Neither Russia nor Ukraine wants to go back to the complicated Black Sea Grain Initiative.
But until a truce emerges, other conflict-wracked countries will remain vulnerable to famine, says @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b…
Thomas de Waal
Thomas Patrick Lowndes de Waal (born 1966) is a British journalist and writer on the Caucasus. He is a senior fellow at Carnegie Europe. He is best known for his 2003 book Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan Through Peace and War. More on Wikipedia
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The Black Sea is now even deadlier and more crucial than the Strait of Hormuz
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Global food security is under threat from escalation between Russia and Ukraine in the Black Sea.
@Tom_deWaal argues that a maritime truce would be in the interests of Moscow, Kyiv, and the world.
Read his blog: carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
The Black Sea was “shipping’s deadliest theatre” in July—more dangerous than the Strait of Hormuz.
The longer dangers to shipping persist there, the more global food security is in the line of fire, warns @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
A summer of escalation in the Black Sea has hurt Ukraine economically and is exacerbating world food security.
A truce is needed—as is a broader reframing of Europe’s Ukraine strategy, writes @Tom_deWaal ⤵️
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Jim Stenman
@JimStenman
As Armenia's 2-year duty-free EU access kicks in around mid-October, I've been digging into who actually benefits. Sounds like a lifeline for fruit, veg, and beverage producers cut off by Russia, but mostly favors large existing exporters. caucasuscrossroads.substack.com/p/eu-tariff-cut-armenia-r… @Tom_deWaal
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Harvested Ukrainian grain is now being shipped out by truck or train, at much greater expense.
@Tom_deWaal argues that a ceasefire in the Black Sea would be good news for Russia, Ukraine, and the world ⤵️
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My piece today on the escalation in the Black Sea and need for a truce, also so grain gets to countries that need it most.
And a message to Europe that a successful strategy for Ukraine also runs through Africa and the Middle East. @Carnegie_Europe carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
A summer of escalation in the Black Sea has hurt Ukraine economically and is exacerbating world food security.
A truce is needed—as is a broader reframing of Europe's Ukraine strategy, writes @Tom_deWaal.
Read: carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/09/a-b… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Thank you, Nigar, for these lovely words. What a great loss. Rest in peace, dear Richard. There are some people you always think will be there and suddenly he isn't. Richard was a friend and colleague for decades, a voice of reason and decency. We will miss him very badly
Nigar Göksel
@nigargoksel
I have known Richard Giragosian since at least 2006. We shared countless panels and argued in cafés about Turkey- Armenia-Azerbaijan issues across Western Europe, Turkey, Armenia and Georgia throughout my 30s and 40s.
Yet somehow, the only photos I could find of us together are from webinars. We were always too busy debating ideas to take photos. And perhaps, given our backgrounds, we were both a little guarded.
We had many divergences, but we kept coming back to each other. There was always a baseline of mutual understanding, and seemingly an assumption that the other would always be there — and always be relevant.
I am so sad that Richard died in Istanbul today. I always assumed he would be there, and that we would continue the dialectic. His absence leaves a huge void in the small world we shared for more than two decades. It also leaves a personal gap in my own history.
Rest in peace, Richard. To borrow one of your classic lines at the end of a panel: the conclusion is that there is no conclusion.
@Richard_RSC -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Turkish Minute
@TurkishMinuteTM
The European Court of Human Rights (@ECHR_CEDH) Grand Chamber ruled on Tuesday that #turkey must free Osman Kavala at once after more than eight years in prison. The court held that Kavala’s conviction was "null and void" under the European Convention on Human Rights and ordered Turkey to undo all its effects. It found violations of Article 3, which bans inhuman or degrading treatment, Article 5 on liberty and security and Article 6 on fair trials. It also found violations of Article 10 on free speech, Article 11 on freedom of assembly and association and Article 18, which bars limits on rights for hidden aims.
ECHR CEDH
@ECHR_CEDH
🔴 Watch live
⚖️ Delivery of the Grand Chamber ruling in Kavala v. Türkiye (no. 2) at a public hearing
🗓️25 August
🕙 10.00 a.m.
🔴 En direct
⚖️ Prononcé dans l’affaire de Grande Chambre Kavala c. Türkiye (no 2), en audience publique
🗓️ 25 août
🕙 10 h
www.youtube.com/watch?v=StXQKrZ8yBk -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Ninety today! The Montreux Convention, the grandfather of international treaties, was signed on July 20, 1936. Ankara does all it can to make this slightly archaic convention the framework for Black Sea security – and itself as the gatekeeper. carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/07/managing-mo…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
📅 | 90 years ago today, the signing of the Montreux Convention positioned Turkey as the principal gatekeeper of the Black Sea.
To support Ukraine, Western partners have no choice but to work closely with Turkey on Black Sea security, argues @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/07/managing-mo… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
Akram Aylisli won the EBRD Literature Prize!
Kathreen E Young accepting the award as translator and on his behalf!!!
@MayaJaggi
@EBRD photo & much more @Tom_deWaal #azerbaycan #azerbaijan #stonedreams -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Amazingly, the Montreux Convention will be 90 years old this month. It’s archaic in parts, but for Turkey it's still an essential document that guarantees its role as the gatekeeper of the Straits-- an aspiration fulfilled after many centuries...
carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/07/managing-mo…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Since 2022 the Montreux Factor has helped Ukraine in its maritime conflict with Russia. What happens next, how to engage with Turkey's position of supporting Ukraine without overly antagonizing Russia—all in my Carnegie paper out today. Just in time also for the NATO summit!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🛡️ | This year's #nato Summit convenes in Turkey on July 7-8, with Ukraine high on the agenda.
European and the alliance's efforts to support Kyiv will require closer engagement with Ankara in the Black Sea, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/07/managing-mo… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Engelsberg Ideas
@EngelsbergIdeas
After two military defeats and the loss of Nagorno-Karabakh, Armenia is betting on peace with Azerbaijan and a future beyond Russia.
Armenia, Azerbaijan and the unfinished peace | @Tom_deWaal
engelsbergideas.com/essays/armenia-azerbaijan-and-the-unf… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Ahead of a critical ection on June 7, #armenia has never received so much attention.
But Yerevan needs slow and steady support, not just a brief and bright show of preelection solidarity, writes @Tom_deWaal ⤵️
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/04/the… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just published - my overview of the Armenian election and the state of the peace process engelsbergideas.com/essays/armenia-azerbaijan-and-the-unf…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My discussion with Samvel Meliqsetyan (in Russian) on the state of the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process, the mood in both countries and how TRIPP is progressing. Thank you to Samvel for interesting questions. www.youtube.com/watch?v=0fXA6p4KCvU
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Super news! Akram Aylisli's early novel People and Trees, superbly translated by Katherine Young is one of the three finalists for the EBRD book award. I am a big fan of the luminous novel and the courageous man and this gives him the tribute he deserves. www.ebrd.com/home/news-and-events/news/2026/ebrd-literatu…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🆕 | Europe has an interest in supporting 🇦🇲 leader Nikol Pashinyan as he tries to make peace with neighbors and loosen ties with Russia.
But it is depersonalized support in the long term, not quickfire flash, that will win the day, says @Tom_deWaal: carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2026/04/the… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Against revisionism. Jokhar Dudayev died 30 years ago. I met the man and saw his brand of macho nationalism in action. I recall here the crazy story of 1990s Chechnya. Russia launched a devastating war--Dudayev played his role in making that war happen. www.youtube.com/watch?v=iDn6su8Z3Ys&t=433s
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Grigor Atanesian
@atanessi
I will be joining the esteemed @Tom_deWaal and other panellists to discuss the South Caucasus and Russia's role in the region at the best venue possible (it's also a pub!), @frontlineclub, on 28 April www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/panel-discussion-uneasy-peace-in-t…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Notes from Georgia/South Caucasus (Hälbig, Ralph)
@SouthCaucasus
Panel discussion: Uneasy Peace in the South Caucasus
Tom de Waal @Tom_deWaal and other panellists to discuss the South Caucasus and Russia's role in the region at the best venue possible (it's also a pub!), @frontlineclub, on 28 April www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/panel-discussion-uneasy-peace-in-t… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🧵 | The South Caucasus in 2026
The TRIPP project is designed to create a new dynamic of Armenia-Azerbaijan economic cooperation.
But Baku and Yerevan must first resolve their differences, write @Tom_deWaal, @ZaurShiriyev, & @AregKochinyan.
[1/4]
carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/03/rewiring-th… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
New Eurasian Strategies Centre (NEST Centre)
@nestcentreorg
The recording of this morning's midweek briefing is now available.
@Tom_deWaal joined @eglod_katia to discuss Armenia’s shifting foreign policy, its evolving ties with Russia, and what this means for the South Caucasus balance.
youtu.be/Py10ijk-wH4 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
The Trump Route for International Peace and Prosperity (TRIPP) is a project with major geopolitical repercussions.
Among others, TRIPP could be a East–West transit route linking Central Asia to Europe, say @Tom_deWaal, @AregKochinyan, & @ZaurShiriyev ⤵️
carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/03/rewiring-th… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Come and join me and Rena Effendi @frontlineclub to see and discuss her wonderful film, Searching for Satyrus about looking for a butterfly and the father she never knew, a journey that takes her across the conflict divide, to Armenia @rena_effendi www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/screening-qa-searching-for-satyrus…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Read about Rena and her film here in The Guardian www.theguardian.com/film/2026/mar/27/rena-effendi-searchi…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
New Eurasian Strategies Centre (NEST Centre)
@nestcentreorg
Join this week's 30-min briefing: 'Russia’s shrinking leverage in Armenia'
9 April | 16:00 CET (10:00 EST)
@Tom_deWaal joins @eglod_katia to unpack how Moscow is responding as Yerevan shifts towards the EU & US.
🔗 Register: zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_SYcxo6UHRDyrm-OeRxxigQ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Many months in the making and a true collaboration on Armenia, Azerbaijan, TRIPP and the prospects for peace and success.
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🆕 | The U.S.-sponsored TRIPP deal is driving the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace process forward.
But several hurdles remain before connectivity and economic interdependence can open up the South Caucasus, argue @Tom_deWaal, @AregKochinyan, and @ZaurShiriyev: carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2026/03/rewiring-th… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Caucasian Journal
@CaucasianJourna
"The age of conflict has indeed passed."
@Tom_deWaal discusses the shifting sands of South Caucasus, from #tripp to #armenia POWs: www.caucasianjournal.org/2026/03/Thomas-de-Waal-age-of-co…
#southcaucasus #pashinyan #azerbaijan #geopolitics @Carnegie_Europe -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A reminder: this was the delusional thinking of the Russian patriotic elite four years ago. Ukraine would roll over, Putin would win a historic victory, Europe would be divided from the US. The reality was different but little to suggest the mindset of these people has changed.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 “The resolution of the Ukraine question.” A mistakenly published Russian article gives us a chilling insight into the neo-imperialist thinking in Russia that drives Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine. A (long) THREAD.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🎧 | While the rules-based order is imperfect, it is actually quite a robust system of agreements we've made, said @jessicadorsey on #europeinsideout.
Listen to her, @Tom_deWaal, & @RCsernatoni discuss how to make international law great again: europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/iseurope-ready-…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
The list of eight conflicts that Trump's "art of the deal" ended has many critics.
Some of the examples championed by the White House do not qualify as proper peace agreements, such as the deal done between Egypt & Ethiopia, notes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/12/tru… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
It's easy to be sniffy about Trump's "Art of the Deal" peace-making. Liberal peace is still the best variety, if rare. But Europe can still learn from Trump's willingness to shake things up and break the status quo. My piece just published. carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/12/tru…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
U.S. President Donald Trump's claims to have ended eight wars may be debatable, but his #peace efforts raise valid questions.
Europe can learn lessons from Washington on how to break the deadlock in protracted conflicts, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/12/tru… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🎧 | Is Britain Becoming More Like Europe?
In this new #europeinsideout episode, @Tom_deWaal, @PeterKellner1, and @annemcelvoy discuss the state of British politics and what it means for EU-UK relations.
Listen now 👉 europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/is-britain-beco… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexander Gabuev 陳寒士
@AlexGabuev
By negotiating directly with the Kremlin, the Trump administration has broken the taboo on diplomatic contacts with Russia. Is it time for Brussels to open its own communication channel to Moscow? Some thoughts for @Carnegie_Europe in a great company. carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/12/tak…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
❔| #ttp: Should Europe Negotiate with Russia?
By negotiating with the Kremlin, the Trump administration has broken the taboo on diplomacy with Russia.
With Ukrainian and European security at stake, is it time to talk to Moscow?
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/12/tak… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
The text of the peace agreement between Armenia & Azerbaijan was initialed, but not signed.
To complete the deal, Baku has a difficult demand: it says Yerevan must revise its constitution, and that will require a referendum, explains @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/11/arm… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Europe is in shock at the second Trump presidency, writes @StefanLehne for @Carnegie_Europe The EU knows it has to get its house in order but first it has to tackle its own strategic and internal weaknesses.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/11/can… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Foreign Affairs
@ForeignAffairs
The U.S.-brokered peace deal between Armenia and Azerbaijan “will succeed only if the United States follows through on implementing the Trump Route for International Peace and Prosperity,” argues @Tom_deWaal.
www.foreignaffairs.com/armenia/unlikely-road-peace-armeni… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just published, my piece on the U.S. #armenia-#azerbaijan deal and its prospects. There is a lot of hard work still to be done, I argue, but the shared coincidence of interests that neither country wants Russia as a guarantor has been transformative. www.foreignaffairs.com/armenia/unlikely-road-peace-south-…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I was very glad of the opportunity to have a substantial conversation with @neweasteurope on the Trump deal with #armenia and #azerbaijan and whether it can work out talkeasterneurope.eu/episodes/episode-235-behind-the-peac…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
@Tom_deWaal: "It was the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan who clearly wanted the US, not Russia, to be the guarantor of the transit road in the region. For various reasons, both sides have strained relations with Russia and reject its control"
jam-news.net/thomas-de-waal-peace-between-yerevan-and-bak… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On #georgia, its rapid descent into authoritarian rule and the EU's struggle (so far) to respond. My piece today for @Carnegie_Europe with some advice for Brussels: don't punish ordinary people by cancelling visa liberalization🇬🇪 carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/09/tim…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Since the 2024 election, Georgia's ruling party has rolled back democracy & sabotaged the country's EU accession process.
To avoid penalizing pro-European citizens, the EU should focus punitive measures on a small group in the elite, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/09/tim… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Vladislav Davidzon
@VladDavidzon
My dear pal @Tom_deWaal has just written a profile of the Odessa philharmonic and its charismatic conductor Hobart Earle for the FP. I wrote about the story of Odessan music at war for my Substack….
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My article on how the orchestra in #odesa#Odessa has played on through all the travails of wartime, and the story of its amazing American conductor, Hobart Earle, who has been with them since 1991.
In today’s FT magazine (sorry, behind a paywall). @ftmag www.ft.com/content/9dc64086-ce45-4a81-8ee0-97c20fe72abc -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Zaur Shiriyev
@ZaurShiriyev
1/3.The leaders of Azerbaijan and Armenia are meeting in Abu Dhabi tomorrow. It’s a direct talk with no third-party mediation, hosted by the UAE. This follows the logic of nearly two years of direct negotiations between the two sides. Now the leaders are following that approach.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
The Red Line - Podcast
@TheRedLinePod
THOMAS DE WAAL (@Tom_deWaal) of @Carnegie_Europe returns to the show to drill down on everything from Russia's proposed "Naval Base" at Ochamchire, to Adjara separatism, to the possibility of reopening the rail connections between Abkhazia and Georgia.
www.theredlinepodcast.com/post/abkhazia-client-or-catalyst -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
oc-media.org/azerbaijani-researcher-bahruz-samadov-senten… Outrageous news from Baku as young scholar and peace activist Bahruz Samadov is given a 15-year jail sentence for "treason." Sorry to say I'm told that the news is even worse: Bahruz tried to take his own life by hanging in his cell. He must be freed.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Here's an essay I wrote for my college magazine about how it took me 35 years to translate Mandelstam's Tristia, the joys and tribulations of poetry translation, and Osip M's amazing mysterious verse, which resonates anew with every generation. heyzine.com/flip-book/floreat-domus-2025
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Since 2022 Central and Eastern Europe has undergone a fundamental shift away from reliance on Russian gas. Will it last? Join Max Hess @zakavkaza, @SergeyVakulenkand me tomorrow for a Carnegie Europe webinar to discuss these issues. It will be insightful! carnegieendowment.org/events/2025/05/securing-energy-inde…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And if you haven't already, read Max's excellent deep dive into the European Russian gas issue here carnegieendowment.org/research/2025/04/how-eastern-europe…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Armenia's Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan thinks that relying on Russia has been a mistake & he wants to open up to the West, @Tom_deWaal said on #europeinsideout.
Listen to him, @RymMomtaz, & @GaroPaylan discuss how Armenia is shifting away from Russia: europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-turkeyand-a… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Please read, share and repost this brave piece of journalism by Will Neal @willneal93 on Georgia and the dealings and Russian connections of London-based Hunnewell Partners which owns Imedi TV amongst other assets and is a close partner of Georgian Dream.
bylinetimes.com/2025/03/31/moscows-ties-to-the-georgian-r…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This reporting has now resulted in Neal being denied re-entry into Georgia, the country he's lived in since 2022. A blow not just against Neal personally but against free speech and independent reporting on Georgia.
rsf.org/en/between-harassment-and-expulsion-georgia-bent-… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🎧 | Turkey & Armenia are divided by decades of unresolved tensions & a closed border.
In a new episode of #europeinsideout, @RymMomtaz, @Tom_deWaal, & @GaroPaylan discuss whether both countries can normalize their relations.
Listen now: europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-turkeyand-a… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Central and Eastern Europe have made a fundamental transition from reliance on Russian gas. Even if there is a halt to the war in Ukraine, there is no going back. Our latest analysis from Carnegie by @zakavkaza Max Hess carnegieendowment.org/research/2025/04/how-eastern-europe…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Podcast on state of play between #armenia and #azerbaijan. Good questions from Wilberforce Society in Cambridge!
open.spotify.com/episode/4rBfnllGX1TteJAqDz8DJQ?nd=1&dlsi… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My piece on the Armenia-Azerbaijan peace agreement -- a big step forward but a long way to go. carnegieendowment.org/emissary/2025/03/armenia-azerbaijan…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 A really positive step forward in #armenian-#azerbaijani peace talks… but we shouldn’t expect a signing ceremony and peace in our time soon.
Some inaccurate reporting out there, this looks to me objective and accurate oc-media.org/armenia-and-azerbaijan-agree-to-peace-deal/Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
5 The main stumbling block remains Baku’s insistence that Armenia change its constitution by removing the preamble which refers to Armenia’s 1990 Declaration of Independence, which makes a territorial claim over Nagorny #karabakh.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
6 The Armenian side says their Constitutional Court has already ruled that this is no longer valid, Baku rejects this.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 Ankara in particular should respond with positive steps towards Armenia – even if it feels unable to authorize a full opening of the border. Western actors, who have a strong interest in the connectivity agenda, should engage more actively here.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
9 Way too soon to call today historic but it is a good day for anyone who cares about Armenian-Azerbaijani peace. Today puts momentum behind diplomacy, not threats of force. Quite possibly the dangerous international environment around Ukraine made this possible. ENDS
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A really good conversation
Salome Zourabichvili
@Zourabichvili_S
Spotlight: Georgia #msc2025
x.com/i/broadcasts/1BdGYqlQWkMGX -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just arrived in Munich. Looking forward very much to moderating this important conversation on 🇬🇪later with President @Zourabichvili_S
Katie Shoshiashvili
@KShoshiashvili
Watch an in-depth conversation on Georgia 🇬🇪 at #msc2025 (17.30 – 18.15 Munich time) as President @Zourabichvili_S addresses @Tom_deWaal’s questions.
securityconference.org/en/msc-2025/agenda/ -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Katie Shoshiashvili
@KShoshiashvili
Watch an in-depth conversation on Georgia 🇬🇪 at #msc2025 (17.30 – 18.15 Munich time) as President @Zourabichvili_S addresses @Tom_deWaal’s questions.
securityconference.org/en/msc-2025/agenda/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On #moldova's gas crisis, #transnistria and a crisis for which Chisinau should have been better prepared. My @Carnegie_Europe column today carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2025/01/mol…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Brilliant Economist article nails the misguided official Ukrainian campaign to cancel heritage in #odesa/#odessa www.economist.com/christmas-specials/2024/12/19/cancel-cu…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"The problem of decolonising Odessa is not that it is in any way pro-Russian—it... defended itself against invasion in 2022. The problem is that it was not a colony so much as a world city ahead of its time—a metropolis"
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Channel 4 News
@Channel4News
True scale of Assad’s slaughter revealed at Syrian mass grave
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Georgian Institute of Politics
@GIP_ge
#scenarios
Where does it end? Three possible outcomes of the political turmoil in #georgia 🇬🇪
We offer three potential scenarios and the implications of each of these hypothetical turns of events.
gip.ge/where-does-it-end-three-possible-outcomes-of-the-p… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Rikard Jozwiak
@RikardJozwiak
Debate among 🇪🇺 foreign ministers on 🇬🇪 over. As expected, 🇭🇺🇸🇰 block sanctions. European Commission will however propose visa lib suspension for 🇬🇪 diplomats, possibly as early as this week. there is a qualified majority for this.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
It should be obvious by now that #georgian democracy is under grave threat – all but a few individuals with cranky agendas can now see that clearly. 🇬🇪
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This from Lincoln Mitchell, long-time Georgia watcher, a key outside supporter of the 2003 Rose Revolution and then of Georgian Dream in 2012. What’s more: “a victory for the Georgian people can be a model for a victory for democracy here in the US.”
lincolnmitchell.substack.com/p/americans-should-be-inspir… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Rapporteur
@rapporteur_news
🎙️Today in the EU, ep. 196
Host @giada_santana and Carnegie's @Tom_deWaal discuss Georgia's apparent shift towards Russia as Georgia is set to elect the country's next president this Saturday (14 December). What can the EU do to respond?
Listen here: eurac.tv/9XEa -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Few will remember but I do...It's 30 years since the Russian military intervention in #chechnya on Dec 11, 1994, a Rubicon moment and a huge tragedy. Here's the reflective piece I wrote for @MoscowTimes a few years back. www.themoscowtimes.com/2019/12/10/chechnyas-awkard-annive…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Stray dogs have become a notable presence at the massive pro-European #tbilisiprotests . Protesters feed and care for them, while the dogs seem to have picked up on the tension, barking at police vehicles and officers.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The repression and state violence in Georgia is escalating. Mariam is co-founder of the leading independent media outlet @OCMediaorg
Mariam Nikuradze
@mari_nikuradze
Ok so update: criminal police summoned me, they called. I asked to be questioned in court in the presence of a judge. That will happen either tomorrow or the day after. Will keep you posted. Have lawyers and everything. Not fleeing the country, not hiding, will continue covering.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Dara Massicot
@MassDara
There are many rumors that Russia is evacuating its bases at Tartus and Khmeimim in Syria, but most assets remain there. If evacuation happens, it will be obvious. A brief thread on what is happening now and what future moves would look like. 🧵
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Maximilian Hess
@zakavkaza
Join @Tom_deWaal @nseskuria @natasabanadze in discussing Georgia’s democratic and European crisis next week at @UCLSSEES www.eventbrite.com/e/georgias-post-election-crisis-challe…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
civil.ge/archives/638801 Jumping before they were pushed? Georgian Dream rejects EU, sets out its own paradigm of what "European" means.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
engelsbergideas.com/essays/will-georgias-geopolitical-hed… As I said here it is Orban's model: "EU accession for Georgia, Moldova, Ukraine and the countries of the western Balkans is seen as a two-sided give-and-take bargaining process, not a one-way transfer of EU norms." But now taken one step further.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Kornely Kakachia
@k_kakachia
Georgia is a unique country in many respects—where one might fail to secure the presidency of the football federation yet still manage to become the president of the entire nation. A bittersweet irony, indeed.civil.ge/archives/638373
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Politika на русском
@CarnegieRu
Четыре дня протестов в центре Сухуми привели к отставке президента и объявлению досрочных выборов. @Olesya_vArt рассуждает о том, как закончится политический кризис в Абхазии и чем он отличается от предыдущих: storage.googleapis.com/crng/russia-abkhazia-relationships…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Endowment
@CarnegieEndow
Is the "axis of enemies" narrative oversimplified?
Russia, China, Iran, & North Korea share adversaries, but their interests are only aligned—not merged. Misinterpreting them as a unified coalition could harm U.S. foreign policy, argues Eugene Rumer ⬇️
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/11/the-united-states-… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Grigor Atanesian
@atanessi
The Khojaly massacre represents the single biggest loss of civilian life in the Karabakh wars. This was established by two contemporary reports by Memorial and HRW. To deny it is wrong, has nothing to do with criticising the Azerbaijani government and doesn't help Armenia at all
Michael Rubin
@mrubin1971
Azerbaijan Treats the Khojaly Massacre as Original Sin, but Its Narrative Is Fiction www.meforum.org/mef-observer/azerbaijan-treats-the-khojal… #azerbaijan #armenia
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Engelsberg Ideas
@EngelsbergIdeas
The Georgian Dream party's retreat from democracy may eventually end up being a lose-lose strategy for the whole country.
Will Georgia’s geopolitical hedging pay off? | @Tom_deWaal
engelsbergideas.com/essays/will-georgias-geopolitical-hed… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just published with @EngelsbergIdeas - my piece on the aftermath of the 🇬🇪 #georgia election and Georgian Dream’s gambit to join the global illiberal multipolar club. engelsbergideas.com/essays/will-georgias-geopolitical-hed…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Exactly
Alexander Thatcher
@ThatchEffendi
Luckily nothing happened between 1490 and 1991, and especially nothing happened around 1863.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Worth reading people on Abkhazia who actually know the place and its history such as Neil
Neil Hauer
@NeilPHauer
4k likes for this thread that leaves out 200 years of history and reduces the Georgian-Abkhaz conflict to 'Russia did it.' News flash: the Abkhaz are real people with real agency and grievances. Writing an article on the situation in Abkhazia this weekend for exactly this reason.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
writer.org/event/people-and-trees/ This is a landmark publication, the first English translation of the most famous novel by Azerbaijan's most distinguished writer, Akram Aylisli. I'm so pleased that I will be in DC next Thursday to help launch it with the wonderful @KEYoung_Poet
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Pjotr Sauer
@PjotrSauer
A political crisis is brewing in the Hague. Nora Achahbar, the Moroccan-born Secretary for Benefits from the ruling centre-right NSC party resigned this morning in response to alleged racist remarks made during a closed-door government meeting following the turmoil in Amsterdam
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Security concerns are increasingly informing the economic & foreign policy decisions of the #southcaucasus countries.
