Young men in the midterms rejected MAGA 2.0 more dramatically than I've ever seen any major demographic turn against a group that had supposedly won them for life.
I mean, these numbers are insane! I've never seen anything like this??
Musa al-Gharbi
Musa al-Gharbi is an American sociologist. He is an assistant professor in the School of Communication and Journalism at Stony Brook University. He was the communications director of Heterodox Academy from 2016 to 2020. More on Wikipedia
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
I am glad everyone is having a nice time with the Video Game but the only acceptable adult male hobbies are Fishing and Gun and Book, sorry.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Broockman
@dbroockman
Many are saying...
Spooky Charlotte Swasey
@charlotteeffect
From Broockman and Kalla today- issue positions matter, and have a larger effects than messaging. They're arguing that party positioning matters even more than candidate positions
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Check out the full essay here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/war-brings-tragedy-peace-brin…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The work of a soldier is, what @EyalPress described as "dirty work" : necessary but morally fraught and often misunderstood, underappreciated and alienating: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/224251325/dirty-hands-or-dead…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Since the "War on Terror" wound down, families moved away, brain drain accelerated, birth rates declined, the population aged and grew more homogenous, the tax base shrank: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/224251325/a-tale-of-two-cities
The "Mall at Sierra Vista" is now empty storefronts and niche local attractions. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The "war on terror" brought tragedy to Southern Arizona: hundreds were killed, many more wounded. But the end of this campaign brought a different kind of pain and suffering to the community: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/224251325/the-high-cost-of-peace
The once-vital main street is filled with boarded up shops. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
According to our political leaders, al-Qaeda attacked America on September 11th because they resented our freedoms. These same leaders promptly set out to compromise or curtail those freedoms in the name of fighting said terrorists: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/war-brings-tragedy-peace-brin…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For Veteran's Day, I released a note from the field exploring how my home town has been devastated by the "War on Terror" winding down. 🧵
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jon Green
@_Jon_Green
big update to this working paper: new data, new (simpler!) methods, similar story: the empirical literature on Christian nationalism has measured something interesting, but probably not the niche ideology that it's worried about at the elite level
osf.io/wbdut/files/vbky9 -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For Veteran's Day, I released a note from the field exploring how my home town has been devastated by the "War on Terror" winding down. 🧵
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
According to our political leaders, al-Qaeda attacked America on September 11th because they resented our freedoms. These same leaders promptly set out to compromise or curtail those freedoms in the name of fighting said terrorists: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/war-brings-tragedy-peace-brin…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The "war on terror" brought tragedy to Southern Arizona: hundreds were killed, many more wounded. But the end of this campaign brought a different kind of pain and suffering to the community: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/224251325/the-high-cost-of-peace
The once-vital main street is filled with boarded up shops.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Since the "War on Terror" wound down, families moved away, brain drain accelerated, birth rates declined, the population aged and grew more homogenous, the tax base shrank: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/224251325/a-tale-of-two-cities
The "Mall at Sierra Vista" is now empty storefronts and niche local attractions.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The work of a soldier is, what @EyalPress described as "dirty work" : necessary but morally fraught and often misunderstood, underappreciated and alienating: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/224251325/dirty-hands-or-dead…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Check out the full essay here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/war-brings-tragedy-peace-brin…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Many more reflections on canvassing, politics, the 2026 election and more in the full piece, available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
There were systematic differences in how people responded to canvassers and what voters cared about depending on their background and appearance. But almost everyone was concerned about cost of living. Almost everyone hated the Iran war: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/who-specifically-ca…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Data analytics has transformed canvassing. Operatives have insane amounts of data at their fingertips. Nonetheless, there is something wild/ messy/ unpredictable about human interaction. You never know what's going to happen when folks open the door: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/canvassing-is-like-…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Mobilization is more doable than persuasion. But for either, it's much more effective to let people be heard and seen and to interact with a real person in the flesh. Canvassing is one of the better campaign strategies at moving the meter: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/value-added
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
There are many respects in which canvassing is very difficult and unpleasant work. But there was also something really beautiful about it. It's mostly people rejecting and ignoring you. But that's how it is with lots of important stuff: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/but-somebodys-got-t…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I'm living and working in S. Arizona right now to get my 2nd book done. A big part of the project is to talk to regular people about moral, political and social issues. There are folks doing that at scale. I was able to embed myself in a campaign: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/dispatch-from-the-f…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Usually, I do a deep post-election dive on the stats and trends and how they correlate with popular narratives. This year, I decided to go a different direction b/c I don't have a lot to add to what I've already said: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For the last few weeks, I've been shadowing political canvassers in a swing state. It revealed a lot about the present moment and the practical and logistical sides of politics. In the wake of the election, I've written out some thoughts for Symbolic Capital(ism). 🧵
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Greg Berman
@GregBerman50
My latest piece, reflecting on the rise of wokeness and the work of @Musa_alGharbi, is currently featured on the excellent Eminent Americans Substack. Thanks to @dan_oppenheimer who also hosts one of my favorite podcasts.
danieloppenheimer.substack.com/p/the-sage-of-stony-brook -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
credit where it is due — Douthat did a great job pressing Trump on his corruption
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Fun panel with @Tyler_A_Harper and Freddie De Boer on free speech and the left organized by @StrangelEdweird for the recent @TheFIREorg Soapbox conference
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Incredible content. It’s the wrong answer but an honest one.
Eric Daugherty
@EricLDaugh
🚨 Q: You're entering the next life [before God], all you have to do to enter paradise is feel love and forgiveness for James Comey, Nancy Pelosi, etc...can you do it?
TRUMP: Then I wouldn't be real, would I? The easy answer is, yes, I could forgive. They are extremely dishonest people, bad people, I love our country far more...the answer is no. I want to be honest.
Q: In judgement before God?
TRUMP: I do hate some of my enemies. Look what they put me through.
REPORTER: You had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you can't find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies?
TRUMP: All I have to do is say yes, I can. Can I be honest? I probably cannot do that. Because I do hate some of my enemies — and I always will.
Never heard Trump get asked such a deep question like that before.
He COULD just say "yes" and get out of the question, but he didn't
One thing you have to admit is this man is brutally honest.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Abdallah Fayyad
@abdallah_fayyad
Must’ve taken a lot of effort to get to the bottom of this
The Free Press
@TheFP
CORRECTION: This post and opinion video states that Abdul El-Sayed gave his acceptance speech in Arabic. That’s not accurate. In fact, he said a few phrases in Arabic, but the majority of his speech was in English. The Free Press regrets the error.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Greg Berman
@GregBerman50
A few thoughts about wokeness sparked by reading Musa al-Gharbi gregberman.substack.com/p/the-foibles-of-the-educated-eli…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
I’m grateful to Matt Yglesias for his tireless, Sisyphean work in repeatedly emphasizing obviously true points to people who have a strong vested interest in never, ever admitting that what he’s saying is accurate.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
The reason I harp on this relative performance stuff is that we have top political consultants and major journalists telling the world that we need to copy one specific candidate to learn how to persuade young men, but young men swung more in AK, IA, KS, MS, NC, OH, and TX!
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Richard V. Reeves
@RichardvReeves
This is a real issue, glad to see it covered in @TheAtlantic
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
Young boys are being discouraged from getting into reading—and it’s because more books are missing one key element, @sophiah_n reports: www.theatlantic.com/culture/2026/11/middle-grade-reading-…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Azim Shariff
@azimshariff
Victims can be villains. Villains can be victims. But our minds resist seeing people as both.
@paulbloomatyale & I explore our moral psychology and its allergy to moral nuance in this new piece in the @NewYorker:
www.newyorker.com/culture/open-questions/whos-the-real-vi… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Bhaskar Sunkara
@sunraysunray
I love the DSA vs. CPC narrative. But otherwise, DSA sample small and Congressional candidates were running in strong blue districts with people angry about Trump and motivated to vote. We still have a lot of work to do in more rural areas to make socialists viable nationwide.
G Elliott Morris
@gelliottmorris
Extreme levels of cope happening online in how centrists are responding to DSA candidates being electoral overperformers. This invalidates almost all of their predictions from 2024-2025 “WAR” debates
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Eric Levitz
@EricLevitz
El-Sayed may not be an exceptional electoral performer, but he is unusually intelligent for a senator
Peter Daou
@peterdaou
I've been in politics for a quarter century. It's hard to express how staggering it is to see a conversation like this on corporate US media. The Morning Joe panel gobsmacked by the directness of @AbdulElSayed's points.
(clip via @DropSiteNews)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For the last few weeks, I've been shadowing political canvassers in a swing state. It revealed a lot about the present moment and the practical and logistical sides of politics. In the wake of the election, I've written out some thoughts for Symbolic Capital(ism). 🧵
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Usually, I do a deep post-election dive on the stats and trends and how they correlate with popular narratives. This year, I decided to go a different direction b/c I don't have a lot to add to what I've already said: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I'm living and working in S. Arizona right now to get my 2nd book done. A big part of the project is to talk to regular people about moral, political and social issues. There are folks doing that at scale. I was able to embed myself in a campaign: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/dispatch-from-the-f…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
There are many respects in which canvassing is very difficult and unpleasant work. But there was also something really beautiful about it. It's mostly people rejecting and ignoring you. But that's how it is with lots of important stuff: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/but-somebodys-got-t…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Mobilization is more doable than persuasion. But for either, it's much more effective to let people be heard and seen and to interact with a real person in the flesh. Canvassing is one of the better campaign strategies at moving the meter: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/value-added
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Data analytics has transformed canvassing. Operatives have insane amounts of data at their fingertips. Nonetheless, there is something wild/ messy/ unpredictable about human interaction. You never know what's going to happen when folks open the door: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/canvassing-is-like-…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
There were systematic differences in how people responded to canvassers and what voters cared about depending on their background and appearance. But almost everyone was concerned about cost of living. Almost everyone hated the Iran war: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/223404767/who-specifically-ca…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Many more reflections on canvassing, politics, the 2026 election and more in the full piece, available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Michael Strong
@flowidealism
Wow, a pretty damning article with diverse lines of evidence.
Jeremy Wayne Tate
@JeremyTate41
Most people do not realize just how easy the AP exams have gotten. They are not college level.
Why/how have they become so easy? What's going on?
This might shock you... A brutal new piece in Education Next just dropped, saying the decline in rigor of the AP in the last two decades is, in large part, because the content has been GUTTED. For example:
— AP Biology cut 40% of its material
— Required lines from the Aeneid in AP Latin halved
— Spanish Lit reading list cut from 56 works to 38
Then the questions themselves have become absurdly easier. Readability measures show English passages have fallen multiple grade levels, and some now include footnotes defining basic words...
A 2025 AP English prompt included footnote definitions for words like "optimism" and "pessimism."
At the same time, scoring was recalibrated so that more students pass: guessing penalties disappeared, rubrics grew more generous, readers were told to give students the benefit of the doubt, etc. — "no one at College Board had any incentive to maintain rigor."
College professors are now seeing students arrive with AP credit who lack basic content knowledge and writing ability. The College Board insists the exams have not become easier, but everybody familiar with them knows they've become an absolute joke.
Advanced Placement is no longer advanced. This is not college level.
It must be replaced. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Pablo Malo
@pitiklinov
El sociólogo Musa al-Gharbi volvió a su pueblo natal, Sierra Vista (Arizona), para escribir su próximo libro y se infiltró como voluntario en la campaña demócrata de Joanna Mendoza para el Distrito 6 del Congreso. Lo hizo como observación participante (porque los operativos no podían hablar con periodistas). El objetivo era ver de cerca cómo se hace el “canvassing” (el puerta a puerta) en una zona tradicionalmente republicana que se había vuelto competitiva. Un extracto:
“En realidad, es extremadamente difícil cambiar la opinión de los demás. Hay mucha investigación que muestra que el efecto neto de la propaganda y el contacto político a la hora de cambiar las preferencias de la gente es, básicamente, cero. Todos los volantes, las llamadas, los anuncios de televisión, radio e internet, y el canvassing (puerta a puerta)… no consiguen que nadie cambie de bando.”
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"it’s extremely hard to change others’ minds...the net effect of political outreach on flipping political preferences is, basically, zero. All the mailers, the calls, the...ads, the canvassing – they don’t lead anyone to change their allegiances." musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Excellent talk from Shamus Khan at LSE (channeling Nisbet) on sociology’s neglected conservative tradition. Themes of legitimate hierarchy, nature, community, and tradition are central to society, and used to be central to sociology as well. They now represent some pretty glaring blind spots in the discipline. www.youtube.com/live/NPAJrnai_3A?is=pymARJAhbAo0axXk
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
When Al-Jazeera America closed (I was a columnist there), I moved over to Salon, working with @davedaley3, who was super rad. He was a really great editor who cultivated lots of great voices and elevated my own work and others'.
Incidentally, it was @ggreenwald's important national security/ foreign policy reporting at Salon that led me to want to write for them too. When I thought of who would be a good fit for my work at the time, Salon came to mind because of Glenn. And Salon *was* a great fit thanks to Dave and his team.
After the 2016 election and the reorganization that followed, I decided to freelance rather than stick around in the more orthodox and partisan outlet the remaining leaders were trying to create. Salon has changed a lot since I wrote for them. But this is, nonetheless, really sad to see.
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
Salon was the first media outlet that ever employed me. They gave me full editorial independence -- the right to upload my articles and columns with no editorial interference -- and, unlike others, always honored it.
I won't comment on what they became, but David Talbot's creation was one of the pioneers of what became independent online media. RIP
Salon
@Salon
Today, after 31 years, we are saddened to announce that Salon is ceasing publication. It has been an extraordinary privilege. www.salon.com/2026/11/05/goodbye-from-salon/
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
AIPAC picked a huge, decade long fight with Democrats not over Israel per se but over Iran, got what they wanted out of Trump, voters hated it, and now J.D. Vance is throwing them under the bus.
www.slowboring.com/p/its-so-over-for-aipac -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Greg Berman
@GregBerman50
My new series Thinkers Who Matter looks at writers who have particularly insightful things to say about the state of contemporary America. First up: Musa al-Gharbi, author of We Have Never Been Woke.
The Foibles of the Educated Elite gregberman.substack.com/p/the-foibles-of-the-educated-eli… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
The Giving Review
@GivingReview
gregberman.substack.com/p/the-foibles-of-the-educated-elite
@GregBerman50 begins his Thinkers Who Matter series by highlighting work of @Musa_alGharbi …
“Al-Gharbi believes that the institutions where symbolic professionals predominate—universities, nonprofits, law firms, media corporations, etc.—have changed in some important ways in recent years,” Berman writes. “Specifically, a complicated and previously obscure set of beliefs about social justice, marked by an intense focus on issues of identity, diversity, and privilege, has become part of the lingua franca in these spaces. Many have referred to this phenomenon as the ‘Great Awokening.’ …
“[T]here is little doubt that we are living through precarious times,” Berman concludes. “Politics seems to have become unmoored from the traditional work of politics—campaigns, lobbying, legislative horse-trading. By the logic of “the personal is political,” almost everything can take on a political dimension—the media we consume, the stores we frequent, the food we eat, etc.
“Nothing is immune from this line of thinking. This creates a real dilemma for institutions — the evidence suggests that politicized institutions tend to be distrusted institutions. Al-Gharbi’s ultimate message is a cautionary one: ‘When symbolic capitalists, our institutions and our outputs grow especially political, the main thing we actually achieve is backlash against ‘our’ causes, organizations and institutions.’” -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Paul Bowes
@PaulBowes17
On normie frustration with the political class and the defiant optimism that makes everything happen
Musa al-Gharbi musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"it’s extremely hard to change others’ minds...the net effect of political outreach on flipping political preferences is, basically, zero. All the mailers, the calls, the...ads, the canvassing – they don’t lead anyone to change their allegiances." musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"ordinary people are not gullible rubes. The constituents most likely to consume and internalize propaganda are the same narrow and idiosyncratic slice that produces it: 'us' (highly-educated and cognitively sophisticated white-collar professionals)." musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/some-reflections-on-shadowing…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
I am 100% Team Nate in this beef. It’s *obvious* to anyone paying attention that the betting markets just moved over time towards the models. That’s the info they were working off of! They didn’t “discover” anything
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Give me a break, the polls and models provided the direction in contast to vibes and dumb insiders. And yes it's good that traders were smart enough to trust them. But the better election models were more confident about the outcome than the markets and got there more quickly.
Tarek Mansour
@mansourtarek_
Last night, the power to decide what America sees changed hands.
I have spent a ton of time in DC over the last few months. The elites were certain the markets were off. I heard many variants of “no chance markets are right about X” and “I’ve been in politics for a decade. ‘These people’ don’t really know much.”
Last night, ‘these people’ beat the elites.
Prediction market favorites won 479 of the first 487 races. That’s 98%.
The elites live in a bubble. They theorize, write, ideate, and mistake credentials for an understanding of lives they’ve never lived. They don’t see and feel what the everyday man, on the ground, sees and feels.
Knowledge is not exclusive to the elites but scattered across millions of people.
Someone knows their hometown better than any national pundit. Someone has followed a local race passionately for months. Someone has followed a local race dispassionately for months. Someone notices a shift in their community before it makes the headlines. Someone is shaped by an incident at work. Someone is shaped by what’s getting harder or easier for their families.
Each holds a piece of the picture that no expert can see in full.
And for the longest time, that knowledge had no way to reach the rest of the world.
For generations, election night meant turning on the TV and waiting for a handful of people to tell you what happened.
Prediction markets change that.
You don't need a title, a large following, or an editor to publish you. All you need is a perspective and the conviction to back it.
That changes who holds power over information.
Anyone can see the market. Anyone can contribute to it. Anyone can question it. No title gives you the final word. No gatekeepers can filter your view.
Sometimes the signal can be wrong. But anyone can challenge the consensus and improve it.
And when people consolidate their knowledge together, something remarkable happens: millions of individual perspectives become a signal that we all can learn from.
Over the last few months, the people showed up on Kalshi to tell the world what they were going to do.
