Now Bibi plays the martyr in a crisis he manufactured.
Netanyahu responds: "I am ready to suffer personal attacks provided that Israel receives from the US the ammunition it needs in the war for its existence"
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Martin Sean Indyk (July 1, 1951 – July 25, 2024) was an Australian-American diplomat and foreign relations analyst with expertise in the Middle East. More on Wikipedia
Now Bibi plays the martyr in a crisis he manufactured.
Netanyahu responds: "I am ready to suffer personal attacks provided that Israel receives from the US the ammunition it needs in the war for its existence"
Israel is at war on four fronts: with Hamas in Gaza; with Houthis in Yemen; with Hezbollah in Lebanon; and with Iran overseeing the operations. What does Netanyahu do? Attack the United States based on a lie that he made up! The Speaker and Leader should withdraw his invitation to address Congress until he recants and apologizes.
Take note: while the rest of the world is preoccupied with Trump’s felony convictions, @POTUS Biden has put a clear choice before Sinwar and Netanyahu: accept a ceasefire-hostages exchange and end the war now. www.axios.com/2024/06/01/biden-gaza-hostage-ceasefire-dea…
Wednesday, May 22, 2024. I never thought I’d live to see this day when Israel’s government rejected a full-fledged offer of peace from Saudi Arabia, the leader of the Arab and Muslim worlds. Wake up Israel! Your government is leading you into ever greater isolation and ruin.
Martin Indyk reposted
I welcome the ICC prosecutor’s request for arrest warrants for Hamas leaders, Sinwar, Deif and Haniyeh, and for Israel’s PM Netanyahu and Defense Minister Gallant. Hamas leaders should be held accountable for the war crimes and crimes against humanity they undoubtedly committed on October 7th (which includes the crimes of extermination, murder, torture, rape, and taking hostages). Netanyahu and Gallant should be held accountable for the war crime and crime against humanity of “starvation of civilians as a method of war” during Israel’s war in Gaza -- there is at the very least “reasonable grounds to believe” that they have committed such a crime (Gallant announced on Oct. 9, 2023, "I have ordered a complete siege on the Gaza Strip. There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel"; ten days later Netanyahu stated, "we will not allow humanitarian assistance, in the form of food and medicines, from our territory to the Gaza Strip"). This is not about drawing a moral equivalence between Hamas and Israel. It is about upholding international law and holding decision-makers accountable. For a detailed analysis of these charges, see: www.justsecurity.org/95864/international-criminal-court-a…
Martin Indyk reposted
🧵 @IntlCrimCourt Prosecutor @KarimKhanQC just applied for arrest warrants for Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin @Netanyahu, among others.
Atlantic Council experts offer their verdict on the application and its implications:
www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/experts-rea…
You are right @elgindy. I wrote the tweet going on the prosecutor’s charges against Netanyahu, before I had seen the Hamas charges.
How does it let Hamas off the hook when 3 of its leaders face similar warrants?
I stand corrected. Thank you @howserob. I wrote the tweet before seeing the Hamas charges.
"let's Hamas off the hook?" W respect, 3 of the 5 charges are of Hamas leaders. Also, this is an ongoing investigation, and according to the Clooney, report more charges and charges of additional suspects are to be expected soon.
It is painful to see an Israeli Prime Minister - any Israeli prime minister - dragged before the ICC in this way. It is unfair and unjust, especially since it lets Hamas off the hook. But if you pay attention to the charges you will see that this is not about “genocide” but rather about the claim that Israel systematically failed to take care of the humanitarian needs of the Palestinian people. Netanyahu could have done a lot more in this regard - he still can. Even today Israel is blocking humanitarian aid flowing to Gaza. Why not let everything flow? It’s the right thing to do and it might just convince the judges to block the prosecutor’s harsh decree.
#icc Prosecutor @KarimKhanQC announces applications for arrest warrants in relation to Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant in the context of the situation in the State of #palestine ⤵️
www.icc-cpi.int/news/statement-icc-prosecutor-karim-aa-kh…
Smuggling under the Egyptian border into Gaza has been a big problem for decades. Guess who turned a blind eye?
@IsraelMatzav
50 humongous tunnels from Rafah to Egypt.
Any comments, Marty, on Egypt's apparent double dealing?
I have worked with Daniel Lubetzky since he founded the One Voice movement thirty years ago. I don’t know any other individual who has done more to promote Israeli-Palestinian reconciliation and moderation in Israeli politics. That he is now taking a stand against anti-Semitism on Columbia’s campus is entirely consistent with his efforts to build bridges between communities, something that should be applauded and supported. Go Daniel and your Kindness!
A few days ago, a news publication reported on a group of Jewish leaders that self-organized to fight antisemitism and expose the crimes that Hamas is committing not just against Israel but also against the Palestinian people and the world. That part is correct. Sadly in today’s era, inflammatory headlines and social media conspiracy theories get unleashed that have no support in facts.
The following facts are accurate and supported by the record:
Building Bridges to Overcome Extremism and Solve Problems Together is My Constant. I founded PeaceWorks Inc. 31 years ago to foster business cooperation among neighbors striving to co-exist in the Middle East. I co-founded the OneVoice Movement with my friend Mohammad Darawshe to help Palestinians and Israelis seize back the agenda for conflict resolution. Most recently, I co-founded the Builders movement to overcome “us vs. them” thinking.
I am proud of standing against all forms of hate and discrimination.
While most of my life that has meant my standing up for other vulnerable groups, Jewish students are now being harassed (called Nazis and encircled); prevented from going to classes and receiving their education; and told they cannot access public spaces because they are Jewish or Israeli.
This is a deliberate strategy from extremist groups that borrow dehumanization tactics from the most shameful periods in history – from when Blacks were not allowed to drink from the same water fountain in our own country just a few decades ago to when Jews were blocked from going to school in Germany and Austria in the 1930s and eventually degraded enough to allow Hitler to send them to death camps. This form of extremism, along with burning American flags or denying Israel’s right to exist, doesn’t just harm Jews and Israelis. It also harms Muslims and Palestinians that quest for peace and get painted negatively by radicals who purport to represent them.
Just as I would condemn hate & discrimination against anyone (Muslim, Christian or Jewish, Black, Brown or White) it is my — and everyone’s — responsibility to stand firmly against those who are bullying and systematically trying to stigmatize Jewish students.
A reporter that had access to thousands of posts from our group could not produce a single one that would substantiate any extremist accusations. Not only that, but the reporter deliberately avoided posts spotlighting cooperation between Israelis and Palestinians, and efforts to build bridges with other communities to fight extremism and all forms of hate.
NY Mayor Eric Adams spoke forcefully against antisemitism. Our community is grateful for his moral clarity and courage. We will show our appreciation and loyalty to him and all those that stand against all forms of hate. No amount of bullying or intimidation will make us cower. The opposite. Now more than ever, we will form alliances against all forms of hate, including hate against Jews.her communities to fight extremism and all forms of hate.
Finally Gantz begins to stir. But his positions and demands are convoluted and contradictory.
BREAKING: Israeli War Cabinet member Benny Gantz gives an ultimatum to Netanyahu and says his party will leave the government if the cabinet doesn't approve a strategy for the war in Gaza by June 8
Martin Indyk reposted
How sad: @washingtonpost goes all in on normalizing a 21st century-version of Protocols of the Elders of Zion by moving its news-less expose on “billionaires & business tycoons” from online to the front-page. @SallyBuzbee @JeffBezos www.frontpages.com/the-washington-post/
Netanyahu, what the hell are you doing with our country? www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-05-17/ty-article/.premiu….
But what Netanyahu is doing is perpetuating Hamas’s ability to regain control of Gaza not eliminating its control. Only a credible, legitimate alternative to Hamas - i.e. the Palestinian Authority - can replace Hamas. To claim it’s no different to Hamas is a lie.
Netanyahu, in apparent response to Israeli defence chief, says Hamas must be eliminated to pave path to alternative Gaza gov't - @Reuters
Glad to see the Aussies are rallying. Podhoretz went a step too far this time! Call me whatever names you like but don’t touch my Vegemite!
Ah, so it’s the vegemite that really upsets you! I’m going to go and have some on toast now. Maybe I’ll have two slices just to spite you.
Ah, so it’s the vegemite that really upsets you! I’m going to go and have some on toast now. Maybe I’ll have two slices just to spite you.
And a one state solution? Hamas’s and Smotrich’s wet dream.
Israeli PM Netanyahu: “Two state solution would be a reward for terrorists.” There you have it.
Clearly frustration with Netanyahu has reached boiling point within his own security cabinet as well as in Washington and Cairo. Something’s gotta give… (even though there’s radio silence from Eisenkot and Gantz).
💥#boom: DefMin Yoav Gallant just publicly demanded Netanyahu "make a decision and declare that Israel will not retain civilian control of Gaza, that there will be no Israeli military rule, and that an alternative to Hamas' government in Gaza Strip will be promoted immediately."
The camel’s nose under the tent. Israel proposes Palestinian Authority unofficially operate Rafah crossing. Let’s hope Bibi doesn’t allow Smotrich to block it. www.axios.com/2024/05/13/israel-palestinian-authority-raf…
Correction: this appears to be a mistranslation of what Bibi said…
Giving the finger to Israel’s closest allies who rushed to its rescue following the calamity of Oct. 7, a thankless Netanyahu invokes this lesson on the eve of (the 🇮🇱) Holocaust Memorial Day: “If we don’t protect ourselves, no one will…We cannot trust the promises of gentiles.”
Now Netanyahu is offending gentiles who care deeply about Israel. As I said before, he’s a clear and present danger to Israel.
Giving the finger to Israel’s closest allies who rushed to its rescue following the calamity of Oct. 7, a thankless Netanyahu invokes this lesson on the eve of (the 🇮🇱) Holocaust Memorial Day: “If we don’t protect ourselves, no one will…We cannot trust the promises of gentiles.”
U.S. put a hold on an ammunition shipment to Israel. This is a clear shot across Bibi’s bow as he talks about defying Biden’s opposition to a Rafah operation. The gloves are off! Hopefully more responsible Israeli leaders will intervene. www.axios.com/2024/05/05/israel-us-ammunition-shipment-hold
When Bibi needs help he doesn’t hesitate to run to Uncle Joe for protection. But when Biden needs help the answer is either “no my coalition won’t let me” or “maybe” with so many conditions and loopholes that it turns out to be a “no.” www.axios.com/2024/04/29/netanyahu-biden-icc-arrest-warra…
Now that’s interesting: Israel is now open to discussing "sustainable calm" in Gaza after an initial hostage release. In other words, Israel is open to ending the war if it can get the hostages back. www.axios.com/2024/04/27/israel-gaza-ceasefire-humanitari…
Benzi Gopstein earned his sanctions honestly. It's about the only honest thing he's ever done.
Violence by extremist settlers against Palestinian civilians is unacceptable. We’re sanctioning Ben Zion Gopstein - the leader of Lehava - whose members engaged in destabilizing violence. @USTreasury is also sanctioning two entities for fundraising for violent extremists.
I thought the United States was supposedly shoving Palestinian statehood down Israel’s throat? Bibi repeatedly lied to his people about that as this US veto of a UNSC resolution calling for recognition of a Palestinian state demonstrates. www.nytimes.com/live/2024/04/18/world/iran-israel-gaza-wa…
There are hundreds of thousands of Arabs who live in Jerusalem who are now under attack from Iran!
From what one can see on CNN, Iran’s drones and missiles are targeting Jerusalem! That has almost never happened before because of the sanctity of the Holy City for Muslims. Maybe Iran doesn’t value Al Quds in the same way?
From what one can see on CNN, Iran’s drones and missiles are targeting Jerusalem! That has almost never happened before because of the sanctity of the Holy City for Muslims. Maybe Iran doesn’t value Al Quds in the same way?
Biden keeps up the pressure on Netanyahu in some of his harshest criticism yet. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-04-10/ty-article/.premiu…
There you have it: “There is a date,” says Bibi; “there is no date” says his defense minister. Who are you going to believe?
🚨BREAKING: Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Galant told U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin during their phone call on Monday that Israel has not yet set a date for an operation in Rafah, according to a source with knowledge of the call
🚨The source told me Gallant said to Austin that Israel would have to carry out several necessary actions before an operation in Rafah, mainly an orderly evacuation of the civilian population and an increase in humanitarian aid
Here’s the perfect illustration of how Bibi tries to dance between the raindrops. Ben Gvir threatens to bring the coalition down if there's no attack on Rafa. But Bibi knows that Biden will oppose an attack on Rafa even by holding up arms supplies. So he responds to Ben Gvir that victory mandates the elimination of the terrorist battalions there. “That is going to happen; there is a date.” Of course he doesn’t tell us what the date is because in fact there is no date. What a piece of work!
Biden put his foot down and let it be known that if there were no change in Netanyahu’s policy, U.S. policy (on arms supplies) would change. Senator Coons (one of Biden’s closest friends in the Senate) announced he would support such “conditionality.” The carrot is Saudi peace.
Today Israel withdrew most of its troops from Gaza. The immediate ceasefire that Biden demanded is still being negotiated but this should seriously limit Israeli military operations to targeted interventions with a commensurate drop in civilian casualties. www.nytimes.com/live/2024/04/08/world/israel-hamas-war-ga…
Netanyahu announces “there’s a date” for the Rafah operation. It’s somewhere between bukra and mañana. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-04-08/ty-article-live/re…
U.S. makes a new proposal for Israel-Hamas hostage and ceasefire deal and, lo
and behold, Netanyahu is responding with new flexibility just like Biden demanded in his ultimatum. www.axios.com/2024/04/08/us-israel-hamas-hostage-deal-pro…
…/2 a pause to allow humanitarian aid to flow, humanitarian workers to return and a pause that does not allow for any large-scale military operation in Rafah. If military operations are not paused the arms flow will be conditioned, slowed, or halted…/3
What emerges from @BarakRavid ‘s report of Biden’s phone call with Bibi is that Biden demanded a “pause” in Israeli military operations while an immediate ceasefire and return of hostages is negotiated…/2 www.axios.com/2024/04/05/biden-netanyahu-us-support-israel
…/3 Between the lines Biden is telling Bibi he no longer has US support for the war he wants to fight and needs to bring it to an end once the hostages are returned…/4
…/4 The problem is this ultimatum is not clearly stated and Bibi will think he can get away with opening some passages into Gaza, firing two commanders, and ignoring the rest of the requirements. Biden has already begun to relieve the pressure by koshering Bibi’s initial steps.
What emerges from @BarakRavid ‘s report of Biden’s phone call with Bibi is that Biden demanded a “pause” in Israeli military operations while an immediate ceasefire and return of hostages is negotiated…/2 www.axios.com/2024/04/05/biden-netanyahu-us-support-israel
Who Still Believes in a Two-State Solution? My conversation with Foreign Affairs Editor Daniel Kurtz-Phalen about the current Biden-Bibi confrontation and other developments in the Gaza War. www.foreignaffairs.com/podcasts/who-still-believes-two-st… via @ForeignAffairs
As I read this, it sounded familiar. I’ve known Bibi since 1982. As the French say, “Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose.”
Just found this in my timeline from 2015 (Clinton emails). Still so true graphics.wsj.com/hillary-clinton-email-documents/pdfs/C05…
Martin Indyk reposted
Two senior officers were dismissed and three other senior officers (A Colonel and two Generals) were reprimanded, the IDF announced. The swift investigation and the subsequent decision to take disciplinary steps against top officers shows that the IDF is taking the incident more seriously than previous cases, as Israel faces intensifying global scrutiny of its actions in Gaza
🚨🚨🚨An IDF investigation concluded that the deadly strike on the World Central Kitchen convoy in Gaza was "a serious violation" of the Israeli military's rules and operating procedures. My report on @axios
www.axios.com/2024/04/05/israel-strike-wck-cause-investig…
Martin Indyk reposted
1/ From the IDF investigation of the WCK assassinations (I'll translate):
THE IDF admits that the vehicles were marked but says it was night time and they did not see the stickers. The IDF says that the convoy was cleared for traveling by all military authorities --->
An important first step but Israel should take the initiative in calling for establishment of an independent investigative tribunal with José Andres invited to appoint a WCK representative. It should be tasked with recommendations to ensure deconfliction. www.axios.com/2024/04/05/israel-strike-wck-cause-investig…
My interpretation of Biden’s ultimatum to Netanyahu:
1. Negotiate an immediate ceasefire and hostage swap by loosening your requirements.
2. Set up immediate, transparent procedures and mechanisms for protecting humanitarian workers in Gaza
3. Open the gates to humanitarian aid to Gaza and remove all restrictions so that aid flows freely from Israel.
4. And if you don’t do all this in the next few days I will condition military assistance to your war in Gaza.
5. Bottom line: Bibi is screwed. He will have to bring this war to an end.
We won’t have to wait long to see what Biden will do if Netanyahu does not respond to his demand for a major change in Israel’s humanitarian policy in Gaza. If Bibi doesn’t respond by dramatic moves to send everything he can through Israeli passages in the coming days, Biden will be required by his own rhetoric to take sanctions.
What to make of Biden’s call on Bibi for an “immediate ceasefire”? It is accompanied by a call on Netanyahu to loosen his demands of Hamas to achieve an agreement for a hostage exchange. It is not the usual call for a “pause” or a time-limited ceasefire. Biden wants a ceasefire now.
Kirby: there’s been a growing frustration (of Biden with Bibi). Kirby notes that the foreign military sales going to Israel now has been in the pipeline for years. Israel still faces threats from Iran. The current sales are not tied to the Gaza war.
Kirby: “we want to see more crossings open up, more trucks coming in, steps to avoid civilian harm, proper steps to deconflict with aid workers.” We need to see how they execute those policy decisions. “The President made clear that absent these changes and movement on a ceasefire that he will have to reconsider his own policy choices with regard to Gaza.”
How much time are you giving the Israelis? Kirby: We would like to see it in the coming hours and days.
WH spokesman Kirby: we’re looking for the execution of concrete steps on humanitarian commitments. If there’s no changes to their approach then there will be changes to ours.” Military aid? “Let’s see what the Israelis do.”
In readout by WH spokesman Kirby of Bibi-Biden phone call, “we want to see some real changes from their side. If not there will be changes from our side.” In coming hours and days “we’ll be looking for tangible changes from their side.”
In phone call with Netanyahu Biden also called for “Israel to announce and implement a series of specific, concrete, and measurable steps to address civilian harm, humanitarian suffering, and the safety of aid workers.” Biden said he would condition US policy on Gaza going forward on his assessment of Israel’s immediate action on these steps.
Biden tells Bibi he wants an “immediate ceasefire in Gaza” and a more lenient position in negotiations with Hamas to achieve a hostage exchange deal.
Those who know Dermer know that he yells when he doesn’t get his way. The UAE ambassador refused to deal with him during the negotiation of the Abraham Accords because he was so offended. Just the kind of diplomat Israel needs at this moment! www.nbcnews.com/politics/national-security/top-israeli-of…
Martin Indyk reposted
BREAKING: President Biden to speak with Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu tomorrow, a senior Israeli official says
“It is not a sign of weakness to feed strangers; it is a sign of strength. The people of Israel need to remember, at this darkest hour, what strength truly looks like.” Jose Andres appeals to the Israeli people to look beyond their own traumas. www.nytimes.com/2024/04/03/opinion/jose-andres-let-people…
After @POTUS Biden expressed his strong criticism of Israeli humanitarian policy in Gaza, Netanyahu cannot ignore his determined opposition to anything but a targeted operation in Rafah. Talks will continue; no Israeli action likely. www.axios.com/2024/04/03/israel-us-rafah-meeting-divisions
Bravo @AllisonKSommer in @haaretzcom: “The Israeli response stood in stark contrast to its reactions to previous humanitarian tragedies in the six months of the Gaza conflict. More than 32,000 people have been killed in Gaza since Hamas' www.haaretz.com/israel-news/haaretz-today/2024-04-02/ty-a…
It’s hard not to note the contrast between Netanyahu’s abject apology to Jose Andreas for the World Kitchen victims and his apparent lack of concern for Palestinian aid worker casualties in Gaza. www.nytimes.com/live/2024/04/02/world/israel-hamas-war-ga…
Jake Sullivan is off to Riyadh cos neither Biden nor MBS are ready to give up on Saudi-Israeli peace (or more exactly the U.S.-Saudi defense treaty that comes with it). Bibi will soon have to decide between a two state solution and his crazy coalition. www.axios.com/2024/04/02/saudi-arabia-israel-normalizatio…
Isn’t it amazing how Netanyahu claims that Hamas will benefit from anything politically untoward for him: UNSC anti-Israel vote-a reward for Hamas; early elections in Israel-Hamas will celebrate; US opposition to Rafah operation-Hamas the beneficiary.
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/netanyahu-hamas-woul…
Here’s @shiraefron ‘s @IsraelPolicy4m report that I referred to in my last tweet. Enlightening and creative. israelpolicyforum.org/a-humanitarian-plan-for-gaza-key-re…
@ShiraEfron from @IsraelPolicy4m has written a deeply informed policy assessment of how the PA can be integrated into Gaza aid efforts in ways that would serve Israel as well as the Palestinians. www.timesofisrael.com/integrating-pa-into-gaza-aid-effort…
It’s a clear decision by Israel’s Palestinian citizens not to go along with Hamas’s plans for the destruction of their lives. Netanyahu deserves some credit for keeping his crazies under control too, thereby demonstrating that it can be done.
A beautiful sight in Jerusalem.
The Waqf confirm 125,000 worshipers performed the third Friday prayer of Ramadan at Al-Aqsa Mosque in Jerusalem.
Hamas urged them to use violence. They did not.
Good Friday; the third Friday of Ramadan; Passover approaching - and a small mercy to celebrate
Martin Indyk reposted
NEW: During his visit to Washington, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant proposed establishing a multi-national military force with troops from Arab countries to improve law and order in Gaza and escort humanitarian aid convoys. My story on @axios www.axios.com/2024/03/29/gaza-arab-security-force-israel-…
Martin Indyk reposted
A significant escalation today in tensions between Netanyahu and the families of the hostages. The background is the decision made by Netanyahu to send a negotiation team to Cairo without a mandate to make concessions.
He did so against the advice of the IDF, Mossad, and Shabak. Netanyahu is also going against the votes of most cabinet members, including just about every Likud member.
The families are outraged at this. Therefore, they organized the largest protest yet today. Tens of thousands showed up.
There is a strong sense of frustration among them, feeling that Netanyahu does not want to end the war for his own reasons. Most hostage families have lost faith in his leadership as a result.
Einav Zangauker, mother of Matan Zangauker, who is a hostage, said, "We see now that you are the obstacle for a deal. We will call to remove you and replace you. We will hound you publicly, and we will not give up." There has been a lot of tension between them before. But this is the first time they have stated publicly that they want him replaced.
Considering how much sway these families have in Israel, this is dramatic. They are particularly influential in the Gantz and Eizenkott camp.
This is big news. The PA is about to end its “pay to slay” payments. That will constitute a big step in the “revitalization” of the PA. @JacobMagid has the details in this thread, including Netanyahu’s foot dragging on approving it, because he doesn’t want to lose a stick to beat the PA with.
🧵The Palestinian Authority is in the final stages of talks with the Biden administration about reforming its controversial welfare policy, which includes payments to terrorists and their families, a US official told The Times of Israel on Friday. (1/X) www.timesofisrael.com/pa-in-final-stages-of-talks-with-us…
An informed analysis of internal Palestinian politics by @Ibishblog that U.S. and Israeli policy-makers should not ignore. It’s all about who controls the PLO. www.thedailybeast.com/hamas-oct-7-attack-was-more-about-f… via @thedailybeast
Some free advice to @AmbDermer as he prepares to meet in Washington:
1. Try to avoid lecturing
2. Try to show a little humility
3. Try to find something to say yes to (like the PA in Gaza)
4. Don’t forget to remove the masking tape before you enter the White House.
Netanyahu’s childish flip-flop on sending his advisers to Washington indicates that he’s losing it. He claims he wanted to send a message to Hamas. The only message Hamas could have received is that there is a deep rift between the U.S. and Israel. That’s on Bibi, not Biden.
Some of Biden's senior advisers laughed when they heard Netanyahu's new stated reason for canceling the trip after the UN Security Council vote was that he wanted to send a message to Hamas
Deeply saddened by the passing of Joe Lieberman, our friend and political inspiration. Joe was a unique politician guided by a moral compass that he never swayed from. He will be sorely missed in these immoral times. May his memory be for a blessing.
A sad and disturbing tale from inside the Israeli-Palestinian protest tents at Stanford by @tab_delete Theo Baker. Worth reading.
"Loggins then asked the Jewish students to identify themselves. He instructed one of them to 'stand up, face the window, and he kind of kicked away his chair,' a witness told me."
A report from Stanford University, from @tab_delete:
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/03/stanford-israel…
Martin Indyk reposted
קריאת השכמה לכל הישראלים שקונים את הלוקשים של נתניהו: סקר מכון ״גאלופ״ מהיום מצביע שרוב בציבור האמריקאי (55%) מתנגד למלחמה שמנהלת ישראל בעזה, ורק 36% תומכים
New Gallup poll: “After narrowly backing Israel’s military action in Gaza in November, Americans now oppose the campaign by a solid margin. 55% currently disapprove of Israel’s actions, while 36% approve.”
Since Nov, approval ⬇️14 pts, disapproval ⬆️ 10 pt news.gallup.com/poll/642695/majority-disapprove-israeli-a…
A great mind has gone but Daniel Kahneman left us a lot to think about. May he rest in peace and may his memory be for a blessing especially for those who aspire to be thoughtful people.
Daniel Kahneman, who changed psychology and economics forever, dies at 90.
Thanks for everything.
We remember him in 10 great quotes:
In the annals of U.S.-Israel relations yesterday was a special day. Israel survived a U.S. abstention on a UNSC resolution. Defense Minister Gallant and his IDF strategic planners had high level consultations at the White House and Pentagon about Rafah and arms supplies. And Netanyahu sat like a child in the corner playing with his broken toys and advisers whom he had forbidden to speak.
Netanyahu’s cancellation of Dermers’ and Hanegbi’s trip to Washington is strictly performative. They are not military experts; they were instructed to be in listening mode only. The talks that matter are taking place at the White House now between Defense minister Gallant and his IDF advisers. Bibi doesn’t have the power to stop them. www.axios.com/2024/03/25/netanyahu-biden-white-house-cris…
A good example of the way that Israeli and U.S. officials are talking past each other. The Israelis feel so (understandably) aggrieved that they can’t hear what their best friend is trying to tell them.
A leaked memo by Assistant Secretary of State Bill Russo warns: "The Israelis seemed oblivious to the fact that they are facing major, possibly generational damage to their reputation not just in the region but elsewhere in the world." Via @ishaantharoor
www.npr.org/2024/03/22/1240148688/israel-gaza-war-state-d…
Non-binding in the sense that it has no consequences for non-compliance with its demands.
Why do you say the resolution is "non-binding"?
The linkage has been broken in NY but as a practical matter the U.S. is insisting on the linkage in the Doha negotiations for the release of hostages. But there should be no doubt: the U.S. is signaling Bibi that his house is on fire and he should not take the U.S. for granted.
Important to distinction to draw here, it called for immediate ceasefire and unconditional release of all hostages, but it did not condition the ceasefire on the release of hostages. As such, the resolution effectively calls for a ceasefire in exchange for nothing.
Pathetic.
What are your Qatari paymasters saying, Martin?
U.S. abstains on UNSC resolution; Bibi cancels consultations in Washington. Israel’s self-isolation is complete. The resolution is non-binding; it calls for a Ramadan ceasefire and the release of hostages; the U.S. abstained. Not good enough for Netanyahu. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-03-25/ty-article-live/hu…
Here’s the operative text of the resolution that Netanyahu objects to. Judge for yourself: “1. Demands an immediate ceasefire for the month of Ramadan respected by all parties leading to a lasting sustainable ceasefire, and also demands the immediate and unconditional release of all hostages, as well as ensuring humanitarian access to address their medical and other humanitarian needs, and further demands that the parties comply with their obligations under international law in relation to all persons they detain;”
U.S. abstains on UNSC resolution; Bibi cancels consultations in Washington. Israel’s self-isolation is complete. The resolution is non-binding; it calls for a Ramadan ceasefire and the release of hostages; the U.S. abstained. Not good enough for Netanyahu. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-03-25/ty-article-live/hu…
The shame is on you @AmbDermer. Israel had much of the world on its side on October 7 but you squandered the goodwill by failing to adequately address the humanitarian situation in Gaza. You were urged, warned, pressured and you’re still not doing what you should.
All those countries turning away from Israel now will look back at this moment as a mark of shame. After all those statements in support of the Jewish people when we're victims, you abandon us now, on the last leg before our victory against a genocidal terrorist force? Shameful.
