SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1065
1. Zelensky states during Pisorius visit to Kyiv that 16% of total milaid to 🇺🇦 has been provided by 🇩🇪
2. 🇷🇺 state media react to what is portrayed as Trump's ultimatum threatening tariffs, taxes and sanctions
François Heisbourg
François Heisbourg (born 24 June 1949) is currently Senior Advisor for Europe at the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) and Special Advisor at the Paris-based Fondation pour la Recherche Stratégique. He was director of the IISS from 1987 to 1992 and its chairman from 2001 to 2018. More on Wikipedia
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg reposted
GAU
@deaidua
Interesting remark from the Ukrainian president. According to him, the aid already provided by Germany accounts for around 16% of the total aid that #ukraine has received to date. Not bad given that more than two dozen countries provide military assistance to Ukraine 🫡.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
I had a meeting in Kyiv with Germany’s Defense Minister, Boris Pistorius. Our conversation focused on key priorities: building a comprehensive air defense shield, investing in Ukraine’s defense industry, ramping up Ukraine’s defense capabilities, training and supporting our soldiers on the battlefield.
I am grateful to Germany for its unwavering support, which has not only strengthened Ukraine’s defense but also played a crucial role in enhancing Europe’s security as a whole. Germany has made one of the largest contributions to protecting Ukraine’s skies and saving countless lives, providing approximately 16% of all the aid Ukraine has received.
We also discussed coordination with our partners to bring about a just peace and reviewed the outcomes of yesterday’s Group of 5 meeting of the defense ministers from Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Italy, and Poland.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1064
1. Zelensky details aspects of last year's talks with Russia in Istanbul. Medvedchuk was slated to replace him
2. Trump's says he'll impose tariffs & sanctions on 🇷🇺 if Putin doesn't negotiate -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
On Trump's first full day in office, the US delivered at least one 747 load of supplies to Ukraine.
A Kalitta Air 747, flying as Camber 332 for United States Transportation Command, landed at Rzeszow Jasionka Airport, a key transit hub for equipment headed to Ukraine. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Mohamed Sifaoui
@Sifaoui
Mercredi 22 janvier 2025
L’écrivain franco-algerien Boualem #sansal vient de passer sa 67e nuit en détention arbitraire.
Il a été arrêté par la dictature algérienne le 16 novembre 2024 pour ses opinions.
Ce régime corrompu et corrupteur dont le fonctionnement repose sur un socle populiste, complotiste et haineux garde en vérité Boualem Sansal en otage espérant obtenir une contrepartie diplomatique de la part de la France.
Un comportement de voyous qui dit tout de ce régime et qui explique pourquoi des Algériens biberonnés à la fois au nationalisme et à l’islamisme applaudissent l’incarcération arbitraire d’un écrivain tout en rêvant quitter ce pays pour un ailleurs qui est parfois la France -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Zelensky revealed that under the "Istanbul agreements," Russia attempted to replace him with Medvedchuk and demanded recognition of the entire Donbas as Russian territory, granting Russian official language status, enshrining Ukraine's neutrality in its Constitution, reducing the Ukrainian army to 50,000 troops, and destroying or handing over all weapons within 20 km of the front line.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Wow...
BBC Weather
@bbcweather
Wow! According to data from flightradar, BA274 flying Las Vegas to Heathrow has just hit a speed of 814mph thanks to extreme jetstream winds!
The subsonic speed record is 835mph, with the jetstream strengtheing later, this record is under threat www.bbc.co.uk/weather/av/68385942?at_bbc_team=editorial -
François Heisbourg reposted
Demetri
@AsiaLens
SCOOP - Two Iranian ships set to carry Chinese chemicals to Iran that can make propellant for 260 mid-range missiles. One ship left China Monday.
enterprise-sharing.ft.com/redeem/86ea1441-487e-45c2-abfe-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Meir Javedanfar Ph.D.- מאיר ג'בדנפר
@MeirJa
Israel's Attack is Good News for Ukraine
Today’s attack by #israel against the UAV and missile production facilities of #iran is also good news for #ukraine and NATO. Bad news for #russia.
This is because the Iranian facilities destroyed were most likely involved in the supply of ballistic missiles and drone technology to Russia. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Nibbling fish, anyone?
William Yang
@WilliamYang120
Breaking: Two undersea cables connecting #taiwan and the outlying island Matsu have been severed since this morning. The exact cause is unknown.
www.cna.com.tw/news/afe/202501220050.aspx -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
So would a demilitarised Russia, dear Pavel
Pavel Podvig
@russianforces
This is, of course, not true. A demilitarized Europe would be a perfectly good way to keep the peace.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"Newspeak" is what Orwell called this in 1984
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
The US Coast Guard have used 'Gulf of America' in their press release.
#gulfofmexico -
François Heisbourg reposted
Frederik Van Lokeren
@KaptainLOMA
Russia's 49 year lease of Tartus got cancelled today. Were the Russian vessels waiting for this event as the political point of no return to start the evacuation? Coming hours might provide more clarity.
MT Anderson
@MT_Anderson
🚨breaking: Tartus🚨
Has the evacuation of 🇷🇺 equipment been approved by Syrian authorities?
It would appear that both Sparta and Sparta II are about to enter port -
François Heisbourg reposted
Armée française - Opérations militaires
@EtatMajorFR
Police du ciel #eap | Interception par des Rafale 🇫🇷 de deux avions 🇷🇺 au-dessus de la mer Baltique ne se conformant pas aux réglementations aériennes internationales.
➡️ Engagement résolu des armées 🇫🇷 pour la protection de l’espace aérien de l’@OTAN_FR malgré la recrudescence des menaces hybrides.🛡️
NATO Air Command
@NATO_AIRCOM
🇫🇷 Rafale & 🇮🇹 Eurofighter scrambled over the Baltic Sea 🇪🇪🇱🇻🇱🇹 to identify 🇷🇺 military aircraft failing to conform to international aviation regulations
#nato continues to provide security to the Alliance population despite the uptick of hybrid threats -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Next thing: Trump will take this weather event as proof of the absence of global warming. Drill, baby, drill....😱😱😱
StormHQ ☈
@StormHQwx
Check out this crazy view in New Orleans, LA as heavy snow continues. #lawx
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Une grande dame
Sébastien Lecornu
@SebLecornu
Médecin et pilote d’hélicoptère, première femme générale de l’armée française, première femme élevée à la dignité de grand-croix de l’ordre national du Mérite, Valérie André n’est plus.
Médecin militaire, elle a évacué, aux pires heures de la guerre d'Indochine, plusieurs soldats français, avec dévouement et courage.
Je salue sa mémoire. -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
President Trump has rescinded former National Security Advisor John Bolton’s security clearance.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Predator sounds exactly right
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
This is insane. GOP Congressman Andy Ogles has introduced a bill to allow Trump to acquire Greenland, saying the Island should be part of the US because “we are the dominant predator.”
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
He sounds like a good motivator
Department of State
@StateDept
.@SecRubio delivers remarks to employees upon arrival at the State Department. www.youtube.com/live/FqNBQJSugqg x.com/i/broadcasts/1DXxyddXZzWJM
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Oliver Alexander
@OAlexanderDK
The Russian evacuation of Tartus begins.
After being in a holding pattern for over a week, the Sparta II has finally been allowed to dock at Tarth’s to evacuate the Russian equipment from the base.
This comes the day after Syria cancelled Russia’s 49 year lease of the port. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Slava 🇺🇦
@Heroiam_Slava
🇲🇩 Moldova is ready to provide financial assistance to Transnistria only if Russian troops are withdrawn from the region, President Maia Sandu says.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
One of the surprising things for first time visitors to Nuuk is to discover the importance of public housing in the capital of Greenland 🇬🇱
Orla Joelsen
@OJoelsen
Snowy storm arrived to Nuuk. Greenland.
January 20, 2025 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Trump may have set the conditions for a Chinese takeover of the WHO
World Health Organization (WHO)
@WHO
WHO comments on United States announcement of intent to withdraw
The World Health Organization regrets the announcement that the United States of America intends to withdraw from the Organization.
WHO plays a crucial role in protecting the health and security of the world’s people, including Americans, by addressing the root causes of disease, building stronger health systems, and detecting, preventing and responding to health emergencies, including disease outbreaks, often in dangerous places where others cannot go.
The United States was a founding member of WHO in 1948 and has participated in shaping and governing WHO’s work ever since, alongside 193 other Member States, including through its active participation in the World Health Assembly and Executive Board.
For over seven decades, WHO and the USA have saved countless lives and protected Americans and all people from health threats. Together, we ended smallpox, and together we have brought polio to the brink of eradication. American institutions have contributed to and benefited from membership in WHO.
With the participation of the United States and other Member States, WHO has over the past 7 years implemented the largest set of reforms in its history, to transform our accountability, cost-effectiveness, and impact in countries. This work continues.
We hope the United States will reconsider and we look forward to engaging in constructive dialogue to maintain the partnership between the USA and WHO, for the benefit of the health and well-being of millions of people around the globe. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. A big deal if the elections next month give birth to a stable Union-led coalition. Stable is the operative word
Mariska den Eelden 🇪🇺🇳🇱
@eeldenden
"As long as Europeans are united, they will be respected in the world". Incoming Chancellor Merz plans to speed up Macron's efforts for financial integration 🇪🇺. Huge coming from the CDU! This policy shift is happening in other "frugal" states as well, including Denmark
-
François Heisbourg reposted
MAKS 26 🇺🇦👀
@Maks_NAFO_FELLA
🛳️🚫🇹🇷 Turkey has arrested "Bloom" vessel, which was transporting drones and ammunition to Russia under the flag of Saint Kitts and Nevis, - Krymskyi Veter
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🇺🇸 Trump's order to suspend international aid for 90 days does NOT affect military assistance to Ukraine, says Ukraine’s counter-disinformation chief Kovalenko.
“It’s about other matters entirely.”
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Trump had signed an order halting foreign assistance for 3 months, pending a review of its alignment with his policies. This includes aid to Ukraine. All foreign aid programs are temporarily suspended for reassessment.
apnews.com/article/trump-foreign-aid-9f5336e84c45a6e782fa… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En effet...Je suis sur Blue Sky pratiquement depuis ses débuts et force m'est de constater que BS a certes moins de tarés que X mais que X reste bien meilleur en termes de source d'infos, d'idées et de résonance. Pour le moment, ce serait une erreur d'abandonner X aux trolls
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1063
Foreplay: 1.Trump suggests that Putin may not be willing to enter into a substantive negotiation
2. Putin states readiness to enter talks leading to a lasting peace (sic)
3. 🇺🇦 drones hit Smolensk cruise missile (Kh-55 Kent, Kh-59 Ovod/Kingbolt) plant -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Certes
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
Russian Pantsir air defence system intercepts Ukrainian kamikaze UAV over Smolensk, Russia.
Ukraine targeted Smolensk Aviation Plant, resulting in damage and fires. -
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
Putin congratulated Donald Trump on inauguration day.
He said that Russia is open to dialogue and negotiations but emphasized that "We will, of course, fight for the interests of Russia, for the interests of the Russian people. This, in fact, is the goal and meaning of the special military operation."
So Putin's position remains the same. He wants a weak and unarmed Ukraine. -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
I have been running this account long enough to have a suspicion that Macron was trying to hide the fact that he is really pissed off in yesterday’s speech.
Élysée
@Elysee
EN DIRECT | Vœux aux armées depuis le Commandement de l'appui terrestre numérique et cyber de Cesson-Sévigné. x.com/i/broadcasts/1dRJZddraMzKB
-
François Heisbourg reposted
auonsson
@auonsson
Hey fellow investigators.
Yesterday you published an article on the Baltic Sea cable breaks.
I pointed out it has lots of easily remedied errors in your infographic, 24h ago. Hundreds others also tagged you.
Errors are still online.
@isaacstanbecker @RobynDixon__ @ellen_fra
auonsson
@auonsson
Washington Post today presented a wholly incomplete infographics on Baltic Sea infrastructure incidents.
Actually damaged structures: 13, presented by WaPo as 4-5.
Actual # incidents: 4, WaPo found 3.
Here is the fix. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Trump est assurément un type déplaisant et peu cultivé. Maid ce n'est pas un minus habens. Ce n'est pas en se laissant influencer par les autres qu'il a réussi l'exploit singulier de se faire réélire haut la main. Il sait ce qu'il veut. Cet homme est dangereusement efficace
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The average American has 10% less life expectancy than the average West European.
Not sure that leaving the WHO will improve the US health care débâcle with the highest expenditures in the world (as Trump restated on Jan 20) and possibly the lowest cost efficiency -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Trump beginning to realise that Putin may not be interested in doing a deal?
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
Trump on Spain: They are BRICS nation. Do you know what a BRICS nation is? You will figure it out.
Fact check: Spain is NOT a BRICS nation. -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
❗️"Zelensky wants to sign a deal, but I don't know if Putin wants to. I think he (Putin) is destroying Russia" — Trump
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Unbelievable. And with shades of Doctor Strangelove. Hagrid and Dumbledore are awesome
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
A North Korean version of Harry Potter made with AI. Now you've seen everything.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1062
1. Later today: US presidential inauguration of Trump 47
2. Zaporizhia hit
3. Multiple drone strikes vs Tatarstan aerospace factories
4. 0f 141 🇷🇺 combat drones, 93 down, 47 lost -
François Heisbourg reposted
Holger Zschaepitz
@Schuldensuehner
Good Morning from Davos, where the 55th WEF kicks off today. Donald Trump will, unsurprisingly, be the elephant in the room, joining via video link on Thursday. However, many key world leaders are notably absent. There’s no French President, no Italian or British Prime Minister, and no Chinese President. Attending are (hopefully outgoing) Chancellor Olaf Scholz, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez, and Argentinian President Javier Milei, who is first stopping at Donald Trump’s inauguration before heading to Davos. #wef25
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Mohamed Sifaoui
@Sifaoui
Dimanche 19 janvier 2025
L’écrivain franco-algerien Boualem #sansal vient de passer sa 64e nuit en détention arbitraire.
Il a été arrêté par la dictature algérienne le 16 novembre 2024 pour ses opinions.
Ce régime corrompu et corrupteur dont le fonctionnement repose sur un socle populiste, complotiste et haineux garde en vérité Boualem Sansal en otage espérant obtenir une contrepartie diplomatique de la part de la France.
Un comportement de voyous qui dit tout de ce régime et qui explique pourquoi des Algériens biberonnés à la fois au nationalisme et à l’islamisme applaudissent l’incarcération arbitraire d’un écrivain tout en rêvant quitter ce pays pour un ailleurs qui est parfois la France. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Reminds me of my 1st visit to Moscow that year. In those days, the still existing building behind the model was called Дом СЕВа (Dom SEVa ), ie COMECON house, the modernist symbol of East Europe's limited sovereignty. Some continuity there. I wonder what became of the lady
Soviet Visuals
@sovietvisuals
Moscow fashion, 1974.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1061
1. Velyka Novasilka under pressure, at hinge between Donetsk and Zaporizhia oblasts
2. Sustained drone attacks vs TurkStream gas pipeline terminal near Anapa
3. Ban on TikTok enters effect in US -
François Heisbourg reposted
Jamming
@balticjam
French Air Force watching Königsberg.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Barbarik
@Sunny_000S
Zelensky named the countries that opposed Ukraine's membership in NATO:"The USA, Hungary, Slovakia & Germany do not to see us in NATO."
While #ukraine is fighting on the frontlines for the Western World against #russia, 𝐔𝐤𝐫𝐚𝐢𝐧𝐞 𝐢𝐧 𝐍𝐀𝐓𝐎 will make NATO stronger.⚔️👊 -
François Heisbourg reposted
C'est Carré 🟩
@Cest__Carre
🇺🇦🇨🇵 Un AMX-10RC(R) de la 155e BM "Anne de Kyiv" équipé d'un filet anti-drones rabatable et de grilles latérales supplémentaires lors d'un entraînement en #ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Sounds right. It tallies with what I had been hearing about the way in which US policy vis à vis the Ukraine war was (mis)shaped with the oversize solitary role of Jake Sullivan. The AUKUS débâcle in 2021 also comes to mind with an AWOL Biden & Kurt Campbell running the show
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
The emerging portrait from these Biden postmortems is of a president who didn't have a typical POTUS level of command due to age-related decline. And who therefore was serving as a sort of proxy president for his staff, "the groups" or whomever had his ear.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Michael Ignatieff's superb @FT piece is less about Canada's future (if any) as a sovereign state than about a Trumpian world of spheres of influence in which the US shrinks into the Monroe doctrine (plus Greenland), Russia may get Europe while China gets the rest (minus India).
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ellie S 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@smileyplankton
That it was allowed to enter @NATO airspace says everything.
Another dangerous display of weakness. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1060
1. Missile strikes vs Kyiv & Kryvyi Rih. 2 Iskander-M/Hwasong down
2. Patrushev says 🇺🇦may cease 2 exist in 2025 (Komsomolskaia Pravda)
3. 🇬🇧🇺🇦accord
4. 🇷🇺paints 🇫🇷maritime patrol plane over Baltic
5. Oil depot burns in Lyudinovo (Kaluga)
6. 🇷🇺drone in Tulcea🇷🇴 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
The aftermath of the Russian ballistic strike on Kyiv this morning.
Three people killed. Three more injured.
Entrance to a subway station and a McDonald's heavily damaged. Water supply pipeline damaged. Lots of people in Kyiv are without water.
We are so tired of all this...
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
Loud explosions were heard in Kyiv. Looks like Russia attacked us with ballistic missiles.
Head of Kyiv military administration reports three people killed by the attack.
Kyiv mayor reported fires in several areas of the city.
Russian attacks on civilians continue. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Russian drone in NATO airspace
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
The first footage of a Russian drone that crashed in Tulcea county, #romania, after an attack near the border, on Kiliya in Ukraine, has appeared online
Romania raised its fighter jets in the air this night because of the Russian attack.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
French maritime patrol aircraft gets painted by 🇷🇺 over Baltic
Sébastien Lecornu
@SebLecornu
Dans la nuit de mercredi à jeudi, un avion de patrouille maritime Atlantique 2 français a été la cible de mesures d'intimidation russes.
Il patrouillait en espace aérien international au-dessus de la mer baltique, dans le cadre d’une opération de l’OTAN, et a été illuminé par le radar de conduite de tir d'un système de défense sol/air S400.
Cette action aggressive russe n'est pas acceptable.
Nos armées continueront d'agir pour défendre la liberté de navigation dans les espaces aériens et maritimes internationaux. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
In Liski, Voronezh region, an oil depot fire continues to grow, now engulfing 4 fuel tanks. Reportedly, there are no fire hydrants nearby, so water must be transported by trucks—leaving little hope of extinguishing it soon. Ukraine attacked the depot two days ago.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I fear that is correct
Ruth Deyermond
@ruth_deyermond
If Trump's demands for 5% spending on defence really plunges European NATO members into crisis mode then they haven't been paying attention. It seems to me that the point of this demand is that it's designed not to be met. That's what should be causing alarm. 🧵
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1058
1. Ongoing 🇺🇦 ops vs infrastructure: Voronezh oil depot ablaze
2. Baltics disconnecting fm 🇷🇺🇧🇾 electricity grid in a few weeks
3. NATO'S "Baltic Sentry" enhanced presence kicks in to surveil seabed infrastructure
4. 🇮🇷 president in Moscow to sign strat pact -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1057
1. 31 Russian cruise missiles down
2 Keir Starmer in Kyiv -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
La voie de l'épée: L' Ukraine et la GRH de guerre: lavoiedelepee.blogspot.com/2025/01/l-ukraine-et-la-grh-de…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Sławomir Dębski
@SlawomirDebski
When American Democrats ask me why some people in Poland think Donald Trump could be a better president for Poland, I just reply: “Well, he couldn’t possibly be worse than Biden…” Especially considering that Poland has been a loyal ally to the Biden administration, and yet it ended up being hit with sanctions that limit its prospects for development. Thank you USA.
@USAmbPoland @AmbDanFried @mikercarpenter
Dom Andrzejczuk
@QuantumDom
The USA imposed restrictions on Poland on the supply of Nvidia chips (all the latest versions, for AI compute).
Poland found itself outside the group of 18 key allies.
Wtf @JoeBiden ? -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1056
1. Briansk area installations hard hit by ATACMS
2. Lukoil refinery near Volgograd burns -
François Heisbourg reposted
GAU
@deaidua
German Military Aid to #ukraine updated with 👇
DELIVERED IN THE PAST 3 WEEKS
— 600 HF-1 loitering munitions
— 46 RQ-35 Heidrun UAVs
— 43 Songbird UAVs
— 50 Vector UAVs
— 20 FFG MRAPs
— 495 HK416 assault rifles
— 11,000 120mm mortar shells
— 19,000 122mm shells
— 14,000 155mm shells
— ammunition for Leopard 1A5 MBTs
— 65 field glasses
— 24,200 wool blankets
— 120,000 chest seals
— 30,000 tourniquets
PLEDGED
— 5 Marder 1A3 IFVs
— 9 BOXER RCT30 IFVs with mobile fire direction centre
— 16 RCH 155 (already known long ago)
You can find all data on already delivered and pledged military aid here 👇
🇩🇪 deaidua.org
🇬🇧 deaidua.org/en/ -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Zelensky responds to U.S. calls to lower the draft age to 18:
'Our partners couldn't provide military equipment for the 100 brigades already on the battlefield,' the Ukrainian President stated. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ray Powell
@GordianKnotRay
👋IT'S LEAVING! 🚢 But why was it off 🇹🇼#taiwan's coast in the first place?
One day after I reported its suspicious activity off the SW coast of Taiwan (see embedded post below), the mystery ship VASILIY SHUKSHIN has decided to depart--not south to Vietnam as it previously self-reported, but straight back north to its home port of Vostochnyy, 🇷🇺#russia.
The Taiwan Coast Guard told local media (cn4.rti.tw/news/view/id/2234737) that the ship did not damage the nearby submarine cables and that it was monitoring its actions.
Now, after being called out, the ship has decided to go back to Russia.
👨🏫So to review, a 🇧🇿#belize-flagged, 🇭🇰#hongkong-registered cargo ship from Russia--which presumably exists to move goods from one port to another--sailed 3,000 km to loiter off SW Taiwan for 3.5 weeks--without seeking to enter any Taiwan port & for no apparent reason--and is now returning to Russia.
Ray Powell
@GordianKnotRay
🚨🤔Why has the cargo vessel VASILIY SHUKSHIN been aimlessly criss-crossing the area near 🇹🇼#taiwan's Fangshan cable landing station (www.submarinecablemap.com/landing-point/fangshan-taiwan) for 3+ weeks⁉️👀
Some curious facts about this ship in the thread below. [🧵1/6] @ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Seriously?
conflictmonitor
@mfnrossiya
Why did he post this?
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
The EU has officially approved inviting Switzerland to join the "Military Schengen" program, which enables the rapid movement of troops across Europe without border delays.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1055
1. 🇨🇳 & 🇮🇳 blocking Russia ghost fleet tankers
2.multiple 🇺🇦 ATACMS & drone strikes in 🇷🇺 oblasts. Orgsintez plant ablaze in Kazan
3. From bad to worse? Tiktok in US may be taken over by Musk?
4. 🇺🇦 Pokrovsk coal operations suspended as front closes in -
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
Chinese officials are evaluating a potential option that involves Elon Musk acquiring TikTok's US operations if the company fails to fend off a controversial ban on the app - Bloomberg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
40%? Pas tout à fait un "détail de l'histoire"
Mohamed Sifaoui
@Sifaoui
On ne peut pas diriger un parti politique et être aussi approximative, aussi légère en somme aussi médiocre @marinetondelier
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
⚡️BREAKING: India, following China, will not accept oil tankers sanctioned by the U.S. over Russia, Bloomberg reports.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Frederic Py
@Frel_
Unless it is backed by actual policies, an article is nothing more than ink. EU did few things recently (EDF being one of them) when it comes to defense but nothing even remotely close to what NATO is.
It’s not about “if X EU must Y” its about what EU does already to prepare -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
My point, indeed
Soledad Lokäarth
@lokaarth
Superb…but toothless when it came to intra-Nato disputes once GR joined, no ?
( Petersberg declaration, IIIA )
www.cvce.eu/content/publication/1999/1/1/16938094-bb79-41… -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
China has refused to accept three tankers carrying Russian oil following the introduction of new U.S. sanctions, Bloomberg reports.
The tankers Olia, Mermar, and Huihai Pacific, which were transporting more than two million barrels of oil, were sanctioned by the U.S. on Friday and are now stranded near China's eastern coast. Shandong Port Group, which operates the ports in Shandong Province, has prohibited the sanctioned tankers from docking, according to Bloomberg. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The problem isn't drafting one (the WEU treaty had a superb article 5), it's convincing friend and foe alike that it's real
Tobias Forsnacke
@forsno
It already has one: 42.7
If NATO dies then the EU must assume its functions, even if that would take years to set up. The trickier problem is what we do if NATO’s just on life support.
When do we pull the plug on grandpa? -
François Heisbourg reposted
Vadim Molodkov 🇪🇪🇪🇺🇺🇦
@VMolodkov
Well. I don't believe in, say, Hungary or Slovakia conforming with Art 5 and with enough persuasion even Germany and US can decide to stand aside, yet I believe the coalition of the willing would include Poland, Finland, Sweden and UK at least. But it will be very, very ugly.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🇭🇷 Croatia's presidential election: Incumbent Zoran Milanović wins re-election with 74.68% of the vote, defeating HDZ candidate Dragan Primorac (25.34%). Known for his EU & NATO criticism of Ukraine support, Milanović calls it "a recognition of my five years of work."
-
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
By the way, at least 127 CAESAR guns will have been delivered to Ukraine in 2025 since spring 2022.
And @KNDS_France will produce at least 144 CAESAR guns in 2025...
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
🇫🇷🇺🇦 | To date, 85 CAESAR guns have been officially delivered to Ukraine. Ukraine is already Europe’s largest CAESAR operator.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1055
1. 🇷🇺 forces pressing in Toretsk and southern envelopment of Pokrovsk
2. 🇺🇦 strikes facility near Kazan -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Earlier today, Russian channels posted a video purportedly showing a strike on what was claimed to be a Ukrainian "Western-made radar system."
Just one catch: it appears to have been a friendly fire incident on a rare North Korean SAM system in Russian service. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes, ie Article.5 by another, European? , name
Michel Vanbruaene
@michelvanbru
On paper, the numbers are clear. However, even without NATO, the Baltics will likely not be isolated but strongly supported by other scandinavian countries and Poland. That would be a much harder nut to crack.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Imperial ambitions. In rhe absence od NATO's arricle 5, invading the Baltic statea would indeed be less challenging than conquering Ukraine latvia.news-pravda.com/en/world/2025/01/11/3640.html
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Imperial ambitions. In rhe absence od NATO's arricle 5, invading the Baltic statea would indeed be less challenging than conquering Ukraine latvia.news-pravda.com/en/world/2025/01/11/3640.html
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Dear John, did you try to follow your own advice? If so, why didn't it work?Best, François 🙂
John Bolton
@AmbJohnBolton
My advice to world leaders looking to do business with Trump: follow the example of Shinzo Abe and talk to Trump as much as possible, not just when you need something. Call him. Meet with him. Talk to him about anything. And if all else fails, learn how to play golf.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Much food for thought in this excellent Adelphi book @IISS_org by @JoshRovner1. Will hopefully lead to much fruitful discussion
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1054
1. New 🇺🇦 law provides for compulsory 3 months wartime basic military training from ages 18 to 25. Not mobilisation & not for university students
2. 980 000 serve in 🇺🇦 armed forces
3. 2 🇰🇵 POWs bagged (WIA)
4. Engels oil depot day 4 still ablaze -
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Jim Maniguet
@jimMehdi001
À lire ⬇️ @jdomerchet @duprat_alain @VincentCrouzet4 @FHeisbourg @PascalBoniface
Morocco Intel
@MoroccoIntel
🇫🇷🇩🇿#flash| En pleine crise diplomatique franco-algérienne, Emmanuel Bonne, conseiller diplomatique d'Emmanuel Macron vient de démissionner suite à des « désaccords ».
Sa carrière de conseiller a commencé en 2012, où il avait rejoint le cabinet de Hollande au sein de l'équipe diplomatique, particulièrement sur la zone Moyen-Orient et Afrique du Nord, ainsi que les affaires traitées à l'ONU. Un périmètre fortement exposé à la triple relation franco-algéro-marocaine.
C'est pendant cette période que la France s'est progressivement rapprochée de l'Algérie et distanciée du Maroc, en revenant en arrière sur le soutien franc au plan d'autonomie affiché sous Nicolas Sarkozy.
Ce rapprochement avec l'Algérie s'est poursuit sous Macron. Il est nommé en 2017 directeur de cabinet du ministre des affaires étrangères de l'époque, Jean-Yves Le Drian, connu pour être algérophile depuis sa jeunesse ou il a passé plusieurs étés à donner des cours en Kabylie.
La presse française a fait état ces derniers jours de différents de fond entre le Quai d'Orsay et Place Beauveau sur l'approche à adopter face à la crise algérienne.
Le parcours d'Emmanuel Bonne a tendance à indiquer qu'il était plutôt du côté du camp algérophile au sein du gouvernement français.
Emmanuel Macron pourrait potentiellement prendre des mesures inédites, « en riposte » comme indiqué hier par le ministre des affaires étrangères français Jean-Noël Barrot, face à l'hostilité répétée et manifeste de l'Algérie vis à vis de la France. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Impressive
Jürgen Nauditt 🇩🇪🇺🇦
@jurgen_nauditt
One of the largest refineries in the russian Federation - "Taneko" - is on fire, - rosZMI.
Unknown drones flew to Tatarstan (1000 km from Ukraine) and paid a visit. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
Mike Nelson
@mikenelson586
43 KIA from a population of 5.9 million is roughly proportional to 2461 KIA from a population of 330 million.
In other words, the Danes shouldered the same burden we did in Afghanistan. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
🔥 In Engels, Russia, a fuel depot fire has been burning for four days straight
Governor Busargin claims that the fire's area has been "reduced by 80%," while admitting that "the fuel combustion process continues."
To recap, Ukrainian drones attacked the fuel depot in Engels on the night of January 8. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Vatnik Soup
@vatniksoup
Serbia finally realized that most of Russia's weaponry isn't really that good.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The Soviet Enrico Macias
Soviet Visuals
@sovietvisuals
"Girls of my country" by Botir Zokirov, USSR TV, 1967.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
mattparlmer 🪐 🌷
@mattparlmer
PLAN is making the contemporary equivalent of the WW2 D-Day Mulberry Harbors
This is not the kind of invasion prep that you can hide easily, and it makes me think that the decision to invade Taiwan has been made and now we’re just running down the clock -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Chinese FONOPS
-
François Heisbourg reposted
AGTOMCAT 🇨🇵 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@agtomcat
The aid would have included several IRIS-T anti-aircraft defence systems, at a time when Ukraine needs them most.
O. Scholtz's volte-faces are impossible to digest. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ellie S 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@smileyplankton
En parlant de la provocation ...
news.usni.org/2024/08/31/chinese-vessels-ram-surround-phi… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1053
1. NATO takes over US air defence in Poland
2. shadow fleet tanker Eventin adrift near Rügen island in Baltic
3. Neptun cruise missile hits ammo & drone facility at Chaltyr (Rostov obl)
4. Strike vs 🇷🇺 3d army command post in Donetsk obl. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Unusual: Canadian warship in South China Sea
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Jürgen Nauditt 🇩🇪🇺🇦
@jurgen_nauditt
No weekend without russian threats.
All Baltic countries should belong to russia, the Lithuanian army will not last even a day in the confrontation with the russian Federation, - russian MP Zhuravlev.
He added that Lithuania should keep quiet and not launch verbal attacks on russia. He also stated that the Suvalk corridor is useful for the russian Federation, as it will allow organizing land deliveries to the Kaliningrad region. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
Greenland is only the tip of the iceberg
A senior Trump aide confirmed that the Greenland gamble is about broader geopolitical dynamics, with the U.S. seeing an increasingly belligerent Russia as a rival for Arctic hegemony.
"This is not just about Greenland. This is about the Arctic. There is a Russia that is trying to be king ... It's about oil and gas. This is about our national security. This is about critical minerals," said Mike Waltz.
Greenland and Svalbard, a Norwegian island, are strategically located. Svalbard is important to Russia because the Northern Fleet must pass through its sea route to reach the Atlantic.
In 2022, when Norway began blocking Russian ships bound for Barentsburg to comply with economic sanctions against Moscow, the Kremlin freaked out and accused Norway of human rights violations.
In 2024, Russia provocatively planted Soviet flags in the Russian-populated towns of Barentsburg and Pyramiden and announced the opening of a new scientific center for polar research.
The biggest danger with Trump’s fixation on taking over Greenland is the potential inspiration it could give to rival powers to start acting in the same imperialist vein, Arctic watchers have warned.
Source: Politico -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Untrue. Ask BMW, Daimler Benz, Siemens among many others what their ownership pattern was under Hitler
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Giorgi Revishvili
@revishvilig
A highly informative infographic detailing the Russian high-value targets attacked by Ukraine in 2024.
Ukraine hit 236 bases, 76 fuel storage facilities, and 71 ammunition depots. The highest number of bases and fuel targets were hit in June (59) and July (43). 1/4 ⬇️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Unsurprising, alas
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
Scholz blocks new aid package for Ukraine
German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock and Defense Minister Boris Pistorius proposed allocating an additional €3 billion in military aid to Ukraine ahead of the Bundestag elections scheduled for February 23. However, Chancellor Olaf Scholz's administration is opposing the initiative, reports Der Spiegel.
The list of weapons for Ukraine was finalized in November 2024, and the Federal Chancellery has indicated it does not support further funds for Kyiv.
The Foreign and Defense Ministries justified the additional aid by citing Ukraine's urgent needs, which were not foreseeable during earlier planning. They emphasized that Ukraine's military situation has significantly worsened in recent months due to intensified Russian offensives. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1052
1. Trump says meeting with Putin is being set up
2. Acetone production plant struck at Gatchina (St.Peterburg outskirt)
3. Engels strategic fuel depot continues to burn -
François Heisbourg reposted
Tim White
@TWMCLtd
3/
It's over 900km from the northern border of #ukraine to #gatchina, near #stpetersburg.
IngrichTech officially produces decorative coatings and doors. However the Ukrainian Centre for Countering Disinformation says it's secretly been turned into a military plant. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Arash Markazi
@ArashMarkazi
To put the size of the Palisades fire into perspective:
- Manhattan, New York City is 14,604 acres.
- Palisades fire so far has burned 17.234 acres. -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
❗️"The 🇨🇿Czech supplied 🇺🇦Ukraine with 1.5 million large-caliber ammunition in 2024, a third of which was 155-caliber," - Czech Defense Minister Jana Cernohova
Results of the "Czech Initiative" on the purchase of ammunition and direct contracts between the Czech and Ukraine. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Louise El Yafi
@LouiseElyafi
🔴THREAD
Alors que nous commémorons aujourd’hui les 10 ans de l’attentat de l’#hypercacher, le PNAT a confirmé que la veuve et complice d’Amedy Coulibaly, Hayat Boumedienne, femme djihadiste la plus recherchée de France était encore vivante et localisée en Syrie.
