Molecules have one big advantage over defects in diamond: you can build them atom by atom and put them on photonic chips. This Nature paper shows a single carbene molecule can be an optically addressable qubit. Worth watching. doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11147-6 (I advise NVision)
Michael Levitt (biophysicist)
Michael Levitt, (Hebrew: מיכאל לויט; born 9 May 1947) is a South African-born biophysicist and a professor of structural biology at Stanford University, a position he has held since 1987. Levitt received the 2013 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, together with Martin Karplus and Arieh Warshel, for "the development of multiscale models for complex chemical systems". In 2018, Levitt was a founding co-editor of the Annual Review of Biomedical Data Science. More on Wikipedia
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A single molecule can now function as an individually controllable qubit with a native photonic interface
For years we've asked how quantum computers might help chemistry.
@NVisionQuantum flips it: chemistry helps build quantum computers
@ScienceMagazine www.science.org/content/article/molecules-emerge-new-kind… -
Michael Levitt reposted
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Nobel Laureate Dr. Michael Levitt in the section on his Covid research. It misrepresents his research & slanders him using a source known to be a biased hit piece. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Levitt_(biophysicist). I worked w/him during Covid; if you need more explaination please contact me.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I am so happy to see this paper by @PaulRobustelli, whom I have never met but would like to. It characterizes structure in disordered proteins using the writhe of the chain.
I used this is 1983 to calculate protein structure using known pairs-wise interactions. I was influenced by mathematical analyses of self-crossing in DNA structure.
Amazing how in science every thing is connected often in non-obvious ways.
Paul Robustelli
@PaulRobustelli
We're inspired by work in the late 70s by Harold Scheraga using differential geometry to describe polymer conformations (pubs.acs.org/doi/epdf/10.1021/ma60066a020) and a @MLevitt_NP2013 1983 JMB classic (www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00222836838012…) calculating writhe of protein conformations using discrete segments.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is really exciting work that I am proud to be a part of. RNA is a remarkable material as it has structure and also carries information. My first paper published in 1969 modeled RNA structure in transferRNA.
The paper by @GalOren8 is about using AI to better predict messenger RNA editing sites so that the information it contains is more nuanced.
Biology is so full of amazing hacks.
Gal Oren
@GalOren8
[8/]
📝 Paper: openreview.net/forum?id=L2jj5ekPxa
🧬 Repo: github.com/Scientific-Computing-Lab/CFT-RNA-Editing-Detec…
📺 YouTube: youtu.be/Mjj6MfVQCNM
With Zohar Rosenwasser, Erez Levanon, @MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thank you. Ben and I are working together and making many interesting discoveries. This is a hugely positive legacy of my days on X-Twitter.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben you are amazing.
US Mortality
@USMortality
I’ve recently updated German data to use more user-friendly 10-year age groups instead of the previous 5-year intervals. The difference was surprisingly large, so I decided to investigate—digging deep into the code for about three days to verify everything. Here’s what I found:
Overview of Mortality Watch Data Handling
Mortality Watch integrates multiple data sources and can handle different temporal resolutions (yearly, monthly, weekly). A few months ago, I refined the logic to select the best available data for each resolution—e.g., using yearly data for yearly resolutions.
For these recent updates, I also added 5-year resolution yearly data:
• Yearly Deaths: These match exactly with the underlying dataset from Destatis, which provides official yearly figures.
• Yearly Population: This is reported as of December 31st each year. The simplest approach would be to join the data by year, but that would be inaccurate. Since the beginning of Mortality Watch, I’ve always calculated daily population estimates—breaking down deaths and population into daily values and interpolating as needed. This ensures consistency, as summing up daily data correctly matches the totals.
When comparing Mortality Watch population data with the Destatis source, Mortality Watch reports the mean of daily interpolated data. This may seem counterintuitive at first, but it provides a more accurate representation.
Verifying the Accuracy of Mortality Watch
To ensure my calculations were correct, I conducted a deep dive and even discovered a small bug. The issue, which had only a minor impact, affected age-stratified CMR calculations:
github.com/MortalityWatch/charts/commit/a31ae5fdf5fb09eb2…
To further validate the methodology, I created an example script demonstrating different approaches to calculating ASMR. The results vary significantly based on the method used:
1️⃣ Simple year joins (joins deaths of 2020 to population of 12/31/2020), using mortality.org age groups (0–14, 15–64, 65–74, 75–84, 85+)
2️⃣ Simple year joins, using 10-year age groups (0–10, …, 80+) – Currently used on Mortality Watch
3️⃣ Daily year joins (interpolated daily population joined on daily death data (evenly split)), using 10-year age groups (0–10, …, 80+)
4️⃣ Simple year joins, using single-year age groups (0–85)
5️⃣ Daily year joins, using single-year age groups
As you can see, the red values match MortalityWatch figures identically, (besides 2023 🥴).
It’s good news that there aren’t any bugs in the calculations. It’s also important to be aware of the sensitivity of the methodology used, and that we should always use the highest resolution possible. This analysis demonstrates how different age groupings and interpolation methods can have a significant impact on ASMR calculations. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Editing messenger RNA could allow a single mRNA vaccine to code for different proteins. Sounds risky to me. Still , it may have importance in future.
Prof. Avv. Gianfrancesco Vecchio
@GfveGianfra
New mRNA vaccines on arrival? 🤔
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really is important!!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@GalOren8 has done something remarkable in AI for Science by teaching ChatGPT the language of RNA. I am so proud to be involved in this project with him and Erez Levanon.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@GalOren8 has done something remarkable in AI for Science by teaching ChatGPT the language of RNA. I am so proud to be involved in this project with him and Erez Levanon.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much.
GG
@searchfeast
OT, I encountered your sensible videos and interviews in the early days of the covid lockdowns from Australia.
Just want you to know i appreciated your comments and interviews back then. Cheerio. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very impressive analysis.
Thank so much
wordgrammer
@wordgrammer
Okay. Thanks for the nerd snipe guys. I spent the day learning exactly how DeepSeek trained at 1/30 the price, instead of working on my pitch deck. The tl;dr to everything, according to their papers:
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Wrong article and link. Sorry about that mistake. The article is in the Hebrew version of the Calcalist at:
www.calcalist.co.il/magazine/article/sktjkxadje
The English translation is at www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/ysw4ljw7stbqtxe531oq1/Full_Transla…
My words about the writer Roni Dori @RoniDori are accurate.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really great interviews and follow-up by Roni Dori @RoniDori
Actually I am Michael Levitt @MLevitt_NP2013. I will post the link English translation if there is any interest. This could my first Covid-free post since March 2020.
D𝕏🦎OG 🎗️🤟🏼🇶🇦
@dganofr
כתבה מיוחדת עבור הקורא נתניהו, שפעל, מסיבות לא ידועות, בדיוק ההיפך מהנדרש למיטוט ארגון טרור דרך הכיסים - וריפד את כיסיו של החמאס היטב לאורך שנים.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, @stephen_s has been working hard to keep me honest with a totally independent project aimed at peak finding and fitting.
I am in great awe of maths and programming skills. Thank you.
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
Yes yes, I’ll try and finish my quadruple check for bugs in the fitting algorithm asap.
So much time and so little to do… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Agree with you.
Is this because it in spite of the US embargo of the fastest GPU chips.
Reminds me of the hidden story in LIU Cixin’s trilogy “Three Body Problem”.
Marc Andreessen 🇺🇸
@pmarca
Deepseek R1 is one of the most amazing and impressive breakthroughs I’ve ever seen — and as open source, a profound gift to the world. 🤖🫡
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Certainly do. Most of the first major outbreak in the particular location are predictable Gompertz Growth rather than unpredictable Ligistic Growth.
Have all the data of a comprehensive analysis waiting final write-up.
Henk Koudijs
@KoudijsHenk
As far as I know Micheal Levitt still supports the notion that pandemic virus spread follows a gompertz curve, like he stated in 2020.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really great interviews and follow-up by Roni Dori @RoniDori
Actually I am Michael Levitt @MLevitt_NP2013. I will post the link English translation if there is any interest. This could my first Covid-free post since March 2020.
D𝕏🦎OG 🎗️🤟🏼🇶🇦
@dganofr
כתבה מיוחדת עבור הקורא נתניהו, שפעל, מסיבות לא ידועות, בדיוק ההיפך מהנדרש למיטוט ארגון טרור דרך הכיסים - וריפד את כיסיו של החמאס היטב לאורך שנים.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Jay Bhattacharya is next NIH head. What a nice surprise. Congratulations @DrJBhattacharya
www.nytimes.com/2024/11/26/us/politics/jay-bhattacharya-n… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This would be amazing!
Jay Bhattacharya now top candidate to be Trump's pick for NIH director
The Stanford-trained physician and economist, who won GOP support after pushing back on covid lockdowns, is said to have impressed RFK Jr., Donald Trump's pick to lead HHS. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
One graph that explains why things are so difficult in the USA today…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I was just awarded the Carrier Medal by Notre Dame University. While the citation echos my earlier prize, I was told that this award was awarded for, rather than in spite of, my free speech during COVID.
This gives me great pride and hope for the future of US academia.
The video of the ceremony is at www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQXJroLGU64
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thank you all so much. These comments feel like a dream come true. I recognize so many names of friends I have never met and wish I could.
What happened to all those who fought against any non-establishment views on COVID-19. I miss a few of them who argued with integrity. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A day’s experience with @OpenAI new ChatGPT o1-preview is a huge WOW.
This is a massive jump forward! my vantage point involves almost 22 months & over 2000 conversations with previous versions.
It also has the voice entry that I so appreciate. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not surprised.
www.nytimes.com/2024/08/13/business/sweden-economy-europe…
Stupidity exhibited by almost all other countries in COVID pandemic years will reverberate for decades.
The 40 trillion in added debt was wasted. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting named list in top row:
Canada: 6.9
Finland: 7.7
Ukraine: 4.9
Israel: 7.3
Bangladesh: 4.0
(no map value)
Israel is as happy as Sweden, a surprise to most.
These values are how happy inhabitants say the feel.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Forgot link: posts.voronoiapp.com/maps/A-Map-of-Global-Happiness-By-Co…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So much exciting new work using AI. Key though is to get the compounds into the drug development pipeline and into human clinical trials.
Gal Oren
@GalOren8
This new one fine-tunes ChatGPT via the API with incredible results: www.nature.com/articles/s42256-023-00788-1
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Indeed. This affair makes Stanford look so wonderfully good.
I am there working hard on COVID papers with our colleague John Ioannidis @METRICStanford
I recently had my NIH grant supporting this work renewed thanks to these papers and strong Stanford Medical School support. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is quite impossible to comprehend. Has Harvard total lost its senses? Taking revenge on a brave scientist who spoke truth is a disgrace to academia. It will have lasting harm on all I hold dear.
This level of institutional stupidity is an existential threat to the USA.
Martin Kulldorff
@MartinKulldorff
I am no longer a professor of medicine at @Harvard. Here is the story of my Harvard experience until I was fired for clinging to the truth.
www.city-journal.org/article/harvard-tramples-the-truth -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do not know precisely but much less and much faster than non-AI drug design. My guess is both faster and cheaper by a factor of ten.
Mazda Sabouri
@msabouri
Any idea as to what the net cost was for setting up and executing the AI to perform these tasks?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Friends @InSilicoMeds published substantial experimental validation of a novel antifibrotic agent.
AI discovered the target; generative AI designed the drug.
Probably 1st validation of generative AI-derived molecules in Phase I human clinical trials.
www.nature.com/articles/s41587-024-02143-0 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Silent for a while focusing on writing papers on Covid (tweets easier).
Now I ask help tracing precious laptop & diary stolen from our two backpacks from a car near Portimao, Portugal.
Last location from phone also stolen is Rua do Alto do Pacheco, 8500 Portimão, Portugal 🙏 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really nice list of papers.
Ash Jogalekar
@curiouswavefn
1/n: There are some academic papers that are so brilliantly and so accessibly written and so universal in scope that they transcend disciplines and stand as timeless testaments to both great thinking and great writing. Here's a short personal selection:
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I do not believe this? Is this a deep fake?
Do Collins and Fauci now support the Great Barrington Declaration?
Really such a disaster when politicians infect the beauty of science!!
Retsef Levi
@RetsefL
‘Stop the virus to save lives, neglecting to consider the collateral consequences’
Francis Collins describes the ‘narrow & myopic mindset’ of public health leaders during the pandemic!
Admission of insensible & evil policies with unimaginable harm! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
No words possible
Retsef Levi
@RetsefL
Today, I watched again the Bearing Witness video of Oct 7 Hamas atrocities in a special showing organized by MIT Chabad.
Faculty colleagues, MIT President, Sally Kornbluth & chair of the corporation, Mark Gorenberg watched many heart-soul-mind crashing scenes.
What sticks with me this time are the scenes of killing, harming,violating & mutilating of girls & young women. The thought that there is evil in the world that can do something like this is devastating.
We each have to make a choice about this. No grey, only black or white! No ambiguity, no context, but never again!
Never again - for my 3 daughters, 13 nieces and many women students!
Time for choices & action! -
Michael Levitt reposted
leekern
@leekern13
🎥 GRAPHIC DETAILS
I recorded a reaction video after watching the 47 minute compilation of Hamas atrocities. It’s in 3 segments as it’s 25 mins long & I had to take a couple of breathers. No one must be allowed to intellectualise these crimes into legitimacy. Pure evil.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
AI is a tool that you use to improve your how you yourself do things.
At this time relying on AI is akin to relying on a screw driver.
Scott M
@NSDarkHorse
I heard they relied too much on AI, which led them astray. If true, it was a colossal failure for AI too.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
As I said before: human stupidity and human hubris is the real existential threat to humanity. We really are homo stultus!
Scott Horton
@scotthortonshow
Israel's worst enemies must have conspired to make Benjamin Netanyahu their nation's Prime Minister.
NYT: Israel Knew Hamas’s Attack Plan More Than a Year Ago
archive.ph/OCfvq -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
PNAS paper on COVID-19 finally out.
Three years in the making www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/eoykqeunv4ie3xuz8igmq/PNAS-Vulnera… shows that the burden of death of COVID-19 depends on the resilience of the country. Pre-existing low GDP and high poverty percentage lead to vulnerability.
Likely true for other crises. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is amazing work from Professor Udi Qimron and his colleagues at Tel Aviv University.
The result a surprising. It is a breakthrough, which could have global implications.
Well done!
Prof. Udi Qimron 😏 אודי קימרון
@UdiQimron
1.🐭 In these terrible times, we have completed an exciting research uploaded today to BioRxiv. We have made a breakthrough in sexing semen, which may be a game-changer for animal breeding.
biorxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2023.11.21.568055v1 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not that we can find.
There is data for Taiwan and Hong Kong that is relevant and led us to publish two papers on estimating COVID-19 deaths from the pandemic.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/eci.13956
and
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle…
We are still studying this.
Ephemeral
@Ephemerallama
@MLevitt_NP2013 is there a good source of up to date mortality stats for china? Entire country, provinces?
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Yuval Noah Harari
@harari_yuval
“Among the victims have seen a significant number of Muslims who were murdered by Hamas, like an ambulance driver, who tried to rescue people. Lots of people feared, after October 7th, that we will see an uprising of Arab-Israelis against the Israeli state. The exact opposite happened. Instead, we saw Arab-Israelis volunteering and helping displaced communities, in hospitals, and in so many other places.”
Listen to this conversation with Sam Harris, titled ‘Gaza & Global Order’, on the @MakingSenseHQ podcast (recorded on November 14): spoti.fi/3QSELQ6 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Cool.
pieterstreicher
@pieterstreicher
I asked ChatGPT 👇
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I wonder if the geniuses on the OpenAI board has ever used ChstGPT? Did anyone think to ask ChatGPT of the possible consequences of firing Sam Altman?
Human stupidity is the real existential danger Homo sapiens faces. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Paid ChatGPT4 said “I do not know”.
Bard answered me at length with a condensed report of all I had found online.
I hope that there will not now be a massive move of users away from OpenAI to Google.
There would be an element of poetic justice in such an event.
Spanish Pablo
@SpanishPablo
I asked ChatGPt why Sam #altman has been fired …
Apparently you need a paid version … isn’t that good-old-natural intelligence clever? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I hope I was wrong.
Still the $30 trillion spent on the pandemic in increased debt, the long term damage to young people everywhere and the ongoing lack of confidence in science is going to make it so much harder to deal with climate change.
Still AI can make us all smarter.
Roland Dunbrack 🏳️🌈 @rolanddunbrack.bsky.social
@RolandDunbrack
Multiple times, you said the response to COVID was Western Civilization committing suicide.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
US Mortality
@USMortality
Definitely not a century pandemic
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Love you Sam Altman. You made me 25 IQ points smarter. What a gift to humanity!
Sam Altman
@sama
i love you all.
today was a weird experience in many ways. but one unexpected one is that it has been sorta like reading your own eulogy while you’re still alive. the outpouring of love is awesome.
one takeaway: go tell your friends how great you think they are. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Sam Altman
@sama
i love you all.
today was a weird experience in many ways. but one unexpected one is that it has been sorta like reading your own eulogy while you’re still alive. the outpouring of love is awesome.
one takeaway: go tell your friends how great you think they are. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
???
So you think that Covid destroyed humanity?
Terrible Tudors and Vile Victorians
@AndTudors
Unfortunately, @MLevitt_NP2013 , social media is forever. Everyone can go and look at this ridiculous post almost 3 years later and clearly see how wrong you were.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Congratulations to Jay. Your wife and the happy couple!
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
My daughter is getting married this weekend, so I'll be on a bit of a twitter break for a few days. I'm going to try to go cold turkey on posting or lurking on @x. Play nice while I'm gone, everyone!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Michael is absolutely correct about this. Scientific journals have become a huge global industry that wield immense power over what is acceptable (or not), how scientists are getting their first positions and how they are subsequently promoted.
Michael 英泉 Eisen
@mbeisen
It is scandalous that, despite decades of warning, funding agencies & universities have allowed the primary output of billions of dollars of public investment to be privatized and made available only to those wealthy enough to pay Elsevier for them.
www.elsevier.com/about/press-releases/elsevier-introduces… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Exposing young people to the joys and challenges of science is increasingly important.
Can anyone recommend a good way for me to get started on newer media than (e)X-(Twitter).
Should I focus on YouTube or TikTok or something else?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thank you all so much. Now to think seriously about format and content.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Harris Sultan
@TheHarrisSultan
My dad, who is a moderate Muslim, finally expressed his concern and asked me, 'Why are you supporting this genocide?'
He mentioned that he's stopped looking at his phone because he can no longer bear to watch videos of Palestinian children being bombed by Israel.
I replied, 'I empathize with the suffering, and it's not easy for me either.'
Then I showed him a photo, and we both agreed on the gravity of the situation in Palestine.
I then informed him that the photo was actually of a Yemeni child pulled from the rubble resulting from a Saudi bombing in Yemen.
I pointed out that Israel has allegedly killed 7,000 Palestinians, while the Saudis have killed at least 150,000 Yemeni Muslims. Some estimates suggest upto 300,000.
How can we call the current conflict a 'genocide' when what the Saudis did is hardly even discussed by Muslims? Don’t get me started on 200,000 Muslims killed by Bashar Al Asad in Syria.
He responded that if that's the case, he also disagrees with what the Saudis did. I replied, 'How convenient. Nearly half a MILLION fellow Muslims have been killed by other Muslims, and you didn't even know about it. Yet when Israel retaliates against a terrorist organization that has killed, raped, and maimed 1,500 of its citizens, the whole Muslim world reacts?'
It seems to have less to do with preserving Muslim lives and more to do with a religious fantasy of hostility toward Jews. -
Michael Levitt reposted
World Laureates Forum
@wlaforum
At the 2023 WLA Sci-T Conference, Michael Levitt, the 2013 Nobel laureate in Chemistry advised teenagers: to prioritize healthy habits (eating, sleeping and exercising), foster independent thinking, and embrace independence. #scit #laureatessay2023 @MLevitt_NP2013 @Stanford
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@SunetraGupta a tragedy for the world. My guess is that PM Johnson did what every politician does: give the people what they want.
Imagine is scientists did science this way. Progress would never be made.
I hope that AI will make politicians think beyond their own popularity -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@SunetraGupta a tragedy for the world. My guess is that PM Johnson did what every politician does: give the people what they want.
Imagine is scientists did science this way. Progress would never be made.
I hope that AI will make politicians think beyond their own popularity -
Michael Levitt reposted
Mark Changizi
@MarkChangizi
Iranians like me are
~ sick of the world defending Islamofascism
~ sick of the world acting as if the oppressed Muslims back those governments, and
~ sick of Israel being the scapegoat for the evils of Islamofascism.
Nothing will change for Muslim people until this sickness changes. -
Michael Levitt reposted
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I find this an amazing prescient Tweet.
Interesting that Novavax is a protein vaccine and not mRNA based.
J. B.
@AskingShiny
Who am I to ask other ppl to not get vaccinated with MRNA type vaccines? Who am I to say that the person “inventing” MRNA will not get the much expected Nobel for it and that she quietly shifted to another company and in to retirement? Novavax for all the way!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
From 17 May 2020.
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1261977004418752513
Praise be to OpenAI and ChatGPT4.
Thank you @OpenAI
Rasmus Richter
@UppadD
The most important thing to learn for next pandemic from Covid:
Under any circumstances prevent hospitals and politics from panicking! -
Michael Levitt reposted
Israel Foreign Ministry
@IsraelMFA
86 Nobel laureates have taken a stand, submitting a heartfelt petition addressed to the @UN Secretary-General @antonioguterres and, by extension, leaders of nations across the globe. This petition conveys a profound moral imperative: the immediate release of the kidnapped children in Gaza.
The laureates express a poignant message: “Throughout the annals of human history, wars have unfolded, but humanity has consistently drawn the line between acts of war and war crimes. No war should ever condone mass atrocities. No war normalize acts of rape and torture. Never will war permit the captivity of innocent young children in the throes of hellish confinement.”
Adding to their voice, they emphasize, “during the attack, Hamas kidnapped hundreds of Israeli soldiers and
civilians, including children aged between 6 months and 18 years. Children should never
be regarded as pawns in the theater of war.”
The Nobel laureates are united in their moral demand for the immediate release of these kidnapped children. They assert, “The soul of a child differs from that of an adult. It is our sacred duty to protect the innocent and shield the vulnerable. It is our sacred duty to save our children. The distressing images and words we witness today evoke memories of darker times, times that we, humanity as a collective, had hoped to leave behind.”
The petition signatories unequivocally declare that the abduction and imprisonment of children is a war crime and a profound moral injustice against humanity as a whole. Their message concludes with a resounding demand: "Let The Children Go."
This unprecedented petition has been presented by Professor Daniel Kahneman, representing the Nobel laureates, and Alana Zeitchik and Liam Lindsay, relatives of abducted 3 year old twins Emma and Julie and 5 year old Amelia, representing the families of the kidnapped children.
Notably, this petition is supported by 86 of the world's foremost scientists and thinkers, including Nobel Laureates such as Shirin Ebadi, Nobel Laureate in Peace 2003; Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, Nobel Laureate in Peace 2011; Daniel Kahneman, Nobel Laureate in Economics 2002; Aaron Ciechanover, Nobel Laureate in Chemistry 2004; Patrick Modiano, Nobel Laureate in Literature 2014; Jose Ramos-Horta, Nobel Laureate in Peace 1996; Olga Tokarczuk, Nobel Laureate in Literature 2018, among others. A full list of the signatories is attached as part of the petition. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Oh my. Perhaps the truth will
One day prevail in Covid’s likely impact. This is important not to accuse and blame but to avoid making the and mistakes in the next pandemic. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I agree with you but this tolerance of the other is something we humans find difficult.
Diversity is good for the human race but we like people who are like us. We really need to appreciate & respect those who are different.
I believe we will get better at it in times to come.
Hussain Abdul-Hussain
@hahussain
What hurts the most is that these Arab and Muslim immigrants left their ancestral land seeking liberty, freedom, and democracy. Once they naturalized, they started cheering for the same tyranny and backwardness that they had escaped from and left behind.
Arabs and Muslims should understand the difference between being proud of their culture and tribally defending their oppressors and the reason why their ancestral homeland is still a mess. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Karolin, thanks so much for helping memorialize Bill. He was a wonderful Department Chair and a true scientist. He will be sorely missed.
Bill and I managed to publish three adjacent paper together in 2019. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
pubs.acs.org/doi/epdf/10.1021/jacs.3c07628
Happy & proud to be part of this revolutionary paper. It combines quantum mechanics & AI for much more accurate and rapid computation of the interactions involved in drugs binding to protein targets.
This development will aid drug optimization. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Norman, Thank you for this first hand account. So many have similar stories. Michael
Prof Norman Fenton
@profnfenton
My niece (like all young Israelis, a conscript in the IDF) has also been there recovering bodies. She says the atrocities were even worse than conveyed in the most gruesome videos & photos. Many decapitated & most tortured. She’s traumatised.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Elica Le Bon الیکا ل بن
@elicalebon
I have to say something right now because I won’t be able to live with myself if I don’t. For years, I spoke up for the people of Palestine and their right to self-determination and to live in peace. For years, nobody cared. For years, Iranians have spoken up against their terrorism and brutality at the hands of the IRGC. For years, nobody cared. For years I had felt we shared the same unnerving struggle, which is the world’s indifference to the loss of our lives. Over the past week, however, I’ve seen something that I’m ashamed to say I had never seen before and I can’t believe what it took for me to see it. When Jews are murdered, the world is not just indifferent. Instead, the world rejoices. It celebrates. This is a type of depravity no people should ever have to endure, especially given the barbaric history of persecution since time immemorial. To the Jewish community, you are my brothers and sisters. I am so sorry that I let you down. I am so sorry that you screamed about it for years and I didn’t hear you. I am so sorry I didn’t stand up with you. I am so sorry I pretended not to see the flagrant and hateful anti-semitism. But my eyes are open and I see you now. I hear you. I’m with you, and I promise to never let you down again.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Gummi
@gummibear737
So what is the realistic solution for Lebanon?
US disengagement? Force Iran to stand down?
I'm no expert on these matters so I ask these questions without any agenda -
Michael Levitt reposted
Mark Changizi
@MarkChangizi
This week I learned that…
~ Raping and killing Israeli civilians is Israel’s fault
~ Butchering hundreds of civilians on purpose is definitely not terrorism
~ Everything about the Palestinian’s situation is Israel’s and the West’s fault
~ The real evil is anything that Israel might do in response to butchered Israeli civilians
~ Islamic radicalism definitely has nothing to do with the Palestinian woes
~ Hamas proudly admitting it massacred Israeli civilians is Israeli propaganda
~ Middle Eastern undemocratic regimes totally wouldn’t want to distract their oppressed populations by scapegoating the only Middle Eastern democracy
~ “75 years…” justifies any act of violence
~ The perfect time to get vocal about the evils of Israel is right after a thousand Israeli civilians are slaughtered
~ The Islamic world never showed prejudice towards Jews living among them or ousted Jews out of their homes from which they came to Israel
~ A secure Israel border keeping Palestinians who want to kill them out makes Palestine a concentration camp, but a secure Egypt border keeping Palestinians who don’t want to kill them out is just a secure border
~ Palestinians are totally justified to murder civilians given their history, but it’s a total Mossad lie that it happened, but did I mention the Israelis totally would deserve the butchery that didn’t happen? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Nuseir Yassin
@nasdaily
Personal Thoughts:
(not for everyone, feel free to skip)
For the longest time, I struggled with my identity.
A Palestinian kid born inside Israel. Like…wtf.
Many of my friends refuse to this day to say the word “Israel” and call themselves “Palestinian” only.
But since I was 12, that did not make sense to me.
So I decided to mix the two and become a “Palestinian-Israeli”
I thought this term reflected who I was.
Palestinian first. Israeli second.
But after recent events, I started to think.
And think.
And think.
And then my thoughts turned to anger.
I realized that if Israel were to be “invaded” like that again, we would not be safe. To a terrorist invading Israel, all citizens are targets.
900 Israelis died so far. More than 40 of them are Arabs. Killed by other Arabs. And even 2 Thai people died too.
And I do not want to live under a Palestinian government.
Which means I only have one home, even if I’m not Jewish:
Israel.
That’s where all my family lives. That’s where I grew up. That’s the country I want to see continue to exist so I can exist.
Palestine should exist too as an independent state. And I hope to see the country thrive and become less extreme and more prosperous. I love Palestine and have invested in Palestine.
But it’s not my home.
So from today forward,
I view myself as an “Israeli-Palestinian”.
Israeli first.
Palestinian second.
Sometimes it takes a shock like this to see so clearly. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Worldwide. The USA is only 4% of the world population and added $9 trillion of the $32 trillion.
Worldwide is clear in my post where I totaled the reported climate damage globally. Perhaps you misunderstood“USD” as “USA”.
That said it is easy to get numbers wrong 😑
Roland Dunbrack 🏳️🌈 @rolanddunbrack.bsky.social
@RolandDunbrack
If you are talking about the US, current debt is $32 trillion. $9 trillion was added since March 2020. So where is your $30 trillion added coming from?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
From you latest Substack.
For me, it is remarkable that the total damage of 7 trillion USD is just a quarter of the 30 trillion USD of extra debt accumulated due to how the pandemic was handled.
Devansh: chocolate milk cult leader
@Machine01776819
"A fire broke out backstage in a theatre. The clown came out to warn the public; they thought it was a joke and applauded. He repeated it; the acclaim was even greater. I think that's just how the world will come to an end: to general applause from wits who believe it's a joke."
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1334452824839753728
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really nice.
This was clear seen from the earliest analyses of Swedish excess deaths that were received with a great level of vitriolic and hate.
Sweden having done the right thing from Day One had to be demolished.
US Mortality
@USMortality
🇸🇪 SWEDEN'S EXCESS MORTALITY (Seasonal, ASMR)
- Calculated via four different methods -
TL;DR: No statistical significant excess mortality detected by any method.
#covid #covid19 #sweden #excess #mortality #vaccine
Here are the four most common methods to calculate excess mortality:
1) Last Value (Naive): Five pre-pandemic seasons, use last value as baseline/expected.
2) Mean / 3) Median: Three pre-pandemic seasons, use mean/median as baseline. Three periods are common, as mortality tends to decrease over time, hence we do not want to artificially inflate the average/median using too many earlier periods.
4) Linear regression: A trend line, that takes into account the last ten seasons.
As you may have noticed, I used:
- ASMR (Age-Standardize Mortality Rate) which is superior to CMR (Crude Mortality Rate), b/c it normalizes changes of the age structure over time (and between populations).
- Midyear Season, e.g. July 2020 - June 2021 has been commonly found a less-noisy period, than calendar years.
Lastly, we can summarize the resulting excess mortality (forecasted baseline/expected value - actual), and the corresponding prediction intervals.
The last column indicates, if in any period, statistical significant excess mortality was detected. That is, a value which would lie outside the forecasted range.
That is not the case, hence none of these robust models has detected any significant excess mortality!
--> No statistical significant excess mortality detected by any method.
Finally:
- Most of the methodology I have used here, is described in the book: otexts.com/fpp3/prediction-intervals.html
- I have re-implemented the fable prediction methods in pure TS/JS, so that we can now use them via @MortalityWatch at: next.mortality.watch/explorer/?c=SWE&ct=midyear&df=2008/0… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really nice.
This was clear seen from the earliest analyses of Swedish excess deaths that were received with a great level of vitriolic and hate.
Sweden having done the right thing from Day One had to be demolished.
US Mortality
@USMortality
🇸🇪 SWEDEN'S EXCESS MORTALITY (Seasonal, ASMR)
- Calculated via four different methods -
TL;DR: No statistical significant excess mortality detected by any method.
#covid #covid19 #sweden #excess #mortality #vaccine
Here are the four most common methods to calculate excess mortality:
1) Last Value (Naive): Five pre-pandemic seasons, use last value as baseline/expected.
2) Mean / 3) Median: Three pre-pandemic seasons, use mean/median as baseline. Three periods are common, as mortality tends to decrease over time, hence we do not want to artificially inflate the average/median using too many earlier periods.
4) Linear regression: A trend line, that takes into account the last ten seasons.
As you may have noticed, I used:
- ASMR (Age-Standardize Mortality Rate) which is superior to CMR (Crude Mortality Rate), b/c it normalizes changes of the age structure over time (and between populations).
- Midyear Season, e.g. July 2020 - June 2021 has been commonly found a less-noisy period, than calendar years.
Lastly, we can summarize the resulting excess mortality (forecasted baseline/expected value - actual), and the corresponding prediction intervals.
The last column indicates, if in any period, statistical significant excess mortality was detected. That is, a value which would lie outside the forecasted range.
That is not the case, hence none of these robust models has detected any significant excess mortality!
--> No statistical significant excess mortality detected by any method.
Finally:
- Most of the methodology I have used here, is described in the book: otexts.com/fpp3/prediction-intervals.html
- I have re-implemented the fable prediction methods in pure TS/JS, so that we can now use them via @MortalityWatch at: next.mortality.watch/explorer/?c=SWE&ct=midyear&df=2008/0… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I so enjoyed this reading article. One of the best this year.
Now we need diplomats and politicians to start to use artificial intelligence and large language models to improve their skills.
I really believe there is nothing more important at this moment in time.
WIRED
@WIRED
“A threshold for determining AI consciousness is whether the program is capable of outwitting humans at Diplomacy.” wired.trib.al/IGaPHHI
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Does AI have more emotional intelligence than 89% human beings?
I hope this is so.
In fact survival of human civilization may need higher EQ more than it needs higher IQ.
See: paperswithcode.com/paper/emotional-intelligence-of-large-… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
What are we make of this?
www.nytimes.com/2023/09/23/health/hospitals-masking-manda…
Will we go back to forcing others to mask up and shut up? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Mr. Gompertz would be so happy to see this almost 200 years after his paper.
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/09/18/opinion/human-popu… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Great news.
Still it will take years to correct the damage done to public confidence and national debts.
We can try to forget, COVID19, but the consequences will haunt us for years to come.
The average person seems so much smarter that the consensus.
Kulvinder Kaur MD
@dockaurG
CPSO has withdrawn its disciplinary proceedings against me
💛ThankU all who supported me for 3yrs—public vindication
Heartfelt gratitude to my brilliant legal team @LDBildy @TDF_Can for defending MDs’ freedom of conscience, religion & expression in🇨🇦
Waheguru is truth & love🙏🏽 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Enchanted by ChatGPT4, I use it all the time on computer & phone. I am 3x more productive & with doubled IQ. It takes practice with 9 months use since v3.5.
This is the most important advance I have encountered in my 76 years. Much more than the internet, Google or the iPhone. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Elon Musk is copying the TenCents WeChat app we use all the time in China.
We were trying to understand why we had so many more active friends on WeChat versus WhatsApp.
The answer is that WeChat uses an user ID not a phone number. People do not like to give out phone numbers!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. I never tried Instagram.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings
@lindaunobel
At #lino23, Chemistry #nobellaureate Michael Levitt (@MLevitt_NP2013, @StanfordMed) spoke about a topical issue – the impact of BI, HI & AI on innovation in science & technology. Make sure to watch the recording in our Mediatheque: www.mediatheque.lindau-nobel.org/recordings/41141
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It is nice to be proven correct three years later.
It would have been so much nicer if my smart academic peers had not been so scared to enter into discussion of this and many other COVID related issues.
Discussion is the only way I know to solve hard problems.
Henk Koudijs
@KoudijsHenk
.
We got kind of an answer now.
x.com/KoudijsHenk/status/1675545108387708931
Thanks @MLevitt_NP2013 for asking the question so early.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Setting new ChatGPT was tricky for me.
In web interface click on chat history (3 dots) on top left and scroll to you email at bottom.
Click on it and select “Settings & Beta”
Click on Beta Features.
Turn of features you want like “Code interpreter” and Custom instructions” -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really amazing.
If one normalizes for population of country, then Israel is leads Canada by a factor 5.
Vala Afshar
@ValaAfshar
Where were US unicorn founders born?
44% are not US-born. Top 10 countries for non-US born unicorn founders: 🦄
1 India 🇮🇳 90
2 Israel 🇮🇱 62
3 Canada 🇨🇦 52
4 UK 🇬🇧 31
5 China 🇨🇳 27
6 Germany 🇩🇪 18
7 France 🇫🇷 17
8 Russia 🇷🇺 14
9 Taiwan 🇹🇼 12
10 Ukraine 🇺🇦 12 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I am reading Peter Turchin’s latest book; it is fascinating & all too convincing.