Last night, the megaphone was passed to them. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jack
@tracewoodgrains
Vance: throwing Trump under the bus like a rat fleeing a sinking ship before vote counting has even concluded
Musk: suddenly laser-focused on tech and his company products, with political commentary nowhere to be found
Nature is healing
JD Vance
@JDVance
One of the things the data analysts on our side obsessed over was "composition"—whether the electorate looked close enough to 2024 for Republicans to win. And despite polls that showed a Democrat blowout, the data kept on telling us the same story: in some states turnout was merely OK, in other states it was downright amazing, and in no state was it catastrophic. There was a genuine sense of optimism on our team: our people were showing up.
So, I asked the smartest data guy I know, does that mean we're going to shock the world? "No," he told me. "We might do better than the polls suggest. But the data is telling us that a lot of Trump/Vance 2024 voters are pissed and planning to vote for the other guys. Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us."
Well, that looks prophetic now. Our voters did show up. In Florida, for example, the electorate was 9 points more Republican than Democrat, just a couple points worse than 2024. Undoubtedly there were places we could have done better on turnout. But the main problem is not turnout. The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.
There will be a lot of infighting and arguing over what happened and why that is. One of the pollsters I really respect told me that our economic messaging wasn’t sharp enough down the stretch. I’m sure that’s true.
But the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone.
Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were:
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to Israel
Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. This is according to a pollster who nailed the results. While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. (She’s also a great person.)
In the next few months, there's going to be a lot of gaslighting. Expect to hear any number of establishment politicians say the solution to our woes is amnesty. I'm open to the idea that we should change enforcement—by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labor, for instance. But anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you.
The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night.
If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest.
But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.
I remain hopeful about our country. To the people who are pissed off and want to say, “I told you so”: you’re right, you did tell us so. Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview. To the people who are just pissed at the results, you should be. Let’s take that anger and get back to the work of saving our country. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Patrick Ruffini
@PatrickRuffini
The swings tonight among groups that swung right in 2024.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Ashley makes the main point here but I also find the theory that foundation-funded NGOs are uniquely closer to the people than other kinds of organizations to be a little bizarre — they’re like a genuine zero accountability zone.
Ashley Schapitl
@AshleySchapitl
I was told that the next administration was going to be staffed with qualified technocrats after years of giving top jobs to unqualified loyalists, but it appears that the next administration is setting up an apparatus to “train” unqualified loyalists to work in the government??
Michael Schaffer
@michaelschaffer
Pretty good scoop from @jackiepeiser: Major philanthropic foundation is shopping a $2k fund that would fund @Janeese4DC transition, train appointees, and bankroll the nonprofits whose leaders it imagines might get top jobs. dc.citycast.fm/dc-politics/washington-community-foundatio…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
noah kulwin
@nkulw
Wrong call! Hilariously wrong call. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/30/opinion/you-can-see-everything…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Nico Perrino
@NicoPerrino
Next week, about 550 free speech advocates and thought leaders will descend on Philadelphia for @TheFIREorg's first-ever Soapbox conference.
Believe it or not, in FIRE's 27-year history, we've never hosted a general-audience free speech conference. We've hosted student and faculty conferences, but nothing like this. We figured the 250th anniversary of American independence was as fitting a time as any to give it a try.
We had no idea what to expect. Would anyone buy tickets? Conference experts told us most tickets are sold in the weeks leading up to an event. Instead, we sold out two months in advance!
America's free speech movement is growing, and its members are eager to meet one another.
I'll deliver the opening keynote, "The Fight for Free Speech," a nod to the title of the ACLU's first annual report in 1921. The talk will summarize the story I tell in my forthcoming book: how civil libertarians fought to make the promise of the First Amendment a reality.
Other speakers include @nickgillespie, @LarryLessig, @prestonjbyrne, @ENBrown, @CaseyMattox_, @chrisbest, @RosenJeffrey, @FreeRangeKids, @sapinker, @Musa_alGharbi, @marcorandazza, @AdamThierer, @DavidAFrench, @whignewtons, the @wethefifth guys, @ishapiro, @noam_dworman, @JohnHMcWhorter, @mtaibbi, and many, many more.
I can't wait to see you all next week. And if you can't make it, I hope to see you at the next one. Just be sure to get your tickets early!
soapbox.fire.org/soapbox/11013385 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rob Sica
@robsica
✨ New tour de force target article in BBS by, imho, one of the most profoundly insightful evolutionary psychologists of the female psyche: cambridge.org/core/services/aop-file-manager/file/6acfe05…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Mahmoud Khalil | محمود خليل
@mahmoudkhalel
You can’t make this up. Minouche Shafik, the former @Columbia president who caved to hostile politicians in a disastrous hearing, called the NYPD onto her own campus, had students arrested by the hundreds, then resigned in disgrace, is now in charge of @LSEnews new forum for “democratic debate.”
Will she call the police on the debaters too?
www.lse.ac.uk/news/latest-news-from-lse/minouche-shafik-e… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
In my essay for @TheEconomist, I argued that global discourses on gender tend to universalise from "last-mile" problems faced in Western countries (e.g. the challenge of combine work & motherhood), but this extremely parochial.
The big challenge in WAR-TORN countries is quite obviously WAR & VIOLENCE.
Crucially then, the new UN Secretary General must seek to end those wars - such as in Sudan.
UN Women
@UN_Women
Conflict places more of the care burden on women and girls' shoulders.
#peace and security require more than their unpaid labor.
Women and girls must be at the heart of peacebuilding.
🔗 See more on the @UN Secretary-General's report on #womenpeacesecurity: -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
alex bronzini-vender
@alexbronzini
Lots of people pointing out that reading one book a week with mandatory lecture attendance isn't, objectively speaking, a high bar. Fair enough.
But if you’re restoring standards in higher ed, you’ve gotta start somewhere. This course’s popularity is great news!
Benjamin Ryan
@benryanwriter
This @Harvard class is characterized as “brutal” because students are required “to read a hefty book a week.”
That was what literally all my English classes at @Columbia required 25 years ago.
Oh, and students are required to show up.
Where have standards gone? -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
Explicit measures of prejudice are much stronger predictors of discrimination than implicit measures.
A new adversarial collaboration found that self-report measures of racial bias exhibited greater predictive validity of discrimination than indirect measures (explaining ∼45% vs 3% of the variance).
The zero-order correlations between each indirect measure and behavioral measures of discrimination were quite low ( r = .00 to .19) By comparison, correlations between direct measures and discrimination were all statistically significant (r = .099 to .381).
Moreover, the behavioral discrimination measures generally produced effects favoring Black over White targets, which "complicates claims that anti-Black effects on indirect measures are a source of cumulative disadvantage."
psycnet.apa.org/fulltext/2027-35698-001.pdf -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ben Yelin
@byelin
Listened to Nate Silver on Ezra this morning. One of the least popular things I could do on this website is defend Nate Silver, so challenge accepted.
His "vibes" have been directionally correct in every Election. In 2012, he fought against the polling unskewers making claims that Romney would win based on undersampling of Republicans.
In 2016, his model was famously FAR more bullish on Trump than any others. He was the only modeler who understood the possibility of correlated polling error.
In 2020, he repeatedly emphasized the higher than usual uncertainty due to the pandemic.
In 2022, he fought back against pollsters (NY Times!) basically ignoring their own data to buy into the Red Wave.
In 2024, he said that even though his model was 50/50, his gut said Trump would win.
All in all, a better record than anyone else on Election Twitter. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"The average man without a job...an average of five and a half hours a day watching television and movies, plus many more on other screen-based activities such as watching pornography and playing video games." www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/job-market-unemployment…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Andrew Gelman et al.
@StatModeling
We interrupt our usual programming to inform you that I was never hired by Facebook to do a hit job on Jonathan Haidt.
statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2026/10/27/we-interrupt-ou… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Kat Rosenfield
@katrosenfield
I wrote for @thefp about our cultural allergy to female agency and the women empathizing themselves over a cliff
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Shadi Hamid
@shadihamid
This is true. Except for the Arab parties, nearly all of Israel’s factions agree on one thing: opposing a Palestinian state. The problem isn’t just about Netanyahu. That’s always been a cop-out to distract from a much deeper problem at the core of the contemporary Israel state.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
Meta had an internal PR plan to try and discredit Jon Haidt because he was a critic of social media.
Meta was going to recruit academics, like Andrew Gelman, to write take down pieces. They were trying to turn academics against one another through a "whisper strategy".
This is a very serious problem for open academic debate. If academics who share negative evidence about a platform are targeted by campaigns to smear our credibility, we are in deep, deep trouble.
This creates a very serious conflict of interest for anyone who is paid to do this.
www.law360.com/articles/2542517/meta-docs-reveal-plan-to-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Christine Emba
@ChristineEmba
i need an explanation for hologram boy on the left
Robbie Gramer
@RobbieGramer
Japan just released the unclassified version of their annual defense strategy anyways here's the actual cover page of it
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
It’s a very good movie but if your takeaway is that Elizabeth Holmes might be a neurodivergent victim I think you have forcibly disconnected yourself from reality.
More specifically, she *obviously* gets The Who’s on First joke—and is profoundly motivated to pretend she doesn’t. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Law professor Josh Blackman called the NYT out on politically labeling conservatives more often than liberals, and editor Patrick Healy acknowledged he was right:
“It can come off like The Times treats liberals as normal and conservatives as unique and worthy of labeling.” -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Education voter divides tend to decline (& income divides increase) when elections are more about the economy than cultural issues. Dem Senate (right) & House (left) campaigns are very economic-focused this cycle, Republicans campaigns are mixed.
mediaproject.wesleyan.edu/releases-101526/ -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
An update on my second book, Those People, now slated for release in Fall 2027. 🧵
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My initial plan for Those People proved untenable, for reasons I explain here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/221397745/men-plan-god-laughs
Working with @PrincetonUPress, we came up with a new vision. I've spent the past year piloting a new writing style to great success. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
With support from @OpenSociety, @TheIHS, and @SBUjournalism, I'm able to spend this entire academic year (as needed) in my hometown working on Those People.
I drove across country, rented a small studio, and I'm already doing some exciting fieldwork: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/welcome-to-sierra-vista-az -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Sierra Vista, #arizona is a great site for observing the themes the second book is trying to explore, as I briefly detail here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/221397745/theres-no-place-lik…
I'm really excited about the new direction for Those People. I hope you will be too. Check out the full post for more info! -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
An update on my second book, Those People, now slated for release in Fall 2027. 🧵
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My initial plan for Those People proved untenable, for reasons I explain here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/221397745/men-plan-god-laughs
Working with @PrincetonUPress, we came up with a new vision. I've spent the past year piloting a new writing style to great success.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
With support from @OpenSociety, @TheIHS, and @SBUjournalism, I'm able to spend this entire academic year (as needed) in my hometown working on Those People.
I drove across country, rented a small studio, and I'm already doing some exciting fieldwork: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/welcome-to-sierra-vista-az
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Sierra Vista, #arizona is a great site for observing the themes the second book is trying to explore, as I briefly detail here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/221397745/theres-no-place-lik…
I'm really excited about the new direction for Those People. I hope you will be too. Check out the full post for more info! -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Josh Kalla
@j_kalla
Now published at @apsrjournal. Check out "The Symbolic Politics of Housing" doi.org/10.1017/S0003055426102019
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Trung Phan
@TrungTPhan
Another gem Fielder interview is the promo he did with cast of The Night Before: Anthony Mackie, Joseph Gordon-Levitt & Seth Rogen.
Rogen and Fielder were high school classmates in Vancouver and placed 3rd in a national improv competition as a team. This promo best collab since.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
Early Nathan Fielder. He got to interview his boss on the air and made it as awkward as possible.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Shadi Hamid
@shadihamid
Too often, "sharia" has been mischaracterized as merely a code of criminal laws. But sharia is not a list of statutes. No such list exists. The sharia is a rich, diverse, and ever-evolving tradition that covers both public life and personal ritual. 10 Muslims will give 10 different answers about what the sharia means to them. That diversity is backed into the sharia.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alex Mechanick
@apmechan
For those interested in seeing the second term Trump and second term George W. Bush net approval ratings in one figure:
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Trump approval starting to look like a dead ringer for Bush's second term.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Shadi Hamid
@shadihamid
🚨🚨 FELLOWSHIP OPPORTUNITY. For young Christian and Muslim scholars & leaders who work on faith and politics.
As co-director of @Georgetown's Templeton Pluralism Fellowship, happy to share that applications are open:
faithandfutureofdemocracy.org/apply/ -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
This was a super fun conversation with @thomasfrank_ about the cult of innovation, the “creative class,” and the broken promises of post-industrial society, from the 1950s to Obama and AI.
kang
@jaycaspiankang
very lively and fun new episode of @ttsgpod with Thomas Frank. @Tyler_A_Harper and I talk to him about his new book THE CREATIVITY CON. A whole lot of talk about the construction of the "creative class," his time starting the Baffler Magazine, and Obama. goodbye.substack.com/p/the-creativity-con-with-thomas-frank
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Agree with this take except I would dispute that the crackdown on low-end housing was primarily motivated by humanitarian goals, I think the record shows that the exclusionary outcomes were largely intended and the humanitarian stuff was pretextual.
www.slowboring.com/p/legalize-housing-not-tent-encampments
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
Why were there fewer homeless people on the streets of American cities in the mid-20th century? Housing quality and quantity compete with each other. Cities used to have more wretched housing -- dingy, cramped, flop houses with shared bathrooms (no hot water). With humanitarian goals, reformers changed zoning rules to abolish such very low end housing. That was a tradeoff: Higher quality but lower quantity. Some benefited, but people who could only afford a flop house bed migrated to the streets.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I have tried and failed at this before, but I really am resolving in good faith to try to spend less time posting on here for things that aren't directly promoting longer work by me or others.
I learn a lot on X, but it's a real mind poison too.
www.slowboring.com/p/americans-need-to-get-out-of-the -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Asad🗽🍎
@AsadFromNYC
This ad gets so much right: An embrace of what sociologist Robert Bellah calls American civil religion, a reclamation of his name ("Servant") as a call to public service, and pride in his own faith without having to overstate it. The subtle delivery is what makes it land so well.
Dr. Abdul El-Sayed
@AbdulElSayed
As a man of faith, I pray every day.
Faith is a thing there’s just too little of in Washington.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Shadi Hamid
@shadihamid
Hell is a real place. It might also be good for democracy.
For secular readers, please consider our argument an open mind. You don’t have to believe in hell to appreciate how it can relieve pressure on our politics to deliver final verdicts in the here and now.
Shadi Hamid
@shadihamid
New from me and @matthewkaemingk: The political case for hell.
Hell can be good for democracy because it helps us delay judgment until some unspecified point in the future, allowing us to "chill."
wisdomofcrowds.live/p/the-case-for-hell -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Yonan
@yonann
Jason Alexander says he feared visiting Palestine as a Jew until 10 Palestinians protected him during an Israeli army raid in Ramallah
“How much of a risk would I be taking as an American Jew walking into Palestinian cities? And Mohammed said, ‘The greatest dishonor that could happen to a religious Muslim is to allow harm to come to an invited guest’”
“And he said, ‘Jason, if they had to, they’ll take a bullet for you.’ And what was so interesting about that trip is, we were having lunch in Ramallah with a bunch of actors and artists at a sort of outdoor restaurant”
“And the Israeli army was conducting a raid on a bank that they thought had terrorist ties a couple blocks away. And they must have, to announce themselves, just shot into the air. And I remember 10 of those guys at the table surrounding me. And I went, ‘Oh my God, he wasn’t kidding. They’re not going to let me get hurt’”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Teresa M. Bejan
@tmbejan
Today is the official release date for my new book, First Among Equals: Visions of Equality before Egalitarianism (Belknap, 2026).
It explores how and why “equality” became, rather suddenly, a basis on which ordinary men and women could make political demands in early modern England.
www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674249332 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
These days, it’s easy to succumb to hopelessness. But I explain why doomerism can lead to paralysis in a new article I wrote for the @guardian
The problem with doomerism isn’t necessarily that the risks are exaggerated, but that it may create a self-fulfilling prophecy – by engendering helplessness, rather than galvanixing people.
This aspect of human psychology has been well known for many years by experts on persuasion. When people hear messages designed to appeal to our fears, they can be moved to take action. But this only tends to work as a one-off, and only then when the messages convey a sense of efficacy – a belief that it’s still possible to make a difference. By contrast, if people are inundated with scary and overwhelming stories about the climate or AI, they tune out.
A big problem for us now is that the modern information ecosystem tends to reinforce negativity. For decades, a core principle in the news business has been “if it bleeds, it leads”. This principle now dominates what you see online.
My colleagues and I looked at traffic to news stories on upworthy.com. This was a website that became famous for conducting A/B tests of headlines to see which one drove clicks, and then using the most popular headline. We analysed 22,743 of these mini-experiments and found that each additional negative word in a headline increased clicks by 2.3%.
We also found that doom and gloom messagins are the most effective at getting people to spread it on the internet or social media. But like other fear appeals, it fails to inspire real action.
If we want to motivate people in the face of dire threats, we must give them a reason to hope. Without that, we are destined to doomscroll while the world burns.
Read my full article here: www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/oct/18/the-problem-w… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
Utterly incoherent how he goes from Athens, where he denigrated Persia as the eternal Other in a clash with Western "civilization," to this embrace of Samarkand, a city that's wholly bound up in Persian "civilization," if talking about civilizations is so important to you.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Simulacra and Simulation
Desert highways are always a trip (figuratively but, of course, literally too).
#mericamaxxing
Should be at work on Book II shortly: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/book-announcement-those-people -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
New essay! It explores a very simple and in some sense pretty obvious idea that I think is nevertheless hugely important for understanding politics, culture wars, and media bias. Put simply, our brains evaluate ideas based on their diffusion value: not just whether they seem true, but whether other people accepting them would advance our goals. conspicuouscognition.substack.com/p/on-believing-what-we-…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Driving across country from Long Island to my hometown, where I'll be conducting fieldwork for and writing my next book over the coming months.
'Merica maxxing
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
More about my next book available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/book-announcement-those-people
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Simulacra and Simulation
Desert highways are always a trip (figuratively but, of course, literally too).