My podcast with @dansenor
podcasts.apple.com/il/podcast/war-cabinet-member-ron-derm…
Go back to where you came from? A classic anti-immigrant trope. From the child of immigrants - what has happened to you?
Congratulations. Go back. You've done enough damage here.
That's funny. I renounced my Australian citizenship in 1993 when I became a US citizen - over 30 years ago. The rest of your usual ad hominem attack is just as accurate.
You speak for morally corrupt ex-officials who take blood money from Qatar to fund your ambitions. Also, you're Australian.
I don’t know who the @Conf_of_Pres imagines it is speaking for but it’s certainly not speaking for me, and I guess many other members of the American Jewish community. Senator Schumer’s remarks were courageous, timely, and correct. conferenceofpresidents.org/press/jewish-leaders-respond-t…
Exactly! They're speaking for settlers not American Jews!
They speak for me!
@Conf_of_Pres did an excellent job!
That's funny. I renounced my Australian citizenship in 1993 when I became a US citizen - over 30 years ago. The rest of your usual ad hominem attack is just as accurate.
You speak for morally corrupt ex-officials who take blood money from Qatar to fund your ambitions. Also, you're Australian.
I don’t know who the @Conf_of_Pres imagines it is speaking for but it’s certainly not speaking for me, and I guess many other members of the American Jewish community. Senator Schumer’s remarks were courageous, timely, and correct. conferenceofpresidents.org/press/jewish-leaders-respond-t…
Martin Indyk reposted
@PCPSR1 March 2024 poll shows that Palestinian support for Hamas drops in both the West Bank and the Gaza Strip from 43% in Dec 2023 to 34% now:
www.pcpsr.org/en/node/969
Accepting a Republican invitation to address Congress would be “brilliant,” destroying bipartisan support for Israel, deepening the rift with Pres Biden, provoking massive anti-Israel demos in Washington, and aligning Israel with MAGA isolationists. www.axios.com/2024/03/20/scoop-house-gop-weighs-inviting-…
I don’t know who the @Conf_of_Pres imagines it is speaking for but it’s certainly not speaking for me, and I guess many other members of the American Jewish community. Senator Schumer’s remarks were courageous, timely, and correct. conferenceofpresidents.org/press/jewish-leaders-respond-t…
This bragging by Bibi about going into Rafah alone is bull shit. The IDF and DefMin Gallant will not move without a US green light; Gantz/Eisenkot won’t approve the operation. I doubt Republicans will take on the onus for a humanitarian disaster either. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-03-20/ty-article-live/ga…
Score a big one for Biden. Despite Netanyahu’s braggadocio there will be no attack on Rafah. Instead Israel will send a team to Washington to discuss how to accommodate US concerns. x.com/i/broadcasts/1YpJkwqBWEmJj
The gloves are off and…the pot calls the kettle black! Bibi, the consummate liar, accuses Washington of spreading falsehoods! Meanwhile he falsely claims that Israelis support his government’s policies, which are the policies of Smotrich and Ben Gvir.
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/netanyahu-tells-aipa…
As @RichardHaass explains in this WSJ weekend essay, Israel’s war of necessity against Hamas left it with choices that all turned out bad. He argues that it needs to do better going forward. www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/the-war-that-israel-could-h…
This warning from Schumer, who is the de facto political leader of America’s Jewish community, gives Biden the pro-Israel backing he needs to proceed with confronting Netanyahu. The speech also created space for pro-Israel Democrats to oppose Israel’s right wing government.
Buried in @SenSchumer ‘s extraordinary speech is a clear warning: if Bibi remains in power “the United States will have no choice but to play a more active role in shaping Israeli policy by using our leverage to change the present course.” www.nytimes.com/2024/03/14/us/politics/schumer-netanyahu-…
But note how Israel’s opposition leaders are criticizing Schumer rather than Netanyahu. Afraid of losing center-right wing voters they have lost their way and their moral compass. Nobody needs them to parrot Bibi. Unless they come to their senses Netanyahu will win the next election.
Buried in @SenSchumer ‘s extraordinary speech is a clear warning: if Bibi remains in power “the United States will have no choice but to play a more active role in shaping Israeli policy by using our leverage to change the present course.” www.nytimes.com/2024/03/14/us/politics/schumer-netanyahu-…
Two more Israeli settler vigilantes were sanctioned today. Shane Bauer profiles Neria Ben Pazi.
The U.S. just announced sanctions against Neria Ben-Pazi and Moshe Sharvit, two Israeli settlers I recently wrote about for the New Yorker. These are two very dangerous men, but the sanctions conspicuously avoid targeting their Israeli state sponsors. Some thoughts and details:
Congratulations and Mabruk to Mohammed Mustafa on his appointment as Palestinian Prime Minister. Hopefully he will appoint a talented team of clean professionals to help him deal with the massive challenges he will face in reforming the PA and spreading its control to Gaza.
BREAKING: Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas appointed on Thursday the chairman of the Palestinian Investment Fund, Mohammed Mustafa, as prime minister of the Palestinian Authority and tasked him with forming a new government. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2024/03/14/abbas-palestinian-prime-minister…
Calling for new elections is calling for Israelis to decide. What's disrespectful about that? Especially when most Israelis agree with Schumer that there should be new elections. This is a man who has been by Israel’s side in every battle. He's trying to tell you your house is on fire. You should respect that.
Wow! Senator Schumer has no rival when it comes to pro-Israel credentials. His broadside against Netanyahu shows American pro-Israelis are with Biden not Bibi. www.cnn.com/2024/03/14/politics/chuck-schumer-israel-elec…
Schumer calls for new election in Israel and sharply criticizes Netanyahu
Israel’s main Hebrew newspaper, Yediot Aharonot, reports today that Netanyahu has rejected a detailed plan put forward by Defense Minister Gallant on behalf of the security establishment for a trained PA security force to enter Gaza to begin to assume control there.
Biden Administration is about to extend sanctions against Israeli settlers to their illegal outposts (illegal under Israeli law). More vigilantes will be added to the sanctions list too. Yossi Dagan beware. www.axios.com/2024/03/14/us-settler-sanctions-west-bank
Finally, after making life hell for Gazan civilians, Israel decides to flood Gaza with aid from entry points in the north. They could’ve done it weeks ago. Instead they caused a rift with the US and a victory for Hamas before coming to their senses. Sigh.
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/israel-will-try-to-f…
Perhaps but a small scale operation won’t take care of the problem in Rafah. Israel has a way forward but it requires a credible plan for protecting the 1.5 million displaced Palestinians in Rafah. That’s a huge challenge but a necessary one. Without it there’ll be a lot of chest beating but no action.
I predict there will be an (at first) relatively small scale operation just to appear like he is defying Biden, then testing how far he can go by gradually ramping up. I doubt Biden Admin has figured out at what exact point it will get tough...
Sen. Mark Warner, another long-time, genuine friend of Israel, speaks out against Netanyahu, warning that his policies are undermining long term support for Israel’s security.
Latest sign of rank-and-file Dems softening on Israel: "Sen. Mark Warner: Netanyahu’s war ‘threatens to undermine’ long-term support for, security of Israel"
jewishinsider.com/2024/03/sen-mark-warner-netanyahus-war-…
For all of Bibi’s braggadocio about his “red line,” there will be no IDF operation in Rafah without a “green light” from Biden and from Egypt’s Sissi. With a war with Hezbollah looming, the IDF cannot risk a cut off or slow down in US arms supplies or a confrontation with Egypt. And after Netanyahu’s failure to deal with the humanitarian situation in Gaza, he will have a hard time convincing Biden that he has a credible plan to deal with the 1.5 million displaced Palestinians in Rafah (Biden’s condition precedent). www.politico.com/news/2024/03/11/biden-may-condition-aid-…
Yes actually. During the 2013/14 negotiations the King agreed to play a role in the West Bank security arrangements. And Abu Mazen agreed to a NATO or US presence to ensure the Palestinians lived up to their security commitments.
I see. You expect either NATO or Jordan to take responsibility for making sure that the Palestinian state sticks to the terms. To your knowledge has Jordan said they would agree to do so?
And an unprecedented US-Israel crisis. Not bad for an organization about to experience “total defeat.”
terms for a temporary (6 week) gaza ceasefire was looking likely…until hamas decided against.
they’d rather israel face more outrage for continued fighting—and a ground war in rafah—during ramadan.
Fine but then you’re choosing never ending war and endless occupation of 6 million Palestinians. Please think about whether that's what you want for your grandchildren.
No. The military occupation has to end. But there can be an agreed failsafe mechanism that would enable the IDF to go back into Palestinian territories if the Palestinian government failed to act against terrorists.
With Israeli security control of all the area?
Israelis, please listen up. Bibi is lying. Noone is trying to ram a Pal state down your throats. Biden is talking about a pathway to an eventual, negotiated 2 state solution in which a demilitarized Pal state lives alongside a secure Jewish state of Israel.
Here’s the excerpt posted by Netanyahu to respond to Biden where he claims he has the overwhelming support of Israelis. That’s a dubious proposition given his low standing in the polls and the deep animus towards him among so many Israelis…/2
רוב הישראלים תומכים במדיניות שאני מוביל. הרוב המכריע מאוחד כפי שלא היה מעולם.
../2. Bibi’s response is a purposeful distortion. Biden never said Bibi was pursuing a “private” policy; he said his policies were losing Israel support internationally. Again, Biden said Bibi has to stop killing civilians; Bibi responds by claiming Israelis won’t support bringing the PA into Gaza (Biden never mentioned the PA)…/3
…/3. Biden talked about a peaceful future with Saudi Arabia; Bibi said he won’t let a Palestinian state be forced down Israel’s throat (as if Biden ever suggested that!). Bibi is clearly playing to his base, using Biden as his foil. Let’s hope Israelis will watch Biden’s interview rather than Bibi’s distortions and manipulations.
Netanyahu hits back at Biden in Politico (excerpts below). Note how Bibi distorts every Biden criticism. Biden says Bibi is damaging Israel’s international standing; Bibi says: the majority of Israelis support me (ignoring his low standing in the polls)..
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/in-response-to-criti…
Lindsay Graham tells @MeetThePress that Trump will support a forgivable, interest free loan to Ukraine. He didn't say whether the same condition should apply to aid to Israel.
Here’s Biden’s MSNBC interview last night about Israel and Gaza. Takeaways: 1. he is intending to get tough with Netanyahu. 2. An Israeli attack on Rafah is a “red line.” 3. He won’t cut Israel’s defensive weapons like Iron Dome (implying that he might slow offensive weapons if Israel crosses his red line). 4. He is thinking of going to Israel to speak to the Israeli public. 5. He hopes Israel will open passages to north Gaza from Israel. Bottom Line: Unless Netanyahu changes course a confrontation with Biden is coming.
At the same time as @netanyahu is failing in his obligation to provide adequate humanitarian assistance to Gaza — leaving the U.S. holding the bag — finance minister Bezalel Smotrich announced approval for 3,500 additional West Bank housing units on Wednesday bringing the total to 18,515 for this year - the largest ever for a one year period. Not the normal way strategic allies behave.
As for Rafah, there will be no green light for an attack on Hamas without a credible plan for protecting the 1.5 m displaced Pals there. Since there is no such conceivable credible plan there will be no green light.
So this is the Biden administration’s message: you can only attack Rafah if you allow more trucks in. As for what happens to the 1.3 million in Rafah, that is your business not ours.
This is very nice from @gantzbe but doesn’t capture the urgency with which the Biden Administration feels Israel must address the humanitarian disaster in Gaza. Let’s hope he’s going to act on that as soon as he returns to Israel. Otherwise there’ll be no green light for a Rafah operation.
I met yesterday with @VP Kamala Harris and US National Security Advisor @JakeSullivan46 followed by a series of other high-level officials in the Senate and Administration, and conveyed my profound appreciation for their support for Israel.
In the meeting, I iterated the imperative of completing the mission of removing the threat Hamas poses to Israel, finding a sustainable solution to ensuring humanitarian aid reaches civilians and not terrorist Hamas, and the importance of completing all of the operation’s military objectives in Gaza in a manner that enables stability and prosperity for the region entirely.
I added further the importance of forming as soon as possible an international mechanism to oversee the humanitarian effort in coordination with countries of the region and as part of the wider normalisation efforts.
I emphasised to VP Harris Israel’s supreme commitment to secure the return of the hostages and finally conveyed my gratitude for the significant pressure the US is applying to advance the matter, particularly during these days.
This is very nice from @gantzbe but doesn’t capture the urgency with which the Biden Administration feels Israel must address the humanitarian disaster in Gaza. Let’s hope he’s going to act on that as soon as he returns to Israel. Otherwise there’ll be no green light for a Rafah operation.
I met yesterday with @VP Kamala Harris and US National Security Advisor @JakeSullivan46 followed by a series of other high-level officials in the Senate and Administration, and conveyed my profound appreciation for their support for Israel.
In the meeting, I iterated the imperative of completing the mission of removing the threat Hamas poses to Israel, finding a sustainable solution to ensuring humanitarian aid reaches civilians and not terrorist Hamas, and the importance of completing all of the operation’s military objectives in Gaza in a manner that enables stability and prosperity for the region entirely.
I added further the importance of forming as soon as possible an international mechanism to oversee the humanitarian effort in coordination with countries of the region and as part of the wider normalisation efforts.
I emphasised to VP Harris Israel’s supreme commitment to secure the return of the hostages and finally conveyed my gratitude for the significant pressure the US is applying to advance the matter, particularly during these days.
Israeli minister criticized at White House over Gaza aid crisis. www.axios.com/2024/03/05/israel-gaza-aid-benny-gantz-whit…
@GahlBurt, White House Social Secretary to Ronald and Nancy Reagan in the 1980s, assesses what Nancy would have done if she were facing @FLOTUS Biden’s predicament today. Her answer is clear: focus on your legacy Joe, not your reelection. www.nytimes.com/2024/03/05/opinion/nancy-reagan-jill-bide…
Here’s a perfect example of the delusional thinking of @AmbDermer and his boss @netanyahu which produced the humanitarian debacle that killed over 100 hungry Palestinians. They contracted local businessmen instead of working with the PA and they could not control the situation.
על זה נאמר: בלי אמונה גם צסק"א לא היתה אוכלת אותה
Thursday’s debacle in northern Gaza that left some 100 Palestinians dead tested Netanyahu’s clan-based proposal for governing Gaza. Private Palestinian contractors from the clans were paid to deliver and distribute aid. It was a predictable disaster. www.nytimes.com/2024/03/03/world/middleeast/israel-aid-ga…
I was the first to come out publicly against extra-judicial killings when Israel first introduced it (look it up). But once Obama adopted it as U.S. policy I had no leg to stand on.
I don't doubt the veracity of this and I love critics of Netanyahu hitting him on security concerns, but if Netanyahu actually had Hamas leadership assassinated would you have supported that move? Sincerely asking.
I hear the VP is even more fed up with Bibi than @POTUS
Actually Gantz is a member of the government and a member of the inner War Cabinet. That’s ample justification for consulting with him.
It's dangerous stuff, waltzing with an opposition party leader. Something the USG otherwise studiously avoids as otherwise looks like meddling in internal political affairs of a sovereign country...
Biden should be able to do both at the same time. Either way he needs the cooperation of the Israeli leadership. Gantz should be able to help him with that since he can’t get Bibi’s cooperation.
There is another way to look at this: Instead stepping up as the leader of the most powerful state on earth to immediately end the starvation of children that his policy has enabled, Biden chooses to play a losing game of meddling in Israeli politics in the name of leadership.
Against the will of Netanyahu, @gantzbe is about to visit Washington for meetings with @VP Harris and NSC adviser Jake Sullivan. Bibi has ordered Israel’s ambassador to boycott the meetings. I wager @POTUS will drop by; might even invite Gantz into the Oval Office. Gantz is a member of Bibi’s War Cabinet. In polls, he leads Netanyahu by a wide margin.
Against the will of Netanyahu, @gantzbe is about to visit Washington for meetings with @VP Harris and NSC adviser Jake Sullivan. Bibi has ordered Israel’s ambassador to boycott the meetings. I wager @POTUS will drop by; might even invite Gantz into the Oval Office. Gantz is a member of Bibi’s War Cabinet. In polls, he leads Netanyahu by a wide margin.
What has happened to Israel?
Israel created a governmental vacuum in Gaza, Palestinian citizens in the north of the Strip are dying of hunger, hunger is also evident in the south. The result is chaos, which is probably what the Israeli government wants. Instead of taking responsibility and caring for the innocent citizens in Gaza and providing them with humanitarian aid as required - food, water, medicine, etc. Israel shirks this moral obligation and a situation is created where people are killed who all they want is to bring food to their family members.
Six times, Bibi declined to act!
In fairness, if those plans were anything like the botched attempt on Khaled Meshaal in Jordan, hard to fault Bibi for declining to act.
Even the strikes on Sheik Yassin & Rantisi in 2004 were contentious. Sharon likely declined to act more than once before moving on them.
Look where your right wing brilliance has landed Israel. A bit more humility and a little less hubris and name-calling might be in order.
In this @ForeignAffairs article by former Israeli PM Ehud Barak, he makes a shocking assertion: “Six times in the past 12 years [Netanyahu] has rejected plans proposed by the heads of Israel’s secret security agency, known as Shabak, to eliminate the Hamas leadership.” Yet more proof that Bibi was Hamas’s best friend. www.foreignaffairs.com/israel/israel-must-decide-where-it…
Former Israeli PM Ehud Barak argues for the urgent necessity of elections in Israel and acceptance of Biden’s plan for a two state solution (with a “but” related to security). He describes Netanyahu as “narcissistic, manipulative, and shortsighted.” Sounds right to me.
At a time of deep trauma, when most Israelis reject a Palestinian state, renown Israeli author David Grossman argues that the 2 state solution is the only way, albeit imperfect, for Israel to avoid the abyss of perpetual war and insecurity. www.nytimes.com/2024/03/01/opinion/israel-gaza-palestinia…
Deeply saddened at the passing of Lord Jacob Rothschild, a man of extraordinary philanthropic vision and a builder of great public institutions. Those institutions - the National Library in Israel, the Supreme Court building, etc will stand forever as reminders of his good works. May his memory be for a blessing.
The human race will then become one family, and the world will be the dwelling of Rational Men. Hail the light #rothschild #illuminati #masonic
Breaking News: Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammed Shtayyeh resigns opening the way for the appointment of a new Palestinian Authority government that can begin the revitalization project and hopefully spread its writ to Gaza.
Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh said he was resigning to allow for the formation of a broad consensus among Palestinians about political arrangements following Israel's war against the Islamist group Hamas in Gaza www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/palestinian-prime-minis…
Smotrich and Ben Gvir should be careful! If they keep up their settlement expansion and Jerusalem provocations they will inevitably be considered for U.S. sanctions. Their associates, like Yossi Dagan and Zvi Sukkot, will come under scrutiny too. Defiance of the US will have its consequences.
The scoop on the hostage negotiations from @IgnatiusPost: Israel and Hamas are inching toward a cease-fire deal www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/02/25/israel-hamas-c…
Smooth as silk, @netanyahu tells @margbrennan that 99 Knesset Members voted against an imposed Pal state. She pointed out that nobody in Washington is proposing that. He should ask the Knesset whether it opposes an eventual negotiated solution in which a secure Jewish state makes peace with a demilitarized Palestinian state. That’s what’s being proposed.
Fortunately Jake Sullivan is not bamboozled by Bibi’s “day after” draft.
11 \ Sullivan told @danabashcnn that Netanyahu hasn’t presented his Gaza day-after plan to the White House and stressed that after reading the press reports about the Israeli Prime Minister’s plan “I have concerns”
On Thursday, Netanyahu presented to the Israeli Cabinet his long-awaited draft for the “day after” in Gaza. Its first requirement is indefinite Israeli military occupation of Gaza, which will ensure Israel will be stuck there and no other country will come to its aid../2
4. As for the credible pathway to a two-state solution that the United States and Saudi Arabia are insisting upon, Netanyahu is ready for “direct negotiations without preconditions.”…/5
5. BUT he has already set a host of preconditions (no PA, deradicalization, etc). AND every minister in his ultra right wing coalition is absolutely opposed to direct negotiations with the Palestinians regardless of what his plan says. #trickybibi.
Netanyahu’s decision to green light Smotrich’s expansion of settlements, including to legalize another ten illegal settlements outposts (illegal under Israeli law), is designed to drive a stake through the heart of the two state solution…/2
www.nytimes.com/live/2024/02/24/world/israel-hamas-war-ga…
2. If Smotrich is not stopped it will be impossible to create a contiguous Palestinian state in the West Bank. Steps the Biden Administration could take without impacting Israel’s security include: labeling settlement products as made in occupied territory rather than Israel…/3
3. Extending sanctions to settlers involved in illegal outposts; linking Saudi normalization to an end to settlement expansion and the transfer of Area C land to the Palestinian Authority; and drafting of a new UNSC resolution condemning settlement activity.
Patience @GerardAraud. The confrontation is coming. You of all people should know that the US ship of state takes time to turn around. But it’s happening. Recently announced settlement activity cannot be allowed to stand if Biden is to be true to his commitment to the two state solution.
It is a hardening of the previous U.S. administration position but a timid one : “inconsistent with international law” is not yet “illegal”. Settlements in the WB are illegal.
Bravo @SecBlinken for reversing the Pompeo doctrine and making clear that Israeli settlements are inconsistent with international law. Next step is to change the labeling on settlement products. But none of that will stop Smotrich. The United States needs to start consultations at the UNSC about a new settlements resolution.
A clear, appropriate and vital statement from @SecBlinken: New settlement construction is counterproductive to peace, “inconsistent with international law” and “only weakens” Israel’s security. This is an important step forward.
Martin Indyk reposted
Israel's worst-ever govt wants to let country burn.The decision to restrict Muslims praying Jerusalem’s AlAqsa in Ramadan is the latest dangerous decision this horrifying govt has made.it was a chance to show war is vs Hamas not Palestine
www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2024-02-20/ty-article-o…
Thank you @aarondmiller2. Coming from you, it’s high praise indeed.
Terrific piece @Martin_Indyk on how the current crisis might over time produce a pathway to a more hopeful future. A great read with invaluable perspective.
“There is a complete disconnection between renewed international calls for a two-state solution and the fears and desires currently shaping Israeli and Palestinian society,” writes @Martin_Indyk. www.foreignaffairs.com/israel/martin-indyk-palestine-stra…
Mark this shift in U.S. policy toward UNSC involvement in the Gaza War: the Biden Administration is willing for the first time to use the UNSC to call for a pause in fighting, a release of all hostages, and a warning against an IDF assault on Rafah. It’s a shot across Netanyahu’s bow, signaling that he can no longer rely on the US veto in the UNSC. www.nytimes.com/live/2024/02/19/world/israel-hamas-war-ga…
Martin Indyk reposted
“There is a complete disconnection between renewed international calls for a two-state solution and the fears and desires currently shaping Israeli and Palestinian society,” writes @Martin_Indyk. www.foreignaffairs.com/israel/martin-indyk-palestine-stra…
Tilting at Windmills: yesterday the Israeli cabinet voted unanimously to reject U.S. unilateral recognition of a Palestinian state. Why the furor? The Biden Administration has no intention of granting such recognition. Its policy is to seek agreement from Israel on a credible pathway to an eventual two state solution. That question was not put to the cabinet because it will bring Netanyahu’s right wing coalition down. So Bibi invents a boogy man to distract his cabinet while stalling the hostage negotiations to make sure he doesn’t have to put the real question to them. #trickybibi.
No need to explain. The Palestinian prime minister is just copying the Israeli prime minister - seeking to ally with one-state extremists like Bibi has done with Ben Gvir and Smotrich.
Martin would "westsplain" that one away somehow.
Tricky Bibi @netanyahu is floating a way to avoid his agreeing to a two state solution: the U.S. rather than Israel will pay Saudi Arabia by recognizing a Palestinian state (under Israeli protest to protect Bibi’s coalition.) Bibi will agree to “direct negotiations without preconditions,” a decades-old Israeli position which can be interpreted as leaving the door open to a Palestinian state. In fact it commits Bibi to nothing and tries to repeat the Abraham Accords formula where the U.S. pays the Arabs for normalization with Israel (F-35s, recognition of Western Sahara, etc.)
I don’t believe Biden will recognize a Pal state at the beginning of the process but it’s good that Bibi is nervous about it. Learning that he cannot take the U.S. for granted will improve US-Israel relations.
Scoop: Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu told Secretary of State Tony Blinken last week that a direct or indirect U.S. recognition of a Palestinian state "would be a prize for those who planned and orchestrated the Oct. 7 massacre. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2024/02/15/netanyahu-palestine-statehood-bl…
Is Netanyahu posturing as a tough negotiator or throttling the hostage talks to avoid confronting his hard-line cabinet colleagues? Either way he is in no hurry to facilitate Biden’s efforts to get a quick ceasefire and hostage exchange. www.axios.com/2024/02/14/gaza-hostage-talks-netanyahu-egy…
Palestinian exiled leader Mohammed Dahlan makes his move into the spotlight just when others are looking to Marwan Barghouti to take over from Abu Mazen. My jaundiced prediction: Barghouti will stay in jail and Dahlan will stay in Abu Dhabi. www.nytimes.com/2024/02/14/world/middleeast/mohammed-dahl…
In a unique act of contrition, White House deputy national security adviser Jon Finer apologizes for the Administration’s lack of sensitivity to the plight of Palestinians. He also expresses deep skepticism about the intentions of Netanyahu’s government. www.nytimes.com/2024/02/09/us/politics/biden-aide-israel-…
Netanyahu’s insistence on absolute victory over Hamas, his dismissal of Hamas’s terms for a hostage swap and his downplaying of the importance of returning the hostages all suggest he’s no longer looking for a deal with Hamas. www.youtube.com/live/PIv2ylQkD88
But in his press conference after meeting with @SecBlinken he left the door open to the return of civilian rule to Gaza this time without mentioning the PA.
Over and over again Netanyahu defends extremist settlers instead of taking action against them, even at the expense of U.S.-Israel relations. Tells you all you need to know about his politics and priorities.
BREAKING: Netanyahu says he protested to Secretary of State Blinken during their meeting today about President Biden’s order regarding the countering of settler violence and told him it was “inappropriate” and “highly problematic”
Bibi is many things but he’s not stupid. Trump effectively called him a coward.
But does Bibi understand that?
Trump again demonstrates his animus towards @netanyahu, revealing that Bibi got cold feet about killing Soleimani. Those who think Bibi is waiting for Trump don’t understand that Trump believes Bibi betrayed him and will not forgive him.
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/trump-israel-was-par…
In the official State Dept readout of the Blinken-MBS meeting today there is no mention of the two state solution! Instead they seek “an enduring end to the crisis in Gaza that provides lasting peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians alike.” www.state.gov/secretary-blinkens-meeting-with-saudi-crown…
Trump again demonstrates his animus towards @netanyahu, revealing that Bibi got cold feet about killing Soleimani. Those who think Bibi is waiting for Trump don’t understand that Trump believes Bibi betrayed him and will not forgive him.
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/trump-israel-was-par…
A lot of wisdom here about the need for Israelis to wean themselves off Bibi’s lies. It’s the beginning of an important conversation that’s starting sooner than I expected given the trauma of October 7. www.haaretz.com/opinion/2024-02-01/ty-article-opinion/.pr…
Martin Indyk reposted
A deal in which Palestinian prisoners will be released, it is important to note that there are not thousands of murderers among them. There are 559 prisoners serving life sentences for murdering Israelis. Yes it is a lot but not thousands. According to my estimate there are currently about 10,000 Palestinian prisoners. Thousands of them are in administrative detention -they were arrested without charges and are in prison without conviction.
All true @Ibishblog but returning the hostages could swamp such calculations.
It would upend everything, but Hamas would take undue credit. Surely Israel wouldn’t release Barghouti unless it’s ready to sign a deal with him in short order, as with Mandela in RSA. Instead, Bibi is promising the full re-occupation of the West Bank and the end of Area A, even.
Now that would set the cat among the pigeons! Barghouti is by far the most popular Palestinian leader. Convicted of multiple terrorist acts, Bibi has refused to release him. Freeing him now will certainly “revitalize” the PA, just not the way we intended!
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/hamas-demands-releas…
Netanyahu rejects Biden’s extraordinary sanctioning of settler extremists saying “there is no room” for such measures. But if Netanyahu had stood up to the settlers rather than coddling them there would have been no need for Biden to act. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-02-01/ty-article/.premiu…
Oh hello @jpodhoretz. Haven’t heard from you for the longest time. Still pursuing your signature ad hominem approach I see. I guess it blinded you to my last sentence. As for ludicrous ideas, have you examined any of yours post 10/7? Some of my ideas were disastrously wrong (like most Israelis I thought that Hamas preferred to feed its people than kill the Jews) but others are making a comeback - viva the two state solution!
