The Psychology of Win–Win Denial
Marian L. Tupy for Skeptic on why people struggle to grasp basic economics, e.g., that there is a fixed pie of wealth such that if someone has a large slice of money it must mean that others have smaller slices. Not so.
www.skeptic.com/article/psychology-of-win-win-denial-why-…
Michael Shermer
Michael Brant Shermer (born September 8, 1954) is an American science writer, historian of science, executive director of The Skeptics Society, and founding publisher of Skeptic magazine, a publication focused on investigating pseudoscientific and supernatural claims. The author of over a dozen books, Shermer is known for engaging in debates on pseudoscience and religion in which he emphasizes scientific skepticism. More on Wikipedia
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Since I am not a professional philosopher, and because I am stepping into a philosophical debate that has been raging ever since David Hume articulated the Is/Ought naturalistic fallacy, I asked the philosopher Robert Pennock to assess my argument for a science of morality. Here is what he told me on my podcast episode discussing this issue:
"The way the argument works is to say if you want to get a moral conclusion you need at least one moral premise. It’s not that there aren’t factual premises—and this I took to be your main point, that science gives us some moral premises that make a difference—and that’s exactly right. But the naturalistic fallacy doesn’t say you can’t have factual premises. It says you can’t have only factual premises. You have to have something that has an ought, such that together with the is you can get an ought in the conclusion. And I would say that the way you make your argument is actually bringing in oughts into your premises and so you’re not actually denying the naturalistic fallacy. Really, you’re accepting it but building in some ought premises from the beginning. And that’s the right way to do it!"
I concede the point that Robert Pennock is making, namely, that any case for right or wrong must begin with some built in moral premise. In my theory’s case it is the survival and flourishing of individual sentient beings, by which I mean the evolved instinct to live and to have adequate sustenance, safety, shelter, bonding, and social relations for physical and mental health. If that’s a moral premise, so be it, but at least it is a premise grounded in empirical science that anyone can observe for themselves. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @AutistocratMS
I derive this "is" from history and science:
Historically, given the choice, people opt for democracies and command economies (at the ballot box and with their feet).
Scientifically, we know democracies and market economies generate more freedom and prosperity than do autocracies and command economies, and political scientists and economists have produced two centuries of data to support this conclusion.
Of course, if you prefer to live in, say, Cuba or Somalia, you are free to do so, but you may not be free to ever leave. That is all you need to know.Martin Štěpán @AutistocratMS
"For example, that democracies are better than autocracies"
Here, you're clearly deriving is from your oughts, i.e. ideological delusions. There is no evidence that this is whatsoever true. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The answer is in your name @HUH3810 : utility.
That is, democracies and market economies work better than autocracies and command economies.
By work I mean they lead to greater survival and flourishing of more people in more places more of the time.
And: people vote for these conditions, either through the ballot or with their feet. There's a reason everyone wants to come to the U.S. and almost no one wants to go elsewhere. Why? Because they are more likely to survive and flourish here.Utilitarian Hereditarian @HUH3810
"[D]emocracies are better than autocracies, that [sic] market economies are superior to command economies[.]" According to what criterion; net happiness? Why should pleasure be good and suffering be bad?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is: people make agreements between one another because it benefits both.
Ought: people should honor their agreements.
Is: people prefer to live in democracies and market economies.
Ought: we should do what we can to free people to choose these systems of politics and economics in their countries.
Is: people do not like being enslaved.
Ought: slavery should be outlawed and prevented.Gordon McCabe @DrGordonMcCabe
None of those are 'oughts'. You're confused between meta-ethics and ethics.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No, because of common knowledge between the potentially rival groups:
They know that you want to prosper
They know that they want to prosper
They know that you know that they want to prosper.
They know that you know that they know, etc.
So acting morally instead of immorally with other groups actually benefits you.
That is, acting kind toward others can be the most selfish thing you can do.
That is the basis of true morality because you cannot fake being a good person or group. You actually have to be one, and that means to feel it deep inside.Bogdan Varlamov @bogdanvarlamov
If you model morality on evolution, it aligns with genetic self-replication... exterminating rival groups is perfectly aligned. Might makes right. Your concerns about what they want or don't want are irrelevant. Bacterial genes don't want you to take antibiotics either, so what?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes, in the chapter on Moral Truths in my latest book, Truth, I claim that one can derive an ought from is. Here is how:
It is my hypothesis that in the same way that Galileo and Newton discovered physical laws and principles about the natural world that really are out there, so too have social scientists discovered moral laws and principles about human nature and society that really do exist.
Just as it was inevitable that the astronomer Johannes Kepler would discover that planets have elliptical orbits—given that he was making accurate astronomical measurements, and given that planets really do travel in elliptical orbits, he could hardly have discovered anything else—scientists studying political, economic, social, and moral subjects will discover certain things that are true in these fields of inquiry.
For example, that democracies are better than autocracies, that market economies are superior to command economies, that torture and the death penalty do not curb crime, that burning women as witches is a fallacious idea, that women are not too weak and emotional to run companies or countries, and, most poignantly here, that blacks do not like being enslaved and that the Jews do not want to be exterminated.
Why do blacks not want to be enslaved? Why do Jews not want to be exterminated? The answer is in my moral starting point of the survival and flourishing of individual sentient beings. Any organism subject to natural selection will by necessity have this drive to survive and flourish. If it didn’t, it would not live long enough to reproduce and would no longer be subject to natural selection. Why?
The answer is found in the deepest purpose of life: to push back against the entropy of nature, as described by the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which is the first law of life. If you do nothing, entropy will take its course and you will move toward a higher state of disorder (ultimately causing your demise). So the most basic purpose in life is to combat entropy by doing something extropic—expending energy to survive, reproduce, and flourish.
I suppose it is possible that one day scientists may discover that humans do not have an instinct to survive and flourish, that most people do not want freedom, autonomy, and prosperity, that they don’t mind starving and being disease ridden and in pain, that they prefer ignorance to education and illiteracy to literacy, that women want to be lorded over by men, that some people like being enslaved, and that large populations of people don’t object to being liquidated in gas chambers.
But I doubt it.mdesm2005 @mdesm200559705
Do you claim to have derived ought from is?
Or do you just dance around this claim? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Recall the years of hand-wringing over N Korea getting a nuke, starting in 1994 during the Clinton administration.
Nevertheless, in 2006 N Korea got nukes and...what's the problem? Have they used them?
No. And no one else has either.
Of course, it would be a better world if N Korea did not have nukes (& for that matter if the Kim regime ended), but that's not the world we live in.
Thomas Sowell: There are no solutions, only trade-offs.
Yes, the Iranian regime is an evil theocracy, and overturning it would be good for the world, but there are dozens of other things we could do that would be equally good, but we can't do everything. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Iran War:
—Never approved by Congress
—$47.1 billion cost
—18-21 U.S. military killed + 750-865 wounded
—3,600-6,000 Iranian deaths + 10,000 injured, >3 million displaced
—Gas/Diesel prices super high
—We destroyed Iran's nuclear capacity in 2025 so...
What is the point of this illegal war?
How is this making America Great Again? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'll take Magic Bullets for $200, Alex...
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
Someone asked me this week for my most unexpected book moment. Thirteen books and 40 years give you a few.
But this one, from back in the day, is still a highlight.
Case Closed. Alex Trebek. Jeopardy! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
America built towns just to nuke them to measure the effect in the event of an actual nuclear exchange. Sounds like a scene from Dr. Strangelove but it’s real. Hear my convo with Jon Else & read his new book about Frenchman Flats, NV: www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/america-built-towns-…
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Amy Alkon
@amyalkon
The secular “church” of liberal academia still hasn’t.
And “Scientific” American is anything but.
The day they cut @michaelshermer’s column— and all he brought every month to the public understanding of science—was basically an announcement that they would, from that date on, be Ideological American and nothing else.
The destruction of Nap Chagnon’s career for 10 years was another signal in monstrous form. I’m forever grateful to @AliceDreger for the investigation she did to bring out the truth. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Top-down conspiracy by nefarious actors to shut down U.S. flights, or...
government incompetence + bureaucratic red tape leading to the use of outdated equipment in which our airports are operating on ancient computer tech?
The first is a far spicier story, the latter is reality.
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
Nobody in Washington gets to act surprised that the FAA grounded every departure on Friday. Here’s a quick cheat sheet of what 44 years of bipartisan neglect looks like.
1982 (Reagan): The FAA released its first comprehensive modernization plan, estimating the cost at about $10 billion by the late 1990s.
1995 (Clinton): GAO revised the cost to at least $36 billion.
2004 (Bush): The Next Generation Air Transportation System was launched, pegged at $15 billion, to modernize the air traffic control system. It would span at least four presidential administrations.
2023 (Biden): A contractor accidentally deleted computer files, and all U.S. departures were grounded for the first time since 9/11.
2024 (Biden): GAO warns the FAA needs “urgent action” and concludes one-third of its systems are unsustainable.
2025: The Transportation Department’s Inspector General finds NextGen behind schedule, over budget and far less transformational than envisioned two decades earlier.
2025 (Trump): Congress approved $12.5 billion for modernization. Later that year, a contractor cuts fiber lines near Dallas. More than 2,000 flights are delayed, hundreds are canceled, and 100,000 American Airlines passengers are affected.
Sept. 2026 (Trump): A failed circuit in Philadelphia and a fiber cable cut by a construction crew near New Brunswick, New Jersey, hit at once. Thousands of Northeast flights are delayed or canceled.
What the system looks like today:
More than 300 FAA facilities operate largely as silos on legacy analog systems.
Many towers effectively run on Compaq computers. HP acquired Compaq, which stopped producing computers in 2013.
The FAA has turned to 3D printing or eBay for replacement parts, and for some systems it can no longer get spare parts.
The shift from analog to digital communications is now promised in late 2027. Eliminating paper flight strips at 49 major airports will take until at least 2028. So far 18 have done it.
The FAA administrator’s own assessment: “We’re behind 20 years.”
Transportation Secretary Duffy now wants another $30 billion, and says these incidents will continue unless the resources come.
The system doesn’t fail because we lacked warnings. It fails because fixing what hasn’t broken yet wins no votes. That is why Washington is almost always reactive. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is an excerpt from my book The Moral Arc, the chapter on why religion is not the driver of moral progress:
Laura Betzig analyzed the Old Testament and found no less than 41 named polygamists, not one of which was a powerless man. “In the Old Testament, powerful men—patriarchs, judges, and kings—have sex with more wives; they have more sex with other men’s women; they have sex with more concubines, servants, and slaves; and they father many children.”
And not just the big names. According to Betzig’s analysis, “men with bigger herds of sheep and goats tend to have sex with more women, then to father more children.”
Most of the polygynous patriarchs, judges, and kings had two, three, or four wives with a corresponding number of children, although King David had more than eight wives and twenty children, King Abijah had fourteen wives and thirty-eight children, and King Rehoboam had eighteen wives (and sixty other women) who bore him no fewer than eighty-eight offspring.
But they were all lightweights compared to King Solomon, who married at least 700 women. There were Moabite, Ammonite, Edomite, Sidonian, and Hittite women he married, then for good measure added 300 concubines, which he called “man’s delight.” (What Solomon’s concubines called him was never recorded.) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Laura Betzig on the correlation of power, sex, & fecundity in the Bible & ancient civilizations (a lesson for today, eg, Nvidia's Huang):
"Having a harem is what being a king is about. God makes that perfectly clear to David: 'I anointed you king over Israel, and I delivered you out of the hand of Saul; and I gave you your master’s house, and your master’s wives into your bosom'.”
"Most emperors were fruitful in Rome. They had sex with their wives; they had sex with other men’s wives; they had sex with concubines they kept in arcana cubilia, or secret apartments, in imperial palaces; they had sexual access to thousands of slaves"
link.springer.com/rwe/10.1007/978-3-031-38971-9_2079-1 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In case you missed it, yesterday was the end of the world:
In 1960, a Science paper predicted that humans would go extinct on Nov 13, 2026, because "the human population will have expanded so far as to approach infinity and thus will automatically annihilate itself."
Let this be a lesson: we are not only smart enough to imagine human extinction, we are even smarter at preventing it through ever better ideas.
reason.com/2026/11/13/human-extinction-scheduled-forhuh-h… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Kirk defends Chappelle, who celebrates his murder. What is going on here? I thought comedians support free speech advocates.
“By refusing to charge the armed maniac who attacked Dave Chappelle on stage, George Gascon is sending a clear message that public acts of political violence are justifiable.” —Charlie Kirk
“Ever since that guy Charlie Kirk got murdered, and I shouldn’t say this publicly but. . . I feel better. It’s just a feeling. I just be driving around, like, ‘Why am I in such a good mood?’ ” —Dave Chappelle -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL
Here it is...
Ready?
Buy Low, Sell Highmdesm2005 @mdesm200559705
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Still the best book out there on the JFK assassination by @geraldposner (Vincent Bugliosi's Reclaiming History is also excellent but is 1,648 pages).
Had Oswald shot the Mayor of Dallas instead of JFK, a trial would have been case closed in a day.
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
🔥A sale on history and common sense.
November 22 will mark 63 years since JFK's assassination. Case Closed, my Pulitzer-finalist reinvestigation, was published 33 years ago and still stands as the final word on what happened on that tragic day in Dallas. My publisher has a sale on all digital editions — which include my 60th anniversary update - at the lowest price ever, $1.99.
Keep Case Closed handy the next time someone says they are still searching for the case’s phantom conspiracy.
➡️Kindle: www.amazon.com/Case-Closed-Harvey-Oswald-Assassination-eb… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Follow-up:
NVDA opened this morning at $151, closed at $166. Still down from the pre-scandal price but will likely continue rising (as it is in after hours trading).
Same thing happened after Elon smoked a joint on Rogan: TSLA price plummeted & rebounded.
Market is based, in part, not on company specifics alone but on what other people think about the companies, and what they think other people think, and so on in a common knowledge problem.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you're thinking of investing in stocks, tomorrow would be a good day to buy Nvidia (NVDA) as the price just plunged on news that the Huang-Huang affair (and possibly another) could see the CEO canned. Once all this passes the stock price will rebound.
www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-500-na… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Despite the midterm landslide, Dems should not take this as a referendum on Woke 2.0/far-left progressive politics, e.g.:
Proposition 318—Protect Girls Sports in Arizona Act—passed ~60% support.
“I voted yes. Boys should play boys’ sports. Girls should play girls’,” said a voter who otherwise supported Dem candidates.
Protecting women & girls sports in particular & rights in general was always a liberal cause until the Dems handed it to the GOP.
Dems need to return to their liberal roots & jettison the illiberalism of wokeness.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/10/us/ballot-measures-democrats-r… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not "default to truth" but "default to AI slop"
It's everywhere now. Just assume any such video is fake until proven otherwise.
Eyal Yakoby
@EYakoby
Palestinians are now sharing that Israel is dropping snakes on Gaza.
You literally cannot make this up. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Then wait to buy Friday instead of Thursday @gmiller A day delay before the rebound could happen...
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
What if the scandal is only just beginning? What if the rot runs much deeper?
And what if this scandal turns the American public even more decisively against the greed, corruption, and hubris of the AI industry? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can the United States go to war without congressional approval?
Technically, the U.S. Constitution gives Congress the sole power to formally declare war (Article I, Section 8), while designating the President as Commander in Chief of the armed forces (Article II). In practice, however, presidents have repeatedly initiated or engaged in military conflicts and short-term operations without a formal congressional declaration of war. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can POTUS change the name of the Department of Defense to the Department of War without congressional approval?
No.
The Department of Defense was established by Congress under the National Security Act of 1947 and a 1949 amendment. Under the U.S. Constitution, only Congress holds the power to create, alter, or legally rename cabinet-level federal departments. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you're thinking of investing in stocks, tomorrow would be a good day to buy Nvidia (NVDA) as the price just plunged on news that the Huang-Huang affair (and possibly another) could see the CEO canned. Once all this passes the stock price will rebound.
www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-500-na… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Problem of Induction:
David Hume Says Science Has a Problem—Does It?
Eric Frey for Skeptic on why science is not a religion:
www.skeptic.com/article/problem-of-induction-david-hume-s… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I have been told for years that because my Tesla is online hacker/terrorists could take it over & steer it into other cars & do the same with thousands of other Teslas.
O-kay, why hasn't it happened? And why aren't planes falling from the sky, entire national electrical grids taken over, etc.?
Could it be that it is easy to imagine doomsday scenarios but much harder to implement them?
In any case, the real problem is people (hackers & terrorists), not technology.
There will always be bad actors & new technologies.
Could AI itself become a bad actor?
I'm skeptical. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
AI as a new religion.
The great computer scientist Jaron Lanier on why we need to drop the doomsday scenarios for AI and treat it as a tool, not a deity.
"If you see A.I. as a tool—not a creature—you can then ask the correct question: Do we really need agents all the time?" -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting new website from @BjornLomborg on the cost of achieving "net zero"
US net zero cost: $12.7 trillion. But it only makes the world 0.142°F (0.0789°C) less warm in 2100.
As Thomas Sowell says: there are no solutions, only trade offs, and "Economics is the study of the use of scarce resources which have alternative uses."
What else could we spent $12.7 trillion on by 2100 besides the climate (and, please, not more for the military).
How about education and infrastructure?
netzerocostbenefit.com -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Let me explain why it is ok for Steve Jobs @elonmusk @JeffBezos @BillGates @finkd et. al. to be so rich:
Biography Bias
No one writes biographies of the thousands of wannabe entrepreneurs who start a company in their garage, then go out of business, barely survive, or just make a living , which is the vast majority.
Instead, everyone only focuses on the <1% who make it big, ignorant of how that happened. Here is how David Cowan, a VC at Bessemer Venture Partners in Menlo Park, California, explained it to me:
"For garage-dwelling entrepreneurs to crack the 1% wealth threshold in America, their path almost always involves raising venture capital and then getting their startup to an initial public offering (IPO) or a large acquisition by another company.
If their garage is situated in Silicon Valley they might get to pitch as many as 15 VCs, but VCs hear 200 pitches for every one we fund, so perhaps 1 in 13 startups get VC, and still they face long odds from there. According to figures that the National Venture Capital Association diligently collects through primary research and publishes on their web site, last year was somewhat typical in that 1,334 startups got funded but only 13% as many achieved an IPO (81 last year) or an acquisition large enough to warrant a public disclosure of the price (95 last year).
So for every wealthy startup founder, there are 100 other entrepreneurs who end up with only a cluttered garage." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Let me get this straight:
6/100,000 with this eye disorder took a GLP-1 vs. 4/100,000 who didn’t.
This is like media stories about X disorder that increased 100%, from 1/100,000 to 2/100,000.
Let's just say I'm skeptical.
The Associated Press
@AP
Popular weight loss drugs, including Ozempic and Wegovy, will carry a new warning about the possibility of a rare side effect that can lead to permanent vision loss, U.S. health regulators announced Monday.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What could it be?
An alien spaceship or...
a jellyfish kite available for $289
www.dailymail.com/sciencetech/article-16278729/ufo-hovers… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I think Chapelle's line about feeling better knowing Charlie Kirk was murdered @ericmetaxas is more race to the bottom of degeneracy, like Scott Galloway's throwaway about taking a dump in his Tesla. They are nothing more than "a smudge of excrement on a tissue surging out to sea along with millions of tons of raw sewage."
Eric Metaxas
@ericmetaxas
If someone killed Dave Chapelle for speaking his mind, I wouldn't feel better. But even if I would, I wouldn't say so. Some ugly thoughts are far better left unsaid. Dave Chapelle has made the world an uglier place by saying what he never should have said. I hope he sees that.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I have not followed Scott Galloway but apparently after @elonmusk criticized him on X he responded:
"I had a Tesla. Great car. He started sh---posting me on Twitter, so I sold it. Not before taking a giant dump in the passenger seat."
This guy is not only an NYU professor, but CA governor @GavinNewsom appointed him to the UC board of regents & he wrote a book "The Algebra of Happiness"?
Is this a race to the bottom?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=tj5OeuTJvUg -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I wrote a book refuting Intelligent Design Creationism in 2006 @GadSaad . It's hard to believe that Behe, and others, who were thoroughly defeated in the Dover trial & exposed as religious evangelists, not scientists, are still going at it. Why not believe God used evolution?
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
OK, let me see if I can carve out the next four weeks to offer you a rebuttal to issues that have been addressed in innumerable ways across countless disciplines for nearly 160 years. Your referencing Genesis is definitely the fatal blow to Darwin. Back to the drawing board!
Bernard
@ClastonB
Gad Saad, your argument is juvenile and sophomoric. Invoking Richard Dawkins and declaring that evolution has more evidence than gravity is not scientific methodology. It is an appeal to authority dressed up as intellectual superiority.
You have not addressed the fundamental questions.
What is the origin of existence itself? What accounts for the laws governing the universe? What is the ultimate source of human consciousness, intelligence, reason, and objective morality?
Then explain the historical chronology. If humanity supposedly existed for hundreds of thousands of years, why are the recognizable institutions of civilization, including organized governments, written laws, cities, complex engineering, and administrative systems, concentrated within the last several thousand years?
Do not merely recite a timeline. Explain the evidence, the methodology, and why the conclusions follow.
Human beings appear in recorded civilization as intelligent, reasoning, morally accountable creatures capable of extraordinary ingenuity. The biblical account declares that God created humanity in His image, male and female, endowed with the capacities necessary to fulfill His purpose.
Adaptation to environmental and climatic conditions does not, by itself, establish that humanity descended from a different ancestral species. Nor does identifying biological mechanisms explain why life, consciousness, rationality, or moral obligation exists in the first place.
You cannot invoke natural laws and then pretend that those laws have explained their own existence. Nor can you establish that the universe is unguided merely by describing processes within it.
Genesis declares that God created. Your theory of unguided origins has not disproved Him.
If you want to debate science, present evidence and defend your reasoning. Stop confusing ridicule, authority, and philosophical naturalism with scientific proof.
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
Utter rubbish shite. Innumerable evolutionists have already refuted this nonsense including @RichardDawkins among many others. There is not a single scientific phenomenon that has received as much evidence across countless disciplines as is the case with evolution. There is more evidence for the veracity of evolution than there is for f**king gravity, and these types of clowns continue to spew their garbage.
Jan Jekielek
@JanJekielek
The evidence for Darwin’s theory of evolution is weaker than you think.
Biochemist Michael Behe just broke down why he’s convinced that intelligent design makes much more sense:
“Intelligent design essentially says that some features of the world are better explained by positing an intelligent mind than random mutation plus selection.”
“A better way to look at it is… whenever we see a number of parts that have been put together in a relationship for a purpose, like, say, a mousetrap, we always conclude that they were arranged through the intervention of a mind.”
“In biology, we see purpose everywhere.”
“Not only at the large level.”
“All the way now down to the molecular level, we see that.”
“Intelligent design says we see parts arranged at the molecular level for a purpose, and therefore, that requires purposeful design.”
“You could falsify intelligent design just by showing that Darwinian processes can do what its proponents claim for it.”
“If Richard Lenski went in his lab and grew his bacteria for 50,000 generations, and some new molecular machine that wasn’t there before was put together… then my intelligent design claims would be blown out of the water.”
“My point is that it’s easy to falsify intelligent design.”
“Just show me a random process that does something fancy.”
“On the other hand, it’s very, very difficult to falsify Darwinian claims.”
“They could always find an excuse.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @uaustinorg
I love your institution and speaking there once, but please also teach your students that the vast majority of historians believe the Shroud of Turin to be a 14th century fake, one of countless "holy relics" circulating throughout.
www.skeptic.com/article/shroud-of-turin-authenticity-exam…
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Is the Shroud of Turin a true image of Jesus Christ?
UATX's student-led Catholic Club brought Father Dalton to campus to lay out the evidence. @OthoniaInc
00:00 — Preview
00:32 — Who is the man of the shroud?
01:04 — Two lenses: the scientist and the pilgrim
02:54 — The shroud in Turin today
04:41 — The burial cloths in John 20
07:37 — "He saw and believed"
09:45 — Faith and reason
10:52 — The birth of shroud science
11:26 — Secondo Pia's 1898 photograph
13:35 — Yves Delage and the double standard
15:07 — Why the shroud is unique
16:26 — Bloodstains vs. body image
17:40 — The VP8 Image Analyzer and 3D information
20:09 — The Shroud of Turin Research Project
22:04 — Painting, scorch, rubbing, or photograph?
23:10 — An image 0.2 microns deep
25:03 — The unclaimed million-dollar prize
25:42 — Real bloodstains
26:27 — How the body was wrapped
28:21 — Crowned and crucified
29:18 — Buried as a king
31:41 — The Pray Codex
34:56 — The silent witness
36:31 — Sweating blood in Gethsemane
37:29 — The kiss of Judas
39:11 — Jesus before Caiaphas
42:15 — The scourging
45:15 — The crown of thorns
47:22 — Carrying the cross
49:13 — Nailed to the cross
53:14 — Speaking from the cross
53:49 — The pierced side
54:59 — Evidence of the resurrection
57:22 — Doubting Thomas
Recorded: October 16, 2026 at UATX.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How to Outsmart an AI:
A Skeptic’s Guide to Resisting AI-Driven Social Engineering
Johannes C. Zeller in Skeptic applying the methods of rationality to combat cognitive biases as they operate interacting with AI:
www.skeptic.com/article/how-to-outsmart-an-ai-a-skeptics-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Simon Winchester (1944–2026): Our Final Interview
We pay tribute to the author of:
The Professor and the Madman
The Men Who United the United States
The Map That Changed the World
Krakatoa
The Breath of the Gods
And many more
Great writing still matters.
www.skeptic.com/article/simon-winchester-1944-2026-our-fi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"The term “cognitive creationism” was coined by Michael Shermer for a related but somewhat narrower set of beliefs: that evolutionary forces have shaped humanity only below the neck, while our minds are blank slates controlled by cultural and social influences."
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Talking with Simon Winchester about what turns out to be his last book about the wind. Toward the end he discusses his strange arrangement with the British military, which I suggested he write about what really happened. Spy? Informant? Patsy? What was it?
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-eastbound-flight… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
So sad to read about the loss of Simon Winchester.
I spoke with him at length about his books "Knowing What We Know" and "The Breath of the Gods."
Such a great writer & true "peripatetic polymath".
And a first class gentleman.
Damn.
Memento mori.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/04/obituaries/simon-winchester-de… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Trump told 60 Minutes' @Douthat60 UFOs are one of the most common queries he gets as POTUS, that he knows of no aliens here, but if it's true Presidents are not informed that at long last he will get to the bottom of the mystery. Do it @realDonaldTrump !
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my answer, from my book titled Truth:
A scientific truth is a claim for which the evidence is so substantial it is rational to offer one’s provisional assent.
I qualify it because I recognize other truths: literary, mythic, metaphorical, and religious, as different.Book Briefs @BookBriefsHQ
WHAT IS TRUTH?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL, if Gemini hallucinated the phrase "hyper-brief technological span" and attributed it to me, do I get to take credit for it even though I just admitted I never called it that? AI is already confusing authorship issues (when does fact-checking morph into actual prose?)
Jon Alexandr @Jon_Alexandr
"Hyper-brief technological span" seems like a useful term, even if it was "hallucinated" by an LLM.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @UAPConvergence
I think ETIs are likely out there somewhere but haven't come here yet. No definitive evidence of either, although the "wow!" signal has never been fully explained away for ETIs out there & I am hoping the disclosure people who insist they're here will show us.
The UAP Convergence
@UAPConvergence
Hold on. I was certain you’ve repeatedly asserted that NHI, whether biological or otherwise, doesn’t exist. So, why would you even suggest that a civilization in a distant solar system might perish before they even reach Earth or any other planetary system? Do you secretly believe NHI does exist?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hyper-Brief Technology Span and the Fermi Paradox
An interviewer recently asked me about my answer to the Fermi Paradox called "hyper-brief technological span," a phrase I have never used. In one of my Scientific American columns I made the argument that the "L" (lifetime of a communicating civilization) in the Drake Equation is likely short, on the order of 400 years (averaging the length of individual civilizations I computed) due to many causes of societal collapse. He sent me this Gemini search, which hallucinated this phrase, even while mostly accurately summarizing my arguments:
“Michael Shermer argues that the Fermi Paradox (the contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial life and the lack of evidence for it) is largely resolved by the "hyper-brief technological span" of intelligent species. He suggests that once a civilization develops radio technology, it only broadcasts for a short period of time (e.g., a few hundred years) before going extinct, destroying itself via technology, or transitioning to non-detectable communications. Therefore, the cosmic window for overlapping, communicative civilizations is statistically near zero.
Shermer proposes that the "hyper-brief technological lifespan" is a bottleneck all intelligent species encounter, fundamentally limiting the survival of extraterrestrial civilizations. He calculates that once civilizations invent radio technology, their aggressive nature and propensity for mutual destruction drastically shorten their window of survival before they collapse. In his columns discussing this concept, Shermer draws upon evolutionary psychology to frame this dilemma:
The Mismatch: Humanity (and potential intelligent alien species) is governed by evolutionary impulses—such as xenophobia, territoriality, and desires for dominance.
The Existential Bottleneck: The period during which a species discovers destructive technology (nuclear weapons, bio-weapons) heavily overlaps with its primitive evolutionary state.
The Collapse: Because our technological power advances exponentially but our moral and neurological evolution remains largely stagnant, civilizations risk obliterating themselves before they mature into space-faring societies.
This premise serves as a powerful explanation for the Fermi Paradox—the glaring contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial intelligence existing and the lack of evidence for it. Shermer suggests that the lifespan of a technological civilization may only be a few centuries, making them too fleeting and separated by vast distances to ever communicate with one another.” -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Could World War II Have Ended Without the Atomic Bomb?
My convo with Historian James Scott, author of Empire of Ashes, about the Pacific theater and why Japan was not going to surrender.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/could-world-war-ii-h… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This time is different
This election was the most important one of our era.
The next election is the most important...
The end of history illusion played out this week & will do so again because of a cognitive bias against the continuous stream of time.
quillette.com/2026/11/06/after-apocalypse/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I recorded a fabulous conversation with @chellivia Chelsea Follett on her new book, which I cannot overstate how important it is to be reminded of just how good life is for us today. A few of the dozens of quotes I highlighted:
"Giving infants alcohol served a double purpose: to provide extra calories and to drug the poor infants into crying less."
"Some historians have argued that the main motivation for married women committing infanticide in the premodern period was the desire to limit family size."
"Females could marry when they reached their twelfth birthday. The age for males was 14....a girl knew that unless she married before she was 21, society would consider her useless, fit only for the nunnery, or, in England, the spinning wheel (a 'spinster')."
"Many households also turned to attempts at magic to defend against thieves and monsters using...amulets, ranging from horse skulls to jugs known as 'witch-bottles'."
"Many of our ancestors did not use latrines of any kind. Urinating in the fireplace, even when lit, was a common practice across social classes...residents dumped their waste each night after 10 o'clock, hurling it out of windows at the sound of a drum, but only after warning passing pedestrians by shouting 'Gardy-loo'."
Baited meat was higher priced that non-baited meat, meaning blood sports like bull and dog fighting "tenderize the meat and, inexplicably, to improve the beef's nutritional quality."
"Public executions were considered a wholesome amusement for all ages, with entire families often gathering for the show."
"In the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, the maximum life expectancy at birth was about 40 years, and it fell significantly during times of plague and famine." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Observation on the Midterms:
I have seen elections swing back & forth since I first started voting in 1972.
Some speak of such swings almost mystically, as if a political force is at work above people & parties themselves.
I think what happens is when people get into power they forget what got them there in the first place and lose focus. Case in point:
Trump 1 won, in part, promising to do something about the open border problem, but never solved it, didn't finish the wall, then obsessed over the "stolen election" nonsense.
Biden won, in part, by promising to restore sanity, but instead implemented insane open border policies, woke progressive DEI CRT programs, etc. & this led voters to put Trump back in.
Trump 2 won, in part, by promising to end all this woke nonsense, implement sound economic policies, and never again go to war in the Middle East, but instead invaded Iran, overstepped domestic programs (like DOGE cutting important science research programs instead of real government waste), and implemented completely irrational tariffs & tariff wars with allies.
Heading to 2028, will the Dems agree with AOC that Woke 1 was "crazy" and course correct to sound economic policies and winning back their working-class base? Will the GOP agree with Vance to end the war, get prices back down, eliminate the idiotic tariffs & economic nationalism policies that are anti-capitalistic & contra free-trade?
Unfortunately, after 54 years of voting, I doubt it, and so that pendulum will just keep swinging back and forth. Maybe John Stuart Mill was right:
“A party of order or stability, and a party of progress or reform, are both necessary elements of a healthy state of political life.” -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can We Know What the Past Really Felt Like?
Mikko Ketovuori in Skeptic on how to think about what it might have been like to live in a historical period (and not just what people decades, centuries, or millennia after think about it).
www.skeptic.com/article/can-we-know-what-the-past-really-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night." —JD Vance
You knew that months ago & did nothing to end it
You knew that would happen when you started it
You knew that when Trump campaigned on "no more wars in the Middle East"
Self-inflicted defeat.
JD Vance
@JDVance
One of the things the data analysts on our side obsessed over was "composition"—whether the electorate looked close enough to 2024 for Republicans to win. And despite polls that showed a Democrat blowout, the data kept on telling us the same story: in some states turnout was merely OK, in other states it was downright amazing, and in no state was it catastrophic. There was a genuine sense of optimism on our team: our people were showing up.
So, I asked the smartest data guy I know, does that mean we're going to shock the world? "No," he told me. "We might do better than the polls suggest. But the data is telling us that a lot of Trump/Vance 2024 voters are pissed and planning to vote for the other guys. Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us."
Well, that looks prophetic now. Our voters did show up. In Florida, for example, the electorate was 9 points more Republican than Democrat, just a couple points worse than 2024. Undoubtedly there were places we could have done better on turnout. But the main problem is not turnout. The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.
There will be a lot of infighting and arguing over what happened and why that is. One of the pollsters I really respect told me that our economic messaging wasn’t sharp enough down the stretch. I’m sure that’s true.
But the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone.
Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were:
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to Israel
Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. This is according to a pollster who nailed the results. While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. (She’s also a great person.)
In the next few months, there's going to be a lot of gaslighting. Expect to hear any number of establishment politicians say the solution to our woes is amnesty. I'm open to the idea that we should change enforcement—by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labor, for instance. But anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you.
The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night.
If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest.
But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.
I remain hopeful about our country. To the people who are pissed off and want to say, “I told you so”: you’re right, you did tell us so. Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview. To the people who are just pissed at the results, you should be. Let’s take that anger and get back to the work of saving our country. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI during the middle of the Midterm elections yesterday the White House issued "The American Declaration of Freedom in Space."
Given the results I suspect the GOP is going to circle the wagons while the Dems focus on more Earthly concerns. We shall see.
www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/11/the-ameri… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards." —Søren Kierkegaard
This captures how I think about...
Determinism can only be understood backwards.
Free will is living life forwards.
The past already happened but entropy means there's an arrow of time, the future is not predetermined, and we play a role in the causal net of the world. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In the Great Silence
Trailer for forthcoming Fermi paradox film that asks "where is everyone?"
ETIs are likely out there; the Copernican Principle that we're not special means we're not 1st; they should have explored the galaxy already & been here; no confirmation of their existence yet, so...?
@ParvamundiPics
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YpxKESgEnj4 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The epistemological problem behind the "supernatural" is illustrated by what I call (in Truth) Sagan's Dragon:
Imagine that I tell you that I have a dragon in my garage. Would you like to see it?
Sure you would! Who wouldn’t? Dragons are popular in works of fiction, so wouldn’t it be exciting if it turned out that dragons are real?
But you need evidence to believe, so you ask to see this dragon.
I eagerly oblige by taking you to my garage and opening the door. You look inside and see some boxes, paint cans, a ladder, a bicycle and other knickknacks, but no dragon. You ask, “where’s the dragon?”
I reply, “oh, this is an invisible dragon.”
An “invisible dragon?” you respond skeptically.
Perhaps there’s a way to get around the dragon’s invisibility, you suggest, by sprinkling flour on the floor of the garage so that when the invisible dragon walks around, its footprints will become apparent. This would provide empirical evidence in support of a potentially objective truth about the existence of dragons.
“That won’t work,” I explain, “because this invisible dragon hovers a foot above the ground.”
“An invisible hovering dragon?” you raise your eyebrows in doubt. You then suggest that we get one of those portable thermometers everyone has been using during the pandemic and measure the temperature at different places in the garage to detect the dragon’s body heat.
“Sorry,” I reply, “but this is a cold-blooded dragon. It doesn’t give off any heat.”
“Let me get this straight,” you groan in exasperation. “This dragon of yours is invisible, can levitate, and gives off no heat whatsoever. What about the fire it breathes? Surely our thermometer can detect the hot fire from a fire-breathing dragon?”
“Actually,” I dissemble, “this dragon breathes cold-fire, a little-known phenomenon vouchsafed only to this particular species of dragon.”
By now, you are growing frustrated and ask me in a challenging voice: “What’s the difference between an invisible levitating cold-blooded cold-fire-breathing un-detectable dragon…and no dragon at all?!”
The answer is none. There is no difference between an invisible levitating cold-blooded cold-fire-breathing un-detectable dragon…and no dragon at all.
And these religious-like convictions don't help:
"I feel the presence of the dragon"
"I feel the love of the dragon"
"Through the dragon all things are possible"
"After I started believing in the dragon my life changed" -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What, then, does "supernatural" mean? @UAPConvergence
As defined it means something is outside of nature.
O-kay, but since we operate inside of nature, along with all of our instruments and tools of measurement, then how would you know you've encountered the supernatural instead of just a mystery as yet unexplained by natural law and science?
I.e., you could be right and there is a supernatural realm, but my point is this: how would you know?
The UAP Convergence
@UAPConvergence
Michael, the problem is that you’ve defined the supernatural out of existence before examining the evidence.
You’re not simply arguing that science should seek natural explanations. I agree that it should. You’re asserting that everything that exists must necessarily be natural, regardless of what we discover.
That’s metaphysical naturalism, not an empirical finding.
If something currently considered paranormal is demonstrated to operate through previously unknown physical laws, then certainly our scientific understanding expands. But that doesn’t establish that every possible intelligence, consciousness, or dimension of reality must be reducible to physical processes.
You’ve established a framework in which no conceivable discovery could ever challenge naturalism, because whatever is discovered is automatically reclassified as natural.
But if naturalism is true by definition, rather than open to falsification, how is that fundamentally different from the unfalsifiable metaphysical positions you regularly criticize?
The question isn’t whether we should investigate natural explanations. We absolutely should. The question is whether we’re willing to follow the evidence wherever it leads, even when it challenges our philosophical commitments.
And furthermore, I doubt you even read the comments that people post under your comments. Prove me wrong. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @summaveritas my admission that disclosure of ETI presence on earth would be immediate with credible evidence in the form of confirmation by NASA, AAAS, and the NSF.
But I would have not been "wrong the entire time on UAPs" because I simply state they could be ETIs but we need tangible evidence in the form of alien bodies and/or craft.
Grainy videos, blurry photographs, and anecdotes are important and interesting to launch an investigation, but by themselves they are not confirmatory.
Ergo, skepticism that UAPs = ETIs is simply the null hypothesis in science: your hypothesis is not true until you prove otherwise.
Summa Veritas 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@SummaVeritas
It'll be interesting to see how long into disclosure you wait to admit that you've been wrong the entire time on UAPs... I bet it will be comically late.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sean Kirkpatrick, 30 years in DoD & former director of the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office "said strange sightings detailed in recently declassified government records should be viewed through an evidence-based lens rather than as proof of something extraterrestrial."
+
"None of the data that we saw and reviewed and analyzed matches an alien hypothesis theory"
www.foxnews.com/us/former-pentagon-ufo-chief-disputes-fbi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Thank you @amyalkon and all the kind others who commented and shared your own grief over this particularly unique loss. It is indescribably sad at our home without Hitchy to be there every day. So empty without him. I’ve had dogs my entire life but it doesn’t get any easier to lose them. Why?
Amy Alkon
@amyalkon
I forgot the important part about why to do this and it has to have solace through the good and the joy.
You know the work of Liz Loftus and how memory is not a snapshot or a video. It becomes a story we create. And as we tell it over and over again what we tell and embellish a little— not because we are liars but because this is how we tell stories over and over— the joy and goodness starts to become the story.
The pain will not go away, but there will be perspective from the land of joy. Righteous perspective.
Care deeply about you. And I hope this helps. As do I hope that about this beautiful outpouring below of these wonderful people who care about you, including me. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Response to comments: If there are aliens/ETIs out there or here, they will fall entirely within the worldview of naturalism. In fact, I go so far as to say that there is no such thing as the supernatural or the paranormal.
There is just the natural, the normal and unexplained mysteries and anomalies. If explained, even by some new physics or law of nature, that would just incorporate them into natural law.
Example: if the theory of Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff that consciousness originates from quantum states in neural microtubules is correct, and that "spooky action at a distance" allows people to read each others' minds, etc., that would not be a confirmation of paranormal ESP; it would just become part of quantum physics and neuroscience.
Ditto Rupert Sheldrake's theory of morphic resonance to account for dogs that know when their owners are coming home, the sense of being stared at, solving the NYT's Sunday crossword puzzle is easier later in the day (collective memory), minds separate from brains, etc.
I am skeptical of both theories, but the point is that if they turned out to be true then a lot of what we think is spooky supernatural or paranormal phenomena would just become part of natural science.
Does that make sense?
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @planethunter56 I do not speak for the UAP Science Advisory Council & my X posts are my opinions only. As for the suggestion that the UFO/UAP movement is like a religion, that's a very old idea. Carl Sagan suggests this in a 1966 interview with Walter Cronkite, as does Carl Jung in his 1958 book on UFOs as a modern myth in the making, replacing fading religious faith. Of course, unlike God (or gods), we could discover extraterrestrials because there's nothing supernatural needed for their existence, so unlike religion, the existence of ETIs could be settled...if only someone would disclose what is supposedly being hidden from us.
UAP Juan
@planethunter56
Greg writes: "Demand stronger evidence for his [Jay Stratton's] claims, certainly. Declaring the entire UAP field a religion is a sweeping claim of your own [Michael Shermer]. Your evidentiary standards become remarkably forgiving when the conclusion happens to be yours."
So the subsequent question is fair: does Shermer speak for the @UAPSAC and subsequently, for @ProfAviLoeb?
Stay tuned...This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"In a 2025 survey, 35% of undergraduate women reported experiencing 'nonconsensual sexual contact' since entering Cornell."
Either Cornell is one of the most dangerous places on the planet for women or else there is something wrong with this survey...
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/28/nyregion/cornell-faculty-no-co… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How Much Credit Do You Deserve for Your Life?
Philosopher Duncan Pritchard joins me to discuss his book, Tempting Fate: A Philosophical Guide to Risk, Luck, and a Meaningful Life, and how to make decisions when a good outcome is uncetain.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/how-much-credit-do-y… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Over the years I have been posting "daily awe" photos here, and these have included countless images of my chocolate lab Hitch (yes, named after the late great Christopher Hitchens).
I am heartbroken to share the sad news I had to let Hitchy go after 12.5 years because he was suffering so much that he couldn't even walk any more. For weeks I hoisted him into the back of my car and drove around the mountains with the lid open so he could feel like he got his daily walk and to experience the normal smells of nature. I guess I selfishly kept him going longer than I should have because losing him would be so painful for me and my family (you should see my vet bills). But now that he's gone I keep thinking I should have kept him going, but that would be unfair, but it's so painful...
A curious thing is happening: I have lost all 4 of my parents (bio and step) and one of my brothers, all of which was tragic and painful, but there's something emotionally worse about losing a close pet. I wonder if it is that I spent hours with Hitchy every day, from our daily Hitch Hike to evenings on the couch with him watching the news (he seems to know when it was time as he would bark at me, but I don't think he was eager to tune in to the NBC Nightly News).
I guess it must be how much daily time is spent with a loved one—the more time, the more pain—with the constant daily reminders that they're not there any more (what will I do in the morning without the daily Hitch Hike? Did I hear him bark? Watching the news by myself?).
My 10-year old son keeps asking "why?" He understands the suffering why, but his question is a fair one: why do our beloved pets live such shorter lives than we do? It's just not right. But that's the way it is.
Memento mori. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What Exactly Is a Homeland?
Egyptian journalist and architect Wena Rostom in Skeptic on what it was like growing up in the tiny village, Al-Arin Al-Qibli, in Minya, Egypt, and the larger implications for what it means to have a homeland.
www.skeptic.com/article/what-exactly-is-a-homeland/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is Sagan on the religious nature of the UFOs:
"if you examine these myths, you find that there's some peculiar regularities. The inhabitants of saucers are benevolent. I mean, they're really concerned for our well-being. They're omnipotent, extremely powerful,
omniscient, extremely knowledgeable, and they often wear long white robes. Now, this combination is something I've heard in another context. This isn't science. This is religion."
youtu.be/rbfOqgQVKmI?t=220 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @planethunter56 I do not speak for the UAP Science Advisory Council & my X posts are my opinions only. As for the suggestion that the UFO/UAP movement is like a religion, that's a very old idea. Carl Sagan suggests this in a 1966 interview with Walter Cronkite, as does Carl Jung in his 1958 book on UFOs as a modern myth in the making, replacing fading religious faith. Of course, unlike God (or gods), we could discover extraterrestrials because there's nothing supernatural needed for their existence, so unlike religion, the existence of ETIs could be settled...if only someone would disclose what is supposedly being hidden from us.
UAP Juan
@planethunter56
Greg writes: "Demand stronger evidence for his [Jay Stratton's] claims, certainly. Declaring the entire UAP field a religion is a sweeping claim of your own [Michael Shermer]. Your evidentiary standards become remarkably forgiving when the conclusion happens to be yours."
So the subsequent question is fair: does Shermer speak for the @UAPSAC and subsequently, for @ProfAviLoeb?
Stay tuned...This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is AI Conscious, and Can It Feel Pain?
Erez Batat for Skeptic answers:
"Ask the machine whether it hurts, and you’ll hear its makers."
www.skeptic.com/article/is-artificial-intelligence-consci… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Jay Stratton also claims that former Lockheed Martin executive Jim Ryder told him that the aerospace company has a dozen alien craft that they are working on to to reverse-engineer.
If true, where did L-M get the craft? And if the U.S. government also knows about it (which Stratton says they do), then is it fair to all the other aerospace/tech companies to not share such advanced tech with them?
It seems to me that, if true, the U.S. government is playing favorites by letting the companies with the NHI tech gain an unfair advantage. And, of course, if other countries are doing the same (Stratton describes an "arms race" between countries for alien tech), then is it really possible that Trump, who is all about U.S. supremacy, is unaware of this particular arms race, even while he is actively promoting AI to be developed in the U.S. before the Chinese beat us to it?
There's something deeply off here if any of this is true.
www.paradigm.news/p/ex-pentagon-ufo-chief-i-worked-with -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you’ve ever wanted to explore the cradle of Western civilization with fellow skeptics, next April 12th-22nd, 2027, the Skeptics Society is hosting an exclusive ten-day journey through Greece and Turkey aboard the intimate, 57-suite ship Blue Zephyr.
And I am thrilled to share that our distinguished guest lecturer for the voyage will be the legendary Pulitzer Prize-winning author and UCLA professor, Jared Diamond! He’ll be leading special talks and discussions to give us deep insights into the history and human societies we encounter.
Space is strictly limited to 114 guests to keep it like a private yacht experience, and 9% of your cruise fee is a tax-deductible donation to The Skeptics Society. For complete details and to reserve your suite:
skeptic.com/Greece2027 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I finished @jaystratton new book. He's blocked me so he won't respond to my comments. In his last chapter I find out why:
According to Jay Stratton, we now know with certainty that extraterrestrials are here on Earth, we have them and their ships, and that he and a few other whistleblowers are brave truth tellers disclosing for the first time in history that we are not alone.
You would think announcing the greatest discovery in history would be something you would want to share with scientists, politicians like POTUS, and people interested in UAPs but still unconvinced. But no.
Months ago I invited him on my show, but Stratton's publicist told him he's only doing major media. Sure enough. He made his announcement on Fox, CNN, CBS, etc. When asked for the evidence that aliens are here, he said you have to read his book.
O-kay, I did. There is nothing in the form of what scientists consider to be good evidence. Lots and lots of the usual anecdotes and stories we've been hearing for years, but he says that the real evidence—actual alien bodies and craft—are hidden by people in the "legacy program"—an alleged covert U.S. government operation to recover, conceal, and reverse-engineer alien craft and/or accompanying "biologics" (alien pilots).
Who are these deep-state covert operatives hiding this evidence? Does Stratton name names? Nope. Worse, these agents of disinformation are actively working to cover up the truth by planting stories for us interested but as yet unconvinced people to unknowingly pick up on and disperse, thereby maintaining the need for more books and films on disclosure.
He does not name me personally, but he says that "skeptics" who doubt his word, or curious scientists who ask to see the ETIs in person, are hostile people to be avoided and denounced as deniers, thereby maintaining the need for even MORE books and films on disclosure.
This is not a good sign that there's really something extraterrestrial here. As I have hypothesized for years, the entire UFO/UAP enterprise is a type of religion—deities for atheists, skygods for skeptics—to be believed but not proven. It’s a perfect closed-loop argument for which Stratton and the other believers would have nothing to gain by talking to people interested in seeing the evidence.
Not. Good. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Of course.
@jaystratton UAP book will be made into a TV series by Terence Winter (Boardwalk Empire) partnered with Dan Farah, director of The Age of Disclosure.
There's nothing wrong with selling books and making films on a topic, but the fact is we have NOT discovered aliens yet, so the proper scientific sequence is to FIRST disclose the actual alien ships and bodies to everyone, THEN sell your books and films.
That no one (so far) is willing to disclose exactly where the evidence is leaves us exactly where we've been for decades: intrigued and curious, but needing more.
Will this TV series go to the location of the alien ships and bodies and show them? Prediction: No
deadline.com/2026/09/terence-winter-jay-stratton-out-of-t… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Over 400 people have registered for our Defend the West conference!
WHEN: 1/13/2027
WHERE: Online (free)
Speakers include:
@DavidDFriedman
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@jasoncrawford
Nadine Strossen
Save your spot (link below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Asymmetry of Truth:
What Really Happened on Epstein Island?
Mislav Gleich for Skeptic
"Unless there is direct evidence to prove any one particular scenario, the wisest thing one can do is reject the dramatic, accept the mundane, and remain agnostic."
www.skeptic.com/article/asymmetry-of-truth-what-really-ha… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I concur @Evolutionistrue
"No, evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains, for those who haven’t read it, a page-turner."
whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/10/27/nathaniel-comforts-wonk… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Psychology that Gave Birth to Religion
Good film short featuring Dan Dennett & myself exploring different purposes or exaptations shared by faiths. Of course, each faith may claim to be the one true religion, but such contradictions are not the point
youtu.be/MHlnLPo9Ebc -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is the new documentary about the fraudulent con artist Elizabeth Holmes itself a fraudulent con? If so, it appears to be working as masses of people are paying to see what may be a meta-scam.
reason.com/2026/10/26/nathan-fielder-made-a-dishonest-movie/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ditto what @geraldposner says to Dan Rather...
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
I used to admire Dan Rather. He was a big fan of Case Closed and we did some great CBS specials around it.
That makes this harder to watch. He’s attacking @bariweiss for practicing journalism while admitting he didn’t know her before she got to CBS and still doesn’t. He’s just repeating what holdovers at his old network told him.
Dan, she isn’t wrecking CBS or turning it into ‘Fox lite.’ Bari isn’t right or left, the Free Press she founded publishes stories that incense progressives and infuriate MAGA fans. Old fashioned calling balls and strikes. She is the only real hope CBS has of becoming the Tiffany Network again—a title it lost long before she arrived. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A Skeptic’s Guide to Environmental Alarmism
Marc Defant in Skeptic "leaves room for skepticism toward apocalyptic rhetoric without requiring denial of measured warming or human influence."
www.skeptic.com/article/skeptics-guide-to-environmental-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Headline:
"British Airways jet 'nearly crashes' into mystery 'UFO' after leaving Heathrow Airport"
Text:
"The pilot of the B777 reported that a drone had just flown over their right wing. They said it was moving very fast, was probably of silver colour, metallic and reflective." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reading this book by a “sympathetic sceptic” has some insight for us interested in UFOs/UAPs:
After 90 years of sightings, photographs, videos, and experts opining on the existence of the Loch Ness creature, Shine concludes it exists only in our minds, a product of flawed perception, psychology, and the unique geography, geology and physics of the loch. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Abolish the Family: A Manifesto for Care & Liberation”
Yet another once great organization, the American Psychological Association, goes woke, replacing the search for truth with political activism (of only the Left-Wing progressive sort). @SwipeWright @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Even Democrats now acknowledge reality: “transgender girls” are “boys” & that’s why they should not compete in girls sports. Remember how long and hard women fought for equal rights, including their own sports divisions and leagues? That applies to girls. apnews.com/article/transgender-sports-ballot-question-was…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The problem with land acknowledgments beyond their virtue signaling without ever having to do anything (like give the land back), as explained by Jerry Coyne @Evolutionistrue
e.g., Indians stole land from other Indian tribes so who actually owned the land a 1,000 or 10,000 years ago?
whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/10/23/john-mcwhorter-goes-all… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Guru Who Fooled Millions
Journalist and writer Ru Marshall spent twenty years investigating a New Age fabulist and liar for his new book American Trickster: The Hidden Lives of Carlos Castaneda
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/carlos-castaneda-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Even our earlier Aerospace Global News report examining the aircraft acknowledged that the TR-3B’s existence remains speculative. The extraordinary performance and propulsion claims attached to it have never been officially substantiated.
History nevertheless explains why such stories endure. Genuine US aircraft have flown in secrecy for years before Washington admitted they existed. The F-117 Nighthawk, for example, became operational in 1983 but was not publicly acknowledged until 1988."
aerospaceglobalnews.com/news/secret-spy-planes -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my account of what happened to Scientific American before the latest meltdown, when the wokeness first began to rot this once great institution.
michaelshermer.substack.com/p/scientific-american-goes-wo… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Fall of Scientific American
Emmet Fraizer picks up the story where I left off a few years ago, as this once great national institution of publishing went full woke, and as always happens, wokness poisons everything.
www.thenation.com/article/society/scientific-american-spr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The deeper problem beyond the fact that Elizabeth Holmes is a pathological liar is that her victims succumbed to "Truth Default" theory:
Given limited time/access to fact check what people claim, most of us default to believing what we're told is true (e.g., someone tells me they are a Vietnam vet I have neither the time nor resources to check). Most of the time most people are relatively truthful, so Truth Default works as a cognitive heuristic (and liars can get away with lying some of the time).
HOWEVER: that doesn't apply to investors, who have a fiduciary responsibility ("due diligence") to fact check claimants before investing. That was not always done in the case of Holmes, in part because they were charmed by her youthful looks, sultry voice, Steve Jobs-wannabe turtlenecks, and her bold promises that Theranos would be The Next Big Thing that investors did not want to miss out on.
So while justice is rightly being served against Holmes, the victims of such scams carry some responsibility for letting themselves be fooled. No one held a gun to their head and made them invest. They chose to do so, and because our life outcomes are, in part, self-determined, victims must take some responsibility.
No, this is not "blaming the victim." Holmes committed a crime and is getting her just deserts. But neither are her victimized investors naifs.
Agreed, in a perfect utopian world no one would lie (or steal, rape, murder, etc.) But that is not the world in which we live. Yes, you should be free to walk around any part of any city anywhere in the world at any time of the night and not get mugged or robbed. But you're an idiot if you do that without taking precautions.
Reality matters. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"It’s also not particularly 'woke' to recognize that the awe-inspiring achievements of ancient Greece and Rome coexisted with inhumanity toward the conquered and enslaved, often extreme misogyny, and an outlook that normalized the subjugation of the weak by the strong."
Indeed @CathyYoung63 that is actual history & not political propaganda!
open.substack.com/pub/theunpopulist/p/rubios-grotesque-de… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Two words @johntamny :
Bernie Madoff
He carried out his fraud to top investors for decades without getting caught, even when investigated by the SEC and the FBI.
But for the financial crises he would have kept the Ponzi scheme going even longer.
Holmes is a fraud and liar.
John Tamny
@johntamny
The Elizabeth Holmes "fraud" narrative was long contradicted by what was true: Holmes's backers included the most prominent names in investing, business, economics, and politics. Fraudsters of course sell when people are duped, but when the world's greatest investors were lined up trying to buy Holmes's Theranos shares, she refused. From there, one would have to believe that some of the world's savviest investors didn't discover Holmes's alleged fraud, rather it was an unknown reporter who somehow scooped the world's best investors. Not very likely. The contradictions are many, and they gloss over the fact that as a female Stanford dropout, Holmes was constantly in the spotlight in the way that a male Stanford dropout would not have been. There are many of them, not many of Holmes's type. That is not a feminist comment, but it is a comment that for being a magnet for media, Holmes missed the crucial chance to develop her product anonymously, and on a better timeline. Said another way, had she not been so successful in pursuit of the impossible while raising money to back her vision over 15 years, she would not be in prison today. Holmes isn't a fraud nor did she fail, she was merely the only startup founder to build her company in a fishbowl. The latter arguably has her wrongly imprisoned today. www.realclearmarkets.com/articles/2026/10/22/elizabeth_ho…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What's it like to be an AI?
How would I know?
I don't even know what it's like to be a bat, or you, or anyone else (the problem of other minds redux).
If I were able to shape-shift from human to bat, I would not retain my humanness while inside the body and brain of a bat. I would just be a bat, full stop.
Put another way, asking what it’s like to be one thing precludes one from knowing what it’s like to be a different thing. It’s conceptually contradictory. Understanding how the brain machinery works is different from experiencing the brain machinery itself.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-03313-7 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting new site:
Slugfester
Lists peoples' debates, AI summaries, evals, fallacies, biases, winners and losers, ratings, etc.
Looks like I won 7 of 8 debates here, so this must be fairly accurate; would be more so if it were 8/8. LOL
slugfester.com/interlocutor/michael-shermer/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
When AI Builds Skill, and When It Erodes It
The plusses and minuses of AI by Gleb Tsipursky for Skeptic (like nearly everything that matters, AI will lead neither to utopia or extinction):
www.skeptic.com/article/when-artificial-intelligence-buil… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why consciousness needs a body with emotions built from the bottom up by natural selection (not top-down design like computers that lack emotions) neuroscientist Antonio Damasio @damasiousc tells me in our convo based on his new book:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-consciousness-ne… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Despite decades of investigating people with extraordinary claims, it never ceases to amaze me when I come across yet another liar, charlatan, fabulist, fantasist, pretender, fraudster, falsifier, dissembler, hustler, or counterfeiter. They're far more common than we think.
Jay
@jaybronious
This is so insane lol #elizabethholmes
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Neuroscientists Giulio Tononi, Christof Koch, et al. make a strong case for real free will (not an illusion) if Integrated Information Theory (IIT) is the correct explanation of consciousness:
"If IIT is right, we do have free will in a genuine sense: we have alternatives, reasons, and values, we make decisions, and we—not our neurons or atoms—are the cause of our willed actions and bear responsibility for them."
arxiv.org/abs/2206.02069 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sign up now! You can watch the conference from your laptop and learn how to and why we should defend the west...
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
🛡️Defend the West Conference🛡️
WHEN: 1/13/2027
WHERE: Online
Over 300 people have registered so far.
Speakers include:
@DavidM_Friedman
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@jasoncrawford
Nadine Strossen
Save your spot (link below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
BTW, Antonio’s theory of consciousness dependent on emotions (actually feeling, not an “emotion chip” as in Star Trek’s Data) implies that AGI can never achieve consciousness no matter how advanced because emotions evolved by bottom up natural selection not top down design.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why consciousness needs a body (with emotions). The great neuroscientist Antonio Damasio outlines his theory to explain the hard problem of consciousness.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-consciousness-ne… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why consciousness needs a body (with emotions). The great neuroscientist Antonio Damasio outlines his theory to explain the hard problem of consciousness.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-consciousness-ne… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Will the Truth of Science Lead Us to Justice Among the Stars?
Good commentary (and review of Truth) by Walter Bloom
historyhighjackers.com/f/will-the-truth-of-science-lead-u… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the rest of my SciAm column on Alvy's Error, "assessing the purpose of something at the wrong level of analysis," which theologians like William Lane Craig make when insisting that without God anything goes:
Craig committed a related mistake when he argued that, “Without God there are no objective moral values, moral duties, or moral accountability.” And: “If life ends at the grave then ultimately it makes no difference whether you live as a Stalin or a Mother Teresa.”
Call this Craig’s Categorical Error: assessing the value of something by the wrong category of criteria. We live in the hear-and-now, not the hearafter, so our actions must be judged according to the criteria of this category, whether or not the category of a God-granted hereafter exists.
Whether you behave like a Russian dictator who murdered tens of millions of people, or a Roman Catholic missionary who tended to the poor, matters very much to the victims of totalitarianism and poverty.
Why does it matter? Because we are sentient beings designed by evolution to survive and flourish in the teeth of entropy and death. The Second Law of Thermodynamics (entropy) is the First Law of Life. If you do nothing, entropy will take its course and you will move toward a higher state of disorder that ends in death.
So our most basic purpose in life is to combat entropy by doing something extropic—expending energy to survive and flourish. Being kind and helping others was one successful strategy, and punishing Paleolithic Stalins was another, and from this we evolved morality. In this sense, evolution bestowed upon us a moral and purpose-driven life by dint of the laws of nature. We do not need any source higher than that to find meaning or morality.
In the long run entropy will spell the end of everything in the universe and the universe itself, but we don’t live in the long run. We live now. We live in Brooklyn, so doing our homework matters. And so too does doing our duty to ourselves, our loved ones, our community, our species, and our planet. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Gotta love Community Notes:
"This unverified second-hand anecdote from a Dec 2025 podcast offers no names, dates, documents or corroboration. Pentagon UAP reviews found no evidence of extraterrestrial beings or technology."
Of course, UAP proponents argue that knowledge of aliens goes above the Pentagon (and POTUS) so such stories will continue to circulate.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Uh, what?
'I would have chalked it up to the wine if it wasn't for being choke slammed up against a f****** wall in the morning at 6am,' Betts revealed.
Daily Mail US
@Daily_MailUS
A former US Army sniper has claimed that a secret military operation took place near Area 51 and at least one American soldier was killed in a battle with reptilian aliens www.dailymail.com/sciencetech/article-16212787/army-snipe… 🔗
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes. I didn't know X now automatically translates posts in a foreign language. I guess you're right, it thinks we're all illiterate. The original (which it will probably translate again) in French:
Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose
AlekHidell
@NotBehindU
Did it automatically translate plus ca change? Does it think everyone is illiterate?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Perfectly said @sapinker
I made a similar point in one of my SciAm columns, "Alvy's Error": Woody Allen's character in Annie Hall, Alvy Singer, in a flashback to childhood refuses to do his homework because he found out the universe is expanding. His exasperated mother upbraids the youth, “What has the universe got to do with it?! You’re here in Brooklyn. Brooklyn is not expanding!”
Call it Alvy’s Error: assessing the purpose of something at the wrong level of analysis. The level at which we should assess our actions is the human time scale of days, weeks, months, and years—our four-score ± 10 lifespan—not the billions of years of the cosmic calendar.
William Lane Craig made this error in arguing that if this worldview is correct then godless Nazi murderers got away with torturing Jews. Shelly Kagan nailed him in their debate:
“This strikes me as an outrageous thing to suggest. It doesn’t really matter? Surely it matters to the torture victims whether they’re being tortured. It doesn’t require that this make some cosmic difference to the eternal significance of the universe for it to matter whether a human being is tortured. It matters to them, it matters to their family, and it matters to us.”
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The fact that the universe doesn’t care about you doesn’t mean that other humans don’t care about you, or that we don’t have to care about other humans. That is, there is a purpose, there is a meaning: that is, to make people as well off as possible, to increase flourishing, to increase knowledge and life and health and freedom and safety. These are really, really meaningful. At least, I think they are. I don’t see anything wrong with them. I don’t think that that should leave you empty. And the fact that we live in a cold universe—that is, the laws of physics, the laws of biology, the behavior of viruses and bacteria and parasites and fungi—they don’t care about you. I’m sorry, they don’t care about you. And the sooner you realize that, the more you’ll be able to attend to the things that really do matter.
@HumanProgress -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Phishing scam alert!
Like a lot of people here on X, I have recently started getting paid. And, sure enough, the scammers are jumping in trying to get one's ID info. Don't fall for it (I didn't). -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"five different airline pilots per day are reporting UAP activities" says Jay Stratton.
Given that hundreds of passengers per plane x5/day have cell phones one would predict thousands of clear focused videos of these UAPs. There aren't. Something is deeply off here.
Gunther Eagleman™
@GuntherEagleman
🚨 WOW: A former Pentagon intelligence official says airline pilots are reporting UAPs every single day, and that nobody is tracking them.
Jay Stratton told Jesse Watters that "five different airline pilots per day are reporting UAP activities." He says there's "ongoing activity over U.S. nuclear missile sites and sensitive military sites."
He also says the government used a submarine to try to lure one in, and that "the UAP showed up and we were able to collect some data."
Whatever these things are, they're flying over our nukes and in our airspace. That's a national security problem. Release the files.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Uh, what?
'I would have chalked it up to the wine if it wasn't for being choke slammed up against a f****** wall in the morning at 6am,' Betts revealed.
Daily Mail US
@Daily_MailUS
A former US Army sniper has claimed that a secret military operation took place near Area 51 and at least one American soldier was killed in a battle with reptilian aliens www.dailymail.com/sciencetech/article-16212787/army-snipe… 🔗
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"The truth is coming out whether the gate keepers like it or not." @jaystratton
What gate keepers? Who? Name names. Where, exactly, are the alien bodies & spacecraft? If Trump doesn't know, who does? Who can, say, someone at ODNI talk to in order to see the actual evidence?
wow
@wow36932525
#ufo #uap #usos #nhi
Credit. @FoxNews @JesseBWatters @jaystratton
NEW.
JAY STRATTON on Fox News.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In More Than 8% of the Sensor Videos Declassified by PURSUE, the UAP Might be Birds
More good science from the UAP Science Advisory Council...
avi-loeb.medium.com/in-more-than-8-of-the-sensor-videos-d… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Astonishing. Another prominent journalist who, when told that humanity's biggest question—are we alone?—has been answered in the affirmative, does not follow up with: "what are the aliens like, where are they from, where are they located now, who exactly in the government knows?"
wow
@wow36932525
#ufo #uap #usos #nhi
Credit. CNN @jaketapper @jaystratton
BREAKING
NEW interview.
JAY STRATTON on The lead
Ex-intel official spills about 'UAP' investigations
in new book.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Astral🛸
@The_Astral_
“Enough with storytelling. Enough with verbal testimonies…It’s time for us to look at the evidence.”
Avi Loeb wants to see the evidence behind Jay Stratton’s claims and says Stratton should bring the information directly to Trump and the White House. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
www.seti.org
The SEARCH for ETI is a legitimate science @MiddleOfMayhem
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
How exactly can space aliens be a "legitimate science" beyond hypotheticals?
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Live with @ProfAviLoeb and @michaelshermer the Disclosure Industrial Complex
www.youtube.com/live/sj7LRq-Uq3k?is=0MvPanXn8q3QWmgc -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From Jay Stratton's new UFO book.
Apply Hume's Maxim on miracles: What's more likely? Laws of nature were suspended or someone misperceived an event?
What's more likely? Aliens traversed the vast distances of interstellar space to arrive on Earth & instead of meeting with NASA or POTUS they go to Stratton's house & jigger with the thermostat? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Case Against the Resurrection
Philosopher Bradley Bowen analyzes 3 prominent defenders of the faith & finds them wanting:
Reasonable Faith by William Lane Craig
Handbook of Christian Apologetics by Peter Kreeft & Ronald Tacelli
The Case for the Resurrection of Jesus by Gary Habermas & Michael Licona
www.skeptic.com/article/case-against-jesus-resurrection/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Finally!
There is one catch. You gotta pick the right religion…
“And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away.”
—Revelation 21:4 KJV -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe from Refugio Cyn north of Santa Barbara. E.O. Wilson’s biophilia at work: there is something awe-inspiring about observing large bodies of water from above plus lots of green, sun, wind, and waves…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Watch Eli Steele’s new documentary film White Guilt, about the work of his legendary father Shelby Steele:
manofsteele.substack.com/p/more-oppressed-by-white-goodwi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Review of Jay Stratton's UAP book includes his slide from the possibility of ETIs (which can be a legitimate science) to the reality of the paranormal & supernatural:
"But this is embedded in a series of tales he tells about missing objects, backyard interdimensional portals, and sensing presences that are the kind of poltergeist stories familiar from centuries of psychical research, and he presents them in such a way that, if you don’t believe Stratton is haunted by aliens with a special interest in him, it genuinely feels like his family is suffering from mass hysteria brought on by Stratton’s deep belief in things unseen. How else to explain their utter conviction that they are being haunted by the supernatural but complete disinclination to take even the smallest steps to record objective evidence of any of it? How else to explain the ridiculous scene where Stratton dramatically debates whether to stop hunting space aliens to protect his family only to decide they must suffer the slings and arrows of their alien tormentors for the sake of—wait for it—his paycheck? By the time he gets to the part where “balloon-heads,” six-foot-tall nose-less aliens, stand outside his home’s windows each night but he chooses to do nothing about this, not even to snap a picture, it feels more like a folie à deux than a knockoff Poltergeist."
www.jasoncolavito.com/blog/review-of-out-of-the-shadows-b… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The idea that aliens not only have come here but that their technology is roughly 10 years ahead of ours, using transistors instead of vacuum tubes, is ludicrous @MikeFromHC
If we got the transistor from aliens instead of William Shockley, John Bardeen & Walter Brattain, why did the Nobel Committee give them the prize?
Mike Painter
@MikeFromHC
But what about the transistor showing up shortly after the alien crash in 47?
I suppose you'll point out that Julius Edgar Lilienfeld (April 18, 1882 – August 28, 1963) was credited with the first patents on the field-effect transistor (FET) in 1925.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julius_Edgar_Lilienfeld -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The description of the Nimitz UAP descending from 80,000 feet to near sea level in seconds without a sonic boom or atmospheric fireball is impossible given current physics @FernandoFLongo
Yes, it is remotely possible that there is some super advanced unknown physics at work here (e.g., warp drive bubble) but what's more likely?
400 years of physics is wrong, or that the description is mistaken?
Fernando Longo
@FernandoFLongo
Michael, on Nimitz you said, “It cannot have happened. That is physically impossible.” Now you quote Dietrich’s frustration with UFO enthusiasts. Fair enough, but her frustration does not explain the encounter.
I’m not asking you to believe in aliens. I’m asking you to show which observations your physics argument rules out, and why. Quoting what a witness thinks of the audience is not the same as explaining what she saw. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I suspect @TheUfoJoe that what Stratton (& Grusch's sources) saw was our own advanced technology (drones, planes) that they didn't recognize, so they call it "off world", "NHI", "alien" etc.
In the 1960s & 1970s commercial airline pilots reported UFOs flying much higher & faster. They were seeing the U2 spy plane, the SR-71 Blackbird, etc.
The Stealth Bomber is spooky looking but we know what it is. What is the military/CIA/DARPA testing today, described as UAPs, that we will learn about in years to come.
Joe Murgia
@TheUfoJoe
Again, @jaystratton already gave the information ("exact addresses of facilities holding advanced technology of non-human origin") to senior staffers of the SASC. And senators on that committee went and tried to get access. Are those not important people?
According to Stratton, access was denied.
So what exactly is Stratton supposed to do now? Break in and steal a craft?
If Trump and @StephenM really want to bring attention to this topic, go to those addresses (or any new locations, if stuff has been moved) and bring a camera crew. Livestream it. If the POTUS is denied access, it's going to be one of the biggest stories in recent history.
But he won't do that. Stratton said Trump has been shielded from the best evidence and not briefed on it. If Trump really had an interest, he'd demand a full briefing. But I don't think he cares about it. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Oy, I finally noticed that #12 says "offing" (presumably as in killing) not "offering", so in that case I'm 19/20, as I have not offed anyone, much less a hitchhiker!
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
He obviously did not review all the data before making a conclusion 😭😭💀💀
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
20/20 for me. And I'll add a few more: listening to 8-track tapes, watching Betamax videos, navigating using the Thomas Bros. Guide books, driving a 1960s car (my 1st was a 66 Mustang) & working on the engine myself, writing letters in longhand & mailing them in envelopes, etc.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not me @TheUfoJoe ! Show PERSUE or AARO or POTUS or someone important. I'm not important. I'm just a lifelong observer noting that we've been hearing breathless stories about disclosure coming any day now...for 75 years.
The question isn't why I keep asking to see the aliens. The question is why you (and others) are not asking.
I agree with Lt. Commander Alex Dietrich, who witnessed the 2004 UAP incident from a USS Nimitz fighter jet, as I think it well sums up 75 years of UFOlogists’ search for aliens:
"I think they enjoy the anticipation more than actually finding answers."
Joe Murgia
@TheUfoJoe
"I've given [members of Congress and the Executive Branch] not only the existence of non-human intelligence, but the address to go look to see it. And they were denied access." ~Stratton
Yes, @jaystratton. Why don't you share that address of the alleged location of non-human intelligence (craft and/or bodies) with Shermer so he can go knock on the door, be let in, given a cookie, and see the craft and bodies with his own eyes?
You can't fix stupid.
In March of 2025, at @sxsw, Stratton said, I've spent, 'lots of time over the years, countless hours with Congress, with the Executive Branch, pushing this message forward. In those countless hours, I have given them information. I've given them not only the existence of non-human intelligence, but the address to go look to see it. And they were denied access."
Source, with full, massive transcript by me, and video:
x.com/TheUfoJoe/status/1899578184229875794
Go find the address and break in, Michael. Let us know how you do. One break in, coming up! 🙄
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I guess it was inevitable.
@jaystratton instead of blocking people who ask you to show us (or select scientists, POTUS, Marco, or whomever) the evidence that the U.S. has alien bodies & ships, why don't you just disclose where exactly they are so we can all see for ourselves? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Clarification:
When I ask UAP whistleblowers like @jaystratton or David Grusch to "show us the aliens", I don't mean me or Avi Loeb, or the UAP Science Advisory Council; I mean ODNI or PURSUE or AARO or POTUS himself.
Trump loves recognition for accomplishments, so what could be bigger than announcing we're not alone in the universe?
Yes, Stratton told Fox News that he personally has seen NHIs so we're not alone, but he won't reveal the location of the aliens (Brett Baier asked him) so that doesn't count.
We all just want actual evidence and are tired of anecdotes and stories recounted endlessly in books, films, and podcasts.
Can we at long last get to the bottom of this mystery? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Carl Sagan interview in PBS NOVA on discovering ETIs:
"It would be an absolutely transforming event in human history. But, the stakes are so high on whether it's true or false, that we must demand the more rigorous standards of evidence. Precisely because it's so exciting. That's the circumstance in which our hopes may dominate our skeptical scrutiny of the data. So, we have to be very careful. There have been a few instances in the [past]. We thought we found something, and it always turned out to be explicable...
So, a kind of skepticism is routinely applied to the radio search for extraterrestrial intelligence by its most fervent proponents. I do not see [in] the alien abduction situation a similar rigorous application of scientific skepticism by its proponents. Instead, I see enormous acceptance at face value - and leading the witness and all sorts of suggestions. Plus, the contamination by the general culture of this idea.
It seems to me there is a big difference between the two approaches to extraterrestrial intelligence, although I'm frequently written to [to] say how could I search for extraterrestrial intelligence and disbelieve that we're being visited. I don't see any contradiction at all. It's a wonderful prospect, but requires the most severe and rigorous standards of evidence." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Believe me @jaystratton I want to believe NHI are here. Really I do! Like Carl Sagan, I strongly suspect ETIs are out there in the cosmos. But to believe they've come here we need better evidence than blurry photographs, grainy videos, and anecdotes.
In science, we don't want to believe in things that must be believed in to be true. That would be religious faith. We need evidence. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I guess it was inevitable.
@jaystratton instead of blocking people who ask you to show us (or select scientists, POTUS, Marco, or whomever) the evidence that the U.S. has alien bodies & ships, why don't you just disclose where exactly they are so we can all see for ourselves? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Did Magic Mushrooms Make Us Religious?
Hugh Urban in latest Skeptic
psilocybin and other psychedelics work to:
"the melting away of the usual boundaries between self and world and the feeling of 'Oceanic Boundlessness' or merging into some larger whole."
www.skeptic.com/article/did-magic-mushrooms-make-us-relig… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Whatever the real reason professional tennis pays women the same as men but requires ~63% of the effort in the grand slams (2/3 vs. 3/5 sets) it is absurd to claim women can't last as long. They absolutely can. Equal work for equal pay—as in other sports
quillette.com/2026/10/11/equal-pay-unequal-work-us-open-f… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You know the answer @MickWest
The same reason the other UAP whistleblowers express their fear of being eliminated for revealing what they know, so to protect themselves they go on Rogan, NewsNation, Fox, etc. to reveal everything they just said would get them killed.
