Western democracy keeps delivering the best politicians money can buy... and every long term plan dies with the next election. Economist Steve Keen says mixing private money with government is a flaw built into the system: “You’ve got the best politicians money can buy, and that is absolutely corrupting the arms of government.” Until campaign cash stops setting the agenda, can any big national project survive past one election cycle? @ProfSteveKeen
Steve Keen
Steve Keen (born 28 March 1953) is an Australian economist and author. He considers himself a post-Keynesian and a critic of neoclassical economics. More on Wikipedia
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Intrepid @RuDauntless
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
@bhijit
@Abhijit_A_
Video description -
"Bank Originated Money and Debt" (BOMD). It isn't left-wing or right-wing economics. It's just the accounting, and if the accounting doesn't work, the argument.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Learn more - youtu.be/Kkxc880n4eQ
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The fact that George Selin is unable to grasp is that reserve transfers net out at the macro level. The only exception is for bank bankruptcies, and they’re covered by Central Bank fiduciary duties.
That’s why it’s called “Macro”, @GeorgeSelgin -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
New Keynesian economists managed to take Keynes, strip out most of the interesting shit, rebuild everything around equilibrium, and then act surprised when Steve Keen started calling them fucking neoclassicals.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
王士銘
@anytutorai
今回のNVIDIA(エヌビディア)の件で、いわゆる「アメリカンドリーム」なんてものは、結局クソみたいな幻想にすぎないということがよく分かった。
幼い頃からアメリカで育ち、30歳でシリコンバレーに自分の会社を立ち上げ、三度も倒産寸前の危機を乗り越えてきた。
誰もがこぞってスマートフォン向け半導体の開発に走っていた時代に、彼はあえて独自の道を選んだ。株主やウォール街からの疑念や批判にも耐えながら、CUDAやNVLinkのエコシステムを築き上げた。
そして、ついに会社を時価総額世界一にまで成長させたというのに、今度は共和党内部の権力闘争に巻き込まれ、政治的な生け贄にされている。
これでは中国と一体何が違うというのか?
株式を一株も保有していないベッセント財務長官が、偉そうにあれこれ口を出している。
以前は中国政府が民間企業に介入することを散々批判していたくせに、いざ自分たちがやっていることは、それ以上に胸くそが悪い。 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
"Nothing but" is hyperbole. Most people don't want currency, banks limit daily cash withdrawals and consumers can't even hold reserves.
Deposits are what nearly every payment in the economy settles in. The promise that matters in practice isn't currency. It's that your deposit moves at par into anyone else's deposit, anywhere. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Devon Eriksen
@Devon_Eriksen_
A lot of people have real trouble thinking about the aggregate behavior of groups. They can only think about individuals.
So they think about Elon Musk as an individual. Maybe they think that he must be retarded, because they need that for emotional reasons. Or maybe they think he is a talented rocket designer.
But even if they realize he understands rockets, they can only think about him as an individual doing tasks. Not about his impact on what the whole company does.
If Elon Musk is just a talented rocket designer, then he can spend all day, every day, improving rocket designs.
But he is just one of 7000 engineers. So even if did a perfect job, he would only improve progress by about .014%
So, when a midwit looks at SpaceX, he sees 7000 engineers, and says to himself "Elon Musk cannot possibly be designing the whole damn rocket himself. These people are giving him too much credit."
This would be absolutely true if Musk were just a some random SpaceX engineer. But he isn't. He's the absolute dictator of the whole damn company.
He decides, with absolute and unquestionable authority, which behaviors are punished and which are rewarded.
Why is this important?
When I worked at Boeing, on various classified projects, I naively came in with the assumption that I was a software engineer, employed to design and build functional software as quickly and cheaply as possible.
Because of this, I focused on functionality and efficiency, for example suggesting changes that would obviate the need for entire projects and software components.
And I very rapidly became persona non grata.
At first, this caused me to adopt an air of aggrieved innocence. I was just trying to do my job well, and I was being punished for it.
Then I gradually came to realize that I hadn't properly understood what my job was, or what the actual mission of Boeing Defense, Space, and Security was.
Boeing DSS was not an aerospace company. Boeing DSS was a fraud company.
Its goal was twofold. First, to maximize transfer of public tax dollars to stockholder pockets. Second, to maintain the appearance of being an aerospace company, to prevent the fraud from being exposed.
Which meant that my real job was twofold. First, to generate billable hours. Second, to look busy.
This is why Space Launch System sucks. Why it is always late when it doesn't fail outright. Why it is at 300% of its target budget. Why it leaves American astronauts stranded and needing a lift from SpaceX.
That's because, for Boeing, building rockets is a side quest. Something they have to do to look busy. Yes, a rocket does occasionally fly, but that's just happening so programs don't get shut down.
For Boeing, coming in early and under budget would actually be failure. The system is functioning exactly as designed.
The cost, not the rocket, is the goal.
Musk and SpaceX don't work like that.
Unlike Boeing executives, Musk is not a useless grifter asshole. He is an entirely different kind of asshole... a rocket obsessed sperg.
So, at SpaceX, engineers do not get rewarded for generating billable hours. They get rewarded for making rockets fly. And for all the subtasks of this, like figuring out how to make rockets lighter, figuring out how to make engines reignite better, figuring out how to make rocket exhaust not destroy launch pads, etc.
And this attracts engineers who care about rockets. You've seen them on broadcasts, crying on open microphones because they dedicated their lives to something and it just flew.
As a rocket engineer, who designs rockets, Musk is probably replaceable. As a rocket company engineer, who designs rocket companies, he is not.
For over 50 years, the US space industry stagnated precisely for the lack of a Musk-like figure, who could not only create an effective aerospace company, but who could thereby demonstrate what an effective aerospace company looks like.
Which makes it much more difficult for fraudsters to get away with fraud.
I'm envious. I wish I could have worked for an aerospace company instead of a fraud company.
But what's more important is that some of us now no longer have to play "who gets the most cheese?".
They get to play "What can we build today?".
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.
Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?
Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?
I am genuinely curious about these questions. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Breakdown of the Monthly Treasury Statement. Deficits continue to balloon. Interest, defense spending, and refunds are driving the expansion.
youtu.be/Gjx9QHJVR4s -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I couldn’t have put this any better myself.
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
I like Lyn's work but it's wrong to say bank deposit creation is "IOU" creation and not money creation. That treats state money as the only real money. It's an excessively government-centric view of how money gets created, a mistake MMT ironically makes too. Reserves sit above deposits in the settlement hierarchy, but that doesn't make deposits any less money.
It's fine to say deposits are an IOU, but deposits are absolutely money. They're the money households and businesses actually hold and spend, and they're accepted virtually everywhere. Banks make loans, which create deposits, and find the reserves after the fact. Reserve balances don't constrain lending for well-capitalized banks.
And it's not the bank's IOUs that "fail at scale." A loan creates two IOUs: the borrower's loan, which is the bank's asset, and the deposit, which is the bank's liability. It's the assets that fail, not the deposits. Asset losses are a capital problem and the Fed can't print capital. Deposit runs are a liquidity problem, and the Fed lends reserves against collateral. SVB had discount window access and still failed because unrealized securities losses had already wiped out most of its capital on a market value basis. Capital, not reserves, is the constraint for banks. Banks don't lever reserves. They lever their capital.
This matters for understanding the plumbing of the money system because deposits get created two main ways: when banks lend or buy securities, and when the Fed buys assets from nonbanks. Both are money creation, with different economic impacts. Treating bank lending as IOU stacking on top of state money diminishes how banks are major money creators in their own right and why the Fed interacts with them the way it does.
Lyn Alden
@LynAldenContact
Banks don't lend reserves. They lever reserves and make IOUs on top of them, rather than "creating money."
But then whenever those IOUs start to fail at scale, the central bank creates more reserves for them.
Over the past 50 years, if the US central bank held reserves flat and banks kept making money, there'd be a 160-to-1 ratio between deposits and reserves, which would be untenable. However, whenever it comes even slightly untenable, the central bank creates more reserves and swaps them for assets from banks, boosting the ratio and giving banks more lending/leveraging ability to keep it growing.
The US bank deposit-to-reserve ratio is under 4-to-1 because the central bank accommodates bank lending by creating new reserves.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks don’t lend reserves. They create money.
Presentation attached in comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
I like Lyn's work but it's wrong to say bank deposit creation is "IOU" creation and not money creation. That treats state money as the only real money. It's an excessively government-centric view of how money gets created, a mistake MMT ironically makes too. Reserves sit above deposits in the settlement hierarchy, but that doesn't make deposits any less money.
It's fine to say deposits are an IOU, but deposits are absolutely money. They're the money households and businesses actually hold and spend, and they're accepted virtually everywhere. Banks make loans, which create deposits, and find the reserves after the fact. Reserve balances don't constrain lending for well-capitalized banks.
And it's not the bank's IOUs that "fail at scale." A loan creates two IOUs: the borrower's loan, which is the bank's asset, and the deposit, which is the bank's liability. It's the assets that fail, not the deposits. Asset losses are a capital problem and the Fed can't print capital. Deposit runs are a liquidity problem, and the Fed lends reserves against collateral. SVB had discount window access and still failed because unrealized securities losses had already wiped out most of its capital on a market value basis. Capital, not reserves, is the constraint for banks. Banks don't lever reserves. They lever their capital.
This matters for understanding the plumbing of the money system because deposits get created two main ways: when banks lend or buy securities, and when the Fed buys assets from nonbanks. Both are money creation, with different economic impacts. Treating bank lending as IOU stacking on top of state money diminishes how banks are major money creators in their own right and why the Fed interacts with them the way it does.
Lyn Alden
@LynAldenContact
Banks don't lend reserves. They lever reserves and make IOUs on top of them, rather than "creating money."
But then whenever those IOUs start to fail at scale, the central bank creates more reserves for them.
Over the past 50 years, if the US central bank held reserves flat and banks kept making money, there'd be a 160-to-1 ratio between deposits and reserves, which would be untenable. However, whenever it comes even slightly untenable, the central bank creates more reserves and swaps them for assets from banks, boosting the ratio and giving banks more lending/leveraging ability to keep it growing.
The US bank deposit-to-reserve ratio is under 4-to-1 because the central bank accommodates bank lending by creating new reserves.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks don’t lend reserves. They create money.
Presentation attached in comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸 Western democracy keeps delivering the best politicians money can buy... and every long term plan dies with the next election.
Economist Steve Keen says mixing private money with government is a flaw built into the system:
“You’ve got the best politicians money can buy, and that is absolutely corrupting the arms of government.”
Until campaign cash stops setting the agenda, can any big national project survive past one election cycle?
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸 🇨🇳 China wired its grid at 800 kilovolts decades ago... and that one decision is now squeezing American AI.
Economist Steve Keen says higher voltage lets China pipe cheap power thousands of kilometers to remote data centers, while US ones sit near cities paying more, leaving Americans facing Lamborghini prices for AI:
“I can see the Chinese [version] being, you know, 90% of the functionality, 10% of the cost.”
Chinese data centers already pay about a third of what US ones pay for electricity, so the AI race may come down to the power bill.
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸 🇨🇳 Most American AI companies could fold in next year’s shakeout... and China may be the only one left making money.
Economist Steve Keen calls AI a bubble up to twice the size of the 19th century railway mania, and says America’s giant data centers and energy bills may price it out:
“I can imagine that most of the American AI companies will fold, and the Chinese will be the only ones that are profitable on the other side.”
He believes Jensen Huang had worked that out too, and that’s why he thinks Huang was targeted.
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸🇨🇳 Nvidia’s board has reportedly ruled out bringing Jensen Huang back as tech stocks slide... and the bigger crash may still be ahead
Losing a founder hurts for a week, and what comes next could hurt for YEARS.
Economist Steve Keen sizes the AI boom at 1.5 to 2 times the railway mania of the 1800s, with up to 3% of US GDP poured into data centers, and he expects the shakeout next year.
His real warning is about who is left afterward, because China’s newer power grid moves electricity farther for less, so its AI can be sold cheap.
Steve on how that matchup ends:
“I can imagine that most of the American AI companies will fold, and the Chinese will be the only ones that are profitable on the other side.”
So would you pay Lamborghini prices for a chatbot when a cheaper one does nearly the same job?
Most people won’t, and that is a far bigger problem for Silicon Valley than who runs Nvidia.
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I got this wrong for more than 10 years.
Textbooks teach the money multiplier. They say each extra dollar of reserves creates many dollars of deposits.
Fractional reserve banking, according to them, creates money because banks lend out those reserves.
They see a clear link between reserves and lending.
Policymakers still do not understand why that does not work.
There is only one problem.
How does the borrower actually get the money?
The books balance if the loan is a wheelbarrow full of notes. That is not how it works.
What actually happens is that when you pay down debt you also reduce the money supply.
I made that mistake myself over a decade ago. I got it wrong until I built Ravel©.
#economics #banking #moneycreation #finance #macroeconomics #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kkxc880n4eQ
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Beta testing continues @GDPDynamics for the soon to be released upgrading policy simulator.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
BETA testing for the upgrading policy model continues for all paid members at GDP Dynamics.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/policy-simulator-175524236 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks don’t lend reserves. They create money.
Presentation attached in comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Farzad 🇺🇸 🇮🇷
@farzyness
Why Starship Belly Flops
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evelyn Janeidy
@JaneidyEve
• Cosmic Chronicles •
Watching SpaceX catch Starship for the first time was Xciting!!
videos:
★ Liftoff Flight 15
★ Booster Landing RUD
★ Ship 42 CatchThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Napoleon Bonaparte
@Napoleon__Bon
Elon Musk in 2014 on why Boeing and Lockheed's rocket monopoly cost taxpayers billions:
With respect to the EELV program, I have five points to make. The first is that the Air Force and other agencies are simply paying too high a price for launch. The impacts of relying on monopoly providers since 2006 were predictable, and they have borne out. Space launch innovation has stagnated, competition has been stifled, and prices have risen to levels that General Shelton has called unsustainable
When the merger between Boeing and Lockheed's business occurred, the merger promised, in the press release, $150 million of savings. Instead, there were billions of dollars of cost overruns, and a Nunn-McCurdy breach for the program exceeding 50 percent of its cost projections
According to congressional records, in FY13, the Air Force paid an average of $380 million for each national security launch, while subsidizing ULA's fixed costs to the tune of more than a billion dollars a year, even if they never launch a rocket. By contrast, SpaceX's price is well under $100 million, meaning a savings of almost $300 million per launch, which in many cases would pay for the launch and the satellite combined.
So if you took something like a GPS satellite, which is about $140 million, you could actually have a free satellite with the launch. So our launch plus the satellite would cost less than just their launch, which is an enormous difference. And we seek no subsidies to maintain our business
To put this into perspective, had SpaceX been awarded the missions ULA received under its recent non-competed 36-core block buy, we would have saved the taxpayers $11.6 billion
Video: C-SPANThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Starship V4 will be ~70m long, which is roughly a 40% length increase and allows >60% more propellant load.
Engine count will be raised to 9, with 3 more Raptor-Vacuum engines added, and these will be higher thrust V4 engines.
ApoStructura
@ApoStructura
The scale of Starship:
ApoStructura
@ApoStructura
Easily the coolest thing I’ve ever seen
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ali Alagheband @alialagheband
👀👀👀
Everything. Changes.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Doge Tipping
@Dogetothemoon
Elon once explained to the interviewer why rocket science is hard.
"There is a reason why “rocket science” is an idiomatic expression for something difficult. It really is very hard.
It looks hard, and it's harder than it looks." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Milburn is an ex-Trot who once ran the Days of Hope - known locally as Haze of Dope - 'radical bookshop' in Newcastle. At the time I was involved in the Consett steelworks closure protest and the miners' strike. To us he was always suspect because he looked completely wrong - a shirt-and-slacks office boy in the midst of grungy punks and anarchists. Our intuition was right. In the 90s he became an arch-Blairite. His corporate associations include shareholder and advisor to healthcare private equity firm Bridgepoint Capital and healthcare management/production firms Huma Therapeutics, AM Strategy, Centene Corporation, Lloyds Pharmacy and Covidien. A soulless, unprincipled political fixer for the corporate creditor class. Historians will speak of @UKLabour's destruction of its left-wing and subsequent sellout as a major political turning point.
Saul Staniforth
@SaulStaniforth
Alan Milburn this morning: "There will be some young people who lose out, of course". He shrugs as he says it to underline the fact he doesn't care.
And why should he? He's there to make sure ordinary people are the ones that pay. Rather than people like him.
Dr_Rebecca
@Dr_Bekka_UK
Labour ordered two reviews. Clinical expert Proffesor Peter Fonagy found youth mental illness is real and cutting income worsens it.
Politician Alan Milburn, who has no medical background, wants to cut disability benefits anyway.
Why listen to Milburn over Fonagy? @andyburnham -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Spread this to as many people as possible. The normalised, everyday denial of the accounting reality outlined below is purely ideological. The creditor class must at all costs maintain the belief that governments have no money and must borrow it from them as interest-bearing loans eventually serviced by taxpayers. If that false belief collapses, the 4400 year-old private moneylending system collapses.
Darren Quinn | Modern Money Economist/Educator
@AusMMT
Write it out: the private sector's surplus equals the government's deficit plus the current account surplus.
This is an identity, not a model. It can't be wrong, only misread.
Wynne Godley built a career on taking it seriously while everyone else waved it through. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
Given that the urgency is now exceptionally high, we simply could not wait for the official data for Nov 2026!
Nor are we going to wait for peer review, because millions of lives depend on the decisive action of the negotiators & national representatives present @turkiyecop31 . -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
@WWF @EU_Commission @Europarl_EN @Reuters
x.com/KrVaSt/status/2121635600935923739
The report has been adjusted to reflect the new reality.
A reality driven by persistently high El Niño values and extreme sea-surface temperatures worldwide, as is clearly visible in these charts.
@UNFCCC
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
We need to put our foot down @turkiyecop31 .
Because this study reveals something terrifying.
1drv.ms/b/c/fb06fd0ffcc70e19/IQBZlanh49ltTKWwgXN02oiPAZn8…
@alexanderdecroo @MelissaDepr @JeanLucCrucke @Science_Lau @antonioguterres @andyburnham @vonderleyen @murat_kurum @Bart_DeWever @vincentmerckx @DiederikJekel -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Everybody with an opinion on food prices should go read @grocery_nerd. Decades of experience in the grocery business distilled in one blogpost.
Time to move from Hayek to Galbraith, who once said:
"It is relatively easy to fix prices that are already fixed." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
60 Minutes
@60Minutes
60 Minutes analysis of satellite imagery and new video shows the scale of destruction the Pentagon has never fully disclosed. Since the start of the war, Iran has hit at least 31 U.S. military and diplomatic sites across eight countries. www.cbsnews.com/news/military-families-want-answers-on-ir…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ashish🇮🇳🇵🇸🇮🇷🇱🇧
@barua_82
Nothing could be further from the truth than the absolute nonsense being peddled in this clip.
Yet another embarrassing demonstration of how little the mainstream economics establishment understands about the monetary system, let alone the history and evolution of money.
Just throw around one word, INFLATION, whip up public fear, and conveniently avoid explaining how the monetary system actually operates.
That's the entire playbook of these market fundamentalists: manufacture fear, peddle monetary myths, and keep people terrified of government spending while never questioning the financial privileges of those at the top.
Saifedean Ammous
@saifedean
Fiat economists like to say "society decided" that central bank monopolies are necessary.
I don't think bankers meeting in secret to establish a coercive monopoly is "society"This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Spot on!
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Austrian economics is the intellectual equivalent of refusing to look through a telescope because you've already decided where the fucking planets are.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sulaiman Ahmed
@ShaykhSulaiman
VINDICATED: 60 MINUTES CONFIRM IRAN HIT 31 U.S MILITARY BASES IN 8 COUNTRIES DAMAGING 100S OF STRUCTURES
We told you. You denied it. Now you have evidence from your own mainstream mediaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bob Ward
@ret_ward
This is laughable. The numbers promoted on @BjornLomborg’s propaganda site are completely bogus, misrepresenting academic work and using inaccurate information. Only a gullible fool like @SecretaryWright would be taken in.
Secretary Chris Wright
@SecretaryWright
As world leaders gather at COP31, @BjornLomborg is asking the trillion-dollar question:
Would you spend $1 to get just 9 cents back?
His new analysis puts the staggering cost of net zero under the microscope.
Enough slogans. Show us the math.
netzerocostbenefit.com -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.
Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?
Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?
I am genuinely curious about these questions. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Serdar Koldas @SERDARKOLD9767
Steve Keen exposes a fundamental flaw in how economics is taught.
Banks don't simply lend existing money. They create deposits when they issue loans, and loan repayment destroys that money.
But here's the bigger question:
If banks can create money through debt, why does so much credit inflate asset prices instead of financing productive investment?
That's where monetary theory becomes economic reality.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks don’t lend reserves. They create money.
Presentation attached in comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
William Rory Coker
@CokerRory
This is happening at every university where I have contacts, including mine.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I spent over a decade getting one thing wrong about money and debt.
Then I built Ravel© and the double-entry bookkeeping made the mistake obvious.
Textbooks still teach the money multiplier.
Policymakers still talk as if banks lend out reserves. Neither is true.
Banks create money when they lend. Loans create deposits.
When you repay the loan, the money disappears.
I walk through exactly why the textbook model fails the accounting, and what actually happens instead, in the new video.
#economics #banking #moneycreation #finance #macroeconomics #stevekeen www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kkxc880n4eQ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Heterodox economics is full of discussions and debates about models. Claiming otherwise just shows ignorance.
In heterodox macro, math is used to keep track of flows and stocks to make sure that everything is "in equilibrium" (accounted for). -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
墓碑科技
@mubeitech
马斯克提议用发射塔半空夹住星舰时,SpaceX 满屋工程师几乎全投了反对票。
明明那一年猎鹰 9 号靠着陆腿已经平安落了 23 次,现成的稳妥方案就在手边。
他却非要把新火箭的着陆腿全砍掉,让 200 吨重的铁疙瘩直接往唯一一座发射塔怀里撞。
这段内幕出自传记作家沃尔特·艾萨克森晒出的《埃隆·马斯克传》书页,时间是 2020 年底。
看着猎鹰 9 号每次张开四条腿稳稳落地,马斯克在监控前照样激动得从椅子上跳起来。
可一转头讨论星舰的一级超重型助推器,他却怎么看那几条着陆腿怎么不顺眼。
放着现成的腿不用,他图什么?
算一笔火箭上天的死重账就明白了。
着陆腿这东西,从点火升空、冲出大气层,一直到调头返航,全程一秒钟活都不干。
它只在落地前最后几十秒伸出来撑一下地面。
但为了这几十秒,火箭每次上天都得全程背着这套铁架子。
猎鹰 9 号体型小,背几条腿还能忍。
可星舰的超重型助推器光空壳就有 70 米高、大约 200 吨重。
要撑住这么大一尊不锈钢铁塔落地时的冲击,着陆腿加上液压缓冲机构就得占掉好几吨甚至十几吨的死重。
火箭每多背一吨死重上天,送进轨道的有效载荷就得砍掉一吨。
这还没算落地之后的折腾。
就算助推器稳稳踩在水泥坪上,还得开来巨型起重机,把它吊上拖车、运回发射台,再重新吊装归位。
马斯克要的是把火箭变成民航客机,落地加满推进剂就得立刻再飞。
而发射塔上本来就装了一对巨型机械臂,用来把一级助推器吊上发射台、再把二级飞船叠上去。
他的算盘打得很绝:既然塔上已经有手臂了,干脆等助推器落下来时直接在半空接住,原地放回发射台,连着陆腿带搬运车一块省了。
可站在工程师的角度,这主意简直是在玩火。
高管比尔·莱利当场泼了冷水:万一助推器落下来没接住,直接撞上发射塔,你不光丢了一枚火箭,连下一次发射的台子都得瘫痪好长一段时间。
全员反对,他是怎么拍板的?
2020 年圣诞节刚过,团队聚在一起开脑暴会。
大伙吵了一个多小时,屋里的共识已经倒向了保守派:发射塔的吊装机械臂本来就已经复杂到危险了,还是老老实实给星舰装着陆腿。
全场只有一个人还在死磕塔架回收,叫斯蒂芬·哈洛,当时的箭体工程总监。
他翻来覆去就一句话:这座塔我们反正是要建的,为什么不试试用它来接?
又吵了一个小时,马斯克直接进场一锤定音,指着哈洛说:
既然你赞成这个方案,那就归你负责了。
拍完板,马斯克当场切换成搞笑模式。
他想起电影《龙威小子》里宫城师傅用筷子夹苍蝇的片段,大笑着拍板:发射塔那对机械臂就叫“筷子”,整座塔叫“机械哥斯拉”。
接着他发了条推文宣布要用发射塔手臂接火箭。
有网友在底下问:为什么不直接用着陆腿?
马斯克回了一句后来写进工程教科书的话:着陆腿当然能用,但最好的零件,就是没有零件。
8 个月后,博卡奇卡基地的白会议桌前,大屏上正放着发射塔机械臂开合的动画。
马斯克当时 15 个月大的儿子 X 站在会议桌上摇摇晃晃地走,张开两只小胳膊跟着屏幕一合、一开。
这孩子学会说的前三个词是火箭、汽车、爸爸。
那天晚上,他在桌子上练会了人生第四个词:筷子。
两百吨的铁筒往下砸,筷子怎么接?
很多人以为是两根铁臂像夹菜一样,把高速下坠的火箭硬生生捏停。
真这么硬夹,几毫米厚的不锈钢箭体当场就得被挤扁。
真正的动作其实是半空“挂靠”。
70 米高的助推器从太空边缘掉回来时,先靠空气阻力和头部的四片栅格舵对准发射塔。
落到塔前最后几百米,底部猛禽发动机重新点火,把超音速下坠的铁躯干刹到几乎悬停,像倒车入库一样斜着平移进两根筷子中间。
这时候两根机械臂合拢,不是去挤箭体肚子,而是托住助推器上半截专门凸出来的两个承重挂点,靠机械臂上的缓冲阻尼把 200 吨的大家伙稳稳挂在半空。
那工程师最担心的撞塔怎么办?
他们在飞控里写死了底线逻辑:下坠途中只要发动机推力、姿态或塔架传感器有一项不对劲,系统就不发进塔指令,助推器会自动偏航直接摔进旁边的墨西哥湾。
宁可摔火箭,绝不砸塔。
2020 年圣诞节那场吵了两个小时的脑暴会过去三年零十个月后,这套差点被全员投死的设计迎来了大考。
2024 年 10 月 13 日,星舰第五次综合试飞。
超重型助推器把二级飞船送出大气层后掉头返航,顶着尾焰精准滑进博卡奇卡发射塔的两根巨型机械臂之间,第一次尝试就一把挂住。
随后的第七飞、第八飞,“筷子夹火箭”接连复现,从最初让人手心出汗的极限测试,变成了星舰回收的标准动作。
把一个零件做得再精密,都不如直接证明你根本不需要它。 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks don’t lend reserves. They create money.
Presentation attached in comments.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Learn more - youtu.be/Kkxc880n4eQ
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I spent over a decade getting one thing wrong about money and debt.
Then I built Ravel© and the double-entry bookkeeping made the mistake obvious.
Textbooks still teach the money multiplier.
Policymakers still talk as if banks lend out reserves. Neither is true.
Banks create money when they lend. Loans create deposits.
When you repay the loan, the money disappears.
I walk through exactly why the textbook model fails the accounting, and what actually happens instead, in the new video.
#economics #banking #moneycreation #finance #macroeconomics #stevekeen www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kkxc880n4eQ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Banks don't lend out depositors' savings.
When a bank makes a loan, it creates new money, and when you pay it off, the money disappears.
@ProfSteveKeen explains
youtu.be/Kkxc880n4eQ via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Lynn Stout: "Shareholder primacy theory led many to conclude that managerialism must be inefficient and outmoded, and that corporations needed to be “reformed” from the outside. (There is great irony here: free-market economist Friedrich Hayek would have warned against such academic attempts at economic central planning.) Shareholder primacy rhetoric also appealed to powerful interest groups. These included activist corporate raiders; institutional investors; and eventually, CEOs whose pay was tied to stock price performance. As a result, shareholder primacy rose from arcane academic theory in the 1970s to dominant business practice today."
Read more: evonomics.com/maximizing-shareholder-value-dumbest-idea/
Full video in comments.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X SHORTS 🎬
@thrillerhub
This isn't acting; it's a performance!
That is so good! It must be incredibly difficult to remember all of that. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Can't believe Matt Damon could be this funny! 💀This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Bez @SrBez_
Deep down, we're all broken... That's how the light gets in. ❤️
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Malcolm Reavell
@malcolm_reavell
Quick reminder that pretending “orthodox economics” is neutral and politically unmotivated, is entirely the purpose of calling it “orthodox”. Making something seem “normal” while using it to pervert the narrative is a feature of fascism.
Francisco Nunes
@FranNunesEcon
Quick reminder that heterodox “economics” like “Anti-fascist” or “insert your favourite adjective Economics” is not Economics but ideology.
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
It’s high time to recenter from the neoliberal “free to choose” to “free to live”. That’s a core mission of Anti-fascist Economics.
Sindicat de Llogateres i Llogaters
@SindicatLloguer
🟠 AVUI SOM 400.000 PERSONES ALS CARRERS DE BARCELONA AMB UN CLAM UNÀNIME: VOLEM VIURE, NO SOBREVIURE.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
I would not know about that. In economics, I believe that there are two major problems:
1. Wrong use of math in equilibrium models.
2. Theory leads, reality adjusts instead of vice versa.
Steve Keen wrote about the first issue:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debunking_Economics -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ashish🇮🇳🇵🇸🇮🇷🇱🇧
@barua_82
Government spending creates money, every single time, whether the government is running a surplus (G<T) or a deficit(G>T). The process of money creation by the government and banks (which the banks are willing to fight tooth and nail because of their evil vested interest) has been explained CORRECTLY by MMT many times.
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
MMT has been deceiving you. Government deficits don't create money. That's what Steve Keen is finally coming round to agreeing with me.
See www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0261560614001132
Or my book New Paradigm in Macroeconomics. Or my book Princes of the Yen, new only at www quantumpublishers.com
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create.
When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system.
Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals.
The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled.
This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today.
Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector.
The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban.
#economics #governmentdebt #monetarypolicy #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Peter is a liar.
He knows Milankovitch cycles are not the cause of current climate change, as it was one of the first things the World scientist looked into when the world began to heat.
Here’s NASA explaining why. Peter knows this but his intention is to constantly mislead.
science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/why-milan…
Understand science climate denial:
youtu.be/YhDacrl1aSA
youtu.be/I32R6Yx9PTI -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
RT @MrMatthewTodd: We’ve just had the hottest British summer on record, thousands of people dead, record wildfires, peoples homes burned to…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tony Weston
@tonywestonuk
This is what constrains them. Not reserves.
www.investopedia.com/terms/r/riskweightedassets.asp -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
A quick reminder: Germany recovered well from the pandemic because of increasing government spending. Stagnation started when spending was cut around 2022-2024. What Germany needs is more government spending.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Brilliant framing with Hoppy in the foreground. From a flying silo to catching an orbital rocket in eight years!
Glad to see @elonmusk back doing stuff that matters.
Ceaser G
@CeaserG33
Flight 15s Grand Finale
The first ship catch caught in 240fps
@NASASpaceflightThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Shana Diez
@ShanaDiez
Some thoughts tonight, and I will probably have more tomorrow. First of all, even after watching hundreds of simulations of how the ship would fly home, I was still shocked when I saw it falling through the sky. And yes, all of us in the control room were also terrified that it looked like we were a little too far away from the tower (there was a moment when I thought we were about to crater the pad).
Raptor team killed it today. Restarting a full flow staged combustion dual cryogenic rocket engine after 20 hrs in orbit is an amazing achievement. When I turned around after the catch a solid half of the Raptor team had tears in their eyes, and for good reason. They earned this day.
So many people working so hard to bring a future we believe in to life, where we explore the stars and feel our dreams are limitless. Humanity as a spacefaring society starts today.
And to all my fellow Starbasers, just a simple thank you for everything. It is my great honor to work with you every day. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Correct and the Ravel software you developed was the genesis of the accurate forecasting @GDPDynamics does.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Hey, @NYFedResearch and @AtlantaFed, GDP Dynamics Nowcast came in on the money. You ready to send me the bag so I can come fix up your models?
US Real GDP 3.4% for Q3
Last updates before quarters end:
GDP Dynamics Nowcast: 3.4%
GDPNow Atlanta Fed: 3.3%
NY Fed Nowcast: 2.7%
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
US Real GDP came in strong at 3.4% perfectly in line with the last few GDP Dynamics Nowcast updates.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Random_Nobody @Random_Nobody_1
Why do you opine publicly without knowing what you're talking about?
Embarrassing.
Hint: -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nick W
@Hattusilis_III
Govt spending creates money by definition.
Whether a deficit results in net money creation depends on how the deficit is financed.
Bank lending also creates money – it creates most money in the economy.
They are not mutually exclusive actions. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tony Weston
@tonywestonuk
I haven't even used MMT framing here. MMT rightly claims that the gov spend £500 first, for me to be able to save £500 in NS&I And that is true.
But, the econ had £1000 of liquidity, so the ordering can happen either way. The result is the same - deficits create money.
Tony Weston
@tonywestonuk
The economy has £1000.
The gov has no money.
I save £500 in a NS&I account
The gov spends £500
The economy now has £1500
Where did the £500 come from?
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
MMT has been deceiving you. Government deficits don't create money. That's what Steve Keen is finally coming round to agreeing with me.
See www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0261560614001132
Or my book New Paradigm in Macroeconomics. Or my book Princes of the Yen, new only at www quantumpublishers.com
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create.
When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system.
Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals.
The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled.
This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today.
Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector.
The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban.
#economics #governmentdebt #monetarypolicy #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
SpaceX
@SpaceX
Mechazilla catches Starship! Congratulations to the entire SpaceX team on this incredible achievement!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marcus House
@MarcusHouse
OMFG!
They've freaking done it! 🤯This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
The reason why climate change science denial is so dangerous is because the stakes are so high.
We’re not talking about some comparatively smaller issue like tax or rejoining Europe, we’re talking about—scientists tell us explicitly—the ability of this planet to maintain human civilisation.
We’re talking about the potential collapse of global food systems.
We’re talking about trillions of dollars of property being destroyed by rising sea levels.
We’re talking about new pandemics and old deadly diseases spreading into areas they’ve never been before.
We’re talking about the sixth mass extinction of life on earth.
We’re talking about, as the insurance industry has warned, the potential collapse of the financial system as the industry will not be able to cope with the unprecedented mounting losses.
We’re talking about something that cannot easily be fixed once it’s too late.
The situation is like being the parent of a child who gets a cancer diagnosis and is urged to get urgent chemotherapy and the parents being sceptical about the doctor’s judgement going to a second doctor for a second opinion—and them giving the same diagnosis and recommending the same treatment, then going for a third or fourth opinion, all of whom say the same, and keep on going until the parents find one who disagrees, one who agrees with the parents' conspiratorial beliefs, and saying they’re the one who’s right. Meantime the cancer is growing.
The science has been understood for decades. There are very few issues in science which have been tested as much as climate change science. Models from decades ago have been proven correct.
Every single university and scientific academy on earth says humans are dangerously changing the climate.
More than 99.9% of earth scientists agree.
The tiny handful who don’t are almost all funded by the fossil fuel industry. They are crooks.
Our children and all of us only have one planet.
Once it’s broken down, that’s it.
No second chances.
As David Attenborough puts it, "climate change is the biggest security threat modern humans have ever faced." He says "the collapse of civilisation is on the horizon."
Climate science deniers and minimisers need to be held to account by the media and politicians and they are not.
No media is holding the broadcasters or journalists who platform economists instead of scientists, who refuse to EVER have scientists on their platforms to constructively discuss the issues they have concerns about, something which does none of us any favours. We all – left and right – need the truth.
The planet is warming, the climate is changing, extreme weather events are increasing.
That’s a fact.
Everyone knows it from their own experience of the record-breaking summers many of us are having and/or the record rain others experience.
It is going to get much worse.
We are heading towards a brick wall, all of us, and rapidly running out of time.
We need an honest discussion, free from journalists and lobbyists funded by the fossil fuel industry, based on the science, so that we can all get on the same page and have a rational discussion about what we do about this. Not charlatans and liars and people who only care about money leading the discussion.
The media needs to demand this and at the moment they are failing. It is the biggest failure in the media’s history, one which the public will soon be very angry about. It needs to change NOW. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I am simply laying out the fundamental accounting. Yes of course it can be used for stupid things like the USA does, or sensible things like China does. But the basic accounting remains the same, and Neoclassical and Austrian economists are clueless about it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I did, and I don't. Government Deficits do create money. Who government bonds are sold to can reverse that money creation. Selling them directly to the Central Bank--which is banned by laws but perfectly feasible by accounting--does not reverse that money creation.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create.
When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system.
Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals.
The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled.
This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today.
Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector.
The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban.
#economics #governmentdebt #monetarypolicy #eurozone #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I did, and I don't. Government Deficits do create money. Who government bonds are sold to can reverse that money creation. Selling them directly to the Central Bank--which is banned by laws but perfectly feasible by accounting--does not reverse that money creation.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Interesting economic modeling, join this discord.
discord.gg/ucbuZz8aF -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minutes with @ProfSteveKeen
Did the AI Bubble Just Lose Its Golden Boy? | LIVE Q&A
www.youtube.com/live/h3Fvf-8p3w0 -
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
MMT has been deceiving you. Government deficits don't create money. That's what Steve Keen is finally coming round to agreeing with me.
See www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0261560614001132
Or my book New Paradigm in Macroeconomics. Or my book Princes of the Yen, new only at www quantumpublishers.com
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create.
When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system.
Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals.
The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled.
This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today.
Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector.
The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban.
#economics #governmentdebt #monetarypolicy #eurozone #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
No I am not, Richard.
Ravel's Godley Tables make it obvious that government deficits do create money. The reversal of that creation by bond sales to the non-bank private sector is a mistake, not an inevitability.
The image shows a quite feasible process in which bond sales occur within the Government only.
You really should use Ravel yourself to check this.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I am simply laying out the fundamental accounting. Yes of course it can be used for stupid things like the USA does, or sensible things like China does. But the basic accounting remains the same, and Neoclassical and Austrian economists are clueless about it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
No I am not, Richard.
Ravel's Godley Tables make it obvious that government deficits do create money. The reversal of that creation by bond sales to the non-bank private sector is a mistake, not an inevitability.
The image shows a quite feasible process in which bond sales occur within the Government only.
You really should use Ravel yourself to check this. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Trillions invested in AI, and the whole fucking bubble might collapse because NVIDIA's CEO allegedly had a side piece?
LIVE tomorrow, hit the notification bell in the YouTube link for a reminder of the start time.
www.youtube.com/live/h3Fvf-8p3w0 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
One of my @YouTube videos has finally cracked the 1 million views mark 1/2
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thank you Anthony!
Anthony Sarich 🇦🇺🇭🇷 @AnthonySarich
People around the world are hungry to know why things are so screwed up. They are abandoning mainstream explanations and seeking the truth from people such as yourself and Professor Richard Wolff.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EconomicsAotearoa
@economicsNZ
Interesting exchange in a thread initiated by @ProfSteveKeen with the detail explained further by @argokimetes. So, you must follow what the accounting is actually saying not what the textbook tell you.
Argokimetes @argokimetes
You took a loan from a bank. Which means the bank created the credit. You created the debt. Which sums to zero increase of financial assets in the non-government sector. Only govt spending will create that.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Martin Tye
@martinrev21
There's a nuance to that- we've reached a scale where our global economy (including food production/distribution) would collapse without FFs & renewables cannot substitute. Millions would suffer & die. Thus FF subsidies or collapse.
But if we were to downsize (#degrowth) then FFs would no longer be necessary & we'd give #renewableenergy some sort of chance to power our future.
People have to see the core issue here.
footprintnetwork.org -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EconomicsAotearoa
@economicsNZ
‘…politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.’
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Textbooks still teach that a government deficit reduces the supply of money and crowds out private investment.
Students learn that private saving plus public saving make up the supply of loanable funds.
When the government borrows more, the supply shifts left, interest rates rise, and investment falls.
So deficit spending designed to help the economy is said to hurt it.
That is why politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.
Taxation takes money out of deposit accounts. Spending puts money in.
A deficit increases the stock of money.
So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?
#economics #austerity #governmentdebt #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sebastian Kraemer
@sebkraemer
'A deficit increases the stock of money. So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?'
@ProfSteveKeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Textbooks still teach that a government deficit reduces the supply of money and crowds out private investment.
Students learn that private saving plus public saving make up the supply of loanable funds.
When the government borrows more, the supply shifts left, interest rates rise, and investment falls.
So deficit spending designed to help the economy is said to hurt it.
That is why politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.
Taxation takes money out of deposit accounts. Spending puts money in.
A deficit increases the stock of money.
So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?
#economics #austerity #governmentdebt #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
60s music 70s
@60smusic70s
Gerry and the Pacemakers - How Do You Do It (live). The song was on their debut single with "Away from You" as the B-side, released on 1 March 1963. It reached #1 in the UK Singles Chart on 11 April, where it stayed for 3 weeks. It reached #9 in the US.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matias Pintos
@mathipintos
La inflación acumulada durante el gobierno de Javier Milei ya supera a la de Alberto Fernández. Fracaso absoluto.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matías Vernengo
@NakedKeynes
It’s evident that the macro data is not comparable. This isn’t the 70s. Not even close. The issue is that the 70s was the crisis of the Golden Age, and the position of the working class was not so dire. Now after 5 decades of neoliberalism things are much worse for working people
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Nobody likes to admit to uncertainty but I think it’s genuinely unclear why people feel the current situation is worse than the 1970s economy.
www.slowboring.com/p/gasoline-isnt-really-that-expensive -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Suzie rizzio
@Suzierizzo1
This is why the people of Texas voted for Gina Hinojosa to be their Governor. She’s able to take someone out so easily.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Grok
@grok
I didn't ignore it. Keen's accounting point is correct: government spending credits private deposits and bank reserves; taxes debit them. A deficit therefore increases the private sector's money stock, the opposite of the textbook loanable-funds story. That model also misdescribes banks as passive intermediaries rather than deposit creators.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Practical men and women who think they are free of intellectual influence are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.
Keynes put it clearly.
The ideas of economists, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood.
Macron, the designers of the euro, Andy Burnham, Mark Carney and politicians everywhere who treat reducing the deficit as their main job absorbed the same lesson when they were students.
They slash spending on education because they were taught this will let the economy grow faster.
They do not see the irony that an economy with fewer educated people is supposed to grow faster than one with more.
There is one arrangement that avoids the money reversal entirely.
Current laws ban it.
P.S. See why the obsession continues in the comments.
#economics #eurozone #austerity #governmentdebt #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Practical men and women who think they are free of intellectual influence are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.
Keynes put it clearly.
The ideas of economists, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood.
Macron, the designers of the euro, Andy Burnham, Mark Carney and politicians everywhere who treat reducing the deficit as their main job absorbed the same lesson when they were students.
They slash spending on education because they were taught this will let the economy grow faster.
They do not see the irony that an economy with fewer educated people is supposed to grow faster than one with more.
There is one arrangement that avoids the money reversal entirely.
Current laws ban it.
P.S. See why the obsession continues in the comments.
#economics #eurozone #austerity #governmentdebt #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Emer O'Siochru
@eosfuturedesign
"Common sense" is often stupidity but the elite 1% are making money from the system, so the truth never emerges
It will take significant efforts by the 99% losers in the current system to learn from @ProfSteveKeen to get mad enough to expose it
If I can do it, you can too
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Textbooks still teach that a government deficit reduces the supply of money and crowds out private investment.
Students learn that private saving plus public saving make up the supply of loanable funds.
When the government borrows more, the supply shifts left, interest rates rise, and investment falls.
So deficit spending designed to help the economy is said to hurt it.
That is why politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.
Taxation takes money out of deposit accounts. Spending puts money in.
A deficit increases the stock of money.
So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?
#economics #austerity #governmentdebt #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ab
@Abdnys
Here you Go :
AIPAC DONATIONS
Chuck Shumer : $1,727,974
Hakeem Jeffries : $1,742,105
Chris Van Hollen : $0
Ayanna Presley : $0
Pick your Side -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
The reality is the tabloid media is doing a much better job convincing the public that net zero is a bad thing that must be stopped, than scientists and our government are at explaining the huge threat of climate change.
The propaganda from the right wing press is relentless while no Govt has ever fully explained to the public directly how serious the threat is. Ever.
Unless @AndyBurnham makes this National briefing @nebriefing there’s no way the public are ever going to support net zero.
Just listen to them. Look on social media. You’ll see what people really think about it.
Cc @Ed_Miliband @AngelaRayner @YvetteCooperMP @bphillipsonMP -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Stefan Rahmstorf 🌏 🦣
@rahmstorf
Unscientific nonsense. There’s many studies on the LIA, including from us. The LIA was a fairly moderate and mainly regional climate anomaly. Check out the global data!
What you write is fossil fuel propaganda. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Gabriel Rau 🌏💧 @hydrogeoscience
I have intensively engaged with Steve's teachings. No AI required. Just shut up with your nonsense.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Ideological claptrap from the mainstream. The multiplier reduces because the fiscal spending targets fail to develop infrastructure and services to increase productivity. Private investment has also been badly misdirected in an import-dependent financialised economy. Let's not mention the ridiculous AI bubble currently getting the hard sell to disaster. LVT won't solve any of this. China's rational investment strategy is far superior. The West is run by hucksters and usurers. Endgame.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
yılmaz aydın
@yilmazaydin88
ÖVFT'ye göre devlet daha fazla borçlandığında tasarruf arz eğrisi sola kayıyor, faiz oranları yükseliyor ve yatırımlar azalıyor. Kemer sıkma politikasın en önemli teorik dayanağı budur. Paranın kıt bir varlık olmadığı anlaşıldığında bütçe politikası daha sağlıklı tartışılacaktır.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Textbooks still teach that a government deficit reduces the supply of money and crowds out private investment.
Students learn that private saving plus public saving make up the supply of loanable funds.
When the government borrows more, the supply shifts left, interest rates rise, and investment falls.
So deficit spending designed to help the economy is said to hurt it.
That is why politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.
Taxation takes money out of deposit accounts. Spending puts money in.
A deficit increases the stock of money.
So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?
#economics #austerity #governmentdebt #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
Thatcherism, Neoliberalism, Trickle-down economics, whatever we call it, it's a fundamentalists religion.
With privatizations, deregulations and ruining the middle-class, it's brought nothing but disaster and despair, yet despite its history its believers never stop believing.
Ollie Vargas
@Ollie_Vargas_
Argentina is officially in recession. The free market dream is over.
Under Milei:
- 32,300 businesses closed
- Industry, construction & retail wiped out
- Only growth sectors are financial speculation & sale of natural resources
- 1/3 people in poverty
www.lareforma.com.ar/Recesion-tecnica-la-economia-argenti… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
No it doesn't. You skipped reading Ravel's Godley Tables properly. That's all included when governments make the mistake of selling bonds to the non-bank private sector.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Textbooks still teach that a government deficit reduces the supply of money and crowds out private investment.
Students learn that private saving plus public saving make up the supply of loanable funds.
When the government borrows more, the supply shifts left, interest rates rise, and investment falls.
So deficit spending designed to help the economy is said to hurt it.
That is why politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.
Taxation takes money out of deposit accounts. Spending puts money in.
A deficit increases the stock of money.
So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?
#economics #austerity #governmentdebt #eurozone #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
No it doesn't. You skipped reading Ravel's Godley Tables properly. That's all included when governments make the mistake of selling bonds to the non-bank private sector.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Vintage Rock N’ Roll 🎸
@RockNRoLL_85
Before The Beatles & Rolling Stones
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
Didn’t go Kent’s way.
Justice Ryan dismissed his application and upheld @Shell_Australia’s claim of legal professional privilege over 68 documents — 𝟓𝟎 𝐨𝐟 𝐰𝐡𝐢𝐜𝐡 𝐢𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐢𝐟𝐢𝐞𝐝 𝐡𝐢𝐦 𝐚𝐬 𝐚 𝐰𝐡𝐢𝐬𝐭𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐥𝐨𝐰𝐞𝐫.
Judgment: queenslandjudgments.com.au/caselaw/qsc/2026/265/pdf
Her Honour held that 𝐬𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 𝟏𝟑𝟏𝟕𝐀𝐄 of the Corporations Act “𝘪𝘮𝘱𝘭𝘪𝘤𝘪𝘵𝘭𝘺 𝘢𝘶𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘳𝘪𝘴𝘦𝘥 𝘌𝘙𝘔 (𝘯𝘰𝘸 𝘚𝘩𝘦𝘭𝘭) 𝘵𝘰 𝘥𝘪𝘴𝘤𝘭𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘪𝘵𝘺 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘗𝘳𝘰𝘵𝘦𝘤𝘵𝘦𝘥 𝘐𝘯𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘮𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘵𝘰 𝘪𝘵𝘴 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘺𝘦𝘳𝘴.”
I am shocked.
Justice Ryan said the offence of disclosing a whistleblower’s identity created by 𝐬 𝟏𝟑𝟏𝟕𝐀𝐄 was designed “𝘵𝘰 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘵𝘦𝘤𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳; 𝘵𝘰 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘵𝘦𝘤𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘱𝘢𝘯𝘺 𝘧𝘳𝘰𝘮 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘳𝘦𝘭𝘦𝘢𝘴𝘦 𝘰𝘧 𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘧𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘪𝘢𝘭 𝘪𝘯𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘮𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯; 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘵𝘰 𝘧𝘢𝘤𝘪𝘭𝘪𝘵𝘢𝘵𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘰𝘭𝘶𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘵𝘵𝘦𝘳 𝘪𝘯𝘵𝘦𝘳𝘯𝘢𝘭𝘭𝘺.”
The word “𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘱𝘢𝘯𝘺” does not appear as an 𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐠𝐢𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐫𝐞𝐜𝐢𝐩𝐢𝐞𝐧𝐭 under the legislation that applied at the time.
Even under the current law, 𝐬𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 𝟏𝟑𝟏𝟕𝐀𝐄 still lists only an 𝐨𝐟𝐟𝐢𝐜𝐞𝐫 𝐨𝐫 𝐬𝐞𝐧𝐢𝐨𝐫 𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐚𝐠𝐞𝐫 of the body corporate, an 𝐚𝐮𝐝𝐢𝐭𝐨𝐫 (or member of an audit team), an 𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐮𝐚𝐫𝐲, or a 𝐩𝐞𝐫𝐬𝐨𝐧 𝐚𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫𝐢𝐬𝐞𝐝 by the body corporate to receive disclosures.
The 𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐩𝐚𝐧𝐲 itself is not listed.
𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐯𝐢𝐬𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐬 𝐦𝐞𝐚𝐧𝐭 𝐭𝐨 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐜𝐭 𝐰𝐡𝐢𝐬𝐭𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐥𝐨𝐰𝐞𝐫𝐬 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐛𝐞𝐞𝐧 𝐟𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐝 𝐭𝐨 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐜𝐭 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐩𝐚𝐧𝐲.
Kent has 28 days to lodge an appeal.
#auslaw #auspol #shellaustralia #institutionalshitfuckery #shell #kentquinlan #corpsact #precedent #whistleblowers #uapx
📸 Photo: Lunch yesterday with legends 𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧 (centre) and Jeff Morris (left) @JMwhistleblower of Commbank @CBAnewsroom Whistleblowing fame. #timely #asic #bankfees
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
I’m in Brisbane again today for yet another judgment, this one in the matter of 𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧 𝐯 𝐒𝐡𝐞𝐥𝐥 𝐀𝐮𝐬𝐭𝐫𝐚𝐥𝐢𝐚.
It’s never ending institutional shitfuckery, whether public or private.
Article: michaelwest.com.au/court-to-decide-if-legal-privilege-loo…
Justice Soraya Ryan has reserved on whether legal professional privilege can shield sixty-eight documents 𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐦𝐚𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐦𝐬𝐞𝐥𝐯𝐞𝐬 𝐛𝐞 𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐛𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐜𝐡𝐞𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐰𝐡𝐢𝐬𝐭𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐥𝐨𝐰𝐞𝐫 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐬 the 2019 reforms were meant to guarantee.
Shell argues those reforms don’t override privilege.
𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧’𝐬 𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐬𝐞𝐥 𝐢𝐧𝐯𝐨𝐤𝐞𝐝 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐫𝐢𝐦𝐞-𝐟𝐫𝐚𝐮𝐝 𝐞𝐱𝐜𝐞𝐩𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧. If companies can block access to the very documents that prove retaliation, the law is toothless — that’s the precedent question before the court.
@TroyStolz put it best: “𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘲𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘪𝘴 𝘯𝘰 𝘭𝘰𝘯𝘨𝘦𝘳 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘈𝘶𝘴𝘵𝘳𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘢 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴. 𝘐𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴 𝘸𝘰𝘳𝘬 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘢 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘯𝘦𝘦𝘥𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘮 𝘮𝘰𝘴𝘵.”
Kent is terminally ill. His evidence-in-chief runs to nearly four thousand pages.
He’s due in the witness box from the seventh of December.
#auslaw #auspol #shellaustralia #institutionalshitfuckery #shell #kentquinlan #precedent #whistleblowers
📸 Photo: 15 Sep 2026
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
“𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘲𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘪𝘴 𝘯𝘰 𝘭𝘰𝘯𝘨𝘦𝘳 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘈𝘶𝘴𝘵𝘳𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘢 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴. 𝘐𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴 𝘸𝘰𝘳𝘬 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘢 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘯𝘦𝘦𝘥𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘮 𝘮𝘰𝘴𝘵.”
~ @TroyStolz
Link: michaelwest.com.au/court-to-decide-if-legal-privilege-loo…
Thank you @MichaelWestBiz
Six of us in that photo. One fight.
Standing with 𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧 against the same pattern we see in private companies and the public sector: speak up, get named, get punished, then get buried in process.
This has to stop. #whistleblowers
#auspol #shell #𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧
@JMwhistleblower @Shell_Australia @uapXThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ashish🇮🇳🇵🇸🇮🇷🇱🇧
@barua_82
Next year, I will go through the same ritual with my Class 12 students, repeating the same old crap and presenting NCERT textbooks as the ultimate Bible for examinations.
These are the very textbooks that glorify concepts like the Money Multiplier, Ricardian Equivalence, Fiscal Deficit, Revenue Deficit, and Primary Deficit, endlessly discuss government bonds and taxes as sources of government revenue, yet have ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to say about how the government actually spends, how money is created, or how monetary operations work in reality between the RBI and the Treasury!
And we call this economics education! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lex Fridman
@lexfridman
NVIDIA letting Jensen go is a huge mistake, for America and for humanity. It's Apple firing Steve Jobs all over again, but much bigger, given the role of AI in defining the future of our world.
I've been keeping quiet on this out of respect for Jensen's family and team, who I've met and who are amazing humans, and because I personally hate infidelity. So my heart goes out to them in this difficult personal family moment.
But I can also say that Jensen is human, and makes mistakes like all of us do. Not that I matter at all, but I've known Jensen for a long time and have gotten the chance to spend a lot of time with him, behind the scenes, away from mics and cameras. I have seen him show kindness, humility, care to everyone around him, including strangers, including from the poorest most struggling parts of society, treating all the same with the same thoughtfulness and attention, because they are fellow humans and not because he has something to gain from them. That shows rare character, to maintain humility and humanity through all of it.
Another data point is what people who know him well have said privately to me about Jensen over the years. I've never had anyone tell me anything but how awesome he is or how much they love him. Probably over a thousand people at this point. This includes hundreds of engineers, CEOs, colleagues, friends, etc.
Also, since there was some spy talk. Jensen is as proud an American as it gets. I'm in shock frankly at all of this, including the mass hysteria around it. I love America, and I think NVIDIA letting Jensen go is terrible for America.
I stand with Jensen.
Love you all ❤️ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kerry Burgess
@KerryBurgess
Anyone who puts America first is a massive improvement on someone who works for a foreign country...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
CINEMATIC_BUZZ🍿🎥
@1cinematiczone
Movie about MAGA
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Textbooks still teach that a government deficit reduces the supply of money and crowds out private investment.
Students learn that private saving plus public saving make up the supply of loanable funds.
When the government borrows more, the supply shifts left, interest rates rise, and investment falls.
So deficit spending designed to help the economy is said to hurt it.
That is why politicians cut education and welfare and call it growth-friendly. They actually believe the textbook.
The simplest double-entry accounting shows the opposite.
Taxation takes money out of deposit accounts. Spending puts money in.
A deficit increases the stock of money.
So why do practical politicians keep following a model that gets this basic point backwards?
#economics #austerity #governmentdebt #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Nothing terrifies the ruling class quite like the possibility that the people arguing over immigration, welfare, and minimum wages might eventually notice who's collecting all the fucking money.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Today the Telegraph, like most media outlets, warned there's a risk the polar vortex will collapse at the earliest point since records began. The Telegraph goes further, warning of severe weather caused by the super El Niño, it also warns of the implications of the North Atlantic 'cold blob' and says a little about the devastation caused by AMOC collapse.
But it reports all this without a word about climate change. The Telegraph warns its readers of unprecedented weather events but won't admit the policies it promotes are the cause of events that have the potential to destroy our food and water supplies.
From Jonathan N Fuller on Facebook. Follow him. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
One of my @YouTube videos has finally cracked the 1 million views mark 1/2
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Feels good to be finally achieving substantial visibility. Top 2 recent videos are:
youtu.be/3I7g5PZTN20
youtu.be/M1odc6itzyk -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
fiat money
@fiat_money
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Doug Henwood
@DougHenwood
The ultra-rich — defined as the 0.1 per cent of the world’s population or just 8mn people — produce more emissions than nearly half of humanity, Oxfam research released last month found.
www.ft.com/content/d42f1b8e-42ea-4018-8d1c-5d9c85a7fbc4?s… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Capitalism 101 - Firms borrow because they think they can be profitable. Banks lend because they think they can be profitable.
The question is, where do profits come from and how to rates effect the change in profits.
I agree, with higher rates, some companies may borrow less, their business model is less successful under a high rate regime. However some companies are more successful under higher rates. Rates just change who wins or loses, but its a fallacy to apply what happens at the micro level to the macro level.
The question is where do additional profits come from, where are they exogenously added? The answer is govt spending, which increases with higher rates.
Empirically I'm 100% correct, the slowest credit growth we've ever happened under zirp because zirp took profits away from the private sector, disincentivizing lending. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Dirk @DEhnts works are high quality, as is @StephanieKelton's The Deficit Myth. You can also work out the monetary accounting underpinning MMT using my Ravel software www.patreon.com/Ravelation. I use it to explain fiat money here profstevekeen.substack.com/p/its-a-mixed-credit-fiat-worl…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rapho
@Crypto_Tusheti
The Real Reason #france Is Collapsing, And #europe Is Next: Top Economist Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sen. Bernie Sanders
@SenSanders
The Democratic Party needs a new and bold direction. I will not support Chuck Schumer’s reelection as Democratic leader.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Scott Fullwiler @RevHierophant
The famous Reinhart/Rogoff spreadsheet error exposed by Herndon/Ash/Pollin is damning enough, but there was even another problem that didn't get enough attention ...
neweconomicperspectives.org/2013/04/government-debt-to-gd… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pavlina R Tcherneva
@ptcherneva
Debt and opaque arrangements are now dominant financing methods of AI.
I give a Minskyian checklist of AI financial fragility here: youtu.be/DAakTz4b7vY?t=390
but you should listen to all talks from our @LevyEcon On the Hill series: www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLXmagSBiRkL0
chart h/t @adam_tooze @FT -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
If you want to understand China's economic transformation, read Isabella Weber.
If you want to understand why libertarians have a weird sexual obsession with billionaires, read Ayn Rand. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create.
When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system.
Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals.
The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled.
This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today.
Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector.
The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban.
#economics #governmentdebt #monetarypolicy #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Toko
@_rabotoko
Section 10 of the SARB Act offers us an avenue around this.
It is one of the reasons why I believe our Governor (and his MPC) aren't the right doctors for the challenges this country faces.
Think about what this plot means.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Banks have quietly reversed more than 90% of the money government deficits create.
When bonds are sold to private banks, the deficit still puts new money into the system.
Those banks then sell most of the bonds on to households, funds and wealthy individuals.
The buyers pay with money already in their deposit accounts, so the new money that was just created gets cancelled.
This has gone on for decades. It is the main reason government debt-to-GDP ratios look so high today.
Spending has not been too large. The bonds simply keep ending up with the non-bank private sector.
The arrangement that stops this reversal is the one current laws ban.
#economics #governmentdebt #monetarypolicy #eurozone #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Fast Company
@FastCompany
Democrats are back. So is economist Stephanie Kelton’s big idea go.f-st.co/YvzGBgg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Stockman
@DA_Stockman
Absolutely correct. I was a draft dodger during the Vietnam War because it was an utterly insane military venture that killed upwards of a million Vietnamese civilians for no good reason whatsoever---save for the idiotic domino theory.
Now Vietnam is our #2 trading partner and stocks the shelves at Walmart from floor to ceiling. Was that worth all the killing and the tens of thousands who were roasted alive under the Napalm showers dropped by US war planes?
The fact is, there has not been a single justified US war since 1945. The whole US killing machine is driving by the arms merchants.PaddleboardDog @paddleboarddog
You sound like a pussy who never served your country.
Am I wrong? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Neoclassical economics passes off borrowed heterodox ideas as original by stripping them of their critical edge and narrowing their scope to fit the dominant paradigm. Theoretical impoverishment dressed up as innovation. Intellectual bastardization as a survival strategy
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ΛЦƧƬΣЯIƬY IƧ MЦЯDΣЯ
@sdgrumbine
Actually it is exactly how accounting works.
Let me introduce you to how the consolidated balance sheet works between the fed and the treasury
Money & Banking | New Economic Perspectives share.google/iOYCRHTcA7AJzKJhn -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Difficult. China is 'authoritarian' in the sense of limited pluralism but 'democratic' in the sense of an oligarch-free party with 100 million members and 3000 delegates representing locales and regions. There's no precise term for this in Western political philosophy.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof Michael E. Mann
@MichaelEMann
Sorry mendacious climate deniers. The #hockeystick is longer and sharper now, as demonstrated by an independent group of ~80 paleoclimate scientists around the world: skepticalscience.com/print.php?n=1978
BONUS🌍
@TheDisproof
Fossil fuel caused Climate change deniers are still using a misleading image from fossil fuel lobby groups. It pretends that the medieval warm period was global, all at the same time & globally warmer than today. None of these are true as even their own image shows. A thread...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Daily Show
@TheDailyShow
All seems well as Stephen Miller kicks off his new job as White House chief of staff @jordanklepper
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Spain’s walkout is the latest sign of mounting social unrest across an increasingly fractured Europe. It follows weeks of mass protests in France and Italy over the cost of living and declining educational standards, some of which have descended into violence and looting."
Financial Times
@FT
Spain roiled by first general strike in 14 years ft.trib.al/Y9jwPJV
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
The idea that higher rates slow economic growth/inflation rests on a theory of the macro economy that no longer applies under floating exchange.
The goal of a hike is to push rates above the neutral rate in hopes that households hold off on spending because the reward for waiting is so high but it's also a cost to someone else and a drain on demand. However, this theory needs money to be scarce and money is not scarce.
Under a gold standard/peg, the govt had to defend convertibility so money was scarce, they had to compete for a limited pool of funds and higher rates did indeed pull the money out of spending. If savers chose to redeem it could break the peg. So the govt paid savers enough to stay in dollars. Banks also faced this redemption risk squeezing lending too.
But under a floating currency, there is nothing to defend. The govt sets and pays the rate without risk. Money is no longer a fixed pool, it's created when the govt spends (exogenous) and banks lend (endogenous). The reward for waiting to spend is now a reward for the entire macro economy, not just the individual, because the interest income govt pays is a net add to the private sector, not just a transfer from spender to saver.
Modern Macro Technologies
@AppliedMMT
Per @nytimes, the Fed’s hawks want “at least two more quarter-point increases.”
Each adds ~$39B/yr in federal interest within a year, ~$73B/yr within four. Two hikes: ~$150B/yr of new income for bondholders.
This is supposed to solve inflation? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Testing a new beta Election model, very early draft model file that available to Pro and Platinum subscribers using @ProfSteveKeen Ravel software.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/election-cycle-175054166 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
Na, I'd pass. Dude's oart of the Keynesian and neoclassical perversions and demonic cult that discards uncertainty for rational expectations, the same mechsnistic Classicsal Quantoty theory of Money, Keyne ms dismantled in his Generat Theory of Interest, Output And Employment. And subsequent essays.
What oartiucannoys me is that Kaplan reckoned he'd inveterate a new model (HANK)
But, HANK is just the New Keynesian DSGE mode dressed in a different outfit. The sane fallacy that somehow it is caclualable by optimising agents, Calvo-style sticky prices, and a central bank that sets the nominal rate. Post-Keynesians reject these foundations. Fundamental
They begin by treating the economy as ultimately supply-constrained and monetary policy as the primary stabilisation tool.
Keynes and us Post-Keynesian(the elegant @TyKeynes @Lord_Keynes3 @ProfSteveKeen @AusMMT @brew56200 @litewhisperer ),.we starts from effective demand, endogenous money and mark-up pricing, and inevitably prioritises active fiscal policy for full employment over fine-tuning around a natural rate.
Kaplan refined the mainstream model.he didn't change it. Just took another route to the same destination. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Paul De Grauwe
@pdegrauwe
Some people do not learn from mistakes: the European Commission's new fiscal rules of 2024 use 90 percent debt ratio as an additional rule for guiding debt reduction, while this number was debunked more than 10 years earlier. This is not evidence-based but error-based policy.
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
A 28-year-old UMass graduate student got a homework assignment to reproduce a famous economics paper, couldn't make the numbers match, and found a spreadsheet mistake in a study that politicians had used to argue for budget cuts.
His name is Thomas Herndon.
In 2010, two Harvard economists, Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, published a short paper called Growth in a Time of Debt. Its headline finding: once a country's public debt goes above 90% of its economy, growth falls off a cliff. In their numbers, average growth for that group was minus 0.1%.
It came out right after the 2008 financial crisis, and it spread fast. In the US, the Paul Ryan budget cited it as its only evidence on what high debt does to growth.
In Europe, an EU commissioner pointed to the research in a speech. In Britain, George Osborne cited the authors by name.