Entre désir de rédemption, parfaite connaissance des textes, “veuve de martyr” devenue influenceuse de Daech mais jamais inquiétée par les autorités à l’époque de sa radicalisation, Hayat Boumedienne représente à elle seule, un grand nombre de caractéristiques propres à la radicalisation des femmes. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Pesky debris
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
"The flames are growing larger—it's terrifying!" Something is burning intensely on the border of Stary Oskol district (Belgorod) and Kursk region. Russian sources claim a Ukrainian drone attack, stating their air defense "shot down all targets." Debris reportedly fell on an industrial site, sparking a fire.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Timothy Snyder
@TimothyDSnyder
1/5. The way Trump, Trump Jr, Tuberville, and Hannity are talking now about Greenland, Mexico, Panama, and Canada plagiarizes Putin in 2013, before the first invasion of Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
On attend la saison 2 🤫🤔😉
Arnaud Cossart
@CBreteuil
#carnetdeculture
Le radeau de la Méduse
1819. Géricault, peintre encore méconnu, s'empare d'un fait divers. Il crée une toile grâce à laquelle il espère triompher au Salon.
Échec total 😓
Il vient pourtant de signer LE chef d'œuvre sur l'invisibilisation 😱
Un fil ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
In Russia, the "Cherkizovo Chicken Kingdom," one of Russia's leading poultry producers, is reportedly on fire. Russians report that debris from Ukrainian drones, shot down by Russian air defenses directly over the facility, caused the blaze.
That naughty debris again. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
In Engels, Russia, at the oil depot hit by Ukrainian drones the situation is deteriorating. The fire continues and has reportedly spread to other tanks.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Apurba Prasad Saikia 🇮🇳 🇮🇱
@ApurbaPras95990
You are right. I vividly remember Macron's precise words in India's support. He even mentioned France's Army.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
RADIO J
@RadioJFrance
Sur la possibilité d’une attaque iranienne avant l’investiture de Trump :
« Si vous êtes un stratège iranien, vous devez être sacrément tenté de franchir le pas nucléaire. Vous avez perdu vos positions en Syrie, perdu le Hezbollah, montré que vous étiez nuls dans la guerre des fusées… »
@FHeisbourg, conseiller spécial à la Fondation pour la recherche stratégique, auteur de « Un monde sans Amérique » aux @OdileJacob dans Géopolitique Le Mag de @SteveNadjarThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A gentle reminder for @KanwalSibal
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1051
1.Trump says NATO Europe should spend 5% of GDP on defence (US does 3.4%)
2. 🇷🇺 bombs housing in Zaporizhia
3. 🇺🇦 strikes oil depot near Engels air base
4. Another 70 attack drones down (46) or lost (24) -
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Russia’s Rosreserv fuel depot in Engels reportedly suffered another massive fuel tank explosion overnight.
The Russian strategic fuel storage facility, hit by Ukrainian attack drones early yesterday morning, continues to burn completely out of control as more tanks ignite. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
So the bottom line is that there is no condemnation by India of Trump's territorial pretensions vis à vis EU territory.
Thank you for making that clear
Kanwal Sibal
@KanwalSibal
French FM has made a defensive statement about defending EU’s territory but without any “condemnation” of Trump’s astonishing territorial claims on allied sovereign countries that are part of NATO and, in Canada’s case, G 7 too. There is open cartographic aggression but no expression of outrage or personal attacks against him.
India has wisely stayed away from taking sides in the Russia- Ukraine/NATO conflict that has European roots and has no reason to take sides in this quarrel within the NATO alliance and territorial issues between the US and EU.
Two of India’s neighbours claim Indian territory. Do enlighten me on any supportive statements by the EU or France against such claims.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
French official condemnation @francediplo has been quick, stark and unequivocal. Any news from India you may wish to share?
Kanwal Sibal
@KanwalSibal
Interesting how imperial ambition, threatening violation of sovereignty, invasion, land grab, map change etc are in this case treated as matters of analysis, sober exchange of views, with no condemnation, moral strictures or demonisation, but the discourse on Putin and Russia is different. Deux poids, deux mesures!
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
Spaghetti Fella-Badger
@SpaghettiBadger
USA also inflates it's numbers because it includes on going medical costs for vets.
Which in all other nato countries is under their normal health spend -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#politique - Choc en Autriche : l’extrême droite au pouvoir : “On est toujours rattrapé par son histoire.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#international -Trump menace d’annexer le Groenland par la force : “Trump n’est pas un homme fantasque. Trump est un homme qui est tactiquement imprévisible, mais il a des idées sur beaucoup de sujets auxquels il tient. ”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#damas - L’inquiétant profil du nouveau ministre syrien : “Il ne faut pas décourager la réforme et l’ouverture du régime, mais il ne faut pas non plus se débarrasser trop rapidement des quelques moyens de pression dont on dispose.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
Carla Reay
@carlareay1
It's a trick, totally predictable that he would ratchet up the figure, to give him an excuse to pull out of NATO.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ridiculoustrump 🇺🇦🇨🇦🇬🇱🇪🇺
@Ridiculoustrum1
Exactly. The U.S. would need to spend another $800 billion on top for their military in order to reach 5% themselves. Don’t see that coming…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Also true. But convincing Trump of that isn't going to be easy...
Toni Mikkola 🏴☠️
@virtaava
While GDP is a relatively good measure, it doesn’t tell the whole story. Some countries fall below the 2% threshold yet maintain well-equipped and capable militaries. Others, despite meeting or exceeding the target—spending as much as 5%—have allowed their forces to deteriorate significantly. This disparity highlights the need for a more comprehensive metric to accurately assess military readiness and capability.
What NATO needs is a complementary metric to GDP—something that evaluates actual readiness, interoperability, and capability. For example, metrics could include force readiness, interoperability with NATO missions, efficiency of spending, and the pace of equipment modernisation. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Who'd have thought! Making Canadian Elections Exciting Again...
Dan Smith
@Dan1763
A Canadian election in an environment of a debate on do you think your nation should exist could be interesting.
Who gets to be the most pro Canadian and by default anti Trump? -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
French official condemnation @francediplo has been quick, stark and unequivocal. Any news from India you may wish to share?
Kanwal Sibal
@KanwalSibal
Interesting how imperial ambition, threatening violation of sovereignty, invasion, land grab, map change etc are in this case treated as matters of analysis, sober exchange of views, with no condemnation, moral strictures or demonisation, but the discourse on Putin and Russia is different. Deux poids, deux mesures!
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ben Hodges
@general_ben
This is why Trump's been focused on ensuring he has an Officer Corps that will be totally loyal to him vs our traditional loyalty to the Constitution. Will they obey what looks to me to be an illegal order to attack a NATO ally? Will the JCS push back on this? Hegseth won't.
Carl Bildt
@carlbildt
At least Trump today ruled out using 🇺🇸 military force against 🇨🇦 - but he didn’t rule out using it against 🇩🇰 if higher tariffs wasn’t enough to get it to agree on the 🇬🇱 issue.This is rapidly moving from the absurd to the dangerous. www.politico.eu/article/donald-trump-military-force-green…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
EmergencyStream
@EmergencyStream
CA | PALISADES FIRE update
The Getty Villa which holds 44,000 ancient Roman, Greek and Etruscan artifacts is now threatened.
Photo courtesy CarvinUpLife on TikTok -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
What's the situation at @RANDCorporation @michaeldrich ?
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
View from Santa Monica of the ongoing rapidly spreading Palisades Fire. This doesn't look good 🔥
x.com/PrettySchlitty2/status/1876708159621853623/video/1 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A few days ago, 3% was the new 2%. So is 5% now the new 3%? Reminder: the US, a global power, currently has defence spending of 3.4% of GDP, less than Poland or Estonia
Ruth Deyermond
@ruth_deyermond
If Trump's demands for 5% spending on defence really plunges European NATO members into crisis mode then they haven't been paying attention. It seems to me that the point of this demand is that it's designed not to be met. That's what should be causing alarm. 🧵
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Deborah Haynes
@haynesdeborah
The public articulation by Donald Trump of a new desired target for NATO allies to spend 5% of national income on defence will surely plunge governments across Europe into crisis mode - not least here in the UK.
Britain presents itself to the world and in particular to the United States as the biggest defence spender in Europe and NATO's most powerful European military.
Yet Sir Keir Starmer has not even managed to set out a timeline for what he describes as a "path to 2.5%" of GDP being invested in his armed forces, up from just over 2% today.
If the prime minister merely sticks to this pledge, he risks being viewed by the new administration as woefully unambitious and not credible on defence. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Good time to act, ie before the 20 January inauguration and Musk's political empowerment as head of DOGE PS: does UK have locus standing vis à vis the Commission on DSA?
Daractenus
@Daractenus
Spain and France have now joined Britain and Germany in asking the European Commission to open an investigation into Elon Musk under EU's DSA, openly (and rightfully might I add) accusing him of spreading misinformation and interfering in European politics.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
PoliticsVideoChannel
@politvidchannel
BREAKING: Canada is planning to fight back against Trump’s tariffs by cutting off all energy supplies to the U.S.
This may get Trump impeached by Congress -
François Heisbourg reposted
Xavier Tytelman
@PeurAvion
Dassault a livré 21 Rafale en 2024 (1 de + que prévu) contre 13 en 2023 et l'objectif 2025 est de dépasser les 30 unités. Le carnet de commande compte 220 Rafale.
Avec 500 ventes au total dont plus de 270 à l'export, ça fait plus de ~20 Md€ pour la balance commerciale.
Voila le résultat de l'excellence 🇫🇷, et ce n'est que le début ! -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Russia's 2021 so-called security treaties are indeed the clear expression of Moscow's strategic ambitions in Europe
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Elie Perot
@Elie_Perot
Greenland is, from the standpoint of EU treaties, an OCT. I think that this page nicely summarises the relationship between OCTs and the EU: international-partnerships.ec.europa.eu/countries/oversea…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
First official French reaction to Trump's anti-Danish threats
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NotIan___F
@FNotian10384
NATO requires consensus of all members. The US would not support it anymore than turkey's vote for thanksgiving.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Charles Monneron
@CharlesMonneron
Trump card (pun intended), is actually Canada (dis-)unity. Rich western provinces are tired to pay for the others. 🇺🇸 only really interested in BC, northern Territories and Alberta, especially if Greenland is in the bag...
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Elie Perot
@Elie_Perot
There is a debate, however, as to whether 42.7 applies to EU's Overseas Countries and Territories (OCT) like Greenland.👇
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not so sure about article 5. It hasn't been invoked in the framework of Greek-Turkish relations. But EU's article 42.7 would definitely be relevant
BuckheadBuckeye
@BuckheadBuckeye
Denmark is a founding member of NATO. Trump is discussing invading an ally which would trigger article 5 for all other NATO members.
25th Amendment conversations won’t be far off.
It’s that sick. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Adam Schwarz
@AdamJSchwarz
Trump asked if he would use military force to capture Greenland from Denmark:
"People don't even know if Denmark has any legal right to it. But if they do, they should give it up because we need it for national security". -
François Heisbourg reposted
Miquel Ros
@rosmiquel
There’s the matter of French speakers too: w’d they b co-opted by superior economic firepower or remain as assertive of linguistic rights as a much smaller minority? maybe a chance for independence? But then the continuum from the North Pole to the tropics would be interrupted
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1050
1. 🇺🇦 says 6 cruise missiles downed in 1 F16 sortie
2. 🇬🇧 mil intel says 🇷🇺 casualties have been rising month on month for 6 straight months. Total KIA WIA MIA at 790K plus
3. Trump threatens NATO ally 🇩🇰 with punitive tarifs -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. Europeans shouldn't push too hard to be a direct part of an eventual Trump-Putin confab re Ukraine
DailyGlow
@quotesmeblack
Don't sit at a table where they talk about others, because when you get up, you're the next topic.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Orla Joelsen
@OJoelsen
Premier of Greenland message today;
“Let me repeat - Greenland belongs to the people of Greenland. Our future and fight for independence is our business. While others, including Danes and Americans, are entitled to their opinions, but we should not be caught up in the hysteria and external pressures distract us from our path. The future is ours and ours to shape. We commit exercising our rights as people and fulfilling our duties with wisdom and care. Every day is spent on working to become independent. We can and we can cooperate” 🇬🇱 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not so sure about article 5. It hasn't been invoked in the framework of Greek-Turkish relations. But EU's article 42.7 would definitely be relevant
BuckheadBuckeye
@BuckheadBuckeye
Denmark is a founding member of NATO. Trump is discussing invading an ally which would trigger article 5 for all other NATO members.
25th Amendment conversations won’t be far off.
It’s that sick. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The bad news is that @realDonaldTrump has annexed Canada. The good news is that he has left out Greenland (for the time being)
Little Think Tank
@L_ThinkTank
[ 🇨🇦 CANADA | 🇺🇸 ÉTATS-UNIS ]
🔸️ Sur son réseau social Truth, Donald Trump poursuit ses provocations et publie 2 cartes dans lesquelles le Canada est intégré aux États-Unis. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Panama? Military precedent is 1989 overthrow of Noriega. Darien migration including Chinese angle as a hic et nunc rationale. Global South fury but manageable. Greenland? Easy: US already has a military bridgehead (Thule) plus available airports. Politically: creating ...1/3
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
...local support as in Hawaii (1898) or Panama (1903) is part of US imperial experience. Atlantic Alliance in tatters as unmanageable collateral effect. Canada: not a militarily serious challenge except maybe for guerilla warfare along Alaskan border? Politically: promising...2/3
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
...sweetheart energy deals to Prairie provinces and helping BC deal with Chinese influence and fentanyl issue. But probably won't work. Collateral damage: end of NATO in North America but manageable (NORAD, NORTHCOMM are the name of the game). Crazy mind games in a Trumpian world
-
François Heisbourg reposted
auonsson
@auonsson
Given the extraordinary amount of Russian naval activity around Baltic Sea today I thought I'd summarize what I saw:
* Corvette and sub stalks Finnish tanker NW Anholt
* Three navy tugs doing racetracks south Anholt
* Corvette enters Kattegatt from south
cont .... -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Trump: threatening a close ally for imperial gain www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2025-01-07/trump-threa… via @business
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1049
1. Brazil completes data transfer of the crashed Azeri Embraer's "black boxes"
2. General Kellogg's visit to Kyiv deferred until after Trump's inauguration
3. Anne de Kiev brigade's travails: some 10% of its effectives have gone AWOL while training in France -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
From 20 January onwards, Elon Musk will be a US government official (as head of DOGE). His statements on foreign leaders will no longer be personal views but will commit the USA and should be treated as malign interference. Will HMG (and @Bundeskanzler ) respond accordingly
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
Elon Musk said UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer should be in prison.
www.politico.eu/article/elon-musk-us-says-uk-keir-starmer… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Théo Laubry 🇺🇸
@TheoLaubry
Par curiosité, j’ai mesuré à la louche l’activité d’Elon Musk sur X au cours de ces 24 dernières heures.
Bilan: +180 publications/commentaires/partages. Tout ce qui touche à Starlink, Tesla et Space X représente une infime minorité (à vue de nez bien moins de 5%). Le reste est en lien avec la politique américaine et européenne (RU/All). Et c’est grosso-modo son rythme de croisière depuis plusieurs jours/semaines/mois.
Autre point intéressant: je ne constate pas de pause particulièrement longue qui pourrait indiquer un temps de sommeil autre qu’une sieste. Sachant qu’en plus de gérer ses entreprises et publier ici, il est aussi un grand amateur de jeux vidéos en ligne et père de famille nombreuse.
Un rythme qui paraît intenable pour le commun des mortels et qui explique aussi peut-être en partie les raisons de son impulsivité. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Could be interesting
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
‼️ Brazil completes decoding of "black boxes" from AZAL plane allegedly shot down by Russian air defenses
Authorities announced that the data extraction from the two flight recorders of the AZAL aircraft, which preliminarily appears to have been shot down by Russian air defenses and crashed near Aktau, was completed on Saturday.
All recovered data has been handed over to the investigative authorities in Kazakhstan for further analysis. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Fernando Cao
@thefernandocz
Ukraine's President just went deep with Lex.
In a raw 2-hour conversation, he revealed:
• Why Trump is key to ending the war
• How 5 nations betrayed Ukraine's trust
• Russia's plans are bigger than anyone realizes
These are his 11 insights you shouldn't miss🧵 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Mmes Hidalgo et Castets à la manœuvre...
Enzo Morel
@mtwit75
La Tour Eiffel, monument payant le plus visité au monde (7 millions de visiteurs par an), dont le billet adulte pour le sommet par ascenseur est à 35,30€, est en déficit, même hors Covid.
Pourquoi ❓ Indice : le propriétaire est la Ville de Paris. -
François Heisbourg reposted
AFP News Agency
@AFP
#breaking Austria's president tasks far right with forming new government
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Canadian politics becoming exciting? Looking forward to Trump's comments (and Macron's)? www.theglobeandmail.com
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1048
1. Another 128 attack drones down (79) or out (49). 2 Kh-59 ALCMs down
2. Electricity transformer out in Apcheronsk (Krasnodar krai).
3. Ongoing 🇺🇦 attack in Kursk oblast -
François Heisbourg reposted
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
J’espère que le quai d’Orsay avait averti l’Elysée que la reconnaissance de la “marocanité” du Sahara Occidental serait vécue comme une déclaration de guerre à Alger. La rupture des relations économiques et l’arrestation de Sansal n’en étaient que les premières étapes.
Atum Mundi
@atummundi
🔹#france 🇫🇷/#algérie 🇩🇿🔹
Menace d'attentats en France, l'Algérie mène-t-elle une guerre hybride contre la France ?
Depuis le rapprochement entre Paris et Rabat, Alger a décidé de lancer une vaste campagne de déstabilisation contre la France.
🧵THREAD🧵1/20 ⬇️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
BNO News Live
@BNODesk
BREAKING: Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to announce resignation this week, according to the Globe and Mail
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Intelschizo
@Schizointel
Ukraine has gone on the offensive in Kursk
Ukraine is spearheading 3 different assaults towards
Bolshoe Soldatskoe
Pushkarnoe
Leonidovo
These towns are defended by
Akhmat, 810th, North Koreans, and several storm Z units.
Russian channels been showing footage of Ukrainian forces using a large number of mine clearers, tanks, armoured vehicles, and report heavily utilising electronic warfare making most drones useless.
Meanwhile Russians are attacking into Sumy on the border where they have been trying for last 2 weeks and in
Kursk near Malaya Loknya
Ran out of room to showcase the rest of the Russian units on the Western Side of Kursk check out @JominiW latest update from December 20th 2024 as a reference!
Based on Russian reports the Ukrainians are having the most successful today so far near
Bolshoe Soldatskoe which is defended by Akhmat -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ray Powell
@GordianKnotRay
🚨Expect more cable sabotage as a maritime #grayzone tactic.
"While the ship sails under 🇨🇲#cameroon’s flag, 🇹🇼#taiwan officials said it was owned by Jie Yang Trading Limited. The 🇭🇰#hongkong-registered company’s only listed director is Guo Wenjie, a mainland 🇨🇳#china citizen."
Bonnie Glaser / 葛來儀
@BonnieGlaser
Taiwan asks South Korea for help over Chinese ship after subsea cable damaged. Will Seoul investigate this incident when the ship arrives in Pusan?
www.ft.com/content/be994bfb-7299-4334-829d-230dddbc7e25 via @ft -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
No kidding. But is running foreign countries part of your remit as head of DOGE, a US government departement?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Department Of Government Efficiency (DOGE) comme il se plaît à rappeler
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Avec cependant un atout politique et stratégique majeur et singulier: Musk, ministre de plein exercice est le numéro 2 du pouvoir présidentiel américain. Ce que n'a jamais été Soros.
Renee Kaddouch-Kulbach
@renee_kaddouch
Musk fait pour de bon tout de que les populistes ont tjs reproché sans preuve à Soros de faire …
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1047
1. Drone strikes vs oil terminal Novatrans at Ust-Luga (Gulf of Finland) and at Smolensk factory
2. Ukraine push at Kursk salient -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
An important thread. @KofmanMichael doesn't do sugar-coating. I fear he's right in this downbeat assessment
Michael Kofman
@KofmanMichael
A long thread on the war and the current situation. Although the worst-case scenarios didn’t materialize in 2024, it was the most difficult period since spring 2022. There were positive developments, and bright spots, but the current trajectory is negative. 1/
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The original line is from Mussolini: "Il Duce ha sempre ragione"
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
TRUMP WAS RIGHT ABOUT EVERYTHING!
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. And much of that continues to be generated from coal, including the worst possible sort, ie lignite (brown coal)
Mark Nelson
@energybants
Germany's electricity production is falling.
Electricity production is a useful proxy for economic health. Generation in 2024 was lower than any year since reunification.
Germany claims it plans to electrify the economy, but it's making and using less electricity, not more. -
François Heisbourg reposted
ChrisO_wiki
@ChrisO_wiki
1/ Russian air defence crews reportedly shot down Azerbaijan Airlines Flight 8243 with two missiles fired from a Pantsir launcher near Grozny, after being 'blinded' by a Russian electronic warfare system, according to a detailed account of the incident on 25 December 2024. ⬇️
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. A very long way to go, via Casablanca, Dakar, AOF (French West Africa), le Soudan (the French part of the Sahel) and presumably from there to the anglo-egyptian Sudan and Egypt
Our Passports
@ourpussports
1940 Portuguese visa issued in London for returning to British Palestine. Travelling back via France and Italy was not possible as before, the events of the war have taken a dire turn!
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ian Ellis
@ianellisjones
🚨 Record-breaking Chinese PLA military activity around Taiwan in 2024
- 3,069 incursions into Taiwan’s ADIZ (+80% yoy)
- 5,110 PLA aircraft detected nearby (+8%)
- 2,501 PLAN warships tracked (+32%)
- Most sorties in a single day (153)
+ 3x major military drills
Quick thread: -
François Heisbourg reposted
Russian Forces Spotter
@TiaFarris10
📸EXCLUSIVE: Photo of the 🇷🇺Russian submarine Novorossyisk off the 🇩🇿Algerian coast (01/01/25). ⚓️ Crossed Gibraltar last night. No more Russian submarines in the Mediterranean: a clear sign of Russia's lack of support in this strategic region. #geopolitics #mediterranean’
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Thord Are Iversen
@The_Lookout_N
Drone incident over the Danish port of Køge last night.
Caller told the Police there were 20 large ones flying about at 2230 local.
Police arrived on scene and observed 4.
"The last drones were observed at 0116, heading out to sea at high speed"
politi.dk/midt-og-vestsjaellands-politi/nyhedsliste/polit… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1046
1. another 🇷🇺 81 attack drones downed or lost; 3 cruise missiles down
2. 🇺🇦 drone+missile attacks underway vs Crimea; Kerch bridge closed.
3. St. Peterburg airport shut down -
François Heisbourg reposted
jean-dominique merchet
@jdomerchet
En #ukraine , les déboires de la brigade « Anne de Kiev », formée en France puis dispersée sur le front. @lemondefr @thomasdistria www.lemonde.fr/international/article/2025/01/04/en-ukrain…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Finders keepers?
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
A Finnish Court denied the release of the Oil Tanker Eagle S, suspected of damaging a Power Line and Telecom Cables in the Baltic Sea. Seized on December 26, the Vessel is under investigation for possible Sanctions Violations involving Russian Oil. The Tanker’s Owner, United Arab Emirates-based Caravella LLC FZ, plans to challenge the decision, while Finnish Authorities suspect it is part of a Fleet evading Sanctions.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
itamilradar
@ItaMilRadar
🚨 Three Russian ships are currently transiting through the Strait of Gibraltar, bringing the total number of Moscow's vessels in the Mediterranean to six, all heading towards #syria.
#russia
➡️ www.itamilradar.com/2025/01/03/a-new-flotilla-of-russian-…
www.itamilradar.com/2025/01/03/a-new-flotilla-of-russian-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Dans la rubrique fais-moi-mal-Johny: je n'arrive pas à compter le nombre de masochistes qui m'expliquent ce matin qu'ils adorent que l'Europe se voie dicter son avenir par le super-ministre US Musk (tout en se plaignant de Soros & Obama, qui ne sont pas au pouvoir). Sublime...
LCI
@LCI
🗣️ @FHeisbourg souligne "l'ingérence" d' @elonmusk : "Il a totalement perdu le sens des proportions"
▶️ @margothaddadThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Dans le domaine diplomatique, c'est le non-dit qui compte souvent le plus. Dans ce thread, c'est la non- évocation du refus syrien de serrer la main de la ministre 🇩🇪 et la non-mention de la levée des sanctions qui pèsent encore sur la Syrie. Les deux sujets peuvent être liés
Jean-Noël Barrot
@jnbarrot
Retour sur ma mission à Damas, avec @ABaerbock.
Voici ce que j’ai vu. Voici ce que j’ai dit.
1/8 -
François Heisbourg reposted
The_Skeptical_Scientist⚗️💉🔬🔭⚖️
@TheSkepticalSc2
But how much of that "dirty" energy was imported into France?
That's the more interesting question!👿😠🤦♂️🤦♀️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1045
1. In 2024, Russia lost 1310 cruise and ballistic missiles
2. In 2025, Russia has already lost 4 helicopters -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nuclear Business Platform
@Nuclear_BP
Nuclear Power Capacity by Country ☢️🌍
👉 www.nuclearbusiness-platform.com
#nuclear #nuclearenergy #power #nuclearpower #smr #china #unitedstates #india #france #russia #southkorea #ukraine #uk #canada #turkey -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed, on both counts
Antti Helanto
@AnttiHelanto
Nuclear waste isn't as big of an issue as many believe. Onkalo nuclear repository in Finland can safely store all the existing nuclear waste in the world and much more. Nuclear is in many places the cleanest solution. In Finland Greens have become nuclear energy supporters.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
At the present rate, we won't need to wait 5 generations for global warming to make life somewhat complicated...
Ridiculoustrump 🇺🇦🇨🇦🇬🇱🇪🇺
@Ridiculoustrum1
“France was 18 times cleaner.”
Yes, when closing one’s eyes regarding the nuclear waste that is produced for the future 500 generations. -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
According to Yurii Butusov, the journalist who wrote the article highlighting the problems surrounding the Anne of Kyiv Brigade, Volodymyr Zelensky will convene a meeting of the General Staff tomorrow.
The main agenda will be to examine the revelations of his investigation into the circumstances of the formation, training and supply of the 155th mechanised brigade.
🔗 www.facebook.com/share/p/1EkFKeSuuZ/ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Don't tell the Greens: too heartbreaking
Mark Nelson
@energybants
France and Germany: Electricity Compared in 2024
This chart shows all 8784 hours in the year.
Germany averaged 349 grams of CO2 per kWh with wind, coal, solar, gas, and biogas.
France averaged 19 grams with nuclear, hydro, wind, solar, and gas.
France was 18 times cleaner. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Encore un complot sioniste, sans doute...🤪🤪🤪
IMAM CHALGHOUMI
@Imam1chalghoumi
Bravo à l’Autorité palestinienne pour cette décision courageuse et ferme contre Al Jazeera, cette chaîne qui fait l’apologie du terrorisme. La voix de la secte des Frères musulmans, porteuse de division, d’importation des conflits et de haine de l’Occident, Al Jazeera incarne une menace directe pour la stabilité et l’unité.
2025 doit être une année de décisions courageuses et fermes face à la secte des Frères musulmans et à leurs idéologies destructrices. Il est temps de neutraliser ce poison qui gangrène nos sociétés et de sanctionner les partis politiques complices qui soutiennent cette mouvance toxique.
Protégeons nos sociétés de la division et refusons que des causes nobles, comme celle de la Palestine, soient perverties à des fins idéologiques ou politiques.
Agissons pour préserver l’unité, protéger notre jeunesse et bâtir une société libérée de la haine, de l’antisémitisme et du rejet de l’autre. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Good to know Elon Musk will explain it all, in the same pithy way he tells Germany, Britain and the European Parliament how to run their affairs
Positive Pulse
@positivepulse01
Another mass shooting. What's wrong with these people. Are they mentally challenged?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1044
🇺🇦's Energoatom to provide power to Moldova 🇲🇩 after cut off of Russian 🇷🇺 gas transit -
François Heisbourg reposted
Matt Tardio
@angertab
Trump Hotel Video Blast Analysis
Qualification:
Retired Special Forces Engineer Sergeant (Green Beret) trained in the construction and reduction of conventional and homemade explosive devices with real world experience.
Analysis:
“Ayackle,” who captured the lobby video, says the vehicle lowered itself shortly after pulling up to the lobby, then went boom. This suggests the vehicle was functioning properly.
Research
Documented cases of Tesla battery fires typically involve one of two things:
1: Charging issues causing overheating
2: Motor Vehicle Collisions/Crashes (MVC)
Image 1
The first frame of the blast shows a large fireball originating from under the rear of the vehicle and out of the front driver side window of the blast. The speed at which the flames appear suggest a deflagration rather than a detonation. The front driver side window is down, flames originate from the rear of the vehicle under the trunk and spread forward. The vehicle remains intact.
Image 2
The trunk lid can be seen intact and thrusted upward with a fire underneath, this suggests a rapid pressure increase typical with deflagration. Additionally, the metal exterior of the trunk appears to remain intact. Rear driver side window of the truck appears intact.
Image 3
The deflagration continues to follow the path of least resistance from the trunk and the bulk of the flame is seen expanding upward from the truck. Flames appear to spread minimal from underneath the vehicle in comparison. This suggest the "main charge" for the explosion originated from the trunk and the initiating charge was underneath it.
Image 4
Fireballs are seen shooting from the trunk of the vehicle and continue to fall consistent with fireworks while the truck remains mostly intact.
Conclusion:
In the cases of documented Tesla MVC's that resulted in fires, reports show that the fires spread rapidly and do not deflagrate in the nature seen in this video. The vehicle was clearly not connected to a charger, nor did it appear to be in a recent MVC prior to the explosion.
The almost instantaneous explosion (deflagration) is consistent with explosives used in fireworks, gun powder, and explosives such as ammonium nitrate based charges.
It is clear that an initiation occurred underneath the suspected fireworks in the rear of the vehicle directing the blast upwards, that the fireworks were likely stacked in the back in a crude attempt to make a main charge. Loose contact between the fireworks likely prevented an instantaneous and larger explosion. -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
❗️🇺🇦Ukraine will provide electricity to 🇲🇩Moldova to cover the deficit in its energy system.
Moldovan state-owned company Energocom announced the purchase of electricity.
"On January 2, we will additionally purchase electricity from the Ukrainian Energoatom at night, when our colleagues have a surplus of energy and can export it." -
François Heisbourg reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
Mass shooting reported at Amazura nightclub in Queens, New York.
At least 11 people have been shot, with emergency services on the scene.
It’s unclear if the shooting is a typical U.S. mass shooting or linked to recent attacks. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
Elon Musk on the Tesla explosion outside the Trump hotel in Vegas: We have now confirmed that the explosion was caused by very large fireworks and/or a bomb carried in the bed of the rented Cybertruck and is unrelated to the vehicle itself. All vehicle telemetry was positive at the time of the explosion.
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
New video released of the Tesla Cybertruck "exploding" outside of the Trump hotel in Las Vegas...💥
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Brisavoine
@brisavoine
Nos amis les Russes (épisode 3247)... Des sites internet de collectivités de Nouvelle-Calédonie et Polynésie française cibles de cyberattaques pro russes www.lnc.nc/article/nouvelle-caledonie/faits-divers/des-si… cc @FHeisbourg @moutet
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Reminds me of the Fort Hood shooting of 2009 (13 dearhs) by a US military psychiatrist of Palestinian origin. But we'll see
BNO News Live
@BNODesk
Shamsud Din Jabbar, the suspect in the New Orleans terror attack, grew up in Texas and served in the U.S. military for 10 years - NYP
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Unhappy New Year in Bourbon street, New Orleans www.cbsnews.com/news/new-orleans-vehicle-crash-bourbon-st…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
À pleurer...
Michael Shurkin
@MichaelShurkin
Très drôle.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Toni Mikkola 🏴☠️
@virtaava
This Is The Way!
"Finland’s Icebreakers: We will absolutely not assist Russia’s shadow fleet in navigating the ice.
The state-owned icebreaker company Arctia’s Chief Operating Officer, Paavo Kojonen, assures that Finnish icebreakers will, under no circumstances, assist Russia’s shadow fleet in navigating the potentially soon-to-be-frozen Gulf of Finland." -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
❗️🇷🇺Russia's Gazprom confirmed that 🇺🇦Ukraine has stopped the transit of Russian gas through its territory
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1043 NEW YEAR'S DAY
1. 🇷🇺 gas transit cut off from 7 AM today
2. 111 attack drones fm 🇷🇺: 63 downed, 48 diverted
3. Orël oil depot hit
С новым годом 2025 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Oliver Alexander
@OAlexanderDK
Recent drone video of the Russian evacuation preparations at Tartus. A large number of trucks lined up to embark on the Sparta when it arrives in the next two days.
Further confirmation that the Monolit-B radar has been removed.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
AGTOMCAT 🇨🇵 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@agtomcat
The Nuremberg trials had the merit of shedding light on Nazi genocidal barbarism.
Read the books, notes and testimonies of Leon Goldensohn and Douglas Kelley, both psychiatrists at the Nuremberg prison. Absolutely frightening insight into the psychology of Nazi dignitaries. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP DAY 1042
1. Putin's 25 th anniversary as President
2. Mi-8 helo downed by naval drone near Crimea
3. Big prisoner exchange. 189 🇺🇦 POWs (incl 2 civilians) freed
4. $2bn end of term US aid to 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A remarkable book. Partial spoiler: the anti- Nuremberg or how not to run an international criminal court
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Super thread; le socialisme dans un seul village
BB27000
@BB27000
C'est l'histoire d'un petit village de Dordogne crée spécialement par le Parti Communiste et la CGT pour loger des cheminots et des travailleurs.
C'est 100 % véridique.
Thread ⤵️⤵️⤵️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
adam seven 🇫🇮 🇪🇺
@a7_FIN_SWE
Not really certain abt. that. The article looks to be based on this one.
www.svt.se/nyheter/inrikes/socialdemokraterna-vill-aktive…
Here the former defense minister Peter Hultqvist calls out for art. 4 consultations. But he's in opposition and they want to raise their profile.
> -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Brilliant...
Daractenus
@Daractenus
As I've split my Russian cities "travel guide" into a myriad of different threads and posts, I've decided to finally gather them all in one place (mostly so I can have something to pin on my profile).
