Paper with Bob Axelrod, “Rational sycophants and Catastrophic Risks”, we show how two properties of long tailed distributions (mean > median & little info from one draw) create incentives for sycophants. (Apologies if you are behind PNAS paywall) www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2537944123
Scott E. Page
Scott E. Page is an American social scientist and John Seely Brown Distinguished University Professor of Complexity, Social Science, and Management at the University of Michigan, where he has been working since 2000. He has also been director of the Center for the Study of Complex Systems at Michigan (2009–2014) and an external faculty member at the Santa Fe Institute (2000–2005 and 2007–present). More on Wikipedia
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
New SFI volume in complexity and economics now available
SFI Press
@SFIPress
Part V– Inequality, Labor & Structural Resilience
23– Complexity Theory and Economic Inequality by @sndurlauf, @DavidMcMillon6, and @Scott_E_Page.
www.sfipress.org/eecs-iv-23
7/15 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Fascinating piece that speaks to me by @ipeirotis on using AI for oral exams. www.behind-the-enemy-lines.com/2025/12/fighting-fire-with…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
AI is changing the physics of collective intelligence—how do we respond? | Brookings www.brookings.edu/articles/ai-is-changing-the-physics-of-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My recent short piece on how AI and Information Technology transform the physics of deliberation: journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/26339137251367733
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thinking same as always!
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Do I drink my usual Americano or try something different? @PTetlock @mjmauboussin @AnnieDuke?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Do I drink my usual Americano or try something different? @PTetlock @mjmauboussin @AnnieDuke?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Phillip Ball kindly sat for an interview to discuss his book "How Life Works" from a #collectiveintelligence perspective. journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/26339137251343587
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At conference where someone said “Chief AI Officers” will not go away. Ironic, that the acronym is CAIO!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Northwestern was kind enough to post a brief piece John Ledyard and I wrote about our PhD advisor Stan Reiter who would be 100 this year www.kellogg.northwestern.edu/-/media/files/academics-rese…
-
Scott Page reposted
UChicago | Stone Center on Inequality & Mobility
@UCStoneCenter
New Episode!
@Scott_E_Page (@UMich) joins host @sndurlauf to unpack complex systems thinking: what it is, why it matters, and how diversity can make systems more resilient.
Listen every other Monday:
Website: stonecenter.uchicago.edu/whats-new/the-inequality-podcast/
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/3QjW4JjjLqYMvoNBc2wswe
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-inequality-podcast/id16…
#complexityscience #systemsthinking -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Honored to have just been elected a member of the National Academy of Sciences. @sfiscience @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss www.nasonline.org/news/2025-nas-election/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Roland: chief supervisor patio installation
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Excited to announce that my book, The Difference, has been reissued as a Princeton Classic!! press.princeton.edu/collections/princeton-classics
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Discussion on AI often focuses on whether it is (a) augmenting humans or (b) an agent. Here's a super thoughtful, important take that it is a cultural and social technology. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adt9819.
This aligns with research at U-Michigan on The Choice sites.google.com/view/the-choice-mhdca/home -
Scott Page reposted
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Yes, this is about you-know-who. Much more at the link below.
www.natesilver.net/p/elon-musk-and-spiky-intelligence -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I organized discussion on descent phenomenon in prediction. Less paradoxical than it first appeared. More data and more parameters prevent overfitting. Slide with key intuition and cite attached
-
Scott Page reposted
Michael Mauboussin
@mjmauboussin
2/Here's a link to the report: www.morganstanley.com/im/publication/insights/articles/ar…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Moderna created 750 GPTs in house openai.com/index/moderna/ The brilliant @Challamel explains how in this exhilarating podcast www.beyondtheprompt.ai AI is assistant, expert, coach, and co-creator. Everyone is now a 5 person team! Using AI is not nearly as risky as not using AI!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Creativity Test. Make a list of dog names such that each sequential pair of dogs is a "funny" combination
Example:
1. Pecan
2. Butter
3. Peanut
4. Mister
5. Rogers
6. Jolly
7. Rancher
Each pair is funny: butter pecan, peanut butter, mister peanut, mister rogers, .. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
In my Collective Intelligence a thread is institutions - markets, democracies, organizations, communities and algorithms - enable better coordination. Website tracking effect of NYCs new congestion pricing policy (a move from self-organization to market) www.congestion-pricing-tracker.com
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
U.S. Executive Order on AI terminology section includes (in order)
(l) The term “Federal law enforcement agency”
(m) The term “floating-point operation”
(n) The term “foreign person”
If you gave people the definitions of (l) and (n), imagine how they might define (m) -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great brief article: gives big picture plusses and minuses of how collections of humans and bots compete, cooperate, coordinate, promote contagion of ideas, and collectively decide. Archive link to an earlier version for those behind Nature's fierwall arxiv.org/pdf/2402.14410
Taha Yasseri
@TahaYasseri
It’s time for a New Sociology of Humans and Machines. Our paper in @NatureHumBehav highlights why understanding this relationship is more urgent than ever. It’s not just humans shaping the world anymore—algorithms and bots are part of the social mix too. www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-02001-8
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
University of Michigan has an open assistant professor position in Complex Systems. Amazing opportunity to do join an interdisciplinary community of faculty and students. Looking for discipline thinkers who transcend disciplines. lsa.umich.edu/cscs/news-events/all-news/search-news/compl…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The University of Michigan now has a hammock policy. Trees 6 inch diameter per hammock up to 3. Max strap height of 8 ft. “Recommended” min height of hammock 18. Encourage your university to adopt to avoid serving on hammock task force! fo.umich.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Hammock_and_Slack…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@AndrewWLo kicking off an MiT SFI conference on building a better society by referencing his paper in @Collective_CI on the wisdom and madness of crowds. The journal would love to see more papers on this topic.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Link to paper journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/26339137221104785
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
P(camel | scribble)?
Cognitive science simplified! -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful paper by @teppofelin and Holweg. Humans innovate by holding beliefs misaligned with existing data (the possibility of flying machines). Humans who act based on theory based causal logic - not patterns of past data - have an advantage over AI papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4737265
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
And then I find a paper finding AI generates ideas of higher novelty (but less feasibility) than humans.
arxiv.org/pdf/2409.04109 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At U of M museum of Art and an exhibit motivated by an academic paper written by my wife @profjennabednar on social flourishing. Wallpaper is the 50 state flowers
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Link to paper here direct.mit.edu/daed/article/152/1/31/115016/Governance-fo…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Or Arch Manning’s dad owns the hotel www.si.com/college/texas/news/cooper-manning-rumored-to-b…
Trey Mckenney Enthusiast
@Gobluety1
@stoolpresidente can you fix this please
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Anita Woolley with a provocative talk on whether purely human teams still exist?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Talking model thinking with Henning tomorrow am!! insead.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_JUiH1jqmTDO2iN4WUHUx4w
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Jacob Taylor of Brookings describing how to move all 17 UN SDGs forward using ideas from Collective Intelligence- see the 17 Rooms initiative www.brookings.edu/projects/17-rooms/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Kim Polese of www.crowdsmart.ai at Collective Intelligence 2024 on how generative collective intelligence - integrating humans and AI - can be used to preserve democracy
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
And we are off!!! @sfiscience Mirta Galesic kicks off Collective Intelligence 2024 www.networkscienceinstitute.org/ci2024
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful piece by @geoffmulgan on Collective Stupidity. You do the collective a disservice if you only skim and agree. Go deep. Go slow. Challenge.
Geoff Mulgan
@geoffmulgan
Spotted in Sheffield yesterday. Thanks for the many fantastic comments/critiques and additions I've had to my piece on this: www.geoffmulgan.com/post/a-theory-of-collective-stupidity…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Eager to see findings from this “natural” experiment in real estate economics on marginal balcony valuation in San Francisco.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Impressive meta analysis of 500+ diversity studies osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/nscd4. Four takeaways
1. Small Effects: Cognitive, Demographic, and Job Related Diversity have small average effect sizes.
True enough, but outperforming by 2-5% means winning.Post not available here, view on X
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
3. Power distance harms teams abilities to tap into cognitive or demographic diversity.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
4. Heterogeneity reigns: Lots of variation in effects. Many go the "wrong" way. Demographic diversity in particular produces lots of variation. Lone exception is that large studies of cognitive diversity almost all positive with larger effect sizes.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@sfiscience Geoff West discusses three approaches to science: variance (explain details), exactitude (big data - prediction & explain), and coarse graining (simplify) www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2209196121
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At @sfiscience nice discussion about whether low dimensional models that we can understand or high dimensional models that predict with greater accuracy. To coarse grain or not to coarse grain that is the question. A cluster of network theorists seem to favor coarseness.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
New outlet for complexity research- thoughtful summary of complexity www.nature.com/articles/s44260-024-00004-0
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
+1 to @MelMitchell1, paper by @mollycrockett well worth reading! Categorization of AI science uses as 1. Oracle (digest info & study design) 2. Surrogate (generate data) 3. Quant (analyze) 4. Arbiter (referee) holds in policy & business analyses as well www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07146-0
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Amazing paper by @PTetlock showing (i) the wisdom of crowds for LLMs (ii) that crowds of LLMs are as accurate as people and (iii) people can improve LLM accuracy arxiv.org/pdf/2402.19379.pdf
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Kudos to my friend Peter Erdi @petererdi. Many know of Erdi as complexity scholar. He wrote "Ranking" and "Repair", fewer know of the passion, thoughtfulness, and effort he puts into teaching. His former students are creating a fund in his honor
www.kzoo.edu/news/complex-systems-studies-professor/ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This piece “Ideological Bayesians - by Kevin Dorst” explains a cool “hierarchical attention” model in a Bayesian context. Very clean model that leaves one a bit more humble about one’s opinions - rational though they may be. Ball video is AMAZING!! kevindorst.substack.com/p/ideological-bayesians
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
They propose that two sentence fragments have the same meaning is the generate the same distribution over continuations (nice idea: measurable over a rich space), but do those continuation distributions imply understanding? www.amazon.science/blog/do-large-language-models-understa…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
More theoretical support for idea that diversity improves performance on complex tasks and hinders performance on easy ones. Might add that with humans, easy tasks can build trust and ability to communicate with one another. This is a really good paper!!! www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-52837-3
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great insights on giving feedback to people from different cultures, identities, and generations. Companies like Amazon demand candor. But being candid with a Dutch team member differs from being candid with a new intern. hbr.org/2023/09/when-diversity-meets-feedback
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
To be precise, it is “vector’s valence”
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Huge advantages to local as opposed to remote collaborations. Nice summary of important work
hyejin youn
@hyejin_youn
We learn from each other in person more than we think we do. insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/could-remote-wor…
-
Scott Page reposted
Chris Dixon
@cdixon
Excited for tomorrow’s book launch. 🙂
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Love this paper!! In a manual labor economy left-handedness hurts productivity (and maybe the lefty - careful with those scissors). In our cognitive economy, we get the full benefit of lefties!!! And, if lefties think differently, they’re worth even more!! link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10887-022-09212-6
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful, fascinating read on the limits and contributions of models by Dan Rockmore. My summary, can’t take actions only with them, can’t take actions without them! www.newyorker.com/culture/annals-of-inquiry/how-much-of-t…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
New paper with Lu Hong: (1) if there exists a test applied to people to select an optimal team, the test must be "how would a team of only that type perform." (2) test exists iff a "replace the worst" property hold. Sum: Tests cannot select best teams. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11238-023-09960-w
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For anyone teaching a social science complexity course, I recommend @MeganTStevenson's "Cause, Effect, and the Structure of the Social World." Shows limits of RCT "engineering" approach in complex criminal legal contexts and other domains. Fabulous work! papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4445710
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
UM Ross has a lecturer position in Management and Organizations. Great opportunity for someone with a PhD who wants to focus on teaching. careers.umich.edu/job_detail/243518/leo-intermittent-lect…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Bob Axelrod's autobiography "A Passion for Cooperation" is available from the University of Michigan Press in paperback, hardcover, and ebook (free download). Bob's love of deep conversations on matters theoretical and practical is evident throughout press.umich.edu/Books/A/A-Passion-for-Cooperation2
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Call for papers: 2024 NSF/CEME Decentralization Conference, Vanderbilt University April 19-21, 2024. Two themes:
1. Mechanism design with AI amplified humans & autonomous AI actors
2. Mechanism Design for blockchains & distributed ledgers
sites.google.com/view/2024-ceme-decentralization-con/home -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Provocative piece on how diverse scientific approaches work in harmony theconversation.com/from-stock-markets-to-brain-scans-new…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Chat GPT takes the World Values survey and proves to be WEIRD (could it have been anything else?)
Joe Henrich
@JoHenrich
Is GPT psychologically WEIRD? Using the World Values Survey and other psych measures, we seat GPT within a global perspective. The culturally more distant a place is from the US, the lower the correlation with GPT @MohammadAtari90 @blasi_lang @DorsaAmir
-
Scott Page reposted
Dashun Wang
@dashunwang
Today is the day!!
Kellogg launches its first research institute, Ryan Institute on Complexity, thanks to a transformative $25M gift!
I am deeply honored & humbled to have the opportunity to help found and direct this new institute!
www.kellogg.northwestern.edu/news/blog/2023/09/06/kellogg…
🚀🚀🚀 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Why we should think of the economy as a complex adaptive system and not only as producing efficient static allocations. Case # 2718 stocks.apple.com/A4j1mqGY8TjGm3jOcVY2k7Q
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Mark Newman shows why PageRank is inappropriate for pairwise competition networks because in PageRank a loss by B to A would increase A’s rank but not lower B’s. (but B lost!) Here’s the paper with a better ranking algorithm.
arxiv.org/pdf/2207.00076.pdf -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Geoff is spot on here. Competence can be taught. Even better voters could and should come to demand it.
Geoff Mulgan
@geoffmulgan
I've done a blog on why we can't afford incompetent politicians; the case for training them better; current examples from around the world; and proposals for the future. All comments and examples welcome. www.geoffmulgan.com/post/can-democracies-afford-incompete…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Our latest collective intelligence webinar! Oracles, bees, wisdom if crowds and spatial correlations of information. Five 8 minute fun talks! youtu.be/ELmm48-zj_0
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A great opportunity for those interested in modeling complex systems
Santa Fe Institute
@sfiscience
Are you interested in learning how to model #humanbehavior using techniques from complex #systemsscience? Join us for #complexity Interactive October 9 – 20 to learn from SFI faculty.
Learn more & #apply now! 👉 santafe.edu/sfi-ci
@MelMitchell1 @Scott_E_Page @psmaldino -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great take on how algorithms now occupy a position similar to markets, hierarchies, and democracies. They aggregate and sometimes muddle information
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful exchange by biologist Deborah Gordon and organizational theorist Daniel Levinthal on the role of oracles in creating collective. intelligence. Perfect oracles provide immediate, perfect signals. Those rarely exist. journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/26339137231170022
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Organizations construct approximate oracles to coordinate behaviors and guide search. Those oracles are often forward looking -- predictive. Ant colonies do not prognosticate. They are "guided by the present." Nor do ants build single oracles. They distribute cognition.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
While both organizations and ants require `oracles' to succeed at A/B testing, they build them in different ways. Difficult to to imagine how any organization or system can perform well without adequate oracles of some form.