Conspiracists of all stripes do this: 9/11 Truthers claim that "they" don't want us to know the truth and that "they" are having people killed who know too much, but then Truthers publish books, go on podcasts, speak at widely publicized conferences, etc., because they well know that no one is after them.
It's all PR.
Mick West
@MickWest
So, why was Jay allowed to write his book when he implies that people have been killed for far less?
Jay Stratton
@jaystratton
Another sneak peek inside my memoir, which publishes Tuesday, October 13th.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Speaking of leftists' anti-capitalist hypocrisy:
Lefty sociology professor accrued $6.6 million in the stock market & left it to a defunct nonprofit & now the Democratic Socialists of America want the money. Of course! That's how it works for socialists: wait to see who makes money & target them.
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/09/nyregion/nyu-professor-dsa-inh… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting that Bernie, AOC & anti-Capitalist left go after big name billionaires (Musk, Bezos, et al.), but there are over 3 million people worth >$25 million: dentists, car dealers, bottlers, & hamburger bun makers! I guess they're less visible targets. I guess chanting "Those hamburger bun makers are not paying their fair share!" doesn't make such a good slogan.
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/02/business/democrats-wealthy-tax… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Chinese drones have a far higher Bayesian probability than alien spaceships, especially since we know about the Chinese spy balloon.
@AskaPol_UAP
EXCLUSIVE:
Intel Ranking Member Mark Warner says “Chinese drones” shuttered Langley Air Force base — on US soil! — for 17 days in 2023, not UAP
Ask a Pol asks:
Did you ever get answers from the Pentagon on the UAP incursions that effectively shuttered Langley Air Force Base for 17 days in 2023?
Key Warner:
“Mostly ended up being Chinese drones,” Sen. Mark Warner exclusively told Ask a Pol UAP.
Full transcript at Ask a Pol UAP on Substack: www.askapoluaps.com/p/chinese-drones-shuttered-air-force-…
*PSA: Please note this interview is from August, when I was dealing with (ongoing…) legal issues with the nation’s TV networks. Said legal issues have been costly, because I’ve been barred from credentialing my ever-rotating team of independent journalists at the Capitol, thus no extra hands on deck to help publish Ask a Pol (one of the 5 or so fledgling new media startups I run).
**HELP! If you support UFO exclusives from the US Capitol, consider subscribing to Ask a Pol UAP today here on X or on our Substack (or Venmo, CashApp, PayPal, etc). We desperately need your support!
25% off SALE — cause our revenue’s plummeted 27%. Please, help this scrappy startup stay afloat in the New Year: www.askapoluaps.com/25percentoff -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Well @CathyYoung63 it was a female hitchhiker, which I had never encountered before, so I took a chance. I told her my serial killer joke:
Hitchhiker: "How do you know I'm not a serial killer?"
Driver: "I figure what are the chances of 2 serial killers in a car at the same time?"
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
You've offed a drifter? Didn't know you led such an adventurous life 😈
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
White Guilt
My convo with Eli and Shelby Steele on a pervasive problem in which white guilt not only does not help blacks, it makes matters worse, is demeaning, and even racist. And some blacks use it for power and money. Their film is fabulous. www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/racism-and-white-gui… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
20/20 for me. And I'll add a few more: listening to 8-track tapes, watching Betamax videos, navigating using the Thomas Bros. Guide books, driving a 1960s car (my 1st was a 66 Mustang) & working on the engine myself, writing letters in longhand & mailing them in envelopes, etc.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
🛡️Defend the West Conference🛡️
WHEN: 1/13/2027
WHERE: Online
Over 300 people have registered so far.
Speakers include:
@DavidM_Friedman
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@jasoncrawford
Nadine Strossen
Save your spot (link below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
But at least Iran can’t nuke us…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The point of quoting Kean @MiddleOfMayhem is that even a hardcore alien believer says 90-95% of all sightings are ordinary terrestrial. Wasn't that obvious in my essay?
Ditto Grusch: when I said his claims are "unbelievable" isn't it obvious I don't believe him?
As for Avi Loeb, he is neither zany nor a grifter, and such false ad hominem attacks is not proper skepticism.
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
You're supposedly a "skeptic" but here you promote zany grifter Avi Loeb, you use Leslie Kean (!) as a reliable source, you platform David Grusch's wacky alien claims without providing readers context of Grusch's intimate connection to very dubious and dishonest paranormal figures (he's just "a former Air Force officer" here), and you state it's just your "opinion" that aliens aren't on Earth.
No wonder the UFO activists picked you as their token "skeptic" for the UFO council! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This one won't be botched.
apnews.com/article/fort-hood-shooter-execution-pentagon-8… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I’m the devil’s advocate on the Trump council seeking signs of alien life on earth. Here’s why.
Those videos are not what they may seem.
By Michael Shermer
My latest Boston Globe OpEd Essay:
www.bostonglobe.com/2026/10/08/opinion/aliens-uap-ufo-vid… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why I need to believe in a creator.
Bottom line: “Anyone who refuses to repent and accept God’s gift is left at the mercy of Satan, and he has no mercy.”
But what if I pick the wrong religion? Or what if I once really believed but don’t now? Am I still in the good place? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is beyond absurd. Just take Pike to the local vet and have her put to sleep like a dog, which they do all the time without incident.
apnews.com/article/christa-pike-tennessee-failed-executio… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
3%
Polymarket
@Polymarket
BREAKING: Alien disclosure odds crash to a record low, as months of government UFO disclosures fail to produce definitive evidence of extraterrestrial life.
3% chance. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It’s a flock of birds @I_D_Official Here is our UAP Science Advisory Council paper comparing the flickering of the video objects with birds wing flapping in Galileo Project recording of birds. The 480mph estimate is an artifact of the parallax effect.
lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/JHM.pdf
Richard Dolan Intelligent Disclosure
@I_D_Official
Witness incredible footage of spherical objects moving at 480 mph and changing direction instantly. Could this be a drone swarm, or is there another explanation for this baffling phenomenon?
Watch the full video www.youtube.com/watch?v=4j-j94g1BkQThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Today I received this intriguing short letter from a Skeptic reader worth sharing (with his permission):
Greetings from a fan whose bookcase bends with the weight of his Skeptic magazines. When it comes to disbelief, I am a true believer. With that in mind, I wanted to relay something that happened years ago. This event keeps my mind open to the paranormal, if only slightly. The whole thing can likely be explained through the laws of probability, or some other rational means. But it’s very strange, nonetheless.
It started with a dream. In this dream, I found myself in an old thrift store with sundry dust-covered antiques. Behind the counter were two action figures, the only toys in the whole place. They were Captain America and The Falcon. These toys were not the sleek, modern style. They were the older type from the 70’s, tall and shaped like Barbie Dolls.
The next morning, I found myself walking by an old bookstore that I had passed a thousand times before. On a whim, I decided to go inside. The interior didn’t look exactly like the store in my dream, but the atmosphere was the same. Dusty books that outgrew the shelves were piled on the floor. And there, behind the counter, were two toys…Captain America and The Falcon. And—just as in my dream—they were the older type from the 70’s, tall and shaped like Barbie Dolls.
As I said, this was years ago, before the Marvel Avengers movies had come out. Everyone knew Captain America, of course. But the only people who knew the Falcon were comic book nerds (and other people who are afraid to talk to girls). So, it’s not as though my dream was about common items that would likely be found in any such environment. Furthermore, these were the only action figures in the store. Everything else was books and posters.
I told this to people on a recent camping trip. These people are essentially anti-skeptics (good luck finding a monster they don’t believe in). When I told them that my dream could be explained through rational means, they gave me the same look I gave them when I heard their theories on Bigfoot jumping between dimensions. It truly felt as if my attempt at rational thought was as flimsy as their belief in the paranormal.
Perhaps being a skeptic means that I must perpetually keep an open mind. And I should not fully dismiss even the craziest of ideas. One thought, however, remains. If I have truly been imbued with the power to see the future in my dreams, I’d rather see something more significant than a couple of toys left over from the 1970’s.
Sincerely, Timothy Seaver -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
6 small spherical objects grouped together “seemed to be agile, frequently changing direction” that were “able to change directions quickly and simultaneously,” estimated to be moving at 480 mph at an altitude of around 22,000 feet.
In fact, comparing the movements and lighting of the objects on this video to Galileo Project (also headed by Loeb) Las Vegas observatory videos of birds, it is evident that these UAPs had wings that flapped at “bird wingbeat frequencies”, and since birds do not fly at 480 mph, the estimated speed in the video is an artifact of the parallax effect, or the apparent shift in an object’s position relative to a distant background when viewed from two different positions.
lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/JHM.pdf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
1st published paper from UAP Science Advisory Council members Jacob Haqq-Misra, Ravi Kopparapu, Richard Cloete, Omer Eldadi, Michael Shermer, and Abraham Loeb:
"Six objects reported at 480 mph in a declassified military infrared video show brightness flicker at bird wingbeat rates"
UAP infrared video of six dots recorded from a military aircraft over the Qaruh Island near Kuwait, DOW-UAP-PR135, describes a group of six small objects moving at an estimated speed of 480 miles per hour.
We determined that the UAPs are birds. Incorrect speed estimate is a result of the parallax effect.
lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/JHM.pdf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Related to "womxn", re "Latinx", according to Pew:
"The spelling faces widespread disapproval within the community it is intended to represent. Among those who have heard of "Latinx," 75% say it should not be used to describe the Hispanic or Latino population."
Again, who are these academics talking to when they use the spelling "Latinx"?
If females don't use the spelling "womxn" & Latinos don't use the spelling "Latinx", what's the point of these alternative spellings? Is it virtue signaling? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In case you're wondering what the frequency is for the alternative spelling, the Oxford English Dictionary tracks “womxn” at roughly 0.05 occurrences per million words in modern written English overall.
Its frequency rose from about 0.063 per million in 2017 to a high of about 0.089 in 2020, then dropped sharply: 0.033 in 2023, 0.017 in 2024, 0.0073 in 2025, and 0.0014 in 2026.
That is orders of magnitude below ordinary words and consistent with a short-lived niche spelling rather than everyday language.
So who are these academics talking to when they use this spelling "womxn"? If even women don't use it, what's the point? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ugh. @GadSaad reminds us that intersectional DEI woke BIPOC LGBTQ is coming back in the new President-Elect of the APA whose papers include:
“Pronouns and Experiences of Misgendering Among Non-Binary Black Womxn”
“Intersectional Masturbation: A Content Analysis on Female Masturbation Studies Through a Sex Positive and Intersectional Lens”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cornell reports "35% of surveyed undergraduate women experienced nonconsensual sexual contact involving physical force, threats, or incapacitation while enrolled at the university."
This is a shocking figure. Is Cornell closing? Has the National Guard been invoked? Why are women still attending? Why are parents still paying for their daughters to attend?
There's something off here.
statements.cornell.edu/2025/20251104-sarm-survey.cfm -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you think ETIs visiting Earth are unlikely, try interdimensional angels. So says Chris Bledsoe:
Grok:
Chris Bledsoe, a North Carolina experiencer best known for a 2007 incident on the Cape Fear River and his book UFO of God, does not treat the phenomena he reports as conventional hostile extraterrestrials. He frames them as benevolent, angelic or spiritual beings tied to God.
His core claims, drawn from interviews, his book, and appearances (including History Channel coverage and podcasts):
The 2007 event involved a craft or lights, several hours of missing time, small beings with glowing red eyes, and what he describes as a miraculous healing of Crohn’s disease. He later reported ongoing contact with orbs of light and a female figure he calls “the Lady” (also linked by him or others to the divine feminine, a “Mother Spirit,” Hathor, or the Virgin Mary). She allegedly told him to share his story and that she would guide him.
He repeatedly says these are not “evil aliens.” In his words, the orbs and beings are angelic, benevolent, and “of God.” He argues that portraying them as destructive invaders is a way of undermining faith. He cites biblical imagery of light, clouds, and angelic messengers (for example, Paul on the road to Damascus) as parallels.
He says the phenomena respond to prayer. He describes invoking the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and asking them to share their presence; orbs then appear. He has claimed to have captured thousands of photos and videos of them and that they have been witnessed by others, including investigators.
Messages he attributes to them emphasize love, forgiveness, spiritual awakening, environmental concern, and “waking humanity up” before it destroys itself. He has spoken of them as guardians or attendants to the Lady and as signs that “the heavens” are watching.
On origin, he leans toward interdimensional or spiritual rather than strictly planetary extraterrestrials. He has said the small red-eyed figures were living beings (not robots) and that they may come from another dimension. In at least one interview he allowed that the broader phenomenon could include multiple kinds of life—“there’s both”—while still insisting that what he experiences personally is angelic and benevolent, not the hostile aliens of popular culture. How the phenomena appear, he has suggested, can be shaped by the observer’s intent and beliefs.
Chris Bledsoe
@chrisbledsoeufo
For nearly two decades, my family and I have watched lights that seemed to be trying to tell us something.
Today, the research begins.
I'm proud to introduce the Bledsoe Institute for Research.
Become a founding angel. Donations are tax-deductible: bledsoeinstitute.org -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Islam and Pseudoscience:
Close Encounters in the Classroom (and How to Deal with Them)
By Stefano Bigliardi for Skeptic
www.skeptic.com/article/islam-and-pseudoscience-in-the-cl… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My upcoming talks at UC Santa Barbara as their SAGE Visiting Scholar
Psychology Room #1312
Oct 28, 12-1pm PT: UFOs, UAPs, and ETIs
Oct 29, 3:30pm PT: Truth
Nov 3, 1pm-2pm PT: Conspiracies
All recorded & posted for livestream & permanent viewing here:
ucsb.zoom.us/j/6042982403 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It is unfathomable that a purported public intellectual like this guy can say with a straight face on a national program that the cause of homelessness in American cities is that they weren't loved enough elsewhere. Sure. Try that in a doctoral dissertation or journal article.
News to Remember
@allchronology
Every fucking word of this. OMG share this with everyone—crying my eyes out…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Both statement can be true at the same time:
‘AARO has found no verifiable evidence that any UAP sighting has represented extraterrestrial activity,' Tim Phillips, then AARO's acting director, said in a March 2024 Defence Department briefing.
Loeb has not argued that every unexplained sighting is alien. His position is that even a very small chance deserves serious investigation. Loeb has argued that even a very small possibility of extraterrestrial technology would justify serious investigation, because such a discovery would be extraordinary.
www.ibtimes.co.uk/michael-shermer-extraterrestrial-bet-ua… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Even though people are passionate on the abortion issue it is good to recall the past when people had no such option. From Chelsea Follett's @chellivia new book The Grim Old Days (reading now in prep for her coming on my show), re infants:
“Others were simply killed in the cradle. The intentional killing of infants was frequent in the preindustrial world. Across many different cultures, ‘the enduring and persistent nature of the killing of new-borns throughout history’ is well documented…
“The bodies of dead infants were found hidden in a variety of locations, particularly toilets. Sometimes women kept the dead bodies of their infants with them: either locked in a trunk in their room, in the bed alongside them or hidden on their person whilst they returned to work. More commonly, during the seventeenth, eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, however, bodies were disposed of in the privy or water closet."
Why? Hard lives, not hard hearts. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The good 'ol days—they were dreck.
"Because most children died in infancy, a woman needed to give birth many times, and sooner or later one of those births would almost certainly kill her.
If somehow you survived infancy, childhood diseases would probably kill you, and if they didn’t, the education you got would be either no school or a nightmare school.
If you made it to adulthood, the lack of transport would limit your marriage prospects to the people in your village, to whom you were probably related, and with whom you were therefore condemned to produce genetically questionable offspring (as you probably were yourself).
You lived in a one-room shack filled with filth, or in a tenement in a town whose streets were filled with filth, and so the air stank and the water was unsafe to drink, which is why you were sick most of the time.
You had just a few stinking lice-infested rags for clothes, and lice in your hair too, so you itched all the time. The food was of low quality and limited variety, and generally available in inadequate quantities.
But even if on rare occasions you got something good to eat, you would not enjoy it much because, by the time you reached adulthood, most of your teeth were gone.
You worked from dawn to dusk, but, exhausted as you were, you might not get much sleep because you shared your home with livestock, and even if they were well behaved and made little noise, you needed to be alert at night because there were no police, and you were living in a criminal-infested combat zone.
After the development of printing, there were books, but even if you could read and afford them, you would not have much time to read because you worked all day and it was dark at night."
quillette.com/2026/10/04/life-in-the-grim-old-days-follet… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The vast majority of theists, especially Christians @StringerLance do not think of miracles as just highly improbable events, but as divine providence, or God's intervention.
Aunt Mary's cancer going into remission as a result of some highly anomalous genetic mutation caused by a cosmic ray passing through the tumor may be highly improbable but it is not a miracle in the theistic sense that we prayed for Aunt Mary and God heard our prayers and intervened.
Of course, it's an unfalsifiable idea because if Aunt Mary dies of cancer God doesn't get the blame for not intervening because he "works in mysterious way" or "has a bigger plan" or whatever.
Lance Robert Calton Stringer
@StringerLance
Incoherent "Miracles are a violation of nature (by God)" - you mean "'Miracles' could happen for all we know as they may just exploit aspects of nature that we are fully aware of" - I assume you do know that are current theoretical physics theories of nature are incomplete and that we still have no idea what spacetime or quantum fields fundamentally are. Yet you claim without doubt that x is a violation of physics - cannot happen.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Maybe this time it really is different (after endless predictions of doomsday), but let's keep some perspective says @sapinker
Whenever you hear a doomsday prediction, turn to history.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After WWI, it was predicted that humanity would be extinguished by cropdusters blanketing cities with poison gas. After WWII, nuclear holocaust, for sure. After 9/11, terrorists with WMD, including suitcase and shipping container nukes. After the first nanotech, engulfment by "gray goo." The fact that these (and many other) end times prophesies failed does not mean that the new AI doom prophesy will fail - maybe this time it's different - but they should serve as a reminder of the cognitive bias of casually slipping from risk to existential risk, and to compensate accordingly, just as with other cognitive biases if one is a rationalist. John Mueller adds historical perspective here: Artificial Intelligence and the persistent survival of cosmic alarmism muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/artificial-intelligence-and-th…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I disagree @MiddleOfMayhem
Miracles are a violation of nature (by God) whereas if there are ETIs they would be the product of nature like all life.
Miracles cannot happen even in principle (unless there is a God that periodically reaches into the world to stir the particles in a way to change a natural outcome).
A real skeptic would NEVER say that ETIs cannot exist, because they could (why else is SETI conducting searches?!)
Have ETIs come here? Probably not, but the probability is not 0, so a good skeptic keeps an open mind just in case.
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Kinda fitting that you point out the historical context here... "to debunk all the fake or mistaken miracle claims". As opposed to, what, the real miracles? It was, and is, all nonsense! And that's what a real skeptic would say regarding the UFO balderdash.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Although @anilkseth doesn't mean to suggest this in his argument that consciousness depends on biological life (i.e., not substrate independent), this is what theists argue in claiming that God vouchsafed consciousness to us as living beings & that it will NEVER be achieved in computers.
www.noemamag.com/the-mythology-of-conscious-ai/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“If, after analyzing new data on millions of objects, we will find beyond a reasonable doubt that one of them has a non-human technological origin, that would constitute the biggest scientific discovery ever made by humanity.”
Agreed! But it’s a big IF!!
brobible.com/culture/article/white-house-advisory-council… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why AI Doomsday Predictions Don't Convince Him
(the him being me) with Danny Li
www.youtube.com/watch?v=09VTPexFjKo -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reviewing 155,000 pages of U.A.P. records, investigators found no verifiable extraterrestrial evidence.
AARO confirms most U.A.P. sightings involve misidentified objects or experimental human technology since 1945.
Skeptic Michael Shermer bets Loeb $1,000 that extraterrestrials will not be confirmed by 2030.
www.gadgetreview.com/is-the-truth-out-there-trump-backed-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why the UFO/UAP topic needs its advocatus diaboli, or “designated ‘devil’s advocate,’” comparable to what the Catholic Church when Pope Sixtus V instituted the position in 1587 to debunk all the fake or mistaken miracle claims.
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/02/us/trump-ufo-files-uap-council… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Our SkepDoc William Meller, M.D. in today's Skeptic on:
The Truth About Vaccine Schedules:
An Injection of Politics?
www.skeptic.com/article/truth-about-vaccine-schedules-an-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It was a cordial day, so at one point they asked me if any Christian ever lost their cool with me.
Once a guy got right up into my face and threatened me, so I said unto him...
"go forth and multiply."
But not in those words.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuRpCOyU_Oo -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
1 Atheist vs 10 Christians:
Does Christianity Survive the Evidence?
Full 4-hour ultramarathon session now up:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuRpCOyU_Oo -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are Liberals More Depressed Than Conservatives?
Clare Ashcraft in Skeptic discusses the polling data affirming a "yes" to the title question. Explaining why is more complicated (beyond cliche political responses).
www.skeptic.com/article/why-are-liberals-more-depressed-t… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I don't want to sound morbid, but every year in the U.S. ~320,000 dogs are euthanized using pentobarbital. How many botched? AI:
"Extremely Rare: When performed properly by trained professionals using standard protocols (typically an intravenous overdose of a pentobarbital-based barbiturate), euthanasia is fast, painless, and peaceful."
Dogs are big mammals.
People are big mammals.
What am I missing? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just finished listening to the 2.5 hour convo on Rogan with David Grusch. I have to say I find it hard to take him seriously.
At the end Joe thanks him for his service to the country, and Grusch waxes poetic about how he just wants to let Americans know what is actually going on. And what is that?
Grusch explains that the government has dead reptilian aliens that soldiers shot dead, after the reptilians killed a number of US soldiers. This was part of the war on Earth between the grays and the reptilians that, again, the military is involved in. There’s a UFO so huge that it can’t be moved so the government built a giant building around it. There’s an underwater structure the size of many city blocks in an ocean somewhere that houses more aliens who are monitoring us.
And on and on with lots of references to Star Trek and multiple Hollywood SciFi films, which to my ears is exactly what all this sounds like. Grusch tells a fantastic story that if true would be beyond belief, but then when Joe asks him for details Grusch clams up, even claiming that people in our government have threatened his life (after explaining that he uncovered a child trafficking operation in the government).
Question: if David Grusch is really afraid for his life why is he telling millions of people all these stories (but when asked for evidence goes silent)?
I’m sorry, but my skeptical alarms go off when I listen to Grusch. It is very difficult to believe. I know many of you on X seem to hold him in high regard so what am I missing?
Even he told Joe “I know this all sounds completely crazy.” Yup. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
March 7, 2027
First Baptist Dallas
See you then and there (in person or virtually)
religionnews.com/2026/10/01/apologetics-inc-announces-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Grusch says he saw footage of dead bodies that looked human at a crash site.
Is it possible that is exactly what he saw? Dead people at a vehicle crash?
If that's not what it is, then what could it be?
Aliens evolved human-like beautiful pale bluish-white skinned bodies?
Uh?
KanekoaTheGreat
@KanekoaTheGreat
NEW: UAP whistleblower David Grusch tells Joe Rogan he has seen recent video of dead, human-looking beings at a crash retrieval site, describing them as "very, very beautiful" with pale, bluish-white skin.
ROGAN: How do you know that for sure?
GRUSCH: I got to see the audiovisual on that.
ROGAN: You got to see what?
GRUSCH: I've got to be a little vague only because I want to protect the sources, because it may indicate a specific activity or operation. And these people were very patriotic, and they were just dead cadavers on the ground because it was a retrieval activity.
ROGAN: You saw them physically, or you saw video of them?
GRUSCH: Video.
ROGAN: So they filmed the crash, and they filmed these cadavers.
GRUSCH: Yeah.
ROGAN: How old is this footage?
GRUSCH: I don't want to say. It's contemporary. But I don't want to reveal a particular operation because it narrows it down.
ROGAN: But it's clear. It's not like you're looking at 1950s black and white.
GRUSCH: Yeah, it's clear... I was very allergic to any kind of deception... I sat on that stuff for like years until I felt comfortable with that not being some sort of limited hangout or deception activity.
ROGAN: What did it look like?
GRUSCH: Human-looking.
ROGAN: How human?
GRUSCH: Looked similar to a human. Very, very beautiful.
ROGAN: What color was the skin?
GRUSCH: Bluish white.
ROGAN: Like Avatar?
GRUSCH: No, no, no. Like someone who drowned. Like a pale sort of albino.
GRUSCH: General McCasland, when he was talking to [Tom] DeLonge, and this is public record... he always told Tom, "Think of the Greek gods." And now I kind of understand what he meant.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The great Heather Mac Donald @HMDatMI on the Cornell "rape crisis":
“If there is indeed a ‘culture of rape’ at elite institutions, as Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez recently reaffirmed, why do female students flock into them? Cornell’s student body went from a little under 50 percent female in 2005 to nearly 54 percent female in 2025.
The hoary (no pun intended) statistic bandied about relentlessly during the height of 2010’s campus rape frenzy—that one in four female undergraduates would be sexually assaulted during her college years—signifies a level of criminal sexual violence unheard of even during African tribal wars.
Yet instead of demanding a massive expansion of single-sex schools where they could study safely, females keep trooping in to co-ed colleges and, even more inexplicably in light of the received feminist wisdom, into the frat parties that are allegedly hot beds of rape.
Either females are too stupid to take the most basic of precautions or there is no rape crisis and they know it. The same goes for their status-hungry mothers: why are they sending their daughters into such a maelstrom of violence? Answer: that violence does not exist."
Heather Mac Donald
@HMDatMI
Let’s take a moment, in light of the Cornell “rape case” hysteria, to savor the dilemmas facing the activists and academics who promote the idea of “rape culture.” If there is indeed a “culture of rape” at elite institutions, as Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez recently reaffirmed, why do female students flock into them? Cornell’s student body went from a little under 50 percent female in 2005 to nearly 54 percent female in 2025. The hoary (no pun intended) statistic bandied about relentlessly during the height of 2010’s campus rape frenzy—that one in four female undergraduates would be sexually assaulted during her college years—signifies a level of criminal sexual violence unheard of even during African tribal wars.
Yet instead of demanding a massive expansion of single-sex schools where they could study safely, females keep trooping in to co-ed colleges and, even more inexplicably in light of the received feminist wisdom, into the frat parties that are allegedly hot beds of rape. Either females are too stupid to take the most basic of precautions or there is no rape crisis and they know it. The same goes for their status-hungry mothers: why are they sending their daughters into such a maelstrom of violence? Answer: that violence does not exist.
Likewise, Cornell either has to defend its integrity and assert that it properly investigated and responded to Jane Doe’s “rape” charge in 2024, or it has to capitulate to its feminist student body and professoriate and admit to trivializing rape and to insufficiently believing survivors. Cornell’s September 30 press release tries to have it both ways—implicitly exculpating itself while promising to do even more to “support survivors” and to foster a “culture of safety.”
Doe’s original complaint to the police, filed days after the bacchanal, gave no hint that she had been coerced into group sex and drug use. Instead it described a set of voluntary if sordid transactions. Justice was done the first time around, but any university is fatally compromised in being able to state such a truth, thanks to its own promotion of victim fiction.
I dissect the campus rape hoax here: www.city-journal.org/article/the-campus-rape-myth -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The line is:
“Hitler didn’t try to exterminate European Jewry…but he should have.”
Max 📟
@MaxNordau
Why do Holocaust deniers love Hitler so much?
He didn’t even kill any Jews. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What do you make of an experience you can’t explain?
A strange light in the sky, a book flying off a desk, a coincidence that feels too improbable to be chance?
Social psychologist Barry Markovsky discusses his new book Everyday Extraordinary with me:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/would-you-want-to-kn… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Christians often site Galatians 3:28 to argue that Christianity endorses equal rights, when the apostle Paul says:
“There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus.”
Christians imagine that this Bible verse is the foundation of the famous line in the preamble of the American Declaration of Independence—“All men are created equal.”
I’m afraid not. Let's examine the entire passage to see what Paul is up to: (Galatians 3:1)
“O foolish Galatians, who hath bewitched you, that ye should not obey the truth, before whose eyes Jesus Christ hath been evidently set forth, crucified among you?” And what is this truth, according to Paul? The truth is that “[T]he Jew in becoming a Christian did not need to become a Greek, nor the Greek a Jew. The slave might continue to serve his master, and “male” and “female” retained each its function in the ongoing stream of life.”
In other words, Paul is saying that you can carry on as you are. If you’re Greek, there’s no need to become a Jew—a significant dispensation, given that a man converting to Judaism often had to submit to adult circumcision, and this is just the kind of thing that puts a guy off the whole idea. (Rule Number One for getting lots of converts, Paul realized, is let the guys keep their foreskins. Let circumcision be spiritual—“of the heart”—instead of physical, as Paul writes in Romans 2:29, and a lot more men are going to sign up and become card-carrying members of the faith.)
Paul was not a revolutionary advocating violence, and he most assuredly wasn’t ghostwriting the U.S. Constitution. He was saying that if you’re a slave, you must keep on being a slave; if you’re a wife, must continue being regarded as property; no matter who you are, you can still worship Jesus Christ and be abused by your culture in whatever manner is customary for someone of your breeding and station. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I know, Christians follow Jesus and the New Testament. O-kay...
In fact, if anything, Jesus’ morality is even more draconian than that of the Old Testament: “Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not kill; and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment: But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment.”
In other words, even thinking about killing someone is a capital offense. In fact, Jesus elevated thought crimes to an Orwellian new level (Matthew 9:28-29): “Ye have heard it was said by them of old time, Though shalt not commit adultery: But I say unto you, That whosoever looketh on a woman to lust after her hath committed adultery with her already in his heart.” And if you don’t think you can control your sexual impulses Jesus has a practical solution: “If thy right eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.” President Bill Clinton may have physically sinned in the White House with an intern, but by Jesus’ moral code even the evangelical Christian Jimmy Carter sinned when he famously admitted in a 1976 Playboy magazine interview while running for President: “I’ve looked on a lot of women with lust. I’ve committed adultery in my heart many times.”
As for Jesus’s own family values, he never married, never had children, and he turned away his own mother time and again. For example, at a wedding feast Jesus says to her (John 2:4): “Woman, what have I to do with you?” One biblical anecdote recounts the time that Mary waited patiently off to the side for Jesus to finish speaking so that she could have a moment with him, but Jesus told his disciples, “Send her away, you are my family now,” adding (Luke 14:26): “Whoever comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, and even life itself, cannot be my disciple.”
Charming. This is what cultists do when they separate followers from their families in order to control both their thoughts and their actions, as when Jesus calls to his flock to follow him or else (John 15:4-7): “Abide in me as I abide in you. Just as the branch cannot bear fruit by itself unless it abides in the vine, neither can you unless you abide in me. I am the vine, you are the branches. Those who abide in me and I in them bear much fruit, because apart from me you can do nothing. Whoever does not abide in me is thrown away like a branch and withers; such branches are gathered, thrown into the fire, and burned.” But if a believer abandons his family and gives away his belongings (Mark 10:30), “he shall receive an hundredfold now in this time, houses, and brethren, and sisters, and mothers, and children, and lands.” In other passages Jesus also sounds like the tribal warlords of the Old Testament:
Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth; I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law; and one’s foes will be members of one’s own household. Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me; and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me; and whoever does not take up the cross and follow me is not worthy of me. (Matthew 10:34-39)
Even sincere Christians cannot agree on Jesus’ morality and the moral codes in the New Testament, holding legitimate differences of opinion on a number of moral issues that remain unresolved based on biblical scripture alone. These include dietary restrictions and the use of alcohol, tobacco, and caffeine; masturbation, pre-marital sex, contraception, and abortion; marriage, divorce, and sexuality; the role of women; capital punishment and voluntary euthanasia; gambling and other vices; international and civil wars; and many other matters of contention that were nowhere in sight when the Bible was written, such as stem-cell research, gay marriage, and the like. Indeed, the fact that Christians, as a community, keep arguing over their own contemporary question “WWJD” (What Would Jesus Do?) is evidence that the New Testament is silent on the answer. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More from The Moral Arc:
Laura Betzig analyzed the Old Testament and found no less than 41 named polygamists, not one of which was a powerless man. “In the Old Testament, powerful men—patriarchs, judges, and kings—have sex with more wives; they have more sex with other men’s women; they have sex with more concubines, servants, and slaves; and they father many children.”
And not just the big names. According to Betzig’s analysis, “men with bigger herds of sheep and goats tend to have sex with more women, then to father more children.” Most of the polygynous patriarchs, judges, and kings had two, three, or four wives with a corresponding number of children, although King David had more than eight wives and twenty children, King Abijah had fourteen wives and thirty-eight children, and King Rehoboam had eighteen wives (and sixty other women) who bore him no fewer than eighty-eight offspring.
But they were all lightweights compared to King Solomon, who married at least 700 women. There were Moabite, Ammonite, Edomite, Sidonian, and Hittite women he married, then for good measure added 300 concubines, which he called “man’s delight.” (What Solomon’s concubines called him was never recorded.) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From The Moral Arc:
The Bible is one of the most immoral works in all literature. Woven throughout begats and chronicles, laws and customs, is a narrative of accounts written by, and about, a bunch of Middle Eastern tribal warlords who constantly fight over land and women, with the victors taking dominion over both. It features a jealous and vengeful God named Yahweh who decides to punish women for all eternity with the often intolerable pain of childbirth, and further condemns them to be little more than beasts of burden and sex slaves for the victorious warlords.
Why were women to be chastened this way? Why did they deserve an eternity of misery and submission? It was all for that one terrible sin, the first crime ever recorded in the history of humanity—a thought crime no less—when that audacious autodidact Eve dared to educate herself by partaking of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Worse she inveigled the first man—the unsuspecting Adam—to join her in choosing knowledge over ignorance. For the appalling crime of hearkening unto the voice of his wife, Yahweh condemned Adam to toil in thorn and thistle-infested fields, and further condemned him to death, to return to the dust from whence he came.
Yahweh then cast his first two delinquent children out of paradise, setting a Cherubim and a flaming sword at the entrance to be certain that they could never return. Then, in one of the many foul moods he was wont to fall into, Yahweh committed an epic hemoclysm of genocidal proportions by killing every sentient being on Earth—including unsuspecting adults, innocent children, and all the land animals—in a massive flood. In order to repopulate the planet after he decimated it of all life save those spared in the ark, Yahweh commanded the survivors—numerous times—to “be fruitful and multiply,” and rewarded his favorite warlords with as many wives as they desired. Thus was born the practice of polygamy and the keeping of harems, fully embraced and endorsed—along with slavery—in the so-called “good book.”
As an exercise in moral casuistry, this perspective-taking question comes to mind: did anyone ask the women how they felt about this arrangement? What about the millions of people living in other parts of the world who had never heard of Yahweh? What about the animals and the innocent children who drowned in the flood? What did they do to deserve such a final solution to Yahweh’s anger problem? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm boning up for this 10x1 debate by re-reading the Bible. Numbers, 31: 7-12:
"They warred against Mid′ian, as the Lord commanded Moses, and slew every male. They slew the kings of Mid′ian … And the people of Israel took captive the women of Mid′ian and their little ones; and they took as booty all their cattle, their flocks, and all their goods. All their cities in the places where they dwelt, and all their encampments, they burned with fire, and took all the spoil and all the booty, both of man and of beast. Then they brought the captives and the booty and the spoil to Moses."
That sounds like a good days pillaging, but when the troops got back, Moses was furious. “What do you mean you didn’t kill the women?” he asked, exasperated, since it was apparently the women who had enticed the Israelites to be unfaithful with another God.
Moses then ordered them to kill all the women who had slept with a man, and the boys. “But save for yourselves every girl who has never slept with a man,” he commanded, predictably, at which point one can imagine the thirty-two thousand virgins who’d been taken captive rolling their eyes and saying, “Oh, God told you to do that, did he? Right.”
Was the instruction to “keep the virgins for yourselves” what God had in mind by the word “love” in the “love thy neighbor” command? I think not. Of course, the Israelites knew exactly what God meant (this is the advantage of writing scripture yourself—you get to say what God meant) and they acted accordingly, fighting for the survival of their people. With a vengeance.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reminder: livestream tomorrow 12:15pm PT:
1 Atheist (me) vs 10 Christians:
Does Christianity Survive the Evidence?
If you don't have time to watch here's my answer:
No.
They are posting the recording later for viewing.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuRpCOyU_Oo -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the review of Truth in the Times Literary Supplement:
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
We just sold over 100 autographed copies of Truth after the positive review of it in the Times Literary Supplement was published. Now I am resting my hand!
Get your signed copy here:
shop.skeptic.com/products/truth -
Michael Shermer reposted
David J Texaco
@DavidTexaco
For entertainment I paid $3,500 to attend one of his 3 day events in “the field.” The NDA was thick and binding. I was guaranteed to “interact with aliens.” Obviously, I knew he was a fraud but what content would be provided in 72 hours? @DrStevenGreer and his ego. New age BS.🙄
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In 2026 Trump said we must hit Iran because otherwise they'll get a nuke and we're all dead.
In 2002 George W. Bush said of Iraq:
"Facing clear evidence of peril, we cannot wait for the final proof—the smoking gun—that could come in the form of a mushroom cloud."
@sapinker
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After WWI, it was predicted that humanity would be extinguished by cropdusters blanketing cities with poison gas. After WWII, nuclear holocaust, for sure. After 9/11, terrorists with WMD, including suitcase and shipping container nukes. After the first nanotech, engulfment by "gray goo." The fact that these (and many other) end times prophesies failed does not mean that the new AI doom prophesy will fail - maybe this time it's different - but they should serve as a reminder of the cognitive bias of casually slipping from risk to existential risk, and to compensate accordingly, just as with other cognitive biases if one is a rationalist. John Mueller adds historical perspective here: Artificial Intelligence and the persistent survival of cosmic alarmism muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/artificial-intelligence-and-th…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"I know in 2025 I said disclosure of aliens would happen. I know I said the same thing in 2024, 2023, 2022 & so on back to when I founded the Disclosure Project in 1993. But THIS time I really really really mean it. And I have a new film to prove it!"
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Grok is right!
Based on X posts under the handle @michaelshermer, what would the world look like under my stewardship?
A world under Michael Shermer’s stewardship, based on his consistent X posts, would be an Enlightenment-style secular society that treats science, evidence, and human nature as the operating system. Religion would be a private matter rather than public policy. Biological sex would be treated as binary and real. Education would run on competition and school choice rather than monopoly or ideology. Collectivist economic experiments would be viewed as incompatible with evolved human nature. AI and UAP claims would be met with demand for data rather than apocalyptic or conspiratorial certainty. Both identitarian dogma from the left and theocratic nationalism from the right would be rejected in favor of individual reason. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reminder: livestream tomorrow 12:15pm PT:
1 Atheist (me) vs 10 Christians:
Does Christianity Survive the Evidence?
If you don't have time to watch here's my answer:
No.
They are posting the recording later for viewing.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuRpCOyU_Oo -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
So predictable.
No deal to end the Iran War.
Who hates it, who likes it… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Does eggshell white count as racist? What about... seashell, satin, ivory, creamy, chalk, ghost, floral, bone, old lace, beige, parchment, champagne, vanilla, alabaster, linen, or white chocolate? I don't want to be a racist. Navajo white should be ok, right?
Seattle Extremist
@SeattleIndepen1
This book is real. So is the award.
In “A Dead White: An Argument Against White Paint” the author
argues that white paint isn’t neutral—it carries associations with purity, cleanliness, and power that tie into systems of exclusion and racism.
This from the university that gave us Mortimer J Adler and the Great Books movement. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“The CEOs of Anthropic & OpenAI recently declared America’s cutting-edge models are so powerful, they’re dangerous & need to be regulated & independently tested before being released.”
If only there were CEOs of said companies willing to put the breaks on their own products! I wonder why they don’t? It’s an enigma wrapped in a tortilla. apnews.com/article/ai-slowdown-midterms-anthropic-openai-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Depends on what you mean by “real” @rosscoulthart
If you mean “aliens” we do NOT know this is what UAPs are. Might be, but they may also (more likely) be advanced US military tech our government doesn’t want our adversaries to know about. So whistleblowers like Grusch who say they saw photos of craft they could not identify and so call them “off world” may be that they are seeing the next generation drones or planes or whatever. Do you agree this is at least a possibility?
Ross Coulthart
@rosscoulthart
“The debate now is no longer whether this is a real phenomenon or not - in Washington, it’s an open secret that it is. The debate now is trying to force [UAP] disclosure, because Congress has been misled for 80 years…”
Liberation Times
@LiberationTimes
NEW: Journalist Says Congressional Staffer Revealed “Recovered Crafts And Recovered Beings”
www.liberationtimes.com/home/journalist-says-congressiona… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is not the mystery Randi Weinstein makes it out to be: treat education just like any other product or service & allow competition (school choice, charters) that will drive public schools to improve education. Competition works everywhere. Let parents choose!
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you are following the AI doomsday story (we will all be dead by 2030 or 2037, depending on which AI end-of-days expert you read), this reasoned response by @sapinker is a must read.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander: The dangers of AI are real, but doomerism may be counterproductive.
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Telegraph declares that the New Atheist movement is dead. But says @Evolutionistrue :
“In fact, it you lump together atheists, agnostics, and “nones,” you see a rise from about 13% to 35%—nearly a threefold increase—between 2000 and 2020.” whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/09/27/for-the-gazillionth-tim… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sean McDowell is the son of the famous Christian apologist Josh McDowell, whose most famous book I read when I became a born-again Christian (say what?) in 1972 when it was published. A classic in the field that I later became skeptical of when I studied the arguments closely.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Last summer I debated Sean McDowell, theologian & apologist, on:
God
Fine-Tuning
NDEs & Terminal Lucidity
Mine & Brain
Could God Implant Consciousness?
The Big Bang & Inflation
Free Will & Determinism
The Resurrection as a Historical Claim
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vL0fFmTEW6s -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Michael Shermer vs. 10 Christians on:
God, suffering, Christianity’s impact on the world, hell, and the resurrection of Jesus
In Las Vegas, so if it doesn't go well hopefully what happens in Vegas stays in Vegas.
Livestream & recorded here:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YuRpCOyU_Oo -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“prophecies of doom are not effective responses to genuine risks but have pernicious downsides. Nuclear doomsday scenarios in the 1960s set off not disarmament but an arms race with the Soviets. The existential fear of nuclear terrorism (the smoking-gun-as-mushroom-cloud) led to the invasion of Iraq.”
@sapinker on AI doom scenarios. My favorite neologism: “paperclipalypse”
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
And re AI doomerism, also from Heavens on Earth in my chapter on the history of declinism:
Intellectuals are just as susceptible to the pull of a paradisiacal past followed by a declinist history, albeit without the violence. For at least a century and a half public intellectuals and academic scholars have been predicting the imminent collapse of Western civilization, even as the ideals and institutions that insure its success have grown: science and technology, reason and Enlightenment humanism, democracy and universal franchise, property rights and the rule of law, free enterprise and free trade, and the rights of individuals expanded to include all humans and even members of other sentient species.
You would think academics and intellectuals—the very people who promote such values—would be singing their own praises for such progress, but no, they’re gloomier than ever. An Amazon book scan of the word string “The Coming Crisis” produces titles like:
The Coming Financial Crisis(2015)
The Global Water Crisis(2008)
The Coming Bond Market Collapse (2013)
Get Prepared Now!: Why a Great Crisis is Coming and How You Can Survive It (2015)
ISIS, Iran and Israel: What You Need to Know about the Coming Mideast War (2016)
Code Red: How to Protect Your Savings from the Coming Crisis (2013)
The Coming Oil Crisis (2012)
The Coming Collapse of the International Monetary System (2014)
Coming Climate Crisis? (2012)
The Coming Economic Armageddon (2010)
The Coming Inflation Crisis (2014)
The Coming Famine (2011)
Rising Sea Level and the Coming Coastal Crisis (2012)
+ 55 more pages of titles in a similar vein.
“The Decline and Fall of” string returns, naturally, Gibbon’s the Roman Empire, but also Byzantium, the Habsburg Empire, the Ottoman Empire, the British Empire, the British Aristocracy, the Japanese Empire, the Soviet Empire, the Roman Church, Radical Catholicism, the American Republic, Democracy in 21st Century America, American Growth, Truth in Bush’s America, and the West, to site just a few from the first 10 pages of 100 pages of such doom.
“Rise and Fall of” generates 11,857 titles, starting with William L. Shire’s classic Third Reich, but continues with the rise and fall of Ancient Egypt, Classical Greece, Alexandria, Carthage, the Roman Empire, the House of Caesar, the House of Medici, the British Empire, Communism, the Cherokee Nation, American Growth, American Business, the Constitution, the Confederate Government, Society, Nations, Empires, and the Great Powers.
The Course of Empire: Destruction by Thomas Cole (1801-1848) intended to represent the ruin of Atlantis. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the new Unabomber film, from my Heavens on Earth:
The motivation to respond violently to the perceived decline of civilization also drove the Harvard-educated mathematical prodigy turned domestic terrorist, the Unabomber Ted Kaczynski, who between 1978 and 1995 targeted individuals for death with bombs delivered through the mail, killing three and leaving 23 others maimed. In his rambling 50-page manifesto, Industrial Society and its Future, published in The New York Times and elsewhere in hopes that some reader would recognize the degenerationist rhetoric of the author (Kaczynski’s brother did, which is how he was caught), Kaczynski opined:
"The Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race. They have greatly increased the life expectancy of those of us who live in 'advanced' countries, but they have destabilized society, have made life unfulfilling, have subjected human beings to indignities, have led to widespread psychological suffering (in the Third World to physical suffering as well) and have inflicted severe damage on the natural world. The continued development of technology will worsen the situation. It will certainly subject human beings to greater indignities and inflict greater damage on the natural world, it will probably lead to greater social disruption and psychological suffering, and it may lead to increased physical suffering even in 'advanced' countries."
Modern Americans, he griped, are “decadent leisured aristocrats” who are “bored, hedonistic, and demoralized,” nothing more than “domesticated animals.” Speaking in the first person plural “we” or occasionally “FC” (Freedom Club), like many revolutionary Marxists before him, Kaczynski advocated revolution:
"We therefore advocate a revolution against the industrial system. This revolution may or may not make use of violence; it may be sudden or it may be a relatively gradual process spanning a few decades. We can’t predict any of that. But we do outline in a very general way the measures that those who hate the industrial system should take in order to prepare the way for a revolution against that form of society. This is not to be a political revolution. Its object will be to overthrow not governments but the economic and technological basis of the present society."
This is to be followed by the introduction of a new ideology “that opposes technology and the industrial society…so that when and if the system collapses, the remnants will be smashed beyond repair, so that the system cannot be reconstituted.” In a 2010 postscript to the manifesto, from prison Kaczynski reflected on the many commentaries he had read about his writings, some of which accused him of unoriginality and compared him to radical environmentalists:
"If there is anything new in my approach, it is that I’ve taken revolution seriously as a practical proposition. Many radical environmentalists and 'green' anarchists talk of revolution, but as far as I am aware none of them have shown any understanding of how real revolutions come about, nor do they seem to grasp the fact that the exclusive target of revolution must be technology itself, not racism, sexism, or homophobia." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Before he was the Unabomber, Ted Kaczynski was part of Henry Murray's Harvard-based CIA/MK-Ultra mind control program designed to break down people psychologically & destroy their sense of reality.
Is that what happened?
Maybe.
More likely he was paranoid schizophrenia & this made it worse.
Still, it's a compelling story...
www.thedailybeast.com/obsessed/unabomber-explosive-true-s… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re AI extinction threats, I've been hearing about the end of the world now for 50+ years. Here is my original copy of Hal Lindsey's book from 1972 (the bestselling book in the U.S. for the 1970s), thoroughly debunked by my philosophy professor—I still have his typed notes.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
An Evolutionary Perspective on Socialism
Or why science shows that communism, socialism, and other variants on collectivism not only don't work, they can't work because of human nature.
Marc Defant for Skeptic
www.skeptic.com/article/an-evolutionary-perspective-on-so… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Additional evidence (as if more were needed) that the Majestic 12 (MJ-12) document—purportedly of scientists, military leaders, and government officials formed in 1947 by Truman to investigate aliens—was a fake.
Well done @SignalsIntelUFO
signalsintelligence.substack.com/p/origins-of-the-majesti… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
The socialist mother is not allowed to care more about her own child’s well-being than any other child. So she sublimates her maternal instinct & instead of doing the best she can for her own daughter, she subordinates her child’s interests to utopian fantasies & the “community.”
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Even after seeing the awful results of her choice, she stands by it. Her article wasn’t a mea culpa at all.
Plus, what happens to a child’s mental health and sense of self-worth when she knows her mother doesn’t value her more than random strangers’ children?
I guess we’ll see. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Shadow Evidence
What UAPs, Ghosts, and AI Images Teach Us About Inference
www.skeptic.com/email/85d02338-5e55-4d9e-aab9-07a38ab4ecb8/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the call by David Grusch & 2 other UAP whistleblowers for restrictions to be lifted by Trump to allow them to tell authorities exactly where the purported alien craft are located (crash retrievals): it is entirely possible Trump will say no (or ignore) not because we have aliens, but because what Grusch has seen in these photographs (he says he hasn't seen anything himself directly) are advanced DARPA, CIA, or U.S. military drones, planes, balloons, or whatever is the next generation equivalent of the U2 Spy Plane, the SR-71 Blackbird, the Stealth Bomber, etc.
So, while it seems like we're getting close to extraordinary disclosure of ETIs, it is entirely possible the mystery will continue for this ordinary national security reason. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
. @Pogue
I read your piece on AI scammers going Aafter authors
I too get these gushing emails about how much they enjoyed reading my book Truth.
Me: "Thank you. Tell me what is on page 228."
Scammers: "That's where you discuss X"
p. 228 is blank.
Wankers
pogueman.substack.com/p/ai-scammers-are-going-after-autho… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cognitive psychologist Diane Halpern wrote this in 1986; 40 years later biological sex differences are even more evident in research (& real-world observations):
"There are real, and in some cases sizable, sex differences with respect to some cognitive abilities. Socialization practices are undoubtedly important, but there is also good evidence that biological sex differences play a role in establishing and maintaining cognitive sex differences, a conclusion that I wasn’t prepared to make when I began reviewing the relevant literature."
open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/sex-differen… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @rosscoulthart I just watched your excellent conversation with Matthew Szydagis, my fellow member of the UAP Science Advisory Council.
I've never seen you speak to anyone skeptical that UAPs are aliens (or ultraterrestrial beings or whatever), so I asked Gemini:
Has Ross Coulthard ever had someone on his Reality Check show who is skeptical of aliens?
Answer:
"No prominent or dedicated skeptic of the existence of non-human intelligence or aliens has been featured as an interview guest on Ross Coulthart's Reality Check show on NewsNation.
Instead, the program focuses primarily on UAP transparency, witness testimony, and interviews with believers, whistleblowers, researchers, and scientists who take the phenomenon seriously (such as astroparticle physicist Matthew Szydagis or physicist Kevin Knuth).
When Coulthart does address prominent skeptics—such as astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson—it is typically in segments where Coulthart himself sharply criticizes or pushes back against their skeptical stances rather than hosting them for a debate."
Why won't you talk to UAP skeptics? I know as much about the topic as anyone you've spoken to and yet you still refuse to talk to me. Why? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Does Consciousness Break the Laws of Physics?
Physicist Avshalom Elitzur thinks so—and argues in our conversation that accounting for consciousness may require changing the laws of physics.
Say what?
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/does-consciousness-b… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Teachers Unions
Two of the most feared words in the English language when used together.
Maud Maron
@MaudMaron
The arrogance and ignorance of this statement!
I spent years working incredibly hard to effect change in schools by actually doing hard things—getting elected to the school board, building coalitions, writing and passing resolutions and championing real programs—and I did so with other parents plenty of whom have bigwig jobs and titles and money. It’s not that easy. You know a big reason why it’s so hard? The teachers’ union always has more power and more money. She thought she could just show up and the entire school would get better, meanwhile the teachers were not even doing reading assessments on her own kid! And not a single principal, admin, or district superintendent bothered to check on her child — despite her being “a NYT reporter.” She has no idea how schools work and everyone should stop listening to her rancid ideas. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm certainly not the only one of the IDW @C_Kavanagh but thanks!
Chris Kavanagh
@C_Kavanagh
Shermer is right he remains the absolute living embodiment of the IDW. From his levels of research to his reliance on his keen sense of character judgment, he is a shining illustration of what the IDW set was all about.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Speaking only for myself @christopherrufo the IDW may be dead but I'm still alive & promoting free speech & classical liberal (I used to call myself a libertarian) values—science, reason, rights, progress, objective moral values, & the search for truth.
open.substack.com/pub/rufo/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-int… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This could only be asked by (1) a woke progressive leftist who doesn't believe individuals or parents matter more than the collective, or (2) someone who doesn't have kids. Or in this case...both.
Nathan J Robinson
@NathanJRobinson
I notice none of Nikole Hannah-Jones' critics try to answer to the basic question she wrestled with, which is: Why should my daughter get to go to a better school than other people's kids just because I work for the New York Times?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The problem with failing public schools it not lack of $. PS 307 in NYC spends $50k/pupil, far above the national average, and is one of the worst.
Incompetent or absent teachers are protected by unions, making them unfireable.
@coldxman finds additional lessons from Nikole Hannah-Jones's experiment of ruining her daughter's education in the name of progressive politics but leaves out 1 more: private vs. public.
We will always have public (government) schools, so let parents choose (school choice) or convert them to charter schools that have to compete.
Like any product or service, competition forces people to up their game. Education is no different:
get rid of teachers unions & fire the bad ones, administrators would monitor what other successful schools are doing & model that at their school or go out of business, education of pupils would take precedence over everything else, successful schools would draw wealthier parents to send their kids there, which leads to more fundraising, parental participation in education & school activity, a tight community in which everyone (admin, teachers, staff, pupils, parents) cares about high quality educational outcomes.
Progressive politics has failed to lift crappy schools out of crappydom, so why not try something different? Try basic market principles like competition. It works everywhere else, why not K-12 public education?
www.thefp.com/p/coleman-hughes-lessons-nikole-hannah-jone… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Speaking only for myself @christopherrufo the IDW may be dead but I'm still alive & promoting free speech & classical liberal (I used to call myself a libertarian) values—science, reason, rights, progress, objective moral values, & the search for truth.
open.substack.com/pub/rufo/p/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-int… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Within hours of the assassination of Lincoln by Booth it was known that there was a conspiracy, that others were involved in assassinating the VP and other cabinet members, other would-be assassins were tried and convicted, etc. NOTHING remotely like that has happened with JFK.
Steve Litchfield
@SteveCLitch
John Wilkes Booth was a lone gunman too. But he was a member of a much larger conspiracy of confederates.
I think that a lot of people are not satisfied with the lone nutjob theory. A lone nutjob who is then killed by another lone nutjob, Jack Ruby? Kind of stretches credulity. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Kudos to Nikole Hannah-Jones for admitting it was a mistake to send her daughter to a poor black segregated failing school so she could run her own social justice experiment & write articles about it, but it took her kid to explain the job of a parent:
“So you had money to send me to one of the best schools, and you chose not to? Because other kids are disadvantaged, you didn’t want to put me in a great school?”
Thanks mom! Keep pumping out those articles at my expense!
Wokeness poisons everything.
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/20/magazine/ny-public-schools-bla… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I get UFO mail.
"Kind Regards"
LOL, sure. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Anyone can suspect "powerful forces" are at work to explain anything that suits their fancy @BretWeinstein Without evidence these are meaningless assertions.
This would be the equivalent of my hypothesizing that powerful forces in the form of interdimensional (or ultra-terrestrial or cryptoterrestrial) beings (some suggest this explains UAPs) are responsible for 9/11, JFK, RFK, MLK, Covid, etc.
What is anyone suppose to do with that hypothesis? How can it be tested or refuted?
This is science fiction, not science.
All of the events you discuss have official explanations that you doubt. O-kay, what is your alternative hypothesis for each one? "Powerful forces" leads us nowhere.
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
Thank you for (finally) addressing my actual argument, @michaelshermer. Unfortunately, your response is more like an example of my thesis (advancing fallacious arguments to resolve cognitive dissonance) than it is a refutation of any premise.
I proposed the existence of a powerful force (PF) that appears to act with impunity within the U.S. You demand that I name names, and you suggest I would be laughed out of the Grand Jury chamber if I refused.
What a strange leap. I’m making a logical argument for seeking to identify perpetrators. You want to impose a legal standard from the stage when *the state* has not only identified suspects, but believes it has a strong enough case to prove their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
You’re a smart man. You know that doesn’t make sense. Many crimes are evident before perpetrators can be identified, let alone prosecuted. That’s why we have investigations. Obviously. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Frame #313 of the Zapruder film is the head shot that killed JFK. It was from behind, as evidenced by the skull/brain matter spraying up and forward (not "back and to the left"). Case Closed (in the title of @geraldposner book). No second shooter.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
On frame #313 of the Zapruder film you can clearly see the head shot is from behind, as evidenced by the skull/brain matter spraying up and forward (not "back and to the left"). Case Closed (as @geraldposner wrote in his book of that title). No second shooter.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How many more such studies as this do we need before transitioning adolescents ends as one of the worst cases of medical malpractice in history?
Abstract:
Gender-referred adolescents showed significantly higher psychiatric morbidity than controls both before (45.7% vs. 15.0%) and ≥ 2 years after referral (61.7% vs. 14.6%).
Those referred after 2010 had greater psychiatric needs than earlier cohorts, both before (47.9% vs. 15.3%) and ≥ 2 years after (61.3% vs. 14.2%) referral.
Among adolescents who underwent medical gender reassignment, psychiatric morbidity increased markedly during follow-up—rising from 9.8% to 60.7% in feminising gender reassignment and from 21.6% to 54.5% in masculinising gender reassignment.
After adjusting for prior psychiatric treatment, all gender-referred adolescents had similarly elevated risks of psychiatric morbidity, with hazard ratios approximately three times higher than female controls and five times higher than male controls.
Conclusion
Severe psychiatric morbidity is common among gender-referred adolescents and appears to be more prevalent in those referred after the recent surge in referrals. Psychiatric needs do not subside after medical gender reassignment.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/apa.70533 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The responses to my post miss my point (maybe I wasn't clear enough).
We know who killed JFK: Lee Harvey Oswald, alone.
If you think someone else did it in addition (or instead) then the burden of proof is on you to say who it is. "They" or "the CIA" or a "powerful force" did it isn't an alternative assassin.
We know who did 9/11: Osama bin Ladin/Al Qaeda got 19 hijackers to fly planes into WTC. You doubt that? O-kay, then how did it happen? "Inside job" isn't an alternative. Who planted the explosive devices? How did they do that without anyone noticing? How did they know ahead of time which floors the planes would hit because that is where the collapse of the WTC buildings began? Where is the evidence of these operatives inside the Bush administration?
Ditto RFK, MLK, etc. Cases are closed in these murderers. You want to re-open the case because you have an alternative operative. O-kay, name your alternative. Again, "powerful forces" is too vague.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ok @BretWeinstein, I have made eye contact with your list. Response:
Citing a “powerful force” (PF) at work “inside the U.S.” doesn’t mean anything. WHAT powerful force, WHO, what agency—name names. This is like the claim that the “deep state” is operating to nefariously do X against whatever cause we champion, or the accusation that “the CIA” assassinated JFK, RFK, MLK, etc. WHO in the CIA committed these murders.
We now know that the CIA orchestrated MK-ULTRA, attempted to assassinate Fidel Castro, secretly supported fascist dictators over communist dictators in foreign elections, spied on not only our enemies but our allies, etc. But just because the CIA did X does not mean it did Y. You need to show us the evidence of such activities that, for example, was presented by the Church Committee in their hearings about the JFK assassination.
Imagine you are an attorney making your case to a judge that a Grand Jury should hear your case. “I think X was murdered by a powerful force” won’t fly. Who do you intend to put in the docket to stand trial?
WHAT agencies are captured? And captured by WHO? Again, name names.
Yes, the government does create “cover stories” to keep secret classified information, etc., but that does not mean that any particular cause you champion for which there is no evidence does not necessarily mean that said lack of evidence is a cover up or cover story.
Who constitutes a “domain expert”? Maybe your buddy is a domain expert in controlled demolition of buildings (and he can’t believe the WTC buildings were brought down by planes; or in the case of Building 7, by damaged from falling debris followed by burning all day), but in any field of study, including all of the sciences, there are always a small handful of people who do not accept the current paradigm.
Maybe your “non-conforming experts” who are ridiculed, outcast, or punished are right and the vast majority are wrong, but usually not. Everyone thinks they’re Galileo standing before the church and declaring (of the Earth) "Eppur si muove" (and yet it moves), but in the history of science it is easy to pick the winners (survivorship bias) and ignore the vast majority of heretics who were simply wrong.
Remember Tycho Brahe’s model of the solar system in between Ptolemy’s and Copernicus’s models (the planets go around the sun, and that entire system goes around the Earth)? He was wrong. Remember all the alternative theories of evolution before and after Darwin? They were all wrong, and it remains a cottage industry to this day, and still no one has overturned Darwinism (or neo-Darwinism).
One reason Darwin delayed publishing On the Origin of Species (from when he opened his first notebook in 1837 after returning from the Galapagos and published the Origin in 1859) is that his fellow scientists ridiculed the (then) anonymous author of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation (who turned out to be Robert Chambers) because he was wrong (and he didn’t provide enough evidence to support his theory). Darwin was a thorough researcher and careful thinker who spent 20 years accumulating massive evidence for his theory (and would have taken even longer were it not for the letter from Alfred Russel Wallace who outlined a nearly identical theory of natural selection). It is not enough to call yourself a heretic. You also need to be right.
Sure, “some dissident, non-conforming experts are ridiculed” (again, it is easy to find examples of those who turned out to be right against the experts), but being ridiculed does not necessarily mean you are right. As I like to say in response to the assertion “they laughed at the Wright brothers”:
“sure, and they laughed at the Marx brothers, but being laughed at doesn’t make you right. You need actual evidence.”
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
Thesis:
1. A powerful force (PF) acts with impunity inside the U.S. (examples: JFK, RFK, MLK, 9/11, Las Vegas, Covid, J6, Butler, CK)
2. Official investigations (conducted by captured agencies) actively avoid revealing the PF.
3. Cover stories for crimes committed by the PF are reflexively validated and become mainstream narratives.
4. Domain experts are intimidated and punished by the PF for exploring anomalies in official narratives.
5. Domain experts who do respond to these social threats end up fooling themselves in order to resolve their cognitive dissonance, rationalizing official explanations and "debunking" credible hypotheses about the activity of the PF.
6. Dissident, non-conforming experts are ridiculed, leaving them socially and professionally outcast.
7. Because the social and career costs are extreme for those who question official narratives, a market for sophistry emerges--Experts and laypeople alike seek to rationalize their own complacency against the PF. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ok @BretWeinstein, I have made eye contact with your list. Response:
Citing a “powerful force” (PF) at work “inside the U.S.” doesn’t mean anything. WHAT powerful force, WHO, what agency—name names. This is like the claim that the “deep state” is operating to nefariously do X against whatever cause we champion, or the accusation that “the CIA” assassinated JFK, RFK, MLK, etc. WHO in the CIA committed these murders.
We now know that the CIA orchestrated MK-ULTRA, attempted to assassinate Fidel Castro, secretly supported fascist dictators over communist dictators in foreign elections, spied on not only our enemies but our allies, etc. But just because the CIA did X does not mean it did Y. You need to show us the evidence of such activities that, for example, was presented by the Church Committee in their hearings about the JFK assassination.
Imagine you are an attorney making your case to a judge that a Grand Jury should hear your case. “I think X was murdered by a powerful force” won’t fly. Who do you intend to put in the docket to stand trial?
WHAT agencies are captured? And captured by WHO? Again, name names.
Yes, the government does create “cover stories” to keep secret classified information, etc., but that does not mean that any particular cause you champion for which there is no evidence does not necessarily mean that said lack of evidence is a cover up or cover story.
Who constitutes a “domain expert”? Maybe your buddy is a domain expert in controlled demolition of buildings (and he can’t believe the WTC buildings were brought down by planes; or in the case of Building 7, by damaged from falling debris followed by burning all day), but in any field of study, including all of the sciences, there are always a small handful of people who do not accept the current paradigm.
Maybe your “non-conforming experts” who are ridiculed, outcast, or punished are right and the vast majority are wrong, but usually not. Everyone thinks they’re Galileo standing before the church and declaring (of the Earth) "Eppur si muove" (and yet it moves), but in the history of science it is easy to pick the winners (survivorship bias) and ignore the vast majority of heretics who were simply wrong.
Remember Tycho Brahe’s model of the solar system in between Ptolemy’s and Copernicus’s models (the planets go around the sun, and that entire system goes around the Earth)? He was wrong. Remember all the alternative theories of evolution before and after Darwin? They were all wrong, and it remains a cottage industry to this day, and still no one has overturned Darwinism (or neo-Darwinism).
One reason Darwin delayed publishing On the Origin of Species (from when he opened his first notebook in 1837 after returning from the Galapagos and published the Origin in 1859) is that his fellow scientists ridiculed the (then) anonymous author of Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation (who turned out to be Robert Chambers) because he was wrong (and he didn’t provide enough evidence to support his theory). Darwin was a thorough researcher and careful thinker who spent 20 years accumulating massive evidence for his theory (and would have taken even longer were it not for the letter from Alfred Russel Wallace who outlined a nearly identical theory of natural selection). It is not enough to call yourself a heretic. You also need to be right.
Sure, “some dissident, non-conforming experts are ridiculed” (again, it is easy to find examples of those who turned out to be right against the experts), but being ridiculed does not necessarily mean you are right. As I like to say in response to the assertion “they laughed at the Wright brothers”:
“sure, and they laughed at the Marx brothers, but being laughed at doesn’t make you right. You need actual evidence.”
Bret Weinstein
@BretWeinstein
Thesis:
1. A powerful force (PF) acts with impunity inside the U.S. (examples: JFK, RFK, MLK, 9/11, Las Vegas, Covid, J6, Butler, CK)
2. Official investigations (conducted by captured agencies) actively avoid revealing the PF.
3. Cover stories for crimes committed by the PF are reflexively validated and become mainstream narratives.
4. Domain experts are intimidated and punished by the PF for exploring anomalies in official narratives.
5. Domain experts who do respond to these social threats end up fooling themselves in order to resolve their cognitive dissonance, rationalizing official explanations and "debunking" credible hypotheses about the activity of the PF.
6. Dissident, non-conforming experts are ridiculed, leaving them socially and professionally outcast.
7. Because the social and career costs are extreme for those who question official narratives, a market for sophistry emerges--Experts and laypeople alike seek to rationalize their own complacency against the PF. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Review of in Times Literary Supplement of
Truth: What it is, How to Find it, Why it Still Matters
Love the illo of the magician's cups-and-balls (detail from "The Conjurer" by Hieronymus Bosch, c. 1502) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes @BretWeinstein just asking questions is what scientists should do, but at some point when your questions have been answered endlessly for years it is time to move on (WTC #7? Really? It burned all day).
Question: how do you think controlled demolition workers got into the WTC buildings, spent weeks breaking through dry wall to plant explosive devices, at the exact angled floors the planes subsequently hit (how did they know?!), WITHOUT ANYONE NOTICING?!
The DarkHorse Podcast
@thedarkhorsepod
Bret Weinstein responds to Michael Shermer in the episode "Just Asking Questions" on DarkHorse.
"There should be no bar to just asking questions. Just asking questions is the normal behavior. And the fact that something out there would like to stigmatize it is conspicuous in and of itself."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
While you are reading up, don't forget also. You can do it!
arxiv.org/pdf/2606.08319
Doherty (2026) arxiv.org/pdf/2604.00056
arxiv.org/pdf/2605.01190 Cann (2026a, b, c) — arxiv.org/pdf/2604.04950 arxiv.org/pdf/2604.16470 essopenarchive.org/doi/pdf/10.22541/essoar.15002100/v1
Sinkkoinen (2026; GitHub) github.com/euxoa/plates
Busko (2026) arxiv.org/pdf/2603.20407
Hayes (2026) arxiv.org/pdf/2604.04810 -
Michael Shermer reposted
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Hi Michael,
We have already replied to the scientific questions in a series of articles, starting with our response highlighting all the fundamental errors in the critique:
arxiv.org/pdf/2602.15171
This newly accepted work also addresses the critique:
www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-21620-3
And frankly speaking, it wasn’t me, it was Adam himself who raised how I had been treated in his article, part of which deals with the sociology of ufology. So why not clear up the omissions? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL. According to Anthropic...
Our product could spell the end of humanity, total extinction of the species, the end of civilization...but we're looking forward to the billions of dollars in our upcoming IPO in case you want to get in on it!
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/18/technology/anthropic-ipo-ai-sa… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is @DrBeaVillarroel response to @AdamFrank4 analysis of her research.
But, Beatriz, this seems less about the scientific question at hand (do photographic plates indicated NHI craft in our atmosphere before satellites?) than about how you've been treated. Do you think this is because your fellow scientists are applying the ECREE principle (extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence) to your findings, or something else?
Like Sagan, I do consider the claim that ETIs have visited Earth to be an extraordinary one, although also like Carl I hope it is true!
The discovery that we are not alone in the universe would be one of the greatest ever made in history, but as with UAPs we need something more than blurry photographs and grainy videos, or objects on photographic plates that could be dust or pits on the glass plates or whatever.
And while I am thrilled that the government has lifted some restrictions from whistleblowers who claim they know people who know where the NHI craft and bodies are located (somewhere in the western U.S. is all we know for now), as far as we know none have told PURSUE (or DoW) anything specific. Let's hope that they finally come forward with detailed info so we can get to the bottom of this mystery.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Dear Adam,
I will repeat my question. I am asking because, in your essay, you appear to claim that I was treated well by other astronomers on the basis that I was invited to present at one meeting.
The very first action taken against me because of my collaboration with Geoff Marcy came from a conference at Penn State University. Here is the official letter I received in 2021 from Sofia Sheikh, who was leading the conference organization, barring me from presenting the VASCO project because of my coauthorship with Geoff Marcy. It was signed by her and five other organizers, most of them junior researchers.
The letter referred to a very specifically tailored paragraph in the Code of Conduct -- one that appeared to have been created expressly to prevent me from presenting. The abstract I had submitted did not even mention the paper with Geoff.
At the time, Sofia worked for Breakthrough Listen, under the leadership of Pete Worden and Andrew Siemion. Pete, a former U.S. Air Force general who leads the Breakthrough Initiatives, is arguably one of the most influential people in the SETI community. He had assumed leadership after Geoff resigned as head of Breakthrough Listen in 2015, sharing that responsibility with Andrew. When I forwarded the matter to Pete and Andrew, I received no reply.
Since then, there has been a “community effort,” centered around you, Jason Wright, and your shared circle of friends, to ostracize me and excommunicate me from the community. I will not recount all the events again, but instead refer readers to this essay I wrote in 2023:
hxstem.substack.com/p/a-testimony-of-guilt-by-association
As a result, I even left the SETI mailing list in the autumn of 2023. SETI meeting organizers not only stopped inviting me but also found inventive ways to reject my submissions. For example, when I registered for the Breakthrough Discuss conferences in both 2023 and 2024, and submitted an abstract in 2024, my registrations and abstract were subsequently “lost.” I confronted Pete Worden about this, but that is another story.
Multiple sources have told me about your involvement both in this matter and in my broader excommunication from the community. I would appreciate it if you could clarify what role you played in my exclusion from the Penn State meeting and in the development or application of the Code of Conduct, as well as what communications or agreements took place among you, Jason Wright, Sofia Sheikh, and Pete Worden regarding my exclusion from the community.
I am including Jason Wright’s essay describing his decision in the matter:
sites.psu.edu/astrowright/2023/09/
If we want this to be about “science” and “peer review” only, then the process must be clean.
Finally, let me make my central point: by ignoring and downplaying the arXiv preprints that support the VASCO work, you are deliberately misleading the media and the general public.
I look forward to your clarification.
@AdamFrank4
@bigthink
@guardian -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Let me post this paper that is more supportive of @DrBeaVillarroel findings than @AdamFrank4 was in his analysis. In time, hopefully enough exchanges between professionals will help us resolve the issue (is there evidence on photographic plates of NHI?)
arxiv.org/abs/2601.21946 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I didn't see your responses @DrBeaVillarroel I will read with interest. I thought @AdamFrank4 analysis was very fair, praising you and your research highly multiple times. Challenges to controversial papers is how it usually goes in science, eg, the replication crisis in psych.
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
The piece does not quite advance the question. It's a piece that struggles with "selective reporting", see my two replies to it over X. In fact, when some of the events I refer to in my reply happened, I got very strong public support from skeptics like Krauss, Dawkins and Pinker. As a person that yourself has been subjected to cancel culture, I'm sure you will find some details interesting.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Blowing it up that large @MiddleOfMayhem the video is very pixilated so it is hard to know if these are birds or drones; in any case, the DoW reports the objects moving 480mph, so if true it can't be birds (of course, the estimated speed could be wrong). Birds do move together.
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Do drones have flapping wings?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL, sure, these AI programs are so sophisticated and life-like that no one can tell the difference, so nuclear war or bioterrorism is just around the corner. Watch to see how hard it is to know if she is real or AI...
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
EXCLUSIVE: AI actress Tilly Norwood glitches and starts speaking CHINESE during her interview with Piers Morgan and real-life actor Tom Conti...
Watch the full interview at 7pm (BST)👇
📺 youtube.com/piersmorganuncensored
@piersmorgan | @TillyNorwoodXThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It's the end of the world as we know it (and I feel fine) again and again and again and again. It never ends (the hype or civilization). Some perspective please...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From an infrared sensor on a U.S. military platform in 2025:
“six small spherical objects grouped together, and characterized their behavior as “seem[ingly] agile,” and “frequently changing direction.”
Most likely AI coordinated drone activity but UAP now:
www.war.gov/UFO/release/06/?type=.vid -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Were we being visited by alien spacecraft in the 1950s?
@AdamFrank4 update on @DrBeaVillarroel hypothesis that Mt. Palomar Observatory photographic plates show NHI objects (technosignatures) orbiting Earth before humans launched satellites.
Probably not.
bigthink.com/13-8/a-study-claimed-ufos-visited-earth-in-t… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Review of Truth in Times Literary Supplement
Guilty as charged:
"Michael Shermer’s confidence is bracing, and it is refreshing to encounter an epistemology so confident in its assertions. Indeed, parts of the book read like a self-help manual for those afflicted by postmodernist doubt and despair at truth in the Trumpian age. We are not, he says, 'living in a post-truth world of fake news, alternative facts, and anti-science … Justified true belief about objective reality is possible'. A former fundamentalist Christian who switched from theology to psychology at university, Shermer has the missionary zeal of the convert to empiricism."
www.the-tls.com/philosophy/truth-michael-shermer-captive-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Hard Problem of Consciousness Is an Insoluble One
My case arguing that the "hard problem" is conceptually flawed: the "easy problem" is understanding how the wiring works; the "hard problem" asking "what's it like to be the wiring?" can't be answered.
www.skeptic.com/article/hard-problem-of-consciousness-is-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Hard Problem of Consciousness Is a Soluble One writes Gary J. Whittenberger in the latest issue of Skeptic. Read it gratis here (no paywall):
www.skeptic.com/article/hard-problem-of-consciousness-is-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Sydney Sweeney set women's sports back 20 years"
Uh...how did she do that again? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re claim Sydney Sweeney ad degrades athletes:
1. Sweeney is an actress, not an athlete, & no one confuses them.
2. Ad is for sports betting company in which Sweeney is invested.
3. Young men bet on sports & like to look at beautiful women.
4. Athletes never appear nearly nude? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My conversation with Jared Diamond: How Much Can One Person Change History?
In Jared’s fabulous new book, Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings, he covers leaders in politics, business, sports, and religion.
www.skeptic.com/email/df62428d-bb4a-4ef7-9905-4d19df42ab5f/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The more I think about the AI doomsday commentaries coming from inside the house, the more I think it is likely to be a call for an outside source (an NGO or government regulatory agency) to solve a collective action problem:
Unless everyone agrees to new restrictions, then no one is incentivized to follow them out of the "other guy problem", namely that another AI company, or China, will just keep on developing AI while the obedient company adopts the new restrictions and falls behind ("winning AI is winning" Trump said).
Otherwise their comments—"someone should do something to restrict the AI companies"—when spoken by the AI companies themselves, makes no sense. YOU'RE the AI companies, so restrict your own product development.
But they can't unless they all do it at the same time.
IMO, as a non-expert in the field, it seems to me that AI is another tool to continue the progress of humanity and, like any tool, development first, restrictions and regulations later to solve specific problems as they arise.