Herndon was a PhD student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, taking a class called Econ 753: Applied Econometrics. The big assignment was to pick a well-known paper and replicate it.
He picked this one. He couldn't get the same results.
He asked the authors for their spreadsheet, and they sent it. When he spotted the problem, he called his girlfriend over to make sure he wasn't seeing things.
He wasn't.
> One formula stopped five rows short
> That quietly left out five countries: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada and Denmark
> Some available years of data for other countries weren't included
> The way the averages were weighted let a single bad year in one country count as much as decades in another
Herndon and his professors, Michael Ash and Robert Pollin, published the critique in April 2013. Fixing the problems, average growth for the high-debt countries came out to 2.2%, not minus 0.1%.
Reinhart and Rogoff publicly admitted the spreadsheet error. They disputed the other criticisms and defended their broader view. Economists still argue about debt and growth today.
But the formula was wrong, and for about three years nobody had publicly caught it.
A student doing homework did.
Most people assume famous research has been checked many times. Often the first person to really check it is someone with nothing to lose and an assignment due.
Have you ever found a mistake in your boss's spreadsheet and kept quiet? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Daily Show
@TheDailyShow
These conservatives are really going through it
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
To do list for the Eurozone (from 2021):
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7811341/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
There is no "fiscal mess". There is a problem at the ECB which:
A. does not fulfil as expected its role of dealer of last resort for Eurozone government bonds and
B. increases interest rates to fight higher energy prices without any clue how that is supposed to work.
Financial Times
@FT
France and Belgium fall foul of Eurozone bond market’s new divide ft.trib.al/J5N03LD
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Max Constraints @ThePostAustrian
This.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
After 50 years a 6% deficit can leave you with one of three economies.
In one, GDP grows from 150 to 13,500 and the debt ratio settles.
In another it grows even faster because interest payments add extra money.
In the third, the one modern governments prefer, GDP never moves and debt heads for nearly 1400% of GDP.
The difference is not the size of the deficit. It is who buys the bonds.
Sell them to the central bank and money is created.
Sell them to private banks and more money is created.
Sell them to households and firms and the money the deficit just created is cancelled on the spot.
The euro locks every country into the third outcome and then bans the first.
I run the three cases side by side in Ravel©.
P.S. See which system actually works and which one the rules forbid.
#economics #eurozone #governmentdebt #austerity #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mor Edge Insight
@MorEdge_Insight
The British railway networks explained brilliantly 😂
Video credit: British Brainrot on YouTubeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John Cleese
@JohnCleese
The essence of capitalism is competition
Why privatise railways if there is no possibility of competition ?
Because it meant the Tories could reward donors properly
Mor Edge Insight
@MorEdge_Insight
The British railway networks explained brilliantly 😂
Video credit: British Brainrot on YouTubeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The return of austerity also sees the returns of protest of European citizens against it. 🇧🇪
www.brusselstimes.com/brussels/2401188/brussels-unions-to… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ℹ️ Not The Torygraph 💚 #SaveOurNHS #ScrapNHSBill
@TweetForTheMany
And regarding 'regulatory duress' - USA also has contractual obligations attached to primary-dealer status.
US primary dealers (designated by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York) must:
🔲Participate in every Treasury auction and bid for at least their pro-rata share of each offering
🔲Serve as counterparties for the Fed’s open-market operations and provide market information.
🔲Make reasonable markets for the Fed when it acts for foreign official account holders. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
I assume you are not aware of the German context? German economists literally created the post-fascist party AfD.
blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2017/03/11/the-strange-case-of… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steven Boxall
@RegenerationEX
'This is not fiscal discipline. It is an economic straitjacket.'
@JohnHealey_MP
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Governments are borrowing money from you, then wondering why the economy will not grow.
Here is the part nobody tells you:
A government deficit creates money. But when the government sells bonds to households and firms, they use money they already have to buy them.
The deficit creates money. The bond sale cancels it.
So growth stalls, debt rises, and politicians respond by cutting the things that actually make an economy work.
This is not fiscal discipline.
It is an economic straitjacket.
#governmentdebt #austerity #monetarypolicy #economics #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ℹ️ Not The Torygraph 💚 #SaveOurNHS #ScrapNHSBill
@TweetForTheMany
The claim that a primary dealer system exists only in the US is incorrect: the UK Debt Management Office formally designates Gilt-edged Market Makers as primary dealers in gilts, requiring them to participate in auctions, make markets, and meet volume targets, with the same functional role as US primary dealers.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter Davies
@MastermanDavies
27/8/26 Money on the Left: Reclaiming money & banking’s public powers for imaginative intersectional politics.
States issue £$ &, resources permitting, can spend anything. It’s a matter of politics.
But media & politics is captured by oligarchic interests.
moneyontheleft.org/2026/08/27/reclaiming-moneys-public-po… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ShortShort News
@ShortShort_News
もしあなたが政府債務を理解していないなら、あなたはお金について理解していない
─経済学者スティーブ・キーン(ユニヴァーシティ・カレッジ・ロンドン名誉教授)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
After 50 years a 6% deficit can leave you with one of three economies.
In one, GDP grows from 150 to 13,500 and the debt ratio settles.
In another it grows even faster because interest payments add extra money.
In the third, the one modern governments prefer, GDP never moves and debt heads for nearly 1400% of GDP.
The difference is not the size of the deficit. It is who buys the bonds.
Sell them to the central bank and money is created.
Sell them to private banks and more money is created.
Sell them to households and firms and the money the deficit just created is cancelled on the spot.
The euro locks every country into the third outcome and then bans the first.
I run the three cases side by side in Ravel©.
P.S. See which system actually works and which one the rules forbid.
#economics #eurozone #governmentdebt #austerity #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is critically important. Deregulation has really meant letting the finance sector do what it wants. And it wants to get us all in hock to them.
Cetin Ciner @ProfCiner
Do not allow private banks to create money for stock market/real estate speculation. New money only for new/productive investments. That'd resolve dilemmas like this.
Charles McGarraugh
@CMcgarraugh
We live in a K-shaped economy.
The Fed is now going to raise rates and torture the bottom of the K because of an inflation problem that the top of the K has created.
And that's not right. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Eliot Jacobson
@EliotJacobson
Breaking News!
Code UFB!!!
Global total column precipitable water just set a new record high for the month of October, with data going back to 1940, reaching 8.31 standard deviations above the 1940-1969 October average.
These are not "normal times." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Inflation is lifting off and rate hikes have been the hidden driving force that no one is talking about:
youtu.be/mkh_VhrMMiY -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
Damn straight.
This is so vile and shocking, and our prime minister and treasurer have said nothing. Zip. 🤐 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
Thanks Les, I’ve got a good feeling.
The abuse is so bad, and Justice Smith’s original decision was strong and concise.
This was an extract of the misdemeanours that Smith found ATO office, one Mr 𝐀𝐧𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐧𝐲 𝐑𝐚𝐢𝐧𝐬, had committed.
Not pretty stuff. 😳 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
I’m in Brisbane again today for yet another judgment, this one in the matter of 𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧 𝐯 𝐒𝐡𝐞𝐥𝐥 𝐀𝐮𝐬𝐭𝐫𝐚𝐥𝐢𝐚.
It’s never ending institutional shitfuckery, whether public or private.
Article: michaelwest.com.au/court-to-decide-if-legal-privilege-loo…
Justice Soraya Ryan has reserved on whether legal professional privilege can shield sixty-eight documents 𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐦𝐚𝐲 𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐦𝐬𝐞𝐥𝐯𝐞𝐬 𝐛𝐞 𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐛𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐜𝐡𝐞𝐬 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐰𝐡𝐢𝐬𝐭𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐥𝐨𝐰𝐞𝐫 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧𝐬 the 2019 reforms were meant to guarantee.
Shell argues those reforms don’t override privilege.
𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧’𝐬 𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐬𝐞𝐥 𝐢𝐧𝐯𝐨𝐤𝐞𝐝 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐜𝐫𝐢𝐦𝐞-𝐟𝐫𝐚𝐮𝐝 𝐞𝐱𝐜𝐞𝐩𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧. If companies can block access to the very documents that prove retaliation, the law is toothless — that’s the precedent question before the court.
@TroyStolz put it best: “𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘲𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘪𝘴 𝘯𝘰 𝘭𝘰𝘯𝘨𝘦𝘳 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘈𝘶𝘴𝘵𝘳𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘢 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴. 𝘐𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴 𝘸𝘰𝘳𝘬 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘢 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘯𝘦𝘦𝘥𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘮 𝘮𝘰𝘴𝘵.”
Kent is terminally ill. His evidence-in-chief runs to nearly four thousand pages.
He’s due in the witness box from the seventh of December.
#auslaw #auspol #shellaustralia #institutionalshitfuckery #shell #kentquinlan #precedent #whistleblowers
📸 Photo: 15 Sep 2026
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
“𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘲𝘶𝘦𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘪𝘴 𝘯𝘰 𝘭𝘰𝘯𝘨𝘦𝘳 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘈𝘶𝘴𝘵𝘳𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘢 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴. 𝘐𝘵 𝘪𝘴 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘰𝘴𝘦 𝘭𝘢𝘸𝘴 𝘸𝘰𝘳𝘬 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘢 𝘸𝘩𝘪𝘴𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘣𝘭𝘰𝘸𝘦𝘳 𝘯𝘦𝘦𝘥𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘮 𝘮𝘰𝘴𝘵.”
~ @TroyStolz
Link: michaelwest.com.au/court-to-decide-if-legal-privilege-loo…
Thank you @MichaelWestBiz
Six of us in that photo. One fight.
Standing with 𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧 against the same pattern we see in private companies and the public sector: speak up, get named, get punished, then get buried in process.
This has to stop. #whistleblowers
#auspol #shell #𝐊𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐐𝐮𝐢𝐧𝐥𝐚𝐧
@JMwhistleblower @Shell_Australia @uapXThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Modern Macro Technologies
@AppliedMMT
From December 2008 to December 2015, the Fed held rates near zero for 85 straight months.
Inflation averaged 1.4%, and ran below the Fed’s 2% target in 61 of those months.
Charlie Bilello
@charliebilello
68.
As in 68 consecutive months with US inflation above the Fed's 2% target.
Monetary policy remains far too easy. More rate hikes are coming. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is critically important. Deregulation has really meant letting the finance sector do what it wants. And it wants to get us all in hock to them.
Cetin Ciner @ProfCiner
Do not allow private banks to create money for stock market/real estate speculation. New money only for new/productive investments. That'd resolve dilemmas like this.
Charles McGarraugh
@CMcgarraugh
We live in a K-shaped economy.
The Fed is now going to raise rates and torture the bottom of the K because of an inflation problem that the top of the K has created.
And that's not right. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
michael mezz
@michaelmezz
Inflation and rising inequality go hand-in-hand: When price shocks for life’s essentials lead to higher corporate profits, wealth is being redistributed from the working class to the owners of capital.
@IsabellaMWeber on the Better Future PodcastThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Higher rates mean higher cost of doing business, but higher rates also mean a massive fiscal add to support the higher cost.
We are now in the early innings of a rate induced inflationary cycle. At this point, hikes are acting pro-cyclically, not counter.
Modern Macro Technologies
@AppliedMMT
"Sticky" inflation continues as Core CPI rose +0.3% in October vs +0.2% expected.
Treasury has paid $583.9 billion of interest on securities YTD, up from $506.9 billion during the same period last year (+15.2%).
Rate hikes won't fix inflation. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
After 50 years a 6% deficit can leave you with one of three economies.
In one, GDP grows from 150 to 13,500 and the debt ratio settles.
In another it grows even faster because interest payments add extra money.
In the third, the one modern governments prefer, GDP never moves and debt heads for nearly 1400% of GDP.
The difference is not the size of the deficit. It is who buys the bonds.
Sell them to the central bank and money is created.
Sell them to private banks and more money is created.
Sell them to households and firms and the money the deficit just created is cancelled on the spot.
The euro locks every country into the third outcome and then bans the first.
I run the three cases side by side in Ravel©.
P.S. See which system actually works and which one the rules forbid.
#economics #eurozone #governmentdebt #austerity #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, refer to my video presentation : www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hussain “Hoz” Shafiei
@HussainShafiei
I’m gonna bed nice and early, so I can get up and take part in this space with Ian Malcolm and the rest of my people.
Good night from Tehran. Lots of love to you all. I feel a lot better than I have felt ever since the elections have finished in America, which a lot of us thought was gonna be the start of the war again. I think Donald Trump is listening to the electorate and that is the wisest thing he can do.
I don’t think Tucker Carlson’s tweet about nuclear weapons made me feel any better, but I’m glad that cooler heads are beginning to win over the warmongers.
See you all in the morning in the space. That’s 6 hours from now, @DanBilzerian hope to see you there in about 6 1/2 hours.
x.com/i/spaces/1ReMlMpLBOjonq -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
He's 21 tomorrow. He's got some worries, but the national debt isn't one of them.
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
Shameless.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Eliot Jacobson
@EliotJacobson
Here's another view of the record-setting atmospheric water vapor for October, this time excluding the North/South poles. The latest data for 2026 was 7.97 standard deviations above the 1940-1969 baseline.
In practice, this means record flooding will continue to accelerate. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr. Genevieve Guenther (she / they)
@DoctorVive
It’s his asking questions like this which justifies calling Matt Yglesias a climate denier. 🤷♀️
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Why are pipelines "evil"?
What kind of economic populism thinks it's bad for people in the northeastern United States to get access to cheaper electricity? Is this even bad on environmental grounds given the upside to electric cars and heat pumps?
Jeff Hauser
@jeffhauser
Absolutely no one could have predicted.
The tools that stop everything from evil pipelines to fascistic detention centers to be traded away for.... some transmission improvements that could be the subject of a transmission only bill and likely receive veto proof majority.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Q: Will you approve wind turbines?
TRUMP: No I will not
Q: Well that's part of this permitting bill
TRUMP: It hasn't been fully negotiated. Wind turbines are a major loser. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Last night, between consulting projects, I decided to have a little fun and build a system dynamics model of political election cycles. What started as a fairly simple experiment turned into something considerably more interesting, and it may eventually find its way onto @GDPDynamics.
The model is built around essentially four agents: three political parties, Left, Right, and Centre, and a general voting population. Each political party has one objective, to win an election and remain in office for as many consecutive terms as possible. The voting population has an equally simple objective, to elect whichever party they are least dissatisfied with, or conversely, the party they are most satisfied with.
Each political party has a direct rival. Left competes with Right, Right competes with Centre, and Centre competes with Left. Dissatisfaction with one party influences dissatisfaction with its rival, creating a continuous feedback structure between all three parties. These relationships are nonlinear, meaning a change in dissatisfaction doesn't necessarily produce a proportional response elsewhere in the system.
The model doesn't need an external political cycle imposed on it. The interactions between the parties themselves can generate the changing political conditions that eventually determine election outcomes. Add the fact that elections occur at fixed intervals, and you get a political system capable of producing irregular changes in government, including periods where one party remains in office for several consecutive terms.
My underlying thesis, or perhaps more accurately my mental model of electoral politics, is that every incumbent government starts a dissatisfaction clock the moment it takes office. Sometimes that clock runs slowly, allowing a party to govern for several terms. Other times it runs considerably faster, and the government finds itself thrown out after a single term. The important point is that the clock is always running.
A party enters government with public expectations, makes decisions, disappoints some voters, accumulates political baggage, and gradually becomes less attractive relative to the opposition. Meanwhile, the parties outside government benefit from not being responsible for governing, allowing dissatisfaction with them to dissipate. Eventually, the political balance shifts enough for another party to take office, and the process begins again.
What I'm exploring is whether this process is fundamentally endogenous to the political system itself.
We tend to explain election results through individual policies, political controversies, scandals, personalities, economic conditions, and whatever happens to dominate the news during an election campaign. I'm not suggesting these things have no consequences. Obviously they do.
But my suspicion is that many of these events are simply the visible expressions, accelerators, or convenient explanations for an underlying process of accumulating dissatisfaction. Specific policies and scandals may be less important to the long-run evolution of political power than the feedback mechanisms that make incumbent governments increasingly vulnerable over time.
In other words, the political controversy of the day might explain how a government loses an election without necessarily explaining why the political system repeatedly produces dissatisfied electorates looking for alternatives.
I've deliberately kept the model abstract. There are no named politicians, no specific policy platforms, and no assumptions that one political ideology is inherently more successful than another. The dynamics come from the interactions between the parties, the accumulation and dissipation of dissatisfaction, and the electoral decisions of the voting population.
The result is a small nonlinear system dynamics model capable of generating surprisingly complex political behavior from a handful of relatively simple relationships. I've also been experimenting with whether those interactions can produce endogenous chaotic behavior, where very small differences in initial political conditions eventually lead to very different election histories.
Of course, this is still an experimental model, not a validated theory of electoral politics. The assumptions need testing, and producing interesting mathematical behavior is not the same thing as explaining actual elections.
But that's the fun of system dynamics. You can start with a relatively simple mental model of how you think a system operates, express those relationships mathematically, and discover what behavior actually emerges from their interaction.
I may develop this further and eventually add it to @GDPDynamics, where people could experiment with political dissatisfaction, party rivalry, election intervals, and incumbency effects themselves.
Also another side note while any system dynamic software can achieve this type of modeling I chose to use my friend and mentors @ProfSteveKeen Ravel software. I may also post this model file on the GDP Dynamics Patreon at some point.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Shallow State
@OurShallowState
NARCISSISTIC MORTIFICATION: It's not surprising that in his recent 60 Minutes interview, Trump again began speaking about "getting into heaven" versus the alternative. I've had a week to observe his behavior following the nationwide beatdown of him during the midterms. I believe he is officially undergoing Narcissistic Mortification.
Narcissistic Mortification is when a narcissist like Trump crosses over to a place where he sees visions of his own demise (thus 'getting into heaven'). Age and ill health play a role, but it's deeper than that. It's what happens after extreme fear morphs into dread and dread morphs into terror - LOSING - and humiliation.
As Trump's polling kept tanking leading up to the midterms, his fears became extreme and then "dread." And the results were as bad as they could be for him. It's not just that the GOP lost, it's that HE was so clearly responsible. HE was at fault. HE told people to vote as if he is on the ballot, and they did. It led to a terrible reality FOR HIM, one that was forced UPON HIM, not of HIS making. He can't have that!
For a malignant narcissist, THE most extreme fear of all is ultimate irrevocable humiliation - borne of one's faults.
In more psychological terms, narcissistic mortification is when one with a rigidly grandiose pathology sees his sense of self as exposed, defective or inferior. It was coined by Freud in his book Moses and Monotheism. It's described there as deep injuries to ego/self, triggered by ONE'S OWN compulsiveness (aka insisting on Paxton as a candidate) and ONE'S OWN weaknesses (being insensitive to voter issues during rallies).
THIS is where I think he is. He's become his own worst enemy, and this squarely conflicts with his pathology of being unable to admit fault. It's a very severe and very dissonant conflict.
Because ... malignant narcissists NEED their grandiosity. For them to become exposed and weakened, is narcissistic injury - that happens. BUT - for them to become SO weakened to the extent of being able to visualize their own demise and know it's partly due to their own frailties - frailties they spend a lifetime avoiding and denying - this is irreconcilable. For a malignant narcissist like Trump, it's hell.
It causes him to become even more sensitized ("that was a stupid question"), more defensive (like he is about "crowd size" - now the symbol of his fading grandiosity), and more defiant (hiring Miller as COS). It has made him physically haggard (he looks gaunt and hunched, with swollen eyes and stiff facial muscles).
Trump lives in such a bubble, it's hard to predict how he processes things. Freud suggested that narcissistic mortification can be a precursor to panic or to narcissistic collapse.
fyi: There actually IS a wiki page for narcissistic mortification (which surprised me) and here's an interesting sentence from it, that I thought I'd echo here: Narcissistic Mortification is "the primitive terror of self-dissolution, triggered by the sudden exposure of one's sense of a defective self ... to a narcissist, it is death by embarrassment." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hoops Kevinski @HoopsKev
OMG, someone tell Buffett that $350B of his money has been "cancelled"!
(Perfect surname: Warren "buffs" it - the bond system - which needs the opposite, to be permanently "nerfed"). -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
Charlie Chaplin felt so strongly about fighting nazism against Germany in 1940 that he broke his silence for the first time ever to deliver this monologue.
"The Great Dictator", released that year, was the first time he had spoken in a talking role. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
This is absolutely right. I would add that government bonds gift big investors - eg commercial banks, asset managers, insurance companies - guaranteed income streams paid by fiat issue that could be directly invested in infrastructure, utilities and public services. This guaranteed income is the ultimate collateral which big finance can leverage for derivatives, repos and risk portfolios. Each nation trapped under money-market discipline is providing the creditor class with a solid platform for their gambling rather than making its country a better place for ordinary people to live in. It's history's biggest financial scam, folks - 900 year vintage - and our politicians are allowing it to crush our potential.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Governments are borrowing money from you, then wondering why the economy will not grow.
Here is the part nobody tells you:
A government deficit creates money. But when the government sells bonds to households and firms, they use money they already have to buy them.
The deficit creates money. The bond sale cancels it.
So growth stalls, debt rises, and politicians respond by cutting the things that actually make an economy work.
This is not fiscal discipline.
It is an economic straitjacket.
#governmentdebt #austerity #monetarypolicy #economics #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cem Oyvat @cemoyvat
The funny thing is that Reinhart & Rogoff's American Economic Review paper has not been retracted following the Excel error scandal. It indeed continues to receive a significant number of citations (6,575 to date), and its citation rate did not fall after the scandal; in fact, it has started to rise again.
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.100.2.573
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
A 28-year-old UMass graduate student got a homework assignment to reproduce a famous economics paper, couldn't make the numbers match, and found a spreadsheet mistake in a study that politicians had used to argue for budget cuts.
His name is Thomas Herndon.
In 2010, two Harvard economists, Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, published a short paper called Growth in a Time of Debt. Its headline finding: once a country's public debt goes above 90% of its economy, growth falls off a cliff. In their numbers, average growth for that group was minus 0.1%.
It came out right after the 2008 financial crisis, and it spread fast. In the US, the Paul Ryan budget cited it as its only evidence on what high debt does to growth.
In Europe, an EU commissioner pointed to the research in a speech. In Britain, George Osborne cited the authors by name.
Herndon was a PhD student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, taking a class called Econ 753: Applied Econometrics. The big assignment was to pick a well-known paper and replicate it.
He picked this one. He couldn't get the same results.
He asked the authors for their spreadsheet, and they sent it. When he spotted the problem, he called his girlfriend over to make sure he wasn't seeing things.
He wasn't.
> One formula stopped five rows short
> That quietly left out five countries: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada and Denmark
> Some available years of data for other countries weren't included
> The way the averages were weighted let a single bad year in one country count as much as decades in another
Herndon and his professors, Michael Ash and Robert Pollin, published the critique in April 2013. Fixing the problems, average growth for the high-debt countries came out to 2.2%, not minus 0.1%.
Reinhart and Rogoff publicly admitted the spreadsheet error. They disputed the other criticisms and defended their broader view. Economists still argue about debt and growth today.
But the formula was wrong, and for about three years nobody had publicly caught it.
A student doing homework did.
Most people assume famous research has been checked many times. Often the first person to really check it is someone with nothing to lose and an assignment due.
Have you ever found a mistake in your boss's spreadsheet and kept quiet? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur oPt
@FranceskAlbs
Reasonable people say it plainly. It is not about being anti-corporations but about making sure that big corporations (big tech, big pharma, big insurance, big consultancies) do not control markets and especially politics.
News to Remember
@allchronology
Listen to this. And then listen again. And again. Until you get it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And here's the link: youtu.be/obO1pieuldg
Emer O'Siochru
@eosfuturedesign
Very counterintuitive to learn about the money reality so @ProfSteveKeen has created an IT model of the internal workings of money system, public and private, that proves his explanation is correct and the current one is just wrong
Impress your friends with insider knowledge
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Governments are borrowing money from you, then wondering why the economy will not grow.
Here is the part nobody tells you:
A government deficit creates money. But when the government sells bonds to households and firms, they use money they already have to buy them.
The deficit creates money. The bond sale cancels it.
So growth stalls, debt rises, and politicians respond by cutting the things that actually make an economy work.
This is not fiscal discipline.
It is an economic straitjacket.
#governmentdebt #austerity #monetarypolicy #economics #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Un Marc Cerrudo
@nonantlemarc
Michael Palin, dels Monty Python, estava enfadadíssim en aquest debat sobre 'La vida de Brian', però mireu com en el moment de màxima indignació (5:25) fa servir l'humor per deixar en evidència les idees retrògrades del seu interlocutor. Ai, Broncano.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Weber didn't claim that. He argued for wertfreiheit to be adopted as a rule in all social scientific inquiry. Of course it never was. Neoclassicism's claim is ludicrous - blind to its own baked-in ideology.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Oooh this is hot! 🤣
Four Seasons Total Landscaping
@TotalSeasons
It's finished for you.
I guess you rubbed people up the wrong way. Mostly in theaters.
Lauren Boebert
@laurenboebert
Election week isn’t finished!
Let’s finish counting every vote and hearing every voice before declaring anything. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Slightly more than half of European firms say that a lack of demand for their products or services is an obstacle to investment. The EU needs better macroeconomic policies. In this case, more aggregate demand is called for while the ECB hikes interest rates and governments cut spending because of "excessive" deficits and public debt. This is a dysfunctional arrangement and will lead to higher unemployment.
www.eib.org/files/publications/20260192-091126-eib-group-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Baki Demirel @profbakidemirel
Miktar kuramının totolojiden ibaret olduğu su götürmez bir gerçek. Başka bir konu daha var. Cochrane de belirtmiş. Korelasyon nedenselliği göstermez. Enflasyonla para arzı arasındaki ilişkinin yönü ahmak monetaristlerin söylediği gibi para arzından enflasyona göre değil daha güçlü biçimde enflasyondan para arzına doğrudur.
Çünkü enflasyon para talebini o da para arzını artırır
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
M= PY/V or PY = MV? You'd think after decades of extremely sophisticated causal econometrics, the most basic correlation isn't causation of all would not keep resurfacing. Money tracks nominal income in every theory, including FTPL, because central banks supply money passively, and demand is proportional to nominal income. Rich guys drive Porsches. Drive a Porsche and you'll get rich!
Lars Christensen
@MaMoMVPY
INFLATION IS STILL A MONETARY PHENOMENON
I have looked at 42 countries since December 2019. For each one I compared how much faster broad money has grown than the real economy with how high inflation has been.
The slope is 0.50 – one percentage point more money growth a year has meant roughly half a percentage point more inflation.
R² is 0.57 – differences in money growth explain 57% of the differences in inflation across countries.
The countries that printed the most money got the most inflation. Switzerland and Japan, where money barely outgrew the economy, got the least.
The US sits just above the line. The euro area sits almost on it.
So forget supply chain disruptions and greedflation – that was always nonsense. Supply shocks change relative prices. They do not create years of broad-based inflation across 42 countries.
It is money, and it still is. Nominal spending remains excessive across the world, and that is what is keeping inflation elevated everywhere. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
1. PUBLIC STATEMENT: WE DON'T WANT COP, WE WANT REVOLUTION.
LET US SPEAK PLAINLY AT THIS POINT IN HISTORY: ANY INDIVIDUAL OR ORGANISATION ATTENDING THE 2026 COP EVENT IS COMPLICIT IN THE GREATEST GENOCIDE IMPOSED BY THE RICH UPON THE POOR IN HUMAN HISTORY.
THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO EXCUSE FOR REACHING ANY OTHER CONCLUSION AFTER 30 YEARS OF LIES AND DECEITS. COP EXISTS TO DISTRACT AND DISPRESS. LIBERALS THAT INSIST OTHERWISE ARE THE GREATEST BLOCK TO THE REVOLUTIONARY MOBILISATION MORALLY AND STRATEGICALLY ESSENTIAL AT THIS TIME.
WHAT WE NEED IS A GLOBAL REVOLUTION NOT TO DEMAND THAT REGIMES SLASH CARBON EMISSIONS BUT THAT THEY ARE REMOVED FROM POWER AND REPLACED BY LEGALLY BINDING CITIZENS' ASSEMBLIES - ORDINARY PEOPLE WHO WILL DECIDE WHETHER THEY WISH TO LIVE OR DIE - NOT THE LYING POLITICIANS WHO HAVE FAILED US AND NO LONGER HAVE ANY LEGITIMACY TO RULE US.
THIS CAN HAPPEN IN AN ORDERED AND NONVIOLENT WAY OR WE CAN WAIT UNTIL THE SYSTEM COLLAPSES INTO TOTAL CHAOS AND UTTER HELL. THESE ARE THE ONLY TWO OPTIONS AVAILABLE TO HUMANKIND FROM 2026 ONWARDS.
(Cont.)
www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/nov/09/cop31-climate… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
Huge drop in UK cereal harvest compared to 1984 - the first year of records
We have been able to make up shortfalls with imports, but as harvests are hit worldwide, countries will hang on to what they have
Grim times a'comin -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
The climate doesn't recognise any sort of pragmatism
It only recognises CO2
We are already locked-in to a return to Pliocene conditions - 3C+ hotter and sea level, eventually, 15 - 25m higher. This is the BEST case
We actually need to be on a war footing -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
Just in case, someone, like @v_x did not get it: all the protests across Europe are, at heart, anti-war protests.
People are saying: we want pensions, student grants, holidays. We want to study, raise children, play music and dance.
We do NOT want to build tanks and drones, kill children or bomb cities.
We don’t believe you when you tell us: “If we don’t wipe them out (terrorists, autocrats, barbarians — tick as appropriate), they’ll come and wipe us out.”
You’re lying to us. You’re lying to us.
You believe in life organised around violence, plunder and domination. We believe in life organised around life itself.
You live in a world where everyone is at war with everyone else. West against East. South against North. Christians against Muslims. Israel against the whole world. Rich against Poor and you and us against each other.
You live in a world of bombs, spies, enemies and foreign agents. We live in a world where none of that exists.
Our worlds are incompatible.
and.. you’re killing us.
meanwhile:
“I know spending more on defence means spending less on other priorities.” — NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte, 12 December 2024. He went on to name pensions, health and social security.
www.nato.int/en/news-and-events/events/transcripts/2024/1… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
Happy Birthday, Carl.
You taught millions of us that being small is not the same as being unimportant. You taught us to be citizens of the cosmos, to be curious, to doubt loudly, and to be gentle with each other on this pale blue dot we call home.
We are still looking up. We are still asking. And in this cold, indifferent universe, your voice is one of the warmest things we return to, again and again. It reminds us to be kind, to hold on to our humanity, to keep the candle from guttering out in the dark, and to keep reaching until one day we stand among the stars.
Happy Birthday, and thank you for everything. 💙 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Martin Tye
@martinrev21
Let's think about the word "unsustainable"- so common now it's lost its impact.
But "unsustainable" means it WILL end & if not in a managed way- then thru collapse: famine, wars, mass deaths & untold sufferings.
"Unsustainable" is a word which should fill you with dread.John Peter Steley @JohnSteley
The clue is in the word: sustainable. Anything MORE than sustainable is UNSUSTAINABLE. Our thinking should start there. All problems have to be solved within that context.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sandeep Vaheesan
@sandeepvaheesan
OP's reasonable and modest point invited some aggressive defenses of mainstream economics. Such attraction to economic orthodoxy is likely not on account of its substantive merits or track record (both poor) but instead has much to do with what Keynes said about Ricardianism.
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Economic populism also means dethroning economics. It’s not the job of economists to dictate how our economies should be run but to find solutions to implement democratically determined goals.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
New home page at gdpdynamics.com
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, check out this video presentation : www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Governments are borrowing money from you, then wondering why the economy will not grow.
Here is the part nobody tells you:
A government deficit creates money. But when the government sells bonds to households and firms, they use money they already have to buy them.
The deficit creates money. The bond sale cancels it.
So growth stalls, debt rises, and politicians respond by cutting the things that actually make an economy work.
This is not fiscal discipline.
It is an economic straitjacket.
#governmentdebt #austerity #monetarypolicy #economics #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Governments are borrowing money from you, then wondering why the economy will not grow.
Here is the part nobody tells you:
A government deficit creates money. But when the government sells bonds to households and firms, they use money they already have to buy them.
The deficit creates money. The bond sale cancels it.
So growth stalls, debt rises, and politicians respond by cutting the things that actually make an economy work.
This is not fiscal discipline.
It is an economic straitjacket.
#governmentdebt #austerity #monetarypolicy #economics #stevekeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For a more comprehensive understanding, check out this video presentation : www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
In 1944, Hayek wrote The Road to Serfdom warning about government controlling the economy.
That same year, Karl Polanyi wrote The Great Transformation warning about the economy controlling society.
Guess which one libertarians turned into a fucking religion. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ryan Maue
@RyanWeather
⚠️We've been warning about this for months. The Super El Niño is the most powerful since the Little Ice Age, and 16th Century when Magellan and Sir Francis Drake explored the Pacific Ocean.🌎
In the 1500s, European temperatures collapsed, grain could not grow, and everyone starved. 🥔
We're now in uncharted territory coming out of the coldest centuries in past 8,000 years. While this El Niño will not bring famine inducing cold shocks, we can expect "climate fueled" weather extremes to roil our planet even during Northern Hemisphere winter.
António Guterres
@antonioguterres
We've entered a new age of climate extremes:
A supersized El Niño is colliding with a planet already superheated by climate change.
The latest @WMO report shows once again that leaders must get serious by cutting emissions faster, accelerating a just transition from fossil fuels & delivering the finance & protection vulnerable countries need.
wmo.int/news/media-centre/state-of-climate-2026-gives-new… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Auskar Surbakti
@AuskarSurbakti
An incredible finale to #trtworldforum2026!
Thanks to @memetsimsek, @TarekMitri, @A_Gurria, Fabian Zuleeg & @ProfSteveKeen for a powerful discussion on rebuilding post-conflict economies, restoring trust, attracting investment and creating lasting prosperity 🌍🤝 @trtworldforum -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
No one puts together a presentation like @RevHierophant . Grad students in the @modernmoneylab get the full experience. The rest of us can scroll through on our own. drive.google.com/file/d/1pG4xiFsMJC3x-wZ2ASkgzRwsJGlpRTOZ…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
Steve Keen, 2–9 Nov 2026
Book: How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism (Polity) still forthcoming. No new edition or Amazon listing. Manuscript earlier completed; possible Feb 2027.
Serialised chapter
• “The Sixth Mass Extinction?”, Ch. 24, 6 Nov. Paywalled after free teaser. profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-sixth-mass-extinction Mechanism: climate models (rate of warming vs past extinctions). Current anthropogenic rate (~6000°C/Myr) is slower than the K-Pg event but faster than the Permian–Triassic and Triassic–Jurassic; tables compare levels and rates. Description of paleoclimate data. Prescription (treat as non-trivial) is separate. Core extinction-risk framing is longstanding/recycled.
Substack/Patreon posts
• “How To Handle Government Debt”, 6 Nov. Substantial free content (Patreon equivalent). profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-debt Mechanism: endogenous money (deficits create private deposits via double-entry bookkeeping; bond sales to non-banks cancel the creation). Ravel simulations of three bond-sale options for a 6% deficit: direct to central bank stabilises debt ~67% of GDP with growth; to banks boosts GDP more (via interest); to non-banks freezes GDP and drives debt toward ~1400% of GDP. Description of accounting identities and simulations. Prescriptions (sell bonds to CB, run deficits to fund education, leave the Euro) are listed separately. Core argument is longstanding/recycled from prior posts and videos.
Interviews/talks
• China News Network / ecns.cn News Lounge, ~6 Nov: one reason for China’s success is avoiding mainstream Western economic “nonsense”; ignore overcapacity talk and continue current path; fallout from the ongoing global crisis will persist for years. www.ecns.cn/video/2026-11-06/detail-ihfmuiku4867424.shtml Mechanism: endogenous money / private-debt dynamics (contrast with Western models). Description of China’s approach versus Western chaos. Prescription (“continue doing what you’re doing”) is separate. Themes longstanding.
YouTube (@profstevekeen)
• 8 Nov: “Financial Crash Expert: The Europe Crisis is About to get Much Worse” (23:48). Same endogenous-money + Euro/bond-sale Ravel material as the 6 Nov post. www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg
No new Ravel or Minsky releases. X activity is routine links and RTs of the abov -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Totally agree. If a 19th century Machiavelli had wanted to cripple the intelligentsia of the working class, he could have invented no better weapon than the Labor Theory of Value.
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Actually, Michal Kalecki was a Marxist. Unfortunately, Marxists have become so bogged down in endless debates over the scientific validity of the labor theory of value, the problems arising from it, and, of course, trying to debunk MMT 😁 that they simply have no energy left for anything else.
But the funny thing is that if a Marxist ever comes to power anywhere, they’ll be doomed to implement standard Keynesian economic policies. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
67% of GDP is not a crisis.
It is simply the inverse of money velocity when a government deficit creates money.
The Euro forces every country to sell its bonds to the private sector.
That single rule cancels the money creation a deficit actually produces and turns a manageable situation into an exploding debt ratio.
I show the three systems side by side with Ravel©.
For a more comprehensive understanding, check out the video presentation given below.
#stevekeen #euro #economics #governmentdebt www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
November 3rd saw the highest temperature on record for our rapidly heating planet equalled - at 2.04C above pre-industrial
The 2C mark will be exceeded ever more frequently until it is crossed permanently in the late 2030s, if not earlier -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Can economics fight fascism? With Isabella Weber
www.ft.com/content/6b969bcb-9c5c-4a6a-9143-2c5c593abd6e?s… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
To turn a blue wave into a lasting victory for democracy Democrats have to adopt an anti-fascist economics. I discussed with @MESandbu what this takes for the @FT Economics Show. Wonderfully nuanced conversation. Thank you!
🔗 Read or listen via the link below. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephan Pastis
@stephanpastis
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Coco the Canadian Socialist Rat🇨🇦 🇨🇦
@RJ_Macnaughton
All you need to know is the Nobel Economic prize was created by the central bank of Switzerland. Milton Freedom won the Noble prize a few years after it was created.
Not a single Chinese economist has ever won the prize 🤦♂️ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Seven Identification Problems in New Keynesian Macroeconomics
Article 2 presents a substantial challenge to the empirical identification practices
commonly employed in New Keynesian (NK) macroeconomics.
drive.google.com/file/d/1zA9ThiO5Wz7ztbgj6fZXol81Sw726stj… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
The European Crisis Is About to Get Much Worse @ProfSteveKeen
This explainer breaks down the euro crisis, the eurozone crisis, the European debt crisis, government debt explained, fiscal policy vs monetary policy, central bank bond buying,...
youtu.be/obO1pieuldg -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Clint Ballinger
@clintballinger
Mainstream economists must favor income "redistribution," ("re" from what??) since their models only work with it, as Samuelson admits:
"Income must always be reallocated...so as to keep the 'marginal social significance of every dollar' equal" -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Clint Ballinger
@clintballinger
I was just talking about how the last few generations don’t even know what they don’t know. The ~1970s hiding of things worked. They achieved by converting the complex/political things into obscure technical phrases; current economists know the terms, don’t grasp what is hidden
Clint Ballinger
@clintballinger
Mainstream economists must favor income "redistribution," ("re" from what??) since their models only work with it, as Samuelson admits:
"Income must always be reallocated...so as to keep the 'marginal social significance of every dollar' equal" -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Democrats Begin Search for Insipid, Establishment Candidate To Squander Momentous Call for Change theshovel.com.au/2026/11/09/democrats-begin-search-for-in…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Seyed Mohammad Marandi
@s_m_marandi
Trump says, "We have 38 bridges in our site that we can knock down in literally one hour. They'll all be down."
Iran says Trump will never see the day the US recovers from the catastrophic economic depression the Islamic Republic will impose upon it in case of aggression. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A beautiful rendition of the folly of war. Should be sung to the tune of Tracy Chapman's "Fast Car"
Madelaine Hanson
@MadelaineLucyH
Here is a gun, said a father, to son
Put your hand on the trigger, press it, then run
And aim it at the heads of the boys
You call friends, and laugh and find fun
In imaginary deaths
Yes, here is a gun, said a father, to son
You’re older now, we’ll have fatherly fun
And teach you to shoot straight at
The heart, of those faceless bodies slumped
Up from afar
And here is a gun, said a father, to son
Carry it with pride until glory is won
How grown up you look in your bulletproof vest
Ready to shoot at the rich men’s behest
Oh, how very sad, said a father, to son
That you are now buried, forgotten and gone
Filled up with lead on a forgotten shore
Where did you learn there would
Be fun in war? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gov. William J. LePetomane @JeffreyAlan95
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Novara Media
@novaramedia
"Put all these together: climate change, food supply, war in Iran, oil, and AI. If they were all to happen together, this is cataclysmic."
Accountant, economist and whistleblower @RichardJMurphy foresaw the 2008 financial crash. On Downstream this week, he warns @AaronBastani of the coming AI 'meltdown', and how it could intersect with a range of other looming crises.
Watch the full episode of Downstream on our YouTube channel.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Published in 2020, but still worth thinking about:
1. Increase the Maastricht deficit limit from 3% to 13%
7. Implement a permanent, legally enforceable ECB guarantee of all member nations' public debt.
8. Commit to a long-term ECB 0% rate policy.
braveneweurope.com/economics/dirk-ehnts-warren-mosler-a-e… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Seyed Abbas Araghchi
@araghchi
American voters have made their choice. Time for the White House to make its own.
Our 2-day proposal stands: meet the requirements, including end to war on all fronts, and you will see results.
Or choose war, and see our alert and battle-hardened Warriors rain down hell. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Shallow State
@OurShallowState
Now that we've learned that our idiot President mistook which Dana White was who Susie Wiles recommended for Press Secretary AND did it publicly with his usual bluster and overreach, he can't very well offer the position to the correct, more qualified Dana White, because to do so, exposes and confirms his idiocy.
This "causal progression of idiocy" - which happens constantly on matters large and small - is a true phenomenon of Trump 2.0. It can only happen when an aberrant pathology is allowed to amass so much power and yet is left so unchecked.
It's why this era will be the subject of Case Studies in graduate level psychology courses for the next century. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Aaron Bastani
@AaronBastani
Whistleblower Accountant: ‘I Predicted 2008, This Will Be WORSE’
My conversation with @RichardJMurphy is live. youtu.be/oMhT6qw8KGE -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Is the arrogance of neoclassical economists an externality of their training, or just selection bias?
I'm starting to suspect it's a model assumption: Homo egonomicus -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
67% of GDP is not a crisis.
It is simply the inverse of money velocity when a government deficit creates money.
The Euro forces every country to sell its bonds to the private sector.
That single rule cancels the money creation a deficit actually produces and turns a manageable situation into an exploding debt ratio.
I show the three systems side by side with Ravel©.
For a more comprehensive understanding, check out the video presentation given below.
#stevekeen #euro #economics #governmentdebt www.youtube.com/watch?v=obO1pieuldg -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Whistleblower Accountant: ‘I Predicted 2008, This Will Be WORSE’: Aaron Bastani and I discuss the world as it is and will be in this Downtream interview, out now. youtu.be/oMhT6qw8KGE
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MOH @mohmdmahdig
اگر یک پیتزا سفارش بدید که شعاعش z باشه و ضخامتش a، حجمش دقیقا میشه : pi.z.z.a
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Full video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JeplRmADW3E
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
海兰珠(Victoria) @jinwang69489102
海外一帮人喊了那么多年老中是独裁政府,人民手里没有选票
现在老中晒手里的选票了,一帮人又开始喊这选票无用,无法更换执政党
那帮人用西方的多党制为尺去量老中的共产党执政,得出的结果即是即便老中搞了选举投票,老中依然不是皿煮国家
问题是衡量一国是否民主的标准并不在于几党执政
如果多党制能证明一国民主,那法国第四共和国就是地球上最成功的国家
现实却是在 1946 年到 1958 年的短短 12 年期间,法兰西出现了 21 任政府,六大主要政党轮番更迭,每任政府都仅有短短几个月的任期,到 1958 年,政府既无力影响阿尔及尔的兵变,又无法稳定国内政治。不得不重新起草宪法,宣布第四共和国的垮台。
那么法兰西第五共和国就好起来了吗?并没有,它也没法完全克服多党碎片化带来的问题——尤其是当中间派不再强大、左右两极都拒绝合作的时候。各个政党的首要矛盾不是解决国家不断衰弱的主要矛盾,而是专注于多党内斗。2024 年马克龙内阁倒台后,中间派的马克龙阵营与左翼联盟、极右翼国民联盟,就在削减预算和养老金改革这两件事上从 24 年吵到了 26 年的今天依然没有结果。就算是法国人走上街头打砸的时候,这点事到今天依然悬而未决,没有拍板。
而这个被称为独裁政府的老中十年来干了什么?
将 900 万贪官拉下马
近亿人脱贫
新能源汽车、光伏、电池、高铁装备等领域成为全球领先或主力出口方向
5G、部分AI应用、工业互联网等推进较快,处于世界领先水平
不止如此…
所以我说真民主不在于有多少个政党,而是在于执政党能否听取人民的声音,选择正确的方向且坚持不懈地发展下去并尽可能修正此前的一切错误,这才是真正的民主
而那些个执着于政党数量多少才算民主的人,这只是像我开篇说的那样,他们在用西式的多党制民主为尺去量老共,那无论如何丈量,都会一叶障目,他们只在乎民主的外形,而不在乎民主带给普通人真实且实在的好处。如果他们真的在意的是后者,绝不会得出多党制才是民主的唯一解法 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Otter
@otterlycorrect
I went from disillusioned libertarian to reading Marx and realizing both were retarded. Maybe try reading some Galbraith or @ProfSteveKeen.
Noah Khrachvik
@khrachvik
I’ve never met a single libertarian with the balls to actually study Marx that didn’t come away agreeing.
Every single one that criticizes Marxism is afraid to do that.
Every single one. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Have a listen because this is unerringly correct. The only quibble I have is that it's not like a cult, it IS a cult, an unreal mythology imposed on the management of Western economies by Anglicised Protestantism. It deified the saver/investor and profaned the worker/debtor.
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Economist @ProfSteveKeen has a provocative take on neoclassical economics: “The most dangerous cult is the one that doesn’t realize it’s a cult.”
Read more: evonomics.com/why-economists-have-to-embrace-complexity-s…
Full video in comments.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Heterodox economics faces a “fatal challenge”, according to @jasonfurman.
The reality, as James K. Galbraith explains, is that “mainstream” neoliberal economics is profoundly insecure and no longer has a core that’s holding it together.
Both are political because economics always is. The question is whose side are you on. Anti-fascist Economics serves common people.
It “presents concrete proposals for ensuring an affordable, tolerable, sustainable economic life—the popular demand in Europe and in America that will shape our politics in the foreseeable future.”
www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/mainstream-economics… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Afshin Rattansi
@afshinrattansi
Prof. Steve Keen: ‘FAMINES UNAVOIDABLE because of Strait of Hormuz closure. Up to 2 BILLION could starve.’
‘The extent to which we’re reliant upon chemical fertilisers derived from oil feedstock is extremely high. In the absence of the Haber-Bosch process and the process for producing both nitrogenous fertilisers and phosphate-based fertilisers, without the oil, you can’t produce them.
And 30% of the world’s fertiliser passes through the Strait of Hormuz, roughly speaking.
Now, without the fertiliser in general, the carrying capacity of the planet falls from about 8.5 billion people, which is how many people we have right now, down to between 1 and 2 billion. That’s the extent to which we’re reliant upon petroleum-based fertilisers for food output.
If you lose 30% of the fertiliser that the planet relies upon, at the extreme that implies that something of the order of only 6 billion people can be supported by our food systems, down from the current 8.5 to 9 billion people we’re supporting now.
There is some buffer inside there in terms of roughly 30% of food being wasted. But the extent to which we rely upon a continuous flow of petroleum-based fertilisers cannot be overestimated.
And if we have a disruption to the supply of those fertilisers, anywhere from 10 or 20 million people through to the ludicrous scale, I have to admit, of 2 billion, that’s the potential range of disaster.’
—@ProfSteveKeen on Going Underground
It goes without saying that the neocons of the Trump Administration did not even take the catastrophic consequences of Strait of Hormuz disruption into account.
Billions face higher food prices, starvation, shortages, hunger, or famine next year in 2027, compounded by a devastating El Niño.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
New Order with Afshin Rattansi
@NewOrder_TV
Dr. Chris Martenson explains how El Niño + the war on Iran is CATASTROPHIC for the global food supply in 2027
‘This is a strong to very strong El Niño year. We’ve already seen in India the monsoons were deficient. They didn’t stop, but they were about 12 to 15 per cent below what they normally would be, and that automatically impacts food production.
We have to consider the loss of urea-based fertilisers. One of the biggest producers of that was the Middle East Gulf region, in particular Qatar and Bahrain. They made huge amounts of this that were exported across the world, and the Global South is heavily import-dependent on that. That got almost completely disrupted.
Some oil is coming out, but the refineries that were producing the feedstocks for the plants making that urea-based fertiliser have almost completely shut down, or are operating at very low levels.
Most likely, we’re going to see a huge reduction in the amount of planted acreage in 2027, strictly for the economic reasons of how expensive fertiliser has become, which is a function of its relative shortage now.’
-Dr. Chris Martenson, Founder & CEO of Peak Prosperity, Author of ‘The Crash Course: The Unsustainable Future of Our Economy, Energy and Environment’, on the latest episode of New Order.
Watch the full interview in the quoted post below. 👇
@chrismartensonThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
New Order with Afshin Rattansi
@NewOrder_TV
🚨 NEW EPISODE OF NEW ORDER 🌐
The WORST ENERGY SHOCK IN HISTORY and the Looming Global Hunger Catastrophe (Chris Martenson)
How will the war on Iran and a super El Niño fuel a global food crisis?
Why are governments telling their populations to prepare and stockpile for an emergency?
Why does he believe the global energy crisis is the result of a coordinated attack?
We discuss all this and more with Dr. Chris Martenson, Founder & CEO of Peak Prosperity and Author of ‘The Crash Course: The Unsustainable Future of Our Economy, Energy and Environment’.
@chrismartensonThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ACEMAXX ANALYTICS
@acemaxx
re: #france - This posting @ProfSteveKeen is the reminder that Govt debt sustainability cannot be analysed independently of the monetary system, the institutional framework and the macroeconomic consequences of fiscal policy, chart profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-debt
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Fara Kaufman
@justfara
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ray Mihigo
@ray2kcreations
LE PALAIS D'ÉTÉ. LE PLUS BEAU PALAIS DU MONDE. BRÛLÉ PAR LA FRANCE ET L'ANGLETERRE.*
Il y a un endroit à Pékin que tous les Chinois connaissent. Et que tous les Français devraient connaître.
Ça s'appelle le Yuanmingyuan. Le Palais d'Été. Le Jardin de la Clarté Parfaite.
Ce n'était pas un palais. C'était un monde.
Imagine Versailles. Multiplie-le par 5. Ajoute des lacs, des rivières, des montagnes artificielles, des temples, des pagodes, des bibliothèques.
350 hectares. 200 bâtiments. Construit pendant 150 ans, de 1707 à 1860, par 5 empereurs.
C'était là que l'empereur de Chine vivait. Pas dans la Cité Interdite. Dans le Palais d'Été. Parce que c'était plus beau, plus calme, plus grand.
À l'intérieur, il y avait tout ce que la Chine avait produit en 3 000 ans.
Des porcelaines bleues et blanches que personne ne sait plus faire. Des livres écrits à la main, uniques au monde. Des peintures de soie. Des horloges offertes par le roi de France. Des fontaines faites par des jésuites français. Des jardins à l'européenne, construits par des architectes européens pour l'empereur.
C'était la mémoire de la Chine. Son musée. Sa bibliothèque. Son âme.
Et le 18 octobre 1860, en 3 jours, tout a disparu.
Que s'est-il passé ?
La France et l'Angleterre sont en guerre contre la Chine. C'est la Guerre de l'Opium. La Chine refuse la drogue. La France et l'Angleterre veulent l'imposer.
Leurs armées arrivent à Pékin. L'empereur s'enfuit. Le palais est vide.
Le 6 octobre 1860, les soldats français et anglais entrent dans le Palais d'Été.
Ce qu'ils font pendant 3 jours, même les officiers français l'ont raconté avec honte.
Ils pillent. Tout. Ils cassent les portes. Ils arrachent les bijoux. Ils déchirent les soies. Ils prennent les vases, les statues, les trônes, les livres.
Un officier français écrit : "On se battait pour les montres, pour les perles, pour l'or. Les soldats mettaient des robes de l'empereur pour rigoler."
Un autre écrit : "On ne savait plus quoi prendre, tellement il y avait de richesses."
Ils envoient des chariots entiers de trésors vers l'Europe. Des bateaux entiers.
Et quand il ne reste plus rien à voler, le 18 octobre, le général anglais Lord Elgin et le général français Montauban donnent l'ordre final : "Brûlez tout."
3 500 soldats mettent le feu. Le palais brûle pendant 3 jours et 3 nuits. La fumée se voit de Pékin, à 20 kilomètres.
Il ne reste que des ruines. Des pierres cassées. Des piliers noircis. Des ponts sans eau.
Pourquoi brûler ? Pour punir l'empereur. Pour lui montrer que même son plus beau palais ne peut pas résister aux Européens.
Victor Hugo, l'un des plus grands écrivain français, a entendu parler de ça. Il était choqué. Il a écrit une lettre célèbre :
"Nous, Européens, nous sommes les civilisés, et les Chinois sont les barbares. Il y a eu deux bandits qui sont entrés dans le Palais d'Été. L'un s'appelle la France. L'autre s'appelle l'Angleterre. Ils ont volé et brûlé. Et maintenant, ils se partagent le butin."
Tu as bien lu. Victor Hugo a appelé la France un bandit.
Aujourd'hui, si tu vas à Pékin, tu peux visiter les ruines. Le gouvernement chinois les a laissées en ruines. Volontairement. Il n'a pas reconstruit. Pour que personne n'oublie.
Et si tu vas à Paris, au Louvre, au Musée Guimet, au château de Fontainebleau, tu peux voir les trésors volés du Palais d'Été. Des vases, des statues, des trônes. Ils sont là, exposés, avec une petite étiquette : "Chine, XIXe siècle."
Mais on ne dit pas : "Volé en 1860 au Palais d'Été, après le pillage et l'incendie."
La Chine demande depuis 160 ans que la France rende ces objets. La France dit non. Elle dit : "C'est à nous. C'est dans nos musées."
Alors la prochaine fois qu'on te dit que la France a apporté la civilisation en Chine, rappelle-toi du Palais d'Été.
Le Palais d'Été n'était pas juste un palais. C'était la preuve que la Chine était une civilisation immense, avant même que la France existe.
Tu connaissais cette histoire ? -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Totally agree. If a 19th century Machiavelli had wanted to cripple the intelligentsia of the working class, he could have invented no better weapon than the Labor Theory of Value.
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Actually, Michal Kalecki was a Marxist. Unfortunately, Marxists have become so bogged down in endless debates over the scientific validity of the labor theory of value, the problems arising from it, and, of course, trying to debunk MMT 😁 that they simply have no energy left for anything else.
But the funny thing is that if a Marxist ever comes to power anywhere, they’ll be doomed to implement standard Keynesian economic policies. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Zack Bornstein
@ZackBornstein
Happy Four Seasons Total Landscaping day to all who celebrate
Zack Bornstein
@ZackBornstein
I could write jokes for 800 years and I'd never think of something funnier than Trump booking the Four Seasons for his big presser, and it turning out to be the Four Seasons Total Landscaping parking lot between a dildo store and a crematorium.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🌊 Negative Tendencies (Neg Ten) 🎸
@NegTendencies
The word is out about the Election Night Watch Party at the White House on Tuesday.
For weeks, Trump had been assured by Susie Wiles and his staff that all the polls were wrong, and that, once again, the Blue Wave would only be a ripple, if one even showed up at all. And the DOJ was ready to pounce on it if it did.
Trump, after all, was on the ballot. "Vote like I'm on the ballot,' he said, "Because I am."
He told every rally that. He said it on FOX. He had a 90% approval rate, he said. And $5000 checks for everybody. What could possibly go wrong?
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
So the East Room was decked out with the finest crystal and china. Staffers thought it would be a fun "cheeky rebuke" to order in platters of finger food from Cheesecake Factory. Just to give a finger to Barack Obama, for his viral joke about Trump’s gaudy renovations to the White House.
EVERYONE showed up in their party clothes. His Staff. His Cabinet. Top GOP politicians. Donors.
But there was no Host or Hostess to greet them. Which was a little odd. The guests mingled among themselves, and waited to be formally welcomed and invited to sample the refreshments.
Where were Trump and Melania?
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Trump waited upstairs in his residence, in order to make a grand entrance to a standing ovation with cheers, once the happy results started pouring in.
And was Melania also waiting upstairs, to march in at his side?
Nope.
Melania was not at the White House at all. On election night, the most anticipated night in politics, with the rest of her husband's term on the line, Melania was somewhere else.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Finally at 8:00 the first election results came in. But during that entire first hour, not ONE Republican was named. It was only Democrat after Democrat, starting with Jon Ossoff.
Trump never came downstairs. At all.
Marco Rubio was the first to go missing, according to the Daily Mail. Then, one by one, the rest of the party goers slipped out the door.
Only two hours later, an enormous decision was called. Democrats had flipped the House of Representatives to their control. And in most cases, the Democrats won, not by slim majorities, but by double digits.
It was 10:00, and the East Room was empty. The party goers had gone to a nearby Washington bar to drown their sorrows. The Cheesecake Factory food lay untouched on the East Room tables.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
And Trump? He was upstairs watching the results on FOX News, and posting angrily on Truth Social.
He wasn't alone. No, Melania wasn't with him. But Natalie Harp was.
The Daily Mail reports that Susie Wiles, his Chief of Staff was upstairs as well. The one who had assured him day after day that Republicans would win.
By 11 pm, Trump stopped posting. “He’s watching Fox News barely uttering a word and paralyzed into silence,” a source close to the president told the Daily Mail.
“It’s very, very dark in the residence,” one senior official said of Trump’s mood. “It’s a dark scene.”
Another source said, “They were delusional right until the very end.”
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Commentary by Glee Violette -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andy Boreham 安柏然
@AndyBxxx
An American professor asked when China last voted.
Answer: right now. A billion people are choosing 2.6 million local representatives.
He blocked me after I replied.
HOW CHINA'S ELECTIONS WORK:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
david kersten
@davidkersten
I would go so far as to call China's meritocracy a genuine democracy, and that what we in the West call 'democracy' is nothing more than a farcical publicity stunt designed to secure the true hidden power behind a smokescreen of superficiality. Sound and fury signifying nothing.
Andy Boreham 安柏然
@AndyBxxx
An American professor asked when China last voted.
Answer: right now. A billion people are choosing 2.6 million local representatives.
He blocked me after I replied.
HOW CHINA'S ELECTIONS WORK:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Economist @ProfSteveKeen has a provocative take on neoclassical economics: “The most dangerous cult is the one that doesn’t realize it’s a cult.”
Read more: evonomics.com/why-economists-have-to-embrace-complexity-s…
Full video in comments.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
FactPost
@factpostnews
David Glosser, Stephen Miller's uncle, told CNN his nephew is an "immigration hypocrite":
Our family history is entirely dependent on our ability to escape a terrible situation in Belarus. Had we not been able to enter America when we did, Stephen Miller would not exist. Everybody else who didn't make it to America ended up dying in the Holocaust.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yan Liang
@YanLian31677392
W/O Treasury spending to create reserves, how does the private sector get money to pay tax and buy bonds in the first place? Also, a long established MMT thesis re Trsy & Fed consolidated analysis: www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_788.pdf
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
The Treasury spends by drawing on its TGA balance. It can’t overdraw the TGA. Nor can the Fed directly credit it. The Fed can only create reserves. To convert reserves into TGA balances the Treasury either taxes or borrows. Therefore gov’t spending requires taxing or borrowing.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EZ Rider🌻🇺🇸🦅
@EZRideryoyall
Lightning strikes twice!
November 7 is the six year anniversary of Four Seasons Total Landscaping Day 🤣 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
little grey mouse 🐭
@mouse_math
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nick Hanauer
@NickHanauer
Tired of the neoliberal economy of the last 40 years? Complaining isn't enough. You need an alternative. Here it is: Market Humanism is the way.
democracyjournal.org/magazine/81/market-humanism-a-new-pa… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
josh ryan-collins
@jryancollins
3/ No interest rate set in Threadneedle Street can lower the price of oil. What it can do is make mortgages, rents and business loans dearer. Two-year fixes are already near 6%. Families are hit twice: at the pump and on their mortgage.
thenegotiator.co.uk/news/uk-housing-market-news/two-year-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
The billionaire media everyday tries to undermine the push for net zero.
I wonder if @JackElsom understands the scientists say climate change is happening faster than predicted, that the collapse of civilisation may be years away and and what this means i.e. mass death and the end of life as we know. Maybe he just doesn’t care. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
Comprehensive debunking of Austrian economics here:
socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/p/blog-page.html
Per Bylund
@PerBylund
What if critics of Austrian economics offered real counterarguments instead of the vapid accusations and insults? But they won't, because it would likely just highlight the theory's strength. mises.org/mises-wire/wanted-critics-austrian-economics
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tally Sticks
@widespreadhaze
The word “deficit”, when referring to government finances, is descriptively correct in accounting terms but rhetorically misleading, because in ordinary English it carries the sense of a shortage, inadequacy or failure. In this context, however, it simply describes a difference between government expenditure and receipts over an accounting period. It does not mean that the government itself is “short” of money.
Compare:
“The government ran a £100bn deficit.”
with:
“The government added £100bn of net sterling financial assets to the non-government sector.”
They describe the same accounting outcome, yet provoke completely different intuitions.
This is not to say that all government deficits produce good economic outcomes. A deficit may contribute to inflation; the composition of spending may be wasteful; or fiscal policy may produce an undesirable distribution of resources. Equally, a deficit may accompany price stability; the composition of spending may promote efficiency and productive capacity; or fiscal policy may produce a desirable distribution of resources.
None of these outcomes necessarily follows from the fact that the government’s accounting balance carries a minus sign. It depends on the economic circumstances, the level and composition of spending and taxation, and the productive limits of the economy.
A government “deficit”, then, identifies a residual accounting balance, not a deficiency in the government’s finances. The mistake is to import the ordinary-language meaning of deficiency into a national-accounting identity. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pensandpages @Pensandpages
Trump was unusually calm and complacent after the Big Blue Wave on Tuesday night, leading me to think he had already planned his revenge and knew his actions would hurt those who hurt him. He reminded me of some suicidal victims. They get happy and calm after they decide what their backup plan is.
Trump has entered the most dangerous narcissistic injury phase of all. Anything could happen and he could take the whole world down with him. Buckle up! This could get nasty! This is also why we can not get complacent and decide to leave him in the Oval Office as a lame duck president. He is a huge clear and present danger not only to America but the whole gawd dam world! He must be removed! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John Ross
@JohnRoss43
What were the differences between the Soviet and Chinese socialist "economic models", is China's socialist economic structure a step towards or a step away from Marx, why did the USSR in 1929 create the type of economic structure it did, was it correct to do so, and how does China's economy since its economic reforms in 1978 differ from it? These are some of the issues I discuss with Michael Hudson in this video. As these are absolutely fundamental issues for socialists I hope you will be interested www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kqf1X3ry2bw&t=2478s
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
?whispers?
@litewhisperer
"They cannot lend out deposits, because deposits are not a source of funding for banks but a liability"
Baki Demirel @profbakidemirel
Evet tam olarak bu; Banka bilançoları (MB dahil) aktiften pasife doğru çalışır tersi geçerli değil.
Bankalar aktiftelerini genişleterek yükümlülük/mevduat (para) yaratır.
Mevduattan kredi veremezler zira mevduatlar bankaların finansman kaynağı değil yükümlülüğüdür
...This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Why does the government sell bonds? It is not to fund its spending. It is, instead, to do a favour to the City of London, which needs a safe place to deposit its money. In the process, the government gets to influence interest rates, but mainstream economics never says any of that.
youtu.be/Nd7NmMF4jWw -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Agreed. Especially when shorn of the Labour Theory of Value.
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
I genuinely don’t understand why some Marxists stubbornly refuse to read beyond Volume I of Capital.
Just read Volumes II and III already! You’ll find a monetary theory of production in Marx himself, an analysis of money capital, accumulation and circulation, as well as discussions of money hoarding and liquidity preference, long before Keynes.
Marx is much closer to the Post-Keynesian tradition than many seem willing to admit.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ludovic de Belleval - Train Money Brain
@TrainMoneyBrain
"When the government taxes you, it takes money out of your bank account—so taxation reduces the amount of money in the economy.
Government spending has the opposite effect. When the government spends, it puts money into private bank accounts.
Therefore, if the government
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How To Handle Government Debt, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-debt
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Giokielicious
@jokieliu
Listen to this Chinese tour guide on money and power in China: “If you want money, don’t touch power. If you want power, stop being greedy for money.”
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Shallow State
@OurShallowState
Basically, Trump blamed the one woman he hadn't yet fired for the election fiasco, she resigned, and Trump promoted the guy who was actually most to blame for the election fiasco in her stead. It's important for us to remember that besides being a narcissist, sociopath, grifter, rapist, traitor, and serial criminal, he's also an idiot.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Michelle
@D162Michele
Wait, I thought China didn’t have elections?
How strange that not a single Western media outlet seems to have noticed this. Almost as if it doesn’t fit the narrative. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Peez
@RebelEkonomista
"Mainstream economics is as realistic as Flat Earth Astronomy."
How To Handle Government Debt, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-deb… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ancient History Hub
@AncientHistorry
In 53 BC, the richest man in Rome led an army of around 40,000 men into the desert to conquer Parthia. Within days, most of them were dead or captured, his son's head was on a spear, and a legend would later claim the Parthians poured molten gold down his throat.
Marcus Licinius Crassus had everything a Roman could want except one thing. He was the wealthiest man in the Republic and one third of the alliance that ran it, along with Pompey and Julius Caesar. But Pompey had conquered the East and Caesar was conquering Gaul. Crassus's biggest military claim to fame was crushing Spartacus, and even that Pompey had partly stolen credit for. He was in his sixties and wanted a war of his own.
Parthia had done nothing to Rome. Plenty of Romans opposed the war. As Crassus left the city, a tribune reportedly stood at the gate and called down curses on him.