-
Scott Page reposted
Daron Acemoglu
@DAcemogluMIT
This is a wonkish thread about information, prices and decentralization. It touches on topics often discussed in economics, but with a revisionist take that might have relevance beyond economics, in particular about AI and control of information.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The brilliant @philipcball on assembly theory and AI (the assembly index). Just how complex (unlikely) is a composite? Biological assemblages (e coli) have higher AI than abiotic ones (coal). Does beer's high AI reveal the power of incentives or luck? www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-theory-for-the-assembly-of-l…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Byung-Chul Han’s Hyperculture (pg 52) “individuals follow their own inclinations, cobbling together their identities from what they find in the hypercultural pool of practices and forms of life.” Kept thinking of this quote while in London. Everyone’s “There” is unique to them.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This is so great!! Glad to see this addition to the growing CI community!! For those interested in collective intelligence, we have a new interdisciplinary journal - please submit us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/collective-intelligence/journal2…
Harvard SEAS
@hseas
Applied math alum Saffron Huang founds @collect_intel to promote tech and especially artificial intelligence policy, whether at specific companies or a local government, that balances progress, participation and safety to help society flourish. seas.harvard.edu/news/2023/04/alumni-profile-saffron-huan…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Decentralization Conference Website
"Robust + Environmental Mechanism Design"
sites.google.com/view/2023decentralization/home -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
2023 Decentralization Conference “Robust +Environmental Mechanism Design” in honor of Roy Radner about to kickoff in ANn Arbor
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My lived experience is that a ten minute bike ride is sufficient and that walking more than 30 minutes becomes wearying - especially when you have dogs that demand a walk on your return home. I’ve never had a driving commute to work (lucky me) so cannot comment on driving
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Last day!!!!! The Santa Fe Institute calling for papers for a three day conference on social challenges - this will be a multidisciplinary thoughtfest on net zero that produces a lot of positive spillovers. Great opportunity to discuss the complexities of modern challenges.
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
🌟Call for proposals🌟
Join us at @sfiscience Jul 31-Aug2 as we wrestle with modern social challenges. Call open to complexity scientists and practitioners alike! www.santafe.edu/info/complex-system-approaches-21st-centu… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Boston!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Fascinating paper on training diverse "juries" of classifiers rather than an aggregate classifier. Each member of the jury represents the classification rules of a type (age, gender, race). One can then construct representative juries of classifiers. dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3491102.3502004
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Wolfram Alpha now “integrated” into ChatGPT. writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/03/chatgpt-gets-its-wolf…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Save Ukrainian Lives (Blood transfusion center)
gofund.me/85e7c6cf -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Proud to part of this @umich teach out on ChatGPT offered for free through Coursera. Describes what it is, how to use it effectively and ethically, and what the impact on the economy and society might be online.umich.edu/teach-outs/chatgpt-teach-out/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
One suspects a steep learning curve for Microsoft Copilot and that those people who embrace the tech early will be far more productive than those who don’t. How though will we learn where to put guardrails to check Copilot’s contributions?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Microsoft's video intro to Copilot shows how AI can transform your word doc into a powerpoint, identify trends on your excel spreadsheet, and summarize all of your emails, chats, and meeting notes. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bf-dbS9CcRU
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Teaching the "madness of crowds". This is one of my favorite examples of people believing something false "The Power Balance Wristband" www.youtube.com/watch?v=6gIMxjr3n5U, which the company later admitted gizmodo.com/powerbalance-admits-their-wristbands-are-a-sc…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@profjennabednar has a thoughtful, powerful new piece on social flourishing based on community, dignity, sustainability, and beauty. A must read. @sfiscience @UMICHCS @fordschool www.amacad.org/publication/governance-human-social-flouri…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Mark Newman of @UMICHCS and @sfiscience receiving the University of Michigan’s highest honor - The Henry Russel Lecture
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My son Cooper (an art student) used midjourney an AI art app to make these images by thoughtfully selecting images and “tweaking parameters.” Art is becoming a data science! Pick variables. Tweak parameters!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I asked my son Cooper to use AI to create a format for a confusing chart. Now - off to find data!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Just one week left to submit papers to the 2023 NSF/CEME Decentralization Conference on Robust+Environmental Mechanism Design.
April 21-23 in Ann Arbor
docs.google.com/document/d/1CfhdI3w_zqlYKqZa6YYR3WBOygUnv… -
Scott Page reposted
Diverse Intelligences Summer Institute #DISI
@DivIntelligence
📣📣 Applications for DISI 2023 are still open! If you are a scholar or storyteller interested in the nature, origins, and future of intelligences, please consider joining us.
Review of applications begins soon (Feb 13)!
**Please share widely!**
disi.org -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For those of you who have a paper you would like to submit to Collective Intelligence, a transdisciplinary ACM/Sage Journal, but who have delayed because typing in the url takes too much effort. Here is a QR to get you there!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Saddened by the passing of Roy Radner. Roy struck a wonderful balance between playfulness and skepticism, which was evident in his captivating smile. Like Arrow, Hurwicz, Reiter, Marschak, and Debreu, Roy believed in the practical relevance of theory. www.econometricsociety.org/uploads/inmemoriam/ROY RADNER.pdf
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A person’s contribution to a team can increase or decrease as a function of the abilities of their teammates. Here’s an extreme case of the former from the NBA. Playing with Steph Curry, Jordan Poole puts up all star stats. Without Curry, Poole is mediocre.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Over a decade ago, I wrote a decision making guide for voters to think through the Michigan Civil Rights Initiative Ballot Proposal. The guide explains multi-criterion decision making (using an example of buying a home). Here's a link. Hope it's useful!
sites.lsa.umich.edu/scottepage/wp-content/uploads/sites/3… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Consecutive clues in today’s NYT crossword. Two easy ones for University of Michigan peeps!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Ironically, this article is the exception!!
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Of 1.1M Twitter links to scientific publications (tracked with Bitly), 49.5% are never clicked at all, and only 0.67% more than 100 times. asistdl.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/asi.2445…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My 4pm EST talk today on creating wise crowds can be live-streamed at link below. The talk will discuss how to embed ideas from group dynamics into formal models to gain insight into how to produce better decisions (and how some processes promote a “madness of crowds”)
Center for Positive Organizations
@PositiveOrg
See you tomorrow in person at “Creating Wise Crowds” with @Scott_E_Page starting at 4 p.m. ET. There’s still time to register, positiveorgs.bus.umich.edu/events/creating-wise-crowds-ho…. Help us celebrate our 150th Positive Links session; see you there! #poslinks #umpositive
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Or not if the landscape is dancing!!!
(Stuart Kauffman should get credit for the distinction between rugged and dancing)
Dror Poleg
@drorpoleg
Oh, Scott’s distinction between rugged and dancing landscape might bring you closer to what you’re looking for.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Provocative piece on the usefulness of noise in computation and creativity and the need for both deep knowledge and walks in the park to produce breakthroughs (ironically, the author notes that reading short summaries on Twitter is not the way to go) theconversation.com/noise-in-the-brain-enables-us-to-make…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A place for disciplined thought without the constraints of disciplines!!
Collective Intelligence
@Collective_CI
🐜🐜🐜 INAUGURAL ISSUE 🐜🐜🐜
CI is a unifying concept that applies to a range of systems from human societies to adaptive matter to brains to AI. Editors—@geoffmulgan, @Scott_E_Page, @c4computation, @ipeirotis + Tom Malone—discuss foundational issues.
journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/26339137221114179 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Agree that no one discipline economic, sociological, or psychological can predict outcomes or guide policy. Disagree that models are to blame. Progress will require applying ensembles of diverse models tied to data combined with qualitative interrogation- not abandoning models
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Wild” game dinner tonight. Crust would have been better but my hand was trembling.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
JLanier (You Are Not a Gadget) The plausibility of our human world, the fact that the buildings don't all fall down and you can eat up poisoned food that someone grew, is immediately palpable evidence of an ocean of goodwill and good behavior from almost everyone, living or dead.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
We are bathed in what we can all love.And yet that love shows itself best through the constraints of civilization, because those constraints compensate for the flaws of human nature. We must see ourselves honestly, and engage ourselves realistically, in order to become better.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
So would I!! Trying to learn more about generative AI - but I agree there’s much to chew on here. For example, today I learned about Eagle Alpha. They offer a diverse array of data sets - clearly this enables diversity for AI
Brad Heitmann
@bradheitmann
I’d be interested in @Scott_E_Page’s take on the #cognitivediversity potential of #generativeai. Specifically #ai as a team member plugged into data sets, design resources, documentation, research etc that not only reveals insights but co-creates end deliverables. @brent_alvord
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
People make better decisions if informed of uncertainty. Appears not to matter if numerical or graphical… unless graphical representation gets interpreted as another deterministic variable. Example: spaghetti hurricane trajectories seen as storm width. www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fcomp.2020.590232/full
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great to be in Milan!!
Flaminio Squazzoni
@squazzoni
@psmaldino & @Scott_E_Page bringing beers to other #ssc2022 delegates to help them surviving a hot evening in #milan!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Quite an amazing Lineup for Friday. Collective Intelligence looking for more great research as we move forward so please submit your papers!!!!
Collective Intelligence
@Collective_CI
COLLECTIVE INTELLIGENCE 1ST ISSUE SYMPOSIUM
Please join the @Collective_CI editors for a discussion w/ our authors on Fri. Sep 16 at 12PM ET to celebrate the search for collective intelligence principles across biology, computer science, physics, AI, + social science. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Cited in Jezebel! Yeah baby!!! I want to thank my friends in THE academy. jezebel.com/i-made-my-colleagues-clap-for-13-minutes-like…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Marriage brings no end of happy surprises - such as when your partner makes you rethink federalism! Kudos to @profjennabednar for article in 100th anniversary issue of Foreign Affairs!!!
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Ready or not, and like it or not, federalism is shaping U.S. domestic *and foreign* policy. Understanding this reality is the first step toward making it work better for us. My article in @ForeignAffairs w Tino Cuéllar of @CarnegieEndow www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/fractured-superpower…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Virtual pairs produced 10% fewer ideas total and 15% fewer creative ideas than in person pairs, but.. virtual were 5% better at evaluating ideas. Aligns with why I miss full office- the spark of conversations www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04643-y.pdf
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Training on examples from multiple disciplines - engineering, economics, biology, and psychology - improves ability to learn the (declarative) concept of negative feedbacks. Support for multi-disciplinary teaching of complexity. escholarship.org/uc/item/85k6f518
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Credit card companies and consumer debt holders win big from the student loan plan - many of the people who owe them money now have less debt making existing debt less risky. How might our government have captured some of this transfer to creditors? www.americanbanker.com/list/how-student-loan-forgiveness-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Also motivation for empiricists when confronted with a variable that is difficult to measure!!!
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
My beloved ebike---my car substitute that gave me superpowers---was stolen from the UM campus on Wednesday mid-morning. Thx to the good folks at @BikeIndex and @Umich campus security for spreading the word. It could show up on any market, so pls let me know if you see it. 🚴♀️❤️
Bike Index
@bikeindexstolen
STOLEN - White Gazelle Ultimate T10 in Ann Arbor, MI bikeindex.org/bikes/1376270
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Daniel Sperber: ".. conceptual processes range over an indefinite variety of domains, including party politics, baseball history, motorcycle maintenance, Zen Bhuddism, French cuisine, Italian opera, chess playing, stamp collecting,.." A nod to Robert Pirsig perhaps?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
one can obtain two 22% EY shots by keeping the brew ratio fixed & setting the GS to 1.3 or 2.0. The chemical composition of the faster shot cannot be same as slower shot owing to molecular differences in solubility, dissolution: the barista indeed needs to taste the coffee
Dan Quintana
@dsquintana
We’re not talking enough about the espresso reproducibility crisis ☕️ www.cell.com/matter/fulltext/S2590-2385(19)30410-2
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
All kidding aside - the “scientific” approach produced equally”tasty coffee” at a savings of $3620. Multiply this by 36k coffee shops and you get potential savings of $129 million per year! Not to mention less land used for coffee production!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Closing of electoral prediction market means loss of collective information - predictit had one in eight chance of Trump winning in January 2021 - clearly some information there - nice analysis by the ever thoughtful @rajivatbarnard rajivsethi.substack.com/p/the-closing-of-a-prediction-mar…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Cool application of information theory to disentangle when a population can be represented as a single “noisy” individual and when individual differences exist psyarxiv.com/th6rm
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Amazing paper - 21 Billion Facebook friendships - showing how being connected to high SES people correlates with economic success www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-04996-4
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Evidence that numeracy and scientific reasoning matter more for preventing “Truth Decay” than does “thinking slow.” Also, (as expected) ideology pushes against truth and toward conspiracy. Robust data analysis: regression, PCA, & CCA www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/RRA10…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Evidence from Cancun that recombination can be a source of innovation!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
No evidence for nudging after adjusting for publication bias | PNAS
I’ve included the link to make it easier to read :) www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2200300119 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Congrats to Michael Barr on his appointment to the Fed!! news.umich.edu/ford-school-dean-michael-barr-confirmed-by…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Explicit and Tacit Knowledge!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Alternatively, we might think of the chair as a “keystone” which prevents the weight of the bureaucracy from collapsing upon us!
André Spicer
@andre_spicer
There is a great paper on how managers in universities can act as 'shit umbrellas'
journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0018726718823243 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Physics and chemistry “gained their triumphs chiefly against systems whose parts are homogeneous and only interacting slightly We who face the complex system must beware of accepting their strategies as universally valid”- W R Ashby 1958
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For democracy to work anywhere - including crypto/DAO - it must solve issues of scope (should this be voted upon?), cognitive depth (do voters have expertise?) and efficiency (why bother?) a16zcrypto.com/lightspeed-democracy-what-web3-organizatio…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For performance of scientific teams Kara Hall and others show an inverted U wrt diversity. Also empirically true for pizza toppings (max in 5-7)!! Agree that in his case, testing would be a significant challenge
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@GalorOded demonstrates an inverted U relationship between diversity and economic well being across countries and time. More diversity creates more ideas but less cohesion. www.theguardian.com/books/2022/apr/30/an-optimists-guide-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
If you live near Miami please keep an eye open for Jen!! She’s a brilliant filmmaker who has gone missing.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Feeling charged up and less discordant!