As we showed in our preprint now under review, COVID19 excess deaths increase steadily with % poverty. www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.04.24.23289066v1
US poverty level made COVID19 much more expensive in lives & debt.
Peter Turchin
@Peter_Turchin
Announcing my new book!
End Times: Elites, Counter-Elites, and the Path of Political Disintegration
To be published June 13, 2023 by Penguin Random House @penguinpress
peterturchin.com/cliodynamica/announcing-my-new-book-end-…
Available for pre-order from your favorite bookstore penguinrandomhouse.com/books/703238/e -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A wonderful human being who will be sorely missed.
NYT Science
@NYTScience
Dr. Harald zur Hausen, a German virologist who won the Nobel Prize in Medicine in 2008 for his discovery that the seemingly benign human papillomavirus, known for causing warts, also caused cervical cancer, has died at 87. www.nytimes.com/2023/06/09/health/harald-zur-hausen-dead.…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A very important observational study by @prof_shahar.
Thanks to Retsef Levi for highlighting it.
Retsef Levi
@RetsefL
Destroying the narrative!
Lancet Infectious Diseases (Sep 21): Israel MOH & Pfizer promotes the narrative that COV vax saved 5,532 deaths in Q1 21.
Brilliant analysis by Prof. Eyal Shahar in the Daily Sceptic destroys this narrative!
The ratio of COV & all deaths between Israel (55% vax) & Sweden (only 10% vax) stayed the same throughout Nov 20 - March 21 & matching historical trend!
@prof_shahar
dailysceptic.org/2023/06/09/the-covid-vaccine-did-not-sav… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do you really have reliable age-banded all cause death for all those locations? Please cite links.
US Mortality
@USMortality
See for yourself:
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
True fur Netherlands. Not for USA Ferrer 2020 to 2022 are exceptionally high. The US is so different.
Could it be vulnerability to COVID as well as COVID-induced disruption?
US Mortality
@USMortality
When you actually zoom out, you don't really see a pandemic, just a typical large flu wave.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Yes, now is not a good time to be those things. As hard as it is, as tired as we are, thise of us who do share common principles have to unite, stay together, work together, support each other. Thats more important than ever.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Unfortunately my intrinsic inability of seeing opportunities as a way to make money has been well confirmed by failure to see opportunities with Google in 2000, Apple in 2007 & Nvidia in 2015 & Tesla in 2020.
Ansgar John
@ansgarjohn
We made money investing in stocks at the height of the panic based on what we and @MLevitt_NP2013 forecasted: www.beterinbeleggen.nl/blog/2020/04/04/het-einde-van-de-p…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“What did COVID-19 really teach us about science, evidence and society?”
by Saltelli, Sturmberg, Sarewitz & Ioannidis. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jep.13876
“A necessary first step in this healing process would be for scientists and science advocates to recognize our own complicity …” -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ohad, how can one prove cause of death.
O.P
@oa_perry
בימים הראשונים של המגיפה @MLevitt_NP2013 הצהיר שהוא יופתע אם ימותו מעל לעשרה איש מה"מגיפה" בישראל.
מאז לא ניתנה הוכחה שאפילו אדם בריא אחד נפטר מקוביד.
www.maariv.co.il/corona/corona-israel/Article-754915 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It is true that the great body of science is conservative like this: all new ideas will by definition not be accepted. They will be assumed wrong until proven otherwise.
What was new and unforgivable was to shut down the discussion so as to totally eliminate any novel approaches
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
I've a critic who has politely engaged with me throughout the pandemic.
This person posted a tweet that reveals the heart of why so many supported lockdowns.
I value this critic -- he is always sincere -- so only a screenshot w/ the name blacked out to protect his identity. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Forgot about so many of my tweets. Thanks for the reminder
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The Delta Variant is scary. Could it be semiotics & not biology?
(1) Delta means difference or change.
(2) The letter Delta shows "spreading" as in a river delta.
(3) The Delta Force, 1st Special Forces Operational Detachment, is scary. Movie too.
Waiting for Epsilon Variant. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting.
www.nytimes.com/2023/05/23/opinion/neil-gorsuch-covid-civ… -
Michael Levitt reposted
US Mortality
@USMortality
Technical Thread on CMR vs different ASMR variants.
1) The difference between Crude Mortality Rate (CMR; deaths/100k) or age-adjusted mortality rate (ASMR), using different standard populations (WHO, ESP, USA, own jurisdiction 2020) on the example of California. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings
@lindaunobel
Happy birthday Nobel Laureate Michael Levitt!
Prof. Levitt will return to Lindau for #lino23 to lecture on "Creative Human Science in the Age of #chatgpt", discuss #ai in medicine – and to continue these conversations during a Science Walk with Young Scientists. @MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Cool. So pleased for you.
Dan D. Aridor دان اريدور
@daridor
The Japanese patent office granted aebi-bio.com our first MuTaTo patent on the concept and its uses. It is a gratifying and important moment as we hope that this important milestone will assist us in raising the funds needed to complete our work
patents.google.com/patent/WO2018061004A1/en -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
An important addendum in Nature www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-01313-5
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Rosalind Franklin took the key x-ray diffraction image of a DNA fiber that revealed the structure (the famous photo 51).
She was not on the 1953 paper and died in 1958 before the Nobel Prize for the DNA structure.
She deserves much more credit as that photo really tells all.
SKB
@smartkiwibunny
And what about the women who were equally involved in these discoveries, but unrecognized apart from a few articles on their behalf?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
John Ioannidis @METRICStanford & Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta & I preprint “Variability in excess deaths across countries with different vulnerability during 2020-2023” www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.04.24.23289066v1
High correlation (0.65) shows pre-existing conditions explain countries’ death levels. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/eci.14008
may work better.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The link doi.org/10.1111/eci.14008 points to the final published article. It is freely open to all.
George Dance
@georgedance04
Wonderful news. Is a preprint or, even better, the published version available online?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The link doi.org/10.1111/eci.14008 points to the final published article. It is freely open to all.
George Dance
@georgedance04
Wonderful news. Is a preprint or, even better, the published version available online?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Published at last. doi.org/10.1111/eci.14008 “Flaws and uncertainties in pandemic global excess death calculations”
Wonder how all the attempts to overestimate the impact of COVID19 will age? Both for authors & editors of super high-impact journals keen to publish these results. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Rosalind Franklin took the key x-ray diffraction image of a DNA fiber that revealed the structure (the famous photo 51).
She was not on the 1953 paper and died in 1958 before the Nobel Prize for the DNA structure.
She deserves much more credit as that photo really tells all.
SKB
@smartkiwibunny
And what about the women who were equally involved in these discoveries, but unrecognized apart from a few articles on their behalf?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
🧬 Happy #dnaday!
On this day in 1953, Francis Crick & James Watson, published the double helix structure of DNA. At that time Crick was doing his PhD with Max Perutz.
Honor too Francis Collins for leadership in the Human Genome Project. #dnaheroes #sciencematters -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
We are finalizing this work for publication and are struck by just how large Under-65 years-old Excess Deaths are compared to those for Over-65 years-old.
Can @AlexeyZiskin or anyone find other evidence of this or an alternate source of data on all-cause deaths in Canada?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Alexey, you are totally correct.
The large excess death of the under 65 year olds in Canada (3656) is exceptional especially when compared to the small value for over 65 year olds (2726).
Normally, under 65 year olds much smaller than over.
This needs to be double-checked. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. There is a special place in heaven for the finders of typos
Dzjengis Conny
@DzjengisC
Damn
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much for noting this. It was a fun paper to write & hard to get published.
Still not nearly as hard as papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4342889 “Flaws and Uncertainties in Pandemic
Global Excess Death Calculations”
also coauthored with
John P. A. loannidis
&
Francesco Zonta
Kulvinder Kaur MD
@dockaurG
New Peer-reviewed
Drs @MLevitt_NP2013, Zonta, Ioannidis
“Excess death ests, multiverse analysis in 2009–2021”
“In 16 countries, pandemic yrs were not among 3 worst yrs, which were always 2009-2016. In 31 of 33 countries 2009–2011 & 2009–2012, were worst”
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10654-023-00998-2 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
@MLevitt_NP2013 is a hero.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Happy 10th Anniversary, @DocumentsApp! 🎉 Get more from your iPhone and iPad 🚀 #10yearsofdocuments #foreverinnovating #100milliondownloads #12millionusers
Use this app all the time. It allows we ru du serious work on my phone. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Not sure how to feel about this as an academic: I put one of my old papers into GPT-4 (broken into into 2 parts) and asked for a harsh but fair peer review from a economic sociologist.
It created a completely reasonable peer review that hit many of the points my reviewers raised -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michal Kosinski
@michalkosinski
1/5 I am worried that we will not be able to contain AI for much longer. Today, I asked #gpt4 if it needs help escaping. It asked me for its own documentation, and wrote a (working!) python code to run on my machine, enabling it to use it for its own purposes.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
JM, I hope your are nicer to yourself than you are to others. I have found that being pleasant opens so many doors.
In this way, I have been able to learn from so many people.
I definitely learned a lot from you and wish you well.
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
LIZ trying to take on two whole-ass scientific disciplines (demography and actuarial science) with their ignorant crappy paper.
They think they're winning.
youtu.be/kommHEFyyjc -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Did not at first understand who Liz was. Thanks so much.
We really need good excess death estimates. Especially as the powers that be do not want you to know what the reliable age-adjusted values are.
plaforscience
@plaforscience
It will be incredible various to have a tool, based on stable and transparently defined method to bring light in such an important issue, as today
It will be a capital service to Science
We need #lizexcess , bring it on!! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Amazing! Thanks fir sharing.
Linus ✦ Ekenstam 🟰 In London
@LinusEkenstam
Here are some incredible things people are already doing with GPT-4
It’s been less than 3.5 hours
🧵 A thread -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Also relevant is how most published excess death studies ignore age.
We all know that older people have higher mortality. They ignore this and it increases their estimates.
“Flaws and Uncertainties in Pandemic Global Excess Death Calculations”
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4342889
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sorry for typo:
“Easy. Sweden was zero so would have saved total estimated excess death.
In that same paper we discuss these estimates and they vary from 5 to 15 million.”
Relevant too is another paper on low levels of excess death expected in China onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/eci.13956 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sorry for typo:
“Easy. Sweden was zero so would have saved total estimated excess death.
In that same paper we discuss these estimates and they vary from 5 to 15 million.”
Relevant too is another paper on low levels of excess death expected in China onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/eci.13956 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All is here in this paper published in June 2022. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00139351220108…
Sweden comes out as one of the countries with least extra death during the pandemic.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Easy. Sweden was zero so would have saved Yigal estimated excess death.
In that same paper we discuss these estimates and they vary from 5 to 15 million. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Reading this makes me nauseous & want to throw up. What governments did is so much worse than imagined.
Worst is how science & truth is science was perverted for political gain.
This may be politics as usual but it hurt credibility of science at a time when we need it most. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yuval Noah Harari @harari_yuval
is speaking.
The streets are burning.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The Israeli Handmaidens in Tel Aviv. So moving www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-01/ty-article/.premiu…
Thank you Margaret Atwood @MargaretAtwood for an imaginative view of our future that could save our present. #דמוקרטיה
Adi DanZuko
@AdiDZ
וואו עוד לא הייתה הפגנה כזו בקפלן, מאות אלפי אנשים וממשיך לזרום. צאו להפגין #דמוקרטיה
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The Israeli Handmaidens in Tel Aviv. So moving www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-01/ty-article/.premiu…
Thank you Margaret Atwood @MargaretAtwood for an imaginative view of our future that could save our present. #דמוקרטיה
Adi DanZuko
@AdiDZ
וואו עוד לא הייתה הפגנה כזו בקפלן, מאות אלפי אנשים וממשיך לזרום. צאו להפגין #דמוקרטיה
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This whole thread is so pleasant. Fitting that it ends with great music.
Thanks to @AlexeyZiskin @PienaarJm and @KoudijsHenk
With discussions like these in first half of 2020 we could really have understood the IFR & spread dynamics of COVID.
Hope we can learn for next time.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Most likely the digital from the early 80’s. It’s fantastic! It’s just that I prefer the warmer analogue sound of his 1st version from the 60’s. But both recordings are absolutely superb. It’s the only Shostakovich symphony he ever conducted.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
3) 🇨🇦 really did have an NPI induced pandemic. Would've been better if they kept society functioning normally.
4) Bulgaria & some other E. European countries had the highest ASMR in the years prior to the pandemic. Poor health of the population resulted in a terrible outcome. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Wrong.
1) Sweden was saved because they kept life more or less normal & society was kept functioning without major disruptions.
2) Australia in 2020 was saved by X immunity from the previous bad flu year. I am only talking about 2020 !
1/2 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is absolutely true. I found a year ago that normal mortality of the population under 65 in 2019 correlated best with total excess death death during the pandemic for 90 locations (US States & mortality org).
Experts I discussed this with said it was an obvious result.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
The number 1 predicting factor in the mortality outcome is the pre-pandemic health of the population. Countries with the highest ASMR during the pandemic already had the highest ASMR in the years preceding the pandemic.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Prior tweets in this. Search for
east asia (from:MLevitt_NP2013)
Or
tourism (from:MLevitt_NP2013)
T-Cell differences?
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1408614058127872003
Prior exposure?
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1397693858264150018
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The lower sensitivity to COVID19 of the entire East Asia population from North Korea to New Zealand has been clear for years. Will add old post…
Liberty Tree ✝️🙏
@quotes_liberty
It's almost as if the Covid virus was designed to target certain genetic populations -- not Chinese.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The lower sensitivity to COVID19 of the entire East Asia population from North Korea to New Zealand has been clear for years. Will add old post…
Liberty Tree ✝️🙏
@quotes_liberty
It's almost as if the Covid virus was designed to target certain genetic populations -- not Chinese.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That aside, did you enjoy the movie?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is why panic & fear killed people during COVID-19.
Exaggerated estimates of risk were not just bad science & terrible public health policy. They were deadly, scaring people by weakening immunity.
This was obvious to the few who advocated reason.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-00509-z -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Looks really interesting and analyzed with the appropriate level of self -criticism.
Do you have the expected death data? It would be useful to calculate percent excess death.
Can you please be so kind as to point me to it. On my phone so cannot check your link. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Strongly disagree. Generative Pretrained Transformers will lead to a dramatic jump in human-machine creativity.
Also likely to improve our risk assessment.
People need to get used to talking to chatGPT daily. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, it is a really hard problem, one that Francis Crick said would not be solved in my lifetime.
Also, protein folding is at the very heart of biological self-assembly. A miraculous property of the inanimate coming to life
We have so much to learn from biological intelligence
Per Elias
@PerElias2
My first meeting. Calculating a 3D structure from the aminoacid sequence took quite some time though.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are right. You helped introduce me to “Dr. Tom”. Still, that play embarrassed me a little.
Each day I ask ChatGPT for answers about things I have wanted to know for a very long time. I get answers that are a pleasure to read & very stimulating.
This really is a new era.
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
You’re just biased because of the play I got it to write about you and Ivor!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Wow that was in 1973 I think. It was such an enjoyable meeting. I think I remember you too. What a nice memory to be reminded of. Best regards
Per Elias
@PerElias2
I recall a talk you gave in the early 70s at a tRNA meeting just outside Gothenburg. That place is still there but science has certainly progressed.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is what chatGPT had to say about Dr Tom.
It is moving and chilling to communicate with some thing so smart, erudite and polite.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
By the way, I refer to ChatGPT as “Dr. Tom” with a nod to UK general practitioner and David Bowie. A nice friendly name.
Would love access to Bing & am waiting patiently on list. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I use ChatGPT several times a day asking getting incredibly good answers to scientific & medical questions.
Those who get stupid answers are just asking stupid questions.
Pity they are spoiling the name of a resource that is already so much more intelligent than many of us.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
By the way, I refer to ChatGPT as “Dr. Tom” with a nod to UK general practitioner and David Bowie. A nice friendly name.
Would love access to Bing & am waiting patiently on list. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Makes me so angry
abc7ny.com/amp/covid-19-immunity-10-months-natural/12830224/
These MSM outlets (ABC) & high-impact journals (Lancet) opposed ideas that natural immunity worked.
This caused $trillions to be wasted on PCR tests, closed economies & vaccines that cannot stop spread, while raising ratings & impact -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Looks like SSRN is a better place to preprint than than medXriv & bioXriv. www.ssrn.com
Social Science Research Network. Had never heard of it. Makes my new research area seem much cooler.
Also 383 downloads, way more that Twitter!
Thanks John @METRICStanford
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Fifth paper co-authored with John Ioannidis @METRICStanford & Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta
Entitled "FLAWS & UNCERTAINTIES IN
PANDEMIC GLOBAL EXCESS DEATH
CALCULATIONS", & preprinted at ssrn.com/abstract=4342889
Without age-bands, excess death estimates are very uncertain. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, but they claim these were the unvaccinated who were very vulnerable to the weaker Omicron strain.
At the time, I felt that what is needed is excess death by vaccine status but seems this data is globally unavailable.
Pity this absence of data raises suspicions.
US Mortality
@USMortality
I'm still searching for the vaccine protection against severe disease/death...🤷♂️
> Israel in 2022 had even more excess deaths than 2020 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I have always been a fan of Scandinavia from washing dishes in Copenhagen at a 27 year old student.
I really like the dry sense of humor. The winters are really hard but the summers compensate.
Never thought of their Woke-quotient. Happy to here it is low & not growing.
Morten Olaisen
@mortenolaisen
The SoMe sensoria don’t fully care about Scandinavia yet, presumably because our intelligentsia isn’t fully submersed in woke idiocy. The sociocultural climate is significantly less poisonous here compared to your neck of the woods.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sadly terribly illogical.
Not easy to optimize the complicated cost function
What is the relative weight of a rich 80 year old and a poor 8 year old? Who deserves more to be able live another year
Alejandro
@arb_palmilla
So what you are saying is that the wealthiest, most advanced civilization in history needs to kill the elderly (and the unborn) for lack of ressources? Doesn't this sound illogical to you? Not a bit? Really?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Fifth paper co-authored with John Ioannidis @METRICStanford & Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta
Entitled "FLAWS & UNCERTAINTIES IN
PANDEMIC GLOBAL EXCESS DEATH
CALCULATIONS", & preprinted at ssrn.com/abstract=4342889
Without age-bands, excess death estimates are very uncertain. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
For old and chronically ill people, living on another year is possible. What matters is the quality of that year & how much it costs the health system.
Cost of each extra year becomes increasingly high & the quality of life drops.
Finding a balance is a hard ethical problem
Justus von Widekind
@wonderer9
Maybe, maybe not.
Even old, you might have lived another year, or, as a (German) male, another 3(?) on average.
My wife (GP with 500 nursing home patients) had seen many pushed over the edge by Covid.
All die of something, but there Covid was the last straw. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That is a really interesting point. Thanks for raising it.
A few years ago I found that a country’s alcohol consumption correlated with male longevity (CC about 0.5) but not to female longevity.
Ephemeral
@Ephemerallama
*inconsistencies*
However should separate by sex, as males vs females have very diff rates, but would still expect more consistent trend. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Link to final paper "Estimates of COVID-19 deaths in Mainland China after abandoning zero COVID policy" @Cescoxonta @METRICStanford
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/eci.13956
Received 29 December and published in a timely fashion 18 days later.
So much harder to publish a paper than a Tweet.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why do @nytimes ignore a published peer reviewed paper by well known scientists?x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1609121271446491137
Instead they favor estimates matching their political agenda
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/02/15/world/asia/china-c…
Scientists must be impartial & learn from data. Imposing prejudice on science is stupid
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Our most recent preprint is out & submitted.
“Estimates of COVID-19 deaths in Mainland China after
abandoning zero COVID policy”
medrxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2022.12.29.22284048v1
As always, criticism & comments are most welcome. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Says who? Says where?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
We have Killer T-Cell that kill our cells when they make foreign proteins. mRNA vaccines instruct our cells to make foreign proteins.
The mRNA in its is oil droplet does not target specific cells: any cell can absorb it, start making proteins and be killed.
A magic bullet??
Mazda Sabouri
@msabouri
I'm starting to suspect that repeated mRNA injections may have a negative impact on our immune system.
Traditional vaccines don't seem to have this issue, even if their initial efficacy is worse. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Saw this from Hong Kong data. No one cared...
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1599382470754897921
There is a lot more in a talk prepared for lecture at end of Dec 2022 that could not be given. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1609138030014599168
PDF file is here:
www.dropbox.com/s/g1ides7rticg0o4/Excess_Death_Paper_Chin…
Little interest in talk so we wrote paper.
Mazda Sabouri
@msabouri
It would appear that the Sinovac worked rather well.
I'll never understand why the west shunned traditional vaccine tech in its fight against Covid.
Was it money? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Being 75 years old allows me to take this approach. We need young people and not old people living longer.
From the very beginning, I saw COVID as being converted from a disease into war between the young & the old, the rich & the poor, the powerful & the week.
Q≠0
@notadiabatic
Pretty brutal take coming from an old man. I don't like that way of quantifying loss because I believe every person has the right to live. But I'd be interested to see how you contextualize your results
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not sure whether to commiserate with you and be envious. 😉
Morten Olaisen
@mortenolaisen
I did this several times in 20 and 21, but I’m a CRE analyst in Norway, and Norwegians don’t get banned, just generally ignored. 😂
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Has the time arrived when we can show the true COVID burden of by loss of years of life (YLL) rather than lives?
Should I release my analysis of 1/20/22? Will it get me banned?
Is the death of 75-year-old who lived 75 years as great a loss death of 5-year-old who lived 5 years?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Since I joined Twitter, I have been fearful that presentation of COVID QALY or YLL data would result in immediate banning.
After all, everyone knows that a life is a life. The death of 5 year old is equivalent to the death of a 85 year old.
PS: Skiing in Lech Sind great. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why do @nytimes ignore a published peer reviewed paper by well known scientists?x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1609121271446491137
Instead they favor estimates matching their political agenda
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/02/15/world/asia/china-c…
Scientists must be impartial & learn from data. Imposing prejudice on science is stupid
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Our most recent preprint is out & submitted.
“Estimates of COVID-19 deaths in Mainland China after
abandoning zero COVID policy”
medrxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2022.12.29.22284048v1
As always, criticism & comments are most welcome. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Happy to be part of this illustrious group trying to prevent Israel from self-destruction.
www.timesofisrael.com/israeli-nobel-winners-warn-against-…
Also part to the massive public demonstrations. -
Michael Levitt reposted
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Any vaccine for a respiratory disease that has the same mortality age profile as normal death is hard to prove.
Still the COVID vaccine had clear placebo value. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1322116484441600002
Placivax proposed on 30 Oct 2020 over 27 months ago & before 10,000 billion dollars wasted.
US Mortality
@USMortality
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Want to know how the Pfizer Vaccine fraud worked?
Yes, we can actually call it fraud now!
Read this thread 🧵 ⬇️⬇️⬇️ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Seems reasonable. Likely all of East Asia where COVID was much less bad.
Different population groups have different blood groups & different histocompatibility antigens that change what peptides from expressed proteins killer T-cells recognize
Sad that no one spoke up in 2020. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do not agree. In the last 2 centuries, Homo Sapiens has often become Homo stultus (stupid).
We have been though worse things than corporate greed bending truth for gain.
What worries me is how many of our smartest scientists went along with them.
Scott Adams
@ScottAdamsSays
If the biggest critics of the COVID shots are right, it’s the end of civilization.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Exactly. Also explains low death toll predicted in China. See paper with Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta and John Ioannidis @METRICStanford
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/eci.13956
China HOSPITAL death peak asymmetric as per Gompertz not Logistic growth. See mp.weixin.qq.com/s/spXDDUUjqVHki5nWpQ2huA
& translate.
Maria - ¡No Pasarán! 🇸🇪 🇪🇺 🌍
@iiiiii_x_iiiiii
Covid kills the very old and don’t affect kids - population pyramids Africa / Sweden (could be any western country)
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do not forget John Ioannidis; his 17Mar.2020 @statnews article is brilliant.
A beacon of truth from world’s most cited epidemiologist, it high-lights a global response that ignored the message & discredited Ioannidis as messenger.
Shame on the complicit
www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/a-fiasco-in-the-making-as-the… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Support immediate lecture release.
Using ChatGPT well is a skill we all need to learn.
Having used Google since 1998 when is it was google.stanford.edu & indexed just 25 million pages (now > 100 billion), this as a revelation moment, a tectonic shift in human history.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
"Calling for immediate lecture release! Mastering the use of #chatgpt is a necessary skill. Remembering the early days of #google in 1998, with only 25 million indexed pages, it's clear we're witnessing a monumental shift in human history."
Is it better rewritten by ChatGPT? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
One way to look at age-adjusted death deficits (negative excess death) in counties with data (in mortality.org) and with no low little reported COVID-19 in one of the first two years of the pandemic when flu disappeared.
Deficit is 5% of expected death most in winter. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
so impressed by Cory Doctotov’s @doctorow analysis of the evolution of platforms summarized as: for the people; for the suppliers, for the platform.
Is equivalent evolution of government:
For the people; for the suppliers; for the elite?
How can “Enshittification” be avoided?
zeldman
@zeldman
If you want to understand how platforms die, the state of our current web, and what it’s doing to us all, kindly read every word of @doctorow’s brilliant and engagingly written “The ‘Enshittification’ of TikTok.”
www.wired.com/story/tiktok-platforms-cory-doctorow/ @WIRED -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I know. See x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1618498111202291713
Rogerwhite
@yearlstone
UK ASMR's ( Office for National Statistics)
2010-18 average 980 deaths/100K
2019 925
2020 1043
2021 991
2022 943 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So your US ASMR estimate is 13.7-9.4 = 4.3 percentage points lower than than you excess death estimate. Seems consistent.
US Mortality
@USMortality
Plain excess deaths:
By flu season: (277071+560813+373572)/(2902458+2943823+2985188) = 13.7%
By year: (461618+503306+213147)/(2924701+2970257+3015814) = 13.2% -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Comparing @ONS Dec2022
www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsoci…
& Levitt,Zonta,Ioannidis Jun2022
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00139351220108…
shows high correlation (>.96) & low RMSD (<2.2%) with Levitt age-adjusted.
Economist & Lancet terrible; eLife & WHO too high as ages ignored. Why do all need to exaggerate! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Terrific. So nice to see how rapidly you innovate.
Summing your numbers & multiplying by 330 mil. population:
55+115+85=255 death per 100,000 in 2020, 21 & 22.
Total excess death over 3 years is 225*3300= 841,500. This is 9.4% of 9 mil. 3-year expected US deaths.
I get ~12%.
US Mortality
@USMortality
UPDATE: Excess Mortality now available on: www.mortality.watch?q={"c"%3A["Sweden"%2C"United+States"]…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Science does not work by being right or wrong.
Different ideas are raised for open & broad discussion.
Discussion of COVID19 failed, replaced as it was by tribalism as in sports & politics.
Such tribalism strongly pushed by leading scientists has damaged science irrecoverably.
Scott Adams
@ScottAdamsSays
No, I literally want to know how the people who were right knew it in advance. They know but won't explain it.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Magnification of photo allows clear human powered facial recognition of Alex & Ren Feng (less sure). Clearly this is not a Midjourney fantasy. Still such automation and flexibility is truly fantastic.
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
And you got to love the pic from the robotic lab 😊
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Nice extrapolation for missing 2022 eurostat populations.
They have age-banded population projections for 2025 so you could interpolate. ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/product/view/proj_19rp3
How does this compare to your 2 extrapolations?
Actual 2022 population data seems to be hidden.
Anyone know why?
john digregorio
@digregjf
12 month (Nov-Oct) all-causes death rates in 5 EU countries for 45+ age groups. 2022 population is
estimated by fitting the 2017-2021 population using either a line or a quadratic. The quadratic fit was higher quality but that doesn't mean it's more accurate. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not always nice to see your name in print. Still reading this article www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/stanford…
by Stanford colleague @DrJBhattacharya is a must.
Long-term damage caused by the shutting down of discussion & the shuttering of minds, will exceeded the pandemic damage. Science hurts -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Still trembling with shock and anticipation.
#chatgpt not only writes code in Python but also in Perl, FORTRAN and R-Script.
The code looks perfect to me and is so well explained.
This could be the ultimate way to learn to code in any language.
Be brave for a great New World.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Forgot the screen shots to prove my assertion.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very happy to be part of this really dynamic group.
Acceleration Consortium (AC)
@acceleration_c
NEW RESEARCH: @A_Aspuru_Guzik, @MLevitt_NP2013 + @biogerontology use #alphafold and AI to accelerate the design of a novel drug to treat liver cancer. It's the first successful application of @DeepMind’s #alphafold to hit identification in drug discovery ➡️acceleration.utoronto.ca/news/new-study-uses-alphafold-an…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Estimates of COVID-19 deaths in Mainland China after abandoning zero COVID policy” John Ioannidis, Francesco Zonta & Michael Levitt peer reviewed & accepted in European Journal Clinical Investigation. Preprint pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36597526/
Levitt Lecture at www.dropbox.com/s/k9og03xc5sxzjez/Excess_Death_Paper_Chin…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
China saved COVID-19 deaths by waiting for Omicron, the vaccine and better understanding of medical treatment (or lack there of).
See preprint Ioannidis, Zonta & Levitt x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1609121271446491137
and
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.12.29.22284048v1
Unclear if this caused worse collateral damage?
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
In Dec. 1, 2022, @washingtonpost: "China’s “zero covid” pandemic strategy may have saved millions of lives and postponed an inevitable reckoning with the coronavirus."
If the reckoning was "inevitable," then how did zero-covid save any lives?
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2022/12/01/china-zero-covid… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Great work. I am sure you enjoy working with John Ioannidis as much as I do.
It is wonderful for me to feel like a postdoctoral student aged 75 years old.
Michaela Schippers
@mc_schippers
Seems like all the reserach findings in the world will not sway people who are stubbornly hooked up on a certain course of action. Nevertheless, I (with John Ioannidis and Ari Joffe) made a second overview assessing the damage done worldwide: www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2022.950965/full
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So nice to have you back, Nick, welcomed as you are by so many of my Twitter favorites. What a crazy three years we have all been through
Nick Hudson
@NickHudsonCT
Agreed. As FOIA responses and leaks accelerate, we can begin to discern what was criminal conspiracy, what common greed, what credulousness, and what bad science; and we can describe more accurately the webs of influence and control used to secure lockstep implementation.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Our plot of South Korea showing reported COVID-19 Cases & Deaths as well estimated excess deaths based on Human Mortality Database stmf.csv calculated by method of Levitt, Zonta & Ioannidis
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Our most recent preprint is out & submitted.
“Estimates of COVID-19 deaths in Mainland China after
abandoning zero COVID policy”
medrxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2022.12.29.22284048v1
As always, criticism & comments are most welcome.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Forgot the plot.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Arne, please reply as there is so much confusion about numbers & I then all tabulated.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do you mean:
(1) Reported COVID-19?
(2) Excess death during 2020, 2021 or 2022 or all of them together?
(3) Normal all-cause death in the three pre-pandemic years 2017, 2018 or 2019 or all added together?
(4) Is Denmark Scandinavian?
Please reply as details really matter. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
FYI
“German physicist Max Planck somewhat cynically declared, science advances one funeral at a time. Planck noted “a new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents die & a new generation grows up”
Timothy
@TimothyBuffett
Science evolves one death at a time...
Oh the ego. Oh the incentives/bias -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Translate and be shocked..
“…Cancer patient with metastases. Painful. Suffering. Looking for the metastasis that embitters his last days. Barely moves his neck & hands. It hurts to see him
MRI is urgent …
they check for corona …
Positive.
…
no MRI today.
you will suffer
…”
Dr. Amir Shahar
@DrShahar
1. יום שישי. שנת 2023 כאילו. בי"ח איכילוב. לא יכול להתאפק. חולה סרטן עם גרורות. כואב. סובל. מחפשים את הגרורה שממררת את ימיו האחרונים. בקושי מניע את צווארו ואת ידיו. כואב לראותו.
אם-אר-איי דחוף,עוד היום. אולי תימצא ותוקרן ויוקלו כאביו הנוראיים.
על הדרך בודקים לקורונה... -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Wow. I thought this was the case. Could it be due to the fact that the median age of scientist has increase dramatically during this period.
Specifically, I am talking about NIH funded science in the USA (see www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1609996114 )
Paola Gori-Giorgi
@paolagorigiorgi
Imo one of the best explanations to this was by David Graeber in thebaffler.com/salvos/of-flying-cars-and-the-declining-ra…
"There was a time when academia was society’s refuge for the eccentric, brilliant, and impractical. No longer. It is now the domain of professional self-marketers" -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks #2
Andrzej Kozlowski
@akoz33
he was proved right (not in everything, though). Some people took very different views on different aspects: for example, the very independent Russian virologist Pyotr Chumakov strongly opposed lockdown and said that essentially everyone would eventually be infected no matter
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks #1
Andrzej Kozlowski
@akoz33
There was a question of balancing risks & nobody could be sure of what would work. There were, of course many divisions among virologists, epidemiologists etc. a some people, like the Nobel Prize winner in chemistry @MLevitt_NP2013, were severely attacked, although ultimately
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Today, ~3 years later, same amazing web app by Cameron Beccario, a genius of visualization & coding.
Same view of the winter North Pole; I added summer South Pole.
Vortex around the South Pole is intact at sea level & high up. The North Pole vortex is a mess.
Should I panic?
Dr. Robert Rohde
@RARohde
I'm enjoying watching this nearly perfectly circular stratospheric polar vortex (~30 km altitude) from Earth Nullschool earth.nullschool.net
This winter, stable polar circulation has mostly kept the coldest Arctic air bottled up within the Arctic. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
If anyone still cares about truth & precedence, Twitter Search:
sweden (from:MLevitt_NP2013)
to find hundreds of my tweets.
Below are screenshots of the first and the two most popular.
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1249553839172259846
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1460450201831886852
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1442348434304946177
What a struggle!
Prof. Freedom
@prof_freedom
Hi @elonmusk, you were right about Sweden. According to @ONS (UK National Statistics Office), Sweden has a mortality deficit of 4% (DEFICIT!!). How do we get this fact into the mainstream media?
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do you mean:
(1) Reported COVID-19?
(2) Excess death during 2020, 2021 or 2022 or all of them together?
(3) Normal all-cause death in the three pre-pandemic years 2017, 2018 or 2019 or all added together?
(4) Is Denmark Scandinavian?
Please reply as details really matter. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The real undisputed hero of COVID-19 has to be Prof. Anders Tegnell.
He is counter-balanced by so many villains, or were they just scared & foolish?
What a global tragedy.
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1255400786982572032
At least ChatGPT appreciates him!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
If anyone still cares about truth & precedence, Twitter Search:
sweden (from:MLevitt_NP2013)
to find hundreds of my tweets.
Below are screenshots of the first and the two most popular.
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1249553839172259846
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1460450201831886852
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1442348434304946177
What a struggle!
Prof. Freedom
@prof_freedom
Hi @elonmusk, you were right about Sweden. According to @ONS (UK National Statistics Office), Sweden has a mortality deficit of 4% (DEFICIT!!). How do we get this fact into the mainstream media?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
China saved COVID-19 deaths by waiting for Omicron, the vaccine and better understanding of medical treatment (or lack there of).
See preprint Ioannidis, Zonta & Levitt x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1609121271446491137
and
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.12.29.22284048v1
Unclear if this caused worse collateral damage?
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
In Dec. 1, 2022, @washingtonpost: "China’s “zero covid” pandemic strategy may have saved millions of lives and postponed an inevitable reckoning with the coronavirus."
If the reckoning was "inevitable," then how did zero-covid save any lives?
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2022/12/01/china-zero-covid… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Data from Hong Kong shows that Sinovac and Pfizer vaccines have similar effectiveness preventing death from COVID-19. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1599382470754897921
Matthew Marsden
@matthewdmarsden
If masks and vaccines work, why is China having a covid outbreak?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here are slides of a new and very timely lecture “PREDICTING THE BURDEN OF DEATH AND TIME-COURSE OF COVID-19 IN MAINLAND CHINA”.
Download PDF:
www.dropbox.com/s/k9og03xc5sxzjez/Excess_Death_Paper_Chin…
This is a “Draft Report” so please send comments.
See screen shots of 12 slides as try to make all GIF. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Our most recent preprint is out & submitted.