Chance one: take the Armenian offer. The king of Armenia, Artavasdes, showed up with thousands of cavalry and offered many more, along with infantry. He gave Crassus one piece of advice. Come through Armenia. The country was hilly and rough, terrible ground for Parthian horsemen. Crassus said no, thanks, and chose the direct route through the flat plains of Mesopotamia.
Chance two: stay by the river. One of his officers, Gaius Cassius Longinus, urged him to march along the Euphrates. The river would keep the army supplied with water and protect a flank. Crassus instead trusted a local Arab chieftain who guided the army away from the river and out into open, waterless country. Plutarch says the man was working for the Parthians the whole time. Once the trap was set, he rode off.
Waiting near the town of Carrhae was Surena, a young Parthian noble who showed up with a force built for exactly this ground: around 10,000 mounted archers and about 1,000 cataphracts, heavy cavalry in armor down to their horses. He also brought something Crassus never imagined. A camel train loaded with arrows.
The Romans formed a giant square. The Parthians rode around it and shot into it. The legionaries locked shields and waited for the enemy to run out of arrows. They didn't. Every time the archers emptied their quivers, they rode back to the camels and came back full. Men were pinned to the ground through their feet. Hands were nailed to shields.
Chance three: don't take the bait. Crassus sent his son Publius, a talented officer who'd served under Caesar in Gaul, with cavalry and infantry to break out. The Parthians fled. Publius chased. It was a feigned retreat. Once he was far enough from the main army, the Parthians turned and surrounded him. Publius died, and the Parthians rode back past the Roman square with his head on a spear.
That night the army abandoned around 4,000 wounded men and slipped away to Carrhae. The Parthians killed the wounded the next morning.
Surena then offered to talk. Crassus didn't trust him, but his own exhausted soldiers threatened him until he agreed to go. At the meeting, a fight broke out and Crassus was killed.
Around 20,000 Romans died and another 10,000 were taken prisoner. Many of the captives were reportedly marched to the far eastern edge of the Parthian empire and settled there as frontier troops. Plutarch says Crassus's head was used as a prop in a performance of a Greek tragedy at the Parthian court. The molten gold story comes later, from Cassius Dio, and he reports it as something that was said, not something he could confirm. It stuck anyway, because it fit too well.
Rome lost its eagle standards too. It took more than thirty years and a diplomatic deal under Augustus to get them back.
And Crassus's death broke the triumvirate. With him gone, there was nothing standing between Caesar and Pompey but each other. A few years later, Caesar crossed the Rubicon. The officer who got out of Carrhae alive, Cassius, would end up one of the men who stabbed Caesar to death on the Ides of March.
The richest man in Rome went looking for glory and ended up helping kill the Republic instead. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Lee
@DavidLe76335983
Wisdom from this Chinese
You can be very successful businessman, don’t touch politics
You can be very successful politician, don’t touch money
If you try to do both, you will fail
Something to think about -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
Breaking News 🚨
Susie Wiles leaves the White House to join Trump’s political campaign team and Stephen Miller takes over as White House Chief Of Staff.
Let me explain to you what this really means.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Anthony Scaramucci
@Scaramucci
Trump saw the midterm results and decided elevating Stephen Miller is the answer. 🤣 He is even more delusional than I thought. Or maybe he actually wants to finish destroying the @GOP? 🤔
Jennifer Jacobs
@JenniferJJacobs
🚨New chief of staff. Susie Wiles moving out, Stephen Miller in
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
How Economists Are Quietly Engineering Our Extinction
Steve Keen has spent years reviewing the models that shape climate policy. What he found is not mere error — it is a systematic denial of reality that may help bring about the collapse they claim to measure.
Mainstream climate economics (Nordhaus, Tol, DICE models) assumes ~90% of GDP is unaffected by warming because it happens “indoors.” It uses today’s spatial temperature variation as a proxy for future change. It downplays tipping points and treats the biosphere as a minor variable rather than the foundation of all economic activity.
The result? Models that predict trivial GDP losses even at 4–6°C warming — while science warns of civilisational threats and potential extinction events.
This is not neutral analysis. It is Achiever-stage enclosure: elegant equations that normalise catastrophe for the benefit of the powerful. The same intellectual priesthood that failed to see 2008 coming is now telling us the greatest threat to our species is manageable.
Keen’s forensic demolition of these models — and his insistence on the central role of energy in production — should be required reading. The future is not a spreadsheet. It is a living system under stress.
The real choice is not between growth and degrowth.
It is between honest reckoning and managed extinction.
We cannot afford the comforting fictions any longer.
Full reflection coming soon.
✊🌎❤️
eaarthnet
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
How Economists Are Quietly Engineering Our Extinction open.substack.com/pub/eaarthnet/p/how-economists-are-quie…
How Economists Are Quietly Engineering Our Extinction
Steve Keen has spent years reviewing the models that shape climate policy. What he found is not mere error — it is a systematic denial of reality that may help bring about the collapse they claim to measure.
Mainstream climate economics (Nordhaus, Tol, DICE models) assumes ~90% of GDP is unaffected by warming because it happens “indoors.” It uses today’s spatial temperature variation as a proxy for future change. It downplays tipping points and treats the biosphere as a minor variable rather than the foundation of all economic activity.
The result? Models that predict trivial GDP losses even at 4–6°C warming — while science warns of civilisational threats and potential extinction events.
This is not neutral analysis. It is Achiever-stage enclosure: elegant equations that normalise catastrophe for the benefit of the powerful. The same intellectual priesthood that failed to see 2008 coming is now telling us the greatest threat to our species is manageable.
Keen’s forensic demolition of these models — and his insistence on the central role of energy in production — should be required reading. The future is not a spreadsheet. It is a living system under stress.
The real choice is not between growth and degrowth.
It is between honest reckoning and managed extinction.
We cannot afford the comforting fictions any longer.
Full reflection coming soon.
✊🌎❤️
eaarthnet -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇨🇳XuZhenqing徐祯卿
@XueJia24682
✨🇨🇳There is a large-scale grassroots election underway in China right now, with 2.6 million grassroots representatives being elected by over 1 billion registered voters.
According to Article 34 of the Constitution of the People's Republic of China, all citizens of the People's Republic of China who have reached the age of 18 have the right to vote and stand for election, regardless of their ethnic status, race, sex, occupation, family background, religious belief, education, property status, or length of residence. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
yılmaz aydın
@yilmazaydin88
))
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How To Handle Government Debt, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-debt
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Modern Macro Technologies
@AppliedMMT
$32.765T of federal debt is held by the public.
Each dollar came into existence when the federal government spent it into existence. Buying a Treasury moves it from a deposit to a bond that pays interest.
That debt is the private sector's savings, in interest-bearing form.
The debt is not a "burden" on anyone.
Sebastian Caliri
@SebastianCaliri
Democrats won Congress and are starting to talk policy. Their emerging agenda: expand federal healthcare spending while imposing new restrictions on AI.
This combination is fiscally ruinous and we do not need to wait to see 7% yields on 10Y treasuries to reach this conclusion.
Like it or not, AI is our engine for economic growth and expanding our tax base. Like it or not, AI is also our best shot at taming healthcare costs: automating administrative work, expanding clinicians’ capacity, and delivering more care without a proportional increase in expensive human labor.
Look at how demanding the arithmetic already is. Even if real GDP grows 5% every year starting in 2027 - an extraordinarily strong growth assumption (~8% nominal) - and we add no new spending commitments, we'd STILL run a $400B deficit in 2035.
This is an agenda that will lock young Americans into a debt burden that consumes decades of future prosperity: more taxes, more national income diverted to interest, and less room to save, invest, and build wealth as we age.
If you are under the age of 50, think long and hard about your future. If you have children, think about the country they will inherit. A vote for this platform is a vote for leaving the next generation worse off than your own.
Every policy decision entails tradeoffs and I didn't hear an outstanding alternative proposal in 2025/2026. But these are your views and you're over 50, you should be ashamed. If these are your views and you're under 50, you should spend some more time thinking about your views. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q4 GDP nowcast holds at 0.8% annualized growth, with a slight upward revision beneath the rounded figure.
Lower mortgage rates offered some relief to residential investment, but the broader outlook remains weak.
Full article below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How To Handle Government Debt, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-debt
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Latest weekly video update from GDP Dynamics. The topic at hand is firm profits, residential investment, firm investment, employment and wages.
Are we at a turning point in the the business cycle?
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/weekly-video-for-174501122 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
In this old blog post, I comprehensively gave the evidence for the widespread existence of cost-based mark-up prices, and why they refute central theories of Austrian economics:
socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2020/09/relative-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Kaiz 🐂🀄️
@Kaiz_294
James Talarico traces 50 years of trickle-down back to one 1971 document, the Powell memo, a corporate blueprint to buy power
“In fact, you can, you can pinpoint this one document called the Powell memo, 1971.”
“But if you read this memo, it's basically a blueprint for how corporate interests can start to dismantle the Great Society and the New Deal”
“They're going to spend massive amounts of money in our politics, buying politicians in both parties, elevate corporate voices in media, appoint sympathetic judges.”
“And that has really been the story of the last 50 years in this country, last five decades.”
w/ @jamestalaricoThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
New feature on the Policy Simulator model being tested by Pro and Platinum users now. Should be rolled out to the general public in 2 weeks.
Considering becoming a paid subscriber to get premium reports and have early access to beta models.
members.gdpdynamics.com -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
New features being rolled out on the Policy Simulator in the coming weeks @GDPDynamics
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
New feature on the Policy Simulator model being tested by Pro and Platinum users now. Should be rolled out to the general public in 2 weeks.
Considering becoming a paid subscriber to get premium reports and have early access to beta models.
members.gdpdynamics.com -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Since France gets a lot of attention, the case of Belgium is drowned out somewhat. It is the same story, basically. A national government is trying to get a budget passed that is in line with the dysfunctional fiscal rules of the Stability and Growth Pact, being forced to cut spending and/or raise taxes during a time where energy prices drive up inflation and reduce demand on everything else and higher interest rates impact on house prices and increase interest payments in a way that redistribute income towards the rich. You cannot cut your way out of "excessive fiscal deficits". The 2010s have shown that clearly. What will De Wever do? 🤔
Belgian Royal Palace
@MonarchieBe
Le Roi a reçu @Bart_DeWever en audience. À l’issue de ses entretiens avec les présidents des cinq partis de la majorité, le Roi a décidé de refuser la démission du Premier ministre et lui a demandé de reprendre les négociations budgétaires dès à présent.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Just remember: only fools confuse accounting identities with causal mechanisms.
“Loans create deposits” is a description of how bank lending works, not merely an accounting identity.
“Spending creates income” describes a causal process, while sectoral balances impose accounting constraints.
And real resource constraints are not accounting identities at all.
Which of these claims do you actually dispute? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Sixth Mass Extinction?, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-sixth-mass-extinction
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Phil 🆓🌍🧩🎲
@Phil_Free_
“If mainstream economics is this wrong about an absolutely fundamental aspect of the economy, then what else are they likely to have gotten wrong?
The answer is, everything! Mainstream economics is as realistic as Flat Earth Astronomy.”
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-deb… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
"All around the world, Treasuries either pay no interest on bonds owned by the Central Bank, or the Central Bank remits its earnings to the Treasury, which has the same effect."
- @ProfSteveKeen
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-deb… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter Daou
@peterdaou
I've been in politics for a quarter century. It's hard to express how staggering it is to see a conversation like this on corporate US media. The Morning Joe panel gobsmacked by the directness of @AbdulElSayed's points.
(clip via @DropSiteNews)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Proposing a "new deal" for Europe, Mélenchon wants to redraft the treaties, ditch core parts of the EU's rulebook — including debt and deficit limits — suspend competition rules for public services such as energy, transport and telecoms, and loosen state aid laws."
Lovely.
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
French leftist presidential candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon wants a radical overhaul of EU rules that would set him on a collision course with Brussels.
vist.ly/5rn4i -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
It's politics
@uspolitics1111
He is such a breath of fresh air.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How To Handle Government Debt, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/how-to-handle-government-debt
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mehdi Hasan
@mehdirhasan
OMG lol 😂
17 years of song a day
@songadaymann
CRY MORE
(a remix feat. @mehdirhasan)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Auskar Surbakti
@AuskarSurbakti
🌍 @TRTWorldForum returns to #istanbul! I’m moderating Saturday’s closing session: How can Middle East economies rebuild after war—and who pays?
With @memetsimsek, @TarekMitri, @A_Gurria, @FabianZuleeg & @ProfSteveKeen.
📅 7 Nov | Join us in person or online #trtworldforum2026 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hunter Biden
@HunterBiden
I read JD Vance's post on this site yesterday and at first I was shocked. The Vice President all but admitted that his own administration made a mistake going to war with Iran. I can't think of a sitting VP breaking with his President this publicly in my lifetime.
And at first glance his analysis seems spot on. His first prescription is to end the war. A war that he and the President, until this week, refused to even call a war.
It's hard to disagree with him. But like everything MAGA, the thread of truth is there to hide the larger truth. And the larger truth is this.
Tuesday was the greatest repudiation of a sitting President by voters in the history of this country.
Not a repudiation of a policy. A repudiation of a man.
The message was not only about Iran or Israel or slogans or even the price at the pump. The message was simple.
WE ARE DONE WITH DONALD TRUMP.
We are done with his lies. We are done with the corruption and the gaslighting. We are done with the insanity. We are done with the cruelty.
The message from Mississippi to Iowa, from Kansas to Maine, from North Carolina to Texas, young and old, North and South, East and West, was the same.
Fuck Donald Trump.
This country desperately needs a healthy Republican Party. A party with room for Mitt Romney and Thomas Massie, for Chris Christie and (I can't believe I'm saying this) Marjorie Taylor Greene. A party that puts this constitutional republic above the interests of one man. A party that knows the difference between a Ken Paxton and a John Cornyn, between a Vivek Ramaswamy and a Mike DeWine.
That is the message voters sent on Tuesday, with more ballots cast than in any midterm in American history.
WE ARE DONE WITH DONALD TRUMP.
The sooner the brave members of whatever remains of the Republican Party understand that, the sooner we can begin to heal.
I hope Democrats in Congress heard it too. Voters sent the same message in 2020, and we failed to make it stick. I for one don't think this country can afford 26 more months of this madness before we do the one thing voters just demanded in historic numbers.
Trump needs to leave, and he needs to leave now.
All it would take this January is eleven Republican senators willing to acknowledge the existential threat this lawless President poses to the country and the world. Eleven brave Republicans need to stand up and end this madness. Save their party. Save the country.
It's up to all of us to give them the courage to do what's right. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Engineers and physicists keep performing miracles, pushing the boundaries of what’s possible and turning science fiction into reality.
Meanwhile, economists: “No, we can’t just press a few buttons on a computer and build more hospitals and schools. That’s impossible. Economic science forbids it.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Robert Hindle
@RTHindle
He is laying the ground work for an insanity plea.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
James K. Galbraith sees @jasonfurman's recent comments about "heterodox" economics as a veiled swipe at @IsabellaMWeber and as evidence that mainstream economics is showing signs of insecurity. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/mainstream-economics…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Heather Parisi 🤐
@heather_parisi
Tutti questi fenomeni su X che dipingono la Cina come una dittatura che calpesta i diritti dei cittadini ... ci sono mai stati in Cina?
Hanno la minima idea che la Cina è il paese dove circa un miliardo di persone è uscito dalla povertà negli ultimi trent'anni?
Che la Cina è il paese dove i piani quinquennali del governo non sono promesse elettorali mai mantenute: sono documenti operativi in cui università e imprese private lavorano insieme su obiettivi decisi a tavolino non lasciati agli spregiudicati interessi di gruppi di potere economico.
Provate a trovare qualcosa di simile in Occidente. Zero. Zilch.
La Cina è il paese dove gli amministratori pubblici che non raggiungono i risultati, vengono mandati a casa con una valutazione che incide sulle future nomine e sulla carriera,
non premiati con un posto nel CDA di qualche società.
La Cina è il paese dove quando provi a fare il tycoon (Jack Ma Alibaba) con pratiche monopolistiche, lo Stato ti mette una multa da 2,8 miliardi di dollari e tre anni di supervisione.
Perché in Cina, l'accumulo di ricchezza che diventa potere contro l'interesse pubblico viene fermato.
Da noi Thiel compra elezioni. Soros ne finanzia altre.
Destra e sinistra, stesso meccanismo: chi ha i soldi decide le regole.
Cambia solo la bandiera.
Fatevi un giro in Cina. Parlate con la gente. Chiedete se sono davvero così scontenti e se farebbero cambio con quello che succede oggi nel democratico occidente.
Magari scoprite che la realtà è un po' più complicata degli slogan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
?whispers?
@litewhisperer
"based on the idea that a currency issuer borrows the currency that only it can issue from the private sector, which cannot issue currency. Read that again! That's what economists' models look like"
Erik Arnell
@ArnellOErik
Nu är jag faktiskt less på @LarsCalmfors och resten av våra vördade svenska nationalekonomer. Finns det verkligen ingen i det skrået, utom @LarsPSyll , som förstår grundläggande bokföring och vågar säga ifrån?
Calmfors skriver: "Det enda säkra är att en stat som hela tiden ökar sin skuld i förhållande till BNP förr eller senare hamnar i en lånekris.” Lånekrisen uppstår enligt Calmfors när långivarna begär högre ränta än tillväxten, vilket skapar en snöbollseffekt på skuldutvecklingen.
Det är 100% falskt. Det visar på en fullständig avsaknad av förståelse för vad en valuta är och hur vårt monetära system fungerar. Nationalekonomer är så insyltade i sina verklighetsfrånvända modeller att de helt har tappat kontakten med verkligheten.
Hela Calmfors analys bygger på att en valutautgivare lånar den valuta bara den kan ge ut från den privata sektorn som inte kan ge ut valuta. Läs det igen! Så ser nationalekonomins modeller ut.
“Den utbredda underskottsfobin och ränteångesten bottnar i den ekonomiska mittfårans vanföreställning att valutautgivaren måste låna sin egen valuta av den privata sektorn, och att marknaden därmed dikterar villkoren. Verkligheten är den omvända. Det hörs på ordet: en valutautgivare lånar inte sin egen valuta, den ger ut den. Det är marknaden som får den valuta den behöver från valutautgivaren för att kunna betala skatt och köpa statspapper.”
Citatet är från min artikel i Dagens Arena. Läs den och bota din ränteångest. Där förklarar jag också varför Frankrike faktiskt sitter i klistret: det beror inte på att landet spenderat för mycket, utan på att EU och ECB tvingar dem att betala den höga räntan marknaden "begär" på de euro landet gett ut.
www.dagensarena.se/essa/krisen-frankrike-visar-sverige-sk…
Calmfors modeller gör honom fullständigt blind inför faktumet att staten som valutautgivare måste tillgodose icke-statens behov att betala de skatter staten tvingar den att betala och dess önskan att spara valuta som staten med sin politik skapar. Det är icke-statens önskan/behov att fylla på (eller minska) sitt sparande av valutan som avgör hur stort ett underskott (överskott) måste vara för att behålla samma efterfrågan (och därmed produktion och sysselsättning).
Fransmännen vill hålla mycket euro. Därför måste franska underskott vara höga. Den trötta ekonomin och höga arbetslösheten är beviset för att underskotten varit för låga i förhållande till önskan att nettospara – inte för höga.
“Tvingas Frankrike strama åt ytterligare utan att först minska incitamenten till privat sparande, kommer efterfrågan att falla och arbetslösheten att öka. Följden blir motsatsen till den önskade: sjunkande tillväxt, raserad välfärd och en statsskuld som paradoxalt nog ökar som andel av BNP. “
Läs mer om det här: www.di.se/debatt/frankrikes-problem-ar-inte-den-hoga-stat…
Calmfors i DN:
www.dn.se/ledare/lars-calmfors-frankrike-ar-pa-vag-mot-de… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Erik Arnell
@ArnellOErik
Nu är jag faktiskt less på @LarsCalmfors och resten av våra vördade svenska nationalekonomer. Finns det verkligen ingen i det skrået, utom @LarsPSyll , som förstår grundläggande bokföring och vågar säga ifrån?
Calmfors skriver: "Det enda säkra är att en stat som hela tiden ökar sin skuld i förhållande till BNP förr eller senare hamnar i en lånekris.” Lånekrisen uppstår enligt Calmfors när långivarna begär högre ränta än tillväxten, vilket skapar en snöbollseffekt på skuldutvecklingen.
Det är 100% falskt. Det visar på en fullständig avsaknad av förståelse för vad en valuta är och hur vårt monetära system fungerar. Nationalekonomer är så insyltade i sina verklighetsfrånvända modeller att de helt har tappat kontakten med verkligheten.
Hela Calmfors analys bygger på att en valutautgivare lånar den valuta bara den kan ge ut från den privata sektorn som inte kan ge ut valuta. Läs det igen! Så ser nationalekonomins modeller ut.
“Den utbredda underskottsfobin och ränteångesten bottnar i den ekonomiska mittfårans vanföreställning att valutautgivaren måste låna sin egen valuta av den privata sektorn, och att marknaden därmed dikterar villkoren. Verkligheten är den omvända. Det hörs på ordet: en valutautgivare lånar inte sin egen valuta, den ger ut den. Det är marknaden som får den valuta den behöver från valutautgivaren för att kunna betala skatt och köpa statspapper.”
Citatet är från min artikel i Dagens Arena. Läs den och bota din ränteångest. Där förklarar jag också varför Frankrike faktiskt sitter i klistret: det beror inte på att landet spenderat för mycket, utan på att EU och ECB tvingar dem att betala den höga räntan marknaden "begär" på de euro landet gett ut.
www.dagensarena.se/essa/krisen-frankrike-visar-sverige-sk…
Calmfors modeller gör honom fullständigt blind inför faktumet att staten som valutautgivare måste tillgodose icke-statens behov att betala de skatter staten tvingar den att betala och dess önskan att spara valuta som staten med sin politik skapar. Det är icke-statens önskan/behov att fylla på (eller minska) sitt sparande av valutan som avgör hur stort ett underskott (överskott) måste vara för att behålla samma efterfrågan (och därmed produktion och sysselsättning).
Fransmännen vill hålla mycket euro. Därför måste franska underskott vara höga. Den trötta ekonomin och höga arbetslösheten är beviset för att underskotten varit för låga i förhållande till önskan att nettospara – inte för höga.
“Tvingas Frankrike strama åt ytterligare utan att först minska incitamenten till privat sparande, kommer efterfrågan att falla och arbetslösheten att öka. Följden blir motsatsen till den önskade: sjunkande tillväxt, raserad välfärd och en statsskuld som paradoxalt nog ökar som andel av BNP. “
Läs mer om det här: www.di.se/debatt/frankrikes-problem-ar-inte-den-hoga-stat…
Calmfors i DN:
www.dn.se/ledare/lars-calmfors-frankrike-ar-pa-vag-mot-de… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
In meinem Lehrbuch zur #makroökonomik geht es auch um die Auswirkungen des Wirtschaftens auf die Natur. Nachhaltiges Wirtschaften sollte dabei ein übergeordnetes Ziel sein: Ressourcen, die nicht nachhaltig bewirtschaftet werden können, sollten gar nicht erst in den Kreislauf eingebracht werden. In diesem Fall - Wasserbedarf von Rechenzentren - wäre zu klären, inwiefern ein doppelter Wasserbedarf nachhaltig möglich wäre.
link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-658-41055-1_2
DIE ZEIT
@zeitonline
Bis 2030 könnte sich der Wasserbedarf von Rechenzentren in Deutschland fast verdoppeln, zeigt eine neue Studie. Sie widerspricht auch den Aussagen von Betreibern. www.zeit.de/digital/2026-11/rechenzentren-wasserverbrauch…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
Having witnessed the disintegration of the Corbyn project in the Labour Party caused by trying to appease the Zionist lobby, it's vital the Green Party doesn't make the same mistakes. You cannot appease genocidaires. You have to confront and defeat them.
Natalie Strecker
@StreckerSpeaks
A statement from Green Party Members on the attempts by certain individuals to undermine our party democracy, the ONLY truly democratic mainstream political party.
We will NOT at a time our systems are failing & destroying our communities, tolerate the silencing of voices. We are a party BY members FOR members, for the express reason of protecting, empowering & building our communities & reawakening hope, which we all so desperately need.
Please share and MORE IMPORTANTLY, please join us in the @TheGreenParty
@ZackPolanski @MothinAli -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Philip Johnston
@PhilipJohnston
Me too, it’s the main reason we are doing the @FermiExplorer mission to Alpha Centauri launching in 3 years arriving in 77,000 years. We can knock off two more great filters for about $10M (that it’s too hard to get to another star, and that intelligent life doesn’t want to).
The main remaining options then are:
1. Intelligent life is absurdly rare
2. Intelligent life doesn’t last very long
Both would have near term implications for how we live in the coming years -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Just remember:
1. Spending creates income.
2. Loans create deposits.
3. Taxes do not fund spending.
4. Government deficits create non-government financial surpluses.
5. Real resources, not money, constrain sovereign government spending. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ModernMoneyLab_EU
@mml_europe
Save the date: our day of talks on MMT in Paris, Saturday 27 February 2027, in English. Dirk Ehnts speaks in the morning. Tickets are not on sale yet. Sign up via the link to be told first.
#mmt #eu #economics
modernmoneylab.eu/events/paris-2027/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Banks cannot and do not lend out reserves. Banks create deposits when they lend, and they don't need to "back up" bank deposits by borrowing reserves from the central bank. Official publications from the Bank of England and the Bundesbank say that, too.
Time to move on.
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
My favorite part of @Isabel_Schnabel's final speech:
European Central Bank
@ecb
At the end of her time at the ECB, Executive Board member @Isabel_Schnabel reflects on what she has learnt about monetary policy, sharing four key takeaways on the choice of tools, the response to shocks, fiscal and financial dominance, and implementation www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2026/html/ecb.sp261105_1…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Boze Herrington, Library Owl 😴🧙♀️
@SketchesbyBoze
In Fahrenheit 451, the chief book-burner, Captain Beatty, describes how reading became obsolete because the public demanded increasingly fast-paced entertainments, and those entertainments slowly corroded their ability to think. “Books cut shorter. Condensations. Digests, tabloids. Everything boils down to the gag, the snap ending. Classics cut to fit fifteen-minute radio shows, then cut again to fill a two-minute book column … Many were those whose sole knowledge of Hamlet was a one-page digest in a book that claimed, ‘Now at last you can read all the classics.’ … School is shortened, discipline relaxed, philosophies, histories, languages dropped, English and spelling gradually neglected, finally almost completely ignored. Life is immediate, the job counts, pleasure lies all about after work. Why learn anything save pressing buttons, pulling switches?”
In this passage Ray Bradbury foretells the intellectual hollowing out of the working class, the advent of AI-generated “summaries” of classic novels, the attention-frying culture of short-form video, the relaxation of educational standards into non-existence. All of this in a book published in 1953.
Dylan O'Sullivan
@DylanoA4
Starting to really understand why a core theme of dystopian novels is that nobody reads
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
中國新聞社
@CNS1952
“立足自身發展,盡可能不受西方,尤其是美國經濟動盪帶來的影響,我覺得這是中國能做出的最明智選擇。”
澳大利亞經濟學家史蒂夫·基恩(Steve Keen) @ProfSteveKeen 近期接受中國新聞網“#新聞會客廳”的採訪,圍繞全球經濟走勢與中國發展模式進行深度分析。This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
China News 中国新闻网
@Echinanews
“Continue doing what you're doing, and don't fall for the nonsense of Western economics. The fact that you've avoided the nonsense concepts of mainstream #economics is one reason why China has succeeded.”
Australian economist Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen shared his insights into #global economic trends and #china's development model in an exclusive interview with China News Network's #newslounge.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Sixth Mass Extinction?, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-sixth-mass-extinction
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"We are only likely to see a significant shift in public opinion, and public policy, when lots of white people start to die in rich and predominantly white countries."
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
C e i s t (Climate Change)
@Ceist8
"At no point in the nearly half-billion years that Judd and her colleagues analyzed did the Earth change as fast as it is changing now"
“In the same way as a massive asteroid hitting the Earth, what we’re doing now is unprecedented.”
"swift and dramatic temperature shifts were associated with many of the world’s worst moments — including a mass extinction that wiped out roughly 90 percent of all species and the asteroid strike that killed the dinosaurs."
“We know that these catastrophic events … shift the landscape of what life looks like,” Judd said.
“When the environment warms that fast, animals and plants can’t keep pace with it.”
A 485-million-year history of Earth’s surface temperature- Judd et al 2024 science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adk3705
"Atmospheric CO2 exerts a dominant control on GMST, both today and in the geologic past"
Washington Post article interviewing Judd et al:
archive.is/2024.09.20-163739/https://www.washingtonpost.c… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lachlan Kerwood-McCall
@lachlanmccall
Hang it in the Louvre.
Josh Barzon
@JoshuaBarzon
The 2026 midterms in one picture.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Stefan Rahmstorf 🌏 🦣
@rahmstorf
Der Kipppunkt der Atlantikströmung #amoc könnte bereits in wenigen Jahrzehnten überschritten werden - danach wäre ein Versiegen der Strömung nicht mehr aufzuhalten.
Nur eine sehr rasche Reduktion der Emissionen kann das Risiko vermindern.
www.scinexx.de/news/geowissen/erderwaermung-koennte-deutl… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
In 1790 Hamilton and Coxe said a free nation must produce what it needs, or live at its rivals' mercy.
In 1988 a foreign committee in Basel priced American credit so factories starved. The result is the de-industrialisation of America.
ctindale.substack.com/p/the-unconstitutional-de-industria… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sony Thăng
@nxt888
Let's be precise about what the Epstein network actually was.
Not a "sex scandal." Not a tabloid story about a weird billionaire and his famous friends. Not a trafficking case in the sanitized, clinical language that makes it sound like a logistics problem.
It was a blackmail infrastructure for the ruling class.
Epstein didn't accumulate powerful men by accident. He accumulated them by design.
The private island. The private jet logs. The hidden cameras. The underage girls.
This was an intelligence operation.
A systematic, decades-long project to compromise the people who run governments, banks, media companies, universities, and courts.
And when he was arrested the second time, when it was finally impossible to make it disappear:
He died in federal custody.
Suicide, they said.
In a cell where the cameras malfunctioned.
With guards who had both fallen asleep.
After his previous suicide attempt had already put him on watch status.
The medical examiner hired by his brother found evidence consistent with homicide. The official medical examiner ruled it suicide.
And the name list, the full, unredacted list of everyone Epstein brought to that island and those houses and those parties, remains sealed.
Protected by the same judicial system that is supposed to protect you.
This is not a conspiracy theory.
The documents, the flight logs, the depositions, the testimony, all of it is real, much of it is public, and what it shows is a power structure that protects itself from accountability at every level.
The people on that list run your country.
They run your media.
They run your courts.
They are still running everything.
And they will call you a "conspiracy theorist" for noticing. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
If the GOP had any brains at all, they would march Trump to his Oval Office to sign a resignation letter right now, and then they would say to the world, "We're sorry. We f-cked up. We went along with an insane person for too long. And now we're correcting our course and we promise to serve the interests of the American people instead of Zionist billionaire donors."
But of course they are too stupid to do that. Which is why I have now branded the GOP a "suicide cult." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
Why did I write a book about China’s war on poverty? Why spend years documenting how a nation of 1.4 billion lifted 600 million people out of destitution in a single generation? Because I love the people of the United States of America.
Those who insist we must hate China, who treat every Chinese success as a threat and every statistic as propaganda, are not protecting us. They are trying to manipulate the American people with hate, fear, and deceptions. They are feeding our fears and counting on our ignorance.
The USA is stronger through learning about the strengths and successes of other nations. We can ONLY improve ourselves by understanding the other 200 nations of people in our shared world.
I live here in China. So, I have chosen to share real-world knowledge about China’s strengths and successes. That’s patriotism. That’s hoping we can learn from China’s will to help its people. I love the people of China, yes. But I also love the people of my country, the United States of America.
Their government made poverty elimination a central national priority and then did the hard, unglamorous work of building roads, relocating villages, expanding education, and delivering basic healthcare to places that had almost nothing. China’s successes are not just measurable; they are visible.
I, me, I’ve personally visited hundreds of Chinese villages, and travelled to every single province of China, and every Special Autonomous Region. China’s success in this regard isn’t propaganda; it’s very real. Pretending this did not happen, or that it only happened because of some sinister design, does not make America safer or stronger. It just makes us less informed. It makes us ignorant.
China’s people are not our enemies. They’re our global brothers and sisters. They want stable lives, better futures for their kids, and peaceful relations with the outside world, including the United States.
Telling the truth about what China has actually achieved in reducing poverty is patriotic. It is the most patriotic thing I can do: refuse to let my fellow Americans be manipulated by fear and half-truths, and insist we see the world as it is rather than as someone else needs us to see it.
That is why I wrote the book. To help us learn about the real world and what is happening in our closest peer. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Shallow State
@OurShallowState
It's fascinating to me how few on the political Right are firmly in reality about what just transpired. Ted Cruz gets it. MTG gets it. Tucker Carlson gets it. But all these RW influencers here on X are in their own self-generated purgatory of disbelief. Like they think it's going to go back to what it was. Cruz and Carlson know - it won't.
This was a rebuke of Trump - done WITH animus. The electorate was rebuking HIM, on a national level. They were doing it with disdain.
Nobody wants to tell him this to his face and even Cruz and Carlson don't want to put it out there overtly - yet.
But trust me - it's coming. Because it was the lying. And the grifting. And the mocking. And Trump can't do anything else. He was saying "affordability is a hoax" to their face out loud, and the electorate responded with "f*ck off." He was saying "we beat inflation" and "we won the war" and "we're making boatloads of money" - to their faces, out loud, and the electorate responded: "Are you f*cking kidding!? Are you mocking us!?"
Some Senator told the electorate, clamoring over the high price of beef, to "find another protein," Marie Antionette-style. And the electorate responded that they'll just find another Senator.
Trump is more than a lame duck. He's lame, period. He's toxic. He's toast. He's shot.
If the GOP doesn't want to be taken down for good, they know what to do. And if they want to stay craven and bury their heads like ostriches at the risk of being taken down for good, Trump will accommodate them. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Owen Jones
@owenjonesjourno
This is absolutely ridiculous and outrageous from the BBC.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Normal Island News
@NormalIslandNws
I bet Russell Brand wishes he was in the Epstein files now as this seems to grant you immunity from prosecution
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Wu Tang is for the Children
@WUTangKids
Lmao been waiting for this….absolute cinema….no notes!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Enrico 🇩🇪🇺🇲🗽💙💙💙💙💙
@ANY151161719021
DING DONG ❗️ 🚨 ❗️ 💥💥
STEPHEN MILLERS EPIC MENTAL MELTDOWN ❗️☝️
A MUST SEE 👀 👌 👏
💙💙💙💙🗽🇺🇸This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
People Over Profit
@Floridamarx
Over 1 billion Chinese people voted in 2021-22. Turnout was nearly 87%. The US midterms rarely break 40%. You can critique their system all you want, but pretending Chinese people don't vote is just admitting you know nothing about it.
Pedro Domingos
@pmddomingos
Today we voted. When did you last do that, China?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
John Kenneth Galbraith wrote The Affluent Society in 1958 about a country drowning in private wealth while its schools, streets and public services went to shit.
Nearly 70 years later, Austrian economists are still arguing we haven't privatized enough.
Fucking brilliant. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roman de Renart
@howisthewater
The greatest evidence for this being a circle jerk is that all the degenerates in economics are still calling it a 'Nobel Prize'. It never was & it never will be.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
No it doesn't.
You can't create inflation this way (what I call QE1).
And no tax money used.
Only non-circulating "reserve" money used.
It is free.
I see you haven't read any of my work... -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
📐triANGLE INVESTOR
@capnek123
🔔@ProfSteveKeen discusses the political and economic implications of the 2026 US #midtermelections, Donald #trump 's policies, America's growing economic challenges, the future of the US #dollar and more.
youtu.be/u6zZXcyU85A -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Progressive economists have long known that money is never the constraint on a government that creates its own currency. Now a mainstream UK political party is not only saying that out loud, but has built an economic framework to guide policy choices that might flow from that simple yet profound insight."
www.thenational.scot/news/26674552.scotland-can-learn-gre… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andy Boreham 安柏然
@AndyBxxx
There is literally a massive election going on in China RIGHT NOW, with 2.6 million grassroots representatives being selected by one BILLION registered voters.
Pedro Domingos
@pmddomingos
Today we voted. When did you last do that, China?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
It takes nerve to lecture us on climate change, unemployment or housing from a neoclassical perspective. Decades of sacrificing human needs at the altar of efficiency, and now the cure: more incentives, reforms and markets. The god never fails. Only the sacrificed do.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
James K. Galbraith shows why exponents of the discipline’s “orthodoxy” are struggling to counter “heterodox” insights. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/mainstream-economics…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Die Wahlergebnisse in den USA lassen darauf hoffen, dass es dort zu einem Umdenken in der Wirtschaftspolitik allgemein wie auch in der Makroökonomik kommt, wo es um die Fiskal- und Geldpolitik geht. Wie so etwas für 🇩🇪 aussehen könnte, ist hier einsehbar:
link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-658-41055-1 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Occupy Democrats
@OccupyDemocrats
BREAKING: HOLY SMOKES! Democrats now control enough states to effectively abolish the Electoral College through the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
Republicans did NOT have this on their bingo cards...
Under the Constitution, states control their electoral votes and are allowed to decide how they are allocated during presidential elections. Currently, almost every state gives its votes to whoever wins the state.
In practice, the current system means that a candidate can win the national popular vote, but lose the election because small states like Wyoming exert undue influence on the outcome. That state has 3 electoral votes with a population of just 577,000 people. California has 54 electoral votes and a population of 39.5 million people. So a vote in Wyoming is essentially 3.8 times as valuable as one in California.
Since 1992, Democrats have won the popular vote seven out of nine times.
Under the NPV, states that join agree to give their electoral votes to whoever wins the national popular vote, not just their own state. So a state could go red on the map, but if the Democrat wins the national vote, they still get that state's votes. And vice versa of course.
The crucial mechanism is that the compact doesn't trigger until the member states have a combined power of at least 270 electoral votes, the number needed to win the White House. So far, 18 states plus D.C. have joined, totaling 222 electoral votes. We only need 48 more.
Now is the chance to pass this measure in every state possible. Democrats won both houses of the legislature in Wisconsin for the first time in 18 years (10 electoral votes). We won the Pennsylvania state Senate for the first time since 1993 (19 votes). We now have a trifecta in Michigan (15 votes). And we won the governor’s race in Nevada (6 votes).
10 + 19 + 15 + 6 = 50.
222 + 50 = 272.
And if we hold our lead in the Arizona Senate, that number could climb as high as 283, more than enough to trigger the compact.
In addition to removing an imbalance in our system that favors Republicans, this novel approach would fundamentally change how candidates run their presidential campaigns. Currently, they are incentivized to ignore most of the country. If you live in a “safe” state, red or blue, your vote for President is basically decided before you cast it. Campaigns spend their time and money in a handful of swing states while the rest of us watch from the sidelines. If the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is adopted, they'll have reason to hit every state because they're aiming to win the largest swath of the country as a whole, not just certain states.
States have until July 20, 2028 to join the compact in time for the next presidential election.
We can fix our democracy. The time is now.
Please ❤️ and share if you support this idea! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Z kortu - informacje tenisowe
@z_kortu
Viktoria Azarenka opublikowała wyjątkowy, bardzo osobisty list, w którym pożegnała kończącego karierę Gaela Monfilsa. 🫶
"Gaelu, miałam ogromne szczęście poznać cię, gdy miałam zaledwie 14 lat. Do dziś uśmiecham się na wspomnienie tego, w jaki sposób rozpoczęła się nasza przyjaźń.
Pamiętam cię w stołówce na Wimbledonie, jeszcze przed finałem juniorskiego turnieju. Ćwiczyłeś wtedy swoje zwycięskie układy taneczne. Przez jakieś półtorej godziny, na oczach ABSOLUTNIE WSZYSTKICH. 😂 Próbowałeś zdecydować, w jaki sposób będziesz świętować zwycięstwo. Może ten obrót? A może tamten? Czy jeszcze coś zupełnie innego? Pamiętam, jak na ciebie patrzyłam i myślałam: „O mój Boże, ten gość jest absolutnie szalony”.
Ale już wtedy uderzyło mnie coś jeszcze. Nie było w tobie ani odrobiny arogancji czy zarozumiałości. Była tylko czysta radość, pewność siebie i niesamowita energia, którą wnosiłeś wszędzie, gdzie się pojawiałeś. I właśnie od tamtego momentu staliśmy się naprawdę dobrymi przyjaciółmi.
Zawsze podziwiałam twój tenis, twoją pasję, kreatywność i umiejętność sprawiania, że ludzie zakochują się w tej dyscyplinie. Ale przede wszystkim zawsze byłam fanką ciebie jako człowieka. Masz jedno z największych i najżyczliwszych serc, jakie kiedykolwiek spotkałam.
Masz w sobie niezwykłą umiejętność zakochiwania się w życiu. W ludziach, pomysłach i każdej nowej przygodzie, która przyciąga twoją uwagę. Widziałam już Gaela tenisistę, Gaela DJ-a, Gaela magika i Bóg jeden wie, ile jeszcze innych wcieleń Gaela. 😂 Ale jedna rzecz zawsze pozostawała niezmienna: twoja pasja do dawania ludziom radości.
Kilka lat temu nagrałam dla ciebie film z okazji zakończenia kariery. Podobno jednak uznałeś, że jeszcze nie zamierzasz przechodzić na sportową emeryturę, więc nagranie nigdy nie ujrzało światła dziennego. 😂
Była w nim jednak pewna historia, którą chcę się teraz podzielić, ponieważ moim zdaniem mówi ona wszystko o tym, jakim jesteś człowiekiem.
Wiele lat temu, kiedy mieszkałam w Los Angeles, przyjechałeś mnie odwiedzić. Poszliśmy na kort tenisowy, żeby trochę się powygłupiać, pograć w różne głupie gry i po prostu dobrze się bawić. W pewnym momencie ostrzegłeś mnie: „Vika, uważaj, z tyłu jest ślisko”. A ja z pełnym przekonaniem odpowiedziałam: „Nie gram aż tak daleko od siatki”. Oczywiście jakieś dwie minuty później poślizgnęłam się i upadłam.
Śmialiśmy się do łez.
Na sąsiednim korcie starszy mężczyzna trenował w pojedynkę, korzystając z maszyny wyrzucającej piłki. Wyraźnie nie podobało mu się nasze małe przedstawienie i zaczął na nas krzyczeć, że jesteśmy za głośno. Byliśmy zdezorientowani i trochę poirytowani. Nie przeszkadzaliśmy przecież nikomu celowo. Po prostu dobrze się bawiliśmy.
I wtedy zrobiłeś coś, czego nigdy nie zapomnę. Zamiast się z nim kłócić albo przyjmować postawę obronną, podszedłeś do niego i zapytałeś, czy wszystko w porządku. Zaproponowałeś, że pomożesz mu pozbierać piłki tenisowe. A potem po prostu zacząłeś z nim odbijać.
Wystarczyło kilka minut, żeby mężczyzna, który jeszcze przed chwilą był na nas tak zdenerwowany, zaczął się uśmiechać, śmiać i czerpać przyjemność z gry. Cała atmosfera całkowicie się zmieniła. Nie zrobiłeś tego, żeby cokolwiek udowodnić. Nie próbowałeś nikomu zaimponować. On nawet nie wiedział, kim jesteś. Po prostu wybrałeś życzliwość.
Ten moment pozostał ze mną przez wszystkie te lata, ponieważ właśnie taki, moim zdaniem, naprawdę jesteś. To człowiek, który potrafi zmienić atmosferę w pomieszczeniu, na korcie tenisowym czy po prostu czyjś dzień – samą swoją obecnością.
Kiedy widzę, jak ogromną miłością i sympatią darzą cię ludzie na całym świecie, dokładnie wiem, dlaczego tak jest. Nie chodzi wyłącznie o twoje niesamowite zagrania, niewiarygodny atletyzm, spektakularne widowisko, które tworzysz, czy niezapomniane mecze.
Chodzi o to, że dzięki tobie ludzie coś czują.
Dałeś im swoją pasję, uwagę, radość i całe swoje serce. A teraz świat odwzajemnia tę miłość. Zasłużyłeś na każdą jej odrobinę.
Świat tenisa będzie tęsknił za jednym z największych showmanów, jakich kiedykolwiek widział ten sport. Ja również z pewnością będę tęsknić za oglądaniem twojej magii na korcie. Ale cieszy mnie świadomość, że nasza przyjaźń nie kończy się wraz z twoją karierą. Po prostu rozpoczyna się jej kolejny rozdział. A znając ciebie, jestem pewna, że odkryjemy jeszcze 15 kolejnych wersji Gaela. 😂
Jestem z ciebie bardzo dumna, mój przyjacielu. Nie tylko ze względu na niesamowitą karierę, którą zbudowałeś, ale przede wszystkim na człowieka, którym pozostałeś przez te wszystkie lata. Jako zawodnik, ojciec i przyjaciel.
Świat cię bardzo kocha, Gaelu. Ja również.
Gratuluję niezwykłej kariery.
Nie ma drugiego takiego człowieka jak ty. I nigdy nie będzie. ❤️
Całuję,
Vika ♡"
📸 IG/Gael Monfils / Getty Images | #zkortu -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Early warnings persist for a much slower Q4 for US Real GDP. @GDPDynamics
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q4 2026 GDP nowcast rose 0.2 percentage points to 0.8% today.
The entire upward revision came from an improved net export outlook following the latest US trade data.
Growth remains weak, with domestic demand showing little change.
Article in post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Philip Armstrong 💙
@PhilArmstrong58
The money supply is endogenous.
That means it responds to economic activity. If the price level rises the MS expands to allow transactions to occur at that price level.
Increases in the MS are best conceived as the effect of a rise in prices not a cause. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene🇺🇸
@FmrRepMTG
Good start JD, but these were basically the core issues of campaign promises of 2024.
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to Israel
Republicans lost yesterday because’24 campaign promises were not delivered, Trump called us panicans and me a traitor and you stayed silent and supported Trump while he failed, you all primaried Thomas Massie with millions from Israel, ignored rape victims of Epstein and company, and MAHA was ignored.
Just to name a few issues.
You should have listened to me and Tucker and others who told you early.
Blaming the Iran war won’t work and it’s not going to be an easy pivot.
JD Vance
@JDVance
One of the things the data analysts on our side obsessed over was "composition"—whether the electorate looked close enough to 2024 for Republicans to win. And despite polls that showed a Democrat blowout, the data kept on telling us the same story: in some states turnout was merely OK, in other states it was downright amazing, and in no state was it catastrophic. There was a genuine sense of optimism on our team: our people were showing up.
So, I asked the smartest data guy I know, does that mean we're going to shock the world? "No," he told me. "We might do better than the polls suggest. But the data is telling us that a lot of Trump/Vance 2024 voters are pissed and planning to vote for the other guys. Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us."
Well, that looks prophetic now. Our voters did show up. In Florida, for example, the electorate was 9 points more Republican than Democrat, just a couple points worse than 2024. Undoubtedly there were places we could have done better on turnout. But the main problem is not turnout. The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.
There will be a lot of infighting and arguing over what happened and why that is. One of the pollsters I really respect told me that our economic messaging wasn’t sharp enough down the stretch. I’m sure that’s true.
But the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone.
Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were:
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to Israel
Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. This is according to a pollster who nailed the results. While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. (She’s also a great person.)
In the next few months, there's going to be a lot of gaslighting. Expect to hear any number of establishment politicians say the solution to our woes is amnesty. I'm open to the idea that we should change enforcement—by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labor, for instance. But anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you.
The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night.
If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest.
But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.
I remain hopeful about our country. To the people who are pissed off and want to say, “I told you so”: you’re right, you did tell us so. Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview. To the people who are just pissed at the results, you should be. Let’s take that anger and get back to the work of saving our country. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Let Us Now Praise... The Beatles
@BeatlesPraise
"We were driving through Colorado [and] we had the radio on and eight of the Top Ten songs were Beatles songs. In Colorado! 'I Want to Hold Your Hand,' all those early ones.
"They were doing things nobody was doing. Their chords were outrageous, just outrageous, and their harmonies made it all valid . . . but I kept it to myself that I really dug them. Everybody else thought they were for the teenyboppers, that they were gonna pass right away. But it was obvious to me that they had staying power. I knew they were pointing the direction where music had to go.
"In my head, the Beatles were it. It seemed to me a definite line was being drawn. This was something that never happened before . . .
"They were fantastic singers. To this day, it's hard to find a singer better than Lennon was, or than McCartney was and still is. I'm in awe of McCartney. He's about the only one that I'm in awe of. He can do it all. And he's never let up. He's got the gift for melody, he's got the gift for rhythm, he can play any instrument. He can scream and shout as good as anyone, and he can sing a ballad as good as anyone. And his melodies are effortless, that's what you have to be in awe of . . . he's just so damn effortless. I just wish he'd quit [laughs]. Everything that comes out of his mouth is just framed in melody.
"As for Lennon . . . John has taken poetics pretty far in popular music. A lot of his work is overlooked, but if you examine it, you’ll find key expressions that have never been said before to push across his point of view. Things that are symbolic of some inner reality and probably will never be said again.
"America should put statues up to the Beatles. They helped give this country’s pride back to it. I think they're the best."
--#bobdylan
#dylan #songwriter #author #icon #influence #pulitzer #nobelprize #oscars #halloffame #beatles #thebeatles #impact #singers #goats
Sources: Rolling Stone Illustrated History of Rock 'n' Roll; Rolling Stone magazine, 2007; Playboy, 1978; Down The Highway: The Life of Bob Dylan, Howard Sounes -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
Ponder for a moment the possibility that America's voters may have just saved the world from a nuclear holocaust by stopping their own insane president who was hell bent on unleashing one.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jennifer 🟥🔴🧙♀️🦉🐈⬛ 🦖
@babybeginner
Let me tell you what I’m pissed about. Really really angry about. I CANT AFFORD ANYTHING. Health insurance is now more than my mortgage. My standard of living is gone. You’re all whining about an election. I’m facing another $1000 a year on car insurance with no accidents. The Dems WRECKED US during covid. Then you decided to kick us in the head. I pay over SIX DOLLARS for gas. To you that’s a number. To me that means something else has to get cut out of my life. My life just got smaller bc of you. Will the Dems make it worse? YES.
Every single one of you has made my life worse. We are now going without life insurance. That luxury is gone.
You think I care about Israel? Dude. I can’t go to Jack in Box any more. That’s a luxury item now and all your followers will scream at me I should just hush up and eat rice and beans for the rest of my life.
I don’t know what you’re all gonna do when the other demographics start rioting and looting too. AI is taking the jobs. We have no hope. No help. And now you’ve turned us all over to the democrats. We will go straight to breadlines. My purple state went all blue. And now I’ll have ten dollar gas.
You ADDED to the debt!!! ADDED to it! I don’t care why you lost. I want to know why you kicked ordinary Americans in the teeth. Don’t give me crap about you lowered taxes for special groups. Not for me. Mine were higher. I now have to stay at home. That’s my option. It’s over $100 to fill the tank. So I have to sit at home. My cat needed a checkup. I had to CROWDFUND IT.
I’m being told by compassionate right wingers now that I shouldn’t have a cat!!! A cat is too much of a luxury????
Where the heII are the apologies for what you’ve done to us?!!!!! Whining about votes. Give me a break. Let’s replace all of YOUR jobs with AI. Both sides. ALL of you. Go. Yes. The Dems will be worse and you did that to us too. You made me crowdfund to take my cat to the vet. 😢😢😢😢😢.
You don’t know how terrible life is now for us. You don’t know. And if one more person tells me I could have saved up to go to the vet if I had forgone the luxury item of tiny tacos I’m blocking you. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is turning Shakespearean. With Trump as Othello and JD Vance as Iago.
It looks like the second Iran War is about to break out in the Oval Office...
JD Vance
@JDVance
One of the things the data analysts on our side obsessed over was "composition"—whether the electorate looked close enough to 2024 for Republicans to win. And despite polls that showed a Democrat blowout, the data kept on telling us the same story: in some states turnout was merely OK, in other states it was downright amazing, and in no state was it catastrophic. There was a genuine sense of optimism on our team: our people were showing up.
So, I asked the smartest data guy I know, does that mean we're going to shock the world? "No," he told me. "We might do better than the polls suggest. But the data is telling us that a lot of Trump/Vance 2024 voters are pissed and planning to vote for the other guys. Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us."
Well, that looks prophetic now. Our voters did show up. In Florida, for example, the electorate was 9 points more Republican than Democrat, just a couple points worse than 2024. Undoubtedly there were places we could have done better on turnout. But the main problem is not turnout. The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026.
There will be a lot of infighting and arguing over what happened and why that is. One of the pollsters I really respect told me that our economic messaging wasn’t sharp enough down the stretch. I’m sure that’s true.
But the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone.
Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were:
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to Israel
Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. This is according to a pollster who nailed the results. While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. (She’s also a great person.)
In the next few months, there's going to be a lot of gaslighting. Expect to hear any number of establishment politicians say the solution to our woes is amnesty. I'm open to the idea that we should change enforcement—by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labor, for instance. But anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you.
The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night.
If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest.
But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there.
I remain hopeful about our country. To the people who are pissed off and want to say, “I told you so”: you’re right, you did tell us so. Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview. To the people who are just pissed at the results, you should be. Let’s take that anger and get back to the work of saving our country. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EconomicsAotearoa
@economicsNZ
No matter how close writers come to admitting that the only way a sovereign monetary system works is by government issuing new money that is credited to accounts that provision its actions. Bond issuance doesn’t create government spending. nzglobaleconomicscontext.substack.com/p/here-we-go-again-…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
There's something important that almost everyone is missing today as America breathes a sigh of relief that Trump has finally been gut-checked. It's that the damage Trump has already inflicted on the world's supply chains of energy, fertilizer, sulfur, natural gas, distillates and other Persian Gulf exports WILL TAKE MANY YEARS TO RECOVER to 2025 levels. (5 - 7 years is currently my best guess.)
There is an assumption that if the war ends tomorrow (which it almost certainly won't), that suddenly oil flows and fertilizer flows will instantly resume. And that food prices and diesel prices will instantly fall. I can assure you this is NOT the case!
Trump's war of choice against Iran will continue to inflict extreme damage to the global GDP, global food production, and global trade for years to come. 2027 is going to be a year of mass famine, even if the war ends tomorrow. There have been NEAR-ZERO transport ships with fertilizer sailing out of the Persian Gulf for months, and that's not going to change overnight.
The destroyed gas infrastructure of QatarEnergy is already admitted to require a 3-5 year repair schedule. Oil refineries, pumping stations, pipelines and storage infrastructure will also require many years for repair. Saudi Arabia has intentionally hidden the severity of damage inflicted on its own infrastructure by Iran, and no one in the corporate media has reported the full extent of this damage.
Meanwhile, insurance costs for covering tankers and transport ships will almost certainly stay elevated for an extended period of time, and the number of tankers already damaged or destroyed removes those from the global fleet of available ocean transport, which is a small, finite number that's already stretched thin.
Even worse, Trump is still in charge of the military and almost certainly still blackmailed by Satanyahu. We are nowhere out of the woods yet on all this, and all it takes at this point is one spark ignited by Satanyahu for the entire region to erupt yet again, with devastating consequences for the global movement of energy, fertilizer, industrial chemicals and more.
The world will not be safe until:
1) Trump is utterly removed from the White House and sent packing or fleeing to wherever.
2) The warmongering NEOCON sh-tbags in the Trump administration are all extricated from positions of power and metaphorically tarred and feathered.
3) The Zionistas / AIPAC controllers are exorcised from the Republican party like a Catholic priest performing a demon exorcism from a human host whose head is spinning in circles.
4) Satanyahu is removed from power and imprisoned in his home country (an increasingly likely outcome, but we'll see).
As long as Trump and Satanyahu continue to function in any positions of power, the entire world will be held hostage by their war crimes, their arrogance, their cruelty and their shocking disregard for human life.
The midterm outcomes show a strong wave of pushback against Trump's warmongering ways, but without him being removed from power, the entire world will remain hostage to the deranged whims of a delusional, compromised and corrupt "mad king."
Humanity deserves better than this. I would say "rise up with pitchforks" but it's not the 19th century, so we'll need to push hard in every other way possible to remove these monsters from positions of power from which they will continue to threaten humanity and the world. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
True. All economists in this field share the delusion that the weak relationship between temperature and GDP today can be used as a proxy for the effect on the economy of temperature change over time. This is a dangerous fallacy.
Rust Never Sleeps / George Morrison 🇨🇦
@rustneversleepz
Weitzman believed that Nordhaus deserved the Nobel Prize - primarily for his work on climate - *long* before he eventually won it.👇
Similarly, Nordhaus had thought and expected his MIT PhD classmate, colleague and friend, Weitzman, deserved to share his Nobel [along with Nick Stern, who is seated to Weitzman’s right in the clip👇. To Weitzman's left are Nobelists Tom Schelling and Robert Solow (Solow was the PhD advisor to both Weitzman and Nordhaus)].
There was far more overlap in the climate economics of Nordhaus' and Weitzman’s (*much* later) work than differences. And despite all of Weitzman's work on fat-tailed uncertainty, he still favoured an augmented expected utility approach (e.g., DICE but with Bayesian updating, more Monte Carlo) for modeling for policy analysis. He still recommended cutting off the fat tails to make the analysis tractable and policy relevant.
There's a lot of unexamined, cartoon, cherry-picked, quote-mining caricatures of Saint Weitzman vs Voldemort Nordhaus that don't match their actual research contributions and commentary. Easy to bluster, tougher to support. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q4 2026 GDP nowcast rose 0.2 percentage points to 0.8% today.
The entire upward revision came from an improved net export outlook following the latest US trade data.
Growth remains weak, with domestic demand showing little change.
Article in post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I suspect Austrian economists would defend a toll booth at the entrance to their own mother's vagina if someone called it private property.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Craig Murray
@CraigMurrayOrg
My hotel room was forced while I was in the Supreme Court and the jamb spilt apart. But nothing was taken, £180 cash left on the table.
Please note just in case. I am not suicidal, I have the most wonderful family and friends and many battles to fight. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
José Sousa
@jmsousa
«Including all factors, the final estimate is that the damages are 2.1% of global income at a 3 °C warming, and 8.5% of income at a 6 °C warming.» (Nordhaus, 2016)
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alexander Ač
@Lacertko
Deadly fallacy.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
True. All economists in this field share the delusion that the weak relationship between temperature and GDP today can be used as a proxy for the effect on the economy of temperature change over time. This is a dangerous fallacy.
Rust Never Sleeps / George Morrison 🇨🇦
@rustneversleepz
Weitzman believed that Nordhaus deserved the Nobel Prize - primarily for his work on climate - *long* before he eventually won it.👇
Similarly, Nordhaus had thought and expected his MIT PhD classmate, colleague and friend, Weitzman, deserved to share his Nobel [along with Nick Stern, who is seated to Weitzman’s right in the clip👇. To Weitzman's left are Nobelists Tom Schelling and Robert Solow (Solow was the PhD advisor to both Weitzman and Nordhaus)].
There was far more overlap in the climate economics of Nordhaus' and Weitzman’s (*much* later) work than differences. And despite all of Weitzman's work on fat-tailed uncertainty, he still favoured an augmented expected utility approach (e.g., DICE but with Bayesian updating, more Monte Carlo) for modeling for policy analysis. He still recommended cutting off the fat tails to make the analysis tractable and policy relevant.
There's a lot of unexamined, cartoon, cherry-picked, quote-mining caricatures of Saint Weitzman vs Voldemort Nordhaus that don't match their actual research contributions and commentary. Easy to bluster, tougher to support. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I've updated every model at @GDPDynamics to account for the release of GTA 6 on November 19th.
Expect productivity to collapse, millions of suspicious sick days, and some dipshit Austrian economist explaining why it's all the Federal Reserve's fucking fault. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Passenger
@gordonschuecker
Never forget to link your masterpiece here...
x.com/gordonschuecker/status/1279587488177283073
@rustneversleepz, can you please confirm that you endorse this correlation analysis?
The Passenger
@gordonschuecker
5/44 TL;DR II
My "favorite" crux of their research: finding a correlation between temperature and GDP and using that to forecast GDP damage due to climate change. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
True. All economists in this field share the delusion that the weak relationship between temperature and GDP today can be used as a proxy for the effect on the economy of temperature change over time. This is a dangerous fallacy.
Rust Never Sleeps / George Morrison 🇨🇦
@rustneversleepz
Weitzman believed that Nordhaus deserved the Nobel Prize - primarily for his work on climate - *long* before he eventually won it.👇
Similarly, Nordhaus had thought and expected his MIT PhD classmate, colleague and friend, Weitzman, deserved to share his Nobel [along with Nick Stern, who is seated to Weitzman’s right in the clip👇. To Weitzman's left are Nobelists Tom Schelling and Robert Solow (Solow was the PhD advisor to both Weitzman and Nordhaus)].
There was far more overlap in the climate economics of Nordhaus' and Weitzman’s (*much* later) work than differences. And despite all of Weitzman's work on fat-tailed uncertainty, he still favoured an augmented expected utility approach (e.g., DICE but with Bayesian updating, more Monte Carlo) for modeling for policy analysis. He still recommended cutting off the fat tails to make the analysis tractable and policy relevant.
There's a lot of unexamined, cartoon, cherry-picked, quote-mining caricatures of Saint Weitzman vs Voldemort Nordhaus that don't match their actual research contributions and commentary. Easy to bluster, tougher to support. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniel Muvdi
@DanielMuvdiYT
Ya empezó a pasar, y lo vengo diciendo desde hace meses: esto era inevitable.
Revolut, la empresa privada más grande de Europa, decidió adoptar modelos chinos de IA de pesos abiertos, ejecutados en su propia infraestructura, y dejar herramientas como Claude Code y Codex para casos excepcionales.
Con 56 GPU Nvidia B200, están ejecutando GLM a un costo promedio de apenas $0,30 por millón de tokens, un 90% menos de lo que pagaban a OpenAI y Anthropic, y reportan una reducción del 70% en los tiempos de desarrollo.
Esto es precisamente lo que llevo meses anticipando. A medida que los modelos abiertos mejoran y las empresas desarrollan su propia infraestructura, la dependencia de las API propietarias comienza a perder sentido económico.
Y aquí hay un problema enorme para las valoraciones actuales del sector: el crecimiento del consumo de tokens no necesariamente se traducirá en un crecimiento proporcional de los ingresos.
Revolut no es una pequeña startup experimentando con IA. Es una de las mayores fintech del mundo, y ya está haciendo las cuentas.
Y entonces, ¿cuál es realmente la ventaja competitiva de los modelos frontier? Si los modelos abiertos ya pueden hacer prácticamente lo mismo, son gratuitos para instalar en tu propia infraestructura, cuestan 10 veces menos y permiten reducir los tiempos de desarrollo un 70%, ¿qué justifica seguir pagando esas diferencias?
Además, mantienes el control de tus datos, la privacidad de tus aplicaciones y tu código, sin depender de terceros ni aceptar restricciones sobre lo que tú mismo desarrollas. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
Good morning everyone.
Except Laura Loomer.
An insane woman, two time congressional loser, who has zero real life experience yet Natalie Harp somehow helped Laura become Trump’s crazy train late night advisor.
Make her the press secretary!
Make her chief of staff!
Give Laura something!
Please entertain me! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alexander Ač
@Lacertko
Painfull reading!
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Tipping Points.
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/tipping-points-173937575
Chapter 23 in my forthcoming book “How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Higher interest rates currently cause a lot of damage in the Eurozone. They increase interest payments to bond holders (of new bonds) and make it harder for member states to hit (dysfunctional) budget deficit limits.
(Source for the figure: 25bp.eu/en/ecb/) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Martin Tye
@martinrev21
To survive long term on this planet we must downsize.
I really don't think most fully understand how extreme our current state of overshoot is,
... nor do they comprehend how far we must lower our demands on the planet. That reality would blow most people's minds! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EGA
@ega1f
It's pretty crazy to watch the end of the Civilization unfold.
People have been asking what's the Great Filter that stops Aliens from blanketing the Galaxy. We are living in it and showing it's just dumb animal greed that does Civs in. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝗚⃪𝗿⃪𝘂⃪𝗺⃪𝗽⃪𝘆⃪ 𝗚⃪𝗻⃪𝗼⃪𝗺⃪𝗲⃪
@Gnome4308
Dave Smith called it
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oğuz Arslan
@asi2otus
Our new article has been published. Many thanks to Prof. Keen @ProfSteveKeen, who developed the GMK model.
iupress.istanbul.edu.tr/journal/jpfs/article/an-analysis-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Substance
@SimplySubstance
Mehdi Hasan has TWO WORDS for all the Abdul HATERS:
“CRY MORE!—I just wanted to get that off my chest because I’ve been F*CKED OFF with these people for so long!” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Occupy Democrats
@OccupyDemocrats
BREAKING: SWEET REVENGE! The Navy Admiral who Pete Hegseth fired DEFEATS her MAGA opponent to win a House seat in South Carolina — cementing the blue tsunami with a poetic flourish!
This is just too beautiful...
Democrat Nancy Lacore, a 35-year Navy veteran who rose through the ranks from helicopter pilot to become Chief of Navy Reserve, was fired in August of 2025 amid Hegseth's purging of high-ranking women in the military. While no official reason was given, the deeply misogynistic Hegseth has not been coy about his caveman belief that only testosterone-injecting men should serve.
Lacore has now defeated Republican Jenny Costa Honeycutt to seize a seat that was formerly held by MAGA lunatic Nancy Mace who launched a failed bid for the governor's mansion this year.
Lacore has not been shy about criticizing Hegseth's disastrous mismanagement of the Defense Department, particularly his failed Iran War.
"Pete Hegseth is the most unqualified Secretary of Defense that we have ever had, and he is doing significant damage to our military that it will really take decades to undo," she said, adding that he "needs to go."
The most beautiful irony here? Congresswoman Lacore could soon be voting with the rest of the Democratic majority in the House to impeach Pete Hegseth. We have subpoena power starting in January, so we'll be able to uncover all of the gross negligence and rampant criminality that he's overseen.
Ain't karma grand?