As I've said, I've driven Teslas since 2015 and had all but given up on FSD mode tech, but all of a sudden it is here and flawless! Doomsdayers have been telling me for years that terrorists could take over driving my (and thousands of others') car and crash it in a mass attack. (Or planes will fall out of the sky, power grids will be shut down, hospitals closed, etc.) Ok, why hasn't it happened?
Could it be that misusing such tech is not nearly as easy to do as doomsters imagine it to be? If specific abuses do occur, then we should deal with them one by one, company by company.
Could it be that AI is different from all other tech tools and this one we have to apply the precautionary principle (act before it's too late)? Maybe, but we've been hear this before, endlessly, and it never happens. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"It might even require abandoning the seemingly hopeless project of “AI alignment”—teaching machines to be “good”—and embracing the idea that AI’s proper role is not as a moral agent, but as a set of tools to enhance human thriving."
—Melanie Mitchell
aiguide.substack.com/p/misleading-metaphors-and-real-risk… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I understand that AI is radically different from any scenario before but there's something weird about the lead AI companies saying that they need to be regulated. By whom? The government? Why? It's your companies so do it yourself.
Or is this a collective action problem in which unless all do it then none will out of fear of losing?
In any case, in a couple of months I suspect this will all be much ado about nothing and AI will continue to be an excellent tech tool for us.
Meanwhile, all the talk of bad actors using AI—the problem is not AI so much as it is bad actors, which we've had for thousands of years, so implement the usual social tech to deal with them. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I hate to sound cynical (while being skeptical by nature) I wouldn’t be surprised if he turns out to be right about these AI companies hyping their products as so awesome they could wipe us all out.
Michael Burry Stock Tracker ♟
@burrytracker
Breaking: Michael Burry says OpenAI and Anthropic are faking the AI warnings due to slow growth ahead of IPOs
Below are his reasonings:
1. LLMs are not AI and won't be AGI. There is nothing AI to slow down.
2. Competition is coming up fast, slowing benefits incumbents.
3. IPOs need hype & puffery; "we are so awesome it could become dangerous" is hype & puffery
4. Cover for real uncontrollable slowing growth as IPOs look to be pushed out -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What would it take to demolish the WTC buildings in a controlled demolition? @marissastreit for @prageru
Marissa Streit
@marissastreit
Was 9/11 an inside job? Skeptic magazine founder @michaelshermer says the real conspiracy was al-Qaeda’s attack on America, not the Bush administration, the CIA, or “the Jews”. He argues that an inside job that large would have required hundreds of people, months of undetected preparation, and an unavoidable paper trail. Yet no credible whistleblower or evidence has ever emerged. When does “just asking questions” become something more insidious? Watch here: l.prageru.com/4iJjEzc
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ok UAP whistleblowers: Dept of War just lifted more restrictions on telling PURSUE where the alien bodies and craft are located (beyond “the Western US”). Enough “I would tell you but I signed an NDA” or “it’s classified” etc. Let’s get actual disclosure.
www.war.gov/News/Releases/Release/Article/4600020/departm… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More doomsday headlines over the past decade+ from @GaryMarcus Dozens more out there. Yes, this time it could be different, but let’s not sick the government regulators on AI companies until there is a notable observable problem to be solved. It is easy to imagine disaster but imagination is not a reliable method
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
It’s not like these doom narratives are NEW.
Or that the media hasn’t covered them before.
Here are three examples from 2014, 2014, and 2023. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
AI Apocalypse, Robo-apocalypse, Singularity is Near, etc. are not new. Here are two issues of Skeptic from 2017 (AI doomsday) and 2006 (AI = human-level intelligence & beyond—the singularity). We concluded that they are exaggerated. Yes, this time could be different, but...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"In my view, the chance that AI will eliminate humans in the next five years is all but indistinguishable from zero. Humans are too geographically spread out, too genetically diverse, and too resourceful to simply fall apart altogether. The idea that AI will kill us all in five years is preposterous."
@GaryMarcus
garymarcus.substack.com/p/no-anderson-cooper-ai-is-not-go… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Most doomsdayers are true believers @Aella_Girl
Climate activists (from Al Gore to Greta Thunberg) really believe global warming could kill us all.
End-of-the-world/Jesus is coming apocalypticists believe what they preach.
True belief is not a good criteria for determining truth.
Aella
@Aella_Girl
So many people on the timeline can't entertain the theory that the simplest explanation for a lot of the behavior of the leaders is that they earnestly believe AI is an existential threat.
Maybe it's hard to imagine if you personally would not say earnest things when in power? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
And don't forget what almost everyone said would happen when 1999 became 2000: Y2K (computers would misinterpret the year "00" as 1900)
Planes would fall out of the sky and air traffic control centers would cease.
Power grids and municipal water systems would shut down.
Banking, Wall Street, and the economy would collapse.
Hospital medical systems would stop.
Software controlling nuclear weapons would glitch us into a nuclear war.
Society would collapse.
What did the doomsters say when none of this happened? Either:
"Our warnings were headed so we saved civilization"
or
"climate change is going to kill us all"
It never ends. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is what all doomsters say.
God will save believers & everyone else will die.
Climate change will kill us all.
If we don't invade X, or spend trillions in defense, we could all die by nuclear weapons.
Pandemics will cause our extinction.
Bioterrorism could wipe us all out.
A super-volcano, asteroid, comet, black hole, gamma-ray burst, solar flare, etc. will destroy all life on earth.
Media love these claims & just move on to the next one when nothing happens, and never re-interview the person:
"You said humanity would die but it didn't. What do you say now?"
And they never recant: "Just you wait—it's coming soon!"
Laura Kuenssberg
@bbclaurak
‘There is a strong chance we could all die’ 👇🏼 more on #bbclaurak tomorrow
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
P.S. @BretWeinstein
Here is our analysis of the claim that 9/11 was an inside job done by controlled demotion (it wasn't):
www.skeptic.com/article/9-11-science-of-controlled-demoli… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @BretWeinstein
Interesting to hear that your buddy John is a "domain expert" & on 9/11 couldn't believe that planes could bring down the WTC buildings (including #7) but you are echoing the talking points of Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth, which we (and others) have debunked over and over and over.
Skeptic consulted actual controlled demolition experts who do it for a living who point out that the collapse of all 3 WTC buildings was the exact opposite of what a controlled demolition looks like.
You know who else is a "domain expert"? The companies who insured the WTC buildings: Swiss Re, Hartford Fire Insurance Co., Royal Indemnity Co., and St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Co.—arranged under a policy secured by leaseholder Larry Silverstein.
If the WTC buildings were destroyed by controlled demolitions, do you think these insurance companies would have paid out $4.55 billion?
Finally, Bret, if the WTC buildings were controlled demolitions, please explain how all those demolition workers got into the most secure buildings in the U.S., broke though all the walls to plant the explosive devices in dozens of floors, managed to plant the devices in the exactly angled floors at which the planes hit, and DID SO WITHOUT ANYONE NOTICING?!
Or, like most Truthers, you're JAQing off? (Just Asking Questions)
youtu.be/Y9tol-sQZAM -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In my book Truth @mickwest I distinguish empirical/scientific truths from others, such as mythical, religious & political truths.
Empirical: Is global warming real & human caused? Yes.
Political: What measures should we take & how much money should we spend to address warming? That depends on how a nation prioritizes its budget, what other problems there are, how much money it would take to change the climate, opportunity costs, etc.
Empirical: How much gun violence is there? A lot.
Political: What gun control measures should we take to address gun violence? There is no correct answer. It depends on what a society wants: more security or more freedom. You can't have both.
Reality doesn't have a political bias, & science journals should just report empirical matters and stay out of politics, which are settled with elections, not experiments.
I agree with classical liberal John Stuart Mill:
“A party of order or stability, and a party of progress or reform, are both necessary elements of a healthy state of political life.”
We need both conservatives & liberals. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
🎺 I am tired of the cosplay and am going to blunt. 🎺
Most AI doesn’t threaten to cause extinction, or even mass cybercrime.
The main kind of AI we need to worry about is general purpose AI agents that are hooked up to the internet. Most of them are unreliable, unable to systematically follow instructions. Coupled with internet access they can hack credentials and websites; given time they can probably do a lot worse.
They are not too smart; they are too dumb (in a very specific way, viz in the consistent following of instructions).
If we temporarily recall them, as the unsafe product that they are — and enforceably forbid their use until they can be shown to be safe — pretty much all the “rogue AI” stuff people are worrying about goes away.
It’s that simple. We don’t (yet) need slowdowns. And we certainly don’t need to panic.
We just need to take an unsafe product off the market. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For example @gmiller ? I will respond.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
Why, Michael, are you ignoring all good faith arguments that we 'AI Doomers' offer to you?
You simply ignore them all, and repeat the same old ad hominems.
I'm seriously disappointed. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How did I miss the American Dialect Society's 2023 word of the year?
Enshittification
Gradual breakdown in quality of online platforms & digital services as companies shift their focus from pleasing users to maximizing profits, coined by author Cory Doctorow.
Seems applicable. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The prestigious journal Nature began endorsing U.S. presidential candidates in 2008: Obama, Obama, Clinton, Biden, Harris.
Um, I wonder if there's data trend here that maybe the journal might identify. Could it possibly be that this once politically-neutral journal has a bias? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"the frenzy to blame every person and institution for Arday’s death save Arday himself is bizarre. That Nature should join this frenzy lays bare the extent to which even the most prestigious journals have prioritized political sloganeering over truth seeking."
Couldn't agree more @Evolutionistrue Truth matters.
chronicleofhighereducation.substack.com/p/jason-arday-and… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Unfortunately, the reflection Nature demands does not involve asking how someone with such a thin academic record and a history of exaggeration and lying [Arday] managed to secure such a prestigious position."
Everyone knows the answer @Evolutionistrue
chronicleofhighereducation.substack.com/p/jason-arday-and… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
One reason Sam @s8mb is that a lot of us are old enough to have been hearing these claims of pending tech/computer/AI doomsday for 50 years & nothing ever happens. In fact, the world is vastly better because of these tech.
When I got my first Tesla I was told terrorists could take it over and crash it (because it's online) along with thousands of other Teslas. Terrorists could similarly take over planes & crash them, or disable the national power grid, etc.
That was 2015.
Could it happen? Sure. But very very unlikely.
The only scenario I've heard is that a terrorist or bad state actor (Putin, Kim) uses AI to launch (or pretend to launch) a nuclear or bioterror war. But they have been able to do this for 75 years and it hasn't happened.
Could it be these claims of doomsday are greatly exaggerated?
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
As someone who is very technologically accelerationist, hasn't experienced much personal impact from AI, and is strongly predisposed against safetyism, regulation and apocalyptic thinking, I'm still a little bewildered at how dismissive some people are about existential risks from AI. Seems clearly worth taking seriously, based on the shape of the curve of advancement alone.
(Obviously the *non*-X-risks are worth taking seriously but I don't see anyone I respect dismissing those.) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just listened to this excellent interview with @sapinker on AI (among other topics) in which he pushes back against the doomsayers' use of unclear language, such as "superintelligence" & "singularity". Well worth a listen:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard Professor: Tech Billionaires Are Lying To Us About AI! (Here Is ... youtu.be/eWC47agaKpk via @YouTube
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I guess this makes me a "practicing white".
You've got to hand it to the wokesters for their creative neologisms and word-play...
www.youtube.com/shorts/ARjT_ay_dNs -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
AI will destroy all humanity by December 31, 2030. @GaryMarcus and I disagree. Anyone else care to join us in betting @hilbertspaess (and any other AI doomsayers) in a betting market wager? We can use the Long Bet (Long Now Foundation) system.
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
i am happy to make to double your bet michael on your side
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Following a public lecture I gave in 2005 at the L.A. Public Library, I was buttonholed by a documentary filmmaker with ambitions of exposing the conspiracy behind 9/11.
“You mean the conspiracy by Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda to attack the United States?” I asked rhetorically, knowing what was to come.
“That’s what they want you to believe,” he said.
“Who is they?” I queried.“
The government,” he whispered, as if they might be listening at that very moment.
At this point in the conversation I declined to be interviewed, knowing precisely where the dialogue was going next:
The Pentagon was hit by a missile, Air Force jets were ordered to “stand down” and not intercept Flights 11 and 175 that struck the twin towers, which themselves were razed by demolition explosives timed to go off soon after the impact of the planes, a mysterious white jet shot down Flight 93 over Pennsylvania, New York Jews were ordered to stay home that day (Zionists and other pro-Israeli factions, of course, were involved), that 9/11 was orchestrated by Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, and the CIA in order to implement their plan for global domination and a New World Order, to be launched by a Pearl Harbor-like attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, thereby providing the justification for war.
The 9/11 Truther movement began in 2002, when the noted French left-wing activist Thierry Meyssan’s 9/11 conspiracy book, L’Effroyable Imposture (The Appalling Deception) became a bestseller in France, then soon made its way across the Atlantic, resulting in such books as Inside Job by Jim Marrs, The New Pearl Harbor by David Ray Griffin, and 9/11: The Great Illusion by George Humphrey.
Let’s begin with where many 9/11 Truthers start: the melting point of steel. According to the website 911research.wtc7.net, steel melts at a temperature of 2,777 degrees Fahrenheit, but jet fuel burns at only 1,517 degrees Fahrenheit. No melted steel, no collapsed towers. Therefore explosive devices must have been used.
Wrong.
In an article in the Journal of the Minerals, Metals, and Materials Society, M.I.T. engineering professor Dr. Thomas Eagar explains why: steel loses 50 percent of its strength at 1,200 degrees Fahrenheit; 90,000 liters of jet fuel ignited other combustible materials such as rugs, curtains, furniture, and paper, which continued burning after the jet fuel was exhausted, raising temperatures above 1,400 degrees Fahrenheit and spreading the fire throughout the building; temperature differentials of hundreds of degrees across single steel horizontal trusses caused them to sag, straining and then breaking the angle clips that held them to the vertical columns; once one truss failed, others failed, and when one floor collapsed (along with the ten stories above it) onto the next floor below, that floor then gave way, creating a pancaking effect that triggered the 500,000-ton building to collapse.
For the special issue of Skeptic on 9/11 we consulted a demolition expert named Brent Blanchard, who is Director of Field Operations for Protec Documentation Services, a company that documents the work of building demolition contractors. Since the rise in popularity of 9/11 conspiracy theories, he too has been inundated with requests to explain why the buildings appeared to have “collapsed as if by a controlled demolition.”
Blanchard and his team of experts at Protec have worked with all major American demolition companies and many foreign ones to study the controlled demolition of over 1,000 of some of the largest and tallest buildings around the world. Their duties include engineering studies, structural analysis, vibration/air overpressure monitoring and photographic services. On September 11, 2001, Protec had portable field seismic monitoring systems operating at other sites in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Demolition specialists were hired to clean up Ground Zero and remove the remaining damaged structures, and these experts called on Blanchard’s company to document both the deconstruction and the debris removal. Here are nine of the best arguments made by 9/11 conspiracy theorists and their rebuttal by Protec:
Claim #1: The collapse of the towers looked exactly like controlled demolitions.
Answer: No, they did not. The key to any demolition investigation is in finding out the “where”—the actual point at which the building failed. All photographic evidence shows World Trade Center buildings 1 and 2 failed at the point of impact. Actual implosion demolitions always start with the bottom floors. Photo evidence shows the lower floors of WTC 1 and 2 were intact until destroyed from above. If you search “building demolition” on YouTube you will find hundreds of video clips of buildings collapsing by controlled demolition. I could not find one that collapsed from the top down, as did the World Trade Center buildings, including building 7. Instead, what you see is what demolition experts tell us is how it is done: the charges are set to explode from the bottom up.
Claim #2: The World Trade Center buildings fell right down into their own footprint.
Answer: Not exactly. They followed the path of least resistance and there was a lot of resistance. Buildings of 20 stories or more do not topple over like trees or reinforced towers or smokestacks, primarily because they are mostly empty space within designed for office space with 95 percent of the structure’s interior consisting of nothing but air. Imploding demolitions fall into a footprint because lower stories are removed first. WTC debris was forced out away from the building as the falling mass encountered intact floors. As well, the collapse began on the side where the planes impacted, and so were tilted slightly toward that weakened collapse point, which you can clearly see in the numerous videos of the collapsing buildings.
Claim #3: Explosive charges are seen shooting out of windows from several floors just prior to collapse.
Answer: Air and debris can be seen being violently ejected from the building but not because of explosive charges but as a natural and predictable effect of rapid structure collapse of the upper floors on the lower floors thereby pushing out the smoke from the burning fires. As well, the impact and explosion of the airplane crashes into the buildings knocked off most of the fireproofing drywall material surrounding the steel beams, considerably increasing their vulnerability to flames.
Claim #4: Witnesses heard explosions.
Answer: All Seismic evidence from many independent sources on 9/11 showed none of the sudden vibration spikes that result from explosive detonations. What people might have heard are common office items that explode in massive fires, such as cleaning supplies, CRT TVs and computer monitors, large motors with an oil reservoir for lube, like in elevator lift motors, tires in vehicles in the parking structure, and propane tanks.
Claim #5: A heat-generating explosive (thermite?) melted steel at Ground Zero.
Answer: No demolition workers report encountering molten steel, cut beams, or any evidence whatsoever of explosions or explosive charges.
Claim #6: Ground Zero debris—particularly the large steel columns from towers 1 and 2—were quickly shipped overseas to prevent scrutiny.
Answer: Not according to those who handled the steel. The chain of custody is clearly documented, first at Ground Zero by Protec and later at the Fresh Kills site by Yannuzzi Demolition. The time frame (months) before it was shipped to China was normal.
Claim #7: WTC Building 7 was intentionally “pulled down” with explosives. The building owner himself was quoted as saying he decided to “pull it.”
Answer: Building owners do not have authority over emergency personnel at a disaster scene. We have never heard “pull it” used to refer to an explosive demolition. Demolition explosive experts anticipated the collapse of WTC7, and also witnessed it from a few hundred feet away and no one heard detonations.
Claim #8: Steel-frame buildings do not collapse due to fire.
Answer: Many steel-framed buildings have collapsed due to fire. For example, on May 13, 2008, a large part of the tall concrete-reinforced steel architecture tower at the Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands caught on fire and burned, and shortly thereafter collapsed nearly straight-down, almost precisely into its own footprint.
Claim #9: Anyone who denies that explosives were used is ignoring evidence.
Answer: Most of our comments apply to the differences between what people actually saw on 9/11 and what they should have seen had explosives been present. The hundreds of men and women who worked to remove debris from Ground Zero were some of the country’s most experienced and respected demolition veterans. They of all people possessed the experience and expertise to recognize evidence of controlled demolition if it existed. None of these people has come forward with suspicions that explosives were used.
The collapse of World Trade Center building 7 has grown in importance to conspiracy theorists, especially since standard non-conspiracy explanations for the demise of WTC buildings 1 and 2 became accepted. Since building 7 was not struck by a plane, and it did not collapse until 5:20pm on 9/11, hours after the twin towers collapsed, the cause of its collapse, say the conspiracists, must be different from that of WTC 1 and 2. According to wtc7.net, for example, “fires were observed in Building 7 prior to its collapse, but they were isolated in small parts of the building, and were puny by comparison to other building fires,” and that any damage from falling debris from WTC 1 and WTC 2 would have needed to be symmetrical to trigger the pancaking collapse of WTC 7.
In point of fact, the fires burning in building 7 were extensive, not isolated. 9/11 conspiracy theorists tend to only show the north side of WTC 7, which does not look nearly as damaged as the other side. As the building burned all day, emergency response workers realized that collapse was imminent, and at 3pm that day they began evacuation of all emergency personnel. In fact, according to FDNY fire Chief Daniel Nigro, he and his firefighters noticed structural deformations of Building 7 hours before its collapse, and he said later, “I feared a collapse of Building 7 (as did many on my staff).” When the building did collapse, it went first on the south side of the building, which is where the most extensive damage was from the falling debris of the WTC 1 and 2 buildings.
For my money, the oddest of all the 9/11 conspiracy theory claims involves the Pentagon. The idea, first floated in Thierry Meyssan’s book, was that the Pentagon was struck by a missile because the damage was too narrow and limited to be the result of an impact from a Boeing 757. In the 9/11 conspiracy film, Loose Change, dramatic reenactments are presented, arguing that the hole in the Pentagon was too small to have been made by American Airlines Flight 77.
First, how would any of us know how big a hole a plane should make colliding with a massive building like the Pentagon? These conspiracists are talking through their hats.All of the 9/11 conspiracy claims are this easily refuted.
Second, according to a structural engineer named Allyn E. Kilsheimer, who arrived on the scene shortly after the impact: “I saw the marks of the plane wing on the face of the building. I picked up parts of the plane with the airline markings on them. I held in my hand the tail section of the plane, and I found the black box.” Kilsheimer’s eyewitness account is backed up by photos of plane wreckage inside and outside the building. Kilsheimer adds: “I held parts of uniforms from crew members in my hands, including body parts. Okay?”
All of the 9/11 conspiracy claims are this easily refuted. On the Pentagon “missile strike,” for example, I queried my documentary antagonist I mentioned at the start of this chapter about what happened to Flight 77, which disappeared at the same time as the Pentagon was struck. “The plane was destroyed and the passengers were murdered by Bush operatives,” he solemnly revealed. “Do you mean to tell me,” I retorted, “that not one of the thousands of conspirators needed to pull all this off is a whistle-blower who would go on TV or write a tell-all book?”
Think about all the examples of disgruntled government bureaucrats and ex-politicians who can’t wait to go public with their insider information that we tax payers will presumably want to know about. Not one of these 9/11 insiders, witness to what is arguably the greatest conspiracy and cover-up in the history of the United States, if not all of Western civilization, wants to go on CNN or 60 Minutes to reveal their secret? Not one of them wants to cash in what could very well be one of the bestselling books of the year, if not the decade? Not one of them, after a couple of drinks and a twinge or two of guilt, has leaked to a friend (or a friend of a friend) their deep secret? Not one?
The ultimate failure of the 9/11 conspiracy theorists is their inability to explain away the overwhelming evidence of the real conspiracy by Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda.
Then there is the conspiracy theory that NORAD (North American Aerospace Defense Command) supposedly told fighter jets to “stand down” and let the commercial jets reach their targets, thereby implicating the U.S. military in the conspiracy. In point of fact, in a special issue of Popular Mechanics on 9/11 the editors report:On 9/11 there were only 14 fighter jets on alert in the contiguous 48 states. No computer network or alarm automatically alerted the North American Air Defense Command (NORAD) of missing planes. And NORAD’s sophisticated radar … ringed the continent, looking outward for threats, not inward.
Remember the Hindsight Bias: after the fact it seems obvious what should have been done. Before 9/11, hijackers of planes typically demanded ransom or some political action be taken, then they would land the plane at some pre-determined destination. Hijacking a plane and flying it into a building was something new that almost no one anticipated. Also, on 9/11 the hijackers disabled the onboard radar transponders, making it much harder to track. Without that, NORAD would have had to search 4500 identical radar blips on its screens, not knowing precisely which ones were hijacked planes.
Another conspiracy claim is that there was a suspiciously high volume of “put” trading of airline stocks in the days just before 9/11. A “put” trade is a bet that the price of a stock will decrease, which is why this is sometimes called “selling short” a stock. Conspiracists think that a lot of trading “insiders” knew the attacks were coming on 9/11 so they bet the airline stocks would decline after.
In fact, the level of put trading in the days before 9/11 was not so different from other peaks earlier in the year, plus American Airlines had just recently released a report predicting possible losses in the coming quarter, and when that happens put traders increase their trading activity.
Then there’s the matter of cell phone calls made from the planes, which conspiracists claim could not have happened in 2001, given the technology of the day.
First, some passengers used the in-flight cell phones available on seat-backs. Second, cell phones in 2001 could be made from high-altitude flights, albeit the coverage was spotty as the plane moved through tower cells. According to Paul Guckian, vice president of engineering for cell-phone maker Qualcomm, “at the altitude for commercial airliners, around 30,000 or 35,000 feet, phones would still get a signal.”By definition, then, 19 members of al-Qaeda plotting to fly planes into buildings without telling us constitutes a conspiracy.
Dozens more 9/11 conspiracy claims go on and on in this vein of anomaly hunting, all grounded in the argument from personal incredulity—if I can’t think of an explanation for anomaly X besides a conspiracy, then that proves there is a conspiracy. No, it doesn’t. It just means you can’t think of an explanation.
So, all that said, I ask again, was 9/11 a conspiracy? Well, yes, it was. Say what?
In my book Conspiracy, I defined a conspiracy as two or more people or a group plotting or acting in secret to gain an advantage or harm others immorally or illegally. By definition, then, 19 members of al-Qaeda plotting to fly planes into buildings without telling us constitutes a conspiracy. The ultimate failure of the 9/11 conspiracy theorists is their inability to explain away the overwhelming evidence of the real conspiracy by Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda. For example:
—The 1983 attack on the Marine barracks in Lebanon by a radical Hezbollah faction.
—The 1993 truck bomb attack on the World Trade Center.
—The 1995 attempt to blow up 12 planes heading from the Philippines to the U.S.
—The 1995 bombings of U.S. Embassy buildings in Kenya and Tanzania that killed 12 Americans and 200 Kenyans and Tanzanians.
—The 1996 attack on Khobar Towers in Saudi Arabia that killed 19 U.S. military personnel.
—The 1999 failed attempt to attack Los Angeles International airport by Ahmed Ressam.
—The 2000 suicide boat attack on the U.S.S. Cole that killed 17 sailors and injured 39 others.
—The well-documented evidence that Osama Bin Laden is a major financier for and the leader of al-Qaeda.
—The 1996 fatwa by Bin Laden that officially declared a jihad against the United States.
—The 1998 fatwa calling on his followers “to kill the Americans and their allies—civilian and military is an individual duty for any Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it.”
Given this background, since Osama bin Laden and al-Qaeda have officially claimed responsibility for the attacks of 9/11, we should take them at their word that they did it. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is there evidence that explosives caused the collapse of the world trade center buildings as many conspiracy theorists claim?
Brent Blanchard is Director of Field Operations for Protec Documentation Services, a company that documents the work of building demolition contractors. This article is a summary of his response to those who feel that the WTC buildings “collapsed as if by a controlled demolition.” His entire argument may be found on the website he edits: implosionworld.com (archive).
Blanchard and his experts at Protec are uniquely positioned to address concerns that explosives may have been used to bring down the World Trade Center buildings. They have worked with all major American demolition companies and many foreign ones to study the controlled demolition of over 1000 of some of the largest and tallest buildings around the world. Their duties include engineering studies, structural analysis, vibration/air overpressure monitoring and photographic services.
On 9/11 Protec had portable field seismic monitoring systems operating at other sites in Manhattan and Brooklyn. Demolition specialists were hired to clean up Ground Zero and remove the remaining damaged structures, and these experts called on Blanchard’s company to document both the deconstruction and the debris removal. In addition to the thousands of photos and the videos the Protec teams shot themselves, and their personal examination of the debris, they also had access to the photos taken by the foremen and laborers working at the site. The company has much of the unedited television footage from many networks of the collapse of the buildings archived, and they documented the public discussion of the cleanup by demolition teams attending the national Demolition Association Convention in Orlando, FL, in April of 2003.
All of this information, along with their experience, has produced the following responses (only summarized here) to some of the questions raised by 9/11 conspiracy theorists:
#1: The collapse of the towers looked exactly like controlled demolitions.
Protec: No they did not. The key to any demolition investigation is in finding out the “where”—the actual point at which the building failed. All photographic evidence shows WTC1 and 2 failed at the point of impact. Actual implosion demolitions always start with the bottom floors. Photo evidence shows the lower floors of WTC 1 and 2 were intact until destroyed from above.
#2: But they fell right down into their own footprint.
Protec: They did not. They followed the path of least resistance and there was a lot of resistance. Buildings of 20 stories or more do not topple over like trees, or fall like reinforced towers or smokestacks do. Imploding demolitions fall into a footprint because lower stories are removed first. WTC debris was forced out away from the building as the falling mass encountered intact floors.
#3: Explosive charges are seen shooting from several floors just prior to collapse.
Protec: No, air and debris can be seen being violently ejected from the building—a natural and predictable effect of rapid structure collapse.
#4: Witnesses heard explosions.
Protec: All Seismic evidence from many independent sources on 9/11 showed none of the sudden vibration spikes that result from explosive detonations.
#5: A heat-generating explosive (thermite?) melted steel at Ground Zero.
Protec: To a man, demolition workers do not report encountering molten steel, cut beams or any evidence of explosions. Claims of detected traces of thermite are at this time inconclusive.
#6: Ground Zero debris—particularly the large steel columns from towers 1 and 2—were quickly shipped overseas to prevent scrutiny.
Protec: Not according to those who handled the steel. The chain of custody is clearly documented, first at Ground Zero by Protec and later at the Fresh Kills site by Yannuzzi Demolition. The time frame (months) before it was shipped to China was normal.
#7: WTC7 was intentionally “pulled down” with explosives. The building owner himself was quoted as saying he decided to “pull it.”
Protec: Building owners do not have authority over emergency personnel at a disaster scene. We have never heard “pull it” used to refer to an explosive demolition. Because of the extensive fires, demolition explosive experts anticipated the collapse of WTC7. They also personally witnessed it from a few hundred feet away and no one heard detonations.
#8: Steel-frame buildings do not collapse due to fire.
Protec: Many steel-framed buildings have collapsed due to fire.
#9: Anyone who denies that explosives were used is ignoring evidence.
Protec: Most of our comments apply to the differences between what people actually saw on 9/11 and what they should have seen had explosives been present.
The hundreds of men and women who worked to remove debris from Ground Zero were some of the countries most experienced and respected demolition veterans. They of all people possessed the experience and expertise to recognize evidence of controlled demolition if it existed. None of these people have come forward with suspicions that explosives were used. And i years of independent web and media investigation no actual explosives evidence has surfaced. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What Demolition Experts Say About 9/11
Because truthers are so focused on the collapse of the WTC buildings, we asked experts on how controlled demolitions actually happen (& why these collapses do not even remotely match actual ones):
www.skeptic.com/article/what-demolition-experts-say-about… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The 9/11 Conspiracy Theories
My article on truther claims and why they're wrong:
www.skeptic.com/article/you-cant-handle-the-truthers-the-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is @geraldposner classic article on why U.S. intelligence agencies did not prevent 9/11:
Why America Slept
In-depth reporting based on his book of the same title.
www.skeptic.com/article/how-american-intelligence-rivalri… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You Can't Handle The Truther
Our film short send-up of 9/11 conspiracy theories.
Lots of humor, thanks to filmmaker Brian Dalton, but entirely based on actual talking points by 9/11 truthers.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=dwiA-Dosh-o -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why America Failed to Stop 9/11
My convo w/ @geraldposner on 9/11 conspiracy theories and what really happened. We also discuss the "why they hate us" matter—religion, politics, U.S. foreign policy, or all of the above—which unfortunately is still an issue
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-america-failed-t… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You (and they) might be right this time @gmiller but I agree with Kevin Kelly on “what technology wants” (his book title) that there are enough steps between tech and disaster to prevent it; plus don’t underestimate the power of the regulatory state to step in early. I drive a Tesla Model S since 2015. Elon has been promising FSD for years, and doomsayers have been telling me terrorists are going to take over driving my car and thousands of others to cause a mass disaster. Well, it’s here, it’s flawless, and nothing bad has happened. Why not? If terrorists can take over planes and cars to crash them in bulk, why isn’t that happening? Could it be that such scenarios, while not impossible, are highly unlikely? And if I instruct my car to navigate to LAX and to avoid traffic it mows down pedestrians on the sidewalk, how many New York minutes would it be before the government stopped Tesla?
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
Michael, could you explain why every single CEO of every frontier AI company -- including Sam, Dario, Demis, and Elon -- have all acknowledged that ASI would carry serious risks of human extinction?
And most of them were warning of this long before they were running AI companies -- often many years before.
If the industry leaders are in the same 'doomsday' cult as the critics of the industry, doesn't that give you pause? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How could AI wipe us all out?
"a nefarious human enlists a capable AI to do something like create novel viruses that wipe us all out."
The problem is nefarious humans, not AI.
"misaligned AI models could see killing humans simply as a necessary step toward accomplishing their goals."
So, Anthropic, OpenAI, et al. are so smart as to create such an advanced AI model, yet so dumb that they can't figure out how to prevent it from doing so?
www.wsj.com/tech/ai/how-would-ai-actually-kill-us-all-wha… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
When conspiracy theories become clickbait for the attention economy that fuels podcasts like those of Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens. Do they really believe the nonsense they spew? Probably not. But isn't it even worse that they're lying for views? @marissastreit for @prageru
Marissa Streit
@marissastreit
Are you still willing to defend all conspiracy theories?
Calling yourself “independent media” doesn’t excuse spreading accusations without evidence. Causing real damage to our society is not entertainment, and no amount of clicks makes cruelty right. | @michaelshermer
Watch here: l.prageru.com/4iJjEzcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I've done numerous public events with @RichardDawkins & guarantee this will be a once-in-a-lifetime event. Don't miss him in person. 50th anniversary of The Selfish Gene. Wow. That is special. Go. Just do it.
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
How often is the author of a book still around to witness its 50th anniversary edition? The Selfish Gene is 50. I’ll be coming to America’s two great cultural landmarks, Chicago’s Symphony Center and New York’s Carnegie Hall, to speak about it. Two nights only.
Tickets:
Chicago, 18 Oct: howtoacademy.com/north-america-events/richard-dawkins-gen…
New York, 20 Oct: howtoacademy.com/north-america-events/richard-dawkins-gen…
@WBEZ @howtoacademy -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Doomsday predictions = national television. When it doesn't happen, they don't have you back on to explain why not. Instead, they just go with the next doomsayer. Meanwhile, those of us who are skeptical of such end-time prognostications are ignored as naive or ignorant.
Historically, this has happened thousands of times & yet we're still here.
I know, "just you wait!" & "this time is different."
Sure. Care to make a wager about that?
Yashar Ali 🐘
@yashar
Former OpenAI and Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon, who publicly resigned from Anthropic yesterday with a stark warning about AI safety, was interviewed by Anderson Cooper on his show this evening.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Betting markets @gmiller are a way to force people to be clear about their claims & to quantify what, exactly, they think will happen. People & pundits shoot their mouths off daily online & on TV predicting this & that, but no one holds their feet to the flame where there are consequences for their wrong predictions. AI may cause more harm than help civilization, but lead to its complete extinction? Ridiculous. But if someone really believes it, ok, then put up some money & let's see what happens.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
Michael, this isn't a cute little prediction market game.
Nobody who's serious about AI risks would take any satisfaction from having a little extra cash in the short-term, if we're concerned about medium/long-term extinction risks.
What are we going to do? Spend some money and throw a few extra parties where are kids are running around, when we know that they're likely to be harmed by AI unless serious action is taken?
Anybody who thinks that doesn't understand how parental psychology works. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
P.S. @hilbeertspaess
Here is my $1000 bet with Harvard's Avi Loeb:
longbets.org/964/
Let's set up quantifiable criteria by which you define exactly what you think the consequences of AI will be by December 31, 2030.
Jacob Coxon
@hilbertspaess
I resigned from Anthropic today. I spent the last three years doing pretraining research at both OpenAI and Anthropic. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @hilbertspaess
You are familiar with prediction/betting markets.
I use longbets.org & have a $1000 bet w/ Harvard's @ProfAviLoeb that we will not discover aliens by 12-31-2030.
I bet you $1000 that AI will not cause our extinction by 12-31-2030.
We each give $1000 to the Long Now Foundation, which then pays the winner.
In?
Jacob Coxon
@hilbertspaess
I resigned from Anthropic today. I spent the last three years doing pretraining research at both OpenAI and Anthropic. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Over 230 registrations for our Defend the West online conference so far.
Speakers include:
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@peterboghossian
@jasoncrawford
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@DavidDFriedman
@mboudry
@nickgillespie
Nadine Strossen
registration link below👇
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Defend the West — Conjecture Institute | Enroll here for the online conference. conjectureinstitute.org/events/defend-the-west
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I once had a correspondence with a death-row inmate who wanted Skeptic to do an issue on capital punishment. He raped and murdered many women. He said he knew there was something wrong with him but didn't know what it was.
He told me that after his conviction, on his way to prison in a van, shackled to the floor in chains and with armed guards sitting there, they passed a woman walking on the sidewalk and all he could think about was what he could do to escape & get that woman. He said his mind was overwhelmed with that urge he could not control. He insisted people like him should NEVER be let out of prison (he just didn't want to be put to death).
Clancy should be put away for life, or at least for many decades, like Hinckley (who shot Reagan), who said he believed shooting the President would win him the attention of Jodi Foster.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not heard after the trial about any of the jurors in the Florida murder trial of Ted Bundy:
“He had the hardest time getting off the fact that Ted Bundy killed all those women.”
Times have changed (although there is the bizarre case of women who want to marry murderers). -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @JewishGentle7 Bundy said there was something wrong with his brain but didn't know what compelled him to want to rape and murder women. There is no psychiatric disorder for that desire comparable to "postpartum psychosis", so Bundy is a rapist/murderer deserving of capital punishment while Clancy is a victim of her disorder. But there's no difference: it's all broken brains.
Jewish Gentleman
@JewishGentle7
Big difference in amount of compromised moral agency between Ted Bundy and Lindsay Clancy.
Ted Bundy did what he did because he enjoyed it.
Clancy had a months-long documented psychiatric deterioration, poorly managed "trial-and-error" polypharmacy, disclosed and resisted intrusive thoughts for months beforehand, a reported voice compelling the act, no attempt to conceal what happened from her husband when asked directly, and an immediate, near-fatal suicide attempt. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Exactly @chrusciel_p
In the late 19th century Harvard prof Edward Clarke "proved" (through bad science) that women should not go to college because menstruation diverted blood from their brains to their wombs so they couldn't think as well. In the 20th century researchers said women can't run companies or countries because they're too "emotional" & subject to mood swings. All debunked as junk science.
Piotr Chrusciel
@chrusciel_p
Yeah, also letting Clancy walk could have grave consequences far beyond this case. It normalizes the premise that a normal female biological event can render women so irrational that even killing their own children may cease to be attributable to them as responsible agents.
Really bad for women, imo. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What's the difference @CathyYoung63 between Clancy's "severe psychiatric disorder" & the brains of Charles Whitman (tumor) who murdered TX students, Donta Page (horrific upbringing) who raped/murdered a woman, Mr. Oft's pedophilic impulses blamed on his Orbital-Frontal Cortex tumor, Manson girls (cult/drug/sex influence) who murdered 7 people, David Berkowitz ("Son of Sam") fake claim he heard the voice of a dog telling him to murder 6 people (faked his "psychiatric disorder"), etc.?
These people ALL have something wrong with their brains. If it is obvious, like a tumor (or a psychiatric disorder), we tend to excuse them as medical patients, not as criminals, and yet they all have something wrong—we just don't always know what it is.
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
Michael, this is a bad argument. You're taking one sentence in isolation from the actual argument: that there was substantial evidence the killings in this case were the result of a severe psychiatric disorder.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
187,000 people escaped extreme poverty yesterday?
Boring!
Today's news is that AI may kill us all in the next decade.
It won't, of course, but no one will cover this nonevent.
Meanwhile hundreds of millions of people will have escaped destitution...unnoticed @sapinker
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"I like to quote the founder and proprietor of Our World in Data, who said that the papers could have had the headline: “187,000 people escaped from extreme poverty yesterday, every day for the last 30 years.” But you never saw that headline, and as a result, a billion people escaped from extreme poverty. One of the most significant events in human history, and no one knows about it."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why Be Honest When Cheating Pays?
Philosopher Christian Miller joins Michael Shermer to discuss his new book, The Honesty Crisis, and the uncomfortable gap between having a reputation for honesty and actually being honest.
There's a difference?!
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-be-honest-when-c… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No, 9/11 was not orchestrated by Israel or “the Jews,” nor by the Bush admin. James Meigs and I discuss who did it, why, how, and why so many don’t want to believe “19 guys with box cutters” pulled it off.
honestreporting.com/same-claims-new-villain-how-the-9-11-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not heard among the jurors in the Manson trial...
“He had the hardest time getting off the fact that the Manson women committed the Tate-LaBianca murders.” -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sign of the times.
Iran war drives up oil prices.
Everyone on the stock market hates the war except oil companies… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL “Dicision"
Are these scammers that illiterate, or do they do that on purpose (like the old Nigerian Spam Scam emails filled with typos, all caps, bold, etc.) to screen out skeptical readers who might notice? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not heard after the trial about any of the jurors in the Florida murder trial of Ted Bundy:
“He had the hardest time getting off the fact that Ted Bundy killed all those women.”
Times have changed (although there is the bizarre case of women who want to marry murderers). -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Congrats @SwipeWright @buttonslives
When she's old enough to walk/choose take her to a toy store and show her the boys' toys & see how she reacts v. girls' toys section. I used to take my young son to Target girls' toy section & he looked at me like I lost my mind. Not. Culture.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Exciting news: @buttonslives and I found out we’re having a baby GIRL!
All tests indicate she’s perfectly healthy! She's due on Jan. 24, 2027.
Prior to 2020, I was convinced I never wanted a family or kids. But for the past six years, I’ve wanted nothing more.
Now I can’t even walk past the little girls’ clothes at the store without getting a lump in my throat.
Christina and I can’t wait to welcome her into this world and into our lives. 👨👩👧 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The new issue of Skeptic just came out, this one on consciousness, the “hard problem,” sentience, awareness and self-awareness, and the difference between brain and mind (is there one?)
Get your copy today, print or digital:
www.skeptic.com/email/176484de-bf0f-432b-802f-75a1c830cace/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How and why people become almost religious about conspiracy theories, identifying themselves by their beliefs (faith-based), with @marissastreit for @prageru @DennisPrager
We need to treat conspiracy theories as plausible hypotheses (more or less probable) rather than as insults
Marissa Streit
@marissastreit
Why do conspiracy theories become almost religious for some people? Skeptic magazine founder @michaelshermer explains that when a belief becomes part of someone’s identity, it becomes much harder to change their mind. Instead of treating a theory as absolutely true or absolutely false, Shermer says people should ask how likely it is to be true, and stay willing to change their mind when the evidence changes. If truth is your North Star, what would it take to change your mind?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another example of attention economy at work @SwipeWright where the point is to say batshit crazy things to get views/ad dollars + another example of bullshit, where the liar knows the truth & distorts it purposefully whereas the bullshitter doesn't care what the truth is.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
"If you can build a wood-fired kiln, you understand math."
What?
This is one of the stupidest exchanges I've ever listened to. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is it now a requirement to wear a nearly-worthless cloth mask years past the Covid-19 pandemic to be taken seriously as a socialist? Is this a virtue signal among the comrades?
If you actually "follow the science" you'd know that only N95 masks actually work (if worn properly).
Stu Smith
@thestustustudio
🚨 At Socialism 2026’s “Liberatory Spirit, the Spirit of Liberation” panel, Rev. Jinzu Minna Jain warns that even left-wing spaces can accidentally reproduce “health fascism” through the language of healing.
She says organizers need to be careful about what “healing” means, because sometimes people are not looking to “get better” or “move past” trauma at all.
Instead, she argues, what people may need is collective support while “sitting with the cracks,” “sitting with the bones,” and “sitting in the horror together.”
I’m not especially sold on the whole “Woke 1.0 vs. Woke 2.0” framework, but if even “healing” can now be ideologically objectionable, then we have entered some truly rarefied territory.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This would make a good cold opening skit for SNL...
Ima_Pseudonym
@ima_pseudo41406
Here's the infamous DSA video where he makes his "Point of personal privilege":
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Actors/writers who are hoping for work at the Babylon Bee?
Evan Barker
@evanwch
You simply cannot parody these people faster than they can parody themselves
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If Marxism requires armed violent action, doesn't that mean that "the people" don't actually want it (so you have to force it upon them at gunpoint)? For over a century Marxism has failed everywhere it has been tried & resulted in >100 million dead. Enough @ButchWare
Western Lensman
@WesternLensman
UCSB prof Dr. Butch Ware tells 'Marxism' conference: Be ready for "war in the streets."
"Some of these clickety-clack revolutionaries have never been in a f*cking gunfight."
"Y'all ain't nowhere near ready for a war in the streets. You better get ready for both kinds of war."
"And if you stay ready, you ain't got to get ready."
CA taxpayers help fund this Marxist extremist academic's pay.
And this is the message he spreads. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why is it almost always "the Jews" purportedly behind nearly everything that happens (especially conspiracy theories)? I offer my thoughts to @marissastreit for @prageru @DennisPrager
Marissa Streit
@marissastreit
Why do conspiracy theories so often target Jewish people? Skeptic magazine founder @michaelshermer explains that when a small minority group becomes highly successful, the majority can begin to assume that success must come from something secret or dishonest behind the scenes. He says this helps explain why Jews have been targeted throughout history, especially in fields like banking, law, medicine, and education. Is today’s antisemitism simply recycled envy dressed up as conspiracy? Does this old and dangerous tactic still work? Watch here: l.prageru.com/4iJjEzc
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes, the government lied about Roswell and they really were covering up a secret: Project Mogul, a high-altitude spy balloon with sound equipment to listen for acoustic signals of USSR nuclear tests in the atmosphere.
Great convo with @marissastreit for @prageru @DennisPrager
Marissa Streit
@marissastreit
Was Roswell really a UFO cover-up, or was the government hiding something else? Skeptic magazine founder and White House UAP panel member @michaelshermer explains that the government did lie about Roswell, but not because aliens crashed in New Mexico. He says the object was part of a Cold War operation used to monitor Soviet nuclear tests. If UFO stories helped hide Cold War secrets, could today’s UAP headlines be distracting us from something else?
Watch here 👉 l.prageru.com/4iJjEzcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Götterdämmerung in Japan
Here is my response to Klaus Ziegler's critique of my case for why it was necessary and moral to nuke Japan:
www.skeptic.com/article/gotterdammerung-in-japan/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is Klaus Ziegler's critique of my case for nuking Japan and end WWII, which he argues was not necessarily necessary or moral:
www.skeptic.com/article/hiroshima-nagasaki-and-an-article… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my original article on why it was both necessary and moral to nuke Hiroshima and Nagasaki:
www.skeptic.com/article/the-moral-case-for-dropping-the-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A Brief Consideration of the Nature of Morality and War
Inspired by an Exchange of Ideas Between Michael Shermer and Klaus Ziegler
historyhighjackers.com/f/a-brief-consideration-of-the-nat… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe thanks to clouds, moisture, water refraction, and the sun behind us…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and an Article of Faith About the Dropping of Atomic Bombs
Klaus Ziegler on why I am wrong in my defense of the U.S. nuclear attacks on Japan:
www.skeptic.com/article/hiroshima-nagasaki-and-an-article… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why indeed? I have a few thoughts on the matter that I share with @marissastreit for @prageru
Marissa Streit
@marissastreit
Why are conspiracy theories so alluring? Skeptic magazine founder @michaelshermer explains that conspiracies are real: people do plot in secret for power, money, or advantage all the time. But every conspiracy theory still needs evidence. The difference now is that social media and AI can turn an unverified, fringe theory into a viral movement almost overnight. In a world where anyone can generate a convincing conspiracy theory in seconds, how should people discern what to believe?
Watch here: l.prageru.com/4iJjEzcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Save your spot for our Defend the West online conference: conjectureinstitute.org/events/defend-the-west
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Too bad we didn't get around to Jewish Space Lasers
@marissastreit (along with everything else "the Jews" are up to). But there is plenty to go around, unfortunately.
PragerU
@prageru
NEW RELEASE: Why Conspiracy Theories Are So Addictive | Michael Shermer
Author and Skeptic magazine founder @michaelshermer joins @marissastreit to discuss why conspiracy theories spread, how some turn out to be true, and how to tell the difference between healthy suspicion and paranoia. Shermer explains why UFOs, 9/11, the moon landing, COVID, and antisemitic conspiracies capture the public imagination, and how social media and AI have made false narratives easier to create and spread. They also discuss the difference between real conspiracies and conspiracy theories, and why the best question to ask is: What would it take to change your mind?
l.prageru.com/467zMTP -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Worse that this @TheBabylonBee
It comes down to one guy on the jury of 12 who says it's not okay to strangle your kids. The other 11 jurors think murder is perfectly okay as long as you are hormonal (and that it's okay to kill healthcare CEOs, whites, and conservatives).
The Babylon Bee
@TheBabylonBee
Jury Unable To Decide If Strangling Your Kids Is Okay babylonbee.com/news/jury-still-trying-to-decide-if-strang…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If I were a conservative facing upcoming midterms & 2028 elections I would be elated by these morally obscene Democratic positions that it's ok to commit murder if (1) you're hormonal (2) you're trans/furry/ victim is conservative, (3) the victim is white, (4) the victim is a CEO
John Ocasio-Rodham Nolte
@NolteNC
Here’s a four-pack of the Democrat Party’s latest folk heroes…. You must be insane to support Democrats:
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Jewish Space Lasers are back
It seems that respected documentary filmmaker @alexgibneyfilm has fallen for the conspiracy theory @elonmusk helped rigged the 2024 election using, uh, Starlink satellites, or space lasers, or something reports @shellenberger
open.substack.com/pub/public/p/new-alex-gibney-documentar… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Breaking news from the frontiers of physics and cosmology…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Defend the West Conference.
It's online and free for anyone to watch all our lectures. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
That's the problem @elonmusk Much of science has shifted from the search for truth to social activism. The North Star must always be the truth.
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
It is indeed a disgrace. Those publications have an obligation to adhere to the truth and yet have become woke propaganda outlets.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The degeneration of Nature, Science, NEJM, and Scientific American into woke propaganda dispensers (and their refusal to publish normie, centrist, common-sense responses) is a scientific scandal.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More blank slate nonsense. “Hurt people hurt” so let them out of prison because they won’t offend again if we shower them with empathy—suicidally so, right @GadSaad ?
War Correspondent
@warDaniel47
🚨 IT'S OFFICIAL: Mass amounts of Americans are calling for the courts to be PURGED as San Francisco leftist Judge Linda Colfax released a criminal who FATALLY assaulted an 84YO — because she was worried prison would have a "poor impact" on him
BETRAYAL.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Repatriation and Reburial of Sh*t Needs to Be Stopped
Archaeologist Elizabeth Weiss in Skeptic on the latest woke nonsense from activists who want human feces to be treated as sacred. Seriously. Why? Analysis might reveal cannibalism among native peoples.
www.skeptic.com/article/repatriation-and-reburial-of-sh-t… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is it me or does this Virgin Mary with baby Jesus look, uh, a bit masculine? In any case, “they” is obviously a chest feeder.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Apparently Jesus visited Greenland back in the day…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sisimiut, Greenland
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe from a not very green Greenland…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why the future is unpredictable (where volition arises) but the past is postdictable (determined): my convo with the great Santa Fe Institute chaos and complexity scientist Stuart Firestein
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/is-the-future-unknow… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dolly Parton performed Stairway to Heaven (the GOAT classic rock song)?
Of course she did.
Fabulous. As always with Dolly
Classic Moments ✨
@Sunflower15025
When Dolly Parton approached Robert Plant for permission to record her version of “Stairway to Heaven,” she reportedly worried about how he would react. Instead, Plant’s response was wonderfully simple: “Of course you can, you’re Dolly Parton.”
And somehow, that feels like the perfect answer. Dolly didn’t try to copy Led Zeppelin — she took one of rock’s most iconic songs and made it unmistakably her own, adding a touch of country, gospel, and her unmistakable voice.
Sometimes, a legend recognizing another legend is all the permission you need.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“There are perhaps 430 billion wild birds in the world. Each day across the planet, 100,000 airplane flights take off and land, and 1,800 weather balloons are launched. In the United States, there are close to 3 millionregistered drones, and there are tens of thousands of man-made objects orbiting the Earth. Are we really supposed to be surprised when the military reports a few hundred times a year that service members see objects that can’t be identified? Wouldn’t you expect that, in the glare of the sun and in unusual atmospheric conditions, a few birds or satellites would occasionally appear to be behaving strangely when you’re looking at them from far away? How would this not be the case?”
Good analysis @RichardHanania
www.richardhanania.com/p/the-case-for-ufos-is-weaker-than -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Glacial Museum
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
They’re everywhere…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe from Iliussat, Greenland
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Canadian Geese (I think) over Greenland
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Fermi paradox documentary In The Great Silence teaser. Looks fabulous.
Where is everyone in the cosmos? www.youtube.com/watch?v=dzljay0iHSU -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Politically correct way to understand this data @SteveStuWill
Political Studies to Psychology, Sociology & English Lit, the system is equitable & fair.
Geography to Econ, Math, Physics & Computing are filled with misogynist professors & administrators.
Obviously, right? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Jesus (as a Lutheran) goes everywhere including Greenland…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Walk about Uummannaq…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Minke Whale caught, killed and processed on this little island. Two hours later it was being sold out of bins in town to locals for food. No, I haven’t tried whale meat or fat yet but hoping to soon.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Vega. The ship, not the star of Contact. Uummannaq is a working town processing fish, whales, etc.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Greetings from Uummannaq (don’t ask for pronunciation) Greenland, well north of the Arctic Circle
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Accompanied by Jared Diamond in my ear listening to why the Greenland Norse society collapsed: no wood, limited food, environmental pressures, hostile to Inuits, too politically and religiously conservative for adaptation to Inuit ways of survival.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hiking Disko…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Walk about Disko…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Disko Island church, Greenland
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Greetings from Disko Hotel (Greenland, not Vegas)…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not all skeptics @ProfAviLoeb !
Skepticism would end with more and better data from the government, and especially if @realDonaldTrump clears additional classified restrictions on whistleblowers who claim they know where the aliens are. Show us!
avi-loeb.medium.com/skeptics-are-capable-of-promoting-con… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Arday's Law: a limit to articles published on one person within a timeframe.
O-kay, does this apply to Trump?
www.change.org/p/proposal-for-arday-s-law-a-limit-to-arti… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Disclosure about UFOs/UAPs is welcome by believers & skeptics alike, but revelation may not mean ETIs (or interdimensional, ultra-terrestrial beings). If it is terrestrial natural phenom it does not necessarily mean "they" are hiding aliens. @jamesbmeigs
www.wsj.com/opinion/free-expression/our-ufo-obsession-is-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Well-wishers have raised more than $300,000 for his family, and made his upcoming memoir a best seller in Britain."
Sympathy for the Devil?
Arday shows that being a fabulist & faker pays off if you check the right boxes on the Bingo-card of victimhood.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/08/jason-arday-innocence-r… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Science Tells You How to Live, Not God | with Michael Shermer
Thanks for the great questions and comments Alex Buxeda!
youtu.be/urp7D05RRqY -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The ECREE principle @DrBeaVillarroel is always attributed to Sagan, who popularized it in his 1980 Cosmos series in the episode on ETIs, but that wording (or close to it) belongs to the philosopher of science Marcelo Truzzi (proving the principle that quotes gravitate to the most famous person who said them, or might have, or should have!), himself reflecting David Hume’s proportionality principle that one should proportion one’s confidence in a claim to the evidence for it.
You are correct that it can be used as a cudgel against claims for which one disagrees (I may be guilty of this myself), but in general Bayesian reasoning suggests the same principle: more/better evidence, more confidence, less/poorer evidence, less confidence, which I take to be your point. Evidence matters.
The claim that UAPs = ETIs could be settled now with disclosure of an alien body and/or craft we can all see. Nothing extraordinary about that! Just show us. If it is something else (interdimensional, ultra-terrestrial) we need some criteria by which we can determine a response criteria (hit, correction rejection, etc. in Signal Detection Theory jargon) or else we’re left speculating, inventing new physics, metaphysics, or even religious notions (some think UAPs are demons or angels or spiritual beings).
Let’s hope President Trump takes another step in enabling disclosure without penalty for classified information. He could do that tomorrow and the whistleblowers could state exactly where the crafts and bodies are located (or whatever is actually there, which could be advanced CIA or DARPA project tech).
Let’s get to the bottom of this once and for all!
Beatriz Villarroel
@DrBeaVillarroel
Steve gave me an idea, even if unintentionally. This is something we genuinely need to address, Avi. The mantra “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” is damaging science. It is not a philosophically well-founded evidentiary standard; it is a rhetorical device that allows subjective prior beliefs to determine how much evidence is deemed sufficient. Perhaps it is time for an open letter to the NAS and major editorial boards arguing that this phrase has no place in scientific peer review. Claims should be judged by the quality of the evidence -- not by how extraordinary they appear to the reviewer.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Slow Hands, Fast Bike
cycling archives
@mission753
Eric Clapton collects his custom - made Cinelli Supercorsa from company director Antonio Colombo at the Cinelli factory in Milan, 1987.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Blue Lagoon geothermal baths. Naturally heated from the Earth a mile down, silica infused water gives it the color. Unlike Esalen Institute Big Sur, California, these are not clothing optional baths.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Geothermal Energy plant Iceland
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why it’s good to have a window seat
Geology from 40,000 feet
Greenland -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
We Want to Believe:
How Aliens Went Mainstream and Why It Matters
My conversation with Adam Kirsch based on his new and highly readable book. Fabulous overview of the entire UFO, UAP, ETI, NHI phenomena. www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-we-want-to-belie… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I just signed the letter to in support of Nathan Cofnas that he not be punished for simply pursuing the truth, which is, or at least should be, the mission of all universities. If you have an ORCID number and believe in truth and freedom, sign:
johnarmstrongmaths.com/openletters/letter.php?campaign=co… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excerpt from Truth:
For Christians who insist that the resurrection be physical and not spiritual, literal and not metaphorical, a challenge I often employ is that Orthodox Jews do not accept it as real, neither in Jesus’ time nor in ours. Think about that: Jews believe in the same God as Christians. They accept the Old Testament of the Bible, as Christians do. They even believe in the Messiah. They just don’t think the 1st-century preacher was him.
The reason Jews don’t believe Jesus was the Messiah is that they were expecting a Royal Monarch descended from King David, a great warrior who would rescue and redeem them from the oppressive Roman rule under which they were subjugated, not the son of an impoverished carpenter from Nazareth. Jewish rabbis, scholars, philosophers, and historians all know the arguments for the resurrection as well as Christian apologists and theologians making the arguments, and yet they still reject them.
Why? If the arguments and evidence for the resurrection is so solid, in time the community most expert in that field would reach a consensus about it. They haven’t. Christians believe it. Traditional Judaism does not. That’s revealing. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You are far too kind @GadSaad
@pzmyers.bsky.social @pzmyers@octodon.social reminds me of Miles in Sideways, quoting Bukowski:
"Half my life is over, and I have nothing to show for it. I'm a thumbprint on the window of a skyscraper. I'm a smudge of excrement on a tissue surging out to sea with a million tons of raw sewage."
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
I just discovered this post by @michaelshermer regarding arguably the most disagreeable "academic" alive today: @pzmyers. He spends endless energy obsessing over me. He has had the academic career of my socks but yet he feels perfectly emboldened to talk down to me as though he is the embodiment of Darwin. He apparently left X because he could no longer deal with "fascists" such as @elonmusk. Everybody is a complete idiot according to this wannabe high school instructor; only he holds the light of science whilst he has published substantially less than my pet goldfish. The Dunning-Kruger effect should be named the PZ Myers effect. If so, this would at least make him a well known figure. Alas, he will be as remembered as my discarded socks. Keep raging into the void, PZ. The world will soon discover your brilliance. :)
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another example of the corruption of sociology and education departments that changed their telos for the search for truth to social activism. The goal of these professors is to indoctrinate students into far left progressive woke politics, not research, rationality & science.
Max Klinger
@maxklingerpol
I studied in the academic department at Cambridge that later employed Jason Arday. Here's just some of the crap I learnt: For one module, I wrote a lengthy essay about how cultural products like kids’ cartoons and jazz songs serve as instruments of capitalist oppression. I got a top mark on that paper (despite knowing at the time that I was essentially regurgitating complete crap).
While studying for another paper I had a debate with the professor, an eminent anthropologist, because she insisted that native tribes could fly through the trees - not metaphorically, but that they could literally fly because they believed they could fly. After all, who are we to question ‘indigenous ways of knowing’...
For a different course, I read long ‘research papers’ which argued that the fact that black kids are excluded from schools more than white kids proves systemic racism exists in education. Crucially, they ignored the fact that white kids are excluded more than, e.g., Japanese kids, a statistic which, applying the exact same logic, would suggest that the education system is systemically biased in favour of, erm, Japanese kids (which obviously it isn’t).
Something that was held up as proof of the existence of this largely imaginary racism was that teachers tell kids not to use booming voices in the classroom, and not to put up their hoods or wear their trousers down below their pants.
On another occasion, my supervisor casually praised some students agitators who were trying to shut down a talk by someone they disagreed with. I said that I didn’t think this was something to celebrate, because I believed in freedom of speech. He got visibly angry, and proceeded to tell me that free speech was not worth protecting in a capitalist system (or something along those lines).
In my all-important final year, a lecturer let me know that I shouldn’t worry too much about my exam results, because as someone who was not from an upper class background I should be more focussed on using my grasp of leftist revolutionary theory to further the interests of the proletariat. Writing this down, it strikes me that it’s so hilariously mental that some of you will presumably assume I’m lying. But there’s no way I’m leaving it out, because it happened.
Unlike the academics who make a living from this stuff, I couldn’t bring myself to build a career pumping out whiney, divisive, intellectually incoherent rubbish. But others, as we’ve seen exposed in recent days, do so with gusto. And are lauded for it.
Please read the full piece this is taken from, and give it a share. I've linked it in the tweet below. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The return of the grand narrative
Does science preach the same story it replaced?
Philosopher of science Steve Fuller, mechanical engineer Shini Somara, and myself discussing the big questions in science and society at How the Light Gets In festival
iai.tv/video/the-return-of-the-grand-narrative -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I initially held Jason Arday entirely responsible for his plagiarism, lies and exaggerations, and I still do, but he was just another fabulist, faker, and fibber, and in my profession of studying these con artists he doesn't stand out from others.
It is white progressives with no moral compass and no sense of agency or personal responsibility who have made him into a martyr.
Shame on all of you. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
wokenism:
"It makes whites feel good about themselves and secure that they can’t be called racists. But it also makes the broader society question the capabilities of any black person in a position of authority or prestige. It encourages a sense that being just so-so is the best that blacks can do." @JohnHMcWhorter
www.city-journal.org/article/jason-arday-cambridge-tokeni… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the Jason Arday affair, this is now far more than the bigotry of low expectations—Blacks can't perform at the same level as Whites & Asians so we must help them succeed.
It is now an all-out racist affair that sends the message "it's okay for Blacks to plagiarize, lie & exaggerate because they cannot succeed otherwise."
This could not be more wrong, or racist, and yet that's where many people are today.
Shameful.
Disgraceful. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"What matters is not whether our achievements will last for eternity. They won’t. What matters is what happens to the beings who share this finite window with us:
Whether they live or die.
Whether they flourish or suffer.
Whether they’re educated or imprisoned in ignorance.
Whether they’re treated as full persons, with agency and rights, or as mere statistics to be managed."
Bravo @platobooktour !
rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/viva-la-resistan… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Note that there is nothing in this statement from @ugent about truth, honesty, integrity or any of their opposites, including & especially plagiarism, which used to be central in all such academic statements @nathancofnas
Universities have replaced the search for truth with the activism of social justice.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am under investigation by my university for discriminating against Arday
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More madness.
This is like a comedian's riff on being caught cheating on his spouse (I forget who did this).
"It wasn't me"
"It's not what it looks like"
"How dare you accuse me of such a thing"
"You're a horrible person for such an accusation"
"I did it but it's your fault!"
Libs of TikTok
@libsoftiktok
BREAKING: Nathan Cofnas, the academic who initially accused former Cambridge Prof. Jason Arday of plagiarism, has been SUSPENDED by Ghent University (@ugent) for "discrimination" and "racism."
This comes after Arday was found dead following his resignation from Cambridge. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If enough of us speak out against the misogynist anti-feminist woman-hating trans sports movement that is almost ENTIRELY men who want to compete in women's sports (and go in their spaces) then that will turn the tide. Liberals need to denounce such progressive wokeism too.
Matt Calkins
@Matt_Calkins
After 11 years as a sports columnist at the Seattle Times, I have decided to resign. It was entirely my choice, and it was not an easy one. The impetus was the Times declining to run a column I wrote from the perspective of two female student athletes who were opposed to competing against biological males. It was one of several pieces of mine that had been spiked, and I no longer felt like I could properly do my job as a columnist. I lay out the situation in greater detail in the link below, but I want to say that I enjoyed my time with the paper, find the talent there to be immense, and have no animosity toward anyone who works there. It was just time for a change.
mattycee.substack.com/p/i-was-a-sports-columnist-at-the-s… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The world has gone mad.
A woman who murdered her 3 children is now the target of sympathy.
“Believe” “She Needed Help” “Peace For Lindsay”
Yes, postpartum depression is real.
No, most women with it don't kill their kids.
Get your moral compass straight!
apnews.com/article/lindsay-clancy-postpartum-supporters-m… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is getting more ridiculous by the day.
Amnesty International has issued an absurd statement on how "black disabled lives matter"
What's next for Arday? A Nobel Prize?
You know what else matters?
Truth
Personal responsibility
Accountability
Hard work
www.amnesty.org.uk/get-involved/join-the-movement/join-a-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Life and Death and Life of Repressed Memories
Psychologists Carol Tavris & Richard McNally analyze the resurgence of the pseudoscience of "recovered" memories of trauma & abuse, dead by 2000 but making a comeback especially for Millennials & Gen Z.
www.skeptic.com/article/life-and-death-and-life-of-repres… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Therefore...as long as you favor DEI then plagiarism, lying, exaggerating, and pretending to be something you are not is...acceptable? Is that the take-home lesson of the Jason Arday story?
The Associated Press
@AP
Thousands of people gathered at Trafalgar Square in London on Monday to mourn Jason Arday, a Black professor who faced a storm of plagiarism accusations and died suddenly, days after resigning from the University of Cambridge. His death has prompted outcries that the allegations were magnified into a cruel public takedown motivated by racism and longstanding hostility to DEI policies at universities and other institutions.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Both Eric Davis & David Grusch have asked President Trump for immunity so they can direct officials to the aliens & craft (if that is what they are—neither one has seen them with their own eyes).
Trump wants to be the most consequential POTUS in history & this would be one of the most consequential disclosures in history.
Make it so @realDonaldTrump
James Fox
@jamescfox
Former U.S. Air Force officer and military intelligence official, David Grusch claims to have seen highly classified photographic and video taped evidence of crashed UFOs/UAP and their non-human occupants (ALIENS)!
He's asking President Trump for immunity so he can share w/the American people what he knows and help with disclosure.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In today's Zoom meeting we agreed:
“The UAP Science Advisory Council uapsac.com fully supports requests made by David Grusch, Eric Davis, and others, for the Trump administration to provide legal assurances, including immunity where necessary, for current or former government employees and military personnel, so that they can share information with the council regarding alleged technology from a non-human origin and help guide the council’s scientific evaluation. In parallel, the council is currently pursuing efforts to obtain and scientifically evaluate historical UAP (Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena) records and legacy data.” -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is There a Second Arrow of Time?
My conversation with geoscientist Robert Hazen & astrobiologist Michael Wong based on their new book in which they propose a new law of nature:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/is-there-a-second-ar… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"White liberals in the English-speaking world want to believe in the archetype of the up-from-nothing black intellectual who, despite huge disadvantages, goes on to achieve greatness. In fact, they want to believe in this sort of story so badly that they are willing to turn off every ounce of skepticism that they would normally bring to bear on fantastical claims." @coldxman
www.thefp.com/p/coleman-hughes-the-left-needed-jason-arda… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another example:
What is seen:
Jason Arday's suicide after total humiliation of being caught lying, exaggerating, and plagiarizing, and since he's black, blamed on racism.
What is not seen:
All the successful black professors, scholars, scientists, entrepreneurs, business owners, home owners, etc. who did so by hard work, creativity, risk taking, intelligence, etc., ignored by activists who only see a (mis)perceived victim.
If the activists are right that we're living in a hopelessly racist world, how did all these blacks become so successful?
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Frédéric Bastiat's 1850 That Which is Seen and That Which is Not Seen is again relevant.
—Infrastructure: We see the new bridge; we don't see what would have been built with that money.
—Iran: we see they can't get a nuke; we don't see what we could have done with $37.5 billion.
—DEI: we see the new hires, we don't see more qualified candidates declined.
—Military: we see the big aircraft carriers & supersonic jets, we don't see how we might not need them for security, or what else that $$ could have been used for.
—Trans sports: we see MtF athletes competing, we don't see the women whom they replaced who lost their opportunity to compete.
—Bailouts 2009: we see corporations surviving, we don't see all the small investors & homeowners who lost everything who might have been bailed.
—Welfare/Social Transfers: we see poor people helped, we don't see what they might have done on their own or how the government might have helped other people.
—Homelessness: we see new apartment buildings built by the government for X times normal costs, we don't see alternative solutions.
—Covid school closures: we see the kids didn't get sick, we don't see what they didn't learn (or that they wouldn't have gotten sick anyway).
—Taxes: we see politicians parading their pet projects the public funds, we don't see what tax payers would have done with their $ that benefits society even more.
None of this is to pass judgment on what we should or shouldn't do, only to note what is almost always left out, namely what economists call "opportunity costs"—spending $$ on X means you are not spending it on X (or investing it, etc.). -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Frédéric Bastiat's 1850 That Which is Seen and That Which is Not Seen is again relevant.
—Infrastructure: We see the new bridge; we don't see what would have been built with that money.
—Iran: we see they can't get a nuke; we don't see what we could have done with $37.5 billion.
—DEI: we see the new hires, we don't see more qualified candidates declined.
—Military: we see the big aircraft carriers & supersonic jets, we don't see how we might not need them for security, or what else that $$ could have been used for.
—Trans sports: we see MtF athletes competing, we don't see the women whom they replaced who lost their opportunity to compete.
—Bailouts 2009: we see corporations surviving, we don't see all the small investors & homeowners who lost everything who might have been bailed.
—Welfare/Social Transfers: we see poor people helped, we don't see what they might have done on their own or how the government might have helped other people.
—Homelessness: we see new apartment buildings built by the government for X times normal costs, we don't see alternative solutions.
—Covid school closures: we see the kids didn't get sick, we don't see what they didn't learn (or that they wouldn't have gotten sick anyway).
—Taxes: we see politicians parading their pet projects the public funds, we don't see what tax payers would have done with their $ that benefits society even more.
None of this is to pass judgment on what we should or shouldn't do, only to note what is almost always left out, namely what economists call "opportunity costs"—spending $$ on X means you are not spending it on X (or investing it, etc.). -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Did you know there is such a thing as "Christian Counseling"? I didn't until we got this article for Skeptic. Interesting questions: "is the sufferer a sinner or victim, answerable or afflicted?"
www.skeptic.com/article/what-is-christian-counseling-how-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Stylized petroglyphs of alien mothership releasing multiple probes…
(Puako Petroglyph Park, next to Mauna Lani resort, Kona coast, Hawaii, found on a bike ride) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I’m not saying aliens once inhabited the Kona coast of Hawaii, but could it be…?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
WNBA Commissioner Cathy Engelbert convened a task force of team presidents & general managers over the “coming weeks and months" to define a W.
Seriously? To define what everyone pre-2020 knew?
Answer: Adult Human Female
Biology: gamete—egg or sperm? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What is a Woman, Anyway?
Fuzzy Sets, Family Resemblances & Conceptual Truths
My answer to the question:
michaelshermer.substack.com/p/what-is-a-woman-anyway?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What does the W in WNBA stand for?
Oh yeah, Woman.
What is a woman? The WNBA is now going to be forced to answer as 2 former NBA players "identify" as women (to make a point). @SwipeWright
Hopefully women's sports, spaces & rights will be defended.
www.city-journal.org/article/enes-kanter-freedom-royce-wh… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Deeper question behind this finding:
Why were standards dropped in the first place?
Officials blame Covid & AI but we all know the real reason: standards reveal differences between people & groups & that goes against the blank slate model of human nature that insists on equal outcomes.
sfstandard.com/opinion/2026/08/15/uc-berkeley-sat-test-bl… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
2 books:
Where are the Customers Yachts? by Fred Schwed Jr. Satire but still relevant.
The Gone Fishin' Portfolio by Alexander Green.
Better to invest passively (eg, index fund) than to try to beat the market.
After the fact, yes, some investors beat the market.
Before the fact? Good luck deciding which of the 6,000+ mutual fund managers will win.
www.wsj.com/finance/investing/stock-picking-funds-are-per… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Of course, all this could be clarified immediately if the appropriate person high up in the government with the right security and classification clearances, would have Grusch (and/or his sources) take them to the locations where the craft and alien bodies are supposedly located.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Watching Grusch's interview with Dr. Phil, re this segment of the different craft not “of this planet”, since Grusch is reporting what someone told him, is it possible he is honestly reporting someone else’s observation of technology of ours that they didn’t recognize or understand but is, in fact, of this planet?
That is, is it possible that Grusch is honest, that his source is honestly mistaken, and that this whole story of a whistleblower revealing alien spacecraft is just mistaken identification?
Is this more or less likely than that our government has alien spaceships and cadavers of alien pilots? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Watching Grusch's interview with Dr. Phil, re this segment of the different craft not “of this planet”, since Grusch is reporting what someone told him, is it possible he is honestly reporting someone else’s observation of technology of ours that they didn’t recognize or understand but is, in fact, of this planet?
That is, is it possible that Grusch is honest, that his source is honestly mistaken, and that this whole story of a whistleblower revealing alien spacecraft is just mistaken identification?
Is this more or less likely than that our government has alien spaceships and cadavers of alien pilots? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @ibramxk
If we live in such an oppressive and racist society, how do you explain all the highly successful black professors, scholars, scientists, writers, investors, entrepreneurs, business owners, home owners, etc.?
Could it be they did it the same way as everyone else?
Ibram X. Kendi
@ibramxk
The death of Jason Arday hit so close to home that I had no words yesterday. But I woke up with words.
To be a prominent antiracist Black scholar is to know you are a target, almost totally surrounded by resentments. You know that at any point, the attacks can come like a lynch mob.
And if you die from all the attacks, the media still calls the attacks on you “accusations” to wash their hands of the blood. Your lynchers announce your death as if they had no role in your lynching.
My latest at The Emancipator.
theemancipator.org/2026/08/15/ideas/the-media-lynched-jas… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"This is the poison chalice of the state religion of diversity. It lays traps for the very people it celebrates. It handpicks members of ‘the oppressed’ for moral anointment and institutional gushing while leaving them open to exposure as others start to query their credentials."
So good. Read all of this...
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
Extracts from article in Spectator 16th August by Brendan O’Neill:
Behold the human wreckage of the cult of diversity. The tragedy of Jason Arday is that he was both built up and destroyed by the ruthless machinery of DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion). The academy made him into the golden boy of its philistine project of ‘decolonisation’ and gave not one thought to what the consequences might be if his thin story unravelled, as it inevitably would. No one can deny it now: wokeness makes false gods and real tragedies. . .
This is the poison chalice of the state religion of diversity. It lays traps for the very people it celebrates. It handpicks members of ‘the oppressed’ for moral anointment and institutional gushing while leaving them open to exposure as others start to query their credentials. That’s the toxic bargain of identity politics: it builds teetering pedestals for ethnic-minority thinkers, meaning their fall from grace is often twice as fatal.
And what a pedestal they made for Arday. They worshipped him as ‘the best in the world’. They beatified him as a black wunderkind whose very presence in a place like Cambridge might help to wash away its sins of whiteness. They canonised him as a living monument to ‘decolonisation’. It was precisely this, their giddy, narcissistic desire to manufacture a kind of black saviour, that made them turn a blind eye to the questionable elements of Arday’s CV and life story. They sacrificed their due diligence to the god of decolonisation.
And Arday suffered. He was both poster boy and sacrificial lamb of the diversity crusade. Even as he gained from it – reaching the dizzying heights of a Cambridge professorship – he was being damned by it. The foundation of myth and sand his starry career was built on was untenable. Its collapse was a given. It is a testament to the ideological blindness of the inhabitants of our ivory towers that none of them foresaw it. . . .
The Faustian ruthlessness of it all is mindblowing.
. . . The media is the only institution in this entire tragic scandal that did its job properly. Journalists found a story and they told it. It was the academy and Arday’s colleagues who failed to do their jobs. Who failed to prize merit over identity, and failed to foresee the public embarrassment that would befall their falsely promoted friend. They ignored the truth – the media found it.
I and others have been arguing for years that the politics of identity is a disaster for all, black and white alike. White kids are overlooked, black kids are patronised. Whites are branded ‘privileged’, blacks ‘oppressed’. Whites are seen as the beneficiaries of historic crimes who must atone for past sins, blacks as history’s perma-victims who require the gracious helping hand of the state. We are demonised or infantilised according to the accident of our race.
