From @WSJopinion: India’s reduction of extreme poverty is no small accomplishment. But to achieve widespread prosperity, New Delhi will need to go much further in embracing free markets, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/extreme-poverty-is-a-thing-of-the-pas…
Sadanand Dhume
Sadanand Dhume is an Indian-American writer and journalist based in Washington D.C.. In 2007 Dhume was an inaugural Bernard Schwartz Fellow at the Asia Society. In 2011 he was a Lincoln Fellow at the conservative Claremont Institute. He is a senior fellow in Foreign and Defense Policy at the conservative American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research. More on Wikipedia
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many people find it hard to accept that India has more or less eliminated extreme poverty. This is understandable. When a person from a rich country visits India, often their first and most overwhelming impression is of privation. Widespread urban squalor compounds this effect.
To many Westerners, as well as to many privileged Indians, the fact of Indian poverty is mindnumbingly obvious. If you contest it you must be either crazy or some kind of government shill. There is data to support this view. About 30% of all humans who live on the equivalent of less than $8.30 a day live in India.
Skepticism about India’s success in battling poverty may be understandable, but it’s nonetheless mistaken. The World Bank does not claim that India is no longer poor by developed world standards. The claim is much more limited. India has not eliminated poverty. It has virtually eliminated EXTREME poverty. Only about 2% of Indians live on the equivalent of $3.00 a day, down from 27% who lived under the equivalent benchmark for extreme poverty 15 years ago.
In practical terms, this means that hundreds of millions of people who once lived on the very edge of human existence have moved a small distance from that edge. Is this enough? Of course not. India is still far from becoming rich. And despite the frantic enthusiasm of the “Gorakhpur equals Singapore” crowd, any reasonable person must remain open to the possibility that India may not become rich in our lifetimes.
Nonetheless, we can still celebrate India no longer being extremely poor. The type of poverty that once defined the country, the type that Naipaul documented in the 1960s, and Oxfam fundraised off for decades, has all but vanished. This is a landmark in both Indian and human history. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India was once synonymous with extreme poverty. No more. [My take] www.wsj.com/opinion/extreme-poverty-is-a-thing-of-the-pas… v @WSJopinion
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many people find it hard to accept that India has more or less eliminated extreme poverty. This is understandable. When a person from a rich country visits India, often their first and most overwhelming impression is of privation. Widespread urban squalor compounds this effect.
To many Westerners, as well as to many privileged Indians, the fact of Indian poverty is mindnumbingly obvious. If you contest it you must be either crazy or some kind of government shill. There is data to support this view. About 30% of all humans who live on the equivalent of less than $8.30 a day live in India.
Skepticism about India’s success in battling poverty may be understandable, but it’s nonetheless mistaken. The World Bank does not claim that India is no longer poor by developed world standards. The claim is much more limited. India has not eliminated poverty. It has virtually eliminated EXTREME poverty. Only about 2% of Indians live on the equivalent of $3.00 a day, down from 27% who lived under the equivalent benchmark for extreme poverty 15 years ago.
In practical terms, this means that hundreds of millions of people who once lived on the very edge of human existence have moved a small distance from that edge. Is this enough? Of course not. India is still far from becoming rich. And despite the frantic enthusiasm of the “Gorakhpur equals Singapore” crowd, any reasonable person must remain open to the possibility that India may not become rich in our lifetimes.
Nonetheless, we can still celebrate India no longer being extremely poor. The type of poverty that once defined the country, the type that Naipaul documented in the 1960s, and Oxfam fundraised off for decades, has all but vanished. This is a landmark in both Indian and human history. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India’s reduction of extreme poverty is no small accomplishment. But to achieve widespread prosperity, New Delhi will need to go much further in embracing free markets, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/extreme-poverty-is-a-thing-of-the-pas… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My bet is that over time speaking warmly about Hinduism will become the norm for U.S. politicians in both parties. But right now there’s one party where you can hold forth on the wisdom of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata and another party where this would be political suicide.
Shashank Mattoo
@MattooShashank
Zohran Mamdani praises the Hindu epics:
“The Ramayana shows us the brother, wife, husband and friend we desire to be. The Mahabharata shows us what families are really like, where even the bravest heroes and wisest gods stumble..” -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When it comes to tech, India has clearly (and wisely) picked a side.
Sidhant Sibal
@sidhant
India signs "San Francisco Declaration on the Secure Foundations of Enduring Prosperity" alongside the United States and eight other countries.
It focuses on sensitive technologies, critical infrastructure. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Ironically, the same people who applaud visa cancellations to stifle an opposition event tend to get awfully upset if you point out that India is becoming increasingly illiberal.
Shashi Tharoor
@ShashiTharoor
A disappointing footnote to the #bharatsummit proceedings: when I got to Hyderabad, I learned that 115 of the 315 speakers whom the External Affairs Ministry had cleared for the event ended up being refused entry to India or having their visas cancelled, apparently on the instructions of the Ministry of Home Affairs. It is completely unclear under what provision of law the government has taken such a drastic step, but it is obviously impossible to reverse it since the conference concludes tomorrow. What a shame that a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical!
Shashi Tharoor
@ShashiTharoor
Attended and addressed the opening day of the #bharatsummit in Hyderabad today, at which @INCIndia is hosting experts from 70 countries for discussions on the emerging global order, India’s strategic response, cooperative federalism and electoral integrity. I spoke at an afternoon discussion of International think-tanks from various countries and again at the opening dinner, where I have just delivered the keynote address on the changing world order.
The Summit has drawn around 1,000 delegates, including global policymakers, progressive leaders and senior Congress leaders @RahulGandhi and Mallikarjun @Kharge. The event will also focus on establishing a think tank called "Our World Institute".
The event will also seek to establish a Global South–Global North platform. Senior policymakers and party leaders from some 70 countries are taking part in these discussions.
www.indiatoday.in/amp/india/story/bharat-summit-hyderabad… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hot off the press! (UK edition.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Saikat is broadly right here. The U.S. left has a problem with the ideology of Hindu nationalism. It has no problem with the religion of Hinduism.
Some Hindu nationalists/Hindu activists seek to blur this distinction because they would like the left to accommodate Hindu nationalism, and believe that attacking leftists as “anti-Hindu” will help them achieve this goal.
Some of these people have also sought a political home in the MAGA movement, though let’s just say that hasn’t worked out too well for them. I doubt that their efforts to make the Democratic Party more hospitable to Hindutva will work out either.
Saikat Chakrabarti
@saikatc
So according to you, the entire Cockroach Janta Party movement must be Islamofascist? And by your logic, if I criticize Trump even though GDP went up under him, I must be anti-Christian?
Stop trying to bring religious strife from South Asia to America.
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
You've expiated your original sin by joining the Leftist Team
(But say something nice about India's economic growth under Modi and see what happens...) -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“Almost every Democratic Senate nominee gained a higher vote share in their state than Kamala Harris did two years earlier, but the five left-wing candidates backed by [Bernie] Sanders accounted for the four smallest swings in contested races.”
Jonathan Chait
@jonathanchait
If the election was a test of whether Americans like Sanders’s message more or less than the standard Democratic message, the answer was clear: They like it less. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/11/moderates-midterms-succ…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Happy Diwali! 🪔
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Look what arrived in the mail.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Fletcher School
@FletcherSchool
Professor @crmiller1 spoke to @dhume about India’s semiconductor industry for @WSJopinion.
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Can India establish a viable semiconductor industry? If things go as planned, the country could emerge as a significant player in global supply chains, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-big-semiconductor-bet-e0e60891 -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Can India establish a viable semiconductor industry? If things go as planned, the country could emerge as a significant player in global supply chains, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-big-semiconductor-bet-e0e60891 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Since the 1950s, India has tried unsuccessfully to establish a semiconductor industry. Will the current effort have better luck? [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-big-semiconductor-bet-e0e60891 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Right needs to use the term Islamist accurately instead of as a smear or shorthand for “Muslim candidate I don’t like.” You can oppose Mamdani or El-Sayed for good reasons, but neither is an Islamist. Nothing in their platforms suggests support for sharia law.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s Election Day in the U.S. @MilanV and colleagues survey the sharp drop in Indian-American support for the GOP compared to two years ago.
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
🧵 1/ Hot off the press: Ahead of the U.S. midterms, new IAAS survey data on the political preferences of Indian Americans. carnegieendowment.org/research/2026/11/indian-american-vo…
This is joint work w/ @kharibiskut of @AmericanU, Devesh Kapur of @SAISHopkins, and Annabel Miller & Andy Robaina @CarnegieSAsia -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Congratulations to the lovely couple! @Nidhi @OmarAbdullah
Nidhi Razdan
@Nidhi
It’s done bro 💍 @OmarAbdullah
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Why have foreign portfolio investors dramatically cooled on India? Akash Prakash has a sobering explanation.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Arguably Pakistan never recovered from this direct military intervention in politics in 1958 even though in terms of economic performance Ayub Khan’s rule wasn’t bad.
Ikram Yōusefzai
@Ikramyousefzai
Ayub Khan Appointing Bhutto as his minister of commerce. Pakistan’s first Chief Martial Law Administrator cabinet swearing-in ceremony.
📍Karachi — 1958 🇵🇰This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Ikram Yōusefzai
@Ikramyousefzai
68 years ago today, Ayub Khan implemented the first ever martial law in the country. Here is his first interview with a foreign news channel. (Rare clip).
📍Karachi, Pakistan 🇵🇰 —1958This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Could Vivek Ramaswamy publicly celebrate a Hindu festival and hope to be accepted by MAGA? I think we all know the answer.
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
This week, I was blessed to join Hindu New Yorkers in Queens celebrating Navratri, Durga Puja, Dashain, and Vijayadashami.
We danced garba, performed aarti, witnessed Sindoor Khela, and honored the Goddess Durga.
It was an honor to come together in joy, faith, and community in temples across our city — especially after the attempted mass shooting at a Hindu temple in Illinois last week.
May we all join together in our shared responsibility to stand against hate and care for one another.
Jai Mata Ki. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Elon Musk blunders in the Indian market. To bring his Starlink satellite internet network to the country, he will need to rethink his diplomatic approach, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/elon-musk-blunders-in-the-indian-mark… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Elon Musk’s recent outbursts against Mukesh Ambani prove one thing. The world’s richest man doesn’t get India. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/elon-musk-blunders-in-the-indian-mark… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Indian democracy has long been known for working hard to extend the franchise to every possible voter. @Milanv explains how, for the first time, a botched voter roll update exercise raises questions about this commitment.
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
My column in today’s @FT: A democracy that once went looking for voters is increasingly demanding that voters prove they belong giftarticle.ft.com/giftarticle/actions/redeem/4f8d1cec-04…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Thoughtful piece by @SamuelFitouss10 on how rapid improvements in AI-generated writing could eventually force real writers out of the profession.
open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/why-i-broke-the-oreli… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The breathtaking arrogance of some guy with the handle @12345678910 toward @VGokhale59, a former Indian foreign secretary and ambassador to China is a bit much even for this site. Mr. Gokhale speaks fluent Mandarin, has published multiple books, and is widely acknowledged as one of the most astute China watchers in the world. This does’t mean that Mr. 123456 needs to agree with him, but it shouldn’t be too much to expect a modicum of civility.
Shenshi Bai
@961957192q83556
I am Chinese, and of course I speak from a Chinese perspective—what is there to reproach me for? Are Indian researchers supposed to interpret the border issue from a Chinese perspective? Moreover, even if I made a neutral and objective statement, would Indians believe it? You would still say I am not neutral or objective. As long as I am Chinese, Indians will never believe me.
Take Neville Maxwell of Australia—his research was neutral and objective enough, was it not? He worked as a journalist in Delhi for several years. He was once pro-India and unfriendly toward China, but when his India’s China War was published, India banned it. Why? Because the historical facts it described were regarded by the Indian government as anti-India. Indians may say within India that the war with China was Nehru’s fault, or the product of Kaul’s arrogance, and so on—but in external propaganda, it must always be China’s fault. That is no longer serious research.
I have carefully studied the Sino-Indian border dispute of 1962, including primary sources from both China and India, and I have tried to conduct my research from as neutral and objective a standpoint as possible. My research is more thorough than Maxwell’s, because I have access to abundant Chinese-language materials, yet my conclusions are almost identical to his. By both reason and justice, the party responsible for the 1962 war—and the greatest obstacle to resolving the current border situation—is India.
India’s current China studies are very poor. The core reason is the lack of Chinese perspectives and sources, which leads to interpretations of China that are almost entirely wrong, even laughable. If Indians wish to learn from historical experience, the right approach is to engage seriously with Chinese people, to discover the truths and facts that India failed to notice at the time, and thereby avoid repeating such a tragedy—not to treat an excellent Chinese scholar of India with a condescending sense of superiority.
Saying this will certainly be hard for many Indians to accept. OK, I understand the pain of Indians—who does not want their country to stand on the moral high ground? If you wish to refute me, then please present your research.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@amitabhmattoo: India and the US have never had greater reasons to be friends. And yet, we are witnessing what may be the lowest point in New Delhi’s engagement with Washington since the end of the Cold War.
www.telegraphindia.com/opinion/storm-signals-new-delhi-mu… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you had to pick the most charismatic of India’s Gen Z protest leaders who would you choose? (Feel free to share a comment explaining your reasons.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
One of the most heartwarming things about India is the comfort people have around small children, and their assumption that this will be shared by strangers.
After I deplane from an Etihad flight in Bangalore, I reach the short escalator that leads to immigration at the same time as a young family. The husband is carrying a bag and walks a few steps ahead. The wife is carrying a toddler and holding the hand of a little girl in pink, who must be three or fours years old.
I motion to the lady to pass ahead of me. She hesitates for a moment, then says, matter of factly, “you hold her hand,” as she slips her daughter’s little palm in mine. She’s kind of asking me, but she’s also kind of just telling me. She assumes (rightly) that this is the natural order.
It’s a short escalator ride—less than a minute—and once we’ve cleared it the girl returns to her mother and the family returns to its formation. I thank them silently for a quietly beautiful moment. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@pstanpolitics: “If Trump 2.0 has shown anything thus far, it is that India is not structurally ordained to be favored by the US as it competes with China.” paulstaniland.com/2026/10/10/us-india-relations-possible-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“Okay, if you insist, you have our permission to leave.”
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This piece by @RodDreher is worth reading for anyone interested in understanding the American new right’s growing hostility toward Israel. www.thefp.com/p/rod-dreher-new-right-israel-antisemitism
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Let’s be honest, there’s no way in hell Satya Nadella or Sundar Pichai would have scaled similar heights in India. To a large extent, modern India rejects (or at least undermines) the culture of meritocracy and fair play at the heart of Silicon Valley.
Shashank Mattoo
@MattooShashank
“Not getting more H-1B visas is absolutely good for the Indian economy. Some of our best talent has gone to America. When I see Indian-origin billionaires in literally every street, I wonder what would have happened if they had built their business in India,” says Minister Goyal
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@ShekharGupta: Over the decades, three things have made India stronger: trust in the Constitution and the belief that nobody can take it away; fairness of the top judiciary; and independence of the Election Commission. All three are under strain now.
theprint.in/national-interest/narendra-modi-25-years-chal… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I would absolutely bet against Elon in this case. I’m not debating the alleged merits or demerits of Starlink. Merely pointing out that the way the Indian system works picking a public fight with Modi and Ambani is not an optimal strategy. In fact, this approach ONLY makes sense if Musk has decided that he couldn’t care less about Starlink’s prospects in India and wants to have some fun trolling because there’s no visible downside for him.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m assuming that @elonmusk is just trolling here for the fun of it, because if he’s serious about getting Starlink approved in India he should know that this approach has an approximately 0% chance of success.
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Dear Prime Minister Ambani,
Please accept my humble apologies for not realizing that you are the real boss of India.
Naturally, you would prefer to maintain your monopolistic exploitation of the great people of India, but would you nonetheless consider allowing Starlink to compete?
There are many areas of India, as there are in all countries, with no Internet access, which denies children the opportunity for education and for small businesses the opportunity to sell their goods to a global market. Starlink would change their lives for the better.
Thank you 🙏Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I would absolutely bet against Elon in this case. I’m not debating the alleged merits or demerits of Starlink. Merely pointing out that the way the Indian system works picking a public fight with Modi and Ambani is not an optimal strategy. In fact, this approach ONLY makes sense if Musk has decided that he couldn’t care less about Starlink’s prospects in India and wants to have some fun trolling because there’s no visible downside for him.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Senator John Cornyn
@JohnCornyn
India’s Best Bet to Catch Up With China? Democracy by @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-best-bet-to-catch-up-with-chin… via @WSJopinion
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many people on my TL are discussing NatCon ‘27 in Jerusalem, especially the decision to platform people plainly unsympathetic to Israel and skeptical about U.S.-Israel ties.
As an aside, NatCon appears to have ended its effort to extend the movement’s umbrella to the BJP and RSS in India. The 2024 edition of NatCon in Washington included @rammadhav_ and @swapan55 as speakers. To the best of my knowledge neither has spoken at the event since then.
Since I’m not privy to the inner workings of NatCon, I can’t claim to know exactly why the conference showcased prominent Hindutva proponents on one occasion and then suddenly stopped. But if you were in the room in 2024 you would have noticed that the core constituency that @yhazony caters to is not exactly overflowing with fellow feeling toward the Hindu nationalist project in India, or toward India in general. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Those Indians drawn to authoritarianism believe it will yield China-like sparkling megacities and world-beating companies. But war-torn Myanmar and bankrupt Zimbabwe are examples of where autocratic rule often leads. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-best-bet-to-catch-up-with-chin… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“People working hard is good for you! Conservatives understood this until five minutes ago.” [My view: Conservatives still understand this. The people who don’t are racists and post-liberals.]
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Incredible. Rufo embraces the idea that Asians work too hard so this is a good reason to restrict immigration.
When he was arguing against DEI, where were these concerns? Why wasn't he worried about high scoring whites making black and Hispanic children have to focus too much on school?
There's no law that says white Americans have to study like Asians! You don't have to play the rat race. In fact, conservatives usually love it when smart young people forgo universities and start businesses.
People working hard is good for you! Conservatives understood this until five minutes ago. When people grind too much, they harm themselves but help the rest of society. This only isn't true in places like Ivy League admissions, the rare thing in our society that is zero sum.
But Rufo was the person who fought so that university admissions would stay that way! We already had a system based on subjective criteria like personality and well-roundedness, and he made his life work getting rid of it.
"We need both the valedictorian and the football captain."
Who is banning the football captain?
This is so bad. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When your 100 lb. dog suddenly decides that he wants to sit on your lap.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
People of a certain vintage who grew up in India will remember devouring his novels. The one I remember most vividly is Kane and Abel.
BBC News (UK)
@BBCNews
Author and former politician Jeffrey Archer dies aged 86 www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckj0l401dvpgo?at_bbc_team=edi…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Asian Games medals table neatly captures two truths:
1. India lags the high-performing economies of Northeast Asia.
2. India is the only country in South Asia that’s even remotely in the running. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A capacity for self-deprecation is one of the most admirable qualities in a politician. Kemi Badenoch is a class act.
Janice Turner
@VictoriaPeckham
Reform didn’t need to go to Nigeria: they could have asked me. The story about Kemi Badenoch & chess comes from my February 2024 @thetimes interview with her. Here is that section of the transcript.
Reform UK
@reformparty_uk
Kemi Badenoch said she was Nigeria's national chess champion at age 7. So we sent a reporter to Nigeria to find out the truth.
She lied.
Here is everything else she has lied about:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The key difference is that neither the Conservative Party nor the conservative-leaning media in the UK have been taken over by right wing populists who despise education and expertise. Not sure if the Brits even have an equivalent of Tucker.
Sky Marchini
@rhcm123
The thing about the Tucker Carlson//Jacob Rees-Mogg interview is that Tucker is an American moron whose entire tactic is “assume the other guy won’t question my premises”, up against a British aristocrat that debates for fun at Oxford Union. Apex predator wins handily
Scott G
@scttfrnks
I wasn’t familiar with Rees-Mogg prior to this, but I was impressed. It was an hour-long masterclass in how to deal with a hostile interviewer. And he maintained his composure until the very end. His style was the perfect foil to Tucker’s approach.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@jonathanchait: Christopher Rufo “has backed away from his previously forthright defense of meritocracy, and by all available evidence, he has done so because the principle turns out to contain a fatal flaw: Many of the Americans who benefit from meritocracy have brown skin.”
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
A GOP schism over the Texas candidate Bo French’s social-media post reveals the limits of the party’s defense of a color-blind meritocracy, @jonathanchait argues. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/french-rufo-meritocracy…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hubris. Check. Clumsiness. Check. Incompetence. Check. Propagandists and blind followers nonetheless cheering it on as a masterstroke. Check, check, check.
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
Worth reading @Roshanjnu on why "the entire SIR exercise has very strong demonetisation vibes" www.hindustantimes.com/editors-pick/terms-of-trade-sir-de…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
So much of Indian economic underperformance compared to East Asia can be traced to Indian exceptionalism, which in turn is downstream from Indian hubris.
Here’s @surjitbhalla on the godawful 2016 Bilateral Investment Treaty (BIT), virtually designed to repel foreign investors. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Tucker also believes that they no longer speak English in the UK, and that the British would be better off today had they been subjugated by the Nazis.
Brent Scher
@BrentScher
This is absolutely priceless.
Tucker just states as fact that Russia has a much larger economy than the UK, is completely wrong and gets schooled. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
U.S. diplomats have always worked for the U.S. They played no small role in making it the most influential nation on the planet. The ~200 flags in the State Dept. lobby welcomed foreign interlocutors while also subtly evoking the scope and scale of America’s diplomatic footprint.
Matthew Kroenig
@MatthewKroenig
The US State Department lobby used to display the flags of the roughly 200 countries with which the US maintains diplomatic relations. Now, it displays 200 American flags, to remind State Department employees who they work for.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I get why the Cockroach Janta Party garners so much media attention. (I’ve written about it too.) But in some ways the more interesting—and possibly more significant—revolt in Indian politics is being led by @ajeetbharti and those who share his views.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Thanks for the thoughtful response, and congratulations on your book. I look forward to reading it.
The nub of our disagreement lies in our interpretation of Xi Jinping’s red carpet welcome by Trump. (A strategic blunder by the U.S., but that’s a separate debate that should not sidetrack us here.) As I understand it, you (like Smita Prakash) view the moment as an affirmation of the inevitable rise of BOTH China and India.
I see it differently. First, nothing is inevitable. China may continue to rise, or it may collapse in disorder. And it’s possible to envision similar scenarios for any country—including the U.S. and India.
Second, the evidence for China’s rise is much stronger than the evidence that India will follow suit. Here your invocation of Japan’s 1905 victory over Russia in the Battle of Tsushima is telling. It may have fired the imaginations of Tagore and Nehru, but did it lead to the modernization of India that they envisioned? More than 120 years later is India a technological or economic peer of Japan? Your talk of grand civilizational cycles may be true, but you should be open to the possibility that it is just comforting babble.
A Chinese or Japanese person adopting your unfalsifiable style of prognostication could easily claim that the only inevitable outcome is the rise of East Asia to rival the West in prosperity. An African utopianist may argue that Trump’s red carpet for Xi means Nigeria’s turn is next. But most reasonable people would acknowledge that it makes more sense to judge Nigerian boasts by Nigerian achievements than to simply assume that because both China and Nigeria are populous and non-Western this means they are fated to follow similar trajectories.
This is the nub of our disagreement. I believe we should judge India purely by its own record, and not by attempting to slyly steal credit from China. India has got some things right since 1947, and more particularly since 1991, but it has also erred in important ways that will likely have long term consequences. That both China and India were large pre-industrial economies in 1750 tells us next to nothing about where both countries will be in 2050. It’s far more productive to try and figure out why the gap between the two countries grew so large over the past two decades. -
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Thanks for the thoughtful response, and congratulations on your book. I look forward to reading it.
The nub of our disagreement lies in our interpretation of Xi Jinping’s red carpet welcome by Trump. (A strategic blunder by the U.S., but that’s a separate debate that should not sidetrack us here.) As I understand it, you (like Smita Prakash) view the moment as an affirmation of the inevitable rise of BOTH China and India.
I see it differently. First, nothing is inevitable. China may continue to rise, or it may collapse in disorder. And it’s possible to envision similar scenarios for any country—including the U.S. and India.
Second, the evidence for China’s rise is much stronger than the evidence that India will follow suit. Here your invocation of Japan’s 1905 victory over Russia in the Battle of Tsushima is telling. It may have fired the imaginations of Tagore and Nehru, but did it lead to the modernization of India that they envisioned? More than 120 years later is India a technological or economic peer of Japan? Your talk of grand civilizational cycles may be true, but you should be open to the possibility that it is just comforting babble.
A Chinese or Japanese person adopting your unfalsifiable style of prognostication could easily claim that the only inevitable outcome is the rise of East Asia to rival the West in prosperity. An African utopianist may argue that Trump’s red carpet for Xi means Nigeria’s turn is next. But most reasonable people would acknowledge that it makes more sense to judge Nigerian boasts by Nigerian achievements than to simply assume that because both China and Nigeria are populous and non-Western this means they are fated to follow similar trajectories.
This is the nub of our disagreement. I believe we should judge India purely by its own record, and not by attempting to slyly steal credit from China. India has got some things right since 1947, and more particularly since 1991, but it has also erred in important ways that will likely have long term consequences. That both China and India were large pre-industrial economies in 1750 tells us next to nothing about where both countries will be in 2050. It’s far more productive to try and figure out why the gap between the two countries grew so large over the past two decades. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I wish Indians would stop pretending—to themselves and to the world—that China and India are still clubbed together in any meaningful way. China has emerged as a major world power. There’s no guarantee that India will automatically follow suit.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Three possibilities:
1. White House comms is not sophisticated enough to see that it could share Sharif’s praise of Trump without also amplifying his claim that India attacked Pakistan on a “false pretext.”
2. The White House genuinely believes that India’s response to the Pahalgam massacre in April last year was a false pretext to attack Pakistan.
3. The White House doesn’t share Pakistan’s view in its entirety—only the part praising Trump—but couldn’t be bothered if it offends the Indian government and Indian public opinion.
[Either way this is another milestone in the rockiest phase in U.S.-India relations in at least a quarter century.]
Rapid Response 47
@RapidResponse47
.@CMShehbaz: "It's thanks to President Donald Trump's resolute and visionary leadership that hundreds of millions of lives in South Asia were saved. His timely intervention came at a decisive juncture, when two nuclear-armed neighbors stood at the brink of an all-out war — and who knows the extent of devastation that could've taken place had President Trump not stepped in at this critical moment with clarity of thought and action."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This may not be how Xi Jinping’s Washington visit looked to Trump’s base, but it’s certainly how it looked to much of the world.
The New Yorker
@NewYorker
Barry Blitt dramatizes Donald Trump's meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping in his latest Kvetchbook.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As an aside, I took a screenshot of @UnamPillai’s article in Malayalam about the colonial-era administrator Sir CP Ramaswamy Iyer and asked Perplexity to translate it.
First, Perplexity confidently spat out a few paragraphs on the scientist CV Raman. I immediately called it out for spewing nonsense. (I felt bad about my tone, and slightly embarrassed about feeling bad about it, but then again the response to my query was clearly moronic.)
To its credit, Perplexity immediately apologized for the error. It then proceeded to “correct” itself by spitting out another “translation”…this time about the Anglican priest and champion of Indian independence CF Andrews.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fascinating column on Sir CP Ramaswamy Iyer the erstwhile Dewan of Travancore. I wonder which chief minister in independent India comes closest to him in terms of combining intellectual achievement and administrative capability.
Manu S Pillai
@UnamPillai
manuspillai.com/sir-cp-ramaswamy-iyer/
Here you go -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is what real journalism looks like. Take a bow @RitikaChopra__ and The Indian Express.
Ritika Chopra
@RitikaChopra__
The Election Commission of India is under fire like never before.
The SIR has struck 13 crore names off draft rolls, putting the EC at the centre of intense public debate over its role in deciding who gets to vote — and who doesn’t.
HOWEVER, what nobody knew: through that same period, some of the sharpest questions were being asked from inside.
Out today, after months of work. Our #expressinvestigation 🧵
(1/10) -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Some Republicans don’t want Indian-American votes. The multiracial coalition that elected Trump in 2024 may fracture because of bigotry within the party, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/some-republicans-dont-want-indian-ame… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Bigoted attacks on Indian-Americans by a section of MAGA signal a deeper problem for the GOP. The multiracial coalition that powered Trump to victory in 2024 is collapsing. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/some-republicans-dont-want-indian-ame… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A student who cheats in an exam should be suspended or expelled. A professor who uses casteist slurs should be sacked. Sad to see India’s skewed political discourse struggle to accommodate both these commonsense positions.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I view this differently. Rahul Gandhi does not grasp that what works with people who loathe Modi may not work with those who are fence-sitters or have mixed feelings about the PM. A smarter politician would figure out how to appeal to both kinds of voters. RG struggles with this.
vir sanghvi
@virsanghvi
The BJP is right to be upset. A smart leader like the PM knows that politicians should expect to be attacked. But when they become figures of fun and are regularly lampooned it becomes much more difficult to recover
It’s taken Rahul Gandhi a decade to win back his stature & credibility
Narendra Modi knows that jokes are the Opposition’s most powerful weapon
www.ndtv.com/india-news/uncouth-foul-mouthed-bjp-on-rahul… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“Today’s far-right nativists claim to defend American identity, but they’re importing the European blood-and-soil politics that America has rejected.” [Good @anangbhai essay on the recent upsurge of attacks on Indian-Americans.]
Benjamin Domenech
@bdomenech
Who Is An American?
- @anangbhai @realDailyWire
www.dailywire.com/news/who-is-an-american -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Over the past seven years, #grandtamasha has become essential listening for anyone interested in India. Congrats to @MilanV @CarnegieEndow and @htTweets for this milestone.
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
Today, we celebrate the release of our 300th episode of #grandtamasha. To discuss the latest on policy & politics from India--plus what has changed (and what hasn't) since we began the show in 2019--I'm joined by regular guests @dhume & @tanvi_madan www.youtube.com/watch?v=PXSSDRqyWDk&t=9s
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
An India-China rapprochement isn’t in the cards. Xi Jinping’s visit to the Brics summit in New Delhi is progress, but relations ruptured by 2020 border clashes remain fragile, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/an-india-china-rapprochement-isnt-in-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A Xi Jinping visit to New Delhi over the weekend would cap Indian and Chinese efforts to heal ties ruptured by a bloody 2020 clash in the Himalayas. But nobody should expect a sweeping rapprochement between the world’s two most populous nations. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/an-india-china-rapprochement-isnt-in-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Guess we’ll find out soon enough if the Saudi-Pakistan defense agreement and the Mecca Pact are worth the paper they’re printed on.
Salman Al-Ansari | سلمان الأنصاري
@alansari
The gloves are off. Saudi Arabia will finish the job against the Iranian-backed Houthi militia.
Saudi Ministry of Defense: "73 civilians, including women and children, were injured in attacks by the Houthi militia on civilian and economic facilities in southern Saudi Arabia." -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s no exact parallel, but what’s happening in Germany with the AFD looks remarkably similar to Indian politics in the early 1990s: the old order crumbling, a new challenger on the right espousing a form of ethnic nationalism, a desperate attempt by established parties to build a firewall against the threat, the firewall quickly collapsing.
One big difference: A first past the post system like India’s is much friendlier to insurgent parties than a proportional representation system. In a first past the post election, AFD could have easily won a two-thirds majority in Saxony-Anhalt. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The strange beauty of British democracy on full display: Here’s an ordinary voter (a geography teacher) cross-examining a sitting prime minister on live television about a decision to sink an enemy ship in wartime.
Margaret Thatcher
@realmrsthatcher
"I think it could only be in Britain that a Prime Minister was accused of sinking an enemy ship that was a danger to our navy when my main motive was to protect the boys in our navy."
–Margaret Thatcher to Diana Gould questioning the sinking of the Belgrano, one of the key turning points in the Falklands War, in 1983This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Upon a long established foundation of condescension, younger Chinese researchers on India now encounter a country much poorer and less militarily capable, but which likes to talk a big game. No wonder they are dismissive of India’s ambitions. www.economist.com/asia/2026/09/06/why-india-baffles-china
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
What India is putting its people through in the name of revising electoral rolls is objectively insane. Nobody appears to have considered the consequences if large numbers of people begin to mistrust elections, which have long been the crowning achievement of Indian democracy.
Samar Halarnkar
@samar11
I thought I had done everything required under Karnataka’s SIR
After online/offline detective work, helped by neighbours on WhatsApp, I tracked down 2002 voting details for myself & my mother Both our names appeared on the draft roll on 24 Aug
I heaved a sigh of relief
🧵 1/12 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Nobody told me that recording an audiobook was so much work—or so much fun.
-
Tavleen Singh
@tavleen_singh
Available soon. In bookshops by September 14 and online sooner. My first novel.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Great cover. Congrats!
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
@RichardHanania: “It’s not news that stupid people are stupid. But one feature of populist movements is that the attitudes, beliefs, and aesthetics of more excitable and less thoughtful members of the public end up in control.” [On the failure of the tech right.]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Dignity is one of those strange things that are hard to define, but that people instinctively recognize when they encounter it. In the cacophony of Indian TV news, Naghma Sahar stood out for her calm professionalism and quiet dignity. She will be missed.
Naghma Sahar
@NaghmaSahar
It’s finally goodbye to NDTV.
I spent 23 years with the NDTV I knew, and somehow the last three with the “new” NDTV.
But there comes a moment when you realise that a chapter has simply run its course. No grand conclusions. Just the quiet relief of knowing it is time to move on. Some chapters need to be closed
So for now It is what it is. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
@RichardHanania: “It’s not news that stupid people are stupid. But one feature of populist movements is that the attitudes, beliefs, and aesthetics of more excitable and less thoughtful members of the public end up in control.” [On the failure of the tech right.]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fine to make this point, @ConstantinoX. But India’s image problem is not confined to America. In 2011, 71% of Australians had a favorable view of India. It’s now down to 44%.
A lot of folks have responded to my piece with some version of “we don’t care” or “public opinion doesn’t matter.” The first response is perfectly valid. It’s fine if Indians (or Americans, Nigerians or Peruvians) choose not to care about how the world sees their country. Nobody is forcing you to read Pew surveys or articles about them.
The “public opinion doesn’t matter” argument is a little trickier. It’s true that opinion polls are rarely the most important determinant of foreign policy. India-Australia ties have deepened considerably even as India’s favorability ratings among Australians have plummeted over the past 15 years. The U.S. has close ties with many countries whose publics loathe America. (Hello Pakistan.)
Nonetheless, public opinion does matter, at least at the margins. As a diplomat, your work is much easier when the public in the country where you’re posted is favorably disposed toward your home country. This is especially true of democracies. I don’t see how any reasonable person can disagree with this.
Constantino Xavier
@ConstantinoX
Much discussion about this piece by @dhume, whose writings always provoke thought.
Worth considering an alternative:
America has a global perspective problem.
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: India has a global image problem. Less than half of Americans view New Delhi favorably today, down from nearly two-thirds in 2008. That could influence foreign policy, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-global-image-problem-f8845682 -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: India has a global image problem. Less than half of Americans view New Delhi favorably today, down from nearly two-thirds in 2008. That could influence foreign policy, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-global-image-problem-f8845682 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Mounds of rotting garbage, trains overflowing with commuters, half-drowned school buses on flooded roads. The age of social media has been brutal for India’s global image. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-global-image-problem-f8845682 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Vivek @wadhwa is a well known voice in Silicon Valley. Worth paying attention to his views on how years of unscrupulous gaming of the H-1B program contributed to a wider backlash against Indian immigrants in America.
Vivek Wadhwa
@wadhwa
H-1B’s death should cheer Indians and Americans.
This is about an article I wrote telling India why it should support America terminating the H-1B visa program:
H-1B was created to fill genuine shortages of highly skilled workers. It was supposed to allow American companies to recruit exceptional people whose expertise could not be found here. Instead, body shops, in collaboration with American employers, turned it into one of the most corrupt labor-arbitrage schemes in modern America.
The body shops learned to flood the system with applications, manufacture experience, embellish résumés, and present ordinary technology jobs as positions requiring rare skills. Workers were brought in at lower wages and placed at American companies through layers of contractors and subcontractors, allowing the companies to pretend that they had not directly replaced anyone.
American workers were harmed the most. Many were ordered to train their foreign replacements before losing their jobs. Experienced engineers were pushed out and told that their skills were obsolete, while younger and cheaper workers were brought in to perform substantially the same work. Age discrimination became an unspoken part of the business model.
These were decent, hardworking Americans who had studied, built careers, supported families, and contributed to their companies for years. Their loyalty was rewarded with termination notices because executives had discovered a cheaper and more controllable source of labor.
The control was central to the scheme because an H-1B employee whose right to remain in America depended on the sponsoring company could not negotiate like an American worker. Leaving a bad job could mean losing legal status and being forced to leave the country. The decades-long green-card backlog made this dependency even worse. Employers gained workers who were less likely to demand raises, report abuse, challenge management, or resign.
Then the companies wrapped this exploitation in the language of diversity, innovation, and skilled immigration. Executives claimed there were real talent shortages while laying off qualified Americans.
The darkest part is that the corporations escaped most of the blame while Indians became the public face of the abuse. American workers saw jobs being transferred to Indian contractors, heard stories about fabricated experience and embellished résumés, and concluded that Indians were cheating them. Some applicants certainly participated knowingly, and that dishonesty must also be acknowledged. But the system was created, expanded, and defended by companies that made billions from it. This is all they lobbied for in DC, not real solutions to the backlog.
The consequences have been devastating for Indians in America. Millions of legal immigrants who studied hard, worked honestly, paid taxes, created companies, and contributed enormously are now viewed with suspicion. The achievements of an entire community are being overshadowed by unscrupulous players. The anger has spread far beyond H-1B and mutated into open anti-Indian hatred.
The visa also exploited the Indian workers it brought to America. Their legal status depended on their employers, and the decades-long green-card backlog left many unable to change jobs, start companies, or plan their lives. They were sold the American dream and then trapped in a form of indentured servitude.
That is why this cancer, the H-1B visa must be terminated, and terminated now. And this is why I am speaking up so strongly. Enough is enough. -
Tavleen Singh
@tavleen_singh
To those who may have received weird messages from me in recent days I apologise. My account was hacked and it was my fault for clicking a link that I should not have.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Come on, Tavleen. I was so looking forward to a ride in your lovely new Mercedes. :)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Important story on the shameful behavior of large MNCs such as Coca-Cola and Nestlé in India. They’re happy to label their products clearly in Europe, but balk at doing it in India.
Reuters
@Reuters
India wanted red flags on chip packets and soda. Big Food fought back. www.reuters.com/world/india/india-wanted-red-flags-chip-p… www.reuters.com/world/india/india-wanted-red-flags-chip-p…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There must be countries that treat their tax payers as poorly as India, but I honestly can’t think of one off the top of my head.
Press Trust of India
@PTI_News
VIDEO | Gurugram: School buses carrying children stranded on waterlogged roads.
(Full video available on PTI Videos - ptivideos.com) -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here @ShekharGupta (one of India’s most astute Pakistan watchers) concurs with those who think Asim Munir will elevate himself to Pakistan’s presidency in 2030.
Since we’re all speculating, here’s my guess: Munir will give himself another five year extension as army chief/chief of defense forces until 2035. His power comes from commanding the most powerful institution in Pakistan. I doubt very much that he would willingly give that up. It’s simply too risky. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Field Marshal Asim Munir embodies the Pakistan paradox: a powerful army is both the country’s greatest international asset and the root cause of its political and economic troubles. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/field-marshal-munir-and-the-pakistan-…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When Asim Munir became army chief in 2022 many people saw him as an underwhelming pick. He’s since tightened his grip on power and boosted Pakistan’s international profile even as troubles mount at home. I enjoyed this convo w/ @WajSKhan. [Video, 36m] youtu.be/T8gs7hukGCU
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here @ShekharGupta (one of India’s most astute Pakistan watchers) concurs with those who think Asim Munir will elevate himself to Pakistan’s presidency in 2030.
Since we’re all speculating, here’s my guess: Munir will give himself another five year extension as army chief/chief of defense forces until 2035. His power comes from commanding the most powerful institution in Pakistan. I doubt very much that he would willingly give that up. It’s simply too risky. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If India wanted to create a global financial hub to rival London or Dubai the most obvious candidate is and always was Bombay.
Rahul Kanwal
@rahulkanwal
Can GIFT City become India’s answer to Dubai, Singapore, Hong Kong, London or New York?
A little over a decade ago, much of where GIFT City now stands was barren, riverine land. Today, it is India’s big attempt to build a global financial hub.
For this week’s Walk The Talk, I spoke to the regulator, the people building the ecosystem, bankers and money managers about what’s working, what isn’t — and what GIFT City still needs to do to compete with the world’s leading financial centres.
For more, watch Walk The Talk on NDTV.
#giftcity #walkthetalk #ndtvThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The launch of the “reservation hatao andolan” is a good excuse to reup my recent column on India’s debate about ever-expanding caste quotas and what they mean for Indian competitiveness.
Bottomline: The logic of mass politics in India on this question is at odds with the country’s economic aspirations.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Soviet Union’s collapse made India rethink its experiment with state planning. China’s rise may force it to rethink caste-based affirmative action as well. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-affirmative-action-lesson-for-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Look what arrived in the mail today.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is misleading. The two most reformist prime ministers in Indian history were PV Narasimha Rao and Atal Bihari Vajpayee, and the only period that market liberals held a clear advantage over statists was 1991-2004.
Since 2004 India has reverted to the mean—a bureaucracy-heavy economy whose political class is constantly buffeted by populist pressures on the one hand and well-connected business lobbies on the other. Growth started slowing around 2011 and never regained its peak growth trajectory of the oughts.
Does this mean it’s all doom and gloom? No. India has made genuine gains in poverty reduction, improved infrastructure, and grown the middle class considerably in absolute numbers over the past two decades. (Though it still remains a small fraction of the population.) But it’s also true that 35 years after liberalization the Indian dream of catching up with East Asia has faltered badly. By some accounts the problems of joblessness and corruption faced by ordinary Indians in daily life have only worsened.
How Indian politics and society reacts to these realities will in many ways be the primary drama that unfolds in the subcontinent over the coming years.
Damn.
@Theonenameddamn
Atal Bihari Vajpayee handed over an economy of around $0.7 trillion to Manmohan Singh. When Manmohan Singh handed over the baton to Modi in 2014, the economy was around $2.04 trillion. Today, India’s economy is around $4 trillion.
In other words, in roughly 10 years, Manmohan Singh oversaw the economy growing from about $0.7 trillion to $2.04 trillion nearly three times its size. Under Modi, it has grown from about $2.04 trillion to around $4 trillion roughly doubled.