At last week's event @Tom_deWaal, @AkhvledianiTina, @jodylaporte1, & @LaurenceBroers discussed this evolution & the stakes for Europe 👇
carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/10/navigating-the-geoec… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Dara Massicot
@MassDara
I've returned from a research trip to Ukraine, where I met many people in Kyiv and along the frontlines. They are brave and kind in ways that words fail to capture. The situation is serious and urgent for many reasons. I share my thoughts in the thread below. /1
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
With the amazing @BayramovaZhala in St James Park (and two pelicans!) before she went to a meeting in parliament. Zhala’s tireless work with her siblings to get her father medical treatment and be freed and to speak up for human rights in Azerbaijan is an inspiration #freegubad!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Becoming a transformative actor on the international stage has always been Orbán's political aim.
His ambition to thrust Hungary to the heart of European—even global—decisionmaking is crucial to his illiberal & populist agenda, argues @ZSzelenyi.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2024/11/orb… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A great discussion last week on the state of the South Caucasus, with particular reference to geo-economics
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
📽️ | Russia's war on Ukraine has reshaped the geopolitical & economic landscape in the South Caucasus.
Last week, @Tom_deWaal, @AkhvledianiTina, @jodylaporte1, & @LaurenceBroers discussed the trends in Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Georgia.
(Re)watch here 👇
carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/10/navigating-the-geoec… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Imagine if in 1942 a U.S. politician mocked Churchill for depending on his American "allowance..."
The Kyiv Independent
@KyivIndependent
⚡️Trump Jr mocks Zelensky, Ukraine in meme about losing 'allowance'.
Donald Trump Jr. reposted an Instagram clip featuring an image of Zelensky with the caption: "POV: You're 38 days from losing your allowance."
kyivindependent.com/trump-jr-mocks-zelensky-ukraine-in-me… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🗓️ | TODAY
The geopolitical & economic profile of the South Caucasus is changing.
At 5pm CET, @Tom_deWaal, @AkhvledianiTina, @jodylaporte1, & @LaurenceBroers will look at how these shifts are impacting the region's relations with Russia & the EU.
Join👇 carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/10/navigating-the-geoec… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/10/navigating-the-geoec…… Join @AkhvledianiTina
@jodylaporte1 @LaurenceBroers and myself later today to discuss the situation in the South Caucasus! -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Georgia's move toward the EU is demand-driven in society.
Recent polling suggests that Georgians trust the EU more than they do any domestic institution; by contrast, Russia and China come at the bottom of the list, explains @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2024/10/geo… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
OC Media
@OCMediaorg
Greta Thunberg speaks to OC Media about COP29 at a protest against the Georgian election results in Tbilisi.
▶️ Georgia election live updates: oc-media.org/live-updates-georgian-opposition-gears-up-fo…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
#azerbaijan is investing in renewable energy while staying committed to hydrocarbon production.
This strategy creates opportunities for Europe to push for transparency in 🇦🇿's #energy sector & openness in its political institutions.
New by @jodylaporte1
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/10/bakus-balancing-ac… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As #azerbaijan gets ready to host #cop29, read the brilliant paper by@jodylaporte1 published today by @Carnegie_Europe on the country’s political economy and the struggles Azerbaijan faces to transition from its exclusive reliance on hydrocarbons.
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/10/bakus-balancing-ac… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
www.reuters.com/world/us/us-pollster-edison-says-georgia-… Two US polling firms say more on why they believe their big exit polls, which estimated support for Georgian Dream at 10 %+ lower than the official results, were accurate. They suggested that GD should have lost the election to the combined opposition
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7 years. A shame and travesty of justice
Emma Sinclair-Webb
@esinclairwebb
Human rights defender Osman Kavala Marks 7 Years Behind Bars - joint statement by @hrw @TR_Litigation @ICJ_org with third-party intervention to the European Court of Human Rights on Kavala (2) v. Türkiye www.hrw.org/news/2024/11/01/turkiye-osman-kavala-marks-7-…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My column today for @Carnegie_Europe on #georgia 🇬🇪 and the challenges the EU faces to help manage a very dangerous situation. carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2024/10/geo…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Viktor Orban has arrived in #georgia 🇬🇪 to congratulate Georgian Dream, spiting the rest of the EU. GD's relations with Russia are hidden, a matter of conjecture, its relationship with Orban Hungary, its Illiberal Idol, is strong, public and critical...
Formula NEWS | English
@FormulaGe
Footage shows Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban leaving his hotel in Tbilisi, near the Georgian parliament where tens of thousands gather right now to protest election rigging, as he was met with loud boos from the crowd on his way to his escort.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Here's a really informative podcast from last week on the Georgia-Hungary relationship with @natasabanadze @peterkreko and @sonjaschiffers ge.boell.org/en/2024/10/24/georgias-hungarian-path-contin…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And here's my piece from last year on the "Orbanizing of Georgia" carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2023/08/the…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
critical as in crucial!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Olesya Vartanyan
@Olesya_vArt
1/ My two cents on the shameful blame game against ethnic minorities in Georgia's recent elections. Yes, the GD support percentages in Javakheti is disheartening and lacks trust. But let’s take a closer look for a reality check. #gvote2024
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Charles Michel
@CharlesMichel
Following the parliamentary elections in Georgia, I intend to put Georgia on the agenda of the informal #euco in Budapest.
We note the OSCE/ODIHR preliminary assessment and call on the Central Election Commission and other relevant authorities to fulfil their duty to swiftly, transparently and independently investigate and adjudicate electoral irregularities and allegations thereof.
These alleged irregularities must be seriously clarified and addressed.
We reiterate the EU’s call to the Georgian leadership to demonstrate its firm commitment to the country’s EU path, also in line with EUCO June and October conclusions.
Constructive and inclusive dialogue across the political spectrum is now paramount.
The November EUCO will assess the situation and set the next steps in our relations with Georgia. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
They want us to believe we are entering the age of Orban
Civil.ge
@CivilGe
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban will arrive in Tbilisi tomorrow for an official visit, the Georgian government administration reported. The visit will last for two days, Oct. 28-29. PM Orban will be accompanied by a delegation of Hungarian ministers and officials.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Different Georgias. Even according to the disputed official results, Tbilisi voted gave more than half its votes to the opposition. Also Rustavi and Kutaisi. Rural and minority areas went to GD. Useful map from @CivilGe civil.ge/archives/631336 #georgianelections2024
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🗳️ | Today, #georgia holds a high-stakes parliamentary election.
In the latest episode of #europeinsideout, @natasabanadze and @Tom_deWaal discussed "the good, the bad and the ugly" scenarios that may unfold in 🇬🇪 after the vote.
Listen and subscribe 👉 europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-georgia-sta… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
An important day for Georgia 🇬🇪
Kornely Kakachia
@k_kakachia
Contributed to an Al Jazeera explainer on the Georgia elections alongside @Tom_deWaal www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/10/26/a-nation-torn-between-r…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 A lot of negative comments on this article on #odesa by Lord Glasman, who is working tirelessly for Ukraine. The headline is over the top and of course Russian is still spoken everywhere on the streets of the city
www.newstatesman.com/world/europe/ukraine/2024/10/silent-…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3 I was honoured to sign this letter calling for a pause on the monuments issue with 100+ writers, scholars, historians, musicians, artists associated with the city and living in it, including several who have served in the Ukrainian armed forces.
docs.google.com/document/d/1el6lTKRqUPdFCFSdx4J3K2oOvVUwE…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 And I just published this with @prospect_uk on what a misguided muddle this is. It’s a huge own-goal for the Ukrainian authorities, which can still be halted.
www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/world/europe/ukraine/68347/ode… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
What is going on in #odesa
Prospect
@prospect_uk
The Ukrainian port city Odesa, which has bravely resisted Putin’s invasion, has a rich Russian-language cultural heritage. The government is wrong to try to cancel it, writes @Tom_deWaal.
www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/world/europe/ukraine/68347/ode… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Prospect
@prospect_uk
The Ukrainian port city Odesa, which has bravely resisted Putin’s invasion, has a rich Russian-language cultural heritage. The government is wrong to try to cancel it, writes @Tom_deWaal.
www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/world/europe/ukraine/68347/ode… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 My piece for @prospect_uk on the misguided decrees that seek to erase monuments associated with Russian-language culture in Odesa, from Babel to Pushkin.
www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/world/europe/ukraine/68347/ode…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3 Here is the open letter to UNESCO if you haven’t seen yet.
docs.google.com/document/d/1el6lTKRqUPdFCFSdx4J3K2oOvVUwE…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 An honour to stand with a distinguished group that includes @ilya_poet @VladDavidzon @Sapritsky_Nahum @Clarkstopher Hobart Earle, Andrei Malaev-Babel, Neal Ascherson, my brother Edmund (of course) and many many more.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
www.ft.com/content/8f9add86-863d-4d60-adfa-bc82382ed20d A really good summary of what is at stake in 🇬🇪 #georgia ahead of tomorrow's election. Glad to be quoted.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
John Simpson
@JohnSimpsonNews
It takes a lot of courage to face Vladimir Putin and put the important, tough questions about the invasion of Ukraine to him. Steve Rosenberg was magnificent, I thought — the BBC at its best.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/videos/c9vn8z2wwy9o -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
In #georgia, there are almost no independent institutions while state resources are concentrated in the hands of the ruling party, said @natasabanadze.
Ahead of tomorrow's parliamentary election, listen to her and @Tom_deWaal on #europeinsideout: europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-georgia-sta… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Only two days till the crucial parliamentary election in #georgia🇬🇪 ! Re-sharing some thoughts on what is at stake and the strategy of the Georgian Dream ruling party
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1. A thread on 🇬🇪 and what's behind Georgian Dream's anti-Western pivot. In the NYT today @joshuakucera sets out some geopolitical factors: war in Ukraine, China, the failure of West to leave a big economic footprint in Georgia--reasons to hedge bets.
www.nytimes.com/2024/10/23/opinion/georgia-election-europ… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1. A thread on 🇬🇪 and what's behind Georgian Dream's anti-Western pivot. In the NYT today @joshuakucera sets out some geopolitical factors: war in Ukraine, China, the failure of West to leave a big economic footprint in Georgia--reasons to hedge bets.
www.nytimes.com/2024/10/23/opinion/georgia-election-europ…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
6. If Georgia’s current malady is an out-of-control paranoid party of power that will do anything to stay in power, its “pre-existing” condition is polarization and winner-takes-all politics. That's been the case since Gamsakhurdia in the early 1990s.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7 Here’s the piece Archil Gegeshidze and I wrote in 2021 about polarization and Georgia’s political culture, in which the epithets “traitor” and “enemy” are still basic currency.
carnegieendowment.org/research/2021/12/divided-georgia-a-…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
11 PS if you were waiting for me to say that Bidzina is Russia’s agent or GD is a Russian plot you came to the wrong commentator... As I’ve said before, they are appeasing Russia, but see no reason in being owned or run by Russia and that’s an important distinction.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🇲🇩 | Moldova Won the Battle, Not the War
Despite Russia's hybrid attacks, Moldova voted in favor of joining the EU.
Brussels must now supercharge its support for the country's resilience & accession efforts, writes @OanaPope.
Read on #strategiceurope ➡️ carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2024/10/mol… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Anna A. Naghdalyan
@naghdalyan
The Armenian National Opera and Ballet Theatre building ahead of the jubilee evening dedicated to the 100th anniversary of Sergey Parajanov.
#yerevan -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Matthew Luxmoore
@mjluxmoore
Chatting to Moldovan voters in several towns this weekend, almost all were for the EU but many opposed amending the constitution as part of what they considered a political move by Sandu. Wouldn’t be so quick to conclude that the country is split on the core issue of EU support.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 A close call in #moldova on the referendum and first round of the pres. election reveals the country’s problems, current and structural: historic polarization, vulnerability to influence of oligarchs and Moscow, poverty, demographic crisis.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c1wnr5qdxe7oPost not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7 As my Carnegie colleague @SamorukovM wrote in his excellent new paper, whoever rules Moldova in the future, it has already moved a long way out of Russia’s orbit.
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/10/moldova-russia-str…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 Moldova is now entirely weaned off Russian gas and the economy is stabilizing. The only way Russia could effect a full takeover of the country is by taking Odesa—which is highly unlikely, thank God. But the latest news is a strong warning against complacency. ENDS
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Another day, another Georgia 🇬🇪 podcast. This time from the terrific @josephine_dash on how artists and cultural figures are fighting back against the purge of the cultural sector and to defend democracy. I was glad to contribute some context! www.dasharts.org.uk/podcast-1/georgias-art-of-protest
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
William Hill, scholar and former diplomat, knows #moldova better than anyone else in the West so this is an essential read www.foreignaffairs.com/moldova/russia-playing-long-game-m…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
On October 26, #georgia will hold a critical election, with the ruling Georgian Dream party determined to stay in power at all costs.
On #europeinsideout, @Tom_deWaal & @natasabanadze discussed possible outcomes & what they mean for 🇬🇪's EU membership: europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-georgia-sta… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Maksim's long-awaited, deeply researched article on Russia and #moldova. Well worth your time!
Maksim Samorukov
@SamorukovM
Russia’s meddling in Moldova is in the open. Still, Kremlin aims not so much at bringing its proxies to power, but at fueling Moldova’s divisions so as to keep the country in geopolitical limbo. My attempt to decipher Moscow’s logic in Moldova (1/5)
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/10/moldova-russia-str… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
What is at stake in #georgia's forthcoming election? What are the risks to 🇬🇪's democracy and EU aspirations if the Georgian Dream wins a majority?
@Tom_deWaal & @natasabanadze unpack it all in the latest episode of #europeinsideout.
Listen & subscribe👇
europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-georgia-sta… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
Some people believe that a Hungarian agency is actually working with GD for their negative campaigning, and from the imagery that's not implausible.
László Róbert Mézes
@LaszloRobMezes
Comparison between new GD banners and the banners of the Fidesz of Orbán from this spring.
On the left: “The slaves of Brussels” “migration” “gender” “war”, President von der Leyen with major opposition politicians. On the right “they bought them” “another dollar-left politician” -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Ahead of the crucial election in Georgia 🇬🇪 on October 26, I spoke to the brilliant @natasabanadze of Chatham House for our Carnegie podcast #europeinsideout. Listen here europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/can-georgia-sta…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
An authoritative deep dive by @AkhvledianiTina into the economies of Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan and their relations and trade with the EU. War in Ukraine has reshaped incentives and boosted trade with Russia. Is Brussels ready to do more? carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/10/the-eu-and-the-sou…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Part of our #europeseast project at @carnegie_europe carnegieendowment.org/projects/europes-east?lang=en¢e…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Today is the anniversary of the day Azerbaijan launched its fateful military operation against Karabakh. My thoughts for @Carnegie_Europe on what are the prospects for a negotiated ARM-AZ peace. carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2024/09/arm…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Gareth Ward
@GarethWardUK
Great news that @British_Airways will start direct flights on the London 🇬🇧 Tbilisi 🇬🇪 route from next year! Hope to see lots more business and tourist travel in both directions… mediacentre.britishairways.com/pressrelease/details/20807
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Hoping fervently that Gubad gets to celebrate his next birthday with his kids in freedom
Emin #FreeGubad
@EminBayramli_
Happy Birthday Dad
Happy Birthday Dr. Gubad Ibadoghlu -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Crisis Group
@CrisisGroup
We are hiring a Senior Analyst, South Caucasus!
📍 Based in the region.
Learn more and apply here ⬇️
jobs.crisisgroup.org/o/senior-analyst-south-caucasus-arme… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Lasha is a great champion of Georgian literature, of tolerance and cooperation, and one of the most thoughtful writers on Georgia's 20th century history and Stalinism. His independence meant he was always in danger of losing his job. Now that sad day has finally come.
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
missed that in this busy day -- the great Lasha Bakradze, whom I am lucky to call a friend, has just been dismissed from his position as the Director of the Georgian Literature Archive.
He has done great work, making the case for the #literature of #georgia as attested also by him regularly being featured & quoted, also by @MayaJaggi (her Georgia article pinned to top of her profile), @NadiaWBeard, publishing w @Tom_deWaal, in @faznet & many more places.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Read the magnificent essay he wrote for us in 2013 on Stalin's legacy to judge for yourself what a worthy figure he was and is to be in charge of the Georgian Literary Archive carnegieendowment.org/research/2013/03/the-stalin-puzzle-…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
missed that in this busy day -- the great Lasha Bakradze, whom I am lucky to call a friend, has just been dismissed from his position as the Director of the Georgian Literature Archive.
He has done great work, making the case for the #literature of #georgia as attested also by him regularly being featured & quoted, also by @MayaJaggi (her Georgia article pinned to top of her profile), @NadiaWBeard, publishing w @Tom_deWaal, in @faznet & many more places. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
For years, Putin has repeated that Russia's conflicts with its neighbors are proxy battles in an existential war with the West.
This narrative validates his agenda that he protects 🇷🇺 from losing the war & saves the state from collapse, says @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/the-end-of-the-nea… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Andrew Roth
@Andrew__Roth
Evan on hundreds of political prisoners who are still being kept in Russia
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Free at last! Anyone who’s dealt with Russia over the years will see a name of someone whose freedom makes them especially glad. In my case it’s the formidable human rights defender and great human being Oleg Orlov.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
what a find -- letter of Bidzina Ivanishvili to Hilary Clinton, 2012:
"A modern civil society has been a cherished goal of the Georgian people since we regained our independence twenty years ago. Unfortunately, old habits are hard to overcome. Our nation is still..." -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hov Nazaretyan
@HovhanNaz
🇷🇺🇦🇲 Russian border guards officially withdrew from Yerevan's Zvartnots airport t.me/armeniasputnik/68947
Hov Nazaretyan
@HovhanNaz
Pashinyan says Russian border guards will leave Yerevan's Zvartnots airport by August 1 t.me/azatutyuntv/18896
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
It’s now one year since the economist, scholar and public activist Gubad Ibadoglu was arrested in Azerbaijan on patently false charges. He is now out of jail and under house arrest but still faces very serious charges. Read what his children have to say
www.justsecurity.org/97937/azerbaijan-arbitrary-detention…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Gubad. is not the only one – there have been at least 18 arrests of civic activists and journalists in the past year. With COP-29 not far away, it’s time to do the right thing and set them free.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Jennifer Eremeeva
@JWEremeeva
Hey @TheRestHistory! @Holland_Tom
& @DCSandbrook
I love your WWI series! I wanted to offer you some historical context on "Russian salad," which you mentioned in the series. It is, indeed, beyond awful today, but it wasn't always!! And it isn't French! 🧵 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
#armenia's relationship with #russia is increasingly fraught, but Yerevan still depends on Moscow for energy and trade.
Meanwhile, the West offers increased political and economic support, but mostly for the long term, writes @Tom_deWaal.
Read more ⬇️
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/07/armenia-navigates-… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is fantastic news. She brings such depth wisdom and experience to the role. The EU chose the right person!
Czech Permanent Representation to the EU
@CZtoEU_Brussels
Political and Security Committee #psc just confirmed the appointment of Magdalena Grono 🇨🇿 as 🇪🇺 Special Representative for the South Caucasus and Georgia 🇬🇪. The nomination will be formally confirmed by the Council of the EU.
Big congratulations & best of luck in the new role!👏 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Pjotr Sauer
@PjotrSauer
Every July 17, I make sure to read @NoahSneider gut-wrenching poem about MH17. 10 years today…
www.noahsneider.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/cloudsthey… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Khinkali, khachapuri and pkhali making demonstrations in London this weekend. Plus Georgian wine tasting. 🇬🇪 cuisine conquers the UK!
foodfestival.natgeotraveller.co.uk/whats-on/2024-festival… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Richard Youngs
@YoungsRichard
The EU faces a 'democracy catch-22', magnified by the far-right challenge. My new article suggests a way to approach this that goes beyond the standard engage-versus-isolate binary. @eudemocracyhub @Carnegie_Europe
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/07/europes-democracy-… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
another wild story that did not make it into English-language media. Otar Partskhaladze now has added "Romanov" to his name, claiming some kind of linkage to Russian royal family.
Former chief prosecutor, key person for lots of dark things...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=hdgXNLe29PE&list=PLuUmjNe7Vz20nC-… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Moving thread about the extraordinary Natasha Estemirova
Tom Parfitt
@parfitt_tom
Today is fifteen years since the Chechen human rights activist Natasha Estemirova was assassinated in Russia’s North Caucasus region.
She was an incredible, inspiring person and is not forgotten.
A few words about her in this thread. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 My new paper on the breakdown of Armenia’s relations with Russia is part of a series with Carnegie colleagues on Europe’s “in-between stares” we have named “Europe’s Arc of Instability” #arcofinstability
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/07/armenia-navigates-…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 And in this podcast with @alexgabuev and @RosaBalfour we discuss the dilemmas the non-aligned countries are facing and the prospects for EU accession
carnegieendowment.org/podcasts/carnegie-politika-podcast?…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
5 Watch this space for Maxim’s forthcoming paper on Moldova!
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just out: my long paper on the breakdown of Armenia’s 🇦🇲relationship with Russia, it’s continuing dependencies and connections, especially in the economic and energy sphere — and what lies ahead carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/07/armenia-navigates-…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I’m emphatically with this group of esteemed experts making eloquent and important points about the deadly consequences a call for “negotiations” with Russia means in reality for Ukraine - and the rest of us.
Only small quibble
Ian Bond
@CER_IanBond
I'm pleased to be among the signatories to this response to the proposal by Lord Skidelsky & others for the West to push Ukraine to accept 'peace' on Russia's terms: www.ft.com/content/52ef3e3e-292c-44d3-80bd-97793487e715?a…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
is the phrase “since 1992” — as I’ve set out in recent work Russia’s 1990s “near abroad” policy had many problems but was very different from what followed by Putin from the mid 2000s. carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/the-end-of-the-nea…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As a de Waal I’m one of these
Soner Cagaptay
@SonerCagaptay
And from "walhaz" (Germanic for stranger/Roman):
Gallia (Roman France)
Wallachia (Romania)
Vlachs (Balkans)
Wales (UK)
Wallonia (Belgium) -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Another door on the past is slammed shut as what was once Russia’s finest paper, my former employer and Alma Mater in journalism, is finally outlawed
The Moscow Times
@MoscowTimes
⚡⚡ Russia has named The Moscow Times an "undesirable" organization, Russian news agencies report.
The label bans MT from operating in Russia and puts anyone affiliated with it at risk of criminal prosecution. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ Today marks 30 years since Alexander Lukashenko was first elected in Belarus. He then abolished term limits and gutted democracy. No one should be in power that long. Since then all other political voices in Belarus have been repressed or exiled.
novayagazeta.eu/articles/2024/07/10/europes-lasting-dicta…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
2/ The right day to draw attention to this important paper by two of my Carnegie Democracy colleagues on causes of democratic backsliding round the world. Lukashenko’s capture of a nascent democracy was an early harbinger of the trend . muse.jhu.edu/article/930425
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Tom Carothers and Brendan Hartnett take 12 case studies of “democratic backsliding” and caution against the idea that a failure to deliver on socio-economic well being is the main cause of democratic regression. For them the strength of democratic institutions is more important
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4/ In Poland, Bangladesh, Tunisia and of course the U.S undemocratic and illiberal leaders came to power via elections and without an explicit program to curtail democracy – but that is exactly what they did. Just like Belarus in 1994. One bad election can be enough…Beware!
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A great read from London’s best expert on the EU
Charles Grant
@CER_Grant
My open letter to @Keir_Starmer, in which I suggest ten ways in which he could help to forge a better and closer relationship with the EU. @CER_EU
www.cer.eu/sites/default/files/insight_CG_letter_K.Starme… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Civil.ge
@CivilGe
Georgia’s EU accession process has been stopped, the EU has frozen 30 million euros in assistance to Georgia, and further measures are being considered in case the situation in the country deteriorates further, 🇪🇺Ambassador to 🇬🇪Paweł Herczyński said. civil.ge/archives/615670
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Simon Schama
@simon_schama
Yesterday in France, Modi denied triumph, votes against Orban in EU elections, Ankara and Istanbul won by opposition to Erdogan ; Polish Law and Justice party defeated, - isnt it time for media pundits to rethink their tired scripts about inexorable nationalist populism?
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Robert Colvile
@rcolvile
Already seeing people saying 'we just need to reunite the Right, job done'. But I've been crunching the numbers and it's not quite that simple/encouraging. Quick thread (1/?)
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
After the political melodrama of the last 8 years hoping for five years of quiet competence
John Kampfner
@johnkampfner
Of all the lines in Starmer's lectern speech, the one that strikes most is a promise 'to end the era of noisy performance'. Is Britain ready for a political and media culture that is sensible and grown-up? It would mark a dramatic change. Let's hope it is
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Nicholas Shakespeare
@dolphinsands
Fry is right. Brexit ruined Britain, the Conservative Party, our sense of humour, our relations with our closest neighbours, our sense of optimism, our confidence, our culture, our finances, our sense of nationality, our place in the world - basically everything really.
Martin Davies 🇬🇧 🇫🇷 🇪🇺 🇨🇦
@martindvz
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Stanfords
@StanfordsTravel
A brilliant evening with two brilliant authors 👏 Thank you @parfitt_tom and @Tom_deWaal for such an insightful and fascinating talk! No better way to celebrate 'High Caucasus' paperback, out today!
Signed copies available✍️www.stanfords.co.uk/high-caucasus-a-mountain-quest-in-rus… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A great evening of Caucasus talk, reminiscences and predictions
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Trevor Warner
@trevorw1953
“Be careful, when a democracy is sick, fascism comes to its bedside, but it is not to inquire about its health.”