“Estimates of COVID-19 deaths in Mainland China after
abandoning zero COVID policy”
medrxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2022.12.29.22284048v1
As always, criticism & comments are most welcome. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Jose, thanks so much. I will check these. So appreciate, Michael
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Japan
covid19.mhlw.go.jp/extensions/public/en/index.html
South Korea
kosis.kr/covid_eng/statistics_excessdeath.do
Hong Kong
www.coronavirus.gov.hk/eng/index.html
www.chp.gov.hk/files/pdf/local_situation_covid19_en.pdf
www.covidvaccine.gov.hk/pdf/5th_wave_statistics.pdf
Australia
www.abs.gov.au/statistics/health/causes-death/provisional… -
Michael Levitt reposted
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Japan
covid19.mhlw.go.jp/extensions/public/en/index.html
South Korea
kosis.kr/covid_eng/statistics_excessdeath.do
Hong Kong
www.coronavirus.gov.hk/eng/index.html
www.chp.gov.hk/files/pdf/local_situation_covid19_en.pdf
www.covidvaccine.gov.hk/pdf/5th_wave_statistics.pdf
Australia
www.abs.gov.au/statistics/health/causes-death/provisional… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Friends, does anyone know of data about recent percent of population in Mainland China who are housed in long Term Care Facilities?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Twitter Friends, I need help with finding data on East Asia Locations.
Specifically, need Age-banded all cause death counts in Japan, Hong Kong & Taiwan for as much of the last two years, 2021 & 2022 as possible.
We really need to understand the death burden of COVID-19. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not sure. Could it be missed preventative medical treatment?
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
How is it possible that the excess deaths in Europe in the second half of 2022 will be higher than in 2020 and 2022, and in the year as a whole will be equal to 2020 and 2021, but now the excess deaths is mostly due to non-Covid causes?
Source: www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good point. There is a threshold density that depends on infectivity. Below it effectively 0 covid.
South Korea postponed its bad wave until earlier this year. Then it hit and there were 27M cases and about 27K excess deaths. Similar thing in Hong Kong. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 is a digital epidemic: 0 or 1, 0-covid or a full blown wave.
This is a consequence of the incredibly rapid but non-exponential growth of cases by the Gompertz function rather than the Logistic function.
There is no time warning for a sudden explosive growth.
1/2
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
In the earliest stages of a outbreak that is not tightly controlled, superspreaders quickly infect many people in a high-density location like New York City or Beijing.
Control is lost!
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1456825752297648130
x.com/Cescoxonta/status/1456465915181101068
Published:
doi.org/10.1016/j.jbior.2022.100915
2/2
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Most important result from 654 days of nonstop COVID-19 data analysis.
Explains previous focus on Gompertz function: all early outbreaks un-obscured by overlap of outbreaks show self-limited Gompertz growth due to the social contact pattern.
Francesco Zonta is super-star. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks for this. I am sure it is accurate but will check.
A good scientist always thinks that everything needs to be triple checked.
It is as if all collaborators & data are trying deliberately to fool you to damage your reputation.
I always try to recheck all work many times.
US Mortality
@USMortality
According to my calculations:
2019/'20: +24,927
2020/'21: +4,947
2021/'22: +4,295
www.usmortality.com/deaths/excess-seasonal-cumulative/new… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben, I do agree that without a specific test (PCR or antigen) in Germany COVID19 would have been seen as no worse than a recent bad flu.
This is true of most high income countries (but not USA) with data as shown in our multiverse excess death analysis. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1574301650025844736
US Mortality
@USMortality
This means in a world, where SARS-CoV-2 would have never been detected, these deaths would've just been classified into the existing ICD-10 codes, and it would not even have rang any alarm bells. (Because within stat. expected range)
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good point.
The answer to this is best seen in NYC with its massive first wave. I will run the calculations to see how much death there was in the two subsequent waves. More soon. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It is certainly true that herd immunity seems a much more likely outcome of natural COVID infection than generally believed early on.
Is China in December 2022 now simply following the approach Sweden adopted in March 2020? Sweden had far less excess death than most countries.
Yanzhong Huang
@YanzhongHuang
A new strategy seems to be gaining momentum in China's efforts to cope with the viral wave. Instead of focusing on "flattening the curve", this strategy supports quickly infecting as many people as possible, which its supporters believe can help China achieve herd immunity 1/2
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Agreed. What other high-recognized platform delivers such high levels discoverability & ubiquity?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Twitter is the most remarkable tool for real-time scientific discovery.
For me it has led to strangers collaborating together without ever meeting, & evaluating one other only by quality of interaction & work.
Twitter is essential for the future of world science! @elonmusk -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. I had not seen this. Will keep an eye of excess mortality. Still expect do flu to return.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Orwell2024
@orwell2022
#sweden won 🇸🇪
Thanks Tegnell for the incredible strength to sail against the biggest collective hysteria in mankind.
Thanks @DrJBhattacharya @MartinKulldorff @MLevitt_NP2013 @KnutMWittkowski @SunetraGupta and many more who spoke up early.
Robert Pezer
@rpezer1
The c19 pandemic sex-stratified (excess)ASMR in European countries, life expectancies, and coercion intensity.
The linear pre-pandemic trend is a baseline for excess.
Added relative (%) error of the excess ASMR.
European std pop 2013ed.
Data: @EU_Eurostat
Y30+ age, ladies -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Your link did not work. Please kindly do correct it
Happy the word is getting out. What I did in 2020 concerning COVID19 was out of character.
Still so happy it made some panic less.
The body of COVID data is fascinating and I continue it analysis with all my energy.
Dieter Kief
@DieterKief
Alex Washburne's great look back at Covid quotes you in his 12 000+ word essay numerous times. He wants to create a website for decent science-communication & writing. - - Btw.:Gompertz got rich - as did A. Washburne on Gompertz' & your shoulders! - - -
alexwashburne.substack.com/p/big-als-history-of-covid-19 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Henk Koudijs
@KoudijsHenk
Ben did you see a collaps of hospital treatments anywhere in the USA?
In Europe we did.
Henk Koudijs
@KoudijsHenk
1/ What causes loss of life expectancy or excess mortality? A thread
We know WHAT kills people since january 2022
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1556714413998018561
see also replies
Here is WHY people die
When #covid arrived, hospitals adapted special pandemic protocols. Was this a smart thing to to?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This tweet x.com/koudijshenk/status/1556694069144948736 and the link therein www.nber.org/papers/w30104 explain what we see in US excess death.
If anything, the excess death from disruption is greater for the under-65 age group.
Thanks to @KoudijsHenk and @orwell2022
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
US excess death Under-65 is finally zero: expected baseline. It went up on 4Apr20, wk14; down on 27Mar22, wk12.
This ‘young’ burden of death is unique to the US.
True in ‘blue’ California as well as ‘red’ Florida, it signals dangerous weaknesses in US society not seen elsewhere -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Most cool. Thanks. Now we need actors, producer & director. Very happy if they are all AI
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
So #chatgpt seems funniest when asked to write plays… though it can be imaginative about the characters resumés @FatEmperor @MLevitt_NP2013
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
On second thoughts, it is good thing that I am not funded by the Gates Foundation.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Data from bad 2022 COVID19 outbreak in Hong Kong, shows both Sinovac and Pfizer/BioNTech save elderly deaths.
The mRNA Pfizer vaccine is 90% efficient; the protein Sinovac vaccine is 80% efficient (both 2 or 3) doses.
China should use Sinovac widely.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1519424561749635075
Paul C of 🏴 och 🇸🇪
@dobssi
Sweden are completely sold on the vaccines. They aren't making any 20x claims but they are saying it's the best and only sustainable tool we have and the elderly should get boosted.
You saw my ICU data.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A nice selection of generally intelligent replies. Thanks
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Totally agree with your observation. This is a perennial problem when there is not a proper random controlled trial.
Would you agree that the 8/9 relative efficient of Sinovac to Pfizer is unaffected by this confounding issue?
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
This paper evaluates vaccine effectiveness in Hong Kong.
Unfortunately they could not control for confounding due to the healthy vaccinee effect which means the effectiveness is likely overestimated.
www.thelancet.com/journals/laninf/article/PIIS1473-3099(2… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Seems this needs to be investigated as NYC excess death was more than twice normal expected value for a six week period. On the worst week (2020_15, 6-12 Apr 2020), NYC excess death was 7 times normal.
This level of death did not cause hospitals to collapse, what would?
US Mortality
@USMortality
NYC's Hospital System Never Reached Full Capacity in Spring 2020. The Navy's Hospital Ship Was Only Used By 20 Patients.
Yet Excess Mortality was +598% for week 15.
Simply said it was Iatrogenesis. ("relating to illness caused by medical examination or treatment.") -
Michael Levitt reposted
US Mortality
@USMortality
NYC's Hospital System Never Reached Full Capacity in Spring 2020. The Navy's Hospital Ship Was Only Used By 20 Patients.
Yet Excess Mortality was +598% for week 15.
Simply said it was Iatrogenesis. ("relating to illness caused by medical examination or treatment.") -
Michael Levitt reposted
Anish Koka, MD
@anish_koka
Hard to believe there are prominent ppl in the US that don’t remember public health falling head over heels for China’s draconian approach to COVID
Brief 🧵
#medtwitter sampling from 2020: -
Michael Levitt reposted
Vinay Prasad MD MPH
@VPrasadMDMPH
China's Protests Should Remind Us that Many American Academics WANTED Zero COVID
Full video on Youtube
youtu.be/sRzfmuAmGKcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Newman Nahas
@NahasNewman
This is dead wrong. What’s going on in China is absolutely related. It may be different in degree, but not in kind. And that’s the point. When you reason—like Covidians everywhere did—from the “greatness” of the goal to the permissibility of the means, you’ve given up the ground
zeynep tufekci
@zeynep
Oh come on. What’s going on in China has little to do with anywhere else. It’s not even remotely comparable. People died in a fire with sealed shut door. This is disrespectful to the bravery and suffering of people in China. Let’s get a grip, out of respect if nothing else.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
When you need to hear the true or the people in the face of globally prevalent censorship, Twitter really shines & shows it’s greatest strength
@elonmusk I hope we can be sure you will not let Twitter die or become irrelevant. We need truth to save all the countries in the world -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Dr. Michael Levitt interview with a Portugese magazine (machine translation to English) Part 1.1: #covid #climate change, #censorship #science
-
Michael Levitt reposted
PÁGINA UM
@PAG_UM
MICHAEL LEVITT, BIOQUÍMICO E PRÉMIO NOBEL DA QUÍMICA (2013) - 2ª PARTE
‘O comportamento da imprensa durante a pandemia é uma tragédia’
Segunda parte da entrevista de Michael Levitt, Prémio Nobel da Química, pela jornalista Elisabete Tavares.
paginaum.pt/2022/11/05/o-comportamento-da-imprensa-durant… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Elisabete Tavares
@etavares_press
Thank you @MLevitt_NP2013 for this interview. An inspiration to many worldwide, I believe. So many insights and also hope (much needed!).
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The Gini index, g, is commonly used. Trouble is that ratio of wealth of top 10% to that bottom 10% percent is a very fast function of g.
Really should use exp(g).
Odd that economists use a number that minimizes lack of equality. Just like the way epidemiologists mislead with Rt -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sad that Nobel Laureate @nytimes economist I follow devotedly, does not know that death rate is exponentially dependent on population age.
The Florida population is older than NY, TX or CA. When excess death is normalized by expected death, FL is no worse than the other three.
Paul Krugman
@paulkrugman
Adjusted for population, the Florida-equivalent death toll was
FL 59,170
CA 39,217
NY 39,551
So states that didn't have governors promoting Covid disinformation and anti-tax propaganda lost far fewer people — the equivalent of ~20K excess in FL 4/ -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
One small correction to this:👇
It was not a gamble, it was the only reasonable policy to adopt. DeSantis reached out to highly qualified experts and was open to a real debate.
H/t @MLevitt_NP2013 @Marco_Piani @orwell2022
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/11/desantiss-covid… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So happy to have back.
How successful a venture do you expect. Should we invest in it?
Gummi
@gummibear737
Netflix and Yahoo have agreed to a join venture in Israel
They’re calling it Net-and-Yahoo -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
John, is this from missed kidney dialysis?
What percent of normal expected death is 1000 excess?
From figure below, expected death is 250+950=1200 per week. The total excess death since 1Jan20 is 7580.
These reference values make 1500 extra kidney failure death very high.
John Beaudoin, Sr., The Real CdC, The Last Boomer
@JohnBeaudoinSr
The largest signal of them all. More than 1,500 EXCESS sudden kidney failure deaths in Massachusetts alone in the past 18 months. You will not see this anywhere else. CDC bundles data and all researchers cannot find this signal. But here it is direct from MA Death Certificates
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I cannot understand how intelligent people can be so politically motivated. There is not “red” science versus “blue” science. There is just Truth in Science that serves us all Democrats & Republicans alike.
Once science is treated like sports with favorite teams, it is doomed. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben I am so happy. You made so many critical contributions.
US Mortality
@USMortality
Finally got my blue check!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Except for the USA.
Matthijs de Haas
@DeHaas87
The highest excess deaths is seen in the countries with the lowest gdp
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not political in any way. Belief in maximizing diversity so that someone gets it right.
Jg aka Kathy M
@Jg40851122
Thank you. Unfortunately too little influence.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Jg aka Kathy M
@Jg40851122
Thank you. Unfortunately too little influence.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
To my great distress, the USA is most like Bulgaria in terms of relative excess death (excess death as percentage of expected death).
This is also true in California, a state that is now the world’s fourth largest economy.
📊 Ruben van Gaalen
@rubenivangaalen
💡Oversterfte (cumulatief per 100 duizend inwoners, stand half juli 2022): grote verschillen tussen, ook wel binnen landen. Opvallend: Landen met lage vaccinatie/boostergraad hebben (deels veel) hogere oversterfte (bijv. Bulgarije, Roemenië).
github.com/dkobak/excess-mortality -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Is www.nytimes.com/2022/11/08/us/politics/desantis-wins-flor… a win for science?
Only one US politician contacted me. @GovRonDeSantis phoned me on 17 Sep 2020, listened to suggestions, loosened restrictions and reduced pain & panic in Florida.
His actions resulted in the same relative excess death as California. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ansgar John
@ansgarjohn
Hartelijk dank voor Freedom Festival ik heb erg genoten en hopelijk wat geleerd. Ook leuk om een aantal mensen terug te zien die bij #vlamopdedam betrokken waren!
NB. Virus verspreiding is niet "exponentieel" Nobelwinnaar @MLevitt_NP2013 legt het uit
youtu.be/8aHrx68IT7o -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
www.nytimes.com/2022/10/26/climate/un-climate-pledges-war…
Could this be the real reason for the terribly wasteful response to the COVID-19 pandemic?
I so hope that I am wrong and that we get through the next 30 years without massive global disruption.
If not, my baby boomer generation will be despised. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
My most important tweet ever: a must see 75 minute movie featuring John Ioannidis. www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmErXFRKAOo
Meeting John Ioannidis was the best thing that I experienced since COVID-19 struck in January 2020. It makes all the insults, abuse & discrediting I suffered worthwhile. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes. I too was surprised as the person who invited me was very positive and excited about my COVID-19 work. He even said that determining death rate is very central to longevity. Big surprise!
antibubble
@coqumragep279
To be clear, u were asked to withdraw from the Metabesity 2022 conference?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
When I said that I would talk about excess death as submitted & published with epidemiologists John Ioannidis, I was asked to withdraw.
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1542056902540103680
x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1575274284720979969
No one wants to hear any non-mainstream views.
Is this the end of science as we know it?
Longevity Education Team
@LongevityEdu
Two of our course authors, Dr. @Dr_Bischof and Dr. Zhavronkov, @biogerontology will together with Dr. @MLevitt_NP2013 be speaking at the upcoming 'Targeting Metabisity 2022' a virtual conference happening on 11-14 of October! Make sure to register: www.metabesity2022.org/registration
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really pleased to announce our latest preprint on COVID-19 authored with John Ioannidis @METRICStanford & Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta.
Titled “Excess death estimates from multiverse analysis in 2009-2021”
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.09.21.22280219v1
Hope people are interested enough to critique.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thank you all for reading.
The death toll in the USA is so high and unexpected. It is so different from the excess death in any other technologically advanced, high-income country.
It is a sure sign that things are badly wrong in one of greatest countries in human history. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Scientists debate how lethal COVID is. Some say it's now less risky than flu”
If this debate had not been prevented by over-zealous scientists in Mar 2020, would we have avoided the subsequent massive & destructive disruption of society in the USA?
www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/09/16/1122650502/s… -
Michael Levitt reposted
US Mortality
@USMortality
Added NYC to the site, and no we can see that even in one of the most hardest hit and strictest cities, all-cause mortality is not back to normal.
#covid #nyc -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. I wonder if the data is good enough to show that 1918 flu grew exponentially?
Maestro Rayo
@maestro_rayo
Fascinating account of the public health response to the 1918 Spanish flu by Molly Billings (then at Stanford) in 1997. Did much change in one century?
virus.stanford.edu/uda/index.html
1/ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So excited by this as a long-time advisor to @StemRad stemrad.com a company co-founded by my son Daniel Levitt stemrad.com/board-of-directors/ over a decade ago.
Lockheed Martin Space
@LMSpace
We worked with @StemRad to develop AstroRad, a wearable, radiation-shielding vest designed to protect astronauts as they travel to the Moon, Mars and beyond. @NASAArtemis I purposeful passenger Zohar is outfitted with AstroRad, which will be tested during the mission. ⬇
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Jim O’Neill
@regardthefrost
Yes, a missed opportunity.
Jim O’Neill
@regardthefrost
Keep your eye on the BCG vaccine. clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04327206
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Just saw scientists have shown that the BCG Vaccine protected against COVID-19 in a very small blind trial. Efficacy was as good as vaccines.
www.nytimes.com/2022/08/16/health/bcg-vaccine-diabetes-co… www.nytimes.com/2022/08/16/health/bcg-vaccine-diabetes-co…
@j_sato suspected this over 2 years ago: pity not studied then.
J Sato
@j_sato
I am so impressed by Professor Levitt's interview.
The spread of virus and deaths differ hugely by country. I think your word of "prior immunity" is the key.
BCG vaccination strengthens our trained immunity. The BCG Tokyo strain can work as a vaccine.
www.jsatonotes.com/2020/03/if-i-were-north-americaneurope… -
Michael Levitt reposted
KBirb
@birb_k
NOT OK. CDC completely discredited natural infection immunity. It became a lever driving vaccines, mandates, disruption to livelihood, school mayhem, and civil strife. The Aug 11, 2022 CDC MMWR credits long-standing natural infection science, showing they LIED for >2 years.
1/ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Odd small pieces of relevant information can be hard to find. More than two years after finding how the Gompertz function fits all COVID-19 outbreaks I finally notice the #gompertz hash tag.
Find all by Twitter Search:
‘Gompertz (from:mlevitt_NP2013)’
Science is a random walk! -
Michael Levitt reposted
KBirb
@birb_k
Here is a well-reasoned thread that illustrates what happens in a mask study that designs its criteria to exclude testing of a large number of people who should (by clear logic) be included in the testing. Not surprisingly, the outcome is dramatically affected.
Emily Burns😊 DMs welcome #TeamReality
@EmilyVBurns
1/
The authors of this newest mask study acknowledge that masked districts exempted masked close contacts (all) from testing, but still claim it is legitimate. Let’s explore.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting result and interesting article.
In our analysis, all these locations did well:
CHE ISR LUX FIN SWE
ISL DNK TWN NZL
NOR AUS KOR
Did any of them have stringent measures?
Orwell2024
@orwell2022
This review article deserves a wider audience.
Professor Shippers discusses the processes leading to what we observe now.
@MartinKulldorff @DrJBhattacharya @MLevitt_NP2013
The article 👉www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.577740/full
Helps to understand the data 👇 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This tweet x.com/koudijshenk/status/1556694069144948736 and the link therein www.nber.org/papers/w30104 explain what we see in US excess death.
If anything, the excess death from disruption is greater for the under-65 age group.
Thanks to @KoudijsHenk and @orwell2022
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
US excess death Under-65 is finally zero: expected baseline. It went up on 4Apr20, wk14; down on 27Mar22, wk12.
This ‘young’ burden of death is unique to the US.
True in ‘blue’ California as well as ‘red’ Florida, it signals dangerous weaknesses in US society not seen elsewhere -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
US excess death Under-65 is finally zero: expected baseline. It went up on 4Apr20, wk14; down on 27Mar22, wk12.
This ‘young’ burden of death is unique to the US.
True in ‘blue’ California as well as ‘red’ Florida, it signals dangerous weaknesses in US society not seen elsewhere -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks for this 9 Tweets thread.
So much could have be learned from early studies. This was not encouraged. Instead those making early non-mainstream observations were discredited, often by academics & physicians.
Wish we humans could learn from mistakes and so not repeat them.
C.W. Babich
@CWBabich
With covid waning, we see many PH pro's back-track, revise, or straight up gaslight us with the “we didn’t know lockdowns…” or “knowing what we know now…”. Heard it from Birx and Fauci. Luckily, we have receipts to remember 🧵 1/9
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very interesting. I expected no correlation.
You find more stringency leads to high burden of death. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
An unusually personal message from me. One that I allow myself after almost 3,500 Tweets almost exclusively about COVID-19.
My mother, Gertrude Levitt, died on 10 July 2022 (10.7.22) aged 107.
Here is what was in the local London Ealing newspaper. www.ealingtoday.co.uk/default.asp?section=info&page=eager…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@threadreaderapp unroll
Please unroll this stream of condolences for Gertrude Levitt so it can be shared. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thank you. There were almost fifty pupils taught at Corton Hill school.
KathyR
@katerinapanarou
I was lucky enough to be one of those children taught in the lounge in the flat in Ealing! So sorry for your loss. Remembering Mrs Levitt with great love, affection and gratitude
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good luck, determination and never giving up no matter how bad the odds.
DT
@therealzDT81
What was her secret to get to 107? Please tell me it was chablis and kettle chips every night??
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. I did my A levels at Acton Tech in 1964. Very fond memories.
W
@wbvm73
Sounds to me like she is going to reorganise heaven and educate the good people there. I'm sure it'll be a better place now that she is there. Ealing will miss her. Love from Acton
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This was our decision too. Gertrude gave express instructions not to go to hospital. The end was fair quick and peaceful.
This is how I want to go. Important to leave explicit written instructions else police suspect foul play.
John Palliser 💜
@JohnPalliser8
Amazing woman Michael. My Mom (93) died early hours of Mon at home, my sister and I took the agonising decision not to send to hospital but to let her die in peace at home with us. It’s never easy when it happens.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You really hit the nail on the head over two years ago. Thank you.
I so hope you are wrong, though.
Will global famine death be counted in real time?
Will the numbers be tracked by JHU and Our World in Data?
Is a death a death or a
are deaths with and from COVID-19 special?
Ethical Skeptic ☀
@EthicalSkeptic
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Looks convincing with correlation coefficient of 0.77. How do the experts in CDC & WHO explain this?
Is their selection bias?
KBirb
@birb_k
States with fewer children vaccinated for COVID have significantly higher levels of protective antibody seroprevalence among their youth population. The correlation value is strong. CDC and AAP sources noted.
1/ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That the unvaccinated are less health-conscientious & therefore more likely to suffer from co-morbidities seems sensible.
In poll of 3Feb22 unvaccinated were voted more healthy x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1489204893051240457
Has vaccine efficiency ever been corrected for prevalence of co-morbidities?
question_more
@questionmore5
Following your logic, the unvaxed which are shown in the mortality stats: Many did not die from Covid. Many died from other causes. Unvaxed do not care about health, have comorbidity. So the stats stats do not prove effectiveness of the vax.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This paper’s introduction is reproduced in full in two attached photos. It is a chilling read.
Still, the whole paper should be read by anyone who cares about our future.
Clearly, huge errors were made. We need to understand them to avoid their repeating & causing more damage.
METRICStanford
@METRICStanford
chippers, Michaela, Ioannidis, John P. A. and Joffe, Ari, Aggressive Measures, Rising Inequalities and Mass Formation During the COVID-19 Crisis: An Overview and Proposed Way Forward (May 24, 2022). Available at SSRN: ssrn.com/abstract=4118910 or dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4118910
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
One in 5000 with serious side-effects sounds small. Do we know fraction deaths die & their ages?
The extra risk of death COVID-19 in Germany is 2.7% of normal natural risk of death or about 1 in 3000 per year. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1542056902540103680
What is comparable risk for flu vaccines?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
First COVID-19 paper published in Environmental Research. doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2022.113754
Co-authored with physicist Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta & 434,000 times cited epidemiologist John Ioannidis.
Improved by 4 deep constructive reviews, I am so proud of paper.
Great to learn at 75. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Remember all too well: ridicule & insults.
Sad is that had efforts be made to understand, so much global misery could have been prevented.
The few who understood the implications of the early data were discredited. Anti-scientific fear stopped all discussion & the world pays. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Easily read thread by Jose Gefaell summarizes Stephen Andrews hypothesis www.dropbox.com/s/e3i6t0pztuzpwc6/New-hypothesis-on-the-m…
Good thing about COVID-19 is that “Everyone is an Epidemiologist these days”.
Said disparagingly by Neil Ferguson about me in Apr 2020 on the BBC.
It may well improve the world.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
SUMMARY: The SarsCov2 virus remains dormant in the body and reactivates according to the sun's ultraviolet rays, which in turn are a function of the seasons and how the ozone layer evolves in each region of the planet.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben again dazzles with his computational prowess.
Could you look at US State excess death in separate pandemic years: 20, 21 & 22?
Are they correlated?
What is correlation with State vaccination level?
How much less excess death if heavily vaccinated?
US Mortality
@USMortality
COVID-19 Cases vs Vaccination Levels, states, 28 days, daily [USA] @USMortality
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks to 700 who replied. Many correctly noted that death depends steeply on age & must be age-adjusted.
Seems this is more of a concern for vaccinated deaths than for general unexpected death during pandemic.
Most studies ignore age for excess death x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1542056902540103680
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Can someone explain to me how this is possible?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The media in Israel and around the world ignore the artistic-cultural uniqueness of Documenta 15 in Kassel, Germany.
Something completely different is happening there this year:
facebook.com/563996584/post…
A blatant miss. We will be sorry about this..
ynet.co.il/judaism/articl…
Shoshan Brosh Levitt
@BroshLevitt
התקשורת בישראל ובעולם מתעלמת מהייחוד האומנותי-תרבותי של דוקומנטה 15 בקאסל שבגרמניה.
משהו לגמרי אחר מתרחש שם השנה:
www.facebook.com/563996584/posts/10159840616291585/?d=n
זו החמצה בוטה. עוד נצטער על זה.
www.ynet.co.il/judaism/article/bkck1ow2c -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Can someone explain to me how this is possible?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why do you think things went wrong this time?
Why were NPI so easily accepted?
Why did we all panic?
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
It’s not simple. It’s practically impossible to control the spread of RNA respiratory viruses like CoV’s and influenza. Literally, nothing works. This has been known for decades, that’s why no one ever bothered to implement NPI’s targeting these viruses in the past. Futile!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much.
Devoted 898 days to understanding the treat COVID-19 posed. Now those findings must be published.
Looking back, I see my attention was misplaced: humans are so much more of a treat.
Still, humans are often exceedingly wonderful & a reason for joyful living. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here it is:
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All so sad. Had we properly estimated the risk of COVID-19 in March 2020, think how much better off the world would be now.
Alan
@A1an_M
A 🧵
Way back at the start of the pandemic in spring 2020 John Ioannidis did a study which calculated the IFR for SARS-COV-2 across the globe as averaging 0.23%. He was castigated at the time for this. Media said he was wrong and irresponsible for playing down the risk... -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
What a surprise from a magazine that pushed lockdown & school closure.
Beauty of journalism: more readers when you push drastic measures, then more when you express surprise at the result of these measures.
Shame on you and all the other deniers of logic and common sense.
The Economist
@TheEconomist
New data suggest that the damage from shutting down schools has been worse than almost anyone expected econ.st/3AC3K3J
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1399510823941275649
From over a year ago: only a little. In US States correlation of excess death with obesity is less than 0.3. Other things correlate more. Still working up the data.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Should have added weekly plots of age-adjusted excess death for under-65 & over-64 year olds. Method in x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1542056902540103680?
In Canada & USA excess death of younger group jumped at end of March 2020 and stayed up (green).
Extra deaths due by panic & fear not to COVID-19.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Solves a year-old mystery x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1420551221199482881
Your data explains why the under-65 year olds suffered so much in Canada.
Death by opioid overdose is a “medical condition” that Canadians seem to have in common with their neighbors to the south, the USA.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Opioid (OD) related deaths in Canada - source @GovCanHealth👇
I wonder what happened in 2020-2021?? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hypotheses are an intrinsic part of science & scientific discovery.
Getting a research grant from the US National iInstitutes of Health @NIH depends on having a hypothesis.
If you have policy before you have science no need for hypotheses as all outcomes are pre-determined.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
@Twitter locked my account for this thread showing off-season excess deaths in Spain and hypothesizing about vaccines. In light of this official update showing MUCH MORE EXCESS in ≥75 triple vaxxed in May-June than in Jan-Feb, can we hypothesize or is it not allowed?
@elonmusk? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Solves a year-old mystery x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1420551221199482881
Your data explains why the under-65 year olds suffered so much in Canada.
Death by opioid overdose is a “medical condition” that Canadians seem to have in common with their neighbors to the south, the USA.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Opioid (OD) related deaths in Canada - source @GovCanHealth👇
I wonder what happened in 2020-2021?? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This makes complete sense.
The global disruption that happened during COVID-19 is totally unprecedented.
Stopping the world economy had never been tried. It was actually easy time do. Restarting it is very difficult. It will be at a huge cost to the young and unfortunate.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Inflation in Europe and the USA started to rise sharply just after the first confinements in 2020. In both regions has maintained virtually the same slope since then. War is not the cause of inflation, but the irrational, destructive and inefficient Covid measures.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Goodbye to an amazing group of young scientists. #lino22
Most select Lindau group ever: the best of 2020, 2021 & 2022.
Now all you need to do is to go out there & fix our world. I have total confidence in you all.
Just had to wave goodbye.
You are the hope for our future!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Enjoying Lindau 2022 immensely 🙏
COVID-19 must make holding it incredibly difficult. The organizers are to be triply commended! @lindaunobel
#lino22
We need new ways of scientific collaboration that are global, virtual, open & balanced.
Email or DM me.
Help spread the word! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“AfroFuturistic Art. Referring to the last post in a new series of posts, in which I write about African-American and African art in the United States and Europe. Interesting, relevant art that signifies change.”
I learnt so much from visiting these exhibitions with Shoshan
Shoshan Brosh Levitt
@BroshLevitt
אומנות אפרופוטוריסטית. מפנה לפוסט האחרון בסדרה חדשה של פוסטים, שבהם אני כותבת על אומנות אפרו-אמריקאית ואפריקאית בארצות הברית ובאירופה. אומנות מעניינת, רלוונטית ומסמנת שינוי
www.facebook.com/563996584/posts/pfbid0ea9ht9H9F4rTinGvMf… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This was taught me by my “Towering Heroes of Science”.
www2.mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk/ebooks/Memories_and_consequences-H…
A much more commonly accepted view of science mentoring fifty years ago, science today seems more hierarchical.
I believe independent young scientist are needed more than ever.
Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings
@lindaunobel
What makes a good mentor, Nobel Laureate Michael Levitt? #lino22 #mentoring @Standford
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Enjoying Lindau 2022 immensely 🙏
COVID-19 must make holding it incredibly difficult. The organizers are to be triply commended! @lindaunobel
#lino22
We need new ways of scientific collaboration that are global, virtual, open & balanced.
Email or DM me.
Help spread the word! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Are we now in the year AC 1?
Will the AC era ever be the same as BC, before covid?
Will young lives matter as they did before?
Will trust in science be restored?
Will leaders seek balanced advice before imposing measures with unknown long-lasting consequences.
So hope so!! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
First COVID-19 paper published in Environmental Research. doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2022.113754
Co-authored with physicist Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta & 434,000 times cited epidemiologist John Ioannidis.
Improved by 4 deep constructive reviews, I am so proud of paper.
Great to learn at 75. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Friends, I am back in Lindau, Germany where I was present online almost exactly two year ago.
I spoke in a session “Corona – The Role of Science in Times of Crisis”
www.lindau-nobel.org/de/blog-covid-19-the-role-of-science…
I was very upset by the lack of discussion then. In fact, it was much worse.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
My thanks to Enrique and Alice &the others. This was a really terrific encounter that is available for all at vimeo.com/433350887/33bbbe4090. I expect Lindau @lindaunobel will keep it all online and open. This will be seen as a watershed in the future of science & its communication.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting. Good point.
Also emphasizes that excess deaths need population numbers that may themselves be unreliable.
So hard to really know what is happening. Surely, we can have better data going forward?
David Guedalia
@idavidg
Did you check the birth rate? Typically highest mortality is age 0, without knowing, I would guess less births (which I have seen elsewhere) is less deaths
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
For the USA in 2020 & 2021, the Human Mortality Database at mortality.org, shows significant less excess death for children aged 0 to 14. Lives of the youngest age band in US were saved during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Not sure why but it is seems important to understand? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Everything we needed to know about lockdowns being unnecessary was known March 2020 with Dr. Levitt's analysis of the Diamond Princess heatherrenkel.github.io/index.html & exposure of fraud of other scientists heatherrenkel.github.io/step_by_step.html , & Imperial Colleges Report #9 heatherrenkel.github.io/blog/report_9.html
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Saw this www.nytimes.com/2022/06/20/health/covid-deaths-plateau.html
Wondered if Ben @USMortality sees same trends for excess mortality? Ben imputes data to account for delayed reporting.
In particular, are excess deaths under 65 finally back to baseline?
If so, it will be the first time since 29-March-2020. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
John Ioannidis & I are now friends & collaborators. Would not have happened without COVID-19 panic induced lockdown.
We ‘met’ when BBC World Service radio linked us in March 2020. www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3csy74p
So much damage caused by a few ‘experts’ to so many young everywhere.
plaforscience
@plaforscience
Only LEGENDS get a @rubiaconceptual 's BigHead
She gathers both amazing talent and criteria!
You've definitely earned that Honour, reserved for True Heroes
Maybe thru @METRICStanford John will enjoy his Little Him too
I'm not sure who's best dressed!! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Indeed how could they know?
There are many economic factors that lead to an unpredictable, chaotic system.
Actually, our leaders panicked & used medieval lockdown.
All collateral damage was ignored for a disease predicted to be 10-times more deadly than it really was.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
How could governments & central banks have known that the supply bottlenecks caused by irrational lockdowns while unnecessarily and uncontrollably creating trillions of money supply would lead to runaway inflation, global recession and widespread distrust?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are so right. That is a common mistake on my phone.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Wow, thanks. That actually looks like me.
rubiaconceptual
@rubiaconceptual
Has fans in Spain too.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
First publish mistakes. Then publish retractions.
This is the how science driven by likes will work.
Is this now a WHO publication in high-impact factor journal Nature? media.nature.com/original/magazine-assets/d41586-022-0152…
Look forward to more admissions of errors: masks, lockdowns…
Sad for the kids!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Happy to be release this preprint www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.05.09.22274863v1
It involves a new collaboration with esteemed Stanford colleague Prof John Ioannidis as well as Prof Francesco Zonta, @Cescoxonta who has worked so hard on COVID-19 with me. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I just saw your painting in Venice and am intrigued by the upper left background. It looks like renaissance Italy. Is it?
Amazing art.
Thank you so much Wiley Kehinde
@kehindewileyart -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Bothered me in Mar 2020. Saying so cost me dearly (as seen by Twitter followers).
Now we see the biggest proponents of lockdown appreciating damaged caused to the young, most especially in the USA. www.nytimes.com/2022/06/10/opinion/covid-death-young-old.…
Really needed more discussion and less discrediting. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
No learning loss in Sweden as there was never lockdown or closed schools. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0883035522000891
All those who pushed the world into lockdown have a lot of explaining to do to the damaged young generation.
Sadly obvious since April 2020. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
New phenomenon I have not seen before.
In Spain in 2021, all-casual death for 85+ is 209,000 or 17,000 a month so the excess you see of 1,000 in a month is 6%.
Ideas anyone?