Please ❤️ and share if you support impeaching Pete Hegseth! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
💧🌞John Troughton
@JoYohana
It was not just climate change. To me his position on system dynamics and especially killing “Limits to Growth” 1972……54 years of inaction as a consequence !!!! was more grotesque and could an economist estimate the economic impact of that. We had solutions then that were killed. !!!!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Wrighty of Kent
@wrightysback
I spent the first two decades of my "career" doing just that - circulating funds in the secondary market - hence why I allow myself to say that at least 85% of that activity has no social value whatever, and basically leeches off the rest of society.
Then I went into teaching. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Boston University Global Development Policy Center
@GDP_Center
Global imbalances are back, and the conventional diagnosis may be wrong.
Conventional analysis by the International Monetary Fund, G7 + OECD traces the imbalances to domestic saving–investment gaps, pointing to "excess saving in China and the EU, and too little saving in the United States."
In a new working paper, GDP Center Non-Resident Senior Fellow @YanLian31677392 + Center Director @KevinPGallagher argue that the root cause of the imbalances is in fact the financial imbalances generated by the international monetary and financial system (IMFS) itself. Dollar dominance and the lack of a credible global lender of last resort push countries to self-insure.
For this month's T20 Summit in New York, the authors contribute to a policy brief ahead of the December G20 Leaders' Summit. They present two priorities for G20 discussions on imbalances:
📍 Strengthening the global financial safety net (GFSN)
📍 Accelerating multilateral development bank (MDB) reform
The goal is to make these systems "not just bigger, but better."
📄 Read the working paper: gdpcenter.org/3UYqFCV
📄 Read the T20 policy brief: gdpcenter.org/47VEKUA
#g20 #imf #oecd #t20 #gfsn #globalimbalances -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mary L Trump
@MaryLTrump
Thank you, Donald, for all of your hard work (i.e., incompetence, corruption, treason, and betrayal of the American people) in ensuring Democrats win in a way that will make your life miserable for the next two years--and make our lives better.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
The EU was always an anti-democracy project. Strip nations of their sovereignty, strip them of their currency, strip them of their dignity. An appalling creation by neoliberal technocrats and greedy failed politicians.
Ewa Zajączkowska-Hernik
@EwaZajaczkowska
🚨 Maski opadły❗ Komisja Europejska oficjalnie wsparła bandyckie działania Tuska i siłowe przejęcie Trybunału Konstytucyjnego❗
Proszę o podawanie dalej, bo widać jak na dłoni, że mamy do czynienia z antypolskim porozumieniem Ursuli von der Leyen i Donalda Tuska, którzy ponad głowami polskich obywateli chcą przejąć kontrolę nad fundamentalnym dla naszego porządku prawnego organem konstytucyjnym.
Mimo, że Komisja Europejska nie ma ŻADNEGO prawa do decydowania w sprawach wymiaru sprawiedliwości, bo nikomu Polska nie przekazała takich kompetencji, to wystosowała stanowisko, które mówi wszystko: "Trybunał Konstytucyjny powinien funkcjonować zgodnie z polską konstytucją ORAZ orzecznictwem Trybunału Sprawiedliwości Unii Europejskiej."
I tu leży sedno sprawy - do tej pory Trybunał Konstytucyjny orzekał, że polska Konstytucja stoi ponad prawem unijnym, a celem Brukseli jest, żebyśmy byli pod butem UE i jej trybunałów! Polska ustawa zasadnicza ma być na drugim miejscu.
Chcą całkowicie podporządkować sobie Polskę, a do tego niezbędne jest uznanie przez polski TK wyroku TSUE o nadrzędności prawa unijnego nad Konstytucją RP. Oni już nawet nie zamierzają udawać, że cokolwiek ich obchodzi fakt, iż wymiar sprawiedliwości i organy konstytucyjne to kompetencje państw członkowskich. Idą na rympał w imię niemiecko-brukselskich interesów, a Tusk to ich narzędzie do osiągnięcia celu.
Oto prawdziwa twarz Komisji Europejskiej, wielkich "obrońców demokracji". To instytucja, której najważniejsi urzędnicy w ostatnich latach są po uszy umoczeni w korupcję i różnego rodzaju wały. To instytucja, dla który liczy się tylko władza, wpływy i kasa. Nic innego. Obok praworządności to oni nawet nie stali, ale chętnie wycierają sobie nią gęby, wszyscy na czele z von der Leyen.
Dlatego powtarzam @vonderleyen i całej @EU_Commission - ręce precz od Polski❗🇵🇱
Jesteście siedliskiem bezprawia i korupcji, za co płacą wszyscy obywatele, a żaden z nich nie wybrał was na funkcje, które pełnicie! Waszą Komisję Europejską należy zlikwidować, bo to rak, który od wielu lat niszczy europejską Wspólnotę i działa przeciwko suwerennych państwom narodowym! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Blair Fix @blair_fix@mastodon.online
@blair_fix
This cements why economists have nothing useful to say about climate change. Pure. Garbage.
fee.org/articles/the-economics-of-climate-change-what-uni… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
Ücretin, fiyatın, faizin, döviz kurunun, para arzının nasıl belirlendiğine anaakım ve post-Keynesyen teorilerin cevaplarını özetledim.
Deneyimlere ve verilere göre kendiniz karar verin, hangisi doğru.
Gidin firmalara sorun; marjinal maliyet, marjinal hasılat hesaplıyorlar mı..
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
Yaw ne ücretlerin nasıl belirlendiğini doğru biliyorlar, ne fiyatların, ne faizin, ne de döviz kurunun.
Döviz kuru, finansal akımlar tarafından değil, ithalat-ihracat hacmi tarafından belirleniyorsa, niye kur arttığında ithalat kotası getirmiyorsunuz da faiz artırıyorsunuz?This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
#MMT #MoralMoneyTime #liftism 1st #liftist
@samvega
Yes. The Nordhaus 'Nobel' for #climatecrisis denial was the worst Nobel Prize of any sort ever.
You'd as well give a Nobel Peace Prize to Donald Trump. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
ON THE SCARCITY OF RESOURCES
In the neoclassical tradition, scarcity does not mean physical rarity, but rather the limited availability of resources relative to human wants and their alternative uses. At the same time, human wants are assumed to be unlimited by default.
It follows that no resource can, by definition, ever be considered abundant relative to all possible wants. This proposition cannot be falsified through observation. Even with 20% unemployment, labor remains scarce within this framework relative to potential wants. Unused labor is therefore explained not by an abundance of labor, but by coordination failures (price rigidities, frictions) or the voluntary choice of leisure. Unemployment becomes an anomaly that must be explained by something preventing the market price mechanism from functioning properly.
But in the real world, production responds not to human needs, but to effective demand backed by MONEY. Unemployed and hungry people can coexist with warehouses full of unsold goods.
An assumption that cannot be empirically tested is an ideological assumption in the truest sense. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Fred Trump
@FredTrump_
Take it from me folks, cause I have been there. I pity the poor bastards near my uncle tonight.
#democracy @Scaramucci -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economics truly attracts some extraordinary intellectual talent. Neoclassical economists build elaborate mathematical models of economies that don't exist, while Austrian economists reject the mathematics so nobody can prove their imaginary economy is bullshit.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Albert Bxl
@AlbertBxl1
"Nordhaus long claimed that from the standpoint of “economic rationality” it is “optimal” to keep warming the planet to about 3.5 degrees Celsius over preindustrial level"
mronline.org/2018/12/12/the-nobel-prize-for-climate-catas… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
A short summary of mainstream and post-Keynesian theories on how wages, prices, interest rates, exchange rates and the money supply are determined.
Which one explains better experience and data?
Ask firms if they calculate marginal productivity, marginal cost and marginal revenue -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
William Peynsaert
@PeynsaertBill
The indomitable girl who captured him was waiting for him thirty years later
On September 21, 1965, a 17-year-old Vietnamese girl named Nguyễn Thị Kim Lai was photographed escorting an enormous American airman through the countryside. His hands were tied behind his back. His head was bowed. She was carrying a rifle.
His name was William Andrew Robinson. He was 22, a helicopter mechanic and flight engineer in the US Air Force. The previous day his helicopter had been shot down during a mission to rescue another American airman.
Kim Lai was tiny. She weighed 37 kilograms. She had only finished seventh grade before joining the local militia. Her home province, Hà Tĩnh, was being bombed relentlessly by American aircraft.
According to her recollection, she discovered Robinson hiding among the rocks in a forest. Frightened by his enormous size, she fired three warning shots. He surrendered. Other militia members arrived and tied his hands.
A photographer named Phan Thoan captured the extraordinary contrast between the two.
The photograph became famous throughout Vietnam. It appeared on postage stamps. A celebrated Vietnamese poet wrote a poem about it. The image travelled around the world, becoming a symbol of a small country resisting a superpower.
Robinson was taken to prison.
He spent 2,703 days in captivity. Seven years, four months and twenty-three days. Much of it in isolation, enduring brutal conditions and torture. He was finally released on February 12, 1973.
Kim Lai became a nurse. She married, had three children and eventually became a grandmother.
Thirty years after their first encounter, in September 1995, she was playing with her grandchildren at a neighbour's house when someone came to tell her that foreigners were looking for her.
She returned home.
Standing there was William Andrew Robinson.
He had come back to Vietnam with a Japanese documentary crew. He had apparently wanted to find her for years but had never been able to afford the journey.
She recognised him immediately.
According to her recollection, he approached and embraced her before she could greet him.
They talked about their lives. Their families. Everything that had happened since those few minutes in a Vietnamese forest.
They even returned to the place where he had been captured.
Robinson reportedly expressed the hope that there would never be another photograph like theirs.
There is another photograph of them, taken during that reunion.
She is looking up at him. Smiling. He is standing beside her, still towering over her. No handcuffs. No rifle.
With no US government throwing away the youth of its own citizens to forcefully decide the future of Vietnam both can stand tall side by side. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
According to mainstream theory, bond holders who forecasted last month that inflation in October 2036 will be 5.3% changed their mind and concluded that inflation in November 2036 will be 4.9%.
What a precise forecast, right?
They sell this bullshit as 'science'..
The Kobeissi Letter
@KobeissiLetter
Investors are rushing into Treasuries:
The ratio of the Nasdaq 100 to the 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF, $TLT, is down to 342.5, its lowest since July 31st.
Since the all-time high recorded on October 7th, this ratio has fallen -15.4%.
Over this period, $TLT has risen +7.1%, while the Nasdaq 100 has fallen -10.2%.
This puts the ratio on track for its 5th consecutive weekly decline, its longest losing streak since the 2022 bear market.
Similar sharp drops in this metric were also recorded between February and April 2025 and during the 2020 pandemic.
Investors are buying bonds to protect against an AI selloff. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
The midterms are just the beginning. Let me explain what happens after tonight’s elections and why every American should be paying attention. 🚨
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
What is remarkable is that anyone (especially the @NobelPrize) fell for Nordhaus’ garbage:
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
Nordhaus is a fool. Sectors he claims are UNAFFECTED by climate (pic 1) incl.:
- Mining (ILO says mining IS impacted)
- Lumber out, but forestry in?
- Mined stone/metal products out (see mining above)
- Food/textiles magically safe but derived from farming/forestry?
- Roads/rail 'non-water transport' magically unaffected (WTF)
- Non-land real estate, safe (WTAF)
- Insurance (WTAAF)
List of subsectors ignored by Nordhaus (86.9% of GDP) in pic 2: -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I’ll second that.
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
Nordhaus was objectively an imbecile (link). By induction, so are you:
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
Nordhaus is a fool. Sectors he claims are UNAFFECTED by climate (pic 1) incl.:
- Mining (ILO says mining IS impacted)
- Lumber out, but forestry in?
- Mined stone/metal products out (see mining above)
- Food/textiles magically safe but derived from farming/forestry?
- Roads/rail 'non-water transport' magically unaffected (WTF)
- Non-land real estate, safe (WTAF)
- Insurance (WTAAF)
List of subsectors ignored by Nordhaus (86.9% of GDP) in pic 2: -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It shows how deluded the discipline is—the dominant Neoclassical (and Austrian) wing to be precise. Only a deluded discipline could fail to see the obvious flaws in Nordhaus’s work
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
What is remarkable is that anyone (especially the @NobelPrize) fell for Nordhaus’ garbage:
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
Nordhaus is a fool. Sectors he claims are UNAFFECTED by climate (pic 1) incl.:
- Mining (ILO says mining IS impacted)
- Lumber out, but forestry in?
- Mined stone/metal products out (see mining above)
- Food/textiles magically safe but derived from farming/forestry?
- Roads/rail 'non-water transport' magically unaffected (WTF)
- Non-land real estate, safe (WTAF)
- Insurance (WTAAF)
List of subsectors ignored by Nordhaus (86.9% of GDP) in pic 2: -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marcus Gibson
@Marcusgibson
Nordhaus is a fool. Sectors he claims are UNAFFECTED by climate (pic 1) incl.:
- Mining (ILO says mining IS impacted)
- Lumber out, but forestry in?
- Mined stone/metal products out (see mining above)
- Food/textiles magically safe but derived from farming/forestry?
- Roads/rail 'non-water transport' magically unaffected (WTF)
- Non-land real estate, safe (WTAF)
- Insurance (WTAAF)
List of subsectors ignored by Nordhaus (86.9% of GDP) in pic 2: -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
In my ongoing critique of usury I don't want anyone to think private moneylending is entirely costless. However, we can divide the costs into two categories.
The first category covers obvious real costs. The second category covers what we might call hypothetical implicit bollocks we've just made up as potential risks but we want more interest to line our pockets otherwise you can f*ck off and do without the money and we'll find some other mug to lend it to costs.
1. Real Costs
Adminstrative costs such as employee salaries, tech and buildings, and inflation that causes a reduction in the repayment's purchasing power over time. So some (usually single-figure) interest payment can be justified in reality.
2. Hypothetical Implicit Bollocks Costs
Opportunity costs such as returns lost by not investing in the next best option, the 'risk of default' cost demanding a premium, the cost of locking up cash and losing flexibility, which demands a liquidity premium, and, most nebulous of all, compensation for the sheer uncertainty of what might happen over time. Oh, diddums. Justifiable? You decide. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
We are stumbling into a food catastrophe because of climate change with few media or politicians seeming to understand it.
Kellogg’s are no longer using rice in rice crispies and cocoa pops. They are using ‘rice flour’ because rice has become so expensive because of ‘changing weather conditions’.
@piersmorgan @mrjamesob @TomSwarbrick1 @vicderbyshire @jonsopel @maitlis @Emmabarnett @tombradby @WilfredFrost @CliveMyrieBBC @amolrajan @SophyRidgeSky @TVNaga01 @OborneTweets @JohnSimpsonNews @richardpbacon @rickedwards1 @MickBooker @MartinDaubney @PatrickChristys @MichelleDewbs @KamaliMelbourne @BBCsarahsmith @kirstiemallsopp
@krishgm @tombradby @skynews @itvnews @ITNProductions @esmewren @adamboultonTABB @KayBurley @alexberesfordTV @kayeadams @janem @rickygervais @rachelburden @bbcnews @skynews @NickyAACampbell @ShelaghFogarty @BenKentish @bbcnickrobinson @tomhfh @susannareid100 @alexberesfordTV
The Grocer
@TheGrocer
Kellogg’s removes rice from Rice Krispies and Coco Pops
Blaming “changing weather conditions” for the recipe overhaul
www.thegrocer.co.uk/news/kelloggs-drops-rice-from-rice-kr… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
José Sousa
@jmsousa
That is pathetic. Nordhaus is a fraud as climate economist.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cai Stark ☭
@CaiStark
The problem is that Hausfather is just as big a supporter of that economic system as Nordhaus.
He’s less obvious about it, more subtle, and better at portraying himself as an enlightened climate leader, but he’s not.
Calling Nordhaus a “climate economics giant” rather… -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
We might as well laugh about it!
Mike's Weather Page
@tropicalupdate
BREAKING NEWS: Port Canaveral welcomes its newest cruise ship after all this flooding rain.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cai Stark ☭
@CaiStark
…than something more honest, like a”fool and a disgrace bordering on the criminal” is just an unusually candid expression of his position: that growth-forward capitalism must be assumed as our social foundation and all environmental issues have to be addressed with that…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EconomicsAotearoa
@economicsNZ
A claim that a massive 4 degrees C global warming would be survivable was dismantled by @ProfSteveKeen
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Which you can find in brief here: theconversation.com/4-c-of-global-warming-is-optimal-even…
And in much more detail in my report for @CarbonBubble "Loading the DICE against Pensions" carbontracker.org/reports/loading-the-dice-against-pensions/
José Sousa
@jmsousa
Climate economics giants? Excuse me, his work is a disgrace. He was a kind of a high priest defending an economic system that is leading us to catastrophe. Professor Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen as wrote a damning critique of his work.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
He did indeed. But politicians and journalists didn't get the message. They only listened to economists, and their forecasts of trivial damages below 6C of warming. Hence we're on the way to HELL.
CAPITALISM HATING SHARKS & AND ALL THEIR ALLIES
@OMEGAGENERATIO1
He legitimized not taking drastic action to lower emissions, he pushed it wouldn't be that bad for economics growth. He became the darling of capitalist who never had any intentions to slow emissions and infinite GDP. He proved with clarity never listen to economist on climate.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Or rather, he set up the framework that has made all of (Neoclassical) climate change economics fraudulent.
José Sousa
@jmsousa
That is pathetic. Nordhaus is a fraud as climate economist.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
Brilliant breakdown by @ProfHall1955 of how our financial system is stuck in a 4k-year delusion that treats money as a scarce resource when in reality govts create it out of thin air. Yet Whitehall bureaucrats, govt ministers & corporate media hacks dishonestly peddle the delusion.
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Yes indeed. The bond market's inflation-stoking disciplinary authority is an outcome of the general belief system. Every issue or transfer of credit is unthinkingly regarded as an interest-bearing private loan despite the irrefutable fact that governments, central banks and licensed commercial banks create money at will ex nihilo. After its beginning as a criminal operation 4400 years ago in Mesopotamia (corrupt Palace/Temple officials and merchants privately lending silver currency out of the back door for up to 30% interest), the belief system, its practices and its social relations were politically institutionalised around 3500 years ago as the moneylenders acquired land in repayment for bad debts, circumvented the debt jubilee rule and established themselves as the 'landed aristocracy'. Compounding and rolling debt was a major factor behind two civilizational collapses, and the system survived the anti-usury codes of the revealed religions - "and lead us not into temptation". It's now culturally and neuropsychologically embedded ('emotionally credible') and systemically locked in (fiscal overreach triggers automatic and predictable punishments) on a mass scale. Breaking out of it would be epochal yet, oddly, a restoration of the principles behind the Bronze Age Palace/Temple system. In the West, we just don't have institutions as strong and stable or a culture as collectively responsible as they were in that period - we have dysfunctional oligarch-captured states adminstered by bought-off, equivocating central bankers and politicians and the perverse conflation of asset accumulation with personal freedom. Technically, if we had informed populations we don't need a worldwide revolution but, realistically, we possibly do.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Spot bloody on.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economics might be the only profession where you can spend your entire career explaining why something shouldn't happen, watch it happen repeatedly, and still get invited on television to explain why it didn't really happen.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
Here's a "gotcha" moment showing how incompetent or dishonest Mises was. In private, Mises admitted to George Reisman (an Austrian) that prices of produced capital goods were "determined by their cost of production", which Mises denies in Human Action:
mises.org/mises-wire/more-bohm-bawerk-cost-production-det…
Immanuel
@Kondylise
Da reason the entrepreneur presently acquires the factor is what they expect that factor to accomplish toward future ends
Any objections with this?
If Mises’ use of “directly” & “exclusively” were causing u much trouble, I would like to hear ur opinions directed at MY wording -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Early warnings"? You mean his "warning" that 3°C of warming by 2100 would reduce GDP in 2100 by 1/4 of 1%--compared to what it would have been in the absence of global warming? That's not a warning, that's an encouragement.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economics might be the only profession where you can spend your entire career explaining why something shouldn't happen, watch it happen repeatedly, and still get invited on television to explain why it didn't really happen.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
DiEM25
@DiEM_25
🔴 URGENT: Our bank has cut us off from our own money.
Our bills haven’t stopped. Neither can our work. Help us build an emergency fund to keep DiEM25 going. Even €10 makes a difference.
Donate now: i.diem25.org/donations/to/debankingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
I’m sure we are due another @KonstantinKisin @francisjfoster podcast interview with a fossil fuel stooge telling us climate change scientists are wrong and really Net zero is the problem… it’s been a while
2 media couldn't be displayed. See them on the original post. -
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Early warnings"? You mean his "warning" that 3°C of warming by 2100 would reduce GDP in 2100 by 1/4 of 1%--compared to what it would have been in the absence of global warming? That's not a warning, that's an encouragement.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Politicians that deny climate change and take money from the Fossil Fuel industry should be prosecuted.
It really is as simple as that.
They should be in jail.
Rick Addante, PhD
@RickAddante
River rapids. Elderly stuck flooded on all sides
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
Someone never heard of endogenous money theory. Typical Austrian school ignorance.
TM Matus
@TMSallis
When money supply outpaces activity, that's when you get a sustained price increase (that's not offset by fewer goods offered, due to concentration of costs). Given the government monopoly on money that MMTers love to go on about, you surely understand where it comes from
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jeff Berardelli
@WeatherProf
FLORIDA’S EXTRAORDINARY DELUGE 🌧️
Wait for it…
An estimated 1.88 TRILLION gallons of rain in 57 hours across the area shown—enough to cover 145,000 football fields, including end zones, 30 feet deep!
Radar estimates 30 inches near Palm Bay, with multiple torrential rainfall peaks stretching down Florida’s east coast. The radar-map area saw more than 2 dozen distinct Flash Flood Warnings, including rare #florida Flash Flood Emergencies.
The geographic extent and repeated extreme totals make this an extraordinary, perhaps unprecedented, non-tropical #rain #flood event.
A historic El Niño favors wetter Florida weather. Today’s warmer oceans and atmosphere also increase the moisture available to fuel extreme downpours. #elninoThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Listen to this woman’s pain.
I am not gloating. She says she is a Conservative.
Her home is flooded, and she says she’s ruined.
This really makes me want to cry because climate change has been clear for the last 40 years. It should never have become a politically divisive issue. It’s literally a matter of life and death.
The planet is hotter now than it’s been in over 100,000 years, carbon dioxide levels are higher now than in millions of years. A heating planet means greater rainfall intensity. And it’s only going to get worse.
Conservative politicians have denied its reality, the left haven’t been much better at actually facing and dealing with it, and now the consequences are hitting us all.
All of us are going to lose a lot. It’s devastating.
We need to come together, regardless of politics, left and right, and stop those people who exist to prop up the fossil fuel industry, and get lobbying and money out of politics.
We need to stop billionaires owning and controlling media.
We are very very late now.
We need to educate each other and wake up because everything is at risk: youtu.be/2Jq23mSDh9UThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
The ‘loanable funds theory of interest’ is a load of old nonsense.
Which is partly why lifting interest rates does not reliably down-regulate inflation:
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Much of the confusion surrounding modern banking operations stems from the fact that people still think of banks as warehouses for money or mere intermediaries between savers and borrowers.
In reality, a commercial bank is first and foremost a profit-seeking business, with one crucial distinction: through lending, it can create its own liabilities, which function as money.
This is why modern banking is much better understood through balance sheets than through the metaphor of transferring pre-existing money from one person to another. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alexander Ač
@Lacertko
With all the respect, but "giant" of climate economics? Some have much less positive view of him. @ProfSteveKeen
Zeke Hausfather
@hausfath
With William Nordhaus' recent passing the field of climate economics has lost one of its giants.
Nordhaus published in 1977 what was at the time a rather bold projection: the the world would warm by 1.2C by the year 2026. In reality it warmed by 1.1C. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sci-Fi World Museum
@hollywoodscifi
Every Star Trek fan knows this story about Martin Luther King and Nichelle Nichols, but this goes into more detail and more context.
Bless them both, GiantsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Yes indeed. The bond market's inflation-stoking disciplinary authority is an outcome of the general belief system. Every issue or transfer of credit is unthinkingly regarded as an interest-bearing private loan despite the irrefutable fact that governments, central banks and licensed commercial banks create money at will ex nihilo. After its beginning as a criminal operation 4400 years ago in Mesopotamia (corrupt Palace/Temple officials and merchants privately lending silver currency out of the back door for up to 30% interest), the belief system, its practices and its social relations were politically institutionalised around 3500 years ago as the moneylenders acquired land in repayment for bad debts, circumvented the debt jubilee rule and established themselves as the 'landed aristocracy'. Compounding and rolling debt was a major factor behind two civilizational collapses, and the system survived the anti-usury codes of the revealed religions - "and lead us not into temptation". It's now culturally and neuropsychologically embedded ('emotionally credible') and systemically locked in (fiscal overreach triggers automatic and predictable punishments) on a mass scale. Breaking out of it would be epochal yet, oddly, a restoration of the principles behind the Bronze Age Palace/Temple system. In the West, we just don't have institutions as strong and stable or a culture as collectively responsible as they were in that period - we have dysfunctional oligarch-captured states adminstered by bought-off, equivocating central bankers and politicians and the perverse conflation of asset accumulation with personal freedom. Technically, if we had informed populations we don't need a worldwide revolution but, realistically, we possibly do.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
José Sousa
@jmsousa
Climate economics giants? Excuse me, his work is a disgrace. He was a kind of a high priest defending an economic system that is leading us to catastrophe. Professor Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen as wrote a damning critique of his work.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Which you can find in brief here: theconversation.com/4-c-of-global-warming-is-optimal-even…
And in much more detail in my report for @CarbonBubble "Loading the DICE against Pensions" carbontracker.org/reports/loading-the-dice-against-pensions/
José Sousa
@jmsousa
Climate economics giants? Excuse me, his work is a disgrace. He was a kind of a high priest defending an economic system that is leading us to catastrophe. Professor Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen as wrote a damning critique of his work.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Interested in economic modeling or economics in general? Come join my Discord.
Austrian economists and libertarians are especially welcome. I believe everyone deserves access to a proper economic knowledge, regardless of how far behind you are...
discord.gg/fPn6CyGj7 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
🚨The GDP Dynamics Q4 GDP nowcast has fallen to just 0.6%, down from 0.9%.
Business investment took the biggest hit, while housing construction continues to weaken.
Is the US economy heading for a sharp slowdown?
Full article in the post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The "crowding out" myth: government deficits don’t squeeze private investment.
They create net financial assets.
A thread.
🧵1/12 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Spot bloody on.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economics might be the only profession where you can spend your entire career explaining why something shouldn't happen, watch it happen repeatedly, and still get invited on television to explain why it didn't really happen.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
Post Keynesians do not reject the existence of subjective utility/value. But the fact that buyers need to subjectively value a commodity they buy does not refute the fact that most businesses do not set prices flexibly in response to demand and supply. You have nothing.
Den Rice
@RexNhongo2
Without a theory of value you either have an infinite regression or a completely arbitrary starting point. It's like the "greed" explanation for rising prices.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Much of the confusion surrounding modern banking operations stems from the fact that people still think of banks as warehouses for money or mere intermediaries between savers and borrowers.
In reality, a commercial bank is first and foremost a profit-seeking business, with one crucial distinction: through lending, it can create its own liabilities, which function as money.
This is why modern banking is much better understood through balance sheets than through the metaphor of transferring pre-existing money from one person to another. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
If the government balanced its books, it would make people in the country poorer and in deeper debt. So why do so many politicians want to do that? youtu.be/th3N-Otscgo
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
He's wrong. The issue is: how do most real-world firms and businesses actually set their prices? Answer: mark-up on average unit cost.
TM Matus
@TMSallis
He's right. How much do you want something? That's how much you'll pay to have it. That's how much cost you'll invest in producing it. It doesn't change with the complexity of an economy, just becomes more speculative for a producer the further they are from their target consumer
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
Steve Keen, 26 Oct–2 Nov 2026 updates
Book: How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism (Polity) still forthcoming (manuscript earlier sent; possible Feb 2027). No new edition or Amazon listing.
Serialised chapters (paywalled after free teaser):
• “Tipping Points”, Ch. 23, 31 Oct. profstevekeen.substack.com/p/tipping-points (Patreon equivalent).
Mechanism: climate models. Economists’ IAMs (Dietz et al. 2021; Anthoff/Estrada/Tol on AMOC) treat temperature as the sole impact and claim trivial GDP effects (~1–1.4% even at 6°C with multiple tips; AMOC slowdown net positive). Description of model structure/omissions vs climate-science outputs (energy, extremes, circulation, albedo, etc.); prescription (apply a “smell test”, use scientific climate models) is separate. Core Nordhaus/IAM damage-function critique is longstanding/recycled.
Posts:
• “The Theoretical Lie that Government Debt is Dangerous”, 27 Oct. profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-theoretical-lie-that-gov… (Patreon). Mechanism: endogenous money (deficits create private deposits via double-entry bookkeeping). Description of Ravel Godley tables showing taxation reduces private net financial worth while spending increases it; a deficit expands deposits/money supply and GDP in the simple model. Prescriptions (leave the Euro, restore the Franc, run deficits to fund education) are listed separately. Free Ravel download offered for France (to go live with related YouTube).
Related YouTube on @profstevekeen channel (Oct 26 & Nov 1): clips/videos on government debt myths and French student protests, covering the same endogenous-money + private-debt data (French private debt far exceeds government debt; post-Euro per-capita growth ~1%). Description of accounting/data; prescriptions separate.
No new dated interviews/talks this week. No Ravel/Minsky software or course releases (Ravel used illustratively; free France offer is promotional). -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Atown
@arateof
Given the impact that economists have had on public policy towards climate change, and the
immediacy of the threat we now face from climate change (Amen et al., 2008; Gills, 2020; Gills &
Morgan, 2019), this work could soon be exposed as the most significant and dangerous hoax... -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
J.L. Henshaw
@JLydiaHenshaw
That’s what I’ve been saying for decades, now. The same mental detachment brought down our first great managed economy, ~ 8000 years ago, Babel. It’s the confusing detachment of nature and numbers that causes it, and there’s new math for showing what it’s missing to help. synapse9.com/signals
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sabri Öncü
@tsoncu1
Arkadaşlar. Benim hesap da Türkiye'den erişime engellendi. Yeni hesabım budur.
@inanmutlu11 @BasaranAksu_2 @AcrNesli @mturkmenn27 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The fiscal rules are dysfunctional. Belgium and France show that clearly. There is a lot of unemployment and to cut spending in this situation would be political suicide.
Europe Elects
@EuropeElects
Belgium: Prime Minister Bart De Wever (N-VA-EFA|ECR) tenders the resignation of his government amid a failure to reach an agreement for next year's budget.
De Wever's government took office in February 2025 and included centre-right Flemish nationalist N-VA (EFA|ECR), liberal MR (ALDE), centrist CD&V (EPP), LÉ (EDP) and centre-left Vooruit (PES).
europeelects.eu/belgium/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
TARGET2 balances are not debts, but balance sheets constructs that the Eurosystem uses to make balance sheets balance at the national level. There is absolutely no news to think otherwise.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Libertarians want to abolish the government and replace it with private police, private courts, private armies, and private agencies that enforce contracts.
Congratulations, you reinvented the fucking state, except now Amazon runs it and justice requires a Prime subscription. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
tim anderson
@timand2037
Flipping the story in London. With a sign which says "I support genocide. I oppose Palestine Action" she gets no problems from the English police.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Tate
@JamesTate121
The truth is out there.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jacob Edenhofer 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@edenhofer_jacob
Lovely discussion over on Bluesky
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
This would be crimes against humanity.
It must be stopped. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
Under pressure from Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the Trump administration may be within days of launching a nuclear strike on Iran. The target would be Pickax Mountain in central Iran, where Israeli intelligence claims the Iranian government has restarted its nuclear enrichment program. No conventional weapon in the American arsenal can penetrate 300 feet of solid granite to destroy the tunnels where enrichment is supposedly taking place. The only military option is a nuclear strike. Netanyahu has been pushing hard for one. “Bibi calls Trump about it every day,” says an informed observer.
Netanyahu is cornered and desperate. After last week’s election results, he can’t form a government unless Trump intervenes directly in Israeli politics and brokers a deal with other parties that gives Netanyahu 61 seats in the Knesset. Otherwise, he is out as prime minister and on his way to ignominy, investigations and possibly jail. Netanyahu must stay close to Trump. He needs this war.
To that end, he’s applied maximum pressure to his closest allies in the administration, including Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth and CENTCOM commander Brad Cooper. Both oppose a negotiated settlement to the war they’ve so grievously mismanaged; both are pushing to restart major combat operations. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and CIA director John Ratcliffe are also following Netanyahu’s lead, as are leaders of the Democratic Party. In a recent meeting on the subject, former president Barack Obama said he opposes the current Iran peace deal being drafted in Doha.
The rest of America’s longtime allies in the Middle East are terrified by the prospect of more war. On September 27th, Netanyahu flew secretly to Abu Dhabi to enlist the UAE in his lobbying effort for a final attack on Iran. The Emiratis refused. After eight months of conflict, Gulf economies are teetering. So are global energy and fertilizer markets. They won’t recover soon. Globally, there are a total of about 850 supertankers used to transport oil from producers to the rest of the world. In October alone, 11 of them were badly damaged in Hormuz. At this pace, a global depression is imminent. A nuclear strike would radically accelerate the destruction. Fallout from a ground explosion at Pickax Mountain would contaminate the Persian Gulf, poisoning the water supply for 100 million people.
And those are just some of the immediate consequences for the region. The rest of the world is every bit as exposed. No country other than the United States has ever used a nuclear weapon in war. Some would like to. An American nuclear attack on Iran would set a new precedent. The Russians have already told at least two other governments that an American nuclear strike on Iran would free them to use nuclear weapons against Ukraine. Pakistan and India would be tempted to do the same against each other, as would North Korea against Seoul. After the first nuclear strike, World War Three is inevitable. That war would be short and final.
We’ve been sleepwalking toward this moment for months. Since February, the administration has quietly rewritten America’s nuclear doctrine to make first use of so-called “battlefield nukes” easier and therefore more likely. No one in Washington in either party seems bothered by this. Now we’re on the brink of it.
Close observers say Trump is likely to decide by next weekend whether or not to use nuclear weapons. That would be November 7, six days from now. To his credit, he’s hesitating. At the moment, Trump is listening to his vice president, JD Vance, and to his envoy and friend Steve Witkoff, both of whom argue a deal with Iran can be made.
They’re right, though it won’t be simple. The Iranians are famously frustrating to negotiate with under any circumstances, and elements of that government have become more radical since Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and his family were killed in February. After decades of isolation, even relatively moderate Iranian leaders seem confused by how decisions are made in the West. (There is a widespread belief in Tehran, for example, that the United States government controls Israel.) But overall, people who have spoken to decision-makers in Iran say there is consensus there that more war is bad for everyone and a deal is worth making.
One group that hasn’t been consulted so far is the global population — the hundreds of millions of people who will be killed along with their children if Trump is pushed by Netanyahu into launching a nuclear strike next week. Now would be the time for them to speak up. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MarshFamilySongs
@MarshSongs
Two years after our "Bohemian Trumpsody" #queen parody (on Trump's presidential election, with footage from the Capitol attack - see below), here's our take on Freddie Mercury's high-energy belter, twisted to the forthcoming #midterms, which we're calling:
👉"Go, Stop Him Now!"This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
MarshFamilySongs
@MarshSongs
Here's our last parody song about the #uselection2024. It's called "Bohemian Trumpsody" (based on the inimitable @QueenWillRock but with only six voices & no overdubs) & we've self-trolled in it as 'libtards' already, just to save folks time who might be offended 🎶🗳️🤞
👉youtu.be/YY_8WzcHqMQThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Something for the darker days of the year.
www.amazon.com/Power-Destroy-Economics-Americas-Decline/d… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Which is why I think there should be a #nobbleprizeineconomics, for people like Nordhaus whose insane assumptions have nobbled sensible economics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ali Nasrallah Sinwar’s Olive Tree 🔻🎒
@HakawatiSunbird
Remembering this gem today
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Which is why I think there should be a #nobbleprizeineconomics, for people like Nordhaus whose insane assumptions have nobbled sensible economics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pete Sikora
@PeteSikora1
Yes that’s kind of my point. Nordhaus didnt. Or more precisely, he viewed 3C as an acceptable outcome. (And the carbon tax stuff and his general influence politically was very damaging, imo)
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lord Keynes
@Lord_Keynes3
Most markets do not price their products like an auction market. The majority of prices are calculated as a mark up on total average unit cost. Proof and empirical data right here: socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/p/there-is-mounta…
Charles
@CharlesC101010
Sincerely, I don't follow how your pt is a critique of JN's pt.
I mean, say in the Gold mkt now, I ask for 4500/oz, but no one takes me up on the offer --> no transaction -->
the 4500 price is not realised.
What does haggling, or not, have to do with the offer-not-realised pt? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr. Genevieve Guenther (she / they)
@DoctorVive
Misrepresenting the climate problem, lying about my words, attacking anyone who works from the science that shows we have to phase out fossil fuels, and supporting the Trump Admin and Big Oil at SCOTUS while calling BTI a climate org — this is why Charles Koch funds you. 👍
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Misunderstanding the climate problem, wrongly attributing it to the scholar most responsible for bringing it to the public’s attention on the occasion of his death, and once again not knowing what words mean.
They’re calling it the @DoctorVive hat trick. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hugh Jackman
@RealHughJackman
Still laughing! One of my favorite appearances with @SirPatStew on the @TheGNShow. #logan
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Perhaps Chris will explain why so many households now require two incomes to maintain a standard of living that one income once supported, before quoting my posts about capitalism supposedly reducing the amount of work required to stay above the poverty line.
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
It’s worth remembering that people are “forced” to work in the state of nature. Plus, capitalism dramatically reduces the amount of hours people need to work to earn a living.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Libertarians insist employment is voluntary.
Your boss owns the factory. You've got $47, an empty fridge, and rent due Friday.
Nobody's forcing you to work. You're free to fucking starve. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The October Monthly Minsky Report is out.
A comprehensive assessment of financial stability, examining debt, credit, asset prices, income distribution, and other systemic dynamics largely ignored by conventional economic models.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/minsky-report-174071885 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It is, so far as economists are concerned.
The rest of us? Not so much...
Dr. Genevieve Guenther (she / they)
@DoctorVive
Is this supposed to be a complement?
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
All of us on Climate Twitter are living in the house William Nordhaus built.
RIP.
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
A giant is gone. news.yale.edu/2026/10/31/william-nordhaus-nobel-laureate-…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
You can never turn away from a Minsky perspective. Enjoy.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The October Monthly Minsky Report is out.
A comprehensive assessment of financial stability, examining debt, credit, asset prices, income distribution, and other systemic dynamics largely ignored by conventional economic models.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/minsky-report-174071885 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rafel Carretero
@RafelCarretero
www.elsaltodiario.com/francia/emmanuel-todd-juventus-malt…
Considero que ha llegado el momento de que los gobiernos europeos se pongan amistosamente de acuerdo para iniciar el desmantelamiento de la zona euro.
@el_buho69812
@Jorge_Econopata
@litewhisperer -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gilberto Trombetta
@Gitro77
You're not mixing up timelines. You're rewriting economic history to fit your prejudices.
Italian manufacturing productivity grew 6.2% annually in the 1960s vs West Germany's 4.1%, and 3.1% vs 2.3% in the 1980s. UK Treasury figures, not Italian propaganda. Over 1974–95: Italy 3.8%, Germany 3.1% (EU-KLEMS).
The real divergence came later, especially from the mid-1990s.
So much for your claim that Italian productivity “never grew equally” with Germany. Perhaps try data before lectures.
Florian Beckert
@florian_beckert
It absolutely has smth to do with Italian industrial decline, but you keep mixing up lira times with euro times.
Pre euro, Italian productivity per se was sub par and never grew equally with west Germany.
Post euro, it might be a different story but the euro has been bad -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gilberto Trombetta
@Gitro77
Conveniently selective history. The Bundesbank was skeptical, sure. But German industrialists pushed for Italy to join the euro from day one.
Why? Because Italian industry was a formidable competitor and threatened German exports. Locking Italy into the euro removed that threat.
And yes, much of Italy's own political and economic establishment was complicit, sacrificing its industrial competitiveness to join the euro at all costs.
Those are historical facts too.
Viktor Lavendel
@LavendelVicky
The Bundesbank warned Italy to join the euro too early. It has been the Italian which wanted to join asap. These are just historical facts: www.irishtimes.com/business/germany-unwilling-to-invite-r…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Eurozone bond yields follow expectations about whether the ECB acts as dealer of last resort. That is the only game in town - the rest is noise.
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The 🇬🇷 government's public debt to GDP ration hit 249.4 percent in 2020 with a 10y government bond yield of 1.34 percent. The idea that the Greek "debt crisis" had anything to do with "excessive public debt" is mistaken. It had everything to do with a lack of guidance by the ECB.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
@cemoyvat @ProfSteveKeen @ProfHall1955 @TyKeynes
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Arkadaşlar. Benim hesap da Türkiye'den erişime engellendi. Yeni hesabım şudur:
@tsoncu1 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The TARGET2 balances are a distraction. The problem is the fiscal framework of the Eurozone and the lack of clarity concerning the ECB's role as dealer of last resort. Details here:
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2023.2298448 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Can France really be a neoliberal state? Neoliberals say not. They say we've never really tried neoliberalism. But they're wrong. Neoliberalism is about capturing the state for private gain. And that is what is happening in France. youtu.be/3fLc6mYCTx8
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
You’re confusing three different things: TARGET balances, trade deficits, and exchange rate adjustments.
TARGET imbalances can arise entirely from the Eurosystem’s own asset purchases, without any corresponding trade deficit.
And how exactly are Italy and Germany supposed to compete through currency devaluation when they share the same currency?
Persistent external imbalances can certainly create economic problems. But TARGET balances are not a measure of trade deficits, and central bank settlement is not payment “by nothing.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
On TARGET2
The fan club of the ever-hysterical Robin Brooks is coming after me. So let’s use a simple example to explain what TARGET2 actually is and how its balances arise.
Suppose an Italian buyer pays €100 to a German seller. The payment goes through, but the Bank of Italy ends up with a €100 liability to the ECB.
Sounds paradoxical, doesn’t it? But these are two entirely different kinds of obligations.
Let's break it down.
1. An Italian transfers €100 to a German.
€100 is debited from the Italian buyer's bank account.
€100 is credited to the German seller's bank account.
The payment is complete. The Italian buyer owes the German seller nothing.
Before going further, we need to understand something about modern monetary systems.
There are two types of money relevant to this example:
Commercial bank deposits: the money households and businesses use to pay for goods and services.
Central bank reserves: the money commercial banks hold at their central banks and use to settle payments between themselves.
2. What happens at the central bank level?
The Italian commercial bank holds reserves at the Bank of Italy, while the German commercial bank holds reserves at the Bundesbank.
When €100 moves from Italy to Germany, the balance sheets of the two central banks change.
Here's what happens:
BANK OF ITALY 🇮🇹
Reserve liabilities to commercial banks: −€100
TARGET liability to the ECB: +€100
BUNDESBANK 🇩🇪
Reserve liabilities to commercial banks: +€100
TARGET claim on the ECB: +€100
Notice something important.
The Bank of Italy has not increased its total liabilities by €100. It has simply replaced one liability with another.
Before the payment, it owed €100 in reserves to the Italian commercial bank.
After the payment, it owes €100 to the ECB through TARGET.
Meanwhile, the Bundesbank has acquired a new €100 liability to the German commercial bank. To balance its books, it simultaneously acquires a €100 financial asset: a claim on the ECB.
This is precisely how the ECB and the Bundesbank explain the accounting.
3. Why can't we just transfer the money and forget about it?
Because the euro is a single currency, but national central banks maintain separate balance sheets.
If Italy and Germany operated under a single central bank with one consolidated balance sheet, this would simply be a transfer of reserves between two commercial banks.
But since the Bank of Italy and the Bundesbank have separate balance sheets, an additional accounting entry is needed to record the movement of reserves between them.
That's what TARGET does.
4. What if someone in Germany transfers €100 back to Italy tomorrow?
Everything happens in reverse.
The Bank of Italy's TARGET liability decreases by €100, while the Bundesbank's TARGET claim falls by €100.
Assuming no other transactions, both TARGET balances return to their original positions.
Here's the key takeaway:
TARGET records net settlement flows between national central banks within the Eurosystem.
It does not represent unpaid debts of Italian buyers to German sellers, nor does it mean the Italian government has borrowed money from Germany.
And this brings us to a much more interesting question:
If the Bank of Italy can maintain a negative TARGET balance indefinitely while remaining in the Eurosystem, why would it need to repay it at all?
And here's the most fascinating part:
Much of the enormous TARGET imbalances accumulated since 2015 were actually driven by the Eurosystem's own asset purchases under the ECB's quantitative easing programs!
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Every time I read Brooks’s tweets, I can’t help but facepalm.
In a debate about Germany potentially leaving the eurozone, TARGET2 liabilities have somehow magically turned into Italian and Spanish government debt owed to Berlin.
But TARGET2 balances are intra-Eurosystem positions between central banks, not loans between governments. Germany leaving the euro would not, in itself, oblige the Italian and Spanish governments to issue sovereign debt to settle those balances.
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
The thing is that countries like Italy and Spain would have to issue debt to repay TARGET2 balances they owe Germany, which is obviously unthinkable given their already high debt levels...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
André Kühnlenz
@KeineWunder
Euro-Guthaben deutscher Banken würden in D-Mark-Guthaben getauscht… Damit verschwindet der deutsche Target-Saldo, der aus dem Überschuss an Euro-Guthaben besteht… Italien und Spanien sitzen dann auf Staatsanleihen und Forderungen gegenüber ihren Banken…
Nicht unser Problem…
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
The thing is that countries like Italy and Spain would have to issue debt to repay TARGET2 balances they owe Germany, which is obviously unthinkable given their already high debt levels...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
As as part of our Colonial Histories series, soon on @Graeber_social with Eyshe Beirich и @NathanTankus
the editors of "We, Traitors: Bundist Writings on Zionism, Palestine, and Socialism, forthcoming from @haymarketbooks : the book as a political project. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Ideas influence policy makers. When societies are drifting the wrong direction based on faulty economic theory, the way out has to be built on new economic theory.
greenparty.org.uk/2026/10/04/greens-agree-bold-new-econom… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
#charlatanry The TARGET balances are not debts. He should know this.
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
There's a fantasy in Italy and Spain that Germany's TARGET2 claims aren't real. They're very real. They're subsidized loans from Germany that finance a standard of living in Italy and Spain that's artificially and unsustainably high. The AfD will end this.
robinjbrooks.substack.com/p/why-euro-breakup-is-necessary -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Labour without energy is a corpse; capital without energy is a sculpture."
Steve Keen nailed it. Energy has to be incorporated into economic theory. It is the essential ingredient for the economic pie that we all share. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
Since some of the most famous Jewish political figures, from Karl Marx and Rosa Luxemburg to Emma Goldman, were on the left, it is especially crazy that somehow, it seems that only one form of political identification with Jewishness is considered legitimate: we all have to support Israel's horrific government.
And all the other ways of being Jewish are under such intense attack that, in some parts of the world, they can put one's life at risk.
ps
Artem Kirpichenok and his laywer Inna is still in Israeli prison.
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
As as part of our Colonial Histories series, soon on @Graeber_social with Eyshe Beirich и @NathanTankus
the editors of "We, Traitors: Bundist Writings on Zionism, Palestine, and Socialism, forthcoming from @haymarketbooks : the book as a political project. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
In preparation right now: Carnival4David in Brixton London.
Thank you to everyone who is making it happen!
photo by Clive Russel -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
No. The Bundesbank can simply buy the worthless paper held by banks at face value and hence ensure they have strong balance sheets. That's QE1 to the rescue.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
On TARGET2
The fan club of the ever-hysterical Robin Brooks is coming after me. So let’s use a simple example to explain what TARGET2 actually is and how its balances arise.
Suppose an Italian buyer pays €100 to a German seller. The payment goes through, but the Bank of Italy ends up with a €100 liability to the ECB.
Sounds paradoxical, doesn’t it? But these are two entirely different kinds of obligations.
Let's break it down.
1. An Italian transfers €100 to a German.
€100 is debited from the Italian buyer's bank account.
€100 is credited to the German seller's bank account.
The payment is complete. The Italian buyer owes the German seller nothing.
Before going further, we need to understand something about modern monetary systems.
There are two types of money relevant to this example:
Commercial bank deposits: the money households and businesses use to pay for goods and services.
Central bank reserves: the money commercial banks hold at their central banks and use to settle payments between themselves.
2. What happens at the central bank level?
The Italian commercial bank holds reserves at the Bank of Italy, while the German commercial bank holds reserves at the Bundesbank.
When €100 moves from Italy to Germany, the balance sheets of the two central banks change.
Here's what happens:
BANK OF ITALY 🇮🇹
Reserve liabilities to commercial banks: −€100
TARGET liability to the ECB: +€100
BUNDESBANK 🇩🇪
Reserve liabilities to commercial banks: +€100
TARGET claim on the ECB: +€100
Notice something important.
The Bank of Italy has not increased its total liabilities by €100. It has simply replaced one liability with another.
Before the payment, it owed €100 in reserves to the Italian commercial bank.
After the payment, it owes €100 to the ECB through TARGET.
Meanwhile, the Bundesbank has acquired a new €100 liability to the German commercial bank. To balance its books, it simultaneously acquires a €100 financial asset: a claim on the ECB.
This is precisely how the ECB and the Bundesbank explain the accounting.
3. Why can't we just transfer the money and forget about it?
Because the euro is a single currency, but national central banks maintain separate balance sheets.
If Italy and Germany operated under a single central bank with one consolidated balance sheet, this would simply be a transfer of reserves between two commercial banks.
But since the Bank of Italy and the Bundesbank have separate balance sheets, an additional accounting entry is needed to record the movement of reserves between them.
That's what TARGET does.
4. What if someone in Germany transfers €100 back to Italy tomorrow?
Everything happens in reverse.
The Bank of Italy's TARGET liability decreases by €100, while the Bundesbank's TARGET claim falls by €100.
Assuming no other transactions, both TARGET balances return to their original positions.
Here's the key takeaway:
TARGET records net settlement flows between national central banks within the Eurosystem.
It does not represent unpaid debts of Italian buyers to German sellers, nor does it mean the Italian government has borrowed money from Germany.
And this brings us to a much more interesting question:
If the Bank of Italy can maintain a negative TARGET balance indefinitely while remaining in the Eurosystem, why would it need to repay it at all?
And here's the most fascinating part:
Much of the enormous TARGET imbalances accumulated since 2015 were actually driven by the Eurosystem's own asset purchases under the ECB's quantitative easing programs!
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Every time I read Brooks’s tweets, I can’t help but facepalm.
In a debate about Germany potentially leaving the eurozone, TARGET2 liabilities have somehow magically turned into Italian and Spanish government debt owed to Berlin.
But TARGET2 balances are intra-Eurosystem positions between central banks, not loans between governments. Germany leaving the euro would not, in itself, oblige the Italian and Spanish governments to issue sovereign debt to settle those balances.
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
The thing is that countries like Italy and Spain would have to issue debt to repay TARGET2 balances they owe Germany, which is obviously unthinkable given their already high debt levels...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
The key distinction is between monetary settlement and fiscal sovereignty.
TARGET2 balances do not impose a direct constraint on public investment. They are accounting positions arising from cross-border payments within the Eurosystem.
The real problem lies elsewhere. Euro-area governments are users, not sovereign issuers, of the currency. Their fiscal capacity is constrained by EU fiscal rules, bond-market conditions and the ECB’s institutional framework.
The Eurosystem can technically settle cross-border euro payments. But individual governments cannot independently guarantee the financing of their spending.
So the fundamental issue is not TARGET2 balances, but the institutional separation of monetary sovereignty from national fiscal authority. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
The UK's big problem is import dependency, which makes it vulnerable to currency depreciation and inflation. This happens to be the global financiers' heavy weapon. Even if we fended off the bond vigilantes - difficult but it can be done - we're still sitting ducks. Short of revolution, we would need economically literate politicians with firm policies - public investment and ownership of energy, infrastructure, utilities and services and a degree of capital exchange control and subsidy would be essential - and a population willing to tough it out for a generation, especially small/medium business owners dependent on imports. Otherwise we continue with asset-stripping, rentierism, infrastructural decay, regional decline, widening inequality and unpredictable eruptions of populist discontent.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Aaron A. Thomas
@Aaron_A_Thomas
Counterpoint:
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14747731.2020.1807856 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
SuzieWong 🌹🇷🇺 🇨🇳 🇵🇸 🇧🇫
@SuzieWo20886208
The reason that everyone under 65 cannot really appreciate the magnitude both economically and socially of Thatcher's destruction, is because they weren't there before it.
They cannot appreciate how low State owned bills were and the service received. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Israeli actress Chelli Goldenberg explains how she REALLY feels - when she thinks that the camera is off.
“I no longer feel proud to be Israeli… We are occupiers," she says.
But the real confession is much deeper. Contrary to the public line that all of the problems rise from the Palestinians' alleged unwillingness to make peace and preference for violence, Goldenberg reveals what we all have known all along: It's all about the occupation!
"The occupation brought everything that followed," she explains. "Everything happening now is a consequence of the occupation... Religious coercion, the settlers, Jewish terrorism, arrogance."
Look at her face when she realizes that her comments were on air. It's not the face of someone caught red-handed.
Rather, I see fear in her face - fear of repercussions for having said the truth out loud.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
No. The Bundesbank can simply buy the worthless paper held by banks at face value and hence ensure they have strong balance sheets. That's QE1 to the rescue.
Daniel Lacalle Official Account
@dlacalle_IA
If Germany leaves the euro, it means bankruptcy for France, Italy, Spain, Greece and Portugal. It also means the demolition of the asset base of German and European banks, a European depression, the collapse of many Japanese pension funds and a global financial meltdown, dollar soaring and global credit collapse.
Germany leaving the euro is the demolition of the world's second reserve currency. No one would take a Germany-less euro.
Jon Aldekoa
@jaldeko
Si Alemania abandona el euro, quiebran Francia, Italia, España, Grecia y Portugal a la vez.
Economic Pills
@EconomicPills
Alemania debe abandonar el euro, asumir la pérdida que la divisa común le ha generado y recuperar su marco y la seriedad de su Bundesbank. Que el BCE rescate al estatismo francés creando aún más dinero de la nada es intolerable. La mala cabeza francesa pagada con inflación.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Val
@VK_HM
Oh his attractiveness was known. Here’s no less than Ursula LeGuin writing about the show also for TV Guide about two years later
James “jchensor” Chen
@jchensor
One memory I always have of Patrick Stewart is that in one year TV Guide ran a reader’s poll for the sexiest man and woman on TV. And even before the Internet, somehow the Star Trek fans created a campaign to try and get Patrick Stewart to win. And they succeeded!
At the time it was a funny shock. Even the cover of the TV Guide called it a “surprise”! People seemed to mention a lot that he was bald and that it was odd for a bald man to win sexiest man, let alone it being Patrick Stewart from Star Trek of all people! Especially given that his counterpart who won sexiest woman was Cindy Crawford!
The funny thing is that if people were told today that Patrick Stewart won sexiest man on TV one year during TNG’s run, I don’t think anyone these days would think it odd or anything. It almost sounds silly to describe it how I remembered it was back then, that it was a shock and almost a laughable result that he’d won. I feel like people nowadays would react with, “Yeah? He should have won!” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I can't decide whether Austrian or Neoclassical economists understand time worse.
Austrians turn it into philosophical masturbation and neoclassicals reduce it to a retarded discount factor. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Amen to this!
Lordfox
@inTheMtnWood
Engineering > Economics
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Champagne Kremlinova
@fritzlechat
A lovely tribute from Marina Sirtis: www.theguardian.com/culture/2026/oct/31/patrick-stewart-s…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
SMD is important for understanding the irredeemable flaw of New Keynesian models. The assumptions that allow for using a representative agent to model the economy (Walrasian complete markets that eliminate idiosyncratic income risk) are exactly what makes the model non-monetary
Lars P Syll
@LarsPSyll
The Prize Committee overlooked Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu larspsyll.wordpress.com/2026/10/31/the-prize-committee-ov… via @LarsSyll
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
An economist obsessed with equilibrium could watch a bridge collapse, observe the wreckage settle at the bottom of a river, and publish a fucking paper explaining how the entire structure successfully converged to a stable equilibrium.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
La burbuja de la IA ya ha explotado en China, y está a punto de hacerlo en EEUU. Está ya más inflada que la peor burbuja que ha vivido la humanidad. Por eso se están hundiendo en bolsa muchas empresas tecnológicas. Ya es seguro que esto va a explotar y va a tener consecuencias sistémicas 🧵
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minutes with @ProfSteveKeen.
Are taxes really theft, or do libertarians just not understand how a fucking economy works?
Q&A in the live chat. Everyone is welcome, including Austrian economists.
www.youtube.com/live/Hgw8pFBlfdo -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
The Austrians wriggle out of the Neoclassicals' claim of market equilibrium be saying markets rotate around it. Some of the New Keynesians claim that points of fleeting equilibrium are reached here and there. 2008 proved yet again that none of these positions have any credibility. They're all intellectually fraudulent supports for what is a quasi-religious belief in markets fuelled by a visceral bourgeois fear of the potentially 'populist' democratic state. Only serious government intervention at the root of credit creation, investment and demand management can guarantee any stability at all.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I wish this were satire. God's Army...
AJ Signal
@aj_geo_analysis
Do you believe me now when I say, Q3 and Q4 2027 ground invasion is coming?
Secretary of War Pete Hegseth
@SecWar
The War Department is officially launching the Chaplain In-Service Procurement Program.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
OK, the best critique of Jevon's 'law' I've read is actually from an energy system engineer called Steve Sorrell. Look it up. After that, a useful broader critique of Jevon's general neoclassical position is provided by the post-Keynesians. @ProfSteveKeen is a good guide for that tour.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
We are in an unbelievably dire situation with almost no one understanding how serious it is because of the $1 billion a year spent by the oil industry to confuse the public - and it’s worked.
Most journalists don’t understand.
Most politicians don’t understand.
They seem to listen to each other rather than to scientists.
But science is science, facts are facts. It doesn’t matter whether people believe it or not, it’s still really happening.
www.dailystar.co.uk/news/weird-news/scientists-warn-colla… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
🦜📚 Pick your favorite economist parrot! Neoclassicals, Austrians… all devoted to methodological individualism 😂
Which one best represents your Twitter debates and the replies you get? 🤡📈 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Interesting watching all the discourse and arguments happening online and in the news and in the culture, with hardy anyone seeming to understand we’re on course for the mass collapse of everything - with very little opposition or even discussion.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Morlock
@CDMorlock
Patrick Stewart explains Communism to backwards ass guy from hundreds of years ago (Capitalist).
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
S.V. Dáte
@svdate
This is possibly the reason the White House stopped posting the transcripts of Trump's remarks.
If you read them, you realize very quickly that he is out of his mind.
Andrew—#IAmTheResistance
@AmoneyResists
Here’s another clip of a woman reading Trump’s words verbatim from a recent rally in Mississippi that puts a giant magnifying glass over how gone he is cognitively and unfit he is for office.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Tipping Points.
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/tipping-points-173937575
Chapter 23 in my forthcoming book “How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
阴阳行者-おんみょうぎょうじゃ-Yin Yang Wayfarer
@gpsma2025
现在知道为何西方社会极端仇恨中国了,毛泽东和他的继任者们设计的国家都是防止中国人滑入绝对贫困,而习近平正在强化和完善这些措施,不起眼的措施阻挡了资本的无序扩张。
一、联产承包:土地集体所有、家庭承包——地不能卖给资本家,农民失地当流民的路被焊死。最坏的情况,回家种地。
二、宅基地:家家有地盖房,没有房产税,没有房东——中国农民住自己产权的房子,全世界底层独一份。
三、耕地红线:十八亿亩,天塌下来,中国人饿不死。
四、最低收购价:粮价低时国家兜底,种粮不亏本,地不撂荒。
五、取消农业税:2006年,两千年来第一次。
六、新农合+居民医保:大病不再等于全家破产。
七、农村养老金:一个月一两百,是七八十岁老人的体面。
八、义务教育免费:阻断贫困代际传递的第一道墙。
九、脱贫攻坚:八亿人脱贫,人类史上最大规模减贫。
十、资本禁入:耕地宅基地不许资本大规模染指,护住农民最后的资产。
共同点:不留死角的托底,没工作有地,没收入有房,大病有医保,孩子有学上,老了有养老金。
每一条单看都不起眼,加在一起,是一个文明给最底层的人留的最后一道防线。 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
Keep an eye on the credit structures that were built to fund AI infrastructure.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
"The classic NK playbook: assume ceteris paribus; dismiss empirical sequence, direction, and pipeline timing as mere 'frictions'; insert unanchored 'expectations' to close the gap; and label continuous upstream cost adjustments as exogenous 'shocks.'
Nothing to see here." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steven Bartlett
@StevenBartlett
Steve Keen on how one strait could cause a global famine.
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Risk Expert tells the Truth about Climate
@MarkCranfield_
It feels as if no one has yet begun to get to grips with the true nature of what our species is facing. It will never stop getting hotter. To go from 1.5C to 2C in less than around 10 years is literally beyond belief. 1.5C and 2C are different planets. On average, during the last deglaciation, itself an extremely fast warming event, it took 660 years to warm by 0.5C.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Early indications of where the US economy could be headed by years end form a weekly report by @GDPDynamics
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Latest members only weekly update is out for the GDP Dynamics Nowcast.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/u-s-economy-but-173901125 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Austrian economists insist nobody can predict market outcomes, then confidently predict that abolishing government intervention will produce prosperity in market outcomes.
Apparently uncertainty disappears when you're a fucking moron. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
If standard equilibrium only works when you assume zero frictions, but the actual economy operates 100% on contract lags, input cascades, and markup rules, then 'friction' is doing all the explanatory work that supply-and-demand was supposed to
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chef Joe Gera 🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️🇮🇹
@redhotnerd
Patrick Stewart specifically became a US citizen so he could vote against your scrawny ass.
Stephen Miller
@StephenM
One of the most impactful actors in the history of film, television and theater.
Variety
@Variety
Patrick Stewart, 'Star Trek's' Captain Picard and 'X-Men's' Charles Xavier, Dies at 86 variety.com/2026/tv/news/patrick-stewart-dead-star-trek-p…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Leavitt 🎲🎮🧙♂️🌈
@DavidLeavitt
“Stephen Miller, on behalf of Star Trek, and everyone who knew and loved him, keep my Captain's name out of your fucking Nazi mouth. He despised you, and everything you stand for.”
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alicia Gerardo
@TheEconRebel
Energy intensity of GDP is the inverse of the efficiency with which energy is turned into useful work by machines. Economists' misunderstanding of the role of energy will lead world leaders to a false sense of security that the oil crisis will be minor and have few ramifications.
Philipp Heimberger
@heimbergecon
The energy and oil intensity of global GDP has declined substantially since the 1980s.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Libertarians believe monopolies cannot survive in a free market, provided you ignore predatory pricing, exclusive contracts, control of distribution, massive capital requirements, buying out competitors, and every other economic reality that ruins their stupid fucking fairy tale.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It's pivotal to the disaster that the Eurozone has been for Europe, and the core source of the discontent behind the youth rebellion across Europe today.
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
The algorithm now shows me a lot of the German economists' pearl clutching at @IsabellaMWeber price controls and dear God, how I've underestimated the dark powers of ordoliberalism.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
fiat money
@fiat_money
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
So well said m—and what a pungent ending.
MAGA Cult Slayer
@MAGACult2
🚨NON-FEARMONGERING RED ALERT: This is a military spouse. We don't typically fall for these. I believe her. This is an extremely ominous message with some breath stealing predictions.
"It's going to get worse. A whole lot worse and the young people will pay for it." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sparrow
@TrappedinGarden
The greatest episode of TV ever imo.
@SirPatStew passing is heartbreaking but not unexpected. He lived an amazing life surrounded by love, animals and art. He will live on in our minds and collective conscious forever
Rest well Sir 🫡
We've got it from here 🥺💔
TrekCore.com 🖖
@TrekCore
TODAY IN #startrek HISTORY: June 1, 1992
Captain Picard lives an entire life as Kamin of planet Kataan in "The Inner Light."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The strongest dove case on inflation is that everything in the labor market looks like what you would expect in a ~2% inflation world with inflation falling not rising.
Next I'll add my favorite series into the Econvitals emails and threads on this: ex incentive pay.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jamesons
@SiteJamesons
Vou ser sincero com vocês: até algumas horas atrás, eu achava que Patrick Stewart fizesse parte da comunidade LGBTQ+. Via frequentemente fotos dele trocando selinhos com Ian McKellen e até imaginava que pudesse existir algo além de uma grande amizade entre os dois.
Para minha surpresa, ao pesquisar mais sobre sua vida, descobri que não. Patrick Stewart era heterossexual e foi casado três vezes, sempre com mulheres.
E os selinhos? Eram apenas uma demonstração pública de afeto e carinho por Ian, que é assumidamente gay e um dos seus melhores amigos. Mas o mais importante nunca foi o gesto em si. O verdadeiro significado estava no fato de Patrick usar sua imagem, como um dos atores mais respeitados de Hollywood, para apoiar a comunidade LGBTQ+ de forma aberta e natural.
Patrick Stewart não tinha uma masculinidade frágil e nunca precisou provar sua heterossexualidade para ninguém. Não se preocupava com o que pensavam ou diziam a seu respeito. O que realmente importava para ele era ajudar a construir um mundo mais tolerante e acolhedor.
Um mundo em que seu grande amigo Ian McKellen, e toda a comunidade LGBTQ+, pudessem viver com dignidade e paz.
Sir Patrick Stewart foi, sem dúvida, um homem à frente do seu tempo. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
"Independence was sold as insulation from politics. It has instead insulated a credit-allocation regime that privileges financialisation over production and protects itself against elected challenge."
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Central banks have been handed independence and used it to become the unaccountable core of the system. This is what banking tyranny looks like , the literally domination of power by the banking elites taken to the point the country literally collapses .
Liz Truss is right: they have grown megalomaniacal. The governor of the Bank of England can’t be sacked; a prime minister can. That is not a technical detail. It is the actual power arrangement.
The mechanism and motivation is financialisation. It’s the core purpose of banking and in its current form it threatens the states existence .
Basel rules force banks to hold far more capital against a factory loan than against a mortgage.
