CHART OF THE DAY: While the surge in Saudi oil production in October attracted most of the attention, there was another big jump: Iraq.
Baghdad boosted output to a 7-year high of ~4.6m b/d last month (just under the all-time high of ~4.8m b/d of Aug 2019) exporting crude via Strait of Hormuz, but also pipeline (via Turkey) and trucking (via Syria) to Mediterranean Sea.
Iraqi oil production has not only recovered well above pre-war levels, but the country has much bigger plans.
Last month, I wrote an @Opinion column flagging how Iraq is attracting international oil companies and could emerge from the war stronger:
"Yes, Iraq is a risky destination, even more so today with a war raging in the neighborhood. But for the first time in decades, the country offers Big Oil the kind of returns it aspires to."
More here: www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2026-10-12/big-oil-goe…
Adam Tooze
John Adam Tooze (born 5 July 1967) is an English-American historian who is a professor at Columbia University, Director of the European Institute and nonresident scholar at Carnegie Europe. Previously, he was Reader in Twentieth-Century History at the University of Cambridge and Gurnee Hart Fellow in History at Jesus College, Cambridge. More on Wikipedia
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alberto Toscano
@Alberto63137378
"once the running of a state involves a permanent and massive shortage of historical knowledge, that state can no longer be led strategically" (Guy Debord, Comments on the Society of the Spectacle)
Middle East Eye
@MiddleEastEye
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio attacked the ICC, suggesting that if the court tried to enforce its rulings against Americans, Washington would respond with force.
Quoting the Roman general Pompey, Rubio said the US response would be: “Stop quoting laws to men with swords.” -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karl Schamotta
@Karl_Schamotta
Attenborough: "And here, on the tarmac, we witness one of nature’s rarest spectacles. Drawn by instinct and incompetent national leadership, the great metal birds gather nose to tail. The courtship is slow and expensive, and results, 9 months later, in multiple regional jets"
Rob DenBleyker
@RobDenBleyker
WOW! an airplane mating swarm. a beautiful and rare sight... in the spring, the air will be full of baby cessnas
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Perhaps rather than reading these as "output gaps" we should read the graph as a map of how the "horizon of expectation" formed at different points in Poland's growth trajectory has been broken and adjusted downwards.
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
If you want to see some scary output gaps, you just have to look at Poland, which is back to post-2008 output gap levels. This is going on all across Eastern Europe and Germany isn't far behind. The war in Ukraine is a big deflationary shock for Europe...
robinjbrooks.substack.com/p/the-case-against-this-inflati… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Heather Long
@byHeatherLong
I know everyone is focused on Nvidia, but the U.S. housing market is in a dramatic slump.
Home sales in October fell to the lowest since 2010
(This is sales of existing homes).
Home sales and home building are drying up as mortgage rates remain above 7% (and home prices remain 50% above 2020 levels). There's unlikely to be much relief anytime soon.
This is a big pain point for many young Americans. Spain is currently experiencing strikes and riots over housing unaffordability. It's a warning to the US. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
French Presidential Candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon:
Life itself, its direction and its force, are constantly pushing us to become one single people, increasingly united, with all our peculiarities.
Being binational is not being a little bit of each. It is something else. It is creole. You understand? It mixes things together and produces unexpected things. -
Adam Tooze reposted
alexander saeedy
@ajsaeedy
Much belated personal news: I am writing a book!
Captain of Industry is the story of Jamie Dimon’s rise to the top of Wall Street and Corporate America, chronicling how he rode a wave of immense consolidation in financial services and survived successive crises to become the preeminent CEO of our times.
It hasn’t been a smooth ride, with plenty of mistakes and miscalculations along the way. But his ambitions have only grown with age, as he now looks to use JPMorgan Chase as a kind of corporate state, using its massive $4 trillion+ balance sheet to influence domestic and foreign affairs, harkening back to the financiers of the Gilded Age.
Can’t wait to share it with everyone. If you have a Jamie story to share, get in touch. -
Adam Tooze reposted
ALEJANDRO AYUSO DIAZ @AlejandAyusoDi
📖 My new book is out for pre-order!
Japanese Colonialism in Manchuria, 1907–1945 (@Palgrave @SpringerNature )
A firm-level study of state and zaibatsu investment, from the South Manchurian Railway to Maoist China’s planned economy.
🔗 link.springer.com/book/9783032343260
#economichistory -
Adam Tooze reposted
Haydn Belfield
@HaydnBelfield
"uneven and combined development" as @adam_tooze would say
Tim Hwang
@timhwang
The coexistence of RSI with a fundamentally bottlenecky world will give rise to a late 2020s that feels like this: the rich strangeness of hyperfuture living alongside large swaths of unchanged or even regressing social practice, a temporal redshift all over your perception
billy
@billyhumblebrag
reading the METR report on RSI and then going to the ribbon cutting ceremony for the new on site recycling bins for my apartment block
Tim Urban
@waitbutwhy
[read about what’s happening with AI]
ME: Wow we’re actually legit fucked this is so bad.
[go outside]
ME: Wait those people are all acting like nothing unusual is happening. Maybe I was just in a paranoid bubble? Yeah it must be that. Phew.
[read more about what’s happening with AI]
ME: Wait no we ARE fucked. Shit. It’s all those people outside who are in a delusional bubble.
[go outside]
ME: Wait... -
Adam Tooze reposted
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
This must've been the greatest day of their entire lives.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Chucheng Feng @fengchucheng
Turning a Chinese person's name into a grotesque cocktail of racial stereotypes and sexual innuendo isn't political analysis. It's racism, plain and simple.
And this guy calls himself a China expert? He should know better. Deleting the post doesn't erase the racism. It just shows he knew how indefensible it was. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Mark Koyama
@MarkKoyama
Reading for the next iteration of my series on state capacity in Prussia and it is interesting to see where popular account such as Ha-Joon Chang get their image of Prussia as a case of state-led economic development from and why it is largely wrong.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alberto Toscano
@Alberto63137378
Critical theorists: be all that you can be.
DOW Rapid Response
@DOWResponse
.@SECWAR “The philosophical doctrines of the Frankfurt School – critical theory and the corrosive apparatus of ‘Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion’ – are fundamentally INCOMPATIBLE with military service and antithetical to the Constitution of the United States.”
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jaan of EVwire.com ⚡
@TheEVuniverse
Europe's biggest car market is going fully electric.
In Germany, battery-electric cars have now out-registered petrol and diesel combined for three months running.
In October, BEVs made up 37.0% of new cars (94,086 of 254,492).
Petrol + diesel made up 24.5%. -
Adam Tooze reposted
𝐋𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐋𝐢
@lingli_vienna
How many people are on China’s public payroll? 🧵
For decades, the size of China’s public payroll was hidden from the public. But a Fudan University research team reverse-engineered the numbers through a statistical reconstruction using indirect data points.
Main findings
1/n -
Adam Tooze reposted
Robin Wigglesworth
@RobinWigg
There’s only one thing you need to get your loved ones this Christmas… HT @noahisreading
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Peasants as a project of intellectual history. This looks absolutely fascinating!
Lafargue
@G_Platzdasch
🚜„Bauern als Projektionsfläche und Verhandlungsmasse in den Welt der Ideen“🧑🌾 www.wiko-berlin.de/wikothek/zeitschrift-fuer-ideengeschic…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
一 个美女 间 谍
Not often that intermediate vocab is this topical! -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
the secret spy that roamed the pages of the New York Times a YEAR ago
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/09/technology/nvidia-chips-china-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Thomas Fazi
@battleforeurope
😅😅😅
Little Green
@thelittlegreen6
BREAKING: Government releases footage of suspected Russian activity in Irish airspace
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
This is the London Banana. As long as you stay within the Banana, you'll have a great time in London. Almost everything outside the Banana is horrible these days, best avoid. Not clear why, or when this happened. But it is what it is.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Julia 🤝
@REMARKSIST
amazing HM weekend, but despite wearing it the whole time only !2! people identified my circulation of capital necklace , worse rate than some random Berlin house parties !
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Historical materialism conference in London is pretty great even if you aren’t a self identified Marxist tbh :)
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Lewis Jackson
@lewjackk
China's green boom in the developing world now rivals all rich world climate finance in size. Cleantech investments and exports to the Global South hit $132 bln last year, versus $139 bln in climate finance in 2024 (the last year we have data.)
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tymofiy Mylovanov
@Mylovanov
Germany has put the officer who built its weapons pipeline to Ukraine in charge of the whole Bundeswehr.
Christian Freuding, 55, takes over in February, as Berlin plans to spend €780bn on defence by the end of 2030 — FT. 1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Guinan
@joecguinan
Many of the issues Stuart Holland was grappling with—on regional and spatial inequality, planning, on the state as entrepreneur and industrial strategy—need to be revisited in our current predicament. He also advocated for a Social Europe that was made impossible by the treaties.
Joe Guinan
@joecguinan
Rest in peace Stuart Holland, one of Britain’s finest radical left economists whose like we don’t see these days. www.uc.pt/feuc/destaques/falecimento-do-professor-rogerio…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Via MUFG. We've never seen foreign investors pile into American stocks the way we have over the last 12 months.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
An announcement I've been hoping to make for two years...
GUEST ALERT
At Odd Lots LIVE on 12/9 in NYC @tracyalloway and I will be talking to @adam_tooze to revisit Wages of Destruction, 20 years on from its release in 2006.
Get your tickets here:
events.bloombergevents.com/event/OddLotsNYC/summary
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
There's more names to come, but among our speakers will be well-known open source AI advocate @linamkhan and life insurance industry analyst @PabloTorre
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
ODD LOTS LIVE, NYC, 12/9
Get your tickets NOW to our final show of the year
@tracyalloway and I have some unambiguously amazing guests lined up, and you WILL feel dumb for not having gotten a ticket when they were still available. events.bloombergevents.com/event/OddLotsNYC/summary -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Aldana Cohen
@aldatweets
When the Polanyian double-movement does bottom-up Keynesian business-cycle regulation.
Matthew B
@boes_
Asked economists if the midterms affect their forecasts at all given how much is riding on the AI boom. They said it could actually prolong the expansion by curbing overinvestment: "A good excuse to kill some projects here that were already looking shaky" www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-05/ai-investment-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Callinicos @alexcallinicos.bsky.social
@alex_callinicos
I was among the 900 academics who signed the open letter protesting Andreas Malm being barred from entering the UK.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Elena Saavedra Buckley
@elenasb_
Is this a totally new political era or is this a Jaws-music-incumbency-whiplash-hyperpolitics-moment of incoherence??? Do I have a book recommendation for you... profilebooks.com/work/in-the-long-run/
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
Stock markets up after election results. But what is most interesting is the composition. Health and solar up, data centers and Musk-related down. Crypto up may be the one I wouldn't have expected.
And note, markets presumably had already been pricing in large Democratic gains. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Anti-AI regulation politics is actually GOOD for AI because it manages the bubble - The Gesamtkapitalist speaks.
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
Anti-AI politics is bad for AI stocks in the short run but very good for preventing a bubble in the medium to long run.
Bubble = supply grossly outpacing demand: Dark fiber optic cables in 1999, railroads to nowhere in 1870. Hard to get there in AI when …
a) existing chips in data centers are currently over-subscribed
b) politics slows the growth of data center supply while demand has time to catch up -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This Affordability Bill idea from Tim Wu @superwuster focusing on market reform and pricing for key essentials seems like a good response to the macro issues facing the new Democratic majority that I raise in the latest Chartbook newsletter: After the midterms: How does America come down from Trump’s “speedball economy”?
Tim Wu
@superwuster
What Democrats should do: draft and pass an Affordability Bill, focused on the "economics of essentials" (healthcare, housing, food, etc). Dare the President to veto it; if he does, dare Republicans to make it veto-proof. If it passes, so much the better; if it doesn't, it becomes a Blueprint for 2028.
The substance of the bill should be pricing reforms (eg, banning of 21st-century price-fixing) and structural reforms (eg changes to merger review for essential industries; private-equity accountability). Core stuff that the majority of Americans agree on.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The issues raised in Chartbook are:
the inside Dem politics of protectionism,
the trade offs from a strong v. weak dollar,
the fiscal question
and the wider war question:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-483-after-the-midterms -
Adam Tooze reposted
philip lewis
@Phil_Lewis_
'In 1860, an enslaved man named Sheppard Peek was listed among the possessions of William Peek. His value was placed at $1400.
More than a century and a half later, Sheppard’s great-great-granddaughter, Keisha Lance Bottoms, was elected governor of GA' www.ajc.com/politics/2026/11/keisha-lance-bottoms-crawfor… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Turns out Mannheim just means Mannheim.
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
Wonderful etymological #map of #germany. Shows the original meaning of all major towns and regions. Lovely piece of work. Sadly only of interest for German speakers. Tag your German friends if you can't read the map :) Source: i.imgur.com/zIogem7.jpg
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Great as ever @simongerman600 Can you read the legend for Berlin?
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
Wonderful etymological #map of #germany. Shows the original meaning of all major towns and regions. Lovely piece of work. Sadly only of interest for German speakers. Tag your German friends if you can't read the map :) Source: i.imgur.com/zIogem7.jpg
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One more reasons to found our philosophical anthropologies on the possibility of such breathtaking imaginative and yet clearly learned and trained skills.
Love Music
@khnh80044
Centuries ago, someone invented this magnificent instrument, and another created this breathtaking piece of music. Now, we get to witness such a brilliant performance. Life truly is a miracle.💖
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Well If Art Gets Funding, Why Shouldn't Football? | Yes Minister | BBC Comedy Greats
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zl0aEz34A4o
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
We heard you liked the opera. You’re in luck. Go to on.nyc.gov/opera to enter the lottery for free tickets to the Metropolitan Opera.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Schnurrbert Schnurrplus
@_schnurri
Picking up @adam_tooze idea of svabian-sichuan fusion I made Mapo-Maultaschen
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This keyboard made Deluge and Crashed.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
Why is China so obsessed with holding on to traditional industries? Aren’t they focused on high-tech growth?
Key reasons as laid out by NDRC:
1. They’re the foundation of the “real economy” and enable new high-tech industries.
2. Traditional industries may have started earlier but innovation and progress in them continues.
3. Employment—they can provide high-quality jobs through industrial upgrading.
Quote from a Q&A with reporters:
Reporter from Singapore’s Lianhe Zaobao:
Amid the wave of high-tech development, how can China’s traditional industries transform themselves while continuing to create jobs?
Fu Jiuling, Director-General of the Department of Industrial Development, National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC):
The Outline of the 15th Five-Year Plan lays out a blueprint for industrial development over the next five years, and it has attracted a great deal of attention. When we talk about technological revolutions and industrial transformation, it is easy to think of emerging industries and industries of the future while overlooking traditional industries. Some even believe that cultivating new growth drivers means traditional industries are no longer important.
At the same time, many people are concerned about the impact of industrial upgrading on employment. I would like to make three points.
First, the transformation of traditional industries toward newer and higher-quality development has always been underway and has never stopped.
We often say that each generation of manufacturing processes, materials, and equipment represents a new stage of technological iteration and industrial upgrading. Experience shows that there are only outdated products, not outdated industries.
Although traditional industries have been around for a long time, they should not be equated with low-end or backward industries. Consider people’s everyday needs for clothing, food, housing, and transportation. Today’s clothing fabrics are incomparably better than those of the past. Bicycles are also becoming lighter, with some now incorporating carbon fiber.
It is fair to say that the so-called traditional industries we see today are very different from what they were several decades ago, or even just a few years ago. The vitality of traditional industries—like old trees sprouting new shoots—is evident everywhere in our daily lives.
Second, traditional industries are the foundation of the real economy, and all three of China’s “new three” industries have emerged from traditional industries.
For example, although the three core systems of new energy vehicles—batteries, electric motors, and electronic controls—have replaced the conventional internal combustion engine powertrain, the manufacturing processes used to produce vehicles remain fundamentally continuous with those of traditional gasoline-powered cars.
The solar photovoltaic industry originated in polysilicon, which belongs to the nonferrous metals industry. The subsequent production of silicon wafers, solar cells, and modules all relies on mature processes from the electronics industry.
Lithium-ion batteries originated in traditional electrochemistry and materials manufacturing.
These industries did not emerge out of thin air. They were built on the strong foundations of traditional industries and sustained technological innovation.
Third, we must proactively understand and respond to the impact of new technological developments on employment.
Looking at manufacturing, during the 14th Five-Year Plan period, employment rose in some industries and fell in others, but overall manufacturing employment remained stable at around 110 million people.
Throughout human history, new technologies have continuously affected employment. The replacement of physical labor by machinery and equipment, and of certain forms of cognitive labor by information technology, has been an ongoing process.
We can see this in our daily lives. Some jobs are disappearing, while new … -
Adam Tooze reposted
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
En route to become one of my favorite stories to explain how messy the energy transition is proving:
Coal mine shifts to EV trucks to save on diesel.
📄: www.wsj.com/world/asia/these-trucks-haul-90-tons-of-coal-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
The big change this year has been the pivot by foreign investors towards US equities and away from US Treasuries/ Agencies ... it isn't so much that friends have stopped buying Treasuries as that everyone is now chasing equity like returns
2/
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-28/us-friendly-na… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ember
@ember_energy
Wind and solar generated more electricity than fossil fuels in the EU for the FIRST time ever in 2025 🌪️☀️
The EU’s milestone shows #cop31 that high renewable penetration is achievable at system scale.
ember-energy.org/latest-insights/european-electricity-rev… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
This is great—impressively researched: “The story of a bold political experiment in nineteenth-century France to establish power through finance.”: press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/C/bo266402165.html
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Objectively remarkable chart. Even chips from 2020 are still seeing their rental value increase.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
Out today in the UK with @AllenLaneBooks!
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
The Age of Confiscation is out this fall. It’s a book about how seizing property has been more important to recent history than we tend to think, and about why it is returning in our era of geopolitics, energy and climate shocks.
You can preorder it here: www.littlebrown.com/titles/nicholas-mulder/the-age-of-con… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Have often watched this video and not know the phrase charge en muraille … what an image.
ithaca rising 🇫🇷 🇬🇧
@ithacarising
The ideal Napoleonic charge - especially the French heavy cavalry's version - was less a wild gallop than a carefully built crescendo. Squadrons started at a walk, moved through the trot and canter, and only went full out in the last stretch so the horses stayed fresh and the ranks stayed locked together ("boot to boot," or charge en muraille "like a wall"). That tight wall of men and mounts was meant to hit with real shock, preferably against an enemy already shaken by guns or infantry.
British cavalry of this era often approached the same problem differently. They had fine horses and bold riders, and a single squadron could be formidable. Yet they had a well-known habit of prioritising speed over control - once they charged, they tended to keep going, scatter, and struggle to re-form. Wellington put it bluntly when he said he considered British cavalry inferior to the French from "want of order," adding that while one British squadron might match two French, larger formations generally favoured the French. In small numbers that dash could still win, but in larger masses the French usually held the edge because they kept better cohesion and were more reliable about holding reserves.
The basic sequence of the charge was much the same on both sides. What set the French practice apart was simply greater consistency in keeping large bodies under control from start to finish.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
Where China’s top 100 richest people got their wealth has shifted dramatically away from real estate to tech.
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
DeepSeek founder Liang Wenfeng is one of the top 10 richest people in China.
China’s Hurun Rich List has seen a surge of individuals in tech: semiconductors, AI, clean tech, etc.
Meanwhile, mainland real estate used to make up 1/3 a decade ago and now has zero in the top 100. -
Adam Tooze reposted
George L. Mosse Program
@GLMosseProgram
A warm #mossewednesday congratulations to Dr. Keith Baker, winner of this year's AHA George L. Mosse prize for his book "Jean-Paul Marat: Prophet of Terror"!
@UWHistoryDept @ESatUWMadison @AHAhistorians -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Sun
@arcticinstincts
One in 46 Taiwanese babies is born to a TSMC employee. The Taiwanese gene pool is being sexually selected for semiconductor proficiency.
afra wang
@afrazhaowang
re-reading gideon lewis-kraus’s feature story “sand castles” on @NewYorker.
so many great details. the AI supply chain becomes a breathing, moving, growing beast, something so visceral and material.
one detail i can’t stop thinking is: one in forty-six babies in taiwan is born to a tsmc employee (?!?!)
next year’s goal: convince a magazine or foundation to fund my tsmc tradwife story.
link: Computer Chips Are the Most Magnificent Things Humanity Has Ever Made www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/10/26/computer-chips-are-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Roman Chlupaty
@romanchlupaty
It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so…
Looking forward to the deep dive at the impact forum impactforum.cz/en/ @adam_tooze!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How stable is the dollar in an age of “speedball capitalism”?
When the AI trade unravels, does the "profit dolla" go with it? -
Adam Tooze reposted
JB
@DiversifiedJB
Great piece by @adam_tooze on the profit dollar. Interestingly, BL-style market-implied returns for US equities are still close to the realized returns of recent decades, despite outsized market cap. Some other observations I would add in chart form:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Riffing off a series of posts on the profit dollar
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-475-after-the-dollar-as -
Adam Tooze reposted
Tim Howles
@AimeTim
-
Adam Tooze reposted
DG.
@dataghees
Added a comment linking to Bank of Canada where Canada has been earning a valuation premium by having liabilities in CAD and returns in USD. If it unravels, Canada could be exposed to both sides of the trade.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Good questions
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How stable is the dollar in an age of “speedball capitalism”?
When the AI trade unravels, does the "profit dolla" go with it? -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How stable is the dollar in an age of “speedball capitalism”?
When the AI trade unravels, does the "profit dolla" go with it?
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Riffing off a series of posts on the profit dollar
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-475-after-the-dollar-as
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
And a remarkable piece of writing in @TheEconomist
www.economist.com/business/2026/09/30/the-era-of-speedbal…
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The latest Chartbook post in the profit dollar series is here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-481-how-stable-is-the-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This would seem to be an official State Department channel celebrating the Christian tradition.
Department of State
@StateDept
America, more than any other nation in world history, was shaped by the Christian tradition of spreading the gospel unto all nations.
Join us in celebrating International Religious Freedom Day.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Stuyvesant v. Dalton": The discourse around these data on the makeup of the Harvard undergraduate cohort is dizzying!
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
I do wonder if the Ivy League will become less socially and culturally prestigious as it becomes more Stuyvesant than Dalton.
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
no no no you don't understand getting rid of affirmative action was supposed to revert harvard to its demographics c. 1920 with lots of spots for heritage americans
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Eylon Levy
@EylonALevy
Socioeconomic status was key indicator of voting in Israel's elections.
Among Jewish voters, in the lowest socio-economic cluster, Netanyahu's coalition won North Korean levels of support. In the top cluster, 81% voted for the Change Bloc.
via @YediotAhronot -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
Have a guest post on my Substack today by the intellectual historian Danilo Scholz who writes about “The Changing of the Straussian Guard: From Fukuyama’s End of History to Trump’s America”: historyofnow.substack.com/p/danilo-scholz-on-the-changing-of
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
Earlier this summer, the wonderful editors at @thebafflermag asked me if I wanted to contribute an essay for a forthcoming issue.
I said I wanted to write about Iranian bricks.
Iran's remarkable brick architecture has become something of a meme. Everyday there's a new picture circulating online of a beautiful brick edifice in some Iranian city (often courtesy of @SustainableTall).
But why is Iran, a country dealing with so many traumas, the site of the most innovative and ambitious brick architecture in the world?
That's the question I set out to answer in this essay, which starts with a visit to the mudbrick village of Abyaneh, just over the ridge from the nuclear site at Natanz.
thebaffler.com/salvos/brick-by-brick-batmanghelidj -
Adam Tooze reposted
Columbia Center for Contemporary Critical Thought
@ColumbiaCCCT
NOVEMBER 13: Join the CCCCT and co-organizers for the Columbia Memorial Workshop: The Legacy of Jürgen Habermas. In-person at Columbia University or remotely from Zoom. November 13 at 9:00 AM. For more information and to register, please visit: www.eventbrite.com/e/jurgen-habermas-legacy-conference-ti…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
Catnip for all the guerrilla Schumpeterians and Charles Tilly fans out there: this @peer_schouten essay in @thebafflermag on Central African supply chains, gold mining and armed groups presents an entire fiscal-cervisial theory of the modern state: thebaffler.com/salvos/the-beer-wars-schouten
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Dr. Liz | Ars Ingenii
@drlizengineer
The shipyard and warehouse of the Dutch East India Company (VOC) in Amsterdam, 1726.
It was the largest of the VOC's six shipyards in the Netherlands. From around 1660 to 1799, approximately 500 ships were built at the Amsterdam yard, accounting for over half the total tonnage of all VOC ships built since 1602. During the 1750s, the shipyard employed 1100 workers and an additional 180 staff members.
The warehouse was 177 m long and 22.5 m high, filled with precious Asian trade goods. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Kral
@DanielKral1
Eurozone bank credit flow to the private sector has turned and banks report a tightening of lending standards as well as lower demand in Q4. Not surprising, but still a headwind for growth in the near-term.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Maureen Thorson
@maureenthorson
“Years do odd things to identity.” A poem by Ursula K. Le Guin.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
New from me: The US has faced a higher cost than any other country from the global Hormuz oil shock, with the crisis adding $160 billion to its fuel bill — or $471 per person on average — despite being the world’s largest oil producer.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The learning recession pairs well with Chartbook 480 on the state of France's schools and the more general problems in education across the OECD.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-480-frances-schools-sy…
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
Friends in Indonesia working to make the 100GW solar target reality by 2030, note that China installed more than that in 9 months, for the fourth year in a row.
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
China installed 61GW of wind and 111GW of solar power in Jan-Sep. Wind tracks last year's record pace, while solar is down from that but tracks 2023 which saw a respectable 200GW added. With energy demand growth slowing, clean energy has a good shot at covering all demand growth.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Andrea Capussela
@AndreaCapussela
Serbia's must be the most well-read parliament ever, by the way: 160 PhDs in 250 candidates
-
Adam Tooze reposted
DEI speedwagon🌹🇵🇸 〽️
@uhshanti
never logging off this website
The Extreme Music Enthusiast
@TheExtremeMusi1
Around 1500, Hieronymus Bosch painted sheet music on a sinner's bare butt in hell. 500 years later, someone transcribed and performed it. Now you can hear the original butt song from hell.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
James Heale
@JAHeale
Best anecdote in Carol Thatcher's book about her father is when Sir Denis boarded a train at Paddington in which the only empty compartment was reserved for Rosewood Psychiatric Hospital.
Denis travelled alone and in comfort as far as Reading when "all these chaps piled in", accompanied by a male nurse, who counted them before the train moved off.
'One, two, three, four ... who are you?"
"I'm the Prime Minister's husband."
"Six, seven, eight, nine..." -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
So many interesting nuggets like this on the weeks before Russia's invasion when the UK was trying to assess their plans to defend themselves.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
New post:
We have a fascinating and candid interview with Tony Radakin who was head of the armed forces 2021-2025.
Covers decisions on Ukraine, the lessons from the UK, the threat from Russia, defence spending and the disaster of military procurement.
samf.substack.com/p/when-russia-attacked-it-felt-like?r=7… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Guppy-level death and consolidation: Did Elon just call it?
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Wow this looks fascinating! Anyone seen it?
Mustafa Sacid
@msacid1
Oxford'dan şöyle bir kitap çıkmış, kapağın tam ortasında da Cavid Bey var
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Is it just me,or is Classical Chinese erotislop having a breakout moment?
0x鸣人
@LuBtc888
元朝文学家姚燧76岁时,和侍奉他沐浴的侍妾发生了关系。
第二天,侍妾说:“您已年迈,倘若我就此身怀有孕,恐怕会被家中怀疑,留个证物给我吧!”
元代文人姚燧这位文坛大佬,不仅笔杆子硬,做人更有温度,
他官至翰林学士承旨,笔下碑文能让王公贵族争相追捧,书法更是自成一派。
如今国博的古代书画展上,还能看到他的《草书诗卷》传世。
可就是这样一位权倾朝野的文人,晚年却因一件风流事,留下了一段跨越百年仍让人唏嘘的佳话。
那年76岁的姚燧退休后,日子过得不算冷清,原配早逝,儿女各自成家。
偌大的姚府里,几个侍妾轮流照料他的起居。
其中一个名叫留香的年轻侍妾,凭着聪慧通透,格外被他看重。
盛夏的一天,暑气逼人,姚燧去府中澡堂沐浴消暑,这个年轻侍妾像往常一样随身伺候,
添热水、擦身子、递衣物,一套动作娴熟又周到。
或许是热气熏人,或许是晚年寂寥,这位古稀老人一时情难自禁,和侍妾度过了一夜。
换做旁人或许只当是一场寻常的宠幸,可这个侍妾却在第二天一早就犯了愁。
留香没有哭哭啼啼,也没有趁机索要名分钱财,反而直接找到姚燧,开门见山说出了自己的担忧:
老爷,您年纪大了,要是我侥幸怀了孕,府里的族人谁会相信,到时候说我私通,我和孩子的命恐怕都保不住,求您给我留个证物吧。
这话一出换做别的权贵,大概率会觉得侍妾贪心、不懂规矩,可姚燧却瞬间懂了。
他在官场沉浮大半辈子,见惯了大家族里的尔虞我诈,更清楚元代妾室的卑微处境。
那时候妾室即便生了孩子,也未必能被家族接纳。
一旦男主人离世,无依无靠的妾室,稍有不慎就会被安上不贞的罪名,轻则被逐,重则丢命。
他更明白这个侍妾要的不是荣华富贵,只是一条活命的退路。
姚燧没有写书信、立字据,因为他知道那些东西太容易被伪造、被销毁,根本靠不住。
他让人取来笔墨纸砚,又让侍妾拿出贴身的围肚,提笔就在那柔软的素绸上,写下了四句诗:
八十年来遇此春,此春过后更无春,纵然不得扶持力,也作坟前拜妇人。
这首诗看似简单,实则藏着满满的承诺和考量。
前两句自嘲古稀之年还能邂逅温情,暗指自己时日无多。
后两句更是直接表态,就算自己不能再庇护她,将来孩子长大,也得认她这个母亲,让她能名正言顺地站在自己坟前祭拜。
更关键的是姚燧的书法是翰林院磨了一辈子的真功夫,苍劲有力,自成一派。
整个元朝都没人能模仿,这笔迹本身,就是最硬的铁证。
果不其然没过多久,姚燧就病逝了,应验了诗里此春过后更无春的谶语。
而他离世没多久,那个侍妾就被查出怀了身孕,消息传到姚家瞬间炸开了锅。
姚家的族人和原配的族人,一个个跳出来指责她不守妇道,一口咬定她肚子里的是野种。
有人叫嚣着要把她赶出家门,还有人提议动家法,彻底整顿家风。
毕竟姚燧年事已高,谁也不愿相信,他临走前还能留下子嗣,更不愿有人来分姚家的家产。
就在这千钧一发之际,侍妾没有慌乱。
她缓缓取出珍藏已久的围肚,当着所有族人的面展开。
姚燧那独一无二的字迹清晰可见,族中长辈一看就认出是他的真迹。
再读完诗里的字句,所有的指责和谩骂,瞬间戛然而止。
没人再敢质疑,因为这首诗就是姚燧留下的遗嘱,是这个卑微女子和未出世孩子的保命符。
后来侍妾顺利生下一个男孩,姚家族人不仅彻底接纳了他们母子,还悉心照料。
那个孩子也继承了姚燧的才情,自幼勤奋好学,最终学有所成,没辜负姚燧当年的期许。
很多人都说姚燧这是风流过后的补偿,可其实这背后藏着的,是一个文人的通透和善良。
他看透了封建宗法的残酷,也读懂了底层女子的无助。
没有用权势压人,也没有敷衍了事,而是用自己最擅长的方式,给了一个弱女子最实在的安全感。
这个侍妾的清醒,更是难得。
她不贪慕虚荣,不抱侥幸心理,在命运的十字路口,主动为自己和孩子争取生机。
而姚燧的难得,在于他身居高位,却没有被权势和偏见裹挟,愿意放下身段,尊重一个卑微的生命。 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Praxis
@praxiss
I don’t think this essay by Fredric Jameson gets nearly enough attention. One aspect that I particularly enjoy about this piece is that he doesn’t just explain how Hegel is applicable to Marxist criticism, as other works often do. He criticizes Marxist critics for their++
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicolas Fulghum
@nicolasfulghum
Q3 2026 was the first quarter ever in the EU where battery electric vehicles outsold pure petrol cars
Over 700k BEVs were sold between July and September, a staggering 64% increase over Q3 2025 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jeff Nascimento
@jnascim
“Aos 34 anos, Lula exala autoridade, não hierarquia. Num gesto que só pode existir entre iguais, alguém puxa sua mão e acende um cigarro no dele. Lula nem olha. Mantém os olhos fixos na direção de onde chega o rumor da multidão. Todos se agitam à volta dele, satélites sob efeito de seu campo gravitacional. Lula, ele próprio, não sai do lugar. Embora cercado de companheiros, nessa hora grave é um homem sozinho. Nada chama mais atenção do que isso”
— João Moreira Salles, “Lula volta a Lula”, 9.mar.2016, in @revistapiaui jnascim.info/8uUc31
🎥: ABC da Greve, de Leon Hirszman (1990)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
Since 2002, the expected share of an individual's life spent in the labour force in the EU has increased from 41.4% to 45.4%.
Higher labour force participation (particularly at older ages) outweighs rising life expectancy. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kit Winder, CFA
@WinderKit
Great note by @FTAlphaville on the different ways to slice and dice French debt metrics. Firstly, converting it into constant currency to make intl rates more comparable, and then looking at spreads over the overnight funding rates, showing how small the current crisis is compared to Greece in the early 2010s.
This is a seismic flicker at the moment - a warning - but not an earthquake (yet).
In the end, perhaps what matters most is how much of a country’s GDP goes towards interest payments. France has quite a long average maturity (8.5yrs) sparing it a degree of urgency. And despite the last few weeks, France’s EU-leading govt spending and debt/GDP levels, the US and Italy are still set to spend a higher proportion of their economic product on paying off interest.
www.ft.com/content/9aa4549e-26f4-4963-94eb-50cf0fc0b8f9?s… How nervous are bond markets about France? -
Adam Tooze reposted
Taisu Zhang
@ZhangTaisu
This is one of the more interesting graphs on CCP disciplinary enforcement I’ve seen in some time. “Hedonism and extravagance” are relatively well-defined offenses (essentially, abusing reimbursement policies and engaging in overly conspicuous consumption—this is why Chinese bureaucrats all wear Longines watches), whereas “formalism and bureaucratism” were, in the past, so poorly defined that they were effectively unenforceable. Since about 2018, there’s been a flurry of regulatory activity seeking to give those terms clearer definition, mainly focusing on “lack of concrete action when implementing top-down directives.” That’s still pretty vague to external observers, but the more interesting question is whether they can at least generate predictable standards of behavior to party insiders. The incredibly rapid growth of disciplinary cases against those offenses suggests, at least, that they’ve become well defined enough to permit large scale, top-down enforcement.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸🇲🇽 New York Mayor Mamdani is now speaking directly to immigrants IN SPANISH, telling them how to deal with ICE agents
And he's getting VERY specific.
Don't open your door without a judicial warrant. You have the right to remain silent. Don't sign anything before speaking with a lawyer.
He even explains how to check whether a warrant is actually signed by a judge, rather than simply issued by immigration authorities.
Mamdani also reminds residents that NYPD officers do not participate in routine federal civil immigration enforcement and points them toward the city's free immigration legal hotline.
He's promising to protect the RIGHT TO PROTEST, too.
This goes beyond criticizing Trump's immigration crackdown. Mamdani is personally walking New Yorkers through how to exercise their rights when federal agents show up at their doors.
And he's doing it in the language many of the people he's trying to reach speak at home.
Writer: OliverThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Gideon Rachman
@gideonrachman
My new book - out today in Britain. All good bookstores etc…Also out in translation in Italy, Germany and the Netherlands this week
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Peer Schouten
@peer_schouten
Nice one by @adam_tooze. Also chimes well with efforts by Africanist archeologists to redefine political complexity away from equating it with purely hierarchical and centralized state formation
Roger Peet ⚗️🕳️
@TooSphexy
‘historical analogy is the refuge of those who can’t face the current situation’ great survey on agglomeration in Africa from Tooze
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicolas Fulghum
@nicolasfulghum
EVs are not a "rich" country phenomenon at all anymore
Roughly 30% of new car sales in Indonesia are already fully battery electric.
Oil importing countries across the globe are making the sensible choice of moving away from oil dependency in the transport sector. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
No!! Stop it!!! We're not doing this
www.crisesnotes.com/sigh-no-ed-zitron-ai-bond-issuance-is…
William Fitzgerald
@william_fitz
"Speculative data center debt is being repackaged and sold to pension and retirement funds, university endowments, and other institutional investors in a manner eerily reminiscent of the subprime bubble."
ourfinancialsecurity.org/resources/brace-for-impact-prote… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Thomas van Linge
@ThomasVLinge
Unboxing videos when you're an influencer fighting in the armed resistance of Myanmar 🇲🇲
No cloths, limited-edition toys, or cosmetics, but brand new radios.
source: www.facebook.com/share/v/1Jn3FPywMA/This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jonathan Fine
@jonathanbfine
in the land of slop, the lit bro is king
Dean W. Ball
@deanwball
is it just me or is everyone hearing more references to this book lately? may have to check it out
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Rutte-Mann, OH GOD that is a horrible thought. But tbVERYc ... Magic Mountain is NOT a favorite book of mine! Like @afrazhaowang I though it was kinda trippy tbh. A rather turgid prog rock trip. Some seriously good moments and a fascinating concept. But for heaven's sake ...
Calculo Ergo Sum
@CalculoErgoZum
The book is also a favourite of NATO secretary Mark Rutte.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Insofar as I had anything to do with the magic mountain meme, it was just me trying to make up for an inadequate literary education. Better late than never …. @TheStalwart @afrazhaowang
Brunella
@brunellaism
i almost want to say that this is just another groupchat conspiring to inject a book into the discourse like with Demons a few months ago (the Mannosphere?) but also like. earlier this week my coworker randomly mentioned this book in a meeting. and then earlier this summer i independently felt an urge to read The Magic Mountain." So who knows really
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
They look starved!
Mark Urban
@MarkUrban01
The inability to get soldiers out of isolated frontline positions for months on end has produced scenes like this - I can’t imagine the psychological damage to these guys
Армія Медіа
@army_tv_ua
65 ОМБр показала повернення бійців, яких вдалося вивести після 320 днів на позиціях
До точки евакуації піхотинці йшли понад 18 кілометрів. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
LOVE the association btw Thomas Mann and Lu Xun here. Totally agree that there are similar problems in modernist thinking and aesthetics in play.
afra wang
@afrazhaowang
I’ve been reading The Magic Mountain (pilled by @adam_tooze’s newsletter).
It feels like a fever dream, entering the mind of a young bourgeois engineer in pre-WWI Europe, where history is suspended and everything is slippery, symbolic, and feverish.
I was thinking: “wow this is what a Freudian turn feels like from inside the European elite. And they have no idea what’s coming!”
It also reminds me of Lu Xun’s “In the Wine Shop” (在酒楼上) which is written around the same time, there’s a same feeling of historical suspension, of people caught in confusion when the old China was clashing with modernization. -
Adam Tooze reposted
.
@GregTSargent
Really striking stuff from new NYT poll: Dems lead GOP on every major issue, including immigration, and are seen as the party of the working class by a 13-point margin:
-
Adam Tooze reposted
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
OPEN LETTER: Sally Rooney is a writer, not a terrorist. Her books must be available to the public. Their withdrawal from sale, on the basis of ill-conceived and draconian anti terror legislation, is an affront to basic principles of free speech and expression so long taken for granted in this country. We categorically reject censorship - whether direct or indirect - and urge the government to change course, amending the legislation which has led us to this point of repressive absurdity.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Dave Jones
@CleanPowerDave
The Strait of Hormuz runs 2 ways... a record 2.6GW of solar panels were exported from China to Saudi Arabia in September☀️
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Financial Times
@FT
In 1950, there were 228mn people living in Africa, with about 33mn in cities. Today there are 1.6bn Africans, 19% of the world’s total, of whom 670mn live in cities. Almost unnoticed, Africa has become an urban story, explains the FT's David Pilling. ft.trib.al/XZw6TGM
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Branko Milanovic
@BrankoMilan
Just got today Boris Kagarlitsky's "Empire of the periphery". Was planning to read it for at least five years (but never go around to ordering it).
Boris is in Russian jail for speaking in favor of peace.
But manuscripts do not burn. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jonathon Catlin
@planetdenken
Happy to share my chapter, "History as Permanent Catastrophe: A Conceptual Collaboration between Walter Benjamin and Theodor W. Adorno," in "Concepts of Culture: New Directions in Conceptual History," eds. Mattias Pirholt & Michael Lipkin. DM for a PDF!
www.jstor.org/stable/jj.38271401 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicolas Fulghum
@nicolasfulghum
Battery electric vehicles were the largest market segment in France in September at over 40%.
Pure combustion vehicles are taking their final breaths. Petrol at 11% and diesel at 2%. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Michael J. Kramer
@MichaelMOTTCM
Credit Default Swaps for Oracle, Broadcom, and Nvidia continue to widen out, with Oracle at a 23% default probability, Nvidia at about 8%, and Broadcom at 12%. Which is pretty amazing, given these are among the largest companies in the world.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ziad Daoud
@ZiadMDaoud
Bahrain is the world's 4th most indebted government
The IMF ranks it behind Sudan, Japan & Singapore
But Japan & Singapore can carry their debt better than Bahrain
It lacks their safe-haven status, savings cushion & currency flexibility -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
One of the things that surprised me most in Schöttler’s biography was a letter that Keynes wrote to Bloch in 1929 telling him he was an Annales subscriber “from the start”. The master of 20th-century macroeconomics cared about socio-economic history and read its journals.
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
For @TheIdeasLetter I wrote about Marc Bloch and the challenge of writing synthetic and structural history. Featuring the Annales, Pirenne, Keynes, fin de siècle social science, and the generalizing ambitions of Carlo Ginzburg and the micro-historians.
www.theideasletter.org/essay/total-historian/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
For @TheIdeasLetter I wrote about Marc Bloch and the challenge of writing synthetic and structural history. Featuring the Annales, Pirenne, Keynes, fin de siècle social science, and the generalizing ambitions of Carlo Ginzburg and the micro-historians.
www.theideasletter.org/essay/total-historian/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
david_mcnair
@David_McNair
@Jayati1609 @davidmcw @adam_tooze
david_mcnair
@David_McNair
At #onedata we're launching the Development Finance Observatory.
A data analyst in your pocket.
Ask it about aid, debt, domestic finance, inflation, trade, and more.
Get a trusted, verifiable answer. 100,000 indicators. 1,300 places and organisations.
developmentfinance.org -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ahmet Benlialper
@AhmetBenlialper
Perry Mehrling marked Bernanke’s "Econ Nobel" by sharing Kindleberger’s verdict on him: “a most ingenious solution to a non-problem.”
x.com/PMehrling/status/1580564044489973760
Now Woodford has just won this year’s prize, and Mehrling is sadly no longer here to weigh in. So here is his own take on Woodford:
"...he abstracts from essentially all of the institutional apparatus of the banking system. Not only is there no capital in his account, but also there are no banks. No doubt there is a wide range of economic problems for which these abstractions are useful, but I confess to some doubts about the usefulness of these abstractions for many monetary problems."
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
Lovely tribute to Perry Mehrling from @adam_tooze
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-478-money-and-empire-for
(worth reading it, particularly the ending, while considering that Michael Woodford just won the Nobel for a model of the economy that explicitly has no money in it at all) -
Adam Tooze reposted
LiorLefineder
@lefineder
After William conquered England in 1066, he incorporated 21% of the land in England as his royal estate.
Then came the rewards for his close followers: 57 people were given control of half the land in England.
Based on the origin of names in the Domesday Book, we can see that almost all major landholders were Norman; only a few hundred English landholders (mostly with smaller lands) are named, who in total possessed just 8% of the landed wealth in England (this figure includes ecclesiastical landholding as well; if only private landholders are counted, it would be even lower)." -
Adam Tooze reposted
Santiago Rossi
@srossiarg
Falleció Perry Mehrling. Gran economista . Su curso de dinero y bancos, en coursera o edx, es excelente.
El prof. Finkman nos hizo leer 'The New Lombard Street' para DCC, que es un muy buen libro. Y justo ese año dio una charla en la UBA. RIP.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There is international econ - based on "island" view of world econ & then there is analysis of global financial network centered on $ - what @PMehrling in his lovely new book on Kindleberger calls a cosmopolitan view. See Chartbook #160 h/t @HyunSongShin
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-160-kindleberger-mehrling -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karl Schamotta
@Karl_Schamotta
Wonderful note on Perry Mehrling’s legacy from @adam_tooze this morning, underlining how—as Perry understood—it’s really not an ‘our dollar/your problem’ world, and never has been. adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-478-money-and-empire-for
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
Hommage d’@adam_tooze à Perry Mehrling et Charles P. Kindleberger : pourquoi et comment la monnaie mondiale, ancrée sur le $, ne circule pas internationalement entre des Etats, mais globalement entre des bilans 1/.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-478-money-and-empire-for -
Adam Tooze reposted
Bruno Maçães
@MacaesBruno
Imagine what future historians and satirists will make of the collapse of the American regime. Makes Rome look so normal
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Was Carney taking the mick and doing Trump hand movements? @gideonrachman
Gideon Rachman
@gideonrachman
Whoever thought Carney would just be a technocratic prime minister should watch this. Perfect timing…
Scott Robertson
@sarobertson_
the crowd absolutely erupts when Carney says the Pacific Link pipeline will reduce Canada's dependence on the U.S.
Mark Carney: "Careful. They might think that's election interference. They're a little touchy down there. We're not. We're getting on with it." -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Link this is extraordinary report is here: www.diis.dk/en/research/congos-regional-war-circulation
Peer Schouten
@peer_schouten
So here it is:
Our new report on eastern Congo's roadblocks, which is actually about how the M23 conflict intersects with a regional trade war over access to eastern Congo's market.
It's also about beer, and how Heineken exited Congo.
A thread w/key findings, maps & figures: -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This looks fascinating @peer_schouten but where is the link to the main report? DIIS report 2026-07
Peer Schouten
@peer_schouten
So here it is:
Our new report on eastern Congo's roadblocks, which is actually about how the M23 conflict intersects with a regional trade war over access to eastern Congo's market.
It's also about beer, and how Heineken exited Congo.
A thread w/key findings, maps & figures: -
Adam Tooze reposted
Iñaki Aldasoro
@i_aldasoro
By a weird coincidence this just came out, as scheduled for the past weeks.
I managed to squeeze a mention to Perry’s passing and a dedication at the end of the acknowledgment note in the cover page right before it was scheduled to come out. A tiny homage
www.bis.org/publications/paper-175-money-and-architecture… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
Perry Mehrling's influence lives on.
Inaki Aldasoro of the BIS @i_aldasoro has a paper out today that draws heavily on his work. I was already poised to big it up, because, having digested it, I decided it was one of the best papers I have ever read on the architecture of money. A perfect synthesis of the many iterations of the money view, framed in the context of recent stablecoin developments (a key point of discussion between Perry and me).
This was before I learned of Perry's death.
It seems particularly poignant that it came out today. And I see Inaki has dedicated it to Perry's memory.
It is a brilliant paper. Please do read it.
www.thepeg.co/p/rip-perry-mehrling-the-grand-architect -
Adam Tooze reposted
Morgan Ricks
@MorganRicks1
During the financial crisis, at the Treasury Department, Perry Mehrling, Gary Gorton, and Paul Tucker were the three thinkers whose work was most useful in helping us reach a deeper understanding of the situation. Later, Perry was
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Terrible news. I loved getting to talk to Perry over the years. Someone with incredible range, depth and clarity. A major influence on my own thought, for sure. RIP.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Stefan Eich
@stefeich
Such terrible terrible news that Perry Mehrling has passed. Hard to describe how much he taught us all. And such a wonderfully curious interlocutor.