Welcome to "Posh Russian cities - The Definitive Edition" 🧵 -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
⚡️ JUST IN: Biden announced almost $2.5 billion in funding for Ukraine
📰 White House -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Looks like Sweden could ask for its first NATO article 4 meeting fr.news.yahoo.com/câbles-marins-mer-baltique-suède-152056…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1041
1. Southern outflanking of Pokrovsk
2. Poland to send Skylink to Ukraine. Could it be because Musk can no longer afford to do so? -
François Heisbourg reposted
Anne-Sylvaine Chassany
@ChassNews
Friedrich Merz said Musk would never have been able to build his Tesla factory in the east German state of Brandenburg with the AfD. It was the far-right party that had, he said, “put up the fiercest opposition to the plant”.
via @FT enterprise-sharing.ft.com/redeem/c9cba3f8-b75d-4b62-a907-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
BREAKING: Azerbaijan Officially Accuses Russia of Downing Plane
The plane that crashed in Aktau was damaged «as a result of ground fire,» Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev stated.
«The facts are that the Azerbaijani plane sustained external damage over Russian territory, near the city of Grozny, and practically lost control. Our plane was rendered uncontrollable by electronic warfare systems. This was the first damage inflicted on the aircraft,» he said.
«One of the moments that saddened and surprised us was the fact that Russian official bodies proposed theories about the explosion of some gas cylinder. This clearly demonstrated that the Russian side wanted to cover up the issue, which, of course, does no credit to anyone.»
Stressing that the plane was not deliberately shot down, Aliyev said, «Admitting guilt, promptly apologizing to Azerbaijan, a country considered friendly, and communicating this to the public — these were the necessary measures and steps that should have been taken.»
«Unfortunately, during the first three days, all we heard from Russia were absurd versions,» Aliyev concluded. -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
🇫🇷🇷🇴 | On the eastern flank, the French troops of the multinational battalion of the @MissionAIGLE are resolutely committed to protecting and defending Romanian territory.
Crăciun Fericit !This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Special Kherson Cat 🐈🇺🇦
@bayraktar_1love
Russian shadow fleet tanker Eagle S will be moved today to the Svartbäck inner anchorage near the Kilpilahti port in Porvoo, Finland.
According to a police statement, the transfer operation began at approximately 10:50 a.m. The operation is led by the Helsinki Police Department with the support of the Finnish Border Guard. yle.fi/a/74-20133526/64-3-254123
Special Kherson Cat 🐈🇺🇦
@bayraktar_1love
The Russian shadow fleet tanker seized for damaging the Estlink-2 cable in the Baltic Sea had spy equipment for tracking NATO ships and aircrafts installed on it.
The hi-tech equipment on board was abnormal for a merchant ship and consumed more power from the ship’s generator, leading to repeated blackouts
Read the article: www.lloydslist.com/LL1151955/Russia-linked-cable-cutting-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
toomas hendrik ilves
@IlvesToomas
The conflict that Musk just kicked off in the US over H1b visas is especially interesting when he simultaneously announces his support for the rabidly anti-immigrant AFD in Germany.
Why be vociferously pro-immigration in the US and anti-immigrant in Europe? It seems odd and bizarre if not contradictory.
I don't think it's because Musk is a Nazi. Rather, the cause Germany's biggest industry and its engineering talent magnet: making cars. Mercedes, BMW, Audi competes because of its superb engineers.
It's not just German engineers though. The working language of BMW's engineering HQ for example is English. Germany draws the best automotive engineers from around the world.
So riling up anti-immigrant sentiment in Germany, pushing a party that would kick out all foreigners while pushing for H1B visas to the US makes perfect sense if you want the automotive engineering talent all to flow to Tesla.
Q.E.D. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NUKES
@atomicarchive
«Radium heating: fireplace in 2000». French card, 1910.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
And by the same token, the signatories recognised the borders of Ukraine including Crimea
NUKES
@atomicarchive
Today marks the 30th anniversary of the Budapest Memorandum, under which Ukraine gave up nuclear weapons in exchange for security assurances from Russia, the United States, and the United Kingdom.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1040
1. Putin acknowledges that 🇷🇺 air defences were in operation in Grozny when Azeri Embraer attempted to land. But does not accept responsibility for crash
2. Six S-300/-409 vs Sumy area -
François Heisbourg reposted
dokdoc. Zeitschrift für den 🇩🇪-🇫🇷 Dialog
@DokumenteDoc
✨Den Beitrag von @FHeisbourg haben wir hochgeladen, kurz bevor unser Portal offline ging. Wenige Wochen vor Trumps Amtseinführung lohnt es sich, sich den Text des 🇫🇷 Sicherheitsexperten genau anzuschauen: Für #trump ist #europa ein "Mini-#china": dokdoc.eu/2024/11/30/die-welt-von-frueher-ist-tot/
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En effet
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Denis Dermenzhi
@iamdenya_de
❗️BREAKING #moldova: Gazprom has officially announced that it will leave Transnistria without gas from January 1.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
itamilradar
@ItaMilRadar
The Russian ship Sparta is currently in the central Mediterranean but has been behaving strangely in recent hours.
(via @scandura)
#russia #syria #libya
➡️ www.itamilradar.com/2024/12/28/the-russian-ship-sparta-co…
www.itamilradar.com/2024/12/28/the-russian-ship-sparta-co… -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
“Hi-tech” Russian signals intelligence equipment was reportedly carried by the tanker Eagle S, currently in custody after reportedly cutting the Estlink-2 cable in the Baltic, per Lloyd’s List.
“They were monitoring all Nato naval ships and aircraft,” Lloyd’s List was told. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Intermarium 24
@intermarium24
#breaking 🇦🇪 FLY Dubai just now halt all flights to russia 👏 Another airline that has decided to take care of the safety of its passengers! Very good !
Intermarium 24
@intermarium24
#breaking 🇦🇿🇰🇿🚫🇷🇺 Azerbaijan and Kazakh Airlines began halting their flights to Russia.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1039
1. Some drone damage in Mykolaiv
2. Fico of 🇸🇰 threatens to stop electricity transfer to Ukraine
3. 🇳🇱 to commit an additional €6bn to 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
The Ukrainian Review
@UkrReview
⚔️ NATO will increase its military presence in the Baltic Sea due to "possible sabotage of submarine cables," — NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Marko Mihkelson 🇪🇪🇺🇦🇪🇺
@markomihkelson
The Kremlin’s shadow fleet should be discredited and isolated on the international stage.
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
A tanker from the Kremlin's shadow fleet paralyzed traffic in the Bosphorus. This is the fourth Russian vessel to have gone out of order in the Black Sea in the past two weeks.
A 274 meters long Cordelia Moon vessel under the flag of Panama had an engine failure. The 18-year-old vessel was heading from the Turkish port of Yalova to Novorossiysk.
Cordelia Moon is one of the Kremlin's shadow fleet vessels. According to Lloyd's List, it has made numerous voyages between Russia and India. On September 30th, the vessel was attacked by the Houthis in the Red Sea as it was mistaken for a British one. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Stefan Forss
@StefanForss46
@alexstubb doesn't see a need for that at present. We'll manage together in cooperation without using this heavy tool. Stubb just held a presser.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
The relations between Azerbaijan and Russia cannot be easily described. You will find between "cordial" and "hostile" almost all shades of grey. I think that the word "pragmatic" is the closest adjective which can be used. In recent years, Russia has been increasingly backing Azeri interests, though they didn't come from a renewed love for Baku, but rather from punishing Armenia, which has increasingly fell out of Moscow's orbit.
The truth is that Azerbaijan increasingly pushes out Russian influence from the Caucasus. With its strong alliance with Turkey and Israel it found a counterweight for both, Russia and Iran. While the latter two are losing strength and influence, Turkey and Israel are on the rise. This is reflected in Azerbaijan's assertive stance in the Caucasus, which neither Moscow nor Tehran can effectively counter, thanks to their losing wars in Ukraine and against Israel.
The shot down of Azeri flight 8243 has the potential to decisively sour relations between Baku and Moscow, if Russia copies its behavior of MH17. The progress Russia made in the last years would be all but evaporated and another open enemy would be a Russia's doorstep. Baku cannot and will not ignore the fact the Flight 8243 was shot down by a Russian air defense unit and Moscow's deflection is making things worse.
Moscow has maneuvered once again in a very difficult situation which stemmed from a useless war. Putin remains the "master strategist" as we know him. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1038
1. 1ST North 🇰🇵 POW
2. 🇫🇮 holds 🇷🇺 tanker possibly linked to cable cuts
3. Putin asserts that in 2021 Biden was ready to delay NATO issue re 🇺🇦 for 15 years
4. Lavrov asserts Macron was ready to enter into bilateral confab with 🇷🇺 -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
All right, people. Many of you seem surprised at how quickly France managed to train Ukrainian pilots and mechanics to operate the Mirage 2000-5F. To sum it up, France reduced bureaucracy, and there was no language barrier drama.
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
“In this regard, we really need to pay tribute to France, because in six months they were able to do what we expected the US to do for a year and a half...
The French have done the basics:
– reduced bureaucracy as much as possible;
- developed a short and effective programme;
- immediately enrolled people for training; - did not f*ck with the language (i.e. they did not look for excuses);
There was no language issue at all, everyone who could speak and understand English immediately started training, the pilots were selected with good knowledge, but for some reason the French are the ones who teach people, while some only raise the bar and stall.
We once mentioned what kind of support we can count on, so after the announcement that Mirages will be modified for ground operations, we are definitely ready to say that the French are ours”. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Interesting thread. Thank you
History Nerd
@_HistoryNerd
Dmitri Polyakov wasn’t just a Soviet general—he was America’s greatest Cold War spy.
For 25 years, he fed the CIA secrets that shaped history, until two American traitors sealed his fate.
This is the story of the man who betrayed the Soviet Union to save it: -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A seriously nasty episode with 🇷🇺 caught red-handed by Azerbaijan trying to kill all aboard a civilian airliner. A straight line of murder and cover-up connects Andropov (KAL007 downing in 1983) and Putin (MH fight In 2014 and now the Azeri Embraer.
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Kill and hide. Azerbaijani officials tell local media that Russia hit flight J2-8243 with an anti-aircraft missile and then jammed electronics and denied permission to land in three airports, steering the damaged plane into the Caspian Sea so that it would crash there and Russia’s role would never be discovered. caliber.az/en/post/preliminary-investigation-azal-aircraf…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Teri Schultz
@terischultz
Have no doubt how seriously Finland is taking this incident: Here's the assembly of law-enforcement authorities holding a press conference on a national holiday. 1/
Teri Schultz
@terischultz
After ANOTHER cable is damaged in the Baltic Sea, Finnish President @alexstubb makes clear where suspicions lie even before the investigation is complete.
"We must be able to prevent the risks posed by ships in Russia's shadow fleet," he says after a briefing on the incident. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Time for the Baltic littoral states to call for a NATO article 4 meeting along with new measures concerning the regulation of maritime traffic affecting the seabed? All best wishes, Alex 🇫🇮
Alexander Stubb
@alexstubb
Sain katsauksen Suomenlahden kaapelirikkoon poliisiylijohtaja Ilkka Koskimäeltä, Keskusrikospoliisin päällikkö Robin Lardotilta ja Rajavartiolaitoksen apulaispäällikkö Markku Hassiselta. Viranomaisemme ovat selvittäneet tapahtumia yhteistyössä tehokkaasti.
Seurasimme tilannetta eilisen aikana tiiviisti PMI @PetteriOrpo kanssa.
Venäjän varjolaivastoon kuuluvien alusten aiheuttamat riskit on pystyttävä torjumaan. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Mohamed Sifaoui
@Sifaoui
Jeudi 26 décembre 2024
L’écrivain franco-algerien Boualem #sansal vient de passer sa 40e nuit en détention arbitraire.
Il a été arrêté par la dictature algérienne le 16 novembre 2024 pour ses opinions.
Ce régime corrompu et corrupteur dont le fonctionnement repose sur un socle populiste, complotiste et haineux garde en vérité Boualem Sansal en otage espérant obtenir une contrepartie diplomatique de la part de la France.
Un comportement de voyous qui dit tout de ce régime et qui explique pourquoi des Algériens biberonnés à la fois au nationalisme et à l’islamisme applaudissent l’incarcération arbitraire d’un écrivain tout en rêvant quitter ce pays pour un ailleurs qui est parfois la France. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I hope the heroes on the flight deck survived; their skill probably saved those thirty plus surviving passengers
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
Euronews: Azerbaijan Airlines plane shot down by Russian missile
The crash of the Azerbaijan Airlines plane was caused by a Russian surface-to-air missile, Euronews reports, citing sources within the Azerbaijani government.
The information has not been officially confirmed. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Antti Helanto
@AnttiHelanto
Finnish authorities caught the vessel conducting sabotage red-handed, authorities have boarded the vessel, conducting investigations. 3 data cables between Finland and Estonia seems to have been cut, and 1 electricity cable, also data cable to Germany may have been cut.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1037
1. Crash landing of Azeri
Embraer 190 at Aktau maybe caused by 🇷🇺air defence fire near Grozny
2. Sinking of 🇷🇺ship near 🇪🇸 may have been deliberate
3. 🇷🇺solid fuel plant struck at Kamensk-Shakhtinsky
4. Kellogg slams Xmas bombing by🇷🇺
5. 🇪🇪 energy cable cut -
François Heisbourg reposted
XFLASH NEWS
@xflash_media
⚡️ Trump's special envoy Keith Kellogg has condemned russia's missile attack on Ukraine on Christmas Day.
"Christmas is supposed to be a time of peace, but Ukraine has been brutally attacked. It's wrong to launch a large-scale missile and drone attack on the day of the Lord's birth. The world is watching closely the actions of both sides. The United States is more determined than ever to bring peace to the region," — Kellogg wrote.
👉Fundraising for the Ukrainian Armed Forces
💸 PayPal
molniamolnievic@gmail.com -
François Heisbourg reposted
Special Kherson Cat 🐈🇺🇦
@bayraktar_1love
❗️/1. Russian air defense most likely caused the crash of an Embraer 190 passenger plane during UAV attack on Chechnya:
An Embraer 190 passenger plane belonging to Azerbaijan Airlines crashed this morning. 67 passengers of which 5 crew members were on board. 32 people survived the crash. All survivors were in the tail section of the plane. 🧵 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Vatnik Soup
@vatniksoup
So far, three cables between Finland and Estonia appear to have been sabotaged, likely with involvement from Russia and China.
Yet, there have been zero consequences for the perpetrators. How much longer will we tolerate this?
Analysis by @auonsson -
François Heisbourg reposted
XFLASH NEWS
@xflash_media
⚡️ A Ukrainian drone has hit the russian vessel Fedor Uryupin in a bay near the village of Chornomorske in Crimea, local media report.
The incident occurred on December 23. The UAV damaged the side of the ship above the waterline, the ship did not sink.
“The Fedor Urupin was seized by Russia in 2014 and now sails under the Russian flag, but its owner is listed as the Ukrainian state-owned company Chornomornaftogaz.”
Join the fundraising for the Armed Forces of Ukraine:
💸 PayPal
molniamolnievic@gmail.com
👉 Follow @blyskavka_ua -
François Heisbourg reposted
Jersey Lee
@real_jerseylee
Perhaps NATO can consider instituting an identification system for all ships going in and out of St Petersburg? Not quite a blockade, but enough to make anyone think twice about sabotage
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui
Cécile Maisonneuve
@CcilMaisonneuve
Le câble de transport d’électricité entre la Finlande et l’Estonie a été détruit. Les infrastructures électriques, de transport comme de production, seront désormais des cibles de plus en plus fréquentes dans le double contexte de l’électrification de nos économies et de guerre asymétrique contre l’Europe. La transition énergétique ne peut plus être conduite sans prise en compte des enjeux de sécurité et de défense. La Suède 🇸🇪 a commencé à le faire en renonçant à des projets d’éoliennes offshore. La France 🇫🇷 doit elle aussi revisiter sa stratégie sur les littoraux qui abritent par ailleurs des infrastructures stratégiques.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Reminds me of the line in "Goldfinger": "once is happenchance; twice is a coincidence; three times is enemy action" www.theguardian.com/world/2024/dec/25/finland-estonia-pow…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
❗️ Deliveries of French Mirage 2000 5F fighters will start in January 2025. The training of Ukrainian pilots and mechanics has already been completed in France.
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
🇫🇷🇺🇦 | After six months, the training of Ukrainian pilots and mechanics on the Mirage 2000-5F has come to an end.
Щасливого Різдва ! -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
One of the final images of the Russian government-owned cargo vessel Ursa Major, as it lists heavily, going down off the coast of Spain.
The Russian vessel sank sometime late yesterday. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
If so, how did it end up in Aktau, Kazakhstan 🇰🇿?
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
A surviving passenger on Azerbaijan Airlines 8243 says the plane tried to land three times in Grozny amid heavy fog, and at the third attempt there was an explosion 💥 outside💥the aircraft. t.me/mig41/39200
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Reminds me of the line in "Goldfinger": "once is happenchance; twice is a coincidence; three times is enemy action" www.theguardian.com/world/2024/dec/25/finland-estonia-pow…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Excellent intercept rates vs cruise missiles but not so vs ballistic missiles
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Ukraine's Air Force report on the missile and drone attack that happened this morning.
Shot down:
0/2 KN-23 ballistic missiles
0/10 S-300/400 ballistic missiles
55/62 Kh-101/555/Kalibr cruise missiles
4/4 Kh-59/69 cruise missiles
54/106 Shahed drones
In addition, 52 more Shahed drones were supressed by electronic warfare or didn't reach its target. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Prior incursions into Moldovan airspace radiomoldova.md/p/43171/moldova-faces-rising-tensions-as-…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A similar incursion by a Kh-101 occurred when I was in Moldova last November. There clearly is a lack of coordination between Ukraine 🇺🇦 Romania 🇷🇴 Moldova 🇲🇩 when it comes to data transfer regarding the sky picture. Note: 🇫🇷 has gifted a Thales air surveillance radar to Moldova
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Remains of a shot down Kh-101 cruise missile. According to Ukrainian monitoring channels, this particular missile entered Romanian and Moldovan airspace for a short period before being shot down over Ukrainian territory. Romanian officials earlier stated 'nothing' was observed in their airspace.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Lucius Gellius Publicola 🏺
@Lucius_Gellius
La diffusion des monnaies de l'empire romain dans le monde, d'après le projet de l'université d'Oxford recensant plus de 6 millions de monaies et 15 000 dépôts monétaires romains.
Témoins des échanges commerciaux sous l'empire, les plus éloignées de Rome furent 4 petites monnaies des nummi (pièces de cuivre) découvertes sur l'île d'Okinawa au Japon dans le château médiéval de Katsuren. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1036 XMAS
Xmas bombing: 70 missiles vs 🇺🇦 (~50 downed says Zelensky ) plus ~100 attack drones, mostly vs energy infrastructure. Ukraine now celebrates Xmas on 25 December.
Note: weather is cool (just below freezing in Kyiv and Kharkiv) -
François Heisbourg reposted
Debra
@Molly4everLoved
-
François Heisbourg reposted
✝ ⚔️ Hunter UA ✠ 🇺🇸🇺🇦
@UaCoins
🚀 Approximate route of missiles during the morning attack... #russialsaterroriststate #kyiv #russiaukrainewar #ukrainerussiawar #russianwarcrimes #ukraine #ukrainewar #ukrainewarnews
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
Every massive Russian strike requires time for preparation. It is never a spontaneous decision. It is a deliberate choice – not only of targets but also of timing and date.
Today, Putin deliberately chose Christmas for an attack. What could be more inhumane? Over 70 missiles, including ballistic ones, and more than a hundred attack drones. The targets are our energy infrastructure. They continue to fight for a blackout in Ukraine.
According to preliminary reports, our defenders managed to shoot down more than 50 missiles and a significant number of drones. Unfortunately, there have been hits. As of now, there are power outages in several regions. Power engineers are working to restore power supply as soon as possible.
I thank everyone who is working for the country, who is on combat duty, who is protecting our skies. We will restore the maximum. Russian evil will not break Ukraine and will not spoil Christmas. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
www.foreignaffairs.com/world/battles-precise-mass-technol…
A useful formulation - precise mass. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1035
1. Additional 🇩🇪 air defence and armour for 🇺🇦
2. 🇷🇺 producing 1500 one-way UAVs a month
3. 🇺🇸 tells its citizens to leave Belarus forthwith -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
One of the ships involved in Russia’s evacuation from Syria, the cargo vessel Ursa Major, reportedly suffered a major engine room explosion in the Mediterranean and sank earlier today.
Spanish press reports that 14 crew have been rescued, 2 are missing. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
An illustration of mass in modern warfare. And it's 🇷🇺 which sets the pace here. NATO countries have got some catching up to do
Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧
@DefenceHQ
Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 23 December 2024.
Find out more about Defence Intelligence's use of language: www.gov.uk/government/news/defence-intelligence-communica…
#standwithukraine 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
❗️The 🇺🇸US State Department urged its citizens to leave🇧🇾 Belarus - there are risks of detention and civil unrest
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Reminds me of Argentina in the days when it was forbidden to provide economic statistics. Not sure this bodes well for China's credibility
Stella Yifan Xie
@yifanxie
China says economists who spread 'inappropriate' views should be fired. One Chinese economist at a bank received an internal warning in recent months, in part for making public comments on the economy, Nikkei Asia learned.
asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-says-economists-who-spread-… via @NikkeiAsia -
François Heisbourg reposted
Salome Zourabichvili
@Zourabichvili_S
What I will do: I will remain loyal to the Georgian Army—its veterans, soldiers, and steadfast partners who built and strengthened it.
I am, and will remain, its Commander-in-Chief! -
François Heisbourg reposted
jean-dominique merchet
@jdomerchet
#ukraine La France devrait fournir six Mirage 2000-5 dans les prochaines semaines, alors qu’il n’y a toujours pas d’accord avec la Grèce pour en ajouter six autres. Six avions seulement...
@jdomerchet @lopinion_fr
www.lopinion.fr/international/ukraine-et-si-poutine-refus… via @lopinion_fr -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Additional German assistance to 🇺🇦 www.facebook.com/share/p/183emNF4Sn/
-
François Heisbourg reposted
OpexNews
@OpexNews
🇫🇷 "L'ASN4G sera un missile hypervéloce, une vitesse dépassant largement Mach 5, et très manœuvrant, capable de porter le feu nucléaire à une distance sans commune mesure avec le missile actuel. Vous l'avez donc compris : il doit être le missile nucléaire capable de pénétrer les défenses adverses les plus denses, les plus développées qui seront en service de 2035 à 2065."
- GEN Stéphane Virem, commandant des forces aériennes stratégiques (FAS) @Armee_de_lair
➡️ air-cosmos.com/article/defense-les-fas-ont-structure-l-ar… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Mariska den Eelden 🇪🇺🇳🇱
@eeldenden
Iceland's new all-women government announced it will hold a referendum to join the EU! The recent election saw an overwhelming landslide victory for pro-EU parties and was already essentially a referendum
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Ah bon?
Frog eater 🇫🇷🇨🇿🇺🇦
@Francois_Creton
Parce que vous le souhaitez ! 🙌
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Drew Pavlou 🇦🇺🇺🇸🇫🇷🇺🇦🇹🇼
@DrewPavlou
Trump just appointed Elbridge Colby as Undersecretary of Defence for Policy.
Colby has posted about 30 times in the past 12 months about rigging Taiwanese semiconductor plants with explosives to blow up just in case China invades.
Colby’s obsession with blowing up TSMC is not just bizarre - it’s extremely unhelpful. It demonstrates a complete failure to understand Xi Jinping’s mindset and ideology. This is a theory-of-mind failure, a fundamental inability to understand the enemy’s motivations.
Xi Jinping doesn’t care if there are semiconductor plants on Taiwan. He doesn’t care if you rig them with explosives. He wants to “return” Taiwan to the fold of the Chinese motherland so that he can go down in history as the leader to finally “reunite” all of China after centuries of fragmentation and division at the hands of foreign powers. He is motivated by historical grievances and ethno-nationalist ideology, not semiconductor fabs.
Back in the 2000s, American neoconservatives invaded Iraq for ideological reasons. The invasion was wrong and a terrible mistake for America but it was not simply a “war for oil” as Bush era leftists like Michael Moore sought to portray it. This was a theory of mind failure on the part of the left vis-a-vis the Bush administration, a failure to understand what was driving their actions. I think figures like Elbridge Colby have actually come to accept the mistaken Noam Chomsky-esque leftist framing of the Iraq War as a war for oil.
Colby therefore tries to project this kind of mindset onto Xi. He imagines Xi as Bush era leftists imagined Dick Cheney. Just as they think Cheney invaded Iraq for oil pipelines, Colby thinks Xi wants to invade Taiwan for Taiwanese semiconductor plants.
They can’t conceive of the idea that Xi Jinping wants to invade Taiwan because he believes that Taiwanese separatists have betrayed their blood and their race by advocating separation from Beijing. It’s very similar to Putin’s belief that Ukrainians are all Russians who have simply betrayed their true Russian nature by looking to the West rather than Moscow.
Because Elbridge Colby doesn’t understand Xi’s fundamental motivations, his thought bubble about blowing up TSMC plants just serves to destroy confidence in the Taiwanese economy and the future of Taiwan as a de facto independent state.
We saw in Biden’s botched Afghan withdrawal just how utterly ruinous and disastrous it can be when panic courses through a society facing the prospect of being abandoned and overrun. We saw the Afghan government collapse in days after fighting against the Taliban for almost two decades.
People say that the Afghans didn’t want to fight but it’s not true - up to seventy thousand Afghan soldiers died fighting the Taliban from 2001 to 2021.
It was only when the US decided to treat the fall of Afghanistan to the Taliban as a fait accompli that the Afghan government disintegrated.
By demanding that TSMC factories be rigged with explosives, Colby is telling the Taiwanese that Chinese annexation is essentially a fait accompli. This is why it’s a disastrous message and a disastrous idea. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Pourquoi ai-je l'impression que ce gouvernement sera le plus court de la Cinquième République?
franceinfo
@franceinfo
🔴 DIRECT - 🗣️ Gérald Darmanin à la Justice, Elisabeth Borne à l'Education, Emmanuel Valls aux Outre-mer…
Le secrétaire général de l'Elysée, Alexis Kohler, annonce la composition de l'équipe gouvernementale sur le perron du palais présidentiel.
#franceinfo #canal27This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Carl Bildt
@carlbildt
Here we go again. Trump 🇺🇸 announces that ”the United States of America feels that the ownership and control of 🇬🇱 is an absolute necessity.” Not only control, but ownership. Doesn’t go down well in 🇩🇰, but hardly in 🇬🇱 either. www.dr.dk/nyheder/udland/derfor-skal-man-ikke-tage-let-pa…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Mohamed Sifaoui
@Sifaoui
Lundi 23 décembre 2024
L’écrivain franco-algerien Boualem #sansal vient de passer sa 37e nuit en détention arbitraire.
Il a été arrêté par la dictature algérienne le 16 novembre 2024 pour ses opinions.
Ce régime corrompu et corrupteur dont le fonctionnement repose sur un socle populiste, complotiste et haineux garde en vérité Boualem Sansal en otage espérant obtenir une contrepartie diplomatique de la part de la France.
Un comportement de voyous qui dit tout de ce régime et qui explique pourquoi des Algériens biberonnés à la fois au nationalisme et à l’islamisme applaudissent l’incarcération arbitraire d’un écrivain tout en rêvant quitter ce pays pour un ailleurs qui est parfois la France. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
What?
Dominique De BEVEC
@de_Bevec
EN DIRECT - #gouvernement #bayrou: Manuel #valls et Élisabeth #borne vont être nommés ministres -*- www.bfmtv.com/politique/gouvernement/direct-gouvernement-… via @BFMTV
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Ça risque de secouer...
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Uh-oh...
AlertesInfos
@AlertesInfos
🚨🇫🇷 FLASH - L’hypothèse d’un changement de Premier ministre n’est "plus totalement à exclure". (via @demontvalon1)
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1034
1. Fico in search of gas sees Putin in Moscow
2. Shahed depot with parts for 400 destroyed in Tatarstan (Alabuga)
3. More North 🇰🇵 troops for 🇷🇺?
4. 1 cruise missile down -
François Heisbourg reposted
Giorgi Revishvili
@revishvilig
North Korea appears to be preparing to deploy additional troops and military equipment to Russia, possibly including suicide drones, in support of Moscow's war against Ukraine. 1/6 ⬇️
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Defender of🇪🇺Sir Rant's Alot Res publica of🇪🇺
@e2dot7182818284
As I said ⬇️
Defender of🇪🇺Sir Rant's Alot Res publica of🇪🇺
@e2dot7182818284
The PM of Japan sent you a friendly, but stern reminder
I further note that the EU & European US allies still tops the USA in support for Ukraine
Europe= EU Institutions+ EU Member+UK=
85+50+15= 150 billion EUR
USA 75 + 56 = 131 billion EUR
I'll leave the conversion into USD to the interested & informed US reader.
For scale:
USA GDP $26.90 Trillion
EU GDP $19.35 Trillion
GB GDP $ 3.60 Trillion
Canada GDP $ 2.30 Trillion
EU+GB GDP $22.95 Trillion
EU+GB+USA+Canada GDP $52.05 Trillion
+ Japan GDP $56.45 Trillion
China GDP $19.40 Trillion
Russia GDP $ 2.10 Trillion
China+RU GDP $21.50 Trillion -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
Oh my, HTS leader Jolani sports a tie for the first time ever during a meeting with Walid Jumblatt and the Druze Sheikhs in Damascus, Syria
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1033
1. 🇷🇺 troops fail to cross Kherson's Antonovosky bridge on Dnipro
2. 🇷🇺 pressure north of Kupiansk -
François Heisbourg reposted
BB27000
@BB27000
Aujourd’hui nous allons parler de train blindé.
Et spécialement du train allemand Panzer Zug 32 (à vos souhait).
Dont le commandant réalisa une super méga boulette de compet !
Thread (réedition) ⤵️ ⤵️⤵️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"Leche, lâche, lynche": la formule est hélas juste
anne testuz 🌎🇫🇷 🎗️
@annetestuz
Le fameux « lèche lâche lynche ». Après il faut reconnaître que EM aide vraiment à le nourrir
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A very strange case indeed. The perp apparently had extreme views directed against (Sunni?) Islam and against Germany as being pro-Muslim www.bbc.com/news/live/c1j08p44w9kt
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Here it is. @elonmusk 's comment on that obviously lunatic AFD sympathiser. Somehow makes sense.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Waiting for @elonmusk 's comment
Anne-Sylvaine Chassany
@ChassNews
“A 50-year-old Saudi ex-Muslim living in East Germany loves the AfD and wants to punish Germany for its tolerance towards Islamists — that really wasn’t on my radar” - Peter Neumann, King’s College expert in terrorism
via @FT @GuyChazan
www.ft.com/content/5e2f3cd2-0a8f-4ac8-9afa-ca3d892d55f7?s… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1032
1. 🇺🇦 to shut off transit of 🇷🇺 gas to Europe on January 1
2. 🇺🇦 double drone attack vs Kazan area high-rise
3. 🇷🇺 bombs Kherson oncology centre
4. 19 🇷🇺 missiles launched, incl Kalibr. 4 missiles down yesterday -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
‼️ BREAKING: Ukraine will stop the transit of Russian gas to EU on January 1 at 7 AM — Prime Minister Shmyhal.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
C'est en effet heureux
Joëlle Alazard
@AlazardJ
Merci à la cour qui est allée au-delà des réquisitoires du parquet. Merci pour Samuel, merci pour sa famille, merci pour les enseignants.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
The 50-Year-Old Saudi National who drove his Car into a Christmas Market tonight in the German City of Magdeburg, in an apparent Terrorist Attack, had been living in Germany since 2006 and was a Doctor at a Hospital in Saxony-Anhalt. He was not previously known to any German Law Enforcement as an Islamic Extremist.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
This will have an effect on the German elections. @elonmusk 's friends at AFD may benefit
Ian Miles Cheong
@ianmiles
CONTENT WARNING: Gruesome footage of the moment a vehicle drove straight through the Christmas market in Magdeburg, Germany.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
‼️ The attacker who drove into a crowd in #magdeburg was born in Saudi Arabia
According to the German newspaper Welt, citing intelligence services, the perpetrator is 50 years old. Prior to the attack, he rented a car, which he then used to drive into the market at the Old Town Square.
❗️ Police found luggage on the passenger seat, which is currently being examined by bomb disposal experts.
AFP reports that up to 80 people were injured in the attack, while Bild states that 11 have died. Official figures have not yet been released.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Interesting opening shot. Not necessarily the hardest of calls, provided the US can deliver
Financial Times
@FT
Trump tells EU to buy US oil and gas or face tariffs www.ft.com/content/9e485614-0080-4a09-8fcb-2df6c3d932a5
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
"Lowering the mobilization age: if you're facing an unarmed person, does it matter if they're 20 or 30?" – Zelensky said.
"A year ago, we discussed training 14 brigades abroad with our partners. Today, we have one fully trained and armed brigade in France, with another being prepared in Germany. So, two total," he stated. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
The Russian attack on Kyiv has damaged St. Nicholas Church, one of the most beautiful landmarks of the Ukrainian capital
Christmas services are traditionally held in this church. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Well deserved! And much success in your endeavours, Kristi
Kristi Raik
@KristiRaik
I'm honoured to become the new Director of @ICDS_Tallinn as of 1 January.
We'll continue to do our best to analyse what's going on in the world and contribute to foreign and security policy debates in Estonia and abroad. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Siôn Jobbins
@SionJobbins
She'll take the cash. They're all grifters like all populist parties.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
May well be. But not sure that as the leader of a famously anti-US party she'll relish support from an overbearing American plutocrat
Gideon Rachman
@gideonrachman
Musk’s megalomania grows apace. He’s clearly trying to engineer a far-right revolution across the western world. He’s now backed the AfD. Before that Reform. And he’s the dominant figure in Trump world. He’ll clearly get behind Le Pen.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1031
1. Five Iskander-M/Hwasong vs Kyiv Damage & casualties
2. Putin threatens use of Oreshnik vs Kyiv
3. EU pledges €30bn new aid to 🇺🇦
4. UK mil intel says 11 000 North 🇰🇵 troops now deployed in 🇷🇺 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Hugo Borges
@hbj_r77032
Mais imagens do ataque de mísseis russos a Kiev.
#russia #ukraine #ukrainerussianwar #russiaukrainewar #russian #kiev -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
❗️In the morning, the Russian army tried to storm the right bank of Kherson.
Previously, two assault groups tried to occupy the Antonivskyi Bridge area under artillery fire. The attempts failed, they were destroyed by the Ukrainian military.
As cover, the Russians launched a massive shelling of Kherson and its suburbs. Residential areas, critical and social infrastructure were under fire, - the head of the OVA. Currently, 6 victims are known. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Fabian Hinz
@fab_hinz
Ukraine just struck the solid propellant rocket motor factory 'Kamensky Plant.' We featured this site in our recent analysis noting that the plant was undergoing significant expansion tied to Russia's efforts to boost missile production.