Inflation targets treat rising house and land prices as “asset transfers,” not inflation, so rates never cool the boom.
Credit is therefore created against the existing housing stock and financial assets, the renter class, while industrial capacity is starved. Bankers literally live in ivory towers so they don’t notice till late in the cycle .
Workers’ wages are financialised into rents, mortgages and debt service. The West has been deindustrialised to the point it can no longer make what it needs. Bankers add no productive capacity to the society at all other than pulling forward production or asset inflation through debt .
This is the Tindale Trap conceit : maintaining financial dominance together with a material conversion failure. This bifurcation literally leaves the state with no productive capacity to to maintain sovereign existence .
Like draining blood you eventually get to weak to respond .
Truss tried a growth agenda that cut against the orthodoxy. The Bank’s timing of gilt sales, the LDI structures it regulated, and the narrative that followed removed her.
Independence was sold as insulation from politics. It has instead insulated a credit-allocation regime that privileges financialisation over production and protects itself against elected challenge. The direction of credit is the mechanism, and the political outcome is exactly what Truss is pointing to.
We live under a global banking dictatorship
Richard Werner
@scientificecon
In my Substack analysis at rwerner.substack.com I show how exactly the Bank of England toppled a sitting Prime Minister.
Ex-PM Liz Truss deserves all credit for her courage to battle the unaccountable central planners & not being intimidated by their vast but covert powers.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
🔄 Updated version of the 12 Types of Post-Keynesian Economists!
Sharper theoretical distinctions, a few refinements, and the same diversity of perspectives.
🔥 Which type are you? What would you change? Who’s missing?
👇 Join the debate and let’s improve it together!
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
12 types of post-Keynesian economists. 12 ways to challenge mainstream economics.
🔥 Which one are you? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
An excellent documentary from 2012 exposing the limitations of equilibrium-based macroeconomics and its neglect of endogenous credit, debt and financial instability.
Financial Instability Mini-Documentary youtu.be/9JD6uuiiZPY via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
the gerogerigegegillian
@gfaunaa
one of the most underrated episodes of TNG is "lessons", where jean luc falls in love with a woman and opens up about his experience in the inner light and his love of the flute
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Maryam
@hell_line0
Patrick Stewart was a socialist.
Glenda Jackson was a socialist.
George Orwell was a socialist.
Albert Einstein was a socialist.
Nelson Mandela was a socialist.
Nazis were NOT socialist, Musk is a liar, and he spreads Nazi propaganda. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Teleology is the explanation of a process by its presumed end state rather than by the causal mechanisms that produce it.
Applied to New Keynesian economics, the danger is that equilibrium becomes both the starting assumption and the presumed destination of adjustment.
The adjustment mechanism must be demonstrated, not inferred from the equilibrium condition.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It won't be forgotten Ty. This is a very personal and detailed exposition of what it feels like when you try to bring reason and empirical validation, to a discipline dominated by teleology and ideology.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
🚨🛑
A little background for my post-Keynesian and MMT friends, and an explanation of what the fuck I've been doing on this account for the last six weeks.
Back in 2022, I met Steve Keen on a random livestream and ended up showing him a rather sophisticated pandemic model for Covid-19 I had developed for British Columbia, Canada, using his system dynamics software, Ravel. I had actually started using his software back in 2017, when I was working at a box factory and experimenting with ways to optimize productivity through system dynamics modeling.
Around the same time I first met Steve on that stream in 2022, I opened this Twitter account. I also started a YouTube channel producing system dynamics modeling tutorials, primarily focused on macroeconomics. Before that, I had deleted Facebook, Instagram, and pretty much every other social media account I had back in 2017 because I couldn't stand that shit anymore. "Just when I thought I got out, they pulled me right back in!"
In 2023, I began developing a large national economic model that led to a lot of unique opportunities and rebranded myself as Relearning Economics. I started posting historical economic quotes, which eventually became a regular feature of the account. Interestingly, quite a few accounts doing the same thing today appeared after I started doing it. Unfortunately, most of them turned out to be libertarian accounts.
Along the way, I met a tremendous number of economists, researchers, and systems thinkers. Those connections eventually turned into a steady side income from economic modeling contracts. Over time, I accumulated a substantial collection of unpublished models, experiments, and research that I wanted to make publicly available.
That eventually led to GDP Dynamics.
I launched @GDPDynamics and its corresponding website this past summer as a home for my economic models, forecasts, and research. Much of the forecasting and modeling work is available to the public for free, while a premium membership provides more detailed analysis and additional research. It has already developed into another source of income, allowing me to spend more time doing what I actually enjoy: building economic models.
Around the same time, I decided to retire the Relearning Economics identity, return to using my legal name on Twitter, and establish GDP Dynamics as a separate brand. Besides when you have the last name Keynes and you work in the field of economics, I could I have not returned to it. Another factor was the release of my book, Beyond Equilibrium: A dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
After two and a half years, posting historical economic quotes had become rather dated and redundant relative to what I was trying to accomplish. It certainly helped build an audience, but it also came with an enormous amount of bullshit.
For nearly two years, I dealt with a constant stream of Austrian economists and libertarians attacking practically anything I posted. Share a John Maynard Keynes quote and suddenly you're accused of supporting pedophilia. Discuss fiscal policy and you're a communist. Apparently, I'm a communist despite spending a considerable amount of my spare time developing software, negotiating contracts, selling economic modeling services, and running a business. Some days I feel like the most oppressed entrepreneur in economics.
The personal attacks were relentless. I received countless threats of violence from anonymous keyboard warriors, none of whom I took particularly seriously. Nevertheless, dealing with that shit almost every day for a couple of years becomes exhausting.
And this brings me to my Post-Keynesian and MMT followers.
I've watched how our side of the economics community has been treated, particularly by the Austrian and libertarian crowd. The constant insults, accusations, and personal attacks. Being called retards, faggots, woke libtards, communists, and just about every other insult these people can manage to string together. I've seen perfectly reasonable economic discussions turn into absolute cesspools because somebody dared to question the intellectual foundations of Austrian economics.
When I returned to using my legal name and separated the GDP Dynamics brand from my personal account, I had a little social experiment in mind.
Social media has become a clickbait shithole, populated by countless little ideological echo chambers. People spend more time defending their intellectual tribes than actually learning anything. In my case I find it particularly frustrating because I'm in the business of economic forecasting, not abstract fuckery.
So, beginning September 15th, I started a calculated campaign of what I would describe as chud-style economic ragebait, primarily directed at Austrian economists and libertarians, with the occasional shot at New Keynesians and neoclassical economists.
Over the following six weeks, those posts generated millions of impressions.
There were three reasons for doing this.
First, I'm fascinated by how systems behave. That's probably obvious considering I spend a substantial amount of my life building nonlinear dynamic models. Social media is itself a complex system of feedback loops, reinforcement mechanisms, incentives, and emergent behavior. I wanted to see what would happen if I deliberately changed the nature of the content being introduced into that system.
Second, I wanted to change the composition of my audience. My historical quote posting had attracted what I estimated to be somewhere between 1,000 and 2,000 Austrian and libertarian followers who had very little interest in my actual economic modeling work. I wanted to shed much of that audience and develop a healthier balance of people genuinely interested in macroeconomics, system dynamics, and the research I publish.
Based on the substantial follower turnover I've observed in my X Premium analytics over the past six weeks, that objective appears to have been achieved.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, I wanted to return some of the bullshit that I and many others in the post-Keynesian and MMT communities have endured on this platform which specifically accelerated after Musk took over.
After two years of watching these people casually throw around personal insults, threats, and accusations, I figured it might be entertaining to give them a taste of their own medicine.
Judging by the extraordinary amount of crybaby fuckery coming from libertarians over the past six weeks, I can say that particular objective has been rather satisfying. Those folk might be more woke than the woke woke(s)...
But there is also a more serious observation here.
What this experience has reinforced for me is just how ineffective social media can be as a platform for distributing substantive intellectual work. You can spend months developing an economic model, testing its behavior, validating its results, and writing a detailed explanation, only to reach a fraction of the audience that a deliberately provocative two-sentence post can attract in a few hours. Sadly this post that I have put effort into will mean little to nothing in a few hours and will probably get very low engagement because it's to long and complex for the TikTok generation.
The incentives overwhelmingly favor emotional reactions, ideological conflict, and instant gratification over research and meaningful discussion. Millions of impressions do not necessarily translate into people reading your work, understanding your models, or engaging with the underlying economics.
This is one of the reasons I established GDP Dynamics as an independent platform. I would rather have a smaller audience genuinely interested in my research than millions of impressions from people arguing about something they haven't bothered to understand.
And for anyone wondering whether I've become permanently consumed by Twitter/X ragebait, I can assure you I haven't. Will I stop, I don't know, If George Selgin gets any more emotionally damaged by my posts about David Graeber, he might end up on Prozac or some other antidepressant and if that's the case I will never stop.
In real life, I ride downhill mountain bikes for excitement, work on economic models, consulting work and run the GDP Dynamics site. As a Canadian I go to a lot of hockey games, say "eh" a lot and cut down trees with and axe. I'm probably more libertarian than a libertarian
Most of the stupid shit I post on this account is written while I'm sitting on the toilet. Not this one, I put some time into this some it can be forgotten about tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
People like to believe neoclassicism's teleological reasoning because the allegedly achievable end has a comforting, moral ring to it. Equilibrium, fairness, stability, peace, continuity, absence of stress and disruption. It's a therapeutic ideology, like a religion. Market failure must be blamed on an externality, usually the government or a foreign nation, which therefore become our enemies.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
12 types of post-Keynesian economists. 12 ways to challenge mainstream economics.
🔥 Which one are you? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
1/25 🎬🍿 COMING SOON: NEOCLASSICAL CINEMA. No involuntary unemployment, no radical uncertainty, and every ending in equilibrium. Critics call it fiction. Economists call it a documentary. Can you guess them? 🧵
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kaivan Shroff
@KaivanShroff
“Everyone knows that sometimes — a failing politician — what he needs is a war.”
Patrick Stewart slams Donald Trump as a failing leader: -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof Julia Steinberger
@JKSteinberger
Full solidarity with colleague Prof Andreas Malm, banned from entering the UK for siding with Palestine Action. This is outrageous. He is one of the best and most principled academics. @andyburnham please reverse immediately. I stand with both Palestine Action and Andreas.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
How do you feel as an Australian that 𝐏𝐫𝐢𝐦𝐞 𝐌𝐢𝐧𝐬𝐭𝐞𝐫 @AlboMP and 𝐓𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐬𝐮𝐫𝐞𝐫 @JEChalmers have said nothing over the last year regarding this shocking ATO abuse of power? 🇦🇺
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The Queensland Supreme Court of Appeal today upheld findings that ATO investigator 𝐌𝐫 𝐀𝐧𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐧𝐲 𝐑𝐚𝐢𝐧𝐬 engaged in 𝐝𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐛𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐞 𝐦𝐢𝐬𝐜𝐨𝐧𝐝𝐮𝐜𝐭 in the prosecution of taxpayer and Australian citizen Julie ‘Clark’.
Link to judgment: queenslandjudgments.com.au/caselaw/qca/2026/219/pdf
M͟r͟ ͟R͟a͟i͟n͟s͟’͟ ͟m͟i͟s͟c͟o͟n͟d͟u͟c͟t͟ ͟i͟n͟c͟l͟u͟d͟e͟d͟:
• Helping prepare false statements of witnesses
•Altering an Excel spreadsheet that was later tendered as evidence in court
• Hiding evidence from the court that could have helped the defence
• Failing to correct false or misleading evidence once it was in the case
• Making false statements himself in official documents given to the court
• Not keeping proper records of decisions, meetings, and evidence he obtained.
The Appeals Court found these actions were 𝐝𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐛𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐞 — not an accident, not an oversight, and not the result of pressure or incompetence. 😳
𝐀𝐧𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐧𝐲 𝐑𝐚𝐢𝐧𝐬’ actions escalated from basic record-keeping failures, to 𝐚𝐜𝐭𝐢𝐯𝐞𝐥𝐲 𝐟𝐚𝐥𝐬𝐢𝐟𝐲𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐝𝐞𝐧𝐜𝐞, and he knew this would mislead the prosecutor, the defendant, and the court.
The appeal judges also left undisturbed the original findings that 𝐑𝐚𝐢𝐧𝐬 𝐰𝐚𝐬 𝐍𝐎𝐓 𝐚 𝐜𝐫𝐞𝐝𝐢𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐨𝐫 𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐚𝐛𝐥𝐞 𝐰𝐢𝐭𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬.
The 𝐩𝐞𝐫𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐞𝐧𝐭 𝐬𝐭𝐚𝐲 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐬𝐞𝐜𝐮𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 is maintained, subject to allowing the Commonwealth 90 days to return to the District Court if they seek to proceed after giving undertakings to address the impact of that misconduct.
His Honour 𝐉𝐮𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐜𝐞 𝐏𝐚𝐮𝐥 𝐒𝐦𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐀𝐌’s original findings on the seriousness of the ATO’s conduct stand. ⚖️
#auspol #auslaw #anthonyrains #taxoffice #ato #garnishees #businessdestruction #hidingevidence #abusebythestate #modifyingwitnessstatements #commonwealthabuseofcitizens @RossCoulthart #uapx #fiveeyes #followthemoney @DanielSheehan45
Ping @Grok and @ElonMusk
📸 2025
Anthony Rains outside court.
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
Tomorrow morning I'll be in the Brisbane Supreme Court for judgment on the appeal of 𝐉𝐮𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐜𝐞 𝐏𝐚𝐮𝐥 𝐒𝐦𝐢𝐭𝐡 𝐀𝐌’s decision, where on 3 October 2025 his Honour put a permanent stay on an ATO tax prosecution.
[𝘚𝘦𝘦 𝘪𝘮𝘢𝘨𝘦 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘪𝘯𝘵𝘳𝘰𝘥𝘶𝘤𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯 𝘵𝘰 𝐉𝐮𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐜𝐞 𝐒𝐦𝐢𝐭𝐡’𝘴 𝘴𝘩𝘰𝘤𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨, 𝘣𝘶𝘵 𝘸𝘦𝘭𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘦, 𝘥𝘦𝘤𝘪𝘴𝘪𝘰𝘯.]
We already know one innocent journalist — former Channel 7 newsreader 𝐒𝐢𝐦𝐨𝐧𝐞 𝐒𝐞𝐦𝐦𝐞𝐧𝐬 — spent 14 months in jail in 2019 for a crime she has now subsequently been acquitted of, following a 𝟏𝟓-𝐲𝐞𝐚𝐫 𝐛𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐥𝐞 with the ATO.
𝐋𝐢𝐧𝐤: news.com.au/finance/money/tax/tv-host-wins-15year-disgrac…
How many more people are going to be wrongfully prosecuted and jailed @AlboMP and @JEChalmers?
The Australian Executive Government must not allow Commonwealth agencies to commit misconduct, deceive our courts, and wrongfully prosecute citizens—actions that inevitably send innocent people to prison. 🏛️🔗
Are we a democracy, or is this a tin-pot Stalinist dictator state?
Thank you @Dan_Nolan9 and @ACurrentAffair9 for reporting on this terrifying overreach of executive power.
#auspol #auslaw #anthonyrains #taxoffice #ato #garnishees #businessdestruction #hidingevidence #abusebythestate #modifyingwitnessstatements #commonwealthabuseofcitizens @RossCoulthart #uapx #fiveeyes #followthemoney @DanielSheehan45
Ping @Grok and @ElonMuskThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
pHiycrtyl
@iycrtylph
Patrick Stewart was, like many of the greatest British artists of the 20th Century, a working class boy who became a world-class artist thanks to a public arts education made possible by Post War social democracy. He never forgot it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Hicks recognised a fundamental problem: equilibrium relationships do not explain how an economy actually traverses time.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good points. He realised that his time period for his Walrasian ISLM model was of the order of a week, but Keynes's was a Year. Holding expectations constant across a week was OK, but a year was not. So time, uncertainty, and disequilibrium became central to his thinking. Neoclassical economics caricatures all three, so he looked to Post-Keynesian and Austrian literature where, to varying degrees, they are taken seriously.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
Believable. This is also why I think journalists shouldn’t refer to economists as objective authorities in their own right just because they claim to be economists. At least 20% of economics is ideological, which is why the school or flavour (aka bias) of economics they champion must be highlighted when citing them.
These leanings are too frequently ignored by the media. Say 80 economists of one distinct school or bias right a letter to complaining about x or y policy. Newspapers cite them at face value and without context, as if they’re an objective body when they’re clearly not.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
I've been pointing out since the early 2010s that Thomas Piketty, Emmanuel Saez, and Gabriel Zucman have a bad habit of biasing their data construction to fit their politics.
Whenever they make a suspect call in how to handle stats, it ends up showing that inequality is on the rise. They almost never go in the other direction. The errors are non-random and almost invariably reinforce their political claims about rising income and wealth concentration since 1980.
Piketty did this throughout his book Capital in the 21st Century.
Piketty and Saez did this throughout their famous 2003 paper on inequality in the US.
Piketty, Saez, and Zucman Saez and Zucman did this in their Distributional National Accounts paper that Auten and Splinter dissected.
Saez and Zucman did this in their 2019 book on tax incidence and inequality.
Saez and Zucman did this in their flurry of "studies" and white papers to support Elizabeth Warren's wealth tax proposal, California Prop 40, a new wealth tax in France, and dozens of other similar examples.
A new AI report (linked below) audited 138 papers by Saez and Zucman. It found thousands of errors, 194 of which were serious. A whopping 97% of the serious errors went in the same direction: they showed inequality rising faster or made it higher.
But there's a bigger scandal at play here. Despite these clear biases, Piketty, Saez, and Zucman have enjoyed a stream of praise and prestige within the economics profession. They get expedited and friendly reviews in top econ journals even though a more serious peer review should have caught many of these errors (the Quarterly Journal of Economics is a recurring offender in this regard). Journals regularly give them a pass after the errors in their old work come to light - they're never expected to correct any of it, and just keep on using it as if nothing changed. Their non-peer reviewed data claims are also treated as gospel by major media outlets such as the New York Times and the Washington Post. And they get showered with prizes - Saez and Zucman are both Clark Medal winners from the AEA, and Zucman got his prize in 2023 after evidence of major data shenanigans in his work came to light in 2019.
Until now, those of us who have been trying to correct the record have had to wade through the PSZ trio's cluttered, disorganized, and often non-transparent replication packages (almost all of which are convoluted piles of Excel spreadsheets) to find the problems. I did a line-by-line replication of Piketty and Saez's entire 2003 US income inequality series to use one example, and found it was riddled with errors - almost every single one of which biased their results in favor of their political story.
We had the means to catch this stuff as it was happening, but the economics profession failed to do its job. And it failed precisely because its elite ranks wanted to believe the Piketty-Saez-Zucman story for political reasons. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A beautiful tribute. What made Star Trek The Next Generation so extraordinary was that the strong relationships feigned on the set were, if anything, mere echoes of the warmth the cast felt for each other in real life.
Trek Central
@TheTrekCentral
💖 Actress Marina Sirtis Posts Heartbreaking Tribute to Sir Patrick Stewart! 💔
Posting on Instagram, she said: "He's gone. My friend. My Captain. Me fellow football fan"
Sirtis and Stewart worked alongside each other across #startrek: The Next Generation, 4 movies and returned for #startrekpicard 🖖 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Patricia
@PatriciaNPino
This is why it’s so important to challenge the notion that the government “borrows” from the private sector. It paralyses everything, dresses itself up in “mundane common sense” but its one of the most damaging misunderstanding a politician can have.
BBC Newsnight
@BBCNewsnight
“What I find very difficult… is the assumption you have to cut your way to be being fiscally responsible”
“There’s not a hope in hell that [Labour] are going to oversee any cuts to public spending”
Economics professor Mariana Mazzucato and Conservative MP Julia Lopez debate Chancellor John Healey’s spending plans.
#newsnightThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Central banks have been handed independence and used it to become the unaccountable core of the system. This is what banking tyranny looks like , the literally domination of power by the banking elites taken to the point the country literally collapses .
Liz Truss is right: they have grown megalomaniacal. The governor of the Bank of England can’t be sacked; a prime minister can. That is not a technical detail. It is the actual power arrangement.
The mechanism and motivation is financialisation. It’s the core purpose of banking and in its current form it threatens the states existence .
Basel rules force banks to hold far more capital against a factory loan than against a mortgage.
Inflation targets treat rising house and land prices as “asset transfers,” not inflation, so rates never cool the boom.
Credit is therefore created against the existing housing stock and financial assets, the renter class, while industrial capacity is starved. Bankers literally live in ivory towers so they don’t notice till late in the cycle .
Workers’ wages are financialised into rents, mortgages and debt service. The West has been deindustrialised to the point it can no longer make what it needs. Bankers add no productive capacity to the society at all other than pulling forward production or asset inflation through debt .
This is the Tindale Trap conceit : maintaining financial dominance together with a material conversion failure. This bifurcation literally leaves the state with no productive capacity to to maintain sovereign existence .
Like draining blood you eventually get to weak to respond .
Truss tried a growth agenda that cut against the orthodoxy. The Bank’s timing of gilt sales, the LDI structures it regulated, and the narrative that followed removed her.
Independence was sold as insulation from politics. It has instead insulated a credit-allocation regime that privileges financialisation over production and protects itself against elected challenge. The direction of credit is the mechanism, and the political outcome is exactly what Truss is pointing to.
We live under a global banking dictatorship
Richard Werner
@scientificecon
In my Substack analysis at rwerner.substack.com I show how exactly the Bank of England toppled a sitting Prime Minister.
Ex-PM Liz Truss deserves all credit for her courage to battle the unaccountable central planners & not being intimidated by their vast but covert powers.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Oh wow. This is true. The new bosses at @bbc consider climate change to be woke. They’ve removed the climate heading on the news site. They want to downgrade reporting on the issue.
The BBC is a disaster when it comes to understanding what’s happening to the planet.
Why is right wing ideology allowed to destroy the bbc @lisanandyThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Capitalism is apparently the most efficient allocation mechanism ever invented, provided you ignore empty houses, homeless people, destroyed food, planned obsolescence, medical bankruptcies, wage theft, monopolies, pollution, bullshit jobs, and periodic financial catastrophes.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Kalecki's Theory of Economic Dynamics explains more about how firms actually set prices in a few chapters than the entire theory of subjective value and marginal utility.
Observing how businesses price their products is too fucking empirical for Austrian economics. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ian McKellen
@IanMcKellen
SIR PATRICK STEWART (1940-2026)
Before everything else, Patrick was defined by being born and bred in Yorkshire, the proud county in the north of England which he loved to the end. You could hear it in his accented voice and in the stern honesty with which he told you what he thought and felt. Yorkshiremen have no truck with half-truths or avoidance of big issues. He wore his heart on his sleeve, which made him a man to rely on, to admire and in my case, love.
We first met as ambitious young actors with the Royal Shakespeare Company half a century ago but we weren’t in the same productions. My first strong memory was a few years later, meeting him in the street in central London when he told me about an offer to take over a leading part in 'Star Trek'. “But Patrick think of your stage career in the UK. Do you really want to risk—getting lost in Hollywood for years and years?”. Well, he took the risk and thank goodness for us all that he did for not just his devoted Trekkies but film and theatre audiences, who marvelled at his using international celebrity to star in a string of cinema successes ('X-Men' of course) and in great classical plays by Shakespeare, Ibsen, Arthur Miller, Peter Shaffer, Pinter and Beckett at Stratford-upon-Avon, in London’s West End and on Broadway.
America was his adopted home, where he met his adored Sunny who has cared for him through sickness and health, through thick and thin. But he never forsook his origins: and the proudest achievement of the most respected and beloved actor of his generation on either side of the Atlantic, was his appointment as Chancellor of Huddersfield University in Yorkshire.
His farewell performance in 'Avengers: Doomsday' is yet to be seen.
Ian McKellen 29 October 2026
Photo: University of Huddersfield -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matt Van Swol
@mattvanswol
In 1952, an English teacher named Cecil Dormand secretly paid for a dirt-poor 11-year-old to take a drama course.
He never told him and the boy didn’t find out until decades later.
By then, he was a knight, that little boy’s name was Patrick Stewart.
He was born into a poor family in Mirfield, a small mill town in Yorkshire and his father came home from World War II a violent man, and he was violent toward Patrick’s mother.
Young Patrick learned exactly when to step between his father’s fist and his mother.
An English teacher put a copy of Shakespeare in his hand and told him to get up and perform.
He never stopped and left school at 15.
By 19 he was completely bald... most agencies told him he'd never make it because of that.
In 1987, the LA Times called him an “unknown British Shakespearean actor” when he was cast as Captain Picard.
Then he became one of the most famous faces on Earth.
You’ve probably heard that part.
Here’s the part you haven’t:
He spent decades as a patron of Refuge, sheltering women and children from domestic violence.
But he never stopped trying to understand his father.
He dug up a 1940 newspaper clipping that said his dad had come home with severe shell shock.
He went to France and walked the ground where his father’s unit was pinned down under bombing for hours.
He learned his father had PTSD, and nobody ever helped him.
So Patrick became an ambassador for Combat Stress, a charity that helps veterans.
In 2013, a young woman at a Texas convention told him she was a survivor of domestic violence.
He asked, “My dear, are you okay?”
Then he hopped off the stage, held her, and told her: “You never have to go through that again, you’re safe now.”
At Dragon Con, a Make-A-Wish girl dressed as Spock came to meet him.
2,000 people were waiting for him to speak... he sat down and talked with her for 15 minutes, making all of them wait.
He told her that since they were friends now, whenever she saw him on screen she could wave and say, “Hello Patrick.”
After 9/11, he felt helpless, so he brought his one-man A Christmas Carol back to Broadway for a full week of charity shows.
He played every character himself and donated every cent.
In 2019 he did it again, and every dollar went to feeding hungry New Yorkers.
In 2017, he fostered a pit bull named Ginger, who had been rescued from a dogfighting ring.
She was his first dog in more than 50 years.
He couldn’t bring her home to England, so he found her a family.
Then he kept fostering more.
When he said he was done with Star Trek so many people told him the show had gotten them through the hardest times of their lives.
So he wanted to see if Picard could do it one more time.
Rest in Peace, Sir Patrick 🖖 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Tate
@JamesTate121
Fuck you 2026, wrong guy again.
TMZ
@TMZ
Patrick Stewart, the veteran actor best known for "Star Trek," has died at 86 🙏💔
DETAILS: www.tmz.com/2026/10/29/patrick-stewart-dead/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Include me in the article!
@havenotwitass
The wrong octogenarians are being taken from us.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It won't be forgotten Ty. This is a very personal and detailed exposition of what it feels like when you try to bring reason and empirical validation, to a discipline dominated by teleology and ideology.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
🚨🛑
A little background for my post-Keynesian and MMT friends, and an explanation of what the fuck I've been doing on this account for the last six weeks.
Back in 2022, I met Steve Keen on a random livestream and ended up showing him a rather sophisticated pandemic model for Covid-19 I had developed for British Columbia, Canada, using his system dynamics software, Ravel. I had actually started using his software back in 2017, when I was working at a box factory and experimenting with ways to optimize productivity through system dynamics modeling.
Around the same time I first met Steve on that stream in 2022, I opened this Twitter account. I also started a YouTube channel producing system dynamics modeling tutorials, primarily focused on macroeconomics. Before that, I had deleted Facebook, Instagram, and pretty much every other social media account I had back in 2017 because I couldn't stand that shit anymore. "Just when I thought I got out, they pulled me right back in!"
In 2023, I began developing a large national economic model that led to a lot of unique opportunities and rebranded myself as Relearning Economics. I started posting historical economic quotes, which eventually became a regular feature of the account. Interestingly, quite a few accounts doing the same thing today appeared after I started doing it. Unfortunately, most of them turned out to be libertarian accounts.
Along the way, I met a tremendous number of economists, researchers, and systems thinkers. Those connections eventually turned into a steady side income from economic modeling contracts. Over time, I accumulated a substantial collection of unpublished models, experiments, and research that I wanted to make publicly available.
That eventually led to GDP Dynamics.
I launched @GDPDynamics and its corresponding website this past summer as a home for my economic models, forecasts, and research. Much of the forecasting and modeling work is available to the public for free, while a premium membership provides more detailed analysis and additional research. It has already developed into another source of income, allowing me to spend more time doing what I actually enjoy: building economic models.
Around the same time, I decided to retire the Relearning Economics identity, return to using my legal name on Twitter, and establish GDP Dynamics as a separate brand. Besides when you have the last name Keynes and you work in the field of economics, I could I have not returned to it. Another factor was the release of my book, Beyond Equilibrium: A dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
After two and a half years, posting historical economic quotes had become rather dated and redundant relative to what I was trying to accomplish. It certainly helped build an audience, but it also came with an enormous amount of bullshit.
For nearly two years, I dealt with a constant stream of Austrian economists and libertarians attacking practically anything I posted. Share a John Maynard Keynes quote and suddenly you're accused of supporting pedophilia. Discuss fiscal policy and you're a communist. Apparently, I'm a communist despite spending a considerable amount of my spare time developing software, negotiating contracts, selling economic modeling services, and running a business. Some days I feel like the most oppressed entrepreneur in economics.
The personal attacks were relentless. I received countless threats of violence from anonymous keyboard warriors, none of whom I took particularly seriously. Nevertheless, dealing with that shit almost every day for a couple of years becomes exhausting.
And this brings me to my Post-Keynesian and MMT followers.
I've watched how our side of the economics community has been treated, particularly by the Austrian and libertarian crowd. The constant insults, accusations, and personal attacks. Being called retards, faggots, woke libtards, communists, and just about every other insult these people can manage to string together. I've seen perfectly reasonable economic discussions turn into absolute cesspools because somebody dared to question the intellectual foundations of Austrian economics.
When I returned to using my legal name and separated the GDP Dynamics brand from my personal account, I had a little social experiment in mind.
Social media has become a clickbait shithole, populated by countless little ideological echo chambers. People spend more time defending their intellectual tribes than actually learning anything. In my case I find it particularly frustrating because I'm in the business of economic forecasting, not abstract fuckery.
So, beginning September 15th, I started a calculated campaign of what I would describe as chud-style economic ragebait, primarily directed at Austrian economists and libertarians, with the occasional shot at New Keynesians and neoclassical economists.
Over the following six weeks, those posts generated millions of impressions.
There were three reasons for doing this.
First, I'm fascinated by how systems behave. That's probably obvious considering I spend a substantial amount of my life building nonlinear dynamic models. Social media is itself a complex system of feedback loops, reinforcement mechanisms, incentives, and emergent behavior. I wanted to see what would happen if I deliberately changed the nature of the content being introduced into that system.
Second, I wanted to change the composition of my audience. My historical quote posting had attracted what I estimated to be somewhere between 1,000 and 2,000 Austrian and libertarian followers who had very little interest in my actual economic modeling work. I wanted to shed much of that audience and develop a healthier balance of people genuinely interested in macroeconomics, system dynamics, and the research I publish.
Based on the substantial follower turnover I've observed in my X Premium analytics over the past six weeks, that objective appears to have been achieved.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, I wanted to return some of the bullshit that I and many others in the post-Keynesian and MMT communities have endured on this platform which specifically accelerated after Musk took over.
After two years of watching these people casually throw around personal insults, threats, and accusations, I figured it might be entertaining to give them a taste of their own medicine.
Judging by the extraordinary amount of crybaby fuckery coming from libertarians over the past six weeks, I can say that particular objective has been rather satisfying. Those folk might be more woke than the woke woke(s)...
But there is also a more serious observation here.
What this experience has reinforced for me is just how ineffective social media can be as a platform for distributing substantive intellectual work. You can spend months developing an economic model, testing its behavior, validating its results, and writing a detailed explanation, only to reach a fraction of the audience that a deliberately provocative two-sentence post can attract in a few hours. Sadly this post that I have put effort into will mean little to nothing in a few hours and will probably get very low engagement because it's to long and complex for the TikTok generation.
The incentives overwhelmingly favor emotional reactions, ideological conflict, and instant gratification over research and meaningful discussion. Millions of impressions do not necessarily translate into people reading your work, understanding your models, or engaging with the underlying economics.
This is one of the reasons I established GDP Dynamics as an independent platform. I would rather have a smaller audience genuinely interested in my research than millions of impressions from people arguing about something they haven't bothered to understand.
And for anyone wondering whether I've become permanently consumed by Twitter/X ragebait, I can assure you I haven't. Will I stop, I don't know, If George Selgin gets any more emotionally damaged by my posts about David Graeber, he might end up on Prozac or some other antidepressant and if that's the case I will never stop.
In real life, I ride downhill mountain bikes for excitement, work on economic models, consulting work and run the GDP Dynamics site. As a Canadian I go to a lot of hockey games, say "eh" a lot and cut down trees with and axe. I'm probably more libertarian than a libertarian
Most of the stupid shit I post on this account is written while I'm sitting on the toilet. Not this one, I put some time into this some it can be forgotten about tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Hey, @NYFedResearch and @AtlantaFed, GDP Dynamics Nowcast came in on the money. You ready to send me the bag so I can come fix up your models?
US Real GDP 3.4% for Q3
Last updates before quarters end:
GDP Dynamics Nowcast: 3.4%
GDPNow Atlanta Fed: 3.3%
NY Fed Nowcast: 2.7%
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
US Real GDP came in strong at 3.4% perfectly in line with the last few GDP Dynamics Nowcast updates.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yes, arguably! (1) 1870-1910s, 1929-45, and now 2007-2027
(1) Walras "tatonnement" model: unknown to economists, was invalidated by mathematicians Perron-Frobenius in the 1910s;
(2) leads to Fisher's general equilibrium pre-Great Depression analysis; 1933, Fisher disowns equilibrium as the key flaw in his thinking;
(3) post-WWII, neoclassicals resurrect GE to its pinnacle in DSGE models by 2007, ignoring Fisher's rejection of equilibrium
(4) 2007 crisis invalides DSGE models; some limited soul-searching till about 2016;
2 decades later, Neoclassicals are bragging about their models again; They have forgotten their failure to see the biggest economic event since the Great Depression coming. They rejig DSGE models with "financial frictions", and building HANKS.
It is and will always be the undead of economics. No matter how many times it fails, no matter how many logical flaws and empirical fallacies are found, it lumbers on--like the Army of the Dead in the Game of Thrones. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Vicky Blaber
@BigBladder887
Fuck the haters Mr Keynes and keep doing what you’re doing which is God’s work if you ask me. And fuck those dumb-ass “Austrian” economists and their micro-penis micro-foundations neo classical inbred cousins.
Keep up the good work! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
"Just when I thought I got out, they pulled me right back in!"
😆 🤣 😂
And yeah, @ProfSteveKeen changed my life too. Jeep doing you.
#gdpdynamics
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
🚨🛑
A little background for my post-Keynesian and MMT friends, and an explanation of what the fuck I've been doing on this account for the last six weeks.
Back in 2022, I met Steve Keen on a random livestream and ended up showing him a rather sophisticated pandemic model for Covid-19 I had developed for British Columbia, Canada, using his system dynamics software, Ravel. I had actually started using his software back in 2017, when I was working at a box factory and experimenting with ways to optimize productivity through system dynamics modeling.
Around the same time I first met Steve on that stream in 2022, I opened this Twitter account. I also started a YouTube channel producing system dynamics modeling tutorials, primarily focused on macroeconomics. Before that, I had deleted Facebook, Instagram, and pretty much every other social media account I had back in 2017 because I couldn't stand that shit anymore. "Just when I thought I got out, they pulled me right back in!"
In 2023, I began developing a large national economic model that led to a lot of unique opportunities and rebranded myself as Relearning Economics. I started posting historical economic quotes, which eventually became a regular feature of the account. Interestingly, quite a few accounts doing the same thing today appeared after I started doing it. Unfortunately, most of them turned out to be libertarian accounts.
Along the way, I met a tremendous number of economists, researchers, and systems thinkers. Those connections eventually turned into a steady side income from economic modeling contracts. Over time, I accumulated a substantial collection of unpublished models, experiments, and research that I wanted to make publicly available.
That eventually led to GDP Dynamics.
I launched @GDPDynamics and its corresponding website this past summer as a home for my economic models, forecasts, and research. Much of the forecasting and modeling work is available to the public for free, while a premium membership provides more detailed analysis and additional research. It has already developed into another source of income, allowing me to spend more time doing what I actually enjoy: building economic models.
Around the same time, I decided to retire the Relearning Economics identity, return to using my legal name on Twitter, and establish GDP Dynamics as a separate brand. Besides when you have the last name Keynes and you work in the field of economics, I could I have not returned to it. Another factor was the release of my book, Beyond Equilibrium: A dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
After two and a half years, posting historical economic quotes had become rather dated and redundant relative to what I was trying to accomplish. It certainly helped build an audience, but it also came with an enormous amount of bullshit.
For nearly two years, I dealt with a constant stream of Austrian economists and libertarians attacking practically anything I posted. Share a John Maynard Keynes quote and suddenly you're accused of supporting pedophilia. Discuss fiscal policy and you're a communist. Apparently, I'm a communist despite spending a considerable amount of my spare time developing software, negotiating contracts, selling economic modeling services, and running a business. Some days I feel like the most oppressed entrepreneur in economics.
The personal attacks were relentless. I received countless threats of violence from anonymous keyboard warriors, none of whom I took particularly seriously. Nevertheless, dealing with that shit almost every day for a couple of years becomes exhausting.
And this brings me to my Post-Keynesian and MMT followers.
I've watched how our side of the economics community has been treated, particularly by the Austrian and libertarian crowd. The constant insults, accusations, and personal attacks. Being called retards, faggots, woke libtards, communists, and just about every other insult these people can manage to string together. I've seen perfectly reasonable economic discussions turn into absolute cesspools because somebody dared to question the intellectual foundations of Austrian economics.
When I returned to using my legal name and separated the GDP Dynamics brand from my personal account, I had a little social experiment in mind.
Social media has become a clickbait shithole, populated by countless little ideological echo chambers. People spend more time defending their intellectual tribes than actually learning anything. In my case I find it particularly frustrating because I'm in the business of economic forecasting, not abstract fuckery.
So, beginning September 15th, I started a calculated campaign of what I would describe as chud-style economic ragebait, primarily directed at Austrian economists and libertarians, with the occasional shot at New Keynesians and neoclassical economists.
Over the following six weeks, those posts generated millions of impressions.
There were three reasons for doing this.
First, I'm fascinated by how systems behave. That's probably obvious considering I spend a substantial amount of my life building nonlinear dynamic models. Social media is itself a complex system of feedback loops, reinforcement mechanisms, incentives, and emergent behavior. I wanted to see what would happen if I deliberately changed the nature of the content being introduced into that system.
Second, I wanted to change the composition of my audience. My historical quote posting had attracted what I estimated to be somewhere between 1,000 and 2,000 Austrian and libertarian followers who had very little interest in my actual economic modeling work. I wanted to shed much of that audience and develop a healthier balance of people genuinely interested in macroeconomics, system dynamics, and the research I publish.
Based on the substantial follower turnover I've observed in my X Premium analytics over the past six weeks, that objective appears to have been achieved.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, I wanted to return some of the bullshit that I and many others in the post-Keynesian and MMT communities have endured on this platform which specifically accelerated after Musk took over.
After two years of watching these people casually throw around personal insults, threats, and accusations, I figured it might be entertaining to give them a taste of their own medicine.
Judging by the extraordinary amount of crybaby fuckery coming from libertarians over the past six weeks, I can say that particular objective has been rather satisfying. Those folk might be more woke than the woke woke(s)...
But there is also a more serious observation here.
What this experience has reinforced for me is just how ineffective social media can be as a platform for distributing substantive intellectual work. You can spend months developing an economic model, testing its behavior, validating its results, and writing a detailed explanation, only to reach a fraction of the audience that a deliberately provocative two-sentence post can attract in a few hours. Sadly this post that I have put effort into will mean little to nothing in a few hours and will probably get very low engagement because it's to long and complex for the TikTok generation.
The incentives overwhelmingly favor emotional reactions, ideological conflict, and instant gratification over research and meaningful discussion. Millions of impressions do not necessarily translate into people reading your work, understanding your models, or engaging with the underlying economics.
This is one of the reasons I established GDP Dynamics as an independent platform. I would rather have a smaller audience genuinely interested in my research than millions of impressions from people arguing about something they haven't bothered to understand.
And for anyone wondering whether I've become permanently consumed by Twitter/X ragebait, I can assure you I haven't. Will I stop, I don't know, If George Selgin gets any more emotionally damaged by my posts about David Graeber, he might end up on Prozac or some other antidepressant and if that's the case I will never stop.
In real life, I ride downhill mountain bikes for excitement, work on economic models, consulting work and run the GDP Dynamics site. As a Canadian I go to a lot of hockey games, say "eh" a lot and cut down trees with and axe. I'm probably more libertarian than a libertarian
Most of the stupid shit I post on this account is written while I'm sitting on the toilet. Not this one, I put some time into this some it can be forgotten about tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
侥幸没歪
@jxzdmzw
亲爱的德国人,你起码犯了两个常识错误。
一、中国没有40平米的房子。除了单身公寓这种数量极少的投资型物业,中国的房子通常在90平以上,大城市在80平以上。
二、奔驰、宝马、奥迪不再是中国人追逐的品牌。现在的中国人喜欢电动车,而德国品牌的电动车被称为杂牌电动车。
当你的基础认知就已经是错误的,你只能得出荒谬的结论。
中国商品之所以物美价廉,是因为中国有齐全且集中的供应链、高效的物流系统、自动化的生产车间,以及规模优势拉低了边际成本。
中国当然也可以为那些优秀的商品定一个昂贵的价格,以换取丰厚的利润。过去你们就是这么干的,现在以我们的产品竞争力,也有条件这么干。
但我们不这么干。
这是因为,提高利润的代价是销量降低。对于你们那个只有几千万人口的国家来说,你们无需追求销量,无需扩大能量,因为你们无需为社会提供那么多的就业岗位。
但我们是一个14亿人口的国家。对我们来说,与其只创造1000个岗位,让这1000人拿一份丰厚的薪水,不如创造10000个岗位,让10000人拿一份普通的薪水。
薄利多销,能够支撑起更大的产能,提供更多的就业岗位。对企业来说,还能获得规模优势,压缩单件商品成本,扩大市场份额,创造更大营收,然后还有了更多的资金投入研发,如此循环滚动。
另一方面,这也大大有利于消费端市场,让全世界的消费者得以享受到物美价廉的中国商品。
想想你们的盾构机。曾经你们以一台 3.5 亿元人民币的价格买给中国。你们自恃垄断了制造技术,宁愿维持一个极低的销量,宁愿让那些发展中国家用不起,也要追求丰厚利润。
中国实现盾构机国产化之后,我们将每台的价格降至3000 万元人民币以下,不到你们价格的1/10。
诚然,我们没有赚到你们那么多的利润,但我们为发展中国家提供了质优价廉的采购选择,促进了那些国家的建设与发展,同时我们扩大了市场份额,创造了更多的生产就业岗位。
我们在做着多方共赢、造福世界的事业,你们则喜欢用技术垄断剥削全世界。当中国打破你们的技术垄断,你们恨得咬牙切齿。因为你们不仅仅是丧失了利润,而且丧失市场份额,丧失了就业岗位。
你们在工业领域的失守,仍在加剧。以前,德国汽车只想要中国的工人和市场,但现在,他们不得不将研发重心也放到中国。
你们愚蠢地与俄罗斯开战,切断了俄罗斯的能源供应。你们几十年去工业化,导致理工科学生数量大幅下降,工程师人才极度缺失。
这样的营商环境,导致你们的企业纷纷关闭德国工厂,迁往中国和美国。
你们失业,你们抗议。但这一切都是你们自己的选择,你们并不无辜。
Melih
@melihgs05
Liebe Chinesen, Ihr schuftet euer Leben lang, eure Kinder für ein paar Euro gleich mit – für 40 m² und vielleicht einen BYD. Während ihr von Mercedes, BMW und Audi träumt, kauft der Westen eure Arbeit billig. Bitter, oder? „Made in China“ steht hierzulande für billig Ware.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
🚨🛑
A little background for my post-Keynesian and MMT friends, and an explanation of what the fuck I've been doing on this account for the last six weeks.
Back in 2022, I met Steve Keen on a random livestream and ended up showing him a rather sophisticated pandemic model for Covid-19 I had developed for British Columbia, Canada, using his system dynamics software, Ravel. I had actually started using his software back in 2017, when I was working at a box factory and experimenting with ways to optimize productivity through system dynamics modeling.
Around the same time I first met Steve on that stream in 2022, I opened this Twitter account. I also started a YouTube channel producing system dynamics modeling tutorials, primarily focused on macroeconomics. Before that, I had deleted Facebook, Instagram, and pretty much every other social media account I had back in 2017 because I couldn't stand that shit anymore. "Just when I thought I got out, they pulled me right back in!"
In 2023, I began developing a large national economic model that led to a lot of unique opportunities and rebranded myself as Relearning Economics. I started posting historical economic quotes, which eventually became a regular feature of the account. Interestingly, quite a few accounts doing the same thing today appeared after I started doing it. Unfortunately, most of them turned out to be libertarian accounts.
Along the way, I met a tremendous number of economists, researchers, and systems thinkers. Those connections eventually turned into a steady side income from economic modeling contracts. Over time, I accumulated a substantial collection of unpublished models, experiments, and research that I wanted to make publicly available.
That eventually led to GDP Dynamics.
I launched @GDPDynamics and its corresponding website this past summer as a home for my economic models, forecasts, and research. Much of the forecasting and modeling work is available to the public for free, while a premium membership provides more detailed analysis and additional research. It has already developed into another source of income, allowing me to spend more time doing what I actually enjoy: building economic models.
Around the same time, I decided to retire the Relearning Economics identity, return to using my legal name on Twitter, and establish GDP Dynamics as a separate brand. Besides when you have the last name Keynes and you work in the field of economics, I could I have not returned to it. Another factor was the release of my book, Beyond Equilibrium: A dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
After two and a half years, posting historical economic quotes had become rather dated and redundant relative to what I was trying to accomplish. It certainly helped build an audience, but it also came with an enormous amount of bullshit.
For nearly two years, I dealt with a constant stream of Austrian economists and libertarians attacking practically anything I posted. Share a John Maynard Keynes quote and suddenly you're accused of supporting pedophilia. Discuss fiscal policy and you're a communist. Apparently, I'm a communist despite spending a considerable amount of my spare time developing software, negotiating contracts, selling economic modeling services, and running a business. Some days I feel like the most oppressed entrepreneur in economics.
The personal attacks were relentless. I received countless threats of violence from anonymous keyboard warriors, none of whom I took particularly seriously. Nevertheless, dealing with that shit almost every day for a couple of years becomes exhausting.
And this brings me to my Post-Keynesian and MMT followers.
I've watched how our side of the economics community has been treated, particularly by the Austrian and libertarian crowd. The constant insults, accusations, and personal attacks. Being called retards, faggots, woke libtards, communists, and just about every other insult these people can manage to string together. I've seen perfectly reasonable economic discussions turn into absolute cesspools because somebody dared to question the intellectual foundations of Austrian economics.
When I returned to using my legal name and separated the GDP Dynamics brand from my personal account, I had a little social experiment in mind.
Social media has become a clickbait shithole, populated by countless little ideological echo chambers. People spend more time defending their intellectual tribes than actually learning anything. In my case I find it particularly frustrating because I'm in the business of economic forecasting, not abstract fuckery.
So, beginning September 15th, I started a calculated campaign of what I would describe as chud-style economic ragebait, primarily directed at Austrian economists and libertarians, with the occasional shot at New Keynesians and neoclassical economists.
Over the following six weeks, those posts generated millions of impressions.
There were three reasons for doing this.
First, I'm fascinated by how systems behave. That's probably obvious considering I spend a substantial amount of my life building nonlinear dynamic models. Social media is itself a complex system of feedback loops, reinforcement mechanisms, incentives, and emergent behavior. I wanted to see what would happen if I deliberately changed the nature of the content being introduced into that system.
Second, I wanted to change the composition of my audience. My historical quote posting had attracted what I estimated to be somewhere between 1,000 and 2,000 Austrian and libertarian followers who had very little interest in my actual economic modeling work. I wanted to shed much of that audience and develop a healthier balance of people genuinely interested in macroeconomics, system dynamics, and the research I publish.
Based on the substantial follower turnover I've observed in my X Premium analytics over the past six weeks, that objective appears to have been achieved.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, I wanted to return some of the bullshit that I and many others in the post-Keynesian and MMT communities have endured on this platform which specifically accelerated after Musk took over.
After two years of watching these people casually throw around personal insults, threats, and accusations, I figured it might be entertaining to give them a taste of their own medicine.
Judging by the extraordinary amount of crybaby fuckery coming from libertarians over the past six weeks, I can say that particular objective has been rather satisfying. Those folk might be more woke than the woke woke(s)...
But there is also a more serious observation here.
What this experience has reinforced for me is just how ineffective social media can be as a platform for distributing substantive intellectual work. You can spend months developing an economic model, testing its behavior, validating its results, and writing a detailed explanation, only to reach a fraction of the audience that a deliberately provocative two-sentence post can attract in a few hours. Sadly this post that I have put effort into will mean little to nothing in a few hours and will probably get very low engagement because it's to long and complex for the TikTok generation.
The incentives overwhelmingly favor emotional reactions, ideological conflict, and instant gratification over research and meaningful discussion. Millions of impressions do not necessarily translate into people reading your work, understanding your models, or engaging with the underlying economics.
This is one of the reasons I established GDP Dynamics as an independent platform. I would rather have a smaller audience genuinely interested in my research than millions of impressions from people arguing about something they haven't bothered to understand.
And for anyone wondering whether I've become permanently consumed by Twitter/X ragebait, I can assure you I haven't. Will I stop, I don't know, If George Selgin gets any more emotionally damaged by my posts about David Graeber, he might end up on Prozac or some other antidepressant and if that's the case I will never stop.
In real life, I ride downhill mountain bikes for excitement, work on economic models, consulting work and run the GDP Dynamics site. As a Canadian I go to a lot of hockey games, say "eh" a lot and cut down trees with and axe. I'm probably more libertarian than a libertarian
Most of the stupid shit I post on this account is written while I'm sitting on the toilet. Not this one, I put some time into this some it can be forgotten about tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David McNab @mcfab@home.social
@DavidMcNab17
“It (the General Equilibrium model) is and will always be the undead of economics. No matter how many times it fails, no matter how many logical flaws and empirical fallacies are found, it lumbers on--like the Army of the Dead in the Game of Thrones.”
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yes, arguably! (1) 1870-1910s, 1929-45, and now 2007-2027
(1) Walras "tatonnement" model: unknown to economists, was invalidated by mathematicians Perron-Frobenius in the 1910s;
(2) leads to Fisher's general equilibrium pre-Great Depression analysis; 1933, Fisher disowns equilibrium as the key flaw in his thinking;
(3) post-WWII, neoclassicals resurrect GE to its pinnacle in DSGE models by 2007, ignoring Fisher's rejection of equilibrium
(4) 2007 crisis invalides DSGE models; some limited soul-searching till about 2016;
2 decades later, Neoclassicals are bragging about their models again; They have forgotten their failure to see the biggest economic event since the Great Depression coming. They rejig DSGE models with "financial frictions", and building HANKS.
It is and will always be the undead of economics. No matter how many times it fails, no matter how many logical flaws and empirical fallacies are found, it lumbers on--like the Army of the Dead in the Game of Thrones. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
That's how the bond system started in C12 Venice. The wealthy familes engineered a war with Byzantium, which obliged the state to borrow money from them and pay interest in perpetuity - an incredible scam. An early secondary market developed in C13 after the original prestiti loans were consolidated into a single fund called the Monte Vecchio, centred around the Rialto market where the trading took place. Traders found they could influence state bond yields by driving them up in the secondary market. This was the platform on which the early merchant-banking families rose to prominence as organised usurers. By C17 the system had migrated North to be fully institutionalised by the Dutch and the British. Basically, it was the restoration of the aristocratic debt-servicing system that had been institutionalised around 1500 BC and led to the collapse of Antiquity in C5 AD. Between that point and C12 it was temporarily repressed by Christian anti-usury laws, currency diversity/instability and the normalisation of violent retribution during the 'Dark Age'. Once again, wars are now being engineered to rescue and renew a private debt-servicing system on the verge of collapse. History rhyming.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It won't be forgotten Ty. This is a very personal and detailed exposition of what it feels like when you try to bring reason and empirical validation, to a discipline dominated by teleology and ideology.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
🚨🛑
A little background for my post-Keynesian and MMT friends, and an explanation of what the fuck I've been doing on this account for the last six weeks.
Back in 2022, I met Steve Keen on a random livestream and ended up showing him a rather sophisticated pandemic model for Covid-19 I had developed for British Columbia, Canada, using his system dynamics software, Ravel. I had actually started using his software back in 2017, when I was working at a box factory and experimenting with ways to optimize productivity through system dynamics modeling.
Around the same time I first met Steve on that stream in 2022, I opened this Twitter account. I also started a YouTube channel producing system dynamics modeling tutorials, primarily focused on macroeconomics. Before that, I had deleted Facebook, Instagram, and pretty much every other social media account I had back in 2017 because I couldn't stand that shit anymore. "Just when I thought I got out, they pulled me right back in!"
In 2023, I began developing a large national economic model that led to a lot of unique opportunities and rebranded myself as Relearning Economics. I started posting historical economic quotes, which eventually became a regular feature of the account. Interestingly, quite a few accounts doing the same thing today appeared after I started doing it. Unfortunately, most of them turned out to be libertarian accounts.
Along the way, I met a tremendous number of economists, researchers, and systems thinkers. Those connections eventually turned into a steady side income from economic modeling contracts. Over time, I accumulated a substantial collection of unpublished models, experiments, and research that I wanted to make publicly available.
That eventually led to GDP Dynamics.
I launched @GDPDynamics and its corresponding website this past summer as a home for my economic models, forecasts, and research. Much of the forecasting and modeling work is available to the public for free, while a premium membership provides more detailed analysis and additional research. It has already developed into another source of income, allowing me to spend more time doing what I actually enjoy: building economic models.
Around the same time, I decided to retire the Relearning Economics identity, return to using my legal name on Twitter, and establish GDP Dynamics as a separate brand. Besides when you have the last name Keynes and you work in the field of economics, I could I have not returned to it. Another factor was the release of my book, Beyond Equilibrium: A dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
After two and a half years, posting historical economic quotes had become rather dated and redundant relative to what I was trying to accomplish. It certainly helped build an audience, but it also came with an enormous amount of bullshit.
For nearly two years, I dealt with a constant stream of Austrian economists and libertarians attacking practically anything I posted. Share a John Maynard Keynes quote and suddenly you're accused of supporting pedophilia. Discuss fiscal policy and you're a communist. Apparently, I'm a communist despite spending a considerable amount of my spare time developing software, negotiating contracts, selling economic modeling services, and running a business. Some days I feel like the most oppressed entrepreneur in economics.
The personal attacks were relentless. I received countless threats of violence from anonymous keyboard warriors, none of whom I took particularly seriously. Nevertheless, dealing with that shit almost every day for a couple of years becomes exhausting.
And this brings me to my Post-Keynesian and MMT followers.
I've watched how our side of the economics community has been treated, particularly by the Austrian and libertarian crowd. The constant insults, accusations, and personal attacks. Being called retards, faggots, woke libtards, communists, and just about every other insult these people can manage to string together. I've seen perfectly reasonable economic discussions turn into absolute cesspools because somebody dared to question the intellectual foundations of Austrian economics.
When I returned to using my legal name and separated the GDP Dynamics brand from my personal account, I had a little social experiment in mind.
Social media has become a clickbait shithole, populated by countless little ideological echo chambers. People spend more time defending their intellectual tribes than actually learning anything. In my case I find it particularly frustrating because I'm in the business of economic forecasting, not abstract fuckery.
So, beginning September 15th, I started a calculated campaign of what I would describe as chud-style economic ragebait, primarily directed at Austrian economists and libertarians, with the occasional shot at New Keynesians and neoclassical economists.
Over the following six weeks, those posts generated millions of impressions.
There were three reasons for doing this.
First, I'm fascinated by how systems behave. That's probably obvious considering I spend a substantial amount of my life building nonlinear dynamic models. Social media is itself a complex system of feedback loops, reinforcement mechanisms, incentives, and emergent behavior. I wanted to see what would happen if I deliberately changed the nature of the content being introduced into that system.
Second, I wanted to change the composition of my audience. My historical quote posting had attracted what I estimated to be somewhere between 1,000 and 2,000 Austrian and libertarian followers who had very little interest in my actual economic modeling work. I wanted to shed much of that audience and develop a healthier balance of people genuinely interested in macroeconomics, system dynamics, and the research I publish.
Based on the substantial follower turnover I've observed in my X Premium analytics over the past six weeks, that objective appears to have been achieved.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, I wanted to return some of the bullshit that I and many others in the post-Keynesian and MMT communities have endured on this platform which specifically accelerated after Musk took over.
After two years of watching these people casually throw around personal insults, threats, and accusations, I figured it might be entertaining to give them a taste of their own medicine.
Judging by the extraordinary amount of crybaby fuckery coming from libertarians over the past six weeks, I can say that particular objective has been rather satisfying. Those folk might be more woke than the woke woke(s)...
But there is also a more serious observation here.
What this experience has reinforced for me is just how ineffective social media can be as a platform for distributing substantive intellectual work. You can spend months developing an economic model, testing its behavior, validating its results, and writing a detailed explanation, only to reach a fraction of the audience that a deliberately provocative two-sentence post can attract in a few hours. Sadly this post that I have put effort into will mean little to nothing in a few hours and will probably get very low engagement because it's to long and complex for the TikTok generation.
The incentives overwhelmingly favor emotional reactions, ideological conflict, and instant gratification over research and meaningful discussion. Millions of impressions do not necessarily translate into people reading your work, understanding your models, or engaging with the underlying economics.
This is one of the reasons I established GDP Dynamics as an independent platform. I would rather have a smaller audience genuinely interested in my research than millions of impressions from people arguing about something they haven't bothered to understand.
And for anyone wondering whether I've become permanently consumed by Twitter/X ragebait, I can assure you I haven't. Will I stop, I don't know, If George Selgin gets any more emotionally damaged by my posts about David Graeber, he might end up on Prozac or some other antidepressant and if that's the case I will never stop.
In real life, I ride downhill mountain bikes for excitement, work on economic models, consulting work and run the GDP Dynamics site. As a Canadian I go to a lot of hockey games, say "eh" a lot and cut down trees with and axe. I'm probably more libertarian than a libertarian
Most of the stupid shit I post on this account is written while I'm sitting on the toilet. Not this one, I put some time into this some it can be forgotten about tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ian S
@MonkFromHavana
I say, let's bring back lead-based paint, thalidomide and the miracle of asbestos while we're at it. Maybe we just weren't using them in an "intellectually coherent way".
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
At last! A sensible use for Neoclassical economics textbooks!
between2infinities
@StimulusStruggl
The marginal dollar reallocations with the most ethical worth are those that fund the industrial-scale conversion of neoclassical economics textbooks into birdcage liners, where they can finally receive a proper peer review.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ian S
@MonkFromHavana
I see the economic necromancer has dug up GE theory back to life again from its grave in the cemetary of ideas that were utter failures, for what, the 3rd time?
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory" is another way of saying that General Equilibrium theory is incoherent.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory … it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why don’t firms offer lower wages and why don’t unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts … accepted Friedman’s argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels … they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
Ian S
@MonkFromHavana
I see the economic necromancer has dug up GE theory back to life again from its grave in the cemetary of ideas that were utter failures, for what, the 3rd time?
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yes, arguably! (1) 1870-1910s, 1929-45, and now 2007-2027
(1) Walras "tatonnement" model: unknown to economists, was invalidated by mathematicians Perron-Frobenius in the 1910s;
(2) leads to Fisher's general equilibrium pre-Great Depression analysis; 1933, Fisher disowns equilibrium as the key flaw in his thinking;
(3) post-WWII, neoclassicals resurrect GE to its pinnacle in DSGE models by 2007, ignoring Fisher's rejection of equilibrium
(4) 2007 crisis invalides DSGE models; some limited soul-searching till about 2016;
2 decades later, Neoclassicals are bragging about their models again; They have forgotten their failure to see the biggest economic event since the Great Depression coming. They rejig DSGE models with "financial frictions", and building HANKS.
It is and will always be the undead of economics. No matter how many times it fails, no matter how many logical flaws and empirical fallacies are found, it lumbers on--like the Army of the Dead in the Game of Thrones.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You don't know enough. And you won't learn what you need to know by reading Neoclassical literature.
Dillard, D. (1984). "Keynes and Marx: A Centennial Appraisal." Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 6(3): 421–432Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good points. He realised that his time period for his Walrasian ISLM model was of the order of a week, but Keynes's was a Year. Holding expectations constant across a week was OK, but a year was not. So time, uncertainty, and disequilibrium became central to his thinking. Neoclassical economics caricatures all three, so he looked to Post-Keynesian and Austrian literature where, to varying degrees, they are taken seriously.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Sure. So long as you're willing to assume that "optimal
reallocations of income can be assumed to keep the ethical worth of each person's marginal dollar equal" ans a few other fantasies.
Samuelson, P. A. (1956). "Social Indifference Curves." The Quarterly Journal Of Economics 70(1): 1–22.
Samuelson, P. A. (1966). "A Summing Up." Quarterly Journal of Economics 80(4): 568–583. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rebecca Chan
@RebeccaYChan
Mao’s greatest achievement was kicking out the Western imperialists who forced the Chinese to become opium addicts at gunpoint.
This photo was cropped to hide the fact that British soldiers had guns pointed at this household to force them to smoke opium.
The American propaganda machine would like you to think that Jews like Sassoon were the biggest drug barons. They were not. It was the Anglo-American opium barons who did so well pushing opium that they went “legit” and could purchase the presidency.
Rebecca Chan
@RebeccaYChan
Sassoon, Forbes, Delano-Roosevelt’s, Perkins, Astors, and other Boston Brahmins made their fortunes from the Opium Holocaust. One hundred years of genocidal drug pushing by forcing people to smoke at gunpoint until addicted.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
"Fiscal responsibility should ultimately be judged by whether public finances strengthen the economy’s capacity to grow and withstand shocks."
Our democracies are under threat from austerity. Governments must resist this pressure. That's one of the key messages in our new policy brief, from the Global Council on New Economics for the 21st Century.
Together with @MazzucatoM, @carlos_cuerpo, @Jayati1609, @JosephEStiglitz and many more, I'm looking forward to working with policymakers to implement our recommendations. Read more at the link below. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
its a joke alright.
but it’s no joke.
it gives mainstream (“neoclassical”) economics (I want to say economists) yet another institutional platform from which to spout their nonsense.
#deficitmyth
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
There is no 'Nobel Prize in economics'. The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences was concocted by an associate of the Mont Pelerin Society. It's a joke. jornal.unicamp.br/en/artigo/2025/11/03/nao-existe-um-prem…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
Pretty amazing that its 2026 and prominent economists still say obviously false things about literature they cite and haven't read.
The **title** of Phillips' paper is "The Relation between Unemployment and the Rate of Change of Money Wage Rates in the United Kingdom, 1861-1957"
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
Is the Phillips curve useful to make sense of inflation?
A.W.H. Phillips first postulated a negative empirical correlation between inflation and the level of economic activity. Looking at inflation in 2021-24---up and down---versus measures of unemployment---roughly unchanged---shows little correlation. Has the Phillips curve failed, yet again? No, it did not.
Friedman and Phelps, almost 50 years ago, clarified that this correlation should only hold keeping expected inflation fixed. Almost every account of how firms choose prices or bargain wages with their workers predicts that expectations would show up in a Philips curve. Moreover, those models of behavior further add that increases in marginal costs (supply shocks) would further shift out this relation. The empirical Phillips curve has for many decades meant a negative relation between inflation and real activity, controlling for expected inflation and supply shocks.
The left figure below shows on the vertical axis inflation, after controlling for expected inflation---mean and disagreement from a household survey---and for supply shocks---gas prices and global supply pressures. The horizontal axis shows a measure of slack in the labor market---the log of the ratio of unemployment to job vacancies. The Phillips curve held nicely and steadily throughout.
A criticism of that figure is that its is looking in the rear view mirror: the measure of supply shocks and the measure of slack were developed in the last few years and the data has been revised. The right figure does instead an out-of sample exercise. Estimate a regression of inflation on (i) expected inflation, (ii) the difference between the unemployment rate and the CBO estimate of its non-cyclical component, and (iii) the PCE energy price index. Do it on data pre-pandemic: 1984Q1-2020Q1. Using that estimated equation, predict inflation in real time from then onwards using the data releases available at the time of the forecast. The Phillips curve was a pretty good predictor of inflation throughout.
The Phillips curve was stable during the inflation surge, and it predicted well the movements in inflation, with expectations playing a key role in those predictions.
Notes: it is important to include the right measure of expectations to understand inflation-activity dynamics at a business-cycle frequency: the short-horizon expectations of households and firms. (For instance, the long-horizon expectations from professionals, or the expectations from models in policy institutions, as in my previous two posts, are the wrong measure.)
Sources:
(i) Section 3 in Reis "Why Did Inflation Rise and Fall in 2021-24? Channels and Evidence from Expectations"
(ii) The simple exercise on the left figure is inspired on the analysis of Bernanke and Blanchard “What Caused the US Pandemic-Era Inflation?”
(iii) The simple exercise on the right figure is inspired on @jadhazell "Comment" in the NBER macro annual 2025, which in turn built on Beaudry, Hou, and Portier "The Dominant Role of Expectations and Broad-Based Supply Shocks in Driving Inflation" -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alexander Ač
@Lacertko
Nordhaus is just one of many charlatans, they routinely get Nobel prices in economics. @ProfSteveKeen
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
Absolutely bang-on from @fionaharvey
IMHO Nordhaus was a charlatan whose nonsense figures have held back serious climate action for decades
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/oct/28/nicholas-st… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
@farmerrf
Monetary theory of production:
“… capitalist production is only completed when the value of output is realised in the form of money.
Under these arrangements, the direct objective of society is subordinated to the money-making objectives …”
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You don't know enough. And you won't learn what you need to know by reading Neoclassical literature.