I recently returned to his brilliant & mischievous "Financialization and its discontents". Great primer. sites.bu.edu/perry/files/2019/04/Financialization-and-its… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What a loss. Woke up this morning thinking this can't be true. RIP Perry.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There is international econ - based on "island" view of world econ & then there is analysis of global financial network centered on $ - what @PMehrling in his lovely new book on Kindleberger calls a cosmopolitan view. See Chartbook #160 h/t @HyunSongShin
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-160-kindleberger-mehrling -
Adam Tooze reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
5/12 Mehrling (2006): interest rates cannot substitute for the credit system. Banks, liquidity, balance sheets, and monetary hierarchies matter. A theory that abstracts from these relationships may explain an interest-rate rule without explaining financial capitalism.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Rajiv Sethi
@rajivatbarnard
Some Recollections of Perry Mehrling
rajivsethi.substack.com/p/some-recollections-of-perry-meh… -
Adam Tooze reposted
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
Perry Mehrling, RIP.
According to the History of Economics Society, Perry Mehrling died "Monday night from injury sustained in a fall several days earlier." He was Professor of International Political Economy at Boston University and, previously, longtime Professor of Economics at Barnard College. He was a highly esteemed historian of economics.
Here is his homepage:
sites.bu.edu/perry/
His last book: "Money and Empire: Charles P. Kindleberger and the Dollar System"
www.amazon.com/Money-Empire-Kindleberger-Economic-Thinkin…
"Charles Kindleberger ranks as one of the twentieth century's best known and most influential international economists. This book traces the evolution of his thinking in the context of a 'key-currency' approach to the rise of the dollar system, here revealed as the indispensable framework for global economic development since World War II. Unlike most of his colleagues, Kindleberger was deeply interested in history, and his economics brimmed with real people and institutional details. His research at the New York Fed and BIS during the Great Depression, his wartime intelligence work, and his role in administering the Marshall Plan gave him deep insight into how the international financial system really operated. A biography of both the dollar and a man, this book is also the story of the development of ideas about how money works. It throws revealing light on the underlying economic forces and political obstacles shaping our globalized world."
Charles Goodhart: "The discipline of economics is balanced, somewhat unsteadily, between two legs, with the skill of the historian on one side and of the mathematical modeler on the other. In the second half of the 20th century, the tide flowed strongly to elevate the second leg and to diminish the first. In this delightful biography of Charlie Kindleberger, a charming and loveable man, Perry Mehrling shows how Charlie, in his chosen role, as an international monetary economist, fought against that tide, often unsuccessfully. Perry writes so beautifully that one would only need a smattering of economics to enjoy the tale; while if one is interested in the history of economic thought in international monetary economics, then this book is, of course, a must read.'
www.amazon.com/Money-Empire-Kindleberger-Economic-Thinkin… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joseph Wang
@josephwang
The jump in Canadian holdings of U.S. bonds may actually be due to China. A big mystery in the market is how China recycles its $1t trade surplus. In the past they bought Treasuries held through Belgium custodians, but some may be through Canadian custodians as well.
Bloomberg
@business
A mysterious surge in Canada's holdings of US bonds is spurring talk China has been shifting its portfolio around the world www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-14/china-s-backdo…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Charlie Bilello
@charliebilello
The most absurd number in CPI? According to the US Government, the cost of health insurance has declined 36% over the last 4 years...
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
"You wouldn't know it if you live in the USA or consume US media...but the fight between EVs and ICEs is basically over. Internal combustion is on it's way out. First it'll look slow, then fast. Fleet turnover will lag sales. But ALL the growth globally is in EVs." -@JesseJenkins
Nicolas Fulghum
@nicolasfulghum
NEW | EV Adoption is booming around the world
The Hormuz crisis once again revealed the risks of an energy system reliant on fossil fuels and countries are taking notice.
Growing EV fleets have saved oil importers more than $20 billion since the start of the war. -
Adam Tooze reposted
LiorLefineder
@lefineder
Shame how war used to be a private matter between gentlemen, and then people went and ruined it by getting everyone involved.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
LiorLefineder
@lefineder
In 225 BC, shortly before the 2nd Punic War, the Romans initiated a census of all "men fit to bear arms" among themselves and their allies in Italy.
Based on the figures from this census, reported in Polybius, here's the approximate ethnic distribution of Italy at the time (excluding Cisalpine Gaul): -
Adam Tooze reposted
Towards New Seas
@towardsnewseas
Deleuze
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Julius Betschka
@JuliusBetschka
Mach‘s gut, Bachkanal!
Nach dem heutigen Tag wird MDR Klassik eingestellt. Der Radiosender, den mein Opa hörte, zu dem ich zuletzt viele Texte geschrieben habe, eines der wenigen Radios, das klassische Musik nicht nur »zum Träumen und Entspannen« spielt, sondern ernst nimmt & über »Die kleine Nachtmusik« hinausdenkt.
MDR Klassik war der einzige Sender, der gezielt die im Wortsinn weltumstürzende Kulturgeschichte Mitteldeutschlands wach hielt, der sich genauso gezielt um alte Musik kümmerte. Kurz: Ausgerechnet in Zeiten, in denen die Besinnung auf das zivilisatorisch Wertvolle wichtiger wird, wird ein quicklebendiges Archiv, ein Leuchtturm dessen eingestellt.
Der Sender war, ganz sicher, eine Nische. Mir erscheint das am Leben halten dieser Nischen wichtiger denn je. Wenn das nicht Programmauftrag des ÖRR ist, was dann? Wir werden uns noch nach solchen Orten zurücksehnen.
Falls das jemand vom MDR-Klassik-Team liest: Sie haben wunderbares Radio gemacht. Danke dafür & farewell! 🫶🏼 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Will Solfiac
@willsolfiac
Obviously I know the reason, but it's an omission that the Omani empire isn't discussed together with the European colonial empires of the same period.
First fighting, and then defeating, the Portuguese in the Middle East and East Africa in the 17th century, then establishing a colonial economy in East Africa in the 18th and 19th centuries.
Ruling places like Mombasa and Zanzibar, with the latter hosting a slave plantation economy (producing cloves), and being the entrepot for a vast trade in slaves and ivory from the East African interior. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Aristocratic Fury
@LandsknechtPike
When you see how small war galleys were you understand why Venice wanted control over all these territories.
War galleys had to be resupplied in max 4 days and Venetian overseas territories were basically a chain of ports through which they could send war galleys far away.
Aristocratic Fury
@LandsknechtPike
Museu Marítim de Barcelona has a full scale replica of John of Austria's flagship Real at the Battle of Lepanto in 1571.
For the battle of Lepanto, this war galley would have been crowded with around 650-700 men (230-290 rowers and 400 soldiers). -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sama Hoole
@SamaHoole
For 60 years the blue tits of Britain broke into the milk on your doorstep, and all they ever took was the cream.
It was first seen in Swaythling, near Southampton, in 1921. A blue tit landed on a bottle, pecked through the cap and drank. By the 1950s every tit in the country seemed to know the trick. Housewives put out saucers, stones and upturned cups. The birds learned to follow the milk float down the street and be waiting at the next step.
You will remember the bottle. Silver foil on top, and beneath it 2 inches of thick yellow cream that had risen overnight, with the white milk underneath. The first one down in the morning got it on the porridge.
That cream was the whole point of the burglary. A bird cannot digest milk. It has no means of handling the sugar in it. Cream is nearly all fat, with very little sugar, so the tits drank down to the line and stopped.
A wild animal weighing 11 grams, with every bird table and berry bush in the street to choose from, worked out how to open a sealed container to get at butterfat.
Then the habit died, in about 10 years. Nobody trapped them or changed the caps. The milk changed. It was homogenised so the cream no longer rose, then skimmed so it was hardly there, then moved to a plastic jug in a supermarket.
The blue tits inspected the red top, found nothing in it worth stealing, and went back to the hedge.
They were the last creatures in Britain to judge a pint of milk on what was actually in it. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Antlion
@antlionai
The hippie trail was such a surreal thing that is almost unimaginable today.
People used to trip balls in Tehran and then be degens in Kabul and Lahore after driving through Iraq and Syria.
And it was just a thing people did over the summer, like going to Machu Picchu. -
Adam Tooze reposted
East Asia Econ
@eastasiaecon
1) Another rise in Korea's already-enormous current account surplus in August. It is now over 25% of GDP. That has several consequences, including...
-
Adam Tooze reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
Latest data point in the Germanisation of the Euro defense landscape
Half of Defense VC funding in Europe is for German startups -
Adam Tooze reposted
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The 2026 #nobelprize in Literature is awarded to the Canadian author Anne Carson, “for her bold and inventive oeuvre that, in playful dialogue with the classical tradition, has created new forms for contemporary literature.” -
Adam Tooze reposted
Chad Zimmerman
@chadzimmerman_
Phenomenal World Books officially publishes books
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Foreign Affairs
@ForeignAffairs
“For much of the past century, policymakers have treated the Horn of Africa and the Arabian Peninsula as separate strategic regions divided by the Red Sea. That distinction is now evaporating,” writes @alanboswell. www.foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/new-red-sea-wars
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
NEW RESEARCH: Pakistan's solar boom is one of the world's most impressive renewable deployment stories.
It is also a story about a broken grid, high electricity prices and inequality.
This is the first peer-reviewed paper to take a deep dive into it.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629626004871 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Princertitude
@princertitude
"-C'est pour quel lycée?
-Pablo Picasso à Fontenay-sous-Bois, Monsieur le Président" -
Adam Tooze reposted
Georg ‘Maverick’ Löfflmann
@gloefflmann
Wer hier noch nie mit einem Immoblienprojekt im Baltikum Pleite gegangen ist und bei polizeilichen Ermittlungen im Zuge der Kindesentführung bei einer Steakhaus-Dynastie in den Verdacht des Landesverrats mit Agententätigkeit für eine fremde Macht geraten ist, werfe den 1. Stein.
WELT
@welt
Warum Ex-BND-Präsident Hanning unter Spionageverdacht geriet www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/plus6ac4c39173cfe42b5b025…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
China is not just exporting more of everything.
China’s share of global exports has been declining in categories such as finished clothing, shoes, and bags.
Bert Hofman(郝福满)
@berthofmanecon
There is talk of a "China Squeeze" i.e. the argument that China, unlike others before, does not "shed" lower value products while moving up the value chain. This seems altogether incorrect. The chart below shows that there are plenty of less complex goods in which China's
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Left Nietzschean
@DevinGoure
From a Wittgensteinian perspective the AI consciousness debate is a philosophical nadir for culture. Virtually everything said about AI consciousness represents what Wittgenstein called the metaphysical use of language: words acting like an idling engine, doing no real work. 1/11
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Greg
@GregGrandin
Useful thread. TLDR: it’s agribusiness: “Where agribusiness carries more weight, Lula lost more. In municipalities where agribusiness accounts for more than half of the local economy, the typical drop was 8.8 percentage points; where it weighs less than 5%, it was 3.9”
Marco Antonio Faganello
@marcofaganello
Onde Lula perdeu votos entre o 1º turno de 2022 e o de 2026, e em que tipo de município? Cruzei o resultado das 5.570 cidades com dados do Censo 2022 e do PIB municipal. Dados do TSE ainda preliminares (05/10). Os principais achados, em 7 tweets.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
MaaikeDx 🖌
@RembrandtsRoom
45 years ago, 1981, Granada Television produced the Mother of all series: ‘Brideshead Revisited’, a tv series in eleven episodes based on the novel by Evelyn Waugh from 1945. With Jeremy Irons who became the "sex symbol for the intellectual woman". 🥰
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Другая планета
@nihilunbounded
Professor Tooze is hell-bent on putting together a team:
Batman v. Alien v. Predator v. Hannibal Lecter.
Not the polcrysis we needed, but the polycrisis we deserved. Thank you Professor Tooze.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Alien v. Predator or MAGA meets AI - a "crossover" monument to the USA at 250.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-456-alien-v-predator-or -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jens Nordvig
@jnordvig
Euro-Crisis II?
French bond spreads have widened more than in the Greek debt crisis of 2010 and also more than during the period of Spanish denomination risk concern in 2012.
Even compared to the most intense period of the Euro-crisis (the sovereign debt / bank nexus of 2011) the current spread widening in France is arguably faster.
In 2011, we had 104bp of widening in 106 days. But in 2016 we have had 67bp of widening in less than a month.
And I would argue that fundamentally the situation is more concerning than in the first Euro-Crisis (2010-2012).
First, France is a big country, and harder to bail out than Greece or other smaller countries.
Second, France's debt dynamics have deteriorated notably since the days of Euro-Crisis I, with debt to GDP now nearing 120%, compared to closer to 80% in 2009.
Third, European politics are even more unstable. The centrist parties (which previously provided a fiscal anchor) have shrunk or entirely disappeared, in both France and Germany, leaving a path to fiscal consolidation much harder to imagine.
Fourth, the competition for capital globally is much fiercer with AI related capital demands putting pressure on global bond markets. Further, with inflation above targets in most G7 economies, it is much harder for central banks to provide backstops for sovereigns.
Back in the first Euro-Crisis i wrote a book about all of this ("The Fall of the Euro: Reinventing the Future of the Eurozone"). The key message was: What allowed the Euro to survive back in 2010-2012 was the political will to keep it together (not any financial or debt metric or bank stat).
Hence, the key question is. Is the political will there now in 2026, and in the years to come, with a number of tricky elections around the corner? -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kurt S. Altrichter, CRPS®
@kurtsaltrichter
For the AI buildout to pay off, Americans will eventually have to spend about 9% of GDP a year on AI services. Sit with that number.
That is roughly what the entire country spends on food.
A Columbia paper presented at Brookings estimates AI revenue would need to hit $3.5 trillion by 2032, about 8.8% of GDP, to justify what is being committed today. That is bigger than any investment boom in US history, and 7 times what Americans spend on phone, streaming, and internet combined.
Now look at computers. Prices fell for 50 straight years, but business spending on them as a share of GDP plateaued in the 1980s and never climbed again. Cheaper and better did not mean an ever-larger slice of the economy.
AI will almost certainly raise productivity. Whether it delivers the revenue investors are pricing is another matter. That gap is what the buildout is underpricing. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reads beautifully in French too.
Paroles d'auteurs
@Paroles_auteurs
"Il existe une forme de tristesse qui naît du fait d'en savoir trop, de voir le monde tel qu'il est vraiment. C'est la tristesse de comprendre que la vie n'est pas une grande aventure, mais une succession de petits moments insignifiants, que l'amour n'est pas un conte de fées, mais une émotion fragile et fugace, que le bonheur n'est pas un état permanent, mais un aperçu rare et fugace de quelque chose auquel on ne peut jamais s'accrocher. Et dans cette compréhension se cache une profonde solitude, un sentiment d'être coupé du monde, des autres, de soi-même."
Virginia Woolf, Vers le phare -
Adam Tooze reposted
che capybara 🇵🇸
@vogon_laureate
According to Mélenchon, he was set on his present path at age 14 when his girlfriend gifted him an 8-volume history of the French Revolution
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joey Politano 🏳️🌈
@JosephPolitano
Sort of insane fact about how broken US urban planning is—America now spends more building *just the lights for roads and highways* than on all subways & ground mass transit combined
Spending on roadway *pavement* is 18x transit spending -
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
.@adam_tooze contre les démons de l’analogie historique: Non, l'IA n'est pas comparable au projet Manhattan. Ce qui est radicalement nouveau dans la menace actuelle , c'est son économie politique: elle est issue de la privatisation de l’action publique
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-477-against-historic-n… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
France is the Biggest Loser in the Global Rates Reset
theovershoot.co/p/france-is-the-biggest-loser-in-the
In much of the rich world, the uptick in the cost of capital corresponds to a relatively benign change in (nominal) growth trajectories. This is less true for Europe, and especially for France. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
Higher education is facing a serious crisis. Enrollment is starting to crater. The public has lost faith in the value of our institution.
Business as usual is not an option. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
"What matters about Brazil, right now; and, how should the rest of the world understand the events unfolding this month?"
Hugely consequential elections in Brazil that you've probably wanted to read more about, this is excellent.
ht @OrangoQuango
www.northsouthnotes.org/p/how-to-watch-brazil-this-month -
Adam Tooze reposted
Greg Ip
@greg_ip
To justify today's AI capex, we'll have to spend 9% of GDP on AI services, a study finds. Is it plausible we'll spend as much on AI as on food? Twice as much as on energy? The law of diminishing returns would like a word. My column: www.wsj.com/tech/ai/will-america-spend-9-of-its-gdp-on-ai…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavi Ruiz
@xruiztru
Brazil alone accounts for around half of South America’s total GDP, more than all the rest of the continent’s economies combined.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Oh, it's Critical Macrofinance time again.
A reminder - French government bonds (OATs) are not just fiscal instruments but also prop up 10% of EUR 13 trillion repo market.
@ecb will have to do defensive derisking OAT purchases via TPI or other instrument
Alexandre Baradez
@ABaradez
⚠️ça continue de se tendre sur le spread OAT🇫🇷-Bund🇩🇪
Il dépasse désormais 150 bps 🔥 -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Adler
@davidrkadler
Holy shit 🇧🇷 In an UNPRECEDENTED move, the United States suspends ALL embassy services in all American consulates in Brazil… with no justification whatsoever. Yet another fear-stoking effort to interfere in the country’s democratic elections this weekend.
Renato Souza
@reporterenato
ATENÇÃO: Estados Unidos suspende serviços da embaixada do país em Brasília e em todos os consulados norte-americanos no país. Comunicado cita questões de segurança, mas não detalha o motivo. Decisão inédita atinge também escritórios em São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, Recife e Porto Alegre. A suspensão dos serviços consulares já está em vigor.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
🏘️ 🏗️ 🇫🇷 Mémoire2Ville 🌆 🚧Sagacité 🏗️ 🏘️
@Memoire2cite
Camping vintage à l'ancienne en norvege avec toiles de tente, et caravanes voitures Triumph Herald, Simca 1000, Hillman Minx années 70
-
Adam Tooze reposted
John Ganz
@lionel_trolling
I found a Soviet primer on dialectical materialism, and this was the note of a previous owner inside
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Christopher Hale
@ChristopherHale
NEW: According to a bombshell report in the New York Times, Anthropic co-founder Chris Olah threatened to walk out of Pope Leo XIV’s AI encyclical launch in May because the pope rejected the idea that machines can be conscious.
Olah’s team then privately lobbied the pope’s advisers “to take the possibility of model consciousness seriously.” Pope Leo XIV held firm.
For months, Anthropic has wined and dined theologians and religious scholars under nondisclosure agreements, hoping they would bless the idea that Claude has moral standing. www.thelettersfromleo.com/p/nyt-anthropic-nearly-walked-o… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Our World in Data
@OurWorldInData
The world faces two energy problems: hundreds of millions lack access to energy, and most of our energy still produces greenhouse gas emissions.
The first energy problem of the world is the problem of energy poverty. People in very poor countries have very low emissions. The reason that the emissions of the poor are low is that they lack access to modern energy and technology. When people lack access to modern energy sources for cooking and heating, they rely on solid fuel sources — mostly firewood, but also dung and crop waste. This comes at a massive cost to the health of people in energy poverty. The reliance on fuelwood is also the reason why poverty is linked to deforestation.
The second energy problem is the one that is more well-known: greenhouse gas emissions are too high. The problem is larger for the extremely rich, but it is not limited to them. People need access to energy for a good life. However, in a world where fossil fuels are the dominant source of energy, access to modern energy means that carbon emissions are too high.
Once we look at it this way, it becomes clear that the twin energy problems are really the two sides of one big problem. We lack large-scale energy alternatives to fossil fuels that are cheap, safe, and sustainable. Until we scale up those alternatives, the world will continue to face the two energy problems of today. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jean Christopher (Chris) Mittelstaedt
@jcmittelstaedt
Super interesting new book
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Callinicos @alexcallinicos.bsky.social
@alex_callinicos
@adam_tooze on the AI apocalypse
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Julius Kölzer
@Julius_Ktxt
Gerade emotionaler Moment an der Edeka-Kasse: „Hier ist ihr Kassenbon, aber haben nicht Sie die Berlin-Wahl auf Twitter eingeordnet?“ Vielen Dank im Namen der ganzen Stadt. Alle haben geklatscht.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
derek guy
@dieworkwear
Nobel Prize economist Daron Acemoglu has been doing a series of daily posts about AI. I've found them very useful in thinking about the issues. Worth reading and following, I think.
Daron Acemoglu
@DAcemogluMIT
Third question on AI.
A question that also remains unasked is whether the AI boom can continue without leading to a massive increase in inequality.
A recent paper by Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh runs the numbers on how much revenue the AI industry needs to generate to recover its massive investment (summary and a link to the paper can be found here: www.brookings.edu/articles/financing-the-ai-buildout/).
Van Nieuwerburgh’s arithmetic should make us more concerned. AI investments will average about 3.6% of GDP annually between 2025 and 2032. Van Nieuwerburgh calculates that, using a 10% rate of return, the industry would need to generate annual revenues of about $3.7 trillion by 2032 to recover these costs (growing from its current levels of about $200 billion or so). That is significantly more than 10% of current US national income, and will likely remain around 10% of national income by 2032, even if GDP growth rose from its current level.
A large fraction of this revenue will go to capital income. That means a massive increase in the share of capital in national income, which has already risen substantially over the last 25 years or so – now standing at an all-time high of about 47% (www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/prod2.pdf).
Capital income is much more unequally distributed than labor income, so a massive increase in the capital share of national income will translate into a very sizable surge in inequality.
The rise in inequality may not stop with the capital share. My work with Pascual Restrepo documents that (automation-driven) increases in the capital share of national income are typically associated with rising labor income inequality as well (see, for example, economics.mit.edu/sites/default/files/2022-10/Tasks Autom…). The same may happen in the next several years, boosting inequality further.
What is missing from our current debate is any discussion of a fundamental dilemma these numbers pose: can the AI boom avoid both an economically costly crash and a huge increase in inequality?
If the industry reaches these revenues, inequality surges. If the industry does not become profitable, a crash, with substantial costs in terms of lost output and jobs, becomes likely.
My assessment would be that the industry is unlikely to reach levels of revenue Van Nieuwerburgh calculates. First, diffusion has been and will likely continue to be slow. Second, competition from open-weight models, which are getting better, will limit how much proprietary models can charge. Third, despite important advances, I still believe that AI models will not be able to automate entire occupations anytime soon, thus limiting their value to businesses as cost-saving devices.
Whether this leads to a crash or not is more complicated and will depend on whether various AI companies are bailed out and what kind of support they receive.
Nevertheless, even if revenues fall short of these gargantuan amounts and we avoid a dramatic surge in inequality, I expect that the diffusion of AI will push up inequality between capital and labor and within labor.
If inequality does surge, a further question becomes central: can our democracy survive such astronomical levels of inequality? -
Adam Tooze reposted
deniz
@gun3ro
this is the only right answer. VPNs are not reliable. eSim are the way to go, then make hotspots with the phone to get unblocked internet on the laptop
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @Brad_Setser fascinating stuff. Would one be right in inferring that Chinese private flows into us equities, the type of thing we see for Europe, are negligible?
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Want to understand the impact of Chinese capital flows on the global economy? Don't start with China's formal reserves, which haven't changed in 10 years. Look at the over $3.5 trillion in cumulative outflows via the banks (the banks are the main buyers of foreign bonds)
1/ -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The anti-Draghi AfD rears its head!
Aleksandar Djokic (Александар Джокич)
@polidemitolog
Germany's AfD is encouraging separatism in Italy's South Tyrol, unsettling Italy's far right, El País reported. The German party recently hosted a conference in parliament on the region, while AfD youth leaders have appeared alongside South Tyrolean separatists calling for independence from Italy. Italy's Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani condemned the initiative as "very serious" and called AfD "anti-Italian".
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Felix Hamer • electricfelix
@electricfelix
“EV charging in China was 17.2 TWh in August, up 51.2% year-on-year.
That's equivalent to ~1.3 million barrels of oil a day, in a global oil market that shifts about 100m bpd.
Just the change from last year cuts global oil demand by 0.5m bpd.”
⚡️⚡️⚡️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Zachary Foster
@_ZachFoster
Ilan Pappe has a new piece out titled, "Why Al-Aqsa Flood Happened."
In it, he argues that Yahya Sinwar confronted Israel similar to how Anwar Sadat confronted Israel in 1971 & Palestinian leaders such as Yasser Arafat in 2000.
Sadat warned that if Israel did not return the Sinai to Egypt through diplomacy, Egypt would go to war...
Arafat warned Ehud Barak & Bill Clinton that if he was unable to return from the Camp David summit in 2000 with a promise to reduce the oppression of the Palestinian people, another uprising would be inevitable...
In Sinwar’s case, we now know that he negotiated with Israel the basic demands of the people of Gaza: an end to the siege, an increase in the food and raw materials entering the besieged enclave, and the release of Palestinian political prisoners.
(This was revealed in a Sep. 2026 @haaretzcom investigation which showed that, in September 2023, Sinwar arranged a private meeting with Fatah official Coal Eyes. "Tell the Israelis that if they don't make progress, I'm preparing a huge surprise for them," he declared emphatically. Here, he dropped a key word for the first time, one that should have triggered red flags: "Tell them to expect a 'zilzal,' an earthquake." www.haaretz.com/israel-news/israel-security/2026-09-08/ty…)
Pappe argues that, like Sadat, Sinwar eventually chose the military option when it became clear that Israel had rejected the political option.
source: www.palestinechronicle.com/why-al-aqsa-flood-happened-rev…
If Americans Knew
@ifamericansknew
Why Hamas Attacked Israel in October 2023 – Israeli professor Ilan Pappé.
Hamas had negotiated with Israel for an end to the 17-year siege strangling Gaza, an increase in food entering Gaza, & release of Palestinian political prisoners. The Israeli army advised Netanyahu to respond to these demands with an all-out attack on Gaza. Al-Aqsa Flood was an attempt to preempt this attack.
This was a breakout from the ghetto by a people who had suffered thousands of deaths, tens of thousands of injuries among children and women, and hundreds of thousands of people losing their homes in the 2014 Israeli assault and remaining displaced in 2023; they were a traumatized population subjected to starvation as a matter of policy during the seventeen-year Israeli blockade and to frequent bombardment from the air, land, and sea.
israelpalestinenews.org/why-hamas-attacked-israel-in-octo… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
New at THE OVERSHOOT:
The Fed Finally Gets It
theovershoot.co/p/the-fed-finally-gets-it
Tariffs, Hormuz, and fiscal policy are not good reasons to hike. The underlying growth trend and the asymmetric sensitivity of private sector spending to the level of interest rates are.
Plus: margin debt! -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
I had not realised before that the Bronze Age Collapse was literally *caused* by iron.
Bronze age powers like the Egyptians, Hittites and Babylonians used bronze weapons, made by combining copper and tin. Tin was so scarce that only the richest and most powerful groups could access it and the bronze weapons it allowed. (Tin was so rare that it was being transported from Cornwall to the Middle East more than 1000 years BC.) The scarcity of tin gave these empires a near-monopoly on violence.
Iron weapons are not actually any better than bronze ones – they're not stronger or easier to work with, as I'd assumed. They're just much, much easier to mass produce once you have bloomeries, which are the first furnaces that were hot enough to melt iron in a way that made them useable for weapons.
Bloomeries meant that iron ore, which was widespread, could be used to make weapons anywhere. That led to warlords, bandits and city-states rising in a massive decentralization of military power, which the Bronze Age empires were unable to resist.
After the invention of the bloomery, skeletons show a measurable increase in weapon-inflicted injuries. 'Destruction layers' with bones and signs of burning have been found from this time at archaeological sites including Troy. Ancient writers – including Herodotus, Ovid, and the writers of the Old Testament – believed the invention of iron had unleashed a new age of violence.
New at Works in Progress, WEAPONS OF MASS DECENTRALIZATION: how iron itself brought about the Bronze Age Collapse. And what technologies could do the same today?
worksinprogress.co/issue/weapons-of-mass-decentralization -
Adam Tooze reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
The depth of Israel's international isolation is difficult to fathom if you're just watching mainstream media.
But these images do not lie. Look at all these delegates leaving the General Assembly in protest as soon as Netanyahu takes the podium...This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
The difference between the performance of immigrants in England + W Europe is staggering. (20 pts equals a year of learning.)
I look at this in detail in the post - it can't be explained away by language or relative advantage. There is a policy factor.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
New post out:
England's schools are now the second highest performing in the world outside the far east, according to the PISA study.
Is this because of policy? Attitude to technology? Cultural factors like immigration? And where can we still improve?
samf.substack.com/p/why-englands-schools-are-doing-so?r=7… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Trent Kannegieter
@trentkann
Thanks @adam_tooze for including my Yale Law Journal piece on a technical theory of AI liability in today’s Chartbook Top Links.
The last few weeks have confirmed that liability will be key to AI governance. Many are calling for regulation after the Hugging Face incident, but the Trump Administration doesn’t look willing to offer any.
That leaves courts. But for claims to stick, they need to be specific about how LLM-based products actually work and why defendants who put these products into safety-critical systems should have known better. That's been missing so far.
Getting technically specific about how LLM-based products work fills that key gap. It explains the engineering reasons that the designers of these products should have expected these harms to occur if they don’t add enough guardrails to their products. Sometimes, the design itself is defective: The harms occur even when the product works just as intended. That doesn’t make a product bad, but it does mean that the producer should pay for the costs.
Another added benefit to this approach is it helps set a clear standard for innovators. Companies understandably don’t want a legal environment with lots of ambiguity! They need clear, predictable rules that let them build without worrying about lawsuits.
In the next few years, my bet is that everyone talking about the "law of AI" will have to get this technically specific. Lots more open questions remain to be solved. Getting into the weeks will be necessary to do so.
Check out Adam's post here: substack.com/home/post/p-214659850
And check out my full piece here: yalelawjournal.org/note/nondeterministic-torts-a-technica…
@YaleLJournal -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
After the dollar as reserve currency, the (profit) dollar as a “portfolio currency”.
Riffing on some great exchanges btw @Karl_Schamotta & @Brad_Setser
adamtooze.substack.com/publish/post/216649356 -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Broder
@broderly
Remember, it's Die Linke's democratic duty to back a red-red-green coalition in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern to defend democracy from fascism, whereas the same coalition in Berlin (but headed by Die Linke) would be a vile, openly antisemitic regime
Kai Whittaker
@Kai_Whittaker
Unabhängig von den schlechten Ergebnissen meiner Partei, müssen sich nun SPD und Grüne entscheiden, ob sie in Berlin erstmals einer offen antisemitischen Partei an die Macht verhelfen.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Outrageous vandalism at Edinburgh uni
Emile Chabal
@emile_chabal
The programme I run, the MSc in Contemporary History, is one of those that will be axed. The bonfire of the universities has truly come for Edinburgh.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Philippa Sigl-Glöckner
@PhilippaSigl
Twitter-Gold
Julius Kölzer
@Julius_Ktxt
Es gibt Mecklenburg-Vorpommern. Aber es gibt auch Mecklenburg und Vorpommern. Wie wir heute Abend voraussichtlich wieder sehen werden, unterscheiden sich beide Regionen deutlich in ihrem Wahlverhalten. Woher kommen diese Unterschiede? Ein Thread. 🧵
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Tutt
@TuttReal
Damn. There is audio of Thomas Mann's 1947 lecture at the Library of Congress on "Nietzsche's philosophy in the light of contemporary events." Just requested it 🤞
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
Kitty map! This is how cats migrated to Europe. Great little writeup in the post too: vividmaps.com/how-cats-migrated-to-europe/
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David Edgerton
@DEHEdgerton
At the launch of Rise and Fall of the British Nation in Chinese translation in Beijing!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Simon Evans
@DrSimEvans
ELECTRIFICATION: Really striking chart showing that three-quarters of final energy demand can now be electrified "economically" (ie at lower lifetime cost) – and 90% electrification is technically possible
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
funny!
Alister
@SchnockRevue
Je sais reconnaître quelqu’un qui fait semblant de bosser en prenant un air pénétrant tout simplement parce que ce fut ma principale activité durant les vingt premières années de ma vie.
Et ça c’en est un. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Colin McCarthy
@US_Stormwatch
The Colorado River crisis will be a defining moment in US history. The river supplies 40 million people; Mead and Powell, two of the nation’s largest reservoirs, are at record lows.
Filling them near full would take ~8 consecutive very wet winters, a statistical impossibility. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
Very cool: The Pinglu Canal in Guangxi is now open, connecting provincial capital Nanning with the Gulf of Tonkin, avoiding 560 km detour through Guangdong. First major Chinese canal since 1949!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David Grossman
@davidgross_man
The stadium crowd waiting for Ed Sheeran has grown confused as Johnny Greenwood's set focuses on his collaborative work with Krystof Penderecki, "48 Responses to Polymorphia"
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Emily Dische-Becker
@Emilydische
Merz's disapproval rating of 88% is apparently the second highest for a western leader in recorded polling history. Francois Hollande hit a 90% disapproval but still had a concurrent higher approval rating than Merz does today
Emily Dische-Becker
@Emilydische
Merz is cartoonishly unlikeable – he has a kind of two-dimensional blundering arrogance, you can see him walking smack into walls and through wet cement while chasing little kids to get off his miserable lawn where even the grass recoils at his presence
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicolas Sawaya
@sawaya_nicolas
One of the most revealing statistics that highlights how Israel operates is the % of destruction wrought on Lebanon pre vs post (first) ceasefire on April 16 2026: "65 per cent of destruction indicators occurred after 16 April, compared with around a third before it".
Nicolas Sawaya
@sawaya_nicolas
You'll notice that despite multiple "ceasefires", Israel continues its attacks in Lebanon, even when Hizballah completely ceases its attacks.
For Israel, a "ceasefire" means you cease, we (continue to) fire. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
A truly fantastic new Modern Intellectual History article by Alexander Zevin on why empire went missing from the so called French liberal revival of the 1970s: "Ferry Retrouvé: Leaving the History of Empire Out of the “Liberal Moment” in France": www.cambridge.org/core/journals/modern-intellectual-histo…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Weber
@OliverBWeber
Ja, hier: www.faz.net/-3bsp2c?share=Twitter&gift&premium=0x75a30b69…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
precisely
Jonas Junack
@JonasJunack
Spannend! Wenn rechtspop. Parteien nicht auf das Migrationsthema angewiesen sind, sondern sich auf Basis einer Elitenkritik konstituieren (die sich in diversen Themenfeldern Bahn brechen kann), dann erscheint die von der AfD getriebene Politik der Zentrumsparteien noch hilfloser.
Luis Guirola
@lm_guirola
I have finally tried to sketch my view of how AfD vote is (unlikely to be) related to a stricter immigration policy lmguirola.substack.com/p/would-a-stricter-immigration-pol…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This seems right to me!
Luis Guirola
@lm_guirola
I have finally tried to sketch my view of how AfD vote is (unlikely to be) related to a stricter immigration policy lmguirola.substack.com/p/would-a-stricter-immigration-pol…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Isaac Scher
@isaacscher
"If gun-toting special operators appear as a modern Frankenstein, this is our monster." Nice capsule history from @adam_tooze. www.ft.com/content/a269a24a-04ea-4166-a978-bee35f094f08
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
You could just feel it all cascading over Labor Day
Evan Gorelick
@EvanGorelick
Scoop: Obama implored Democratic leaders to move A.I. oversight to the center of the party's agenda, warning during a private fundraiser this past week that the technology could be “dangerous” if they do not get on top of it. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/13/us/politics/obama-democrats-ai…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Andrew Curran
@AndrewCurran_
Twenty-five Fields Medal winners have published a joint declaration warning about what they see as a severe misalignment between AI companies and the mathematics community.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Remarkable data on preferences of far-right AfD voters in Germany courtesy of @schieritz & @Julius_Ktxt & AI translation featured in today's chartbook newsletter. Deep concerns about the economy ....
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-474-the-state-is-the-p…Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Or "big government" ... This is best understood neither as incoherence or a narrow petty bourgeois class interest, but a coherent rejection of "the system" which cannot be trusted to fix urgent problems without radical change.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What gives the AfD its credibility as an anti-systemic force is not any socio-economic promise, but its open racism and xenophobia and its culture war attitude. As argued in chartbook 473 adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-473-germanys-democratic
and today's 474
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-474-the-state-is-the-p…
and explored on @OnesandToozePod
open.spotify.com/episode/40C32weFruoIIApaSRfOeG -
Adam Tooze reposted
Alister
@SchnockRevue
Georges Pompidou et Léopold Sédar Senghor en khâgne au lycée Louis-le-Grand en 1931
#schnockarchives
~ˏˋ Y@ki ˊˎ˗
@Yakiseo
Instant Schnock du jour …
Pompidou - Sedar Senghor -
Adam Tooze reposted
talmon joseph smith
@talmonsmith
what's funny is 'Men Have Gained NO JOBS Since Trump Took Office' sounds so hyperbolic -- but nope. there it is, on net:
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Financial Times
@FT
FT exclusive: The IMF dropped the lead candidate to become its new chief economist at the eleventh hour after he was found to have made critical remarks about the Trump administration’s economic policies, according to people briefed on the process ft.trib.al/L3JKoT8
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Julius Kölzer
@Julius_Ktxt
2024 haben wir argumentiert, dass Wahlkarten die Stärke der AfD in Ostdeutschland verzerren: Sie erscheint fast überall als stärkste Kraft, erreicht aber meist nur relative Mehrheiten um die 35 %. Zwei Jahre später sind vielerorts aus relativen Mehrheiten absolute geworden.
Julius Kölzer
@Julius_Ktxt
Blaue Wahlkarten prägen die mediale Berichterstattung zu Wahlerfolgen der AfD. Vor den Landtagswahlen zeigen @pluggedchris, @KuhlenDaniel, @SiefkenLeon und ich in einem Beitrag für @dvpw, warum diese Karten oft trügerische Eindrücke vermitteln können. 🧵👇shorturl.at/J7hQ5
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kim-Mai Cutler
@kimmaicutler
“She estimated that the average student tested in China was more than five years ahead of American students in math, and three years ahead in science.”
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
New PISA results are out. Here is what the NYT says:
“The reading scores of American 15-year-olds have fallen sharply since 2022 and are near their lowest point in 25 years” -
Adam Tooze reposted
🔴 Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung
@rosaluxstiftung
👉 Den ganzen Kommentar von Anika Taschke kostenlos auf unserer Webseite lesen: www.rosalux.de/news/id/55194/sachsen-anhalt-politiklabor-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tariq Ali
@TariqAli_News
The situation in Germany reflects the state of Europe as a whole: disintegrating extreme centre parties, budgets designed for the ultra-rich, collapsing social infrastructures and a huge decline in educational standard. That is what I argue in more detail on my substack on 'Turbulence in Germany.'
substack.com/home/post/p-214648935 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jeet Heer
@HeerJeet
One crucial take-away is that AfD is harvesting anti-system rage, which means the establishment attempt to stigmatize them as a threat to fundamentally sound system is actually counterproductive: it only reinforces AfD claim that the only choice is far right or the failed system. The true challenge to AfD has to be from another anti-system party.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reflecting on the political earthquake in Germany and the question of an "alternative to the Alternative (fD)"
Latest chartbook newsletter just dropped. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-473-germanys-democratic -
Adam Tooze reposted
Berthold Seliger
@BertholdSeliger
Ligetis „Le Grand Macabre“ beim Musikfest Berlin: Die große Unordnung, mit denkwürdigen Verbindungen in die Gegenwart. Mein Text im Feuilleton von @ndaktuell
@blnfestspiele @Yle_Rso @nicholascollon
Also starring: @NesrineMalik @adam_tooze
www.nd-aktuell.de/artikel/1202347.musikfest-berlin-le-gra… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
extraordinary account of the shock therapy that CDU/West Germany inflicted on East Germany post 1989. Made me wonder about the neat identity Vs material benefits account of AfD success from
@adam_tooze
Le Monde diplomatique 🖋
@mdiplo
En Saxe-Anhalt, cette crise politique possède une généalogie : « l’unification » de 1990, la liquidation industrielle et la mise sous tutelle de l’Est.
Pour comprendre ce 44%, nous republions cet article.
www.monde-diplomatique.fr/2019/11/KNAEBEL/60911 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Julius Kölzer
@Julius_Ktxt
Auch die gestrige Chartbook-Ausgabe von @adam_tooze zur AfD-Wahl und zu linker Wirtschaftspolitik ist sehr spannend.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reflecting on the political earthquake in Germany and the question of an "alternative to the Alternative (fD)"
Latest chartbook newsletter just dropped. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-473-germanys-democratic -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jana Hensel
@jana_hensel
Danke, lieber @adam_tooze, für die freundliche Erwähnung. Genau so ist es, schauen wir auf die Zahlen, können wir sehen, dass der Abschied von Teilen der Ostdeutschen von der Parteiendemokratie schon vor 20 Jahren begann. Und zwar mit der Einführung von Hartz IV.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Adam Tooze on two important points -- the impact of the China shock on not yet deindustrialized Europe, and the complexities created by a world where China doesn't want its surplus to flow directly into Treasuries ...
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Harrowell
@yorksranter
as it appears to be "Why Sachsen-Anhalt Means You Must Support My Politics" day, here is an excellent thread on German opinion research into the AfD. Shorter: they are not clamouring for more welfare state
Julius Kölzer
@Julius_Ktxt
Ende letzter Woche gab es Kritik an diesem Post. Ich habe deshalb nochmals Befunde zu sozial- und wirtschaftspolitischen Einstellungen der AfD-Wählerschaft zusammengetragen. Ebenfalls habe ich zu diesem Thema Surveydaten der GLES und des Allbus ausgewertet. Ein langer Thread.🧵
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Sir Norman of Nowhere. 🏴☠️
@Normanjam67
This seems relevant today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Spoof appeal calling for the construction of an antifascist protective wall (the old GDR name for the Berlin wall) to protect old WEST germany v. the East.
Martin Sonneborn
@MartinSonneborn
Die PARTEI hat ihre Sonntagsdemonstrationen bereits gestartet... PopulismusSmiley!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reflecting on the political earthquake in Germany and the question of an "alternative to the Alternative (fD)"
Latest chartbook newsletter just dropped. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-473-germanys-democratic -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
OMG! Soeder's bedroom poster of FJS!
Markus Söder
@Markus_Soeder
Heute wäre der 111. Geburtstag von Franz Josef Strauß. Sein Leitspruch „Bayern ist meine Heimat, Deutschland mein Vaterland, Europa meine Zukunft" begleitet mich bis heute. Er bleibt unvergessen als politischer Visionär und Vater des modernen Bayerns. Er hat Bayern stark gemacht, und war der Grund, warum ich in die CSU eingetreten bin.
P.S.: Dieses Poster von ihm hing damals über meinem Bett. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Erin Burnett
@ErinBurnett
This is consistent with Trump’s truth social posts. In this case, it’s also important to consider that people who work for the President of the United States are rewarded for such posts.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
In brightest day, in blackest night, no evil shall escape my sight. Let those who worship evil's might beware my power... Green Lantern's light!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jonas Junack
@JonasJunack
Generationengerechtigkeit war immer schon ein Instrument, um Kürzungen und Einsparungen in der Gegenwart durchzusetzen.
Andreas Rinke
@Andreas__Rinke
Statt "Wohlstand für alle" will der Kanzler "Wohlstand für alle Generationen" - eine Art neuen Generationenvertrag. Und: "Nach diesen Landtagswahlen möchte ich, dass die CDU Deutschlands eine grundsätzliche Diskussion über die Frage führt, was macht uns eigentlich aus?" 3/6
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Its interesting in this @infratestdimap polling on Sachsen-Anhalt voters how the two prompts with Sicherheit (security) #1 & #3 play off each other! Internal security, migration, social (or is it societal?) security all resonate with each other in the top three. @IsabellaMWeber www.tagesschau.de/inland/innenpolitik/umfragen-afd-landta…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I am not sure I agree @IsabellaMWeber Both of those are too benign. I think this sounds much more like "society must be defended" tbh.
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
I didn’t provide a good translation. Thanks for pointing out @adam_tooze! Social welfare or economic security might be better translations.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @IsabellaMWeber don't you think that "Soziale Sicherheit" - not the same common or garden term as "social security" in the US - probably connotes something rather more ominous for potential AfD voters?
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Neoliberals portray social security spending as spoiling the people. In fact, it’s democracy’s self-defense. Your dignity should not depend on how much money you make. That’s why we need a mind shift in economics.
Social security is the #1 concern for voters in Saxony-Anhalt. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @IsabellaMWeber don't you think that "Soziale Sicherheit" - not the same common or garden term as "social security" in the US - probably connotes something rather more ominous for potential AfD voters?
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Neoliberals portray social security spending as spoiling the people. In fact, it’s democracy’s self-defense. Your dignity should not depend on how much money you make. That’s why we need a mind shift in economics.
Social security is the #1 concern for voters in Saxony-Anhalt. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Europe Elects
@EuropeElects
Germany, 92.3% of electoral districts counted:
Saxony-Anhalt regional parliament election
AfD (ESN): 45.0% (+24.2)
CDU (EPP): 16.7% (-20.4)
SPD (S&D): 9.0% (+0.6)
GRÜNE (Greens/EFA): 8.8% (+2.9)
LINKE (LEFT): 8.4% (-2.6)
BSW (NI): 5.2% (+5.2)
FDP (RE): 2.5% (-3.9)
FW (RE): 1.2% (-1.9)
Tierschutz (LEFT): 1.1% (-0.3)
Garten (*): 0.6% (-0.2)
Tierallianz (*): 0.6% (+0.1)
Volt (Greens/EFA): 0.3% (+0.3)
PARTEI (NI): 0.3% (-0.4)
PdF (RE): 0.2% (+0.2)
Basis (*): 0.1% (-1.4)
+/- vs. Last election result
➤ europeelects.eu/germany -
Adam Tooze reposted
Don Winslow
@donwinslow
For Republicans, this is called an INCONVENIENT FACT.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kerri Bitsoff
@kerri_bitsoff
1/ Hizballah's own statements and documents show what Iran's collapse is doing to its most important proxy. Hizballah’s bank, AQAH, has spent the last few months selling its collateral and defaulting on what it owes civilians while it protects its fighters' paychecks. The money was short before Iran's economy buckled: Tehran planned to send half the $2 billion Hizballah asked for per @kann_news. Now Iran can barely move what little it promised. 🧵
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Assaad Razzouk
@AssaadRazzouk
For the 1st time in modern industrial history, a sharp decline in oil consumption (not coal) drove an overall reduction in China's CO2 emissions, which fell 1% year-on-year in Q2 2026 despite coal-fired power generation rebounding
>Trigger: the Strait of Hormuz crisis. China's oil imports crashed 32%, consumption fell 9% overall and 16% in transport. Yet mobility is up: freight tonnage rose 2.4%, urban trips rose 2.9%
>The shock landed on a system already primed to absorb it
>EV charging volumes surged 60% in Q2
>Electric heavy-truck sales jumped 77% YoY, hitting 45%+ of new heavy-truck sales
>EVs alone displaced 19m tons of oil in the quarter (+50% YoY) and 36m tons in H1, already more than the UK burns in half a year
>If H2 keeps pace, China's 2026's EV oil displacement will hit 80m tons: about all of Mexico's annual consumption
Oil demand is being structurally hollowed out. Once road transport electrifies, oil doesn’t decline gradually, it drops off a cliff. The terminal decline of crude is well on its way
cleantechnica.com/2026/09/02/analysis-chinas-co2-emission… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
@BMarchetich, @DrDuncanBell; @njtmulder ; @adam_tooze ; @stefeich
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Crazy chart from the amazing Michael Cembalest of JP Morgan.