Cyber Boroshno
@cyber_boroshno
Удар ракетами по виробничому майданчику ФКП "Комбінат "Камєнскій"
Локація: Кам'янск-Шахтинський, ростовська область
Комбінат виробляє ракетне паливо й ще у 2020 році був переведений на 12-годинні робочі зміни.
оператор - 48.2996222, 40.1868895 -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
“There is nothing more beautiful than SCALP and Storm Shadow missiles towards the evil empire!” — @KpsZSU
🇫🇷🇬🇧🇺🇦
Special Kherson Cat 🐈🇺🇦
@bayraktar_1love
For the first time in the entire war, Storm Shadow/SCALP cruise missiles targeted the Rostov region of Russia.
(Video -1, Photo -2): Debris of one of the Storm Shadow/SCALP missile in Rostov region of Russia;
(Video -3): Impacts;
(Video -4): Very dense air defence activity.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
*Kamensky
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1030
1. SCALP attack vs Kamesnky explosives & propellant plant (Rostov area)
2. Drone attack vs oil refinery at Novoshakhtinsky (Rostov area)
3. 3d oil tanker in trouble near Kerch
4. 100s of Noth 🇰🇵 troops KIA in Kursk area -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1030
1. SCALP attack vs Kamesnky explosives & propellant plant (Rostov area)
2. Drone attack vs oil refinery at Novoshakhtinsky (Rostov area)
3. 3d oil tanker in trouble near Kerch
4. 100s of Noth 🇰🇵 troops KIA in Kursk area -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Bien du courage!
Jean-Baptiste Jeangène Vilmer
@jeangene_vilmer
Très fort tremblement de terre au Vanuatu, ambassade détruite (déchirée en 2, rez-de-chaussée ambassade 🇺🇸 écrasée), personnel sain et sauf mais nombreuses victimes dans le pays, vols suspendus, comm coupées, ni eau ni électricité, organisons secours 🇫🇷🇦🇺🇳🇿., num urgence à venir
-
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#russie - Général éliminé : Moscou arrête un suspect en 24h ! : “Si les Russes ont attrapé si vite le suspect, ils auraient pu prévenir l’attaque. Ils avaient forcément un début de piste au moment même où l’engin a explosé.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
olexander scherba🇺🇦
@olex_scherba
A stunning intercept by Ukraine special services. A Russian nurse talking.
… Wounded Koreans started arriving!… 120 in one train only!… Why are we making such a big fuss about it? Special rooms for ‘em, huh?… Not a word in Russian! All looking alike!… Should I write their names on their faces?… How am I supposed to understand their gibberish?… We aren’t even allowed to speak English to them!… And they keep coming! 100 yesterday… 120 today… How many more?…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
GAU
@deaidua
Major turnaround in the case of the Slovakian-based essential German repair and maintenance hub for Ukrainian military equipment! In October, it was announced that the hub was to be expanded. Now officials are saying that the hub is to be completely closed!
This was reported by the German Press Agency, while a spokesperson for the Ministry of Defence confirmed this upon inquiry.
The repair and maintenance hub, where Ukrainian heavy weapon systems such as PzH 2000 self-propelled artillery systems, MARS II MLRS, Gepard SPAAGs and ATF Dingo 2s were previously maintained and repaired, is to be completely dismantled by the end of the year and relocated to Germany.
Officially, the reasons for this are said to be the changing conditions and the sometimes extremely complex repair work that had to be carried out on the damaged vehicles.
GAU
@deaidua
My latest piece → The Slovakian-based repair and maintenance hub for primarily German-supplied Ukrainian vehicles and weapon systems which are damaged or require maintenance will be further expanded.
deaidua.org/news/2024/10/13/slovakia-germany-ukraine-repa… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
China is pushing Russia out of Kazakhstan's uranium sector — Russia is gradually losing its influence in Central Asia.
A Chinese state company has bought Rosatom's shares in a Kazakh uranium mining operation, and plans to acquire others. As the world’s largest uranium producer, Kazakhstan accounts for 43% of global supply. Traditionally, Russia controlled the transport routes for Kazakh uranium to Europe, but sanctions have pushed Astana to seek alternatives. China, the second-largest nuclear energy producer with the fastest-growing civilian reactor fleet, offers both demand and a sanctions-free transit route.
In the vast Kazakh steppes, the power struggle between Moscow and Beijing is far from new. But with Russia diminished, Kazakhstan is choosing China—and the shift looks irreversible.
Historically, as a former Soviet republic, Kazakhstan maintained close economic and security ties with Russia. Cooperation seemed stronger than ever when Russian-led CSTO troops intervened to suppress protests in Kazakhstan in January 2022. However, Russia’s war in Ukraine has drastically altered the balance.
▪️Sanctions have made Russia’s economy far less competitive, leaving China as the dominant economic partner. Last year, China overtook Russia as Kazakhstan’s largest trading partner, with two-way trade reaching $41 billion. Even Kazakhstan's brief role as a hub for sanctions avoidance wasn’t enough to bridge the growing economic gap.
▪️Russia has lost its credibility as a regional security provider. The war exposed Moscow’s military vulnerabilities, and other neighbors have grown wary of aligning too closely with a regime that harbors colonial ambitions. This has made cooperation with China far more appealing.
▪️The optics reflect this shift. At the recent Shanghai Cooperation Organization summit in Astana, Kazakh President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev personally welcomed Xi Jinping at the airport—an honor not extended to his long-time CSTO ally, Vladimir Putin. Tokayev, fluent in Chinese and a former diplomat to Beijing, clearly understands where Kazakhstan’s future lies.
▪️China and Kazakhstan are now expanding cooperation in critical sectors like logistics. Positioned as a key hub for China-Europe trade, Kazakhstan benefits from Beijing’s push to improve transit infrastructure across the region.
The uranium deal underscores the scale of change. Russia’s economic and geopolitical decline has forced it to cede ground to China, potentially in exchange for Beijing’s tacit support of its war effort. Either way, China emerges as the clear winner—strengthening its hold over Central Asia while extracting economic and strategic benefits from Russia’s weakening position. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1029
1. 🇷🇺flagged ship loads grain in Crimea for delivery to Houthi-Yemen
2. EU commission opens investigation on TikTok re alleged election interference in Romania 🇷🇴 -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🇪🇺 The European Union is reconsidering the confiscation of Russia's frozen assets, worth approximately $300 billion, to transfer them to Ukraine, Bloomberg reports. Until now, the EU and G7 countries have used only the profits generated from these frozen assets, but a decision to fully confiscate and transfer the funds would represent a significant shift from the current approach.
According to Bloomberg sources, some EU member states are assessing the potential impact of such a move on the euro as a currency, as well as the risk that third countries might withdraw their assets from states initiating confiscation. EU foreign ministers discussed the idea during a meeting in Brussels, and the topic may resurface at the EU leaders' summit scheduled for Thursday.
Meanwhile, U.S. President Joe Biden continues to urge the EU to move forward with confiscation. EU diplomat Kaja Kallas emphasized that “frozen assets must be directly confiscated.”
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-12-17/eu-takes-a-fre… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Bellingcat
@bellingcat
Ukraine says it is outraged by the continued export of grain by a Russian-flagged vessel from a sanctioned port in occupied Crimea to Houthi-controlled Yemen. Bellingcat and @LloydsList investigate: www.bellingcat.com/news/2024/12/18/ukraine-outraged-at-ye…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Kirilov's aide was killed on the same occasion
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1028
1. 🇺🇦 SBU claims death by IED of 🇷🇺 head of CRBN defence forces General Igor Kirilov in Moscow
2. 🇺🇦 strikes vs 🇷🇺 fuel logistic links between Crimea and Zaporizhia -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1028
1. 🇺🇦 SBU claims death by IED of 🇷🇺 head of CRBN defence forces General Igor Kirilov in Moscow
2. 🇺🇦 strikes vs 🇷🇺 fuel logistic links between Crimea and Zaporizhia -
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Tim White
@TWMCLtd
1/2
#ukraine claims it destroyed an enemy train in #zaporizhzhia region, carrying vital fuel for #russia's invasion.
Kyiv says 40 fuel tanks worth $4 million were wrecked in yesterday's "unique, multi-stage operation" to cut off the logistics route from occupied #crimea. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Oliver Alexander
@OAlexanderDK
🧵More and more pointing towards the Russia/HTS deal to keep their bases has fallen apart.
The media caught wind of the deal negotiations on the 12th.
On the 12th Russia started moving its valuable S400 system out of Khmeimim Air Base
Oliver Alexander
@OAlexanderDK
The Russian S400 is definitely leaving Khmeimim Air Base.
The drone video from yesterday shows that they have packed up their 91N6E radar and it was parked on the apron ready to be loaded onto an AN-124. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1027
1. 2 🇷🇺 oil tankers sink in Kerch strait
2. Oil tanks ablaze near Orël
3. Scholz faces vote of censure today
4. SPD electoral program bans transfer of Taurus, includes prompt deep strike
5. 🇷🇺 forces pursue grignotage south of Pokrovsk -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Impressive. At least these explosives won't end up in Russian hands on the Ukrainian front
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
Aftermath of the Explosion, seen from several Miles.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ukraine Battle Map
@ukraine_map
List of ATACMS fired at Russia
November 19th - 8 ATACMS
November 24th - 2 to 5 ATACMS
November 25th - 5 to 8 ATACMS
December 11th - 6 ATACMS
Ukraine 🇺🇦 launched 21 to 27 ATACMS at Russia in the past month, striking Bryansk, Kursk, and Taganrog. With 1 strike in the past 3 weeks -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️A second tank caught fire at an attacked oil depot in the 🇷🇺Oryol region, local residents report
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
According to Russian media, two tankers, Volgoneft-212 and Volgoneft-239, are in distress near the Kerch Strait, just kilometers from shore. For 4 hours, 13/14 crew members on each vessel have been stranded on deck as massive waves reportedly breached the ships.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1026
1. 🇺🇦 UAVs hit OMON building in Grozny
2. North 🇰🇵 troops apparently enter battle in Kursk salient
3. 🇺🇦 ready to help provide food to Syria -
François Heisbourg reposted
L'Orient-Le Jour
@LOrientLeJour
🟥 [#moyen_orient] L'armée russe se retire en partie de Syrie, mais ne compte pas quitter ses deux bases stratégiques
www.lorientlejour.com/article/1439800/larmee-russe-se-ret… -
François Heisbourg reposted
XFLASH NEWS
@xflash_media
⚡️ The city of Grozny in Chechnya (russia) was attacked by UAVs, — local media reports.
There is no official information yet.
👉Follow
@blyskavka_ua -
François Heisbourg reposted
Alla Poedie 🇺🇦🇫🇷
@AllaPoedie
Le debut d'une #attaque des Nord-coréens dans la région de #koursk contre les positions ukrainiennes
En raison de la confusion, les troupes nord-coréennes ont détruit un véhicule blindé avec les hommes de Kadyrov.
8 #tchétchènes sont tués
#gur -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Bless the Montreux convention
Jake Broe
@RealJakeBroe
Russia's ships that had to flee their naval base in Syria are now under-fueled and under-supplied drifting in the Mediterranean Sea without a plan of how they will get home. That's hilarious.
@officejjsmartThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
Preliminary data indicates that Russia has begun using a significant number of North Korean soldiers in its assaults. These troops are being integrated into combined units and deployed in operations within the Kursk region. For now, their involvement is limited to this area, but there is information suggesting they may be used on other fronts as well.
Losses among these North Korean troops are already noticeable. In fact, Moscow has dragged yet another state into this war—and done so to the fullest extent. And if this is not escalation, then what is the escalation so many have talked about? It is Putin who takes steps to expand and prolong this war, pushing the possibility of peace further away.
And he wants the world to face additional problems in Asia as well, which is why the Russians are training North Korea in modern warfare. It is clear that Moscow is ignoring calls for de-escalation from all countries—from China and Brazil to many others.
Whenever there is no firm global response, Russia exacerbates the war. It has always been this way. We will defend ourselves—including against these North Koreans. We will continue to act in full coordination with all our partners to bring this war to an end—one that ensures a reliable and lasting peace.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1025
1. Recap of yesterday's missile and drone battle:
80/99 cruise missiles down including 55 Kh-55s and -101s, 1 Kh59/691 Iskander-K and 24 Kalibr.
1/2 Iskander-M, 1 Hwasong down
Plus upward of 130 Shahed and other combat drones down or lost out of 132 -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
The 155th Ukrainian mechanised brigade, heavily armed and trained by France, this autumn, is said to have been deployed on the Pokrovsk front. However, part of it was dismantled on its return to reinforce other brigades.
In response to a question from @lavoixdunord, the Ministry of the Armed Forces replied that France is “currently the only country to have implemented a complete training model (...) which has been welcomed by our Ukrainian partner. It was the Ukrainian armed forces that organised the selection of the Ukrainian soldiers who make up this brigade and the management of the flows. It is also, of course, the Ukrainian Armed Forces that define the conditions for deployment on Ukrainian soil.”
The Ministry of the Armed Forces adds that with regard to the request of a member of parliament to supply drones to the 155th brigade, the censure of the government and the resignation of the ministers have “suspended” all requests. Even the most urgent.
www.lavoixdunord.fr/1533644/article/2024-12-14/comme-un-d…
Марʼяна Безугла (Mariana Bezuhla)
@marybezuhla
The fate of the 155th Separate Mechanized Brigade named after Anna of Kyiv, which was pompously presented and "trained" in France, remains the same as with all the other new "zombie brigades," or as they are also called, "paper brigades." These brigades are endlessly created for the sake of reporting: people are forced into them, but no coordination of command structures is carried out. Later, the unit is simply torn apart and attached to others, with most being sent to assault units, except for those "placed" in staff positions through shady schemes.
What happened to the 155th Brigade... Even the French efforts to make the brigade specialized couldn't save it from the poor military decisions of our generals, which ultimately dismantled the unit.
And all this is being done instead of reinforcing the best units, reducing bloated staffs, and focusing on the cohesion and training of the teams.
It seems as if this is deliberately done to benefit the Russians.
Below is one of the messages from the military:
"Update about my brigade: The essence of the matter is that this new brigade, essentially, wasn’t needed by anyone from the very beginning (even though people from all over Ukraine were urgently gathered to staff it).
It was equipped to present a show for the French, to secure weapons from them.
Now, upon returning to Ukraine, this brigade is being dismantled like donor organs for other brigades. On the one hand, this way, we received new weapons and reinforcements for existing brigades. On the other hand, none of our units are properly coordinated, neither with one another nor with the brigades they’ve been attached to". -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
Russia fired 93 missiles and more than 200 drones into Ukraine. 81 missiles were neutralized, of which 11 have been destroyed by Ukrainian F-16 jets.
Overall, Russia‘s terror campaign today was an expensive one. The costs are above a billion USD. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Politically, the least bad choice in a bad situation. In human terms, a respected and honest man. Alas, his tenure is unlikely to much outlast that of his predecessor Michel Barnier
Sophie Pedder
@PedderSophie
🚨Emmanuel Macron has named the veteran centrist François Bayrou as the new 🇫🇷 prime minister. He takes over today from the conservative Michel Barnier, and has to start afresh the task of forming a government and drafting a new budget for 2025
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1024
1. Ongoing: 93+ missiles vs 🇺🇦 incl Kinzhal, Kalibr, Hwasong, 11 cruise missiles downed by F16s
2. DoD spox says possible new Oreshnik strike
3. M.Shatsky, dep designer at Rosatom Mars plant (eg Kh-55, 59, 101) killed in Moscow
4. Novossibirsk mil plant ablaze -
François Heisbourg reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
Another Russian missile strike against Ukraine. Cruise missiles, ballistic missiles. According to preliminary reports, 93 missiles were launched, including at least one North Korean missile. A total of 81 missiles were shot down, 11 of which were cruise missiles intercepted by our F-16s. Additionally, the Russians used nearly 200 drones in this attack. This was one of the largest strikes targeting our energy infrastructure.
This is Putin’s “peace plan”—to destroy everything. This is how he wants “negotiations”—by terrorizing millions of people. He is neither limited in long-range capabilities nor in acquiring the necessary components to produce missiles. Oil gives Putin enough money to believe in his impunity. A strong reaction is needed from the world: a massive attack must be met with a massive reaction. This is the only way terror can be stopped.
If leaders fear responding or become accustomed to terror, Putin sees it as permission to continue. Patriots are needed to shoot down these missiles and prove that terror will not achieve its goals. Sanctions against Russia for the war must be strengthened to genuinely impact Russia’s missile production.
Putin won’t be stopped by empty talk—strength is what is needed to bring peace. Strength that is not afraid of its ability to confront and stop evil.
The world can stop this madness, and to do so, it must first stop the madness in Moscow that has been ordering terror for over 20 years. Strength is what is needed. Ukraine is grateful to everyone who is helping. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Andrii Sybiha 🇺🇦
@andrii_sybiha
Massive Russian missile attack on Ukraine this morning, primarily targeting the energy system. Russia aims to deprive us of energy. Instead, we must deprive it of the means of terror. I reiterate my call for the urgent delivery of 20 NASAMS, HAWK, or IRIS-T air defense systems.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Simon Ostrovsky
@SimonOstrovsky
It’s not every day that an interview is interrupted by a Russian missile strike, but I guess I couldn’t have asked for a better illustration of the point I was trying to make. The Biden administration has shown little boldness in its dealings with countries helping Russia re-arm.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Oliver Alexander
@OAlexanderDK
Interesting detail in the latest drone video showing Khmeimim air base today. The Russian S400 SAM battery had none of its TELs erected and ready.
Not having the system ready to fire is highly unusual unless they are planning to move it in the very near future.
Guy Plopsky
@GuyPlopsky
Aerial view of 4 TELs of Russia's #s400 SAM system in #khmeimim, Syria. #airdefense #missiledefense
Video/Source: www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJck8cFvvTQ -
François Heisbourg reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Obviously another way of viewing this video is that the Russian base in Hmeimim, Syria, and its personnel are effectively defenseless hostages. With a video drone flying unmolested, wouldn’t take much for a few FPV drones to blow up the Russian aircraft and the ammo warehouses.
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Syrian rebels meanwhile fly drones over the Russian air base in Hmeimim — pretty amazing upclose look.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Babak Taghvaee - The Crisis Watch
@BabakTaghvaee1
Al-Joulani, leader of the #hts terrorist organization has appointed Abdolrahman Fattahi (عبدالرحمن فتاحی) an #iranian Kurdish Salafist as his deputy of #iran relations. Fattahi was member of Ansar Al-Islam, an Al-Qaeda linked group in #iran before joining The movement of Sunni Iranian immigrants in 2013.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
What else can go wrong? McKinsey Australia tasked with strategising the AUKUS nuclear sub procurement. Australie : remous après le choix de McKinsey sur le projet de sous-marins nucléaires www.consultor.fr/articles/australie-remous-apres-le-choix…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1023
1. Front-line situation remains complicated says 🇺🇦 gen staff
2. Multiple hits by Neptun, Peklo, Palyanytsya missiles vs 🇷🇺 targets in Crimea
3. 🇺🇦 strikes Grozny (energy target ?)
4. Austria 🇦🇹 terminates gas contract with Gazprom due to end in 2040 -
François Heisbourg reposted
-
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#international - Réfugiés syriens : L’Europe se barricade : “L’accueil des réfugiés syriens en 2015-2016 n’était pas un sujet de première importance en France. Alors qu’en Allemagne et en Autriche, c’était un enjeu humain majeur.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#syrie - Terreur syrienne : L’ombre d'Aloïs Brunner : “Hafez al-Assad et Aloïs Brunner étaient fait pour s’entendre. Brunner est réputé pour avoir causé la mort de 20 000 personnes rien qu’en France.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1022
1. Three 🇷🇺 missiles strike incl. lethal hit vs Zaporizhia (7 dead)
2. 🇺🇦 strike vs A-50 AEW aviation maintenance plant in Taganrog -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🇩🇪 CDU leader Merz says Germany would not supply Taurus missiles to Ukraine unilaterally but only in coordination with the next U.S. administration and European allies. Speaking after his meeting with Zelensky, Merz noted training on the system takes 4 months—by then, Trump could be in office.
"We must answer these questions together with the U.S. and Europe, not alone," he said. However, Merz doubts any single weapon system could fundamentally change the war.
www.n-tv.de/politik/15-52-Berichte-ueber-Durchbruch-der-R… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Quite a clutch of SSM containers there
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Charles Monneron
@CharlesMonneron
As the saying goes, “events overwhelm us, let’s pretend we organized them “, but in the case of 🇹🇷 , it may not be pretend…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1021
1. Merz meets Zelensky in Kyiv. Reaffirms conditional Taurus delivery if he becomes chancellor
2.S-400 battery destroyed by UAF in Simferopol (Crimea)
3. 2 Kh-59/69 down -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Russia's Mediterranian Flotilla is no longer in its Syrian port of Tartus.
The Kilo-class diesel sub Novorossiysk, Kaliningrad-class oiler Vyazma, Admiral Grigorovich-class frigate Admiral Grigorovich, and an Admiral Gorshkov-class frigate have left port in the past 48 hours.
MT Anderson
@MT_Anderson
🇷🇺Med Sea Flotilla🇷🇺
3m📷 from the port of Tartus on 9 December 2024
Appears that all 🇷🇺navy vessels have departed from the military piers
Doesn't 100% mean that they've evacuated but it's starting to look that way...
Time to watch Tobruk maybe? -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
Soldiers from the Anne of Kyiv Brigade are reportedly deployed in the Donbas.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Naftali Hazony
@nhazony
Israel has conquered Mt. Hermon, the highest mountain in Syria, its peak reaching 2,814m. Syria’s capital, Damascus, is only 40 km away, now within range of Israel’s artillery shells. Here’s why Israel took this mountain:
1/7 🧵 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Emile Hokayem (@emile-hokayem.bsky.social)
@emile_hokayem
It is increasingly clear that what happened is a negotiated exit for Assad and a negotiated transition, agreed by the Astana powers and the Arab states.
UN and Western states briefed but not shapers.
The question is what guarantees, if any, Russia and Iran asked for and got.
Al-Jumhuriya English
@aljumhuriya_eng
A Syrian source told Al-Jumhuriya that Assad’s fate was sealed on December 7 in Doha, during Astana meetings with Arab partners.
During the meeting Russia and Iran informed Ankara of their readiness to facilitate a political transition in Syria. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Like so many other people in the 🇺🇸, 🇮🇷,🇷🇺,🇪🇺,🇮🇱, the Arab world (naturally including Damascus), I didn't see this coming. Nor will I attempt to explain why it happened when it did & the way it did. 🇹🇷 may just possibly be an exception to this collective failure in foresight.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Bonne question. Et y aura-t-il une occupation du grand amphi de Sciences Po?
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
Timelapse of 13 years of Syrian Civil War:
🟥 Assad Regime
🟩 Syrian Revolutionaries
🟨 PKK/YPG
⬛️ Islamic StateThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
Syrian embassy in Moscow
The time interval between Russian "red lines" and reality is sometimes just a weekend.
Source of pic: Al Jazeera -
François Heisbourg reposted
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
Russian Telegram channels published a video of Syrian fighters raising their flag over the Syrian embassy in Russia.
In the past day, Russian media moved on from calling the fighters "terrorists" to "opposition".
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
Russia asked Turkey to help with withdrawing Russian troops from Syria - CNN Türk.
The media reports that Russian troops will be sent to an area where Turkish military units are located, then sent to Russia by sea.
"It is understood that it will withdraw its soldiers in the field except for Tartus, Deniz and Himeyim air bases," the media writes.
Meanwhile, OSINT researchers note that according to satellite images, Russians have probably withdrawn at least part of their personnel from the Tartus and Himeyim bases. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Mohamed Sifaoui
@Sifaoui
Lundi 9 décembre 2024
L’écrivain franco-algerien Boualem #sansal vient de passer sa 23e nuit en détention arbitraire.
Il a été arrêté par la dictature algérienne le 16 novembre 2024 pour ses opinions.
Ce régime corrompu et corrupteur dont le fonctionnement repose sur un socle populiste, complotiste et haineux garde en vérité Boualem Sansal en otage espérant obtenir une contrepartie diplomatique de la part de la France.
Un comportement de voyous qui dit tout de ce régime et qui explique pourquoi des Algériens biberonnés à la fois au nationalisme et à l’islamisme applaudissent l’incarcération arbitraire d’un écrivain tout en rêvant quitter ce pays pour un ailleurs qui est parfois la France. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Jay in Kyiv
@JayinKyiv
Here's Russian state media admitting that Assad's job was to make sure no pipelines went through Syria into Turkey so that all that cheaper Saudi and Qatari LNG never hurt Russia's gas monopoly, the one Putin lost anyway by invading Ukraine.
Jay in Kyiv
@JayinKyiv
Since 2012, Putin's puppet Assad was there to make sure the Arab Gas pipeline never got finished. The project that would have brought super cheap Saudi and Qatari gas into Turkey and on to the European market.
Even Hungary, Austria and Serbia aren't going to say no to this.
No more long tanker voyages for Qatari LNG or missing out on low priced Saudi gas, it'll all merrily head into Europe.
The last bits of European market Putin is still managing to sell to will be even further cut. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
In July 2022, Russia blew up the barracks of the Olenivka prison camp in occupied Donetsk, murdering more than 50 Ukrainian POWs and then blaming it on a Ukrainian missile strike.
Today, the director of the Olenivka camp at the time, Sergey Evsukov, was killed in a car bombing in Donetsk. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1020
1. Zelensky says 🇺🇦 KIA=43K ( 🇷🇺 = 198 K KIA) since war began
2. Shaheds hit infrastructure targets in Vinnytsia area -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Wondering whether Syria will continue to handle Iran🇮🇷 interests in the US🇺🇲 as has been the case since 1979 (Switwerland🇨🇭 handles US interests in Iran 🇮🇷
Our Passports
@ourpussports
For today's' events: an image of an early Syrian visa issued in Washington at the end of 1945.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Emile Hokayem (@emile-hokayem.bsky.social)
@emile_hokayem
A key reason why the Assad regime was so brittle is that his loyalist constituencies but also fence-sitters got to see post-'victory' that things only got worse. There was no 'victory dividend'.
No plan, no resources, no mindset to take Syria to a better place. He never cared about it and could never do it.
Just rapacity, oppression and disorder. European, Asian and Arab states could not see its hollowness because they did not have their finger on the Syrian pulse and did not care to. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Guy Elster גיא אלסטר
@guyelster
#breaking Iran’s embassy in Damascus is being stormed by protesters
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
TWZ
@thewarzonewire
Signs of possible evacuation at Russia's Khmeimim Air Base in Syria. Multiple airlifters have arrived at the base. 3 IL-76s and 1 AN-124. The An-72 is usually forward based there. There also appears to be a Su-24 on the runway. Major uptick in airlifted presence. Expect more.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Do the Moon and Mars programs count as foreign aid? @DOGE @elonmusk
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Tartous: No place for Russians anymore
Thomas van Linge
@ThomasVLinge
#syria: in the coastal city of #tartous the statue of Hafez al-Assad has been toppled.
The Alawite community, like the rest of the Syrian people, want a #freesyria. A Syria without the #assad dictatorship. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Latakia's turn, in the Alawite heatland and close to Russia's military facilities
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
Yet another Statue of Former Syrian President Hafez al-Assad is torn down and dragged through the Streets, this time in the Northwestern City of Latakia.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1019
1. Meeting in Paris between Zelensky, Trump & Macron
2. 🇫🇷 to resume SCALP production in 2025
3. Putin's protégé Bashar al-Assad falls after 12 day lightning offensive -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
Syrian Rebels this morning, at the Gates of Assad’s Presidential Palace in the Capital of Damascus.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
According to the General Staff of the armed forces, the air force’s stock of SCALP-EG cruise missiles will be replenished in 2024. And according to a parliamentary report, “the year 2025 will also be crucial for the replenishment of the SCALP missiles transferred to the Ukrainian partner”. €2 billion will be allocated in 2025 to upgrade stocks of SCALP-EG, Aster and MICA missiles.
👉 www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/rapports/cion_def/l17b0… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Kinda symbolic that Trump is meeting Zelensky on the day Putin lost Syria
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
I had a good and productive trilateral meeting with President @realDonaldTrump and President @EmmanuelMacron at the Élysée Palace.
President Trump is, as always, resolute. I thank him. I also extend my gratitude to Emmanuel for organizing this important meeting.
We all want this war to end as soon as possible and in a just way. We spoke about our people, the situation on the ground, and a just peace.
We agreed to continue working together and keep in contact. Peace through strength is possible. -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
President-Elect Donald J. Trump meets with Ukrainian President Zelensky in Paris.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1018
1. Romanian constitutional court annuals 1st round ('TikTok elex') of presidential election and orders rerun
2. 5 🇷🇺 missiles vs 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Karim Franceschi
@karimfranceschi
I’ve fought in #syria for half a decade—as an SDF soldier. In that time, I studied war, drew battle plans, and learned to know my enemy. When HTS seized their first village, I saw what few others could. Take a peek at what’s coming next—a 🧵
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Thord Are Iversen
@The_Lookout_N
The Russian Navy hasn't abandoned Tartus.
Here we see, I think, the parts of the Kilo-class SSK Novorossiysk at the left edge, a Gorshkov-class FFG, an oiler I believe is Vyazma (not 100% sure) and the Grigorovich-class FFG Admiral Grigorovich.
Brady Africk
@bradyafr
As rebel forces gain ground in Syria, only a few warships remain in Russia's naval base in Tartus.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
The President of Ukraine, Volodymyr Zelensky, is expected to take part in the re-opening ceremony of Notre-Dame Cathedral in Paris.
rmc.bfmtv.com/actualites/international/notre-dame-de-pari… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Thomas van Linge
@ThomasVLinge
#syria BREAKING: #sdf forces have entered the city of #deirzezzor and are taking control of the airport.
The #assad regime is finished in the east. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
Turkish President Erdoğan on the developments in Syria:
As of now; Idlib, Hama, Homs and of course Damascus. This march of the opposition continues.
We had called Assad. We said, let's determine the future of Syria together. We did not receive a positive response unfortunately. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Three nuclear power plants in Ukraine have significantly restored electricity production, according to the IAEA. The Khmelnytskyi, Rivne, and South Ukrainian NPPs now operate eight reactors out of nine, with most gradually increasing power.
www.iaea.org/newscenter/pressreleases/update-263-iaea-dir… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1016
The usual grind in the air and on the ground: no salient single event militarily or politically last night -
François Heisbourg reposted
InterMarium
@inter_marium
Ta(c)k!!! Sweden and Denmark to spend billions on joint combat vehicle order: Of the 205 CV90 vehicles ordered, 115 will be delivered to Denmark, 50 to Sweden and 40 to #ukraine, the Swedish government said in a statement. www.thelocal.dk/20241206/sweden-and-denmark-to-spend-bill…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ukraine Battle Map
@ukraine_map
HTS is less than 22km from splitting the Coast of Syria 🇸🇾 with the ports of Tartus and Latakia from being connected to Damascus and the rest of Syria
A day ago, HTS was ~70km away. It’s a total collapse at this point -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Looks like the Jebel Alaouite is up for grabs. Incredible
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
The path of Syrian rebel kamikaze drone attacks to Russian bases in Syria. Map by Rybar
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Emile Hokayem (@emile-hokayem.bsky.social)
@emile_hokayem
Thinking about all the delusional European and Arab ideas to normalise with Assad all these years in the hope that the 'state' can be fixed so that the refugees could go home.
There was no state left under Bashar, and he could not even build/reorganise a proper security system after 'winning' in 2016-18! -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — Entire Hama city is under the control of Syrian rebels.
Major defeat for the Assad government. It just took few days to capture a major city which was fortified with reinforcements
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — Syrian government officially acknowledges that Syrian military had withdrawn from Hama city after fierce battle, ceding the territory to Syrian rebels
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Could this be the same firm which does beepers? 🙃
ChrisO_wiki
@ChrisO_wiki
1/ Russia's VT-40 'Judgment Day' FPV drones are reportedly blowing up on launch and killing their own operators. It's the latest in a series of problems that are being blamed on a manufacturer that appears to be more interested in quantity than quality. ⬇️
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Colby Badhwar
@ColbyBadhwar
🇺🇸☎️🇷🇺 General Gerasimov, Chief of Russia's General Staff, called General Brown, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff last week.
“at the request of General Gerasimov, General Brown agreed to not proactively announce the [very rare] call.”
Interestingly, Gerasimov told Brown that the Oreshnik IRBM strike on Ukraine was planned long before President Biden authorized limited ATACMS strikes on internationally recognized Russian territory.
Not sure what the motivation for conveying that claim would be.
Via NYT, link in alt text. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1017
1. 30th anniversary of the Budapest Memorandum, a document which demonstrates the need for cast-iron (eg NATO) defence guarantees for 🇺🇦
2. 2 Iskander-M strikes in Dnipro area
3. Warning signals fm Russian ship to German helo in the Baltic -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Of course, the picture doesn't look quite as good for Russia if one factors in the Ukrainian territorial gains in Russia (Kursk)
War Mapper
@War_Mapper
Russia has achieved net territorial gains inside Ukraine every month since November 2023.
Since June 2024, these gains have grown consistently larger each month, reflecting a steady acceleration in the pace of their advance. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Well, well...In addition, because French SSNs use LEU, proliferation concerns would be less pressing. However, as we say in France, "chat échaudé craint l'eau froide" (loosely: "once bitten, twice shy"; literally: "scalded cat fears cold water") www.aspistrategist.org.au/aukus-risks-are-piling-up-austr…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
Maria Avdeeva
@maria_avdv
Just read the Budapest Memorandum—six short paragraphs, and Russia has broken every single one. Why would anyone believe Russia will keep any agreement without it being backed by decisive force?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Many wars in this war:
1. Rebels pro-Al Qaeda and vs Bashar (and 🇷🇺) and YPG (and 🇺🇸) and Daesh
2. YPG vs Rebels (and 🇹🇷) and Daesh and Bashar (& 🇷🇺)
3. Hezbollah and 🇮🇷 pro Bashar vs 🇮🇱 (& vice versa)
4. Daesh vs Rebels (and Al Qaeda)
Note: This is a gross oversimplification.
Karim Franceschi
@karimfranceschi
1/ A map of tonight's events: a platoon-sized incursion by the Turkish-backed Fajr al-Hurriya coalition into Manbij was repelled by the SDF. This is part of a larger ethnic cleansing operation unfolding across northern Syria, targeting Kurdish-majority areas. 🧵
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
ICYMI: A Winning Strategy to End Russia's War Against Ukraine | U-M LSA Weiser Center for Europe and Eurasia (WCEE). Hopefully, our work at Ann Arbor will help pave the way to the end of Russia's war against Ukraine. ii.umich.edu/wcee/news-events/news/search-news/a-winning-…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Expect therefore a new round (s) of great political uncertainty. In budget terms, 2025 expenditure may be by twelfths, replicating the 2024 budget. The default mode will be not to add or cancel new programmes (ie, previously budgetted aid to 🇺🇦 would presumably continue)
Sophie Pedder
@PedderSophie
Extraordinary moment in France. Parliament has just voted down Michel Barnier’s government, thanks to the left and Le Pen’s far right voting together. It’s the first time parliament has overthrown a 🇫🇷 government since 1962
-
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
“The rate of production of AASM bombs has also accelerated, both to enable larger deliveries to Ukraine and to replenish national stocks.” — @HConwayMouret
👉 www.senat.fr/rap/a24-146-8/a24-146-8_mono.html
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
According to the General Staff of the armed forces, the air force’s stock of SCALP-EG cruise missiles will be replenished in 2024. And according to a parliamentary report, “the year 2025 will also be crucial for the replenishment of the SCALP missiles transferred to the Ukrainian partner”. €2 billion will be allocated in 2025 to upgrade stocks of SCALP-EG, Aster and MICA missiles.