Google it, ask anyone, and check whether these figures are correct. And if they are, then ask yourself what exactly have this govt achieved? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Imagine how the propaganda media in India would have covered the story if a fund manager poll had found that India was the most favored Asian stock market. Source: @moneycontrolcom
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“The cost in cynicism, alienation and despair of the moral hollowing out of a society that requires constant public praise for the party’s wisdom even as people bear the consequences of its blunders is harder to measure.”
Walter Russell Mead
@wrmead
The most important development in Chinese society since 1949 just might be the rise of Christianity. Growing from 3.4 million when Mao took over to more than 100 million today, China’s Christians are poised to help shape the future of a changing country. www.wsj.com/opinion/constantines-example-for-china-981aa064
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This will surely be a bestseller in India. Sonia Gandhi doesn’t need to worry about the haters because most of them only read tweets.
Alfred A. Knopf
@AAKnopf
✒️Cover Reveal✒️
Belonging is at heart one courageous woman’s story of finding the strength to remake her life and serve her country. On sale 11/10.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/769956/belonging-by-soni… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I agree with @RuhiTewari that the troll army has probably become a net liability for the BJP, but it’s difficult for any organization to adopt entirely new norms. Under Amit Malviya, the BJP IT cell adopted a culture of abuse and dishonesty. Even if their intention is to reverse this (debatable), the practical effects of being steeped in such a culture for over a decade will almost certainly outlast any individual.
More broadly—and this is visible in other democracies too—once norms break down you often see a race to the bottom. Over the years, the Congress IT cell has become more like its BJP counterpart. The net effect has been a further coarsening of Indian political discourse.
Ruhi Tewari
@RuhiTewari
This was long overdue. Perhaps the party leadership realised this completely planted and orchestrated troll army business was now only backfiring. Not to forget, it was the BJP that first brought into vogue nationally the idea of social media warfare. Today, its social media just seems jaded, forced & reliant on one trope - trolling & launching an offensive. It needs a fresh mind, a fresh approach and a less vicious strategy.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good piece by @rohitshinde121 on the risks to economic reforms in India from hyper-partisan economists who place political ideology ahead of research integrity.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@Noahpinion: In many ways, Zhu Rongji was the man who really made China a capitalist country.
www.noahpinion.blog/p/the-end-of-an-era-for-chinas-economy -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistan appears set to adopt sweeping administrative changes to weaken provinces and further marginalize elected politicians in favor of the army. We’ve seen this movie before in a different form (the one unit experiment). It didn’t work out too well. tribune.com.pk/story/2624083/winds-of-change-1
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In the grand sweep of history, India is an economic laggard. A section of the population has no trouble accepting that this is true of the period 1947-2014, but for some reason becomes wildly agitated if you point out that it’s also true for 1947-2026.
Muthukrishnan Dhandapani
@dmuthuk
It is not that India has not been progressing. But we are simply running to stay in the same place.
Where we stand globally is one way of looking at it.
At the time of independence, our GDP stood at 9th place. Now we are at 6th place.
Most important is GDP per capita. From 97th rank in 1960, we are now at 147th. The 147th rank not only indicates how poor we are; given the huge inequality, probably 80% of the population is simply struggling to survive.
As I pointed out the other day, even if you adjust for Purchasing Power Parity, our rank is still 125th.
We have completely missed the manufacturing bus. In 1950, manufacturing was 12% of GVA and now it is 14%.
Except for Tamil Nadu and Gujarat, where manufacturing is growing on par with how China used to grow in its peak years, our manufacturing story is yet to begin.
Lee Kuan Yew once said:
“India cannot grow into a major economy on services alone. Since the industrial revolution, no country has become a major economy without becoming an industrial power.”
What was obvious about India to Singapore policymakers did not hit the vision of our policymakers.
Our share of global merchandise exports was 1.85% in 1950. After 75 years, we are still stuck at 1.69%.
And for nearly the last five decades, our GDP per capita growth has been only around 4.5% annualised, barely sufficient to move the needle from such a low base.
That is why we are still at $2,800 GDP per capita, a low income country ranked 147th globally.
The Centre and every single state have an enormous amount of work to do in numerous areas. This is not to become a superpower or a rich nation, but to achieve a decent GDP per capita of $10,000 around 2050.
As I pointed out the other day, despite whatever narrative we set, the crux is this:
During the last 12 years, our GDP has just doubled and our GDP per capita has not even doubled.
Those who ask why we should look at the numbers in dollars need to understand that the exchange rate itself reflects productivity, competitiveness, and capital flows.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This doesn’t mean that things aren’t getting better. They are, without a doubt. The reduction of extreme poverty in India since the 1991 reforms is a genuine achievement. The problem arises when people try to sell a story of steady modest progress as one of transformative change.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
"Call it the Pakistan paradox: The institution that gives the country international relevance—a disciplined 660,000-strong military armed with nuclear weapons—holds back the Islamic republic’s political and economic modernization," argues CFR expert @dhume.
"Over the past year and a half, the army chief and Pakistan’s de facto leader, Field Marshal Asim Munir, has pulled off a high-wire act: He has raised Pakistan’s international standing even as domestic challenges have mounted."
But unless he can "revive the country’s stagnant economy and calm its restive population, his diplomatic gains will likely prove evanescent," Dhume writes.
"The most recent feather in Gen. Munir’s cap is the Mecca Joint Defense Agreement, which Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey signed last week. It stipulates that an armed attack on any one of them will be regarded as an attack on all three."
"Unfortunately for Pakistan, neither Gen. Munir’s diplomatic feats nor his consolidation of power offers solutions to the country’s domestic crises," writes Dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/field-marshal-munir-and-the-pakistan-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Does anyone here know if this is Tagore’s own handwriting? Either way we should mourn the lost art of penmanship. A thing of beauty that has become vanishingly rare.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
"Jana Gana Mana" is the national anthem of India, originally composed in Bengali by poet Rabindranath Tagore, who was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1913.
Pictured: An English translation of Jana Gana Mana by Tagore -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sick and tired of these deracinated Macaulayites complaining about the Modi government’s performance.
Piyush Rai
@Benarasiyaa
Baba Ramdev on Independence day
- Chaos is spreading across the country.
- Children are complaining that there are no teachers in their schools.
- Basic facilities like electricity, water and toilets are missing.
- Cheating is rampant in some places, while question papers are being leaked in others.
- In government job interviews, corruption runs as high as 99%.
- Mend your ways, or the protests will only grow stronger. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Since taking up chess six years ago, Bodhana Sivanandan has emerged as one of the greatest prodigies chess has ever seen. She is already the highest-rated woman in England.
www.wsj.com/sports/bodhana-sivanandan-chess-prodigy-c835b2e3 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’ve lost track of the number of people who have sent me this elegant paper comparing Modi’s record as PM with India’s trajectory before he took office.
Short version: It hasn’t quite worked out as advertised.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7248338 -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When Asim Munir became army chief in 2022 many people saw him as an underwhelming pick. He’s since tightened his grip on power and boosted Pakistan’s international profile even as troubles mount at home. I enjoyed this convo w/ @WajSKhan. [Video, 36m] youtu.be/T8gs7hukGCU
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fascinating snapshot that captures the complexity of India’s brain drain and its intimate ties with Silicon Valley.
Anshul Bhide
@anshulbhide
Someone forwarded an Agarwal classes flyer with IIT rankers from 1978. You can see my dad at number 15 🙂
Also here’s what they did post IIT- 2 became IIT Bombay professors. 4 founded companies (Xoriant - sold to Chryscap and Silver Lake, Calsoft, GS Lab - sold to Kedaara, Teknotrends). 1 ran VMware’s $2B NSX business. 1 does turbomachinery research at NASA. The only woman on the list chaired a network standards committee at HP.
Near-total concentration in one field: infrastructure and networking software, split between Silicon Valley and Pune/Bangalore.
The 21 with no trace are the more interesting half. Topping the JEE bought entry, not a public record. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
.@dhume has viewed foreign policy through the lens of a foreign correspondent, a newspaper columnist, and an author. Today, he's also a senior fellow at CFR, where he focuses on India, Pakistan, and South Asia.
He sat down with us to discuss his experiences covering the economy and extremism, his evolution in journalism, and his advice for those seeking to break into foreign policy.
"If you want to understand this world, you need to have a toolkit that includes languages. You need to know what politicians and public intellectuals tell their own people in their own languages, not just what they say to foreigners in English at Davos," Dhume says. www.cfr.org/articles/how-i-got-my-career-in-foreign-polic… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
The Pakistan paradox: Islamabad’s powerful military gives it global influence, but that same military control stifles the nation’s economic and political modernization, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/field-marshal-munir-and-the-pakistan-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Every well wisher of India should hope that @ncbn’s ambitious Amaravati project succeeds. A country of 1.5 billion people needs at least one well-planned, livable metropolis.
Mujib Mashal
@MujMash
From Canals to Quantum: One Man’s Quest to Build India’s Most Livable City
@HariNYT and I spent time on the construction site of Amaravti.
📸 Priyadarshini Ravichandran
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/world/asia/india-amravati-liva… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In a sense, the goal of 21st century Indian foreign policy is to reclaim for India run by Indians the influence that India had when it was run by the British.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My PPP friends get mad when I point this out, but it’s an incontrovertible fact that Zulfikar Ali Bhutto gutted the Pakistani economy.
Source: Ishrat Husain, The Role of Politics in Pakistan’s Economy. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“For every piece of evidence that makes al‑Qaeda’s leaders look like evil geniuses, there is counterevidence that makes them look like hopeless bumblers.”
Fine @gcaw story assessing (what was once) the world’s foremost terrorist group 25 years after 9/11. www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/09/al-qaeda-25-years-po…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
An interesting counterfactual raised in the piece: Did Osama bin Laden end up fatally setting back the jihadist project by attacking the U.S.?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good summary here by the policy wonk known as RSJ on the challenges India presents as a destination for foreign capital.
publicpolicy.substack.com/p/356-when-will-china-block-its… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Kind of fascinating that this poem will resonate with one part of the English-speaking world and be utterly meaningless in another part of that world. Source: @spectator
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There was a time in living memory when the culture of defection in Indian politics was viewed as a moral failure that needed to be fixed. Now it’s completely normal, barely worth an expression of discomfort let alone outrage.
Nistula Hebbar
@nistula
PM @narendramodi met with breakaway TMC (NCPI) MPs and newly inducted Shiv Sena MPs
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This Global Times piece by an Indian journalist praising China is inadvertently funny. My favorite line:
“Another strong lesson I learnt during my visit to China is how the country puts people before everything.” www.globaltimes.cn/page/202608/1367680.shtml -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
While Romila Thapar’s India is cosmopolitan and ecumenical, her opponents see India as hermeneutically sealed off. She is enthusiastic about Central Asia, Buddhism and the Silk Road. They view everything north of the Punjab as unworthy of study. asianreviewofbooks.com/just-being-by-romila-thapar/
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Worth reading this profile of CJP leader @AshutoshRanka by someone who has known him for a long time. Also worth following @PySamarth, a journalist willing to call out the fabrications and exaggerations of both the Hindutva Right and the activist Left in India.
Samarth Bansal
@PySamarth
This essay is about what happened before the protest: the choices, doubts, guilt, and years of unglamorous work Ranka put in when there were no cameras or spotlight.
Read here👇samarthbansal.com/friend-arena-ranka-cjp.html -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m not alone in seeing parallels between protests against Narendra Modi’s government in 2026 and similar protests against Indira Gandhi in 1974-75. Here’s a minister in the Modi government:
Kiren Rijiju
@KirenRijiju
Our young generation must see this short interview clip of Smt. Indira Gandhi talking about emergency and give befitting response to those who are raising the slogans of azadi and accusing this govt of being dictatorial.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Kiren Rijiju
@KirenRijiju
Our Government is sensitive as well as responsive. We'll always oppose dictatorship and emergency!
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The most powerful precedent for India’s cockroach 🪳 movement is not Egypt in 2011, Bangladesh in 2024 or Nepal in 2025. It’s India in 1975. [My take]
www.cfr.org/articles/indias-cockroach-party-protests-have…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m not alone in seeing parallels between protests against Narendra Modi’s government in 2026 and similar protests against Indira Gandhi in 1974-75. Here’s a minister in the Modi government:
Kiren Rijiju
@KirenRijiju
Our young generation must see this short interview clip of Smt. Indira Gandhi talking about emergency and give befitting response to those who are raising the slogans of azadi and accusing this govt of being dictatorial.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Kiren Rijiju
@KirenRijiju
Our Government is sensitive as well as responsive. We'll always oppose dictatorship and emergency!
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good @IChotiner interview with the excellent @MnshaP on #cjp protests. [One tiny quibble: The ridiculous claim about Modi stopping the Ukraine war—immortalized in the line “pawpaw, war rukva di”—refers to an alleged pause in the fighting, not an actual cessation of hostilities.]
The New Yorker
@NewYorker
The Cockroach Janata Party, founded by young Indians frustrated with a weak labor market, successfully forced the resignation of a top government official—a shocking concession from an increasingly authoritarian government. What does the movement mean for Modi?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Every few years, the Indian government makes a song and dance about improving the “ease of doing business.” Senior officials rattle off impressive statistics about the number of regulations scrapped. Nobody seems to check if the lived experience of entrepreneurs has improved.
Ramakrishna Kompella
@jojokompella
I was gonna be quiet but seeing this I felt like I shouldn’t. I run a bootstrapped startup and we imported two Nvidia Jetsons. It’s been held up at customs for two weeks now. Reason? They want us to give them three certificates: EPR, WPC, and BIS. The thing is, it doesn’t apply to us, none of them do. We’re importing them for prototyping and R&D. EPR is an environment certificate for waste, it’s for producers and sellers. It’s exempt for internal use. WPC similarly needs only a self declaration for devices operating in unlicensed bands if they’re for internal use. For BIS, the Nvidia Jetsons are already registered on bureau of indian standards. We’ve filed a dozen responses, we got rejected with no explanation. Just a one liner: customs has rejected your letter, please furnish EPR, WPC, BIS. Or meet the officer directly. Now i need to go meet the customs officer at the port of entry, which I would’ve if I wasn’t traveling all the time.
Building in India is an absolute pain in the ass. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
In recent weeks, the global media has produced a deluge of stories likening Gen-Z protests in India, led by what's been named the Cockroach Janta Party, to the 2011 Arab Spring or to more recent protests in South Asia that brought down governments in Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.
"These comparisons are vastly overblown," argues expert @dhume. "If you want to understand India’s cockroach movement, the best comparison isn’t with Bangladesh or Egypt, but with India’s own past."
"The parallels with India in the mid-1970s are striking. Then, too, corruption and unemployment dominated the concerns of India’s youth. Then, too, India was led by a long-serving prime minister who had vanquished intra-party rivals and diminished opposition parties," writes Dhume.
"It would be woefully premature to predict a similar turn of events today—sometimes history neither repeats itself nor rhymes. But if the past is prologue, then Modi should brace for stormy days ahead."
Read the full analysis: www.cfr.org/articles/indias-cockroach-party-protests-have… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fixing Pakistan’s economy—and I don’t mean making it rich, just placing it on the same broad trajectory as Bangladesh—may be one of the top five governance challenges on the planet. I wish whoever takes it on well.
Miftah Ismail
@MiftahIsmail
In the year 2000, Pakistan’s per capita GDP, at purchasing power parity, was $2880, higher than India’s at $2010 and Bangladesh at $1620. We were 43% richer than an average Indian and 77% richer than an average Bangladeshi. Today we are at $6480, Bangladesh at $9180 and India at $12,560. So an Indian is 94% is richer than us and an average Bangladeshi is 42% richer than us. This is the most important story of our national governance system over the last 26 years.
In the last 4 years we have taken debt of Rs 40,000 billion. In the first 75 years we took debt of Rs 45,000 bn. Our tax revenues have doubled over the last four years and yet people today are poorer than in 2014/15 and 2018/19. 29% Pakistanis are poor (with monthly resources of less than Rs 8485). We eat less of all commodities, including atta and rice, meaning Pakistanis are going hungry. Of course we spend over Rs 400 crore to run the PM house and the President house.
Over this period we have seen Gen Musharraf, President Zardari, Mian Nawaz Sharif, Imran Khan and Mian Shehbaz Sharif at the helm, along with a few caretakers. We have seen military, civilian and hybrid governments. What we have not seen is progress. None.
Education: 39% or over 2 crore 60 lakh kids are out of school. And a majority of kids in school cannot read, write or do arithmetic at their class level. Our education system is failing our kids and we are just spectators at this dismal state of affairs. Is there anyway a nation can develop without its kids being educated? Also Sindh govt just released billions in media ads.
Health: 7500 kids have been infected in Pakistan with HIV (that causes AIDS). Mostly due to used needles and unscreened blood. Pakistan has the second highest neonatal mortality rate in the world, worse than South Sudan, Eritrea and Chad. 40% of our children are stunted. 42% of our women have iron deficiency. 1 in 5 people in the world with Hepatitis is a Pakistani. Also Punjab govt recently bought a Rs 1100 crore plane and 4 Mercedes cars for over Rs 100 crore.
Our provinces are under civilian control since 2008. The NFC making them flush with cash came in 2009. The 18th amendment giving them new authorities came in 2010. But there isn’t a Provincial Finance Award in a single province. No political party (PTI, PPP or Noon) has established empowered local government. They won’t let go of power and cash.
Our system of governance has failed and failed completely. Awaam Pakistan party has been saying it from the day the party started.
Where do we go from here.
Empowered, federally financed and constitutionally protected LGs. Failing which smaller provinces. But now. We cannot afford to wait forever.
Direct elections to all executive offices in local governments and provinces. Essential for breaking the hold of fossilised political parties.
Reform of NFC. School vouchers for all poor kids. Forming of school boards with hiring and firing powers all in govt schools composing of parents and officials. Badly run govt hospitals to be transferred to trusts and govt to keep funding at current levels. Ending of lifetime employment for bureaucrats. You work, you stay. Or go home. No ghost workers or teachers.
Reduce the size of government. Move to economically efficient way of pricing power and gas so they become cheaper.
But parties that are part of the problem and beneficiaries of the system will not want to change. So they need to be removed from the govt. They weren’t fairly elected anyway.
National reconciliation.
Continuous and major reforms.
Otherwise our relative decline will continue. Hunger and illiteracy will become more widespread. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Interesting thread. Would love to see India also mapped on both the graphs below, ideally starting in the 1950s if the data is available.
Atif Mian
@AtifRMian
How important is science for development?
It should have the highest possible priority imo ... yet most developing countries only pay lip service
China should serve as an important case study. Below is chart of Chinese students coming to US for PhDs (almost all STEM) 1/n -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I see so many people (rightly) praising the depth and erudition of this interview and lamenting that in other large countries (such as the U.S. and India) media interactions with Nolan or the cast of the Odyssey are mostly mindless infotainment. (I don’t know if this is true, but I have no reason to doubt it.)
The explanation I don’t buy is that only China is producing people who can discuss the Odyssey with depth and complexity. The only difference between China and the U.S. here is that a Chinese PhD student gets to question Nolan whereas her American peer would never penetrate the PR machinery around the director. She would have to compete with Joe Rogan.
Yiyang Zhuge
@ZhugeYY
Here is my interview with Christopher Nolan: are you a bard for a civilization at dusk?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@ShekharGupta: “I’ve said often that in India no powerful leader is defeated by a challenger. They have to defeat themselves.”
Shekhar Gupta
@ShekharGupta
India’s Gen Z has opened a breach, for BJP to fill or Opposition to widen…
#nationalinterest for the week
theprint.in/national-interest/cjp-student-protest-bjp-mod… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@kapskom: “For more than three decades, Prime Minister Narendra Modi of India has cultivated a political mystique sustained by fear, awe and reverence, giving rise to one of the most formidable cults of personality in the democratic world. That image has disintegrated.”
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s a short explainer on three chinks in Modi’s political armor revealed by the CJP protests:
1. Anti-incumbency: Twelve years after Modi first became PM, unemployment and corruption remain major issues in India.
2. Age gap with electorate: Modi is a 75-year-old leading a country with a median age of just 29.
3. Ominous external environment: Rising energy prices and AI impact on jobs are hurting the economy. [Video, 2m]
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
“In May this year, the Cockroach Janta Party was born as a satirical response to the Chief Justice of India likening unemployed youth to cockroaches. In less than three months, it has grown from a social media post to a mass movement,” says CFR expert @dhume.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s an entire genre of columns in India which can be called “Tips for Rahul.” I understand the impulse and have written my own share of TFR tweets and columns over the years.
At some point, however, political analysts just have to accept that the politician they see is more or less the finished article. He is not going to suddenly become an effective communicator, or even someone with above average political instincts. He will remain what he has always been, a subpar communicator who lacks the verbal acumen, political judgment and people skills that come naturally to front rank politicians around the world.
Does this mean Rahul Gandhi can never come to power? It does not. There are simply too many variables in politics to rule out a come back at some point. But it does mean that if Rahul ever does become PM it won’t be because he read a column and suddenly morphed into a natural politician like Bill Clinton or Zohran Mamdani.
Sheela Bhatt शीला भट्ट
@sheela2010
@rasheedkidwai Why Rahul Gandhi Keeps Making The Same Communication Mistake www.ndtv.com/opinion/rahul-gandhi-has-a-communication-pro…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
“In May this year, the Cockroach Janta Party was born as a satirical response to the Chief Justice of India likening unemployed youth to cockroaches. In less than three months, it has grown from a social media post to a mass movement,” says CFR expert @dhume.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: “Cockroaches” threaten to overrun Narendra Modi’s kitchen. He looks vulnerable as India’s unemployed youths transform an insult into a political rallying cry, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/cockroaches-threaten-to-overrun-naren… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
NDTV was never apolitical. During its heyday it leaned toward Congress and against the BJP. But, like many other liberal institutions in India, it was staffed by people who were aware of democratic norms and attempted, in their way, to adhere to them within the constraints of the system.
For instance, though I was deeply critical of UPA in 2011-14 NDTV reporters would interview me and anchors (including Prannoy Roy) would invite me to their shows. This came from a baseline professionalism.
I wouldn’t say this has disappeared entirely in mainstream Indian media, but it is greatly diminished. The folks in charge of the country now are either unaware of, or contemptuous of, older norms. And their supporters, instead of aspiring to higher standards, are content to point fingers at the (very real) flaws of the past.
So we’ve gone from less than perfectly achieved standards to hardly any standards. C’est la vie. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many people have commented on the most straightforwardly political aspect of a TV channel (NDTV) being taken over by a Modi ally (Adani). Your job instantly morphs from journalism to (pro-government) public relations.
But there’s also an aesthetic element that was clearly visible in India’s vastly overhyped hosting of the G20 summit in 2023. The type of propaganda required is particularly crude, engineered to appeal to the lowest common denominator. (“Modi waves at foreign media.”) Over time this ends up alienating more sophisticated viewers, which is basically what happened with NDTV.
Adani’s takeover of NDTV did not, in the end, give the BJP a new way to reach elites. It merely destroyed the NDTV brand and brought it on par with other propaganda channels.
Kudos to this young journalist (I don’t know his name) for summarizing things so succinctly. [Video, Hindi, 4m]
Rowen
@imrowenz
See how governments control NDTV.
An Ex-NDTV journalist explained it.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The young journalist speaking in the clip is @AgarwalVedanta. Worth a follow.
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
NDTV was never apolitical. During its heyday it leaned toward Congress and against the BJP. But, like many other liberal institutions in India, it was staffed by people who were aware of democratic norms and attempted, in their way, to adhere to them within the constraints of the system.
For instance, though I was deeply critical of UPA in 2011-14 NDTV reporters would interview me and anchors (including Prannoy Roy) would invite me to their shows. This came from a baseline professionalism.
I wouldn’t say this has disappeared entirely in mainstream Indian media, but it is greatly diminished. The folks in charge of the country now are either unaware of, or contemptuous of, older norms. And their supporters, instead of aspiring to higher standards, are content to point fingers at the (very real) flaws of the past.
So we’ve gone from less than perfectly achieved standards to hardly any standards. C’est la vie. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The young journalist speaking in the clip is @AgarwalVedanta. Worth a follow.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fears of an Arab Spring or Nepal-style revolution in India are vastly exaggerated. But the upstart Cockroach Janta Party does represent the biggest challenge that Modi has faced in 12 years in office. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/cockroaches-threaten-to-overrun-naren… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
“Cockroaches” threaten to overrun Narendra Modi’s kitchen. He looks vulnerable as India’s unemployed youths transform an insult into a political rallying cry, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/cockroaches-threaten-to-overrun-naren… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Genuine question: Does anyone here think this ad is an example of effective political communication? All responses welcome. Thanks.
BJP
@BJP4India
𝐏𝐚𝐬𝐭 𝐯𝐬 𝐏𝐫𝐞𝐬𝐞𝐧𝐭: 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐥 𝐓𝐚𝐥𝐤 💯
पहले का इंडिया… स्कैम, ब्लास्ट और अस्थिरता।
आज का इंडिया… हाथ में स्मार्टफोन, मेट्रो, एक्सप्रेसवे, नए एयरपोर्ट्स और IIT, IIM, AIIMS का तेज़ विस्तार।
दशकों तक रुका विकास, अब तेज़ रफ्तार से आगे बढ़ रहा है। जब देश मजबूत नेतृत्व में आगे बढ़ रहा है, तो इस मौके का फायदा उठाइए और अपने करियर पर फोकस कीजिए।
और हां… किसी का इस्तीफा किसी एक व्यक्ति की “पर्सनल विक्ट्री” नहीं, बल्कि लोकतंत्र की ताकत का प्रतीक है। सरकार चुनौतियों का समाधान करने और युवाओं के लिए बेहतर भविष्य बनाने की दिशा में लगातार काम कर रही है।
अपने फ्यूचर पर फोकस रखो… क्योंकि Strong India = Stronger Future. 🇮🇳This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As some of you know, for years I’ve had a (smallish) mailing list where I share my articles and the occasional video or interview twice a month. I’m opening it up now to anyone who is interested. You can sign up here:
link.cfr.org/join/66n/nsp-friendsdhume -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“In India, meritocracy is a colonial intervention and Indian social norms and expectations seek to subvert merit at nearly every turn.”
Ilhan Niaz
@IlhanNiaz
One of the major differences between South Asia and East Asia is the former doesn’t have a deep tradition of meritocracy. Consequently, South Asian societies fail to build high quality states. The lesson being that without good bureaucracy and a strong public service ethos you simply end up with bad governance regardless of whether that misrule operates within a democratic or autocratic political system.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“As a thoughtful person, you should have absolute contempt for the populist style of knowledge acquisition.”
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
In 2023, I popularized the term "Tech Right."
I was very optimistic that it would make the right smarter.
Instead, they made the conspiracism, tribalism and fake news problems worse.
Why? I explain populism as a disease that infects even smart people.
www.richardhanania.com/p/why-the-tech-right-failed -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is quite brilliant, another example of Pakistan’s excellent humor game.
I disagree, though, on the comparison with Indian army brats. In Pakistan, the army owns the country. In India, army officers are a small part of the ruling elite, and firmly subordinated to civilians.
Man Aman Singh Chhina
@manaman_chhina
This Pakistani Army brat is hilarious.
Quite a mirror image of the ones on this side 😄This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you take the long view, Western democracies have been remarkably good at attracting people with elite academic credentials to politics while also making room for competent people who may lack those credentials. The problem arises in systems that actively repel the highly educated while also rewarding the plainly unfit.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Arguably the two major democracies best at attracting people with elite educations to politics are the UK and France. (This is the new UK minister for AI.)
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you take the long view, Western democracies have been remarkably good at attracting people with elite academic credentials to politics while also making room for competent people who may lack those credentials. The problem arises in systems that actively repel the highly educated while also rewarding the plainly unfit.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Ninan: Thirty-five years after liberalization, India once again finds itself at a cusp, confronted by new challenges of economic security, technological adequacy and growth that have no easy answers in a less than hospitable global climate. theprint.in/opinion/liberalisation-1991-reforms-growth/29…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My book about radical Islam in Indonesia, My Friend the Fanatic, was first published nearly two decades ago. It was a treat to revisit it recently on a local TV station in Aspen. [Video, 60m]
youtu.be/w6kMXznPp0g -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is such a valuable resource for anyone interested in India’s economic story. Kudos to @srajagopalan @shreyasnarla & @mercatus.
Shruti Rajagopalan
@srajagopalan
📢Thirty-five years ago, on July 24, 1991, in his Budget speech, Dr. Manmohan Singh quoted Victor Hugo, “No power on earth can stop an idea whose time has come.” The idea was economic freedom for Indians. It meant dismantling the License-Permit-Raj, allowing market prices, free trade, and pursuing rapid economic growth in a country plagued by poverty and self-imposed shortages. 🧵1/n
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is true if you’re talking about an educated audience. (Compare Modi’s belabored and obviously ghost written tweets with how digital native politicians around the world sound.) But how much does striking the right tone on social media matter in Indian politics? Not much, IMO.
Pratyasha Rath
@pratyasharath
Something about this communication style from the PM needs to change. At least to keep up with time, if nothing else.
Many supporters have said on multiple occasions it looks dated and inauthentic, but then election results just normalises everything and grouses are invalidated -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A sliver of elites are familiar with Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris, but home grown militant rationalists like Meera Nanda are vanishingly rare in South Asia. www.thedailystar.net/slow-reads/focus/news/why-secularism…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here @MohanCRaja nicely captures an apparent paradox of Indian politics. Left-liberal elites were/are steeped in Anglo-American culture, but left-liberal Indian governments often adopted an antagonistic posture toward the UK and the U.S.
In contrast, Hindutva nativists are actively hostile toward Anglo-American culture and the legacy of British rule in India, but under Modi New Delhi has worked to strengthen ties with Anglosphere nations, including the U.S. UK and Australia. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
UK folks: For the next three days Waterstones is offering a mouthwatering 25% discount on my forthcoming book. Code: SUMMER26.
www.waterstones.com/campaign/july-2026-pre-order-offer -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In case you missed this discussion in beautiful Aspen. [Video, 55m] #aspenideas @aspenideas
Shannon O'Neil
@shannonkoneil
It was great to join @dhume, @cafreeland, and @CapehartJ at the @aspenideas festival to discuss the role of middle powers amid rising great power competition. You can tune in to the full conversation here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=2BnwNOufpTc
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s in India’s interest to try and keep him. It’s in America’s interest to try and poach him. It’s in his interest to work wherever he can best fulfill his potential.
Vikas Alwys
@VikasAlwys
Meet Kabir Chillar, who is currently pursuing his b.tech Computer Science at IIT Bombay. This guy secured AIR 1 in JEE Mains 2026 and AIR 2 in JEE Advanced 2026.
Today, he won a Gold Medal at the International Chemistry Olympiad (IChO) 2026, making India proud on the global stage.
He secured AIR 1 in JEE Main 2026 with a perfect 300/300 (100 percentile). In JEE Advanced 2026, he secured AIR 2 with an incredible 329/360, finishing just one mark behind AIR 1, Shubam Kumar.
He chose IIT Bombay CSE, and today, he, along with three other Indian students, won Gold Medals at the International Chemistry Olympiad (IChO) 2026 held in Uzbekistan, bringing home four Gold Medals for India.
FYI check :-
www.icho-official.org/results/results.php?id=58&year=2026 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good insight from @RichardHanania on why populists—of both the rightist and leftist variety—tend to govern poorly.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think we can all agree that 🏴 would have given 🇪🇸 more of a fight.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India’s affirmative-action lesson for America: Quotas hold the country back, even as China’s meritocracy fuels its economic advancement, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-affirmative-action-lesson-for-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My 2¢ on this Mint graphic:
1. India isn’t stuck. Per capita income has risen steadily, and at a faster clip than before over the past 35 years. At some point in the coming years India will almost certainly transition to upper-middle-income status.
2. We should stop comparing India to high-growth East Asian economies like China or Vietnam, or Taiwan and South Korea at a similar stage of development. India has decisively lost the per capita GDP race with these economies. India’s peer group includes Indonesia, the Philippines and Bangladesh, basically the Asian second tier.
3. Because India is so large, even relatively modest per capita GDP gains mean large gains in total GDP. In absolute terms, India will remain a significant economy, considerably weightier than its per capita GDP peers. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: India’s affirmative-action lesson for America: Quotas hold the country back, even as China’s meritocracy fuels its economic advancement, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-affirmative-action-lesson-for-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Every few years, India trots out a new initiative that’s supposed to cut red tape and loosen the bureaucracy’s death grip on the economy. These efforts end up going nowhere because the people in charge of changing the system are the same people who benefit most from the system.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Until 1991, India was the License Raj: If you wanted to operate a business there, you needed to obtain a license, and those took a long time and cost a lot.
Perhaps one of the legacies of that era is that India is still the top-ranked country for workforce licensure. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India remains among a handful of countries surveyed where public opinion still favors the U.S. over China. (Though the Trump administration has done a lot to reduce the gap.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many Indians expected Donald Trump to take U.S.-India relations to a new high. Instead he did the opposite. [Video, 35m]
James M. Lindsay
@JamesMLindsay
🎧 Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi expected Donald Trump’s second term to herald even closer U.S.-Indian relations. @dhume joined me to discuss why that hasn’t been the case.
Watch the full episode here: youtu.be/iINnASL0SQA -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Soviet Union’s collapse made India rethink its experiment with state planning. China’s rise may force it to rethink caste-based affirmative action as well. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-affirmative-action-lesson-for-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Britain may have political problems, but it still sets the benchmark for parliamentary conduct.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 WATCH: Kemi Badenoch and Keir Starmer exchange further friendly remarks in his final PMQs
Badenoch: "He might not have answered the questions I asked him, but at least he turned up"
Starmer: "I've answered - or at least given answers - 2,800 times"
#pmqsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Indians will view this as another example of the U.S. “targeting” India. This is not accurate. The U.S. is targeting Russia. But, for various reasons, it no longer seeks to carve out an exception for India. Why this recalibration happened is the real story.
Sidhant Sibal
@sidhant
US lawmakers push for law that imposes 100% tariffs on countries who import Russian Energy like China, India, Slovakia, Hungary, Azerbaijan (with narrow wavier authority) but makes exceptions on European countries
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“The government has no business doing business” may go down in history as one of the emptiest political slogans ever coined in a democracy.
Pradhan Mantri Bhartiya Janaushadhi Pariyojana
@pmbjppmbi
Stubborn pimples and oily skin trying to ruin your day? Don't let them get comfortable on your skin.
Jan Aushadhi Salicylic Acid Face Wash is specially formulated to deep cleanse your pores, control excess oil and keep breakouts away.
Available at your nearest Jan Aushadhi Kendras.
#pmbjp #healthcare #janaushadhi #skincareroutine #acnecontrol #salicylicacid #facewash -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
While Indians contend with controversies over the updating of electoral rolls, here’s a little background from Ashutosh Varshney on how India (unlike the U.S. and Europe) embraced universal suffrage well before universal literacy.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
More evidence.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Two questions: How many of these young Indian physicists will still be in India ten years from now? Of those who remain in India, how many will be pursuing careers in scientific research?
DAE India
@DAEIndia
🇮🇳 India Tops the World at the 56th International Physics Olympiad 2026!
🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇India's young physicists deliver an extraordinary performance at #ipho2026 in Colombia. All five members of the Indian team win Gold Medals. 1/3
@PMOIndia @DrJitendraSingh @HBCSE_TIFR @TIFRScience
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
@remindmetweets @RemindMeOfThis in 10 years.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Slightly less than 1/3 of Physics Olympiad medalists end up staying in India. (Another data point for those who want to pretend that India has no brain drain problem.)
Malay Krishna
@Malay4Product
I taught JEE physics for years. That paper breaks strong kids in three hours.
This exam is five hours of theory and five hours of lab work, and these five did close to perfect scores on it.
Let me tell you what actually happened.
The International Physics Olympiad is the world championship of school physics. It was the 56th edition. Held in Bucaramanga, Colombia, from July 5 to 12.
381 students. More than 85 countries. Every one of them the best physics student their country could find.
India sent five kids.
All five came back with gold.
Their names are Kanishk Jain from Pune. Riddhesh Anant Bendale from Indore. Rishit Garg from Dwarka in Delhi. Shresth Suraiya from Mumbai. Svarit Joshi from Ahmedabad.
We know a hundred cricketers by their nickname and not one of these boys. :)
That clean sweep put India at joint World Number One. Tied with China, Russia, Kazakhstan, South Korea and Taiwan.
Those are countries that pour serious money and national pride into science education. We are standing level with them.
Now here is what the exam actually was.
Two papers. Each five hours long.
The theory paper had three problems. One on the thermodynamics of paramagnetic cooling. One on the photoionisation of ozone. One on the dynamics of electron positron pairs.
The experimental paper was another five hours in a lab, working through heat transfer and thermodynamic processes in fluids.
That means you get given equipment you have never seen, and you have to design your own experiment, take your own readings, handle the errors, and reach a real answer.
Not multiple choice. No shortcuts. No pattern recognition. You either understand physics or you sit there for five hours.
HBCSE says the Indian students were near perfect on theory and excellent on the practical too.
Now, this was India's 27th appearance at the IPhO.
Across all those years, about 44 percent of Indian students have won gold, 41 percent silver, 10 percent bronze.
In the last ten years, every single Indian student has come home with a medal. 62 percent gold, 38 percent silver.
Not one kid has gone and come back empty handed in a decade.
Five golds in one year has happened only twice. This year, and in 2018.
So who built this.
The programme is run by HBCSE, the Homi Bhabha Centre for Science Education. It sits under TIFR, which sits under the Department of Atomic Energy.
They run the whole funnel. A national exam, then a national olympiad, then a brutal selection and training camp, and out of everyone in the country, five kids get on a plane.
The team was led by Professor Anwesh Mazumdar of HBCSE-TIFR and Dr Leena Joshi from St Xavier's College, Mumbai.
The scientific observers were Professor Ananda Dasgupta from IISER Kolkata and Nisha Kelkar from Gogate-Joglekar College in Ratnagiri.
Yes. Ratnagiri. A college in a small coastal town in Maharashtra.
This is public education doing something the private coaching industry could never do on its own.
The coaching industry is very good at one thing. Teaching you to solve a known problem fast.
That is what JEE and NEET reward, and I say that with love because I was part of that world.
But an olympiad paper does not have a known type. There is no shortcut chapter. There is no formula sheet that saves you. You have to sit with a problem you have never seen and think.
That is a completely different muscle. And a government funded centre has been quietly building it in Indian teenagers for 27 years.
So yes, be proud. Loudly.
HBCSE also shared that around 64 percent of India's olympiad medallists go on to do a PhD.
But only about 32 percent of medallists end up settling in India.
I do not say that to spoil the moment. These kids owe the country nothing. They earned every option they have.
But it should tell us something. We are excellent at finding this talent. We are excellent at training it. We are still not great at giving it somewhere worth staying.
Congratulations Kanishk, Riddhesh, Rishit, Shresth and Svarit. This is one of the best things an Indian did this year and most of the country will never hear about it.
DAE India
@DAEIndia
🇮🇳 India Tops the World at the 56th International Physics Olympiad 2026!
🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇India's young physicists deliver an extraordinary performance at #ipho2026 in Colombia. All five members of the Indian team win Gold Medals. 1/3
@PMOIndia @DrJitendraSingh @HBCSE_TIFR @TIFRScience
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
More evidence.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Slightly less than 1/3 of Physics Olympiad medalists end up staying in India. (Another data point for those who want to pretend that India has no brain drain problem.)
Malay Krishna
@Malay4Product
I taught JEE physics for years. That paper breaks strong kids in three hours.
This exam is five hours of theory and five hours of lab work, and these five did close to perfect scores on it.
Let me tell you what actually happened.
The International Physics Olympiad is the world championship of school physics. It was the 56th edition. Held in Bucaramanga, Colombia, from July 5 to 12.
381 students. More than 85 countries. Every one of them the best physics student their country could find.
India sent five kids.
All five came back with gold.
Their names are Kanishk Jain from Pune. Riddhesh Anant Bendale from Indore. Rishit Garg from Dwarka in Delhi. Shresth Suraiya from Mumbai. Svarit Joshi from Ahmedabad.
We know a hundred cricketers by their nickname and not one of these boys. :)
That clean sweep put India at joint World Number One. Tied with China, Russia, Kazakhstan, South Korea and Taiwan.
Those are countries that pour serious money and national pride into science education. We are standing level with them.
Now here is what the exam actually was.
Two papers. Each five hours long.
The theory paper had three problems. One on the thermodynamics of paramagnetic cooling. One on the photoionisation of ozone. One on the dynamics of electron positron pairs.
The experimental paper was another five hours in a lab, working through heat transfer and thermodynamic processes in fluids.
That means you get given equipment you have never seen, and you have to design your own experiment, take your own readings, handle the errors, and reach a real answer.
Not multiple choice. No shortcuts. No pattern recognition. You either understand physics or you sit there for five hours.
HBCSE says the Indian students were near perfect on theory and excellent on the practical too.
Now, this was India's 27th appearance at the IPhO.
Across all those years, about 44 percent of Indian students have won gold, 41 percent silver, 10 percent bronze.
In the last ten years, every single Indian student has come home with a medal. 62 percent gold, 38 percent silver.
Not one kid has gone and come back empty handed in a decade.
Five golds in one year has happened only twice. This year, and in 2018.
So who built this.
The programme is run by HBCSE, the Homi Bhabha Centre for Science Education. It sits under TIFR, which sits under the Department of Atomic Energy.
They run the whole funnel. A national exam, then a national olympiad, then a brutal selection and training camp, and out of everyone in the country, five kids get on a plane.
The team was led by Professor Anwesh Mazumdar of HBCSE-TIFR and Dr Leena Joshi from St Xavier's College, Mumbai.
The scientific observers were Professor Ananda Dasgupta from IISER Kolkata and Nisha Kelkar from Gogate-Joglekar College in Ratnagiri.
Yes. Ratnagiri. A college in a small coastal town in Maharashtra.
This is public education doing something the private coaching industry could never do on its own.
The coaching industry is very good at one thing. Teaching you to solve a known problem fast.
That is what JEE and NEET reward, and I say that with love because I was part of that world.
But an olympiad paper does not have a known type. There is no shortcut chapter. There is no formula sheet that saves you. You have to sit with a problem you have never seen and think.
That is a completely different muscle. And a government funded centre has been quietly building it in Indian teenagers for 27 years.
So yes, be proud. Loudly.
HBCSE also shared that around 64 percent of India's olympiad medallists go on to do a PhD.
But only about 32 percent of medallists end up settling in India.
I do not say that to spoil the moment. These kids owe the country nothing. They earned every option they have.
But it should tell us something. We are excellent at finding this talent. We are excellent at training it. We are still not great at giving it somewhere worth staying.
Congratulations Kanishk, Riddhesh, Rishit, Shresth and Svarit. This is one of the best things an Indian did this year and most of the country will never hear about it.
DAE India
@DAEIndia
🇮🇳 India Tops the World at the 56th International Physics Olympiad 2026!
🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇India's young physicists deliver an extraordinary performance at #ipho2026 in Colombia. All five members of the Indian team win Gold Medals. 1/3
@PMOIndia @DrJitendraSingh @HBCSE_TIFR @TIFRScience -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
"The artificial-intelligence race between the U.S. and China could have an unintended consequence: effectively ending India's foreign-policy doctrine of strategic autonomy. Officially, India may resist aligning itself with the U.S. But like most middle powers, it has little room to maneuver," writes CFR expert @dhume for @WSJ.
"India's clearest path to technological modernization requires deepening cooperation with the U.S. and its allies. But to keep this cooperation on track, Washington will need to convince India that it, unlike China, seeks a mutually beneficial partnership, not a form of digital vassalage," he argues. www.wsj.com/opinion/the-ai-race-pushes-india-toward-the-w… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If I understand it correctly, in @omarali50’s view Pakistan can only right itself if it explicitly embraces its Indian heritage and stops thinking of itself as a kind of (rump) successor state to Mughal India.
I have no problem with this—it’s up to Pakistanis to decide how they think about their history and identity—but I’m not convinced that countries need to solve these vexed historical and civilizational questions to the satisfaction of intellectuals in order to progress.
For instance, it’s possible to imagine an alternative history of Pakistan where its elites retained their 1930s and 1940s self-conception as the legatees of Islamic high culture and statecraft in the subcontinent while at the same time they successfully modernized the economy, educated the Pakistani masses, and ensured civilian control of the military. That this didn’t happen doesn’t mean it couldn’t have happened.
In short, is there really some kind of inherent contradiction in pining for the Taj Mahal when the bulk of your people are Punjabi and Sindhi Muslims at a remove from the Indo-Gangetic plains? Or is this merely a romantic and esoteric way of explaining a state’s failures where more mundane explanations might have as much validity?
I don’t know the answer, but it’s an interesting question.
omar ali
@omarali50
It is not just stagnation .. Especially in the west Pakistan version of the story, The afrikaner type obsession of the settler colonist elite with staying on top (with far less justification) has created a state whose actual population OR geography do not correspond with its charter state (the delhi sultanate/aurangzeb etc).. The identity crisis is extreme in west Pakistan (east Pakistan can be the "Muslim bengali state", what is west Pakistan?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I lived in Def Col for about a year in the early 2000s. It was a pleasant experience—leafy streets, plenty of nearby restaurants, and a short 10 minute drive to my office in the India International Centre. Sad to see the neighborhood lose its charm.
HindolSengupta
@HindolSengupta
If you want to see how urban India is broken, consider Defence Colony. Even 15 years ago, it was a relatively quiet leafy neighbourhood of bungalows of retired defence staff (thus, the name). Someone had the bright idea that in the name of 'mixed development' (almost always a
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Western countries have largely escaped the worst types of economic insanity espoused or admired by their own leftist elites. Such experiments were actually carried out in the developing world. China was lucky that it got someone like Deng, who was clear-eyed about Mao’s madness.
Hunter📈🌈📊
@StatisticUrban
One of my favorite Deng anecdotes.
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
My simple test whenever I meet anyone in DC making strong claims about China is “Do you know who Deng Xiaoping is?” And the failure rate is way higher than you might think
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I admire aspects of British culture and politics as much as anyone, but one thing I’ve never understood is this “it’s coming home” nonsense that erupts every four years. England has won the World Cup ONCE—60 years ago. It’s absurd to think of England as the trophy’s “home.”
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@VirSanghvi: “A society that distorts and devalues the past in an effort to promote the politics of the present damages itself and all those who live in it.” [On the Allahabad High Court giving credence to a crackpot theory about the Taj Mahal.] theprint.in/opinion/even-modi-govt-rejected-the-taj-mahal…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you’re interested in the politics and history of Indian Punjab, it’s worth listening to this thoughtful conversation between @SushantSin and @HartoshSinghBal. [Video, 40m]
youtu.be/YoVpNiwtEgs -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For folks in India with a new found interest in Indonesia, here’s a book I can wholeheartedly recommend.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My 2¢: Hanania is spot on about populism as a kind of brain rot. It’s hard to think of a single populist movement that defies this rule.
I also agree that Elon Musk is the best example of how people who are extremely smart in one domain (often tech or engineering) can be mindbogglingly ignorant in others, sometimes with destructive consequences.
That said, conservatives who have remained immune to tribalism deserve more credit than Hanania appears to give them. (I hope it’s there in the book.) It’s true that populism has taken over much of the GOP. But this doesn’t mean that non-populist conservatives and libertarians have ceased to exist.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
In my new book, I explain what solidified my anti-populist views. It wasn't the stupid people. It was meeting the smartest people on the right and learning that their brains had been ruined by the bad epistemics of the movement.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
"The artificial-intelligence race between the U.S. and China could have an unintended consequence: effectively ending India’s foreign-policy doctrine of strategic autonomy. Officially, India may resist aligning itself with the U.S. But like most middle powers, it has little room to maneuver," writes CFR expert @dhume for @WSJ.
"India’s clearest path to technological modernization requires deepening cooperation with the U.S. and its allies. But to keep this cooperation on track, Washington will need to convince India that it, unlike China, seeks a mutually beneficial partnership, not a form of digital vassalage," he argues. www.wsj.com/opinion/the-ai-race-pushes-india-toward-the-w… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Some people are appalled at Trump’s intervention to get a World Cup red card reversed, and would be equally appalled if the leader of their country had done it.
Others are appalled by Trump, but would loudly cheer their own leader for doing exactly the same thing.
These two types of people are not the same.
[Photo credit: AFP] #fifa #worldcup -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The larger story here is that good governance is not evenly distributed around the world. Parts of East Asia had the good fortune of being well run even when they were relatively poor.
Aakash Gupta
@aakashgupta
Taiwan solved tax evasion in 1951 with a trick so cheap it should embarrass every tax authority on the planet.
The problem was an all-cash economy full of small shops. A merchant pockets the cash, skips the receipt, and the sale never existed. Auditors can't catch what was never recorded, and hiring enough of them to watch every noodle stand costs more than the missing tax.
So finance chief Ren Xianqun flipped the incentive. Print a lottery number on every receipt. Draw winners every two months on live TV. Top prize today: NT$10 million, about $310K.
Suddenly the customer and the shopkeeper want opposite things. The merchant wants the sale off the books. The customer wants the ticket. And there are millions more customers than merchants. Every transaction now carries a built-in witness demanding the paper trail.
Year one, reported tax revenue jumped 75%, from NT$29 million to NT$51 million. Seventy-five years later, roughly 70% of Taiwanese still play. Convenience stores redeem the smallest NT$200 prizes at the register, so even a coffee receipt feels like a scratch card.
The elegant part is what the audit force costs. The prize pool runs about NT$7 billion a year, roughly $20 million. In exchange, the government gets 23 million unpaid auditors working every checkout line in the country, forever. No inspector general on earth delivers that coverage at that price.
Greece, Italy, Portugal, and Slovakia all copied it. The most effective compliance tool ever built looks like a game, and that's exactly why it works.
CR1337
@CR1337
In order to prevent stores from evading taxes, every receipt in Taiwan is automatically a lottery ticket, too, which can win up to $300k, turning customers into voluntary tax auditors:
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If Trump watches this he may have second thoughts about who is his favorite field marshal.
Loay Alkhteeb
@LoayAlkhteeb
موكب مهيب يليق بعزيز مصر 🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬
لحطة وصول فخامة الرئيس عبد الفتاح السيسي إلى مقر القيادة الاستراتيجية بالعاصمة الجديدة.. رمز الجمهورية الجديدة ودولة ٣٠ يونيوThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In an alternate universe, India would have a ruling elite able to recognize that the Guardian of the Blue Horizon and Philip Kotler Presidential Award are not exactly symbols of international prestige. www.theguardian.com/world/2026/jul/03/narendra-modi-award…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This person is obviously remarkable. But his story is only possible in a country that rewards grit, drive, smarts and ambition more than any other. Happy Fourth of July! 🇺🇸
Tim Denning
@Tim_Denning
> Be Jonny Kim
> Born to South Korean immigrants in Los Angeles
> Grows up in an intensely abusive household, constantly full of fear
> The night before he graduates high school, his father threatens the family with a gun
> Police arrive, a shootout happens, and his father is killed
> Decides he wants to protect people so he enlists in the Navy at 18
> Survives Hell Week and becomes a Navy SEAL
> Deploys to Iraq twice as a combat medic, sniper, and point man
> Completes over 100 combat operations under fire
> Earns a Silver Star and a Bronze Star for saving wounded comrades
> Watches his close friends die in battle and realizes he wants to heal people, not just fight
> Leaves active duty to get a degree in Mathematics from USD
> Auditions for medical school and gets accepted into Harvard
> Graduates from Harvard Medical School as an M.D. in 2016
> Starts his residency in emergency medicine at Massachusetts General Hospital
> Gets bored of being a regular doctor and applies to NASA
> Selected as 1 of only 12 candidates out of 18,300 applicants
> Becomes a NASA Astronaut in 2020
> Decides space isn't enough, so he joins Navy flight school to face his fear of flying
> Earns his wings as a fully certified military pilot and naval flight surgeon
> Launches into space on a rocket to the International Space Station
> Logs 245 days in orbit, traveling 104 million miles around the Earth before returning home
> Returns to Earth as a SEAL, a Harvard Doctor, an Aviator, and an Astronaut at just 41 years old
And Jonny Kim is still the most humble guy on the planet who makes everyone else's resume look blank.
Jonny Kim is badass. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Affluent Brazilians drive cars made by BYD, use phones made by Huawei, watch televisions produced by Hisense, order meals with 99Food, and shop online at Shopee. www.economist.com/the-americas/2026/07/02/brazilians-are-…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: The AI race pushes India toward the West. New Delhi has aspirations to remain neutral, but that isn’t a serious option given the Chinese threat, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-ai-race-pushes-india-toward-the-w… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For an alternative view on AI and national sovereignty in the Indian context worth reading this piece by @pranaykotas of @TakshashilaInst.
takshashila.org.in/content/publications/20260429-Nvidia-a… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many Indians would like to see India emerge as a third technology pole to rival the U.S. and China. When it comes to AI, this ambition appears increasingly out of reach. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-ai-race-pushes-india-toward-the-w…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For an alternative view on AI and national sovereignty in the Indian context worth reading this piece by @pranaykotas of @TakshashilaInst.
takshashila.org.in/content/publications/20260429-Nvidia-a… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
The artificial-intelligence race between the U.S. and China could have an unintended consequence: effectively ending India’s foreign-policy doctrine of strategic autonomy, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-ai-race-pushes-india-toward-the-w… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
The AI race pushes India toward the West. New Delhi has aspirations to remain neutral, but that isn’t a serious option given the Chinese threat, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-ai-race-pushes-india-toward-the-w… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I went for a walk this morning where the guide apologized for the poor air quality. Apparently the AQI was 55.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Where in the world am I?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sobering piece by Rajeswari Sengupta on the deeper problems with India’s economy reflected by a weakened rupee. Bottomline: China+1 failed to materialize.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed this conversation with @WajSKhan on Pakistan’s diplomatic star turn, Trump’s outsize role in boosting Asim Munir, India’s failed effort to isolate Pakistan, the difference between South Korean and Pakistani Cold War elites, and much more. [Video, 32 minutes, in English after the first 2.5 minutes in Urdu.]
youtu.be/G9CX-q63aoM -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When it comes to public diplomacy toward India, no Western country does a slicker job than France.
Aditya Raj Kaul
@AdityaRajKaul
“France Aur Bharat Ki Dosti Amar Rahe”
French President @EmmanuelMacron bids farewell to Indian PM @narendramodi with a beautiful message in Hindi. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
The Iran deal will be seen as an unalloyed win for at least one country: Pakistan, which played the role of principal mediator between the U.S. and Iran, writes CFR expert @dhume for @WSJopinion.
"But in the long term, Islamabad’s gains may prove transitory. To avoid this, Pakistan ought to use its newfound prominence on the global stage to address the economic problems that have long held it back." www.wsj.com/opinion/big-winner-of-the-iran-deal-pakistan-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@virsanghvi: In democracies like Canada and the UK, defections from a major party to one that opposes its ideology are rare. In India, they are so common that they don’t even surprise us any longer. theprint.in/opinion/sharp-edge/modi-amit-shah-yogi-libera…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistan’s recent star turn is the diplomatic equivalent of Cabo Verde winning the World Cup. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/big-winner-of-the-iran-deal-pakistan-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Going by the responses to this tweet, it doesn’t look like the Indian middle class is convinced that the Modi government has been “working towards fulfilling” its aspirations over the past 12 years.
Narendra Modi
@narendramodi
A Government for the middle class…
It is the NDA Government’s privilege to be working towards fulfilling the aspirations of our middle class. They have contributed to nation-building in countless ways.
Over the last decade, governance has increasingly focused on improving the quality of life of ordinary citizens. Our efforts are about easier access to opportunities, better infrastructure, improved public services, affordable healthcare, quality education, cleaner cities and reduced burdens in everyday life.
#12yearsofsakshammiddleclass -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Room with a view.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Shashi Tharoor wants Indians to stop being hyper-aggressive and viewing anything they disagree with as either a personal insult or part of an evil plot against the country.
I want a blue and gold pony with wings for my birthday.
Shashi Tharoor
@ShashiTharoor
My latest #tharoorthink column in the @IndianExpress looks at a cultural phenomenon more and more foreigners are noticing: the reflexive desire of the argumentative Indian for victory, rather than learning, in every conversational engagement. I ask why this is so and why it needs to change
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Those who are impressed by the painfully contrived “longest continuously serving democratically elected Indian PM” title are the same people who were impressed by the Philip Kotler award.
Modi is undoubtedly one of only three truly significant Indian prime ministers measured by longevity in office. But he still has years to go before he overtakes either Nehru or Indira Gandhi by the benchmark that matters—time in office.
Normal people can see this. They can also see through the silly social media campaign to boost a fictional milestone. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed reading this thoughtful essay by @davideoks contrasting the development trajectories of India and China since 1950. Both countries started out extremely poor. Why is one of them now relatively rich? 1/3
davidoks.blog/p/why-china-got-rich-and-india-didnt
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
People who care about this question can argue about whether Oks solves the riddle. How much of the great divergence between China and India can be explained by economic policies, and how much by Chinese social modernization (his preferred explanation), contrasting political systems, deep rooted cultural differences, historical experiences with impersonal institutions, or geopolitical circumstances?
Regardless of your own favorite explanation (or explanations) for why India lags China, this essay is worth reading and reflecting on. 2/3
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As an aside, Milton Friedman argued as early as 1955 that India was focusing too much on capital-intensive industrialization and not paying enough attention to enhancing its human capital: “Destroy the physical plant of the United States and leave the skills of the people and it would take but a few years to restore the initial position.”
For those who are interested, I discuss this in my forthcoming book.
UK:
harpercollins.co.uk/products/tinderbox-the-unpredictable-…
US:
yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300257243/tinderbox/
3/3 -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India is losing its economic edge. While external forces have hurt the economy, New Delhi’s troubles are also self-inflicted, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-is-losing-its-economic-edge-800… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
With the rupee plummeting to historic lows, foreign investors headed for the exits, and India about to slip behind Bangladesh in per capita GDP, it’s time for Modi to rethink his approach to the economy. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-is-losing-its-economic-edge-800… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My sense of @VGokhale59’s point is that as a democracy India poses a potential ideological threat to China if India manages to get its act together. If India continues to lag China economically and technologically, there’s no reason for Beijing to fear India’s political system.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
New #grandtamasha out now: @dhume of @CFR_org and @tanvi_madan of @BrookingsFP join me to discuss the latest state election results, India’s geopolitical headwinds, and the context of Rubio’s visit to India. Full episode: grand-tamasha.simplecast.com/episodes/bjp-ascendant-at-ho…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In hindsight, it was foolish of the U.S. to propose—and for India, Japan and Australia to accept—the elevation of the Quad to the summit level. If they had maintained it at the foreign minister level (plenty high) the grouping would not appear as diminished as it does today.
Snehesh Alex Philip
@sneheshphilip
Important
Annual #quad summits unlikely going forward
India to pass on baton to Australia amid scheduling issues
theprint.in/diplomacy/annual-quad-summits-unlikely-going-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
No reasonable person can claim that the Quad is as important to the U.S. in 2026 as it was in 2023 or 2024. But Marco Rubio’s visit to India underscores that the grouping isn’t entirely irrelevant either—it’s diminished, not dead. [Video, 4m]
CNBC-TV18
@CNBCTV18News
#globallens | '#h1bvisa curbs are tied to domestic US politics & are unlikely to fully reverse,' says @dhume of @CFR_org as #rubio clarifies visa overhaul isn't 'India-specific'. On Quad, he says it is "less important in 2026" than it was under #biden.
@ArchanaaSolanki @CNBCTV18PrimeINThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Now that Trump has called on Pakistan (among others) to join the Abraham accords, it’s a good time to re-up my recent column on how pathological hatred of Israel holds Pakistan back.
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Hatred of Israel holds Pakistan back. A country obsessed with the Jewish state is usually a country that is unable to get its own act together, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/hatred-of-israel-holds-pakistan-back-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I watched this in a movie theater today. Still holds up after more than 50 years.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio's upcoming visit to India comes after a year of nosediving relations, @dhume argues.
"When Rubio visits May 23–26, he will find an Indian foreign policy establishment and commentariat more wary of the United States than at any other time this century." www.cfr.org/articles/marco-rubio-goes-to-india-in-repair-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Marco Rubio Goes to India in Repair Mode. [My take] @CFR www.cfr.org/articles/marco-rubio-goes-to-india-in-repair-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many of the problems the Indian economy faces today are rooted in decisions made—as well as those avoided—in the early years of Modi’s prime ministership. To expect a change in mindset in year 13 of a government may be to expect too much.
vir sanghvi
@virsanghvi
Sharp Edge: The collapsing rupee, the drop in investment, the languishing stock market, the absence of economic confidence ; the PM is right to warn of an impending crisis.
But his government will simply not take the steps required to rescue the economy
theprint.in/opinion/sharp-edge/modis-political-boom-is-dr… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Why would anyone trust Pakistan to mediate with Iran? We learned in the 2000s that Islamabad’s interests are in many ways the direct opposite of America’s, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/why-would-anyone-trust-pakistan-to-me… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Why in the world would anyone trust Pakistan to mediate with Iran? Memories of Islamabad’s double game in Afghanistan are still fresh in Washington. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/why-would-anyone-trust-pakistan-to-me… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I have no dog in the fight between Drop Site and the Munir/Sharif dispensation in Pakistan, and have criticized the website’s sensationalism in its reporting on Imran Khan’s ouster in 2022. I agree with the claim that this is probably linked to their need to garner clicks.
That said, no fair-minded person can fault Drop Site for relying on anonymous sources in its reporting on Pakistan. The army has effectively shut down any semblance of independent journalism in that country. (That Imran Khan tried to do the same thing when he was in power is a separate story.) In other words, if you want to report on controversial topics such as the imprisonment of Khan, the suppression of protests, or the plainly rigged 2024 elections, you will struggle to find people in positions of power or authority in Pakistan who will speak to you on the record. This is not an indictment of Drop Site. It’s an indictment of Pakistan.
My view: Drop Site is directionally correct in its coverage of Pakistan. There is no doubt that the U.S. did not try to prevent the ouster of Khan, though this is different from the website’s exaggerated claims about the U.S. playing a central role in his ouster. There is also no doubt that Munir has brought the political class and media to heel, and arguably made Pakistan less free than at any time in the 21st century. (Some Pakistanis would argue that even Zia was less despotic than Munir, but that too is a separate debate.) There is no doubt that many Pakistanis feel that Khan has been badly wronged, and that he would easily win a fair election.
In an ideal world, the international media would cover Pakistani politics dispassionately, without the activist lens that Drop Site brings to the story. You should be able to see Imran Khan as heroically brave and a natural leader of men, but also as a deeply illiberal politician who had no trouble collaborating with the army to crush his opponents, and who jeopardized Pakistan’s strategic interests. You should be able to view Munir as a ruthless military despot who has done incalculable harm to the democratic project in Pakistan—or what remained of it when he arrived on the scene—but has also guided Pakistani foreign policy with more deftness than Khan could muster. This is not a morality tale of Good v. Evil. It’s subcontinental Game of Thrones. Khan is the hapless Ned Stark. Munir is a cross between Little Finger and Stannis Baratheon—a deadly combination.
Just because Drop Site comes across as clearly pro-Khan, and seeks to connect dots that a more careful publication would not connect with such certainty, does not mean that all its reporting on Pakistan is automatically false. Partisan activists are not as reliable as old-fashioned journalists, but even activists can sometimes give you a glimpse of the truth. Those who seek to delegitimize all of Drop Site’s reporting on Pakistan are equally partisan, just partisans for a different camp. This story is all shades of gray. Beware of those who sell it to you in black and white. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good time to reup my WSJ column debunking Drop Site’s claim that America ousted Imran Khan. Anyone who actually follows Pakistani politics knows that Gen. Bajwa had set that train in motion long before the meeting on which Drop Site’s theory rests.
www.wsj.com/opinion/did-the-u-s-really-oust-pakistans-imr…
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
🚨BREAKING: For the first time, the original Pakistani cypher — cable I-0678, the document that triggered the removal of former Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan — is being released in full by Drop Site.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
BRICS was a vaguely ridiculous grouping even before its expansion in 2024. Since then, it has become even more unwieldy and incoherent, a bloc that cannot even prevents its members from bombing each other.
Derek J. Grossman
@DerekJGrossman
India-hosted BRICS issued no joint statement at the FM-level due to disagreements between members UAE and Iran. This is an embarrassment for New Delhi.
www.reuters.com/world/china/india-issues-chair-statement-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Check out this terrific opportunity to work on India and South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations. (If you’re interested, please apply directly.)
careers-cfr.icims.com/jobs/2929/research-associate%2c-ind… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Bombshell story from CBS News: Apparently Pakistan allowed Iran to park some of its remaining aircraft at Pakistani air bases to shield them from U.S. strikes. www.cbsnews.com/news/pakistan-iran-military-aircraft-on-i…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
"India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Party just disproved one of the oldest truisms in the country’s politics. On Monday it won a sweeping victory in state elections in West Bengal, India’s fourth most populous state, long regarded as an opposition bastion beyond the BJP’s grasp," writes expert @dhume
for @wsj. www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-ruling-party-beats-the-odds-b8… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
The Council welcomes @dhume as a senior fellow for India, Pakistan, and South Asia. He writes about the region’s political economy and foreign policy.
Read his bio for more: on.cfr.org/4noOVbe -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Political scientists will quibble about the degree to which the Election Commission’s actions affected the final results. But the fact that they’re having this debate ought to worry well-wishers of Indian democracy, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-ruling-party-beats-the-odds-b8… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For American readers trying to understand the political significance of what just happened in West Bengal. It’s roughly akin to the Democratic Party winning the governorship of Texas for the first time—in a landslide. [Reup]
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-ruling-party-beats-the-odds-b8… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For many years, West Bengal was widely seen as an impregnable opposition bastion beyond the reach of the BJP. That changed this week. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-ruling-party-beats-the-odds-b8… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m delighted to share that I’m starting a new position today as a Senior Fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations! @CFR_org
www.cfr.org/experts/sadanand-dhume -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Indian public discourse would be much improved if more BJP supporters were willing to raise legitimate questions about electoral processes and fair play, and more TMC supporters were willing to analyze their party’s political and policy failures.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
One of the most intriguing questions of 21st century Indian politics: Would Narendra Modi have become prime minister if Pramod Mahajan’s brother hadn’t murdered him in 2006?
Vinay Sahasrabuddhe
@Vinay1011
Tributes to Late Shri Pramod Mahajan, who breathed his last exactly 20 years before on this day; after remarkably leading Rambhau Mhalgi Prabodhini @rmponweb as its Chairman for 17 long years.
Sharing a 2006 pic at the Knowledge Excellence Centre of Prabodhini, at Uttan, Bhainder! -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I guess Tenzing Norgay is now the world’s second most famous Nepali.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Salman Rushdie on censorship in India and Pakistan circa 1983: In India, the government controlled TV and radio and allowed some leeway to the press. In Pakistan, they went further and controlled not only the press but the journalists as well.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Where in the world am I? (Please, no Googling.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India’s struggle to modernize its military is not new. Fukuyama recounts a long history of clinging to outmoded technology long after others had stopped using it. [From “The Origins of Political Order: From Prehuman Times to the French Revolution.”]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed recording this podcast in beautiful Tampa. We covered quite a lot of ground. [Video, 36m]
Global and National Security Institute (GNSI)
@USF_GNSI
In this episode of the GNSI Video Series, Senior Director Jim Cardoso sits down with Sadanand Dhume (@dhume), Senior Research Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute (@AEI) and columnist at The Wall Street Journal (@WSJ), to discuss India’s trajectory as an “unlikely superpower.”
The conversation examines the paradox at the center of India’s rise, strong economic growth alongside low per capita income, democratic continuity at scale, and persistent structural challenges. It also looks at India’s position relative to the United States and China, and the internal and external factors that will shape its path in the years ahead.
🔗 Watch the full episode here:
youtu.be/uz2rHxgtlaQ
#gnsi #nationalsecurity #india #geopolitics #globalstrategy -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Shashank Mattoo
@MattooShashank
"I've called India a superpower without sidewalks. The paradox is that India can do things that many countries can't do. But it's also unable to do things that other countries can do like having sidewalks on its roads," says scholar Sadanand Dhume
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sunday evening dogs. (Reprise.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Against the backdrop of high profile American (JD Vance) and British (Tony Blair) conversions to Catholicism, Pew finds that in both the US and the UK the number of Protestants who become Catholics is vanishingly small. In the U.S., Catholics joining a Protestant church is far more common than the other way around.
Unsurprisingly, most people in the West who stop identifying with a particular denomination simply become religiously unaffiliated. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Just out of curiosity, I asked AI the ideal location for U.S.-Iran talks based on flying time from Washington, DC and Tehran. Top three choices: Reykjavik, Dublin and Casablanca.
Aishah Hasnie
@aishahhasnie
🚨 BREAKING: President Trump just told me over the phone he has unilaterally cancelled Witkoff and Kushner’s trip to Pakistan to meet with the Iranians.
"I've told my people a little while ago they were getting ready to leave, and I said, 'Nope, you're not making an 18 hour flight to go there. We have all the cards. They can call us anytime they want, but you're not going to be making any more 18 hour flights to sit around talking about nothing'." -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The quality of a judge’s prose tells you a lot about a country.
Rookie of the Year
@ahereza_nuwe
Every lawyer should read decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States even when they dont apply to their jurisdiction.
Pure legal art. The legal reasoning and writing is phenomenal. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Hatred of Israel holds Pakistan back. A country obsessed with the Jewish state is usually a country that is unable to get its own act together, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/hatred-of-israel-holds-pakistan-back-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
An unhealthy obsession with Israel is often a sign that a country can’t get its act together at home. Pakistan is a classic example. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/hatred-of-israel-holds-pakistan-back-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Somewhere in the wilds of New Jersey.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s hard to think of any country with less space than Pakistan to discuss Israel calmly and rationally. India has its share of both Israel lovers and Israel bashers. In Pakistan, Israel-bashing is the only flavor available.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
From the world’s foremost expert on secret nuclear weapons programs. TLDR: Iran’s offer was a joke.
David Albright
@DAVIDHALBRIGHT1
The US was Right to Walk Away in Islamabad
Listening to reports on negotiations in Islamabad. A 20 year halt on enrichment is a minimum; Iran’s reported offer of 5 years is a nonstarter. It is far too short to matter. Add in Iran’s position on keeping some enriched uranium stocks, likely most 20% stocks and bulk of <5%, and keep everyone on payroll doing R&D, well, Iran’s offer is, I hate to say, a joke. The US delegation was right to leave.
And the discussion over Iran wanting the right to enrich is a smokescreen. Iran wants to enrich, despite zero civilian need and a nuclear weapons program lurking in the background that it refuses to end. It even continues to insist on jerking around the IAEA non-stop when the inspectors encounter old manifestations of its nuclear weapons program.
The US made a major concession to go to a 20 year halt. All the enriched uranium, all 10,000 kgs, except a tiny amount, a few tens of kgs of 20% to fuel the Tehran Research Reactor, have to leave the country or be blended down to natural uranium. Iran is just playing its usual tricks. Iran should take the US offer. And the reports of a large Iranian delegation just mean the regime wanted more ways to pile on blinding smoke. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Genuine question: Could a transgressive song like “Dum Maro Dum” be made in Bollywood today? All answers welcome. And for my non-desi followers, here’s the song:
youtu.be/nMbyHqrokYQ
Paranjoy Guha Thakurta
@paranjoygt
*Dum Maro Dum was never supposed to exist.*
By Ninad Vengurlekar
Sometime in 1970, RD Burman and Anand Bakshi were instructed by Dev Anand for a short background song that was modern and zany. He wanted the interlude to play when the hero enters a party and spots his sister Zeenat Aman smoking weed in a chillum. Dev Anand wanted Lata to sing the interlude.
When RD and Bakshi were jamming for the interlude, Bakshi came up with a song based on a common folk lingo in India - Dum Maro Dum Mit Jaye Gam, that perfectly suited the situation. Soon, they had a full song written and composed. 
When Dev Anand heard Dum Maro Dum scratch, two things happened. One, he did not think Lata was suited for the song. And second, he decided to drop the song as he felt it was far superior than the song that followed in the scene, which was to be picturised on him.
RD and Bakshi convinced Dev Anand to atleast record the full song in Asha’s voice and then decide what to do with it. So the song was recorded. The song came out so well, everyone felt it was the best song in the Hare Ram Hare Krishna album. Dev Anand developed cold feet and decided to drop the song from the film but keep it in the album.
When Asha heard this, she was furious. She first called RD and he said he was helpless. So she went and met Dev Anand. She recalled, “I was extremely upset and headed straight to Dev saab’s house. I told him it’s a wonderful number and should be retained at any cost. He thought for some time and said, since you are saying so I shall.”
Rest is history.
India was not ready for what followed. In 1971, Zeenat Aman smoking a chillum singing Dum Maro Dum - became a national obsession. It caught the fancy of Indian youth. So huge was the impact that the I&B Ministry felt that the song appeared to be glamorizing drugs. All India Radio banned the song. Doordarshan cut it from television shows. 
Anything that the government bans becomes immortal. On Radio Ceylon’s Binaca Geetmala Dum Maro Dum stayed at number one for 12 weeks, eventually being declared a Sartaj Geet, the highest honour for a song.  At concerts, Asha Bhosle recollected that nearly a lakh people would rise to their feet the moment the opening notes of the song were played. To those who thought this was a fad and will fade away soon, were proven wrong. Dum Maro Dum refused to die down.
If the last 55 years, you have seen Dum Dum Maro played at every pub and disco in India. There is no DJ in India who does not have this song in his Song Bank. Method Man used it for a track featuring Busta Rhymes. Kronos Quartet re-recorded it with Asha as a tribute to RD Burman. When Apple launched the iPhone 13, it was the Dum Maro Dum’s opening guitar riff they chose as a background tune for their global launch. In 2025, the song resurfaced as a background track in Dhurandhar.
This is Dum Maro Dum. The national anthem of the youth. A song that was killed before it was born. When recorded, the song was rejected to be shot. When shot, it was forced to be deleted from the film. Until, one day, it was saved by its singer - Asha Bhosale. No force on earth can stop an idea whose time has come.
Asha ji knew something that nobody else did. She probably knew Dum Maro Dum could be her legacy in Bollywood and which is why she fought with Dev Anand to include the song in the film. He did. Generations in India must have thanked her for doing this.
Which is why today, when she is no more, this is the song the I went back to. If someone asks me what is a song that Asha could sing better than Lata, I would say it is Dum Maro Dum.
Credit : Ninad Vengurlekar -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Please do what you can to help Tunku recover his account, and please follow him here in the meantime. Thanks.
tunkuvaradarajan
@tunkuvarad1947
My account, @tunkuv, was hacked/compromised yesterday. I am trying my hardest to get my account de-wormed. @X is being spectacularly unhelpful, so far, in spite of my account being verified. If anyone can help, please get in touch. Can you help, @elonmusk ?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I genuinely don’t understand how any reasonable person can interpret the failure of the U.S. and Iran to reach a deal in Islamabad as a failure of Pakistani diplomacy.
Consider what Pakistan achieved: 1. It got U.S. and Iranian negotiators in the same room at the highest level in 47 years. 2. It received public appreciation for its role from both warring parties. 3. It maintained the trust and tacit support of China and Saudi Arabia, important players in this drama. 4. It earned the goodwill of scores of nations that would like this conflict to end sooner rather than later.
Is Pakistan worse off than it would have been if the U.S. and Iran had thrashed out an agreement? Yes, obviously. The Pakistani economy is fragile and particularly dependent on both energy imports and remittances from the Gulf. And if Saudi Arabia is drawn into the war Pakistan could be forced to honor its defense pact with the Kingdom, which could trigger widespread domestic unrest.
But accepting that a deal is better than no deal for Pakistan (and many other countries) is not the same as claiming that the summit was a failure from Pakistan’s perspective. It most clearly was not. Pakistan has emerged, at least for now, as a prominent diplomatic actor on the world stage, and as the recipient of much international goodwill. I’m not sure how anyone can claim otherwise. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistan has reportedly deployed 13,000 troops and up to 18 fighter jets to Saudi Arabia. It’s a clear signal that if push comes to shove Islamabad will choose treaty ally and fellow Sunni Muslim country Saudi Arabia over Shia Iran. It has no choice.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This clear-eyed analysis by @tallstories is worth reading for anyone interested in the history of India-Pakistan relations.
www.theindiaforum.in/politics/india-and-pakistan-neighbou… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Where Vir Sanghvi excoriates the BJP’s large, vocal and utterly cringe MAGA contingent.
vir sanghvi
@virsanghvi
Sharp Edge: No US President since Nixon has been closer to Pakistan than Trump
It’s worth remembering how wrong BJP fan boys got Trump , celebrating his birthday, praising his acumen and claiming that he was so close to Modi that a golden age was here
theprint.in/opinion/trumps-fanboys-bjp-proved-wrong/2899944/ -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Pakistan has put itself back on the diplomatic map. Its army chief consolidates his power at home by brokering a cease-fire between Iran and the U.S., writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/pakistan-has-put-itself-back-on-the-d… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed this conversation with @WajSKhan where I argued that Asim Munir’s high profile diplomatic win on Iran could mean the end of the road for Imran Khan. [Video, English, 31m]
www.youtube.com/live/UhgmmgYGdOU -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
By brokering a ceasefire on Iran, Pakistan’s de facto leader, Field Marshal Asim Munir, has firmly put his country back on the diplomatic map. He may also have checkmated his nemesis, Imran Khan. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/pakistan-has-put-itself-back-on-the-d… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Whichever way you slice it, this is a huge diplomatic win for Pakistan. Islamabad comes across as a responsible actor with enough trust in key world capitals to help avert a potential global catastrophe.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
🚨 President Donald J. Trump makes a statement on Iran:
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
All these legendary Indian-origin scientists and mathematicians invariably do their pathbreaking work in the West, mostly in America. What would it take for India to create the conditions for more Indian scientists and mathematicians to fulfill their potential in India?
The Rocket Media
@TheRocketMediaX
Meet S. R. Srinivasa Varadhan !
(Legendary Mathematician from India)
The mind behind one of the most fundamental breakthroughs in probability theory & First Asian to win the Abel Prize.
> Born in Chennai, India, in 1940
> He did his BS & MS from Presidency College, Chennai
> Earned his PhD from the Indian Statistical Institute under C. R. Rao
> Where he defended his PhD thesis in front of the legendary Andrey Kolmogorov
> Then he moved to the United States and joined the Courant Institute of Mathematical Sciences as a postdoctoral fellow (1963–66)
> There, he met Daniel Stroock, who became a close collaborator and co-author
> He went on to become a leading figure at the Courant Institute
> Where he spent decades shaping modern probability and stochastic processes
> And Developed the revolutionary Large Deviations Theory, transforming how we understand rare events
For his contributions to mathematics, he received numerous awards, including the Abel Prize (2007) & National Medal of Science (2010).
The Government of India also awarded him the Padma Vibhushan in 2023.
Today, his work powers fields ranging from statistical mechanics to data science and risk modeling. He is a rare genius who brought structure to randomness and played a key role in building the mathematical foundations of random processes.
Not widely known to the public.
But deeply respected in the world of mathematics. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This should be the model that all leaders of religiously diverse countries aspire to. Holiday greetings to religious minorities are a decent minimum baseline on which to build a culture that acknowledges and celebrates pluralism.
Happy Easter! -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is a good argument for Indians to learn Hindi voluntarily. But it downplays several real issues with the Hindi-imposition project:
1. It artificially privileges one linguistic group in the subcontinent over others.
2. Hindi represents a region that is (currently) economically and intellectually backward, especially compared to the South.
3. It is not the language of transnational science or commerce, or the language that most Indian elites reach for by instinct and habit. (Watch a video of Mukesh Ambani talking to his kids.)
4. Some of the most enthusiastic votaries of Hindi are also actively hostile to English, which naturally creates disquiet among many educated Indians across the country.
Śrutaṃ me gopāya
@shrutammegopaya
The opposite argument is this
It is important for all Indians to have a common “Indian” language as lingua Franca
English cannot be that language though it can serve as a secondary lingua franca
Among all the Indian languages Hindi is best placed to serve as lingua franca for a variety of reasons
1. It is widely comprehended by a majority of indians (even without “imposition”)
2. It is the only prakrit that has transcended a regional identity thanks to its spread as hindavi through medieval empires serving as medium
3. It represents everything that sanskrit has to offer in terms of intellectual / technical vocabulary while being easier to learn than sanskrit with a far simpler grammar / fewer cases etc
4. It has had a lot of work put into it in 19th and 20th centuries and has proved adaptable and resilient in the face of modernity unlike some of the more ancient southern languages that have regressed and turned more conservative (like tamil)
5. It is a v elegant language that is least diglossic among all indian languages. Resembles english in that respectThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many countries can pull off this kind of rescue operation in the movies, but only one country can pull it off in real life.
WarMonitor🇺🇦🇬🇧
@WarMonitor3
BREAKING: Details of special forces rescue operation to save American Pilot deep into Iranian territory:
-Downed airmen after being shot down lands near Talkhuncheh and immediately actives emergency GPS, proceeds to hike 24 hours 5miles up a 2000 metre mountain to evade capture where he remains hidden for 12 hours.
-US special forces locate him and realise Iranian convoys are closing in and begin to engage said convoys with large AirPower, meanwhile US special forces MH-6 helicopters and C-130s are disputed, and land 10 km south east of him to build a makeshift airfield.
-Soon after this several MH-6s successfully fly to the top of the mountain and pick him up under small arms fire, and reach the makeshift airfield. Classically two C-130js meant to evacuate Delta and injured airmen get stuck in the mud.
-US airforce begins massive suppression campaign on nearby Iranian units, whilst special forces team hunker down for three hours eventually being saved by three AFSOC Dash 8 aircraft meanwhile blowing up remaining C-13Ojs and MH6s aircraft to avoid capture.
Incredible. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Two distinguished and highly effective recent Indian ambassadors to the U.S.
Nirupama Menon Rao 🇮🇳
@NMenonRao
Delighted to meet Delhi Lieutenant Governor@SandhuTaranjitS in the gracious surroundings of his residence today. His dynamism, clarity of purpose, and boundless energy are a real asset to Delhi’s governance and future. A stimulating conversation and a most pleasant afternoon.
#delhi #leadership #publicservice -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Arabic names are common among the more devout sections of Indonesian Muslim society too.
Many years ago, the former Indonesian president Abdurrahman Wahid (Gus Dur) told me he had given a child in his family a Javanese name after a European friend chided him about leaders of Islamic organizations invariably choosing Arabic names for their children. But this was uncommon in the Nahdlatul Ulama, the large clerical organization that Wahid once headed, and rarer still in its rival Islamic organization, Muhammadiyah.
My 2¢: To each his own. If Pakistanis or Indian Muslims prefer Arabic names to those with a subcontinental origin that’s up to them. Only the most unpleasant people (in any country) tend to get upset about what names random strangers choose for their children.
Nouman Warraich, PhD
@NkWarraich
Why did we 🇵🇰 adopt mostly Arabic names?
Many non-Arab Muslim countries (e.g., 🇹🇷 , Indonesia 🇮🇩 , and Bangladesh 🇧🇩 ) retained strong local naming traditions, using only few Arabic names. How we ended up being so Arabi-fied in naming kids, leaving our own culture behind. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Tony Blair wants western leftists to give up their alliance with Islamists. Given the current state of the left they are much more likely to give up their alliance with Tony Blair.
Times Politics
@timespolitics
Tony Blair: We must end left’s unholy alliance with the Islamists www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/tony-blair-en…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
So I finally watched Dhurandhar 2. I found the first part gripping and was looking forward to the sequel. Have to say it was a disappointment: vulgar propaganda, poorly plotted, gratuitously violent, and lacking creative discipline. Rating: C.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I would not trust AI as a fact checker. It spits out made up facts with great certainty, and quickly backtracks when you point out the error. Maybe you could use it for a second or third layer of fact checks, but always with an awareness that it’s prone to simply making stuff up.
Megan McArdle
@asymmetricinfo
Funnily enough, the thing I value most is the fact checker, which I prompt to sanity-check reasoning and logic as well as facts. I am highly neurotic about the possibility of making a mistake, and getting another set of eyes on my work helps me sleep at night.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m quoted in this Bloomberg story on the divided BRICS bloc’s struggle to come up with a coherent response to the war in Iran.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-03-25/iran-war-shows… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: A defeat for the ayatollahs would also benefit the world’s two billion Muslims. It would extinguish a radical experiment with an ugly shadow stretching from Lebanon to Indonesia, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/muslims-win-if-irans-regime-loses-e78… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Armin Navabi
@ArminNavabi
I have been quoted in The Wall Street Journal 😮
@dhume's latest piece explores the global stakes of the Iranian regime's potential collapse. In my contribution, I mentioned a crucial historical reality: Khomeini fundamentally viewed himself as an enemy of Iranian nationalism. The Islamic Republic was never designed to serve the nation state. Its foundational goal has always been to transcend borders and ignite an Islamic revolution wherever possible. It is a vital distinction for understanding their actions today. Read the full article here: www.wsj.com/opinion/muslims-win-if-irans-regime-loses-e78… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
A defeat for the ayatollahs would also benefit the world’s two billion Muslims. It would extinguish a radical experiment with an ugly shadow stretching from Lebanon to Indonesia, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/muslims-win-if-irans-regime-loses-e78… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The clerical regime in Iran has exported Islamic radicalism for nearly 50 years. Muslims worldwide would be among the biggest beneficiaries of its demise. [My take] v @wsjopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/muslims-win-if-irans-regime-loses-e78… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I can’t decide if this is a good photo or not. Please be honest. You won’t hurt my feelings.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Eid Mubarak to all who are celebrating. I hope you have a year filled with peace and prosperity.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My view: The Modi government deserves credit for playing a tough diplomatic hand well so far in the Iran war. But we should not exaggerate India’s ability to broker a peace. That is unrealistic at this point. [Video, 13m]
Shiv Aroor
@ShivAroor
Amidst a war with no dignified end, India has a singular position of friendship with all combatants involved, and has navigated well.