6% of GDP US current account deficit here we come ... -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @michaelxpettis I like this formulation of global balance as an arm-wrestling match and your point about Chinese agency is well taken, but whereas you tend to think of policy in the USA and China as relatively unitary and motivated in conventional macro-policy ways e.g. in those passages about the Fed or fiscal policy adjusting to unemployment, I think my view rests on the assumption that the US is a plural, not to say incoherent, actor, and the fiscal side in the US has a logic of its own which we might think of as targeting not so much the fiscal balance as tax rates and perhaps the gap btw pre-tax & post-tax gini (i.e. the degree of redistribution) plus a perennial "screw the Dems" impulse on the part of the GOP and loyalty to Trump. Only in exceptional circumstances i.e. 2008 and 2020-2021 is your standard unemployment-driven reaction function operative. In part because, as in China, there are structural limits to welfare policy and no sensible national system of unemployment insurance i.e. relatively few automatic stabilizers.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
I think its an implicit claim. The global balance must balance. Unless it is just a series of coincidences that keep S - I in one economy always exactly equal to I- S in the other, then one must drive the other. To simplify, either the US imbalance drives the Chinese imbalance, or the Chinese imbalance drives the US imbalance. I would argue that as a rule, countries that exert more control over their external accounts drive imbalances in countries that exert less control.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @michaelxpettis thanks for this excellent exchange and thanks for spelling out for me your thinking as clearly as this and highlighting the underlying Keynesian "indirect" logic by which the identity is fulfilled. I fully appreciate the need to think through such feedback loops and the fact that the accounts must balance. BUT where I think our agreement lies is in the way you incorporate the reaction function of US policy. You restate the case here: “But while the central bank and fiscal authorities won’t respond directly to an increase in capital inflows, they do respond to the rises in unemployment. They can do so through monetary easing or larger fiscal deficits. Debt, whether household or fiscal, is negative saving, so the internal imbalance can instead adjust through an increase in negative saving. This prevents unemployment from rising by creating new demand to replace the manufacturing demand that has flowed abroad.” (MP) To me, this does not seem like a plausible account of US policy on the fiscal side. This is where I do think that “contingent” and “accidental” forces do come into play. On my view the coincidence of US fiscal deficits and Chinese development policy in the 2000s is a coincidence. A “happy” and self-reinforcing one at first - happy because it helps to offset the impact of China shock 1.0 in the US and self-reinforcing because it sets the recycling mechanisms in motion. In my story something like the Keynesian/Robinsonian adjustment mechanism is trying to operate in the background, but BOTH Chinese industrial policy AND US fiscal policy are stuck in their ways. That leaves the monetary system, Wall street etc flexing to fill gap and debt levels rising on the US side as @Vinodh_Rag has helpfully spelled out. These debt stocks are not inherently unsustainable but they require more and more “balancing” and redistribution by way of taxes and interest payments, and more and more stress on the Wall Street Fed nexus hence Bessent v. Warsh etc.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
You are right to say that Washington doesn’t expand the deficit as a way of offsetting the inflow, Adam. The mechanism is indirect. If there is a net $100 inflow into the US, the resulting change in its external imbalance must be perfectly matched by a corresponding change in its internal imbalance. To simplify, either investment must rise by $100 or saving must decline by $100.
Given the sophistication of the American financial system, the huge stockpiles of cash American businesses are sitting on, and their own surveys, it is pretty clear that the constraint on American business investment (and indeed investment in most advanced economies) is demand rather than scarce capital. In that case, net inflows will not drive investment up by $100.
But the internal imbalance must still adjust to the change in the external imbalance. If investment doesn't rise, it must adjust in some way that results in a $100 decline in saving. One possibility is the Joan Robinson scenario. As American manufacturing competitiveness declines, American manufacturers close production or move it offshore. With no replacement for the demand that has leaked abroad, US unemployment rises, and unemployed workers, of course, have a negative saving rate. The internal imbalance thus accommodates the change in the external imbalance through a rise in unemployment.
But while the central bank and fiscal authorities won’t respond directly to an increase in capital inflows, they do respond to the rises in unemployment. They can do so through monetary easing or larger fiscal deficits. Debt, whether household or fiscal, is negative saving, so the internal imbalance can instead adjust through an increase in negative saving. This prevents unemployment from rising by creating new demand to replace the manufacturing demand that has flowed abroad.
In this scenario, what we should see is not a rise in unemployment but a rise in household or fiscal debt, combined with a shift in production out of manufacturing and into services. And this, of course, is just what we have seen since the late 1970s.
By the way, this is essentially the same mechanism described by Atif Mian, Ludwig Straub and Amir Sufi in their series of papers on “indebted demand” and the “saving glut of the rich.”
They note that a rise in income inequality in the US is not associated with higher saving and higher investment, even though the rich save more of their income. Instead, it is associated with more household debt.
The mechanism is essentially the same: when income shifts toward households that save more, or towards foreigners who save more, if investment doesn't rise, demand has to be sustained by increased borrowing elsewhere. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joey Politano 🏳️🌈
@JosephPolitano
Of course, none of the AI buildout would be possible except for the fact that Trump has completely exempted the industry from tariffs
The exemption for computers & parts is now so large that it represents nearly 1/5 of imports on its own, dwarfing every other tariff exemption -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joey Politano 🏳️🌈
@JosephPolitano
Hard to overstate the degree to which AI-related imports have completely reshaped US trade flows at this point
Another record high for computer & parts imports in official data released this morning, tracking at nearly $700B annualized, up 126% over the last year alone -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"What I find far harder to understand is the claim made by you and others that Chinese savings have been forced up because of their need to accommodate low saving in the US." - honestly puzzled by this @michaelxpettis To best of my knowledge i have never made any such claim, or anything like it. Scratching my head tbh.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
I don't see how. As I have argued many times, your assumption – that net capital inflows must drive down US interest rates – makes no sense. It requires that there be only one way a country can accommodate net inflows, and of course this simply isn't true.
-If net inflows fund much needed domestic investment in an economy with high investment needs and scarce saving (i.e. a rapidly-growing developing economy), they would indeed do so by reducing interest rates. This was the case for the US in the 19th Century, but it is no longer the case today for any advanced economy.
-If net inflows caused a rise in domestic US unemployment (Joan Robinson's beggar-thy-neighbor case), the resulting economic slowdown would probably be accompanied by a decline in interest rates. In that case net inflows would also "cause" a decline in interest rates.
-But if the Fed responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by easing, and encouraging enough of a rise in household debt to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
-Similarly, if Washington responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by expanding the fiscal deficit by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then, again, domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
-On the other hand if net inflows drive up asset prices, the wealth effect can drive down household saving (i.e. drive up household consumption) by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad, in which case there is, once again, no predictable impact on interest rates. In the late 1920s, the wealth effect may have actually resulted in a rise in interest rates.
The point is that the latter three cases are far more likely in the case of the US than the former two, which suggests that it is wrong to insist that net inflows must drive down interest rates. If we were looking for evidence that net inflows correspond more to higher household and fiscal debt than to higher investment or unemployment, we would want to see household and fiscal debt begin to rise just as trade imbalances began to soar in the late 1970s, which of course is what seems to have happened, not just since the late 1970s but also in the past few months.
What I find far harder to understand is the claim made by you and others that Chinese savings have been forced up because of their need to accommodate low saving in the US. If every country in the world saved slightly more than it invested, the claim that this was in response to domestic US conditions would seem a little more plausible, but when excess saving is so heavily concentrated in a handful of countries, and especially concentrated in China, it seems to me that we must accept that countries like China possesses at least some degree of agency in determining their domestic imbalances, and if thse result in very high saving relative to investment, this excess must be absorbed by someone.
I also reject your "strong version" of my claim, i.e. that the only thing that affects US financial and monetary conditions is the extent of net capital inflows. Not only have I never made this argument, but I suspect no one in history has ever made the argument. Of all the straw men in economic debates, this is probably the one that least needs to be kicked down.
The actual claim is that for any country, its external imbalance must always be perfectly consistent with its internal imbalance. In that case anything that forces a change in the external imbalance must force a change in the internal imbalance. This change can occur in many ways, intermediated by domestic institutions and conditions, but it must occur. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In my view our difference can be sharpened by looking at this option: "Similarly, if Washington responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by expanding the fiscal deficit by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then, again, domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate." Yes, Washington has expanded the deficit, but it surely has nothing to do with domestic macroeconomic balance, let alone the need to offset any inflow from China.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
I don't see how. As I have argued many times, your assumption – that net capital inflows must drive down US interest rates – makes no sense. It requires that there be only one way a country can accommodate net inflows, and of course this simply isn't true.
-If net inflows fund much needed domestic investment in an economy with high investment needs and scarce saving (i.e. a rapidly-growing developing economy), they would indeed do so by reducing interest rates. This was the case for the US in the 19th Century, but it is no longer the case today for any advanced economy.
-If net inflows caused a rise in domestic US unemployment (Joan Robinson's beggar-thy-neighbor case), the resulting economic slowdown would probably be accompanied by a decline in interest rates. In that case net inflows would also "cause" a decline in interest rates.
-But if the Fed responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by easing, and encouraging enough of a rise in household debt to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
-Similarly, if Washington responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by expanding the fiscal deficit by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then, again, domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
-On the other hand if net inflows drive up asset prices, the wealth effect can drive down household saving (i.e. drive up household consumption) by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad, in which case there is, once again, no predictable impact on interest rates. In the late 1920s, the wealth effect may have actually resulted in a rise in interest rates.
The point is that the latter three cases are far more likely in the case of the US than the former two, which suggests that it is wrong to insist that net inflows must drive down interest rates. If we were looking for evidence that net inflows correspond more to higher household and fiscal debt than to higher investment or unemployment, we would want to see household and fiscal debt begin to rise just as trade imbalances began to soar in the late 1970s, which of course is what seems to have happened, not just since the late 1970s but also in the past few months.
What I find far harder to understand is the claim made by you and others that Chinese savings have been forced up because of their need to accommodate low saving in the US. If every country in the world saved slightly more than it invested, the claim that this was in response to domestic US conditions would seem a little more plausible, but when excess saving is so heavily concentrated in a handful of countries, and especially concentrated in China, it seems to me that we must accept that countries like China possesses at least some degree of agency in determining their domestic imbalances, and if thse result in very high saving relative to investment, this excess must be absorbed by someone.
I also reject your "strong version" of my claim, i.e. that the only thing that affects US financial and monetary conditions is the extent of net capital inflows. Not only have I never made this argument, but I suspect no one in history has ever made the argument. Of all the straw men in economic debates, this is probably the one that least needs to be kicked down.
The actual claim is that for any country, its external imbalance must always be perfectly consistent with its internal imbalance. In that case anything that forces a change in the external imbalance must force a change in the internal imbalance. This change can occur in many ways, intermediated by domestic institutions and conditions, but it must occur. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
HI @michaelxpettis to address the straw man point: In each of the arguments below you offer chains of causation that I summarized as the "strong version".
-If net inflows caused a rise in domestic US unemployment (Joan Robinson's beggar-thy-neighbor case), the resulting economic slowdown would probably be accompanied by a decline in interest rates. In that case net inflows would also "cause" a decline in interest rates. -But if the Fed responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by easing, and encouraging enough of a rise in household debt to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate. -Similarly, if Washington responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by expanding the fiscal deficit by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then, again, domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
I don't see how. As I have argued many times, your assumption – that net capital inflows must drive down US interest rates – makes no sense. It requires that there be only one way a country can accommodate net inflows, and of course this simply isn't true.
-If net inflows fund much needed domestic investment in an economy with high investment needs and scarce saving (i.e. a rapidly-growing developing economy), they would indeed do so by reducing interest rates. This was the case for the US in the 19th Century, but it is no longer the case today for any advanced economy.
-If net inflows caused a rise in domestic US unemployment (Joan Robinson's beggar-thy-neighbor case), the resulting economic slowdown would probably be accompanied by a decline in interest rates. In that case net inflows would also "cause" a decline in interest rates.
-But if the Fed responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by easing, and encouraging enough of a rise in household debt to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
-Similarly, if Washington responds to the possibility of higher US unemployment by expanding the fiscal deficit by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad through the trade deficit, then, again, domestic debt rises in line with foreign demand for domestic debt, and so there is not predictable impact on the interest rate.
-On the other hand if net inflows drive up asset prices, the wealth effect can drive down household saving (i.e. drive up household consumption) by enough to balance the extent to which net domestic demand flows abroad, in which case there is, once again, no predictable impact on interest rates. In the late 1920s, the wealth effect may have actually resulted in a rise in interest rates.
The point is that the latter three cases are far more likely in the case of the US than the former two, which suggests that it is wrong to insist that net inflows must drive down interest rates. If we were looking for evidence that net inflows correspond more to higher household and fiscal debt than to higher investment or unemployment, we would want to see household and fiscal debt begin to rise just as trade imbalances began to soar in the late 1970s, which of course is what seems to have happened, not just since the late 1970s but also in the past few months.
What I find far harder to understand is the claim made by you and others that Chinese savings have been forced up because of their need to accommodate low saving in the US. If every country in the world saved slightly more than it invested, the claim that this was in response to domestic US conditions would seem a little more plausible, but when excess saving is so heavily concentrated in a handful of countries, and especially concentrated in China, it seems to me that we must accept that countries like China possesses at least some degree of agency in determining their domestic imbalances, and if thse result in very high saving relative to investment, this excess must be absorbed by someone.
I also reject your "strong version" of my claim, i.e. that the only thing that affects US financial and monetary conditions is the extent of net capital inflows. Not only have I never made this argument, but I suspect no one in history has ever made the argument. Of all the straw men in economic debates, this is probably the one that least needs to be kicked down.
The actual claim is that for any country, its external imbalance must always be perfectly consistent with its internal imbalance. In that case anything that forces a change in the external imbalance must force a change in the internal imbalance. This change can occur in many ways, intermediated by domestic institutions and conditions, but it must occur. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
The source is here. sankaran.substack.com/p/is-us-healthcare-the-dark-matter?…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Eric Weinberger
@eric_weinberger
ok guys this one's for you @cszabla @AntonJaegermm @adam_tooze @AlanSmithee1987
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Speaking of the relative autonomy of US sectoral balances vis a vis international capital flow dynamics, here is @M_C_Klein providing a lucid account of US aggregate demand pressures without mentioning current account.
theovershoot.co/p/rising-bond-yields-are-good-actually -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Question for @michaelxpettis and those who argue for priority of capital flows in driving global imbalances. How do u interpret today's configuration of giant Chinese trade surplus AND rising US yields? Doesnt this suggest that Cn "push" and US "pull" factors are relatively autonomous?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Bernstein
@Bernstein
Eumeswil. You gotta read Eumeswil.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Neo-Burgundian technocracy: On the Marble Cliffs & Ernst Jünger’s reckoning with nihilism.
In 1939, months before WWII, WWI hero and nihilist poet of the 1920s Ernst Jünger published a remarkable short novel. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Neo-Burgundian technocracy: On the Marble Cliffs & Ernst Jünger’s reckoning with nihilism.
In 1939, months before WWII, WWI hero and nihilist poet of the 1920s Ernst Jünger published a remarkable short novel.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Of all the critiques of technocracy in the 1930s Jünger's is one of the most psychologically compelling. A man whose thought is as violent and "armed" as reality itself. Coercing nature but entranced by the scent of artificial flowers.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For Jünger On the Marble Cliffs (1939) marks a crucial step in his development away from his Nietzschean persona of the 1920s and early 1930s. adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-472-neo-burgundian-tec…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Simon S. Luo
@simonshluo
I taught Galbraith in my Cold War Idea course. Fairly useful for students to grapple with the economic roots of certain liberal ideas and their critics.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jessica Huseman
@JessicaHuseman
The White House has selected a still from a video in which the goose ultimately wins the fight, and the eagle walks away confused. It’s even from CBC. We are just handing Canada things to make fun of us for.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIjaxrQBkPk -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Who exactly is @SecScottBessent talking about? Iran? Or his own government. h/t @schieritz
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
@SecScottBessent
As the Iranian people struggle to afford basic necessities, the corrupt regime continues to squander enormous sums abroad.
Instead of funneling billions of dollars to its terrorist proxies, the regime should spend that money for its people. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
CHART OF THE DAY: The rise of the Permian ultra-long horizontal oil well: >15,000 feet.
“Virtually nonexistent before 2020, these wells, more than three miles long, accounted for 15% of all new Permian well completions in 2025.”
🔗: www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=67984 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Still Safe?
The US Treasury caught in a vortex of cognitive dissonance.
Latest Chartbook newsletter riffing on a powerful paper by Hanno Lustig for Aspen Institute.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-471-still-safe-cognitive -
Adam Tooze reposted
Surplus | Das Wirtschaftsmagazin
@surplusmagazin
Wer den Welthandel verstehen will, darf nicht nur auf die Straße von Hormus schauen. Auch das afrikanische Dschibuti ist eine Drehscheibe geopolitischer Interessen.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Dawn of a new age of financial repression? Opening of an epic Treasury v. Fed battle? Bessent's Treasury market intervention ahead of Jackson Hole has provoked much comment. My own bet is that this has more in common with the shambles of Operation Epic Fury.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
I suspect that French self-image would greatly benefit from being exposed to Germany's shambolic train system
Total train delays in 2025 in Germany reached 66.8 years... -
Adam Tooze reposted
Cornell University
@Cornell
Researchers at Cornell have created an interactive map identifying 1.8 million individual trees in New York City, with a new approach that could optimize the placement of trees for cooling in cities around the world.
In the study, researchers identify the types of trees using satellite imagery as well as on-the-ground datasets and 3D data collected with lidar, short for light detection and ranging. The approach was 82% accurate overall and higher for common types of New York City trees.
It’s the first “wall-to-wall,” citywide map identifying trees in natural areas and other unsurveyed areas, which together constitute an estimated 65% of the city’s canopy and have not been accounted for on previous maps.
The research team will use the map to determine which trees are best for cooling, and the data could inform a host of other planting decisions where the type of tree makes a difference, from reducing allergens to managing invasive pests.
Read more: news.cornell.edu/stories/2026/08/wall-wall-map-nyc-trees-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Tutt
@TuttReal
Karatani has a new translated book out this month, so I had to drop everything and read it. Highlights are that Jameson has a review essay of The Structure of World History in here. The main essay by Karatani on the end of modern literature is interesting, he has developed a theory of stages of capitalism that is maddeningly precise.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Really enjoyed Adam Tooze's latest two substacks -- on the Fed's intervention to stabilize the Treasury market in March 2020, and on the structural change in the Treasury market linked to a rise in issuance relative to global reserve demand
1/
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-469-the-risk-of-unwind -
Adam Tooze reposted
Vinodh Raghunathan
@Vinodh_Rag
What if the funding framing is backwards? Post-2016 the causality runs from NIIP deterioration to equity valuation expansion, not equity inflows to deficit financing. The equity position may be the stock repricing rather than the flow being financed.
The question is what is worsening the NIIP? -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joequant
@joequant
China and the Gulf States. The basic argument that I have with @Brad_Sester is that we seem to agree that there are large amounts of hidden flows associated with China, but I think he misidentifies the flows as the "Chinese state" rather than "wealthy Chinese."
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Etra
@EtraAlex
The real question for the BOP nerds and one that perhaps @Brad_Setser and @adam_tooze's networks can help explain: If foreign private flows to UST from OFCs is just 'round tripping' by hedge funds, what is the actual source of net external financing for the US CA deficit?
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Really enjoyed Adam Tooze's latest two substacks -- on the Fed's intervention to stabilize the Treasury market in March 2020, and on the structural change in the Treasury market linked to a rise in issuance relative to global reserve demand
1/
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-469-the-risk-of-unwind -
Adam Tooze reposted
CMN Nguyen
@ngcmn26
This documentary reminded me of my recent sadnesses: the shutdown of The Workers’ newspaper (1975-2026), and the absence and erasure of Vietnam’s working class in its political and intellectual discourses. The migrant workers’ literature in China has no equivalent in Vietnam.
CMN Nguyen
@ngcmn26
Documentary: ‘Exploitation in Vietnam’s factories’ @DeutscheWelle youtu.be/nzcLJrYfFpI
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If all history is contemporary history, then all contemporary perception is also historical. Chartbook 468 on the stresses in the US Treasury market and the memory of the March 2020 meltdown. Read here and sign up for more: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-468-apocalypse-now-in-the
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Derek R Peterson
@Unseen_Archive
Colleagues will be sorry to hear that historian John Iliffe has this morning passed away in Cambridge at age 87.
Iliffe was a maker of the academic field of African history. He took up a post at the University of Dar es Salaam shortly after Tanganyika's independence.
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sixth Tone
@SixthTone
Zhuge Yiyang was catapulted to international academic stardom for her viral interview with Christopher Nolan. Now, Chinese social media users say they’ve found evidence she plagiarized others’ works.
www.sixthtone.com/news/1018913 -
Adam Tooze reposted
André Kühnlenz
@KeineWunder
“Source: Great grafik from André Kühnlenz in FUW”
😍😍😍 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Is the shambles of the German railway system the result of a GM experiment gone horribly wrong!? Methinks Bahn may have some explaining to do!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
"A bold, revelatory history of confiscation, or the government seizure of private property... illuminating its role in the biggest atrocities—and most revolutionary social advancements—of our time."
@njtmulder's new book will be a must read for climate people. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
As raging storms or as smothering heat lockdown, the crisis of global heating is going to manifest in many different ways around the globe. As Europe is experiencing this summer, the socio-economic impact will be large.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One thing we know for sure, is that though the losses in the Global North will be huge, the impact will be most painful in the Global South.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Check out Chartbook 467 on heatwave economics and sign up for more here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-467-mad-dogs-and-heatwave -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Ein Modell, das ein Warum hat, kann fast jedes Wie finden.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Bernd Ulrich
@berndulrich
Die Deutschen haben beschlossen, ungebremst in die #klimakrise zu gehen. Aber weil sie sich dafür schämen, wollen sie vom #klima nichts mehr hören. Selbst und gerade dann nicht, wenn es ihnen gerade um die Ohren fliegt www.zeit.de/politik/2026-08/hitze-sommer-folgen-klimakris…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Eagleton
@Oliver_Eagleton
Everyone's saying it.
Check out those germs if you haven't already: tribunemag.co.uk/issue/late-populism
Daniel Gerke
@drgerke1
Very impressed indeed with the latest edition of @tribunemagazine - asking exactly the right questions and already providing the germs of some answers
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Straits of Hormuz, you say. ... oh no! Europe's #1 economy is at the mercy of the Straits of Kaub a narrowing of the river Rhine channel where robber barons once held sway.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Today, climate change and the endless deferral of German infrastructure policy has turned the Kaub passage of the Rhine it into a bottleneck that threatens to throttle what little growth Germany can muster.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A story, as if out of a fairytale that threatens to turn into a logistics nightmare. Read it here at Chartbook newsletter and sign up for more:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-466-the-straits-of-kaub -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
Hannah Arendt--upset at 1955 conference about having to summarize her thinking in a few minutes and opposing what she calls "the figure of the re-writing man":
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ember
@ember_energy
SOON | China's solar and wind generation grew 27% in the first half of 2025, contributing to a 2% decline in coal generation 📉
What else happened in China’s power sector in 2025? Answers at the launch of our China Energy Transition Review ⤵️
ember-energy.org/latest-updates/launch-of-the-china-energ… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Shaiel Ben-Ephraim
@academic_la
This investigation by the Financial Times is staggering in its findings and in its scope and methodological rigor. Some of the findings, backed up by incredible levels of forensic evidence:
1) Israel completed much of its systematic destruction across Israeli-occupied southern Lebanon after Israeli forces took control of already-emptied villages in mid-April, and after the April 17 ceasefire. The ceasefire was used to make these areas completely uninhabitable.
2) The scale of destruction is incredible. Roughly 85,000 housing units damaged or destroyed (likely an undercount); 62 villages and farms inside the "yellow line" occupation zone, covering ~6% of Lebanon and extending ~10km inland, with ~270,000 residents barred from returning. Over 20% of the south's farmland and forest destroyed, ancient olive groves worst hit. All Litani river bridges destroyed; at least 2,500km of water infrastructure gone.
3) This is stated policy and an intentional plan to make an entire area uninhabitable and never allow the population to return. Defence minister Israel Katz explicitly invoked the "Rafah and Beit Hanoun model" and later boasted of destroying "24 Lebanese villages… not house by house, but entire villages."
4) This is without a doubt a war crime. Destruction of property requires immediate military necessity and not speculative ideas that Hezbollah may use a building some day. Not allowing the return amounts to the ethnic cleansing of the area.
The lack of any real consequences for Gaza, meant that Israel felt free to do the same in Lebanon. It is now doing the same in the West Bank. This will stop unless we stop it. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
CHART OF THE DAY: @IEA estimates Chinese EV fleet (cars + trucks) is displacing >1.5m b/d of oil demand (up from ~1m b/d) a year ago.
"This displacement [...] suggests an acceleration in the already very strong growth in the use of electricity for transportation," the IEA said. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Is "new SOCIALIST UPRISING" really the headline under which we are going to write America's political history in the summer of 2026? Not just a little overstated? How about "left abundance" or the "social democratic push"? @DKThomp
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
I still think the new socialist uprising is creating a kind of left-wing party-within-the-party that accentuates the benefits and costs of Democrats overperformance among college grads rather than entirely fixes the problem
One way that might be showing up is that the easiest groups to survey, which tend to be over-represented in modern polls -- college-educated ppl who pay attention to politics -- are disproportionately socialist
OSZ
@OpenSourceZone
Last 5 Wisconsin Governor Democratic Primary Polls
State Navigate: 🔵 Hong +22
Public Policy Polling: 🔵 Hong +18
Marquette University: 🔵 Hong +25
State Navigate: 🔵 Hong +29
Public Policy Polling: 🔵 Hong +20
Results (88% Reporting): 🟡Crowley +0.5 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
Really? THIS is what they're worried about? What a disgrace this committee is. At a time when racial profiling is driving talent away from American shores and harming US competitiveness, they want to stir up anti-Chinese grievance?
Select Committee on China
@ChinaSelect
Are you an American student, postdoctoral researcher, or academic who believes you were denied a research position, laboratory opportunity, or postdoctoral appointment because preference was given to applicants from China?
@ChinaSelect wants to hear from you. If you have firsthand information or supporting documentation, please contact the Committee through our whistleblower email at scc.whistleblower@mail.house.gov. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Colin McCarthy
@US_Stormwatch
Water temperatures in the Persian Gulf, the hottest sea on the planet, have reached as high as 97°F (36°C), over the past week as the region endures an extreme heatwave.
Some cities in Iran have experienced weeks of temperatures near 50°C (122°F).
The extraordinarily warm Persian Gulf is also fueling a brutal combination of heat and humidity, with the heat index reaching 145°F (63°C) on August 7 in Doha, Qatar.
Extreme heat across the Middle East is becoming increasingly difficult to endure. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Eagleton
@Oliver_Eagleton
A gripping account of how, in its attempt to destroy the centre left, Podemos ended up revitalising it under the hegemony of Pedro Sánchez — and what that says about the 'populist hypothesis' more widely.
Subscribe to read: tribunemag.co.uk/subscribe
Eoghan Gilmartin
@EoghanGilmartin
Delighted to have a long piece in @tribunemagazine's new print edition, the first under editor @Oliver_Eagleton.
I trace the Spanish left's trajectory over the last decade from Podemos' irruption in 2014 through its retreat and the renewal of the centre-left under Pedro Sanchez.
This, however, is not a narrative of straightforward defeat for left populism: "At the same time as its electoral ambitions came apart another arc bent in the opposite direction, with Podemos continuing to exert a powerful ideological influence on Spanish politics, turning it into Europe’s progressive outlier.
We can only draw the right lessons from this experiment if we grasp these two distinct dimensions: the failure of Podemos’s radical mission, which flowed from its inability to resolve fundamental strategic and organisational problems, and its strange, lingering
afterlife. Governing some of the country’s largest cities and eventually ascending to national office as the junior coalition partner to PSOE, Podemos and its allies made clearer policy gains than left-populist forces elsewhere on the continent." -
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Eagleton
@Oliver_Eagleton
This essay by @gabrielwinant in the latest Tribune is a major theoretical intervention.
It explains why changing patterns of production mean that struggle now emerges not from 'class homogeneity' but from communities 'marked by particularity'.
Read here: tribunemag.co.uk/2026/07/is-it-over -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Fave self-ironizing, Berlin street art of the day:
"a narrow circle of people"
With some help from AI, I was able to figure out that the reference is to Lenin's "In Memory of Herzen" of 1912, in which describes the Decembrists (1825) as a narrow circle "terribly remote from the people". -
Adam Tooze reposted
Esben Schjørring
@esben_schj
Exactly. And some of the scenes are almost identical. On the beach with Calypso reiterates the Goa-scene with Franka Potente - even the lines. Its really hard to understand why Nolan has this intense dialogue with the Bourne-films.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Mika Walker Kane
@MWalkerKane
German Hellenism: Winckelmann, Goethe, Schiller, Hegel, Humboldt, Hölderlin, Nietzsche.
Anglo Hellenism: Matthew Arnold and Jason Bourne. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Yeah. I liked that Wilson point too. TBH Im more invested in Bourne than Odysseus. But even his physiognomy gives the game away. Sly Odysseus isnt supposed to be some buff hunk is he?
night brain
@_night_brain__
I liked the Wilson review where she says "Look, text Odysseus isn't Jason Bourne or something. He's complicated, changes identities, schemes and plays tricks, lots of techne"
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If you want to watch a half-drowned Matt Damon realizing he can never go home and thus re-finding his identity in exotic locations in Europe, The Bourne Identity has it over the Odyssey in every respect other than the scale of special effects.
Ángel Talavera
@atalaveraEcon
A grotesque bad take, more like.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
vraimentcausal
@vraimentcausal
and perhaps more importantly, he was recommended listening to fela kuti some weeks ago
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Oh God, after being rock solid first on Iraq in 2003 and then on Gaza in 2023 now @Villepin is explaining why everyone should read Michel Foucault's The Order of Things ... is this some kinda all-too-pleasing AI hallucination?
Dominique de Villepin
@Villepin
Je voudrais vous parler d’un livre qui déplace nos certitudes.
Dans Les Mots et les choses, Foucault montre que chaque époque pense à l’intérieur d’un cadre invisible, d’une grammaire du possible, et que cet ordre change sans que nous en ayons conscience.
Il nous dit que nos débats portent sur des cadres de pensée avant de porter sur des opinions, et que contrôler le savoir, c’est contrôler le possible.
Il nous dit aussi qu’une société qui oublie que ses catégories sont construites les transforme en essences, ce qui constitue le premier pas vers la déshumanisation.
Lisons Foucault et gardons quelques gestes simples d’humanité : quand un débat s’enflamme, demandons-nous qui a le pouvoir de nommer, de définir, de classer. Quand une technologie promet l’objectivité, demandons-nous quel tableau elle construit et à qui il profite.
Quand une société devient dure, demandons-nous quel « homme » elle fabrique. Notre époque se croit moderne parce qu’elle possède des machines puissantes.
La vraie modernité serait de garder la liberté de penser autrement qu’elles, de rappeler que derrière les mots il y a des choses, et derrière les choses des vies. Si nous perdons ce lien, nous perdrons plus qu’un débat, nous perdrons notre humanité.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Nolan's "Odyssey” is a commentary on world where rules have collapsed", I agree @im_PULSE that this is way to rescue meaning from the film. But fact that this brutish all-American rendition is what Hollywood makes of Homer today also points to why we are in this mess = symptomatic.
Idrees Ahmad
@im_PULSE
It's an extraordinary film and I'd encourage everyone to go see it. newlinesmag.com/argument/the-odyssey-wars/
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Fernando Johansson 🕳
@binarydee
The Odyssey as farce, Hollywood as tragedy
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Saw the film of the moment ... and what have we even been discussing? Forget finer points of historical detail or textual interpretation, even on its own terms, just as an action-quest this version of the Odyssey is a grotesque, puerile failure.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The sociology wars have crossed the Atlantic and have now started in Germany too.
DIE ZEIT
@zeitonline
Ist die Soziologie zu links? Wer das behauptet, wie Armin Nassehi und Irmhild Saake in der ZEIT, verkennt das eigene Fach und betreibt das Geschäft seiner Gegner. www.zeit.de/feuilleton/2026-08/wissenschaft-soziologie-li…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
Can't wait for this to happen! In only 250 million years our continents will have merged into a single super-continent "Pangaea Proxima". Look at the cute Atlantic! The Himalaya won't be the highest mountain range anymore! Source: www.nationalgeographic.com/premium/article/explore-atlas-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If you want to watch a half-drowned Matt Damon realizing he can never go home and thus re-finding his identity in exotic locations in Europe, The Bourne Identity has it over the Odyssey in every respect other than the scale of special effects.
Ángel Talavera
@atalaveraEcon
A grotesque bad take, more like.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Saw the film of the moment ... and what have we even been discussing? Forget finer points of historical detail or textual interpretation, even on its own terms, just as an action-quest this version of the Odyssey is a grotesque, puerile failure.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Pablo Bortz
@pablobortz
This is a wonderful essay, a joy to read, and actually a damning condemnation of today's elites (including in my own country, Argentina) by Thomas Mann & Keynes. Recommended reading.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Dr Faustus thus becomes the emblematic figure for a Keynes-o-Mannian liberal modernity.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-465-the-last-of-the-ma… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Eagleton
@Oliver_Eagleton
Episode two of postscript is now live!
Barnaby and Paul Gilroy discuss Marxism and anti-racism from the 'long 1970s' to the present:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=fn574DiflCc -
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
"Le fait est que chaque écrivain crée ses précurseurs. Son apport modifie notre conception du passé aussi bien que du futur." — Jorge Luis Borges, « Kafka et ses précurseurs », Autres Inquisitions.
Démonstration:
👇
🧵
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How to rethink bourgeois liberalism's options in the 20th century. Last weekend I started a new mini series with a post about Thomas Mann's Zauberberg and the end of history. Today @stefeich and I speculate about the parallels btwn Mann and ... Keynes.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How to rethink bourgeois liberalism's options in the 20th century. Last weekend I started a new mini series with a post about Thomas Mann's Zauberberg and the end of history. Today @stefeich and I speculate about the parallels btwn Mann and ... Keynes.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Meanwhile for Keynes, it is Malthus and Newton that unlock the doors to a different understanding of modernity.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Dr Faustus thus becomes the emblematic figure for a Keynes-o-Mannian liberal modernity.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-465-the-last-of-the-ma… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Tribune
@tribunemagazine
Episode 2 of postscript is here!
Barnaby Raine talks to Paul Gilroy about his life and work, and how we can imagine freedom in a world of capitalism and racism.
Click here to watch the full episode: youtu.be/fn574DiflCc -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Going to be an interesting time of adjustment in the US!!!!!
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
There seems to be a growing acknowledgement around the word that Keynes was right when he proposed at Bretton Woods a global trading regime that limited persistent trade imbalances and restricted global financial flows.
In her new Foreign Affairs piece, Lori Wallach proposes a similar restructuring of the global trading regime, arguing that because our current trading system rewards countries that improve their manufacturing competitiveness by suppressing wage growth relative to productivity growth (and by ignoring environmental costs), it's no surprise that income inequality has risen across most countries over the past four decades.
Like a growing number of analysts, she argues that countries should be free to choose their own growth models, but they should not be able to externalize the associated costs via their trade and capital accounts.
@WallachLori
www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/right-way-balance-trade via @ForeignAffairs -
Adam Tooze reposted
Branko Milanovic
@BrankoMilan
You cannot treat the most successful economic growth in the history of the world as an exception to the generally valid rules of economics.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Yin Shao Loong
@yinshaoloong
The hair-splitting and handwringing over “China shock” v “China squeeze” might be more usefully reframed as Transatlantic Economic Eclipse and a Development Squeeze on the Global South. China is only part of the challenge for the latter. The US and EU imposed major constraints.1/
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"China Squeeze" - the politics of development counterfactuals.
China Shock 1.0: happened in the 2000s.
China Shock 2.0: warning of what may happen next.
China Squeeze: what could allegedly have happened if it were not for China's development. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Love this formulation. There really is a "lump of consumption" fallacy at work here @teortaxesTex
Teortaxes▶️ (DeepSeek 推特🐋铁粉 2023 – ∞)
@teortaxesTex
I think China Squeeze theory is comforting fiction. It assumes that consumption is scarce while production is in principle abundant but goes to the first mover. On these terms, China couldn't even happen. Well, it did.
We wouldn't have such abundance without China happening.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"China Squeeze" - the politics of development counterfactuals.
China Shock 1.0: happened in the 2000s.
China Shock 2.0: warning of what may happen next.
China Squeeze: what could allegedly have happened if it were not for China's development. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Teortaxes▶️ (DeepSeek 推特🐋铁粉 2023 – ∞)
@teortaxesTex
I think China Squeeze theory is comforting fiction. It assumes that consumption is scarce while production is in principle abundant but goes to the first mover. On these terms, China couldn't even happen. Well, it did.
We wouldn't have such abundance without China happening.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"China Squeeze" - the politics of development counterfactuals.
China Shock 1.0: happened in the 2000s.
China Shock 2.0: warning of what may happen next.
China Squeeze: what could allegedly have happened if it were not for China's development. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"China Squeeze" - the politics of development counterfactuals.
China Shock 1.0: happened in the 2000s.
China Shock 2.0: warning of what may happen next.
China Squeeze: what could allegedly have happened if it were not for China's development.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
But as @pretentiouswhat & Leon Liao have pointed out, Development is Not a Queue.
These counterfactuals rest on highly debatable assumptions about paths of development.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Furthermore, in their work on India, Subramanian, Chatterjee & Kapur flip the terms of the argument by focusing not on China's fx manipulation and industrial policy but on the short-comings of India's development model.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
So the entire "China squeeze" argument, at least as articulated so far by Subramanian and co-authors seems to rest on very fragile foundations.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For the chartbook newsletter, click here:
adamtooze.substack.com/publish/post/204211896
Ends with a flourish and a reference to @afrazhaowang and her wonderful essay on China's own industrial development counterfactualists. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Loay_Mudhoon
@Loay_Mudhoon
Spannendes, aufschlussreiches Gespräch mit dem Wirtschaftswissenschaftler und Historiker @adam_tooze
Auszug:
ZEIT: Sie sind Historiker: Wie blicken Sie in diesen dunklen Zeiten in die Zukunft?
Tooze: Wir im Westen haben Probleme, und ich will sie nicht kleinreden. Aber gerade aus historischer Perspektive müssen wir uns der Relativität unseres Standpunktes bewusst werden. Die These, dass wir in dunklen Zeiten leben, wird in großen Teilen der restlichen Welt als Gegenwartsbeschreibung nicht verstanden. Vor allem in Asien steht die wirtschaftliche und soziale Entwicklung im Mittelpunkt. Das geht nicht ohne Krisen und Nebenwirkungen, aber die Rede von »dunklen Zeiten« erfasst die Dramatik des Wandels nicht, der sich eher wie eine Revolution anfühlt. Wir im Westen haben immer gesagt, dass wir es gutheißen, wenn sich die Welt entwickelt, und haben das Ende der kolonialen Zeit begrüßt. Haben wir das eigentlich jemals ernst gemeint? Jetzt ist der Wandel jedenfalls da. Davor zurückzuschrecken, zeugt entweder von Naivität oder von Unredlichkeit.
Mark Schieritz
@schieritz
Wir haben mit @adam_tooze gesprochen
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Philipp Heimberger
@heimbergecon
Interesting new QJE paper builds a global working hours database for 160 countries covering 97% of world population. Globally, 59% of people aged 15+ work, averaging 42 hours/week; women account for 35% of GDP-producing hours. Hours are only weakly related to development.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Eric Hobsbawm visiting Paris for Bastille day 1936 during Popular Front.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVQ4dfC34TI -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Do Musil, do dos Passos, do Peter Weiss … all ambitious, do Lu Xun … all on the long-term list.
Klaus Feldmann
@feldmann_k
Robert Musil's *The Man Without Qualities* is more significant—literarily, aesthetically, historically, politically, and epistemologically—than Thomas Mann's classic *The Magic Mountain*.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How history ended in Davos ... on, or about September, 1907. Thomas Mann's classic Zauberberg (Magic Mountain) is one of the novels of the moment. @martinwolf_ @delong have both invoked it as a milestone. It has been my June-July reading.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Thanks @EtraAlex recommendations most welcome. Dos Passos on the list.
Alex Etra
@EtraAlex
May i recommend dos passos USA trilogy for similar treatment
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
"America is ushering in a new age of militarism and bellicosity — with the British establishment in tow. The Left’s politics should be organised around stopping the relentless drive to war.": tribunemag.co.uk/2026/07/against-rearmament
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How history ended in Davos ... on, or about September, 1907. Thomas Mann's classic Zauberberg (Magic Mountain) is one of the novels of the moment. @martinwolf_ @delong have both invoked it as a milestone. It has been my June-July reading.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reminiscent at times of late 20th century enclave literature, like Ballard's Super-Cannes.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
First in a new series on literature and thinking the crisis (still need a good title). In the mean time, read the newsletter and sign up for more here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-463-zauberbergmagic-mo… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Yiyang Zhuge
@ZhugeYY
Here is my interview with Christopher Nolan: are you a bard for a civilization at dusk?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ones and Tooze
@OnesandToozePod
Episode #253: The Odyssey
@adam_tooze and @CameronAbadi analyze the classic epic from an economic perspective: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-odyssey/id1584397047?i=… -
Adam Tooze reposted
PBS News
@NewsHour
The State Department said it takes "full responsibility" for "hastily" altering and then presenting a map of Africa at a global AIDS conference that mislabeled every single country it highlighted.
An analysis by Reuters found a watermark in the map image that suggests it was made with OpenAI. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Novara Media
@novaramedia
“I feel like I’m living in a nightmare.”
Police arrested multiple people under the Terrorism Act at a Palestine Action protest on Thursday even though they did not appear to be expressing support for the proscribed group.
Novara Media’s @StevenJMethven spoke to people who said they were being wrongly detained under section 12, which prohibits showing or inviting support for a terrorist organisation and carries a maximum sentence of 14 years in prison.
“I have not breached the law in any way,” one woman said.
The Metropolitan police said officers made at least 152 arrests at the protest outside Westminster magistrates court. The majority, 134, were made under section 12.
Palestine Action was proscribed as a terrorist organisation last year after its members repeatedly damaged weapons factories that were supplying arms for Israel’s genocide in Gaza.
Thousands have been arrested since the ban for holding signs that read: “I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action.”
A challenge to the ban will be heard at the supreme court later this year.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Defend Our Juries
@DefendOurJuries
Britain today: An elderly woman in a wheelchair is escorted away by the police and risks up to 14 years in prison for supporting terrorism since the Home Secretary proscribed a protest group in 2025.
Her crime? She said: "I support Palestine Action and I encourage you to join". -
Adam Tooze reposted
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
Good new Adam Tooze piece on China Shock 1.0 and China Shock 2.0: "China shock 2.0 isn’t simply a globalization shock triggering a social backlash. What China is delivering in the 2020s is an industrial policy shock of global scale."
I discuss it in my latest substack piece.
michaelpettis858496.substack.com/p/domestic-continuities-…
@adam_tooze open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-462-china-sho… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Defend Our Juries
@DefendOurJuries
NEW: Sir Jonathon Porritt, arrested under Terrorism law outside Westminster Magistrates Court.
As police escorted him away he said "I am a supporter of Palestine Action, trying to save lives is not terrorism, exposing this Governments complicity in genocide is not terrorism." -
Adam Tooze reposted
Reuters Africa
@ReutersAfrica
A U.S. government map of Africa mislabeled every country during a State Department presentation at a global conference in Brazil this week, causing a stir among attendees who took screenshots and posted them online. www.reuters.com/world/africa/us-government-map-africa-mis…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
two humps and the 14-15 commodity price shock in headline data technically; manufacturing captures the two peaks perfectly!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Anton Hofmiller
@bnzchr
Gianni Infantino’s vulgar, grasping, Italian-Swiss corruption really does make one long for the halcyon days of Sepp Blatter and his elegant, refined, German-Swiss corruption.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jonathon P Sine
@JonathonPSine
America and China are the least externally dependent major economies in the world...as tabulated via OECD's intercountry input-output data 2022.
1) US and China are the least reliant on foreign demand -
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
The common feature of the first China shock and the second China shock is that both are eras where China's export growth wildly exceeds the expansion of global trade
10/ -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Thx @Brad_Setser really wish I had had this perfect graph to hand for the China Shock 1.0 v. 2.0 post yesterday. Really gives us the "two humps".
For the post, see below and sign up for more.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-462-china-shocked-beyond
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Another measure of the China shock is China's raw trade surplus (a better measure than its BoP surplus imo) as a share of its GDP -- the surplus is now up to around 7% of GDP, only a bit below its 06-08 levels
cc @adam_tooze -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China shocked: Beyond the talk of China Shock 1.0 and China Shock 2.0.
Talk of 1.0 and 2.0 suggests too much continuity btw the early 2000s and today.
What we are living through is a dramatic acceleration and intensification.
After years of foreshocks are we living through the first rumblings of the "Big One"
open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-462-china-sho… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Prem Thakker
@prem_thakker
New poll: Americans believe the U.S. should arrest Benjamin Netanyahu by a +22 margin
Total: 49-27
Black: 53-13
Hispanic: 52-15
Ages 18-29: 58-17
Harris voters: 74-10
Independents: 55-20
23% of Trump voters agree as well
Economist/YouGov: -
Adam Tooze reposted
DELARUE Emmanuel
@DELARUEEm
Je suis vraiment inquiet pour la librairie papeterie Gibert.
Les rayons commencent à se vider. C'est d'une tristesse.
Les élus parisiens ou de riches mécènes ne peuvent-ils rien faire pour sauver cette institution de la Culture ?
C'est maintenant qu'il faut réagir. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
The standard macro recommendation for the US on global imbalances is to fix its fiscal deficits, with some bla-bla mention of entitlements. But the interesting point is that the US public sector is actually better at containing healthcare costs than the US private sector.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Mika Walker Kane
@MWalkerKane
There is also a dialectic here between lost pasts and lost futures. Are newly imagined futures possible without newly imagined pasts? We need new histories to have new futures: we cannot give birth to new futures fully-formed out of the head of Zeus.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Polycrisis and the nostalgia for lost futures.
How to react when old visions of the future collapse & The Wolf of radical change is finally at the door.
Chartbook 461 just dropped.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-461-polycrisis-and-nos… -
Adam Tooze reposted
juan
@juanbuis
i can’t believe someone solved recipe design decades ago and everyone just decided to ignore it
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Harrowell
@yorksranter
a man haunted by his catastrophic speculation in frontier cheese stocks
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Kojève the intellectual inspiration for @FukuyamaFrancis end of history thesis, lost most of his money in the stock market crash of 1931, where he had imprudently bought shares of the cheesemaker La vache qui rit!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Kojève the intellectual inspiration for @FukuyamaFrancis end of history thesis, lost most of his money in the stock market crash of 1931, where he had imprudently bought shares of the cheesemaker La vache qui rit!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
Excellent—especially enjoyed discussion of Koselleck
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Polycrisis and the nostalgia for lost futures.
How to react when old visions of the future collapse & The Wolf of radical change is finally at the door.