Albert Camus
#frenchelections -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Susie Dent
@susie_dent
Word of the day is 'ultra-crepidate' (19th century): to comment at length on a subject you know virtually nothing about.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
William Dunbar
@undrawbill
Georgian “leftist” running for George Galloway’s pro-Russian party in my neighbourhood. Anyone know him?
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Very sad news
I’ve never been to Albania but I feel as if I have, having read Kadare’s novels. Poetry, folklore, history and devastating political satire, all combined in one writer. What a unique voice.
www.theguardian.com/books/article/2024/jul/01/ismail-kada… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Centre for European Reform (CER)
@CER_EU
JOIN US - 3 July - @CER_EU/ @Carnegie_Europe hybrid discussion on 'The end of the near abroad', London/Zoom
Speakers: Anna Matveeva @KingsCollegeLon and @Tom_deWaal
Chair: @CER_IanBond
Email conference@cer.eu for more info and registration -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Watch Iberia vs Iberia in Iberia
Max Fras
@maxfras
No better place to watch 🇪🇸🇬🇪
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"The European Council calls on Georgia’s authorities to clarify their intentions by reversing the current course of action which jeopardises Georgia’s EU path, de facto leading to a halt of the accession process." #georgia 🇬🇪 www.eeas.europa.eu/delegations/georgia/extracts-georgia-c…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
If you are in London next Wednesday, come and join us. Otherwise tune in online!
Centre for European Reform (CER)
@CER_EU
JOIN US - 3 July - @CER_EU/ @Carnegie_Europe hybrid discussion on 'The end of the near abroad', London/Zoom
Speakers: Anna Matveeva @KingsCollegeLon and @Tom_deWaal
Chair: @CER_IanBond
Email conference@cer.eu for more info and registration -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On Russia's "niche" in #bosnia. Its problems weren't caused by Russia but its dysfunction, esp. the powers used and abused by Republika Srpska, provides Russia with opportunities to cause trouble. @DimitarBechev 's paper in our "Arc of Instability" series carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/06/bosnia-between-rus…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
90 percent of my Twitter feed is still Georgians celebrating their incredible football victory last night, and I don’t mind 🇬🇪
Georgian Footy
@GeorgianFooty
🇬🇪⚽️THE GREATEST NIGHT IN THE HISTORY OF GEORGIAN FOOTBALL
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Will Downing
@WillDowningComm
Now. You’re probably wondering how that sounded in Georgian. Well…. #geopor
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Mariam Nikuradze
@mari_nikuradze
People really needed something positive here in Georgia, more celebratioons from streets now!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Across Georgia, in bars, pubs, and parks, tens of thousands of fans are cheering for their national team. The match against Portugal is underway, and Georgia is leading 2-0.
This video is from the Mikheil Meskhi Stadium in Tbilisi, capturing the moment when Georges Mikautadze scored the second goal. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
people can't believe it. Game barely started and a goal! #georgia
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Stanfords
@StanfordsTravel
Only a few tickets left for @parfitt_tom in conversation with @Tom_deWaal Event! We highly recommend you check -it out. Not every day, you get to hear from two preeminent experts on the Caucasus region. The talk ought to be one for the books!
🎟️www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/tom-parfitt-and-tom-de-waal-in-con… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Nikolaus von Twickel 🇪🇺
@niktwick
In which @Tom_deWaal points out that traditionally pro-Western Georgia 🇬🇪 now has a pro-Russian government while Armenia 🇦🇲 is vice versa. Should they swap governments? @CarnegieRussia
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
European External Action Service - EEAS 🇪🇺
@eu_eeas
“The door for Georgia to become member of the EU is open. But if the government continues on the same track, this door will be closed. The government has to listen to the Georgian people and support their EU aspirations", said HR/VP @JosepBorrellF ahead of today’s #fac.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Along #russia's borders, countries are undergoing societal and political shifts as they stake out greater independence from Moscow.
But that does not mean that they are turning toward the West, nor toward #democracy, says @Tom_deWaal.
Learn more ⬇️
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/the-end-of-the-nea… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/06/between-russia-and-t… Come join me, @SamorukovM and @Anja_WS in Berlin on Tuesday to talk #armenia, #moldova, Russia and the EU.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And read our joint paper on the "Arc of Instability" and how countries that are neighbours of both Russia and the EU have been navigating their way since 2022 carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/bosnia-moldova-arm…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Robert Parsons
@RobParsonsF24
Have just arrived in Tbilisi. 35° during the day & 200,000 people in a city of 1 mn without water following landslide in Aragvi gorge. Instead of creating entirely artificial probems over NGO transparency, why does the govt not focus its attention on more existential problems?
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
This is the main topic in #tbilisi right now. Many restaurants can't serve main courses, as they can't run dishwashers.
(Wouldn't it be great to have a government that actually fixes problems -- rather than creating one after another?) -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tom Parfitt
@parfitt_tom
Elena Kostyuchenko (@mirrorsbreath) winning the @Pushkin_House Book Prize tonight. So deserved. Elena spoke movingly of giving voice to victims of the Ukraine war while fearing that "sometimes when we talk we add energy to this thing".
I was delighted to be on the shortlist. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Pushkin House
@Pushkin_House
Elena Kostyuchenko, journalist, writer and activist, has just won the Pushkin House Book Prize 2024 for "I Love Russia: Reporting from a Lost Country" (@TheBodleyHead). A huge congratulations to Elena!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
❓ | Is the EU's Agenda in Jeopardy?
A stronger far-right presence in the @Europarl_EN could impede some EU policies.
But the main test to the union's global role may come from the rise of nationalist politics in France and Germany.
Experts weigh in 👉
carnegieendowment.org/europe/strategic-europe/2024/06/jud… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I'm really delighted that Zaur, the best independent Azerbaijani expert, is joining Carnegie
Zaur Shiriyev
@ZaurShiriyev
I am thrilled to announce that starting today, I will be working as a non-resident scholar at the Carnegie Russia and Eurasia Center. I look forward to engaging with colleagues and contributing to the ongoing scholarly work related to the Caucasus and Central Asia.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Oliver Bullough
@OliverBullough
I like this thread and found myself wondering what I would do to help tackle corruption and financial crime (without costing too much money).
x.com/jamesrbuk/status/1800846035788722391 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
The EU faces myriad threats that constrain it as a global actor.
Tomorrow, @FedericaMog, Javier Solana, @RosaBalfour, @asazca, Cornelius Adebahr, @TaniaLatici, @B_Giegerich, & @SusMonika will discuss how the 🇪🇺 can meet foreign policy challenges.
Join ⤵️
carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/06/making-the-eu-a-stro… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I'm talking "the end of the Near Abroad" on Thursday at the @KingsRussia Institute in London. Come along! mailchi.mp/d0a817d2d041/z46vzl0kp6-16194930 And before you do read...
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
my long paper for @Carnegie_Europe and @IWM_Vienna on Russia's fraught and changing relations with its neighbours. Plenty to discuss! carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/the-end-of-the-nea…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The mind truly boggles at this panel on #moldova in St Petersburg llast week that included: Eurasian master-conspiracist Alexander Dugin and Moldovan businessman/politician (the man behind the $1bln banking theft) Ilan Shor, with the added bonus of...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xv8gGeAC45k
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
...Georgian ex-KGB general Igor Giorgadze (fled to Russia in 1995 after attempted assassination of Shevardnadze). Chaired by Russian/Transdniestrian Duma deputy Alina Arshinova. If someone can bear to listen and tell me what they said I would be grateful!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
The most popular video of the week on social media in Georgia features Mariam Shekelashvili, a village girl from the Lagodekhi district, performing an exceptionally artistic rendition of the famous dance once performed by the Georgian cinema legend Sofiko Chiaureli
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Laurent Vinatier only ever worked on peace and dialogue projects. His detention looks like a brazen act of hostage-taking by the Russian authorities.
Mike Eckel
@Mike_Eckel
Laurent Vinatier, a French national and adviser at the Center for Humanitarian Dialogue (a Swiss NGO), appears in a Moscow court today. Russia's Investigative Committee has accused him of collecting information on the Russian military (among other things).
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ Putin on the benefits of a North-South corridor via Azerbaijan to Iran. “I am aware that President Ilham Aliyev supports this project. We have spoken with him about that on many occasions. The leadership of Iran is also in support of this project.” azertag.az/en/xeber/president_vladimir_putin_relations_be…
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3 Roads are easy. What about rail? I got comments saying the most likely route is a new railway from Astara to Resht. I am sceptical TBH. It is 162km long through mountainous terrain. The cost will be astronomical. How will Iran and Russia, both heavily sanctioned, finance it?
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 That is why I put the emphasis on Russia’s interest in the so-called "Zangezur Corridor" via Armenia to join Iran’s existing railway to Nakhchivan. That route is only 43 km long. However Armenia needs to be coerced/persuading into accepting the Russian version of this.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
“The #georgian government aspires to join a club of countries that might be called the Eurasian chapter of Illiberalism International....Having hedged between Russia and the west since 2022, its members are now tilting more towards Moscow. @ftopinion" www.ft.com/content/80b6dea5-a905-41a4-b53a-d8b650dd99bc
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Richard Youngs
@YoungsRichard
As EU elections begin, with wave of commentary focused almost exclusively on far-right, my slightly different take on this test for European democracy. For @JoDemocracy @Carnegie_Europe @eudemocracyhub
www.journalofdemocracy.org/online-exclusive/why-the-europ… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
John Lichfield
@john_lichfield
On 6 June, 1944, Michel Pain, my neighbour in the Norman hills was 8 years old and living in Courseulles-sur-Mer, in the centre of Juno Beach. His granddad, Emil Lesaunier was killed by an allied shell before his eyes, one of 20,000 civilians to die in the Normandy campaign. 1/
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
📢 | How can the EU harness its foreign policy tools to become a more effective global actor?
Next Wednesday, @FedericaMog, Javier Solana, @RosaBalfour, @asazca, Cornelius Adebahr, @TaniaLatici,@B_Giegerich, & @SusMonika will discuss.
Register to join ➡️
carnegieendowment.org/events/2024/06/making-the-eu-a-stro… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
❗️🇬🇪 Georgia's ruling party has announced it will introduce a package of anti-LGBT bills in Parliament today.
The package includes the primary bill "On Family Values and Protection of Minors" and 18 amendments to existing legislation, including the Civil and Labor Codes. The bills frequently conflate LGBT issues with incest.
Parliament Speaker Shalva Papuashvili outlined the eight main issues addressed by the package:
⭕️ Reinforcement of the constitutional definition of marriage as a union between a man and a woman;
⭕️ Prohibition of child adoption by LGBT individuals;
⭕️ Ban on sex reassignment surgeries and related medical procedures;
⭕️ Requirement for documents to reflect only biological sex;
⭕️ Prohibition on airing content that could be seen as promoting same-sex relationships or incest;
⭕️ Ban on public gatherings and demonstrations intended to promote same-sex relationships or incest;
⭕️ Amendment to the Labor Code designating May 17 (marked internationally as the International Day Against Homophobia, Transphobia and Biphobia) as a holiday to honor the Day of Sanctity of the Family.
The ruling party, Georgian Dream, aims to pass the package in the first reading during the spring session (ending late in June) and continue in the fall.
The topic of LGBT rights is highly sensitive in Georgia. By raising it, the ruling party hopes to attract the conservative segment of the population ahead of the elections in October. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
glykosymoritis
Putin’s Hidden Game in the South Caucasus: Azerbaijan’s Rise, Georgia’s Drift, and Russia’s Quest for a Gateway to Iran and the Middle East www.foreignaffairs.com/azerbaijan/putins-hidden-game-sout… By @Tom_deWaal #putinism #geopolitics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My article on Russia and the South Caucasus for @ForeignAffairs. Lots to say but a big theme is this: because of the Ukraine war and sanctions “economic security in the South Caucasus—for now at least—is more important than the hard variety.” www.foreignaffairs.com/azerbaijan/putins-hidden-game-sout…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Georgian Institute of Politics
@GIP_ge
#expertcomments
📌 #georgiandream Party Reintroduces and Passes the Draft Law on #foreignagents: Why Now?
🔎 At the request of the Georgian Institute of Politics (GIP), a selection of experts from different countries responded to the questions ⬇️
gip.ge/publication-post/georgian-dream-party-reintroduces… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Dustin Gilbreath
@GilbreathDustin
Darn foreign agents and their dentistry programs.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🇷🇺 | Putin's official Russian state discourse is founded on a defensive posture that is fixated on the Kremlin's perceived enemies.
He is a statist and an exceptionalist—and both of these ideas resonate with the #russian public, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/the-end-of-the-nea… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Talking #georgia 🇬🇪 for the @lawfare Daily podcast. Lots to discuss
Lawfare
@lawfare
On today's Lawfare Daily, @annaehickey talked to @Tom_deWaal about the controversial foreign agent bill passed by the Georgian parliament, why it was so controversial, how the U.S. and European Union have reacted, and more. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily-georgia's-fore…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Now in German!
Zeitschrift OSTEUROPA
@ZOsteuropa
Profit, Paranoia, Protest: @Tom_deWaal über die Proteste in #georgien
(many thanks to @EngelsbergIdeas for permitting the German translation)
zeitschrift-osteuropa.de/blog/profit-paranoia-protest/ -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alex Raufoglu
@ralexdc
NEW! U.S. has a message to Georgian Dream:
"If you want to be in our community, including to benefit from things like where your kids go to school, then you have to start acting like a member of that community."
Amb O'Brien's briefing just ended. Here are some quotes
1/7 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Josep Borrell Fontelles
@JosepBorrellF
The Council of Europe @VeniceComm has strongly recommended Georgia to repeal the Law on Foreign Influence in its current form.
We call on the authorities to follow the recommendation in view of safeguarding the fundamental elements of Georgia's democracy. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Larry the Cat
@Number10cat
The last time the UK held a general election in July was in 1945. Labour gained 242 seats in a landslide...
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Paranoia, repression, autarky, sanctions-proofing, joining Europe’s Illiberal Club. But there is resistance.
ICYMI My take on Georgia’s dangerous moment for @EngelsbergIdeas
engelsbergideas.com/essays/georgian-nightmare/ -
Thomas de Waal reposted
ERSTE Foundation | @erstestiftung.org on Bluesky
@erstefoundation
"The war in Ukraine marks a historical juncture for more countries than just Ukraine and Russia", writes @Tom_deWaal (@EuropesFutures
Fellow 2022/23).
Read more about "The End of the Near Abroad": www.iwm.at/europes-futures/publication/the-end-of-the-nea…
@IWM_Vienna @Carnegie_Europe @IVejvoda -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
In #georgia, a mobilised citizenry is resisting a ruling party intent on eliminating all opposition & staying in power at all costs.
The October vote may be the best hope to end the crisis & give 🇬🇪 citizens a say, writes @Tom_deWaal for @EngelsbergIdeas.
engelsbergideas.com/essays/georgian-nightmare/ -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Marija Pejčinović Burić
@MarijaPBuric
I call upon 🇬🇪 authorities to implement our @coe @VeniceComm recommendations with a view of bringing the Law on Transparency of Foreign Influence in line with European standards @CoE stands ready to provide assistance @GeoMissionCoE1 www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-PI(2024)013-e
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Great discussion last night on how the string of countries, from Central Asia to South Caucasus to Moldova, watch Ukraine, Russia, and the West. the conclusions they draw. With the superb @AdeCar , and @herszenhorn
Georgia's crisis fits into this bigger picture. Watch here!
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
⏰ | STARTING NOW
#russia's war on Ukraine has ended Moscow's claim to be a security patron for its neighbors.
@Tom_deWaal, @AdeCar, and @herszenhorn are kicking off their debate on the political trajectory of countries in 🇷🇺's vicinity.
Follow live 👉 www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCjS3xJngBw -
Thomas de Waal reposted
IWM
@IWM_Vienna
New Europe's Futures Essay out now!
The Russo-Ukrainian War marks the end of the near abroad—the idea that Russia enjoys a special status in much of the post-Soviet space. But while Russia’s neighbors are seeking greater independence, they are not necessarily turning West.
A paper by @Tom_deWaal (@EuropesFutures Fellow 2022/23), published jointly by @Carnegie_Europe and the IWM:
www.iwm.at/europes-futures/publication/the-end-of-the-nea… @erstefoundation -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Rikard Jozwiak
@RikardJozwiak
The Venice Commission has just published its opinion on 🇬🇪 foreign agent law. the key conclusion: "strongly recommends repealing the Law in its current form"
read it all here:
www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/default.aspx?pdffil… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A long piece on Georgia 🇬🇪at a tipping point in its modern history. I try to look in depth at the economic aspect, which is key. I see GD as wanting a business partnership with Russia, not a political alignment, but the EU is an impediment to that.
engelsbergideas.com/essays/georgian-nightmare/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Coming up in just over an hour...
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Russia's 2022 invasion of #ukraine has changed Moscow's relations with its post-Soviet neighbors.
At 5pm CEST, @Tom_deWaal, @AdeCar, and @herszenhorn will unpack what the war means for countries in Eastern Europe, Central Asia, & the Caucasus.
Join us 👉 carnegieeurope.eu/events/2024/05/navigating-change-in-rus… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Important correction. NGOs deserve scrutiny like everyone else but this is probably Problem no.39 for Georgia 🇬🇪 behind a long list of the really urgent challenges to the country.
Tamar Qeburia
@tamunaseb
The Nation's new piece is problematic for many reasons, but I'd like to focus on one aspect: Rochowanski's claim about NGO job salaries in Georgia, citing figures as high as $60k–70k per year for senior leadership.
This is simply not accurate. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Formula NEWS | English
@FormulaGe
“I stood in this exact place with the Prime Minister of Georgia and then I clearly said that I consider this law to be a mistake and that it should not have been adopted. After this law was adopted, nothing has changed in my position,” German Chancellor, Olaf Scholz, said at a press conference.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
BREAKING: The President of Georgia has vetoed the "foreign agents" law.
"This law, in its essence and spirit, is Russian. It contradicts our Constitution and all European standards, posing an obstacle on our path to Europe," Salome Zourabichvili stated at a special briefing just moments ago.
She ruled out the possibility of negotiations with the authorities regarding "improving" the law.
The veto will be submitted to parliament today.
"This veto is very straightforward. The law must be repealed." -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is the weirdest Caucasus-Pacific story since Tuvalu de-recognized Abkhazia... www.politico.eu/article/france-accuse-azerbaijan-fomentin…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The Georgian government is not just not compromising on its Foreign Influence law, it quietly introduced an amendment in the third reading which extends its punitive reach to individuals., as well as organizations.
OC Media
@OCMediaorg
A lawyer with the Tbilisi-based Civil Society Foundation has stated that Georgian Dream has already broadened the scope of the foreign agent's law, allowing authorities to fine individuals for failing to provide financial information.
➡️ Live updates: shorturl.at/mJquJ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 It’s finally out! Part historical essay, part policy paper, The End of the Near Abroad is my attempt to look in depth at the changing dynamics of Russia’s relationship with its post-Soviet neighbours. carnegieendowment.org/research/2024/05/the-end-of-the-nea…
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 they're also doing active business with Moscow on petro-deals and connectivity routes and getting reassurances on regime preservation
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
9 These leaders' occasional de-colonial rhetoric is quite performative. It's out of sync with large parts of their societies which are more progressive (or would like to be) in their choices about education, media and relations with the rest of the world.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
11 Georgia is of course a hybrid case. A society and institutions that are decisively pro-Western, a leadership that was trying to have it both ways but is increasingly appeasing Moscow.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
12 I'd say GD's dealing with Moscow is likely more about business than formal alignment. (It would be suicide for any Georgian govt to join Russian led institutions like the EAEU). But it puts them closer to the first camp than the second. More soon but pls read the piece! ENDS
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Sophie Alexander
@SophieAlex1
Reporting from Tbilisi where we met Georgian protestor @gvbrdghvnian. He says he was homophobic before watching your Out There documentary, which changed his life @stephenfry. He now adores you so much he named his gorgeous dog, Fry.
Photos by @CharlieBrunskil -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Join us! This discussion next Tuesday is long-planned but even more relevant given what's going on in Georgia.
It's tied to a long paper I've written The End of the Near Abroad on Russia's different relationships with its different neighbours to be published imminently.
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Since Putin's invasion of Ukraine, #russia's neighbors have come to see Moscow as more of a threat than a security patron.
On Tuesday, @Tom_deWaal, @AdeCar, & @herszenhorn will unpack the political dynamics in 🇷🇺's contested neighborhood.
Register now: carnegieeurope.eu/events/2024/05/navigating-change-in-rus… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Tbilisi-resident Azerbaijani talks back live at Az State TV's attempts to smear the Georgian protests
Cavid #FreeUlviyya
@cavidaga
Queen @SamBayramova puts Azerbaijani State TV journalist in his place on live TV in Tbilisi:
— Liar! Provocator!
— Can you not interrupt?
— Liar! Provocator! Azerbaijani people, don't believe this provocator. Such things don't happen in Tbilisi. West is a friend to Georgia, not an enemy.
— *Goes on talking live*
— Are you not ashamed? You are a journalist, you should be ashamed. West is closest friend to Georgia. Of course, we have to be funded by West. You are mistaking freedom of speech with provocations. I am in favor of freedom of Georgia.
— And I am a media representative.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
The Georgian parliament overrode the president's veto and passed amendments to the Election Code, eliminating quotas for women on party lists for parliamentary elections.
The President's veto message was supported by only one MP, while 28 voted against it.
As a result, the parliament eliminated the requirement for every four candidates on party lists to include at least one woman. The proposal to abolish the quotas was initially put forward by the opposition party Girchi.
"Congratulations, there will be many more male bigwigs on the list than the moneyless, though intelligent women," commented MP Khatia Dekanoidze, a member of the Eurooptimists political group. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 A privilege to share this Chatham House webinar on the crisis in Georgia with wise watchers of 🇬🇪 who’ve written about the country for decades. www.chathamhouse.org/events/all/research-event/protests-g…
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3 Stephen Jones says, “The Georgian Dream government is at war with Georgian society.” And talks about Georgia's systemic democratic deficit and the need for participatory democracy.
And @natasabanadze on how and why GD changed – “no one elected them on a Eurosceptic program.”
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 I had the job of talking geopolitics. Watch it, but I argue that GD’s goal is more to join what I call "Illiberalism International" and appease Russia than align with it fully. No 🇬🇪 govt can survive by restoring relations with Moscow. But they can win other things.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The EU finally agrees a statement on Georgia 🇬🇪 it’s tough but pulls a few punches that some member states would have liked to see delivered
European External Action Service - EEAS 🇪🇺
@eu_eeas
🇬🇪 "The adoption of this law [“on transparency of foreign influence”] negatively impacts Georgia’s progress on the EU path. The choice on the way forward is in Georgia’s hands".
Statement by HR/VP @JosepBorrellF and Commissioner @OliverVarhelyi: europa.eu/!7ymKpW. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexandra Prokopenko
@amenka
Economist Andrey Belousov appointed on a MoD. What does it say? A quick🧵
- Putin's priority is war; war of attrition is won by economics. Belousov is in favor of stimulating demand from the budget, which means that military spending will at least not decrease but rather increase -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Today. Join us!
Chatham House Events
@CH_Events
🚨NEW EVENT🚨
Protests in Georgia: what’s at stake?
Speakers:
▪️ @HansGutbrod
▪️ @Tom_deWaal
▪️ @LubicaP
▪️ Stephen Jones,@DCRES_Harvard
▪️ @natasabanadze
Join this @CHRussiaEurasia event.
Date📅: 13 May
Time📷: 14:00
Register👇
www.chathamhouse.org/events/all/research-event/protests-g… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Good to see. I hope the British embassy will now follow suit
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Andrew Stroehlein
@astroehlein
In armed conflicts, the world’s primary focus should, of course, always be on the suffering of innocents on the ground.
But we should also think about the destruction of minds beyond the immediate war zone - how reason and morality are wrecked by a conflict mentality. People condemn one side’s atrocities while justifying (or ignoring) the other’s, as if the laws of war and expectations of basic decency only apply to one side.
I feel to help end the former - the immediate suffering - we’ve got to work on the latter - the wider poisoned atmosphere.
We need more people defending universal humanity and condemning atrocities regardless of which side has committed them - more people supporting principles over partisanism. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Georgia's ambassador to France resigns over the "Foreign Agent law" -- the first top official to make the leap. More to come?
Gocha Javakhishvili
@Gocha_Javakhi
Les tensions et le climat actuels engendrés par le projet de loi réincarné dans nos relations avec nos amis et partenaires étrangers🇪🇺 rendent ma mission en tant qu'ambassadeur extraordinaire et plénipotentiaire de 🇬🇪 auprès de la République française et de Monaco extrêmement /1
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
We will talk Georgia and its current crisis next Monday. Tune in!
Chatham House Events
@CH_Events
🚨NEW EVENT🚨
Protests in Georgia: what’s at stake?
Speakers:
▪️ @HansGutbrod
▪️ @Tom_deWaal
▪️ @LubicaP
▪️ Stephen Jones,@DCRES_Harvard
▪️ @natasabanadze
Join this @CHRussiaEurasia event.
Date📅: 13 May
Time📷: 14:00
Register👇
www.chathamhouse.org/events/all/research-event/protests-g… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Chatham House Events
@CH_Events
🚨NEW EVENT🚨
Protests in Georgia: what’s at stake?
Speakers:
▪️ @HansGutbrod
▪️ @Tom_deWaal
▪️ @LubicaP
▪️ Stephen Jones,@DCRES_Harvard
▪️ @natasabanadze
Join this @CHRussiaEurasia event.
Date📅: 13 May
Time📷: 14:00
Register👇
www.chathamhouse.org/events/all/research-event/protests-g… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Glad to see this
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Young Georgians on why they are protesting against the Foreign Agents Bill and their fears that they won’t be able to carry on living in 🇬🇪
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
In Georgia, on the front lines of protests against the "foreign agents bill," stands the youth - students and high school students. We asked them what they are protesting against and how they organize themselves to defend their rights.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
In a way the Eurasian Economic Union is working for Russia's neighbors as they're not under sanctions & serve as in-between states for reexport, said @Tom_deWaal on #europeinsideout.