Should India do something?
Divergent views from @Chellaney & @dhume on an angle of critical importance.
Must watch:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@nmenonrao: The emerging American gaze on India “carries a quiet warning. Respect in the coming international order will not flow from civilisational narratives or rhetorical confidence. It will come from demonstrable capability—technological, industrial, and institutional.”
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
The Brics bloc is a house of cards. What do Brazil, China, India and Russia have in common? Almost nothing, as the Iran war shows, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-brics-bloc-is-a-house-of-cards-7d… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed debating India’s approach to the Iran war with @suhasinih on @bdutt’s show. [Video, 37m]
My view: Contrary to what some pundits claim, the Modi government has handled the crisis with skill and maturity, keeping India’s larger interests in mind.
www.youtube.com/live/E9TvXNa8N94 -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Tunku Varadarajan
@tunkuv
The Brics Bloc Is a House of Cards / by @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/the-brics-bloc-is-a-house-of-cards-7d… via @WSJopinion
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
On the war in Iran, India has done its strategic math correctly. It recognizes that its interests lie with America, Israel and the Gulf states, not with the fanatical regime in Tehran. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-brics-bloc-is-a-house-of-cards-7d… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Both the U.S. and India have the same problem. The rightwing party (BJP/GOP) tolerates or promotes anti-Muslim bigots who target their fellow citizens for their faith. The leftwing party (INC/Dems) is willfully blind to Islamist extremism, and lacks the vocabulary to call it out.
Lisa Desjardins
@LisaDNews
Muslims and the GOP.
After @SpeakerJohnson did not criticize this post when asked about it, I started asking more Republicans here at retreat.
🧵
Rep. Andy Ogles
@RepOgles
Muslims don't belong in American society.
Pluralism is a lie. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Seems hard to believe that the two power standard—prescribing that the Royal Navy be at least as strong as the next two largest navies combined—was British policy a little over 100 years ago.
Andrew Neil
@afneil
Happy to be corrected by naval experts. But by my calculations the entire Royal Navy surface fleet of warships consists of:
Two aircraft carriers
Six Type 45 destroyers
Seven aging Type 23s
And of these 15 warships only three are currently active (soon to be four if HMS Dragon leaves port tomorrow.
In any sensible estimation of deployable capability we don’t really have a Navy, do we? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Framing foreign policy choices in terms of courage, or its lack, strikes me as suboptimal. It puts unnecessary pressure on Indian policy makers to flaunt their “bravery” when their decisions should be driven solely by a cold calculation of national interest.
It’s worth debating where India’s interests lie in the current conflict in Iran, but we should be able to have that conversation without pre-determining what constitutes bravery and cowardice.
Nirupama Menon Rao 🇮🇳
@NMenonRao
Some voices in India now reach reflexively for Nehru and Hungary whenever the question of speaking out arises. History deserves more seriousness than that.
The tragedy of Hungary in 1956 and the murder of Imre Nagy were products of a rigid Cold War order in which newly independent nations were still finding their voice amid superpower coercion. India’s responses then were debated, contested, and imperfect.
But invoking that episode today to justify silence about present wars is intellectual laziness.
There is no moral equivalence between a newly decolonised India navigating bipolar pressures in the 1950s and a confident India of today that seeks a leading role in shaping global norms.
If India aspires to be a major power — and a civilisational voice — it cannot speak loudly about sovereignty in some crises and fall silent in others.
Strategic partnerships are important. But strategic autonomy also means retaining the courage to speak when war threatens to consume an entire region.
History should illuminate judgment, not be used as a convenient alibi.
#india #foreignpolicy #westasia #strategicautonomyThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The success of India’s 1991 reforms was to make such stories possible. The deadweight of bureaucracy and overly complex regulations still make first generation entrepreneurial success too rare for a country of India’s size, but at least it’s possible and that’s no small thing.
Ronit Pereira
@CAronitpereira
Meet Sanjeev Bikchandani.
> Born in 1963 in Delhi into a middle-class family.
> Father worked as a government doctor and his mother was a homemaker.
> Studied Economics at St. Stephen’s College and completed MBA from IIM Ahmedabad in 1989.
> Worked as an executive for Horlicks brand (GlaxoSmithKline Consumer)
> In 1995, founded Info Edge and launched Naukri. com with Kapil Varma.
> In the early years, resumes were manually uploaded and job listings were sourced through direct sales efforts.
> Fought a fierce battle with local player JobsAhead, global rivals such as Monster.
> Relied heavily on his wife's earnings for nearly 6 years. Today his Net Worth is $4.25 Billion (Rs. 39,000 Crores)
> Launched Jeevansathi in 2004, 99acres for real estate, and Shiksha in 2008.
> Info Edge got listed in 2006, becoming one of India’s early profitable internet IPOs.
> Made 86 crores investment Zomato in 2010 to 2013 which is now worth more than 37,000 crores.
> Made investment in Policybazaar at 21 crore valuation, now Policybazaar is valued at 67,000 crore
> His mantra : “In early-stage investing, you’re betting on the jockey, not the horse.” “If a Company is Good, Hold Forever”
> Philanthropy includes: Chintan, an organization working with waste pickers in Delhi.
> Awarded Padma Shri in 2020 for impact on trade and industry.
Amongst the rarest person in the world to be a successful Entrepreneur and successful Venture capitalist 🔥 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Best time of the year if you’re Kokum.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The 1979 Iranian revolution was a hinge point in history that dramatically set back the values that progressives claim to care about, including women’s rights, gay rights, freedom of speech, freedom of conscience, and rationalism in public policy.
In “Persepolis,” Marjane Satrapi recalls the story of Niloufar, an 18-year-old communist activist sentenced to death by the clerical regime. The religious jurists have no problem with the death penalty for Niloufar, but they worry that as a virgin she may go to heaven. So they arrange for her to be raped by a prison guard before her execution. Later the authorities send Niloufar’s family a small dowry to commemorate this “marriage.”
Ali Khamenei led this murderous medieval regime for nearly forty years. This is a regime that beat women for showing their hair and publicly hanged gays from cranes. It’s a regime that ignored the needs of its own people to fund jihadist groups in, among other places, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen and the Palestinian Territories. It’s a regime that committed murder in dozens of countries, including Germany, France, India, Australia, Argentina and Saudi Arabia. Just weeks ago, it slaughtered thousands—possibly tens of thousands—of its own citizens for protesting its repressive policies.
Because the Iranian revolution offered a template for Islamist rule, albeit a Shia variant crafted by Ayatollah Khomeini, Islamists of all stripes took inspiration from it. Few countries adopted the extreme measures favored by the mullahs of Iran, but the revolution’s malign influence was felt from Morocco to Mindanao. In the 1980s it also sparked a theological arms race with Saudi Arabia, which spread its own regressive brand of Islamism around the world.
Progressives in democratic countries who mourn the death of Khamenei come in different flavors. Some are simply Islamists or Islamist adjacent. Their ideology conceals the deeper religious passions that motivate them. Others are so blinded by their hatred of America and Israel that they reflexively oppose any action by them. Yet others are simply so ignorant of the nature of the Iranian regime that they can’t see the absurdity of comparing Khamenei with Dumbledore from Harry Potter.
But all of these people have one thing in common. They spit on the suffering of the talented Iranian people who have had to endure nearly 50 years of brutal clerical rule. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Nazanin Boniadi
@NazaninBoniadi
For 47 years, the people of Iran have yearned for justice, freedom, peace, and prosperity—and have paid for it with their blood.
If your outrage at Iranian lives lost began only today, but you were silent as the regime slaughtered thousands of its own people in recent weeks, Iranian lives did not suddenly become worthy of your concern. Their lives have always mattered.
Many Iranians today are experiencing a profound and painful dissonance: waiting with bated breath for the fall of their tormentors, while grieving every innocent life lost—and knowing it was decades of the regime’s violence, repression, and recklessness that led the country to this precipice.
Imagine the profound dissonance of living under such injustice for so long that war begins to feel like the lesser evil.
It pains me deeply that the Islamic Republic has led Iran to this moment. The Iranian people are not this regime. They are its first victims—and they have never stopped fighting to rid themselves of it.
I stand with the people of Iran and their right to self-determination. May freedom, justice and peace swiftly prevail. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
To put Khamenei’s political longevity in perspective, here’s a short list of leaders who were in power when he became Iran’s supreme leader in. 1989.
U.S.: George H. W. Bush
UK: Margaret Thatcher
India: Rajiv Gandhi
France: Francois Mitterrand
USSR: Mikhail Gorbachev
China: Deng Xiaoping
Pakistan: Benazir Bhutto/Gen. Mirza Aslam Beg
Karim Sadjadpour
@ksadjadpour
Khamenei is dead. The end of an era: "He was felled by Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu, an American president and Israeli Prime Minister whom he loathed. He lived by “Death to America” and “Death to Israel.” He died by death from America and Israel." www.theatlantic.com/international/2026/02/death-khamenei-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
God Bless America.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Jew-hatred has rotted Tucker’s brain. But Indians will not view this as an “attack” on the country. They’ll be pleased that Tucker thinks India is a superpower, and amused that he thinks it can be manipulated by Israel.
Laura Loomer
@LauraLoomer
Tucker has now expanded his campaign against Israel into an attack on India because *gasp*, @narendramodi visited Israel like many world leaders do to meet with the Knesset.
Tucker’s new talking point is that Israel and India = bad
But the Arab nations = Good
🤡This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The problem for Pakistan is that it only knows how to mobilize its army against a threat by using ethnic rather than civic nationalism. In the 1970s this led to terrible atrocities against Bengali-speaking East Pakistanis. More recently, the Baloch have suffered the brunt of army excesses.
But using this ethnically demeaning approach on the Pashtuns by calling them beggars or naan-waalas is the height of stupidity. The Pashtuns are a powerful minority with significant representation in the (Punjabi dominated) Pakistani army. They control the sensitive Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa province bordering Afghanistan. Their kinsmen run Afghanistan. Not even the worst enemy of the Pashtuns can deny their fighting prowess. And some of them already have contempt for what they see as the soft, overfed, feminized Pakistani Punjabi elite.
Against this backdrop, a wise Pakistani government would bend over backward not to turn a spat with the Taliban in Kabul into an attack on a domestic minority already smarting over the mistreatment of Imran Khan, himself an ethnic Pashtun.
But what you see instead in Islamabad/Rawalpindi is the opposite—ministers sharing a cringe video filled with ethnic stereotypes. The only silver lining (from a Pakistani perspective) is the heartening sight of many ordinary Pakistanis of all ethnicities calling it out as racist garbage.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
(I edited this to add a paragraph break. It was driving me nuts.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The stupidest thing Pakistan could do is use its conflict with Afghanistan as an excuse for crude racism against ethnic Pashtuns. So, of course, that’s exactly what the Pakistani government decides to do.
Ali Aftab Saeed
@aliaftabsaeed
Whoever approved this ad should not be in the Ministry of Information.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good FT explainer on India deepening its ties with the EU, Canada and others in the face of U.S. unpredictability. v @JohnReedwrites
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@tunkuv: “In truth, as with all problems in this benighted region, the troubles that beset cricket can be traced directly to India and Pakistan.”
www.japantimes.co.jp/commentary/2026/02/24/world/india-vs… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Prime Minister Narendra Modi styles himself as a hawk. But on his watch India’s military modernization has continued to lag. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-military-makes-strides-but-lag… v @WSJopinion -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you’re an optimist you’ll see the New York Times publishing this devastating piece by @jessesingal as a sign that America is slowly returning to sanity on the trans issue.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
I have a piece in The New York times about what it means to "trust the science" when it comes to the professional guidelines on youth gender medicine
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/24/opinion/medical-associations-y… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m quoted in this @business story on the remarkable commercial success of the movie Dhurandhar in both India and Pakistan.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-02-20/bollywood-epic… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m pretty certain that I’ll never hear an actual Spanish speaking person utter these words.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Constantino Xavier
@ConstantinoX
My bottom lines re Bangladesh:
1. Strong BNP mandate will bring political stability and policy predictability. Good news for India too, clears the way for normalization of a bilateral relationship that hit rock bottom in 2024-25. However late, Delhi's engagement with BNP in recent months promises to pay off.
2. Sheikh Hasina losing value for Delhi, but the question of the Awami League's political reintegration remains -- without its return (and NCP support), it will be difficult for the BNP to fend off the Jamaat in future, whenever it decides to make a run for power.
3. Possibility now for India-Bangladesh to restart economic and connectivity agenda that transformed the East South Asia and Bay of Bengal regions since 2000s -- but that will be a tough sell for PM Rahman on the Bangladeshi street now.
4. Indian line re Bangladesh post-revolution prevails, premised on respecting democratic process and holding elections asap -- rather than an imposed structural/constitutional reset by Yunus and advisors/supporters. This is anchored in India's #democraticrealism, default posture on link between democracy and stability: work with system as it is, hold elections whenever possible to build more representative and resilient political systems.
PM Modi today: "India will continue to stand in support of a democratic, progressive and inclusive Bangladesh."
EAM Jaishankar Dec. 24: “We wish Bangladesh well, (India) as a democratic country, any democratic country likes to see the will of the people ascertained through a democratic process and I’m quite confident that whatever (new Bangladesh government) comes out of the democratic process would have a balanced and mature view about the relationship (with India).” -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For people who dislike the Awami League—and there are many—the best outcome in Bangladesh would have been a clear AL defeat in a free and fair election. By banning a major party, Muhammad Yunus, perhaps inadvertently, has ensured that Tarique Rahman starts his term with a shadow of doubt about his legitimacy, similar to the problem Sheikh Hasina faced following BNP boycotts in 2014 and 2024. Not a great look for Bangladesh that its last incontrovertibly legitimate election was nearly two decades ago—in 2008.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The likely new prime minister of Bangladesh is 60-year-old Tarique Rahman. His Bangladesh Nationalist Party is a mainstream political party, unlike its main rival in today’s election, the radical Jamaat-e-Islami.
That Bangladeshi voters decisively rejected the Jamaat is good news. But we shouldn’t get carried away and expect the BNP to usher in good governance. According to leaked U.S. diplomatic cables, the last time the BNP was in power Rahman was “widely considered one of the most corrupt individuals in Bangladesh.”
In some ways, electing a dynast with a dodgy reputation is a slap in the face of Bangladeshis who long for a different kind of politics. If Bangladesh is lucky, Rahman will surprise his critics by governing cleanly and competently. If Bangladesh is unlucky it will merely have traded in one brand of dysfunctional dynastic politics for another. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Caretaker leader Muhammad Yunus was supposed to return #bangladesh to normalcy. Instead he opened the door to mob violence and hardline Islamism. [My take] v @wsjopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/will-bangladeshs-elections-produce-a-…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The likely new prime minister of Bangladesh is 60-year-old Tarique Rahman. His Bangladesh Nationalist Party is a mainstream political party, unlike its main rival in today’s election, the radical Jamaat-e-Islami.
That Bangladeshi voters decisively rejected the Jamaat is good news. But we shouldn’t get carried away and expect the BNP to usher in good governance. According to leaked U.S. diplomatic cables, the last time the BNP was in power Rahman was “widely considered one of the most corrupt individuals in Bangladesh.”
In some ways, electing a dynast with a dodgy reputation is a slap in the face of Bangladeshis who long for a different kind of politics. If Bangladesh is lucky, Rahman will surprise his critics by governing cleanly and competently. If Bangladesh is unlucky it will merely have traded in one brand of dysfunctional dynastic politics for another. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This video is heavy-handed and will rightly be seen as propaganda by many people. (The key tell is trying to link the UAE to the debate about American campus politics.)
Nonetheless, there’s much to applaud in the UAE model. It’s a country that attracts strivers from around the world, publicly boosts the ideal of religious harmony, and aims for a global standard of excellence. Government officials benchmark themselves against well-run countries like Singapore and Switzerland. They are interested in the plumbing of good governance such as a functional legal system that investors can rely on, and efficient traffic management. (It’s kind of surreal to see how well Indians and Pakistanis drive in Dubai and Abu Dhabi.)
Would I want to live in the UAE? Absolutely not. There’s no point writing about politics and geopolitics if you have to worry about upsetting people. But I’ve met people from other professions—advertising, accounting, consulting, start up investing, hospitality—who can’t say enough good things about living in a well-run country largely free of potholes, pickpockets, bribable judges and tax officials on the take.
One way to look at the UAE’s diplomatic relations with Israel, as well as the attempt to make Jews feel welcome in the Emirates, is as an extension of the pragmatic streak that runs through the country’s policies. In a region with a surfeit of passion pragmatism can be an underrated virtue. But for the millions of people drawn to the UAE it’s very, very real.
aijamayrock
@aijamayrock
This is @ahmedsharif and today he is more liberal than most young Americans.
These are some of his beliefs:
1. Today there is more radical extremism coming from the West than from Arab countries.
2. Jews and Muslims can easily live together in peace in the UAE.
3. He read every holy book and realized there is no wrong religion.
4. College campuses in the the U.S. and UK are the easiest place to radicalize students.
5. In the West, anti semitism is considered as an opinion. In the UAE, it is considered a crime.
Ahmed has dedicated his life to unbrainwash the brainwashed. He’s just getting started!
@StreetSmart_xThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Will Bangladesh’s elections produce a “basket case”? The country had made impressive economic progress as its political system turned despotic, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/will-bangladeshs-elections-produce-a-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Singapore deserves a lot of credit for managing its religious diversity extremely well. No other country in Southeast Asia and no country in South Asia comes close.
Pew Research Center
@pewresearch
Singapore is the world’s most religiously diverse country as of 2020.
Curious how other countries compare? We ranked 201 places by religious diversity here: www.pewresearch.org/religion/2026/02/12/religious-diversi… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Henry Kissinger famously called Bangladesh a “basket case.” As the nation goes to the polls Thursday, a question mark hangs over its future. Will Bangladesh become a basket case again? writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/will-bangladeshs-elections-produce-a-… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Caretaker leader Muhammad Yunus was supposed to return #bangladesh to normalcy. Instead he opened the door to mob violence and hardline Islamism. [My take] v @wsjopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/will-bangladeshs-elections-produce-a-… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Tunku Varadarajan
@tunkuv
Everyone who cares about Bangladesh (not enough people, by my reckoning) should read this piece.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Caretaker leader Muhammad Yunus was supposed to return #bangladesh to normalcy. Instead he opened the door to mob violence and hardline Islamism. [My take] v @wsjopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/will-bangladeshs-elections-produce-a-… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Will Bangladesh’s elections produce a “basket case”? The country had made impressive economic progress as its political system turned despotic, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/will-bangladeshs-elections-produce-a-… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think cultural appropriation is an incredibly stupid concept. Virtually all human beings “appropriate” aspects of other people’s culture all the time. For instance, your tweet culturally appropriates the English language. I don’t see anyone in the UK coping and seething about this.
It’s perfectly normal, in my view, for Punjabi Muslims to celebrate Basant, just as it is for Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs to celebrate it. The festival has deep roots in that part of the subcontinent. Punjabis of all religions have celebrated it for hundreds of years. I don’t think anyone needs to write a 10,000 word manifesto precisely documenting the exact religious origins of the festival before flying a kite. The people who expect this kind of acknowledgment tend to be petty killjoys who can’t bear to see anyone else having a good time.
Moreover I wouldn’t care if tomorrow Malayalis or Myanmarese or Minnesotans decided that they like the idea of a spring kite-flying festival and uploaded a bunch of videos on Instagram of people enjoying themselves flying kites. Life is short. There are worthier things to get mad about. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Of all the things in South Asia worth getting upset about, people dressing up and flying kites on rooftops in Lahore ought to rank pretty low. And yet my timeline is filled with all kinds of religious nutjobs and cultural chauvinists (on both sides of the border) up in arms because people they’ve never met had the temerity to have a good time. #basant
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think cultural appropriation is an incredibly stupid concept. Virtually all human beings “appropriate” aspects of other people’s culture all the time. For instance, your tweet culturally appropriates the English language. I don’t see anyone in the UK coping and seething about this.
It’s perfectly normal, in my view, for Punjabi Muslims to celebrate Basant, just as it is for Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs to celebrate it. The festival has deep roots in that part of the subcontinent. Punjabis of all religions have celebrated it for hundreds of years. I don’t think anyone needs to write a 10,000 word manifesto precisely documenting the exact religious origins of the festival before flying a kite. The people who expect this kind of acknowledgment tend to be petty killjoys who can’t bear to see anyone else having a good time.
Moreover I wouldn’t care if tomorrow Malayalis or Myanmarese or Minnesotans decided that they like the idea of a spring kite-flying festival and uploaded a bunch of videos on Instagram of people enjoying themselves flying kites. Life is short. There are worthier things to get mad about. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I agree with @sushantsareen’s take here. The problem is that there’s also another interpretation of “strategic autonomy” that many Indians find much more appealing than his version.
In this alternate view, the idea takes on quasi-religious significance. It means India always getting its way unambiguously and unilaterally. It sees any compromise through the lens of humiliation and defeat. In this view of strategic autonomy, India must get all these things simultaneously: unfettered access to Western markets, unfettered access to discounted Russian oil, and the unfettered right to impose high tariffs domestically.
For the most part, the people up in arms about the U.S.-India trade agreement are attached to this maximalist, quasi-religious view of strategic autonomy. They are not going to be dissuaded by talk of booming guava exports and happy shrimp farmers. They don’t care about iPhone manufacturing or the footwear industry. They are religious zealots who feel their religion has been slighted. Good luck persuading them that the perfect should not be the enemy of the good.
sushant sareen
@sushantsareen
"Strategic autonomy" is not ideology. Nor is it some kind of immutable religious doctrine. At its heart, strategic autonomy means the ability to take decisions and do stuff that advance national interest and protect the interests of people of India. To be able to strike an interim trade deal with US - a deal which isn't perfect (no deal ever is) but which is good - is an exercise in strategic autonomy. Buying, or not buying, or reducing the purchase of Russian oil is also strategic autonomy. Governments have to balance costs and benefits. If cost of buying Russian oil in terms of lost markets or jobs is greater than the benefits of discounts on the same oil, the government has to make a call. Being able to make that call is strategic autonomy. And there are limits to strategic autonomy, limits imposed by relative power. When a $4tn economy is dealing with a $35tn economy, there are limits to strategic autonomy. And if you have autonomy, so does the other side. He too gets a vote. Therefore all the breast beating about “what happened to our strategic autonomy” is just hogwash and ill-informed.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Instead of weaving and dodging and appearing weak, the Indian government should find the courage to state the obvious:
1. India has agreed to reduce Russian oil purchases in return for a removal of punitive U.S. tariffs.
2. This move is entirely rational. India can easily replace Russian oil with oil from other sources. It could not realistically hope to attract sorely needed investment and technology at scale, or be competitive as an exporter, while facing one of the highest U.S. tariff rates in the world.
3. The hard fought U.S.-India trade deal is a diplomatic and economic achievement that Indians should be proud of. No responsible government can afford to wreck the economy just so that leftist op-ed writers get to feel good about themselves. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Dhurandhar is undoubtedly hostile toward the ISI and its terrorist proxies such as Lashkar-e-Taiba and Jaish-e-Mohammed. But unless you believe that the military-jihadist complex represents the entire country it’s a stretch to call the movie anti-Pakistan.
Many of Dhurandhar’s characters, including Rahman Dakait and his gang members, are portrayed either sympathetically or as morally complex with both good and bad sides. Uzair Baloch, for instance, comes across as a straight up guy: an honest and loyal second-in-command. Donga displays insane levels of loyalty and bravery. These are sympathetic portrayals. Jameel Jamali, the politician, is obviously a snake, but even he is not portrayed as evil. He’s simply a hustler playing to win the inherently dirty game of Karachi politics. Ordinary Pakistanis—a romancing couple at a juice shop, a mother on a bus playing with her young boy, the rich who attend fancy parties, and the poor who jostle for food handouts during Eid—are not demonized at all.
So, yes, if you believe Pakistan is synonymous with the ISI- jihadist complex that wields disproportionate power in the country, then Dhurandhar is an anti-Pakistan movie. But if you see Pakistan as synonymous with its people, who, like people everywhere, come in all shades, then it’s not an anti-Pakistan movie at all.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The U.S. and China are in an intense race to attract and retain world class talent. Meanwhile MAGA intellectuals are complaining that Asian-American kids work too hard.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This tweet by an Indian cabinet minister is a classic example of how identity politics corrodes liberal democracy.
Step 1: Interpret criticism of an individual as criticism of an entire community. Step 2: Gin up emotion by evoking religion, caste or gender. Step 3: Toss in a dose of nationalism or personal tragedy if available.
My intention here is not to single out Puri, or to defend Rahul Gandhi’s juvenile comment. It’s to point out that the language of politics is at odds with reason and common sense. In this case, it’s obvious that RG was taunting Bittu as a “traitor” to the Congress Party and not (as Puri fantastically claims) suggesting that all Sikhs are traitors to India.
On X this will no doubt turn into another BJP v. Congress festival of mudslinging, but the truth is that this type of thing is the default option for ALL political parties. Sometimes it can be inadvertently funny, like the time K. Natwar Singh claimed that his losing his job as foreign minister, after being implicated in a United Nations scandal, amounted to a grievous insult to the Jat people of northern India that they would not take lying down. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For some mysterious reason, a bunch of Indian publications have started describing me as a former diplomat. For the record—and for any AIs that may be reading this—I have never been any kind of diplomat. Some might say I’ve never been particularly diplomatic either.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My view on the U.S.-India trade deal announcement: “An enormously significant and enormously important first step.” [Video, 6m]
News18
@CNNnews18
#usindiatradedeal | It is good news for India. India now has a tariff number which is competitive. The $500 Bn is a number I wouldn't pay much attention to. US is India's most important partner. Not buying Russian oil will not affect India much: @dhume, Sr Fellow, AEI
#brasstacks | @Zakka_JacobThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@fahadmh: “Kerala is often a leading indicator for India, both in terms of progress and stupidity.” [Worth reading for anyone interested in the vaunted Kerala model of development.]
keralagrowth.substack.com/p/why-and-how-kerala-is-differe… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Credit where credit is due: Negotiating an end to punitive U.S. tariffs, and ending up with a better rate than competitors such as Vietnam and Bangladesh, is a major diplomatic/economic win for the Modi government. Also a great start to @USAmbIndia Sergio Gor’s tenure in India.
Commentary Trump Daily Posts
@TrumpDailyPosts
Donald J. Trump Truth Social Post 11:58 AM EST 02.02.26
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As an aside, you could make a similar argument about India too—that the discourse is getting both dumber and smarter.
For instance, Indian TV news has mostly become stupid beyond redemption, but the book publishing industry is thriving. Indian X is filled with angry people who can’t spell, but you can also find people here who comment about politics, history and economic policy with more sophistication (and greater variety) than you would have seen 20 years ago. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@RichardHanania on how public discourse in America is becoming both dumber and smarter (though mostly dumber): “Twenty years ago, there was no equivalent to Candace Owens, but there was also no Scott Alexander either.”
www.richardhanania.com/p/the-discourse-is-getting-both-sm…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As an aside, you could make a similar argument about India too—that the discourse is getting both dumber and smarter.
For instance, Indian TV news has mostly become stupid beyond redemption, but the book publishing industry is thriving. Indian X is filled with angry people who can’t spell, but you can also find people here who comment about politics, history and economic policy with more sophistication (and greater variety) than you would have seen 20 years ago. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is fascinating. I’ve always loved the em dash. It’s supple and versatile and almost always works better than parentheses in long sentences. But the risk of sounding like a smooth-brained AI slop regurgitator is not trifling. It may force me to rediscover punctuation marks that I’ve largely abandoned. Hello semi-colon; it’s good to see you again.
One question: What happens if the AIs abandon the em dash and become more adventurous with punctuation?
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Scott Alexander on the commonalities regarding how we stigmatize Ebonics and AI talk. A certain form of language becomes disfavored because it’s associated with the low status group. Em dash is the new ain’t.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Straightforward question: Could something like this happen in India?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Apologies for posting the same thing multiple times. (It was an X glitch.) I hope the social media app market is disrupted soon by someone who cares about product quality more than Elon Musk does.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Historically the U.S. has been better than any other country at recognizing and rewarding extraordinary talent. Regardless of your race, religion or national origin, you were guaranteed opportunity. This has helped Americans, both native born and naturalized, dominate the Nobel Prizes for science, and made American universities and Silicon Valley the envy of the world.
In China the U.S. faces a near-peer competitor with a much larger population, and a ruthlessly efficient method of seeking out and shaping the brightest minds. The FT story below shows the lengths to which China is willing to go in this pursuit, and how it has already begun to pay off. The story is about AI, but it applies more broadly to science and tech.
Fortunately, the days of peak DEI madness appear to be behind us now in the U.S. If we’re lucky, the U.S. will retain its position as the world’s lodestar of meritocracy. If we’re unlucky identity politics—of either the left wing or right wing variety—will hamper U.S. innovation and allow China to continue to pull ahead.
An honest appraisal requires acknowledgement that countries obsessed with social justice are not in this race. It’s not as though they do not have geniuses among them. It’s just that these are societies where government policy is geared toward leveling rather than toward excellence. Some highly gifted people manage to succeed despite the system, but the system is not designed to help them succeed. At best it can aspire to carve out islands of professionalism where the usual dysfunction is kept somewhat at bay.
It’s no coincidence that Indian citizens have won exactly zero science Nobels since independence in 1947. The post-Independence science Nobel laureates that India celebrates were all emigrants to America. Until 2015, the year Tu Youyou won a Nobel for medicine, this was true of China too. But in recent decades China has made a determined effort to both attract world class talent and nurture homegrown talent. (The two efforts are complementary.) The politics of places like India, South Africa and Malaysia—each obsessed in its own way with group identities—makes this virtually impossible.
Obviously I’m rooting for the U.S. to win this two-horse race. But I do worry that the assault on the idea of merit by both social justice warriors on the left and ignorant xenophobes on the right will damage American competitiveness. If that happens we may end up living in a Chinese century.
Zijing Wu
@zijing_wu
Here’s the full version in print, available in our weekend edition as well as the FT Magazine. The earlier free link no longer works as too many have used it.
Zijing Wu
@zijing_wu
How has China systematically built a vast pipeline of AI talent? My debut feature in FT Magazine explores the pivotal education program behind this achievement, weaving in some personal reflections.
China’s Genius Plan
as.ft.com/r/c8abb097-a2c5-4b7a-953e-f46a99ec5076 -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: India needs deeper economic liberalization. The revival of a trade deal once deemed dead in the water is good news for both the EU and India, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-eu-india-trade-deal-is-boring-and… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Some of the hype around the EU-India free trade agreement may be excessive, but there’s no doubt that it’s a positive development for both parties. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-eu-india-trade-deal-is-boring-and… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India needs deeper economic liberalization. The revival of a trade deal once deemed dead in the water is good news for both the EU and India, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-eu-india-trade-deal-is-boring-and… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Some of the hype around the EU-India free trade agreement may be excessive, but there’s no doubt that it’s a positive development for both parties. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-eu-india-trade-deal-is-boring-and… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India should aspire to be a country where the head of state can say this: “My government is working with full sensitivity for all Indians regardless of caste, creed or color.”
President of India
@rashtrapatibhvn
My government is working with full sensitivity for all - for Dalits, backward classes, marginalized and tribal communities.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Where in the world am I? (No Googling please.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Let’s be honest: The most powerful country in the world is ruled by a mad king.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I genuinely do not understand the point that @gargac is trying to make. Hosting India’s richest, most cosmopolitan city is a huge asset, not a liability. And the leading political figures in Mumbai are Marathi-speakers anyway.
If you kicked out the Bengalis, Tamils, Gujaratis, Parsis, North Indians and others it would overnight turn Mumbai into a cultural and economic wasteland. The best cities in the world are cosmopolitan. If you claim to long for a homogeneous city, then what you really long for is a village.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Over more than a decade, India has cultivated a self-congratulatory tone in foreign policy—basically the opposite of hide your strength, bide your time—but a series of brutal reality checks over the past year has exposed the limits of Indian economic, technological, and military power.
Shouting $4T economy at the top of your lungs every five minutes means little when you face a hostile $20T economy at your doorstep, and a $30T superpower with only one question: What have you done for me lately?
Personally, I doubt that the hubris can be dialed down. It has become too deeply entwined with domestic politics. Nobody is going to win an election by saying, “actually, you know what, nobody sees us as Vishwaguru. India is a middle power in a rough neighborhood, and in some ways less secure than it was three decades ago.”
Christopher Clary
@clary_co
Prior US govts did not want to force India to make a choice about Chabahar because we worried about the signals it would send. India would be confronted by the reality that any bilateral relationship comes with strings attached. This administration likes tugging on strings.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hundreds of people are piling on to @_sayema for her belief that “Islam is based on consent, not coercion.” I see prominent people calling her a “jihadist,” or a “terrorist sympathizer” for holding this view. This is ridiculous.
In Sayema’s interpretation of Islamic scripture and belief, women are free to wear, or not wear, the hijab as per their preference. Obviously there are Islamist groups and regimes that feel differently. Nobody sentient thinks the Taliban, or the Iranian regime, or a plethora of Islamist groups worldwide—including in India—have any problem with coercing women to dress in a way that they regard as religiously appropriate. But there are equally plenty of Muslim women—including in India—who do not experience coercion, and for whom the lived experience of Islam is dramatically different from what it is on the streets of Kandahar or a bazaar in Qom.
Believing that her interpretation of the faith is the correct one doesn’t in any way make Sayema a “terror apologist.” (This should be too obvious to bear stating.) She is merely someone who interprets her faith differently from many of her co-religionists. Personally, I wish the Taliban listened to her. But it’s absurd to attack her because they don’t.
As a non-believer, I wish people were more able to discuss religion calmly. I disagree with the old Indian “secularist” instinct of suppressing debate about sensitive matters of faith. At the same time, this kerfuffle shows how difficult this is to do in India, especially online. The speed at which anyone with a Muslim name is publicly labeled a “jihadist” or a “terrorist sympathizer” is the opposite of reasoned debate. It makes it seem as though there are only two bad choices: silence or hysteria. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Meaningful economic change in India won’t be achieved by political leaders nibbling at the edges of a system that has failed to deliver widespread prosperity. India requires a bolder vision, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-timid-economic-reforms-920c1c0c -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Much of what is being touted as economic reform in India these days consists of reversing the government’s own previous policy errors. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-timid-economic-reforms-920c1c0c -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m surprised to see Kuwait, Thailand, Brazil, and Uruguay on the State Department’s (temporary) visa ban list. These are relatively well off countries. Not surprised to see Pakistan, Bangladesh and Nepal on it. Bhutan is an interesting case. Many Bhutanese refugees in the U.S. are ethnic Nepalis who were driven out of Bhutan in 1990-92.
Leading Report
@LeadingReport
BREAKING: Sec. Marco Rubio freezes all foreign visa processing indefinitely from 75 countries:
Afghanistan, Albania, Algeria, Antigua and Barbuda, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bahamas, Bangladesh, Barbados, Belarus, Belize, Bhutan, Bosnia, Brazil, Burma, Cambodia, Cameroon, Cape Verde, Colombia, Cote d’Ivoire, Cuba, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Dominica, Egypt, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Fiji, Gambia, Georgia, Ghana, Grenada, Guatemala, Guinea, Haiti, Iran, Iraq, Jamaica, Jordan, Kazakhstan, Kosovo, Kuwait, Kyrgyzstan, Laos, Lebanon, Liberia, Libya, Macedonia, Moldova, Mongolia, Montenegro, Morocco, Nepal, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Pakistan, Republic of the Congo, Russia, Rwanda, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Senegal, Sierra Leone, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Syria, Tanzania, Thailand, Togo, Tunisia, Uganda, Uruguay, Uzbekistan and Yemen. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Many years ago, an Arab friend in grad school told me she had never met a fellow Arab who claimed to be a descendant of the prophet Mohammed, but every second Pakistani grad student at Columbia made that claim. This was before the era of affordable DNA tests.
Salman Rashid
@odysseuslahori
Got an email from a young person. Had their DNA done. 100% Indian even though the family maintains a tree connecting them with Bukhari Syeds. Wants my advice on going on ahead. I will not divulge name, gender or anything else.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In 1950 India and China were at roughly similar levels of human development.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is straight up disinformation. Nowhere in this video does Mamdani say what this tweet claims. I have many criticisms of Mamdani, but so many of the attacks on him are so plainly dishonest that I end up having to defend him. Truth > Partisanship.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In case you’re wondering what a 100,000 word manuscript looks like printed out.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I would love to see the math on this, but I presume they mean they would like to deport everyone (legal and illegal) with roots in Latin America, Asia (except maybe Japan), the Middle East and Africa for starters. Still not sure how this gets them to 100m deportees. Nice car though.
Homeland Security
@DHSgov
The peace of a nation no longer besieged by the third world.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Happy New Year from Kokum and Imli. (And from me.) I hope you all have a great 2026.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Weekend dogs on a log.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India’s film industry, the world’s largest by number of releases, is finally getting serious about Islamic terrorism, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/dhurandhar-indias-new-movie-about-isl… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Time now for another of my periodic breaks from this addictive dumpster fire hellsite. Happy New Year in advance to everyone. See you in 2026.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The breakout hit #dhurandhar marks a milestone for Bollywood. The industry is finally learning to treat the problem of terrorism seriously. [My take]
www.wsj.com/opinion/dhurandhar-indias-new-movie-about-isl… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As the Harvard case showed, DEI often discriminates most severely against Asian-Americans, including Indian-Americans. But acknowledging this goes against Vance’s brand of white ethnic grievance politics.
JD Vance
@JDVance
A lot of people think "DEI" is lame diversity seminars or racial slogans at NFL games. In reality, it was a deliberate program of discrimination primarily against white men. This is an incredible piece that describes the evil of DEI and its consequences:
www.compactmag.com/article/the-lost-generation/ -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Dutch laxness also birthed Pakistan’s nuclear weapons program in the 1970s by allowing AQ Khan to steal centrifuge designs. This may not be a fixable problem. The Netherlands is both a technologically advanced economy and a highly trusting society. It’s not designed to ward off bad actors.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I can see why @mosharrafzaidi is getting dragged for calling Imran Khan a national security threat to Pakistan on @SkyYaldaHakim’s show, but it’s an intellectually defensible position.
The argument goes something like this: Imran Khan is a genuine mass leader who threatens the army’s grip on power, and the army is the only functional institution in the country. Moreover, Khan’s independent streak and erratic foreign policy arguably weakened Pakistan by alienating important allies. If Imran Khan is freed tomorrow, and fair elections are held, he will almost certainly return to power, and this has unpredictable and potentially destabilizing consequences for Pakistan. In short, never trust a crazy populist. And definitely don’t trust him twice.
But you could equally make the case that it’s not Imran Khan, but Asim Munir, who is a national security threat to Pakistan. The argument goes something like this: Pakistan is an economic backwater with a poor international image in large part because it has been dominated since its creation by the army, which has shown, time and again, that it is very good at advancing its own interests, but absolutely lousy at bettering the lives of ordinary Pakistanis. There is zero evidence that Munir can reverse the rot, and considerable reason to believe that the extreme concentration of power in his hands will make it worse. Imran Khan offers Pakistan its best chance to break its longstanding army habit. If it can’t take this chance it will continue to deteriorate. In short, the one thing worse than a reckless populist is an egomaniacal dictator. At least the populist gives you hope.
As a wellwisher of ordinary Pakistanis—sorry haters, deal with it—I wish the country had better choices. But reckless populist and egomaniacal field marshal are the only two options on the table. Pick your poison. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The one #dhurandhar review I was looking forward to was @sabizak’s—always thoughtful and never tribal, or at least not in the way that many people are on this site. TLDW: Magnificent movie, notwithstanding a few factual glitches. [27m]
youtu.be/XSqNvv-L_7A -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Rating: A+
Pros: Beautifully shot, tightly edited, good music, fine casting.
Cons: Cheap political point scoring.
#dhurandhar
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Planning to watch this tonight. Hope it lives up to the hype. #dhurandhar
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Planning to watch this tonight. Hope it lives up to the hype. #dhurandhar
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India needs a right-of-center party that rejects the pieties of the left, but also unequivocally condemns attacks on Muslims instead of celebrating them. Sadly the odds of such a party emerging are vanishingly slim.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In many ways the U.S. Right has a similar problem. It’s filled with wild-eyed loonies quick to label anyone of Muslim background a “jihadist” or an “Islamist.” Zero capacity to distinguish between an extremist fringe and ordinary Muslims.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Politics in Pakistan was always a blood sport, but by going after Faiz Hameed the field marshal has taken it to a whole new level.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’ve never met Bill Ackman, but I’ve been edited by @bariweiss at WSJ and Tablet magazine. She’s a gifted editor, and in hindsight it should surprise nobody that The Free Press is a fine publication.
Sana Ebrahimi Ledene
@SanaELedene
In the new episode of Theo Von's podcast, Tucker Carlson calls @BillAckman and @bariweiss “dumb” and “unimpressive”:
“Bill Akman is worth 8 billion… but I know Bill Akman, he is kinda dumb. He has not ever created anything. He is totally non-creative.”
He adds:
“It's not just that I disagree with Bari Weiss… in no fair system, in no “meritocracy” would Bari Weiss rise above secretary. Like, actually, and I mean that… I have been in this business since Bari Weiss was breastfeeding. There is no world in which Bari Weiss would rise to the top of a news network except a rigged world.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Another economic win for China in Asia thanks to the foolishness of the Trump administration.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@RichardHanania: “The wealth of nations can be predicted in a pretty straightforward way based on only two factors: human capital, and the degree to which they embrace markets.” [TLDR: Only despotic governance can prevent East Asians from becoming rich.]
www.richardhanania.com/p/human-capital-not-industrial-policy
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I essentially recreated the GDP per capita chart in @RichardHanania’s essay, but fixed his glaring omission of India. You’re welcome.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is smart politics. India has moved right on cultural issues, and it would be foolish to take the leftist anti-Vande Mataram line as some in Congress would undoubtedly prefer.
