig
@lowcarbgp
@robbwolf
@drjasonfung
@KenDBerryMD
@SBakerMD
@drmarkhyman
@shellenberger
@DrJBhattacharya -
gary taubes reposted
Eric Chance
@EricChance
Entering 2024 morbidly obese? T2D? Consuming a daily buffet of pharmaceuticals?
You know you need to make some changes but don’t know how?
Well. I don’t have a product to sell you here on X but I do have a gift to give…
HOPE
I am you. I was you. I have walked your walk. Lived with your shame and embarrassment. I know what it feels like to miss out on life but still put on the fake smile in hopes others don’t see the pain.
Two years ago I had no idea how dramatically my life was about to change but it all upended in Jan 2022 when I learned I was T2D after landing in the ICU in diabetic ketoacidosis.
-320+lbs
-T2D
-CPAP
-High BP
-Blood lipids wrecked
-Cholesterol north of 300
-Triglycerides north of 500
-Gout issues
-NAFLD
I was metabolically bankrupt and had a choice to make.
Choose the easy and continue along or change it all.
I chose to change it all. All of it.
Reversed the T2D in less than 4 months.
Dropped 145+lbs by June 2023
No longer require any prescriptions and my bloodwork is all within range and even near optimal in many aspects for my age.
I’m not going to say it’s easy. It’s not. It’s hard. All good things require actions and effort.
So I’m going to continue to share my experiences and what helped me eliminate/remedy the laundry list of issues above.
Like I said, I don’t have a product or plan to sell (nothing wrong with anyone who does, lot of great options from knowledgeable people here on X —- that’s just not me) but I do have HOPE to give if you are like me. I have walked in your shoes.
Start rewriting your story now. Today. With your next meal. Your next bite. Take it one day at a time. Focus on being the best you can be today and make it happen.
You have complete and absolute control over what you put in your mouth. Stop making excuses. Start making action.
The reality is you aren’t that far away from where you want to be. Time and consistency will get you here.
I did it and I’m just a regular guy. 49 years old. Obese or morbidly obese my entire adult life. I’m not special. I just show up and give what I got every day.
Join me in making 2024 the healthiest version of yourself you possibly can.
#carnivore
#keto
#weightlosstransformation
#weightlossjourney -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
I was lucky to read an advance copy of @garytaubes' new book. Let's not bankrupt healthcare system. Let's all buy a copies of Gary's book and give them to the influential people we know.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The cost to society of diabetes:
$1.1 billion/day
$413 billion/year*
Are new drugs the answer?
Or will we bankrupt the healthcare system?
There must be a better way.
My new book, Rethinking Diabetes, is out on Jan 2nd
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
*diabetesjournals.org/care/article/47/Supplement_1/S11/153…
@diabetesdaily @ADA_DiabetesPro @IntDiabetesFed @JoslinDiabetes @diaTribeNews @Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1 @DiabetesCanada @ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The cost to society of diabetes:
$1.1 billion/day
$413 billion/year*
Are new drugs the answer?
Or will we bankrupt the healthcare system?
There must be a better way.
My new book, Rethinking Diabetes, is out on Jan 2nd
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre…
*diabetesjournals.org/care/article/47/Supplement_1/S11/153…
@diabetesdaily @ADA_DiabetesPro @IntDiabetesFed @JoslinDiabetes @diaTribeNews @Diabetescouk
@BeyondType1 @DiabetesCanada @ADCESdiabetes
@Diabetes_DRI -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
If you are struggling with anything from depression or anxiety to bipolar disorder, a proper diet can be more powerful than any drug.
I've read this book and recommend it highly! @GeorgiaEdeMD #mentalhealth
Georgia Ede MD
@GeorgiaEdeMD
We're officially one month away from the launch of my new book, Change Your Diet, Change Your Mind! 📚🍽️🧠
Do you believe as strongly as I do in the power of diet to improve, potentially prevent, or perhaps even reverse a wide variety of chronic mental (and physical) health conditions?
Do you wish more people had reliable, scientifically accurate information about what a brain-healthy diet should look like?
Do you wish more people knew how much more control they could have over their mood, memory, thinking, and behavior if they applied simple biological truths about brain food and brain metabolism to their lives?
Let's work together to reach and empower individuals, families, clinicians, and communities who have not yet been introduced to these ideas.
You can help by sharing this post to spread the word or pre-ordering the book for yourself or a loved one from your favorite store: www.diagnosisdiet.com/change-your-diet-change-your-mind #booktwitter -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Honored to get a starred review from Booklist for my new book, Rethinking Diabetes.
It's out on January 2nd, available for pre-order now.
www.amazon.com/Rethinking-Diabetes-Science-Successful-Tre… -
gary taubes reposted
Shelly Heinrichs
@ShellyHeinrichs
Excited to listen to @garytaubes latest book! #reversingdiabetes #reversinginsulinresistance #wholefoods #lowcarb #keto
-
gary taubes reposted
Alan Watson
@DietHeartNews
Of course, in many cases, the disorder has gone on too long. (And required insulin is not the same as Ozempic and Jardiance.) One in 3 today are diabetic or pre-diabetic. People at risk need to do their own research and, as necessary, find a competent MD. Consider @garytaubes
-
gary taubes reposted
Columbia Magazine
@columbiamag
Whether you’re looking to take control of an illness or get better sleep, Columbians have a book for it. These six titles by @garytaubes '81JRN, @fperrywilson '06VPS, @catbohannon '09SOA, '22GSAS, and other authors will help you live a healthier life. magazine.columbia.edu/article/6-health-and-wellness-books…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
🔥 Just over 72 hrs and 657k views
See @BudoffMd's award winning presentation (#lmhrstudy) - vs matched control (#miheart) analysis 👇👇👇
↔️ #ldl 272 (4.7 yrs) vs 123
✅ No statistically sig difference in plaque
✅ No correlation of plaque w/ LDL
⚠️ More research needed ⚠️
Dave Feldman
@realDaveFeldman
🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨
BREAKING: @BudoffMd has now presented the matched analysis for:
KETO (#lmhrstudy) vs Control (#miheart)
-🙏Please RT🙏-
METHODS – 80 Participants of #lmhrstudy fell within #miheart age range and were then matched 1:1 for age, gender, race, diabetes mellitus, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, and past smoking to asymptomatic subjects from the #miheart cohort.
PRIMARY ANALYSIS – High resolution heart scans (#ccta) allowing for primary analysis of Total Plaque Score (TPS), Total Stenosis Score (TSS) and Segment Involvement Score (SIS)
RESULTS
The matched mean age was 55.5 years, with mean #ldl cholesterol of 272 mg/dL (max LDL-C 591) mg/dl and mean 4.7 years duration on a ketogenic diet.
🚨 There was no significant difference in coronary plaque burden of #lmhrstudy (mean LDL-C 272) cohort as compared to #miheart controls (mean LDL 123 mg/dl); nb: pre-KETO LDL-C in KETO group was 122 mg/dl
🚨 There was no significant difference in CAC (median and IQR) [0 (0,56)] versus [1 (0, 49)], p = 0.520
🚨 No relationship of LDL-C elevations and plaque
⚠️ This analysis is on baseline scans and the study is still ongoing for second CCTA completion in our cohort by February of 2024. And as always, please continue to work with your doctor.
- I will have my own video reaction and thoughts in the coming hours.
🙏🙏🙏 to everyone -- and I mean everyone -- who helped us get to this pivotal milestone. 🙏🙏🙏This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Important questions raised by @bigfatsurprise.
If your institute & research are funded by organizations devoted to promoting veganism, can we trust you to be rigorously testing the benefits & harms of a vegan diet?
Should we assume your goal here, too, is advocacy?
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
My latest investigation into why nutrition science is so hard to trust.
"Stanford's Vegan Twin Study: Science or PR Stunt?"
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/stanfords-vegan-twin-stud… -
gary taubes reposted
Neil Barsky
@nsbarsky
I would second this.
Without the work of @garytaubes, this article would not have been written.
And without his books, I might not even have been aware of the low-carb science that put me on the path to health.
Amy Alkon
@amyalkon
This, from @nsbarsky’s piece.
And Gary, thanks so much for all you do and have done. I hope on occasions when you have a shitburger of a day, you’ll do as I say (hah hah) here: Think of all the people who, thanks to your work, are alive and thriving instead of dead or suffering terribly. That is just huge. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Superbly written, important op-ed by @nsbarsky on reversing type 2 diabetes.
Reversing this condition is possible with diet alone, but MDs won't quite tell you, bc they're immersed in the pharma model of treatment. New book by @garytaubes reveals the story.
Please share! -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Two facts we must confront:
1. This is a national scandal (international, as well).
2. Diabetes is reversible by diet: "One way to think about it is that my diabetes manifested itself if I ate carbs. If I didn’t, I was essentially fine." -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ozempic for menopausal weight gain. Interesting article in The NYT.
www.nytimes.com/2023/11/27/well/live/menopause-ozempic-we…
Mayo Clinic's @StephFaubionMD says of these women struggling with weight gain, “They come in, and they’re often in tears about it. They don’t know what’s happening,”
So why are they gaining weight? What's happening?
The new conventional wisdom, per @KevinH_PhD et al., suggests that excess weight/fat is caused by the brain's failure at a subconscious level, "to control food intake in response to the body’s dynamic energy needs as well as environmental influences?"
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9071483/
But, says the NYT, we're talking about 1.5 lbs of excess weight/year for up to a decade. That's 14 to 15 kcal/day stored as fat.
That's 2 almonds worth of body fat stored each day.
So are we to believe that menopause induces changes in the brains of half of humanity such that they become incapable of eating a little bit less than previously?
Even if they have to eat 100 kcal/day less to prevent 15 kcal/day stored as fat, why isn't that easy enough? Why the tears? Why don't they know what's happening?
Would someone explain this to me?
Why are we not discussing the hormonal changes with menopause -- particularly reduced estrogen secretion -- that favor fat storage as the primary mechanism?
Is it too simple to think of this as a hormonal phenomenon that directly influences fat storage, disassociating it from the quantity of food consumed?
Help me out here. -
gary taubes reposted
Brian Sanders
@FoodLiesOrg
This is how the propaganda works, folks
You get 2 tiny patties of beef, the world’s healthiest food…
The bioavailable and complete protein and fat that fueled our species for all of history…
And cover it in every bit of processed slop you can get your hands on and deep fry it in seed oils…
Then you blame the 2 thin patties of perfect human nutrition
That’s $ciEnCe 🤡
📹 @kyleistook -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
US now spending $1.2B dollars a DAY on diabetes.
A disease we know how to treat--and reverse--yet the expert establishment is not letting people know...bc..why? resistance to change? pharma$$? We Americans deserve to know the truth--and to be healthy.
www.healio.com/news/endocrinology/20231109/cost-of-diabet… -
gary taubes reposted
Swiss Re
@SwissRe
📺Which areas of research and future strategies are needed to address #diabetes, #obesity, and ill #metabolichealth? Find out in this panel discussion with @john_schoonbee, @garytaubes, @BenBikmanPhD, @davidludwigmd, @gsgarrett, @Branca59, and @ShebaniMD: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vg_SEHo3eyY?utm_campaign=cpn-1894…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nina Teicholz, @bigfatsurprise, is one of the few journalists, if not the only one, investigating nutrition researchers and the web of conflicts of interest entangling their work.
This is required reading.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
New report: Harvard leader Willett recently had a paper linking red meat + diabetes. Yet this idea has been refuted in clinical trials. Why does Willett persist?
This investigation finds the answer in a mixture of personal ambition, bad science, financial interests and personal bias.
shorturl.at/yCRU3 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Rethinking Diabetes will be out in the New Year.
Kirkus gives it a starred review, calling it a "must-read book for diabetics, but doctors will also learn a lot."
www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/gary-taubes/rethinking… #kirkusreviews -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Just a couple of clarifications:
1. Experiments aren't done to prove hypotheses, they're done to test them.
2. We can all think what we want. You cannot expect people to be free of preconceptions -- scientists or those of us who just pretend. That's why the whole hypothesis and test thing.
But something is causing these epidemics of ob/db. If it's a food group -- seed oils, carbs, sugary beverages, red meat, pick your poison?? -- we might want to know that and so avoid it. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here's another way to think about it:
In the midst of unprecedented epidemics of obesity and diabetes, the NIH bureaucrats think they should spend our tax money not on identifying unambiguously, the cause of these diseases/disorders, but personalized dietary therapies. 😐
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
If the @NIH is going to spend $189M on a diet study, why not do it right-- a randomized controlled clinical trial, which is the gold standard.
This study will be hampered by lack of a control group + major confounding, including fact that subjects will be volunteers.
Why not get data that would truly be valuable? -
gary taubes reposted
Karen Thomson
@_karen_thomson_
Look what popped up on my timeline today @garytaubes @bigfatsurprise ❤️
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
And hey, @nytimes readers, did you know that it's possible to reverse type 2 diabetes, hypertension + more, and that this has been known, studied, practiced by MDs for 10y+ now?