He & Fiona Hill discussed how Russia's war has impacted these countries: europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/what-next-for-r… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
An extremely dangerous speech that will chill anyone who cares about Georgia 🇬🇪 to the bone. There will be plenty of commentary but no summary can convey the full-on conspiracy-minded paranoia. Bidzina Ivanishvili seems to believe this stuff. Read in full civil.ge/archives/602348
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Another day in Azerbaijan and another decent brave pro-democracy activist is arrested. For Anar Mammadli it’s a second round. He was part of the wave of dissident Azerbaijanis arrested in 2013 and was awarded the Václav Havel Prize in jail. Outrageous that he’s arrested again
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Anar Mammadli, the head of the independent Center for Election Monitoring and Study of Democracy (SMDTM), was detained in Azerbaijan. According to his friends on social media, Mammadli was forcefully taken into a car by individuals in civilian clothing on a street in Baku and driven away in an unknown direction.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs press service briefly stated that an investigation was underway against Mammadli, without specifying the charges. There is public speculation that this arrest is related to the case of the independent publication Abzas Media, where the entire management team and several journalists were arrested on corruption charges. Read more here 👉 jam-news.net/female-journalists-arrested-in-azerbaijan/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On the day that Georgian PM Irakli Kobakhidze gave a rabble-rousing speech attacking “so-called liberals” at the CPAC meeting in Budapest, read my piece from last year on how much Georgian Dream takes inspiration from Orban. carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And here is a report on Kobakhidze’s speech if you can stomach it. civil.ge/archives/601368
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Some good news from Baku. Gubad is still charged but has at least left prison and is now under house arrest. He can get some medical care after months of suffering. Huge credit to his three incredible kids for their tireless campaigning efforts!
Ibad bayramov #FreeGubad
@BayramovIbad
Dear all,
My father, Dr. Gubad Ibadoghlu, has been allowed for house arrest! He is still conditionally imprisoned and can’t leave Baku but now he can get medical care!
Thank you all for your continuous support during this period!
We will continue for his unconditional release! -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Russia has lost its claim to a sphere of influence, to the idea of a “Near Abroad”, since the invasion of Ukraine but the direction of travel is less clear. Listen to me and Fiona Hill discuss this big topic in the @Carnegie_Europe podcast out today. europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/what-next-for-r…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
We talk the politics of multiple neighbourhoods, Russia’s threats, intentions and inconsistencies and how and why trade has actually increased.
It’s also the topic of a long forthcoming paper by me for @Carnegie_Europe. Watch this space! -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This thread from last year by Hans is a must read. He sets out why the 🇬🇪 govt's now-revived foreign agents law is not really about getting transparency but is about suppressing and intimidating Georgia's diverse non-governmental sector
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
though the horse has bolted, of sorts, here my analysis of "the law". It is squarely bad faith.
You can sensibly call it the "we can repress anyone we like" law.
I can compare it with an analysis I did of such transparency laws in 2017 more globally, for @TAInitiative 1/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Sad to hear the friendly warm tones of Martin Handley presenting his last Sunday morning on @BBCRadio3 Losing a good broadcaster from your daily life is like losing a member of the family. All the best, Martin!
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Georgia!
Georgia • GFF
@GeorgiaGff
🔥🕺🏻 ს ა ქ ა რ თ ვ ე ლ ო 🇬🇪 . .
🔥🕺🏻 G E O R G I A 🇬🇪
#geogre #მევარსაქართველო -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The metaphor @samagreene uses here is brilliant, of Putin's Russia as a religious cult and Navalny as the heretic who had to be crushed for inspiring a "crisis of faith" among ordinary Russians. tldrussia.substack.com/p/life-after-death
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Still places for this event later today. Looking forward to a good turnout and discussion www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/the-south-caucasus-in-the-shadow-o…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
In 2024 Armenia is likely to come under pressure from both Baku & Moscow to accede to a plan for the Zangezur Corridor that does not suit Yerevan.
Local incidents of violence could have major consequences & must be watched very closely, says @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/91621 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Thank you, Steve.
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
I saw his hearse & his coffin. I saw thousands of Russians paying him their last respects. But it’s still hard to believe that Alexei Navalny is dead. Among his supporters there's disbelief & defiance. Our report from Moscow. Producer @LizaShuvalova Camera @AntonChicherov & team
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Kamil Całus
@KamilCaus
Naddniestrze proszące Rosję o obronę to nic nowego. Region tej jest de facto rosyjskim protektoratem i robi to regularnie, nie zapominajmy o tym. Deklaracja która dziś wystosowali deputowani tego regionu raczej nie skończy się rosyjską interwencją :) Rosja nie ma fizycznie 1/
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
In a Moscow court today we saw Russian human rights campaigner Oleg Orlov sentenced to 2 ½ years in prison. At his trial he’d spoken of a Russia “sinking ever more deeply into darkness.” Our report for @BBCNews Camera @AntonChicherov
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Would be very significant
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Volodymyr Zelensky will probably visit Armenia on March 4th; he will also visit Azerbaijan, as informed by the Armenian edition of Radio Liberty, citing their sources.
#ukraine #armenia #azerbaijan #diplomacy #zelensky #internationalrelations -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Time to reshare my blog piece of 4 years ago on distorted historical Armenian-Azerbaijani narratives, esp. around Sumgait and Khojaly. Where other nations have atoned for past crimes, we're likely to see bad old conspiracy theories recycled this week.
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/81137 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Phillips P. OBrien
@PhillipsPOBrien
Ukraine finding out what it must be like to be married to Boris Johnson.
John Crace
@JohnJCrace
Boris Johnson tells The Sun the world is safer with Donald Trump in White House
So much for his commitment to Ukraine -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Arkady Ostrovsky
@ArkadyOstrovsky
Gulag that never died. My piece about prison and fear in Russia. www.economist.com/1843/2024/02/22/a-day-in-the-life-of-a-…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Two podcasts on recent ARM-AZ developments. In English for @OCMediaorg on the the negotiations and the stakes in it for Russia and Western powers. (Since then I’m a bit more optimistic on the prospect of resumption of high-level meetings in Europe). oc-media.org/podcasts/podcast-are-armenia-and-azerbaijan-…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And на русском языке in Russian with the ever-sharp Shahin Hajiyev of Turan on Azerbaijan post-elections, the deterioration of relations between Baku and the West and the implications for a deal with Armenia. www.youtube.com/watch?v=_79c0ThgV0Y
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 Kamil writes in Polish so you’ll have to translate, but he is an extremely well-informed and level-headed commentator on #transnistria #transdniestria In short the move by Tiraspol should not be taken at face value. It's more a political crisis than a military one...
Kamil Całus
@KamilCaus
Temat powoli zaczyna być podgrzewany przez media, więc odnieśmy się do niego. Oto 28 lutego Naddniestrze ma zwrócić się do Rosji z wnioskiem o uznanie jego niepodległości (oraz potencjalnie z prośbą o przyłączenie do Federacji). Prawda to? O jaki zjazd chodzi? Tłumaczymy.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
2...Russia has no capacity to intervene there (there are fewer than 100 Russian soldiers on the ground) TN does not really want it Probably should be read as a cri de coeur to OSCE and others to intervene and try to mitigate the economic squeeze they are now under from Chisnau.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3 As it happens here is an article by Kamil from exactly 10 years ago the last time this happened/did not happen in 2014. www.euractiv.com/section/europe-s-east/news/anxiety-grows…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Francis Scarr
@francis_scarr
Two years ago yesterday
Francis Scarr
@francis_scarr
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov last weekend:
"Let us remind you, over its entire history, Russia has never attacked anyone. For Russia, which has lived through so many wars, it is the last country in Europe which even wants to say or pronounce the word 'war'." -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🇦🇿 president Aliyev's confidence stems from a double insurance policy with Putin & Erdoğan.
The stress on the two leaders is deliberate—these are very personal bonds between men who speak the same macho language of power & money, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/91621 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Sam Greene
@samagreene
Navalny.
So many thoughts have been expressed in the time that it has taken me to collect my own, that I'm not sure what this is worth. By the key words are Navalny's own: не сдавайтесь. Don't surrender.
/1 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
RIP Alexey Navalny @navalny and let us hope those words of yours eventually come true for Russia and Ukraine and this is your legacy
Alexey Navalny
@navalny
The combination of aggressive warfare, corruption, inept generals, weak economy, and heroism and high motivation of the defending forces can only result in defeat.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1. A follow-up on my blog piece yesterday for @carnegie_europe about Armenia and Azerbaijan and prospects of war or peace in 2024
Please note the main point of the piece is about Azerbaijan, Russia and the corridor (see below) but I also mentioned the shootings on the border
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
2. Some Azerbaijanis complained that I only gave the Armenian version of the clash yesterday. When I filed the piece in the morning I saw Armenian reports that two (later 4) of their soldiers had died. It's worth adding that an Azerbaijani soldier was also wounded earlier.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3. What happened? It's unlikely we will know it all. I can only say I’ve heard the name Nerkin Hand from Western officials as a very vulnerable point for the Armenians, where Azerbaijani troops are close, there are also Russian border guards and the EUMA mission lacks access.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4. But let's get back to my main concern – why is Baku insisting that the Russian FSB guards the Zangezur Corridor?
We all know that Pashinyan is trying to get rid of the Russian military presence. He would do so more boldly if did not feel threatened by Azerbaijan.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
5. 1. Western actors still believe in the Zangezur corridor/Syunik transit route. They've come up with modalities where security is provided by third-party actors, not Russia. Why is Azerbaijan not getting behind this version of the corridor and still insisting on the Russians?
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
6. The piece again with more details carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/91621
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My blog piece for @Carnegie_Europe on the prospects of a peace agreement in 2024 between Armenia and Azerbaijan and justifiable concerns that Baku and Moscow are pushing for Russian control of the “Zangezur Corridor.”
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/91621 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
www.rferl.org/a/azerbaijan-armenia-peace-negotiations-one… A really comprehensive analysis of the state of negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan by @joshuakucera The bilateral track is the last one standing. It is serious but as Josh quotes me saying here, "if this doesn't work, then we're in big trouble."
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
What Josh doesn't go into much here is the importance the Armenian side attaches to "dispute resolution mechanism" and some kind of international underpinning of any agreement reached in the bilateral process, probably at the UN. A big issue.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tatiana Stanovaya
@Stanovaya
What can be anticipated from #putin's #interview with @TuckerCarlson ?
Understanding the context is crucial. Putin perceives 2024 as a pivotal year, viewing it as a window of opportunity for Russia to potentially shift the dynamics of the war in Ukraine in its favor. He anticipates a temporary gap in Western military support, with ammunition production expected to ramp up only by early 2025. Concurrently, the U.S. election cycle might lead to a less decisive American geopolitical strategy towards supporting Kyiv, and the European Union, facing its own internal disagreements, is unlikely to compensate for this support on its own. Moreover, Ukraine could be grappling with significant internal political challenges, especially with the anticipated resignation of Zaluzhny.
In this scenario, Putin's immediate goal is to convince the West, particularly Washington, to dismiss Zelensky and to encourage a new, potentially more pliable Ukrainian government to enter negotiations with Russia (Putin thinks that this is how it works). However, Putin's aim for these negotiations is not to seek a tangible compromise but to halt Kyiv's military resistance, paving the way for what he sees as eventual capitulation (a regime friendly to Russia and all that follows).
Against this strategic backdrop, Putin badly needs to reach a Western audience. It is probable that during the interview, he will attempt to position himself as a friend to the American people, arguing that it is in the U.S.'s interest to cease its support for Ukraine. He is likely to brand himself as a peacemaker, contrasting his stance with that of the current U.S. administration, which he accuses of prolonging the conflict at Ukraine's expense. Thus, the interview is a platform for Putin to widen his access to American viewers and garner support for his narrative. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
www.facebook.com/events/715883907044240/ If you are in Cambridge next Tuesday Feb 13 I will be in conversation about "translating Russian poetry in time of war, talking about Mandelstam's Tristia. All welcome.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
RBmediaTopAuthors
@RBmediaAuthors
Looking for your next audiobook? For a limited time, you can download "Black Garden: Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War" for 50% off! @tom_dewaal www.audiobooks.com/promotions/promotedBook/513939/black-g…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Morning scan: what’s big news in Georgia today, January 26:
● Two protesters in Tbilisi, who unsuccessfully attempted to prevent the eviction of a family for non-payment of a bank debt, are now facing 3-6 years in prison. Giorgi Hasaya and Kako Chikobawa are accused of damaging the car of enforcement bureau employees. The court rejected the lawyers’ proposal to release them on bail until the final court hearing, despite guarantees from professors at the universities where the accused work.
● The leader of the ruling party is confident in securing a constitutional majority in the upcoming parliamentary elections in October. Currently, Georgian Dream holds a simple majority in parliament. Irakli Kobakhidze believes that the United National Movement, led by the opposition leader, will receive no more than 30-35 mandates.
● The NGO “Coalition for Reliable Information” demands that the authorities “stop the targeted attack on civil organizations.” The statement cites “discreditable statements by the Chairman of Parliament against the head of the Tolerance Center under the Public Defender Beku Mindiashvili, the Laboratory for the Study of the Soviet Past (SovLab), and Civic Idea.” The organization sees these political manipulations as a significant threat, especially with elections scheduled this year.
● Georgia ranks third in the updated Eastern Partnership Index, following Moldova and Ukraine. Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Belarus share the fourth, fifth, and sixth places, respectively.
● Doctors included in the special commission created by the Public Defender visited ex-President Saakashvili at the Vivamed clinic after a four-month break. They noted some progress in his condition, although his neurological condition remains severe.
● Doctors at the Republican Hospital in Tbilisi urge fellow citizens to join their protest announced for today. The team is protesting against the decision to demolish the clinic, with authorities citing the old building’s condition. Plans include constructing a new clinic on the site, and all employees have been offered jobs in other clinics along with monetary compensation.
● A young man succumbed to knife wounds in the center of Tbilisi, on Orbeliani Square. Preliminary information suggests he was attacked on the street by several teenagers. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
With Marina Nagai I spoke to a high-profile House of Lords @LordsIRCom session on Armenia and Azerbaijan earlier. Lots of questions on what are the chances of a peace deal in 2024, the dangers of new conflict and what the UK can do. A good discussion parliamentlive.tv/event/index/ee24ad75-dcc5-4b53-9081-143…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Vladislav Davidzon
@VladDavidzon
Congratulations to my beloved Odessa for (once again) producing a French Prime Minister! We have not had an Odessa connected French PM since the Duke de Richelieu returned from Odessa to become Prime Minister of France under King Louis XVIII.
Vladislav Davidzon
@VladDavidzon
The new French Prime minister is half White Russian aristocracy from Odessa ( mother is de Couriss) and half Tunisian Jew! How chic a combination!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
"I wouldn't expect an invasion from Azerbaijan, but rather strong pressure on Armenia," stated @Tom_deWaal in an interview with the Armenian branch of Radio Liberty, discussing Baku's plans.
jam-news.net/tom-de-waals-opinion-on-armenia-azerbaijan-r… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I love this picture! Happy 100th birthday to Sergei Parajanov, artist, dreamer, iconoclast, son of the Caucasus and of Ukraine too. A man who managed to live in the Soviet Union as if the Soviet Union didn’t matter.
Ani Poghosyan
@aniboghoss
Sergey Parajanov would’ve turned 100 years old today. The maestro was not just a visionary in cinema but also a staunch advocate for human rights and freedom. He once described himself as an “Armenian born in Georgia, imprisoned in Russia for Ukrainian nationalism”.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexander Gabuev 陳寒士
@AlexGabuev
📢📢📢
We are hiring! Come work with @CarnegieEndow in Berlin with a group of terrific colleagues. More details on the application form below👇
carnegieendowment.applicantpro.com/jobs/3185775 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A cornucopia of reading recommendations here from @engelsbergideas. For myself-- novelist @Gospodinov68 and historian @ClairePKaiser might not usually keep company...but I’m grateful to both for making me think differently about modern European history. engelsbergideas.com/reviews/books-of-the-year-2/
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Fascinating. First young man from the South Caucasus (an ancient Ossetian of sorts) trying to get a place at Cambridge www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-67755415
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The quest for "absolute security" at the expense of diplomacy and compromise--an illusion that can cost you dear. A lesson Israel's government is failing to learn and Armenians clung to in their time. Great column from @MarcChampion1 (quoting me). www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-12-19/israel-gaza…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
The EU is present in the South Caucasus as a regional power that offers citizens what Iran, Russia & Turkey cannot.
It offers a path to #democracy, investment in technology & infrastructure, and visa-free travel, writes @Tom_deWaal on @EngelsbergIdeas.
engelsbergideas.com/essays/armenias-existential-moment/ -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🇺🇦 | Is Europe Still Committed to Ukraine?
Support for #ukraine remains high among European publics but is not a priority for all EU countries.
While continued aid may be costly, Europe will pay a much higher price if Putin prevails.
15 experts comment: carnegieeurope.eu/p-91246 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Negotiations over a "peace agreement" between Baku & Yerevan continue, but the Western-mediated process has not yet resumed.
If Western diplomacy stalls, several candidates-including Iran-are keen to fill the vacuum.
Read @Tom_deWaal on @EngelsbergIdeas:
engelsbergideas.com/essays/armenias-existential-moment/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Big congratulations to Edmund on chairing the 2024 Booker Prize panel! But will your family ever get to see you next year? The novels may come between us. www.thebookseller.com/news/de-waal-and-collins-to-judge-t…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Putin “ doesn’t care what people believe in, so long as they believe that everyone else around them believes in whatever it is that Putin is selling.” Sam Greene excellent as usual
Sam Greene
@samagreene
To date, Putin hasn’t elaborated a clear ideology for his rule and his war. It is purposefully vague. He doesn’t care what people believe in, so long as they believe that everyone else around them believes in whatever it is that Putin is selling. The performance is key.
/4 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My father (he’s 94) spent 24 hours in A and E before he eventually got a decent hospital bed in central London. He has COVID and is getting good treatment now. I will always be haunted by an over-worked A and E doctor telling me, “I spent my whole day apologizing to people..”
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
– because NHS resources are at breaking point.
So imagine my feelings as I read that the UK govt. already spent £240 million on their ridiculous sadistic policy of trying to send a few hundred asylum seekers to Rwanda. Pure grotesque. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Francis Scarr
@francis_scarr
This clip of Russian opposition politician Vladimir Ryzhkov on TV in 2004 has recently resurfaced thanks to @CurrentTimeTv
His warnings for the country’s future are frighteningly prophetic
You might also recognise the presenter… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Zaur Shiriyev
@ZaurShiriyev
1/4 This is a landmark deal. It is the first struck directly between Baku and Yerevan, without the involvement of Brussels, DC and Moscow.
azertag.az/en/xeber/joint_statement_of_the_presidential_a… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
UK health system in breakdown. My brothers and I have now spent many hours in turn in A and E keeping my elderly Dad company. Staff are unfailingly professional, they simply don't have enough beds.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
“[Putin] is the most intelligent gentleman,” Karin Kneissl tells me. Austria’s ex-foreign minister, who once danced with Putin, has moved to Russia. Her response to my question about the dance: “Boring. The dog just fell asleep because he knows the topic." rb.gy/nm09n6
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Peter Foster
@pmdfoster
That winning formula:
- take complex issue (Brexit, Northern Ireland, Asylum)
- tell everyone it’s simple, if England was sovereign 🏴
- demonise those raising rational objections
- resign when you get close to having to implement what you said was ‘easy’.
Rinse. Repeat. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Happy Birthday, Akram Aylisli!
Some Armenians and Azerbaijanis sometimes ask me (tediously!) “Who do you *really* support?” Here is my answer. A patriot of the Caucasus, not just one nationality, a village boy who became a global writer, a voice of courage and peace...
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
...And let’s not forget Akram Bey is still silenced, unable to travel outside Baku and speak publicly. The situation is no better than as I described two years ago here.
www.opendemocracy.net/en/odr/the-outspoken-azerbaijani-wr… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My long essay on the state of the South Caucasus published for @engelsbergIdeas The aftermath of Azerbaijan’s violent takeover of Karabakh, the precarious state of Armenia and the lessons Georgia takes from it. The new focus on Zangezur and Nakhchivan... engelsbergideas.com/essays/armenias-existential-moment/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
...invites parallels with 1917-21 (another theme), the last time those two territories were on the international agenda. Back then Turkey and Russia engaged in both contestation and collusion and Western powers came and went. Will it be different this time?
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexander Gabuev 陳寒士
@AlexGabuev
"There is the pro-war majority, which supports the war partly by ignoring it in everyday life."
Another clear-eyed and hence depressing piece by my Moscow-based @CarnegieEndow colleague @AndrKolesnikov in @ForeignAffairs. www.foreignaffairs.com/russian-federation/putins-war-party -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I was a day late for the Rose Revolution in 2003…I got to Tbilisi when Shevardnadze had already resigned. But I did get to see Shevy himself and wrote this with Margarita (still going strong at @JAMnewsCaucasus). It came out 20 years ago today…
www.worldpress.org/Europe/1689.cfmPost not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Post 2003 there was of course a massive transformation of domestic policy and change of generations post but the foreign policy trajectory to the West did not change—it had already been set by Shevardnadze and key things (eg withdrawal of Russian troops) achieved.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Shevardnadze was indeed bitter that night. He’d misjudged things badly and had an undignified exit. But I believe history will judge him kindly
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
We talked about 🇬🇪 #georgia and the EU but about so much more than that! Also about the strategies Georgian govt and others are adopting in a contested international space. Thanks to @natasabanadze and @k_kakachia for a great discussion
Kornely Kakachia
@k_kakachia
Thrilled to have engaged in a timely discussion yesterday, exploring pivotal facets of the 🇪🇺🇬🇪 relationship with @Tom_deWaal of @CarnegieEurope and @natasabanadze , from Chatham House. #eu #georgiarelations carnegieeurope.eu/2023/11/30/georgia-s-winding-road-to-eu…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Simon Nixon
@Simon_Nixon
Extraordinary that no major political party in Britain is willing to respect the will of the people...
YouGov
@YouGov
A majority of Britons would support joining the single market, even if this meant free movement of people
All Britons
Support: 57%
Oppose: 22%
Leave voters
Support: 35%
Oppose: 45%
Remain voters
Support: 83%
Oppose: 6%
yougov.co.uk/politics/articles/47997-britons-support-rejo… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🇬🇪 | Brussels faces tough choices if it wants to support #georgia's European aspirations despite its increasingly illiberal government.
Tomorrow, join @natasabanadze, @k_kakachia, & @Tom_deWaal for a discussion on what is at stake in EU-Georgia relations.
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/11/30/georgia-s-winding-road-to-eu… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
rayhan demytrie
@rayhandemytrie
Yet another independent #journalist Aziz Orujev is arrested in #azerbaijan in front of his toddler. A picture that speaks thousands of words #authoritarianism via @JAMnewsCaucasus full article here shorturl.at/lpGH8
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Want to understand the geopolitical dance that is EU-Georgia relations? And what happens now as 🇬🇪 edges towards EU candidate status? Join the brilliant @natasabanadze , @k_kakachia and me tomorrow as we talk it over at 16.30 CET. Register here carnegieeurope.eu/2023/11/30/georgia-s-winding-road-to-eu…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Read Natalie's deep and insightful paper for @Carnegie_Europe here. ხვალამდე! carnegieeurope.eu/2023/11/16/eu-georgia-relations-local-s…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hans Gutbrod
@HansGutbrod
petty dictatorship on full display in #azerbaijan as alumni who were given (generous) stipends by U.S. are being labelled as "agents" in "secret cooperation".
Extra petty to show name of junior embassy employee, to intimidate. @richkauz qafqazinfo.az/news/detail/abs-bu-hotelde-azerbaycandaki-a… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Andy Marshall 📸
@fotofacade
Blast from the past: It took me ten years to take this image. Until this photograph was taken, the vagaries of the weather had stoppered my ultimate goal of getting the sunrise over Beverley. This view from Westwood Common is universal and timeless. #thread
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
The number of brown bears in the wild is actively growing in Georgia. The video was filmed by rangers in the mountainous Kazbegi National Park in early November.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Poor Britain: we don't get to enjoy the family consumer-free fun of Thanksgiving but we get the abomination that is Black Friday.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A new series of arrests of dissenting voices in Azerbaijan, including well known disabilities rights activist Mahammad Kekalov, who had just returned form the EaP civil society forum. So a message to the EU as well. www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/22/azerbaijan-crackdown-independ…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Happy St George’s Day to all Giorgis, Gigas and Gogas in Georgia
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Almost 200,000 Georgians carry the name of Giorgi (or its derivatives), the state services agency reports today as Georgia celebrates one of its most significant religious holidays, St. George's Day. This constitutes over 10% of the country's male population.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Giles Milton
@GilesMilton1
Yesterday I was a granted a rare tour of the treasures in the strongroom-vaults of the National Archives @UkNatArchives
Here's what I saw... 1/7 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is new. For years I heard Armenians say “The US is pro-Azerbaijan because of oil and gas” and Azerbaijanis say, “The US is pro-Armenia because of the Armenian Lobby.” Official business carried on regardless. Now this kind of conspiracy talk comes from the highest level.
Hikmet Hajiyev
@HikmetHajiyev
During 30 years long occupation of Azerbaijan's land by Armenia when million more Azerbaijanis were subject of notorious and bloody ethnic cleansing the United States stood with aggressoor state of Armenia. Nowadays, the same policy continues in the same form and manifestation.
Pretending to academic or professional impartiality would be incorrect, as professor of 'Human Rights" Practice at University Samantha Power @PowerUSAID in her propaganda book "A Problem from Hell": America and the Age of Genocide (2002)" passed in complete silence over the genocide and atrocities committed by Armenia against innocent Azerbaijani civilians. As United States PermRep at United Nations Security Council, she never dared to raise the plight of Azerbaijani refugees and IDPs and demand implementation of UNSC resolutions, let alone condemning occupation of Armenia.
Under the umbrella of Aurora Prize, Samantha Power came together with the founder of this fund, notorious oligarch and money launderer Ruben Vardanyan who also financed separatism in Ukraine. Interestingly, in 2019, European Parliament members demanded sanctions against Troyka Dialogue Banker(s) founder - Ruben Vardanyan for money laundering schemes. Ruben Vardanyan was also planning coup d'etat against the United States supported political leadership of Armenia after having established himself in Karabakh since October 2022.