The New York Times
@nytimes
All new smartphones, tablets and laptops in the EU will be required to use a USB-C charger by 2026, under an agreement reached on Tuesday. The new law had been opposed by companies including Apple. www.nytimes.com/2022/06/07/technology/eu-tablets-phones-u…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Regressions + variance decomposition of surveyed well-being as a function of UN Sustainable Development Goals reveals stark regional variations. Americas: Life below water matters; Former Soviets & Africa: Law Doesn't. static1.squarespace.com/static/5d59c0bdfff8290001f869d1/t…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Inspirational start to my day. This groundhog elevated its game!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Dynamic collective intelligence: Tasks: 1 & 2, States: A & B. Task 1 better in state A, 2 in state B. States switch at rate R, population adapts at rate L. Each task replenishes a stock that depletes at rate D. For some R,L,D, collective flexibility.
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2116066119 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
With @tamasdb at ES Forum in Frankfort.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Hyperbolic PCR Preferences: People apparently willing to pay 40E to reduce wait from 36 to 24 hours, and from 24 to 12 hours, but 70E to reduce from 12 to 3 hours!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Managing in sixteen dimensions is not easy” Podcast – Consulting Unplugged consultingunplugged.com/podcast/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Data based models outperform experts on means and confidence intervals on energy technology forecasts. Differences in sizes of confidence intervals astounding - models produce far bigger ranges. www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1917165118
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Everything we think we know about the world is a model. Every word & every language is a model. All maps & statistics, books & databases, equations & computer models are models. So are the ways I picture the world in my head… None is or ever will be the real world. - D Meadows
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful analysis of regressivity of blanket loan forgiveness-blog update particularly enlightening - top 40% get more than bottom 40%. And doctors, who average income is $333k get a large chunk www.brookings.edu/research/student-loan-forgiveness-is-re…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Standard AI model: give computer data and objective function and hit return. General intelligence in AI will involve feeding networked knowledge and involve modular systems. Fascinating how general knowledge appears to require a collective intelligence. www.amacad.org/publication/if-we-succeed
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#decent2022 An experimental inclusive format for NBER Decentralization Conference April 22-23. Speakers at four "live" locations: Bocconi, Columbia, Michigan, and Stanford. Come in person, participate via zoom, or both: Program and registration here: sites.google.com/view/decentralization-2022/home
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Self Organization! www.facebook.com/718610610/posts/10166180505895611/?d=n
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Eleanor Roosevelt candy dish - an ideal birthday gift for the theorist in your family!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Is being fair intuitive and does self-interest require reasoning? It depends. We intuitively punish bad behavior and reward good behavior. Proactive fairness and honesty may require a bit of thought. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S01497634173043…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Swarming bees-dynamic collective intelligence. (My individual intelligence low as I had four bees on my hand when finished filming!)
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Latest thoughts from @tpkehler from crowdsmart.ai on how to use AI to improve social collaboration by identifying and aligning core ideas. Collective intelligence does not happen by chance - it requires assemblage and process. medium.datadriveninvestor.com/finding-common-ground-socia…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
And my birthday (59 -egad) as well as the date that many children no longer wear boots at recess!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Most of the wonderful places in the world were not made by architects but by the people.” Christopher Alexander, A Pattern Language. The pattern I hold most dear - light from two sides-holds for both rooms and minds. May he Rest In Peace. May we create living spaces.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A comical take by the ever brilliant @ladamic on how cognitive limitations go “thunk” in multidimensional decision making contexts and why a diversity of models can reduce error.
Lada Adamic
@ladamic
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Only two days remaining to submit papers to 2022 Decentralization Conference "The Scope of Mechanism Design: From Bespoke Mechanisms to General Insights" to be held at four locations simultaneously. docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd2yr35QKBLS4oyxlJxnBBzq…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Kudos to Discover for bringing jobs to where people live! chicago.suntimes.com/business/2021/9/20/22676556/discover…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The new journal Collective Intelligence is about to start publishing. If you have or know of a great academic talk on Collective Intelligence, please add it to the thread below. And follow @Collective_CI. We're working to build a community!
Collective Intelligence
@Collective_CI
Cultivating a list of videos that provide general introductions to Collective Intelligence. Here's my 2018 attempt from a social science perspective. Please post links to your talks or talks that you found helpful in the thread. www.youtube.com/watch?v=46LgXUDbS0o
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Could lack of trust in institutions be in a negative feedback loop? thepointmag.com/forms-of-life/influence-inflation/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The best books for an aspiring or inspiring social scientist (or at least a decent collection of them) shepherd.com/best-books/for-aspiring-or-inspiring-social-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Discussions improve collective intelligence on numerical predictions (I’ve seen this dozens of times) but not yes/no classifications. One thought: for numerical predictions, discussion identifies extreme bad predictions; these don’t exist in binary case hbr.org/2021/09/some-questions-benefit-from-group-discuss…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great Article: Because wicked problems are essentially unfair and complex, effective solutions have to come through some kind of fair process leadership. knowledge.insead.edu/leadership-organisations/leadership-… via @INSEADKnowledge
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The 2022 Decentralization Conference will focus on specialized/bespoke mechanisms and "big think" mechanism design. To promote inclusivity yet enable human interaction, the conference will be held in four locations across the country simultaneously. docs.google.com/document/d/1GELbMDj6YuLbQoJfbTaCD9ARjzL_d…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Video summary of a paper with Maxim Sytch and Yonghyun Kim revealing the complexities of building robust supply-chains youtu.be/pdktN3xAxi0 via @YouTube
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Just happened upon this novel solution to a common pooch resource allocation problem
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Nice article on value of having our representatives interns be more representative @csmonitor www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2022/0208/Who-s-crafting-p…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
When assigned to teach (boring) criminal procedure, Yale Kamisar went all in & redefined the field. His writings resulted in the Miranda ruling. Reminder that even the most mundane teaching assignment offers opportunity for intellectual engagement. www.nytimes.com/2022/02/04/us/yale-kamisar-dead.amp.html
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Cool Research - large sample, good design - by @amirgoldb showing the amount of cognitive diversity should vary as a function of task within a group: during ideation, teams should encourage more cognitive diversity; during implementation less. www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/think-different-sometimes-t…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My home state Michigan voted to enfranchise a panel of randomly selected citizens to redraw our congressional and state electoral districts with GREAT results - fair, competitive districts. Will other states follow? Could this end gerrymandering? www.nytimes.com/2021/12/29/us/politics/michigan-congressi…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
During pandemic, high school debate participation down 25%. Loss of opportunity to build skills, community, and thrive. Differential access to extracurriculars should receive more attention. www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00221546.2021.191255… www.nytimes.com/2021/12/13/opinion/debate-important-lesso…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Congrats to @glmanzo on Research Handbook on Analytical Sociology covering norms, structures, context, contingency, action theory, social interactions. cumulative advantage, complex contagions, and network amplification. Guaranteed to float Coleman's Boat! www.e-elgar.com/shop/usd/research-handbook-on-analytical-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Federalism creates a “reservoir” of diversity of interests and information - as the latter diffuses, we can formulate more effective policies. Polarization makes the reservoir less diverse. How can well designed systems remedy this? Read here!
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
🌟New article alert!!🌟--- Democracy relies on diverse information; polarization compresses information. I describe why that's a threat to democracy and what institutional remedies are available, including federalism. www.pnas.org/content/118/50/e2113843118
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Super cool installation by my friend James Cogswell at UM
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
"The pandemic ... made us hyper aware of the world that we couldn't see." Amazing installation bringing microbes to human scale, surrounding the viewer using natural light & shadow. Kudos & thanks to artist/colleague/friend James Cogswell www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcg__GLK2Ao
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thinking of decision making as “social” by positioning doctors in peer networks produces reduction of of race and gender bias in clinical settings. Achieving collective intelligence requires good process and context not mere averaging. www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26905-5
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“the calculus of cost-benefit analysis may lie at cross purposes with the attempt to find meaning” Meaghan O’Gieblyn
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Model thinking in action - seeing value creation as formulating and solving specific problems. Same approach should work in policy settings. mbrjournal.com/2021/11/03/value-lab-a-tool-for-entreprene…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A deep, provocative idea: policing affects more than crime. Proposition 1: The new public safety research must seek to probe the effects of policing on a range of outcomes, including education, health, community flourishing, and subjective well-being.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Note that whites in more diverse areas (cities) vote more for D. In Richmond, even if 100% of non whites voted D, you need 56% of white vote to be D to get 75% D overall. If (more reasonably) 90% of nonwhites vote D, you need 65% of white vote to be D to get 75% D overall.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Astute observation by @kevinroose in NYT on why Zuckerberg has made the Meta pivot: who wants to be CEO of Facebook? “ a Boomer-dominated sludge pit filled with cute animal videos and hyperpartisan garbage” - More importantly, who aspires to work there?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The research process in three words: angst until synthesis
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
From NYT obit of M Csikszentmihalyi - author of “Flow”
-
Scott Page reposted
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
arxiv.org/abs/2107.04165
@phil_of_ai @profjamesevans @klakhani and moi show that the work that most influences us is that done by intellectually distant colleagues at the same institution -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Many university endowments saw windfall gains (@Umich, where I teach, endowment grew 40% to $17B) Seems to me to be a moment in time for elite colleges and universities to be more innovative.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My plenary talk at the 2021 Annual Meetings of the American Political Science Association on Leveraging Diversity (in a complex world) has been made free to everyone (thanks APSA!!!) Eager for comments, on my "punch card" analogy (43:00)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vz1rFC6brOo -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
What will surely be a provocative, erudite keynote early tomorrow (8am EDT) by Sophia Rosenfeld to kick off a new series at UM & Penn on common sense and critique within in a deliberative democracy. Open to anyone.
sites.google.com/umich.edu/common-sense-colloquia-public/… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Kudos to my colleague (and onboarding mentor) Sue Ashford on her new book which shows how to make big changes through sequences of small (validated) steps. Change is always hard. Flexing makes it easier! www.amazon.com/Power-Flexing-Experiments-Create-Life-Chan…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I had great fun appearing on Simon and Florian's Game Changer Podcast discussing the value of models. Listen here. www.tws-partners.com/podcast/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great piece in NYT on Wole Soyinka, who wrote and lives the quote “a tiger does not shout its tigritude. It acts.” www.nytimes.com/2021/09/25/books/wole-soyinka-chronicles-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
While prepping a class on uncertainty I received the following email “The delivery date for your purchase has been updated from September 15th please click on link below for latest information.” I click on the link and see the following:
“Expected delivery: Mid September” -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Someone’s reputation is, to a large extent, the ongoing effect of a conversation spread out in time and social space about that person’s reasons.” - The Enigma of Reason
Sperber and Mercier page 142 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This ideal theoretical model cannot probably be achieved. Partial models, imperfect as they may be, are the only means developed by science for understanding the universe .. the main tool of science is the human mind and the human mind is finite. A Rosenblueth & N Wiener (1945)
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A Poignant Gaussian Distribution: the late Gerald Gaus's final book - The Open Society and Its Complexities now being shipped. In the book, Gaus shows that moral and ideological diversity are the foundation, not the enemy, of a free and open society. global.oup.com/academic/product/the-open-society-and-its-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
If no other precautions are taken, Delta can spread through a half-vaccinated country more quickly than the original virus could in a completely unvaccinated country www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2021/08/delta-has-chan…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
How thousands of soccer fans collectively influence player salaries- they estimate player value by crowdsourcing information and then leverage diversity of views through dialogue. Perhaps someone should make a similar site for CEOs www.nytimes.com/2021/08/12/sports/soccer/soccer-football-…
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
We talkin about practice.
Best explanation I've heard yet of mRNA vaccines.
Drew Comments
@sjs856
They Got Pfizer. I Got Moderna
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The brilliant @seeratsohi unpacks Booker’s game through the lenses of social learning and complexity theory. Book combines skills of Rip and Kobe (with a dash of LeBron) to thrive (create a niche). And yet, just a drop of water in an endless sea www.theringer.com/2021/7/20/22585025/devin-booker-phoenix…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
What are standing ovations: A sign of respect? Evidence of prestige hierarchies in action? Expressions of insecurity? Bandwagon effects? Attempts at collective signaling? Yes, Yes, Yes, and Yes (at least according to @NAChristakis @CBicchieri and me!) www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2021/07/awkward-long-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great new practical guide to applying the intelligence community's tools of "analytic tradecraft" to risky business decisions by former CIA analyst, Jay Grusin, and financial risk manager, Steve Lindo. Loads of time tested ideas, advice, and frameworks. www.amazon.com/Intelligent-Analysis-Uncertainty-High-Stak…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Brilliant exposition on how ends - predict/explain - contribute to choice of model - agent based (bottom up) or systems dynamics (top down) by Gordon and Ouellette @sfiscience @Stanford. Benchmark paper for #collectiveintelligence www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphy.2021.687823/full
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@matthewsyed: how the collective brain produces simultaneous discovery & the meaning of originality - w/ riffs on romantic poets, airline and hospital safety, and how the Beatles Rubber Soul filtered Motown through a Liverpoolean Lens - awesome! www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m000x4wh
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
New article (sadly firewalled) describing how the search for exceptionalism biases toward those with high SES based on exposure to more opportunities with Uma Jayakumar www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00221546.2021.1912554
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At National Eye Institute panel on Diversity today. Michael Chiang @NEIDirector demonstrating strong, inclusive, leadership. Huge potential to transform vision research for aging and diversifying society.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Compelling case is made for social consumption of beer as valuable component of cultural tool kits (nod to Anne Swidler), for the occasional sip of whiskey for problem solving Googlers, and for faculty clubs!! www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2021/07/america-drin…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Very Uncooperative Hairstylist.
www.freep.com/story/news/health/2021/06/01/michigan-hair-… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great article on need for institutional redesign for a flourishing economy featuring @profjennabednar of @UMICHCS @fordschool
Financial Times
@FinancialTimes
A rebounding economy won’t mean a return to the status quo www.ft.com/content/08191411-4097-4bd3-be93-cbfd4ad7888a?l…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Women and men differ in their expectations about inflation. Difference not innate. Instead, explained by whether men go grocery shopping and see price volatility. "Honey, could you run to the store for coffee, juice, and an updated inflation estimate?" www.pnas.org/content/118/21/e2008534118.abstract
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
CASBS Panel Today at 2pm on Human Flourishing featuring @profjennabednar @HilaryCottam - how government, corporations, and communities repair our social fabric and create a sense of shared purpose and sustainable prosperity. Register here stanford.zoom.us/webinar/register/7716015790768/WN_v4Osky…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Two days ago, a little boy referred to Oda as a Good Pyrenees. This morning, Oda reminded us all that she is called a Great Pyrenees for a reason.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Michael Lewis in The Premonition: "A secret team of dissenting doctors, nicknamed the Wolverines, has everything necessary to fight the pandemic: brilliant backgrounds, world-class labs, prior experience…everything, that is, except official permission."
Love the name: Go BLUE! -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Expected sunny day in Ann Arbor broke grey and wet. Fitting as @UMICHCS mourns the loss of our irrepressible Charlie Doering
He is not here; but far away
The noise of life begins again,
And ghastly thro’ the drizzling rain
On the bald street breaks the blank day.