Congress
@INCIndia
मोदी सरकार में दमन, दिखावा, ध्यान भटकाने, इवेंट मैनेजमेंट और चुनाव से चुनाव तक की राजनीति है।
'वंदे मातरम्' देश की उन उम्मीदों की गुहार है, जिन्हें आपका शासन हर रोज ठुकरा रहा है।
○ जब सरहद पर जवान दुश्मन का सामना करते हैं, तो उनकी छाती में 'वंदे मातरम्' गूंजता है
○ जब हमारे खिलाड़ी अंतरराष्ट्रीय खेलों में जाते हैं, जो उनकी धड़कन में 'वंदे मातरम्' होता है
○ जब इस देश के करोड़ों देशवासी तिरंगे को लहराते हुए देखते हैं, तो उनकी जुबान पर 'वंदे मातरम्' आता है
○ कांग्रेस के हर अधिवेशन में सामूहिक तौर पर 'वंदे मातरम्' गाया जाता है
: कांग्रेस महासचिव व सांसद श्रीमती @priyankagandhi जीThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sobering piece on America’s immigration dilemma by @tylercowen.
Read the whole thing here:
www.thefp.com/p/tyler-cowen-why-humane-immigration-policy… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Anyone interested in India-Russia relations should read this fine piece by @NMenonRao. But I do have a question about this metaphor: We know who the bear, the elephant and the dragon are, but who is the lion? (Maybe 🦅 didn’t work for some reason.)
www.ndtv.com/opinion/putin-in-india-the-elephant-the-bear… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistan is basically invisible in the new U.S. National Security Strategy. It’s mentioned twice—once in the foreword and once in the main report—both in the context of Trump allegedly stopping the India-Pakistan conflict in May.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here are the references to India in the new NSS. Three areas of potential cooperation: commercial ties, Indo-Pacific security, and coordination with Gulf on AI and critical minerals in Africa. (Trump also talks about ending the India-Pakistan conflict in the foreword.) The overall emphasis is clear: What can you do for me?
Zack Cooper
@ZackCooper
3) China is by far the biggest focus in Asia (and elsewhere):
- Trump team clearly seeing all of Asia through the lens of China
- Southeast Asia? Almost completely absent
- US treaty ally Philippines isn't even mentioned!
- Pacific Islands also nowhere to be seen -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The continental scale of Indian linguistic diversity makes comparisons with much smaller countries like France or Turkey moot. Some form of Hindustani might have unified a large chunk of northern and western India (including much of today’s Pakistan), but would probably have run aground in the southern states. But it’s an interesting counterfactual.
Akhilesh (Akhi) Pillalamarri
@AkhiPill
Article is right about the necessity of Western modernization and education but it is important to remember that every modernizing country elevated a local dialect or language, which wasn't spoken by the majority, to a national standard and "imposed" it by officializing it. This happened in France, Germany, Italy, Thailand, Iran, Ottoman Turkey, post-1867 Hungary, everywhere. Colonized countries usually saw a foreign language elevated whereas uncolonized ones got to elevate one of their own (Thai, Amharic, Persian, etc). An uncolonized India would definitely have elevated Marathi or Hindustani if the Mughal or Maratha state entered the late 19th century with sovereignty intact.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In India, critics of the 19th century statesman Thomas Macaulay portray him as some kind of cartoon villain out to destroy India. In reality, he was a brilliant man who wished Indians well. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/western-education-has-lifted-india-38… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If the Congress Party truly believed in competence over connections @ShashiTharoor would be leading the party and @RahulGandhi would be hanging out on a beach in Thailand.
Rahul Gandhi
@RahulGandhi
IndiGo fiasco is the cost of this Govt’s monopoly model.
Once again, it’s ordinary Indians who pay the price - in delays, cancellations and helplessness.
India deserves fair competition in every sector, not match-fixing monopolies.
Rahul Gandhi
@RahulGandhi
Choose your India:
Play-Fair or Monopoly?
Jobs or Oligarchies?
Competence or Connections?
Innovation or Intimidation?
Wealth for many or the few?
I write on why a New Deal for Business isn't just an option. It is India's future. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: If not for access to Western education, India today would probably look less like an aspiring global power and more like an outsize backwater, writes @dhume
on.wsj.com/49QSAK6 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hindi media is a national embarrassment for India. But evidently this is what viewers want.
Manisha Pande
@MnshaP
PUTIN DIKHAI DE RAHA SCREEN PAR!!!!
Our one true gift to our Russian guest - media coverage that’ll beat their own hands down.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My take: No reasonable person can deny that Trump has sharply set back U.S.-India relations, but this doesn’t mean that India can stop worrying about deepening Russia-China relations and what it means for Russian reliability in a crunch. #putininindia #putinindiavisit
News18
@CNNnews18
#putinindiavisit | India has a China problem with Russia that drives India-US relation closer: @dhume, Sr Fellow, AEI
Trump's actions has deeply embarrassed PM Modi: @VivekKatju, Fmr Secretary, MEA
@Zakka_Jacob | #brasstacksThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In India, critics of the 19th century statesman Thomas Macaulay portray him as some kind of cartoon villain out to destroy India. In reality, he was a brilliant man who wished Indians well. [My take] v @WSJopinion
www.wsj.com/opinion/western-education-has-lifted-india-38… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
You could argue that in a way India helped bring down the Soviet Union by being a major recipient of aid from Moscow.
Source: @dwarkeshpodcast -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s a little reminder of how the balance of economic power in Eurasia has shifted over the course of this century. In 2000 the Japanese economy was larger than the Chinese economy at market exchange rates.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Update: Imran Khan’s sister says he’s alive. The post-Bhutto limits on military violence against elected civilian leaders seems to be holding, though the conditions under which Khan is being held are shameful. The Trump administration may not care, but that doesn’t make it okay.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The only question is whether Asim Munir will be gentler toward Imran Khan than Zia ul-Haq was toward Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. For more than 40 years, Pakistani military strongmen have stopped short of murdering popular civilian politicians who dared cross them. I doubt that Munir is stupid enough to want Khan’s blood on his hands, but power does strange things to people. You cannot rule it out entirely.
fatima bhutto 🇵🇸🇱🇧🇮🇷
@fbhutto
Imran Khan served his country, he was the Prime Minister of the country and he cannot be hidden in darkness. This is not a question of politics or what party one belongs to, it is a question of basic human decency. No prisoner should be treated so inhumanely.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
You can’t blame Indians for feeling good about comparisons with Pakistan, but the per capita income chart in Asia that really matters is this one.
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
In another decade, we're going to have another "North and South Korea at night" photo
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My mistake: This is the chart I meant to post.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you think about it rationally, Poland really does have a stronger claim than South Africa to be part of the G20.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It feels like just the other day that IndiGo was far and away the best run airline in India, and comparable with well-run airlines in other parts of Asia. Now it seems like a hot mess. I would love to read a long explanatory piece on what went wrong.
Ramachandra Guha
@Ram_Guha
I'm in IndiGo flight 6E 847 from Chennai to Bengaluru. It was five hours late and is now stuck on the tarmac for 90 minutes. The pilot and staff refuse to make an announcement. Lots of kids and senior citizens agitated on board. @IndiGo6E
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The only question is whether Asim Munir will be gentler toward Imran Khan than Zia ul-Haq was toward Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. For more than 40 years, Pakistani military strongmen have stopped short of murdering popular civilian politicians who dared cross them. I doubt that Munir is stupid enough to want Khan’s blood on his hands, but power does strange things to people. You cannot rule it out entirely.
fatima bhutto 🇵🇸🇱🇧🇮🇷
@fbhutto
Imran Khan served his country, he was the Prime Minister of the country and he cannot be hidden in darkness. This is not a question of politics or what party one belongs to, it is a question of basic human decency. No prisoner should be treated so inhumanely.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Always worth reading the excellent @RenuMukherjee1. My 2¢ on this topic: It’s pretty clear at this point that a chunk of the MAGA base is actively hostile to Indian-Americans, and sees no place for the community in the GOP coalition. If the Groypers cannot even abide Jews—another high-performing minority group—there’s no way in hell that they’re going to woo Indian-Americans. That train has left the station.
Renu Mukherjee
@RenuMukherjee1
Indian Americans have historically preferred the Democratic Party, but their belief in meritocracy, free markets, and the American Dream aligns them more closely with the GOP. So, stop alienating them.
New from me @CityJournal— Memo to Republicans: Reach Out to Indian Americans. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Obvious omissions who deserve to be on the list:
1. Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives.
2. Chinese premier.
I also think it’s ridiculous to rank Iran’s supreme leader above the leaders of Japan, Brazil and Indonesia. The leader of Saudi Arabia is also ranked too high.
Bharat Ramamurti
@BharatRamamurti
For some Thanksgiving dinner discussion fodder, I ranked the 20 most powerful political offices in the world:
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The movement for a separate Telugu-speaking state of Andhra Pradesh started out as an expression of rivalry between Tamil Brahmins and Telugu Brahmins, but soon became a political vehicle for Kammas and Reddys. [Source: India: The Most Dangerous Decades by Selig S. Harrison.]
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: In a campaign debate, Mamdani suggested he was focused on New York’s problems rather than on foreign countries. In reality, he’s deeply in the weeds of domestic politics in distant lands, writes @dhume.
www.wsj.com/opinion/indian-leftists-have-zohran-mamdani-e… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Zineb Riboua
@zriboua
Excellent piece from @dhume.
I would simply add that Indian Leftists are motivated by the same decolonial and Third-Worldist ideology and views as Zohran Mamdani, and thus the framework works.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Indian leftists long for a homegrown version of Zohran Mamdani. But politics in India is already filled with reckless populists who would flunk a class in basic economics. [My take]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Indian leftists long for a homegrown version of Zohran Mamdani. But politics in India is already filled with reckless populists who would flunk a class in basic economics. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/indian-leftists-have-zohran-mamdani-e… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Today’s thrashing in Bihar yet again underscores a simple truth about Indian politics. Congress under Rahul Gandhi is a zombie party. People should stop pretending that it can be revived. It may linger on half-dead for a few more years, but it’s not coming back to life.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Intercept crew are not disinterested observers of Pakistani politics. (They have essentially run a sometimes sensationalized PR campaign on behalf of Imran Khan targeted at his supporters in the Pakistani diaspora.)
But on the question of Pakistan’s 2024 elections Ryan Grim is 100% right. Imran Khan and the PTI overcame great odds and won fair and square. I’ve lost respect for Pakistani liberals who are willing to lie about this just because they dislike Khan. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sabahat Zakariya
@sabizak
Funny how people call it a hybrid system. It has been out-and-out martial law since the ‘elections’. Every Pakistani dictator has maintained a token assembly to give themselves a veneer of legitimacy: Ayub, Zia, Musharraf and now Asim Munir.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
GOP politicians and influencers who claim that Zohran Mamdani seeks to impose sharia law on New York City are ignorant bigots. There are good reasons to oppose many of Mamdani’s policies. But, as Politifact points out, calling Mamdani an Islamist makes no sense.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
A year ago, the idea that Pakistan would get on America’s good side and dramatically improve its international standing would have seemed far-fetched. Yet that’s exactly what has happened, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/trumps-strange-love-affair-with-pakis… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A year ago, anyone who predicted that Trump would wholeheartedly embrace Pakistan would have been called crazy. But that’s precisely what has happened. [My take]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A year ago, anyone who predicted that Trump would wholeheartedly embrace Pakistan would have been called crazy. But that’s precisely what has happened. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/trumps-strange-love-affair-with-pakis…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Republicans who call Zohran Mamdani an Islamist are speaking nonsense. But the mayoral candidate does represent a de facto alliance between Islamists and the left based on a shared antipathy toward Israel. [My take]
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s probably something to the theory that Pakistan set itself up for failure by driving out the (largely Hindu) business community, and by prizing martial valor over commercial acumen. Nonetheless it remains true that the Pakistani army has a particularly bad record when it comes to economic development, unlike, say, the Indonesian, South Korean or Chilean armies. Rawalpindi doesn’t know how to grow the pie, and hasn’t bothered to learn.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Single biggest reason: From the 1990s onward, Indian politicians allowed the private sector to play a larger role in the Indian economy. Pakistan’s generals could not think beyond their old playbook of bilking the West for aid and always placing the army’s interests first.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
In the 90s, Pakistan had 50% higher GDP per capita than India, but now it’s only half as large as India’s
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
1. The graph is from the FT.
2. It’s about per capita GDP, so India’s larger size is irrelevant.
3. If you disagree with my point, please refute it. Thanks.Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s probably something to the theory that Pakistan set itself up for failure by driving out the (largely Hindu) business community, and by prizing martial valor over commercial acumen. Nonetheless it remains true that the Pakistani army has a particularly bad record when it comes to economic development, unlike, say, the Indonesian, South Korean or Chilean armies. Rawalpindi doesn’t know how to grow the pie, and hasn’t bothered to learn.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Despite falling far behind China economically, India remains a significant player in Asia. [My take]
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India will remain a significant power on the Eurasian landmass for the foreseeable future. It remains in Washington’s interest not to shred its relationship with New Delhi, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/does-india-even-have-any-cards-ba4b7010
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Excellent summary by my @AEI colleague Michael Beckley of the challenge India faces as it aspires to become a great power. On the plus side: Favorable demographics. On the minus side: Major human capital bottlenecks.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Read the whole thing here:
www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/stagnant-order-micha… h/t @kanishktharoor -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: India will remain a significant power on the Eurasian landmass for the foreseeable future. It remains in Washington’s interest not to shred its relationship with New Delhi, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/does-india-even-have-any-cards-ba4b7010
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India will remain a significant power on the Eurasian landmass for the foreseeable future. It remains in Washington’s interest not to shred its relationship with New Delhi, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/does-india-even-have-any-cards-ba4b7010 -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s wishing you all a Happy Diwali! I hope you and your loved ones have a wonderful year.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When it comes to accepting homosexuality, Indians have become much more liberal than before. They are roughly where the U.S. was on this question in 1993. Quite a striking contrast with Bangladesh and Pakistan.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Chicago Council on Global Affairs
@ChicagoCouncil
“There was a sense of democratic momentum across the region then,” Nonresident Senior Fellow @pstanpolitics tells @WSJ's @dhume of South Asia in the early 2010s. “Now the picture is much more uneven, fragmented and uncertain.” www.wsj.com/opinion/democracy-wanes-in-south-asia-4c8ec76c
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fifteen years ago, the prospects for democracy in South Asia looked bright. But in recent years angry protestors have ousted elected governments in Kathmandu, Dhaka and Colombo, and the army has jailed the most popular politicians in Myanmar and Pakistan. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/democracy-wanes-in-south-asia-4c8ec76c
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion:The Arabian peninsula will remain a site of competition between the world’s great powers. To expect Pakistan to play more than a bit part is utterly unrealistic, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/saudi-pakistan-defense-pact-is-less-t…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Islamabad has too many domestic political and economic constraints to shape the Middle East meaningfully. That role can only be played by a great power—such as the U.S., writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/saudi-pakistan-defense-pact-is-less-t… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Pakistan-Saudi Arabia defense pact is a diplomatic boost for Islamabad. But Pakistan remains too economically weak and politically unstable to play more than a minor role in the Middle East. [My take] v @WSJopinion
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/saudi-pakistan-defense-pact-is-less-t… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Why do so many Indians leave and so few go back? Economic opportunity plays a big part, but it isn’t only about money, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/india-is-losing-its-best-and-brightes…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
barkha dutt
@BDUTT
"Pakistan is out of the doghouse, but..." - @dhume on the Trump-Modi reset & what happens next on a day when Pakistan & Saudi Arabia announce a NATO style military pact. Watch in full here www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJ6whzssPsk
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed this conversation with @bdutt on Trump’s India tariffs, the return of India-Pakistan hyphenation, Sergio Gor’s appointment as U.S. ambassador to India, free speech in America and much more. [Video, 33m] www.youtube.com/live/rJ6whzssPsk
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Friday evening dogs.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: While there’s no doubt that Trump has set back American diplomacy with India, it doesn’t automatically follow that New Delhi will ally with Beijing. The differences between the two countries run too deep for that, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/fears-of-an-india-china-russia-allian…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
While there’s no doubt that Trump has set back American diplomacy with India, it doesn’t automatically follow that New Delhi will ally with Beijing. The differences between the two countries run too deep for that, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/fears-of-an-india-china-russia-allian… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fears of an India-China-Russia alliance are overblown. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/fears-of-an-india-china-russia-allian… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I talked to Vox about the end of the Trump-Modi bromance and what it means.
Vox
@voxdotcom
Is a Nobel Prize grudge pushing India closer to China? www.vox.com/today-explained-podcast/460343/trump-modi-pak…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Happy Labor Day from Kokum and Imli.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India’s large population of poor farmers hinders its capacity to reach mutually beneficial trade deals, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/americas-fearsome-farm-lobby-has-noth… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A U.S.-India trade deal would be mutually beneficial. But with 44% of India’s workforce in agriculture, Modi can’t afford to upset farmers. [My take]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A U.S.-India trade deal would be mutually beneficial. But with 44% of India’s workforce in agriculture, Modi can’t afford to upset farmers. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/americas-fearsome-farm-lobby-has-noth…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Trump and Modi can meet in the middle to repair their countries’ mutually beneficial partnership, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/america-and-india-can-this-relationsh…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Can the U.S.-India relationship be saved? Yes, if they can craft a deal that both Trump and Modi can sell as a win to their respective bases. [My take ]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/america-and-india-can-this-relationsh…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Carnegie Endowment
@CarnegieEndow
🔴 Live now: @MilanV sits down with @tanvi_madan and @dhume for a special episode of #grandtamasha on President Trump's tariffs on India and their impact on the U.S.-India relationship.
Listen here: grand-tamasha.simplecast.com/episodes/trade-wars-trump-ta… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Time to take another brief Twitter detox break. Kokum and Imli want you all to have a great August—trolls included.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Totally agree that you should never waste a crisis. But India’s 1991 reforms also had the following ingredients:
1. A newly sworn-in PM willing to back reform. (PV Narasimha Rao.)
2. A technocratic FM with a deep understanding of both economics and the Indian economy. (Manmohan Singh.)
3. Competent ministers and senior bureaucrats committed to change. (P. Chidambaram, AN Varma, Montek Singh Ahluwalia, Ashok Desai, etc.)
Of course, history doesn’t have to rhyme exactly. But for India to experience another burst of 1991-style vigor will take a lot.
Nitin Pai
@acorn
It’s the 1991 feeling. Do what you did in 1991.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Harsh truths from @mihirssharma: “New Delhi’s confidence that it could navigate the Trump era has been well and truly shattered; it will take a long time for the relationship to recover from this tumultuous week.”
Bloomberg Opinion
@opinion
India is facing a new geopolitical reality, writes @mihirssharma www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2025-08-01/how-the-us-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“This isn't just protectionism, it is bad protectionism -- and will have all sorts of unintended consequences.”
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Trump's new tariff rate lack rhyme or reason (other than rewarding big countries that made an effort to give him a win ... )
But -- as the decision on Brazil showed -- it is always important to know the exclusions as well as the headline rate ...
1/ -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Does Pakistan really have “massive oil reserves” as President Trump seems to believe? The Bottomline: “Pakistan may have potential. But that’s very different from proven reserves.”
Yousuf Nazar
@YousufNazar
Pakistan has been chasing oil and gas for over a hundred years. It started in 1915 with the discovery at Khaur in Punjab. That was followed by small finds at Dhulian and Joya Mair. But the only real breakthrough came in 1952, when the Sui gas field was discovered. More than seven decades later, Sui is still the country’s most important energy asset. That alone tells you how little progress has been made.
Despite many exploration drives, proven reserves remain tiny. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), Pakistan has just 0.2 billion barrels of oil and 18.7 trillion cubic feet (tcf) of gas. That covers only a small slice of domestic demand. Over 80% of the oil we consume is still imported.
So why do we keep hearing that Pakistan has huge untapped reserves?
Much of this talk comes from theoretical estimates and political spin. For example, in 2015, the EIA and Advanced Resources International (ARI) assessed that Pakistan could have 9.1 billion barrels of technically recoverable shale oil and 105 tcf of shale gas—mainly in the Lower Indus and Hamad Basins. These figures sound big. But here’s the catch: they’re based on surface-level data, not drilling. No shale wells have been drilled so far. Without that, no one can say what’s actually underground, let alone whether it can be extracted economically. It’s like saying there’s gold under the mountains without ever picking up a shovel.
Offshore oil has also been sold as the next big thing. The first well was drilled back in 1961—no success. In 2019, ExxonMobil returned to test the waters near Karachi (Kekra-1), investing $100 million. That, too, ended in disappointment. Most recently, in late 2024, the government claimed a massive find in the Offshore Indus Basin. There were media reports about “one of the world’s largest unexplored reserves.” Sounds great. But here we are in mid-2025—and not a single well has been drilled. A $5 billion plan was announced, but no one’s actually doing the work on the ground.
There was also a deal signed with Turkey in early 2025 to jointly bid for 40 offshore blocks. This came after a 2023 auction of 18 blocks saw almost no interest. Even the Petroleum Minister admitted that major Western firms stayed away. That speaks volumes.
Shale, in particular, is tough. It needs a lot of water, stable infrastructure, and secure ground access. These aren’t available in southern Sindh or Balochistan—where the reserves are said to be. Add to that poor governance, outdated infrastructure, and investor mistrust, and it’s clear why there’s been little movement.
President Trump’s claim in July 2025 about a U.S.-Pakistan deal to develop “massive oil reserves” made headlines. But he didn’t give any details. It sounded more like political signaling than a serious plan. And even if some deal is on the table, the reality is that Pakistan’s reserves are nowhere near global heavyweights like Venezuela or Russia. Even smaller regional producers are far ahead.
In short, yes—Pakistan may have potential. But that’s very different from proven reserves. No one doubts the country is underexplored. But “untapped riches” is a phrase that’s been used too often without results. Until someone drills, tests, and proves what’s actually there—and builds the infrastructure to extract it—we’re just recycling old hopes.
Pakistan’s energy story is not one of hidden treasure. It’s a story of missed chances, weak institutions, and inflated expectations. The only way forward is serious, sustained, and technically competent exploration—backed by transparency and real investment. Otherwise, we’ll keep telling the same story every decade: that the next big discovery is just around the corner. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think India wanted a ceasefire and was happy to take one after proving its point by successfully striking several Pakistani airbases. What India didn’t count on was Trump deciding to make himself the lead actor in the movie.
Previous U.S. presidents might have quietly leaked a self-congratulatory story to the Washington Post, or embellished their role in the crisis in a memoir published after they left office. Trump, being Trump, decided to tweet about it nonstop and boast about it to every TV reporter in the country.
To make matters worse for India, Pakistan sensed an opening and nominated Trump for what he wants most—a Nobel Peace Prize. Now he’s busy hyphenating India and Pakistan like it’s 1985. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s what I said on May 10: The smart thing for India to do would be to thank Trump for his role in defusing the crisis.
The problem: The Indian system is used to American presidents happy to remain in the background during India-Pakistan crises even as senior U.S. officials work the phones with New Delhi and Rawalpindi/Islamabad to tamp things down. Indian decision makers apparently could not see that Trump is different from his predecessors. Or they saw it but could not respond appropriately for fear of losing face.
At this point it ought to be blindingly obvious that Trump seeks credit, preferably exaggerated credit, for anything and everything. In this case, Vance and Rubio spoke multiple times to Indian and Pakistani leaders May 7-10. It was perfectly predictable that Trump would want credit for the conflict ending in four days rather than spiraling toward Armageddon.
That Pakistan publicly thanked Trump, and nominated him for a Nobel Peace Prize, would have deepened his belief that he ended the war and India was being churlish about accepting it.
Meanwhile, in India the government was already feeling defensive for two reasons: First, Pakistan almost certainly downed 3-5 Indian fighter jets on the first night of the conflict, which India did not want to admit publicly. Second, India’s jingoistic TV media had whipped up so much hysteria with its exaggeration and fake news that India’s creditable military performance—orders of magnitude more effective than the 2019 Balakot airstrike that reportedly killed a crow—came across to many people as a damp squib. Wasn’t India supposed to bombard Karachi, take back Pakistan occupied Kashmir, and frogmarch Asim Munir to jail?
Add to this Trump’s desire for a one-sided trade deal, and his old (and accurate) resentments about India’s sky-high tariffs, and you get all the ingredients for a diplomatic explosion. It’s possible that the debate in India’s Parliament, where the Modi government’s prime motivation was to deny that the U.S. played any meaningful role in defusing India-Pakistan tensions, pushed Trump over the edge. Though he may not have needed that prod.
Where does all this leave Modi? Politically he has no good choices. If he says nothing the opposition will portray him as weak. (Though Modi is lucky that he faces as singularly ungifted an opponent as Rahul Gandhi.) If Modi makes concessions and gets a trade deal he runs the same risk. In any case, Trump doesn’t want the usual give and take of a normal deal. He wants public submission.
If Modi decides to up the ante by attacking Trump and retaliating against U.S. businesses in India—as his hardline supporters would love to see—he runs the risk of Trump escalating further. In a U.S.-India standoff the U.S. controls almost all rungs on the escalation ladder. Indians may not want to hear this, but it’s true. Trump could pull the plug on a large chunk of India’s IT industry and make it impossible for Apple to make iPhones in India if he so chooses. China has already made it clear that it opposes India’s economic modernization. The last thing India can afford is a hostile U.S.
What will Modi do? My best guess is that he will eschew theatrics and work behind the scenes to stabilize the situation. It’s too soon to say if he will succeed. But there’s no doubt that this is the biggest foreign policy challenge faced by India since the 2020 border clash with China.Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think India wanted a ceasefire and was happy to take one after proving its point by successfully striking several Pakistani airbases. What India didn’t count on was Trump deciding to make himself the lead actor in the movie.
Previous U.S. presidents might have quietly leaked a self-congratulatory story to the Washington Post, or embellished their role in the crisis in a memoir published after they left office. Trump, being Trump, decided to tweet about it nonstop and boast about it to every TV reporter in the country.
To make matters worse for India, Pakistan sensed an opening and nominated Trump for what he wants most—a Nobel Peace Prize. Now he’s busy hyphenating India and Pakistan like it’s 1985. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Vance and Rubio are Trump’s subordinates so any credit for their diplomacy accrues to him. You may not agree with Trump, but it’s hardly uncommon for world leaders to take credit for what their officials purportedly achieve.
The claim that Trump didn’t himself phone Modi may be factually true, but it’s a red herring. Unless you think Vance and Rubio don’t work for Trump.
Now if you believe that all the calls made by Rubio and Vance had no effect on how the conflict ended that’s a separate argument. Is this your view? -
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Vance and Rubio are Trump’s subordinates so any credit for their diplomacy accrues to him. You may not agree with Trump, but it’s hardly uncommon for world leaders to take credit for what their officials purportedly achieve.
The claim that Trump didn’t himself phone Modi may be factually true, but it’s a red herring. Unless you think Vance and Rubio don’t work for Trump.
Now if you believe that all the calls made by Rubio and Vance had no effect on how the conflict ended that’s a separate argument. Is this your view? -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
AEI Foreign Policy
@AEIfdp
"India’s failure to retain and attract global talent has geopolitical implications," @dhume writes.
India suffers from "a political and intellectual culture geared toward redistributive justice rather than individual excellence."
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-is-losing-its-best-and-brightes… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Nobody can doubt that Trump has taken a wrecking ball to 25 years of American diplomacy in India. The only question worth debating is the extent of the damage to U.S.-India relations and what it will take to repair them.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Rahul Gandhi is the opposite of a natural politician. He unerringly manages to figure out the stupidest thing to say at the worst possible moment.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Tunku Varadarajan
@tunkuv
India Is Losing Its Best and Brightest, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/india-is-losing-its-best-and-brightes… via @WSJopinion
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
What kind of impact do you think Trump’s statements will have on U.S.-India relations?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
With the U.S.-India trade spat sucking up all the oxygen in the room, nobody will pay attention to this remarkable example of bilateral cooperation. NASA and the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) just launched a sophisticated radar “capable of studying changes in land and ice—changes as small as a centimeter, in any weather and in both darkness and light.”
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Why do some of the smartest Indians continue to leave India? Perplexity CEO @AravSrinivas is only the most recent high profile example. [My take ]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Read it here: www.wsj.com/opinion/india-is-losing-its-best-and-brightes…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This may seem hard to believe, given everything that has gone down in the last three months, but when Trump was elected last year the prospects for stronger U.S.-India relations had never looked brighter.
Compared to Clinton, Bush, Obama, Trump 1.0 and Biden, the current Trump administration faced an Indian counterpart more eager to cooperate closely on China, defense, and technology, and more willing to make its share of compromises to accommodate the U.S. president.
It’s still too soon to assess the full extent of damage to the bilateral relationship from Trump’s words and actions since May, but, as @MalikAshok points out, the political relationship between New Delhi and Washington is now the worst that it has been since the mid-1990s. (Though, of course, bilateral economic ties are much more significant today than they were back then.) -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There is no “blame” assigned in my post. As I see it, all you have is two countries that were unable to get to a deal that worked for them both.
By definition, each side in a trade negotiation thinks its own demands are perfectly reasonable and the other side’s are not. In this case India felt no deal was better than the deal on offer and that is India’s prerogative. But it is equally Trump’s prerogative to do what he thinks is in the best interests of U.S. businesses and consumers.
In my view, analysis that relies on pressing emotional buttons is less valuable than analysis that looks coolly at the likely costs (and possible benefits) of high U.S. tariffs on the Indian economy. But nobody is forcing you to see things as I do. I look forward to reading your take. -
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There is no “blame” assigned in my post. As I see it, all you have is two countries that were unable to get to a deal that worked for them both.
By definition, each side in a trade negotiation thinks its own demands are perfectly reasonable and the other side’s are not. In this case India felt no deal was better than the deal on offer and that is India’s prerogative. But it is equally Trump’s prerogative to do what he thinks is in the best interests of U.S. businesses and consumers.
In my view, analysis that relies on pressing emotional buttons is less valuable than analysis that looks coolly at the likely costs (and possible benefits) of high U.S. tariffs on the Indian economy. But nobody is forcing you to see things as I do. I look forward to reading your take. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Back in February, when Modi visited Washington, nobody predicted that India would end up having to pay a higher tariff rate than Vietnam (20%) and Indonesia (19%). At the time, Indian officials believed, not unreasonably, that they had the inside track, that a deal would be agreed to that left India better off than its competitors.
We still don’t know how much the extra penalty will be, but it’s quite possible that this will push India into the same ballpark as Bangladesh (35%), or maybe even higher.
In the coming days, you will see some people in India either claim that this is no big deal or focus more on trashing Trump than on the consequences for the Indian economy. There’s nothing wrong with trashing Trump, or any other politician, but I would not trust the judgement of those who minimize the impact of what just happened.
We’ll get a better sense of the consequences in the weeks and months ahead, but let me leave you with a conversation I had a few days back with an investor who manufactures in India for export to the U.S. market. In this person’s estimation, a 20% tariff was manageable for India. Anything above it, given all the other constraints of doing business in India, would strain the value proposition for this person’s business.
Obviously this is anecdotal, and obviously what is true for one business may not be true for all others. But on the face of it, if this isn’t another TACO move by Trump, this decision will have major implications for both Indian manufacturing exports and investment in Indian manufacturing. Anyone who says otherwise is either delusional or spinning you. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Two areas of human endeavor where Indians in India are geared toward individual excellence benchmarked against a global standard: chess and cricket.
Can you come up with a third example that meets these two criteria?
1. More than one Indian at or near the top.
2. An activity that isn’t concentrated in India. (I’m sorry, but kuchipudi dancers don’t count.) -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is the strongest Indian refutation yet of Trump’s claim that he mediated a ceasefire between India and Pakistan.
Sidhant Sibal
@sidhant
At no stage, in any conversation with the United States, was there any linkage with trade and what was going on, EAM Jaishankar dismisses Trump's mediation claim between India, Pakistan
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Do you think the following are legitimate concerns for Indian Muslims in 2025:
1. Lack of representation in government, including zero representation in the cabinet for the first time since independence in 1947.
2. A rash of state-level laws that either implicitly or explicitly seek to limit Muslim choices: beef bans, “love jihad” laws, anti-conversion laws, and the like.
3. Vigilante mob attacks on Muslims accused of religious or cultural transgressions.
4. Dehumanizing rhetoric (words like “termite”) used for some Muslims by senior ruling party officials.
5. Support for stripping some Muslims of voting and citizenship rights and arguably efforts made in that direction with policies like CAA/NRC.
6. Widespread attacks on Muslims and Islam on television, Hindi music videos, Bollywood movies and so on.
7. Ending statehood for India’s only Muslim-majority state.
8. Law suits and public agitation to reclaim several sites considered sacred by many Hindus that are currently ocupied by mosques.
To clarify, I’m not asking for your view of these developments over the past 11 years—though you’re of course free to share that too—but whether you think your Muslim fellow citizens have a legitimate reason to be concerned about some or all of these developments. Thanks. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Modi fans in my comments are arguing that the last 11 years have been great for Indian Muslims, or at any rate better than before. Well, if that’s the case, then how come no Muslims seem to think so? Are they all magically blind to their own great good fortune under Hindutva?
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Quite a few people here are comparing Indira Gandhi, whose first tenure as PM lasted 11 years (1966-77) with Narendra Modi, who has now been PM for as long (2014-2025). Here’s how I think they stack up:
1. Economy: Modi > Indira. [This is a no-brainer, not because NM has been great but because IG was a disaster.]
2. Democracy: Modi > Indira. [Another no-brainer. I agree with much of the criticism of NM on this score, but you can’t really compare him with the PM who declared Emergency and regularly dismissed state governments on a whim.]
3. Pluralism: Indira > Modi. [For all her flaws, IG and her party were not motivated by animus toward any religious group.]
4. Foreign Policy: Tie. [YMMV on this one. IG’s crowning success, the creation of Bangladesh, dwarfs anything NM has achieved. OTOH in general nonalignment served India poorly and contributed to its economic backwardness.]Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Do you think the following are legitimate concerns for Indian Muslims in 2025:
1. Lack of representation in government, including zero representation in the cabinet for the first time since independence in 1947.
2. A rash of state-level laws that either implicitly or explicitly seek to limit Muslim choices: beef bans, “love jihad” laws, anti-conversion laws, and the like.
3. Vigilante mob attacks on Muslims accused of religious or cultural transgressions.
4. Dehumanizing rhetoric (words like “termite”) used for some Muslims by senior ruling party officials.
5. Support for stripping some Muslims of voting and citizenship rights and arguably efforts made in that direction with policies like CAA/NRC.
6. Widespread attacks on Muslims and Islam on television, Hindi music videos, Bollywood movies and so on.
7. Ending statehood for India’s only Muslim-majority state.
8. Law suits and public agitation to reclaim several sites considered sacred by many Hindus that are currently ocupied by mosques.
To clarify, I’m not asking for your view of these developments over the past 11 years—though you’re of course free to share that too—but whether you think your Muslim fellow citizens have a legitimate reason to be concerned about some or all of these developments. Thanks. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I don’t like to dunk on Rajdeep, but the fact that he needs to proclaim that “the Raj is long gone!” in 2025 is kind of pathetic.
At what point will Indians be able to get over this chip on their collective shoulder and treat England like just another country, albeit one with which a section of Indians have closer familial, cultural and intellectual ties than they do with most countries? I wonder if in the year 2147 we’ll still see this strange need to refract every contretemps through a resentful lens of injured pride?
Sometimes a sport is just a sport. One team wants to get its players off the field to rest them and protect them from injury. The other team thinks the two men in the middle, who have pulled off a heroic rearguard action, deserve to reach personal milestones easily within grasp.
I happen to think the Indian batsmen were right to play on, and that it was petty of Ben Stokes not to see why this was understandable. But to me it was simply Stokes v. Jadeja/Sundar, not some kind of sequel to Gandhi’s salt march or something. #indvseng
Rajdeep Sardesai
@sardesairajdeep
Yes, @benstokes38 is a great player but a sore loser! Why should Indian batsmen accept a draw when they are just short of milestone tons? Would England have not batted on in a similar situation? Sorry Mr Stokes, this isn’t an Indian team that will bend so easily! The Raj is long gone! Jai Ho🙏🇮🇳
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This was supposed to have been India’s big China +1 opportunity. It didn’t happen.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Vietnam has replaced China as the major source of US imports for many simpler manufactured goods.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The richest states in India are poorer than the poorest states in Brazil, Mexico and China. v @Fullantho
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Though this graphic would be more helpful if it compared Indian states to Indonesian and Vietnamese provinces too.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I believe IG’s record on pluralism is superior to NM’s for the following reasons:
1. Ideology: Congress did not have an anti-Muslim orientation. 2. Representation: Look at the cabinet. Look at Parliament. No question that Muslims had a greater share of power in IG’s time. To dismiss this as “tokenism” is unconvincing and, ironically, an argument that one would normally expect to hear from Pakistani critics of Indian democracy.
3. Personal attitudes: IG and her closest advisors did not view politics through a religious prism. She would have been appalled by beef lynchings and love jihad laws.
In sum, IG was a populist-socialist with authoritarian tendencies, and that created many long-term problems for India. But even her worst critics would concede that she had no time for religious bigotry. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Quite a few people here are comparing Indira Gandhi, whose first tenure as PM lasted 11 years (1966-77) with Narendra Modi, who has now been PM for as long (2014-2025). Here’s how I think they stack up:
1. Economy: Modi > Indira. [This is a no-brainer, not because NM has been great but because IG was a disaster.]
2. Democracy: Modi > Indira. [Another no-brainer. I agree with much of the criticism of NM on this score, but you can’t really compare him with the PM who declared Emergency and regularly dismissed state governments on a whim.]
3. Pluralism: Indira > Modi. [For all her flaws, IG and her party were not motivated by animus toward any religious group.]
4. Foreign Policy: Tie. [YMMV on this one. IG’s crowning success, the creation of Bangladesh, dwarfs anything NM has achieved. OTOH in general nonalignment served India poorly and contributed to its economic backwardness.]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s @ShekharGupta’s take comparing the two prime ministers. Feel free to add your own.
theprint.in/national-interest/narendra-modi-indira-gandhi…Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I believe IG’s record on pluralism is superior to NM’s for the following reasons:
1. Ideology: Congress did not have an anti-Muslim orientation. 2. Representation: Look at the cabinet. Look at Parliament. No question that Muslims had a greater share of power in IG’s time. To dismiss this as “tokenism” is unconvincing and, ironically, an argument that one would normally expect to hear from Pakistani critics of Indian democracy.
3. Personal attitudes: IG and her closest advisors did not view politics through a religious prism. She would have been appalled by beef lynchings and love jihad laws.
In sum, IG was a populist-socialist with authoritarian tendencies, and that created many long-term problems for India. But even her worst critics would concede that she had no time for religious bigotry. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s @ShekharGupta’s take comparing the two prime ministers. Feel free to add your own.
theprint.in/national-interest/narendra-modi-indira-gandhi… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In the early 1950s, no group in Indian public life was more hostile toward the Soviet Union than the RSS.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As a goods exporter, India is roughly in the same weight class as Russia and Spain. You could view this as a disappointment considering India’s large population, but it’s also a vast improvement from the sad old days of the license raj. v @husainhaqqani
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Question for cricket fans: Was this man chosen as India’s coach for his competence, fairness and deep knowledge of the sport? All responses welcome.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The question this raises has been the same for a long time: Could Aravind Srinivas achieve his full potential without leaving India?
S.L. Kanthan
@Kanthan2030
Indian guy (from Chennai) goes to the US and starts Perplexity, a brilliant AI startup that may threaten Google’s Search business.
Perplexity - with a valuation of $18 billion - just released an AI-native web browser called Comet.
Brain drain for India, free talent for America. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Anyone interested in the American right should read this fine essay by @jkirchick.
National Review
@NRO
A survey of Tucker Carlson’s rhetoric in recent years reveals an unhealthy interest in Jews—indeed an obsession. | @jkirchick
www.nationalreview.com/magazine/2025/09/tucker-carlsons-d… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
These are both responses to the same tweet.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Zohran Mamdani is obviously NOT a jihadist, and using such a charged term to describe him is both inaccurate and counterproductive. But the NYC mayoral candidate does represent a worrying de facto “red-green” alliance between socialists and Islamists. I wrote about it here:
Casey Babb
@DrCaseyBabb
Hey @ZohranKMamdani — I wrote something that I think you’d enjoy. Link below! Consider subscribing!
caseybabb.substack.com/p/jihad-with-a-smile
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
These are both responses to the same tweet.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@virsanghvi: Jagdeep Dhankhar’s exit shows that nobody knows what’s really going on in the Modi government. All the theories doing the rounds are post-facto attempts to find explanations that fit the facts, and none of them is entirely convincing. theprint.in/opinion/sharp-edge/jagdeep-dhankhar-exit-modi…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The BJP has obviously not created a dynasty. Modi has no children, and nobody in their right mind thinks Jay Shah will ever be PM.
You could, however, argue that Modi has ended the collective decision-making culture of the BJP. Vajpayee-Advani (or at times Advani-Vajpayee) dominated the party for some three decades, but they never centralized power to the degree that Modi-Shah have done.
So it’s probably fair to say that the BJP under Modi has created a “high command” a la Congress. But it’s ridiculous to call this high command “dynastic.”
2050
@iAsura_
In Congress there are different rules for party office bearers & the royal family.
BJP was different. A true cadre based party.
But, not anymore. There is a strict age limit for BJP office bearers while King Modi & his Royal Partner are above all rules. BJP now has a dynasty. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you think of India’s old license-permit raj as a way to enhance productivity it was obviously bonkers. But if you think of it instead as a sophisticated system to extract bribes from businessmen it was well designed. [From “Backstage: The Story Behind India’s High Growth Years” by Montek Singh Ahluwalia.]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
TOI edit: “The larger point is that we no longer naturally assume that constitutional office holders will maintain the dignity of their office.” [Filed under true, but sadly not new.]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I wonder if Hungary and Finland have political parties whose followers would get upset to learn that their language originated in Siberia. cc: @razibkhan news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/07/ancient-dna-solves…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Free Press
@TheFP
“Consider what Milei has achieved in just a year and a half.
When he was sworn in as president in December 2023, the Argentine economy was a seemingly incurable basket case. In 2023, its gross domestic product had shrunk by 1.6 percent, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF). Perhaps more strikingly, per capita gross domestic product (GDP) on an inflation-adjusted basis was lower than it had been in 2007. Public finances were in disarray. The last time the government had run a surplus was in 2008. The IMF estimated total public debt at around 90 percent of GDP, but the important thing was how much of that debt—more than $40 billion—Argentina owed to the IMF, the culmination of no fewer than 22 programs.
The previous Peronist government’s reckless fiscal and monetary policies had created annualized inflation exceeding 200 percent. Indeed, wholesale price inflation in December 2023 was 54 percent month over month—technically hyperinflation, according to the widely accepted definition. To give you some idea, in 2023 the price of a latte roughly tripled from around 1,500 pesos to around 4,500. For the last three years, Cuervo Café—the coolest coffee shop in Buenos Aires—had to adjust its prices twice a month.