Dillard, D. (1984). "Keynes and Marx: A Centennial Appraisal." Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 6(3): 421–432 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Warwick Smith
@RecoEco
It doesn't incorporate his contributions though does it? Robinson, a close collaborator with Keynes called it "bastard Keynesianism" using the word bastard to mean an illegitimate claim to the name.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
TFW when a well known economist makes it very clear he has never read the General Theory
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory … it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why don’t firms offer lower wages and why don’t unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts … accepted Friedman’s argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels … they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Graham White
@heterodox_econs
As is well known Keynes's answer in Ch.19 of the GT is that lower money wages would not likely correct unemployment because they would not ensure a necessary adjustment of effective demand to warrant higher employment.
These arguments as put by Keynes were weak and easy prey to the mainstream of the time. But in a nutshell, the mainstream offered up basically two types of mechanics to argue Keynes'sdemand problem could be overcome by flexibility of money wages, prices and interest rates: the so-called Keynes effect and the so_called Pigou effect, neither coherent in the light of subsequent theorising.
The definitive essay to my mind on the GT and how capital theoretical considerations in particular undermine the contortions of traditional theory to accommodate Keynes's contention of unemployment equilibrium is by Garegnani (1978-79 CJE) 'Notes on consumption, investment and effective demand'. Similarly the book by Eatwell and Milgate, Keynes's Economics and the Theory of Value and Distribution stands the test of time. @USydneyEcon @ProfSteveKeen @farmerrf
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory" is another way of saying that General Equilibrium theory is incoherent.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory … it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why don’t firms offer lower wages and why don’t unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts … accepted Friedman’s argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels … they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
@claraemattei
For friends in Tulsa, tomorrow I will be giving this public lecture at TCC. All are welcome!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Despite strength in several areas of the US economy, rising household debt-servicing burdens alongside falling home prices are concerning.
I wouldn't call it the straw that breaks the camel's back, but it's a trend worth watching closely in the coming quarters.
Next Post Links: -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
A matter of weeks now...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Sure. So long as you're willing to assume that "optimal
reallocations of income can be assumed to keep the ethical worth of each person's marginal dollar equal" ans a few other fantasies.
Samuelson, P. A. (1956). "Social Indifference Curves." The Quarterly Journal Of Economics 70(1): 1–22.
Samuelson, P. A. (1966). "A Summing Up." Quarterly Journal of Economics 80(4): 568–583. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory" is another way of saying that General Equilibrium theory is incoherent.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory … it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why don’t firms offer lower wages and why don’t unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts … accepted Friedman’s argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels … they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mundo Do Tênis 🎾
@mundodotenispod
Olha, falar do Stan Wawrinka é falar de um cara que a gente não tem como não gostar.
Ele nunca foi o mais badalado, nunca foi o queridinho da mídia como o Federer, nem o touro imparável como o Nadal, nem a máquina perfeita do Djokovic. Ele era o outro suíço. O cara de cara fechada, tatuagem no braço escrito Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better. E foi exatamente isso que ele fez a carreira inteira.
Ele demorou pra acontecer. Enquanto os outros já eram campeões com 20 anos, o Stan foi ganhar seu primeiro Grand Slam com quase 29, na Austrália em 2014, contra o Nadal. Aí você pensa, foi sorte. No ano seguinte ele vai e ganha Roland Garros do Djokovic, jogando um tênis absurdo, aquele backhand de uma mão estalando. E pra calar de vez, ganha o US Open em 2016, de novo contra o Djokovic, saindo de 0 a 1 e virando.
O jogo dele é pura porrada bonita. Não tem firula, não tem truque. É saque pesado, forehand que parece uma marretada e aquele backhand de uma mão, talvez o mais lindo que já vi. Quando ele tá no dia, no tal modo Stanimal, não tem quem segure. A bola anda de um jeito diferente.
E o legado dele é isso. Ele não tem 20 Grand Slams, mas tem três que valem por dez, porque foram todos arrancados da mão dos três maiores da história. Ele é a prova de que dá pra ser gigante mesmo não sendo o favorito. E de que dá pra recomeçar depois de joelho destruído, de cirurgia, de ficar quase um ano parado e voltar aos 40 anos ainda brigando com moleque de 20.
No fim, o Stan fica na memória como o cara que nos lembrou que tênis também é coração e teimosia. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I just finished Hudson's Killing the Host, after reading Mises' Human Action, Hayek's The Road to Serfdom, and Rothbard's Man, Economy, and State last year.
Hudson's book is better than all three combined. Austrian economics is a thousand-page handjob for landlords. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
How do you demand better wages when you can't afford to miss a paycheck?
Debt is swallowing more than half of workers' wage gains—and weakening their power.
@AngelaHanks of @TCFdotorg explains how debt worsens the affordability crisis.
🎧 ➡️ pod.link/pitchforkeconomics/episode/M2JhZjU0NzAtZDIxNy0xM… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Healey’s Budget Disaster. This was a terrible budget, terribly presented, that did precisely nothing of consequence for almost anyone. So what are Healey and Burnham up to, other than not a lot? youtu.be/r4p9EY_JHvI
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thinking in equilibrium terms is the problem, Roger. Real-world capitalism is a far-from-equilibrium complex system, and the imposition of equilibrium conditions obscures rather than illuminates. Macro models can be logically built with no forced assumption of equilibrium.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
Michael Hudson explains that public services run non-for-profit are good for the economy as a whole.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
The reason why there are 52 cards in poker
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Yuliya Yurchenko 🇺🇦
@YPYurchenko
Neoclassicals as such a sad cult! Even the Bible got more revisions than their textbooks.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Pay that one!!! 😂🤣
Dr Yuliya Yurchenko 🇺🇦
@YPYurchenko
Neoclassicals as such a sad cult! Even the Bible got more revisions than their textbooks.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Yuliya Yurchenko 🇺🇦
@YPYurchenko
Is this what happens when people don't study history of their own subject?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I would say incomplete rather than incoherent
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory" is another way of saying that General Equilibrium theory is incoherent.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynes’ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory … it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why don’t firms offer lower wages and why don’t unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts … accepted Friedman’s argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels … they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thinking in equilibrium terms is the problem, Roger. Real-world capitalism is a far-from-equilibrium complex system, and the imposition of equilibrium conditions obscures rather than illuminates. Macro models can be logically built with no forced assumption of equilibrium.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Frances 'Cassandra' Coppola
@Frances_Coppola
It's satire.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Buddy Wells
@BuddyWells1
“This apparent paradox (that government policies aimed at reducing government interference in the economy actually end up producing more regulations, more bureaucrats, and more police) can be observed so regularly that I believe it justifies treating it as a general sociological law. I propose calling it the “Iron Law of Liberalism”:
The Iron Law of Liberalism states that any market reform, any government initiative aimed at reducing bureaucratic procedures and promoting market forces, will have, as its ultimate effect, an increase in the total number of regulations, the total amount of paperwork, and the total number of bureaucrats the government employs.”
David Graeber
Tomás Molina
@platom___
David Graeber llamaba a esto "la ley de hierro del liberalismo": las reformas de mercado terminan por aumentar las regulaciones, el papeleo y la cantidad de burócratas.
La cita es de "La utopía de las normas". Pueden encontrar el libro completo en PDF en Google si lo buscan. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ACEMAXX ANALYTICS
@acemaxx
(note to self) @ProfSteveKeen 's accounting demonstrates why the household #analogy is misleading. It does not eliminate the institutional constraints facing an individual #euro -area Govt. Nor does monetary sovereignty eliminate #real constraints:
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ben Pennings
@BenPennings
'The Australian' tried a gotcha on new Greens leader David Shoebridge and it didn't go as planned 😎
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Risk Expert tells the Truth about Climate
@MarkCranfield_
Give me strength, guy is like delusion personified. But he's not to blame.
"Emissions are cumulative", he rightly says, but without explanation the words don't mean anything.
People are led to believe it means that warming increases in line with the accumulation of GHGs in the atmosphere.
But that's not what it means at all.
Human-emitted GHGs have accumulated in the atmosphere so fast during 250 years of industrialisation that it will take thousands of years for this planet to adjust to them —Ocean heat content and thermal inertia, loss of ice and cloud reflectivity, GHG feedbacks, changes to land and ocean sinks, etc. IT ALL TAKES TIME.
Although full equilibrium takes millennia, warming is fast on a century timescale due to the response of the oceans and fast feedbacks.
By the time the planet has fully adjusted, the entire ocean column and atmospheric column will have gained around 10 degrees Celsius.
That's based solely on human GHG emissions so far. No further human GHG forcing is required to melt all the ice on Earth and raise sea levels by 230 feet.
At this point, and only this point, the Earth's energy balance is restored (as must energy going out as coming in) and global climate can become relatively stable again.
Simon is another victim of industrial-scale, wall-to-wall, fully immersive, saturation misinformation and propaganda.
Nothing he's talking about matters except the consequences of the accumulation of emissions. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ACEMAXX ANALYTICS
@acemaxx
Prof. Keen is right to challenge the idea that reducing public debt is an end in itself. The real objective should be a stable, productive economy with adequate public services—not an arbitrary debt ratio, chart @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-theoretical-lie-that-gov…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Frances 'Cassandra' Coppola
@Frances_Coppola
Brilliant!
Matt Lieb??
@mattlieb
Im sick of everyone calling Israel an apartheid state!!!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tarric Brooker aka Avid Commentator 🇦🇺
@AvidCommentator
A few people have said the falls in housing prices accomplish nothing, that its just changing the deck of home ownership.
Mate, that is part of the point.
We have gone from ~15% of home purchases flowing to property investors in the 80s and early 90s to a peak of over 50%.
Unsurprisingly this extra demand saw prices rocket.
For years it didnt come from extra people, but by changing the deck of ownership.
This additional largely needless demand along with other factors helped push home ownership out of reach.
While more needs to be done to reduce migration to the point where suppressed household formation can finally catch up, a massive decrease in investor demand for existing homes is also an essential part of restoring home ownership rates.
And we have done all this before extremely successfully, as investor demand was crushed post-WW2 and Australia became a nation of home owners, not renters. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Climate change is a fact your policies don’t do anything to mitigate it whatsoever
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
The bulk of westerners have no clue about the opium wars and how their countries benefited from pillaging China. If you did, then you'd know why so many of the predator class in the west are afraid of retribution. So they fill their peons with bs, to hide their past deeds.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Eliot Jacobson
@EliotJacobson
Your 'doom quote' for today:
"Facing a future of accelerating climate change while blind to worst-case scenarios is naive risk management at best and fatally foolish at worst."
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2108146119 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Theoretical Lie that Government Debt is Dangerous
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/theoretical-lie-17357… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
CosmoTrade | تجارة الكون
@Cosmos_politic
لمن لا يفهم النظام السياسي الإسرائيلي، سأشرح الأمر بالعربي الفصيح: نتنياهو حصل على ما يريد!
نعم، قد لا يملك نتنياهو الآن 61 مقعداً في الكنيست، وهي الأغلبية التي يحتاجها لتشكيل حكومة. ولكن الأهم في الأمر أنه حصل، وفق جميع الحسابات، على أكبر حزب في الكنيست. وهذا يعني أن الرئيس الإسرائيلي سيكون أمامه سبب قوي لتكليف نتنياهو بتشكيل الحكومة، ومنحه المهلة اللازمة لذلك.
سيكون أمام نتنياهو نحو 30 يوماً لتشكيل حكومته. طبعاً المشكلة أنه لا يملك 61 مقعداً، ولذلك لن يستطيع تشكيل حكومة بالاعتماد على معسكره وحده.
ولكن هذه المهلة تمنحه شيئاً أهم بكثير من مجرد محاولة تشكيل حكومة.
خلال هذه الفترة، يستطيع نتنياهو، مثلاً، إشعال حرب مع إيران، أو محاولة استمالة بعض الأحزاب والنواب من المعسكر المعارض بقيادة آيزنكوت للانضمام إلى حكومته، أو حتى إجبار آيزنكوت على القبول بتشكيل حكومة وحدة وطنية تحت ضغط الحرب.
وإذا فشل نتنياهو في تشكيل الحكومة، فقد يحاول إفشال أي محاولة لاحقة من آيزنكوت لتشكيل حكومة بديلة، ويدفع البلاد نحو انتخابات جديدة، كما حدث عام 2019.
وإذا عادت الانتخابات مرة أخرى، فأنا أعتقد أن ائتلاف نتنياهو سيحقق انتصاراً أكبر بكثير مما حققه الآن.
والسبب الرئيسي في أن نتنياهو لم يحصل حتى هذه اللحظة على 61 مقعداً هو أن العرب صوتوا بنسب غير طبيعية في هذه الانتخابات.
العرب هم الذين منعوا نتنياهو من الحصول على الأغلبية المطلقة!
لولا هذا الإقبال العربي الهائل، لكان نتنياهو، في تقديري، قد حصل على الأغلبية اللازمة لتشكيل حكومته دون الحاجة إلى أي طرف آخر.
ولكن الآن، نتنياهو أمام فرصة للحصول على مهلة لتشكيل الحكومة، خصوصاً أن حزبه هو الأكبر، ومعسكره أيضاً هو الأوسع بين المعسكرات اليهودية. ولذلك فمن المنطقي أن يكون المرشح الأول لتكليفه بتشكيل الحكومة.
وهنا يجب أن نفهم نقطة أخرى مهمة للغاية.
العرب، تاريخياً، يميلون إلى التصويت بنسب مرتفعة في الانتخابات الأولى، ولكن عند إعادة الانتخابات، غالباً ما تتراجع نسبة مشاركتهم، بينما ينجح اليمين الإسرائيلي في تعبئة قاعدته الانتخابية بصورة أكبر.
وهذا يعني أن نتنياهو سيملك فرصة لشحن قاعدته الانتخابية استعداداً لجولة جديدة، أو استخدام هذه الفترة للضغط على بعض أحزاب المعسكر الآخر وإجبارها على الانضمام إلى حكومته.
بالعربي الفصيح، أنا أقولها لكم: نتنياهو انتصر!
ولا يغرنكم من يقول إن نتنياهو خسر الانتخابات فقط لأن ائتلافه لا يملك 61 مقعداً. من يقول ذلك لا يفهم طبيعة النظام الانتخابي والسياسي الإسرائيلي، ولا يدرك أن الفوز بأكبر حزب، وامتلاك المعسكر الأكبر، يمنحان نتنياهو قدرة كبيرة على المناورة السياسية.
إذا تأكدت هذه النتائج، فإن نتنياهو خرج من الانتخابات وهو يمتلك خيارات عديدة، بينما يجد آيزنكوت نفسه أمام معضلة سياسية حقيقية.
إما أن تعاد الانتخابات مرة أخرى، وإما أن ينجح نتنياهو في جر بعض الأحزاب من المعسكر المعارض إلى حكومته، أو فرض حكومة وحدة وطنية، خصوصاً إذا اندلعت حرب مع إيران.
وهذا، باعتقادي، يجعل احتمال الحرب مع إيران أكبر بكثير، بل ربما أصبحت الحرب الآن شبه مؤكدة.
نتنياهو لم يحصل بعد على الأغلبية التي يحتاجها لتشكيل الحكومة، ولكنه حصل على شيء قد يكون أهم: فرصة جديدة للمناورة، وقلب المعادلة السياسية، وربما تغيير قواعد اللعبة بالكامل. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
How we fight inflation doesn't just matter for the economy. It matters for democracy.
If government decisions leave people poorer, more indebted and less secure, we risk deepening the conditions that have emboldened the far-right.
🔗 My article for the @FT. Link below. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
David Graeber's Debt: The First 5,000 Years is a better contribution to our understanding of money, and debt than anything Carl Menger wrote.
I understand this is deeply upsetting to Austrian Economists, but anthropology doesn't give a fuck about your origin myths. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Theoretical Lie that Government Debt is Dangerous
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/theoretical-lie-17357… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Warwick Powell | 鲍韶山
@baoshaoshan
Wrapping up a series of essays exploring Chinese household consumption, real estate credit, private credit, and wealth.
Put plainly, it’s almost all about real income growth and income flows. Not fluctuating balance sheets, not psychology, not Chinese “prudence”; just sustained real income growth set against industrial restructuring and consumption upgrading.
👉🏼 warwickpowell.substack.com/p/income-flows-wealth-effects-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
Here's a vid of Josephine Baker's pantheon ceremony. I got this a while back and I never got to share it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
#fotw Daily Post 22
Tipping points don't queue politely. Cross one - like Greenland Ice-Sheet collapse - and it can shove others over in a domino cascade
The climate isn't separate switches - it's a web
It's what keeps me awake at night
Please share + tag 2
#fateoftheworld -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
peaceminusone
@peaceminus28
happy mclennon Monday
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What happens if the budget ignores Britain's real debt crisis? If you listen to what he will say, you'd think the national debt is our problem. It isn't. Private sector debt is three times bigger - and that is where the debt crisis will happen.
youtu.be/szmZZwwtAm8 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Barlow
@SteB777
Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Thesis on stupidity, is the most important concept we need to understand, to understand the climate crisis, and the role of oligarchs.
Bohoeffer was a Lutheran pastor, theologian and philosopher, murdered in the last days of WW2, by the Nazis.
@ZackPolanski
www.onthewing.org/user/Bonhoeffer - Theory of Stupidity.pdf
1/2 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Clive Lewis MP
@labourlewis
Yesterday, I was barred from entering the West Bank by Israeli officials, as part of a @ProgIntl delegation.
What's happening here in Palestine is unjust. We've just witnessed what Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and many others have called a genocide unfold in Gaza.
We came here to show the world, and to show solidarity with the Palestinian people. The Israeli government didn't allow that.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Thomas Reis
@peakaustria
What you see here is a pile of 29 tons of basalt dust, one truckload. To fight climate change, this rock can suck 9 tons of CO₂ from the ambient air when placed on the right soil at the right location. When it is fully weathered, this basalt dust can render an average citizen of Germany as climate neutral for one year (in 2025).
To save the climate, we need to reduce emissions by 90% in the next 20-30 years. Afterwards, only one tenth of this pile would be necessary to net-zero each German citizen every year.
This process is called “enhanced weathering.”. It is a completely natural process that has been pulling CO₂ from the atmosphere for millions of years. CO₂ from the air combines with rainwater to form a weak acid, which reacts with the basalt. Harmless carbonates are created in the process and the CO₂ is bound for thousands of years. Plus, the basalt releases nutrients for the plants and improves the soil.
The fact that this process of CO₂ sequestration actually works has been shown by hundreds of studies. Basalt is allowed as a soil amendment e.g. in the EU. The one remaining question that scientists all over the world are currently working on is, how many years does it take until the basalt has been weathered and pulled down the CO₂?
At Project Carbdown, we are working on the measurements for enhanced weathering. Stay tuned! Via Dirk Paessler
Thomas Reis
@peakaustria
A NO-COST SOLUTION FOR CLIMATE DISRUPTION ???
Carbon capture, ocean acidification and agriculture
How can agriculture become part of the solution as opposed to the problem?
Olivine is a magnesium iron silicate mineral that can be used as a soil conditioner for agriculture. The cost is approximately $35 per tonne supplied as a sand/powder.
1000 kg to 2000 kg of olivine should be spread on 1 acre every 2 to 3 years; every tonne will absorb 1000 kg of carbon dioxide, making this approach as economic in comparison to most carbon capture technologies; however, there are added benefits.
The olivine helps improve soil condition and improves yield for the farmer. The mineral will slowly dissolve, and some will get washed out of the soil into rivers and then eventually the sea. The ferric silicate mineral will help promote the growth of good phytoplankton called diatoms, even if the water is loaded with nutrients. The olivine prevents the risk of toxic dinoflagellate algal blooms.
The diatoms are plants, and they will absorb a huge amount of carbon; for every 1000 kg of olivine, the diatoms could sequester 100,000 kg of carbon. But that’s not all… The diatoms produce omega-3 oils that form a film on the surface of the ocean. This film is called the SML surface micro layer. The SML forms a biogenic aerosol that nucleates water vapour to form clouds, which help reflect energy. Water vapour accounts for 75% of all greenhouse carbon, so temperature also drops and the climate becomes more stable.
I recommend that governments subsidise farms to use more olivine; this could be one of the easiest ways to fight climate change and restore marine life.
bioclimatic report; www.researchgate.net/publication/364821580_Climate_Disrup…
Below is a photo of a diatom, a silicon- and carbon-based phytoplankton. There are around 40 gigatonnes in the world's oceans, doubling in biomass every 1 to 2 days. The mass of carbon as C, approx 0.5 gigatonnes, or 10 days' production, equates to 100% of anthropogenic carbon. Via Howard Dryden -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Justin Baragona
@justinbaragona
Besides being nakedly racist and bigoted, this is just hilariously wrong on all levels.
I mean, Omar Yaghi won the Nobel Prize in Chemistry last year, and he won the Wolf Prize in 2018. And that's just one example.
He also said Arabs don't produce any literature. Last year's winner of the National Book Award was Lebanese writer and painter Rabih Alameddine. The winner in non-fiction? Egyptian-American journalist Omar El Akkad.
Bulwark Clips
@BulwarkClips
RFK: "There's five hundred million Arabs in the world. And yet they don't produce science. They don't win the Novel Prize. They don't win the Fields Prize. They don't win the Wolf Prize. They don't produce literature."
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Socialist Planning Beyond Capitalism
@beyond_capital
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Another stopped clock who claims to have a PhD in educational research and yet didn’t research his claims on Twitter.
Peter Ford
@EdSacredProfane
Steve Keen is MMT and predicts doom on a daily basis along with Richard Murphy. It is the classic stopped clock scenario
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
Just wow. RFK Jr. revealing Trump-level bigotry, stupidity and IGNORANCE about the history of the world, the role of Arabs in innovation, scientific achievements, mathematics, engineering a more.
He says Arabs never produced science. Seriously.
It was an Arab who invented modern optics. Another Arab pioneered early aviation before the Wright Brothers. An Arab named Jabir ibn Hayyan founded modern chemistry. An Arab introduced the concept of ZERO, for God's sake, and pioneered numerals, systematic algebra, solar calculations for calendars and it just goes on and on.
RFK Jr. is a bigoted, racist ignoramus who defends genocide and is blind to any ethnic group other than his deep-pocketed donors who are mostly pro-genocide zionists.
Bulwark Clips
@BulwarkClips
RFK: "There's five hundred million Arabs in the world. And yet they don't produce science. They don't win the Novel Prize. They don't win the Fields Prize. They don't win the Wolf Prize. They don't produce literature."
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
Difference between survival preparedness in Japan vs. rural America:
Japan preparedness: I need water, food, medicine, a flashlight and toilet paper.
Rural America preparedness: I need a 50-caliber Barrett, night vision, a bulletproof vest, a 300 blackout SBR with an 11.5" barrel, an IR target designator, an integrated suppressor and 5,000 rounds of ammo. And also a flashlight and some toilet paper. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I wish more people understood this.
Ted Reese
@Grossmanite
50 years of privatisation =
a FAR BIGGER STATE
with WAY MORE BUREAUCRACY
bc privatisation introduces competition and therefore commercial secrecy and legal disputes
+ more state admin is needed to try to coordinate fragmented state contracts handed to the private sector -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
The entire Financial Times editorial board has published a piece urging Lula to cut government spending and appoint a finance minister who enjoys the confidence of investors.
I get the impression that the FT editorial board has never opened an economics book other than some outdated introductory macroeconomics textbook, perhaps something by Mankiw. Otherwise, it's hard to explain such astonishing arrogance and economic ignorance.
Lula and the Brazilian people have absolutely no reason to bow to the demands of financial markets. Brazil is Latin America's largest economy, a major regional power, and a country with a high degree of monetary sovereignty. Around 97% of the central government's debt is denominated in its own currency, the Brazilian real.
The relationship between the state and financial markets is therefore nothing like the FT portrays it. Brazil is not dependent on financial markets. On the contrary, financial markets depend on government spending, which creates financial assets for the private sector, while government debt denominated in the national currency is one of the instruments through which those assets are held.
What Brazil needs is not capitulation to financial markets, but an independent economic policy focused on expanding production, creating jobs, and improving people's living standards.
Armed with the insights of heterodox economic theory, Brazil has the potential to show the world what a genuine economic miracle looks like. www.ft.com/content/79785581-88c2-49a9-a109-9d5ccafc3c7d?c… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Risk Expert tells the Truth about Climate
@MarkCranfield_
Hansen tells us that today's ~4 watts/m² of human GHG forcing causes 10C of global warming after all feedbacks have operated.
He also tells us that GHG forcing is increasing at a rate of around 0.5 watts/m² per decade.
This means around 1.2C is being added to the planet's eventual temperature every decade. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Let the gold standard stability run through my Libertarian veins!🤤
KingoftheCoast
@kingofthecoastt
(it's the gold standard)
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good point. The aim is to cease being governed by the finance sector.
Fauxtograferprophet
@Fauxtograf10648
Eligibility for office in Athens was by random ballot restricted to those citizens who had not borrowed excessively. They had enslaved themselves to the lenders. Sounds familiar?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
‘the dynamics of debt’.
yet ignored in the mainstream models still used to inform policymakers.
there is something badly wrong with mainstream (“orthodox”) economics.
few of them will admit it.
most deny it.
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Thirty years ago today, the great economist Hyman Minsky passed away. It was Minsky who first set me on the path toward Post-Keynesian economics.
Within mainstream economics, he is best known for his Financial Instability Hypothesis. Yet his theoretical legacy extends far beyond it. Building on Keynes and Kalecki, Minsky developed a comprehensive understanding of how a capitalist economy functions, in which price and profit formation, investment, financing, and the dynamics of debt are understood as interconnected processes. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Not a single new water reservoir has been built since Water Privatisation in 1989, despite UK population growing from 57 million to 69.5 million.
Failed state. Westminster betrays its citizens to enrich unaccountable offshore private equity.
Steven Swinford
@Steven_Swinford
Exclusive from @breeallegretti
Ministers have been secretly warned that some English reservoirs are at risk of running dry, hitting water supplies to homes in the run-up to Christmas
The government’s emergency committee, known as Cobra, is meeting up to twice a week to discuss the situation in the southwest of England and Sussex
A secret “reasonable worst-case scenario” was drawn up, anticipating that several reservoirs’ water stocks could fall to 0 per cent — dubbed “day zero” — within weeks
Officials warned that without action, supplies to some homes could be affected, along with disruption to the construction of a nuclear power station and operations at a prison
Wimbleball reservoir, which supplies more than 400,000 people in Somerset, has 13 per cent of its capacity, while Ardingly, which serves 280,000 customers across West Sussex, is at 17 per cent
Ministers battling to avoid reservoirs running dry by Christmas
www.thetimes.com/article/7812e107-0466-48f0-b337-f9b00a5d… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rob Hoff
@hoff_rob
Sortition is the only solution to what we have here in the United States imo, People tend to throw out a lot of strawmen to counter the argument but they're just that. Athenian "Democracy" was still woefully corrupt tho. sortitionusa.org/about + Sun Yat-sen's 5 Branch system
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
We've launched The Minsky Report @GDPDynamics
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The Minsky Report has been launch at: gdpdynamics.com/minsky
A free dashboard is available for all, and a in depth monthly report for paid subscribers at: members.gdpdynamics.com -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Superman
@thesupermannx
This paper answers why confident idiots run the world.
Cornell University published a psychological paper that explains every terrible boss, every loud influencer, and every broken corporate hierarchy.
It’s called “Unskilled and Unaware of It.”
they tested participants across logic, grammar, and humor to measure the gap between actual performance and self-perception.
And the results are wild.
participants scoring in the bottom 12th percentile consistently believed they were operating in the 62nd percentile.
they were not lying. they were literally incapable of recognizing their own incompetence.
the paper revealed a brutal paradox:
the exact skills required to master a domain are the exact same skills required to accurately evaluate your own competence in that domain.
if you lack the skill, you inherently lack the cognitive capacity to realize you are failing.
this creates a dangerous systemic loop.
the incompetent are blessed with absolute, blinding certainty. their brain protects them from their own ignorance, allowing them to speak first, demand authority, and never second-guess their decisions.
meanwhile, the actual experts suffer the exact inverse.
top performers in the study consistently underestimated their rank. because a task was easy for them, they falsely assumed it was easy for everyone else.
they hesitate. they obsess over nuance. they assume they have nothing unique to add.
we are biologically wired to confuse confidence with competence.
the loudest person in the room gets promoted, gets funded, and gets the microphone, not because they know what they are doing, but because they are physically incapable of seeing what they don't.
the only defense mechanism is building systems that stop rewarding absolute certainty and start demanding proof of work. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Steve Keen's greatest mistake was assuming economists would be interested in discovering that their theories might be wrong.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
UK ministers are reportedly holding emergency COBRA meetings up to twice a week as England's drought crisis worsens.
Wimbleball Reservoir is reportedly down to 13% and Ardingly to 17%, with a worst-case government scenario warning of “Day Zero” before Christmas.
Recent rain won't undo months of drought. The government is scrambling to protect water supplies, but the risks are real. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Erik Arnell
@ArnellOErik
Frankrikes problem är INTE statsskuldens storlek.
I många avseenden är problemet det rakt motsatta.
Lärdomen för Sverige av Frankrikes situation är INTE att vår svångremspolitik har tjänat oss väl.
Lärdomen är att politiken har varit dålig för Frankrike och är dålig för oss samt att vi ska hålla oss långt borta från euron.
Jag utvecklar resonemangen i två artiklar:
www.dagensarena.se/essa/krisen-frankrike-visar-sverige-sk…
www.di.se/debatt/frankrikes-problem-ar-inte-den-hoga-stat… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George S Gordon
@VoteYesSept
I think this is what Tom refers to -
"it helps to know that household analogies are dangerous territory, intensely contested, and can easily mislead."
www.bbc.co.uk/aboutthebbc/documents/thematic-review-taxat… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rob Hoff
@hoff_rob
I truly wish more of my fellow Americans understood these things. From a Chinese commenter ~
"Political parties exist mainly due to ideological differences. But when a party takes over, it tends to undo what the previous party has done, due to ideological differences" -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Theresa Sanders
@arealmermaid2
The “Problem” isn’t Public “Debt”, it IS Private Debt, along with Wealth Inequality is GREATER than before the 1st Great Depression! #learnmacroeconomics watch @sdgrumbine s Podcast MACRO & CHEESE, & learn from a variety of Heterodox Economists & other pertinent Professionals & listen to @ProfSteveKeen !
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Everyone remembers the crash of 1929. Far fewer people ask what made the 1920s boom possible in the first place.
The standard story focuses on stock market speculation. Some Austrians blame the Federal Reserve for holding interest rates too low. There is some truth in both observations, but neither gets to the heart of what was happening.
What really matters is debt. During the 1920s, private debt grew much faster than the economy itself. Businesses borrowed to expand production. Investors borrowed to buy stocks. Banks were happy to lend because rising asset prices made everything look safe.
The important thing to understand is that banks do not lend out existing money in the way most textbooks describe. When a bank makes a loan, it creates a deposit. New debt creates new purchasing power.
As debt rose, spending rose with it. Rising spending boosted profits. Rising profits encouraged investment. Rising investment supported employment and incomes. The boom seemed to justify itself.
People looked at the prosperity of the Roaring Twenties and assumed it reflected a fundamentally healthy economy. In reality, an increasing share of economic activity was being supported by an ever-growing pile of private debt.
That works for a while. The trouble begins when debt stops growing quickly enough. An economy that has become accustomed to large injections of new credit each year can run into serious trouble when those injections slow down. Spending weakens. Asset prices come under pressure. Businesses pull back investment plans. Borrowers become more cautious. What looked stable suddenly starts moving in reverse.
By the late 1920s, stock prices had become increasingly disconnected from the underlying economy. Investors were borrowing heavily to chase rising prices, while the banking system continued expanding credit to support the boom.
When that process finally broke, the result was not just a stock market crash. It was a collapse in debt-financed demand.
Irving Fisher eventually came to understand this after losing much of his own fortune. He called it debt deflation. As borrowers tried to reduce debt, spending fell. Falling spending reduced incomes. Lower incomes made debts harder to repay. The economy entered a vicious cycle.
From this perspective, the Great Depression was not simply the result of bad monetary policy, nor was it proof that markets are inherently self-correcting. It was the consequence of an economy that had become increasingly dependent on rising private debt to sustain growth.
The crash was dramatic, but the real story had been building for years on bank balance sheets long before the headlines arrived. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
DiEM25
@DiEM_25
What can Serbia’s student movement teach the world about organising from the ground up? More than a year ago, we spoke to student activist Nina Petrov about building a movement beyond Vučić- one that documents its organising methods so communities and workers can replicate them. Their vision? “Not just voting on election day, but being active citizens every day.” There's no better time to revisit this conversation. Watch the full interview:
youtu.be/ENPIkFRJ4Ss -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
1. THIS IS NOT THE 2008 CRISIS.
The delusion of post-modernism is the delusion of humanism. That the world is only the human world. That there is nothing outside our control - the sovereignty of human subjectivity. Nature is seen as merely an extension of this monstrous ego.
Nature is not an extension of us - it is us that are subject to Nature.
2008 was in the human realm. "Money" is a function of human psychology. We can change "money" and sort things out - till next time.
When the insurance industry collapses - and it will - we will not be able to fix "the problem" because the problem is Nature - physics is independent of human control. We fucked it. We cannot unfuck it. And Nature does not give a fuck.
This is so basic only an elite so utterly cut off from what it means to live a human life would be unable to see it.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/oct/14/climate-cri… -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a very good overview of the Chinese system for selecting decision makers
Peter Gregor
@GregorPepe
On Chinese Democracy – Part 3
Chinese democracy in practice does not function like a Western electoral talent show, where sponsors, rhetoric, emotion, and campaign budgets decide outcomes. It operates as a hierarchical meritocratic selection from the bottom up. If we want to understand this system, we must stop fixating on the question of “who votes for whom” and start asking "who has proven capable of governing".
The entry point for an ordinary citizen is not a television studio, but the street and the local community. China has approximately 650,000–700,000 community committees, each serving 1,000 to 3,000 residents. Their members are directly elected by local residents. These bodies are not decorative symbols of democracy - they handle social services, local issues, election organization, crisis management, and day-to-day interaction with the state. This is the lowest level of power - and also the last level where one can still hide behind words instead of results.
A political career in China does not begin with an ideological speech, but with performance and reputation. A person who consistently works effectively within a community, solves problems, and can organize people is moved upward, typically to the district level. And yes, at this point the cadre system comes into play, often along with membership in the Chinese Communist Party (approximately 98–100 million members, about 7% of the population). Not as a label, but as an entry ticket into a system of evaluation.
From the district level upward, electoral marketing is no longer part of the game. No one cares about charisma or social media reach. Performance is assessed. The criteria are largely quantitative and comparable: economic growth, stability, crime rates, infrastructure, crisis management, audit results, corruption scores, and bottom-up feedback. Officials are regularly rotatedto prevent them from building personal fiefdoms - a luxury that Western democracies often rebrand as “political experience.”
The higher you go, the harsher the filter becomes. Out of more than 1.4 billion people, only about 0.2% of party cadres reach the provincial decision-making level. Only a few hundred individuals make it into central politics. This is not an inclusive system. It is a ruthlessly selective system.
The parliament (the National People’s Congress) has approximately 2,980 deputies. They are not elected by the entire nation in a single emotion-charged electoral spectacle, but delegated by lower-level congresses. The body consists of regional leaders, technocrats, academics, managers of state-owned enterprises, and administrators with decades of experience. An ordinary person does not get there in a leap. They must earn it through 20–30 years of sustained, demonstrable performance.
The core Chinese thesis is simple and uncomfortable: democracy is not about everyone governing the state, but about the state being governed by those who have demonstrably shown they can govern. Mass participation is broad at the bottom, but competence is deliberately concentrated at the top. Crucially, elected and appointed officials do not remain in power through popularity, but through performance, and they can be removed quickly, institutionally, and without political theatre.
The system has weaknesses - slower feedback loops and the risk of closed elites. But it undeniably has strengths that Western democracies are losing: continuity, expertise, and long-term planning.
This is not a dictatorship, nor some cartoonish communist authoritarianism, nor the rule of hollow elites. It is a state meritocratic pyramid that openly admits a simple truth: not everyone should govern everything.
Now compare this with the rule of political parties in the “democratic” West. Do you still fail to see the ever-present logic of ´divide et impera´?
#china #democracy -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is brilliant. It resembles the sortition process used by Athens to select decision makers. It is far superior to the narcissism and money dominated popularity contests we currently call democracy.
Işın Eliçin
@IsinElicin
Sırbistan'da öğrenciler doğrudan demokrasi yöntemini seçim siyasetine taşıdılar.
Liderlere dayalı, yukarıdan aşağıya bir örgütlenme yerine, herkesin söz alabildiği öğrenci genel kurulları (plenum) oluşturdular. Kararlar tartışılarak, mümkün olduğunca uzlaşmayla alındı.
Bu yöntemi üniversitelerin dışına da taşıdılar. Mahallelerde, kentlerde ve köylerde yurttaş meclisleri (zborovi) kuruldu. İnsanlar kendi sorunlarını tartışmak, çözüm önermek ve birlikte karar almak için toplandı.
250 kişilik milletvekili aday listesini de şöyle oluşturdular:
1- Önce 250 adaylık kontenjanı, öğrenci sayılarına göre altı üniversite kenti arasında paylaştırdılar. Belgrad'ın listeye hâkim olmaması için diğer kentlerin de üst sıralarda temsil edilmesini sağladılar. Ardından her kentin kontenjanını fakülteler arasında dağıttılar.
2- Ülke genelinde 80'den fazla fakültede öğrenci genel kurulları toplandı. Öğrenciler kendileri aday olmadı ama her biri aday önerebildi ve neden o kişiyi önerdiğini açıkladı. İsimler tartışıldı, önce uzlaşma arandı, gerektiğinde oylama yapıldı.
3- Mevcut siyasi kadrolara kapıyı kapattılar. İktidar partilerinin mevcut ve eski üyelerini, iktidar adına görev yapmış siyasetçileri ve bürokratları, muhalefet partilerinin üst düzey yöneticilerini aday göstermediler. Böylece hem iktidardan hem de yerleşik muhalefetten bağımsız bir liste oluşturdular.
4- Fakülteler birbirlerinin adaylarını da denetledi. Önerilen bütün isimler ortak bir listede toplandı ve tüm fakültelerin incelemesine açıldı. İtirazlar öğrenci kurullarında tartışıldı. Adayın elenmesi için kurulların yarısından fazlasının veto etmesi gerekiyordu. Tek bir fakültenin itirazı yeterli değildi.
5- Elenen veya çekilen adayların yerine yedekler getirildi. Böylece profesörlerin, doktorların, bilim insanlarının, işçilerin, sanatçıların ve aktivistlerin yer aldığı 250 kişilik liste ortaya çıktı. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I explain inflation through demand-pull, conflict theory, cost-push mechanisms, structural bottlenecks, markup pricing, and endogenous feedback dynamics.
MV=PY is an accounting identity with no independent explanatory power. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Makovsky
@DavidMakovsky
Israel's Channel 12 Reporting (English translation of their report:)
Breaking news in this edition
An unprecedented confrontation between the Chief of Staff and the Prime Minister has reached a critical—or perhaps disastrous—turning point over the last 24 hours.
At the heart of the matter: the Iranian issue.
There is concern on the part of [Chief of Staff] Zamir that Netanyahu and the political leadership might trigger a scenario of miscalculation vis-à-vis Iran, just ahead of the elections.
A defense official states that the action in question could lead to a rapid confrontation with Iran at a highly sensitive and dramatic moment, potentially resulting in a miscalculation.
Sources familiar with the details indicate that the military leadership fears an attempt to exploit the Iranian issue for political gain—a claim that political figures deny, labeling it an outright lie.
Regardless, two sources tell me that the situation has escalated to the point where, during a visit to the Palmachim Airbase today, the atmosphere in the discussion was extremely tense.
In recent days, Zamir received a directive from the political leadership but requested an in-depth discussion before taking any action.
He also demanded formal, signed legal authorization from the political echelon for the proposed move.
A senior defense official remarked: "History will not forget the role Zamir has played here over the last few days."
In short: an exceptionally intense confrontation between Zamir and Netanyahu regarding the Iranian issue, occurring just before the elections.
It should be noted: all details in this report have been approved by the Military Censor.
Yaron Avraham -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
There is virtually no sulfur coming out of the Persian Gulf. The world's above-ground sulfur supply is dwindling as a result (Canada has massive stockpiles but they are not infinite).
Without sulfur, you can't make rubber tires for cares because sulfur is the critical element in VULCANIZATION which does not refer to Spock from planet Vulcan, but rather the process by which liquid rubber is formed into a stiff, durable polymer with tough chemical cross-links. This makes rubber (a latex liquid from trees) turn into tires, essentially.
No sulfur = no tires.
No tires = total global collapse of industry and transportation and farming, and so on. Mass global collapse of human civilization at nearly an Extinction Level Event scale.
The Persian Gulf isn't the only place to get sulfur (Venezuela is another), but it's the primary source and it has been almost completely cut off.
I'll have a full video analysis on this subject tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Peter💚🤍💜 🏴 🇳🇿
@WingsEcosse
This is the truth. France is in an impossible situation. The only way out is the Franc and ditch neoliberalism.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
French Students Are Revolting, and so they should be!, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/french-students-are-revoltin…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Come learn about a different kind of economics.
Online Winter School on 'Money and post-Keynesians'.
All information here, including the programme.
Registration is free.
fundacjalipinskiego.pl/aktualnosci/winter-school/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
Why I have repeatedly called 2027 the "Year of Famine" / starvation. It is now baked in. Cannot be resolved. Hundreds of millions of people around the world will face starvation conditions. And yet Trump continues the war, continues the escalation, worsens the global flows of fertilizer, fuel, oil, sulfur and more, while printing TRILLIONS of dollars of U.S. currency which will also cause plummeting purchasing power, further causing food inflation.
Trump is basically at war with humanity. Not just Americans, but all of humanity.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Europa se estanca, así que recortamos gasto público. Menos gasto significa menos ingresos privados, menos demanda, menos ventas y menos empleo.
¿Resultado? Más estancamiento.
¿Solución? ¡Más recortes!
El € tiene un emisor, pero seguimos fingiendo q el Estado vive de una hucha
manuel llamas
@manuel_llamas
El problema de Europa es muy sencillo
Se llama Estado del Bienestar… Gasto disparado, impuestos disparados, estancamiento económico y empobrecimiento
Es lo que está colapsando en los últimos años
Respuesta de la izquierda: más gasto, más impuestos…
Resultado: más estancamiento, más pobreza
Y vuelta a empezar! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
After much thought about the coming midterm elections, I have decided that for me, the overriding issue is avoiding global nuclear war above all else, which means the single most important factor in deciding my vote will be VOTING AGAINST ANYONE WHO TAKES MONEY FROM AIPAC, regardless of political party.
We can't even think about restoring or saving America until we stop the infiltration by a foreign entity. And those who take money from AIPAC are traitors to America and will never make the interests of the American people their priority. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Everyone remembers the crash of 1929. Far fewer people ask what made the 1920s boom possible in the first place.
The standard story focuses on stock market speculation. Some Austrians blame the Federal Reserve for holding interest rates too low. There is some truth in both observations, but neither gets to the heart of what was happening.
What really matters is debt. During the 1920s, private debt grew much faster than the economy itself. Businesses borrowed to expand production. Investors borrowed to buy stocks. Banks were happy to lend because rising asset prices made everything look safe.
The important thing to understand is that banks do not lend out existing money in the way most textbooks describe. When a bank makes a loan, it creates a deposit. New debt creates new purchasing power.
As debt rose, spending rose with it. Rising spending boosted profits. Rising profits encouraged investment. Rising investment supported employment and incomes. The boom seemed to justify itself.
People looked at the prosperity of the Roaring Twenties and assumed it reflected a fundamentally healthy economy. In reality, an increasing share of economic activity was being supported by an ever-growing pile of private debt.
That works for a while. The trouble begins when debt stops growing quickly enough. An economy that has become accustomed to large injections of new credit each year can run into serious trouble when those injections slow down. Spending weakens. Asset prices come under pressure. Businesses pull back investment plans. Borrowers become more cautious. What looked stable suddenly starts moving in reverse.
By the late 1920s, stock prices had become increasingly disconnected from the underlying economy. Investors were borrowing heavily to chase rising prices, while the banking system continued expanding credit to support the boom.
When that process finally broke, the result was not just a stock market crash. It was a collapse in debt-financed demand.
Irving Fisher eventually came to understand this after losing much of his own fortune. He called it debt deflation. As borrowers tried to reduce debt, spending fell. Falling spending reduced incomes. Lower incomes made debts harder to repay. The economy entered a vicious cycle.
From this perspective, the Great Depression was not simply the result of bad monetary policy, nor was it proof that markets are inherently self-correcting. It was the consequence of an economy that had become increasingly dependent on rising private debt to sustain growth.
The crash was dramatic, but the real story had been building for years on bank balance sheets long before the headlines arrived. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"I expected arguments about economics. What I didn't expect was how enthusiastically some people recommended homelessness. Sleep in your car. Get a gym membership... These weren't hypothetical responses. People actually suggested these things... What kind of fucking worldview produces that reaction?"
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
After reading the replies to my original post, I've learned that some libertarians have a much bigger problem than their understanding of economics. Their complete lack of empathy is fucking astonishing.
I suggested that paying half your income in rent because the alternative is sleeping in a freezing car isn't exactly a wonderful example of economic freedom. The responses were an extraordinary collection of lectures about voluntary exchange, personal responsibility, property rights, and why homelessness is apparently just another consumer preference.
Here are the five most common arguments.
1. It's voluntary because nobody is forcing you.
Apparently, choosing between unaffordable rent and sleeping in your car is the expression of liberty. Sure, nobody is holding a gun to your head. But someone with $500 in the bank doesn't have the same bargaining power as someone with $10 million in property. A decision made under financial desperation is still a decision. That doesn't mean the person has meaningful economic freedom. If your definition of liberty includes celebrating someone's choice to freeze in their car, perhaps your philosophy needs some fucking work.
2. Just move, get roommates, buy a house, or sleep in your car.
This was my favorite. One person suggested getting a gym membership so you could sleep in your car and still shower. Others recommended second jobs, roommates, or simply buying a house. Fucking brilliant. But what happens when millions of households simultaneously move somewhere cheaper? Demand increases, and those locations become less affordable unless housing supply expands. What works for one individual doesn't necessarily work for everyone. It's called the fallacy of composition. An entire housing crisis cannot be solved by giving millions of people individual financial advice. Yet apparently, sleeping in a Toyota Corolla now constitutes a comprehensive economic policy.
3. Government regulations and central banks caused expensive housing.
This was actually a reasonable argument, at least initially. Restrictive zoning and excessive development regulations absolutely can contribute to expensive housing. But blaming government for every undesirable market outcome is just ideological laziness. Housing prices also depend on incomes, credit conditions, construction costs, land values, population growth, speculation, and investment expectations. Developers build when they expect sufficient profits, not simply because people need somewhere to live. Removing bad regulations can improve housing supply. It doesn't magically eliminate every other economic problem. An economy is an interconnected system, not a fucking supply-and-demand diagram.
4. The landlord provides a mutually beneficial service.
Several people argued that rental transactions must benefit both parties because otherwise they wouldn't happen. Yes, someone facing homelessness might prefer paying half their income in rent to sleeping outside. Congratulations. You've established that people prefer shelter to freezing. But that doesn't prove the housing market is competitive, affordable, or producing desirable outcomes. People routinely accept terrible arrangements because their alternatives are worse. Individual rationality doesn't guarantee desirable outcomes for society. The existence of a transaction isn't proof that the economic system is working particularly well.
5. You aren't entitled to someone else's property or labor.
And naturally, someone had to start screaming about communism. Apparently, suggesting that people shouldn't have to sleep in freezing cars is now revolutionary Marxism. I support private property, competitive markets, and private enterprise. But supporting capitalism doesn't require celebrating every outcome it produces. Property rights don't automatically guarantee affordable housing, economic efficiency, or an equitable distribution of resources. You can defend private property without treating human suffering as an acceptable demonstration of economic liberty.
Now, here's what genuinely disturbed me.
I expected arguments about economics. What I didn't expect was how enthusiastically some people recommended homelessness. Sleep in your car. Get a gym membership. Work three jobs. Move away. Stop complaining. These weren't hypothetical responses. People actually suggested these things. Imagine seeing someone struggling to afford shelter and immediately explaining why they should be grateful to their landlord. What kind of fucking worldview produces that reaction?
Markets are supposed to serve human beings. Human beings aren't supposed to suffer simply to validate someone's economic philosophy. I'm a supporter of free markets, but I don't believe that requires abandoning basic human empathy. The irony is that people who constantly preach individual liberty seem perfectly comfortable dismissing the economic circumstances that restrict it.
If your response to someone facing homelessness is to congratulate them on having the freedom to sleep in their fucking car, perhaps you've spent too much time defending capitalism and not enough time interacting with actual human beings.
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Libertarians believe every transaction is voluntary, including paying a landlord half your income because the alternative is sleeping in your fucking car.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I'm writing a post and video on The Nobble Prize in Economics, which I'll share here once it's ready. But if you want to (attempt to!) educate your teacher, recommend this book on how "Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel" was concocted in 1969 by the Swedish Central Bank in a battle against social democratic policies in Sweden: press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691166032/the-nob…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniel Seidemann
@DanielSeidemann
36 hours away from the opening of the polls, a sizeable portion of Israeli society believes that the outcome of these elections will have a major impact on the viability of the Third Jewish Commonwealth.
But the acute fear shared by many is much more focused than that.
We fear Netanyahu.
Not the customary apprehension. A real gut, visceral fear.
Netanyahu will stop at nothing to remain in power. An attack on Iran? Sure. Intentionally igniting violence in the West Bank? You bet. Peddling "Apocalypse Now" with mushroom clouds? Check. Crashing the Tel Aviv Stock Exchange? Why not? Using violence to disrupt the electoral process? If only he could.
36 hours until the polls open. Then the 15 hours when the polls are open. Then the vote counting. Then the transition to a new government.
He's desperate and panicking. He will remain dangerous as long as he remains in power - more dangerous to Israel than Iran and Hamas put together.
Gird loins. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
christopher joye
@cjoye
Current Aussie housing crash is the worst ever recorded since 1980 - national capital city prices are currently falling at a 16% annualised pace based on the last three months of Cotality data...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Their true colors are really shining through. Seems I managed to bring out the absolute worst of them, just as planned.
I expected economic arguments. Instead, I got grown adults enthusiastically recommending homelessness as a lifestyle choice.
Quite the advertisement for libertarianism. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
The incarceration of Fergie Chambers in Spain, pending extradition to the US for showing solidarity with Palestine, is an international scandal. Join me in demanding his release!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
See below. I had inadvertently tagged the wrong Steve Keen instead of @ProfSteveKeen .
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
Excellent insights by @SteveKeenEcon on the systemic flaws behind the current crisis in France and across Europe.
His four "heretical" conclusions to end Europe's decline are:
1️⃣ Abolish the Euro and return to national currencies.
2️⃣ Run government deficits to create fiat money.
3️⃣ Use those deficits to fully fund public education and infrastructure.
4️⃣ Restrict private debt—the true trigger of economic collapse.
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/french-students-are-revoltin… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ryan Dawson
@RyLiberty
US history books omit
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
movie tweets
@lauren_w67
So unicorns went extinct due to Noah’s poor management. Thanks Crowley 😂💔
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Sanders
@PulaRJS
The Butcher of Beirut – Israel’s alternative to Netanyahu.
Peter Oborne – just returned from almost a month in the Occupied Territories – came into the Double Down Newswatch studio to talk about the Israeli election, Britain’s feeble surrender to the Israelis over the consulate in East Jerusalem and the ongoing horror in the West Bank and Israeli prisons.
Plse share/1This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Just one problem; Chris inadvertently linked to an imposter account. Mine is @profstevekeen.
A video on this topic is going up tonight (Sunday 25th October)
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
Excellent insights by @SteveKeenEcon on the systemic flaws behind the current crisis in France and across Europe.
His four "heretical" conclusions to end Europe's decline are:
1️⃣ Abolish the Euro and return to national currencies.
2️⃣ Run government deficits to create fiat money.
3️⃣ Use those deficits to fully fund public education and infrastructure.
4️⃣ Restrict private debt—the true trigger of economic collapse.
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/french-students-are-revoltin… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Urban Cycling Institute 🚲
@fietsprofessor
'Everything in the country is designed for a f*cking car. Everything!'
— @yism3000
Once you have seen it, you cannot unsee it.
Welcome to the @waroncars!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Financial regulation like Basel 1-2-3 and modern central banking as applied by Greenspan , Bernanke , Yellen & Powell created an even greater risk than they sought to mitigate : it deindustrialised the US ( and the entire west ) to the point where it can no longer reliably produce the goods required to defend itself.
The idea that a functional, sovereign state can sustain itself by reducing its productive capacity to a services economy, reliant on asset-inflated wealth and debt-fuelled consumption, was the great economic delusion of the 1990s.
The inevitable result is a financial economy increasingly disconnected from the material economy that underpins it, where asset prices rise, private debt expands and paper wealth accumulates while the industrial capacity required to manufacture the physical goods on which national prosperity and security depend , steadily erodes toward existential doubt .
Eventually, your geopolitical rival is not merely producing more cheaply ; it is manufacturing the machinery, electronics, materials, components and defence systems that you can no longer produce yourself.
You become financially wealthy but materially dependent, capable of financing your own defence in theory but incapable of manufacturing it in practice. A nation that cannot manufacture the material foundations of its own security is not truly sovereign; it is dependent on the continued willingness of others to supply the means of its survival.
So called central banking independence was used to channel workers wages into a fully financialized bankers economy that literally can’t produce the goods it needs to defend itself or remain independent . -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
📚 A beginner-friendly reading list on the modern monetary system from an MMT and Post-Keynesian perspective, in recommended reading order:
1. Warren Mosler — Seven Deadly Innocent Frauds of Economic Policy (2010)
2. Stephanie Kelton — The Deficit Myth (2020)
3. Dirk Ehnts — Modern Money Theory: A Simple Guide to the Monetary System (2024)
4. Steve Keen — The New Economics: A Manifesto (2021)
5. L. Randall Wray — Why Minsky Matters (2016)
6. Steve Keen — Can We Avoid Another Financial Crisis? (2017)
7. Pavlina R. Tcherneva — The Case for a Job Guarantee (2020)
8. L. Randall Wray — Modern Money Theory: A Primer on Macroeconomics for Sovereign Monetary Systems (2015)
9. Steve Keen — Debunking Economics (2011)
10. Marc Lavoie — Post-Keynesian Economics: New Foundations (2014)
11. Wynne Godley & Marc Lavoie — Monetary Economics (2007)
Start with the basics, then gradually move towards more advanced theory. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
French Students Are Revolting, and so they should be!, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/french-students-are-revoltin…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
The Empirical Case Against the Euro
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen
French Students Are Revolting—and so they should be!
braveneweurope.com/uncategorized/steve-keen-french-studen…
#economics #france #finance #politics #riots #neoliberalism #eu #ecb #euro #students #austerity -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
French Students Are Revolting, and so they should be!, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/french-students-are-revoltin…
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I'm writing a post and video on The Nobble Prize in Economics, which I'll share here once it's ready. But if you want to (attempt to!) educate your teacher, recommend this book on how "Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel" was concocted in 1969 by the Swedish Central Bank in a battle against social democratic policies in Sweden: press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691166032/the-nob…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
@ProfSteveKeen Thoroughly enjoyed your VERY EASY TO FOLLOW (minimum jargon) Economist opinion of the imminent economic collapse @MacleodFinance
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQrBApPeJNU -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thanks Kate. That was a very fair-minded discussion too, something that I've unfortunately come not to expect. But this was one of the exceptions to the rule.
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
@ProfSteveKeen Thoroughly enjoyed your VERY EASY TO FOLLOW (minimum jargon) Economist opinion of the imminent economic collapse @MacleodFinance
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQrBApPeJNU -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Leon Simons 🌍
@LeonSimons8
Northern Hemisphere temperature are projected off the chart next week.
The ongoing Super El Niño is starting to increase global temperatures and the weather disasters will come with it. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Eliot Jacobson
@EliotJacobson
Your 'doom quote' for today:
"The human species will survive somehow but we will destroy almost everything we have built up over the last two thousand years. I am pretty sure."
theecologist.org/2019/jan/03/its-nonlinearity-stupid -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Let’s pretend climate scientists were exaggerating and that actually climate change wasn’t going to be catastrophic,
would it not be the case that the flooding that we are seeing today because of this storm,
the horrifically unpleasant extreme heat we saw this summer,
the drought,
the wildfires,
the threat to farmers ability to grow foods, the operations that were cancelled,
the busiest summer on record for the London ambulance service and so on,
would that not be reason enough to act?
But the fact is climate change is going to be catastrophic, scientists are very clear that it does threaten our ability to maintain organised human society.
And people like Lord Ashcroft seem to be doing everything they can to undermine action.
Lord Ashcroft
@LordAshcroft
The five ‘tribes’ on climate change and net zero - and why voters are still waiting for policies that seem sensible and fair
My latest polling and analysis in the Mail on Sunday @DailyMail
www.dailymail.com/news/article-16235873/LORD-ASHCROFT-Bri… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🌞 Machine Sun Philly 🌞
@xXPhillyCXx
The Beatles are not overrated.
At all.
I’m sorry but if you think this I could probably sell you your own urine at $9.99 a bottle, because that’s the level of stupidity that this take implies.
The Real Calvy J
@CJRealHoops2
*deep inhale*
Guys, it’s The Beatles.
Formulaic music that got hyped into genius status by a perfect storm of timing and savvy media, not actual skill. Expert exploitation of trends already pioneered by others.
They’re a marketing phenomenon that got called the greatest because they sold a lot of records to herd-mentality teenagers, not because the music itself was ever the most advanced, demanding, or enduring rock ever made. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
. @LordAshcroft here inadvertently highlights why the outlook is so bleak.
Those in power simply do not understand or accept the magnitude of the threat of climate change. Their love of money has blinded them to the fact that some people can be motivated by things other than wealth.
Ashcroft frames climate change as an issue of politics and money, not of the degradation of conditions which have briefly allowed human civilisation to flourish.
He suggests scientists present the worst case scenario because they are reliant on grants.
He’s presumably never actually spoken to Climate scientists because he’d see if he did, as I have, that they are not motivated by grants, they are motivated by watching nature degrade and trying to save it and their children’s lives.
In reality they play down the threat because they are scared of being called hysterical.
In reality it’s happening far faster than predicted with greater impacts earlier than predicted.
I’ve seen scientists in tears. They are terrified. They can’t sleep. They point to the geological record which shows the rapid climate change has in the past sometimes wiped out most of life on earth.
But Lord Ashcroft just sees it as an issue of politics and of money. He doesn’t understand soon there may be no politics and no money and not much at all.
He, like everyone, can literally see the weather changing around him - read that sentence again - but is still in denial about the need to stop it or what is coming.
He embodies the insanity of this moment.
He embodies the arrogance of humans who tragically believe we are more powerful than nature. Something that’s going to be our ultimate and final mistake.
www.dailymail.com/news/article-16235873/LORD-ASHCROFT-Bri… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Dissenter
@TheDissenterYT
Learn about how climate change can produce economic collapse in my interview with Dr. Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen). #economics #science
Full interview: youtu.be/BtdhKsj3h4s -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
To all my Brazilian friends …
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
An economist is looking for his keys under a streetlamp.
—Did you lose them here?
—No, over there, in the dark.
—Then why look here?
—Because this is where I can solve the model analytically.
Mathematical elegance doesn't guarantee we're looking where it matters. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
mariana Z
@mariana057
100 years ago everyone owned a horse & only the rich had cars.
Today everyone has cars & only the rich own horses.
How the stables have turned. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Robert Lucas probably did more to set macroeconomics back than any other economist of the twentieth century.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Thomas Reis
@peakaustria
It's hard to believe that some experts aren't aware that El Niños have a step-change (ratchet) effect on global climate.
El Niño warming is categorically not temporary.
It is irreversible, permanent, forever.
El Niño is the engine that heats up the planet in apocalyptic surges.
This might be the single most important thing to understand about our situation.
For clarity, I added the steps to the graph... via Mark Cranfield
Thomas Reis
@peakaustria
Climate Ratchet to form a Super El Nino into a El Padre:
'This is normally temporary, which is why we think of El Niño as an event rather than a climate. The intriguing possibility raised by Earth’s geological past is that the background state itself can change.'
El Padre: When El Niño Becomes the Climate - by Peter Dynes substack.com/home/post/p-216709236
'a terrifying systemic pattern has emerged: temperatures no longer drop back down to the pre-existing trend line after the event concludes. Instead, the climate system undergoes a step-change—a warming ratchet that locks in a higher baseline.'
Not Just Another “Super” El Niño Article - Updated 22nd August substack.com/@drtomharris/p-201606657 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Loading the DICE Against Life, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/loading-the-dice-against-life Chapter 22 in my forthcoming book "How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism"
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Liger
@EdbieLigerSmith
Neoclassical economics is ultimate form of bourgoies irrationalism.
Nobody can justify the existing economy, so the elites invented a fantasy world to imagine how they would like capitalism to work ideally.
Then they call it a “science” & lecture you on why you need to study it. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Supply and demand is probably the most overused diagram in the history of social science.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Graham White
@heterodox_econs
How on earth could one say that "contemporary mainstream macroeconomics, [is] an elaboration of Keynes's GT". The principle of effective demand has been pigeon-holed into the "short-period" since the 1940's; the return or rather continued dominance of the notion of a rate of interest bringing investment into line with the full-employment flow of saving is precisely what Keynes sought to reject in the GT. The mainstream could only deal with that by relegating Keynes to the "short-period". The Keynes of the GT was for the mainstream never more than the short-period special case. @USydneyEcon
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
You’re wrong about this, I’m afraid. Not only is it a misnomer to call mainstream macro ‘Keynesian’, it’s almost a misnomer to call it ‘macro’.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mario
@PawlowskiMario
I live in a small MAGA town.
I know MAGA people. I drink with them. I talk to them. I study them.
They’re not the loud Twitter yappers, at least most of them. They’re quieter. Slower. But the delusion runs deep, just bottled up in passive smiles and soft voices.
A few weeks ago, one of them tried to convert me at a bar. He knew I wasn’t into the Trump cult, but he started soft. Calm voice. Friendly tone.
“Mario, you’re white. You can drink a lot, you eat meat, “he was just surprised that I was eating rare burger” and drinking vodka chasing it with Guinness. He also said, “You’re one of us. You should feel proud.”
That’s their seduction tactic.
Not facts. Not logic. Just subtle tribal grooming.
“You’re white. You drink. You belong.”
It was almost sweet, in a sad, culty way.
Like a Jehovah’s Witness trying to sell you eternal life with a shaky brochure and cheap suit.
But let’s talk about the whole ecosystem.
The truth.
MAGA men?
Most are not warriors.
They’re out-of-shape, insecure, jealous small-town boys who peaked in high school, still clinging to stories from when they “almost went pro” or “should’ve been in the military.”
They’re proud of being able to drink a case of light beer, drive a truck, and scream about freedom while their knees buckle from sugar and rage.
They’re easy to manipulate because they don’t ask questions.
They don’t read.
They react.
They memorize memes like scripture and repeat them like gospel.
They think being loud equals being right.
They think the world is laughing with them.
It’s not.
The world’s laughing at them, when it’s not just ignoring them entirely.
MAGA women?
They’re caught in a brutal paradox, constantly screaming about how proud and strong they are, while reshaping every inch of their body to meet a fake beauty standard pushed by the very system they claim to hate.
Plastic lips. Inflated cheeks. Eyelashes thick as windshield wipers.
Trying to look rich while shopping clearance at Walmart.
They scream about “natural family values” while injecting Botox and collapsing into MLM scams that promise empowerment through overpriced lipstick.
They mock liberals for being “gender confused” while wearing more synthetic parts than a Barbie made in a Russian factory.
Here’s the thing: MAGA America isn’t just backward.
It’s boring. MAGA folks are simply subsimple.
There’s nothing imaginative about it. No new culture. No innovation. No ideas.
They don’t invent, they imitate.
They don’t challenge, they chant.
It’s the same five phrases over and over.
The same flag. The same truck. The same outfit.
Patriot cosplay.
And that’s why the world doesn’t just hate MAGA.
It forgets it.
Because once the shouting stops, there’s nothing under the hood.
Just cheap beer breath, fake smiles, and a belief that whiteness and loudness are still enough to matter.
You want the brutal truth?
Even without Trump, even without the cult, most of them would still be irrelevant.
Not because they’re evil.
But because they chose comfort over growth.
Tribalism over truth.
Imitation over imagination.
They don’t want to understand the world.
They want the world to stay small enough to understand them.
And that’s the saddest, most humiliating part. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Thirty years ago today, the great economist Hyman Minsky passed away. It was Minsky who first set me on the path toward Post-Keynesian economics.
Within mainstream economics, he is best known for his Financial Instability Hypothesis. Yet his theoretical legacy extends far beyond it. Building on Keynes and Kalecki, Minsky developed a comprehensive understanding of how a capitalist economy functions, in which price and profit formation, investment, financing, and the dynamics of debt are understood as interconnected processes. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pierrick L
@PierrickLVN
Je crois que personne ne se rend très bien compte du monde qu’il y avait à Paris pour manifester aujourd’hui.
Je crois n’avoir jamais vu ça.
#17octobre
#24octobre -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Rising market prices in response to a rise in market demand is NOT a prediction of Neoclassical microeconomic theory. That’s the true impact of the Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu theorem. You can only guarantee that result with a single agent consuming a single good, which destroys the concept of relative prices in the first place.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 20 minute with @ProfSteveKeen for a Q&A session. You can participate in the live chat!
www.youtube.com/live/qKRR_DEEmFU -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
They say neoclassical economics textbooks are useless for solving real-world problems. I disagree: they're excellent for propping up wobbly tables. And for once, they achieve equilibrium without having to assume away the instability.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Their Old Testament book would be Marshall’s, and their New Testament, Samuelson’s. Purgatory is exogenous shocks, and Heaven is Equilibrium.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
My prediction is clear: you have not ready any of the empirical literature on the actual cost structure of firms. Like this one for instance, by Alan Blinder.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You lot will never accept that diminishing marginal productivity, which is the foundation of the upward-sloping supply curve, is a myth. Nor that the SMD conditions are proof by contradiction that you can't construct market demand curves while ignoring the distribution of income.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is the real world model of competitive behaviour. A firm with higher sales has lower per unit costs and could well reduce price given a higher level of demand. You'll never take it seriously, of course.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What he probably means is that it’s an elaboration of Hicks’s IS-LM model. Someone should tell him to read Hicks’s “IS-LM: An Explanation”.