- Tennyson -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My friend Ron Inglehart passed yesterday. Ron’s academic accomplishments are awe inspiring. In my heart though, I think of Ron as a devoted parent who regularly took walks with his son. Passing our house, Ron would boom a hello and share his joy in life images.app.goo.gl/YJVMR5UrSPeqpUVCA
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The brilliant @katy_milkman unpacks a key distinction between incentives and motivation. Effective gamification requires alignment and buy in.
Katy Milkman
@katy_milkman
An adapted piece from my new book #howtochange is just out in @WIRED on the power and pitfalls of gamification. It holds potential to help us achieve more at home and at work, but only if used wisely.
Featuring #research by @janagallus @emollick @NRothbard www.wired.com/story/power-and-pitfalls-gamification/ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Recipe to create a three dimensional complex adaptive system that operates at the edge of chaos: step 1: leave outer door to porch open until a chickadee enters. step 2: allow M > 1 dogs onto porch.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The domain name informationentropy.com was available and has been bought by a cannabis shop in Ann Arbor - Egad. One wonders how long before a divorce lawyer buys kldivergence.com informationentropy.com
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great piece on collective mental health - particularly like the insight that we need to look at variance not just averages - organizational depression may be concentrated among those on lower rungs of the organization ladder
Geoff Mulgan
@geoffmulgan
Companies will thrive only if they recognise mental health is not an individual issue theprint.in/health/companies-will-thrive-only-if-they-rec… via @ThePrintIndia
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Third author (definition)
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Irony: (def’n) rewriting the introduction of an R&R on supply chain disruption because of the Ever Given in the Suez, then just before you re re submit, the auto industry supply chain all but shuts down for lack of chips. In response, Peugeot using throwback analog speedometer
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Congrats Prexy Martin. Well deserved honor. As I type, Kevin Quinn is recalibrating the new ideological midpoint of academy members!!
Andrew D. Martin
@WashUChancellor
I'm incredibly honored and humbled to be among those elected members of the @americanacad along with four of my @WUSTL colleagues! source.wustl.edu/2021/04/chancellor-four-faculty-members-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great piece by @tkehler on integrating human intelligence and AI to produce collectively intelligent investment decisions (if you've got 10 minutes, it'll be well spent)
towardsdatascience.com/transforming-organizational-decisi… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A “shack stack burger” fries and a shake lightens your wallet to the tune of $25+ either you are teaching some wealthy undergrads or they should scooch Shake Shack up vertically!!
Catherine D. Tan
@Catherineoscopy
Ta daaaaaaa
Used the Bourdieu graphs so the axis is inverted -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
NPR Marketplace reporter @JasGarsd interview with @UzziLeadership and me on how orgs can thoughtfully leverage data to better attract, retain, and promote a diverse workforce. @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss www.marketplace.org/2021/04/19/for-companies-trying-to-di…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Perhaps I have a different conception of "savage." Gates' commitment to getting it right as opposed to being right strikes me as Gates being wise. Gates separates himself from his ideas - a rare ability.
Zack Kanter
@zackkanter
Larry Ellison on Bill Gates being an absolute savage.
(‘Softwar’) -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For the 50th anniversary of the Decentralization conference we commissioned an Econ Theory/Mech Design crossword puzzle. It’s individually rational to print this out and give it a go. You may need a hint for the first clue, as it’s nearly impossible for non theorists!!
Alex Teytelboym
@t8el
The Decentralization conference might be over 😭, but @natanlast's delightful Decentralization Crossword is here for all to enjoy. 👇👇 Five attendees successfully completed it and are getting a haul of @Scott_E_Page's signed books sent to them. Have fun!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Cool blog by @NickArnosti containing a diverse collection of fun, quick read models covering Lebron TripDubs (the Coupon Collector Problem), License plate lotteries, NBA rebounds, running in circles, and matching vs queuing nickarnosti.com/blog/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Provocative letter on how minimum parking set asides - which seem like a good idea- actually give cars priority over people and undermine public transportation parkingreform.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Shoup-Friedm…
-
Scott Page reposted
Jessica Flack
@C4COMPUTATION
Letter writing, w/ its slow + intimate pace, used to play a key role in idea development in the sciences. In this tradition, CI will be publishing exchanges of letters on challenging topics. The 1st is b/w titans + will be on the pros+cons of noise in collective decision-making.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Here we go!!! #decent21 kicks off in 20 minutes! Two and a half days of amazing papers bridging theory and practice!
CAASI @GSPIA
@CaasiPitt
Today is the day. @PittTweet @GSPIA @CaasiPitt are so excited to present the 50th anniversary of @nberpubs #decent21 conference (supported by @NSF & @ESRC). At 11:50 EST, we will be kicking off the conference with an introduction and welcome from @seralinardi and @Scott_E_Page.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The SAME data were given to 73 research teams to test the SAME hypotheses on immigration and policy support. The result: 17% support, 58% no effect, 25% reject. Evidence that empiricists rely on different models to organize data.
osf.io/preprints/metaarxiv/cd5j9/ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Nearly 400 registered for #decent21. Tomorrow is last day to register. Friday, features amazing research in educational disparities and migration. @TommyAn53041153, @t8el, @alexander_betts @red_abebe sites.google.com/view/caasi-pitt/decentralization-2021/re…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#decent2021 kicks off Thursday at 11:45 with noon Keynote by Tuomas Sandholm "Sample Complexity of Mechanism Design" Question: How large must sample be so that the optimal mechanism for the sample is nearly optimal IRL? sites.google.com/view/caasi-pitt/decentralization-2021?au…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Amazing SFI podcast w/ Jonas Delage www.santafe.edu/culture/podcast discussing the interplay between pressure to conform socially while avoiding cognitive dissonance. See also @profjennabednar, @jonesrooy, and sites.lsa.umich.edu/scottepage/wp-content/uploads/sites/3… @sfiscience @UMICHCS
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Decentralization Conference Preview Mech Design for Vulnerable Populations. April 15-17 youtu.be/e98LUo9YY-s via @YouTube Register for any session you like (see previous tweets for link)@UMICHCS #decent2021
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Loved writing this paper with a brilliant ensemble. I note (with irony) as an editor of Collective Intelligence (CI), that Trends in Cognitive Science limited the # authors - most contributors relegated to a footnote! At CI no restrictions! Submit us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/collective-intelligence/journal2…
Josh Wolfe
@wolfejosh
Explore vs Exploit. Wow by Princeton's @icouzin @sfiscience key for #vc #startups #investing www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661314002332
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great two minute video by @seralinardi describing how mechanism design offers tools for assisting vulnerable populations - the theme of the 2021 Decentralization Conference www.youtube.com/watch?v=OLig4bgfBmU
Register here
sites.google.com/view/caasi-pitt/decentralization-2021?au… -
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Worried about democracy in the U.S. states? militias? racist violence? party polarization? Jim Crow 2.0? This and more 🌟tomorrow @ noon 🌟 Join me and @AFilindra @JakeMGrumbach @robmickey @dmcguire13 @Slaterpolitics Register at myumi.ch/Yy8AM
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
As part of the 2021 Decentralization Conference, the amazing team at Pitt has put together videos. Here's @yanchen describing the paper she will present on how to motivate experts to contribute to Wikipedia. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-LniqISOn88
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Full conference program and registration here
sites.google.com/view/caasi-pitt/decentralization-2021?au… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
April 15-17 The University of Pittsburgh will be hosting the 50th Anniversary Decentralization Conference with the theme of Mechanism Design for Vulnerable Populations. sites.google.com/view/caasi-pitt/decentralization-2021?au… conference is open to all!
Post not available here, view on X
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The history of this conference traces back to Hurwicz, Reuter, Radner, Marschak, and Arrow who were asking foundational questions about the capacity of decentralized systems to make allocation decisions. This year, @seralinardi has challenged the mech design community.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Can the tools and frameworks from mechanism design help address problems for the most vulnerable among us? Can we translate theoretical insights in a way that informs people on the ground working in vulnerable populations?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
That time a student turned in a rough draft and I said, oh this is great. It’s an A. www.mlb.com/amp/news/miguel-cabrera-homers-in-snow-on-ope…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Arundhati Roy: “The Pandemic Is a Portal” www.yesmagazine.org/video/coronavirus-pandemic-arundhati-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Yesterday, I leapt from an am Silicon Valley discussion of collective intelligence & the hybrid cloud with brilliant people at @nutanix to a joyful champagne popping birthday party for @amine_ouazad with Europeans. Coining #zoomlash - love to hear your #zoomlash experiences
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Paperback edition of The Model Thinker now available with new chapter on COVID models. Huge shoutout to Basic Books for going all in with a Maize and Blue cover. @sfiscience @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss www.amazon.com/Model-Thinker-What-Need-Know/dp/1541675711
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This graphic in the economist shows the incredible (non competitive) concentration of firms in tech. @ProfFionasm
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“With consistency a great soul simply has nothing to do.” Emerson. Sixty plus degree weather in Michigan in early March (a rare event). Seven plus inches of ice on the lake in early March (even rarer). Both on the same day? Be a hedgehog! @PTetlock
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A web page version of my talk today on systemic inequality with some gif animations explaining difference between emergent systemic effects and separable effects - comments welcome @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss
sites.google.com/view/scottepagestructuralinequality/home -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Taught coordination failure to undergrads last week. Next time I’m making Oda and Roland sit in!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
From Dick Nisbett's "Thinking: A Memoir" : consensus thinking on intelligence was largely wrong: too much on heritability too little on environment, too much on IQ too little on cognitive skills & knowledge, & wrong in concluding genetic role in blacks and whites IQ differences
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
(Asking for a friend) Has anyone - 1980’s Mad Magazine/Weird Al style - rewritten the lyrics to “You Only Get One Shot” from Hamilton as “You Only Get Two Shots” (from Pfizer)?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The question of whether diversity beget diversity has always fascinated me. Yes, more diversity would seem to imply more niches, but... exploit often follows explore. Great empirical analysis that says yes it does @ChrisKempes www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-76658-2
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Spectacular paper by @BuyalskayaSan @CFCamerer and @gallomarcos. We live in a golden age of social science with better data, improved methodology, and more interdisciplinary efforts. Strong argument using behavioral econ and social networks as exemplars. www.pnas.org/content/118/5/e2002923118
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Only connect!
And buy Noreena’s award winning latest book! -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Proud and eager to begin on this latest adventure with a diverse, talented collection of people! Think! Write! Submit! Free yourself of disciplinary constraints!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Here’s another: Oregon State: “Shiver me Timbers!” www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/an-applicants-guide-to-studen…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Just completed a regression using twelve years of data and found that the number of hours before banana bread is gone (H) as a function of number of sons - out of two - at home (S) can be written as follows: H =48-21S
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
"It is hardly possible to overrate the value … of placing human beings in contact with persons dissimilar to themselves. Such communication has always been, and is peculiarly in the present age, one of the primary sources of progress." John Stuart Mill
www.ibe.org.uk/resource/ethicsofdiversity.html -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great content for those teaching complex adaptive systems courses this winter @LuisZaman www.nytimes.com/2020/12/28/science/math-conway-game-of-li…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
42 is usually the answer to the ultimate question. In today’s NYT puzzle it’s the question to the ultimate answer! Go Blue!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A HUGE spend - $35 Billion ($30 From JP Morgan) - to expand financial services and build infrastructure to improve racial equity. Virtue signaling or a shift in priorities from making $$ to improving the world? Answer: A little bit of neither.
www.wsj.com/articles/companies-have-promised-billions-tow… via @WSJ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My colleague Patrick Grim at @UMICHCS makes awesome holiday cards. This year he’s outdone himself with a bit of Santa magic!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Today! The amazing @LindredG released a free 4 week course: Leading Diverse Teams and Organizations covering identity, privilege, bias, & micro aggressions. Make your organization more inclusive by improving yourself. #dei @MichiganRoss, #leadership
www.coursera.org/learn/leading-diverse-teams-and-organiza… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Kim Border, an economist @Caltech passed away yesterday. @ben_golub describes Kim’s awe inspiring depth as a teacher. When I arrived at Caltech as an assistant professor, Kim took it upon himself to be not my mentor or colleague, but my Friend. I treasure him for that.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Any truth to the rumor that the World Bridge Federation has been asked to use an alternative word for Trump because the card game Go Fish is filing a trademark to be rebranded as “Trump”?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Huge loss. I had the honor and privilege of being on PhD committees with Frank. Brilliant and
Inclusive person. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Can too much time and too many resources undermine attempts to achieve collective intelligence through overthinking? Or, can a strict reliance on democratic rule prevent it? www.nytimes.com/2020/11/18/sports/basketball/nba-draft-mi…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
No meetings week!
apple.news/AEStqNJOyTXWrnjb_ooIMJQ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Lots of threads on Meritocracy - here’s a link to free pdf of the book that coined the term “The Rise Of The Meritocracy” - a book of social science fiction which explores the consequences of a fully meritocratic society. Weighing in at a mere 184 pages kuangaliablog.files.wordpress.com/2017/04/michael_young_t…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My wife Jenna’s mom Karen was diagnosed with COVID yesterday. Please where masks and socially distance.
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
My mom was diagnosed this morning and is now hospitalized in the COVID ward of her local hospital north of Detroit. Please mask up everyone. It’s not political.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Wow was that a Freudian slip “where masks!”
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
You never forget how to ride a bike! fb.watch/1LO5uu33_-/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great Zoom Time Saving Teaching Tip: Preload two polls to use every class.
Y/N Question: Answers: Y, N, Maybe
Multiple Choice Question: Answers A,B,C,D
Then pose the specific question on your powerpoint slide. No need to preload polls. Thanks Will Thomas @MichiganRoss. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
How to misrepresent data lesson #4
Use different units on vertical axis to make one data set appear to have more variance than the other.
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
In case you are wondering, evidence does not support inconsistency of vote totals with Benford’s law per my brilliant colleague Walter Mebane www-personal.umich.edu/~wmebane/inapB.pdf
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Want to understand how RNA vaccines work? Dr Kizzmekia Corbett explains starting at 47:10.
Imagine preparing our immune system by telling them about the invaders’ spiky helmets rather than describing their full uniform. Brilliant!!
www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/decoding-covid-19/ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Trump to hold rally in Nevada. A brief reminder of Festinger’s original study of cognitive dissonance. (Hint: Please remove all metal before arriving at Four Seasons Total Landscaping.) www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/12/the-christmas-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A good first step in forecasting is establishing a baseline. Voter Fraud exists. So how much? From 2000-2014, the US has 31 verified cases or 2 per year. This year will surely be higher than average, maybe 5? 8? www.brennancenter.org/sites/default/files/analysis/Briefi…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Breaking News: This weekend The Big Ten will not show the first quarter of any games and not reveal any scores. Following the completion of the fourth quarter, the first quarter will be aired at one-fourth speed with breaks for studio crew to grab dinner.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This is the best!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A reminder that our life experiences and interactions with the political system and not our “racial” categories underpin our votes. Not difficult to figure out which group suffered under socialism and which received insufficient post disaster support by incumbent government.