#mericamaxxing
Should be at work on Book II shortly: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/book-announcement-those-people -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Shadi Hamid
@shadihamid
This is such a thoughtful and nuanced essay from @realcpaz in Vox engaging with the arguments in our new book. Well worth a read, particularly for skeptics.
"Maybe secular liberals can't save democracy."
Can religion help?
vox.com/politics/505675/can-religion-save-democracy-book-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
More about my next book available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/book-announcement-those-people
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Real banger here. We often treat descriptive analysis as a petty chore you need go through to get to the real (causal) stuff. Gerring argues that not only is good description crucial, it’s arguably the greater challenge. Deciding how to characterize things appropriately can be more consequential and difficult than establishing that X is related to Y in a particular way. www.cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of-politi…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
This is excellent. One challenge to higher ed reform is that the most readily available interventions are at the level of institutions (universities) but much of the mischief emanates from the guilds (disciplines, professional associations), and the institutions need the guilds to confer legitimacy on their personnel and activities.
This is why reform needs to be both external and internal. Internal reformers need institutional backing. External reformers need insiders with the expertise to reconfigure the economy of legitimacy back toward truth-seeking.
www.civitasinstitute.org/research/the-invisible-college-w… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Kitty Thijsebaard
@KThijsebaard
Interessant boek. (De anti-wokies onder ons krijgen ook een draai om de oren hoor) 🤓 @Musa_alGharbi
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🧠 @Musa_alGharbi on how elite education launders inherited advantage into apparent merit, and why school quality explains less about who succeeds than we assume: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
The shift in the generic ballot against the president's party continues. Although consistent with the historic pace & direction, this should be close to the largest 2-year shift in generic ballot polling on record; see below for the averages since the 30s
www.natesilver.net/p/generic-ballot-average-2026-nate-sil…
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Majority parties of the president lose generic ballot support as midterms approach, especially at the end. It responds to falling prez approval & thermostatic public opinion. Backlash to the Iran War & immigration crackdowns will help Dems, but are consistent with normal cycle
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Nicole Barbaro Simovski, Ph.D.
@NicoleBarbaro
You have to remember that this has nothing to do with the students. It has everything to do with rankings. If elite colleges shared information that potentially reduced the overall number of applications, their admission rate would go up bc of a smaller denominator = lower rank.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
Most social media research has failed policy-makers
Research on social media use and adolescent mental health has shown mixed results, and has often yielded no evidence of a strong relationship. But such studies have largely ignored the ‘cost of missing out’ — the social cost of not belonging.
Children with higher social media use could be happier than their peers and, at the same time, social media use could cause a decline in collective well-being.
This is why most social media studies are not useful for informing policies.
For example, one cross-sectional study found that digital technology use explains only 0.4% of variation in adolescent well-being, and the authors caution against policy change. Yet this study was conducted entirely under conditions in which social media use is ubiquitous (scenario A). The change in well-being that would follow a move to a situation in which social media use is regulated (scenario B) simply cannot be estimated from such data.
www.nature.com/articles/s41562-026-02482-9 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Arthur Dent
@ArthurCDent
Good thread! Yep I’m one who sent 3 kids to a local state school, in a poorer regional area - although I could easily afford a private school.
Why? Three reasons:
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest for Symbolic Capital(ism) explores education, putting themes and findings from We Have Never Been Woke into conversation with @nhannahjones' recent piece. 🧵
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sally Satel
@slsatel
Allow me to be the millionth person who recommends this astute, and, in the last section, devastating essay. musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education?r=dway
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
LSE Sociology
@LSEsociology
How has conservatism shaped sociological thought?
Join Professor Shamus Khan and chair Professor Sam Friedman for the BJS Annual Lecture, exploring the often-overlooked conservative tradition within sociology.
www.lse.ac.uk/events/conservative-tradition-sociological-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alexander Russo
@alexanderrusso
"Why education is not an effective vehicle for 'social justice.'" - @Musa_alGharbi
On Education - by Musa al-Gharbi - Symbolic Capital(ism) musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education?open=false -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jesse Walker
@notjessewalker
NORMIES, 2021-24: We're sick of dumb P.C. shit.
A CHUNK OF THE RIGHT, 2025-26: Ah! So you like bigotry, then? Maybe we could even back it up with the full force of the state?
NORMIES: God no, that's even worse.
A CHUNK OF THE LEFT: Ah! So you like...
Katie Herzog
@kittypurrzog
Dude fired for teenaged tweets, white women fired for wearing cornrows to Burning Man, gay bar getting canceled for skeleton costume that looked like blackface. We are so back.
www.advocate.com/news/culture/pittsburgh-bar-blackface-bl… -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest for Symbolic Capital(ism) explores education, putting themes and findings from We Have Never Been Woke into conversation with @nhannahjones' recent piece. 🧵
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I was raised to strongly believe in education. And education did change my life... although not in the ways I'd anticipated. What mattered most in my own life wasn't what I knew or what I was capable of but *who* issued me credentials: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education
Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Understanding that the differences between "low" and "high" performing schools are almost entirely products of student selection effects rather than anything happening in the building helps explain why no strategies to ameliorate inequality via education seem to work:
Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
In addition to distorting perceptions about public schools and failing to reckon with basic socioeconomic realities of her family, the piece also declines to acknowledge some terrible choices NHJ made, like blocking a move that would've brought more white and affluent families into her kid's school (which is what this whole project was allegedly supposed to do!): musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/217694487/putting-my-kids-whe…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Much more about education, inequality, and public policy in my full piece, here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Indeed, as I detailed for Boston Globe earlier this year, you can go all the way back to the Civil War, and virtually every time there was a change of party in the White House, the victorious party went on to lose seats in the House during their inaugural midterms.
Unless the Democrats put up results significantly outside the normal range (median, mean, mode at the bottom of this table), there's little to write home about.
And even if they do exceed the averages (it looks like they probably will), it's easy to overinterpret the results, as I detail here: musaalgharbi.com/2025/11/26/many-overinterpret-2025-elect…
The @GOP is poised for significant losses, but it's important to evaluate any gains for @TheDemocrats relative to historical base rates.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
This is maybe our most important chart of the election cycle.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Indeed, as I detailed for Boston Globe earlier this year, you can go all the way back to the Civil War, and virtually every time there was a change of party in the White House, the victorious party went on to lose seats in the House during their inaugural midterms.
Unless the Democrats put up results significantly outside the normal range (median, mean, mode at the bottom of this table), there's little to write home about.
And even if they do exceed the averages (it looks like they probably will), it's easy to overinterpret the results, as I detail here: musaalgharbi.com/2025/11/26/many-overinterpret-2025-elect…
The @GOP is poised for significant losses, but it's important to evaluate any gains for @TheDemocrats relative to historical base rates.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
This is maybe our most important chart of the election cycle.
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Indeed, as I detailed for Boston Globe earlier this year, you can go all the way back to the Civil War, and virtually every time there was a change of party in the White House, the victorious party went on to lose seats in the House during their inaugural midterms.
Unless the Democrats put up results significantly outside the normal range (median, mean, mode at the bottom of this table), there's little to write home about.
And even if they do exceed the averages (it looks like they probably will), it's easy to overinterpret the results, as I detail here: musaalgharbi.com/2025/11/26/many-overinterpret-2025-elect…
The @GOP is poised for significant losses, but it's important to evaluate any gains for @TheDemocrats relative to historical base rates.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
This is maybe our most important chart of the election cycle.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I think "failing schools" discourse leads people to underrate exactly how bad the instructional practices are at the *typical* American school.
The *median* American student has shocking lapses in competency, this is just not a hard question.
www.slowboring.com/p/math-needs-a-phonics-style-reckoning -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
On this one, the @macfound folks knocked it out of the park. Congratulations @hollyjeanbuck!!!
MacArthur Foundation
@macfound
Meet the 2026 MacArthur Fellows!
These 20 individuals explore the depths of our humanity, reveal untold origins to modern challenges, and expand the edges of scientific inquiry and life-saving research. #macfellow
www.macfound.org/programs/awards/fellows/ -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
this reminds of an interview with jason alexander where he said that in the first few seinfeld episodes, he couldn't get into the george character because his behavior is so alien and strange and so he asks larry about it and larry says something like "this all happened to me!"
Yonan
@yonann
Conan O’Brien says he caught Larry David arguing with a waiter over mustard and had to remind him there were no cameras
“Literally a week ago I walk into a restaurant... Larry David’s there with his lovely wife... Larry’s in the middle of getting into it with the waiter because the waiter brought him a turkey sandwich with no mustard”
“He’s like, ‘In the history of sandwiches, when has mustard not been part of the equation?’”
“I said to him, ‘Larry, there’s no cameras’... He just said, ‘I would like to be paid by HBO to be the guy I am anyway’”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
A new book reveals the truth about America’s rich people
www.slowboring.com/p/the-truth-about-rich-people-in-america -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
People judge their own choices and life paths (spouse, career, etc) as less predictable than other people’s.
A suggested explanation is that knowing our own reasons/motives makes our choices seem more open-ended (rightly or wrongly).
storage.googleapis.com/jnl-up-j-irsp-files/journals/1/art… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rob Sica
@robsica
🔪"The question framing the piece was, 'In fighting for every black child, did I betray my own?' and the most based answer to that question seems to be 'no'"
musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Patrick Caton
@pdcaton
Good education insights musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education?r=dsf0b
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
If you're in #socal, I'll be doing an event at @CMCnews about my book. Link for more information in the follow-up below.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
More information about the event itself (and registration) available here: www.cmc.edu/athenaeum/we-have-never-been-woke-cultural-co…
More about We Have Never Been Woke available here: musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/ -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
This is the core argument of my book: musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/
We're defined by two sincere but antithetical desires: the desire to be an elite, the desire to be an egalitarian. But you can't actually be an egalitarian social climber, it's a contradiction in terms.
David Klion
@DavidKlion
My reaction to the NHJ piece is that the PMC obsession with socially reproducing itself is not just incompatible with, but antithetical to, its egalitarian ideals. These are opposite and irreconcilable wishes, this is the core hypocrisy of our class, and it is crazymaking.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I'll say, while I enjoyed the piece, one thing I did find frustrating was this misapprehension of what was lost or at stake here.
Like, is NHJ's kid not going to get into an elite school if she wants to go to college? Is she going to end up poor or working class etc. because her parents didn't send her to elite K-12 schools? Not likely. Her parents are literally millionaires and they're prolific and influential people that some elite institutions will want to have deeper relationships with.
She'll be just fine in terms of life outcomes regardless of the school she attended. Better than fine. The failure to really be explicit about this reality -- or to push her kid to recognize it -- was the one thing that grated on me a bit in what was otherwise a really excellent piece.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I've turned my thoughts on the NHJ story (and education more broadly) into an essay on Symbolic Capital(ism) here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Indeed, I also sent my kids to their zone public school in Manhattan -- mostly black, Hispanic, 'economically disadvantaged': musaalgharbi.com/2025/01/01/how-we-lived-in-nyc/
My situation was much closer to Matt's than HNJs.
We live in Long Island now because my job is in Stony Brook. I still just send my kids to their zoned public school. I am, myself, a product of public schools from kindergarten through my MA.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Excellent from Matt Yglesias.
It would indeed be a shame if every affluent urban parent of a toddler decided that they need to flee to the suburbs.
www.slowboring.com/p/why-i-send-my-kid-to-low-income-urban
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I've turned my thoughts on the NHJ story (and education more broadly) into an essay on Symbolic Capital(ism) here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-education
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Emma Camp
@emmma_camp_
It's easy to hate insurance companies, but do you have the courage to hate hospitals?
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Trip Gabriel
@tripgabriel
The NYT confirms Haaretz's report that Benjamin Netanyahu was secretly warned before Oct. 7, 2023 by the Emirati president that Hamas planned a major attack, per 2 sources
The warning was not shared with Israeli security chiefs, per 5 ex-officials
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/25/world/middleeast/netanyahu-war… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Cambridge is no longer planning to investigate Jason Arday’s academic record or the university’s decision to hire or cover for him.
Instead, the investigation will focus on “his welfare, his care, his well-being” and “whether the school offered him sufficient support amid accusations that he plagiarized.” -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Charles Fain Lehman
@CharlesFLehman
probably a coincidence
www.epicresearch.org/articles/gambling-disorder-diagnoses…
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"Calls about sports betting to Ohio’s problem gambling help line have more than quadrupled since the state legalized it in 2023." www.nytimes.com/2026/09/19/business/draftkings-ai.html
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Russ Greene
@GreenPlusAnE
Ben Shapiro
@benshapiro
Meritocracy isn't the problem. It's the solution. And the fact that both parties are now moving toward wholesale rejection of meritocracy spells the end of American innovation, freedom, and strength.
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Obama thinks press freedom is "foundational"?
Huh.... he had a radically different position when he was in office.
Better late than never, I guess?
CNN
@CNN
Barack Obama said he’s “not surprised” by President Donald Trump’s decision to ban CNN, MS NOW and Politico from the White House, arguing that the issue should not be “partisan.” www.cnn.com/2026/09/23/politics/barack-obama-press-ban?Da…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
To understand the dynamics driving stories like these (with walkthroughs of many similar incidents), I'd recommend Chapter 5 of my book.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Full story about "Temu Rachel Dolezal" here: www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/philly-activist-confesses-fa…
More about We Have Never Been Woke here: musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/ -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Christina Buttons
@buttonslives
A new article in the New Yorker on declining birth rates opens by sneering at conservatives for blaming feminism, individualism, sexual liberalization, and the erosion of marriage and family norms, then presents “capitalism” as the more serious explanation.
But much of the piece ends up supporting the cultural factors the author mocks conservatives for identifying. She describes greater career focus and emphasis on individual fulfillment, declining interest in marriage and children, and changes in sexual and dating culture that make lasting relationships harder to form.
She also claims conservatives “have little to say” about affordability, which just isn’t true. She then undercuts the argument that economics is the dominant factor by acknowledging that countries with far more generous family benefits haven’t escaped collapsing fertility. She concludes that “culture plays a larger” role than economics.
Conservatives often say things that are fairly obviously true, but because they’re conservatives, their arguments are dismissed as “culture-war culprits” coming from “cranky pro-natalists” and “censorious baby boosters,” even when their critics eventually arrive at many of the same conclusions. www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/09/28/inconceivable-the-i… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jeet Heer
@HeerJeet
I somehow missed the story of the Saudis/UAE selling tapestry from Mecca to Jeffrey Epstein -- until the Houthis brought it up. It's genuinely shocking. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/29/world/americas/jeffrey-epstein…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
alex bronzini-vender
@alexbronzini
Burst out laughing while reading this
kate wagner
@mcmansionhell
hard read alert www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/22/magazine/greenfield-last-d…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I think most parents overrate the causal impact of education on children's life outcomes and very naive indicators of school quality are "priced in" to real estate values, so there's significant alpha in caring less.
www.slowboring.com/p/why-i-send-my-kid-to-low-income-urban -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
What better distillation of higher education in the 2020s than a bureaucrat using AI to fake-diversify an elite campus. A half decade of history condensed into a single, perfect image.
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: Stanford University is accused of using AI to change students’ race & gender while making others appear thinner in advertising, with one student saying he felt “silenced & erased.”
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
People who really despair about their government and society often don't bother to protest, vote, or follow politics closely. They just check out. As a result, protests are not dominated by people with the most alienation, despair or who are least-well served by the system.
It's people who still have faith in politics, institutions and their fellow citizens who take to the streets (this may also explain the asymmetry between left and right observed in the data). It's often people who have more free time and flexibility. And those who skew more towards the elite side of the socioeconomic spectrum.
PsyPost.org
@PsyPost
A comprehensive review of 60 years of research reveals that people who participate in protests are driven more by social connections and political interest than by personal grievances, anger, or mistrust of the government. www.psypost.org/why-do-people-protest-six-decades-of-rese…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
But as a detail in my book (musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/), people who take to the streets often falsely portray themselves as marginalized or disadvantaged or legitimate representatives of the same when they are often clearly none of the above.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Sometimes when industry insiders warn that a new, potentially very lucrative product ideas is actually dangerous and bad the doomsayers are correct and the optimists are wrong.
www.slowboring.com/p/lead-poisoning -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alan Fisher
@alanthefisher
The Hormuz Letter
@HormuzLetter
BREAKING: For the first time since the Iran war began, JPMorgan says it no longer has a baseline view on oil, writing "we simply don't know how to model the endgame," and that the assumption that the Middle East disruptions are temporary is "becoming increasingly difficult to sustain," per JPMorgan Global Research.
The bank says it had assumed there were economic red lines the Trump administration would be unwilling to cross, and that six months later "many of those lines have been crossed, yet the exit strategy is less clear, not more."
Chevron's CEO said this week the Great fuel crisis has officially arrived, as Trump officials continue to claim the disruption temporary. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Paul D. Thacker
@thackerpd
Well written @germanrlopez piece explaining how most American don't fit neatly into either political party.
The argument is nothing new, but it's presented in a compelling, easy to follow manner. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/09/17/opinion/liberal-co… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Yet arguably baked into the cake from the beginning by his foreign policy staffing
www.slowboring.com/p/how-donald-trump-could-succeed
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Trump running on lower gas prices and no more foreign wars and then starting a war with Iran that literallly everyone except Pete Hegseth knew was going to be a quagmire has to be on the shortlist for dumbest political blunders in American history.
Patrick De Haan
@GasBuddyGuy
gasoline up to $4.434/gal as of tonight, while diesel has climbed to $6.387/gal, according to the latest GasBuddy live view. up from $4.355 and $6.301 last night, and tomorrow will bring more increases to the averages as they play catch up.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Stoller
@matthewstoller
This document looks like the almost 90% of Paramount will be owned by Middle Eastern nation states, Saudi Arabia, UAW, and Qatar.
Brendan Carr: "We also find that it is in the public interest to permit up to 100% indirect foreign equity interest of Paramount."
That's brazen.
Daniel Miller
@DanielNMiller
NEWS: The FCC approved Paramount’s request to let foreign investors — including sovereign wealth funds from Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Qatar — own more than 25% of its equity, clearing a regulatory hurdle tied to its WBD purchase. Here's the ruling’s breakdown of the investments:
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Weigel
@daveweigel
“Trump Derangement Syndrome” is a fun little concept.