👉 www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/rapports/cion_def/l17b0… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1016
1. German MFA Baerbock doesn't rule out Forces in 🇺🇦 as part of a cease fire deal
2. Kherson as possible target of 🇷🇺 mil ops?
3. Slow missile night (1 Kh-59/69) and average attack drone activity vs 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
Germany's Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock has refused to rule out deploying Bundeswehr soldiers to Ukraine as part of any future cease-fire deal. www.politico.eu/article/germany-annalena-baerbock-wont-ru…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"Japanification" of China. Wondering what the strategic effect may be: hopefully not a remake of 1930s Japan
-
François Heisbourg reposted
WarTranslated
@wartranslated
Russia may be preparing a large-scale offensive on Kherson ahead of Trump’s inauguration: Russia has already prepared 300 boats to cross the Dnipro river, according to the head of the Kherson Regional Military Administration.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
'Hearts and minds', Russian style
Rob Lee
@RALee85
"Kherson’s civilians have been, since midsummer, the target of an experiment without precedent in modern European warfare: a concerted Russian campaign to empty a city by stalking its residents with attack drones.
The killer machines, sometimes by the swarm, hover above homes, buzz into buildings and chase people down streets in their cars, riding bicycles or simply on foot. The targets are not soldiers, or tanks, but civilian life...
Since mid-July, Kherson and its neighboring villages along the western side of the Dnipro river have suffered more than 9,500 attacks with small drones, killing at least 37 people and injuring hundreds more, according to Prokudin, regional prosecutors and police."
@ChristopherJM @samjoiner @inari_ta
www.ft.com/content/31b630b3-2639-456c-ba50-3caea7a9b2b5 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"It's a pity both sides can't lose"...
Naftali Hazony
@nhazony
The rebels are now advancing towards Hama, Syria, and are only 40km away from the strategic city of Homs. But who are these rebels? Who is their leader? And what might they do if they took control of Syria? 1/13 🧵
-
François Heisbourg reposted
HistoricalTristan
@HistoricalTris1
Though China supplies most of the world's low grade Gallium, Japan, Slovakia, the UK and US all produce the high grade Gallium needed in chip manufacture. Most Sb used in Europe comes from Turkey. The US has its own Ge and more available. China's policy will backfire.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Maybe. But itay not be great for US-Chinese relations. Trump 1.0 denounced the "China virus". Could Trump 2.0 now return to the topic with a vengeance?
Michel Vanbruaene
@michelvanbru
Am I the only one to think that it is a good news? Laboratory leaks should be much easier to contain than 'natural' spread between species or in market places...
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Who would have guessed...
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
The U.S. Congress Attributes COVID-19 to a Laboratory Origin
COVID-19 "most likely originated from a laboratory in Wuhan, China," and spread due to a leak, according to a congressional report following a two-year investigation.
Lawmakers presented five arguments supporting their conclusion. They claim that COVID-19 has unique biological characteristics not found in nature. Additionally, all cases of infection stemmed from a single instance of the virus entering a human host, whereas previous pandemics involved multiple pathways of transmission.
The report also highlighted the presence of a research lab studying SARS viruses in Wuhan. According to the congressmen, this lab operated with insufficient levels of biological safety.
"Researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) fell ill with a virus similar to COVID in the fall of 2019, months before COVID-19 was identified at the wildlife market. By all scientific standards, if there were evidence of a natural origin, it would have emerged by now," the report concluded. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1014
1. 3 cruise missiles down. Comparatively calm air defence situation (low dozens of drones)
2. Norwegian F35s to fly air patrols at Rzeszów -
François Heisbourg reposted
Jamming
@balticjam
”Norway will safeguard the airspace above the airport in Rzeszów, Poland” www.regjeringen.no/en/aktuelt/norge-bidrar-med-f-35-kampf…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Thord Are Iversen
@The_Lookout_N
More cable troubles:
An internet cable between Finland and Sweden has been cut/damaged, on land in Finland, and the case is being investigated as possible sabotage.
Krigsplacerad
@krigsplacerad
”Kabelbrottet upptäcktes i natt och ska ha skett på land i Finland. Polisen misstänker brott och svenska myndigheter är informerade, rapporterar radion.”
www.expressen.se/nyheter/sverige/uppgifter-kabelbrott-pa-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Who would have guessed...
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
The U.S. Congress Attributes COVID-19 to a Laboratory Origin
COVID-19 "most likely originated from a laboratory in Wuhan, China," and spread due to a leak, according to a congressional report following a two-year investigation.
Lawmakers presented five arguments supporting their conclusion. They claim that COVID-19 has unique biological characteristics not found in nature. Additionally, all cases of infection stemmed from a single instance of the virus entering a human host, whereas previous pandemics involved multiple pathways of transmission.
The report also highlighted the presence of a research lab studying SARS viruses in Wuhan. According to the congressmen, this lab operated with insufficient levels of biological safety.
"Researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) fell ill with a virus similar to COVID in the fall of 2019, months before COVID-19 was identified at the wildlife market. By all scientific standards, if there were evidence of a natural origin, it would have emerged by now," the report concluded. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Holger Zschaepitz
@Schuldensuehner
France to hold no-confidence vote on govt Wednesday w/far-right leader Marine Le Pen expected to join forces with a left-wing coalition to topple the govt. BBG)
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
Syrian rebels made significant progress on Hama front last night. They steadily approach the city by seizing nearby strategic towns one by one.
It isn’t an easy task as footage indicate regime indeed resists this time.
But the HTS-aligned forces have more discipline and they have the tech advantage of FPV drones -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Enfin! La France va recouvrer une capacité SEAD/DEAD dont la guerre d'Ukraine montre l'importance air-cosmos.com/article/les-rafale-f4-francais-recupereron…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Tymofiy Mylovanov
@Mylovanov
Putin to reject Trump’s peace offer. New Russian conditions demand concessions from the U.S., not just Ukraine:
“Kellogg comes to Moscow with his plan, we take it and tell him to screw himself, because we don’t like any of it.”
1/
Financial Times
@FT
Putin to reject Trump’s opening peace offer, says Russian tycoon www.ft.com/content/ac39b604-ef6d-41cb-bb8c-0eb76e002176
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1013
1. Scholz in Kyiv announcing € 350 M in military aid
2. Relatively uiet missile and drone night -
François Heisbourg reposted
Camille Grand
@camille_grand
Good recap indeed but also important to put things in perspective: Russian forces suffer heavy losses to achieve significant but far from spectacular gains. Following the recent offensive, Russia controls an additional 0.2 percent of the Ukrainian territory (660.000 km2).
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ian Ellis
@ianellisjones
A lot going on in the Indo-Pacific — a few things you may have missed last week 🧵
- Chinese balloons are back around Taiwan
- China + Russia conduct 9th joint strategic aerial patrol
- Largest swarm of Chinese ships ever near Philippines’ Thitu island
- Taiwan intercepts China Coast Guard ships in Kinmen’s restricted waters
- Three PRC research vessels enter the Philippines’ EEZ
- CCG carries out intrusive patrols in Malaysia’s EEZ
- Taiwan’s President lands in Hawaii, irking Beijing
- U.S. approves $320 million arms sale to Taiwan
China could launch military drills, or exercise “Joint Sword C,” in response. More info + sources below. -
François Heisbourg reposted
GAU
@deaidua
Chancellor Olaf Scholz has arrived in #ukraine and said that he would be announcing €650 million in new military aid today. I will, of course, be following this and reporting on it, but I have the suspicion that this is by no means “new aid”.
As recently as September, it was reported that military equipment worth €1.4 billion would be delivered by the end of the year. This was reconfirmed just a month later.
Now “another” 650 million euros just in December? I am very sure that it is simply the rest of the €1.4 billion already announced. This is likely to include two IRIS-T systems (1 IRIS-T SLM fire unit, 2 IRIS-T launchers), further self-propelled howitzers, Gepard SPAAGs and more.
Apart from that, isn't it striking that Marcus Faber, Chairman of the Defence Committee of the German Bundestag, already said in September that aid financed by an €650 million EPF reimbursement is part of the €1.4 billion package and now exactly €650 million will be announced?
Well, I'll let it surprise me.
Bundeskanzler a.D. Olaf Scholz
@KanzlerScholz
Deutschland wird der stärkste Unterstützer der Ukraine in Europa bleiben.
Beim Treffen mit @ZelenskyyUa werde ich weitere Rüstungsgüter im Wert von 650 Millionen Euro ankündigen, die noch im Dezember geliefert werden sollen. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Helpful recap. Nothing big yet (the ground seized in 2024 is still smaller than the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg). But the question is: all other things remaining equal in terms of manpower mobilisation and Western aid, how long before the front cracks?
Emil Kastehelmi
@emilkastehelmi
This fall has been grim for Ukraine. According to our assessment, between 1 September and 30 November, the Russians captured over 1600 km2 in Ukraine, and retook roughly 500 km2 in Kursk. The rate of advance accelerated every month, despite the Russians suffering heavy losses. 1/
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Bonne question. Avec tout ce qui se passe en Méditerranée orientale, ce n'est peut-être pas le bon moment pour faire des galipettes dans l'océan Indien ://www.varmatin.com/marine/mystere-le-porte-avions-charles-de-gaulle-est-il-vraiment-parti-en-mission-dans-le-pacifique-960089
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
French Senate report: don't hold your breath on the future of FCAS. Not a surprise.
Laurent Lagneau
@zonemilitaire
Selon le Sénat, les divergences avec Berlin font douter de l’avenir du Système de combat aérien du futur www.opex360.com/2024/12/01/selon-le-senat-les-divergences…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine - Novembre 2024
Synthèse, de fin de mois, des superficies occupées par l'armée russe | LPR | DPR dans les oblasts d'Ukraine.
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Sicker than sick. This person is tapped by Trump to serve as ambassador to France.
The Intellectualist
@highbrow_nobrow
This is Jared Kushner’s dad, who has been nominated to be the U.S. Ambassador to France.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Good idea, too, my friend
Michael Shurkin
@MichaelShurkin
I'll take the job!
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Rather like (but better than) Tu-95
Michael Corbett Hawkins
@MCorbettHawkins
Sub-sonic, only 70 years old…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Voixi un petit rappel du pedigree de Charles Kushner, à l'adresse de ceux qui trouvent que la France devrait lui donner son agrément. Je ne suis pas bégueule et plutôt Realpolitiker mais là, j'ai du mal à suivre
Bruno Tertrais
@BrunoTertrais
Ladies and gentlemen, Trump's ambassador to France.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1012
1. Kaja Kallas et al. from freshly instated EU institutions in Kyiv
2. Quiet missile (2) day
3. Not improving transatlantic relations: Trump wants to name convicted felon Charles Kushner as US ambassador to France -
François Heisbourg reposted
Alexandra Brzozowski
@alex_owski
🇪🇺🇺🇦 Europe's backing for #ukraine should remain unrestricted, incl possibility of deploying troops in the future, to help maintain strategic ambiguity toward #russia, #eu's new top diplomat @kajakallas reporters, including @Euractiv, on the train to Kyiv. www.euractiv.com/section/global-europe/news/eus-top-diplo…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
La France 🇫🇷 saura-t-elle refuser son agrément à la nomination de ce triste sire comme ambassadeur des US à Paris? Note: bien que rare, ce type de refus fait partie des prérogatives diplomatiques des États souverains
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
Je conseille de lire son cv. « Juicy » comme diraient les Américains…. Inutile de dire qu’il n’a pas la moindre connaissance de notre pays. Au moins, il aura accès au président. On se console comme on peut.
Ben Jacobs
@Bencjacobs
Trump announces Charles Kushner, Jared's father, as his nominee to be Ambassador to France
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Charles Kushner, a time-serving condemned felon proposed by Trump as ambassador to France. I hope we'll do the honourable thing and refuse our agrément to this nomination
Marion Van Renterghem
@MarionVanR
La nomination de Charles Kushner comme ambassadeur des 🇺🇸 en 🇫🇷 est une insulte de Trump à la 🇫🇷.
Le père de son gendre, condamné pour malversations fiscales, avait passé un a dans une prison fédérale avant d’être gracié par Trump lors de son 1er mandat. www.liberation.fr/international/amerique/charles-kushner-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
Je conseille de lire son cv. « Juicy » comme diraient les Américains…. Inutile de dire qu’il n’a pas la moindre connaissance de notre pays. Au moins, il aura accès au président. On se console comme on peut.
Ben Jacobs
@Bencjacobs
Trump announces Charles Kushner, Jared's father, as his nominee to be Ambassador to France
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Gradual and incremental shifts but laying the ground for an uncertain future
Etienne Marcuz
@Etienne_Marcuz
Slowly and quitely, 🇫🇷 French strategic air forces (FAS) seem to increase their joint training with 🇪🇺European allies. After ☢️ nuclear-capable Rafale deployed to 🇱🇹Lithuania for air policy missions earlier this week, others trained with 🇩🇪German Eurofighter over the 2 countries.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
NEW: Syrian news site Sawt Al-Asima, which specialises on Damascus news, says there are no security incidents in Damascus and its countryside, and everything being circulated on social media about clashes between Syrian army units or security services is false.
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — Very violent clashes between the Syrian Republican Guard and the Fourth Division in Damascus are being reported by the opposition media.
The clashes are concentrated inside the capital, specifically in the Kafr Sousa area. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
President of Georgia Salome Zourabichvili will not leave her post until a legitimate parliament and president are elected
"My mandate remains in effect until a legally elected parliament appoints someone to replace me. I am with you and will stay with you," she stated.
Zourabichvili’s term is set to end in December 2024. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — Gunfire in sourthern Syrian city Daraa reported by the opposition media. Daraa is bordering Jordan.
If true, Syrian regime is falling apart -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — Very violent clashes between the Syrian Republican Guard and the Fourth Division in Damascus are being reported by the opposition media.
The clashes are concentrated inside the capital, specifically in the Kafr Sousa area. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Great film. It was subsequently withdrawn from Soviet cinemas during the period of the Hitler-Stalin pact
DepressedBergman
@DannyDrinksWine
On this day, 86 years ago, Sergei Eisenstein's "Alexander Nevsky" (1938) premiered in Moscow, Soviet Union.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Looks like a real thunder-run: 4 days from Idlib to Aleppo then Hama followed by Homs
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
NEW: Russian military leaders residing in the "Grand Hama Hotel" left towards Homs Governorate, Sham Network claims.
Below, Syrian rebels seize a Russian armoured vehicle in northern Hama countryside -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nigel Gould-Davies
@Nigelgd1
In light of Zelenskyy's @SkyNews interview, I highly recommend this prescient 2023 piece on Ukraine's "Adenauer option" by @FHeisbourg, which explores logic and prospects of what Ze proposes.
@SurvivalEditors @IISS_org @dana_allin
www.iiss.org/online-analysis/survival-online/2023/07/how-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Some folks have been suggesting that my 07.2023 piece in @IISS_org 'Survival' may have helped inspire Zelensky's latest suggestions concerning the territorial status quo & NATO membership. I can neither confirm nor deny this. Here it this as a refresher www.iiss.org/online-analysis/survival-online/2023/07/how-…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
Peskov refrained from answering whether Bashar al-Assad is indeed in Moscow.
"I have nothing to say on this matter," said Putin's press secretary.
However, several Russian Telegram channels report that Assad, along with his entire family, has settled at the Four Seasons hotel in Moscow. It is also reported that late on November 29, he was granted an audience with Putin.
I remind you that the former president of Ukraine, Viktor Yanukovych, has been living in Russia for 10 years, after fleeing the country in February 2014 following the shooting of peaceful protesters on Independence Square in Kyiv.
Currently, Yanukovych lives in an upscale area near Moscow called "Barvikha." It is part of "Rublyovka," where the richest and most influential people in Russia reside.
Perhaps Assad will settle nearby?
Assad has stated that Syria will recognize the "new borders" of Russia, referring to the temporarily occupied Ukrainian territories, and at the beginning of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, he promised Putin to send 40,000 Syrians and weapons to assist the occupying forces. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Julian Röpcke 🇩🇪🤝🇺🇦
@JulianRoepcke
Kursish YPG forces reached Aleppo airport before Turkish-backed rebels … this is gonna be interesting and probably bloody.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Holger Zschaepitz
@Schuldensuehner
Good morning from Germany where the once-thriving southern regions are experiencing an unprecedented decline due to deindustrialization. Baden-Württemberg remains stuck in a permanent recession, w/its economy shrinking by 0.4% in Q3—significantly greater slump than in Germany as a whole. Meanwhile, other regions are faring much better: Brandenburg's economy grew by 1.1% QoQ, and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania saw a 1% jump, as the industry plays a smaller role in these areas. www.welt.de/wirtschaft/plus254720044/In-Deutschlands-frue…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1011
1. Zelensky ready to discuss temporary loss of occupied territory and protection of unoccupied 🇺🇦 by NATO umbrella. I call it the Adenauer option, adapted to the current age (as detailed in my @IISS_org piece in "Survival" summer 2023)
2. Quiet air situation -
François Heisbourg reposted
Clash Report
@clashreport
NEW: Zelensky appoints Mykhailo Drapatyi as Commander of Ukraine’s Ground Forces.
Drapatyi, a battle-hardened general, is famed for his 2014 Mariupol breakthrough on a BMP, a symbol of the city’s liberation. -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️🇺🇦Ukrainian F-16 fighters destroyed seven 🇷🇺Russian cruise missiles aimed at civilian targets a few nights ago. They were effective, Ukrainian President Zelensky said.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
1/2 Guerre d'Ukraine | 29/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Niu-York-Toretsk🔹U241129-0821
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241129-0852
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241129-0844
🌐 Vuhledar-Velyka novosilka🔹U241129-0840
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Of course, the South Korean model relied, and continues to rely, on the presence of dozens of thousands of combat-ready US soldiers on the ground
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
In principle, West German concept probably soundest for a durable, effective war outcome.
For both systemic and Ukrainian reasons.
Alts - ‘porcupine’ armed UA to teeth, 1953 SK coalition of willing - finesse NATO.
Practical politics suggest SK model may be most likely.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
All analogies are imperfect, incl my "Adenauer model". But it has the virtue of showing that NATO membership was compatible with unresolved borders+division. What is less well known is that article 5 was made conditional on the non-use of force in the pursuit of reunification
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
Zelensky seeks what @fheisbourg first raised in Survival (afaik): West German model.
Concept sound; analogy tricky. UK, FR & US already occupied West Germany/Bizonia. NATO then also abt assuaging European fears DE re-armament.
Kissinger did note UA in NATO a stability for RF. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
Assadists and the remnants of Hezbollah, backed by Iran and Russia vs. Jihadis backed by Turkey. All the worst people in the world are converging on Aleppo (the once great city where my family hails from) to slaughter each other.
I hope they all win. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Yuka Koshino | 越野 結花
@YukaKoshino
Here is an evening scoop by Nikkei.
Japan, U.K. and Italy to invite Saudi Arabia to next-gen fighter project asia.nikkei.com/Politics/Defense/Japan-U.K.-and-Italy-to-… via @NikkeiAsia -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Thank you ☺️
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Does a central banker need to say anything about arms procurement in general and US arms in particular?
-
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
“I thanked France for its readiness to assist with urgently strengthening Ukraine’s air defense, as well as for its comprehensive defense support and the expedited process for transferring Mirage aircraft.” — @ZelenskyyUa
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
“In this regard, we really need to pay tribute to France, because in six months they were able to do what we expected the US to do for a year and a half...
The French have done the basics:
– reduced bureaucracy as much as possible;
- developed a short and effective programme;
- immediately enrolled people for training; - did not f*ck with the language (i.e. they did not look for excuses);
There was no language issue at all, everyone who could speak and understand English immediately started training, the pilots were selected with good knowledge, but for some reason the French are the ones who teach people, while some only raise the bar and stall.
We once mentioned what kind of support we can count on, so after the announcement that Mirages will be modified for ground operations, we are definitely ready to say that the French are ours”. -
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
Rebel Fighters filmed at the Center of Aleppo in Northern Syria, as Hayat Tahir al-Sham (HTS) continues to Advance into the City without almost any Resistance from the Syrian Army or its Allies.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Annette Heinisch
@HeinischAnnette
Ja, seufz. What else could go wrong - mir fiele da noch die Migration ein, die Infrastruktur und...nein, ich höre lieber auf.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
No politics-free Russian energy, no cheap US defence, no privileged Chinese market access: what else could go wrong?
-
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#géopolitique - Afrique : L'armée française n'est plus la bienvenue : “Un président sénégalais va réaffirmer avec raison, et il a l’obligation de le dire : nous sommes un pays souverain.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
All analogies are imperfect, incl my "Adenauer model". But it has the virtue of showing that NATO membership was compatible with unresolved borders+division. What is less well known is that article 5 was made conditional on the non-use of force in the pursuit of reunification
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
Zelensky seeks what @fheisbourg first raised in Survival (afaik): West German model.
Concept sound; analogy tricky. UK, FR & US already occupied West Germany/Bizonia. NATO then also abt assuaging European fears DE re-armament.
Kissinger did note UA in NATO a stability for RF. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Thomas van Linge
@ThomasVLinge
Russia has commented on events in #syria: "We call on the Syrian government to restore order at the front in Aleppo"
Code for: figure it out yourself this time.
الجزيرة - عاجل
@AJABreaking
عاجل | الرئاسة الروسية بشأن الوضع بحلب: ندعو النظام السوري إلى استعادة النظام الدستوري في المنطقة في أسرع وقت ممكن
-
François Heisbourg reposted
jean-dominique merchet
@jdomerchet
Faute d'être partie à temps d'Afrique, la France est mise dehors -
@jdomerchet @lopinion_fr
Le Tchad et le Sénégal veulent mettre fin à la présence militaire française. Un exemple de plus du décrochage de Paris sur la scène internationale www.lopinion.fr/international/faute-detre-partie-a-temps-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Thomas van Linge
@ThomasVLinge
#syria: footage of rebel forces, the final moments before they moved out and advanced into the city of #aleppo.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Salome Zourabichvili
@Zourabichvili_S
Today marks the end of the constitutional coup unfolding for weeks. The course set months ago, taking us from Europe toward Russia, has now concluded.
Today, this illegitimate government declared not peace, but war—on its own people, past, and future.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1010
1. Big missile night: 111 launched (incl 16 Kalibr), 86 cruise missiles down
2. 'Atlas' oil depot ablaze (Rostov obl.)
3. Georgia renoumces EU integration -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Strategic autonomy this is not. A politically unwise statement by ECB head www.marketwatch.com/story/eu-should-avoid-trade-war-with-…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Plutôt d'accord. Dans le passé, la présence française avait un sens face aux incursions de la Libye de Kadhafi. Ce n'est plus le problème. Mais voyons la suite
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Maybe. This has actually happened before in each of the two countries. So let's wait for the follow-through. That being said, this time may be more serious, ie definitive
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
HUGE: Both Chad and Senegal declare same day that they no longer require the services of French military in their country
Fabrice Riceputi
@campvolant
"Combien y a-t-il de soldats sénégalais en France ?"
Bassirou Diomaye Faye : « Il n’y aura bientôt plus de soldats français au Sénégal » www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2024/11/28/bassirou-diomay… via @lemondefr -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
HUGE: Both Chad and Senegal declare same day that they no longer require the services of French military in their country
Fabrice Riceputi
@campvolant
"Combien y a-t-il de soldats sénégalais en France ?"
Bassirou Diomaye Faye : « Il n’y aura bientôt plus de soldats français au Sénégal » www.lemonde.fr/afrique/article/2024/11/28/bassirou-diomay… via @lemondefr -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Busy place, the Baltic sea 🌊
Aki H Heikkinen
@akihheikkinen
Swedish cargo ship is on fire near Bornholm.
Fire and explosion onboard reported on mayday call. Five people being evacuated. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
No politics-free Russian energy, no cheap US defence, no privileged Chinese market access: what else could go wrong?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Time for a Baltic Montreux convention, maybe. With Denmark 🇩🇰 as the gatekeeper?
Scribbles
@Scribbles646
Should only allow approved ships into Lake NATO from now on
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
⚡️⚡️ BREAKING: Georgia has officially renounced European integration
Georgia refuses from negotiations on accession to the EU until 2028. This was announced by Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze.
Today, the European Parliament adopted a resolution that does not recognize Georgia's parliamentary results and demands sanctions against the leaders of the "Georgian Dream". -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Aleppo blues?
AlexandruC4
@AlexandruC4
BREAKING: Syria's Assad arrived in Moscow for an unplanned visit
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Frederik Ducrozet
@fwred
🚨With some help from @jeuasommenulle, this morning the 🇬🇷 10-year Greek government bond yield fell below its 🇫🇷 French OAT equivalent.
What a time to be alive. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
BREAKING — IRGC officially confirms the death of a high ranking Iranian general in Aleppo during the clashes with the Syrian rebel forces
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
NEW: Syrian rebels managed to kill IRGC’s Brigadier General Kiyomarth Porhashmi in Aleppo during the latest offensive, Iran’s SNN agency reports
He is described as the the commander of the Iranian advisors in Syria -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Looks like someone who has forgotten to do a pit stop before going on stage
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
I wasn't sure about Putin's hands.
But these legs and feet are definitely his. And the heels, too. That's clear. -
François Heisbourg reposted
OpexNews
@OpexNews
🇫🇷🇺🇦 Le groupe de défense français DCI a proposé ses services au MINARM pour envoyer d'anciens soldats sur le territoire ukrainien.
Cet engagement concerne des formations au maniement des canons #caesar, aux drones ou encore du soutien médical.
www.lalettre.fr/fr/entreprises_defense-et-aeronautique/20… -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️The Dutch Minister of Defense announced that the 🇳🇱Netherlands has delivered three Patriot missile launchers to 🇺🇦Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragıp Soylu
@ragipsoylu
Wow: Syrian rebels are at a 10km distance to Aleppo city center.
They captured Khan Al-Asal and then Al Zarba, both strategic locations sitting on the highways -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
L'Académie française va devoir insérer "le spread" (n.m.) dans la toute nouvelle version du Dictionnaire, avec "auto-dissuasion" et "islamo-gauchisme"
LASSERRE ISABELLE
@ilasserre
Oui. Le déni français s'applique décidément dans tous les secteurs. Les yeux fermés sur: la menace russe, la menace islamiste et maintenant la menace financière.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not sure @Bundeskanzler Scholz will appreciate my comparison with his forerunners during the euromissile crisis during the 1980s.
Landry Charrier
@landry_charrier
⚡️"Wir erleben derzeit nicht einen Bruchteil der Bedrohung, die wir (...) Anfang der Achtzigerjahre hatten. Wenn wir damals so ängstlich reagiert hätten wie Olaf #scholz (...), würden die Sowjetrussen heute in Biarritz stehen" (@FHeisbourg, #ukraine)👇 www.welt.de/politik/ausland/plus254683716/Sicherheitsexpe…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
My full-length interview in @welt . Sorry for the paywall www.welt.de/politik/ausland/plus254683716/Sicherheitsexpe…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Of course, the Muj in Afghanistan got their training (eg Stingers) fm the tooth fairy, Contras in Nicaragua were bystanders, Bill Casey never helped UNITA., Lebanon never happened etc. etc. Overt or covert mil assistance by US operatives was Cold War SOP as was the case for Sovs
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
@shashj Understand the frustration. Suggest CW inapposite. No 🇺🇸 troops Afghan 1979-88, Angola, Nicaragua, El Salvador, Ethiopia, etc. 🇺🇦 today on EU doorstep; 🇺🇸 troops in combat de facto wider war; plus 🇨🇳🇮🇳 etc impacts. 🇺🇦 key problem partial mobilization & bad training.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
My "Soviets in Biarritz" quote in @welt interview, in reference to Olaf Scholz's policy as compared to his forerunners during the 1980s euro-missile crisis
Landry Charrier
@landry_charrier
⚡️"Wir erleben derzeit nicht einen Bruchteil der Bedrohung, die wir (...) Anfang der Achtzigerjahre hatten. Wenn wir damals so ängstlich reagiert hätten wie Olaf #scholz (...), würden die Sowjetrussen heute in Biarritz stehen" (@FHeisbourg, #ukraine)👇 www.welt.de/politik/ausland/plus254683716/Sicherheitsexpe…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Now estimated at 76 Kalibr
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1009
-Russian energy offensive: 22 Kalibr missiles, plus drones hit, inter alia, electricity substations. Multiple blackouts -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Latest update on last night's energy attack: 76 Kalibr
Ukrainian Air Force
@KpsZSU
We work 🫡
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1009
-Russian energy offensive: 22 Kalibr missiles, plus drones hit, inter alia, electricity substations. Multiple blackouts -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
Illia Ponomarenko 🇺🇦
@IAPonomarenko
Sorry, but lowering the draft age to 18 for the sake of getting more manpower while partners still spend months and years weighing the risks of escalation with every single weapon and equipment type that Ukraine begs for does not seem to look like a good long-term strategy.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Exact.
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
Boualem Sansal est une victime collatérale du rapprochement franco-marocain. Son arrestation est une prise d’otage dans le cadre d’une confrontation franco-algérienne qui ne fait que commencer.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
All true. But US has from day 1 of the full-scale invasion has studiously avoided sending any military personnel to 🇺🇦, including the sort of assistance which Soviets & US provided to their Cold War allies. Catastrophic zero-risk policy which 🇬🇧🇫🇷 are now trying to pull away from
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Charles Lister
@Charles_Lister
HUGE development -- opposition forces have taken the 46th Regiment base from #assad's regime.
They're now ~5km from #aleppo city -- a 🧵on today's developments:
Charles Lister
@Charles_Lister
NEW -- #syria armed opposition (Fathul Mubeen + #hts) has launched a major offensive in western #aleppo, the 1st such operation since 2020.
Columns of armored vehicles, one SVBIED & several thousand fighters have captured x6 villages from #assad's regime. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Do as I say, don't do as I do?
Felicia Schwartz
@felschwartz
Biden administration tells Ukraine to drop its conscription age to 18 to address severe manpower shortage -- w/ @ChristopherJM www.ft.com/content/328141b2-fc6e-43a1-aa6b-262358b9ac0e
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
BREAKING: Donald Trump appoints Keith Kellogg, former National Security Adviser to Vice President Mike Pence, as Special Envoy to Ukraine and Russia.
Here’s what retired General Kellogg told Congress last year about the importance of supporting Ukraine: “Letting the Ukrainians defeat it [Russia] takes a strategic adversary off the table so we can focus on what we should be focusing against our primary adversary, which is China.” -
François Heisbourg reposted
Christopher Bugøjbjerg 🇨🇭
@tofer_dreamer
La question n’est pas le si mais le où et quand. Et dire que 🇫🇷 et 🇩🇪 sont empêtrés dans des problématiques de gouvernances internes quand de tels enjeux sont en train de naître. Est ce que les opinions sont prêtes à la guerre? Franchement j’ai peur.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
InsideNK
@inside_nk
"We are in an actual war with Russia," says former MI6 chief Sir Richard Dearlove. The former head of MI6 told Sky News that Europe is no longer in a "pre-war situation" with Russia but "an actual war" and that it is in a "very difficult situation."
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Sounds right
Tommy Lund
@TommyLundn
HEAD OF GERMAN FOREIGN INTELLIGENCE: RUSSIA'S IS AIMING TO PROVE THAT NATO WILL NOT STAND UNITED IN AN ARTICLE 5 SCENARIO -rtrs
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
1/2 Guerre d'Ukraine | 26/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Bakhmut-Chasiv Yar🔹U241126-1815
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241126-1821
🌐 Kurakhove-Velyka novosilka🔹U241126-1824
🌐 Velyka novosilka-Urozhaine🔹U241126-1828
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
2/2 Guerre d'Ukraine | 26/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Kupiansk🔹U241126-1807
🌐 Pischane-Stelmakhivka🔹U241126-1810
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1008
1. 70% of electricity down in Ternipil obl.
2. 2 ATACMS vs 🇷🇺
3. 🇫🇷 A2SM Hammer vs 🇷🇺 facility in Kursk
(As long as 🇺🇦 daily communiqués no longer distinguish between Shaheds and other BPLA drones, I no longer carry statistics re Shaheds) -
François Heisbourg reposted
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
Recent poll and Fall 2023 dismissal, today. One poll, of course.
Before Nov. 2024 thought his initial broach concretizing a multi-year plan for specific victory outcomes best path for UA internal cohesion, force generation and holistic Coalition ⬆️ aid delivery re-appraisal. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Alexander Clarkson
@APHClarkson
Though with nr. 1 the serious discussions are about a postwar European security order while the media freakout is about the far less likely scenario of European troops entering Ukraine openly during the war.
Another apples vs oranges strategic panic.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1007
1. Media buzz in Paris re 🇫🇷🇬🇧 convos concerning soldiers in 🇺🇦 notably for training purposes
2. Rutte-Erdoğan meeting in 🇹🇷
3. 71 Shaheds down yesterday, similar number lost
4. 5 missiles vs 🇺🇦, 1 down -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Zaluzhny goes public again www.rtbf.be/article/c-est-deja-la-troisieme-guerre-mondia…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1007
1. Media buzz in Paris re 🇫🇷🇬🇧 convos concerning soldiers in 🇺🇦 notably for training purposes
2. Rutte-Erdoğan meeting in 🇹🇷
3. 71 Shaheds down yesterday, similar number lost
4. 5 missiles vs 🇺🇦, 1 down -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The last two as the more likely. Number 3 could have easily been done a long time ago. Indeed it was done even before the war began, but military trainers (in the Lviv area) were pulled out when Biden stated there would be no US soldiers in Ukraine. And we all fell in line
Mark Urban
@MarkUrban01
UK & France could send troop to Ukraine according to @lemondefr today, citing talks between them about how to deal with incoming Trump admin. My interpretation is there could be 3 scenarios:
- if RU troops broke through & were heading for Kyiv (v unlikely but Macron has suggested something along these lines before)
- as part of plans to strengthen disengagement under any ceasefire deal
- to train new Ukraine army formations after an armistice (as they did before Feb 2022) -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Excellent Philippe Val sur Boualem Sansal youtu.be/JJ6oCP5kGHc
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1006
1. 🇷🇴 hard-right presidential candidate Calin Georgescu leads 1st round of elex
2. Again: 'Complicated' front-line situation says 🇺🇦 general staff
3. 🇺🇦 destroys S-400 radar in Kursk area
4. 🇫🇷: 'no red lines' in support for 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine | 23/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Pischane-Stelmakhivka🔹U241123-0932
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241123-0955
🌐 Kurakhove-Velyka novosilka🔹U241123-0947
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
Pas un mot sur les bombardements russes massifs et indiscriminés sur l’Ukraine, pas un mot sur l’entrée en guerre des nord-coréens. Non : seuls sont coupables les États Unis et Israël.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine | 19/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Bakhmut-Chasiv Yar🔹U241119-1758
🌐 Niu-York-Toretsk🔹U241119-1800
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241119-1806
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241119-1811
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Agence France-Presse
@afpfr
🇷🇴 Séisme électoral en Roumanie : Calin Georgescu, un candidat prorusse que personne n'attendait est arrivé en tête dimanche du premier tour de l'élection présidentielle devant le Premier ministre pro-européen Marcel Ciolacu, après le dépouillement de plus de 98% des suffrages #afp
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I rather like this airborne shell-game concept. Something worth discussing with the NPG countries
Etienne Marcuz
@Etienne_Marcuz
...mockups of ASMPA-R (already exist for exercises) in what would be a massive shell game.