Ami Dar
@AmiDar
Maybe being specific is more useful than throwing around broad categories like “Hispanic” or “Latino?”
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My family voting at my masked sons’ former elementary school in Ann Arbor today. Special family moment.
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
#ivoted family style. Boy did it feel great to feed my ballot into the machine. #govote
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
One more reason to support public art.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Some Sunday morning shade from the New York Times puzzle maker?
(What is the status of your manuscript by the way?) -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great thread by Shane on the necessity and limits of models - and many models
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Duh? Of course the counties with the highest per capita outbreaks have small populations. So do the counties with the lowest per capita rates. This is basic statistics! @nytimes
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A video representation of my progress on a recent paper es.pn/34jxBgP
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A mere 10% of twitter users generate 97% of tweets about politics.” Most people view the hyperbole from the extremes as “just politics” I bet only 1% of Twitter users generate 99% of ——
(Insert area academic study here) great piece @ykrupnikov www.nytimes.com/2020/10/20/opinion/polarization-politics-… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
We can’t just “add diversity and stir” nor can we care only about the immediate “business case.” We need inclusive, diverse firms because we want a functioning diverse society where everyone can thrive. Wisdom. hbr.org/2020/11/getting-serious-about-diversity-enough-al…
-
Scott Page reposted
Shane Parrish
@shaneparrish
Kind before clever.
Others before you.
Give before getting.
Prevent before solving.
Listen before speaking. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Process and formal methods outperform intuition. You might have thought this was true intuitively, but good to have a model and an empirical analysis :)
Robin Hanson
@robinhanson
Formal analysis wins: "CEOs use markedly different processes to make strategic decisions; some follow highly formalized … others rely heavily on instinct … structured strategy processes are associated with larger firm size & faster employment growth" www.nber.org/papers/w27952
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Jocelyn Benson and Frank LaRose on Voter Turnout and Access in Ohio and Michigan with @profjennabednar fordschool.umich.edu/events/2020/2020-election-voter-turn…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Not just a good idea - it’s the law! Mask mandates lower deaths by 80% and cases by 90% when indoor dining was reopened. Other factors in play here, but those are ginormous (to use the technical term) effect sizes. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11606-020-06277-0
-
Scott Page reposted
Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy
@fordschool
This week in #policytalks: Secretaries of State @JocelynBenson and @FrankLaRose on voting rights and voter access. Moderated by @profjennabednar.
📆 Tomorrow: Friday, October 9
🕒 3 PM - 4 PM EDT
Presented in partnership with @detroitpublictv. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Instead of relying on expertise, the administration has turned to uninformed “opinion leaders” and charlatans who obscure the truth and facilitate the promulgation of outright lies.” Imagine how this read pre-edit!! www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMe2029812
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Spectacular article on how adults and children apply a “what if everyone did that” in novel situations. Describes cognitive mechanism as well. Will @JoHenrich find this WEIRD? www.pnas.org/content/early/2020/10/01/2014505117
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Miami Dolphins provide framework for diverse leadership on, off field www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/30008063/miami-dolphins-provi…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Do superspreading events explain clustering of outbreaks? And are people, places with poor ventilation, or the combination of the two the cause? And, if the last of these, how do we respond? apple.news/AEeGWztiwSqiwClYBfEv1ew
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The $3.75 per hour solution to my dog barking during zoom seminars. Thanks to Sparrow meats!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#thesocialdilemma went golfing with my son yesterday and based on his location, he began getting ads in his feed for golf equipment. Explains why I’ve been getting those ads for limited pro stock tractor pulling engines.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For all of my faculty colleagues at @UMich in agony over our 65% revote / p-hack / affront to rile followers everywhere. Here is a glimmer of hope. A famous paper showing you only need 64% www.jstor.org/stable/1912699
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The overwhelming concerns that people voiced were that the administration take action on structural racism, show humility, apologize, increase transparency, and decentralize. Huge thank you to the awesome @UMich community for helping my prepare. Go Blue! www.freep.com/story/news/education/2020/09/15/university-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Tomorrow 1:45 -2:30 EST I engage in a live, frank conversation with UM President and Provost about pandemic and other issues. Streaming at umich.edu/watch. Members of the University Community, send me your thoughts, concerns, and questions here
forms.gle/5b84pHvAf6nD6vBQ8 -
Scott Page reposted
john seely brown
@jseelybrown
Please try to listen in...
Institute For The Future
@iftf
Sept. 3: Join Ann Pendleton-Jullian and @jseelybrown for part two of their conversation on navigating our “whitewater world” - a world that is hyperconnected, rapidly changing, and radically contingent. Moderated by IFTF Distinguished Fellow Richard Adler. iftf.zoom.us/webinar/register/6515979505945/WN_QEVq9jtES4…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful piece on how the Milwaukee Bucks refusal to play differed from NBA’s corporate approach to raise awareness. The Buck’s action seemed more real because, well, it was. www.theringer.com/nba/2020/8/27/21404988/nba-strike-colli…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
University of Illinois steps up with amazing saliva based test that even measures viral load. Testing everyone frequently. Great interview here www.facebook.com/163536409904/posts/10158904231379905/?vh…
-
Scott Page reposted
john seely brown
@jseelybrown
Please try to come...
Institute For The Future
@iftf
Tomorrow! Join Ann Pendleton-Jullian and @jseelybrown to hear how we can use a new mindset to navigate our “whitewater world” - a world that is hyperconnected and radically contingent. Moderated by IFTF Distinguished Fellow Richard Adler. iftf.zoom.us/webinar/register/1315948630414/WN_23tbv5VfQ2…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Excellent thread on proven interventions that reduce crime
Anna Harvey
@annalilharvey
Recently there's been lots of interest in alternatives to law enforcement. Many have also expressed concern about recent increases in violent crime.
So: what non-law enforcement policies/programs have been shown specifically to reduce *violent crime*?
A thread: -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Honored and excited to be part of a new interdisciplinary journal focusing on collective intelligence. Please submit papers and help us learn why and how more is both different and wiser! @MichiganRoss @UMICHCS @sfiscience
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
+ "In my life I have done all I can to demonstrate that the way of peace, the way of love and nonviolence is the more excellent way." An amazing person with uncommon humility.
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
"Democracy is not a state. It is an act, and each generation must do its part to help build ... a nation and world society at peace with itself."
John Lewis points to our North Star and reminds us that we have the power to choose it to light our path.
www.nytimes.com/2020/07/30/opinion/john-lewis-civil-right… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My HBR piece on how preventing workplace spread of Covid requires thinking systemically. Reducing transmission on each pathway (people - objects - air) independently result in a connected transmission network. @UMICHCS @sfiscience @MichiganRos
hbr.org/2020/07/reopening-the-office-heres-how-to-stymie-… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Wallace Stegner describing the rapids of the Colorado. “They are not ocean waves, where the water remains in place and only the form passes on. Here the form remains and the water passes on..” At this moment, which are we?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A complexity take on post Covid innovation - rugged landscapes, spinglasses, & multi-armed bandits @UMICHCS @sfiscience @MichiganRoss
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Coronavirus and Innovation- some optimistic thoughts on our post Covid world items.ssrc.org/covid-19-and-the-social-sciences/policy-mo…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Coronavirus and Innovation- some optimistic thoughts on our post Covid world items.ssrc.org/covid-19-and-the-social-sciences/policy-mo…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
New book by awesome INSEAD prof Charlie Galunic.
Charles Galunic
@CharlesGalunic
In case you need some summer reading, my book was just launched. :-)
In the past 20 years of leadership development, the space has been filled with mirrors.
I thought we needed a few more windows.
www.amazon.com/Backstage-Leadership-Invisible-Effective-L… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Congrats to my partner Jenna Bednar on her new position at the Ford School!!
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
I'm delighted to share some personal news...
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Nice - I figured someone had done this with better graphics
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
From math.stackexchange.com/questions/973242/sum-of-cubes-proof. Add the shapes of the same color to form the requisite cubes
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Tayfun Sonmez posted this awesome equality: the square of the first n integers equals the sum of the first n cubes. Inductive proof is easy. Here’s a direct proof I came up with that “unhinges” the square to create n columns - one for each cube. @stevenstrogatz wannabe
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A nice graph to keep in your back pocket the next time someone opens a discussion of the efficient market hypothesis. All ears on how covid caused this massive drop and the rise. Did teenagers learn to make Mac and cheese in May? images.app.goo.gl/99D21xGUyw3brRYY7
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For those of us sending children off to school, plan for three contingencies 1. Child gets virus 2. College shuts down - your child is asymptomatic 3. You catch virus and child about to come home. Have quarantine/care plans for each scenario. (None can include my basement!)
-
Scott Page reposted
Dr. Trevon D Logan
May I please get 2 friends to copy and repost? I am trying to demonstrate that someone is always listening.
#suicideawareness
1-800-273-8255
Just two. Any two. Copy- not retweet -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
How many of you have a favorite lecture that sometimes induces this same effect in students? Mine is (ironically) on the value of information. @UMICHCS newatlas.com/medical/suspended-animation-torpor-induced-h…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Also, some insights by Darwin, Keynes, and Hume!! As well as @TaniaLombrozo whose name is misspelled!!!
Santa Fe Institute
@sfiscience
The stock market doesn't make any sense. This @Forbes piece, drawing on SFI Chair @mjmauboussin & SFI Profs John Miller & @Scott_E_Page, explains why: it's a complex adaptive system. A "Keynesian Beauty Contest." A predictive arms race. A kind of ecology:
www.forbes.com/sites/johnjennings/2020/06/15/why-the-stoc… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My son Cooper made these floor stickers that draw attention to one of the many ways in which the pandemic obliges us to be large enough to contain contradiction ( to borrow a phrase from Whitman)
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Help reopen Mama Safia’s Kitchen. www.npr.org/2020/06/01/866379762/restaurant-owner-whose-b…
www.gofundme.com/f/save-mama-safias-kitchen -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Huge shout out to the amazing @presnick and his team at @umsi for for developing this interactive app mistartmap.info that shows risk levels by county in Michigan.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Growing optimistic about virtual + physical reopening of UM because of tech portfolio. Not just Zoom, but Loom, Yellowdig, Perusall, Slack, Sway, and Canvas. Students will learn how to learn, interact, lead, communicate, and build communities virtually. @MichiganRoss @UMICHCS
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thanks to the Ann Arbor Ypsilanti Chamber of Commerce for Taping a Presentation of the Reopening Toolkit (60 minutes so bring popcorn). @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss
Video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=etxODlUDgbM
Revised Toolkit: sites.google.com/view/reopening-toolkit/home -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Tomorrow am, I'm talking strategies for reopening to Ann Arbor and Ypsi Chamber of Commerce. Anyone have any last minute reads, websites, opinions, data, thoughts, mindsets that I might use? @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_WYEnHCMkR4y9bDqoymQsCA
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Dagen H: 3/9/67 Sweden switched from driving on the lef side of the road to the right. Dagen H had a theme song ``Stay to the right, Svensson, keep to the right otherwise it ends only with a bang" Is Swedish Social Distancing HipHop next?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ntVcOVemvdo -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
What epidemiology models can do: explain patterns, predict trends, guide policy. All aided by better data. Here are some nontechnical explanations of some of the many models in use www.nature.com/articles/s42254-020-0178-4
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Jenna @profjennabednar and Andrea @jonesrooy Live tonight at 7pm as they posit deep questions: Is Federalism a State of Mind? Why do we split pies and layer cakes? Does the concept of robustness hold up to scrutiny? And, why did Dolly Madison not James make cupcakes? Be there A2!
University of Michigan Complex Systems
@UMICHCS
Tonight! CSCS affiliate faculty Jenna Bednar to be featured guest on CSCS and @umichLSA alum Andrea Jones-Rooy's 'Ask a Political Scientist' 7:00 pm here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=X5sy3fQFjHg
@profJennaBednar @JonesRooy -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thejas Suvarna, a UM-Ross student, and I have created two quizzes to test your skills at predicting pandemics. You get two weeks of data and must predict total number - reply with your score! @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss @sfiscience sites.google.com/umich.edu/predict-pandemics/home
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
'Lives or livelihoods' misses the point of pandemic recovery wisdom from @rajivatbarnard @sfiscience thehill.com/opinion/finance/497481-lives-or-livelihoods-m…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
When I’m about to throw more spaghetti at the fridge hoping that something sticks, I have learned to first check to make sure that there actually is a fridge. @sfiscience @UMICHCS
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Tahiti of my Soul
"Consider the subtleness of the sea; how its most dreaded creatures glide under water, unapparent for the most part, and treacherously hidden beneath the loveliest tints of azure." Melville
The Amazing Benedict Cumberbatch- 7 min
www.mobydickbigread.com/chapter-58-brit/ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Model in Science suggests effective contact tracing must be instantaneous. Looming question: will those traced and told to quarantine do so? Or, will they dismiss the advice because they feel fine? “Traced and Quarantined” needs to be an honorable status! science.sciencemag.org/content/368/6491/eabb6936.full
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Some brief videos that go into more details of the main points in my WaPo article linked below can be found here m.youtube.com/channel/UCaaOg1O7tA7F3RheEqGCtzw
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Which model do you trust? Many! www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/05/07/which-pandemic…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Which model do you trust? Many! www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/05/07/which-pandemic…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Filed this under “How to Make a Good Analogy” Sure, the Velociraptors Are Still On the Loose, But That’s No Reason Not to Reopen Jurassic Park. www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/sure-the-velociraptors-are-st…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great general information COVID Site by @ProfEmilyOster
explaincovid.org -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
State health department tells university COVID-19 modeling team to stop (just for a while). No ma’am. Yes SIR! www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/arizona-health/2020/05…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Lots of food for thought here - evidence that we don’t see higher order needs of less fortunate.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Reopening:
McKinsey: www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporat…
Rouge Professor:sites.google.com/view/reopening-toolkit/home -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Spectacular thread by my colleague @LuisZaman providing intuition for how infections spread threadreaderapp.com/thread/1257308273004298240.html
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Current Wisdom: High Essential, Low Risk (auto repair) get to open early. Low Essential, High Risk (fitness centers) remain closed. @sfiscience: "the economy is a complex system." Firms adapt. Low Essential, High Risk firms today may be High Essential, Low Risk firms tomorrow.
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
A view of the gallery in the Michigan State Senate today, as senators vote on whether to extend the state of emergency.
Senator Dayna Polehanki
@SenPolehanki
Directly above me, men with rifles yelling at us. Some of my colleagues who own bullet proof vests are wearing them. I have never appreciated our Sergeants-at-Arms more than today. #mileg
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Sasquatch evidence for you doubters!