You will swallow any ludicrous idea or theory, as your entire career demonstrates
This is a bfd if Biden goes ahead. Every other hold out state (mainly EU) would follow making it all but unanimous and isolating Israel. Big question: Which borders would US recognize for the Palestinian state? US would have to treat Palestine as a state under military occupation. A big reward for Palestine before it undertakes any of the “revitalization” regarded as necessary for the day after. On balance the idea is premature imo. www.axios.com/2024/01/31/palestine-statehood-biden-israel…
This is a bfd if Biden goes ahead. Every other hold out state (mainly EU) would follow making it all but unanimous and isolating Israel. Big question: Which borders would US recognize for the Palestinian state? US would have to treat Palestine as a state under military occupation. A big reward for Palestine before it undertakes any of the “revitalization” regarded as necessary for the day after. On balance the idea is premature imo. www.axios.com/2024/01/31/palestine-statehood-biden-israel…
11 Israeli cabinet ministers and 15 other MKs signed a pledge at this rally to settle Gaza with Jews and transfer Palestinians from there. I called them crazy. The White House called them “irresponsible, reckless, incendiary.” Netanyahu calls them “bros.” www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/israels-far-right-plots-a-n…
Meanwhile, Netanyahu and his crazy ministers have precipitated a crisis with neighboring Egypt. Their talk of transferring Gazans to Egypt and settling Gaza is threatening the Israel-Egypt peace treaty. Instead of shutting them up, Bibi is sending his charming Mossad chief to Cairo. No substitute for wise leadership which is sorely lacking. www.axios.com/2024/01/29/israel-spy-chief-egypt-hamas-gaza
A well-informed guide to ambitious American diplomatic efforts to end the Gaza War and open a pathway to a two state solution. Note the floating of the idea of a UNSC resolution that would enshrine the two state solution in international law. www.nytimes.com/2024/01/27/world/middleeast/gaza-war-isra…
The Saudi head of the Muslim World League calls for joint Muslim-Jewish interfaith leadership to counter the hatred generated by the Gaza War. Bravo! www.economist.com/by-invitation/2024/01/25/a-muslim-faith…
So much for Netanyahu preferring to use Egypt as a mediator instead of Qatar. He has become such a captive of his ultra-nationalist coalition that he alienates everyone he needs to help Israel, from Biden to Qatar to Sisi. He is a clear and present danger.
Israel is reporting that Egypt's Sisi is refusing to speak to Netanyahu. They have not spoken once since October 7, which is astonishing.
Why is @netanyahu criticizing the Qatari mediator which is doing its best to negotiate a hostage/prisoner swap on Israel’s behalf? He says it’s because they fund Hamas. But he encouraged them to fund Hamas! And he needs their relationship with Hamas to get the hostages released. Typically, he’s just looking for someone else to blame.
We are appalled by the alleged remarks attributed to the Israeli Prime Minister in various media reports about Qatar’s mediation role. These remarks if validated, are irresponsible and destructive to the efforts to save innocent lives, but are not surprising.
For months, and following a successful mediation last year that led to the release of more than a hundred hostage, Qatar has been engaged in regular dialogue with the negotiating parties including Israeli institutions, attempting to establish the framework for a new hostage agreement and the immediate entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza.
If the reported remarks are found to be true, the Israeli PM would only be obstructing and undermining the mediation process, for reasons that appear to serve his political career instead of prioritizing saving innocent lives, including Israeli hostages.
Instead of concerning himself with Qatar’s strategic relations with the United States, we hope Netanyahu decides to operate in good faith and concentrate on the release of the hostages.
Martin Indyk reposted
New: Israel has given Hamas a proposal through Qatari and Egyptian mediators that includes up to two months of a pause in the fighting as part of a multi-phase deal that would include the release of all remaining hostages held in Gaza. My story on @axios www.axios.com/2024/01/22/israel-hamas-gaza-ceasefire-host…
NYT: The number of Gazans dying each day has fallen almost in half since early December and almost two-thirds since the peak in late October. This is a direct result of Biden’s arm around Israel approach. He deserves credit. www.nytimes.com/2024/01/22/briefing/israel-gaza-war-death…
Internal pressure from the IDF is building on Netanyahu to prioritize swapping hostages. But so far Hamas seems in no hurry. www.nytimes.com/2024/01/20/world/middleeast/israel-hamas-…
This US intel assessment reinforces Eisenkot’s argument that Israel cannot eradicate Hamas in any reasonable time frame and should focus on negotiating a return of the hostages for a prolonged pause instead. www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/hamas-toll-thus-far-falls-s…
I hope you’re right but the choice that Bibi faces is an invidious one for him personally so he will do his best to wiggle out of it with his usual combination of tricks, winks, and straight out lies.
I suspect @POTUS agrees with you. He might well be forcing Netanyahu to show his hand.
Yes or no?
Say yes unequivocally to two-stated, you lose your coalition. Say no, you lose the remnants of of international support and block the way to any vaguely acceptable post-war Gaza.
I hate to disagree with @potus Biden but he is falling for Bibi’s spin and shticks. @netanyahu is selling what he disparagingly refers to as a “state minus,” which is not an independent Palestinian state at all. It’s minus sovereignty, minus independence, minus territorial contiguity, and minus freedom from occupation. Don’t buy it, Joe!
Donald Trump told me in April 2021: "Bibi never wanted peace. He just tapped us along. Tap, tap, tap, tap..."
Biden yesterday: Bibi isn't against any kind of 2 state solution. It is possible to get it while he is in power
To @POTUS Biden, in case your very capable aides can’t hit the translate button: @netanyahu two hours ago: “I will not compromise on full Israeli security control over the entire area west of Jordan - and this is contrary to a Palestinian state.”
לא אתפשר על שליטה ביטחונית ישראלית מלאה על כל השטח ממערב לירדן - וזה מנוגד למדינה פלסטינית.
There’s a lot of wisdom in this thread from @UEvental. Even though you may have to use the translation tool to read it, you won’t be wasting your time.
10 מכות
שוב כל ראשי הבטחון מתריעים ושוב כל הנורות נדלקות, ושוב הממשלה וראשה מתעלמים, משיקולי בייס פוליטי, הישרדות ויעדים אידיאולוגיים לא ריאליים. כאילו כלום לא נלמד אחרי ה-7 באוקטובר. מדיניות הממשלה מנחיתה מכות ב-10 תחומי ביטחון, שיחד מייצרות נזק מערכתי כולל לביטחון הלאומי.
>>
I hate to disagree with @potus Biden but he is falling for Bibi’s spin and shticks. @netanyahu is selling what he disparagingly refers to as a “state minus,” which is not an independent Palestinian state at all. It’s minus sovereignty, minus independence, minus territorial contiguity, and minus freedom from occupation. Don’t buy it, Joe!
Donald Trump told me in April 2021: "Bibi never wanted peace. He just tapped us along. Tap, tap, tap, tap..."
Biden yesterday: Bibi isn't against any kind of 2 state solution. It is possible to get it while he is in power
Patience habibi. It’s Shabbat in Israel. Let’s see what happens when Shabbat ends.
Former PM Ehud Barak on Israel’s predicament: Israel needs an early election – before it's too late www.haaretz.com/opinion/2024-01-18/ty-article-opinion/.pr…
🧵@netanyahu ‘s argument that Israel must have security control forever “from the river to the sea” should not be taken at face value even if most Israelis in the wake of Oct 7 agree with him. It all depends on the security arrangements.
www.nytimes.com/2024/01/18/world/middleeast/netanyahu-pal…
6…Israel is dependent on the U.S. for its defense and deterrence. Taking help from the U.S. to defend against any possible threat from the West Bank is just what Israel did in Sinai and can afford to do again if it serves the cause of peace with the Palestinians.
7. Israelis in their traumatized condition understandably may take Netanyahu’s security claims at face value, but true friends of Israel should call them for what they are: Bull Shit!
We are now in a full-fledged US-Israel confrontation over the day after…in the middle of the war! I repeat: Netanyahu is a clear and present danger to the well-being of Israel.
💥Following Netanyahu's NO, NO, NO press conference, the White House says: "US will not stop working toward a two-state solution; there will a post-war Gaza and no reoccupation of Gaza."
Martin Indyk reposted
💥Netanyahu says elections would harm the war effort & that he has told the Americans he opposes a Palestinian state in any possible scenario.
💥Netanyahu boasts he allows only the "most minimal" humanitarian aid into Gaza & promises Israelis unending war. Asked about calls for elections: "Elections would be irresponsible. To tear people apart? Only Hamas & Iran want that & we won't give it to them." (& 75% of Israelis)
Hamas is back governing Gaza City! This is on Netanyahu.
In Gaza City, Hamas police have taken over again as the IDF thins out its troops. They are preventing looting. Meanwhile, Hamas authorities are bringing in aid trucks to supply markets. Israel refused to come up with a day-after plan: the day after is the return of Hamas rule.
Martin Indyk reposted
Eisenkot: “The State of Israel should ask itself after such a serious incident, how do we continue from here with a leadership that has failed miserably."
"מדינת ישראל צריכה לשאול את עצמה אחרי אירוע כל כך חמור, איך ממשיכים מכאן עם הנהגה שכשלה כישלון חרוץ". הנה קטע מתוך הריאיון עם גדי איזנקוט ששידרנו אמש - גם על הקריאה שלו ללכת לבחירות:
Wow! Eisenkot lays down the gauntlet to Netanyahu: “Israel is a democratic state that needs to ask itself after such a grave event how it continues from here with a leadership which has failed so completely.” www.nytimes.com/live/2024/01/18/world/israel-hamas-news/a…
If not now, when?
Eisenkot denounces Netanyahu on prime time tv. Could this be the trigger for a government upheaval? 🤞 www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-01-18/ty-article-live/re…
Martin Indyk reposted
💥Following Netanyahu's NO, NO, NO press conference, the White House says: "US will not stop working toward a two-state solution; there will a post-war Gaza and no reoccupation of Gaza."
Israel’s defense minister Gallant explicitly contradicts @netanyahu: "In the clearest way, a strong Palestinian Authority is an Israeli security interest, nothing less." www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-01-14/ty-article-live/id…
I think that’s already underway. But the demand for overall security responsibility is going to keep sucking the IDF back in, as you say. However, it will discover that the international community is not going to subsidize and facilitate its occupation of Gaza. At that point it will have to choose. But for that to happen there will have to be a viable alternative mechanism to maintain order in Gaza and prevent the return of Hamas. A credible international force and a “revitalized” PA with a trained police force will be essential. But that will take time to establish, probably 9-12 months. And in the meantime, that sucking sound will continue.
The wisest course is for Israel to get major forces out of Gaza as soon as possible and use special forces and limited means against those responsible for October 7. Anything else is going to lead an extra lead to this re-occupation, which would be Hamas’s big victory. Just go!
Last night Israeli defense minister Gallant laid out to the security cabinet the IDF’s plan for the “day after” in Gaza. It has four components: Israeli responsibility for overall security (including freedom to operate in Gaza); cooperation with Egypt to control and seal the Egypt/Gaza border; a U.S.-led international force to maintain order; and a civilian administrative structure based on local employees. Notably, Gallant declared there will be no Israeli civilian presence in Gaza.
5/6 Slowly but surely, Netanyahu’s bluster and grandiosity is giving way to the practical needs of a day after policy which Israel cannot meet without the support and cooperation of the United States and the international community.
6/6 Notwithstanding his opposition to the PA, I believe the next thing Netanyahu will do is find a way to hand over to Blinken the $75m of PA money that Smotrich is withholding, thereby helping to prevent the financial collapse of the PA. Watch for a package deal in which Abu Mazen appoints a new technocratic PM and prisoner payments are reformed, paving the way for Biden’s “Revitalized PA” to start picking up the pieces in Gaza.
In @netanyahu ‘s delusional “day after” plans he imagined he would block the return of the PA to Gaza and do away with UNWRA. But today an Israeli “political official” actually praised the work of UNWRA:
“We have a problem with UNRWA, which perpetuates Palestinian refugeehood. Israel will aspire to find an alternative.” Having said that, the political official noted that UNRWA would initially continue to administer civilian life in the Gaza Strip since, “Currently, they are doing positive work, maybe for the first time in the organization’s history. They are distributing food, water and medicine and they are the only actor that can do that at present.”
“The fringe chillingly edges toward the norm in terms of defining the long history of right-wing sedition in America.” Great review by CIA counter-terrorism expert Phil Mudd of @hoffman_bruce and Jacob Ware’s book “God, Guns and Sedition.” www.thecipherbrief.com/column_article/a-journey-into-far-…
The Economist too calls for Bibi to be sacked because he’s doing such a terrible job prosecuting the war and impeding regional cooperation against Iran. Trouble is neither of us have a vote! www.economist.com/leaders/2024/01/03/binyamin-netanyahu-i… from @TheEconomist
Violent, far-right, white supremacist extremism is a threat to us all. In this scary must read, my colleagues @hoffman_bruce and @Jacob_A_Ware unveil the dangerous world that lurks beneath the surface of our divisive politics. “God, Guns, and Sedition” - highly recommended.
📖 Out NOW: "God, Guns, and Sedition," a new book by @hoffman_bruce and @Jacob_A_Ware, explores the rise of far-right terrorism in the United States—and how to counter it.
Learn more and buy the book: on.cfr.org/47a1TQk
That’s true. But that’s because to do otherwise would have ignited the democracy movement on top of the “bring them home” movement and led to massive street demonstrations calling for Netanyahu’s resignation. He is above all a survivalist.
He accepted the ruling. Immediately. Reasonably.
Here’s a new development in the annals of U.S.-Israel relations. The State Dept is reprimanding ministers in @netanyahu ‘s government for promoting the resettlement of Palestinians outside their homes in Gaza because Bibi is refusing to do so. www.state.gov/rejection-of-irresponsible-statements-on-re…
@netanyahu is at it again this morning, with his divide and rule policy toward the Palestinians. His “day after” plan for Gaza is to build up local clans at the expense of the PA which he insists has to overcome humiliating conditions before he’ll allow it to play a role in Gaza.
Turning to local clans in Gaza is a throw back to the “village leagues” that Israel tried to promote in the West Bank in the 1970s. They were universally rejected by the Palestinians as collaborators.
Michael Oren, Israel’s former ambo to the US, says it best: The Oct. 7 attack undercut Israel’s claim that it would defend itself by itself. “Whether we liked it or not, we were dependent on the United States. And that meant they have a say in things.” www.nytimes.com/2023/12/31/us/politics/us-israel-hamas-wa…
YES!!! There are judges in Jerusalem: Israeli Supreme Court strikes down Bibi's controversial judicial overhaul law www.axios.com/2024/01/01/israel-supreme-court-judicial-ov…
What's wrong with this picture? Biden bypasses Congressional review to speed weapons to Israel while Netanyahu refuses Biden’s personal request to provide the PA with its own funds to prevent its collapse. www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/democratic-senator-b… via @timesofisrael
Martin Indyk reposted
#telaviv tonight: Thousands of Israelis are back on the streets protesting for @Netahyahu's ouster and new elections. NOW.
Martin Indyk reposted
💥Tonight brings the 97th consecutive poll (since March 16) in which Netanyahu's coalition is abjectly rejected. Were elections held today, Netanyahu's current coalition would win 45 out of 120 Knesset seats, and the anti-Netanyahu parties would win 𝟕𝟏.
Martin Indyk reposted
💥In response to @BarakRavid's revelation that Joe Biden finally let his temper loose on Netanyahu about Israel retaining Palestinian tax money, FinMin Smotrich declares thag Israel will continue to withhold Palestinian tax funds for "as long I'm in charge."
Scoop: President Biden held a difficult & frustrating phone call last weekend with Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu and asked that Israel release withheld Palestinian tax revenues. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2023/12/28/biden-netanyahu-call-palestinian…
Yet another example of how difficult @netanyahu is to deal with to the point of @POTUS Biden hanging up on him. Bibi prefers his alliance with Smotrich to Israel’s alliance with the United States! www.axios.com/2023/12/28/biden-netanyahu-call-palestinian…
Excellent analysis from @EhudYaariJLM and @Levitt_Matt on the internal tensions between Hamas military and political leadership. You won't read this anywhere else. www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/growing-inter…
Make up your mind @mdubowitz. Do you want Qatar to use its ties with Hamas to secure more hostage releases or do you want Qatar to cuts its ties with Hamas at which point it will have no leverage. You can’t have it both ways.
My take: President Biden issued an unusually terse statement after he spoke to the emir of Qatar on December 26 about the fate of the American and other hostages held by Doha’s Hamas partners. One hopes he read the emir the riot act. Americans are dying in Gaza dungeons, and every minute of captivity that passes not only endangers those still alive: It also bleeds U.S. credibility on the global stage.
So sad and yet so resilient - a powerful statement of national purpose behind bringing the Israeli hostages home. After I got through shedding a tear my next thought was “Bibi is toast.” Just imagine the impact of a thousand Israel musicians in a mass song to “send Bibi home!”
Homeland concert
The national flagship project for the return of the hostages
The biggest concert ever held in Israel
With 1,000 musicians gathered from all over the country
in the Caesarea amphitheater
with the hostages families
In a mass prayer for their return home
#homelandconcert
#קונצרטמולדת
#bringthemhomenow
talya.yarom.event.maker
A critical element in”day after” planning: Palestinians must be a part of any post-war Gaza peacekeeping force www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/12/28/gaza-peacekeep…
Oh the grandiosity! @Netanyahu imagines Israel can eradicate Hamas, demilitarize Gaza, and remake Palestinian society in Israel’s image. And to do so, “for the foreseeable future Israel will have to retain overriding security responsibility over Gaza.” www.wsj.com/articles/benjamin-netanyahu-our-three-prerequ…
I wonder how many Israelis are actually ready to sign up for the indefinite reoccupation of Gaza until the minds of Gazans have been “deradicalized.” I don’t believe Joe Biden or any Arab leader will be willing to do so.
Martin Indyk reposted
1 \ Egypt gave Israel and Hamas on Saturday night a proposal for relaunching talks on a three-phase deal to secure release of hostages held by Hamas in Gaza, two Israeli officials told me
Some sober advice for Israelis from Jeremy Isaacharoff, former senior Israeli diplomat and key player in the Abraham Accords. blogs.timesofisrael.com/ultimately-an-israeli-victory-res…
The NYT provides back up to what I “X’d” yesterday: “Israel says it has achieved operational control in some areas in the north, but the grinding progress is leading some prominent Israeli military analysts and political commentators to point to a widening gap between the reality on the ground and the rhetoric of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who pledged on Wednesday that the war “will continue until Hamas is eliminated — until victory.”
www.nytimes.com/2023/12/22/world/middleeast/israel-gaza-e…
Amid all the controversy about the Palestinian Authority returning to Gaza, it’s worth remembering that it never actually left. Since 2007, when Hamas took over in a military coup, the PA has continued to pay one-third of its budget to Gaza for water and electricity (provided by Israel) and to pay the salaries of some 37,000 PA employees, including 19,000 policemen in Gaza. It’s unclear what they’ve been doing since 2007 but there appears to be a cadre of technocrats and civil servants in Gaza that already work for the PA.
Here’s the first sign that @netanyahu is preparing to give in to @POTUS Biden’s demand that the Palestinian Authority take control in Gaza. One aide tells the Saudi media that he’s prepared to agree, while another tells a domestic audience it won’t happen. www.nytimes.com/live/2023/12/21/world/israel-hamas-war-ga…
Watch next how Bibi starts to level conditions and requirements on the PA which will sound reasonable (no incitement, no pay-to-slay, etc) but which will be designed to set up the PA for failure. Fortunately, Biden and his advisers are all too aware of Bibi’s shticks by now.
What’s needed is a “revitalized” Palestinian Authority that is capable of and committed to meeting the needs of its people, not one that’s seen to be jumping through Bibi’s hoops. Of course it should reform its prisoner payments system. There’s reason to believe it’s ready to do so. But not on demand from Netanyahu.
Former PM Ehud Olmert has reached the same conclusion: “It's decision time. A cease-fire with living hostages, or a forced cessation of hostilities with dead ones.” www.haaretz.com/opinion/2023-12-22/ty-article-opinion/.pr…
Today is a turning point in Israel when leading journalists (Barnea, Bergman, Caspit etc.) tell the Israeli public what @netanyahu will not tell them: that Hamas is bruised but will not be defeated and the best that can be done now is to negotiate a return of the hostages at a high price.
And Bibi @Netanyahu too! Only new leadership in Israel and Palestine can generate hope for eventual reconciliation. But neither Bibi nor Abu Mazen will go quietly into the night. It will take mass movements on both sides to demand that they leave, now! www.nytimes.com/2023/12/21/opinion/palestine-leadership-w…
And it now turns out that @Netanyahu sold Israeli commitments to the Oslo Accords on false pretenses designed to lead to the dissolution of any hope for a Palestinian state. So who’s zoomin whom? There were people of good faith on BOTH sides who sought genuine peace. They were betrayed by their leaders.
The PLO sees its recognition of Israel’s right to exist as completely compatible with its demands that, in effect, will lead to the dissolution of Israel.
This is how the PLO sold Oslo to the Palestinian people.
What I love about people like @RationalSettler is that he is so quick to assert that the PA/PLO lies about their real intentions toward Israel when his hero @netanyahu just admitted that he lied for years about his true intentions toward the Palestinians! There's a black kettle here.
This is a classic half-truth.
The “Oslo peace processors” got Arafat to recognize Israel, but not as a Jewish state.
The Palestinian plan all along has been to return millions of Palestinians to Israel and simply use Israel’s democracy to vote it into a Palestinian state.
What are you missing? Did you know that as part of Oslo the PLO (and its offshoot the PA) formally recognized Israel’s right to exist - not its existence but it's right to exist. They have never renounced that recognition.
This makes Bibi seem reasonable. If Palestinians would admit Israel should exist, then on this logic these Palestinians would get a state. And not until then. That just seems to be the reality of the situation. What am I missing?
Half-truth? You obviously are not aware that the demand for the Palestinians to recognize Israel as a Jewish state came more than a decade after the PLO had recognized Israel’s right to exist. It was introduced as a new demand by Tzipi Livni when she headed the negotiations with the Palestinians around 2006. Prior to that Israel never required Egypt, Jordan or the PLO to recognize Israel as a Jewish state. Israel moved the bar.
This is a classic half-truth.
The “Oslo peace processors” got Arafat to recognize Israel, but not as a Jewish state.
The Palestinian plan all along has been to return millions of Palestinians to Israel and simply use Israel’s democracy to vote it into a Palestinian state.
What are you missing? Did you know that as part of Oslo the PLO (and its offshoot the PA) formally recognized Israel’s right to exist - not its existence but it's right to exist. They have never renounced that recognition.
This makes Bibi seem reasonable. If Palestinians would admit Israel should exist, then on this logic these Palestinians would get a state. And not until then. That just seems to be the reality of the situation. What am I missing?
By the way, the United States supported Livni’s demand and it was incorporated into the Kerry principles in 2014 when I was heading up the negotiations.
What are you missing? Did you know that as part of Oslo the PLO (and its offshoot the PA) formally recognized Israel’s right to exist - not its existence but it's right to exist. They have never renounced that recognition.
This makes Bibi seem reasonable. If Palestinians would admit Israel should exist, then on this logic these Palestinians would get a state. And not until then. That just seems to be the reality of the situation. What am I missing?
I’m deeply grateful for @AmboRudd for this honor. As I told him today, to the extent that I have been successful in my career, I owe a great debt to the country that nurtured and educated me, taught me to speak truth to power, to see the world from a different perspective, and to speak with an Aussie accent!
I had the honour today of presenting an Honorary Order of Australia medal to a giant of international affairs, @Martin_Indyk. He is unparalleled in his contributions to the Australian foreign policy community, and to deepening the connection between the 🇺🇸 and 🇦🇺.
So proud today to be invested into the Order of Australia by Ambassador Kevin Rudd on behalf of the Governor General of Australia.
After my investiture as a member of the Order of Australia with Australian Ambassador Kevin Rudd and my wife Gahl.
There @netanyahu goes again: last night he reiterated his position that he would not allow the PA to govern the Gaza Strip after the war. “I will not allow the State of Israel to repeat the critical mistake of Oslo, which brought to the heart of our land—and to Gaza—the most extreme elements in the entire Arab world, who are committed to the destruction of the State of Israel and who teach that goal to their children.”
But now Oslo and the PA are back, resurrected by the U.S., Israel’s only friend in this crisis, and the Sunni Arab leaders, who will not support any of Bibi’s delusional day after schemes.
If Bibi sticks to his guns, Israel will have to reoccupy Gaza, run it and pay for it in the face of opposition from the US, and the Arab states. It's not sustainable. If Biden stands his ground, Netanyahu will cave.
Full interview in English with Jake Sullivan and @LeviYonit from Israel TV last night, clearly explaining US strategy toward the Gaza war. Israelis should be grateful that while their leadership is playing politics there’s an American adult in the room looking out for their interests.
Full interview with @jakejsullivan on @N12News
Hallelujah! Israel "likely" to open Gaza-Israel crossing to allow more aid into enclave. Better late than never but why doesn’t Israel take the humanitarian initiative rather than be dragged into it by the United States? www.axios.com/2023/12/12/gaza-humanitarian-aid
He can’t. It provides for a Palestinian state. It’s opposed by his coalition. Moreover at the time he did not accept the Trump plan because significant parts of the Likud, under the influence of the settler lobby, opposed it too.
What if Netanyahu accepts the Trump Plan?
The UAE’s position of no aid for the rehabilitation of Gaza without a clear road map to a two state solution is the Arab, U.S. and EU consensus. If Netanyahu refuses this, Israel will be left alone to pay for Gaza’s rehabilitation. It’s only a matter of time before Bibi caves or his government collapses.
The United Arab Emirates announces that it will condition its financial and political support for the reconstruction of Gaza after the war on the advancement of a US-backed initiative toward a two-state solution. (1/5)
Yawn. We delivered the Israel-Jordan Peace Treaty. We delivered the Wye Plantation agreement in which Netanyahu handed over 13% of the West Bank to Arafat. Above all we delivered the Clinton Parameters which provide the framework for the two state solution. And what did you do?
Correction: Netanyahu spoke hours before Biden, again ruling out a PA role in Gaza. Biden was responding to Bibi’s rejection by telling him to change his government whose far-right members want to destroy the PA not revitalize it.
Netanyahu’s response to Biden’s call for him to change his government so that Israel can be more open to a two-state solution: “Gaza will neither be Hamastan nor Fatahstan.” That leaves open only one other possibility: Israelistan. Good luck with that! www.axios.com/2023/12/12/biden-netanyahu-hamas-israel-cri…
Netanyahu’s response to Biden’s call for him to change his government so that Israel can be more open to a two-state solution: “Gaza will neither be Hamastan nor Fatahstan.” That leaves open only one other possibility: Israelistan. Good luck with that! www.axios.com/2023/12/12/biden-netanyahu-hamas-israel-cri…
BREAKING: Biden: Netanyahu needs 'to change' coalition, Israel is starting to 'lose support' around world
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/biden-netanyahu-need…
Signs of revival of hostage negotiations. It seems the Qataris want to test whether Israeli military pressure has changed Hamas’s calculus. Israel seems to be all in favor. Stay tuned…
1 \ Qatari mediators contacted Israel over the weekend to check if it is interested in relaunching indirect talks with Hamas over a new deal to secure release of Israeli hostages held in Gaza, two Israeli sources told me
Does the Pentagon regret Qatari funding for the largest U.S. air base in the ME? Do Cornell and Georgetown SFS regret Qatari funding for their campuses in Doha? Qatar provided Brookings with funding to set up a think tank in Doha to promote policy-relevant research on the ME. Today’s NYT story is about Netanyahu seeking Qatari funding to support Hamas’s rule in Gaza. Apples and oranges.
Yes, Israel needs new leadership. But let’s talk about those apples: Do you regret taking millions of dollars for Brookings from an Islamist government that secretly funds Hamas’s military wing responsible for horrific violence (“Separately, Israeli intelligence has long assessed that Qatar uses other channels to secretly fund Hamas’ military wing…”www.nytimes.com/2023/12/10/world/middleeast/israel-qatar-…), incited violence against Americans and Israelis and antisemitism through its Al Jazeera propaganda arm, and hosted one of the masterminds of 9/11 (KSM) and Hamas leaders? Why your silence regarding Qatar’s policies while blaming Israel for allowing it?