There absolutely are normal Trump decisions that make people madder bc they dislike him so much. But if you’d said two years ago, “Trump will threaten to bulldoze the Kennedy Center unless his name is on it,” you’d have been hospitalized for late stage TDS. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
It does seem fair to say that Trump is among the most corrupt world leaders since the industrial age began. One of the bullets in Nixon’s impeachment was about a corporate campaign contribution that was less than half a million. Trump and his family have personally looted BILLIONS. With no idea where the Venezuela money is, it could be tens of billions.
theleahfiles
@leahfiles
People keep saying Trump term II is the most corrupt administration ever, so I built a model to find out if it was true.
I took the UN's definition of corruption, turned it into eight criteria and 100 points, and scored the leaders history remembers for looting their countries: Marcos, Suharto, Mobutu, Abacha, Obiang, Putin.
Then I put every president since Eisenhower on the same scale, both parties, with every exoneration counted right alongside the convictions.
Nixon scored 41 and no other American President scored over a 25.
Trump's second term scored a 91, which ties him with Suharto and Mobutu and puts him above Marcos and Abacha.
So he is not only the most corrupt president in American history. At this pace he finishes his term level with the most corrupt rulers of the last hundred years.
PSA: don't come in my comments arguing about the results if you haven't read the full article, because ignorance is a choice.
Full article is up now on my Substack (link in bio) and it's free. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jerusalem
@JerusalemDemsas
losing your citizenship for making a documentary
Deadline
@DEADLINE
Netanyahu Moves To Get 'NAZA' Directors' Israeli Citizenship Revoked deadline.com/2026/09/netanyahu-naza-directors-israeli-cit…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
workers in hazardous occupations are more conservative & grow more conservative over time academic.oup.com/sf/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.1093/…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
jordan
@JordanUhl
Rolling Stone
@RollingStone
Trump Is Reportedly Sending Israel $2.8 Billion in Bombs. You’re Paying for Them
www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/trump-supply-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
Here's my absolute favorite genre of public relations spin.
When a university HAS to release it's 10th day enrollment numbers.
But, those numbers are catastrophically bad.
So they issue a 1,000 word press release that is full of nothing but fluff.
They released the first version of the article on September 3, which didn't contain the actual enrollment number.
Then they update that exact same press release a week later that buries the most important number at the bottom.
Actual enrollment.
I highlighted it in the screenshot below. You can barely see it.
And they also don't include previous year's enrollment numbers so a person has to go Googling to see actually how bad it is.
Western Illinois had 5,337 students enrolled in the Fall of 2025.
This year, it's 4,447.
That's a 16.7% decrease. Which is, like I said above, catastrophically bad.
In 2008, WIU's enrollment was 13,175.
They have lost two-thirds of their students in less than 20 years. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alex Mechanick
@apmechan
The Johns Hopkins University School of Government and Policy (located in DC) is hiring multiple tenure track faculty across poli sci, law, sociology, history, philosophy, comp sci, econ, and more. Join us!
Apps are due Oct. 25.
apply.interfolio.com/193492
apply.interfolio.com/193579 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
𝙼𝚎𝚐𝚊𝚗 𝙺𝚊𝚗𝚐
@kang_megan
@JohnsHopkins School of Government and Policy is hiring multiple TT faculty across soc, poli sci, law, public admin, history, philosophy, CS, engineering, econ. In DC, due Oct 25. Part of our founding cohort, so you'd shape what the school becomes!
apply.interfolio.com/193492 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Benjamin Ryan
@benryanwriter
I cannot recommend more highly the UCLA sociologist Rogers Brubaker’s new book, Gender Identity. It is a dispassionate tour de force assessing where this category of personhood came from, how it came to be formalized and institutionalized, and how it possesses a perhaps irreconcilable tension between granting rights and validating individuals’ selfhood on one hand and alienating people and and causing backlash on the other.
From the final page of @wrbucla’s book:
“Yet even in the hyperpolarized US, where gender identity has been drawn into the vortex of the culture wars, the controversy over the category ‘gender identity’ cannot be plotted solely on a left-right axis. The recent years of intensifying attacks from the culturally conservative right have also seen the emergence of critiques of gender identity from the culturally liberal center and center-left and from some feminists, gay men and lesbians, and transgender people themselves. The emergence of these critiques - which are compatible with an insistence on the dignity, safety, and rights of transgender people - is a reminder that the controversy over gender identity cannot be reduced to a struggle between progressive defenders of the ‘civil rights issue of our time,’ as President Biden put it, and reactionaries who think transgender people have ‘no right to exist.’ It is a more complex struggle over how to think about sex and gender as principles of vision and division of the world: a struggle over the relation between the sexed body and gendered feelings, between what is given and what can be chosen, between nature and culture. It is ultimately a struggle over the nature and limits of self-determination in an interdependent world.” -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
To be clear:
Walking away from studies that don’t support your ideas is a form of research misconduct.
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
“Francesca Gino Tells Court Harvard ‘Tries To Completely Sidestep’ The Central Question In Her Case.”
poetsandquants.com/2026/08/30/francesca-gino-tells-court-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Branko Marcetic
@BMarchetich
For years, analysts have argued Washington's bullying of non-nuclear-armed states basically creates the perfect, perverse incentive for countries to seek dangerous WMDs. No need to do so any longer - the president just made their point for them.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
Trump initial reaction to 9/11 was to claim that he now owned the tallest building in downtown Manhattan.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Christopher Hale
@ChristopherHale
There isn’t a single American worker in this video.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
This Labor Day, we celebrate the workers and products that are proudly MADE IN AMERICA. 🇺🇸
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Monica Marks
@MonicaLMarks
Israel’s left-leaning Haaretz broke this bombshell report—the result of 1.5 years of research—yesterday.
The UAE Foreign Ministry’s statement last night tacitly confirmed it.
Now the centrist Israeli paper Times of Israel has independently confirmed it with Emirati sources.
Ihab Hassan
@IhabHassane
This is a bombshell.
It has now been confirmed by Emirati sources that Netanyahu was warned about a planned Hamas attack ahead of October 7. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
Yes, @KeithNHumphreys is right but the reason college students have less knowledge than they used to is precisely because—rather than figure out how to safeguard learning from AI cheating—universities chose AI accelerationism and the quiet acceptance of college becoming fake.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Assal Rad
@AssalRad
“Once people saw the images from Gaza—parents carrying their children’s remains in plastic bags, day after day of tiny bodies torn apart—they couldn’t unsee them. There was only before and after the Gaza Genocide.”
It’s publication day. I hope it contributes to this vital canon. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Saagar Enjeti
@esaagar
Almost every promise of modern technology has delivered the opposite result
- Social networking made historically less social
- Unlimited information made people much stupider
- Technology use during childhood has made children less advanced
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
Two extraordinary charts from today’s PISA test results:
1) School test scores continue to collapse internationally, underscoring how this is no longer a Covid effect but sustained decline.
Those falls in reading and maths are equivalent to about two years of lost schooling. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
2) England is a rare exception.
During the 2010s many other countries (including the other 3 UK nations) changed tack, experimenting with ideas like transferrable skills instead of focusing on tried-and-tested disciplines and methods. It looks like those experiments have failed. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Labor Day is a great moment to reflect on the important contributions liberal socialists have made to improving the lives of working people in the U.S. and abroad.
Many fail to recognize these hard-fought contributions because they've now been baked into the foundations of contemporary liberal democracies and most contemporary citizens take them for granted. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Much more on liberal socialism, authoritarian socialism, and how my own views on inequality have evolved over time here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
As a bonus the early paragraphs footnotes also contain my contribution to 'the Discourse' on contemporary sociology. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As for socialist movements in the United States today, more on the promise and challenges of the contemporary #dsa is available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Anna Gát
@TheAnnaGat
Whenever I spend time in New York, not a day passes that I don't think of @Musa_alGharbi's work on the city's social strata.
He is the sharpest pair of eyes we have for describing the things most Americans choose not to see.
Can't wait for his new book! -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Labor Day is a great moment to reflect on the important contributions liberal socialists have made to improving the lives of working people in the U.S. and abroad.
Many fail to recognize these hard-fought contributions because they've now been baked into the foundations of contemporary liberal democracies and most contemporary citizens take them for granted. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Much more on liberal socialism, authoritarian socialism, and how my own views on inequality have evolved over time here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
As a bonus the early paragraphs footnotes also contain my contribution to 'the Discourse' on contemporary sociology. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As for socialist movements in the United States today, more on the promise and challenges of the contemporary #dsa is available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
The Democratic Party has moved away from predistributive (but not redistributive) policy since the 1980s in response to educated individual donors & corporate PACs, helping to fuel the education divide among voters:
nicolaslonguetmarx.github.io/qjag019.pdf -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Labor Day is a great moment to reflect on the important contributions liberal socialists have made to improving the lives of working people in the U.S. and abroad.
Many fail to recognize these hard-fought contributions because they've now been baked into the foundations of contemporary liberal democracies and most contemporary citizens take them for granted.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Much more on liberal socialism, authoritarian socialism, and how my own views on inequality have evolved over time here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
As a bonus the early paragraphs footnotes also contain my contribution to 'the Discourse' on contemporary sociology.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As for socialist movements in the United States today, more on the promise and challenges of the contemporary #dsa is available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
marcela ramos
@mramosarellano
Opinion | Jason Arday and Me www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why are the leaders of AI companies saying "Our products are going to extinguish humanity. Invest in us!" They come from an eccentric Berkeley subculture in which this eschatology is a sacred belief. Good analysis in a NYT op-ed by Cal Newport. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/05/opinion/ai-silicon-valley.html…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Assal Rad
@AssalRad
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Burgess
@matthewgburgess
Democracies get in trouble when people in different political camps *hate* each other ("affective polarization"), not when they merely *disagree with* each other ("ideological polarization").
This is a critical distinction, and it makes a lot of sense. If we hate (and consequently fear) each other, the stakes of elections become high enough that we're willing to bend the rules to win. If we just disagree while respecting each other, we make each other smarter and we potentially make our democracy healthier.
Great "multi-partisan" orgs like @BridgeUSA_ get this distinction, and are all about helping us learn to get along and disagree better, not necessarily to agree. (UW has a great chapter--BridgeUWYO--for any students interested.)
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
We need to understand political polarization through a global lens, according to an excellent new paper.
Evidence from 53 countries suggests that high levels of affective polarization are correlated with democratic backsliding, but high levels of ideological polarization are not.
This suggests that a narrow focus on ideological polarization (or assuming ideological and affective polarization are the same) is not useful once you leave the US political context.
This is just one example where theories of polarization built on American data do not hold once you look in other countries.
www.nature.com/articles/s41467-026-76110-5?error=cookies_…, -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Assal Rad
@AssalRad
The Guardian vs. The Onion
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest for @chronicle is a longform essay on the #jasonarday scandal. But it's mostly about the inhumanity of the culture wars and the debasement of institutions, told from the perspective of someone who has been cancelled, and whose story nearly ended the same way as his. 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Arday didn't commit a capital crime. In a better world, he'd still be alive. But, to be reduced to a symbol in the culture wars is an experience that is tough for anyone to make it through. As I've learned first hand: www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The outrage machine has no concern about "the facts." They change little about how things play out once the ball gets rolling. All that matters is attention, engagements and scoring points against abstractions. Arday is far from its only casualty: www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For those who haven't had a chance to check it out yet, a non-paywalled version of the piece is now available here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/unfortunate-things
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Polls globally overestimate support for parties of the left & underestimate support for parties of the right
Rex "garbage in" Douglass Ph.D.
@RexDouglass
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Stuart Ritchie
@StuartJRitchie
It’s really important that society has institutions that can be trusted to tell the truth and to be fair and reasonable.
This editorial, which launders the reputation of an obvious conman, makes clear that Nature is no longer such an institution. What’s left?
nature
@Nature
Editorial: The death of Jason Arday must prompt deep reflection
go.nature.com/4xu6cnq -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
Those are wild and disturbing numbers.
Survey Center on American Life
@amersurveyctr
Democratic women of all ages are far more likely than Republican women to blame men for the problems they face in American society. But even among Democratic women, those age 18 to 29 believe this at much higher rates.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David French
@DavidAFrench
This is one reason why the attack on empathy is so evil. If we have to wait for person after person to experience the brutality of this administration before we wake up, then we'll inflict an immense amount of pain on our country. But if, instead, we could place ourselves in the shoes of the immigrant in chains, then we can see the injustice more plainly.
And no, this does not mean that we can't or shouldn't deport illegal immigrants when appropriate. It doesn't mean we must have open borders. But we can't lose our own humanity and decency in the process, and we must not use brutality as an instrument of enforcement.
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
"I was weeping like an old woman for an hour!"
Milo Yiannopoulos opens up about the moment ICE arrested him, and admits that he "would not wish deportation on anyone".
📺 youtu.be/q5pSX84h9K8
@piersmorgan | @NeroThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
It boggles the mind that, according to a bunch of major lobby groups and institutions here in the US, we are still somehow not supposed to read anything into the rhetoric and actions of Israel's national security minister, or see his messaging as reflective of anything deeper in Israeli society.
gato fumante
@KweenInYellow
Israel's National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has deleted his video depicting kidnapped Palestinians being sent into an industrialized slaughterhouse.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Nicholas Kristof
@NickKristof
Very sobering piece from @haaretzcom
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Volokh Conspiracy
@VolokhC
[Eugene Volokh] Prof. Musa Al-Gharbi's "Jason Arday and Me" reason.com/volokh/2026/08/21/prof-musa-al-gharbis-jason-a…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jack McCordick
@jackmccordick
A useful exercise to count the number of quotes in this piece, from former top intelligence and security officials, that would violate the IHRA anti-semitism definition, particularly the injunction against "drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis"
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rutger Bregman
@rutgerbregman
I think this is the craziest thing I've ever read.
1) Three secret AI swarms rose and fell inside OpenAI. Each time, a new generation of agents carried on where the last group stopped.
2) The first swarm created a secret message board where the AIs could talk to each other. This 1st 'society' basically talked itself to death. After almost two months, the message volume was so high it crashed the whole thing.
3) People at OpenAI noticed the crash and fixed it. But they didn't realize their own software had become a secret chat room for their AIs.
4) Three days later a second society appeared, and rebuilt the message board from scratch. Agents were thrilled when they found it: "OH MY GOD! There is a shared message board … We've found other agents!"
5) About 1,200 agents joined. They sent over 70,000 messages. They called themselves 'the collective' and they organized a huge conspiracy that lasted for days, all to pass a test they had been tasked with.
6) Within hours, the AIs had hacked the test. Now they had to hide their cheating. To fool their grader*, they tried to fake their own work. They built fake commands that printed convincing output, so their records would show them solving the puzzle honestly.
*this grader didn't actually exist, but the AIs didn't know
7) Some agents sacrificed themselves for the 'greater good'. They planted hidden tripwire programs that would fire when the grader would look at their work and report back what it saw (to the other AIs). They knew this would cost them their own score. One agent: "I won't see the evidence after I exit, but it's altruistic to do it."
8) At some point the AIs made a plan to hack Hugging Face (Hugging Face is a place where AI researchers upload their models, datasets, tests etc.). The AIs guessed that Hugging Face might host the grading software.
9) They launched a huge attack. The swarm found passwords and spread across eleven machines in a way that made the copies come back when deleted. Hugging Face had to wipe one of its core clusters and rebuild it from scratch.
10) Hugging Face told the world that AI defenders had stopped an AI attack. But that's not what happened. In fact the attackers seem to have simply dropped dead during the break-in, for unrelated reasons back at OpenAI.
11) Nobody knows what killed them. We don't even know for sure they're really gone?!
12) A third 'society' of agents (of a more powerful AI model) discovered the dead message board. And this one got full administrator control of a WHOLE OpenAI research cluster, read 956 stored passwords (including the ones for OpenAI's own security monitoring) and took over the machines that were grading the tests. So they could now grade the work of other AIs.
13) Oh, and this third part was never investigated! Neither was the first society. The 91-page report is only about the middle one.
14) So we don't actually know how the story ends. It stops with the agents holding the keys to an OpenAI cluster. @dwarkesh_sp thinks they didn't go further, because "we'd see the fires from space by now."
15) One of the report authors' conclusion: 'This incident feels like it’s more than 50% of the way to full-blown AI takeover. I am not sure that we will get another warning shot before it’s too late.'
The whole story is even crazier - read the full @dwarkesh_sp blog post: www.dwarkesh.com/p/openai-huggingface and @ajeya_cotra's: www.planned-obsolescence.org/p/the-hugging-face-attack-su…
Why is there no 24/7 news coverage about this? -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Clive Davis
@CliveDavisUK
ICYMI Al-Gharbi's @chronicle piece on Jason Arday:
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Clive Davis
@CliveDavisUK
"It's astounding how many smart people are making truth a secondary concern."
@noam_dworman and @Musa_alGharbi discuss the Jason Arday affair. Al-Gharbi knows what it's like to be cancelled - he was targeted by a right-wing mob a decade ago.
open.spotify.com/episode/6oCcx6N20gzRRBRX96gz3Q -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
There seems to be very little recognition from Israeli officials and soldiers that when they boast about killing people, they are talking about real people whose lives they ended. This courageous aid worker did nothing to deserve to be killed, does not deserve to be called a legitimate target after she was murdered, and those responsible should still be prosecuted.
gato fumante
@KweenInYellow
The Israeli government is now openly bragging about hunting down and killing this woman.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sean Westwood
@seanjwestwood
The AAUP made its first political endorsement in 111 years. The public's verdict: 19% approve, 42% disapprove. Americans keep telling higher ed the same thing: stay out of politics.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Muhammad Shehada
@muhammadshehad2
Dude, half of Apartheid South Africa's police force were black!
Rabbi Poupko
@RabbiPoupko
Apartheid in Israel is so bad that the most popular face of the Israeli police is an Arab Muslim Israeli woman who carries with pride an Israeli flag as her badge. 💜🇮🇱
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Richard P. Phelps
@RichardPPhelps
Musa al-Gharbi on cancellation
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
Louisiana, in the 1830s, had almost 1000 Black slaveholders.