Mich_Chevious
@Mich_Chevious
Michigan’s flag has a Sasquatch!! images.app.goo.gl/LJRWgomYy8u6YbhbA
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Michigan leading the nation in lowering transmission - by Rt
And our flag has a Sasquatch! rt.live -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A Reopening Toolkit for Businesses and Organizations: 20 strategies from a complex systems perspective. How to maintain functionality, prevent the spread, and create meaningful work. @MichiganRoss @UMICHCS @sfiscience sites.google.com/view/reopening-toolkit/home
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My undergraduate students @MichiganRoss and @UMICHCS have completed their crowdsourced "Models of COVID" website. Lot's of models, data, and insights. Really proud of their accomplishment. Give it a look - lots there to learn.
sites.google.com/umich.edu/manymodelsclovid19/home -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great website by State of Michigan for businesses to reopen www.misafeworkplaces.com
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
University if Michigan’s Jenna Bednar talking about Federalism in NPRs Marketplace today! States cannot do this alone @profjennabednar @umichLSA @UMICHCS @sfiscience podcasts.google.com?feed=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cubWFya2V0cGxhY2Uu…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Kudos to my former a PhD student @ulisrael1 Uriah Israel featured in this piece on how students mix thoroughly. Good for spread of knowledge and, alas, for the spread of Coronavirus. www.chronicle.com/article/A-Very-Small-World-How-Data/248556
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Information in its real essence is probably too amorphous, too ambiguous, too subjective, too slippery and elusive, to ever be pinned down precisely by the objective and deterministic processes embodied in a computer”. Hence, many models... tdan.com/review-of-data-and-reality-3rd-edition/16130
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
For those more technically minded, i.e. "whose afraid of differential equations!" my amazing colleague Marisa Eisenberg will be giving an online seminar on her COVID-19 models for the state of Michigan at 3pm EST live on Bluejeans micde.umich.edu/event/webinar-transmission-modeling-meise…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“Like being on EBay with 50 other states!” @profjennabednar clarifies misconceptions about federalism www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/04/17/course-trumps-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Second piece by Josh Epstein and colleagues showing how models can help with re-opening of the economy www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/04/07/coronavirus-tes…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great piece by Josh Epstein. We must get out in front of "vaccine fear" is crucial. Getting those recovered back to work is essential. Are We Already Missing the Next Epidemic? www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/03/31/coronavirus-ame… via @politico
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Lancet chart showing fatality rates from coronavirus and COVID-19 disease (not the same). Enormous relative risks to older populations. Other data show 2X to 5X increases from underlying health issues. As societies open up, we must identify and protect the most vulnerable.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Understanding Epidemics: The IHME Model and Curve Fitting. In this video, I explain the #ihme model and how it uses data and policy interventions to make predictions. @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss @sfiscience
youtu.be/z3tg77POEeU via @YouTube -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Video #4 networks, contact tracing and superspreaders with @az_jacobs youtu.be/NEn1HW2gnqQ
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Pleased to release the fourth video in the Understanding Epidemics - A Many Model Approach series. My star colleague Abbie Jacobs @az_jacobs shares her knowledge of network effects. @MichiganRoss @UMICHCS @Umichlsa @sfiscience
youtu.be/NEn1HW2gnqQ via @YouTube -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Read this a little too quickly this morning!
Kiran Johny
@johnywrites
Every departments should have multiple expert fringe groups + a @PTetlock + a @Scott_E_Page + most importantly an annoying functional narcissist like @nntaleb
Every depmts should be connected to others in transparent information exchange & depmts should be feedback sensitive. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Big thank you to @UMICHCS (Linda Wood) and @umichLSA for putting together this website of COVID-19 educational materials. @sfiscience @MichiganRoss
lsa.umich.edu/cscs/news-events/all-news/search-news/profe… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I am pleased to release another video in my Understanding Epidemics series. This video explains the SIR model, a core model of epidemiology. @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss @sfiscience
Understanding Epidemics: The SIR Model and COVID-19 youtu.be/72kLBDiy0h0 via @YouTube
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Yes!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My UM colleague Mark Newman author of The Atlas of the Real World made this map of the US states where each state’s size is proportional to the number of COVID-19 cases.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I am working to produce a collection of videos explaining how models and data can help us understand the COVID epidemic and make policy. Here is my latest effort. It explains fatality rate models, categories, and the bias-variance tradeoff. Please share!!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Y4pTOdFFyQ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Carl makes some strong points here. Model assumes China level lockdown, uses curve fitting not microfoundations, and ignores possibility of pandemic. In modal case 3% of us get virus. WE NEED MANY MODELS! Not just one with great graphics!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thought provoking idea: what if the government had just cancelled April economically? Any financial obligations due April X would just be due May X. Then just send each person enough to live on for a month.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Professors and teachers: Your can still join the The Hypermind Pandemic Prediction Contest. It lasts for two more weeks. We have hundreds of participants. Great opportunity to teach about markets. We will be posting questions for classroom analysis on Friday!
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I am excited to announce that hypermind.com and I have created a prediction market that touches on the impacts of COVID-19. It is free and meant to be used in online classes to teach markets, information, etc.. please retweet! Click on site! sites.google.com/umich.edu/2020predictionmarket/home
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
To help clarify a common misunderstanding about the fatality rate of COVID-19, I made a short educational video. @UMICHCS @SFI
www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLzUVrTSSwY -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My Collective Intelligence Class at UM-Ross has produced a website showing how models can explain and predict the spread of COVID-19 and how models are being used to guide policy. sites.google.com/umich.edu/manymodelsclovid19/home
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Why waste this opportunity? Keep these well-trained, community-minded people on the payroll working domestically. We need the help. I bet @AlanKhazei or @cecmunoz would have a good idea for how to redeploy them. www.washingtonpost.com/politics/the-peace-corps-isnt-just…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I am excited to announce that hypermind.com and I have created a prediction market that touches on the impacts of COVID-19. It is free and meant to be used in online classes to teach markets, information, etc.. please retweet! Click on site! sites.google.com/umich.edu/2020predictionmarket/home
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Project quo imus crowdsources the question “where are we going” here is a “whish” that tech will enable us to make better decisions and find creative routes to human flourishing.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Among the many highlights of @TheEconomist special report on the data economy 2/22 “We all think data are so objective, but they are actually as interpretable as Shakespeare” Mike Potter of Qlik. I would add - in that diversity of interpretations lies the true value of the data.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great article on how data limitations hinder ability of models to make precise estimates of how fast coronavirus spreads and it’s fatality rate. www.statnews.com/2020/02/14/disease-modelers-see-future-o…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Wendell Berry - “ The Eyes to Acre Ratio” perhaps more important than Price earning ratios!!! www.dissentmagazine.org/article/nature-as-an-ally-an-inte…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Yael, even the colors match!!!
Yael Grushka-Cockayne
I compared @Scott_E_Page's shared Economist graph of equity analysts (whereby Northern Europe favors Northern Europe) to voting patterns in the @Eurovision song contest
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Economist graph showing equity analysts from Northern (Southern) Europe are biased in favor of Northern (Southern) European firms. Effect size non trivial - 6-8%
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Economist graph showing equity analysts from Northern (Southern) Europe are biased in favor of Northern (Southern) European firms. Effect size non trivial - 6-8%
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Katherine W. Phillips - she lived and taught the value of diversity. www.nytimes.com/2020/02/13/business/katherine-w-phillips-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A very authentic Sr Dean David L. Taylor from Georgetown Medical School - we must supplement “hope” with “opportunities” for students to acquire the “technical and clinical skills” required to be successful doctors. “We must intentionally raise competencies!”
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great piece by Professor Stephens on using tools from social science to reduce bias
Nicole Stephens
@NM_Stephens
I'm excited about this new piece I wrote for #kellogginsight magazine! It summarizes the content I'll teach in my new diversity course - The Strategy and Science of Bias Reduction - to be offered to full-time MBA students at @KelloggSchool this Spring! insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/employees-inclus…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Rutgers Newark makes a magnificent hire. JM is brilliant!!!
sasn.rutgers.edu/news-events/news/sasn-welcomes-new-dean-… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Graphic in today’s WSJ showing how very good private schools attempt to buy their way to the top through merit aid. Most of this money likely goes to wealthy families.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Join Us! This should be an amazing opportunity to think deeply about how to construct institutions for vulnerable populations.
Sera Linardi
@seralinardi
1/31/2020 is the deadline for the 2020 NSF/CEME Decentralization Conf: Mech Design for Vulnerable Population. Excited to have Tuomas Sandholm & @muunver as keynote speakers. @Scott_E_Page, J.Jeong and I hope to see you at @GSPIA Pittsburgh on 4/17-19! sites.google.com/view/caasi-pitt/decentralization-2020/about
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Facebook just suggested I friend Robert Putnam. I am beside myself with ironic joy! #iwillneverbowlalone
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This evening, we lost Katherine Phillips to cancer. A scholar who brought passion, charisma, and incredible strength to every endeavor, Katherine was a kind and thoughtful friend and a role model. We think. We write. We aim to make a difference. She did. images.app.goo.gl/t2DQh815S6v2C4Zw6
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@ovulsezer says that if you first establish women’s credentials, you can reduce mansplaining.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At @UMICHCS and @RossBizImpact we ran an amazing interdisciplinary conference comparing markets, hierarchies, democracies, communities, and algorithms as allocatative institutions and creators of culture.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Here’s an overview of The Choice - an opening to a broader discussion linking institutions to not just outcomes but also our ways of living sites.google.com/u/0/s/1k8UTDPzX1nd1pNCPBBFvzSAQKYsnMXiS/…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Paul Resnick - Algorithms @RossBizImpact @UMICHCS rossmedia.bus.umich.edu/rossmedia/Play/92005c03d74341b687…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Rebecca Hardin - Communities @UMICHCS @RossBizImpact rossmedia.bus.umich.edu/rossmedia/Play/d5c9710b2bc14e1385…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Lisa Disch - Democracies @UMICHCS @RossBizImpact rossmedia.bus.umich.edu/rossmedia/Play/15dfa2d698714b5cbe…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Elizabeth Popp Berman on Hierarchies @UMICHCS @RossBizImpact rossmedia.bus.umich.edu/rossmedia/Play/955b3ca54a7542eabb…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Here’s Betsey Stevenson on Markets. @UMICHCS @RossBizImpact rossmedia.bus.umich.edu/rossmedia/Play/f39ba925e6df449ca4…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Dina brilliantly captures key takeaways (in a mere 21 Tweets) of Bertrand’s breathtaking, data intensive summary on gender.
@20 word version- having a child hurts women economically and it’s tough to disentangle norms and preferences so economists need to engage social psychology
Dina D. Pomeranz 🟣
@DinaPomeranz
Thread of Marianne Bertrand's Ely Lecture at the #assa2020 on economics gender research:👇
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Fabulous new book by @ChengweiLiu on how not to be fooled by randomness and how to manage and make decisions when success involves luck. @mjmauboussin will love this. Filled with illustrative cases!! www.amazon.com/Luck-Business-Idea-Ideas-Management/dp/113…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#choiceumich Oscar Ybarra explains human need for agency and for community. Do different institutions pull us in different directions? Markets toward agency, democracy toward community?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#choiceumich Stanford’s Melissa Valentine explains how API’s (algorithms) replace formal organizations
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
World chess champion is 6th out of 7 million in Fantasy Soccer. Chalks it up to luck! He’s right BTW. Skill gets him to top 1000, then he gets darn lucky! www.theguardian.com/sport/2019/dec/08/world-chess-champio…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Trenchant observation of how a single ranking - in this case Parker’s wine scoring - can to a lack of diversity. In this case, diversity returned though a combination of dedication to craft, appreciation of locality, and market forces @petererdi www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/11/25/how-natural-wine-be…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great fun finally meeting my frien @matthewsyed in person. Look for Rebel Ideas - his British bestseller in the US next fall
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
In London with Expedia Group #productacademy for a one day teach in where we talked about collective intelligence and engaged with multiple models and categories to analyze business decisions. Huge Fun!!!. @vrbo @ExpediaUK
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Swiss has approx 24% immigrants about 85% from within EU. They are out innovating the general Swiss population. Is this in part a story of institutional support?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Oscar Ybarra opened his talk on the benefits of interpersonal relationships with this thought provoking quote.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Nice piece on how analogies and models drive creativity - 8 minute read (to get access you have to choose a type: investor or intermediary then the article is free)
www.avivainvestors.com/en-gb/views/aiq-investment-thinkin… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Brian Arthur asks “if John Holland is the solution, what is the problem?” Arthur pays homage to one of the great complexity thinkers describing how economics must assume adaptive agents confronting ill defined problems. @UMICHCS @sfiscience
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
George Mason
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Peter Erdi deeply unpacks rankings showing that some are dubious, others can be manipulated, and others lead us to silly distortions so we can rise in google searches and academic rankings. I love this book so much, I wrote the forward! (Really) www.amazon.com/Ranking-Unwritten-Rules-Social-Game/dp/019…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A fantastic new book on AI by @MelMitchell1 who writes with incomparable clarity and wisdom. Great buy for that person who wants a core understanding of the ideas, science, applications, and implications without the HYPE!
Congrats Melanie!! www.amazon.com/Artificial-Intelligence-Guide-Thinking-Hum… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Foreign Policy describes the limits of Randomized Controlled Trials - the basis of this year’s Economics Nobel - as a development tool. foreignpolicy.com/2019/10/22/economics-development-rcts-e…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
I know this may sound “childlike” but a fail of this magnitude when any number of non gendered non ridiculous leadership scorecards exist at the touch of a link www.franksonnenbergonline.com/blog/leadership-scorecard/ is proof of why we need diversity training.
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
This "score sheet" was used in an Ernst & Young diversity training session LAST YEAR. The "feminine" column is pure silliness. The "masculine" column, if all terms are somehow akin to what it means to act as a leader, is exactly how our country and planet got to where we are.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
High dimensional multiple objective problems as a rule have no best solution. Any given one will involve trade offs. Such problems do have super horrible solutions. Supreme Court just ruled if we can’t have a best, we will just let super horrible stand.
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
An expected decision, but a reminder of what it means: with the US SC ruling out a judicial fix, only in states with direct democracy do the people have real access to a remedy for partisan gerrymandering.
Detroit Free Press
@freep
US Supreme Court overturns ruling in Michigan gerrymandering case: What it means rssfeeds.freep.com/~/608020890/0/freep/home~US-Supreme-Co…
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
An expected decision, but a reminder of what it means: with the US SC ruling out a judicial fix, only in states with direct democracy do the people have real access to a remedy for partisan gerrymandering.
Detroit Free Press
@freep
US Supreme Court overturns ruling in Michigan gerrymandering case: What it means rssfeeds.freep.com/~/608020890/0/freep/home~US-Supreme-Co…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Do we maximize reward or minimize surprise? A “great thinker as literary device” piece on entropy minimization. Deep nugget - is the theory “as if” predictive or “as is” descriptive. The latter would be a surprise, so former must be true!!! www.wired.com/story/karl-friston-free-energy-principle-ar…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Doyne Farmer makes the case for calibrated agent based models in the financial sector!