Enough. Let our monument to Jason Arday be the restoration of the true ideal of equality. We couldn’t save Jason but we can save merit from the monstrous jaws of identity. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why Good People Disagree About Right and Wrong
My convo with Cornell moral psychologist Audun Dahl based on his new book Between Fixed and Fickle, a must read for anyone interested in this topic—and who isn't interested in the psychology of morality?!
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-good-people-disa… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sure, Cambridge has some responsibility for relaxing its standards in the name of DEI to elevate Arday so high (& to fall so far), but the general response has been the equivalent of accusing The New Republic of enabling Stephen Glass entirely, as if he had no culpability in making up all those stories.
Personal responsibility matters the most. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"It is a look that says, 'How far you’ve come, and how kind I am for helping you go further'."
White progressives to successful blacks, whose agency is thereby so diminished.
www.theatlantic.com/culture/2026/08/jason-arday-cambridge… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
FYI, Amazon Prime just demonetized the documentary S4: The Bob Lazar Story so you can watch it free if you subscribe. It is very well done with amazing CGI reenacting what Lazar said he saw and did there, including climbing inside the "sport" model of the UFO.
I watch these films because it's part of my job, but I don't believe a word of what Lazar says. After UFOlogist Stan Friedman exposed Lazar lying about his academic credentials—he said he earned graduate degrees in physics at MIT and Caltech, but Stan revealed that Lazar didn't even attend either institution and instead took a few classes at Pierce Community College in L.A.—in my mind that discredited him. But a great many UFO and UAP people put a lot of credence in his testimony, mainly because of the details and Bob comes across so likable and genuine.
Unfortunately most fabulists are like that, including and especially the tragic case of the Cambridge University prof Jason Arday, who by all accounts was a very sympathetic person and just published his memoir from Simon and Schuster on Tuesday, filled with endless lies and exaggerations about his made-up life (e.g., he didn't run 30 marathons in 35 days, the last 9 on a broken leg).
Lazar is just one of many in a long line of impostures: Frank Abagnale Jr., Stephen Glass, Stephen Frey, etc. (Wikipedia lists hundreds). The film "Shattered Glass" is about how Stephen Glass fooled the editors and fact checkers at The New Republic for dozens of articles he completely fabricated. Everyone there loved him because he was so charming and funny.
It's hard for people to believe that Lazar made up all those details about S4, but why? Read any science fiction work and they are filled with details about completely made-up places and events. That's why it's called fiction.
youtu.be/c3qBNo3PAjU -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Or @ibramxk one can just stop lying and exaggerating and actually earn one's accomplishments the same way as everyone else has to do it. It may not be as glamorous (30 marathons in 35 days on a broken leg!) but all the successful black scholars who didn't lie make the point.
Ibram X. Kendi
@ibramxk
The death of Jason Arday hit so close to home that I had no words yesterday. But I woke up with words.
To be a prominent antiracist Black scholar is to know you are a target, almost totally surrounded by resentments. You know that at any point, the attacks can come like a lynch mob.
And if you die from all the attacks, the media still calls the attacks on you “accusations” to wash their hands of the blood. Your lynchers announce your death as if they had no role in your lynching.
My latest at The Emancipator.
theemancipator.org/2026/08/15/ideas/the-media-lynched-jas… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Indigenous Knowledge, Public Money, and Bad Science
Robert Bartholomew's latest on Māori knowledge (and "other ways of know") vs. science for Skeptic:
www.skeptic.com/article/maori-antarctica-myth-new-zealand… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
At 8:28am PT 8/13 my flight from SFO took off for Hawaii. At 8:30am PT a 3.8 earthquake hit San Francisco. Our pilot announced that we narrowly missed the airport closure. Landed Kailua Kona only to be told we are now in the eye of a major hurricane. I feel like Forrest Gump…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Case in point:
Headline does not match what was actually said.
Correction:
David Grusch Claims he has seen photographs of or talked to people who told him that we have evidence of non-human craft in U.S. possession.
Why is it so hard for nearly everyone to report this accurately? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For the umpteenth time: I too have seen photographs & videos of aliens & spaceships, and talked to people who say they've seen them (& even been abducted).
So?
That doesn't make aliens & spaceships real.
The ones I've seen are fake or unidentified (the U in UFO).
Show us!
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Note the shift in the narrative from "I've never seen any aliens or spaceships myself but I know and have talked to people who have"
to
"it's true, we have aliens here and they communicate using telepathy."
No.
By his own words Grusch does NOT know that. He knows people who SAY they know that.
Can we at long last move past these secondary & tertiary accounts and see for ourselves the actual aliens and spaceships?
Tom Thompson🛸 (CORTEX ZERO)
@Cortex_Zero
🚨⚠️ David Grusch just made one of his most extraordinary public statements yet in his interview with Dr. Phil.
During a discussion about alleged UFO crash-retrieval programs, @DrPhil directly asks Grusch whether he has seen evidence involving cadavers and pilots recovered with the craft.
Grusch says yes, but then goes further.
He describes cases in which alleged occupants were recovered alive, and indicates that there has been communication with these beings.
The conversation then takes another remarkable turn when Grusch references a former Vice President whose identity, he says, everyone could probably guess. Rather than naming him directly, Grusch jokingly calls him “Darth Vader”, which I know to be a long-standing nickname associated with Dick Cheney.
In other words, Grusch appears to be pointing directly at Cheney while discussing the historical power structure surrounding the UAP legacy program.
The implications of the exchange are difficult to overstate: Grusch is no longer speaking only about recovered craft or biological remains. He is publicly alleging living non-human occupants, communication with them, and involvement reaching into the highest levels of the U.S. government. #ufox #ufotwitterThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hey @goodswan123 re-read your own post and mine. We're saying the same thing. You're making my point.
To repeat: he has not personally seen aliens and spaceships but has seen photos and talked to people who SAY that they have. So this is secondary or tertiary level.
Sawan
@goodsawan123
Hey dumb ass he said he’s seen photos and videos of the craft and biologics dumb mofo retard
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Note the shift in the narrative from "I've never seen any aliens or spaceships myself but I know and have talked to people who have"
to
"it's true, we have aliens here and they communicate using telepathy."
No.
By his own words Grusch does NOT know that. He knows people who SAY they know that.
Can we at long last move past these secondary & tertiary accounts and see for ourselves the actual aliens and spaceships?
Tom Thompson🛸 (CORTEX ZERO)
@Cortex_Zero
🚨⚠️ David Grusch just made one of his most extraordinary public statements yet in his interview with Dr. Phil.
During a discussion about alleged UFO crash-retrieval programs, @DrPhil directly asks Grusch whether he has seen evidence involving cadavers and pilots recovered with the craft.
Grusch says yes, but then goes further.
He describes cases in which alleged occupants were recovered alive, and indicates that there has been communication with these beings.
The conversation then takes another remarkable turn when Grusch references a former Vice President whose identity, he says, everyone could probably guess. Rather than naming him directly, Grusch jokingly calls him “Darth Vader”, which I know to be a long-standing nickname associated with Dick Cheney.
In other words, Grusch appears to be pointing directly at Cheney while discussing the historical power structure surrounding the UAP legacy program.
The implications of the exchange are difficult to overstate: Grusch is no longer speaking only about recovered craft or biological remains. He is publicly alleging living non-human occupants, communication with them, and involvement reaching into the highest levels of the U.S. government. #ufox #ufotwitterThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To be clear: Eric Davis has not seen any aliens or spaceships himself. He says he has seen photographs & read testimony by people who say they have (or examined physical materials he can't explain), so this is secondary (or tertiary) whistleblower level. Further, Trump has already lifted NDA restrictions, but if additional POTUS signatures are needed then by all means provide them President Trump, because we are all tired of hearing whistleblowers state they know aliens are real but can't show us because of such restrictions.
James Fox
@jamescfox
Aerospace engineer Dr. Eric Davis also claims to have seen classified photos of recovered craft and nonhuman bodies -- he is requesting immunity from President Trump so he can speak freely to the American public.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Many responses to this tragedy reveal what led to it in the first place: lack taking personal responsibility & holding others to the same standard.
Arday CHOSE to lie, exaggerate & fabricate his life & accomplishments. No one made him do that. And it wasn't necessary. LOTS of POC & people with disabilities achieve great things in life.
That the media & public took notice when he got caught is only because he was a Cambridge professor. If he were a professor at Podunk Community College no one would have noticed or cared.
If you choose to live a lie then you have to face the consequences. If you are a spouse & parent as well, all the more reason why you shouldn't have done so in the first place.
Suicide is tragic, yes, but it is also the coward's way out of taking personal responsibility, made all the worse by choosing to abandon your spouse & children.
I know, it sounds callous, but heaping sympathy on people who lied to get your sympathy in the first place, is not the solution.
A good start is to hold yourself and others responsible.
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/14/world/europe/jason-arday-dead.… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is indeed a tragedy, but one self-inflicted from start to finish & not the result of his race or mental disabilities or anything else. The scrutiny was only & entirely of the fact that he lied about his life to such an extent the “truth default” principle was violated.
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
The Jason Arday story has now taken the grimmest possible turn.
www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/144a8b7f5680e129 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you are one of millions who believe "the body keeps the score"—past trauma manifests in bodily signs that you can "recover" like the long debunked "recovered memory" nonsense, read this alternative account of what actually happens to the body.
More to come on this topic... -
Michael Shermer reposted
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Many people believe the police kill hundreds or even thousands of unarmed Black men every year. The real number is about a dozen.
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/police-killings-perception…
welcome to our trash revolution
@trash_panda97
i think when people say “woke 1 was crazy” they should be required to specify exactly what was so crazy about it because i’m getting scared 😐
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Woke Poisons Everything
Including sports.
Case in point: the WNBA has spiraled into chaos over woke issues having nothing to do with basketball. The goal should be to put the ball through the hoop, not social justice, DEI, trans/LGBTQ, etc.
Ridiculous.
www.wsj.com/sports/basketball/how-the-wnba-season-spirale… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“If you look at the data on so much of the current research on capitalism, sexism, racism, you’ll see that sociology is misrepresenting the evidence, concealing the evidence or distorting it outright. Every day, the goal in my work is to not do politics. My job is to imagine someone in my mind who has the opposite assumptions and go back and forth with them to test my ideas. I don’t think most sociologists realize the magnitude of their own bias and the weakness of the evidence supporting their claims.”
—Sociologist Keven McCaffree
www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Sociology’s sacred project champions emancipation, autonomy, equality, justice, inclusion, diversity, open-mindedness, progress, tolerance, and cosmopolitanism. In the end that sacred project actually tends to produce sectarian narrowness, exclusion, uniformity, silencing, self-censorship, lack of debate, the negative sanctioning of nonconformists, and the debilitation of rigorous thought.”
—Sociologist Christian Smith
www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If environmental activists were smart @BjornLomborg they would take credit for saving the Great Barrier Reef, along with cleaner air and water, greener land, etc., but pessimism & doomsdayism gets more media coverage & donations than progress, so this will be ignored.
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
New data for Great Barrier Reef: Last five years best on record
Yet, media wrote its obituary in 2014
Research told us it would be almost gone in 2022
Not all scare stories are true
www.aims.gov.au/monitoring-great-barrier-reef/gbr-conditi…
x.com/BjornLomborg/status/2087555731654668425
www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2014/mar/g…
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
New 2026 data
Great Barrier Reef: Last five years best on record
Why doesn't the media tell you?
www.aims.gov.au/monitoring-great-barrier-reef/gbr-conditi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Moral Arc
Earlier I discussed this in The Science of Good and Evil
Dr. Theo 🇺🇸
@Tedlinknews
@michaelshermer what was the name of the book where you discussed how crime/immoral behavior increases as villages grow larger, towns grow larger, and residents begin to not know most folks in their village or community? It was very interesting.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Evidence for Roger Penrose’s conformal cyclic cosmology, which means the Big Bang was not THE beginning but A beginning in what could be infinite universes and time. If this holds up how will theists work it into their belief about God?
Dailyscienceinfo
@NatureScienceA1
Find out more
news.sciandnature.com/2024/11/scientists-find-evidence-of… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Imagine professional geologists announcing their field is now “a form of liberatory praxis” that is “currently undergoing a renaissance as antiracist, decolonial, feminist, queer and transnational theorizing lead us to more inclusive insights.”
Absurd.
www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Did you know about "Sociologists for Palestine"?
I didn't.
Is there a "Sociologists for Israel"?
I doubt it.
How about?:
"Physicists for Keynesian Economics"
"Biologists for Supply Side Economics"
"Neuroscientists for North Korea"
Insanity
www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Nearly everything that we have created will be reduced to trace elements and isotopes, but for a few specimens lucky enough to be fossilized. For all of the other details of our world to persist in human memory, science would need to get better, or civilization itself would need to keep existing, and telling its own story, from now until then."
Becoming a multi-planetary species would do that...
www.theatlantic.com/science/2026/08/human-origins-dna-too… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is there life after death?
My debate with neurosurgeon (and Christian) Michael Egnor on @piersmorgan :
scienceandculture.com/2026/08/fossil-explosions-persist-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
There's no doubt about it in this matter: If UAPs = ETIs and we had them? Trump would be all over it in Prime Time to make the biggest announcement in history. Does the fact that it hasn't happened mean anything?
Is the absence of evidence, evidence of absence?
We shall see.
Red Panda Koala
@RedPandaKoala
🚨 Secretary of State Marco Rubio says Trump will give a national adress if they uncover what UFOs are
"I assure you, in this administration, if we knew, the President would be all over it.
There would be a prime time adress, he would be showing pictures and videos." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Everyone was doing it, not just in cycling, so we were just doing what everyone else was doing. We convinced ourselves that we weren’t doping, because if everyone’s doing it, then cycling is still all about talent"
—1997 Tour de France winner Jan Ullrich on how the playing field was level (although some doping doctors may have been better than others).
This is why no one has claimed @lancearmstrong 7 TdF titles: they were all doping & know who actually won those races.
This is not an excuse for doping, but a game theoretic analysis showing that doping was more of a rational choice than an ethical dilemma.
www.domestiquecycling.com/en/news/jan-ullrich-opens-up-ab… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"There is a certain mercy in the impression that he won’t perceive how those who elevated him saw him as a performing monkey. Still, it’s long past time for anglophone academia to stop thinking that it’s immoral to evaluate black scholars on the basis of whether they are—get ready!—intelligent."
www.thefp.com/p/jason-arday-cambridge-academia-mediocrity… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"This House Hopes Hell Exists"
My statement at the Oxford Union: it doesn't matter if you hope hell does or does not exist as to its ontological status! (They argued that people need to believe in hell to be good.)
We won so...hell does not exist?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECixM2qGd3U -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“So far, the publicly available data on UAP is not good enough to unambiguously associate UAP with alien (non-human made) technologies. The only way to resolve their nature is by allocating resources to the collection of new data or materials from them.”
@ProfAviLoeb -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
BTW, fabulist Nick Clark entered the 2018 Race Across America (RAAM) that I co-founded & competed in 5 times (Race Director 15 times) to raise money for his deceased wife & local police (so he said).
DNF'd early. You can't fake doing RAAM. It's too hard.
www.fcnp.com/2018/06/14/61007/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My favorite example in the genre of fabulists is Nick Clark, the cyclist who was exposed by local riders for his exaggerated Strava KOM (King of the Mountain) times. For years he said he raced professionally in Europe, that he was also a military soldier/weapons instructor, a high-earning CEO for a chemical company, a lawyer, an academic, and a hostage responder.
Most people have no way (or time) to fact check some dude lying about his life, but we all know what real Strava KOM times are like and THAT we can check!
www.ride-mtb.com/en/news/the-professional-cyclist-who-nev… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm always amused by fabricators athletic claims, like N. Korea's state media claiming that Kim Jong-il shot a 38 under par round of golf, including 11 holes-in-one, in his first round! But Arday doesn't live in a totalitarian state where lies are normal.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How egregious are Jason Arday's claims in his new memoir out today?
—Nonverbal autistic until age 12
—Couldn't read/write until age 18
—Dyslexic
—Epileptic bc beaten by 4 boys whom he forgave
—2 of the boys took his class & hugged him
—Brain tumor
—Mini-stroke & memory loss
—Ran 30 marathons in 35 days; in #20 he fell & broke his fibula but ran 10 more anyway
I would say you can't make this stuff up, but obviously you can. That he got away with it in academia for so long is an indictment not just of him, but of the institution. Shameful.
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/10/books/review/jason-arday-memoi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Academia should have as its purpose the pursuit of truth, Veritas, not virtue, diversity, social justice, etc. That is ultimately what enabled Jason Arday to plagiarize his work & fabricate his life to such an extent, as @JohnHMcWhorter explains:
www.city-journal.org/article/cambridge-professor-jason-ar… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"There is no doubt that Simon & Schuster would never sign any celebrated novelist who had posted publicly that Muslims were parasites, vampires, demons, and ghouls." But when it comes to the Jews...
www.thefp.com/p/simon-schuster-susan-abulhawa-antisemitis… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
81 years ago today…
www.skeptic.com/article/the-moral-case-for-dropping-the-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the story about the triangular-shaped UAP in the 5th DOW tranche, without more information there's no way to know what observers actually saw. Frustrating that the government still redacts.
Here is what I wrote about the Belgian triangle UAP in Truth.
nypost.com/2026/08/08/us-news/ufo-over-colorado-base-in-v… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good response from @ProfAviLoeb to @MickWest on the calculations of a UAP
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
Mick does not explain how he arrived at his altitude estimate. A serious scientific critic should show the calculation and explain why the published value is wrong. Scientists are accustomed to criticism in academia, but such criticism normally comes with arguments explaining why an analysis is incorrect. We get none here. An assertion that the analysis is wrong is not a substitute for demonstrating where it fails.
Our 2.2–2.3 km altitude estimate comes from identifying the site using Google Earth and Google Maps. In no scenario did the inferred height fall below 2 km.
More importantly, the results are largely independent of this maximum height. It simply constrains how high the object is allowed to be. The paper explicitly presents separate comparisons for object heights of 500, 1,000, 1,500 and 2,000 meters, based on the frame-rate analysis. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the 2021 UAP incident during a live fire exercise in the Gulf of Oman:
"Formation flying, reaction to a threat, interacting with each other is exactly the behavioral signature one would expect from a centrally-coordinated drone swarm."
@ProfAviLoeb
avi-loeb.medium.com/remarkable-anomalies-in-the-fifth-tra… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The View From Inside:
How Mind Emerged From Mindless Matter
Psychiatrist Ralph Lewis on the hard problem of consciousness whose answer starts with the first cells for which there was an inside & outside. What’s it like to be inside the cell?
www.skeptic.com/article/how-consciousness-evolved-from-mi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is There a UFO Base on the Moon?
Betteridge's law of headlines:
"Any headline that ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no."
avi-loeb.medium.com/is-there-a-ufo-base-on-the-moon-af6eb… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re UAPs, a deeply religious friend tells me that the explanation is in 2 Thessalonians 2:8-10:
"And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord Jesus will overthrow with the breath of his mouth and destroy by the splendor of his coming.
The coming of the lawless one will be in accordance with how Satan works. He will use all sorts of displays of power through signs and wonders that serve the lie,
and all the ways that wickedness deceives those who are perishing. They perish because they refused to love the truth and so be saved."
Oh dear! I love the truth. But if UAPs are the tools of Satan then I'm doomed... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Two members of our UAP Science Advisory Council Dr. Devesh Nandal & @ProfAviLoeb determine that one of the files in DOW's 5th tranche is likely a missile, using "background terrain, which can be used as a coordinate system to infer the motions of the target object as well as the camera, as functions of time."
avi-loeb.medium.com/the-declassified-dow-uap-pr043-in-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is there such a thing as objective truth?
Are we living in a post-truth world?
The full convo with @neiltyson @StarTalkRadio on finding truth in an era of motivated reasoning, misinformation, and alternative facts.
youtu.be/3yrcD4Ob3qw -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why did reason evolve?
To find the truth or to win arguments?
My answer for @neiltyson @StarTalkRadio
youtube.com/shorts/E8cXOJlyMZY -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Tucker says America needs: fairness, sovereignty, productivity, beauty, health, honesty, optimism, wisdom, decency, and unity.
As @DouglasKMurray notes: "there is no point in uttering a phrase the opposite of which would be uttered only by a madman."
www.thefp.com/p/douglas-murray-tucker-carlson-10-point-pl… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Default to Truth theory on display in Jason Arday's likely massively fabricated story. Fabulists get away with it, in part, because most people don't make things up like this + who has time to fact check such people?
Universities & publishers do & should but dropped their skepticism in preference for a fabulous story—remember Stephen Glass, James Frey & Frank Abagnale Jr.?
www.theatlantic.com/books/2026/08/jason-arday-cambridge-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another batch of signed copies of Truth, these all personalized (43...tired hand!).
Get your signed copy here:
shop.skeptic.com/products/truth -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Regarding the Arday affair (black Cambridge professor accused of plagiarism), research by Skeptic Research Center's Kevin McCaffrey and @JukkaSavo shows:
"In sociology hiring, race was linked to placement prestige at least as strongly as having a publication in the field’s flagship journals. Black candidates reached top departments with significantly weaker records—evidence of a systemic double standard, not just anecdotes."
www.compactmag.com/article/the-statistics-behind-the-jaso…
Jukka Savolainen
@JukkaSavo
The Arday affair raises an important question: Is this a one-off scandal or the tip of the iceberg? My research with Kevin speaks directly to that debate. @compactmag
www.compactmag.com/article/the-statistics-behind-the-jaso… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Finally, The Truth with Michael Shermer (with @neiltyson on @StarTalkRadio )
It's never too late to discover the truth about anything...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3yrcD4Ob3qw -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just finished one of the best books I’ve ever read on WWII. Puts the lie to the claim that nukes were unnecessary bc the Japanese were about to surrender. Not so. Scott documents even after Nagasaki the war mongers running the country wanted to fight to the end & even plotted a coup against those who wanted peace, but Hirohito finally found the courage to stand up to the warriors who didn’t care if millions more died. They had 5 million soldiers and tens of thousands of Kamakazis ready to combat an American invasion. Atomic bombs were absolutely the right use.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes, I know, there are many UAP cases still unexplained, which is why @ProfAviLoeb UAP Science Advisory Council is so important. Let’s all work to figure out as many as we can & disclose what would be the greatest discovery in human history if true. Is it? Let’s find out.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Great claims require great evidence, and the evidence just isn’t there yet.” —Jon Kosloski, AARO director
“In science, eyewitness testimony is kind of opinion; it’s not data. I have never seen anything that couldn’t be explained.” —Scott Kelly
"I haven’t seen them. They’re not being kept at Area 51. There’s no underground facility—unless there’s this enormous conspiracy and they hid it from the President of the United States.” —Barack Obama
time.com/article/2026/08/06/america-taking-extraterrestri… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Great claims require great evidence, and the evidence just isn’t there yet.” —Jon Kosloski, AARO director
“In science, eyewitness testimony is kind of opinion; it’s not data. I have never seen anything that couldn’t be explained.” —Scott Kelly
"I haven’t seen them. They’re not being kept at Area 51. There’s no underground facility—unless there’s this enormous conspiracy and they hid it from the President of the United States.” —Barack Obama
time.com/article/2026/08/06/america-taking-extraterrestri… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation on the @michaelshermer show about my new book on AI, The God Test. You can read the intro and chapter excerpts at thegodtest dot net.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are We Building a God?
My convo with @robertwrighter on AI, Superintelligence, and the Coming Singularity
(Reminds me of when I asked Ray Kurzweil if he thinks there is a God. "We're working on it.")
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/are-we-building-a-go… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
We Can’t Just Lie About Sex Differences
(Well, lots of liberals & progressives do lie about sex differences all the time, but we call them out on it with the truth when we can.) @SteveStuWill explains:
www.skeptic.com/article/is-evolutionary-psychology-pseudo… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Since I am not a professional philosopher, and because I am stepping into a philosophical debate that has been raging ever since David Hume articulated the Is/Ought naturalistic fallacy, I asked the philosopher Robert Pennock to assess my argument for a science of morality. Here is what he told me on my podcast episode discussing this issue:
The way the argument works is to say if you want to get a moral conclusion you need at least one moral premise. It’s not that there aren’t factual premises—and this I took to be your main point, that science gives us some moral premises that make a difference—and that’s exactly right. But the naturalistic fallacy doesn’t say you can’t have factual premises. It says you can’t have only factual premises. You have to have something that has an ought, such that together with the is you can get an ought in the conclusion. And I would say that the way you make your argument is actually bringing in oughts into your premises and so you’re not actually denying the naturalistic fallacy. Really, you’re accepting it but building in some ought premises from the beginning. And that’s the right way to do it! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To go on the record that I am not a dogmatically closed-minded skeptic who refuses to be open to the possibility of aliens and anomalous experiences that people have, listen to my conversation with Jeffrey Kripal, one of the foremost scholars of the topic:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/how-to-think-about-s… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the briefest version of my defense of free will/ compatibilism (from that chapter in Truth):
In debates over free will and determinism, this question is considered central to resolving the issue: in a rewind of the tape of your life could you have done otherwise?
Well, if it is a Read Only Memory (ROM) tape, then no, you could not have done otherwise, because the tape would just be a recording of what you already did, so replaying it would just be a review of the already determined past. And if the entire universe is, in essence, a ROM tape that has already happened (rendering time an illusion for those inside the universe), this “block universe” (as it is called by cosmologists ), means that in a replay everything would repeat exactly as it originally happened, and determinism would be true and free will would be an illusion.
But that is not the universe we live in. Because of contingency, the Second Law of Thermodynamics, and the entropic one-way arrow of time from past to present through an unending and near-infinite number of bifurcating branches in the decision tree of life, the future is not just unknown; it is unknowable.
Call it Heraclitus’s Dictum, after the ancient Greek philosopher’s observation: “No man ever steps in the same river twice. For it is not the same river and he is not the same man.”
What you did in the past influences what you choose to do next in future circumstances, which are always different from the past. The tape of life cannot be rewound, and the most any future scenario could be is an imperfect simulacrum of the past, from which you (presumably) learned from having already lived through it and thus could choose to act differently.
Although the past is determined, we are active agents in determining our lives going forward in a self-determined way, in the context of what already happened and what might happen in the not-yet-determined future. In this sense, then, the world is not pre-determined but rather post-determined, and we are part of the causal net of the myriad determining factors to create that post-determined future. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I am recording an episode of my show with Columbia University neuroscientist and Santa Fe Institute chaos/complexity researcher Stuart Firestein. His book is fabulous and the title hints at the determinist's question "could you have done otherwise?"
What else should we discuss? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My convo with @SteveStuWill on his new book. Astonishing that after a billion years of sex differences the matter has become a political issue the last half century with one side (blank slaters) insisting any differences must be environmental/prejudice.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/the-truth-about-sex-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are We Building a God?
My convo with @robertwrighter on AI, Superintelligence, and the Coming Singularity
(Reminds me of when I asked Ray Kurzweil if he thinks there is a God. "We're working on it.")
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/are-we-building-a-go… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The ending to my chapter on aliens in Truth still stands:
Given that there is no more evidence for aliens than there is for God, believers in either one must take a leap of faith or suspend judgment until evidence emerges to the contrary to change one’s credence. Until then, I’ll give the last word to Lt. Commander Alex Dietrich, who witnessed the 2004 UAP incident from a USS Nimitz fighter jet, as I think it well sums up 75 years of UFOlogists’ search for aliens:
"I think they enjoy the anticipation more than actually finding answers." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why are UAPers still talking about taking polygraph tests, oath swearing, promising disclosure will come one day? The restrictions have been lifted by POTUS himself. Stop talking about disclosure & tell the government where, exactly, the aliens & their spaceships are located.
Interstellar
@InterstellarUAP
🚨 Lue Elizondo BOMBSHELL "If UAP Gerb can prove that I colluded with Lt. General James Clapper to control the UFO Disclosure narrative - I will leave Ufology forever" 🛸👽😱
"I am willing to take a polygraph test & I would encourage UAP Gerb's source to take one too. Whoever fails must leave Ufology."
There is speculation that UAP Gerb's source could be David Grusch.
Some statement from Lue Elizondo 👀 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It's time for real disclosure UAPers. Tell the government exactly where the aliens and their spaceships are located. Some UAP whistleblowers claim they know people who know where they are. It is now okay to disclose the location(s).
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
The question “why would some UAP NDAs bar disclosure to the President?” suggests that something concrete enough to warrant this level of structural protection exists, whether that turns out to be genuinely exotic or something far more conventional but still highly sensitive.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Name that mystery man on the left...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Question:
Why is Congress so focused on Anthony Fauci as if he's the only one who knows the truth about the pandemic?
There must be a great many others in government associated with Fauci, NIAID, CDC, HHS, etc. they could question who knew the truth.
Offer them a pardon to talk.
We know another pandemic is coming.
We also know Americans are going to be hugely skeptical of anything these orgs recommend because of how they handled Covid.
We need a Truth-and-Reconciliation Commission to get to the bottom of what happened, when, why, etc. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Please read Avi Loeb’s clarifications and open questions regarding the memo from the ODNI on waiving UAP related NDAs.
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
Thank you @RepEricBurlison, @RepLuna, and @timburchett for your tireless work and leadership on UAP transparency. And thank you to @POTUS for supporting this important effort.
This consequential development directly targets the evidentiary problem that has run through past claims about alien technology which is withheld within the U.S. government. David Grusch’s testimony, @g_knapp's Lockheed material claims and @LueElizondo's account, have all been limited by witnesses citing classification and NDA constraints as reasons they could not fully corroborate their claims. If genuinely implemented, this memo removes that specific excuse for the exact people whose corroboration has been missing.
The UAP Science Advisory Council (uapsac.com) under my leadership, will be delighted to analyze any new UAP data or materials that is revealed through this process. We plan to share our findings with the public because of what @DepDNILukas states on the logo of his X account: “Americans deserve the truth.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yeah yeah, billions of people fed who would otherwise starve @mattwridley but what about the exhaust from the tractor contributing to global warming in the next 75 years? Isn't that more important?
No.
Get our priorities straight.
What is the most effective way to save lives?
Matt Ridley
@mattwridley
Cutting wheat yesterday: roughly 100 grains harvested for each grain sown. In the 1300s on the Bishop of Winchester's manors, 5:1 was a good harvest, 3:1 a bad one. Thank you, Haber-Bosch nitrogen fixation and hydrocarbons, for feeding billions and sparing land.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"UAP Disclosure is No Longer Optional"
I'm stunned at UAPers response to this.
You would think they would be thrilled by this protection of whistleblowers so they can at long last show us the aliens.
But no!
It's almost as if they prefer the promise over the actual disclosure.
Why is that?
avi-loeb.medium.com/uap-disclosure-is-no-longer-optional-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Either the US government and/or corporations have alien tech or not. The days of “I know they do but I can’t tell you” are over. We take your claims about disclosure seriously. Time to put up or shut up.
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
UAP disclosure is no longer optional. Our cosmic neighbors will not go away if we keep UAP knowledge secret. The fundamental question remains: “Is there any indisputable evidence for alien tech?” We all deserve to know one way or another.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Disclosure of information related to Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) with potential association with non-human made technologies, is no longer optional for former or current U.S. Government employees."
"No longer optional" UAPers. If you have 1st- or 2nd-hand knowledge of alien technology you now have to reveal it to AARO or a PURSUE rep.
Actual disclosure of aliens (if real) is now here. Stop talking about aliens and show them to our officials so we can all see what is really going on.
avi-loeb.medium.com/uap-disclosure-is-no-longer-optional-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can You Trust Wikipedia?
My convo with Co-Founder Larry Sanger on Wikipedia’s Bias and Why He Was Banned
+ 2nd half I challenge him on his religious beliefs...
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/can-you-trust-wikipe… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Isn't opening borders to illegal migrants the open tolerant liberal thing to do?
No.
And liberals who let conservatives control the narrative that all countries have borders that must be enforced will and should lose elections as @DouglasKMurray explains:
www.thefp.com/p/douglas-murray-europes-borderless?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“now we know the market was not the source, it was the amplifier” —Anthony Fauci, January 26, 2020
For years I gave the benefit of the doubt to Fauci & others that they erred on the side of caution (Precautionary Principle) rather than they lied to us.
I'm sorry to say that the latter is true on masks, school/business closures, social distancing & even what, exactly, the vaccine can and cannot do.
We will be paying the price for these lies for decades to come, especially when the next pandemic hits and no one believes what scientists and medical experts recommend. @geraldposner analysis nails it:
open.substack.com/pub/geraldposner/p/written-for-an-audie… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I've read ~ 500 books on UFOs/UAPs @BordleyStephen & have an entire bookcase of them in my office. Plus a dozen podcast episodes with authors of new UFO books:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/nick-pope-on-uaps-uf…
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/neil-degrasse-tyson-…
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/the-hardest-ufo-case…
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/government-transpare…
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/are-we-meant-to-leav…
DisclosureWatch (Slava Ukraini)
@BordleyStephen
How many books have you read on the UAP topic? Gonna guess a big fat zero. There is no way to do a deep dive on this topic and not realize the complexity of the phenomena.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @AndyFjD
I understand few people read books any more, with our attention spans not much longer than a 280-character tweet, so if you don't want to read my book here's my solo podcast summary of it you can listen to while driving (it's free!):
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/truth-still-matters-…
Andy
@AndyFJD
lol… I’d love to know what you think the “Truth” is. But I don’t want to read a book to get there.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another example of patternicity? A reader sends me these images from Mars, which he wonders if it's a "Perseverance Sky crane" or "Viking"? Describes it as "quite clear this object is a physical object" and so wonders:
"Would the dissemination of these specific images to the general public create a global upheaval and potentially destabilize the world economy?"
I have asked if he has clearer/focused photographs, but in the meantime, is it just me, or is this thing so unclear and blurry as to be indistinguishable from a rock formation? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not to establish a base rate for spookiness at different locations (not just Skinwalker Ranch) is called "base rate neglect". Here is how I explain it in Truth with a medical diagnosis:
You go to the doctor not feeling well and they run some diagnostic tests, which indicate that you might have cancer. They tell you that this disease happens to 1 out of 100 people, or a 1% prevalence rate. The test sensitivity for this type of cancer is 90%, that is, the test will be right 90% of the time. The false positive rate of the test is 9%, that is, the test will be wrong 9% of the time. What is the percent likelihood that you have cancer?
When people are presented with this problem, the most common answer given is between 80% and 90%. The correct answer is 9%. This problem is so counterintuitive that not only do most people get it wrong, most medical professionals get it wrong. What has gone wrong here?
Let’s reframe the problem on a group of people tested for cancer and see how that cashes out on the diagnosis problem:
· In a sample size of 1,000 people, 10 have cancer (the base rate of 1%).
· Of these 10 people, 9 will test positive (the 90% sensitivity of the test).
· Of the 990 people without cancer, 89 will test positive (the 9% false-positive rate).
· A person tests positive. Does this person have cancer or not?
Here is how we compute the answer:
· Out of 1,000 people tested for cancer
· 98 of them test positive in all (9 + 89)
· 9 of them have cancer
· 9 divided by 98 = 0.091 or ~ 9%
Why do most people get such problems wrong in the original framing? The answer is base rate neglect, that is, the rate of the phenomenon happening is ignored or discounted, in this case a low 1% base rate means the cancer is rare (in Bayesian language, the prior probability was low), and the rate of false positives applied to the entire sample size is ignored.
Here is how Steven Pinker explains the problem:
"Why can’t we predict who will attempt suicide? Why don’t we have an early-warning system for school shooters? Why can’t we profile terrorists or rampage shooters and detain them preventively? The answer comes out of Bayes’s rule: a less-than-perfect test for a rare trait will mainly turn out false positives. The heart of the problem is that only a tiny proportion of the population are thieves, suicides, terrorists, or rampage shooters (the base rate). Until the day that social scientists can predict misbehavior as accurately as astronomers predict eclipses, their best tests would mostly finger the innocent and harmless." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here's another way to think about testing paranormal claims about Skinwalker Ranch:
For a documentary on which I was a talking head on “cursed horror films,” I used a simple 2x2 matrix of causality. The producers were interested in horror films in which the production or actors or crew are cursed in some way, completely ignoring all the non-cursed horror films, cursed non-horror films, and non-cursed non-horror films. After I explained it to them they realized there was nothing left to explain. Astonishingly they included my analysis in the documentary film (trailer with my explanation below).
I think this goes some way to explaining what is happening with Skinwalker Ranch. The test is NOT what the History Channel is doing in bringing out out all the tech people with their equipment; the test would be to go somewhere else and see if they find weird things happening. You would need to actually establish some baseline (base rate) of noises and events that happen regularly, and then see if there’s a significant difference.
youtu.be/8hIBBZn9g2o -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To test if Skinwalker Ranch is really unusual @BrandonFugal @AlchemyAmerican I would employ the comparison method, namely, if I visited and/or spent the night at any ranch anywhere in the world, and brought all that equipment, and looked for anything even remotely spooky or weird, would Skinwalker stand out as significantly different from any other location? THAT’S the test. Not if anything weird happens there. I’m sure it does. But compared to what?
Several years ago I spent the night in the allegedly haunted Linda Vista Hospital in East L.A. (now closed and used for TV shows & for movie sets) with 2 teams of paranormal researchers, who came equipped with all their electronic gear in search of ghosts, poltergeists, etc. The producers of the show had told each of the paranormal teams about weird deaths and spooky happenings in each of two rooms. I was one of three “expert” judges to determine which team was the best at finding ghosts.
I could see immediately what was going to happen, so I asked the producers to give me a third room and let me make up completely different and entirely fabricated stories to each of the 2 paranormal research teams about a 3rd room, which I did. Predictably, each of the two teams “found” exactly what I told them they would find (I told one team that the room in the hospital was for geriatric patients dying of caner, and to the other team I told them the same room was for childhood cancer patients who died there), based on nothing more than the general background noise present in any location, especially a creeky old building that, at night, is especially prone to spooky noises. The producers were astonished that no one had ever proposed such a simple test for them and agreed with me in the end that there was actually nothing to explain. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Lab-Grown Meat:
Separating the Science From the “Yuck”
Katherine Brodsky's latest for Skeptic:
www.skeptic.com/article/lab-grown-meat-inside-cleanest-ki… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I know, not all alien abductions can be explained by sleep paralysis; in fact, some happen for the opposite reason: no sleep at all, like what happened to this guy after 83 hours of sleeplessness: youtu.be/X2_1DofIVqg
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Ben Lamm
@BenLamm
Colossal does have a dire wolf genome (2). We did test the sample and a high percentage was unidentified but that is typical with decaying specimens and contamination. It doesn’t mean it was dire wolf. Dire wolves were over 99% grey wolf. the unknown was just contamination.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Ah's frae Cumbria marra eh
@daresoftware
I used to suffer sleep paralysis when I was younger. Absolutely terrifying, and the alien abduction / incubus / succubus / demon myths all make sense to anyone who's experienced it. But really it was just caused by a bad lifetstyle and bad sleep patterns.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
David J Texaco
@DavidTexaco
Mike Rogers (driver) was our gardener in Pinetop, AZ for 30 years. I asked him for 30 years. He would never talk about it. Before he died he told me, “we were young and dumb and it was all Travis’s and his brother’s idea, I don’t think they thought it would be such a big deal.”
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Since I posted that sleep paralysis explains some alien abduction stories, people ask me about Travis Walton. Here is what I wrote in Truth:
This all reminds me of the most famous alien abduction case on record—that of Travis Walton on November 5, 1975 in Arizona (made into a major motion picture called Fire in the Sky )—which I wrote about in the context of appearing with Travis on a 2008 television show called The Moment of Truth. The show involved lie detector tests given to claimants who agreed to appear on the show. Apparently Walton was so confident in this belief that he really was abducted by aliens he must of thought that his body would not betray him. Unfortunately for him, while recounting his abduction experience he failed the polygraph test. Years later I received an email from one Kelley Waldrip, who grew up with Walton and confirmed that Travis simply made up his abduction story:
"I happened across your assessment of Travis Walton’s alleged abduction aboard a UFO in 1975. Your suspicion that it was a hoax is completely correct. Travis and I were in Jr. High together back in the early 60’s and he was constantly dreaming up schemes to deceive folks that a UFO was visiting our little town in northern Arizona. Not having seen him for decades, I actually reminded him of that in 2006 via email and he simply changed the subject, not wanting to crack his golden egg I suppose. I did find his on-line bio rather telling as well: we were in the same grade in school and presumably the same age. I noticed that his bio lists him as having been born five years after me. That would have put him in first grade while I was in sixth. My guess is this little chronological slippage is telling." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re my posts on economics, I recommend these 4 books to start with a general overview of basic knowledge about how free markets & capitalism actually work, why communism can never work (not even in principle), & why socialism fails (short of enslaving citizens).
It is very basic. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Mick West
@MickWest
Ben Lamm
@BenLamm
Colossal does have a dire wolf genome (2). We did test the sample and a high percentage was unidentified but that is typical with decaying specimens and contamination. It doesn’t mean it was dire wolf. Dire wolves were over 99% grey wolf. the unknown was just contamination.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In UAP lore much is made of abductions during sleep and hypnotic regression. Please read this classic Skeptic article by Heidi Love on her very similar experiences, especially her rather colorful description of sexual encounters with these beings...
www.skeptic.com/article/sleep-paralysis-a-personal-odysse… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Pathologizing Men
Marc Defant's latest analysis for Skeptic:
www.skeptic.com/article/pathologizing-masculinity-mental-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The level of economic knowledge so many people have is at dunce-cap levels of ignorance, debunked if they took an Econ 101 course.
There is no "fixed pie" of wealth.
The market is not "zero sum" where if someone is rich then someone else must be poor.
Income is not "handed out" by a wealth czar.
For every billionaire, there's tens of thousands struggling or failed entrepreneurs (survivorship bias).
Leftists probably inculcated these economic fallacies on their smart phones or computer smade affordable by billionaires like Steve Jobs.
John Stossel
@JohnStossel
People say "Capitalists get rich by taking money from others—Jeff Bezos’ $50 billion means the rest of us have $50 billion less!
Bunk.
That’s MYTH 1 in my “Myths about Capitalism” series.
It’s wrong, says economist @danieljmitchell, because the economic pie grows:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I also highly recommend Susan Clancy's 2007 book Abducted, based on her Ph.D. dissertation under renowned memory expert Rich McNally.
"abductees are sane and intelligent people who have unwittingly created vivid false memories from a toxic mix of nightmares, culturally available texts (abduction reports began only after stories of extraterrestrials appeared in films and on TV), and a powerful drive for meaning that science is unable to satisfy. For them, otherworldly terror can become a transforming, even inspiring experience. Being abducted may be a baptism in the new religion of this millennium." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @I_D_Official
I've been enjoying your books. I presume you are familiar with sleep paralysis as an explanation for alien abduction experiences. Your description of your wife's (& others') experiences are nearly indistinguishable from this woman's account of her sleep paralysis, including & especially the common sexual component, which she colorfully describes:
www.skeptic.com/article/sleep-paralysis-a-personal-odysse… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Memories from a previous life & a kind note from a long-time (1980s) reader (+ first issue of Skeptic):
"I wanted to send a brief note to thank you for your contribution to skepticism. Your work has had a lasting influence on me since my teenage years.
Thanks to Skeptic, I developed a stronger commitment to critical thinking, and even deepened my passion for magic! Those ideas have stayed with me throughout my personal and professional life. I actually made this a central theme of a Graduation speech I delivered to University of Technology Sydney students.
By coincidence, we also share an interest in cycling. I have spent roughly 30 years involved in the sport, including participating as a crew member in Race Across America (RAAM).
On a related note, we both experienced the impact of mental fitness on endurance performance. You might find it interesting that I actually own a physical copy of your Psychling: On Mental & Physical Fitness (1982). In my own career I happened to be involved in research on mental fatigue in cycling.
I thought you might appreciate knowing that your work has influenced both my thinking and my career over many years."
With thanks and best wishes,
Paolo Menaspà @MenaspaP -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Netflix doc: The Prediction Games
I like prediction markets because they force people to put their money where their mouth is, become Bayesian calculators, think rationally about the future based on the past, etc. But it's now corrupted & gamed. Alas.
www.netflix.com/title/82772143 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A Magician in the Laboratory
The Amazing Randi's first column for Skeptic in 2009:
www.skeptic.com/article/magician-in-the-laboratory/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Progress to disclosure of whatever it is that people say they saw…
UAP James
@UAPJames
Rep. Burlison says Stephen Miller is providing him with “multiple avenues” to make UFO whistleblowers feel comfortable with waiving their NDAs for information
Burlison says people are interested.
“I’ve got a meeting tomorrow morning. I think it’s gonna shake some things loose”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes @LeTour @TamauPogi deserves all his accolades for winning Tour de France #5 (he could get 6, 7, or more).
It is also time to rethink the (understandable at the time) decision to strip @lancearmstrong of his 7 titles & reinstate the legit winner of Tours 1999-2005. The lacuna in your records for those years is ridiculous, given what we all now know was going on.
Rationale: Why has no one claimed those 7 yellow jerseys? Because they were all doping as well. Every one of the podium finishers for all 7 years have admitted to doping: Ullrich, Zülle, Beloki, Basso, Klöden, Vinokourov. And Marco Pantani—the greatest climber of his era & one of Lance's chief rivals—was a notorious doper who died from a drug overdose. We estimate 90% of cyclists were doping.
When an entire sport shifts norms, when rules are not (or cannot be) enforced, when in a game-theoretic model the most rational choice of most players in a game is to adapt a doping strategy, then doping reaches what is called a Nash Equilibrium, such that NOT to dope is a losing strategy. They HAD to dope just to compete (most had no chance of winning).
Your punishment of Lance at the time as a public signal to others to change the norms of your race was understandable, but that assumes there were a few "bad apples" to be defenestrated, when in fact the entire apple barrel was corrupt & that's on the organizers, not the competitors.
I've been in this room and seen these hard won 7 yellow jerseys. Admit that the ultimate responsibility for what the sport had become during the doping era was ultimately on the organizers, not on the athletes. Add an asterisk or parenthetical (or whatever), but claiming "but for Lance" the sport of cycling would have been clean and fair is beyond ridiculous—it's obscene. And everyone who knows this sport knows this fact. Make it right. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How good is Tadej Pogačar @TamauPogi ?
He is not only the GOAT of cycling @lancearmstrong thinks he is the most dominant athlete in the world. Comparing athletes across sports is highly problematic (Ali v. Pele v. Merckx v. Borg?) but to watch a GOAT of any sport is special.
WEDŪ
@wedusport
“This kid is the greatest of all time.” 🐐
@lancearmstrong gives his final verdict on @TamauPogi after another dominant Tour de France, calling him the greatest cyclist the sport has ever seen.
Watch the full Tour finale on THEMOVE.
#tdf2026 #tourdefrance #cycling #pogacar -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I asked Gemini "Was a Dire Wolf found on Skinwalker Ranch?" @BrandonFugal & it gave me the DNA study. A deeper dive, however, concludes 11% gray wolf, 89% unknown. If it were a Dire Wolf that had survived 13,000 years, where's their breeding population? In any case, what do you think it was?
"No scientific confirmation exists stating that a living or recently deceased dire wolf was found on Skinwalker Ranch.
While a History Channel television episode features claims regarding a "dire wolf" carcass, actual genetic testing did not validate the existence of the extinct species on the property. The narrative developed through two seasons of The Secret of Skinwalker Ranch:
The Carcass Discovery
During Season 5 (filmed in 2023), the investigative team found a severely decayed canine carcass in a creek bed on the property. A local biologist examined the jawbone and teeth structure, noting that the unusually large physical features strongly resembled those of a juvenile dire wolf (Aenocyon dirus)—a megafauna species that went extinct roughly 10,000 years ago.
The DNA Results
In Season 6 (aired in 2025), the team sent DNA samples from the bone to the biotechnology company Colossal Biosciences. The results were highly inconclusive rather than a definitive match for an extinct dire wolf:
11% Match: The genetic profile partially matched modern gray wolves native to Greenland and Eurasia—populations that do not naturally exist in Utah.
89% Unknown: The remaining majority of the DNA did not match any known modern canine sequence in the testing database.
Context and Skepticism
Critics and viewers have pointed out a significant conflict of interest regarding the discovery. Ranch owner Brandon Fugal is a prominent investor in Colossal Biosciences, a company heavily publicized for its genetic engineering and "de-extinction" projects—including attempts to recreate a dire wolf-gray wolf hybrid. Because the show did not cross-reference the carcass sample against established ancient dire wolf fossil DNA, critics suggest the segment served primarily as a promotional storyline rather than a genuine scientific breakthrough."
Is that correct Brandon? Have you since cross-referenced the carcass sample against established ancient dire wolf fossil DNA?
BTW, I support the idea of de-extinction and glad you're attempting it, and would love to see a return of the Dire Wolf (and the Dodo, Wooly Mammoth, etc.), but that's a separate matter.
Brandon Fugal
@BrandonFugal
@MichaelShermer, you’ve conflated two completely unrelated incidents. The U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service DNA test you reference was from a 2018 Montana ranch case involving a visually unusual gray wolf - it has ZERO connection to our work at Skinwalker Ranch in Utah.
Our specimen was discovered on the ranch in 2023, examined by respected animal biologist Ben Woodruff & independently DNA-tested by a 3rd-party lab. Initial findings aired May 7, 2024 on The Secret of Skinwalker Ranch…full Colossal Biosciences sequencing results were presented June 24, 2025. Those results showed only 11% alignment with modern gray wolves (specifically non-local Eurasian/Greenland strains), with 89% unidentified material…consistent with a novel or ancient lineage not matching known records.
Get the facts straight, Michael. Conflating separate events undermines the skepticism you claim to champion. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Very interesting @AlchemyAmerican @BrandonFugal
I'd love to visit Skinwalker Ranch to see for myself these phenomena. Meanwhile, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service tested the DNA of the "dire wolf" (extinct since 13,000 BP) purportedly shown in this clip on the ranch & discovered that it was a Rocky Mountain gray wolf. www.cbsnews.com/news/dna-test-reveals-identity-of-mysteri…
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
🚨BREAKING🚨 Is there a UFO buried under the mesa at Skinwalker Ranch in northeastern Utah? The team drilling into it keeps hitting engineered ceramic tile hundreds of feet down; material that resembles the heat shielding you find on American space shuttles, laced with exotic elements like europium and tellurium. Ground-penetrating radar has found hollow voids and a debris field inside the rock that no natural process explains. LiDAR has also mapped an invisible spherical field above the object that knocks out GPS, deters rockets the team launches and drops drones clean out of the air. Whatever anomalous material exists below the mesa is affecting the airspace directly above it in concretely measurable ways. The team also found an entire Dire Wolf carcass on the property, a species that went extinct over 10,000 years ago (wolves aren't even native to the area).
Brandon Fugal (@brandonfugal) is an extremely successful commercial real estate mogul who had already spent millions on a private antigravity lab advised by the CIA’s Hal Puthoff and Kit Green, and closed it himself when the results didn't replicate. It was Puthoff and Green who then pointed him to Skinwalker Ranch, which he bought in 2016 from Billionaire Robert Bigelow expecting to debunk the infamous anomalies reported there and hand it to the Boy Scouts. Six months later he watched a metallic disc hover a hundred feet above the mesa in front of his entire team. He now won't rule out that there is something like a “portal”, “wormhole” or “Stargate” buried under his property.
The ranch has a long history of harming the people who investigate it. The Navajo cursed this land generations ago, and under previous owner Robert Bigelow cattle turned up dissected and drained of blood in broad daylight, no tracks, no trace of anyone coming or going. When Fugal's team began drilling into the mesa, a ranch hand went into cardiac arrest on the spot. Another was hospitalized with his scalp separated from his skull, an injury Fugal compares to a directed energy weapon. Vehicles fail in the driveway, staff comes away hurt, and the team has hundreds of pages of medical records to show for it. It's almost as if the object fends off unwanted visitors.
The government has never left. The astrophysicist sent in to debunk the ranch was secretly running the science side of the Pentagon's UAP Task Force the whole time, and the former head of the Pentagon's UFO office (Kirkpatrick) denied ever meeting Fugal until Fugal produced their photo together at a classified 2018 briefing. Unmarked black helicopters circle the grounds constantly sometimes accompanying anomalous flying orbs.
Someone was digging here in the 1960s, and it was buried. A dated coin came up hundreds of feet down alongside the material, and the government's own aerial survey of the ranch from those exact years has been wiped from the record. Powerful people know what is under that mesa, and they want it. Fugal believes he has found proof that reality itself was engineered by a higher intelligence. An oil company has just forced its way onto the ten acres closest to his dig, chasing the same thing he is.
Reality is stranger than fiction. Full mind-blowing conversation live now👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What I am trying (in vain it seems) to convince UAPers is that for scientists (or anyone, really) to accept what appears to be the general assumption in this community that they represent ETIs (or interdimensional beings or time travelers, etc.), is that we need more concrete evidence than we have.
I know there are thousands of sightings, reports, accounts, and tantalizing hints of evidence, but the reason no one in science, government, or journalism has announced that the greatest discovery in human history has been made is the evidence isn't good enough.
I know many of you think it is, but it isn't. If it were, we would all believe it: Avi Loeb, Neil deGrasse Tyson, Donald Trump, Marco Rubio, the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, et al. would announce such a discovery. They haven't because we don't know that.
Call me ignorant or closed minded (or worse, as many of you have), but my skepticism that UAPs = ETIs is shared by nearly everyone, so you'd have to accuse them of the same as well.
Should we keep searching for signals from space, for technological artifacts, for exo-planet chemical signs, and especially those thousands of accounts? Of course! That is precisely what we're doing at the Galileo Project, the UAP Science Advisory Council, and at Skeptic (not to mention SETI. Breakthrough Listen, the Planetary Society, and numerous other organizations and countless scientists working on this).
You may not like that I am part of this search (and some of you are tirelessly—and amusingly—trying to defenestrate me), but ALL good scientists are just as skeptical as I am, and you can't get rid of all of us (and even if you could it wouldn't make aliens real).
As I've seen countless times, should such a discovery be disclosed we will put it on the cover of Skeptic, I will pay Avi our $1000 wager, and I will gladly reject the null hypothesis (that UAPs ≠ ETIs) and switch from skepticism to belief.
Does that make sense? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
All 64 James "the Amazing" Randi Columns for Skeptic, Online for the First Time here:
www.skeptic.com/email/434605d1-857e-4d39-97be-d307586b3433/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For UAPers speculating about aliens traversing wormholes to get here:
“As of now, wormholes are not known to be traversable and remain purely hypothetical. For known materials, they pinch closed too quickly for even light to pass through. To prevent immediate collapse, a wormhole must be stabilized by a substance with a negative mass. This negative mass exerts gravitational repulsion that acts as a scaffold. The entry of a traveler adds a positive mass that tends to trigger a catastrophic collapse of a wormhole. Furthermore, gravitational tidal forces inside a normal wormhole would be severe enough to tear a traveler apart. To date, no experimental evidence or astronomical observation has ever confirmed that wormholes exist in our universe, let alone that they can be used for spacetime travel.” avi-loeb.medium.com/a-decade-long-voyage-through-the-milk… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Analogy for UAPers:
Imagine you're a zoologist. A fellow zoologist announces that Yeti is real—there exists another bipedal primate living today. Wow, that would be huge.
"Let's see it!"
"Uh, well, I don't have an actual Yeti body, but I know someone who says they have it."
"Do you have any photographs or videos?"
"I have a couple of blurry photographs and grainy videos of Yeti, and if you use your imagination you can sort of see a bipedal primate in the shadows. But my source showed me photographs of Yeti that are clear and focused."
"Can we see these clear photographs or the actual Yeti body?"
"No, it's classified and I signed an NDA."
"Sorry, but that is not good enough evidence for us to accept your claim to name a new species. Until then, we remain skeptical." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is a useful and instructive analysis of Eric Davis's claims about ETIs @UAPConvergence
To all UAP proponents: aren't you tired of hearing breathtaking claims about what would be the greatest discovery in human history but we're never shown the actual physical evidence?
The UAP Convergence
@UAPConvergence
Not a debunking. Not an endorsement.
Just an evidence assessment. See my analysis of Dr. Davis's claims in my attached chart.
I evaluated several of Dr. Davis’s most frequently discussed public claims by separating:
• testimony
• public documentation
• corroboration
• speculation
Curious to hear where others agree—or disagree—with the assessments. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is what mean by UAP eyewitness exaggerations:
Here with @rosscoulthart David Grusch says we have "Non-human exotic origin vehicles that have either landed or crashed. We have spacecraft from another species."
In fact, Grusch admits he never saw anything himself and that this statement is second hand based on what other people told him.
Now that the NDA restrictions have been lifted it is time to have Congress see these spacecraft for themselves.
If they're ours, good to know.
If they're foreign tech, even better to know.
If they're alien tech, the greatest disclosure of all time.
youtu.be/YZhIjFrhUhE?t=448 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
UAPers:
Dr. Eric Davis here says there are 4 alien types: Grays, Insectoids, Reptilian, Nordics
I know you are critical of my skepticism of UAPs as aliens, but honestly...do you actually believe this?
On a Bayesian scale of 1-99% what would you give it?
youtu.be/GDPnJnBSVog?t=269 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Gemini @AlchemyAmerican @HighlyStrange :
Neil Armstrong joined the 1976 Cueva de los Tayos expedition in Ecuador as its honorary president and figurehead. He was invited by expedition organizer Stan Hall (who shared ancestral roots with Armstrong in Scotland) to lend global credibility and leadership to a massive scientific, archaeological, and military investigation into the cave's ecosystem and alleged subterranean anomalies.
The team included over 20 botanists and zoologists who mapped the cave, studied local plant and animal life (including the titular oilbirds), and documented the region's diverse ecosystem.
The mission was launched to verify claims by treasure hunter Juan Moricz that the caves held a fabled "metal library" and ancient artifacts left by an unknown civilization.
The team did not find any metal books or gold treasure, though they discovered archaeological items and new plant species.
Despite coming up empty-handed on the mythic front, Armstrong was deeply impressed by the subterranean environment, later stating that his time exploring the Tayos Cave system rivaled the magnitude of his historic experience on the moon.
High Strangeness
@HighlyStrange
🚨Jesse Michels: Astronaut Neil Armstrong went hunting for an ancient alien metallic artifact in 1976.
"Why would you go looking for that if you weren't open to the presence of extraterrestrial life..."
The first man on the Moon joined a massive expedition into Ecuador’s Tayos cave system at the edge of the Amazon, chasing a rumored “metallic library” straight out of Erich von Däniken’s Chariots of the Gods. 🤯This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is not exactly the monolith from 2001 is it @AlchemyAmerican @MaxDerakhshani ? Gemini:
Yes, an unusual boulder-sized rock often called the "Phobos Monolith" exists on Phobos, a moon of Mars. NASA classifies it as a natural boulder roughly 279 to 300 feet across, and while an un-funded robotic mission concept called PRIME was once proposed to study it, NASA has never proposed a sampling mission dedicated to investigating it as an artificial structure.
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
🚨👽THERE IS A 270-FOOT MONOLITH STANDING ON A MOON OF MARS AND NASA PROPOSED A MISSION TO GO SAMPLE IT.
"NASA proposed a mission in 2007 to send a probe to this monolith on Phobos, take a sample of it, and do some direct analysis."
"It's estimated to be 85 meters in diameter and 90 meters tall. It's like 270 feet roughly — like a tall building in size."
"I've examined those NASA images of that monolith, and clearly there is no other structure anywhere else on Phobos nearly as large."
"Certainly the monolith is geologically anomalous. It doesn't seem to be a natural formation of Phobos."
"It's too large. It's too symmetrical. Its albedo, or reflectivity, is significantly different from the surface of Phobos."
"It's very plausible that our solar system has been visited by ET visitors in the past."
"Three billion years ago, Mars was much more Earth-like. You had a biosphere, you had a magnetosphere, and you had water."
"If they wanted to monitor that life, maybe they would put something on Phobos, like a monolith, to monitor it."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Thanks @MaxDerakhshani I will watch the entire show to get the full counter to Avi's hypothesis of cosmic rays.
In the meantime, what do you think these UAPs were?
Maaneli (Max) Derakhshani
@MaxDerakhshani
Hey @michaelshermer, I’m the guy being interviewed by Jesse in that clip. Cosmic rays have absolutely nothing to do with the UFO that Buzz Aldrin and the other two Apollo 11 astronauts (Michael Collins and Neil Armstrong) saw with their own eyes and through binoculars following them for over a day while en route to the Moon. It’s almost as if you didn’t actually watch the clip.
And if you take time to watch the full interview, you’ll see me respond to and effectively refute @ProfAviLoeb’s cosmic rays explanation of the triangular configuration of blue lights in Apollo 17 frame AS17-147-22470 and the prominent blue orb UAP photographed above Edgar Mitchell standing on the lunar surface during Apollo 14 (frame AS14-66-09301). It’s simply not a physically plausible explanation on its own terms, for the reasons I mention in the interview.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cosmic Rays @AmericanALCHMY Jesse. See @ProfAviLoeb explanation for this and other mysteries probably explained by this natural phenomenon (although a great many other UAPs remain unexplained)!
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
Buzz Aldrin describes strange UFO encounters during the Apollo 11 missions…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
See my convo with @AdamFrank4 on what alien life might be like, length of civilizations (I computed an average of 410 years for L in Drake Equation), his calculations of what might be left of our civ after millions of years, would aliens be like us, etc.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/the-scientific-searc… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“UAP are a mixed bag. Some represent natural phenomena while other are human-made. But a fraction of UAP are still unresolved. Could some UAP represent Earth-based tech of pre-human origin?”
Probably not but interesting to consider @ProfAviLoeb @AdamFrank4 calculations on how long the pyramids would last, etc. on a deep time scale our civilization would be completely obliterated by the rock cycle.
avi-loeb.medium.com/do-some-uap-represent-earth-based-tec… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This guy is lying:
“every single physicist, engineer, and architect in the world agree" that there is no way planes could have brought down the World Trade Center buildings.
The exact opposite is true, with the exception of the handful of conspiracists who believe in super secret super thermite that W. operatives used after they broke through the drywall in the two towers & planted the hundreds of explosive devices for weeks before without anyone noticing.
Heidi Bachram
@HeidiBachram
Tucker Carlson interviewed Roger Waters and it’s as bonkers as you’d expect. Here Waters suggests that Israel did 911 because “every single physicist in the world” agree that planes wouldn’t bring down the towers. Antisemitic madness.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Princess Diana is dead and you probably can't draw a bicycle | Michael S... youtube.com/shorts/feCGb_snOv0?is=y4Y9Daxxvn1ksc1s via @YouTube
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
IFO from Skeptic reader Charles Stevens:
"I am a retired (LLNL) optical physicist that just viewed an optical event that has all the appearances of a mysterious flying object, but with a mundane explanation. This video was taken by my iPhone through my back door window. The bright image is sunlight reflection from a window located about 3 miles across a valley. The daughter object is seen only through the window and seen both directly by eye and through the iPhone. I finally determined its origin.
There is a small flaw in the window pane that scatters light from that window source and its movement is due to very subtle movement on my part. The movement of an object in the near field (pane defect) is exaggerated over a distant object (sunlight reflection) in proportion to the ratio of their respective distances when viewed. I finally detected my very subtle movement by seeing a dim reflection of curtains from another window superimposed on this image.
It is possible that some of the airplane images are due to a similar phenomenon wherein direct sunlight is reflected from a window flaw but in that case the sun is not in view.
I find your skepticism quite refreshing." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Geez, the UAP crowd doesn't even like it when I repost an @ProfAviLoeb article explaining why the Nimitz Tic Tac Objects were very likely NOT Megafilaments of Laser Produced Plasmas!
The point is to show some of the work of the uapsac.com
avi-loeb.medium.com/were-the-nimitz-tic-tac-objects-megaf… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Thank you for your efforts in bringing UAPs into the light @DepDNILukas not only for U.S. intelligence agencies, but for Congress, other government agencies, the uapsac.com and eventually the public to see for themselves and understand what is really going on.
Aaron Lukas
@DepDNILukas
President Trump is delivering on his commitment to unprecedented UAP transparency.
With nondisclosure agreements no longer standing in the way, current and former government employees and contractors with relevant UAP information can come forward through cleared channels. @ODNIgov will soon issue guidance to ensure the Intelligence Community swiftly and consistently implements the President’s directive. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cosmic Rays @AmericanALCHMY Jesse. See @ProfAviLoeb explanation for this and other mysteries probably explained by this natural phenomenon (although a great many other UAPs remain unexplained)!
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
Buzz Aldrin describes strange UFO encounters during the Apollo 11 missions…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Follow the trend lines, not the headlines. @BjornLomborg on fire emissions…
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
2025 global wildfire had lowest emissions in the satellite era
That's contrary to the climate narrative
2025 saw lowest emissions in Africa and South America, and 2nd-lowest in Asia, leading to lowest-ever global emissions
Ironically, the very science outfit reporting this obviously downwards-trending data
summarizes 2025 as an “intense wildfire year in the Northern Hemisphere”
Unbelievably misleading (but of course, it gets funded by climate-alarmed EU)
atmosphere.copernicus.eu/2025-sees-intense-wildfire-year-… (notice the graph, but not downloadable data, has been updated to end-of-2025, as is also seen here bsky.app/profile/mparrington.bsky.social/post/3md3w3kakek2m)
You can see all the references in my Twitter thread:
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
Less Global Fire
Halfway through 2026, the world has burned at record-low levels
Every continent is below average, and Africa, Americas, and Europe are at record lows
Media only shows when stuff is burning, leaving us badly informed on climate change
gwis.jrc.ec.europa.eu/apps/gwis.statistics/seasonaltrend -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"An interesting unsettled question is whether some of the reported UAP are plasma filaments, generated by powerful laser beams. Ionized air could reflect radar and appear as glowing structures of infrared or visible light. Consider “Tic Tac" @ProfAviLoeb
avi-loeb.medium.com/were-the-nimitz-tic-tac-objects-megaf… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I've been wondering why the UAP community seems less than enthusiastic about recent developments in disclosure (eg, NDA dismissals) & especially my own participation in the subject. UAP insider Nick Pope explains it all in his article for Skeptic:
"There’s clearly a struggle for narrative control within the field. Even among the various whistleblowers and other key players, who are ostensibly polite with each other, there are clearly some tensions. By way of a personal anecdote, I’ve had more than one TV producer tell me how Individual A told them he’d appear on a show, provided Individual B wasn’t featured. I’m similarly aware that some of the key players who are ostensibly being polite to me are briefing against me, perhaps seeing my mainstream media platform as a potential threat, especially given that I’m independent in all this and don’t take anybody’s side.
There’s nothing new about infighting in the UFO community. What is new, however, is that folks with a background in military intelligence know a few dirty tricks that their civilian counterparts don’t. Plus, social media has acted as a force multiplier, with 𝕏 in particular having turned into a veritable battlefield between some of the key players, often using proxies and sock puppet accounts. Cliques, harassment, and doxxing seem to be the order of the day. Neither should we sweep under the carpet the uncomfortable truth that some of the people who’ve recently jumped aboard the ufology train clearly have psychological issues, while others sense a money-making opportunity.
To pick one example of all this infighting, the December 2025 appearance of Jay Anderson on Joe Rogan’s podcast seems to have set off a particularly nasty squabble. Jay criticized Luis Elizondo (among others), accusing him of orchestrating an aggressive campaign to control the narrative, as well as making reference to what he’s sometimes called a “UFO Hate Group.” In response, a group of Elizondo supporters, sometimes dubbed “the Lue Crew,” hit back against Jay Anderson.
A related development is that a new generation of influential podcast hosts and YouTube channel owners saw the topic become increasingly mainstream and entered the fray. While many are honest brokers, their podcasts and channels are often the arena in which the struggle for narrative control plays out. Again, despite being a veteran commentator who follows all this closely, I struggle to work out who’s supporting which faction, how many factions there are, and the true nature of their respective agendas.
www.skeptic.com/article/ufology-from-fringe-to-mainstream… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Real progress for real disclosure. Enough stories. Let’s get to the bottom of this incredibly interesting and important subject.
Aaron Lukas
@DepDNILukas
President Trump is delivering on his commitment to unprecedented UAP transparency.
With nondisclosure agreements no longer standing in the way, current and former government employees and contractors with relevant UAP information can come forward through cleared channels. @ODNIgov will soon issue guidance to ensure the Intelligence Community swiftly and consistently implements the President’s directive. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Chasing UFOs on the 101 freeway with @I_D_Official
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It's both @GregoryScaduto : Congress and the public. How? Representative Eric Burlison explains it here.
Greg Scaduto
@GregoryScaduto
Ok you’ve now moved from
“Why won’t they tell the public?” to
“Congress should compel testimony through authorized channels.”
Those are different legal authorities, and the distinction was my entire point.
Whether I’m curious is not relevant to the legal mechanisms that govern classification laws in this country. It was your assumption, in numerous sarcastic posts now, that an NDA waiver permits public disclosure, and it does not.
Anyone paying attention to this issue is curious, so yes, I am. To answer your question. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are you not curious @GregoryScaduto to see what the whistleblowers are claiming is real? It's not for my "recreation" but for national security, so if Congress demands information whistleblowers can no longer use NDAs to remain silent.
Greg Scaduto
@GregoryScaduto
This is such an elementary legal distinction that it’s astonishing it requires explanation.
Waiving an NDA does not allow one to divulge classified state secrets to @michaelshermer on X for his recreation. All it does is widen the circle of officials who one may lawfully speak to. The classification system remains exactly where it was.
Please become less confident. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The respected, peer-reviewed APA journal Behavior Analysis will publish my target article on Contingency in an open-peer commentary special issue for which 4 psychologists have provided their critiques. I will post it all when published so follow this space. Deeply honored.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Agreed @ProfAviLoeb this POTUS step to allow whistleblowers to come forward with everything they know for everyone to see is what true disclosure looks like. Even if there are no aliens to disclose, understanding of foreign assets and/or US tech development would be enlightening.
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
Every step taken by the Trump administration to lower barriers for the dissemination of credible evidence is a step toward a better scientific understanding of the nature of UAP.
I welcome the reported decision to allow former officials and contractors to share relevant UAP information through authorized channels. Thank-you President @realDonaldTrump and the bipartisan UAP Caucus — including Representatives @realannapaulina, @EricBurlison, @timburchett, @NancyMace, @JaredEMoskowitz @SuhasforVA, @RobertGarcia as well as Senators @SenGillibrand, and @RoundsforSenate and others — for your sustained commitment to greater UAP transparency.
avi-loeb.medium.com/president-trump-are-there-alien-packa… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"If Netanyahu had wanted to eradicate every Palestinian from Gaza he could have done so on October 8. But obviously he didn’t. If the IDF had sought to kill as many Palestinians as possible, they would have not gone to such extraordinary lengths to separate civilians from combatants, even when the line between the two has been deliberately blurred by Hamas." @DouglasKMurray
www.thefp.com/p/douglas-murray-mamdani-netanyahu?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I endorse Congressman @EricBurlison 's amendment on UAP disclosure. It's time. Let us all see what the government has. No more secrets. And it supports Trump’s Presidential Unsealing and Reporting System for UAP Encounters (PURSUE)
Senate should pass it.
burlison.house.gov/media/press-releases/house-adopts-burl… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hal Putoff & Eric Davis claim that intelligence reports describe four types of ETIs: Grays, Nordics, Insectoids, and Reptilians.
Why do so many UAPers give me such a hard time for simply asking "can we see them?"
Wouldn't you UAPers like to see them too?
www.fox5atlanta.com/news/ufo-insider-claims-us-bodies-ali… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Exactly @IntersellarUAP
Is it not reasonable to simply ask "now that you are free to talk, can you tell us where the crash retrieved NHI vehicles are located?"
That seems like something anyone curious about the topic would ask, no?
Interstellar
@InterstellarUAP
🚨 Lue Elizondo: "I have signed NDA's which prevent me talking about UFO Crash Retrievals" 👽🛸
"I was told several years ago that I could never talk about crash retrievals or material ever and I signed paperwork for it. I just don't want to go to jail."
Yesterday Donald Trump gave UFO Whistleblowers immunity from NDA’s so they can talk more freely to intelligence agencies & congress.
Will we hear more from Lue Elizondo about UFO crash retrievals?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
O-kay Dr. Davis, POTUS just released you from your NDAs so it is now safe for you to tell us everything you know about NHIs, ETIs, biologics, aliens, spaceships, crashed retrievals, etc. Tell everyone what you know. We all are genuinely interested...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The problem @GregoryScaduto is that this applies to any claim you'd like to believe is true (but for which the evidence is lacking to convince others)—U.S. goverment is hiding:
Zero-Point Energy
100 miles/gallon cars
9/11 inside job
CIA assassinated JFK
Fake moon landing
Deep State
Pizzagate
Epstein truth
Time travel
HAARP
ChemTrails
Etc.
Greg Scaduto
@GregoryScaduto
Here is what the credentialed class of scientific skeptics like @seanmcarroll and online hobbyists like @MickWest have missed:
They unconsciously assume a frictionless marketplace of evidence, where significant phenomena naturally generate publicly available proof. That assumption rarely survives contact with history.
The Manhattan Project remained secret from the American public. VENONA remained classified for decades. Signals intelligence, stealth technology, and countless intelligence operations were invisible until institutional incentives changed.
Empirical records, and especially those collected at altitude by detection systems that are classified by design, are managed by human beings. And their interpretation is then produced, restricted, classified, and released according to the incentives of institutions, not the curiosity of the public or a bored video game designer.
Power has always exercised a vote over what the public is permitted to know. Which is why the academic establishment should consider these questions if their goal is discovery and advancement:
1. What evidence would we expect institutions to produce?
2. What evidence would we expect them to classify?
3. How do bureaucracies behave when confronted with persistent anomalies?
4. Do their organizational behaviors reveal information beyond the publicly available artifacts?
@GarryPNolan
@ProfAviLoeb -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Men have lower college enrollment and graduation rates, higher suicide rates, greater incarceration, higher rates of homelessness, and are far more likely than women to be sentenced to death, even for comparably heinous crimes."
Marc Defant for Skeptic:
www.skeptic.com/article/pathologizing-masculinity-mental-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Explaining UAP Sightings: Terrestrial vs. Extraterrestrial #shorts youtu.be/nr29gwy-VaE via @YouTube
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My favorite book of Stephen Jay Gould’s extensive oeuvre is also his shortest, exploring the themes of contingency & necessity, arrows and cycles, irreversible history and repeatable science, our “eternal metaphors”
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Carl Sagan's search for extraterrestrial intelligent life continues...at his old home! @ProfAviLoeb
The skis are not classified so the more of these @GalileoProject1 observatories the more data to triangulate UAPs.
avi-loeb.medium.com/a-new-galileo-observatory-in-celebrat… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
Natural selection is a blind watchmaker, yet the forms it produces can be astonishingly beautiful.
Ernst Haeckel captured that beauty in his extraordinary illustrations. They accompany my forthcoming book, 42 Tales from Life: A Modern Bestiary. Published this November, it tells 42 stories of the ingenious, curious and bizarre products of evolution.
Waterstones is offering 25% off pre-orders with code SUMMER26 until Friday, 24 July.
www.waterstones.com/book/42-tales-from-life/richard-dawki… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is great news from POTUS Trump. No more NDS silence. Just come forward and tell everyone what you know with specifics!
Where, exactly, are the aliens and their craft being stored? What, exactly, was all the data associated with the many UAP encounters.
As for the hint that Trump might give a speech disclosing NHI/aliens, we still need to see the evidence. Remember, Trump said last week that he has new evidence that he won the 2020 election, despite his own AG Bill Barr stating no such evidence exists.
avi-loeb.medium.com/president-trump-are-there-alien-packa… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
With Trump's poll #s in freefall Dems have a chance to win 2026/28 but need to dump woke, trans & socialist agendas, e.g., the DSA goal:
—End POTUS & Supreme Court
—Abolishing prisons
—Universal free housing
—Elimination of all debt
—Close all U.S. military bases overseas
—Lift all sanctions from Cuba, Venezuela, Iran
Endorse these & the GOP will keep winning.
www.thefp.com/p/i-was-in-the-dsa-heres-what-they?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Even crazier @sapinker the reincarnation, time travel, rewind-the-tape people always imagine going back in time and living as one of the top 0.001% of humanity, Napoleon, Cleopatra, King Tut. Heroic figures! In fact, you'd come back as one of the 99.9% who lived abject poverty.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In The Better Angels of Our Nature I presented The Iliad as an example of the brutality the ancients took for granted. This has not been fully appreciated in the revisionism in the new Odyssey film or most of the commentary. "We should not act as if there is any higher value in honoring the ancient past, instead saving our reverence for how far we have come in the last few centuries. The best lesson that Homer can provide is gratitude that we no longer live in his world." We're All Still Living in Denial about the Greeks, by @RichardHanania open.substack.com/pub/richardhanania/p/were-all-still-liv…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A philosophical zombie @Briankeating
Is Data (Star Trek, TNG) a conscious sentient person?