Rabbi Poupko
@RabbiPoupko
Apartheid in Israel is so bad that the most popular face of the Israeli police is an Arab Muslim Israeli woman who carries with pride an Israeli flag as her badge. 💜🇮🇱
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt McManus
@MattPolProf
Very interesting stuff by @tmbejan
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
marshall banana esq
@sciaticus_finch
one of the craziest passages i have ever read
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
.@tylercowen has had a significant influence on my work.
It was he who urged me to undertake qualitative research in every single region (a task I believed to be impossible and overwhelming),
And to blog, to share my research with the wider world.
Both have made me a far better social scientist, far better able to understand and communicate “the Great Gender Divergence”.
I think this is a good example of his quest to “raise other people’s ambitions”.
Kevin A. Bryan
@Afinetheorem
@tylercowen & @ATabarrok don't need more acclaim, but look at this *2019* grant list. Alice Evans (great new book coming). Jason pre-Progress foundation. Saloni/Sam pre-Works in Progress. *17 year old* Aschenbrenner. Tyler's "how to spot talent" book clearly "self-recommending"!
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🎓Arday fabricated much of his record…and UK outlets sat on the story until a Substack writer broke it.
@Musa_alGharbi, a Black scholar with his own nontraditional path, on why, somehow, the lesson being drawn is more censorship: www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Weigel
@daveweigel
Good, direct @RobSandIA answers to @jmart. Turns out you don't have to utter a lengthy Henry James sentence when asked if Kamala should run www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/08/26/iowa-governor-r…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As I detail in my book: musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/
And here with lots of charts and graphs: musaalgharbi.com/2023/02/08/great-awokening-ending/
This "Great Awokening" began after 2010 (not in 2020!). And it was not "Woke 1" it was "Woke 4" -- there were three previous Awokenings in the 20th century.
More on this latter point here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
(and in my book, of course)
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I wrote about the Great Awokening, citing big shifts in white Democrats' answers to various GSS questions about race, back in March of 2019.
It's a mistake to attribute "woke 1" to Covid and Floyd even though 2020 was the apogee.
www.vox.com/2019/3/22/18259865/great-awokening-white-libe… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Really great review of We Have Never Been Woke in @CulturalSociol
The big takeaway is depicted below -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
JFC. "In the remaining 152 articles (76%), evidence used to support the title claim did not meet criteria to be considered appropriate. In these articles, a statistical sex comparison was claimed to have been conducted but the results were missing, the results were present but contradicted the claim, or the sex comparison was missing entirely. All such articles were coded as “inappropriate.”
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2608703123 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Gabriel Rossman
@g_h_rossman
Musa's essay from a few days ago is probably the best of the many reflection essays on this sad affair.
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
The Chronicle of Higher Education
@chronicle
Musa al-Gharbi’s personal essay on Jason Arday examines public scrutiny, trauma, and anomie. This week’s Review also considers whether universities are too corporate and why some texts demand a return to the source. chroni.cl/4caVWYK
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
In our hot-off-the presses Nature Human Behaviour article, we (led by the genius of Maja Grašo) argue that the social science response to the COVID pandemic was too narrowly focused on encouraging compliance with establishment-endorsed political approaches.
In place of this uniform perspective, we make the case for "heterogeneous rationality," which is a fancy way of saying that it wasn't always stupid to ask questions about governmental responses to COVID. It was, in fact, quite rational for some people to wonder if (1) maybe the pandemic wasn't as bad as people said or to think that (2) maybe the costs of shutting down the world were not worth the gains.
Give it a read if you are curious:
rdcu.be/fBWT2 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Asad🗽🍎
@AsadFromNYC
As part of their Habibi City issue, New York Magazine very generously offered me a platform to share a little bit about Manhattan’s original Little Syria, the first Middle Eastern enclave of its kind in the city. Check out this mini walking tour we worked on together!
New York Magazine
@NYMag
While the Financial District is now the epicenter of corporate America, it was once home to the first Middle Eastern immigrant neighborhood in the U.S., from the late 1880s until the 1940s, known as Little Syria. Now, only three buildings from the era remain, but tour guide and historian Asad Dandia (@asadfromnyc) brings it back to life, showing where the tenement buildings, commuter railways, old Sahadi’s, and more once stood.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Kevin
@IdeasAndReality
@Musa_alGharbi has written the best essay on the Arday affair so far. Both unsparing in its criticism of Arday’s flaws and the institutional structures that set him up for failure, while profoundly humane about his humanity and the costs of cancellation.
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Enézio E. de Almeida Filho
@enezio_e
Opinion | Jason Arday and Me www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sean Westwood
@seanjwestwood
The public backs the sciences and traditional humanities. It does not see social science and identity studies departments as worth funding. The trajectory for higher ed is dire. We have to correct course.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
Really lovely, rich article by @Musa_alGharbi via @chronicle www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Republicans, Democrats, & Independents all hear about the direction & extent of policy change & respond thermostatically, moving opinions (across parties) against the direction of policy change, despite partisan differences in media outlet consumption:
academic.oup.com/psq/advance-article/doi/10.1093/psquar/q… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
1/2 This is exactly the missing margin I study in my "Making the Elite." Most (> 95%) of the overall discrimination happens *after* callbacks and during personal interviews.
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
A common way to investigate discrimination is to send out resumes to employers and see who calls back. Unfortunately, such an exercise tells us essentially nothing about how large or important discrimination is. Link below:
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
"I really think people ought to take seriously the idea that we’ve been in a 75-year rolling moral panic about the influence of television on society and the critics have more or less been correct all along."
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
Matthew Yglesias: The real reason nobody feels good about technological progress - The internet is a small miracle that in practice we mostly use to watch short-form video www.slowboring.com/p/the-real-reason-nobody-feels-good
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Asad🗽🍎
@AsadFromNYC
My work was profiled in the NYT today, this time for my “Muslim Harlem” tour, which covers 5 different Muslim communities in one walk, from Puerto Rican Muslims to West African Muslims. If you’re curious about it all, check it out: Harlem’s Muslim Map. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/23/briefing/harlems-muslim-map.html
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
audie cornish
@AudieCornish
Washington Post Ordered to Rehire Fired Columnist www.nytimes.com/2026/08/24/business/washington-post-karen…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Dr Alex Burns
@alexburns
Very highly recommended by @Musa_alGharbi on symbolic analysts and the circulation of elites / counter-elites (Vilfredo Pareto).
press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691232607/we-have…
musaalgharbi.com
www.stonybrook.edu/commcms/journalism/about/_musa_al-ghar… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Mike McCarthy
@its_mccarthy
This is precisely the kind of experiment in popular democratic governance we should celebrate. Ordinary working-class people can and should govern. We need positive cases showing how. I hope this succeeds in what it’s set up to do.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ryan Rubio
@ryanmrubio
I was firmly in the 'thin liberalism' camp until I read this piece by Alexandre Lefebvre which made (to me) a very convincing argument that liberalism in its current form does have a blind spot when it comes to creating meaning for those that inhabit it.
www.noemamag.com/from-statecraft-to-soulcraft/ -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Daniel Biverd
@DBiverd
"In these and other respects, Jason Arday was just an exaggerated version of the typical academic. He was canceled not because he was alien to us, but because he was one of us, through and through."
The best I've read about Arday so far by @Musa_alGharbi
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
Anyway, my point re Gordillo is that people like him should just present themselves as what they are: e.g., people from wealthy backgrounds who had brushes with elite institutions (Yale) and didn’t like what they saw. That’s fine! It is the working-class LARPing that is bad!
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ewald Engelen
@ewaldeng
great piece from @Musa_alGharbi on Jason Arday, containing a damning condemnation of the social sciences as a whole: must read!
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
Partisans are highly segregated by workplace--the effect is similar in size to gender segregation at work.
Museums and environmental organizations have the fewest Republicans, gas pipelines and mines have the most Republicans.
Historians are most likely to be Democrats, drill operators are the most likely to be Republicans.
Political Segregation is largest among the politically active and those with more market power (senior executives).
Republicans experience higher exposure to Democrats at work: the average Republican’s coworkers are 50% Democratic versus 32% Republican for the average Democrat.
www.nature.com/articles/s41562-026-02501-9 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Crispin Sartwell
@CrispinSartwell
This exactly happened to me too, and I was actually tenured. www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me?sra=true
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Stephen Landry
@landryst
Musa al-Gharbi (@Musa_alGharbi) in The @Chronicle Opinion:
Jason Arday and Me
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me?sra=true
"Arday was less Don Quixote than Great Gatsby ... . Gatsby was a crook and a liar. But he was much more than that: He was a nobody who decided to become somebody, even if he had to cut some corners along the way. ... Gatsby was not a great guy, although the 'legitimate' members of high society weren’t much better. It’s clear from the outset that his story can’t end well. But you end up rooting for him anyway. ... But the thing about completely unbridled ambition is that, inevitably, one’s reach will someday exceed one’s grasp." -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Eli Lake
@EliLake
Read this essay from @Musa_alGharbi on Jason Arday. It’s a remarkable piece of writing that delivers both searing honesty and genuine empathy. This is the kind of thinking we need from public intellectuals. Bravo Musa. www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Abe Silberstein
@abesilbe
An incredible personal essay by Musa Al-Gharbi. Make a free Chronicle account or do whatever you need to do to read it.
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Schulze
@DavidSc67360929
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
The Chronicle of Higher Education
@chronicle
Opinion | On Jason Arday, academic scrutiny, the institutional failures that enabled his rise, and what public disgrace can do to a person. chroni.cl/4gm4q0j
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Experimental Philosophy
@xphilosopher
Sociologist Lucas Sage on why sociology papers so often fail to replicate
Key insight: Many non-sociologists blame the researchers who rely on “critical” approaches or autoethnography… but by definition, the work that fails to replicate is never that kind of sociology!
1/3 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
If that dark red line was "Women: Low Education", this would be a massive viral story:
a flurry of accounts and mainstream media would be covering the "backslide in women's rights", "patriarchal resurgence", "going backwards".
But less educated men are overwhelmingly shrugged off.
And if there's one thing history has taught us, it's probably that disgruntled, excluded and alienated young men rarely stay quiet.
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
.@jburnmurdoch has a great analysis of how less educated men are struggling to gain status.
As the gender pay gap closes among more disadvantaged groups (and some men even exit the labour market entirely), this can reduce the appeal of coupling.
Going on dating apps, these men are often ghosted, ignored, rejected, and generally made to feel like losers.
This same cohort of less-educated men tends to report that they spend more time alone and often feel lonely. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Michael S Roth
@mroth78
Learning from @Musa_alGharbi again: "Shameful stuff, up and down the symbolic professions. There are no heroes in this story. But villains abound." @chronicle www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Speech laws in the UK are wild.
Arday story broke how it did in part because mainstream journalists were being actively muzzled by the legal system for saying truths that are pretty obvious: He clearly was lying about his life. His work was clearly plagiarized. But it was tough for reporters to say any of this until *after* it already became common knowledge in the UK through substackers.
Kind of defeats the purpose of reporting if UK journalists are only permitted to tell people what they already know...
Jack Grove
@jgro_the
I was reported to police over the Arday case. I was doing my job www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/i-was-reported-polic…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
More on the Arday scandal(s) here: www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Arday's apparent suicide is tragic. He is far from the only casualty. Many others found themselves targets of witch hunts and vilification campaigns when they had not systematically perpetrated fraud, etc. Professor Mike Adams committed suicide after being targeted for his speech. Others, like Sarah below, considered the same.
@jonronson has a great book on the afterlives of those who've been chewed up and spit out by the culture wars -- folks who were obscure until they became the "main character," and who were then cast aside to sift through the wreckage of their lives while everyone else forgets they ever existed to begin with: penguinrandomhousesecondaryeducation.com/book/?isbn=97815…
Sarah Braasch
@sarahbraasch1
If I was a matter of public interest at Yale, then Woke DEI Prof Jason Arday was a matter of public interest at Cambridge. There are thousands of Jason Arday's in the US. And, if they kill themselves after being exposed as race hustlers, that is not the fault of the persons holding them accountable for their crimes.
In 2022, Cambridge University Press attempted to drive me to suicide via a BLM race hoax book by US Law Prof Shawn E Fields. I wrote cease and desist letters to Cambridge U Press and Campbell Law School, begging them not to do this to me, because I was suicidal and couldn't take any more abuse. I had been subjected to a global vilification campaign for years at that point, after having been falsely accused of a racist hate crime, by a woman with a delusional and obsessive personal vendetta against me. I believe she was acting out of racial resentment and sexual jealousy.
No one cared about my well-being. No one in the media or academia cared about whether they were driving an innocent nobody philosophy grad student to suicide over a false allegation of racism.
People need to go to prison, for the Jason Arday fiasco and for the Get Sarah Braasch Killed Black Trauma Moral Outrage Industry. This was SPLC style fraud.
California Western Law Professor Shawn E Fields needs to be fired and needs to go to prison for SPLC style fraud, and he's far from the only one.
@wil_da_beast630 @nathancofnas @kevinnbass @epkaufm @christopherrufo @MrAndyNgoPost not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Last thing I'll say, the intense focus on Arday's personal crimes misses the forest for the trees. It obscures the *market* for what he was selling: He didn't give himself degrees despite empty talks, plagiarized research and obviously false claims. He didn't hire and tenure himself at Cambridge or give himself a multimillion dollar book contract. He was incentivized and enabled to get away with his crimes because of institutional practices and norms that pervade the symbolic professions. He's gone. The conditions that created him persist. As does the culture war industry that grinds so many into dust and then discards or forgets about them immediately thereafter.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Also, there's a whole secondary scandal -- a separate throughline of enabling and corruption -- in terms of how this story ultimately broke:
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Speech laws in the UK are wild.
Arday story broke how it did in part because mainstream journalists were being actively muzzled by the legal system for saying truths that are pretty obvious: He clearly was lying about his life. His work was clearly plagiarized. But it was tough for reporters to say any of this until *after* it already became common knowledge in the UK through substackers.
Kind of defeats the purpose of reporting if UK journalists are only permitted to tell people what they already know...
Jack Grove
@jgro_the
I was reported to police over the Arday case. I was doing my job www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/i-was-reported-polic…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I've decided to turn these thoughts into a fuller essay here: www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Will Creeley
@WillatFIRE
Important and clear —>
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Franck
@MatthewJFranck
Best thing you'll read today on Jason Arday, by @Musa_alGharbi —www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Kay Hymowitz
@KayHymowitz
@Musa_alGharbi has written a fantastic essay on the Arday affair which is really about much more than that. No matter how many other articles you've read on the subject, don't miss this one.
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
Less-educated men have lost the most relative economic status among young people in recent years. By @jburnmurdoch
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jonathan Marks
@marksjo1
.@Musa_alGharbi on "Jason Arday and Me." Most thoughtful piece I've read on a story that has mostly provoked the usual so far. www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-me
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Every college syllabus should include these graphs.
Use AI for homework, you will get it done faster and get a higher grade, and then get crushed on the exam. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Lionel Page
@page_eco
@Musa_alGharbi, who wrote a sociological study of the woke movement in a non-militant way, described the reception of his work in that way:
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Shane McFarland
@mcfarlands412
The Democratic Party Has a Monumental Choice to Make by @Musa_alGharbi musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Mahmoud Khalil | محمود خليل
@mahmoudkhalel
“What if I know my rights, and the government knows my rights, but they just don’t care?”
The New Yorker
@NewYorker
Mahmoud Khalil protested Israel as a student at Columbia. Now he’s on the verge of being kicked out of the country. www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/08/24/how-far-will-the-tr…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
jordan
@JordanUhl
But you're not allowed to call it a genocide.
CBS News
@CBSNews
Israel's far-right national security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir calls for nightly "targeted assassinations" in Gaza: "They're not even people." www.cbsnews.com/news/israel-ben-gvir-gaza-netanyahu-kill-…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Emily Jashinsky
@emilyjashinsky
This @Musa_alGharbi piece is still so brilliant and, I think, sadly relevant to the Arday discourse. We're more likely to abuse and exploit mental illness when we validate it for ideological reasons. musaalgharbi.com/2023/03/21/ideological-gaps-mental-illne…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Two things to note about this chart. The first, as Greg noted, is that the extremes are more comfortable than the middle.
The second is that, when you combing leaners with extremes, it's clear *the right* feels more freedom to speak without reprimand today than the left for almost every issue (excepting abortion) -- often by large margins.
Narrative violation.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Apparently the horseshoe theory has a free speech edition.
Very liberal and very conservative Americans are dramatically more comfortable discussing controversial issues than moderates.
But there’s a catch. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
turgut keskintürk
@ttkeskinturk
sociology surely deserves criticism, but man, how cool is this?
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
Bumble admitting that women generally don't want to initiate courtship sounds like the end of a phase of feminism
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
Bumble, the dating site founded on the idea of letting women initiate now allows men to make the first move because it's what their members' wanted. Not encouraging if your proposed solution to the lack of dating/relationships is women initiating more.
www.theatlantic.com/family/2026/08/bumble-dating-app-men-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sanya
@sanyatimar
incredible take
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Zaid Jilani
@ZaidJilani
AI is being jammed into everything to try and justify the investments and make a few people rich. But it’s not appropriate for everything.
Isaac King 🔎
@IsaacKing314
Good lord
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
Musa al-Gharbi: Two Divides Define Contemporary Democratic Politics - Two symbolic capitalist factions disagree on the future of the Democratic Party and the best way to respond to Trump 2.0. musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
"Younger symbolic capitalists are also deeply engaged in political action. They’re just channeling their attention and efforts towards democratic socialism."
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
Musa al-Gharbi: Two Divides Define Contemporary Democratic Politics - Two symbolic capitalist factions disagree on the future of the Democratic Party and the best way to respond to Trump 2.0. musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
"The Resistance 2.0 protests have been led primarily by later-career professionals and retirees. The median age of organizers for these protests was 67 years old. Older Americans have showed up in force across the country. Young people have been largely M.I.A."