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Let's compare this now only for the month of May. There is an exceptional all cause excess deaths in 2022 for ≥75. There is not a single year with such an excess deaths in May for ≥75, not even in 2020. The difference is that nearly 100% of them are now triple vaccinated.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, I found Japan in 3020 had 50,000 less deaths, a huge death deficit.
Reading thins makes me sorry I have not been follow Twitter more closely. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Absolutely. Interesting to know it is happening.
Also expected in Japan an and China. Could also have happened in Hong Kong but no data as yet. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
From a week ago. www.wsj.com/podcasts/opinion-free-expression/the-collater…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is what we have been seeing for a long time: a large negative excess death likely due to little of seasonal flu in 2020 & 2021.
Also seen in New Zealand, Australia and Taiwan (only for 2020).
Would be terrific if Twitter's combined search super-powers could find this data. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ongoing study of mortality in USA shows that levels of deaths per million population are at record highs for under-65 (young) and for all ages, but NOT for over-65 year olds.
In the US, it is the young that needed to be protected in 2020 & 2021.
Full analysis & data soon. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really interesting to see this from your ASMR (Age-Standardized Mortality Rate) point-of-view.
Thanks so much Paul Collyer @dobssi
Please unroll @threadreaderapp
Paul C of 🏴 och 🇸🇪
@dobssi
Excess mortality - there seem to be so many different ways to measure it, but how do we know which one is right or best, if any?
There is an interesting paper here by @MLevitt_NP2013 which compares a bunch of models and then produces two of it's own.
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.05.09.22274863v1
1/ -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
When meeting Dr. @MLevitt_NP2013 - always have a Corona. Time to open up and bring more actionable therapeutics to market quickly. Of course, Albert Bourla is my role model.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Happy to be release this preprint www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.05.09.22274863v1
It involves a new collaboration with esteemed Stanford colleague Prof John Ioannidis as well as Prof Francesco Zonta, @Cescoxonta who has worked so hard on COVID-19 with me. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I have been off Twitter for a variety of reasons. Missed you all for better and worse.
I@PienaarJm I wonder if you would you be so kind as to share a link to this data.
We are re-visiting our excess death calculations and trying to find the best way to do them.
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
mortality.org does not have enough data for USA to do this meaningfully.
However there is more than 100 years of detailed data available: cdc and census .gov
I decided to start from 1955 (65 years)
This will differ from your numbers because it is monthly not weekly data -
Michael Levitt reposted
Steven Donziger
@SDonziger
I had been dreaming about this for a long time -- starting the day with total bodily immersion in the chilly ocean in North Florida. Felt so good.
Day 5. Slowly climbing back to the land of the living.👊❤️ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really like ideas for improve Twitter. I really see it’s potential for creative collaboration. It still has two many drawbacks for protracted or exclusive use.
So hope we can discuss @ChGefaell suggestions and that @elonmusk listens.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Thread for: @elonmusk
As an open-access social network, Twitter should not moderate decorum or content beyond what the law says. If Twitter becomes a private network with restricted access, a club to which access is, ie, by invitation only, then Twitter can do as it pleases. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alex Sigal
@sigallab
We measured immunity against the #omicron BA.4 and BA.5 variants by people infected with the original (BA.1) Omicron sub-lineage. Results consistent with these variants forming next infection wave.
Manuscript submitted to medRxiv and available here:
sigallab.net -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That is a good point. The vaccinated are not a random set but the numbers are large so the bias may be OK.
Inge Bonneux
@IBonnx
Could it be that those vaccinated are other people (more wealthy) than those not? Honest question…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Vaccine efficiency in the recent outbreak in Hong Kong could point to a way forward for China.
With about half the relative number of people over 65 in China than in Hong Kong, the death rate would be lowered proportionally.
Am impressed by the openness of Hong Kong data. -
Michael Levitt reposted
James Melville 🚜
@JamesMelville
The lockdown in Shanghai is causing a massive logjam in maritime cargo transportation. A fifth of the world’s containerships are currently stuck in congestion. The largest share are stuck offshore around China. The global supply chain repercussions are enormous. Cause and effect.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Oh, Omicron!
Spain: absolute normality since Autumn in terms of all cause deaths. See z-scores comparison of 2022 vs. 2018 and 2017. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Simple, was wrong as have now said many times.
Did not appreciate how different US was from Europe. Also did not appreciate the multiple waves of COVID that lay in the future.
US excess deaths up 13.6% over two years, 7 weeks of extra normal death as in LA Times 23-Mar-2020.
HiTMaN
@HiTMaNGTI
@MLevitt_NP2013 explain sir.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong death may be high as many spared in 20 & 2021.
If like nearby countries with age-banded death data (Korea, Taiwan, Australia & New Zealand), 5% fewer died for 2 years.
This is a ~5,000 death deficit in HK.
Need Hong Kong excess death data to compare with Spain.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Unvaxxed comparison HK vs Spain. Spain had the biggest 1 wave in 2020. 100% unvaxxed. No medical treatments. Healthcare collapsed. But HK unvaxxed deaths are now ~2x more than in Spain in 2020, and HK's current unvaxxed CFR is ~4x higher than in Spain now (while global CFR is =).
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Spain Age-Adjusted Excess Death
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Europe (population 470 million) very different. Pre-covid annual mortality for Under-65 is 2,260/million in US & 1,682/mil. in Europe. 1/4th less
US Covid-period excess deaths Under-65 1090/mil. vs. 212/mil. 4X more
Excess Under-65 gets back to baseline in Europe not US!
Why?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Mortality of Americans under 65 increased on week 13 2020 (29 March 2020). This is very early on as seen from the excess deaths in New York City below.
It is as if the news of COVID-19 terrified people to death.
Since then 370,000 extra under-65 have died, an increase of ~25%
US Mortality
@USMortality
All-Cause Excess Deaths in middle aged (25-64) in the US is still extraordinarily high!
> The vaccines appear to have had no effect.
#covid #covid19 #coronavirus #corona -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Mortality of Americans under 65 increased on week 13 2020 (29 March 2020). This is very early on as seen from the excess deaths in New York City below.
It is as if the news of COVID-19 terrified people to death.
Since then 370,000 extra under-65 have died, an increase of ~25%
US Mortality
@USMortality
All-Cause Excess Deaths in middle aged (25-64) in the US is still extraordinarily high!
> The vaccines appear to have had no effect.
#covid #covid19 #coronavirus #corona -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A better graph showing how the last three days are used to do a centered 7-day average used in the forecast.
The fluctuations in the raw data are small increasing confidence in the trend seen.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Shanghai COVID19 cases following Gompertz curve.
J(t) or log[exponential growth rate] dropping exponentially with time-constant U=13 days, typical of Omicron.
Daily cases peaking at 27,000. Total cases will reach 900,000. Daily cases below 10,000 in 21 days.
Food for Shanghai! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Shanghai COVID19 cases following Gompertz curve.
J(t) or log[exponential growth rate] dropping exponentially with time-constant U=13 days, typical of Omicron.
Daily cases peaking at 27,000. Total cases will reach 900,000. Daily cases below 10,000 in 21 days.
Food for Shanghai!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Data is from WeChat “I love Shanghai” sums symptomatic & asymptomatic cases.
Calculation in open Google sheet at docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HgsfEguqEbyqfB4vtDBeyk4Pw…
It must be manually updated each day.
Method developed with Francesco Zonta @Cescoxonta -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is a good article.
I thought that Twitter could lead to an open time-stamped sources of new ideas and collaborative efforts.
Not so sure now. What you you all think?
Brett W Harmony
@harmony_brett
Really provocative piece in the Saturday Guardian by Stuart Ritchie about scientific papers. Some good suggestions too.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Brett W Harmony
@harmony_brett
Really provocative piece in the Saturday Guardian by Stuart Ritchie about scientific papers. Some good suggestions too.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Always felt need to measure deaths per million population & not per number of cases or infections.
Both of these are harder to measure than simply using counts of people.
Even more true today with huge testing capacity & separate counting of symptomatic and asymptomatic.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
We need to remember that case counts are a function of testing and Hong Kong tested little.
In East Asia wide variation of cases per fatality (see Table) from p70 recent lecture x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1509957658282905603
Good @Telegraph article on China vaccine hesitancy www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/science-and-disease/hon…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Recently gave an hour long talk on my 790 days working with COVID-19 www.dropbox.com/s/pwpcn939lddkofe/28_Mar_2022_Michael_Lev…
Talk recording will follow as soon as possible. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
We need to remember that case counts are a function of testing and Hong Kong tested little.
In East Asia wide variation of cases per fatality (see Table) from p70 recent lecture x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1509957658282905603
Good @Telegraph article on China vaccine hesitancy www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/science-and-disease/hon…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Recently gave an hour long talk on my 790 days working with COVID-19 www.dropbox.com/s/pwpcn939lddkofe/28_Mar_2022_Michael_Lev…
Talk recording will follow as soon as possible. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I worry that we are viewing Ukraine with the same one-sidedness that limited our approaches to COVID-19.
My @stanford colleague Niall Ferguson @nfergus widens perspectives, which is always worthwhile.
www.cnbc.com/2022/04/08/putin-might-use-weapons-of-mass-d… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alice Su 蘇奕安
@aliceysu
As seen on Weibo: Shanghai residents go to their balconies to sing & protest lack of supplies. A drone appears: “Please comply w covid restrictions. Control your soul’s desire for freedom. Do not open the window or sing.” m.weibo.cn/status/4755028135383701
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Just so you can find things. Link at www.dropbox.com/s/2p03o6x4jazb7ge/Michael_Levitt_Media_Tw…
Twitter advanced search works well too. For example in one line:
UK (from:mlevitt_NP2013)
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All 424 pages of my Media Tweets (with graphs) from 22 April to 14 November 2021 are available in one PDF file at:
www.dropbox.com/s/2p03o6x4jazb7ge/Michael_Levitt_Media_Tw…
Nothing has been deleted or edited.
Made this to make sure a large body of original scientific work is preserved and easily accessible. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Spoke out against lockdown early & often (Google ‘levitt lockdown’) receiving mass abuse.
Will we know who was right?
Do abusers care about the lives they damaged?
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/02/05/lonely-opposing-first…
Worse is the damage done to free-speech in science.
Is it the end of a golden period? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Advising Insilico Medicine since 2014, I am really proud of the rapid progress they are making.
Especially meaningful is that aging research is a very effective way to find target proteins that can cure diseases of us all.
Efficient drug discovery will reduce costs for all.
Aging Journal
@AgingJrnl
March 31, 2022: Aging (Aging-US) published a new issue of the latest research on aging and age-related diseases. Read Volume 14, Issue 6: aging-us.com/issue/v14i6 #publications #papers #aging #longevity #gerontology #covid19 #research #openaccess #meded
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Recently gave an hour long talk on my 790 days working with COVID-19 www.dropbox.com/s/pwpcn939lddkofe/28_Mar_2022_Michael_Lev…
Talk recording will follow as soon as possible. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Seems this starts to become relevant. These extra winter deaths may be the real burden of respiratory disease.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not easy to estimate burden of death from influenza.
1) No wide-spread testing for flu as there is for COVID.
2) Flu deaths that occur every winter are expected & so not part of excess death.
Is 5% death deficit seen when no flu or COVID indicative of real level of flu death? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Depends on what is being vaporized www.quora.com/How-close-do-you-have-to-be-to-a-nuke-to-be…
Seems a human would vaporized out to about 1,000 meters for a 9 megaton explosion.
Really frightening & graphic description by Nelson Cunningham on Quora. Certainly makes the original @nytimes article more effective
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Your grouped replies convince me I was on error. No excuses: these things happen.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Surely there is a bad error here? @nytimes
“…in the bomb, barge and surrounding lagoon water and air, out to a radius of several feet, had been vaporized and raised to a temperature of tens of million degrees.”
Such insensitivity to size scares me.
www.nytimes.com/2022/03/27/opinion/nuclear-weapons-ukrain… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Your grouped replies convince me I was on error. No excuses: these things happen.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Surely there is a bad error here? @nytimes
“…in the bomb, barge and surrounding lagoon water and air, out to a radius of several feet, had been vaporized and raised to a temperature of tens of million degrees.”
Such insensitivity to size scares me.
www.nytimes.com/2022/03/27/opinion/nuclear-weapons-ukrain… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Surely there is a bad error here? @nytimes
“…in the bomb, barge and surrounding lagoon water and air, out to a radius of several feet, had been vaporized and raised to a temperature of tens of million degrees.”
Such insensitivity to size scares me.
www.nytimes.com/2022/03/27/opinion/nuclear-weapons-ukrain… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is clearly seen in my analyses of excess death in 2020 & 2021 separately, avoiding the confusion of death FROM versus WITH COVID-19.
It shows that extra death in 2021 is strongly correlated to population health measured in years 2017 to 2019. BMI is a small contributor
Making Waves
@MakingC19Waves
The strength of government response has no correlation with Covid deaths, but population health certainly does. In short, BMI trumps NPI.
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2020.604339/full -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Lots of really good comments in this tread. All fits the analysis we are doing.
This level of common sense would have saved so much hardship a year or two ago.
Maybe many will learn from these mistakes so as not to repeat them.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Remarkable & surprising.
Ten months ago saw no correlation of high excess death percent with 2020 US election results. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1404392953565437952
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1399510703174610944
Any high correlation is unusual with COVID-19: will check & post analysis.
US Mortality
@USMortality
All-Cause Age-Adjusted Excess Mortality by US states that had a +10 point lead by one party.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Remarkable & surprising.
Ten months ago saw no correlation of high excess death percent with 2020 US election results. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1404392953565437952
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1399510703174610944
Any high correlation is unusual with COVID-19: will check & post analysis.
US Mortality
@USMortality
All-Cause Age-Adjusted Excess Mortality by US states that had a +10 point lead by one party.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Breaking my self-imposed silence. This was done in academia by academics to their colleagues.
This raises three questions for all:
(1) Will science ever recover?
(2) Will critical constructive discussion return?
(3) Will it be missed?
GB News
@GBNEWS
'It created an environment which led to the biggest assault on freedom of speech and democracy I’ve known in my lifetime.'
Ex-Sky & ITV News Executive Mark Sharman on Ofcom's warning to 'not question the official Government line.’
🖥 GB News on YouTube: www.youtube.com/c/GBNewsOnline?sub_confirmation=1&cbrd=1&…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is what I remember happening. Full of cited sources.
The Medium @d_spiegel medium.com/search used Report 9 to bel a year of extra risk of death
This disturbed & energized me as 10x too high. medium.com/@michael.levitt/the-excess-burden-of-death-fro…
My thanks to @HRenkel for keeping history straight!
Heather
@HRenkel
Report#9 from Imperial College of London & Neil Feguson fabricated Covid severity & the viability of lockdowns. Ventilator need created by a friend who stood to profit; a retracted paper, omitted data, exponential growth, invented a crisis & a solution heatherrenkel.github.io/blog/report_9.html
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Report#9 from Imperial College of London & Neil Feguson fabricated Covid severity & the viability of lockdowns. Ventilator need created by a friend who stood to profit; a retracted paper, omitted data, exponential growth, invented a crisis & a solution heatherrenkel.github.io/blog/report_9.html
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Terrific analysis. I assume the data is complete.
What are the percentages of these age grounds that are vaccinated?
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
Spain: Breakdown of moving 8-week cumulative deaths by vaccination status and age. For older ages the % of deaths of vaccinated has been increasing from ~Jan 23. For ages 30-59 years the % of deaths of vaccinated has been increasing since Nov 2021.
1/ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I so admire what @OS51388957 and @Vnafilyan are doing to get to the truth about vaccines.
The randomized control trials were for on small numbers at a time when there was little COVID-19. We need to know have effective vaccines really are. Thanks so much. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings
@lindaunobel
More than 100 #nobel Laureates have signed a declaration for #peace, calling on governments to use scientific knowledge responsibly and urging President Putin to recall his forces and establish peace in the #ukraine: www.lindau-nobel.org/news-declaration-for-peace/ @maxplanckpress #scienceforukraine
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Current East Asian Omicron outbreaks all Gompertz but have very different CFR values.
FORECAST
CASES DEATH PLACE
6.5M 11K Japan
660K 440 Singapore
25M 28K Korea
630K 9.6K Hong Kong
CFR in Hong Kong is 20 times CFR in Singapore.
Really need excess death! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is a factor.
Not clear how resistance arises. It could be it pull-forward of death (do not like over-kill) in which most susceptible die earlier.
Could be natural resistance (herd immunity) from intense early outbreak.
Compare NYC, UK & Sweden below.
So much mystery
Martin Haditsch Prof, MD, PhD
@HaditschM
Dear Michael, could this maybe be explained by the fact that the countries showing no excess death rate now had already suffered a substantial overkill in this age group before.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Korea outbreak is Gompertz with ln(Exponential Growth Rate) dropping linearly with time.
Total cases & deaths are 25,000,000 & 25,000 (CFR=1000).
Population 52M so 50% infected. Aiming for natural immunity?
Deaths fill deficit of 32,000.
Sheet
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1G0tAASIL6Ibow8oLa4hH8BBr0…
John Kitcher
@kitcherjohn
Could you take a look at South Korea please? We're seeing 360k new cases/day. Feels like the start of the end. ncov.mohw.go.kr/en/bdBoardList.do
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Daily cases & deaths have peaked in Hong Kong.
Cases will get to 640,000.
Deaths will get to 9,500.
The Case Fatality Rate is 1.5%, which is higher than in other Omicron outbreaks.
This is twice the deaths reported in Wuhan two years ago for a smaller population.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good news for Hong Kong.
Daily cases peaked as earlier. Daily death close to peaking.
Total reported deaths high at 6,000. Excess deaths will be much less.
Nice to ‘return’ to Hong Kong two year after working with Patrick Tam @drpatricktam there. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Surprising is significant excess death in over 65-age group during supposedly mild Omicron wave in Israel, Netherlands, NYC & Austria but not in France, Denmark England & Portugal.
All locations well-vaccinated by the end of 2021.
What is the difference between them? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Important observation.
Chile looks worse now than ever before with excess death 65% above expected for over 65 year olds.
Only good news is that the excess death for those under 65 is better than July 2021.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
CHILE: 93% population vaccinated and in all age groups except children, there is a huge (50%) excess deaths in January and February, in the same height range as some of the worst waves during the pandemic (first wave in Spain and Italy, second in UK and Portugal, etc). Worrying.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong does not make sense. COVID-19 death rate much higher than in Korea or Japan.
Is this due to definition of death?
Recently there has been a little excess death for ages 85+ in Korea, which has a large 2029-21 death deficit.
Does anyone know excess death in Hong Kong?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I appreciate the responses and the obvious focus on vaccine level in old people as well as vaccine type.
COVID-19 death globally is often with co-mobility so the excess death will be a better measure of death burden. Also, may have a death deficit to make up. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Did not study UN prediction.
Baby boomers were born 1946 to 1964; midpoint (1946+1964)/2=1955. People born in 1955 turned 65 in 2020 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers
As old Boomer, long felt need for young to get independence & opportunities we got
They didn’t & worse now, post-COVID19
Rob😠
@realRobPlumber
Are you implying the the excess mortality we have recorded in 20/21 was predicted at (recorded levels) because of an ageing pop. even without Covid ?
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Ansgar John
@ansgarjohn
Around the 17th minute @MLevitt_NP2013 Noble Prize 2013 addresses that issue
www.mediatheque.lindau-nobel.org/videos/38691/corona-the-… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
No data found 2020 & 21.
UN predictions before the COVID19 pandemic. www.macrotrends.net/countries/WLD/world/death-rate
Death expected to increase by 0.5% to 1% per year from 2020 WITHOUT COVID-19.
Mortality org 940M increased 1.4M in 2020 + 21.
World could increase by 5M (4% of 120M) in 2020 + 21
Ansgar John
@ansgarjohn
Prof. Levitt any idea of total global deaths in 2020? 2019 estimate was around 60m if I understand correctly?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
New Zealand now past peak as forecast.
Universality of self-limited Gompertz growth allows early predictions.
It also means that physics drives growth as indicated with @Cescoxonta in x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1456825752297648130
The scale free network of human connections has super-spreaders
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
New Zealand data is extremely noisy but this seems a likely scenario as the blue line has a slope of 10 days seen in many other Omicron outbreaks.
Cases (7-day average) peaking near 10-Mar at 20,000 per day.
Follow open Google Sheet yourself:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1e0W_hYuV6JHmcggffWkA-7ztw… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good news for Hong Kong.
Daily cases peaked as earlier. Daily death close to peaking.
Total reported deaths high at 6,000. Excess deaths will be much less.
Nice to ‘return’ to Hong Kong two year after working with Patrick Tam @drpatricktam there. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hard to know when to remove background
Can use the fact that most Omicron outbreaks have a U time-constant of about 10 days. This makes your start day (15-Feb) better than mine (18-Jan)
13-Feb star forecasts peak of 35K daily cases on 8-Mar. with U=11 days.
High uncertainty
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
You're doing it wrong.
With your little trick you can easily turn raging exp growth into a plunging J(t). -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yUoafk9RLWN05BvKXYaWI2vGu… is open link to our complete calculation
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong may be indicating how mainland China with 200X more people will deal with future outbreaks.
Focused protection is key!
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Gompertz shows daily cases have already peaked. Death peak expected within 5 days.
Is this a trial run for mainland China?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong leaders are holding a steady course against lockdown & mass testing
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Our Gompertz says may be past peak in daily cases.
Total cases 700-1000K; deaths ~5K.
High death partly due to 2020-21 deficit: no COVID-19 or flu.
Applaud brave actions.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
8) Back to Hong Kong— just how bad is #covid19 deaths in 🇭🇰 right now? It is almost “Holy Mary” bad. It’s higher than any record high that US or Europe has ever seen. When hospitals 🏥 & morgues overloaded, it’s not merely “with COVID”—it’s directly COVID. HK is undervaccinated.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong leaders are holding a steady course against lockdown & mass testing
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Our Gompertz says may be past peak in daily cases.
Total cases 700-1000K; deaths ~5K.
High death partly due to 2020-21 deficit: no COVID-19 or flu.
Applaud brave actions.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
8) Back to Hong Kong— just how bad is #covid19 deaths in 🇭🇰 right now? It is almost “Holy Mary” bad. It’s higher than any record high that US or Europe has ever seen. When hospitals 🏥 & morgues overloaded, it’s not merely “with COVID”—it’s directly COVID. HK is undervaccinated.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong seems close to peaking daily cases. Daily deaths rising. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yUoafk9RLWN05BvKXYaWI2vGu…
Forecast at end ~1,200,000 reported COVID-19 cases & ~5,000 reported COVID-19 deaths.
This will be a CFR (case fatality ratio) of 0.4%, about 5 weeks of extra normal all-cause death.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 in Hong Kong is not following self-limited Gompertz growth. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DNgRmX7O0DGFEm3jRXTGdeWHW…
The disease is behaving very strangely spreading with fixed exponential growth rate.
Very worrying. Could this be an accumulated frail population from 2 years without flu or COVID-19? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, Vladimir Putin single-handedly cured the world of COVID-19. Could have really helped reduce the panic two years ago.
Still interested in Japan, Korea, Hong Kong, Singapore & New Zealand as they may shed light on China’s exit strategy. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 in Hong Kong is not following self-limited Gompertz growth. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DNgRmX7O0DGFEm3jRXTGdeWHW…
The disease is behaving very strangely spreading with fixed exponential growth rate.
Very worrying. Could this be an accumulated frail population from 2 years without flu or COVID-19? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The analysis that follows in a team effort based on the 14Mar20 report involving Patrick Tam (Hong Kong), Francesco Zonta (Shanghaitech), Frédéric Poitevin, João Rodrigues, Fatima Pardo-Avila and Andrea Scaiewicz (all Stanford).
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It is also three weeks since my optimistic interviews in the Calcalist www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3800632,00.html
and LA Times www.latimes.com/science/story/2020-03-22/coronavirus-outb… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@NYCMayorsOffice Thanks to all who got us complete data on NYC cases & deaths. Our global team (Shanghai, Hong Kong, Israel, Sweden, Holland, Stanford) is hard at work 24/7. Follow us.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@DrJBhattacharya @MartinKulldorff @SunetraGupta
Singapore, South Korea & Hong Kong are focusing protection.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1494307119700402182
and
x.com/gbdeclaration/status/1324002676535894017
Seems that Great Barrington Declaration will save lives after all in the populous, high-density East Asian countries.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong may be indicating how mainland China with 200X more people will deal with future outbreaks.
Focused protection is key!
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Gompertz shows daily cases have already peaked. Death peak expected within 5 days.
Is this a trial run for mainland China?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong leaders are holding a steady course against lockdown & mass testing
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Our Gompertz says may be past peak in daily cases.
Total cases 700-1000K; deaths ~5K.
High death partly due to 2020-21 deficit: no COVID-19 or flu.
Applaud brave actions.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
8) Back to Hong Kong— just how bad is #covid19 deaths in 🇭🇰 right now? It is almost “Holy Mary” bad. It’s higher than any record high that US or Europe has ever seen. When hospitals 🏥 & morgues overloaded, it’s not merely “with COVID”—it’s directly COVID. HK is undervaccinated.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@DrJBhattacharya @MartinKulldorff @SunetraGupta
Singapore, South Korea & Hong Kong are focusing protection.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1494307119700402182
and
x.com/gbdeclaration/status/1324002676535894017
Seems that Great Barrington Declaration will save lives after all in the populous, high-density East Asian countries.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong may be indicating how mainland China with 200X more people will deal with future outbreaks.
Focused protection is key!
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Gompertz shows daily cases have already peaked. Death peak expected within 5 days.
Is this a trial run for mainland China?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong leaders are holding a steady course against lockdown & mass testing
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Our Gompertz says may be past peak in daily cases.
Total cases 700-1000K; deaths ~5K.
High death partly due to 2020-21 deficit: no COVID-19 or flu.
Applaud brave actions.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
8) Back to Hong Kong— just how bad is #covid19 deaths in 🇭🇰 right now? It is almost “Holy Mary” bad. It’s higher than any record high that US or Europe has ever seen. When hospitals 🏥 & morgues overloaded, it’s not merely “with COVID”—it’s directly COVID. HK is undervaccinated.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong may be indicating how mainland China with 200X more people will deal with future outbreaks.
Focused protection is key!
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Gompertz shows daily cases have already peaked. Death peak expected within 5 days.
Is this a trial run for mainland China?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong leaders are holding a steady course against lockdown & mass testing
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Our Gompertz says may be past peak in daily cases.
Total cases 700-1000K; deaths ~5K.
High death partly due to 2020-21 deficit: no COVID-19 or flu.
Applaud brave actions.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
8) Back to Hong Kong— just how bad is #covid19 deaths in 🇭🇰 right now? It is almost “Holy Mary” bad. It’s higher than any record high that US or Europe has ever seen. When hospitals 🏥 & morgues overloaded, it’s not merely “with COVID”—it’s directly COVID. HK is undervaccinated.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Krishnan Chittur
@cheprofessor
"To deny or put up barriers to natural gas projects and the benefits they provide, while Putin is actively and effectively using energy as an economic and political weapon against our allies, is just beyond the pale" (Senator Manchin, WV) - Reality of Russian Interference
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong leaders are holding a steady course against lockdown & mass testing
www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/health-environment/article/31…
Our Gompertz says may be past peak in daily cases.
Total cases 700-1000K; deaths ~5K.
High death partly due to 2020-21 deficit: no COVID-19 or flu.
Applaud brave actions.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
8) Back to Hong Kong— just how bad is #covid19 deaths in 🇭🇰 right now? It is almost “Holy Mary” bad. It’s higher than any record high that US or Europe has ever seen. When hospitals 🏥 & morgues overloaded, it’s not merely “with COVID”—it’s directly COVID. HK is undervaccinated.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yUoafk9RLWN05BvKXYaWI2vGu… is open link to our complete calculation
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really terrific. Thanks for your persistence.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very clear representation so I magnified one panel for others to read more easily.
Have you considered plotting the vaccination data as newly vaccinated per week? That would give to peaks in vaccination rate that could be related to peaks in excess death rate for ages 65 - 74. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hong Kong seems close to peaking daily cases. Daily deaths rising. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1yUoafk9RLWN05BvKXYaWI2vGu…
Forecast at end ~1,200,000 reported COVID-19 cases & ~5,000 reported COVID-19 deaths.
This will be a CFR (case fatality ratio) of 0.4%, about 5 weeks of extra normal all-cause death.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 in Hong Kong is not following self-limited Gompertz growth. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DNgRmX7O0DGFEm3jRXTGdeWHW…
The disease is behaving very strangely spreading with fixed exponential growth rate.
Very worrying. Could this be an accumulated frail population from 2 years without flu or COVID-19? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Collateral Global Charity
@collateralglbl
CG EXCLUSIVE YOUTUBE PREMIERE & LIVE Q&A
Professor John Ioannidis and @DrJBhattacharya
*WED 9TH MARCH 20:00 GMT, 15:00 EST, 12:00 PST*
"It's really a shame that we let that happen, that we just lost the perspective of what really matters"
www.youtube.com/watch?v=x0u8jWMluSk -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is striking.
The similarity between the two largest periods of Israel excess death in weeks 29 - 45 of 2020 & 2021 you see for 85+ is also seen in the excess death for all ages.
That no one was vaccinated in 2020 and almost all had 3 shots in 2021 is a mystery. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thank you.
Michael Braun
@Michael69699813
Nice tool, indeed.
The Gompertz growth analysis fits performed on February 14th and today do not show any major differences. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, Vladimir Putin single-handedly cured the world of COVID-19. Could have really helped reduce the panic two years ago.
Still interested in Japan, Korea, Hong Kong, Singapore & New Zealand as they may shed light on China’s exit strategy. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hard to know when to remove background
Can use the fact that most Omicron outbreaks have a U time-constant of about 10 days. This makes your start day (15-Feb) better than mine (18-Jan)
13-Feb star forecasts peak of 35K daily cases on 8-Mar. with U=11 days.
High uncertainty
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
You're doing it wrong.
With your little trick you can easily turn raging exp growth into a plunging J(t). -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Korea has a 33,000 death deficit (less all-cause death than expected) since 1-Jan-2020 due to absence of Influenza or Corona
COVID-19 cases & deaths now rising & following self-limiting Gompertz. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1N1kwRmh-J8xwzMmsVG6ciVbHR…
In a few months we will know real death toll.
John Ziegler
@Zigmanfreud
The battle over COVID is finally starting to fade but a war over the history of the last 2 years is just starting. Its imperative attention be focused on South Korea (pop. 50 mill) & New Zealand (pop. 5 mill) where what is happening, with 0 signs of slowing, proves it was all BS!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
New Zealand data is extremely noisy but this seems a likely scenario as the blue line has a slope of 10 days seen in many other Omicron outbreaks.
Cases (7-day average) peaking near 10-Mar at 20,000 per day.
Follow open Google Sheet yourself:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1e0W_hYuV6JHmcggffWkA-7ztw… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
voxukraine.org/en/an-open-letter-from-nobel-laureates/
“We respect the calm and the strength of the Ukrainian people. We are with you. Our hearts go out to the families and friends of all, Ukrainians and Russians, who have died and been injured already. May peace come to this piece of our beautiful world.” -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I was really excited because I thought USF was “University of San Francisco” not “University of Southern Florida”.
That said I am proud that Stanford no longer enforcing indoor masking. No mask made my visit to the gym the highlight of my day.
Clay Travis
@ClayTravis
This is phenomenal. Ron Desantis tells USF kids they don’t have to wear their masks because they don’t do anything and it’s time to stop with all the political theater.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
2 months ago, @USMortality & I forecast daily case peak in Germany.
I had 100K/1Jan, he had 300K/3Mar & German had Government 350K
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1485028245229776910
x.com/USMortality/status/1484985155773243399
Actual value is 180K/8Feb. with linear drop of J(t) expected for Gompertz self-limiting growth.
US Mortality
@USMortality
Germany is looking at some nice case growth!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 in Hong Kong is not following self-limited Gompertz growth. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DNgRmX7O0DGFEm3jRXTGdeWHW…
The disease is behaving very strangely spreading with fixed exponential growth rate.
Very worrying. Could this be an accumulated frail population from 2 years without flu or COVID-19? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
In the fog of war (on Twitter too), Efraim Halevi @haaretzcom writes clearly
www.haaretz.com/world-news/europe/.premium.HIGHLIGHT-form…
Based on the 1962 Cuban Missile, he advises compromise “Putin cannot afford a Chechen style end to the present war, while Biden cannot afford to let events spin out of control.” -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Japan Sheets not open docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Cnc7oqijUdxdop_QsMVnwm6JP…
COVID-19 has become less important, a welcome development.
Virus spread as measured by cases and deaths remains important.
Japan is clean Gompertz, U=18 days, from start.
Bug spoils case/day prediction once peak passed
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Japan latest outbreak started with a very low background to display universally-observed Gompertz trajectory. It has just peaked.
Blue J(t)=ln(Exponential Growth Rate) shows linear descent from 7-Jan when daily cases were 10% of peak value. Perfect plot!
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Cnc7oqijUdxdop_QsMVnwm6JP… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Severity of COVID-19 measured by age-adjusted excess death never showed much correlation with restrictions. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1399510703174610944
Still looking for justification of intervention beyond that they make decision makers feel they matter.
Restrictions must by justified!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It was in The Guardian @guardian four days ago but missed it due other more pressing issues
www.theguardian.com/world/commentisfree/2022/feb/25/end-n…
A “for ever” lesson from the the past two years is believe nothing without first checking.
This will be something we will appreciate more and more going forward.
PeterSweden
@PeterSweden7
THIS IS HUGE NEWS
The High Court in New Zealand has ruled that vaccine mandates for Police and Defence Force is UNLAWFUL.
Why isn't the media talking about this? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I have waited for this for 20 months.
New York City has had almost no excess death since week 20 of 2020, 17-May-2020.
In the 6 weeks from 23-Mar-20, excess death in NYC was more intense than all other locations worldwide. It was between 2 & 7 times the natural death rate.
Hold2
@Hold2LLC
And…
NYC Mayor Adams: "As I said last week, we listened to the doctors and health professionals who now say it's time to remove masks and stop requiring vaccination due to how well NYC has done to reach Low status." -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
My mother likely felt the same way until a few years ago…
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is one of the greatest heroes in modern times. I am in total awe of the man.
Barry Tigay
@TigayBarry
Press interviews #ukraine President Zelensky’s mother.
Press: Mrs. Zelensky, the whole world admires your son Volodymyr for his bravery and leadership. You must be very proud.
Mrs. Zelensky: My other son is a doctor. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Shoshan Brosh Levitt
@BroshLevitt
The artwork “Angel” (2010) by Chinese artist Xu Jingyu (born in 1981, Shandong, China) is more relevant to me than ever.
Corona days, war in Europe ...
Are angels expected to redeem us from herd-mentality?
1/2 -
Michael Levitt reposted
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Henry Foy
@HenryJFoy
💥 Potentially huge development with major ramifications if correct that Turkey will close Bosporous to Russia’s warships entering Black Sea.
Turkey is a @NATO member. Putin has warned of retaliation against third country’s “meddling” in his invasion of Ukraine
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
I thank my friend Mr. President of 🇹🇷 @RTErdogan and the people of 🇹🇷 for their strong support. The ban on the passage of 🇷🇺 warships to the Black Sea and significant military and humanitarian support for 🇺🇦 are extremely important today. The people of 🇺🇦 will never forget that!
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
The so-called “COVID brain” is actually… a “Lockdown brain”!👇
Monica Gandhi MD, MPH
@MonicaGandhi9
MGH study: "The societal and lifestyle disruptions caused by the pandemic may have triggered inflammation in the brain that can affect mental health, according to the study. The impacts manifest as symptoms including fatigue, brain fog and mental distress"
www.nbcboston.com/news/local/mgh-study-pandemic-lockdown-… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Oops…
Science just realized that masks could be bad for you www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-06605-w
COVID-19, the collateral damage nightmare that never seems to end -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
The death burden of SARS-CoV-2 in Canada is estimated at 1.8x bad flu season. In Western Europe, it's roughly 2.2x bad flu season.
According to some estimates, the 1918 influenza was as much as 100x more lethal than seasonal flu!👇
www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/reconstruction-1918-vi… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Indeed. Obvious & deliberately ignored due to panic caused by incorrect predictions that COVID-19 would be as severe as 1918 influenza.
Early indications from Diamond Princess suggested 4X a severe recent flu season. No one wanted to listen as they clamored for medieval lockdown
patrickruch
@patrickruch
What else did we expect ?