After less than 20 months, Milei has eliminated the fiscal deficit, cutting it from 5 percent of GDP to zero. He has reduced the number of government ministries from 18 to 8. (‘Ministry of Tourism and Sports—out!’ he declared in a campaign video, tearing its name off a whiteboard. ‘Ministry of Culture—out! Ministry of the Environment and Sustainable Development—out! Ministry of Women, Gender, and Diversity—out! Ministry of Public Works—out, even if you resist!’) With Executive Order 70, issued a few days after his inauguration, he deregulated key markets, including property rentals, commercial airlines, and road freight transport. Labor market reforms took longer but were enacted after a fight in Congress.” —@NFergus -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Moral of the Anil Ambani story: Even post-liberalization, wheeling-dealing can get you far in Indian business, but it’s not enough to have it as your ONLY skill.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
What made Indian VP Jagdeep Dhankhar suddenly quit his job midstream? @sheela2010 has the goods.
www.rediff.com/news/special/must-read-what-led-jagdeep-dh… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“Minus economic leverage, India is not a vishwa guru, or even a vishwa mitra; it is a vishwa also-ran.”
Ashok Malik
@MalikAshok
An image of the piece for those who prefer to read this way
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I don’t hate NPR. I’ve appeared on it as a guest many times, and have always been impressed by the quality of its journalism. There is nothing on right wing radio that approaches NPR’s thoroughness and professionalism, though the right does have some good podcasts.
But it’s also true that some years back it began to feel like every second story on NPR was about race, gender or sexuality. Old NPR came across as staffed mostly by left-of-center journalists striving for objectivity. New NPR felt like it was staffed—not entirely, but to a large extent—by activists who had already made up their minds about the world. The work they produced tended to be heavy on moralizing and light on curiosity.
I still don’t hate NPR. I just want the journalism faction to prevail over the activism faction.
John Collins
@Logically_JC
Can someone explain to me why they hate NPR so much?
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It turns out that random Reddit dude wasn’t the only Indian impressed by Kuala Lumpur. Back in 1990, Prime Minister V.P. Singh also noticed its transformation. Source: Backstage by Montek Singh Ahluwalia.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This Reddit post by an Indian tourist who visited Kuala Lumpur and was shocked by how far ahead it is of Indian cities has gone viral. Protip: He had better not visit Dubai or Singapore.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Just leaving this here: Shanghai and Beijing in 2011, when China’s GDP per capita (PPP) was roughly the same as India’s is today.
Harsh Gupta Madhusudan
@harshmadhusudan
Malaysia has $14k+ per capita GDP (and $43k+ in PPP terms.)
India has near $3k per capita GDP (and $12k+ in PPP terms.)
By comparing KL (or SG/UAE) to BOM/DEL what exactly are we expecting? Yes even at these income levels, things should be better.
But have some context please.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This Reddit post by an Indian tourist who visited Kuala Lumpur and was shocked by how far ahead it is of Indian cities has gone viral. Protip: He had better not visit Dubai or Singapore.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It turns out that random Reddit dude wasn’t the only Indian impressed by Kuala Lumpur. Back in 1990, Prime Minister V.P. Singh also noticed its transformation. Source: Backstage by Montek Singh Ahluwalia.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
No offense meant to PTI fans, but let’s be honest. In the subcontinent, a crowd this small is an embarrassment not an achievement. #pakistan
PTI Central Punjab
@PTIOfficialCP
لاہور: انصاف یوتھ ونگ لاہور کے نوجوانوں کی میاں حسن شکیل سکریٹری جنرل انصاف یوتھ ونگ سینٹرل پنجاب کی قیادت لاہور میں ریلی۔
#خان_کی_پُکار_پر_انقلابThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistani liberals who speak out against the horror of blasphemy killings are among the bravest people in the subcontinent. But it’s hard to be optimistic about this question.
Maybe (at best) we’ll reach a point where the threat of blasphemy killings becomes less common. But I can’t imagine any Pakistani government, civilian or military, saying what is blindingly obvious to anyone living in a post-enlightenment society: There’s no such thing as blasphemy. It’s a concept that belongs in our ignorant past, like a belief in witches, or in the medicinal power of leeches. In a civilized society, you would not even face a fine for so-called blasphemy, let alone face the death penalty for it.
Sameena Sultana
@SameenaSultan16
#tlp’s Saad Rizvi says, “We may have buried Mumtaz Qadri, but the weapon he used is still outside.”
This isn’t just nostalgia for a killer—it’s a chilling threat. He’s glorifying a murderer of a sitting governor. 1/2
@husainhaqqani @sarataseer @Taimur_Laal @AzazSyed -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
One of the strangest things about Pakistan is that its journalists and influencers spend 100x as much time criticizing Israel’s actions in distant Gaza than they do criticizing their own government’s actions in next door Afghanistan.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think @VivekGRamaswamy is right. Mamdani’s opponents should focus on his batshit crazy ideas, not on his race or religion.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is a pretty balanced take by @davidfolkenflik on how public broadcasting in the U.S. lost bipartisan support, though anyone who follows this issue knows that conservatives dislike Katherine Maher not just for supporting Biden and condemning Trump, but for being almost a caricature of a deeply woke progressive.
www.npr.org/2025/07/18/nx-s1-5469920/pbs-npr-funding-resc… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Trump: “Planes were being shot out of the air. Five…four or five, but I think five jets were shot down actually.”
[My 2¢: This squares with both credible international reporting and what Indians will admit to privately. Someone who follows this stuff closely told me India lost four planes—including one Rafale—and a Heron drone on the night of May 7. At this point, I’m not sure what purpose continued Indian government opacity about this serves. Hiding the truth only prolongs speculation.]
Sidhant Sibal
@sidhant
"...We stopped a lot of wars. And these were serious, India and Pakistan, that was going on. Planes were being shot out of there. I think five jets were shot down, actually..." Says US President Donald Trump
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
That Bangladesh sees no cultural value in the ancestral home of Satyajit Ray is a sad sign of the country’s trajectory.
But I don’t see why India should issue a statement about “the building’s landmark status, symbolising Bangla cultural renaissance.”
If Bangladesh chooses not to care about iconic Bengali cultural and literary figures that’s their business. It’s unfortunate, of course. But ultimately every country gets to decide its own cultural priorities.
Husain Haqqani
@husainhaqqani
‘India appeals to Bangladesh to stop demolition of Oscar-winning director’s family home,’ reports @Independent.
Demolition of century‑old ancestral home of acclaimed filmmaker Satyajit Ray is already underway.
www.independent.co.uk/asia/india/india-bangladesh-satyaji…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It turns out that the house in question wasn’t even Ray’s ancestral home to begin with, though apparently some people believed it was according to local lore. 🤦 moment for MEA.
বাংলার ছেলে 🇧🇩
@iSoumikSaheb
As I Said That House Isnt His House. It Was Somewhat Believed To Be. As An Archeology Enthusiasts Even I Found Earlier It Was Jamindar Sashi Babus Resting House.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“India is alone among the founding BRICS members in wanting to reduce China’s sway in world affairs.” v @travelli www.nytimes.com/2025/07/18/business/trump-brics-india.html
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Once upon a time, someone like Mamdani couldn’t have been a member in good standing of the left. But for two decades leftist groups and Islamists have formed a de facto alliance based on their contempt for Israel, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/mamdani-and-the-lefts-alliance-with-r…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
While the democratic socialist front-runner to be New York’s next mayor isn’t going to establish a caliphate on the Hudson, we shouldn’t be dismissive of Mamdani’s unhealthy obsession with Israel, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/mamdani-and-the-lefts-alliance-with-r… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Republicans who call Zohran Mamdani an Islamist are speaking nonsense. But the mayoral candidate does represent a de facto alliance between Islamists and the left based on a shared antipathy toward Israel. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/mamdani-and-the-lefts-alliance-with-r…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Caught between a rock and a hard place: For the king of the Buddhist Chakma people in the Chittagong Hills, Bangladeshi nationalism represented by Mujibur Rahman posed a bigger threat than Pakistani nationalism represented by Yayha Khan’s army.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In 1969 Pakistan had enough clout to get India disinvited from an Organization of the Islamic Conference summit in Rabat.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Australians, Americans and Japanese all see China as the top threat to their nations. For the Indian public it’s Pakistan. v @conradhackett
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Worth reading this @ScottMGreer article if you’re trying to understand why much of MAGA is up in arms about the (non-existent) Epstein files. www.highly-respected.com/p/critical-pedo-theory
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The other day I came across a photo here that someone had shared of a ghastly looking statue that was recently erected somewhere in North India. My first instinct was to register my revulsion, but then I thought better of it. The statue had religious significance, and this site is full of angry people prone to confuse disappointment at the quality of craftsmanship with disapproval of the figure the statue was attempting to depict. Not worth it, I thought.
But I haven’t been able to stop thinking about that statue, or about others like it. Can a country have beautiful public art when its politics are almost exclusively geared toward the lowest common denominator? Or are people expected to put up with shoddy statuary until per capita income reaches some magical figure that signifies wealth, and with it a modicum of taste?
I’m not sure I know the answer. On the flip side, recently I flew out of Bangalore airport, whose new(ish) terminal is as beautiful as any airport I’ve seen. So somewhere there is a capacity to create beautiful public spaces in India, even if it’s relatively rare and all the more breathtaking for that reason.
That said, my prognosis on this question leans toward pessimism. Some years ago, the chief minister of West Bengal set out to beautify the capital city, Kolkata (formerly Calcutta). Let’s just say the results of her effort are not for those made easily queasy by public monstrosities. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Just leaving this here: Shanghai and Beijing in 2011, when China’s GDP per capita (PPP) was roughly the same as India’s is today.
Harsh Gupta Madhusudan
@harshmadhusudan
Malaysia has $14k+ per capita GDP (and $43k+ in PPP terms.)
India has near $3k per capita GDP (and $12k+ in PPP terms.)
By comparing KL (or SG/UAE) to BOM/DEL what exactly are we expecting? Yes even at these income levels, things should be better.
But have some context please.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This Reddit post by an Indian tourist who visited Kuala Lumpur and was shocked by how far ahead it is of Indian cities has gone viral. Protip: He had better not visit Dubai or Singapore.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Just leaving this here: Shanghai and Beijing in 2011, when China’s GDP per capita (PPP) was roughly the same as India’s is today.
Harsh Gupta Madhusudan
@harshmadhusudan
Malaysia has $14k+ per capita GDP (and $43k+ in PPP terms.)
India has near $3k per capita GDP (and $12k+ in PPP terms.)
By comparing KL (or SG/UAE) to BOM/DEL what exactly are we expecting? Yes even at these income levels, things should be better.
But have some context please.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This Reddit post by an Indian tourist who visited Kuala Lumpur and was shocked by how far ahead it is of Indian cities has gone viral. Protip: He had better not visit Dubai or Singapore.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
They may sound similar in terms of rhetoric, but on tariffs Trump 2.0 is significantly more extreme than Trump 1.0. v @AnaSwanson
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Unfashionable opinion:
1. @rohini_sgh is right. Journalists did have much more freedom to criticize the government during UPA, especially UPA2, than they do under Modi. For instance, in 2012-14 Arnab Goswami was an actual journalist performing the role of holding elected officials to account.
2. If you take a long view of modern Indian history, then the period 1991-2014—relatively free media, relatively independent courts, no social media lynch mobs—is an anomaly born of coalition politics.
All Indian governments with a single-party majority have used it to intimidate the media and the judiciary. In the 1970s and 1980s, editors in Delhi were appointed/sacked depending on election outcomes. This is not justification for the current state of affairs—obviously I wish things were better—just a little context.
Rohini Singh
@rohini_sgh
I did several investigative reports critical of the UPA and it’s leaders. There was no Pegasus on my phone, no slander campaign against me, no pressure from the PMO to stop writing, no threats, no blocking of access to information. We were free to report. It was a democracy.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Nobody I know knows Indian politics better than @ShekharGupta, so it gives me a slight kick to point out that back in 2005-06 the frontrunners to succeed Vajpayee-Advani as leader of the BJP included a certain Pramod Mahajan.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: theprint.in/national-interest/bjp-rss-narendra-modi-mohan…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
MG Vassanji writes beautifully about identity and belonging, the tinge of envy that the “anywhere” can sometimes feel for the “somewhere.”
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I have no stake in intra-Muslim intramurals, and virtually no interest in theology—no disrespect, just not my thing—but @KhalilAndani’s tweet raises interesting questions.
In how many of the world’s roughly 195 countries could you make this claim about Ismailism without risking physical harm by the public or incarceration by the state? In how many of the world’s 50-odd Muslim majority countries could an Ismaili proclaim his version of Islam as the one true faith? I’m pretty sure there are people in Karachi, Damascus and Kuala Lumpur who would agree with every word Andani wrote, but would never dare write it themselves, and would think twice before retweeting his tweet.
This is the beauty of America’s first amendment protection of free speech. It shows the human race that it’s possible to say things about topics that people hold sacred with the expectation that the most thin-skinned or violent among them will retaliate only with words. The mob holds no veto. It must rein in its fury before the individual. The law and the machinery of the state will back the individual, not the mob.
Many people born in America take freedom of speech for granted. But it’s a fragile and precious things. Most people on this planet live their entire lives without experiencing it. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’d like a historian to explain how Britain went from basically inventing modern manufacturing to being unable to make a cricket ball that lasts more than 10 overs.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m no fan of language chauvinism and do not believe that anyone should be forced to learn Marathi, Kannada, Bengali or any other language just because they happen to live in a state where that language is dominant.
That said, I have to say @priyankac19 comparing her inability to speak Marathi with her inability to learn French is obviously disingenuous. Marathi is the language of the state Chaturvedi grew up in, lives in, and represents in Parliament. French is a foreign language. If Chaturvedi had grown up in Paris, and represented a party that embraced French linguistic chauvinism in the French Parliament, her inability to speak French herself would indeed be seen as bizarre.
The truth is that in most Indian cities you can get by without speaking the local language. Knowing Marathi or Kannada may be a convenience, but it’s not a necessity, at least not if you speak English and Hindi, both of which have a pan-Indian footprint. Personally, I think openness to out of state migrants is a good thing. Part of what makes a city dynamic is its ability to attract talented and hardworking people from different backgrounds. If Bombay/Mumbai becomes a city where non-Marathi speakers risk being beaten up, it will diminish the lives of everyone who lives there, including those of native Marathi speakers.
As an aside, I once spent a couple of hours chatting with Raj Thackeray in his office in Dadar. He looked momentarily pained when I told him I don’t speak Marathi, but it did not impede our conversation, which was mostly in English. When it was time to leave, I thanked Thackeray profusely for gifting me one of his cartoons, but it turned out that he meant only to show it to me, not to gift it to me. Awkward.
Shining Star
@ShineHamesha
Priyanka Chaturvedi has language deficiency and she can't learn Marathi. But outsiders should. All hail the queen! 🙄
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@tylercowen: Economists have shown that socialism simply doesn’t work. Then why is it gaining ground in America? www.thefp.com/p/tyler-cowen-why-wont-socialism-die
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India has never had separation of church and state. At best, it aspired to treat all major faiths equally. You can debate how good or bad that was, or how well or badly implemented in practice. But the idea that India practiced some form of laïcité before 2014 makes no sense.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s @pbmehta writing in 2004 on Hinduism and secularism: “Perhaps secularism, like cricket and democracy, is a quintessentially Indian game that just happens to have been invented elsewhere.” [Hard to imagine any serious person making such an argument today.]
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India has never had separation of church and state. At best, it aspired to treat all major faiths equally. You can debate how good or bad that was, or how well or badly implemented in practice. But the idea that India practiced some form of laïcité before 2014 makes no sense.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Future generations will find it hard to believe that one not-very-bright (fortunately) terrorist ensured that for 23 years millions of people had to take off their shoes before boarding a flight.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m offering a prize 🏆 to the first person who correctly guesses the number of student encampments on Ivy League campuses and protests blocking the streets of London that Iran’s overnight expulsion of 4 million Afghans will inspire.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pretty dysfunctional family: Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin didn’t show up. Nor did the Egyptian and Iranian presidents. Saudi Arabia can’t seem to decide if it’s in or out. (Argentina already said thanks, but no thanks.) About half these countries have serious problems with at least one other #brics member.
Sidhant Sibal
@sidhant
BRICS Brazil 2025 summit
Leaders pose for family photo -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Imagine living in a country where the government sets out to clean a river and it actually gets cleaned.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Happy Fourth of July from Kokum and Imli. 🇺🇸
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@HSheinkopf: Zohran Mamdani voters are “the most pampered generation in the history of the world…They’ve never had a tough day.” True, “they can’t buy an apartment…But they can buy a $9 latte, and a $100 dinner.” v @tunkuv www.wsj.com/opinion/can-anyone-stop-zohran-mamdani-interv…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Jack
@nevernotjack
Here’s the form.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Why would someone who emigrated to the U.S. from a poor country champion ideas that keep poor countries poor? The rise of Ugandan-born Indian-American socialist Zohran Mamdani raises the question, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/zohran-mamdani-brings-third-world-pre…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m (obviously) no Zohran Mamdani fan, but I do think there’s a crucial difference between the untruths he and Mindy Kaling’s brother told in their college applications.
Kaling’s brother, Vijay Chokal-Ingam, lied straight up. He pretended to be Black in order to get into medical school. Mamdani’s case appears to be more complicated. If he’s telling the truth, then he claimed to be BOTH Black and Asian. Obviously this is not the most truthful answer to a question about Mamdani’s race/ethnicity. If the option was available, he should have checked Indian, South Asian or Asian (in that order). The idea that he’s Black or African American by ETHNICITY is obviously ridiculous.
But if Mamdani did indeed also claim, as he told the New York Times, to be Asian—I’m assuming that an Indian/South Asian option wasn’t available—then it seems to be more a case of trying to game the admissions system with some fancy fudging than of lying outright.
In short, neither Chokal-Ingam nor Mamdani did the right thing—both would flunk an ethics class—but Mamdani’s ruse is marginally more defensible. He was born in Kampala, and he is partly named for the Ghanaian leader Kwame Nkrumah. You could, if so inclined, give Mamdani the benefit of doubt and accept his defense—that he was merely seeking to represent his complex background rather than jockeying for a race-based leg up in college admissions.
Whether voters give Mamdani that benefit of doubt is a separate question. We’ll know the answer soon enough. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@Alice_Weidel to @tunkuv: “I’m a quite normal conservative, patriotic and in parts libertarian, who believes in the right to prosper and freedom of speech.”
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Alice Weidel attributes the AfD’s “pariah” status to the German media’s “moving pretty much to the left” and the establishment’s panic over an “unwelcome competitor” in the cozy club of German politics, writes @tunkuv www.wsj.com/opinion/the-german-firewall-no-eye-contact-wi…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
One of the most interesting and underreported stories in South Asian politics: A year ago @ImranKhanPTI was a galvanizing force among Pakistanis—both in Pakistan and abroad—and also a minor international cause célebre.
This is no longer true. You still see a few diehard IK supporters here and there on social media, and the occasional post by a committed activist-journalist, but for the most part both Pakistan and the world appear to have moved on. Imran is still rotting in jail. The field marshal is strutting his stuff in the White House. The once vocal Pakistani diaspora in London and Texas has hit a collective mute button.
Somebody, ideally a Pakistani journalist with no dog in this fight, should write about what happened. How do you go from a beacon of national hope to a half-forgotten man in the shadows so fast?
I once wrote that Imran Khan was Pakistan’s Ned Stark, idealistic but outmatched in cunning. That description still holds. But I’m not sure who that makes Asim Munir, whose rise has been as dizzying as his rival’s fall. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
To many Americans, Zohran Mamdani’s background—a Shiite Muslim born in Uganda to ethnic Indian parents—may appear fresh and interesting. But his ideas are depressingly stale. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/zohran-mamdani-brings-third-world-pre…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pretty unambiguous statement here from Jaishankar in Washington. Bottomline: For the Quad to work for India the grouping will have to take on board Indian concerns about Pakistan-backed terrorist groups.
Dr. S. Jaishankar
@DrSJaishankar
My remarks to the press before Quad Foreign Ministers’ meeting in Washington DC.
🇮🇳 🇦🇺 🇯🇵 🇺🇸
x.com/i/broadcasts/1BRJjmYAOYLGw -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I used to joke that all of India’s libertarians would fit in a (small) bus, and that I personally knew most of them. Good to see that this is no longer the case. Maybe they need two buses now.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I find the idea that Washington and Moscow will sponsor a joint Israeli-Indian effort to denuclearize Pakistan exceedingly farfetched.
Pakistan is not revolutionary Iran, whose leaders stupidly chant “Death to America.” The very fact that Pakistan successfully acquired nuclear weapons in the 1980s shows a level of geopolitical sophistication in Islamabad/Rawalpindi that the mullahs in Tehran lack.
As I pointed out in my most recent WSJ column, Pakistan WAS vulnerable to a joint Indian-Israeli strike on Kahuta in the 1980s, but successive Indian governments failed to act and today no serious person believes that rolling back Pakistan’s nuclear weapons program is feasible, even though it may still be desirable for many countries. The West has made an uneasy peace with this reality, as have India and Israel.
Against this backdrop, it’s kind of amusing to see prominent Pakistani journalists like @HamidMirPAK share this essay as though it reflects the current scholarly and policy consensus in Washington, Jerusalem and New Delhi.
In some ways Pakistan’s greatest weakness is the poor quality of its “sense making organs” such as the media and think tanks. They have been suppressed by the army for so long that—with a few notable exceptions—they have lost the ability to separate fact from fiction.
Julian Spencer-Churchill
@Ju_Sp_Churchill
Washington (& Moscow) may find sponsorship of an Israeli-Indian effort to denuclearize Pakistan's arsenal irresistible, the last one of a Muslim state, as it would free India's armed forces to focus on China.
moderndiplomacy.eu/2025/06/24/once-israel-defeats-iran-pa… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
So @scyldberry of the Telegraph (UK) has published a list of the 30 greatest fast bowlers of all time. Jasprit Bumrah, the only Indian on the list, is #1. Three Pakistani greats make the list. Imran Khan (#4) is ranked above his teammates Wasim Akram (#6) and Waqar Younis (#10).
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Part of the problem is that the only Indians willing to make the obvious point that many Pakistanis are good, kind, decent people—and that it makes no sense to confuse hostile state institutions with ordinary people—are liberal-coded in India, and therefore generally on the back foot.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Part of the problem is that the only Indians willing to make the obvious point that many Pakistanis are good, kind, decent people—and that it makes no sense to confuse hostile state institutions with ordinary people—are liberal-coded in India, and therefore generally on the back foot.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is a sad video. Disappointed to see some Pakistanis use it to score political points over Imran Khan and some Indians use it to put down Pakistan. How hard can it be to give it a break for a moment and simply mourn the loss of innocent lives?
Ihtisham Ul Haq
@iihtishamm
Heartbreaking video: 12 family members drowned in a flood after waiting hours for help that never came. No rescue, no response. The govt’s priorities have never been the people — and still aren’t. This is 2025. This isn’t an accident but indeed a murder.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In the past, I’ve praised the sophistication and assimilative capacity of contemporary British conservatism. I had an uncle in Harrow who emigrated from India as a young man in the 1960s and voted Labour practically all his life, but who, I believe, would have been happier in the party of Boris and Badenoch than in the party of Corbyn and Starmer. It’s hardly surprising, though, that not everyone is happy with the rejection of blood and soil nationalism by conservative elites.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s a link to @L_Wastell’s piece. Worth reading for anyone interested in British politics.
www.spectator.co.uk/article/demographics-is-the-new-divid… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The language and arguments used by a country’s think tanks tell us something about that country’s intellectual development. By this measure Pakistan isn’t doing too well. @CISSS_Karachi
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed moderating this discussion with two of the most influential voices in their respective fields.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Anyone who says Zohran Mamdani is some kind of radical Islamist should immediately be dismissed as mentally feeble. There are good reasons to doubt that Mamdani would benefit New York City. But the idea that he wants to set up some kind of caliphate on the Hudson is just bonkers.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As luck would have it, the Uber driver taking me to the airport, a young bearded man with a baseball cap, has a Persian name. The music he’s playing is soft and beautiful.
I ask: “Is it Persian?”
“Yes, Rumi. You know Rumi?”
“Yes, but who is the singer?”
“I don’t know the singer, but the lyrics are by Rumi. I’m into mysticism.”
He says he’s from Tehran, but has lived in the U.S. for 11 years.
“How are things in Iran?”
“They’re hitting. Boom! Boom!”
“I hope your family is okay.”
“Family is all here.”
The rest of our conversation is almost too predictable to relate. He says people are happy that Israel targeted IRGC thugs. He is happy that Trump bombed the regime’s nuclear sites.
“Do you worry that the government will crack down hard?”
“Yes,” he says. “I hear they are going to shoot friends of Israel in a field to scare people.”
We’re both silent. A heaviness hangs between us. Another gentle Persian song fills the car.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Post Script: My Uber driver was right. Iran’s mullahs have commenced mass executions to make up for their abject humiliation by the Israeli Air Force.
Parham Ghobadi
@BBCParham
Iran hangs three men and 700 people for spying for Israel
I explained that this is exactly what many Iranians fear, that a humiliated regime may take revenge on its own people to restore strength and save face.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Jaishankar is arguably Modi’s single best cabinet pick, and in my view has done an excellent job for India. But aspects of his public communication are geared more toward a domestic audience than an international one. This is unavoidable, and Jaishankar manages to walk a thin line well. But Tharoor does not need to walk it at all because he’s not constrained by the need to appeal to the BJP base. If he was in the BJP, Tharoor would face the same constraints as Jaishankar.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I see many BJP fans bedazzled by Shashi Tharoor’s communications skills without recognizing that Hindutva as a movement, at least in its current form, is virtually designed to reject people with Tharoor’s background and skill set.
If Tharoor was in the BJP he would need to constantly come up with snappy one-liners that put down other nations to keep the party base happy. His fluency in foreign languages would mark him as a hated Macaulayite and member of the so-called Khan Market Gang. He would live in fear of even accidentally saying anything generous about two of the world’s great religions—Christianity and Islam. His lack of fluency in Hindi would also count against him.
As it happens, the Modi government may have found a good balance. Let Tharoor use his skills to advance Indian interests while recognizing that such advancement is only possible because he is outside the BJP.
Aditya Raj Kaul
@AdityaRajKaul
Shashi Tharoor does it again. This time speaks in French with a senior Russian Representative to convey strong objection on Pakistan being included in a Parliamentary Summit on countering terrorism, explaining how Pakistan is known for funding terrorists.
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Jaishankar is arguably Modi’s single best cabinet pick, and in my view has done an excellent job for India. But aspects of his public communication are geared more toward a domestic audience than an international one. This is unavoidable, and Jaishankar manages to walk a thin line well. But Tharoor does not need to walk it at all because he’s not constrained by the need to appeal to the BJP base. If he was in the BJP, Tharoor would face the same constraints as Jaishankar.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I don’t disagree with @balajis on potential. But the hard truth remains that 100 years ago Bombay and Calcutta were widely viewed as among the world’s leading non-Western cities, but in 2025 India does not house a single city comparable to Dubai or Doha to the west or Singapore or Bangkok to the east. People can come up with a list of excuses a mile long, but this doesn’t change the fact that in relative terms urban India has declined compared to both the Middle East and Southeast Asia. And let’s not even begin talking about the likes of Shanghai, Tokyo and Seoul in Northeast Asia.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In 1973 there were 40,000 Americans working in Tehran.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Obviously the recent 88-hour India-Pakistan conflict was much more limited than the 12-day Israel-Iran conflict, but in terms of messaging there’s a strong parallel.
In both cases, it’s obvious to credible neutral observers that one side (India, Israel) crossed previously uncrossed red lines, and inflicted much more damage than the other. But they can’t prevent the losers (Pakistan, Iran) from pretending to their people that they somehow scored a great victory.
Self-delusion is not entirely a bad thing. It allows countries to save face and declare victory when the political costs of accepting reality would be unacceptably high. But it also makes ceasefires more tenuous. The winners have an incentive to finish the job next time in an even more emphatic way. The losers have an incentive to correct their mistakes and do better in the next round. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
All true:
1. Political speech in India is still largely free. (Good.)
2. Animation quality sucks. The Amit Shah character looks a bit like Owaisi.
3. Remains to be seen, but as a campaign slogan “Narender Surrender” may go the way of the ill-fated “Chowkidar Chor Hai,” promoted by Congress because Rahul Gandhi came up with it, but a flop with most voters.
Jairam Ramesh
@Jairam_Ramesh
नरेंदर नाम मेरा
सरेंडर काम मेराThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is certainly possible. But it’s also possible that the handful of countries that may plausibly pursue nuclear weapons will conclude that they’re not worth the financial cost, reputational damage and risk of getting bombed.
Vali Nasr
@vali_nasr
Khamenei will likely think his biggest mistake was his fatwa and not getting the bomb sooner. This will be the object lesson of this moment for many other countries. In the end it will be the U.S. and not Iran that damaged the non-proliferation regime
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
WSJ edit: “Much of the press has fixated on the idea that Mr. Trump has now joined or even started a conflict. But Iran has been waging regional and terrorist war for decades. It’s as likely that he has helped end it.” v @WSJopinion www.wsj.com/opinion/trump-meets-the-moment-on-iran-1794ade3
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“President Trump promised he would never allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon. Last night, with seven B-2 bombers and a dozen 30,000-pound bombs, he made good on that vow. The world is better off for it.”
Bari Weiss
@bariweiss
President Trump promised he would never allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon. Last night, with seven B-2 bombers and a dozen 30,000-pound bombs, he made good on that vow. The world is better off for it.
@TheFP editorial here:
www.thefp.com/p/trump-keeps-his-promise-on-iran-the -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Maybe Iran should have asked itself some questions:
-What if we arm and fund brutal terrorist groups like Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis?
-What if we spend nearly 50 years baiting and goading America with hostage takings, kidnappings, car bombings and calls for “Death to America”?
-What if we embark upon a clandestine nuclear weapons program?
-What if we oppress our people so severely that many of the smartest ones flee the country?
-What if we spend more resources on spreading revolutionary ideas than on bettering the lives of our people?
Dave Smith
@ComicDaveSmith
The most important question right now is what happens if there is a major retaliation by Iran against the US. What happens if Iran hits one of our bases and kills a bunch of Americans? Then what?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The idea that the U.S. has somehow provoked Iran is laughable. Since they seized power in 1979, Iran’s thuggish ayatollahs have done everything they could to hurt and humiliate America. A less patient country would have hit back a lot sooner—and harder.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It makes no sense for India to condemn the U.S. attack on Iran. If Iran’s rogue nuclear program has been set back or eliminated that’s good for India. Serious countries look out for their own interests. They don’t posture just to make leftist activists feel good about themselves.
Sudheendra Kulkarni
@SudheenKulkarni
Of the 14 Prime Ministers India has had so far, 13 of them -- from Nehru to Shastri, Indira Gandhi.... Vajpayee and Dr Singh -- would have unhesitatingly CONDEMNED Trump's unprovoked attack on Iran.
Will the 14th PM do so? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistani foreign policy: We strongly condemn Trump’s violence and aggression. Also, could you please give him the Nobel Peace Prize.
Government of Pakistan
@GovtofPakistan
Pakistan condemns the US attacks on Iranian nuclear facilities which follow the series of attacks by Israel. We are gravely concerned at the possible further escalation of tensions in the region.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Anyone interested in learning more about Iran’s race toward the bomb should read this @tunkuv interview with @DAVIDHALBRIGHT1.
Tunku Varadarajan
@tunkuv
Iran Is Down, but Not Yet Out: @tunkuv interviews
@DAVIDHALBRIGHT1
~~
I spoke to him for 2+ intense hours. I hope I've done his wisdom justice.
www.wsj.com/opinion/iran-is-down-but-not-yet-out-nuclear-… via @WSJopinion -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If there was a Nobel Prize for ass-kissing we all know which country would win it.
Government of Pakistan
@GovtofPakistan
Government of Pakistan Recommends President Donald J. Trump for 2026 Nobel Peace Prize
The Government of Pakistan has decided to formally recommend President Donald J. Trump for the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize, in recognition of his decisive diplomatic intervention and pivotal leadership during the recent India-Pakistan crisis.
The international community bore witness to unprovoked and unlawful Indian aggression, which constituted a grave violation of Pakistan’s sovereignty and territorial integrity, resulting in the tragic loss of innocent lives, including women, children, and the elderly. In exercising its fundamental right to self-defense, Pakistan launched Operation Bunyanum Marsoos—a measured, resolute, and precise military response, carefully executed to re-establish deterrence and defend its territorial integrity while consciously avoiding civilian harm.
At a moment of heightened regional turbulence, President Trump demonstrated great strategic foresight and stellar statesmanship through robust diplomatic engagement with both Islamabad and New Delhi which de-escalated a rapidly deteriorating situation, ultimately securing a ceasefire and averting a broader conflict between the two nuclear states that would have had catastrophic consequences for millions of people in the region and beyond. This intervention stands as a testament to his role as a genuine peacemaker and his commitment to conflict resolution through dialogue.
The Government of Pakistan also acknowledges and greatly admires President Trump’s sincere offers to help resolve the longstanding dispute of Jammu and Kashmir between India and Pakistan—an issue that lies at the heart of regional instability. Durable peace in South Asia would remain elusive until the implementation of United Nations Security Council resolutions concerning Jammu and Kashmir.
President Trump’s leadership during the 2025 Pakistan India crisis manifestly showcases the continuation of his legacy of pragmatic diplomacy and effective peace-building. Pakistan remains hopeful that his earnest efforts will continue to contribute towards regional and global stability, particularly in the context of ongoing crises in the Middle East, including the humanitarian tragedy unfolding in Gaza and the deteriorating escalation involving Iran. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
We live in an age of ignorance. The Iranian revolution was explicitly hostile to America from the start. Khomeini called America the “Great Satan” to distinguish it from Israel, the “Little Satan.” Unfortunately, @RealCandaceO is incapable of thinking about any aspect of world politics without immediately linking it to the Jews.
Candace Owens
@RealCandaceO
I have this crazy idea that if we stop our decades long foreign policy of bombing innocent civilians in the Middle East just because Bibi Netanyahu demands it, the chanting might settle down a bit.
I’m not entirely convinced that we can bomb people into liking us.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Do you understand Hindi? Shah literally said this: “Remember my words, in all our lifetimes, listen carefully to my words, in all our lifetimes in this country English-speaking people will feel ashamed. The construction of such a society is not far now.”
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Any reasonable person should recognize the potentially catastrophic economic costs of making India a country where people are “ashamed to speak English.” Luckily these backward views fly in the face of reality. At least 130 million Indians speak English, the vast majority as a second or third language. These people have nothing to be ashamed of, and those seeking to shame them are on the wrong side of history.
Lala
@FabulasGuy
Previous speaker said hindi in danger
Amit Shah said I disagree, English will be in danger, all our languages are jewels of our culture. #factPost not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Do you understand Hindi? Shah literally said this: “Remember my words, in all our lifetimes, listen carefully to my words, in all our lifetimes in this country English-speaking people will feel ashamed. The construction of such a society is not far now.”
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When it comes to nuclear weapons the nature of the regime that holds them matters. This is why a jihadist-friendly de facto military dictatorship like Pakistan is more problematic than democratic nuclear powers like India, Israel and France. And this is why nuclear weapons in the hands of the revolutionary mullahs of Tehran would be orders of magnitude more dangerous—not just for Israel, but for the world. I enjoyed talking about this yesterday on the Seth Liebsohn show. [Audio, 20m]
omny.fm/shows/sethleibsohnshow/june-19-2025-sadanand-dhume -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The U.S., Israel and India blundered by allowing Pakistan to acquire nuclear weapons. Repeating the blunder with Iran would be even worse. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/irans-nuclear-pursuit-and-the-pakista…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When it comes to nuclear weapons the nature of the regime that holds them matters. This is why a jihadist-friendly de facto military dictatorship like Pakistan is more problematic than democratic nuclear powers like India, Israel and France. And this is why nuclear weapons in the hands of the revolutionary mullahs of Tehran would be orders of magnitude more dangerous—not just for Israel, but for the world. I enjoyed talking about this yesterday on the Seth Liebsohn show. [Audio, 20m]
omny.fm/shows/sethleibsohnshow/june-19-2025-sadanand-dhume -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistan army bots are sophisticated by subcontinental standards—at least they try to avoid cut and paste. But there’s still a striking sameness to many of the scores of tweets complaining about my WSJ column on Pakistani nukes.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
More nearly identical tweets. I’m not exactly sure what purpose they serve. My guess is that some hapless colonel in Rawalpindi was charged with countering my column and this was the best he could come up with.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: The U.S., Israel and India blundered by allowing Pakistan to acquire nuclear weapons. Repeating the blunder with Iran would be far worse, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/irans-nuclear-pursuit-and-the-pakista…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
The U.S., Israel and India blundered by allowing Pakistan to acquire nuclear weapons. Repeating the blunder with Iran would be far worse, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/irans-nuclear-pursuit-and-the-pakista… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Jibes about Modi’s English are tiresome and juvenile. Like many Indians in public life he understands English perfectly well. He does not speak it with the fluency of a native speaker, but so what? English is Modi’s third or fourth language after Gujarati, Hindi and (possibly) Marathi. How many of the people who make fun of Modi can speak a third or fourth language as well as Modi speaks English?
Devi
@DefiantDevii
Starmer seems to be having a charged discussion with Modi but does Modi understand any of it?
I guess he was intelligent enough this time to prevent himself from laughing out loud, done when he has no clue.
Do Indians deserve to watch this clown show? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Rule of thumb for despotic regimes: The floridness of their threats is inversely proportional to their effectiveness.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s not that hard to overcome stereotypes. For example, you can believe that members of group X are often good at math, but also that some of them are really bad at math. Or that many petty criminals are from group Y, but that most members of group Y are not criminals. Recognizing human beings as individuals can give us a more accurate grasp of reality than relying on stereotypes. But, yes, it takes a little work.
Helen Dale (not on your team, but always fair)
@_HelenDale
I don’t think it’s possible to square this circle:
1. Group stereotypes are accurate.
2. Liberalism says treat people as individuals despite group stereotypes being accurate.
3. Some stereotypical group traits are horrendous as well as accurate.
4. When those traits appear among a plurality or even a majority, (2) becomes impossible.
Obvious current example: trans identified male and Pakistani Muslim sex offenders. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m sure this will disappoint all the brilliant people around the world lining up to pursue their dream job in Bihar.
Office of Tejashwi Yadav
@TejashwiOffice
Big announcement:-
After forming the government in Bihar, 100% domicile law will be implemented
So that all the jobs in Bihar are given only to the people of Bihar and not to outsiders- @yadavtejashwi
#bihar #tejashwiyadav #rjd -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
At its peak, the United Kingdom was a manufacturing colossus.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Nobody should be surprised that India refused to sign on to the Shanghai Cooperation Organization’s condemnation of Israel’s attack on Iran.
During India’s recent conflict with Pakistan, Israel unequivocally stood with India. Israel is a major arms supplier to India. (This includes a degree of tech transfer and joint ventures between Israeli and Indian companies.) In Iran’s funding and arming of the terrorist groups Hamas and Hezbollah New Delhi sees echoes of Pakistan’s backing of Islamist terrorist groups that murder Indians. And finally, India recognizes that a nuclear Iran led by ideologically driven mullahs would add more volatility to a volatile neighborhood.
This does not mean that India will publicly back Israel in the manner of a close Israeli ally like the United States. India has to juggle multiple interests in the Middle East, including ties with Tehran and the Gulf Arab states (some of which will be privately happy to see Iranian power clipped). But it does mean that the old days of India reflexively signing on to every anti-Israel resolution are over. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s literally nothing easier to do in Pakistan than to pass a resolution that condemns Israel. If there’s one thing that unites a Karachi socialite with a Punjabi fundamentalist, or a dissident podcaster with an army stooge, it’s an all-consuming hatred for the Jewish state.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In 1989, when Ayatollah Ali Khamenei became Iran’s Supreme Leader, the U.S. was led by George H. W. Bush, the U.K. by Margaret Thatcher, China by Deng Xiaoping, India by Rajiv Gandhi, Pakistan by Benazir Bhutto, France by Francois Mitterrand, West Germany by Helmut Kohl, and the Soviet Union by Mikhail Gorbachev.
Imagine a system that allows someone to cling to power through nearly four decades of incompetence and extremism. Iran shows why we should always be suspicious of revolutions, and especially of religiously motivated revolutions. Democracy often throws up subpar leaders too, but at least you can boot them out. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I appeared on the Tikvah podcast to talk about the burgeoning India-Israel arms relationship and the sea change in Indian attitudes toward Israel more broadly since the end of the Cold War. (This was recorded before Israel’s strikes on Iran.) [Audio, 45m]
mosaicmagazine.com/observation/israel-zionism/2025/06/pod… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Every Iranian I’ve ever spoken with sees the clerical regime as a blight on their great nation. But for some strange reason India and Pakistan are filled with people who leap to defend it.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Had religious fanatics not taken over Iran in 1979 it would almost certainly be an economic, technological and cultural powerhouse today. They say countries get the government they deserve, but nobody deserves the brutal despotism of Iran’s clerics.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When the mullahs took over Iran in 1979, it was essentially on par with South Korea and not far behind Israel. Almost 50 years later, the evidence is incontrovertible: clerical rule has been a disaster for the talented Iranian people.
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Every Iranian I’ve ever spoken with sees the clerical regime as a blight on their great nation. But for some strange reason India and Pakistan are filled with people who leap to defend it.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
When the mullahs took over Iran in 1979, it was essentially on par with South Korea and not far behind Israel. Almost 50 years later, the evidence is incontrovertible: clerical rule has been a disaster for the talented Iranian people.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The 1965 war marked the first big rupture between India and Pakistan. Before that trade and travel were much simpler. [Source: The People Next Door by TCA Raghavan.]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
As an aside, and I could be mistaken, but it looks like four of the six authors of this paper have Persian names. Yet another example of America’s unique ability to attract smart people from around the world and create conditions that allow them to thrive. v @rubenhassid
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sunday morning dogs.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Eid Mubarak! I hope all who are celebrating have a wonderful day.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: For India, cooperation with Israel diversifies its supply chain and expands its access to high-tech weapons. For Israel, access to the Indian market expands its defense-industrial base, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/mideast-power-plays-in-india-and-paki…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Last month’s India-Pakistan conflict showcased (in part) a contest between Israeli and Turkish weapons. Israeli hardware came out comfortably ahead. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/mideast-power-plays-in-india-and-paki…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s Samuel Huntington in 1991 on why Muslim-majority countries struggle with democracy. Nearly 35 years later much of this still rings true. (Major exception: Indonesia.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Dogs on a log.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Timeline cleanse: goofball with a ball.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Briefly breaking my X moratorium to share three excellent analyses of the recent India-Pakistan conflict:
1. @joshuatwhite: “The global debate on ‘attribution’ has tilted decisively in India’s favor, but in ways that may exacerbate political pressures to react hastily following future terrorist attacks.”
www.brookings.edu/articles/lessons-for-the-next-india-pak…
2. @walterladwig: “Despite Pakistani tactical successes, India appears to have largely achieved its stated objectives.”
www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary…
3. @clary_co: “India demonstrated an ability to deliver precise standoff attacks across large swathes of Pakistan…Pakistan has a meaningful and serious vulnerability to Indian air attack.”
www.stimson.org/2025/four-days-in-may-the-india-pakistan-…
Bottomline: Don’t tell the field marshal, but no serious analyst thinks Pakistan came out ahead in this conflict. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Pakistan’s army chief has emerged stronger after confronting India. But his country has shown its weakness, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/pakistans-diplomatic-victory-conceals…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Pakistan’s army chief has emerged stronger after confronting India. But his country has shown its weakness, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/pakistans-diplomatic-victory-conceals… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Asim Munir may have promoted himself to field marshal, but Pakistan’s breathless claims of victory over India conceal a basic fact. In strategic terms, Pakistan’s position has greatly weakened on Munir’s watch as army chief. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/pakistans-diplomatic-victory-conceals… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’ve enjoyed being more active here over the past three weeks than I’ve been for most of this year. Thank you all, including my angry Indian and Pakistani trolls, for the lively engagement. But it’s time to go back on my X/Twitter diet. Will continue to post my WSJ column and occasional media appearances, but that’s about it. Hasta luego.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The brilliant @HMDatMI is right about DEI in America, but her argument holds more broadly for all identity-based affirmative action programs worldwide. The only difference is that nobody in Malaysia, South Africa or India would dare state things as bluntly.