No, because the paper of record has not run a story on this news that could transform your life. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Belly fat is actually a formal diagnostic marker for insulin resistance--so, scary.
The NYT treats its readers like children: coddling them, encouraging them to feel like victims, comfort eat, binge eat. But its readers are smart! And I'd bet they prefer to live in good health. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Then, framing obesity as victim status rather than a medical condition...well, I can't see that being helpful.
Certainly no one with a disease should be mocked. But we have to take obesity seriously. It is a primary risk factor for T2 diabetes and other chronic diseases. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
NYT resists any info. on the v. real risks that excess sugars/grains destroy health. When the paper ran an op-ed by Drs. Hallberg/Hamdy in favor of the low-carb diet (in 2016), NYT's Gina Kolata attacked it a few days later in a "news" piece.
No piece on low-carb science since -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
I want people to feel comforted and stress-free as much as anyone, but there are other, far healthier foods that can do this.
And when will the NYT wake up to the enormous body of science showing that sugar/grains are the fast road to obesity, diabetes, heart disease, etc -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
And ICYMI, here's what the Times recommended in the middle of the pandemic, when we knew that obesity, diabetes etc vastly increased the risk of worsened outcomes and death from Covid
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
I'm having trouble believing that the @nytime cares about the health of its readers.
Here's a featured recipe from this week. A stack of pancakes with syrup that will send your blood sugar sky high and is one of the worst possible ways to start the day. -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
This should be a great conference! Quite a line-up of speakers.
Sign up⬇️
Karen Thomson
@_karen_thomson_
RevitaFest just went live! The schedule features the brightest, most brilliant minds in health and wellness! Register at revitafest.com
@ProfTimNoakes @bigfatsurprise @DrAseemMalhotra @robbwolf @Mark_Sisson @RobertLustigMD @jonnoproudfoot @drjasonfung @SBakerMD @DrEades @mdeades @emilykumler -
gary taubes reposted
Nutrition Coalition
@4dietaryreform
Type 2 diabetes is a devastating condition, leading to blindness, amputation, heart disease + more.
But it can be REVERSED--in just weeks.
In Alabama, a program➡️T2 reversal.
Surprisingly, those in lowest socio-economic groups did best.
www.nutritioncoalition.us/news/reversing-diabetes-in-alabama -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
An important op-ed by @davidludwigmd, A. Lichtenstein, W. Willett, Frank Hu
These experts are not always aligned, but they agree on this:
The @WHO's recent low-fat diet recommendation is ill-advised. A giant step backwards. This diet, introduced in 60s, was based on weak science. Then tested in many large clinical trials and found not only to have no effect on preventing obesity, diabetes & cancer, but also to CAUSE heart disease!
The WHO is ignoring this evidence.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00029165236615… -
gary taubes reposted
Maureen Smith
@campmaureen
Taubes deconstructs mainstream reporting on the MIND diet trial for cognitive decline prevention: “It’s like getting to watch how the immune system of a living organism responds in real time to the appearance of a threat.”
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ever wonder why nutrition advice seems never to change, even as clinical trials frequently refute it? My latest Substack--MIND and the Media--examines the role of journalists in perpetuating nutritional dogma, even when reporting on trials that refute it. open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/mind-and-the-med…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ever wonder why nutrition advice seems never to change, even as clinical trials frequently refute it? My latest Substack--MIND and the Media--examines the role of journalists in perpetuating nutritional dogma, even when reporting on trials that refute it. open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/mind-and-the-med…
-
gary taubes reposted
John Schoonbee
@john_schoonbee
Maybe now we can get somewhere. Healthcare vs. Sickcare.
I am so proud that Swiss Re is putting effort into this. The aligned interests between our business, and the health and wellbeing of our policyholders is so obvious. And our vision of making the world more resilient beyond paying claims, also comes through so strongly with this focus on improving metabolic health.
To misquote Steven Jobs..."I want to put a dent in metabolic ill-health"
I know all these great people or companies hope we can manage that and more!
@bigfatsurprise @garytaubes @lowcarbGP @drjasonfung @BenBikmanPhD @LeefstijlSticht @davidludwigmd @drmarkhyman @RobertLustigMD @GroHealth @samiinkinen @AdamWolfberg @virtahealth @keto_live @KetoCounselor @GeorgiaEdeMD @ShebaniMD @ChrisPalmerMD @IainCampbellPhD @CampbellMurdoch @DoctorTro @DrCaseysKitchen @Levels @PharmacistCath @VoedingLeeft @janellison @DavidBaszucki @Metabolic_Mind
What an incredible group of people. Singularly striving to improve people's health. I am honoured to know and collaborate with them.
Swiss Re
@SwissRe
What's the solution to improve or put in remission noncommunicable diseases that kill 41 million people each year, costing USD 47 trillion between 2010-30? Good nutrition & lifestyle, says our Global CMO @john_schoonbee. Learn why it matters for insurers: www.swissre.com/reinsurance/life-and-health/l-h-risk-tren….
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Huge @WashPost piece on declining life-expentancy and massive toll chronic disease on ever-younger people.
A large body of science shows that type 2 diabetes can be reversed, blood pressure normalized and many other conditions improved in a matter of just weeks with carbohydrate restriction. Yet the media, experts continue to stick their heads in the sand. It seems criminal at this point
www.washingtonpost.com/health/interactive/2023/american-l… -
gary taubes reposted
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
This sobering book by @jamestabery argues that disproportionate investment in the science underlying “precision medicine” has led to less focus on important environmental drivers of poor health. Is the same story repeating in the context of “precision nutrition”? HT @garytaubes
-
gary taubes reposted
Kathleen Hays
@Kathleen_Hays
Maybe WHO should read your book and the books of so many others like @DrEades @garytaubes
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
It's begun: Youtube now down-ranking health news that doesn't comply with World Health Org (WHO) guidelines, which are low-fat and low sat-fat.
If the WHO doesn't approve, it's "misinformation"
So if you search "keto diet," top hit is this:
(Note: only 166K views) versus.... -
gary taubes reposted
Swiss Re
@SwissRe
What role does #nutrition play in fighting obesity and #diabetes? Join our conference with @bmj_latest and leading experts who will talk about ultra-processed foods, food addiction and more: www.swissre.com/institute/conferences/food-for-thought-20….
@garytaubes @Dr__Guess @kamranabbasi -
gary taubes reposted
Tim Noakes
@ProfTimNoakes
When I was in medical training in the 1970s, I recall that Professor Christiaan Barnard who performed the world's first successful human heart transplant (on a patient with obliterative coronary artery disease due to type 2 diabetes causing end-stage heart failure) told us that the "normal" blood cholesterol concentration was 7.5mmol/L. That was before the word "statin" had entered the medical lexicon and the "heart-healthy", prudent, low-fat diet "in moderation" had still not been invented to save Senator George McGovern's ailing political career @bigfatsurprise @garytaubes
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Kimberley D Bruce
@kimberleydbruce
Great start to the 8th Symposia on Ketogenic Therapies #keto2023. @garytaubes making the case for low-carb keto diets in obesity, diabetes and epilepsy.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Great opportunity for some critical science journalism. Please pass the word.
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
🚨 New Science Journalism Fellowship!
The Johns Hopkins Science Writing program and @GoodSciProject are awarding $5K reporting grants for articles that reveal flaws in science policy, practice, or funding.
Grateful for RTs and help spreading the word.
advanced.jhu.edu/good-science/ -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Ironically, the WHO reports on aspartame are, in fact, based on weak evidence. To understand why, read this in-depth analysis by a top independent science journalist @garytaubes, not paid by any industry.
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/confounders-biases-and-th… -
gary taubes reposted
John Schoonbee
@john_schoonbee
Food for thought 2023 (with BMJ) and our own Fixing Metabolic health. Now open for virtual attendance.
www.swissre.com/institute/conferences/food-for-thought-20…
www.swissre.com/swissre/institute/conferences/fixing-meta…
@garytaubes @davidludwigmd @bigfatsurprise @lowcarbGP @drjasonfung @GeorgiaEdeMD @BenBikmanPhD -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Equating a positive energy balance with weight gain
👉"is like saying the only way to make money in the stock market is to buy low and sell high – an observation that, while true, is meaningless as an investment strategy"
New review of Carb-Insulin Model
royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2022.0211 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
This is not just corporate science. It is the type of nutrition science practiced at most of our top universities and also relied upon by the US Dietary Guidelines for Americans (and the World Health Org). Association does not mean causation.
Cary Kelly
@CaryKelly11
Corporate science: If a person eats this and gets healthy, it’s because of the veggies. If a person eats this and gets sick, it’s because of the meat.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
1 Data from the new James Webb Telescope suggests fundamental concepts in our understanding of the universe need to be rethought.
Isn't this a situation that every scientist dreams of?
www.nytimes.com/2023/09/02/opinion/cosmology-crisis-webb-…
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2 And, yes, the parallels to obesity science are obvious.
Although the anomalies that cosmologists see as speaking to their fundamental understanding of the problem, obesity researchers describe merely as "promis[ing] to be a rich area of discovery". 😐
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adg2718 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Do artificial sweeteners make you fat, per a recent WHO study? The inimitable @garytaubes walks you through the numbers and explains why not just this study but so much nutritional science can't be trusted.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My latest piece on Substack looks at the lessons to be learned from the recent reports on artificial sweeteners.
Thanks again to @bigfatsurprise and Unsettled Science.
Confounders, Biases, and the Sweetener Science open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/confounders-bias… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My latest piece on Substack looks at the lessons to be learned from the recent reports on artificial sweeteners.
Thanks again to @bigfatsurprise and Unsettled Science.
Confounders, Biases, and the Sweetener Science open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/confounders-bias… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Great early coverage of my new book, Rethinking Diabetes, in Medscape, by editor-at-large George Lundberg.
www.medscape.com/viewarticle/995726?src= -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thinking more about this: clearly there's a controversy/conflict here. @tamarhaspel surely knows this, and it's been replicated in replies.
So why would a journalist report one side of a scientific controversy as though it's clearly true, and not simply report the conflict itself? Who gains? Surely not WP readers?
Tamar Haspel
@TamarHaspel
A decent % of replies: "This is totally obvious, nobody disagrees, get a grip!"
Another decent %: "This is totally wrong."
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/08/23/calories-in-calori… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
No, Christopher and Tamar, the real disagreement is whether this is meaningful.
That you expend more calories than you take in when losing weight says nothing about WHY you are losing weight.
Do you seriously not understand this?
Christopher Gardner
@GardnerPhD
Calories in/Calories out
Great piece on this today from @TamarHaspel
The real disagreement isn’t over whether this is true; it’s whether the effect is large enough to make a difference in weight loss.
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/08/23/calories-in-calori… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Sometimes I wonder whether the effort of trying to build this movement is worth it. Then I get an email like this one titled "You saved my life" and I know it is. The credit actually goes to my son for taking on ketogenic therapy and sticking with it and for pioneers like @ChrisPalmerMD @GeorgiaEdeMD @ShebaniMD and @IainCampbellPhD.
Highlights:
After beginning ketogenic therapy for Bipolar II, this person found it took:
- 4 days to relieve a decade of chronic anxiety
- 1 week to eliminate strange thoughts
- 2 weeks to no longer tell he had bipolar disorder
Continued full remission.
What are we waiting for?
The text of the email is below, bold added by me:
#ketoformentalhealth #metabolicpsychiatry -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sounding like I'm blurbing, which I am:
If you want to understand better how fashions are formed in science and why certain research disciplines (and paradigms of thought) come to dominate, Tyranny of the Gene is a must and gripping read.
Jim Tabery 🤔
@jamestabery
I've been inspired by the work of @DorothyERoberts, @CaulfieldTim, @NaomiOreskes, @garytaubes, @sandrogalea, & @douglasstarr ever since I was in grad school.
So having _Tyranny of the Gene_ published today with their endorsements is an incredible honor.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/622502/tyranny-of-the-ge… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How about healthy user bias?
Hypothesis: the participants who consume no artificial sweeteners tend to be more health conscious?
They can't be compared with those who, well, don't worry about it.
These people are different in ways that go far beyond the noncaloric sweeteners they consume.
We tend to think that those who consume these non-caloric sweeteners are health conscious because they're choosing sucralose, say, or aspartame over sugar. But maybe avoiding sweeteners entirely is both a marker of leanness (i.e., the reverse causation) and a marker of health-conscious behavior (healthy-user bias).
These small risk ratios don't have to be the result of just one bias. They could be the accumulation of many.
Think Steffen et al have the data to rule that out?
Think they care?
Hint: A few RCTS would take care of all these unknowns.
Charles Brenner, PhD
@CharlesMBrenner
reverse causation much?
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My entree into Substack. Thanks @bigfatsurprise for hosting.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
The MIND diet, long considered the 'gold standard' for mental health, finally gets tested in a clinical trial. And turns out it was no better than the control.