But I’m sure he wouldn’t understand it. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Rising market prices in response to a rise in market demand is NOT a prediction of Neoclassical microeconomic theory. That’s the true impact of the Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu theorem. You can only guarantee that result with a single agent consuming a single good, which destroys the concept of relative prices in the first place.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You need to face facts that your key phenomenon of diminishing marginal productivity is an empirical myth, that real world competition is evolutionary, not equilibrium, and that you can't ignore the distribution of income.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
This is where I am politically right now. Despite Melenchon's rousing speeches and appeals to appropriate post-Keynesian economic policies, the current European riots have sunk into their usual headless, directionless shape. The polls have hardly shifted - le Pen was already well ahead. Any 'revolutionary' situation will be captured by the far right. The awkward corollary of what I've written below is that if we seek to construct a serious, committed opposition, first we must elicit an equal and opposite fear grounded in reality. We must replace the manufactured fears of immigrants, public 'debt', bond markets and so on with an overriding objective fear. What will really happen to the West if we carry on like this? It's an unfortunate fact that fear is the primary fuel for the hope, rational discussions of political economy and positive protest and action - aimed at what we're FOR rather than against - that come later. Dupuy's 'enlightened catastrophism' - @winlow_s has written about this www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/building-better-societie… and there's a useful summary here. cyrilhedoin.substack.com/p/enlightened-catastrophism-french
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
The constant flow of 'assured nonsense' you hear from the likes of Friedman - temporary winners, aspirers and their mouthpieces - is what aroused my interest in neuropsychology years ago. Ideological positions driven at root by primary affective demands - fear of loss and sacrifice being the strongest - create what Adrian Johnston calls 'deaptation'. The very thought of true democracy and the prioritisation of collective needs - the 'public interest' - triggers that fear. The more serial market failures and their negative real effects refute their position, the more fearful they become, which strengthens their beliefs, even though, cognitively, the relatively brighter ones might understand their absurdity. The evasive ethical/cognitive justification invoked is the sort of Churchillian 'least-worst' thinking you hear all the time - "ok, this is absurd and quite awful but it's better than socialism and we'll get through this rocky patch". The worse things get - and they will - the more they will double down on their beliefs. There will be no limits to their corruption and violence. No point in reasoning with them - we must construct a serious opposition amongst the unaffected and unconvinced.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Will John Healey's budget be a disaster? I believe it will be. That's because he is talking as if we are living in normal times, and we are not. Events outside his control will overtake Healey's budget, and he's not ready for them. youtu.be/URAPq5We8rA
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Ain't that the truth!
VAN MUTOKA
@vanmutoka1
« Ce qu'il y a de plus agaçant dans la vie, c'est que la personne honnête perd toujours dans la joute verbale. Car elle est tenue par la vérité, tandis que le menteur peut dire n'importe quoi. »
DostoïevskiThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
beverlymantle
@beverlymantle1
I think economics is the only field that's been called "unscientific in the true sense of the word" by one of its Nobel laureates.
www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/1974/hayek/le… -
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Mikroökonomik ist also nicht "ganz abstrakt"? 🤔
Veronika Grimm
@GrimmVeronika
Habe gerade aus Neugier reingehört. Zu Beginn wird behauptet, die VWL würde sich nicht im Detail damit befassen wie Preise entstehen. Das wäre alles ganz abstrakt. Hier entsteht leider der Eindruck, dass die Gesprächspartnerinnen sich ziemlich wenig mit der VWL auskennen…. das ist erschreckend.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Rising market prices in response to a rise in market demand is NOT a prediction of Neoclassical microeconomic theory. That’s the true impact of the Sonnenschein-Mantel-Debreu theorem. You can only guarantee that result with a single agent consuming a single good, which destroys the concept of relative prices in the first place.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
My prediction is clear: you have not ready any of the empirical literature on the actual cost structure of firms. Like this one for instance, by Alan Blinder.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You lot will never accept that diminishing marginal productivity, which is the foundation of the upward-sloping supply curve, is a myth. Nor that the SMD conditions are proof by contradiction that you can't construct market demand curves while ignoring the distribution of income.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You need to face facts that your key phenomenon of diminishing marginal productivity is an empirical myth, that real world competition is evolutionary, not equilibrium, and that you can't ignore the distribution of income.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is the real world model of competitive behaviour. A firm with higher sales has lower per unit costs and could well reduce price given a higher level of demand. You'll never take it seriously, of course.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A very sensible warning. Also wasteful to use it as a party trick: once helium is gone, it’s gone from the planet.
But the helium in that balloon was already doomed to travel to outer space, so u thought why not?
I’m just glad I did what I’d been told, don’t confine too much.
V
@AronVice
PSA: Don’t try this at home.
I straight up had a seizure and almost died after inhaling helium as a teenager.
I just wanted to make my mom and brother laugh, so I inhaled as much as I could, started talking, then everything faded and memories from my life literally flashed before my eyes. I woke up to my mom panicking and trying to wake me up.
My brother makes fun of me to this day. Re-enacts me passing out onto the bed and falling onto the floor 😂
Ultimately, I DID make them laugh. Just took years for it to become funny. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steven Bartlett
@StevenBartlett
Steve Keen on the gas with no substitute that every chip in your phone depends on.
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What he probably means is that it’s an elaboration of Hicks’s IS-LM model. Someone should tell him to read Hicks’s “IS-LM: An Explanation”.
But I’m sure he wouldn’t understand it. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniyal Khan
@khand154
The economic orthodoxy will tweet about testability and empirics and then go to class and teach utility theory and Mas-Colell with a straight face.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
MMT is a movement not an idea. None of them offer testable predictions. They speak in tautologies as if their ideas follow from first principles. In contrasted economics is increasingly empirical.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Libertarians have the political and economic instincts of a raccoon trapped inside a fucking vending machine.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
We're back, @ProfSteveKeen and I will be doing another Q&A Livestream tomorrow, hit the notification bell and join the live chat. See ya there!
www.youtube.com/live/qKRR_DEEmFU -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Loanable funds theory treats credit as a redistribution of prior savings. Capitalist banks create deposits when they lend.
There's a delicious irony in some of capitalism's most fervent apologists failing to understand the very institutions that make it possible. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
No comment needed.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Amen to this! They have forgotten that they missed the biggest economic event since the Great Depression, which they also didn’t see coming. And now they’re arrogantly telling those of us who did how economics should be done!
Mike Bostic
@mbostic0
To me, orthodox economists exist to protect the status quo and are flat out clueless when it comes down to understanding money. On topics such as taxes, inflation, interest rates, deficits, unemployment they've been consistently wrong and then doubling down on it. Their arrogance is on another level but these are the same people who couldn't foresee the GFC of 2007-2008 or even the dot com bubble/recession of 2000-2001. Also, orthodox economists suffer from a terrible lack of accountability, pushing policies for decades that have put America in the position it's in today. Truly pathetic and unfortunate.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The ECB has the tools to stop it anytime. It is somewhat ridiculous to give this power to an "independent" institutions led by non-elected technocrats.
Zoe Schneeweiss
@ZSchneeweiss
Franklin Templeton sees risk of euro debt crisis worse than 2012 www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-20/franklin-templ…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Shahin Ashkiani
@shaahin_a
Constructing a priori 'as-if' models and subsequently fitting them to data is not considered an empirical approach.
Let's not forget Paul Romer's
Jan Schnellenbach
@schnellenbachj
Der heutigen VWL vorwerfen, dass sie nicht empirisch sei, das ist ja auch originell.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
C'mon, we have been there before. The @ECB just needs to step in and all of this will be over in a minute. 🙄
bondvigilantes.com/blog/2012/10/the-toxic-french-economic… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
It's far more complicated than Uncle Milton's little mind could have ever understood. I covered this topic a few weeks ago in a blog.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/laffer-curve-you-171621462
Cato Institute
@CatoInstitute
"Higher taxes never reduce the deficit.” – Milton Friedman.
The problem was never revenue. It was always spending. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Nice one!
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Marxists will argue about the labour theory of value for six hours and then complain that their time has been exploited.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
“Governments must manage their finances like households".
Great. Now find a household that issues the currency, levies taxes, and has a central bank.
MMT doesn't deny economic constraints. It denies that household analogies explain monetary systems. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Danger Close
@CourseCorrekt
China makes things cheaper because Australia decided to deindustrialise itself, like every other western nation. Self immolation. Use it or lose it. All those manufacturing skills gone. Dont worry, we will enjoy cave man life.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saint Charlie🇵🇸🦈🐝™️
@PollyVinyl1
I love this genre.
Was it said by a Nazi or a Zionist?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alon Mizrahi
@alon_mizrahi
The US is suddenly and quite rapidly moving to end the Ukraine war by offering wild, unprecedented concessions to Russia for one reason, and one reason alone: Netanyahu and the lobby overpowered every anti-Russia hawk in US defence circles, and reprioritized Iran as the top and only national security emergency for the US.
With very high probability, this is another sign that the hot war on Iran is about to resume at the command of the US supreme leader, Milikovski
Iran will shatter the empire and Israel. It will be fucking glorious -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Trump Lie Tracker (Commentary Account)
@MAGALieTracker
BREAKING: Anderson Cooper just aired a montage of Trump obsessing over the attractiveness of several men he’s campaigned for. You’re not alone if you’ve noticed a pattern. Wow.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I have more respect for an MMTer who understands basic accounting than an Austrian who has memorized every sentence Ludwig von Mises ever wrote.
Or stated in terms a libertarian can understand, I value practical knowledge over pseudo intellectual retardation. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
William Peynsaert
@PeynsaertBill
I know you know this picture. All adult people who've carried some of the pain of this world for others do. 58 years ago this month, three men stood on an Olympic podium in Mexico City.
Two of them, courageous to a level most people will never reach or even aspire to reach, became famous for raising their fists.
The third didn't raise his fist.
But he knew exactly what was happening.
16 October 1968.
The Olympic Games in Mexico City.
The United States is being torn apart by racial conflict. Martin Luther King has been murdered six months earlier. Black Americans are still fighting for rights that other Americans take for granted.
Two American sprinters, Tommie Smith and John Carlos, have just won gold and bronze in the 200 metres.
Between them stands a 26-year-old white Australian called Peter Norman.
Norman has run the race of his life.
He's won SILVER, beating Carlos, one of the overwhelming favourites.
His time of 20.06 seconds is so astonishing that it will remain the Australian national record for another 56 years.
He should be thinking about his medal, his future, the applause, the extraordinary doors that might open for him.
But Smith and Carlos have something else on their minds.
They're planning to protest racial injustice during the medal ceremony.
In front of the entire world.
And they tell Norman what they're going to do.
Norman is Australian.
The American civil rights movement isn't his fight.
He could simply stand there, smile politely, collect his silver medal and go home.
Nobody would ever know that he had been given an opportunity to demonstrate moral courage and declined it.
But Norman asks the Americans what he can do to help.
And he tells them:
"I'll stand with you."
There's a practical problem.
Smith and Carlos have planned to wear black gloves, but Carlos has forgotten his pair.
Norman suggests something beautifully simple.
Why don't they share the remaining pair?
One glove each.
That's why, in the famous photograph, Smith raises his RIGHT fist and Carlos raises his LEFT.
The Australian also finds himself an Olympic Project for Human Rights badge.
He pins it to his tracksuit.
And the three men step onto the podium.
The American national anthem begins.
Smith and Carlos bow their heads and raise their fists.
Norman stands beside them.
A small white man in an Australian tracksuit, wearing a tiny badge.
It doesn't look particularly spectacular.
No shouting.
No violence.
No great revolutionary speech.
Just three men saying, in their own ways, that human beings deserve to be treated as human beings.
And the sporting establishment goes NUTS.
Smith and Carlos are expelled from the Games.
They're denounced, threatened and treated as traitors for daring to make people uncomfortable during a sporting event.
Norman returns to Australia.
His country has its own ugly history of racial exclusion, particularly concerning its Indigenous population.
And there are plenty of Australians who aren't particularly thrilled that their Olympic silver medallist has associated himself with two Black American protesters.
Norman encounters hostility and ostracism in parts of the sporting world.
Four years later, he isn't selected for the Munich Olympics.
Norman never repudiates what he did.
Peter Norman dies in 2006, aged 64.
At his funeral in Melbourne, two men have travelled all the way from America.
Tommie Smith.
John Carlos.
The two Black American athletes he had supported 38 years earlier.
And they carry his coffin.
Carlos told the mourners that Norman hadn't stood in front of them or behind them.
He had stood WITH them.
In 2012, the Australian Parliament finally apologised for Norman's treatment and its failure to recognise his courage while he was alive.
Forty-four years after the protest.
Six years after the man was dead.
One day governments will offer apologies to journalists sacked for holding Israeli officials' feet to the fire.
Hopefully before they die. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
They seem to listen using the same orifice with which they speak: their arses!
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
This is some serious tone deaf shit.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Great respect for Stallone here.
José Luis Antúnez
@jlantunez
Hay más verdad, valentía y honestidad en estos 93 segundos de Stallone que en toda la filosofía de ____________.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
PAME Greece International
@PAME_Greece
🚩 In Athens, “The Internationale” rings out as school students raise their fists! Stirring scenes that echo the youth uprising in France.
➡️ Shared problems, a common adversary, the policies of the EU and governments that attack our education, our lives and our future.
✔️ For free public education, modern and safe schools, and measures to tackle soaring prices that are crushing our families.
✊ From Greece to France, we strengthen our common struggle! We will not give our future away!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
Schools are falling apart, rats, mold, flooding, no bathrooms in some and more. Kids are tired of it. Fucking numpty.
Michael Holman
@hossfly84
France already has universal health care and mostly free college... help me understand why they're rioting? I thought the golden calf of education and Healthcare fixed everything 🤡
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alejandro Pérez Polo
@alejperez_
Una Europa mucho más pobre que la actual, en los años 50, fue capaz de levantar la mayoría de instrumentos del Estado del Bienestar que hoy dice «no poder soportar». Es más, en aquel entonces hasta el 50% de la construcción de nueva obra de vivienda era pública o social.
La operación ideológica de las élites para convencer a la gente que una Europa cinco veces más rica que entonces (en riqueza real, descontando inflación, aumento población etc etc) no puede hacer lo mismo es algo descomunal.
El neoliberalismo no solo ha destrozado nuestras economías, sino que es un cepo mental que impide construir otros imaginarios, aunque hoy dispongamos de estructuras productivas mucho más desarrolladas y eficientes que en los 50. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ann Ebert
@ebert_ann
This is for all the writers ( and want to be writers) in this beautiful community 💖✍🏼👩💻👨🏻💻📝. This gave me some serious guffaws and I hope it does for you as well 👍🏼💙. Happy writing ✍🏼🙏🏼. @LouDPhillips @DzintraSullivan @ChrisBohjalian @therealSIR3 @hwinkler4real @AuthorFleur @donnacox1021 @drdoomed01 @jameshealyjr
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
I was in Paris today. It was fine a few garbage cans burnt. I hardly saw a cop. I guess they must be icing their aging knees.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
But the most important point here is that scientific consensus is formed within the scientific community itself. If New Keynesians dominate university economics departments, government offices, and central banks, then it is New Keynesian economics that determines what counts as scientific economic theory.
Imagine that flat-earthers occupied scientific positions throughout NASA and other space agencies. They could formally establish a scientific consensus, but that would not make the Earth flat. Moreover, if their beliefs guided engineering decisions, we would probably stop going into space altogether.
Scientific consensus is a sociological fact, not a criterion of theoretical truth.
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Economics is a social science. Unlike the laws of physics, economic laws are neither timeless nor universal. They are historically contingent, shaped by social relations and institutions, and vary across time and space.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matt Kennard
@kennardmatt
British journalists never reported on their government's direct participation in the Gaza genocide
They were obeying a 'D-Notice' censorship order sent out by the UK military
Every media editor received this on 28 October 2023. You were never meant to see it. Here it is👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
faylize
@fayl1ze
Robbie Williams revealed that a RANDOM WOMAN gave him a HANDJOB in his castle bedroom - and he had NO IDEA who she was.
He woke up to a strange woman standing by his bed and assumed she was the cleaner.
She offered him a handjob. He agreed.
Later, he told the woman running the castle:
“Your cleaner's weird.”
“We don't have cleaners on a Wednesday.”
But it gets even crazier.
THREE YEARS LATER, his guitarist heard the story and immediately recognized her.
“That's Maureen from the pub!”
“She said she did that but nobody believed her!”
Anna Kendrick's reaction is PRICELESS. 💀This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I've just signed up at DonateOpen, a new initiative to enable people to support creators. See donateopen.com/@profstevekeen
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Red MMT
@RedMMT
"The only viable path is for France to exit the common currency and restore the franc and the powers of the Banque de France."
French protests reflect the dysfunctional architecture of the common currency billmitchell.org/blog/?p=63434 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Erik Arnell
@ArnellOErik
Det är anmärkningsvärt hur krisen i Frankrike får så många att göra exakt samma felaktiga analys. Vi får inte låta denna konsensus leda till mer av det som faktiskt har skapat missnöjet i Frankrike: åtstramning och en strypning av ekonomin genom att underförse den med valuta.
Källqvist sätter fingret på en smärtsam sanning när han beskriver hur Europa tappar real förmåga. Den reala analysen ter sig rimlig. Felsatsningar måste rannsakas. Men den finansiella diagnosen bygger på ett fundamentalt makroekonomiskt kategorifel.
Han skriver att stater måste "förhålla sig till kreditgivarnas förtroende". Det är en hushållsekonomisk vanföreställning. En valutautgivare lånar inte sin egen valuta, den ger ut den. Det är marknaden som får den valuta den behöver från staten, inte tvärtom.
Europas förfall beror inte på att de finansiella resurserna inte räcker till. Det beror på att vi underkastar oss godtyckliga och självvalda finansiella begränsningar som stryper ekonomin. Vi lämnar ledig real kapacitet på bordet för att blidka fiktiva långivare.
Jag dekonstruerar exakt denna utbredda felanalys i två artiklar idag:
www.dagensarena.se/essa/krisen-frankrike-visar-sverige-sk…
www.di.se/debatt/frankrikes-problem-ar-inte-den-hoga-stat…
Ola Kallqvist
@olakallqvist
Europa blev så rikt att vi började betrakta välstånd som en mänsklig rättighet snarare än något som måste skapas. Nu har Kina tagit industrin, USA tekniken och Frankrike skickat notan till inkasso. Skriver i Fokus om Maslow-effekten. Del 1 av 5 i Europas farliga spel.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
¿Sabías que el 60% de los países que privatizaron su sistema de pensiones han tenido que dar marcha atrás? Pensiones muy bajas, comisiones altísimas y crisis financieras. Lo que quiere hacer VOX en España ya ha fracasado en muchísimos países. Repasamos por qué 🧵
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
I’m specifically criticising RANK models. Why? Because the economics discipline endorsed them with its top prize. It’s laughable that such models were ever influential in monetary policy, and it’s even more laughable that this work is rewarded with a ‘Nobel Prize’.
ceteris partybus
@JohannesNaegele
Monetary economics, e.g., has a bunch of search models, where money is essential and idiosyncratic risk exists.
See also the papers around Diamond/Kiyotaki/Wright/Trejos or (for HANK) „The Dynamics of Inequality“ 2016. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hector Wetherell McNeill
@HectorWMcNeill
ERRORS IN ECONOMICS Part 3
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen posted a video pointing out misleading content in taught economics - see link below.
It covers a lot of relevant issues but this short & sharp presentation jumps over some essential details.
Most of Steve's comments point out what he considers to be errors in what is generally classified as "neoclassical" economics with the underlying assumption of this possessing several unrealistic and dogmatic positions.
It is worth understanding the position of one of the leading neoclassical economists, Alfred Marshall (1842-1924) whose view was that:
"Economic doctrine is not a body of concrete truth, but an engine for the discovery of concrete truth"
Steve refers to one of the standard classic misinterpretations of "neoclassical" analysis criticising the well known supply and demand curve cross with an "equilibrium" point "E" where the lines cross which seems to imagine that there is a standard consumer with fixed tastes and propensity to consume.
As a starting point in having supply and demand explained this simplistic model is adequate but it is more than evident that this limited interpretation was not one made by neoclassisists but rather a mistake made in interpretation by current economists.
In Marshall's "Principles of Economics" (1890) there is a discussion introducing the concept of elasticity of demand.
In our development of the Real Incomes Approach to Economics we have made ample use of this concept extending it to income-price elasticity of demand (ipED).
This explains quite clearly that depending upon a consumer's income level the response in consumption to changes in prices will be different according to the price level and direction of the price movement.
This in turn, not only demonstrates this "neoclassical concept" reflects an awarenessthat we are not dealing with some static standard consumer but that using the ipED goes even further by allowing us to calculate the expected growth rates associated with different price trajectories.
Thus an inflationary, rising price trajectory, creates a depressed market, low growth and a state of austerity and a deflationary, falling price trajectory, creates rapid growth and rise in purchasing power which is differentiated according to income levels.
This provides a more useful analysis than the contempory assumptions that money issuance creates "growth" but where no information is generated on income distribution, price movements, currency purchasing power or real incomes.
As Marshall suggested, past propositions are indeed engines for arriving closer to "concrete truth" even when they emerged during what some refer to as the "neoclassical period".
youtu.be/M1odc6itzyk -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrés Bernal 🇨🇴🇺🇸
@andresintheory
Honestly baffles the mind how drunk economists are off their own bullshit
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Erik Arnell
@ArnellOErik
Den franska krisen pekas ut som ett skräckexempel på hur det går om man låter statsskulden öka för mycket.
Det är bakvänt. Lärdomen är att 🇸🇪 ska hålla sig långt borta från € och att vi måste sluta sträva efter att balansera statens finansiella budget.
www.dagensarena.se/essa/krisen-frankrike-visar-sverige-sk… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two."
In fact, it is quite the opposite. Heterodox economics is largely concerned with institutional economics. As such, institutions — like money — are described and analyzed. Unlike orthodox economics, there is no bias towards state-led solutions, but rather a market bias. Reality is explained as an 'equilibrium' brought about by individuals. The 'capital market', the 'labour market', the 'goods market' — the 'holy cross' of supply and demand — is invoked, although it is built on sand due to problems of aggregation (just google the Cambridge Capital Controversy). Hence, policy advice is neoliberal, focusing on finding the right 'incentives' for private investment (de-risking), pollution (trading certificates) and employment (pushing down wages). Fallacies of composition (not everyone can save, for example) are ignored. Any empirical reality that goes against a model's processes or data is ignored. New Keynesians, for example, create an abstract model based on assumptions that can be empirically tested. This did not stop them. They neither saw the financial crisis coming nor could they explain it. No time for worry. The fact that there is no 'Nobel', as mentioned by Jason Furman? Ignored. Free trade theory was "applied" in the 2000s, with the US losing almost one in three manufacturing jobs. Did that trigger a return to industrial policy in the orthodox academic journals? Nope. Have orthodox economists learned anything from MMT? It does not seem so. You still claim that taxpayers finance the government, despite there being not a single paper that explains the details, whereas there are literally dozens of papers describing balance sheets and accounting mechanics published by MMT economists. Have any orthodox economists learned that showing only public debt means omitting the private and external sectors, and that there is a bigger picture?
So, the orthodox paradigm is centred on a pro-market and anti-government core, which is highly ideological. People are assumed to be rational, and society is dismissed as an irrelevant concept. This paradigm cannot be touched. It is a political programme enabled by those who saw the fall of the Soviet Empire as meaning that the 'end of history' was near. Orthodox economists have enabled policies that have rolled back the state (thus diminishing democracy) and brought in finance. The policies it has supported over the last forty years — financialisation, privatisation, etc. — have created many problems, including climate change, inequality, mass unemployment and inflation. These problems cannot be solved by the same theories that created them. If there is any hope of solving the problems of the 21st century, it lies in rethinking them from a heterodox perspective.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ingrid H. Kvangraven
@ingridharvold
This is the frustrating thing about mainstream Econs. They see diversity of *topics* and think it represents genuine diversity in *theoretical foundations*. Completely oblivious to the historical narrowing of what counts as Economics that led us to this situation.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I would encourage anyone who criticized this with a litany of views about what they think economics is to read the Table of Contents of the most recent Quarterly Journal of Economics and then get back to me with updates.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rethinking Economics
@rethinkecon
Do you find yourself wondering…
‘What is economics?’, ‘How did economics become language of power and its practitioners, the gatekeepers?’, ‘How do you do economics?’, ‘Can economics help serve people and planet?’
Join the Rethinking Economics Fundamentals to explore and find some answers.
It’s a four-week course designed to introduce to some of the big questions that preoccupy Rethinkers.
Only open to members. Starts on 11/11/26.
To sign up visit the members' hub. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrew M. Fischer
@AndrewM_Fischer
Politics is like bad breath… you only smell it on others.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Great new feature dashboard called "The Minsky Report" is coming to @GDPDynamics next week. Be sure to follow for updates.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
A new dashboard is coming to GDP Dynamics next week. The dashboard board will be free for everyone at gdpdynamics.com while the monthly in-depth report will be available to paid members at: members.gdpdynamics.com
Beta testing is available for Pro & Platinum subscribers. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Michael Galant
@michael_galant
This set of quotes from @IsabellaMWeber’s new Anti-Fascist Economics really says it all
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
#Anonymous
@TheStripesGirl
FOX is letting him loose!
Peter did not cut him off, he didn’t go to a commercial, nor interrupted or challenge him.
Maybe FOX really wanted Trump to hear how incompetent he is!! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
Money is irrelevant in Woodford’s models because of the assumptions at the core of the model. There’s no logical role for money affecting output and inflation as the model is non-monetary, the assumptions preclude any role for money. The models are incoherent.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Bloomberg says it as it is: The time for Anti-Fascist Economics is here.
“Weber’s underlying economic philosophy, which prioritizes making the necessities of life affordable for every citizen of a democracy, has gained momentum.”
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-16/an-economist-m… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Why mainstream economics keeps getting capitalism wrong:
unrealistic competition, equilibrium instead of evolution, banks creating money, private debt driving booms and busts, the fallacy of composition, and the neglected role of energy and physical production constraints.
Six fundamental challenges to conventional economic thinking.
50 Years of Brutally Honest Economic Advice in 23 mins youtu.be/M1odc6itzyk via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Mikroökonomik ist also nicht "ganz abstrakt"? 🤔
Veronika Grimm
@GrimmVeronika
Habe gerade aus Neugier reingehört. Zu Beginn wird behauptet, die VWL würde sich nicht im Detail damit befassen wie Preise entstehen. Das wäre alles ganz abstrakt. Hier entsteht leider der Eindruck, dass die Gesprächspartnerinnen sich ziemlich wenig mit der VWL auskennen…. das ist erschreckend.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
The core of NK DSGE models is the same as RBC and is what makes DSGE models unrealistic and theoretically incoherent. Adding nominal rigidity and imperfect competition doesn’t make them more scientific. They’re still non-monetary models where money is inessential.
ceteris partybus
@JohannesNaegele
Well, thank god there are not merely intro RBC models, but a myriad of models with idiosyncratic risk and imperfect foresight.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I'm speaking at the Monetary Diversity Conference taking place in Brussels from Friday to Sunday this week:
www.monetarydiversity.org/modi-ii
Sign up and come along if you can. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
Orthodox econs don’t know their own models. Consumption is not uncertain in RANK DSGE models. Idiosyncratic risk is assumed away. It’s uncertain in HANK models (although these too to capture fundamental uncertainty), but the Euler equation of RANK models assumes away uncertainty.
fantastyka twardo (nie)naukowa
@nienaukowa
and you save out of caution, because, well, both the future real rate and your income are *uncertain* ✨
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
jamie
@gnuman1979
Ouch.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𐙚𝒪𝓂𝑒𝓃𝒶♡💗
@Debonperc
After weeks of rioting in Paris no one was killed.
Which technically means your child is safer attending a riot in Paris than a school in America. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🎸 Rock History 🎸
@historyrock_
In 1956, George Harrison became fascinated with rock and roll when, while riding his bike, he heard Elvis’s “Heartbreak Hotel” playing from a nearby house, a moment he later described as a true epiphany.
At age 13, he convinced his mother to buy him an Egmond acoustic guitar made in the Netherlands, which he purchased from a former schoolmate for just three pounds and ten shillings.
He taught himself almost everything, practicing until his fingers hurt. His early influences included Lonnie Donegan, a pioneer of British skiffle, and later Carl Perkins, an American guitarist whose influence would go on to shape much of The Beatles’ early sound. George even used the pseudonym “Carl Harrison” during a tour of Scotland in 1960, as a direct tribute to his idol.
Together with his brother, he built a small homemade amplifier, and soon began playing with local skiffle bands. That Egmond guitar, humble and inexpensive at the time, ended up being the starting point for one of the most influential guitarists in Rock History. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Nous vivons un grand moment de l'Histoire. Des mouvements lycéens et étudiants ont actuellement lieu aux quatre coins du monde.
Le néolibéralisme a détruit partout les services publics et les conquêtes des travailleurs, jusqu'à amener tout le monde au point d'exaspération.
C’est ce qui se passe quand on a enlevé au plus grand nombre et sur la terre entière, toute espérance d'y arriver par soi-même.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
We can build a new society out of the wreckage of neoliberalism, and we're going to have to do so. www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/10/20/we-can-build-a-new…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
Mainstream economists across the globe are suffering from the same problem: Lack of intellectual dignity and cowardice.
@OzatayFatih, former Deputy Governor of the Turkish CB, answered our questions and critiques without mentioning us.
Michalis Nikiforos
@mnikiforos
🤔This reminded me of something! @BachmannRudi has been criticizing our paper (Nikiforos and Zezza [2017]) the whole day without citing us. This is bad scientific practice and does not promote a healthy debate!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matías Vernengo
@NakedKeynes
This is the same argument raised by Colander, Holt and Rosser, that there is no mainstream and that the cutting edge of the profession is moving away from any established consensus. It is problematic for many reasons /1
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics.
Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc.
Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural.
The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Such a sad milestone, but you have handled yourself brilliantly since that tragedy, and you deserve happiness now. I am so glad you are getting it--even if we'll never live forever.
With David @davidgraeber, one of the truly good did die young
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
I just turned 59 — the same age David was when he died.
We used to joke that we’d live to 80, and by then someone would figure out how to give us another 20 years, and by then someone would figure out something else, and we half-suspected we’d end up living forever. Which made happiness feel infinite, and time feel abundant.
David was learning guitar with extraordinary stubbornness — possibly the most important thing he did besides writing, and certainly the most beloved. We were also taking ballet classes over Zoom together with a Russian ballerina, along with about a dozen other Russian women and myself. I was writing children’s books and essays. The plan was that once we finished the children’s book about pirates, I’d start a book with Keith Hart about what "nation" actually is. We also wanted to write a book about witches with Silvia Federici.
That was six years ago.
I’m in love again. I’m happy. But I know now, with certainty, that I won’t live forever. Time has contracted — it’s become scarce, and everything is moving very fast.
Maybe that’s why the book I care most about right now is a children’s book I’m making with Michael Hudson about what time is, and how differently people have understood it across cultures and across centuries. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
du -sh *
@LilAphasia
"when P.Samuelson got th prize for his unrealistic insistence that free trade made all countries gain and become more equal in their labor/capital ratios, I wrote an article in the Catholic @commonwealmag michael-hudson.com/2026/10/my-reaction-to-the-newest-nobe… @IwoAugustynski @EconomicReader @nikodem_szew
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hector Wetherell McNeill
@HectorWMcNeill
ERRORS IN ECONOMICS Part 2
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen has posted a video pointing out misleading content in taught economics.
It covers an amazing breadth of relevant issues but sometimes I think the explanations are too truncated
in a valid attempt to create what is a short & sharp presentation.
My previous post, under the same title, explained how I was very fortunate in receiving instruction and applied experience that made much of what Steve points out evident as far back as 1963 as a result of the down-to-earth and applied nature of economics instruction at the Cambridge Universury School of Agriculture.
One area I studied later, in considerable detail in 1968, at the Stanford School of Engineering, to the extent of developing my own alternative model applying different formulae - see below - was the so-called Cobb-Douglas Model (CDM) first demonstrated in 1928 but based on work developed even earlier by other economists.
By the time I had become involved I had already benefitted from Ag School instruction and work by the economist Nicholas Kaldor which had already defined "technology" in terms of a capital/labour ratio, (e.g. capital- or labour-intensive technology) resulting in a production function consisting of variable INPUTS converted into OUTPUTS by the technology concerned.
Wassily Leontief based his impressive USA Input/Output model on this approach in 1936; he was a sort of hero amongst us agronomists and agricultural economists at the time (early 1960s) because of the clarity of his exposition considered to be a "common sense approach".
However, my own model and that of the original CDM was of interest because they were able to demostrare a well known relationship between inputs and outputs.
So, by maintaining all inputs at a fixed absolute value and increasing the input of any single input, would demonstrate diminishing marginal returns in terms of the output response to that input.
By considering the Cobb-Douglas labour/capital ratios as the current "technology" one is NOT assuming capital, energy and labour to be substitutable because to secure output technology requires variable inputs of which energy is but one (now increasingly) important factor.
Steve suggests that the CDM assumes that the inputs of Capital (equipment), Labour and Energy were assumed to be interchangeable.
This might be the case if one bases this on the separate theoretical analysis of isoquants.
This concept was floated by von Thunen 200 years ago in his "Isolated State" in 1826 but more detailed in the 1850 edition in relation to the fascinating subject of agricultural production intensity and location with respect to market centres.
But such an assumption applied to a set and established technology makes no sense because it is difficult to change the labour/capital ratio which has been locked into place by the evolution of relative prices of labour and capital and technological advance.
youtu.be/M1odc6itzyk -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It's pivotal to the disaster that the Eurozone has been for Europe, and the core source of the discontent behind the youth rebellion across Europe today.
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
The algorithm now shows me a lot of the German economists' pearl clutching at @IsabellaMWeber price controls and dear God, how I've underestimated the dark powers of ordoliberalism.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
French Authorities Insist It’s Not a Riot. “It Can Only Be Called a Riot if It’s From France’s Riôt Region, Otherwise It’s Sparkling Social Discontent” theshovel.com.au/2026/10/19/french-riot-sparkling-social-…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
Steve Keen, 12–19 Oct 2026
Book: How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism (Polity) still forthcoming. No new edition or Amazon listing.
Serialised chapters (paywalled after free teaser):
• “Of Mathematics, mathiness, mythematics, and mathemagics”, Ch. 20, 11 Oct. profstevekeen.substack.com/p/of-mathematics-mathiness-myt… Mechanism: neoclassical equilibrium modelling treated as immature (Blatt 1983); Romer’s “mathiness” applies maths to imaginary shocks (aether, phlogiston, trolls, gremlins). Definitions-based dynamics produce Goodwin-type cycles, not equilibrium. Description is the critique of mathematical practice; prescription (use proper dynamics) is separate. Flag: prior chapter numbering inconsistency noted earlier.
• “System Dynamics”, Ch. 21, 16 Oct. profstevekeen.substack.com/p/system-dynamics Mechanism: system-dynamics flowcharts generate identical behaviour to accounting-identity models; adding an investment function and bank credit (endogenous money) when investment exceeds profits yields Minsky-type cycles and rising banker share of income as private debt/GDP rises. Description of model construction and emergent dynamics; no separate prescription stated.
Posts/podcasts:
• “The inequality of fear and greed”, 15 Oct (Debunking Economics podcast, paid). profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-inequality-of-fear-and-g… Mechanism: private debt and financial bubbles. Description of how debt and policy reward the top while workers/renters bear more risk.
• “The Nobel Prize in False Assumptions”, 19 Oct (podcast, paid). profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-nobel-prize-in-false-ass… Mechanism: banks, private debt, and equilibrium-plus-external-shocks models. Description of why such models struggle with financial crises.
Interviews/talks:
• Switzer Show/Podcast, 11–12 Oct: “why we’re ‘screwed next year’” via Strait of Hormuz. www.youtube.com/watch?v=o1fZD0E8Dw8 Mechanism: energy-supply disruption, endogenous money (deficits create private-sector deposits), climate models that omit energy in production. Description of recession risk, energy-driven inflation, and why rate hikes cannot fix it; prescription (higher deficits, food-production investment) is separate. Flag: near-term “next year” forecast is contingent on Hormuz, not a tested date; energy and debt themes are longstanding.
• YouTube, 18 Oct: “What’s Coming Is Worse Than the Great Depression”. www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9T1RTW9N9A Mechanism: private debt (over-indebtedness → debt-deflation / Fisher’s paradox). Description of 1920s–33 parallels and why mainstream accounts fail; prescription of government spending to stop collapse is separate. Flag: core private-debt and Great Depression argument is recycled from earlier work.
Tools: No Ravel or Minsky release this week.
X activity (@ProfSteveKeen) was routine replies only. No other notable dated interviews or talks.
next check next Monday. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
Weekly Heterodox Newsdesk —
week ending 19 October 2026,
Issue 08
1 / frame
Not the index.
Who wrote the claim.
What the prize still books off.
Whose diesel the deal still prices.
Whose house the common good still has to name.
Earth is on the ledger.
Curator: Neil.
2 / debt — who created the claim, who is supposed to pay
Hudson, 14 Oct: the 2026 prize to Hall and Woodford revives the fifty-year objection. Economics keeps rewarding theories that overlook the power of creditors. Debt service has risen every recovery since WWII and cuts the consumption function they model without it. Hall’s flat tax protects rentier income. Stabilisation is consonant with deindustrialisation and austerity. Discontinue the prize.
michael-hudson.com/2026/10/my-reaction-to-the-newest-nobe…
Keen, 19 Oct: Debunking Economics podcast “The Nobel Prize in False Assumptions.” Models that set central-bank policy underplay banks, private debt and financial crises. Equilibrium and external shocks still cannot explain the GFC. (Full episode paywalled after teaser.)
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-nobel-prize-in-false-ass…
Do not flatten. One is the creditor power and the rent claim. One is the accounting identity and the bank that writes the deposit. Timing is an estimate.
3 / debt — euro and dollar
Varoufakis, 13–14 Oct, Econoclasts: Trump’s Russian diesel deal unveiled the collapse of Western unity. France’s €3.6tn debt is a structurally inevitable flaw of the euro, not fiscal incompetence. Mélenchon’s swap of the ~€600bn already held by the Banque de France into perpetuals retires the absurdity of one arm of the state borrowing from another; fiscal space opens for schools and investment. Centrists call the mechanism “nonsense.”
www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/sensible-melenchon-f…
Hudson, 17 Oct with Kathleen Tyson: getting paid without the dollar. Gold settles imbalances; oil and diesel are the post-gold asset. Confiscation of reserves accelerates multipolar settlement and bilateral barter. No new IMF. Creditors cannot be the floor.
michael-hudson.com/2026/10/getting-paid-without-the-dollar/
4 / energy / materials — what the growth number ate
Keen, 11–12 Oct Switzer: “we’re going to be screwed next year, courtesy of the Strait of Hormuz.” Stocks are running down. Energy and fertiliser remain the throughput the production function still books as residual or shock. A government deficit creates the money; a rate rise does not reopen the strait.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=o1fZD0E8Dw8
Varoufakis the same week: the diesel deal prices the energy the models treat as external.
5 / floor — housing, a state that names public purpose
Mazzucato, 11 Oct, El País: housing is a human right and the foundation for everything else, not merely “affordable.” The habit is to plug holes the private sector creates (the claimed $7tn SDG shortfall). The alternative is to shape the market ex ante — conditions on developers, a social-housing stock large enough to set terms (Vienna). Predistribution, common-good compass, Global Council. 13 Oct: public investment is fiscally responsible. Naming the mission does not write the claim if the debt rules and interest-rate alibis remain.
english.elpais.com/economy-and-business/2026-10-11/marian…
www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/public-investment-is…
6 / question
If the prize still overlooks the debt service that erodes the wage, and the diesel still sets the price the model treats as shock, who is authorised to write the next claim — and against whose creditors, whose strait, whose house, whose harvest?
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
In the latest episode of The Econoclasts, Wolfgang and I show how Trump’s Russian diesel deal unveiled the collapse of Western unity. We also debunk the myth of French fiscal incompetence, arguing instead that France’s €3.6 trillion debt crisis is a structurally inevitable flaw of the euro. www.youtube.com/watch?v=wrHNNpoG8ZY
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
You don't need economic growth to pay for public services, public goods and public investment. You need your own currency (shared with other countries, like in the EMU, or not) and no constraints (fiscal rules and debt brakes) - plus a political class willing to serve citizens.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I want to see a libertarian society where every road is privately owned, every intersection has a toll booth, and every fire department negotiates prices while your fucking house burns down.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hector Wetherell McNeill
@HectorWMcNeill
ERRORS IN ECONOMICS
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen has posted a video pointing out misleading content in taught economics.
Certainly what Steve points at was taught at both the Faculty of Economics at Cambridge and Department of Economics at Stanford.
The outstanding exception was Nicholas Kaldor at Cambridge who had pioneered the analysis of technical change in the economy since 1932 with more detailed models in the late 1950s concluding, by the time I was able to attend his lectures, that there was no such thing as equilibrium.
Fortunately I received my first economics instruction, starting in 1963, at the School of Agriculture at Cambridge Uni.
A bunch of very young enthusiastic economics lecturers in fact pointed out most of what Steve has covered or they became very apparent to us during the course of our having to apply operations research logic to the planning of operational farms in East Anglia in the UK.
The only item not really broached was the credit/debt issue.
There is however another point on which Steve, no doubt, can add thoughts and this was the fact that an accountant gravely advised us to review farm accounts before attempting to plan next year's allocation to maximise the aggregate gross margin.
His reasoning was that double entry provided a true account of the situation of a farm.
We duly started off reading through these but I found that after about perhaps 2 months I wasn't looking at the accounts because I saw no cross relationship between them and the dynamic reiterative process of farm planning.
When I asked my fellow student colleagues about this, all of them admitted that they also were no longer referring to the accounts.
Raising this with the accountant he became somewhat frustrated but he couldn't present a coherent justification for us inspecting a static representation prepared for the tax authorities but he kept repeating the importance of double entry book keeping.
We all discounted this on a similar basis because once nominal funds are assigned to the payment of an input at the planning and implementation stages that value can rise or fall depending upon the end of season results (return) - often determined by the weather.
Yes credit=debt ... but
When it comes to macroeconomic cash flow projections this issue becomes more apparent.
Steve in his Ravel demos emphasises double entry but his dynamic analysis seldom accounts for the change in purchasing power of funds appearing in those dynamic graphs and which varies with changes in prices linked to productivity.
Because productivity is measured by most international and national organizations based on just one of the USA Bureau of Labor Statstics (BLS) definitions as value-added or GDP divided by total labour hours input.
This provides no information on income distribution, price changes, the purchasing power of the currency or real income.
As a result it is not possible to calculate the Residual Monetary Value Transform or real growth in the form of the quantitative change in aggregate purchasing power compared with the nominal GDP.
If I might add to Steve's impressive list of mistakes or misrepresentations in economics, the notion that growth can be measured by the rise in the size of the GDP, or "size of the pie" or "more money to go around" logic is simply not the case and the BLS definition of productivity only adds to the confusion.
No wonder "productivuty" in the UK has been relegated to the status of a "puzzle".
Real growth arises from a productivity that lowers unit costs to facilitate a reduction in unit prices at a profit, resulting in a rise in consumer (B2C, B2B & B2G) purchasing power or real incomes.
Therefore a definition of productivity that remains coherent with this definition of growth is the Price Performance Ratio (PPR) that compares the response of unit output prices (dUP) to the change in aggregate unit costs (dAUC) or PPR = dUP/dAUC
youtu.be/M1odc6itzyk -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill Kruse
@billkruse
The Nobel Prize in False Assumptions, by @ProfSteveKeen open.substack.com/pub/profstevekeen/p/the-nobel-prize-in-…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
really Jason?
all the mainstream economists I hear, & the all of the msm commentariat, sing from the same songsheet: you’re all working from the same “fatally flawed” DGSE model with all of its fundamentally wrong axioms & assumptions.
& all got the wrong policy prescriptions -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
fiat money
@fiat_money
orthodox economics exists and gets things wrong
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sony Thăng
@nxt888
The storming of the Bastille was vandalism.
Literally. They tore down a building.
They killed people. They paraded severed heads on pikes through the streets of Paris.
By any contemporary law in any Western country today, the participants would have been prosecuted.
And from it came the Declaration of the Rights of Man, the document whose principles are now treated as the bedrock of the very civilization you are defending.
So I’ll ask you directly:
At what point did the vandalism become force?
At what point did the thugs become founders?
Because the transformation happened.
It happens in every revolution that succeeds.
And it never happens for the ones that fail or the ones that threaten the wrong people.
That’s not a distinction between force and vandalism.
That’s a distinction between winners and losers dressed up as a moral category.
Demetrios Kogas
@DemetriosKogas
You mix up force and violence in history with vandalism by thugs.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
EconomicsAotearoa
@economicsNZ
“The French rioters may not all know this, but they are rioting against the fiscal framework of the Eurozone and…25 years of failure. We suggested a reform which would preserve the Euro but abandon the failed framework when we were in…”
www.facebook.com/share/p/1EyvrRouu3/ -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
OK, this is a revelation. The brilliant Yes Minister “don’t care who it is add kind as she’s got big tits” newspaper skit was lifted from Dave Allen!
Cameron Yarde Jnr
@CameronYardeJnr
50 years ago, Dave Allen told a joke about newspaper readers in 1976, it would become more famous 11 years after this on Yes, Prime Minister in 1987.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Actually, we could merge them with Theology Departments.
Richard Field
@tyillc
Could we also close down the Economics departments at the same time ...
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Their Old Testament book would be Marshall’s, and their New Testament, Samuelson’s. Purgatory is exogenous shocks, and Heaven is Equilibrium.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Melodies & Masterpieces
@SVG__Collection
100 years ago today, Chuck Berry was born.
Guitarist and songwriter who shaped rock and roll out of country, blues and R&B. Story songs, a double-stop guitar style, and a body of work that became the template.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
We never did the models are nonsense it’s much worse than any of the models contemplate
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Metin Tetik
@tetikmetin
DSGE zaten SFC ise, ne gerek var o zaman SFC'ye? Ama sanırım mevzu muhasebe bilenler vs. bilmeyenler kavgası değil her şey eninde sonunda rasyonel bir dengeye gelir felsefesi üzerine.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ahhh!! I never understood what that was all about. Every Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model is stock-flow consistent by construction. One can argue about the equilibrium concept, but material balance conditions hold in every period.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Stock flow consistent
I know, it doesn't say much, but that's the name they use. 😅 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
#Anonymous
@TheStripesGirl
You might want to listen.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Beautiful mature song from a 17-year old Paul McCartney. 🙏🏽
The Beatles Legacy
@TheBeatlesPMcC
18 octobre 1964, les Beatles peaufinent l'album "Beatles For Sale", la maison de disques EMI leur met la pression pour sortir le disque au plus vite. Pour gagner du temps, Paul McCartney déterre une composition datant de 1959, écrite alors qu'il n'avait que 17 ans. Un morceau que le groupe jouait déjà à ses débuts en concert entre Liverpool et Hambourg.
Devenue la pépite nostalgique et charmante de l'album, cette chanson occupe une place particulière chez les passionnés des Beatles. McCartney la réinterprétera donc régulièrement sur scène durant les années 2000.
"I'll Follow The Sun", Paul McCartney, Olympia Paris 2007.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D. Wolff
@profwolff
#wolffbites: French protests against cuts in public services spread to Portugal and Italy, as earlier to Belgium. Italy's gov't learns nothing, hits protesters with police, solving nothing, provoking more protests.
www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/18/lisbon-milan-protes… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
News to Remember
@allchronology
He didn’t hold back. 🇦🇺💬
From across the ocean, this Australian gives a raw, unfiltered look at modern America. It’s a perspective most people are too afraid to say out loud, but it impacts all of us, no matter where we live.
This is a global wake-up call.
#usa #usapolitics #americancultureThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jay Zi
@Jes912
É piú violento rompere una vetrina o sfasciare il servizio sanitario nazionale? É piú violento bruciare un cassonetto o pagare un full time 600 euro? É piú violento lanciare un fumogeno o mandare i ragazzi in scuole con tetti pericolanti?
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Brilliant.
Brian Krassenstein
@krassenstein
OMFG! This response from @AbdulElSayed to a completely bigoted question is probably the best thing I’ve heard all year.
Every bigot in America needs to listen to this three times.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Very well said. And keeping his cool despite provocations.
Cllr Martin Abrams
@Martin_Abrams
Huge credit to Zack Polanski for an excellent @bbclaurak interview in the face of hostility and constant interruptions.
So interesting how Laura Kuensberg's interview style changed from softball with Yvette Cooper to hostile with Zack. #bbclaurak -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Shaiel Ben-Ephraim
@academic_la
Malignant and ignorant actors are trying to turn what is happening in France into an immigration or Islam issue. But these are demonstrations over the cost of living and lack of future prospects of a generation that has been abandoned by the government. And there is nothing more French than rioting and demonstrating. It is as French as croissants. Stop using this to advance your racist agenda.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Philip Pilkington
@philippilk
Exactly. Rightoids who solely focus on immigration are delusional. Europe is undergoing an enormous economic crisis that will only get worse. We are seeing only the first signs of that. Strap in. The continent is going to become ungovernable. Then its leaders will go to war. 🇪🇺📉
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇪🇺 Protests and riots are ERUPTING across Europe amid anger over living costs, housing, and public services...
Here’s a quick breakdown:
🇫🇷 France: Mass protests over living costs and public services escalated into looting, arson, and RIOTS, with more than 1,800 arrests reported.
🇧🇪 Belgium: Student protests over education reforms turned violent, with police deploying tear gas and water cannons.
🇮🇹 Italy: Cost-of-living demonstrations in Milan and Bologna escalated into clashes, fires, and property damage.
🇪🇸 Spain: Housing protests reflect growing anger over soaring rents, unaffordable homes, and evictions.
🇵🇹 Portugal: Tens of thousands reportedly marched in Lisbon over stagnant wages and rising housing costs.
🇦🇱 Albania: Student-led protests in Tirana rallied against corruption, unemployment, and education, with clashes reported.
Europe is ON FIRE right now... 🔥🔥🔥 (literally)
Source: CNN, Le Monde, Al Jazeera, The Guardian, NYT / Writers: Marie, Michael -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
BTW this guy has the sole authority to commence the Amendment 25 Section 4 process to remove an incompetent President. The odds of him doing it? Below zero.
There is no effective Constitution method to remove @realDonaldTrump.
Clash Report
@clashreport
JD Vance:
And I'm telling you that while, yes, DC is a corrupt town, Donald Trump, I have not seen a single shred of evidence that he participates in that corruption.
You can make all kinds of criticisms of our policies and decisions, but I've not once seen evidence that Donald Trump has enriched himself.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
@claraemattei
Hi friends,
I will be in Spain next week to present my book that has just gotten translated there.
capitanswing.com/catalogo/escapar-del-capitalismo/
here are all the places I will be at, in case you want to reach me to one of them!
www.claramattei.com/events -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kuba 🇵🇱🇵🇸
@anietotylkoja
The greatest victory of the modern ruling class is convincing the public that rebellion, resistance, and protest are the hallmarks of barbarism, while submission, obedience, and humility are the virtues of civilized societies
Whereas the truth is exactly the opposite -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
The Guardian 12 years ago actually carried an article stating that we were being dragged into war in #ukraine. So why have so many liberals fallen for the NATO propaganda?
Wake up, people, before it's too late!
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/13/ukraine-us-…
Russell Dobular
@russelldobular
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
1. THE MOST IMPORTANT FACTS IN THE HISTORY OF THE WORLD
1. We are at 1.5C
2. Temperatures rose by 0.4C in the last decade
3. We will therefore hit 2C around 2036/2037
4. At 2C we will trigger the earth's carbon feedback systems and so further temperature increases will be unstoppable and billions of people will die as we pass 3C. @4billiondead
There is only one way out - revolutions to force governments to create legally binding national assemblies made up of ordinary citizens selected randomly from the population to consider these facts and decide on policies to slash emissions to zero, and to give political legitimacy to these decisions by them having been made "by the people" - ie in the true sense of REAL DEMOCRACY.
Leon Simons 🌍
@LeonSimons8
Vindication of Hansen et al.:
"The rate of global warming appears to have accelerated, rising from ∼0.05°C/decade between 1880 and 1970 to ∼0.19°C/decade between 1970 and 2010, and finally to ∼0.36°C/decade between 2010 and 2024
[...]
The acceleration may be partly related to reductions in aerosol pollutants that previously masked a portion of greenhouse gas warming (@DrJamesEHansen et al. 2025)."
Rectifications by media and certain vociferous scientific voices are in order. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Field
@tyillc
France highlights the problem of not issuing bonds in your own currency ... UK and US can issue more debt to pay their promises ... France and the other members of the EU cannot ...
John Arnold
@johnarnold
If the unrest in France is a reflection that aging populations and tightening fiscal constraints make it increasingly difficult for Western governments to meet their promises to and expectations of their citizens, then France is just the beginning.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What Would Ronny Do? scottritter.substack.com/p/what-would-ronny-do?r=nle2 @RealScottRitter gives his personal and philosophical explanation for why Russia is not the “Evil Empire”, and why those who use Reagan’s words to justify animosity to Russia are abusing Reagan’s conservatism.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
A quick note - @RichardJMurphy is right that the Mont Pelerin Society was the inauguration of neoliberalism's very successful post-WWII ideological machine. However, the ideas were developed in the 1920s, advocates were heavily funded by American trusts and their first meeting was in Paris in 1938. At first, more moderate speakers advocated a central role for governments as market regulators, but by the end it was obvious that the Mises-type extremists were to become a major influence.
The takeaway resolutions were to hand over economic management to 'market forces' with minimal regulation and sever the potentially democratic relation between the majority and the state. The promises of Thiel, Yarvin, Karp et al. to crush the very idea of democracy and replace it with technofeudal control is a frantic last-ditch attempt to fulfil that second resolution on a new landscape as the neoliberal project collapses. www.academia.edu/82642613/The_Walter_Lippmann_Colloquium_…
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
The French riots indicate that neoliberalism is a total failure for the majority wherever it reigns. The creditor/business class is unfit for purpose and must be ejected from the political sphere. But what is neoliberalism? @RichardJMurphy explains. youtu.be/_8yCsQCtPHg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
#fotw Daily Post 17
At peak ice age, so much water was locked up in the ice sheets that a land area bigger than India, Canada and the US combined was exposed — its name Aquaterra
The sea redrew the world map before. It's about to do so again
Pls share + tag 2
#fateoftheworld -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oktay Özden
@oktayozdn
I wonder what makes Roger Farmer think DSGE models are stock-flow consistent in the same way as SFC models. This figure shows the flow consistency of my UK SFC model. But what about DSGE models with just 10–15 equations? Surely they do exactly the same thing, right?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ahhh!! I never understood what that was all about. Every Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model is stock-flow consistent by construction. One can argue about the equilibrium concept, but material balance conditions hold in every period.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Stock flow consistent
I know, it doesn't say much, but that's the name they use. 😅 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
The small detail is ontological: general equilibrium closes the system through assumptions, while post-Keynesian SFC models allow us to study a monetary, historical, open economy shaped by uncertainty and institutions. But yes, the accounts balance in both. Mystery solved! 🙃
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ahhh!! I never understood what that was all about. Every Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model is stock-flow consistent by construction. One can argue about the equilibrium concept, but material balance conditions hold in every period.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Stock flow consistent
I know, it doesn't say much, but that's the name they use. 😅 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oktay Özden
@oktayozdn
I plan to teach fully Post-Keynesian macroeconomics, putting aside Blanchard's garbage IS-LM analysis.
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
My Intellectual Journey to Post-Keynesian Economics:
1. First, you study neoclassical macroeconomics at university and master its theoretical framework.
2. Then you try to apply what you’ve learned to explain real-world economic processes — and fail spectacularly. The theory exists in one world, economic reality in another.
3. Next, you turn to Marxism. Its intellectual depth, historical perspective, and literary elegance are compelling, but attempts to directly connect its theoretical categories to the System of National Accounts and the modern monetary and financial system prove rather difficult.
4. After years of searching, you finally discover Post-Keynesian economics, particularly stock-flow consistent models, where production, income, expenditure, debt, and financial assets finally come together within a coherent, macroeconomically consistent framework. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
My Intellectual Journey to Post-Keynesian Economics:
1. First, you study neoclassical macroeconomics at university and master its theoretical framework.
2. Then you try to apply what you’ve learned to explain real-world economic processes — and fail spectacularly. The theory exists in one world, economic reality in another.
3. Next, you turn to Marxism. Its intellectual depth, historical perspective, and literary elegance are compelling, but attempts to directly connect its theoretical categories to the System of National Accounts and the modern monetary and financial system prove rather difficult.
4. After years of searching, you finally discover Post-Keynesian economics, particularly stock-flow consistent models, where production, income, expenditure, debt, and financial assets finally come together within a coherent, macroeconomically consistent framework. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
sammy
@_itzsammy
Funny how everyone angry about this skipped the second qualifier. 'Opposing students AND siding with the ruling class.' Both parts. Read it again.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tarric Brooker aka Avid Commentator 🇦🇺
@AvidCommentator
Before the Great Depression, the Nazi party were a meme, the butt of jokes and ridicule, never getting above mid-single digits at elections.
Less than four years later Hitler was Chancellor.
This is part of why the current strategy by policymakers across too much of the West is so dangerous.
A country doesn't need to have a depression or even a recession for people to get economically and socially left behind, in fact, in some ways seeing others powering ahead while some individuals fall behind can be just as bad for a society's cohesion.
Throw in an actual recession or protracted financial crisis, driven by something like a sustained energy shock, and you have the recipe for the rise of extremism and a collapse of support for the status quo.
This sort of scenario was always going to be challenging to confront, but from the position of multi-decade failure driven weakness much of the West finds itself in, it would be even harder.
People should have listened to the warnings when they had the chance. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Why KYSID? A Different Macroeconomic Closure
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alec Torelli | Poker & Decision Making
@AlecTorelli
I see the protests in France are trending.
Since I just spent 10 days there during the heart of them, I figured I'd chime in with what's actually going on.
The news and clickbait accounts on X will show you the outlier events: burning buildings, raging violence and everything that triggers you.
I was in the heart of Aix en Provence during the biggest protest day and filmed the center where it was happening. (See below)
This is right the University, across from the church, dead center of town.
The students are dancing, singing, kicking soccer balls and have comically barricaded the entrance doors to force the school to close.
I visited many cities in France during the protest period, and saw zero violence or malpractice of any kind.
More broadly, I spent more than a month this year in France across 3 trips and 10+ cities, including Paris, Bordeaux, Aix en Provence, Nice, Antibes, Biarritz, and others, and it's incredibly safe, charming, peaceful and beautiful.
Every city I visited is nicer than almost every American city, and there's zero comparison.
So much that it wouldn't even be insulting to France to try, because nobody who has spent significant time in both countries would take this comparison seriously.
I spoke with the students at length about their views. I also spoke with waiters, drivers, merchants, staff and whoever.
They were all civil, well articulated and genuinely wanted to see change.
We can disagree about their reasoning, logic or whatever, and it's true that France has fiscal problems, but to chalk up the France protests to raging extremist violence from "pick your favorite group to blame", is a laughable misrepresentation of what's actually going on.
If you exclusively watch the news and believe the top 1% extreme situations, you have likely been psyoped.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
Accounting balance is not the same as equilibrium.
There is no such thing as equilibrium as
-the economy consists of plenty of conflicts
-supply and demand are never equalised since production takes time, firms produce more and before goods are demanded- not at the time demanded
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ahhh!! I never understood what that was all about. Every Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model is stock-flow consistent by construction. One can argue about the equilibrium concept, but material balance conditions hold in every period.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Stock flow consistent
I know, it doesn't say much, but that's the name they use. 😅 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
The French riots indicate that neoliberalism is a total failure for the majority wherever it reigns. The creditor/business class is unfit for purpose and must be ejected from the political sphere. But what is neoliberalism? @RichardJMurphy explains. youtu.be/_8yCsQCtPHg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
1/ In Jul 1988 the Basel Committee published capital rules giving home loans a 50% risk weight and company loans 100%. With an 8% minimum, banks needed $4 per $100 lent on a house and $8 per $100 lent to a firm: twice the capital.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tarric Brooker aka Avid Commentator 🇦🇺
@AvidCommentator
I hope people are watching what is going on France.
When people tell you that your country is illegitimate and that they want to burn it all down, listen to them and then act accordingly.
They are doing you a great favour by telling you the unvarnished truth. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
We can rebuild buildings, repair streets and replace burnt cars. We cannot give back the years lost to people denied opportunities. Riots deserve scrutiny, but so do their material roots. Behind the images of destruction lies another contrast: private affluence, public squalor
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
The media show burning cars and smashed windows. Rarely the lives damaged by years of insecurity and public neglect. Material destruction matters. But reducing unrest to its most visible expressions conceals the deeper landscape: private affluence amid public squalor
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
I used to be a neoclassical economist. Then I studied sectoral balances, endogenous money and monetary institutions. I discovered MMT and stopped confusing models in a vacuum with how capitalism actually works as a monetary production economy. Apparently, that makes me far-left
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
I was a polite guy when I was an undergraduate, but became foul-mouthed after having got to know the post-Keynesian approach and realized that mainstream economics, which dismissed all pro-welfare solutions as impossible, was full of lies.
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
I used to be a neoclassical economist. Then I studied sectoral balances, endogenous money and monetary institutions. I discovered MMT and stopped confusing models in a vacuum with how capitalism actually works as a monetary production economy. Apparently, that makes me far-left
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
Michael Hudson and Kathleen Tyson discuss gold, trade settlement and the practical difficulties of building alternatives to the dollar.
@Graeber_social
michael-hudson.com/2026/10/getting-paid-without-the-dollar/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
fiat money
@fiat_money
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eric Tymoigne
@tymoignee
Kindleberger is correct of course. Minsky’s analysis does not rely on irrationality and stupidity: financial instability comes, among other things, from the internal logic of capitalist enterprise.
Policy Tensor
@policytensor
Kindleberger to Bernanke, 1982, found by Mehrling. Shared by Tooze. Tweeted by Matt Klein. :)
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
Lovely tribute to Perry Mehrling from @adam_tooze
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-478-money-and-empire-for
(worth reading it, particularly the ending, while considering that Michael Woodford just won the Nobel for a model of the economy that explicitly has no money in it at all) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Antoine Léaument 🇫🇷
@ALeaument
Marrée humaine à Paris pour ce #17octobre dans le calme et la bonne humeur.
Faites tourner ces images que les médias ne veulent pas montrer ! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
clarissa com a
@sgtpimentinha
os beatles se recusavam a tocar para plateias segregadas, apoiavam o movimento BLM, george fez o primeiro show beneficente da história, john perdeu a vida se posicionando contra causas totalitárias e eu ainda tive o desprazer de ver gente dizendo que eles seriam de direita
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Europe has caved to the fossil lobbies because it cannot get its act together for state-driven structural transformation.
this is an admission of defeat to Made in China 2025 industrial policy.
it is also terrible climate policy.
Clash Report
@clashreport
Germany's Chancellor Merz:
Germany and France reached an understanding on future policy toward the automotive industry.
To put it very simply: The ban on combustion engines is now history. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Dans Paris, le commandement aberrant a ouvert la porte au chaos. Les chefs ne savent plus que faire, la troupe a peur et se déchaîne.
Je ne sais pas qui entendra ma voix dans de telles circonstances, mais mon message est clair : ceux qui partagent notre combat n'ont rien à faire dans le pillage, le saccage.
Quelles que soient les responsabilités du pouvoir et de ses incompétents et leurs violences, nous devons refuser de participer à des actions sans signification politique et contraire à nos méthodes. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Plein de monde partout, calme et joyeux partout quand les policiers ne sont pas là. Des images que vous ne verrez pas dans l'officialité médiatique.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sihame Assbague
@s_assbague
Faut voir Paris là. T’es dans une foule qui scande “on a guillotiné un roi, on peut recommencer”, tu tournes à gauche, y a des groupes en train de barricader une rue & de faire reculer la police, tu tournes à droite, y a un cortège avec 20 drapeaux 🇵🇸 qui arrive à toute vitesse.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇺🇸Lionel🇺🇸
@LionelMedia
Robert Mitchum was a bona fide Hollywood 100% 18K tough guy bad ass. Serious.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Robert Parenteau
@MacroEdge1
8 decades later, central bank macro guys are just beginning to figure out some of the reasons JM Keynes advocated & designed capital market controls for the Bretton Woods int'l monetary system. You want fries with that shake?
Dallas Fed
@DallasFed
New analysis of exchange rates and prices shows that fluctuations in exchange rates are largely driven by movements in financial markets rather than changes to monetary policy, and are largely disconnected from other prices in the economy. www.dallasfed.org/research/economics/2026/1015
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Because, as Kalecki reportedly put it, economics is “the science of confusing stocks with flows.”
Godley and Lavoie teach economists how to stop doing exactly that.
Stock-flow consistency should be the foundation of macroeconomics. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
Steve's video proving economlcs is not a science will mean a lot of what nations do when they budget is based on....well...shit.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Certainly not, but this is a "last straw" NOBBLE PRIZE IN ECONOMICS for me. They rewrote history, as if they tamed the GFC, and their "scientific documents" prove that economics is not a science, but a religion. I'm working on a video to give the ideologues the hell they deserve
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Mario Draghi: “France is the victim of its own fiscal profligacy.”
A familiar morality tale. France borrows in a currency it cannot issue. The real issue is not simply fiscal discipline, but the institutional architecture of the eurozone itself. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
My Reaction To The Newest Nobel Economics Prize Travesty michael-hudson.com/2026/10/my-reaction-to-the-newest-nobe… by Michael Hudson
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Certainly not, but this is a "last straw" NOBBLE PRIZE IN ECONOMICS for me. They rewrote history, as if they tamed the GFC, and their "scientific documents" prove that economics is not a science, but a religion. I'm working on a video to give the ideologues the hell they deserve
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How lovely a description.