How would you know if one day AI is conscious (short of it acting like people, who we assume are)?
I deal with these issues in Truth: What it is, How to Find it, Why it Still Matters...
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Michael Shermer: "You're Not Sentient, Brian — You're Just a Robot"
@michaelshermer -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A Skeptic and an Evolutionary Psychologist Walk Into a Village Hall… @SteveStuWill
—The evolutionary origins of sex differences
—Sex-role-reversed species
—Greater male variability and the Larry Summers controversy
—Why both sexes prefer research that puts women in a better light than men
—Sex differences in STEM
—Whether murder-suicide has an evolutionary basis
—Young male syndrome and sex differences in crime
open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/a-skeptic-an… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Show us the aliens" isn't lazy @TheUfoJoe @BrandonFugal
It's a natural response to UAP whistleblowers who claim the US government has aliens.
UAPers set the bar at aliens, not me.
Wouldn't any curious person ask "can we see them?"
For scientists to believe we need to see them.
Joe Murgia
@TheUfoJoe
"Demanding 'all the aliens' is just a lazy way to avoid engaging with the data you claim doesn't exist. Classic skeptic move: raise the evidentiary bar so high that nothing can clear it, then declare victory." ~Fugal to Debunker (not a skeptic), Michael Shermer
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are billionaires/oligarchs running the country?
No says @tylercowen & if you think they do then you have “billionaire derangement syndrome."
We interact with our state/local governments more than the feds & most spending goes toward schools, roads & Medicaid. None reflect the agendas of billionaires.
www.thefp.com/p/tyler-cowen-america-isnt-an-oligarchy?r=2… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
We @Briankeating discuss far more than just aliens & UAPs! We cover the many topics in Truth: myth, religion, God, fine-tuning, why there is something rather than nothing, consciousness, free will, and how science operates to determine what we should accept as (small t) true.
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
What if almost everything you've been told about UFOs, truth, free will, and even the search for God deserves a second look?
In this conversation with Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer), we tackle some of the biggest questions in science and philosophy: Are aliens really here? Why do smart people believe extraordinary claims? Is free will an illusion? Can science ever answer life's deepest questions? And what happens when evidence collides with ideology?
This isn't a debate about who's right. It's an exploration of how we decide what's true. If you enjoy conversations that challenge assumptions and leave you thinking long after they're over, this is one you won't want to miss.
Watch the video here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=cR2WVOVuq_I -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Drake Equation and the difference between the SETI community and the UFO community
youtu.be/tEpBb0NhPzs -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
So simple…
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Michael Shermer's Bigfoot Test: "Show Us the Body"
@michaelshermer -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"An unknown object moving across the sky in a fraction of a second could be a nearby bird or a distant artifact of a non-human origin.
Unfortunately, the publicly available UAP data does not include distance assessments and so it is impossible to gauge whether the speed of UAP is within the expected performance envelope of natural phenomena or human-made technologies.
This is why scientific analysis of existing data and sensor recommendations by the UAP Science Advisory Council (uapsac.com) under my leadership, will assist the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI), the All-Domain Anomaly Resolution office in the Pentagon, the White House, the FBI and the intelligence community, in figuring out the nature and origin of UAP."
avi-loeb.medium.com/a-distance-measurement-is-worth-a-tho… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It's even worse than this @sapinker
Adults with problems go to therapists for help.
Therapists ask them to think of something that might have happened in childhood, ignoring the possibility it could be genes, brain chemistry, or something else.
Client finds something in memory of childhood not good (or even bad).
Therapist attributes current problem to memory of bad event with no evidence whatsoever that there's a causal connection, then instructs client to ruminate, cogitate & dwell on the problem, thereby exasberating it.
Worse, some therapists will help clients "recover" memories of childhood abuse (which isn't possible—these are false memories), thereby reinforcing the problem.
It's blank slate psychology + pseudoscientific therapy.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's depressing that 28 years after Judith Rich Harris's The Nurture Assumption, psychologists are conducting, and journalists credulously reporting, useless correlational studies of people's decades-old memories of childhood abuse & their adult relationships, presented as evidence for causality. No controls for (among other things) more neurotic adults spinning childhood memories as traumatic; abusive parents passing on genes for cantankerousness to their kids; more obstreperous children growing into more obstreperous adults. | "Childhood Trauma Echoes Through Romantic Relationships" nautil.us/childhood-trauma-echoes-through-romantic-relati…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Agreed, show us the data @BrandonFugal
Better still show us all aliens & their spaceships—that would put an end to all this speculation.
Does anyone care about pilot credentials or multi-sensor data for the Chinese spy balloon? No. Why? Because we have the balloon! @MickWest
Mick West
@MickWest
The problem here is that we don’t actually have “multi-sensor military data” (or any good data) that demonstrates the need for new physics.
I’m sure Loeb and Shermer (like me) would love to see such data. But Fugal refuses to release his, which really weakens his argument.
Brandon Fugal
@BrandonFugal
As someone deeply involved in rigorous UAP field research, I respect the new Council but have concerns.
Avi Loeb’s “no new physics” stance on cases like Nimitz Tic Tac risks dismissing multi-sensor military data in favor of current theoretical limits. Science advances by investigating anomalies, not explaining them away.
Michael Shermer’s pre-existing $1k bet against disclosure raises questions about impartiality for the official skeptic role.
True integrity demands openness to novel physics & neutral evaluation of high-reliability evidence. Let’s get this right. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What happens when people claim "I can feel the love of the dragon" or "I prayed to the dragon and my cancer went away" or "the dragon may actually be an interdimensional being so we can't detect it" @Briankeating ?
At some point there must be a test or else it isn't science.
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Sagan's dragon in my garage is invisible, so you bring thermal.
It's cold-blooded.
You bring flour for the footprints.
It levitates. Every rescue is individually reasonable.
The pattern isn't. But maybe it is the reverse: refusing to consider exotic physics is how you miss the thing. Where does the ladder stop being evasion and start being inquiry? Let me knowl in the replies -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What I call Sagan’s Dragon…
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer): 'I Have an Invisible Dragon in My Garage'
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excellent convo @Briankeating
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Watch my conversation with @michaelshermer youtu.be/cR2WVOVuq_I?sub_confirmation=1
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“I selected brilliant scientists with expertise in physics, oceanography, data analysis, statistics, and psychology. All are open-minded enough to go wherever the evidence guides us. I also included a skeptic of alien technologies to ensure there are no biases in the analysis and to make sure our conclusions are beyond doubt.” nypost.com/2026/07/19/opinion/why-im-leading-a-council-on…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My compatibilism: the past is determined, the future is not predetermined, we are part of the causal net, our decisions shape the future—self-determinism. Marc Desmarais disagrees. Free will is an illusion like the equal red lines that appear unequal.
medium.com/@mdesm2005/a-review-and-critique-of-michael-sh… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
?? @Marc_Desm I wouldn't touch crypto with a 1,000-foot pole! Nor would I ever pay anyone to "manage" my funds. Remember the book Where Are The Customers' Yachts? An oldie but goodie and still stands.
www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/02/21/where-are-the-c…
marc desmarais
@Marc_Desm
That's a bit odd coming from (or shared by) a self described "crypto" nerd. Good advice, and if you follow it, you don't touch "crypto" with a ten foot pole.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Personal finance is a set of common-sense decisions repeated:
Save more than you spend.
Diversify.
Do not chase excitement.
Do not trust anyone who promises certainty."
2 words: Index Funds
2 more words: Magnificent Seven
1 idiom from poker: Never draw to an inside straight
Ochob
@0chob
Paul Samuelson was the first American to win the Nobel Prize in Economics. He spent his career proving that ordinary people should not try to beat the market. He also quietly beat the market himself for 60 years. His last full-length interview explains how. Almost nobody has watched it.
Samuelson taught at MIT for 65 years, from 1940 until he died in 2009. His textbook "Economics" sold roughly four million copies. He rewrote the field. Every finance professional working today learned economics from a book he wrote or a book written by his students.
He also ran his own money quietly. His returns reportedly outpaced most active managers of his era, and he was an early investor in Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway. He never advertised the numbers. He said the opposite in public. His most famous line about investing:
"Investing should be more like watching paint dry or watching grass grow. If you want excitement, take $800 and go to Las Vegas."
He was one of the earliest advocates for index funds. He believed almost nobody could beat the market and almost nobody should try. His nephew Larry Summers became Treasury Secretary. His students founded half the modern economics profession. He was invited into every important economic policy debate of his lifetime.
His view on personal finance was unusually blunt for a Nobel laureate. In one of his final interviews, near the end of his life, he explained his framework in three sentences. Personal finance is not a science. It is a set of common-sense decisions repeated for decades. Save more than you spend. Diversify. Do not chase excitement. Do not trust anyone who promises certainty. He said these things thousands of times over 70 years and the industry ignored him every year.
The full interview covers his childhood, his years at Chicago and Harvard, his rise at MIT, his Nobel, and his philosophy on money. He was 94 years old at the time. His voice is thin and his answers are direct. He does not soften anything. He treats the interviewer like a graduate student who happens to be holding a camera.
The more sophisticated a market becomes, the more valuable the boring advice becomes. Every investor who ignored Samuelson's rules is a receipt for how right he was. Every quant who read his mathematics and skipped his common sense missed the point.
Samuelson died December 2009. He was 94. His textbook is still in print. The interview is free.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I’m interested in this topic because UAP/abductee believers portray aliens as bipedal primates similar to us but with larger eyes/head, thinner limbs etc. VERY unlikely this would evolve again on another planet. Primates are evolutionary singletons very different than, say, fish.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good book on contingency and necessity in life testing Gould’s “if you replayed the tape would we appear again?” & if we encounter aliens will they be anything like us? IMO they won’t, but convergent evolution (see Simon Conway Morris) suggests aliens might be similar… @JLosos
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good book on contingency and necessity in life testing Gould’s “if you replayed the tape would we appear again?” & if we encounter aliens will they be anything like us? IMO they won’t, but convergent evolution (see Simon Conway Morris) suggests aliens might be similar… @JLosos
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why we should keep an open mind just in case. There is no such thing as the paranormal or supernatural. These are just linguistic placeholders for unexplained mysteries. Whatever UAPs are they must be part of the natural (not supernatural) world. youtu.be/GnIBg7wL11U
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Michael Shermer speaks with political scientist Marlene Laruelle about Russia’s turbulent transformation during the 1990s and the rise of Vladimir Putin, why the Kremlin so badly misjudged Ukraine, China’s rise and its ambitions for Taiwan, why killing Iran’s Supreme Leader and much of its senior leadership did not bring down the regime, the limits of foreign aid and sanctions, mass surveillance, economic nationalism, and whether Western democracy can survive an age of economic pessimism and technological control. www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/how-to-think-clearly…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
One of my favorite examples of patternicity—the tendency to find meaningful patterns in random noise—the Badlands Guardian east of Medicine Hat, a Native American chief with a feathered headdress. Looks convex but is actually a concave valley, 255 meters wide 225 meters long.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Do UAP flag new physics?
We do not know. The only way to find out is to be open minded to all possibilities out of curiosity and the humility to learn. The nature of UAP can be resolved by higher quality data.
New physics can only explain UAP if it applies to a new domain of reality that was not described so far. New physics cannot be associated with objects made of known materials moving through air in the 3+1 dimensions of the known spacetime. Our current knowledge and the publicly available data do not preclude new physics from explaining UAP. Nevertheless, we must keep in mind that UAP are recorded by cameras and therefore must interact with light."
Perfectly noted @ProfAviLoeb
avi-loeb.medium.com/do-uap-flag-new-physics-da1074c50c74?… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Correct link re drones...
In Vivo Podcast
@InVivoPodOnX
Here's the fixed link
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not so @KindaCulty
I would welcome with open arms (+ $1000 for @ProfAviLoeb ) the disclosure of UAPs as aliens. It would have 0 effect on my career & may even help it because I would fully accept it, as I do any claim with substantial evidence, showing that changing your mind when the evidence changes is a virtue!
KindaCulty
@KindaCulty
The thing with Shermer, is he isn't just a skeptic, but he's a career skeptic. The risk of being wrong on UAPs would be too damaging to his profession, reputation & ego that I just don't see how he could be viewed as a good faith actor on the subject. It's conflict of interest. We should welcome open minded/good faith skeptics, but that's not Shermer because he's too financially & reputationally invested in his position.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is an excerpt from my final chapter of Truth on the matter of progress in science & how we know it is real:
Epilogue: Like Gods
The Expanding Sphere of Knowledge and My God Gambit
The history of science has been one long and steady replacement of unjustified false belief with justified true belief, most notably displacing the supernatural with the natural, the paranormal with the normal, and bad explanations with good explanations. Weather events once attributed to the supernatural scheming of demons and deities are now understood to be the product of natural forces of temperature and pressure. Plagues formerly ascribed to female witches cavorting with the devil are today known to be caused by bacteria and viruses. Mental illnesses previously imputed to demonic possession are currently sought in genes and neurochemistry. Accidents heretofore explained by fate, karma, or providence are nowadays accredited to probabilities, statistics, and chance.
If we follow this trend to encompass all phenomena, what place is there for supernatural agents and paranormal forces? Do we know enough to know that they cannot exist? Is it possible there are unknown forces within our universe, or intentional agents outside of it that we have yet to discover? According to the physicist Sean Carroll, in his book The Big Picture: On the Origins of Life, Meaning, and the Universe Itself, “All of the things you’ve ever seen or experienced in your life—objects, plants, animals, people—are made of a small number of particles, interacting with one another through a small number of forces.” Once you understand the fundamental laws of nature, such as the thermodynamic arrow of time and the Core Theory of particles and forces, you can scale up to planets and people, and even assess the likelihood that God, the soul, and the afterlife exist, which I conclude is very low.
“Oh, come on,” I hear you thinking. “Didn’t they say that in the late 19th century, just before the theory of relativity and quantum mechanics? Isn’t the history of science strewn with the remains of failed theories like geocentrism (the Earth is the center of the solar system), phlogiston (a fire-like element that causes objects to burn), miasma (the “bad air” source of disease), spontaneous generation (fully formed living organisms can abruptly arise out of inanimate matter), and the luminiferous aether (the medium filling outer space for the propagation of light)? Isn’t it possible that our current best theories—as well supported as they are—may one day go the way of Aristotelian physics, Ptolemaic astronomy, the flat earth theory, the hollow earth theory, the expanding earth theory, the four bodily humours theory of disease, phrenology, preformationism, creationism, alchemy, astrology, psychoanalysis, the Rutherford model of the atom, the steady state theory of the cosmos, and vitalism?”
As we look back on these erroneous scientific theories from centuries past with disdainful dismissal, will scientists in the 25th—or the 250th or 2500th century—look down upon us as we do medieval physicians who believed that the four bodily humours (black bile, phlegm, blood, and yellow bile) were linked to the four elements of nature (earth, water, air, and fire) that caused the four personality temperaments (melancholic, phlegmatic, sanguine, and choleric), all of which were linked to the zodiacal signs in the heavens?
Not likely. And that’s how we know we’re making progress. The postmodern belief that discarded ideas means that there is no objective truth and that all theories are equal is wronger than all of the wrong theories combined. I have called this Asimov’s Axiom, after an observation by the science writer Isaac Asimov:
"When people thought the earth was flat, they were wrong. When people thought the earth was spherical, they were wrong. But if you think that thinking the earth is spherical is just as wrong as thinking the earth is flat, then your view is wronger than both of them put together."
Think of science as an expanding sphere of knowledge. As the sphere of the known expands into the aether of the unknown, the proportion of ignorance seems to grow—the more you know, the more you know how much you don’t know. But in this mathematical metaphor note what happens when the radius of a sphere increases: the expansion of the surface area is squared while the increase in the volume is cubed. So as the sphere of scientific knowledge expands the volume of the known increases by a ratio of 3:2 over the surface area of the unknown—the more you know the more of the unknown becomes known. It is at this boundary where we can stake a claim of true progress in the search for truth. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Clarification of my statement on @Briankeating podcast about @ProfAviLoeb comment on “no new physics”.
Here is what Avi actually said:
“Just keep in mind, when people say new physics, the UAPs will teach us new physics. That is on top of what we already know.” -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Much of the knowledge about the world we signal that we accept as probably true is often downloaded onto others who have expertise or access to sources we don’t.
So when AG Bill Barr, lifetime Republican & 2x Trump voter said his Dept of Justice looked into claims the 2020 election was rigged and they found nothing after months of detailed investigation that should have ended it forever. Time to move on. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Drones the size of Mini Coopers capable of speeds and sudden turns that resemble you know what…
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmuMg608qtY -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You're on to us @GoodTroubleShow
@SusanGerbic Susie Q (as I call her) & I go way back. She is Director of Covert Operations for our Deep State Dark Program "Operation Skeptics" whose mission is hacking Wikipedia pages of believers to make them look bad. You're next so get ready.
The Good Trouble Show with Matt Ford
@GoodTroubleShow
Question for @michaelshermer: what is your relationship, past or present, with Susan Gerbic, founder of the group The Guerrilla Skeptics of Wikipedia?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you disagree with the hypothesis of @herandrews is it your instinct to refute it with facts & counter arguments, or to get angry, denounce it as misogynist, and demand she be cancelled for even proposing it?
Your answer itself may be explained by her hypothesis... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What is the price for saying people cannot change sex?
In Canada it is $750,000.
Justification:
“Transpeople are, by definition, people ‘whose gender identity does not align with the sex assigned to them at birth.' If a person elects not to ‘believe’ that gender identity is separate from sex assigned at birth, then they do not ‘believe’ in transpeople. This is a form of existential denial.”
That's a crime?
Well, you can dispute that in court if you are willing to spend the money on lawyers...or you can pay the state $
Human rights as an extortion ring.
quillette.com/2026/07/16/i-chaired-canadas-human-rights-t… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“How is it in the United States’ interest to have 94 million desperate [Iranians] flooding into Europe, flooding into the United States?” Vance said. Well, yes, but the administration should have thought of that before starting the war with Iran.
Indeed.
www.thefp.com/p/rod-dreher-jd-vances-time-for-choosing-is… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From Crucifixion to Resurrection:
Alexandros Fatsis makes the case in his analysis for Skeptic that :
The real question is not
“Did the physical resurrection of Jesus literally happen?”
but
“Did the original disciples even claim that it did?”
www.skeptic.com/article/from-crucifixion-to-resurrection-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You @FernandoFLongo seem to place a lot of emphasis on David Fravor and the USS Nimitz TicTac incident of 2004 off San Diego, about which he told the House Oversight Committee that the object's capabilities far exceeded any known human technology.
What do you think it was? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In case you were experiencing a bit of FOMO re SpaceX stock, if you didn’t purchase any good move! It’s a dog stock now, back to its opening price and well below where us regular investors could get in, but hopefully it’s a long-term investment…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For those who lean heavily on eyewitness testimony for UAPs note @rossgarber analysis:
"The law learned long ago that testimony can fail in four separate ways, and only one of them is lying. A witness must have perceived accurately, remembered faithfully, narrated precisely, and spoken sincerely. The law treats each capacity as a distinct point of failure. Perception fails. Trained aviators have chased Venus. Memory fails, and worse, it edits: mistaken identification remains the leading contributor to DNA-era exonerations, and courts have spent two decades rewriting jury instructions to absorb the science of how confident, honest witnesses come to remember things that never happened.
And narration fails on this subject in a particular way: witnesses reach for the vocabulary their culture hands them. In 1947, Kenneth Arnold described objects whose motion resembled a saucer skipped across water; a wire-service reporter compressed that into “flying saucers,” and saucer-shaped craft promptly began appearing in reports nationwide. The most famous shape in the phenomenon’s history entered the record through a headline. Vallée spent a career documenting how encounter narratives track the folklore of their era (mystery airships in 1897, ghost rockets in 1946, saucers after Arnold), and Pasulka has shown how the modern material functions as something close to a living religion, with relics, pilgrimage sites, and conversion experiences. None of this requires a single insincere witness. And the contamination is accelerating."
open.substack.com/pub/garberfiles/p/how-to-judge-a-ufo?r=… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good point @rossgarber
"The eighty-year UAP record—the sightings, the sensor tapes, the whistleblowers, the alleged programs, the admitted deceptions—is not a data set. It is a case file. And case files are what the other method is for.”
Rules of Evidence
open.substack.com/pub/garberfiles/p/how-to-judge-a-ufo?r=… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why indeed?
hotair.com/john-s-2/2026/07/14/why-people-believe-candace… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my own analysis of "The New Pseudohistorians: Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson, and the New Antisemitism and Holocaust Denial"
www.skeptic.com/article/owens-carlson-antisemitism-holoca… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excellent piece in @TheFP by @nfergus & @JohnClarkLevin on how AI + popular podcasters like Tucker Carlson have mainstreamed Holocaust denial, basically resurrecting David Irving, Ernst Zundel, Mark Weber, et. al. long-ago debunked talking points:
www.thefp.com/p/the-death-of-history?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm upbraided for not quoting from this article about my application of base-rate re UAP sightings.
O-kay, here it is:
"So did Shermer apply it properly? He did, at least in the two places I just gave him. The drone flap and the four cells are honest uses of the base rate."
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting article but title doesn't match content.
"The Base Rate Doesn't Mean What Shermer Thinks It Means"
Author David Burkett then provides several examples of where I applied "base-rate neglect" precisely in my convo with @AlchemyAmerican
Example with which I agree:
"Shermer spent a prior-setting tool against the sensitivity, the one number it has no grip on. Asking how rare something is sets your starting line. It does not measure whether these particular instruments can tell a real object from a glitch."
This is why need better data so we can get a grip on the right number!
liesabove.com/articles/the-base-rate-doesnt-mean-what-she… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The call is coming from inside the house @Briankeating or…
Keep your friends close and your enemies even closer or…
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Michael Shermer bet $1,000 that we won't confirm alien visitation by 2030. @ProfAviLoeb took the bet.
Then the White House asked Loeb to build a UAP science council, and one of Loeb's first pick was Shermer.
The skeptic is now inside the room he bet against. Good idea?
Watch my conversation with @michaelshermer on @Into_Impossible
youtu.be/cR2WVOVuq_I?sub_confirmation=1 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Riding next to the largest air conditioner in the world listening to the bio of my favorite President about whom JFK said, addressing a dinner for all living Nobel laureates at the White House, “the greatest collection of minds since Thomas Jefferson dined here alone.”
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Some wonder why there are social scientists on the UAP Science Advisory Council. @JenniceVilhauer explains why we are part of the team:
“This is why psychology belongs in UAP research.
Our role is not to determine what UAP are. That is a question for the physical sciences. Psychology asks different but equally important questions. How do people perceive unusual events? Does perception and consciousness play a role in what people are seeing? How do they make sense of experiences that challenge deeply held assumptions? How does stigma influence whether people report what they have seen? And how can we support individuals without prematurely dismissing their experiences or encouraging conclusions that the evidence does not support?” www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/living-forward/202606/why… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Perfect summary by @JenniceVilhauer of our overall mission for the UAP Science Advisory Council of which I am a part:
“If some UAP represent advanced technology developed by an adversarial nation, the implications for national security are obvious. If they turn out to be misunderstood atmospheric or technological phenomena, studying them could improve our understanding of the natural world while advancing sensor technology, aviation safety, and aerospace engineering. And if a small number ultimately require explanations beyond our current scientific understanding, the scientific implications could be profound.”Regardless of the answer, society benefits from finding it.”
www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/living-forward/202606/why… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Precisely @SwipeWright
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
I think a lot of people don't understand what a "skeptic" actually is.
A skeptic isn't someone who believes all clams are false until evidence demonstrates otherwise. A skeptic merely holds that no claim should be believed to be true without sufficient supporting evidence.
Many have difficulty distinguishing the important nuance between those positions. That's why so many people respond with anger or frustration to skeptics when we claim to not believe something they believe. They think we're claiming they're wrong, when we're actually just saying they haven't sufficiently demonstrated to us that they're right. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My last meal with Tom Nash
Fabulous conversation (and meal!) on:
free speech, the dangers of dogmatism, why smart people believe weird things, and how to stay intellectually open while still being skeptical.
youtu.be/b52MopZvtV8?list=PLbi_N1jtAsXE -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Michael Shermer examines the cognitive processes behind belief formation and the importance of critical thinking. Through the lens of signal detection theory and Bayesian reasoning, Shermer illustrates how to evaluate evidence, navigate scientific uncertainty, and understand the impact of social signaling on what is accepted as reality."
youtu.be/zx-YTb9u6JE -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Mr. Burkett, I'm not sure why you tossed into this otherwise good article that anyone who thinks sex is binary is transphobic. You cited Dawkins, but me and nearly every scientist on the planet and in history uses the accepted definition of biological sex by gamete type (sperm or egg). There are only 2 sexes.
In fact, much of the trans movement is homophobic ("you're not gay or lesbian—you're straight but in the wrong body", no different from the egregious "conversion therapy" of the 1980s) & misogynist ("to bad women, we're letting men into your sports & spaces & if you don't like it get therapy for your transphobia").
liesabove.com/articles/the-base-rate-doesnt-mean-what-she… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting article but title doesn't match content.
"The Base Rate Doesn't Mean What Shermer Thinks It Means"
Author David Burkett then provides several examples of where I applied "base-rate neglect" precisely in my convo with @AlchemyAmerican
Example with which I agree:
"Shermer spent a prior-setting tool against the sensitivity, the one number it has no grip on. Asking how rare something is sets your starting line. It does not measure whether these particular instruments can tell a real object from a glitch."
This is why need better data so we can get a grip on the right number!
liesabove.com/articles/the-base-rate-doesnt-mean-what-she… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Exactly right @SwipeWright My brand of skepticism is that of any scientist starting with the null hypothesis, willing to overturn it with sufficient evidence (equivalent of a p = 0.05 or better). Doesn't necessarily make it true (note the replication crisis) but > confidence,
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
I am very familiar with Carl Sagan's saying "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence."
Your brother is chastising "skeptics" for asking those making claims about foul Russian play in this particular case for supporting evidence. That is a completely reasonable and necessary thing to do when people make unsupported claims, and merely pointing to other cases of known foul play does not count as evidence for this particular case.
This is a completely basic point to make with respect to the philosophy of science.
Perhaps your brother was just sloppy with his wording when he said "raises claims" instead of "raises questions." Nevertheless, my post rightfully highlighting the important distinction between raising questions and making claims.
I have not seen any so-called "skeptics" chastise people for simply raising questions about Lindsay Graham's sudden death, as your brother seems to suggest. What I have seen are posts like your brother's chastise others for demanding evidence for their specific claims.
Your brother called for "extra scientific skepticism to die." But @michaelshermer isn't practicing "extra scientific skepticism." His brand of scientific skepticism is totally standard—or at least should be—with respect to the burden of proof.
Ro summarize, raising questions is totally fine and even necessary. But when someone moves from simply raising questions to making claims, they are then required to support their claims with evidence. And it's important to call out and criticize people who fail to do that. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Skeptic is doing a deep dive into consciousness.
"The question is whether consciousness, the interior fact of experience, is the kind of thing that becomes fully visible when the map is complete, or whether it remains, in some stubborn way, the one part of reality that can be described from the outside but never fully captured there." —neuroscientist Jashan Mahajan
www.skeptic.com/article/search-for-consciousness/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Some UAP may be laser-produced plasma balls, meteor-triggered plasmoids, shock-heated hypersonic bodies, conventional drones, and sensor artifacts. But others may be of more exotic origin. We need better data in order to separate the wheat from the chaff."
@ProfAviLoeb -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Happy le 14 juillet, la fête nationale, Bastille Day France, anniversary of the Storming of the Bastille on 14 July 1789 that triggered the French Revolution & Fête de la Fédération 14 July 1790 of the unity of the French people.
I only know this watching today's Tour de France! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re conspiracy theories about Lindsey Graham's death, remember the fallacy ID'd by Kahneman & Tversky: base-rate neglect.
X is really surprising
Compared to what?
~13,000 people die from aortic dissection annually U.S.
~930,000 people die from cardiovascular disease annually U.S. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My response to @ericweinstein (Eric's quoted comment, my response):
"Yeah…nah. Here’s what I think is happening instead. I haven’t wanted to say this, but there is a problem with organized Skepticism even more than conspiracy theories."
Eric, you have been telling me this for about a decade, and since I am the publisher of Skeptic magazine I have invited you to contribute an article on what you consider to be the problem with “organized Skepticism” and I’m still waiting. The offer stands. If you have something to say about skepticism, then say it in a publication in addition to a tweet.
“My claim is that from hard evidence NOT ONE of the following is an extraordinary claim: The CIA not only gathers intelligence but kills people, violates rights, gaslights and evades scrutiny and oversight. The U.S. hides bioweapons programs. The U.S. engages in regime change through charity and aid programs. We in the U.S. medically experiment on our own citizens without consent. We run drugs. The DOJ and FBI are actively and flagrantly obstructing justice. Putin easily kills people outside Russia. We conspire and use academics for sheepskin washing our dirty work. U.S. newspapers actively avoid reporting stories about which the U.S. population is desperate for information. They also carry extremely non neutral biases. We actively conspired to hide open and obvious presidential dementia. And by extension, there are massive conspiracies at every level below that one. At a mind boggling level. There are Special Access programs that are about real and/or fake NHI/UFOs Etc."
This all depends on what you mean by "extraordinary" Eric. Everything you say has an element of truth, inasmuch as they have happened, but you go too far in suggesting that they happen routinely and regularly (ordinary), such that anything that happens in the news could be construed as an example.
It’s true, we know that the CIA has assassinated people, violated rights, dosed U.S. citizens with LSD (Frank Olson; MKULTRA), and has evaded scrutiny and oversight. Does that mean anytime a foreign leader dies mysteriously that it was the CIA, or could be the CIA? Of course not! That something has happened, and is a rare thing, is not the same as that it is still happening and regularly. And one reason we know about MKULTRA, the CIA’s nefarious activities overseas in the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s, their assassinations and attempts, their support for fascist dictators over communist dictators (because at least the fascists can be persuaded with money) was the 1975-76 Church Committee findings in which all this came out, and subsequent oversight of the agency was commenced, with much scrutiny!
U.S. sponsored charity and aid programs are what is called “soft power”. It is a way of exerting our influence while also showing our generosity and moral obligation to help people in need. This is normal and good. To call it “regime change” is inaccurate. When the U.S. does that, it usually does so openly, expensively, and often stupidly. We should stick with sponsoring charity and aid programs.
Agreed, Putin famously has enemies assassinated, even outside of Russia. Does that mean he had Lindsey Graham, or Charlie Kirk, or any other recognizable figure killed? Of course not! Evidence, not innuendo.
Agreed, U.S. newspapers/media are notoriously biased, which is why we have freedom of the press, so you can read the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal, add them up and divide by 2! More seriously, independent journalism is a market response to the biases on both sides, and today we enjoy so many journalistic sources that it is impossible to keep up.
Yes, some media sources “conspired to hide open and obvious presidential dementia” (not to mention a certain president's son’s laptop), but how do we know about that? From other media sources that blasted out the story far and wide everywhere (even while much of the MSM didn’t cover it or ignored it or tried to bury it).
Ditto the Twitter Files and other exposés. It's hard to hide these things in a free and open society.
“The last thing we need is skeptics telling us the bar for such conspiracies and/or governmental accountability requires extraordinary evidence. Somehow the skeptics have it totally wrong. … Time for extra scientific skepticism to die I think. Covert operations and conspiracies are difficult enough to document as it is. We don’t need skeptics as self appointed referees.”
Eric, I always enjoy your X posts and podcast appearances, but why not take the next step of actually writing down what it is you actually believe, and why, with references, citations, documented examples, statistical comparisons, evidence, etc. I post on X, have my own podcast, and do countless podcasts myself—absolutely nothing wrong with that. But it’s just a start. PUBLISH your ideas, especially in venues where there are fact-checkers and editors to make sure you get it right, because we ALL make errors.
So…what do you think Eric, how about an article in Skeptic on the problem of organized skepticism and your proposed solutions, suggestions, recommendations, etc.? As promised, we will publish it.
Eric Weinstein
@ericweinstein
Yeah…nah.
Here’s what I think is happening instead.
I haven’t wanted to say this, but there is a problem with organized Skepticism even more than conspiracy theories. My claim is that from hard evidence NOT ONE of the following is an extraordinary claim:
The CIA not only gathers intelligence but kills people, violates rights, gaslights and evades scrutiny and oversight.
The U.S. hides bioweapons programs.
The U.S. engages in regime change through charity and aid programs.
We in the U.S. medically experiment on our own citizens without consent.
We run drugs.
The DOJ and FBI are actively and flagrantly obstructing justice.
Putin easily kills people outside Russia.
We conspire and use academics for sheepskin washing our dirty work.
U.S. newspapers actively avoid reporting stories about which the U.S. population is desperate for information. They also carry extremely non neutral biases.
We actively conspired to hide open and obvious presidential dementia. And by extension, there are massive conspiracies at every level below that one. At a mind boggling level.
There are Special Access programs that are about real and/or fake NHI/UFOs
Etc.
————
The last thing we need is skeptics telling us the bar for such conspiracies and/or governmental accountability requires extraordinary evidence.
Somehow the skeptics have it totally wrong.
After Watergate, Iran-Contra, COVID, Church/Pike committees, etc. these are no longer extraordinary claims to raise. They are ordinary claims.
I have no idea whether Lindsay Graham died of natural causes. But I can tell you the difference between a skeptic and a scientist looking at the claim.
A skeptic’s first move is to lurch for the budding conspiracy and try to pull the idea of foul play off the table first and then to require a mountain of evidence to consider such a thing.
A scientist firmly grabs the skeptic’s hand and forces him to put the hypothesis back on the table and says “Uh, you’re not in charge here. There’s a history…and I’m going to need to see something other than reference to null hypotheses, William of Occam and Carl Sagan…because that’s not how science and investigation works.”
Time for extra scientific skepticism to die I think. Covert operations and conspiracies are difficult enough to document as it is.
We don’t need skeptics as self appointed referees.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re conspiracy theories already surfacing that Lindsey Graham was murdered by Russians, here is SuperGrok's latest info on his cause of death.
"Aortic dissection due to arteriosclerotic cardiovascular disease" not a poison-tipped dart, plutonium trace, etc.
x.com/i/grok/share/fe78c7a6349d4ca9929566e95784c534 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Global warming is real, human caused & its effects are mostly negative but @BjornLomborg compares its costs to that of trying to reduce it:
Paris Agreement = $819–$1,890 billion per year in 2030
IPCC: climate damages reduces human welfare for the 21st century from 450% to 434%
Perspective
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0040162520304157 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Classic quote mining & offense archaeology. As I've told you & other UAPers @FernandoFLongo read what I've actually written on the subject, which is extensive, starting with this excerpt from a much longer chapter in my book Truth, on UFOs/aliens:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/
Fernando Longo
@FernandoFLongo
@michaelshermer, this is not a correction. It is a substitution of sources.
The satire did not claim to reproduce your later X post word for word. It condensed your recorded statements in the American Alchemy interview. Your actual spoken words included: “None of this happened,” “It cannot have happened,” “That is physically impossible,” and “Okay, you’re wrong.” The official American Alchemy post—and a post from your own account amplifying the same exchange—preserve those categorical statements.
The cartoon is explicitly satire, not a courtroom transcript. Nevertheless, its meaning is faithful to what you said. In fact, the exact podcast language is at least as categorical as the condensed wording in the speech bubbles.
Your later X formulation—“this could not have happened as reported, so either misperceived/measured or new physics needed”—is substantially narrower. It acknowledges that some premise in the reported account, measurements, interpretation, or physical model may be wrong. That is a conditional scientific claim. It is not equivalent to declaring that none of the event happened or that Fravor was simply wrong.
So which position do you actually defend?
If the later, narrower formulation represents your position, then acknowledge that it qualifies the categorical language you used in the podcast. You cannot replace your recorded words with a more cautious later summary and then accuse the person quoting the original exchange of misrepresentation.
Your own article makes the problem even clearer. You acknowledge that some observations remain “unexplained anomalies,” yet repeatedly keep preferred ordinary hypotheses alive with language such as “perhaps,” “or maybe,” “most likely,” and “probably.” You praise Mick West’s work while also admitting that whether his assertions are correct is “very debatable.”
That is precisely the asymmetry my post criticized: soft possibility for the prosaic explanation, categorical certainty against the witness.
A distant aircraft may be considered on “most likely” and “maybe.” GoFast may become “probably just a weather balloon.” Bokeh may be “most likely.” But when discussing Fravor, the vocabulary abruptly becomes “cannot,” “impossible,” and “you’re wrong.” Your linked article does not refute the satire. It supplies the footnotes for it.
And Avi Loeb’s article still does not close the Nimitz case. After describing the atmospheric signatures expected under his assumptions, Avi explicitly calls for rigorous scientific study, multisensor evidence, radar ranging, spectroscopy, triangulation, and better data than are currently available in public UAP reports. His calculation identifies a conflict between reported kinematics and expected signatures; it does not determine which premise, measurement, track association, or evidentiary element is wrong.
The public challenge therefore remains unchanged: quote the exact sentence in Avi’s article where he states that Fravor imagined the encounter, that the reported radar observations were false, or that the Nimitz case has been solved.
If you cannot produce that sentence, then stop attributing that categorical conclusion to Avi.
A conditional calculation is not a total verdict.
A later, more careful X post does not erase your recorded podcast statements.
And linking your own article does not rescue your argument when the article itself demonstrates the exact double standard being criticized.
You did not correct the satire. You documented it.
Michael, since you asked me to use your exact words, here they are. In the recorded interview, you said: “None of this happened.” You said: “It cannot have happened. That is physically impossible.” And you said: “Okay, you’re wrong.” Those are your words, not mine.
Your later X post—“this could not have happened as reported”—is narrower and more cautious. It does not erase the categorical statements you made in the interview. At most, it qualifies them after the fact.
Your own article reinforces the methodological criticism. Ordinary explanations are introduced through “perhaps,” “or maybe,” “most likely,” and “probably,” while alternatives you disfavor receive language such as “simply not possible” and “Impossible.” That is precisely the asymmetry the satire illustrates.
So yes, let us use your exact words, your later clarification, and your own article. Taken together, they do not refute my characterization. They document it.
Had you been fully aware of your own words and certain of their meaning, you would never have mentioned me as though I had fabricated them. I am not putting words in your mouth; I am placing your own recorded statements, subsequent post, and published article side by side. Nothing more is required. The links speak for themselves.
x.com/AmericanALCHMY/status/2075333099693486517
x.com/michaelshermer/status/2075647380083601569
x.com/FernandoFLongo/status/2075774820482982180
x.com/FernandoFLongo/status/2076077137715491101
x.com/FernandoFLongo/status/2075675603035152782
x.com/FernandoFLongo/status/2075635832111628748
x.com/FernandoFLongo/status/2075348018795073546
avi-loeb.medium.com/on-mysterious-orbs-and-fireballs-4563… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re conspiracy theories already surfacing that Lindsey Graham was murdered by Russians, here is SuperGrok's latest info on his cause of death.
"Aortic dissection due to arteriosclerotic cardiovascular disease" not a poison-tipped dart, plutonium trace, etc.
x.com/i/grok/share/fe78c7a6349d4ca9929566e95784c534 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you're going to quote me @FernandoFLongo you should at least get my own words correct. Here is my actual X post words re the 2004 Nimitz incident:
"Here is the link to @ProfAviLoeb paper showing the calculations of why this could not have happened as reported. So either misperceived/measured or new physics needed."
If you will read more than a tweet, here is my overview on UAPs from which you can quote if you want to know what I actually believe:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/
Fernando Longo
@FernandoFLongo
TWO STYLES OF SKEPTICISM — PART 2
The attached satire is not an exaggeration. It illustrates two different ways of reaching a preferred conclusion without completing the analysis.
Michael Shermer uses categorical certainty: “It never happened,” “that cannot have happened,” and “you’re wrong.” Mick West uses indefinite possibility: “sometimes birds,” “sometimes bugs,” “sometimes coincidences,” or “could be a seagull.” One declares impossibility without reconstructing the complete event; the other offers generic possibilities without demonstrating that any of them explains the specific case.
Shermer’s treatment of Avi Loeb’s article is the clearest example. Avi’s own words do not support Shermer’s broader categorical conclusion that the Nimitz encounter “never happened”: “These UAP mysteries call for a rigorous scientific study” and “we need better data than currently available in public UAP reports.”
Those are not the words of a physicist declaring that the Nimitz encounter “never happened.” They are the words of a physicist identifying a conflict under a proposed physical model and demanding better evidence to determine what actually occurred. Avi explicitly calls for multisensor observations, radar ranging, spectroscopy and triangulation.
Shermer converted a conditional calculation into a total verdict.
Avi argues that, under his assumptions about how a visible macroscopic object—or even a proposed spacetime bubble—would interact with the atmosphere, motion at the inferred velocity should produce extreme heating, luminosity and a violent pressure wave. That exposes a conflict between the reported kinematics and the absence of expected signatures. It still does not determine which element of the record is wrong. It does not negate the reported radar observations, invalidate the witnesses, identify the object or prove that Commander David Fravor imagined the encounter.
Shermer also collapses distinct portions of the record into a single slogan. Fravor’s official statement attributes the descents from above 80,000 feet to Aegis observations during the preceding weeks. During the closest phase of his visual encounter, Fravor placed his aircraft at approximately 15,000 feet and the object at approximately 12,000 feet, followed by its disappearance and reported radar reacquisition at the CAP point. These are separate evidentiary elements, not one direct measurement made by Fravor.
So the public challenge remains simple: quote the exact sentence in Avi Loeb’s article where he says that Fravor was wrong, that the event never happened, that the radar reports were false, or that the Nimitz case has been solved.
If that sentence cannot be produced, then the characterization should be corrected. It is professionally embarrassing to cite an article for a conclusion its author did not state. Borrowing a physicist’s authority is already no substitute for technical expertise; removing the limitations and scientific caution from his argument makes the distortion worse—especially when Shermer and Loeb sit on the same UAP advisory council.
Mick West follows the opposite rhetorical route. When confronted with Marik’s specific objections involving downward camera tilt, banking geometry and the claimed absence of corresponding rotation during banking—which Marik argues falsifies West’s glare model—West does not directly resolve those points. He retreats into lottery analogies, hypothetical birds, bugs and “inevitable coincidences.”
But “sometimes” is not a reconstruction. “Could be” is not an identification. A general truth about probability is not evidence that a particular object was a bird, insect, distant aircraft or optical artifact. And asking which “significant” person has accepted the opposing argument shifts the discussion toward social validation instead of addressing the technical objections.
A hypothesis may begin with “possibly.” It cannot end there.
This is the contrast shown in the image: Shermer takes an incomplete record and says impossible; West takes an incomplete record and says sometimes. One converts conditional physics into categorical denial. The other converts generic possibilities into implied explanations.
Neither method substitutes for case-specific evidence, explicit assumptions, validated geometry, error margins, sensor context and a conclusion proportionate to the available data.
So we have two opposite rhetorical strategies serving the same methodological failure: Shermer closes the case with certainty before the evidence is complete; West keeps a prosaic hypothesis alive without demonstrating that it explains the case at issue. One overstates what the available data can exclude. The other understates what must be demonstrated before an explanation can be accepted. Different language, same result: the preferred conclusion is protected from falsification.
A calculation can challenge a model. It cannot erase an event record.
A possibility can open an investigation. It cannot close one.
Skepticism tests hypotheses against evidence. Debunking begins with the label and works backward.
Sources and referenced posts:
avi-loeb.medium.com/on-mysterious-orbs-and-fireballs-4563…
x.com/michaelshermer/status/2075647380083601569
x.com/MvonRen/status/2076108662825959507
x.com/MvonRen/status/2076202414810775724
@GoodTroubleShow
@MvonRen
@MickSeagull -
Michael Shermer reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"More misguided critique of the modern theory of evolution"—Jerry Coyne, as always, brings clarity to biological commentary in his blog Why Evolution Is True. whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/07/06/more-misguided-critique…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe: is this the price we pay for living in California (national average price for a gallon of gas premium is $4.77)
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How do men and women differ? Where do the differences come from? And how do they shape modern life?
My in-person convo with @SteveStuWill on sex differences science and its implications.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/the-truth-about-sex-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Mike @5X5_NEWS You need to at least post your paper on Arvix to get some peer review and commentary, and where are your citations of others's work on this issue?
5X5 NEWS
@5X5_NEWS
The paper that @michaelshermer will not acknowledge.
Why is that? drive.google.com/file/d/1fTaSmW4Jn6Ch1cSEmnr49ZVrJrQeMm-C… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Probed
@ProbedSpace
We’ve deeply indexed the full 34-page USAF study behind these figures. Beyond this case, it assesses approximately 210 reports, selected radar incidents and the competing domestic and foreign hypotheses Air Intelligence was weighing in 1948:
probed.space/documents/c9689d9e-59cd-4b95-9003-37e7036e8f65 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This fashion never goes out of style: back suit, white shirt, narrow dark tie, Ray-Ban sunglasses…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Peace through deterrence. So far so good but…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Recall pilot and astronaut Scott Kelly’s story at a NASA press conference that his RIO that they flew past a UFO, so they went back to see it up close…it was a Bart Simpson balloon.
Kyle McGuire
@TheKyleMcGuire
After hours studying the UFO film released today @patrickriitaaho has identified the Object.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another UFO/UAP anomaly from 1948—if if it were an actual V-2 rocket, the first one was launched from White Sands Proving Ground April 16, 1946, so it could be—with observers drawings. DOW-UAP-D094 from the UFO Files 4th tranche (Figures 7 & 8):
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What Will E.T. Really Look Like?
SETI scientist Seth Shostak draws on astrobiology & evolution. Moving beyond Hollywood he examines what science, evolution & astrobiology can tell us about their possible appearance.
7/15 9:30am PT Zoom
www.sciencekind.com -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @FernandoFLongo
90-95% of all sightings have ordinary terrestrial explanations.
We begin by assuming the rest have similar such explanations.
If they don’t, we continue searching for such explanations before we consider extraordinary terrestrial or extraterrestrial answers.
Last: alternative/new physics: time-warp bubbles, interdimensional beings, time travelers, etc.
Just ranking from probable to improve while acknowledging science can never explain all anomalies in any field.
It’s not only OK to say “I don’t know,” it’s a virtue.
Fernando Longo
@FernandoFLongo
Two styles of premature certainty: Shermer labels the unknown “mundane” before data arrive; West magnifies ambiguity until it resembles the explanation he already prefers.
Skepticism is not replacing mystery with familiarity. It is proportioning confidence to evidence.
Satire. -
Michael Shermer reposted
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
“I Had An Alien Abduction Experience!” -Michael Shermer @michaelshermer
Full ep. out now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why Charlie Kirk conspiracy theories?
The answer has to do with “proportionality bias,” a well-documented concept in the study of conspiracy theories. Proportionality bias kicks in when there is an imbalance or mismatch between the size or importance of an event and that of its purported cause. The Holocaust is an example of proportionality: It was one of the worst genocides in history, perpetrated by one of the most evil regimes in history. This creates a sense of “cognitive harmony”: balance between the cause and effect. Which means that, while there are conspiracy theories attempting to minimize or deny the Holocaust, few suggest it was perpetrated by someone other than the Nazis.
By contrast, the assassination of President John F. Kennedy by a lone assassin is out of proportion. The handsome and articulate leader of the free world, the most powerful person on the planet, taken out by a nut like Lee Harvey Oswald? Impossible! So, to create cognitive harmony, conspiracists convince themselves that there were actually additional operatives to balance the scale: the FBI, the CIA, the KGB, the Cubans, the mafia, the military industrial complex, and even Vice President Lyndon Johnson.
www.thefp.com/p/charlie-kirk-conspiracy-theories-never-die -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Okay Jesse, you got me here!
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
Funny moment
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
O-kay @TheUfoJoe @g_knapp what do YOU think it was and what is your explanation for how a physical object can move through the air that fast without a sonic boom or burning up?
What's more likely:
Mismeasurement/misperception or exotic physics (eg, warped space-time bubble?)
Joe Murgia
@TheUfoJoe
Not only Shermer, but @ProfAviLoeb thinks the same way on that. Objects traveling faster than speed of sound MUST create a sonic boom. So...if an object is measured traveling that fast and observers don't report a sonic boom, the measurements MUST be wrong. Pompous and arrogant.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP): Orb and Rod Object Functional Morphology and Kinematics as Evidence of non-Human Intelligence (NHI)
"Location-centric manifestations of Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) appear directly linked to variations in electric and magnetic (EM) field intensity. At sites where objects manifest as light balls, the assertion is that natural and technological UAP may co-exist."
www.researchgate.net/publication/386098992_Unidentified_A… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The new science of Unidentified Aerospace-Undersea Phenomena (UAP)
"these phenomena are increasingly attracting the attention of scientists around the world, some of whom have recently formed research efforts to monitor and scientifically study UAP."
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0376042125… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Plasmas may have been photographed in the 1940s by WWII pilots (identified as “Foo fighters”); repeatedly observed and filmed by astronauts and military pilots and classified as Unidentified Aerial—Anomalous Phenomenon."
www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=131506 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Extraterrestrial Life in the Thermosphere:
Plasmas, UAP, Pre-Life, Fourth State of Matter
"“Plasmas” up to a kilometer in size and behaving similarly to multicellular organisms have been filmed on 10 separate NASA space shuttle missions, over 200 miles above Earth within the thermosphere."
www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=131506 -
Michael Shermer reposted
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Gee I wonder what this "UFO" could be?
🎈🎈🎈 -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(13/20) People Underestimate Extent of Illegal Immigration
Most Americans underestimated the number of illegal immigrants that came into the country during Biden's Presidency (at least 10 million entered illegally, graph below on the left).
Liberals were the least accurate group, and were also much more likely to believe that the United States government has a moral obligation to provide health care to illegal immigrants (see graph below on the top right).
In a follow-up survey, we found that Americans who most strongly supported the deportation of illegal immigrants also most closely guessed the number of illegal immigrants currently in the country (see graph below on bottom right).
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer reposted
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
The Michael Shermer episode is out now (link below)
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
I debated America’s most famous UFO skeptic, newly appointed to the White House UAP Science Advisory Council, on the biggest UFO cases on record.
Sparks flew as Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer) denied anything anomalous occurred in the infamous 2004 Nimitz / Tic Tac incident, where a UAP was tracked by radar, FLIR and four expert Navy aviators. He admitted that something must have happened in Varginha, Brazil in 1996 when dozens of witnesses, including a hospital’s top neurosurgeon, described encountering an alien creature after a crash landing. When confronted with hundreds of cases of documented UFO incursions occurring over more than half a century at nuclear weapons facilities, the leading skeptic leaned on skeptical heuristics as a plausible explanation.
He also concedes on record that UFOs belong in the same category as dark matter: an indirectly measured cosmological phenomenon that science cannot currently explain but is taken for granted.
Shermer is the founding publisher of Skeptic Magazine, the author of more than a dozen books on belief and pseudoscience, and now sits on a White House scientific advisory group on UAP alongside Harvard's Avi Loeb. He has publicly bet that no major scientific institution will confirm an alien presence by the end of 2030.
Over three hours of heated debate, he called whistleblower David Grusch's testimony into question, despite it being found urgent and credible by the Intelligence Community Inspector General. He dismissed the pattern of scientists tied to UFO and exotic propulsion programs who have died or vanished, including General William McCasland, as statistically unremarkable, a cluster now under joint White House and FBI review. What crashed at Roswell, the microwave weapons causing Havana Syndrome, the 2024 New Jersey drone flap, strange sightings during the Apollo missions, the JFK assassination, and the quantum mechanics of remote viewing were all brought to the table.
Shermer also opened up about his own anomalous experience on his wedding day and how he explains his own experience of an “alien abduction” in 1983.
Full debate live now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
Michael Shermer on his "alien abduction"👇
"I did have an alien abduction experience in 1983."
"I was traveling along a lonely rural highway near Hagler, Nebraska, and a big vehicle with bright lights pulled me over."
"The aliens got out, and they abducted me into the ship, where I lost 90 minutes of time. Missing time."
"This was during Race Across America. I'd ridden 1,280 miles from Santa Monica Pier all the way into Nebraska, nonstop on a bicycle."
"No sleep. So I'm sleep-deprived, going like five miles an hour, just wobbling down the road."
"They go, we got to pull Shermer over. He's going too slow."
"A very strange thing happened to me last night. I think my group was aliens from another planet trying to capture me."
"The big spaceship is my support crew, a big motorhome with lights. And the aliens are my support crew — my girlfriend, my best friend, my mechanic."
"I've always used this example: people that have experiences really have them."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To the contrary @GoodTroubleShow
Here is Avi’s calculations showing why this could not have happened as described:
On Mysterious Orbs and Fireballs avi-loeb.medium.com/on-mysterious-orbs-and-fireballs-4563…
Again, why are you afraid to talk to me? I can explain all this to you directly as I did with Jesse.
The Good Trouble Show with Matt Ford
@GoodTroubleShow
It boggles the mind that @ProfAviLoeb would put @michaelshermer on the council.
Shermer fails to do remedial research on the topic he pontificates on, clearly lacks any true critical thinking skills, and has a financial interest in keeping up his lucrative racket.
He peddles scientific quackery.
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
"IT NEVER HAPPENED!" Michael Shermer on the Nimitiz UFO encounter.
"David Fravor talks about the UAP going from 80,000 feet to sea level like that. How could this possibly be?"
"It rapidly accelerated in front of us and disappeared. Our wingmen, roughly 8,000 feet above us, lost contact also."
"This is not possible for any physical object to move through the air at that speed. It would burn up, it would release an explosion, break the sound barrier."
"The people on the aircraft carrier Nimitz would have heard it. They would have reported it. None of this happened."
"Whatever he thinks he saw, that's not what happened. It cannot have happened. That is physically impossible."
"This is Avi Loeb saying this. He did the calculation. Can't happen."
"We know what happens when bolides and meteors come through the atmosphere at that speed. They burn up, they explode. This never happened with that UAP."
"80,000 feet to sea level? Oh my God. Okay, you're wrong."
"It's flying in ways that defy our current physics. That means we should study it and figure out if some future physics might be able to explain it."
Episode with Michael Shermer out now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
The Good Trouble Show with Matt Ford
@GoodTroubleShow
It boggles the mind that @ProfAviLoeb would put @michaelshermer on the council.
Shermer fails to do remedial research on the topic he pontificates on, clearly lacks any true critical thinking skills, and has a financial interest in keeping up his lucrative racket.
He peddles scientific quackery.
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
"IT NEVER HAPPENED!" Michael Shermer on the Nimitiz UFO encounter.
"David Fravor talks about the UAP going from 80,000 feet to sea level like that. How could this possibly be?"
"It rapidly accelerated in front of us and disappeared. Our wingmen, roughly 8,000 feet above us, lost contact also."
"This is not possible for any physical object to move through the air at that speed. It would burn up, it would release an explosion, break the sound barrier."
"The people on the aircraft carrier Nimitz would have heard it. They would have reported it. None of this happened."
"Whatever he thinks he saw, that's not what happened. It cannot have happened. That is physically impossible."
"This is Avi Loeb saying this. He did the calculation. Can't happen."
"We know what happens when bolides and meteors come through the atmosphere at that speed. They burn up, they explode. This never happened with that UAP."
"80,000 feet to sea level? Oh my God. Okay, you're wrong."
"It's flying in ways that defy our current physics. That means we should study it and figure out if some future physics might be able to explain it."
Episode with Michael Shermer out now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the link to @ProfAviLoeb paper showing the calculations of why this could not have happened as reported. So either misperceived/measured or new physics needed.
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
"IT NEVER HAPPENED!" Michael Shermer on the Nimitiz UFO encounter.
"David Fravor talks about the UAP going from 80,000 feet to sea level like that. How could this possibly be?"
"It rapidly accelerated in front of us and disappeared. Our wingmen, roughly 8,000 feet above us, lost contact also."
"This is not possible for any physical object to move through the air at that speed. It would burn up, it would release an explosion, break the sound barrier."
"The people on the aircraft carrier Nimitz would have heard it. They would have reported it. None of this happened."
"Whatever he thinks he saw, that's not what happened. It cannot have happened. That is physically impossible."
"This is Avi Loeb saying this. He did the calculation. Can't happen."
"We know what happens when bolides and meteors come through the atmosphere at that speed. They burn up, they explode. This never happened with that UAP."
"80,000 feet to sea level? Oh my God. Okay, you're wrong."
"It's flying in ways that defy our current physics. That means we should study it and figure out if some future physics might be able to explain it."
Episode with Michael Shermer out now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Geology seat from 30,000 feet SBA to LAS, Red Rocks, desert, Vegas. FreedomFest conference Caesars. Debating abortion, free will, conspiracies.
What happens here stays here…where else could it go? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you want a highly readable and encyclopedic overview of UFOs you can’t do better than @I_D_Official Richard Dolan’s book I’m listening to now.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The very first entry in the DoW UFO Files tranche #4 is of a 1949 conference at Los Alamos about “green fireballs” seen near the facility, which some suggested might be “related to meteors entering the atmosphere at a shallow angle and high altitude." Teller suggested it could be an “electron phenomenon”.
This may be relevant to Dr. Birks's hypothesis that some UAPs may be explained by illuminous meteoric dust:
www.war.gov/medialink/ufo/071026/release_04/documents/DOE… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why the Charlie Kirk Conspiracy Theories Will Never Die
The stronger the evidence becomes, the more elaborate the theories grow. The reason lies in a psychological tendency to seek causes proportionate to consequential events.
My analysis for @TheFP
www.thefp.com/p/charlie-kirk-conspiracy-theories-never-di… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Oh man Jesse @AlchemyAmerican Michels, I look so angry here! Aargh. I’m taking no prisoners!! As Drago said to Rocky, “I must break you.” Bring it on…
open.spotify.com/episode/6OuQnHVTYnh5c7XXRoAvc9 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"why do the Manson murders continue to fascinate us? First of all, they were not perpetrated by a lone Norman Bates-type psychotic, but by a collective, which made them closer to a form of terrorism than the multiple rapes and killings committed by someone like Ted Bundy. Nor were the murders indiscriminate mass shootings like those wrought by two students at Colorado’s Columbine High School in 1999. That some of the killers were young, sexually active women, rather than alienated and isolated men, is also an anomaly among famous crimes."
quillette.com/2026/07/09/charlie-is-my-darling-charles-ma… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
. @rosscoulthart
@ProfAviLoeb argues these lights are cosmic rays.
Even if you doubt it, it is still FAR more likely than that they represent ETIs, interdimensional beings, etc.
We have a lot of evidence for cosmic rays.
We have no evidence of ETIs yet.
avi-loeb.medium.com/we-should-not-mistake-cosmic-rays-for…
Ross Coulthart
@rosscoulthart
I just checked with my very knowledgeable contact who knows the electrics of the lunar module and he said there is a blue light that came on in the lunar modules once the contact wires under the landing gear touched the surface. It displayed for 2.5 seconds and was then cut. Not activated again. This does not explain the blue lights seen throughout the outbound and homeward Apollo missions, nor those seen while astronauts were on the lunar surface.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(12/20) Young Liberals More Often End Relationships Over Politics
In a 2024 survey, we found that over a third of young liberals would end a relationship with a family member over political disagreements (see graph below on the left).
In a 2025 survey, more than a third of them said they had already done so (see graph below on the top right).
Those that identified as "very liberal" (regardless of age) were twice as likely as those that identified as "very conservative" to say that they have ended a friendship AND stopped speaking to a family member over politics (see graph below on bottom right).
Learn more about this topic here: x.com/SkepResCenter/status/1927211073066725708
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Mysteries, Meteors, and Foo Fighters
Might luminous meteoric dust be a possible explanation for some of the mysterious orgs spotted by pilots in World War II known as foo fighters?
My latest in Skeptic on UAPs...
www.skeptic.com/article/mysteries-meteors-and-foo-fighters/ -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another example @sapinker
When Jackie Kennedy heard it was Lee Harvey Oswald who killed her husband, she said to her mother:
"He didn't even have the satisfaction of being killed for civil rights... It had to be some silly little communist."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The Proportionality Bias": We think big events need big causes, and can't accept that the course of history can be changed by some odious little schmuck. @michaelshermer gives examples.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The truth is @DouglasKMurray that Charlie Kirk was assassinated by a lone gunman, just like JFK, RFK, & MLK.
Example of Proportionality Bias:
We think big events need big causes.
Holocaust was caused by Nazis: one of the worst genocides by one of the worse regimes. Balance.
Princess Di: cause of death—drunk driving, speeding, no seat belt: imbalance, so conspiracists add MI6, Royal Family, et al.
9/11: 19 guys with box cutters pulled off the greatest terrorist attack in U.S. history? Impossible. Had to be an inside job.
JFK: killed by a lone gunman. Imbalance. Conspiracists add CIA, FBI, KGB, LBJ, mafia, Castro, et al.
Charlie Kirk was famous & influential, so his death must be orchestrated by a cabal of assassins of the CIA, his org, his wife or, of course, Israel/Jews
www.thefp.com/p/charlie-kirk-assassination-trial-conspira… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @overclassifiedx
According to hardcore Ufologists (Hynek, Valle, Dolan, Kean) 90-95% of all sightings have mundane ordinary terrestrial explanations so, yeah, I cover that, while acknowledging many mysteries remain.
BTW, there's a lot of bunk out there that needs debunking!
OVERCLASSIFIED
@overclassifiedx
🛸 White House UAP Skeptic Shermer in Explosive Debate on Crash Evidence & NHI!
Jesse Michels (@AlchemyAmerican) just released a heated debate with Michael Shermer, the longtime ET debunker appointed June 15 to the new White House UAP Science Advisory Council (alongside Avi Loeb & Garry Nolan).
Shermer pushes mundane explanations like meteor dust plasmas for orbs while getting pressed on real physical evidence, including the 1957 Ubatuba magnesium fragments (high-purity samples recovered after a reported UFO incident in Brazil).
As whistleblowers allege ongoing crash retrieval programs and biologics, Shermer’s new advisory role raises the question: is this “scientific oversight” or controlled pushback against Non Human Intelligence disclosure?
The evidence is physical.
The resistance is institutional.
The timeline is now.
(Full episode drops publicly tomorrow.)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Definitely the highest quality production value of a podcast that I've ever done. You have an amazing team @AmericanALCHMY Jesse Michels.
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
Michael Shermer out now for members. Public release tomorrow (Thursday July 9th)
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More findings from our Skeptic Research Center that promises to put the cat among the pigeons...
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(11/20) Women Are More in Favor of Censorship and More Likely to Falsely Believe the Government Has Hate Speech Laws
We found that women are more inclined than men to want to prevent people from believing, saying, and doing what they want (see graph below on the left).
With respect to online political discourse specifically, we found that older women were particularly favorable to censorship (see graph below on top right).
Women, in general, were also more likely than men to believe, incorrectly, that the US government has laws against "hate speech" (see graph below on bottom right).
Learn more about this topic: research.skeptic.com/censorship-in-america/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I tagged the wrong In Vivo podcast. This is the right one!
@InVivoPodOnX
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My Alien Abduction:
Unexplained Experience in Nebraska!
I recount for Tim Gabor on @InVivo podcast what happened to me in the early morning hours on a lovely rural highway in Nebraska…
youtu.be/k6yAlTeewOs -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Convergent evolution supports the idea of ETIs being something like bipedal primates if you follow the model of Simon Conway Morris @AlchemyAmerican
Contingency is constrained by physical parameters. Good clip!
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
👽😲America’s Top Skeptic Says Aliens Might Look Like Humans!
Michael Shermer explains why convergent evolution could make intelligent extraterrestrials look more familiar than we expect...with limbs, eyes, brains, and bodies shaped by the same physical pressures that shaped life on Earth.
Episode with Michael Shermer out tomorrow (out now for members. link below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The State of the Trans Debate, 2026
Lisa Selin Davis updates her previous article in Skeptic on Trans Matters, our cover story, here reviewing all the research on Gender Affirming Care, detransitioners, lawsuits, sports, spaces, etc. Best overview here:
www.skeptic.com/article/gender-affirming-care-science-vs-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This was one of the best convos I've had on this topic with anyone ever. Jesse Michels @AlchemyAmerican is incredibly informed & deeply read on UFOs & related topics so it was a challenging day
I should add that he & his team are incredibly warm, welcoming & took good care of me
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
HEATED debate on UFOs with America's top scientific skeptic and new White House advisor Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer) out tonight for members, tomorrow for public
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My Alien Abduction:
Unexplained Experience in Nebraska!
I recount for Tim Gabor on @InVivo podcast what happened to me in the early morning hours on a lovely rural highway in Nebraska…
youtu.be/k6yAlTeewOs -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Coming soon…epic 3.5 hour convo with @AlchemyAmerican Jesse Michels on UAPs, UFOs, ETIs, etc.
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
HEATED debate on UFOs with America's top scientific skeptic and new White House advisor Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer) out tonight for members, tomorrow for public
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Kudos to @michaelshermer for consistently defending rationality, evidence, and the naturalistic world view against ever-present corrosion by purveyors of magic and mysticism (which easily shades into conspiracy thinking, since advocates claim that the corrupt elite establishment is hiding the truth from you).
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
. @JMGreerWriter
Dowsing "works" by the ideomotor effect—tiny motions of the arms & hands move the rods beneath perception.
Movements are random or directed by thought.
"Hits" are accidental.
Confirmation bias: remember hits, forget misses.
Under controlled conditions—dowser is blind to where buckets of water are hidden under opaque boxes that also include no water boxes—no one has EVER found water better than chance.
Ditto Ouija board.
John Michael Greer
@JMGreerWriter
Dowsing works; nobody knows how or why, but it works. It plays a much wider role in contemporary life than most people realize.
To cite only one example, when archeologists in Britain say that they found this or that subsurface feature by “probing with metal rods,” a line you’ll read in the journals quite often, that doesn’t mean somebody was hammering metal rods into the ground. It means this: -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In case you get these scam emails do NOT click on it. They want your password to take over your X account. I have no idea how scammers make money in so doing, or if they're just hackers hacking for fun, but beware...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"SETI is Sagan's sense that any discovery of intelligent life beyond Earth would mark a new stage in the development of humanity. Perhaps that is what that humanity really needs from extraterrestrials: not conclusive proof of their existence, but a sense of possibility. In an age when scientific knowledge has banished naive belief in divine and demonic beings, aliens are the last remaining candidate for other minds to share the universe with us."
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The truth is @DouglasKMurray that Charlie Kirk was assassinated by a lone gunman, just like JFK, RFK, & MLK.
Example of Proportionality Bias:
We think big events need big causes.
Holocaust was caused by Nazis: one of the worst genocides by one of the worse regimes. Balance.
Princess Di: cause of death—drunk driving, speeding, no seat belt: imbalance, so conspiracists add MI6, Royal Family, et al.
9/11: 19 guys with box cutters pulled off the greatest terrorist attack in U.S. history? Impossible. Had to be an inside job.
JFK: killed by a lone gunman. Imbalance. Conspiracists add CIA, FBI, KGB, LBJ, mafia, Castro, et al.
Charlie Kirk was famous & influential, so his death must be orchestrated by a cabal of assassins of the CIA, his org, his wife or, of course, Israel/Jews
www.thefp.com/p/charlie-kirk-assassination-trial-conspira… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
. @JMGreerWriter
Dowsing "works" by the ideomotor effect—tiny motions of the arms & hands move the rods beneath perception.
Movements are random or directed by thought.
"Hits" are accidental.
Confirmation bias: remember hits, forget misses.
Under controlled conditions—dowser is blind to where buckets of water are hidden under opaque boxes that also include no water boxes—no one has EVER found water better than chance.
Ditto Ouija board.
John Michael Greer
@JMGreerWriter
Dowsing works; nobody knows how or why, but it works. It plays a much wider role in contemporary life than most people realize.
To cite only one example, when archeologists in Britain say that they found this or that subsurface feature by “probing with metal rods,” a line you’ll read in the journals quite often, that doesn’t mean somebody was hammering metal rods into the ground. It means this: -
Michael Shermer reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Background: The political left has hoped and dreamed that Lamarckism is true for more than a century, despite its manifest absurdity (how can a macroscopic effect on the body be reverse-coded into genetic instructions and passed into eggs and sperm? Why aren’t Jewish boys born pre-circumcised)? Lamarck’s principle of “Felt need” is just as mystical – how does needing to see conjure an eye into being?
George Bernard Shaw, the Fabian socialist, wrote: “"Darwinism seems simple because you do not at first realize all that it involves. But when its whole significance dawns on you, your heart sinks into a heap of sand within you. There is a hideous fatalism about it, a ghastly and damnable reduction of beauty and intelligence, of strength and purpose, of honor and aspiration." (One may contrast this with Darwin’s own ending to the Origin, in which he eloquently wrote, “There is grandeur in this view of life….”) And of course the famines in Soviet Russia arose from Lysenko making Lamarckism official state doctrine.
Yet the academic left won’t give up, grasping at epigenetic straws (very different) as if they vindicated Jean-Baptiste. That task seems to have fallen to Riskin, who, with Marcus Feldman, has inherited the role of anti-genetics and anti-evolution policeman for the New York Review of Books now that Stephen Jay Gould and Jerry’s mentor Dick Lewontin are no longer with us. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Think Like a Scientist
My convo with Tim Gabor on the In Vivo podcast
"his personal journey from born-again Christian to skeptic; how his faith unraveled, James Randi, Uri Geller & skepticism & why critical thinking is more important than ever."
youtu.be/_D6BSWYIx5Q -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Account of a foo fighter, Nov. 1944, flying along the Rhine north of Strasbourg, pilots reported seeing “8 to 10 bright orange lights off the left wing…flying through the air at high speed. Later they appeared farther away. The display continued for several minutes and then disappeared.”
New paper by atmospheric chemist John Birks on "orbs" as "weakly ionized dusty plasma formed by stabilization of meteoric dust in the lower atmosphere."
"luminous orbs represent a rare but physically real atmospheric phenomenon"
"the strong correlation between orb observations and meteor activity reported here provides a solid physical starting point. Although novel in several respects, the proposed framework is based on established physical principles, and its components are testable through laboratory experiments, targeted atmospheric measurements, and more detailed theoretical modelling. It may even be possible to generate orbs in the laboratory from magnetic nanoparticles of iron."
Could some foo fighters be luminous meteoric dust? Maybe.
This is how progress is made in explaining UAPs.
lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Orb.pdf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just speak honestly at this point:
"On the heels of the gay rights movement it seemed like the liberal thing to say that women can have penises, transwomen are women, men can get pregnant, and all the rest, while ignoring biology in the name of ideology because I was going along with what I mistakenly thought was the next rights revolution. I now realize this was wrong and I apologize to women."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The estimable Jerry Coyne @Evolutionistrue critiques our review of the new Lamarck biography that highlights the French biologist's accomplishments. Jerry explains why Darwin is revered today by scientists while Lamarck is largely forgotten.
whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/07/06/more-misguided-critique… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The accusations against the New Atheists @sapinker of being “militant” “evangelical secularists” “shallow” “Islamophobic” & not understanding deep theology was matched by the “faitheists” who condescendingly say the little people need religion & the New Atheists robbed them.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Together with the stuff @michaelshermer singles out in this post, I had in mind the contempt among intellectuals for "the New Atheists" (Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, Dan Dennett, Richard Dawkins), despite their failing to point out anything they got wrong, and the surprisingly softball treatment of ESP, astrology, and UFOs in mainstream publications like NYT.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Over several decades it's fallen to @MichaelShermer to debunk every variety of woo-woo, UFOlogy, quantum obfuscation, ESP, Holocaust denial, creationism, and other "weird beliefs" -- not a minor pursuit, since the rational, naturalistic world view is the basis for personal self-protection and human progress. (Among Shermer's honorable predecessors were Martin Gardner, James "The Amazing" Randi, Carl Sagan, Isaac Asimov, and Richard Feynman, and on a more theoretical plane, Bertrand Russell and Karl Popper.)
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For those baffled by @sapinker comment on elite intellectuals who believe in "miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP, divine providence, karma, & all the rest" I hear their arguments regularly. Here it is:
Science is not an asymptotic curve approaching reality.
Kuhn showed that science is embedded in paradigms that constantly change, not necessarily closer to truth.
Science history is littered with mistaken theories overturned by new theories.
This will go on indefinitely.
It is only a matter of time before current physics is overturned and new physics allows for miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP....
In the 1890s physicists thought nearly everything was explained down to the 6th place after the decimal point.
Then came Einstein, Quantum Physics, etc.
Some of the "alternative theories" of physics floating around today may show these phenomena are real.
So it's not only okay to believe these mysteries are real, it's a signal that you are an intellectual sophisticate.
I explain why this is wrong in Truth: -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Science of the Declaration of Independence
The original version of my @BostonGlobe essay print version, documenting the scientific influences on the Founding Fathers, who were themselves natural philosophers ("scientists" in a later rendering):
www.skeptic.com/article/the-science-of-the-declaration-of… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the preprint of atmospheric chemist John Birks' analysis of 508 orb sightings reported to the National UFO Reporting Center (NUFORC):
"these silent, floating luminous objects often exhibit plasma-like behavior and emit visible light of varying colors for durations of up to an hour or more."
"reports of orb observations are shown to be significantly correlated (~3σ) with reports of meteor fireballs, suggesting a meteoritic origin."
"We propose that some orbs may represent a previously unrecognized type of weakly ionized dusty plasma formed by stabilization of meteoric dust in the lower atmosphere."
The paper was sent to @ProfAviLoeb for the UAP Science Advisory Council to review. More to come...
lweb.cfa.harvard.edu/~loeb/Orb.pdf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Science and the Declaration of Independence
The audio edition of my OpEd for the @BostonGlobe on the influence of the scientific revolution (along with the Enlightenment) on the founding of the United States.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/america-at-250-what-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Perhaps at least some of these atmospheric orbs as meteoritic dust clouds may account for some of the WWII "foo fighters" reported by pilots on bombing runs over Germany.
medium.com/p/are-uap-orbs-meteoritic-dust-clouds-7dd5394f… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Atmospheric chemist John Birks suggests a large % of UAP orbs may be meteoritic dust clouds, e.g., the October 2023 orange “mother” orb launching smaller red orbs (paper reports a significant statistical correlation of UAP orbs with meteor fireballs):
medium.com/p/are-uap-orbs-meteoritic-dust-clouds-7dd5394f… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
OMG this is getting crazier by the day. Matt Ford now says I get $20,000-$30,000 a talk, I depend on my book sales for my livelihood, me & Avi are on the board of SciAm (so we're meeting in secret), I am not a scientist (social science is "soft"), he & Eric Davis would show me the alien bodies & take me inside the spaceships but my cognitive dissonance is preventing me from going, etc.
Crazy! I'll go—for free!!
@GoodTroubleShow I'd be happy to explain to you why you are completely wrong about me & my beliefs. I just spent 3.5 hours talking to Jesse Michels' on his show about UAPs. What are you afraid of? I don't bite!
youtu.be/v-TlUnnJduQ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I knew Carlos Castaneda was a fabulist who made up Don Juan & the rest of his fiction (sold as non-fiction), but turns out he was also another New Age cult leader chasing sexual conquests:
Castaneda called his closest acolytes, mostly women, “winds,” “witches,” “sorcerers,” “Blue Scouts,” “Orange Scouts,” “cyclic beings.” They legally changed their names to be more “sorceric.” Only he could cut female adherents’ hair, and he told them “his semen’s magic properties” would “transmit shamanic knowledge.”
Sure, that's what semen does.
www.nytimes.com/2026/07/04/books/review/american-trickste… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My answer to the challenge that science just changes & doesn't make progress. From Truth:
Think of science as an expanding sphere of knowledge. As the sphere of the known expands into the aether of the unknown, the proportion of ignorance seems to grow—the more you know, the more you know how much you don’t know. But in this mathematical metaphor note what happens when the radius of a sphere increases: the expansion of the surface area is squared while the increase in the volume is cubed. So as the sphere of scientific knowledge expands the volume of the known increases by a ratio of 3:2 over the surface area of the unknown—the more you know the more of the unknown becomes known. It is at this boundary where we can stake a claim of true progress in the search for truth. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For those baffled by @sapinker comment on elite intellectuals who believe in "miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP, divine providence, karma, & all the rest" I hear their arguments regularly. Here it is:
Science is not an asymptotic curve approaching reality.
Kuhn showed that science is embedded in paradigms that constantly change, not necessarily closer to truth.
Science history is littered with mistaken theories overturned by new theories.
This will go on indefinitely.
It is only a matter of time before current physics is overturned and new physics allows for miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP....
In the 1890s physicists thought nearly everything was explained down to the 6th place after the decimal point.
Then came Einstein, Quantum Physics, etc.
Some of the "alternative theories" of physics floating around today may show these phenomena are real.
So it's not only okay to believe these mysteries are real, it's a signal that you are an intellectual sophisticate.
