Harvard economist sees parallels between Trump, Zedong and Castro
NATHAN VANDERKLIPPE
INTERNATIONAL CORRESPONDENT
President Donald Trump holds a document with notes about Kilmar Abrego Garcia as he speaks with reporters during a swearing in ceremony for Dr. Mehmet Oz to be Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, in the Oval Office of the White House, on April 18, in Washington.
It is, at first blush, a startling idea: Donald Trump is cut from a cloth similar to that of Mao Zedong or Fidel Castro.
But all three men are best understood as revolutionary leaders, dedicated to the destruction of institutional norms, says Ricardo Hausmann, a noted economist whose views are informed by personal experience. His Jewish parents fled the Holocaust for Venezuela. There, Prof. Hausmann served as minister of planning and on the board of the country’s central bank before leaving for the U.S., where he is a scholar at Harvard and founding director of The Growth Lab, a hub for economic and policy research.
In recent weeks, his position has given him a personal stake in the White House demands of universities, as the Trump administration contemplates stripping Harvard of its tax-exempt status and ability to recruit foreign students.
Can you talk about how your background informs your perspective on what we’re seeing in the U.S. today?
Ricardo Hausmann: My parents both survived the Holocaust and got to Venezuela, my father in 1943 and my mother in 1949. The perception was that Europe was unstable, and by contrast Venezuela was a stable democracy. Then in 1999, Venezuela started down the road toward authoritarianism and now outright dictatorship.
So, you realize that you go through periods in which life seems so orderly, and then these worlds sometimes collapse.
Do you think your experience has allowed you to see things more clearly than what others, who have only grown up living in a stable U.S., may struggle to see?
Prof. Hausmann: Once you’ve seen democracies die on you, you kind of develop a sense of foreboding as you see some signs of that happening in the U.S. My colleague Steven Levitsky wrote the book on how democracies die. And that book is full of Venezuela. So there is a certain déjà vu in the current state of affairs in the U.S.
Let’s start with where you draw optimism at the moment. Where do you see key differences in the U.S. relative to what you experienced in Venezuela?
Prof. Hausmann: In any society, there are some forces that protect the status quo.
Nineteenth-century British political philosopher Michael Oakeshott was saying that the conservative predisposition starts with appreciating what you have in life. What you have is, in part, a bequest of the past.
Contrary to that is a more revolutionary predisposition that starts by saying that what exists is bad. If something exists, it’s proof of its corruption. That makes you want to change anything that exists.
There is also this additional tension in any liberal democracy, because democracy means in some sense the rule of the majority. And liberalism means that people have inalienable rights that cannot be taken away by a majority.
So when societies suddenly are in a more revolutionary situation, they find checks and balances – all these mechanisms that protect individual and minority rights – to be an impediment to realizing the will of the majority. Then suddenly you see an attack on the institutions that guaranteed the individual liberties and freedoms that you took for granted.
In that context, I think Trump is a revolutionary figure. He wants to destroy all the rules of what he inherited.
Harvard versus Trump is the new battle for independence
If Trump is a revolutionary figure, what does that tell us about the next three-and-a-half – or more – years will look like?
Prof. Hausmann: Sometimes I think that Trump is doing so many changes to so many things that it may look like Mickey Mouse and the Sorcerer’s Apprentice, where he starts destroying things and suddenly loses control.
Trump may not understand how the U.S. benefits from the international order that he inherited, in which the U.S. has a very substantial advantage in technology. That technological advantage creates an enormous possibility of making money by deploying that technology globally.
That has worked remarkably well for the U.S. The U.S. is supposedly running this very large deficit in goods, but that deficit is completely compensated for by its surplus in services sold to the rest of the world. Central to that is American intellectual property.
So the Magnificent 7 in the stock market – Apple, Google, Facebook, Netflix, etc. – they make more than half of their revenue abroad. That doesn’t appear as U.S. exports.
And now he’s destroying the ability to monetize technology abroad. And he’s destroying the ability to create the technology by attacking the scientific ecosystem. So he is in a process of killing what has been the basis of American prosperity, with the idea that somehow the marvel that he inherited is somehow hurting the U.S.
If one wants to restrain the destructive nature of a revolutionary leader, how does one do that? Is it even possible?
Prof. Hausmann: Right now, all the actions that he is taking have a very flimsy legal basis. And they are all being challenged in the courts. We will see if the courts stop him or not – but the courts made him immune to criminal prosecution for decisions he takes. And we’ll see if he loses control of the House of Representatives in November, 2026, and if suddenly he doesn’t have a pliant legislature.
Will the system of powers become an obstacle to his attempts to have no constraints on the exercise of his agenda? That all remains to be played out. That’s where the battle is.
What is your current level of optimism in this idea that the broader U.S. institutions will hold? Or are you, like some of your academic colleagues, thinking of moving to Canada?
Prof. Hausmann: This is a fantastic opportunity for Canada to become a scientific and technological powerhouse, in the same way as the U.S. became a scientific and technological powerhouse by absorbing refugees from Germany. Scientific and technological prowess is very hard to develop from a human perspective, but it’s very easy to attract from a geographic perspective. And if the U.S. becomes this place that’s inhospitable to intellectual workers, countries that are able to attract them and create an environment for their flourishing can suddenly become a technological powerhouse in a very short time.
The idea of the U.S. becoming inhospitable – isn’t that a far-off prospect?
Prof. Hausmann: No. Trump is questioning assumptions that liberal democracies have given their citizens for a long time, because they see this incredible bequest of the past – the best universities in the world, the most advanced scientific and technological ecosystem in the world – as enemies. And these people have options.
This interview has been edited and condensed.