A HUMAN RIGHTS PLATFORM FOR ISRAEL/PALESTINE
People like Macklemore, Abdul El-Sayed, Zohran Mamdani, and Ro Khanna may not be bigots or antisemites in their hearts. I don’t know.
What I do know is that they and others like them repeatedly deploy shorthand, dog-whistle language that takes an extraordinarily complex conflict, in which rights, wrongs, suffering, and responsibility are widely distributed, and reduces it to facile, inflammatory slogans designed to foment anger, generate social media attention, erase essential historical and moral complexity, and help normalize a socially contagious bigotry that has become increasingly fashionable in some left and right-wing circles and online.
If they genuinely want to advance human rights, they should move beyond these cynical and divisive slogans and embrace a more serious, consistent, unbigoted, and universal human-rights platform in their speeches, concert announcements, campaign events, and social media posts:
• Respect the rights, dignity, and humanity of all people.
• Fully recognize the profound tragedies, traumas, displacement, and suffering experienced by both the Jewish/Israeli and Palestinian peoples.
• Acknowledge that most Israelis, Palestinians, and other people across the region would rather live in peace, dignity, prosperity, and security than in perpetual war and insecurity.
• Work toward a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in which two equally indigenous peoples can live side by side in peace, dignity, freedom, and security.
• Stand unequivocally for a future in which Israelis and Palestinians alike can raise their children without terrorism, occupation, war, displacement, hatred, or fear.
• Reject the idea that supporting Palestinian human rights requires denying Jewish history, Jewish indigeneity, Israeli security, or the legitimacy of Israel’s existence, while equally rejecting the idea that supporting Israel requires dismissing Palestinian identity, suffering, dignity, or legitimate aspirations for national self-determination.
• Support serious learning about the history and complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict rather than reducing one of the world’s most difficult conflicts to simplistic TikTok slogans.
• Acknowledge the near-complete destruction and displacement of ancient Jewish communities across much of the Middle East and North Africa during the 20th century.
• Acknowledge that Palestinian and Arab leaders have rejected multiple peace proposals over the decades —including in 1937, 1947, 2000, and 2008—that could plausibly have led to the creation of a Palestinian state.
• Recognize that Israel captured Gaza in the 1967 war, withdrew its military forces and settlements from Gaza in 2005, and hoped that disengagement could help create conditions for an eventual Palestinian state. Recognize as well that this strategy failed catastrophically after Hamas seized control of Gaza and transformed it into a base for terror and war against Israel.
• Unequivocally and without reservation condemn the September 11 and October 7 terrorist attacks.
• Recognize that Hamas carried out the October 7 massacres to derail the possibility of Israeli-Saudi normalization and provoke Israel into a devastating military confrontation in which Hamas sought to exploit Palestinian civilian deaths and suffering for strategic advantage.
• Condemn Hamas for investing enormous resources in hundreds of miles of subterranean military tunnels while leaving Gaza’s civilian population dangerously exposed above ground, and for deliberately (per their own internal documents) exploiting Palestinian civilian suffering and deaths as part of its military and political strategy.
• Call on Hamas and Hezbollah to immediately and unconditionally surrender, lay down their arms, and end their campaigns of terror.
• Call to free the Palestinian people from Hamas, the Lebanese people from Hezbollah, and the Iranian people from the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and the repressive Iranian regime.
• Condemn the Iranian regime for the brutal murder of tens of thousands of its own civilians and demand that Iran immediately cease all support for terrorism and terror proxies.
• Recognize Israel’s absolute right to defend itself, including through military force, against terrorist organizations committed to its destruction.
• Call on the Israeli government to immediately rein in and prosecute Jewish extremists/terrorists carrying out illegal acts of violence in the West Bank.
• Recognize that while Israel has an absolute right to defend itself against terrorist organizations seeking and actively working toward its destruction, it also has a solemn responsibility to wage even a just and necessary war as ethically, carefully, and humanely as possible.
• Recognize that calls to “globalize the intifada” and to free Palestine “from the river to the sea,” in the current context and against the backdrop of the explicitly eliminationist ideologies of terrorist organizations including Hamas and Hezbollah, can reasonably be understood as calls for violence against Jews and the destruction of Israel.
• Make clear that, in all but a few, narrow set of cases, anti-Zionism is a form of antisemitism because it denies Jews the same right to national self-determination routinely recognized for scores of other peoples around the world.
• Condemn antisemitism, Islamophobia, racism, bigotry, dehumanization, and hate speech in all their forms.
• Support human rights in Israel and Palestine as part of a broader commitment to the rights, dignity, freedoms, and responsibilities of all people and all communities everywhere.
It’s admittedly a long list, but that is precisely the point. Reducing all of this complexity to facile, distorted slogans is not peace activism, human rights advocacy, support for the Palestinian people, or a serious effort to advance a future Palestinian state. Instead, it is participation in a dangerous propaganda war that rewards outrage, flattens history, fuels hatred, and turns human suffering into political currency. This may generate social media attention and applause from ideological allies, but it deepens division, empowers extremists, and makes peace less likely.
Our world deserves something far more serious, honest, humane, and constructive. Artists and politicians have the tremendous opportunity to help lead the way toward this better world. I hope more of them will.