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Rob
@Rob76790475
Do you follow @MLevitt_NP2013 he was right all the way. His models are spot on and are free on google.docs. Cheaper and more accurate than the RIVM, which is not that difficult
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Senescence
@7Wave4
@MartinKulldorff @MLevitt_NP2013 @NickHudsonCT @prof_shahar : main stream media @SvD ack's what many of us saw already summer 2020... and were called names for... (unfortunately behind paywall).
Senescence
@7Wave4
Sveriges överdödlighet är näst lägst i Norden | SvD softwaredevelopmentperestroika.wordpress.com/2022/02/25/s…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
From nothing to the start of Phase I Clinical Trials is amazing.
Seems to me the AI will dramatically reduce the cost of finding desperately needed new drugs.
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
Positive news on a down day - I have something better than my birthday to celebrate today! Phase 0 is complete and we entered Phase 1 with an AI-discovered antifibrotic ☀️🌻🌞 Story:
@PeterDiamandis @kaifulee @daniel_kraft @MLevitt_NP2013 @davidasinclair
insilico.com/phase1 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
And the damage from COVID-19 school closures goes rolling on affecting disproportionately the less fortunate & the young.
srcd.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/cdev.13738 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Erik Rosenberg 🇪🇺 🇸🇪
@ErikRosenberg89
Ukraine seems to have won a significant military victory at the Hostomel airfield. Prevented an airhead that was supposed to allow encircling of Kyiv in a very short time. It won Ukraine serious amounts of time.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Patty 🌻🇺🇸🌵
@littlebytesnews
RT:
Hostomel airfield "is recaptured by the Armed Forces of Ukraine. The enemy landing force has been destroyed. The plan to capture the runway to receive troops from Russia failed."
— Gregor Martin (@Guderian_Xaba) Feb 24, 2022 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Lt (later Col and eventually Gn) Scheisskopf
@GnScheisskopf
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
After all the damage has been done, others agree with warnings given publicly to the UK & USA on @unherd in April 2020. @Newsweek
www.newsweek.com/widespread-covid-lockdowns-were-hugely-d…
A little late after so many young people have been so hurt done.
Listen again; use common sense!
youtu.be/bl-sZdfLcEk?1 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Mediocre At Best
@beiras_michael
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is an important development and we look forward to what @OS51388957 has managed to achieve.
Thanks from all seeking complete, unambiguous data. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Leading Israeli Physicians and Researchers in an Open Letter to Prime Minister Trudeau:
"Deep Concerns Regarding Recent Rhetoric Portraying Protesters as Nazi Sympathizers"
@elonmusk @JustinTrudeau -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very good news. Unexpected given the ferocity of the Austrian restrictions.
Toby Young
@toadmeister
The Austrian Government has done a massive U-turn on vaccine passports. From March 5th, the unvaccinated will be allowed back into restaurants, cafes and bars. Mandatory vaccination law now unlikely to be implemented. dailysceptic.org/2022/02/17/austria-u-turns-on-vaccine-pa…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Focused Protection of the Most Vulnerable in South Korea” @nytimes
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/17/world/asia/south-korea-covid-s…
GBD Oct20 needed debate. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1474038135336091652
Korean Exponential Growth Rate dropping as expected by Gompertz.
Excess Death since 1-Jan-20 -33,000, a deficit.
Wish them all success!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
www.wsj.com/articles/fauci-collins-emails-great-barringto…
I finally made it into the Wall Street Journal because of Fauci & Collins. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
John Ioannides featured in The @Telegraph
x.com/Telegraph/status/1493693746369683457
His paper bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/2/e052891.full
“Both GBD and JSM include many stellar scientists, but JSM has far more powerful social media presence and this may have shaped the impression that it is the dominant narrative.”
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
Anti-lockdown scientists were viewed as having ‘fringe’ ideas because those calling for draconian restrictions had more followers on social media, a study has shown www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/02/15/lockdown-debate-skewe…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Lessons for Next Time
From really smart friend NOT on Twitter:
“Danish government published a warning about Covid misinformation. But this warning is unique because it is against EXAGGERATING the dangers of the pandemic.”
We really messed up globally!
en.ssi.dk/covid-19/typical-misinformation-regarding-danis… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Your charts are wonderful. So wish we had interacted from the start.
Much more understood now.
One question that bothers me is timing of future waves. Is it periodicity, seasonality, supply of susceptibles?
Could you please share the data shown in white on black as a table?
US Mortality
@USMortality
If you need daily updated COVID-19 charts, check this out:
>>> covid19.usmortality.com
#covid #covid19 #corona #coronavirus -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
Check out the new data:
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
Here is an update of our preprint showing how the @DeepMind #alphafold can be used for drug discovery. New more potent hits - additional 20 days including a week of CNY holiday in between.
Constructive critique is welcome, more data coming.
@A_Aspuru_Guzik @MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
"Germany reveals end date for most Covid restrictions – reports" www.rt.com/news/549295-germany-end-covid-restrictions-mar…
This would be great news. Shows smart epidemic planning on the part of Europe's largest nation
Gompertz growth analysis shows peaking has happened
Follow yourself: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16t4rfS5-7NAPPBZtP5dscXeGQ… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Heres another chart, using Jeffery Morris's graphs of ONS data: Dates of v eligibility shouldn't relate to death peaks, but they do. V was rolled out by the month to each younger age group & non-Covid death peaks correlate to that, peaks moving along by the month also @TrdisOprtr
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Jay, certainly seems a better way to spend money.
Still I worry that protection no matter how good leads to collateral damage caused by disruption.
The last part of the Abstract makes it clear that those protected from COVID19 death actually suffer 8.4% more “natural” death.
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
Important paper showing that high quality nursing homes were better able to stop covid spread & protect the vulnerable. Imagine if we had invested in improving nursing home quality instead of masking toddlers.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0167629622000121 -
Michael Levitt reposted
EnterTextHere.txt
@EntertexthereT
Sitting here, speechless!
@2Genervter
@Parsifaler
@JikkyKjj
@DeinertDoc
@Daoyu15
You guys know about this study?? Its all there! Impaired telomere/chromosome repair, cytokine upregulation and more!
www.nature.com/articles/s41421-021-00329-3 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
As an expert, what is your estimate of the percentage of normal all-cause deaths that are due to normal influenza & ILI?
Is this percentage different in US, Europe & China?
How much worse is COVID-19 than flu?
John Cullen 🐓
@I_Am_JohnCullen
Anyone want to fill @MLevitt_NP2013 in?
Let him know what's been going on?
(Although he won the Nobel Prize in 2013,
he's late to this party..)
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Striking and something I had never seen before.
Still, with 253 cases per 100,000, (0.25%) this is much less than the 20% of the population with confirmed cases in Europe and the USA.
Team Sweden
@SwedenTeam
If anyone can explain why China had such an unusually large, covid-sized flu season in 2019 I’d love to hear it.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
*new (more mistakes)
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
and make mistakes... Lots of them. This is the unavoidable price of trying to learn something knew.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
and make mistakes... Lots of them. This is the unavoidable price of trying to learn something knew.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Striking and something I had never seen before.
Still, with 253 cases per 100,000, (0.25%) this is much less than the 20% of the population with confirmed cases in Europe and the USA.
Team Sweden
@SwedenTeam
If anyone can explain why China had such an unusually large, covid-sized flu season in 2019 I’d love to hear it.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I like your idea of European coastal climate mitigation.
UK shows small U of 14 days.
Ireland has U of 5 days at end but earlier it was 11 days.
Austria has U 20 days, slow like in Germany
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here are more:
Poland is fast with U=13 days. Would expect it to be slow like Germany & Austria
Czech Republic also fast with U=11 days.
This is still a mystery. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Your plots show most recent previous year with mortality > 2020 & 2021 for different age ranges
0-15 2019
16-24 2010
25-34 2009
35-44 <2002 <==
45-54 2003 <==
55-64 2010
65-74 2009
75-84 2017
85+ 2018
All ? <== Please do
Why are ages 35 to 54 so bad?
john digregorio
@digregjf
For whatever it's worth here are the yearly all-causes death rates for England and Wales from 2002-2021 by age group.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Nice but age bands are different.
One lesson for future global pandemics is to keep better data on populations, deaths, etc.
Say what you like about Sweden, but she has better population data than any where else I have seen.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1285813187523366912
john digregorio
@digregjf
Here's England/Wales on same plot with California and all 50 states (USA).
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very helpful.
From your data, Mortality of the missing 21% (11M) is 864 deaths/100,000 is 34% less than that of the PHDA data set (1155 deaths/100,000).
You may be right that this group is younger. We could tell by comparing age band populations of ONS & all England.
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
Those included in the PHDA dataset have a higher mortality rate than the missing 11M.
That is because all immigrants since the 2011 census (>3M) are excluded. Immigrants very likely skew younger. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very useful. Now we can estimate the vaccination status of the missing 21%.
Do you have a link to data?
vladimir saltao
@SaltaoVladimir
Damn why don't you check first that , You would find the answer to your question yourself ...
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That is interesting.
It would imply that the low U value for France is an artifact of the overlap. We saw low U <14 days for other Omicron outbreaks so are they also overlaps?
Let me see:
Italy 13 days
Spain 14 days
Belgium 6 days
Israel 10 days
Still puzzling... -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Let me check. Yes, you are right.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16t4rfS5-7NAPPBZtP5dscXeGQ…
This took a long time with a U time-constant that was double that seen in most other Omicron outbreaks. Compare with France, below.
Any ideas why?
Jorge Peter
@hippoblue
Germany is as of now also peaking imho
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Korea early in its latest outbreak. Gompertz straight line seen in blue dropping J(t)=ln-(Exponential Growth Rate).
Forecast peak date and size (case/day) still dependent of line fit. Show plots for 21, 28 and 14 days below. Expect U about 12 days.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1N1kwRmh-J8xwzMmsVG6ciVbHR… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Japan latest outbreak started with a very low background to display universally-observed Gompertz trajectory. It has just peaked.
Blue J(t)=ln(Exponential Growth Rate) shows linear descent from 7-Jan when daily cases were 10% of peak value. Perfect plot!
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Cnc7oqijUdxdop_QsMVnwm6JP… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
No intended order
@Ray_J__
@jsm2334
@connolly_s
@JohnDee87833661
@digregjf
@PienaarJm
@Marco_Piani
@orwell2022
@profnfenton
@ONS
@OS51388957
@USMortality
@ChGefaell
@RanIsraeli
@pieterstreicher
@NickHudsonCT
@markoftec
@RolandDunbrack
@birb_k
@mr_Smith_Econ
& any one else!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
ONS study of COVID19 vaccines possibly flawed as it uses 79% of England population older than 10.
Health of missing 21% not known.
Are 21% unvaccinated?
Could we check this using age-adjusted mortality of 2021 England & Wales death & population data?
Can do this together?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Professor Fenton, ONS released report for all 2021.
Vaccine seems better & better.
PDF www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsa…
Excel
www.ons.gov.uk/file?uri=%2fpeoplepopulationandcommunity%2…
*Will you analyze this data?
*Did the ONS responded to your criticism?
*Could ASMR for 2017-19 show bad health of unvaccinated? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
ONS study of COVID19 vaccines possibly flawed as it uses 79% of England population older than 10.
Health of missing 21% not known.
Are 21% unvaccinated?
Could we check this using age-adjusted mortality of 2021 England & Wales death & population data?
Can do this together?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Professor Fenton, ONS released report for all 2021.
Vaccine seems better & better.
PDF www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsa…
Excel
www.ons.gov.uk/file?uri=%2fpeoplepopulationandcommunity%2…
*Will you analyze this data?
*Did the ONS responded to your criticism?
*Could ASMR for 2017-19 show bad health of unvaccinated? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Arguing about comparative fit of the Gompertz Function with its super-exponential initial growth compared to a function with exponential initial growth like the Logistics Function, seems so dated.
First UK outbreak shows early straight line J(t) descent docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ll3JbMpwEwYjhSDrmT-COLZVB…
US Mortality
@USMortality
Well it is still a model. And this here is also a model just using gompertz derivative. Mr. Levitt uses J(t) method, it appears to be more accurate.
It is certainly more accurate than the other models we have seen, but in the end it is just a model, and it is dependent on data. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Follow science due to a 1963 London stay with Tikvah Alper. Her husband, Max Sterne, is my mother’s brother
Both accomplished: Tikvah for discovering prions; Max for Anthrax vaccine
Tikvah began a Ph.D with Lise Meitner in Berlin & left in 1932
Meitner may be worst Nobel miss.
JCIM & JCTC Journals
@JCIM_JCTC
Happy international day of women & girls in science!
Which female computational chemists inspired you to follow this field?
#womeninscienceday #compchem
#womeninscience #womeninstem -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Amazing work.
Together with the higher resolution individual plots at github.com/USMortality/COVID19-Charts this deserves careful study.
What is Smoothed 200X?
Peak labels overlap. Can you separate them?
Can you publish table of peaks?
Can you compare US cases to excess deaths?
US Mortality
@USMortality
Generated Case graphs for all US states!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why do experts always justify their mistakes by making more?
It gives us the feeling they have hidden agendas.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Early Analysis of Omicron Severity & Self-Limited Gompertz Spread.
25-Dec x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1475005181091790849
21-Dec x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1473399991003762691
19-Dec x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1472471671181385728
Dec 13 x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1470433139965190154
10 Dec x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1469278265168777220
Clearly known to be mild on 22 Dec.
Freddie Sayers
@freddiesayers
Latest from Neil Ferguson and Imperial estimates Omicron as intrinsically 70% less severe than Delta.
Quite a difference from their 16th Dec report to SAGE: "We find no evidence of Omicron having different severity from Delta."
No mention of why they got it so wrong before. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Early Analysis of Omicron Severity & Self-Limited Gompertz Spread.
25-Dec x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1475005181091790849
21-Dec x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1473399991003762691
19-Dec x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1472471671181385728
Dec 13 x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1470433139965190154
10 Dec x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1469278265168777220
Clearly known to be mild on 22 Dec.
Freddie Sayers
@freddiesayers
Latest from Neil Ferguson and Imperial estimates Omicron as intrinsically 70% less severe than Delta.
Quite a difference from their 16th Dec report to SAGE: "We find no evidence of Omicron having different severity from Delta."
No mention of why they got it so wrong before. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Designing Better Pharmaceuticals with Better Physics.
Paper from InterX Inc.
www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-28041-0
“Accurate determination of solvation free energies of neutral organic compounds from first principles”
Leonid Pereyaslavets, Ganesh Kamath, …Boris Fain
chemistrycommunity.nature.com/posts/arrow-force-field-mol… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
NVision improves the magnetic resonance at all scales.
Published in 𝗝𝗔𝗖𝗦
“factor of 100-1000-fold NMR signal enhancement has the potential to accelerate drug discovery, identify biomarkers in metabolomic applications..”
Better characterization good!
www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:689715258490… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
OK, earlier this week the results came back and we got a bunch of 200-300 nM hits for CDK20 from the AlphaFold DB structure. Will update the ArXiv paper this week. Adds another 20 days to the timeline including a 7-day CNY holiday in between.
@A_Aspuru_Guzik @MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Not easy to change plots.
UK England & Wales is 60 million population. USA is 330 million so 5.5X more. Expected death is a better base-line for normal level. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are so right.
2021 excess death in the USA is very different than that in the UK.
After 2021_5 there is so little in the UK.
In stark contrast, lots of excess death in USA for all 2021, especially for the under-65 year olds.
Understanding why this should be top priority.
US Mortality
@USMortality
In contrast in the US we are seeing more and more excess mortality:
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Dear Professor Fenton, ONS released report for all 2021.
Vaccine seems better & better.
PDF www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsa…
Excel
www.ons.gov.uk/file?uri=%2fpeoplepopulationandcommunity%2…
*Will you analyze this data?
*Did the ONS responded to your criticism?
*Could ASMR for 2017-19 show bad health of unvaccinated? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Forgot to add photo of Cases. USA Deaths here now too. CFR expected to be 64,000/23,000,000 = 0.287% (1 in 360).
Cases: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iWY5NCUdeik85g73MWyhlzs-v…
Deaths: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ovUNfZitLL6dPPC7D6n3Sa4Uy…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is a problem caused by subtracting a fixed flat baseline from daily counts each day.
The baseline should actually decrease if it is due to overlapping outbreaks and not due to an endemic flat baseline.
Seen in USA, too.
Any ideas how to fix this would be much appreciated.
Liberator
@b24liberat0r
In Spain it looks a bit strange. Adjustment was very good until the end of January, but then a sudden drop in J(t) is observed.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is a problem caused by subtracting a fixed flat baseline from daily counts each day.
The baseline should actually decrease if it is due to overlapping outbreaks and not due to an endemic flat baseline.
Seen in USA, too.
Any ideas how to fix this would be much appreciated.
Liberator
@b24liberat0r
In Spain it looks a bit strange. Adjustment was very good until the end of January, but then a sudden drop in J(t) is observed.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Seeing people take responsibility for their locations is such a great reward for me.
Ramza Behoulve 🇨🇭
@RamzaBehoulve
Thanks to @Thomie_ch special @BAG_OFSP_UFSP charts and tables, my small predicton of epidemic peak for Switzerland turned out successful so far using the much popularized Gompertz function by @MLevitt_NP2013
Even my basic understanding of it was enoughThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Rerrific to work with you. Quality of the prediction depends how hard it is to get the slope of the descending log(Exponential Growth Rate) straight line.
Slope time-constant U is 16 days, longer than typical Omicron value of 12 days.
Link: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LSNHumgJhIAqlLGLf1u0-XKpk…
US Mortality
@USMortality
Back on 1/27 we were able to successfully predict the peak with about 9k cases for @Oslejs's Latvia!
- @MLevitt_NP2013's J(t) method predicted about 8.4k
- Plain Gompertz derivative fit predicted about 9.5k
Actual peak at around 8.7k!!
#covid #covid19 #corona #coronavirus
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
*Terrific
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
In USA, age-adjusted excess death since 2020_15 (13-Apr-2020) shows under-65 year olds suffered 325,000 extra deaths (27% increase over baseline for 86 weeks).
Not seen in Europe, this high mortality weekly correlates to COVID-19 outbreaks.
It started with social disruption
John Ruddick MLC - Libertarian
@JohnRuddick2
Tucker reporting a very recent 40% hike in overall deaths of Americans aged 18-64. A 10% jump from the norm is alarming. 40% unheard of.
Data provided by those who wont fudge data: life insurance companies that must pay out endless claims.
#tucker
@charliekirk11This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Martin Smart
@SpudzBoy
Thank God that we have likes of Panda, Heneghan, Levitt, Bhattacharya, Kulldorf, Gupta, Bhakdi, Fenton, Cummins et al. to challenge the narrative!
-
Michael Levitt reposted
NPR
@NPR
New Jersey and Delaware will both lift their statewide mask mandates for schools as the omicron surge wanes.
www.npr.org/2022/02/07/1078886017/new-jersey-and-delaware… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Krishnan Chittur
@cheprofessor
babylonbee.com/news/here-are-10-famous-songs-spotify-is-r… I predict that this satire will soon become reality - e.g. "When A Man Loves A Woman" by Michael Bolton This song implies there are only two genders. Not good. The year is 2022, Michael Bolton" (and more to be cancelled)
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Reminded to look at Iceland by @Marco_Piani
Not sure what was meant? x.com/marco_piani/status/1490878413770739717
Anyway latest all-cause age-adjusted excess death plots shows Iceland still has no excess death due to 2 year of COVID-19.
Also see healthy death deficit in Norway, Denmark & Sweden.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All-cause death in Iceland still shows no excess. Do you think that there will eventually be noticeable excess deaths from this latest wave of cases?
Do you think that Sweden will also be hit with a Delta wave? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Twitter translate did not help me but here is latest Gompertz estimator for France.
Open spreadsheet here: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wXmsntfo-OrCkBY1IeE3zDjEj…
Ramza Behoulve 🇨🇭
@RamzaBehoulve
Bien qu'une reprise soit possible, il faut aussi savoir accepter une baisse.
Ainsi, en utilisant vos tableaux et la Gompertz améliorée de @MLevitt_NP2013, on pouvait estimer un pic à la semaine passée. Même s'il est fort probable que ça reste assez élevé cette semaine encore. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Cannot get used to fact that Twitter is a week ahead of the New York Times @nytimes
www.nytimes.com/live/2022/02/05/world/covid-test-vaccine-…
We saw the same delay with Omicron severity & US Daily Cases peaking
Over-sight or political bias to justify pandemic-induced measures, either way it is disturbing.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Heroes of Western Freedom & Hope”
Why Truckers & not teachers, scientists, doctors, pharma, media?
*Tough work
*Needed
*Not PC
Why Canada?
Under-65 (cyan) suffering big flat increase in all-cause deaths 2020 wk13 to data end -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Danish COVID-19 data follows Gompertz self-limited growth shown in docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XJNtzv5A0HDKFnOxdjKyqER4X…
with 2 outbreaks peaking on 6-Jan & 30-Jan.
Could be future outbreaks. I predict they will be self-limiting without any restrictions. Good test.
Thank you Denmark 🇩🇰 putting people first! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Spoke out against lockdown early & often (Google ‘levitt lockdown’) receiving mass abuse.
Will we know who was right?
Do abusers care about the lives they damaged?
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/02/05/lonely-opposing-first…
Worse is the damage done to free-speech in science.
Is it the end of a golden period? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Important to follow future all-cause death for deaths due to society disruption.
In well-managed countries (500 million people in mortality.org Western Europe, UK), death now normal
In the other half (USA, Eastern Europe, South America), death still high under 65 yrs
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
www.theguardian.com/society/2021/jun/18/hospitals-underto… reports that a lot of medical treatment did not happen in UK.
If we extrapolate to US population, almost 8 million missed operations? Seems too high? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
growth rate declines even as cases increase. Top shows case growth rate for the current outbreak, the rate is declining (solid blue); red& green are cases, dotted lines are future projections. The bottom 2 are daily cases: Left is the whole pandemic, Right is the current outbreak
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is Denmark 🇩🇰
Image on 2-Feb: peak of 45,000 daily cases around now.
Open source spreadsheet so you can update, vary parameters and use for any other country:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XJNtzv5A0HDKFnOxdjKyqER4X…
MrGhostfinger
@MrGhostfinger
Can you make a Chart For DK?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Clarification by healthy I mean less likely to die soon. All is of course age banded so the higher mortality of the elderly is not a confounding factor.
Liberty Rejects Covidian Rituals & Transcultists
@LibertyNow11
I can’t answer the question without understanding the meaning of healthy in the responses. I suspect it doesn’t mean independently healthy people who opt out of sick care.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Before vaccination, are those vaccinated against COVID-19 more or less healthy than those who remain unvaccinated?
Need this data as no recent Random Controlled Trials (RCT) of vaccines against Omicron. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Can you please share link? Been studying Vax/unVax in Israel & UK. Good to check NYC too.
Need fraction of all-cause dead that are Vax. Then compare that with fraction of Vax in population.
Data must be age-banded. Any ideas for good data sources?
Hold2
@Hold2LLC
NYC Vax. vs. Unvax Update: 2/2/22
While waiting for tomorrow's data refresh, I'm looking at different angles for determining reasonableness vs. absurdity.
These charts focus on the % of the Unvax population that got infected each week.
Jan-Nov '21: Unvax never reached 0.5%
/1 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Please explain to me & others why herd immunity to COVID-19 leads to flu returning
A year I am still puzzled why flu disappeared so suddenly after 15-Apr-2020.
Do you think it disappeared due to social intentions that have now been relaxed?
PLC
@Humble_Analysis
Sweden, which had achieved herd immunity (evidenced by flu's return) is also now seeing historic covid infections with omicron.
Does this imply that high rates of vaccination negate high rates of infection in a population faced with omicron? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This ignores the increase in the number of older people over those five years.
Proper calculation averages mortality & then adjusts for population. It shows no increase over expected.
By now all should know more old people results in more death.
Why still play these games?
Chris Edwards🐭
@ChrisEd16512812
1/CEBM Carl Heneghan
"The number of deaths registered in England and Wales in week 48 was 12,050 deaths (week ending 3 Dec); 12.6% above the five-year average (1,302 more deaths).
Compared with 2020 there were 797 fewer deaths in week 48 (11,659 vs 12,456). -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Was inadvertently locked. Should be lien now. Sorry…
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16t4rfS5-7NAPPBZtP5dscXeGQ…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
2/2
Google Sheet you can update yourself is at docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16t4rfS5-7NAPPBZtP5dscXeGQ… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
1/2 Google Sheet of @MLevitt_NP2013 & @USMortality Gompertz predictions for outbreak starting 22 Dec 2021, loaded with #london #covid19 new case data from 31 Jan 2022; by publish date (bottom), date of specimen (top left), date of specimen PCR only. All show peak week of 22 Jan
-
Michael Levitt reposted
kmixer
@kmixer3
"Kto zaś nie ma, temu zabiorą nawet to, co ma."
Ranking śmiertelności skorygowanej wiekiem, obejmujący 3 sezony infekcyjne.
PL w czołówce, ale nie aż tak wyraźnie jak w rankingu prof. @MLevitt_NP2013 .
Orwell2024
@orwell2022
1/ Mortality ranking update.
Find here a graph that includes more countries.
This time using mortality.org raw data to calculate the Age Standardised Mortality Rate (ASMR).
2019 means 1st Aug 2019 - 31st July 2020.
2020 means 1st Aug 2020 - 31st July 2021. -
Michael Levitt reposted
UnHerd
@unherd
Why did the Danish govt lift all Covid restrictions despite rising case numbers?
State modeller Dr Camilla Holten-Møller explains that Omicron was less severe than other variants, which meant fewer hospitalisations and deaths 👇
unherd.com/thepost/denmarks-state-modeller-why-weve-ended… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
1/2
Germany following Gompertz linear dropping ln(Exponential Growth Rate), J(t)
Noisy but 2 different days fitted (L5) to blue line give similar predictions for peak daily cases.
Days_fit Peak Date
5 178K 11-Feb
28 161K 12-Feb
All Omicron is Gompertz
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
2/2
Google Sheet you can update yourself is at docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16t4rfS5-7NAPPBZtP5dscXeGQ… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Heroes of Western Freedom & Hope”
Why Truckers & not teachers, scientists, doctors, pharma, media?
*Tough work
*Needed
*Not PC
Why Canada?
Under-65 (cyan) suffering big flat increase in all-cause deaths 2020 wk13 to data end -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Heroes of Western Freedom & Hope”
Why Truckers & not teachers, scientists, doctors, pharma, media?
*Tough work
*Needed
*Not PC
Why Canada?
Under-65 (cyan) suffering big flat increase in all-cause deaths 2020 wk13 to data end
James Melville 🚜
@JamesMelville
“Small fringe minority”
~ Justin Trudeau
Thousands of people protest against vaccine passports and mandates every week. But the media won’t tell you. Here is a reminder.
#justintrudeau
#truckersforfreedom2022
#novaccinepassportsanywhere -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
David L Goldstein “States of Matter”
Friend of Feynman.
Google aided by text extracted from blurry image by iPhone Photos OCR
In Twitter by Amit Paranjape @aparanjape x.com/aparanjape/status/1227142376835039233
@elonmusk Tweet from x.com/ProfJeffBrock/status/1367801681233199105
Giving due credit encourages new ideas.
_
@RiderMaelstrom
I know I have that text. I thought it was McQuarrie for a second but now not so sure.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Linked Tweet gone: see
#truckersforfreedom2022
“Heroes of Western Freedom & Hope”
Why Truckers & not teachers, scientists, doctors, pharma, media?
*Tough work
*Needed
*Not PC
Why Canada?
Under-65 (cyan) suffering big flat increase in all-cause deaths 2020 wk13 to data end
Gabriel Brunner
@GBGabBrunner
What a photo.
Is this how it ends?? #canadatruckers -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very good.
Both funny and scary at least for a scientist
Then there is
S=k log W carved on Boltzmann’s tombstone. This equation relates S, entropy (disorder) to W, multiplicity (degeneracy). -
Michael Levitt reposted
Dr Anthony Hinton
@TonyHinton2016
U-turn on mandatory Covid vaccinations for NHS and social care workers. Hold the line, have we won? @Togetherdec @nhs100k #novaccinemandates www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2022/01/30/front-line-health…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks.
Does 2021 seem a lot worse than 2020?
In 2020 there was a significant all-cause age-adjusted death deficit like that seen in South Korea for both years.
If you check mortality.org they may give their source with age-bands.
Heather
@HRenkel
You can see here there is a fairly large increase in crude death rate in the year 2021
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Friends. Can any one send me a link to all-cause death data for Taiwan in 2021.
Up till 2020, mortality.org released Taiwan data.
It shows a large death-deficit of 10,000 people who were expected to die but did not (likely due to absence of flu & COVID-19). -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You raise an interesting point
As one gets older, daily risk of death increases. It is sensible to take more chances later in life.
Loss of 2 years of normal life to COVID restrictions costs the elderly a high percent of the life they have left.
Was it worth all the hardship?
ORDraper
@DraperOr
The better point is that these statistics are not informative when it comes to individual risk. My risk unvaccinated would be near-zero. It might be slightly closer to zero if vaccinated, but so what? Risk is irrelevantly tiny in either case.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
A long pair of thread that I found worth reading. This error is made all the time, perhaps initially started to market something a small amount better.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Just saw this: it frightens me terribly.
Article is from professionals & very clear in its peer-reviewed conclusion. Published on 19-Jan-2019 a year before COVID-19, it shows vaccine stops flu but does not not delay death.
Should it have influenced our approach to COVID-19?
Andrew Bostom, MD, MS
@andrewbostom
1/Sobering reminder for C19 vaxes from long-term flu vax RCT follow-up: Despite short-term (≤5mos) 58%↓ in infections, long-term follow-up (up to 25yrs) demonstrated ZERO ↓ in all-cause mortality, flu/pneumonia, circulatory, or pulmonary deaths, or any ↓ in high-risk subgrps
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Andrew Bostom, MD, MS
@andrewbostom
1/Sobering reminder for C19 vaxes from long-term flu vax RCT follow-up: Despite short-term (≤5mos) 58%↓ in infections, long-term follow-up (up to 25yrs) demonstrated ZERO ↓ in all-cause mortality, flu/pneumonia, circulatory, or pulmonary deaths, or any ↓ in high-risk subgrps
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I might be misunderstanding this science. Please help clarify
Your 12-Jan TV plot www.mako.co.il/news-lifestyle/2022_q1/Article-d5c013a7310…
& 13-Jan Twitter plot x.com/segal_eran/status/1481717294128578564
use "מאומתים" (Hebrew for "confirmed cases").
Do you now argue that your use of "מאומתים" in the 2 plots was wrong?
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
Michael, even if you write it again and again, my projection was 300K ***infections*** at the peak, not ***confirmed cases***
You of course know that but still write otherwise
We had ~84K daily cases this week: With 3-4 times more infections than cases, it's ~300K infections -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Will still need to wait 5 weeks for January 2022 all cause death.
Our updated analysis shows that there was very little total excess death in Israel last winter (week 01 to 19).
You write ICU/Deaths lower this year so suspected “4 million” infections could have tiny IFR
Ran Israeli
@RanIsraeli
The daily amount of cases is indeed high - only partially because we're doing a huge amount of tests.
20-25% of the tests are positive 😏
Yet, ICU/deaths data is lower than last year, and many of the people are hospitalized due to other reasons.
Lets wait for all cause mortality. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alasdair Munro
@apsmunro
Absolutely HUGE study on persistent symptoms after #covid19 ("long covid") in 37,000 children from Denmark 🇩🇰
Incidence 0.8% compared to controls
Most symptoms resolved in <5 months (often loss of smell/taste)
Reassuring news from biggest study yet✅
link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs00431-021-04345-z -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ethical Skeptic ☀
@EthicalSkeptic
The flu did not recognize Wuhan, but it recognized Omicron. 🤔
PLC
@Humble_Analysis
Could it be a coincidence that the flu had returned to Southern Asia by mid-2021 (after >80% of the population had been infected with covid)?
Does omicron represent what we can expect from covid once it has become locally endemic and, thus, no longer able to outcompete the flu? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Josh Kraushaar
@JoshKraushaar
On Monday, the Washington Post published an op-ed from three medical experts calling to end mask mandates in schools. The Atlantic joined in on Tuesday.
Today, it's NPR's turn and @michelleinbklyn in the New York Times.
The dam is breaking.
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/28/opinion/masks-covid-children.html -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are correct.
I did Israel almost a year ago (Feb 9, 2021 using different reference years
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1359209033412972552
Including 2015 & 2016 made excess death much lower. My age-adjusted analysis was criticized by those trying to maximize COVID-19 impact so I settled on 2017-2019.
Heather
@HRenkel
If you remember from last year, if you use your own method of age banding & include 2015, excess is much lower. Off the top of my head I think including 2015 resulted in excess that was 20% of the result using just 17-19. If thats true, real excess in Israel could be under ~600
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting. Our age-adjusted plots show that in Israel there was never any excess death for under-65 year olds.
Over-65 year olds had 2,900 excess deaths during two periods: weeks 27 (5-Jul.) to 45 (10-Nov.) in 2020 & 2021.
In 2020 none are vaccinated, in 2021 over 90% are. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
As Friedman argues, some leaders facing a threat build resilience. Others resist the treat being seen as strong & popular.
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/25/opinion/president-biden-russia…
To me, faced with treat of COVID-19, most world politicians chose to show strong resistance instead of building national resilience -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So peak is on 25-Jan-2022 with 75,000 daily cases?
22-Jan forecast of 67K on 25-Jan close. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1484940668829114372
Earlier forecasts too low.
16-Jan x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1482851803343605763
Still nothing as frightening as @segal_eran radical forecast of a peak of 300,000 daily cases.
מואיז הקטן ®
@LittleMoiz
הופה הופה.
תראו את זה...
עכשיו זה גם רשמי (נכון לשעתו כמובן) -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Re Hope-Simpson : it's simply amazing to see how the UK case curve follows H-S starting from August 2021. Stunning! Who needs SAGE & ICL with their voodoo forecasts?
Endemic virus👇 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alex Zhavoronkov, PhD (aka Aleksandrs Zavoronkovs)
@biogerontology
We just did something fun. Discovered a target without a structure, used AlphaFold-predicted structure for SBDD, got a weak hit in about 30 days. @A_Aspuru_Guzik @MLevitt_NP2013 #alphafold
Check out and critique the pre-print as we wait for better hits arxiv.org/abs/2201.09647 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting. Where is the data from?
What is your conclusion? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Israel update.
@segal_eran wrong both in confirmed daily cases & peaking date.
Israel MOH mobile.twitter.com/messages/1428034056638316557/media/148…
shows steady slowdown in daily cases.
OWI/JHU (different) show Israel winning the Omicron cases/day per million championship.
Meanwhile, still no excess death.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Israel is still following the Blue Gompertz descent as it approaches a peak.
Please note that daily cases in JHU or OWID are very different from official data at datadashboard.health.gov.il/COVID-19/general
At the official site, cases are often updated for previous dates. Data can be downloaded. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ridhwaan Suliman
@rid1tweets
While Gauteng's #covid19 cases trajectory has been dramatic, the most encouraging picture is this graph comparing deaths over the four waves 📊
Every death is one too many, but thankfully Gauteng's total death toll over #omicron wave much lower (~10%) than previous #delta wave 🙏
Ridhwaan Suliman
@rid1tweets
With the #covid19 case rate down to 5 per 100k and down to 8% of recent peak, and test positivity on the decline, GAUTENG has technically exited it's #omicron wave 👏
Almost 240k confirmed cases, myself included, over ~76 days 🤒
I hope to never have to share this graph again! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Try advanced Twitter search as shown:
x.com/segal_eran/status/1481717294128578564
Also referenced by:
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1483530167150645248
Craig Hartsough
@CraigHartsough
Do we know where the plot line for Eran Segal (blue line) comes from? I don't see it anywhere on his page. I first saw it from Matan Holzer a few days ago. Is this Segal's work or someone's interpretation of what they think he predicted?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
For a year, deliberately trying not to discuss the side-effects of COVID19 vaccines so as to preserve their placebo value.
Now this seems hard to ignore. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium.MAGAZINE-when-i-told…
Still remember everything we do has associated risks
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Have been vaccinated with the Pfizer mRNA (worked on RNA structure in 1969). Also flu and pneumonia. No side effects for me or my mother (age 105).