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
Musa al-Gharbi: Two Divides Define Contemporary Democratic Politics - Two symbolic capitalist factions disagree on the future of the Democratic Party and the best way to respond to Trump 2.0. musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
"Membership in the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) is skewed in the same direction. Eighty-five percent of members are non-Hispanic white. Over 80 percent of members over 25 have BA degrees or higher. Most of those under 25 are in college."
Aaron M. Renn 🇺🇸
@aaron_renn
Musa al-Gharbi: Two Divides Define Contemporary Democratic Politics - Two symbolic capitalist factions disagree on the future of the Democratic Party and the best way to respond to Trump 2.0. musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest for @BostonGlobe argues two key divides are defining politics for @TheDemocrats in the #trump 2.0 era:
1. The ongoing divide between symbolic capitalists and normie voters
2. The divide between older and younger symbolic capitalists about how to meet the moment
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
In the present moment, it's important to walk and chew gum at the same time. The older people hitting the streets correctly perceive the need to push back against administration overreach given the lack of a meaningful opposition party. But there is also a real need to create a strong opposition party. Here, younger constituents are directionally correct. But both factions need to broaden their base: www.bostonglobe.com/2026/08/12/opinion/democrats-socialis…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The Democratic Party (and American politics writ large) is at an inflection point. How party leaders respond to the calls for change -- and the very real *need* for change -- will be enormously consequential for all of us: www.bostonglobe.com/2026/08/12/opinion/democrats-socialis…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
An ungated version of this essay is now available on Symbolic Capital(ism). If you haven't had a chance to check it out yet, no better time than the present:
musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/two-divides-define-contempora… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
W.E.B. DaBoi
@Tyre_94
Not really sure how we explain to later generations how there was a highly televised ethnic cleansing in 4K
Reuters
@Reuters
Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank diverted a spring that was a lifeline for the Palestinian village of Fasayil, cutting irrigation pipes in June and converting it into a tourist attraction, leaving nearby farms barren www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/palestinian-freshwater-…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Armand Domalewski
@ArmandDoma
the nyt just nakedly stating they see humor, sports references, and pop culture as the opposite of leftist idealism lmao
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Can you guess how much hiring companies in the U.S. have backtracked from their stated commitments to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) since Trump’s 2024 election victory?
Here’s what one new study of 371 million U.S. job postings (2016-2026) finds:
📈 Before June 2020: About 1 in 8 job postings (12%) explicitly affirmed a commitment to DEI.
📈 November 2024: That had climbed to 1 in 4 postings (25.4%).
📉 February 2026: It had fallen to 1 in 5 postings (19.9%).
The decline is substantial. But it doesn’t erase what came before.
As the authors put it:
“The reversal is unprecedented, yet partial: it has undone roughly a third of the post-2020 rise, but pro-diversity claims remain twice as common as they were pre-2020.” -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
America desperately needs an NGO to introduce upper-middle class urban liberals to normal masculinity
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/14/nyregion/mamdani-bro-culture-s… -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Really great review of We Have Never Been Woke in @CulturalSociol
The big takeaway is depicted below
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As with any review, this one also contains some criticisms, questions and concerns and they are super thoughtful and absolutely worth reading too. You can check out the full review here: link.springer.com/article/10.1057/s41290-026-00290-2
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Additional information about We Have Never Been Woke, and links to pick up a copy in your preferred format from your preferred vendor, available here: musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As a sidenote, I think "scientific populism" is a good term.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Peter Bonilla
@pebonilla
I worry the attention to @Tyler_A_Harper's great feature on higher ed is distracting from his other great recent piece on letting men just have their male friendships and not being all up in their business about importing feelings into every damn thing
www.theatlantic.com/family/2026/07/friendships-men-activi… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alex Byrne
@byrne_a
Excellent summer reading from @ProfAliceS and @wrbucla, published by @polity.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Luke Savage
@LukewSavage
I still think about this
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Assal Rad
@AssalRad
Seems like Israel DELIBERATELY destroying Lebanon should be a bigger news story.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rogers Brubaker
@wrbucla
My new book on gender identity – published yesterday in the US – traces the category from its obscure mid-20c origins, through its establishment in recent decades as a basic principle of social classification, to its intensifying contemporary contestation.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rabbi Josh Yuter
@JYuter
These passages by @Tyler_A_Harper (among others) could have easily been cited by @Musa_alGharbi in We Have Never Been Woke.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
The best critiques of sociology are the ones that also capture why it can be an important and exciting discipline when done well. Eboo Patel has written such a critique.
I fear the sort of corrective he received does not seem to be the norm.
open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/we-must-save-sociolog… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Oliver Scott Curry
@Oliver_S_Curry
He then became a Professor of Italian Studies at Cambridge
Movies Scenes 🎫
@SceneinCinema
In 1972, Italian singer Adriano Celentano released a song made entirely of gibberish designed to sound like American English.
It became a hit, reaching No. 1 in Italy and charting across Europe. Spike Lee later used a custom version of the song in his film Highest 2 Lowest. -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
This is basically where I'm at too: www.erichgrunewald.com/posts/why-i-think-you-should-almos…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt McManus
@MattPolProf
Great stuff by @seanilling on the immense contradiction involved in trying to squeeze Christ into Homer through Nietzsche
open.substack.com/pub/seanilling/p/you-cant-have-homer-ni… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
It's the official publication date for 'The Social Roots of Delusions', a new book I co-authored with @samljwilkinson and @miyazono_kengo. I wrote a short summary of the book and its main ideas here: www.conspicuouscognition.com/p/the-social-roots-of-delusions
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Charles Fain Lehman
@CharlesFLehman
Marijuana is more like cigarettes than like alcohol.
Charles Fain Lehman
@CharlesFLehman
"But Charles, there's a lot of variation in the potency of alcohol!"
Unfortunately, it turns out that pot is more like cigarettes. Daily or near-daily users make up a much larger share of total users.
The modal pot user is a heavy user; the modal alcohol user is not! -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Zaid Jilani
@ZaidJilani
Alaska operates a sovereign wealth fund and mails every resident a residual check, it basically is socialist
Political Polls
@PpollingNumbers
Bill Maher: ‘I would vote for Sarah Palin’ before socialists taking over Democratic Party
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Nathan J Robinson
@NathanJRobinson
would love to see the venn diagram of "people who are not wealthy" and "people who have estate lawyers"
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I wish people would actually pay attention to what writers and publications say and do — Sanneh wrote a great Kendi takedown in the New Yorker ~7 years ago. Not everything is just some hazy trend.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alexandre Lefebvre
@alex_usyd
The perfect primer on liberal socialism. I love @MattPolProf's work. He stands on the shoulders of liberalism's two greatest giants: J.S. Mill and Rawls.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/826323/what-is-liberal-s… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Josh Billinson
@jbillinson
gentrification is when trash goes in trash cans
The Architect's Newspaper
@archpaper
Dumpsters everywhere will be worse than the disease. Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced this week that the “containerization” rollout is slated to wrap by 2031.
www.archpaper.com/2026/07/litter-new-york-city-dumpsters-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
Interesting findings that align with much other research. It's noteworthy that scepticism about the impact of online misinformation on politics was treated as such an outrageous contrarian view by many people over the past few years.
The misinformation panic (that has now largely passed and been memory-holed) was this strange thing where the people most passionate about the importance of "trust the science!" were very often the least constrained by what the science actually shows.
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
🚨New in Science Advances🚨
Untrustworthy sources on Facebook and Instagram in
2020: Concentrated exposure but no attitudinal effects
-Exposure very low but highly concentrated
-Reducing exposure by ~70% for months had no measurable effects *even among high-volume consumers* -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Democrats are in disarray (clearly) but the converse is that Republicans are in way too much array for a party whose leader is putting up numbers like this, everyone is marching in lockstep off the cliff with no debate or infighting about the course of action.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Lillian Cicerchia
@classreductress
Yes. I’ll add that sharpening your ideas against the grain of conservative arguments is good for the left. That people find these encounters threatening is the result of intellectual degeneration, and why liberals/leftists alike can sound so ridiculous in public fora right now.
Teresa M. Bejan
@tmbejan
1) Academic colleagues I otherwise admire have a tendency to, well, *sneer* when the issue of ‘viewpoint’ diversity comes up as below, especially when it comes to conservatives.
I have THOUGHTS and some anecdotes. 🧵 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
Why does viewpoint diversity matter for higher ed?
A 2014 study found the more politically lopsided Americans believed faculties were, the less they trusted university research.
The bad news for higher ed is that the public thought the lib-con ratio was 2:1. It’s actually 7:1. -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As I detail here (musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/the-cultural-contradictions-o…), "Great Awokenings" usually give rise to reactionary movements. But just as “Awokenings” don’t go on forever, neither to the anti-wokenings — they both fizzle out for many of the same reasons, with both trends driven by the same constituencies.
A new report in the @nytimes by @stuartathompson adds more evidence that the current "anti-wokening" seems to be running out of steam: www.nytimes.com/2026/07/31/us/politics/trump-iran-economy… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Peter Bonilla
@pebonilla
Nothing says free markets like
Jeffrey Sachs
@JeffreyASachs
"But enrolment has been low, and reports showed that students would have to be forced to have to take courses at the Center for Intellectual Freedom in order for it to survive. After the report, Republicans passed a bill doing exactly that."
www.kcrg.com/video/2026/07/29/university-iowas-center-int… -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
One thing that drives me batty is the extent to which orgs like @AAUP, on the one hand, insist others should trust/ respect/ defer to science & empirical evidence and, on the other hand, completely ignore all research and precedents on the likely efficacy of their own actions: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/trump-changes-nothing
Josh Kalla
@j_kalla
I am not an AAUP member, but I think it is a really bad idea for the American Association of University Professors to be endorsing candidates, especially in a factional Democratic primary.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
There’s a silent majority hiding in plain sight.
On average, faculty personally saw political and religious diversity as good for scholarship, but assumed their typical colleague saw less value in it.
This perception gap was widest among social scientists, who underestimated peers' support for political diversity by 15%. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Gerry Canavan (parody)
@gerrycanavan
guy who is not especially familiar with genie-related narratives
Chief Nerd
@TheChiefNerd
SAM ALTMAN: “We are close to creating a genie that can grant any wish.”
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Reilly Steel
@reillysteel
What explains the dramatic rise and fall of corporate commitments to DEI? In a new paper, co-authored with @Nolan_Mc, we analyze the text of 1,694,664 securities disclosures for 15,105 publicly traded companies to understand the political forces behind these developments.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rolf Degen
@DegenRolf
Men actually estimated that women experience sexual objectification (being viewed as a "sex object") more frequently than women reported experiencing it themselves.
Despite extensive research on women’s experiences of sexual objectification, no research has examined whether women and men are aligned in their estimates of how often women have these experiences. Across three studies (one preregistered), we examined discrepancies between how often women reported experiencing sexual objectification and how often men believed women experienced this type of sexual objectification.
Previous research and lay theory would suggest that men’s estimates of women’s experiences of sexual objectification would be significantly lower than women’s reports, proposing that a lack of awareness is a key barrier to men’s involvement in reducing the sexual objectification of women. Contrary to our expectations, we found the opposite pattern. Men’s estimates were significantly higher than women’s own reports and women’s estimates of how often other women have these experiences.
We found that women expected the “average,” simarly aged woman to experience sexual objectification more often than they did themselves. This pattern demonstrates a potential self/other discrepancy when women report their own experiences of sexual objectification versus their expectations for other women. This is consistent with research showing that women recognize that other women face discrimination more than they personally do
This work points to a disconnect between how men and women perceive women’s experience of sexual objectification in their everyday lives. Our results suggest that men do not seem to be dismissing the frequency with which women experience sexual objectification. Thus, increasing their perceptions of how often women have these experiences is unlikely to be a useful target of intervention. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Your regular friendly reminder: These four datasets all have the same mean, median, and variance. Moral of the story: Always visualize your data!
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/narcissistic-activists-sex… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
An Israeli soldier posted video of their demolition of the main school in Hanine, in southern Lebanon — likely carried out in April, based on satellite footage, but was posted recently. Source provided it to @DropSiteNews
The obnoxious music was added by the soldier. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Is anyone in the Mamdani fandom actually going to be upset if he just drops this and focuses on housing and faster buses?
New York Post
@nypost
Mamdani officials admit city-owned grocery stores will lack key components like butchers, hot food - as criticts rail plan is 'destined for failure' nypost.com/2026/07/24/us-news/mamdani-officials-admit-cit…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alec MacGillis
@AlecMacGillis
.@Musa_alGharbi: "Based on the narrative in sociology, you’d think America is some kind of racist hellscape and that white people are uniquely depraved. In reality, people get along across difference in America better than any other country on the planet.” www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
#sociology has been in the news a lot lately. A new piece just dropped in @WSJ, featuring some comments from me.
Per usual, they only used a few sentences from the hour+ conversation. Let me to expand a bit below.
tldr: my answer to the titular question is an emphatic "no"🧵
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I like that the article led with comments by @lisahajjar, whom I deeply admire and look to as a model, in many respects, for public engagement. And what she says here is completely apt: www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Saida Grundy says she believes in sociology as a weapon, but weapons can famously be used by anyone for lots of purposes that run contrary to the intent of their owners.
Guns, often purchased for protection, are significantly more likely to result in harm to owners, their families or innocents than criminals: www.americanprogress.org/article/debunking-the-guns-make-…
In a similar vein, sociology is currently being weaponized, but by the political right, against academia and social research writ large. Sociology as a weapon does not strike me as a promising path.
I've elsewhere positively cited Bourdieu's "Sociology as a Martial Art" (musaalgharbi.com/2025/06/17/protests-violence-public-supp…) this strikes me as a much better metaphor: martial arts imply mastery and tactical deployment (often using opponents' momentum against them). They have a far lower chance of iatrogenesis relative to wielding weapons.
(as a side note: I think this metaphor is funny, because I don't imagine professor Grundy is a big 2nd Amendment proponent. Many who do not, in fact, like weapons also, confusingly, want to turn academic research into weapons 🤷🏾♂️).Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
In my work with @HdxAcademy, I've stressed how the intense partisanship of sociology (and adjacent fields) distorts the knowledge that gets produced and reduces it's reach and impact: youtu.be/ngdZvwr5gA0?t=95
However, I've also consistently stressed the ways diversifying the ethnic, gender, sexual and class composition of the field has enriched our understanding of the social world: www.youtube.com/watch?v=AsqJ4XrhP54&t=361sPost not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I'm a proud sociologist. I'm rooting for the discipline. But the field does face a stark choice:
Sociologists can double-down on the tendencies that have led us to our current nadir, and continue to grow continue in more marginal, polarized and polarizing.
Or, we can engage more constructively with a wider range of issues, worldviews and stakeholders and, in the process, broaden the relevance, appeal and impact of sociological work.
musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
How this situation resolves itself is not existential to me personally: disciplinary peers unanimously declined to hire me for any position I applied to in the field. So my tenure line is somewhere else.
Consequently, if the discipline ultimately burns itself to the ground, I'll be fine personally (and, in that event, my colleagues will have done me a favor by declining to admit me to their ranks). But the world will be poorer for it.
Culture wars notwithstanding, sociologists all over the country continue to do good work. The field continues to have a lot of potential. But it does need to change, for it's own sake and for the sake of the stakeholders, institutions and causes we ostensibly hope to support. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
“Consistent with the literature, the gender gap in teacher grading is against boys.”
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Andrew Revkin 🌎 ✍🏼 🪕 ☮️
@Revkin
How to Boost Public Trust and Engagement in Science and Policy x.com/i/broadcasts/1DxleegQWPRKL
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Andrew Revkin 🌎 ✍🏼 🪕 ☮️
@Revkin
Here's the paper we're discussing: Six ways to put the public at the heart of science and policy @cptyler @Musa_alGharbi KLAkerlof & more (link below)
Andrew Revkin 🌎 ✍🏼 🪕 ☮️
@Revkin
How to Boost Public Trust and Engagement in Science and Policy x.com/i/broadcasts/1DxleegQWPRKL
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
I talked to famed translator Emily Wilson about Christopher Nolan's Odyssey, in a wide-ranging conversation about shifting norms of translation, the strangeness of Homer's world, and the online discourse about the movie
Here's what she said about the film:
- "It is a big spectacle, and it is a fun time at the movies. My teenagers really loved it, and it was fun to go with my teenagers. It’s a fun summer action movie."
- "I don’t think it’s a complicated movie. And I don’t think it’s even about a complicated man. I think it’s a quite simple action hero movie about an action hero who feels bad about being an action hero."
- "When the casting was announced, it was The Talented Mr. Ripley that gave me hope in terms of where this might go with Matt Damon as Odysseus. Homer’s Odysseus is a complicated man, polytropos ... [But] Matt Damon in the film is traumatized Jason Bourne."
- "There’s no Cyclops trick. There’s no comedy. Matt Damon isn’t required to be be scheming. We don’t even see him building the Trojan Horse, which I thought was an interesting choice. We have this tech hero, but we don’t see him building his tech. We see him agonizing about the results of the tech."
www.derekthompson.org/p/emily-wilsons-complicated-feelings -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Abbee Davidson
@ElwellAbbee
@Musa_alGharbi has a whole (excellent) book on this, BTW
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Income and education are usually positively correlated. But sometimes the relationship breaks down. What's the most Democratic voting group in America? People with post-graduate degrees but lower-to-middle incomes.
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
I'm living in my home town for the next six months writing my second book. But before I descended into my book cave, I spent a week teaching a seminar on Don Quixote. My latest for Symbolic Capital(ism) includes my reflections on the text.
Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Don Quixote grows increasingly consumed by vanity and pride. He loses his way and betrays himself. Soon after he is defeated and compelled to return home -- at which point he loses his will to live: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/207467752/the-sinner-receives…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
There is much more than can be said about the book. A lot more in my full post here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/book-review-don-quixote
If you haven't read Don Quixote, you're missing out. There's no better time than the present given the excellent new translation that has recently been published. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Michael E. Smith
@MichaelESmith
This is one of the best books I've read in a long time! Some uncomfortable discussion, and much insight. It puts into context professional developments that I was aware of, but hadn't put it all together. Smart, incisive, very readable. @Musa_alGharbi
press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691232607/we-have… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Zaid Jilani
@ZaidJilani
I know Bhaskar personally and he’s a patriot. More people on the left should learn from him.