Apples and oranges @mdubowitz. At least we agree that Netanyahu made a huge mistake. I hope we also agree that he needs to be held accountable. Job one for every prime minister is to protect the citizens of his country. He needs to resign.
Agreed. Netanyahu made a huge mistake.
But Qatar and Brookings signed an agreement in 2017 that netted the think tank millions of dollars in foreign government funding. Now, who led that effort on behalf of Brookings? www.mofa.gov.qa/en/all-mofa-news/details/2017/05/15/qatar…
Another must read investigative blockbuster from @MarkMazzettiNYT and @ronenbergman skewering @netanyahu for his years-long funding of Hamas via Qatar. He needs to resign before he does even more damage to Israel. www.nytimes.com/2023/12/10/world/middleeast/israel-qatar-…
Netanyahu Must Be Politically Destroyed, or Israel Will Go Down With Him. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-12-10/ty-article/.premiu…
Yes it’s personal because I have seen up front over many years of dealing with him personally just what a danger @netanyahu is to the US-Israel relationship. Go ahead and dismiss my informed opinion but you can’t dismiss the facts (read the NYT article).
Netanyahu does need to resign along with military and intelligence leadership. But your obsession with BIbi is personal and not based on what’s good for Israel.
I would agree with you if @netanyahu wasn’t currently causing a rift with Joe Biden, Israel’s only friend in this crisis. His determination to stay in power no matter the cost is a clear and present danger to Israel. He needs to resign…yesterday!
Skewer, skewer, skewer. Leaders have been known to make grievous errors. How many hit jobs can you deliver while Israel fights for its life?
Another must read investigative blockbuster from @MarkMazzettiNYT and @ronenbergman skewering @netanyahu for his years-long funding of Hamas via Qatar. He needs to resign before he does even more damage to Israel. www.nytimes.com/2023/12/10/world/middleeast/israel-qatar-…
Every night now, Netanyahu lectures Israelis on the need to maintain Israel’s indefinite occupation of Gaza after the fighting is over. Here’s last night’s braggadocio: “Once the war is over, Israel will have to guarantee that the Gaza Strip is demilitarized. Only one force can guarantee that: the IDF. No international force can be responsible for that. I won’t shut my eyes and I won’t accept any other arrangement.”
Finally, settler vigilantes will pay a price for their violent efforts to uproot West Bank Palestinians. I hope their Israeli government sponsors will not be allowed to fly either. www.state.gov/announcement-of-visa-restriction-policy-to-…
Yup. That’s Bibi’s position, dictated by ultra-right wing coalition partners and his own delusions. We’ll see how long it lasts when he discovers he’s stuck in Gaza and responsible for paying the bills.
💥Prime Minister Netanyahu, in private conversations last week with Knesset members AND with American officials, said, "not only will there not be a renewed Palestinian Authority in Gaza after the war– there will be no Palestinian Authority in Gaza at all."
Do you have a choice?
Do you trust the PA?
Last night @netanyahu again rejected the PA’s role in day after Gaza. “We will need something else,” he declared. What is that? Does he believe he can conjure up a docile Palestinian leadership willing to do his bidding in Gaza? And who will pay for it? Israel’s PM is delusional.
Martin Indyk reposted
How would Kissinger solve the Israel-Hamas war today? Incrementally, @Martin_Indyk writes in a guest opinion. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/30/kissinger-isra…
Say what you like about the passing of Henry Kissinger - and I see that the Henry-Haters are having a field day on social media - he was a man of history and a student of history, a refugee from chaos and a lifelong pursuer of order. Master of the Game of diplomatic manipulation, deeply insightful about the state of the world, his wise counsel was sought by princes, potentates, autocrats and Democrats. He went out in a blaze of glory and to make sure we would remember him he left us all his books! Rest in peace, Henry. I for one will miss you greatly.
Exactly.
Meaning that Bibi would dismiss PA efforts against terrorists as insignificant compared to results, while simultaneously insisting that Israel's targeting should only be judged on effort to avoid civilian deaths, instead of on results.
My take on how Kissinger would have dealt with the Israel-Hamas war: Incrementally. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/30/kissinger-isra…
I had to chuckle when I heard @SecBlinken just now: “The way Israel defends itself matters. As I told the PM, intent matters, but so do results.” It reminded me of how Bibi would lecture us that 100% Palestinian efforts on security didn’t matter. He demanded 100% results!
On October 5, I had the opportunity to interview Henry Kissinger about his take-aways from the 1973 Yom Kippur War at a 50th anniversary symposium at the Council on Foreign Relations. One of his last interviews. Worth watching for his insights - at 100 he was still going strong.
Martin Indyk reposted
Whatever my personal view of Kissinger, I looked at the prism through which he was seeing the world.
And in 1971, he was single-mindedly focused on China. But he underestimated how much Beijing wanted rapprochement w/ the US & overestimated how much China cared about Pakistan.
For further insight into this topic, it can be helpful to read @tanvi_madan’s excellent 'Fateful Triangle: How China Shaped US-India Relations During the Cold War'.
Another must-read.
@IgnatiusPost wrote this column today based on an insider briefing from the Doha negotiations. It confirms that they are aiming for a bigger pause for hostages deal, the logic for which I laid out in my earlier 🧵. They just might get it. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/28/qatar-hostage-…
As negotiations on extending the Israel-Hamas pause begin in Doha, some preliminary observations:
1. Hamas remains in control in Gaza capable of enforcing the ceasefire on all the other terrorist groups, including PIJ.
7. How far both sides will be prepared to go in trading hostages and prisoners for the pause is about to be tested but the pressures and incentives for both to stick with it are at the moment stronger than the incentives to go back to war.
8. The time could be ripe for a larger swap deal.
Congratulations @BarakRavid on a well-deserved appointment. We viewers of CNN will now be the beneficiaries of your exceptional Washington scooping skills.
BREAKING: Some personal and exciting news. I want to thank @CNN for their trust and my editors at @axios and @WallaNews for their support and faith in me
Note this report well 👇. Netanyahu is playing politics with the U.S.-Israel relationship at a moment when Israel is totally dependent on the U.S. for the prosecution of this war. His hubris threatens Israel. www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/pm-lobbying-likud-mk… via @timesofisrael
One minor side benefit of this horrendous crisis: Israel is openly hosting an official Qatari delegation for the first time in some 25 years (Israel and Qatar used to have economic offices in the 1990s but Qatar closed its office down after the outbreak of the Intifada.)
I stand corrected. Jake Sullivan just told Dana Bash @cnn that Red Cross visits are part of the deal while expressing doubt that Hamas will comply.
Last week Netanyahu leaked during the cabinet deliberations that he had secured Red Cross access to the remaining hostages as part of the deal. That was a big deal. Turns out it was just Bibi spin. He had demanded access but it is not part of the agreement.
Martin Indyk reposted
BREAKING: White House national security adviser Jake Sullivan tells NBC @kwelkernbc: We have reason to believe that at least one Amercian held by Hamas. will be released today. We hope Abigail Edan will be released but we can't know for sure until it happens
Last week Netanyahu leaked during the cabinet deliberations that he had secured Red Cross access to the remaining hostages as part of the deal. That was a big deal. Turns out it was just Bibi spin. He had demanded access but it is not part of the agreement.
Four cheers for @POTUS Biden! This hostage release deal is brilliantly structured to meet America’s strategic and humanitarian objectives and the needs of Israelis and Palestinians. It’s a rare feat in the annals of ME deal-making. BRAVO!
www.youtube.com/live/yEP4MRM05zs via @YouTube
Martin Indyk reposted
💥#breaking: @IDFSpokesperson says the hostages have arrived in Israel.
🧵While the hostage families wait anxiously, Bibi resorts to his standard playbook:
1. Drag out the cabinet deliberations to show how difficult it is to get his ministers to agree even though he already has a majority…
2. In the meantime leak from the Cabinet room that the Red Cross will have access to the remaining hostages so he can claim an additional achievement (which it is).
3. Claim that he hung tough to get a better deal at a lower price.
4. Give Biden credit for getting the better deal so the administration can't complain about the wringer he has put them through on every little detail.
5. Minimize the concessions he made by emphasizing that the war will go on even as he implements the ceasefire.
6. Why not just let others give him credit for a tough and courageous decision? Because he has staked his reputation on not being a “freier” in negotiations with the Palestinians - “I won’t give unless I get” has been his campaign motto since 1996!
“I’m not capable of sobering up from the prospect of establishing peace.” A clarion call from @AyOdeh that provides a shining beacon of hope in these darkest hours of Israeli-Palestinian conflict. www.haaretz.com/opinion/2023-11-20/ty-article-opinion/.pr…
If you want to understand the IDF strategy for the next phase of the war in Gaza, you should read this report by @IgnatiusPost based on interviews with top defense officials in Israel.
Opinion by David Ignatius: A change of course is coming to a campaign that has yielded military gains at immense cost to civilians. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/18/israel-gaza-wa…
Boker Tov! Surely all can now see that one state solutions are only recipes for continuing the conflict in horrific and previously unimaginable ways. The two state solution is the ONLY way to end the conflict. Two states for two people, living separately.
Dmitry Shumsky, one of Israel’s most original left-wing political thinkers in @haaretzcom on why the October 7 Hamas attack ended the binational one-state delusion leaving only the two-state solution as a just and realistic solution to the conflict www.haaretz.com/opinion/2023-11-17/ty-article-opinion/.pr…
Interested in “day after” scenarios? Here’s a creative proposal from Nathan Brown and @HamzawyAmr for a realistic Arab role. I think a Saudi-US-led initiative with Arab state endorsement is likely to be more effective but the API II framework provides a constructive basis.
My colleagues Nathan Brown & @HamzawyAmr offer a more innovative proposal for diplomacy than we’ve seen in years:
Arab Peace Initiative II: How Arab Leadership Could Design a Peace Plan in Israel and Palestine - Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
carnegieendowment.org/2023/11/17/arab-peace-initiative-ii…
Netanyahu’s denigration of the Palestinian Authority is what he has been doing for a decade - weakening the PA and strengthening Hamas (since it's a zero sum game). This is the same PA that is doing its best to prevent the West Bank from erupting. www.axios.com/2023/11/11/gaza-palestinian-authority-contr…
That should please Smotrich and anger Biden, which tells you something about where Bibi’s priorities lie. I wonder who Bibi has in mind to govern Gaza then. A UN force? A local mayor? Itamar Ben Gvir?
BREAKING: Netanyahu says he is against the return of the Palestinian Authority to the Gaza strip on the day after the war
Martin Indyk reposted
This is powerful, heartbreaking, and somehow heartening at same time, describing the horror of war in Gaza and the selfless humanity of people under bombardment.
"The people that stayed behind are heroes."
A powerful testimony from MSF Nurse Activity Manager Emily (Cali) Callahan, who exited Gaza last Wed. She spoke w/ @andersoncooper on @CNN yesterday about the strength of the Palestinian staff still in Gaza.
Martin Indyk reposted
"The percentage of young Democrats who said Biden was too pro-Israeli doubled, going from 20.6% in October to 41.5% in November... To put this in perspective, if one excludes those who said they did not know where Biden stood, the percentage comes to 72.3%."
Must read: Fascinating account of Hamas’s planning for and objectives of the October 7 attack on Israel. Its leadership wants “permanent war” with Israel. www.nytimes.com/2023/11/08/world/middleeast/hamas-israel-…
There he goes again: Smotrich now wants to prevent West Bank Palestinians from harvesting their olives by creating “Palestinian-free buffer zones” around West Bank settlements. Any excuse to push Palestinians off their land. www.timesofisrael.com/smotrich-calls-for-palestinian-free…
This is how it started in Lebanon. A march of folly. www.nytimes.com/live/2023/11/07/world/israel-hamas-war-ga…
Martin Indyk reposted
From the archive: In a 2003 essay, former U.S. ambassador to Israel @Martin_Indyk made the case for international intervention in Gaza and the West Bank.
www.foreignaffairs.com/israel/trusteeship-palestine-marti…
Martin Indyk reposted
This is hard to watch, but we must all watch, as far too many people on this hellsite, & elsewhere, have weirdly & cruelly decided that opposing Israel's war in Gaza requires them to try & deny the sheer scale of Hamas brutality on Oct 7th. It doesn't.
www.cnn.com/videos/world/2023/10/30/morgue-burial-israel-…
Martin Indyk reposted
Everyone should watch this. Now.
Thank you, @DonnyDeutsch.
Congratulations Ambassador Jack Lew! And bravo to those Republican Senators, including Rand Paul, for recognizing the urgent necessity of having a U.S. ambassador in Jerusalem at this moment of crisis.
The US Senate has confirmed the nomination Jack Lew to become the next US ambassador to Israel.
The final vote tally is 53 to 43, with several Republicans, including Sens. Lindsey Graham and Rand Paul, crossing the aisle to vote with Democrats in approving Biden's pick
Me dishonest? Did the Government of Israel not take a decision to support the PA? Is Smotrich a member of that government? Or does he get to run his own policy which includes in his own words “from the river to the sea?” (Also happens to be a Hamas slogan.)
Are you really so dishonest as to accuse the Israeli Finance Minister of being on Hamas's side because he won't release funds to the PA?
The U.S. also stopped funding the PA because it pays terrorists to kill Jews - that was the US Congress. Are they also on Hamas's side?
Before the Israel-Hamas war @raad_zeid and I pointed to the dangerous plans of @bezalelsm Israel’s Finance Minister to undermine the Palestinian Authority. Today he notified @netanyahu that he would not release Palestinian tax revenues to the PA. Must be on Hamas’s side!
@raad_zeid and I analyze the dangerous Smotrich Plan for the West Bank in @ForeignAffairs. If MBS and @potus Biden don’t use the Israeli-Saudi deal to block Smotrich they will be courting disaster. www.foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/what-saudi-israeli-dea…
Martin Indyk reposted
BREAKING: U.S. asked Israel to release Palestinian tax revenues withheld by far-right Israeli finance minister. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2023/10/31/israel-hamas-war-tax-palestinian…
For those thinking about the “day after” the latest Israel-Hamas war, I’m re-upping the articles I published in 2003 and 2007 in Foreign Affairs: “Is Trusteeship for Palestine the Answer?” www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/israel/2007-07-27/trustee… via @ForeignAffairs
Martin Indyk reposted
brandenburg gate, berlin right now
quite a statement from the german government
Martin Indyk reposted
WATCH: Today, CFR President Michael Froman moderated a conversation with @Martin_Indyk, @stevenacook, and Ray Takeyh on Hamas's attacks on Israel.
Watch: on.cfr.org/3LQPyJ2
Martin Indyk reposted
The fight for democracy is taking place across the globe. An interesting conversation @92ndStreetY on 10/8 about Israel w/ @RichardHaass @ItamarRabinovi @Martin_Indyk, Lihi Ben Shitrit & @rudoren. Info & tkts at: www.92ny.org/event/israel-democracy @jdforward @nyuniversity @DanDavidPrize
Martin Indyk reposted
🗓️October 3 at 12PM ET
📺“Implications of the October War: From Warfighting to Peacemaking” with Efraim Halevy, Abdel Monem Said Aly, and @Martin_Indyk. @DavidMakovsky will moderate the discussion.
Watch: www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/october-1973-…
Martin Indyk reposted
.@Martin_Indyk and @raad_zeid discuss Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich’s plan for the annexation of the West Bank—and how the Biden administration can put an end to Smotrich’s revanchist ambitions:
www.foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/what-saudi-israeli-dea…
@raad_zeid and I analyze the dangerous Smotrich Plan for the West Bank in @ForeignAffairs. If MBS and @potus Biden don’t use the Israeli-Saudi deal to block Smotrich they will be courting disaster. www.foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/what-saudi-israeli-dea…
The Palestinians will not be sidelined in the Israel-Saudi peace deal according to @BarakRavid but what they get will be determined in a tug of war between Smotrich/Ben Gvir and Biden/MBS. Ideology vs power politics. www.axios.com/2023/09/28/saudi-mega-deal-biden-netanyahu-…
For all that happened at UNGA in NY this week, this @BretBaier interview with Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is the really big news - it provides a clear indication that the Israeli-Saudi peace deal is ON.
Important #mbs interview:
- 🇮🇱🇵🇸 #israel normalisation:
"Every day we get closer, it seems it's for the first time, a real one. Serious. We're going to see how it goes...If we have a breakthrough of reaching a deal that gives #palestine their needs and make the region come, we're going to work with whoever's there.”
- 🇮🇷 #iran:
"Well, we are concerned of any country getting a nuclear weapon...If they get one, we have to get one. For security reasons and for balancing power in the Middle East. But we don't want to see that"
Martin Indyk reposted
Fascinating discussion w @IsraelPolicy4m Israel fellow, @NimrodNovik, Saudi researcher @AzizAlghashian, & interview w Amb. @Martin_Indyk on efforts to promote Israel-Saudi normalization & more www.wbur.org/onpoint/2023/09/22/saudi-israel-normalizatio…
Martin Indyk reposted
Important #mbs interview:
- 🇮🇱🇵🇸 #israel normalisation:
"Every day we get closer, it seems it's for the first time, a real one. Serious. We're going to see how it goes...If we have a breakthrough of reaching a deal that gives #palestine their needs and make the region come, we're going to work with whoever's there.”
- 🇮🇷 #iran:
"Well, we are concerned of any country getting a nuclear weapon...If they get one, we have to get one. For security reasons and for balancing power in the Middle East. But we don't want to see that"
Martin Indyk reposted
The framework agreement signed in 1993 is easily dismissed as a failed peace initiative, says @Martin_Indyk. “But was it the accords that failed, or was it the statesmen and politicians who failed to pursue the opportunities that diplomacy had provided?” econ.st/48rc3xZ
Oslo is dead; long live Oslo. My take on Oslo at 30 for the Economist. www.economist.com/by-invitation/2023/09/12/martin-indyk-r…
Thank you @mfullilove @LowyInstitute for a great conversation about the 50th anniversary of the Yom Kippur War - a war that led to peace; and the 30th anniversary of the Oslo Accords - a peace that led to war; and the implications for US efforts to achieve a Saudi-Israeli peace.
I really enjoyed speaking with @Martin_Indyk at the @LowyInstitute yesterday about Kissingerian diplomacy, the proposal to normalise US-Saudi-Israel relations, and the role of leaders in peacemaking. You can access the video and audio of the event here: www.lowyinstitute.org/event/what-would-kissinger-do-lesso…
Martin Indyk reposted
I’ve got some news! www.axios.com/2023/09/11/yaroslav-trofimov-ukraine-russia…
I have been despairing about how to respond to Abu Mazen’s profoundly anti-Semitic diatribe. How could someone who has treated me as a personal friend for three decades at the same time harbor such hateful views of my people?
Thank you to our dear Palestinian brothers and sisters for speaking out against anti-Semitism -
Excerpt: “We the undersigned, Palestinian academics, writers, artists, activists, and people of all walks of life, unequivocally condemn the morally and politically reprehensible comments made by President of the Palestinian Authority Mahmoud Abbas about the Holocaust. Rooted in a racial theory widespread in European culture and science at the time, the Nazi genocide of the Jewish people was born of antisemitism, fascism, and racism. We adamantly reject any attempt to diminish, misrepresent, or justify antisemitism, Nazi crimes against humanity, or historical revisionism vis-a-vis the Holocaust. “
Rashid Khalidi -- Sherene Seikaly -- Tareq Baconi -- Muhammad Ali Khalidi -- Zaha Hassan -- Noura Erakat -- Raja Shehadeh -- Isabella Hammad -- Lana Tatour -- Nadia Abu El-Haj -- Bashir Abu-Manneh -- Annemarie Jacir -- Raef Zreik -- Leena Dallasheh -- Lila Abu Lughod -- Kareem Rabie -- Mezna Qato -- Amahl Bishara -- Dana El Kurd -- Nadia Hijab -- Samera Esmeir -- Ahmad Samih Khalidi -- Abdel Razzaq Takriti -- Maha Nassar -- Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian -- Huwaida Arraf -- Rosemary Sayigh -- Areej Sabbagh-Khoury -- Tamara Ben-Halim -- Yezid Sayigh -- Jumana Manna -- Nadim Bawalsa -- Yousef Munnayer -- Omar Qattan -- Ismail Nashef -- Nu'man Kanfani -- Himmat Zoubi -- Shahd Hammouri -- Hamzé Attar
This post from leading Palestinian thinkers shows that there is an important distinction to be made between the Palestinian people and their benighted leadership.
Just did an interesting interview with @PatsKarvelas on Australia’s @RNBreakfast show. www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/radionational-breakfast/is…
So good to be back Down Under at my home away from home the Lowy Institute. Thank you @mfullilove for making @LowyInstitute the best in class of foreign policy think tanks.
Very nice to welcome founding @LowyInstitute Board member @Martin_Indyk back to Bligh Street today.
Martin will be speaking to us tomorrow on the subject: ‘What would Kissinger do? Lessons of US diplomacy in the Middle East and elsewhere.’
Deeply saddened to learn that Oded Eran has left us. From our days together in Washington in the 1980s, to his role in the peace diplomacy of the 1990s, to his time as Israel’s ambassador to Jordan, to his leadership at INSS, Oded was the consummate diplomat/analyst.
Oded was always one step ahead of us in reading the situation and coming up with creative ideas for overcoming the inevitable obstacles to solution. And he always managed to do it with a smile or a joke. It was a pleasure and honor to be his friend and colleague.
Oded served his country with great distinction. He served his friends with great loyalty and good cheer. The likes of him will not pass this way again. May his memory be a blessing to his family and many friends.
Looks like Bibi is going to have to choose between Smotrich and peace with Saudi Arabia. For anybody not fearing a jail sentence, the choice would be obvious. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-08-28/ty-article/.premiu…
Jewish supremacy seems to come naturally to this clown Ben Gvir. @netanyahu should remove him from office before he does even more damage to Israel.
Israeli Jewish supremacist minister of internal security Ben Gvir: "My right, my wife's right and my kids right to drive around the West Bank is more important from the Arabs' right for freedom of movement"
Mabruk @shadihamid! Proud of you.
Some personal news! I'll be joining @washingtonpost as a columnist and member of the Editorial Board. It's bittersweet leaving Brookings after 14 years but it seems like the right time to take on a new challenge.
www.washingtonpost.com/pr/2023/08/22/shadi-hamid-alexi-mc…
Meanwhile in the West Bank, Smotrich’s de facto annexation proceeds in broad daylight: Two “legalized” outposts in the Hebron hills to be expanded. And NIS 700 million to be taken from other ministries to promote settlement in northern Samaria in violation of a pledge to the US.
Bravo!
Great to meet again with my friend Ambassador @OMarkarova. We discussed a range of important topics, including Iran’s destabilizing activities in Ukraine and the Middle East. I conveyed Israel’s continued support for Ukraine and the Ukrainian people. 🇮🇱🇺🇦
Agree. In addition, as former Treasury Secretary, Jack Lew has gravitas on economic issues. And as a longtime friend of Israel and proud modern Orthodox Jew, Jack will have the ideal combination of a friendly but skeptical disposition. As @ShalomLipner says: “unspinnable.”
Would come with the full skill set: political heft, top-tier administration experience, ability to speak on behalf of WH principals, familiarity with the players and issues.
In short, would be an "unspinnable" force to reckon with.
So Bibi as well as MBS wants a security guarantee from the US. This gives @POTUS Biden significant leverage over both of them. I hope he uses it.
Scoop: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wants to get a security agreement with the U.S. focused on deterring Iran in the context of the mega-deal the Biden administration is trying to reach with Saudi Arabia and Israel. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2023/08/09/israel-us-security-deal-biden-ne…
Bravo and thank you @Rob_Malley for your own tireless efforts to release these Americans from Iranian prisons.
It’s only a 1st step & every day they continue to be robbed of their freedom is a day too many
But for Siamak, Morad, Emad, two others released from prison, &their loved ones, this is welcome news too long in coming
I know my colleagues won’t rest until they all return home.
Were any of those nefarious projects lacking in funding? What price should we pay for the freedom of wrongly imprisoned Americans? Or should we leave them to rot in Iranian prisons for the sake of preventing fungibility? These are difficult moral dilemmas.
The $6 billion will not only be used for humanitarian purposes. In the real world, where cash is fungible, it will free up $6 billion to be used for terrorism, funding drones for Russia, domestic repression, and nuclear weapons expansion.
Looks like 5 Americans unjustly jailed by Iran will soon be coming home. The price: the unfreezing of $6bn of Iranian assets held in South Korean banks. Money will be transferred to Qatar to ensure it can only be spent on items not subject to US sanctions. on.ft.com/3OydOQN
Martin Indyk reposted
🎧 On this episode of the Why It Matters podcast, @GabSierraWrites talks to @DavidMSacks1 and @jamestwotree about what a potential war with China over Taiwan could mean for the U.S. and the world—and how it can be avoided.
Listen: on.cfr.org/45cH8mf
Interesting Emirati red lines for its relations with Netanyahu’s government: Egypt; Jordan; and Jerusalem. Apparently no red lines when it comes to the Palestinians or the West Bank.
UAE-Israël: "We postponed Benjamin Netanyahu’s visit to the UAE, and we have to differentiate between our long term commitment to the relationship and dealing with the current Israeli authorities", says an Emirati high official. "We have three red lines" vis-à-vis Israël.
🙏🙏🙏
Very thorough and moving interview here with
@Martin_Indyk who's dedicated decades of his life to the US - Israel relationship including personal efforts to bridge the political divide between Israel and our Palestinian neighbors. Kudos @AllisonKSommer and
@haaretzcom
Martin Indyk reposted
Smotrich’s Decisive Plan “Executive Summary” says “the Arabs of Judea & Samaria” “who wish to forgo national aspirations” can stay & have “autonomous municipal administrations lacking national characteristics” while those who keep “national ambitions will receive aid to emigrate”
Well then let’s also not pretend that anything you’re advocating is going to help the Palestinians either. And we can all wallow in despair together.
An Israeli commitment not to annex or build further settlements isn't worth the paper it is written on. How many times are they going to get away with selling the same thing over again? If KSA & Israel want to get together whatever but let's not pretend it'll help Palestinians.
Martin Indyk reposted
Smotrich’s Decisive Plan to create a Jewish State across to the Jordan River and make Palestinians either accept subjugation or have to leave
Do you hear yourself @YousefMunayyer? I’m not advocating that Israel be rewarded. The Israeli-Saudi peace deal is currently being negotiated, like it or not. I’m advocating that it must have a Palestinian component, which neither Bibi nor MBS seem to want.
Yeah because rewarding Israel for bad behavior isn't exactly how we got here. I wonder sometimes if these people hear themselves.
Those who would stop him need to stop his plan for de facto annexation of the West Bank via settlement expansion and the legalization of illegal outposts. By insisting on this in the Israel-Saudi peace deal, @POTUS Biden can use a carrot rather than sticks to head Smotrich off.
As Smotrich explains, the key to the achievement of his one (Jewish) state vision is the role of settlements in dashing Palestinian national aspirations. Those who advocate for abandoning the two state solution should recognize that they are doing Smotrich’s bidding.
For those who haven’t read it, I’m reupping Bezalel Smotrich’s 2017 plan for establishing Jewish sovereignty from the river to the sea. As “Minister in the Ministry of Defense,” he’s now implementing this plan. We can’t say he didn’t warn us. hashiloach.org.il/israels-decisive-plan/
Those who would stop him need to stop his plan for de facto annexation of the West Bank via settlement expansion and the legalization of illegal outposts. By insisting on this in the Israel-Saudi peace deal, @POTUS Biden can use a carrot rather than sticks to head Smotrich off.
For those who haven’t read it, I’m reupping Bezalel Smotrich’s 2017 plan for establishing Jewish sovereignty from the river to the sea. As “Minister in the Ministry of Defense,” he’s now implementing this plan. We can’t say he didn’t warn us. hashiloach.org.il/israels-decisive-plan/
Israelis and Palestinians are more alike than either would care to admit. Fauda captured this.
Netanyahu is like the old-time pre-Oslo Arafat - he says in moderate tones what the Western audiences want to hear in English, and what his right-wing constituency in Israel want to hear against the judicial system in Hebrew. Finally a symmetry between Netanyahu and Arafat!
Netanyahu goes into full spin mode, granting interviews to ABC and CNN to convey the message that the legislation he just passed-against massive opposition- is nothing more than “a minor correction”to an “activist court.” Notice that he doesn’t dare try that on with the Israeli media.
Martin Indyk reposted
And here is Netanyahu spinning with Steve Inskeep on NPR's Morning Edition today (recorded yesterday, I think). 7 minutes. Skillful interview IMO. www.npr.org/2023/07/28/1190663407/israeli-prime-minister-…
Netanyahu goes into full spin mode, granting interviews to ABC and CNN to convey the message that the legislation he just passed-against massive opposition- is nothing more than “a minor correction”to an “activist court.” Notice that he doesn’t dare try that on with the Israeli media.