I'm honored that @garytaubes chose to write about this on "Unsettled Science"
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/lessons-from-the-mind-die… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As do I.
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
I agree 👍
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Highly recommend the provocative essay in the @NYtimes today by @jamestabery and the book from which it's adapted, Tyranny of the Gene.
www.nytimes.com/2023/08/05/opinion/personalized-medicine-…
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/622502/tyranny-of-the-ge… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nice critical assessment by @adamgopnik of the ultraprocessed food science.
I particularly liked his 2 "reasonable questions" about diet at the end:
"What pleasure does it provide when you eat it? and Will it kill you sooner than you deserve to die?" www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/07/31/ultra-processed-peo… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nicely put.
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
I just read the Opinion Piece in the @nytimes about @hubermanlab and fitness culture among straight men
🚨I did not like it, and here’s why:
First, the perspective seems from someone who hasn’t done her homework on who Huberman is, exemplified by her decision to quote a colleague in explaining Huberman as “Goop for him.”
Personally, I find analogizing the free publication education platform of Stanford neuroscientist who routinely publishes in top journals to a generally regarded as pseudoscience company that markets expensive vaginal steaming and ‘wearable stickers to rebalance the energy in your body’ a least mildly offensive. If I were Andrew, I’d be fuming (but he's probably cool as a cucumber).
There’s also problematic messaging in the article about the interest of ‘straight middle aged dudes’ in fitness
The author calls “nerding out about diet and fitness” a “stereotypically more feminine pursuit,” and then seems to imply capturing men’s interest in #fitness is a great marketing tactic:
Quote: “Because women were the main consumers of this kind of information, it’s not surprising that marketers would look for a different approach to attract men — and that appeal has often been couched in science and statistics, which is how Huberman frames his information.”
Personally, I’ve spent dozens of hours and $0 on HubermanLab. FWIW, a “V-steam” from Goop goes for $200, although I suppose I don’t have a vagina.
The article then goes for the orthorexia play… “And certainly diet and fitness extremes can be as psychologically damaging to men.”
Admittedly, the article walks it back, stating that it’s probably “positive that middle-aged men are becoming more deliberate about taking care of their health.” By why even go there? It's just poor messaging dressed up as nuance
Overall, this article was primarily confused or unnecessary messaging that tries to knock at a scientific and social media HERO by someone who transparently just seemed annoyed her husband left athletic greens goo in the dishwasher and likes to talk about protein.
The article closes, “I simply do not want to hear another word about protein.”
The article: www.nytimes.com/2023/08/02/opinion/huberman-husband.html
I'm sure @hubermanlab would be much gentler in his response, which is actually why I feel the urge to be a bit of a bull-dog right now. I ask humbly he retweets and we will see how the community feels... -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
People with diabetes have been given bad advice for decades. Eating carbohydrates than taking insulin to "cover" it is not good medicine.
I can't wait for @garytaubes new book, Rethinking Diabetes, which takes us through the history of how we got here.
RD
@RRDDDDDDDDDD
⚡️⚡️⚡️LOW CARB DEBATE. 60 second clip of Dr. Richard Bernstein making the case for normal blood sugars for people with diabetes.
-
gary taubes reposted
Professor Charles Xavier
@PezeshkiCharles
There are enormous implications of your work to the collective mind we share. This one is long, but IMHO, worth the exploration. What is sugar doing to our brains from a much larger perspective?
empathy.guru/2017/12/29/weight-loss-by-the-v-memes-v-cutt… -
gary taubes reposted
Pete Shaw
@PeterMShaw
Eat Meat & Vegetables
Nuts & Seeds
Some Fruit
Little Starch
And…
NO SUGAR
Still the most elegant description and prescription for a healthy diet.
Take a listen to @emilykumler interview @garytaubes on the Broken Science Initiative podcast:
podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/the-broken-science-podcast/… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr Lucia
@LuciaAronica
🧵 Exciting news! 🎉Our article on ultra #lowfat and ultra #lowcarb #ketogenic diet is now published in @FrontNutrition. We examined the effects of these diets on #weightloss, #bloodlipids, & #refinedgrain intake in the DIETFITS #randomizedclinicaltrial 👉 www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnut.2023.1220020/full
-
gary taubes reposted
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
2/2) This messaging is misleading: While cancers are heterogenous, and not all cancers feed on primary on sugar, many do [feel encouraged to google Warburg effect].
More to the point, there are growing data showing low-sugar and #ketodiets can improve outcomes as adjunctive therapy for some patients with cancer.
So, can you have a coke, M&Ms or “natural” sugars in apples with some Jiff PB if you have cancer? Sure. You "can." But if your cancer is a “sugar addict” maybe it’s not the best idea. Chat with your oncologist.
ht/ @davidludwigmd @Sam_Apple1 @RobertLustigMD @ascarbs @garytaubes
I also recommend Sam Apple's book, Ravenous, for an interesting scientific and historical perspective www.amazon.com/Ravenous-Warburg-Search-Cancer-Diet-Connec… -
gary taubes reposted
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
🧵This certainly isn't the worst version of this article I've seen, but it's really strange that there's no discussion of the difference between glucose and sucrose (table sugar) and no mention of insulin. The core argument of these sorts of articles usually goes like this ..1/
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
1/2) @nytimes ignores growing evidence, and diminishes sugar-restriction for #cancer
👉“[I]f you have cancer … [eat] a balanced, healthy diet” -- “[A] dab of peanut butter on an apple slice”
👉“[I]t’s OK to indulge in a little added sugar, even on a daily basis”
...fine 12 tsp of "added sugar" per day” (> a can of coke or ~100g M&Ms) -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This prompted my loudest, spontaneous LOL in years. Hilarious!
Then I realized that, so far as the obesity and diabetes establishments are concerned, I'm essentially Tony.😐
www.tomgauld.com/shop/science-hell-print -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
There were years when our son was so unwell with Bipolar I that we couldn't go on a family vacation. There were times he was so sedated from medications he would not leave his room. It's been a miracle to see him in true form again for more than 2 years. #ketoformentalhealth
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Interesting thought experiment: let's say we add protein to the Snackwells, making them a high-protein, sugary, low-fat treat.
The protein leverage model would predict you'd eat less which would lead to less fat accumumulation.
Maybe, but I'm still betting on the nuts.
Deborah Gordon, M.D.
@DrDeborahMD
Or, in other words, "Good Calories, Bad Calories" , & thanks to @GaryTaubes we all know it's the insulin and the Fudge Pretzels.
-
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Just published:
Canceling the Science on Saturated Fats open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/canceling-the-sc… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
News! Congress has recognized that the US Dietary Guidelines do NOT serve Americans with obesity, diabetes or other chronic diseases.
For people with these conditions, the US Guidelines are not for you.
A big win for @4dietaryreform!
TY @EricaHauver
Erica Hauver
@EricaHauver
Huge win from @4dietaryreform, @bigfatsurprise & thousands who have testified and/or sent comments to the USDA/HHS about the scientific & scope failures of the US Dietary Guidelines.
This group has secured acknowledgement and action from the House Appropriations Committee. -
gary taubes reposted
Alan Watson
@DietHeartNews
go to @garytaubes and click to read the first chapter of his Keto book - no charge.
-
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
A clinical trial of ketogenic therapy for Anorexia will begin in August at UCSD. Given that current treatment paradigms lead to a 50 percent relapse rate, it’s high time the field tried something new. This case series, and the 5-person trial of keto plus ketamine recently published, has laid down a foundation of important evidence we can now build upon.
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
🤔Should we "medicalize" eating disorders?
I think the answer is "Yes, Absolutely!" Here's why:
The brain and mind have long been (and largely remain) a block-box in medicine. The tools we have the explore them are limited.
This fact, combined with the fact that the "mind" is synonymous with "human experience" contributes to a tendency to see mental health disorders as something under the strict control of societal forces and human "will."
Focusing on eating disorders (ED) specifically, there is clearly a societal contribution, with changing standards of beauty and the proliferation of visual social media contributing to a rise in body dysmorphia; however, it does not follow that ED are purely sociological phenomenon.
The mind and human experience are rooted in the brain.
The brain is material, an organ similar any other - albeit more complex, fragile and more difficult to study. But just because we don't understand it's function and metabolism, as we do those of a pancreas or heart, doesn't mean disorders of mind aren't, fundamentally, disorders of brain that deserve - nay, require (!) - medical treatment of root cause to be properly addressed.
#anorexia is a good example because it's a disease state with which it's hard for most people to relate and one that seems so entangled with a pathological attachment to current standards of "skinny" beauty in the modern world. But it's not that simple. The more we learn the more it becomes clear that #anorexia (and BN, BED, sugar addiction etc.) have metabolic, genetic, microbiome etc fingerprints. Determining causation can be difficult, but it stands to reason there are metabolic etiologies, ie that metabolic dysfunction in anorexia isn't just an epiphenomenon, but a cause itself.
It follows that interventions that correct metabolic dysfunction could help treat ED / #anorexia, and this is consistent with the results of our case series #keto for anorexia. HOW exactly could keto work for anorexia? Unclear. But I suspect the journey of the next 10-20 years in mental health will be using new technology to discover and treat the metabolic underpinnings of mental health disorders. These are exciting and hopeful times.
Finally, to answer my own question: we should medicalize anorexia because in doing so we make progress towards alleviating the stigma falsely associated with the idea of a broken self/mind and acknowledge that "we don't know" is a great starting point to start learning about what goes on in the brain of people suffering from this and related devastating conditions.
Thanks for reading
@KenDBerryMD @MichelleHurnRD @bschermd @janellison @Metabolic_Mind @ChrisPalmerMD
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
1/10) 🚨NEW! #keto for Anorexia🚨
We report on 3 patients who achieved remission from treatment-resistant anorexia using animal-based keto diet 🥩🍳
👉BMIs 10 - 13 kg/m2
👉Each gained ≥20kg
👉+Dramatic improvements in mental health
insulinresistance.org/index.php/jir/article/view/84/257
Read & Share🧵🙏 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Yes, it is. And it has been for quite some time.
The Science of What We Eat Is Failing Us www.nytimes.com/2023/06/19/opinion/nutrition-science.html -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Austrian physician Wolfgang Lutz discussed this in "Life Without Bread" (co-authored by former NIH biochemist Christian Allan).
Q; What if some anorexia is a fat-storage disorder (as believed by 1930s-50s German clinicians)?
Can it be reversed by a hypoinsulinemic diet?
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
1/10) 🚨NEW! #keto for Anorexia🚨
We report on 3 patients who achieved remission from treatment-resistant anorexia using animal-based keto diet 🥩🍳
👉BMIs 10 - 13 kg/m2
👉Each gained ≥20kg
👉+Dramatic improvements in mental health
insulinresistance.org/index.php/jir/article/view/84/257
Read & Share🧵🙏
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Until the 1950s, German discussions of weight regulation covered both obesity and anorexia/leanness (Fettsucht und Magerscuht).
Some believed they were both energy balance problems, hence eating disorders -- too much and too little.
Others saw both as fat storage defects.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here's Lutz on low-carb for leanness.
He does say that the approach is likely to first lead to weight loss, which is likely to deter physicians or patients from continuing long enough to see benefits. That's a significant problem to solve. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Continuing the thread re @TamarHaspel on SFA.
2. If you ate a low-carb, high-SFA diet (Keto), dropped lbs, blood pressure, trigs, insulin & blood sugar, increased HDL -- per Virta's trial -- would you be healthier? Even if LDL goes up?
www.virtahealth.com/blog/2yr-t2d-trial-outcomes-virta-nut…
13/21
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Twitter seems to have eaten tweets 13-21. Regrettably.
I do not have time (at the moment) to reconstitute them, so I hope this will suffice.
If you'd like me to try, let me know.Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Secondary outcomes cont.
👉 CHD mortality: "may have little or no effect."
👉 CHD events (re 17): "unclear as the evidence is of very low‐quality..."
19/21
gary taubes
@garytaubes
What about the actual evidence.
16 RCTs made the cut.
👉 15 were unblinded (col. 3)
👉 11 of those had systematic differences in care -- i.e., performance bias (col 8)
👉 3 of the remaining 4 achieved no cholesterol reduction (col 11)
A sad state of affairs.
20/21
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Scientific controversies are settled when the evidence becomes unambiguous.
The problem with consensus is it is dependent on preconceptions and beliefs -- what the research community would like the evidence to be, rather than what it actually is.
21/21 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
"That should settle it, don't you think?" @TamarHaspel asks.
My answer, not surprisingly, no.
As I've said before about nutrition research in this context (and others), let's pretend this is science.
Read on.
1/21
Tamar Haspel
@TamarHaspel
Nutrition truths are hard to suss out. But the evidence on saturated fat is surprisingly clear.
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/06/09/saturated-fat-nutr…Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
So I'd say the jury is still out.