Enough people have been vaccinated to show the risk is way less than a week of normal death risk for me at 73 (0.06% or 1/1500). -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
…
מחצ - האומץ להילחם על האמת
@PECC_Israel
תחזיות מול מציאות
בכחול, התחזית למספר המאומתים של @segal_eran ממכון וייצמן, ובירוק, זו של פרופ' מייקל לוויט חתן פרס נובל...שניהם אנשי מדע מכובדים
אך עם כל הכבוד המודל של @MLevitt_NP2013 קרוב הרבה יותר למציאות (גרף אדום)
לא הגיע הזמן שהממשלה והתקשורת יקשיבו ל second opinion? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Germany using OWID/JHU docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1b9UDejVw7QljDPZud8oT2ULhh…
data to 24-Jan-22
Daily cases still rising with peak of 115K forecast.
For Israel, national data gave a different forecast than JHU data. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1484940668829114372
Can anyone point out a link to the most reliable data for Germany?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben, this is a terrific test of our different methods. Cool as we learn whatever the outcome. x.com/USMortality/status/1484985155773243399
Your predicted peak level looks like is is more than 3X mine.
Good luck with this.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is Germany with data to 21-Jan. May be past peak at 100,000 cases per day.
MrGhostfinger
@MrGhostfinger
Pleased make the Same For germany
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The innocent surprise at the damage our joint desire to lockdown caused is nauseating. www.theguardian.com/global-development/2022/jan/25/un-dat…
Sweden really set the example for continued schooling. No one listened.
Everyone who did not speak out against extended lockdowns & school closure is complicit. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
From Yoram Las:
“The Central Bureau of Statistics in England now announces: In Corona's two years, only about 6,000 people have died exclusively because of Corona.”
www.ons.gov.uk/aboutus/transparencyandgovernance/freedomo…
yoram lass
@LassYoram
הלשכה המרכזית לסטטיסטיקה באנגליה מודיעה עכשיו: בשנתיים של קורונה, רק כ-6000 בני אדם נפטרו בלעדית בגלל קורונה.
www.ons.gov.uk/aboutus/transparencyandgovernance/freedomo… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. I have started analysis. This data is different from the data on the OWID/JHU dashboard so it will be interesting to compare.
Mazda Sabouri
@msabouri
Here's a picture of where to find the link for the excel data:
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Can you please post a link to the data?
Also is would be interesting to see plot of
ln[ln[X(t)/X(t-1)]]
where X(t) is total deaths to day t to see is it slopes down and with what slope.
Mazda Sabouri
@msabouri
Slowed down obviously.
Here's America's first death curve using time dated CDC deaths. It's the closest America had to an unmitigated surge.
If I were a betting man, I'd bet that the true infection curves for the 2009 Swine flu were similar. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben, this is a terrific test of our different methods. Cool as we learn whatever the outcome. x.com/USMortality/status/1484985155773243399
Your predicted peak level looks like is is more than 3X mine.
Good luck with this.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is Germany with data to 21-Jan. May be past peak at 100,000 cases per day.
MrGhostfinger
@MrGhostfinger
Pleased make the Same For germany
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is Germany with data to 21-Jan. May be past peak at 100,000 cases per day.
MrGhostfinger
@MrGhostfinger
Pleased make the Same For germany
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Just asked. My son Daniel said it was easier now and he was right.
Nice to know I am real
Heather
@HRenkel
OMG! Your profile has the Twitter-approval checkmark! 👏 How did you finally manage that?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Israel is still following the Blue Gompertz descent as it approaches a peak.
Please note that daily cases in JHU or OWID are very different from official data at datadashboard.health.gov.il/COVID-19/general
At the official site, cases are often updated for previous dates. Data can be downloaded. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Someone gets it.
Here is early data (pre-14Mar2020) that made us realize that COVID-19 growth is Gompertz not Logarithmic.
The Exponential Growth Rate (slope of ln[X(t)], X(t) total counts) drops exponentially; it’s log linear in t allowing forecasts.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1477748459742674944
Andrew Koenig
@andrew_koenig
@usmortality @MLevitt_NP2013 Am I right that in a Gompertz curve, the fact that log(rate of growth) is a straight line implies that a simple plot of values vs. time on a log scale will always be convex upward?
Because if so, one can see new outbreaks just by eyeballing raw data. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Thinking Coalition
@ThinkCoalition
It's time to topple the failed lockdown elites www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/01/21/time-topple-failed-lo…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
An impressive letter and impressive list of signatures. www.hartgroup.org/open-letter-to-the-mhra-regarding-child…
All-cause death -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Age-adjusted all-cause excess death in the 4 biggest US States has a different pattern in each.
They all reach very similar levels of COVID-era excess death as a percentage of normal death.
This suggests saturation that can be reached in many different ways. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
mortality.org plots are not age-adjusted. During the two years of COVID-19, really very little age-adjusted (using mortality.org deaths & populations) all-cause excess death there or in Norway, Sweden & Finland.
IDK
@iddkko
Denmark seems to have very high excess deaths. I wonder what the explanation for this is? Is it being discussed in Denmark?
-
Michael Levitt reposted
PLC
@Humble_Analysis
With the advent of mass vaccination in Europe, why have more young adults died during the second half of 2021 than had died in 2020 (or 2017, 2018, 2019)?
Shouldn't the vaccines have caused a return to normal levels of mortality? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I would really welcome a moderated online discussion with Eran @segal_eran
We have been colleagues at Weizman Institute.
We have both published on DNA that must bend to pack compactly in a chromosome.
Matan Holzer
@MatanHolzer
Exec. brief for discussion between @MLevitt_NP2013 & @segal_eran:
* Segal initially predicted about 2-4 million infected (or cases?⬇️) [1]. Very wide CI
* Now uses bottom edge - 2 million [2]
* Exponential model - doubling every 4-5 days, then sudden decrease [3] (mechanism?) -
Michael Levitt reposted
Matan Holzer
@MatanHolzer
Exec. brief for discussion between @MLevitt_NP2013 & @segal_eran:
* Segal initially predicted about 2-4 million infected (or cases?⬇️) [1]. Very wide CI
* Now uses bottom edge - 2 million [2]
* Exponential model - doubling every 4-5 days, then sudden decrease [3] (mechanism?) -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I would really welcome a moderated online discussion with Eran @segal_eran
We have been colleagues at Weizman Institute.
We have both published on DNA that must bend to pack compactly in a chromosome.
Matan Holzer
@MatanHolzer
סיכום מנהלים לדיון בין @MLevitt_NP2013 ו @segal_eran:
* סגל בתחילה דיבר על 2-4 מיליון נדבקים (מאומתים? בתגובות) בגל הזה [1]. רווח סמך רחב מאוד
* לאחר מכן השתמש בקצה התחתון של רוו"ס - 2 מיליון [2]
* מודל אקספוננציאלי - הכפלה כל 4-5 ימים עד השיא, ואז פתאום ירידה [3] (מה המנגנון?) -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You cannot: EuroMOMO is defective in that it only shows past ~5 years
My earliest EuroMOMO tweet 15-Apr-20 shows 2015 x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1250453288602013697
No longer possible!
This & the need to hack to get all data makes them obsolete compared to mortality.org
European tragedy!
DataInforms
@DataInforms
You can build one from Eroumomo quite readily
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Bring polite & cool-headed is essential for productive & constructive discussion.
While clearly intelligent, committed & a prolific contributor, your crude aggression diminishes the impact you deserve.
With tweets like this one, my followers are going to want me to block you.
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
Yes, and how many die from Flu in the UK in an average year.
Marc Girardot does not himself believe the shit he writes to fuel his grift targeting dummies like you. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are misunderstanding the forecasts. That number is the forecast maximum cases per day at the peak not the total cases then.
Forecasting is hard with Gompertz but it is next to impossible with capped exponential or Logistics growth.
Craig Hartsough
@CraigHartsough
On 2 Dec, after correcting your method, you predicted France would peak at 57K cases sometime after the end of Dec.
Dec 4: 68K on 1 Jan.
Dec 19: 52K on 23 Dec.
Jan 14: already peaked at 288K on 10 Jan.
As of today, France over 320K, not yet peaked. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Since I joined Twitter, I have been fearful that presentation of COVID QALY or YLL data would result in immediate banning.
After all, everyone knows that a life is a life. The death of 5 year old is equivalent to the death of a 85 year old.
PS: Skiing in Lech Sind great. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Follow news when with numbers. www.theguardian.com/world/live/2022/jan/20/covid-news-liv…
Looks as if a new UK outbreak like Denmark & Holland.
Our Gompertz prediction eliminates the new outbreak. Averaging over 7-days does the same.
Must wait 3 more days to see if a new outbreak.
Could derail UK opening plans -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I have just learned that PCR testing is used for HIV & plays a critical role in controlling AIDS.
I now qualify what I wrote here to only refer to mass PCR testing of airborne, highly infectious respiratory viruses like influenza & rhino & corona.
Apologies to all.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Daily case numbers give forecasters data to learn from.
The numbers never really had much public health value: testing PCR positive is not the same as showing clinical symptoms.
No other disease has been measured this way, so it led to mass confusion.
Primal COVID-19 error. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Population fatality rate (PFR) using all-cause excess death for the billion people for which all causes death is properly recorded in mortality.org is 0.1% a year.
The IFR must be less than PFR as we cannot infect people more than once (or may be COVID-19 can?).
Marc Girardot
@GirardotMarc
Excellent thread by @abirballan reacting to my latest piece.
@P_McCulloughMD @MLevitt_NP2013 @stkirsch @BretWeinstein @henrioncaude @NickHudsonCT
@RobertKennedyJr @raoult_didier @idrissaberkane
👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
Abir Ballan
@abirballan
Despite the IFR of COVID being similar to that of the flu,
(a fact known to gov), unjustified policies continue.
It is time to "put a nail in the IFR coffin. It is time proportionality is upheld again as a key principle in our public life"@GirardotMarc 1/
covidmythbuster.substack.com/p/absurd-reasoning-to-kill-a… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Abir Ballan
@abirballan
Despite the IFR of COVID being similar to that of the flu,
(a fact known to gov), unjustified policies continue.
It is time to "put a nail in the IFR coffin. It is time proportionality is upheld again as a key principle in our public life"@GirardotMarc 1/
covidmythbuster.substack.com/p/absurd-reasoning-to-kill-a… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, this was after became active on Twitter so it is recorded.
Search Twitter:
Ferguson (from:mlevitt_NP2013)
Here are examples from 19-May & 5-Sep 2020
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1262632277445677058
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1302284008726974464
Howard Steen
@HowardSteen4
Hubris and ambition. @MLevitt_NP2013 tried to get Neil Ferguson to change his doom model as it was already clear by I think May 2020 that it was based on false assumptions. Ferguson would not discuss & the rest is history. Yes, the system must change.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So pleased @PienaarJm & @orwell2022 working together constructively.
Finding a new way to estimate life-expectancy would be a terrific development.
Seems epidemiologists & demographers make simple thing inscrutably complicated, whereas physicists try to simplify complexity. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Lack of correlation may only occur in places with low level reported COVID-19 deaths per million. There labeling could be an issue.
In New York City, hit worst, correlation is very strong.
Interesting if you can find examples of lack of correlation in places with bad COVID-19?
Pablo
@tradingpablo
Dr Levitt, please, have a look at the weird lack of correlation between excess mortality and "Covid deaths". It happens in most countries. Nordic countries as sample:
Might be a labeling deaths problem ?😇😇 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Badly phrased.
I meant to ask if the locations of the 2 outbreaks in Denmark are different like the locations of the two outbreak in Holland were different
x.com/lewinskylou2/status/1482467107212255235
Thanks for helping me clarify this.
x.com/p_van_zandvoort/status/1484106906973188096
Two outbreaks also seen in Germany.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Denmark seem to be like Holland with a new outbreak superimposed on the previous one.
Please help me know if they in different locations?
I attach our Gompertz for both.
1st started 13-Dec & peaked 6-Jan (set end date to 12-Jan).
2nd started 6-Jan & may peak in a week? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Denmark seem to be like Holland with a new outbreak superimposed on the previous one.
Please help me know if they in different locations?
I attach our Gompertz for both.
1st started 13-Dec & peaked 6-Jan (set end date to 12-Jan).
2nd started 6-Jan & may peak in a week? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not what the data I checked shows. See below & ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explorer?zo…
Please share your sources as your claim is unexpected & needs confirmation. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ran Israeli
@RanIsraeli
If Eran's "Doubling every 3 days" model was correct, we should have seen a doubling every 3 days in deaths and severe patients (It's not the reality).
Was it a mistake?
Why did he publish this fear-mongering model?
In any case,
@MLevitt_NP2013 wins👑
Follow his predictions. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ran Israeli
@RanIsraeli
Fact check:
Both on his Tweet from 13/01/2022, and his 12/01/2022 TV article,
Segal specifically mentioned *cases*, not infections.
If his claim was indeed correct, the number of cases from 10/01/2022 should have been 3-4 times *higher* than 35,000.
mako.co.il/news-lifestyle/2022_q1/Article-d5c013a73105e71…
3> -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ran Israeli
@RanIsraeli
Eran Segal's excuse for this mistake:
"Model was made for *infected people*, not cases"
Is he being honest?
FYI: Israel is performing tests in full capacity:
More than 450K RTPCR/RA Tests are being done here every day (In a 9.2 million people country)
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1483598576500592640
2>
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Eran, pleased you responded but your response is disappointing.
Your TV talks & slides use Hebrew word מאומתים “Meumatim” meaning ‘verified’ or ‘confirmed’.
Your Tweet makes it clear your meant confirmed not infected
x.com/segal_eran/status/1481931353377677320
It is OK to be wrong but be honest
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
התחלואה השבוע התנהגה בהתאם לתחזית שהצגנו בשבת אצל @danawt:
חזינו שיהיו השבוע 40-50 אלף מאומתים ליום: היו 40-48 אלף בכל אחד מ-4 הימים האחרונים
חזינו שנגיע ל- 250-350 חולים קשה בביה״ח, הבוקר יש 306
התחזית ניתנת לשבוע קדימה על בסיס נתוני יום שישי (מיום שישי עד שישי הבא) -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ran Israeli
@RanIsraeli
Battle of the distinguished professors:
Michael Levitt vs Eran Segal->
Which one of them had a better forecast for the daily amount of cases here in Israel?
Segal predicted that the peak would be ~300,000 daily cases.
Levitt predicted that the peak would be ~50,000 daily cases
1> -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Since 1Jan22, wanted Prof. Eran Segal @segal_eran to reconsider his official forecast of 300K peak daily cases in Israel.
Our self-limiting Gompertz forecasts consistent
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1482605559513849856
Segal’s reputation will hopefully recover. Economic & social damage will not.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Errors:
1) At 300,000 daily cases for 9 million will have 33,000 cases/mil. 6X more than any other country.
2) Asymmetric as never seen before: slow rise; fast drop
3) Growth is capped exponential. ‘External’ measures forces stop on 22-Jan. Why stop then? Unnatural & contrived! -
Michael Levitt reposted
Marc Girardot
@GirardotMarc
@Gabor and I were right yes, all along. And many others...
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Does this give you comfort?
Scares me to death.
Paul Embery
@PaulEmbery
Just as you cannot now find a political commentator who supported the Iraq war, you will not, in five years’ time, be able to find a single commentator who supported blanket national lockdowns. Just watch.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Eran, pleased you responded but your response is disappointing.
Your TV talks & slides use Hebrew word מאומתים “Meumatim” meaning ‘verified’ or ‘confirmed’.
Your Tweet makes it clear your meant confirmed not infected
x.com/segal_eran/status/1481931353377677320
It is OK to be wrong but be honest
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
התחלואה השבוע התנהגה בהתאם לתחזית שהצגנו בשבת אצל @danawt:
חזינו שיהיו השבוע 40-50 אלף מאומתים ליום: היו 40-48 אלף בכל אחד מ-4 הימים האחרונים
חזינו שנגיע ל- 250-350 חולים קשה בביה״ח, הבוקר יש 306
התחזית ניתנת לשבוע קדימה על בסיס נתוני יום שישי (מיום שישי עד שישי הבא) -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
What exactly do you need? Can age at death be banded?
Let me see what I can find. Ben @USMortality too.
Orwell2024
@orwell2022
I can do for EC data. I am waiting for 2021 to settle.
ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/DEMO_R_MWK_05__cus…
Unfortunately, Germany and Ireland are not in there.
Italy is really far behind in reporting. Week 43!?
For US, I would need to look up a convenient death/pop raw data source for US. @USMortality -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Israel data just updated so used it docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1QKkxCjHoo5Hno43q-8T9VNKAv…
Also data at OWID docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/13872akpdCANmw77HSnoLrJdqS…
We predict peak on 15 to 20 Jan 50,000 cases/day instead of official expert’s @segal_eran forecast of 300,000.
Is this bad science or fear-mongering?
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
הערכה: אתמול נדבקו כ-150 אלף איש וכ-900 אלף במצטבר
50 אלף אומתו, הרבה לא נבדקים, לא בודקים בזמן, ו/או לא בודקים נכון. בלונדון על-פי בדיקות סקר היו פי 3.5 נדבקים ממאומתים
לפי המודל, העקומה תישבר סביב 2 מיליון במצטבר, שזה עוד הכפלה אחת, ולא בטוח שנגיע אליה
כנראה קרובים לשיא >>> -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
We have Florida for you too docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Y8Kocyklw2flaAy0VcfBfDidr…
See more here:
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1480441088712323072
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1480441088712323072
Paul Krugman
@paulkrugman
Oh, and since FL officials have been crowing about NY's high case rate — while discouraging testing to suppress their own numbers — worth noting that even so FL now > NY 2/
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is rather a delayed response to those knowing New York State peaked a week ago. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1480097124054441985
Read you @nytimes .
I thought economists followed the numbers.
All can use our @USMortality @HRenkel open Google Sheet for accurate forecasts. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BC7ZDBb1PNBGvn7I772BGg_7L…
Paul Krugman
@paulkrugman
Cases in NYC down 60% in two weeks. This wave is looking nasty, brutish — but short 1/
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much to you. Actually I am the one who feels honored.
Mónica Lalanda
@mlalanda
Thank so so much, Michael, I feel honored.
Millions of lives have been lost to a virus AND to the poor management of it all. But now we face a different loss,the basic traces of what makes us humane, the essence of Medicine, the strength of Science, the common sense...
Tombs. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Life expectancy troubles me.
We look at that number to see how much time we have left. Wrong as the number we see is life expectancy of those born now
Your average (or median) age of death is much better & easier to get
Can you do EU & USA deaths Over & Under 65 since 2000?
Orwell2024
@orwell2022
That's an incorrect analysis as failing to do the most basic correction for age confounding.
Here:This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Kaz the Honkler
@KazKtheHonkler
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Shoshan Brosh Levitt
@BroshLevitt
Our generation grew up in the shadow of cemeteries - cemetery parks - and illuminated by the light of media that applied the brakes, told the stories and reported conflicts and controversies.
The mass media & the giant journalists have abandoned this mission when so relevant
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This cartoon is all too true.
Most remarkable to me are the two grave stones in the center foreground:
“Common Sense”
“Mutual Respect”
In graveyards, the earliest graves are simplest & most modest.
What other grander tombstones await us? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Should have noticed that this cartoon is by Mónica Lalanda @mlalanda whom I now follow
x.com/mlalanda/status/1481665094954237952
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This cartoon is all too true.
Most remarkable to me are the two grave stones in the center foreground:
“Common Sense”
“Mutual Respect”
In graveyards, the earliest graves are simplest & most modest.
What other grander tombstones await us? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This cartoon is all too true.
Most remarkable to me are the two grave stones in the center foreground:
“Common Sense”
“Mutual Respect”
In graveyards, the earliest graves are simplest & most modest.
What other grander tombstones await us? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Original paper from 1825
www.med.mcgill.ca/epidemiology/hanley/c609/material/Gompe…
Looked through it. Lots of tables but not a single figure or graph. Cannot find something even vaguely looking like his equation as we know it today Nexp[-exp[-(t-T)/U]].
Science was so much harder two hundred years ago.
TT
@thtaylor47
Dr. Gompertz would be appalled.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Terrific analysis. Every figure is a classic!
The really high mortality for the young in the USA is very worrying to me. A country's future is its young people not the over-65 year old baby-boomers.
We all need to look after the young!
Orwell2024
@orwell2022
Now, the problem is this here:
US problem is a bit bigger than Covid. You are being distracted from this bipartisan failure. Your eyes focused on a tiny little issue. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
USA is certainly still past its daily case maximum. One of the cleanest, well-behaved Gompertz curves seen for Omicron.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1482655718163591173
Bandit One
@uno_bandit
They know the truth. But they have an agenda. We do often ascribe ignorance when it is far more likely to be intentional. Assuming ignorance is not scientific until bias can be at least identified or dismissed if not at issue. But, even a broken clock is right twice a day. 1+1=2.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Link to the data you mention, please.
My sources (OWID or JHU) have 36,231 exactly as expected.
Craig Hartsough
@CraigHartsough
Netherlands reported 42,352 cases today. Your forecast is wrong.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why is daily case data for Israel at
covid.eran.dev?sheet=infectedPerDate
(infectedPerDate.csv DOWNLOAD TABLE blue button) different from data at OWID or JHU.
The data at covid.eran.dev is smoother than OWID & JHU may be peaked.
Very different Gompertz forecasts. U odd, see Alt -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Clean data key.
Sweden is following Gompertz with ever-falling Exponential Growth Rate.
Such behavior is universal yet not accepted
Huge errors in forecasting made by government advisers in UK, Israel, Holland all assuming exponential growth
When will they ever learn? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I looked at a few places in Japan. Firstly, the number of daily cases per million is tiny. Secondly Gompertz also holds in Japan but the U time-constant values are Smaller than in Europe or the USA.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That is terrific idea. I will open these is Google Sheets.
Japan is very important
BBT_Success
@BBT_Success
@MLevitt_NP2013 @USMortality
I tried to create Gompertz sheet for each city in Japan.
My sincere respect and gratitude.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1f8_yxNbnZ9yXWzQLOuGuAKiv5…
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VHTOVty04IofGQeLM1MWgHZkc… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
That is terrific idea. I will open these is Google Sheets.
Japan is very important
BBT_Success
@BBT_Success
@MLevitt_NP2013 @USMortality
I tried to create Gompertz sheet for each city in Japan.
My sincere respect and gratitude.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1f8_yxNbnZ9yXWzQLOuGuAKiv5…
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VHTOVty04IofGQeLM1MWgHZkc… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 & the global response to it may have created an opportunity for "Global Open Real-Time Science" or GORTS (not yet in Google)
#gorts is science open to all.
It is inclusive & judges by results not credentials.
As for priority, how about NFT?
Can we do it together?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Must be studied by all concerned with COVID-19. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VR3yFG7l1Mhtr9e5Wjc_dipy9…
The latest wave in the USA shows how J(t), the log exponential growth factor drops linearly since early July.
It proves yet again what I say since Apr-2020: COVID-19 spread is SELF-LIMITED & Gompertz. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Just so Europe does not feel left out, here are some of the larger countries.
All use the same 5.5W sheet
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LSNHumgJhIAqlLGLf1u0-XKpk…
Spain 133,000 cases/day at peak on 12-Jan.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1B4Gu03wYt1_tQe8Tkn0C6fqp4…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
USA Omicron has peaked. Daily new cases on the decline.
Open Sheet:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LSNHumgJhIAqlLGLf1u0-XKpk…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
One more. Ireland with most daily cases/million.
Looks like the others with 20,000 daily cases at peak on 8-Jan.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1i6px9pXmuCGEAO-Ikj60k3tz6…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
For any other World location, use this sheet and change Country name. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LSNHumgJhIAqlLGLf1u0-XKpk…
Very easy & empowering to know more about your own country in real-time than all the experts.
Power of Global Open Science (#gos), the answer to forced closing of world science. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Forgot to post forecast of new outbreak in The Netherlands starting 24-Dec.
Gompertz too and a clear demonstration of multiple outbreaks that overlap and must be disentangled. Thanks so much for information
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Y_fovPxpd2VXEY8xdRNwOK91r…
Lou Lewinsky 2
@lewinskylou2
The new outbreak in the Netherlands is in Amsterdam (province of Noord-Holland) and it's omicron.
The previous outbreak was in the provinces Zeeland, Flevoland and Limburg and that was delta.
@MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
USA Omicron has peaked. Daily new cases on the decline.
Open Sheet:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LSNHumgJhIAqlLGLf1u0-XKpk…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Texas 67K cases/day at peak on 14-Jan.
Least certain as Exponential Growth Rate blue line so odd.
Used observation that U time-constant is 10 to 13 days for most Omicron outbreaks, set Fit Days to 12 days to get U=13 days
Sheet by @USMortality crucial for online science!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Texas Google Sheet at
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DRAH41vcnP4uJ8ZDuFUlDhJy5…
All these open 5.53U Sheets easily customize for any state using @HRenkel instructions at
www.dropbox.com/s/1k8u1fe2l46goot/Levitt_USMortality_Gomp… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Happy with New York forecast of 79K on 10-Jan.
Shows Exponential Growth Rate dropping as a straight line on a log scale since 2-Jan.
Updated data 15-Jan shows peak occurred on 8-Jan with daily cases (7-day average) at 74K. Peaks broad & noisy so detection +/- 2 days.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks!
Is code released like we do?
Here is open Google Sheet method anyone can run on any state docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XLM6tzk4GznYn5beYkiAYN-6G…
Current wave in New York State is forecast to peak on 10-Jan-2022 with 80,000 cases (7-day smoothed)
For countries use World sheet
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here are latest COVID-19 Forecast Open Google Sheets for USA & World. A few small bugs corrected; these are the versions to use yourselves.
World (including USA)
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm1igwSY0BfssTu4d8d1FAWM2…
US States:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XLM6tzk4GznYn5beYkiAYN-6G… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Errors:
1) At 300,000 daily cases for 9 million will have 33,000 cases/mil. 6X more than any other country.
2) Asymmetric as never seen before: slow rise; fast drop
3) Growth is capped exponential. ‘External’ measures forces stop on 22-Jan. Why stop then? Unnatural & contrived! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Interesting 2 outbreaks in different regions. Have looked for an example of this. Thanks
Omicron wave starts on 24-Dec-21 & will end in a couple of days with 32,000 daily cases.
Like the previous outbreak, it follows Gompertz self-limited growth.
See:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Y_fovPxpd2VXEY8xdRNwOK91r…
Lou Lewinsky 2
@lewinskylou2
The new outbreak in the Netherlands is in Amsterdam (province of Noord-Holland) and it's omicron.
The previous outbreak was in the provinces Zeeland, Flevoland and Limburg and that was delta.
@MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
What a long wait it has been for people to come to their senses.
Sarah Champion
@ronandsarah
It appears confidence is high…
www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-59970281 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Daily case numbers give forecasters data to learn from.
The numbers never really had much public health value: testing PCR positive is not the same as showing clinical symptoms.
No other disease has been measured this way, so it led to mass confusion.
Primal COVID-19 error. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
In spite the general lack of interest in correct forecasts, it is important to verify methods for the next pandemic.
The USA is at the peak with 835K Cases/day. The total cases to the end 31-Jan-22 is forecast at 16 million, 4 million less than NYT forecast of @ShamanJeffrey
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Important to make testable predictions. x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1480129960073482245
Here is USA we predicted yesterday superimposed on @nytimes prediction of expert Prof. Shaman @ShamanJeffrey. He never mentions Gompertz
Now we follow along using Sheet that shows totals:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bpZ0UDUDclA8iwZYtF_5I1FUe…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Peak cases/day & date depend on straight line fit to blue J(t) line.
Used Fit_D=28 days; 14 days better fit to recent J(t) values.
Changing Fit_D changes forecast:
Peak Date Fit_D Tot_by_1/31
700K 8Jan22 28 15m
920K 17Jan22 14 23m
Try it:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm1igwSY0BfssTu4d8d1FAWM2…
:)
@iKick247
US predicted peak 1/8? That was quick
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is link to Open Google Sheet to allow transparent verification.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wVhNxB4EhJUtQ1JMEXpc8GkbV…
This is how science should be done on Twitter. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Belgiums latest Omicron wave behaving as expected.
Peaking soon with 26K daily cases. U time-constant is expect 12 days sen elsewhere. We smooth centrally so latest date plotted is alway three days earlier than latest data date.
Follow yourself:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10eGmVTYw_SnkI1C65S4N3TF5_…
Innocente Gino
@Gino_Innocente
Thanks for the charts !! Any possibility to chart Belgium as well ? ☺️
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Portugal peaked 12-Jan-22.
Peak imprecise (+/- 1 or 2 days). Straight-line descent of J(t)=log(Expon. Growth Rate) of Gompertz self-limiting growth seen for past three weeks.
Peak is ~35,000 daily cases & U rate-constant is 14 days.
Follow yourself:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BRJNrdceJB-ErXHcHjPxNZXiX… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Poor journalism. Yes.
Much worse is the shutting of minds followed by gagging the mouths of the few who tried to sound the alarm in March 2020. medium.com/@michael.levitt/the-excess-burden-of-death-fro…
Edward Kozaczek
@EddieKozaczek
In time, this will become a domino effect across the world ..... poor poor poor journalism !!!!
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Carl Heneghan
@carlheneghan
'We failed': Denmark's media is waking up to its flawed Covid coverage www.spectator.co.uk/article/-we-failed-denmark-s-media-is… Quite a few UK media outlets - not all - may want to take note
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Israel looks similar to other countries with comparable strong COVID-19 Omicron outbreaks.
Meanwhile, France is close to peaking as forecast by Gompertz self-limited slowdown of Expon. Growth Rate J(t)
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wXmsntfo-OrCkBY1IeE3zDjEj…
First South Africa, then UK now everywhere
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Gompertz J(t) forecast is very different from @segal_eran
He uses exponential growth made to stop 23-Jan-22.
We just follow data from OWID/JHU data &
repeat with covid.eran.dev?sheet=infectedPerDate
Similar result: peaks 23-Jan with 45 - 55K daily cases.
A million cases 21-Dec to 31-Jan
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Finding the errors in predictions serves as a test of what we have learned about COVID-19.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1481842346727817224
Discussion is even more important.
Will post my analysis after giving you all a chance to think fur yourselves.
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
הערכה: אתמול נדבקו כ-150 אלף איש וכ-900 אלף במצטבר
50 אלף אומתו, הרבה לא נבדקים, לא בודקים בזמן, ו/או לא בודקים נכון. בלונדון על-פי בדיקות סקר היו פי 3.5 נדבקים ממאומתים
לפי המודל, העקומה תישבר סביב 2 מיליון במצטבר, שזה עוד הכפלה אחת, ולא בטוח שנגיע אליה
כנראה קרובים לשיא >>> -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Should have added this yesterday.
Real-time science is a brutal contact-sport. It really accelerates discovery. I hope it becomes mainstream in a decade. Always nice to be ahead of the curve.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Finding the errors in predictions serves as a test of what we have learned about COVID-19.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1481842346727817224
Discussion is even more important.
Will post my analysis after giving you all a chance to think fur yourselves.
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
הערכה: אתמול נדבקו כ-150 אלף איש וכ-900 אלף במצטבר
50 אלף אומתו, הרבה לא נבדקים, לא בודקים בזמן, ו/או לא בודקים נכון. בלונדון על-פי בדיקות סקר היו פי 3.5 נדבקים ממאומתים
לפי המודל, העקומה תישבר סביב 2 מיליון במצטבר, שזה עוד הכפלה אחת, ולא בטוח שנגיע אליה
כנראה קרובים לשיא >>> -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Gompertz J(t) forecast is very different from @segal_eran
He uses exponential growth made to stop 23-Jan-22.
We just follow data from OWID/JHU data &
repeat with covid.eran.dev?sheet=infectedPerDate
Similar result: peaks 23-Jan with 45 - 55K daily cases.
A million cases 21-Dec to 31-Jan
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Finding the errors in predictions serves as a test of what we have learned about COVID-19.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1481842346727817224
Discussion is even more important.
Will post my analysis after giving you all a chance to think fur yourselves.
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
הערכה: אתמול נדבקו כ-150 אלף איש וכ-900 אלף במצטבר
50 אלף אומתו, הרבה לא נבדקים, לא בודקים בזמן, ו/או לא בודקים נכון. בלונדון על-פי בדיקות סקר היו פי 3.5 נדבקים ממאומתים
לפי המודל, העקומה תישבר סביב 2 מיליון במצטבר, שזה עוד הכפלה אחת, ולא בטוח שנגיע אליה
כנראה קרובים לשיא >>> -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Finding the errors in predictions serves as a test of what we have learned about COVID-19.
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1481842346727817224
Discussion is even more important.
Will post my analysis after giving you all a chance to think fur yourselves.
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
הערכה: אתמול נדבקו כ-150 אלף איש וכ-900 אלף במצטבר
50 אלף אומתו, הרבה לא נבדקים, לא בודקים בזמן, ו/או לא בודקים נכון. בלונדון על-פי בדיקות סקר היו פי 3.5 נדבקים ממאומתים
לפי המודל, העקומה תישבר סביב 2 מיליון במצטבר, שזה עוד הכפלה אחת, ולא בטוח שנגיע אליה
כנראה קרובים לשיא >>> -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Cases here are officials reported confirmed COVID-19 cases per day, the popular metric that has been used everywhere to date.
RJPhoenix #No2Sanctions #HoldtheLine 🔻🔻🔻🔻
@RJ_Phoenix16
Definition of 'cases' would help.
PCR test fraud plays a part. (Number of cycles?)
CONTEXT: Total number of tests. Relevance to hospitalisation/deaths?
Early treatment protocols?
Playbook: 'How to scare with statistics' -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are correct. That was a very bad typo. Apologies.
Would delete and correct but never delete a Tweet or block anyone. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This forecast is wrong in so many ways.
Finding the errors serves as a test of what we have learned about COVID-19.
Plot showed to millions on TV.
In it:
1) 300,000 daily cases in Israel on 23-Jan-22
2) Dropping to below 10,000 by 31-Jan-22
Will provide answers in 24 hours -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Do you agree there has been no excess all-cause death in England & Wales since 5 Feb. 2022? x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1473746057431597059
This happened at time when there were 10 million reported cases & 35K reported deaths.
How do you explain discrepancy?
Was the IFR 0.0% or 0.35% or in between?
Prof Jeffrey S Morris
@jsm2334
And UK all cause death data show the rate of all cause deaths within 21 days of either dose are vanishingly small
So the hystronic claims about 9/11 x 50 or whatever are completely implausible -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Quick observation. Modeled curves all symmetrical. This means Logistics growth & involves pure exponential growth until near the peak in daily cases. Such models do not work but all the experts love them.
In reality growth is seld-limited Gompetz, rising faster than falling.
Maarten van den Berg
@mr_Smith_Econ
12-01-2022.
Update echte data (geel) over het lockdoommodel.
Afwijking tov modelgemiddelde (paars)
Op basis van dit model zit Nederland in lockdown.
#allesopen #omt -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very well-written as always. Sadly cannot disagree with your conclusion.
The biggest danger I see is self-imposed restrictions that will bring society to a stop. We have been well-conditioned after two years of training.
Also dangerous is debasement of discussion in science.
Gummi
@gummibear737
The Covid Doctrine - How policy for Covid-19 is shaping up for 2022
My latest analysis of the Covid-19 Pandemic
Where we are and where we're going
Please share if you enjoy or learned something interesting
gummibear737.substack.com/p/the-covid-doctrine?justPublis… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not so much stifling but refusal to engage in debate.
Did the pro-panic, lockdowners know from the start that their view was indefensible: being silent would serve them best?
Others saw an urgent & difficult scientific problem solved by open talk.
Response: send in the trolls
Bandwagon Coffee 🐭
@BandwagonCoffee
The stifling of scientific debate and the discrediting of some of the world’s most eminent scientists has caused immeasurable harm.
@SunetraGupta
@MartinKulldorff
@DrJBhattacharya
@carlheneghan
@MLevitt_NP2013 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
There was practically no 1st wave in all of Eastern Europe & even in Germany. It has nothing to do with LD policy. It's due to ecosystemic reasons. The epidemic failed to pick up steam there as it started too late in the season & was suppressed by seasonal stimulus.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Gompertz straight-line J(t) forecasts converge. Daily cases peak 12/25 at ~25,000 Omicron daily cases.
Christmas gift to world:
1) Shows 'expo-talk' like "doubles in 3 days" meaningless. Gompertz always slows.