At a moment when Bibi took a big step to undermine Israel’s independent judiciary, Abu Mazen takes a small step towards restoring the independence of the Palestinian judiciary.
Martin Indyk reposted
I am very excited that the National Press Club will recognize my @axios story on the U.S. brokered Red Sea Island deal between Saudi & Israel with an honorable mention at its upcoming awards ceremony. I couldn't have done it without a great team of editors. Thanks @PressClubDC
Scoop: U.S. negotiating deal among Saudis, Israelis and Egyptians ahead of Bidens trip to the Middle East. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2022/05/23/saudi-arabia-egypt-israel-red-se…
Martin Indyk reposted
1/5- This is text from a letter penned by foremost Israeli defense & security heads spanning decades of leadership at IDF, Mossad, Shabak, and Police, supporting hundreds of thousands of Israeli citizens standing against Netanyahu's efforts to undermine rule of law & democracy.
Martin Indyk reposted
Netanyahu off to hospital tonight to have a pacemaker installed. He looks OK in a video he just released but this adds another twist to what will be 48 dramatic hours in Israel
Just to be clear that quote is from Dan Kurtzer, not me.
Ukraine is making slow, costly progress. Not enough yet to convince Putin to end his bloody war. But enough for him to cause havoc in the grain market.
ISW calculated based on its own control of terrain data that since the beginning of the #ukrainian counteroffensive on June 4 to July 9 Ukrainian forces liberated approximately 253 square kilometers (97 square miles) of territory.
isw.pub/UkrWar071623
Some shrewd and disturbing analysis from INSS’s Tamir Hayman (former IDF head of military intelligence) about the Jenin operation that is currently underway. www.inss.org.il/social_media/jenin/
Mazel Tov Dan! And thank you for taking on this important challenge. Blessed are the peacemakers.
Deeply honored to join @StateDept_NEA and looking forward to working with partners to help advance a more peaceful, prosperous, integrated region. My thanks to @SecBlinken and @SafiraLeaf for their confidence. Ready to get to work!
@StateDept
Thank you @saadmohseni. High praise, coming from you! And greatly appreciated.
This is a must read for all aspiring diplomats and negotiators: @Martin_Indyk’s sober, thorough and balanced account of Kissinger’s shuttle diplomacy, that helped deliver a new political order in the Middle East. Indyk presents Kissinger as he was: insecure, competitive, conniving and yet brilliant for managing to bring all the parties together for his deal. His failures stand out i.e. an Israel-Jordan deal, his failure to understand the needs of the Palestinians (and to address them), his Israeli bias etc and yet he manages to create an environment where conflict has been avoided for 50 years.
As @OriNir_APN argues in this disturbing op-ed, Netanyahu’s government is normalizing settler vigilante violence. Smotrich, the settler minister within the Defense Ministry, seems to have free reign. It’s settlements and settlers gone wild. www.nytimes.com/2023/06/26/opinion/international-world/we…
All's well that ends well?!
Russian media quotes Peskov:
"The criminal case against Prigozhin is suspended, he will "head to Belarus".
Peskov doesn't know what role Prigozhin will play in Belarus.
The authorities will not persecute those members of Wagner who took part in this revolt, considering their merits earned on the battlefield."
Martin Indyk reposted
Prigozhin says it's over:
"They were going to dismantle PMC Wagner. We came out on 23 June to the March of Justice. In a day, we walked to nearly 200km away from Moscow. In this time, we did not spill a single drop of blood of our fighters. Now, the moment has come when blood may spill. That’s why, understanding the responsibility for spilling Russian blood on one of the sides, we are turning back our convoys and going back to field camps according to the plan."
Audio: t.me/concordgroup_official/1303
Martin Indyk reposted
Moscow is huge metro area and will swallow 400 armored vehicles. Fascinating to think about where they’re headed and what they will do when they get there. The attempted Coup in Turkey couldn’t answer that question though this one seems much better planned and resourced.
Russian telegram reports Wagner entered Moscow oblast, 2hrs from the capital. Mayor declares state of emergency, Monday no work.
Prigozhin’s Moscow blitz could prove more successful than the run on Kyiv.
Wagner progressing like Taliban, RU army useless like Afghan govt forces
Martin Indyk reposted
The 🇷🇺217th Guards Airborne Regiment defected to to #wagner
Russian military blogger “Fighterbomber:” There are no mines on the roads, bridges are open, no orders have been brought to a bunch of units at all…
Fighterbomber: "Wagner has speed, it's moving through unsecured areas, our generals are unable to respond:
"The most basic and most powerful weapon that Wagner has is speed.
While our fathers-commanders decide where to strike, the column is already a hundred kilometers to the north, demolishing ridiculous cars with sand and other keeper tapes.
There are no mines on the roads, bridges are open, no orders have been brought to a bunch of units at all, and so on. It is clear that in a couple of days the commanders will tighten up, but Wagner will not wait for this moment.
The inertia of our generals, of course, was taken into account by Wagner in their plan.
And yes, I keep forgetting to say. If you think that I am for one of the parties, you are mistaken. I know perfectly well that both sides are absolutely matched for each other. Bellends on both sides. And they equally give a fuck about our problems. I am for Russia, and only for it.
But today there is no choice. Today, everyone who fights against our army is our enemy. The only defense and support of our country is our army and navy. And the enemy must be destroyed.
And after the victory, we will reward everyone according to their merits."
Martin Indyk reposted
Prigozhin, audio message 12:46PM BST, on support by the locals and the "mine barrier" in Rostov:
"Why is the country supporting us? Because we went with a March for Justice. We were hit, first with artillery, then with helicopters. We went without a single round fired, we didn’t touch a single conscript. We didn’t kill a single person on our way.
We were attacked by aviation, helis, planes, but we reached Rostov. Without a single round, we captured the building of the HQs. We didn’t interfere with the work of a single person.
On the streets, people are unfurling flags of PMC Wagner. In shops, when guys go there, people ask to pay for them as they want to do something good.
Words of compliments are voiced. And another thing. In media, information about certain “mine barriers” are spread. When we came here, we removed these mine barriers from the adjacent building of the HQs, in the morning. It was poorly placed. It was just an unprofessional, not useful idea. So we removed this mine barrier."
Audio: t.me/concordgroup_official/1299
According to this map, Prigozhin’s forces are 200 miles from Moscow and moving north.
So far @simonmontefiore, Wagner forces do not appear to have met any resistance. They took Rostov-on-Don without firing a shot. They have shot down Russian army helicopters but it’s not clear that those helicopters were firing on them. Regular forces may not have joined Prigozhin but they don’t seem to be resisting him.
The key questions in this momentous revolt against Putin r those that faced nicholas II in 1917, Nicholas 1 1825, Peter I 1698 and many other Russian tsars: 1. watch to see if any regular forces & security forces join the mutuneers. If not, this will fail…
Martin Indyk reposted
Is Putin facing his Czar Nicholas II moment?
www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2023/06/russia-…
I'm no Putin expert but to me his speech this morning telegraphs weakness. His comparison with 1917 magnifies Prigozhin’s challenge. He admits he has lost Rostov-on-Don. He is begging people not to join the rebellion.
❗️Full morning of 24 June address by Putin to the nation in regards to the military coup:
"I appeal to the citizens of Russia, to the personnel of the Armed Forces, law enforcement and security services, fighters and commanders currently fighting on their positions, repelling the enemy attacks, doing it heroically.
I spoke to the commanders in all directions last night. I appeal also to those who were deceptively pulled into the criminal adventure, pushed towards a serious crime of an armed mutiny.
Russia today is leading the most difficult war for its future, repelling the aggression of neo-nazis and their handlers. Against us, the whole military, economical and information machines of the West are turned.
We fight for the lives and security of our people. For our sovereignty and independence. The right to remain Russia, a state with 1000 years of history.
It’s a battle where the fate of our people is decided requires uniting of all our forces, unity, consolidation and responsibility. Everything else hat weakens us must be shoved to the side.
Our external enemies are using any arguments to undermine us from within. Thus, actions splitting our unity is a betrayal of our people, our combat brothers who fight now at the frontline. It’s a strike in the back of our country and our people.
Exactly this strike was dealt in 1917 when the country was in WW1, but its victory was stolen. Intrigues, and arguments behind the army’s back turned out to be the greatest catastrophe, destruction of the army and the state, loss of huge territories, resulting in a tragedy and a civil war.
Russians were killing Russians, brothers killing brothers. But the beneficiaries were various political chevaliers of fortune and foreign powers who divided the country, and tore it into parts. We will not let this happen.
We will protect our people and state from any threats, including internal betrayal. What we’re facing is exactly internal betrayal. Extraordinary ambitions and personal interests led to treason. Treason of their own country and people and of the case that fighters of Wagner were dying for alongside our soldiers.
Heroes who liberated Soledar and Artemivsk, towns and cities of the Donbas. They fought and were giving lives to Novorossiya and the unity of the Russian world. Their name and glory were also betrayed by those who are trying to organise the mutiny, pushing the country into anarchy and brother-killing, to a defeat, in the end, and capitulation.
Repeat: any internal mutiny is a deadly threat to our state, to us as a nation. It’s a strike against our nation, our people. And our actions to defend the fatherland from such a threat will be brutal.
Anyone who consciously went on the path of betrayal, who prepared the armed mutiny, went on the path of blackmail and terrorist actions, will take an inevitable punishment.
They will answer to the law and our people. The Armed Forces and other departments were properly instructed. Extra anti-terrorist measures are now being implemented in Moscow, Moscow region, and a number of other regions.
Decisive actions will be taken to stabilise the situation in Rostov-on-Don. It remains difficult. The operation of civilian and military control departments is practically blocked.
As a President of Russia and the Supreme Commander, as a citizen of Russia, I will do everything to defend the country, protect the Constitution, lives and safety, liberty of the citizens.
Those who prepared the military mutiny, who raise weapons against combat brothers, have betrayed Russia, and will pay for this. And those who are being pulled into the crime, I’m asking to not make this crucial, tragic, unrepeatable mistake. Do the one right choice - stop participating in criminal actions.
I believe that we will defend and preserve what’s sacred for us. And together with the motherland, we will overcome all challenges, and become even stronger.
Martin Indyk reposted
Questions in abundance m. Who will win? Unlikely Prigozin at the end of the day, but how and when will he lose? And Putin will also lose since the core stability of his regime is shattered. The new time of trouble of 🇷🇺 has begun.
Martin Indyk reposted
Latest Defence Intelligence update on the situation in Ukraine - 24 June 2023.
Find out more about Defence Intelligence's use of language: ow.ly/EkLH50ORnJx
🇺🇦 #standwithukraine 🇺🇦
Martin Indyk reposted
"Wagner" tanks passing #lipetsk region M4 highway toward #moscow
Martin Indyk reposted
Civilians in Rostov are bringing food and beverages to Wagner fighters.
Martin Indyk reposted
airstrike on Wagner convoy
Martin Indyk reposted
Martin Indyk reposted
Explosion at the headquarters of the Southern Military District in #rostov which is controlled by Wagner since early morning
“Could not break into the program schedule.” That says it all. Against our preferences my wife and I spent the night glued to our Twitter feeds.
@MSNBC called me for the 7pm hour but we could not break into the program schedule fast enough. We should all wait for tomorrow for more info.
As usual @LawDavF has the shrewdest, most thought-provoking commentary on the Prigozhin coup attempt. Bottom line - this ain't over, Putin is screwed, and Ukraine is the beneficiary if its commanders can exploit Russia’s obvious division and distraction. Worth reading. 👇👇👇
My first stab at trying to make sense of the remarkable events in Russia. No doubt updates will be needed. Comments welcome. samf.substack.com/p/prigozhins-mutiny?sd=pf
Martin Indyk reposted
An extraordinary video of Prigozhin taking over the HQ of the Southern Military District in Rostov, telling the deputy defense minister and the deputy head of GRU that he’s marching onto Moscow to save Russia, and that he shot down three helicopters.
Martin Indyk reposted
It’s wild how rapidly this situation is developing. First, no sign of Wagner units, then sightings of columns moving, and shortly thereafter this stand-off in Rostov with MPs and Wagner forces on the same street seemingly doing nothing.
More videos from the Southern Military District HQ. The Telegram channel says there are soldiers in the building and there are up to 300 Wagner fighters in Rostov. Some of the vehicles are military police. 9/
t.me/rostov_glavniy/55694
t.me/rostov_glavniy/55696
t.me/rostov_glavniy/55697
Martin Indyk reposted
It is reported that Wagner's column has passed the first checkpoints.
They say they are on their way to Novocherkassk, where the army headquarters are. It is also known that a column of 400 vehicles left Millerovo in the direction of Moscow.
Martin Indyk reposted
🚨 Special Operations Forces (SSO) commanded by Major General Valery Flustikov have taken over control of the Ministry of Defence headquarters on Frunzenskaya in Moscow. Right now, there's no way of knowing whose side he is really on: Shoigu or Prigozhin. Probably "wait & see."
Martin Indyk reposted
Key thing to watch: if the FSB actually tries to arrest Prigozhin, will his troops protect him and clash with Russian authorities? Or step aside? The unfolding chaos could force many people to make choices, take sides, hence great uncertainty about where this leads.
The NY Post and Twitter 🤪
Then how do you know it's really happening? : )
Just watched your excellent interview with Masha Gessen @chrislhayes. Fascinating assessment. Thank you!
We covered the story in the last hour and I'm about to do it now!
Martin Indyk reposted
The absence in public of Putin so far in this crisis is striking.
Not my CNN!
CNN was on it till 8
There’s a coup attempt happening now in Russia and I can’t find any US news channel that is reporting on it. Anderson Cooper is in Newfoundland. MSNBC is obsessed with Trump 24/7.
Martin Indyk reposted
I think it suggests that security services have Surovikin and Alekseyev in front of a beige wall, maybe in the same room. So the people that might have been of help to Prigozhin in the armed forces are visibly ‘unwilling ’, and others will see these videos, drawing conclusions.
Martin Indyk reposted
It’s hard to predict how things turn out with Prigozhin push. But having covered Gorbachev coup 1991 and Parliament v Yeltsin in 93, my sense is that even if eruptions are quashed, they have a habit of fragmenting Kremlin leadership -weakening the incumbent by degrees.
Martin Indyk reposted
Too early to tell what the Russian-on-Russian split means, but Yevgeny Prigozhin seems to have gone public with a fight that will end with some serious losers. He's publicly declared war on the Russian Ministry of Defense--and claimed his forces are already under attack by them.
The writing is on the wall for all those who want to see it: Israelis can have normalization or settlements but they can't have both. www.timesofisrael.com/morocco-cancels-next-months-negev-f…
Plus a crumbling Palestinian Authority, a Palestinian Security Force that doesn't operate in the northern West Bank cities, easy access to weapons smuggled in from Israel and Jordan, and a huge number of easy targets in the thousands of settlers using roads in the West Bank.
Events in Jenin and Eli should surprise no one. A perfect storm is raging: a 56 year old Israeli occupation; the most extreme Israeli government; Hamas/Jihad backed cells and independent Palestinian groups in West Bank planning terror attacks. A bloody cul-de-sac w/no way out.
What government deliberately puts its citizens in harm’s way to deter terrorist attacks? 560,000 settlers in the West Bank haven't stopped terrorist attacks - they just provide easy targets as yesterday’s deplorable attack shows. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-06-21/ty-article/.premiu….
Interesting. What borders for the Palestinian state would the US be recognizing?
What if Biden agreed to recognize Palestinian statehood--most states already do--if the Saudis normalize their relations with Israel? This would allow MBS to claim he secured Palestinian statehood, albeit under occupation, and allow Biden to deliver something significant for the Palestinians, without requiring any concessions from Israel's far-right government (which are unlikely). Bibi would just have to accept US recognition of Palestine in exchange for Israeli-Saudi normalization.
In this three-way deal, it’s clear what the U.S. is expected to pay: for Saudi Arabia a security guarantee, an open arms spigot, and green lighting an independent uranium enrichment capability; for Israel, underwriting peace with the Arab and Muslim world and…
"The United States is now in the midst of complex negotiations among three leaders who have their own reasons for a deal but are making demands that might prove to be too costly. And they simply do not much like or trust each other." www.nytimes.com/2023/06/17/us/politics/biden-saudi-arabia…
compensation for the arms sold to Saudi Arabia to maintain Israel’s qualitative edge. But what will Biden ask of Bibi and MBS in return? Like UAE ambo Yousef Al-Oteiba, he should write op-ed pieces in Saudi and Israeli media, requiring each to choose: …
MBS should have to choose between an alliance with the U.S. or continued hedging with China, Russia, and Iran. Bibi should have to choose between peace with the Arab and Muslim worlds or continued de facto annexation of the West Bank. Joe should not become MBS’s and Bibi’s freier.
Is that all there is?
The U.S. is deeply troubled by the Israeli government’s announcement of plans to advance over 4,000 new settlement units in the West Bank & the changes to its planning system that may expedite approvals. Settlement expansion is an obstacle to peace.
www.state.gov/the-united-states-is-deeply-troubled-with-i…
Martin Indyk reposted
Video Briefing on Thursday (6/15) on our new policy report, Leveraging the Prospect of Israel-Saudi Normalization to Advance Israeli-Palestinian Progress
With co-authors @ShiraEfron, @EvanGottesman, and @mkoplow alongside Amb. @Martin_Indyk
Register: israelpolicyforum.zoom.us/webinar/register/7716865815551/…
And what did the Biden Administration tell the Government of Israel? “Don’t do it,” for certain. But a warning without teeth will not deter the Smotrichs and Ben Gvirs and their settler constituents. Fortunately, the US has leverage...
Scoop: The Israeli government told the Biden administration it intends to announce later this month the building and planning of thousands of new housing units in the settlements in the occupied West Bank. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2023/06/12/israel-west-bank-settlement-unit…
We should tell Netanyahu that we are not prepared to pay the high price MBS is demanding from the US for making peace with Israel if he green-lights settlement expansion.
A “radical territorial surrender plan?” Wow. Whose territory was “surrendered?” And was “40% of the West Bank” a “radical surrender?” Only if you believe all of the West Bank belongs to Israel. Now that's radical. As radical as your failed judicial coup.
One would have thought from Oslo Accords that if gov't can adopt radical and hard to reverse territorial surrender plan with 61 votes, judicial reform that could be undone simply by next Knesset could be passed with 64, but no, your "democracy" is a one-way street.
Bravo @Yonatan_Touval! That makes four of us. Pretty soon we’ll have a movement!
Agree. A lot healthier, first, and foremost, for Israel, whose chronic dependence on the US has turned it into an adolescent state that doesn't take responsibility for its own actions, above all its continued occupation.
Now you're talking. The US-Israel relationship would be a lot healthier without this dependence. Time for Israel at 75 to stand on its own two feet, I say. Let's see if there are more than three Israelis who agree with us. I doubt it.
Technically we do. At least 90% of it is corporate welfare for US military industry, since Israel has to use that money to buy US weapons. For all I care, they can end this so called foreign aid, if that means no more strings attached!
Should have known I could rely on you @AlonPinkas! That makes three of us. Anybody else?
Unlike you though, I do believe in a full-fledged defense alliance.
Martin Indyk reposted
Sweeping review of my new book, THE LAND OF HOPE AND FEAR, in this week's Jerusalem Report magazine, my original journalistic home here, by the great Ralph Amelan. Thanks Ralph and @stevelinde www.jpost.com/israel-news/article-744830
Truly impressive. Bibi is cornered, caught between his far-right partners and the Israeli street, neither of which is willing to go home.
Protest organizers: From Metulla to Eilat, 300,000 protesters demonstrated against the Netanyahu government for the 22nd week in a row, 155,000 in Tel Aviv.
Now you're talking. The US-Israel relationship would be a lot healthier without this dependence. Time for Israel at 75 to stand on its own two feet, I say. Let's see if there are more than three Israelis who agree with us. I doubt it.
Technically we do. At least 90% of it is corporate welfare for US military industry, since Israel has to use that money to buy US weapons. For all I care, they can end this so called foreign aid, if that means no more strings attached!
If it's so inconsequential why don't you pay for your arms yourselves? Then you could ignore us. Somehow, I don't think the Israeli national security establishment would agree with you.
“Heavily dependent”—US aid is maybe 3% of Israel’s government budget. That’s before US benefiting from Israel’s tech and intel sharing.
Which actually proves Uri’s point, doesn’t it?
If you don't like advice from American citizens about U.S policy toward Israel @RationalSettler, you could stop taking our money. But as long as Israel remains heavily dependent on American largesse you are obliged to take our views into account, no matter how unpalatable.
We’ve got a professor in Maryland debating a former Ambassador in Manhattan about what should happen with my neighbors and my life.
Spoiler Alert: Neither of these people wil have any influence on what happens. #zionism allowed Jews in Israel to determine their own future.
“It is not time to abandon the two-state solution. Rather, the time has come to reinvigorate it.” My counter-argument in @ForeignAffairs to @ShibleyTelhami et al. www.foreignaffairs.com/responses/can-two-state-solution-b…
And the wolf will dwell with the lamb,
And the leopard will lie down with the young goat... www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/iran-says-form-naval-al…
Martin Indyk reposted
Join the @NATLCOMMITTEE on Tuesday, June 13th for "Shifting Geopolitics in the Middle East" when @AmbElliott along with @AshaCastleberry @hdagres @Martin_Indyk will discuss the future of the U.S. policy in the Middle East.
Register today!
www.ncafp.org/event-shifting-geopolitics-in-the-middle-east/
Martin Indyk reposted
This debate @ForeignAffairs between @Martin_Indyk @dahliasc @ShibleyTelhami @robsatloff et al. With little such debate taking place on the ground & no clear endgames on either side of the lines, Israelis now fighting over legitimacy of holding the Palestinian flag at protests
“It is not time to abandon the two-state solution. Rather, the time has come to reinvigorate it.” My counter-argument in @ForeignAffairs to @ShibleyTelhami et al. www.foreignaffairs.com/responses/can-two-state-solution-b…
So was Jeffrey Epstein 🤦♂️
So was the actor who played the camp commandant.
If you don't like advice from American citizens about U.S policy toward Israel @RationalSettler, you could stop taking our money. But as long as Israel remains heavily dependent on American largesse you are obliged to take our views into account, no matter how unpalatable.
We’ve got a professor in Maryland debating a former Ambassador in Manhattan about what should happen with my neighbors and my life.
Spoiler Alert: Neither of these people wil have any influence on what happens. #zionism allowed Jews in Israel to determine their own future.
“It is not time to abandon the two-state solution. Rather, the time has come to reinvigorate it.” My counter-argument in @ForeignAffairs to @ShibleyTelhami et al. www.foreignaffairs.com/responses/can-two-state-solution-b…
“It is not time to abandon the two-state solution. Rather, the time has come to reinvigorate it.” My counter-argument in @ForeignAffairs to @ShibleyTelhami et al. www.foreignaffairs.com/responses/can-two-state-solution-b…
Indeed. Just one of the multiple ironies of the Middle East.
You broke the code.
So instead of telling Netanyahu "no way on your watch" the Saudi's decided to ask for something he can't deliver?
What took them so long? Blinded by the light.
Israel lowering expectations of a breakthrough with Saudi Arabia after realizing the implications for it's security of MBS’s demands for F35s and an independent nuclear enrichment facility. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-05-31/ty-article/.premiu…
Me a sophist snoot? I LOVED Pine Gap.
As an Australian American, impressed by @netflix / @abcnews #pinegap - show captured nuances of diplomacy that surround 🇦🇺🇺🇸 relations, specially with reference to hawks and doves on 🇨🇳 - show unfairly got bad reviews by sophist snoots cc: @jonathanvswan @MrKRudd @Martin_Indyk
Mark this;
“Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.”
A stark cry for government intervention from the very people who developed this threat to humanity. www.safe.ai/statement-on-ai-risk
Martin Indyk reposted
He brilliantly outplayed the Soviets in the Middle East. @Martin_Indyk tells the story in his "Master of the Game" (www.amazon.co.uk/Master-Game-Kissinger-Middle-Diplomacy/d…), and you will see it also in my book, with new evidence.
““My theme is the need for balance and moderation.” At 100, Henry Kissinger borrows from the 19th century to address the challenges of the 21st. Happy Birthday Henry! www.economist.com/briefing/2023/05/17/henry-kissinger-exp…
100 years of experience distilled into one sentence: “I think the art [of diplomacy] is to present relations with China as a mutual concern in which agreements are made because both parties think it is best for themselves.” Happy Birthday Dr Kissinger! www.wsj.com/articles/the-great-strategist-henry-kissinger…
Martin Indyk reposted
"Master of the Game" by @Martin_Indyk looks at Kissinger's Middle East shuttle diplomacy and explains better than any other account just how he was so successful at managing the world's most complex negotiations.
www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1101947543
www.politics-prose.com/book/9781101947548
Thank you @peterbakernyt. At first the title was all that HAK liked about my book too!
"Master of the Game" by @Martin_Indyk looks at Kissinger's Middle East shuttle diplomacy and explains better than any other account just how he was so successful at managing the world's most complex negotiations.
www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1101947543
www.politics-prose.com/book/9781101947548
And when are you @RationalSettler going to realize that Palestinians claim the same territory just as steadfastly and legitimately as their homeland, and that you cannot rule over three million Palestinians forever? You don’t sound “rational” to me.
When are the failed peace processors like Ambassador Indyk going to realize that “settlement activity” i.e. Jews moving back to the heartland of their historic homeland, isn’t going to stop?
Jews are back for good, and it’s about time Indyk and crew realize that and move on.
Agreed. Each side has to do their part or it won’t work. For example: the US has to provide a security guarantee and arms sales to Saudi Arabia. Israel has to stop settlement activity and hand over more West Bank territory to the Palestinian Authority. The PA has to prevent terrorism and incitement. And Saudi Arabia has to make full peace with Israel.
I hope the US won't be the only party making concessions here...
Agreed. Each side has to do their part or it won’t work. For example: the US has to provide a security guarantee and arms sales to Saudi Arabia. Israel has to stop settlement activity and hand over more West Bank territory to the Palestinian Authority. The PA has to prevent terrorism and incitement. And Saudi Arabia has to make full peace with Israel.
I hope the US won't be the only party making concessions here...
Thanks @Yonatan_Touval. You are right that there are always different takes in the USG. Where they stand depends on where they sit. But a decision by @POTUS Biden to go for an Israeli-Saudi peace deal this year is dispositive.
Thank you for this, @Martin_Indyk. There are clearly different takes within the U.S. admin on the significance of this push. Your voice here certainly adds additional indication that the effort should not be dismissed.
Thanks @joshua_landis for highlighting this excellent review of “Master of the Game” by @james_barr.
Kissinger quote during 1973 War:
"Did you see the Saudi Foreign Minister come out like a good little boy and say they had very fruitful talks with us?’ he joked to colleagues on 17 October 1973
That same day the Arabs announced they would cut production drastically and unilaterally imposed new prices. By New Year’s Eve the price of crude oil had risen fourfold.
Kissinger didn't believe that the Saudi's would embargo. He would later threaten military action against KSA
Via @James_Barr excellent review
engelsbergideas.com/reviews/the-middle-east-kissingers-ma…
Whatever a US official may have told you, the White House is making a push for full normalization between Israel and Saudi Arabia this year. Maybe they’ll fail. For sure there’s hot air coming from Israel. But it would be a mistake to miss the significance of a White House decision to make Israeli-Saudi peace a priority. And they would not have leaked that decision to multiple people if they didn’t think they had a good chance.
#breaking: U.S. official tells me recent statements by Saudi/Gulf officials should "put to rest talk of a major U.S. push for 𝗦𝗮𝘂𝗱𝗶-𝗜𝘀𝗿𝗮𝗲𝗹𝗶 #𝗻𝗼𝗿𝗺𝗮𝗹𝗶𝘇𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻." Calls talks "a campaign full of 𝗵𝗼𝘁 𝗮𝗶𝗿 blown by well-meaning folks mostly in #israel."
Hmmm. So Netanyahu promises Biden not to build a new settlement in Homesh but instead will move the yeshiva to nearby “state land” and call it Homesh! I hope @USAmbIsrael Tom Nides calls it for what it is - bs.
Scoop: Israel tells U.S. it won't turn Homesh outpost into new settlement. My story on @axios
www.axios.com/2023/05/23/israel-homesh-settlement-palesti…
UAE think tank head, Dr. Ebtesam Al-Ketbi speaks truth to Netanyahu’s far-right government: “You have embarrassed us. No more Arab states will normalize ties with Israel.” www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-05-22/ty-article/.premiu….
Strong rap.