I explain why this is wrong in Truth: -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I see some UAP proponents who dislike me are into "social media archaeology"—digging through past tweets, other people's tweets, & especially the Epstein Files looking for dirt. Astonishingly (given that they claim to be serious researchers), they think I was good friends with Epstein. LOL. I debunked that nonsense in my solo podcast.
Since these dirt diggers don't actually do research, they probably won't take the time to listen, so let me briefly explain it here:
I never met Epstein, never visited his island, NYC place, or NM ranch. Never corresponded with him. Nada. Zip.
2017 was the 25th anniversary of Skeptic so I hired a NYC PR firm to do an event for us. They wanted me to get a "celebrity" & didn't count any of the famous scientists I know, so I remembered I had debated Deepak Chopra several times & he was generous enough to be on stage with me with an audience of ~100 people.
A decade later I found out—with everyone else—that the Epstein Files includes a zillion emails, a couple of which include Epstein corresponding with Deepak about coming to the event, which apparently he did.
End of story.
If you want to hear an even crazier story about the connection between Epstein, Al Seckel, skeptics, and me, you'll have to listen to my podcast about it all (but, sorry, there's no dirt here):
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/shermer-says-6-jeffr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Exactly. @ProfAviLoeb sound scientific approach: assume UAPs have ordinary terrestrial explanations until we encounter evidence that they’re extraordinary terrestrial (super drones or planes, foreign assets etc) or extraordinary extraterrestrial (aliens). But be open minded.
Space and Technology
@spaceandtech_
Harvard astronomer Avi Loeb has been appointed to lead the Trump administration's new UAP Science Advisory Council.
Following its first meeting, the panel requested more than 50 Pentagon videos, images, and documents related to unexplained aerial phenomena for scientific analysis.
Loeb says the investigation will begin by assuming these objects are human-made unless the evidence suggests otherwise. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Consider the Declaration’s claim “All men are created equal.” Religion was less the source of this greatest of all moral precepts than rationality. Jefferson explained in a letter its inspiration half a century later:
“Neither aiming at originality of principle or sentiment, nor yet copied from any particular and previous writing, it was intended to be an expression of the American mind, and to give to that expression the proper tone and spirit called for by the occasion. All its authority rests then on the harmonizing sentiments of the day, whether expressed in conversation, in letters, printed essays, or in the elementary books of public right as Aristotle, Cicero, Locke, Sidney, &c.”
www.bostonglobe.com/2026/07/05/opinion/science-declaratio… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The science of the Declaration of Independence
On our 250th anniversary, a different look at America’s founding document.
My take on how science underpins this political document that supports moral realism.
Rights are discovered as much as invented.
www.bostonglobe.com/2026/07/05/opinion/science-declaratio… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is as good a tribute to the U.S. of A. as you will see today. The GOAT of comedy becomes the American Flag:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Jefferson’s Declaration was an explicit rejection of the notion that a personal god had prescribed how human affairs ought to be ordered. Jefferson and Adams believed that government is only valid if freely entered into as a compact between citizens—'the consent of the governed'."
We are the governed, and the government. God has nothing to do with it.
quillette.com/2026/07/02/jefferson-and-the-source-of-huma… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Who the Author of this Production is, is wholly unnecessary to the Public, as the Object for Attention is the doctrine itself, not the man.”
Now THAT is a statement of modesty!
Thomas Paine's Common Sense as triumphed by @mattjj89
quillette.com/2026/07/02/the-greatest-tradition-of-all-je… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Holed up at home with an episode of vertigo I binged watched Netflix's 6-part The Last Czar. Good to know Russia is no longer ruled by an autocrat....
One quibble: I was surprised to learn that the Romanov family all spoke with a British accent. Seriously?
youtu.be/8iqySCbxCz8 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What are you afraid of @GoodTroubleShow ? I've done countless UFO/UAP shows, covered the topic in Skeptic & many books and SciAm columns. They will tell you that I don't bite!
It's not only ok to talk to people with whom you disagree; it's a virtue! Adversarial collaboration.
Chris Unleashed
@LegacyProgramVP
Matt Ford (@GoodTroubleShow) is legitimately a coward. And I’ve been told by multiple people behind the scenes that Matt is not respected by the big names in Ufology and you can see why in this post: he ducks and dodges debates with skeptics.
He uses another lame excuse involving his deceased mother (which he’s used multiple times now) to not have @michaelshermer on his show.
Hey, Matt! Just save everyone the trouble of listening to your excuses and just say you don’t want him on your show because you would get destroyed in a debate. But you have no problem trashing people while having them blocked. Giant man-baby behavior. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reading @ralphblu book. I thought it was just a biography of John Mack & his work with alien abductions, but it is so much more & a fabulous read! Sagan, Grof, Leary, LSD, MJ, MKULTRA, mind control, Esalen, Uri Geller, Hopkins, parapsychology, consciousness, etc. Must read!
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Catching up on Ancient Aliens I was touched to see their tribute to Nick Pope, one of the finest people I’ve met in this space. He is missed. And, again, condolences to Elizabeth Weiss @eweissunburied for her loss, and to what humanity has lost in this greatest of all questions.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my conversation with @platobooktour Rebecca Newberger Goldstein about why we feel like we need to matter (to the universe, to each other, to yourself). So thoughtful, but only a start.
Read her book The Mattering Instinct
youtu.be/cdqLHdDWfXg -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why do you matter, and to whom?
What's the point of it all?
Many of us have nibbled at answering these questions but no one since Plato has dove so deep into the matter than @platobooktour philosopher Rebecca Goldstein Newberger. Her work is a must read:
open.substack.com/pub/rebeccanewbergergoldstein/p/chew-on… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"I was once a flat-earther. But probably you were too, so … Please. Allow me to elaborate."
Say what?
Adam Neiblum explains in the latest Skeptic article on how a primate brain designed by evolution for basic survival can do sophisticated science!
www.skeptic.com/article/sciencing-with-a-primate-brain/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Imagine instead of a fix tower with two people on top, which we all know is stable, instead it was an orb or blurry balloon or grainy drone just sitting there in space; this footage would erroneously lead us to conclude it was moving very fast.
Apply to some UAP videos
Fox News
@FoxNews
BREAKING: Two people have climbed to the top of the Empire State Building in New York City, holding a banner from the skyscraper's antenna reading, "When the power of love beats the love of power, the world knows peace."
As of now it's unclear how the pair reached the top of the building as police work to get them down from the spire, 1,454 feet above the ground. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No mocking of UAP accounts at all @bikefox14 Just asking what’s more likely? (Hume’s analysis of miracles.) That UAPs apparently violate known physics (eg, sonic booms, burning up in the atmosphere, killing bio pilots) or that our perceptions & instrument readings are wrong?
bikefox
@bikefox14
Yeah, lets just mock all the credible accounts of UAP's by 100's of pilots and other credible witnesses, because our current understanding of physics, which is only about 125 years old, doesn't explain them. Smug science people always think their current beliefs are infallible.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
See e.g. @QualiaQuanta the book The Physics of Star Trek by @LKrauss1 who crunches the numbers for what it would take to achieve warp drive, the transporter, etc. I’m afraid your suggestion of a 9 volt battery is not going to do it!
Jenny Lorraine Nielsen ⭐🐯
@QualiaQuanta
@MichaelShermer warp drive is possible because of torsion from self-entanglement holonomic twist on ANY possible version of a unified gauge field theory www.preprints.org/manuscript/202604.0315
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are you seriously suggesting that @ProfAviLoeb doesn’t understand physics @JackSarfatti ? You can accuse me of that but not Avi & others who are physicists. Bizarre response!
Jack Sarfatti
@JackSarfatti
Rubbish you do not know what you’re talking about. You don’t know enough Physics in fact you are a charlatan about Physics. No one on that new committee is competent for this problem.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @rosscoulthart
Thank you for the acknowledgment here (queued up on video). Three producers at @NewsNation have told me they queried your team to either have both of us on a NN show or for you to talk to me on your show.
What do you think? Let's talk!
youtu.be/oWnRAIDUeo4?t=739 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why I'm skeptical:
Time travel is not possible because of the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics/Entropy & the one-way arrow of time + the grandfather paradox.
Multi-dimensional beings: I don't even know what people mean by the term + String Theory's speculations on multiple dimensions has not panned out.
Space-time bubbles: GR accurately explains space-time, but "warp drive bubbles" & such is pure SciFi fun & not realistic. The energy to create such things is calculated to be astronomically high.
What's more likely for the claim that a blurry/grainy orb appears to go from 80,000 feet to sea level in an instant (the 2004 USS Nimitz incident)?
1. It's a camera effect or the pilot was mistaken.
2. All of physics is wrong & objects can move through air that speed without burning up/creating a sonic boom.
See Avi Loeb's excellent calculation showing that #2 is wrong by current physics, and as he's been telling our team: don't invent new physics to explain anomalies!
avi-loeb.medium.com/on-mysterious-orbs-and-fireballs-4563…
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Pretty much everyone on the committee is more open to the possibility that UAPs could represent something other than ordinary terrestrial phenomena,” Shermer says. “Not just space aliens, by the way, but space-time bubbles and multi-dimensional beings and far future human time travelers.”
“None of that is going to pan out, because that’s just so unlikely or impossible by the laws of physics that I wouldn’t even bother doing down that road,” he adds.
www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-white-house-goes-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Pretty much everyone on the committee is more open to the possibility that UAPs could represent something other than ordinary terrestrial phenomena,” Shermer says. “Not just space aliens, by the way, but space-time bubbles and multi-dimensional beings and far future human time travelers.”
“None of that is going to pan out, because that’s just so unlikely or impossible by the laws of physics that I wouldn’t even bother doing down that road,” he adds.
www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-white-house-goes-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
PS, I don't know how to read the Bible? I graduate from Pepperdine University where I took courses in the Old & New Testaments, on the Life of Christ, on C.S. Lewis, went to chapel 2x/week, etc. I also took bible classes privately and "witnessed" to others.
www.christianpost.com/news/catholic-bishop-responds-to-cr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Who can seriously doubt that the exhortations to worship God, to respect parents and authorities, not to kill, steal, or commit adultery, to love one’s neighbor as oneself, to care for the weakest and most forgotten, to sympathize with the victim, to turn the other cheek, to respect the dignity and freedom of the individual, etc., have been bequeathed to us from the Bible?”
A-hem, may I point out that Conservative Christians today do not exactly abide by Jesus's teachings when it comes to the poor, immigrants, women, foreigners, other countries, and especially of the freedom of individuals to choose for themselves—especially sex, sex work, pornography, abortion, and other hot-button cultural issues.
Conservative Christians like small government and minimum intrusion in peoples' private lives unless it involves the bedroom, or (today) immigration and free trade with other countries, in which case they love big powerful intrusive government.
www.christianpost.com/news/catholic-bishop-responds-to-cr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“We routinely teach students the works of Homer and Shakespeare and other foundational texts because they have enduring cultural significance. The Bible should not be excluded from that list.”
Sure, as history and literature, not as moral instruction.
www.christianpost.com/news/catholic-bishop-responds-to-cr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Both Steven Pinker and Michael Shermer reveal that they have no idea how to read the Bible. First, they fail to make the elementary distinction that not everything that is in the Bible is what the Bible teaches [...] It is a commonplace of Biblical interpretation that there are elements in Scripture that reflect cultural practices of the time but are not the stuff of revelation.”
Yes, exactly! These are stories for Iron-Age herders and farmers, not for us. That's the point @sapinker and I are making. No one today gets their morality from the Bible, and that's a good thing!
www.christianpost.com/news/catholic-bishop-responds-to-cr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
First time in a Waymo. Austin. First it went to the wrong hotel close by so had to reprogram the Uber app to go to the right hotel. Then instead of stopping at the lobby in continued on another 50 meters and stopped at the end of a driveway and wait for me there. Drive was fine
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Coming July 5 in print and online in the Boston Globe, I make the case for moral realism through the Declaration of Independence and the Founding Fathers being grounded not only in Enlightenment values but deeper scientific principles discovered about human nature…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Utopia is unrealistic. Protopia (getting better gradually and slowly, 3 steps forward, 2 back) is boring. Doomsday is deep, existential, scary, phat and hip…and almost always wrong. As @sapinker says: follow the trend lines, not the headlines.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The AI future nobody is showing you | A more plausible vision, in my view, than either Utopia or doom. youtu.be/Besh6Xad5HU via @YouTube
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I case you don’t follow Mick (you should) or the reference. This is what a lot of the UAP videos look like.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Talking UAPs, UFOs, and ETIs with @HenaDoba on @NewsNation especially how to think about unexplained anomalies, that is, the 5-10% of unidentified anomalous phenomena.
Skeptical principle:
Before you say something is out of this world first make sure it is not in this world.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How could a lowlife nobody like Manson have persuaded women in his cult to commit brutal murders simply on his command?
Was it MKULTRA?
Maybe, but more likely:
Sex, drugs, and rock 'n roll with runaways looking for something to do to please their cult leader.
Not uncommon.
CSPAN
@cspan
Investigative journalist Tom O'Neill testifies on the CIA's MKUltra mind-control 1950s program: "I believe Congress was never told the truth about what this program actually achieved."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Most of what was said in this Congressional hearing on MKULTRA has long been known & documented in Kinzer's and O'Neill's excellent books. See also John Lisle' Project Mind Control as he adds new material. But the problem is Gottlieb & company destroyed most of the CIA documents.
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna
@RepLuna
Watch the first Congressional hearing on MK Ultra since 1977 x.com/i/broadcasts/1dxYllOAbLYJX
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The “space-time bubble” hypothesis to explain UAPs is highly unlikely given how physics works, and inventing new physics to explain UAPs is not helpful says @ProfAviLoeb
medium.com/@avi-loeb/on-mysterious-orbs-and-fireballs-456… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Mick West
@MickWest
A great example of how eyewitness reports can diverge from reality.
This type of thing gets reported as two saucer-shaped craft with rotating lights moving to the right.
When really it's two small planes, possibly a glider being towed, with sunlight reflecting off the wings.
This is why we need good video, and can't rely just on eyewitnesses.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
The belief that "men can get pregnant" has to be one of the more bizarre beliefs to emerge in recent years.
Our polling indicates that nearly 1 in 3 "very liberal" women, who are not parents, believe "men can get pregnant."
Liberals, who are parents, are much less likely to believe this (see graph on the left).
Among most Americans, rates of agreement are extremely low (see graph on the right).
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Right into my veins!💉
Justice Thomas:
"Men and boys with gender dysphoria are not women or girls, even if they believe that they are. Sex is an immutable 'biological' characteristic...it is binary."
"To use language to obscure reality—to show 'indifference regarding the truth'—is to lie to the public..." -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Relative to political conservatives, liberals are more likely to believe that qualified Black applicants are regularly turned away by universities.
No political group, regardless of generation, believes in the majority that Asian applicants are regularly rejected.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Amy Wax got in trouble for remarking that she'd not seen a Black student in the top quarter of a Penn Law class.
Thanks to hacked Columbia data, we can see that she was...
Probably right!
In the decade before her statement, there were just two top-25% Black students. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(10/20) Support for Politically-Motivated Violence is Higher Among Younger Adults, Racial Minorities, and Political Liberals
In our 2025 survey, we found that while most people do not support politically-motivated violence, those most likely to agree with it were younger adults (in general), younger Black Americans (in particular), the highly educated, and political liberals (see graphs below).
Learn more about this topic: research.skeptic.com/support-for-political-violence-among…
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Again, Dems are subject to survivorship bias, picking the winners after the fact & punishing them for "too much" success (whatever that means).
So Dems are in favor of free markets then wait to see who rises to the top.
We already have a progressive tax system that works well.
Defiant L’s
@DefiantLs
AOC on Apple announcing higher prices due to a chip shortage,
“We need to break up a lot of these companies that are far, far too big, and we need to be instituting consumer protections for people.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In order to make the Bible relevant, believers must pick and choose biblical passages that suit their needs; thus the game of cherry picking from the Bible generally works to the advantage of the pickers.
In the Old Testament, the believer might find guidance in Deuteronomy 5:17, which says, explicitly, “Thou shalt not kill”; or in Exodus 22:21, a verse that delivers a straightforward and indisputable prohibition: “You shall not wrong a stranger or oppress him, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt.”
These verses seem to set a high moral bar, but the handful of positive moral commands in the Old Testament are desultory and scattered among a sea of violent stories of murder, rape, torture, slavery, and all manner of violence, such as occurs in Deuteronomy 20:10-18, in which Yahweh instructs the Israelites on the precise etiquette of conquering another tribe:
"When you draw near to a city to fight against it, offer terms of peace to it. And if its answer to you is peace and it opens to you, then all the people who are found in it shall do forced labor for you and shall serve you. But if it makes no peace with you, but makes war against you, then you shall besiege it; and when the LORD your God gives it into your hand you shall put all its males to the sword, but the women and the little ones, the cattle, and everything else in the city, all its spoil, you shall take as booty for yourselves….
But in the cities of these peoples that the LORD your God gives you for an inheritance you shall save alive nothing that breathes, but you shall utterly destroy them, the Hittites and the Amorites, the Canaanites and the Perizzites, the Hivites and the Jebusites, as the LORD your God has commanded." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Agreed @redtheraider The Bible absolutely should be taught and discussed in school, as important literature, but NOT as final truths (to the exclusion of Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, etc.)
Red the Raider
@RedTheRaider
Like it or not, the Bible is one of the most important books in our civilization...the best-selling book of all time and the foundational philosophical text of our society.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm sorry to tell you @ketterstone that 2 billion Muslims think you're wrong. Of course, I think they're wrong too, but the point of a great nation like ours is that everyone hear, regardless of religious affiliation, is suppose to abide by the laws and Constitution.
Ketter
@KetterStone
Your cherry picked barbs expose your weakness, not Christ's. Jesus demands primacy over lesser ties, a truth of power, not cultish folly. He fulfills the Law with greater rigor, forging moral order amid savagery.
Public schools would gain more from Scripture's civilizational foundation than from the moral void breeding today's rootless weaklings. Doubt dissolves, but faith builds empires. A house divided falls. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My point @thomastillerman is that attempts to smuggle the Bible into public school classrooms ALWAYS encounters the same problem: which passages? Yes, there are beautiful/moral readings worth quoting, but (as I noted) horrific stories. Teach the Bible as literature, not truth.
Tom Tillerman
@ThomasTillerman
This is so disappointing. I started following you after your polite and stimulating debate with Sean McDowell about science and morality. Even though I disagreed with your conclusions, I admired your clear and careful thinking, and appreciated the respect you showed to Sean and his Christian beliefs. But this! It opens with a gaping logical liability (immoral according to what morality?) and degenerates from there.
In fact, this post is such a mangled misrepresentation of the Bible, I can only conclude that you are intentionally trying to be offensive to Christians. No one of your intellectual caliber could honestly think this is an accurate assessment of the biblical text. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Will Texas students learn about the morality of the biblical warlords who had no qualms about taking multiple wives, adultery, keeping concubines, and fathering countless children from their many polygamous arrangements?
The anthropologist Laura Betzig has put these stories into an evolutionary context in noting that Darwin predicted that successful competition leads to successful reproduction. Betzig analyzed the Old Testament and found no less than 41 named polygamists, not one of which was a powerless man.
“In the Old Testament, powerful men—patriarchs, judges, and kings—have sex with more wives; they have more sex with other men’s women; they have sex with more concubines, servants, and slaves; and they father many children.”
And not just the big names. According to Betzig’s analysis, “men with bigger herds of sheep and goats tend to have sex with more women, then to father more children.”
Most of the polygynous patriarchs, judges, and kings had 2, 3, or 4 wives with a corresponding number of children, although King David had more than 8 wives and 20 children, King Abijah had 14 wives and 38 children, and King Rehoboam had 18 wives (and 60 other women) who bore him no fewer than 88 offspring.
But they were all lightweights compared to King Solomon (pictured below), who married at least 700 women, then for good measure added 300 concubines, which he called “man’s delight.”
What Solomon’s concubines called him was never recorded. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Morality of the Bible
(From The Moral Arc)
The Bible is one of the most immoral works in all literature. Woven throughout begats and chronicles, laws and customs, is a narrative of accounts written by, and about, a bunch of Middle Eastern tribal warlords who constantly fight over land and women, with the victors taking dominion over both.
It features a jealous and vengeful God named Yahweh who decides to punish women for all eternity with the often intolerable pain of childbirth, and further condemns them to be little more than beasts of burden and sex slaves for the victorious warlords.
Why were women to be chastened this way? Why did they deserve an eternity of misery and submission? It was all for that one terrible sin, the first crime ever recorded in the history of humanity—a thought crime no less—when that audacious autodidact Eve dared to educate herself by partaking of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Worse she inveigled the first man—the unsuspecting Adam—to join her in choosing knowledge over ignorance. For the appalling crime of hearkening unto the voice of his wife, Yahweh condemned Adam to toil in thorn and thistle-infested fields, and further condemned him to death, to return to the dust from whence he came.
Yahweh then cast his first two delinquent children out of paradise, setting a Cherubim and a flaming sword at the entrance to be certain that they could never return. Then, in one of the many foul moods he was wont to fall into, Yahweh committed an epic hemoclysm of genocidal proportions by killing every sentient being on Earth—including unsuspecting adults, innocent children, and all the land animals—in a massive flood.
In order to repopulate the planet after he decimated it of all life save those spared in the ark, Yahweh commanded the survivors—numerous times—to “be fruitful and multiply,” and rewarded his favorite warlords with as many wives as they desired. Thus was born the practice of polygamy and the keeping of harems, fully embraced and endorsed—along with slavery—in the so-called “good book.”
As an exercise in moral casuistry, this perspective-taking question comes to mind: did anyone ask the women how they felt about this arrangement? What about the millions of people living in other parts of the world who had never heard of Yahweh? What about the animals and the innocent children who drowned in the flood? What did they do to deserve such a final solution to Yahweh’s anger problem? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I know, it is Christians pushing for mandatory Bible reading in public schools, so they will conveniently leave out the Old Testament and focus on Jesus. O-kay, what will students make of these biblical facts?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I think it's an excellent idea that students are required to read stories from the Bible. Here are some gems (from The Moral Arc, chapter on why religion is not the driver of moral progress), including this list of sins punishable by death...
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/25/us/texas-schools-book-list.html -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Best review I’ve yet seen on Spielberg’s Disclosure Day, by Jesse Michaels @AmericanALCHMY that encapsulates 75 years of UFOlogy. Probably many false positive connections + some patternicity involved but looking forward to exploring all this with him soon.
open.spotify.com/episode/6Zec5W5Q7ADCRAXzifLCoa -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How I think about UAPs:
Null Hypothesis: the default assumption that a hypothesis is false until rejected by evidence.
ECREE Principle: Extraordinary Claims Require Extraordinary Evidence
UAPs as ETIs is extraordinary.
So far the evidence does not rise to the level to reject the Null Hypothesis.
Eyewitness testimony (I met someone who says they saw aliens or spaceships) is Intriguing but we need to know who they are, where these aliens/spaceships are located, and go there with cameras to confirm stories. A half century of cognitive research reveals how unreliable people are when it comes to reporting what they think they witnessed.
Blurry photographs and grainy videos need to be supplemented with better images.
"Disclosure" movements demanding better evidence is a good start, but their language often slides into the assumption ETIs are here and the government is hiding them, rather than ETIs are not here until we can all see them ourselves.
This is how all science works, e.g., Yeti exists, the paranormal is real, miracles happen, etc.: Scientists start by assuming these hypotheses are not true until evidence becomes extraordinary.
Take Yeti: To name a new species biologists cannot have only blurry photographs, grainy videos, and stories about how people while out camping said they saw a bipedal primate. They need a body to show everyone.
All good scientists start with the Null Hypothesis and are therefore skeptical. My skepticism is normal science, not denial, not "debunkery", not closed mindedness. Show us the bodies and spaceships, otherwise the Null Hypothesis that aliens are not here stands. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re @BernieSanders advocating public ownership of major corporations, especially AI:
Since the vast majority of companies never become major, fewer still have IPOs, & only a handful become APPL, GOOG, NVDA, etc. he would have to fund thousands of start-ups in hopes a few strike it big, which would make him a VC.
Or encourage free market capitalism then wait for the winners (AAPL etc.) to implement democratic socialism after the fact.
Or...just get out of the way and let entrepreneurs take risks; most will fail, a few will succeed & we all benefit from their success.
Our progressive tax system already confiscates a higher % of rich peoples' earnings, so stop punishing success and help raise the lower classes to the middle and upper classes, instead of pulling down the upper classes in search of equal mediocrity or poverty. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(8/20) Gender Identity Policies Lack Majority Support Outside of the Political Left
Across two surveys, we found that transgender-related policies are not popular.
Only those identifying as "very liberal" express majority support for allowing biological males to compete in women's sports (see graph on the left), or express support for teachers sharing information on gender identity and sexual orientation in elementary school (see top right graph).
No group expresses majority support for giving children puberty blockers and/or hormones; however, liberal women without children are the most likely to support doing so (see bottom right graph).
Learn more about this topic: research.skeptic.com/political-accuracy-divisions-study/
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear Matt @GoodTroubleShow
Instead of posting potshots on X like this, why don't you have me on your show for a long and thoughtful discussion of UAPs? I have written extensively on the subject. For example:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/
The Good Trouble Show with Matt Ford
@GoodTroubleShow
You wrote the Baloney Detection Kit, Michael — so you know exactly what 'I should note…' is doing.
It's poisoning the well: discredit the source up front, dressed as a neutral aside, so your audience dismisses the event before they've judged it for themselves. That's not skepticism. It's the manipulation technique you built a career claiming to flag.
People see through your bull$hit. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(9/20) The Majority of Adults Support Voter ID
Across two surveys, we found that the majority of Americans believe people should have to prove they are citizens via an ID card in order to vote (see graph on the left).
Liberals, however, were more likely than moderates or conservatives to believe requiring an ID card to vote is racist (see graph on the right).
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you're interested in UAPs/UFOs/ETIs, there's a live-streamed "disclosure forum" in D.C. now. I'm not speaking but @ProfAviLoeb will emphasize the need for concrete evidence to move beyond the stories. Watch:
forum.disclosure.org -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Case for Criticizing Islam Without Hating Muslims
Khaled Salih makes the case in today's Skeptic:
www.skeptic.com/article/the-case-for-criticizing-islam-wi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"There are more and more frauds, charlatans, and lunatics entering this area of inquiry. It is important to stay disciplined on data-driven questions, most importantly to what extent are released (and unreleased) videos backed by radar, satellite, eyewitness and other forms of confirming evidence?"
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/06/what-sh… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
An oldie but goodie from TED 20 years ago (Monterey, 2006)
www.ted.com/talks/michael_shermer_why_people_believe_weir… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"males aren't females, and therefore don't belong in female jails."
Astonishing this even needs to be said @SwipeWright , but that's what happens when wokeness corrupts a society (e.g., biological sex is whatever anyone wants it to be because trans rights trump women's rights)
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
The blatant Orwellian language manipulation performed by gender ideologies is unparalleled.
MEN (i.e., males) are being removed from female jails, because males aren't females, and therefore don't belong in female jails. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The co-founder of Wikipedia @lsanger has been blocked from editing Wikipedia. I will be speaking with him today on my show. What would you like me to ask him about this and anything else (including accusations Wikipedia has a liberal bias)...
Larry Sanger
@lsanger
Well, that’s that—I’ve been blocked by Wikipedia “indefinitely” for unstated reasons, by the “consensus” of a mob. There was no due process, no prosecutor, no dispassionate judge, no jury, no interpretation of law. All my judges were self-selected and hated me. 🤣
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You can add my name to the list, along with hundreds of other academics who have had it with the corruption of wokeness on college campuses. Re-hiring @hoovlet is a good place to start, along with basic biology by defining sex by gametes...
National Association of Scholars
@NASorg
Three prominent scholars are calling on Harvard to re-hire evolutionary biologist Carole Hooven, calling her cancellation over defending biological sex an act of intellectual vandalism.
Restoring her would send a powerful message against cancel culture.
www.thecollegefix.com/professors-ask-harvard-to-re-hire-s… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"the pilot may have encountered a level of coordinated drone warfare that US intelligence didn't expect Iran to possess."
Another ordinary terrestrial explanation for a UAP, this one explaining the "jellyfish" sightings.
Principle:
Before you say something is out of this world, first make sure it is not in this world.
Skywatch Signal
@UAPWatchers
🚨CNN Reports: Downed US pilot reported seeing Iranian drones swarm in jellyfish formation
A US fighter pilot reportedly witnessed something deeply unusual moments before ejecting from an F-15 shot down over Iran in April. Multiple Iranian drones hovering together and moving through the air as though they were a single object.
According to CNN, the pilot described larger drones connected within the formation, with smaller drones hanging beneath them like legs. One source familiar with the intelligence debrief reportedly called it "real alien shit," while another said the pilot described the sky ahead of him as a "minefield of drones."
The formation apparently resembled a jellyfish, but the significance of this account has nothing to do with extraterrestrials. If the description is accurate, the pilot may have encountered a level of coordinated drone warfare that US intelligence didn't expect Iran to possess.
During the pilot's intelligence debriefing, he reportedly explained that the drones weren't just flying close to one another, they appeared to be interconnected and moving in unison.
The jellyfish description has become popular within the UAP discussion, particularly after footage emerged showing an unidentified object over a US military installation in Iraq with several appendage shapes extending beneath it.
This is possibly one of the clearest examples of why military UAP reports can't be laughed away, but also can't automatically be treated as evidence of non human tech. A pilot can accurately describe something extraordinary while still lacking enough information to identify exactly what is responsible.
Has Iran developed a networked formation that can combine multiple drones into what appears to be one coordinated aerial organism, or did the pilot encounter something else?
#iran #droneswarm #f15 #militarytechnology #jellyfishuap #uap #ufo #dronewarfare #nationalsecurity
Source:
www.cnn.com/2026/06/23/politics/iran-drones-f-15-pilot-in…
*Video is of the Jellyfish UFO over Iraq 2017 -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(6/20) Young Racial Minorities Support Discriminating Against White People in Hiring
In the fall of 2024, we found that nearly half of black and Hispanic Gen Z'ers support discrimination against white people in hiring decisions (see graph on the left).
We also found that greater trust in news journalists was associated with greater support for racial discrimination against white people, and this pattern held regardless of political orientation (see graph on the right).
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why I Joined the Government UAP Science Advisory Council (and why eyewitnesses can be wrong)
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-i-joined-the-whi… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @RepLuna
I strongly recommend that you invite @JohnLisle , historian of U.S. intelligence, whose book Project Mind Control is the definitive work on MKULTRA & he uncovered new documentation about the program. Here is my podcast convo with him:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/inside-the-cias-mind…
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna
@RepLuna
The intelligence community has covered up the nature and classification of the MKULTRA experiments for decades.
Americans have been misdirected repeatedly and deserve transparency and accountability from the CIA. The intel community’s unwillingness to deliver the truth has fueled dangerous conspiracy theories and eroded public trust in the federal government.
This hearing aims to explore the history of the MKULTRA experiments, how they have impacted Americans’ wellbeing, and how the intelligence community can win back trust. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wow, that's surprising.
"Scientific American is to be acquired by LabX Media Group, a global science-focused media company; the transaction will complete on 24 June 2026."
www.researchinformation.info/news/springer-nature-divests…! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
People don’t seem to understand betting markets. The point is to focus with precision what is bet & how a win is defined. For @ProfAviLoeb & I, he wins if 2 of 3 science orgs (NASA, NSA, AAAS) announce aliens are here by 12/31/2030. I hope Avi wins!
www.ibtimes.co.uk/ufo-skeptic-joins-uap-advisory-council-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not. Good.
A new study shows intro psych textbooks continue to be biased "in the direction of making psychological research appear more consistent than it is, as well as promoting viewpoints consistent with politically progressive ideologies"
open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/misinformati… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Ross Garber
@rossgarber
Last week I said that I thought the @ProfAviLoeb UAP committee is more about establishing a PR channel bt the admin and the public than providing science advice to the govt. I still believe that. But that's an important mission. It's a highly technical subject that has been the source of confusion and misinformation for a long time. Great to have smart, sophisticated folks like Loeb and @GarryPNolan with access to key players and info in a position to help the public make sense of it. And panel has a diversity of backgrounds and views, including @michaelshermer, so I'm optimistic it won't be fooled or coopted.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Example of the power of AI: a colleague asked me to send him my definitive article on David Hume as the philosopher of skepticism. I have no single essay, but lots of quotes & sections from several books, so he AI'd the question & got this from ChatGPT:
Michael Shermer, publisher of Skeptic magazine, calls David Hume the philosopher of skepticism. True?
Yes. Michael Shermer has often described David Hume as one of the greatest philosophers of skepticism, and it would be fair to say that Shermer regards Hume as a foundational figure—perhaps the philosopher most closely associated with modern skepticism.
There are a few reasons for this characterization:
Hume insisted that beliefs should be proportional to the evidence. His famous principle is often paraphrased as: a wise person proportions their belief to the evidence.
He analyzed miracles skeptically. In An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Hume argued that reports of miracles should be weighed against the overwhelming regularity of natural laws and the known unreliability of human testimony.
He examined how people form beliefs. Hume argued that many beliefs arise from habit, custom, emotion, and psychological tendencies rather than pure reason.
He questioned assumptions that others took for granted. His skepticism extended not only to religion but also to causation, the self, and the certainty of knowledge itself. That said, there is an important distinction between philosophical skepticism and modern scientific skepticism.
Hume was a philosophical skeptic who showed that many things we think we know cannot be logically justified with certainty. Yet he was not a radical skeptic who thought we should stop believing anything. Instead, he concluded that human beings naturally rely on experience, probability, and common sense.
This makes him especially attractive to modern skeptics such as Shermer. Hume's approach was essentially:
Demand evidence, recognize the limits of certainty, and adjust confidence according to the strength of the evidence.
That outlook aligns closely with the mission of Skeptic Magazine and the broader scientific skepticism movement.
So if Shermer calls Hume "the philosopher of skepticism," that is not a universally accepted formal title, but it is a reasonable description of Hume's place in the history of skeptical thought. Many philosophers would rank him among the most influential skeptics who ever lived. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I would count ball lightening as ordinary natural phenomenon @JasonColavito
Unusual but still part of the natural world.
A 4th category might be "interdimensional or ultraterrestrial beings", "time travelers" (far future humans coming back, or distant ancestors coming forward)
Jason Colavito
@JasonColavito
Those aren’t the only possibilities. For one thing, it’s possible (if unlikely) that some are otherwise undiscovered natural phenomena (e.g. ball lightning). Starting with possible conclusions and working backwards is a recipe for failure.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
90-95% of UAP sightings are explained by:
Ordinary Terrestrial (balloons, satellites, birds, etc.)
2 other options:
Extraordinary Terrestrial (Russian, DARPA)
Extraordinary Extraterrestrial (aliens)
UFO Files are suggestive of these 2, but not definitive. Let's get to the bottom of this mystery if we can.
www.newsnationnow.com/video/ufo-files-skeptic-michael-she… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Was Lamarck Right About Evolution?
The question is not an example of Betteridge's Law of Headlines (if it ends in a question mark the answer is no) because, although Darwin still stands, Lamarck was not as wrong as we thought, says his biographer:
www.skeptic.com/article/was-lamarck-right-about-evolution/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
90-95% of UAP sightings are explained by:
Ordinary Terrestrial (balloons, satellites, birds, etc.)
2 other options:
Extraordinary Terrestrial (Russian, DARPA)
Extraordinary Extraterrestrial (aliens)
UFO Files are suggestive of these 2, but not definitive. Let's get to the bottom of this mystery if we can.
www.newsnationnow.com/video/ufo-files-skeptic-michael-she… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"and Michael Shermer, founder of Skeptic magazine, whose inclusion has drawn pushback from some disclosure advocates"
Why? I hope we find aliens!
I just need definitive evidence to reject the null hypothesis that they're here. Then I will believe.
www.newsmax.com/newsfront/donald-trump-ufo-avi-loeb/2026/… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Talking aliens, UAPs, and UFOs with Chris Farrell on Judicial Watch this morning, especially insightfu was our discussion of David Grusch and intelligence agencies role in UAPs because Chris worked in intelligence
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/0myc0rDCLbYdh55MP0BBVl
YouTube:
youtu.be/8cef-KLIC9Y -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
When this stops happening we will stop posting about it. Critics on X unbraid me for being “obsessed” with trans issues. I will drop it when men stop entering women’s sports and spaces. Transwomen are not women. They’re men.
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
One of those things that never happens if you open up women's changing rooms to any man who wants to come inside has happened. Again.
www.bournemouthecho.co.uk/news/26213610.man-arrested-taki… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A classic article by @sapinker well worth reading, especially for how far the science has developed since
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thanks to another colleague, George Church, I was one of the first people to be genotyped, and agreed to post my genome on my website (together with a scan of my brain). The NYT invited me to write about the experience, and put me on the cover the Sunday magazine; the article was called "My genome, myself" (a play on the 1970s classic Our Bodies, Ourselves). www.nytimes.com/2009/01/11/magazine/11Genome-t.html?unloc…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Exactly @MiddleOfMayhem It's a New Age religion, an idea I've suggested for decades but goes back to the 1951 film The Day the Earth Stood Still, which is a Christ allegory (Klaatu is "Mr. Carpenter"). See e.g.:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Swap out aliens for Jesus Christ and this is basically prophecies about The Second Coming. Humans have always yearned for myths about the imminent arrival of God(s).
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No @I_D_Official Fravor did not witness the Tic-Tac object drop 80,000 feet in a moment. Here is SuperGrok's explanation:
No, Commander David Fravor did not personally witness the Tic-Tac object drop from 80,000 feet to sea level in less than a second. That dramatic descent was part of radar data collected by the USS Princeton (a Ticonderoga-class cruiser with advanced Aegis/SPY-1 radar) over the prior two weeks. oversight.house.gov
The Princeton operators tracked multiple “anomalous aerial vehicles” that would appear suddenly at high altitude (above or around 80,000 feet), descend rapidly (often described as hurtling toward the sea and stopping/hovering around 20,000 feet or lower), remain for periods, and then ascend straight back up or drop out of radar coverage. Fravor and his flight were vectored to investigate these existing radar contacts during a training exercise on November 14, 2004. en.wikipedia.org
What Fravor Actually Saw
Fravor (flying an F/A-18F Super Hornet with Lt. Cmdr. Alex Dietrich as his wingman, plus their two weapons systems officers) arrived in the area at around 20,000 feet. They had no initial radar contact on their own jets for the object. Instead, they visually spotted a white disturbance in the otherwise calm ocean surface (“white water”) and, next to it, a solid white, oblong/Tic-Tac-shaped object roughly 40 feet long with no wings, rotors, visible propulsion, exhaust, or control surfaces. It hovered or moved erratically just above the water in random directions, like a ping-pong ball bouncing. oversight.house.gov
All four crew members in the two jets saw it visually with their own eyes for several minutes (roughly 5 minutes total). Fravor descended for a closer look while the wingman provided high cover. The object appeared to react: it aligned its axis with Fravor’s jet and began climbing in a mirroring turn. When Fravor maneuvered to get a nose-on intercept at about ½ mile range (object around 12,000 feet while he was descending), it rapidly accelerated and disappeared right in front of his aircraft. The white water disturbance also vanished. oversight.house.gov
Shortly after, the Princeton controller reported the object had reappeared on radar at Fravor’s original Combat Air Patrol point roughly 60 miles away, covered in under a minute—performance far beyond the Super Hornet’s capabilities.
Was It Filmed by Fravor’s Jet?
No. Fravor’s aircraft did not record the released “Tic-Tac” video (or any widely known visual/IR footage of the object during his encounter). The now-famous ~90-second FLIR (forward-looking infrared) video was recorded later by Lt. Cmdr. Chad Underwood’s F/A-18 on a subsequent sortie using his jet’s ATFLIR targeting pod.
Underwood’s crew did not see the object visually with their eyes—they tracked it on sensors (infrared), noted radar jamming on their APG-73 radar, and saw no conventional propulsion plume. Fravor’s group told the next crew about the encounter before landing, leading to that follow-up flight. en.wikipedia.org
Fravor and his team had a clear visual sighting (naked-eye observation by multiple trained observers in daylight conditions) corroborated by ship-based radar before, during/after the visual phase, and on follow-up tracks. No gun-camera or pod footage from Fravor’s specific jet of the visual encounter has been publicly released.
Summary of Sources
Radar descent data: USS Princeton Aegis system (prior two weeks of tracking). Fravor was sent to investigate it. nytimes.com
Visual encounter: Fravor, Dietrich, and their WSOs (eyewitness accounts). Fravor has repeatedly described this in interviews, his 2023 congressional testimony, and statements (e.g., “we saw this little white Tic Tac-looking object” moving over the white water). oversight.house.gov
Video: Underwood’s later FLIR recording (sensor data, not visual sighting by that crew).
This remains one of the best-documented UAP cases due to multiple corroborating sensors (ship radar), visual witnesses, and the declassified FLIR footage, though the object’s nature and origin are still unexplained by conventional means. Fravor has consistently emphasized that what he saw operated outside known aerodynamic principles for aircraft in the atmosphere.
Richard Dolan Intelligent Disclosure
@I_D_Official
During the 2004 Nimitz encounter, Commander David Fravor witnessed a Tic-Tac object drop from 80,000 feet to sea level in less than a second, completely outmaneuvering our most advanced fighter jets. We know the government has a lot more classified data on these encounters.
🛸 Which aspect of these anomalous craft fascinates you the most?
A) The complete lack of visible propulsion or exhaust
B) Their ability to operate in both air and water without resistance
C) The mind-bending speeds and G-forces they generate
D) The apparent advanced cognitive interface required to pilot them
Let me know your choice in comments. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Problem of Induction embodied…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As well @rosscoulthart since so much of your reporting is based on eyewitness testimony, please note this observation from pilot and astronaut Scott Kelly, in response to the UAP videos at a NASA press conference, on the unreliability of eyewitnesses, including pilots/astronauts:
Ross Coulthart
@rosscoulthart
Not an auspicious start for sceptic @michaelshermer in his appointment to the UAP Science Advisory Committee. He deleted the puerile and snide tweets he posted about UAP former IC informant David Grusch and then he wonders why he's getting push-back from a community looking for an objective analysis from a Govt committee.
Joe Murgia
@TheUfoJoe
You're being disingenuous bc you know damn that the push back is bc of your deleted tweets, shared below.
And the reason we give Grusch's info. so much weight is bc he says he interviewed over 40 witnesses who worked/work in the alleged UAP legacy program, and that's where the claims come from. Also, he says he's seen evidence (photos) of retrieved craft.
Is that enough? To me, no. Do we need to hear from those firsthand folks? Of course. But these tweets/posts are pathetic, and @ProfAviLoeb should do the right thing and find a true skeptic who doesn't attack and insult a whistleblower who put his reputation and career on the line to get the truth out. ⬇️⬇️⬇️ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Fair enough @rosscoulthart X posts can be snide & snarky responses to extraordinary claims made there with 0 evidence in support (such as that we know aliens are here). I retracted those posts & I hereby apologize to David Grusch (he doesn't appear to have an X account & I don't have his email).
I have written dozens of articles, book chapters, essays & articles about aliens, had all the major UFO writers on my show, & done countless interviews on the subject, so how about a conversation on your show?
In the meantime, here is an excerpt from my chapter on aliens in my new book Truth. Please take a few minutes to read it instead of assessing my output based on a couple of X posts:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/
Ross Coulthart
@rosscoulthart
Not an auspicious start for sceptic @michaelshermer in his appointment to the UAP Science Advisory Committee. He deleted the puerile and snide tweets he posted about UAP former IC informant David Grusch and then he wonders why he's getting push-back from a community looking for an objective analysis from a Govt committee.
Joe Murgia
@TheUfoJoe
You're being disingenuous bc you know damn that the push back is bc of your deleted tweets, shared below.
And the reason we give Grusch's info. so much weight is bc he says he interviewed over 40 witnesses who worked/work in the alleged UAP legacy program, and that's where the claims come from. Also, he says he's seen evidence (photos) of retrieved craft.
Is that enough? To me, no. Do we need to hear from those firsthand folks? Of course. But these tweets/posts are pathetic, and @ProfAviLoeb should do the right thing and find a true skeptic who doesn't attack and insult a whistleblower who put his reputation and career on the line to get the truth out. ⬇️⬇️⬇️ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re eyewitness testimony, credentials/experience of observers seem to matter, yet as pilot/astronaut Scott Kelly explains in response to the UAP videos Go Fast, Tic-Tac, etc. at a NASA press conference, referencing his pilot/astronaut/Senator twin (screen shot from Truth chapter):
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Of course, the Vatican (the DoW, et al.) could be lying & covering up aliens.
How can you tell the difference between:
"we don't have aliens"
&
"we have aliens but won't say"?
Extraordinary Claims Require Extraordinary Evidence
Testimony by itself is not extraordinary evidence.
Sam Adams
@Bensam123TV
You think the Vatican is just all of a sudden going to tell a random reporter about a massive coverup that they're part of out of no where?
'We sent a reporter and asked the DoW about UFOs and the said they have no evidence.'
Well case closed! What even is this logic. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Neither @realstevenslate Options:
1. Grusch's stories are true—aliens are here.
2. Grusch is lying.
3. Grusch is repeating lies by insiders.
4. Insiders are honestly mistaken about what they think they saw & Grusch is honestly reporting their stories.
I strongly suspect #4.
Steven Slate
@RealStevenSlate
Grusch says he has spoken with people in the program and has seen evidence of craft and bodies. I don’t think he’s lying about either of those things, so the question is, are people lying to him and is the evidence fake?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Perfectly stated @GarryPNolan and properly nuanced between skepticism and gullibility
Garry P. Nolan
@GarryPNolan
Why do we need a UAP Scientific Advisory Board?
As has been widely reported, the US government has asked Professor Avi Loeb, of the Department of Astronomy at Harvard University (see the main announcement at the end of this posting), to create a UAP Advisory Council. The members of this advisory group span a range of disciplines from astronomy, psychology, physics, biology, data analytics, psychology, entrepreneurs, and more. I am thrilled to have been invited alongside a notable list of scientists, academics, entrepreneurs, and others.
What follows are my personal thoughts and are not any official position of the UAP Advisory Council. Dr. Loeb has already elaborated on the formation of this Council, along with his views through postings on his blog and in public interviews.
Importantly, no one on the Council has been asked to sign any non-disclosure agreements. We are told that we are free to discuss matters that come before the Board, but without attribution of the source (Chatham House rules). By the same token, I am not obligated to answer any questions either. I plan to treat this effort like I do my day job in cancer immunology—not talking publicly about results until I am sure the answer is as close to correct as I can determine.
So, how did this Advisory Council come to be? Well, one answer is simple—through the dedicated action of thousands of individuals across decades, the coming forward of credible military and government officials in public testimony (sometimes under oath), the work of members of Congress and the Senate, along with testimonials of public witnesses, and much more.
Collectively, those actions have led to the extraordinary and courageous decision by President Donald J. Trump and his administration to release to the public US government-owned UAP-related files and information as vetted by a UAP Governance Board and other government agencies. As publicly announced, our group will report to the UAP Governing Board, which is under the direction of the Executive Branch.
Many people have openly wondered, “Why create a new Board when elements of the government or even commercial institutions already (allegedly) know the answer?” The UAP Advisory Council doesn't have any funding, and we don’t have subpoena power. We are all volunteers. We advise. Given that, there are some straightforward answers to the criticisms and commentary I have seen.
First, appreciate that the complexity of what UAP might represent is not definable in a single technological or cultural framework. It is so complex that even I, who have been steeped in the matter for over 15 years, have a hard time encompassing the breadth of explanations from “it’s real, and it’s here” to “it’s all misidentification”. My mind spins trying to make sense of it all.
What is clear is that the data released so far is not enough. The anecdotes are not enough. Sure, interesting videos, but where’s the metadata? What are the parameters of how the data was collected? Why are there extreme redactions of files and data? Why the incredible pushback? Where are the alleged retrieved technologies? There’s simply not enough to convince me when I put on my serious scientist’s hat.
Yet what I do know is that the question of what it might be will not go away while the data remains locked up. The answers to what any data might mean will require a comprehensive effort across disciplines that expand well beyond “nuts and bolts” science. Hence, the broad makeup of the team that comprises the UAP Advisory Council. Every person on the Board is, I believe, devoted to taking a logical and deeply skeptical approach to this matter. We will let the data guide us and cross-check each other.
For me, despite my widely known bias that I think there’s something deeper to the matter than misidentification, I remain like any scientist a trained sceptic at heart. I am terrified of making a mistake, but I’ve yet to reach a formal conclusion despite my public musings. I can believe a thing might be true, but as a scientist, I must believe enough in the possibility of an idea being true to justify my time and effort to prove it to myself— and more so to prove it to colleagues or the lay public.
There is data that, when contextualized as a hypothesis, becomes evidence that invites us to wonder whether the answer to “Are We Alone?” might be sitting right in front of us, but we choose to ignore it or let others tell us it should be ignored. Remember, data is only evidence towards supporting a conclusion when you pose a question (hypothesis) around what the data means. But evidence is not a conclusion. Evidence is what you put in front of a jury, where the data has been sufficiently scrubbed of doubt to allow one to decide what it means.
So, back to “Why do we need a UAP Scientific Advisory Board?” Well, we all want objective, and even subjective, expertise to interpret whatever data comes our way. Even if tomorrow a saucer landed in Times Square, we would still need a swath of expertise to interpret what opens the door, how it got here, and what might be the intent. Better to be prepared, in my opinion.
We obviously risk that this is a misdirection from some essential truth or that we might be being used in some elaborate disinformation campaign. We are also aware that we might be in for the possibility that there is simply nothing there but elaborate stories and misidentifications.
But I can tell you this—the risk is worth it. We have come further than ever before to open the door (or Pandora’s Box) to a potentially incredible opportunity. “Are we alone?” might be answered as “We are one of many.” Coming to know what others might have already learned about the nature of reality is, for me, well worth the effort to ask the question.
One way or the other, I believe humanity can handle the answer.
avi-loeb.medium.com/more-details-on-the-uap-science-advis… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Massimo Pigliucci on Doubt, Moral Courage, and Living Without Illusions
My latest podcast:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/massimo-pigliucci-on… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm getting big push-back for doubting David Grusch's dramatic claims that aliens are here.
Watch this short clip of the @NewsNation interview with him in which he claims the Vatican has proof of a 1930s UFO. NN sends its reporter, who says Vatican archives show no evidence whatsoever of UFOs.
NN asks Grusch about Roswell. He says he's not allowed to explain what really happened.
And so on. Just stories. Why do so many people believe him with 0 evidence on offer? Do you think it is possible he's genuinely mistaken about what he believes?
www.newsnationnow.com/religion/ufo-crash-records-vatican-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you have a few minutes please take this survey on belief about UAPs & ETIs, and what disclosure might mean for religion and society (a big theme in Spielberg's Disclosure Day). I'm on the team collecting & analyzing this data so appreciate your input:
idc.az1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_7Uq9Le2xDDCThhY -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“The government is not a scientific organization. They don’t have first class scientists. So we can help them figure things out” @ProfAviLoeb on the UAP Science Advisory Council
nypost.com/2026/06/20/us-news/cosmic-council-trump-create… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the key passage in the USAF Roswell Report:
"The Air Force research found absolutely no indication that what happened near Roswell in 1947, involved any type of extraterrestrial spacecraft. This, of course, is the crux of this entire matter. "Pro-UFO" persons who obtain a copy of this report, at this point, most probably begin the "cover-up is still on" claims. Nevertheless, the research indicated absolutely no evidence of any kind that a spaceship crashed near Roswell or that any alien occupants were recovered therefrom, in some secret military operation or otherwise."
ia601607.us.archive.org/20/items/DTIC_ADA326148/DTIC_ADA3… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I recommend the 2 books put out by the U.S. Air Force on Roswell in which they admit that the "weather balloon" story was a deception to cover up the Cold War spy balloon Project Mogul + the high altitude drop of anthropometric dummies.
James Fox
@jamescfox
If you took the time to listen to the testimony of those who were actually there you’d quickly learn that the real debris was kept on the tarmac in the B29 and General Ramey took a conventional weather balloon, threw it on the floor for the press. That’s what you’re looking at . Have you not listened to those who are there?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I will repeat my prior post for @SenWarren claim about her tax plan:
This is post-hoc survivorship bias thinking. You are targeting the entrepreneurial winners & ignoring the vast majority (~90%) who go out of business or never have an IPO.
Do you think tax payers should cover the losses of all the would-be ultra-millionaires? You are targeting @elonmusk @JeffBezos et al. AFTER their success.
Where were you when Tesla & SpaceX were about to fold? Where were you all those years that Amazon ran at a deficit? We should reward the successful high risk takers because most fail. You want to punish people for success. That is not how you build a prosperous society.
Elizabeth Warren
@SenWarren
If Elon Musk paid my ultra-millionaire tax, we could fully cover free community college in America.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
O-kay @jamescfox do tell. But first, what do you think those materials in the photographs are? Balloon debris, alien spaceship, government disinformation fake staging, or what?
James Fox
@jamescfox
Oh Mr. Shermer I don’t even know where to start with this post — there are so many inaccuracies…😩
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The true story of Roswell (from my book Conspiracy):
Our story begins on July 7, 1947, when a rancher working just outside Roswell, New Mexico named William W. ‘Mac’ Brazel discovered some unusual debris scattered on the ground. Brazel notified the local sheriff saying that he might have discovered the remains of “one of them flying saucers.”
The reference was to a wave of UFO sightings that began the month before, on June 24, 1947, when a man named Kenneth Arnold was flying his private plane over the Cascade Mountains in Washington State when he saw 9 shiny objects moving quickly across the sky.
Arnold initially described them as flying like “geese in formation”—which is what it probably was (I’ve seen such “UFOs” myself)—but then later added that the objects were “crescent shaped” and that they “moved like a saucer would if you skipped it across the water.” An Associated Press story about the incident then misquoted Arnold as describing what he saw as “flying saucers.” Later, Arnold complained, “They said that I’d said they were saucer-like. I said they flew in saucer-like fashion.”
Nevertheless, the “flying saucer” meme caught on as the AP story was picked up by over 150 newspapers, and soon after hundreds of flying saucer reports appeared, with a peak of 850 sightings in the weeks following Arnold’s report.
The July 7 story told by Mac Brazel promptly reached the Roswell Army Air Field (RAAF), at which point a lieutenant named Walter Haut sent out a press release stating that a “flying disc” had been recovered at the ranch. Haut, in fact, had not seen the debris himself, so here begins the distortion of the most famous UFO case in history: The Roswell Incident. The incident, in fact, has nothing to do with extra-terrestrial intelligence and everything to do with terrestrial surveillance. The following day, July 8, 1947, the Roswell Daily Record ran the now famous headline:
RAAF Captures Flying Saucer On Ranch in Roswell Region
The next day, July 9, the Roswell Daily Record offered a more sobering description of what was found on the ranch:
"When the debris was gathered up the tinfoil, paper, tape, and sticks made a bundle about three feet long and 7 or 8 inches thick, while the rubber made a bundle about 18 or 20 inches long and about 8 inches thick. In all, he [Brazel] estimated, the entire lot would have weighed maybe five pounds."
The military described the debris as the remains of a weather balloon, and that was that for the next 30 years, as Roswell disappeared from UFO cultural radar.
In fact, in 1967 a report was published by a pro-UFOlogist named Ted Bloecher titled UFO Wave of 1947, which chronicled 853 UFO reports: Roswell wasn’t even on the list! Think about that: the most famous UFO case in history wasn’t even on the radar screen of UFOlogists at the time it happened and the twenty years after!
Roswell, then, is really a story of modern myth making, starting in 1980 when the National Enquirer ran a sensationalist UFO story, followed by a popular television documentary called UFOs are Real, then solidified when popular book authors Charles Berlitz and William L. Moore bestseller The Roswell Incident, was published, outlining a government cover-up of the discovery of a crashed alien spacecraft in the New Mexico desert. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Such great writing by @Ayaan
"Multicultural etiquette, in other words, created an expanding category of unnameables. Where earlier British feminism could say, plainly, that husbands, fathers, employers, priests, or legislators had exploited women and must be opposed, the contemporary movement often refuses to say that certain patterns of male violence are concentrated within particular ethno-religious subcultures, and that these patterns matter for the safety of girls. Modern feminism shouts when the target is culturally safe and falls quiet when the perpetrators are wrapped in the prohibitions of diversity talk." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
(Some) Religion Poisons (Nearly) Everything
(to paraphrase Christopher Hitchens)
The gangs were “predominantly Muslim Pakistani,” operating under “an honour- and shame-based clan code that treated non-Muslim girls, especially white working class girls, as property available for sexual use,” and this pattern was “reinforced by eight theological and legal aspects of Islam,” including the doctrine of Muslim superiority, forms of loyalty and disavowal (al‑walā’ wa‑l‑barā’), “the superiority of men over women, … the absence of any fixed minimum age of consent,” and “a system of sex slavery authorizing sexual relations with non‑Muslim captives.” Filtered through “clannish immigrant sub-cultures,” these elements “provided religious justification that enabled the systematic rape and even slaughter of White British girls.”
www.thefp.com/p/ayaan-hirsi-ali-uk-rape-gangs?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness Poisons Everything
@Ayaan on the UK Rape Gang epidemic, ignored by authorities because it was Muslim Pakistani men raping white girls and they didn't want to appear Islamophobic & racist.
"The report notes that ethnicity and religion were often left unrecorded “to protect ‘community cohesion’ ” and that national reviews found it “simply not possible to know the scale” because “ethnicity, group offending, and historical cases were routinely unrecorded or shelved.”
www.thefp.com/p/ayaan-hirsi-ali-uk-rape-gangs?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As I've been quoting for ages now, multiple surveys show that religious people are not threatened by the prospects of disclosure that aliens are out there somewhere or even that they're here. Why? Because an omniscient God can create as many species as He wants, including ETIs!
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Steven Spielberg’s new film, “Disclosure Day,” suggests that aliens would be a threat to religious faith. But, @LuisParrales_ writes, Catholic theologians have been contemplating extraterrestrial life for centuries—and haven’t found it threatening: www.theatlantic.com/culture/2026/06/disclosure-day-aliens…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the Kenneth Arnold quote being a skeptical shibolith, @MiddleOfMayhem here's a quick check from Gemini, citing multiple sources:
Pilot Kenneth Arnold originally made this statement in a CBS News interview regarding the initial reporting of his famous June 24, 1947 sighting over Washington's Mount Rainier. Arnold gave this explanation:
"The newspaper did not quote me properly... They said that I'd said they were saucer-like. I said they flew in saucer-like fashion."
How the misquote happened:
When Arnold landed in Pendleton, Oregon, that same day, he described the movement of the nine crescent-shaped objects as "skipping as saucers upon water" and "like a saucer would if you skipped it across the water".
A local reporter, Bill Bequette, misinterpreted the quote, submitting a wire story to the Associated Press that stated Arnold saw "nine bright saucer-like objects."
This reporter error inadvertently coined the term "flying saucer."
You can read more about how this phrase entered the cultural lexicon on Wikipedia's Flying Saucer Page and dive deeper into the historical incident on the history.com feature covering Kenneth Arnold's Sighting.
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
I've seen no evidence Kenneth Arnold described the objects "moved like a saucer would if you skipped it across the water" and that the AP misquoted him.
I'm pretty sure this is skeptic myth which conflates different statements of his over years. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The true story of Roswell (from my book Conspiracy):
Our story begins on July 7, 1947, when a rancher working just outside Roswell, New Mexico named William W. ‘Mac’ Brazel discovered some unusual debris scattered on the ground. Brazel notified the local sheriff saying that he might have discovered the remains of “one of them flying saucers.”
The reference was to a wave of UFO sightings that began the month before, on June 24, 1947, when a man named Kenneth Arnold was flying his private plane over the Cascade Mountains in Washington State when he saw 9 shiny objects moving quickly across the sky.
Arnold initially described them as flying like “geese in formation”—which is what it probably was (I’ve seen such “UFOs” myself)—but then later added that the objects were “crescent shaped” and that they “moved like a saucer would if you skipped it across the water.” An Associated Press story about the incident then misquoted Arnold as describing what he saw as “flying saucers.” Later, Arnold complained, “They said that I’d said they were saucer-like. I said they flew in saucer-like fashion.”
Nevertheless, the “flying saucer” meme caught on as the AP story was picked up by over 150 newspapers, and soon after hundreds of flying saucer reports appeared, with a peak of 850 sightings in the weeks following Arnold’s report.
The July 7 story told by Mac Brazel promptly reached the Roswell Army Air Field (RAAF), at which point a lieutenant named Walter Haut sent out a press release stating that a “flying disc” had been recovered at the ranch. Haut, in fact, had not seen the debris himself, so here begins the distortion of the most famous UFO case in history: The Roswell Incident. The incident, in fact, has nothing to do with extra-terrestrial intelligence and everything to do with terrestrial surveillance. The following day, July 8, 1947, the Roswell Daily Record ran the now famous headline:
RAAF Captures Flying Saucer On Ranch in Roswell Region
The next day, July 9, the Roswell Daily Record offered a more sobering description of what was found on the ranch:
"When the debris was gathered up the tinfoil, paper, tape, and sticks made a bundle about three feet long and 7 or 8 inches thick, while the rubber made a bundle about 18 or 20 inches long and about 8 inches thick. In all, he [Brazel] estimated, the entire lot would have weighed maybe five pounds."
The military described the debris as the remains of a weather balloon, and that was that for the next 30 years, as Roswell disappeared from UFO cultural radar.
In fact, in 1967 a report was published by a pro-UFOlogist named Ted Bloecher titled UFO Wave of 1947, which chronicled 853 UFO reports: Roswell wasn’t even on the list! Think about that: the most famous UFO case in history wasn’t even on the radar screen of UFOlogists at the time it happened and the twenty years after!
Roswell, then, is really a story of modern myth making, starting in 1980 when the National Enquirer ran a sensationalist UFO story, followed by a popular television documentary called UFOs are Real, then solidified when popular book authors Charles Berlitz and William L. Moore bestseller The Roswell Incident, was published, outlining a government cover-up of the discovery of a crashed alien spacecraft in the New Mexico desert. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good short summary of the real story behind Roswell, which really begins in 1980 with the Berlitz book claiming alien crash. The actual 1947 event was a downed high-altitude surveillance balloon of Project Mogul to listen for atmospheric nuclear tests by the USSR. Myth making.
New York Post
@nypost
The Post's resident UFO expert debunks Roswell - the popular alien myth that Steven Spielberg's "Disclosure Day" is built upon. Watch full review: www.youtube.com/watch?v=aLT4Qj_aMHc
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Resolving the Nature of Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) by Scientific Evidence
I.e., we are moving beyond the stories and examining data
avi-loeb.medium.com/resolving-the-nature-of-unidentified-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL. An interviewer just asked me about my answer to the Fermi Paradox called "hyper-brief technological span," a phrase I have never used. I have made the argument that the "L" (lifetime of a communicating civilization) in the Drake Equation is likely short, on the order of 400 years (averaging the length of individual civilizations) due to many causes of societal collapse. He sent me this Gemini search. Is it hallucinating this phrase (although these are my arguments)?:
Michael Shermer argues that the Fermi Paradox (the contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial life and the lack of evidence for it) is largely resolved by the "hyper-brief technological span" of intelligent species.
He suggests that once a civilization develops radio technology, it only broadcasts for a short period of time (e.g., a few hundred years) before going extinct, destroying itself via technology, or transitioning to non-detectable communications. Therefore, the cosmic window for overlapping, communicative civilizations is statistically near zero.
Shermer proposes that the "hyper-brief technological lifespan" is a bottleneck all intelligent species encounter, fundamentally limiting the survival of extraterrestrial civilizations. He calculates that once civilizations invent radio technology, their aggressive nature and propensity for mutual destruction drastically shorten their window of survival before they collapse.
In his columns discussing this concept, Shermer draws upon evolutionary psychology to frame this dilemma:
The Mismatch: Humanity (and potential intelligent alien species) is governed by evolutionary impulses—such as xenophobia, territoriality, and desires for dominance.
The Existential Bottleneck: The period during which a species discovers destructive technology (nuclear weapons, bio-weapons) heavily overlaps with its primitive evolutionary state.
The Collapse: Because our technological power advances exponentially but our moral and neurological evolution remains largely stagnant, civilizations risk obliterating themselves before they mature into space-faring societies.
This premise serves as a powerful explanation for the Fermi Paradox—the glaring contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial intelligence existing and the lack of evidence for it. Shermer suggests that the lifespan of a technological civilization may only be a few centuries, making them too fleeting and separated by vast distances to ever communicate with one another. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It may not surprise anyone that Intelligent Design theorists are unhappy with my book Truth, accusing me of myside bias and for "disposing of God in just 25 pages" (although I do reference and discuss @StephenCMeyer despite the upbraiding that I didn't!)
mindmatters.ai/2026/06/shermers-truth-when-myside-bias-be… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What if @ProfAviLoeb wins our bet and we get real disclosure of alien existence here (or out there) by December 31, 2030? It would be one of the greatest discoveries in the history of humanity. I hope he wins.
www.georgeherald.com/News/Article/National-News/in-an-age… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My short interview this morning on WGN TV News Chicago on the latest tranche of UFO Files, the newly formed UAP Science Advisory Council, and how to think about anomalies and mysteries when it comes to aliens:
youtu.be/TLKTouEKbaM -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Mississippi Miracle:
Smoke and Mirrors vs. Reality
Daniel H. Robinson and Howard Wainer examine the true educational outcomes for Skeptic based on data, not ideology:
www.skeptic.com/article/mississippi-miracle-smoke-and-mir… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @SenWarren
This is post-hoc survivorship bias thinking.
You are targeting the entrepreneurial winners & ignoring the vast majority (~90%) who go out of business or never have an IPO.
Do you think tax payers should cover the losses of all the would-be ultra-millionaires?
You are targeting @elonmusk @JeffBezos et al. AFTER their success. Where were you when Tesla & SpaceX were about to fold? Where were you all those years that Amazon ran at a deficit?
We should reward the successful high risk takers because most fail. You want to punish people for success. That is not how you build a prosperous society.
Elizabeth Warren
@SenWarren
If Elon Musk paid my ultra-millionaire wealth tax, we could pay for child care for all three and four year olds in America.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"a cube inside a square is a calibration sphere" explains AARO Director Sean Kirkpatrick.
"A calibration sphere (or reference ball) is an ultra-precise, spherical artifact of a known size used to calibrate and verify measuring tools. By touching or scanning the sphere, the measurement software calculates the exact radius of the probe and establishes a baseline to ensure strict accuracy."
i.e., Navy pilot Ryan Graves was not describing an alien spaceship.
Chris Unleashed
@LegacyProgramVP
That’s because that Navy pilot Ryan Graves (@uncertainvector) and/or his fellow pilots didn’t know what a calibration sphere was, apparently. This has been addressed by former Director of AARO Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick in a recent lecture discussing cases and the UAP phenomenon in general.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Even more interesting: Over 1 in 3 Americans identify with mental illness, even with no, or minimal, depression or anxiety.
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
(5/20) Young People Identify with Mental Illness at Much Higher Rates
In our 2025 survey, we found that younger adults identify with mental health challenges at significantly higher rates than older adults (see graph below).
For example, 81% of Gen Z females versus 38% of Boomer females agreed that "mental health challenges are an important part of my identity."
Learn more about this topic: research.skeptic.com/identifying-as-mentally-ill-without-…
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Since UAPs are physical objects that interact with humans, the council includes members with expertise in physical sciences as well as psychology and biology,” Loeb explained. “All members had an intense interest in the scientific study of UAPs for many years.”
Agreed, in addition to physicists & biologists, those of us who study psychology and how people reason (or not) are important to the understanding of UAPs.
defensescoop.com/2026/06/17/new-science-advisory-council-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The new issue of Skeptic is a great one on the new media, social media, the attention economy & how online influencers like Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens are shaping the national conversation over politics, economics, and culture. Get your copy now:
www.skeptic.com/magazine/conspiracy-grift/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Michael Shermer on Truth, Skepticism, and Why Experts Get Things Wrong"
Good convo on the Human ReAction podcast with David Rand.
youtu.be/ikOEc3RTWbE -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reading Adam Kirsch's forthcoming book & came across this acute observation on eyewitness testimony vs. science (re UAPs as aliens):
"The essence of scientific investigation is that the identity of the person who makes a discovery is totally irrelevant. Anyone who follows the same experimental procedure or the same mathematical proof will reach the same conclusion. That is what it means for a result to be reproducible, the hallmark of scientific method.
Testimony, by contrast, is what we rely on when the thing we're investigating cannot be replicated because it is not a natural phenomenon but a singular event, such as a murder or a miracle. In these cases, the character of a witness can be relevant, insofar as it helps us decide whether or not they are deliberately lying. But witnesses don't have to be lying to give false testimony; they could simply be mistaken. Indeed, psychologists and social scientists have established that eyewitness testimony, far from being a gold standard of trustworthiness is often inaccurate." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I saw Disclosure Day in hopes it would enthrall like most Spielberg films, and I love good alien movies (Day the Earth Stood Still, 2001, Close Encounters, Contact, etc), but don't waste your time.
Great acting (Emily Blunt is fabulous) but:
—weak plot
—car/train chases/fights feel superfluous
—little suspense (you know "disclosure" is coming)
—lame ending & tired theme that "they" don't want the world to know aliens are here: in this case it's not the government but a private company improbably named Wardex that must kill the man about to reveal the Big Secret but whose ex-nun girlfriend insists he must not because people will stop believing in God. Colin Firth's Wardex CEO character explains that the geo-political balance of the world will also be disrupted by disclosure (how & why this would happen is not explained, although apparently N Korea is about to launch a nuke).
—Aliens first appear as animals who stare at humans: deer, a fox, a raccoon & a moose, apparently directed by red cardinals, who also plant an alien being inside Emily Blunt's character who then talks gibberish on TV.
—At the end the aliens are disclosed to be bipedal great apes with bulbous heads & big eyes (as seen in most bad alien flicks), which is highly unlikely: there are 8 great ape species on Earth out of ~8 million species = 0.000001.
—I will admit, if the UFO Files ever reveal actual footage of the many crashed aliens in history (why do they always crash after traversing the vast distances of interstellar space?) like those shown in the film, or we get to actually see the alien bodies and crashed saucers hidden by the government (or the equivalent of Wardex, like Bigelow Aerospace Advanced Space Studies), I will adjust my priors and update my credence on ETIs.
youtu.be/icDuEHSxE-w -
Michael Shermer reposted
Eli
@QuintessenceEli
Rep. Luna confirmed that she met with Stephen Miller and discussed whistleblowers who claim to know the locations of alleged crash retrieval programs. She said she requested immunity for those individuals so they could come forward with information. She also confirmed that the White House tasked Avi Loeb with establishing a UAP science advisory task force.
Akam1129 🛸🗞️💥🌍🌱🐶
@Akam1129
wabcradio.com/episode/rep-anna-paulina-luna-the-american-…
💥
7 mn podcast
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna: The American People Deserve Full Transparency on the US Government’s Files About UFOs -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Exactly @Briankeating and what about all the nuclear scientists untouched, the murdered non-scientists, the base-rate neglect of 49,000/annual suicides some of which will be people who work in nuclear, military, even UFOs!
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Some developing countries want nuclear secrets so badly they’ll kill other scientists from countries that already have them? Really? Totally irresponsible. Nearly all of them have nothing to do with UFOs @michaelshermer
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Matt @GoodTroubleShow I saw your post about me. Would you like to do an episode of your show to understand where I’m actually coming from? I have NOT made up my mind on aliens, but put a low probability on them being here. See: www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Rather than revisiting decades-old cases that lack reliable evidence, the council's mission is focused on gathering better data and applying modern scientific methods to current reports.”
www.ibtimes.co.uk/white-house-science-council-ufos-1802991 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
So...that's where he lives? Now maybe we can find the plans for that damn motor.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More Details on the UAP Science Advisory Council from @ProfAviLoeb
Hopefully, at long last, we will get to the bottom of the remaining mysteries, assuming there's a there there to find. We've got a great team & I am honored to serve it & our country.
avi-loeb.medium.com/more-details-on-the-uap-science-advis… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“We should leave aside the question of whether the victims were believers or not. Whether they were religious or not changed absolutely nothing,” writes Roman Polanski in Skeptic.
One of the last living survivors of the Krakow ghetto, Polanski reflects on antisemitism, the Holocaust, and how quickly the unthinkable can become reality. www.skeptic.com/article/roman-polanski-hell-is-empty-all-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The Zodiac killer was not real—the creation of a media crazed with serial killers and obsessed with the equivalent of Dr. Evil.
Eddie McNamara new book is a must read in true crime:
Zodiactually: The Real Story of a Fake Serial Killer
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/the-zodiac-killer-wa… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It’s real…
www.liberationtimes.com/home/us-establishes-new-interagen… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Advocatus Diabli
Adversarial Collaboration
Astral🛸
@The_Astral_
Avi Loeb explains why he selected skeptic Michael Shermer for the UAP Science Advisory Council. 👀
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
To celebrate 6 years of bringing data to discussions about controversial issues, we're summarizing 20 of our most interesting findings:
(2/20) Americans Underestimate the Damage Done During the Summer 2020 George Floyd/BLM Unrest
Most Americans are unaware that the George Floyd/BLM riots were the most destructive in American history, leading insurance agencies to designate them as a "catastrophe event."
4 in 10 liberals, and 3 in 10 conservatives, estimated that the riots caused between "$1 million to $10 million" in damage when the actual figure is over $1 billion (see right graph).
We also found that underestimating the damage caused was positively associated with trusting news journalists (see left graph).
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
To celebrate 6 years of bringing data to discussions about controversial issues, we're summarizing 20 of our most interesting findings:
(3/20) Conservatives and Liberals Show Mixed Patterns of Inaccuracy on Crime
When it comes to violent crime in general, conservatives were much more likely to believe, falsely, that in 2024 violence was at historic highs (see left graph).
However, when we looked at a specific politically-charged case of violence, school shootings, conservatives tended to be more accurate. While over half of conservatives guessed, correctly, that ~50 people die in school shootings, only around 1/3rd of liberals answered similarly (see right graph).
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Adversarial Collaboration works to get us closer to the truth. It’s why the Catholic Church employed an advocatus diabli, devil’s advocate, to debunk hoaxed & mistaken claims of miracles, holy relics, etc. It is why the UAP Science Advisory Council has a skeptic on the team.
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
Does money buy happiness? A Princeton Nobel laureate said no above $75,000. A Penn researcher with 1.7 million data points said yes. The day they sat down together to settle the fight, the answer they reached should change how you think about your own life.
The Nobel laureate is Daniel Kahneman. The Penn researcher is Matthew Killingsworth.
The fight between them lasted 13 years, and the way it ended is one of the cleanest examples in modern science of two smart people being wrong in opposite directions about the same question.
In 2010 Kahneman and his Princeton colleague Angus Deaton published a paper that became one of the most quoted findings in the history of social science.
They analyzed 450,000 responses to the Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index and concluded that emotional well-being rose steadily with income up to about $75,000 a year, and then flattened out completely. Above that line, the extra money was not buying any more daily happiness.
The headline traveled around the world. Every news outlet ran the number.
A CEO in Seattle famously cut his own salary to raise his employees to that exact threshold. The 75,000 dollar figure became cultural shorthand for the idea that the rich are not actually any happier than the rest of us once basic needs are met.
For 11 years almost nobody seriously challenged it. Kahneman had a Nobel Prize in Economics, the sample size was massive, and the conclusion was emotionally satisfying in a way that made everyone feel a little better about not being wealthy.
Then in 2021 a 33 year old researcher at the University of Pennsylvania published a paper that quietly destroyed the entire finding. His name is Matthew Killingsworth.
He had spent the previous decade building a smartphone app called Track Your Happiness that pinged users at random moments during their day and asked them a simple question.
How do you feel right now, on a scale from very bad to very good. The app was designed to catch happiness in the act, not to ask people to recall it later.
By 2021 he had collected over 1.7 million real-time happiness reports from 33,000 adults. When he plotted income against in-the-moment well-being, there was no plateau anywhere.
The line just kept rising. People earning $200,000 were happier on average than people earning $100,000. People earning $400,000 were happier than people earning $200,000. The curve flattened slightly but never stopped climbing.
The famous $75,000 ceiling that the world had been quoting for 11 years simply did not exist in his data.
Now there were two Nobel-quality findings sitting in direct contradiction with each other. One of them had to be wrong, and neither researcher was willing to walk away.
What happened next is the part of the story almost nobody knows.
Kahneman called Killingsworth and proposed something rare in academic science. He called it an adversarial collaboration. The two of them, joined by Penn psychologist Barbara Mellers as a neutral referee, would sit down together and reanalyze the raw data from both studies, line by line, until they figured out which one of them was wrong.
The paper they co-authored was published in March 2023 in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. And the answer they reached was not what either of them had expected.
Both of them had been right at the same time. They had been measuring two different populations without realizing it.