Azerbaijanophobia, Turkphobia, political corruption, "moneytalkism", and political speculations under the so-called Aurora prize were probably shared values and interests between Ruben Vardanyan and Samantha Power.
Mask Off! There is no place for USAID operation in Azerbaijan any longer! -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Christian Wigand
@ExtSpoxEU
Azerbaijan: 🇪🇺 regrets decision to extend the pre-trial detention of the distinguished scholar & activist Gubad Ibadoghlu to 7 months. We urge 🇦🇿 authorities to ensure his access to necessary medical care, as well as his & activist Bakhtiyar Hajiyev’s immediate release.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ Unmissable for anyone who follows Georgia 🇬🇪
We just published Natalie Sabanadze’s paper on Georgia-EU relations for @Carnegie_Europe in our Europe’s East series. An authoritative look at a very tangled relationship and the dilemmas the EU now faces. carnegieeurope.eu/2023/11/16/eu-georgia-relations-local-s…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
5/ (For those of you who don’t know her, you should! Natalie used to be Georgian ambassador to the EU and has now joined @ChathamHouse. Wonderful to have her in London as an analyst.)
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
6/ @natasabanadze (oops I forgot!)
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
Baku cancels November 20 meeting between the foreign ministers of Azerbaijan and Armenia in Washington, says "high-level visits from the US to Azerbaijan are no longer appropriate".
This is in response to what Azerbaijan’s foreign ministry refers to as “one-sided and biased remarks" by the U.S. Assistant Secretary of State James O’Brien who questioned "Baku’s commitment to a comprehensive peace with Armenia” and said the U.S. was cancelling high-level bilateral meetings and engagements with Azerbaijan. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Dustin Gilbreath
@GilbreathDustin
I.e 200,000 people or a bit over 5% of the country left in 2021 and 2022. That’s 1 in 20 people. And there’s more people that have left this year. I don’t know how much is circular migration but it’s a stunning number in any case
ბათუმელები • Batumelebi.ge
@Batumelebi_ge
Possible Impacts of the #emigration of the Working-Age Population from #georgia
📈80,351 citizens left the country in 2021, and in 2022, the number of emigrants was 125,269.
🔴Experts anticipate higher 2023 data compared to previous years.
Interview: batumelebi.ge/news/502804/ -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Engelsberg Ideas
@EngelsbergIdeas
Now judged one of the world’s most liveable cities, the sedate Austrian capital was once a hothouse of social and cultural experiment with profound consequences, good and evil.
@charlesemmerson reviews a new book on Vienna, the city of ideas.
engelsbergideas.com/reviews/viennas-vapour-trail/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Pressure mounting on govt. of Azerbaijan over their jailing and mistreatment of Gubad, after he put the Baku-EU gas deal under hard scrutiny and continues to probe corruption issues. An excellent piece by @polinaivanovva Free him now! www.ft.com/content/d218380c-79f7-4675-9fd9-8bb13a529937
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As I recall, the last "Common Sense Tsar" advocated «Православие, самодержавие, народность» (Orthodoxy, Autocracy, Nationality)... It didn't end well. www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/nov/14/what-views-will-…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Seven Foreign Secretaries in seven years. Even Premier League football clubs don't do this. Is this a a way to run a foreign policy? Only last week I heard FCDO people saying, "Thank God for Cleverly, who got to grips with the job..."
Sophia Gaston
@sophgaston
Astonishing to think that in the space of just seven years, we have had seven Foreign Secretaries...
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Dionis Cenușa
@DionisCenusa
#eu_enlargement: The Georgian govt has prepared its narratives following the EU Commission's recommendation to grant candidate status to Georgia upon the implementation of 9 conditions (neither Ukraine nor Moldova were exposed to additional conditions). Below are 5 main themes⤵️
Shalva Papuashvili 🇬🇪
@shpapuashvili
Five myths about Georgia’s EU candidate status
The European Commission’s recommendation this week to grant Georgia the EU candidate country status was a historic decision. After granting the European Perspective last year, this week’s decision constitutes an entirely new level of progress. It also brings a higher level of responsibility for the Georgian Government. The European Commission’s announcement met the Georgian government’s and public’s expectations, duly reflecting our decade-long unwavering commitment to the European path and Western orientation. This decision is, hopefully, a precursor to an even more important decision this December.
The Georgian public and government welcomed and appreciated the European Commission’s seminal decision. Sadly, the day that should have been a moment of national unity, was marred by the opposition’s relentless attempts to discredit the government’s role in this achievement. These attempts rest on myths that aim to discredit the Georgian government and, despite being baseless and slanderous, require an answer.
Therefore, this piece is not about the future plans for addressing the EU’s new propositions about Georgia’s future membership in the EU. The incumbent Georgian Dream government will, in due course, make efforts to advance the country to the next stage of integration with the EU, the membership negotiations. Rather, I am writing to dispel the myths that have been contrived and disseminated about Georgia’s EU candidate country status in the past few months. These myths were born out of disinformation, political bias, and misperceptions.
1. Georgian government has done too little to deserve the candidate status
The major myth among them is that Georgia was given the candidate status without duly fulfilling the 12 priorities originally set out by the European Commission in June 2022. Nothing can be farther from the truth. The 12 priorities were dealt with, almost single-handedly, by the Georgian Dream authorities. The Parliament, in particular, worked hard. Parliamentary working groups, the Committees, and the staff completed an immense volume of work. Nearly a hundred laws were passed for the purpose of fulfillment of the EU recommendations, which constitutes one third of the overall Parliamentary work.
This was accomplished in close coordination with the executive branch – the governmental ministries, agencies, and the diplomatic corps. The bulk of this work, as usual, may not have been immediately visible to the outsiders, but those in charge in Brussels and the European capitals know all too well what has been accomplished.
Majority of these 12 priorities that were somewhat imprecise and nebulous at first, were re-conceptualized and re-defined in more or less precise and verifiable terms by the Georgian Parliament and Government, and then communicated with the European partners, to be fulfilled during the last year and a half.
In fact, the new nine ‘steps to be taken’, recommended by the European Commission now, repeat only few of the previous points, and do so in a more rigorously formulated way than the previous 12 recommendations. They implicitly indicate that the Commission recognizes that the majority of the past recommendations have been met or need to be reformulated for further, more elaborate effort.
2. People deserved the status, not the government
Separating the democratically elected government from the people is a tactic from the Kremlin’s playbook, and a beloved revolutionary approach of the Soviet regime in the past. In democracy, such as Georgia, the government acts upon the will of people. The government’s obtaining, first, of the European Perspective and, then, the candidacy recommendation are the proofs thereof. Georgian Dream was the only party that incorporated the intention to apply for EU membership by 2024 in its pre-election program of 2020, and diligently worked its way along the designated path.
Moreover, even if the sophist argument about separating government from people is taken for its face value, it does not stand up to scrutiny in Georgia’s case. According to ALL public surveys and polls, Georgian electorate resolutely favors the ruling Georgian Dream party over the opposition by a large margin, sometimes all of them, taken together.
The opposition’s attempt to virtually separate Georgian people from their government even made one foreign critic to arrogantly refer to the status recommendation as a ‘gift’ to the Georgian people, which probably was demeaning more to the EU than to the Georgian public.
3. Georgian government distanced itself from Europe
Georgian Dream incorporated the double clause of European and Euro-Atlantic integration, respectively the EU and NATO, into the new edition of the Constitution in 2018. Apart from these and other legislative measures, ALL major diplomatic victories on the EU front that advanced Georgia towards Europe, have been secured under the Georgian Dream government in the past 11 years. We signed the Association Agreement with the EU, which included the Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Area. We achieved and, equally importantly, successfully maintained the visa-free travel between Georgia and the European Union. Finally, last year, we gained the European Perspective for the country.
All these achievements stemmed from the Government’s strong political will and the efficiency of the ever-improving public institutions.
4. The opposition worked hard for the status
This is the most vicious and cynical myth. The opposition, especially its radical part, attempted first to sabotage the work on EU’s 12 priorities, then to smear the Georgian government’s efforts, and, finally, to downplay the importance of the accomplishment. However, once they realized that the candidacy was happening and its political importance was high, the opposition tried to claim a stake in the achievement.
Then, the truth, of course, is not on our opponents’ side. The parliamentary work on 12 priorities was organized along the working groups and the Parliamentary Committees. The opposition’s participation (or, rather, non-participation) in the process can be very easily measured both quantitatively and qualitatively. This simple measurement would only indicate that the opposition’s contribution was modest, to put it mildly. Quite to the contrary, the radical part of the opposition, in fact, tried in earnest to damage the process. Their calculation was that failure to fulfil the 12 recommendations would lead to the failure to get the candidate status. This, in the opposition’s mind, would turn the people against the government and, therefore, their radical part boycotted most of the work in the Parliament. They did not participate in most of the voting either, for passing the legislation presumed by the EU recommendations. Again, this is very easy to verify. Moreover, many of them took pains of travelling abroad extensively to smear the government’s efforts. The opposition did not achieve much in the national capitals or the European Commission itself, but were more ‘successful’ in the European Parliament, which is the EU political body most malleable to political influences and bias.
Unfortunately, some politically biased non-governmental organizations worked in close coordination with the radicals.
So, in cases where it was possible for the ruling party to cooperate with the moderate wing of the opposition (e.g. electing the ombudsman with the parliamentary consensus), progress was achieved and the recommendation was counted as ‘fulfilled’ unequivocally. The same can be said about the electoral reform, which was assessed under the rubric of ‘significant progress’ by the EU.
However, those EU-designated priorities that required involvement of the opposition or civil society proved to be more problematic, to put it mildly. Opposition, especially its radical part, torpedoed the fulfillment of those preconditions. Such were the cases of de-polarization or involvement of civil society in decision-making. Even when the moderate opposition MPs co-operated with the governing party, they were systematically bullied by their radical colleagues and by some politically biased NGOs. This shameful practice was later publicly revealed by those moderate opposition MPs who voted for the consensual election of the ombudsman, as required by one of the EU priorities.
Similarly, in cases where civil society organizations showed interest and intent for cooperation, the ruling party duly involved them in the process (e.g. the Parliament’s cooperation with the Georgian National Platform of the Eastern Partnership Civil Society Forum). However, unfortunately, some politically biased NGOs opted out from the process and attacked the government’s efforts from the outside.
5. Candidacy was about geopolitics, not Georgia’s performance
Geopolitical factors create the permissive or challenging environment but it is up to the governments to exploit it to their advantage. International political change, per definition, influences Georgia’s progress towards Europe. The Russian invasion of Ukraine cannot be cast as an opportunity for Georgia. In fact, this unjustified and inhumane invasion has exacerbated the already daunting security challenge for our country. Everybody knows that Russian occupying forces are almost in the vicinity of Tbilisi, threatening Georgian sovereignty on daily basis, as tragically showcased by the recent murder of Georgian citizen Tamaz Ginturi, near the occupation line of the Tskhinvali region.
In the past three decades, Georgian people developed its democratic governance structures at a gunpoint. It is very difficult to find any other nation with the same extent of democratic achievements as Georgia in a similarly threatening geopolitical environment.
Presenting the invasion of Ukraine as an opportunity for Georgia is immoral. It did change geopolitics but let us not forget also that Georgia has always been forerunner in the Eastern Partnership format, since the day of its creation, and remains as such according to all numerical data.
Above all, geopolitics did not change since June 2022, when the European Commission’s recommendation on granting Georgia a candidate status turned out to be negative. So, to ask a rhetorical question, how did geopolitics favor us this time, if Georgia did not improve its credentials?
What lies ahead?
With all this said, the major achievement that will remain in history is the European Commission’s decision, not the politicking around it.
We have a lot of work ahead. It is good that the communication with the EU over the new nine recommendations appears, this time, to be better structured than before. This gives us good understanding of recommendations so that to measure and codify our progress. We believe that the existing structured dialogue with the EU would actually enhance the efficiency of Georgia’s continuous progress.
Especially interesting is the new clause on disinformation. It may be crucial for Georgia’s political development. This clause is very welcome by Georgian authorities. Manipulation, creation of misperceptions, and outright disinformation are the diseases that poisoned Georgia’s political climate for years. Tackling disinformation will be the most important step forward for ending polarization and radicalization in Georgian politics. Disinformation feeds confrontation in our political life. Diminishing the level of disinformation will help us consolidate our democracy and move more quickly towards the EU.
Georgian government is resolute about achieving the maximum on Georgia’s path of European integration in the coming years. We believe that the next general elections, scheduled for October 2024, will bring the renewal of the political mandate for Georgian Dream to bring Georgia to actual integration into the European Union.
The future is promising. We should seize the opportunity and return Georgia to where it belongs, to the European family of nations. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Ominous signals of new war intent from Ethiopia to get access to the sea. By my brilliant brother Alex, so worth taking very seriously www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-67332811
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On the state of ARM-AZ negotiations, the Israel-Gaza war, different positions of Azerbaijan and Turkey, the impact on Ukraine and the South Caucasus. Glad, as always, to talk (in Russian) to Arshaluis Mghdesyan of @CivilNetTV www.civilnet.am/ru/news/756640/в-брюсселе-встревожены-азе…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Cavid #FreeUlviyya
@cavidaga
Once you start to read archival documents from a hundred years ago, you realize we never moved an inch to the future.
March 1919 - General Digby Shuttleworth (1876-1948) speaks with the head of Karabakh Armenians Aslan Shahnazarov. Everything looks familiar in this dialogue. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Mariam Nikuradze
@mari_nikuradze
President Zurabishvili addresses crowd gathered outside her residnece. She congratulated people with today's decision. She started her address by also congratulating Abkhazians and Ossetians: "our European future is yoir European future too," she said.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Starting soon
Harriman Institute
@HarrimanInst
What are the implications of September 2023 for the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict? Tune in on Wed 11/8 @ noon ET, for a webinar w/@NYUJordanCenter featuring @Tom_deWaal @AnnaOhanyan03 Mohammad Ayatollahi Tabaar. Mods: @CooleyOnEurasia & Joshua Tucker harriman.columbia.edu/event/the-nagorno-karabakh-conflict…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The EU's long-awaited announcement on Georgia 🇬🇪 is a kind of non-decision decision. 🇬🇪 gets candidate status, which the govt. can hail as a victory. But conditions remain--accession is far off. Plus it's presented as a prize for the public not the govt. oc-media.org/european-commission-greenlights-eu-candidacy…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Jessica Duchen ✍️🎶
@jessicaduchen
My favourite Tchaikovsky quote is: "Inspiration is a muse that does not willingly visit the lazy."
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
For years @rochowanski has delved deeper into the realities of the North Caucasus than almost anyone. Read how she links the anti-Semitic attack in Dagestan with "entitled rage" and violence against women in particular. Meanwhile the state... www.themoscowtimes.com/2023/11/02/dagestan-riot-fueled-by…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
condones, exculpates or turns a blind eye
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Harriman Institute
@HarrimanInst
What are the implications of September 2023 for the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict? Tune in on Wed 11/8 @ noon ET, for a webinar w/@NYUJordanCenter featuring @Tom_deWaal @AnnaOhanyan03 Mohammad Ayatollahi Tabaar. Mods: @CooleyOnEurasia & Joshua Tucker harriman.columbia.edu/event/the-nagorno-karabakh-conflict…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Ibad bayramov #FreeGubad
@BayramovIbad
I am writing this with a heavy heart, my father's life hanging by a thread. He lies in an 🇦🇿 detention center, unable to move. My father, who criticized our government, now teeters on the brink of a diabetic coma and stroke.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Cavid #FreeUlviyya
@cavidaga
Just took this photo. It used to house the Armenian embassy in Azerbaijan in 1918-1920. Two countries were in war, but they had embassies and had ethnic MPs in parliaments.
Built by German architect Johann Edell, who also made numerous other projects throughout the city. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexander Gabuev 陳寒士
@AlexGabuev
"Both the Prigozhin mutiny and the pogroms in the North Caucasus show that no matter how brutal the Russian regime may seem, it is weak and indecisive as soon as it is confronted with any non-anti-Putin unrest." Some sharp observations by @Stanovaya. carnegieendowment.org/politika/90873
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Politika
@CEIP_Politika
All decisions made at the regional level in Russia are built around the desire to prove loyalty to Putin. In terms of political survival, that is now far more important than preventing something as serious as an anti-Semitic pogrom, writes @Stanovaya
carnegieendowment.org/politika/90873 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A must read for anyone interested in the North Caucasus
Tom Parfitt
@parfitt_tom
Thread/Reading List:
For those learning about Dagestan for the first time (after the recent anti-Jewish pogroms), may I humbly offer my memoir 'High Caucasus' and the following English-language books for wider background and context on the republic: -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A toxic mix of years of repression of dissent, unsolved socio-economic problems, the degradation of traditional Islam and old cultural norms, an information space full of conspiracy theories in a region Moscow has not fully controlled for decades. More to come, I fear…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Damon M. Wilson
@DamonMacWilson
Emrin, son of @gubad_ibadoglu, warns his father faces a diabetic coma while unjustly imprisoned in Azerbaijan on the Day of Political Prisoners with @MoveDemocracy #setthemfree
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Pippa Crerar
@PippaCrerar
Just as crisis was unfolding, Johnson held 25-minute call with Evgeny Lebedev who he later (controversially) awarded a peerage.
Reynolds says he can't recall if he asked why, when ex-PM had more urgent matters to deal with. "I may have said 'are you sure you want to do this?'" -
Thomas de Waal reposted
PACE
@PACE_News
"It's simply unacceptable" - marking today's Day of Political Prisoners, @PACE_President Tiny Kox again makes a strong appeal for the release of all those unfairly jailed for political reasons.
More:
pace.coe.int/en/news/9269/-it-s-simply-unacceptable-pace-… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Authoritative analysis by @chambersharold8 on the anti-Semitic violence in Dagestan. He makes it clear that it tells us a lot about the dire situation in the N Caucasus, but much less (or almost nothing) about Russia as a whole.
Harold Chambers
@chambersharold8
My coverage and analysis of yesterday's storming of the Makhachkala airport, what led to it, & what this means for Dagestan. Please give it a read on @RiddleRussia:
ridl.io/the-storming-of-uytash/ -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Thought-provoking read from @GIP_ge on the EU's looming decision on whether or not to give Georgia candidate status, setting out the risks and rewards of each choice -- with provisional conclusion that granting status is better than the reverse. gip.ge/publication-post/two-scenarios-for-the-decision-on…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Mark Galeotti
@MarkGaleotti
Rather than failed sanctions on Russian oligarchs (they can't turn against Putin) and security officials (they were already compromised), @pevchikh makes a sensible proposal to target Putin's celebrity cheerleaders
Maria Pevchikh
@pevchikh
1/16 You've heard a million times that sanctions against Putin's regime don't work. That Putin isn't actually affected by them. That's right because he isn't.The same approach is tried over and over for almost 2 years, yielding no results. How about I suggest something different?
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A really terrible situation. Gubad needs proper medical help now
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tomila Lankina
@TomilaLankina
Please circulate the recording of @LSEnews @LSEIRDept webinar dedicated to Gubad Ibadoghlu as part of a global campaign to raise awareness about political prisoners in Azerbaijan #freegubad youtu.be/2GhzgfgN-js via @YouTube @HeathershawJ @Tom_deWaal @BayramovaZhala
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carob Mill
@carobmill
Workers on the Millennium Bridge, by reducing the headroom of the bridge while they work, have triggered an ancient by-law of London requiring that a bale of straw be hung underneath to warn river traffic:
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Judy Dempsey
@Judy_Dempsey
A new start for 🇵🇱. young people need it. and so does🇪🇺 maybe under @donaldtusk he might prepare 🇵🇱 to join €zone. would give 🇵🇱 a special influence. but that's down the road. Rule of law, ending polarization, womens' rights are the big issues.
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90786 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 Read in full Pres. Aliyev’s victory speech from Khankendi/Stepanakert yesterday—and be warned. It’s an angry speech, dwelling on past grievances, with nothing about the future or reconciliation. No olive branches.
president.az/en/articles/view/61587Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
6 It bodes ill for what comes next with the Republic of Armenia. No sign here of what Westerners are urging: that Aliyev should start to treat Armenia and Pashinyan as a partner, rather than a defeated adversary.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7 Instead it suggests that Aliyev still believes he derives legitimacy from the public by mobilizing anti-Armenian sentiment. So strong indications that he will keep on threatening Armenia itself.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is today. Join us. Webinar on free speech in Azerbaijan and the detention of Gubad Ibadoglu.
John Heathershaw @jheathershaw.bsky.social
@HeathershawJ
Today at 5pm @LSEIRDept!
@TomilaLankina @Tom_deWaal Alexander Morrison
#freegubad
www.lse.ac.uk/international-relations/ir-events -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tessa Szyszkowitz
@tessaszy
Too many tragedies happen currently at once: Caucasus expert @Tom_deWaal explains here the wider implications of the end of Nagorno-Karabakh. Talk in English for @FalterRadio by @BKFVienna 👇🏻
@falter_at
#hörtipp: Das tragische Ende der autonomen Republik Berg-Karabach.
Kaukasusexperte @Tom_deWaal über die regionale Machtverschiebung durch den aserbaidschanischen Sieg über Armenien und die Schwäche Russlands. Ein Gespräch mit @tessaszy im @BKFVienna ↓ www.falter.at/falter/radio -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Andrew Forde
@DrAndrewForde
The CoE Parliamentary Assembly has adopted a report, resolution and recommendation to the Member States in relation to the Humanitarian Situation in Nagorno-Karabakh.
Despite several amendments being made, the documents are still very strong indeed
1.
pace.coe.int/en/files/33146 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Rauf puts it more eloquently than I managed to
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Very glad and honoured to speak to the PACE session today on #karabakh, Armenia and Azerbaijan. It got feisty! Amongst other issues I argued that Baku's "reintegration" agenda should be treated with great caution and considered only within a much bigger framework.
PACE_Legal
@PACE_LegalHR
Thank you Mr @Tom_deWaal, Mr Andreas Wissner and Prof Björn Schiffbauer for their contributions during today’s joint hearing on the human rights and humanitarian situation of #karabakh Armenians and international obligations of Azerbaijan
🔴recording here:www.youtube.com/live/tXA28lVrXDY -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As Hungarian PM Viktor Orban arrives in Georgia I'm resharing this piece from last month in which I explore what both governments get out of the deepening Georgian-Hungarian relationship carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Very disappointing that @nybooks, whom we rely on for critical insight on world affairs, would publish this.
Legitimate points about recent Azerbaijani aggression and threats nullified by being put in an entirely Armenian nationalist/genocide framework
www.nybooks.com/online/2023/10/10/armenias-mortal-calculu…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Azerbaijanis are made invisible. The author says merely, “ the Karabakh Armenians also took control of seven adjoining Azeri districts, a sort of ‘security belt’ that geographically united the region with Armenia.” The people who lived there? You can do better than this @nybooks
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
@eliothiggins.bsky.social
@EliotHiggins
A fake BBC video claiming a Bellingcat investigation shows Ukraine smuggled weapons to Hamas is being pushed by Russian social media users. It's unclear if this is a Russian government disinformation campaign or a grassroots effort, but it's 100% fake
t.me/sheyhtamir1974/58755 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A deserved tribute to a brave and decent peacemaker unjustly sitting in jail
PACE
@PACE_News
The 2023 Václav Havel Human Rights Prize – which honours outstanding civil society action in defence of human rights – has been awarded to imprisoned Turkish human rights defender Osman #kavala.
Watch the award ceremony here:
fb.watch/nzJ0-vkAqr/
More coming...
#havelprize -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Bright Garden Voices
@brightgardenv
Garden Chat #12 is now available on our Instagram account. Thank you @Tom_deWaal for joining us for a conversation about your work and the state of affairs concerning Armenia, Azerbaijan, Karabakh, and more. www.instagram.com/reel/CyLE9CDu6qE/
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
If you read only one piece on the #karabakh conflict and Armenia and Azerbaijan do read this. A powerful blast of humanity and a cry from the heart, as an Azerbaijani IDP calls for the cycle of ethnic cleansing to stop. www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/oct/09/azerbaijani…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Bright Garden Voices
@brightgardenv
Happening in less than 30 minutes!
Bright Garden Voices
@brightgardenv
Garden Chat #12 - @Tom_deWaal, a veteran journalist and writer specializing on the Caucasus and Eastern Europe, will join us for a conversation about his work and recent developments in Nagorno-Karabakh and between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Bright Garden Voices
@brightgardenv
Garden Chat #12 - @Tom_deWaal, a veteran journalist and writer specializing on the Caucasus and Eastern Europe, will join us for a conversation about his work and recent developments in Nagorno-Karabakh and between Armenia and Azerbaijan.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Cavid #FreeUlviyya
@cavidaga
Can't really believe they continue to talk about "Gandzasar was built by Caucasian Albanians" tale. Just let it go, man. You are not doing a favor to Azerbaijan, on the contrary, you are making us a laughing stock.
U.S. Azerbaijanis Network
@USAzerisNetwork
Ganjasar was built by Caucasian Albanians in Caucasian Albania, as a seat of the autocephalous Caucasian Albanian Christian church. It was not part of Armenia.
Armenians did ruin it - such as in 2011 when they used cement (!) & marble to basically destroy 13th century structure -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tomila Lankina
@TomilaLankina
Please join us on October 16 for a @LSEIRDept webinar dedicated to Azeri repression, money & reputation laundering & plight of jailed Azerbaijan anti-corruption activist @gubad_ibadoglu w leading experts on the Caucasus @Tom_deWaal , Central Asia @HeathershawJ and @NizamiOxford
John Heathershaw @jheathershaw.bsky.social
@HeathershawJ
On 16 Oct, @Tom_deWaal, Alexander M (@NizamiOxford), @TomilaLankina & I will speak at this online @LSEIRDept event about Gubad Ibadoghlu, Azerbaijan's repression & reputation laundering, & the threat these present to academic exchange. @AFI_WG
Come!
www.lse.ac.uk/international-relations/ir-events -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Christopher Cherry 🏴
@christophcherry
Fear and fury in Yerevan… Myself and the brilliant @Andrew__Roth made a documentary in Armenia, tracing the emotional last days of Nagorno-Karabakh as it surrendered to Azeri control.
www.theguardian.com/news/video/2023/oct/05/the-fall-of-na… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Thank you, Grigor!