Chartbook 461 just dropped.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-461-polycrisis-and-nos… -
Adam Tooze reposted
John Handel
@_John_Handel
The gnashing of teeth re: sociology is so funny to me. I have no idea what people are talking about because my main entry to sociology was Donald Mackenzie & others in social studies of markets who do amazing on the technicalities of modern finance
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David Fishman
@pretentiouswhat
One uniquely exhausting thing about writing on China is that every proper argument seems to require preparing a mini Wikipedia of caveats, footnotes, and pre-emptive clarifications. You can't simply make the argument you actually want to make. You have to first ask yourself what assumptions your readers will bring to the table or what common misconceptions or debates might be triggered by a particular phrasing. Trying to make a good faith effort of it requires trying to anticipate as many possible objections as possible before they occur and getting ahead of them.
As an example from my piece today, I wrote that industrialization is not a queue, and that productive capacity does not automatically relocate to whichever country has the lowest wages once another country moves up the value chain - it also needs a foundation of productive capacity to receive it. To me, that seemed like a fairly straightforward point about development economics.
One critical response I received: "China had nothing when we decided to industrialize them 50 years ago."
So then we aren't discussing my argument anymore. We are now debating whether China itself possessed any meaningful industrial capacity prior to the reform era...something I had neglected to pre-empt in my piece.
Suddenly I find myself wondering whether I should have included an extra paragraph in the price or at least. footnote explaining that China in 1979 was poor but not a barren wasteland. It already possessed infrastructure, industrial enterprises, power generation, engineers, railways, ports, literate human capital, state capacity etc. It was in fact unusually well positioned to receive FDI. I know this. China scholars know this. People that study development economics know this. But most people probably don't know this...so is it the critic's fault for being ignorant, or my fault for not foreseeing the issue?
Of course even if I got that one, I'd probably miss another. The piece is still going. Maybe someone will object to how I've defined infrastructure or challenge my definition of industrialization itself. Or more likely an objection I can't even imagine yet. No matter how many caveats and qualifications you add, someone will always find a background assumption you neglected to footnote.
The dispiriting thing here isn't that people will disagree with me. That's part of sharing an opinion in a public space. But it's a bummer that China discussions feels like they require reconstructing an entire agreed worldview from first principles before you can have any kind of conversation. I think that's probably something most people writing about China have experienced. Or at least will recognize. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Polycrisis and the nostalgia for lost futures.
How to react when old visions of the future collapse & The Wolf of radical change is finally at the door.
Chartbook 461 just dropped.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-461-polycrisis-and-nos… -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Fishman
@pretentiouswhat
This is the kind of unfalsifiable counterfactual we should be more comfortable rejecting on intellectual principle.
"They would have received more FDI if not for Chinese domestic subsidies" is not a real argument unless you can specify which sectors, which countries, which subsidies, and which mechanisms would link the subsidies to the missing investment.
The evidence we have suggests the opposite. Per the very platforms like CEPR that are most worried about China Shock 2.0, Chinese policy support is concentrated in strategic/high-tech segments, not in the low-end manufacturing that developing countries would plausibly be competing with China for.
So the explanatory power of subsidies for China's competitiveness in low-end consumer goods sectors like toys or apparel is quite weak, and hard to connect to a "missing FDI" counterfactual. It's the productivity ecosystems, logistics, energy networks, industrial clusters, supplier depth, etc... Not wages, and not subsidies!
1/2
Victor Shih
@vshih2
That’s true, a few lucky countries have gotten extensive industrial investment from Chinese companies but that still leaves many developing countries with less FDI than they would’ve received without massive financial subsidies to Chinese firms
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ones and Tooze
@OnesandToozePod
Episode #252: The Economics of Andy Burnham
Britain’s new prime minister, Andy Burnham, calls his economic philosophy “Manchesterism,” after the city he led as mayor. @adam_tooze and @CameronAbadi examine the history of the term: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-economics-of-andy-burnh… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The only Americans whose sentiment is not at an all-time low, are Republicans, according to the University of Michigan. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
From a 1953 speech by Eisenhower, cited by @HC_Richardson, a striking computation, and a deeper point:
“The cost of one modern heavy bomber is this: a modern brick school in more than 30 cities. It is two electric power plants, each serving a town of 60,000 population. It is two fine, fully equipped hospitals. It is some 50 miles of concrete highway. We pay for a single fighter plane with a half million bushels of wheat. We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed more than 8,000 people.” -
Adam Tooze reposted
Richard Heydarian
@RichHeydarian
“Tactical-Situational” à la @adam_tooze memorable ontological description of our era
Laura Rozen
@lrozen
There is never a deal with Trump, unless perhaps it is self enrichment. There is just an announcement followed by perpetual negotiation.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
SD
@10ON12
@fionamce well worth a listen to @adam_tooze and @CameronAbadi on Manchesterism, Burnham & whether any of it will work.
The @OnesandToozePod is mind expanding - recommended.
open.spotify.com/episode/604PBnkWwfXN3md58QaznG -
Adam Tooze reposted
Bojan Pancevski
@bopanc
Despite all the bollox you will read on here, Odyssey is a well-made, enjoyable Hollywood blockbuster. Odysseus as a PTSD & guilt ridden veteran is unusual but interesting, even if devoid of trickstery and mischief. The diversity casting is not hurting the movie's authenticity (unlike some other films) - and if you’re really that much into phenotype authenticity and DNA, Matt Damon as Odysseus will stick out as a man of north European stock, ie not the kind of guy you’d meet on Ithaca.
Fans of phenotype rigour should watch the 1968 series with Bekim Fehmiu, a Yugoslav Albanian, and Irene Papas, a Greek.
The didactic message that the Bronze Age Collapse holds lessons for our time - as confirmed by @TomHolland1996 in an interview with @holland_tom - seems poignant even though the cultures that perished then were wiped out by foreign invasions rather than by their own decay. For great and accessible scholarship about the actual world of the Odyssey go to @digkabri's marvellous books.
As for cultures that offer the collapse lesson more clearly, I saw the move in the most appropriate setting: one of the great cinemas of the Golden Age of the Austrian-Hungarian Empire, a recently perished culture that adorned Europe, and the world, with some of its most beautiful cities from today’s Ukraine to the Mediterranean. Some of the successor states had to undergo a kind of brief Dark Age and none could ever produce such cities again, for their cultural peak was reached in the bygone days of the fallen Empire that everyone later resented, yet is now using to attract tourist revenue and historic cred.
If you visit Vienna, Prague, Lviv, Budapest or Triest (and you must), it's impossible to even imagine the present polities producing such gems of human civilisation; rather, they look like glorious remnants of an extinct race of giants, which is what post-collapse people believed of ruins like Mycenae or, for example, Bath. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ilias Alami
@IliasAlami
What an extraordinarily wide-ranging conversation between Barnaby Raine and @adam_tooze
I strongly recommend opening a bottle of wine and just enjoying the ride.
open.spotify.com/show/033MAsevPzsgkmHYUPupC8 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
Benjamin Netanyahu is a war criminal.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
dwayne woods
@twittwoods
A Tooze spank 💪🏽
-
Adam Tooze reposted
dwayne woods
@twittwoods
My German pretzel moment
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Sama Hoole
@SamaHoole
A tin of sardines costs about a pound. Here is what is inside.
- More omega-3 than a £12 fish oil capsule (still in the fish, not gone rancid on a shelf)
- 375% of your daily B12 (every plant on earth offers none)
- A third of your vitamin D (more than a British winter gives you)
- 74% of your selenium (the mineral half the country is short of)
- Calcium off the bones (no dairy, softened until you can't feel them)
- 25g of complete protein (every amino acid present)
- Mercury at 0.013ppm (swordfish runs seventy times higher)
The supplement aisle sells you that same sardine in pieces. A capsule of the oil, a tablet of the D, a tub of the selenium, forty quid the lot, half of it oxidising before you get home.
Or the tin. A pound. The whole animal, everything in its right place.
They keep telling you superfoods are exotic and expensive. This one's been on the bottom shelf the whole time. -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Edgerton
@DEHEdgerton
Delighted that my Rise and Fall of the British Nation has been published in China (as Twilight of Empire)! @kingshistory www.163.com/dy/article/L2E8AF2C05521GCR.html?spss=dy_author
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Greedflation meets the China shock: Can Europe's car industry be saved without feeding the cost of living crisis?
One of the things that drives me nuts is when critical discourses succeed each other without logical connection. This chartbook tries to bridge two of recent vintage.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
With reference to the work of @MazzucatoM @SOMO and others on the financialization of European big business.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The newsletter link is here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-460-greedflation-meets
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Percy
@Percy3945
Chartbook 460 Greedflation meets China shock: Can Europe's car industry be saved without making the cost of living crisis worse? , by @adam_tooze open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-460-greedflat…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
derek guy
@dieworkwear
Excited to announce I started a podcast with my friend @trufelman, where here we read classic philosophical works and explore what they can teach us about why we buy, wear, and value the things we do. It’s a basically a podcast for people who love clothes, books, and big ideas.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
oh look, the @FT wrote an entire article on China's plans for fiscal stimulus without once mentioning public debt, black holes, bond vigilantes or the plague
www.ft.com/content/9cf9b393-3ac7-4cfc-9dd1-4fc23831e6a0?s… -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Edgerton
@DEHEdgerton
La lectura del dia! Chartbook 459 Spain v. Argentina 1816-2026: uneven and combined development in the world economy & on the pitch. by @adam_tooze open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-459-spain-v-a…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I kinda like this social scientific underpinning for the critique of "boomer hard-hat industrial policy".
Renaud Foucart
@RenaudFoucart
"Objectively," everything is a footnote on this absolute masterpiece :-) When the median voter is old, the economy fails to modernize, and letting people vote on industrial policy makes things worse
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Weber
@OliverBWeber
Was ein Inhaltsverzeichnis hat, muss fertig werden.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Spain v. Argentina 1816-2026: uneven and combined development in the world economy & on the pitch.
The latest Chartbook just dropped.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-459-spain-v-argentina-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Peter Thiel to receive the Axel Springer Award in Berlin following a Laudatio by Bari Weiss. If you scripted this ...
Dorin Popa
@NiceBastard
Da kommt am 24. September in Berlin zusammen, was zusammen gehört. Peter Thiel erhält den Axel Springer Award 2026. „Wegen seiner Thesen wird Thiel angegriffen und diskreditiert.“ Die Laudatio hält die umstrittene Chefredakteurin von CBS News, Bari Weiss. www.axelspringer.com/de/ax-press-release/peter-thiel-erha…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Novara Media
@novaramedia
UK universities that aggressively targeted students and staff for showing support for Palestine have signed up to a new alliance with the Ministry of Defence (MoD).
35 institutions have joined the Defence Universities Alliance, an initiative which is part of a £182m investment package and which hopes to “boost defence industry skills across the UK” and “support vital research into new defence technologies”.
Founding members will “strengthen connections between academia and the defence sector”, the government said, “helping to support a pipeline of skilled graduates into exciting careers, including cyber security, robotics, AI, aerospace engineering and advanced manufacturing”.
These members include King’s College London (KCL) and University College London (UCL), which combined have opened at least 50 disciplinary cases against staff and students who took part in pro-Palestine protest activity from October 2023 through to November 2025, according to a joint investigation by Al Jazeera and Liberty Investigates.
13 of the 26 people investigated by KCL were involved in the encampment protest at the university that started in May 2025. One student told Al Jazeera and Liberty Investigates that she was banned from campus after posting in a pro-Gaza WhatsApp group that she felt “sick” after finding out one of her lecturers had spent four years in the Israeli army.
A spokesperson for KCL told Al Jazeera and Liberty Investigates the university has a duty to investigate all complaints it receives “and we do this thoroughly and fairly”.
KCL is one of many UK universities to already have deep ties with the MoD and the defence industry, and participates in Hack 4 MoD, a university module that lets postgraduate students tackle live defence and security problems.
The British arms manufacturer BAE Systems also has extensive links with UK universities, including active strategic partnerships with Manchester, Strathclyde, Cranfield, Nottingham, and Southampton. All these institutions bar Southampton are members of DUA.
BAE manufactures vital components of F35 fighter jets, which are used extensively by Israel’s military to kill civilians and destroy civilian infrastructure in Gaza.
“The Defence Universities Alliance represents a dangerous escalation in the militarisation of education,” a spokesperson for Campaign Against the Arms Trade told Novara Media. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ho-fung Hung
@hofunghung
they are reportedly arrested for selling Emily Feng's book (Chinese translation published in Taiwan)
William Nee
@williamnee
More disturbing news from #hongkong:
Hong Kong national security police raid 2 independent bookstores, arrest 5 for alleged sedition
hongkongfp.com/2026/07/15/breaking-hong-kong-police-raid-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Lloyd Mathias
@LloydMathias
OMG! Thierry Henry’s deconstruction of the build-up to #spain second goal, on @FOXSports is pure gold!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Feels a little ai scripted, but this well describes what happened last night.
Einstein De La Hess
@Einstein_psg
🚨J’AI RAISON DEPUIS LE DÉBUT
👉Cette demi-finale contre l’Espagne n’est pas seulement une défaite. C’est l’échec d’une philosophie de jeu.
Depuis deux ans, je répète que le football moderne est entré dans une nouvelle ère : celle du pressing, du contre-pressing et de la récupération haute.
Beaucoup m’ont insulté en expliquant que seul le talent individuel comptait encore. Ce soir, l’Espagne a apporté la démonstration inverse.
👉Pendant tout le match, les Espagnols ont étouffé la France. Nos quatre attaquants ont été privés de ballons, non parce qu’ils auraient soudain perdu leur talent, mais parce que le système espagnol empêchait tout simplement la France de jouer. Le football moderne ne commence plus avec les attaquants ; il commence par la récupération du ballon. Celui qui récupère haut impose son jeu. Celui qui subit ne fait que courir après le ballon.
👉C’est exactement ce que Luis Enrique a construit au PSG. Beaucoup y voyaient un choix esthétique. En réalité, c’est une révolution tactique. L’Espagne applique les mêmes principes : onze joueurs qui attaquent, onze joueurs qui défendent, pressing coordonné, contre-pressing immédiat et récupération à trente mètres du but adverse.
👉À l’inverse, Didier Deschamps est resté fidèle à un football d’une autre époque : bloc plus bas, transitions, attente de l’exploit individuel. Tant que l’opposition est moyenne, cela peut suffire. Mais face à une équipe d’élite qui maîtrise parfaitement le pressing, ce modèle explose.
👉Le parcours de la France a entretenu une illusion. L’Irak, la Suède, la Norvège et le Maroc ne représentent pas le niveau de l’Espagne. Dès que le niveau tactique s’est élevé, toutes les limites du système français sont apparues.
👉Pour moi, au plus haut niveau, seul le palmarès collectif compte. Les statistiques individuelles, les records ou les titres de meilleur buteur n’ont de valeur que s’ils conduisent à remporter les plus grandes compétitions. Le football moderne ne sacre plus le meilleur joueur ; il sacre le meilleur collectif. Cette demi-finale en est une illustration éclatante. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sander Tordoir
@SanderTordoir
Scenario is on -- nice bump to Dutch nominal GDP incoming.
ASML just lifted net sales for '26 to €43- €45bn, from €36-40bn.
With the firm saying its customers "continue to accelerate their capacity expansion plans" while "order intake remained extremely strong in H1 2026."
Sander Tordoir
@SanderTordoir
Asias stunning semiconductor boom will inevitably push capex into Dutch semiconductor machinery.
The GDP growth estimates for the Netherlands for 2026 and 2027 - 0.8 and 1.1 per cent per the Dutch central bank - seem too low to me.
Outturns will be higher.
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Reuters China
@ReutersChina
EXCLUSIVE: China detains US seismologist who has studied North Korean nuclear tests www.reuters.com/world/us/china-detains-us-seismologist-wh…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Amanda Mull
@amandamull
I know we're talking a lot about young people's literacy but a grown man on LinkedIn asked for a version of this with shorter, easier to understand paragraphs (they are already short because it is running in print) and I'm begging you guys to read something other than LLM outputs
Amanda Mull
@amandamull
For August’s Businessweek—The Grift Issue!—I wrote about skyrocketing rates of credit card chargebacks, which are up 46% since 2021. It’s driven by two things: retailers behaving in scammy ways, and shoppers trying to scam them back. Gift link: www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-07-13/credit-card-ho…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Peter Verovšek
@PeterVerovsek
The Australian Broadcasting Corporation's Religion & Ethics website has just republished a combined and slightly revised version of two essays I recently published on Habermas. it is an honor to be able to showcase my work to a new audience down under
www.abc.net.au/religion/jurgen-habermas-death-as-end-of-v… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Tribune
@tribunemagazine
Tribune has a new podcast! Barnaby Raine hosts postscript, a series of conversations on the future of the left amid the slow death of Western civilisation.
Episode 1 sees Barnaby and @adam_tooze debate whether liberal politics can save us now. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Anton Jäger
@AntonJaegermm
An important piece, yet limited by its refusal to see that there is no response to the AI-apocalypse that doesn’t imply meddling with private property. As @adam_tooze put it, imagine doing nuclear non-proliferation if the Manhattan Project was privately run.
Nikhil Pal Singh
@nikhil_palsingh
Persuasive…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
Adam Tooze: “I’m also not a person of faith, and I don’t think most people of my kind are — we’re not carried by the promise of any great emancipation. It’s telling that there’s been a revival of religion in certain segments of the British upper-middle and professional class, because one feels the lack of it — especially, I’d say, in the face of the threat of AI, which now intrudes directly into the realm of our own intellectual production.”: open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-458-poscript-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Aaron Freedman
@freedaaron
Really appreciated this dialogue as getting to the crux of what “communism vs liberalism” or “reform vs revolution”” means today: can a project of human liberation ever come from within Western civilization, with its history of such deep violence?
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chartbook 458 just dropped. A conversation with Barnaby Raine about politics, economics, continuities of violence and hyper-agency. #1 of Postscript, B's new podcast series with @tribunemagazine
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-458-poscript-a-convers… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
Que sauver du naufrage de la civilisation occidentale? Comment y construire des coalitions capables d’exercer réellement un pouvoir "progressiste" qui minimise la violence? Avec quelles priorités? Riche entretien d’@adam_tooze avec Barnaby Raine.
open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-458-poscript-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chartbook 458 just dropped. A conversation with Barnaby Raine about politics, economics, continuities of violence and hyper-agency. #1 of Postscript, B's new podcast series with @tribunemagazine
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-458-poscript-a-convers… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Greg Kable
@GregKable
The twist nobody had on their VW bingo card
A deal to keep the Osnabrück plant operating by building components for Israel's Iron Dome system is reportedly being blocked by Qatar – Volkswagen's third-largest shareholder
Geopolitics has become part of the boardroom
@VWGroup -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
I wonder what would happen to tech valuations if you let the trio of Raghuram Rajan, Bill White, and Tom Sargent manage the Fed's response to US fiscal policy and to US financial instability threats.
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Marc Andreessen is now part of the Fed. www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary2…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Phil 🆓🌍🧩🎲
@Phil_Free_
“‘The bond market’ isn’t an irresistible objective force like the weather or an avalanche.
Which is why the silence about the [BoE] is so significant.”
Voldemort on Threadneedle street. The Bank of England & the "haunted house" of English politics
open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-449-voldemort… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Rawson 🙏
@PonderingDurian
Top 5 long form reads of the week:
1. @adam_tooze's chartbook has been on fire lately, but this is my favorite:
Link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-455-the-ai-boom-chinas
2. If you want taste, you're gonna have to eat by @jxnlco
Link: x.com/jxnlco/article/2073819508729684462
3. The reading guide to Chinese biotech by @NikoMcCarty (yes, curation plays)
Link: nikomc.com/china-guide/
4. Unitree's Impossible Trajectory is Still Overlooked by @SemiAnalysis_
Link: newsletter.semianalysis.com/p/chinas-unitree-will-dominat…
5. Crypto theses on $Hype and solana:Grass7B4RdKfBCjTKgSqnXkqjwiGvQyFbuSCUJr3XXjs respectively by @multicoin and @YanLiberman
Hype Link: multicoin.capital/2026/06/25/hyperliquid-hype-analysis-an…
Grass Link: x.com/YanLiberman/status/2073009827580629239
***
Self-dealing, but think my investment theses on Automation, Multipolarity, and Demographics is also a worthwhile read.
Link: delphiventures.io/writings/the-decade-ahead
Yan Liberman
@YanLiberman
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Angelica 🌐⚛️🇹🇼🇨🇳🇺🇸
@AngelicaOung
Lol Zhu Rongji’s cuts was to satisfy WTO accession requirements. They were so severe Gordon Chang predicted Zhu was in a double-bind: either he won’t be able to make the cuts or it will be so dire that China would collapse.
The trauma on the Dongbei rust belt is generational. They just made a TV drama about it called the Longest Season.
OK Then
@okaythenfuture
The West just dreams delusionally of China waking up one day and saying "Okay we will deindustrialize now".
China has looked at the arc of human history and said no,
we will simply make our plants more efficient, more automated, and we will retain the entire grammar of industrial logic and production.
Why on earth would one abandon Industrial prominence if one has attained it?
Sadly the West should ask their predecessors why on earth they thought it was a good idea to empower Chinese civilization via tech transfers in the first place. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The cost surge for the summer BBQ in the US is driven by the beef, as shown in the Financial Times. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
This is becoming an increasingly important story: "A Chinese thin tank estimates the number of people in flexible employment - without a permanent full-time contract - rising to 320 million this year from 280 million in 2025, about 44% of China's workforce. China's gig economy has become a crucial employment buffer as the property crisis wipes out construction jobs and manufacturers shed workers through automation and cost-cutting amid tariffs, overcapacity and price wars."
www.reuters.com/business/world-at-work/chinas-booming-gig… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Brazilian commentary on the multi-decade fall from grace of the national football team is now reaching Max Weber levels "The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism"
Decline of Catholicism in Brazil -> team lacks joy & soul etc
(fwiw, i don't buy civilizational args!) -
Adam Tooze reposted
Anton Jäger
@AntonJaegermm
Lenin said you have to be "as radical as reality itself" but maybe the problem is reality no longer exists
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump on USA-Belgium: "If they beat us, they can be really proud. The other way, if they beat us, we'll say -- I say it was rigged, just like the election was rigged in 2020, but I won't get into that."
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump on USA-Belgium: "If they beat us, they can be really proud. The other way, if they beat us, we'll say -- I say it was rigged, just like the election was rigged in 2020, but I won't get into that."
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Rachel Kryshak
@RachelKryshak
To be clear: Whether it is or isn’t a red to Balogun is now irrelevant. Government interference is a violation of FIFA Article 2 & 15, and the punishment is disqualification and suspension. Nepal was suspended.
This is an admission of the violation. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sander Tordoir
@SanderTordoir
The Vikings - Nordic pension funds - storming the beaches of North America in search for exceptional returns?
Given Brads criticism of the profit dollar paradigm it seems like it’s a case of Viking-on-Viking violence. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Callinicos @alexcallinicos.bsky.social
@alex_callinicos
Adam Tooze:
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
substack.com/@sankaran/note/p-140856687?r=r6t
Barchart
@Barchart
BREAKING 🚨: China
Chinese Stocks are underperforming the rest of the world by the most in a quarter century 📉 🤯 👀 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ralph Leonard
@buffsoldier_96
My latest piece for @compactmag on how this World Cup shows just how blurred and messy national boundaries are:
(link in next tweet) -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Woke up in Singapore and realized I had had a very weird dream in which "the Viking of macroeconomics" @brad_Setser merged with the figure of Erling Haaland. And now I can't unsee it!
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Very much agree with @adam_tooze --
The most important thing to know about the international financial system right now is that the dollar's share of a global equity market index is higher than the dollar's share of official fx reserves
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Michael Lazarus
@Mblaz39
Barnaby Raine interviews @adam_tooze on new @tribunemagazine podcast. Lucid discussion of political freedom, intellectual tradition and working class strategy. Especially valuable critique of Keynes. www.youtube.com/watch?v=zFeZ8VF7Hlw
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Very much agree with @adam_tooze --
The most important thing to know about the international financial system right now is that the dollar's share of a global equity market index is higher than the dollar's share of official fx reserves
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Philipp Straehl
@Philipp_Straehl
VW, Porsche und Mercedes haben Probleme.
Einige haben mit der Wirtschaftspolitik zu tun. Viele sind hausgemacht.
Dazu kommt, dass in den guten Jahren kein Geld für schlechte Jahre zurückgelegt wurde. Dieses Geld fehlt nun.
Dividenden: -
Adam Tooze reposted
Gabriel Zucman
@gabriel_zucman
Now that the California billionaire tax is officially on the ballot this November, voters deserve logical arguments.
This guest essay in today’s New York Times, by two economists from the Hoover Institution, is based on a shocking logical mistake. 🧵 -
Adam Tooze reposted
juna elena
@mayjunejuna
appreciate @adam_tooze doing the numbers on tempelhofer feld
-
Adam Tooze reposted
John Bennett
@JohnBennettBBC
It’s incredible that over 50 players at this World Cup are from the Paris area.
If only someone had made a BBC documentary about it…. They have!
It was a great experience talking to players, coaches & historians about the magic on Paris’s streets.
👇
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct6cdf -
Adam Tooze reposted
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
Scoop from @fbermingham: “Sefcovic said on Monday that talks were "intensive, focused and constructive" and that there was "much more understanding for the common challenges for the European situation from our Chinese counterparts than we had before".”
www.scmp.com/news/china/article/3359222/china-signals-ope… -
Adam Tooze reposted
ACEMAXX ANALYTICS
@acemaxx
This is a very interesting piece b/c it shows that @Adam_Tooze is trying to occupy a middle ground b/w two increasingly polarized camps, chart @surplusmagazin www.surplusmagazin.de/china-schock-2-0-deutsche-wirtschaf…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Aron Roberts
@aronro
TY for this @SluggerOToole share!
If these stats on Southern Irish Catholics in North America during the Revolutionary War period are accurate, that complicates the "Presbyterian Revolution" narrative here by @adam_tooze, which is in itself fascinating!
adamtooze.substack.com/p/anchovies-and-fishflation-innova… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Alien v. Predator or MAGA meets AI - a "crossover" monument to the USA at 250.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-456-alien-v-predator-or -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
We seem to have hit a nerve with this one.
Close to 100k views across platforms in 24 hours for an academic paper on tabloid framing and the German heating law.
I suspect it's because so many countries are watching the same playbook unfold at home.
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
NEW RESEARCH: One German tabloid coined one word. "Heizungshammer" spread to 1,100+ articles and helped to effectively kill Germany's heating law.
We analysed 333 BILD articles to trace how tabloid framing became legislation.
Out today, open access:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629626003038 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
Today's article is an absurdly deep dive into what life was like in America 100 years ago, in 1926, on America's 150th
Some favorite factoids about life in 1926:
- Farming is collapsing: Agriculture’s employment share fell from 50% in 1870 to <25% in 1926. The price of cotton & corn fell 50% after WWI. percent.
- Manufacturing productivity growth is insane: In 1910, it took ~15 hours to put together a Model T; by 1926, a new car rolls off an assembly line every 10 seconds. A vehicle that cost the avg worker two years’ wages before World War I cost 3 months’ earnings in 1926
- Americans are obsessed, obsessed, obsessed with cars: 1920s Kansas had more vehicles than France
- The influence of flappers on fashion is quantifiable: The amount of fabric in the avg dress fell from 20 yards in 1910 to 7 yards in 1926
- Prohibition killed a lot of people: 12k people died in 1927 from drinking industrial alcohol that the feds had poisoned on purpose to discourage consumption—adjusted for population, that'd be the mortality equivalent of 36k people dying in 2026, which is roughly the number of car deaths
- Sports were very different: No TV means no commercial breaks, and players were in a rush. In one doubleheader against the New York Yankees on September 26, 1926, the St. Louis Browns won 6–1 in 72 minutes and then won 6–2 in 55 minutes with a one-hour break in between
- 1926 might have been the high-water mark for literacy in US history: The number of books published annually had doubled since the 1910s; magazine advertising revenues grew by 500%
- All this change was driving ppl crazy: In Germany, where medical records were better, the number of patients registered in mental hospitals grew from 40,375 in 1870 to 220,881 in 1910. Over the same period, the share of patients admitted to general hospitals for illnesses of the nervous system rose from 44 to 60%.
www.derekthompson.org/p/america-1926-an-absurdly-deep-dive -
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Berman
@economicsnoah
Scoop: As it pitched the Trump administration on loosening chip export controls last year, Nvidia told the U.S. government that its most formidable Chinese competitor, Huawei, could have “the flexibility to satisfy global AI chip demand.” More details: www.thewirechina.com/2026/07/02/nvidia-uses-the-specter-o…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ian Johnson
@iandenisjohnson
How the 2009 murder of a Uyghur songwriter sparked an uprising--and gave the CCP the justification it needed for its erasure of Uyghur cultural identity. @MinjianArchives latest newsletter by the brilliant Isabelle Mo.
(Chinese/English no paywall)
chinaunofficialarchives.substack.com/p/xj75 -
Adam Tooze reposted
derek guy
@dieworkwear
The women in this video are engaging in a process known as waulking, which was historically done by soaking tweed in stale urine, then beating it until it softened and shrank. As urine ferments, it breaks down into ammonia, which cuts through the lanolin (grease) inherent in wool
Brian Gàidhlig 🏴
@BhriainGael
A group of women singing while finishing Harris tweed in the Outer Hebrides islands of Scotland in the early 1940s
A time capsule of a long vanished era.
🏴💙🎶This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jean-Michel Glachant
@JMGlachant
In Wall Street Journal
In roughly a decade, after 2014,
Chinese car makers increased their home country market share by 2/3
and arrived at 67% nationally
Dwarfing all the westerners (US or EU) -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ian Johnson
@iandenisjohnson
It was an honor to review this book. The link should go to a gift version of the article but DM me if you need a PDF.
Foreign Affairs
@ForeignAffairs
Xu Guoqi’s new book, “The Idea of China,” examines the origin of China’s identity crisis—and the different paths the country might have taken. Read @iandenisjohnson’s review: www.foreignaffairs.com/reviews/who-china-ian-johnson
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Everyone is talking about the China shock 2.0 that is reverberating through Europe. What we aren't talking about is the financial repression that contains something far more spectacular. Check out the latest chartbook newsletter here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-455-the-ai-boom-chinas -
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Another superb Tooze essay, on the centrality of financial repression -- external and internal -- to the Chinese model
1/
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The AI boom, China's walled-in-wealth and the financial barriers that separate the two. - World Economy July 2026.
Latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Continuing & widening the exchange with @SanderTordoir & @Brad_Setser @michaelxpettis
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-455-the-ai-boom-chinas -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Strange fault lines in the world economy in the summer of 2026: The US is refusing the greentech revolution that is triggering China shock 2.0 in Europe. Meanwhile Beijing blocks China's wealth from joining the AI boom. Check out latest Chartbook newsletter.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The AI boom, China's walled-in-wealth and the financial barriers that separate the two. - World Economy July 2026.
Latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Continuing & widening the exchange with @SanderTordoir & @Brad_Setser @michaelxpettis
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-455-the-ai-boom-chinas -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jean Christopher (Chris) Mittelstaedt
@jcmittelstaedt
New CCP Membership data is out for 2025 - grew 1% to 101,286,000 people - share of >61 years old rose to 30% (retirees 22% of total), % of students fell to 2.5%, % of public servants (党政机关工作人员) has been decreasing as well - only 7.3% (down from 8% 2021)
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
What I find puzzling is not the adoption of a "managed trade" framework by previously liberal champions of globalization.
But that Krugman & others do not seem to know that the European auto industry has already made a choice to not die
How? By partnering with Chinese EV firms!
Mike
@Doranimated
Krugman boards the Trump train. Who could have predicted this?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
Adoption of air conditioning in Europe at U.S. levels would bring massive health benefits, while the emission implications would be minuscule, unlike many suggest - and, done right, it would help the clean energy transition by boosting electrification and clean energy. 🧵
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Frontier markets are facing nasty rates, but not due to wider spreads. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
MichaelIngle
@ChinaNotes
China’s enormous size does have advantages. It is hard to conceive of a country with a population 25 times the size of the UK or France at converging per capita GDP levels.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Tolouse is all widebodies. Hamburg is 321s and 320 parts for Airbus China. But total imports are down, so this isn't a Hamburg story (chinese import data in USD terms)
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Excellent essay. No doubt one of the defining features of the China shock has been how it has reallocated the global surplus.
The old exportweltmeister has been dethroned -- and China has world scale in advanced manufacturing, which is new and disruptive
1/
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China shock 2.0 and mercantilist-on-mercantilist violence.
A riff on Davos, China, Germany, @Brad_Setser @SanderTordoir and the echoes of history in Dalian/Port Arthur.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-454-china-shock-20-and -
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
The 2006 Economist article that the US was at risk of putting too much pressure on China b/c of its then wildly undervalued currency was directed in part at me. Guess I have been arguing with the magazine on this issue for ~ 20ys ...
Sander Tordoir
@SanderTordoir
The Economist has a history of being way too relaxed about Chinas undervalued currency and surpluses.
Here it is from 2006: “China's vast purchases of American Treasury bonds - designed to hold down the yuan -have kept [US] long-term bond yields lower.”
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
‘Hobsbawm’s canonization was a Western tribute to a great historian who had erected a monument to Europe amid its decline, when the lights and shadows of its civilization appeared, in retrospect, as a vanished past, as impressive as it was tragic.’ www.theideasletter.org/essay/the-century-of-eric-hobsbawm/
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
Western battery makers aim for quality at the level of defects per million battery cells.
CATL aims for quality at the level of defects per billion battery cells.
Really fascinating piece on CATL and its obsession with quality by @stevelevine www.theinformation.com/articles/chinese-megabillionaire-b… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Finbarr Bermingham
@fbermingham
Read the full piece on his Chartbook newsletter. Really worth your time
open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-454-china-sho… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sander Tordoir
@SanderTordoir
Tooze has made a balanced set of observations in various places.
His frame of Germany turning to the yuan exchange rate - so obviously undervalued - as an ‘escape valve’, struck home.
A way to address Chinas imbalances whilst squaring Berlins internal fissures on China policy.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China shock 2.0 and mercantilist-on-mercantilist violence.
A riff on Davos, China, Germany, @Brad_Setser @SanderTordoir and the echoes of history in Dalian/Port Arthur.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-454-china-shock-20-and -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China shock 2.0 and mercantilist-on-mercantilist violence.
A riff on Davos, China, Germany, @Brad_Setser @SanderTordoir and the echoes of history in Dalian/Port Arthur.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-454-china-shock-20-and -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There is Wall Street and then there is JP Morgan. Source: Financial Times. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Data-Center Boom Is Sparking a Third Wave of Inflation. Is AI going to truly promise an increased productivity? If so, will it come in time to affect inflation? Chart below from the WSJ article by Justin Lahart. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
China's new electrification target is here: electricity should make up 35% of final energy consumption by 2030, up from about 30% today.
The EU aims to go from 24% to 32% in the same time period. A good goal, but incredibly ambitious. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
it was surprising to hear @UniteSharon criticize Ed Miliband's record as 'job destroying' climate activism.
We hope she reconsiders, on the day where UK is under extreme heat warnings.
The climate crisis is real, we need a Chancellor who fights it.
www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/jun/24/progressive-econ… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
As a proud union member, this short-sightedness of union management infuriates me.
They're fighting Miliband because he's 'destroyed fossil jobs', cause he's too green.
All this in a week of boiling temperatures.
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
it was surprising to hear @UniteSharon criticize Ed Miliband's record as 'job destroying' climate activism.
We hope she reconsiders, on the day where UK is under extreme heat warnings.
The climate crisis is real, we need a Chancellor who fights it.
www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/jun/24/progressive-econ… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The stock market is about to digest a lot of new equity, according to Bloomberg. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A durian glut. Be afraid. Be very afraid!
The Straits Times
@straits_times
Durian prices in Malaysia crash to 16 cents each as oversupply hits market www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/durian-prices-in-malays…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Bilal Qureshi's article on the The Forgotten Final Chapter of W.E.B. Du Bois on Bloomberg is fascinating. More suggested readings featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-06-19/in-ghana-w-e-b… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Today is the 85th anniversary of Nazi Germany's invasion of the Soviet Union unleashing a multi-faceted campaign of racialized violence, anti-Bolshevism & conquest and settlement.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-453-22-june-1941-the-85th -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
We talk a lot about China’s famous universities. But the huge surge in spending has come in corporate R&D, according to rand.org. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I look at this very nice graph @NewLeftEViews and ask myself, what exactly are we arguing about? The upturn in the export demand share of Chinese manuf value added 2020-2025, from 24 to 27% ? That is what the kerfuffle is about?
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
The OECD's TiVA data are cool. And there's an argument that export data overstate China's external dependence. But the conclusion here is not supported.
It's worth looking more closely: they do a lot to clarify different narratives about China's rebalancing efforts, the role of external demand, which global markets have been driving it, the key inflection points.
The short version: the rebalancing pursued for over a decade stall around 2015, when the big high tech manufacturing push begins, while foreign- and domestic demand move inversely after 2019, and the investment share remains at a level close to its 2009 peak.
Note: when compared to other major emerging markets during this same period, the household and foreign components are hugely aberrant, respectively 21% below and 16% above the average.
1/5
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China’s manufacturing sector has always benefited from export demand but c. three quarters of production is sold domestically. (Source of chart mentioned on the figure) More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
This is a photograph I took yesterday when I visited Tilton House, Keynes’s final home and place of death. The house is in a sad state of disrepair.
Tilton sits at the foot of Firle Beacon, in the South Downs. It began as a Sussex farmhouse and was given a Georgian face in the eighteenth century. It has always been a lease from the Gage Estate.
In August 1925, after Maynard Keynes married Lydia Lopokova, he took the lease on Tilton. From then on, Keynes divided his life: London in the week, Cambridge for working weekends, and Tilton for the rest.
The Treatise on Money (1930) and, above all, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936) took shape here.
Keynes was moderately wealthy and gave the house electric light, central heating, and French paintings. He added substantial acreage and farmed it through a manager, playing the “gentleman farmer” à la Clarkson.
He loved the place enough to take its name. Raised to the peerage in 1942, he became Baron Keynes of Tilton. He died here in April 1946, and his ashes were scattered on the Downs above. Lydia stayed on, increasingly alone, until her own death in 1981.
Robert Skidelsky, Keynes’s great biographer, took the lease in 1986 and wrote at Keynes’s own desk. When he was ennobled in 1991, he took the name of Baron Skidelsky of Tilton.
More recently, Tilton became a yoga-and-writing retreat, but the business moved to a different location some time ago.
Standing in front of Tilton yesterday, I thought how odd it is that we let this happen at all. The National Trust already keeps Monk’s House, where the Woolfs lived. The Charleston Trust keeps Charleston, a few minutes down the same lane. Tilton is the missing corner of that triangle.
Surely someone, the National Trust or a smaller foundation, could take Tilton on and open it. It would not take much, and it is worth doing. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Europe's Machiavellian moment? Riffing on @AntonJaegermm recent piece in the @nytimes on Luuk van Middelaar.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-452-europes-machiavellian -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China’s manufacturing sector has always benefited from export demand but c. three quarters of production is sold domestically. (Source of chart mentioned on the figure) More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Monetary policy is tightening again (unweighted average of central banks) according to Bloomberg. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
America's Achilles' heel in trade: Three Dependencies shown by McKinsey in this chart below. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Le Grand Continent
@Grand_Continent
Pour l'historien britannique de la polycrise, le wok et le piment sont devenus des instruments empiriques nécessaires dans le monde du réveil chinois.
Découvrez le succulent porc cuit deux fois à la Sichuanaise dans la recette préparée par @adam_tooze.
legrandcontinent.eu/fr/dimanches/le-porc-cuit-deux-fois-a… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How fast is the US Treasury market changing (with plumbing new debts), according to the Economist. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Are we in a tri polar world, investment super-cycle? More on energy, history, and politics featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
Global CO2 emissions largely plateaued since 2013 thanks to clean energy growth - "next time someone shows you a graph of CO2 concentrations arguing that nothing is changing, show them how much worse it'd have been had we really done nothing to change our emissions trajectory."
Zeke Hausfather
@hausfath
Global CO2 emissions have plateaued since 2013, leading to a slower growth in atmospheric CO2 than would have otherwise been the case. In a new analysis at The Climate Brink, I've taken look at what would have happened if emissions had continued to grow.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
This is extraordinarily rare.
In fact, according to a key figure in the German business community (who is a dear friend of mine), it's unprecedented.
An op-ed, two pages, centerpiece, in Germany’s most important economic newspaper (the Handelsblatt) that begs the German establishment to stop looking at China via the prism of propaganda. And it's by their Shanghai bureau chief - not some outside contributor.
The title is "The China debate cannot continue like this!" and the article makes the case that it's suicidal, from a German and European standpoint, to keep reducing China to false caricatures rather than facts.
In effect it's rubbish in, rubbish out: if you tell people lies about China - whichever direction they go (anti or pro) - then obviously the policies that come out will be rubbish, designed for a mirage of a country that exists only in people's imagination.
Needless to say, this is absolutely music to my ears because it's literally the main point I've been making in my advocacy around China for now almost 10 years. Some are finally seeing the light...
I also believe, as I argued in my article "Are Western media turning China-friendly?" last year (arnaudbertrand.substack.com/p/are-western-media-turning-c…) that this type of coverage was bound to happen, and there will be more and more of it.
Why? For a very simple structural reason: China is now too powerful to coerce. The West, and Europe in particular, just don't have the leverage anymore. Which means that if you tell China to do something and they don't want to, they just won't do it. Period.
In this situation, incapable of coercing, your only remaining choice is... convincing. And what do you need if you want to convince someone? Well, you need to understand them: understand how they think, how they behave, what drives them, what they actually want.
In other words: the moment coercion stops being an option, not only does propaganda stop being useful, it begins to be actively harmful as genuine understand becomes a strategic necessity. Reality is finally becoming profitable again.
Which means, if you're a journalist reading this and you're peddling some of your usual lies, describing China as some sort of cartoonish dictatorial dystopia that's simultaneously on the verge of collapse yet a "threat" to the whole world (in short, if you write on China for The Economist or the FT), be on notice: the real threat to your country isn't China. It's you. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
India is facing some seriously unpaletable choices, according to the data presented by the Reserve Bank of India. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Read Today's Chartbook Top Links here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-1125-ai-segmentation-i…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How strong are AI players from China? It appears that Alibaba and Bytedance are the only major non-US AI players that are present across all five layers of the AI stack. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Moi, sur le second choc chinois, dans Atlantico
(en francais)
atlantico.fr/article/decryptage/choc-chinois-le-grand-dec… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ben Judah
@b_judah
The growing risk of a collapse of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation system, of which the Gulf Stream is part, is nothing less than the number one long-term security threat to our way of life in Britain, Europe and the Western world in the era in which we live.
The consequences on our societies of an AMOC collapse would be simply devastating for Britain especially, beyond anything imaginable but a full blown super pandemic or nuclear war — with scientists modelling temperatures dropping around 15.c and half of our arable land being lost.
This is just one of many climate catastrophes starring at us of the modelling and the observed data and is why it is why Labour has continued to place such importance on Net Zero and international climate talks despite the Greens and progressive activists now looking elsewhere post-October 7th and the Conservatives joining Reform in now campaigning against them.
It is also one of the most important areas our foreign policy has and must continue to diverge from Trump’s America, an active opponent to progress on this agenda. It is also why despite the huge security, technological and industrial risks they pose we need an active and substantive dialogue here as far as is possible with China — which Labour has pushed for.
David Ullrich
@DavidUllrich202
Mysterious ‘cold blob’ in the Atlantic suggests the AMOC is weakening
A patch of ocean south-east of Greenland is the only place on Earth that is cooling, and it could be a sign that the warm water “conveyor belt” in the Atlantic is slowing down
www.newscientist.com/article/2529078-mysterious-cold-blob… -
Adam Tooze reposted
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
High modernism was good actually and “the state having a plan” is the foundation of industrial society, that doesn’t change no matter how much you cherry pick. Someone should write an updated, withering review entitled “Reading James Scott in Beijing” or sth.
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
Have I ever mentioned that I really dislike this book and I don’t see at all why people rave over it?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
“The real surprise from the OECD’s subsidy numbers is that it cost China less than $18bn in sectoral support over 15 years to build an industry that can now provide more clean power than the world can readily absorb.”
Assaad Razzouk
@AssaadRazzouk
"Since when were solar panels just another commodity? They are a technological miracle. They make us into farmers of the sun"
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Thomas Fazi
@battleforeurope
Crazy that this is getting barely any coverage. This year’s European Press Prize was just awarded to an investigative report by the Dutch newspaper De Volkskrant. It is entitled “What the Wounds Tell” and in it the journalists Maud Effting and Willem Feenstra document the cases of 114 children in Gaza under the age of 15 who were struck by a single bullet to the head or chest. Almost all of them died or were left severely disabled. They chose to document only the cases of boys and girls under the age of 15 (though often much younger: aged 3, 4 or 7) because these are children who can be immediately identified as such. “A single bullet in these parts of the body is a clear indication that these children were deliberately targeted“, the two journalists write.
This is the article: www.volkskrant.nl/kijkverder/v/2025/schotwonden-palestijn… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Peter Unfried
@peterunfried
Die Lebenserwartung in Deutschland macht man Dir nicht zum Vorwurf. Das ist vielleicht das Einzige, das man Dir nicht zum Vorwurf macht.“
@adam_tooze (l.) heute im Berliner Ensemble bei „Habeck live“ zum Gastgeber. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
On my way to Paris for a keynote on 'Michel Aglietta and the ambivalence of money'
and I am going to risk a joke about objet petit s -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
According to World Government Bonds, right now, Morocco’s ten-year bond yield is lower than that of the United States! More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Anton Jäger
@AntonJaegermm
Interesting, even for someone who thinks AI is a terminally boring topic. Would have gone well with some Kluge:
"Modernism, Alexander Kluge observed somewhere, is our classicism, our classical antiquity. That presumes that it is over; but if so, when did it begin?"
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What times are these? Crying fire in a Berlin lecture theatre.
Reflecting on moments of dysphoria in thinking about our current situation.
The latest Chartbook just dropped:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/what-times-are-these -
Adam Tooze reposted
Marc Chandler
@marcmakingsense
@adam_tooze writes on excess capacity in PRC solar panels. Yet, overcapacity is viewed as primarily a PRC issue. In US, one of largest producers of food, ~20% of US children on nutritional supplement. That is what my new book Surplus addresses. www.ft.com/content/b6cac184-75a4-47ab-94c5-5eb8c92cd407
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What times are these? Crying fire in a Berlin lecture theatre.
Reflecting on moments of dysphoria in thinking about our current situation.
The latest Chartbook just dropped:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/what-times-are-these -
Adam Tooze reposted
FarmPolicy
@FarmPolicy
1/ Roughly 28% of U.S. #soybean production is in an area experiencing #drought conditions, according to the @USDA weekly Ag in Drought report:
www.usda.gov/sites/default/files/documents/AgInDrought.pdf -
Adam Tooze reposted
Torsten Menge
@torte81
Jede/r Grüne, die/der als Reaktion auf die Nichtwahl Deutschlands in den UN-Sicherheitsrat von Respekt von Menschenrechten und Völkerrecht spricht, sollte zu diesem Video Stellung nehmen müssen.
Patrick Kaczmarczyk
@pat_kaczmarczyk
Dass die Grünen bei dem Debakel auf die Bundesregierung zeigen, zeugt von einem beeindruckenden Mangel an Selbstreflexion. Waren sie nicht maßgeblich mitverantwortlich für die Außenpolitik der letzten Jahre? War Baerbock nicht das Aushängeschild der unerträglichen Doppelmoral?