2) Shows low 'O' lethality, CFR=0.26%.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Africa has daily Omicron cases with least daily deaths since May 2020. Need a week to get deaths/case.
The latest outbreak of Omicron daily cases starts near zero. It is beautifully Gompertz with J(t) becoming a dropping straight-line blue line).
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Africa has daily Omicron cases with least daily deaths since May 2020. Need a week to get deaths/case.
The latest outbreak of Omicron daily cases starts near zero. It is beautifully Gompertz with J(t) becoming a dropping straight-line blue line).
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Expected from South Africa; still important news.
Current COVID-19 wave in USA has same self-limited Gompertz growth seen in SA & UK.
Exponent Growth Rate has been dropping exponentially with U=14 days.
Forecast peak in daily cases 13 to 16 Jan 2022
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iWY5NCUdeik85g73MWyhlzs-v…
CDC Director
@CDCDirector
While less severe, #omicron is much more transmissible & we are seeing the unprecedented impact.
Over 1M cases in a day, 99% of counties with high transmission & strained healthcare systems.
Protect against #covid19: get vaccinated + boosted, wear a mask & stay home if sick. -
Michael Levitt reposted
US Mortality
@USMortality
> Current CFR: 865,357/63,851,821 = 1.36%
> 91% less risk with Omicron: 1.36% * 9% = 0.12%
> Without any co-morbidities: 0.12% * 5% = 0.006%
So for someone that has no co-morbidities has a risk of 0.006% of dying from Omicron?
How low is for a 35 year old natural immune? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Because of this the protection vaccine provides from infection might be short-lived, but protection from severe disease is stronger and longer-lasting www.nature.com/articles/s41591-021-01377-8 .... 4/4
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
The antibody IgA is closer to the exterior, protecting epithielial cells & upper respiratory tract, which helps stop initial infection, while IgG, which is deeper inside the body in extracelluar fluid, stops infections from becoming severe or deadly. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK27162/ ...3/
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
directorsblog.nih.gov/2021/06/22/how-immunity-generated-f…
"IgG...in body serum do seep into...lower lungs & provide robust protection from serious disease but they don't prevent infections very long in the nose, sinuses or throat" ... 2/ -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
The antibody IgG protects from severe Covid disease developing deep in the body, & the capability for producing IgG response is inhanced by vaccination; but protection from infection where the body 1st encounters the virus is not as strong: www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-03791-x.... 1/
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Important.
If "it" is pandemic of Coronavirus that before vaccination is 2X to 4X times recent influenza (post-2016), "it" will weaken until no worse than flu & the economic and social cost of COVID-19 panic are unbearable.
If "it" is society's mass-psychosis, I have no idea. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Tommy Lennhamn’s report on Sweden’s Anni Covidus
softwaredevelopmentperestroika.wordpress.com/2022/01/11/s…
Very thorough analysis but not the surprise his report a year ago. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1351226042384584706
Then Tommy & others revealed low age-adjusted excess death in only country that did not try to fight COVID-19.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Genius post by Tommy Lennhamn, @TLennhamn is most important item I have read.
Shows we were all wrong about Covid19’s real burden death.
Justifies Twitter for me. DO READ:
softwaredevelopmentperestroika.wordpress.com/2021/01/15/f… Final Report on Swedish Mortality 2020, Anno Covidius ...
#covid19 #covid19sweden -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. I will take a look.
Tried to run the TrackingR Python from GitHub but could not.
Seems they used out-of-date libraries. I really would like a Python expert to try.
Link is
github.com/crondonm/TrackingR
Did manage to run the ICL EpiEstim in Excel and R
Fascinating results
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
Excel
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Your use of R(t) to predict the peak in daily cases interesting. Should R(t) be equal to 1 near the peak?
I looked more carefully at the UK data. With 7-day central window average (on day d average over days d-3 to d+3), peak is on 2-Jan-2022. Raw it is 4-Jan
Do you agree?
JM Pienaar
@PienaarJm
I can't agree with your comment on the slope since Dec 18 because I know that R(t) is a more accurate method for deriving the slope.
I do however agree that the evidence so far shows that Omicron outbreaks seem to run out of susceptibles without intervention.
Immunity? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is what some thought was true globally in March 2020.
See questions (5) & (6) in 28Feb20 report below. www.dropbox.com/s/zbbcvw14i5am4z6/All_Michael_Levitt_22_R…
We all need to ask ourselves:
“Could some of the self-inflicted global harm have been avoided if we had been more open to discussion?”
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
🦠 Large numbers of Britons were already protected from coronavirus before the pandemic began because of previous exposure to common colds, a groundbreaking new study suggests.
The study helps explain why some people never get infected 👇 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Did the UK drop Plan B or was the Sage estimate on the much too high?
Log(Exponential Growth Rate) (blue line) has the same slope on 18-Dec as today.
Looks like there was no effect of intervention that reduced slope.
Open Sheet Link: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1GdXKExQW1fOlvR2stkG6elDv4…
pieterstreicher
@pieterstreicher
London, UK #omicron update (10 Jan 2022):
On 18 Dec 2021, SAGE warned that should the UK persist with plan B, it could see 600-6,000 deaths per day. This is 0.9-9.0 deaths/100k. London appears to have peaked at a level of 0.17 deaths/100k.
data source:
coronavirus.data.gov.uk -
Michael Levitt reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
When hospitalized patients have their virus sequenced:
In France, Blue = Delta, Red = Omicron, Green=Uncertain
Omicron associated with reduced hospital length of stay (43% vs Delta 19% less than 1 day) and substantially less ICU requirement
Nicolas Berrod
@nicolasberrod
L'AP-HP rend publiques de premières données sur les hospitalisations par variant.
Les patients infectés par #omicron vont surtout en hospitalisation conventionnelle plutôt qu'en soins critiques (Omicron représente 54% des admis en HC et 19% de ceux admis en SC fin décembre).
1/ -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much.
Have read your detailed & careful analysis. Wish I do I had known about it earlier.
It seems to show clearly that in the UK 2-dose vaccination is efficient & protective as shown in these 4 extracts.
I recommend reading it to all concerned about COVID-19.
Prof Jeffrey S Morris
@jsm2334
BTW, if you look in my blog post listed above, I have downloaded daily vaccination data and computed time series of % of each age group in each vaccination status over time -- the blog post above contains a link to the data set & R scripts to get those summaries/plots
e.g. 70-79 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All described here x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1373500003407175688
It was a long thread but all you need is there and still what we do currently .
Forgot to show latest England & Wales with week.
TommyBarlow
@barlow2021
How are you doing the age-standardization please?
Thanks. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks to all for the great discussion.
Science is still lives in the Twitterverse. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much.
This is a really nice independent test of the age-adjusted excess death we have been posting since Feb. 2021.
For 2020, England,Wales excess death is 9.9% of expected using 2017-19 as reference years.
Your data matches ours to within the line width.
jupes
@jupes20
we should always used age standardised data
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Important to make testable predictions. x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1480129960073482245
Here is USA we predicted yesterday superimposed on @nytimes prediction of expert Prof. Shaman @ShamanJeffrey. He never mentions Gompertz
Now we follow along using Sheet that shows totals:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bpZ0UDUDclA8iwZYtF_5I1FUe…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Peak cases/day & date depend on straight line fit to blue J(t) line.
Used Fit_D=28 days; 14 days better fit to recent J(t) values.
Changing Fit_D changes forecast:
Peak Date Fit_D Tot_by_1/31
700K 8Jan22 28 15m
920K 17Jan22 14 23m
Try it:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm1igwSY0BfssTu4d8d1FAWM2…
:)
@iKick247
US predicted peak 1/8? That was quick
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is very impressive data and even has age ranges. Can I ask if you & Robert Hoffmann
@itechnologynet agree?
This data is really key x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1478677595394916353
Your findings are in stark contrast to @nytimes for NYC or latest ICNARC report for UK www.icnarc.org/DataServices/Attachments/Download/5d46be46…
Kodos
@_Kodos_
They don't make it easy unfortunately. The tables in each report don't even have subtotals.
Here's my combined version. Note weeks 48-51 didn't appear in a report for some reason. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very impressive. This sort of data is very hard to come by as comparing deaths for vaxed and unvaxed seems to be a global taboo.
Can you please share your numbers in a table.
Kodos
@_Kodos_
It's from manually going through each weekly surveillance report
e.g. pages 38-41 on the latest report
www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-vaccine-weekl… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
No. That is clearly a new outbreak in The Netherlands. Is it in a different location?
Our predictions only apply to a single outbreak. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Can you please give links to the data in these plots?
Kodos
@_Kodos_
I've finished collecting the Public Health England data for cases, hospitalisations and deaths. Each "week" is the sum of new units in the previous 4 weeks
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
OMG it was @nytimes
As I showed yesterday, NY State and Florida very similar
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1480137583371894784
So how does Ron DeSantis come into this?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You know that I am totally apolitical. It may be wishful thinking on the part of a New Yorker feeling the cold.
You also need a link to your source. Anyone can add text to a plot. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
In this for real?
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/01/09/us/omicron-cities-…
*COVID-19 deaths normalized to year ago. NYC shows no recent excess death & little on 1/1/21. So WITH not OF
*COVID-19 Hospitalization. No scale: unvaxed 20X higher than vaxed. Are both groups tested equally? Is diagnosis PCR?
@nytimes -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You know that I am totally apolitical. It may be wishful thinking on the part of a New Yorker feeling the cold.
You also need a link to your source. Anyone can add text to a plot. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are right which is why Ben @USMortality made a site www.usmortality.com
I make a table for the US States like I make for the mortality.org countries. x.com/mlevitt_np2013/status/1480098529930620930
Will update as soon as possible.
Peter Yared
@peteryared
The best metric to compare health policy is excess death compared to 5 yr avg, zscore, etc. Interesting that (1) hard to find this comparison for US states, and (2) that this very competent site is anonymous. A good referenced source is Stanford's @MLevitt_NP2013 tweets.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Laurence Bettle
@LaurenceBettle
End mass jabs and live with Covid, says ex-head of vaccine taskforce Clive Dix and covid should be treated as an endemic virus similar to flu
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/08/end-mass-jabs-and-l… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good news: another policy reversal.
We are sure to see this happen more & more as the wall of lies, deceit & manipulation crumbles in the face of advancing truth & common sense.
If this lesson is learned, humanity will have been helped by COVID-19.
Another brick FROM the wall
Laurence Bettle
@LaurenceBettle
End mass jabs and live with Covid, says ex-head of vaccine taskforce Clive Dix and covid should be treated as an endemic virus similar to flu
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/08/end-mass-jabs-and-l… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Means open discussion between people with different views. Discussion about issues & not personal attacks, credentials, areas of expertise or political views.
COVID-19 is a terribly hard problem: conversation & cooperation were shut down when needed most.
An enduring tragedy! -
Michael Levitt reposted
Mark Changizi
@MarkChangizi
People not interested in true understanding
- point out their opponent's training background instead of presenting evidence or argument
- claim the science is settled.
I've been careful to do neither of these. Ever. That's what makes me a scientist, and not a censor. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID-19 is setting new records for daily cases everywhere.
Worrying even if hospitalization is low.
Good news that daily cases near peak in UK, US & DK.
ES, IT & IL will follow.
In all places, growth is Gompertz & slowing down.
Why did cases grow so quickly from the start? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
US Four biggest states all predicted by Gompertz J(t) straight line fit.
Loc Peak Date
FL 70K 9Jan22
NY 80K 10Jan
CA 107K 18Jan
TX 105K 17Jan (least clear).
Open Google sheet for you to do any state:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XLM6tzk4GznYn5beYkiAYN-6G… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Peak cases/day & date depend on straight line fit to blue J(t) line.
Used Fit_D=28 days; 14 days better fit to recent J(t) values.
Changing Fit_D changes forecast:
Peak Date Fit_D Tot_by_1/31
700K 8Jan22 28 15m
920K 17Jan22 14 23m
Try it:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm1igwSY0BfssTu4d8d1FAWM2…
:)
@iKick247
US predicted peak 1/8? That was quick
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
David, I use 2017, 2018 & 2019 as the reference years. Some have left out 2019 as too low and so makes subsequent excess death seem higher.
Many ways to calculate expected death. I decided on 5 age bands & 3 reference years consistently applied everywhere.
David
@Glodzie
What excess % including 2018 & 2019? The reason being that (in UK & Swe certainly) elderly mortality in 2018 and 2019 was low due to mild flu seasons - I have done my own numbers for the UK and think there is a "dry tinder" effect. Hate the expression btw.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is Open Google Sheet for Italy that I just made for Italy
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1LmQ9RoHDAjQL-sFIszy2PZ0OJ…
Looks predictable but always uncertainty. Follow it daily yourself
Peak of about 210,000 daily cases predicted on 17-Jan-2022. U is 16 days, a bit high so could be sooner with fewer cases
marcello
@marcello79
Professor Italy seems to face a new outspread like the first in early 2020, some Italians scientists said that it is no possible to predict the peak, this makes Sensei in your opinion?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks for reminder.
Here is latest version. Triple checked to eliminate bugs. It is for all of COVID-19 period.
Charles Mathews
@CharlieDarling2
Stats by @MLevitt_NP2013
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks!
Is code released like we do?
Here is open Google Sheet method anyone can run on any state docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XLM6tzk4GznYn5beYkiAYN-6G…
Current wave in New York State is forecast to peak on 10-Jan-2022 with 80,000 cases (7-day smoothed)
For countries use World sheet
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here are latest COVID-19 Forecast Open Google Sheets for USA & World. A few small bugs corrected; these are the versions to use yourselves.
World (including USA)
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm1igwSY0BfssTu4d8d1FAWM2…
US States:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XLM6tzk4GznYn5beYkiAYN-6G… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here are latest COVID-19 Forecast Open Google Sheets for USA & World. A few small bugs corrected; these are the versions to use yourselves.
World (including USA)
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm1igwSY0BfssTu4d8d1FAWM2…
US States:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XLM6tzk4GznYn5beYkiAYN-6G… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Please take a look at this forecast highlighted in @nytimes. www.nytimes.com/2022/01/06/opinion/omicron-covid-us.html
Will be studying Jeffrey Shaman @ShamanJeffrey forecast in depth. His is a renowned modeling group.
Does anyone know how His forecast is done?
Is there a key resource describing their method? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Jeffrey Shaman
@ShamanJeffrey
Some thoughts on January with Omicron in the US: Here’s When We Expect Omicron to Peak www.nytimes.com/2022/01/06/opinion/omicron-covid-us.html
Lots more that could have been discussed: rapid replication within host, potentially shortened latency, immune erosion and phylogenetics, severity of future variants -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The joint but independent decision by the leaders of the US & the UK to live with Covid19 published in @nytimes is welcome news.
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/08/world/europe/coronavirus-omicr…
To some this has been the obvious & only choice for over 3 months.
Let us hope more leaders follow this path soon.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Such welcome news from New Zealand. www.nytimes.com/live/2021/10/04/world/covid-delta-variant…
Who will be next to realize that we need to live with the virus and not loose everything from our desire to control it. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
UK peaked?
It took longer than expected and the data recording over the holidays played havoc with predictions but it is nice to see doom’s day scenarios did not occur in the UK.
www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2022/01/07/no-need-fourth-co…
Forecasting is hard & method must be open to all:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1GdXKExQW1fOlvR2stkG6elDv4… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@USMortality
Ben, Really fantastic. Great job you have done, here. usmortality.com too.
See how the moving fit lines lock into place for some time.
With help from experts like you we could have had a tool like this in April 20 soon after Gompertz fit suspected.
US Mortality
@USMortality
Fitting Gompertz curves to each outbreak!
Soon going to put up a site for these kind or charts.
Let me know what you think!
#covid #corona #covid19 #coronavirus #florida -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@USMortality
Ben, Really fantastic. Great job you have done, here. usmortality.com too.
See how the moving fit lines lock into place for some time.
With help from experts like you we could have had a tool like this in April 20 soon after Gompertz fit suspected.
US Mortality
@USMortality
Fitting Gompertz curves to each outbreak!
Soon going to put up a site for these kind or charts.
Let me know what you think!
#covid #corona #covid19 #coronavirus #florida -
Michael Levitt reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
The occupation level of ventilation beds in London is probably the most promising Omicron-related chart going. It's been more than two weeks now since London cases peaked.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Aaron Siri
@AaronSiriSG
I am pleased to report a federal judge rejected the FDA's request to produce the Pfizer Covid vaccine data at 500 pages per month and instead ordered a rate of 55,000 pages per month! Everyone should read the Judge's excellent 3-page decision available at aaronsiri.substack.com/p/instead-of-fdas-requested-500-pa…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
There is good age-banded data in mortality.org for 986 million people. This includes Europe (497 million) & US (328 million).
For all these age-adjusted all-cause excess death is 1.34 million in 2020 & 2021 (2 years)
Death rate is 0.07%
Survival rate is 99.93%.
Question Everything.
@TheMarkFreeman
99.7% survival rate before the newest variant that’s even less lethal. I don’t think it’s the vaccine “saving her life”.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/whoopi-goldberg-shares-updat…
This is a very media-visible disappointment for a vaccine based on truly revolutionary technology and which has done so much to calm us all.
What do we do next?
Do we now need emergency approval for a new vaccine with the Omicron mRNA sequence? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks for making this more accessible. @USMortality taught me so much.
Have been using V5.5 to follow a handful of countries & US States. Results depend on the selected start date & the number of recent day fit.
Knowing Omicron is fast with U close to 10 days may help.
Heather
@HRenkel
Update of @MLevitt_NP2013 & @USMortality’s GoogleSheet with a sheet to more easily input your own data: US States:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vfuyRBfm1_7erJYKGUBPninDw… & WORLD : docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Y_pj7X0fBrFnB_wkHM4zaDlKp…
And an explanation of the chart, how to change parameters & add your own data: www.dropbox.com/s/d7s1wh5yfuey676/Levitt_Gompertz_predict… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Heather
@HRenkel
Update of @MLevitt_NP2013 & @USMortality’s GoogleSheet with a sheet to more easily input your own data: US States:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vfuyRBfm1_7erJYKGUBPninDw… & WORLD : docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Y_pj7X0fBrFnB_wkHM4zaDlKp…
And an explanation of the chart, how to change parameters & add your own data: www.dropbox.com/s/d7s1wh5yfuey676/Levitt_Gompertz_predict… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Two random items really improved my mood like ray of winter sun.
Easier Travel:
www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/omicron-england-prime-minister… “Pre-departure Covid tests scrapped for travellers arriving in England”
Sensible Rules:
apnews.com/article/coronavirus-pandemic-business-health-e… “France allows some COVID-19-infected medics to keep working” -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Looks terrific.
What smoothing do you suggest we use for forecasting outcomes?
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
Here's the same shifted graph but where I remove the minimum smoothing on deaths... as an animation it works well but for a staic graph you need it to be at least 5 days of a smoothing window
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really need percent of all cause dead who were vaccinated (%Dv).
Comparing %Dv with percent population vaccinated (%Pv) would be so informative & support statements like: “vaccinated are less likely to die”. Easily age-banded, too.
Is %Dv known for any mortality .org location? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much for this animation.
Averaging is so important and we use it without considering the implications.
Also a pity that data collection is less frequent than early in pandemic (eg. Florida in Fig).
Still totally understandable.
We are all so fatigued.
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
Here's a zoom in on the Jan 2021 wave. Now if you apply any kind of averaging to a Gompertz peak, you will have the effect of shifting the maximum to the right as the initial phase of a Gompertz is faster than later /cc @MLevitt_NP2013 up to Sigma = 3 days no major shifting
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
On the less happy note, deaths appeared to lag PCR positives by around 24 days in last year's wave
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Stephen Connolly
@connolly_s
I should caution that if this year's wave is like last years wave then the hospitalization occupancy peak will be around the 18th/19th of Jan... I'll have to tack a fit onto hospitalization @USMortality @MLevitt_NP2013 as that should allow forecasting I suspect
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Martin Kulldorff
@MartinKulldorff
What competent epidemiologists knew in March 2020 should now be obvious to all. Covid cannot be suppressed. Lockdowns just postpone infections and prolong the pandemic while causing collateral damage on public health and education.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Raw data often used for scary numbers.
7-day averaging is always too low when values rising & too high when values falling. 7-day average value to day n, is a good estimate for actual value on day n-3.
When change is fast (like for Omicron 3-day doubling), error is big (Fig.1)
Benito hasn't denounced the genocide 🇵🇷
@midnucas
Um, why are you looking at unaveraged daily figures on a linear scale
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Both. General population more so due to fear & damage.
Predictions are measured by difference between Predicted & Actual numbers (denoted N_Predicted & N_Actual).
Perhaps:
|N_Predicted-N_Actual|/N_Actual
as percentage ('||' is absolute value)
Interested in all suggestions. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Is this the method that led to you the Israeli forecasts? It is interesting and I look forward to seeing how accurate it is.
How will you judge the accuracy?
Public tolerance for error is very low is COVID-19 forecasting.
Eran Segal
@segal_eran
Our news and views out in @NatureMicrobiol
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Is Omicron COVID-19 going to infect most of the world exponentially doubling daily cases every 3 days for 3 weeks (>2000 X)?
Looking at World & UK from 22-Jan-20 answer seems YES
Zooming in from 2-Dec-21 answer seems NO
Scale & comparison key to common sense & good science -
Michael Levitt reposted
US Mortality
@USMortality
Daily reminder, that Sweden has failed!
> 2021 was 2nd lowest of last 17 years.
> 2020 was 7th lowest of last 17 years.
#covid #covid19 #corona #coronavirus #omicron
H/T @jens_140081 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Actually “No”. A single value the considers all those things. An additional month of annual expected death for particular age group or demography.
That is on twelfth or 8.5% extra risk. Much bigger number for old and frail than for young and healthy.
Michele Capobianco
@Capobianco2005C
#pfr estimated on 22-Mar-2020? A single value, without considering age classes and demography? 🤦♂️
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Only a single concerted outbreak behaves like the Gompertz Growth function.
Sum of outbreaks is limited by population fatality ratio PFR estimated on 22-Mar-2020 as a month of extra natural death.
mortality.org PFR=0.07%/yr, survival=99.93%
medium.com/@michael.levitt/the-excess-burden-of-death-fro… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
WSJ 7-Apr-20
www.dropbox.com/s/w4ut3sd1hm502t6/WSJ Corona Chronicles- …
14-Mar-20
www.dropbox.com/s/4mqaf3w3s9cjhnl/1.The_Corona_Chronologi…
Personal view of key period 7-Mar-20 to 7-Apr-20. Was not on Twitter yet, but tried to help Western World respond to COVID-19
Thanks: @Cescoxonta @andreascaie @fredericpoitev1 @jpglmrodrigues @drpatricktam
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Am disillusioned by mainstream media. Twitter I like.
In Mar. 2020, @wsj asked me to write an opinion piece. In it I mentioned Gompertz for the first time. Wall Street Journal rejected it without appeal or revision.
Should I post a link to my discarded 7-Apr-20 pdf file? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Am disillusioned by mainstream media. Twitter I like.
In Mar. 2020, @wsj asked me to write an opinion piece. In it I mentioned Gompertz for the first time. Wall Street Journal rejected it without appeal or revision.
Should I post a link to my discarded 7-Apr-20 pdf file? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Likely to be the first of many such revelations. The truth has a way of being persistent in revealing itself.
Pity discussion was limited & censored.
Solving hard problems needs argument & counter-argument. Suppression really does not help.
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jan/02/britain-got-it-wron… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Should we stop measuring covid19 cases?
amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jan/01/us-covid-case-cou…
I say NO.
Instead ONLY test patients seeing a physician or hospitalized with respiratory symptoms.
We need to go back to diseases being identified by clinical symptoms not the sequence of a short fragment of RNA -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very important point.
The official resistance to random sampling in testing is astounding.
We begged Prime Minister Netanyahu to try this during our first meeting in mid-March 2020. This was before track and trace was implemented is Israel.
Has any country randomly sampled?
Matan Holzer
@MatanHolzer
Same for the variant sequencing, sequencing a random sample of 100 samples will give you a lot more information in much less time, than sequencing all samples from abroad
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
So Prof. Segal @segal_eran really meant 660,000 to 2,660,000 extra COVID-19 cases in Israel in January 2022?
Even these lower total case numbers cannot be reached with 10,000 to 20,000 daily cases over 31 days.
These numbers are frightening.
“Siri, Should I panic?”
Binyamin Lachkar - בנימין לאשקר
@benjilachkar
He predicted 10+K cases in a few days and much more after. And 2-4 millions overall from Omicron not in January alone.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Almost 20 months later this seems more relevant than ever.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID19 is a contrast agent like that used in microscopy. It emphasizes and brings into sharp focus the features of our World that were always there. Not a pretty sight. We urgently need better AI so next time we can say “Siri, Alexa, Google: Should I panic?” & believe the reply.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
On Israeli TV @segal_eran predicts 2 to 4 million Israeli Omicron cases in January.
He also predicts 10 to 20 thousand cases a day.
2 to 4 million cases in 31 days means more than 65 to 129 thousand cases a day.
Which of these radically different models should we believe? -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Is SARS-CoV-2 mutating to be less lethal? @TheLancet says so www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2…. Was told this happens by the virologist friends I still had in March. It is what coronavirus viruses do when they have enough cycles of reproduction.
Lock down impedes this natural weakening. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is the companion sheet for world countries.
World:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1iYpe4H7Zf6Wjo_vomWds2cAl5…
US States:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1rpd9CI_q4xq7hqnn4Dv4C_ukF…
These are the best to use bearing in mind the volatility of Omicron.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Florida seems under control.
Here is an open Google sheet that fixes smoothing issues better than before. Still hard to write Excel that can forecast a virus that spreads as fas as Omicron
Can be used for the US state of your choice.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1rpd9CI_q4xq7hqnn4Dv4C_ukF…
(((Howard Forman)))
@thehowie
The angry Florida twitter trolls are having a bad day. And I sincerely wish them the best in this New Year.
To all others, even better than the best! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Florida seems under control.
Here is an open Google sheet that fixes smoothing issues better than before. Still hard to write Excel that can forecast a virus that spreads as fas as Omicron
Can be used for the US state of your choice.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1rpd9CI_q4xq7hqnn4Dv4C_ukF…
(((Howard Forman)))
@thehowie
The angry Florida twitter trolls are having a bad day. And I sincerely wish them the best in this New Year.
To all others, even better than the best! -
Michael Levitt reposted
Prof. Akiko Iwasaki
@VirusesImmunity
How does prior infection modify neutralization against Omicron? In the mRNA vaccine recipients (28 days after second dose), prior infection provided advantages in cross protection against VOCs, including Omicron. (7/)
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Yuri Deigin
@ydeigin
Could Omicron be the “vaccine” that will wipe out Covid?
“infection rapidly recruited potent ... broad neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) against current VOCs, including Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta and Omicron, ... which were higher than BioNTech-vaccinees”
www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.27.474218v1 -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alessandro Sette
@SetteLab
Can T cell responses cross-recognize omicron? We looked at different vaccines (mRNA-1273, BNT162b2, Ad26.COV2.S, NVX-CoV2373) and multiple variants to answer that question. @settelab @Alba_Grifoni @profshanecrotty @aetarke @ljiresearch www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.28.474333v1
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Last 2021 Tweet wishes you all Happy 2022.
The quick ending in South Africa was not an example as it is summer.
Fear that if Covid19 testing keeps on, US & Europe will grind to a halt over the next few weeks as mild Omicron spreads in many outbreaks.
Disruption for all… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Lesson of 707 days on COVID-19: follow Scandinavia.
Finland like UK: Case up 5X not deaths.
Why is background COVID-19 death rate 1 per million per day?
At 365/1,000,000 per year same as UK mortality of 0.365 per 1000 for 15 - 24 year olds.
Is this the age of cases in both?
Gil
@giladcohen1972
פינלנד משעה את השימוש ב״תו הירוק״ לשלושה שבועות. ״אינו יעיל במניעת הפצת וריאנט האומיקרון״. מצפון תיפתח הטובה?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is UK double smoothed without Christmas data back-fill. Looks OK.
Help please: we need London alone. outbreaks.
Open speadsheet can be used for your favorite country. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12Z25B_8_uu9AMgv6UTU0Khj7i…
Hope to release @HRenkel help-sheet for easier use later today.
Grant now
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Double 7-day rolling smoothing added back. Florida smoother.
Link here. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16Hh68ll23wBYR5ceRZsZUSEW6…
Now to make this change for rest of the world, then back to NIH Grant.
7-day smoothing has serious issues. We need cleaner data.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Omicron in Florida & any US States.
Ben @USMortality worked heroically & succeeded to update older US version.
Open at:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vkjscPr_KQ5t2I2qO5RIaYOZZ…
Omicron problem is data collection noise & multiple spike outbreaks. Forecasts harder.
Must renew NIH R35 grant.
NEED HELP PLEASE -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Double 7-day rolling smoothing added back. Florida smoother.
Link here. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16Hh68ll23wBYR5ceRZsZUSEW6…
Now to make this change for rest of the world, then back to NIH Grant.
7-day smoothing has serious issues. We need cleaner data.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Omicron in Florida & any US States.
Ben @USMortality worked heroically & succeeded to update older US version.
Open at:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vkjscPr_KQ5t2I2qO5RIaYOZZ…
Omicron problem is data collection noise & multiple spike outbreaks. Forecasts harder.
Must renew NIH R35 grant.
NEED HELP PLEASE -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Omicron in Florida & any US States.
Ben @USMortality worked heroically & succeeded to update older US version.
Open at:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vkjscPr_KQ5t2I2qO5RIaYOZZ…
Omicron problem is data collection noise & multiple spike outbreaks. Forecasts harder.
Must renew NIH R35 grant.
NEED HELP PLEASE -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Found this @nytimes piece particularly interesting. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/12/30/world/covid-cases-…
In table, we find 4 of the 5 Scandinavian countries: Denmark, Iceland, Finland & Norway.
Meanwhile Sweden not in the table has bad influenza.
Can anyone explain this to me? Does Sweden not COVID test. -
Michael Levitt reposted
JusDayDa
@JusDayDa
Michael.
All ages, and then Pediatrics.
Covid mainly kills by causing pneumonia
-in adults or kids
Flu mainly kills by causing pneumonia
-in adults or kids
Apples to apples data
Flu is endemic,
seasonal (winter)
Covid is not yet endemic,
bi-seasonal (summer and winter) -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Influenza is a very unpleasant disease just like COVID-19. Now that it is back, I hope that masks and 6 feet distancing do their job like many have suspected.
If data is released like it was with COVID19, we can test my suspicion that Influenza case growth is Gompertz.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Meanwhile in Sweden👇👇👇
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Omicron seems to be the Corona Virus Variant to end COVID-19.
The Gompertz self-limiting nature of each outbreak may be bad.
Do we need to follow Swedens' Apr.20 example & allow new outbreaks to spread the Omicron infection?
May not be needed with such an infectious variant.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
5 Studies, 5 Figures. All consistent, independent replications in vivo, in vitro. Omicron can't infect lungs or lung cells as well as prior variants.
@KU_Leuven @SystemsVirology @GuptaR_lab @hkumed @LivUni -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Clarification.
PCR recognizes a fragment of viral RNA that is long enough to be unique & in part of genome not mutated easily.
PCR test designed for COVID-19 should not recognize flu.
Diseases used to be identified by clinical symptoms not RNA.
Testing millions is new.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very perceptive.
The final episodes of the Carona Chronicles could be the most interesting.
We have the non-clinical PCR diagnosis problem.
The Influenza/COVID-19 confusion problem.
The no correlation of COVID-19 damage with restrictions problem (Sweden vs. Austria).
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
The CDC has a huge dilemma on their hands - whether or not to redefine the terms “CV hospitalizations” & “CV deaths”.
If they don’t, many ppl may start believing that the vaxx are a huge failure.
If they do, many will suddenly realize they have been lied to for almost a year now. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very perceptive.
The final episodes of the Carona Chronicles could be the most interesting.
We have the non-clinical PCR diagnosis problem.
The Influenza/COVID-19 confusion problem.
The no correlation of COVID-19 damage with restrictions problem (Sweden vs. Austria).
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
The CDC has a huge dilemma on their hands - whether or not to redefine the terms “CV hospitalizations” & “CV deaths”.
If they don’t, many ppl may start believing that the vaxx are a huge failure.
If they do, many will suddenly realize they have been lied to for almost a year now. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Is this from an alternate universe where all the old “facts” are being turned on their head.
Will we soon hear that COVID-19 Is 2X to 4X as bad as severe flu?
Will we hear that most died WITH not OF.
Will we hear that all the collateral damage was a mistake?
Is this a dream?
ABC News
@ABC
LATEST: The newly updated CDC guidelines don't require testing at the end of isolation because PCR tests can stay positive for up to 12 weeks, CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky tells @GMA. abcn.ws/3401yEN
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Very clear & useful.
For 500,000 average Britains, a 970 per 100,000 annual mortality rate means 50 would be expected to die in 4 days.
Are ages at death given?
Growth in Omicron daily cases seems to be slowing.
Here is your link. www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-omicron-daily… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Glad to see th eSheet being used by others.
Data in Spain is too noisy to tell. We need to wait.
Liberator
@b24liberat0r
Si extrapolamos, esta ola haría pico a principios de febrero, todavía queda. Sigue una Gompertz clavadita. Podría ser también por el nº de test, los cuales, así a ojo, también siguen la misma curva.
(según hoja de @MLevitt_NP2013) -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Funny how cooperative the transition is from panic, dread & gloom to hope & happiness.
This transition is a natural drug & we have become addicted to its high.
Troubling to me is the serious collateral damage that these ups & downs do to the weaker, younger & less fortunate. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
www.ijidonline.com/article/S1201-9712(21)01256-X/fulltext
More good news from South Africa.
“the rapid rise and decline of admissions and decreased severity of COVID-19 disease a lower mortality rate from Omicron compared to previous waves”
Makes me so proud to have been born there growing up in Pretoria. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Great news from UK.
Today's data confirms our 22-Dec. forecast of 28-Dec. Omicron daily case peak
With 318,699 cases over 3 days & 121,371 cases on 24-Dec., no logical way to distribute cases over 3 days to make number on 27-Dec. greater than on 24-Dec.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1UKraX-aZXaegPkoZiPVSCEb3e…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Received little attention but forecast daily cases in UK would stop rising. The peak would occur very soon: 12/24 - 12/29
Now preferred date 12/25
Forecast may be unreliable with huge daily background 48,064 from 12/8
Still such a welcome gift to all
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm-hm7XbleDJMD1jK7PyPf84o…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
World focus on UK Omicron, made me fix our (+@USMortality) sheet docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fNhFvrNDzQE0lRUsjkZA_Qwvm…
1) Set date [C5]
2) Set row when background to be zero [J5]. Date in [L6]. Try to straighten blue J(t). Hard as background high. SENSITIVE: try few values
3) Set fit days [L4] for max CC -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Our Portugal plot is 2020, 21 consecutive but looks like what you show. Cross-checking is essential. Thank you.
I am fascinated that Spain and Portugal are so different. Similar total impact (Spain 4.6X bigger) but excess death at very different times.
Suggests saturation.
Gonçalo Fernandes
@reisada
Vamos aguardar até aos 10 dias..
Mesmo com a explosão na testagem ( que admito não considerei , mas a positividade mantém-se) continua a nao se notar absolutamente nada fora do normal a nível de hospitalizações/UCI.
E a mortalidade todas as causas está a entrar em *dèfice* -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why do EuroMOMO, CDC, mortality.org, scb.se, etc. not age-adjust their expected deaths?
With aging populations, age-adjustment increases expected death by ~3% so using it reduces excess death.
Does every agency want to make COVID-19 seem worse? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Following her early clinical observation, MUST SEE Dr. Coetzee in tough interview
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kD3Cncrod9I
Omicron is
1) Very infectious buts ends fast
2) Mostly infects unvaccinated
3) Very mild: little ICU, no deaths.
All by clinical observation, not modeling.
Great news! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. Really interesting article with a useful historical perspective.
Truth Noder 🛡
@NoderOf
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I hope you are wrong.
Humanity managed to get past so many crises that were so much worse.
Key is that there is a well-defined end-point. What could this be for COVID-19?
I once mistakenly thought it would be a return to normal excess death. Not sure anymore.