Strong criticism? Same old rap on the knuckles.
Martin Indyk reposted
#ukrainian military sources reported that #russian forces lost part of the dominant heights around #bakhmut and noted that sustained Ukrainian advances could lead to a tactical encirclement of #wagner forces in Bakhmut. (1/6) isw.pub/UkrWar052123
NEW: #wagner Group mercenaries likely secured the western administrative borders of #bakhmut City while #ukrainian forces are continuing to prioritize counterattacks on Bakhmut’s outskirts.
Our latest: isw.pub/UkrWar052123
Martin Indyk reposted
.@StateDeptSpox: “We are deeply troubled by the Israeli government’s order that allows its citizens to establish a permanent presence in the Homesh outpost in the northern West Bank, which according to Israeli law was illegally built on private Palestinian land. (1/4)
Bravo! Strong criticism from the State Department of Israeli far-right government’s decision to renege on a commitment made to the USG. The strength of the US-Israel relationship depends on both sides living up to their commitments.
Advancing Israeli settlements in the West Bank is an obstacle to peace and the possibility of a two-state solution. We further underscore the imperative of maintaining the historic status quo at the holy sites in Jerusalem. www.state.gov/settlements-in-the-west-bank/
Martin Indyk reposted
Joined @AmandaBDan and @cjkeller8 on today's @TimesofIsrael daily podcast to discuss @IKershner's new book, @issacharoff's new show and what I really think about Noa Kirel's so-called "diplomatic scandal."
www.timesofisrael.com/daily-briefing-may-21-minister-ben-…
If @peterbakernyt recommends it, you know it’s going to be worth reading.
Out tomorrow: "The Land of Hope and Fear," a timely look at modern Israel as it turns 75, the dynamism and discord, the feats and the failings, by @IKershner who knows, and tells, the story better than anyone.
www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/1101946768
www.politics-prose.com/book/9781101946763
In ‘The Land of Hope and Fear,’ veteran New York Times correspondent Isabel Kershner crisscrosses ‘a country on the precipice’ and comes away with ‘great faith in the people.” A great review in the Times of Israel. www.timesofisrael.com/a-house-divided-new-book-explores-r…
An ugly way to tarnish the spiritual beauty of a shared Jerusalem for the three Abrahamic faiths.
The United States unequivocally opposes racist language of any form. We condemn the hateful chants such as “Death to Arabs” during today’s marches in Jerusalem.
Martin Indyk reposted
Now that THE LAND OF HOPE AND FEAR: Israel's Battle for its Inner Soul is out in the world, time to say thank you to my wonderful blurbers, @Martin_Indyk @AmbDennisRoss @DoritRabinyan, Nahum Barnea & Sari Nusseibeh, who took the time to read the manuscript and offer kind words 🙏
Not since @tomfriedman’s From Beirut to Jerusalem has there been a book like @IKershner ‘s Land of Hope and Fear. It’s the complete guide to the politics of Israel today. Isabel Kershner, veteran NYT correspondent in Israel, has written a brilliant book.
Drop everything and read my NYT colleague Isabel Kershner’s new book on Israel!
www.publishersweekly.com/9781101946763
A brilliant piece of public diplomacy by Aaron Snype, spokesman @USAinUK, riffing off Netflix’s “The Diplomat.” Looking forward to his fact check on episode 2. The pilot was such a hit, Aaron should turn it into a series.
An interesting anecdote and a useful antidote to those who argue that Biden hasn’t pursued the expansion of the Abraham Accords. From the English version of Barak Ravid’s book, “Trump’s Peace.”
New: How Biden tried to get a normalization deal between Israel and Mauritania. @jacobkornbluh writes about one of the stories in the English edition of my book "Trump's Peace". Read it here: forward.com/news/546177/joe-biden-donald-trump-abraham-ac…
Martin Indyk reposted
Scoop: My book “Trump’s Peace” is out in ENGLISH including the explosive interview with Trump (in which he says about Bibi: “F**k him"). It includes a new chapter with never-before-published stories on Biden's diplomacy in the Middle East. Order now: www.amazon.com/dp/B0C4K28HD1
Way off base @BarakRavid! Jared Kushner is no Amos Hochstein! Biden's Harry Hopkins would be a better fit.
Amos Hochstein seems to be Biden's Jared Kushner
Good luck @BarakRavid! Washington awaits you with open arms.
BREAKING: I am moving to Washington DC with my family this summer to work for @axios. I will continue covering many of the issues I am covering today but also new ones. I am very excited. Will have more details for you soon
Martin Indyk reposted
*Without a doubt- the strangest assassination I've ever seen*
A senior Iranian cleric and member of one of the regime's most important committees was shot and killed by a security guard at a bank in northern Mazandaran province.
The bank's CCTV records show the senior Ayatollah
Now there’s a good idea 👇
Note para 4: “…the receiving State is not obliged to give to the sending State reasons for its decision.”
The Biden administration can refuse to accept May Golan as Israel's Consul General in NY (see the relevant clause in the Vienna convention on consular relations). Golan's racist & xenophobic record & the fact she was a member of the Jewish Power party could create such a scenario
Bibi makes his pitch again for peace with Saudi Arabia first (Palestinians lucky last). Watch him dodge repeated questions about what he would do for the Palestinians to ease Saudi Arabia's decision. It's all about what MBS would get, not what Bibi would give.
If that's true it will be seen by the American Jewish community as a sign of utmost disrespect.
BREAKING: Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu wants to appoint racist and xenophobic Likud lawmaker May Golan as Israel's consul general in New York who is in charge of the relations with the biggest Jewish community in the U.S. and the ties with the big Jewish organizations
There you go: China to rescue the 2-state solution. Just when you all thought it was dead. www.al-monitor.com/originals/2023/04/china-ready-facilita…
Martin Indyk reposted
For the 15th week in a row, more than 100K Israelis demonstrate in Tel Aviv against the Netanyahu government's judicial overhaul. More than 100K demonstrate in other cities, including 40K in the Likud stronghold of Netanya. Photo from TLV by Amir Goldstein
We agree on facing the one-state reality but the way to change it is to end the occupation so Palestinians can exercise their right to national self-determination, not to give up on that right for equal rights in Israel.
That's fine, but it should not be used as a smokescreen to maintain an apartheid-like reality that has lasted most of a century with no end in sight; freedom for Palestinians must be immediate priority.
My friend @ShibleyTelhami describes well the one-state reality that exists in Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories today. But his prescription for a U.S.-imposed binational state is a recipe for continuing the conflict, not resolving it...1/3 www.foreignaffairs.com/middle-east/israel-palestine-one-s…
The US should never give up on the two-state solution, no matter how distant it is today, because that would be giving up on ever resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in favor of an alternative that will only deepen it. It would be better for the U.S. ...
to put some real muscle behind its opposition to actions, such as settlement activity, that close off the hope of a two state solution. 75 years ago the UN called for two states for two peoples. That remains the only way to achieve Israeli-Palestinian peace.
As Sharon used to say: “There’s wisdom in restraint.”
Prime Minister Netanyahu decides to suspend visits by Jews and tourists at the Temple Mount\Haram al-Sharif compound in Jerusalem until the end of Ramadan. Similar decision was made in previous years
Bravo! Let’s hope Netanyahu has the wisdom to put his differences with the Israeli people behind them too.
BREAKING: Netanyahu backtracks and says minister of defense @yoavgallant will not be fired. "I decided to put the differences we had behind us," he says
Thanks @PreetBharara for such an engaging conversation about the internal and external crises that Israel faces and what we can learn from them.
I spoke with former U.S. Ambassador to Israel @Martin_Indyk about the political crisis unfolding in that country. He was extremely insightful — about Netanyahu, Biden, and what it all means for us here in the United States. Listen: cafe.com/stay-tuned/in-brief-a-political-crisis-in-israel…
Netanyahu and Likud continue to crater in the polls. Israeli Ch 13 reported last night that were elections held today Likud would get only 20 seats (vs 32 today). Gantz and Lapid would have a majority of 64 seats. 71% of Israelis believe Bibi is doing a bad job.
The people know their way to Kaplan Street, even during Passover and despite the security situation! Note the banner of Bibi as Pharaoh.
For the 14th week in a row and in the middle of the Passover holiday, more than 100K Israelis protested tonight in Tel Aviv against the Netanyahu government's judicial overhaul plan. Thousands more demonstrated across the country
As I said, “good luck with that.” Washington would applaud. Just like it welcomed the Saudi-Iran deal. If China can help stabilize the region and reduce the violence, ahlan wu’sahlan.
But let us not sell that short, if the Chinese managed to bring #riyadh to the table, that will definitely be a game changer, and where would #washington be if that materialised 😉
China to the rescue. Good luck with that. m.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-738678
@AlonPinkas is on fire in his denunciation of Netanyahu’s “kakistocracy.” 👇👇👇 www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-04-07/ty-article/.premiu….
The escalating violence provides Netanyahu with an opportunity to forge internal unity by putting judicial overhaul on indefinite pause, reinstating Defense Minister Galant, and offering to replace Ben Gvir and Smotrich with Gantz and Lapid. Likelihood? Between zero and none.
And now a terror attack in Tel Aviv: One Killed, 3 Wounded in Suspected Shooting and Ramming Attack in Tel Aviv. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-04-07/ty-article/two-peo….
Now two Israeli girls killed in West Bank terrorist attack. I don’t recall such a confluence of violent events. After the Israeli police beatings, Netanyahu is exercising restraint but with settlers killed he’ll be under pressure to act more forcefully. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-04-07/ty-article/three-i….
Here we go...
BREAKING: Israeli foreign ministry instructed Israeli ambassadors to convey a message to host governments that Israel is going to retaliate to the rocket fire from Lebanon. “You need to speak to stress that Israel will take the needed steps to defend itself”, the instruction said
You can watch my remarks to the Asia Society Policy Institute on China’s mediation efforts in the Gulf here 👇 My counter-intuitive argument: U.S. interests are served by China's mediation. asiasociety.org/video/chinas-international-mediation-effo…
Finally Israel fulfills a commitment made by @Netanyahu 10 yrs ago to open the Allenby Bridge crossing 24/5. Kudos to @HadyAmr and @USambIsrael Nides for pushing it over the line. Now WB Pals will be able to travel more freely, a basic human right. www.timesofisrael.com/israel-starts-running-allenby-cross…
There they go again: after pledging production targets would stay steady “for the rest of the year, period!” OPEC+ announced today a surprise oil production cut of more than 1 million bpd. Saudi Arabia takes the lead with a 500,000 bpd cut. www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-04-02/saudi-arabia-m… via @markets
The people know their way back to Kaplan Street. Hundreds of thousands of Israelis marched last night in a message to Netanyahu that the pause will not buy peace as long as his judicial reform remains on the table. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-04-02/ty-article/.premiu….
Martin Indyk reposted
Next week in New York, we're hosting an important conversation on China’s growing involvement in international conflicts around the world. 🌎🌍🌏
Join @dannyrrussel, @rorrydaniels, @Martin_Indyk and Thomas Pickering: asiasociety.org/policy-institute/events/chinas-internatio…
Martin Indyk reposted
🗓 In case you missed it, check out our Twitter Space conversation with @stevenacook, @robbinscarla, and @Martin_Indyk
on the current political crisis in Israel. Tune in below ⬇️ on.cfr.org/3znaAbC
Like clockwork, Republican politicians attack Biden for his criticism of Netanyahu. I wonder how many calls Bibi and Dermer made to them in the last 24 hours. Watch for a McCarthy invitation to Bibi to address the House next. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-31/ty-article/.premiu….
Et tu, Marco? GOP lawmakers lament overhaul's security ramifications for Israel
www.timesofisrael.com/breaking-silence-gop-lawmakers-lame…
“Israel cannot continue down this road.” Some tough love from @POTUS Joe toward his good friend Bibi. This is not about internal interference as Bibi would have it. It’s that friends don’t let friends drive drunk. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-28/ty-article/.premiu…
Martin Indyk reposted
🗓 Join us on 3/29 at 1:00 p.m. ET for a Twitter Space conversation with @stevenacook, @robbinscarla, and @Martin_Indyk
on the current political crisis in Israel. Set a reminder below! ⬇️ on.cfr.org/3nkH7w1
Martin Indyk reposted
Massive protests in Israel have put Prime Minister Netanyahu’s plans for judicial reform on hold. “It’s going to be extremely difficult to work out a compromise,” says former U.S. ambassador to Israel @Martin_Indyk. @WalterIsaacson
Latest polls show Israel's Opposition Overtakes Netanyahu Bloc to Reach Majority, Both Gantz and Lapid also beat Netanyahu in approval contest. It means Bibi can't let his government collapse and the far-right has him captive. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-27/ty-article/.premiu….
Martin Indyk reposted
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, having paused his controversial plan to overhaul Israel’s independent judiciary, claims the country will overcome what he calls a “great debate.” @Martin_Indyk joins @WalterIsaacson to discuss what's at stake. youtu.be/h3T4lQ4-8qY
My interview with @WalterIsaacson for @amanpour’s TV show, screening tonight. On the Israel crisis, of course.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, having paused his controversial plan to overhaul Israel’s independent judiciary, claims the country will overcome what he calls a “great debate.” @Martin_Indyk joins @WalterIsaacson to discuss what's at stake. youtu.be/h3T4lQ4-8qY
You're right. I could've added Palestinian incitement, failure of both sides to live up to their Oslo commitments, etc etc. There's no shortage of reasons. But those have been constants. The factors I cite are new and inflammatory.
Hope you’ll join Carla and Steven and me in Twitter Space tomorrow to discuss Israel’s political crisis.
🗓 Join us on 3/29 at 1:00 p.m. ET for a Twitter Space conversation with @stevenacook, @robbinscarla, and @Martin_Indyk on the current political crisis in Israel. Set a reminder below! ⬇️ on.cfr.org/42M3oDm
My FT oped on the democracy crisis in Israel: Preoccupied with internal tensions, policymakers have little bandwidth to deal with impending external crises. www.ft.com/content/ddd80ff2-160c-435c-a9c3-21280871a8e2
One should never count Bibi out, but his bungling of this crisis could mark a turning point in his standing among the Israeli public.
Israeli TV Ch. 12 instant poll: How do you grade Netanyahu's conduct?
68% bad; 25% good; 7% don't know.
2 Instant polls show Likud and Smotrich-Ben Gvir losing power, and opposition parties (Gantz and Lapid) gaining power.
(Bibi not only losing support but also his legacy).
It feels like Mubarak sending in the camel thugs to beat up the demonstrators in Cairo. Bibi’s last desperate act?
Right-wing WhatsApp groups are buzzing with calls to demonstrate across Israel in defense of the government's judicial coup, with some calling on supporters to take up arms
www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-27/ty-article/.premiu…
Martin Indyk reposted
🗣Netanyahu's Address to the Nation, meant to take place this morning, has been delayed till further notice as he is hammered by coalition partners threatening to resign. Least surprising development of the past 12 weeks.
Things fall apart...
In light of Netanyahu's emerging decision to place judicial overhaul on hold, infighting erupted between Likud and its Coalition allies in the Knesset, leading to the postponing of the announcement.
www.israelhayom.com/2023/03/27/flights-from-israel-ground…
Even @netanyahu’s lawyer is going on strike!
Netanyahu lawyer says he won’t represent him unless overhaul halted www.timesofisrael.com/netanyahu-lawyer-says-he-wont-repre…
Martin Indyk reposted
💥Port of Ashdod is closed.... incalculable damage to the economy.
Likud's Haim Bibas, head of the association of (striking) local council heads: "The outcry is real. This needs to stop. It's time everyone understand - to stop, start negotiating, undo Gallant's dismissal
💥No nursery schools, no shopping malls
One of the protest organizers @GileadSher declares its aim:
At 14:00 a demonstration 🇮🇱 outside the Knesset: the state will remain shut down until the absolute *stopping and abolition* of *all* the laws of the dictatorship.
Martin Indyk reposted
In a stunning development & in a stirring speech, head of the @HistadrutGlobal, Arnon Ben David, with labor & business leaders on stage together, announces immediate general strike demanding an immediate halt to the judicial coup!
#לא_נחייה_תחת_דיקטטורה
@yairlapid statement on arrival at the Knesset today:
…We've never been closer to falling apart. Our national security is at risk, our economy is crumbling, our foreign relations are at their lowest point ever, we don't know what to say to our children about their future in this
This is one of those moments. I call on the government, on the Likud, get a grip, stop the legislation and come talk.
I call on the coalition, let’s go to the President’s Residence, start a real national dialogue…
…at the end of which we will have a constitution based on the Declaration of Independence and a country in which we all live together with mutual respect.
Martin Indyk reposted
"Time to Flood the Streets"
Netanyahu's reckless decision to fire his defense minister for speaking out against the judicial overhaul, spooked Israelis into action. They texted family and friends, and hundreds of thousands went out to protest at midnight.
www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-27/ty-article/.premiu…
Martin Indyk reposted
Israel’s Histadrut Trade Federation announced a general strike, in coordination with the main businesses, to “stop the judicial revolution.” The Israeli Medical Association has also announced that the health sector will go on strike from tomorrow. Netanyahu still silent.
Martin Indyk reposted
#breaking: The biggest labour union in Israel, announces a general strike against the judicial plan
Strikes spreading across Israel. The country is beginning to stop functioning. The more @netanyahu pushes forward, the more the people will push back. Soon pausing the legislation will not be enough to restore normalcy. The revolt is turning into a revolution.
#breaking: Israel main airport Ben Gurion Airport goes on strike - in response to the dismissal of Minister of Defense Gallant and judicial Reform
Martin Indyk reposted
BREAKING: A spokeswoman for the White House National Security Council told me: We are deeply concerned by the ongoing developments in Israel, including the potential impact on military readiness raised by Minister Gallant, which further underscores the urgent need for compromise
Martin Indyk reposted
Join us tomorrow in DC, including @martin_indyk - follow the live on our profile
More then 600,000 Israelis took to the street tonight to save Israeli Democracy
*Now is the time to act!* People who are still on the fence, not taking part, are not friends of Israel
Join a rally: unxeptable.org/events
@IsraeliDefend
#defendisraelidemocracy
#unxeptable
Martin Indyk reposted
Tomorrow at 12:30, Embassy of Israel in DC, another rally in fight for Israeli Democracy. @Martin_Indyk will be there. Come and join us!
@IsraeliDefend @YCharash
Martin Indyk reposted
BREAKING: Israeli Minister of Defense Yoav Gallant calls for an immediate suspension of the judicial overhaul legislation until after independence day (April 25th) and says continuation of the legislation is a threat to Israel's national security
Martin Indyk reposted
Kaplan Street in Tel Aviv ahead of what is expected to be the biggest demonstration so far since the protests against Netanyahu's plan to weaken the supreme court started 12 weeks ago
Martin Indyk reposted
🚨There are initial reports of another shooting in the West Bank town of Huwara
@netanyahu in background briefing declares black is white, down is up, illegal is legal, and ties with Washington are not frayed. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-24/ty-article/.premiu….
The crisis in Israel deepens. @netanyahu is pressing ahead with legislation to give himself power to stack the court despite calls from @POTUS Biden and Defense Minister @yoavgallant to pause and in defiance of his Attorney General’s injunction to stay out of it.
There are ever fewer ways to avoid a full-blown crisis w/ serious security, economic & political consequences for Israel. Despite pressure on many fronts -- foreign leaders, high-tech & business sectors, and security establishment -- Netanyahu shows no signs of slowing down. 16/
Bibi is locked and loaded, hands on the steering wheel, as he drives Israel off the cliff.
BREAKING: Netanyahu says he will not suspend judicial overhaul despite mass protests and will bring to a vote in the coming days a law that will give the government an automatic majority in appointing supreme court judges
Some wisdom from @ShalomLipner about Israel's democratic crisis 👇 www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2023/03/israels-great-…
I don’t remember when was the last time the State Dept summoned an Israeli ambassador formally to convey concern.
State Department summons Israel's ambassador to Washington to convey "U.S. concern regarding legislation passed by the Israeli Knesset rescinding important aspects of the 2005 Disengagement Law."
This is a big deal!
www.state.gov/deputy-secretary-shermans-meeting-with-isra…
Two can play this game: It’s time to review the Pompeo decision that legitimized settlement activity. And Trump’s recognition of Israeli sovereignty on the Golan Heights.
BREAKING: U.S. says new Israeli law to repeal the 2005 disengagement in the northern West Bank is “provocative” & violation of commitments given to the U.S. by two Israeli governments including this week: “We call on Israel to refrain from allowing settlers to return to the area”
Smotrich’s incendiary statements and the coalition’s provocative settlement moves are exasperating the US and Europe, where leaders are already alarmed by Bibi’s anti-democratic moves against the independence of the judiciary. Yaish gvul! There’s a limit. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-21/ty-article/.premiu….
Israel’s premier strategic studies think tank @INSSIsrael rings the alarm bell in its first-ever “Strategic Alert.” It warns of the dire consequences of the judicial reforms already taking place and the impact on Israel’s resiliency. www.inss.org.il/publication/strategic-alert/
If the Knesset decides to repeal the ban on entering evacuated settlements in the northern West Bank, shouldn’t @POTUS Biden withdraw the 2005 Bush letter recognizing the settlement blocs, which was an explicit quid pro quo?
www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/knesset-set-to-repea…
Although the headline doesn't reflect it, the fine print suggests that @netanyahu may have just blinked. Simcha Rothman has announced the delay of most of the judicial reform legislation until the summer session. BUT he still wants to appoint the judges. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-19/ty-article/.premiu…
The Economist (which once labeled Bibi “The Serial Bungler”) declares him unfit and dangerous to Israel’s future: “Alas, his brand is too toxic and he is too bent on self-preservation. His time has passed.” www.economist.com/leaders/2023/03/16/will-bibi-break-israel
Such a pleasure to attend a rehearsal at Tel Aviv’s Music Conservatory of Polyphany, the Arab-Jewish youth orchestra that plays exquisitely beautiful music under conductor Nabeel Ashkar.
Martin Indyk reposted
President Clinton’s Ambassador to Israel @Martin_Indyk: “I am dismayed and very concerned about this judicial revolution and the impact it will have on Israel’s democracy – and therefore the impact it will have on U.S.-Israel relations.”
www.haaretz.com/israel-news/podcasts/2023-03-16/ty-articl…
Martin Indyk reposted
It’s well worth listening to @Martin_Indyk on the domestic situation in 🇮🇱 right now. He certainly knows what he is talking about.
My observations from ground zero in Tel Aviv. Thanks @AllisonKSommer and @amirtibon for a great conversation on the threat to Israel’s democracy on @haaretzcom podcast. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/podcasts/2023-03-16/ty-articl…
My observations from ground zero in Tel Aviv. Thanks @AllisonKSommer and @amirtibon for a great conversation on the threat to Israel’s democracy on @haaretzcom podcast. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/podcasts/2023-03-16/ty-articl…
Takes a lot of training to eat and talk at the same time. Just as well restaurants have banned smoking!
I've never understood how breakfast meetings work. Surely it is not good for the indigestive system to have to chew, listen, swallow, speak on repeat throughout the first meal of the day? It is not natural and it cannot be good.
Martin Indyk reposted
Started this sunny day in Jerusalem with a constructive breakfast with @SwedeninJERU, @EUpalestinians, @Martin_Indyk and others discussing primarily the difficult economic situation in Palestine.
“Netanyahu was given a way out and he chose unity inside his coalition over national unity in Israel.” @AnshelPfeffer nails it. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-15/ty-article/.premiu….
The sad truth is that it’s too late and too early for compromise. Too late because Netanyahu is being dragged along by extremists who have no intention of stopping and too early because the more they push forward the more determined the opposition is to push back. Train wreck.
BREAKING: Netanyahu rejects President Herzog's compromise proposal for judicial reform: "Many parts of his proposal only perpetuate the current status and do not restore the balance between the different branches of power. This is the sad truth"
The US has the strong support of its European allies against Russia. If things go south with China we will have the strong support of our Asian allies. Whether we have Saudi Arabia in our corner is marginal in both cases.
Look how difficult it was for you to get more countries aboard to pressure Russia over Ukraine. If things go south with China you will need the same kind of support. Especially from those providing it with energy.
Come on @BoazTibon! Do you really believe that because China affected a Iran-Saudi reconciliation we lost control of the flow of oil from the Gulf? How many warships does China have in the Gulf?
What a desperate rationalization. By controlling the flow of oil from the Persian Gulf, you had leverage over China. Big one. This is definitely an American defeat.
This also an Israeli defeat. Bibi's defeat.
If you want to play a blame game then the Saudis have their share too. And if we hadn’t develop fracking, they wouldn’t have had to sell so much of their oil to China. But if your point is that the US-Saudi relationship is in need of repair and renovation, I agree.
These are valid points. But isn’t there some validity to the own goal interpretation of the present admin policy towards Riyadh? (From “Make MBS a Pariah” to “give me oil” to “make peace with Israel” to China taking lead in Gulf diplomacy…)
Here’s a more sober bottom-line from @TheEconomist of the Chinese-brokered Iran-Saudi rapprochement:
“But the underlying issues have not changed: this agreement is more about perception than reality.” www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2023/03/10/china…
I’m not sure @POTUS Biden will appreciate @netanyahu criticizing him for “weakness towards Iran” just because Saudi Arabia and Iran affected a diplomatic rapprochement under Chinese auspices. For years, the US has been encouraging this rapprochement because it will help reduce…
1 \ BREAKING: A senior Israeli official said in a briefing with reporters who traveled with Prime Minister Netanyahu to Rome that the agreement between Saudi Arabia and Iran is a result of weakness towards Iran by the U.S., the West and the previous Israeli government
Gulf tensions, which serves US interests. That’s not weakness, it’s common sense (which Bibi seems to be sorely lacking these days). If the rapprochement results in Iran cutting support for Houthis in Yemen, that too will serve US interests in ending the conflict and reducing…
the suffering of the Yemeni people. As for China’s diplomatic achievement, it’s about time it contributed to stability in the Gulf. For years, the US has protected the sea lanes that enable China to import oil from Iran and Saudi Arabia and the Chinese have free-loaded.
Some calm and sensible analysis of the Saudi-Iran agreement to resume diplomatic relations from Jon Alterman. A good antidote to the hyperventilating in much of the media. www.csis.org/analysis/why-did-china-help-saudi-arabia-and…
"Hady and the Peace Processors!"
Finally, @netanyahu has found his voice. He thanks @bezalelsm Smotrich for correcting his “inappropriate” words and then goes on, with classic “whataboutism,” to attack the PA for incitement.
It is important for all of us to work to tone down the rhetoric lower the temperature.
That includes speaking out forcefully against inappropriate statements and even correcting our own statements when we misspeak or when our words are taken out of context >>
Record Number of Israelis Protest Against Netanyahu’s Judicial Coup in 95 locations across Israel. Former Likud minister addresses 150,000 in Tel Aviv. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-03-04/ty-article/.premiu….
My interview on Israel Channel 11 yesterday about the impact of the judicial revolution and ministerial incitement on US-Israel relations.
מרטין אינדיק, לשעבר שגריר ארה"ב בישראל, מזהיר: הרפורמה המשפטית מסכנת את טיב היחסים בין המדינות | לידיעה המלאה >>> www.kan.org.il/item/?itemId=146890
#העולם_היום
Martin Indyk reposted
#russian officials are promoting an information operation that falsely frames Russia’s war in #ukraine as existential to the continued existence of the Russian Federation.
isw.pub/UkrWar02272023
Agreed. He froze discussion of additional settlements. Legalization and building will continue apace.
Sorry Martin Bibi tweeted: no freeze in the settlements
This is a misleading headline. Israel agreed to halt discussion of additional settlement construction. The unprecedented decision to legalize 9 illegal outposts and build 10,000 new settlement units has been grandfathered. It will not be frozen or undone. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-02-26/ty-article/.premiu…
This illustrates how different the situation is from the second intifada.There are 200,000 more settlers in the West Bank today-many of them young and militant. On the other side the Lion’s Den youth are too young to be deterred by what happened back then. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-02-26/ty-article/.premiu…
Here’s the communique from today’s Aqaba security summit. An important forum has been created to try to prevent the violence from escalating out of control. Bringing Jordan and Egypt formally into that process is helpful. But I fear it’s too late. petra.gov.jo/Include/InnerPage.jsp?ID=48480&lang=en&name=…
In the Middle East, only Syria voted against the UNGA resolution that demanded Russia leave Ukraine. Iran and Algeria abstained. All other Arab countries and Israel voted in favor (Lebanon was stuck in traffic).
The UN General Assembly adopted a resolution that demands #russia leave #ukraine.
In favour: 141
Against: 7
Abstentions: 32
Martin Indyk reposted
Can Saudi Arabia, under MBS, ever be a reliable and credible security partner to the United States?