Meanwhile, a couple of thought experiments:
1. If you ate more like the French & Swiss (copious SFAs from butter, cheese and meats) and less like the AHA prescribes (low fat/SFA) -- should you expect to die prematurely?
Thoughts?
12/21
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Twitter seems to have eaten tweets 13-21. Regrettably.
I do not have time (at the moment) to reconstitute them, so I hope this will suffice.
If you'd like me to try, let me know. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My new book -- "Rethinking Diabetes" -- is available for preorder.
garytaubes.com/my-new-book-rethinking-diabetes-is-availab… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
For those who think the American Heart Association bases its dietary advice on hard evidence, please read Nina Teicholz -- @bigfatsurprise .
Understanding modern nutrition science requires a grasp of the house of cards upon which it's built.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Here's my new post on the American Heart Association's diet. What is the evidence that it fights heart disease?
And why did the group deep-six its own evidence review?
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/evidence-for-the-american… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
The @SFChronicle has kindly published my essay about our family's journey in #ketoformentalhealth.
"Prescription pharmaceuticals are commonplace and widely accepted by patients, physicians and insurers. A dietary prescription should also be on the table."
www.sfchronicle.com/opinion/article/nourishing-brain-keto… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
DASH is generally rated best for high blood pressure
In this 4-month trial a Very-Low-Carb (ketogenic) diet was superior to DASH:
👉Sys BP (10 vs 5 mm Hg)
👉Wt loss (19 vs 10 lb)
👉HbA1c (0.35 vs 0.14%)
👉⬇️drug usage
More reason for a large-scale trial!www.annfammed.org/content/21/3/256 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm going to pass on taking seriously an article that suggests people get diabetes from insufficient yogurt consumption.
That insufficient yogurt consumption is more diabetogenic than excess intake of sugary beverages is, well, icing on cake.
Time to re-assess the methodology?
Travis Statham
@Travis_Statham
www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8 - the paper @garytaubes @bigfatsurprise
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I suppose, re @davidmjohns and his new article in @TheAtlantic, this means insufficient ice cream consumption is even MORE diabetogenic, but the authors chose to keep that to themselves. (@Dmozaffarian, we're talking to you!) www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2023/05/ice-cream-ba…
-
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Nutritional Ketosis (#keto) for #anorexia?
Our latest #metabolicmind video blew my mind. It's a love story between a young woman sick with anorexia for 15 yrs and her physician aunt. It's also a scientific detective story in which a 100-year old intervention for seizures--contraindicated for Anorexia--was used as a cure. A pilot trial of 5 patients followed, discussed here in detail. Stay tuned for more research. Watch the full video here:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYkVyATHQ0Q&t=312s -
gary taubes reposted
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
Important thread. We're unlikely to ever make real progress in cancer prevention until we focus on insulin resistance.
Lykke Sylow
@LykkeSylow
In our systematic review and meta-analysis, we found that patients with cancer are highly insulin resistant. Strikingly, insulin resistance in patients with cancer was similar to the level of insulin resistance of people with type 2 diabetes
dx.doi.org/10.1080/0284186X.2023.2197124 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm still siding with @nicknorwitz.
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
🚨The #spc debate is HERE
YouTube: youtu.be/NhnzlZew-Yw?t=2400
Podcast: www.peak-human.com/post/dr-ted-naiman-nick-norwitz-phd-an…
In this 🧵 I want to highlight of 5 arguments, which I’ll call the:
1. validity problem
2. tire and wheel paradigm
3. value add proposition
4. potential to harm
5. not about the carbs -
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
1/3 Here's our latest Metabolic Mind Podcast. It's an inspiring story of one family using nutritional #ketosis to treat #dementia and eventually regain their lives. www.youtube.com/watch?v=rx9UOhBfbys
-
gary taubes reposted
Calley Means
@calleymeans
UK children exposed to sugar rationing during WW2 experienced higher educational attainment and median incomes later in life.
freakonomics.com/podcast/what-is-sugar-really-doing-to-you/ -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As a science reporter (and possible nut), I'd revise this slightly: I ask not "what are the chances you're wrong?" but "how are you likely to be wrong?"
If they can't answer that, it means they're not trying hard enough.
Not a nut, necessarily, but not doing good science. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'm siding with @nicknorwitz on this one.
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
I hear you, but it’s important to highlight for those reading this and those tagged, the push-back against DietDoctor is NOT about defending low-carb dogma but calling out pseudo-science. Please feel free to (continue to) do so for certain low-carb/keto or vegan or carnivore etc “extremists.” That’s fair. But let’s separate that minority portion of any “tribe” from those with a particular interest in ANY evidence-based dietary approach. And let’s not condone nonsense algorithms built on an arbitrary weighting of non-comprehensive variables that produces results like these
In no world is:
- Popcorn 🍿 with yeast a better weight loss food than eggs
- Pizza 🍕 better for fat loss than watermelon
- Coke 🥤 healthier in any way shape or form than extra virgin olive oil
Some may say I’m “trolling” DD. I say these are their scores and it’s their responsible for defending them and/or collecting data to validate their model
Happy to tag all “sides” @BioLayne @jeffreyboadi_ @ethanjweiss @KCKlatt @CakeNutrition @KetoCarnivore @DaveEDanna @AdrianSotoMota @davidludwigmd because this shouldn’t be controversial -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Fantastic interview with @DominicDAgosti2.
-
gary taubes reposted
Metabolic Mind
@Metabolic_Mind
The result? A committed group of scientists and clinicians ready to improve 1) public and clinician education, 2) scientific research, 3) public policy, and more.
Stay tuned for for developments in #ketoformentalhealth and #metabolicpsychiatry here at #metabolicmind. -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. Ann
@AnnChildersMD
@TyBeal et. al. found the bioavailable nutrient density of the EAT - Lancet Planetary Health Diet lacking. The recommendation: More animal, less plant www.thelancet.com/journals/lanplh/article/PIIS2542-5196(2… @FatEmperor @drjamesdinic @MigraineBook @Tarunashree1 @ProfTimNoakes @bigfatsurprise @nytimes @CNN
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nick makes very good points here.
Satiety Per Calorie (SPC) is not just a black box calculator of dubious validity and, at best, untested benefit, but clearly a marketing tool.
I'd have hoped for a little more humility from @dietdoctor in presenting his ideas.
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
1/ As time has passed and positions have evolved, I’d like to do another thread 🧵 on Satiety Per Calorie (SPC) covering:
👉 Utility vs. Limitations
👉 Issues w/ messaging, “evolutionarily normal” “open-minded”
👉 And to get at sense of prevailing opinions (Poll!) -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
I was like this mother--helpless and frustrated as I watched my son cycle in and out of psych wards and trial 29 different psych medications. Then we learned about nutritional ketosis as a treatment for psychosis. Our son has been symptom free for 2 years. I would love to share our story with this family. It doesn't have to be this way.
Our story at www.metabolicmind.org
www.theguardian.com/society/2023/feb/25/this-feels-more-l… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Looking forward to listening to this! For a long time, no one would even talk about obesity, but now that there's a drug...that's changed. Let the conversation happen! My bias: food > drugs. Interested to hear the arguments.
Honestly with Bari Weiss
@thehonestlypod
Type 2 diabetes drug, Ozempic, allows people who struggle with their weight to finally shed the pounds. But it's also abused by celebrities. Is it a miracle cure for obesity? Or too good to be true?
Today, @Chikagirl, @VPrasadMDMPH, @calleymeans debate: spoti.fi/3Yx1NyN -
gary taubes reposted
Michael Eades, M.D.🏹
@DrEades
Funny, but not far from the truth.
-
gary taubes reposted
Harvard University Press International
@HarvardUPLondon
Forthcoming in May, The World of Sugar by Ulbe Bosma is the definitive 2,500-year history of sugar and its human costs, from its little-known origins as a luxury good in Asia to worldwide environmental devastation and the obesity pandemic.
Learn more: www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674279391 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The Cleveland Clinic's @drmarkhyman is my go-to authority for Functional Medicine and for practical, useful advice on aging and, most importantly, aging well.
Mark Hyman, M.D.
@drmarkhyman
I’m so excited because my new book, Young Forever, is out today! In this book, I cover everything that affects your lifespan, the science of longevity, and everything that you can start to implement today to live a long and happy life. Order here: www.amazon.com/Young-Forever-Secrets-Longest-Healthiest/d…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
More signs that the paradigm is shifting.
If you could reverse diabetes w/ nutritional ketosis -- now well tested, effective and safe -- would you choose that over even the latest drug therapies, expensive as they are with unknown long-term risks?
Virta Health
@virtahealth
Virta is now officially in network w/ @blueshieldofca, signaling a major expansion of our partnership with the state’s largest insurer.
By making it even easier for members to join Virta, BSCA is taking a big step towards reversing this epidemic in CA. news.blueshieldca.com/2023/02/07/blue-shield-of-californi… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
New chart from Tufts' new food ranking system.
53 General Mills cereals all healthier than cheddar cheese, milk, egg cooked in butter
Including:
Dora the Explorer, Berry Burst Cheerios, Count Chocola, Lucky Charms, Chex Chocolate.
(General Mills funds a Tufts Food Inst 🤨) -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
More required reading by @bigfatsurprise .
Read and subscribe.
Nobody in mainstream journalism is doing this kind of investigative reporting on nutrition, and it is, clearly, so desperately needed.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
New findings on the Tufts Food Compass:
Kellogg's, General Mills, PepsiCo pay Tufts to be members of its innovation center. And their products get top rankings.
Froot Loops, Maple Pecan Crunch, Honey Smacks...all > cheddar cheese
4 new charts in this post
unsettledscience.substack.com/p/tufts-food-compassits-wor… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Keto & Cognition
👉Low carb (<5%) vs high carb (>45%)
👉Cross-over trial, 7 men in military
After 2 wk adaptation, @lowcarb keto showed:
⬆️psychomotor vigilance
⬆️running memory
⬆️vigor
⬇️fatigue
⬇️sleepiness
Prelim, needs replication
#diet #nutrition
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jsr.13832 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
1954
"[Obesity was explained] with laconic references to the law of conservation of energy accompanied by knowing nods"
"What did not seem to be generally known however was...abnormal metabolic processes of obesity might cause a positive caloric balance"
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02880976 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why is Prader Willi Syndrome important in thinking about obesity?
It is an extreme example of the assumption that the voracious eating -- i.e., hyperphagia -- that can associate with fat accumulation is its cause.
This observation is among several that suggest otherwise.
1/4
Jim Johnson, PhD
@JimJohnsonSci
Intriguing links between hyperinsulinemia and Prader-Willi syndrome
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/osp4.663Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
It's not an academic issue.
Treatment implications are profound:
1. If hyperphagia causes the obesity, then it makes sense to restrict patient access to food.
2. If the drive to accumulate fat causes hyperphagia -- via hyperinsulinemia -- then it doesn't.
3/4
gary taubes
@garytaubes
In the latter, the hyperphagia would be a response to a kind of "internal starvation."
Restricting access to food in this case might be as cruel as it sounds.
Treating the hyperinsulinemia -- as the authors suggest -- might be far more effective AND do far less harm.
4/4 -
gary taubes reposted
Jim Johnson, PhD
@JimJohnsonSci
Intriguing links between hyperinsulinemia and Prader-Willi syndrome
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/osp4.663 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
New AAP guidelines on childhood obesity emphasize drugs/surgery
👉Pushback in opposite direction is to be expected, per today's NYT www.nytimes.com/2023/01/26/opinion/aap-obesity-guidelines…
👉Obesity in kids isn't caused by GI tract problems needing surgery. Time for more thoughtful approach to diet, lifestyle
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
New Clinical Practice Guidelines on Childhood #obesity
Excellent and useful review in many respects, including social determinants of health!
For treatment:
👉2 pages on drugs
👉2 pages on bariatric surgery
👉2 sentences on low-glycemic, low-carb diets🤔
publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/doi/10.1542/peds.… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Let's clarify:
If a columnist (TH) criticizes a journalist's thinking/book, that's a review.
If the journalist (GT) responds by criticizing the columnist's reporting, that's an insult.
Do I have that right?
And am I insulting you now if I criticize your choice of words?
Tamar Haspel
@TamarHaspel
Gary if you want to talk seriously on twitter maybe don't insult the people you want to talk to.
I used to think I could talk seriously to you but I learned better last go-round.
Over and out. -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
Unleashing the power of nutrition in Scotland with the Public Health Collaboration (a charity) A morning conference, Edinburgh Sat 18 March 2023. I am presenting with some new friends PLEASE support us, book here www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/unleashing-the-power-of-nutrition-… @PHCukorg @IainCampbellPhD @AllyTransforms
-
gary taubes reposted
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
Signs of progress in today's New York Times...
www.nytimes.com/2023/01/19/well/eat/nutrition-myths.html -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Vegan vs Low-fat Omnivore
159 African American women (mostly)
BMI≈37
≈50 nutrition/cooking classes (impressive) in 2 yr
Despite the intensive intervention:
👉"there were no differences between the groups, and the magnitude of changes overall was small"
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2800277 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Listened to @ProfEmilyOster on my dog walk this morning. 16 minutes in, Emily talks about interpreting evidence and why she does so differently than the "associations." I couldn't agree more.