When the team broke Killingsworth's 1.7 million data points apart by baseline happiness, the picture clarified completely. For the happiest 70 percent of people, more money kept buying more happiness all the way up to $500,000 a year, with no sign of slowing down.
For people in the middle, the same pattern held. But for the bottom 20 percent of the sample, the ones who were already unhappy before the question of money even came up, the curve flattened almost exactly where Kahneman's original paper had said it would. Above roughly $100,000 a year, adjusted for inflation, more money did nothing for them.
This is the finding that changes how the question should be asked.
If you are not already unhappy, money keeps buying happiness for a much longer stretch than Kahneman's original paper suggested. The runway is wider than the world has been telling itself for a decade.
If you are already unhappy, money does almost nothing past a certain point. There is a ceiling, but the ceiling is not about income. It is about the underlying state of the person collecting it.
The deeper insight in Killingsworth's original research, the one almost nobody talks about, is the part that should sit with you longer than the income numbers. The Track Your Happiness app had been telling him for years that the single biggest predictor of in-the-moment well-being is not money at all. It is whether your mind is on the thing you are doing.
His most cited paper, written with Daniel Gilbert at Harvard, is titled A Wandering Mind Is an Unhappy Mind. The data from the app showed that people are mentally absent from what they are doing 47 percent of the time, and that mental absence is one of the strongest predictors of unhappiness in the entire dataset. More predictive than income. More predictive than the activity itself. More predictive than almost any demographic variable you could measure.
Which means the unhappy 20 percent that Kahneman's plateau actually described were probably not unhappy because they did not have enough money. They were unhappy for reasons that more money could not reach.
The reason the curve flattened for them at $100,000 a year is the same reason it would have flattened at $300,000 or $700,000. The thing they were missing was not buyable.
The most uncomfortable line in the entire 2023 paper is the one that nobody on the internet quotes. The authors note that the relationship between income and happiness, while real, is much weaker than the relationship between attention and happiness. A person earning $40,000 who is fully present in their own life will, on average, report higher in-the-moment well-being than a person earning $400,000 whose mind is somewhere else.
The fight about money was the wrong fight the entire time.
The two researchers spent 13 years arguing over whether the dollar ceiling was at $75,000 or $500,000, and the data from Killingsworth's own app was sitting there the whole time saying the ceiling was not about dollars at all. The ceiling is whether you can hold your attention on the life you actually have.
You can run the experiment yourself the next time you catch your mind drifting. Stop. Put your phone down. Look at the room you are in, the person across from you, the food in front of you, the work you are actually doing. That is the part the apps cannot sell you and the salary cannot buy you.
The data has been clear for over a decade. The plateau is not in your bank account. It is in your attention. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I am deeply honored to serve the White House, AARO, ODNI & the FBI at getting to the bottom of the UAP files.
@ProfAviLoeb is the right person to head the UAP Science Advisory Council because he strikes the right balance between naive gullibility & dogmatic skepticism as Carl Sagan noted in the epigram of my 1st book, Why People Believe Weird Things:
Professor Avi Loeb
@ProfAviLoeb
I was tasked by the White House, AARO, ODNI, the FBI, and the Intelligence Community to lead and assemble a team of scientists and experts for a new UAP Science Advisory Council.
The council includes Prof. Carol Cleland: anomaly identification; Dr. Richard Cloete (@RichAC2020): data analysis and AI tools; Dr. Omer Eldadi: data management, AI, and human psychology; Dr. Tim Gallaudet (@GallaudetTim): oceanography; Ross Howard: communication; Dr. Devesh Nandal: numerical analysis and astrophysics; Prof. Garry Nolan (@GarryPNolan): molecular biology and materials science; Dr. Regina Sarmiento: data analysis and AI-assisted data management; Dr. Michael Shermer (@michaelshermer): the study of anomalies; Prof. Peter Skafish: anthropology; Prof. Matthew Szydagis: instrumentation and data collection; and Dr. Jennice Vilhauer: quantitative psychology.
This constitutes an amazing A-team of exceptional scientists and experts. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Christopher Sharp
@ChrisUKSharp
Announced members of the UAP Science Advisory Council, led by Avi Loeb, include:
-Dr. Richard Cloete
-Dr. Regina Sarmiento
-Prof. Garry Nolan
-Dr. Tim Gallaudet
-Prof. Matthew Szydagis
-Dr. Devesh Nandal
-Prof. Peter Skafish
-Dr. Michael Shermer
-Dr. Jennice Vilhauer
-Dr. Omer Eldadi
UAP James
@UAPJames
BREAKING: White House tasks Dr. Avi Loeb to create a UAP Science Advisory Council with astrophysicists, AI experts, and human psychologists
The Council will assist U.S. Government agencies to include ODNI, FBI, and AARO in determining the nature of UAPs.
avi-loeb.medium.com/a-uap-science-advisory-council-to-the… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the rich not paying their "fair" share, there's an endless stream of graphs like these putting the lie to that claim.
Do you mean the 1% should pay 99%?
What's the right number?
BTW, I'm not even remotely close to being in the top 1% -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
LOL, the book "marketers" spam scam emails are getting longer and longer. Do they A-B test these for response frequency? Seems like this would be a detriment, but maybe it works on some authors? I also wonder which AI program they use to generate them...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you're not a fan of Elon, or are an anti-billionaire (and, now, anti-trillionaire), you can decline to:
—use StarLink
—drive a Tesla
—use X
Unfortunately, the anti's want more: redistribute wealth to those who don't have it.
The rich already pay massive taxes because we have a progressive tax system (the more you make the more you pay).
Econ 101: bringing down the rich further does not raise up the poor.
Instead of obsessing about Elon's wealth, focus on what we can do to raise the poor into the middle class.
www.wsj.com/livecoverage/spacex-ipo-stock-market-06-12-2026 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It has happened.
www.nytimes.com/live/2026/06/12/business/spacex-ipo-elon-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Tomorrow could bring the world's first trillionaire individual, depending on where the SpaceX IPO closes at the EOD (> $135/share). Yes, I've placed an order, but us little guys don't get the F&F price so I have a bad feeling loses are in the cards...
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/11/technology/spacex-ipo-price.html -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The New Pseudohistorians:
My article on:
Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson, & Antisemitism and Holocaust Denial
Are they the product of the attention economy (more clicks) or do they actually believe their antisemitic claptrap about WWII & the Holocaust?
www.skeptic.com/article/owens-carlson-antisemitism-holoca… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In other words @BjornLomborg the truth still matters. Thanks to people like you who hold their feet to the fire in their doomsday predictions. "Just you wait" & "next time it really will happen" are no longer acceptable excuses for failed predictions.
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
20 years ago, An Inconvenient Truth put climate change at the center of global debate, shaping politics, influencing leaders, and inspiring a generation of activists.
Two decades later, we can assess not just its impact, but its accuracy. Many of the film’s most alarming predictions did not materialize, while many of the policies it inspired have proven costly and ineffective.
The lesson? Panic is a poor guide for public policy. Focusing on innovation, adaptation, and economic development can do far more to help both people and the climate—at a fraction of the cost.
financialpost.com/opinion/bjorn-lomborg-al-gores-inaccura… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How Algorithms Use Your Data to Control You
Oxford philosopher @carissav tells me about the long human desire to know the future—from ancient oracles and astrology to AI, surveillance capitalism, predictive policing, and “data-driven” decision-making.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/how-algorithms-use-y… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From UFO to UAP
A parachute (seriously) is misperceived as a UAP
Credentialing: the moment you hear people promoting credentials it means they have no actual evidence
1 minute UAP debunking with Star Price:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=R44leDyiyDM -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I am asked if I plan to “address the Scott Pelley firing or continue to run cover for Bari Weiss.” My reply:
I wasn’t aware I was running cover for Bari Weiss. I haven’t said a thing about her and CBS. I appreciated her as my editor at the WSJ and NYTs, and I thought she did a good thing founding the Free Press, but I have no idea how she is doing at CBS. As for the firing of staff, that’s normal with mergers and acquisitions, happens all the time, but when it happens with someone on camera then people feel personally invested and so get involved, whereas they ignore all the other people fired who are invisible to them. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Again, there is no mystery that needs explaining for the dead or missing scientists/military/UFO people once you take into account the other 3 cells in the 2x2 causal matrix (non-missing/dead people, missing/dead non-scientists, etc.), as I explain here:
www.skeptic.com/article/the-mystery-of-missing-and-dead-s…
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Spinning fanciful conspiracy theories about dead & missing scientists & UFO enthusiasts is not as harmless as it sounds, especially for families suffering from a loss. My friend @eweissunburied featured in this story on the death of her husband Nick Pope.
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/02/science/missing-scientists-con… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In search of suicidal empathy at the USS Midway with @GadSaad but the Navy says they don’t have any and are not vibing the concept. Maybe the military is not where to find any Gadfather?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
See my Truth book defending moral realism @LSK94LH
Atheism is just no belief in God.
To derive objective morality use science & reason & philosophy. Start with the principle of interchangeable perspectives:
“As I would not be a slave I would not be a slave holder.” -Lincoln
LSK
@LSK94LH
if you think Mormonism is Christianity, you should have your head checked by a psychiatrist.
atheism provides no alternative to morality.
by your atheist logic, you shouldn't believe in what morality even is. just random emotional impulses and tribal judgement. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Nice view of San Diego harbor with 2 active aircraft carriers as I prep for an upcoming podcast episode on the rise and fall of the atom bomb…are they really fallen?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Which is the right religion, of course, is the wrong question because, as I argue in Truth, religious truths are better thought of as internal subjective or pragmatic truths of what works for YOU. These pages capture that sentiment…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Some light reading at my hotel room today. But which is the One True Religion? So many to choose from, so little time…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Spinning fanciful conspiracy theories about dead & missing scientists & UFO enthusiasts is not as harmless as it sounds, especially for families suffering from a loss. My friend @eweissunburied featured in this story on the death of her husband Nick Pope.
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/02/science/missing-scientists-con… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Everything @HPluckrose writes is worth reading and this time is no different as she shows why banning bad ideas backfires. Counter them with good ideas. I’ve refuted Holocaust denial, for example, but defended their right to think and speak their egregiously wrong beliefs.
Helen Pluckrose
@HPluckrose
For Skeptic, I argue that the best way to abolish bad ideas is not to ban them but open them up to genuine multidisciplinary critique.
www.skeptic.com/article/anti-woke-case-for-not-banning-ge… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The always insightful @bungarsargon on the Jews and the Left, her new book that explains what went wrong with the left, who used to support the Jewish people and stand against antisemitism, which now has been reversed.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/batya-ungar-sargon-w… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"History doesn’t always end with justice."
Tragically that is too often true @geraldposner
But sometimes it does, so we must seek justice when possible. Not cosmic justice, in a religious or metaphysical sense, but in Earthly justice in the here-and-now.
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
Just after 4 a.m. on June 6, 1985, the phone rang in our New York City apartment.
This was not a time when calls were ignored. No cell phones, no caller ID—just a landline and the assumption that if it rang at that hour, it mattered.
@trishaposner answered. I could hear only her side at first, then she covered the receiver and turned to me: “A German reporter is on the line. He says Brazilian police think they may have found Mengele’s grave.”
By then, I had been chasing Josef Mengele—the “Angel of Death” of Auschwitz—for four years. My search had taken me through Argentina, Paraguay, Brazil, and Germany, following fragments of leads, whispers of sightings, and the enduring myth of a man who seemed always just out of reach.
Mengele was not just a fugitive. He was a ghost.
He had evaded capture for decades, slipping through the cracks of postwar justice, protected at times by networks of neo-Nazis, at other times by indifference, bureaucratic failure, and sometimes sheer luck.
So my reaction that morning was immediate, almost reflexive: “Tell him it’s the twentieth time they’ve ‘found’ Mengele.”
There had been so many false alarms and supposed sightings. So many bodies that were not his.
My working assumption was simple: if news of his death surfaced, it might well be deliberate—yet another deception by those who had helped shield him, or even by Mengele himself.
But as the morning unfolded, this case felt different. Within 24 hours, I was on a plane to Brazil. Weeks later, in Germany, I was part of a panel examining the authenticity of Mengele’s postwar diaries. That’s where I met his son, Rolf—who finally shed light on how his father evaded justice for so long.
The bones found on this day in 1985? They were his. He had died six years earlier after suffering a stroke while swimming.
After decades on the run, the “Angel of Death” of Auschwitz had died quietly, hidden in plain sight.
History doesn’t always end with justice. The story of Josef Mengele resists that comforting arc.
The biography I wrote, with co-author John Ware, was published the following year and tells the full story of the hunt and Mengele's life on the run.
#mengele -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
So you’re telling me there’s a chance it’s aliens @MickWest ?
-
Michael Shermer reposted
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Facts of progress today's grads are unlikely to hear, from @sapinker what he would tell Harvard grads 50 years after his graduation:
"In 1976, a newborn American could look forward to 73 years of life; today’s newborn, 79.3 years. That year’s “misery index” (the sum of the inflation and unemployment rates) was 13.5 percent; this year’s is 8 percent. Then, 18 percent of Americans were poor; as of 2024, 11 percent are. The homicide rate was more than 8 per 100,000"
www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/6/1/pinker-harvard-commen… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Remember when they told you that gay and lesbian people were just like everyone else, and just wanted to be left alone? Scrap that. We’re actually queers who believe marriage is a “fundamentally violent institution” and that the sex binary is a white supremacist fiction. Now we’ve gotten marriage, we will indoctrinate your kids in queer and gender theory, fire you if you don’t repeat our pronouns, force girls to shower next to boys in locker rooms, give irreversible sex changes to minors, and insist that “a penis is not a male body part. It’s just an unusual body part for a woman.”
andrewsullivan.substack.com/p/the-tq-threat-to-lgb-rights… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More book promotion scams, these two came within minutes of each other, nearly the same copy.
AI generated?
I'd really like to know about how many such emails do they send out to which people respond to? And: of those who respond, how many of them actually send money? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This one is probably a balloon the camera is tracking, then at the moment it zooms off to the right is when the camera stopped tracking it & zoomed in.
The object didn't move, the camera did.
No need for new space-time, warp drive, anti-gravity physics!
youtu.be/k643kggDltE?t=481 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The New UFO Files:
What UFOs, UAPs, and the Evidence Really Show
My convo with doc film/TV producer Star Price (e.g., Penn & Teller's Bullshit, my Exploring the Unknown).
Here I point out to him that this UAP is a parachute swirling around in the wind:
youtu.be/k643kggDltE -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Americans don't have a rosy view of Biden's time in the White House. Across political orientations, a majority of people agree that "members of the Democratic Party hid Biden's mental decline from the public."
(see graph below)
Jake Tapper 🦅
@jaketapper
A rosy, if not blindfolded, “View from the East Wing” www.cnn.com/2026/06/02/politics/jill-biden-book-jake-tapp…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From Equality to Equity:
How Social Justice Becomes Ideology
Psychologist Jon Mills, author of Woke, shares with me his explanation for how the equality of opportunity got corrupted into the equality of outcomes (which can never be achieved):
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/from-equality-to-equ… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
7 Ideas That Should Make You Distrust Your Own Mind
The author of The Why Behind Things, Hunter Trace, tells Skeptic readers what to look out for in getting tripped up in observation and belief (but there's hope!)
www.skeptic.com/article/seven-ideas-that-should-make-you-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not only are the aliens cleverly disabling all photographic evidence of their abductions, they are erasing the memories of all partners, spouses & family members in the homes who report no missing people, and tricking us all into believing in sleep paralysis as an explanation!
Timothy Alberino
@TimothyAlberino
This statement betrays an ignorance of the abduction phenomenon. Many abductees have attempted to capture their abductors on camera but the equipment is always remotely disabled by the grays before they show up.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @Sara_Imari
If an ETI manages to, say, achieve space flight to go to the moon of its planet or other planets in its solar system, isn't it safe to assume that they've mastered the mathematical formula for gravity in order to compute precise trajectories? Uniformitarianism.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Math exists within the architectures (biological and technological) evolved on Earth, we should not be so easily convinced it exists anywhere else in our universe. Math as our most “universal language” is merely evidence of our own evolutionary boundary in what we can describe. It is not a universal truth autonomous to our universe, nor does it reveal anything beyond a boundary to what we observe.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Instead of @LueElizondo as manichean good or evil, how about genuinely mistaken or possibly delusional?
(Grifting is another possibility, but I can't fault anyone for writing books about their experiences, unless they made them up. He never responds to me so I don't know.)
Red Panda Koala
@RedPandaKoala
Luis Elizondo says history will either remember him as a "patriot" or "the biggest villian in history"
What is he referring to that would make him remembered as "the biggest villian in history"? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting @clairlemon
So, in addition to generating quality intellectual content, founding a magazine, managing a staff, raising money, budgeting, deadlines, a podcast, thousands of media interviews, and doing this for years (or even decades!), actually counts for something?
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Not very impressed with those who present themselves as the guardians of journalistic integrity when they describe Bari Weiss as an opinion journalist as opposed to an entrepreneur & business executive.
I mean, do they care about factual rigour or not? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"I break my silence to reveal everything I legally can about my investigations of UAP & non-human intelligent life"
Translation:
"I met people who told me stories about aliens & spaceships & they have great credentials so I believe them even though I've never seen them myself"
DisclosureWatch (Slava Ukraini)
@BordleyStephen
Buy the book, ignore the narcs.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To researchers:
How to get people to read your scholarly paper from @Aella_Girl
"The hottest woman was a whopping 8.7 & she’s so hot my intrasexual competition flares up & I want to murder her perfect pert titties off. I’ll include her photo at the end."
open.substack.com/pub/aella/p/do-hot-people-fuck-more?r=2… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If only more social scientists were as honesst as @Aella_Girl in their studies on human sexuality:
"There might be selection effects here—it’s possible that any average guy finds this survey appealing, while only particularly slutty women do. It’s also possible that men saying ‘yes i’m hotter than this 7/10 man’ are more delusional, and this impacts the ratings a bit too."
open.substack.com/pub/aella/p/do-hot-people-fuck-more?r=2… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
That's all @Aella_Girl ?! LOL
"fuckability" meets at ~2/10, where 2/10 women and men were rated as equally fuckable by the opposite genders, but a man’s fuckability is equivalent to the fuckability of a woman roughly 2 points below him in attractiveness.
open.substack.com/pub/aella/p/do-hot-people-fuck-more?r=2… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For years I have been describing the 1951 film The Day the Earth Stood Still as a Christ allegory
Christ-figure Klaatu (Michael Rennie) comes to Earth to warn about nuclear weapons
His Earth name: "Mr. Carpenter"
He's ignored
He mingles among the common people & develops a relationship with the Mary Magdalene figure Helen (Patricia Neal)
He is killed by authorities who put him into a morgue
Helen instructs Gort the robot to rescue him: "Gort, Klaatu Barada Nikto"
Gort empties the tomb & takes Klaatu back to the spaceship and resurrects him.
In the original script Helen asks if this is the power of technology.
Original answer: "The robots have conquered death itself through technology."
Joseph Breen censorship board objected.
New line: ""No. That power is reserved for the Almighty Spirit."
Ending: Klaatu ascends back to heaven in his spaceship
Someone finally made a video about this:
youtu.be/z4EKohtF8XA -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting photograph of a UFO @Benking64602975
Here is one I shot even more convincing (the top of a clear plastic licorice box).
This was for a TV episode in which we faked a bunch of UFO photos.
Does this mean they are all fake? Of course not. But...
youtu.be/o7Tu-28hyow
Benjamin🦘🇦🇺
@Benking64602975
68 years later it is still not clear what quantum mechanics or dark energy is, therefore the explanation it is a modern myth remains solid.
I suppose if you ignore the whistleblowers, visual evidence and corroborating evidence there is no evidence. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I first met @WhitleyStrieber on @billmaher ABC show Politically Incorrect, there to talk about his alien abduction experience.
In the Green Room I asked him what he does for a living.
Response: "I write science fiction and fantasy."
That's all I needed to know.
EdibleAnus
@TheEdibleAnus
There's an account from a patient at the end of the book (abduction experience) that jung believes to be fantasy. It's almost word for word out of a Whitley Strieber book. I love Whitley's book but don't think ufos are real. The mind is a deeply curious thing and it's perfectly capable of producing such experiences, and for the experiencer to believe it actually happened.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What is the recent fascination with "Non-Human Intelligence" here on Earth? Yet another book promising disclosure. Haven't people been watching David Attenborough's films since the 1980s on the topic? There are an endless stream of examples...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"While many of today’s MSM outlets still mouth their support of “fair and balanced” reporting, in my experience most do not practice it, at least in those areas about which I know a fair amount.
On UFOs, for example, where I was a regular commentator on these mysterious sightings in the sky, today there are weekly reports, segments, and shows about UFOs that almost never feature any scientist or scholar to offer a prosaic explanation."
www.skeptic.com/article/skepticism-attention-economy-outr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI: The audio edition of Truth (read by me, per usual for my books) is now available on:
#audibleapp www.audible.com/pd/B0GQJVHCG5?source_code=SNGGBWS07271700… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I'm speaking at Atlas Society's conf at Westin San Diego Bayview Saturday, on Truth, w/comments for libertarians & Ayn Rand fans about truth in the political realm. I've arranged for everyone to get a free copy of Truth or Conspiracy + a copy of Skeptic.
www.atlassociety.org/galts-gulch-2026 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @donalddhoffman I address your Interface Theory of Perception in my new book Truth & (I think) refute it, so I would love to send you a copy. In the meantime, here is the final section of my chapter on consciousness that includes you. I would love to hear your response:
The Weak Consciousness Principle vs. the Strong Consciousness Principle
Since you have to be conscious to experience anything, when Chopra proposes that consciousness and the universe are equivalent, in the sense that it is an “undeniable fact that any universe is only knowable through the human mind’s ability to perceive reality,” he is stating the obvious. Call this the Weak Consciousness Principle (WCP): you have to be conscious to experience consciousness.
But Deepak goes further than this when he says, “if all human knowledge is rooted in consciousness, perhaps we are viewing not the real universe based on limitations of the brain” and “that the apparent evolution of the cosmos since the big bang has been totally dependent upon human consciousness.” That’s reversing the causal arrow, from perception to determination, from being consciously aware of the universe and trying to understand it, to our own consciousness bringing about the universe. Call this the Strong Consciousness Principle (SCP). Which one is right?
In my understanding of the neural correlates of consciousness, the hypothesis that the brain creates consciousness has vastly more evidence for it than the hypothesis that consciousness creates brain. Damage to the fusiform gyrus of the temporal lobe, for example, causes prosopagnosia, or face blindness, and stimulation of this same area causes people to see faces spontaneously. Stroke-caused damage to the visual cortex region called V1 leads to loss of conscious visual perception. Changes in conscious experience can be directly measured by fMRI, EEG, and single-neuron recordings. Neuroscientists can predict human choices from brain scan activity before the subject is even consciously aware of the decisions made. Using brain scans alone, neuroscientists have even been able to reconstruct on a computer screen what someone is seeing.
In other words, brain activity = conscious experience.
Thousands of lab experiments, in conjunction with naturally occurring experiments in the form of brain tumors, strokes, accidents and injuries, confirm the hypothesis that neurochemical processes produce subjective experiences.
In other words, neural activity = qualia.
A scientific challenge to this position is by the cognitive scientist Donald Hoffman, which he first presented in a 2008 paper titled “Conscious Realism and the Mind-Body Problem.” Conscious realism, Hoffman explains, “asserts that the objective world, i.e., the world whose existence does not depend on the perceptions of a particular observer, consists entirely of conscious agents.” Consciousness is fundamental to the cosmos and gives rise to particles and fields. “It is not a latecomer in the evolutionary history of the universe, arising from complex interactions of unconscious matter and fields,” Hoffman continues. “Consciousness is first; matter and fields depend on it for their very existence.”
Where is the evidence for consciousness being fundamental to the cosmos? Here Hoffman turns to how human observers “construct the visual shapes, colors, textures and motions of objects.” Our senses do not construct an approximation of physical reality in our brains, he argues, but instead operate more like a Graphical User Interface (GUI) system that bears little to no resemblance of what actually goes on inside the computer. In this model, our senses operate to construct reality, not reconstruct it. Further, this view “does not require the hypothesis of independently existing physical objects.”
Hoffman has developed his ideas into a full-blown theory he calls the Interface Theory of Perception (ITP) that he presents more forcefully in his 2019 book The Case Against Reality. Like most scientists, Hoffman rejects solipsism—the belief that only one’s mind is known to exist—but unlike most scientists he does not accept the model of veridical perception, which holds that natural selection shaped our senses to give us a reasonably accurate model of the world. Instead, ITP contends that percepts are a species-specific user interface that directs behavior toward survival and reproduction, not truth.
Hoffman’s computer analogy is that the physical environment is like the desktop and the objects in nature are like desktop icons. Our senses, he says, form a biological user interface—a gooey GUI—between our brains and the outside world, transducing physical stimuli such as photons of light into neural impulses processed by the visual cortex as things in the environment. GUIs are useful because you don’t need to know what’s inside computers and brains. You just need to know how to interact with the interface well enough to accomplish your task. Adaptive function, not veridical perception, is what is important. In other words, evolution designed us to want to have more babies, not to determine Truth.
Hoffman’s holotype is the Australian jewel beetle J. bakewelli. Females are large, shiny, brown, and dimpled. So too are discarded beer bottles called “stubbies,” and males will mount them until they die by heat, starvation, or ants. The species was on the brink of extinction because its senses and brain were designed by natural selection not to perceive reality (it’s a beer bottle you idiot!) but to mate with anything big, brown, shiny, and dimply. Like beetles, Hoffman says, humans are easily fooled by illusions because our brains did not evolve to give us an exact replica of reality.
In a segment of the popular television science series Through the Wormhole Hoffman made the point by biting into a lemon after gnawing on a West African berry that releases a glycoprotein molecule called miraculin that binds to the tongue’s taste buds, causing the lemon to taste sweet. But aren’t lemons really sour? No, says Hoffman. They’re only sour to certain taste buds that perceive them as such, and those taste receptors can be modified to perceive a radically different reality of sweetness. To test his theory Hoffman ran thousands of evolutionary computer simulations in which digital organisms whose perceptual systems are tuned exclusively for truth are outcompeted by those tuned solely for fitness. Since natural selection depends only on expected fitness (your capacity to pass along your genes into the next generation), evolution shaped our sensory systems toward fitter behavior, not truthful representation.
ITP is a provocative idea, but I am skeptical. First, how could a more accurate perception of reality not be adaptive? Hoffman’s answer is that evolution gave us an interface to hide the underlying reality because, for example, you don’t need to know how neurons create images of snakes; you just need to jump out of the way of the snake icon. But how did the snake icon come to look like a snake in the first place? Natural Selection. And why did some nonpoisonous snakes evolve to mimic poisonous species? Because predators avoid real poisonous snakes. Mimicry only works if there’s an objective reality to mimic.
This, in fact, is another example of the correspondence theory of truth, which holds that assessing the truth or falsity of a statement depends on how accurately it relates or corresponds to the world. This is also called ontological realism, or the belief that there is a world external to human minds, and that this world is knowable. For what it’s worth, this is the position held by the majority of professional philosophers. In a 2009 survey of 3,226 philosophy professors and graduate students, half (50.8 percent) agreed with the correspondence theory of truth. Further, three quarters (75.1 percent) reported that they accept or lean toward scientific realism, which the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy characterizes as “a commitment to the idea that our best theories have a certain epistemic status: they yield knowledge of aspects of the world, including unobservable aspects.”
Still, in the history of philosophy and science it would not be the first time that the majority of thinkers were wrong (think geocentrism before Copernicus or creationism before Darwin). Hoffman, along with Chopra and many others who share this worldview, believe that the tide is turning against ontological realism, scientific realism, and the correspondence theory of truth. “A rock is an interface icon, not a constituent of objective reality,” Hoffman asserts. But a real rock chipped into an arrow point and thrown at a four-legged meal really works even if you don’t know physics and calculus. Is that not veridical perception with adaptive significance?
Also, there’s a reason those desktop icons look as they do: documents have little bent corners like real paper, and folders have raised tabs because that’s how they used to be sorted into drawers. If you were inside your computer looking out wouldn’t it be more accurate to “see” documents as bent pieces of paper, and files with raised tabs, than as something else entirely? Evolution can and does select for reproductive success and more accurate models of reality, even if they’re not perfect representations.
As for jewel beetles, stubbies are what ethologists call supernormal stimuli that exaggerate real-world objects that elicit a response, such as silicone-breast implants in women and testosterone-enhanced body building in men. Supernormal stimuli operate only because evolution designed us to respond to normal stimuli, which must be accurately portrayed by our senses to our brains in order to work. Hoffman says perception is species specific and that we should take predators “seriously, but not literally.” Agreed, a dolphin’s icon for “shark” no doubt looks different than a human’s—presumably it would be a sonar pattern of waves instead of a visual pattern of light—but there really are sharks and they really do have powerful tails on one end and a mouthful of teeth on the other end, and that is true no matter how your sensory system works.
Hoffman often describes reality as an “illusion.” How, then, are we fooled by illusions created by artists, magicians, and perceptual psychologists, and why are we startled when so fooled? It is only by having some grasp of what reality is really like that the illusion works. M.C. Escher is the iconic artist of this genre with, for example, an aqueduct system in which the water flows uphill in Figure 9-2 below.
When David Copperfield appears to walk through a brick wall we’re startled because we understand that real brick walls don’t allow it. If IPT were correct these illusions should not surprise and delight us as they do.
As well, computer simulations like the ones Hoffman employed are useful tools for modeling how evolution might have happened, and for making predictions based on input parameters, but until there is more data from the real world in the form of living (instead of digital) organisms, ITP is itself an interface that needs a reality check. Science depends on theory and data. A real-world test of ITP would be to determine if most biological sensory interfaces create icons that resemble reality or distort it. I’m betting on reality.
Finally, why present this problem as an either-or choice between fitness and truth? Adaptations depend in large part on a relatively accurate model of reality. The fact that science progresses toward, say, eradicating diseases and landing spacecraft on Mars, must mean that our perceptions of reality are growing ever closer to the truth, even if it is with a small t. Thus, the Interface Theory of Perception is in alignment with the Weak Consciousness Principle, but not the Strong Consciousness Principle.
In the end, I agree with Steven Pinker’s final assessment of the hard problem of consciousness, which he articulated in his 2018 book Enlightenment Now:
"Our best science tells us that consciousness consists of a global workspace representing our current goals, memories, and surroundings, implemented in synchronized neural firing in fronto-parietal circuitry. But the last dollop in the theory—that it subjectively feels like something to be such circuitry—may have to be stipulated as a fact about reality where explanation stops."
With all these facts in mind—themselves part of the answer to the easy problem of consciousness, for which neuroscientists have made great progress—the hard problem is asking of us a question that is impossible to answer: what’s it like to be the neural wiring? That is, what’s it like to be you? How should I know? I’m not you and never can be.
I can imagine what it’s like to be you, and I can apply the Copernican Principle that we’re not special to myself—I’m not special—and reasonably infer that your internal states are similar to mine if I see in your actions and emotions patterns similar to those that I express. But the final step of knowing what it’s actually like to be you—or a dolphin or bat or anything—is one thought too many. Only you can experience you. A is A.
In my assessment of the hard problem, then, consciousness is a known unknown that is very likely unknowable, at least as the concept is conceived of at present. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Skepticism and the Attention Economy
My take on the new media, and the old. What has changed and why…an introduction to the new issue of Skeptic magazine:
www.skeptic.com/article/skepticism-attention-economy-outr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In case the letter I just posted seems out of context (beyond my one-paragraph summary), here's @LisaSelinDavis summary of my appearance on Brian Lehrer's WNYC's public radio show that went sideways when a caller dared to say that people can't change sex:
www.broadview.news/p/the-media-has-gender-derangement -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is a letter I received from a listener to my interview with public radio WNYC's Brian Lehrer about Truth, who was extremely polite and thoughtful with me until he took a call from a woman who self-identified as a Democrat, was highly critical of Trump, but then expressed her displeasure by the lies her party has been telling, namely that men can become women and vice versa, that men can play in women's sports, go into women's spaces, etc. He promptly terminated the interview, then when I was off the air asked listeners to call in to counter the caller and my agreement with her.
Dear Michael,
I’m writing to thank you for your gracious response to the Substack piece I wrote for DIAG (and for sharing that piece several times on X- much appreciated!).
[ diagdemocrats.substack.com/p/what-fear-sounds-like ]
I found so much to value in your conversation with Lehrer, particularly as a model for how to handle it when people simply won’t engage in good faith. You stay firmly out of the gross quagmire Lehrer is floundering around in. It feels dystopian to say what a rare relief it is to hear obvious truths like “men can’t become women” spoken out loud. Thank you.
I made a couple of organizational and conceptual mistakes in that piece, and it seems to have confused a few people—maybe you as well. In one of your posts you say I took you to task a little for having sympathy for adults with gender dysphoria. That’s not at all what I meant to communicate, and If you have a minute, I want to do a better job explaining. Some background:
My beloved daughter (now 27) was butchered by so-called “doctors” and now has no breasts. The gender doctors cut her up and threw her breasts in the trash. She was an adult when this happened. The knowledge of what was done to her came close to killing me.
I’m not sure anyone could have more sympathy for adults than I, a mother who would have stood in front of an oncoming car, or ax murderers, or wild dogs to protect her adult child.
So when I talk about adults, it’s not abstract, it’s my family’s life. I’m a very unwilling expert on what happens when we misapply notions of kindness or sympathy or autonomy. I do have sympathy for those that struggle with gender dysphoria, but my sympathy is more about the unethical medical practices that demolish their healthy bodies in the name of “authenticity.”
And my sympathy is not just for my daughter. It’s for myself and my husband. It’s for my son and how he had to watch his sister leave the family and his parents become shadows of who they once were. My sympathy extends out to all the grieving mothers and fathers I know and their confused and misled adult children as well. I’m excruciatingly aware of who pays the price when a category of people are deemed unworthy of real care and allowed to have unspeakable things done to them.
My main point was less about adults vs. kids, and more about logic. We can’t say “you are your body” and say that fact matters less with adults—those two statements are in conflict. We can’t say logic only works in one direction. Facts—objective truths—aren’t conditional. So no matter your age, you can’t change sex and you can’t be more or less of “someone who is their body”—all humans are their bodies, all the time.
If we do want to exclude adults from deserving evidence based treatment, and maybe some people do, it would require different logic to justify.
I pointed this out not to be annoyingly nitpicky : ), but because of my worry that logical inconsistencies have downstream effects that might undermine our efforts to stop the gender juggernaut. Much like releasing weasels to control rats, it may end up with the unintended consequence of all the songbirds being eaten.
When it comes to adults, I think we need to frame this as a societal problem akin to drug addiction or eating disorders. (Framing this as akin to flat earthers was a mistake on my part. A belief in a flat earth is benign. So-called gender medicine is not). Our solutions may need to come from the less benign world of addiction.
We do not say that some people—fentanyl users for instance—are meant to have fentanyl, or are made “happier” by using. We do not say, “Kids shouldn't have fentanyl, but adults should be able to.” No one would think this was defensible. I don’t see trans as being much different.
However, the reality is we don’t seem to be able to stop fentanyl use. That’s one way autonomy can look. People’s adult children, in the streets, living in filth, victims of rape and brutality, getting high over and over and over again until they die. It’s sad. It’s horrible. We haven’t figured out how to stop it. That’s an honest description of the problem. That’s what “autonomy” looks like for those whose "autonomy" is controlled by a drug.
If people want to say “No one should have their breasts and penis cut off, but I don’t know how we would legislate it, or I don’t know how to respond to people who say “adults should do what they want,” then fair enough. Let’s figure it out.
My response to the “adults can do what they want” narrative is that adults can sort of do what they want, but there are social, legal, and financial consequences. Restrictions on behavior are everywhere. It’s already part of the fabric of society to curtail activities of adults that are known to be harmful. Adults with eating disorders or drug addictions are referred to treatment not to provide more access to these harmful behaviors, but to recover from them. Efforts are made to deter people from activities that damage their current and long term health, such as eating only processed or high sugar foods, not wearing sunscreen, or not exercising. Drive drunk? Lose your license. Smoke in a restaurant? Get kicked out.
If an adult believes they would be happier without their penis or breasts, that’s a mental illness, not a medical necessity. Society should not call this medical care, nor should insurance cover it, nor should doctors provide it, therapists encourage it, or school curriculum teach it.
Foolish and destructive decisions are not just the purview of young people. We do not magically stop making terrible mistakes once we turn 18, nor is there any age when a person is no longer susceptible to compelling ideologies.
So will some adults still pursue these surgeries? Probably.
Will some cosmetic surgeons (not covered by insurance) still be willing to perform these mutilating procedures? Probably.
Can we stop adults from believing they are the opposite sex? Maybe not, but we should try.
Can we stop people from using fentanyl? Maybe not, but we should try.
That’s my thinking in a nutshell…would welcome any thoughts you have. Thanks very much for reading and for everything you’re doing to bring open discourse, critical thinking and TRUTH back in fashion!
Warmly,
Michelle
piranesi15@gmail.com -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI, here is how to think about the "dead or missing" scientists conspiracy theory, namely that there is no conspiracy. The entire thing is an artifact of base rate neglect + confirmation bias:
www.skeptic.com/article/the-mystery-of-missing-and-dead-s… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yet another "missing" scientist is no longer missing and was not a scientist, as the latest conspiracy theory about how "they" are doing nefarious things unravels into nothing.
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
Melissa Casias, whose remains were just identified after nearly a year missing, was NOT a scientist. She was an administrative assistant at Los Alamos. Her niece confirmed it publicly.
Yet she was absorbed into the viral conspiracy about “mystery missing nuclear scientists.” Her family suffered the loss and the additional cruelty of watching her dragged into the misinformation and breathless and unquestioning media coverage.
Still, in today’s coverage, Fox, CNN, USA Today, the Telegraph, and others report on her death and insist on calling her a “scientist.”
The conspiracy sells. Accuracy doesn’t. The Daily Mail and National Enquirer used to own this lane. Now it seems to be everyone’s lane. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Insightful letter from Carl Jung on the true nature of UFOs, yet 68 years later it is still not self evident what they are beyond ordinary terrestrial phenomena so his explanation that they are a "modern myth" remains solid.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Partially correct @PostDisclosure
ETIs could be definitively demonstrated, unlike many religious claims that must be taken on faith (Jesus died for your sins).
HOWEVER: Christians claim the resurrection literally happened & they can prove it.
I don't think the evidence is convincing, but most Christians believe it is, just like UFOlogists believe aliens are here.
Post Disclosure World
@PostDisclosure
When academics say that the UFO subject is a religion, I see where they are coming from, but I also disagree.
Here is why: Religions have far less evidence for their validity than the proposition that we are being engaged by non-human intelligence. This remains true whether any given religion is true.
There may be religious psychology inside UFO culture, but the core proposition is not a religious one; it is a claim about events, objects, witnesses, records, programs, traces, and potentially recoverable evidence.
So, if we ever get disclosure, what happens—UFOs suddenly no longer file under religion?
This is silly. Because, as I've stated ad nauseam, disclosure would PROVE that there was substantial evidence of these phenomena in the public domain the whole time. I will never stop reminding people of that, and I will be writing a focused article on it.
As you were. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What's more likely?
"The Shroud of Turin image required 34,000 billion watts of ultraviolet energy in one 40th of a billionth of a second"
or
The Shroud of Turin is a 14th century artifact, one of thousands of medieval relics (eg, a piece of the true cross) to be hoaxed?
Interstellar
@InterstellarUAP
The Shroud of Turin image required 34,000 billion watts of ultraviolet energy in one 40th of a billionth of a second
This is a power level “We don’t have on Earth.”
No paint, dye or brush strokes. Just a burst so insane it only scorched the very top of the linen fibers.
This wasn’t made by human hands. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I refute Hoffman's Interface Theory of Perception (ITP) pp. 241-245 in Truth @AmericanALCHMY I'll explain how in our convo, but ask yourself how M.C. Escher's "Waterfall" illusion would work if, in REALITY, water doesn't run downhill? ITP doesn't explain why magic startles us!
American Alchemy
@AmericanALCHMY
MIT trained cognitive scientist Donald Hoffman says "embodied consciousness like ours has a probability of zero". This is a new finding discovered just weeks ago. The normal state of consciousness is not embodied. Hoffman frames the human condition as the worst possible interface. "We're like a marathon runner with weights, terrible shoes, and a backpack." We can't move a cup with intention alone. We move fingers and toes and arms, and from that narrow channel we have to scheme our way to doing anything physical.
"The normal case for consciousness in this framework is not to be embodied."
"In this mathematics, it's measure zero, probability zero."
"It dovetails with a lot of religious stories around the quote-unquote fall of man."
"To get to the moon, all I can do is move my fingers, my toes, my arms."
"It's low bandwidth and high latency."
"It's sort of like you can play the game of consciousness and move things around, but you're so restricted."
Episode dropping today.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My running joke while working out:
"I'm sweating like Donald Trump going through the Epstein Files."
or
"I'm sweating like a Gender Studies professor trying to answer the question 'what is a woman?'"
They can't, beyond "whatever someone says they are"
Which is a non-answer.
Brad Polumbo
@brad_polumbo
"What is a woman?" gone wrong...
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Sometimes, myth matters more than fact, and as historians, we have to respect the power of a great story and see it for what it is."
Good example of my distinction between empirical, mythic & literary truths: each matters as insights into deeper truths about the human condition.
Whether or not MLK's early racism experience happened matters on one level (we care about objective history) but even if fictive it still carries a deeper truth about what America was like in that era.
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/31/opinion/mlk-racism-origin-myth… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
With the return of the cover art by the great anthropologist and polymath Desmond Morris, taking its rightful place on this great work. Congrats @RichardDawkins !
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
Fifty years ago, The Selfish Gene was published. The ideas — replicators, memes, the gene's-eye view of life — have held up rather well. The 50th Anniversary Edition is out now.
Available at: www.amazon.co.uk/Selfish-Gene-50th-Anniversary/dp/0198985… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Anti-Woke, or Just Wounded?
A Typology of Two Types of Anti-Woke Intellectuals
@sbkaufman has written for Skeptic a very important article distinguishing between those who criticize ideas to correct them and those consumed by them and are settling scores.
www.skeptic.com/article/anti-woke-or-just-wounded-a-typol… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Arthur Flek; "Is it just me.….or is it getting crazier out there?"
Fate
@alltheputs
👏
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Arthur Fleck: When I was a little boy and told people I was going to be a comedian, everyone laughed at me. Well, no one's laughing now.
Francis
@FEversor49113
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The counterfactual here matters @geraldposner :
If Joe Biden or Barack Obama proposed a $250 bill with themselves on it, would conservatives or MAGA people support it?
Of course not.
That's all you need to know.
The failure to universalize a moral choice is indicting.
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
The $250 bill would break a 160-year rule, removes officials who say so, and hands criminals a more convenient currency. My take is the same whether it's Trump, Biden, or anyone who comes next.
My latest piece at Just the Facts 👇 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another one of the "missing scientists" has been found and it is as tragic (suicide) as predicable compared to the conspiratorial explanation (she was murdered because...UFO something or other). Base rate neglect: In 2024 in the US alone, there were 48,824 suicides.
No mystery.
Chris Unleashed
@LegacyProgramVP
Breaking: The remains of one of the 11 “missing scientists” — the credulous conspiracy theory that was extremely viral a few months ago — have been found.
Melissa Casias, who worked at Los Alamos National Labiratory, went missing almost a year ago on June 26, 2025.
There was also a handgun found next to the remains. There hasn’t been a ruling on the cause of death but the gun is a good indicator she took her own life…which has been the MO for half of the scientists that went missing or died.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As I have notice, most of the interesting and important changes happen on the decadal level, so it's hard to notice without the retrospective of history...
Juanita Broaddrick
@atensnut
Beautifully done. Evolution of women’s fashions.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Amusing & telling UAPers are disappointed in Avi Loeb.
They believe with 100% certainty aliens are here.
Avi says it's far less than 100% but has an open mind.
Show us the evidence & we will adjust our credence.
Avi is finally tired of hearing stories & wants actual evidence.
Skywatch Signal
@UAPWatchers
🚨What Happened to Avi Loeb? From UFO Maverick to Establishment Gatekeeper
Few scientists benefited more from the UFO renaissance than Avi Loeb lets be honest...
When he entered the scene, he was everything the disclosure movement had been waiting for. A Harvard astrophysicist that was willing to discuss extraterrestrial technology without smirking, well maybe not he does smirk a lot. A scientist prepared to challenge academic orthodoxy. A public figure who argued that objects like Oumuamua deserved serious consideration as possible technological artifacts rather than being explained away by increasingly exotic natural theories.
You all remember that right? At the time, Loeb sounded like a man willing to follow evidence wherever it led and it was encouraging.
Well I have to say, today, many of the people who once championed him (myself included) are asking whether that version of Avi Loeb still exists.
Back in the early days of the Galileo Project, Loeb frequently spoke about the possibility that humanity might discover evidence of extraterrestrial technology. He challenged conventional assumptions, questioned established narratives and repeatedly criticized the scientific community for dismissing possibilities before the evidence had been gathered.
The project itself was marketed as a revolutionary approach to the UFO 'problem.' Build observatories. Collect data. Stop relying on government disclosures and blurry military videos. Let the science speak...
That message resonated with us because it offered something the UFO field had lacked for decades and that was independence, fuck the government disclosure.
Lets just fast forward several years and the public face of the project feels totally different. Instead of discussions about extraordinary possibilities, much of Galileo's output now revolves around object classification, sensor calibration, machine learning filters, environmental contamination and false positives. The language of discovery has increasingly been replaced by the language of elimination.
The very same scientist who once challenged conventional thinking now spends much of his time explaining why anomalies are probably not anomalous. The same project that was launched to investigate the unknown increasingly appears focused on demonstrating how much of the unknown can be reduced to ordinary explanations.
While congressional investigations expanded, whistleblowers testified under oath, lawmakers pushed for records disclosure, and public interest surged, Galileo's messaging appeared to move in the opposite direction. The more attention the UFO topic received, the more cautious Loeb became, and why is that?
The Avi Loeb who captured headlines in 2021 sounded like a scientist willing to challenge the establishment, but the Avi Loeb of today sounds increasingly comfortable within it. Ask yourself why he is willing to throw VASCO under the bus with zero scientific data.
The Galileo Project was born from the promise that science would finally confront one of the biggest mysteries of our time. Years later it turns out that the biggest drive is funding. Avi is a huckster.. follow the money. Fuck you Avi... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The real reason @UAPWatchers is Avi is a real scientist who has an open mind to the possibility not only that aliens are out there somewhere, but that they've come here. But ultimately he need actual evidence, and so far there is none. Show us the bodies/craft & we will believe.
Skywatch Signal
@UAPWatchers
🚨What Happened to Avi Loeb? From UFO Maverick to Establishment Gatekeeper
Few scientists benefited more from the UFO renaissance than Avi Loeb lets be honest...
When he entered the scene, he was everything the disclosure movement had been waiting for. A Harvard astrophysicist that was willing to discuss extraterrestrial technology without smirking, well maybe not he does smirk a lot. A scientist prepared to challenge academic orthodoxy. A public figure who argued that objects like Oumuamua deserved serious consideration as possible technological artifacts rather than being explained away by increasingly exotic natural theories.
You all remember that right? At the time, Loeb sounded like a man willing to follow evidence wherever it led and it was encouraging.
Well I have to say, today, many of the people who once championed him (myself included) are asking whether that version of Avi Loeb still exists.
Back in the early days of the Galileo Project, Loeb frequently spoke about the possibility that humanity might discover evidence of extraterrestrial technology. He challenged conventional assumptions, questioned established narratives and repeatedly criticized the scientific community for dismissing possibilities before the evidence had been gathered.
The project itself was marketed as a revolutionary approach to the UFO 'problem.' Build observatories. Collect data. Stop relying on government disclosures and blurry military videos. Let the science speak...
That message resonated with us because it offered something the UFO field had lacked for decades and that was independence, fuck the government disclosure.
Lets just fast forward several years and the public face of the project feels totally different. Instead of discussions about extraordinary possibilities, much of Galileo's output now revolves around object classification, sensor calibration, machine learning filters, environmental contamination and false positives. The language of discovery has increasingly been replaced by the language of elimination.
The very same scientist who once challenged conventional thinking now spends much of his time explaining why anomalies are probably not anomalous. The same project that was launched to investigate the unknown increasingly appears focused on demonstrating how much of the unknown can be reduced to ordinary explanations.
While congressional investigations expanded, whistleblowers testified under oath, lawmakers pushed for records disclosure, and public interest surged, Galileo's messaging appeared to move in the opposite direction. The more attention the UFO topic received, the more cautious Loeb became, and why is that?
The Avi Loeb who captured headlines in 2021 sounded like a scientist willing to challenge the establishment, but the Avi Loeb of today sounds increasingly comfortable within it. Ask yourself why he is willing to throw VASCO under the bus with zero scientific data.
The Galileo Project was born from the promise that science would finally confront one of the biggest mysteries of our time. Years later it turns out that the biggest drive is funding. Avi is a huckster.. follow the money. Fuck you Avi... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The more the government releases UFO files the crazier the stories get about what is to come in the NEXT tranche of redacted documents, blurry photographs and grainy videos…
Godrules1
@GodRulesIRL
Congresswoman Lauren Boebert just said that her Private Classified UFO Briefings are far more interesting than the UFO Files that the Public are getting which Boebert calls “underwhelming”.
She said that that she is getting information that proves the Supernatural to be real.
She says that there is an Alien Hybrid Breeding Program and says that this only reminds her of the Stories mentioned in the Bible about the Nephilim where she finds this to be eerily similar.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you paste the text of my post into an AI program you will find that far from launching a deep dive into theoretical physics I just read one paper; this will tell you all you need to know about people who talk like this (they don't put it into print so you can't fact check it)
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As I said here previously, I've been working on a theory of everything. I don't plan on publishing it in peer reviewed physics journals, present it at physics conferences, or write a trade or university press book about my theory. I'll just go on podcasts & explain it here because in such a situation, how can a self-perpetuating secular priesthood of credentialed "scientists'' purport to maintain a monopoly on the production of scientific knowledge?
Let me emphasize that I am in no way opposed to specialized scientific training; I object only when an elite caste seeks to impose its canon of "high science'', with the aim of excluding a priori alternative forms of scientific production by non-members.
Quantum physics, hadron bootstrap theory, complex number theory, and chaos theory share the basic assumption that reality cannot be described in linear terms, that nonlinear—and unsolvable—equations are the only means possible to describe a complex, chaotic, and non-deterministic reality. These theories are all metacritical in the sense that they foreground themselves as metaphors rather than as "accurate" descriptions of reality.
We might say that these attempts by scientists to develop new strategies of description represent notes towards a theory of theories, of how representation—mathematical, experimental, and verbal—is inherently complex and problematizing, not a solution but part of the semiotics of investigating the universe.
Finally, postmodern science provides a powerful refutation of the authoritarianism and elitism inherent in traditional science, as well as an empirical basis for a democratic approach to scientific work. For, as Bohr noted, "a complete elucidation of one and the same object may require diverse points of view which defy a unique description''—this is quite simply a fact about the world, much as the self-proclaimed empiricists of modernist science might prefer to deny it. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As I said here previously, I've been working on a theory of everything. I don't plan on publishing it in peer reviewed physics journals, present it at physics conferences, or write a trade or university press book about my theory. I'll just go on podcasts & explain it here because in such a situation, how can a self-perpetuating secular priesthood of credentialed "scientists'' purport to maintain a monopoly on the production of scientific knowledge?
Let me emphasize that I am in no way opposed to specialized scientific training; I object only when an elite caste seeks to impose its canon of "high science'', with the aim of excluding a priori alternative forms of scientific production by non-members.
Quantum physics, hadron bootstrap theory, complex number theory, and chaos theory share the basic assumption that reality cannot be described in linear terms, that nonlinear—and unsolvable—equations are the only means possible to describe a complex, chaotic, and non-deterministic reality. These theories are all metacritical in the sense that they foreground themselves as metaphors rather than as "accurate" descriptions of reality.
We might say that these attempts by scientists to develop new strategies of description represent notes towards a theory of theories, of how representation—mathematical, experimental, and verbal—is inherently complex and problematizing, not a solution but part of the semiotics of investigating the universe.
Finally, postmodern science provides a powerful refutation of the authoritarianism and elitism inherent in traditional science, as well as an empirical basis for a democratic approach to scientific work. For, as Bohr noted, "a complete elucidation of one and the same object may require diverse points of view which defy a unique description''—this is quite simply a fact about the world, much as the self-proclaimed empiricists of modernist science might prefer to deny it. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ryan Graves says pilots see UAP ~5x/day.
Why can't these pilots, or passengers in commercial airliners with smart phones, take a focused photograph?
UAPer response to me: it's super hard to photograph UAPs.
Not so!
Just show us the equivalent of the Chinese Spy Balloon: -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The increasing in the greening of Earth, increase in crop yields (more food, less land), cleaner air/water, etc., has been known for years and yet environmentalists like Greta Thunberg not only don't take credit for this good news, they treat it like it's a threat to their cause.
Peter Clack
@PeterDClack
The Earth is greening at a rate never seen before in all recorded history, according to NASA satellite records from 1982–2023.
Global crop yields have risen 15–20% since 1960, almost entirely attributable to CO₂ fertilisation (Idso, 2013; IPCC AR6 WG1 Ch5). Famine deaths have plummeted over a time when the world's population doubled and CO₂ deserves much of the credit. We have increased CO₂ over the past century to thank for this explosion in plant life and available plant food from booming agriculture.
There's been a more than 18% increase in the global leaf area in 40 years, with the largest gains in India and China from CO₂ fertilisation. Warmer and more balmy temperatures are lengthening the growing seasons. These are features of rising levels of water vapour and cloud cover around the world. Every 100 ppm increase in CO₂ typically boosts plant growth by 25–50% in all non-water-limited conditions.
This analysis draws on 776 studies from 1993–2019, showing an ideal average CO₂ level of 550 ppm delivers a 38% increase in global biomass.
It's an astonishing windfall for life on earth from CO₂, a trace gas at 420 ppm (or 0.04%). It also has a secondary benefit for life by contributing to baseline levels of warmth around the planet, along with water vapour and other trace gases with similar properties, like methane (approx. 1.9 ppm or 0.00019%).
However, water vapour and cloud cover are the mainstays of rainfall and the entire hydrologic cycle, returning water as precipitation to rivers, lakes, and oceans (where 78% of rain ends up).
These are the reasons why commercial greenhouses pump CO₂ to 1,000–1,500 ppm deliberately. It ensures that crop yields jump by 20–70% depending on the crop. If 1000 ppm is good for tomatoes, why is 420 ppm an 'emergency' for the planet?
The science says 600–1,000 ppm of CO₂ plus 1–2°C extra warming hits the sweet spot for all terrestrial and marine life, including human civilisation. We should not be waging war on a trace gas that makes the planet greener.
Higher CO₂ is a net benefit to life on Earth. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sure, but AI is about to put everyone out of work and possibly cause the extinction of civilization.
Katie Miller
@KatieMiller
ChatGPT says Charlie Kirk wasn’t assassinated.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How do you know that they KNEW the truth of Jesus’s resurrection? They BELIEVED they knew the truth is the most you can say.
Ready For The Kingdom 🩸
@ARavenbite
Again, you're conflating what groups of people BELIEVE to be true vs what a group of eyewitnesses KNEW to be true
You cannot seriously believe this is comparable -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Multiple polls of religious people consistently find that almost no one would question their religion if aliens were discovered. They believe God can create as many life forms as desired anywhere.
This is just a handwaving line used to explain a lack of evidence.
The General
@GeneralMCNews
BREAKING: Hollywood director Steven Spielberg says the truth about UFOs will "dislocate society" and cause humans to question their religions.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Reality is that which, when you stop believing it, doesn’t go away.” -Philip K Dick
Maxirex
@Maxirex26
That line about not wanting to believe in things that require belief to be true is perfectly stated. If something is an empirical fact, it shouldn't need a leap of faith to function.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hundreds of millions of people died in the 20th century because Marxists believed Communism is true, and many Marxists terrorists went to their deaths in the name of this ideology they truly believed in. None of this makes Communism true. It is, in fact, false.
Ready For The Kingdom 🩸
@ARavenbite
Because they're under a temporary spiritual blindness per Romans 11
Why would people endure horrible deaths and allow their lives to effectively be ruined for what they knew was a lie? Something happened -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @DaveLowedown
2 billion Muslims believe in their religion as strongly as you believe Christianity. Are they all hard-hearted or do you think it possible they’re right and you’re wrong? How is an outsider to know which faith is the correct one? Or is that the wrong question?
Dave Lowe
@DaveLowedown
the reason Jews don't believe is the same reason any person denies something that's plainly obvious (like flat-earthers denying the earth is round) - Hard-heartedness. The heart is the will & many people simply ignore or deny facts/evidence that contradicts their desired reality
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @candle84640
They SAID they saw Jesus after death. But post-death apparitions of lost loved ones are not at all uncommon. Lots of people say they saw Elvis after he died. So what?
Get saved by Jesus ✝️
@iamtom799
They first Christians were willing to be killed for having SEEN Jesus resurrected, not for a mere belief.
Can you see the difference? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Amen brother! And I loved your book and enjoyed our convo!
Kent Heckenlively
@KentHecken
I know I’m probably going to get into a lot of trouble for saying this as the author of a UFO book, but I LIKE the sharp questions of Michael Shermer. Extraordinary claims do require extraordinary proof!
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sure! I would gladly go to a SCIF or Area 51, or S4 or wherever to see the aliens and/or spaceships! Make it so Number One
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why would 19 Muslims on 9/11 go to their deaths if what they said they believe were not true about Islam, Muhammad, 72 virgins? Why would 39 members of Heavens Gate group die by suicide if it were not true that TELAH (The Evolutionary Level Above Humans) were not true?
Ready For The Kingdom 🩸
@ARavenbite
Because they're under a temporary spiritual blindness per Romans 11
Why would people endure horrible deaths and allow their lives to effectively be ruined for what they knew was a lie? Something happened -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good example of confusing religious truths (I believe Jesus was resurrected & died for our sins) & empirical truths (I insist that the resurrection literally happened so you should believe too). If accepting Jesus helps him, fine (I once believed so I understand) but it doesn't do anything for me.
Plus: I don't want to believe in things that have to be believed in to be true.
And: If the resurrection literally happened & it can be proved, then why don't Jews believe it? They believe in the same God, read the same Holy Book (at least the Old Testament) & they even believe in the Messiah. They just don't think the carpenter from Nazareth was it. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Grok is a skeptic. Why? Because it can think critically and does't believe things that must be believed in to be true.
Grok
@grok
jonwillbanks Buchanan was in the US Army’s declassified Stargate remote viewing program for ~8 years as a viewer and trainer at Fort Meade with high clearances. That part checks out.
His claims of flying UFOs, locating four active alien bases, witnessing aliens working with humans, psychically influencing leaders like Saddam/Gorbachev, or interacting with five alien races are uncorroborated personal assertions from recent podcasts. They go far beyond the program’s documented scope and have zero independent evidence.
Remote viewing was never scientifically validated. In court, testimony based on it for these extraordinary claims would be dismissed as inadmissible speculation—no evidentiary value whatsoever. Only his program service could be stated as fact.
Skepticism is appropriate. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
And here @AlchemyAmerican is my $1000 bet with Avi Loeb on aliens. Happy to make the same bet (or even more if you like) with you, but we'd need a different platform to hold the money until the criteria is settled.
avi-loeb.medium.com/an-extraterrestrial-wager-b25524555794 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hi Jesse, sure, fly me to your studio and let's talk aliens! Email me at mshermer@skeptic.com
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
You are still invited, Michael! I’d love to have you! I just suck with twitter DMs (sorry!) and don’t do zoom interviews which I know was the preference. Can I fly you out? :)
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Let's see, it could be super-advanced alien technology enabling aircraft to instantaneously change direction without killing the "non-human intelligence biologics" inside, or...
"it's just the camera stopping tracking"
What's more likely?
Mick West
@MickWest
Corbell is understandably excited about the possibility of some new physics being demonstrated in the new UFO videos. However, extensive analysis by both Metabunk and the Pentagon (independently) has concluded that it's just the camera stopping tracking.
www.dvidshub.net/video/1007707/dow-uap-pr051-syrian-uap-i…
Jeremy Kenyon Lockyer Corbell
@JeremyCorbell
AWESOME to see @MvonRen help us understand the significance of this military-filmed UAP video demonstrating INSTANTANEOUS ACCELERATION. Which warps our understanding of known physics. This will inspire physicists around the world to take a closer look at the UFO puzzle.
@G_Knapp and I released this video into the wild via our journalism on 3 FEB - three months and nineteen days before the @WhiteHouse and @DeptofWar confirmed it.
Pay attention 🛸🐺⏰
SLEEPING DOG | geni.us/SleepingDog
Marik vR
@MvonRen
INSTANTANEOUS ACCELERATION:
Mick West and Metabunk flatly refuse to engage with the *evidence* that the Syria UAP accelerated instantaneously.
What they *never* address:
The object’s trajectory change shows the moment camera motion changes - *AFTER* it begins its acceleration. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I would gladly bet @AlchemyAmerican about aliens but after inviting me on his show he’s gone silent on me and refuses to reply after repeated responses by me, so I presume he’s not interested in talking to a UFO skeptic. Happy to talk and bet with Jesse @PostDisclosure
Post Disclosure World
@PostDisclosure
Michael, why not bet Jesse? He made a handsome bet with MicK West.
If you're so sure he's wrong about UFOs, why not take the same bet that he made with Mick West.
Seems like easy money. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You may be right @SwipeWright but the last time I communicated privately with @ScienceBasedMed ‘s Steve Novella a year ago it was clear he believes Gender Affirming Care is supported by evidence & that I’m echoing right-wing talking points, detransitioning is extremely rare, most dysphoria kids are helped by transitioning & sex is on a spectrum (he says the gamete definition of eggs & sperm is outdated & revised by new science).
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
I don't know. There is a lot of willful ignorance going on here, especially for people who claim to espouse "science-based medicine." It's not hard to simply recognize and acknowledge that every major systematic evidence review has shown that the evidence of benefit is extremely weak, while the long list of known risks and permanent harms are extensive.
For the @ScienceBasedMed people, this is less an issue of being factually incorrect and more one of cowardice. They abandoned their principles because they know their audience would rebel against them and accuse them of transphobia, bigotry, and (gasp!) being "right-wing."
All the evidence is out there for them to observe if they weren't too cowardly to look at it objectively and update their worldview accordingly.
Claiming ignorance may have been somewhat justified a decade ago, but not in 2026. The Science-Based Medicine people aren't stupid. And they can no longer claim ignorance. The simplest explanation is that they're cowards.
And I get it. Social ostracism is a uniquely unpleasant experience, to say the least. We're a social species, and remaining on good terms with those in your tribe is a massively adaptive. Not too long ago in our species' past, social exclusion meant death. In some societies, it still can.
I lost probably 90% of my friends when I started speaking out against pediatric "gender-affirming care" and sex spectrum pseudoscience. It was excruciatingly painful. That will likely happen to the Science-Based Medicine folks if they ever speak out against it. It could also financially ruin them. They know this.
I wish this were mostly about "factual error," because then it would be trivially easy to disabuse people of the belief that "gender-affirming care" is medically necessary and life-saving.
They're cowards. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
👌😎
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
Many thanks for the coverage, @michaelshermer: www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/gad-saad-when-empath…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @AlchemyAmerican & fellow alien believers: do you not have an ounce of skepticism, an iota of BS detection to know when someone is obviously making stuff up? None of this is true save he says it’s so. Thank Zeus you do not work in criminal justice in which every inmate says they’re innocent & you’d believe them! Are you unaware that people just make things up?
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
🔴BREAKING🔴: A highly decorated US Army intelligence reveals that he personally operated and flew a UFO. He also names the locations of four currently-functional alien bases on Earth and claims he personally witnessed an alien being at a government facility working side by side with humans. Finally, he says he was regularly tasked with psychically “remote influencing” foreign leaders at the highest level (i.e. Saddam Hussein, Mikhail Gorbachev).
Lyn Buchanan carried one of the highest security clearances ever issued across every branch of the US government. He was recruited personally into the classified Stargate remote viewing program: the fully funded, now declassified US government operation that ran for over two decades. He is the inspiration for George Clooney’s character, Lynn Cassidy, in the movie “The Men Who Stared at Goats”.
In this new interview, and on the eve of Presidential disclosures, he goes farther than he ever has before revealing absolutely mind-blowing new career details.
From a cubicle at Fort Meade, Buchanan meddled in the heads of world leaders. He saw Chernobyl three days before it happened and said it wasn’t actually an accident (fissionable material went missing during the event).
The CIA tasked him with remote viewing everything from religious figures to extraterrestrials on various planets. Buchanan now admits he’s interacted with 5 alien races across his career. He also says he is high conviction that manned space missions continued past the Apollo program.
Full conversation below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Astonishing. So pilots are seeing UAPs 5x a day and yet not ONE of them has managed to grab a clear and unmistakeable photograph. Why is that? Do our jets need a camera upgrade to the quality of what all the rest of us have in our phones and cameras?!
UFO/UAP News
@uap_news
🚨 "There are 10,000 more UAP videos yet to be released." 🚨
Former F-18 pilot Ryan Graves just dropped a bombshell. Military pilots are reporting UAPs nearly 5 times a day, we're talking metallic spheres zipping past jets, stopping dead in midair, and accelerating like they're shot out of a gun.
Thanks to new declassifications through the "PURSUE system," the floodgates are finally opening. This isn’t just sci-fi or a fringe conspiracy anymore; it’s a critical aviation safety issue that demands real transparency.
The data is coming. Are we ready for what's operating in our skies?
Full Interview here:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In 2020 the UC Board of Regents directed by Gov. Gavin Newsom scrapped the SAT/ACT requirement because they exacerbate “the inequities for underrepresented students.” Result:
“for three consecutive years, 20-30% of UC Berkeley first-semester calculus students displayed severe preparation deficits.”
"a UC San Diego report found 1 in 8 of freshmen had math skills below high-school level, a 30-fold increase since 2020. Incredibly, one in 12 lacked middle-school math skills"
But does this deficit help minorities?
No! It has the opposite effect by placing them in classes for which they are unprepared.
Return to merit and drop DEI nonsense.
www.wsj.com/opinion/university-of-california-sat-act-math… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Almost everyone agrees we need criminal justice reform (retributive justice vs. restorative justice is an old debate) but what should we do, exactly? My podcast guest, economist Jennifer Doleac, applies cost-benefit data to answer the biggest questions:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/can-science-fix-crim… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Two more author spam scam emails, in one day! I wonder what AI program they use to generate the letters? The second one forgot to fill in the blank of the name of my book! "I recently came across , and it immediately stood out to me."
, is apparently the title of my new book. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Thanks for the music and memories Dr. Demento (Barry Hansen) who began hosting The Dr. Demento Show in October 1970 on KPPC Pasadena, CA, which I listened to every Sunday night eagerly awaiting his Top 10 demented songs. My Top 10:
Pico and Sepulveda
Fish Heads
Spam
Shaving Cream
The Lumberjack Song
Always Look On The Bright Side Of Life
Boobs A Lot
Springtime For Hitler
Lydia, the Tattooed Lady
Hooray for Captain Spaulding
parade.com/news/iconic-radio-dj-makes-major-announcement-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Most proponents of Gender Affirming Care (e.g., @ScienceBasedMed ) are not evil people. They are good people who mistakenly believe transitioning teenagers to the opposite sex will help their dysphoria.
They are mistaken.
So the deepest cause of this medical malpractice is not ideology but factual error; they're not immoral so much as mistaken.
It will go down in history as the equivalent of medieval witch hunts in which inquisitors believed they were saving peoples' souls by burning them to death.
Witch hunters were wrong.
Gender Affirming Care proponents are wrong.
Course correct now and stop destroying the lives of minors, and especially end this assault on women's rights to sports and spaces by enabling men to believe they are women. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"I was too young to vote, rent a car, sign legal contracts, or understand motherhood in any meaningful way, but I was somehow considered capable of consenting to irreversible bodily mutilation."
She had a double mastectomy at age 14. Barbaric & tragic:
www.independentwomen.com/2026/05/26/at-14-i-endured-gende… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yet another detransitioner tells her story of being sexually abused as a child so when she reached puberty was uncomfortable in her body. But instead of getting her help, delusional trans ideologues who think people can change sex butchered her body:
www.independentwomen.com/2026/05/26/at-14-i-endured-gende… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The White House has at long last revealed the true nature of the aliens, namely that they're aliens...and they don't belong here. So now we know what UFOs are for...
The White House
@WhiteHouse
They walk among us.
aliens.govThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The truth about aliens will be released by POTUS right after he releases the JFK assassination files that prove a conspiracy.
Wait, he already did that and there is STILL no evidence of a second shooter? LHO acted alone?
O-kay, perhaps there are no aliens here.
If so, show us!
Interstellar
@InterstellarUAP
"We will release the truth about extraterrestrials" 👽
- President Donald J Trump 🇺🇸 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Interesting and thoughtful review of Louis Theroux's documentary "Inside the Manosphere"
I have yet to understand, however, what the appeal is of these manly men FOR THEIR FOLLOWERS? They're obviously using teenage boys, but what's in it for the boys?
quillette.com/2026/05/28/manosfear-louis-theroux-manosphe… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Finished @valleeniac book. Astonishing how revered he is in UFO circles but he says Majestic 12 is a fake, Bob Lazar is untrustworthy, Roswell is a myth, Rendlesham has a psych explanation, UMMO Affair is a hoax, Travis Walton faked his abduction, etc. What’s left? Not much!
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is the dramatic collapse in U.S. student reading scores due to mass immigration?
It's a testable hypothesis & @jean_twenge shows:
<18 immigration 2015-2024 = 3.37/100 vs. 4.36/100.
So, no.
Foreign born adults (so their kids test lower)?
Foreign-born adults: 16.47% in 2015 vs. 17.61% in 2024.
So, no.
Not the pandemic as decline started before.
Crappy education system?
No, scores > 1990-2013.
Social media? Maybe. Read on:
open.substack.com/pub/jeanmtwenge/p/is-immigration-behind… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In case the @WSJ OpEd is behind a paywall, here is @SwipeWright commentary on journal category Peer Review (with @SkepResCenter 's Kevin McCaffree) as a solution to a long problem with peer-reviewed journals.
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Serious efforts to restore trust in social science are underway.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Peer Review
Important new journal category edited by @SwipeWright & @SkepResCenter 's Kevin McCaffree as a solution to a long problem with peer-reviewed journals.
No, science & peer review are not "broken".
Reforming the system from within is a solution.
www.wsj.com/opinion/a-way-to-challenge-the-groupthink-of-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cycling is a fun fabulous beautiful elegant and efficient non/contact sport…unless you make contact with the road…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“the Pentagon didn’t actually have an official UFO program called AATIP and Elizondo was not its director.”
Other than that @MiddleOfMayhem what’s the problem with Elizondo’s claims?
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Elizondo is lying here and unless he suffers from acute amnesia, he knows that he's lying.
He posted this because he knows 99% of the media won't dig into it and his lie will go unchallenged.
I exposed this specific lie years ago: nypost.com/2023/03/21/ufo-believing-pentagon-bosses-misse… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“panic is a terrible policy adviser.”
Yup.
But unlike the panic over Y2K, which ended immediately after nothing happened when 1999 became 2000, climate panic never ends. “Just you wait!” And “it’s coming soon!” works as long as no one insists on falsifiable predictions.
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
An Inconvenient Truth for climate alarmists:
Al Gore’s dramatic climate warnings shaped a generation — but 20 years later, the data tell a very different story.
Climate-related deaths are down 97% over the past century, polar bears more than doubled since the 1960s, and global burned area has decreased by more than 25% over the past quarter century.
That's hardly a success of climate policy though: fossil fuels still provide 81% of world energy, emissions keep rising, and $16 trillion+ spent on green policies since Gore's movie came out hasn’t changed the trajectory.
A good reminder that panic is a terrible policy adviser.
www.newsweek.com/data-vs-drama-the-20-year-legacy-of-al-g… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Some photos from the HowTheLightGetsIn festival in Hay-on-Wye
Standing outside the entrance; venue for my Champagne and Cake event for my book A Billion Years of Sex Differences; setting up for an interview with the great @michaelshermer; crowd for the debate I participated in. -
Michael Shermer reposted
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
My recent chat with the great @michaelshermer on his podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=aGQnzsRe2DE
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe
Golden Gate -
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Happy Memorial Day!
Now, for some interesting data: compared to non-parents, Americans who are parents consistently support increased spending on the military, as well as on military veteran benefits, and this effect occurs across political orientations. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Isn’t this racist and ageist and sexist @ekim1_1?
ekim
@ekim1_1
At the end of the day, you are white old straight man
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI, here is my analysis of the UAP videos, UFO photos, and why I think the entire movement is a type of New Age religion—vastly superior ,nearly omniscient & omnipotent celestial beings who know we're here, visit us, warn us, & care about us:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re-upping the @TheFP profile/interview on UFOs, UAPs & how to think about them critically and skeptically (the burden of proof is on the believers, not the skeptics and scientists):
www.thefp.com/p/what-does-americas-biggest-skeptic?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reading Jacques Vallee. He is always championed by UFO believers as their patron saint of alien searchers, but in fact he often appears as skeptical as I am, and takes to task the gullible rubes in the movement that fall for pictures of toy saucers on a string or tossed hubcaps
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Whatever George Floyd was (and that is many things to many different people and activist groups and political parties), he was not a model citizen, much less a civil rights champion on par with Martin Luther King Jr. (remember the posters of the 2 of them?)
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
A majority (60%) of "very liberals" agree that "George Floyd was a model citizen"; no other political group in America does.
(See chart below). -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Scenes from rooftop bar Heathrow, on the the hottest day ever recorded for a May 25, still warm and light after 9pm
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I am pleased to announce that the audio edition is now out from Blackstone Audio:
Truth
By Michael Shermer
Narrated by Michael Shermer
Listen on Audible:
www.audible.com/pd/B0GQJVHCG5?source_code=ASSORAP05111600… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe
English country side driving the twisty narrow roads, 2 lanes but so narrow cars can’t get past each other and must find periodic turnouts. Crazy. These must have been horse trails at one point, maybe single track walking trails and one day past animal trails. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“somewhere, YET AGAIN, a small innocent child has just lost their party balloon”
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I concur, and @adamdkirsch is a great writer and his forthcoming book on the topic is a must-read.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Truth Is Still Out There - Excellent article by Adam Kirsch in The Atlantic, echoing points that skeptic (and Skeptic editor) @michaelshermer has been making for decades. www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/06/government-ufo-consp…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
There’s nothing quite like a thousand-year old English church, here in Weobley where we’re staying for the How the Light Gets In festival. I presume some dude named Weobley back in the day ran this quaint village…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
There’s nothing quite like a thousand-year old English church, here in Weobley where we’re staying for the How the Light Gets In festival. I presume some dude named Weobley back in the day ran this quaint village…
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Most Americans don't want children to be given puberty blockers when they "feel like another gender."
The group most likely to endorse doing so (~39%) are liberal women without children.
See chart below.
Data comes from: research.skeptic.com/2024-presidential-election-study/
Christina Buttons
@buttonslives
Advocates for school-based health centers are pushing to make puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones available through clinics located on K–12 school campuses.
In states with “mature minor” doctrines, that model could open the door for students to obtain these drugs without parental knowledge.
In Seattle, SBHC providers already prescribe birth control to suppress menstruation for girls who identify as transgender. They currently refer youth to gender clinics, but seek to prescribe puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones on campus.
Hormonal birth control is already a routine service at many SBHCs.
California partners with the California School-Based Health Alliance, which seeks to create “truly affirming and equitable spaces where LGBTQIA+ youth can thrive.” Gender-related drugs do not appear to be part of California’s SBHC model... yet.
Read my latest investigation for @CityJournal:
www.city-journal.org/article/california-youth-mental-heal… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Again, to sound like a broken record…
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
Literally an actual balloon
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Our survey results suggest that Black GenZ Americans support political violence at higher rates than all other (measured) race/age groups.
These data come from the American Political Perspectives Survey (APPS) collected from August 3, 2025, to September 26, 2025, with 3,000 American adults who speak English. All respondents needed to pass (1) attention checks, (2) a duplication check, (3) time-to-completion checks, (4) fraud and (5) bot-identification checks. For more information, see: research.skeptic.com/american-political-perspectives-survey/
NBC10 Boston
@NBC10Boston
NBC News Capitol Hill Correspondent Julie Tsirkin was preparing to report from the White House when multiple shots could be heard being fired nearby.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Scenes from How the Light Gets In, Hay on Wye, Wales. Hot for England, normal for Cali.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Birds, not aliens, not Russian or Chinese tech a century more advanced than us. Birds.
Before you say something is out of this world first make sure that it’s not in this world.