@ayaelb passed my question to @Martin_Indyk, who thinks that the issue of reliability and responsibility is a “challenge” facing U.S.-Saudi relations.
Very happy to be in your company @OrenKessler. Congratulations on the publication of “Palestine 1936”!
(1936 was the year my mother and grandfather left Tel Aviv for Auckland, New Zealand, for reasons I now understand having read your fascinating book.)
B&N Tyson’s Corner! (DC area)
In the esteemed company of @simonmontefiore and @Martin_Indyk
Martin Indyk reposted
Thank you to @Martin_Indyk, @ayaelb, F. Gregory Gause, & Bilal Saab for participating in a discussion on U.S.-Saudi security relations. Watch the full webinar below⬇️
www.youtube.com/watch?v=F2DLM7JSBio
Martin Indyk reposted
“The one thing that would turn Congress around would be full normalization between Saudi Arabia and Israel. I can imagine Chuck Schumer and Kevin McCarthy working together to push for a treaty commitment to Saudi Arabia in that context.” - @Martin_Indyk #meievents
Martin Indyk reposted
“I think that if our security relationship with Saudi Arabia is to be deepened because the Saudis want it, then there are certain obligations that come with that in terms of looking out for American interests as well.” - @Martin_Indyk #meievents
Here’s the text of yesterday’s UNSC Presidential Statement expressing dismay and strong opposition to Israeli settlement activity and condemning violence.
Today, #uaexunsc successfully led the adoption of a Presidential Statement that reiterated the Security Council’s “unwavering commitment” to the two-State solution. The Council also underscored its:
➡️ Dismay with Israel's announcement to proceed with the construction and expansion of settlements and to “legalize” settlement outposts
➡️ Condemnation of all acts of violence targeting civilians, including acts of terrorism
➡️ Calls for upholding the unchanged historic status quo at the holy sites in Jerusalem, and the special role of Jordan in this regard
📖 ⬇️
True, until the situation looked so dangerous that @SecBlinken intervened…and appears to have succeeded. Nothing succeeds like success.
Then that would arguably breathe new life into the peace process. I don't think U.S. understands how Saudi's + Abraham Accords can become pathway to a solution. It just feels like the United States doesn't want to dedicate any effort toward doing so.
That’s right. But what if the US makes it a condition for the things MBS wants from the US?
I think the real question is, does Riyadh have a genuine interest in solving the I/P conflict ? Last time I read, it sounded like the Saudi's were willing to bypass the Palestinian issue and was open to normalizing with the Israelis.
Exactly right. But sometimes in the ME kicking the can down the road can serve a time-buying purpose. The question is what to do with that time. Imagine that PA eliminates “pay to slay” and GOI gives back all the money it’s been withholding. Imagine GOI hands over territory…
What positive process do you have in mind, Martin, that the current Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority are likely to embrace or even come close to embracing? While I applaud Blinken‘s efforts, essentially this is just kicking the can down the road with no answers.
in Area C for Palestinian development as part of a package deal for normalization with Saudi Arabia. “You could say I’m a dreamer, but…” we’ve been so caught up in the negative spiral we’ve forgotten how to think positively. What matters most is that the US has reengaged.
Uh oh! IAEA has found enriched uranium in Iran of 84% purity. Ninety percent is weapons grade. www.wsj.com/articles/near-weapons-grade-enriched-uranium-…
Bravo to @SecBlinken and his team for averting an Israeli-Palestinian crisis. Deft US diplomacy. But what happens in 3 months’ time when the deal expires? Refraining from negative steps needs to be replaced by a positive process. Good first step! www.axios.com/2023/02/19/israel-palestinian-un-security-c…
Martin Indyk reposted
Join @Martin_Indyk, @ayaelb, F. Gregory Gause, & Bilal Saab for a conversation on U.S.-Saudi relations with a focus on security & future strategic cooperation between the two countries.
2/21 @ 12pm ET, register below. www.mei.edu/events/after-oil-security-blueprint-resetting…
Abstention on a UNSC resolution condemning WB settlements is the only thing that will get Netanyahu’s attention.
Courageous and smart analysis from @mkoplow from @IsraelPolicy4m on how to get Netanyahu to stop taking @POTUS Biden for granted. israelpolicyforum.org/2023/02/16/its-time-for-the-u-s-to-…
Epic is right @RationalSettler. It will be the beginning of the end of the Jewish and democratic state. Nothing to celebrate so I won’t be joining you as you take Israel off the cliff.
Ambassador, expanding our towns isn't a done deal, so we're not celebrating...yet. But we are cautiously optimistic. We've been this close before only to have peace processors like you ruin it. But if we get these expansions, please be my guest at the celebration, it'll be epic.
While Israelis are preoccupied with the assault on the independence of their judiciary, the settlers are celebrating Netanyahu’s decision to launch the greatest expansion in the history of the settlement movement. Dismissing the criticism from Western governments Smotrich...
the finance minister told the settlers, “Our hold on areas of the homeland and developing settlements should be admired and seen as a miracle, not denounced...The settlements will continue to thrive.”
Now the action moves to the UN Security Council. If the Pals play it smart they’ll avoid Jerusalem and use US language opposing the settlements, making it possible for Biden to abstain. But they'll probably insist on too much and end up with a US veto. www.timesofisrael.com/palestinians-readying-security-coun…
Are you referring to the Indian government too, @RRRameshRRR? Did Modi even express concern?
Nothing.
Important that US and major European allies are "deeply troubled" and "strongly opposed" to Netanyahu's unprecedented settlements decision that creates 9 new settlements and 10,000 new units. But what will these mighty nations do about it?
www.state.gov/joint-statement-of-the-foreign-ministers-of…
It was good to be back on set with @jdickerson talking about Israeli judicial reform. John’s a Master of the Game of interviewing.
My interview with ABC Radio Australia on the civil revolt in Israel.
In Jerusalem, an estimated 100,000 Israelis took to the streets overnight, outside the country's Parliament.
The protesters gathered in opposition to laws that they say threaten the sovereignty of the courts.
@Martin_Indyk
www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/breakfast/thousands…
Not holding my breath but at least they're talking, and under the auspices of the Israeli president.
BREAKING: Minister of Justice Yariv Levin & the chairman of the Knesset judicial & legislative committee @rothmar invited opposition leader Yair Lapid and former MoD Benny Gantz for a meeting with President Herzog tonight to launch negotiations on the judicial plan
These decisions come in the face of explicit opposition by the Biden Administration, expressed publicly by @SecBlinken and in private by other senior officials, because of the negative impact they will have on the hope of a two state solution. Something needs to be done!
BREAKING: The Israeli security cabinet decided to legalize 9 illegal outposts in the West Bank and turn them into new settlements, connect dozens of other illegal outposts to state infrastructure and approve planning & building of thousands of new housing units in the settlements
Statement by 56 leading US economists, including 11 Nobel prize winners, warning of the deleterious effects on the Israeli economy that will flow from Netanyahu’s anti-democratic judicial reforms. 👇👇👇
statement-by-leading-us-economists.net
Martin Indyk reposted
For the 6th week in a row, mass protests against Netanyahu's plan to weaken the judicial system. According to assessments, more than 100K people are demonstrating tonight across Israel - in Tel Aviv (here in the drone footage👇), Jerusalem, Haifa & a dozen other major cities
“What a citizen she was!” @Peggynoonannyc ‘s beautifully poignant remembrance of Ann Korologos. “She made institutions work.”
Ann Korologos will be buried today. A remarkable woman, taken from her loving husband Tom and all her friends too suddenly and too soon. As her successors at the ME Investment Initiative we dedicate ourselves to preserving her legacy. Rest in peace, Ann. www.washingtonpost.com/obituaries/2023/01/31/ann-mclaughl…
Just read this poignant report by @peterbakernyt of Michael Gerson’s memorial. Compassionate conservatism seems to have died with Michael but his words remain: “...even when strength fails, there is perseverance. And even when perseverance fails..
As friends and admirers paid tribute to Mike Gerson this week, some worried that the notion of "compassionate conservatism" that he championed will be buried along with him. www.nytimes.com/2023/02/10/us/politics/michael-gerson-mem…
...there is hope. And even when hope fails, there is love. And love never fails.” Michael’s memory is a blessing.
As far as I know, they weren't planning to have Bibi visit in the short term even before the civil revolt erupted in Israel. They planned a three step : Sullivan and Blinken to Israel and then a substantive phone call with POTUS. But now they have a better justification for delay
One casualty of the judiciary debate in Israel is U.S. seems in no hurry to invite PM @netanyahu to the White House.Based on talks with people in the Admin.,they have a wait and see attitude given all the controversy. With past terms as guide, Bibi thought he would at WH by now.
Israeli civil society is still in open revolt tonight against Netanyahu’s judicial reforms.
More than 100 thousand Israelis are demonstrating tonight in Tel Aviv and other cities around the country against Netanyahu's plan to weaken the supreme court and other Democratic institutions. This is the 6th week in a row demonstrations are taking place
Thanks for noticing @wgkantai. I hope you enjoy the rest of “Master of the Game.”
This is the first I have ever heard that Brezhnev was in as serious a psychological crisis as Nixon was during the Yom Kippur War.
From @Martin_Indyk’s ‘Master of the Game’
If you’re a Jewish-American and haven’t read this already, you should. It’s an open letter from three centrist Israeli journalists, all staunch defenders of Israel, calling on all of us to speak out against Netanyahu’s judicial reforms. www.timesofisrael.com/an-open-letter-to-israels-friends-i…
Martin Indyk reposted
This is the first I have ever heard that Brezhnev was in as serious a psychological crisis as Nixon was during the Yom Kippur War.
From @Martin_Indyk’s ‘Master of the Game’
Martin Indyk reposted
. “Master of the Game: Henry Kissinger and the Art of Middle East Diplomacy” by Ambassador @Martin_Indyk.
Important history For all diplomats, interested people and decision makers, the book is now in Arabic edition.
Martin Indyk reposted
Israel and the occupied West Bank are gripped by the deadliest bloodshed in years.
The US says the immediate priority is to restore calm. @ritula, @Martin_Indyk, @nour_odeh and @InbarProf consider how realistic this is
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct33q6?at_bbc_team=editorial
Mazel Tov, Tal. Shalom Sudan. That’s four on your belt. Where to next?
Worried about Ukraine? Don’t be. According to the always reliable @TheStudyofWar , Putin has ordered the conquest of Luhansk and Donetsk Oblasts by March 2023. But “Putin may have overestimated the Russian military’s own capabilities again. ISW has observed no evidence that…
Russian forces have restored sufficient combat power to defeat Ukraine’s forces in eastern Ukraine.” ISW assesses that Putin’s offensive will likely culminate in April without achieving any significant objective.Then expect a Ukrainian counter-offensive with newly acquired tanks.
The Pals should certainly do that but if they did, Bibi would disparage and trash them because to take the deal would lead to his downfall. He learned that lesson at Wye in 1998 and will never give up West Bank territory again. That's why “peace for peace” is his slogan.
If the Palestinians united behind a leadership that accepts the concept of a Jewish state living next to a demilitarized Palestinian state, Bibi would take that deal. For now, they are too angry to go there to the detriment of their own long term interests.
Israel was acting in its enlightened self-interest. And now Israel employs 150,000 Palestinians, hugely benefiting the Palestinian economy. But at the same time 560,000 Israeli settlers moved into the West Bank and settled the land. You didn’t mention that.
Soon after the Six Day War, Israel adopted a liberal policy aimed at radically improving the lives of the Arabs - a 🧵
(1) Universal education was instituted
(2) universities were opened
(3) hospitals were built
(4) modern roads were cut into the hills.
1/8
@amirtibon in @haaretzcom sets the record straight on Israeli judicial reforms after Netanyahu’s misleading claims in his interview with CNN’s @jaketapper. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-02-01/ty-article/.premiu…
Re-upping this piece by NYTimes’s Brett Stephens, a staunch defender of Israel, in case you’re inclined to accept Netanyahu’s spin in his interview with CNN’s @jaketapper www.nytimes.com/2023/01/24/opinion/jewish-leaders-zelensk…
Watching Netanyahu’s CNN interview it’s clear he’s lost none of his ability to spin even @jaketapper.
1. He claims he made “peace for peace” with the Arabs as if he paid nothing for peace with states that weren’t even at war with Israel. In fact he paid with promises…
…not to annex the West Bank and to support the sale of F35s to the UAE.
2. He claims the Palestinians have never accepted Israel’s existence. In fact the PLO recognized Israel’s “right to exist” in September 1993.
3. He claims he’ll allow Palestinians to govern themselves
but Israel has to have “overriding security control.” In fact that means Israel will maintain the military occupation forever.
4. He claims his judicial reforms will align Israel with other democratic states but the states he’s talking about are the illiberal democracies.
in fact he was never asked to accept it because Abu Mazen was not willing to respond to it (on that he was accurate).
6. He claims that the US took a “huge chunk” of Israel’s military supplies to give to Ukraine when in fact they are American supplies prepositioned in Israel...
That's at least six Scaramuccis.
We shall see. Area C land would be good.
After Blinken’s visit to Jerusalem and Ramallah, US diplomacy enters a new phase of greater effort to promote calm and steps toward eventual reconciliation. Let’s hope it’s not too late. www.haaretz.com/us-news/2023-01-31/ty-article/.premium/u-….
Martin Indyk reposted
On the growing unease in Washington over Israel’s extreme-right turn, with insights from @Martin_Indyk, @RepRashida, and @ShibleyTelhami
time.com/6251298/blinken-israel-visit-us-tensions/
Very proud that the great Egyptian publishing house @NahdetMisrgroup has just published “Master of the Game” in Arabic. They did an excellent job with the translation assisted by my friend @VictorShalhoub.
. “Master of the Game: Henry Kissinger and the Art of Middle East Diplomacy” by Ambassador @Martin_Indyk.
Important history For all diplomats, interested people and decision makers, the book is now in Arabic edition.
“Blue is blue.” @USAmbIsrael Tom Nides explains to Israelis that Arab and Palestinian-Americans must be allowed free entry into Israel if Israelis are to enjoy visa-free entry into the United States. A lesson in “reciprocity.”
Martin Indyk reposted
.@ZelenskyyUa: “Never again to hatred. Never again to indifference. The more nations of the world overcome indifference, the less space there will be in the world for hatred. Eternal memory to all victims of the Holocaust!”
Martin Indyk reposted
We are horrified by today's deadly terror attack in a synagogue in Jerusalem, in which at least seven worshippers were murdered. We offer heartfelt condolences to the victims' families and wish a swift recovery to those injured.
Saddened and sickened by the murder of seven Israelis this Shabbat eve outside a synagogue in Jerusalem by a Palestinian resident of the city. I grieve for all the victims of this bloody conflict and condemn the perpetrators and those who celebrate the death of innocents.
OMG!
BREAKING: 5 Israelis killed in a shooting attack in Jerusalem. Perpetrator killed
Was the elderly woman a terrorist too? Or did you run out of characters to express your regret at the “collateral damage?”
Ambassador @Martin_Indyk left out the major terrorist attack the Palestinian terror community was planning against Israeli civilians that led to the IDF raid of Jenin today. Did you run out of characters in your tweet?
Just another bloody Thursday in the West Bank: 9 Pals killed by the IDF in Jenin including an elderly woman; the PA decides (yet again) that it will reduce security cooperation and appeal to ICC; settlers plan 18,000 new units; and Sec Blinken announces he’s visiting next week.
All praise goes to them but a little birdie told me it was your idea. So, well done!
Thanks, Martin - but the “well done” belongs to the terrific @HolocaustMuseum team and, especially 92 year-old dynamo Ruth Cohen, whose gripping story of surviving ghetto, deportation, #auschwitz and other labor camps to build a new life in America left an indelible impact.
Just another bloody Thursday in the West Bank: 9 Pals killed by the IDF in Jenin including an elderly woman; the PA decides (yet again) that it will reduce security cooperation and appeal to ICC; settlers plan 18,000 new units; and Sec Blinken announces he’s visiting next week.
Amid all the bleak reports from Israel, here's a good news story and a heartwarming photo. Well done @robsatloff.
I was honored to participate w/@HolocaustMuseum team in #holocaust Remembrance Day event at @Zayed_U in #abudhabi, hosted by #uae Culture Minister @NouraAlKaabi, w/special guest #auschwitz survivor #ruthcohen, who shared her powerful story.
Israeli National Missions Minister Orit Struck:“We have taken upon ourselves in this government...the holy task of strengthening and reinforcing settlement...the national task whose final goal is, as is cited explicitly in the coalition agreement, the application of sovereignty.”
Israeli civil society is in open revolt against the proposed judicial reforms. Yesterday, over 300 economists, a Nobel Prize economist, and 3 Bank of Israel governors warned of the high risk that Israel’s credit rating will be adversely impacted.
Breaking: The Israeli software company, Papaya Global, has announced its decision to withdraw its business from Israel in response to Netanyahu’s proposed judicial reform - the first company to do so.
Want to be a good citizen? Then check this out. @RichardHaass talking with Morning Joe about his new book: “The Ten Habits of Good Citizens.” youtu.be/dQhSnXcw4Es
Mick Davis is the former head of Britain's Conservative Party and leader of the British Jewish community. His appeal to diaspora Jews to man the barricades is important reading 👇👇👇 www.jewishnews.co.uk/opinion-seeing-theocrats-and-bigots-… via @JewishNewsUK
Bravo Bret Stephens for speaking the truth about Netanyahu’s “move along the current of illiberal democracy.” As he concludes stingingly, “the Jewish people’s greatest leader resides in Kyiv rather than Jerusalem.” www.nytimes.com/2023/01/24/opinion/jewish-leaders-zelensk…
Pay-to-slay! apnews.com/article/israel-government-only-on-ap-yitzhak-r…
I rest my case.
I don’t consider Jews building on their historic homeland “illegal.” I shudder at the thought.
Settler violence is horrible, but let’s recognize it as the small issue it is. It hardly happens and you know it. Palestinian terrorism is a much larger and more frequent problem.
The “arm around Israel” approach is working (so far). Yesterday, on orders from Defense Minister Galant, the IDF dismantled an illegal outpost, despite protests from Smotrich and Ben Gvir. This comes in the immediate aftermath of Jake Sullivan’s meeting with Bibi.
And it's double the number that attended last weekend’s rally.
To my U.S. followers: This is the equivalent of 4 million people demonstrating in New York
Not quite. As I show in “Master of the Game” Kissinger was determined to ensure that American arms were not defeated by Soviet arms but he was also determined to prevent Egypt from being defeated so badly by Israel that Sadat could not enter peace negotiations. Quite similar to..
Unfortunately there is a difference: The US had highest interest that the YK war was finished decisively. Here the geopolitical interests of the US are better served when this war drags out as long as possible. In theory, european interests should be different, but yeah.
Ukraine where Biden wants Russia set back enough to accept a lasting peace but not enough that it escalates to nuclear conflict. Superpowers have different interests than their smaller power clients. But sometimes the tail can wag the dog.
Saudi FM @faisalbinfarhan appears definitive about Saudi “true normalization” with Israel not coming before Palestinian statehood. That’s not what MBS has told his U.S. and Israeli interlocutors. Shockingly, Saudi leaders seem to be saying different things to different audiences.
🇸🇦 🇮🇱 🇵🇸 “True normalization and true stability will only come through giving the Palestinians (...) a state”. @KSAmofaEN @FaisalbinFarhan @Davos
Excellent reporting by @helenecooper et al on a critical shift in US strategy to give Ukraine the weapons it needs to change Putin's calculus and convince him that to continue the war risks losing Crimea as well as the territory he occupied after Feb 2022. www.nytimes.com/2023/01/18/us/politics/ukraine-crimea-mil…
Martin Indyk reposted
Jacinda Ardern rewrote the rulebook for how world leaders are supposed to look and act, and further endeared the citizens of the world to NZ because of it. A masterclass in international public diplomacy. Best wishes to PM Ardern and her family.
More evidence of Moscow’s waning influence on its periphery as a result of being bogged down in Ukraine. www.wsj.com/articles/russias-influence-wanes-in-ex-soviet…
@Max_Fisher's interesting effort to draw lessons from past wars for the Ukraine conflict, misinterprets the lessons of the October 1973 Yom Kippur War 🧵. Sadat did not launch war to "reestablish regional dominance." He launched war in order to make peace. www.nytimes.com/2023/01/16/world/europe/russia-ukraine-wa…
The lessons from 1973 for the Ukraine conflict? The US and its allies need to resupply the Ukrainian armed forces with sufficient weapons to pressure Russia into accepting both a ceasefire AND the UN principle of no acquisition of territory by force.
Disengagement negotiations should then proceed on the basis of Russian withdrawal in stages to "secure and recognized borders."
Martin Indyk reposted
apparently, they will appoint Aryeh Deris' son in his place. Would love to be the fly on the wall in their home
BREAKING: This 10:1 Israeli Supreme Court decision escalates the constitutional crisis and generates a political crisis for Bibi’s coalition. I suspect Bibi will uphold the Court’s decision, remove Deri from office, then use it to step up his campaign against the Supreme Court.
BREAKING: Israeli Supreme Court revokes appointment of minister Aryeh Deri. My report on @axios
www.axios.com/2023/01/18/israeli-supreme-court-revokes-ap…
Martin Indyk reposted
Rosen’s request to avoid meeting Ben-Gvir, Smotrich or their allies will set the tone for U.S. lawmakers visiting the country in the future, reports @Bsamuels0 in @haaretzcom www.haaretz.com/us-news/2023-01-17/ty-article/.premium/pr…
"The whole house is about to be destroyed. There was nothing like this in all my days at home, so dangerous and serious.” That’s former Israeli Minister of Justice Dan Meridor speaking before the Knesset’s Law and Justice Cttee today about the proposed judicial reforms.
Martin Indyk reposted
I've been working on the Berlin crisis (1958-61), reading hundreds and hundreds of documents, secondary literature etc, so here's a thread that summarises my findings. Although it's deep history, I think it's relevant for our understanding of crises in general, including today.
Students of the balance of power take note - there are signs of Putin’s waning power on Russia’s periphery. What starts in Nagorno-Karabakh will surely spread to Syria where Iran and Turkey are well-placed to take advantage. www.nytimes.com/2023/01/17/world/europe/armenia-azerbaija…
First it was @SenatorMenendez. Now it’s @SenJackyRosen leading a bipartisan Senate delegation to Israel. These are two of the most pro-Israel Senators but they want nothing to do with Ben Gvir and Smotrich.That tells you something. www.axios.com/2023/01/17/rosen-ben-gvir-smotrich-far-righ…
Israel’s Supreme Court Chief Justice Esther Hayut speaks out against Justice Minister @YarivLevine ‘s proposed changes to the system of justice: “The plan is not a plan to fix the justice system - it is a plan to crush it. It will severely damage the independence of the judges...
...and their ability to faithfully fulfill their role as public servants. The meaning of this bad plan is therefore to change the democratic identity of the country beyond recognition.”
Martin Indyk reposted
@Martin_Indyk: “What Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia has said to the Israelis is essentially: “I don’t care anymore about the Palestinians. What I want you to do is help me in Washington. Use your influence in Washington to improve the US-Saudi relationship & get me the arms..” 1/2
🎧📨 On this episode of The President's Inbox, @Martin_Indyk sits down with @JamesMLindsay to discuss the consequences of Benjamin Netanyahu’s return as Israel’s prime minister.
Tune in below ⬇️ on.cfr.org/3Czo5Xp
Martin Indyk reposted
🎧📨 On this episode of The President's Inbox, @Martin_Indyk sits down with @JamesMLindsay to discuss the consequences of Benjamin Netanyahu’s return as Israel’s prime minister.
Tune in below ⬇️ on.cfr.org/3k931kx
Martin Indyk reposted
🎧📨 On this episode of The President's Inbox, @Martin_Indyk sits down with @JamesMLindsay to discuss the consequences of Benjamin Netanyahu’s return as Israel’s prime minister.
Tune in below ⬇️ on.cfr.org/3Czo5Xp
Me too! May his memory be a blessing, from a great admirer.
My conversation with @JamesMLindsay on @CFR_org ‘s The President’s Inbox about the new Israeli government and the challenges it will pose to @POTUS45 Biden. www.cfr.org/podcasts/israels-new-government-martin-indyk
That's just not true. There was no duress; just the wisdom of Israel’s prime ministers at the time and ever since-including Netanyahu.
You’re obfuscating. There are rabbis who endorsed it for purely religious reasons. But otherwise it’s done under duress to avoid the murderous Arab reaction. It’s a reflection the the religious supremacy and hatred that is at the core of the conflict.
Martin Indyk reposted
In a sometimes bitter debate about a contentious visit by an Israeli Minister to a holy site, I’m with @Martin_Indyk here against an utterly disingenuous set of arguments.
“Just walking around?” Why couldn't he take his morning walk somewhere else instead of causing a needless provocation and trangressing against the judgment of the Chief Rabbis?
He was actually just waking around; the entire 15 minute visit was on video. Why do you insinuate nefarious actions when the actions are literally on video and easily researched?
I'm not the Halacha Police and would never aspire to be. I was simply pointing out that if the prayer is only audible to the person praying how would anybody else know whether he was praying? Ben Gvir and his fellow travelers make very clear that their intention is to pray...
It’s actually called Standing Prayer, and is supposed to be loud enough to be audible to yourself, is not quite silent. In any case, since when did you become the Halacha Police!?
on the Temple Mount/Haram a-Sharif. Not just to visit but to pray. They intend to change the status quo.
There you go again - answering a question with a question. But I'll answer yours: the supposed “act of discrimination” was a decision made by the government of Israel in 1967 and upheld by every Israeli government since,including all the Likud-led governments. And...
Why should a Jew feel the need to stay away from the most sacred spot to Jews just to honor an absurd act of discrimination against Jews?
it was endorsed by the Rabbinical authorities ever since.
“Just walking around?” Why couldn't he take his morning walk somewhere else instead of causing a needless provocation and trangressing against the judgment of the Chief Rabbis?
He was actually just waking around; the entire 15 minute visit was on video. Why do you insinuate nefarious actions when the actions are literally on video and easily researched?
Even @AlanDersh speaks out against @netanyahu ‘s judicial reform 'tragedy'. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-01-08/ty-article/staunch….
Thank you @RationalSettler, which is why it’s called silent prayer. If a Jew goes up onto the Temple Mount/Noble Sanctuary and says a prayer loud enough only for him/her to hear how would anyone else know they were praying?
Ambassador, with all due respect, this is an area I know well. The amidah is to be said loud enough for you to hear but not loud enough for anyone else to hear. It’s called the silent Shemoneh Esrei to differentiate it from other parts of prayer that is said out loud.
I haven't studied it @RationalSettler , I’ve said silent prayers every time I’ve gone to synagogue. It’s called the Amidah. It’s said silently by the congregation and then repeated out loud. Just happens to be the central prayer of the Jewish liturgy.
Ambassador @Martin_Indyk you might not have studied this previously, but according to Halacha (Jewish law) prayer must be vocalized aloud.
The need for vocalization is why there is an issue with Jewish prayer, otherwise, you’d be correct.
Martin Indyk reposted
There is absolute justification for keeping the status quo and refraining from lighting matches next to open flames.
This govt has no right to condemn us to endless wars.
Hear the #mothers_call
Get back to negotiations.
www.womenwagepeace.org.il/women-partners-for-peace/
I do.
Martin, do you believe there is any justification for Israel to control the Western Wall and for Jews to be living in the Jewish Quarter?
So you dispute the rulings of the Chief Rabbis in Jerusalem? A hochem!
That is ridiculous. Since the beginning of time, Mount Moriah has been set aside as the premier place of prayer. To this day Jews focus their prayers in the direction of the Temple Mount so that their prayers can ascend to heaven via that spot (I Kings 9, II chronicles 8)
There is absolute justification. It’s called “shalom bayit.” There’s also the consistent position of the chief rabbis that, for Jews, praying on the Temple Mount is a sin.
There is absolutely no justification for telling Jews they can't pray on their most sancified place, the Temple Mount, simply because Muslims claim Jews praying on the Temple Mount offends them.
The United Nations Security Council will meet today - at the request of the UAE - to discuss Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir’s visit to the Haram a-Sharif/Temple Mount yesterday.
Indeed.
Martin if what you suggested occurs .It will put the normalization process on thin ice.
Too early for that. But when Smotrich and Ben Gvir generate a crisis in US-Israel relations, Israel-Diaspora relations, and Israel-Arab relations simultaneously, Israelis might begin to ask. And that's coming.
Absolutely correct! Also shows the high cost of pandering to extremist groups for the sake of stitching a coalition. Hopefully there’s a question floating somewhere: Is it worth the cost to national interest?