Honestly with Bari Weiss
@thehonestlypod
Four months into motherhood, @bariweiss and @NellieBowles sit down with @profemilyoster to ask their most burning parenting questions:
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As usual, @Sam_Apple1's tweet thread -- this one on the lengthy history of a "fad diet" -- is very much worth a read. As is his book, Ravenous....
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
Thread: What I learned from a 140-Year-Old Keto Diary
While researching Ravenous — the Kindle version is temporarily on sale for $2.99: www.amazon.com/Ravenous-Warburg-Search-Cancer-Diet-Connec… — I came across a surprising find in… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
CARB Kerfuffle
Our new analysis of a famous trial (DIETFITS) finds that reducing processed carbs drove weight loss compared to fat/calorie intake
Critics claim we don't explain "all or most" wt loss, so our findings can be dismissed
Let's consider
1/13
doi.org/10.1016/j.ajcnut.2022.12.014 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A 10-part tutorial from @davidludwigmd, re-analyzing DIETFITS.
A question of quality (type of carbs) vs. quantity (calories)?
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Digging into DIETFITS!
In this major trial from 2018, weight loss did not differ on a low-carb vs low-fat #diet
Does this disprove carb-insulin model of #obesity?
In a reanalysis my coauthors and I offer a different interpretation
Open Access Link doi.org/10.1016/j.ajcnut.2022.12.014
1/10 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
What predicts drug free remission of T2D on a low carb diet and what happens to those who don’t achieve remission? We publish today here nutrition.bmj.com/content/early/2023/01/02/bmjnph-2022-00… 97% of participants who chose low carb improved their diabetic control 51% achieved drug free remission #hope 😊
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Getting there, via The Whale:
"strong genetic and epigenetic controls... dictate who will acquire obesity...in response to our worsening obesogenic environment; one full of sugar, excessive carbohydrates, oils, and highly processed food-substances." www.medpagetoday.com/popmedicine/popmedicine/102322 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
A recent trial found more wt loss on a low- vs high-carb diet at the 6-month main endpoint (PMID36508737)
In follow-up (no intervention) the difference was lost. Some consider this a negative study
After stopping meds, wt is regained. But we don't consider that drug failure!👇 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I'd want to see this replicated, but what @bschermd suggests is an obvious implication. RCTS with a keto intervention should settle this.
-
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Treatment resistant bipolar depression improves with metformin treatment. . Further evidence of bipolar as a metabolic disorder. This widely-used drug could help millions. How do we incorporate this into clinical care? @metformin4bipolar #trio_bdstudy
www.psychiatrist.com/jcp/bipolar/treating-insulin-resista… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
NEW DIET TRIAL
165 patients, T2 Diabetes
Carb: ≈15 v 45%
Fat ≈60 v 30%
At 6 mo, low-carb vs low-fat group:
⬆️ wt loss (8 lb)
⬇️ HbA1c (.6%)
⬇️ Ins resist
⬇️ fatty liver (≥1 pt improvement)
Lipids mixed
Low carb group reported greater calorie intake🤔 annals.org/aim/article/doi/10.7326/M22-1787 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is Claude Bernard, circa 1865.
Wouldn't it be nice if this were even vaguely true of any clinical trial in obesity or nutrition? -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Time for the annual stories on preventing holiday weight gain.
(Also a new way to think about obesity in the first place)
news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/12/eating-more-during… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Even if it doesn't, which I can easily imagine, why isn't it then reversed by a persistent negative energy balance of 10 kcal/d (or 20 or 50) over the rest of the year?
What differentiates those of us who holiday gorge and stay lean (as I do), and those who gorge and don't? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I took my sons to see the Giants play the Raiders in Oakland in 2017. Our only NFL game and the only game that Eli missed in his career. A disappointment then.
Now I'm proud to say we got to see Geno Smith play.
How can you not be a Geno Smith fan?
theathletic.com/3923435/2022/11/23/geno-smith-seahawks-ri… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A history lesson to inform your understanding:
1. Hetherington and Ranson used the term "hidden cellular semi-starvation" to explain the hyperphagia -- i.e., ravenous hunger -- in VMH-lesioned rats in 1942.
journals.physiology.org/doi/abs/10.1152/ajplegacy.1942.13…
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2. Astwood used the term "internal starvation" in his not-famous-enough-apparently 1963 "Heritage of Corpulence" lecture to explain the hunger that obese individuals would feel when calorie-restricting to become lean. academic.oup.com/endo/article-abstract/71/2/337/2702961?l…
gary taubes
@garytaubes
3. For common obesity, as stated, the energy deficit that has to be explained/endured is only a few tens of calories per day, per Thorkild's talk: the amount accreting daily in the fat tissue.
No internal starvation necessary, only a subtle shift in fuel partitioning. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
1. I appreciated the invite to attend (not present), and as I told you when you extended it, and you agreed, it was far more cost-effective to watch the conference over the internet than to fly from Oakland to London to do so. I have now watched it.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2. I have questioned @davidludwigmd's interpretation and so expertise many times, as he would be the first to tell you. It's the nature of a good scientific collaboration. As for @bcorkey, I have been reprimanded on twitter for doing just that. (Ask @JimJohnsonSci .)
gary taubes
@garytaubes
3. I appreciated your attempt to bring together a disparate range of opinions. A good thing. But that's missing the point. To repeat:
After a century of debate over the cause of obesity, decades deep into the ob/db epidemic, we can now agree we don't know the cause.
Why? -
gary taubes reposted
Andrew D. Huberman, Ph.D.
@hubermanlab
New Huberman Lab Podcast:
A DIET FOR MENTAL HEALTH
w/@ChrisPalmerMD @harvardmed
• Ketogenic Diet for Depression
• Obesity & Mitochondrial Disease
• How to Regenerate Mitochondria
• Nutrition to Treat Schizophrenia
• Ketosis & Fertility, Sleep, Weight
hubermanlab.com/dr-chris-palmer-diet-nutrition-for-mental… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Long article with 100 explanations for why Beyond Meat is failing. But basically it's a highly processed industrial product...which failed to win over consumers despite massive support and investment. People just don't want fake foods.
www.wsj.com/articles/beyond-meat-ethan-brown-stock-layoff… -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
This should come as no surprise.
med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2021/09/insulin-resistance… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
3 points:
1. Before paradigms shift, the (ideally) correct paradigm is inevitably a minority viewpoint, initially promoted by just one or a few researchers (and, in this case, journalists).
Arguing against it because it's a minority position seems naive. See Kuhn.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2. If this is your evidence against it -- absence of evidence for a starvation state -- you're not understanding the hypothesis.
As T. Sørensen noted in London, daily fat accretion in common obesity is a few 10s of kcal/dy.
No starvation necessary or measurable change in Eout.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
3. If the actual cause of obesity is important -- see, "obesity epidemic, dire circumstances" -- shouldn't your understanding of the dominant alternative hypothesis equal that of its proponents?
And, regrettably, shouldn't they (we?) be the ones to judge? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As you know, John, the nature of a functioning science is to question dogma; i.e., the expertise of the experts.
Considering the dire nature of the ob/db epidemic, and the decades it's been building, how much faith/trust do you think we should have in your expertise?
1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Side note: We can have these discussions without ad hominem attacks (implying I only question your interpretation of the evidence, and so your expertise, because "them books aint going to sell themselves").
You seem like a very nice guy in person. Why the pettiness? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Certainly an apt summary of the meeting.
But... when your scientific "experts" embrace ignorance 28 years into an epidemic, after 90 yrs of research, wouldn't it be a good idea to question their expertise?
www.statnews.com/2021/09/13/how-a-fatally-tragically-flaw…
The Williams Lab
@thewilliamslab
Great summary of current state in obesity research!
-
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
We published our results.
In our retrospective review of consecutive patients in our program we were able to drop 38lbs, and blood pressure dropped by 17 points while our patients stopped medications. -
gary taubes reposted
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
When I helped a patient lose weight w/ a #ketogenic diet, my goal was to help him live a healthier life despite his schizoaffective disorder; I never thought it would help his psychiatric symptoms.
#brainenergy Theory of Mental Illness with @dhrupurohit lnk.to/dhru-345 -
gary taubes reposted
Nicole Laurent, LMHC
@KetoCounselor
@drdrew @KenDBerryMD @joerogan @ProfTimNoakes @tferriss @Calv_Hunt @ascarbs @CampbellMurdoch @MikhailaFuller Would any of you please consider retweeting this thread? To help me find participants for this study? @EdinburghUni is looking for people with Bipolar disorder using keto
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Required reading:
It’s National Diabetes Month, and U.S. Plans Will Lead to…More Diabetes, by @bigfatsurprise open.substack.com/pub/unsettledscience/p/its-national-dia… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here's another way to think of it:
Re wikipedia: "Starvation is a severe deficiency in caloric energy intake, below the level needed to maintain an organism's life.... It is the most extreme form of malnutrition.
1/n
Nick
@upRootNutrition
Wait, why is fat restriction starvation while carb restriction is not starvation? How are you defining starvation and what is occurring differently in these scenarios such that you infer starvation for the one case and not the other?
Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Carb restriction can be a severe reduction in energy intake, but, even when continued indefinitely, it apparently causes no "symptoms and effects of starvation."
Is the same true for prolonged fat restriction?
Among the symptoms of starvation: hunger.
3/n
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How I phased it in Good Calories, Bad Calories:
If people lose weight on carb-restriction because they eat less (i.e., calorically deprive themselves), why aren't they hungry?
And if they don't eat less, why do they lose weight? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ok, differences:
1. Carb restriction will lower insulin, post-prandial and AUC. Fat restriction, without carb restriction, will not.
2. In carb restriction, the body is fueled on protein and fat. Just as it is when fasting.
1/n
Nick
@upRootNutrition
Wait, why is fat restriction starvation while carb restriction is not starvation? How are you defining starvation and what is occurring differently in these scenarios such that you infer starvation for the one case and not the other?
Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
4. Is "eating less" -- i.e., fewer calories than when weight stable -- necessary for fat loss during carb restriction?
I would assume not, but it can be tested.
By the same token, is it necessary for fat restriction?
I would assume so, but it can be tested.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
And,
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I think (with more humility, I hope), that what you mean is that "eating less" is required for sustained fat loss. Because we're agreeing on tightly associated.
But... what you're observing (usually) is that people with sustained fat loss decrease intake.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
An alternative hypothesis: fat mass is reduced by lowering insulin (i.e, restricting carbs).
Now you're burning your fat for fuel rather than storing it.
The increase in fat mobilization/oxidation causes the "eating less," not the other way around.
A viable hypothesis? -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
We address the central issue to this debate explicitly in our recent @ejcneditor paper.
Does energy balance alter body fat?
Or does changing body fat alter energy balance?
(Not an especially radical notion, when considering the adolescent growth spurt).
doi.org/10.1038/s41430-022-01179-2 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
On World Diabetes Day (yesterday), a study in the prestigious journal Pediatrics reports that bariatric surgery in teens:
👉"is underutilized nationally"
Maybe so. But the same could be said of intensive, comprehensive support for meaningful diet change
publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/doi/10.1542/peds.… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I was just about to answer this and then I saw that @titusquin (thanks, Han) had answered it for me: "Yes. For the millionth time, a caloric deficit IS weight loss."
If someone is in a caloric deficit they are losing weight. The two statements are equivalent.
1/2
Dr. Spencer Nadolsky
@DrNadolsky
Gary plain and simple,
If people with obesity eat a high carbohydrate diet while in a calorie deficit, will they lose fat?
Yes or no
gary taubes
@garytaubes
But, re Allison's point in London, that says nothing about the cause of the excess fat accumulation(which was, by the way, caloric surplus).
Could you answer my questions now?
They seemed simple enough. Quid Pro Quo?
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Ok, thanks. But I could still use clarification.
See David Allison's discussion in the recent obesity meeting at the Royal Society in London.
Is he denying energy balance by observing there is no causality in the energy balance equation?
youtu.be/xkN1floffGs?t=23938
Dr. Spencer Nadolsky
@DrNadolsky
There are many who believe energy balance is invalid and that fat loss comes down to hormones (insulin).
For example, if you’re eating in a calorie deficit, but eating carbohydrates and therefore releasing insulin, the insulin will prevent fat loss despite the calorie deficit.Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Now... If I say that insulin CAN (not will) prevent fat loss in those predisposed to obesity, am I denying energy balance?
Sure, at some sufficient level of semi-starvation (of caloric deprivation) weight will/must be lost, but does that tell us why the excess fat was gained?
gary taubes
@garytaubes
PS. You're not allowed to say, "because of eating too much", i.e., a caloric surplus, because that's tautological. Circular logic.