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Anthropic adoption has overtaken OpenAI adoption among US businesses in the US! More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/anthropic-overtakes-openai-chinas
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
US AI giants are issuing debt all over the world. Google/Alphabet is leading the charge, according to Bloomberg. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Nvidia really isn’t a second Cisco. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"bubble concentrations" of the US stock market in the spring of this year, shown by Michael Harnett at the Bank of America. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Guizhou-style Spaetzle with Weisskraut and Kohlrabi … recommended!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Behold the birth of … Ma Po Maultaschen! Sino-Swabian fusion.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
$22.6 bn profit-sharing at Samsung: The biggest profit-sharing exercise ever? More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Power business, energised. The reality of power investments and trends from Bloomberg. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This is interesting
New Left Review
@NewLeftReview
Dylan Riley (@DylanRiley6216) on comparing Marx and Weber:
‘A general lesson is contained here: standpoints are politico-epistemological achievements, not unmediated expressions of social being.’
newleftreview.org/sidecar/posts/angles-of-vision -
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
If the clean energy transition proceeds like any other technological transition, it will indeed have failed. Only the demise of the old saves the climate.
A false beat in a good Liebreich piece.
Michael Liebreich - @MLiebreich.bsky.social
@MLiebreich
My latest for Bloomberg: "We are about to see the Great Clean Energy Acceleration 2.0 – a discontinuity in energy markets as profound as the oil shocks of the 1970s, and one that could bring forward peak fossil fuel use and emissions to this side of 2030." about.bnef.com/insights/clean-energy/liebreich-the-great-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Now it makes sense, UK's most conservative central bank governor in decades has a PhD in the cotton industry.
No wonder his monetarist advisors are running rings around him.
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
I've written about how @AndyBurnhamGM or @ZackPolanski can stop worrying about bond vigilantes' veto on big, transformative ambitions.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/may/21/politicians… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Hey @FT let me correct this for your readers -
Has the Trump administration collapsed the Cuban economy ?
Financial Times
@FT
Cuba is facing one of its worst crises in decades. The communist island is grappling with severe shortages, while sanctions from Washington are squeezing key sources of revenue and oil supplies. John Reed discusses the reasons behind the country’s economic turmoil.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
junge Welt
@jungewelt
Die 1910 ausgerufene Erste Republik Portugal war von Anfang an in der Krise. Vor 100 Jahren wurde sie durch einen Militärputsch zu Fall gebracht, der der Diktatur Salazars den Weg bereitete.
www.jungewelt.de/artikel/523193.html -
Adam Tooze reposted
Tony Annett
@tonyannett
Stunning.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In his latest @BrankoMilan calculates that, measured in terms of population-weighted-growth points, China’s growth was 20 times larger than that of boom-time Japan and more than 290 times larger than the growth of gilded age America.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Clearly China's economic growth over the last forty years has been huge, but how huge by historical standards?
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In his latest @BrankoMilan calculates that, measured in terms of population-weighted-growth points, China’s growth was 20 times larger than that of boom-time Japan and more than 290 times larger than the growth of gilded age America.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In latest Chartbook I use GDP measures to reach the same conclusion: we aint seen nothing like i! The US in the late 19th century may have driven large share of global GDP growth, but world economy was a fraction of today and growing far more slowly.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-450-modern-growth-surges -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Despite the worries, so far, inflation expectations seem to have remained anchored. Chartbook Top Links of the day has more:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/bond-market-jitters-supply-chain…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Shibley Telhami
@ShibleyTelhami
Senator @ChrisVanHollen: "Democrats need to face a hard truth... The Democratic Party has provided reflexive and unconditional support to Israeli governments, even as their actions have increasingly undermined American interests and values." Amen.
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/26/opinion/democrats-israel.html -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
G7 countries are now borrowing at rates that were enjoyed by Emerging Markets in the early 2020s. More at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/bond-breakout-big-effects-of-bad
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Trade between China and Russia has grown in recent years. Chartbook Top Links of the day has just dropped!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/bond-breakout-big-effects-of-bad…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Is oil about to run out … ? More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
James Meadway
@meadwaj
Strongly recommend @DanielaGabor’s step by step account of what’s really happening with bond markets - and how to really deal with them without wishful thinking.
(The “Bailey premium” we pay govt borrowing costs also deserves wider circulation.)
Link below. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Again and again, the Bank of England is run by conservative economists, systematically defending the status-quo and wielding veto power over transformative ambitions.
Steven Swinford
@Steven_Swinford
Breaking:
Andrew Bailey, the governor of the Bank of England, suggests that price caps on essential goods in supermarkets are unsustainable
'The question you have to think through is are you doing it for some well grounded, temporary reason? If you start doing it as a matter of course you are artificially moving prices relative to costs. That's not a sustainable thing in the long run. It does need to be thought through'
Dr Swati Dhingra, a member of the Monetary Policy Committee, says lots of countries have tried price controls but they have not worked. 'The biggest problem is you're dampening the price signal, precisely what you want people to react to. As a market economy you can do that for a little bit but how long can you let it go on?
'I grew up with price controls on food all my life. That story to some degree was very successful in being able to cure famine and poverty. But at the same time it has ended up creating a highly distorted agricultural sector in India. Do it with a lot of caution and a lot of thinking behind what it is trying to target.' -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
I've written about how @AndyBurnhamGM or @ZackPolanski can stop worrying about bond vigilantes' veto on big, transformative ambitions.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/may/21/politicians… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Far from dominance: American consumers have seen the biggest hike in petrol and diesel prices of all countries across the G7 since the start of the war on Iran. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How Asia trumps the petrodollar from the Gavekal Research. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Not an abstract question @TheStalwart
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
I hope it doesn't happen. But I wonder if we ever get to the point where authors on the level of, say, Sebastian Mallaby or Tooze release original work first and only as a podcast series. Something distinct from an audiobook, maybe going back and forth with a "host".
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
look @AndyBurnhamGM - we're really in hock to @bankofengland , the scariest bond vigilante because it's a public institution that pretends to pursue the public good while pushing up the cost of government borrowing
www.thetimes.com/business/economics/article/bank-of-engla… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If housing were more affordable in the UK and the US, the birth rate might be slightly higher but it would not reverse the overall trend. More at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/missiles-made-in-arkansas-more-h…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The coming Great Wealth Transfer Includes $570 Billion in Classic Cars. Chartbook Top Links of the day has more:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/missiles-made-in-arkansas-more-h…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Learning beats digging: Makes me smile whenever I see it! H/t @Ember
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Peter S. Goodman
@petersgoodman
8/ Thanks for reading this far. Story here: www.nytimes.com/2026/05/18/business/iran-war-somalia-usai…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The basic logic of population decline is playing out in Japan in stark form. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/missiles-made-in-arkansas-more-h…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A new fiscal-monetary framework to renew Britain.
This by Louise Haigh in @RenewalJournal pairs well with Chartbook 449 on the silence around the Bank of England: Voldemort on Threadneedle St.
renewal.org.uk/articles/a-new-fiscal-framework-to-renew-b… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jonathan Shainin
@jonathanshainin
Truly brutal obituary for the Starmer project from one of Britain’s great living historians, David Edgerton
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
"The question is not whether Labour values have been usurped by Starmer’s faction. It is what kind of party could be built out of the corpse of Starmer’s party. One option is clearly a more Blairite party: pro-tech giants, the US, and privatisation. But are there any serious options to create a progressive party, one that dares speak out on the issues of the day, that actually communicates with a progressive electorate? It is hard to see at the moment whether the ambition or capacity exists within it.
It is worth noting that Starmer’s Party is only barely the official party of the organised working class. Whereas Labour had affiliated to it nearly every major trade union, today only just over half of union members are in party-affiliated unions. And even then some may leave. This is hardly surprising: as it stands its policies, Starmer’s Party’s political instincts, are far closer to those of the Tories and Reform than to the progressive parties that are eating it up. And that is not accidental, or the result of a lack of vision. It was the whole point."
Read @DEHEdgerton's obituary for Starmerism
www.newstatesman.com/politics/labour/2026/05/the-labour-p… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Anton Jäger
@AntonJaegermm
Honestly this is pretty good
Whyvert
@whyvert
Can you reduce all of political philosophy to one diagram?
A pretty good attempt.
(From a book on Machiavelli by Gabriele Pedulla.) -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Adler
@davidrkadler
Over the past few years, I have been privileged to prepare my doctoral dissertation at the @UniofOxford. Today, I successfully defended that dissertation. I am so grateful to all of you who supported this research — above all, to my brilliant supervisor @benwansell. Thank you 🩷
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hedge funds pivot to biofuels anticipating a bump from the Iran war. Find out more in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/biofuel-boom-a-plague-of-deer-wr…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Will Self
@wself
“That is why Starmer attracts such visceral hostility. Not because he is secretly tyrannical or uniquely manipulative, but because he appears as the anthropomorphic embodiment of procedural Britain itself: the human face of the unread contract.”
-
Adam Tooze reposted
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
Take this FT piece from today. “Oh UK's the gilt market may have become untethered from its peers” and the explanation amounts to “we’re addicted to debt”. It is mentioned in HALF A SENTENCE that the Bank is actively shedding gilts. THIS IS NOT SERIOUS FINANCIAL JOURNALISM.
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
It is remarkable how toxic and dysfunctional budgetary politics in Britain have become when the fiscal authority courts instability by formulating its polices around where yields and sterling will go in response while the Bank sits on its hand and nobody talks about it.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ben Zaranko
@BenZaranko
On the role of the Bank of England, I think these comments from Louise Haigh earlier in the week are indicative of where Labour party thinking might go. Discussions about monetary-fiscal coordination feel likely. Leaves all of the crucial details to be filled in, of course.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Whoever wishes to talk about the bond market, should not be silent about the central bank"
One week in Britain - what a week - and I am already seeing ghosts!
Voldemort on Threadneedle street. The Bank of England and the "haunted house" of English politics. The latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Sign up below for more. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Lyle Morris
@LyleJMorris
Cool annotated side-by-side picture by @nytimes of who attended the Trump-Xi summit.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Shocking - @FT long read on UK bond market with v little analysis beyond 'a lot of debt, powerful investors'
Nothing on linkers, one sentence on Bank of England actively selling gifts when no other central bank does.
www.ft.com/content/681c033e-de48-4edc-9214-339fde583c9a?s… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Helen Thompson POLIS
@HelenHet20
‘Never again’ as Gordon Brown’s response to Black Wednesday in 1992 was vindicated; ‘never again’ as Rachel Reeve's response to the misdiagnosed Truss crisis in 2022 has helped destroy Starmer and is turning his removal into another economic trauma.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Whoever wishes to talk about the bond market, should not be silent about the central bank"
One week in Britain - what a week - and I am already seeing ghosts!
Voldemort on Threadneedle street. The Bank of England and the "haunted house" of English politics. The latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Sign up below for more. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Whoever wishes to talk about the bond market, should not be silent about the central bank"
One week in Britain - what a week - and I am already seeing ghosts!
Voldemort on Threadneedle street. The Bank of England and the "haunted house" of English politics. The latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Sign up below for more.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The fruit of sane-making conversations with @DanielaGabor and my old friend Matt I.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This chartbook newsletter focuses on BofE independence. Citing (verbatim) an excellent post by @robin_j_brooks though ofc he "plays for the other team".
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-449-voldemort-on-threa… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“Cut out and keep” for a reality check on fiscal positions and yields:
More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Why, in the matter of Xu Ziaoren (Macaron), are the German authorities dismissing the well-documented research of one of China's leading ex-pat investigative journalists? @Chai20230817 should be heard!
柴静
@Chai20230817
In response to inquiries from multiple German media outlets, I am issuing this statement regarding my interviewee Xu Xiaoren (known online as Macaron ), who currently faces imminent deportation from Germany.
In March 2025, Xu was the only Chinese citizen I encountered on the Russian frontlines willing to appear on camera, showing his face, to condemn the war:
"Every inch of land is paid for in blood. It is inhuman and immoral."
For the year that followed, he endured relentless persecution and lived in flight because of this. Guided by professional ethics, I documented his journey through video, audio, and over 100,000 words of investigative notes, cross-verified by multiple witnesses, to record the risks the interviewee faced and to offer him a measure of protection.
In thirty years of investigative journalism, this is the first time I have had to do this. It shows how grave I believed the situation to be.
In February 2026, Xu escaped Russia. By April, I was informed that he had reached Germany, facing immediate deportation. He asked me to submit these original records to @BAMF_Dialog.
I never got the chance. No evidence was reviewed. No contact was made — with me or any other witness. Instead, BAMF ruled his application "manifestly unfounded," dismissing my statement as "mere rumors and unsubstantiated assertions."
I am grateful for the attention of the press. A man who admitted he entered the war by mistake, who then defected from within it, and what he became over that year, may tell us something about how wars could truly end: the reflection, the suffering, the compassion, the change. It is a battle of the human soul. I ask the German people to hear his story, and to judge for themselves.
This is my full statement in German: -
Adam Tooze reposted
柴静
@Chai20230817
In response to inquiries from multiple German media outlets, I am issuing this statement regarding my interviewee Xu Xiaoren (known online as Macaron ), who currently faces imminent deportation from Germany.
In March 2025, Xu was the only Chinese citizen I encountered on the Russian frontlines willing to appear on camera, showing his face, to condemn the war:
"Every inch of land is paid for in blood. It is inhuman and immoral."
For the year that followed, he endured relentless persecution and lived in flight because of this. Guided by professional ethics, I documented his journey through video, audio, and over 100,000 words of investigative notes, cross-verified by multiple witnesses, to record the risks the interviewee faced and to offer him a measure of protection.
In thirty years of investigative journalism, this is the first time I have had to do this. It shows how grave I believed the situation to be.
In February 2026, Xu escaped Russia. By April, I was informed that he had reached Germany, facing immediate deportation. He asked me to submit these original records to @BAMF_Dialog.
I never got the chance. No evidence was reviewed. No contact was made — with me or any other witness. Instead, BAMF ruled his application "manifestly unfounded," dismissing my statement as "mere rumors and unsubstantiated assertions."
I am grateful for the attention of the press. A man who admitted he entered the war by mistake, who then defected from within it, and what he became over that year, may tell us something about how wars could truly end: the reflection, the suffering, the compassion, the change. It is a battle of the human soul. I ask the German people to hear his story, and to judge for themselves.
This is my full statement in German: -
Adam Tooze reposted
Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur oPt
@FranceskAlbs
BREAKING! US court ha suspended the US sanctions against me!
As the judge says: "Protecting the Freedom of speech is always just the public interest".
Thanks to my daughter and my husband for stepping up to defend me, and everyone who has helped so far.
Together we are One. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
Government debt was cheapest when we most cared about net zero emissions. And yet we did so little
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
I urge UK journalists/politicians to read Nangle before alarmist incantations about power of bond investors
' greatest compliment the bond market can give a chancellor aiming for economic rejuvenation is a mild sell-off'
@AndyBurnhamGM @ZackPolanski
Financial Times
@FT
Who do gilt investors want to lead Britain? ft.trib.al/pJqjd4v
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If US petrol prices hit $5 per gallon, as JPMorgan’s Natasha Kaneva is canvassing, expect knipchens! More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/will-gas-hit-5-capitalists-capit…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Welcome to the Great Hunkering Down. Why aren’t more people quitting their jobs? Chartbook Top Links just dropped, check it out:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/will-gas-hit-5-capitalists-capit…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
In 2022, Erica Moret and I published this @ForeignAffairs essay, explaining that "sanctions are an economic weapon designed to cause inflation."
Can't help but see today's CPI print and think that sanctioned countries are figuring out how to retaliate.
www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/world/2022-01-17/hidden-t… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Big tech’s investment spending is increasing. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/big-techs-investment-spending-se…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The transformation of the Chinese “elite” since the 1980s has been dramatic. In the 1980s the richest 5 percent were made up of people drawing their incomes from public sector sources. By 2018 private income predominates and the group is far more mixed and dominated by business owners and professionals. This and more featured in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/big-techs-investment-spending-se…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
your reminder that last time politics got chaotic, Andrew Bailey chose to queenslayer.
or, in technical language, the Bank of England abdicated its responsibilities to act as market-maker of last resort for UK gilts.
Alex Wickham
@alexwickham
NEW: UK assets are sliding as Keir Starmer is on the brink
Gilt yields spiked as much as 10 basis points at the open
The pound is down 0.5% against the dollar
UK banks are leading a selloff in stocks -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A history of the shortlived Tuareg nation, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Price controls
Nationalization
Financial repression
Fiscal-monetary coordination
@GitaGopinath warns that all four of these policies might form a heterodox response to our current situation of high economic tension.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Rather than anathematizing "heterodoxy", in a dangerous 3rd-best world, we should be considering all the options. This is in the spirit of work on a new policy framework done at both @IMFNews and BIS in 2019-2020, which @GitaGopinath inspired.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Check out the latest Chartbook newsletter here and sign up for more:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-448-price-controls-nat… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ben McWilliams
@McwilliamsBen
Investment in clean technology manufacturing facilities is falling worldwide, despite global demand for clean technologies growing rapidly.
Our new piece joint @Bruegel_org @rhodium_group unpacks the important trends.
A thread / 4. 👇 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Manchester Guardian’s response to the British General Strike of May 1926. More interesting sources featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
I'm at the @OECD conference on the Future of Development Cooperation and first impression:
as development aid shrinks, everyone is talking sovereignty - including from the Ghana-led Accra Reset. -
Adam Tooze reposted
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
The fiscal constraints are binding because of how the Truss/Kwarteng incident was metabolised by the current crop which seems determined to write the letters 'EM' on to its forehead. Meanwhile Britain has an unusually unaccomodative central bank. These are political constraints.
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
Beyond anything about Starmer per se the big problem for any British government seems to be that post Truss, the fiscal constraints really are binding which will frustrate whoever suceeds him
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The US economy in May 2026 - how much cognitive dissonance can you handle? The elites are complacent amidst mounting signs of tension.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Latest Chartbook newsletter unpacks the cognitive dissonance. Check it out here and sign up for more:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-447-the-us-economy-in-may
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
?
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Spain’s migration policy is reshuffling the labour market. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/tariffs-really-are-bad-for-your-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
When worrying about China shocks and AI shocks it is worth remembering that shifts in the structure of employment are inherent to the process of modern economic growth. Featured in today`s Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/tariffs-really-are-bad-for-your-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tariq Ali
@TariqAli_News
Rajiv Menon was my barrister when I appeared before the Tribunal investigating police surveillance of left and women's groups. His opening speech was brilliant. He is on of this country's most gifted barristers, a descendant of Mike Mansfield. His prosecution is an appalling instance of some judges prostrating themselves before the needs of the state as they did a number of times against Irish and Muslim prisoners. One hope they might have learnt from how they treated the Irish. Doesn't seem to be the case.
Martin Shaw
@martinshawx
It may not be fully appreciated that the UK is not only seeing unprecedented treatment of direct action protestors as “terrorists”, but a lawyer representing them is himself being prosecuted for his remarks in court.
Here his fellow lawyers explain what is happening and express solidarity. A crucial case for justice and the rule of law in the UK.
Garden Court North
@gcnchambers
(1/3) Garden Court North members express solidarity with Rajiv Menon KC, a highly respected silk and member of @gardencourtlaw, who faces prosecution for contempt of court following his closing speech in a high-profile and politically sensitive criminal trial.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Garden Court North
@gcnchambers
(2/3) The suggestion that a barrister may face such personal sanction for the content of a closing speech – an unprecedented step in our experience – risks creating a chilling effect across the legal profession.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Martin Shaw
@martinshawx
It may not be fully appreciated that the UK is not only seeing unprecedented treatment of direct action protestors as “terrorists”, but a lawyer representing them is himself being prosecuted for his remarks in court.
Here his fellow lawyers explain what is happening and express solidarity. A crucial case for justice and the rule of law in the UK.
Garden Court North
@gcnchambers
(1/3) Garden Court North members express solidarity with Rajiv Menon KC, a highly respected silk and member of @gardencourtlaw, who faces prosecution for contempt of court following his closing speech in a high-profile and politically sensitive criminal trial.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tom Newton Dunn
@tnewtondunn
There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Vectors of Chinamaxxing
#1 The most obvious is technocratic envy - Dang Wang’s thesis in Breakneck, that China is a society run by engineers, bent on “engineering the future”.
#2 Then there is the shock of the encounter with Chinese reality on the part of visitors to China - whether those visits are stage managed by official tourist agencies, or not.
#3 Another dimension of enthusiasm is retro-authenticity - street scenes from Beijing on Chongqing as reminders of a lost world of “down to earth” life.
#4 There is a lot of interest in Chinese ways of wellness
#5 The West has discovered that Chinese netizens have a great sense of humor.
#6 Chinese popular culture is one of the great generators of the styles and paraphernalia of “cuteness”.
#7 The erotic realm: recurring rumors of epidemics of “Yellow fever” sweeping the dating scene.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Summarizing a fascinating discussion at Accent Sister.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The latest Chartbook newsletter, just dropped. Sign up here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-446-soft-power-with-ch…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Fahad Ansari 🇵🇸 (Stop the Gaza genocide)
@fahadansari
Rajiv Menon KC has been dragged before the court for contempt for
(1) Highlighting a case from 1670 which established beyond question the independence of the jury
(2) Reading out the inscription of a plaque at the Old Bailey commemorating the case, which states that it “established the right of juries to give their verdict according to their convictions”.
Every lawyer in the country should go on strike to protest this latest attempt to protect Israel by now sanctioning lawyers for doing their job.
Huda Ammori
@HudaAmmori
The lead barrister in the first Filton24 trial is being prosecuted for contempt of court for successfully defending his client, Charlotte Head.
The unprecedented prosecution of a barrister came after the defendants were acquitted of aggravated burglary. www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/may/05/barrister-palesti… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Eleanora (formerly LeftieStats) 🍉🏳️⚧️
@LeftieStats
🗳️ The Green win in Hackney's Mayoral election is extraordinary when you look at past results.
For the past 22 years, Labour have won every single Hackney Mayor election by at least 25pts.
In 2026, they lost to the Greens by 11.7pts. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chinese ag-industrial policy story: the US is already levying anti-dumping duties on the following Chinese bio/ag tech firms that were selling underpriced pea protein to the USA. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Despite record tariff levels, the US trade deficit is widening in large part because of the boom in AI-related investment. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joey Politano 🏳️🌈
@JosephPolitano
The US tech sector continues losing jobs—overall, employment decreased by 10k last month and is down 53k over the last year
That's not as bad as the worst of the 2024 tech-cession, but extremely bad compared to the 2022 boom or even pre-2020 norms -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
The headline numbers here are quite striking. But the losses from damages or destroyed assets may be even more striking. The Iranians have destroyed $11.9 billion in weaponry, equipment, and assets.
Stephen Semler
@stephensemler
The US has spent an estimated $71.8 billion on the Iran War, or $1.2 billion per day on average.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Quite the post!
Wieland Giebel
@WielandGiebel
Das Ende des Faschismus am 8. Mai 1945? Von wegen. Diese Zeitung las mein Vater bis zu seinem Tod – wie 120.000 andere auch – jeden Freitag bis 1979.
Mit 17 verlor er im Krieg durch einen Granatsplitter ein Auge. Betrunken nahm er auf Partys sein Glasauge heraus – als makabre Nummer eines Besiegten. Genützt hat es nichts. Wie viele meiner Lehrer blieb er ein Verlierer seines Lebens: voller Schuld, voller Schweigen, voller Gewalt. Sie prügelten ihre Kinder. Die Frauen litten und bekamen Wochenendemigräne, wenn der Mann zu Hause war.
Das NS-Milieu verschwand nicht 1945. Es überdauerte Jahrzehnte. Mitläufer und Täter verdrängten, schwiegen, machten weiter. Bis weit in die 1970er Jahre hinein. Eine kaputte Generation – körperlich versehrt, emotional zerstört. Eine Generation von Verlierern. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Emeka Ajene ✍🏽
@eajene
Be wary of anyone talking about how fast Africa is growing without ever mentioning these two words: per capita.
This chart maps the speed and persistence of per capita GDP growth across the continent — not just whether economies are growing, but whether living standards are actually rising.
What it shows:
• Established growth markets: Rwanda, Ethiopia, Côte d'Ivoire, Mauritius — consistent compounders with structural momentum.
• Ascending: Senegal, DRC, Morocco, Kenya — outperforming their historical baseline. The inflection is real.
• Treading water: Mozambique, Cameroon, Tunisia, Namibia — growing, but not pulling away.
• Reversing: Nigeria, Angola, Ghana, Equatorial Guinea — had structural tailwinds, lost them.
• Structurally challenged: Sudan, Central African Republic, Burundi — fragility and conflict are the common thread. And South Africa, the continent's largest economy, belongs here too.
Many investors treat Africa as a single entity.
And most analysis stops at GDP.
But when it comes to improving standards of living:
Africa isn't one market. It's at least five.
—
Afridigest Intelligence — intelligence & advisory to win in Africa's growth markets: afridigest.com/intelligence | Follow Afridigest on LinkedIn & Instagram -
Adam Tooze reposted
Joey Politano 🏳️🌈
@JosephPolitano
US data center construction rose to a new record high in official data released today, hitting a pace of nearly $50B/yr (and this only includes data center facilities, not the expensive computers within)
Spending is up 34% over the last year and 260% since the launch of ChatGPT -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ann Fitzpatrick
@ann123fitz
From @adam_tooze Chartbook newsletter.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
Après l’américanisation, l’enchinoisement des esprits et des comportements? Via quels facteurs? Quelques pistes et questionnements d’’@adam_tooze sur la dimension "culturelle (?)" du deuxième choc chinois?open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-446-soft-powe…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Benjamin Wolf 🇺🇦
@benbawan
Most Europeans 🇪🇺 live longer than Americans 🇺🇸 - we know that.
But what’s striking is that life expectancy relative to the US has increased in every single one of these European countries in the last two decades. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
Probably the funniest graph ever published by the FT: our 3 possible futures are either 1) infinite wealth and abundance, 2) human extinction or 3) 0.2% faster GDP growth 🤣
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
You can't read this lede and not think something is fundamentally broken in the United States.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Latin America’s productivity stagnation now places it below the global average. Don’t have to agree with the prescriptions in this essay to apprecite the significance of this graph. More on today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/running-out-of-fertilizer-why-no…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What to worry about and what not to worry about regarding data centers. Great writeup from Andy Masley, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link to Chartbook: adamtooze.substack.com/p/running-out-of-fertilizer-why-no…
And here's the link to Andy's post: blog.andymasley.com/p/data-center-land-use-issues-are-fake? -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Iran war is already having major repercussions on fertilizer supply, even in the US! Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/running-out-of-fertilizer-why-no…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Wortel-London
@dlondonwortel
Never saw this 1971 cover for Jane Jacob's "Death and Life" before - what do you think?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Every so often I think about how, in 2022, for $24B we could had "prototype vaccines ready for each of the 26 known viral families that cause human disease" so they can be deployed in 100 days if there was ever a need.
This effort was not funded. ifp.org/why-barda-deserves-more-funding/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Lawrence Zhang 張樂翔
@HistorianZhang
I bought these when I was in high school. They're still top tier history visualizations
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Gita Gopinath
@GitaGopinath
It was only a matter of time. Justin is great at this. Good luck @JustinWolfers
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/06/business/dealbook/justin-wolfe… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Dave Jones
@CleanPowerDave
Yes, they're forecast to get cheaper in the US.
But also everywhere else.. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Dave Jones
@CleanPowerDave
If you live in the US and wonder why the world has gone renewables crazy...
...it's because renewables are much cheaper in most of the rest of the world🤷♂️
(and also fossil fuels are generally more expensive) -
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
The EU has many, many energy targets. But with the electrification rate, this fossil-deficient continent has finally found the right objective.
My new piece for the @ecfr DARE* project. -
Adam Tooze reposted
AukeHoekstra
@AukeHoekstra
If you put that ethanol into the combustion engine of a car (that throws ~75% away as heat) and compare it with an electric vehicle, the end result becomes ~500:1 in favor of solar.
And solar can go on roofs or be combined with other agricultural appliations.
robert
@rfhirschfeld
“Ethanol is just comically inefficient solar energy.” - Tom Philpott
-
Adam Tooze reposted
PassBlue
@pass_blue
Luke Lindberg, Trump nominee to run @WFP, at UNHQ looking for an "iconic" backdrop in which to be photographed
passblue.com/2026/04/09/trump-nominates-an-america-first-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Dayen
@ddayen
I was at the Milken Conference today, and none of the investors and hedge funders and private equity guys assembled wanted to think much about the war we started that is going to trigger a global recession.
prospect.org/2026/05/05/complacent-class-2026-milken-inst… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
🇮🇳 Communist Rule Ends in India’s Kerala State
India’s left suffered a historic collapse in state elections, losing its last major governing stronghold in Kerala after the Congress-led United Democratic Front swept the state, winning over 100 of 140 seats.
The Left Democratic Front, led by the CPI(M), fell to around 35 seats, ending communist rule in Kerala after a decade in power. Analysts say this marks the first time since 1977 that no Indian state will be governed by the left. (The Times of India)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu Nationalist BJP scored a historic breakthrough in West Bengal, taking power in the state for the first time with more than 200 seats, defeating Mamata Banerjee’s Trinamool Congress. (Reuters)
Video: NDTV interview w/ Congress’ Shashi TharoorThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
OPEC Drama Kings ...episode 2 of our Polycrisis bonus season out now!
@kmac
We live in the Prince of Darkness MBZ world
Listen wherever you get your podcasts: pod.link/1884213852 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Stranded countries are far more dangerous than "stranded assets" of pvt oil companies. It's Western navel gazing to only focus on latter & not powerful National Oil Companies
Ep2 Polycrisis DRAMA KINGS @kmac & I chat about UAE shock OPEC exit
Listen here:pod.link/1884213852 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Robin Wigglesworth
@RobinWigg
One of the absolute best things about being a financial journalist (now apparently a “veteran” one) is that I sometimes get early access to some fascinating books. And I’ve been *very* excited about getting my hands on @lahamed2’s latest ever since I heard it was in the works.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Running the economy hot is good for productivity growth (TFP). More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/scaling-tech-layoffs-why-to-run-the
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Because of its heavy reliance on domestically-mined coal, China is far less vulnerable to global energy price shocks than the EU. This and more featured in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/scaling-tech-layoffs-why-to-run-the
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The news on AI-driven, tech layoffs in 2026 harsh, but it is nowhere near as bad as those in 2022-2023. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/scaling-tech-layoffs-why-to-run-the
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
This is the sort of chart you see in a medieval history book explaining the origins of an event called something like 'The Upheaval of 1328'
Daniel Freeman
@1689Freeman
Unfortunately there's a much more sobering trend when you look at median pay...
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How the Normans built a modern state in England after 1066: fascinating argument by Jean-Philippe Genet. Summary featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Absolutely fantastic piece about why beef prices are so high. Contrary to what many people may surmise, it's not the meatpackers getting margin right now. It's the actual ranchers, who are benefitting from an overall scarcity of calves www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2026-beef-prices-cattle-supply…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Ruban I.P. Not for tourists. 1964. State Tretyakov Gallery, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
All very well, but you really dont gauge Adorno's presence in German public life unless you take account of radio. People may have been scared to cite him, but he had many channels. Highly recommend this excellent book:
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
And before you say "That's because they wrote in German!"
Nobody noticed their works in German either until the 60s-70s. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Teaching this essay from Socialist Register 2026 for my final end of year class on "capitalism and democracy" and I agree @SteveMaher18 , it is excellent! I might wanna wrangle with you and Scott Aquanno over significance of China but I almost entirely agree with yr US story.
Steve Maher
@SteveMaher18
I'm really pleased with our essay in the new volume of the Socialist Register. In it, we challenge arguments that Trump emerged from capitalism's decline into "techno-feudalism", "political capitalism", or an "asset economy" driven by central banks inflating asset prices.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Edward Ongweso Jr
@bigblackjacobin
never in my life thought I’d see a Lin Bao x Panic! At the Disco edit but
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The rise of fathering. This and more featured in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Source: Home Economics homeeconomics.substack.com/p/dads-are-doing-more-childcar…
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/price-shocks-the-economics-of-fa…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tej Parikh
@tejparikh90
Donald Trump's green new deal
My latest column for @FT: The US president has inadvertently raised the appeal of renewable energy across the world: as.ft.com/r/f15c2c58-d497-4478-b5f5-92c6efd78d1a -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China is far more dependent on imported food/feed than either the US or the EU. In a world of "food regimes", this is a highly unusual and unique development.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Though China does have a food security regime for corn, wheat and rice. For soybeans, which are crucial for pork supply, it relies on imports.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Latest Chartbook newsletter riffs on a piece for the @FT to ask whether we can expect this regime to last, or whether China will apply the "industrial policy" playbook to big ag. Check it out here and sign up for more: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-445-is-a-china-shock-c…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How the price shock of 2021-2022 mutated into a more comprehensive wave of inflation. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/price-shocks-the-economics-of-fa…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Is China about to decouple on food?
Riffing on a piece in the FT in the latest chartbook this morning.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-445-is-a-china-shock-c…
www.ft.com/content/637215a5-4814-49c4-ae24-c6a96adb56cf -
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
Beaucoup de ce qu'il vaut mieux savoir de Kevin Warsh, le nouveau président présumé de la Réserve fédérale
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-444-rolling-back-the-big
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Who is Kevin Warsh? A lawyer, not an economist. A Republican insider. Fickle on interest rates. Married into the Lauder-Trump connection. But, also a paid up member of the Stanford-Hoover Institution-neoconservative connection.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If you ask why the US dominates so many areas of high-tech weaponry in the West, the scale of defense R&D gives you an answer. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Who is Kevin Warsh? A lawyer, not an economist. A Republican insider. Fickle on interest rates. Married into the Lauder-Trump connection. But, also a paid up member of the Stanford-Hoover Institution-neoconservative connection.
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
And the exponent of a multi-century vision, which sees the values of the Enlightenment under threat.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Check out the latest Chartbook newsletter here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-444-rolling-back-the-big
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Matthew C. Klein is the only "contrarian macro chart guy" I've seen who consistently comes up with defensible novel insights...subscribe to his blog!
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
New at THE OVERSHOOT:
The Growth Impulse from the Data Center Boom
theovershoot.co/p/the-growth-impulse-from-the-data
There is much less than meets the eye, although the official numbers may also be undercounting some of what is happening. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
American retail electricity prices are running very far ahead of CPI - striking report by Grace Fan featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Finbarr Bermingham
@fbermingham
Absolutely fascinating translation of a senior Chinese diplomat in Kyiv's account of days leading up to & day of Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
The most jarring thing: even the Chinese on the ground were trying to convince Kyiv that war was imminent but were brushed off -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Imagine growing up and living in "Fascist Disneyland", also known as the small Italian town of Predappio, the birthplace of Mussolini. Even a 100 years on, the small town still draws 100.000 yearly visitors. Great book by Paolo Heywood, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/is-americas-long-consumer-boom-f…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Faking a market panic to force Trump's hand on Iran - find myself put in mind of a Wolfgang Streeck line (sic) about how the left should instrumentalize panic more.
Dario Perkins
@darioperkins
💡I've got an idea... Calm markets are really bad for getting a deal on Iran. Trump is clearly in no hurry. But the damage to the global economy only gets worse. SO why dont we, you know, fake a market panic. His advisers can pretend stocks are in meltdown and we can all play along.. (some of you are pretty good at that anyway...)
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Dario Perkins
@darioperkins
💡I've got an idea... Calm markets are really bad for getting a deal on Iran. Trump is clearly in no hurry. But the damage to the global economy only gets worse. SO why dont we, you know, fake a market panic. His advisers can pretend stocks are in meltdown and we can all play along.. (some of you are pretty good at that anyway...)
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In the short-term and for a limited time, the losses of oil from the Straits of Hormuz can be made up. More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/is-americas-long-consumer-boom-f…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Joe's work on this has been excellent
19th Street also should take note
Maybe 15th Street as well
Joseph Gagnon
@GagnonMacro
With all due respect to my esteemed Mass Ave neighbor and colleague, my research shows that FX intervention does work. Each $1 of intervention raises the current account balance between $0.30 and $0.70, with more recent estimates supporting the higher end....
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
Few people have done more to advance how the field of economics approaches the study of sanctioned countries than @frrodriguezc.
In this new piece, he challenges a recent paper that downplays the negative impact of the U.S. embargo on the Cuban economy.
www.thesanctionsage.com/p/measuring-the-effect-of-the-emb… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Timothy Taylor
@TimothyTTaylor
Global Trade Imbalances: Actual Problems, Unlikely Solutions
conversableeconomist.com/2026/04/30/global-trade-imbalanc… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Aaron Blake
@AaronBlake
61% of Americans say the Iran war is a "mistake," per new WaPo-ABC poll.
In Iraq, it took more than 3 years to reach that high.
In Vietnam, it took 6 years. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
Carl Schmitt enthusiasts (and particularly Postliberals) depict him as a "giant" of 20th century political theory. Despite this claim, Schmitt was almost entirely ignored in the English-speaking world until the early 2000s. We now have clear empirical evidence of this fact.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Since COVID, the US has been riding a sustained surge in consumer spending. Will it continue? Today's Chartbook Top Links just dropped, check it out:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/is-americas-long-consumer-boom-f…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Cairo Smith
@cairoasmith
There's a common misconception that Brutalist buildings were unpainted, but thanks to microscopic analysis of the exteriors we can now recreate what they looked like in their prime.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
March had a lot of tech layoffs, with layoffs affecting 45,800 tech employees it was the worst month in at least two years. More at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/currencies-arent-just-vibes-big-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
American central banking enters a new era.
Nick Timiraos
@NickTimiraos
What’s the heavier lift: 365 lbs on your 67th birthday or telling your colleagues you changed your mind on rate cuts? Chris Waller seems comfortable with both.
(He posted this video on his LinkedIn account) -
Adam Tooze reposted
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
⭐My new Factful Friday is posted (early)
👉The Strait of Hormuz had never been effectively closed in modern history. Until now.
👉This marks a new phase in what I call World War Trade in my recent book.
👉Correlation doesn't mean causation, but US and China normalised the weaponisation of trade. Now Iran has spread the logic shipping.
👉The real danger is proliferation as nations everywhere learnt that controlling a chokepoint can be a powerful deterrent.
👉We need a visible commitment to keeping shipping lanes as arteries of prosperity, not arrows of economic warfare.
💥A job for Mark Carney’s middle powers?
Link in first reply (avoids algo throttling)
cc: @AdamPosen, @IMD_Bschool, @cepr_org, @adam_tooze, @jasonfurman, @BrankoMilan, @ChrisGiles_, @ChadBown, @CER_Grant, @jburnmurdoch, @jamescrabtree, @NIESRorg, @ezraklein, @elerianm, @erikbryn, @GitaGopinath, @gabriel_zucman, @Hugodixon, @kaushikcbasu, @k_sonin, @lugaricano, @lugaricano, @lindayueh, @MarkJCarney, @MaxCRoser, @NOIweala, @Nouriel, @NOELreports, @ojblanchard1, @paulkrugman, @politico, @agnesbq1, @DannyQuah, @RBReich, @RayDalio, @SimonEvenett, @simonjhix, @sjwrenlewis, @scottlincicome, @D_A_Irwin, @michaelxpettis -
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
"Hold on. We the taxpayers are going to pay companies $900 million, which is more than 6x what we spend on wind power R&D, to NOT build wind power at a time when electricity prices are spiking and we need more clean power?" - @CostaSamaras
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Rachel Karten
@milkkarten
lena dunham reportedly sold 60k copies of her book in the first week. she did a ton of press on substack—guest essays, q&as, etc. thought this was an interesting insight that likely also applies to products other than books.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Berliner Ensemble
@blnensemble
"Was wird aus Amerika?": in der letzten Ausgabe von "Habeck live" vor dem Sommer am 7.6. spricht Robert Habeck mit den Historikern @adam_tooze und @tzimmer_history über die politische Zukunft der USA. am 4.5. startet der reguläre Vorverkauf. www.berliner-ensemble.de/inszenierung/habeck-live-was-wir…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Mika Walker Kane
@MWalkerKane
'Build the ballroom' is the new 'Build the wall.'
Acyn
@Acyn
Lindsey Graham says they are going introduce legislation that’s going to authorize 400 million dollars to be spent on building the ballroom: We pay for it by offsetting it with customs fees. The sooner we get the ballroom built, the better it is for the country.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
James Jackson
@derJamesJackson
New: the AfD are five points ahead of the CDU in the polls
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The story of the US auto industry since the late 1990s is all about integration with Mexico. More at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-war-and-the-markets-irans-de…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Helen Andrews
@herandrews
Add it to the list of notable forthcoming non-fiction.
Benjamin R. Young
@DubstepInDPRK
Coming to (academic) bookstores near you this July. Published with @CornellPress
-
Adam Tooze reposted
ED1
@ed1_DC
The Islamabad section was one of the best podcast segments ones and tooze have done recently, please make it a series. I'd add the plans for Indonesia's Nusantara, as well as the l'enfant plan for DC and its realization post civil-war by a freedman labor force, its a great story
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In 2024 Iran, according to official figures, spent only 2 percent of GDP on defense. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped, check it out:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-war-and-the-markets-irans-de…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Robinson Meyer
@robinsonmeyer
It’s the age of electricity and America isn’t ready.
Virtually every goal that Americans care about requires big changes to the power grid. I’m in @nytopinion today on why power bills are going up, whether AI is to blame, & what we need to do about it:
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/04/27/opinion/electricit… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Howard W. French
@hofrench
"If you live outside Africa —whether in the Americas, Europe or Asia —Africa is going to be a bigger part of your life. In trade, investment, tourism, literature and music, African integration into the world system is beginning in the way it did for Asia over half a century ago"
Foreign Policy
@ForeignPolicy
“How Africa Works” paints a demographic picture that is refreshingly free of the scaremongering common in Western discourse, writes columnist @hofrench. foreignpolicy.com/2026/04/24/how-africa-works-joe-studwel…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
The concept of “involution” in the Chinese context basically came from anthropologist Xiang Biao describing a deeper cultural trend.
Here he is in a powerful interview with @61LiuYi:
“The main change is this: effort driven by hope has become effort driven by fear. When we said work hard and you can change your fate — it was naïve, almost muddled, but people genuinely believed it. You looked around and there seemed to be examples of it working, so you worked hard. Now it’s: if you don’t work hard, you’ll be tossed out entirely.” chinabooksreview.com/2026/04/14/wtc-xiang-biao/ -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I'm thinking Brasilia, Rotterdam, Chandigarh, Haussmann's Paris, Germania, Stalin's remodeling of Moscow, Beijing, Barcelona ... could really be an endlessly fascinating thread. How about it @CameronAbadi & @OnesandToozePod ?
G Rodrigues
@gpriorrodrigues
Omg yes yes yes @adam_tooze and @CameronAbadi more episodes on urban planers, cities and stuff like that
-
Adam Tooze reposted
G Rodrigues
@gpriorrodrigues
Omg yes yes yes @adam_tooze and @CameronAbadi more episodes on urban planers, cities and stuff like that
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Arthur Pengelly
@adpengelly
This is what remains of the church on that hill.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
World War I as an underground war: Around the village of Vauquois in the Argonne, the war went below the surface. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/data-center-blowback-nazis-in-li…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
US oil and gas exports are booming, especially in Europe. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/data-center-blowback-nazis-in-li…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I will be at the Committee on Global Thought's 20 year anniversary event tomorrow!
We will be discussing on the theme of "The Global University? Looking Back, Looking Forward".
Tuesday. April 28, 2026 at 5:30 PM
The Lee C. Bollinger Forum, 605 W 125th Street
Register here: -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Across both parties the mood in the US is turning against data center construction. This and more featured in the Chartbook Top Link today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/data-center-blowback-nazis-in-li…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex Callinicos @alexcallinicos.bsky.social
@alex_callinicos
‘The global dollar system was not set in motion by a single diplomatic coup — oil for dollars. It was invented quietly by private actors, then endorsed and protected by the US. America didn’t just push its dollar out into the world. It found dollars in London, then decided … 1/
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Benjamin Carantino
@CarantinoB
Passionnante discussion d’Adam Tooze sur les déséquilibres mondiaux de 1914 et sur ceux d’aujourd’hui. A lire !
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hard-working hegemon? Why 21st-century America is not like Edwardian Britain.
Thanks to the Hobsonian vision of @michaelxpettis and @M_C_Klein and the pervasiveness of the Thucydides trap argument we are haunted right now by analogies to the per 1914 moment. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The “new normal” for US inflation is no longer below 2 percent - EXCELLENT series of graphs from Mike Nolan at Reuters. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
You are a billionaire Syrian property developer who wants to cash in on the reconstruction boom. Turns out you need some help in Washington DC to get sactions lifted. Well you know where to turn! More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
None really. But conditional on a bad crop, Allen's.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What I find so alluring @MWalkerKane is that it is so hard to tell! These conversations circle endlessly around that question. At one point he estimates his actual, amphetamine-adjusted age to be 90+.
Mika Walker Kane
@MWalkerKane
My question re Sartre has always been: did his philosophy produce this lifestyle or did this lifestyle produce his philosophy?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Matt Huber
@Matthuber78
This is a great corrective!
"The petrodollar story gets cause & effect exactly backwards. Oil producers priced barrels & profits in $ in the 1970s bc an infrastructure of global $ banking, what we now call the eurodollar system, was already in place - not in NYC, but in London" -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Totally with you on the scale point. @RobinRivaton
Robin Rivaton
@RobinRivaton
China’s scale is not just another data point in world history. It is structurally new.
The model does not merely mobilize labor and industry. It mobilizes household savings at suppressed returns and feeds them into the state-industrial machine.
As long as Chinese households accept that bargain, Western complaints about “unfairness” are mostly beside the point. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
Now, it’s official!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
"This times is different": poursuite du bras de fer d’@adam_tooze avec @Brad_Setser @michaelxpettis et @M_C_Klein sur les déséquilibres mondiaux actuels (et la scie macroéconomique des "surcapacités" issues de la "sous-consommation" chinoises). Décoiffant et important.A suivre
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hard-working hegemon? Why 21st-century America is not like Edwardian Britain.
Thanks to the Hobsonian vision of @michaelxpettis and @M_C_Klein and the pervasiveness of the Thucydides trap argument we are haunted right now by analogies to the per 1914 moment. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Gaza Notifications
@gazanotice
🚨Israel assassinated Imad Miqdad yesterday in a drone strike, targeting his solar-powered phone charging station in Gaza yesterday.
Miqdad had been providing civilians with a rare means of communication amid ongoing electricity cuts.
The strike killed him and destroyed the facility, further limiting access to basic services and connectivity for residents.
Gaza Notifications
@gazanotice
🚨BREAKING : In a new massacre, Israeli drones directly targeted a phone-charging point run by civilian Imad Miqdad moments ago in the Sheikh Radwan neighborhood of Gaza City, killing him along with other civilians.
With no electricity infrastructure left in displacement camps, solar-powered and improvised energy points have become essential for survival, yet they are being deliberately targeted, cutting civilians off from even the most basic means of living. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Hei Wa Wa
@yaqobhyndes
This group of French researchers (Sur le champ) trained about 200 re-enactors to test the crowd dynamics of hoplite warfare and routing more generally. It's really interesting how the often frustratingly vague statements of ancient writers become clear with this footage
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hard-working hegemon? Why 21st-century America is not like Edwardian Britain. Another one for @Brad_Setser in my global imbalances mini-series
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-443-hard-working-hegemon -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hard-working hegemon? Why 21st-century America is not like Edwardian Britain.