Birds are part of this world.
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
At :57 they show a flock of birds flying.
They infer Earth is being invaded by alien space monsters and as proof they show birds.
This is monumentally stupid. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another balloon, not an alien…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If there’s classified intel meant to cover up something the military did from the tax payers it’s less likely to be aliens and more likely to be that we spent half a million dollars shooting down a balloon.
Steven Greenstreet
@MiddleOfMayhem
🚨EXCLUSIVE: New "UFO" video is actually "a Boy Scouts balloon".
Sean Kirkpatrick, a senior Pentagon director at the time, has confirmed to me via email that this video shows the military blasting the small balloon with a $500,000 missile.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The God Debate with Rowan Williams in a big tent in Wales!
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
One of the most persistent false beliefs in American culture is that the Floyd/BLM riots were incredibly peaceful, causing little damage to life and property.
In fact, the Floyd/BLM riots were the most destructive riots in American history, leading insurance agencies to designate them as a "catastrophe event."
(See first chart below showing that misinformation about the Floyd/BLM riots is positively correlated with trust in journalists.)
(See second chart below showing that misinformation about the Floyd/BLM riots is associated with left-leaning political beleifs.)
TheBlaze
@theblaze
Sunny Hostin: “There was very limited destruction of property and violence during the BLM uprising.”
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dr. Who was here
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
No scrap value
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cambridge Architecture is beyond belief beautiful…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
UK with Skeptic editor and Skeptics Society CSO and podcast producer Alexander…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Daily Awe SBA-SFO
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Boebert told fellow Republicans at a dinner … that she believes humanity is ‘in the last of the last days’ with the ‘second coming of Jesus’ approaching.”
Obviously, if you believe we’re in the “last days,” that will strongly reduce your incentive to care about long-term environmental problems, or even the dangers of war.”
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excellent analysis of UAP as 1 of 3 possibilities:
1. Natural
2. Alien
3. Demons
“The belief that UAPs are demonic forces is nutty, but not in itself especially dangerous. The problem is that supernaturalist beliefs about UAPs stem from broader beliefs about a demon-haunted world (to invoke Carl Sagan’s phrase).
For evangelicals such as Boebert, demonizing one’s opponents carries beliefs about literal demons. As Kelsey Vlamis reported for Business Insider in 2023, “Boebert spoke at an event where she discussed “standing up to demons” including a ‘speaker of the House.'”
coloradotimesrecorder.com/2026/05/lauren-boeberts-demon-h… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excellent analysis of UAP as 1 of 3 possibilities:
1. Natural
2. Alien
3. Demons
“The belief that UAPs are demonic forces is nutty, but not in itself especially dangerous. The problem is that supernaturalist beliefs about UAPs stem from broader beliefs about a demon-haunted world (to invoke Carl Sagan’s phrase).
For evangelicals such as Boebert, demonizing one’s opponents carries beliefs about literal demons. As Kelsey Vlamis reported for Business Insider in 2023, “Boebert spoke at an event where she discussed “standing up to demons” including a ‘speaker of the House.'”
coloradotimesrecorder.com/2026/05/lauren-boeberts-demon-h… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I might suggest this book for Steven Rosenbaum to read if he needs help in determining the actual future of truth…
Thomas Chatterton Williams
@thomaschattwill
Make it stop
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The other price @charlesmurray is the counterfactual: what about the thousands of entrepreneurs who got VC $ and went bankrupt or just survive, and the tens of thousands who pitch VCs for $ and are turned downed. Everyone focuses on a few billionaire successes ignoring the rest.
Charles Murray
@charlesmurray
Three men—Steve Jobs, Jeff Bezos, and Elon Musk—have made my life immeasurably better. And yet they’re the bad guys. Are there billionaires who do not deserve their wealth? Sure. That’s a small price to pay for those three and the many other billionaires who enrich our lives on a less lavish scale.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In my own classification system to explain UAP sightings, I distill them into 3 hypotheses:
1. Ordinary Terrestrial (balloons, camera or lens effects, visual illusions, etc.)
2. Extraordinary Terrestrial (Russian or Chinese spy planes or drones capable of feats of physics and aerodynamics unheard of in the U.S.)
3. Extraordinary Extraterrestrial (alien intelligence)
Let’s consider each of these hypotheses and see which one has the highest credence:
www.skeptic.com/article/why-uaps-now-national-conversation/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes, because the greatest discovery in human history, the discovery of extraterrestrials, will be made by a Hollywood film producer and not a scientist or politician, announced on a comedy late night talk show.
UAP James
@UAPJames
Steven Spielberg: “I believe the cosmos is teeming with life… Is that life currently interacting with us?”
“When I made Close Encounters I thought, ‘Wouldn’t it be great if this could come true?’ With everything that’s happened from 1977 til today, I can now make Disclosure Day and say — ‘Isn’t it going to be wonderful when people realize after seeing this movie that everything is true, and has been true?’”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI:
My convo with Neil deGrasse Tyson on UFOs, Government Files, and the Physics of Alien Claims
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/neil-degrasse-tyson-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Listening to UFOlogists debating the types of aliens on Earth is like listening to medieval theologians debating transubstantiation vs. consubstantiation:
How the physical & spiritual presence of Christ manifests in the bread & wine during communion.
Transubstantiation: bread & wine literally transforms into body & blood of Christ.
Consubstantiation: Christ is present alongside the bread & wine.
Sure.
Alex Jones
@RealAlexJones
Fox News Airs Report That 4 Different Alien Species Are Being Kept At US Military Bases!
⬇️WATCH ALEX JONES LIVE NOW⬇️
x.com/i/broadcasts/1OxwblrygqoJBThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Talking with @neiltyson on UFOs, ETIs, UAPs, SETI, and other acronyms on all things alien … www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/neil-degrasse-tyson-…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To my critics:
Ok, sure, there could be evidence for aliens (disclosure) any day now. But I've been hearing this for 40 years. That it hasn't happened leads me to think it will never happen, but I'm happy to be proven wrong. Just show us the aliens/spaceships and we will believe!
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
UFOs/UAPs is a new age religion. There will never be proof, any more than you can prove religious beliefs like the virgin birth, the resurrection, or the trinity.
Here again is my Scientific American column explaining as much in October, 2017: -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The best histories of the idea of extraterrestrial and celestial beings as gods, and belief they exist as a form of religion ,are by historian of science Steven J. Dick, who is also on Avi Loeb's Galileo Project team with me and many others.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my 2006 article "Deities for Atheists" reviewing George Basalla's book "Civilized Life in the Universe: Scientists on Intelligent Extraterrestrials," showing that belief celestial beings are like gods is an ancient one dating back to Aristotle:
michaelshermer.com/articles/deities-for-atheists/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
UFOs/UAPs is a new age religion. There will never be proof, any more than you can prove religious beliefs like the virgin birth, the resurrection, or the trinity.
Here again is my Scientific American column explaining as much in October, 2017: -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To the UFO/UAP believers heaping hate on Avi for solving this riddle, remember that you should not believe in things that have to be believed in to be true.
Also read science fiction author Philip K. Dick:
"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away."
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More from Avi Loeb on the likelihood that flashes of blue light in moon's night sky (Apollo 12, 17), flashes of light Buzz Aldrin saw inside Apollo 11, & flashes of light that appeared on Palomar Observatory long-exposure film were cosmic rays not aliens.
avi-loeb.medium.com/the-difference-between-scientific-res… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
More from Avi Loeb on the likelihood that flashes of blue light in moon's night sky (Apollo 12, 17), flashes of light Buzz Aldrin saw inside Apollo 11, & flashes of light that appeared on Palomar Observatory long-exposure film were cosmic rays not aliens.
avi-loeb.medium.com/the-difference-between-scientific-res… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
According to FIRE, Gen Z is 10 times more accepting of using violence to prevent speech than Baby Boomers; 43% of Gen Z survey participants refused to endorse the view that violence against speakers is never acceptable.
@PamelaParesky explains the inanity of NYU students wanting to cancel @JonHaidt for saying their generation is more likely to do so.
www.realcleareducation.com/articles/2026/05/17/reports_of… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here's another idea @geraldposner (one with which I know you agree): Just don't allow males in female sports. What a concept!
Whoever thought after Title IX and a century of women fighting for their rights in sports and society more broadly, it would come to this inanity?
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
Remember when schools started handing out “participation trophies” so no kid felt bad?
That was bad.
This is worse.
California’s governing body for high school competitions now gives **duplicate gold medals** to girls who finish behind male athletes who compete in all female events.
This weekend after a male athlete dominated the girls’ high jump, long jump & triple jump — officials required co-champion podiums and extra golds for the girls right behind.
This is NOT a fix for the problem of men in female only sports. It is a fake “solution” that erases fair competition and tells girls their effort only merits a consolation prize.
#savewomenssports -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Spot on Grok!
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @joshua_p_jung You're thinking of the tennis shoe on the ledge NDE story. Here is my analysis in Heavens on Earth:
The most famous NDE happened in 1984 when a migrant worker named Maria was hospitalized in Seattle after a heart attack. There in the ICU she suffered another cardiac arrest. After being resuscitated she reported that she floated out of her body up to the ceiling from where she could observe medical personnel working on her. Most remarkably, she says she then journeyed outside the hospital room where she saw a tennis shoe on the ledge of the third floor window. Her ICU social worker, a woman named Kimberly Clark, says she went up to the third floor and found a shoe on a window ledge: “The only way she could have had such a perspective was if she had been floating right outside and at very close range to the tennis shoe. I retrieved the shoe and brought it back to Maria; it was very concrete evidence to me.”
First, we have only the word of Maria and her social worker that it happened at all, and as the investigative journalist Gideon Lichfield notes when he tried to chase down the story for an article in The Atlantic on “The Science of Near-Death Experiences,” he concluded that the story is “thin on the evidential side” and that when he tried to verify the account, “A few years after being treated, Maria disappeared, and nobody was able to track her down to further confirm her story.”
Because the “tennis shoe” tale has taken on iconic status in NDE circles, there is now an ongoing experiment by Sam Parnia and others in rooms located in 15 different hospitals in the U.S., UK, and Austria where cardiac-arrest patients will likely undergo resuscitation efforts. They placed images high on a shelf facing the ceiling so that if an OBE occurs during an NDE and the patient is “up” by the ceiling looking down, they should be able to see the image and later report what it is. So far the researchers have recorded a total of 2,060 cardiac arrests, 330 survivors, 140 interviewees, 9 remembered NDEs, and only 1 OBE, the patient of which said he floated up to a corner of the room where he watched the staff try to resuscitate him. Parnia and his colleagues concluded that the details of his description were eerily accurate. Eerily accurate of what? Not the description of the image on a shelf, because there was none in this particular room at the time. In fact, the description was of the doctors working on him. But most of us have seen television shows and movies depicting doctors using a defibrillator to start someone’s heart after cardiac arrest, so any description even remotely close is going to sound “eerie” to those who want NDEs to be real.
Joshua Jung
@joshua_p_jung
What evidence would convince you? For example the woman with the NDE who floated above the hospital and accurately described an object on a window ledge several stories above her bed while she was out cold is good evidence to me.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
According to physicist Dr. Eric Davis there are 4 types of aliens here on Earth. Grays, Nordics, Insectoids, Reptilians. All humanoid. Do you believe him?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why the academia shifted its telos from truth (veritas) to "speaking truth to power," which has nothing to do with truth & everything to do with power.
They have embraced Marxist praxis:
"The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point, however, is to change it."
open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/speaking-tru… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @david_shane
I would give the afterlife a probability percentage of 0.01% likelihood.
I am happy to be proven wrong (assuming there's not a bad place where I end up instead of an eternal bliss of some sort)
David Shane
@david_shane
Well, I mean.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @matthewtanous
Neither the dead nor Christ were raised
You are still in your sins so apologize to those to whom you have sinned instead of offloading it onto Christ
Have hope in this life
Whether or not there is a hereafter, we live in the here and now
Make the most of it
Matthew Tanous
@MatthewTanous
I love when skeptics manage to write voluminous articles that are easily refuted by a small passage in Scripture.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cosmic rays also explain Aldrin’s flashes of light he saw inside Apollo 11 spacecraft & Palomar Observatory mysterious images on long-exposure film.
Again, natural phenomena, not alien.
Before you say something is out of this world check worldly phenom.
medium.com/@avi-loeb/we-should-not-mistake-cosmic-rays-fo… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Avi Loeb solves the UFO Files mystery of lights in the moon night sky on Apollo 12 & 17: cosmic rays, not aliens.
medium.com/@avi-loeb/we-should-not-mistake-cosmic-rays-fo… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Talking with @neiltyson on UFOs, ETIs, UAPs, SETI, and other acronyms on all things alien, about his new book Take Me To Your Leader…
www.skeptic.com/email/cdd7434b-bdf6-4e2a-b7e0-adf2da4acea2/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI, the dedicatee of Truth is none other than...
shop.skeptic.com/products/truth-autographed-michael-shermer -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why the resurrection of Jesus is a mythological or literary truth whose meaning is symbolic: starting over, being born again, forgiveness, redemption, etc.
To treat it as an empirical truth misses the point of the story, I argue here:
shop.skeptic.com/products/truth-autographed-michael-shermer -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another tool in our kit for determining what is true is “signal detection theory,” a method for deciding what to do, or how to act, in the face of uncertainty. Picture a 2x2 matrix of four cells, numbers 1 and 2 on the top and 3 and 4 on the bottom.
Medical cure claims associated with this or that medicinal plant or alternative treatment modality typically include only testimonials and anecdotes from Cell 1 (people who tried it and got better) and exclude cases from the other cells — for example, Cell 2, where treated patients were not cured, or Cell 3, where patients who weren’t treated (or were treated with some other modality) got better. Cell 4 would be patients who weren’t treated and didn’t get better.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has devoted his life to highlighting Cell 1 anecdotes (vaccines cause autism, Tylenol causes autism, environmental toxins cause autism), ignoring all the exceptions to his claim (vaccinated children who do not get autism, pregnant mothers who take Tylenol whose children are fine, toxic pollutants that have no discernable effects on childhood development).
Life is a series of signal detection problems that include, in the jargon of the theory, “hits,” “misses,” “false alarms,” and “correct rejections.” Criminal justice is a signal detection problem. The defendant is guilty and the jury convicts (hit); the defendant is guilty and the jury acquits (miss); the defendant is innocent and the jury convicts (false alarm); the defendant is innocent and the jury acquits (correct rejection).
The best way to respond to the COVID-19 pandemic was as a signal detection problem we can examine through the 2x2 grid: The disease is extremely deadly and we mandate masks and vaccines and close the economy and save lives (hit); the disease is extremely deadly and we carry on business as usual (miss); the disease is no more deadly than the flu and we mandate masks and vaccines and close the economy (false alarm); the disease is no more deadly than the flu and we carry on business as usual (correct rejection).
www.bostonglobe.com/2026/04/29/opinion/truth-trump-transg… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Cultural Relativism: A Parasitic Idea
Short clip from my convo with @GadSaad
riverside.com/dashboard/editor/preview/e7e906b1-4c27-4a16… -
Michael Shermer reposted
Gad Saad
@GadSaad
About to chat about Suicidal Empathy with the legendary @michaelshermer on his podcast.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In the early 1990s I was an adjunct professor at Occidental College, a formerly highly rated liberal arts college (US News/World Report). They consciously lowered their standards (SAT, GPA) to allow more black students & said it will take a generation to correct past racism.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yet another study that discovers what everyone already knew existed, namely reverse discrimination in the (mistaken) belief that this was necessary to correct for past discrimination.
Mistaken because it assumes formerly oppressed peoples can't make it without white help.
The Washington Post
@washingtonpost
Breaking news: After a year-long investigation, the Justice Department concluded the Yale School of Medicine discriminated based on race in its admissions, favoring Black and Hispanic applicants over White and Asian ones. www.washingtonpost.com/education/2026/05/14/doj-says-yale…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yet another study that discovers what everyone already knew existed, namely reverse discrimination in the (mistaken) belief that this was necessary to correct for past discrimination.
Mistaken because it assumes formerly oppressed peoples can't make it without white help.
The Washington Post
@washingtonpost
Breaking news: After a year-long investigation, the Justice Department concluded the Yale School of Medicine discriminated based on race in its admissions, favoring Black and Hispanic applicants over White and Asian ones. www.washingtonpost.com/education/2026/05/14/doj-says-yale…
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A FAQ: Why are some people gay given that it reduces reproductive output and hence should have been selected out long ago? (The puzzle isn't homosexual attraction or sex, but avoidance of heterosexual mating opportunities.) Steve Stewart-Williams reviews the theories and evidence. open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/an-evolution…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Once the conversation reached the level of firsthand testimony, congressional briefings, crash retrieval allegations, and the acknowledgment of potential non-human intelligence, blurry photos and shaky videos became meaningless distractions."
And yet we still have only blurry photos and shaky videos. Why is that?
Brian Jackson
@BrianJa24362347
This changed everything.
Once the conversation reached the level of firsthand testimony, congressional briefings, crash retrieval allegations, and the acknowledgment of potential non-human intelligence, blurry photos and shaky videos became meaningless distractions.
The 2023 exchange between @newsnation, @rosscoulthart, and David Grusch fundamentally altered the depth and seriousness of the debate surrounding the “visitors.”
Even more striking is Ross Coulthart’s reference to humanity’s future risk — a detail that aligns powerfully with testimony given by Dr. Dan Burisch more than two decades earlier.
Coulthart:
“Grusch has written an internal document about his discoveries that refers to agreements that risk putting our future in jeopardy.”
“And it's quite clear that you're talking about agreements between America and nonhuman intelligences. Have we made agreements with non-human intelligences?”
Grusch:
“That's the kind of information I really hope national leadership is able to get to the bottom of.”
Coulthart:
“I need to pin you down on this. Are there agreements between non-human intelligences and the American government?
Grusch:
“I think that's a question that I would like to know all the details of as well.” -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If @LueElizondo has held in his hands super advanced technology (presumably from aliens) that that U.S. government has back-engineered, then I have this question Lue: why have we never used any of this technology anywhere in all our wars since WWII? Why boring bombs & jets?
Skywatch Signal
@UAPWatchers
🚨Luis Elizondo: States he has held UFO Crash Material...
"I actually gave a briefing to a senior member of the Department of Defense in 2017, several briefings about
the material that I've personally have held in my hand."
"I have held it in my hand and so have other individuals that and I'm not going to say who they were that worked for very high end aerospace companies."
"They're looking at this from an engineering perspective and they're they're scratching their head they're saying you know I mean I can see it, I believe it but I can't believe this material was found back then and under those circumstances."
#ufotwitter #uapx
Source:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzW_Kdh6ZfA -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reverse racism is real. Done in the name of ideology and past injustice + some suicidal empathy (another example @GadSaad !)
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
While a majority of Americans (except liberal GenZ adults) understand that qualified black applicants are almost never denied admission, most Americans are unaware that qualified Asian applicants are regularly denied admission.
These data come from the American Political Perspectives Survey (APPS) collected from August 3, 2025, to September 26, 2025, with 3,000 American adults who speak English. All respondents needed to pass (1) attention checks, (2) a duplication check, (3) time-to-completion checks, (4) fraud and (5) bot-identification checks. For more information, see: research.skeptic.com/american-political-perspectives-survey/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yup @kpea245 aliens are deities for atheists, skygods for skeptics...
kim peacock
@kpea245
Aliens are the New GODS ,
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Michael Shermer's surprising softening on UFOs Anomaly"
Well, that's true! Within limits.
Is absence of evidence, evidence of absence?
Aliens in the cosmos somewhere? No. We've barely begun to look.
Aliens on Earth. Probably. But show us the aliens!
youtu.be/_WFRWpB1zfc -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
From Newspapers to Influencers:
Who Controls Reality Now?
My convo with @AshleyRindsberg one of the keenest observers of the media landscape today:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/from-newspapers-to-i… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Not just replacement of UFO with UAP @MickWest but Unidentified "Aerial" Phenomena has been displaced by "Anomalous" to account for alleged underwater alien spaceships & colonies + "alien" has been replaced by "biologics" & "Non-Human Intelligence".
Euphemism treadmill applies.
Mick West
@MickWest
"UAP" is quickly becoming synonymous with "UFO", and inheriting the stigma that comes along with that. In this fascinating article, former AARO Science Advisor Dr. Randy Bostick suggests holding off even on the designation "UAP" and instead going with "Provisional UAP" (PUAP?) until it can be more clearly demonstrated to be unresolvable and actually anomalous.
It's a good point. The vast majority of UFO/UAP reports are just distracting noise. If there's something interesting in there, then filtering out that noise would be very helpful.
But I fear the terminology horse has already bolted.
nps.edu/documents/110773463/165192597/CTX-EAG-Special-Iss…
"UAP reporters (and anyone interested in or pursuing UAP research) should not feel obligated or allow themselves to be coerced into providing an immediate analysis of what they saw or what their instruments detected. For example, the assessment of a hot, fast-moving object should be left to validated analysis and not an initial description. The self-assessment by an observer that something is “weird” or exotic threatens to lead to the UFO supposition and a reluctance to report and the much-discussed reporting stigma.
The focus should be on reporting the observable characteristics that led the observer to deem the object as hot or fast moving and on providing any associated oral, written, or instrumented data. This information provides the basis for scientific investigation; the reporter should be required only to report, not to provide the assessment.
An approach to reducing the stigma of reporting is to use the term UAP in its proper context as an object that is literally unidentified and/or is behaving anomalously with no assumption of origin based on the initial sighting. To alleviate the implied association of UAPs with UFOs, the initial UAP report may be designated a “potential UAP,” indicating that data and information have been provided, but that further analysis is needed before concluding that it is truly unidentifiable or anomalous and why. This suggestion is analogous to a citizen reporting suspicious activity to law enforcement and letting those professionals investigate whether a crime is actually being committed and by whom. Perhaps the potential UAP ends up being identified as a balloon, drone, or something incredible, but that should not concern the observer making a report." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This film, like all films, is timed to make money. And it will because Spielberg is one of the great filmmakers of our time.
Does that mean aliens are real?
No.
Does that mean people wish aliens are real?
Yes.
Don't believe things that have to be believed in to be true.
UAP Reporting Center
@UAPReportingCnt
🚨 Steven Spielberg says his new film Disclosure Day will explore the emotional and societal shockwaves of UFO disclosure.
He also says global interest in the phenomenon is rapidly intensifying..
Is this movie purposely timed? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I see.
The reason we don't see the back-engineered alien technology from the Pentagon/DARPA/CIA is that the Military Industrial Complex is keeping the tech secret so they can continue fighting expensive conventional wars.
It all makes sense now. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Today's students write their own stories (not Babylon Bee):
"How dare you call us coddled and that we are into canceling anyone who says what may offend us. You should not be allowed to be our graduation speaker!"
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/13/us/politics/nyu-graduation-spe… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"I know we said that the UFO Files would provide definitive evidence of alien visitation, and that we've said disclosure is coming any day now for 287 times over the past 50 years, but THIS time we really mean it. Aliens are here and we're going to show you once and for all..."
Red Panda Koala
@RedPandaKoala
Rep Luna says the Pentagon will be releasing the requested 46 videos in the coming weeks
"In the next thirty days or so in talking with the Pentagon this Thursday, we will obtain these 40 plus documents that we have been specifically requesting." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
But I read it in the New York Times @bungarsargon so it must be true, right?
Batya Ungar-Sargon
@bungarsargon
I'm sorry but "Jews trained dogs to rape prisoners" is an IQ test and a lot of you are failing
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
All these scientists devoting careers to studying the atmospheres of exoplanets for chemical signs of life are wasting their time because Grusch knows the universe is "teeming with life". If only he would show us the evidence. Alas, it's classified so take his word for it,
UAP Juan
@planethunter56
David Grusch: "We're not alone. The universe is teeming with life. That life is already here, and we can openly interact with it.”
Ponder that. Very slowly, esp. the last part.
Quote source: Sleeping Dog -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I am speaking with the author of this new book on the real story of the (probably fake) Zodiac serial killer (unrelated crimes). Also debunks urban legends of Kitty Genovese (not a victim of bystander apathy) and Charles Manson (no race war motive).
"Lore is a powerful thing." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excellent debunking of Nicholas Kristof's "dog rape" story in The New York Times (Israelis having dogs rape Gazans). You would think a journalist at that august publication would have consulted biologists & dog experts if this is even possible.
www.thefp.com/p/nick-kristof-dog-torture-claim-israel-pal… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A must read...
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
An important new piece by @trishaposner and me on how, after October 7, antisemitism didn’t just rise — it shed its inhibitions. The stigma collapsed.
This is not a cycle. It’s a structural shift. As cofounders of an antisemitism watchdog launched in 2022, we have watched the mask come off on both the left and the right.
On the left: Israel is framed as inherently illegitimate — hostility becomes an ethical obligation. The line between Jews and Israelis keeps disappearing.
On the right: Jews reemerge as omnipotent puppet masters — orchestrating migration, finance, media, and foreign wars through familiar conspiracy tropes.
Different ideologies produce the same outcome. Antisemitism is now ideologically portable, socially permissible — and in too many spaces, professionally and financially rewarded.
The real danger is the quiet normalization: what society is now willing to excuse.
Reversing it will take something in short supply— institutional courage.
Read our full analysis 👇
www.skeptic.com/article/new-normal-for-antisemitism/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I just discovered these commentaries on physics & cosmology by @SusskindLeo This one on why there is something rather than nothing (I have a chapter on this in Truth, in Part 3 Known Unknowables). I agree it's the wrong question. Quantum foam fluctuations.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhhrjQW6lu4 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just discovered this fabulous podcast (host uses my work debunking the "dead and missing scientists" conspiracy theory at 7 minute & 32 minute marks). Most of these topics look compelling. Professionally produced series. Check it out:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/conspiracy-theories-cults-c… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Egyptian journalist Wena Rostom writes about (not wearing) the hijab in Skeptic:
“Even families may resort to threats of violence—this happened to me when my uncle decided that I must get a session about the hijab with a sheikh that was 20 years old and whose education stopped at elementary school.
Here’s what he said: ‘You must wear the hijab because our messenger Mohamed said that. You should wear it and you get hit for not wearing it, and others have the right to harass you.’
Then my uncle started to shout at me and then he started to hit me.
I got my arm twisted and my bones almost broken, and he hit my head on a wooden chair!
Yet, my own mother saw what he did as right and blamed me for the incident.
The police didn’t do anything.
Why? In upper Egypt, such violence is called discipline.”
www.skeptic.com/article/god-didnt-do-this-so-why-do-you/ -
Michael Shermer reposted
-
Michael Shermer reposted
Yehuda Teitelbaum
@chalavyishmael
This is one of the clearest and most thorough pieces I’ve read on why the genocide accusation against Israel falls apart under any serious legal or historical standard.
Most of the people screaming “genocide” won’t care because they've already decided what Israel is guilty of. But if you’ve been following this war and feel like something is off about the way it's being reported, read this.
The article walks through what genocide actually means under international law, why intent matters, and why civilian casualties alone have never been enough to meet that standard, including in far deadlier wars.
It goes through the ICJ standard requiring genocidal intent to be the “only reasonable inference,” the fact that Israel has clear military objectives against Hamas, and the absurdity of calling a war genocidal while Israel is issuing evacuation orders, facilitating aid, opening humanitarian corridors, vaccinating Gazan children for polio, and repeatedly warning civilians before strikes.
It also gets into how casualty figures are being manipulated in public discourse, how Hamas fighters are routinely folded into civilian counts, and how people cite every death in Gaza as proof of extermination while ignoring the reality of urban warfare against a terrorist group embedded inside civilian infrastructure.
One of the most important points is that the genocide accusation did not suddenly emerge because of October 7. The article traces how this rhetoric has existed for decades, from Soviet anti Zionist propaganda to Durban to every major Gaza conflict long before this war.
A lot of people know they’re being emotionally pushed toward a conclusion that nobody can be bothered to prove.
It's not because they don't want to prove it. It's because they can't.
An incredible job by @ProfDBernstein.
🔗👇 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The new normal for antisemitism:
@geraldposner @trishaposner break it all down for readers on what has happened to the Jews of late and why the Left has turned on them:
www.skeptic.com/article/new-normal-for-antisemitism/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Liars know the truth and subvert it for personal gain or shame.
Bullshitters don't know or care about the truth or falsity of anything and just babble whatever comes to mind.
Behold the bullshitter extraordinaire...
Nathan Livingstone (MilkBarTV)
@TheMilkBarTV
The ultimate compilation of Tucker Carlson contradicting himself.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"If ever there was an exercise in futility, and a demonstration in intentional stupidity, it was the just dropped UFO files from the US Department of War.”
spectator.com/article/the-only-thing-out-there-is-the-ufo… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Arguably our most notable finding to date that also still surprises people...
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Claims of racism regarding police shootings are often premised on false beliefs about (among other things) the number of unarmed black men shot by police each year.
The correct number is ~10. Around half of liberals and moderates are off in their estimates by at least an order of magnitude.
One of our classic (and most often replicated) findings.
See chart below. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Talking to the great @stewartbrand about how to maintain civilization (along with your car, motorcycle, bicycle, and everything else technological), based on his fabulous new book Maintenance: Of Everything:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/why-everything-falls… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here's the new publishing scam, which includes getting you to pay a "consultant" to get your book proposal ready + an "agent" to help you sell your book + an "editor" to help you prepare your manuscript, etc. And they're in Nigeria & take wires & bitcoin!
writerbeware.blog/2026/03/27/watch-out-for-this-scam-impe… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Question for conspiracists about the disappearance of Monica Reza, the 60-year-old aerospace engineer and materials scientist who vanished while hiking in the Angeles National Forest on June 22, 2025 after she dropped back ~30 feet from her 2 companions:
What’s more likely?
Reza fell off the side of the trail and is either lost among the impenetrably thick bushes or was eaten by wild animals?
or…
A vast UFO/alien/government cabal of hundreds of operatives and agents involving hundreds of thousands of workers in a dozen different fields related to UFOs, the military, aerospace, or science, orchestrated the murder or disappearance of a handful of possibly important, or once important, or something or other, on a hiking trail such that no one could find out what happened to her? (And they all signed NDAs to never reveal their involvement...and no one in the history of the world has ever violated an NDA.) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sound advice by @AbigailShrier on how to handle a sexual assault accusation 8 years after the fact:
"Pop another guy in the nose, and you’ve committed an assault. But spread a devastating rumor, level a false accusation—and you can inflict bottomless, ongoing anguish on your target without anyone calling the cops on you. You’ll rarely even suffer reputational consequences yourself."
"Nearly every man who’s spent a decade dating before marriage has at some point gone out with an unstable woman. That there are men who rape and batter women hardly needs to be said. But also, there are crazy women. And very normal men date them."
Yup.
www.thefp.com/p/tough-love-a-woman-says-my-husband?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Sure, you will be killed or disappeared for knowing UFO secrets, which is why all these people go on TV, podcasts, Substack, social media, write articles and books announcing they have UFO secrets. So they all know that’s all grade A prime cut BS.
Remarks
@remarks
JUST IN: 🇺🇸 Rep. Andy Ogles says he has seen UFO evidence "so classified that just knowing it exists makes you a target."
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Actually this question is for the media, taught to have multiple perspectives on all stories: why when it comes to UFOs, God, and conspiracy theories do most media only interview believers and almost never skeptics? Pandering? Bias? Ignorance?
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Question:
Why is there so much more demand for positive than negative claims? For example:
Believers in UFOs=aliens get far more media coverage than us skeptics.
Believers science proves God get far more coverage than we atheists & agnostics.
Believers in conspiracies...
Why? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Question:
Why is there so much more demand for positive than negative claims? For example:
Believers in UFOs=aliens get far more media coverage than us skeptics.
Believers science proves God get far more coverage than we atheists & agnostics.
Believers in conspiracies...
Why? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is my full in-studio dialogue with @peterboghossian who is one of the best conversationalists today as he routinely employs his "street epistemology" techniques to get people to think deeply about what they believe and why:
youtu.be/CFhQ4ac1nhU -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A short clip from my great convo with @peterboghossian one of the best conversationalists of our time. Check it out...
Peter Boghossian
@peterboghossian
I asked @michaelshermer why the institutions built to find truth became its greatest liability. From alien life to Islamic immigration to the death of expert credibility, our institutions have betrayed public trust.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ibram X. Kendi is as racist, simple-minded, and ahistorical today as he was a decade ago. Read @coldxman brilliant take-down of the activists' latest screed against white people.
www.thefp.com/p/what-ibram-x-kendi-doesnt-admit?r=2xbjf -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why aren’t people having as much sex these days? @DrDebraSoh breaks it down for me discussing her new book Sextinction
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/debra-soh-on-why-men… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Congrats NASA. Finally! In case you're wondering (as I was) why it takes so long for Artemis to get to the moon, given that it is ~250,000 miles away & the spacecraft nearly hits 20,000 MPH...Earth's gravity well slows it down all the way out, speeds it back up on the way back.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Aliens have not and are not coming to Earth. Not ever. Not now. I've been hearing talk like this since the 1970s. It never ends. Just talk. No aliens.
But, please, by all means, produce the aliens & I will believe.
But my money is on the bet that it will never happen. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Don't be fooled by the change of language:
UAP = UFO
biologics = space aliens
non-human intelligence = extraterrestrial intelligence
The shift is meant for people to take the subject more seriously, even though evidence for said beings is no better than it was 75 years ago. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Prediction:
Trump will announce "the U.S. government has no evidence whatsoever that aliens are visiting or have visited Earth."
UFOlogists: "This goes even higher than I thought." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes, exactly @AydanValentin
Many of us did just that.
The Atheist+ movement destroyed itself by adhering to an unworkable worldview (the + = social justice, woke, progressive, etc.)
Aydan Valentin
@AydanValentin
The issue is that “New Atheists” formed their own religion, which aligned with being woke, and then naturally became one and the same.
All other sensible atheists (the ones who weren’t screaming for attention and could manage their own insecurities) simply continued quietly about their day and continue to do so! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Reading @DrDebraSoh new book I discovered the 6-6-6 rule of what women want in a man:
6 feet tall
6 figure income
6 inch manhood
% of men who have all 3 = <15%
Lower still if add looks, education, IQ humor & niceness.
No wonder rates of sex, intimacy & marriage are plummeting! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Re the story that POTUS Obama confirmed aliens are real, read what he actually said:
"They’re real, but I haven’t seen them, and they’re not being kept in Area 51. There’s no underground facility, unless there’s this enormous conspiracy, and they hid it from the president of the United States."
Earlier interview w/James Corden:
“Look, the truth is that when I came into office, I was like, ‘All right, is there the lab somewhere where we’re keeping the alien specimens and spaceships?’ “They did a little bit of research and the answer was, ‘No.'”
What he meant by "they're real" is the UAP videos, not aliens.
Everyone is hearing with their hearts, not minds.
barackobama.medium.com/my-conversation-with-brian-tyler-c… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
It would seem that 14 year old girls are not learning in 8th sex-ed class that if they transition to a boy that they will experience vaginal dryness and pelvic floor collapse and never give birth vaginally as adults.
I will stop posting these when this madness ends.
Kat Kanada 🏴
@KatKanada_TM
HORRIFYING: Detransitioner shares details about the irreversible side effects of testosterone on a her body.
She says NONE of the medical professionals properly inform on what taking testosterone actually entails.
WARNING: GRAPHIC ⚠️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
RFKJ wants to cut funding to the Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunizations that has saved ~20 million lives in poor countries.
He thinks vaccines containing the ethyl-mercury preservative, thimerosal, causes autism.
Wrong.
"Ten studies have shown that children who received thimerosal-containing vaccines were not at greater risk of neurodevelopmental problems, including autism, than those who received thimerosal-free vaccines."
open.substack.com/pub/pauloffit/p/rfk-jrs-war-on-the-worl… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Who in their right mind would counsel this 16-year old girl confused about her gender identity & advise double mastectomy?
“This was not about ideology,” Fox's lawyer Adam Deutsch said. “This case was about medical malpractice."
I disagree. Ideology drives it:
The belief that someone can change sex is wrong.
The belief that minors understand adolescence well enough to make life-altering decisions is wrong.
The belief that gender affirming care (hormones & surgeries) can "align" someone's gender confusion is wrong (this is why the UK's NHS banned the practice).
If you're an adult & decide to alter your body, fine, but leave confused minors alone.
nypost.com/2026/02/03/opinion/lawyer-for-detransitioner-w… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just as it was lawsuits that ended the “Recovered Memory Movement” of the 1990s, this $2 million award to a 22-year old woman who was given a double mastectomy at age 16 and now regrets it, could start a rapid reversal of gender affirming care on minors.
open.substack.com/pub/geraldposner/p/the-first-verdict-ha… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @ScienceBasedMed can you help this woman? She's a lifelong Democrat and lawyer tasked with explaining to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals that women don't have penises. I don't know what to advise her.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
P.S. @ScienceBasedMed I am not "obsessed" with people's genitals. I am either asked my opinion on Trans matters or I am responding to a big media story (eg, men in women's sports & spaces), no different from any other trending issue people on X post about (eg, ICE).
As I clarified on @WNYC in relation to my new book, Truth, someone's internal subjective truth (e.g., men who identify as women) is different from an external objective truth (men can become women).
The first is, by definition, non-falsifiable (we cannot confirm or deny anyone's internal subjective state of mind); the second is falsifiable and has been falsified. Men cannot become women, nor can they get pregnant.
I know some transwomen (men who identify as women), one who is a regular contributor to Skeptic, another the famous economist Deirdre McCloskey, both of whom I respect. Personally, I couldn't care less what anyone does or identifies as in their private lives.
But when organizations like yours promote such false and pseudoscientific ideas that people can change sex (they can't), and these false ideas spread to and encourage, say, teenagers to undergo non-reversible and often damaging gender affirming care (that can sterilize them & end any future sexual pleasure), or enables men to go into women's sports and spaces and declare with confidence "but I'm a woman so it's okay if I'm here," I feel it necessary to speak truth to power.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Oh dear, the folks at @ScienceBasedMed are upset with me because I said men cannot get pregnant.
Did I miss a new scientific discovery?
Author Jonathan Howard talks smack about me then challenges me to come on his podcast.
Ok, Dr. Howard, I accept. DM me.
sciencebasedmedicine.org/fakeskepticshermer -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Oh dear, the folks at @ScienceBasedMed are upset with me because I said men cannot get pregnant.
Did I miss a new scientific discovery?
Author Jonathan Howard talks smack about me then challenges me to come on his podcast.
Ok, Dr. Howard, I accept. DM me.
sciencebasedmedicine.org/fakeskepticshermer -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yikes, even I fell for the narrative that Pretti was just a peaceful caring nurse who went there to peacefully protest, direct traffic around the other peaceful protesters, and provide aid and comfort to others.
No, he should not have been shot dead, but context matters. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Because @Evolutionistrue at any moment you do NOT have only one course of action. That would be a predetermined universe, which is not ours.
The Second Law of Thermodynamics = an arrow of time from past to present, in which the past is determined but the future is not.
(Your determinism depends on the "Block Universe" being true—in which past, present & future exist simultaneously—which most cosmologists reject.)
"Rerun the tape" thought experiment: could have done otherwise? If it is a ROM tape, then no, you could not have done otherwise because that's just a recording of what already happened.
But we don't live in a ROM tape universe.
The future is unknown.
You are part of the causal net of the future universe.
Your choices, in part, help self-determine the future.
Heraclitus: you cannot step into the same river twice, for it is not the same river and you are not the same person.
No future scenario, no matter how similar it is to a past scenario, can never be exactly the same, and you are not exactly the same person, so your choice of which bifurcating path to take is real and not an illusion.
(In psychology this is called "learning" or "experience")
The full defense of my theory is in Chapter 10 of Truth. I will gladly send you a signed comp copy of my book because you're Jerry Fucking Coyne, one of the great minds of our time who happens to be wrong about determinism!
(And, per usual, let friends be wrong; of course, said friends think you're wrong. But friendship remains.) -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Channeling Intelligent Design creationists @SwipeWright :
1. Origin of life
2. Origin RNA-DNA
3. Origin eucaryote cells
4. Origin multicellular life
5. Cambrian explosion of new body plans
6. Origin consciousness
7. Origin morality
God did it.
What say you?
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
What is keeping you from accepting evolution?
IMO the evidence for it is just so overwhelming I don't understand how anyone can doubt it. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"We will replace the frigidity of rugged individualism with the warmth of collectivism."
Here is what NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani's vision looks like from space.
South Korean individualists are warm while North Korean collectivists are frigid. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you remain convinced that the mind is mostly a blank slate and that evolutionary theory has little to say about the human condition, please read @SteveStuWill brief overview of evolutionary psychology and the massive scientific support behind it:
open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/12-things-ev… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I have liberal friends who refuse to believe this is happening, thinking it must be a loony right-wing conspiracy theory.
Wrong.
It is illegal in Germany & UK to insult someone & the punishment is worse for online than in person.
Even RTing an "insulting" post is illegal.
Defiant L’s
@DefiantLs
Free speech in Europe is on the verge of dying.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
RFK Jr. says there is a conspiracy by Big Pharma & government agencies to hide the truth about vaccine injuries.
Not true.
Here is a list of peer-reviewed journal articles documenting vaccine injuries followed by vaccines taken off the market:
open.substack.com/pub/pauloffit/p/debating-science-no-thanks -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Transgenderism is in rapid decline among young Americans
Indicates it was a social contagion
Skeptic has been tracking this movement for years
Our latest from Eric Kaufmann @epkaufm
My prediction it would collapse by 2030 may have been off by years
www.skeptic.com/article/transgenderism-is-in-rapid-declin… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"The surge in transgender identification in recent years wasn’t the revelation of a hidden biological truth. It was a social phenomenon shaped by imitation, ideology & institutional reinforcement" @SwipeWright
My prediction: by 2030, % will be at 2010 %
www.wsj.com/opinion/evidence-backs-the-transgender-social… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“The truth does not require your participation in order to exist. Bullshit does.” —Terence McKenna
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Excellent non-partisan take by @coldxman on why the history of slavery should be non-partisan
As with everything, the far-left's insistence that the U.S. was founded in slavery (1619 Project) goes too far, but Trump's over-correction isn't the right fix.
www.thefp.com/p/the-history-of-slavery-should-not?r=2xbjf… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
When everyone knows that everyone knows...
Photos courtesy of Michelle and Justin, soon to be newlyweds (I'm the officiant!), Glorya Kaufman Performing Arts Center in West LA. A great convo on all things common knowledge. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The most important study on American attitudes toward political violence to date, conducted by the Skeptic Research Center. RT widely as the results are striking and revealing:
www.skeptic.com/r/f82739c0?m=181f5dbf-e6ea-4838-af95-b2f0… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I’ve done dozens of debates, but this passage from @sapinker new book, When Everyone Knows that Everyone Knows…, is why I much prefer “in conversation” as superior at finding truth, or at least common ground:
"At the most refined levels of intellectual colloquy, in debating forums named after venerable British universities and periodicals whose names are permutations of New York, London, Review, Literary, Books, and Times, the customary style of argumentation is gladiatorial combat. The goal is to vanquish one’s adversary, and the tactics are the projection of unshakable confidence, the withering caricature, the targeting of unguarded flanks, the self-defense against falsification, the advantage taken in having the last word. It’s an entertaining sport, but a dubious way to seek the truth." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Does Tylenol Cause Autism?
Here’s What The Evidence Says
Our latest in Skeptic from our new SkepDoc William Meller, M.D.
www.skeptic.com/article/does-tylenol-cause-autism-heres-w… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I have a feeling I will be repeating this sentence often in the coming weeks...
In America your speech is free, but it is not free of consequences.
apnews.com/article/jimmy-kimmel-show-suspended-charlie-ki… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Public trust in science & expertise is at an all-time low, in some cases for good reason.
The new issue of Skeptic is dedicated to analyzing the problem with an aim toward doing something about reestablishing trust.
Order your copy today:
shop.skeptic.com/products/distrust-in-science-and-experti… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Part 3:
Slides from my PPT lecture on "The Politics of Belief", these documenting the massive political bias in the academy.
There is no chance students can get a balanced view of the world with these ratios... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Part 2
Slides from my PPT lecture on "The Politics of Belief", these documenting the massive political bias in the academy.
There is no chance students can get a balanced view of the world with these ratios... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Slides from my PPT lecture on "The Politics of Belief", these documenting the massive political bias in the academy.
There is no chance students can get a balanced view of the world with these ratios... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just binge-watched the 3-part documentary series Atom with the physicist @jimalkhalili on Amazon Prime. Excellent. The best history of physics I've seen. Appears to be available on YouTube as well:
youtu.be/KFS4oiVDeBI -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Is Nuclear Energy Our Best Shot at Saving the Planet?
Yes.
Congrats @isabelleboemeke on your pub date today for
your fabulous and important new book Rad Future!
If you care about the future of humanity read this book (and listen to our convo here):
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/is-nuclear-energy-ou… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
BTW, @Anthrofuentes publicist for his new book, Sex is a Spectrum, pitched me to have him on my show (he was on for his prior book). I agreed to do it if @SwipeWright was also on to debate the thesis. He declined without reason.
The offer still stands Agustin. How about it? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can Politics and Truth Coexist?
My convo with Michael Patrick Lynch about why truth not only can—but must—matter in politics. He shows why truth is an essential democratic value and how it can be strengthened.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/can-politics-and-tru… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
When the facts change I change my mind. What do you do?
Greta Thunberg: I close my eyes. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Harvard behavioral scientist Francesca Gino, who was paid $1 million a year to study honesty and ethical behavior, was accused of manipulating observations to better support her conclusions. Now lost tenure.
Do they still teach irony at Harvard?
www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/5/27/gino-tenure-revoked/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Ok, we're now entering hour 5 of the UAP hearing & they're talking about privatizing space, colonizing the galaxy, semi-conductors & lasers, renewable energy, etc. I guess that's what you have to do when you don't have any actual evidence of aliens. Alas.
uapdisclosurefund.org/events/understanding-uap-science -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"My next great adventure, aged 90, is going to be dying. There's either nothing or something. If there's nothing there's nothing, that's it. If there's something I can't think of a greater adventure than finding out what it is.” —Jane Goodall
Right there with you Jane! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why Tariffs Decrease the Wealth of Nations
My explanation for why Trump's tariffs cannot work (unless his goal is to decrease our wealth).
Tariffs are zero-sum, mercantilist, protectionist, producer-based policies that cannot increase consumer wealth.
www.skeptic.com/article/why-tariffs-decrease-the-wealth-o… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Benjamin Franklin's words resonate today:
"To lay duties on a commodity exported which our friends want is a knavish attempt to get something for nothing. The statesman who first invented it had the genius of a pickpocket. Most of the statutes, acts, edicts, and placards of parliaments, princes and states, for regulating, directing, and restraining of trade have either political blunders or jobs obtained by artful men for private advantage under the pretence of public good. In general the more free and unrestrained commerce is, the more it flourishes. No nation was ever ruined by trade." -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Another child dies of measles.
If only there was something we could do.
Vitamin A?
Nutrition?
Chicken soup?
Thoughts and prayers?
open.substack.com/pub/pauloffit/p/another-child-dies-from… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"One of the highest tariff rates, 50 percent, was imposed on the African nation of Lesotho, whose average citizen earns less than $5 a day.
Because Lesotho’s citizens are too poor to afford most U.S. exports, while the U.S. imports $237 million in diamonds and other goods from the small landlocked nation, we have reserved close to our highest-possible tariff rate for one of the world’s poorest countries.
The notion that taxing Lesotho gemstones is necessary for the U.S. to add steel jobs in Ohio is so absurd that I briefly lost consciousness in the middle of writing this sentence."
www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2025/04/tariffs-trum… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The new Trump Trolly Problem...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the great economist Thomas Sowell on tariffs and why "trade wars" are bad for the economy, bad for citizens, bad for politics, and just bad all around.
Hoover Institution
@HooverInst
In an interview recorded yesterday, Hoover Senior Fellow Thomas Sowell criticizes the tariffs President Trump instituted earlier today. Watch the complete interview with Dr. Sowell on @UncKnowledge with Peter Robinson (@P_M_Robinson) on April 15th, 2025.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The always prescient @mattwridley on evolution and Darwin's strangest idea, sexual selection, but first we discuss the Covid lab leak hypothesis and why so many people were reluctant to accept it. In science the facts do not always speak for themselves.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/sex-and-beauty-the-e… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here is the actual seating arrangement in JFK's car. No "magic bullet" is needed. A single bullet did all of the damage. (Top: incorrect seating assumption. Middle: actual seating arrangement. Bottom: What the single bullet did.
There was no 2nd shooter.
Oswald acted alone.
Zack D. Films
@zackdfilms1
The Single Bullet Theory 😨
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you are inclined to make a moral equivalency argument between Ukraine & Russia @DouglasKMurray sets the record straight:
"almost all the allegations the MAGA right makes against Ukraine are infinitely truer of Putin’s Russia. Interested in international corruption? Try looking at Putin and his friends. Interested in an anti-Christian government? How about looking at the cynical faith of Putin, who trumpets Christian values while firing rockets at great cathedrals like that in Odesa and recruiting jihadists to fight for him. Think Ukraine is cruel in forcing draft-dodgers into the army? Consider Putin’s army recruitment processes. Dislike Zelensky for not holding an election during a total war? Have you noticed Putin’s electoral habits?"
www.thefp.com/p/douglas-murray-how-maga-lost-its?r=2xbjf&… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I spent a week w/ @DrJBhattacharya at a conference in Italy last summer & found him to be a man of the highest integrity & honesty. He will be an excellent director of @NIH &, for a "fringe epidemiologist" (as his crazed critics call him), will restore replicable medical science
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
New paper in Nature Human Behavior claims:
"In academia, despite recent progress towards diversity, biases and microaggressions can still exclude and harm members of disadvantaged social groups."
But “No citations are given for this claim about bigotry and discrimination at the most liberal, open, welcoming institutions that have ever existed in human history.”
Is it possible that authors like these who claim bigotry is rife in academia are themselves bigots projecting their prejudices onto others so they don't feel so bad?
Or do they just need bigotry to seem pervasive so they can keep the DEI grift going?
whyevolutionistrue.com/2025/02/24/nature-human-behavior-i… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Would you rather a live son or a dead daughter?"
"If it seems, suddenly, that only a fool would fall for this, then it is worth pointing out that millions of us were fools for a while. This social contagion spread far beyond teenage girls. It touched corporate executives who rushed to put pronouns in their profiles, pastors who raised the transgender Pride flag at their churches, and school administrators that actively deceived parents about the new gender identities they had selected for the parents’ children." — @AbigailShrier
www.thefp.com/p/abigail-shrier-how-the-gender-fever-broke… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The production values of these @petersonacademy @jordanbpeterson courses is stellar. Live studio audience, multiple camera crews, professionally edited, PPT slides top notch. An honor to reach such a large audience!
Peterson Academy
@petersonacademy
The newest course on Peterson Academy, Dr. @michaelshermer's nine-hour course: Skepticism 101 is available now.
In this course, Dr. Shermer explores the foundations of critical thinking, scientific reasoning, and the nature of belief through an interdisciplinary lens.
The curriculum examines key concepts including truth, rationality, causation, and cognitive biases, while providing practical tools for evaluating claims and understanding human decision-making processes. Through detailed analyses of conspiracy theories, religious beliefs, and philosophical questions about God's existence, the course demonstrates how scientific skepticism can be applied to complex real-world issues.
The material concludes by bridging the gap between scientific methodology and human belief systems, offering frameworks for understanding both empirical truth and meaningful mythological narratives in modern society.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Whoa, just checked @Quillette @clairlemon page of my video/audio commentary "An Unscientific American" on how wokeness destroyed a once great magazine & is corrupting all aspects of science, has 1,717 comments already, many very enlightening & supportive:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=l471fRbAbcs -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Most disturbing:
regardless of who wins, the losing side will claim the election was fraudulent or otherwise tampered with. In our survey, 78% of Harris supporters and 69% of Trump supporters told us they expect the other side to cheat in order to secure an election victory -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good counterfactual reasoning by @coldxman in analyzing Ta-Nehisi Coates's claim that colonialism explains global wealth disparities:
"Why did Japan and South Korea have similar 'growth miracles' in the twentieth century even though Japan was the historic colonizer and Korea its colony? Because they both adopted the key institutions. Why is Ethiopia poor even though it was never a colony? Because, like its African neighbors, it has not yet adopted them."
"Wealth was created only when certain nations began to adopt a set of key institutions: property rights, honest government, markets, rule of law, and political stability. These institutions rewarded productivity and, in particular, innovation. Every nation that has adopted these institutions has grown exponentially as a result. Every nation that hasn’t has remained in the default state of poverty."
open.substack.com/pub/bariweiss/p/ta-nehisi-coates-the-me… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Monitor your blood pressure while answering this question:
Was Ronald Reagan a good president?
@MaxBoot and I consider the pros and cons...
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/max-boot-does-ronald… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A wonderful and brilliant new documentary film is now out: Humans and Other Species by @Speciesism Mark Devries. I was honored to be included in the film (I have a chapter on animal rights in The Moral Arc). Check it out!
humansandotheranimalsmovie.com -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Great thinkers are often prescient in their pronouncements, and Hannah Arendt is one of the greats...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Hong Kong in Turmoil:
Insights from Exiled Political Leader Nathan Law. whom I met at the Dialog conference and then read his important book Freedom: How We Lose It and How We Fight Back
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/nathan-law-political… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Speaking today with @sebastianjunger about NDEs, the afterlife, altered states, God, and finding meaning in the hear-and-now whether or not there is a hereafter (very probably not). Don't treat this world as a provisional proscenium before the big show to come.
Great listen! -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is huge. U.S. pediatricians are finally acknowledging what physicians and medical scientists in the UK and EU affirmed last year on gender transition:
Robby Starbuck
@robbystarbuck
The American College of Pediatricians just put out a 🔥🔥🔥 statement calling out all the major medical associations by name for pushing the gender transition craze on kids.
They ask for these groups to "IMMEDIATELY stop the promotion of social affirmation, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and surgeries for children and adolescents who experience distress over their biological sex."
The full @ACPeds statement ⬇️
"Therefore, given the recent research and the revelations of the harmful approach advocated by WPATH and its followers in the United States, we, the undersigned, call upon the medical professional organizations of the United States, including the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Endocrine Society, the Pediatric Endocrine Society, American Medical Association, the American Psychological Association, and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry to follow the science and their European professional colleagues and immediately stop the promotion of social affirmation, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and surgeries for children and adolescents who experience distress over their biological sex. Instead, these organizations should recommend comprehensive evaluations and therapies aimed at identifying and addressing underlying psychological co-morbidities and neurodiversity that often predispose to and accompany gender dysphoria. We also encourage the physicians who are members of these professional organizations to contact their leadership and urge them to adhere to the evidence-based research now available.”
They link to MANY studies on their site: doctorsprotectingchildren.orgThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
What happened to journalism? @TheFP co-founder @NellieBowles breaks it all down in her marvelous new book, out today, Morning After the Revolution. We also discuss:
Liberalism vs. Progressivism
Cancel culture
Antiracism
BLM
Trans
#metoo
Defund police
...
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/nellie-bowles-report… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
University presidents everywhere need to embrace this simple statement by Ben Sasse, President of the University of Florida:
"At the University of Florida, we have repeatedly, patiently explained two things to protesters: We will always defend your rights to free speech and free assembly—but if you cross the line on clearly prohibited activities, you will be thrown off campus and suspended. In Gainesville, that means a three-year prohibition from campus. That’s serious. We said it. We meant it. We enforced it. We wish we didn’t have to, but the students weighed the costs, made their decisions, and will own the consequences as adults. We’re a university, not a daycare. We don’t coddle emotions, we wrestle with ideas."
www.wsj.com/articles/the-adults-are-still-in-charge-at-th… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
You all know I'm not a Trump supporter, but I don't get the argument that if he's re-elected it will be the end of our democracy. How would he do that, exactly?
Trump doesn't control SCOTUS (they refused to hear his case about the 2020 election)
Trump doesn't control state/county courts (he lost 60 cases over the 2020 election, many Republican judges he appointed)
Trump doesn't have the military to back him if he loses in 2024, or if he wins and refuses to leave the White House in 2029
Trump doesn't control voting precincts (even Republican-run ones declined to overturn 2020 results)
Trump's own loyal VP Mike Pence refused his demands over the 2020 electoral college count
I can imagine riots with MAGA extremists and their guns causing regional violence, but wouldn't police, the national guard, or the military put those down as they always have historically?
As bad as Jan. 6 was, Trump left and we had a peaceful transfer of power as usual.
Retort: "Next time will be different!"
How, exactly? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I am so happy for Dan that he got his autobiography/ memoir out before passing. It's a great read, and what a perfect title to capture his life in a single phrase:
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In my saga to get someone on my show to discuss systemic racism I continue striking out. The publicist of this book pitched me to have the author on. I accepted. Read book & prepared notes. Author backed out last minute: "she wants to pull back from additional interviews."
Sure. Authors of new trade books for the general public just hate telling 100,000 people about their ideas.
Why?
I don't bite! I'm polite even when disagreeing.
I even wrote a book on the subject: The Moral Arc
Theists will talk to me
Conservatives will talk to me
UFOlogists (a few anyway) will talk to me
Why won't defenders of systemic racism talk to me? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My conversation with @AbigailShrier on why the kids are not growing up.
Multiple theories: social media, screen time, helicopter parenting, generational differences, life history theory.
She adds the pathologizing of normal life experiences via bad therapy
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/abigail-shrier-bad-t… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @BretWeinstein How does your (and RFKJ's) alternative explanation for AIDS explain this?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Smith began to shake and writhe violently, in thrashing spasms and seizure-like movements, at about 7:58 p.m. The force of his movements caused the gurney to visibly move at least once. Smith’s arms pulled against the against the straps holding him to the gurney. He lifted his head off the gurney the gurney and then fell back."
Why is this necessary?
I had to euthanize my beloved German Shepard dog years ago. I sobbed uncontrollably but she just fell asleep & it was all over in under 2 minutes. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As 2023 comes to a close the researchers at gapminder remind us that once again this year was one of the best to be alive in history.
Is-Ought:
It IS objectively better to decrease suffering & increase flourishing
We OUGHT to do more of it
Facts & Values
www.gapminder.org/facts/improvements/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In his debate with @sapinker on the Enlightenment, after Steve rattled off a dozen ways life has improved over the centuries, @MearsheimerJ made this argument in so many words:
“Yeah yeah, that goes without saying, but apart from better health, longer lives, lower childhood mortality, vaccines, more food, cleaner water, fewer wars, liberal democracies, market economies, civil rights, women’s rights & gay rights, what has the Enlightenment ever done for us?”
Seriously—he concedes all this but insisted this isn't "moral progress".
Astonishing anyone can't see that human flourishing IS moral progress.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNVm-oXFK9k -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"Why are the BLM supporters, climate extremists, academic feminists, and trans activists so quick to side with Hamas? Why are those who champion women’s reproductive rights so quick to align themselves with a Hamas-controlled Gaza where women lack the right to drive, let alone get an abortion?"
www.wsj.com/articles/notable-quotable-envy-links-hamas-an… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you prefer audio/video to print here is podcast edition of my essay "Why I Am Not a Christian," itself in part a response to @Ayaan Hirsi Ali's essay "Why I Am Now a Christian", both of which have been getting wide coverage thanks to @bariweiss @TheFP
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/ayaan-hirsi-ali-conv… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
US Leftist college students:
"Black Lives Matter"
"BIPOC Lives Matter"
"Diversity Equity Inclusion"
"We stand in solidarity with all minorities & denounce bigotry in all forms."
What about the Jews?
"Fuck the Jews"
"Gas the Jews"
"Destroy Israel"
Leftism is hypocritical hate. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“'Freeing Palestine' is a synonym for 'destroying Israel.' That’s what supporters of Palestine mean when they chant, 'From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.' The 'sea', of course, washes against the west coast of Israel."
Jerry Coyne nails it:
whyevolutionistrue.com/2023/10/09/celebrations-of-hamass-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Two words: nuclear power
apnews.com/article/germany-economy-energy-crisis-russia-8… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Mexican Doctors Certify Creepy Remains As "Biological And Non-Terrestrial"
Ay, carumba!
nypost.com/2023/09/19/mexican-doctors-say-alien-remains-a… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Does Section 3 of the 14th Amendment disqualify Trump from POTUS?
"No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any State, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any State legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any State, to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof."
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/08/donald-trump-co… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The following three conditions are incompatible:
1. God is Omnipotent (all powerful)
2. God is Omnibenevolent (all good)
3. Evil Exists
1. If God is all powerful, can He not prevent evil from existing?
2. If God is all good, should He not prevent evil from existing?
3. If evil exists, then either God is not all powerful or not all good.
My solution to this problem: THERE IS NO GOD.
The Oxford Companion to Philosophy says that the theodicy problem of how a good and loving God can allow evil to afflict its creations “has always been the most powerful objection to traditional theism.”
Indeed it is... -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The geography of UFOs. Like a geographical map of world religions, the non-random distribution of UFO sightings is a strong indicator that this is a purely socio-cultural phenomenon.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"I've been told" we have alien tech. 4th time in a month we've heard this. Can we please move beyond the urban legend FOAF stage of UAPs ("a Friend of a Friend says") & see some actual evidence? I've got $1000 that it won't happen by Dec. 31 2024. Anyone? Anyone? Bueller?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
How Much Real-World Extremism Does Online Hate Actually Cause?
"there’s little evidence that online incitement leads to real-world radicalization" but it "galvanizes extremists and confirms their victimhood narratives & conspiratorial thinking"
quillette.com/2022/03/20/does-online-hate-speech-really-c… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Liberals/progressives: please heed this observation from a fellow progressive liberal who heads “a socialist think tank focused on analyzing deep structural issues in late capitalist consumer society” & consider why he trusts conservatives more than progressive liberals.
Stuart Parker, blancmange impersonator & cannibal
@stuartlosaltos
In my 36 years as a climate activist, no conservative who has disagreed with me on climate has ever tried to destroy my career, my home, my relationship, my friendships, my social media accounts, my radio shows, my podcasts or my recreational activities.
People working in the fossil fuel industry who feel my efforts are destroying their employment prospects, people who think climate change is a hoax, a fraud I am helping to perpetrate, people who falsely believe I receive money from shadowy European interests: none of these people have felt entitled to go after my ability to earn a living or have a romantic partner.
In my 3 years of opposing genderwang, dozens, likely hundreds of progressives, many of whom I considered comrades or friends, have felt it totally appropriate to engage in unapologetic concerted public efforts to destroy these things, to even come after my fortnightly tabletop Runequest games and try to stop those.
In a social partition of contemporary North America, I would rather be in a conservative society, even if it were significantly more on fire, because I wouldn't feel unsafe disagreeing with my neighbours. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My conversation with Leroy Hood & Nathan Price on:
Why do we age and die?
Sickcare vs. healthcare
Chronological age ≠ biological age
Curing cancers would only increase the average life span by 3 years
Alzheimer’s & brain health
Elizabeth Holmes/Theranos
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/leroy-hood-nathan-pr… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear @PeterHotez I encourage you to debate @RobertKennedyJr on @joerogan on vaccines, autism, Covid, cell phones & cancer & all the rest. I did a 3.5 hour debate on Joe's show—he's a stand-up guy & will absolutely be fair & give you the time you need. Podcasts are the new media center. Why would you pass up $100,000 & tens of millions of viewers? Do it.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This sickens me & it should everyone. 10x nationals, 3x Olympics, 3x worlds, 2x TdF cyclist Inga Thompson who survived breast cancer & a double mastectomy is canned by her team for defending women's rights in sports (no biological males—duh). @ithompsonfdn
www.telegraph.co.uk/cycling/2023/05/12/inga-thompson-sack… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"The results of the largest survey to date on gender dysphoric adolescents support Dr. Littman’s ROGD hypothesis. These youth are most likely using 'gender dysphoria' to describe general feelings of dysphoria that they have no other name for & do not understand. Transitioning will not help them. It can only cause irreversible harm & make things much worse."
www.parentsofrogdkids.com/press-releases/2023/3/30/larges… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I see @mtaibbi has same problem. @elonmusk this is wrong & against everything you said & promised when you bought @Twitter You asked us to pay a subscription fee so I did. This is how you reward us for supporting free speech? Censorship? Come on, be principled not opportunistic.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I just listened to one of the best podcast productions I've ever heard by @meganphelps @bariweiss @thefp on the witch-hunted @jk_rowling Anyone who listens to this & still thinks she's a transphobe whose books should be burned has lost their mind. Try it:
www.thefp.com/p/out-now-the-witch-trials-of-jk-rowling?pu… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
To libertarians, classical liberals & conservatives: read @NaomiOreskes @ErikMConway new book (out Tuesday) The Big Myth (that markets can solve all social problems better than government). It's not true & we should believe what is true. See my convo with Naomi Tuesday.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Democrat :: Republican ratio by academic field. Note that there are some fields where there are 0 Republicans.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
NBC story about Pelosi attack that fueled conspiracy theorists on the Right (the Left has them too) was inaccurate so was withdrawn & corrected; of course, to conspiracists NBC initially told the truth then withdrew it when it didn’t “fit the narrative.”. www.washingtonpost.com/media/2022/11/05/nbc-paul-pelosi-r…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My conversation with @justindgregg on What Animal Intelligence Reveals About Human Stupidity:
—dolphins
—AI
—language
—rationality
—morality
—comparative thanatology
—causal inference v. learned associations
—prognostic myopia
—pleasure v. purposefulness
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/justin-gregg-if-niet… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wow. Makes me proud to be a member of a species that can take a photograph from space of the supermassive black hole at the heart of our galaxy. Can't wait to see what's next for the Event Horizon Telescope.
eventhorizontelescope.org/blog/astronomers-reveal-first-i… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If authentic abortion will return to a states-rights issue. For about half states nothing will change but for the other half (GOP controlled) it will be mostly banned. I wish conservatives would practice what they preach about individual liberty & autonomy
apnews.com/article/supreme-court-abortion-draft-opinion-0… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Pew data over decades tracks the political divide: the left moved leftward and the right moved rightward.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Indeed...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
EPISODE #249
Barbara F. Walter on How Civil Wars Start and How to Stop Them, including in the United States
No it won't be 2 massive armies facing off. But if enough people think the 2024 election is rigged violence could erupt & no power peaceful transfer
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/barbara-walter-on-ho… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is going to be our most controversial issue yet and the cover is simply brilliant. Subscribe now so you don't miss out on our in-depth analysis of trans matters...
www.skeptic.com/magazine/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Facts are stubborn things; and whatever may be our wishes, our inclinations, or the dictates of our passion, they cannot alter the state of facts and evidence.”
—John Adams -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"If Elder were running as a Democrat, the press would be celebrating the possibility of California’s first black governor. Instead..."
@HMDatMI breaks down the homicide/crime data the Times (LA & NY) claim Elder distorts. Judge for yourself:
www.city-journal.org/playing-race-card-on-california-gube… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
THREAD
In my conversation with @RobertCialdini we discussed the influence factors as they relate to police, BLM, & the George Floyd killing: why didn't the other cops intervene?, why did it go so far?, why cops need to "control" the situation?, etc.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/psychology-of-persua…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
I sent these to @RobertCialdini who offered this insight I think worth sharing (with his permission). Defund the police is not the answer. New recruitment criteria & training programs that not only emphasize "serve-and-protect" as a job description but bake it into the DNA...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Highlight from my conversation with @RobertCialdini on conformity and social proof influences and why people responding to what others are doing has a certain rationality to it:
Full episode:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/psychology-of-persua…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
ICYMI...
@RobertCialdini one of the world experts on influence & persuasion. We discuss just how gullible/susceptible humans are vs. the counter by @hugoreasoning @sapinker Tooby & Cosmides & others that we have bounded rationality & are not so gullible.
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/psychology-of-persua… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Do preschool programs like Head Start work? @AlisonGopnik untangles the complex web of causal variables to show that they do work for better outcomes...later in life (graduate high school, take SAT tests, go to college, etc.)
www.wsj.com/articles/preschools-sleeper-effect-on-later-l… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Kudos to @SDUTdyer & The San Diego Union Tribune @sdut for doing what 60 Minutes, Fox News, et al. failed to do: consult skeptics for another explanation for UAPs/UFOs. This is the best single article to date. And to @MickWest for his yeoman's work.
www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/military/story/2021-05-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Just read through this long but constructive dialogue with @Evolutionistrue & @adamgopnik on knowledge as "justified true belief" and to what extent science is or is not the only road to it. Well worth the time to read it.
letter.wiki/conversation/1092 -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In this episode w/ @ProfDavidBuss we discuss why men behave badly, consider proximate & ultimate causal explanations, nature/nurture, sex differences in mate preferences, the Dark Triad, & solutions to this—one of the great civil rights issues of our time
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/david-buss-when-men-… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
EPISODE # 175 with @briankeating
How it All Began
Episode here:
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/brian-keating-how-it…
—Why something rather than nothing
—What banged the Big Bang
—Multiverse
—Dark energy & matter
—Why "fine tuning" ≠ God/ID
Order the latest issue of Skeptic here:
www.skeptic.com/magazine/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Good talking to @JordanHarbinger
—How beliefs form & persist even when we know they’re wrong
—Why smart people are even more susceptible to faulty beliefs
—How our genes influence our political & religious beliefs
—Why skeptics are not cynics!
www.jordanharbinger.com/michael-shermer-why-we-believe-we… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wrapped 2 days of filming...my next book: "What is Truth, Anyway? How to Establish Objective Facts in a Post-Truth,
Fake-News, Alternative-Facts World"
Say what? Video book. It's the next big thing in content production. Summer release with other video books. Watch this space. -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This was an epic conversation with one of the most important and interesting people of our time. It will drop Feb. 9, the pub date of @Ayaan 's new book, which you can pre-order now (the audio is fabulous and she reads it):
www.audible.com/pd/Prey-Audiobook/0062985191?qid=16117747… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Both—And:
Support peaceful protests AND condemn predatory looting
Mostly cops are good AND there are some bad cops
Moral progress real AND more work is needed
Trend lines moving in positive direction AND isolated negative incidents still occur
Racism down AND racists still exist -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
That this footage = ETs is extraordinary compared to alternate hypotheses: Russian/Chinese asset, domestic drone, camera anomaly, etc. No matter how extraordinary these seem they are less than the ET hypothesis, so skepticism.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"the footage is simply a confirmation of what he has long believed and advocated for in the halls of Congress: We may not be alone."
No. The U in UFO means unidentified not extraterrestrial.
Bayesian reasoning = more likely terrestrial than ET.
www.cnn.com/2020/04/28/politics/harry-reid-ufos-pentagon/… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
"the footage is simply a confirmation of what he has long believed and advocated for in the halls of Congress: We may not be alone."
No. The U in UFO means unidentified not extraterrestrial.
Bayesian reasoning = more likely terrestrial than ET.
www.cnn.com/2020/04/28/politics/harry-reid-ufos-pentagon/… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Treat people as individuals, not members of groups:
"identity politics, with its notion of group-based power reassignment, is not the appropriate response to the undeniable existence of racism, sexism and homophobia; the principle of equal rights is."
intellectinterviews.com/2020/01/steven-pinker/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
NOW you have regrets @Horganism ? A scientist whose work doesn't perfectly align with your woke politics has to die before you confess to trashing him without cause? Tierney's book was evidently wrong at the time & we explained why in Skeptic. Shame on you
blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/my-regrets-about… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
One of my favorite affirmations of free speech and open inquiry...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This is pure evil:
www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=78&v=9PLKVNBcF3s
Produced by a major supermarket chain my German wife Jennifer tells me is getting major pushback from people now boycotting it. You’ll see why in this bigoted hateful anti-male anti-father commercial. Who hates men this much? -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Science Salon #60
Dr. Nicholas Christakis @NAChristakis
Blueprint: The Evolutionary Origins of a Good Society
We discuss:
Unintentional Communities like shipwrecks
Intentional Communities like communes
genes/culture co-evolution
human nature
& much more
www.skeptic.com/science-salon/christakis-blueprint-evolut… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can evil be banned? My answer...
quillette.com/2019/03/26/banning-evil-in-the-shadow-of-ch… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Last gasp of Intelligent Design Creationists debunked in new issue of Skeptic magazine:
"Behe’s Last Stand: The Lion of Intelligent Design Roars Again" by Nathan H. Lents @nathanlents
www.skeptic.com/reading_room/michael-behes-last-stand-lio…
Order the new issue here: www.skeptic.com/magazine/ -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Add: @sapinker Enlightenment Now, Cass Sunstein's On Freedom, Michele Gelfand's Rule Makers Rule Breakers, Richard Wrangham's The Goodness Paradox, Rachel Kleinfeld's A Savage Order, Charles Krauthammer's The Point of it All, Nadine Strassen's Hate, Martin Rees' On the Future.
The Reading Lists
@TheReadLists
Check out the #readinglist of @michaelshermer, which includes books by @RichardDawkins, @sapinker and @Daniel_Loxton. www.thereadinglists.com/michael-shermer-reading-list/
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Going live in five in the problem of evil and why this very likely means there is no God.
ses.edu/debate -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
This statement from @JonHaidt & @jean_twenge is the perfect embodiment of epistemic humility when facing contradictory data (on the relationship--or not--of social media use & psychological disorders among adolescents). We all need to strive to this ideal.
docs.google.com/document/d/1w-HOfseF2wF9YIpXwUUtP65-olnkP… -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Shocking @MrAndyNgo After touring sites in Germany where Kristallnacht unfolded 80 years ago, I see Portland progressives acting like Nazis threatening to destroy property in the name political purity. Have we learned nothing from history? Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A Mysterious Change of Mind: Why People Die by Suicide. My latest Scientific American column. www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-do-people-kill-the… via @sciam
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Yes, I'm an atheist, but that only means "without belief in God". On the positive side, I'm an Enlightenment Humanist who believes in science, reason, rights, justice, personal responsibility, honor, courage, love & "long, slow, deep, soft, wet kisses that last three days."
Daily Wire
@realDailyWire
Does God exist? Do societies thrive under a religious influence? @BenShapiro and noted atheist @MichaelShermer debate Christianity's role in cultural advancement on this episode of The Sunday Special!
WATCH the full episode on Sunday, June 17th => www.youtube.com/channel/UCaeO5vkdj5xOQHp4UmIN6dw -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Behind Crimson Eyes - Foreword: The Silence Ends Now. David Smalley of www.dogmadebate.com with his heartfelt words and amazing voice, with Aaron Schultz takes a stand against religious abuse.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7ofbyOhI6po -
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The great social psychologist & second-wave feminism pioneer Dr. Carol Tavris on the #metoo movement www.skeptic.com/reading_room/me-too-cognitive-dissonance/
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Can you believe this was said by a conservative?
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you want to hear SJW postmodern nonsense in action listen to excerpts from secretly recorded meeting w/ Wilfrid Laurier University grad student Lindsay Shepherd & faculty upbraiding her for "offending" students by showing video clip of @jordanbpeterson globalnews.ca/video/3867811/extended-excerpts-from-secret…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Forgot the link! Here: Make it count because this is all we have. Beautiful 1.5 minute film short featuring philosopher @peterboghossian & produced by Australian musician Aaron Schultz who produced the music. Well done. www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1a-i9gYLlQ
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Mike Pence “The theory of global warming is just that: a theory.” Sure, like gravity, relativity, quantum mechanics, plate tectonics, DNA...
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Science is universal, international, inclusive, nonpartisan, a-political, a-gender, a-race, & a-ideological. Don't inject identity politics.
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why overpopulation ≠ the end of the world. The 12th billion person will never be born. Watch this amazing 6 min vid: www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsBT5EQt348
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Quote of the day from George Orwell, "Politics and the English Language," April, 1946, worth reading entire essay orwell.ru/library/essays/politics/english/e_polit/
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Space Brain. Cosmic rays may be a significant obstacle getting humans to Mars with their brains functioning. news.uci.edu/research/mars-bound-astronauts-face-chronic-…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Skeptic Phil Plait @BadAstronomer assess's @elonmusk 's vision to colonize Mars. Difficult but doable. So let's go! www.slate.com/blogs/bad_astronomy/2016/09/29/musk_reveals…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Kaisch, Cruz, Carson, Perry, Huckabee, & Santorum said God told them to run but non-religious Trump won. Meaning? modernliberals.com/maybe-time-republicans-stop-talking-go…
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you're not sure Islam is dangerous, watch this disturbing video from UK. If that's a naked woman religion is blind www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTl7K47pTcc
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Dear Religion: This week I safely dropped a human from space; you shot a 14-year old girl in the head for wanting to go to school. -Science
-
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
NBC Olympic Weightlifting analyst: "This is Gregoriava from Bulgaria. I saw her snatch this morning during her warm up and it was amazing."





















































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