Logical Consequences of Ben Gvir’s 13 minute visit to the Haram a-Sharif/Temple Mount (a 🧵):
1. UAE postpones Bibi’s visit to Abu Dhabi
2. Jordan leads furious condemnation by Arab world.
3. Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Turkey join in...
to extend visiting hours and allow prayer on the Haram a-Sharif/Temple Mount.
And that's just in the first 24 hours since Ben Gvir made his provocative move. As leader of the opposition @yairlapid noted before the visit...
this is what happens when Netanyahu puts “the most irresponsible person in the Middle East responsible over the most volatile place in the Middle East.”
Perhaps. But the elephant in the room is whether Israel is going to help Ukraine defend against Iranian drones.
When you speak to Lavrov before you speak to Germany, France, UK and Ukraine - that's a more pro-Russian line in my opinion
It’s not about stealing; it’s about competing claims. BUT, in my many years of dealing with @netanyahu, he has never before claimed an “exclusive” right to “all areas of the Land of Israel.” He was willing to share the land, at times even based on the 1967 lines. Not any more.
FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA! l
This is the most honest Israeli government statement ever!
It’s the Yakov style of governing:
“If I don’t steal it… Well, I’m gonna steal it! Actually, I already stole it.”
Rest in peace, Barbara Walters, one of the great TV interviewers of all time. Here she is talking about her historic joint interview with Anwar Sadat and Menachem Begin after Sadat’s visit to Jerusalem in November 1977. May here memory be for a blessing. youtu.be/unwvV947X1U
Martin Indyk reposted
This is probably the most egregious bit where Smotrich says his policy doesn’t mean changing the political or legal status of the occupied territories while annexation actually appears in the coalition agreement and his plans certainly change the legal status of the settlements
Mistrust and verify… www.wsj.com/articles/israels-new-government-isnt-what-you…
Famed Israeli author David Grossman paints a disturbing picture of the Netanyahu government’s threat to Israeli democracy. 👇 www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2022-12-28/ty-article-opinion…
Martin Indyk reposted
My top 6 books read in 2022 (out of 81):
- The Pope and Mussolini, @DavidKertzer
- Master of the Game par @Martin_Indyk
- The Kite Runner, @khaledhosseini
- The Love Songs of W.E.B. Du Bois, @BlkLibraryGirl
- Opening Day, @jonathaneig
- People Love Dead Jews @DaraHorn
Thank you @peterbakernyt. The Divider and The Man Who Ran Washington are on the top of my list!
Looking for a good book for a holiday gift? Here are some of my favorites from 2022. m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10228530146015279&id=…
@davidfrum captures the meaning of the Zelensky moment for America. 👇👇👇 www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/12/volodymyr-zelen…
Well said @FoxmanAbraham. Bibi deserves to be congratulated on forming a government. He won a democratic election, fair and square. Now let's see what he does with his renewed power. Abe hopes; I doubt.
Congratulations PM on your new government- now we wait to see which promises you will fulfill- those you made to all of Israel’s citizens and to the Jewish people —- or to the promises you made to your new coalition partners. We who love and cherish Israel- hope the former.
In case you missed this critical turning point in U.S.-Iran relations...
The nuclear deal with Iran “is dead,” Biden admitted, even as he was maintaining that he won’t announce the JCPOA has died.
The US lives with Pakistani bombs, Indian bombs, North Korean bombs. We can live with an Iranian bomb. But can our Israeli and Arab allies? And if not, can we live with a Middle Eastern nuclear arms race or the consequences for regional stability of an Israeli preventive strike?
It's past time for the US to consider extending a nuclear deterrent umbrella to our Middle Eastern allies. An unpopular move for sure, but one that looks increasingly and urgently necessary.
Did you forget that he committed to no annexation in the West Bank in return for normalization with the UAE?
Totally. It’s cost-free for MBS and might help him with the US. But Bibi is not playing for marginal advantage. He badly wants normalization with Saudi Arabia. He now believes he can get it without any Palestinian concessions.
He may, but it would be surprising if he really *believes* Netanyahu can help him with Biden. MBS may simply be happy for Netanyahu to help him, if he can. Why not?
The Abraham Accords are Bibi’s legacy. To protect them he needs MBZ’s goodwill. To promote them he needs Joe Biden’s goodwill. But above all he needs to keep the lid on violence in the West Bank and Gaza. And for all that he needs to restrain and contain Smotrich and Ben Gvir.
A relevant precedent: when launching Abraham Accords, signatories sought to insulate normalization fm I-P developments. Since 5/21, Lapid, Bennett, Gantz were repeatedly advised that I-P violence risked pace of normalization, even protecting that which had been accomplished.
But to stay out of jail Bibi also needs Smotrich and Ben Gvir. It’s a helluva balancing act. Bibi is a master of the game but this is going to be the toughest challenge he has ever faced.
One of my few good tweets.
That is correct. So either the FM didn’t get the memo, or — shockingly — the Saudis are saying one thing in public and another thing in private to the Israelis.
As I said, “equally improbable.” But Bibi is going to try. And that means he has to make nice to the Dems, starting with Joe, his “good friend of 40 years.”
And what have I been saying all day @Ibishblog? “All I’m saying is that MBS has recruited Bibi to the task of helping mend U.S.-Saudi ties and that Bibi fully intends to try, believing it will lead to Israeli-Saudi normalization without any concessions to the Palestinians.”
WHAT HAVE I BEEN SAYING ALL DAY @Martin_Indyk?
“Bibi, who spent so many years dissing Obama and Dems, and prioritizing relations with the GOP & evangelical groups over liberal Jews, is an unlikely bridge-builder between KSA and Democrats.”
EXACTLY! www.nytimes.com/2022/12/15/opinion/israel-palestinians-ar…
Agree @rmslim. Things have already escalated in WB even before Smotrich and Ben Gvir get to work. But Bibi will do his best to keep the lid on. Despite the braggadocio he’s always cautious in using force. See in the Al-Arabiya interview how proud he is of his record on this.
things might escalate soon in WB which will prompt a strong response from Netanyahu govt. then no Arab govt incl KSA & other GCC govts would want to be seen siding with Israeli govt.
Prison? Here’s another news flash: Bibi is not going to prison during his upcoming term as PM, either because he’ll change the law or change the Attorney General, or both.
Can Bibi do that from prison? The guy's one in a million, I'm tellin' ya...
R u sure? To be clear, something important has happened. MBS has shifted the goal posts. He is no longer conditioning normalization on what happens with the Palestinians. Instead it’s conditioned on an equally improbable requirement: that Bibi solve his problem with the U.S.
There won’t be Israeli-Saudi normalization anytime soon but Bibi will no longer feel any pressure to pursue reconciliation with the Palestinians in order to achieve it.
As for US-Saudi ties being “strongly on the mend,” that would be news to senior Biden officials. Last time I checked the “reevaluation” of relations is still very much their ongoing policy.
How could Netanyahu, of all people, convince Biden to change his attitude towards MBS? I get there’s a personal problem between them but Bibi has one too. And US-Saudi ties are strongly on the mend despite clear personal coldness between the 2 leaders. This seems hollow to me.
Improbable, certainly. All I’m saying is that MBS has recruited Bibi to the task of helping mend U.S.-Saudi ties and that Bibi fully intends to try, believing it will lead to Israeli-Saudi normalization without any concessions to the Palestinians.
How could Netanyahu, of all people, convince Biden to change his attitude towards MBS? I get there’s a personal problem between them but Bibi has one too. And US-Saudi ties are strongly on the mend despite clear personal coldness between the 2 leaders. This seems hollow to me.
Palestinian Chicken - 2nd season.
That’s the theory. In practice more likely there’ll be no F35s, no normalization, and more Palestinians (and Israelis) killed.
Who’s delusional, me or MBS?
Beg to differ @Ibishblog. MBS has a problem with Biden and he believes Bibi can help him. He has set a high bar for normalization but he has conveyed to Israel that it no longer involves progress on the Palestinian issue. That’s why Bibi is so excited. What he wants from Bibi…
They don't need him and they're not interested in normalizing with Israel under current circumstances. I'd say Netanyahu will have a hard enough time repairing his own ties to Biden, even though US-Israel relations are still fine. But, really, the Saudi's don't need this guy.
…is help with a security guarantee from the US and arms sales, including F35s. That’s why Bibi told Al-Arabiya that he will tell Biden to reaffirm the alliance with Saudi Arabia. The delicious irony in this situation is that Bibi can only deliver on MBS’s requirements if …
…he makes nice to Biden and the Democrats. No more playing the Republicans off against the Dems. And it gives Biden leverage over Bibi.
Have you become a Bibi skeptic @DanArbell?
….and if you believe a word of what Bibi is saying here there’s a bridge in Brooklyn I’d want to sell you
Here he comes: Bibi signals to Saudi-owned Al-Arabiya that he will be taking MBS's cause to Washington, pressing Biden to reaffirm the alliance with Saudi Arabia. In return? He wants normalization with Saudi Arabia ahead of progress with the Palestinians. youtu.be/fpfnhvx1AcI
Felicitations et mazel tov to @DanielSeidemann. So well-deserved.
🎖️🇫🇷 Le Consul général de France à Jérusalem a remis la Légion d’honneur à @DanielSeidemann, fondateur de l’ONG @TJJerusalem, pour son engagement au service de la paix à Jérusalem et de la solution à deux Etats.
Here he comes: Bibi signals to Saudi-owned Al-Arabiya that he will be taking MBS's cause to Washington, pressing Biden to reaffirm the alliance with Saudi Arabia. In return? He wants normalization with Saudi Arabia ahead of progress with the Palestinians. youtu.be/fpfnhvx1AcI
Henry Kissinger talks to @LowyInstitute director @mfullilove about Putin, Zelensky and Xi Jinping. His views on Putin (“a character out of Dostoevsky”) are particularly interesting. Definitely worth a listen. 👇 pca.st/episode/b60079e2-0909-45ea-b67c-ccdb6420ab73
Martin Indyk reposted
🎧On this week's episode of the Decision Points podcast, @Martin_Indyk discusses former Secretary of State and National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger’s regional strategy from the 1973 war to the beginnings of the peace process.
Listen: shows.acast.com/decision-points/episodes/kissingers-middl…
Martin Indyk reposted
We were privileged to hear from several distinguished leaders including Prime Minister @yairlapid, President @Isaac_Herzog, President @BillClinton, and former Sec. of State @JohnKerry. They offered meaningful, heartfelt congratulations to @Martin_Indyk:
youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_frjZouo78fSBUjYbLf205wvvsG0KyQb
Martin Indyk reposted
We were honored to be joined by @StateDept Special Representative Hady Amr, who offered greetings on behalf of @POTUS and @SecBlinken, and presented his friend and honoree @Martin_Indyk with his award.
Martin Indyk reposted
Ex-US envoy @Martin_Indyk to Israel predicts ‘dark times’ will precede renewed interest in peace www.timesofisrael.com/ex-us-envoy-to-israel-predicts-dark… via @timesofisrael
Martin Indyk reposted
“Be ready when that moment comes, and it will come just like it’s come every other time when people have suffered from violence and tried all the alternatives, they will come back to the idea of pursuing peace.”
What an honor to hear from @Martin_Indyk. So incredibly inspired.
Ex-US envoy to Israel predicts ‘dark times’ will precede renewed interest in peace www.timesofisrael.com/ex-us-envoy-to-israel-predicts-dark… via @timesofisrael
Thanks @DavidMakovsky for a great conversation in Decision Points Podcast (Season 4!) on Henry Kissinger’s Middle East strategy.
On today’s Decision Points, @Martin_Indyk discusses Henry Kissinger’s Middle East strategy. Listen to how the U.S. balanced Cold War grand strategy & regional aims in 1973 and how Kissinger laid the groundwork Israel's peace w/ largest Arab country, Egypt. play.acast.com/s/5db0a7590a8d06631ea7967e/638a71245908900…
What a team! Helping each other bomb Ukrainian civilians and beat up Iranian women. An axis of evil.
#breaking Iran has officially requested Russia to help it quell the popular uprising through the sales of anti-riot vehicles and equipment and dispatch of Russian advisors as it's preparing for a long-term confrontation with protesters, according to reports obtained by @IranIntl.
Saudi Arabia and the UAE aren’t the only ones to face the abandonment/entrapment dilemma in their relations with the US. Even a formal ally like Australia faces the problem, according to this @LawDavF report from Down Under. open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/aukus-and-alliance?r=zgqu
Want to understand how the Chinese superpower wields its “soft power” globally? Then check this out👇👇👇
In a new book, out TODAY, @JoshKurlantzick analyzes China's attempts to become a media, information, and influence superpower, seeking to shape the domestic politics, local media, and information environments around the world.
Order your copy ⬇️
on.cfr.org/3FkGr0s
You'd be wrong @MaxAbrahms. The USG has always been concerned about the illegal outposts because if made permanent they would be connected to the main settlements making it impossible to create territorial contiguity for the Palestinian state.
I believe it’s been sometime since “outposts” were considered a top impediment to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
That's why Bush '43 insisted that PM Sharon dismantle them when they first went up and why every U.S. president since has insisted that the government of Israel live up to Sharon's commitment to Bush that he would remove all of them. (p.s. they are illegal under Israeli law!).
Whenever someone tells you that they feel sorry for Bibi because of all the hardliners he has to cope with, show them this photo. Netanyahu made this bed and invited all these extremist, racist, misogynist, anti-gay, anti-democrats to lie in it with him.
The person Netanyahu is shaking hands with is Avi Maoz, the leader of Noam, a radical religious party that focuses on opposing LGBTQ & women's rights. They signed a coalition deal today. Maoz will be a deputy minister at the PM office in charge of a new Jewish identity department
You may say I’m a dreamer. But I’m not the only one. I hope someday you’ll join us and the world will be as one.
It seems to me that Ambassador @Martin_Indyk lives in the 1990's and has a time machine where he periodically drops in to the 2020's and writes how we're killing his dreams...he's just not aware they died decades ago and he's the only one who doesn't know it.
Goodbye 2 state solution: Bibi just committed to Ben Gvir in their coalition agreement “that the status of illegal settlement Homesh, Evyatar yeshiva, and all “younger settlements” in Judea and Samaria will be regulated” i.e. all illegal settlement outposts will be legalized.
Erakat and Farraj were very interested. But before they had a chance to brief Abu Mazen, he announced a reconciliation agreement with Hamas and Bibi called off the negotiations. Still, the episode shows that Israel can transfer WB territory to the Pals without a cabinet decision.
How did the Palestinian Authority respond to this offer ?
The one upside (though it’s cold comfort) is that when it blows it will be clear that Ben Gvir failed to stop it. That’s probably part of Bibi’s calculation in extending Ben Gvir’s responsibilities to the West Bank. But he too is playing with fire.
I would add, in this case it’s also handing him control of all the fire extinguishers and emergency exits.
As “National Security Minister” Ben Gvir will also have authority over the Judea and Samaria Border Police Division, previously under the control of the Defense Minister. That’s equivalent to handing matches to a pyromaniac.
Not yours @PeterBeinart. There is no alternative to the 2 state solution. Every other solution is just a recipe for continued conflict. But since we can’t get there from here, we need an incremental process of separation. When I was responsible for Israeli-Palestinian …
what's your preferred alternative?
negotiations, Netanyahu offered the Palestinians 30,000 dunams in Area C without a Cabinet decision. Let’s start there.
Some 3 weeks ago @BretStephen_NYT was hopeful that “there’s still time for Netanyahu and his erstwhile rivals to put aside their petty differences [and] freeze Ben-Gvir and his repugnant allies out of the next government…”. Not happening. www.nytimes.com/2022/11/08/opinion/israel-election-fascis…
Some 3 weeks ago www.nytimes.com/2022/11/08/opinion/israel-election-fascis…
Both. And playing with fire.
Is Israel pushing the envelope or pushing its luck?!
As “National Security Minister” Ben Gvir will also have authority over the Judea and Samaria Border Police Division, previously under the control of the Defense Minister. That’s equivalent to handing matches to a pyromaniac.
Might be obvious to you @AlonPinkas but I have shocking news for you: most of the rest of the world isn’t watching the coalition negotiations in Israel.
Goodbye 2 state solution: Bibi just committed to Ben Gvir in their coalition agreement “that the status of illegal settlement Homesh, Evyatar yeshiva, and all “younger settlements” in Judea and Samaria will be regulated” i.e. all illegal settlement outposts will be legalized.
Good point! www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-11-25/us-navy-ai-…
Oh really? And what exactly were the Druze going to do to the PA or PIJ (which had the body)?
Credible threat from the Druze was the reason they released the body. Stop pretending.
And the UAE can stop normalization (softly or not so softly).
thank you 🙏
so they can start annexing (softly or not so softly) on Feb 2024
How to treat the PA as a partner: Defense Minister Benny Gantz just now: “I want to express my appreciation for the Palestinian Authority for its actions to return the late Tiran Fero to his family. That is a basic humanitarian step following a depraved and inhuman act.”
Yes the Pals have agency and yes they need to take responsibility for their own fate. But Israel holds all the cards; it’s the much stronger party. It can help rebuild the PA but it has to treat it as a partner rather than repudiating and denigrating it.
Why building a credible, legitimate, capable, accountable Palestinian Authority is an Israeli responsibility? Are Palestinians babies? Don’t they have any agency at all? The USA should put pressure on them.
The alternative to Hamastan cannot be Israeli occupation forever. It can only be a credible, legitimate, capable, accountable Palestinian Authority. Since that’s in Israel’s interest it should be building up the PA not dragging it down.
2 states solution, as of 2008 Hamas wins majority in every election that were held or will be held in foreseeable future.
Hence, by definition the 2ed state of the utopian "2 states solution" is Hamastan.
No way!! Not any government in Israel which is not far left will accept.
@LawDavF presents all the evidence for a clear conclusion: “Putin’s armies are unable to solve his Ukraine problem….The war was lost long ago.” How to get Putin to accept this? “There is no alternative to keeping up the military pressure.” open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/is-russia-losing?r=zgqu
Here we go: True to form, Netanyahu offers to buy off his extremist coalition partners with settlement activity, in this case he would be breaking a commitment to the US. What starts badly will end up worse. Hope somebody in Washington is paying attention. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2022-11-15/ty-article/.premiu…
The Biden Administration should strongly oppose this move because it will directly undermine its commitment to a two state solution. Besides, the Govt of Israel promised the USG that all illegal outposts would be dismantled. They are illegal under Israeli law.
Netanyahu has told Smotrich the Religious Zionism leader he wants to annex to Israel the West Bank illegal settlements which will take away any hope the Palestinians have left of gaining an autonomous and contiguous state even with restricted powers
Could be. But then what?
Not sure it's unaffiliated. It's a tactic driven by an entity in the region.
Easy to point fingers; much harder to find a way to prevent the coming explosion.
Let's not forget the Palestinian "leadership" which has never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity. They have fueled the hate and turned down two serious offers for a state. That is the heart of the problem.
This is what the coming intifada looks like. Young, unaffiliated Palestinians, with no hope and easy access to weapons, too young to remember the last intifada, attacking settlers who provide readily available targets in the West Bank.
Add a crumbling PA and a right wing/settler Israeli government intent on cracking down in retaliation and the explosive mix is complete. The fuse may already have been lit.
Interesting that the Chinese didn’t put this joint nuclear language in their statement. Maybe Xi thinks Putin won’t notice.
3: Unlike most things in the US readout, which are framed as unilateral statements by Biden, this one is framed jointly: "President Biden and President Xi reiterated their agreement." There's only party threatening nuclear use in Ukraine, so for once Beijing didn't both-sides it.
Martin Indyk reposted
1: Two things jump out at me immediately from the US readout: The first is the reference to joint working groups - suggests a basis for (modest) progress and that there was some Chinese give on the suspension of various dialogues after the Pelosi visit. www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022…
For the love of Joe, he shouldn’t run. www.economist.com/united-states/2022/11/10/joe-biden-shou…
Learning to listen is critical to the art of diplomacy.
1-5 This post is less about partisan politics and more about how we can improve our thinking by listening to points of view that are different - even opposing - from our own.
Another strategic setback for Russia as it announces retreat from the key Ukrainian city of Kherson www.axios.com/2022/11/09/russia-kherson-withdrawal-ukrain…
Bibi has one big reason to resist this alarming scenario @DanielSeidemann: it will put the Abraham Accords in serious jeopardy.
8)
11.
In the past, Al Aqsa was the least occupied space in East Jerusalem; today it is often the most occupied.
As difficult it is to predict, there is no doubt: Al Aqsa/the Temple Mount will be stage center, more than ever the epicenter of the conflict.
This is what a normal, peaceful, democratic transfer of power looks like. A reminder of how far so many have strayed in the US: Israeli PM Lapid congratulates Netanyahu on election win www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/israeli-far-rightist-vo…
def 3 @bseikhan: don’t invade Yemen; don’t dismember a dissenter; don’t blockade a brother; don’t promise and then not deliver.
Martin Indyk's Abridged English Dictionary, 2022 Ed.:
Saudi must become more responsible:
def: toe the line; requires bit of groveling and subservience.
def 2: relinquish self interest and aspirations to appease a hegemonic partner, etc..
Wisdom from Karen Elliott House. A new US-Saudi crisis looms in December when Europe price-caps Russian oil and West needs Saudi offsets. Meanwhile Riyadh needs US protection from a threatening Iran. It’s time to talk not walk. www.wsj.com/articles/us-saudi-feud-crown-prince-mbs-biden… via @WSJ
@AnshelPfeffer knows Bibi well having studied him for years. So this piece, though speculative, makes a lot of sense: first get rid of the trial, then get rid of Ben Gvir. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/elections/2022-11-03/ty-artic…
But those partnerships are even less reliable than the US in the face of Iranian threats. Russia is dependent on Iran. China is straddling. Only the US is capable of providing the security guarantee MBS seeks. But we will only supply it if Saudi Arabia becomes more responsible.
Not sure there will be a sufficient answer to that call, and that is what drives the sense of insecurity and need for new constellation of partnerships, as I described in the article.
Here’s why diplomacy matters: Russia says it’s rejoining Ukraine grain deal brokered to avert world famine. apple.news/An9ZyUSh0SaaCaRT2mjqXzg
With 85% of actual vote counted Bibi is clearly back. Lapid has ordered his staff to prepare for an orderly transition. It looks like Meretz will not pass the threshold and the right wing-religious bloc will end up with a clear victory of ~64 seats. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/elections/2022-11-01/ty-artic….
Are you that afraid that you can’t stand with the West against a naked act of Russian aggression against a small democratic neighbor?
Master of the Game is published today! Here’s a thoughtful review by @JeremiSuri in @NYTimes. He calls it “brilliant” and “fascinating.” www.nytimes.com/2021/10/26/books/review/master-of-the-gam…
Whether it’s Hamas or the Palestinian Authority, the Palestinian people deserve leaders who respect their basic right to speak, vote, organize and dissent. Freedom from tyranny and freedom from occupation are two sides of the same coin. www.nytimes.com/2021/07/07/world/middleeast/Palestinian-A…
Ned said it. By George, he said it! “Do we think that the West Bank is occupied? Yes.” It took him three days to get there but now there’s no going back. And amazingly, the sky didn’t fall.
State Dept spox Ned Price at daily briefing: “It is a historical fact that Israel occupied the West Bank, Gaza, and the Golan Heights after the 1967 war... Do we think that the West Bank is occupied? Yes.”
UAE-Israel relations have hit a Bibi-bump in the road.
From the UAE’s perspective, the purpose of the Abrahamic Accords is to provide a robust strategic foundation to foster peace and prosperity with the State of Israel and in the wider region. The UAE will not be a part in any internal electioneering in Israel, now or ever.
Interesting details from @BarakRavid including the role of Hady Amr and Julie Sawyer who will have the Israeli-Palestinian file at State and NSC respectively. Both worked with me in the special envoy’s office. They are the best and brightest. www.axios.com/newsletters/axios-tel-aviv/
@ABlinken is an inspired choice for SecState. Seasoned, reliable, insightful, unflappable, with that secret diplomatic ingredient - politesse. So close to President-Elect Biden that he can speak for him authoritatively and speak to him with candor. www.nytimes.com/2020/11/22/us/politics/biden-antony-blink…
Can’t you see John McCain smiling down on Arizona today with his two thumbs pointing up? God bless @cindymccain for sustaining his legacy.
Congratulations to my dear friend and President-elect @JoeBiden Vice-President-elect @KamalaHarris. Its time to move beyond politics and toward building a stronger america. I know Joe will unify the country toward a better future.
You might enjoy this podcast about the #abrahamaccords with UAE ambo Yousef Al-Otaiba, Dennis Ross and Dan Shapiro. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/hinge-history-middle-east-a…
Surprise! China and Russia are refusing to extend the UN arms embargo on Iran. We have only Trump to blame for pulling out of the Iran nuclear deal. Stupid diplomacy on steroids. www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-iran-un/iran-nuclear-deal-…
Read and weep for the immense, unnecessary suffering that Trump's incompetence has wrought. And the dysfunction is far from over even now. www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2020/04/04/coron…
What’s worth US troops dying for in the ME these days? Not much. My argument in the WSJ Saturday Essay...
Iran will understand from this that the US is attempting to shut down its economy. If the US wants Iran to negotiate rather than capitulate it needs to signal that it will ease sanctions if Iran reverses the steps it has now taken to enrich uranium and advance towards the bomb.
Maximum pressure on the Iranian regime continues. The U.S. is sanctioning eight senior Iranian leaders and numerous entities in the metals industry in response to #iran’s attacks against U.S. forces and interests. Our sanctions will continue until Iran changes its behavior.
2. MBS needs to stand up and take personal responsibility for the murder and commit to transparent measures to ensure that such things won't happen again. Then he needs to end Saudi involvement in the Yemen War, release dissenters, and double down on reform.
A unanimous condemnation of the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia by the US Senate sends a strong message to King Salman: this problem in U.S.-Saudi relations cannot be swept under the rug or ignored. It will continue to eat away at our strategic relationship to the benefit of Iran.
A unanimous condemnation of the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia by the US Senate sends a strong message to King Salman: this problem in U.S.-Saudi relations cannot be swept under the rug or ignored. It will continue to eat away at our strategic relationship to the benefit of Iran.
There is a crisis between Israel and World Jewry but the reason is not assimilation. It’s the extreme policies advocated by @naftalibennett and his government’s refusal to treat Reform and Conservative Jews as equal to his orthodox constituency.
Minister of diaspora @naftalibennett: "There is an unprecedented crisis between Israel and the Jewish diaspora. The reason is a major problem of assimilation and that more and more Jews around the world don't care about their Judaism and don't care about Israel"
Big day for me yesterday. Thirty-five years since migrating to Washington, twenty-five years since the Oslo signing, seventeen years since joining Brookings, I’m leaving Washington and heading for NY and the Council on Foreign Relations. www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2018/09/25-year…
Putin: no solid reason for tensions between US and Russia. [Right, if you ignore gross Russian interference in US elections.]
Nothing would’ve sold there, which is what Arafat feared. But if they’re the arbiters of what is an acceptable deal then there will never be a deal.
From the perspective of most #palestinians, particularly the refugees, the #clinton Parameters were viewed as such despite being forthcoming in several other areas and respects. That’s why they didn’t sell in #jabalia, #bureij, #jalazone, or #qalandia!
Hamas turns off the demonstrations on Nakba Day. Shows they have control if anybody doubted it. This may yet prove a more effective lever for getting Israel, Egypt and PA to relieve the siege than rockets and tunnels. But, as usual, Gazans pay the price. www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-hamas-israel-cool-it…
Abu Mazen summoned to Riyadh in the midst of turmoil there. Something is up.
www.haaretz.com/middle-east-news/palestinians/1.821303
@sbg1 reports Trump took commitment to Article V out of his NATO speech - that would make it deliberate. www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/06/05/trump-nato-spe…
3 cheers for the "administrative state:" U.S. Quietly Lifts Limit on Number of Refugees Allowed In www.nytimes.com/2017/05/26/us/politics/united-states-refu…
Happy 69th Birthday Israel! A great achievement, as this survey attests: Both Jews and Arabs say they're proud to be Israeli.
Tillerson's tough talk: "Russia failed in its responsibility to get rid of Syria's chemical weapons. Either incompetence or malfeasance."
Something consequential is going on in Saudi Arabia: success would be huge and failure more so. Worth watching. www.nytimes.com/2016/10/14/world/middleeast/saudi-arabia-…
Wow! Official tells NYT Israel Rejects Kerry's attempt to intimidate. We're in dangerous territory. www.nytimes.com/2015/07/26/world/middleeast/israel-is-ste…
Buji: in all the polls people trust me. That's what matters. #saban14