Thanks to the Hobsonian vision of @michaelxpettis and @M_C_Klein and the pervasiveness of the Thucydides trap argument we are haunted right now by analogies to the per 1914 moment.Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The UK was a hard-working hegemon with capital exports that more or less paid for themselves from foreign earnings.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For a comparison of our hall of mirrors world with that earlier form of hegemony, see the lastest Chartbook newsletter: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-443-hard-working-hegemon
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Only a little way into these conversations between John Gerassi and Sartre, but the exchanges between them about their families and relationships, Sartre’s childhood, projects and the meaning of life (sic) are fascinating. More at the Chartbook Top Links of the day:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/china-investing-in-batteries-ind…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
Denmark's coal-to-wind transition is one of the most dramatic energy transformations of the past three decades.
In 1990, coal provided 90% of Danish electricity. Today it is under 3%.
Wind now covers roughly 60% of electricity generation. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Kim
@oliverwkim
Bizarre
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A chart for the new world in which you care about when American farmers apply fertilizers to their fields! Linked in today's Chartbook Top links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/china-investing-in-batteries-ind…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China has been spreading its battery bets across much of Europe! More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/china-investing-in-batteries-ind…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David Adler
@davidrkadler
Does no one else see in these videos the most terrifying premonition for all of human civilization?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
peak PEACE w/no bullshit would be cool 😵💫
@mmahoooooit
“Its main appeal is that it can be deployed by the US Treasury Secretary without accountability to a forum like the Fed Board.”
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For more on how "swap lines" morph into "slush lines" check out the latest Chartbook newsletter and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-443-obscurity-to-notor… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Victor Mallet
@VJMallet
Known in Britain as an 'omnishambles'!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Tooze is on a roll -- great instant history of the Exchange Stabilization Fund
1/2
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For more on how "swap lines" morph into "slush lines" check out the latest Chartbook newsletter and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-443-obscurity-to-notor… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The US cattle and beef industry is in a bad way. Find out more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chinas-oil-reserves-global-hunger
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
The FT notes that the Treasury's ESF appears cash constrained relative to even the Emirates' central bank, let alone the Emirates sovereign funds
1/ -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Bessent's Treasury is pioneering a new kind of highly political financial agency. First there was the financial package for Millei in September 2025, now for UAE and other allies.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The ideal vehicle for this kind of discretionary, high-stakes political intervention is not the Fed but the Treasury's very-own ESF. This practice goes all the way back to the Clinton administration and Mexico in 1994/1995.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For more on how "swap lines" morph into "slush lines" check out the latest Chartbook newsletter and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-443-obscurity-to-notor… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Robert Lucas Scott
@_rob_scott
A recording of J. H. Prynne reflecting on reading at Gillian Rose’s funeral and on his “brief but remarkable and incandescent friendship with her” (University of Sussex, 2006)
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
And a lot of that growth in renewable power capacity in the US @70sBachchan is in the ultimate "petrostate", Texas!
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
feel like the whole "US is a Petrostate" discourse misses that nearly 90 percent of all electricity demand growth in the US has been met by renewables recently
-
Adam Tooze reposted
John Bistline
@JEBistline
People still talk about energy storage as the missing piece that will eventually make renewables work. In Arizona, it's already >20% of total capacity and still climbing. At some point "the future" becomes "this year's data."
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Interesting indeed. But we dont disagree in any way, other, perhaps, than your assertion that Chinese competition is discouraging EV innovation elsewhere. Surely not true for players like VW. @LucaFornaro3
Luca Fornaro
@LucaFornaro3
This post by @adam_tooze is excellent. There's one point missing: global imbalances are part of a struggle for technological hegemony. When China puts in place policies that foster trade surpluses in high-tech sectors, it is not only boosting its own technological development,
-
Adam Tooze reposted
A.V. Marraccini
@saintsoftness
Stop skipping the Homeric textual equivalent of Maya Lin’s Vietnam War Memorial! The catalogue of ships in Book II is meant to make you feel the sheer weight of those deaths, hear a name that might be someone you knew once, make war tangible to the ear!
Tim Stanley
@timothy_stanley
Incredible. An ancient Egyptian was mummified with an extract from The Iliad... and they chose Book 2? (The ships) This is the bit everyone usually skips!
www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/04/21/iliad-found-stu… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Dave DeCamp
@DecampDave
I know I'm always going on about this, but isn't it crazy that the US has bombed Somalia 58 times this year and nobody knows about it
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Justin Sandefur
@JustinSandefur
with @charlesjkenny:
USAID fallout update
aid disbursements have fallen a bit less, and new obligations a bit more, than we guessed a year ago -- while new PEPFAR data may hint at a lower mortality impact than we forecast.
www.cgdev.org/blog/usaid-spending-country-and-sector-leve… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
André Rougé in 2022, considered to be the leader of Les Horaces. In today's Chartbook Top Links, I recommend reading Far-Right France: Le Pen, Bardella and the Future of Europe, by Victor Mallet. More charts and links featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Dave Jones
@CleanPowerDave
AFRICA SOLAR: wowsers, almost 4GW of panels in one month!
Yes, it was prior to the 9% China export rebate changes, so a bit of a rise was expected, but even still!
Records everywhere..
🧵
Dave Jones
@CleanPowerDave
AFRICA SOLAR: 7 months later, and still new records are being set☀️
DRC🇨🇩, Egypt🇪🇬, Mozambique🇲🇿, Zambia🇿🇲 and Zimbabwe🇿🇼 show a particularly new step up... -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Under the sanctions regime, Iran’s trade has diversified dramatically. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jared Henderson
@jhendersonYT
Weil's The Need for Roots, which Routledge decided needed some root vegetables on the cover.
Stoni Astley
@StoniAstley
Any examples of a bad cover for a great book?
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicolas Fulghum
@nicolasfulghum
Pakistan's solar buildout is truly incredible
2020: 4 TWh, 3% of the mix
2024: 20 TWh, 11%
2025: 37 TWh, 19%
Nearly all distributed solar generation. Solar is modular, scalable and affordable and the fastest way to energy independence for many countries. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
Incredible. We will watch sport after sport gradually fall to robots.
The Rundown AI
@TheRundownAI
Sony AI just published the first autonomous robot to beat elite humans at a competitive physical sport.
Its name is Ace. The sport is table tennis. The paper dropped in Nature today.
9 cameras triangulate the ball in 3D. Three systems zoom in on the ball's logo mid-flight to read its spin axis.
End-to-end reaction time is around 20 milliseconds, roughly 10x faster than a human.
It learned by playing itself for 3,000 hours in simulation. No human demonstrations.
In April 2025, Ace beat 3 of 5 elite players and lost to both pros. By December, it had beaten a pro.
At one point, Ace returned an impossible backspin shot. Kinjiro Nakamura, a 1992 Barcelona Olympian, watched from the side:
"No one else would have been able to do that. I didn't think it was possible. But the fact that it was possible means there is a possibility that a human could do it too." -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Kral
@DanielKral1
South Korea and Poland present two distinct solutions to the challenges of late development shaped by their unique contexts.
Korea, and other East Asian economies, protected their nascent industries before exposing them to global competition. The aim was to create domestic champions that would become the engine of domestic growth and innovation, bringing the countries to the global technological frontier. They were able to do so in the context of their Western alignment in the Cold War. Iconic global brands from South Korea and Taiwan emerged as a result, though many other countries attempting this path have failed.
In contrast, Poland and other Central and Eastern European (CEE) economies underwent a turbulent transition from centrally planned to market economies while facing strict constraints from EU accession and membership rules, which precluded protectionist measures. In this setting, foreign direct investment (FDI) became the primary solution. Rather than complementing or building local capabilities, FDI largely supplanted them. CEE countries integrated deeply into global value chains, typically in lower-value, downstream segments dominated by foreign multinationals. Hence, there are no Polish or Romanian global champions; where local successes exist, they largely function as suppliers for these multinationals.
An open question for CEE’s “hyper-integrationist” development model is whether it can achieve full convergence with Western living standards, given its structural reliance on external agents of modernization and limited indigenous innovation capacity (the differences in R&D spending versus Korea a great example). Can an economy attain high-income status without developing globally competitive firms and reaching the technological frontier?
This challenge differs qualitatively from that confronting stagnant Western European economies (eg. Germany, France, and the UK). The latter must sustain growth and competitiveness at the technological frontier amid a host of new domestic and global challenges. As a result, CEE experiences offer few direct lessons for Western Europe, which explains their limited prominence in reports such as Mario Draghi’s on restoring EU competitiveness.
Marcin Piatkowski
@mmpiatkowski
A surprising finding: Poland's (and Romania's) speed of income convergence after reaching a $25,000 in GDP PPP pc income threshold has so far been as fast that of South Korea 🇰🇷 even though Poland 🇵🇱 spends on R&D only 1/3 of that in South Korea (and Romania 🇷🇴only 1/10!)👇
Interpretation:
- One can become high-income by absorbing technology (including through FDI), not only by innovating at the frontier (and building cheabols to make it happen). This suggests that Polish/Central European growth model can be easier to replicate for developing countries than that of South Korea/Asian Tigers b/c it is much easier to open the economy/absorb technology/attract FDI than to build globally successful cheabols.
Question:
- At what income level does the technology absorption success story ends? Achieving 100% of the EU average level of income, which Poland may reach by 2035, may be the key threshold. That said, South Korea has stopped converging around the EU-27 income average👇 and its high level of R&D spending (and existence of global companies) seems not to have made much of a difference (although arguably there are other benefits of being at the innovation frontier, including military technological prowess [although UKR, which has had hardly any R&D before the war is proving it wrong], global soft power etc.).
@Noahpinion
www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/002/2025/007/article-A… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Assaad Razzouk
@AssaadRazzouk
Solar isn't just growing. The scale of its 2025 surge is completely bonkers
>We added enough new solar last year to displace every single unit of gas power generated by 100% of LNG exports through the Strait of Hormuz
>So just 1 year of solar growth wiped out the energy equivalent of the world's most critical fossil fuel chokepoint
>Solar growth was 18x gas growth
>China alone added more solar in 1 year than the entire world in 2023
This isn't a transition. It's a hostile takeover by superior economics. Betting on fossil fuels today is exactly like betting on whale oil while Edison was turning on the lightbulb -
Adam Tooze reposted
World Data Analysis
@World_Data_A
A different World by 2030: The great shift in global manufacturing
The structure of global industrial production is undergoing a profound transformation. In 2000, high-income countries, led by the United States, Japan, and Germany,dominated manufacturing output, with the U.S. alone holding around 25%. China’s share was just 6%.
By 2030, the picture changes dramatically. China’s share is projected to surge to ~45%, becoming by far the dominant manufacturing power. In contrast, the U.S. declines to around 11%, while traditional industrial leaders like Japan and Germany fall to single-digit shares. At the same time, other emerging economies, such as India and Türkiye, begin to gain visibility, though still at much smaller scales.
The inner circle reinforces this shift: global manufacturing is moving from a high-income country-dominated system to one increasingly centered around upper-middle-income Asia, particularly China. In 2000, high-income countries (blue) dominated global manufacturing with roughly ~75% share, while upper-middle-income Asia (red, mainly China) accounted for only about ~15%. By 2030, this balance is projected to shift dramatically, with Asia rising to around ~50%, overtaking high-income economies, whose share falls to roughly ~35–40%, marking a clear relocation of industrial power.
Source: @SCS_PI -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Global imbalances - April 2026. A new cocktail in old bottles.
The latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped.
Check it out here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-442-global-imbalances-a -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jesse D. Jenkins
@JesseJenkins
You wouldn't know it if you live in the USA or consume US media and politics, but the fight between EVs and ICEs is basically over. Internal combustion is on it's way out. First it'll look slow, then fast. Fleet turnover will lag sales. But ALL the growth globally is in EVs. If your company isn't competitive in building EVs and can only build internal combustion, you're going to be stuck serving an ever-smaller share of a shrinking global market over the next decade...
Assaad Razzouk
@AssaadRazzouk
New IEA data: EV sales in emerging markets surge 80% in 2025
>India: EVs up 75% to record 2.3m EV units sold
>Indonesia: 125% increase
>Viet Nam: EVs hit staggering 40% share of new car sales
>Thailand: EV share of new sales hit 21%
>Latin America: Region saw 70% annual growth
>Mexico: Sales tripled
>Brazil: Sales up 40%
>Ecuador and Uruguay: Experienced massive jumps of 240% and 140%
The "EVs are only for rich countries and China" bullshit is officially over -
Adam Tooze reposted
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
CHART OF THE DAY: The size of the 🇨🇳 Chinese strategic petroleum reserve is mind blowing: larger than 🇺🇸 US + 🇯🇵 Japan + the whole of 🇪🇺 Western Europe combined.
Via @EIAgov — more: www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=67504 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
The Song dynasty’s tax/GDP ratio was running at the same level as Britain during the Napoleonic Wars 800 years later. Important data point to globalize the fiscal-military state literature.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Curious what @Brad_Setser makes of the arguments made in "The Chinese current account imbalances: Puzzles, patterns, and possible causes" by Chang Ma and Shang-Jin Wei of Fudan.
cepr.org/system/files/publication-files/295969-paris_repo… -
Adam Tooze reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
Renewables provided more electricity production than coal last year. And while no individual renewable source yet matches coal, solar was at almost 1/3 the output of coal in 2025 and is doubling globally roughly every three years (putting it on pace to surpass coal around 2032).
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Energy Secretary Chris Wright: "I'm pretty confident coal will lead the world in global electricity production when I die"
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Eastern Libya’s Top Money Man - or how Libya’s central bank financed the assault on Tripoli by way of Abu Dhabi. The Sentry article featured in the Chartbook Top Links today.
thesentry.org/reports/eastern-libyas-top-money-man/
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-tanker-convoy-to-the-gulf-coast
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Empty tankers mainly from Asia form long lines from Cape of Good Hope to US Gulf Coast. Find out more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/publish/posts/published
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
America Is in the Middle of a Stealth Manufacturing Boom, as shown in this visual from the WSJ. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicolas Fulghum
@nicolasfulghum
For anyone wondering whether the fossil fuel crisis in the Middle East is driving interest in clean energy technologies:
China's exports of batteries, EVs and solar products shot up in March to $21.9 billion!
This is an all-time record and a 70% increase over March 2025.
Ember
@ember_energy
NEW | Record exports of solar, batteries and EVs last month 📈
China’s exports for the ‘new three’ industries reached a record high of $21.9bn in March 2026, up 70% year-on-year, in the wake of the US-Israel war with Iran and changing export rebates for solar and batteries. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
You found me at a very Warring States Period of my life
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ben Rhodes
@brhodes
"The most systematic destruction was caused by D9 bulldozers made by the US company Caterpillar. These giant armored machines stabbed their blades into the ground, churning up fields, felling orchards, flattening homes, tearing through roads and ploughing through cemeteries."
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Wortel-London
@dlondonwortel
It’s not just new, it’s newspeak
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How gum arabic – the ingredient that puts the gloss in Coke, Pepsi and M&Ms – is fuelling the conflict in Sudan (from Jeune Afrique). Find out more in the Chartbook Top Link of today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“Looking through”, “looking beyond”, one way or another the US equity market is not looking down. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/looking-through-iran-japans-car-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Explaining the Resilience of Global Growth in 2025 from the IMF. Lower tariffs or other variables? More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Abdelal shows how capital market liberalization was pushed by groups of European actors including leading French socialists. Today's Chrtbook Top Links in the comment below
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joseph Torigian
@JosephTorigian
Leafing through this new book.... looks great, excited to read.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The impact of the war on the global economy as measured by revisions to the IMF’s World Economic Outlook: a very significant hit to the Middle East itself and Low-income Developing Economics. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Two-Faced Present - A conversation about the “short twentieth century” – and the paradoxical twenty-first with Wang Hui (in collaboration with @Equatormag and @KaiserKuo Big shout out to @CGCBeijing for hosting our event. Video to follow I hope.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Who are the Dems? The Economist polled some 19,000 Democrats and grouped them on the basis of some fancy maths. Interesting results, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-last-prewar-tankers-reach-th…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The last oil tankers to traverse the Strait of Hormuz before the outbreak of war will reach refineries in the coming days, in a pivotal moment analysts warn could herald physical shortages in Europe and the US within weeks. More at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-last-prewar-tankers-reach-th…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Aaron Freedman
@freedaaron
Where's the money? Geography of bank deposits in 1967 vs 2024
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
Reading the report by experts on global imbalances for the G7. shorturl.at/zZf25 and the many current discussions on the topic. I shall tweet several reactions, (and try to put them together in some piece later on).
Do we care about imbalances because they reflect underlying distortions or mistaken policies? Or because even if not, they have effects on other countries which are bad? Or both, and in what proportions? For example: Do we care about the Chinese surplus because it reflects bad Chinese policies, or because it has adverse effects on German manufacturing? Do we care about US fiscal policy because it is irresponsible, or because it increases the world interest rate and this is somehow unacceptable? -
Adam Tooze reposted
Karl Schamotta
@Karl_Schamotta
The US Treasury market has only grown more dominant in recent decades, exploding in scale while its closest rivals have remained fragmented (the euro area), strictly controlled (China), or largely moribund (Japan). Global investors have no real alternatives:
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Wortel-London
@dlondonwortel
The American Archive of Public Broadcasting, to their eternal glory, have digitized more than 7,000 public radio and television programs from 1940 to the present.
It's a treasure trove of historic newsreels, interviews, speeches, and more.
Dive in here.
americanarchive.org -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hungary’s real wages have been picking up, but btw 2004 and the early 2010s they went from middle of the East European pack to the bottom of the league. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/schumpeterian-waves-in-the-us-ec…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
in a new paper on Coercive Credit Regimes where we map in detail the critical credit/industrial nexus that powers the extraordinary Made in China 2025 success
osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/qwrb2_v1
Robert Ward
@RobertAlanWard
Unlevel playing field - FT chart showing how China’s industrial subsidies dwarf everyone else’s, esp ‘below market borrowings’.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ted Merz
@TedMerz
The best story about The New York Times this week didn’t appear in the paper.
In fact it wasn’t an article at all, but a web site created by a freelance journalist named Ted Alcorn.
Alcorn tapped into the paper’s public API to create a dashboard that provides some extraordinary insights.
The first was that over the past 25 years, the Times employed – at various times – a total of 26,000 reporters who wrote 1.5 billion words to produce 2.2 million articles.
You can use the dashboard to drill down to see which beats, topics and people have been covered the most and how that coverage has fluctuated.
A few examples of the kinds of things Alcorn cited that he noticed:
➡️Trump dominates headlines vs everyone
➡️Maggie Haberman has the most bylines recently
➡️India has been undercovered per-capita
➡️China coverage peaked around 2014
➡️Iowa stories surge every four years
Political partisans will mine the site for ammunition to argue the paper of record is pro THIS or anti THAT.
But that debate misses larger truths unearthed counting the number of stories in so many ways over such a long time period.
The volume provides a measure of attention largely independent of ideology. Whether a news story about Trump is positive or negative doesn’t change the fact it is about Trump. And the fact that a story was published about Trump reflects interest in hm.
It’s not a perfect system, but at this scale, breath and consistency, there is probably no better public dataset to measure what is on everyone's mind.
What Alcorn built – whether he realized it or not – was effectively a better version of Google Trends.
Google Trends provides comparisons based on search but they don't give you the actual data. It's normalized so you get relative percentages and that limits the comparisons you can make.
The Times archive comes from a single institution with a mostly consistent editorial policy over 25 years. That makes apples to apples comparisons possible. It’s a clean cohort in a world where good data is hard to find.
It provides a useful signal for understanding how attention has shifted among countries, companies, or individuals.
Times reporters jumped on the site when it appeared, mostly to see where they ranked on the leader board. Times editors will likely use the tool to better understand how coverage has shifted.
Given its utility, it’s sort of insane that it took an outsider to build it.
But in an open API world, the best analytics often are built by people outside the wall.
Alcorn explained the difficulty of reconciling data: Categories shift and reporters change names. The same subject gets coded differently over time.
Some Times reporters flagged bugs and suggested features.
But so far the paper hasn’t commented on the project, which he cheekily called Below the Fold.
Here is the link to the @tedalcorn site tedalcorn.github.io/nyt/ -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I will be at the Committee on Global Thought's 20 year anniversary event!
We will be discussing on the theme of "The Global University? Looking Back, Looking Forward".
Tuesday. April 28, 2026 at 5:30 PM
The Lee C. Bollinger Forum, 605 W 125th Street
Register here: -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reports of the end of China’s One Belt One Road lending were very premature - 2025 was a record year for new commitments. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/schumpeterian-waves-in-the-us-ec…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Because it combines technological waves with macroeconomic quantities, this is such an important graph (quibbles about quantification aside). More on this in the Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/schumpeterian-waves-in-the-us-ec…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nathan J Robinson
@NathanJRobinson
did you know: every day the @WSJ opinion editors have an internal contest to see who can commission the most sociopathic editorial. Here's the latest entry
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The oil that the USA imports from the Gulf is overwhelmingly medium sour, much of which ships to the West Coast which lacks pipeline access to domestic or Canadian oil. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Evan A. Feigenbaum
@EvanFeigenbaum
Really amazing footage of Chiang Kai-shek visiting Yan Xishan in Shanxi in 1934. H.H. Kung and Song Ailing also make appearances.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Angus Bylsma
@AngusBylsma
This week’s (not) review! - a very short discussion of, and excerpt from, Vasily Grossman’s Everything Flows. For those who prefer their novels unabashedly world-historical…
Link below 👇
Angus Bylsma
@AngusBylsma
Really enjoying this. Despite the latter’s fame, it seems to me that Grossman is a much more powerful and sophisticated critic of Stalinism than Solzhenitsyn.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Australia is uniquely vulnerable to disruptions in diesel supply,leading to a real diesel Armada heading there in the wake of the crisis in the Strait of Hormuz. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-australian-diesel-armada-the…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
CanadianChemicalStatsGuy
@DaveCherniak
This is a fantastic thread!
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Good question from @adam_tooze
Not sure the IMF - which used the lagged and under reported Chinese 2024 current account data -- made the best case.
Think the real answer is China's manufacturing surplus is actually huge v history (would be bigger in real terms)
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
An increasingly coherent picture of the impact of AI on jobs, by @jburnmurdoch @ft:
1. New Fed paper by Crane and Soto now confirms with official labor force survey data what private payroll analysis was showing: roughly 500,000 fewer coders are working than pre-LLM trends would predict.
2. Argues evidence consistent with my work (with Lin and Wu, link in my pinned post) on weak/strong bundles: junior developers and contractors hold "weak bundles" (their work is mostly standalone coding that AI can substitute directly), senior developers hold "tight bundles" where coding is combined with domain expertise, judgment, and cross-functional responsibilities, making substitution much harder.
3. Freund & Mann and Gans & Goldfarb add a second lens: what matters is the value of the tasks that survive automation. Remove coding from a senior role and you free up time for higher-value work; remove it from a junior role and almost nothing remains.
www.ft.com/content/b69f8599-eaf1-477a-a5a8-60a715e56a04?s… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Surveying the Middle East’s energy infrastructure damage (from FT Alphaville Robin Wigglesworth). More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/from-coalstate-to-electrostate-the
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Michel Bauwens
@mbauwens
* On Karl Polanyi's (The Great Transformation) influence in China
www.karlpolanyisociety.com/2021/05/28/polanyi-in-china/
"In 2007, the first simplified Chinese translation of The Great Transformation was published in mainland China. Today, Chinese scholars not only refer to Polanyi’s theory in order to explain the problems in China’s reform and opening-up process, but also develop a global vision and try to reflect on the structural problems with modern complex societies." -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In the current war on Iran not only are there thousands of strikes, but millions of people are within the immediate field of the destruction. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/from-coalstate-to-electrostate-the
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Turkey appears to be living off its gold reserves. Find out more in the Chartbook Top Link of today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/from-coalstate-to-electrostate-the
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Unless I am seeing things, there is something wrong with this graph in @IMFNews WEO Chp2 2026. World defense spending did no halve as a share of global gdp in the mid 1960s! Can anyone explain. Ive checked @SIPRIorg database.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kristalina Georgieva
@KGeorgieva
Higher fertilizer prices and supply chain disruptions could push another 45 million people into hunger, resulting in a total number of over 360 million. At the #imfmeetings Curtain Raiser, I shared how this could get worse over time: www.imf.org/en/news/articles/2026/04/09/sp040926-spring-m…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Diane Swonk
@DianeSwonk
Asked if I have ever seen anything like this labor market. NO. NOTHING. IT IS UNIQUE.
FedResearch
@FedResearch
ICYMI: Labor force growth could be near-zero starting this year, due to weak population growth & declining labor force participation. Such weak growth is unprecedented in the United States’ recent history. This has significant economic implications: (1/2) www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/labor-for…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
The University of Michigan has been measuring consumer sentiment since 1952. We just got the first Iran-afflicted measure for April, and it's at the lowest level ever recorded.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“The president has threatened to destroy a civilization. How does an investor process that?”
Bruno Maçães
@MacaesBruno
Best summary of America I have seen
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The price shock in Eastern Europe after COVID was far worse than in the West! Today's Chartbook Top Links has more:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/how-orbans-hungary-is-lagging-th…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Not only can the German defense establishment not build its own ships. It can’t even commission them competently from other people. Excellent reporting from Laura Pitel in the FT, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/how-orbans-hungary-is-lagging-th…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
ZTE was indeed China's Sputnik moment.
More than ChatGPT. More than the Oct 2022 export controls. More than the Huawei sanctions that followed. Trump's decision to cut off ZTE from US tech on April 15, 2018 was a seismic wake-up call for the nation. It basically brought one of China's high-tech champions to the brink of collapse with the stroke of a pen.
This NYT piece by @liyuan from that time looks so prescient now: www.nytimes.com/2018/06/10/technology/china-technology-zt…. I still think about this quote from a researcher at Tsinghua: "We realized that China's prosperity was built on sand."
So much that we see today in China--the new Five-Year Plan, the obsession with tech self-reliance 科技自立自强, the Central Science & Technology Commission, the Manhattan Project-style effort to build out a fully domestic semiconductor supply chain--can be partly traced back to that ZTE shock. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Despite all the bluster around Orban’s supposed economic successes, Hungary lags towards the bottom of the East European “convergence” club. More at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/how-orbans-hungary-is-lagging-th…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There is a bit of me that thinks this must be an April’s fools joke. But I think it is for real. More in this in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Source: www.pistachiowars.com -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
Two translations of my book The Age of Confiscation coming later this year // De Nederlandse vertaling verschijnt eind augustus bij @alfabetboeken // Und die deutsche Übersetzung wird im November bei @_s_fischer erscheinen.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Stefan Eich
@stefeich
Reading Seaford’s amazing book was actually one of my ways into all of this. Totally blew my mind! He also wrote a neat article on money and tragedy a few years before the book: www.jstor.org/stable/632234
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
sounds like one for @stefeich
mica
@nonredeemer
“How were the Greeks able to invent philosophy and tragedy? In this book Richard Seaford argues that a large part of the answer can be found in another momentous development, the invention and rapid spread of coinage which produced the first ever thoroughly monetised society.”
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Shanu Mathew
@ShanuMathew93
Nearly half of US data centers planned for this year are expected to be delayed or canceled. Not a capital availability or chip problem. It's transformers and electrical equipment. Lead times have gone from 24 months to five years. The big four are spending $650B+ in 2026 alone but can't actually source the gear domestically.
So we must buy from China. Ironic that the country the US has to beat in AI is also the country supplying the parts to build it. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Sugarman
@Daniel_Sugarman
An FT correction for the ages...
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Oil or petroleum importer with low income and shaky balance of payments? Your bond yields just shot up. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-collapse-of-the-new-deal-fin…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Methanol - another basic material the price of which has surged. More on this in the Chartbook Top links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-collapse-of-the-new-deal-fin…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @Brad_Setser one of the questions I have is simply why the alarm at this moment? I know the industry-level data can look dramatic. But looking at the macro picture one might be tempted to say that the imbalance are broadly what they have been for a two decades.
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Happy to see the IMF has noticed the expansion of global current account imbalances --
And guess what, the IMF seems to have rediscovered the idea that currency manipulation can drive imbalances (though manipulation has been renamed "macro-industrial policy" ... )
1/ many -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Already saw this in 2022. But same is clearly true for rich East Asian economies and China.
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Am I wrong about calculated logic of Bidding war?
1 there is a limited amount of hydrocarbon molecules in the world for many months
2 the more US & Europe shield their citizens with subsidies & fuel tax exemptions the more effectively molecules will find their way to the US & EU
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Chief economist at Berenberg Bank, said he is not expecting widespread energy shortages in Europe or US. These countries are “rich enough to outbid anyone else if we have to”
Ugly rich vs poor politics of BIDDING WARS in shortages. We saw it with masks, vaccines,LNG in 2020s -
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Am I wrong about calculated logic of Bidding war?
1 there is a limited amount of hydrocarbon molecules in the world for many months
2 the more US & Europe shield their citizens with subsidies & fuel tax exemptions the more effectively molecules will find their way to the US & EU
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Chief economist at Berenberg Bank, said he is not expecting widespread energy shortages in Europe or US. These countries are “rich enough to outbid anyone else if we have to”
Ugly rich vs poor politics of BIDDING WARS in shortages. We saw it with masks, vaccines,LNG in 2020s -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ava Petrucci
@mmeJen
It will go very poorly for the United States if the people of the world witness this man get blown up on his live stream.
Iran Embassy in Australia
@IraninAustralia
Iranian musician Ali Ghamsari, a composer and Tar player, announced that starting today, he will stay at Damavand power plant responsible for providing half of Tehran’s electricity with his instrument for some time, creating music to help prevent attacks on Iran's infrastructure.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Yale’s Famed Investing Model Falters at a Fraught Time for Colleges. More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/americas-aging-homes-russias-ira…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
What's stunning about this rhetoric is that the vast majority of the world outside the US sees the Trump admin as the aggressor that has provoked the current crisis, and the dissonance is wild
Headquarters
@HQNewsNow
JD Vance doubles down on Trump’s new post threatening “a whole civilization will die tonight” and implies Trump might use nuclear weapons
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Aaron Freedman
@freedaaron
slowly but surely moving towards a publishable place with this banking concentration map
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
Lebanon is one of the most surprising clean energy stories in the world.
Solar went from <1% of electricity in 2020 to nearly 30% by 2024.
Not because of policy - because the state grid collapsed and people installed rooftop solar out of sheer necessity. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Nikhil Pal Singh
@nikhil_palsingh
Nothing about last nights explosions in Jubail Industrial City in Saudi Arabia in today's New York Times or Wall Street Journal. The US press has become utterly useless, incapable of charting the long term impact this war will have on the people it supposedly seeks to inform.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Christy Thornton
@llchristyll
My article "Riots could be expected: Toward a global history of protest and reaction at the World Bank" is now officially published in the newest issue of the Journal of Global History - open access! Read for post-Maoist rioters and Robert McNamara lore: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-global-history…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Yohan
@yohaniddawela
A team of researchers just traced the supply chain of every building and bridge across 1,000 cities. The resulting carbon data makes our current housing targets look mathematically impossible.
For years, we lacked a way to calculate the true environmental cost of urban growth. Global economic models track the flow of money and ecological impacts at the national level. We knew exactly how much carbon a country emitted making steel and concrete. We just couldn't trace those materials down to the specific metropolitan areas consuming them.
So a team built a top-down allocation model to find out. They took 20 years of global input-output data and merged it with local economic proxies like construction employment and regional GDP. They effectively generated an itemised receipt for the embodied carbon of every highway, pipeline, and residential tower built in major global cities.
Then they calculated strict cumulative carbon budgets. They took the remaining global carbon allowance required to stay below 2°C of warming and divided it up. They allocated shares to specific sectors and then distributed those shares to individual cities based on population and historic emission rates. A city like Montréal gets a hard mathematical limit on how much carbon its construction sector can emit from 2020 onwards.
This is where the climate data collides with the housing crisis.
Most major cities are projecting massive population growth and authorising immense residential construction programmes to match. Toronto plans to build hundreds of thousands of new units by 2031.
The researchers calculated the material intensity of this future housing stock. They pulled data on the concrete, steel, brick, and glass required for different building types. They then ran complex simulations to model the life-cycle emissions of manufacturing those exact materials.
When you multiply the required new floor space by the embodied carbon of standard construction materials, the budgets immediately fail. Building enough housing to meet projected population growth using our current supply chains guarantees a massive carbon overshoot.
The gap between these two realities forces a brutal choice. We either accept that we will blow past our remaining global carbon budget, or we drastically change how we build. Meeting future housing demands within the required climate limits demands an immediate shift away from high-emission concrete and steel toward timber and radical material efficiency.
The maths is completely unforgiving. You can have the necessary housing, or you can use traditional building methods. You can't have both.
Link to article: www.nature.com/articles/s44284-025-00379-8 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
America’s homes are increasingly old and in need of maintenance. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/americas-aging-homes-russias-ira…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
ArtButMakeItNow
@artbutnow
The Garden of Earthly Delights (detail), by Hieronymus Bosch, 1480-1505, 📸 by @alexbrandon
-
Adam Tooze reposted
npj
@TiltingatM3
There's a PhD student at Columbia, Seokju Oh, whose work on wwi grain trade regulations is so cool you guys won't even believe me
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Pelagia
@Ljiljana1972
RIP David Lynch you would have loved this.
Paul Schofield
@pschofie79
Am I stoned right now? I must be stoned.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Labour market indicators suggest the US economy is still going strong. This and more in the today's Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/jobs-v-cardboard-boxes-pakistan-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Many African retail markets are contested by dueling French and South African chains. This and more featured in the Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/jobs-v-cardboard-boxes-pakistan-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China moves upstream in production networks. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/jobs-v-cardboard-boxes-pakistan-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Solar is now the less capital-intensive option. More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Gaurab Chakrabarti
@Gaurab
Apple sealed water inside the iPhone 17 Pro. It's called a vapor chamber. Held at partial vacuum, the water boils well below 100°C. That's the design. When the A19 Pro heats up, the water vaporizes, spreads across a 40mm copper envelope, condenses, and wicks back through copper powder that was sintered at 900°C in hydrogen (to form the pore structure). There's no pump or fan. Apple implemented the same phase-change principle that runs a nuclear reactor in a copper sheet thinner than a credit card. Samsung already shipped this in 2019. Apple waited six years. A sealed vacuum with water and porous copper has to survive drops, temperature extremes, and five years of daily use without a single leak. One leak and the cycle dies permanently. Apple needs 80 to 100 million of these per year. Three suppliers make them, all in Taiwan and China.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Added to which, a single first-rate warship in Nelson's fleet had more heavy artillery firepower than several Napoleonic corps.
Stilicho
@GenStilicho
These ships were -- by far -- the most expensive and complex machines in existence at the time. A substantial cotton mill at the end of the 18th century cost £5,000; the Royal Navy spent £13,000 every six months to keep a single first-rate warship afloat.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tacos and Airplanes
@blob_watcher
whoever leaked the exact JASSM-ER quantities to Bloomberg...I salute you!
Bloomberg
@business
The next steps in the US military campaign against Iran will commit nearly its entire inventory of stealthy JASSM-ER cruise missiles, drawing them from stockpiles devoted to other regions. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-04-04/us-deploys-bul…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
US crude oil production breaks new records. What does this mean for other countries? For the American public? More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jacobin
@jacobin
The war on Iran is a joint effort by segments of the US, Israeli, European, and Arab ruling classes that are committed to global and regional domination — not just the result of Israeli pressure on Donald Trump.jacobin.com/2026/03/netanyahu-iran-war-neocons-trump
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Iddo עידו عيدو
@iddoelam
Great piece by @Nimrod_Flash published at @jacobin about the Iran war, recommend you go and read it asap
jacobin.com/2026/03/netanyahu-iran-war-neocons-trump -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jake Werner
@jwdwerner
Great encapsulation of the Biden admin on China:
Recitation of pieties about how important diplomacy is to avoid conflict...
alongside a contorted definition of interests that inevitably leads to conflict.
Council on Foreign Relations
@CFR_org
“I have had to look President Xi in the eye and say, ‘President, America’s national security is not for sale. Period. Full stop,’” says @GinaRaimondo, CFR expert and former U.S. secretary of commerce.
“The truth of it is, their interests are opposed to ours. Right? Like they want to control their supply chain. They want to use critical minerals as leverage over us. They want and will take Taiwan. We want the opposite.”
🔗 Watch the full conversation: on.cfr.org/4bIWMw3 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The winners and losers of the Iran war are not who you might expect. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chinas-pork-glut-desalination-at…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Will water be decisive in the Gulf war? The arid Arab countries of the Gulf increasingly rely on desalination, which provides 90% or more of the drinking-water supply for Bahrain, Kuwait and Qatar, and almost as much for Oman. For Saudi Arabia it is 70%, and roughly 40% in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). More in today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chinas-pork-glut-desalination-at…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alon Mizrahi
@alon_mizrahi
Let's spend coffee time playing a little wargame in which the US decides to take on Iran and commit to a full war against it
Look at this map. Where could the US stage an invasion of Iran?
To Iran's east, you'll find Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Turkmenistan. A big triple no.
To Iran's south: the Persian Gulf which it completely dominates. No good.
To Iran's west: Iraq and Turkiye. The first a definite no, the second, a no so probable it must be considered a certain. Turkiye will not go to war with Iran for the US and Israel - a war not only sure to decimate it, but a war Turkich people will be fanatically against.
To Iran's north is the Caspian Sea. No use.
Azerbaijan and Armenia present an opening, but how will hundreds of thousands of NATO soldiers get there (let alone undetected)? If they go by sea, they will need to traverse the Mediterranean and the Black Sea and virtually physically go through Istanbul. Not only politically complicated, but a long long journey that gives Iran tons of time to prepare.
Remember the months and months the US took to amass forces for the Iraq invasion? It took 6 months or so - with no interruptions.
The problem is, with Iran, there's no way they're going to simply build up forces near the designated target's borders.
Iran has an arsenal of hundreds of thousands of guided and precise ballistic missiles, satellites in space and eyes almost everywhere. If a war is declared or started, every American asset within 0-3000 kilometers of Iran's borders will be bombarded so viciously no missile defense system will be able to stop it.
And all those dozens and dozens of American bases scattered throughout the vast area surrounding Iran? How will the US defend them under an attack on a scale of 1000 October 7th's combined?
Additionally, Iran has the most sophisticated anti-ship missiles in the world (Russia's Yakhont), of which it probably has thousands by now. This means no surface ship is going to be able to come close enough to Iran to make it an effective striking weapon (is this going to be the first time we get to see an aircraft carrier drowning? I believe potentially yes).
The US will have to rely on air superiority, but this is going to prove a very difficult, almost impossible task. US planes will have to fly a long way to get to Iran (and back), and it has invested massively in air defense systems, including some of the most sophisticated in Russia's arsenal. The US will lose many planes which will take years to replenish, and Iran will be able to target with ballistic missiles and drones all the bases from which they take off in Europe or the Middle East.
Another tool the US will use is cruise missiles fired from submarines: but this, too, does not win wars, and can be costly against a rival that prepared for this.
A full-scale invasion of Iran will require potentially millions of soldiers and will take years. The West is simply incapable of an effort of this kind: where will they find millions of young men willing to die at sea in order to occupy a country thousands of miles away? Today? Give me a break.
All this time the Iranians will be defending their home and their independence. The West will be trying to colonize and destroy them. They will have Gaza on their minds.
-
I didn't mention Israel because it is virtually irrelevant in this war. Hizbullah alone is enough to paralyze it and keep its military busy for months.
-
Bonus point: think about what happens to energy prices in an actual war with Iran. 500$ for an oil barrel? 1000$? 2000$? All is possible.
Guess what country will remain the biggest international producer and exporter of oil and gas, and rip all those extra many, many trillions. You guessed tight. Russia. If the Persian Gulf is up in flames, Russia will become a global economic superpower (at a time when the US is dwindled militarily and economically and cannot even fake a military threat against it).
-
Another bonus point: you think Iran cannot, or will not attack on American soil? Think again. From cyber attacks to large-scale, professional, military-level sabotage and guerrilla warfare, in a war with Iran life in the US will definitely not be business as usual, and not only because inflation will be something 200%, and thousands of dead soldiers will return home in coffins every month for a long time.
-
The US cannot win a war against Iran. And I believe all parties involved know it. The only thing that remains unknown is how insane and self-destructive the US has become under Netanyahu's and AIPAC's, how shall we call it, influence -
Adam Tooze reposted
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
ones and tooze about economic background of tiananmen is excellent
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
The US is often described as a petrostate these days, for obvious reasons. China is often called an electrostate, also for obvious reasons. But the contrast isn't quite so neat: 90%+ of new US energy infra is green and not much gov't rev comes from oil... open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-439-electrost…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chinese government bonds emerge as lone war haven. More on this in today's version of the Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chinese-safe-haven-bonds-dc-delu…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tiberius
@tiberiusfiles
This is 10x older than the United States
Art Gallery
@X_ArtGallery
Holding Hands
Persepolis (Iran), c. 500 BC -
Adam Tooze reposted
Chris Martenson
@chrismartenson
There's a lot of confusion out there, including with Trump, that the US has lots of oil to sell to the world.
We do not. We're a net importer of crude (~+3 Mb/d). The EIA reports that fact in great detail every week.
The confusion stems from using the term "petroleum exports" which includes the bodacious amounts of natural gas liquids (NGL) that come from our wet gas plays. That stuff isn't "oil" and it is exported because it's wildly overproduced compared to our needs.
Yes, the US is a net exporter of "petroleum," but it's also a net IMPORTER of crude oil. In other words, the US has none to sell.
There's more complexity to why we export 3M b/d of crude (it's the wrong kind for our refineries) and also import 6.4 M b/d of crude (which is the right kind).
John Ʌ Konrad V
@johnkonrad
BREAKING: US Navy will not open the Strait of Hormuz
Trump gives nations who import oil from the Middle East three options:
1) Buy your oil from US and Venezuela instead
2) Secure the Strait themselves with limited US support
Or
3) Wait for Hormuz to reopen naturally -
Adam Tooze reposted
Aaron Bastani
@AaronBastani
Israel, even with the US, can’t knock out Iran. So now they are killing university students in their dormitories.
Utterly evil, but conveys how desperate Tel Aviv is becoming.
Babak Taghvaee - The Crisis Watch
@BabakTaghvaee1
BREAKING: This is another war crime committed by the Israeli Air Force. They are now targeting university dormitories in Iran in an attempt to kill students.
At 16:00 today, a strike was reported in Tehran’s Velenjak area, possibly targeting the women’s dormitory of Shahid Beheshti University. Reports indicate the location is inside a residential and academic area, raising serious concerns about deliberate targeting of civilian infrastructure.
#operationepicfury #operationlionsroar -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kenneth Roth
@KenRoth
The US military reportedly committed a "double tap" strike in Iran. The "two strikes had hit the bridge around an hour apart, the second arriving while emergency responders were assisting the wounded," even though rescue workers are protected civilians. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/02/world/middleeast/trump-iran-br…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Last 18 months have not been good for US industries. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/chinese-safe-haven-bonds-dc-delu…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ramy Abdu| رامي عبده
@RamAbdu
🚨Three Flemish universities jointly award an honorary doctorate—for the first time—to Italian jurist @FranceskAlbs , recognizing her work on human rights and international justice.
The ceremony in Antwerp drew over 1,000 attendees. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Seriye Sezen
@SeriyeSezen
New article !
It "has examined how the Turkish War of Independence and the… Kemalist reforms were perceived, narrated, and debated in the Chinese press during the Republican era, with particular attention to the 1930s."+ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
In the past 30 days, Idris Robinson, a philosopher at Texas State University, Shirin Saeidi, a political scientist at the University of Arkansas, and Aris Fani, a scholar of Persian Studies at the University of Washington, have all been fired for speaking about the wars.
Laila Al-Arian
@LailaAlarian
The University of Washington appears to have removed a professor, Aria Fani, from his position as director of the Middle East Center because he criticized Israel and stated that the claim that Iran was pursuing a nuclear weapon was untrue.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
I like the idea of the US as a novel form of "closed petrostate", since it doesn't qualify as a petrostate in the traditional sense--the non-oil, non-gas economy is too developed.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Electrostates v. petrostates. Clarifying a tricky distinction. Chartbook 439 just dropped.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-439-electrostates-v-pe… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Electrostates v. petrostates. Clarifying a tricky distinction. Chartbook 439 just dropped.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-439-electrostates-v-pe… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
AI-enabling goods were big drivers of US imports in 2025. More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Vali Nasr
@vali_nasr
The Pasteur Institute has been an icon of Iran’s health care system, a symbol of modern Iran, established a century ago along with foundational health and education institutions. Destroying it could have no other purpose than assaulting Iran’s history, erasing the history of its modernization and development—take Iranians back to the Stone Age.
Al Jazeera Breaking News
@AJENews
US‑Israeli strikes have hit the century‑old Pasteur Institute in Tehran, causing extensive damage, according to Iran’s Health Ministry.
🔴LIVE updates: www.aljazeera.com/news/liveblog/2026/4/2/iran-war-live-tr… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Petrodollar (or lack of them) update:
Saudi 2025 balance of payments data is out, and the Saudi "current account" break even oil price (based on ~ 7 mbd in exports of crude/ product) is still right around $100 a barrel
1/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
John Bistline
@JEBistline
This is my favorite climate change chart. Japanese monks, aristocrats, and emperors kept meticulous records of cherry blossom festivals for 1,200 years and accidentally built the world's longest climate dataset.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Bert Hofman(郝福满)
@berthofmanecon
Fascinating research on the geolocation of science 1980-2022 by Abhishek Nagaraj and Randol Yao China’s rising share in top research, and U.S. relative decline are key findings, but EU persistence, the rise of India and re-appearance of Russia are among the other findings.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Gita Gopinath
@GitaGopinath
It is striking how much direct trade between the US and China has fallen off over the last decade. China's share in US imports at 9% is back down to what it was right before China joined the WTO (2001).
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Nigeria is a country of truly extreme regional inequality. The ratio between per capita income in Lagos State and Kano is ten to one, however your measure it. More on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/california-running-on-batteries-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Evan A. Feigenbaum
@EvanFeigenbaum
This isn't even the half of it. Now do the hard policy tradeoffs and fiscal constraints that will ensue, especially for Asian economies.
Just take Indonesia, where Prabowo has had a lot riding on the fuel subsidy, a free nutritious meals program, and so on. And let's imagine a world of budget constraints where leaders like him may have to start curtailing signature programs that, in turn, undermine welfare gains, or else blow through fiscal constraints and run fresh budget deficits. In Indonesia's case, for example, that isn't even permitted since there is statutory requirement to hold the deficit to 3% of GDP.
We've got reports this morning of three Korean airlines in emergency management. And so much more around the region ...
Meanwhile, there seems to be a parallel debate in Washington, where there is so much self-satisfied talk in Washington about "back footing China" by "picking of its allies like Iran." But isn't it fantastical to think that a double whammy of a year of (1) American trade policy and tariffs that have undermined many of the prevailing developmental assumptions in Asia and (2) American Middle East policy that both wrecks Asian energy security and forces these kinds of fiscal and programmatic choices will have zero effect on U.S. posture in the region?
Whose debate are we having here in DC?
I used to write a column for India's financial newspaper @bsindia called "DC Diary." Am thinking of starting a new column called "DC Delusions," in which other people's realities are extrapolated away while Washington projects its strategic debating about "competing with China" onto everyone and everything.
Bottom line: think there are some tough choices ahead for Asian governments.
Neil McCoy-Ward
@NeilMcCoyWard
It’s only week five this is the global picture as of today.
🇧🇩 Bangladesh - Fuel rationing active. Universities closed. Military deployed in oil depots.
🇱🇰 Sri Lanka - Fuel rationing active. 15 litre per week cap for private motorists. Four day school week. Scaled back public sector operations.
🇸🇮 Slovenia - 50 litre per day cap on fuel for private drivers. 200 litres for businesses and farmers. Indefinite.
🇵🇭 Philippines - National energy emergency declared. Four day working week in place.
🇵🇰 Pakistan - Four day work weeks and school closures still in effect.