Again, all the means described here already exist so this would come at almost no additional costs, except probably for nuclear command, control and communication means (NC3) that would... -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Genau, ja!
dokdoc. Zeitschrift für den 🇩🇪-🇫🇷 Dialog
@DokumenteDoc
📢 Wegen technischer Probleme können wir zzt. keine neuen Beiträge einstellen. In wenigen Tagen sind wir wieder für Sie da - mit einer nagelneuen Webseite 🎉🥳 und Beiträgen von @FHeisbourg, @BrunoTertrais, @PierreBuhler, @jm_magro, @frankmontwit! Sie dürfen gespannt sein!
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Charles Monneron
@CharlesMonneron
Low cost LNG is still high cost NG. Liquefying NG eats the margin of chemical/industrial products where NG is the main feedstock. The rest is power, but it is expensive power, which also shrinks the demand.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1005
1. 🇫🇷 lifts restrictions on use of SCALP. Good idea but not that many available for use
2. Scholz redux: Pistorius out of the running to head SPD in 2025 elex
3. 50 Shaheds down, 19 lost, 4 somewhere
4. "On front line, the situation remains complicated" for 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
You may want to pass on your tweet to The Economist (which we both are citing from...).
Arthur Darquandier
I’m sorry but, respectfully, it’s a bit shortsighted. It’s a long game, like any strategic game:
1. You kick your main rival out
2. You flood the market with overcapacity
3. You sit tight during low economic cycles
4. Your smaller competitors are in the doodoo because they don’t have the balance sheet to weather the low cycles. They can’t fight and you can even take control of some of their assets at a cheap price
5. You control the market with long term contracts -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A good question to put to The Economist (rhe piece is worrh reading). But my understanding is that the place of gas in the European energy mix is changing after the crisis of 2022-3
Nicholas Vinocur ✍️
@NicholasVinocur
Why is European demand shrinking? I keep reading about our energy crisis
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes but it's the end of the piece which is the most interesting, which The Economist describes pretty much as follows: in short order, the US finds itself awash with unwanted low cost LNG as other non-Russian and non-US entrants come on line & European demand continues to shrink
Arthur Darquandier
« America is now a gas-exporting superpower—a development that has transformed the global energy market. Last year the country sold over four times as much natural gas overseas as it did in 2015 »
@BrunoTertrais @FHeisbourg
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2024/11/21/donald… -
François Heisbourg reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
What an incredible cover page
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1004
1. Orechnik attack: no clear Russian BDA concerning possible damage to Pivden/Yuzh mash plant in Dnipro.
2. 🇺🇦 strike vs Berdiansk facility
3. 114 Shaheds strike on 22 November: 64 down, 41 lost -
François Heisbourg reposted
Norbert Röttgen
@n_roettgen
Kaum ist der #kanzler mit seiner Angstrhetorik abgemeldet, steigen die Zustimmungswerte für mehr militärische Unterstützung der #ukraine massiv. Die Menschen verstehen, dass Freiheit & Sicherheit in Europa auf dem Spiel stehen.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Sébastien Le Fol
@sebastienlefol
Pour Boualem Sansal et @daoud_kamel la liberté a un prix dont nous n'avons pas conscience. En Algérie, la prison. Chez nous, le mépris d'une certaine gauche drapée dans son "oui, mais", ou bien la prise en otage par les boutefeux de salon. 1/2 www.letelegramme.fr/opinions/edito-daoud-sansal-le-prix-d…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1003
1. 🇷🇺 fires IRBM "Orechnik" ('nut -tree') fm East of Kazakhstan aiming at Soviet-era Yuzhmash missile plant in Dnipro. No BDA yet. MIssile maybe derived fm "Rubezh" RS-26 (SS-X-31). US warned in frame of US-USSR agreement
2. 8/13 cruise missiles down in 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1002
1.Storm Shadow may have been used vs 🇷🇺 military facility at Marino in Kursk area TBC
2. US DoD authorises delivery of anti-personnel mines to 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
News 🛰️
@EUFreeCitizen
🇺🇦#ukraine 🇷🇺#russia #ukrainewar #ukrainerussiawar️️ 🇺🇸#usa #us
Multiple ballistic missiles are heading towards Dnipro, a city in central Ukraine, with several explosions already reported in the area
📽 The sounds of explosions that were heard in the Dnipro
📷 Ukrainian monitor pages claim that 6x Tu-95MS Strategic Bombers departed from Air Bases in Western Russia -
François Heisbourg reposted
Corinne Lepage
@corinnelepage
Plein soutien à @FHeisbourg et à ceUx qui dans la direction ont le courage de ne pas céder aux islamistes
Maxime Loth
@loth_maxime
« Vive Intifada » « Sciences po complice » sont tagués sur les murs de Sciences Po.
Notre école est encore visée par des militants pro palestiniens. Ces appels à la violence dans un contexte où Rima Hassan pose des cibles sur certains de nos professeurs sont très inquiétants. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. No US functional equivalent of Storm Shadow-SCALP has been delivered to Ukraine. 🇬🇧 🇫🇷 have transferred them since summer last year; they substantially improved 🇺🇦 strategic situation in the Black Sea -and 🇷🇺 didn't escalate
Colby Badhwar
@ColbyBadhwar
🇺🇲🇺🇦 Politico: "ATACMS may be the last major offensive weapons system left that the US has to take off its shelf and hand to Ukraine."
They've thought of nothing but they're all out of ideas!
I can come up with a very long list, starting with AGM-158A JASSM. -
François Heisbourg reposted
New Strategy Center
@NSC_Romania
🌐 Very interesting panel discussion at the Moldova Security Forum, on the security challenges in the Black Sea region, with @grozaiulian, @JJCarafano, @FHeisbourg, @sinemacikmese and chaired by George Scutaru.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
John Hardie
@JohnH105
Technically, ATACMS is still in full-rate production at ~500 per annum, a Lockheed spokesman said last year. They’re just all for export. Reportedly, Biden admin has refused to bump Ukraine up the list like we did with PATRIOT & NASAMS interceptors.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1001
1. 🇷🇺 lays out new nuclear doctrine. Little substantive change but plentiful lurid commentary by Peskov to promote self-deterrence in the West. Problem: the more you signal consequence-free nuclear intent, the less credible it becomes
2. Cables cut in Baltic -
François Heisbourg reposted
WarMonitor🇺🇦🇬🇧
@WarMonitor3
3 Danish navy ships are converging on the Chinese vessel suspect of cutting communication cables right now!
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Dmitry Stefanovich
@KomissarWhipla
New Basic Principles of State Policy of the Russian Federation on Nuclear Deterrence are in force.
Stay tuned for analysis.
publication.pravo.gov.ru/document/0001202411190001 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
And I signed the letter because it firmly focuses on Europe's choices, decisions and responsibilities -Europe has agency
Benjamin Tallis 🇺🇦
@bctallis
I'm delighted that experts like @general_ben signed our letter, and support our 5 point plan for a coalition of the willing to secure Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Or more precisely, Ukraine violated the Peskov doctrine. Unlikely that the meaning of nuclear doctrine is entrusted to a talking head
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
⚡️ Ukraine has already violated Putin's nuclear doctrine
Ukraine has for the first time struck the Russian territory with ATACMS missiles, the Ukrainian news and analysis website Censor. net has said. According to the publication, they attacked an arsenal in the Bryansk Region.
The AFU General Staff has confirmed that Ukraine has struck an arsenal of the 1046th logistics center near the town of Karachev in Russia's Bryansk region. However, the General Staff did not say whether the strike was carried out with Western weapons.
Curiously, the ATACMS strike, which are ballistic missiles, are grounds for a retaliatory nuclear strike by Russia, according to Putin's new nuclear doctrine. Thus Putin's doctrine was violated on the very first day it was signed. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The Ukrainians did well to strike as quickly as they just did in Briansk oblast. That should make it harder for Jake Sullivan to backtrack
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
So it was all bait and switch?
Nick Schifrin
@nickschifrin
Highlights of our @newshour interview with @JakeSullivan46:
Q: Two US officials confirm the administration gave Ukraine authorization to use ATACMS in Russia. Why?
A: "We don't have anything to announce or confirm on that today. So those remain unconfirmed reports. One thing I would point out, though, for context, is that Russia has just engaged in a massive escalation in this war. They have brought in a foreign army, North Korea, North Korean troops to the front lines of the battle. And that represents a sea change in the nature of this conflict." -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nikolai Sokov
@SokovNikolai
The 2024 language goes back, more or less, to 2000 (it was revised to higher criterion in 2010 under Medvedev).
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. But this is Peskov speaking, not the Ukaz issued by the Kremlin
Tatiana Stanovaya
@Stanovaya
Vladimir Putin has signed Russia’s revised nuclear doctrine, which includes key amendments he personally presented in September. These changes lower the threshold for nuclear use and create more leeway for a Russian nuclear response to Ukrainian—or, as the Kremlin frames it, Western—strikes on Russian territory. Here are three my considerations:
1. Timing is critical. According to Peskov, Putin’s spokesman, these changes were developed over several months. However, their publication was deliberately timed to highlight a connection to Biden’s decision to authorise Ukraine to use long-range missiles for deep strikes into Russian territory.
2. A Direct Threat: This may be the first time the Kremlin has explicitly acknowledged, even when prompted by a question, the potential use of nuclear weapons as a response to strikes on Russian territory using long-range missiles. Put simply, Peskov openly admits that the Kremlin is currently considering the possibility of a nuclear strike.
3. Escalation is Too Attractive Right Now: The current situation offers Putin a significant temptation to escalate. With Trump not yet in office, such a move would not interfere with any immediate peace initiatives but could instead reinforce Trump’s argument for direct dialogue with Putin. Simultaneously, it would expose Biden to criticism for being the catalyst of the escalation while potentially discouraging Ukraine from further using long-range missiles.
Putin may see the current situation as a strategic “in-between” moment—anticipating possible peace initiatives from Trump while emphasising what he views as the “irresponsibility” of Biden’s policy. Putin may seek to present the West with two stark choices: “Do you want a nuclear war? You will have it,” or “Let’s end this war on Russia’s terms.” This marks an extraordinarily dangerous juncture. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
⚡️ Ukraine has already violated Putin's nuclear doctrine
Ukraine has for the first time struck the Russian territory with ATACMS missiles, the Ukrainian news and analysis website Censor. net has said. According to the publication, they attacked an arsenal in the Bryansk Region.
The AFU General Staff has confirmed that Ukraine has struck an arsenal of the 1046th logistics center near the town of Karachev in Russia's Bryansk region. However, the General Staff did not say whether the strike was carried out with Western weapons.
Curiously, the ATACMS strike, which are ballistic missiles, are grounds for a retaliatory nuclear strike by Russia, according to Putin's new nuclear doctrine. Thus Putin's doctrine was violated on the very first day it was signed. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Apparently not happenchance nor random fishing accidents
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
Two undersea internet cables in the Baltic Sea have been disrupted by sabotage – German Defense Minister Pistorius.
"A very clear sign that something is going on there. No one believes that these cables were accidentally damaged. And I don't want to believe in the versions that anchors are to blame. So we have to conclude, without knowing who did that, that this is a hybrid action. And we also have to assume, without knowing, of course, that this is sabotage," the German minister said. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The US provided F-16s? And of course, the problems are Ukraine's fault because of the manpower issue?
Nick Schifrin
@nickschifrin
Q: But Ukraine is losing more territory today than any point this year. Do you really believe that nothing the US could have done earlier would have changed that?
A: "We provided the tanks, we provided the F-16s, we provided the HIMARS, we provided the Patriots. We provided many of the things that you said earlier we wouldn't provide. And it's not back then--it's rather today that Ukraine finds itself in a more challenged position on the battlefield, suggesting that there's not a straight line between those weapons systems and how it does on the battlefield. Where is the straightest line between you, between Ukrainian performance and inputs? It's on mobilization of manpower." -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
So it was all bait and switch?
Nick Schifrin
@nickschifrin
Highlights of our @newshour interview with @JakeSullivan46:
Q: Two US officials confirm the administration gave Ukraine authorization to use ATACMS in Russia. Why?
A: "We don't have anything to announce or confirm on that today. So those remain unconfirmed reports. One thing I would point out, though, for context, is that Russia has just engaged in a massive escalation in this war. They have brought in a foreign army, North Korea, North Korean troops to the front lines of the battle. And that represents a sea change in the nature of this conflict." -
François Heisbourg reposted
Oana Lungescu
@LungescuOana
Good morning from Chișinău 🇲🇩
Kickoff for the 1st #moldova Security Forum #msf2024 - even more important to strengthen this strategic country as we mark 1000 days since the start of Russia’s illegal full-fledged invasion against brave #ukraine -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Presumably because it doesn't have the tools to do so
-
François Heisbourg reposted
MAKS 26 🇺🇦👀
@Maks_NAFO_FELLA
❗️🛳️ A Russian spy ship has been escorted out of the Irish Sea after it entered Irish-controlled waters and patrolled an area containing critical energy and internet submarine pipelines and cables, - The Guardian
Its presence has raised fresh concerns about the security of the interconnector cables that run between Ireland and the UK carrying global internet traffic from huge datacentres operated by tech companies including Google and Microsoft, which have their EU headquarters sited in Ireland. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Colby Badhwar
@ColbyBadhwar
For comparison, in 1994 the US Army had Load, Assemble & Pack facilitization for 867,000 artillery projectiles per month. Metal parts facilitization was 463,700/month. Actual production rates were substantially less and BRAC quickly slashed capacity down to the bone, but it gives you a sense of what the United States was capable of 30 years ago.
During Vietnam and Reagan's defense build up in the 1980s, those figures exceeded 1 million shells per month.
Colby Badhwar
@ColbyBadhwar
🇺🇸🇺🇦 How did the US Department of Defense set their monthly production target for 155mm artillery ammo?
Ukr operational requirements?
Army Acquisition Objective?
Total Munitions Requirement?
Nope.
"I pulled the number of 100,000/m out of the air." - Undersecretary LaPlante -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Overnight in Bryansk Oblast, a missile alert was declared. Shortly after, explosions were recorded near the 67th GRAU arsenal in Karachev.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 1000
1. Putin's 4-day special military operation reaches its 1000th day
2. Erdoğan said to propose a peace plan at G20 meeting in Brazil 🇧🇷 . Note: 🇹🇷 & 🇷🇺 interests are hardly congruent in Black Sea
3. No let up: 51 Shahed down, 30 lost out of 87 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧
@DefenceHQ
Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 18 November 2024.
Find out more about Defence Intelligence's use of language: www.gov.uk/government/news/defence-intelligence-communica…
#standwithukraine 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Antti Helanto
@AnttiHelanto
C-Lion 1 data cable between Finland and Germany is broken. Russia doesn't deserve to be assumed innocent every time something like this happens, and they shouldn't go unpunished.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Clotilde I.🌻🔱🦩
@Cloclozazaprive
Sorry, but I think France and the UK are still not clear about these authorisations. For now, the US is only talking about restricted targets in the Kursk region. Theoretically, it is good news. Practically, I may not change a lot on the front. It's a start. Time is running out.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
It takes all of Putin's mindless arrogance to provoke a break with Austria 🇦🇹, arguably the Western country which has the strongest links with Moscow since 1955
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
This morning, Russian Gazprom stopped gas supplies to Austria.
Austria's close cooperation in gas imports, which had existed since 1968, first with the USSR and then with Russia, came to an abrupt halt within 3 days.
◾️ How and why did it happen?
On November 14, Austrian company OMV won an arbitration against Gazprom for $242 million (excluding interest and court costs). The lawsuit was filed because of irregular gas supplies and their complete cessation in September 2022, when the Kremlin hoped to freeze Europe.
Vienna realized that Gazprom would not pay and decided to immediately claim this amount through the existing contract. In other words, instead of transferring regular monthly payments for gas supplied to Gazprom, OMV planned to withhold them until the amount awarded by the court was reached.
◾️ On October 15, OMV received a letter from Gazprom Export (a subsidiary of Gazprom) stating that natural gas supplies under the existing contract would be stopped completely.
◾️ On November 16, Gazprom cut off gas supplies to Austria, its oldest and largest EU customer among those remaining.
However, Vienna turned out to be ready, diversifying gas supplies with the help of non-Russian sources.
Moreover, it actually pushed Moscow toward such a scenario.
◾️ Chancellor Karl Nehammer noted that what had happened was "what we have been preparing for since the beginning of the war in Ukraine" and assured that gas storage facilities were full and "no one will freeze this winter, no home will be cold."
"We will not be blackmailed by anyone, not even by the Russian president. We will not be brought to our knees by Putin's government, by Putin himself," he declared.
Minister for Climate Action, Environment, Energy, Mobility, Innovation and Technology Leonore Gewessler made a similar statement.
"The actions of Gazprom today prove once again that Russia is not a partner. But tomorrow also marks the end of a risk. If we no longer receive supplies from Russia, we can no longer be blackmailed," she wrote.
◾️ And most importantly.
By stopping gas supplies to Austria, Gazprom has thus violated the terms of the contract, valid until 2040.
And, by doing so, it gave Austria a formal pretext for an early and legally clean exit from the contract, thereby getting rid of their gas dependence on Russia.
And thus depriving the Kremlin of part of the gas revenues used for the war.
Putin has "outplayed" everyone once again.
📹: Kurier -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
According the Le Figaro, France and UK have authorized the usage of SCALP EG / Stormshadow against targets in Russia.
As I said, there are no Russian red lines. They are bluffs to cover Russia‘s aggression. A defending nation has all right to strike the aggressor, everywhere. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Why? UK and France have been authorising the use of SCALP-Storm Shadow vs targets in Crimea & occupied Donbas since summer 2023 -which Putin's 🇷🇺 views as a constitutional parts of 🇷🇺 . So from the Kremlin's viewpoint, what's the difference with Kursk, Belgorod?...
Steve Rosenberg
@BBCSteveR
Russian media reaction to President Biden allowing Ukraine to strike inside Russia with long-range missiles ranges from “Biden is moving the world closer to a catastrophe” to “This is not something out of the blue and invincible.” #readingrussia
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Ce n'était pas le cas jusque vers 2018, après que l'Égypte ait exigé la dés-ITARisation. Je ne sais pas quelle sont les dates des lots livrés à l'Ukraine
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
Le SCALP est ITAR-free.
www.latribune.fr/entreprises-finance/industrie/aeronautiq… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 999
1. Biden White House OKs use of US missiles behind 🇷🇺 front lines
2. Quiet night: 8 Shaheds down, 3 lost out of 11
3. Small missile strike: 2 Iskander-M, 1 Kh-59/69
4. No clear BDA yet re yesterday's big missile+drone strike vs energy infrastructure -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
US finally does the right thing, 999 days after the beginning of the war. Hoping UK and France can now do the same. And what about Taurus?
CNN
@CNN
President Biden authorizes Ukraine to use long-range US weapons in Russia
www.cnn.com/2024/11/17/politics/biden-authorizes-ukraine-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The Russian read-out of the Scholz-Putin telcon makes 'brazen sound like a euphemism
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Putin’s response to Scholtz’s call came this morning, with a rain of drones and missiles on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure. He took a diplomatic win and kept going. That’s why appeasement is doomed.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
While Elon mocks Ukraine, Russia is carrying out one of the biggest missile barrages on Ukrainian cities in recent months. Millions of civilians in shelters, explosions in Kyiv, Dnipro, Rivne, Lviv and Mykolaiv, as critical infrastructure and power stations targeted ahead of the winter.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine - Semaine 46 | 2024
Ukraine
Gains (+ 0 km²) 🟨
Pertes (- 123.05 km²) 🟦
Russie | LPR | DPR
Gains (+ 129.13 km²) 🟥
Pertes (- 0 km²) ⬛️
+ Zone Sud-Ouest Koursk
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. And no Taurus either
Alexander Kokcharov
@alex_kokcharov
The United States still blocks Ukraine from striking these launch sites on Russian territory, despite many of these sites being within range of weapons provided to the Ukrainian armed forces.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Alexander Kokcharov
@alex_kokcharov
Russian attack with missiles and drones targeting Ukraine’s energy infrastructure resulted in serious damage of equipment at thermal power plants:
2/2
www.ukrinform.net/rubric-economy/3927965-russian-attack-l… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 998
1. Big missile attack vs 🇺🇦 with good intercept rate:
Missiles 102 down/120
Kalibr 85/101
Kinzhal 7/8
Kh-59.69 5/5
Kh-22.31P 4/4
Zirkon 1/1
0/1 Iskander M
Shahed 42/90 down, ? lost
2. Kupiansk pressed -
François Heisbourg reposted
Alexander Kokcharov
@alex_kokcharov
Overnight, #russia launched a massive combined long-range attack on #ukraine, with 120 missiles and 90 attack UAVs. Ukrainian defence forces destroyed more than 140 incoming Russian air targets.
1/2
www.ukrinform.net/rubric-ato/3927958-ukraines-air-defense… -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
36h after the call between Scholz and Putin, as well as President-elect Trump's warning not to escalate, Russia launched its first massive winter terror wave. According to official Ukrainian source:
"A massive combined attack targeted all regions of Ukraine. Overnight and this morning, Russian terrorists used various types of drones, including Shaheds, as well as cruise, ballistic, and aeroballistic missiles - Zircons, Iskanders, and Kinzhals. In total, approximately 120 missiles and 90 drones were launched. Our air defense forces destroyed over 140 aerial targets."
Damage is reported to infrastructure, especially in Kryvyi Riv, where energy and water supply has been suspended. In Dnipro train infrastructure has been effected. Areas in Mykolaiv and Lviv have been struck as well. Human casualties have been reported across the country. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The chart omits significant European donors (Czechia, Baltic states...) & part of the EU financial contribution also has a military purpose. I suspect that if all this is included, the overall European military contribution to Ukraine is equal to, or greater than, that of the US
Guy-Philippe Goldstein 🌻
@guypgoldstein
Hoping that the FT/Kiel institute figures would be correct… - so far the US is €7 Bn **ahead** of all other European countries in terms of Mil spending.
If FR was at about the level of UK/Ger (€9-11 Bn) rather than the much lower €3Bn, then European countries would be at the same level as the US.
Strategic autonomy has a price.
Are we willing to pay for it?
And actually, do we have any credible choices?
Mujtaba Rahman
@Mij_Europe
This chart from FT/Kiel Institute is revealing, putting EU, Ger & Fr support for Ukraine into context
Ger has provided lots of €bn for Ukraine, but doesn't really have a policy
Fr has a clear policy, but no credibility, given miserly €bn its provided since late Jan 2022 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I'm surprised that in this chart French and Polish military aid to Ukraine is considered to be of € 3 bn in both cases.
Mujtaba Rahman
@Mij_Europe
This chart from FT/Kiel Institute is revealing, putting EU, Ger & Fr support for Ukraine into context
Ger has provided lots of €bn for Ukraine, but doesn't really have a policy
Fr has a clear policy, but no credibility, given miserly €bn its provided since late Jan 2022 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 997
1. Sharp reaction by Zelensky re Scholz's telcon with Putin
2. Reopening of Lviv airport in 2025 broached according to business sources
3. 53 Shaheds down out of 83. Tallies of the other 30 falling out of radar coverage may or may not suggest EW interference -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Details on 6 November 🇺🇦 operation vs Russian port of Kaspiysk
Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧
@DefenceHQ
Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 15 November 2024.
Find out more about Defence Intelligence's use of language: www.gov.uk/government/news/defence-intelligence-communica…
#standwithukraine 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
1/2 Guerre d'Ukraine | 14-15/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Pischane-Stelmakhivka🔹U241115-0838
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241115-0852
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241115-0857
🌐 Velyka novosilka-Urozhaine🔹U241115-0900
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
⚡️ Kyiv is in talks with European authorities and airlines to resume flights, reports Reuters. Crispin Ellison, senior partner at Marsh McLennan, stated that Lviv Airport could reopen as early as 2025.
www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-could-reopen-lviv-ai… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui. Aucune raison de quitter le champ de bataille
Paroles de Combattants de la Libération
@paroles_la
En 3 jours, @paroles_la a perdu 500 abonnés. Disons que X a fermé de faux comptes.
Mais depuis le rachat de Twitter, le nombre de lectures a été divisé par 5.
Moralité : ces portraits lassent (et ce serait normal) ou X ne leur fait plus place.
Dans les 2 cas, faut-il continuer ? -
François Heisbourg reposted
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
A map of France tracking the departments with the highest casualty rates during WW1.
The more rural the department, the less literate the men were, and thus more likely to serve in the infantry where casualty rates were much higher. -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
Ukraine‘s President Zelenskyy clearly criticized the Scholz-Putin call, correctly calling it a Pandora’s box.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not in the water at all...
Brisavoine
@brisavoine
So AUKUS is dead in the water? cc @FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Jules Verne, pas Gilles, cher @24hPujadas
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#musk - L'homme le plus riche du monde...et ministre : “Musk veut aller sur Mars et rendre l’humanité “transplanétaire”, c’est sa motivation pour s’être engagé en politique.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
Henri Schmit
@Schmit_Henri
On the basis of national polls CDU/CSU (33% vote, 36% seats) + SPD (15% vote, 16% seats) is the only possible coalition, if you exclude AfD (18% vote, 20% seats).
www.wahlrecht.de/umfragen/ -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ian Ellis
@ianellisjones
At Biden’s farewell meeting with Chinese leader Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the APEC meeting in Peru this weekend, he plans to warn Xi that China’s daily intrusions into waters and airspace adjacent to Taiwan are “eroding the status quo” in the region, Politico reported.
Ian Ellis
@ianellisjones
Updated chart visualizing Chinese PLA incursions into Taiwan’s air defense ID zone (ADIZ) this year.
The record-breaking surge began in May following President Lai’s inauguration. By August, ADIZ incursions had already surpassed 2023 totals — with the tally now 1,000+ higher. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 996
1. confirmed: car-bomb killing of head of 🇷🇺 Black Sea fleet in Sebastopol, capt.Trankovsky
2. Scholz reiterates no Taurus to 🇺🇦
3. 25/29 Shaheds down, mostly in Odesa area. 1/2 Kh-59/69 down
4. Strike vs Krymsk Air base in Krasnodar area -
François Heisbourg reposted
Colby Badhwar
@ColbyBadhwar
"We should double the production rate of PATRIOT [PAC-3 MSE], it's going to be a lot of money, but we should do it." -USD(A&S) LaPlante
Lockheed currently produces ~500 MSEs per year, is on contract with the Army to reach 550/y next year, and has internally funded 650/y by 2027. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A Merz-Scholz #groko could be just as incoherent as the outgoing #ampel . Pauvre Europe!
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
Scholz is doubling down that he is not going to deliver any German cruise missiles to Ukraine.
He is in full election mode to appease not only Russia, but also his SPD base. He didn’t learn anything from the past and it is good that his time will be up in a few months. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Nice capsule thread on Azerbaijan's influence-ops vs 🇫🇷. I suspect this activism isn't only an Azeri countermove vs French support of Armenia but also Baku's reaction to the failure of 🇦🇿 attempts to corrupt French decision-makers in years past
𝐆𝐞𝐨𝐓𝐚𝐥𝐞𝐬
@GeoTales_
Azerbaïdjan 🇦🇿 - BIG
🔸C'est l'histoire d'un tout petit pays qui s'est mis en tête de faire de l'ingérence sur les terres de France avec sa toute petite officine de propagande nauséabonde :
Le Baku Initiative Group
Thread 🧶 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
With the big Dutch order and prospective other ones, our friends from down under may find themselves at the end of a longish queue for French subs...
Felix Drost
@felix_drost
Time to dust off those old French submarines
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Une (vraie) question: quelle est l'appartenance des drapeaux rouges et noirs au-dessus (à droite) et en dessous de la bombe (à gauche)?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Eye-shutting bad
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Obviously, Gabbard still needs to be confirmed by the Senate. But hard to see how Five Eyes and intelligence cooperation with other U.S. treaty allies will survive this unscathed.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
A car bomb likely planted by Ukrainian agents in Sevastopol, occupied Crimea, killed Russian Navy Captain Valery Trankovsky, commander of the Russian Black Sea Fleet’s 41st Missile Ships Brigade. His ships fired hundreds of missiles at Ukrainian cities in the last three years, killing and maiming many civilians.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Those days will be difficult indeed. And the alignment of the stars in Europe could hardly be worse in terms of facing up to the challenge
M.M
@M198918
After Trump chose the Secretary of Defense, a Fox News presenter, and the Director of National Intelligence who was supportive of Russia, I believe that there are difficult days ahead for NATO and Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
This is seriously big and bad. I hope the Senate will block her confirmation -but I don't expect that to happen.
Tulsi Gabbard 🌺
@TulsiGabbard
Thank you, @realDonaldTrump, for the opportunity to serve as a member of your cabinet to defend the safety, security and freedom of the American people. I look forward to getting to work.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
France will supply Ukraine with 6 Mirage 2000-5s, upgraded to fire SCALP air-launched cruise missiles, as part of its first tranche of fighter deliveries in the near future.
The fighters will come with maintenance and other logistical support provided by France. -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️The Security Service of 🇺🇦Ukraine confirmed the liquidation of the chief of staff of the missile ships of the 🇷🇺Russian Black Sea Fleet, Valery Trankovsky, in the temporarily occupied Sevastopol.
Trankovsky is a war criminal who gave orders to launch cruise missiles from the Black Sea at civilian objects in Ukraine.
In particular, he shelled Vinnytsia with "Kalibr" in July 2022. Then 29 civilians died. Trankovsky also repeatedly shelled Odessa and other cities, which killed many civilians. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 995
1. 🇷🇺 presses hard on Kupiansk & vs Kursk pocket
2. Section of damaged Dzhankoy bridge with Crimea collapses? TBC
3. 21/59 Shaheds down, 38 others lost. 5 missiles launched, 4 cruise missiles down
4. 🇩🇪 snap elex on 23 FEB
5. GOP retains House majority in US -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#musk - L'homme le plus riche du monde...et ministre : “Musk veut aller sur Mars et rendre l’humanité “transplanétaire”, c’est sa motivation pour s’être engagé en politique.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A frequent problem when you start by overpromising: when you eventually deliver, people tend to remember the initial promise even if you deliver quite creditably
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 994
1. Peter Hegseth, Fox News host, US SecDef designate
2. Multiple strikes vs Simferopol -
François Heisbourg reposted
POLITICO
@politico
‘Who the f--k is this guy?’: Defense world reacts to Trump’s surprise Pentagon pick www.politico.com/news/2024/11/12/defense-world-reacts-to-…
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🚨 In Simferopol, a fuel tanker explosion has been reported. So far, one person is known to be injured, but local sources say the blasts are ongoing. Firefighting efforts involve 40 firefighters and 12 fire engines
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Over 10 explosions have been reported in Simferopol, occupied Crimea, reportedly near a gas station.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Antti Helanto
@AnttiHelanto
Finnish Defense Force has been preparing for this type of war for generations. They do part of the artillery production in-house. They don't reveal figures but have said their cost is way below market price and production quantity amongst the biggest producers.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️🇹🇼Taiwan sent up to 15 air defense systems of HAWK anti-aircraft missile batteries to 🇺🇦Ukraine, - Forbes.
Each of these batteries has at least six three-missile launchers and associated radars. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Niall Ferguson
@nfergus
I am a supporter of ending the war in Ukraine, as the Biden-Harris strategy is leading inexorably to a Russian victory. But "peace through strength" should not entail swallowing bogus narratives from shills for the Kremlin and CCP.
Dave Benner, Nemesis of Neocons
@dbenner83
🚨 WATCH: Jeffrey Sachs tells the cold, hard truth how the US and NATO provoked war in Ukraine in 4 minutes
"It started in 1990, when US Secretary of State James Baker said to Mikhail Gorbachev that NATO would not move one inch eastward...
The US then cheated on this, starting in 1994, when Clinton signed off on a plan to expand NATO all the way to Ukraine.
The expansion of NATO started in 1999 with Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic.
Then, the US led the bombing of Serbia in 1999. That was the use of NATO to bomb a European capital for 78 straight days to break the country apart.
The Russians didn't like that very much, but even Putin started out pro-European and pro-American. He considered whether to join NATO when there was still the idea of some kind of mutually respectful relationship.
In 2002, the US unilaterally walked out of the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty. What it did was trigger the US putting in missile systems in Eastern Europe that Russia views as a dire, direct threat to national security, by making possible a decapitation strike of missiles that are a few minutes away from Moscow.
In 2004-2005, the US engaged in a soft regime change in Ukraine, the so-called First Color Revolution.
In 2009, Yanukovych won the election and became president in 2010 on the basis of neutrality in Ukraine.
In 2014, the US participated actively in the overthrow of Yanukovych. Nuland and the US Ambassador to Ukraine...talked about regime change. So they made the new government!
The US then said 'now NATO's really going to enlarge.' Putin kept saying 'stop, you promised no NATO enlargement.'
Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Bulgaria, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, seven more countries in the 'not one inch eastward.'
In 2021, Putin put on the table a draft Russian-US security agreement. The basis of it was no NATO enlargement.
The special military operations started, and five days later Zelenskyy said 'okay, okay, neutrality.'
And then the US and Britain said no way, you guys fight on. We've got your back. That's 600,000 deaths now of Ukrainians since Boris Johnson flew to Kyiv to tell them to be brave. Absolutely ghastly.
We're not dealing with, as we're told every day, this madman like Hitler. This is complete bogus, fake history that is a purely PR narrative of the US government.
We're playing games here. So God forbid a nuclear power comes at us. I don't know what's going to happen, but we came at them."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
France will supply Ukraine 'in the short term' with 6 (3 more than initially pledged to be delivered in early 2025) Mirage 2000-5F multirole fighter jets including comprehensive support.
www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/rapports/cion_def/l17b0… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Rather like the US, in fact #israel
the cameron account.
@cameron19460429
A lot of countries felt naked after only having a few days worth of artillery shells in their stocks. Germany and Spain are examples of countries that a refilling their stocks currently.