@sfiscience You can’t sweep all that human heterogeneity under a rug and expect to estimate risk!!! www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-10-03/chaos-scientis… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Don’t ban new technologies; but also don’t let startups litter your sidewalks with scooters without first experimenting - Ryan Muldoon expounds on the precautionary principle www.buffalo.edu/ubnow/spotlight.host.html/content/shared/…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Writing advice from Santa Fe’s incomparably no nonsense Cormac McCarthy. Seek clarity. Don’t both elucidate and elaborate. And, oh by the way, focus on what you want the reader to learn. www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02918-5
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
I'm teaching collective action problems tomorrow and think I'll ditch the slides and just show this clip.
Buffy Wicks
@BuffyWicks
Smug, mediocre, Republican Congressman takes on @GretaThunberg—
Greta proceeds to:
-remind him she's a badass
-destroy the very premise of his question
-roast him when he misses her pt
Imagine a future w/Greta asking the q's. To get there, we must first heed her call to action.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A moment to have faith in the future. 500+ student organizations @UMich . Each making the world better, advancing knowledge, building community, or just making fun! Go Blue!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Martin Weitzman wrote and thought deeply about how to create a fair, sustainable, innovative economy. His model of recombinant growth is brilliant. www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-09-03/weitzman-sh…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Potentially cool new platform showcasing two leading thinkers on a single issue with short back and forth. Hoping for more frisson in future! www.pairagraph.com
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#stop@8000
A careful replication of the famous 10,000 hours of practice study finds that the really good. practice more than the best. We should cease to be surprised when huge effect sizes based on N = 30 are overturned or shrink. royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.190327?cookie… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Superb graphical summary of Chetty’s research. No big surprises qualitatively - better to have rich parents, go to elite college, and live in a safe, wealthy neighborhood. Contribution lies in the magnitudes! Steep patent curve shows lost Einsteins! www.brookings.edu/blog/social-mobility-memos/2018/01/11/r…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Lucid explanation of Grossman-Stiglitz paradox: markets are only price efficient with a lot of active traders, but if prices are efficient, there’s little reason to trade. I discuss this in The Model Thinker but not nearly as clearly! insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/the-groucho-marx…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Study showing racial bias in selecting teams of fund managers- more scrutiny for diverse teams www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2019-08/dcl-nsf080819.php
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My thoughts on a fantastic and challenging new book on crime!
Rajiv Sethi
@rajivatbarnard
A deep, searching, and thankfully positive review of #shadowsofdoubt by the inimitable @Scott_E_Page crookedtimber.org/2019/08/14/the-incarcerating-power-of-s…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Many are surprised Ross would compromise long held values. Vanity Fare reports Ross’s financial interest in extending EB-5 visas (aka $500k residency cards) for multi-billion dollar Hudson Yards. apple.news/AdOnbxe_9Qq2E6t0qpAjUng
-
Scott Page reposted
Annie Duke
@AnnieDuke
The facts we look for, notice and share are implicitly an opinion.
And a multi-part signal attempting to change opinions about the situation, yourself, others, etc.
We are messy beings.
h/t @JosephESweeney -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
If you like ideas, consider this!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Informative, erudite, readable, piece on Information theory - entropy, K-L divergence, and all that by @SimonDeDeo. H2O molecules in ice have zero entropy, in water, their location is slippery, that is uncertain. tuvalu.santafe.edu/~simon/it.pdf
-
Scott Page reposted
Brian Uzzi
@UzziLeadership
A new HBR article by @joshua_a_becker and @ned_smith answers big questions about the adept management of crowd wisdom. Research by Becker with Damon Centola and others shows the secrets of how to keep smart individuals from being collectively dumb. hbr.org/2019/07/research-for-crowdsourcing-to-work-everyo…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A book full of ideas worthy of tweets - Among them how to use computers to reduce our emotional burdens. Also, What fun! Adam’s examoles spsn Banksy, The Polar Express,Man U, and dodge-ball - and I’m not finished reading!! @KelloggSchool www.amazon.com/Power-Human-Shared-Humanity-Create/dp/0393…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Amazing paper using LinkedIn data showing global labor flows. Industry matters more than geography. Strong ocular resonance by sector with @ricardo_hausman and @cesifoti economic complexity graphs. People move to connected industries. www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-11380-w
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Congrats to Libby Wood @sfiscience for becoming an editor of APSA - the flagship journal in political science!! politicalsciencenow.com/apsa-announces-the-new-editorial-…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At Council of Supplier Diversity Professionals
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
A big f*-ing (for federalism) deal: When the federal government turns unpredictable, the states lead domestic policy. Automakers reach a 50-state solution by recognizing California's authority to set emissions policy and agree to nullify Trump's rollback of Obama-era GHG goals.
Detroit Free Press
@freep
4 automakers reach emissions deal with California, bucking rollback rssfeeds.freep.com/~/604873448/0/freep/home~automakers-re…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The interdisciplinary tale of the forthcoming cosmic crisp apple. Economics: not a commodity; biology: crossbreeding 10k trees a year; search theory: selecting the best; and horticulture: the switch to dwarf trees (and oh yeah just a little marketing!)clsndy.co/cosmic-crisp
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Complexity Explained website - awesome introduction to complex systems!!! Lots of references to research from @sfiscience @UMICHCS complexityexplained.github.io
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Duncan Watts @IC2S2 speaks a hard truth. @profjennabednar takes a more optimistic view that the act of writing those papers thrown over the wall improves everyone’s thinking. To which I would add, that more often than we think our papers are mined for parts - PageRank, etc...
George Richardson
@g_r_richardson
Duncan Watts - "For 20 years I thought my job was as a basic scientist. Publish papers and throw them over the wall for someone else to apply. I now realise that there's no one on the other side of the wall. Just a huge pile of papers that we've all thrown over." #ic2s2
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Mirta Galesic @SFIscience describing how people who make estimates from their social circles make better predictions. Diversity (entropy of friends’ types) improves accuracy the most followed by education. Wise crowds can be built by dropping people who live in echo chambers!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@sfiscience @IC2S2 Great conference so far!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thanks!! It is humbling to be in such company
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
So proud of @Scott_E_Page on becoming the John Seely Brown Distinguished University Professor, the university's highest honor! @jseelybrown @UMICHCS @MichiganRoss record.umich.edu/articles/six-faculty-members-named-disti…
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
There's something fishy about the data that generated this map.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Speaking to Warburg-Pincus and to make sure everyone pays attention to my talk all phones will be in lockdown! You put the phone in a sealed pouch that you unseal with the mechanism used at clothing stores! I’m taking these back to @UMich for my undergrad classes!!! #yondr
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Just read about Abreu’s paper orchestra in John Seeley Brown and Ann Pendleton-Jillian’s book Design Unbound. Similar idea. By practicing early with fewer degrees of freedom (no real instrument or computer), we can learn good habits. Rada argues even better habits!
Rada Mihalcea
@radamihalcea
Like others who learned CS in a country/time where computers were too expensive to afford, I learned CS mostly on paper. It was a great way to focus on computational thinking & mental models. Great post by @guzdial on the value of learning ML without code.
computinged.wordpress.com/2019/07/08/learning-to-build-ma… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#citationequality A leading journal made me cull self citations.” The limit is four. I had eight: four books written by me, three papers with women as lead author, and a paper with two men and two women. I axed three books and kept the three papers with women as lead author.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“A double bind is far worse than a straightforward damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don’t dilemma. It requires you to obey two mutually exclusive commands: Anything you do to fulfill one violates the other.” - Deborah Tannen (Some password advice from Wilma’s in Ann Arbor)
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Just so we're all clear about what happened: this morning the Court declared redistricting to be judicially untouchable. If it locks in minority power, oh well. People in the 18 states with citizen-initiated const'l amendmnts can fix it. Everywhere else: No democracy for you.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Oatmeal latte? 35 North Santa Fe (Brian Arthur recombination?) @sfiscience. Its expected value was lower than my usual Americano, but trying it had information value #banditmodel
Extra Credit: if I came to SF as rarely as @mjmauboussin, I would have been irrational! -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
More Stephanie Forrest @sfiscience @ASU, “we never intended or anticipated this functionality being used this way - and that is on us “ - Sheryl Sandburg. (To which I might add, “if you build it, he will come” - Kevin Costner)
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Stephanie Forrest of @ASU discussing cyber security at @sfiscience. Her thoughtful characterization includes both pure nefarious actors (Adversarial Machine Learning, Hardware Attacks) and economically driven nefarious actors (bank and data theft,ransomware).
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Reflections by Brian Arthur on his famous HBR piece on his seminal ideas about increasing returns (copyedited by Cormac) @sfiscience When the piece first came out, I complemented Brian on his writing - the piece is spectacular- he replied “here’s the story...”
Bill Gurley
@bgurley
Read this www.fastcompany.com/3064681/most-important-economic-theor…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Ann Pendleton-Julian @sfiscience cities confront a constant tension between top down planners and a bottom up push from people living their “messy lives” that innovate within/despite the plan. Urban designs as platforms upon which people create meaningful lives!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Models of power complicate rethinking electoral college! Great example of many model thinking. Model 1: votes per person Model 2 voting power based on pivotal probability.
Justin Fox
@foxjust
I wrote a column about the widely held belief that the Electoral College is tilted in favor of smaller states and rural areas www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2019-06-12/electoral-c…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The team thinking about #thechoice is @profjennabednar @vanishingcorp (Jerry Davis) and @jjprescott2009
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At #thechoice at @UMich we have been discussing the relative merits of markets, hierarchies, democracies, algorithms, and self organization. Here’s a great NYU video on the work of Melissa Schilling youtu.be/J0kdOlqgF6E via @YouTube
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#google hey @jkurkoski I’m caught on camera giving a shout out to Google research
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A wonderfully concise three minute summary of The Diversity Bonus - leaves me wondering why I needed those extra 237 pages!!!
Emerald HRM
@EmeraldHRM
Development and Learning in Organizations has a new issue out, it includes a book summary of The Diversity Bonus by @Scott_E_Page (free access) here www.emerald.com/dlo/article/33/3/31/21286/Book-summary-th… #teams #diversity #orgs
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thoughtful, nontechnical, compassionate piece on neurodiversity, autism, impairment, and disability.
Dr. Philippe Chouinard
@DrPChouinard
Amazing piece on #neurodiversity by Aiyana Bailin:
‘When we say “#autism is just another way of being human,” we mean that profound impairments don’t change a person’s right to dignity, to privacy and to as much self-determination as possible’ blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/clearing-up-som… via @sciam -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Paradoxes of machine learning Simpson + 4 more @jrdothoughts link.medium.com/2NnCwog6lX
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Astute clarifying erudite explanation of fractals by my colleague Mitchell @UMICHCS theconversation.com/mathematics-of-scale-big-small-and-ev…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Facebook goes crypto!
What will happen? www.coindesk.com/everything-we-know-about-facebooks-crypt… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Listening to the brilliant Carol Dweck in person for the first time. Blown away by the clarity and power of her thinking. Here’s her @farnamstreet interview fs.blog/2015/03/carol-dweck-mindset/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great fun chatting with Marist’s polling gurus about the value of models!
Marist Poll
@maristpoll
What does it mean to be a “model thinker?” We speak with @Scott_E_Page, @UMich professor & author of the The Model Thinker, on this week’s episode of our podcast, Poll Hub. maristpoll.marist.edu/poll-hub-prejudice-in-the-united-st…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
MOOCs advantage the advantaged!
"Expansion of educational
opportunities to underserved populations
will require political movements that
change the focus, funding, and purpose of
higher education; they will not be achieved
through new technologies alone."
science.sciencemag.org/content/363/6423/130 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A reminder of the depth of our attachment to our alma maters. Juwan Howard was an All American, an NBA All Star, won two NBA titles, signed the NBA's first $100 million contract, and was the first NBA early entrant to graduate on with his class. A poignant 1:57. #goblue
Brad Galli
@BradGalli
Juwan Howard is really, really emotional at this Michigan press conference.
He took a long time to gather himself.
“Tears of joy,” he said.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Visiting @zingermans training center. Great signal of a strong continuous learning environment- a library of books and Bacon!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Congrats to @profjennabednar for winning the Martha Derthwick Award from the American Political Science Association for her book The Robust Federation. She was way ahead of the profession in her engagement of concept of robustness. Well deserved! images.app.goo.gl/FbFra59aoF9NAii4A
-
Scott Page reposted
Sebastian Gustke
@SebastianGustke
Great Episode about navigating life with Mental Models @Scott_E_Page podcasts.apple.com/de/podcast/venture-stories/id131676926…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The cold hard economic facts obliging a distinction between middle income and middle class www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/brainard20190510…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Two times the sea level rise may equal N times the social and economic costs (N is large!)
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
A new @PNASNews study shows that rising sea levels may be twice what the IPCC estimated, and we will need to plan for the displacement of up to 187 million people. Climate migration may be the social force of the 21C. www.pnas.org/content/early/2019/05/14/1817205116
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At World Bank, Lily Tsai @mit describes how much of the evidence for the efficacy of citizen engagement comes from Uganda and Indonesia- two counties with high state capacity raising a deep question: is state capacity necessary to devolve power back to the people?@asmeen
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
“It is a world of immense opportunities IF you are willing to unleash your imagination while invoking your skills”- JSB
Wise words on teams, flow, and riding the rapids of the modern problem@solving economy www.rit.edu/news/keynote-speaker-john-seely-browns-2019-c… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Who would have guessed? The Ringer - a sportszine goes deep in driverless car industry. Nice piece! www.theringer.com/tech/2019/5/16/18625127/driverless-cars… via @ringer
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Evidence that A/B testing (the current gold standard) produces different results than implementing A or B - those darn people they are rather tough to pin down www.pnas.org/content/early/2019/05/08/1820701116
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great article on latest piece by @mjmauboussin For an individual investor to beat institutional money managers you need a Behavioral, Analytic, Informational or Technical edge. Take the BAIT! usermatch.targeting.unrulymedia.com/usermatch/iponweb/ba3…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At an ecology conference and learned a new catch phrase “sequence the frass” which means “perform dna analysis of insect excrement” or alternatively “take a deep look at that shit!”