By pointing that out, am I denying energy balance? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I've been thinking about this since @DrNadolsky tweeted it.
I fear I fit the first one for sure.
Spencer, can you explain, though, what precisely you mean by "deny energy balance?"
It's not as clear (to us alleged zealots, anyway) as it might be to you.
Dr. Spencer Nadolsky
@DrNadolsky
Chatting with a few folks about this.
Is there a low carb thought leader who doesn’t fit at least one of these? -
gary taubes reposted
Philippe Hujoel
@hujoel
Publicly funded research agendas can become captured by private interests, not public interests. A vignette here on how the Sugar Research Foundation sharpened this skill almost as soon as they were created. @garytaubes @sugarpolitics
-
gary taubes reposted
Tim Ferriss
@tferriss
NEW podcast episode is up!
"Chris Palmer, MD, of Harvard Medical School (@ChrisPalmerMD) — Optimizing Brain Energy for Mental Health, The Incredible Potential of Metabolic Psychiatry, Extraordinary Case Studies, and More"
Please enjoy! 🙌
tim.blog/2022/11/10/chris-palmer/ -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Fake meat is about inflating markets through virtue signaling. Not even remotely about human health.
-
gary taubes reposted
Robert Lufkin MD
@robertlufkinmd
It doesn't have to be this way.
ht/t @AlpacaAurelius -
gary taubes reposted
Sami Inkinen
@samiinkinen
Enjoying @FoxNews this morning - uplifting message about our T2 diabetes epidemic and how @DeptVetAffairs is helping Veterans reverse T2 diabetes. 👏
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Few private initiatives are more exciting (to me) than what @janellison, @DavidBaszucki, and their son Matthew are doing to fight bipolar disorder and improve mental health.
Watch the video.
baszuckigroup.com -
gary taubes reposted
Benjamin Bikman
@BenBikmanPhD
Some believe that eating more fat causes fatty liver disease (#nafld). A #lowcarb diet reduces liver #fat 3X more than a high-carb diet (after a fast). If #insulin is low, the liver has little choice but to burn fat. #keto www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1922344117
-
gary taubes reposted
Nick Norwitz MD PhD
@nicknorwitz
Remember, #keto is restrictive and unsustainable
-
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
My son started ketogenic therapy on 5 bipolar meds. He has gotten off Valium, reduced Zyprexa by 50% and reduced Lithium from 1500mg to 1050mg so far with zero withdrawal effects. #ketoformentalhealth
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I also recommend the book. Required reading. (Skip the pills).
Chris Palmer, MD
@ChrisPalmerMD
Brain Energy is available as a book… or in pill form!
I recommend the book. 🤣 -
gary taubes reposted
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
If, like our son, Matt Baszucki, you are treating bipolar disorder with ketogenic diet, would you consider filling in a confidential questionnaire? @IainCampbellPhD is leading this project to add lived experience to the scientific literature. #ketoformentalhealth
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Not surprising: a low-carb diet might prevent diabetes, but...
Controls should have received an equal intervention: ideally, a different diet.
Still, it raises the question: does this mean the high-carb usual diet accelerates progression to diabetes?
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2797714 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
File this under #signsofparadigmshifting: Mr. Emmanuel "was a vegan until she convinced him to read [@CarnivoreMD's] The Carnivore Code."
www.nytimes.com/2022/10/27/style/sarah-staudinger-staud.h… -
gary taubes reposted
Amy Alkon
@amyalkon
Unpaywalled paper linked in article, by @davidludwigmd (also author of WaPo piece) +@garytaubes, Jeff Volek, Walter Willett, @drericwestman, et al.
www.nature.com/articles/s41430-022-01179-2
Taubes has shown for years a calorie is not a calorie. Also see his NYMag piece debunking exercise myths. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
On a different note, yikes. This one rocked my office and we're forty or so miles away.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Last June, the journal Science Advances published "Epidemiology Beyond Its Limits", proposing that I had done epidemiologists a disservice in 1995 with my critical article in Science, "Epidemiology Faces Its Limits."
The journal published my response, but it's hard to find. 1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The link is buried (😐) at the very bottom of the original article.
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.abn3328
I've attached the letter for those who don't have the patience.
We agree that my 1995 article in Science was unsatisfactory, but for very different reasons.
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Advice on how to live to a ripe old age, by @gdlundberg. About as good as it gets. www.medscape.com/viewarticle/979752
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Good catch, and a sloppy mistake on my part. Yes, unprocessed meat.
-
gary taubes reposted
gary taubes
@garytaubes
@NatureMedicine just published "burden of proof" studies on food and health.
Processed meats seem to have been exonerated: "weak or no evidence of associations" w/ 6 cardiometabolic diseases & cancer.
Will anyone care? So far no media attention.
www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01968-z -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
@NatureMedicine just published "burden of proof" studies on food and health.
Processed meats seem to have been exonerated: "weak or no evidence of associations" w/ 6 cardiometabolic diseases & cancer.
Will anyone care? So far no media attention.
www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01968-z -
gary taubes reposted
James McCarter
@JPMcCarter
The misplaced health & environmental halo of highly processed plant-based meats is wearing off. Same consumer scrutiny should apply to other plant-based alternatives that don't provide benefit like oat milk. @bigfatsurprise @garytaubes @JayneReesBuxton www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/industry/retail-distribu…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Delighted to see an article in the @nytimes on climate change that's not fear-mongering, but rather thoughtful and balanced.
Terrific journalism by @noahgshannon .
www.nytimes.com/2022/10/05/magazine/uruguay-renewable-ene…
But I do have one question...
gary taubes
@garytaubes
@noahgshannon, you say that
"livestock... are responsible for 14 percent of total global emitting"
and
"the U.S. livestock industry produces...a little over 4 percent of the country's total."
14 % vs. 4 %. Could you explain this difference? -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Does eating/drinking sugar cause diabetes?
In 1913, Fred Allen (Harvard) wrote that the "general attitude of the medical profession is doubtful or negative as regards statement in words... but the practice of the medical profession is wholly affirmative."
1/3
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Over a century later, nothing has changed.
Now, re @nytimes and a recent report to Congress, there is a "strong link between sugar-sweetened beverages and Type 2 diabetes". We should make it more difficult/expensive for folks to drink sugar.
www.nytimes.com/2022/10/05/health/diabetes-prevention-die…
2/3
gary taubes
@garytaubes
But they don't (won't?) say that sugar causes diabetes.
If they did, maybe we'd have to treat it as we do cigarettes (re lung cancer). Stop treating it as a benign pleasure.
Maybe, as Allen suggested, some experimental data should be added to the existing evidence?
3/3 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
#t2d It's not just about remission. Mitigation, improving blood sugar control really matters too. High blood glucose is linked to cardiovascular risk. This person with T2D used a Freestyle Libre to find out where the sugar was in his diet & look best blood sugar results in 6 yrs
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
In major genetic study
👉⬆️ body fat occurs BEFORE ⬆️calorie intake
👉obesity dependent on high insulin secretion
👉evidence for relevance to human obesity
Result
👉"differs from the dogmatic view"
👉fulfills key predictions of #carbohydrateinsulinmodel
www.nature.com/articles/s42255-022-00629-2 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
THE FIRST EVER published data on outcomes of a clinical intervention for food addiction by my wife @jen_unwin This is why ‘moderation’ is so difficult for many people with a weight problem and why stigmatisation of obesity is so wrong www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2022.1005523/f…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Type 2 diabetes in youth doubled since 2001.
But a national review concludes data "insufficient to assess the balance of benefits and harms of screening for type 2 diabetes" in youth.
Seems a strong indictment of the poor prospects of current treatment 🙁jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2796244 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Influential Gates-backed study on red meat (#gbd), whose estimates were off by 36x, is now questioned by the World Cancer Research Fund Int'l--which says the report lacks transparency and more 1/ www.foodnavigator.com/Article/2022/09/09/study-linking-de…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I should add that the ADA is slowly coming around but with all the new meds, they may never get there. The tendency of these organizations -- whether venality or not -- is to prioritize drug therapy while giving lip service to diet.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Yes, agreed. Although, of course, they assume that folks with T1 do not want to diet -- that no one does.
So assumption #2: blood sugar will be controlled primarily by insulin, but now they fear (justifiably!!) hypoglycemic episodes.
So better to go high than risk low. 😐 -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Yes, agreed. Although, of course, they assume that folks with T1 do not want to diet -- that no one does.
So assumption #2: blood sugar will be controlled primarily by insulin, but now they fear (justifiably!!) hypoglycemic episodes.
So better to go high than risk low. 😐 -
gary taubes reposted
DoctorTro | Metabolic & Obesity Physician
@DoctorTro
🚨New paper🚨
A large corporation, with a strong focus on employee well-being, asked my practice to setup an employee wellness program focused on metabolic health
& the results were amazing🤩
Weight: ⬇️38lbs
BP: ⬇️17mmHg
A1c: ⬇️1.1%
10yr ♥️ risk:⬇️44%
www.mdpi.com/2218-1989/12/9/848 -
gary taubes reposted
Lori Shemek, PhD
@LoriShemek
On the show this week, I'm excited to have NYT bestselling author @garytaubes of The Case for Keto, The Case Against Sugar, Why We Get Fat, Good Calories, Bad Calories & investigative science/health journalist. 🎙️
thispodcastburnsfat.libsyn.com/the-case-for-keto-with-gar…
#keto #obesity #fatloss #insulin -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
As Peter Cleave said, going on 60 years ago, if it's the sugar that causes the dysbiosis in the mouth and so tooth decay, it's worth betting it's the sugar all the way down the GI tract.
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Do high-fat diets cause obesity?
Rodents gain weight on high-fat diets. But these typically also have sugar and other fast digesting carbs.
👉Turns out, the problem is the sugar, not fat, through effects on gut microbiome, according to a major new study.
www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(22)00992-8 -
gary taubes reposted
Brian Johnson
@heroicbrian
Exciting news! We'll be releasing a NEW PhilosophersNote EVERY SINGLE WEEK.
The latest: The Case for Keto by @garytaubes, an AWESOME overview of why Optimizing our metabolism (via our insulin) is so important, along with HOW to do so.
- Team Heroic
#keto #readinglist -
gary taubes reposted
Jose Antonio PhD
@JoseAntonioPhD
Ketogenic diet: an effective treatment approach for neurodegenerative diseases.
www.qxmd.com/r/36043794 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
People Who Do Strength Training Live Longer — and Better www.nytimes.com/2022/08/24/well/move/cardio-strength-trai…
Ok, that's cool. But does that mean strength training (significantly) lengthens life?
The researchers and @nytimes are assuming association implies causality.
It's good copy, but bad journalism. -
gary taubes reposted
LowCarbUSA®
@lowcarbusa
There's still (a little) time to purchase your tickets for the Symposium for Metabolic Health - San Diego (Aug. 25-28). In-person & livestream options available.
www.lowcarbusa.org/smhp-symposiums/san-diego-2022/
#smpsd2022 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Clever comment, Bill, but it raises a few questions:
1. Does @bigfatsurprise say that in the article? Does she mention LC,A-B diets?
2. Are the academics criticizing the methodology known proponents of low-carb, animal-based diets?
1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
3. Is the question about black box data a legitimate one? Is it important?
4. Does the author's beliefs about the nature of a healthy diet render it illegitimate?
5. Is skepticism necessary for a functioning science, or does it get in the way (as you seem to imply)?
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why are We Basing Food Policy on Black Box Data?, by @bigfatsurprise unsettledscience.substack.com/p/why-are-we-basing-food-po…
-
gary taubes reposted
Rohit Jindal 📚
@rohit_jindal29
43. Good Calories, Bad Calories: Fats, Carbs, and the Controversial Science of Diet and Health by Gary Taubes (@garytaubes)
44. The Law by Bastiat
45. Ashtavakra Gita - Bart Marshall Translation
46. I Am That by Nisargadatta Maharaj
47. Raja Yoga by Vivekananda -
gary taubes reposted
Rohit Jindal 📚
@rohit_jindal29
An exhaustive list of @naval's reading recommendations
Non-fiction, fiction, short stories, graphic novels and blogs
[THREAD] 👇👇 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We have covered this ground ad nauseum.
If you clearly prefer @KevinH_PhD's interpretation of his non-randomized 4-week pilot study to @davidludwigmd's interpretation of his 20-week randomized trial, then yes.
But such a clear preference seems difficult to defend. 1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
More importantly, in the midst of worldwide ob/db pandemics, this is either important, as we believe it is, or not.
If it is important, it won't be settled by Twitter, only by further experiment/research.
Is it safe to say, you think it's not an important issue? -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
New post on competing view of obesity cause and effect
@Medium
#carbinsulinmodel
davidludwigmd.medium.com/when-scientific-paradigms-collid… -
gary taubes reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Is it time to upend the calorie, "energy balance," 100-year old model?