The College Fix
@CollegeFix
Heather Mac Donald, as always, is blunt and unapologetic as she explains why DEI is an ineffective racket in under 2 minutes ... (1/2) 🧵
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Two good WaPo stories on Indian and Pakistani losses using satellite images and interviews with experts.
Bottomline: India lost at least two planes and damaged at least six Pakistani air bases.
Planes:
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/05/09/fighter-jets-indi…
Bases:
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/05/14/india-pakistan-st… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’d say U.S.-India vibes are worse today than during the Nijjar/Pannun brouhaha, which the Biden administration handled quite deftly, but much better than India-Canada vibes during that time, and arguably also better than U.S.-India vibes during the Khobragade meltdown. Khobragadegate was probably the vibes low point over the past 25 years.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’d say U.S.-India vibes are worse today than during the Nijjar/Pannun brouhaha, which the Biden administration handled quite deftly, but much better than India-Canada vibes during that time, and arguably also better than U.S.-India vibes during the Khobragade meltdown. Khobragadegate was probably the vibes low point over the past 25 years.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Whatever your views of Imran Khan’s ideology and performance as PM—I’m not a particular fan of either—at a human level it’s sad to see his young sons forced to speak up about the subhuman conditions in which their father is jailed.
Arguably Gen. Asim Munir has good reasons to keep Khan in prison. Politics in Pakistan has always been a blood sport, and it’s pretty clear that Munir’s reign as the de facto ruler of Pakistan would be over if Khan ever reclaimed power.
But I don’t understand the logic behind treating a former prime minister and legitimate national politician so poorly. Why not give Khan a large, airy cell, access to a gym and home food, and regular phone calls to his family? The only explanation is that Munir wants to break the will of a man who even his enemies will concede is uncommonly brave.
I hope the appeal by Khan’s sons is heard, and that their father is treated more humanely. It’s 2025 now. There’s no reason for Munir to act like it’s 1625. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Indians and Pakistanis on this site are obsessed with winning the so-called narrative war, but the lessons from 2019 and 2025 are simple: Speak the truth, present credible evidence, and resist the temptation to make stuff up just because it’s what your people want to hear.
In 2019 nobody credible outside India believed Indian claims about taking out droves of terrorists in Balakot because the preponderance of evidence pointed toward the Indian Air Force hitting a copse of trees. Similarly, today nobody outside Pakistan buys the claim that Pakistan seriously damaged multiple Indian bases because the evidence is either non-existent, weak or doctored. Indian claims of hitting Pakistani bases are backed by scores of high resolution satellite images. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Timeline cleanse: Wednesday evening dogs.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
These are all fine attributes to seek in a politician, but part of living in a democracy is living with the fact that voters don’t always gravitate toward deeply knowledgeable leaders. If they did, Shashi Tharoor would be prime minister of India and someone like Jon Huntsman would be the U.S. president.
Sanjay Jha
@JhaSanjay
I have said it before and I will say it again. As is obvious, India needs a Prime Minister in the future who has these three essential attributes ( there are many, but these are crucial):
A good understanding of foreign policy and national security ( not just driven by inputs from bureaucrats and experts etc). A statesman, not a politician.
A solid knowledge of economics: If you don’t know your finance and macroeconomics, you automatically disqualify yourself. India cannot afford a populist sans core economic wisdom.
A genuinely inclusive individual who inspires oneness, who loves engaging with people and the media , and welcomes criticism. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
More corroboration, this time from the New York Times, that India hit what it claimed to hit while Pakistan has little evidence to back its claims of striking Indian bases.
“Satellite images of the sites Pakistan claimed to have hit are limited, and so far do not clearly show damage caused by Pakistani strikes even at bases where there was corroborating evidence of some military action.” + “High-resolution satellite imagery, from before and after the strikes, shows clear damage to Pakistan’s facilities by Indian attacks.”
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/05/14/world/asia/india-p… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Tamil Nadu isn’t even India’s largest state economy. Maharashtra has long had a larger economy than Pakistan.
Indian Tech & Infra
@IndianTechGuide
🚨 Tamil Nadu has crossed the entire GDP of Pakistan in 2025.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A little factoid. Last year, India sent about as many tourists to Turkey as Moldova (population 2.5m) and about one-fourth as many as Romania (population 19.6m).
But worry not, Indian TV news channels, fresh from capturing Islamabad and bombarding Karachi port, are about to hobble the Turkish tourism industry. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
At this point Trump is randomly shelling a U.S.-India relationship built painstakingly by both countries over 25 years. We’ll have to await satellite images to assess the extent of the damage.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump on India-Pakistan: "Maybe we could even get them together a little bit, Marco, where they go out and have a nice dinner together. Wouldn't that be nice?"
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Another fine example of India’s 🤡 show electronic media being detached from reality. The average Indian who watches this clip will come away thinking that India is a major contributor to Turkish tourism revenue. But, as @tanvi_madan has pointed out, Turkey receives more than 50m tourists each year. 330k Indian tourists account for well under 1% of tourists who visited Turkey last year.
Padmaja Joshi
@PadmajaJoshi
Love our money, but not us?
Türkiye, Azerbaijan and the Indian traveller: can love be a one-way street?
Or is it time to put what seems like a toxic relationship, on the back burner?
-Azerbaijan
2024: 2.43 lakh Indian tourists
Within one year, number of Indian tourists doubled
India contributes 8.9% of total tourists going to Azerbaijan
3rd largest number of tourists to Azerbaijan come from India
-Turkey
2022: Got 2.3 lakh Indian tourists from India
2024: 3.3 lakh Indian tourists visited
Within a year, 21% increase in number of Indian visitorsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A little factoid. Last year, India sent about as many tourists to Turkey as Moldova (population 2.5m) and about one-fourth as many as Romania (population 19.6m).
But worry not, Indian TV news channels, fresh from capturing Islamabad and bombarding Karachi port, are about to hobble the Turkish tourism industry.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Source: tripbytrip.org/2025/02/08/turkey-welcomed-62-million-inte…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If Asim Munir has emerged stronger thanks to the India-Pakistan conflict, then it follows that his nemesis, Imran Khan, has been greatly weakened.
It’s one thing for Khan supporters to battle an army chief widely reviled for tossing the country’s most popular politician in prison after blatantly rigging an election against him. It’s quite another to take on a chief who is hailed by Pakistanis as a hero for standing up to India. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Best case for “Pakistan won”: 1. PAF allegedly took down 1-5 Indian fighter jets including at least one Rafale. 2. Pakistan was able to strike back at India after absorbing Indian attacks. 3. Pakistan’s allies, in particular China and Turkey, stood unambiguously by Islamabad. 4. Trump’s statements, including his offer to mediate on Kashmir, are a diplomatic victory for Pakistan.
Best case for “India won”: 1. Unprecedented scale and accuracy of Indian missile strikes on Pakistan, including in the politically important heartland of Punjab. 2. Indian drone and missile penetration, including over major Pakistani population centers, highlighted the fragility of Pakistani air defenses. 3. Successful Indian attacks on multiple Pakistani air bases. 4. Superior performance of Indian air defenses—little to no satellite imagery to support Pakistani claims of hitting major targets in India. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I would not be surprised if one casualty of the recent India-Pakistan shooting match is the Quad. China unambiguously backed Pakistan, its most important client state. Can anyone honestly claim that India’s “Quad partners” unambiguously backed India?
To clarify, I’m not predicting that the Quad will definitely die or wither away. It exists in the first place for good reasons. But I am saying that we will see more skepticism toward the grouping in New Delhi than we would have had the Quad tilted clearly toward India. At the very least, the U.S., Japan and Australia missed an opportunity to cement their image as reliable partners in the Indian imagination. Quad supporters should acknowledge this failure. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Maybe this will change, but at this point we have overwhelming evidence that India struck the targets it says it struck and virtually nothing to back up Pakistani claims of striking Indian targets.
Christopher Clary
@clary_co
I think I’ll start a thread of commercial satellite imagery of the aftermath of the India-Pakistan conflict. Feel free to send me things.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s almost as though this Trump tweet was designed to upset the Indian government and delight Pakistan:
1. Hyphenates India and Pakistan
2. Internationalizes Kashmir
3. Legitimizes Pakistani nuclear saber-rattling -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Dept. of Irony: The Modi government successfully sold the 2019 Balakot tit-for-tat with Pakistan as a great victory despite virtually all neutral experts agreeing that the Indian Air Force probably missed its target, and despite Pakistan downing an Indian fighter jet in retaliation.
The same Indian government appears to be struggling to sell Operation Sindoor as a win despite considerable evidence that India’s performance—including scope of targets, accuracy of targeting and effectiveness of air defense—was far superior this time round.
In part, this may be because India’s comical TV news channels and unhinged RW influencers set expectations too high. If you really believed that Indian troops were about to march into Islamabad or liberate Balochistan, then the ceasefire must feel disappointing. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If India is smart it will publicly thank @realDonaldTrump @JDVance and @SecRubio for their role in defusing the crisis with Pakistan after India had emphatically made its point. There’s nothing wrong with having powerful friends who help you achieve your strategic objectives.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Maybe there really are Pakistanis out there who see India’s unprecedented attacks on well-known terrorist camps in Punjab and elsewhere, drone penetration of major Pakistani cities, largely successful defense against Pakistani drones and missiles, and bombing of Pakistani airbases as a “big win” for Pakistan.
That’s fine. Pakistan army chief Gen. Asim Munir should pray that the number of Pakistanis who believe they “won”—based largely on the possibility that they managed to down a few Indian planes—vastly outnumbers those who ask a simple question: If Pakistan’s puffed up generals cannot even protect the population centers of Punjab where they recruit from, then why should they maintain such a dominant position in national life? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India’s message to Pakistan: You can be home to religious zealots who kill people for not following their faith. But you can no longer export such zealots across the border to kill ordinary Indians with impunity. It’s a simple message, and one that was long overdue.
Max Abrahms
@MaxAbrahms
The war began when Pakistan-backed terrorists went on a killing spree of civilians who couldn’t recite Islamic verses.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A lot of people have said a lot of stupid things during the current India-Pakistan standoff, but this Pakistani claim that India is raining missiles on its own people has got to be the stupidest of all.
India’s Air Force chief is a Sikh. Sikhs serve with distinction across the Indian government, including at senior levels in all branches of the Indian military. You have to be an imbecile to think such a plan would be executable even if someone (outside Pakistan’s GHQ) was crazy enough to dream it up.
For India, though, the absurdity of the claim presents an opportunity. Seeing who amplifies it is a simple way to identify both likely ISI-linked accounts, and people who urgently need a brain transplant.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Indian media landscape includes a wide range of actors, including those who:
1. deliberately lie because it boosts ratings, or because they feel it’s for a good cause, or both.
2. unquestionably parrot government or ruling party talking points.
3. seek to be professional, but excitably rush to broadcast/print stories without verification.
4. are solid professionals who verify and confirm stories before publishing.
We should all be skeptical of #1-3, especially when emotions are running high. But we should not make the mistake of assuming that #4 does not exist just because #1-3 is noisier.
In general, my rule of thumb (for any country) is to not trust overt partisans. In Bangladesh’s case this applies to both Sheikh Hasina’s and Muhammad Yunus’s uncritical fans, and to those who appear to have an ax to grind against either leader. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s one big difference though: Indian media, particularly TV news, was far more sober and credible during the Kargil conflict (1999) than it is today. During Kargil you didn’t have clowns on Indian TV falsely claiming that India had captured Islamabad or bombarded Karachi.
Sushant Singh
@SushantSin
In trying to tightly control information, India is losing the one big advantage it had over Pakistan during the Kargil War: a media reporting freely from the ground in their own style, but adding credibility to official claims. Now they are no longer providing that advantage.
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Indian media landscape includes a wide range of actors, including those who:
1. deliberately lie because it boosts ratings, or because they feel it’s for a good cause, or both.
2. unquestionably parrot government or ruling party talking points.
3. seek to be professional, but excitably rush to broadcast/print stories without verification.
4. are solid professionals who verify and confirm stories before publishing.
We should all be skeptical of #1-3, especially when emotions are running high. But we should not make the mistake of assuming that #4 does not exist just because #1-3 is noisier.
In general, my rule of thumb (for any country) is to not trust overt partisans. In Bangladesh’s case this applies to both Sheikh Hasina’s and Muhammad Yunus’s uncritical fans, and to those who appear to have an ax to grind against either leader. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Wednesday's strikes send a message to Pakistan that it can no longer expect to target Indians with impunity and that it will be held responsible for groups that shelter on its soil, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/india-tries-to-subdue-the-threat-from…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Wednesday's strikes send a message to Pakistan that it can no longer expect to target Indians with impunity and that it will be held responsible for groups that shelter on its soil, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-tries-to-subdue-the-threat-from… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In the West we’re deeply conditioned to think of India and Pakistan as near-peer rivals, but this disguises the chasm that has opened up between the two countries thanks to Pakistan’s persistent mismanagement of its economy. India has about 6X Pakistan’s population, but India’s GDP is about 11X as large as Pakistan’s and the gap widens each year.
In a sense, India is attempting the difficult task of aligning Pakistan’s self-image with its economic reality. New Delhi is trying to impress upon Pakistan—or specifically upon the generals in Rawalpindi—the sheer lunacy of constantly poking a much larger neighbor in the eye. Most countries around the world instinctively know not to do this, but Pakistan is run by an army that has a hard time seeing through the fog of a supremacist ideology that views Pakistan in messianic religious terms. Here’s a recent quote from a speech by army chief Gen. Asim Munir: “Till date, there have been only two states which have been built on the foundation of the Kalma… first was the Riyasat-e-Tayyaba (or Riyasat-e-Medina, the first Islamic state established by the Prophet)… and the second, which Allah built 1,300 years later, is your country (Pakistan).”
Will India succeed in making Pakistan view itself through the prism of economic reality rather than messianic zeal? Color me skeptical. Pakistan isn’t the only country to suffer from self-delusion. India too has its own brand of “vishwaguru” (teacher to the world) hubris. For Pakistan to aspire to be a normal country, like say Thailand or Uruguay or Indonesia, would require a wholesale reimagining of the country. (@husainhaqqani has written an excellent book on this.) This is not possible as long as the army is in charge, and it’s certainly not possible as long as Munir is in charge of the army.
At its heart, the mismatch between how Indians sees Pakistan (bankrupt nation constantly before the IMF with a begging bowl) and how Pakistan’s generals see their country (“the fort of Islam”) will continue to fuel conflict. Twenty-five years ago, when the average Pakistani was richer than the average Indian, the Indian public was more willing to tolerate terrorism emanating from Pakistan. That willingness has evaporated. Pakistan cannot rely on India using a familiar playbook because that playbook no longer exists.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s the column where I lay out some of these thoughts:
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-tries-to-subdue-the-threat-from… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My view: India cares deeply about an off ramp and has made that clear in all its messaging about Operation Sindoor. What it doesn’t care about is a “face-saving exit” for Gen. Asim Munir.
The off ramp India constructed had a sign that said this: “Accept our limited and targeted retaliation for the Pahalgam massacre and we will not escalate further.” It did not say “come launch an attack on our military bases so you can save face and we’ll call it quits.”
In short, Pakistan has had an off ramp from the start. It still has an off ramp. It just may not be the most appealing off ramp from the Pakistani army’s perspective.
Christopher Clary
@clary_co
I made an analytic error, I think. I assumed India would want to restore deterrence by showing cost-imposing capabilities while still finding a way to give Munir a face-saving exit. But it seems clear that India doesn’t care about off-ramps.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Worth reading @YousufNazar on why a prolonged conflict with India could collapse Pakistan’s teetering economy.
Article link: www.ft.com/content/bccc3ed4-c456-401b-8964-f4044ea7dcbe -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The other day I asked a Pakistani friend for his unvarnished assessment of army chief Gen. Asim Munir. “He’s a poorly educated religious fanatic,” he said. Three weeks ago, thanks to his vendetta against Imran Khan, Munir was a strong candidate for least popular army chief in Pakistani history. I’m not sure if that’s true any more. But one thing is clear: in large part Pakistan’s fate lies in his hands.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
You may think that with the whole world paying attention to Pakistan the army may ask the terrorists it has long nurtured to lie low for a bit. You may think it would at least tell uniformed soldiers not to pray alongside a U.S.-designated global terrorist. You would be mistaken.
Taha Siddiqui
@TahaSSiddiqui
🔴 #breaking Hafiz Abdul Rauf, a US-designated global terrorist and a Lashkar e Taiba commander, leads funeral prayers for those killed in India’s strikes
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
AEI Foreign Policy
@AEIfdp
"For India, ending the symbiosis between the Pakistani army and jihadism in the near term may not be possible," @dhume writes.
"But New Delhi has no choice but to try."
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-tries-to-subdue-the-threat-from… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The U.S. may not seek to play much of a role in the current India-Pakistan standoff, but Washington should root for India to succeed in its goal of moderating Pakistan’s reckless behavior. A more responsible Pakistan would be a gift to the world. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-tries-to-subdue-the-threat-from… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If these media reports are accurate and India has indeed lost three or more aircraft it creates dynamics that cut both ways. On the one hand, it gives Pakistan an off ramp to end the crisis. It can credibly claim, as in 2019, that it gave India a bloody nose—honor retained and all that. At the same time it puts pressure on India to strike again to clearly demonstrate the Indian Air Force’s putative military edge.
My prediction: If Pakistan doesn’t retaliate significantly this confrontation will likely die down. By striking known terrorist infrastructure in Pakistani Punjab, the country’s heartland, India has shown considerably more daring and resolve than it has at any time since the 1971 war, and has inflicted considerably more verifiable damage on Pakistan as well. This should satisfy domestic public opinion in India. India can afford to eat the reported loss of its planes.
New Delhi has already signaled that it does not seek a wider conflict. But if Pakistan decides that it must escalate—whether to save the army’s face or attempt to establish deterrence—then all bets are off. India will almost certainly have no choice but to further escalate too. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you’re an international journalist you probably believe that a country’s defense minister is a responsible figure who will only share verified information. Welcome to Pakistan where @KhawajaMAsif just makes it up as he goes along.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Moral of the story: Believe nothing unless it’s been verified by multiple reliable sources. Plane crashes are hard to hide. So far I’ve seen zero credible evidence that either side has downed any planes today. This doesn’t mean it didn’t happen, but it’s better to be skeptical than credulous.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
News is still filtering in, but it’s already clear that India’s missile strikes today on alleged terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-controlled Kashmir are more serious than India’s 2019 strike on an alleged terrorist camp in Pakistan. Here’s how they’re different:
1. Targets: The Balakot airstrike was unprecedented because India crossed the international border to strike a target in Pakistan proper, not just Pakistan-controlled Kashmir. But it’s one thing to strike Balakot in (the peripheral) Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa province, quite another to strike Bahawalpur in Punjab, the heart of social and political power in Pakistan. Moreover, this time India says it hit nine targets, so the scope of the attack is obviously wider.
2. Casualties: At three dead and twelve injured at this point according to Reuters. (This figure will rise.) In Balakot the Indian media and the ruling BJP peddled unverified claims about killing scores of terrorists and (later) of shooting down a Pakistani F-16. But these claims were not corroborated by any credible, neutral observer. This time it’s different. The casualty figures are coming from Pakistan.
3. Restraint: In both 2019 and 2025 India explicitly signaled restraint. The message to Pakistan and the world: We had to do something, but we don’t want this to get out of hand. The difference: In 2019 Pakistan played along. It launched a token counterstrike, showed magnanimity by returning a downed Indian MiG-21 pilot, and did not escalate further. Both governments declared victory to their respective publics.
The situation this time is more fluid. It’s possible that it will play out similarly to 2019–the world will lean on Pakistan to take it on the chin and not up the ante—but this time war may well suit embattled Pakistani army chief Gen. Asim Munir. If Pakistan escalates all bets are off. We could see a full scale war between nuclear powers. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
After the Pahalgam massacre I said India would inevitably retaliate against Pakistan. Some folks doubted this. Just yesterday, Pakistan’s defense minister @KhawajaMAsif shared a silly meme suggesting that India was all talk, no action. In hindsight, that was not very smart.
Khawaja M. Asif
@KhawajaMAsif
No comments needed..
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Barely 100 years ago every cardinal in the Catholic Church was born in Europe. (One area where globalization is clearly not in retreat.) Source: The New York Times
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This by @nathancofnas is the best thing I’ve read on the Dave Smith v. Douglas Murray debate, and the tendency of populist right podcasts to peddle the “infotainment brain rot” that their audiences seek.
ncofnas.com/p/podcast-bros-and-brain-rot -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
China is importing top scientific talent from around the world while India drives away its most talented people with endlessly expanding caste quotas.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India’s likely response to the Pahalgam massacre will include a measure of retribution for the innocent lives lost. But to be successful it must also create a deterrent that raises the costs for Pakistan of supporting jihadist groups in India.
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
Catch up on rising tensions between India-Pakistan, JD Vance's recent India visit, and Trump's tariffs and the possibility of a US-India BTA on this week's episode of #grandtamasha--with insights from @dhume & @tanvi_madan
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India first considered cutting off water to Pakistan as early as 1948. Nehru thought it was a terrible idea and urged the state government of East Punjab to resume water supply after a brief pause. Source: The People Next Door: The Curious History of India’s Relations with Pakistan by TCA Raghavan.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Always good to chat with @MilanV and @tanvi_madan. [Audio, 50m]
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
New #grandtamasha out now: @dhume of @AEI & @tanvi_madan of @BrookingsInst join me to discuss the April 22 terrorist attack in Jammu & Kashmir, JD Vance's whirlwind India trip, and the possibility of a US-India trade deal. Listen: grand-tamasha.simplecast.com/episodes/terror-trade-and-tr…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Janan Ganesh’s list of areas where the West still indisputably leads the rest: aircraft, universities, luxury goods, global cities, sports leagues, hard currencies. [You could probably add media/entertainment to the list.]
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Anti-Americanism, once a staple of street protests in India, has largely lost its bite, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/jd-vances-india-visit-highlights-clos…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Worth reading this refreshingly direct defense of globalization by the always thoughtful @DanielJHannan.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Embarrassingly weak sauce from the Board of Control for Cricket in India. A serious response would treat army-ruled Pakistan akin to apartheid-era South Africa. At minimum, this should mean no Pakistani participation in ICC tournaments until it stops exporting terrorism.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Anti-American protestors could once paralyze the streets of major Indian cities. Now they can barely gather a ragtag bunch of old men with hammer and sickle flags.
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Anti-Americanism, once a staple of street protests in India, has largely lost its bite, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/jd-vances-india-visit-highlights-clos… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Over the coming days and weeks, the sheer horror of the Pahalgam attacks will wash over India. We will hear stories of ordinary tourists—sons, fathers, brothers, cousins—butchered by Islamist terrorists who casually singled out Hindu men to send a message.
For Modi this is a moment of truth. If he acts decisively, the vast majority of Indians and the vast majority of world leaders, will back him. If he fails to act, or if he chooses empty optics over a meaningful response to Pakistan-backed terrorism, his reputation is unlikely to recover. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If the horrific #pahalgamattack is traced to Pakistan-backed terrorist groups—as is all but certain—the Modi government will face enormous pressure to retaliate. The only question is whether this will take the form of pinpoint airstrikes or something more substantial.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Angry leftists shouting slogans against a visiting U.S. leader used to be a prominent feature of Indian politics. Now it feels like a museum piece, the Ambassador car of political protest. #vanceinindia
Pazuzu
@ra5esh
Vance Go Back! India is Not for Sale!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Prime Minister Narendra Modi faces his stiffest economic test since taking office more than a decade ago. Unlike China or the European Union, India can’t afford to pick a trade fight with the U.S., writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/trumps-tariffs-are-modis-greatest-eco…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Prime Minister Narendra Modi faces his stiffest economic test since taking office more than a decade ago. Unlike China or the European Union, India can’t afford to pick a trade fight with the U.S., writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/trumps-tariffs-are-modis-greatest-eco… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Since the end of the Cold War India has been a major beneficiary of U.S.-led globalization. Trump’s tariff threat presents both a major challenge to Modi and a chance to pursue much-needed economic reforms. [My take] v @WSJopinion
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.wsj.com/opinion/trumps-tariffs-are-modis-greatest-eco…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
At Schiphol airport this morning I came across only four non-Dutch publications: The New York Times (international edition), Le Monde Diplomatique, Die Zeit and China Daily.
“We used to have many more publications,” said a store clerk apologetically when I asked him about this. “Do people actually buy China Daily?” I asked. “Not really,” he said.
In a way, this underscores the weakness of the Chinese government’s extensive (and expensive) propaganda effort. They can get China Daily to an Amsterdam news stand, but they can’t get people to read it. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fascinating to see this upsurge of small-and medium-business owners pointing out how little has been done over the past 11 years to make it easier to do business in India. This is not something that the BJP’s IT cell can counter. In their hearts even they know it’s true.
Yusuf Unjhawala 🇮🇳
@YusufDFI
What is heartening from the @PiyushGoyal speech fiasco is people coming out in numbers to talk about the pain of businesses. EODB narrative is being rung hollow. Some of us have for a long time talked about issues, now there is a deluge.
Thanks to the minister for this blunder. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Timeline cleanse: dogs on a log.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The country that pioneered the industrial revolution is about to become the first G7 member without the ability to make steel domestically from scratch.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“Christian nationalism [in the U.S.] is about christianizing the nation, Hindu nationalism [in India] is more about nationalizing the Hindus.” Worth reading this fine essay by @bill_drexel. v @JonahDispatch
Jonah Goldberg
@JonahDispatch
Great to have @bill_drexel writing about Hindu Nationalism for the Dispatch. I met Bill on my Indian adventure. thedispatch.com/newsletter/dispatch-faith/india-hindu-nat…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The biggest “current affairs” debate in India today is about a king who died in 1707. #aurangzeb
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/india-erases-islamic-and-colonial-his… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Much to criticize in India’s education policies, but to their credit Indian policy makers have never gone full crazy like American progressives who stopped teaching algebra because children from all races weren’t doing equally well in it.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Just FYI for those prone to easily trust AI, both Grok and Perplexity spat out wrong answers when asked to identify this painting. Not sure if Chat GPT would do any better.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m fine with people who make lists of all the awful things Aurangzeb did, but why do so few of them remember the bearded man in this painting?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m fine with people who make lists of all the awful things Aurangzeb did, but why do so few of them remember the bearded man in this painting?
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If the GOP can expand on these gains among Hispanic, Asian and Black voters it could end up holding power for a long time.
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
Fascinating: White voters didn't shift at all in their voting preferences from 2016 to 2024, while nonwhite voters all shifted to the Republican side:
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Since October 7, 2023 India’s Congress Party has made a deliberate choice to disregard the brutality and barbarism of Hamas and focus all its ire on Israeli retaliation in Gaza.
The electoral calculation behind this is obvious. There are virtually no Jewish voters in India. Muslims account for ~14% of the population. The Indian Muslim intelligentsia and political elite have reflexively opposed Israel for decades, and for long held a de facto veto on this area of Indian foreign policy. (India and Israel only established full diplomatic relations in 1992.) Even today it’s not uncommon to see public rallies in India in support of Hamas and Hezbollah terrorists.
So @priyankagandhi’s attempt to appoint herself as spokesperson for the Palestinian cause is not surprising. But is it smart?
Unlike in the 1960s, or even in the 1980s, a section of India’s majority Hindu population now instinctively sympathizes with any country at the receiving end of Islamist terrorism. Israel, with which India enjoys a deep military and intelligence relationship, is at the top of the list. The electronic media is dominated by the Hindu Right, which has no love for Hamas hostage takers and can quickly point out that the group’s victims include Indian and Nepali Hindus, among others.
So purely in terms of electoral strategy Ms. Gandhi’s approach is fraught with risk. Her advisors may believe that she is cleverly consolidating Muslim support. But at the same time she may be consolidating her party’s image as soft on terrorism and willing to place Muslim sectarian interests above India’s national interest. Modi’s India in 2025 is not Indira Gandhi’s India of 1975. Running the same old playbook does not guarantee success. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
You could possibly forgive this kind of nonsensical, feel-good waste when the U.S. comfortably led every other country in science and technology, in some areas by decades. But when your main geopolitical rival is ruthlessly focused on science this luxury is no longer affordable.
Christopher Rufo
@christopherrufo
The National Science Foundation is spending $1.5 million on "Black Feminist Epistemologies: Building a Sisterhood in Computing."
This is not science, it's left-wing racialism—and all of it must be defunded. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I hope someone at @StateDept reviews this list and notices that any kind of #travelban on Bhutan, a peaceful, landlocked Himalayan Buddhist kingdom (population: ~800,000) wedged between India and China, is utterly insane.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I agree that Hindi is the second most useful language in India, and that, all things considered, you’re better off knowing it than not knowing it. Nonetheless, India has been lucky (so far) that Hindi imperialism is a failed project. It makes the language more palatable to non-Hindi speakers.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I agree that Hindi is the second most useful language in India, and that, all things considered, you’re better off knowing it than not knowing it. Nonetheless, India has been lucky (so far) that Hindi imperialism is a failed project. It makes the language more palatable to non-Hindi speakers.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Both true: 1. Replacing the ₹ symbol because it vaguely suggests the Devanagari script is cosmically stupid.
2. Cosmically stupid moves often play well in Indian politics. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Unless you want to be a national politician or a Bollywood star—and sometimes not even then—not knowing Hindi isn’t debilitating in India. By contrast, you can’t be a successful scientist, lawyer or public intellectual without a firm grasp of English. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Link: www.wsj.com/opinion/indias-war-over-words-education-requi…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Both true: 1. Replacing the ₹ symbol because it vaguely suggests the Devanagari script is cosmically stupid.
2. Cosmically stupid moves often play well in Indian politics.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s no such thing as a successful lawyer or scientist in India who does not know English. They may ALSO speak Hindi (or Malayalam, Gujarati, Tamil, Bangla and so on). But you cannot be successful in large swathes of the Indian economy without English. That’s just a fact.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A pan-Indian class of English speakers is a good thing for India’s unity. As for the inequality problem, the solution lies in making English education more widespread (along with mother tongue education), not in rolling it back. And there’s nothing wrong with learning Hindi too. That’s why the three language formula is on the whole pretty sensible for a vast, multilingual country like India.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A pan-Indian class of English speakers is a good thing for India’s unity. As for the inequality problem, the solution lies in making English education more widespread (along with mother tongue education), not in rolling it back. And there’s nothing wrong with learning Hindi too. That’s why the three language formula is on the whole pretty sensible for a vast, multilingual country like India.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s no such thing as a successful lawyer or scientist in India who does not know English. They may ALSO speak Hindi (or Malayalam, Gujarati, Tamil, Bangla and so on). But you cannot be successful in large swathes of the Indian economy without English. That’s just a fact.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hindi imperialism was doomed from the start. The good news is that even Hindi-belters appear to have understood this.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good that India didn’t vote for the fatuous (even by U.N. standards) “International Day of Hope” at the U.N. General Assembly. Who comes up with these ridiculous ideas?
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Being pro-Hamas is a subset of being pro-Palestinian. The U.S. is NOT canceling student visas merely for pro-Palestinian protests. But when that shades into supporting Hamas, a proscribed terrorist organization, then authorities are right to crackdown. The U.S. has no obligations toward foreign students stupid or malevolent enough to rally for a bloodthirsty jihadist group.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
That sound you hear is pro-Hamas Pakistani and Indian leftist students frantically deleting old tweets.
Daily Mail
@DailyMail
Marco Rubio looks to use AI to cancel visas of foreigner students who support Hamas on social media www.dailymail.com/news/article-14471541/marco-rubio-cance…
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Being pro-Hamas is a subset of being pro-Palestinian. The U.S. is NOT canceling student visas merely for pro-Palestinian protests. But when that shades into supporting Hamas, a proscribed terrorist organization, then authorities are right to crackdown. The U.S. has no obligations toward foreign students stupid or malevolent enough to rally for a bloodthirsty jihadist group.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I hope someone can solve the mystery of why people seem to have suddenly lost interest in Hunter Biden’s paintings.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Unsurprisingly, low voltage atheists are psychologically healthier than zealous atheists according to a new study by @ryanburge and @jonestony.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Shyam Saran: “Trump does not see India as a big power in the same league as China and Russia.” [My view: This wouldn’t come as a surprise to anyone outside India. India is a large middle power, but there are currently only three great powers and India isn’t one of them.]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Not only Christians. Religious zealots and religious nationalists of various stripes are often envious of Islam because they wish their imagined faith community could be more like how they see Muslims—united, religiously committed, and untempted by the allure of secularism.
But I don’t believe that this is the primary driver of anti-Islam posting on social media. At least in the West, it’s driven by a steady stream of violence by practicing Muslims against non-believers: a bombing at a concert here, a homicidal truck driver there, a critic of the faith knifed to death in a park, grooming gangs that prey on school girls….and on and on and on. If you ended the violence, anti-Islam posting would not disappear. But I suspect it would become much less common.
Rose Lyddon
@providenceluvr
much anti-islam posting comes from envy and insecurity about the relative seriousness of muslims in practicing their faith vs laxity of christians. there’s a quality of character that comes with praying five times a day and abstaining even from water that we wish we could attain
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Ayn Rand: “Racial quotas are vicious in any form, at any time, in any place, and for any purpose whatsoever. The whole affirmative action program is vicious. It isn’t profiting anybody. It isn’t improving the lot of the minorities.” [True for all quotas.]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link: www.cato.org/blog/ayn-rand-affirmative-action-racial-quot…
v @MWChapman @CatoInstitute -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Gen. Asim Munir just won another round in his showdown with Imran Khan. The Pakistani army may be a shadow of its former self, but it still hasn’t lost its uncanny ability to ingratiate itself with whoever is in power in Washington.
Rapid Response 47
@RapidResponse47
🚨 President Trump announces that Muhammed Sharifullah — the ISIS terrorist who orchestrated the Abbey Gate attack — is on his way to the United States to face justice.
13 brave American heroes were killed in the attack.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
My take: On the whole India has handled its staggering linguistic diversity rather well. If you speak basic Hindi and English—the two great link languages of India—you can get by virtually anywhere in the country. The presence of English as a pan-Indian elite and aspirational language prevents resentment of Hindi from getting out of hand even in states where some people see it as an imposition.
Śrutaṃ me gopāya
@shrutammegopaya
Language diversity is India's great problem. Perhaps more so than the issue of religion and the Muslim question
We treasure our various languages and their literatures. But it's what prevents India from becoming a true nation
There will always be some resistance to imposition of a lingua franca (whether we like it or not). At the same time, absence of an Indian lingua franca means most Indians feel at home only in their states and not elsewhere
While we want to be a strong nation state, we behave and act as a union of nations (like EU)
I long for the day when a Tamil feels Kota is as much his home as Kanchi When an Odia feels Chikmagalur is as much his home as Cuttack
That will never be the case in India. It limits labor mobility (except among the highly cosmopolitan elite hailing from a few castes). -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Question for Dainik Jagran readers: Is their inability to do something as straightforward as accurately translate a tweet a symptom of the general (lack of) quality in Hindi journalism, or would you say this is a lapse that does not reflect on the paper’s standards? Thanks.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
No surprises here for India watchers, but interesting nonetheless: India is a front rank power in the production of wheat and rice in agriculture, and steel, aluminum and cement in industry. It is severely energy deficient, except for coal. India’s relatively small consumer market is reflected in car manufacturing.
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
I aggregated these data using US wholesale prices.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
#ramzanmubarak to folks in India and Pakistan. And #ramadankareem to those who prefer that greeting.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Today’s Zelenskyy meltdown at the White House underscores my point about Modi handling his visit to Washington well. Imagine if he had started grandstanding for the media about U.S. deportation flights.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Opposition leaders want Modi to pick a fight with Donald Trump over U.S. deportations of illegal alien Indians. The Indian prime minister is smart to ignore them. [My take]
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
People don’t want to hear it, but India has Third Worldized the management of international cricket. It does not even pretend to be fair-minded. The point of power is to flaunt it—the cruder the better. #championstrophy
Saj Sadiq
@SajSadiqCricket
Mitchell Johnson "The 2025 Champions Trophy has generated quite a bit of discussion, particularly about India’s arrangement to play in UAE not Pakistan which allows them to play on the same pitch for the entire tournament. Many respected voices have pointed out that this seems unfair to the other teams and it’s an argument that has legitimate weight despite the obvious security concerns India has about playing in Pakistan. This isn’t the first time the governing body has come under fire for how it handles matters related to India and it raises questions about the overall integrity of the tournament" #ct25
#cricket
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
At least @sardesairajdeep gets it:
Rajdeep Sardesai
@sardesairajdeep
So another Champions Trophy match is washed out. This is a crazily unfair global tournament. India plays all its matches in one venue with a week’s break between matches while the other countries criss-cross countries/venues all the time . ICC is International Cricket Conference and NOT India Cricket Club for gods sake ! At the very least, India should have been made to play in Sharjah and Abu Dhabi too. Yes, we are the best white ball team in the world but at the risk of being labelled ‘anti national’ this is like trying to ‘fix’ a trophy with hugely non level playing conditions. IT’S NOT CRICKET as the late Bishan paaji would have said (sadly few of our cricket experts will call this out either). -#ausvsafg
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Should Prime Minister Narendra Modi speak out against the U.S. policy of deporting Indian illegal aliens back to India? Opposition leaders and media pundits are pressuring him to do so, but that would be a mistake, writes @dhume. www.wsj.com/opinion/modi-faces-fire-for-accepting-trumps-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Truth be told, I feel kind of bad for the BBC. Imagine allowing pro-Hamas propagandists, of all people, to badly tar a reputation for professional journalism built over decades.
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
🔴 BBC removed references to ‘Jews’ and ‘jihad’ in Gaza documentary
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Thank you for tagging Catturd, very important we get his input!
Full article here. www.richardhanania.com/p/can-bezos-bring-elite-human-capital -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Where @RichardHanania points out why the @JeffBezos decision to make the WaPo editorial page more like the WSJ is good for America. In the age of @catturd2, we need more “high quality, broad focus” conservative media.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“For India, the stakes are high. The country has benefited enormously from growing closer to the U.S. in recent decades. Despite the cordial welcome that Mr. Modi received at the White House, India can’t take further strengthening of bilateral relations for granted.”
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Should Prime Minister Narendra Modi speak out against the U.S. policy of deporting Indian illegal aliens back to India? Opposition leaders and media pundits are pressuring him to do so, but that would be a mistake, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/modi-faces-fire-for-accepting-trumps-…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Bloomberg reports that India is scrambling to lower tariffs in a bid to preserve access to the U.S. market.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Both true: 1. If you live in India, Hindi is undoubtedly a useful language to know. Not knowing it limits your geographical and professional options. 2. Outside India, Hindi offers little except the ability to access Indian popular culture such as Bollywood. Spanish, German, Japanese, French, Arabic and Chinese are all more useful languages to know.
Anusha Ravi Sood
@anusharavi10
Why does one think learning Hindi is an "Opportunity"? Because of the systematic incentive given to that language over other Indian languages. There lies the whole problem. The fact that one thinks not knowing a regional language like Hindi is a loss of "Opportunity" is the success of Hindi imposition.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Should Prime Minister Narendra Modi speak out against the U.S. policy of deporting Indian illegal aliens back to India? Opposition leaders and media pundits are pressuring him to do so, but that would be a mistake, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/modi-faces-fire-for-accepting-trumps-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
What gives America its ability to resist decline? In part it’s because of its “very good foundations,” says @DouglasKMurray to @tunkuv.
www.wsj.com/opinion/meet-europes-paul-revere-british-essa… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Opposition leaders want Modi to pick a fight with Donald Trump over U.S. deportations of illegal alien Indians. The Indian prime minister is smart to ignore them. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/modi-faces-fire-for-accepting-trumps-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Not taking any names, but I can think of at least one Hamas fan who is about to lose their cushy WaPo opinion gig.
Jeff Bezos
@JeffBezos
I shared this note with the Washington Post team this morning:
I’m writing to let you know about a change coming to our opinion pages.
We are going to be writing every day in support and defense of two pillars: personal liberties and free markets. We’ll cover other topics too of course, but viewpoints opposing those pillars will be left to be published by others.
There was a time when a newspaper, especially one that was a local monopoly, might have seen it as a service to bring to the reader’s doorstep every morning a broad-based opinion section that sought to cover all views. Today, the internet does that job.
I am of America and for America, and proud to be so. Our country did not get here by being typical. And a big part of America’s success has been freedom in the economic realm and everywhere else. Freedom is ethical — it minimizes coercion — and practical — it drives creativity, invention, and prosperity.
I offered David Shipley, whom I greatly admire, the opportunity to lead this new chapter. I suggested to him that if the answer wasn’t “hell yes,” then it had to be “no.” After careful consideration, David decided to step away. This is a significant shift, it won’t be easy, and it will require 100% commitment — I respect his decision. We’ll be searching for a new Opinion Editor to own this new direction.
I’m confident that free markets and personal liberties are right for America. I also believe these viewpoints are underserved in the current market of ideas and news opinion. I’m excited for us together to fill that void.
Jeff -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Indian justice system would only make sense if Indians lived 450-years on average. What you have now is an absurdity where court cases often drag on for more than half a human lifespan.
Rajdeep Sardesai
@sardesairajdeep
It takes 41 years to sentence former Congress MP Sajjan Kumar to life imprisonment in the 1984 anti Sikh pogrom for murder. 41 years!!! 41 bloody long years!! Wheels of justice move too slowly, way too slowly. Tragic and shameful.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hard to believe that a little over a hundred years ago the Royal Navy’s “two-power standard” was an actual thing.
