Quatremer's goodbye letter to "Libération"
www.lepoint.fr/societe/je-reprends-ma-liberte-car-elle-es…
"Goodbye Libé !
Dear friends of Libération ,
I confess, I'm a libertarian, and like all libertarians, a provocateur. Neither god nor master. That's precisely why I chose Libération in 1984. A free, chaotic, dissident, nonconformist newspaper, the one Serge July recreated in May 1981, Libération II. “In the beginning of Libération, there was chaos, ” as he so aptly wrote, an early chaos that long marked the newspaper. Unlikely and passionate people worked there together, people who spent their time arguing in public, something that would have been impossible in other staid, institutional publications, and then made up over a drink or a meal. We weren't afraid of anything, especially not of those who didn't think like us; on the contrary, we sought confrontation with them. We would never have censored anyone or anything (with a few exceptions, it must be admitted). It was forbidden to forbid, a legacy of May 1968 that one could be proud of, even if there were sometimes excesses that Libération had the courage to acknowledge, unlike many other newspapers. And it was perfectly willing to break the dishes and put its feet up on the table.
But all good things must come to an end. I take my leave.
I thank the successive editorial directors who for a long time allowed me to practice my profession in complete independence within the newspaper, but also on other platforms, the majority of my colleagues with whom I have always had cordial relations over time, and the various shareholders who have more than generously financed us without ever interfering in the editorial process, I can testify to that.
If I leave, it's not because of Europe, the subject to which I have passionately devoted a very large part of my professional life. I belong to that social-democratic left that fights religious obscurantism of any kind, racism, anti-Semitism, discrimination, hatred of Muslims, sexism, homophobia, social injustice, authoritarian regimes, and so on. It's the left that considers individual and collective freedoms sacred, freedom of expression in particular, and that does not compromise on the rule of law and the Republic.
I can only observe, unfortunately, that it is now a minority, even on the verge of disappearing. For fear of being accused of “Islamophobia” or neocolonialism, or, more cynically, in an attempt to secure a specific community vote, a segment of the political and media left tolerates within its ranks homophobic, misogynistic, transphobic, anti-secular, anti-free speech rhetoric, and the clericalism with which it allies itself. Since the pogrom of October 7th, it has transformed the hostility to the Netanyahu government, which I fully share, and the legitimate support for the Palestinian cause into a virulent anti-Zionism, a mask for unbridled anti-Semitism, as Vladimir Jankélévitch so aptly understood, which is the negation of the values not only of the left, but of the Republic. People demonstrate in front of synagogues, attack Jews, shout “Heil Hitler” at demonstrations, and silence intellectuals, artists, scientists, and journalists because they are Jewish and therefore Zionist and therefore “genocidal.” Anyone, Jewish or not, who doesn’t subscribe to this ideology is labeled a fascist, based on a new kind of antifascism that is a carbon copy of the very thing it claims to fight, thanks to its violence—sometimes deadly.
This new left, wallowing in anti-Semitism, defends freedom of expression… the same opinion as itself.
As in the heyday of the USSR and the Comintern, the thought police reign with ideological terror through anathemas, slanderous denunciations, and a culture of cancellation. Jews are labeled as Nazis, Israel and Jews worldwide are accused of genocide, just as they were accused of deicide in the past, Israel's right to exist is denied—something no other country can do—and antisemitism is considered, at its core, to be just another opinion, no longer a non-negotiable value… Yes, all of this is permitted. But denouncing anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism, defending Israel's right to exist, challenging the claim that this country is committing genocide or organizing a famine, pointing out the use of civilian populations as human shields by Hamas terrorists, questioning the instrumentalization of UNRWA or the UN by Islamists, ah, no!
Yet, I tell you, as someone who is not Jewish: antisemitism in all its forms, even the most insidious, is the unmistakable marker of hatred for the Republic, for freedoms, for the rule of law, for equality, for humanism. It foreshadows totalitarianism.
This new left, wallowing in antisemitism, defends freedom of expression… the very same opinion it holds. It discriminates between good and bad victims instead of defending all of humanity. It insults and defames those who don't toe the line of its propaganda, its lies, and its hatred. Thus, contrary to what the proponents of this left—which is left in name only—have claimed since October 7th, I have never confused Muslims with Islamism, nor Palestinians with Hamas and its sycophants. Anyone who accuses me of racism, Islamophobia (an accusation that only kills those accused of it), and fascism is either an idiot, a scoundrel, or both.
I am past the age of giving in to the intimidation tactics of those who are "offended" and whose standards vary.
I admit it, I don't recognize myself in this particular left wing, which is the very negation of the principles that founded Libération . Certainly, they are far from being the majority in the newspaper, and even less so in its leadership, but using harassment tactics tried and tested on the far left, they manage to make the air unbreathable for me. So I bow out. I reclaim my freedom, for it is my most precious possession. I have no intention of relinquishing the slightest bit of it, nor of submitting to any discipline whatsoever, nor of devoting my time to justifying myself before small groups in show trials. I'm past the age of giving in to the intimidation of these ever-shifting "offended" individuals. I could have said, like Pialat: "You don't like me? I don't like you either." But that would be untrue. I have liked and still like many of you. But more than you, I value my freedom. The real rebels are not who you think they are.
I may be leaving Libération , but not its readers, those who have read, listened to, and loved me throughout these years, those for whom the diversity of opinions within the left is a precious treasure. As Jean-Paul Sartre said in 1973 about Libération , which he co-founded with Serge July, it is “ a newspaper that is not that of a party and where the journalists, all left-wing, do not necessarily share the same opinion .” To all these readers, I invite you to join me on other platforms where I will continue to make my voice heard and defend the values and the journalism in which I believe.
I hope that the majority of you will continue, as I have tried to do in recent years, to defend Libération against those who would hold it hostage in the name of an ideology contrary to its values. To those who will fight to “liberate Libération ,” to borrow once again a phrase from Serge July dating back to 1981, I wish you well, just as I wish Sonia Delesalle-Stolper, its new editor-in-chief, well. Remember, freedom is recognized by the noise it makes when it leaves.
Jean Quatremer"