Grigor Atanesian
@atanessi
Can’t recommend more this translation of Osip Mandelstam’s Tristia by @Tom_deWaal. This is some of the best Silver Age poetry, like this poem comparing the 1917 Bolshevik revolution to the biblical catastrophe.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On Putin, October 1993 and dividing lines in the Russian “patriotic” camp. A piece I wrote in 2014 on how the divide between Strelkov, Borodai etc and Putin dates back to the bloody end of the White House siege 30 years ago still looks relevant.
carnegiemoscow.org/commentary/56228
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
October 1993 was a fight between the Russian state and xenophobic nationalists for whom ideas were bigger than the state. Both were prepared to use force and Yeltsin's attack set a terrible precedent.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Putin now uses the language of the second nationalist camp but in 1993 he was very much on the side of Yeltsin and the state. And he still is surely above all else a gosudarstvennik.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Which helps explain why he is prepared to crush true-believer violent nationalist entrepreneurs like Strelkov and Prigozhin, when they stop being a tool and look like a threat.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I don’t normally respond to allegations against me--life is too short. But I should point out, in response to what some Azerbaijani media are saying, that I have never worked with or for Ruben Vardanyan.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
It’s well known that the late (much respected) Vartan Gregorian, former president of the Carnegie Corporation of New York, co-founded the Aurora Prize with Vardanyan several years ago. That’s all very transparent and hardly a revelation.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I won't comment on this any further.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Kavala'ya Özgürlük
@FreeOsmanKavala
Today is the birthday of #osmankavala, whose 6 years of unjust imprisonment turned into a conviction with the recent decision of the Court of Cassation and who will now be held under the harshest prison conditions in Turkey.
#happybirthday #freeosmankavala -
Thomas de Waal reposted
CNAS
@CNASdc
“This is about politics, war, and insecurities, it is not about historical hostilities” remarks @Tom_deWaal on the Latest Brussels Sprouts with @AKendallTaylor and @jteurope. Listen now: www.cnas.org/publications/podcast/understanding-the-nagor…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
“A ghost town”
Hov Nazaretyan
@HovhanNaz
latest footage from Stepanakert's central square
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Osman’s case is so sad and unnecessary and a stain on Turkey’s international reputation
Kavala'ya Özgürlük
@FreeOsmanKavala
Osman Kavala's statement regarding the approval of the aggravated life imprisonment sentence given by the Supreme Court in the Gezi Park case is below.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Note to media: I’ll be travelling for the next week so won’t be responding to requests for interviews or comments on the Karabakh/ARM/AZ situation. (My critics on this platform will doubtless be glad!) Some things to look out for in coming days in a very unstable situation :
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
5.how many of the de facto Karabakhi officials (people who served in governments there over the years) will be detained? And what about local military commanders? Another big issue looming.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
6. Will some Armenians stay in Stepanakert? The Russians will want some to justify their PKF staying, Baku will want something to show for its “reintegration” policy, Yerevan will be glad to have fewer refugees
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7. Continue to watch for statements from Baku, Ankara and Moscow to push their joint agenda on the transport route to Nakhchivan across Armenian territory (so-called “Zangezur Corridor”).
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7. Continue to watch for statements from Baku, Ankara and Moscow to push their joint agenda on the transport route to Nakhchivan across Armenian territory (so-called “Zangezur Corridor”).
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
MarshFamilySongs
@MarshSongs
The final sea shanty of the trilogy 🎶⚓️(an adaptation of #wellerman and #drunkensailor) inspired by @SuellaBraverman's recent speech on migration.
We stand and sing in solidarity with a different vision from #braverman's of what our country stands for & who it should stand by🧡This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Izabella Tabarovsky
@IzaTabaro
“Armenia will be in turmoil for a long time. The loss of Nagorno-Karabakh is the biggest defeat and trauma for Armenians since the fall of Kars to the Turks in 1920. It’s probably bigger than that.” From @Tom_deWaal carnegie-mec.org/diwan/90657
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I was really glad to get to discuss the #karabakh crisis and what comes next at proper length with knowledgeable people. Gloomy prognoses though
CNAS
@CNASdc
NEW: @Tom_deWaal and Amb. Phil Reeker break down the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict on the latest Brussels Sprouts with @AKendallTaylor and @jteurope. Listen here⬇️ www.cnas.org/publications/podcast/understanding-the-nagor…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Gwendolyn Sasse
@GwendolynSasse
It‘s officially out!! Thanks @politybooks for making it happen - and to the many scholars & friends who inspired it. The list is too long but some are mentioned in the preface…
Polity
@politybooks
"The war against Ukraine did not begin on 24 February 2022, but eight years earlier. The annexation of Crimea, the war in the Donbas and the full-scale invasion are three phases in one war."
Russia's War Against Ukraine by @GwendolynSasse is out now! -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Sarah Rainsford
@sarahrainsford
The children of Nagorno Karabakh have already known two wars in their short lives. Now they are living as refugees. There is a giant aid effort under way in Armenia to help them, but for the youngest arrivals here, these are bewildering times
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
The World
@TheWorld
On The World 🌍 today:
@Tom_deWaal: On the latest from Nagorno-Karabakh
@johnwlast: Before Sukkot, some Rabbis inspect citrus crops in Calabria #sacrednation
@matthias_huss: Switzerland losing its glaciers at an alarming rate
Tune in 📻 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Monstrous abuse is right
Emma Sinclair-Webb
@esinclairwebb
Turkey's top appeal court decision to uphold the baseless convictions of Osman Kavala to life imprisonment, Çiğdem Mater, Can Atalay, Mine Özerden, Tayfun Kahraman to 18 yrs in the Gezi trial is a monstrous abuse of the justice system, proof that courts obey the presidency
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Malcolm H. Kerr Carnegie Middle East Center
@CarnegieMEC
In an interview, @Tom_deWaal discusses the stakes, and risks, in the recent fighting in the contested territory.
#nagornokarabakh
carnegie-mec.org/diwan/90657 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hov Nazaretyan
@HovhanNaz
Kremlin spokesperson Peskov says Armenia's decision to ratify the Rome Statute of the ICC is an "extremely hostile" move
tass.ru/politika/18863977 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
RIP Nagorny Karabakh (July 7, 1923 - September 28,2023)
* Final dissolution January 1, 2024 -
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
* Final dissolution January 1 2024
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Hov Nazaretyan
@HovhanNaz
"Lavrov called on the leadership of Armenia to remember the unfortunate fate of countries that relied on the United States"
tass.ru/politika/18857207 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
rayhan demytrie
@rayhandemytrie
This #karabakh #armenian woman lost two of her underaged children during #azerbaijan's military offensive last week. A really important & speedy investigation by the #bbc & #karabakh reporter @SiranushSargsy1
BBC News (World)
@BBCWorld
'They bombed everywhere': Survivors recount Karabakh attack www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-66925791
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 @ForeignAffairs asked for a longer piece. This is about how Western actors never really got in the game in resolving the #karabakh conflict. And latterly were outflanked, could not prevent war and the awful scenes of flight we see today.
www.foreignaffairs.com/armenia/end-nagorno-karabakh
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
2 If there’s one piece of policy advice here it's to push for the replacement of the trilateral (Aliyev-Pashinyan-Putin) agreement of Nov 2020, that's no longer fit for purpose, and replace it with something under a broader international, probably UN, umbrella.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 Some people out there are blaming me. To which I say, I've been warning all summer of the risk of a military operation and I said in August that “Aliyev is in a hurry” and something was brewing. Do I regret that I didn’t say it more loudly and often? Of course I do.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
9 I wish more people had been paying attention in Europe and the US, and the band of Karabakh watchers was not so small. This conflict never got the attention it deserved.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
“A huge mistake”
MFA Russia 🇷🇺
@mfa_russia
⚡️ We are convinced that the Armenian leadership is making a huge mistake by deliberately attempting to sever Armenia's multifaceted and centuries-old ties with Russia, making the country a hostage to Western geopolitical games.
Read in full 🔗 mid.ru/ru/foreign_policy/news/1906229/?lang=en&clear_cache=Y -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Azerbaijan’s decision to use violence when the EU was actively trying to mediate in #karabakh makes for a decisive break in EU-Baku relations. And that’s not all—also a pivot to Russia and a domestic crackdown. My piece today for @Carnegie_Europe carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90631
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Altay is always on point
Altay Göyüşov
@AltayRashidoglu
Aliyev calls Armenians to stay and live like Azerbaijanis. I also would like to see them accepted Azerbaijani citizenship. I am absolutely sure that contribution of Armenians would be enormously beneficial for political, economic and cultural life of Azerbaijan. However, reluctance to live like Azerbaijanis is exactly one of the main reasons why the Armenian separatist movement in Nagorno-Karabakh started in the first place.
During the late Soviet era, Armenia was a comparatively prosperous and freer place than Azerbaijan ruled by Heydar Aliyev. So, Armenians of Karabakh wanted to live like Yerevanians, not like Azerbaijanis.
And the current political system in Azerbaijan is not better. I think that life under the entrenched, corrupt dictatorship can be anything but attractive for the people who lived in a relatively free society during the last thirty years.
There is no doubt, if Armenians answer positively to this call, even within Azerbaijan they will live a better life than the vast majority of Azerbaijanis, also due to the fact that Ilham Aliyev will have to treat them differently, at least in the beginning. Yet, it will still be a daunting life under extremely corrupt dictatorship.
Moreover, in the economic sense, life in Azerbaijan is not much better than in Armenia too. Yes, Azerbaijan is an oil rich country. However, everything in the country belongs to the ruling family. The ruling family members and their entourage are benefitting from the oil wealth while social well-being of the rest of Azerbaijanis is hardly better than social conditions of population in Armenia. If you ask young Azerbaijanis what their future plans are, many will respond that they are looking for ways to leave the country. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Marut Vanyan
@marutvanian
Just a river of cars... from Stepanakert to Hakari...
We drove two meters, waited two hours...
Be patient, those who haven't arrived yet… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Days after Azerbaijan's military takeover of Karabakh, Presidents Aliyev and Erdogan meet in Nakhchivan today and will very likely make ultimatums to the Armenian govt. to "open the Zangezur Corridor or else..." With Russia's agreement so long as its troops are deployed there.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Can we be really going the world of 1918-21 when big powers try to use force to draw and redraw the map of the Caucasus? Let it not be so. Most relevant book is suddenly Kazemzadeh's classic of 1951
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
It's available online if you want to read about the Armenian-Azerbaijani battles for control of Karabakh, Nakhchivan, Zangezur in that era that created the modern map of the region.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The sad exodus from Karabakh is underway. Huge credit to @marutvanian @SiranushSargsy1 and others for continuing to tell us the human story from inside Karabakh under impossible circumstances.
Marut Vanyan
@marutvanian
Everyone is looking for 5L petrol…
Morning Stepanakert… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Please read this thread
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Andrew S. Weiss
@andrewsweiss
A warning from @Tom_deWaal: “Barring an unexpected international initiative, the main question may now be whether a mass exodus of Karabakhis to Armenia will happen in an orderly fashion or with bloodshed and detentions of male residents.” carnegieeurope.eu/2023/09/22/tragic-endgame-in-karabakh-p…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The dire humanitarian issue inside Karabakh is surely the main story today. The more international attention and plans for international presence the better. Diplomats in Baku should be asking to visit the region. www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-66888945
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 Reading both alarming reports of the situation on the ground in #karabakh and Western reaction at UNSC meeting last night a disturbing déjà vu of the beginning of the Bosnia war. (I hope I’m wrong)
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
2 From the ground, a first round of talks. Good. But also: no resumption of mass deliveries of food and supplies via Lachin, thousands of Karabakhis displaced from their homes, Azerbaijani soldiers still moving at will.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 Main conclusion is that Western actors know and say there needs to be some kind of international presence on the ground to protect local Armenians and oversee events but currently Azerbaijan and Russia both blocking it
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
9 (later) Since I wrote this Hikmet Hajiev has posted this, which contains some positive messages (I don't like to be a prophet of doom) but also looks to set the stage for mass exodus of Karabakhis from their homeland
Hikmet Hajiyev
@HikmetHajiyev
I had a meeting with the @ICRC Baku Office and other international partners.
Strict observance of the İnternational Humanitarian Law by the Armed Forces of Azerbaijan and by all means, avoiding collateral damage during the local anti-terrorist measures, which lasted 23 hours and 51 minutes, were commended.
As the Prime Minister of Armenia himself admitted, civilians were not harmed. In this regard, unverified and unserious statements by EU, French, and German officials remain incomprehensible.
- During the meeting with ICRC, we stated that all necessary conditions are provided and will be provided for the delivery of medicine, food and other goods by ICRC via Lachin-Khankendi and Aghdam-Khankendi roads.
- Azerbaijani side is ready to provide medical assistance to wounded servicemen of armenian origin or help them through the ICRC. Upon the inquiry movement of ICRC medical vehicles is supported to collect wounded military personnel. For this purpose, we are also ready to allocate emergency medical vehicles and provide medical care.
- For medical evacuations to Armenia medical vehicles can also come from Armenia.
- Work is underway with Russian Peacekeepers to collect the bodies of combatants left on the field.
- We support to receive additional personnel from ICRC Geneva Office. We also support sending of additional personnel from the Baku office to Khankendi sub-office.
- On the basis of voluntary and individual choice, we ensure the safety of the movement of civilians with their own vehicles along the Khankendi-Lachin road. Those who want to go are mostly family members of military personnel.
- Military personnel who voluntarily lay down their weapons are free as we openly stated.
- Within the concept of civil-military cooperation, Azerbaijani military and civilian personnel on the ground are helping civilians and will continue to do so. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Great summary of UNSC session on Karabakh crisis
Gabriel Armas-Cardona
@GArmasCardona
I'll be watching and live tweeting the UN Security Council meeting today regarding #nagornokarabakh.
You can watch it as well here:
media.un.org/en/asset/k1t/k1ti94chwd -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
RIP dear lost colleague
robert shrimsley
@robertshrimsley
The FT journalist Sander Thoenes was murdered by Indonesia soldiers in East Timor, 24 years ago today.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Note to media: conflict in #karabakh is not over. As well as talks today, reports of gunfire, terrified Armenian civilians in Stepanakert. Also some local officers not laying down their arms. Casualty figures now estimated at 200+ Follow @cavidaga @marutvanian @SiranushSargsy1
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Some somber discussion here on events of the last three days: Baku’s subjugation of the Karabakh Armenians by force, how it used Russia and Turkey to get what it wanted and Western diplomacy/ peacemaking was sidelined. With other guests from the region. oc-media.org/podcasts/podcast-the-end-of-nagorno-karabakh/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The post mortem will be long, but for now the situation on the ground is still dire and worthy of close attention. Thank you to @OCMediaorg
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Marut Vanyan
@marutvanian
Next to the ICRC Office in Stepanakert.
No electricity in the city. Charging phone is as important as bread, especially for me. Trying to do my best to be in touch with you.
Can’t be sometimes, sorry about that. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Caucasus specialist Thomas de Waal of Carnegie Europe said the terms of the ceasefire and the coming talks were very much on Azerbaijan's terms and left ethnic Armenians looking unprotected. www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-66863702
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"This looks like the end of a 35-year-old project, some would say a century-old project, of the Armenians of Karabakh to secede from Azerbaijan," he told the BBC.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"We're probably, unfortunately, seeing a project whereby the Azerbaijanis offer so little to the Karabakh Armenians that most if not all of them will leave."
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alec Luhn
@AlecLuhn
The other big losers in Karabakh are the US & EU, “which have tried hard to be mediators in this conflict but whose message of rights and international guarantees is being drowned out by the tougher messages of Azerbaijan and Russia” - @Tom_deWaal www.theguardian.com/world/live/2023/sep/20/nagorno-karaba…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
The Moscow Times
@MoscowTimes
The circulated instructions to media and officials follow Armenia’s frustration over what it sees as Russia’s failure to guarantee its security.
www.themoscowtimes.com/2023/09/20/kremlin-orders-media-la… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Cavid #FreeUlviyya
@cavidaga
Breaking — “Through the mediation of the command of the Russian peacekeepers, an agreement was reached on a complete cessation of hostilities from 13:00 on September 20” — Sputnik Armenia.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A hugely consequential day for #karabakh and its people. Residents of eastern villages and towns in flight and Azerbaijani forces advancing. Read Laurence
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Olesya Vartanyan
@Olesya_vArt
1/Fighting in Nagorno-Karabakh is ongoing. Several thousand civilians were evacuated from areas close to the front lines, facing problems with their accommodation and deepening the humanitarian crisis that the locals have been struggling with for over 9 months. 📷 by @marutvanian
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 Day 1 of a new war in #karabakh (an awful thing to write.) A terrible day for Western diplomacy, for peacemakers, above all of course for the people of Karabakh. Main observation, I'm afraid, is that it has the potential to get a whole lot worse.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 What comes next could be worse, however. Next step may be a ground attack to take population centres where most Armenian armed men are stationed and thousands of civilians live. With a prospect of much greater bloodshed.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
5 So a little precious time remains for international diplomacy before this scenario occurs.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 I’m far away but for independent coverage read @JAMnewsCaucasus @OCMediaorg @eurasianet and their brave journalists, also @GabrielCSGavin and the one and only @cavidaga Also of course @joshuakucera and the brilliant @LaurenceBroers
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
9 And if you want more of me (quite understand if you don't) I am about ten minutes in in this edition of BBC Newshour tonight www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w172z09m7dg0n5s
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
For updates on the Azerbaijan attack on Karabakh please also follow the excellent and independent @JAMnewsCaucasus jam-news.net/hostilities-n-karabakh-azerbaijan-launched-a…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This piece I wrote last month on the dangers of a new #karabakh conflict is of course out of date because of today's dreadful news of the Azerbaijani attack. But but I hope gives useful context if you haven’t been following the situation recently engelsbergideas.com/notebook/armenia-azerbaijan-on-the-br…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Always read Laurence on the #karabakh situation. Fully endorse everything, except that it was expected. There was hope that after a couple of weeks of intense diplomacy by EU and US that this had been averted. But Russia's role (decision not to act) probably crucial
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The news everyone feared but hoped could be avoided. Azerbaijan launches military assault on Karabakh. Bitter terrible news for the people in Karabakh and for the whole region. Read live updates here oc-media.org/live-updates-stepanakert-under-fire-as-war-b…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
The 'routinisation' of Russia’s war in Ukraine in the Russian media. #readingrussia
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is good news. But four trucks is still very little for the huge needs inside #karabakh, where bread has been rationed for several weeks. Hopefully this works, and can be scaled up very quickly.
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
@ICRC
As a result of persistent diplomatic efforts to find a humanitarian consensus between the decision-makers, today we are bringing shipments of wheat flour and essential medical items.
The operation includes 2 trucks simultaneously delivering goods via the Lachin & Aghdam roads. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
James Kilner
@jkjourno
"War markings" have appeared on Azerbaijani military equipment as Armenia warns of a new conflict. With insight from the Centre for Information Resilience @Cen4infoRes and de Waal @Tom_deWaal
www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2023/09/15/azerbaijani-tro… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Only two mentions of my #tristia in this compendium review of #mandelstam books by Clare Cavanaugh but they are very complementary – my translations are “elegant” and the book is “splendidly annotated.”
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Overall CC surely asks the important question – does M’s tragic death in the Gulag get in the way of our appreciating his poems, especially the life-affirming verse in a collection like Tristia? www.the-tls.co.uk/articles/osip-mandelstam-ralph-dutli-wo…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Tristia still available here! www.arcpublications.co.uk/books/osip-mandelstam-tristia-681
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Henry Gould
@henryghenrik
oh gosh… here they come… some new Mandelstam books (reviewed in the TLS)
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
ALASTAIR CAMPBELL
@campbellclaret
Arsonist alarmed that people think the fire should be put out …
Roland Smith
@rolandmcs
I do believe someone is starting to worry...
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Robert Ananyan
@robananyan
Yuri Kim, acting Deputy Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs of the US Department of State, announced during a discussion in the US Senate on the humanitarian crisis in Nagorno Karabakh that the US will not tolerate any military action in Nagorno Karabakh.
#usa #armenia #azerbaijan #russia #nagornokarabakh #artsakh #karabakh -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Marina Kaljurand MEP
@MarinaKaljurand
No comment needed, numbers are saying everything: @Europarl_EN condemned arrest of Dr. @gubad_ibadoglu by #azerbaijani authorities and called for his immediate release, as well as release of all political prisoners.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
We live in a weird world where an American pro-Azerbaijani neocon is fighting for the implementation of Putin’s deal of November 2020 for Russian FSB border guards to guard the Zangezur Corridor/route to Nakhchivan across Armenia.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My thoughts today are with my friend Gubad Ibadoglu, LSE scholar and academic, spending his birthday in a Baku jail cell, with many health problems. Accusations are grotesque – including alleged Gulenist links of a man I last met for beer in a London pub. #freegubad now!
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
First delivery of supplies arrives in #karabakh from Azerbaijani side in almost three months, organized by @ICRC Good news but…
Artak Beglaryan | #StopArtsakhGenocide
@Artak_Beglaryan
This morning, the humanitarian truck of the Russian Red Cross entered Artsakh through Aghdam upon the agreement between the parties. The first truck since June 15.
The next step should be access via the Lachin Corridor. Let's see how Azerbaijan honors its commitments & promises.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1. It’s only one truck. Needs are much much bigger 2.Karabakh Armenians say that the deal is now for deliveries to come via Lachin Corridor, where there is a big convoy waiting 3. If that works it gets situation only back to early summer, no agreement on movement of people. Also
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4. Larger threat of conflict still looms. But credit to the diplomats in EU, US (and probably Russia) who got this initial deal through after huge amounts of work. At least the third try in last few months.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Glad to be part of this timely discussion of the current crisis in Berlin tomorrow #karabakh
Silvia Stoeber
@tavisupleba
Event: Blockade of the #lachin Corridor and the Current State of #armenia|n-#azerbaijan|I Relations, on Tuesday, September 12 at 6:30 p.m. at DGAP in Berlin with @meistefan1, @Tom_deWaal and @tavisupleba, moderated by Stefan Weichsel, DGO dgo-online.org/kalender/berlin/2023/blockade-of-the-lachi…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Secretary Antony Blinken
@SecBlinken
The United States calls on Azerbaijan and Armenia to continue working together to resolve outstanding issues through direct dialogue. The Lachin corridor should reopen immediately with additional routes into Nagorno-Karabakh. www.state.gov/urgent-need-for-humanitarian-supplies-into-…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Engelsberg Ideas
@EngelsbergIdeas
Conflict in the South Caucasus could break out for the third time in as many decades. But a compromise may still be possible.
Armenia, Azerbaijan on the brink – again | @Tom_deWaal
engelsbergideas.com/notebook/armenia-azerbaijan-on-the-br… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As EUHR Josep Borrell visits 🇬🇪 today to talk EU candidate status read my article on how #georgia’s ruling party is adopting illiberal Hungary as its model to play with both Europe and Russia. Only on Tuesday… carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
the Georgian and Hungarian foreign ministers repeated the same talking points in Budapest: refusing 🇬🇪 candidate status is “unfair”, they are for “peace” in Ukraine dailynewshungary.com/hungary-supports-georgias-eu-accession/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And here is Borrell, diplomatically, telling the Georgian govt. the ball is in their court and they are not on the right track at the moment. Difficult decisions ahead. #georgia #hungary civil.ge/archives/558132/amp
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
volodymyr dubovyk
@VolodymDubovyk
I do not know if everyone here is following news from Yerevan in the last few days. But they keep on coming. First, PM Pashinyan said that exclusive dependence on Russia does not serve Armenia's security well anymore. This was long time coming.
Next we learn that Pashinyan's wife is coming to Kyiv summit of first ladies and gentlemen. Not only that, but she is bringing some humanitarian assistance with her. First time ever in the context of the ongoing Russian war on Ukraine.
Finally, we see news about the forthcoming joint Armenia-U.S. exercises which are about to commence in a few days from now.
All of this is rasing numerous questions. Is this an ultimate Armenian "zeitenwende"? Or more of an attempt of a balancing act? Is major turnaround even possible? Russia still maintains its base in Gyumri. Will Russia react somehow? Can it even, considering their preoccupation with Ukraine? What can it do?
Is this a sign of Washington trying to seize an opportunity here and fill the vacuum in the Souther Caucasus. Is this a start of a protracted efoort, trend or a one-time thing?
How does all this impact relations in the triangle Yerevan-Baku-Ankara? Surely, all problems there are not going to just disappear, but there must be an impact. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Jonathan Eyal
@JEyal_RUSI
Do read this excellent @Tom_deWaal analysis on the "Orbanisation of Georgia". Few understand the region better than Tom De Waal
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
By enlisting in Viktor Orbán's global culture war, the #georgian elite is aligning itself with authoritarian governments.