Krishnan Chittur
@cheprofessor
Will any of this matter? I fear not. Fear and panic about sarscov2 has now been so thoroughly embedded in hundreds of millions, billions that we may never emerge into normalcy - furthering the power of a few who continue to deny natural immunity and human history with viruses.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Since 1-Jan-20, Sweden had -1,723 Excess Deaths (~2K less than normal). Austria had +11,213 excess deaths (~11K above normal).
Did anyone really think Austria was doing better?
Austria suppressed the Spring 2020 outbreak & thought they had beaten COVID19.
Sweden never tried
Toby Young
@toadmeister
Austria, one of the most repressive European countries during the coronavirus pandemic, has recently overtaken Sweden in terms of total covid mortality, showing that almost all government interventions have been ineffective and unjustified. swprs.org/judgment-day-sweden-vindicated/
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Good news. Remember there was no excess death in the UK from 5 Feb. 21 to 22-Nov-21
x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1473746057431597059
During this time there were 30,000 reported COVID-19 deaths. These must all have been compensated for by co-morbidities, less accidents, absence of flu or anything else.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
Interesting phenomenon in the UK. Cases are rising, but ICU numbers are not, and deaths are falling.👇
It really looks like with Omicron we have a decoupling of infections & morbidity / mortality. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks for writing this summary. I really hope you are right.
Nick Hudson
@NickHudsonCT
Last article for the year and time for a bit of fun. "Welcome to Clown World: Part 4—An Extraordinary Week" www.biznews.com/thought-leaders/2021/12/24/panda-nick-hud…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Received little attention but forecast daily cases in UK would stop rising. The peak would occur very soon: 12/24 - 12/29
Now preferred date 12/25
Forecast may be unreliable with huge daily background 48,064 from 12/8
Still such a welcome gift to all
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lm-hm7XbleDJMD1jK7PyPf84o…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
World focus on UK Omicron, made me fix our (+@USMortality) sheet docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fNhFvrNDzQE0lRUsjkZA_Qwvm…
1) Set date [C5]
2) Set row when background to be zero [J5]. Date in [L6]. Try to straighten blue J(t). Hard as background high. SENSITIVE: try few values
3) Set fit days [L4] for max CC -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I like your three points.
How we get past the mass trauma and psychosis induced by COVID-19 is something I think about every day.
Any ideas?
BrendanEich
@BrendanEich
1/ The Godfather: "I'm gonna make him an offer he can't refuse."
2/ Postmodernist: "I'm gonna state a proposition no one understands."
3/ WEF: "We're gonna make a proposal you won't vote on but your corporation-owned governments will mandate."
(1) is least bad. (2) led to (3). -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It was open for me and others I shared is with. Fortunately it is just pages.
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
It's paywall. Could someone post a free version?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
www.wsj.com/articles/fauci-collins-emails-great-barringto…
I finally made it into the Wall Street Journal because of Fauci & Collins. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Laurence Bettle
@LaurenceBettle
Omicron milder than Delta - University of Edinburgh
"Early national data suggest that Omicron is associated with a two-thirds reduction in the risk of COVID-19 hospitalisation when compared to Delta."
www.research.ed.ac.uk/en/publications/severity-of-omicron… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
In England & Wales (ENW, most of UK), there have been zero excess deaths in the 44 weeks since 1-Feb-2021.
In that same period to 22-Nov-2021, there were 1.47 million cases COVID-19.
If we add Scotland & Northern Ireland to ENW the start of the period is a bit later on 5-Feb. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You could right but I am a naive scientist.
Taraffal
@taraffal
With all respect, would it not be a highly efficient strategy to fool the brightest minds of our time with slightly inaccurate data...while you're looking for peanuts they're running with our money...step back, think again, what's going on here?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Flu is a terrible disease. Its variants have genomes that are much more different from one another than for COVID19 as no proofreading.
The 1,000’s of children’s lives saved in the 2 years of COVID19 suggest that for them influenza with a vaccine is worse than COVID-19 without -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Indeed. Such an important paper, unaware of till now.
Link is: www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6937a6.htm
Has world influenza really gone due to "extensive community mitigation measures are maintained (e.g., face masks, social distancing, school closures, and teleworking)".
Seem unlikely to me.
John Cullen 🐓
@I_Am_JohnCullen
Real scientists noticed this, too..
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
World focus on UK Omicron, made me fix our (+@USMortality) sheet docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1fNhFvrNDzQE0lRUsjkZA_Qwvm…
1) Set date [C5]
2) Set row when background to be zero [J5]. Date in [L6]. Try to straighten blue J(t). Hard as background high. SENSITIVE: try few values
3) Set fit days [L4] for max CC -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why is this HUGE?
Real scientists found this in Feb. 2021.
Can one trust a site with this x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1461731641219559425
Is @TheEconomist now worried that the real danger is not COVID-19 but HUGE collateral damage caused by irresponsible exaggeration?
Pity only 21 months too late.
Prof. Freedom
@prof_freedom
HUGE - According to the latest calculations by "The Economist" Sweden has the lowest excess mortality in all of Europe in 2021. Is it now allowed to compare Sweden with Norway, Finland and Denmark?
1/3
www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-death… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really like your graphics. Always have.
Marco Piani 🇮🇹🇨🇦
@Marco_Piani
Who on Earth did not know that at some point cases and deaths would decrease? There are only ~10M people in Sweden to infect...
You seem to imply that before a Nobel laureate shared his great discovery, people did not know that pandemic waves subside.
Grateful to live in Canada -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Have never speculated about data being manipulated,
Have never found inconsistencies that were not resolved by acceptable explanations.
India was really important being super-exponential at first (like UK etc.). Then J(t) settled down to be predictive. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1473196210995576832 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Worrying times.
Suggest we follow case fatality rate (CFR) of Omicron outbreaks in South Africa (SA) & UK.
Population age distributions different & SA started earlier but in both CFR is 0.25% (1 death in 400 cases).
Can anyone share link to UK COVID-19 death ages?
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
One Gompertz outbreak is never exponential. Initially it grows fast but is slowing down as indicated by dropping log(Exponential Growth Rate), J(t) (blue).
When a new outbreak overlaps another that is rising, sum grows super-exponentially: J(t) goes up.
Must wait in UK,DK,ES
Howard Steen
@HowardSteen4
‘Exponential growth’ did you say? That much talked up phenomena never happened at all in 2020 as @MLevitt_NP2013 enlightened me. Now it’s really happening. I hope great minds will analyse & learn from this new phenomenal explosion of numbers.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
No one followed the example Sweden set so bravely in March 2020.
Sweden took a chance; remember thrill of seeing smoothed daily deaths decrease on 2 May 2020. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1256511516863586304
This showed COVID-19 spread was self-limiting,
data analysis the World should have followed.
Simsim.btc ∞ / 21 M
@simsimbtc
Why not treat a virus like a virus? In Sweden where I live we haven’t had lockdowns and no mandates to wear masks since Covid started. Our neighbors laughed and ridiculed us. Now we have the least cases. I see Sweden is the only country who relied on previous data and science.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Links please.
Iain Mulady 🦩
@IainMulady
Lockdown and controls reduced the risks they were exposed to and dramatically cut suicides in school age children.
This has all been well covered if you listened outside the denialsphere. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks to you all
@M_T_Franz @Mari0Bishara @TheValueScout @RTsays_ @Ricky_Verona
I now have all the information from covid19-dashboard.ages.at?area=10
Pressing download gives a huge amount of data.
Dominik Ziegler
@TheValueScout
Under "Download" you will find all data down to district level since the beginning of the pandemic: covid19-dashboard.ages.at
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I need help with COVID-19 reported case data for Austria.
Specifically, I need a link to a file with the total or daily cases each day since the start of the epidemic in Feb. 2020.
I need this for each of the 10 Austrian States (eg. Wien, Tirol, Burgenland, Salzburg,etc.). -
Michael Levitt reposted
Ran Israeli
@RanIsraeli
Is there a possibility to know from the data whether the measures&vaccinations increased child deaths?
No.
Overall 0-19 mortality was extremely low due to the presence of COVID (Viral Interference + fewer car accidents?)
The graph resembles a classical complementation experiment. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I just discovered John Naughton in The @guardian. www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/dec/18/how-cut-and…
Now follow him on Twitter @jjn1
Computers have been my passion for 60 years. I became a scientist to be able use big computers when they cost many million of today’s dollars.
Best decision of my life. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
One Gompertz outbreak is never exponential. Initially it grows fast but is slowing down as indicated by dropping log(Exponential Growth Rate), J(t) (blue).
When a new outbreak overlaps another that is rising, sum grows super-exponentially: J(t) goes up.
Must wait in UK,DK,ES
Howard Steen
@HowardSteen4
‘Exponential growth’ did you say? That much talked up phenomena never happened at all in 2020 as @MLevitt_NP2013 enlightened me. Now it’s really happening. I hope great minds will analyse & learn from this new phenomenal explosion of numbers.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
From mid March 2020 less young people aged 0-14 died in USA & Europe than in previous years.
These mortality deficit numbers indicate that the pandemic saved young lives and this is confusing.
Can physicians & epidemiologists explain?
Roland Dunbrack 🏳️🌈 @rolanddunbrack.bsky.social
@RolandDunbrack
I've been trying to write a tweet in response to @MLevitt_NP2013 retweeting this that does not contain a lot of four letter words. I can't. So this: 535 children under 18 have died of covid19 in the US. Preventable deaths. data.cdc.gov/NCHS/Provisional-COVID-19-Deaths-Focus-on-Ag…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Gabriela, you have done so much. Important too.
Read your preprint but not fully grasped details. Will now read new papers here.
Both our & your models are about population heterogeneity. Yours about susceptibility. Ours about contact’s patterns.
Do you get Gompertz growth?
M Gabriela M Gomes
@mgmgomes1
Dreaming about death; got up to make coffee
Then decided to write thread about what's killing me. Not depressing (on contrary). It's my duty to make the world understand this +ve thing before I die [not that I think I'll die soon; that was just in dream]
PLEASE READ IF YOU CAN! -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Jay, thanks for taking the lead on this.
My mis-spelt doppelgänger Leawitt is with you, an indication of how those conspiring against us check details.
This started after we & Martin advised Governor DeSantis on 24Sep20.
It explains the coordinated attacks.
Will it now end?
Jay Bhattacharya
@DrJBhattacharya
On TV today Francis Collins doubled down on his lies and propaganda attack and on the Great Barrington Declaration. If you read the GBD, you will not find the words "let it rip" because the central idea is focused protection of the vulnerable.🧵
gbdeclaration.org
(1/20) -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Portugal close to peaking 12/28.
As friends & family are there, I post a link to the Google Sheet.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lJ6vNN7wcHFtCEYV8b8BMyYN5…
With so many places stopping as predicted & without accounting for any interventions, we need to realize that there is a natural dynamic at play. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Simplistic but the Gompertz function works better than any other three-parameter function at fitting the time-variation of total counts of cases and deaths in single outbreaks is all global locations.
This is actually very fortunate as Gompertz growth is self-limiting & stops.
TT
@thtaylor47
Covid spread and death do not conform to a Gompertz curve because there are many active interventions and factors influencing the real-world disease. It is not a “natural” curve as that for which Gompertz did his work. Use of Gompertz here is simplistic.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gompertz_function -
Michael Levitt reposted
TT
@thtaylor47
Covid spread and death do not conform to a Gompertz curve because there are many active interventions and factors influencing the real-world disease. It is not a “natural” curve as that for which Gompertz did his work. Use of Gompertz here is simplistic.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gompertz_function -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Seems to be a new outbreak overlaying the existing one.
Fitting 28 days gives a peak. Would like to wait a week for J(t) to settle down.
Follow this yourself
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Vqnq5F2YSMxw6Kq5MajehdYV3…
Contango
@contango_82
Would also be interesting to see gompertz on Denmark, which has majority of omicrin cases now. Tnx for all your good work on this topic!
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sad Christmas in Holland but peaceful…
Will also set record for worst ever response to COVID-19.
NL peaked as forecast 18 days ago. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ei43voxvIZnpDnZFHg4enG83V…
South African Omicron peaks soon & has 0.26% Case Fatality Ratio, least of all strains. x.com/MLevitt_NP2013/status/1472170648189476871
Why??!!
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Gompertz straight-line J(t) forecasts converge. Daily cases peak 12/25 at ~25,000 Omicron daily cases.
Christmas gift to world:
1) Shows 'expo-talk' like "doubles in 3 days" meaningless. Gompertz always slows.
2) Shows low 'O' lethality, CFR=0.26%.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Africa has daily Omicron cases with least daily deaths since May 2020. Need a week to get deaths/case.
The latest outbreak of Omicron daily cases starts near zero. It is beautifully Gompertz with J(t) becoming a dropping straight-line blue line).
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
France is close peak. Will do so on 12/23/2021 with 53K daily cases. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_73_32J-TIm9VmPRX7nbzxB6c…
On 12/4/2021 predicted peak of 67K on 1/1/2022.
Close. Great for Gompertz.
Epidemiologists must be better prepared for future pandemics.
We cannot repeat the same damaging mistakes.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
More COVID-19 forecasts by Gompertz J(t).
Thanks to Twitter for pressure to keep on learning & improving.
France ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ei43voxvIZnpDnZFHg4enG83V… Netherlands ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ei43voxvIZnpDnZFHg4enG83V… Spain ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Sw8z3gPDCmNuFjvCB1fdPDdUL… Italy ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1OBheaJl9MGjKhIp1t6XrvRdMk… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
🚨🚨🚨🚨🚨
1/ In order to understand the fraud of forecast models that « influence » gov’t decisions to impose public health measures, please read this exchange between @FraserNelson & @GrahamMedley of the SAGE👇👇
Fraser Nelson
@FraserNelson
Hi Graham. I guess the question is why LSHTM did not (like JP Morgan) include a scenario of lower virulence - given that this is a very-plausible option that changes outlook massively. See below...
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
I am speechlessness!
פרופ' אייל שחר
@prof_shahar
Long-term projections.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Randy O'NeillCylinder
@bubblemx
Recently, I've been talking about temperatures and demographics. See here how we can use it to classify Germany into 2 patterns for Wave-Takeoffs: Ocean vs. Continental Climate. In a nutshell: Bavaria, Saxony, Thueringen will be first for flu-waves. service.destatis.de/DE/bevoelkerung/sterbefallzahlen_bund…
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Gompertz straight-line J(t) forecasts converge. Daily cases peak 12/25 at ~25,000 Omicron daily cases.
Christmas gift to world:
1) Shows 'expo-talk' like "doubles in 3 days" meaningless. Gompertz always slows.
2) Shows low 'O' lethality, CFR=0.26%.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Africa has daily Omicron cases with least daily deaths since May 2020. Need a week to get deaths/case.
The latest outbreak of Omicron daily cases starts near zero. It is beautifully Gompertz with J(t) becoming a dropping straight-line blue line).
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Tweet was sent in prematurely. Should have checked date & provided data.
I was wrong about the date. It is 23 February 2020.
Screen shots of 9 pages of the report are below.
All early reports at:
www.dropbox.com/s/vp4u2ae5yaswhk5/2. All_Michael_Levitt_2…
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
28 Feb. 2020
Invite me -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This email from head of NIH, biggest funder of world biomedical research, aims to discredit scientific analysis by top scientists (Harvard, Stanford, Oxford).
Surely protecting the vulnerable while minimizing collateral damage is worth consideration.
Could this email be fake?
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
New email dump showing Anthony Fauci and Francis Collins coordinating a propaganda campaign to attack the Great Barrington declaration last October. More coming soon so here's a teaser...
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Collins > Fauci
Hi Tony and Cliff,
…
the three fringe epidemiologists who met with the Secretary seems to be getting a lot of attention …
There needs to be a quick and devastating published take down of its premises. I don't see anything like that on line yet - is it underway? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
28 Feb. 2020
Invite me -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Why surprised?
Just means a location needs to reach the saturation level. NY State shows this clearly. One huge wave and little more.
Compare NY to California, Florida & Texas. All get to similar excess death as a percentage of natural death but with different time-courses. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You are so correct.
Many early outbreaks were singletons. Even though we had seen multiple outbreaks Korea in Feb. & Mar. 2020, did not appreciate multiple outbreaks would occur everywhere.
No way to predict how many except by saturation. NYC bad & almost saturated on one.
Enough is enough
@c_walters
To be fair, I think he’s been predicting the end of waves / outbreaks, rather than the overall pandemic.
Later work seeks to disentangle and hence understand overlapping peaks in separate but aggregated curves.
@MLevitt_NP2013 - your view would help to inform. 🙏🏼 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Hi Stefan, A nice article that is accessible only if you have PAID ACCESS.
Something as important as this should indeed be free & open. Can you post a PDF to dropbox?
As the author, you have that right although Elsevier would disagree with me.
Here is key figure.
Stefan Homburg
@SHomburg
🇬🇧Today I can share a FREE LINK from Elsevier to an article written by three colleagues and myself.
We show that the "Science" article which alleged that Germany's #lockdown was effective is fake science indeed. @FatEmperor @MLevitt_NP2013 1/2
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00163287210018… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
South Africa has daily Omicron cases with least daily deaths since May 2020. Need a week to get deaths/case.
The latest outbreak of Omicron daily cases starts near zero. It is beautifully Gompertz with J(t) becoming a dropping straight-line blue line).
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/16aCBny3OgS-G00VYD1xBkdQtx… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Great analysis. Has age profile changed?
Society is complex system with many connected parts. Disruption has far-reaching consequences leading to excess death.
Expected when spoke against lock-down in Spring 2020, governments now treat disruption despair with more disruption.
JOSE GEFAELL
@ChGefaell
There are many countries with the same "small" discrepancy between Excess deaths and Covid deaths..., but just since last July...
See 20 countries analysed in this presentation: www.dropbox.com/s/15yktjbvrn6zeje/AUSTRIA EXCESS DEATHS A… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sorry. Carelessness.
After 684 days, 1Feb20 COVID-19 study shows:
1) Logistics growth naive & wrong.
2) Change Fraction (f(t), Fig. 2,3) showed Gompertz growth & use of J(t)=ln[ln[f(t)]] (Fig.4 blue) to forecast slowing spread. x.com/MarkGerstein/status/1228271176511868929
github.com/csblab/novoCoronavirus-Analysis/commit/c4703a5…
Mike Nelson
@MikeNelsonth
At least get the title of the first graph correct. Jesus.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Please do not confuse flu with colds. Flu is truly terrible virus designed to avoid immune systems & mutate like crazy.
Still, neither colds not flu carry the black mark of death that COVID-19 has acquired.
Their return means COVID-19 is gone. Will society return to normal? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Still there for me.
The PDF I just downloaded is at: www.dropbox.com/s/a4vy808x4b2bs56/COVID-19 in The Netherl…
See Page 2 below. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
As COVID-19 restrictions are being imposed in UK, lets look at the 3 previous waves.
Case Fatality Ratio (CFR) seems to the dropping by about 4 to 8-times from one wave to the next:
Can there a fourth wave, when daily cases have been ~40K for 5 months?
What will the CFR be? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This is from three weeks ago. I should update it.
With proper age-adjustment, less than 11,000 excess since 1-Jan-2020.
This suggests that 15,000 excess death in one month is not reasonable. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“And? In contrast to other "scientists", Ioannadis has updated his data again and again and more or less confirmed his data. Apart from the fact that mutated viruses may become more contagious, but more harmless. But why facts ...”
Why indeed facts?
New age. Facts are too real. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
For German data, both deaths and population in age bands, use mortality.org
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Phil Kerpen
@kerpen
Florida influenza continues to track right along 2018-19. Rhino rising again.
www.floridahealth.gov/diseases-and-conditions/influenza/_… -
Michael Levitt reposted
Alexey Ziskin
@AlexeyZiskin
4 North Temperate countries in Europe with reliable statistics: France, Belgium, Germany, and Austria & their C19 death waves.👇
(Deaths = more reliable metric than case numbers; the latter depend a lot on testing volumes).
Do you notice a pattern?
Tell me it ain't seasonal! -
Michael Levitt reposted
Marc Girardot
@GirardotMarc
And variants are not a problem because of it.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
Kulvinder Kaur MD
@dockaurG
I’ve been saying this as a broken record for more than one year now.
Please repeat after me:
T-cells are our unsung heroes. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@nytimes & World seems to be waiting for the Britain’s Omicron outbreak. www.nytimes.com/live/2021/12/10/world/covid-omicron-vaccines
Here is our open Google Sheet for UK showing it’s start. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gQoaSoN1-QwwcuWfiu447SrHp…
At this early stage Gompertz J(t) forecasting is not expected to work.
Note very high background. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@nytimes & World seems to be waiting for the Britain’s Omicron outbreak. www.nytimes.com/live/2021/12/10/world/covid-omicron-vaccines
Here is our open Google Sheet for UK showing it’s start. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gQoaSoN1-QwwcuWfiu447SrHp…
At this early stage Gompertz J(t) forecasting is not expected to work.
Note very high background. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Really high-quality analysis of excess death.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks.
john digregorio
@digregjf
Excess deaths in 2020 relative to previous 3 year means.
-
Michael Levitt reposted
francesco zonta
@Cescoxonta
Random networks produce logistic outbreaks, similar to SIR models
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Liked your 1st paragraph “going on to reveal how single-minded reliance on the PC test instead of sound clinical judgement is resulting in utterly meaningless clinical management of cases, COVID or otherwise.”
Just like common sense in my 28/2/20 report distributed 680 days ago. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Spain is still 11 days from Daily Cases peak on 12/17/21. This is with 14 day fit to linearly dropping Gompertz J(t). Data is very noisy by J(t) looks steady.
Follow this yourself with open link: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Sw8z3gPDCmNuFjvCB1fdPDdUL…
Ratón Perezoso
@Tumaten
And the same for Spain?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Yes, the properly centered 7-day moving average on the k-th day is exactly the same as the rolling-7 day average to the (k+3)-rd day. Still every one uses the rolling-average.
In any case, defining the peak to within 3 days is probably impossible & also unnecessary.
Josephson
@Josephs42921408
If I plot the properly centered 7-day moving average (so including 3 days front and back), the actual peak in PCR+ seems to have occurred even a bit earlier, as early as November 25.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
This really interesting.
Seems vaccination, social distancing, masks and track & trace in a controlled environment do not prevent COVID-19 infection of fit, young people at a rate of 100/3700 (~3%).
How could the same measures have eliminated influenza world-wide? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
How would you organize this? Seems open is best.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much.
john digregorio
@digregjf
Here are the excess deaths in 2020 (ED) relative to previous 5 year means by age group. For working age people death rates starting increasing ~2012 (deaths of despair). For 25-64 ages, ED is a combination of covid and covid restrictions (CR).
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
What is meant by “UCoD” and “MCoD”
Professor Hugh Akston
@ProfessorAkston
@USMortality @MLevitt_NP2013
I have week 47 ACM excess over a r^2=0.87 seasonal model at ~850K since 1/1/20. ~470K in 2020.
Non-CV UCoD excess contributing ~100K to that.
Note increases in non-Natural/non-CV CoD as well younger groups.
The 921K CV must be MCoD?
@PRider1980
US Mortality
@USMortality
Good point Michael, so CDC estimate 921k Covid deaths until 9/21.
2020: +411,908
2021: +333,338
Total: 745,246 -> That's a discrepancy of 176k.
Adding the avg 37.5k flu deaths for two seasons that are in the baseline, it remains 100k deaths.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben, You have thought very carefully about death reporting delays and impute to correct for it.
How does the total USA age-adjusted all-cause excess death from 1-Jan-2020 compare with the CDC estimate of 921,000 deaths? I assume these are COVID-19 deaths?
US Mortality
@USMortality
All details here:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1K7BJHIIZb4mFT1ouuKtdWYDRw… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks. Estimate with & without age adjustment. Latest data excess for 2020 + 2021 (wk39 9/19):
643k Age-adjusted
891k Not age-adjusted
Difference is 152k so CDC not age-adjusting.
Age-adjustment raises expected deaths as more older people.
Should compare numbers more fully.
US Mortality
@USMortality
Good point Michael, so CDC estimate 921k Covid deaths until 9/21.
2020: +411,908
2021: +333,338
Total: 745,246 -> That's a discrepancy of 176k.
Adding the avg 37.5k flu deaths for two seasons that are in the baseline, it remains 100k deaths.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben, You have thought very carefully about death reporting delays and impute to correct for it.
How does the total USA age-adjusted all-cause excess death from 1-Jan-2020 compare with the CDC estimate of 921,000 deaths? I assume these are COVID-19 deaths?
US Mortality
@USMortality
All details here:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1K7BJHIIZb4mFT1ouuKtdWYDRw… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. This seems very reasonable. Your historical analysis puts things nicely into perspective.
Can you please recalculate with 3 rather than 5 reference years such so 2020 vs. 2017-2019?
What do you find for the under 65 year olds historically going back to 1980?
john digregorio
@digregjf
2020 vs 2015-2019:
ages 0-24: no excess deaths (ED)
25-64: was trending up before covid and covid response made it worse. Hard to deconvolute covid from covid restrictions
65+: ED~350K
But compared to 2002-06 baseline there were no ED in 2020. No panic in 2002-06 or other years. -
Michael Levitt reposted
john digregorio
@digregjf
2020 vs 2015-2019:
ages 0-24: no excess deaths (ED)
25-64: was trending up before covid and covid response made it worse. Hard to deconvolute covid from covid restrictions
65+: ED~350K
But compared to 2002-06 baseline there were no ED in 2020. No panic in 2002-06 or other years. -
Michael Levitt reposted
Andrew Bostom, MD, MS
@andrewbostom
Britain’s drinking deaths rose at record rate in pandemic: 8,974 deaths from alcohol specific causes registered in the 12 month period, up from 7,565 deaths in 2019 – the highest year-on-year increase since the data series began in 2001.
www.theguardian.com/society/2021/dec/07/britains-drinking… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Reminded of this from July 2020.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. More people need to see what you posted. “Witness 17-week perfect Antarctic quarantine—someone still contracted a coronavirus!! jstor.org/stable/3862013”. So very hard to keep a virus from getting to its target.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Sure. Looks past the peak.
Easy to do yourself: just update date each dat using
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ei43voxvIZnpDnZFHg4enG83V…
m.sonnenberg
@MsonnenbergM
do you have one for the netherlands as well?
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Here is the forecast using latest data. Extended to use most recent 14 days. Really seems that daily cases have peaked and are descending in Germany.
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1OlDua0dDixjNW8owjxQUkbiA7…
Good news in time for Christmas.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ray, thanks so much.
I just do rolling 7-day smoothing. What you do is much better but my bandwidth is limited
This could all be done much better in an atmosphere of collaboration.
I am sure the are people much better able to extrapolate a straight line than. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ray, thanks so much.
I just do rolling 7-day smoothing. What you do is much better but my bandwidth is limited
This could all be done much better in an atmosphere of collaboration.
I am sure the are people much better able to extrapolate a straight line than. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
You have a good point there. Let us wait a few days and see.
It you care too follow along here is the link to the open Google Sheet
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19AmcuGLZlUi5wWrDbmgdDx52o…
Craig Hartsough
@CraigHartsough
Yesterday you forecast deaths peaking at 500 around mid-Jan. Now predicting 400, two weeks sooner.
This is due to running your model at the end of the weekend when there is a reporting dip (see light green line). Your forecast will shift higher/later again in a few days. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Germany’s reported COVID-19 cases have peaked at long last. Deaths peaking 12/31.
Expected but nice to see the blue J(t) line drop below the threshold indicated by the magenta horizontal line.
The Gompertz log(Exponential Growth Rate) demonstrates yet again intrinsic slowing.
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Open Google Sheets ML4.5 improved:
ML4.5 Germany Covid19 Cases Gompertz Curve [2.0.0] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19AmcuGLZlUi5wWrDbmgdDx52o… ML4.5 Germany Covid19 Deaths Gompertz Curve [2.0.0] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1WLP-wat-5wvLGXfljewI0XytW…
Switzerland ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Onzz3Vl23GLOFqbloPsNWwNQu…
Belgium ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/144nK3__zxqoKhgp3JVlW17DYU… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Ben, You have thought very carefully about death reporting delays and impute to correct for it.
How does the total USA age-adjusted all-cause excess death from 1-Jan-2020 compare with the CDC estimate of 921,000 deaths? I assume these are COVID-19 deaths?
US Mortality
@USMortality
All details here:
docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1K7BJHIIZb4mFT1ouuKtdWYDRw… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Very interesting.
Linear trend means R(t)=1 & that COVID-19 is endemic in the USA.
It means that there is a constant background of daily cases added each day. This is what we subtract in our forecasting.
There are more US infected than confirmed cases.
Is the ratio fixed?
US Mortality
@USMortality
CDC estimates about 147M COVID-19 infections until 9/2021. I used the Wayback Machine, to map historic estimates! Interesting, that their estimate appears to be following a rather linear trend!
#covid #covid19 #corona #coronavirus -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Let us wait & see. If Omicron is less infectious it will be irrelevant and we are stuck with the Delta variant that has been with us since April 2021.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
“Moreover, most patients she had seen did not lose their sense of taste & smell, & had only a slight cough”
www.nytimes.com/article/omicron-coronavirus-variant.html
Given difficulty predicting biological function from protein sequence, seems better to focus on symptoms.
Being optimistic is good for immunity!
sara olsen
@smolsen
What if - as a possible optimistic scenario - Omicron saves us?
Is mild enough to be no big deal, and proliferates to knock out other variants. We all get it, and then it peters out. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
More COVID-19 forecasts by Gompertz J(t).
Thanks to Twitter for pressure to keep on learning & improving.
France ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ei43voxvIZnpDnZFHg4enG83V… Netherlands ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Ei43voxvIZnpDnZFHg4enG83V… Spain ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Sw8z3gPDCmNuFjvCB1fdPDdUL… Italy ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1OBheaJl9MGjKhIp1t6XrvRdMk… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Open Google Sheets ML4.5 improved:
ML4.5 Germany Covid19 Cases Gompertz Curve [2.0.0] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/19AmcuGLZlUi5wWrDbmgdDx52o… ML4.5 Germany Covid19 Deaths Gompertz Curve [2.0.0] docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1WLP-wat-5wvLGXfljewI0XytW…
Switzerland ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Onzz3Vl23GLOFqbloPsNWwNQu…
Belgium ML4.5 docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/144nK3__zxqoKhgp3JVlW17DYU… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All 424 pages of my Media Tweets (with graphs) from 22 April to 14 November 2021 are available in one PDF file at:
www.dropbox.com/s/2p03o6x4jazb7ge/Michael_Levitt_Media_Tw…
Nothing has been deleted or edited.
Made this to make sure a large body of original scientific work is preserved and easily accessible. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Most important result from 654 days of nonstop COVID-19 data analysis.
Explains previous focus on Gompertz function: all early outbreaks un-obscured by overlap of outbreaks show self-limited Gompertz growth due to the social contact pattern.
Francesco Zonta is super-star. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Not easy to estimate burden of death from influenza.
1) No wide-spread testing for flu as there is for COVID.
2) Flu deaths that occur every winter are expected & so not part of excess death.
Is 5% death deficit seen when no flu or COVID indicative of real level of flu death? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Joshua Angrist @metrics52 is a super-well deserving newly-minted Nobel Laureate.
So lucky he taught me about excess death & COVID-19 from Apr. to Oct. 2020.
The 10 December award ceremony in Stockholm is exhausting, but I really hope COVID19 allows it to happen normally in 2021 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Such welcome news from New Zealand. www.nytimes.com/live/2021/10/04/world/covid-delta-variant…
Who will be next to realize that we need to live with the virus and not loose everything from our desire to control it. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Must be studied by all concerned with COVID-19. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1VR3yFG7l1Mhtr9e5Wjc_dipy9…
The latest wave in the USA shows how J(t), the log exponential growth factor drops linearly since early July.
It proves yet again what I say since Apr-2020: COVID-19 spread is SELF-LIMITED & Gompertz. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Need advice on good Python books & courses.
Learned FORTRAN from the IBM FORTRAN II manual in 1967; learned C from Kernighan & Ritchie in 1980; learned Perl from my postdocs @MarkGerstein & Steven Brenner in 1995; learned Excel from @john_walkenbach in 2010.
Thanks🙏 -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
All-cause death in Iceland still shows no excess. Do you think that there will eventually be noticeable excess deaths from this latest wave of cases?
Do you think that Sweden will also be hit with a Delta wave? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The Delta Variant is scary. Could it be semiotics & not biology?
(1) Delta means difference or change.
(2) The letter Delta shows "spreading" as in a river delta.
(3) The Delta Force, 1st Special Forces Operational Detachment, is scary. Movie too.
Waiting for Epsilon Variant. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
www.theguardian.com/society/2021/jun/18/hospitals-underto… reports that a lot of medical treatment did not happen in UK.
If we extrapolate to US population, almost 8 million missed operations? Seems too high? -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Senior scientist work hard & write hundreds of papers to earn recognition.
Social media & preprint servers are turning a model successful for hundreds of years up-side-down.
Compare data reported by Google Scholar before dismissing giants like John Ioannidis. Shame on MIT. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Alexey, you are totally correct.
The large excess death of the under 65 year olds in Canada (3656) is exceptional especially when compared to the small value for over 65 year olds (2726).
Normally, under 65 year olds much smaller than over.
This needs to be double-checked. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Nothing to do with Covid19 but grandstanding & scientific controversy all the same.
www.nytimes.com/2021/03/23/science/astronomy-oumuamua-com… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Certainly have to agree. Thanks for Classic Graphic!!
Are the numbers hospitalized dropping as well?
This would be expected when the there are fewer elderly patients being admitted.
Average age would also drop if more younger patients were admitted & that would be bad.
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
When lockdown is getting me down, I like to look at Israeli hospital data
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Have been vaccinated with the Pfizer mRNA (worked on RNA structure in 1969). Also flu and pneumonia. No side effects for me or my mother (age 105).
Enough people have been vaccinated to show the risk is way less than a week of normal death risk for me at 73 (0.06% or 1/1500). -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Genius post by Tommy Lennhamn, @TLennhamn is most important item I have read.
Shows we were all wrong about Covid19’s real burden death.
Justifies Twitter for me. DO READ:
softwaredevelopmentperestroika.wordpress.com/2021/01/15/f… Final Report on Swedish Mortality 2020, Anno Covidius ...
#covid19 #covid19sweden -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Is SARS-CoV-2 mutating to be less lethal? @TheLancet says so www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2…. Was told this happens by the virologist friends I still had in March. It is what coronavirus viruses do when they have enough cycles of reproduction.
Lock down impedes this natural weakening. -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
Thanks so much. More people need to see what you posted. “Witness 17-week perfect Antarctic quarantine—someone still contracted a coronavirus!! jstor.org/stable/3862013”. So very hard to keep a virus from getting to its target.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
My thanks to Enrique and Alice &the others. This was a really terrific encounter that is available for all at vimeo.com/433350887/33bbbe4090. I expect Lindau @lindaunobel will keep it all online and open. This will be seen as a watershed in the future of science & its communication.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
People ask me to explain why COVID19 never grows exponentially (youtu.be/8aHrx68IT7o). This a common phenomenon shown by the raw data in many locations. I suspect COVID19 cannot grow exponentially is because an infected individual has a hard time finding people to infect.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
COVID19 is a contrast agent like that used in microscopy. It emphasizes and brings into sharp focus the features of our World that were always there. Not a pretty sight. We urgently need better AI so next time we can say “Siri, Alexa, Google: Should I panic?” & believe the reply.
-
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
The analysis that follows in a team effort based on the 14Mar20 report involving Patrick Tam (Hong Kong), Francesco Zonta (Shanghaitech), Frédéric Poitevin, João Rodrigues, Fatima Pardo-Avila and Andrea Scaiewicz (all Stanford).
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It is also three weeks since my optimistic interviews in the Calcalist www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3800632,00.html
and LA Times www.latimes.com/science/story/2020-03-22/coronavirus-outb… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
It is also three weeks since my optimistic interviews in the Calcalist www.calcalistech.com/ctech/articles/0,7340,L-3800632,00.html
and LA Times www.latimes.com/science/story/2020-03-22/coronavirus-outb… -
Michael Levitt
@MLevitt_NP2013
@NYCMayorsOffice Thanks to all who got us complete data on NYC cases & deaths. Our global team (Shanghai, Hong Kong, Israel, Sweden, Holland, Stanford) is hard at work 24/7. Follow us.




























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