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Deep, clear thinking by Andrea Jones-Rooy @jonesrooy on the relevance of the concept of emergence for diversity and inclusion qz.com/1611261/emergence-might-be-the-key-to-increasing-d…
-
Scott Page reposted
Nicholas A. Christakis
@NAChristakis
This is very Japanese, very inventive, and very evocative of swarm robots.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Evolution of Trust Nicky Case’s amazing interactive simulation of the evolution of trust - covers much of what I cover in The Model Thinket ncase.me/trust/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great piece on distinction between information and knowledge and the power and limits of AI in age of complexity by @dweinberger medium.com/p/machine-learning-might-render-the-human-ques…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Power of Financial Advisory Teams - Barron's — Evidence that teams outperform individuals as financial advisors measured by fund growth. www.barrons.com/articles/the-power-of-financial-advisory-…
-
Scott Page reposted
University of Pittsburgh
@PittTweet
A study led by Pitt's Osea Giuntella (@Osea82) gives new insight into how our bodies are affected by living on the wrong side of a time zone. Full article from @washingtonpost here: www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/04/19/how-living-wro… #h2p
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@"On Causality" www.linkedin.com/pulse/causality-r-preston-mcafee on @LinkedIn Preston McAfee waxes eloquent on causality, data, and MODELS!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Thanks to Farnham Street- Becoming a Model Thinker: My Interview with Professor and Mental Model Expert Scott Page [The Knowledge Project Ep.… fs.blog/scott-page/ via @farnamstreet
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Top Leaders Explain The Benefits Of (And How To) Diversify Your Network www.forbes.com/sites/darrahbrustein/2019/02/24/top-leader…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great paper on how often an optimal strategy beats randomness in a simple game of picking the color of a card. Answer 85% Fermat's Library (title is inappropriate for today) fermatslibrary.com/s/how-often-should-you-beat-your-kids
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Further proof of Schelling’s deeply inquisitive nature, and an exam that demands more thinking than regurgitation. Reading list and final exam for course "Conflict, Coalition and Strategy". Schelling, 1970 www.irwincollier.com/harvard-reading-list-and-final-exam-…
-
Scott Page reposted
Good Authority
@goodauth
The real college admissions scandal isn’t bribes and cheating. @Scott_E_Page explains.
@adeelnyt @jaclyncosgrove
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/03/21/real-college-a… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Agreed!!
Data - Information - Knowledge - Wisdom
Statistics transform data into information. Getting to Wisdom takes two more steps. #themodelthinker
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
I hope and believe that in this era of #bigdata, theory becomes ever more crucial. P values can't build wisdom. Great advice in this special issue from The American Statistician. www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00031305.2019.1583913
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The American Statistician "do not say statistically significant, do not believe a result just because p < 0.05 reject a result because p > 0.05, or conclude anything of scientific or practical importance based on significance" www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00031305.2019.1583913
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Perils of Quantification | Boston Review-Spectacular elucidation of Campbell’s Law - if you quantify a performance criterion people will distort behavior - by @ethanbdm I should have had him guest/ghost write that chapter of #themodelthinker bostonreview.net/forum/economics-after-neoliberalism/etha…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Inclusive Economics Is Complexity Economics | Boston Review - Inclusivity obliges the possibility of non equilibrium phenomena (or so we say) bostonreview.net/forum/economics-after-neoliberalism/comp…
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Unfair admissions because: water polo, as @henryfarrell so succinctly pulls together the highlights of this provocative paper by Uma Jayakumar & @Scott_E_Page. Importantly, tho, the answer is not less, but more. Let everyone play.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#yale, #usc, #stanford allowed explicit purchase of admission. The wealthy also implicitly purchase admission through greater opportunities to excel. High SES students may be 20 times more likely to exhibit the exceptional talent #umich #cscs #sfi
documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%…
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Paper by Uma Jayakumar and I (with help from Orrie Page) showing the implicit benefit is here
documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
America is shutting its doors to some of the best young minds (opinion) - CNN “Ultimately we will lose not just our status as a global leader but the very identity that earned it.” Cornell President Martha Pollack #innovation www.cnn.com/2019/03/04/opinions/trump-immigration-interna…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great article by John Stoll as @WSJ in which I describe the daily flows of #bigdata as a "rolling hairball" @CSCS and @SFI
documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Testimony by Rutgers Law Dean David Lopez on Diversity in Tech and Algorithmic Bias - lots of ideas backed by data
documentcloud.adobe.com/link/track?uri=urn%3Aaaid%3Ascds%… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
CrowdSmart Transforms Startup Investing with New Predictive AI Platform - proud to be part of Crowdsmart’s incredible team!!! globenewswire.com/news-release/2019/03/05/1748105/0/en/Cr…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Fabulous new book on Networks for a general audience by Matthew Jackson of Stanford and SFI The Human Network: How Your Social Position Determines Your Power, Beliefs, and Behaviors www.amazon.com/Human-Network-Position-Determines-Behavior…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Had an amazing chat this morning with Michael Delgado at Experian — The Model Thinker: Making Data Work for You w/ Dr. Scott E. Page #datatalk - Experian Global News Blog www.experian.com/blogs/news/datatalk/model-thinker/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The surprising reason zebras have stripes and why wearing striped shirts keeps you free of mosquito bites #co-evolution apple.news/ADd67NNRwSaaY93IoGRKezg
-
Scott Page reposted
Ali Minai
@barbarikon
My latest 3QD piece on AI: www.3quarksdaily.com/3quarksdaily/2019/02/what-ai-fails-t… @yaneerbaryam @MelMitchell1 @stevenstrogatz
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great Argument for why we Need models and not just data by Hansen review.chicagobooth.edu/economics/2019/article/purely-evi…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Challenge accepted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
@C4COMPUTATION nominated me to post covers of #7booksilove. For Valentine's Day I'm breaking the no review, no explanation rule, h/t @kjhealy. #3/7 = #modelthinker Nominating @Scott_E_Page
Roses are convex
Violets homogenous
Our love seems identified
But is likely endogenous -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
After Accusations Of Bias--AI Could Bring Diversity To Tech via @forbes www.forbes.com/sites/tinawoods/2019/02/11/after-accusatio…
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Should we make choices, whether big or small, using markets, hierarchies, democracies, algorithms, or through self-organization? Looking forward to our conference #thechoice tomorrow @MichiganRoss, co-org w @vanishingcorp @Scott_E_Page @jjprescott2009 #complexity
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Richard Bookstaber’s #theendoftheory makes a strong case for agent based models to study and dampen financial crises. Convincing portrayal of financial system as an aggregation of reflexive heuristics #soros. Nice complement to writings of #doynefarmer who also advocates ABM
-
Scott Page reposted
Jenna Bednar
@profjennabednar
Martha Nussbaum rocks. dailynous.com/2019/01/23/nussbaum-uses-berggruen-winnings…
-
Scott Page reposted
Duncan Watts
@duncanjwatts
Delighted to be joining @Penn, including @Wharton, @PennEngineers, and @AnnenbergPenn, and looking forward to exciting new ventures!
Penn
@Penn
Duncan Watts (@duncanjwatts), a pioneer in the use of data to study networks, will become the 23rd Penn Integrates Knowledge Professor on July 1. In announcing his appointment, President Amy Gutmann said he “stands at the epicenter of these fields.” penntoday.upenn.edu/news/duncan-watts-appointed-penn-inte…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Reading Prediction Machines by @joshgans. More data had diminishing returns but increases in predictive accuracy have increasing returns in value: doubling data increasing accuracy of fraud prediction from 99% to 99.9% means you are ten times less likely to err (0.1% to 1%)
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Here's How to Fix the Senate - The Atlantic - My Friend Eric Orts charts a path to more equal representation (if we don’t get slogged down in maple syrup!) www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/01/heres-how-fix-s…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Philosopher Redefining Equality | The New Yorker - A great piece on my Michigan Colleague E. Anderson www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/01/07/the-philosopher-red…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A Single Cell Hints at a Solution to the Biggest Problem in Computer Science-great article on how a well designed mechanism can enable a simple learning algorithm to solve a hard problem-not unlike a market! www.popularmechanics.com/science/math/a25686417/amoeba-math/
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Some good books new and old on identity and meritocracy whatarewritersreading.blogspot.com/2018/12/scott-e-page.html
-
Scott Page reposted
Knowledge at Wharton
@whartonknows
Wed. @whartonknows on @BizRadio132 (10:30A ET):
@Scott_E_Page joins the show to discuss his new book "The Model Thinker", which looks at how you can better understand #bigdata and make it work for you. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@"To solve complicated business problems, many perspectives beats just one" www.linkedin.com/pulse/solve-complicated-business-problem… on @LinkedIn
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Nice juxtaposition: NYT and Linked In A.I. as Talent Scout: Unorthodox Hires, and Maybe Lower Pay www.nytimes.com/2018/12/06/business/economy/artificial-in…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Amazon has discounted my book 56% - you can now buy it for $14
@The Model Thinker: What You Need to Know to Make Data Work for You: Scott E. Page: 9780465094622: amazon.com: Books www.amazon.com/Model-Thinker-What-Need-Know/dp/0465094627 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
@"To solve complicated business problems, many perspectives beats just one" www.linkedin.com/pulse/solve-complicated-business-problem… on @LinkedIn
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
In an era of big data and complex problems, model thinking becomes even more valuable. And we should use many models not just one.
Book just released! www.amazon.com/Model-Thinker-What-Need-Know/dp/0465094627 -
Scott Page reposted
Michael Mauboussin
@mjmauboussin
Performance Persistence Through the Lens of Chance Models
To what extent will performance differences persist? . . . We empirically examine this statistical account of performance persistence in six datasets... sci-hub.tw/10.5465/AMBPP.2018.19 -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Why “Many-Model Thinkers” Make Better Decisions hbr.org/2018/11/why-many-model-thinkers-make-better-decis…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#allthenewsthatsfittoprint Today’s New York Times front page informs us about rising art prices for “David Hockney” “Jeff Koons” “Three African Americans” and a “Female Painter” Looking forward to weekend Times review of concert by JayZ and “female singer”
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
A year ago Roger Reynolds had a vision on how to bridge chasms and communicate knowledge through deep conversations across disciplines. He's breaking people out of their silos and going deep.
www.sandiegouniontribune.com/lifestyle/people/sd-me-chasm…
www.bridgingchasms.org/about.html -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Join Kim Polese to hear how Venture Capital can use state of the art AI to promote Women VCs zoom.us/webinar/register/2215364230449/WN_9xoKW7PtS4amoBD…
-
Scott Page reposted
Complexity Digest
@cxdig
Centrality-Friendship Paradoxes: When Our Friends Are More Important Than Us via @stevenstrogatz sco.lt/5Eormz
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At Union College to celebrate the inauguration of my friend David Harris as President. President Harris and I will discuss education and purpose tonight at historic Nott Hall.
Union College has landed a formidable, brilliant leader in David. www.union.edu/inauguration -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Science career ads are disproportionately seen by men www.salon.com/2018/08/20/science-career-ads-are-dispropor…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Hot streaks in academia, art, and film - great new work by Dashun Wang (based on the paper expect more from him soon!) insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/career-hot-streaks
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Creating a workplace where cognitive diversity flourishes starts with self awareness!
www.shrm.org/hr-today/news/hr-magazine/0618/pages/how-to-… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Given that 15% of tenured US economists are women. The odds of drawing 24 men and 0 women randomly would be 2%.
Megan Stevenson
@MeganTStevenson
I just noticed that there are no female editors or co-editors at any of the main law & economics journals: JLE, JLEO, JLS, ALER, IRLE, EJLE. 24 total editors listed online and no women. Wuzzup with that? Embarrassing.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My book The Model Thinker now has an official release date: November 2018.
www.basicbooks.com/titles/scott-e-page/model-thinker/9780…
Thanks to the many students who participated in the Model Thinking MOOC for their input. -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Could a neuroscientist explain a microprocessor?
Uh - no. Current techniques reveal structures in data but do not reveal the hierarchical structure.
journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?id=10.1371/journal… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At Stockholm Resilience Centre, where they apply complexity thinking to sustainability policy. Here’s a nice introduction to their take on resilience thinking www.stockholmresilience.org/research/research-news/2015-0…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
At Northwestern University Dumas domain dinner - an interdisciplinary event. The focus is on neuroscience. Thomas Bozza describing the most powerful sensory system in the world. #cats❤️dogs
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Last summer in Beijing, my son Cooper and I were struck by the abundance of rental bikes. Trucks would show up and unload hundreds on the sidewalk. #externality
-
Scott Page reposted
Patrick OShaughnessy
@patrick_oshag
My conversation with @samhinkie on
-the long view
-applied innovation
-data science, machine learning
-his time at the Rockets, remaking the 76ers
-the importance of hiring and recruiting
-the limits of being contrarian
This one was very fun
investorfieldguide.com/hinkie/ -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Mike Schipper, the judge, and I have been lifelong friends and were high school basketball teammates. He has consistently stepped up and done the right thing. Super proud of him and his brother Jim for taking the initiative here. www.woodtv.com/news/michigan/judge-family-talk-to-teens-a…
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#flinttown at The Ferris Wheel, an incubator. Flint is trying to generate 100k ideas to think, make, and market. This is a post water crisis hive of optimism!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
My take (informed by many others) on Collective Intelligence.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=46LgXUDbS0o&t=7s&index=1&list=PLk… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
John Tresch of Warburg Institute describing how people taking pictures of food create our world - and oh by the way require ten days of energy production from a nuclear power plant. #frankeinstitute #uchicago
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great new report from the WK Kellogg Foundation on the Business Case for Racial Equity. Provides non partisan macro estimates on economic gains from improving equity.
www.businesscaseforracialequity.org -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
The Key to Everything www.nybooks.com/articles/2018/05/10/the-key-to-everything/ via @nybooks
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#behavioraleconomics: How much of the penninsula’s innovative secret sauce lies in brilliance and how much resides in a culture of productive behavior? bars empty at 10pm, bike paths crowded at 6am, coffee shops humming by 7:30am - just wondering....
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Great article by Gary Sandefur and Phil Deloria on indigenous leadership. Many of the core tenets from collective intelligence are embedded in the indigenous practices. #unexpected transdisciplinary www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1162/DAED_a_00496
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Spring has yet to arrive in Ann Arbor - might we have already headed into fall?
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
This Saturday, I'm talking at UM's Saturday Morning Physics on Collective Intelligence. It's a public talk. events.dsa.umich.edu/event/48134. Anyone who has written or read anything super cool in this area in the past few months, please send my way!!!
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Spoke today at Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Conference at #oaklanduniversity. Two optimistic poems by #aliceajoydavis opened the day on a high note. Great to reconnect with new Oakland President and former Michigan Health System Head, Ora Pescovitz.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
#desmoines, where Principal employees 8000+, was just ranked 4th best place to live in America. Cool brick downtown area, lots of festivals, and (paradoxically) no traffic. Loft apartments everywhere.
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Yesterday, I had the honor of speaking at #waynestate and hanging with Taylor Cox. Today, Des Moines - Principal - with the amazing #anitawoolley, talking collective intelligence
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Spent Friday at #mdanderson Cancer Center Houston talking diversity at grand rounds. Big thanks to Elizabeth Travis.
Scott Cantor shared this paper on collective accuracy of plastic surgeons. Any one surgeon is not a good predictor but a group is!
journals.lww.com/prsgo/pages/articleviewer.aspx?year=2013… -
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Looking forward to a really interesting ten weeks of Model Thinking
-
Scott Page
@Scott_E_Page
Model Thinking is now up and running on Coursera
www.coursera.org/course/modelthinking


























































































