Then there’s some exports to MENA and foreign customers. -
François Heisbourg reposted
the cameron account.
@cameron19460429
They aren’t RHM is on track to produce 700,000 next year and the U.S will do over 1 million and in 2025 will reach a rate of 102,000 a month.
European production is larger than U.S production but it’s not all going to Ukraine some reports indicate the majority isn’t going there -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Some of this (pumping 🇺🇦 full of weapons, DMZs, PKFs) ressemble what Biden once called the "🇮🇱i option" (ie, before 7 October 2023). Setting other issues aside, the option only works if you have a nuclear deterrent...As Zelensky put it during his US visit: it's NATO or nukes
Mick Ryan, AM
@WarintheFuture
In the past few days, speculation about a potential ‘Ukraine solution’ from the incoming Trump administration has accelerated. Here, I examine possible components of this, or other, 'peace plans' for #ukraine. 1/10 🧵🇺🇦
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui. Idem pour le 8 mai. Et on peut faire l'économie de l'Assomption (que mon curé à toujours eu du mal à m' expliquer) voire l'Ascension. Et comme cela se passe dans d'autres pays, rien n'empêche de fixer les jours fériés au vendredi ou lundi pour empêcher les viaduc absurdes
Michel Goya
@Michel_Goya
S'il ne devait rester qu'un seul jour férié dans l'année, ce serait bien celui consacré à tous ceux qui sont morts pour la France.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Pistorius would be much better news for European defence and for the French-German relationship. Serious guy
Carl Bildt
@carlbildt
Now it’s clear that the elections in 🇩🇪 will be on February 23. That makes more sense. The remaining question is whether SPD will stick to Scholz as their candidate for Chancellor or go for far more popular Pistorius. I’ll put my money on the latter. www.welt.de
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Good stuff
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🇫🇷🇺🇦 France to deliver 600 AASM bombs to Ukraine before the end of 2024.
In response to growing demand, the French Ministry of Armed Forces aims to ramp up production, with plans to produce 1,200 AASM bombs by 2025 to replenish stocks and support Ukraine's defense efforts. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes!
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Comparing apples and oranges, in very bad faith. The EU budget is only for EU-competence programs and is a tiny fraction of the combined national budgets of EU member states. €118 billion (over three years) is not even 0.2% of the EU’s annual GDP. (Edited to correct the math.)
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
When you have to cope with the mass drone and missile attacks versus Ukraine, air defence ammo had better come in commodity-scale deliveries...
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed, the EU did not meet its 1 million annualised shell target last March and won't meet the original 1.7 million aimpoint this year. Conversely, at year's end, it does~1 million annualised. Better than the US. As stated in my earlier tweets.
John F
@JohnF67272
Just in July there were reports that Euro production was not at levels senior EU officials were promising. www.rferl.org/a/ukraine-weapons-shells-european-union-eu-…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Agreed. But hi-intensity long wars are about producing+expending commodies: high-end excellence and networking is valuable, but not an end in itself. On Patriot: MBDA-D is now getting in the picture, as a result of the war in Europe; US doesn't do enough mass. Short-war syndrome
Jonathan Caverley
@jcaverley
I should've been more precise about "munitions." Conflating 155 mm shells & PAC 3 missiles is like equating toasters & photolithography machines. Absent huge R&D, Europe's DIB will be stuck in the Draghi Report's middle-tech trap, building defense toasters sciencebusiness.net/news/european-innovation-council/drag…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes, but. The US has plenty of kit in important areas (ie JASSM stand-off weapons) but won't deliver because of Jake Sullivan rules. In many others, the sad truth is that the US defence industrial base has been as unprepared for war time production runs as Europe's.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
You are right when it comes to totting up the past 1000 days or so (note: same remarks apply to US delivering 600 000 South Korean shells in the same timeframe). But I am writing about end 2024 annualised production rate
Frederic Culmann
@FCulmann
Many of those shells were bought on the international market by EU countries - local production is up and will get higher, but it's still far less than needed to re-equip and support Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Time to call Rheinmetall and others for a quick update on ongoing (end 2024) annualised production rates. To repeat: not the same thing as Borrell's retrospective of 2022-24
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Writing from memory: the 1 million annual production rate end 2024
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
* I'm not using the retrospective Borrell figures which amalgamate stockpile and new shell deliveries over the Feb22 and end 2024. I'm annualising current (end 2024) production rates.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
* "actually no" meaning no to your suggestion that I may have been aggregating pre-existing stocks and subsequent production
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Actually no. I am comparing ongoing production rates in both EU and US cases. Kaja Kallas's brainwave in 2022 actually helped generate the requisite political and industrial momentum
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Actually no. I am comparing ongoing production rates in both EU and US cases. Kaja Kallas's brainwave in 2022 actually helped generate the requisite political and industrial momentum
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Public opinion takes Zeitenwende more seriously than Scholz
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. UK too, not only EU 🙂
Daniel Arfire
@turnofftheglory
We opened a plant today for 155mm. Was closed in 2008. Money and know how from UK.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Daniel Arfire
@turnofftheglory
I like him too.
✙ Constantine ✙
@Teoyaomiquu
Waltz, new national security adviser about on the russian war against Ukraine.
I’m beginning to like him. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Hmm... OUTput of ammo & weapons comes from companies, not countries. For instance, Rheinmetall or KNDS have plants in several countries. Ditto US: companies produce stuff, not state bureaucracies. Budget INput for the 155mm ammo is largely at EU level, rather than @ country level
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 993
1. Looks like Rubio will become Secretary of State. Was against aid bill to 🇺🇦 last spring
2. Mike Waltz possibly head of NSC. Implications for 🇺🇦 unclear
3. Kremlin denies Trump urged Putin in telcon to refrain from escalation -
François Heisbourg reposted
Andrii Naumov
@Naumov_Andrii
Kremlin denies reports of Trump urging Putin for restraint in Ukraine, calling it "fiction." Meanwhile, drone warfare escalates, civilians are under attack, and 🇺🇦 calls for more support. EU & allies pledge ongoing aid, warning of risks during the US transition period. #ukraine #russia#StandWithUkraine
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A real European success: the EU now produces more 155 mm shells than the US does even if it's still not enough and the picture isn't the same in other areas of war production. But the assumption that the European defence industrial base can't ramp up is plain wrong
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🇪🇺 The EU has delivered over 980,000 shells to Ukraine so far. By the end of the year, the number of delivered shells will reach 1.5 million, says EU foreign policy chief Borrell.
"I know that we made a commitment to reach this level by the spring - and we failed. But we will be able to by the end of the year. And for this we have accelerated considerably." #ukraine #eu
www.eurointegration.com.ua/interview/2024/11/11/7198104/ -
François Heisbourg reposted
Brisavoine
@brisavoine
Qu'en pensent @FHeisbourg ? @AntoineBondaz ? @FGodement ?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 992
1. 8 Tu-95 loft ALCMa vs 🇺🇦 (2 Kh-59/69 down)
2. Mass drone attacks by both protagonists. 74 Shahed launched (39 down, 33 lost says 🇺🇦)
3. 1st Trump-Putin telcon, focussing on war vs 🇺🇦. Trump aiming to announce deal within 24h of inauguration? -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui
Michèle 🇫🇷🇪🇺🇺🇦🇲🇦🇮🇱
@MBaujet
Vraiment une mauvaise nouvelle pour l’Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
An important and negative decision for America's partners www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-says-haley-pompeo-will-not…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Grignotage is grignotage
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine - Semaine 45 | 2024
Ukraine
Gains (+ 0.19 km²) 🟨
Pertes (- 166.93 km²) 🟦
Russie | LPR | DPR
Gains (+ 169.24 km²) 🟥
Pertes (- 0 km²) ⬛️
+ Zone Koursk
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Holger Zschaepitz
@Schuldensuehner
Good Morning from #germany, where electricity prices have soared this week due to a period of "dark doldrums." With foggy weather & hardly any wind, renewable energy production dropped significantly. As a result, Germany had to import more electricity than ever before.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not easily done
MAKS 26 🇺🇦👀
@Maks_NAFO_FELLA
🇫🇷🚀🇺🇦 France will supply Ukraine with a new batch of "SCALP EG" missiles, - Lecornu
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Ukrainian drones also visited the Bryansk region overnight. They struck a unit of the 1060th logistics center, previously home to the 120th depot of the main missile and artillery directorate of Russia's Ministry of Defense.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
XFLASH NEWS
@xflash_media
⚡️ moscow Region was attacked by drones. Several fires broke out, — local media reported.
It is stated that the total number of drones shot down on the approach to moscow reached 32.
At the same time, russian locals publish videos of private houses on fire in Ramenskoye and Sofino near moscow.
👉Follow
@blyskavka_ua -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 991
1. Softening-up process begins: Brian Lanza tells Kyiv Crimea is gone. Musk talks re stopping bloodshed
2. 145 Shaheds lost: 62 down, 67 lost, 6 hit targets. Thermobarics?
3. Explosives factory in Aleksin (Tula) burns. 🇺🇦 drones also in Moscow, Bryansk areas -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
In Tula area
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
This is where a Frenchman can only be impressed between French and German electoral practice. It took ony 28 days to move from Macron's decision to dissolve rhe national assembly to the final outcome of the second round of the election
Wolfgang Ischinger
@ischinger
Die Horror-Vorstellung, dass wir womöglich bis Frühsommer auf Abschluss v Koslitionsverhandlungen und eine handlungsfähige Regierung warten müssen, während Trump dann schon 6 Monate lang macht, was er will mit der Ukraine usw, lässt mir die Haare zu Berge stehen.Eile ist geboten!
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
An important reminder
TheLvivJournal
@LvivJournal
About Trump's plan to "freeze" the conflict:
russia won't accept it. Kherson, Zaporizhzhia & Donetsk regions are, since Sep 2022, "legally part of russia & occupied by Ukraine". So, signing a peace deal, in the current situation, would mean "ceding territory" to Ukraine...➡️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Bizarre indeed. Though to my knowledge the number of available Storm Shadow is somewhat higher than that of French SCALP (scraping the bottom of the barrel), the situation isn't great and isn't amenable to rapid change
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Velina Tchakarova
@vtchakarova
Scholz didn‘t invite Poland to the Quad meeting in Berlin. Now Poland’s Tusk to meet EU, UK, NATO leaders on Ukraine after Trump win, but not Germany.
#velsig
www.politico.eu/article/poland-donald-tusk-meet-eu-uk-lea… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
Ils iront tous….
Wojciech Pawelczyk
@WojPawelczyk
BREAKING: Polish President Andrzej Duda is flying to the United States to meet with President Donald Trump at his Mar-a-Lago residence in Florida on Friday evening 🇵🇱🤝🇺🇸
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"Not a show for Trump"? An important decision whatever the case may be re Trump
Paul Triolo
@pstAsiatech
TSMC to close door on producing advanced AI chips for China from Monday
This is very important development, with TSMC continuing to be put in position of acting as an arm of US export control policy. A short thread. 🧵
www.ft.com/content/a736beeb-b38a-484e-bbe9-98e92ecb66d9 via @ft -
François Heisbourg reposted
Paul Triolo
@pstAsiatech
TSMC to close door on producing advanced AI chips for China from Monday
This is very important development, with TSMC continuing to be put in position of acting as an arm of US export control policy. A short thread. 🧵
www.ft.com/content/a736beeb-b38a-484e-bbe9-98e92ecb66d9 via @ft -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. The IISS bottom-line is that 66% of European defence procurement is NOT from the US -meaning military budget increases in Europe do NOT go to the US. The majority of European military spending comes back to European taxpayers in the form of orders and jobs
IISS News
@IISS_org
Delegates at #iisspds24 have asked why our European defence procurement figures are different from the Draghi Report? Answer: We measure procurement, they measure international armaments transfer.
Read the IISS Strategic Dossier now: www.iiss.org/publications/strategic-dossiers/building-def… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I'm afraid I'm with Shashank on this one
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
Odesa has been struck by a massive Shahed drone strike. Several fires are observed..
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
1/2 Guerre d'Ukraine | 08/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Pischane-Stelmakhivka🔹U241108-1021
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241108-1028
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241108-1038
🌐 Orikhiv-Robotyne🔹U241108-1047
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Note: my latest book contains a Lithuania-Kaliningrad scenario
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. He also noted that Russian-occupied Ukraine represents ~two-thirds of the Baltic States, including their capitals, the bulk of their Russian minorities -and the land-bridge to Kaliningrad via 'beautiful Lithuania'. He remarked that Russian force reconstitution had begun
Sir John Chipman
@chipmanj
General Jürgen-Joachim von Standrart, Commander, Multi-National Corps Northeast NATO at IISS Prague Defence Summit that provokes strategic thinking by noting the fact the then German government said that the security of the West required deploying to the Hindu Kush in Afghanistan but now we debate whether we give 15 or 18 things to Ukraine. Hmm…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. He also noted that Russian-occupied Ukraine represents ~two-thirds of the Baltic States, including their capitals, the bulk of their Russian minorities -and the land-bridge to Kaliningrad via 'beautiful Lithuania'. He remarked that Russian force reconstitution had begun
Sir John Chipman
@chipmanj
General Jürgen-Joachim von Standrart, Commander, Multi-National Corps Northeast NATO at IISS Prague Defence Summit that provokes strategic thinking by noting the fact the then German government said that the security of the West required deploying to the Hindu Kush in Afghanistan but now we debate whether we give 15 or 18 things to Ukraine. Hmm…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Pour dire le moins...
Taehwan Shin
@shin_taehwan
Est-ce plan vrai? J’ai pas trouvé aucune citation.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Sérieusement? Poutine adorera les troupes européennes (UE et/ou OTAN) en Ukraine et le maintien et le maintien de Zelensky au pouvoir...
Restitutor Orientis 🇱🇮
@restitutorII
🇺🇸🇺🇦🇷🇺
Ukraine: Le plan de paix de Trump pour l'Ukraine :
- Cessez-le-feu immédiat
- La Russie conserve ses gains territoriaux
- Création d’une zone démilitarisée le long de la ligne de front
- Les armées européennes (et non américaine) financeront et patrouilleront dans la zone tampon pour garantir le cessez-le-feu et dissuader la Russie
- L'Ukraine suspendra son adhésion à l'OTAN pendant 20 ans
- Les États-Unis fourniront des armes à l'Ukraine pour dissuader toute agression future de la Russie -
François Heisbourg reposted
Atum Mundi
@atummundi
🔹#mozambique 🇲🇿🔹
Le Mozambique se soulève face au FRELIMO, parti au pouvoir accusé de fraudes électorales.
La police et l'armée ont multiplié les tirs sur les civils qui manifestaient, des dizaines de morts sont à déplorer.
🧵THREAD🧵1/12 ⬇️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 990
1. Zelensky in Budapest 🇭🇺 European political community summit
2. Trump and Musk in phone call with Zelensky
3. 🇫🇮 offers base for NATO recce drones
4. 32 drones down, 18 lost, 1 on target
5. 3 cruise missiles down -
François Heisbourg reposted
Anton Gerashchenko
@Gerashchenko_en
An eighth Russian general has been killed in the war in Ukraine, Russian media report.
Major General Pavel Klimenko was reportedly attacked by a drone at a checkpoint near Krasnohorivka (near the front line), moving in a group on motorcycles.
Klimenko commanded the 5th Donetsk Motor Rifle Brigade, which was created on the basis of the Oplot battalion in 2014 by the "DPR authorities." -
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️🇫🇮Finland offers to place a base for NATO's large reconnaissance drones on its territory.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
🪖MilitaryNewsUA🇺🇦
@front_ukrainian
⚡️Resigned 🇩🇪German Finance Minister Christian Lindner said that Scholz fired him because of a proposal to send Taurus missiles to Ukraine, — Berliner Zeitung
According to him, Scholz gave the task of allocating €3 billion in financial support to Ukraine, however, Lindner stated that this was impossible due to the difficult financial situation in the country. Instead, the minister offered Scholz to send Taurus missiles, to which Scholz flatly refused and informed Lindner of his resignation. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Christopher Miller
@ChristopherJM
President Zelensky’s team confirms to me that Elon Musk was on the call with Trump and the Ukrainian president and participated in the discussion.
Barak Ravid
@BarakRavid
🇺🇸🇺🇦Scoop: Elon Musk joined Trump's call with Zelensky. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2024/11/08/musk-trump-zelensky-ukraine-call -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Currently being discussed at @IISS_org Prague Defence Summit. Bottom-lines: contrary to widely received assumptions in EU -Brussels, 78% of ongoing European defence investment does NOT go to the US. The actual number is 34%. Prior studies counted crossborder transfers only. 1/
IISS News
@IISS_org
Book launch!
📘 Don't miss the latest IISS Strategic Dossier on Europe's defence capabilities.
Key insights on transatlantic cooperation, defence spending, industrial capacity, resilience & supply-chain security.
⏰ 13:30-14:30 GMT | 14:30-15:30 CET
Join the event live from Prague. #iisspds24 www.iiss.org/events/2024/10/iiss-strategic-dossier-launch… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
So it begins
Demetri
@AsiaLens
SCOOP - Trump asks Robert Lighthizer to return as US trade representative
www.ft.com/content/5003b5b9-7d36-49a7-96cc-d5fecc7a0a96?s… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Demetri
@AsiaLens
SCOOP - Trump asks Robert Lighthizer to return as US trade representative
www.ft.com/content/5003b5b9-7d36-49a7-96cc-d5fecc7a0a96?s… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Currently being discussed at @IISS_org Prague Defence Summit. Bottom-lines: contrary to widely received assumptions in EU -Brussels, 78% of ongoing European defence investment does NOT go to the US. The actual number is 34%. Prior studies counted crossborder transfers only. 1/
IISS News
@IISS_org
Book launch!
📘 Don't miss the latest IISS Strategic Dossier on Europe's defence capabilities.
Key insights on transatlantic cooperation, defence spending, industrial capacity, resilience & supply-chain security.
⏰ 13:30-14:30 GMT | 14:30-15:30 CET
Join the event live from Prague. #iisspds24 www.iiss.org/events/2024/10/iiss-strategic-dossier-launch…
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The IISS study incorporates in-country procurement which is a big share of arms acquisition in 🇫🇷 🇩🇪 & 🇬🇧. This has big implications since it will be difficult to get citizens to accept defence budget increases if they are led to believe that most of the money goes to Trump's US
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Bis repetita
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En effet. Et pour la suite, après l'investiture présidentielle le 20 janvier prochain, le lecteur amateur de sensations fortes pourra se reporter au chapitre 8 sur la fin des alliances dans mon 'Un monde sans l'Amérique'.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
My two-bits re Trump and Europe in @le_NouvelObs
Flore Thomasset
@FloreThomasset
« Donald #trump déteste l’Europe, particulièrement l’Allemagne, et méprise les Français ».
@FHeisbourg est dans @Le_NouvelObs, par @DimitriKrier
www.nouvelobs.com/monde/20241108.OBS96073/donald-trump-de… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Flore Thomasset
@FloreThomasset
« Donald #trump déteste l’Europe, particulièrement l’Allemagne, et méprise les Français ».
@FHeisbourg est dans @Le_NouvelObs, par @DimitriKrier
www.nouvelobs.com/monde/20241108.OBS96073/donald-trump-de… -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
President Zelenskyy and current German opposition leader - and highly likely next Chancellor - had a phone call this morning. He was asking the Ukrainian president:
Merz: "What do you need? Money or equipment?"
Zelenskyy: "We have enough money until 2026. We need weapons. We need long-range weapons with no restrictions."
Merz has repeatedly demanded to deliver the TAURUS missile. It is not only a good solutions which is specifically required by Ukraine, but also possible without increasing debts in Germany. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Biden administration, not (yet) Trump
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
The US will support Ukraine-Russia negotiations if Zelensky is ready, says State Dept. spokesman Matthew Miller during a press briefing. Miller emphasized that it is up to Zelensky if and when to start negotiations.
www.state.gov/briefings/department-press-briefing-novembe… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 989
1. 92 Shaheds launched, 62 down, ? lost; x Iskander-Ms launched, 4 Kh-59/69 down
2. Tougher German coalition on the horizon?? German early elections in January-March 2025
3. Russian progression ongoing on Donbass front -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not a great situation
Ministry of Defence 🇬🇧
@DefenceHQ
Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 5 November 2024.
Find out more about Defence Intelligence's use of language: www.gov.uk/government/news/defence-intelligence-communica…
#standwithukraine 🇺🇦 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The optimist is the one who cries, because he's been brutally punished by reality. The pessimist smiles: he is rewarded by things turning out so much better than he feared 🙃🙃🙃
USSR Pictures
@PicturesUssr
"Optimist and pessimist." USSR, 1936. Photo by E. Mikulina
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
❗️ The Biden administration plans to urgently send the remaining $6 billion in security support to Ukraine before Trump's inauguration, reports Politico.
www.politico.com/news/2024/11/06/biden-trump-ukraine-assi… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine | 06/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Kupiansk-Pischane🔹U241106-1838
🌐 Niu-York-Toretsk🔹U241106-1832
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241106-1820
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241106-1828
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Maximilian Terhalle
@M_Terhalle
Merz possesses a sense of economic and geopolitical urgency which is vastly different from that of Scholz. So, expect elections in January, or February at the latest.
Scholz's failure at such a moment in time is no less than strategically embarassing. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
And hopefully there will be early elections in March leading to a functioning coalition- instead of paralysis with disfunctional governance till next autumn. Maybe a remake of the remarkable Schmidt-Kohl transfer in 1982-83. @AnnwieAnna @ClaudMajor @RikeFranke @M_Terhalle
Adt adt
@Adtadt3
And there is no more government in Berlin....
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Le devenir politique et stratégique de l'Allemagne et par ricochet de l'Europe toute entiere est désormais dans la balance à l'ombre de Trump et de Poutine. #ukraine l'www.france24.com/fr/europe/20241107-éclatement-de-la-coal…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
An issue is not a synonym of problem. The problem was that the electorate (the issue) wasn't convinced by the alternative (the problem), ie Kamala and the Democratic Party
rideitlikeyoustoleit
@jt24121
Ha. The EU has set the course for failure 😐....look at the numbers and the situation in each county. I like getting different views, why I follow you. But saying the majority of the US population is the problem is a bit much. You are not coming from a position of strength 😐
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
This is true, but in political terms, this is also as short-sighted as short-sighted gets. The sad reality is that Trump and his party won the election fair and square. The US electorate is the issue.
🇪 🇷 🇮 🇨 Lecomte 🇧🇪🇺🇦
La couverture de la version numérique du magazine Vanity Fair écrit à côté du portrait du nouveau président figure la légende : "34 accusations criminelles, 1 condamnation, 2 affaires en cours, 2 mises en accusation, 6 faillites. 4 ans de plus.
47e président américain".
#russie #ukraine #nafo #felas #trump -
François Heisbourg reposted
WarTranslated
@wartranslated
Yesterday's attack on Kaspiysk in Dagestan from a different angle.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes, but. It will take a currently non-existent parliamentary majority in Paris to follow through Macron's calls for greater European sovereignty in the wake of Trump's election. And I'm not sure he has enough political credit to do a referendum. @benjaminhaddad @EmmanuelMacron
Élysée
@Elysee
EN DIRECT | L’intervention du Président @EmmanuelMacron au Sommet de la Communauté politique européenne. x.com/i/broadcasts/1BRJjwLNNyjxw
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 988
1. Heavy drone attack vs Kiyv & Odesa. 74 down, 25 lost, 7 hit (5 districts in Kyiv)
2. Strike vs warship in Kaspyisk (Daghestan) confirmed -
François Heisbourg reposted
Mick Ryan, AM
@WarintheFuture
Finally, a sense of urgency has emerged. Pity we didn’t see a strategic sense of urgency to support #ukraine from Washington or Europe 3 years ago…we have collectively been too slow, too risk adverse and too scared of Russia losing.
Jack Detsch
@JackDetsch
NEW: The Biden admin is planning to rush the last $6B remaining in Ukraine security assistance out the door by Inauguration, as the outgoing team prepares for the weapons flow to end once Trump takes office.
From @paulmcleary and me: www.politico.com/news/2024/11/06/biden-trump-ukraine-assi… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Great piece by @StevenErlanger in @nytimes with input from yours only and @_georginawright @jana_puglierin...
Steven Erlanger
@StevenErlanger
European allies and the Trump conundrum. My take. @StevenErlanger
Explore this gift article from The New York Times. You can read it for free without a subscription. www.nytimes.com/2024/11/07/world/europe/trump-nato-ukrain… -
François Heisbourg reposted
infos non stop
@ActusNonStop
▶️#international - Retour de Trump : L'onde de choc pour l'Europe : “Il y a un problème pour Trump qui s’est mis dans une position de demandeur vis à vis de Poutine.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#international - Retour de Trump : L'onde de choc pour l'Europe : “Il y a un problème pour Trump qui s’est mis dans une position de demandeur vis à vis de Poutine.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
Vincent Lamal
@LamalVincent
La réponse de l’Allemagne à Trump après son élection ?
Germany at NATO
@GermanyNATO
🇩🇪 is planning to reintroduce national service to strengthen its national and collective deterrence & defence capabilities and build up a strong reserve. The new legislation was approved by the Cabinet today and will be debated in the Bundesrat and Bundestag early next year. 1/2
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
Trump's defeat of Harris was much closer than people realize, and than his ±3% popular vote victory implies.
But therein lies the true horror for the Democrats: They knew the Blue Wall states—Michigan, Pennsylvania & Wisconsin—were critical & they would have won them, and thus the presidency (likely until 2033), with miniscule shifts:
0.5% swing in WI (18,000 votes)
0.7% swing in MI (38,000 votes)
1.2% swing in PA (78,000 votes)
So any small shift away from their voter-repelling, wokey, postmodernism-derived ideological fringe elite positions (trans, Hamas, etc.) and/or choosing a better VP candidate (i.e., Shapiro) would have won them the White House.
But they just couldn't—they stuck with the Hamas-fans and Imane Khelif diehards and sleepwalked to a generational electoral apocalypse. -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#international - Retour de Trump : L'onde de choc pour l'Europe : “Il y a un problème pour Trump qui s’est mis dans une position de demandeur vis à vis de Poutine.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#ÉtatsUnis - "Le plus grand retour de l'Histoire" : “Harris a perdu parce qu’elle a tout le temps parlé de Trump. Elle a été non crédible sur les questions d’immigration et économique.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️ -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A helpful thread
Etienne Marcuz
@Etienne_Marcuz
🇫🇷 The road toward a French ☢️ umbrella 🇪🇺
Dear European friends, times are tough and I know we French people can be a pain to deal with (working on it). But here are some ideas on how to work together to build a new nuclear umbrella over Europe.
A thread 🧶 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Au niveau aspirationnel certes. En termes pratiques, il y a hélas l'alternative calamiteuse de l'Europe impuissance, avec la 🇫🇷 et l'🇩🇪 avec leurs problèmes gravissimes de gouvernance & le 🇬🇧 qui reste hors de l'UE et un Trump qui va jouer à fond le bilatéral avec Orbán & autres
Frédéric Encel
@FredericEncel
Il n’y a cette fois plus d’alternative à l’Europe-puissance, au-delà de la simple UE. Avec le Royaume-Uni bien entendu.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Sorry: 987 (it's been a long and bad night)
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 587
1. Not good news for 🇺🇦: Trump-Vance ticket elected along with Senate majority
2. 🇺🇦🇰🇵 exchange fires in Kursk pocket
3. TBC: strike vs Caspian Fleet warship
4. 38 Shaheds down, 20 lost out of 63 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
That last sentence...🥲
Bruno Tertrais
@BrunoTertrais
The absence of strong national leaders in many European countries might be a blessing in disguise - there will be less suspicions that one particular country seeks to impose its own agenda. But that will require statesmanship and a spirit of compromise and unity.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. And currently neither France nor Germany are in a political position to spearhead a European initiative jointly or severally. Alas
Camille Grand
@camille_grand
No European leader is in a position to speak for Europe alone. Only a strong and coordinated message (also involving EU and NATO leadership) of à Europe taking its responsibilities could make a difference. But Europeans probably too divided?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 587
1. Not good news for 🇺🇦: Trump-Vance ticket elected along with Senate majority
2. 🇺🇦🇰🇵 exchange fires in Kursk pocket
3. TBC: strike vs Caspian Fleet warship
4. 38 Shaheds down, 20 lost out of 63 -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. And currently neither France nor Germany are in a political position to spearhead a European initiative jointly or severally. Alas
Camille Grand
@camille_grand
No European leader is in a position to speak for Europe alone. Only a strong and coordinated message (also involving EU and NATO leadership) of à Europe taking its responsibilities could make a difference. But Europeans probably too divided?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Trump 47 nous considérera-t-il comme des alliés?
Benjamin Haddad
@benjaminhaddad
Les Américains sont nos alliés et nous travaillerons avec le président Trump comme nous l’avons fait au cours de son premier mandat.
C’est en étant unis au niveau européen que nous pourrons peser dans la relation et défendre nos intérêts économiques et stratégiques. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Cartes du Monde
@CartesDuMonde
Pologne 🇵🇱
Le Premier ministre Polonais, Donald Tusk,considère que l'Europe doit désormais être en capacité d'assurer sa propre défense sans dépendre des turbulences politiques Américaines. Si l'Europe n'arrive pas à se réveiller sur ce point alors le continent sera menacé. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Ukraine justifies Kursk operation as a preventive offensive against an expected Russian attack on Sumy www.facebook.com/share/p/1Ab8TR26v7/
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
A Japanese take on my seppuku-for-the-German-coalition recommendation
nobu akiyama
@nobu_akiyama
欧州有識者のがっかりぶりといったら…
それにしても、エイスブール御大、「切腹」はどうなんでしょうね?
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Seppuku ASAP is probably the best thing the German coalition can do at this stage, paving the way for something like the Schmidt-Kohl switchover in 1982. The earlier Germany returns to a more or less functional coalition, the better
Tom Nuttall
@tom_nuttall
Germany's government is not going to spend the day working out how to respond to this result, consulting with allies and demonstrating leadership within Europe. It's going to spend the day deciding whether or not to commit hara-kiri.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NEXTA
@nexta_tv
Republicans are gaining a majority in the U.S. Congress
According to preliminary data published by the Associated Press, the Republicans have 51 seats in the Senate, the Democrats - 42. In the House of Representatives, Republicans, preliminary, get 187 seats, Democrats - 163. Democrat Sarah McBride became the first transgender woman in the U.S. Congress: she was elected to the House of Representatives from the state of Delaware. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes, he's been bad news. But we may well see much worse come 20 January
Oliver Alexander
@OAlexanderDK
Ukraine does have one thing to celebrate. Only 2 more months of being forced to listen to this useless coward.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Hoping that this will be confirmed. A feat performed through Ukraine's efforts
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Kiitos! 🇫🇮🇨🇵🇪🇺
Jussi Träskilä
@traskila
que qq1 le traduise en finnois sur le champ🙏
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Seppuku ASAP is probably the best thing the German coalition can do at this stage, paving the way for something like the Schmidt-Kohl switchover in 1982. The earlier Germany returns to a more or less functional coalition, the better
Tom Nuttall
@tom_nuttall
Germany's government is not going to spend the day working out how to respond to this result, consulting with allies and demonstrating leadership within Europe. It's going to spend the day deciding whether or not to commit hara-kiri.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Lecture pour un requiem
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Dark November. Trump and the GOP are on a romp towards a trifecta of power: the presidency, the Senate (53+), the House. Crunch time for a paralysed Europe
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Le Point
@LePoint
«La raison pour laquelle vous vous êtes fait huer ce n'est pas parce que vous étiez une femme mais parce que vous étiez con.»
La colère de Marjane Satrapi adressée à #sandrinerousseau
✒️ @scoignard
➡️ l.lepoint.fr/qwX -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Two Georgias, one Russia meddling
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
🚨 Two polling stations in Georgia have been evacuated after five bomb threats reportedly sent from Russia, per CNN citing Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger. The threats led to temporary closures of voting sites in Union City, a community with a 90% African American population.
www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/2024-election-trump-harris -
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine | 04/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Pischane-Stelmakhivka🔹U241104-1833
🌐 Balka Zhuravka(Nevske)-Kreminna🔹U241104-1839
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241104-1825
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241104-1829
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Romain Pigenel
@Romain_Pigenel
🇺🇸🗳️🫏🐘Ce soir, the place to be pour suivre l'élection Harris vs Trump c'est à l'@ENS_ULM avec le Super Mardi organisé par le @Grand_Continent ! Inscriptions closes mais streaming disponible ici : legrandcontinent.eu/fr/evenements/super-mardi-soiree-elec…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed
toozewhatnot
@toozewhatnot
Yes, but you can't forget that like ideology (such as exists in the region) theology has also been insanely Americanized in the last 30 years.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Absolument. Pas un exemple à suivre
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Pas ou pas encore (nous nous approchons plutôt de la situation anversoise). Mais ceux en Frence qui voudraient faire intervenir l'armée font comme si nous étions au Mexique...
Olivier Kempf
@egea_blog
Vous trouver que nous sommes proches de la situation mexicaine ?
Cf la tentation du Bukelisme, que nous avions traitée dans la vigie www.lettrevigie.com/blog/2023/07/19/la-tentation-du-bukel…
poke @InforOrphelines -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed.
Rym Momtaz ريم ممتاز (rmomtaz.bsky.social)
@RymMomtaz
To hope for a presidency that carries significant risks for US democracy and the world economy just so that the Europeans can finally wake up - because an *actual war* on their continent isn't enough - betrays the depth of European strategic delinquency and navel-gazing.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En effet. Comme en atteste le Mexique
Olivier Kempf
@egea_blog
Ça ne servirait a rien
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
When I go to Kyiv, I prefer to know what people think rather than to tell them to keep quiet. I'm not talking about rabble-rousers or copperheads (to use an American analogy)
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
Agree no question Zelensky, Yermak et al actively deflecting real Ukrainian despondency to West (see, eg recent digs 🇺🇸 🇵🇱 etc). And a Corsican correct morale > to material.
But task of ensuring 🇺🇦 prevails requires -to me- more than amplifying manipulative, indulgent emotion.
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes, this is a dire line of thought & emotion which I picked up in Kyiv during my late September visit. Though some in Western Europe dismiss it as a form of moral blackmail, I take it seriously
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
If Ukraine is defeated and occupied by Russia one day, many Ukrainians will blame the fickle and unreliable West for their tragedy. And if Russia’s armies head to Poland and further into Europe after that, they will have hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian veterans in their ranks — some forced to fight, but many others animated by the “stab in the back” rancor. It’s not too late to prevent that.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I'm at a loss to explain why orthodoxy and support for Trump overlap so neatly in this set of polls
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
How would Europeans vote in the US election?
Is there an explanation for Trump's very strong standing in central+south-eastern Europe? -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. Which is why I took and take such remarks at face value. But do our politicians meet non political folks in Ukraine?