🇲🇲 Myanmar - Alternating driving days imposed.
🇹🇭 Thailand - Diesel price cap imposed. Government officials told to work from home and limit travel. Fuel exports banned except to Cambodia and Laos.
🇻🇳 Vietnam - Tapping fuel price stabilisation fund. Officials encouraged to work from home and limit travel.
🇰🇪 Kenya - Rationing by major fuel suppliers ongoing. Rural areas already running out.
🇪🇬 Egypt - Fuel and electricity rationing active. Malls, restaurants and retailers shutting at 9pm. Illuminated billboards switched off. Government buildings closing at 6pm.
🇮🇳 India - Government phasing out LPG cylinders for households with access to piped gas to prioritise supply.
🇨🇳 China - Export ban on diesel, gasoline and aviation fuel until at least end of March.
🇰🇷 South Korea - Fuel price cap imposed. First in 30 years. Voluntary fuel conservation measures in place.
🇯🇵 Japan - Refiners requesting government release of stockpiled oil. 95% of crude imported from Gulf states.
🇪🇸 Spain - €5 billion emergency package. Tax reductions on electricity and gas. Subsidies for transport operators and farmers.
🇩🇪 Germany - BASF raising prices on goods by up to 30%.
What could be coming
🇬🇧 UK - Ministers could activate contingency powers to introduce fuel rationing at petrol stations. 80% of UK goods travel by road. IEA has advised considering carpooling and working from home to save fuel.
🇪🇺 EU - Emergency measures under discussion. Storage across many member states below 30%.
Shell's CEO warned Europe could face fuel rationing starting in April if the Strait stays closed.
G7 finance ministers, energy ministers and central bank governors met in Paris today and issued a joint statement saying they stand ready to take "all necessary measures" to preserve stability in energy markets.
None of these restrictions have been easing. In several countries they are only getting worse. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
I love how Vance has combined right-wing nativism with the drippy, superficially introspective memoir style that is a signature of NPR liberalism.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Lindsey Hilsum
@lindseyhilsum
These are the people who are always forgotten: the seafarers from India, the Philippines and other countries who we rely on to take goods around the world, but are underpaid and frequently abandoned at sea.
Shanaka Anslem Perera ⚡
@shanaka86
JUST IN: Three thousand ships are anchored in and around the Strait of Hormuz. Twenty thousand seafarers are aboard them. Fresh food ran out two weeks ago. Perishables are rotting in refrigerated holds whose generators are burning through the last reserves of diesel. Water is rationed. Mental health is deteriorating. No mass evacuation plan exists. No humanitarian corridor has been negotiated. No international body has the authority or the means to move twenty thousand people off three thousand ships through a five-nautical-mile channel controlled by the IRGC.
These are the people who move the global economy. Every barrel of oil that reaches a refinery was carried by a seafarer. Every container of goods that stocks a shelf was loaded by one. Every tonne of fertiliser that feeds a field was shipped by one. The war has trapped the invisible workforce that makes globalisation function, and the world has not noticed because the world never notices seafarers until the shelves are empty.
The ships themselves are worth tens of billions. The cargo aboard them is worth more. Crude oil, liquefied natural gas, urea, ammonia, consumer electronics, automotive parts, and 200 cryogenic containers of helium that are boiling off at a rate that no engineer can reverse. The stranded fleet is a floating warehouse of every molecule the global economy needs, and the molecules are degrading while the crews ration drinking water. The cargo is valued higher than the people guarding it, and neither can move.
The IRGC’s Larak corridor clearance system does not only control entry. It controls exit. A vessel that wants to leave the anchorage zone must obtain the same clearance code, submit the same documentation, and receive the same pilot escort as a vessel seeking to transit. The customs border works in both directions. These crews are not stranded by geography alone. They are stranded by bureaucracy, the same bureaucracy Iran wrapped in the language of sovereign maritime governance when the parliamentary committee approved the Hormuz Management Plan. The toll booth charges for passage through. It also charges for passage out.
No centralised evacuation exists because evacuation at this scale would require IRGC approval, and requesting approval would legitimise the system the United States refuses to recognise. So the crews wait. The International Transport Workers Federation issues statements. P&I clubs cover individual medical evacuations by helicopter. Flag states, predominantly Panama, Liberia, and the Marshall Islands, register ships but do not operate navies. The system that made global shipping cheap by divorcing flag from nationality has left twenty thousand people without a government willing to retrieve them.
The seafarers are from the Philippines, India, Bangladesh, Myanmar, Indonesia. Countries whose workers crew the world’s merchant fleet because the monthly pay of $1,500 to $3,000 exceeds anything available at home. They signed contracts to deliver cargo across oceans. They did not sign contracts to become indefinite residents of a war zone, rationing water on a ship whose cargo of ammonia could feed a million people if it could reach a port that is 40 nautical miles and one IRGC clearance code away.
The helium boils off. The fertiliser waits. The crude oil sits. And the people who carry it all drink less water today than yesterday.
The supply chain has a human body at the very bottom of it. The body is thirsty.
open.substack.com/pub/shanakaanslemperera/p/the-last-mole… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Though fertilizer prices are soaring, so far food prices are not. Good news from Alan Beattie in the Financial Times. Featured on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/california-running-on-batteries-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This cycle’s cause was not cyclical - Citrini’s radical scenario for AI, featutred in today's version of the Chartboo Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/ai-doom-loop-the-travails-of-the
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Economist on AIPAC’s shifting strategies. More in this in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/ai-doom-loop-the-travails-of-the
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Richard Seymour
@leninology
“This is, in some ways, a twenty-first century rejig of the classic Trotskyist reading of the far right’s popularity.”
Correct.
A. J. A. Woods
@adubwoods
My review of Richard Seymour's 'Disaster Nationalism' for @MarxPhilosophy
marxandphilosophy.org.uk/reviews/22617_disaster-nationali… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hi @Brad_Setser I'd be a fool to argue with you about bofp issues. But what did I say? Are Chinese imports large? Yup. (Could they be larger? Sure but that is a different point). Are Chinese imports stable? Yup. (Might they be growing? Sure. But that is a different argument). So they are large and stable and thus stabilizing. No more. No less.
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
I am a big fan of Chartbook and the collected works of Tooze -- but there is no way to look at China over the last 6 years and conclude that it has been a source of demand for the global economy
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Its not even that @AngelicaOung I'm putting myself in the position of a think tanker in Beijing and asking how easy would it be to write a five point plan for global leadership? The answer is very easy. That tells us something.
Angelica 🌐⚛️🇹🇼🇨🇳🇺🇸
@AngelicaOung
What’s wrong Steve? He’s bullish in China and decide to give some advice on how China can help make the world a little better in this chaotic moment that’s well meaning. Why does that mean he is disloyal or biased?
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Mexico’s dualistic labour market is weighted towards informality. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/ai-doom-loop-the-travails-of-the
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Trump coin and lessons from the Ostrogoths by Brendan Greeley is insightful from the Financial Times. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Bruno Maçães
@MacaesBruno
For us living in 2026 there are contemporary images that make a destroyed Berlin pale
Epic Maps 🗺️
@theepicmap
Berlin at the end of WW2
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Yohan
@yohaniddawela
We track poverty too slowly to respond effectively.
But a new open-source tool now lets us map wealth in near real-time using satellite imagery.
Here’s what you need to know: -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Great graph on changes in Chinese energy generation, show the sudden emergence of renewables since 2020. More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jonathan Derbyshire
@Jderbyshire
A blueprint for Chinese global leadership -- @adam_tooze's latest column for @ftopinion www.ft.com/content/cf2eeead-461d-4e3b-aeb7-48b30114643c
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
ICE is buying up warehouses … for people. Great article in the Wall Street Journal featured on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/fertilizer-plants-out-warehousin…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hard to think of a more important map than this right now, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/fertilizer-plants-out-warehousin…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Will Hutton
@williamnhutton
Ed Miliband gets relentless bile from the right for his ‘ideological’ commitment to clean, cheap renewable energy - just as Nye Bevan once did for creating the NHS. Yet on March 25 97.7 % of our electricity was from renewables. A revolution is unfolding. observer.co.uk/news/columnists/article/an-energy-revoluti…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nikhil Pal Singh
@nikhil_palsingh
So good,
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
@kmac and I argue: The reaction illustrates a market consensus that over-indexes on the power of finance and US military power, and under-indexes on Iran’s resolve and asymmetric chokepoint power, and the physical vulnerability of production and logistics.
www.phenomenalworld.org/analysis/war-on-iran/ -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Higher average per capita incomes in the US are down to the divergence of the top 10 percent of the income distribution from the rest of the US and the rest of the world. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/trump-as-the-duke-of-york-the-op…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nikhil Pal Singh
@nikhil_palsingh
What Israel is doing is unconscionable and possibly the most dangerous military adventurism we have seen in our lifetimes
Al Jazeera Breaking News
@AJENews
BREAKING: Rosatom says situation at Iran's Bushehr nuclear power plant continues to deterioriate after multiple Israeli attacks.
🔴 LIVE updates: www.aljazeera.com/news/liveblog/2026/3/28/iran-war-live-t… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Lowkey
@Lowkey0nline
Israel has just killed Lebanese journalist Fatima Ftouni. I am honoured to have known her.
Just at the beginning of the month she reported on Israel killing seven members of her own family live on air.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Martin Asser
@martasser
Never forgot that day Fatima Ftouni held up her mic after an Israeli air strike in 2024 and called it the weapon she and colleagues were targeted for. Israel murdered her today.
Rita El Jammal
@rita_jammal
مراسلة الميادين فاطمة فتوني: هذا ما تبقّى من درعي وخوذتي وميكروفوني...
-
Adam Tooze reposted
sarah
@sahouraxo
Israel murdered every single person in this photo today in South Lebanon.
Every. Single. One.
2 journalists
7 paramedics
1 Lebanese soldier
They bombed the journalists’ vehicle — then bombed them again when paramedics rushed to help. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Trump as the grand old Duke of York, who marches oil up the hill and then marches it down again. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/trump-as-the-duke-of-york-the-op…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Xavier Delcourt
@x_delcourt
Superbe👇👇👇
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"The continuation of critical theory by narrative means" - Alexander Kluge and the anti-realism of feelings.
Latest Chartbook just dropped. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-438-the-continuation-of -
Adam Tooze reposted
Rockport
@RockportAI
Adorno's last student just died. And the question he spent 60 years answering — how do you keep critical theory alive when the academy kills it — has never mattered more. Audio breakdown: 🙏 @adam_tooze
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
katy
@gewittrderrosen
The only person I know of who has ever dared to read the Angel of History another way
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"The continuation of critical theory by narrative means" - Alexander Kluge and the anti-realism of feelings.
Latest Chartbook just dropped. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-438-the-continuation-of -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"The continuation of critical theory by narrative means" - Alexander Kluge and the anti-realism of feelings.
Latest Chartbook just dropped. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-438-the-continuation-of -
Adam Tooze reposted
Mauro Gilli
@Mauro_Gilli
This image from the @FT shows how the war in Iran could have dramatic effects on global food security.
Without natural gas, ammonia and urea—key nitrogen fertilizers—cannot be produced.
Without them, crop yields collapse. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
Incredible work from Susannah and the FT team.
Keep an eye on the Horn of Africa: "In Somalia, prices of basic foods have risen by around a fifth since the conflict began, according to the UN’s World Food Programme"!
Susannah Savage
@SavageSusannah
Everyone’s watching oil.
They should be watching food and fertiliser.
New Big Read on the hidden risk to global food.@FT
W/ @janatausch @evawxiao @AndresSchipani @redwanxyz @jyots43 as.ft.com/r/0b436888-a118-4134-abee-5117d3d635ff -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Cuba is being worn down by the relentless US blockade, shown by this chart on the Economist. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Mortgage interest rates are hitting 7 percent and sellers are locked into COVID era mortgages that are in negative real interest rate territory. More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Wortel-London
@dlondonwortel
The Cooper Union, to their eternal glory, has uploaded hundreds of recordings and transcripts from speakers who have graced their Great Hall.
We are talking Michael Harrington, Frances Fox Piven, Jane Addams, Henry George, Kropotkin, and more.
Dive in!
greathallvoices.cooper.edu -
Adam Tooze reposted
Branko Milanovic
@BrankoMilan
A three-step typical approach to China.
Step 1. Say the official numbers are bogus.
Well, the problem is: one cannot deny that China is leading the world in a number of new technologies. it is among the greatest importers of luxury goods, its infrastructure has taken leaps & bounds in the past 20 years. So the numbers cannot be *that* wrong. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Violence in the DRC is flaring up again, months after a peace deal was signed. More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-costs-of-the-iran-war-vw-to-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
oh nooooooo!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Oh noooooo! Alexander Kluge RIP.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
oh NOOOOOOO!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
90% of Indian LPG imports (itself making up 60% of Indian LPG consumption) come through the Strait of Hormuz. India might not only be facing a price shock soon, but a real insufficiency in supply! Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-costs-of-the-iran-war-vw-to-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
Amazing how so many ppl are down on green tech coz they live in the US & narrative is clean tech is gay & energy dominance blah
All the serious money -Jeffries in this case -telling their clients to double down on cleantech
skywriter.blue/@70sbachchan.bsky.social/3mh4k52ybvs2t -
Adam Tooze reposted
Neil Thomas 牛犇
@neilthomas123
Love the print title of the @nytimes guest essay that I wrote with Jing Qian
It's a radically simple summary of a simple argument that is surprisingly radical
Thanks to Dan Martin for the superb edit! -
Adam Tooze reposted
Stefan Eich
@stefeich
Loving those moments when our forlorn messages in a bottle serendipitously reach an unexpected shore
lavitalenta
@lavitalenta
Nothing short of miraculous that here is a book on two topics I’m newly interested in that has them synthesized beautifully. It’s astounding
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Aramco, the largest oil company in the world, earned $93 bn last year. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links.
Source: How They Make Money
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/where-china-gets-its-oil-how-aramco
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Where China gets is oil from. This and more in the today's Chartbook Top Links.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/where-china-gets-its-oil-how-aramco
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Which countries are most dependent on fertilizer through the Straits of Hormuz. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/where-china-gets-its-oil-how-aramco
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Gerardo L. Munck
@GerardoMunck
Poggi on the State
These books by Gianfranco Poggi offer nuanced discussion of central issues in the study of politics and society: the state and power. They offer a reminder of the important things that need to be studied. -
Adam Tooze reposted
lavitalenta
@lavitalenta
Nothing short of miraculous that here is a book on two topics I’m newly interested in that has them synthesized beautifully. It’s astounding
-
Adam Tooze reposted
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
With respect, but marginal pricing in high-renewables systems not only undermines political support for renewables because it fails to deliver average costs to households but also creates greater volatility which does undermine incentives to invest in end-use equipment like EV, heat pumps etc. (Why invest in a heat pump if the price of electricity is still gonna be the price of gas?) Pretty much how it’s shaken out in much of Europe.
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
if you think too much about electricity markets you'll go mad BUT, generally, marginal pricing can be very very friendly to renewables
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
Having just seen long lines for cooking gas cylinders on the streets of cities in India — one of many bystanders to the conflict whose population has been seriously impacted—I’m struck yet again by how relatively insulated the U.S. is from the wars it unleashes
Jesse Watters
@JesseBWatters
Spring Break goes WILD☀️ 🍺🤪
and the students have NO IDEA what’s going on🤣
“The BIGGEST issue in America is what BIKINI I’m wearing tomorrow”👙
“We’re going to war with IRAQ that’s been crazy”🤔
“I’ve NEVER heard the word Ayatollah in my life”🫢
“Is Venezuela in SPAIN?”😬😬😬This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Jason Bordoff
@JasonBordoff
The best compliment I got today about being on Ezra was from my daughter. I guess the bar was low. 😂
"I kept forgetting you were my dad because it was just really interesting"
Jason Bordoff
@JasonBordoff
Huge thanks to @ezraklein for having me on to talk about today's energy crisis, where we are headed, and what the longer term implications are likely to be for energy security, geopolitics, and the energy transition. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/how-bad-could-the-iran-oil-…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
Which country gets the highest share of its fertilizer through the Strait of Hormuz?
Sudan, the world's hungriest country, which faced famine before this crisis. -
Adam Tooze reposted
npj
@TiltingatM3
People gotta stop saying stuff like this, since 1) sterling was not as dominant then as the dollar is today 2) imperialism in India did the balancing, more and more as time went on bc UK did have deficits w RoW 3) gold & silver were the reserves, very different from fiat dollar
2 media couldn't be displayed. See them on the original post.
Hutontiber
@hutontiber
Britain was the world's reserved currency for 100 years without running current account deficits, quite a generous surpluses actually 3/..
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The White House Is Using the Wrong Oil Price for the Iran War. More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In December 2023 the ECB considered a “Scenario analysis of a potential further escalation of the conflict in the Middle East”, more at today's Chartbook Top Links!
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-geography-of-world-trade-dem…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Nice map in the WSJ of the Critical Energy Assets hit in the Gulf, featured on today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-geography-of-world-trade-dem…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Bert Hofman(郝福满)
@berthofmanecon
Since some of you asked, here is the list of the Chinese scholars participating in the China Development Forum
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Nicholas Mulder
@njtmulder
In the 20th century fuel hydrogenation was the ultimate resort of countries with coal deposits that developed blockade-phobia. Not just Germany and South Africa but imperial Japan (some of which ended up in North Korea), Franco’s Spain, Fascist Italy and even the USSR.
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
coal to liquids is so fascinating: you need to be rich enough to make the huge upfront investment in industrial capacity *and* be seriously worried about getting cut off from oil, which leaves you nazi germany, apartheid south africa, and china
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Sam Haselby
@samhaselby
The war on Iran is a massive, systemic failure of the US political system. No one but the military contracts and Israel fanatics wants it. It's terrible for Americans, for the whole world. Where is the opposition party? Where are the checks and balances? Where is democracy?
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The basic geography of world trade is centered around three poles #1 EU, #2 China, #3 US. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/the-geography-of-world-trade-dem…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Greg Ip
@greg_ip
Very big deal. @HyunSongShin is a legit rock star of financial and monetary economics. Reminiscent of Raghuram Rajan being named to run the Reserve Bank of India or Stan Fischer to run the Bank of Israel.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Alex
@notcomplex_
The average adult height in China and the US is now roughly equal.
Many have not fully realized just how much China has grown—in this case, literally. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Bloomberg
@business
South Korea’s President Lee Jae Myung has nominated Shin Hyun Song, head of the monetary and economic department at the Bank for International Settlements, as the new Bank of Korea governor, the Presidential Office said Sunday www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-03-22/skorea-s-lee-n…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
This week’s podcast drops Thursday and is all about this piece, with the author @Changxche!
The New Yorker
@NewYorker
The Chinese Communist Party has embraced the study of Greek and Latin—as, in some ways, an antidote to the modern West. newyorkermag.visitlink.me/yl-IXJ
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Petrodollars! Nothing produces more heated discussion and, in my experience, less insight. Myths trump facts, because the actual data is a bit obscure --
But here is the most important thing to know. Before the Hormuz crisis, the flow of petrodollars had more or less dried up
1/many -
Adam Tooze reposted
Evan A. Feigenbaum
@EvanFeigenbaum
In 2011, fifteen years ago, I wrote an essay for @TWQgw on the reemergence of an interconnected "historical Asia" instead of the fragmented "Cold War Asia" anomaly to which Americans had grown accustomed. A fantastic essay in Swarajya on the Chettiar financial empire, which stretched into Southeast Asia, and deployed private capital from Malaya to Vietnam, got me reflecting on it again. For a thousand years, as I argued in my 2011 essay, an astonishingly interconnected Asia was pretty much the natural order of things. "Asia is being reborn," I argued, "and remade." Yet, the United States, I warned, "is badly prepared for this momentous rebirth, which is at once stitching Asia back together and making the United States less relevant in each of Asia’s constituent parts. Asians are, in various ways, passing the United States by, restoring ancient ties, and repairing long-broken strategic and economic links." This great piece gets at one element of the historical connection and the role of clans and communities, not just monarchs and empires, in this. In fact, it was empires, including the British and Russian empires, that contributed to the anomaly—when Tsarist armies arrived in Central Asia and the Soviet Union subsequently severed many traditional connections, and many of India’s traditional roles in Asia were subsumed within the British empire. It's been 15 years since I wrote this essay and U.S. policy still thinks in terms of Cold War referents rather than historical ones. If you want to see how quickly traditional patterns have reasserted themselves, just look at China's outsized role in Central Asia, compared to where it was even when I wrote this piece in 2011—which, by the way, was fully two years before Beijing tried to formalize some of this with its Belt and Road Initiative but the patterns were already patently obvious to anyone bothering to pay attention even before the BRI existed. But because U.S. policy now refracts the entire continent and all of its subregions through the prism of competition with China—a bipolar construct that doesn't capture historical patterns and evolving realities—it is missing a lot about the contours of what will certainly be a more integrated Asia if you pull this thread into the 2030s and beyond. America will miss opportunities in every part of the region over time, and find the United States less relevant to Asia’s future. I've been warning about this for a long time. Anyway, I loved this discussion of "the Chettiar way of wealth" from @SwarajyaMag, highlighting some of India's traditional roles to the east, and here's my 2011 essay in @TWQgw: www.csis.org/analysis/twq-why-america-no-longer-gets-asia…
Swarajya
@SwarajyaMag
Before modern multinational banks reached Southeast Asia, merchants from 75 villages in Tamil Nadu had already built a transnational financial system.
They financed rice in Burma, rubber in Malaya, retail in Singapore, plantations in Ceylon — connected not by contracts but by kinship and reputation.
This is the story of the Chettiars.🧵 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Trump’s wall is making a billionaire family. More on this in the Chartbook Top Link today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/texas-energy-is-changing-200bn-for
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The $200bn capital boost to US banks. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links of today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/texas-energy-is-changing-200bn-for
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Joe Kerr
@societylivr1984
There's an old saying in Schelling—I know it's in Hegel, probably in Schelling—that all great world-historic facts and personages appear, so to speak, twice. He forgot to add: the first time as... as... tragedy... the second time as... as... it's funny if it happens again
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jason Bordoff
@JasonBordoff
Indeed. Exactly as Erica Downs and I wrote @ForeignPolicy just after the conflict started foreignpolicy.com/2026/03/06/iran-china-green-energy-oil-…
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
CHINA ALREADY GOT ITS FIRST WIN FROM THE WAR IN IRAN
In today's newsletter, I wrote about how the long term trend of countries reducing their oil imports by substituting them with Chinese tech is already accelerating since the start of the war
www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2026-03-20/china-has-a… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Bert Hofman(郝福满)
@berthofmanecon
Two of the best public intellectuals on Twitter are debating China on Substack this week. @Scholars_Stage open.substack.com/pub/scholarstage/p/china-and-the-future…
And @Noahpinion open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/china-is-quietly-looki… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Almut Rochowanski
@rochowanski
The FT's longtime Tehran correspondent Najmeh Bozorgmehr has written an anti-war manifesto that is simultaneously intimate and epic, heart-breaking and hopeful. A reminder how war is an assault on humanity itself.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jan Rosenow
@janrosenow
BREAKING: The blackout in Spain and Portugal in April 2025 did NOT happen because of renewables.
The final ENTSO-E report on last year's Iberian blackout is out — and it's essential reading for anyone working on the energy transition.
www.entsoe.eu/news/2026/03/20/entso-e-publishes-expert-pa… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Whereas the Iran war shock has barely budged inflation expectations and no more than mildly jolted expectations of monetary policy in the US, the same shock has completely transformed the outlook for many other central banks. More charts, graphs, and links featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Bichler and Nizan’s latest: How the relative earnings of the core oil companies vary with the oil price. Featured in today's Chartbook Top Links:
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Great graphic of the spread of the Asian financial crisis from Bangkok in July 1997 to the rest of South East and East Asia … and Russia. Featured in today's Chartbook Top Links:
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One of the reasons why you might think that carbon pricing could work: higher prices help lower the oil intensity of global output. Chartbook Top Links of the day just dropped:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/petro-core-china-is-not-done-wit…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
In 1507-15, the Portuguese crown built the fort of Our Lady of the Conception in Hormuz, to control trade from India and charge hefty tolls to passing ships. From the outset, holding the fort and controlling the Strait of Hormuz required constant fighting with local emirs; by 1662 the Shah of Persia (backed by British forces) took it for good. After a detailed account of the back-and-forth in a fierce and bloody seven‑month naval battle in 1521–22 in the Strait of Hormuz, Commander Saturnino Monteiro, in the first volume of his treatise "Batalhas e Combates da Marinha Portuguesa,” concluded: "...and thus ended this stupid and useless war of Hormuz, with everything remaining as it had been before."
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Apple Now Makes About 25% of iPhones in India After China Pivot. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/one-day-chicken-one-day-feathers
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
‘One day chicken, one day feathers’: why US shale producers are not cheering $100 oil. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/one-day-chicken-one-day-feathers
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
$50 billion or $200 billion, the message is still the same:
A vote to fund the war is a vote for the war.
Jeff Stein
@jstein_sun
SCOOP: The Pentagon asked the White House today for more than *$200 billion* for the Iran war supplemental, sources say
Some White House aides think Congress won't support b/c it's so big
Will tee up giant battle in Congress -
Adam Tooze reposted
Haytham Kaafarani
@hayfarani
I am a US citizen & Surgeon who took care of the Boston Maraton Bombing victims in 2013. I paid for 7 years to own a small apartment in downtown #beirut for my 3 kids to enjoy summers there. Today, #israel reduced my dream home to rubble, with american weapons, paid by my taxes.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
New Left EViews
@NewLeftEViews
Again this the famously sober and non-sensationalist energy market guy.
Rory Johnston
@Rory_Johnston
I think that a big part of the reason that people still think Trump will be in for the Iran War long haul is that they don’t appreciate how truly, insanely unhinged the energy market is about to get if this doesn’t end soon.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
According to TSLombard, Trump’s numbers are horrible on just about everything, but on the economy it is looking really bad. More charts and graphs featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
it is true that 2026 is seeing the most sudden shock to oil and gas supply. But both 1973 and 1979 had a very significant effect on long-run output as well. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Evan A. Feigenbaum
@EvanFeigenbaum
I'm afraid China's economic presence in Central Asia went way beyond oil, gas, and mining some time ago. If folks still think it's all just about extractive industries, they've missed quite a bit about the Chinese presence.
The Diplomat
@Diplomat_APAC
Today, we’re exploring the influx of investment in Central Asia’s resource sector, and whether both sides can actually achieve what they want: for the US and others, untangling their reliance on China; for the Central Asian states, avoiding the infamous resource curse.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The scale of the violence in Haiti is horrifying. If I read these numbers correctly we are talking about thousands of killings per quarter. Chartbook Top Links has more:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/global-lng-chinas-gig-workers-ha…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Pakistan looks like the Asian energy importer that is most at risk because of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz. More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Emma Ashford
@EmmaMAshford
First defection.
Joe Kent
@joekent16jan19
After much reflection, I have decided to resign from my position as Director of the National Counterterrorism Center, effective today.
I cannot in good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran. Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.
It has been an honor serving under @POTUS and @DNIGabbard and leading the professionals at NCTC.
May God bless America. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Ramez Naam
@ramez
Indoor living area per person has roughly tripled in the US since 1950.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tim Shipman
@ShippersUnbound
Very sad to learn of the death of Len Deighton, who was one of the two greatest spy thriller writers of all time and in some regards was Le Carre’s superior.
Anyone who has not read Deighton should try Funeral in Berlin, Bomber or SSGB. Most of all they should seek out Berlin Game, the start of an epic 10 book Cold War series focused on Bernard Samson.
Deighton’s writing was sharp, satirical, gripping and often amusing. His office infighting in the intelligence services was delicious and his characters are beautifully drawn.
The Samson cycle starts with a meticulously plotted run of five books (Berlin Game, Mexico Set, London Match, Spy Hook and Spy Line) which all stand alone but tell one big story from the jaded but dedicated perspective Bernard a brilliant field operative. Len’s genius idea was to use the sixth, Spy Sinker, to retell the whole cycle from the perspective of everyone else, exposing what Bernard didn’t know and misunderstood.
There is then an origin story about Bernard’s dad during the war, Winter, and then a concluding trilogy of Faith, Hope and Charity, which is not as high quality but deals with the fallout from the events of books 1-5.
It’s an epic achievement and the greatest long series in spy fiction, accepting that the Smiley series is the greatest short series.
Do yourself a favour, give it a try -
Adam Tooze reposted
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
Most of the great modern anti-war thinkers believed that a peaceful society necessitated a kind of moral development of its people, as well as the easing of social divisions.
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
The Nation: “Trump’s war on Iran is very unpopular. As pollster G. Elliot Morris notes, it is the most unpopular a US war has ever been when it started…and with just 38 percent of Americans in favor.”: www.thenation.com/article/world/iran-war-trump-peace-acti…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Ben Judah
@b_judah
Mamdani is an expression of the fading of old diasporas. Hostile to traditional Jewish diaspora views on Israel. And hardly even aware the Irish diaspora — now older, much more assimilated and smaller as a share of New York — has views on Irish unification worth considering.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Kate Mackenzie and Tim Sahay at Phenomenal World posted this nice map of the global LNG market. It's featured in today's Chartbook Top Links:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/global-lng-chinas-gig-workers-ha…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Steven Levine
@Left_Hegelian
What makes Habermas a critical theorist, rather than a theorist who is critical, is that his theory contains a account of reason and its pathologies that is directly tied to a social theory. Without the connection to a theory of reason one is not doing 'critical theory'.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Helen Thompson POLIS
@HelenHet20
The persistent use of the term ‘clean power’ to free float between energy and electricity as if they are the same thing just obfuscates the real stakes. 2/2
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I agree. Best effort to rationalize the war that I have read as well.
Ben Smith
@semaforben
Most convincing argument I've read recently that the Pentagon knows what it's doing, from ... Al Jazeera www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2026/3/16/the-us-israeli-strat…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Tracy Alloway
@tracyalloway
I was in Hong Kong in Feb 2020 and remember this being a very weird time. Investors had been worrying about the US-China trade war under Trump 1.0. Then China effectively shut down most of its economy and markets basically shrugged.
Similar vibes right now
Jesse Livermore
@Jesse_Livermore
Best analogue I can think of for today's market vibe is the period in mid Feb 2020 bf Covid when the news flow was uniformly negative but people weren't selling bc they were bulled up on other themes and were scared of missing the uptrend that was set to resume once Covid faded.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
New from us: how Pakistan's solar boom is dampening the impact of the Hormuz crisis on the country. Solar power allowed LNG&diesel imports to fall after the previous gas crisis in 2021-22, with the solar boom set to avoid $7bn in fossil fuel import costs this year.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Isaac B. Kardon
@IBKardon
Xi Jinping's most recent speech on maritime power articulates many of the priorities that differentiate PRC efforts (concrete, steel, and sea-water industrial policy) from dysfunction in US maritime industrial strategy and policy: web.archive.org/web/20260315220548/https://www.qstheory.c…
John F Sullivan
@JohnF_Sullivan
Qiushi (March 15, 2026): "The 21st century is the century of the ocean; whoever wins the ocean wins the future. China is one of the earliest nations in the world to develop and utilize the ocean ... We must deeply implement Xi Jinping’s vision to build a maritime power."
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
After decades of infra-maxxing, many believe China's infrastructure boom is reaching the end.
Not so, says Yu Yongding: "The scope for further infrastructure investment in China remains very large." Reminds me of Lu Feng's industrial maximalism. www.eastisread.com/p/yu-yongding-there-is-no-consumption -
Adam Tooze reposted
Shanaka Anslem Perera ⚡
@shanaka86
On March 12, India formally asked China for emergency urea to keep its fertilizer plants running.
On March 16, China halted NPK fertilizer blend exports and extended its phosphate suspension through August.
Read that sequence again. The world’s most populous nation asked the world’s largest fertilizer producer for help. The response was a lockdown.
This is the second trap.
The first trap is Hormuz. One-third of global seaborne fertilizer trade physically blocked. Transit collapsed 97 percent. Gulf urea, ammonia, and sulfur stranded behind mines, drones, and an insurance market that has fractured beyond repair.
The second trap is China. Beijing looked at the Hormuz crisis, calculated that Gulf sulfur (over half of China’s imports) would not arrive, and made the rational decision to protect 1.4 billion of its own people first. Strategic sulfur reserves activated. Commercial nitrogen and phosphate stocks released early. NPK blends locked down for export. Phosphate banned through August. The 725 million tonne grain target in the 15th Five-Year Plan does not bend for India’s Kharif season.
Nobody should be surprised. This is exactly what China did in 2022 when the Ukraine shock hit. It is what China will always do. And it is what every government with the capacity to hoard will do when the molecules run short. The crisis does not produce global solidarity. It produces national triage. And in national triage, the countries with domestic production and strategic reserves survive. The countries that depend on imports from those countries do not.
India has 17.7 million tonnes of fertilizer stockpiled, up 36.5 percent year-over-year. That is a buffer, not a solution. Plants are running at 60 percent capacity. The subsidy bill has been revised to 1.86 lakh crore rupees, over 40 percent of the entire subsidy budget, with urea sold at 242 rupees per bag against international prices many times higher. If Skymet’s 60% probability of below-normal monsoon materializes during Kharif, India faces a food production challenge of a severity not seen since the crisis that prompted the Green Revolution.
Bangladesh has shut 4 to 5 of six urea factories. Boro rice season is underway with no domestic nitrogen. Pakistan’s debt service consumes 81 percent of tax revenue. Egypt feeds 69 million on bread subsidies at prices it never budgeted while owing $28 billion in external debt. Southeast Asia faces granular urea above $700 per tonne. Sri Lanka, the country that already proved what happens when fertilizer vanishes, faces 15 to 30 percent yield risk from the same import dependence that collapsed its rice output 40% in 2021.
Now map the sulfur cascade that almost nobody is tracking.
Roughly half of global seaborne sulfur trade is Gulf-sourced. Sulfuric acid is the chemical required to convert raw phosphate rock into plant-available fertilizer. Without Gulf sulfur, phosphate processing breaks globally. Morocco’s OCP, the world’s largest phosphate exporter, imports roughly 3.7 million tonnes of Gulf sulfur annually. China imports over 4 million tonnes. The sulfur shortage does not just constrain nitrogen supply. It simultaneously fractures the phosphate chain, creating the first simultaneous disruption of all three primary crop nutrients since the Haber-Bosch process was industrialized.
Two forces are now converging on the global food system from opposite directions. Iran blocks the molecules physically. China blocks them administratively. Neither is acting irrationally. Both are executing national survival logic. And the countries caught between them, the ones with no domestic production, no strategic reserves, and no fiscal capacity to compete on the spot market, absorb the full force of both.
318 mn people were at crisis-level hunger before either trap snapped shut.
The math does not require malice to produce catastrophe. It only requires geography, chemistry, and a planting calendar that waits for nobody.
open.substack.com/pub/shanakaanslemperera/p/the-nitrogen-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Congratulations to Helene Rey;
What a great fit between the economist and the role
Bank for International Settlements
@BIS_org
Hélène Rey, Professor of Economics at @LBS, is appointed as Economic Adviser and Head of the Monetary and Economic Department, replacing Hyun Song Shin, from 1 September 2026
www.bis.org/media-releases/20260316-helene-rey-appointed-… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Noah Gordon
@noah_gordon_
Reminiscent of the food export restrictions in the 2022 food crisis, including Indian rice, Indonesian palm oil, Argentine wheat, and Russian beef
Bloomberg
@business
The Chinese government has asked exporters to halt outbound shipments of nitrogen-potassium fertilizer blends www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-03-16/china-reins-in…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Hélène Rey
@helene_rey
Looking forward to this new chapter in a great organisation. What a daunting task to follow Hyun!
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Jeet Heer
@HeerJeet
I'm genuinely surprised by this. I've long thought Israel was, even from the point of view of empire, a strategic liability to the USA but never thought figures like Kristol and Kagan would come around to that.
Max Blumenthal
@MaxBlumenthal
The Iran war is so bad that PNAC co-founder Robert Kagan now describes Israel as a strategic liability leading the US into a quagmire
“It’s kind of like saying South Vietnam was a great ally in the fight against North Vietnam.”
Bill Kristol nods along -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Guess who is going to do well out of an oil price shock! But not all Oil Majors are benefiting in the same way. BP and EXXON are far more exposed to the Middle East than is Chevron. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/oil-profits-why-2026-is-not-2025
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Nice graphic illustrating the Biden-era shift in the US alliance system in Asia from hub and spokes to latticework. One thought was that it might be “Trump-proof”. This and more on the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/oil-profits-why-2026-is-not-2025
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Coal is still huge in China, but its role in the power system is shifting to that of a flexibility reserve. More on this in the Chartbook Top Link today.
Source: Ember
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/oil-profits-why-2026-is-not-2025
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Weber
@OliverBWeber
Heute im Blatt mit ein paar mehr Zeilen.
Oliver Weber
@OliverBWeber
In Zeilen fassen, was zu groß für ein paar Zeilen ist:
www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/buecher/autoren/juergen-ha… -
Adam Tooze reposted
camilo
@AscendedYield
New paper by India's former Chief Economic Adviser says the country's GDP has been overstated by roughly 22%.
A fifth of the economy doesn't exist.
camilo
@AscendedYield
India's 20 years of GDP misestimation: New evidence www.piie.com/publications/working-papers/2026/indias-20-y…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Oliver Weber
@OliverBWeber
In Zeilen fassen, was zu groß für ein paar Zeilen ist:
www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/buecher/autoren/juergen-ha… -
Adam Tooze reposted
Evan A. Feigenbaum
@EvanFeigenbaum
"Evan Feigenbaum, an Asia expert at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said that, after 10 years of US warnings about the need to constrain China, 'we’re now in a bizarro world where the president actually appears to be begging Beijing for an expeditionary naval deployment.' In the short term, he added, 'Hormuz is not China’s problem — it is Trump’s problem and they have no obvious incentive to paint an Iranian target on their back, figuratively or literally.'”
Financial Times
@FT
Trump throws US-China reboot off course by saying he could delay Xi summit ft.trib.al/lVFDxdj
-
Adam Tooze reposted
The Kobeissi Letter
@KobeissiLetter
This is not receiving enough attention:
Qatar is the world's 2nd-largest helium producer, supplying ~33% of global output, at 63 million cubic meters in 2025.
When Qatar's Ras Laffan facility, the world's largest LNG export plant, shut down due to the Iran war, helium supply was cut, as helium is extracted as a byproduct of natural gas processing.
As a result, the market is now losing ~5.2 million cubic meters of helium per month, with almost no spare capacity globally, as helium evaporates during storage and must reach end users within ~45 days.
The disruption has already DOUBLED helium prices since the Iran war began.
If disruptions last 60 to 90 days, prices could surge another +25% to +50%, potentially exceeding $2,000 per thousand cubic feet, over 4 times early 2026 levels.
The Iran war is disrupting far more than oil and gas. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
His personal views only, but probably not all that far off from how this is viewed by official Beijing.
Chairman Rabbit
@ChairmanRabbit
Quick comment on China-US relationship (and Beijing summit).
1. China-US relations are bilateral, pertaining to the ties between two major powers. Neither China nor the US wishes to see their bilateral relationship affected by the Iran issue. This holds true for both sides. (Claims in Western strategic circles and media that the US strike on Iran targets China are simply outlandish.)
2. Nevertheless, the fact remains: a summit between Chinese and US leaders requires "creating suitable conditions and eliminating unnecessary disruptions." The Iran war clearly falls outside suitable conditions and constitutes an unnecessary disruption. This is the Elephant in the Room, and as April approaches, it becomes increasingly evident.
3. The US/West believes China holds influence over Iran. Currently, Trump’s most pressing challenge is the Iran issue, the oil crisis, and all the ensuing economic and political repercussions. Until this is resolved, he is in no mood to meet with anyone - including European allies ("NATO"). For the time being, all other matters must serve and align with the Iran issue. This may not be his preference, but it is the reality he faces.
4. Consequently, external expectations for his potential visit to China have shifted. If he visits China and returns "empty-handed," still unable to resolve the Strait of Hormuz crisis, then the visit would effectively be considered a failure. This would imply that, at this juncture, China-US relations and the Iran issue are already intertwined, despite the fact that this is contrary to the true intentions of both countries. In short, the "favorable conditions" required for such a meeting are conspicuously absent.
5. On the matter of escort missions: this is America’s problem, not China’s. Iran has made it clear that it will only target adversary nations, namely the US and its allies. Chinese vessels can still navigate the strait - although with difficulty, it remains technically feasible. To put it really bluntly: the current reality is not Chinese warships escorting Chinese vessels, but rather the Iranians ensuring safe passage for China. So, how exactly is China supposed to assist the US? By having Chinese warships escort American vessels? They might as well invite Iranian warships to escort the U.S. fleet! This is clearly absurd, and cannot be a solution. The real solution lies in the US, Israel and Iran sitting down to negotiate, meeting each other’s conditions, and ending the war. (Of course, as of now, no foundation for such negotiations exists.)
6. The US openly tramples on international law, launching outrageous attacks against a sovereign state (which also happens to be China’s friendly partner), drawing increasing condemnation and resistance from the international community. Under such circumstances, why expect China to "roll out the red carpet" for Trump?
Personal views only. -
Adam Tooze reposted
💗
@ma1ybe
Since men are too busy with podcasts, someone has to do real jobs
Zoya🕊️
@Zoya_ki_batein
Recent data shows more women are skipping college to make six figures as electricians, car mechanics and truck drivers nypost.com/2024/08/13/lifestyle/women-skipping-college-ma…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Farrukh
@implausibleblog
Ed Miliband, "The price of gas is set on the international market, whether it comes from the north sea, or is imported"
"We're price taker and not a price maker"
"There is one lesson from this crisis, and only one lesson"
"We need homegrown clean power that we can control"
"We cannot keep being on this fossil fuel roller coaster"
Thank you for the clear explanation @Ed_Miliband - please do this every time the subject is raised and get the message across 👏This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Everyone is talking about energy and oil. Here is matching oil type, supplier and buyer as illustrated. More featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Xiao Wang
@xiaowang1984
It's actually kind of cool to see ERCOT hit 75% non synchronous gen penetration without any explicit goals towards it like Eirgrid or NESO or AEMO
TSSA
@txsolarstorage
Not only did solar generate its most MW in Texas history today (32,334 MW), it also powered nearly 2/3 of the grid for much of the afternoon. Great to see our members powering Texas.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
David French
@DavidAFrench
This is a remarkable development. Just extraordinary and unanticipated by almost everyone.
EMPR.media
@EuromaidanPR
Movement of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in February-March of this year in Zaporizhia.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Matthew Specter
@spectermatt
Habermas was extremely generous with me as a young doctoral student writing his dissertation on his political development in the Federal Republic. RIP.
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
We’re partnering with Art House NY to give out 5,000 free movie tickets at independent theaters around the city.
Our independent theaters are among the best in the world — building community through culture and strengthening the local economy.
More New Yorkers deserve to experience them.
Time Out New York
@TimeOutNewYork
Here's how to snag yours. www.timeout.com/newyork/news/nyc-is-giving-out-5-000-free…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Arvind Subramanian
@arvindsubraman
.@abhishekecon @FelmanJosh & me in @IndianExpress on 20 years of India's GDP mis-estimation (indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/how-gdp-data-mi…)
Full @PIIE research paper (www.piie.com/publications/working-papers/2026/indias-20-y…)
Main finding: real GDP growth over-estimated 1.5-2% b/w 2012-24; & under-estimated 1-1.5% b/w 2005-12
🧵 -
Adam Tooze reposted
Richard Seymour
@leninology
Mélenchon's answer on 'The Dig' podcast, on being smeared as 'antisemitic' as a way to delegitimise Muslims and Palestine solidarity:
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Karthik Sankaran
@RajaKorman
Might start doing this more often. A roundup of the week in visual gags.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"... in this case, actually closing a kill chain" ... CLOSING A KILL CHAIN!
Bilawal Sidhu
@bilawalsidhu
Probably the most current look at Palantir’s maven smart system software. Here’s the DoW’s Chief AI officer showing how it works:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
He was a hero. His global philosophical legacy was to accede to the end of history, in various ways, w/ consequences that critical theory hasn't recovered from, and which affected and reflected liberal political and constitutional thought to its detriment. apnews.com/article/juergen-habermas-dead-germany-2b541721…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Truly a privilege to be part of this conversation.
David Harvey
@profdavidharvey
Join us for the launch of The Story of Capital, published by @VersoBooks, at @PeoplesForumNYC (320 West 37th Street) on March 30th at 6:30 PM. The event will feature a discussion between myself and acclaimed historian @adam_tooze.
www.eventbrite.com/e/the-story-of-capital-book-launch-tic… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Our terrific MA in Global Thought program is accepting applications for fall 2026! This is truly a unique program. Applications close March 19.
Learn more here:
cgt.columbia.edu/academics/ma/admission/ -
Adam Tooze reposted
Alan Smithee
@AlanSmithee1987
Strolling about the city, passing people by, wondering whether they, too, have penned a Habermas obituary
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Markus Samuel Haselbeck
@CiaoCiaota
I started a new position working on a collection of mainly pre-modern Chinese books once owned by Jozef Mullie at KU Leuven Libraries, making these works available to scholars. Over the coming months, I'll be posting some of the fascinating texts and illustrations I come across.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Private credit is more wobbly than it may seem! More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Economist has looked into rising electricity prices, and has come to the conclusion: don’t blame the data centers! Today's Chartbook Top Links just dropped with more:
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Here's the link: adamtooze.substack.com/p/dont-blame-data-centers-a-new-ty…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Albert Pinto
@70sBachchan
ok this banger replaces Amartya sen and Jean Dreze classic summation on India's staggering inequality:
India is like "islands of California in seas of sub-saharan Africa"
Far more accurate after service-led genuine growth of last 30 years. archive.ph/08Ipb
Soutik Biswas
@soutikBBC
‘India is like three countries stacked in an economic ladder: 25m live in ‘Australia’-like affluence, ~200m in a ‘Philippines’-style service economy, while the rest struggle in conditions closer to sub-Saharan ‘Africa’. www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2026-03-13/india-can-t…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
This is an important book. Real accountability doesn’t exist in Washington, but hopefully this deeply reported account of how the Biden administration helped perpetrate the Gaza genocide will create reputational and professional costs for those responsible, to deter others.
Akbar Shahid Ahmed
@AkbarSAhmed
News from Iran & Lebanon increasingly resembles years of bloodshed in Gaza—civilian areas pummeled, international law ignored & a spiral of war endangering millions. Understanding why means understanding the US-Israel dynamic in one key period: under President Joe Biden, after October 7, 2023.
CROSSING THE RED LINE, the book I’ve been working on for more than 2 years, documents the Biden administration’s failures in Gaza & beyond. I conducted over 150 interviews to detail why the US enabled unimaginable violence against Palestinians and Lebanese, and ignored off-ramps toward peace – with Biden drawing a red line, yet still rushing weapons to Israel after Benjamin Netanyahu crossed it. He sent Israel a message of impunity and sent Americans a message of disdain and incompetence, helping Donald Trump win back power.
I’m thrilled to share that the book is now available for pre-order at wwnorton.com/books/9781324118190.
These orders affect availability in bookstores, my publisher’s decisions about printing numbers + more. If accountability for Palestine matters to you, or if my investigative reporting has ever struck a chord, please place an order. To those who made this possible, in my life and at Norton: I can’t thank you enough. Onward to publication day: September 22! -
Adam Tooze reposted
John Raymond Hanger
@johnrhanger
Long Duration Battery Boom Begins!
9.6 GWh of LDES deployed in 2025.
~35 GWh of LDES in 2026.
422 GWh in pipeline.
LDES makes reliable 95% plus wind & solar grids possible around world.