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/28/obesity-carboh… by @davidludwigmd @PostOpinions
www.nature.com/articles/s41430-022-01179-2 @NatureComms
"Overeating is a symptom, not a cause" -
gary taubes reposted
Alfred A. Knopf
@AAKnopf
Learn more about why the established rules for eating healthy might be the wrong approach to weight loss for millions in THE CASE FOR KETO by @garytaubes!
(📖: www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/561551/the-case-for-keto…)
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/28/obesity-carboh… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A near-perfect distillation of the controversy over the diet-obesity relationship.
Critically important.
A must-read for your representatives in Congress, if they care about the public health (and for the staffers who work with them).
Please help get them to notice this.
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
"With the cost of just one weight-related complication, diabetes, almost $1 billion a day, we must consider different ways of solving the intractable problem of obesity and open our minds to a radical-sounding notion: Overeating is a symptom, not a cause."
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/28/obesity-carboh… -
gary taubes reposted
Michael Pollan
@michaelpollan
Opinion | Carbohydrates, not calories, are to blame for obesity - The Washington Post www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/28/obesity-carboh…
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
My response to your post (also submitted online)
👇👇👇 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Please read + share
"Obesity isn’t an overeating problem, it’s a calorie distribution problem — too many calories from each meal being siphoned off into fat tissue." Which happens on a low-fat diet high in sugars+starches www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/28/obesity-carboh…
via Dr. Ludwig @washingtonpost 1/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Journalistic interpretation: Like many exceedingly smart people, @dandrucker apparently assumes no need to do his homework when straying from his area of expertise.
So, are there really two paradigms?
Absolutely and profoundly so.
Let's look:
1/12
Daniel J Drucker
@DanielJDrucker
Are there really competing paradigms for #obesity pathogenesis? And why is it useful for some to rewrite the nearly identical review every few months? @ejcneditor www.nature.com/articles/s41430-022-01179-2
Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The role/meaning of positive energy balance?
EBM: Excess fat storage is CAUSED by positive energy balance: Ein - Eout CAUSES ΔE
CIM: Excess fat storage IS the positive energy balance that must be explained: Ein - Eout EQUALS (i.e, IS) ΔE
11/12
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Leanness v. Obesity
EBM: People with obesity were no different than people who remain lean; they merely ate too much.
CIM: People with obesity are physiologically and metabolically predisposed to store excess fat in a carb-rich environment. Lean people aren’t.
12/12 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Critics of the Carbohydrate-Insulin Model built a new Energy Balance Model of obesity.
My 15 coauthors and I have a few thoughts about it. @ejcneditor @SpringerNature #carbinsulinmodel
New review open access at this link 👇👇👇
doi.org/10.1038/s41430-022-01179-2
Thread 1/16 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
A review (I'm an author) found 95% of 2020 Guidelines committee members had at least one relationship with industry, and majority had 20+ relationships with industry, incl many w/ Kellogg, Kraft, General Mills, Dannon, the Int'l Life Sciences Inst (ILSI)
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/public-health-nutrition/a… -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Our paper includes 2 former members of Guidelines' committees, published in NASEM invitation-only journal. Gives hope that it will be considered...
Bc remember, Guidelines are hugely influential! By law, must be followed by all federal programs. In practice followed by many more -
gary taubes reposted
JB and family
@SimmonsBart
If you read one thread today……please make it this one.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
I'm delighted to be an author on this paper, just published, in a journal of the Nat'l Academies of Sciences. A deep-dive analysis of US Dietary Guidelines (#dga),🧵on findings
academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/advance-article/doi/10.1093/pn… -
gary taubes reposted
SMHP
@TheSMHP
The Symposium for Metabolic Health — San Diego, will be held August 25-28, 2022.
In-person & livestream options are available.
Learn more & register: www.lowcarbusa.org/smhp-symposiums/san-diego-2022/ -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I just subscribed to Unsettled Science. Nina Teicholz @bigfatsurprise is one of the few journalists writing critically and thoughtfully about nutrition research and policy.
We need to support her work. We need to read her regularly.
unsettledscience.substack.com -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I couldn't be more excited to see how @KetoForMentalHealth plays out.
Jan Ellison Baszucki
@janellison
Our son recovered from Bipolar I with help from a ketogenic metabolic intervention with 100 years of evidence in epilepsy. We funded these 5 trials in keto for mental health conditions. @DavidBaszucki
#ketoformentalhealth #metabolicpsychiatrycommunity
www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/baszucki-brain-research-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Thank you @amandaripley. I'm among the 42%. And thank you @dnbornstein for doing something about it.
Opinion | I stopped reading the news. Is the problem me — or the product? www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/08/how-to-fix-new… -
gary taubes reposted
P. Jeffrey Ungar, PhD
@pjungar
How does that site address this situation? Are we supposed to use it to assess the breakdown of possible fruit servings? What question will that settle? Will it *prove* eating more fruit is good for health?
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A quick and dirty assessment of the RCT literature.
A 2021 AHA Scientific Advisory Statement on dietary guidelines cites ONLY 5 trials consistent with the observation that fruit and vegetable intake associates with reduced CHD: www.ahajournals.org/doi/full/10.1161/CIR.0000000000001031…
1/5
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Those that did in the context of greater dietary change -- the Women's Health Initiative, for instance -- showed no benefit. Despite trial design (comparison to usual care) that should have biased the trial to show one even if none existed.
Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Title of the fifth of the 5 studies (16 wks): "Increasing fruit and vegetable intake has NO dose-response effect on conventional cardiovascular risk factors in overweight adults at high risk of developing cardiovascular disease."
Adding F&V had no benefit on risk factors.😐
4/5
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If anyone can find a rigorous review of clinical trial evidence testing fruit alone (I'd settle for F&V) it would be nice to discuss in this context. I have to go make dinner (no fruit, plenty of vegetables).
5/5 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The first was an assumption, but your point is a good one.
The context, though, of my tweet: we believe fruit-rich diets are beneficial (reduce or prevent chronic disease) based almost exclusively on epidemiologic surveys.
Few RCTs have ever tried to test that hypothesis.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Those that did in the context of greater dietary change -- the Women's Health Initiative, for instance -- showed no benefit. Despite trial design (comparison to usual care) that should have biased the trial to show one even if none existed.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Now combine this with the new study reported in NYT -- observational -- which defines a healthy diet as high in fruit (and vegetables) and then elicits surprise that it isn't beneficial on its own.
A lesson in how assumptions bias future science.
www.nytimes.com/2022/07/13/well/move/exercise-diet-diseas…
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Fruit is not always your friend🍎
New trial finds that 4+ servings fruit/day worsened markers for heart disease, fatty liver disease.
Increased blood sugars (bad for diabetes)
compared to people eating 2 servings or less.
Bc most fruit is high in sugar
www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00365521.2022.2071109… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A story about anchovies dying by the thousands, literally falling from the heavens on SF homes, and it's not apocalyptic, not end-of-the-world, climate-change catastrophe. I could almost cry with happiness.
www.nytimes.com/2022/07/07/us/anchovy-dead-falling-from-s… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
I should have also thanked @HugoLindgren for making this article (and all that followed) happen.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Today is the 20th anniversary of my (in?)famous "What if Fat Doesn't Make You Fat" cover article in the @nytimes .
Working from the research of @davidludwigmd, @drericwestman, and others, it helped catalyze a revolution.
www.nytimes.com/2002/07/07/magazine/what-if-it-s-all-been… -
gary taubes reposted
Steve Scarfe, PhD
@MrScarfe
For anyone that can't read it due to paywall, here is a "gift link"
www.nytimes.com/2002/07/07/magazine/what-if-it-s-all-been… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Today is the 20th anniversary of my (in?)famous "What if Fat Doesn't Make You Fat" cover article in the @nytimes .
Working from the research of @davidludwigmd, @drericwestman, and others, it helped catalyze a revolution.
www.nytimes.com/2002/07/07/magazine/what-if-it-s-all-been… -
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Attention, e-Cig Users:
Switch from vape to butter
😂
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fimmu.2022.913044/full -
gary taubes reposted
Bret Scher, MD
@bschermd
I'll have to look into apple podcasts, but here is a link that should work www.dietdoctor.com/video/podcast/episode-1-gary-taubes
-
gary taubes reposted
Dr. David Ludwig
@davidludwigmd
Canines, Carbohydrates & Obesity
Decreasing carbohydrate consumption in dogs seems to increase energy requirements (speed up metabolism).
Also metabolic fuels in blood higher on low carb diets.
👉Preliminary data in dogs supporting the #carbinsulinmodel
www.mdpi.com/2218-1989/12/7/591 -
gary taubes reposted
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
It's far from a simple case that meat is bad for health and bad for the environment. The truth on those Qs is complex and very likely the opposite of what people are led to believe. See the great new book by @JayneReesBuxton www.dailymail.co.uk/home/books/article-10901489/Eating-me…
-
gary taubes reposted
Nicolai Worm
@NicolaiWorm
No #low-carb diet was tested in the ARIC study...we believe Seidelmann's study conclusions might restrict patient choices, inhibits future research, and impedes the advancement of public health.
@davidludwigmd @bigfatsurprise @ProfTimNoakes @garytaubes www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(2… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Important reporting by @bigfatsurprise. Please subscribe to the newsletter and pass this on.
USDA Ignoring the Science on Low-Carb Diets, by @bigfatsurprise unsettledscience.substack.com/p/usda-ignoring-the-science… -
gary taubes reposted
Scott Mulvaney
@livethefuel
Dear lord, my biz travels help me see all kinds of things. False point of sale marketing signage should be illegal. NOT Healthy Snacks! #nsng
@VinnieTortorich @AnnaVocino @bigfatsurprise @garytaubes @FructoseNo -
gary taubes reposted
Beth Akeson
@bethakeson
Menu choices are labeled heart healthy when they are NOT. High carb- sugar laden foods are NOT heart healthy, yet people continue to be misled. These men are working hard to dispel these myths. @RobertLustigMD @garytaubes
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Excellent thread by @Sam_Apple1 on Thread Reader App threadreaderapp.com/thread/1537835213211979782.html
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
1. Yes. If an animal gets obese or just fatter even when food intake is restricted, then I do not believe you can blame hyperphagia -- i.e., excessive hunger -- for the obesity.
1/2
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
Just to be clear. You believe data on ob/ob mice, with absence of leptin, shows that hyperphagia consequent to leptin deficiency is not the major driver of their extreme obesity? And that hyperphagia due to leptin deficiency is not due to deficient leptin action in the cns?
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2. Yes, the alternative hypothesis: feeding behavior is responding to the availability of metabolic fuels in the periphery. In the absence of leptin, inhibition of FFAox in hepatocytes, compounded by hyperinsulinemnia, lipolysis inhibition --> obesity & hyperphagia.
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Let's backtrack: what do you think causes common obesity?
Since we're in the midst of an obesity epidemic, that's the issue.
Brain dysregulation of energy intake/balance, per @KevinH_PhD et al's latest paper and CW for 60 years, or dysregulation of fat metabolism?
1/2
Ethan J. Weiss
@ethanjweiss
I thought the ? was whether there are hormones that directly regulate appetite/satiety in the CNS. I think the answer to that is resoundingly yes. If the CIM now includes that insulin, ketones, GLP1, or anything regulate appetite directly in the CNS, then sign me up for the CIM
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Saying both sounds good, but it's possible -- the CIM -- that the latter causes the former.
As a scientist, I know you're intensely curious about this -- a prerequisite.
Signing up for a hypothesis because it agrees with your preconceptions seems, well, contra-indicated. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Leptin inhibits AgRP neurons. Pair-fed animals (the necessary controls) get fatter with AgRP stimulation.
It suggests Agrp influences peripheral substrate utilization, lipogenesis, etc.: i.e., fuel partitioning. diabetesjournals.org/diabetes/article/50/2/248/13372/Effe…
1/1
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
One of the cited studies showed leptin receptor deletion in AgRP neurons recapitulated obesity with high leptin levels similar to ob/ob mice. So, if leptin's actions on the periphery "trumped" its central action then then why did they develop obesity? doi.org/10.1038/s41586-018-0049-7
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2. AgRP-ablated pups (neonates) become obese also w/out hyperphagia and when pair-fed.
Ablating leptin on AgRP neurons removes the inhibition. Animals get fatter, because AgRP is affecting peripheral fat metabolism. Not feeding behavior directly. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3501217/
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
The key question -- i.e., what you should be asking yourself courtesy of physiological psychology (1960s-1980s) -- is whether feeding behavior and the brain are responding to the oxidation of available fuels in the periphery?
Do you know that literature?
1/2
Ethan J. Weiss
@ethanjweiss
So then in animals where the insulin receptor is knocked out in adipocytes resulting in severe metabolic derangement with massive hyperinsulinemia & no fat, is it the central insulin signaling that drives the ravenous hyperphagia or is it the lack of central leptin signaling?
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My answer: all of the above, but dominated by peripheral effects: no fat stores, means no post-absorptive fuel supply. Hyperinsulinemia --> only carbs oxidized. No leptin --> only carbs again. So no peripheral fuels post-meal --> hyperphagia.