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
People saying this are not politicians for external consumption. Conversations among ordinary Ukrainians are not blackmail. They are an analysis of probable outcomes.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes, this is a dire line of thought & emotion which I picked up in Kyiv during my late September visit. Though some in Western Europe dismiss it as a form of moral blackmail, I take it seriously
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
If Ukraine is defeated and occupied by Russia one day, many Ukrainians will blame the fickle and unreliable West for their tragedy. And if Russia’s armies head to Poland and further into Europe after that, they will have hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian veterans in their ranks — some forced to fight, but many others animated by the “stab in the back” rancor. It’s not too late to prevent that.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 986
1. Election day in US...
2. 79 Shaheds launched, 48 down, 30 lost, 1 ? -
François Heisbourg reposted
Conference of European Rabbis
@europeanrabbis
#russia is using #antisemitism in #europe to destabilize Europe.
This includes fake stories on #telegram and other social media networks about #jewish leaders, false statements about #ukraine, and more.
@EU_Commission -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Hoping there will still be a free and sovereign Ukraine around by the time Germany agrees to do the right thing
Johann Wadephul
@JoWadephul
Contrary to @Bundeskanzler #scholz, @cducsubt firmly believes that there is a place for #ukraine 🇺🇦 within @NATO. It is the only way to guarantee Ukraine's safety in the long run and foster peace and stability across #europe.
This must be the lesson after more than 2 years of war against Ukraine. #putin will not stop unless there are clear lines and higher stakes for him.
A warm welcome to the new @SecGenNATO, Mark #rutte. Thank you for stopping by at the @cducsubt to discuss the options with us. #wearenato #strongertogether #nato -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Closer than closest www.natesilver.net/p/a-random-number-generator-determined
-
François Heisbourg reposted
NOELREPORTS 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@NOELreports
According to Ukrainian military source Lieutenant of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, call sign “Alex”, reports Ukrainian advances near the village of Shakhtars'ke, northwest of Vuhledar.
He adds that securing these gains remains uncertain, but that this local advance is crucial for improving operational positioning. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes. One should always pay attention to what dictatorships tell us about their limitless appetite for power.
Reinhard Bütikofer
@bueti
Must read article by Global Times: If a business engages in near-shoring or friend-shoring or in any way tries to de-sinicize it is seen as "legitimate action by China" to take "decisive countermeasure" like sanctioning. Once on a Chinese hook, stay there! www.globaltimes.cn/page/202411/1322387.shtml
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine | 03/11/24
Secteurs :
🌐 Niu-York-Toretsk🔹U241103-1825
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241103-1839
🌐 Kurakhove-Kostiantynivka🔹U241103-1831
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
It might literally wind up in the range where who's "ahead" in our final forecast is determined by luck. There's still a little bit of variance introduced by running "only" 40,000 simulations (we'll run 80,000 tonight but still...)
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
This is getting really weird ( ~0.05% )
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
It's published.
We ran 80,000 simulations tonight.
Harris won in 40,012.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Pål Jonson
@PlJonson
🇸🇪 government today decided to reject the applications of 13 offshore wind farms in the Baltic Sea, while granting one (Poseidon) on the Swedish west coast. The reaction time in the event of a missile attack could go from 2 minutes to 60 seconds with wind farms in the way. (1/4)
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En effet. Et circonstance aggravante, la frontière Oder-Neisse n'avait pas encore été reconnue en droit par la RFA, alors que les frontières orientales de l'Ukraine ont été fixées en droit depuis l'indépendance en 1991.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 985
1. Maia Sandu reelected in Moldova 🇲🇩 with 55.4% of the popular vote
2. Another 50 Shahed down and 27 lost out of 80
3. Five missiles hit Ukraine 🇺🇦 including an Iskander-M vs Dnipro -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
PM update. A lot of polling in the afternoon, but most of the higher-quality polls fired earlier in the weekend. Declining lead in national polls getting a little bit bearish for Harris, although the model doesn’t care about national polls much.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
air plus news
@airplusnews
🔴 Air France a décidé de suspendre jusqu’à nouvel ordre le survol de la zone de la Mer Rouge. En conséquence, l’itinéraire de certains de ses vols a été modifié. En fonction de leur localisation, certains appareils ont pu faire demi-tour et revenir se poser à leur aéroport de départ.
⚠️ Cette décision fait suite à la suspicion d’observation par un équipage d’un objet lumineux à haute altitude dans la zone du Soudan.
air plus news
@airplusnews
🔴 Situation anormale en Afrique.
▫️Les vols Air France de Paris vers Madagascar & le Kenya font demi-tour vers Paris.
▫️Le vol Air France Paris CDG - La Réunion de ce soir, reporté à demain.
▫️Le vol Air France Maurice - Paris CDG modifie sa route, avec cap Nord-Est, et allongement du temps de parcours.
▫️Air Austral annule son vol Dzaoudzi - Nairobi - Paris d’aujourd’hui. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Morning model update.
NYT swing state polls good for Harris but not great.
Morning Consult swing state polls good for Trump but not great.
It’s a pure toss-up. All the numbers at the link.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
War Mapper
@War_Mapper
The final 4 charts show how control has changed in the 4 most active oblasts.
Other occupied oblasts have had minimal or no changes to control.
(3/3) -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Another day, another harvest of Shahed...
Tim White
@TWMCLtd
For those who were with me last night on the thread, you will know it was a heavy night, especially in #kyiv.
Nothing hit its target!
96 drones and one missile were fired by #russia
Shot down: 66 + missile
EW: 27
Last seen in #belarus: 1
Still flying at 9am: 2
#slavaukraini -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 984
The (relative) calm before the US elections? No salient events for the time being today -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Weird stuff...An upset in the offing?
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
So I have some thoughts about that Selzer poll. A lot of thoughts. Excuse any typos, this was put together fast, though we did catch all the "Seltzers".
www.natesilver.net/p/a-shocking-iowa-poll-means-somebody -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 983
1. 🇷🇺 loses a 35th Sukhoi-34
2. 🇷🇺 launches 6 missiles vs 🇺🇦
3. 🇺🇦 Donbas front in trouble -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Aukus-Paukus: hop presto -look Ma, Australia apparently only has one operational sub left 🇦🇺
Laurent Lagneau
@zonemilitaire
La marine australienne n’aurait plus qu’un seul sous-marin opérationnel pour le moment www.opex360.com/2024/11/02/la-marine-australienne-naurait…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
As close as close gets...
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
This morning's update. Chart tells the story I think. Possibly another update later today.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Hélas
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Well yes. Wondering what @ElbridgeColby makes of this development
Sir John Chipman
@chipmanj
Three more awkward questions:
What is the point of Western countries announcing a ‘pivot to Asia’ or an ‘Indo-Pacific tilt’, if when Asia’s super-rogue state — North Korea — comes knocking on Europe’s door with soldiers armed by the enemy to kill Europeans, the door is left open?
How is it that North Korea is obliged to respect a demilitarised zone (DMZ) on the Korean Peninsula but is free to militarise Kursk against Ukraine having only to suffer a US and NATO confirmation to the press of their presence?
If American ‘Asia hawks’ believe the biggest threats to the West come from opponents in Asia, why not engage and defeat them when they deploy ‘out of area’ with lethal intent to Europe?
Sir John Chipman
@chipmanj
Fascinating that there are some 10,000 North Korean troops in Russia and ‘leaders’ in the West are concerned that helping Ukraine target Russian positions in Russia that launch attacks against Ukrainian civilians would be escalatory and turn Western countries into co-combatants. Russia can escalate with North Korean and Iranian help to its cold heart’s content, but in the European theatre, whose stability is a ‘core interest’ of the West, it is solemnly declared that NATO states should not get directly involved. Middle East and Asian bad actors have unilaterally obtained for themselves a multiple entry visa to Europe with no restrictions to kill Ukrainians. Western leaders cry foul but keep long range attack missiles and other key capability on the sidelines. The political-military muscle memory of the Cold War has so dramatically dissipated that strategic arthritis has set in to the detriment of Europe’s security.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
In Kyiv, some call it the Jake Sullivan doctrine of self-deterrence
Sir John Chipman
@chipmanj
Fascinating that there are some 10,000 North Korean troops in Russia and ‘leaders’ in the West are concerned that helping Ukraine target Russian positions in Russia that launch attacks against Ukrainian civilians would be escalatory and turn Western countries into co-combatants. Russia can escalate with North Korean and Iranian help to its cold heart’s content, but in the European theatre, whose stability is a ‘core interest’ of the West, it is solemnly declared that NATO states should not get directly involved. Middle East and Asian bad actors have unilaterally obtained for themselves a multiple entry visa to Europe with no restrictions to kill Ukrainians. Western leaders cry foul but keep long range attack missiles and other key capability on the sidelines. The political-military muscle memory of the Cold War has so dramatically dissipated that strategic arthritis has set in to the detriment of Europe’s security.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
Guerre d'Ukraine - Octobre 2024
Synthèse, de fin de mois, des superficies occupées par l'armée russe | LPR | DPR dans les oblasts d'Ukraine.
+ Localisation des nouvelles zones occupées -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not reassuring. Looks like recovery could happen rapidly
Holger Roonemaa
@holger_r
Here's a story we worked on for a year. We analysed 24 RU mil bases behind Baltic and Polish borders and engaged top level military sources to evaluate our findings.
It is a story how the war would play out in case RU would decide to start it. 🧵⬇️
ekspress.delfi.ee/artikkel/120333504/satellite-imagery-an… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Our first model run of November! One of Harris's better updates lately, at least in the Blue Wall states.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
*Stavropol area oil refinery
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 982
1. 🇷🇺 forces closing in on Kupiansk while moving South of Pokrovsk
2. 🇺🇦 hits Stavropol
3. Discussions between Zelensky & Orbán
4. 31 Shahed down, 14 lost; 6 missiles lost, 1 Kh-59/69 down -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 982
1. 🇷🇺 forces closing in on Kupiansk while moving South of Pokrovsk
2. 🇺🇦 hits Stavropol
3. Discussions between Zelensky & Orbán
4. 31 Shahed down, 14 lost; 6 missiles lost, 1 Kh-59/69 down -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Even his name is given (ie in Cyrillic: Ли, Джон дже)
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
PM update. This morning's batch of polls was pretty good for Harris but the afternoon was stronger for Trump. All pretty incremental at this point. Still, a gap is opening up between PA and MI/WI, and Harris may need backup plans if the Blue Wall is split.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Lucius Gellius Publicola 🏺
@Lucius_Gellius
Le génie romain à l'épreuve des catastrophes naturelles: le barrage romain d'Almonacid de la Cuba (Aragon) , qui est le plus grand barrage de l'empire romain encore debout, a résisté aux pluies diluviennes qui se sont abattues en Espagne ces derniers jours.
Ce barrage de 34 m de haut à été construit sous Auguste à la fin du Ier siècle avant JC et est resté fonctionnel en tant que réserve d'eau jusqu' à la moitié du Ier siècle après JC.
En raison de problèmes de colmatage dans son réservoir, il a finalement été utilisé comme déversoir pour détourner les eaux vers les zones irriguées de Belchite, à travers un ancien canal d'origine également romaine, long de 8 km. Aujourd'hui, il continue à jouer ce rôle. -
François Heisbourg reposted
France Inter Presse
@inter_presse
A #8h20 sur @franceinter :
Election américaine : le monde d’après
@MarionLHour reçoit @FHeisbourg, conseiller spécial à la Fondation pour la recherche stratégique et @ElisaChelle, professeure en science politique et chercheuse affiliée à Sciences Po. (LIEPP).
#le69inter -
François Heisbourg reposted
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
“France has launched a debate on equipping the Mirages with A2SM bombs produced by Safran, as well as the F-16s. This certainly raises technical issues of interoperability that need to be resolved. But how can we believe that these bombs are usable and effective on Russian aircraft and that they can not be carried by American aircraft?” — @MurielDomenach, former 🇫🇷 ambassador to @FranceOTAN
French Aid to Europe 🇨🇵 🇪🇺
@aidefranceukr
A significant amount of work is being carried out to adapt AASM Hammer bombs to F-16 jets that will be delivered to Ukraine.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Update. The forecast remains extremely stable and extremely close to 50/50.
Trump made real gains in mid-October, but the forecast is ~unchanged from 10-12 days ago. We think people are getting a little carried away with narratives about momentum, etc.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
My two-bits in Die Welt from my Un Monde sans l'Amérique @OdileJacob
Landry Charrier
@landry_charrier
✨La France 🇫🇷 au bord de la faillite, l’Allemagne 🇩🇪 en proie à la récession: les deux puissances motrices de l’#ue 🇪🇺 sont dans l’incapacité de déployer un puissant leadership. Un constat qui inquiète alors que l’histoire s’accélère (@Madabout_Paris): dokdoc.eu/fr/politique/24168/le-gong-a-t-il-deja-sonne/
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Poulet volant
@Pouletvolant3
1/2 Guerre d'Ukraine | 30/10/24
🌐 Synthèse mouvements🔹U241030-1031
Secteurs :
🌐 Pischane-Stelmakhivka🔹U241030-1009
🌐 Selydove-Krasnohorivka🔹U241030-1017
🌐 Vuhledar-Kostiantynivka🔹U241030-1029
#ukrainerussianwar #guerreenukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
(((Tendar)))
@Tendar
It has been revealed that one of the requests by Ukraine regarding the victory plan, which were kept secret but were leaked, considered BGM-109 Tomahawk cruise missiles. Even the Block II versions of that missile type has a range of 2,500 km (1,550 miles). The entire area west of the Ural mountains and even beyond would be in range.
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Sonia jerbi fourati
@FouratiJerbi
Quand la 🇫🇷 commencera t elle à représenter les musulmanes telles q elles sont aussi ?
Libres , élégantes et cultivées .
La dindasse voilée inculte bégayant des éléments de langage de science pô a envahi l’espace.
Et ns nous sommes invisibilisées par le système médiatique. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 981
1. Controlling the narrative: Slovak PM FIco gives interview to Skabeyeva on RT1
2. 4 Iskander-M/Hwasong & 8 Kh-59/69 launches (2 Kh down)
3. 17 Shahed down, 23 lost, 3 hits
4. Intense fighting fm Kupiansk to Vuhledar areas -
François Heisbourg reposted
Norwegian Ministry of Defence
@Forsvarsdep
Norway 🇳🇴increases support for the Ukrainian Air Force 🇺🇦by NOK 1.3 billion and donates 130 small boats:
www.regjeringen.no/en/aktuelt/oker-stotten-til-det-ukrain…
#standwithukraine #ukraine @DefenceU @norwayinukraine -
François Heisbourg reposted
Ragnar Gudmundsson 🇮🇸🇺🇦
@ragnarbjartur
⚡️ WAR IN #ukraine - OCT 31, 2024
■ Record: Most casualties per week & month since start of invasion
■ Most in 2024: Vehicles & air defence systems hit in one day
■ Tank, artillery & drone losses also above 7-day average
■ Massive 🇷🇺 shelling but strikes below average
See dashboard for further data
#ukrainewar #ukrainerussiawar
📈 lookerstudio.google.com/s/otTZHSrXOhs -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Whoa North Carolina now #2 tipping point state.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
DrLeoStrauss - same handle @bsky.social
@DrLeoStrauss
Possible Dem control of House good news for American democracy and Ukraine. Will be close.
A new House sits January 3, 2025. This would prevent Johnson/GOP to conspire with Trump to overthrow election procedurally.
Ukraine aid in 2025 still would face GOP hurdle in Senate.
Adam Carlson
@admcrlsn
House vibe check: 6 days out
🔵 Democrats: 222
🔴 Republicans: 213
Given the outsized number of competitive districts in mail-heavy states in the west, in this scenario the House would likely not be callable for at least a few days (perhaps over a week). -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Russia is now broadening its scope, even while its war against Ukraine is still ongoing
MAKS 26 🇺🇦👀
@Maks_NAFO_FELLA
🇬🇪 "It must be admitted that Russia has won in Georgia today. They took part of the country, then changed the policy, the government. And now there is a pro-Russian government. Their choice is friendship with Russia, not the EU," — Zelensky
🇲🇩 "Moldova is going in the same direction. You will see, Russia is following the same path. They want to do the same and will do it in a year or two if the West does not stop its talk about red lines," he said. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
The proud watchword of the battle of Verdun 1916
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Ukraine’s new French trained and equipped brigade, the 155th Mechanized, has a new motto:
“On ne passe pas”
“They shall not pass” -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Rob Lee
@RALee85
“On manpower, too, Russia remains solvent. Its army is recruiting around 30,000 men per month, says the nato official. That is not enough to meet internal targets, says another official, but it is adequate to cover even the gargantuan losses of recent months.”
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Sonia jerbi fourati
@FouratiJerbi
Les musulmanes ne se voilent pas .
Le voile est un truc de barbus islamistes , importé d Arabie saoudite .
Ici princesse Khadija fille de SM Mohamed VI , commandeur des croyants . -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
▶️#Élections - Trump : Ce que l’Europe ne peut pas comprendre : “Trump n’est pas perçu aux États-Unis comme un homme imprévisible. Il n’a pas laissé un mauvais souvenir à ses électeurs pendant son premier mandat.”
@FHeisbourg
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
An overstatement obviously but it was strongly expressed indeed...
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
When I was in Kyiv 4 weeks ago, among the officials I met, the only person who was more unpopular than Vladimir Putin was Jake Sullivan, he of self-deterrence and no deep-strike
Franz-Stefan Gady
@HoansSolo
'Among Ukrainians, blaming the West — rare in the first year of the war — is gaining traction after delays in military aid and a feeling that Ukraine’s allies are only providing enough weapons for Ukraine not to lose. Europe and the United States have so far spent about $220 billion on aid and military equipment for Ukraine...'
www.nytimes.com/2024/10/29/world/europe/ukraine-zelensky-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Model update.
After consistent gains by Trump in mid-October, really pretty steady over the past 10 days.
Probably an evening update too.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
When I was in Kyiv 4 weeks ago, among the officials I met, the only person who was more unpopular than Vladimir Putin was Jake Sullivan, he of self-deterrence and no deep-strike
Franz-Stefan Gady
@HoansSolo
'Among Ukrainians, blaming the West — rare in the first year of the war — is gaining traction after delays in military aid and a feeling that Ukraine’s allies are only providing enough weapons for Ukraine not to lose. Europe and the United States have so far spent about $220 billion on aid and military equipment for Ukraine...'
www.nytimes.com/2024/10/29/world/europe/ukraine-zelensky-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Christopher Miller
@ChristopherJM
Scoop with @maxseddon & @cornishft: Ukraine and Russia are in preliminary discussions about halting strikes on each other’s energy infrastructure. Kyiv is seeking to resume Qatar-mediated negotiations that came close to agreement in August before Kursk.
www.ft.com/content/69a57022-aeed-4bfe-8ada-b2ccd38f162a -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui. "Mais pourvu que l'arrière tienne!" comme disaient les poilus. Et c'est bien l'arrière (américain, européen, et aussi ukrainien) qui me soucie
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 980
1. 🇷🇺 exercises its strategic nuclear missiles
2. 🇺🇦 drone attack vs 'Vladimir Putin' special forces academy in Gudermes (Chechnya). Kadyrov vows revenge
3. 62 Shaheds launched: 33 down, 25 lost, 4 may have hit something -
François Heisbourg reposted
MFA of Ukraine 🇺🇦
@MFA_Ukraine
Russia has attacked the very center of #kharkiv, targeting not only the cultural heritage of the city but also a UNESCO site.
This is Derzhprom, one of #ukraine's first skyscrapers and one of the largest in the world, built back in 1928. -
François Heisbourg reposted
🇪 🇷 🇮 🇨 Lecomte 🇧🇪🇺🇦
La présidente suisse propose de lever l'interdiction de réexportation d'armes vers l'Ukraine.
L'interdiction qui empêche actuellement la réexportation d'armes suisses d'un autre pays vers l'Ukraine devrait être levée, elle est préjudiciable à la sécurité du pays, a déclaré la présidente de la Confédération Viola Amherd.
Mme Amherd a également déclaré que la #suisse devait investir davantage dans la sécurité en Europe et qu'elle prévoyait de renforcer les liens avec ses partenaires, y compris l'OTAN.
#russie #ukraine #nafo #felasThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
🌙PM update
Lotta polling. Good news for Harris in MI and NC. Good news for Trump in GA and AZ.
Topline remains basically unchanged.
www.natesilver.net/p/nate-silver-2024-president-election-… -
François Heisbourg reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Russian glide bombs severely damage the iconic building of Derzhprom, the symbol of Kharkiv and one of Europe’s first skyscrapers that housed the Ukrainian government after it was completed in 1928. Derzhprom survived the Nazis but not Putin. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derzhprom
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
FOUREST EN LIBERTÉ.
▶️#politique - Y. Belattar au Maroc : “Sa présence dans la délégation française révèle l’inconséquence et l’inconsistance présidentielle sur ces sujets délicats.”
@CarolineFourest
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
24h Pujadas
@24hPujadas
FOUREST EN LIBERTÉ.
▶️#politique - Y. Belattar au Maroc : “Sa présence dans la délégation française révèle l’inconséquence et l’inconsistance présidentielle sur ces sujets délicats.”
@CarolineFourest
#24hpujadas #lci #la26 ⤵️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
François Heisbourg reposted
Rasmus Larsson 🇸🇪🇺🇦
@rasmusdotse
I thin it’s the same in Sweden. Maybe Swedish #föpol posters can clarify?
-
François Heisbourg reposted
Harmiton
@Harmiton2
In Finland it is legal for Defence forces, Police and Border Guard to shoot down drones if in critical areas, air fields, military bases or above military vessels. Also legal to shoot ships, subs etc if ROEs are met.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En effet. Et pour la suite, après l'investiture présidentielle le 20 janvier prochain, le lecteur amateur de sensations fortes pourra se reporter au chapitre 8 sur la fin des alliances dans mon 'Un monde sans l'Amérique'.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Nos soldats n'ont pas simplement "perdu la vie", ils ont été assassinés. Et les commanditaires et organisateurs de "l'attaque terroriste" sont connus. Pourquoi ne pas les nommer? Spoiler: il s'agissait du Hezbollah.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not so sure. Germany with a poulation larger than France's looks quite good on that chart given its high share of renewables. Only problem is that you'd never guess from that chart that 🇩🇪has a carbon footprint per Kilowatt of electricity produced 9 times greater than that of 🇫🇷
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Le baiser qui tue. The kiss that kills as Russian official supports National Rally in French elections fr.news.yahoo.com/législatives-2024-russie-apporte-soutie…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP 🇺🇦 DAY 819
More 🇷🇺assertion, more 🇺🇸 self-deterrence
1. 🇷🇺 conducts its nuke manoeuvres (Iskander+bombers)
2. 🇷🇺 purports to change maritime borders with 🇫🇮+🇱🇹 (Baltiisk)
3. DoD press sec MajGen Ryder says US policy unchanged re targets, all in 🇺🇦
4. 24/24 Shahed down -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Macron may be unpleasantly divisive & unhelpfully clumsy: but he is changing Europe's strategic paradigm for the good. Biden's self deterrence & Scholz's muddled pacifism are on the backfoot// Don’t rule out troops to Ukraine, Finnish FM says www.politico.com/newsletters/national-security-daily/2024… via @politico
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
La confusion dans les rangs occidentaux n'est pas la même chose que le maniement de l'ambiguïté stratégique
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I'm still trying to fully make sense of Macron's statement re a collective security commitment with partners including non-mil forces in Ukraine and defense of Moldova.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I'm still trying to fully make sense of Macron's statement re a collective security commitment with partners including non-mil forces in Ukraine and defense of Moldova.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
One of the findings of our 2016 report on Finland and NATO was that Finland, then a non-member, was actually understating its defence expenditure. 🇫🇮 has the refreshingly unusual habit of focussing on delivery rather than on PR
Finland at NATO
@FinlandatNATO
"Finland clearly meets the 2% target for defence spending. We are also contributing in #nato burden-sharing by active participation in collective peacetime missions."
Minister @anttihakkanen at today's meeting of NATO Ministers of Defence.
#defmin -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Yes
Gérard Araud
@GerardAraud
In foreign policy, the sentence “we should do something not to appear weak” is the surest way to commit a mistake.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Superb: excellently researched (including plenty of recently accessed Russian archives) and well-written. And as the title implies, the focus is as much on Stalin, as decision-maker, as it is on Finland itself
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"Europe must wake up. (...) more European NATO in Europe": wise words from a wise man in an exposed country. Will the Europeans 🇪🇺 take heed? www.presidentti.fi/en/speeches/new-years-speech-by-presid…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Le fait que le Qatar ait financé pendant des années l'effort de guerre du Hamas n'a naturellement rien à y voir
Georges Malbrunot
@Malbrunot
Le Premier ministre du Qatar, cheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahmane al-Thani, affirme qu'une "génération entière d'habitants du Moyen-Orient risque de se radicaliser en raison de la guerre à Gaza".
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Oui, en France, on peut manifester en masse, dans la dignité, sans exclusive, sans violence, contre l'antisémitisme et pour les valeurs qui font la République
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Un crève coeur que cette cérémonie dans la Cour d'Honneur des Invalides: jamais je ne l'oublierai. Rappel: le Hezbollah est toujours actif. Les jeunes terroristes de l'époque en sont devenus les cadres dirigeants. Hamas au sud, Hezbollah au nord, Jihadistes un peu partout...
Stéphane Morin Ⓜ️
@StephaneMorin_
23 octobre 1983. 40 ans. L’immeuble #drakkar explose. Massacre de 58 soldats français 🇫🇷 déployés au Liban 🇱🇧 pour la paix au titre de la Force de Sécurité Multinationale de l’ONU 🇺🇳
Horreur et terreur islamiques
#inmemoriam
#enguerre
@Armees_Gouv -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Est-ce seulement moi, mais je suis surpris par la faible résonance médiatique du fait que 30 de nos compatriotes ont été assassinés par le Hamas? Je voudrais me tromper. C'est l'acte de terrorisme le plus meurtrier depuis Nice le 14 juillet 2016 (86 morts) www.francetvinfo.fr/monde/proche-orient/israel-palestine/…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
En Israël, le bilan s'agissant de nos concitoyens est actuellement de huit tués et vingt disparus. Apparemment, pour Madame Panot, il ne s'agirait pas de victimes d'une organisation terroriste. Ou, comme je l'espère, vous ai-je mal compris, Madame @MathildePanot ?
Le Monde
@lemondefr
Guerre Israël-Hamas : Mathilde Panot ne qualifie pas le Hamas d’organisation terroriste et s’attire des critiques www.lemonde.fr/politique/article/2023/10/10/guerre-israel…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
All the more impressive since Israel, and specifically Bibi, never shared such words with Zelensky when Ukraine was invaded
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
Horrible news from Israel. My condolences go out to everyone who lost relatives or close ones in the terrorist attack. We have faith that order will be restored and terrorists will be defeated.
Terror should have no place in the world, because it is always a crime, not just against a specific country or this terror’s victims, but against humanity in general and our entire world.
Anyone who resorts to terror commits a crime against the world. Whoever finances terror is committing a crime against the world. The world must stand united and in solidarity so that terror does not attempt to break or subjugate life anywhere and at any moment.
Israel's right to self-defense is unquestionable.
All details surrounding this terrorist assault must be revealed so that the world knows and holds accountable everyone who supported and helped carry out the attack.
All Ukrainian citizens who remain in the risk zone must carefully obey all orders issued by local security services and remain vigilant. Please be cautious. The Ukrainian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and our embassy in Israel are ready to assist in any situation.
To support Ukrainians in Israel, we established an operational headquarters. If you require assistance, please contact any of our diplomatic or consular offices in any convenient and accessible manner.
Every life is valuable! We condemn all forms of terrorism. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Barbarians
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Some would say that 2022 was like 1914 (Tannenberg) & 2024 may be like 1916, ie the eve of 1917. Others would compress all of the above into 1904-05 (with US Presdt playing in 2025 the role of Teddy Roosevelt, helping 🇷🇺 after Tsushima & Mukden...)
So many analogies available...
Edward N Luttwak
@ELuttwak
The Russian army of 2022 was as per 1941; of 2023 it is like 1942. War must end. However beset & weak only the US Pres can propose the only possible plan: plebiscites for Donetsk & Luhansk (votes for all there pre 2010 even if refugees)w 10K inspectors w side-arms)no other claims
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Crass
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Maaybe that's why the US is known as the "Middle Empire"? (Just joking)
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Same question vis à vis the White House. No 'offensive' weapons, then no tanks, then no combat aircraft etc.
Peter Nemschak
@PNemschak
Has the idea of effective deterrence sunk into the average European mind ? Deterrence still has a negative connotation for a public which has not experienced war for two generations in Western Europe.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
SITREP DAY 386
1. 🇵🇱 arrests 🇷🇺 team spying on arms transfers
2. 🇵🇱 prez Duda says 4 MiG 29s delivery in a few days
3. 🇮🇱 to transfer anti-drone kit to 🇺🇦
4. At 10th Ramstein group meet, 9 countries confirm pledge re 150 Leo 2s
5. 🇫🇮 prez Niinistö to meet 🇹🇷 prez Erdoğan Friday -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
About time, too
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Not a minute too soon in terms of preparing for an uncertain winter
Velina Tchakarova
@vtchakarova
German Minister of Finance Lindner said that he is open for the use of nuclear energy to avoid electricity shortage in Germany.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Are the coalition leaders listening?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
🧵Unfathomable: 🇩🇪 (rightly) insists on the difficulty of stopping gas imports from 🇷🇺. Yet it could cover 30% of the road to zero gas by restarting the 3 nuclear plants shut 4 months ago & by not closing down the last 3 NPPs in December 2022. This would involve limited cost 1/.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Given what is happening to non-NATO 🇺🇦 , the strategically most prudent option may now be the close-to-immediate admission of 🇸🇪+🇫🇮 into NATO, while the bulk of🇷🇺's combat forces is otherwise occupied. The situation is no longer that of the 2016 report @niinisto @carlbildt
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Remarquable fil qui remet avec précision et un minimum d' esprit partisan le clocher au milieu du village européen
Arnaud Danjean
@ArnaudDanjean
Échange intéressant sur la défense avec le Président Macron lors du débat au Parlement Européen. N’ayant bien sûr pas pu répondre à sa réponse,je maintiens qu’affirmer que «la défense européenne a plus progressé ces 2 dernières années que depuis des décennies» ne rime à rien! ⤵️
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. The Finnish president @niinisto has been raising the issue for years, most recently in his New Years message, including pointed language about the EU's limited role. One can't say that Brussels has responded in a satisfactory manner.
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Some 375 Afghan nationals evacuated to France last night. Bringing them by a convoy of minibusses to the airport under armed protection appears to have been a harrowing process: 3 hours to drive 7 kilometres
Defense 280
@Defense137
395 ressortissants (dont une vingtaine de Français et une majorité d'Afghans) évacués cette nuit de l'ambassade de France vers l'aéroport de Kaboul, par le détachement de protection (éléments PN dont RAID) de l'ambassadeur David Martinon
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
"Patently not Saigon": a difficult sell for @ABlinken. The West's over-ambitious mission in Afghanistan during the 19 years after Osama ben Laden was chased out has ended in the most shameful manner
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Indeed. EU is where US was 50 days ago in terms of vaccination. I assess at 60 000 the extra deaths in population-adjusted terms suffered by the EU in comparison to US during that 50 day period
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
I agree with your bottom-line of dealing with the Russia of today. But with a twist: Russia's decline is a lagging not a leading indicator, it has already happened. China is the post USSR super-power, not Russia, and Russia won't catch up. The Russia we have is what it is: 1/
Nicu Popescu
@nicupopescu
my take: Is Russia in decline? maybe yes, maybe no. But basing EU policy on Russia on such determinism is short-sighted. The EU needs to deal with Russia of today, not that of 2050 or 2070. ecfr.eu/article/why-the-eu-should-stop-waiting-for-the-go…
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Nice. Should be standard issue for every politician, journalist, researcher...
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
Statistical fallacies that you will want to avoid. Source: www.geckoboard.com/resources/statistical-fallacies/
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
2 ways to describe the big decision to dissolve the CFAfranc in WestAfrica: 1) WAfrica loses a colonial relic & will now enjoy the benefits of monetary independence 2) WAfrica loses its European-backed version of the euro & will no longer enjoy the benefits of monetary stability
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Un mal très français: vouloir faire l'Europe sans les Européens. Il est grand temps de devenir sérieux.
Dommage que ce soit Sylvie Goulard qui en soit la victime.
Jean Quatremer
@quatremer
Les leçons du naufrage français.
www.liberation.fr/planete/2019/10/13/le-goulardgate-renfo… -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Journée-test, voire journée-pivot, dans la vie politique de l'Algérie. Après la prière du vendredi, l'ampleur de la mobilisation, son déroulement du côté des manifestants comme des forces de l'ordre sera clé. En attendant, l'hélico survole le centre d' #alger & El Watan se vend
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Murders in Germany: 662; in the US: 12997. Murder rate per 100 000: 0.8 Germany; 4.2 in US. Five times higher in US...
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
The people of Germany are turning against their leadership as migration is rocking the already tenuous Berlin coalition. Crime in Germany is way up. Big mistake made all over Europe in allowing millions of people in who have so strongly and violently changed their culture!
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Correct, alas
Tom Wright
@thomaswright08
FDP, Merkel's likely coalition partner, strongly opposed to many French ideas for deeper integration of Eurozone
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Syrian Sarin in 2013: CW forensics
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Gänsehaut, goose pimples, chair de poule: 3 birds for 1 feeling
Markus Jox
@mmjox
Gänsehaut. Vive la France! Vive l'Europe!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Delirium breaks out in @EmmanuelMacron 's camp
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Nudging, Nazi style
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
UK still not realizing that negotiating goals of UK (getting a good deal) and of EU (keeping EU27 united) are deeply different
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Fascinating @ohanasteve: Financial exposures to Russia&Ukraine www.the-american-interest.com/articles/2014/04/12/ukraine… << will it predict countries' reactions to UKR events?
-
François Heisbourg
@FHeisbourg
Turkish events remind me of May68 in France, not Arab Spring: conservative democratically elected leader out of touch with urban youth




























































































































































































































































































































































































