RE & Batteries are coming for fossil fuels.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-03-03/china-s-big-ba… #energysky -
Adam Tooze reposted
Soutik Biswas
@soutikBBC
‘India is like three countries stacked in an economic ladder: 25m live in ‘Australia’-like affluence, ~200m in a ‘Philippines’-style service economy, while the rest struggle in conditions closer to sub-Saharan ‘Africa’. www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2026-03-13/india-can-t…
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Rafael Proença
@externalidades
if you care about the human costs of the war, you should care about people in developing countries most exposed to the economic shocks. Who are those? 1/
-
Adam Tooze reposted
Janis Kluge
@jakluge
German electricity mix in recent days. The blue and yellow stuff doesn't have to pass through the Strait of Hormuz.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Martin Wolf on three scenarios for the world economy. This and other topics in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/tax-the-billionaires-americas-first
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The longer we live, the more the cancer odds go against us. So it is a race between medicine and aging. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Find out more here: adamtooze.substack.com/publish/post/190754771?back=%2Fpub…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman on the Sanders proposal for a billionaire tax. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Interesting chart by Seth Ackerman that gives us another way of comparing European and American incomes. I've linked to it on the Chartbook Top Links of the day:
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In an astonishing transformation in British politics, the Greens, not Labour, are now the most popular party not just with young, but also with the 20 percent who are struggling most in economic terms. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A preponderance of fund managers now thinks US tech firms are overinvesting in AI. More on this in the Chartbook Top Link today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The CO2 emissions from food are pretty much all in the production not packaging or transport.
Benjamin Todd
@ben_j_todd
If you want to reduce emissions, ignore plastic packaging and food miles: almost all food emissions come from production.
Reducing meat will do far more than anything else. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Unseasonal war. How the US-Israeli war on Iran threatens the global agricultural cycle.
Latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Check it out and sign up here.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-436-unseasonal-war-how -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The natural gas spike is bad, but it has a long way to go before it matches 2022. More on this in the Chartbook Top Links today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Why is it that the rest find it so hard to get it this right?
Clash Report
@clashreport
Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez on Iran:
Today more than ever, it is essential to remember that one can be against a hateful regime, as is the case with the Iranian regime, as is the whole of Spanish society, and at the same time be against an unjustified, dangerous military intervention outside of international law.
That one must be against a war initiated without the authorization of the United States Congress or the United Nations Security Council and, as I have said before, one that violates international law.
And that there is always room for a negotiated solution, instead of being dragged along by the devastation of arms as the only possible way out.
Therefore, I would like once again, as we have done since the beginning, to appeal for immediate de-escalation, for full respect for international law in all the conflicts we are unfortunately suffering, and for the urgency of resuming dialogue as soon as possible.
That is where Spain will be, and that is where I believe the whole of the European Union should be. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"To advocate for lopsided, nation-state rearmament as the path of least resistance, while rejecting deep military integration & common financing, is not just short-sighted. It is a betrayal of the most basic wisdom of European integration." www.ft.com/content/2445132e-7208-4a3e-a493-c565ae1ab5b5
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Ok comrades. I’ve slept on it and I’m here to admit that I do have a dark food secret. But it’s not DoorDash and a credit card. It’s tinned fish hoarding. This year I’m saying no. With the help of family & friends, I’m gonna “eat these down”. One tin per week will get me there.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
When Penguins fly!
NXT EU
@NXT4EU
German Government just posted this video on TikTok with the caption
"Europe. For sure." -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Amazing is the world. US officials are systematically seeking to subvert the independence of judiciaries around the world in the interests of political friends of the American right-wing.
Alex Taylor
@AlexTaylorNews
Amazing moment on French TV. A French judge explains how Trump sent people from the US Embassy basically trying to intimidate her during Le Pen's trial for embezzlement - something they've done to other judges around the world
My English sub-titles 👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Because, you know, Brexit was all about “taking back control”. More content great graphs and links featured on today's Chartbook Top Links in the comment below.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
When the man is right, he is right! And just look at those awesome machines. The size of that hub!
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
China has now started installing 20MW offshore wind turbines. You just need 50 of those to match the capacity of an average 1GW nuclear plant.
This might sound trivial but think for a minute how much easier it is to install a wind turbine than it is to build a nuclear plant. The latest nuclear reactor in the U.S., Vogtle Units 3 & 4, took 11 years to build. Whereas you can install a wind turbine in just two to three weeks (yes, really: www.researchgate.net/publication/324919069_Offshore_wind_…)
That's an insane differential: a couple of weeks vs. 11 years.
With of course immense implications on costs: it's much cheaper to build, with a much safer risk profile. For one thing you start generating revenue in weeks instead of getting your capital tied up during more than a decade. As a reminder, Vogtle's cost overruns actually bankrupted Westinghouse - America's flagship nuclear company - in 2017 (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westinghouse_Electric_Company). No major energy company can possibly get bankrupt over a wind turbine project.
This is why, again, it's positively insane to believe that green energy is "a scam": the numbers are right there. The only scam is convincing people otherwise, which ironically favors China: they power their factories with cheap, rapidly deployed energy while we get the culture war. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How do Americans feel about AI - fascinating data from top Democratic-party pollster David Shor. This and other topics in today's version of the Chartbook Top Links.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Spain now borrows at lower rates than France and the spread to Germany is at c. 0.5 percent. This and more in the Chartbook Top Links today.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The more I think about it, the more I agree with @NewLeftEViews on this.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
As in-person working declines and AI takes off, data center spending is set to overtaken investment in office space. More on today's Chartbook Top Links!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Let me go a bit harder on this @zeitonline You talk about "Bestuerzung" (dismay) over a serious intellectual meeting about German politics and culture. I suggest you focus on this astonishing report on the ruination of Gaza and the question of who is responsible. h/t @wsj
DIE ZEIT
@zeitonline
"Das eigentlich Bestürzende war, dass es sich in Zürich nicht um irgendeinen Palästina-Kongress mit ein paar Aktivisten handelte, sondern dass auf den Podien die Spitzen der Kultur saßen": Peter Neumann schreibt über die Tagung "Rise & Fall of the BRD". www.zeit.de/kultur/2025-12/der-grosse-kanton-rise-fall-of…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Millions are turning to AI for therapy. But is the technology ready? Discuss this in today's Chartbook Top Links.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Data centres consume 5% of America’s electricity, up from 2% a decade ago. The International Energy Agency projects nearly 10% by 2030. More at today's Chartbook Top Links:
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The US edges past Italy and Greece as global debt champion. Read more on this in today's Chartbook.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
BYD has more than twice the share of the next contender in the Chinese EV market. Tesla is relegated to sixth place with one sixth of the market share. Find out more in today's Chartbook.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China and robotaxi advancements. Read more on today's Top Links in the comment below:
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
90 percent of electric trucks added in Q2 2025 were in China. Over 89,000 electric trucks were sold in the first half of 2025, up 140% from the same period last year. Read more in today’s Chartbook!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Wish I'd seen this from @tracyalloway earlier to illustrate the latest chartbook on the malign coincidence of MAGA and the moment of hyperscaling.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The bloodbath in China’s car market is fierce.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In relation to labour costs, Western manufacturing industry has FAR fewer robots than you would expect and the East Asian industrial powerhouses have FAR more. Where the robots are—featured in today’s Chartbook Top Link.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This is really not a joke ...
The White House
@WhiteHouse
ARE YOU READY… TO MAKE AMERICA FIT AGAIN
WHITE HOUSE X @TRIPLEH 🔥This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
More US sectors are experiencing job losses than job gains, this normally betokens a recession.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
American electricity prices are rising sharply this summer, thanks to heavy demand and supply tightness. For more insights visit today’s Chartbook Top Link.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This morning’s Chartbook Top Link featured how AI is undoing the search-bargain on which the internet has hitherto depended.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The National Health Service is the closest thing that the UK has to a national religion, and it is in crisis.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Since 2008, the UK economy has seen the most severe growth-slowdown of any advanced economy.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
US science funding in 2025 is down by 50 percent.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One could only wish that Ivy League schools had leadership that spoke with the eloquence and courage of this dedicated educator, Jaime Cook Prek-12 Principal.
Rick Perlstein
@rickperlstein
Do not look away.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One for the ages. I guess AI is producing this stuff, right? Or actual humans? In either case class it under hallucination.
Pete Hegseth
@PeteHegseth
America stands with Greenland.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This is such an exciting initiative. Wish I could be in Tulsa!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chartbook 349 Scholasticides
The latest Chartbook newsletter just dropped. open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-349-scholasti… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The sheer stupidity of this is something to reckon with.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump: "We don't want windmills in this country. We're putting an order on it. I've already sort of done it. We don't want windmills ... you know what else people don't like? Those massive solar fields."
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hannah Forsyth's Virtue Capitalists is the sort of book that changes how you see the world. Sign up to learn more about the rise of the professional middle class and meritocracy in today's Chartbook Top Links: adamtooze.substack.com/p/airline-profits-global-migration…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Why Elon Musk might care so much about Federal government has been featured in today's Chartbook Top Link. Sign up here for more: adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-576-social-exclusion-i…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China’s port in Peru is the first in the region to support “post-Panamax” ships aka modern vessels too large for the Panama Canal. The implications for Chinese and South American trade are featured in today’s Chartbook Top Links. Sign up for more here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/defending-the-fed-betting-on-inv…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Is recovery in Gaza possible? Cam and I thinking through the anniversary of October 7th @OnesandToozePod featured at Chartbook top links. Explore more thought-provoking topics and updates in the Chartbook Top Links here: adamtooze.substack.com/p/why-deglobalization-isnt-really-…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
LOSING their minds. Truly.
James Jackson
@derJamesJackson
Green Minister Cem Özdemir says it’s “awful and terrible that Greta Thunberg went on a pro-Palestine rally “and it should make those of us who praised her before reconsider”
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In Germany you literally need an empirical research to enable people to distinguish pro Palestinian from anti semitic. Kant: self inflicted immaturity!
Patrick Kaczmarczyk
@pat_kaczmarczyk
"Der an das junge, linke und akademische Milieu gerichtete Antisemitismusvorwurf ist vorschnell – tatsächlich handelt es ich um die am wenigsten antisemitisch eingestellte Gruppe in Deutschland."
Neue Studie der Uni Mannheim: www.uni-mannheim.de/news/gip-policy-brief-2-24/
Das wichtigste in Kürze 👇 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
A direct threat that Israel will reduce Lebanon, like Gaza, to rubble. A threat disguised as natural process "fall into abyss of destruction and suffering".
This is what we, in the US are backing.
www.theguardian.com/world/live/2024/oct/08/israel-iran-li… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
US tax payers are covering 25% of the costs of Israel's rampage when Israel has a gdp per capita on a par with Germany's and a 60% debt to GDP level in 2023 a figure US fiscal hawks can only dream of ...
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
The US is sending record levels of military aid to Israel, but unless you put the total in context it's hard to understand how extraordinary it is.
The military aid sent to Israel is nearly double Iran's *total military spending*.
Iran's military spending was $10.3bn in 2023. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Behind the scenes, Hochstein, McGurk and other top U.S. national security officials are describing Israel’s Lebanon operations as a history-defining moment — one that will reshape the Middle East for the better for years to come." This is the Israeli-US synthesis at this moment!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"We are now dealing with an imperial Israel that is solving its problems in someone else's country, world opinion be damned." CBS 1982.
Occupation Movie
@OccupationMovie
During Israel's 1982 invasion of Lebanon, amazing to see US media shine a light on the sheer brutality of the invasion & openly blast Israel as an imperial bully. Far cry from the stenographers to power posing as "journalists" in corporate media today. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gdkwNCzZd0&rco=1
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Most radical wing of AfD led by Hoecke predicted to get more than 1/3 seats in Thuringia giving them a blocking vote even if excluded from government. www.zdf.de/nachrichten/politik/deutschland/landtagswahl-t…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
US railway stock, which once dominated the stock market, have declined in relative importance. But that should not be confused with commercial failure.
They made a very good long-term investment indeed.
Striking data in Chartbook newsletter today
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-308-stock-market-turmoil -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This is blatant, overt, indeed boastful interference in US democracy, by an organization openly committed to promoting the interests of a country other than the USA.
Armani
@historyoarmani2
and folks were terrified of “Russian interference” in 2016
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I thought this must be a joke, but Walz truly did create a "national" Beyoncé day in Minnesota.
Governor Tim Walz
@GovTimWalz
I might be Governor of Minnesota, but we all know who runs the world. Welcome to Minnesota, Beyoncé!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How nature healed and bald eagles returned to parts of Wisconsin.
A cheery map featured in Chartbook Top Links today. Check it out and sign up for more here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-476-jim-crow-and-black -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Fermin Revueltas (1902-1935), Nacionalismo Industrial
Featured in Chartbook Top Links today. Check it out and sign up for more here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-475-tariffs-as-the-mai… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
America’s long retreat from 19th-century protectionism
Featured in Chartbook Top Links today.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-474-the-cyprus-civil-war -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Adjusting for GDP rather than just inflation it is a little less extreme, but the point stands. US support for Israel's on-going massacre in Gaza is utterly grotesque.
Stephen Semler
@stephensemler
-Nixon gave Israel $13B in military aid after the Yom Kippur war started
-Carter gave Israel $14B after the Egypt-Israeli peace treaty
-Biden gave Israel $18B in weapons after it was charged with genocide -
Hanno Hauenstein
@hahauenstein
Tony Judt, Masha Gessen, Etienne Balibar unter der Headline „Zu viele ausgezeichnete Antisemiten“ zu listen – langsam aber sicher wird die von mir geschätzte Taz teils ununterscheidbar von der BILD-Zeitung. Politisches Irrlichtern nach rechts für die Klicks – bitter mit anzusehen
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Not lost for words @tazgezwitscher just exhausted by the serial stupidity and grotesquely lopsided politics of these disgraceful equations.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"The focus on growth is surely right. ... But this sense of assuredness is entirely at odds with the little we really know about growth’s causes."
@danielsusskind featured in Chartbook Top Links today.
Check it out and sign up for more. adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-471-global-billionaires -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
So monarchical is American conception of Presidency that Biden is feted as a ruler who "gave up power" in favor of anointed successor, rather than a vain politician who misjudged his sell by date & has been belatedly persuaded to spare himself humiliation & give Dems a chance.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Manuel Álvarez Bravo", Las lavanderas sobrentendidas".
Amazing Mexican photographer of 20th century featured in Chartbook Top Links today. Check it out and sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/top-links-464-how-manufactured-g… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Did the ECB maybe overdo the interest rate tightening? Dramatic collapse in the flow of credit to the European private sector should surely have forced an earlier halt.
Telling data featured in the latest Top Links from Chartbook newsletter.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/houstons-real-estate-bust-europes -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
On May 29 New Delhi recorded a peak temperature of 52.9, just 1.5 shy of the Death Valley world record of 54.4! 30 m people find themselves in a hellish urban furnace.
www.ft.com/content/312258d4-c7ae-4683-8ba1-af78e792c0e1 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In India a heatwave is killing polling staff running the election. The crisis is already here.
Hartosh Singh Bal
@HartoshSinghBal
where in the world would this be acceptable with such matter of fact ease.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Are the Houthis "exogenous"? Or, do we have ask ourselves, how many billion-dollar container ships can go through a chokepoint, with poor and angry people on both sides, exactly how long can you ignore the Palestinian question, before something happens?
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
☹️Govt economist: Oh no, higher prices.
😁Acad economist: Oh yea, exogenous variation. www.ft.com/content/a03da8f6-b468-4a86-8db5-83838f7d6409?s… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Texas has become #1 in wind/solar energy in USA reports @jburnmurdoch NO mention in of Bidenomics, just technology and costs.
It is this kind of news @BuddyYakov that suggested the comment I made. Does someone know better? Is IRA at work in Texas boom?
www.ft.com/content/ef2f6f8e-60df-4ccd-8c4f-ef5cd0eb3176 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
It simple does not matter what American musicians actually mean. If they make a sardonic reference to American patriotism ... it becomes a patriotic song!
Born in the USA
Now: Keep on Rocking in the Free World.
Here are the darkly ironic lyrics:
There’s colors on the street
Red, white, and blue
People shuffling their feet
People sleeping in their shoes
There’s a warning sign on the road ahead
There’s a lot of people saying we’d be better off dead (than Red or maybe than poor, AT)
Don’t feel like Satan, but I am to them
So I try to forget it any way I can
[Chorus]
Keep on rockin' in the free world
I see a woman in the night
With a baby in her hand
There's an old street light
Near a garbage can
Now she put the kid away and she’s gone to get a hit
She hates her life and what she’s done to it
There’s one more kid that’ll never go to school
Never get to fall in love, never get to be cool
Keep on rockin' in the free world
We got a thousand points of light
For the homeless man
We got a kinder, gentler machine gun hand
We've got department stores and toilet paper
Got styrofoam boxes for the ozone layer
Got a man of the people says keep hope alive
Got fuel to burn, got roads to drive
CSPAN
@cspan
.@SecBlinken plays "Rockin' in the Free World" at Barman Dictat, an underground cocktail bar and music venue in Kyiv, Ukraine.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Even more intense than Columbia by all accounts. This is citywide repression.
Jeanne Theoharis
@JeanneTheoharis
Friends, please, please amplify. The NYPD are now raiding City College. Reports are hundreds of cops. Please, I know that what happened at Columbia tonight is sickening--but this is Part II. And our @cuny students are largely working class students of color.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Today locked out of offices. Not just a place of work but the place we define by our teaching and research without which it is literally nothing more than a bunch of badly managed assets and a hospital.
Karl Jacoby
@karl_jacoby
Faculty at #columbia protecting students from possible arrest
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Meanwhile, towards its own staff @Columbia Presidency is engaged in deliberate obfuscation. 2 hours ago we received a rambling email suggesting an increasing impatience with negotiations and new focus on graduation etc but no specific deadlines or threats.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chartbook 279: Columbia University's "crisis" - a political economy sketch map.
The latest chartbook newsletter just dropped.
Check it out and sign up here: open.substack.com/pub/adamtooze/p/chartbook-279-columbia-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In The World Is Still on Fire - @LHSummers & N.K. Singh on behalf of IEG offer a devastating review of the failure of dev finance in 2023.
www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/imf-world-bank-sprin…
Chartbook Newsltter 277 reviews this remarkable prise de conscience
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-277-the-world-is-still -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
God, if you need something to make you feel better right now, watch this all the way to the end! It just gets better and better.
Nature is Amazing ☘️
@AMAZlNGNATURE
Faith in Humanity Restored!! ❤️
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Exec committee of Columbia Univ Senate—the body that the President should consult pursuant to Section 444—did “not approve the presence of NYPD on our campus at this time,” Shafik "consulted" but did not gain agreement & then invited in NYPD riot squad.
www.columbiaspectator.com/news/2024/04/18/shafik-authoriz… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
From Bauhaus to Buchenwald. This is the most surprising and fascinating book of German history I have read in a long while. Congrats @suhrkamp For an English appreciation check out Chartbook #274
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-274-from-bauhaus-to-bu… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Global disparities in health spending are staggering. Obs. But dont just shrug. Let the numbers sink in! $145 v. $6469! The @IHME_UW reports are essential reading.
www.healthdata.org/sites/default/files/files/policy_repor… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“We’re seeing Germany undo legislative packages . . . whose passage should be a formality,” he said. “That really damages Germany’s reputation. The other EU states are just shaking their heads in disbelief.”
www.ft.com/content/16251601-615a-4089-ad91-eca4a0b5ee6e -
Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Yeah @MacaesBruno take this down please. Respect for what you are doing, but that isnt the ruling and you know it.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
On the face of it, the AfD leadership proposing that Germany holding a referendum on leaving EU seems crazy. But in fact it does nicely pick our their supporters.
www.ft.com/content/5050571e-79f9-4cb7-991c-093702ec8833 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I want to associate myself with Rashid Khalidi's devastating critique of the Columbia University administration infringement of free speech and blatant bias against pro-Palestinian students. This should not stand in a self-respecting university. It is a disgrace.
Tarik Endale | ታሪክ እንዳለ
@Tarik_Endale
Professor Rashid Khalidi in an open letter to Columbia University administration in response to an email sent by deans on Dec 21st, 2023.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Just in case you were wondering where @TheEconomist stands on this whole end of neoliberalism/new Washington consensus thing ...
-
Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò
@OlufemiOTaiwo
"Solid majorities of Germans remain open-minded and welcoming to diversity. But cultural politics only go so far. All too often what is missing is money...combining austerity and large-scale migration is a recipe for xenophobia."
@adam_tooze in FT
www.ft.com/content/ff6f9bbe-d50f-413d-8287-51f3fe070142Post not available here, view on X
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Plus the reasonable aim is not to win over the 14% of far-right/neo-Nazi, but to persuade the wavering 20% that "something is being done" -> restoring the quarantine and confining AfD to whatever its core vote is.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Though considered quintessential “good job”, auto jobs did not start that way. In 1935 average pay was half the amount necessary to support a family of four. The historic 1936-1937 Sit Down Strike helped create an industry where a job pays on average of $73k
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
And yes, before you ask, of course I blame the Schuldenbremse!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
To put these German renewable power CAPACITY figures in perspective, China will add as much capacity as Germany installed in the last quarter century this year.
www.ft.com/content/2488d434-bbd3-4e63-ac88-1e5a2c3967d2 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Despite fond liberal imaginings, WWII was not won by New Deal or FDR's bomber program. At home USA barely broke sweat. Work of crushing Nazis done by Stalinist SU. If we are "declaring war on climate change", will it be China carrying fight this time?
foreignpolicy.com/2020/01/15/climate-socialism-supercharg… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
On top of massive business lobbying, the OECD (headed by a conservative Australian) helped arm twist Australia's labour government into watering down a law that would have required thousands of multinationals to publicly say where they pay tax.
www.ft.com/content/b21cfde0-8940-45db-b3e3-3e9807d7b957 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Extraordinary detail from the Gary Simmons public enemy show at @mcachicago
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I had to check this to believe it: "Elke Kahr is an Austrian politician of the Communist Party of Austria who has served as Mayor of Graz, the second-largest city in Austria, since 2021." WOW Austrian cities are different!
David Broder
@broderly
In Graz, where Communist Elke Kahr is mayor, her party is next weekend holding the sixth edition of an annual "Yugo–Fešta" celebrating Austria's former socialist neighbour
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There are growing concerns in China tech world bout U.S. government order restricting outbound investment in key technologies. Paul Rosen, the U.S. assistant secretary of the Treasury for investment security, confirmed persistent rumors.
www.caixinglobal.com/2023-06-29/in-depth-proposed-biden-c… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One minute Western elite was worrying earnestly about balance of democracy and capitalism and announcing a new social contract, next we are assigning both fiscal & monetary policy to hammer inflation & maintain financial stability cos .. TINA. C'mon ...!
www.ft.com/content/2e2c5a23-af05-4124-ac6b-73e34651a5de -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Very clarifying taxonomy of differing positions on "industrial policy" and "derisking" from @JWMason1
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"In Washington the music is military." This by Grey Anderson in @NewLeftReview on the nat sec logic of the new industrial policy is truly excellent!
newleftreview.org/sidecar/posts/strategies-of-denial -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Intel’s chip project is the largest foreign investment in postwar German history and is seen as pivotal to EU plans to double its share of the global semiconductor market from less than 10 per cent today to 20 per cent by 2030.
www.ft.com/content/7663d813-504e-4ec7-84e8-ad9e272389f5 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Sudan on your mind? It should be. For some relief and (at times melancholy beauty) check out Noori & His Dorpa Band (live @Le Guess Who? 2022) courtesy of the fablous @vrijegeluiden platform.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dNTMUuYTLc&t=2s -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"On average, fiscal consolidations do not reduce debt-to-GDP ratios." @IMFNews
www.imf.org/en/Publications/WEO/Issues/2023/04/11/world-e… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"As a historian"
On the courage of Vladimir Kara-Murza.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-208-as-a-historian-the -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Been a lot of chatter since last year about Europe's "return to coal", "falling back in love with fossil fuels". This commentary claims to speak for realism against green ideology and yet it is itself at odds with the facts. New piece for @ForeignPolicy
foreignpolicy.com/2023/04/05/europe-energy-crisis-securit… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
JAKE SULLIVAN: The intelligence community’s analysis was that Russia would achieve substantial gains very rapidly. Kyiv could easily fall fast. It wasn’t just the pressure of a war starting. It was the pressure of Russia, brutally, ruthlessly succeeding
www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/02/24/russia-ukraine-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Chartbook: Grim art, the BoJ's last stand, Ukrainian refugees and the border-industrial complex adamtooze.substack.com/p/grim-art-the-bojs-last-stand-ukr…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Archipelago capitalism, the Bahamas and FTX. Chartbook #188 putting a recent piece on Bahamas in relation to work by @zeithistoriker Pistor and @vanessahistory
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-188-archipelago-capita… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Did a Chartbook newsletter to go with the @OnesandToozePod episode for MLK day
foreignpolicy.com/podcasts/ones-and-tooze/the-economic-ph…
My thinking about this very indebted to @DavidpStein PhD
FEARING INFLATION, INFLATING FEARS: THE END OF FULL EMPLOYMENT AND
THE RISE OF THE CARCERAL STATE -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“Silicon Saxony” is Europe’s largest microelectronics / ICT cluster, or so it claims. If TSMC makes good on its intention of locating in Dresden that is a huge coup. Plus Intel is eying Magdeburg.
business-saxony.com/en/industry-sectors/microelectronics-ict -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Translation; Web3 startup demonstrating the powerful fix offered by blockchain in 2022.
Dirk Hagemann
@derhagemann
ein Web3 Startup zeigt, welches Problem es 2022 mit Hilfe der Blockchain gelöst hat
. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Late to this "party", but reversion of @FT UK economics team to deficit hawkery/austerity 2.0 complete with DIY "how to fill the black hole" app illustrated with pictures of homeless children v. roadworks trade offs is ... "special".
www.ft.com/content/acbddf57-17d3-4aed-bfcd-34162da18d95 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Not ending yet: trade globalization since 1827.
www.ft.com/content/d62bfec1-5e2e-4490-aeb9-a72b6a602269 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
100th anniversary of Mussolini's March on Rome: @claraemattei wrote a brilliantly provocative book on liberal economists, austerity, & the fascist regime. In response I did a Chartbook Newsletter on theme of authoritarian temptation and liberal expertise.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-166-19222022-the-cente… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There is international econ - based on "island" view of world econ & then there is analysis of global financial network centered on $ - what @PMehrling in his lovely new book on Kindleberger calls a cosmopolitan view. See Chartbook #160 h/t @HyunSongShin
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-160-kindleberger-mehrling -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Bangladeshi textile industry exports grew from $32mn in 1984 to $34bn today. In 2020, Bangladesh earned twice as much from garment exports as all 54 African countries combined.
www.ft.com/content/9022be83-8a52-4b95-a213-951ecfb8335d -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Hourly wages EZ-Uk-US: Jut to put the talk of a wage-price spiral in Europe in perspective.
www.ft.com/content/2c555bc7-4285-44bb-88cb-c2489e1f8304 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
China’s birth rate fell by just under 30% 2019-2021, the largest two-year fall since the country’s Great Famine between 1959 and 1961. Just 10.6mn babies were born in China in 2021, the lowest number recorded since the Communist party took power in 1949.
www.ft.com/content/a1389fba-ffd6-474e-8eed-ac9198453e94 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For European energy sovereignty, new LNG terminals etc may be necessary as flexible back up. BUT huge strides could be made by using less fossil fuels through efficiency and determined push in renewables. Essential this from @AgoraEW @MatthiasBuck4
static.agora-energiewende.de/fileadmin/Projekte/2021/2021… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Did a piece for @NewStatesman and @GavJacobson on the Mearsheimer debate
www.newstatesman.com/ideas/2022/03/john-mearsheimer-and-t…
Followed it up with Chartbook #95 on realism and great power politics.
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-95-is-ukraine-the-wests -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This conversation with @ezraklein about liberalism, economic development, Russia and war was a journey in its own right. podcasts.apple.com/fr/podcast/the-ezra-klein-show/id15486…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
We are in truly dangerous spiral:
Brave Ukrainian resistance frustrates Russian attack -> Kiev refuses humiliating negotiations.
Russia about to ramp up destructiveness of attack
NATO members rushing weapons to Ukraine
EU/US announce major sanctions.
What is Russia’s next move? -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“Europe made a bet to maintain jobs, on the expectation that businesses could recover their previous activity, and for most companies, in almost all sectors, that’s what has happened.” Short-time working was the right way to go!
www.ft.com/content/4453e5ac-3490-4726-8caf-794440dc7183 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Remarkable moment when universal owner i.e. Blackrock says to central banks. This is inflation is different. Don’t slam on brakes and cause unnecessary damage. Let inflation facilitate supply side adjustment
www.ft.com/content/1e59e952-c5cf-4c8e-983a-560170c87cda -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Americans are wildly overoptimistic about chances of upward social mobility. Europeans are pessimistic. Actual mobility higher in Europe than in the US.
thedailyshot.com/2022/01/12/small-businesses-havent-been-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If rich countries are building houses at less than half the rate we did in the 1960s should we be surprised that real estate prices are rising to record levels? Asks @TheEconomist
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/how-long-can-the-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Did anyone predict that we would be starting 2022 debating price controls, the WWII and Nixon experiences and regime crisis in Kazakhstan? #66 of my Chartbook newsletter just dropped. Sign up here:
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-66-more-on-inflation-and
H/t to @policytensor for the nice graph! -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In terms of output per hour worked, France is slightly ahead of Germany and remarkably close to the United States.
www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/6b749602-en.pdf -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
By 2050, 1 in 4 of world’s population will be African. One-third of the world’s working age population, defined as 15- to 64-year-olds, will be African. Nigeria will have pop >400 m -> 3rd most populous country in world. H/t @davidpilling
www.ft.com/content/819e5d76-7652-4c4a-9157-b49d040fa1b6 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Your regular reminder that GLOBAL government energy R&D spending is less than what Americans spend annually on pet food & treats. Not vet bills. Just food and treats …. Energy transition? Seriously?
WE AIN'T EVEN TRYING!
One for @ErikFossing
iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/5e6b3821-bb8f-4df4-a88b-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This debate btw Andreas Malm and @MuellerTadzio on the strategic and tactical options for radical climate movement is cracking.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnlDeLXaifY -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Per capita manuf value added across the US in the early 20th century gives a stark image of “core” v. “Periphery”.
From work by Elizabeth Sanders and Richard Bensel. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Xi’s “common prosperity for all”, line has knocked €61.7bn, or almost 10 per cent, from the collective market value of Western luxury brands LVMH, Hermès, Kering, Richemont and Burberry since August 17.
www.ft.com/content/4cf59a34-cd03-48a1-b5d0-0c71922ef9b3 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Astonishingly, America’s EPA preannounces the days on which it will monitor PM2.5 pollution. Using satellite data Eric Zou confirms that on the other days businesses pump out much higher levels of filth. www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/09/04/poorly-devise…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
What if the Corona crisis was just a trial run?
Shutdown teaser in the @nytimes
this morning.
LOVE the illustration. THANKS @doble_entendre www.nytimes.com/2021/09/01/opinion/covid-pandemic-global-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In 2024 Maersk is taking delivery of 8 container vessels rated at 16k boxes each capable of running china->EU on green methanol.
Capital cost per ship $175m = 10–15% premium. Fuel is twice as expensive. But Amazon and H&M will pay. We CAN do this!
www.ft.com/content/800faea2-1024-4ea6-ade6-1680820e925b -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Did Truman understand that Hiroshima was a city? Horrifying questions from @wellerstein
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Regular reminder that the COVID pandemic is …. NOT OVER. Shocked myself back into awareness this morning by consulting THAT @FT
Graph of COVID deaths. For Latin America, in particular, this is an ongoing disaster of huge scale. www.ft.com/content/a2901ce8-5eb7-4633-b89c-cbdf5b386938 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
To get to net zero the world needs capital. The average cost of capital for a wind project in Indonesia is about four times that of one in Germany. Investors and politicians in rich countries claim to want to help, but they are not yet doing enough.
www.economist.com/briefing/2021/06/12/the-bottlenecks-whi… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Greek debt is a rather striking demonstration of how politics defines “sustainability"! Most of it held by various European institutions and ECB actively buying in market for rest -> 200% of GDP with rock bottom yields.
H/t @MagnusBarsoe @jfkirkegaard -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Right here, right now: The narrow path to net zero by 2050 as charted by the @IEA in a dramatic new report, involves continued production of fossil fuels, especially from OPEC, but a radical halt to new development and exploration.
www.ft.com/content/2bf04fff-5b2f-4d96-a4ea-ff55e029f18e -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This interview of @derspiegel with @omri_boehm on the prospects for Israel after the two state solution is worth your time.
DER SPIEGEL
@derspiegel
Der deutsch-israelische Philosoph Omri Boehm wuchs im Norden Israels auf, wo viele Araber leben. Hier spricht er über die Ursachen der Eskalation, die Gefahr eines Bürgerkriegs – und Auswege aus der Gewalt.
www.spiegel.de/ausland/israel-interview-mit-philosoph-omr… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Reflecting the combined impact of lower tax rates and ruthless tax optimization strategies, the median effective tax rate for the world’s biggest firms has halved -- dropping from 35% in 1990 to 17% in 2020.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-04-30/charting-the-g… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Eric Hobsbawm visiting Paris for Bastille day 1936 during Popular Front.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wVQ4dfC34TI -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Goodbye, Chicago boys. Hello, M.I.T. gang.” As @paulkrugman says, from the 1990s it was MIT that ruled the roost - implication being that actually existing neoliberalism a la Clinton, Blair was all theirs.
For more see
foreignpolicy.com/2021/04/01/janet-yellen-mario-draghi-it…
www.nytimes.com/2015/07/24/opinion/paul-krugman-the-mit-g… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Like great projects of past, the plan will unify & mobilize the country to meet the great challenges of our time: climate crisis & the ambitions of an autocratic China.”
US places China on par with climate as challenge not China as partner on climate.
www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Kojève the intellectual inspiration for @FukuyamaFrancis end of history thesis, lost most of his money in the stock market crash of 1931, where he had imprudently bought shares of the cheesemaker La vache qui rit!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
‘Craziest things happen in politics. Credits dried up. The Reich is verging on bankruptcy. Our hour approaches with eerie certainty, and we will seize it. After Brüning, it is our turn.’ Goebbels 14/7/1931
Straumann’s 1931 is essential on how DEflation opened door to HItler -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"Bitcoin mining’s energy consumption eclipses that of major global tech companies providing entertainment and services, looking at annual electrical energy consumption values from various reports:” and ALL EV!
ketanjoshi.co/2021/03/11/bitcoin-is-a-mouth-hungry-for-fo… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Over the half century btw 1970 and 2020 the UK’s rate of deindustrialization was the most dramatic amongst advanced economies. From fascinating piece by @andrewbatson at @Gavekal on China’s new efforts to resist deindustrialization.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Unused vaccines are a crime.
95 % of the AstraZeneca vaccine delivered to German state of Saxony have not been used. Further deliveries should cease. Reallocation to low income countries NOW. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
France had administered 16% of 1.1m doses of AstraZeneca received. Germany, Italy 20%, Spain < 33%. Unless that rate rises all new supply should be reallocated to low income countries. We need to get shots in people’s arms. Unused shots = a crime.
www.ft.com/content/767fdd85-5329-479d-b565-4ec85d28b492 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"The ECB is a monument to
the proposition that money is too serious to be left to politicians: in these matters there is no such thing as a responsible politician, democratic money is bad money.” Rudiger Dornbusch 1999.
web.mit.edu/15.018/attach/Dornbusch, R. Essays 1998-2001.pdf -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Half a BILLION dollars were spent on the Georgia Senate races. @axios via @SoberLook
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The richest 100 people in the US added about $600bn to their wealth in 2020.
www.bloomberg.com/features/2020-economic-recovery-inequal… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
This report on fiasco of EU vaccine policy by @derspiegel
is as alarming and depressing as everyone say. Must Read! #vaccine
www.spiegel.de/international/europe/the-planning-disaster… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If projected vaccine production for 2021 were optimally distributed, it should be sufficient to cover 85% of the world’s population. @GoldmanSachs via @SoberLook #vaccinepolecon
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In terms of reduction in carbon intensity of electricity generation (gCO2/kwh), the UK led world over last decade with US in #2! Ahead of Germany, Australia and China.
www.ft.com/content/66ac52e2-e9af-4eed-8be0-d1268309b579 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Stats on “foreign” fishing in UK waters are distorted by fact that UK owners of UK fishing quotas sold them to EU competitors, mainly in the 1990s when their value plunged. Belgian and Danish quota owners did so even more.
www.bbc.com/news/52420116 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Which Americans donated to Biden v. Trump campaign. An extraordinary breakdown by occupations: compare business owners, truckers, police officers with nurses, teachers, lawyers. Remarkable data from @jqlngu
www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2020-election-trump-biden-dono… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
34% of small businesses in the US could not pay rent in October. 46% of beauty salons, 40% restaurants and gyms. This clearly isnt sustainable over many more months. @Alignable via @SoberLook
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The Millennial generation, born between 1981 and 1996, control just 4.6% of U.S. wealth even though they are the largest in the workforce with 72 million members.
@BSteverman @atanzi
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-08/top-50-richest… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
According to latest data, the 50 richest people in the US, are worth almost $2 trillion, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index, up $339 billion from the beginning of 2020.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-08/top-50-richest… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Why were Americans fighting in Belleau Wood in 1918?
OH YES! One of @ProfPaulPoast brilliant threads. You have to read this. Marvelous stuff.
Paul Poast
@ProfPaulPoast
Let's talk about the 1918 Battle of Belleau Wood and why the American Marines who died in it were not "suckers"
[THREAD] -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Despite a glut of global food production, initial United Nations forecasts show that in a worst-case scenario, about a tenth of the world’s population won’t have enough to eat this year.
@megandurisin
@ekrembert
@tatifre
www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-08-31/hunger-is-thre… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Watched #coup53 new documentary about overthrow of Mosaddegh by Taghi Amirani. It really is engrossing. Montage of footage from different eras is fantastic. You won’t be surprised if you follow debate, but having material put together like this is great!
www.theguardian.com/film/2020/aug/20/coup-53-reviewhttps:… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Uchronique:
Pour une histoire des possibles
Analyses contrefactuelles et futurs non advenus
Quentin Deluermoz
Pierre Singaravélou
Counterfactual history comes to France.
www.seuil.com/ouvrage/pour-une-histoire-des-possibles-que… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
U.S Small-Area Life Expectancy Estimates Project tracks life expectancy at census tract level. As of 2017, the average life expectancy at birth in the United States was 78.6 years but this varies hugely with poverty rate e.g. Ohio.
www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/usaleep/usaleep.html
www.communitysolutions.com/research/life-expectancy-race-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Since 2013 Xi has progressively tightened his grip: "Approximately 60% (15 members) of the 19th Politburo of the CCP have direct ties to Xi, up from around 20% (five members) of the 18th Politburo.” Remarkable analysis by @MacroPoloChina
macropolo.org/analysis/the-ties-that-bind-xi-people-polit… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Ho Chi Minh at the Congress of the French Communist Party in Marseille, 1921.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
There is no necessity to open up new foreign markets; the home markets are capable of indefinite expansion provided that ‘income’ or power to demand commodities, is properly distributed’
Hobson Imperialism (1902) trying vainly to forestall Lenin’s reinterpretation ahead of time -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The global COVID-19 pandemic is NOT OVER. IT IS ACCELERATING: Unprecedented 130.4k new positive tests on June 3.
In Europe, at least, you could say it is slowing.
In US it is NOT.
In both Lat Am and Asia it is accelerating alarmingly!
www.cnn.com/2020/06/05/world/coronavirus-cases-rising-fas… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Airlines in trouble: only 4 are profitable at 62% load factor. You need to get to 80% for most of industry to be making any profit at all. www.ft.com/content/abc6355a-3801-4e32-a992-f55e475d4454
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Europe’s Hamiltonian Moment...or the Beginning of the End?
Great discussion with @gilliantett @LauBooneEco @MSchularick courtesy of @INETeconomics
www.ineteconomics.org/events/the-future-of-europe -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
American households as a whole have deleveraged relative to income. But this too is a story of inequality. Borrowing by prime borrowers has recovered strongly v. Subprime which has collapsed and stayed down.
www.federalreserve.gov/publications/files/financial-stabi… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
If you can follow, Voßkuhle’s delivery of ECB judgement of German Supreme Court is worth listening too. He combines assertion of common legal culture of Europe with de facto sovereignty of German Court and back of envelope Stammtisch critique of QE.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrWo36aqMvg -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
2020 is not 2008 - central bank interventions to stop the “capital market crisis” are far larger than those to meet the banking crisis of 2008. @RobinWigg
www.ft.com/content/d9812fee-798a-11ea-9840-1b8019d9a987 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
For real? EU rebadges cohesion funds as corona crisis response but then allocates the funds according to old key -> HUNGARY with mild COVID-19 outbreak receives 5.6bn = 3.8% of GDP v. Italy 2.3bn = 0.1%
Did @derspiegel miss something? Or this is as grotesque as it sounds? -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Since 1995, the Italian state has posted a primary surplus in 24 out of 25 years; the crisis year 2009 was the only exception so far. Thats a GENERATION of austerity! This summary of Italian situation by @heimbergecon is must read.
wiiw.ac.at/italy-is-of-systemic-importance--european-solu… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
More senior Eurozone officials should follow @KlaasKnot
example in insisting that the "call for solidarity is totally understandable”. Furthermore, it is one to which Europe can and should respond in a highly visible way. Amidst the grimness it is actually an opportunity! Bravo. -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Above all the failure of the US to adopt adequate containment is going to make it into a truly national crisis in a nation of 327 m whereas in China it remained confined to a province giving them the chance of a strategic response. We are headed straight to triage.
Megan Greene
@economistmeg
The US is on the wrong side of that Italy line. There are a number of reasons why (cough, testing, cough). But spring breakers pretending this isn’t happening (packed beaches in Clearwater, I’m looking at you!) probably doesn’t help.
Make good choices... -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
I did a piece on the trans-Atlantic left and the Green New Deal for @ForeignPolicy
Perhaps of interest to @tedfertik @70sBachchan
foreignpolicy.com/2020/01/15/climate-socialism-supercharg… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Why the future must belong to fake meat. The carbon, water and land use footprint of existing meat subsitutes are already a tiny fraction of regular herd beef.
@TheEconomist -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Deforestation worldwide broken down by crop. Beef in Brazil accounts for more than total Indonesian deforestation. But palm oil in Indonesia is #2 factor globally. Amazing paper by Pendrill, Persson, Godar & Kastner
iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ab0d41/pdf -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
One of the problems with the “just transition” is that the new skilled manual jobs in the green economy - PV installer and wind turbine tech - are poorly paid. @StatistaCharts via @SoberLook
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Germany’s federal government will earn over €6bn this year by selling negative-yielding debt. @Schuldensuehner via @SoberLook
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
1988 The Funderal Murders Anyone wondering whether the Good Friday Agreement/Backstop etc are really a BIG deal, would be well advised to watch this powerful documentary by @vengle1
about one of the most brutal moments in the troubles. www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b09wfrk0 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
In terms of FDI, Europe remains the largest investor in Africa with the Dutch having increased their involvement more rapidly even than China in recent years (Beer? gas/oil?) @Aligarciaherrer & Xu
bruegel.org/2019/07/chinas-investment-in-africa-what-the-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Are we really living in an age of disruption? Compared to the period 1870-1970 the extent of structural change in US employment since 1970 seems relatively sluggish. Nothing to compare to collapse of agriculture. @DeutscheBank via @SoberLook
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
thought-provoking intervention by @MFratzscher on the “German model”. Stressing "political failure to address some legitimate concerns about rising regional inequality and social polarisation” as cause of rise of AfD. Much to debate!
www.ft.com/content/50b57130-86be-11e9-b861-54ee436f9768 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
“If the crisis has shown anything, it is that we will use all the flexibility within our mandate to fulfil our mandate — and we will do so again to answer any challenges to price stability in the future.” Draghi looks to be pre-commiting his successor!
www.ft.com/content/ea28f876-91a1-11e9-b7ea-60e35ef678d2 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Roughly 2/3 of the increase in inequality in annual earnings in US after 1981 was explained by growing differences in pay between firms, rather than within firms. Divergence particularly pronounced between large firms. Song, Price, Guvenen, Bloom, Von Wachter QJE 2019
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Rich countries tend to have large middle classes (btw 75 and 200% of median income), the exception is the US. @OECD_Stat @LaurenceBoone data cited by @DeutscheBank
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
BHP finds that mixed gender mining teams are far more punctual, easier on equipment and half as dangerous. Fascinating report by @TheEconomist on the gendered division of labour, sexism, wages and productivity. www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2019/02/16/men-st…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"almost half of the CO2 emitted by the entire industrial sector comes from four industries; cement, steel, ammonia and ethylene.” Many of those industrial processes have barely changed since 19th century. It is time for dramatic innovation.
www.economist.com/technology-quarterly/2018/12/01/how-to-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Western coalition bombing in Afghanistan is on track for record in 2018.
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
I haven’t heard much about #afghanistan in my Western media bubble. I had no idea that a record number of bombs was dropped on Afghanistan in 2018.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How China’s decision to end recycled plastic imports shocked and transformed a global industry and now threatens entire global industry. Remarkable report and graphics from @FT @lesliehook @JohnReedwrites
www.ft.com/content/360e2524-d71a-11e8-a854-33d6f82e62f8 -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Zeche Zollverein - a coal mine complex in Essen is a UNESCO world heritage site www.zollverein.de
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
"anyone who has ever bothered to check the data” @M_C_Klein will discover that the Japanese really never did suffer a lost decade but the Swiss and Dutch kinda did. ftalphaville.ft.com/2014/12/04/2059371/did-japan-actually…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Global Wealth Concentration has increased seriously since the crisis: share of top 1% has surged from 36 tp 46% www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-lehman-anniversary/
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Not only are migrant flows to Europe way down but they are shifting from Italy to Spain.www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-07-03/migrants-migra…
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Delighted to see that The Internationalists by @scottjshapiro and @oonahathaway in @TheEconomist books of 2017. Well-deserved! Not just a conversation-starter, a call to thought! www.economist.com/news/books-and-arts/21732078-best-books…
humanityjournal.org/blog/the-shifting-meaning-of-war-and-… -
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
East European, SE Europeans, Irish and Portuguese are spectacularly mobile @SoberLook
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
FANTASTIC data source on family income level and US college admission. MUST READ.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
How healthcare ate the US economy … graphs a bit distorting … but scale of this shift is remarkable.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Four devastating sketches by Paul Klee from 1933: violence, man-hunt, emigration, accusation on the street
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Fascinated by Nunan’s Humanitarian Invasion. Mind-blowingly multi-faceted! God this new literature is good!
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Peak process. at Ellis Island: April 17, 1907 = 11,747 arrivals. Processing time 2-5 hours. 29 questions answered. 2 % rejected.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Bahrdt 1787: Mutual enjoyment is the spice of all human joy. No happiness amongst men is possible without communication and sharing.
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
The appalling waste of human capital due to the Eurozone debacle: Unemployed young university grads across OECD
-
Adam Tooze
@adam_tooze
Thanks Chase for digging out this great piece on abortive June 2012 effort to broker international position on Syria
Chase Madar
@ChaseMadar
A succinct @guardian op-ed from 2012 on the diplomatic solution to Syria that Washington, Paris & London stiff-armed: www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/05/why-kofi-an…














































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