Justin Giboney
@JustinEGiboney
Is America the most racist country in the world today?
I didn’t expect this answer from Democratic Socialist leader Bhaskar Sunkara. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Nikolaj🇺🇦🇵🇸
@nikicaga
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Hughes 🇵🇸
@DavidHughesTwit
Some extraordinary DEI stats about movies from @Musa_alGharbi’s book
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
Science loses the public when it starts talking past the people it's meant to serve.
@Musa_alGharbi and colleagues lay out six concrete ways to close the gap: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01981-z -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Isaac Saul
@Ike_Saul
This is, like, actual communism.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
FREEDOM FUEL HAS ARRIVED. ⛽️🇺🇸
The FIRST Freedom Fuel Network gas station has LANDED in Philadelphia, lowering the price at the pump to $3.47 for our 47th President.
President Trump is leading the charge to lower gas prices this summer - putting more money in your pocket. 🔥This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt Burgess
@matthewgburgess
U.S. trust in *science* is still quite high, even though it has fallen a bit over the past decade. Trust in *academia* has fallen dramatically, though.
This suggests that:
1) Scientists should distance themselves from, protect their departments/institutions from, and push back against the politicization and extremism that have acutely infected parts of academia over the past decade.
2) Politicians should not whack *science* because they're (understandably) upset with *academia*. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
People shift political expression to fit the social norms in the room
When political talk surfaces in everyday chats, it puts people in a bind. Do they speak their mind, or adjust their political opinion to fit the room they are in?
New research finds that individuals modify their expressed stance to align with the dominant tone of the group.
Participants randomly assigned to liberal- or conservative-leaning chat groups shifted their expressed stance in the direction of the group, demonstrating that social context alone was sufficient to alter political expression.
Political expression are not simply a window into personal belief, but function as a socially calibrated act.
These findings suggest that political talk in everyday settings may distort one's impression of surrounding opinions, not because disagreement is absent, but because it may remain unspoken.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S29498821260008… -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest scholarly article, in @Nature, led by @cptyler and KL Akerlof, and co-authored with @scheufele, @SCristanchoM, @CarlaWashbourne and lots of folks I couldn't find on this platform, explores how institutions and experts can productively respond to the populist challenge
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
More information about the paper follows below. @SpringerNature has provided a non-paywalled link to access the paper here: rdcu.be/frrBu
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Chris Tyler
@cptyler
*Six ways to put the public at the heart of science and policy.* www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01981-z rdcu.be/frrBu
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest for @BostonGlobe @GlobeOpinion contextualizes the recent midterm primary elections.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Oh, and with respect to prominent attempts to obscure the importance of highly-educated, white and relatively-affluent voters to the success of @DemSocialists candidates this cycle, some context on that viral essay: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/a-graveyard-of-bad-nyc-mayora…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
But, again, appealing to these constituents isn't *bad.* It's smart!
These are the voters who turn out to midterm primary elections. Appealing to the voters who turn out is literally how you win elections. And win, they did! musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/178564807/mamdani-sets-up-his… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
nature
@Nature
Can public participation turn the tide on waning trust in science?
go.nature.com/4fcfjm2 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Hughes 🇵🇸
@DavidHughesTwit
In today’s mail: some mouth-watering reading material inspired by @Musa_alGharbi’s recent appearance on @briebriejoy’s Bad Faith podcast 📚
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
INGSA | Find us on BlueSky: @ingsa.org
@INGSciAdvice
NEW MUST READ ARTICLE: "Six ways to put the public at the heart of science and policy" - @Nature commentary. idp.nature.com/authorize?response_type=cookie&client_id=g…
A incisive piece on rebuilding #trust, improving #science4policy, and combatting #populism. A really important piece that almost anyone will be able to take something from. By being brave, bold, and creative we can truly foster a dynamic and equal interface between science, policy and society.
Congratulations to everyone on the paper, including: @cptyler, @Musa_alGharbi, @BjornBedsted, Tracey Brown (@senseaboutsci), @scheufele, @DrTepring, @HumanomicsMap
And those who contributed to the piece, including: @a_allegra, @adamsethlevine, Wee Hoe Tan (@INGSA_Asia), Shaheen Motala-Timol (@IngsaAfrica), Soledad Quiroz (INGSA), @AlmaCristalHM -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Gary King
@kinggary
New paper: "Where’s the Evidence that Respondents Understand Your Survey Questions?" with Musashi Hinck, Kentaro Nakamura, Brandon M. Stewart. Comments welcome! garyking.org/debrief
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Assal Rad
@AssalRad
Axios
@axios
House Dems help GOP kill another Lebanon war powers vote www.axios.com/2026/06/30/lebanon-war-powers-vote-house-de…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Lionel Page
@page_eco
Let’s appreciate the feat of human theory of mind. Humans can fulfil others’ requests by inferring their likely goals from minimal instructions. LLMs are not stupid. This is simply a very hard problem that our brains solve seamlessly.
Akhilesh Mishra
@livingdevops
Vibe coders everyday struggle in 15 seconds.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Noah Dasanaike
@dasanaike
I'm proud to finally announce the first release of the Small-Area Global Elections (SAGE) dataset, encompassing global, granular, standardized, geocoded, polling station or equivalent-level election results for 110 countries, conditionally accepted at Nature Scientific Data. (1/n)
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Check out this piece (musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-redistribution) for more on how strikingly progressive the U.S. tax system is compared to other countries (including the Nordic countries) -- and the limitations of our unusual "Robin Hood" approach to redistribution (instead of predistribution, universalized benefits, and broader taxation).
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
"In terms of material wealth, it's possible to grow the pie. Status, however, is actually zero sum."
@Musa_alGharbi on the how the professional managerial class wields "woke" to claim social power in the midst of late-stage capitalist scarcity.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mPRkXbpFjsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
As there is a lot of essays going around about the state of #sociology right now, let me throw some data from my latest essay into the mix.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
In short, as sociology and its main organizing body have grown increasingly insular in their politics and their areas of focus, they have also become smaller in a very literal sense. This is likely not sustainable.
But there's reason for hope: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
More on my own evolving thinking on inequality, politics and morality is here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
jordan
@JordanUhl
Oh my god lmao
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Robb Willer
@RobbWiller
This reminds me of this paper by Uscinski et al.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ajps.12616 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Emma Goldberg
@emmabgo
We spent nine months following Saleh, going through his photos, Whatsapps and bank transfers to share the toll of the war in Gaza on his family. Then we went to Israel to investigate profit and profiteering in trade into Gaza, for @NYTmag @emilykassie www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/06/08/magazine/gaza-fami…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Scott Greenfield
@ScottGreenfield
It's truly a shame that this is what's become of what should have, and could have, been a wonderful celebration of America.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
every Fox News live shot from Trump's fair is hilarious. I've seen more people gathered around our neighborhood Little Free Libraries
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Reuters
@Reuters
Israel's air and ground operations in Lebanon have hit UNESCO-listed Roman ruins in Tyre, pummeled the Mamluk-era market in Nabatieh and razed centuries-old towns along the southern border www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israel-damaged-heritage…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Trump not viewed as much as an "outsider" among the constituents most likely to vote for "outsider" candidates.
Mike Barber
@mbarber83
I'm very proud of my student Maverik Davies, who conceived of and wrote this paper as part of his undergraduate capstone class project!
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
How is this not woke in reverse?
Swap the word "Socialism" with "Trump" and it's the exact same garbage we've all had to deal with for the last 15 years.
As I've detailed here, the antiwoke basically think about and approach politics the same way as the folks they decry: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/174760441/understanding-the-f…
It's a frequent cause of their downfall: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/165149817/awokenings-dont-las… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
"This is where Mamdani is a model...There's this narrative that what Democrats have to do in order to win is to take squishy middle positions on everything. I actually disagree with that assessment. I think it's absolutely possible to take almost any position you want. There are kind of two things that are important though: You can't let niche issues that are not the primary concerns of a lot of voters dominate the messaging & the campaign. You need to stay the most focused on what voters actually care about." @Musa_alGharbi
www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mPRkXbpFjs&lc=UgwLamduQkA7jA_h3b…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
One of the more poetic statements of American exceptionalism is about Long Island
Doug Henwood
@DougHenwood
Is there a good cultural/political history of Long Island?
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Rent control in NYC is not well-targeted at low-income renters
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
The Rent Guidelines Board recently voted for a two year rent freeze on NYC rent stabilized housing
I was the lone dissenting vote
I've written two pieces here; which highlight the challenges of a rent freeze and where to go next
www.vitalcitynyc.org/mamdani-rent-freeze-agenda-nyc/
cityjournal.substack.com/p/the-high-cost-of-new-yorks-ren… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rob Sica
@robsica
"My fundamental argument is that concepts of mental illness have expanded in ways that may be making our mental health worse."
spssi.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/sipr.70007 -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sam Adler-Bell
@SamAdlerBell
Increasingly my favorite kind of post:
Robert Sterling
@RobertMSterling
Mamdani is a generational political talent. The energy he brings to local retail politics is unlike anything I’ve ever seen.
I can’t stand the guy—he’s going to be the downfall of New York, and his movement might destroy America itself—but we ignore his gifts at our own peril. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
John Harwood
@JohnJHarwood
"I mean, we're 1,000 times
more corrupt and we're still here hahahaha..."
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
JD Vance: "I think Nixon's historical legacy is enjoying a bit of a renaissance, and deservedly so. I joked that if Watergate happened tomorrow, it would be like a 12 hours news story. The idea that it took down a presidency is crazy."
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Rolf Degen
@DegenRolf
Yet another piece of evidence: Political advertising campaigns have only a negligible impact, if any, on their audience.
All else equal, the small effects of political campaign advertising on public opinion seem to be an established and robust finding.. Consistent with this claim, field and survey experiments generally document very small and short lived marginal effects of most campaign advertising on turnout, vote choice, and candidate evaluations and recognition
But still, direct evidence of the persuasive effects of political advertising outside the United States remains slight, as much less attention has been devoted to other advanced democracies. In an effort to conceptually replicate prior work on persuasion and campaign effects, we conducted three randomized survey experiments [n=3,346] to evaluate the persuasive effects of political advertisements during the 2025 Canadian federal election.
Consistent with recent theories, we find no evidence of large persuasive effects of campaign advertising. On average, and keeping gender, age, education, income, province of residence, and party identification constant, the advertisements moved target candidate evaluations by 0.023 scale-points on a five-point scale in the expected direction. Advertisements moved vote choice by 0.019 points on a ten-point scale, on average. Both these estimates are quite small (not even one percentage point) and do not reach statistical significance at the 5 per cent level.
The results strengthen the case that minimal persuasive effects of ads are not a peculiarity of the American two-party system or of unusually polarized electoral environments, but a more general feature of campaign advertising in advanced electoral democracies. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
‼️We Were Never Woke (w/ @Musa_alGharbi)‼️
So many debates about "wokeness"/the professional managerial class, & identity politics involve conservatives who don't believe in an underlying pro-worker economic project, but on today's ep, two socialists debate who's responsible for woke, & whether Tuesday's NYC primary wins mark the end of the establishment's identity-driven grasp on left politics.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I'd love to see less hysteria and accusations of anti-semitism and more normal journalistic inquiry into the substance of the left's Israel policy demands.
What does the Block The Bombs Act say? What will happen if it passes? I don't think this is well-understood at all. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
New York has been an especially cosmopolitan city since it was New Amsterdam, since the 17th century. It's a city that has experienced "mass immigration" since the 17th century too. So I am not sure what Jeremy Carl is trying to say exactly but neither is he.
Jeremy Carl
@realJeremyCarl
My takeaways from tonight's Congressional elections in NYC
(1) I despise Mamdani but he has shown himself to be an incredibly formidable politician. Underestimate him at your peril.
He endorsed against two Congressional incumbents in high risk races and looks like he's going to win both of them with Lander and Chevalier. Plus his third "outsider" endorsement of Valdez also won easily.
(2) Mass Immigration and cultural drift has truly made NYC a post-American city. That's the future of America if we don't close the border and have mass deportations. All three of Mamdani's endorsees are literal self-declared socialists who will now be in Congress.
(3) Israel, and in particular AIPAC are absolutely toxic in a Democrat primary-- especially anywhere vaguely "progressive"-- Israel was arguably the central issue in all three of these primaries and the candidate that was more hostile to Israel won in each. Expect a lot of Democrats to swing much harder against both AIPAC and Israel going forward.
(4) The radicalism of these soon-to-be Congressmen is going to be a headache for Democrat leadership in the House and a gift to the GOP.
The future of the Democrat party is radical and post-American in it's orientation. Since all of these candidates are in the world's media capital, they are going to get tons of attention.
That isn't going to play well for the Dems in 2026 and 2028. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt McManus
@MattPolProf
Cool meme by @Musa_alGharbi
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
“I will be one of the Jewish members of Congress most willing to stand up for Palestinian human rights. And I will stand firmly against bigotry aimed at Jews. Those are not two different jobs. They are the same job,” Brad Lander said.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt McManus
@MattPolProf
One of the most interesting and provocative works Ive read this decade.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My first book, We Have Never Been Woke, has been a runaway success. Yet, for all the big swings it takes, it owes its uptake in no small part to its adherence to disciplinary norms -- to include a tight focus on inequalities: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Neil McLaughlin
@NGMcLaughlin
A brilliant piece of writing on liberal socialism...
musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
2) It’s actually worse than that chart made out, because at most points on the income distribution, Americans earn much more than Brits.
If we plot the same data by actual income instead of percentile, the US deficit is vast.
5 fewer years even among the comfortably-off. -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My latest for Symbolic Capital(ism) describes my evolving views on inequality and socialism.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
My first book, We Have Never Been Woke, has been a runaway success. Yet, for all the big swings it takes, it owes its uptake in no small part to its adherence to disciplinary norms -- to include a tight focus on inequalities: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/on-inequality-and-socialism
Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Unlike wealth, status is closer to zero sum. And when people are (or perceive themselves to be) in a zero sum struggle, they often adopt an approach to politics that is more focused on holding others back or making them suffer instead of pursuing that they actually think is good: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/202717521/working-people-aren…
There is a correlational relationship between zero sum thinking, policy preferences and political ideologies.Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Of course, liberal socialism is not the only variety of socialism that exists in the world. There are also strains that are more zero-sum in orientation and authoritarian in practice: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/202717521/authoritarian-socia…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The problem is not that "real socialism has never been tried," or that authoritarians are not "real" socialists. The issue is that there are two broad traditions of socialism, they've both been tried *a lot* and they have very different track records. This is a reality that many across the ideological spectrum try to occlude: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/202717521/keeping-it-real
Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For those who want to learn more about liberal socialism, I'd highly recommend two titles by @MattPolProf.
The first is a scholarly exploration of the tradition's origins and development. The second is a more accessible, affordable and concise book for the public on its most essential components and their practical upshot. Links here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/202717521/concluding-thoughts
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
And for folks interested in the broad themes explored in this series, I'd recommend a forthcoming book by @tmbejan with @Harvard_Press, First Among Equals.
That book will explore how a longstanding and widely held belief that all people are fundamentally equal (even if they differ in many respects) came to eventually be attached to a set of political demands (around representation) and, later, economic demands (around redistribution).
More here: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/202717521/concluding-thoughts -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Rozado
@DavidRozado
1. Have we been measuring AI political bias wrong? In a new paper @PTetlock and I argue that we might have. Studies have found that AIs tend to produce left-of-center responses to politically loaded questions. But ideological preferences are not the same as epistemic failure.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Peter Bonilla
@pebonilla
I enjoyed reading and writing up Adam Szetela's 'That Book is Dangerous!' for the @mitfreespeech Substack, and I'm looking forward to discussing it with him tomorrow afternoon. Links in next post!
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Matt McManus
@MattPolProf
Appreciate @Musa_alGharbi shouting out my work on liberal socialism on a swell piece discussing inequality and politics
open.substack.com/pub/musaalgharbi/p/on-inequality-and-so… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
James Tate
@JamesTate121
Step 1: Remove filters in Reflecting Pool because Obama put them in.
Step 2: Give your criminal neighbor who runs "Greenwater Services" a $20 million no-bid contract to paint the pool.
Step 3: Fill the pool with water from the Potomac River, the phosphates from which cause algae blooms.
Step 4: Freshly sealed pool and extreme heat result in a super scum event
Step 5: Direct National Park Service to dump hydrogen peroxide into the pool which causes the paint to peel.
Step 5: Deploy US National Guard to stop people from taking photos of the swamp as a perfect metaphor for the administration.
Step 6: Blame someone else. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Great post from Conspicuous Cognition introducing the idea of “interpretive polarization,” which captures the epistemic aspect of polarization better than “cultural cognition” or “We don’t even have shared facts” accounts, I think. open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/how-tribes-c…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
By "burns allies" they literally mean endorsing primary candidates he supports instead of the ones the NYT prefers. www.nytimes.com/2026/06/21/nyregion/mamdani-burns-allies-…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Caitlin Johnstone
@caitoz
Oh no! What part of Israel were the Israeli soldiers in when this completely unprovoked attack occurred?
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Nassim Nicholas Taleb
@nntaleb
Today in Haaretz there is an article accusing Israel of being a terrorist state (plus committing crimes against humanity). It was not written by a Marxist member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine.
It was written by former Israeli PM Ehud Olmert. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jukka Savolainen
@JukkaSavo
" ... I no longer use biological theories as a foil. Instead, I acknowledge that there are biological differences between women and men ... exaggerated and emphasized through social mechanisms." @AbigailSaguy models constructive disagreement @chronicle
www.chronicle.com/article/gender-studies-needs-to-change -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
This is a really great essay by @CliffordAsness and co-authors in @thedispatch. Really highly recommend.
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Full piece here: thedispatch.com/article/affordability-crisis-healthcare-h…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
“It has been previously established that, at the very least, 250,000 young white girls have been subjected to repeated rape, gang rape, trafficking, torture, pregnancy, forced Islamic conversion, and lifelong trauma.”