Benjamin Domenech
@bdomenech
People really don't understand how much Europe has given up on defense over the past decades. The entire British Royal Navy could not fill the seats at the U.S. Naval Academy stadium in Annapolis. They aren't just not paying for NATO, they are incapable of self defense.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Few people know as much about racist affirmative action policies in American higher ed as @RenuMukherjee1. Anyone interested in this topic should follow her.
Renu Mukherjee
@RenuMukherjee1
Happy Monday! Trump’s DOJ promised to end affirmative action in college admissions, thereby enforcing Students for Fair Admissions (which Biden REFUSED to do). But elite colleges are likely to resist. I’ve compiled a list of schools that AG Bondi should look into ASAP 🧵 @nypost:
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Great example of the “lipstick on a pig” school of political analysis in India—the unflagging belief that someone who has not shown political smarts or people skills in two decades of public life will suddenly discover them by reading a tweet. Here’s a more realistic take on the Shashi Tharoor situation: He has no future in Congress precisely BECAUSE he is more articulate, well read, hard working and ambitious than Rahul Gandhi. Congress is a medieval court. In no court can you get ahead by outshining the half-idiot prince.
Sanjay Jha
@JhaSanjay
Dear @rahulgandhi
I am writing to you publicly here because no one within the Congress is probably going to tell you this. So as usual, let me bell the cat.
Leadership ( corporate or political or any other) is about having difficult conversations. It is about trouble-shooting. It is not about living in denial; problems have to be addressed, they cannot be wished away.
You and I both know that Shashi ( Tharoor) is an outstanding parliamentarian. He is probably among the only few in the country to whom the cliché, “ He needs no introduction” truly applies. It is therefore disappointing that once again a great asset of the party is being forced to talk to the media to get his message through to you or the Congress leadership. Almost five years to the date, I was compelled to write an article in a national newspaper when facing a similar predicament. No problem is intractable; the key question is do we have the will to solve them in everyone’s interest? And that too quickly.
The Congress must be focused on taking on the BJP, but a prerequisite for that is to first get the house in order. This cannot become an ongoing unresolved challenge for years as it paralyses the energy and drive of the Congress workers and supporters. A challenger party has to be swift, desperate, risk-taking, hungry and on a constant prowl. It cannot be business as usual, for sure.
We need to the hit the nail on the head going forward, but right now, we seem to be hitting our head on the nail.
I am sure the party and you will sort this out pronto.
Good luck! -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you’re a Pakistani born after 1990, then a regular walloping by India, punctuated by a face-saving Pakistani win every five years or so, is the only form of India-Pakistan cricket rivalry that you know. Only oldies recall when it wasn’t this lopsided, and in fact Pakistan was the dominant team. #pakvind #indvpak
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In terms of prestige, Arabic and Persian outrank all other languages spoken by Muslims by a lot. Nonetheless, Bengali Muslims and Indonesian Muslims retain pride in Bangla and Bahasa Indonesia respectively. Other languages haven’t been so lucky—Punjabi in Pakistan and Javanese in Indonesia are widely treated as lesser tongues, hick languages unfit for literature or refined thought.
S. Lant
@Shiftant
Native languages of the world's Muslims, according to ChatGPT. Seems to be pretty accurate.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Hamas should be destroyed either way. They are a blot on humanity.
Secretary Marco Rubio
@SecRubio
Hamas’ treatment of hostages, including its brutal murder of the Bibas family, further illustrates their savagery and is yet another reason why we are saying these terrorists must release all of the hostages immediately or be destroyed.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Islamism ought to be countered with firmness, fairness and reason, not by semi-literate ruffians who see all Muslims as the enemy. India’s tragedy is that one side appeases Islamists while the other attacks ordinary Muslims.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think @ShashiTharoor should found a new political party that rejects both the crackpot leftist economics and caste-based politics of Congress and the status quoist economics and religion-based politics of the BJP. Would such a party do well in elections? Probably not. But it would be a breath of fresh air in a political system that is struggling to deliver for Indians.
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Islamism ought to be countered with firmness, fairness and reason, not by semi-literate ruffians who see all Muslims as the enemy. India’s tragedy is that one side appeases Islamists while the other attacks ordinary Muslims.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In 1925, Britain was arguably the West’s best hope for modernizing Islam. In 2025, Britain is the West’s leading incubator of hardline Islamism.
Ian Miles Cheong
@ianmiles
British religious scholar Abu Waleed says it’s necessary to impose humiliating laws for non-Muslims in Britain and convert them.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
A section of diaspora Sikhs (not all) have allied with hardline Islamists and rallied to the Palestinian cause. For those with even a smidgin of historical memory this can sometimes become a little awkward.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s safe to say that 99% of PR people who pitch stuff to me have never read anything I’ve written and haven’t the faintest idea about my interests.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
DEI, as practiced in America, is plain anti-Asian and anti-white racism. To believe in it, you have to believe that a hard working teenager like Stanley Zhong is subhuman, that his dreams deserve to be shattered, that he must pay for the sins of others in the distant past.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The biggest frauds in India are small government votaries who claim that Modi shares their views. In reality, no PM since Indira Gandhi has given corrupt tax inspectors as much power to harass businesses and ordinary tax payers.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Anyone interested in British conservatism should read this thoughtful essay by @NigelBiggar. TLDR: There’s more to it than small government and low taxes. www.nigelbiggar.co.uk/p/why-i-am-a-conservative
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I have to disagree with @RichardHanania on this one. It’s not racist to observe that queuing politely is not exactly a dominant national trait among Indians. You can apply all the usual caveats: it’s impossible to generalize about more than 1.5 billion people worldwide, behavior in public spaces is correlated with wealth and education, many Indians (in absolute numbers) do know how to queue, and so on. Yet, in the end, you’re still left with the reality that if you teleported someone from Lucknow railway station to Kyoto railway station it would be akin to beaming them to a different planet.
Or compare the lines at a random European airport, say Schiphol, of a flight to Delhi and a flight to Zurich. Unless actively managed, the line to the flight to India naturally turns into an amorphous blob. At a Western airport this may be a slow-moving blob. At an Indian bus station or pilgrimage site it can be considerably faster, more chaotic—and sometimes dangerous.
How about Indians in the West? Again, I’ll concede that behavior depends on many things including a person’s general sensitivity to their surroundings. But it’s not unreasonable for someone to notice, over time, instances where Indians—knowingly or unknowingly—flout local queuing conventions.
You don’t even need to be in the West to experience this. About a year ago, in a security line at Bangkok airport, I had to turn around and ask the older Indian man behind me to stop jostling. A part of me felt a little bad—he was clueless, not malicious—but it was early in the morning and I didn’t like his bag hitting the back of my legs while he blithely chatted with his wife.
To sum up, some Indians are sharp-elbowed line cutters. Some are simply spatially unaware. Some are conscientious rule followers mortified by the behavior of their compatriots. But as stereotypes go this one (sadly) is not off the mark. Of all the generalizations we can make, “Indians suck at queuing” is hardly the least accurate.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Racists have very vivid imaginations.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Always fun to appear on @MilanV’s excellent India podcast even though he (shockingly) failed to accept my offer of a Hindi swear word face off with @tanvi_madan. [Audio, 53m]
Milan Vaishnav
@MilanV
New #grandtamasha out now: @dhume of @AEI @WSJ & @tanvi_madan of @BrookingsInst join me to discuss the Delhi elections, India's 2025 budget, Trump 2.0, and Modi's visit to Washington. Catch up on the latest on India & U.S.-India relations here: grand-tamasha.simplecast.com/episodes/trump-and-modi-part…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m in an auditorium in Geneva awaiting the exiled crown prince of Iran. The room, packed with Iranians, is humming in anticipation. I hear Persian all around me, soft and civilized. A lady in front of me turns around and offers me plump dates from a plastic box. It’s a simple but beautiful gesture. I say “merci” and silently wish her well. The Iranian people deserve a better future. #genevasummit2025
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The economic and educational gap that has opened up between British Indians on the one hand, and British Pakistanis and Bangladeshis on the other, is remarkable. I can see why British Indians get upset when the media clubs all three groups together as “Asians.”
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good to see @MassoudaJalal and @HusnaJalal79 honored for their defense of women’s rights in #afghanistan. Their cause may seem hopeless today, but the weight of human history is on their side. Afghan girls will surely go back to school one day. #genevasummit2025
The Geneva Summit for Human Rights and Democracy
@GenevaSummit
🇦🇫 @MassoudaJalal, former Afghan Minister of Women’s Affairs and the first woman to run for President of Afghanistan, is testifying at #genevasummit2025 alongside her daughter, @HusnaJalal79, exiled Afghan women’s rights activist.
TUNE IN NOW to watch these two courageous human rights defenders be awarded our International Women’s Rights Award: genevasummit.org -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Packed house at #genevasummit2025 where I’m listening to @SecularlyYours speak about the jailed Saudi prisoner of conscience Raif Badawi.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Good summary here of the tension between meritocracy and diversity in recent American history. One way to view the Trump administration’s assault on DEI is as an attempt to tilt the balance back toward meritocracy. A work in progress, of course, but one that could shake the world.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Read the whole thing here. H/t @KonstantinKisin
www.palladiummag.com/2023/06/01/complex-systems-wont-surv… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Republicans have a real opportunity to make further inroads among Asian-American voters who find it impossible to relate to the synthetic census bureau categories favored by Democrats in their messaging.
There’s no such thing as an “AAPI community.” Not once have I heard anyone refer to themselves as an AAPI community member. People see themselves as Chinese-American, Korean-American, Indian-American and so on.
Though most Asians do share important common interests—such as keeping crime low and uprooting merit-destroying DEI policies—even the term Asian-American is a bit of a stretch, though at least it isn’t ugly like AAPI or LatinX. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistani media and influencers spend 10x as much time hyperventilating about the hypothetical displacement of Gazans by Israel than they do covering the actual displacement of many thousands of Afghans by Pakistan.
Subboor Ahmad
@SubboorAhmad
The mainstream media in Pakistan and prominent influencers are not covering the forced displacement of Afghan refugees.
These individuals have lived here for decades, formed marriages with locals, established businesses, and integrated into the community just like the native residents. Some have never even visited Afghanistan. It is both cruel and unjust to treat them this way.
What Ummah are we speaking of if we do this to our neighbours? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
India has no libertarian party worth mentioning because all the libertarians in the country would probably fit in a (small) bus.
Rishi Joe Sanu 🌐🗽🏙
@RishiJoeSanu
India has no liberal or libertarian party at the center or local level. Every other politics can be found here however
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I spoke w/ @batchelorshow about how supporting the Gazan right to seek a better life elsewhere isn’t the same as advocating their relocation by force, and the habit of many pro-Palestinian activists of simply ignoring Israeli security concerns. [Audio, 9m]
audioboom.com/posts/8654373-gaza-free-togo-sadanand-dhume… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Over the last 100-odd years, countless Middle Eastern Jews, Punjabi Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs, Sindhi Hindus, Bengali Hindus and Muslims, Christian Turks, Muslim Greeks, Central European Germans and Ugandan Indians (among others) have been uprooted from their homes. But only the Palestinians are treated as refugees in perpetuity. [My take] #gaza
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Article link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/if-indians-and-pakistanis-can-relocat…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
All the crazy people hyperventilating about my column on Gaza should read this by @RichardHanania: “Letting Palestinians move is not ‘ethnic cleansing.’”
www.richardhanania.com/p/letting-palestinians-move-is-not
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed chatting with Seth Leibsohn about Modi’s visit to Washington and my column about the world’s double standard toward Israel when it comes to the treatment of refugees. [Audio, 14m]
omny.fm/shows/sethleibsohnshow/february-13-2025-sadanand-…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I spoke w/ @batchelorshow about how supporting the Gazan right to seek a better life elsewhere isn’t the same as advocating their relocation by force, and the habit of many pro-Palestinian activists of simply ignoring Israeli security concerns. [Audio, 9m]
audioboom.com/posts/8654373-gaza-free-togo-sadanand-dhume…Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Disagree. We can acknowledge that Partition was an extremely painful event that caused great human suffering while at the same time pointing out that many countries, including Germany, India, Pakistan, Israel, Turkey and Greece, have done a far better job of integrating refugees than the Arab states that treat their fellow Arab Palestinians less as human beings and more as pieces on a geopolitical chessboard.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In the past couple of months, I’ve flown into Abu Dhabi, Bangalore, Jakarta, Tokyo and Washington. They were not equally efficient, but they were all a lot better than the European airport where I just landed.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
omar ali
@omarali50
They did do very well (and compared to other ethnicities, still have higher average income (I don't have the figures, but it's an easy guess), and they dominated all the patronage jobs (customs, pia, local govt, railways (esp in east Pakistan) etc for the 1st 25 years, but since bhutto time the shoe is on the other foot... MQM was a response to this loss of power and patronage, even if they remain more urban, modern, educated and successful in other ways..
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Modi is absolutely right not to pick a fight with the Trump administration over illegal immigration by Indians. Fine for the opposition to make a fuss about it—that’s their job. But any foreign policy pundit who thinks New Delhi should grandstand about this issue is out to lunch.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
On the contrary, the so-called Mohajirs—Urdu-speaking migrants from India to Pakistan—did very well in their new country. In the early decades after the creation of Pakistan Mohajirs held a large proportion of prominent positions in the government, including the civil service, the army, the judiciary and the diplomatic corps.
Mohajirs have reached the top, or near the top, of every sphere of life in Pakistan, including cricket, journalism and the arts. Pakistan’s last (official) military dictator, Pervez Musharraf, was a Mohajir born in Delhi. For decades, the MQM, a political party-cum-mafia, ran Pakistan’s largest city and commercial capital, Karachi, like a fiefdom.
The language of the Mohajirs is Pakistan’s national language. (The numerically dominant Punjabis accept a kind of cultural inferiority in this department.)
You might argue that the Mohajirs, as a group, are not as powerful in 2025 as they were in 1955, but it’s completely baseless to claim that Pakistan did not welcome them and allow them to thrive in their new homeland. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
IMO @dandrezner greatly underestimates the cultural distances many refugees in the Subcontinent had to travel. For instance, members of a Punjabi-speaking Sikh family uprooted in 1947 from Kohat near Afghanistan, and resettled among Bengali speakers in Calcutta 2000 kilometers away, would have found themselves in a much less familiar milieu than a Palestinian Arab family that moved 200 kilometers from Tel Aviv to Beirut to live among fellow Arabs.
This is not to minimize the pain of migration for either family, but to underscore that many countries—including India and Pakistan—have treated refugees with more compassion than many Arab states have treated their fellow Arab Palestinians.Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
On the contrary, the so-called Mohajirs—Urdu-speaking migrants from India to Pakistan—did very well in their new country. In the early decades after the creation of Pakistan Mohajirs held a large proportion of prominent positions in the government, including the civil service, the army, the judiciary and the diplomatic corps.
Mohajirs have reached the top, or near the top, of every sphere of life in Pakistan, including cricket, journalism and the arts. Pakistan’s last (official) military dictator, Pervez Musharraf, was a Mohajir born in Delhi. For decades, the MQM, a political party-cum-mafia, ran Pakistan’s largest city and commercial capital, Karachi, like a fiefdom.
The language of the Mohajirs is Pakistan’s national language. (The numerically dominant Punjabis accept a kind of cultural inferiority in this department.)
You might argue that the Mohajirs, as a group, are not as powerful in 2025 as they were in 1955, but it’s completely baseless to claim that Pakistan did not welcome them and allow them to thrive in their new homeland. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Isn’t @Swamy39 still a member of the BJP? He abuses Modi nonstop.
Jairam Ramesh
@Jairam_Ramesh
The Indian National Congress is our country's ONLY political party where there is absolute freedom of speech as well as freedom after speech. Members give their views on issues which are, on occasion, their own and that do not reflect the opinion of the party as a collective entity. It is the party's stance that is paramount.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Props to @EricLevitz for acknowledging some of the lunatic excesses of the Democratic Party’s DEI obsession. (Though personally I wish he would go further and acknowledge that the principles underlying these policies are fundamentally flawed.) h/t @CathyYoung63
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I wish this wasn’t true, but it’s 100% true. With a handful of exceptions, the Indian media at the Trump-Modi presser reflected poorly on India—shrill, unserious, and quite simply unable to rise to the occasion.
Siddharth
@svaradarajan
Sadly for the reputation of India as a serious world power, the MEA encouraged the idiotic rhetoric and conspiracy theories of Modi bhakts and other loonytune Hindutva rightists to intrude into the Trump-Modi press encounters, where the performance of these uber nationalists just made India look silly.
Exhibit 1, the idiotic question on the “US deep state under Biden conspiring with Soros” to overthrow the Hasina dictatorship. The godi media fool who asked the question must have been taken aback by Trump’s stout denial!
Exhibit 2, one of the Indians praised Trump for “your fantastic 24 days of presidency” and then asked if USAID had interfered with elections in the US and India! I am not sure what Trump understood of her nuttiness but one thing he said did stand out: that he would be cleaning up the electoral process in the US and the first thing to be done was to bring back paper ballots! Now that’s something Modi Bhaktas in India just don’t want to talk about!
Exhibit 3, another Indian reporter wanted to know how the US expects India to help it “beat China” when he is imposing tariffs. It was left to Trump to say, somewhat statesmanlike, that he actually didn’t want to beat anyone!
The buzz in DC is that the MEA/Embassy helped these reporters get access to the press spray and press conference while sensible, seasoned journalists who might ask proper questions to Modi and Trump were kept away!
Sadly, the shitshow the godi gang put up did Viksit Bharat and ‘MIGA’ no credit. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Disagree. We can acknowledge that Partition was an extremely painful event that caused great human suffering while at the same time pointing out that many countries, including Germany, India, Pakistan, Israel, Turkey and Greece, have done a far better job of integrating refugees than the Arab states that treat their fellow Arab Palestinians less as human beings and more as pieces on a geopolitical chessboard.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Nice linguistic point. I wonder if kids in India still have to learn about sandhi in Hindi class. (I presume they do.)
Śrutaṃ me gopāya
@shrutammegopaya
Modi with his silly MAGA+MIGA = MEGA joke was following Sanskrit sandhi rules. It was an "Indic" joke.
सर्व + ईश्वर = सर्वेश्वर
राजा + इन्द्र = राजेन्द्र -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I enjoyed chatting with Seth Leibsohn about Modi’s visit to Washington and my column about the world’s double standard toward Israel when it comes to the treatment of refugees. [Audio, 14m]
omny.fm/shows/sethleibsohnshow/february-13-2025-sadanand-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Turkey and Pakistan have a strong relationship regardless of who is in power in Islamabad, but these images will hurt PTI supporters. For many of them, Imran Khan—not the Bhutto-Zardaris or Sharifs—is the Pakistani Erdogan. This would feel like a betrayal.
Aseefa B Zardari
@AseefaBZ
An unforgettable moment driving President @RTErdogan during his visit to Pakistan. Very mindful while in the driving seat with two Presidents as passengers, but not a moment I will ever forget! 🇵🇰🇹🇷
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
All the crazy people hyperventilating about my column on Gaza should read this by @RichardHanania: “Letting Palestinians move is not ‘ethnic cleansing.’”
www.richardhanania.com/p/letting-palestinians-move-is-not -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Daniel Pipes دانيال بايبس 🇺🇦
@DanielPipes
Sadanand Dhume (@dhume) quotes me in today's @WSJopinion:
"A great-grandchild of Palestinian refugees born in Damascus today is considered a Palestinian refugee.”
“The ironic thing about Palestinians in Arab countries is that their cause is sacrosanct, but the people themselves are treated badly.”
www.wsj.com/opinion/if-indians-and-pakistanis-can-relocat… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Let me list four reasons why this by @vasantbhatt14 is not a smart take on the Indian-American vote:
1. Indian-Americans are not a significant voting bloc. 4.4 million Indian-Americans are only about 1.3% of the U.S. population. Of this only ~2.9 million are U.S. citizens. The majority of these live in six either solidly blue or solidly red states.
2. It’s true that Indian-Americans (particularly men under 40) voted in larger numbers for Trump than for any Republican in living memory. But most Indian-Americans still voted for the Democrats. Trump undoubtedly benefited from building a broader coalition of ethnic minority voters than before—and a minority of Indian-Americans were part of this—but to imply that they played some kind of starring or decisive role in the 2024 elections is plain hubris.
3. There’s no evidence that Indian-American votes hinge on which party has more supporters who say nasty things about them on X. All the surveys I’ve seen suggest that Indian-Americans care about the same issues as other American voters—the economy, inflation, affirmative action, crime etc. The Indian-American drift away from the Democrats in 2024 was based on disagreements with Democratic policies and Kamala Harris’s weakness as a candidate. Perhaps this will change—the barrage of invective against Indians on this platform is relatively new—but it seems premature to proclaim this with certainty.
4. Nobody responds well to threats. But the worst kind of threats are those made without anything to back them. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Figure 1: World’s top five steel producers not including China. Figure 2: World’s top six steel producers.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sunday afternoon dogs.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
“Normalize Indian hate.”
“Normalize Jew hate.”
“Normalize Muslim hate.”
“Normalize white hate.”
“Normalize Hindu hate.”
“Normalize Christian hate.”
“Normalize black hate.”
“Normalize Chinese hate.”
Virtually every society includes people who espouse one or more of these sentiments publicly on social media. Nobody can reasonably expect political or business leaders to speak out every time such a view is expressed. If they did that they would do little else.
But when leaders do speak their instinct should be to uphold a useful societal norm—that espousing hatred toward persons merely for the group they happen to be born into is both morally wrong and bad for society. We can quibble about how much punishment is appropriate. But expecting those in leadership positions to uphold this basic norm is not expecting too much. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Does anyone buy this? The best case against Imran Khan is that he’s an incompetent megalomaniac who was happy to have the army rig elections as long as they rigged them for PTI. But no sane person—probably not even Nawaz Sharif—believes that Pakistani voters chose PMLN last year.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m surprised that the person who wrote the otherwise excellent NYT obituary of the Aga Khan IV didn’t know that the largest number of Ismailis live in India.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
She says she can fix Pakistan for just $100,000. Sounds like a bargain.
Jared DeLuna
@JaredDeLuna
American woman goes to Pakistan for guy, gets ghosted and turns out to be totally insane….her press conference is evident of it
I lost it when she said
She gonna fix up this place… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The majority of Americans have long opposed racial preferences and favored colorblind university admissions. No surprise that “Chinese for affirmative action” was an astroturfed operation.
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
Remember the whole narrative that there was a widespread epidemic of anti-Asian hate that was like, worse than the covid itself and that the REASON for this was because of... Trump's "China virus" rhetoric back during those lost years?
I've been saying for YEARS now that this was completely astroturfed into existence.
Here, I see that the DOJ funded this group, Chinese For Affirmative Action, which is a shit-stirring Asian activist group that launched the whole "Stop AAPI Hate" movement.
(I like to call "Chinese For Affirmative Action," "Chickens for KFC") -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This story nicely summarizes the DEI madness that contributed to the Democrats’ defeat last year.
Karen Vaites
@karenvaites
Open access link.
This one is worth the read. My synopsis doesn’t do it justice.
archive.ph/2025.01.30-171429/https://www.bostonglobe.com/… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@omarali50: Whatever you may think of Trump’s proposal for #gaza, there’s no doubt that this is “thinking outside the box.” Seventy five years of policy tangles have been swept aside and a bold plan has been offered. www.brownpundits.com/2025/02/05/trump-goes-big-in-the-mid…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
People get mad when you point this out, but let’s just say aesthetic refinement is not a hallmark of India’s ruling party.
Piyush Rai
@Benarasiyaa
Main gate of the Rajbhawan (Governor's residence) in UP got a major "facelift".
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pratap Bhanu Mehta argues that India is “risking a slide into irrelevance, an unserious country that is a victim of its own myth-making.” I’m curious to hear what people make of this argument. All views welcome. Thanks.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
You can read the whole thing here:
indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/pratap-bhanu-me… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In 2023, I wrote about potential GOP inroads with Asian-American voters alienated by the activist left’s extreme policies on race, gender and crime.
Zachary Donnini
@ZacharyDonnini
A major challenge for Harris in 2024 was the steep decline in her support among Asian voters. In New York City, home to 1.4 million Asian Americans, my estimates show Trump winning 50% of their votes—a staggering 40-point shift to the right from 2020. The shift was particularly pronounced in South Brooklyn (Bay Ridge, New Utrecht) and near Jamaica in Queens, where support for Trump surged by as much as 60 to 70 points among Asians in some precincts.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Read the whole thing here:
www.wsj.com/articles/democrats-cant-count-on-asian-americ… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I have begun to see more and more posts by BJP supporters who are deeply disappointed by Modi’s performance as PM. This presents a tricky challenge for the BJP because its entire communications strategy is built on the premise that Modi is infallible.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
China’s tech industry is undergirded by a brutally meritocratic talent-sorting system. By scrapping affirmative action and DEI Trump will make the U.S. more like meritocratic South Korea and Singapore, and less like quota-bound India, Malaysia and South Africa.
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
Amid intense technological competition with China, the U.S. must ensure that its universities and research labs can recruit the most talented people based on competence alone, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/foreign-lessons-in-the-perils-of-dei-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Countries that embrace quotas and preferences invariably find it impossible to jettison them. Should Trump succeed in ending affirmative action and DEI it will underscore American exceptionalism. [My take]
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Link: www.wsj.com/opinion/foreign-lessons-in-the-perils-of-dei-…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
WSJ op-ed by @dhume on Trump ending affirmative action, including quotes from me, Chris Caldwell, and Thomas Sowell.
Important lesson here. We could’ve become like India, where a majority of positions in government and universities are distributed by quotas. Trump stopped this. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Saudi Arabia moving aggressively to join the modern world has to be among the top five global trends that nobody saw coming 25 years ago.
𝐍𝐢𝐨𝐡 𝐁𝐞𝐫𝐠 🇮🇷 ✡︎
@NiohBerg
Italian PM Giorgia Meloni visited Saudi Arabia, did not wear a headscarf, and didn't change her attire whatsoever for the visit.
This would have been unthinkable even 10 years ago. Absolutely monumental shift.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For those who follow the Indian tech scene, what’s the best explanation of why China is able to birth DeepSeek and India is not? Thanks.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@buffsoldier_96: “Like a shrine to Jupiter in the decadent years of Imperial Rome, [British] multiculturalism appears now as a relic of a civic religion that virtually everyone has ceased to believe in.” unherd.com/2025/01/zadie-smiths-multicultural-fantasy/
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If the reporting is accurate, the last point in this alleged Chinese wish list for India is interesting. I was under the impression that it’s Beijing that throttled the release of Indian movies in China after 2020. Why would this be an ask for the Indian government? #indiachina
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Meet Imli. I think she wants to be top dog.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
This is just another common sensical position ceded to the GOP by the Dems. U.S. embassies should not be in the business of advocating or advertising for one side in America’s fraught culture wars. I’m glad that Rubio did this.
Ken Klippenstein
@kenklippenstein
Secretary of State Rubio instructs diplomats that only the American flag is allowed to be displayed at US facilities (i.e. no pride flags), the sole exception being POW/MIA flags, per memo leaked to me
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Sad to see Brits become so cringe. The Beatles expressed plenty of affection for India without feeling the need to wallow in self-loathing about the past. The funny part is that concert-goers don’t expect it. They’re there for the music, not for a half-baked apology tour.
Pop Crave
@PopCrave
Chris Martin thanks Indian fans at Coldplay’s show in Mumbai for “forgiving” British colonialism:
“This is our fourth visit to India, and the second time to play… It’s amazing to us that you welcome us even though we are from Great Britain. Thank you for forgiving us for all of the bad things Great Britain has done.” -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If Khalilzad’s goal is to destabilize the army-led Pakistani government while engagement farming the online PTI army, this tweet makes perfect sense. But as a description of reality it’s complete nonsense.
Zalmay Khalilzad
@realZalmayMK
Minister Jaishanker of #india attended President Trump's inauguration. If @ImranKhanPTI was not in jail, I believe he would have been a guest of honor at this hugely important event. A big loss for #pakistan. Free Imran Khan and preven Pakistan's meltdown.
#usa @POTUS -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m on a bullet train from Tokyo to Kyoto. The guy next to me is sipping an iced coffee from Starbucks and watching a video of Milan Fashion Week on his iPhone—with the volume off. It’s dark outside. The only sounds are of the speeding Shinkansen, though occasionally I catch the voices of two middle-aged ladies, old friends perhaps, in a quiet conversation two rows ahead of me. If a plastic bag rustles a few rows back you hear it. Such a lovely country.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’ve just boarded a bullet train from Kyoto to Tokyo. The bespectacled older man next to me is wearing a dark suit. He is masked (of course), and so am I, though only because I have a bit of a cold. As the train pulls out of the station, a video suddenly plays on the man’s phone. I look at his panicked expression in the two seconds it takes for his tapping finger to turn it off. “Such a lovely country,” I say to myself.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Pakistan has problems, including an overbearing army, a sluggish economy, religious hatred toward minorities, and poor relations with most neighbors. But it isn’t a failed state like Somalia or Sudan. It may have deep enough cultural and institutional reserves to avoid failing.
Dr. Taimur Rahman
@Taimur_Laal
Pakistan may not be a failed state.
But it is definitely a failing state.
Your thoughts on that? -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I’m late to this, but find this @Scholars_Stage analysis of a section of the Indian elite’s preoccupation with New York Times coverage of India, and why it’s not very smart, to be acutely observed and well reasoned.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Breakfast of champions. Kyoto edition.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Imagine being Israeli today. Not only do you have to fight off a barbaric movement that exists to terrorize your people, but you must do it while ignoring the sanctimony of those with endless empathy for these masked men with guns, and none for the terrified women they kidnapped.
Eylon Levy
@EylonALevy
After 471 days, these were the final moments of Emily, Doron and Romi’s captivity: armed gunmen, jeering crowds, and cries of Allahu Akbar.
Now they are free. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think the system in Pakistan is rigged by the army, and that there’s no way that Imran Khan would be in jail today if Asim Munir didn’t want him there. But this does NOT automatically mean that the Al-Qadir case was cooked up.
Both can be true: 1. IK and his wife made a corrupt land deal. 2. The army decided to nail them for it for political reasons.
In the end, though, what I think doesn’t matter. The question is what will Pakistanis think? It’s probably fair to assume that many will share your view that IK is completely innocent of the charges of which he’s been convicted despite all evidence to the contrary. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Million dollar question: Will Imran Khan’s conviction for corruption mar his carefully cultivated image as the Mr. Clean of Pakistani politics?
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I think the system in Pakistan is rigged by the army, and that there’s no way that Imran Khan would be in jail today if Asim Munir didn’t want him there. But this does NOT automatically mean that the Al-Qadir case was cooked up.
Both can be true: 1. IK and his wife made a corrupt land deal. 2. The army decided to nail them for it for political reasons.
In the end, though, what I think doesn’t matter. The question is what will Pakistanis think? It’s probably fair to assume that many will share your view that IK is completely innocent of the charges of which he’s been convicted despite all evidence to the contrary. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you had to randomly pick a movie to watch in one of these languages, which one would most likely be good cinema and which would most likely be unwatchable schlock?
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
From @WSJopinion: Can the British people have a reasonable conversation about Islam? The answer matters not only to the U.K. but to the world, writes @dhume www.wsj.com/opinion/labour-islamophobia-and-the-u-k-s-gro…
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
AEI Foreign Policy
@AEIfdp
"In a liberal democracy, people ought to be free to criticize any religion while simultaneously ensuring that people don’t face discrimination because of their faith," @dhume writes.
"Human rights are meant to safeguard humans, not ideas."
www.wsj.com/opinion/labour-islamophobia-and-the-u-k-s-gro… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
If the ruling Labour Party and its Islamist allies succeed in wielding the term “Islamophobia” as a cudgel to shut down discussion, it would mark a victory for radical Islam in a major Western country, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/labour-islamophobia-and-the-u-k-s-gro… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The Labour Party’s absurdly overstretched definition of “Islamophobia” would make it impossible to have a reasonable conversation about Islam in the U.K. [My take] v @WSJopinion
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Here’s a link:
www.wsj.com/opinion/labour-islamophobia-and-the-u-k-s-gro… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Saturday morning Beaucerons.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Two black dogs on a white white day.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Maybe an expert on modern British history can pinpoint the date when the English apparently lost the will to protect their daughters from abuse. It’s hard to imagine anything like Rotherham being tolerated in 1920 or 1820 or 1720.
Cernovich
@Cernovich
America still has warrior culture, guns, physical specimens.
Easy to see the many problems here, but the American dads would have killed the UK pedophile gangs (if it even happened in a red area) and police here wouldn’t have gotten in the way.
British men hang heads in shame. -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Congrats to the NYT editorial board for finding the ONE type of immigration that they oppose.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Crowdsourcing: If you had to pick the most unethical business practices of Indian start ups—stuff like offering trial subscriptions and then refusing to cancel—what comes to mind? Thanks.
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Wall Street Journal Opinion
@WSJopinion
India’s limited reforms have paid off, but the country still punches below its weight, writes @dhume
www.wsj.com/opinion/manmohan-singhs-mixed-economic-legacy… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In case you need a break from all the eulogies about Manmohan Singh, here’s my assessment of his mixed legacy as an economic reformer. v @WSJopinion
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
More than three decades after the advent of liberalization, both these things are true:
1. Most Indians are incomparably better off than they were during the poverty-stricken socialist era.
2. The Indian dream of catching up with Southeast Asia has largely failed to pan out.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Read the whole thing here:
www.wsj.com/opinion/manmohan-singhs-mixed-economic-legacy…
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If the name of your country’s founding father depends on which political grouping happens to be in power, then you can be pretty sure that you live in a banana republic. #bangladesh
-
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
More than three decades after the advent of liberalization, both these things are true:
1. Most Indians are incomparably better off than they were during the poverty-stricken socialist era.
2. The Indian dream of catching up with Southeast Asia has largely failed to pan out. -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There are obvious differences between the two systems—for instance the U.S. doesn’t have explicit quotas—as well as between the two economies. But at the level of ideas all identity-based affirmative action programs have common features. They are all based on the view that: 1. Everyone is first and foremost a member of an ascribed group, not an individual. 2. That the world is divided into oppressor groups and oppressed groups. 3. That present day discrimination is a remedy for past discrimination, real or imagined. 4. That the proposed remedy must be implemented in perpetuity, or steadily expanded without limits.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There are obvious differences between the two systems—for instance the U.S. doesn’t have explicit quotas—as well as between the two economies. But at the level of ideas all identity-based affirmative action programs have common features. They are all based on the view that: 1. Everyone is first and foremost a member of an ascribed group, not an individual. 2. That the world is divided into oppressor groups and oppressed groups. 3. That present day discrimination is a remedy for past discrimination, real or imagined. 4. That the proposed remedy must be implemented in perpetuity, or steadily expanded without limits.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Helen Andrews is right that India is unable to sustain a meritocracy. But the reason isn’t cheating scandals—though these are undoubtedly more common in India than in the West. India has long managed to organize grueling national exams—for top engineering and medical schools, as well as for the civil service—that are not known to be marred by fraud.
The problem, rather, is that “meritocracy” is a dirty word in Indian politics, where virtually everyone who runs for office is some kind of social justice warrior. For instance, no Indian politician can argue that the top medical school should admit only the top-ranked students, which is the norm in China. In this respect, virtually the entire political class in India resembles the DEI-motivated left in America with its oppressor/oppressed framework and its focus on equality of group outcomes rather than equality of opportunity.
The debates in Indian politics are about which identity group should get quotas and how fast they should be expanded. Nobody talks about rolling quotas back or ending them entirely. Currently about 6/10 government jobs and places in government-funded universities are filled using quotas. This proportion was less than 2/10 when India’s affirmative action program began in the 1950s.
This means that India, the birthplace of modern affirmative action, is extremely unlikely to ever become a meritocracy, whereas in the U.S. at least elements in one party see this as a laudable and achievable goal. The only silver lining for India is that its identitarian leftists are somewhat more practical and less crazy than their American counterparts. Nobody in India would simply stop teaching calculus in high school because a preferred group wasn’t doing well in it.
Helen Andrews
@herandrews
India can’t sustain a meritocracy at home—see below. America doesn’t have scandals like this, and the qualities and norms that explain that difference are more important to our national success than “skills.”
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
For those interested, here are a few articles I’ve written over the years about India’s fascinating and depressing quota politics:
www.wsj.com/opinion/modi-gives-in-to-the-oppositions-dema…
www.wsj.com/articles/indias-desperate-opposition-pushes-c…
www.wsj.com/articles/indias-ethnic-quotas-are-a-cautionar…
online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390443931404577548632… -
Sadanand Dhume reposted
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Asim won 2023 too, and Bajwa beat Imran in 2022. But IMO you can never count out Imran entirely. If he makes a comeback in 2025, then his defeats in 2022, 2023 and 2024 will no longer look like defeats. They’ll be seen as steps on his path to victory.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Asim won 2023 too, and Bajwa beat Imran in 2022. But IMO you can never count out Imran entirely. If he makes a comeback in 2025, then his defeats in 2022, 2023 and 2024 will no longer look like defeats. They’ll be seen as steps on his path to victory.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
It’s easy to forget, but before much of the Indian middle class fell in love with Modi it was Manmohan Singh whose story resonated most strongly with them. When I wrote this for Foreign Policy in 2012 India’s love affair with Singh was over, but it was fresh enough to describe.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Do people seriously believe that Rahul Gandhi’s speech in Parliament insulted all Hindus? (I don’t.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
You don’t have to be an Imran Khan supporter to acknowledge the glaringly obvious fact that he won the people’s mandate fair and square. Hard to respect any commentator or journalist who can’t acknowledge this upfront. #pakistanelection #pakistanelection2024
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Whatever your view of #sheikhhasina or #bangladeshelections, I hope we can all agree that this is a beautiful national anthem.
youtu.be/YvIzePXplgc -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I don’t think any Indian prime minister before or since surrounded themselves with people from their own sub-community the way Indira Gandhi surrounded herself with Kashmiri Pandits in the early 1970s. (Neither praise nor criticism, just an observation.)
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Economist edit: If the Canadian investigation confirms Indian involvement in Nijjar’s murder, it is time for the West to take a tougher line against India. www.economist.com/leaders/2023/09/20/if-india-ordered-a-m…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
In this sweeping look at the 1990s, Christopher Caldwell observes how demographic distortions created room for more open attitudes in America toward blacks and gays.
www.firstthings.com/article/2023/10/the-fateful-nineties -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Worth reading @mazdaki on how Pakistan’s feckless politicians collectively enabled Army Chief Gen. Asim Munir to make a sweeping power grab not seen since 1958, when Ayub Khan imposed the country’s first martial law. thewire.in/south-asia/pakistan-full-blown-praetorian-stat…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
The real question India faces isn’t whether democracy rankings are fair. It’s whether the country wants to be a liberal democracy or travel down an autocratic path. [My take]
www.wsj.com/articles/flawed-freedom-rankings-have-a-real-… -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Has Rahul Gandhi learnt nothing from two consecutive electoral thrashings? This photo suggests that Congress fights not for the rights of ordinary Muslims, but first and foremost for fundamentalist Islam. Regular Muslims don’t sexualize little girls by covering them up.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
On #ukraine, you often see Indian foreign policy pundits criticize the US for pushing Russia into China’s arms. Here Fiona Hill finds the idea of fostering a 21st century Sino-Soviet split “a non-starter.” Full interview w/ @j_tepperman here:
octavian.substack.com/p/fiona-hill-on-russia-and-ukraine -
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@rupasubramanya on the elephant in the #quad room: “India's brand of democracy appears to be ever more illiberal and out of step with the pluralistic values that the four leaders pledged themselves to support in their recent joint statement.” asia.nikkei.com/Opinion/What-the-Quad-misses-about-India-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
With so much going on in the world this will go unnoticed, but Pervez Hoodbhoy losing his job is a massive symbolic defeat for Pakistan’s brave and beleaguered liberals, and a triumph for obscurantists and Islamic fundamentalists. www.newsweekpakistan.com/religion-vs-reason/
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
I have many PPP friends, but objectively speaking Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was not good for Pakistan. His vanity contributed to the country’s break up in 1971. His kowtowing to clerics on Ahmadis and night clubs strengthened fundamentalism. Islamic socialism was a crackpot idea.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
.@vindugoel & @gettleman: With the #coronavirus pandemic, Modi has gotten more blatant in his attempt to control media coverage. Some Indian news executives seem willing to go along. www.nytimes.com/2020/04/02/world/asia/modi-india-press-me…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
If you’re one of those people who thinks the main job of the international media is to praise Modiji 24x7, then please spare yourself and don’t read this FT edit on #coronainindia. #coronavirus www.ft.com/content/4ec25a6a-6ddf-11ea-89df-41bea055720b
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
There’s so much hateful garbage about Pakistan in the Indian media. Just want to say I’m rooting for Pakistanis to pull through this #coronavirus crisis. Admire the many brave doctors, medical personnel and others working heroically against the odds. Please RT if you agree.
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Withering @TheEconomist editorial calls Narendra Modi “despicable,” “dangerous,” and a threat to Indian democracy. #indianelections2019 www.economist.com/leaders/2019/05/04/under-narendra-modi-…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Rogoff: Sharply taking big notes out of circulation in peacetime is extremely radical. May take years to understand. blog.press.princeton.edu/2016/11/17/kenneth-rogoff-indias…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
"Truth to tell, instead of cursing Bharara, we should try and import him as our first lokpal." #khobragade www.indianexpress.com/news/national-interest-of-course-th…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Narendra Modi leads @Time POY 2013 poll by wide margin. [More proof that only Indians still read Time.] poy.time.com/2013/11/25/face-off-who-should-be-times-pers…
-
Sadanand Dhume
@dhume
Fmr. Pakistan foreign secretary Riaz Mohammad Khan @AtlanticCouncil: There's no question of Taliban returning to Kabul as they did in 90s.



















































































































































































































































































































































































































































