The same civilizational discourse comes from the 🇹🇷 and 🇦🇿 presidents, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Ilham Aliyev, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Now in 🇬🇪 Georgia’s illiberal ruling party says it will impeach President Zurabishvili for… “unauthorised” meetings with European leaders. jam-news.net/impeachment-of-the-georgian-president-for-vi…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
For Georgian Dream’s “Orbanizing” strategy read my piece published just yesterday with @Carnegie_Europe carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Politika на русском
@CarnegieRu
Карабахская война 2020 года завершилась явной победой Азербайджана, но точку в конфликте не поставила. Почему угроза новой войны остается реальной — объясняет @Tom_deWaal
carnegieendowment.org/politika/90435 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As the new political season opens in Georgia 🇬🇪 and the EU faces the imminent dilemma on whether to grant the country candidate status, my piece for @Carnegie_Europe on how the government sees Orban’s Hungary as a successful partner and model carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90465
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Luke Harding
@lukeharding1968
‘They want us to die in the streets’: my @guardian piece on the Nagorno-Karabakh blockade, and what Armenians say is an attempt by Baku to stave them into submission www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/22/inside-nagorno-kara…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Ulviyya Asadzade
@UlviyyeAsadzade
check out my new interview with @Tom_deWaal
www.youtube.com/watch?v=u8JBxsPqVZc
#azerbaijan #armenian #karabakh -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My piece on the worsening crisis in and around #karabakh, serious humanitarian needs of local Armenians, ominous signs of new conflict, Azerbaijani hubris/self-confidence and why the world needs to pay much more urgent attention.
engelsbergideas.com/notebook/armenia-azerbaijan-on-the-br…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
“Time is required to resolve a conflict whose levels of complication go as deep as those of Cyprus, Kashmir, and Jerusalem…” but Pres. Aliyev looks to be in a hurry. Everything could come crashing down
Thank you to @EngelsbergIdeas for allowing me to write about this at length -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Adam Sharp
@AdamCSharp
I'd like to take this opportunity to remind everyone that a Finnish version of “they're a few sandwiches short of a picnic” is hänellä ei ole kaikki muumit laaksossa. It means “they don't have all the Moomins in the valley”
#moominsday -
Thomas de Waal reposted
European External Action Service - EEAS 🇪🇺
@eu_eeas
3 years ago, Belarus was robbed of its future. Sham elections led to systematic repression. Thousands were forced into exile and sent to prison. But Belarusians will not be silenced. We stand with them in their fight for justice and free elections. #freebelarus #standwithbelarus
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Chris Bryant
@RhonddaBryant
Hate to point out the obvious but if @RobertJenrick gets his way and 🇬🇧 leaves the European Court of Human Rights and therefore the Council of Europe we shall be joining a select group of Russia 🇷🇺 and Belarus 🇧🇾
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Hard to believe it is 15 years since the #georgia-#russia war of 2008. It feels like yesterday. Some important parallels with the Ukraine war: Russia’s brutal use of force against a neighbour. An important difference too: the Georgian leadership’s reckless and violent actions.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
In my Caucasus book, I tell in detail the story of how the conflict started and the five days of war. Here are three pages of it.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Here are also two pictures from the book. A neighbourhood of Tskhinvali shelled by Georgian artillery. And a burning apartment block in Gori hit by Russian planes. So many tragically died in those five days, they should not be forgotten.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexander Kavtaradze
@alexkavtaradze_
Terrible tragedy in Shovi, Racha (northwestern Georgia). 11 people confirmed dead as the result of the mudslide here. Thinking of all the families and hoping for the best as the search and rescue efforts continue for more than 20 people.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Always read @AndrKolesnikov. Another hugely thought provoking piece from him on the condition of Russian society
Andrei Kolesnikov
@AndrKolesnikov
Are opinion polls possible in a concentration camp? This is a question worth asking, but it leads on logically to another question: do the respondents see themselves as living in a concentration camp? carnegieendowment.org/politika/90327
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Daniel Ofman
@OfmanDaniel
Azerbaijan’s blockade of the Lachin Corridor has resulted in a humanitarian crisis Nagorno-Karabakh. Listen to my latest with sharp comments from @Tigartsakh @ZaurShiriyev and Nina Shahverdyan, a schoolteacher in Stepanakert. @TheWorld @lilithiumm_
theworld.org/stories/2023-08-02/tensions-between-armenia-… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
@ICRC
1/Today, during a humanitarian transfer of 15 patients through the Lachin Corridor by the ICRC, one patient was arrested.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
"The situation has deteriorated to the point where I don't believe in quantitative surveys (...) We use qualitative methods."
🇺🇦 sociologist Tetiana Krivosheya tells @Tom_deWaal about the use of chatbots in polling & how war changed her work & life ⬇️
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/07/06/ukrainian-pollster-on-person… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My interview to Shahin Hajiev of Turan in Baku (in Russian) about the crisis in and around #karabakh #kарабах the Lachin-Aghdam issue, the peace talks, the Russians, threat of a military escalation. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ep5jrWp8xpk
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
In the medium to longer term we can anticipate traffic with Aghdam, but that needs agreement and dialogue with the Karabakh Armenians first who are still deeply afraid of this option, it will not work if it is just declared overnight with no preparation
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My main point is that if there is to be a successful peace process time is needed--a lot of time--to deal with issues that have accumulated over decades and two wars. If Pres. Aliyev tries to force the issue, we risk another conflict. Time to de-escalate.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Out today and I can confirm from reading parts of it that @zakavkaza has done a brilliant job, telling us the story of sanctions, the energy trade and the multiple fronts of economic conflict the Ukraine war has produced.
Maximilian Hess
@zakavkaza
The launch of my book, Economic War, is today!
And Vladimir Putin has decided to advertise it, declaring that the dollar 'is an instrument of political combat' while acknowledging Russia’s challenges in fighting it.
You can read lots more about it here:geni.us/7RWV -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Borrell EU statement on #karabakh is extremely clear: humanitarian situation is grave; Azerbaijan must open the Lachin corridor for supplies; Aghdam road would be complement to #lachin, not alternative; work of @ICRC must not be impeded. Much less clear: what Baku will do
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I spoke to a friend in #karabakh last night who confirmed how terrible the situation is there – food shortages big queues when supplies do appear. No gas and intermittent electricity. Mourners must walk to a funeral because there's no petrol or diesel.
www.icrc.org/en/document/azerbaijan-armenia-sides-must-re…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Azerbaijanis here telling me there is no problem need to ask themselves why even basic supplies are not getting through, even from the ICRC.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Nabila Massrali
@NabilaEUspox
#azerbaijan: The EU is following closely developments related to the arrest of renowned scholar and activist Gubad Ibadoghlu. We call on 🇦🇿to ensure his access to medication, to swiftly release him, and to respect his rights, including his right to due process.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
James Waterhouse
@JamWaterhouse
“They don’t understand what hunger is. People are starving. There’s supply but people are being denied it for no reason.”
Our film from Odesa, a city at the sharp end of Russia’s withdrawal from the grain deal.
With 🎥 @manuelfocus @AakritiThapar @Anastasiia_Lev & Anna TsybaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Giorgi Gogia
@Giorgi_Gogia
Azerbaijan authorities should immediately free renowned scholar & opposition politician Gubad Ibadoghlu & drop bogus charges against him! His arrest falls square in a pattern of pursuing dubious charges against gov’t critics, says @hrw
www.hrw.org/news/2023/07/25/azerbaijan-opposition-leader-… #freegubad! -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
More
International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC)
@ICRC
🧵 Despite persistent efforts, we are currently unable to deliver aid via the Lachin corridor & other routes, including Aghdam.
With these convoys blocked, our concern is that the humanitarian situation will further deteriorate. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
At some point a bad situation simply breaks. Laurence on the extreme situation now in #karabakh. We can say who's culpable (responsibility is shared) and what can be done (few options left for the Karabakhis, let’s be honest). Right now the responsibility is on #azerbaijan
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
to open the Lachin corridor and ease the humanitarian situation.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
...
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Vote Tory if you want more Greek holidays like this one…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Appalling news from Baku. @gubad_ibadoglu Azerbaijani economist and opposition politician, visiting fellow at LSE @LSEIRDept was arrested yesterday. His daughter says her mother was beaten up. www.turan.az/ext/news/2023/7/free/politics_news/en/6746.htm
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Gubad is a tenacious scholarly critic of Azerbaijan's petrostate model and government corruption www.lse.ac.uk/international-relations/people/visiting-fel…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
volodymyr dubovyk
@VolodymDubovyk
Barbarian invasion. Odesa House of Scientists. July 23, 2023. My heart aches so much. This place was like a second home.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
After Russian missiles have wreaked several nights of horrible destruction on #odesa #odessa do please read Tetyana’s stories of the city’s changing identity in wartime. carnegieeurope.eu/2023/07/06/ukrainian-pollster-on-person…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
In very good company here... For summer reading I thoroughly recommend @Gospodinov68 's magnificent time-twisting novel, @ArkadyOstrovsky 's podcast series on Russia, plus Warwick Ball's history of the Eurasian steppe carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/90218
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
From Transdniestria to Karabakh, non-state entities and breakaway states in the former Soviet space are in trouble. Some thoughts on this in my interview to Ilya Roubanis for @Caucasus_Watch caucasuswatch.de/en/interviews/statelets-and-the-russian-…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
IWM
@IWM_Vienna
Listen to IWM Permanent Fellow @IVejvoda and @EuropesFutures Fellow @BalazsJarabik discuss the future of Ukraine and its neighbors in a Europe forever changed by the full-scale Russian invasion of 24 February 2022:
www.iwm.at/podcasts/vienna-coffee-house-conversations-wit… @erstefoundation -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Very sad to learn of the death of Richard Hovannisian. It's touching to see the tributes to him from all round the world. His books on the Armenian First Republic will remain the classic texts. I will remember a fine gentleman who was always generous with his time and thoughts.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
It makes no sense now to just ask people questions, 🇺🇦 sociologist Tetiana Krivosheya told @Tom_deWaal.
"We are preoccupied with one thing now: we want victory. [...] We need to stop going to funerals, stop going crazy, stop being afraid of missiles."
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/07/06/ukrainian-pollster-on-person… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Today is the 100th anniversary of the formation of the NKAO (Nagorny Karabakh Autonomous Region) within Soviet Azerbaijan in 1923. Not a date either Armenians or Azerbaijanis will be marking. Meanwhile the humanitarian situation in #karabakh remains dire. oc-media.org/features/food-shortages-and-fear-as-peacekee…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Series 2 of @BBCSteveR vs Lukashenko. He asks yet more tough questions on #prigozhin, nuclear weapons, political prisoners in #belarus. All delivered calmly and the big man calls him "Steve" in response. This will be taught in journalism classes for years!
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
In Minsk I ask Alexander Lukashenko:
• would he allow Wagner to attack Ukraine from Belarus?
• would he have a say in launching Russian tactical nuclear weapons?
• about human rights in Belarus.
Producer @LizaShuvalova @BBCNewsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🆕 | How do you conduct a #poll in a country at war?
"On the one hand, we're sociologists and we need to be objective. On the other hand, it's not just that our society has changed—we've changed as well . . ." Tetiana Krivosheya told @Tom_deWaal.
Read ⤵️
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/07/06/ukrainian-pollster-on-person… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My interview with #odesa/#odessa sociologist Tetyana Krivosheya, on being a sociologist in wartime, what polls can't and can tell us, the changing identity of the city, the personal toll the war takes on everyone. "We need to stop going to funerals..." carnegieeurope.eu/2023/07/06/ukrainian-pollster-on-person…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Max Fras
@maxfras
Tbilisi changing from a hub of Russian opposition and independent media to a hub for rich Russians flying to the French Riviera is an absolute disgrace
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The coverage of Ukraine, Russia and Eastern Europe at @opendemocracyru is always some of the most original and intellectually challenging. I enjoy writing for them over the years and hope to continue to do so. A worthy recipient of donations!
Tom Rowley
@te_rowley
Hi everyone. We’re raising money for @opendemocracyru’s survival at the moment. We’ve already raised £50,000 from private donors, but to get it, we need your help – and that means every £/$/€ you give us is effectively doubled.
support.opendemocracy.net/odr-crowdfunder -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Uilleam Blacker 🇺🇦
@BlackerUilleam
When Victoria Amelina spoke at @UCLSSEES in April, she'd just written a poem about her experiences talking to women and documenting Russian war crimes in de-occupied areas. Here's a video of her reading the original; my translation is below. So painful to listen to this now. 1/2
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Katarina Mathernova 🇪🇺
@kmathernova
Busy day online - chairing my last #wbif Strategic Board & saying goodbye to great community of supporters of #westernbalkans, and addressing EU enlargement & Ukraine Moldova Georgia at @Carnegie_Europe and @dgapev Advisory Board. Inspiring discussion all around!
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ EU Enlargement is back! But there are big obstacles ahead.
Read the new paper in the @Carnegie_Europe #europeseast series by Kataryna Wolczuk
on the prospects of #ukraine, #moldova and #georgia joining the EU and “avoiding Purgatory.”
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/06/28/overcoming-eu-accession-chal…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
10/ The trouble is proposals like that require institutional reform, eg to switch from unanimity to qualified majority voting (QMV) on accession landmarks. Again an issue of political will.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
11/ So… European leaders acknowledge the
historic importance of a new wave of enlargement on a declarative level, but a plan to make it happen is not yet a reality. Now read the paper! carnegieeurope.eu/2023/06/28/overcoming-eu-accession-chal… ENDS -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
So awful. Two latest young victims of Russian missiles. I've heard that large proportion of Ukrainian population (I heard 50 percent but cannot verify) know personally someone who died in the war.
Jeremy Bowen
@BowenBBC
These 14 year old twin sisters, Yulia and Anna Aksenchenko were killed in the Russian attack on Kramatorsk in eastern Ukraine. Total of 9 dead identified so far including another child and more than 50 wounded. Photo released by the city council t.me/kramatorsk_rada/12986
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Listen if you can!
IWM
@IWM_Vienna
A spectacular discussion between Ivan Krastev & @TimothyDSnyder awaits you. Can't be on site? Well, then just
www.youtube.com/live/rqCGUVYkcmM -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Michael Kofman
@KofmanMichael
A few thoughts on Prigozhin's armed insurrection/mutiny/rebellion. For now it appears over. Wagner seems to be standing down, and leaving Rostov for LNR. Prigozhin launched a mutiny that ultimately challenged Putin’s power, and the system. Thread. 1/
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Sam Greene
@samagreene
Well, that made no sense whatsoever.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
IWM
@IWM_Vienna
As part of the @EuropesFutures Symposium at @cas_see_uniri, IWM Rector @MishaGlenny will deliver the Erhard Busek Memorial Lecture, followed by a panel discussion with @EuropesFutures Fellows @NathalieTocci & @StefanLehne.
Follow the livestream here:
www.youtube.com/live/h2_uBbEsyCY -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Good timing @JohnLechner1 !
John Lechner
@JohnLechner1
I've been waiting a few months to say this, but now seems as good a time as any... Excited to announce that I am writing a book on #wagner and #prigozhin with @BloomsburyPub!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Mark Galeotti
@MarkGaleotti
All still pretty unclear as to Prigozhin's rebellion, but am struck by the uncompromising language in Putin's emergency address in which he denounces this as treason and a betrayal of the Fatherland 1/
kremlin.ru/events/president/news/71496 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Kristof Bender
@kristofbender
Fascinating presentation on #ukraine identity and relations with #russia by @Forostyna at @EuropesFutures symposion organised by @IWM_Vienna in Cres, can be watched online here: www.youtube.com/live/-fahoGtKHoY.
@erstefoundation -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
It's bad enough that Levan Berdenishvili--intellectual, writer, ex-chief librarian of Georgian, former political prisoner, a man who should be a national hero-- was assaulted and abused in the middle of Tbilisi... one of several such incidents recently, civil.ge/archives/548945
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
But now chief ruling party talking head normalizes the violence, pointing to Berdzenishvili's comments about 18th century monarch King Erekle II. Of course this is a debate not so much about history as about relations with Russia. www.interpressnews.ge/en/article/125944-irakli-kobakhidze…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
In solidarity with Levan, and because it is a fantastic and witty book, do read his amazing Soviet prison memoir Sacred Darkness www.europaeditions.com/book/9781609454920/sacred-darkness
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Jaka Bartolj mediahistorynow.bsky.social
@MediaHistoryNow
I'm currently rereading @Tom_deWaal's wonderful 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘊𝘢𝘶𝘤𝘢𝘴𝘶𝘴: 𝘈𝘯 𝘐𝘯𝘵𝘳𝘰𝘥𝘶𝘤𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯, which mentions how such environment-centered approaches are also the key for sustainable tourism in the highland areas of the Caucasus:
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tom Parfitt
@parfitt_tom
Six weeks today until publication of my memoir, High Caucasus: A Mountain Quest in Russia's Haunted Hinterland (July 20)...
Pre-orders and reviews very welcome! geni.us/highcaucasus
I'm extremely grateful to authors who have endorsed the book>> -
Thomas de Waal reposted
SUSPILNE NEWS 📰
@suspilne_news
📸Residents of the flooded Korabel district in Kherson are trying to save their and their neighbors' animals.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is a brave and important piece by @KaterynaZarembo for @Carnegie_Europe We all see the resilience of Ukrainians and we know the cost, but what the cost is less talked about and analysed carnegieeurope.eu/2023/06/01/resilience-and-trauma-of-ukr…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
what the cost is is less talked about
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Inspiring scenes from Chisinau, great to see. But a lot of work to be done to further #moldova's EU accession...
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
As I say here also: carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89732
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Politika на русском
@CarnegieRu
Молдаване получили то, чего в менее экстремальных условиях им пришлось бы дожидаться не один десяток лет: статус кандидата на вступление в Евросоюз. Однако сохранить набранный темп евроинтеграции и не свернуть с этого пути будет сложнее, пишет @Tom_deWaal carnegieendowment.org/politika/89795
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
If Russia has a light touch on Transdniestria, that is also because it still has bigger designs for Moldovan politics as a whole.
🇲🇩 elections are won in the middle ground and a large minority of the population still looks to Russia, writes @Tom_deWaal.
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89732 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Good news yesterday that the Black Sea Grain Initiative was extended for 60 days. A pattern: Russia makes a fuss and then extends. For broader context see the @Carnegie_Europe podcast on the Black Sea with @DimitarBechev
carnegieeurope.eu/europeinsideout
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
See also my essay on #odessa #odesa the city of grain, and much else besides, published yesterday. The grain deal is a lifeline for its economy.
engelsbergideas.com/essays/how-war-made-odessa-more-ukrai…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The bad news yesterday: 30 Russian missiles launched at the city, 29 of them shot down. The worst attack in a long time. Just a coincidence that it coincided with the grain deal?
www.reuters.com/world/falling-debris-causes-fires-two-kyi… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On #odessa #odesa, a city that went to bed on Feb 23 2022 speaking Russian and woke up in wartime speaking Ukrainian. The city identifies with Ukraine as never before but there are still tensions with Kyiv. My essay published today with @EngelsbergIdeas engelsbergideas.com/essays/how-war-made-odessa-more-ukrai…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Also my ancestral city: a place of grain, humour, cats, culture and secular Jewish tradition that will always enthral. I was so glad to be back, even in wartime.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Yes
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
After a year of non-stop crisis #moldova is launched on a EU accession track But the public took a big economic hit last year and support for the govt. has fallen. Over to you, Brussels! My piece for @Carnegie_Europe with thanks to @IWM @EuropesFutures carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89732
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The one and only @BBCSteveR! Fine Kremlinologist and also Eurovision afficionado extraordinary...
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
Just another day at work: played #eurovision classics at a piano party, accompanied the incredible Rebecca Ferguson singing Let It Be…and held hands with Mel Giedroyc. Here’s our report for #bbcnews10 @bbceurovision @Eurovision @RebeccaFMusic
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The latest chapter in the contestation of the Black Sea: the situation in Odessa, the grain deal, Crimea, the future of the Montreux convention--all in the latest episode of the @Carnegie_Europe podcast with @DimitarBechev europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/why-black-sea-i…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Some good news on the Armenia-Azerbaijan front as Blinken reports “tangible progress” after talks in Washington.
The issue here is a bilateral framework agreement between the two countries. The US has been working hard on a draft text for months.
www.state.gov/secretary-antony-j-blinken-at-the-bilateral…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Positive but worth bearing in mind two things:
There will be no real until there is a peaceful resolution of the Karabakh issue. Any talk of NK secession is now off the table, in Yerevan too, the formula is now "protection of rights and security" of NK Armenians
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Yet, Baku continues to be highly aggressive towards the Karabakh Armenians, keeps the Lachin Corridor closed for almost five months now. Humanitarian situation in NK itself is worsening.
jam-news.net/ongoing-blockade-in-nk/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Also: Moscow wants its own meeting in the exact same format. That raises the risks of “forum-shopping” as the parties to the conflict look for a better deal with a different mediator. Russia has its own agenda here, obviously, as it always has... www.armenpress.am/eng/news/1110128/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
real peace
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Tymofiy Mylovanov
@Mylovanov
What language do Ukrainians speak in Kyiv? Russian propaganda says people afraid to speak Russian in fear of prosecution. Ukrainians say Kyiv is multilingual and people are free to speak any language. I took a walk this morning and counted. 1/
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The EU's enlargement eastward is a geopolitical imperative but the process needs fixing. Joining 15 others to discuss this crucial topic for @Judy_Dempsey and @Carnegie_Europe I hope the people at @eu_near are reading...
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
🇪🇺 | Is the EU Ready for Further Enlargement?
Russia's invasion of Ukraine has made EU #enlargement a geopolitical imperative.
But internal reforms may be needed before the union can integrate new members.
16 experts answer @Judy_Dempsey's question
👉 carnegieeurope.eu/p-89678 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Three great books in a tough competition
The EBRD
@EBRD
A big day for #ebrdliteratureprize2023!
Our distinguished judges @tobylichtig @mayajaggi @arkadyostrovsky @natasharandall have chosen the finalists!
Congratulations to all three:
www.ebrd.com/news/2023/ebrd-literature-prize-2023-three-f… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A new chapter begins in Berlin for our Carnegie colleagues with the opening of the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center. Wishing them all the best and looking forward to collaboration
Carnegie Endowment
@CarnegieEndow
Today we proudly announce the launch of the Carnegie Russia Eurasia Center in Berlin, our fifth global center.
Carnegie President Tino Cuéllar spoke about the work and mission of the new center, click the link below to learn more:
carnegieendowment.org/posts/2023/04/carnegie-endowment-fo… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
For the best analysis on the fighting in #sudan, the "rivalrous oligopoly" of the two sides and the bleak perspectives ahead read my brother Alex, who has known the country for almost 40 years. @WorldPeaceFdtn sites.tufts.edu/reinventingpeace/2023/04/19/sudans-new-wa…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Footage of a huge cemetery of Wagner dead near Novosibirsk
Сибирь Пост
@SibirPost
Массовое захоронение с символикой ЧВК «Вагнер» и российскими флагами найдено на кладбище в Новосибирске.
Часть фамилий удалось подтвердить. Многие прежде вообще не упоминались в официальных некрологах
tayga.info/181446 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"It's not a competition." Very eloquent from @Dannythefink and a truth to be applied to many other historical atrocities as well...
Times Radio
@TimesRadio
“My mother was in Belsen concentration camp… she always used to say, it’s not a competition. That is exactly the mistake that Diane Abbott has made.”
@DannytheFink says Diane Abbott and Jeremy Corbyn “refuse to recognise” oppression that “doesn’t fit” in their worldview.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On the saddest day in the Armenian calendar, when Armenians remember more than one million ancestors killed and a culture destroyed, find a moment for this poignant folk song saved by the composer Komitas and beautifully played by the @Chilingirians.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzvySN6spfo
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
More Armenian music, family history and the tragic story of Komitas all set out here by the Chilingirians chilingirianquartet.co.uk/armenian-komitas-songs/
(Worrying developments in the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict but that can wait till tomorrow.)
#armeniangenocideday -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
#odesa #odessa keeps its sense of humour in time of war. Signs on a closed shop (in Ukrainian) “We are working but because of one as*hole we have to invest in plywood” and “When that as*hole dies we’ll have celebratory 70% discounts” (I’m told the word is good local slang)
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Also, in Russian: “No entry to people with a bad sense of humour” and “We have no WiFi but we can sell you the neighbour’s password.” Plus they speak Odesa language (Of course they do with signs like that)
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
So glad to be back in #odessa #odesa: rainy, subdued, a bit battered, quite empty, but slowly coming back to life. A firm belief here that Russians can never take this city. Military defences are now secure, port working partially again thanks to UN grain deal.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A trip of research and solidarity with wonderful @iwm_Vienna colleagues from @EuropesFutures Futures programme. Here we are in front of plinth of the now removed Catherine the Great statue (only put up in 2007)
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A joyful moment! Standing again outside the old Ephrussi family house, in the finest location in the city, where my ancestors lived in the 19th century. The Boulevard is closed for security reasons but the view from the back gate on the opera house is still pretty good!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Kristof Bender
@kristofbender
🇲🇩has the highest nr of🇺🇦refugees pc in Europe and Russian troops on its territory. This small (and often neglected) country has impressively managed war effects, but needs more support by🇪🇺& MS. Insightful visit to #chisinau organised by @IWM_Vienna's @EuropesFutures programme.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
“The irony of the ‘Pushkin must fall’ statue programme in Ukraine is that Pushkin himself might well have shrugged his shoulders at it – and quite probably approved of it. The poet distrusted statues and the idolisation they embodied.”
engelsbergideas.com/essays/taking-pushkin-off-his-pedestal/Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
So my essay is about the push-and-pull between the venerated Pushkin of the imperial/Soviet state and the "poet of freedom" who inspired Herzen, Sinyavsky, Tsvetaeva, Dovlatov and Mamardashvili. And how Russian literature has been fetishized in unhealthy ways.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My thanks to @AlexEtkind , @sophiepinkhmmm , @BananaKarenina whose work guided me in writing this. Also to Robert Chandler, Marcus Levitt, Anna Narinskaya.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/04/13/new-opening-for-eu-central-a… Central Asia in the spotlight in Anna's important new paper for @Carnegie_Europe. Read it all! Her expertise takes us deep into issues so often discussed superficially eg to what extent is Russian influence declining, how viable is the Middle Corridor?
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Also, the limits of the EU's normative power in the region and the reasons for a failure to build regional integration in #centralasia
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Richard Giragosian
@Richard_RSC
Fighting in southern #armenia has ceased. Situation stable but casualties on both sides. Demonstrates dangerous lack of deterrence & risk of sudden escalation. Combat operation targeting Armenia is a significant expansion of battle space & interstate conflict by Azerbaijan
Richard Giragosian
@Richard_RSC
initial reports of sudden escalation in southern Armenia with Azerbaijani attacks quickly expanding to include sustained mortar fire; fears of mounting casualties
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I'm excited! Published today: my translation of Osip Mandelstam’s 1922 collection Tristia. It’s a very personal project I’ve been working on for more than 30 years (really!) So glad to see it published in a beautiful edition by @Arc_Poetry
www.arcpublications.co.uk/books/osip-mandelstam-tristia-681Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
If you're on London on April 12 the book launch at @Pushkin_House is open to all, so long as you register
www.pushkinhouse.org/events/mandelstams-tristia-translate…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And you can peek inside the book here. Enjoy! www.arcpublications.co.uk/books/osip-mandelstam-tristia-6…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A lot going on in the world but keep watching the deteriorating #armenia-#azerbaijan situation if you can. Lachin corridor to #karabakh now blocked by Azerbaijanis for 100 days. Latest aggressive speech by Pres Aliyev: "Armenia must accept our conditions" caspiannews.com/news-detail/president-aliyev-reveals-cond…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
US Sec of State Blinken talking to both leaders in last couple of days, calls for reopening Lachin road, reviving "peace process" that is in severe trouble. I presume EU leaders are also making calls, it would be good to hear from them in public too. www.state.gov/secretary-blinkens-call-with-azerbaijani-pr…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And this is my recent piece on "Armenia's year of insecurity" which was quite bleak then but would even bleaker now. The risk all too great of more violence. carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89157
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Thanks to the @NewEastEurope team! I talk here about the fallout of the Ukraine war in the Caucasus, the Lachin Corridor crisis (now in its 101st day), real threats of new #armenia-#azerbaijan violence talkeasterneurope.eu/episodes/episode-133-the-blockade-of…
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Since Russia began its war on #ukraine in February 2022, we have seen a different EU in Eastern Europe.