-
gary taubes reposted
Raphael Sirtoli
@raphaels7
you would think that the need to explain how "eating too much" isn't strictly necessary for obesity would be like catnip to obesity researchers
well, you'd be wrong
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is another excellent example of the problem we've been discussing. @StephenRahilly and his colleagues were apparently unaware that the ob/ob mouse gets obese when half-starved -- that the obesity can be disassociated from the hyperphagia.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4066138/
1/2 -
gary taubes reposted
Sam Apple
@Sam_Apple1
🧵19/ The U.S. Government sued The Sugar Institute for collusion, and it was shut down in 1936. Its mission would be taken up by The Sugar Association Inc. (SAI). In The Case Against Sugar, @garytaubes recounts the sad saga of how the SAI managed to muddy the science on sugar.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
1. To establish that the brain is the primary organ, you would have to document that leptin's action in other organs -- the liver, most likely -- doesn't trump it. These studies don't do that.
They say the brain is an important organ, not that it's the primary.
1/2
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
It's difficult to reconcile the data presented by @sguyenet in the thread below documenting the central action of leptin with the conclusion of @garytaubes that "leptin's dominant effect is in the periphery as a fuel partitioning FFAox hormone"
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Had @StephenORahilly known this fundamental fact, he might have asked how leptin could induce obesity independent of a central satiating effect. Possible conclusion: leptin's dominant effect is in the periphery as a fuel partitioning FFAox hormone.
Bias drives interpretation.
2/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
2. Nor do these studies establish mechanism.
They say nothing about whether leptin in the brain works primarily to regulate hunger/satiety (EBM) or fuel partitioning in the periphery, via CNS and endocrine signals, which in turn feeds back on hunger/satiety (CIM)?
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
This is another excellent example of the problem we've been discussing. @StephenRahilly and his colleagues were apparently unaware that the ob/ob mouse gets obese when half-starved -- that the obesity can be disassociated from the hyperphagia.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4066138/
1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Had @StephenORahilly known this fundamental fact, he might have asked how leptin could induce obesity independent of a central satiating effect. Possible conclusion: leptin's dominant effect is in the periphery as a fuel partitioning FFAox hormone.
Bias drives interpretation.
2/2 -
gary taubes reposted
Dr David Unwin
@lowcarbGP
I shall be in The House of Lords tomorrow night for the launching of the ‘Beyond Pills Campaign’ There are valid lifestyle alternatives to so many lifelong medications prescribed for the chronic diseases of modern life We could spend those £££s differently & better @bmj_latest
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
More signs of the paradigm changing and the message disseminating widely. I was in Copenhagen lecturing last week. NOCCO (the No Carbs Company) was advertising on the side of the Forum. This from my passing car.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Allow me to go into more detail. As I said in my LTE to the Hall et al paper, academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/95/2/309/4576721?login=false
a common problem in ob research is designing experiments based on the assumption that weight is indeed regulated by energy balance, which should be the hypothesis tested.
1/8
Stephan J. Guyenet
@sguyenet
Empty words.
The topic at hand is the role of leptin in the defense of elevated fat mass. I suggest reading Rudy's papers rather than repeating vague assertions.
doi.org/10.1210/jcem.87.5.8628
www.jci.org/articles/view/35055
doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.111.012385Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Had Leibel et al not ASSUMED that the leptin effect would be sustained, but rather tested it, they might have replicated Rafael & Herling's observation in ob/ob mice. journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/ajpregu.2000.278…
7/8
gary taubes
@garytaubes
They might have concluded, as Rafael & Herling did, that "no leptin-specific central satiety signal" was necessary to explain the observation.
Leibel et al didn't because they worked with only one hypothesis: energy balance. Hence, ignoring the revolution in fat metabolism.
8/8 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Hard questions to answer. You can see the diabetes epidemic starting in the 1800s (hospital records). OB rates increase throughout 1900s. In the 1960s, we turned breakfast into dessert for the kids who were adults when the epidemic started.
1/2
Plomeek Soup
@PlomeekSoup
Ok, even if we focus on that, why did they take 200 years to cause an obesity epidemic starting in the 1980s if they're so fattening?
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Refrigerators became ubiquitous post-WW2, with it home consumption of juices and sodas. The intergenerational passage of the predisposition from mother to child in the womb plays a part. The advice to those getting fatter became eat carbs.
All could explain it.
2/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
It's too simplistic to assume that what caused the epidemic happened coincident with the epidemic and not, in this case, in the decades leading up to it.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Yes, but you'd have trouble ruling out sugar and sugary beverages as the trigger in China. They might consume half the Japanese level, but it has been exploding recently and may be particularly high in urban areas. They might be particularly susceptible as a population.
1/2
Tucker Goodrich
@TuckerGoodrich
This would be compelling if it weren't for the Chinese.
They eat a 1/2 the Japanese level of sugar, and are in the midst of an obesity epidemic.
Common genetic background.
Sugar cons:
www.foodpyramid.com/healthy-eating/which-country-consumes…
"Overweight and obesity in China":
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1550451/
gary taubes
@garytaubes
A black swan would be a population that experiences an ob/db epidemic w/out a nutrition transition that included a significant intake in sugar/sugary beverage intake.
Here's what I hope is a thoughtful discussion:
garytaubes.com/thoughts-on-a-black-swan-2-the-hadza-and-h…
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
When I asked him about the obese, semi-starved ob/ob mouse (consuming half the kcal of lean animals fed ad lib) he said it was an interesting point and he hadn't thought about it.
As with you, I was trying to get him to think about it as it's a fundamental observation.
1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Why fundamental observation?
Because if you're going to blame the obesity on over-eating (positive energy balance), then the obvious question is whether they get obese even when you control for the over-feeding or force them to underfeed.
They do. -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Tax dollars are being used for you to argue with me on twitter. It seems only fair.
You keep asserting dogmatically that I "ignored so much" without saying what I ignored. Please be specific. It's hard to defend against these assertions without saying "just read the book.
1/2
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
Sorry, but tax dollars aren’t going to be used to hold your hand as I walk you through the papers. Still, it’s surprising that you ignored so much despite being the only one to read the literature. Curious, how you know you are the only one to do so? Have you done an experiment?
gary taubes
@garytaubes
We've discussed leptin. I didn't mention it. I did mention that ob/ob (leptin-deficient) mice get and stay obese even when half-starved. That was ignored. @JohnSpeakman4 has provided a "guess", clearly a work in progress. Any thoughts?
2/2 -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Here's an early example of the divergence.
In 1948, a leading authority, John Brobeck, explains fat storage as "a passive process" driven most often by "excessive food intake." Brobeck's thinking (building on Newburgh, building on von Noorden) is the origin of today's.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Put simply, the science of excess fat accumulation (obesity) diverged from the science of fat accumulation in the 1940s. And it has remained so ever since. See, for instance, the difference between the thinking about fat accumulation in adipocytes and in obesity in Lehninger's.
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Same year, Wertheimer and Shapiro, in THE seminal review on the new science (the revolution) of fat metabolism, say "mobilization and deposition of fat go on continuously, WITHOUT REGARD TO THE NUTRITIONAL STATE OF THE ANIMAL."
-
Post not available here, view on X
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Put simply, the science of excess fat accumulation (obesity) diverged from the science of fat accumulation in the 1940s. And it has remained so ever since. See, for instance, the difference between the thinking about fat accumulation in adipocytes and in obesity in Lehninger's.
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Sorry, I missed this one. Many questions:
1. How do you define positive energy balance if the animal is no heavier than the lean?
2. And the lean animal, so long as it's growing/getting heavier, is also in positive energy balance.
3. Why fat in one, not in the other?
1/2
gary taubes
@garytaubes
4. The big one: how do they "pile fat into the stores"? What's the mechanism? The lean (also in +EB) don't.
5. And how do you know that's not the primary effect?
All of this can be explained by leptin upregulating FFAox. No leptin -> no FFAox ->excess fat stored ->hunger. -
gary taubes reposted
Low Carb Down Under
@lowcarb_aus
Our latest release from 'Low Carb San Diego 2021' courtesy of @lowcarbusa - Gary Taubes looks at the history obesity medicine to explain where we went wrong @garytaubes
youtu.be/IbtxJZPviUo -
gary taubes reposted
GameStudioLaw.com - Dale Dietrich
@DaleDietrich
NBC News broadcast a report tonight saying that low carb diets can reverse diabetes. Of course they can. We’ve known that for year This is a HUGE deal. Finally low carb diets are getting public recognition as Whoo hoo! @garytaubes @BrianLenzkes
youtu.be/kqkhj653nIs -
gary taubes reposted
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
Our @AJCNutrition paper on the Energy Balance Model of obesity resulted in 3 letters to the editor:
doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqac162 from @garytaubes
doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqac161 from Mark Friedman
doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqac160 from Torres-Carot et al.
Our response: doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqac163
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
I was honored to lead an international team of renowned obesity scientists (including @Farooqi_Lab @StephenORahilly @DrLeanneRedman @JohnSpeakman4 @deirdre_tobias) to address widespread misunderstandings about modern obesity science in @AJCNutrition: academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nq…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
All the comments, can be found here: academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-articles
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My response to @KevinH_PhD et al's EBM vs CIM article is on-line here (and worth a read, IMHO):
watermark.silverchair.com/nqac162.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE4…
And @KevinH_PhD et al's response to the response here (also worth a read) :watermark.silverchair.com/nqac163.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE4…
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
I was honored to lead an international team of renowned obesity scientists (including @Farooqi_Lab @StephenORahilly @DrLeanneRedman @JohnSpeakman4 @deirdre_tobias) to address widespread misunderstandings about modern obesity science in @AJCNutrition: academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nq…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
My response to @KevinH_PhD et al's EBM vs CIM article is on-line here (and worth a read, IMHO):
watermark.silverchair.com/nqac162.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE4…
And @KevinH_PhD et al's response to the response here (also worth a read) :watermark.silverchair.com/nqac163.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE4…
Kevin Hall
@KevinH_PhD
I was honored to lead an international team of renowned obesity scientists (including @Farooqi_Lab @StephenORahilly @DrLeanneRedman @JohnSpeakman4 @deirdre_tobias) to address widespread misunderstandings about modern obesity science in @AJCNutrition: academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nq…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Diabetes and the Virta Health program may be tipping points.
It's one thing to just lose some excess weight if the rest of your life isn't working. Putting your diabetes into remission and getting off insulin presents a different ratio of risks to benefits.
Virta Health
@virtahealth
For the past 7 years, Virta has been writing the science on diabetes reversal and remission. Today, we’re sharing the latest installment, with 5-year outcomes from our landmark clinical trial & 2-year results from our work with Veteran patients. www.virtahealth.com/blog/long-term-type-2-diabetes-revers…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nice to see @fayeflam's assessment of minority views in science in the Washington Post, as well
Censorship Isn't the Best Way to Crack Down on Quack Science - The Washington Post - www.washingtonpost.com/business/censorship-isnt-the-best-… -
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Nice mention in @fayeflam's latest column, re being on the good side of the minority opinion spectrum in science. Thanks, Faye. www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-02-01/censorship-…
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
If nothing else, the USDA and the national health organizations have to stop ignoring the science on low-carb diets and include them in their guidelines.
Nina Teicholz, PhD
@bigfatsurprise
Major new paper on low-carb diet, making the case that it should be one option in the US Dietary Guidelines for Americans, esp. for people w/ obesity, diabetes etc. Paper addresses criticisms of low-carb, such as idea that it's not heart healthy 1/ www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/10/3299
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
Among Americans, #diabetes is more prevalent today than ever, #obesity is at epic proportions, and nearly 10 percent of children are thought to have nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (#nafld). #sugar is at the root of these problems. garytaubes.com/works/books/the-case-against-sugar-2016/
-
gary taubes
@garytaubes
How much did bad science contribute to obesity? Maybe a lot? Talking with Jonathan Levi at Becoming SuperHuman www.becomingasuperhuman.com/gary-taubes-how-bad-science-m…
























































































































































































































































































































