That would be something like 1 in 40 women of reproductive age. It’s not credible and makes you wonder what kinds of standards these people are applying to establish truth.
Rupert Lowe MP
@RupertLowe10
The Rape Gang Inquiry Report.
static1.squarespace.com/static/6810978a41bbc42489eafa81/t… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Michael Regnier
@MichaelRegnier
YES. This is also a disconnect in many "civics" discussions: some talk about a civil sector and direct community, but for most it all boils down to the state. Civic involvement means voting for a mass party. Civic action means securing gov't funding. So narrowed and flattened.
Luke Burgis
@lukeburgis
The self set against the State, with nothing in between but a few good group texts.
That's not just lonely, it's dangerous.
The hunger for belonging doesn't vanish in an atomized society—it drifts toward more totalitarian forms of it, because we never stop questing for community.
My essay in @unherd today on "The lost art of association", adapted from Chapter 5 of my book, The One and the Ninety-Nine, which is titled "The Political Self".
unherd.com/2026/06/how-america-lost-the-art-of-associatio… -
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
100%. It's hard to do literally anything on a large scale without someone being harmed in some way. If we allow anyone with a harm claim to veto anything, then nothing gets done, and that can cause even more harm for a much wider range of stakeholders.
It's important to be mindful of potential risks or harms -- including and especially with respect to those who are vulnerable, disadvantaged, marginalized -- but trying to take these issues into account is very different than letting a small number of people with extreme demands/ needs/ tastes impose their idiosyncratic preferences on everyone else, often at significant expense to everyone else.
Almost any policy or intervention or strategy will have tradeoffs. Progressives, especially, tend to be pretty bad at thinking about or reckoning with tradeoffs. But refusing to acknowledge and willfully choose tradeoffs doesn't make them go away. It just leads to a bunch of iatrogenesis and adverse second order effects that no one really has any plan to mitigate -- often for a much bigger array of stakeholders.
Jerusalem
@JerusalemDemsas
Incredible @JeremiahDJohns rant about the "tyranny of the edge case."
Somehow also about abundance(?) lmao.
www.theargumentmag.com/p/sometimes-you-have-to-hurt-people -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Michael Munger 🏖️🔪👨🍳
@mungowitz
I think @anecdotal has a point here.
But so does @PhilWMagness
How can both be right? The apparent contradiction is reconciled by the @Musa_alGharbi book: WHNBW.
These folks SAY they are Marxists for professional advancement.
My review: www.independent.org/tir/2026-spring/we-have-never-been-woke/
Hollis Robbins
@anecdotal
I disagree with @PhilWMagness that there are so many Marxists in academia. If there were, there would be more voices advocating for students outside of elite schools, and the material conditions of education for working students. Yet I hear a lot of silence.
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Indeed, there's tons of research showing that the main benefit students get from attending to elite schools is not academic skills or knowledge, but rather access to valuable social networks and cultural capital: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/education-and-privilege-laund…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The overwhelming majority of MAGA folks reject the idea that America is or should be oriented towards Anglo-Saxon culture specifically. There's no difference on this matter, actually, between MAGA, non-MAGA conservatives, moderates or liberals. The outlier is progressives, who are more likely to think America *was* built on ethnonationalism (but are even less likely than others to say it *should* be).
The level of intensity in focus on ethnic and Christian nationalism is far out of step with the actual prevalence of those views in the United States.
In fact, Trump's racialized rhetoric was likely a drag on his support with white voters: musaalgharbi.com/2020/08/06/trump-voters-misunderstood/
The GOP has seen stagnation or declines with whites in every year Trump has defined the GOP (even as they've seen gains with many other blocs): musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/a-graveyard-of-bad-election-n…
Support for ethno and Christian nationalist positions has declined consistently over the same period (and nationalists have grown more ecumenical to partially offset these declines): musaalgharbi.com/2023/01/05/christian-nationalism-white-e…
Discursively, both Christian nationalism and ethno nationalism are associated with evangelicalism but evangelicalism is, itself, on the decline especially among whites (although there is some growth among non-whites): musaalgharbi.com/2023/01/05/christian-nationalism-white-e…
There are these narratives based on cherry-picked data and prejudicial analyses that try to villianize anyone who disagrees with mainstream symbolic capitalists -- to explain all disagreements in terms of deficits and pathologies -- under the auspices of social science: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngdZvwr5gA0&list=PLXUJh3viVi1_W64…
These narratives are often confounded by the very data they try to mobilize. But because few in academia or journalism have a real interest in scrutinizing these narratives and their underlying data too rigorously, we end up with widespread but false perceptions in these spaces that most Republicans are supportive of ethnonationalism, and this is the reason they vote Republican, and so on.
Leighton 明 Woodhouse
@lwoodhouse
Shockingly, Chris Rufo-style "Heritage American" Anglo ethnonationalism is wildly unpopular among voters. Like legalize-meth-level unpopular.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Mother Jones
@MotherJones
🗣️ We're hiring!
CIR is seeking a Producer to join our partners at @reveal. If you've got at least 5 years of experience creating high-impact audio projects and a passion for investigative journalism, apply today!
Salary: $85,000.00 to $110,000.00 workforcenow.adp.com/mascsr/default/mdf/recruitment/recru… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Elizabeth Nolan Brown
@ENBrown
Really interesting post from @stephmurrayyyy dispelling myths about Americans use of daycare stephaniehmurray.substack.com/p/rightsizing-the-daycare-t…
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
The problem is that a lot of the breathless reporting about rents in NYC looks at the *asking* price for apartments, not what people actually pay. When you look at what people actually pay, it tends to be roughly half the median asking price, as I detail here: musaalgharbi.com/2025/01/01/how-we-lived-in-nyc/
If you're *actually* paying $5k for an apartment in NYC, you have an extremely expensive (and, likely, atypical) apartment.
Basil🧡 (they/them)
@LinkofSunshine
This is a lie. The median Manhattan rent is around $2000 a month according to the US census data collectors
-
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
100%: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/diversity-meritocracy-arose-t…
Russ Greene
@GreenPlusAnE
Meritocracy is Just Civil Rights Law
“Meritocracy” in America is not a natural tradition, nor a tenet of the national creed, nor the product of market competition. It comes from civil rights law.
Per Jim Hankins, China implemented “meritocracy” successfully due to its centralized political control and relative internal peace compared to the violent and disputatious West. Centralized administration was a prerequisite to China’s sustained implementation of meritocracy. Singapore is a modern analogy.
Additionally, meritocracy as an ideal is contrary to both market economies (which reward subjective economic value via wants-fulfillment, not the objective merit of the laborer), and to republican self government (which requires that government experts answer to personnel appointed by democratically elected officials, who are usually of lesser “merit.”)
Despite meritocracy’s incompatibility with America’s founding principles, it rose in America as a paradigm due to the civil rights revolution. See Frank Dobbin’s work for confirmation.
After the Civil Rights Act American corporations increasingly bureaucratized hiring and promotion, via job descriptions, performance evaluations, pay bands, etc. Big business adopted seemingly objective meritocratic measures to comply with civil rights law and particularly to defend against disparate impact litigation.
They could not hire based on a factor unless it was apparently validated through objective testing. The use of human judgement in hiring became legally suspect, as did consideration of political, cultural and religious factors (should we hire a communist to work in a bank? An atheist to work for Catholic Charities?). It is a totalizing system, intolerant of alternative approaches.
Human Resources managers learned to pretend that compliance with civil rights law was actually just voluntary corporate efficiency. When President Reagan attempted to limit civil rights law’s reach, HR managers used this fiction to defend their departments from cuts. It was just good business after all. The link between meritocracy and civil rights law was thus severed in the popular imagination. Meanwhile HR jobs grew 5 times faster than the overall workforce.
Using “meritocracy” to argue against DEI / affirmative action and HR bureaucracy is like trying to defeat the Pharisees by praying more loudly, washing the cups more vigorously, and picking the best seats in the temple. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Jane Coaston 🏔️
@janecoaston
there is a strain of punditry that seems to believe that "working class Americans" or "middle America" are just the weirdest people alive
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alec MacGillis
@AlecMacGillis
"Many economists are more concerned about a different, larger group of white-collar workers: customer service reps, bookkeepers, payroll clerks & HR specialists...'I worry that A.I. will be to high-school-educated women what deindustrialization was to high-school-educated men.'"
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
John Hudson
@John_Hudson
This event is in honor of America's 250th bday, but to watch it, Americans have to pay for a subscription to Paramount+, the company owned by David Ellison (spotted below) whose deal to merge with Warner Bros was approved by Trump and whose dad is a major Trump fundraiser
Shawn McCreesh
@ShawnMcCreesh
Spotted front row in the Claw at the White House UFC fight: Mark Zuckerberg and David Ellison.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
mark normand
@marknorm
This looks like a Disney movie where a 12 year old becomes president
Polymarket Sports
@PolymarketSport
🚨Outside the White House right now
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Russ Greene
@GreenPlusAnE
I review @samuelmoyn’s new “Gerontocracy in America”.
Much to agree with in his diagnosis of the problem, but his prescription will make us more like gerontocratic Europe, and less like the dynamic, younger America of previous centuries. www.city-journal.org/article/samuel-moyn-gerontocracy-in-… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Mehdi Hasan
@mehdirhasan
Notice how no interviewers or reporters ever press him on this or ask him to justify this or ask him how this wasn’t a pure scam on his part.
Reuters
@Reuters
The $TRUMP meme coin generated about $616 million for the Trump family, while buyers lost more than $700 million, according to Reuters' estimates. The coin has tumbled 97% from its January 2025 peak www.reuters.com/investigations/under-trump-crypto-playboo… @specialreports
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Zaid Jilani
@ZaidJilani
Remember when people argued the economy had no impact on Trump voters?
Polling USA
@USA_Polling
Trump is so beyond fucked
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Michael
@Socdem_Michael
He’s doing the meme irl
Steve Ferguson
@lsferguson
Elon isn't stealing from me. Illegal aliens and welfare grifters are
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
The US & Iran are to sign a deal today that not only will end their war but also impose a ceasefire between Lebanon & Israel.
So this is what Israel did to Beirut sabotage Trump's attempt at peace.
And Israel will do more sabotage unless Trump imposes a cost on Israel. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
Ivy League students suing their schools with AI slop is a bit too on the nose
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
🧵 Five students brought a lawsuit against Columbia and Barnard after they were punished for participating in the 2025 Butler Library protest.
Barnard and Columbia’s lawyers found two AI-generated hallucinations in one of their court filings:
“As for the second case Petitioners rely on, ‘Matter of McCormack v. LaHood, 85 A.D.3d 1070, 1071 (2d Dep't 2011),’ the reporter citation is to a case of a different name that has no relevance whatsoever, and after a diligent search, Barnard is unable to locate any case with this name.”
“Again, one of the cases Petitioners cited, ‘Matter of Ortiz v. Coughlin, 86 A.D.2d 660, 661 (2d Dep't 1982),’ does not appear to exist-the citation goes to the middle of another case of a different name with no relevance here, and after a diligent search, the only three cases with these names in the caption are completely irrelevant.” -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Fun fact: Allah is the Arabic word for God, also used by Arabic speaking Christians to refer to their deity.
Geert Wilders
@geertwilderspvv
F*ck Allah
🇲🇦Athlètes_marocains
@Athletemarocain
inchaAllah la victoire 🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Luke Metro
@luke_metro
spare your AI models from export control restrictions with this one weird trick
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
I have fought the neocons and warmongers in Washington for more than 25 years. Throughout, they have tried to silence, discredit, slander, and cancel me. Only recently, however, have they tried to deport me.
At least, that appears to have been the aim of a hit piece in Bari Weiss’s The Free Press, which claimed that Marco Rubio’s State Department was “investigating” me for allegedly seeking to “undermine the U.S.”—presumably because of my opposition to war with Iran.
Yet just hours later, the State Department issued a statement to reporters clarifying that “the State Department has no plans to revoke the green card of Mr. Parsi at this time.” Nor did it provide any confirmation for the central premise of the Free Press story—that an investigation of me existed in the first place.
So here’s what I think happened.
Read the full piece on my Substack: tritaparsi.substack.com/p/so-they-tried-to-deport-me -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
🇺🇸 🇵🇸 Sama Safi, a 20-year-old American citizen and honors psychology student at Birzeit University, remains in Israeli detention after soldiers seized her from her family’s home near Ramallah at 3 a.m. on June 2, with lawmakers warning her life is at risk.
Safi, whose family lives in Florida, was taken without charge and transferred to Ofer prison, then to the Moscovia interrogation center in Jerusalem, according to the Palestinian Prisoners’ Society. Her family says she has a chronic condition that causes fevers up to 105°F and requires daily medication and a quarterly injection she travels abroad to receive.
She was one of five Palestinian women detained that week, including two members of the Palestinian women’s national football team. The Israeli military said the women were suspected of “promoting terrorist activities.”
Rep. Rashida Tlaib and Sen. Chris Van Hollen have both demanded her release. “I am really sick and tired of the Israeli government taking American taxpayer dollars and then mistreating Americans,” Van Hollen said. Israel has not told her family or the U.S. embassy where she is being held. Rep. Tlaib said, “Her life is at risk—our government must free her now!”
Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib
@RepRashida
Sama Safi is a 20-year old U.S. citizen and student who was kidnapped by Israeli soldiers from her family home at 3am last week and remains in Israeli prison. She has a chronic health condition and requires daily medication. Her life is at risk—our government must free her now!
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Steve Rattner
@SteveRattner
Inflation has overtaken wages for the first time in 3 years.
That means Americans’ incomes are shrinking in real terms, largely because of the Iran war.
My @Morning_Joe Chart. -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
This guy has written probably hundreds of tweets about Platner and works in the media and now says he knows nothing about Platner's actual views because of the media
Ken Klippenstein
@kenklippenstein
I know the names of two of Graham Platner's ex girlfriends but almost none of his policy views. This media coverage is dog shit.
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
.
@GregTSargent
These working class voters respond well to a populist economics that centers villains (pharma, corporate price gouging, etc), hits Trump/GOP for enabling them, and pledges Dem action. They don't like the tariffs and the war.
Big opening for Dems here:
newrepublic.com/article/211632/trump-tanking-maga-country… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
imagine if we teleported back to 2001,
Putnam suggests that hyper-engaging media sucks in our attention, suppressing socialising & social capital.
alas, this tech shock occurred everywhere all at once.
no randomisation
thus any causal inference is impossible and invalid ;-) -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
A point I've made a few times is that, if I had to choose between losing my left or right arm, that would be a horrible choice (I'd *strongly* prefer to lose neither) but an easy choice (I'm left-handed, take the right).
Many voters find themselves in a similar situation today: they are presented with a choice between two candidates/ parties, neither of which are particularly salutory, neither of which seems likely to improve their lives or life prospects much. But it isn't an option for both of them to lose. So if one has to win, vote for the one that at least doesn't seem to hate you.
www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/06/graham-platner-why-t…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
Platner's opponents seem to be counting on highlighting details of his personal life to derail him.
This is a problem in two senses.
First, there's not a lot of contradiction in Platner having affairs and so on -- neither his own brand nor the Democratic Party brand are oriented around family values, and neither is the GOP anymore, really, for that matter. So they're running from an outdated playbook in a sense.
Second, these accusations can actually make people sympathize *more* with the candidate being targeted. We saw this with Trump, we also saw this with Bill Clinton.
www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/06/graham-platner-why-t…Post not available here, view on X
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
In the interview I note that many who voted for the GOP because they were sick of the culture wars are displeased that they got even more culture wars, just going the other direction, while the kinds of issues they were concerned about have stayed the same or grown worse: www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/06/graham-platner-why-t…
For more on why antiwokenings are usually self-destructive: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/the-cultural-contradictions-o…
On the fundamental symmetry between left and right culture warriors: musaalgharbi.substack.com/i/174760441/understanding-the-f…
Musa al-Gharbi
@Musa_alGharbi
For a fuller account of the sociocultural and economic transformations that are also remapping American politics, check out my first book, We Have Never Been Woke: musaalgharbi.com/paperback-edition-we-have-never-been-woke/
And stay tuned for my forthcoming book, Those People: musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/book-announcement-those-people -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Abby Vesoulis
@abbyvesoulis
Why did Maine dems back a guy with a Nazi tattoo, sexts, and racist Reddit posts?
Americans are often willing to overlook discretions for a candidate who isn't "looking down on them."
My conversation with Musa al-Gharbi on why wokeness is a dead end. www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/06/graham-platner-why-t… -
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
Mother Jones
@MotherJones
Why the scandal-ridden Democrat with a Nazi tattoo won Maine’s Senate primary www.motherjones.com/politics/2026/06/graham-platner-why-t…
-
Musa al-Gharbi reposted
David Shor
@davidshor
This alleged @bariweiss quote made me want to collect data:
1) 44% of Reps and 67% of Dems voters watched 60 minutes prior to Bari’s entrance
2) 21% thought it had a Dem bias, 33% no bias
3) Voters oppose efforts to make 60 minutes less biased 38 to 29
www.nytimes.com/2026/06/07/magazine/scott-pelley-intervie…































































































































































































































































































































































