But if it is serious about deeper integration, the 🇪🇺 must find the funds & words to win over new societal constituencies, says @Tom_deWaal.
More 👇 carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89278 -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Vladislav Davidzon
@VladDavidzon
92 year old Russian lady lucidly explains the “savagery of those raised by Russian television”
Daniel Hamilton 🇺🇦💪
@danielrhamilton
Well this didn’t quite go to plan, did it? 😂
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I only wish there was the time to read these great titles in the #ebrdliteratureprize2023 Being a judge two years ago was a mind-expanding experience and the same may be even truer today.
The EBRD
@EBRD
🥁 #ebrdliteratureprize2023 shortlist is out! 📚
Our judges @tobylichtig, @mayajaggi @arkadyostrovsky, @natasharandall selected the 10 best works of literature from our regions translated into English.
Congratulations!
www.ebrd.com/news/2023/ebrd-literature-prize-2023-shortli…
The shortlisted titles are 🧵: -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I was in good company here tackling a big question -- the EU's Eastern Europe strategy.
Judy Dempsey
@Judy_Dempsey
Great answers. 🇪🇺has to revamp its strategy for our E neighbors🇲🇩🇧🇾🇬🇪🇦🇲🇺🇦 many tks @KristiRaik @MartinCZV4EU @AlenaKudzko @JohnOBrennan2 @Tom_deWaal @B_Lebanidze @NonaMikhelidze @radniankou @sinikukka @AndriyTyushka @Elizabiet
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89278 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Things are looking ominous in #karabakh #armenia #azerbaijan Lachin Corridor still closed. Tough maximalist rhetoric from Baku seems to reject any option but enforced integration of the NK Armenians with no autonomy or international security provision.
jam-news.net/azerbaijans-reaction-to-pashinyans-statement/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
No Armenian leader will accept this--even Pashinyan who has gone quite far in the last year. No sign of the Charles Michel talks restarting, as long as Lachin crisis continues. So the threat grows of more violence.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
European position restated by Chancellor Scholz with Pres. Aliyev this week, restating principles of Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity, need to protect “rights and security” of NK Armenians and peaceful resolution. But attention of course is limited.
www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/aktuelles/aserbaidschans-p… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Ivana Stradner
@ivanastradner
Russia in the UN Security Council meeting accused the West of Russophobia. The UK had a brilliant strategy - they turned the tables on Russia and accused the Kremlin of ruining the reputation of Russia. @ferguseckersley spoke in Russian. This is really good. 🇬🇧👏
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Margo Gontar 🔱
@MargoGontar
This is Oleksandra. She is 6. She lost her leg in russian missile attack on Zatoka village, near Odesa. In summer 2022 she went to Austria for rehabilitation, in October she got her prosthesis and began learning to walk again and now is getting back to gymnastics training💪🔥
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Excellent analysis of the current crisis in Georgia 🇬🇪 the deeper systemic issues driving GD’s authoritarian turn and the EU’s conditionality dilemma carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89260 @k_kakachia @B_Lebanidze
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The core of the issue in two paragraphs
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
BBC please take note
Royal Academy of Music
@RoyalAcadMusic
Today we welcomed @BBCSingers for a masterclass with our choral conducting students. For nearly 20 years we've been proud to work with #bbcsingers. We cannot overestimate the importance of exceptional role models like them for the future of music > www.ram.ac.uk/news/academy-leads-charge-against-bbc-cuts
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal reposted
CRRC Georgia
@crrcgeorgia
This week on the Caucasus Data Blog, @GilbreathDustin takes a look at how the public felt about the government's performance on getting Georgia EU candidate status, prior to the foreign agents law's introduction:
oc-media.org/features/datablog-is-the-georgian-government… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
The Cultural Tutor
@culturaltutor
Why do people wear these pointless bits of fabric called ties?
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Giorgi Gogia
@Giorgi_Gogia
Vigilance is needed! At least twice 🇬🇪’s ruling party did U-turn on promises given to calm popular protests. They should
-Vote the bills down
-Investigate legitimacy &proportionality of used police force
-Ensure due process of detainees
-Ensure enabling envirnment 4 civil society
Giorgi Gogia
@Giorgi_Gogia
Mood is cautiously festive in 🇬🇪Georgia. Excited that authorities backtracked from adopting Russian-style foreign agent law that would silence critical voices in the country. However, they withdrew not because they disagreed with it, but claiming failed PR civil.ge/archives/530265
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
OC Media
@OCMediaorg
BREAKING: Georgian Dream and People’s Power have announced that they are ‘unconditionally’ rescinding the draft foreign influence law, following two nights of protests in Tbilisi.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
The Gesualdo Six
@TheGesualdoSix
The BBC Singers are at the pinnacle of the UK’s choral scene – a beacon for choral broadcasting around the world, and an inspiration to ensembles like us.
The news that they are to be disbanded is appalling. We hope this decision can be reversed.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-64875989 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 Pay attention to #georgia 🇬🇪 today! A THREAD Last night police in Tbilisi forcibly dispersed a protest against a new Foreign Agent law rushed through parliament. It’s an escalation by the ever more authoritarian Georgian Dream govt
Reuters
@Reuters
Protesters in Tbilisi shielded a woman waving an EU flag from a water cannon directed at them, as police in the ex-Soviet state of Georgia tried to break up a protest outside parliament against a draft law on ‘foreign agents’ www.reuters.com/world/europe/georgian-police-use-tear-gas…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
11 I think the agenda is more isolationist, and to play up conservative nativist patriotic sentiments. The preferred state model looks more like Azerbaijan: balance between West and Russia, consolidate one-party rule, control institutions, end scrutiny of NGOs and journalists.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
12 All told, it’s a big moment for Georgia, still a democracy, but definitely a struggling one. Sending solidarity today to all my Georgian friends.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is a long conversation I did with the Armenian Mer Herosner podcast. I guess I’m not their usual kind of guest but we had a good substantial discussion about the history of the #karabakh conflict and my book Black Garden. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lf8Z9BHy0qY
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Important days in the war in eastern Ukraine, a major crisis in Georgia, but don’t forget also the situation in and around #karabakh. Here's the piece I published a week ago on “Armenia’s insecurity” for @Carnegie_Europe @Judy_Dempsey
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89157Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My main point: the ARM-AZ situation is very volatile, it can tip into more violence, or there could be a framework peace agreement. PM Pashinyan has gone out on a limb, but Pres. Aliyev continues to press and make the Armenians insecure--a situation which Russia exploits.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The piece was criticized by parts of Azerbaijani and Armenian Twitter (predictably!), judge for yourself!
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A super talk earlier today at KCL by @DrRadchenko on his forthcoming 1000-page book on Soviet foreign policy in the Cold War. There was both intellectual rigor and anecdote -- Hegel, Brezhnev's obsessions and how you can't hide nuclear missiles under Cuban palm trees
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The big theme Sergei spelled out--that a lot of Soviet actions were guided by a craving for "recognition" by the US and China as a serious power in he world, their obsession with Great Power status above all else--has a big resonance in the Putin era obviously
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The book will evidently reshape a lot of thinking about the Cold War. It will be a door-stop for sure but also a must-read
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Alexander Kavtaradze
@alexkavtaradze_
I believe the Georgian gov. party has miscalculated the response that their “foreign agent” bill would have from the 🇬🇪 society and here’s why 👇
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A very important few days in Georgia 🇬🇪
JAMnews
@JAMnewsCaucasus
🇬🇪Currently in #tbilisi, protestors are rallying against the bill "On Foreign Influence", which all independent media, non-governmental organizations, the opposition, the president and Western partners of the country consider to be a copy of the Russian law on foreign agents.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
gunnerblog
@gunnerblog
Sadly that will be my last Arsenal game as I officially died
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This is quite historic. Azerbaijan has named a representative to talk to the #karabakh Armenians. I first advocated direct Baku-Stepanakert dialogue about 25 years ago (!) So glad to see this happening, even if the context is quite grim.
caliber.az/en/post/149259/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Hopefully they will meet again by themselves without Russian peacekeepers in the room. Interesting to note also the mention of the mining issue--confirming the views of experts such as Arif Yunus who say that a dispute over mine ownership was a factor in the current crisis.
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
#armenia is still in a state of semi-permanent crisis that predates Russia's war on Ukraine.
There are some bleak scenarios for how 2023 could end: more violence with Azerbaijan, pressure from Russia, and domestic political turmoil.
Read @Tom_deWaal 👇
carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89157 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Richly deserved. Watch if you haven't yet done so
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
Our interview with Alexander Lukashenko has won the Royal Television Society Network Interview of the Year award. An honour for us & a real team effort with my superb colleagues @BBCWillVernon @mattgodtv @AntonChicherov. Here’s an excerpt. Full interview www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZdxBOOnVgnY
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"The Frankensteins had to disown their monster." @fotoole on top form on the #protocol deal www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/feb/28/deal-2021-b…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just published: my column for @Carnegie_Europe on #armenia, Pashinyan's risk-taking and how much depends on how #azerbaijan decides to act. carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/89157
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The UN, unusually, weighing in to warn about the impact of the "foreign agent" law in the Georgian parliament
Nick Beresford
@NickBeresford2
"The United Nations in Georgia expresses profound concern that adoption of the draft Law on Transparency of Foreign Influence would risk impeding the work of civil society and media and the essential contributions they make to Georgian democracy" www.undp.org/georgia/news/un-statement-on-draft-law-on-tr…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
We mustn’t lose the sense of raw shock and outrage at what Russia did one year ago. Indifference and “normalization” of this hideous war is surely the biggest danger, as it drags on
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A peaceful European country is experiencing an unprovoked invasion unseen since the Second World War. Heartbreaking, tragic and totally senseless.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On the eve of the first anniversary of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, it's worth re-reading this piece by my Carnegie colleagues, @andrewsweiss and Eugene Rumer from Nov 2021 on Putin's "unfinished business." They called it exactly right. carnegieendowment.org/2021/11/12/ukraine-putin-s-unfinish…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Armenian-Russian businessman Ruben Vardanyan is ousted from his position as "state minister" of Nagorny #karabakh. Perhaps a solution to the Lachin road crisis now in the offing. And something that Harutyunan, Aliyev and Pashinyan were all seeking... president.nkr.am/ru/news/consultations/5726/
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Two factors contributing to this. One, as others noting here, the ICJ judgement calling on Azerbaijan to re-open the Lachin Corridor (and also referring to "Nagorno-Karabakh" and the November 2020 agreement) www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/2023-02/180-20230222-…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The other, negotiations at the Munich Security Conference on opening direct Baku-Stepanakert talks--but the Azerbaijanis insisted they would not talk to Vardanyan. More details here interfax.com/newsroom/top-stories/88205/
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
IWM
@IWM_Vienna
Tune in to our YouTube channel for today's discussion with @Tom_deWaal and @IVejvoda, starting at 6pm CET:
www.youtube.com/live/rETmJ78eQfA -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Civil.ge
@CivilGe
Sovereignist People's Power faction of the majority presented the draft on "foreign agents." We have summarized the draft law's content, which will impose #russia style curbs on civil society groups.
civil.ge/archives/525575 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
This Friday in Vienna
IWM
@IWM_Vienna
This Friday, @EuropesFutures Fellow @Tom_deWaal will speak about how the Russo-Ukrainian War has ended the concepts of “the Near Abroad” & the “post-Soviet space” & what this means for Russia’s own cohesion, state identity & relations with its neighbors:
www.iwm.at/event/end-of-the-near-abroad -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The Turkey-Syria earthquake is the most horrible event to hit this region for decades. If one small good thing has come out of it, it's the opening of the ARM-TR border to allow Armenian aid to come in -- and the Turkish govt's welcoming of that. And it's harder now to close it.
Serdar KILIÇ
@serdarkilic9
Depremin hemen akabindeki 28 kişilik A/K ekibi ve teknik ekipmana ilaveten,Ermenistan halkının 5 TIR dolusu 100 tonluk gıda,ilaç,su ve sair acil yardım paketi de bu sabah Alican sınır kapısından geçerek Adıyaman'a doğru yola çıktı.Teşekkürler @RubenRubinyan teşekkürler Ermenistan
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A decade since Akram Aylisli's books were burned in Azerbaijan. Time to lift the restrictions on a tireless advocated of Azerbaijani-Armenia dialogue and reconciliation!
Pushkin House
@Pushkin_House
Today marks 10 years since protesters in western Azerbaijan have burned books by a novelist Akram Aylisli, because of his novel 'Stone Dreams', which described sensitive issues in relations between Azerbaijan and Armenia. (continues in comments)
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
OC Media
@OCMediaorg
EXCLUSIVE: A new survey from Azerbaijani think-tank the Agora Analytical Collective shows which countries young Azerbaijanis like and dislike, which they see as a threat or an ally, and their views on the conflict with Armenia.
oc-media.org/features/analysis-how-azerbaijans-youth-feel… -
Thomas de Waal reposted
Rachel King
@heartovglass
After an enormous effort on the part of many, and the patient discretion of the finder, we were delighted to announce the discovery of this marvelous #tudor heart-shaped pendant yesterday. Thank you to everybody who has shared their knowledge thus far... work will continue
Treasure Registrars
@TRegistrars
The British Museum announced the discovery of an impressive Tudor-period gold and enamel heart pendant and chain from Warwickshire : finds.org.uk/database/artefacts/record/id/985944 reported to @StaffsWMFLO
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
Martin Schüepp
@M_Schuepp
Access to urgent medical care is vital.
Acting as a neutral humanitarian intermediary enables the @ICRC to facilitate such access 👇 www.icrc.org/en/document/operational-update-situation-alo… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Bad news. Relations between Azerbaijan and Iran already worsening before this
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
On the #karabakh blockade, Russia's weakness and inaction, the security vacuum in the Caucasus, and the challenge to the EU. My piece in today's @ftopinion #armenia #azerbaijan www.ft.com/content/4ebb88a2-9237-4597-b9c3-a0a4ed2a63e6
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
#serbia has been Europe's outlier since the Ukraine war began, keeping its links with Russia, despite being an EU candidate country. In our new #europeseast paper for @Carnegie_Europe @DimitarBechev explains Vucic’s game of playing both sides. Read it!
carnegieeurope.eu/2023/01/19/hedging-its-bets-serbia-betw… -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A great tour d'horizon on 2023 holds for Turkey (a lot) by our two superb Turkey watchers @sinanulgen1 and @MarcPierini1 in the new episode of the @Carnegie_Europe podcast #europeinsideout europe-inside-out.simplecast.com/episodes/how-2023-could-…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Next week in Brussels with @meistefan1, @LaureDelcour & @RosaBalfour discussing the EU's longer-term policy on the Eastern neighbourhood and Russia. But it's an in-person event only!
Carnegie Europe
@Carnegie_Europe
Nearly one year into Putin's war on #ukraine, the EU must rethink its longer-term Russia policy & better integrate its Eastern neighbors.
Next Wednesday, @meistefan1, @LaureDelcour, @Tom_deWaal, & @RosaBalfour will discuss how this can be done.
Register: carnegieeurope.eu/e-8015 -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
www.saveur.com/culture/pankisi-valley-kist-cuisine/ A lovely piece of food and cultural writing by @BenKKemper on visiting Georgia's Pankisi Valley and learning how to cook Kist khinkali. Re-presenting a place that's still tainted by old stereotypes.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Today marks a month of Azerbaijan’s blockade of the Armenian population of Nagorny Karabakh. It’s a bad situation getting worse: a developing humanitarian crisis and a sad harbinger of more conflict in 2023. I'm quoted in this piece on CNN today edition.cnn.com/2023/01/12/europe/armenia-azerbaijan-nago…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
And this is a longer interview (in Russian) I gave to the independent Turan news agency in Azerbaijan, where I get to say a lot more www.youtube.com/watch?v=bmZbET6lSEk
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A big question remains why Russia is so inactive as its 2020 ceasefire deal is undermined. For sure Russia is weaker due to its war in Ukraine and wants to keep Azerbaijan on side. As I say, it's very likely a lot of bargaining with Baku is going on behind the scenes.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 Still a grave situation in and around Karabakh, between #armenia and #azerbaijan. A few comments. Azerbaijanis still blocking the #lachin road to Nagorny #karabakh and the situation there worsens with each day. @hrw the latest to voice alarm
www.hrw.org/news/2022/12/21/azerbaijan-nagorno-karabakh-l…Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3 Armenian PM Pashinyan today lashes out at the Russians for inaction--a message that won't go down well in Moscow. www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/12/22/armenia-pm-blames-russi…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
4 Another factor. My old friend Arif Yunus setting out here why a dispute over lucrative mining concessions is worth watching. Arif is one of those who see the Ruben Vardanyan factor as a big reason for official Azerbaijani frustration
www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-krn6jgy2YPost not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8 Arm. side meanwhile presses for parallel negotiations on NK and guarantees for the people there. The EU also uses that language. As we see in last 2 years, when the Arm. side plays for time, Azerbaijan resorts to coercive tactics or force. A spiral of distrust and violence.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
9 Not much to celebrate here, but let’s hope the humanitarian situation in NK eases as soon as possible. Happy Holidays all the same!
-
Thomas de Waal reposted
The Cultural Tutor
@culturaltutor
Today is the winter solstice - the first day of the season. So here is a thread of the most beautiful paintings of winter:
The Hunters in the Snow by Pieter Bruegel the Elder (1565) -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ On the long and toxic legacy of Zviad #gamsakhurdia, Georgia’s disastrous first nationalist president, for this week’s @hated_and_dead podcast. If #georgia has done well in the last 30 years it's despite not because of Zviad.
The Hated and the Dead Podcast
@hated_and_dead
This week’s episode concerns Zviad Gamsakhurdia, modern Georgia’s first President.
His presidency is a lesson in how not to do nationalism… authority on all things in the Caucasus @Tom_deWaal joined me for this!
Spotify:
open.spotify.com/episode/2kMxsJylXGB0FinDtynbdS
Apple:
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-hated-and-the-dead/id15…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
2/ The Gamsakhurdia story is still unfortunately a bit of a taboo topic. for public debate in Georgia. Much of the public still views him through rose-tinted spectacles. That's a problem for a country that aspires to a modern European future.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
3/ It's one of the themes of @katiesartania's brilliant essay in last year's Carnegie's Future of Georgia series, based on polling data about Georgian’s views of their post-independence history carnegieeurope.eu/2021/04/27/struggle-and-sacrifice-narra…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
“She is not bashing her opponents, not talking in patriotic slogans but about real issues.” So glad to see this article by Celestine Bohlen about the remarkable @dolidze_anna come out in the NYT, in which I give some commentary. www.nytimes.com/2022/12/14/world/europe/georgia-anna-doli…?
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Reports that gas was restored to Nagorny Karabakh Armenians today, but the de facto blockade by Baku continues with the blocking of the Lachin road for a 5th day. A crisis that deserves a lot more international media attention than it is getting jam-news.net/fifth-day-of-protest-on-the-lachin-corridor/
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Here’s an interview I gave (in Russian) to @CivilNetTV earlier today on the new crisis in #lachin and #karabakh Grateful to be given a bit of space to give my views as to why Azerbaijan chose this moment to escalate...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Syd60qpINw&t=207s
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
...how in my view this as much directed at the Russian PKs as Armenians, the problematic Russian role and (a constant theme over the years) need for international security presence of some kind, difficult as that is to imagine right now.
-
Judy Dempsey
@Judy_Dempsey
This is v important as described by @Tom_deWaal about role of #russian ‘peacekeepers’ and civil society / environmentalists in this fragile /combustible part of the Caucasus.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ If you haven’t been watching the situation in the so-called #lachin Corridor, the only road connecting Armenia and #karabakh, you should now. The Armenian-Azerbaijani situation may be sliding slowly back into conflict. A short thread.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Thanks, Judy! But please note the environmentalists are not genuine civil society actors, more "little green men" of the Russian variety.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Update to previous thread. Situation gets worse with reports of gas cut-off to Armenians of Karabakh -- a manufactured humanitarian crisis. And the Western reaction and alarm is getting stronger. www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/armeniaazerbaijan-statement-spoke…
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ If you haven’t been watching the situation in the so-called #lachin Corridor, the only road connecting Armenia and #karabakh, you should now. The Armenian-Azerbaijani situation may be sliding slowly back into conflict. A short thread.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1/ If you haven’t been watching the situation in the so-called #lachin Corridor, the only road connecting Armenia and #karabakh, you should now. The Armenian-Azerbaijani situation may be sliding slowly back into conflict. A short thread.
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
7/ In Karabakh itself the Russian PKF has no agreed mandate or rules of engagement. It's been somewhat depleted thanks to Ukraine. But it’s also regarded by NK Armenians as their main protector—thereby driving more distrust in Baku.
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
8/ Pres. Aliyev does, I believe, want a peace agreement, not a new war, but it looks as though he also wants concessions which the Armenian side says it cannot meet. A big risk that we get serious new outbreak of violence by default.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
1 “The resolution of the Ukraine question.” A mistakenly published Russian article gives us a chilling insight into the neo-imperialist thinking in Russia that drives Putin’s decision to invade Ukraine. A (long) THREAD.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
A peaceful European country is experiencing an unprovoked invasion unseen since the Second World War. Heartbreaking, tragic and totally senseless.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Hundreds of people are still missing presumed dead from the second Karabakh war of 2020. Wishing @ICRC stamina and success in their noble work of helping locate them www.icrc.org/en/document/nagorno-karabakh-conflict-afterm…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
What a great loss. One of the bravest people I ever met. His mission to Chechnya in 1994 to stop the war was an act of supreme principle and courage. He warned about Russia’s slide away from democracy earlier than almost anyone. www.rferl.org/a/russia-kovalyov-obituary-human-rights/314…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
English text
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
English translation of the Armenia, Azerbaijan deal that has been circulating on social media
Important parts:
• Russian peacekeepers will be in Lachin corridor for 5 years
• Nakhichevan — Azerbaijan transportation will be unblocked, the link will be controlled by Russia -
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
With so much else happening in the world, the appalling case of Gulag historian Yury Dmitriev being given a 13-year prison sentence by a Russian court is not giving the attention it deserves. The man is a hero. www.indexoncensorship.org/2020/10/yuri-dmitriev-the-histo…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Here is a thoughtful Azerbaijani perspective, that Armenians should pay attention to, even if they don't agree with it. If there had been more Anars on each side over the last 25 years real dialogue would have been possible
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Just published: my piece for @Carnegie_Europe on how the new Karabakh conflict is not just a humanitarian disaster but a fresh blow to a European multilateral order.
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
I've been avoiding mentioning the "Syrians to Azerbaijan" #karabakh story--very alarming if true, but little info. This is the most credible report I've seen on it. Yet question remains how could Sunni fighters be persuaded to go and fight for mostly Shiite Azerbaijan?
Elizabeth Tsurkov
@LizHurra
Some clarifications on the Syrians apparently being shipped by Turkey to fight in Azerbaijan (previous thread here: x.com/Elizrael/status/1310164366097027072)
I know some of the men who've signed up to go & spoke to relatives & friends of men who've left (but no confirmation of their arrival)This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Post not available here, view on X
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Watch the whole interview! ahvalnews.com/azerbaijan-armenia/armenia-lacks-incentives… 2/2
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Horrible news. This AM a military offensive by Azerbaijan on #karabakh frontline. Already a small war. Heavy weapons used, Internet down in Az, Arm. side announced mobilization. Follows rise in bellicose rhetoric from both sides—Karabakh Arm. leader declared today...
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
The courageous Asida Shakryl confronts some of #abkhazia's most difficult issues, including the rights of the residents of Gali region. oc-media.org/abkhazian-hr-commissioner-condemns-torture-e…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
My column "The Munich fiasco will have shown neutrals how Armenians and Azerbaijanis are still deeply trapped in the Karabakh conflict and the chronic need for a third alternative narrative that does not merely rehearse 2 distorted versions of the past." carnegieeurope.eu/strategiceurope/81137
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Sinn Fein seeking No Deal to achieve a United Ireland out of the chaos. Set out with terrifying plausibility by @fotoole www.irishtimes.com/opinion/fintan-o-toole-sinn-féin-joins…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
"It’s time to look at this afresh and say — is it time to give this another push, to come up with a bigger offer to #abkhazia?.. This assistance package should not be unconditional." My interview to @OCMediaorg I really enjoyed the conversation. oc-media.org/interview-de-waal-is-it-time-to-come-up-with…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Finally out! After 2 years of tramping round distant corners of Europe, my report with ideas for better “engagement without recognition” with Abkhazia, Transdniestria and northern Cyprus—and why Ukraine is different. There are many twists and turns. carnegieeurope.eu/2018/12/03/uncertain-ground-engaging-wi…
-
Thomas de Waal
@Tom_deWaal
Is the break between Kremlin and the West permanent? Read answers of Fyodor Lukyanov @nyberg_ren @AngelaStent carnegie.ru/commentary/?fa=64994





















































































































































