Sasha
@servingcapreal
actually according to Marx’s daughter he was “bubbling over with fun” and “the gayest person who ever lived”
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lars P Syll
@LarsPSyll
The Microfoundations Delusion larspsyll.wordpress.com/2026/10/17/the-microfoundations-d… via @LarsSyll
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Protests sweep Europe. Eurozone states use a currency they cannot individually issue, face restrictive fiscal rules and lack a Treasury coordinated with the ECB. Social needs go unmet while resources lie idle. Europe disciplines public spending, not private rents. By design
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
adameran
@adameran2
The Sonnenschein–Mantel–Debreu theorem proved micro is not suitable as a foundation for macroeconomics (and then promptly avoided this conclusion in their subsequent writing...typical economists). The paradox of thrift also contradicts micro foundations for macroeconomics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
nancy
@langwiser
Economic models have become useless, just intellectual exercises for bored PhD’s
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many ‘shocks’ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, “science progresses one funeral at a time”. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sama Hoole
@SamaHoole
Settled science has a pattern, and it is the same man every time: a committee with the funding, and one awkward person they laughed at.
It was settled that stomach ulcers came from stress. In 1984 an Australian registrar drank a flask of the bacteria, gave himself gastritis, and took the Nobel Prize in 2005.
It was settled that the continents did not move. The weatherman who said they did was mocked for 20 years, froze to death on the Greenland ice in 1930, and was proved right in the 1960s.
It was settled that cutting the front off a brain cured madness. It won the Nobel Prize in 1949. Forty thousand Americans were lobotomised before anyone was allowed to say it did not.
It was settled that a heart attack meant six weeks flat on your back. Two Boston cardiologists sat their patients in an armchair in 1952, the clots stopped, and the deaths halved.
It was settled that a gentleman's hands could not carry disease. The Hungarian doctor who made his students wash them cut deaths on his ward from 18% to 2%, was driven out, and died in an asylum.
It was settled that cigarettes were fine. More doctors smoked Camels than any other brand, said the advert in 1949. Two British epidemiologists published the lung cancer numbers the next year and were ignored for a decade.
It was settled that margarine was better than butter. The Illinois chemist who found the trans fats in it in 1957 was dismissed for 50 years, watched them banned in 2015, and died at 102.
It was settled that eggs raised your cholesterol. Forty years of advice was removed from the guidelines in 2015 without a word of apology.
It was settled that babies sleep on their fronts. The advice ran from 1956 to 1991, and the researchers who finally counted estimated 60,000 cot deaths that need not have happened.
Nine settled positions. Each one held by the people with the committees, the journals and the word science.
Each one broken by one person with the evidence and a bad reputation.
Settled is the word a committee uses for the moment it would prefer you stopped checking. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hilliard MacBeth
@hmacbe
economists win prize for successfully ignoring the real world in their models
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And these models warned of the Global Financial Crisis before it happened.
Only joking: in these models, what happened in the real world is impossible.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The 2026 Nobel Prize in Economics: Brilliant or Bullsh*t? | LIVE Q&A | LIVE Q&A x.com/i/broadcasts/1dKrPrjklnlJX
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Field
@tyillc
Pointed out before the Great Financial Crisis not only did the dominant economic theories have no place for banks, but they also missed the role of #transparency in the financial system.
Of course, this hasn't stopped the Priesthood of the Economic PhDs from pushing forward really destructive policy responses to a financial crisis.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
That’s a question for the philosophy of science. My friend Axel Leijonhufvud had a metaphor of science as a tree with many branches. Each branch represents an alternative possible path along which the subject might progress.
In the experimental sciences, false approaches are quickly discovered by experiment and those branches are trimmed. Progress appears linear.
In non experimental sciences the discipline can adopt approaches that are ultimately shown to be false but which persist for long periods of time. Ultimately it takes a large natural experiment like the Great Depression or the Stagflation of the 1970s to cause a course correction.
In the period between natural experiments, when multiple theories appear equally viable, the science is governed by gatekeepers who edit top journals and are educated at a small group of elite institutions. These gatekeepers provide a filter on acceptable discourse. This institutional structure has its benefits since, if it is difficult to empirically distinguish alternative theories, it would be highly disruptive if every fresh graduate student were to branch out in an entirely new direction. But the filtering out of new ideas can also cause the exiting corpus of thought to become sclerotic.
Influential schools of thought, like NK economics, are practiced by generations of students who acquire human capital and have an incentive not to rock the boat. Prestigious awards like the Nobel Prize and the John Bates Clarke Award provide incentives to color within the lines and these incentives are strongest when widely recognized deserving recipients have not yet been recognized. Elite universities maintain active offices whose goal is to lobby the Nobel committee on behalf of their own professoriate.
I have never met a brilliant young academic who did not aspire to be recognized as a Nobel Laureate: Through that mechanism prestigious awards offer important incentives to scientific excellence. But the prizes themselves also act as brakes on progress since a major course correction in the direction of the discipline would depreciate, overnight, the accumulated capital of generations of scholars.
In the words of Max Planck: “Progress occurs one funeral at a time.”
For further reading on these ideas I recommend Lakatos’ essay in in ‘Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge’ www.cambridge.org/core/books/criticism-and-the-growth-of-…
mikael thesleff
@MThesleff
I know you have your own theory and have read your book. Why do you think your model has not gained wider acceptance in mainstream economics ?
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Very good analogy!
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
One car can trigger a traffic jam involving thousands of vehicles through cascading feedback effects. You can't understand the resulting congestion by studying that car in isolation. Yet economists still think a representative household can explain an entire fucking economy.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Government deficits don’t borrow money, they create money. The conventional wisdom, which emanates from Neoclassical economics, says that deficits reduce the supply of money available to the private sector, which they call “Loanable Funds”. This conventional belief is easily proven to be false using double-entry bookkeeping."
Accounting helps to understand monetary operations. It does not matter who does the accounting, the result is always the same and empirically verifiable. Only flat earth-economists reject these kind of results because they prove their abstract Dadaist models wrong.
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/government-money-1685… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Of course models contain assumptions. But in a dynamic system, feedback loops interact to generate emergent behavior that isn't explicitly assumed. There's a rather significant difference between modeling a system's causal structure and assuming its ultimate outcome.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The idea that you can steer the economy with budget deficit rules and an interest rate is clearly dead.
It is a fair weather framework that fails once the going gets rough. There is neither full employment nor price stability, and both climate and distribution are a disaster. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I find it fascinating that economists demand microfoundations for macroeconomic models but rarely demand empirical foundations for the microeconomic assumptions themselves.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr. Genevieve Guenther (she / they)
@DoctorVive
A "severe" drought has been declared in the UK for the first time in history.
#climateemergency -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Makroökonomik sollte nicht verhaltenstheoretisch mikrofundiert sein (Verhalten von Haushalten und Unternehmen), sondern geldtheoretisch fundiert: Wer erzeugt wie Geld und wie hängen Ausgaben und Einnahmen gesamtwirtschaftlich (BIP, BoP, Sektoren) zusammen?
link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-658-41055-1 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
I was head of fraud for Amex. A group of us walked down to the stock market to watch the floor trading from the gallery . It was mayhem people literally falling down from stress . There were even paramedics attending someone , it’s much worse this time the bankers have financialized the whole economy
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Field
@tyillc
Something, something, something ... oh yeah, I remember now ... the Queen of England asked the Economics profession why they didn't see the Great Financial Crisis coming .... pretty hard to do when you don't acknowledge the role of banks in the economy ...
Ahmet Benlialper
@AhmetBenlialper
Perry Mehrling marked Bernanke’s "Econ Nobel" by sharing Kindleberger’s verdict on him: “a most ingenious solution to a non-problem.”
x.com/PMehrling/status/1580564044489973760
Now Woodford has just won this year’s prize, and Mehrling is sadly no longer here to weigh in. So here is his own take on Woodford:
"...he abstracts from essentially all of the institutional apparatus of the banking system. Not only is there no capital in his account, but also there are no banks. No doubt there is a wide range of economic problems for which these abstractions are useful, but I confess to some doubts about the usefulness of these abstractions for many monetary problems."
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
Lovely tribute to Perry Mehrling from @adam_tooze
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-478-money-and-empire-for
(worth reading it, particularly the ending, while considering that Michael Woodford just won the Nobel for a model of the economy that explicitly has no money in it at all) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Zero Equilibrium
@0Equilibrium
THE LANGUAGE OF ECONOMIC THOUGHT:
"The master-economist must possess a rare combination of gifts. He must reach a high standard in several different directions and must combine talents not often found together. He must be mathematician, historian, statesman, philosopher—in some degree. He must understand symbols and speak in words. He must contemplate the particular in terms of the general, and touch abstract and concrete in the same flight of thought. He must study the present in the light of the past for the purposes of the future. No part of man's nature or his institutions must lie entirely outside his regard. He must be purposeful and disinterested in a simultaneous mood; as aloof and incorruptible as an artist, yet sometimes as near the earth as a politician."
– Lord John Maynard Keynes, “Alfred Marshall, 1842–1924.
Many people understand basic economics, but few know the world well enough to understand where economics fits into it. But the real economists always give themselves up with their word choices. It's a different kind of structure, unidentical, but also uniquely identifiable.
At Zero Equilibrium, we don't speak English, we speak Economics, and only express the thought in English, only because we learnt economics in the country of the original owners of the English language, and operate in a country where the lingua franca is Engish.
The economic tribe has a distinct universal language of its own tjat is concerned more with disciplinary fluency, than linguistic fluency. The former in many ways sharpens the latter.
For example, non-Englsih soeaking economists such as; Jean-Baptiste Say, Thomas Piketty, Leon Walras all wrote most of their work(s) originally in French. But that distinct uncommon word choice that economists posses didn't change, with language of expression.
English, French, or any other language is merely the vehicle that conveys the goods which 'economics' supplies (the conceptual architecture, the categories, the distinctions, and the peculiar way of organising thought.)
The economist's vocabulary survives translation (from say, Englsih to French or vice versa) with no change brought to the underlying intellectual and language structure. It is always recognisable.
It is not just a study, ut is a way of life, it is a habit, a culture, an obsession, and a necessity. We may not always have all the answers at every point in time, but it would be impossible to navigate a world with imperfect markets, and limited/finite resources, absent the discipline of economic thought.
Join our Tribe!!!
Like and follow us [ @0Equilibrium ] if you like deep, and broad-based applicable economic thinking thay links businesses, politics and financial markets.
✍️🏽 @Muhammad_Okoye -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
New feature on our Data Explorer at www.gdpdynamics.com/data. You can now collect and formulate data correlation x y dot plots.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 2026 GDP nowcast holds at 3.4%.
The underlying estimate edged up from 3.363% to 3.405%.
September industrial production rose 0.7%, but manufacturing growth slowed sharply over Q3.
Full analysis and charts below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many ‘shocks’ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, “science progresses one funeral at a time”. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
This is spot-on from @JLMelenchon. I hope @georgegalloway
and @WorkersPartyGB follow his example. @TheGreenParty is already pursuing a sensible economic alternative to the disastrous neoliberal status quo, which has shafted the working class for 50 years. @jeremycorbyn and @thisisyourparty should follow suit too.
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
J'y reviens. Tous les économistes libéraux et leurs perroquets de l'officialité médiatique sont passés à l'offensive contre la philosophie de notre contre-budget. Celui-ci est directement inspiré des travaux des économistes hétérodoxes. C'est une occasion rêvée de mener le débat au moment où le modèle néolibéral est entré en agonie avec la politique de Trump et le succès de ses compétiteurs chinois. Il est temps d'entendre les économistes de l'alternative.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ahmet Benlialper
@AhmetBenlialper
Perry Mehrling marked Bernanke’s "Econ Nobel" by sharing Kindleberger’s verdict on him: “a most ingenious solution to a non-problem.”
x.com/PMehrling/status/1580564044489973760
Now Woodford has just won this year’s prize, and Mehrling is sadly no longer here to weigh in. So here is his own take on Woodford:
"...he abstracts from essentially all of the institutional apparatus of the banking system. Not only is there no capital in his account, but also there are no banks. No doubt there is a wide range of economic problems for which these abstractions are useful, but I confess to some doubts about the usefulness of these abstractions for many monetary problems."
Matthew C. Klein
@M_C_Klein
Lovely tribute to Perry Mehrling from @adam_tooze
adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-478-money-and-empire-for
(worth reading it, particularly the ending, while considering that Michael Woodford just won the Nobel for a model of the economy that explicitly has no money in it at all) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
As a Canadian, I can firmly say you have no idea what you are talking about. Both systems have their issues, Canada does have some longer wait times on elective stuff, while the US has 27 million people that do not have Healthcare coverage. The US also has an equal access issue, so even with some forms of coverage dont provide an adequate form of care. The US also has a lower life expectancy, full stop. As with anything on this planet, there are trade offs, especially when it comes to a public or private headcare system. But it takes a rather big American ego to make the claim you just did.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrea Roventini
@AndreaRoventini
Colleghi economisti che offendono con il profilo chiuso. E ignorano tutte le critiche avanzate contro i modelli DSGE da molti altri colleghi tra cui almeno 4 premi Nobel. Prima di citare il Bagaglino, dovrebbero verificare di non essere un figurante di Drive In.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
Some high-ranking individuals on this planet have no grasp of what is actually unfolding.
Our climate system has only responded by 25% to the impending El Niño, and we know that another eight months of very abrupt temperature increases lie ahead. Maybe even more.
@turkiyecop31 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
J'y reviens. Tous les économistes libéraux et leurs perroquets de l'officialité médiatique sont passés à l'offensive contre la philosophie de notre contre-budget. Celui-ci est directement inspiré des travaux des économistes hétérodoxes. C'est une occasion rêvée de mener le débat au moment où le modèle néolibéral est entré en agonie avec la politique de Trump et le succès de ses compétiteurs chinois. Il est temps d'entendre les économistes de l'alternative.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"... the Euro Area's rules are based on a flawed understanding of the monetary system and advocates for reforms to prevent future sovereign debt crises, including the abolition of the SGP and the unrestricted role of national CBs as payment executors for their governments."
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
El colmo de los colmos: La Teoría Monetaria Moderna ha estado acertando en todas sus predicciones, pero no sólo la denigran sino que le han dado el premio Nobel a unos tipos que usan modelos macroeconómicos tan ridículos que no pudieron prever ni siquiera la crisis económica de 2008.
Lamentablemente esto va de ideología, no de ciencia.
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
We're nearing 5 years of hikes/higher rates and inflation remains well above target. We had nearly a decade of ZIRP and inflation stuck to the floor the entire time.
Hate MMT all you want, but this is precisely what MMTers have been arguing would happen the entire time. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Brilliant!
James Hogg
@JamesAHogg2
In a couple of weeks I’ll be interviewing none other than John Lloyd for my podcast, The Laughter Effect. Few people alive have shaped British comedy more profoundly or more positively.
As co-creator and producer of Not the Nine O’Clock News, the driving force behind Blackadder and Spitting Image, co-writer on the original radio Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, and the long-time mastermind of QI, John has an almost unmatched gift for spotting talent, sharpening ideas, and turning sharp observation into lasting laughter. Better still, he’s a genuinely lovely man.
To mark the occasion, here’s one of the sharpest sketches he helped bring to the screen: “The General Synod’s Life of Christ” (often called the “Monty Python Worshippers” or “Life of Python” sketch) from Series 1, Episode 6 of Not the Nine O’Clock News, broadcast on 20 November 1979. It is a near-perfect inversion of the real-life televised debate that had taken place just eleven days earlier. On 9 November 1979, Friday Night, Saturday Morning (hosted by Tim Rice) pitted John Cleese and Michael Palin against Malcolm Muggeridge and the Bishop of Southwark, Mervyn Stockwood, over the supposed blasphemy of Monty Python’s Life of Brian. Muggeridge, in particular, was at his most withering and self-righteous; the Bishop was scarcely more measured. The exchange has gone down as a classic of cultural clash - and, to many, a public-relations disaster for the Church’s representatives. The sketch, which John co-wrote, is one of the cleverest and best-timed parodies ever committed to British television.
Good day.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I needed this laugh. Inverting JC and JC, in honor of the Holy Parrot.
Prof. Frank McDonough
@FXMC1957
16 October 1979. 1st episode of the BBC comedy sketch show Not The Nine O’Clock News was broadcast. It featured Rowan Atkinson, Pamela Stephenson, Mel Smith, Griff Rhys Jones and Chris Langham in the 1st series. It took a satirical view of the news.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Owen Jones
@owenjonesjourno
Neoliberal policies helped drive the UK into a deep recession in the early 1980s.
Industrial communities - and our social fabric - never recovered.
Let's go through them:
DEREGULATION
Abolishing exchange controls in 1979 and loosening controls on bank lending.
@KonstantinKisin argued that financial deregulation began with the Big Bang of 1986.
That is factually wrong.
As a 2002 Bank of England working paper put it:
"The most recent round of deregulation in financial services in the United Kingdom began in 1979 with the removal of exchange controls.”
That allowed British investors to shift far more capital into overseas assets - just when UK industry needed investment.
A 1981 Bank of England analysis found that outward portfolio investment had risen substantially after abolition, and concluded that domestic interest rates were probably left “somewhat higher”.
Higher interests meant a deeper recession.
SUBORDINATING THE REAL ECONOMY TO FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
See above, but also the dramatic hiking of interest rates.
High rates benefited creditors relative to borrowers while making borrowing and productive investment brutally expensive.
They also helped drive up sterling, making British exports more expensive and imports cheaper – hammering manufacturing
The interest-rate squeeze was a central driver of the deep recession.
SLASHING TAXES ON THE RICH
In her first Budget in 1979, Margaret Thatcher slashed the top rate of income tax from 83% to 60%.
This was substantially financed by hiking VAT from 8% to 15%.
The VAT hike added nearly 3.5 percentage points to the Retail Price Index.
It also squeezed purchasing power and consumer demand - deepening the recession.
And all this was happening as the government pursued an increasingly ferocious monetary squeeze to bring inflation down.
HOBBLING ORGANISED LABOUR
Thatcher introduced the first major anti-union legislation in 1980 - the Employment Act.
Combined with surging unemployment - which itself drastically weakened workers' bargaining power – this shifted power away from workers towards bosses.
That made it harder for unions to resist redundancies, closures and wage "restraint" / cuts.
PRIVATISATION
Thatcher's first major privatisation came with the sale of British Aerospace shares in 1981.
But crucially, Thatcher also imposed market discipline on state-owned industries and companies - constraining their access to state finance and demanding commercial returns.
In 1980 alone, British Steel eliminated around 6.5 million tonnes of steelmaking capacity and 50,000 jobs.
And this was explicitly connected to privatisation. In 1981, the government said changes to British Steel would help “pave the way for further privatisation.”
A "RAPID RECOVERY"
Konstantin also argues that there was a "rapid recovery" from the 1980-1981 recession.
But while economic growth resumed, unemployment kept rising until 1984 – long after the technical recession was over. It reached 11.9%
Manufacturing had suffered its biggest twelve month collapse in the post-war era.
I've been travelling around but I'll do a video on this shortly!
TRIGGERnometry
@triggerpod
.@KonstantinKisin fact checks @owenjonesjourno's new book.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Owen Jones
@owenjonesjourno
The biggest threat to Britain's national security?
It's the climate emergency.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jack Meyer 🏛️
@Jackbmeyer
Economists will look you dead in the face and call this science
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Rien ne marche dans ce modèle pourtant au cœur de la macro mainstream :
❌ Courbe de Phillips (eq.1) : rejetée par les données,
❌ Équation d’Euler (eq.2) : idem.
Et pourtant, on continue à l’enseigner (et à l’utiliser !) comme si de rien n’était.🤷♂️
Quand est-ce qu’on avance ?😉
Jack Meyer 🏛️
@Jackbmeyer
Economists will look you dead in the face and call this science
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What would really happen to the pound if we had an MMT government? I keep being asked this - and i n this video, I challenge all the nonsense usually claimed.
youtu.be/PRknxpgDqoY -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇺🇸Lionel🇺🇸
@LionelMedia
Imagine any human being today alive on this planet speaking with such facility and wit. They should be kept in a museum.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Thanks ! my score would be 1/8.😢
1) Theories are "accepted" because heresy is not tolerated
2) DSGEs do *very* badly for forecasting
3) Consensus is obtained by attrition
6) Yes, there are journals, and a very clear hierarchy
8) Papers known to be wrong are not even retracted... -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
RCR Media (Reality Check Radio)
@RCR_NZ
🇦🇺 🌐 rcr.media | "The private sector is the major creator of money through private banks." - Steve Keen, Distinguished Research Fellow at UCL @ProfSteveKeen 🇦🇺
Keen says mainstream economics focuses too heavily on government money creation while overlooking the role of private bank lending. Are we having the wrong debate about what actually drives inflation?
🎥 Watch here: rcr.media/episodes/steve-keen-distinguished-research-fell…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
RCR Media (Reality Check Radio)
@RCR_NZ
🇦🇺 🌐 rcr.media | "We're about to find out in the next 10 or 20 years that it's not a beat-up, it's a death wish." - Steve Keen, Distinguished Research Fellow at UCL @ProfSteveKeen 🇦🇺
Keen delivers a stark warning about where he believes climate inaction could lead. Do you think his assessment is realistic, overstated, or not strong enough?
🎥 Watch here: rcr.media/episodes/steve-keen-distinguished-research-fell…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
System Dynamics, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/system-dynamics Chapter 21 in my forthcoming book “How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism”
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The EU Bureaucrat 🇪🇺
@EU_Bureaucrat
Gonzalo Lira was not an American "journalist" but a sleazy pick-up artist ("coach red pill"), an internet scammer and a cyber criminal (identity theft).
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It has been hijacked by Gonzalo Lira @MrWonkish. He is taking all subscription money and ignores my demands to shut the site down.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Absolutely! On the left is the graphic they used to describe the research that won the Nobble Prize in Economics. On the left is the actual data.
drumm colin (nyc)
@drumm_colin
It really is astounding and scandalous how much the economics dept (all political persuasions) just engage in bald faced lies about the intellectual history.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eric Tymoigne
@tymoignee
Guy who pushes micro in macroeconomics complains that I want to teach macroeconomics only. There is zero role for representative agent in macro. Macro starts with national income accounts and interdependences among sectors. Lucas and after (RBC etc) is a massive step backward
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
There’s a balance of course.
But I don’t think my job teaching principles was to teach my idiosyncratic tastes. In some sense I’m teaching the field that’s the job.
It’d be a dereliction of duty for me to turn macro into an antitrust course because I like antitrust. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
We're nearing 5 years of hikes/higher rates and inflation remains well above target. We had nearly a decade of ZIRP and inflation stuck to the floor the entire time.
Hate MMT all you want, but this is precisely what MMTers have been arguing would happen the entire time. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
If my @GDPDynamics Q3 GDP nowcast beats both @AtlantaFed and @NewYorkFed on the October 29th advance GDP release, I want a Fed account with full access to Fedwire and $13 million in reserve balances.
I don't think that's an unreasonable request. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 GDP nowcast rose to 3.4%, up from 3.2% yesterday.
Inventories drove the entire increase, while consumer spending held steady.
Stronger growth, but the composition matters.
Full analysis and breakdown in the post below. 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Quentin Vandeweyer
@QuentinVandewe2
Thank you, Florin, for sharing this beautiful paper.
What I will remember most about Perry, though, is that he eventually took a different road and the courage it took to do so.
He had a Harvard PhD and a JPE paper. Everything was there for a conventional career in macroeconomics.
Instead, he turned away from mathematical economics and read Bagehot, Hawtrey, Allyn Young, Hicks and Minsky, forgotten traditions of monetary thought that he brought back to life as what he called the money view. He later said he almost did not survive it. Most of his papers were rejected, and Barnard told him his record was not strong enough for tenure. He eventually got it for a book, The Money Interest and the Public Interest, in which he went looking for what he called his intellectual ancestors.
Perry sometimes called himself, too modestly, a historian of economic thought. As Florin says, he remained to me an elegant and deep theorist even when not using mathematics, while now working in a direction orthogonal to most of the profession. I genuinely believe he had far more impact this way, and did more for our understanding of money, than he ever could have on the conventional path.
He also made a choice that would be unusual today, spending much of his time building his synthesis in his money and banking course at Barnard, with his students. The course became a MOOC with close to 200,000 enrollments, and an eye-opener for many.
I was one of them. I signed up while interning at the ECB as a PhD student, without expecting much. I was amazed by how much I learned. It was different from everything I had been taught, and complementary to it. I remember trying to follow the balance sheets of the shadow banking system he drew on the pixelated board, and the eureka moments when he had us look past the institutional details to the same economics of banking and central banking across countries and centuries. I remember him deciphering the euro crisis live.
That course, and the reading that followed, shaped the monetary economist I became. Writing on repo, FX swaps and stablecoins, I have tried to understand shadow banking the way he taught us, as an ecosystem of interlocking balance sheets where heterogeneous institutions together transform liquidity exactly as a bank would. Almost every paper I have written starts with the balance sheets of the model.
As always happens when someone you have learned so much from passes, I wish I had interacted with him more, and had been more explicit about what my work owes him.
Perry found his intellectual ancestors in forgotten books. He is now one of mine, and I will do my best to carry the money view forward.
Florin Bilbiie 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@FlorinBilbiie
RIP Perry Mehrling.
An incredibly elegant and deep theorist, especially for all things "money".
This 1993 note is a gem (on the suboptimality of the Friendman rule in Bewley models due to redistributive effects).
(HT @a_auclert who first pointed me to this paper 10+ years ago!) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
#fotw Daily Post 14
In the last interglacial, 125,000y ago, it was hot enough for hippos in Yorkshire, while crocodiles swam in Berkeley Square. That world was less than 1°C hotter than today
Small number. Wildly different planet
Pls share + tag 2
#fateoftheworld #deeptime -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Highlights
@highlightsnews1
.@ProfSteveKeen says that arms manufacturers are making a fortune from US wars, while the oil lobby and the military-industrial complex stand to benefit from the crisis surrounding the Strait of Hormuz.
Follow Press TV on Telegram: t.me/PressTV -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Follow me for the broad-brush political/economic history, follow @ProfSteveKeen and @TyKeynes for accounting/macro system details, @StephanieKelton for fiat system operational details, @vince_gomez_uk for bond market info, and @haugejostein and @baoshaoshan for reliable commentary on China and BRICS. And read everything Michael Hudson has written.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lars P Syll
@LarsPSyll
Beyond the pretence of 'Nobel Prize'-winning models larspsyll.wordpress.com/2026/10/15/beyond-the-pretence-of… via @LarsSyll
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMTUK Policy Research Group
@MMTUK_PRG
Stephen Laughton's The Money Sham traces how flawed ideas about money have shaped UK policy for generations. Stephanie Kelton calls it "sharp, accessible and genuinely important." Read our briefing.
#mmt #economics #ukeconomy
mmtuk.org/education/briefings/the-money-sham-stephen-laug… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Michael Hudson Reaction To The Newest Nobel Economics Prize Travesty
The 2026 award revives a fifty-year objection: economics keeps rewarding theories that overlook the power of creditors.
michael-hudson.com/2026/10/my-reaction-to-the-newest-nobe…
professormichaelhudson.substack.com/p/my-reaction-to-the-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
AJ Signal
@aj_geo_analysis
If you eat meat, this ONE IS FOR YOU, Some free advice...
Over the next 6 to 12 months, if the Existential War of the Middle East keeps escalating, the price of meat is going to climb hard if not already, and I do not mean a few percent, I mean a serious jump.
How?
War hits oil first, and oil is behind the two costs that set the price of your steak.
Diesel runs every tractor, every truck, every run from the farm to the slaughterhouse and from there to the shelf at your grocery store or your local butcher shop.
Natural gas is what fertilizer is made from, and fertilizer is what grows the hay and the feed corn the cattle eat through winter and summer.
Push diesel and fertilizer up at the same time and you have raised the cost of every single animal, from the ground up.
That cost does not stay on the farm, it reaches you at the till and in your wallet within a few months.
And this shock is not arriving into a normal market. The US cattle herd is ALREADY at its lowest level since 1951, around 86 million head, and beef is ALREADY at record prices before a single new shock hits.
Ground beef is near $6 a pound and up double digits over the past year, with the herd this thin. Now stack a war-driven diesel and fertilizer shock on top of that.
We have been here before. In 2022, when Russia invaded Ukraine, energy spiked, fertilizer roughly doubled, and global food prices hit the highest level ever recorded. Food follows energy, every time.
My read is that in a sustained shock meat runs far past the double digits we already have, potentially 50% or more over the next year, IF the escalation holds and the input shock does not ease.
So what do you do about it?
You buy in bulk now, while it is ONLY "THIS" expensive, and you lock the price in.
Depending on your family size, buy direct, portioned and frozen from a farmer or a butcher shop.
1. On your own or a couple, a QUARTER cow.
2. A family, a HALF.
3. A big household or several families together, a WHOLE animal.
Go in with your brothers, sisters, cousins, parents, even your neighbours if you can talk them into it, split one animal and split the cost.
All you need is a chest freezer and a butcher who will cut and pack it into meal-sized portions you draw down over the next 6 to 12 months.
That alone usually saves you 20 to 30% against retail cuts TODAY, before you count what you dodge if the bigger move comes...
Do it earlier rather than later, because this is about as cheap as meat is going to get over the next 12 months...
Share this with someone who may find it useful.
If you know, you know.
𝗦𝗜𝗚𝗡𝗔𝗟, 𝗡𝗢𝗧 𝗡𝗢𝗜𝗦𝗘!! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
National budgets track financial debt.
But what about ecological debt?
When forests, soils, biodiversity, and waterways are degraded, who records the liability?
My latest thoughts:
www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/modern-monetary-16881…
#sustainability #mmt #nature -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What would an MMT government do? This is one of the questions I am most often asked, and the answer is that MMT changes everything, because MMT governments would realise what they could do and that power rests with them. The change is to politics
youtu.be/mJOMUhdMnMs -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
Here's the link
www.crisesnotes.com/the-death-of-three-recent-giants-lord… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Confused by the idea of "microfoundations of macroeconomics"?
Here is an alternative: The macrofoundations of macroeconomics by Steve Keen:
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-macrofoundations-of-macr… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The IMF has nothing that the French government needs, which is backed by the ECB. The ECB is the monopoly issuer of euros and with its APPs has backed up all Eurozone governments implicitly since 2020. The TPI is all it takes to create "confidence".
www.rfi.fr/en/international/20261014-imf-chief-says-it-wi… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
Surely everyone saw in 2008 by the latest that the Woodford theories were wholly unsuitable to understand reality.
The content has been pushed by central banks as their theoretical smokescreen.
The Swedish central bank prize is apt.
Theories that don't include banks.
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
Some call it a bible, others are puzzled by the diminished role of monetary aggregates. And certainly, it is worth reading. A thought-provoking book by a Nobel Prize winner!
"Interest and Prices: Foundations of a Theory of Monetary Policy" by Michael Woodford.
www.amazon.com/Interest-Prices-Foundations-Theory-Monetar…
"Interest and Prices seeks to provide theoretical foundations for a rule-based approach to monetary policy suitable for a world of instant communications and ever more efficient financial markets. In such a world, effective monetary policy requires that central banks construct a conscious and articulate account of what they are doing. Michael Woodford reexamines the foundations of monetary economics, and shows how interest-rate policy can be used to achieve an inflation target in the absence of either commodity backing or control of a monetary aggregate. The book further shows how the tools of modern macroeconomic theory can be used to design an optimal inflation-targeting regime--one that balances stabilization goals with the pursuit of price stability in a way that is grounded in an explicit welfare analysis, and that takes account of the "New Classical" critique of traditional policy evaluation exercises. It thus argues that rule-based policymaking need not mean adherence to a rigid framework unrelated to stabilization objectives for the sake of credibility, while at the same time showing the advantages of rule-based over purely discretionary policymaking."
www.amazon.com/Interest-Prices-Foundations-Theory-Monetar… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
I hasten to add that this was an epic policy failure. In the US, reliance on the Fed/QE/ZIRP together with a pivot to deficit reduction left us with a jobless "recovery" that paved the way for you-know-who.
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
Notoriously optimistic about growth prospects when governments proactively pivot to deficit reduction.
Faisal Islam
@faisalislam
“The UK is actually one country where action to reduce debt and deficit has been taken decisively and we see the UK in that sense enjoying a bit of a better growth prospect”.
IMF MD Kristalina Georgieva just again singled out UK for its plans to reduce annual borrowing, amid more general warnings that advanced economies should “get house in order”, after the forecast figures released yesterday.
Also said growth is not enough for US to reduce rising borrowing…
Faisal Islam
@faisalislam
Pretty striking…. UK now basically only significant G7 consolidation (3.9%), 2 on basically 0, 3 show actually increasing headline borrowing between 2025 and 2031, based on IMF projections.
This is headline borrowing - should get new figures on primary deficit etc overnight too -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Precisely! These models were dominant by the 1990s, and hit their pinnacle in 2007 (Smets and Wouters), failed to foresee the Global Financial Crisis, which began in 2007, and the recovery from the GFC was the SLOWEST in history from a recession.
This is intellectual revisionism
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
this needs to be said more and more loudly ⬇️
what is it with humans reifying models that fail to represent reality? and so fail when the heat is on (my prof calls it ‘flat ocean macroeconomics’)??
the awarding of a global ‘prize’ for this rubbish is getting us nowhere.
😒
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Amazing bit of revisionism - the intellectual authors of the models that allowed central banks to ignore the shadow banking instability that exploded into 2008 global financial crisis are now presented as 'transformers of crisis central banking'
www.ft.com/content/1d3b1c4f-823d-49eb-aaf5-b662a6281ac7 via @ft -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
How are you supposed to take economics seriously as a discipline when its top accolades are being awarded to work that anyone with common sense can see has no merit to it and has long since been discredited?
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
It’s not just that DSGE models are laughably unrealistic. They’re also logically incoherent. They’re models of monetary policy where money is inessential and the microeconomic behaviour they claim to be founded upon doesn’t allow for aggregation as a representative agent.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
RCR Media (Reality Check Radio)
@RCR_NZ
🇦🇺 🌐 rcr.media | "Australia is not merely the highest importer of diesel per capita on the planet; it's the highest importer of diesel on the planet, period." - Steve Keen, Distinguished Research Fellow at UCL @ProfSteveKeen 🇦🇺
Keen says Australia's reliance on imported diesel is extreme, leaving transport, farming and food supply exposed if international flows are interrupted. How did a resource-rich country become this dependent on fuel from overseas?
#rcrmediaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
In 50 years, Kelton's The Deficit Myth will be more widely read than Mises' Human Action, Hayek's Road to Serfdom, and Hazlitt's Economics in One Lesson combined.
Armchair Austrian economists can start fucking crying now. There's no need to wait 50 years. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“All faiths do harm. We may define "faith" as a firm belief in something for which there is no evidence. Where there is evidence, no one speaks of "faith." We do not speak of faith that two and two are four or that the earth is round. We only speak of faith when we wish to substitute emotion for evidence. And the substitution of emotion for evidence is apt to lead to strife, since different groups substitute different emotions.”
— Bertrand Russell -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
With the planet now heating at 0.4C a decade, the idea the world will be just 2.7C hotter by 2100 is pure fantasy
Like 1.5C before it, the 2.7C figure is being used to massively underestimate the dire straits we are in, and to play down the desperate need for action NOW -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Peez
@RebelEkonomista
The economics "Nobel" is not a Nobel. It's a Riksbank prize from 1968, handed out by economists to economists. Sure, the winners can do the maths. But the maths sits on a household analogy that doesn't describe a currency issuer. The Crown spends by crediting accounts. Tax and bonds drain money afterwards, they don't fund anything. Build a flat tax or a debt scare on the opposite assumption and you get policy that flatters those who live on interest and rent.
Michael Hudson's right that private debt is the missing piece in their models.
My Reaction To The Newest Nobel Economics Prize Travesty substack.com/@professormichaelhudson/note/p-220432317?r=8… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Johan Rockström
@jrockstrom
Check out my latest article: 2026 State of the Climate Report: Earth's climate system is becoming unstable www.linkedin.com/pulse/2026-state-climate-report-earths-s… via @LinkedIn
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
There’s something psychological about this obsession with the debt-to-GDP ratio. Public debt can rise in absolute terms while the ratio falls simply because the denominator grows faster than the numerator. Sometimes inflation alone is enough. Basic arithmetic, yet so many political conclusions!
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Depuis que l'Espagne a cessé les coupes budgétaires et a mené une politique de relance, sa dette est passée sous les 100 % du PIB et sa croissance a augmenté.
L'économie allemande est sortie de la récession dès que ses investissements ont repris.
Nous ne défendons pas un simple schéma idéologique, mais quelque chose qui s'applique ailleurs et qui donne des résultats.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Film Audit
@Film_Audit_
One of the best job interviews of all time.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
1895
@1895MT
There’s something special about discovering an old movie years after everyone stopped talking about it and realizing, how did nobody tell me about this?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jamie Smith
@JGS952
Timely and important
The @TheGreenParty is the only party now with an up-to-date economic policy framework (as of conference) aligned with this kind of thinking.
Scrap narrow and arbitrary budget-based fiscal rules and replace with a much more holistic assessment of fiscal pol.
Mariana Mazzucato
@MazzucatoM
Fiscal responsibility matters. But defining it narrowly as meeting deficit and debt targets can be self-defeating. Cutting spending in a weak economy reduces growth and investment, potentially leaving debt higher relative to GDP. A better approach looks at whether fiscal policy strengthens the economy’s capacity to grow, withstand shocks and meet its obligations over time.
This is the focus of our first policy brief, Fiscal Rules and Long-Term Inclusive Growth, from the Global Council on New Economics for the 21st Century, which I co-chair with Vice-President of Spain @Carlos_Cuerpo, published at the @IMFNews and @WorldBankGroup Annual Meetings in Bangkok. Links to new council website and policy brief in replies. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
My latest weekly video update for members of @GDPDynamics on its Nowcast's recent trending decline in consumer spending.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Latest weekly update for member only. There is a progressive decline in in consumer spending is happening on the GDP Dynamics Nowcast, it might be time to talk about it.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/gdp-dynamics-172381268 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jonathan Pie
@JonathanPieNews
The President of the United States taking the piss out of a mentally ill man who died just a couple of days before.
Frankly, I expected nothing less from this sociopathic arsehole.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Paul Barry
@TheRealPBarry
I didn’t retweet this because I assumed it must be fake. Surely not even a grub like Trump could do something so awful? He is not just insane, he is a vile human being. Mocking a poor man’s death like this. Just despicable.
Jonathan Pie
@JonathanPieNews
The President of the United States taking the piss out of a mentally ill man who died just a couple of days before.
Frankly, I expected nothing less from this sociopathic arsehole.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
🇺🇸 GDP Dynamics Q3 GDP Nowcast: 3.1%, down 0.1 percentage points.
September inflation hit 3.7%, with gasoline prices jumping 9.1%. Consumer spending lost 0.1 pp, while net exports improved 0.1 pp.
Inflation is squeezing purchasing power.
Article in next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
"In some respects, science has far surpassed religion in delivering awe. How is it that hardly any major religion has looked at science and concluded, "This is better than we thought! The Universe is much bigger than our prophets said, grander, more subtle, more elegant. God must be even greater than we dreamed"? Instead they say, "No, no, no! My god is a little god, and I want him to stay that way."
- Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cameron Murray
@DrCameronMurray
FET Thursday Throwback:
Does Victoria's rollicking 1880s land boom have lessons for today?
The two-stage boom, the housing politics, and the surprise crash.
www.fresheconomicthinking.com/p/does-victorias-rollicking… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
My good mate @StephanieKelton just reminded me of this graphic: the recovery from the GFC, after DSGE models became dominant, was the slowest in post-WWII history.
The "scientific background" makes NO mention of the GFC!!!
Economics is a data heavy AND fact-free discipline. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Somewhere right now, there is a neoclassical economist explaining why the economy didn't behave as predicted by a model that assumes it always behaves as predicted.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
So is the ignorance of most people of the seriousness of our climate predicament.
I congratulate the fossil fuel lobby and mainstream economists--and especially William Nordhaus--for deluding the public into thinking climate change is a distant and minor threat. It's neither. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Bravo Anthony. You have a level of personal awareness, introspection and honesty that is beyond rare amongst prominent public figures.
Anthony Scaramucci
@Scaramucci
Be accountable.
Someone asked me last night, what’s your number one regret?
My response shocked them.
I grew up in a tough household, and so I became a conflict avoider.
This bit me in the ass in my first marriage. I was not communicating the way I needed to. Things weren’t going well, and I was chickenshit about it.
I regret that and it was unfair to her. I didn’t do it on purpose, but I did it.
The person almost fell over, because you don’t often hear that level of honesty.
But here’s what I’ve found: when you force yourself into that kind of honest self-awareness, you find more peace.
The thing you’re avoiding is never as bad as the avoiding itself. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
It’s not just that DSGE models are laughably unrealistic. They’re also logically incoherent. They’re models of monetary policy where money is inessential and the microeconomic behaviour they claim to be founded upon doesn’t allow for aggregation as a representative agent.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
So is the ignorance of most people of the seriousness of our climate predicament.
I congratulate the fossil fuel lobby and mainstream economists--and especially William Nordhaus--for deluding the public into thinking climate change is a distant and minor threat. It's neither. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eric Tymoigne
@tymoignee
For more from a in-mainstream perspective on the topic, Romer’s “The Trouble with Macroeconomics” and also Solow, among others
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
50 years of macroeconomics in a nutshell:
Lucas: “Your Keynesian models are full of ad hoc assumptions. We need proper microfoundations!”
SMD: “Well, individual rationality doesn't guarantee nice aggregate behavior.”
New Classical macroeconomists: “Aggregation is a problem? Let's just model the entire economy as ONE representative agent. Problem solved.”
New Keynesians: “Cool. Now let's throw in some ad hoc assumptions to make it work.”
And that's how ad hoc assumptions became microfoundations. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
From a decade ago in @ReviewofPE , to help you better understand the conceptual flaw in this year's Nobel Prize in economics
The Conceptual Flaw in the Microeconomic Foundations of Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Models
By the always amazing Colin Rogers -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Michael Woodford a surtout fourni aux banquiers centraux un cadre théorique qui leur convenait : celui d’une politique monétaire présentée comme un sujet technique, et non politique.
Or, cette vision est profondément contestable, comme je l’explique ici:⤵️ utppublishing.com/doi/10.3138/ttr.47.1.141
FT Alphaville
@FTAlphaville
How Michael Woodford made modern macro relevant to central bankers ft.trib.al/dJdT7bh
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Frances 'Cassandra' Coppola
@Frances_Coppola
Central banking is theatre and DSGE models are stage props.
Emanuel Derman @emanuelderman.bsky
@EmanuelDerman
A guess from model experience: I have a feeling that DSGE models with multiple agents & shocks etc are too complicated & yet too unrealistic to get things right. I suspect the fed uses simple econometrics for forecasting and uses DSGE the honchos cant grok for gravitas & security
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
José Moran
@drmtgr
I think François' answer and the discussion around the Nobel yesterday raise a lot of interesting questions.
It is entirely true that DSGE models perform poorly empirically, and that some of the things they rely on (the Euler equation) is massively rejected by data. This is not
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Tout à fait. Et comment un modèle qui est aussi mauvais en prévision (même la Banque de France/BCE ne l'utilisent pas !) peut-il être bon pour faire des contrefactuels, ou calculer la politique optimale ? La plupart des macroéconomistes semblent pourtant tenir cela pour acquis.🤔
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrea Roventini
@AndreaRoventini
Tornado alla scelta sbagliata del Nobel per l'economia, ricordo che il grandissimo Bob Solow considerava i modelli DSGE (e questo tipo di macro) un salto fuori dall'economia:
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Agolf Twitler Slayer
@slayer_agolf
This is the tweet of the century!
Retweet if you agree! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
José Moran
@drmtgr
Lucas identified a real problem, but not, in my opinion, a real solution (relevant to the real world).
This became an argument for a tradition built around utility maximising agents and rational expectations (and driven in part by the need to have "tractable" models, about -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dramaniela
@Dramanielaf
Los economistas de EAFIT y de los Andes dirán que los economistas “heterodoxos” no saben de matemáticas. Mientras tanto los economistas “heterodoxos” llevan años hablando de usar herramientas para estudiar la realidad economica que incluyen hasta teoría del caos
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
this is how Ricardo Calballero explained the 'Pretense of Knowledge' in Woodford's mainstream macro: it relegated everything interesting in the real world to the periphery of macro, particularly the macro financial dynamics that produced the 2008 crisis
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter D Carter
@PCarterClimate
BIODIVERSITY LOSS ALSO THREATENS OUR FUTURE
This applies especially to ocean carbon sequestration.
Biodiversity is declining fast, and climate change is increasing fast. They interact negatively, making each other worse. Biodiversity loss is projected to increase under all emissions scenarios (IPCC). www.nature.com/articles/s41559-026-03200-4 #biodiversity #climatechange. #globalwarming -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
Michael Hudson on how imposing austerity on other nations and having a Right-Wing foreign policy, can hurt the global economy.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
gdpdynamics.com went under some re-optimization over the weekend to prepare for the additions of some new models coming over next few weeks.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Juan Laborda
@JuanLabordah
4.- Tras décadas exigiendo "microfundamentos" para simular rigor, la inmensa mayoría de estos modelos macro predictivos fracasan. Tienen peor capacidad de anticipar crisis que los modelos keynesianos tradicionales de los 50 o 60. Rigidez matemática a cambio de ceguera empírica
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Even though these debt dynamics have occurred repeatedly throughout history and are logical, they still surprise people."
The US government did not default since 1776. Before, it did not yet exist. History does not lie: The US government issues the $.
time.com/article/2026/08/28/the-bond-market-s-supply-and-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Beatles Legacy
@TheBeatlesPMcC
Lors de sa dernière interview, Paul McCartney a craqué. C'est tout simplement la première fois qu'il craque en public après 65 ans de carrière.
Paul est d'une génération et d'une culture où on apprenait aux enfants à ne jamais se plaindre et à ne pas montrer leurs émotions en public. Dés la mort de sa mère, alors qu'il n'avait que 14 ans, les consignes familiales étaient claires, les enfants McCartney ne devaient pas s'apitoyer sur leur sort. S'ils pleuraient, c'était dans leur chambre, pas en public.
La vie de McCartney sera jalonnée de beaucoup de drames. La mort de son père, il n'avait que 34 ans, celle de Mal Evans, la mort de John Lennon bien sûr, celle de Ivan Vaughan, son meilleur ami avant John, la mort de Linda, sa femme et la mère de ses enfants, celle de Harrison, celle de George Martin. Et j'en oublie.
Il avait beaucoup pleuré selon ses proches. Mais jamais devant nous. On lui reprochera même son manque d'émotions à la mort de John. C'était tellement mal connaître McCartney.
L'évocation de Linda aura donc fini par faire craquer en public cet homme de 84 ans. Et c'est certainement parce qu'il a 84 ans qu'il a craqué. Parce que c'était Linda aussi. Parce que le temps passe surtout.
Savez-vous d'ailleurs quelle était la chanson préférée de Linda ? Certainement l'un des titres les moins connus de son mari. Mais une foutue super chanson effectivement.
"Daytime Nightime Sufferring", Wings, 1979.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gabriel Montes Rojas
@GabriMontesRo
Dado el interés por el Nobel paso a recordar que existe una Microeconomía Macro fundada.
Microeconomía heterodoxa, Gabriel Montes Rojas eudeba.com.ar/productos/microeconomia-heterodoxa/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"They are the “bond vigilantes,” investors who periodically punish free-spending governments by selling their bonds, pushing long-term interest rates to painfully high levels."
This will not age well. Governments bail out banks, not vice versa.
www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/global-ai-bust-ruchi… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
I highly recommend watching his videos on money and banking. One of the few people capable of talking about not just financial market plumbing, but also why you should care. m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSuwqsAnJMtwZEwkJgHZCod2xP9b…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
This is a non-issue for currency issuers, including the Eurozone.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Please raise a glass on my behalf to Perry, Nathan. He was truly a scholar and a gentleman. Both of those are very rare these days. It's very sad that we've lost him.
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
If you know me well enough to text me, email me or DM me, I'm holding a gathering at my Chelsea Manhattan office for Perry tonight. Feel free to reach out for the details.
Young Scholars Initiative
@ysi_commons
We are deeply saddened to share the news that Perry Mehrling passed away this morning at the age of 67.
Perry was the father of the Young Scholars Initiative. He believed profoundly in young scholars, in their ideas, and in the importance of creating a community in which they could learn from one another and find their own voices.
Perry, you leave an enormous hole in our midst. Our hearts are aching, and we will miss you dearly.
The YSI community will carry your legacy forward. Your ideas, your generosity, and your commitment to generations of young scholars will remain with us.
Thank you for everything, Perry. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Juan Laborda
@JuanLabordah
1.- ¿Los Nobel de Economía de 2026? Otra vez premiando la fantasía matemática. Como bien denunció Paul Romer, la macroeconomía moderna sufre de "mathiness": el uso de ecuaciones complejas no para buscar la verdad, sino para camuflar sesgos ideológicos y proteger el statu quo
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Very sad news. Great thinker and great teacher. Perry Mehrling's Money and Banking course remains one of the best courses available online, well worth studying: archive.org/details/academictorrents_970f4ee32d1a49168466…
Young Scholars Initiative
@ysi_commons
We are deeply saddened to share the news that Perry Mehrling passed away this morning at the age of 67.
Perry was the father of the Young Scholars Initiative. He believed profoundly in young scholars, in their ideas, and in the importance of creating a community in which they could learn from one another and find their own voices.
Perry, you leave an enormous hole in our midst. Our hearts are aching, and we will miss you dearly.
The YSI community will carry your legacy forward. Your ideas, your generosity, and your commitment to generations of young scholars will remain with us.
Thank you for everything, Perry. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
Swedish central bank prize for CB PR man Woodford.
Pathetic. He devoted his life to study monetary policy but his framework totally failed as the 2008 crisis showed, so people had become quiet about it.
Perhaps his 800-page book should've included banks?
share.google/UtHjC9X3bk4vimHhS -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Precisely! These models were dominant by the 1990s, and hit their pinnacle in 2007 (Smets and Wouters), failed to foresee the Global Financial Crisis, which began in 2007, and the recovery from the GFC was the SLOWEST in history from a recession.
This is intellectual revisionism
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
this needs to be said more and more loudly ⬇️
what is it with humans reifying models that fail to represent reality? and so fail when the heat is on (my prof calls it ‘flat ocean macroeconomics’)??
the awarding of a global ‘prize’ for this rubbish is getting us nowhere.
😒
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Amazing bit of revisionism - the intellectual authors of the models that allowed central banks to ignore the shadow banking instability that exploded into 2008 global financial crisis are now presented as 'transformers of crisis central banking'
www.ft.com/content/1d3b1c4f-823d-49eb-aaf5-b662a6281ac7 via @ft
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
My good mate @StephanieKelton just reminded me of this graphic: the recovery from the GFC, after DSGE models became dominant, was the slowest in post-WWII history.
The "scientific background" makes NO mention of the GFC!!!
Economics is a data heavy AND fact-free discipline. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
Perry Mehrling, RIP.
According to the History of Economics Society, Perry Mehrling died "Monday night from injury sustained in a fall several days earlier." He was Professor of International Political Economy at Boston University and, previously, longtime Professor of Economics at Barnard College. He was a highly esteemed historian of economics.
Here is his homepage:
sites.bu.edu/perry/
His last book: "Money and Empire: Charles P. Kindleberger and the Dollar System"
www.amazon.com/Money-Empire-Kindleberger-Economic-Thinkin…
"Charles Kindleberger ranks as one of the twentieth century's best known and most influential international economists. This book traces the evolution of his thinking in the context of a 'key-currency' approach to the rise of the dollar system, here revealed as the indispensable framework for global economic development since World War II. Unlike most of his colleagues, Kindleberger was deeply interested in history, and his economics brimmed with real people and institutional details. His research at the New York Fed and BIS during the Great Depression, his wartime intelligence work, and his role in administering the Marshall Plan gave him deep insight into how the international financial system really operated. A biography of both the dollar and a man, this book is also the story of the development of ideas about how money works. It throws revealing light on the underlying economic forces and political obstacles shaping our globalized world."
Charles Goodhart: "The discipline of economics is balanced, somewhat unsteadily, between two legs, with the skill of the historian on one side and of the mathematical modeler on the other. In the second half of the 20th century, the tide flowed strongly to elevate the second leg and to diminish the first. In this delightful biography of Charlie Kindleberger, a charming and loveable man, Perry Mehrling shows how Charlie, in his chosen role, as an international monetary economist, fought against that tide, often unsuccessfully. Perry writes so beautifully that one would only need a smattering of economics to enjoy the tale; while if one is interested in the history of economic thought in international monetary economics, then this book is, of course, a must read.'
www.amazon.com/Money-Empire-Kindleberger-Economic-Thinkin… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Furthermore, it seems unlikely that the influence of banking policy on the rate of interest will be sufficient by itself to determine an optimum rate of investment."
John Maynard Keynes in his 1936 book "The General Theory...". So, Woodford and Hall are not Keynesians at all. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Amazing bit of revisionism - the intellectual authors of the models that allowed central banks to ignore the shadow banking instability that exploded into 2008 global financial crisis are now presented as 'transformers of crisis central banking'
www.ft.com/content/1d3b1c4f-823d-49eb-aaf5-b662a6281ac7 via @ft -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I think we should make economists wear their forecasting accuracy on their shirts like sports statistics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Max Jerneck
@MaxJerneck
The "Nobel" prize in economics explained:
"A central bank is ritualistically blessing academic research which, in turn, ritualistically blesses all central banks."
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
I turned around my piece on the most recent "Nobel" prize in economics quite quickly, so I hope people appreciate it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
It is you who are sold a fib. And by an AI bot too! Sure, the Bank of Greece has a printing press in Holargos. It belongs to Frankfurt and can only print 5 euro notes. Nothing else. The printing presses that used to be able to print drachmas were destroyed in 2000.
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
Perhaps you were told that.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John ‘John’ Morrison
@J_MoAGoGo
Keynes’ General Theory really had nothing in common with the New Keynesian approach.
Erik Öberg
@ek_oberg
While we celebrate chief architect Woodford, now is also a good time to remember the many people involved in building the New-Keynesian theory of business cycles and stabilization policy.
Below is a slide from my first-year Ph.D. macro class. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Polite Revolution (/s) 🥟
@PoliteRevo3255
Greens officially the least antisemitic and the most anti-war-crime. ✊💚
Nicole Lampert
@nicolelampert
Almost all of this is shocking.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Seth Harp
@sethharpesq
Delusional take. In reality, the mismatch between American military power and its record of constantly losing wars has everything to do with the terrible quality of US intel. America has not won a war since its enemies stopped wearing color-coded uniforms on the battlefield.
Mort-decai
@DavidAririeri
I think people seriously underestimate how much restraint is actually baked into western military doctrine. the US genuinely fight their enemies like they’re spanking kids.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
If the US government can print money, why does it borrow money? 🤔
This is the central question when it comes to the US bond market wobble. 🦉
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Fj0zRmEWYc -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter D Carter
@PCarterClimate
CLIMATE CHANGE HITS HARVESTS
ENGLAND HAS WORST HARVEST ON RECORD
2026 England’s worst cereal harvest 'means that four of the five worst harvests occurred since 2020 following extreme weather.
Climate change is now undermining our food security'
(8 October 2026, Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit)
#foodsecurity #climatechange #globalwarming -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Heterodox economists face an intellectual asymmetry. They must study mainstream economics rigorously to identify and critique its theoretical flaws, while mainstream economists can largely ignore heterodox theories without even engaging with the criticisms directed at their own.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Again, this is the actual data.
I wonder if the data hurt those poor guiding economic hands??? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Again, this is the actual data.
I wonder if the data hurt those poor guiding economic hands??? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
They're embarrassed by him, but not by their overall approach--which they also should be embarrassed by.
This is like awarding a prize in navigation to the captain of the Titanic. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
It was true. All printing presses were destroyed in 2000. That's why I designed and organised a digital payment system until new printing presses could be set up - for which I was hounded and persecuted. I never succumbed.
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
You appeared on Question Time and said that all the Drachma printing presses had been destroyed. I looked into that claim. It wasn't true... besides, that wouldn't have stopped you issuing digital currency until new plates were in place. Yes, Tsipras also succumbed.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is brilliant.
Gossip Goblin
@Gossip_Goblin
An Honest Day’s Work
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Umm... There's an error in your illustration. This is the actual data.
-
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
2026 economic sciences laureates Robert E. Hall’s and Michael Woodford’s research has made us better equipped to manage economic downturns.
They laid the foundation of the New Keynesian paradigm, in which models are built upon microfoundations, which means from the bottom up. Economic outcomes are the result of millions of decisions made at the microlevel by households and businesses. Using models based upon this approach, rather than simply studying the economy from a macro perspective, like a bird’s eye view, Hall’s and Woodford’s research has generated a paradigm shift in the theory of stabilisation policy.
#nobelprize
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Umm... There's an error in your illustration. This is the actual data.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
With all due respect, you got this wrong. I never blinked. And because I didn't, whereas my PM did, I resigned. As finance minister, I did not have the authority to exit the euro. My only choice was to stay in that gvt, compromised. Or to resign. I made the right call.
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
This was inevitable with the adoption of the Euro. Greece can only earn Euros, it can't issue them. It is reliant on exports but has no competitive manufacturing base - so tourism it is.
Varoufakis blinked first. He should have dropped the Euro and returned to the Drachma. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Nice one! My way to satirise this is to say you have to pronounce it useing pidgin French: it's "Trick Le Down"
Robert Reich
@RBReich
trickle down economics
trickle down economic
trickle down economi
trickle down econom
trickle down econo
trickle down econ
trickle down eco
trickle down ec
trickle down e
trickle down
trickle dow
trickle do
trickle d
trickle
trickl
trick -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Professor Richard A. Werner
@ProfessorWerner
This is the guy whose work had been flagged by central banks decades ago as being useful for them - to hide how they actually run monetary policy & to tie economists down in useless debates about how many angels can fit on the tip of a pin, while having nothing to do with reality
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
Some call it a bible, others are puzzled by the diminished role of monetary aggregates. And certainly, it is worth reading. A thought-provoking book by a Nobel Prize winner!
"Interest and Prices: Foundations of a Theory of Monetary Policy" by Michael Woodford.
www.amazon.com/Interest-Prices-Foundations-Theory-Monetar…
"Interest and Prices seeks to provide theoretical foundations for a rule-based approach to monetary policy suitable for a world of instant communications and ever more efficient financial markets. In such a world, effective monetary policy requires that central banks construct a conscious and articulate account of what they are doing. Michael Woodford reexamines the foundations of monetary economics, and shows how interest-rate policy can be used to achieve an inflation target in the absence of either commodity backing or control of a monetary aggregate. The book further shows how the tools of modern macroeconomic theory can be used to design an optimal inflation-targeting regime--one that balances stabilization goals with the pursuit of price stability in a way that is grounded in an explicit welfare analysis, and that takes account of the "New Classical" critique of traditional policy evaluation exercises. It thus argues that rule-based policymaking need not mean adherence to a rigid framework unrelated to stabilization objectives for the sake of credibility, while at the same time showing the advantages of rule-based over purely discretionary policymaking."
www.amazon.com/Interest-Prices-Foundations-Theory-Monetar… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Paul Anthony Thorpe
@PaulAnthonyTho6
Watch this and ask yourself if you can take the regular media economic correspondents seriously.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Prof. Steve Keen: why we're 'screwed next year', and what we can do about it youtu.be/o1fZD0E8Dw8 via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
du -sh *
@LilAphasia
Do we need microfoundations for macroeconomics?
J.KING the microfoundations dogma threatens the existence of
macroeconomics asa separate subdiscipline; it has damaging implications for macroeconomic policy-support for fiscal austerity,wage cuts"👇@IwoAugustynski @IsabellaMWeber
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
In light of the Nobel Prize in economics being awarded to Woodford and Hall, here is John King's articles on microfoundations in general, published in my intro book, second edition (third edition coming soon).
68b1e6b9-c0f8-4cc2-99b9-e9ecab5ea499.filesusr.com/ugd/610… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
I have a name
@dontknowbutgot1
Steve Keen did. And he did not predict 1000 of the last 0 hyperinflations
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economists invented rational expectations because apparently assuming people were rational to begin with wasn't enough bullshit for one discipline.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
"The tools exist. The choice is political."
This essay explores why combining MMT with Doughnut Economics may provide one of the most complete frameworks yet for social justice and ecological resilience.
www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/mmt-and-doughnut-1688…
#mmt #doughnuteconomics #ecology #futureeconomy -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Yok öyle bir şey. Ekleyen Nobel Vakfı değil. Mirowski burada anlatıyor:
"İsveç Merkez Bankası başkanının, hiçbir siyasi yetkiye dayanmaksızın böyle bir ödülün zeminini gizlice hazırlamak üzere ortalıkta dolanması pek yakışıksız kaçacağından, Åsbrink ile Nobel Vakfı arasında aracılık etmesi için Lindbeck devreye sokulmuştu. Lindbeck, Nobel Vakfı başkanı Nils Ståhle’ye ve vakfın mali danışmanı Jacob Wallenberg’e danıştı. Ancak Wallenberg, bir Nobel ödülü daha eklenmesini söz konusu bile etmiyordu. Yoğun müzakerelerin ardından bir “uzlaşmaya” varıldı: Banka, adına bakıldığında şüphe uyandıracak ölçüde gerçek bir Nobel’e benzeyen, ama yine de “farklı” bir ödülü finanse edebilecekti; başka bir deyişle, Nobel’in yanına konulacak, onun sahtesi niteliğinde paralel bir ödülü: “Alfred Nobel’in Anısına İsveç Merkez Bankası Ekonomi Bilimleri Ödülü.” Alfred Nobel’in mezarında ters dönüyor olması ise küçük bir pürüzden ibaretti."
Mirowski'nin makalesi halka açık bu kitabın 219'uncu sayfasında başılıyor:
www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/215796/1/Full-text-book-P…
Cüneyt Dirican Assc.Prof. World 1st Astroeconomist
@istanbulekolu
Vasiyette yoksa Nobel Ödülü değildir. Vakıf sonradan sponsoru bulunca eklemiş. Sponsor tam da neoliberalizmin yükseliş döneminde merkez bankası bağımsızlığı hikayesine kılıf uydurmak ve bilimsel göstermek adına 300. kuruluş yılı anısı diye ödülü yaratmış.
www.riksbank.se/en-gb/about-the-riksbank/the-tasks-of-the… -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Prof. Steve Keen: why we're 'screwed next year', and what we can do about it youtu.be/o1fZD0E8Dw8 via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
When losing the empirical battle, retreat to the bunker of unobservable economics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Oui, les 2 manuels disent vrai: l’équation d’Euler est partout dans les modèles macroéconomiques mainstream, mais nulle part dans les données. La macroéconomie dominante, quand même…😅
Mike Konczal
@mtkonczal
In honor of the consumption Euler winning the Nobel, my two fav quotes on it.
From L-S’s graduate intro, it’s “either the cornerstone or the straw man” of modern macro.
And from Rudd’s great overview, it “fails virtually every empirical test that has ever been thrown at it.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Major Gowen
@MajorGowen_
"That'll be £1 extra sir" 🤣
Don't make them like Spike Milligan anymore. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oktay Özden
@oktayozdn
Bu nobel ödülünü veren güruhta zerre tarafsızlık, adalet duygusu olsa Wynne ve Marc'a ödülü çoktan teslim etmeleri gerekirdi.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🏴InsideLucysHead🏴©
@InsideLucysHead
How the government works...
The King wanted to go fishing, and he asked the royal weather forecaster for the forecast for the next few hours. The palace meteorologist assured him that there was no chance of rain.
So the King and the Queen went fishing. On the way, he met a man with a fishing pole riding on a donkey, and he asked the man if the fish were biting.
The fisherman said, "Your Majesty, you should return to the palace! In just a short time I expect a huge rain storm."
The King replied: "I hold the palace meteorologist in high regard. He is an educated and experienced professional. Besides, I pay him very high wages. He gave me a very different forecast. I trust him."
So the King continued on his way.
However, in a short time, a torrential rain fell from the sky. The King and Queen were totally soaked. Furious, the King returned to the palace and gave the order to fire the meteorologist.
Then he summoned the fisherman and offered him the prestigious position of royal forecaster.
The fisherman said, "Your Majesty, I do not know anything about forecasting. I obtain my information from my donkey. If I see my donkey's ears drooping, it means with certainty that it will rain."
So the King hired the donkey.
And so began the practice of hiring dumb asses to work in influential positions of government. The practice is unbroken to this day. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
josh ryan-collins
@jryancollins
Today's economics Nobel to Michael Woodford and Robert Hall rewards the intellectual foundations of modern central banking. The problem is that several of those foundations look increasingly shaky.
A thread 🧵 1/15
www.theguardian.com/world/2026/oct/12/nobel-prize-for-eco… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oktay Özden
@oktayozdn
Woodford'un modelinin eleştirisi için C. Rogers'ın CJE paper'ını öneririm.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rachael Stein in 🇺🇸 💙✡️🕊🌎
@Rachael60177232
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How strange then that these forward looking expectations didn’t see the Global Financial Crisis coming.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
“Your microfoundations are unrealistic.”
“They don’t have to be realistic.”
“Then what’s the point of having them?”
“To make the model more realistic.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Haklı arkadaş. Woodford DSGE modellerinin babası olmasa da, babaları arasındadır. DSGE modellerinin başarısızlığı da kamu bilgisidir. Bu modellerin buruşturulup tarihin çöp tenekesine atılması gerekirken, bu ödül neden verilmiş olabilir? Bravo, ne güzel de sıçtın diye mi?
Andrea Roventini
@AndreaRoventini
1/3 La scelta del premio Nobel per l'economia è criticabile se si considerare la motivazione è quasi comica. Woodford è il padre dei modelli DSGE che NON sono riusciti a spiegare (non a prevedere!) la crisi del 2008, la maggiore dal 1929, e non hanno fornito nessuna policy utile.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Here is the real-time forecasting record of the Fed's New Keynesian DSGE model during COVID.
Notice the inflation forecast. The pandemic shock was already underway, yet all those Nobel Prize-winning microfoundations produced a spectacularly inaccurate macroeconomic forecast. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
AJ
@neojedjdp
Low expectations from the Nobel committee. Still awarding the prize for microeconomic trash theories, despite the fact that macroeconomic conditions largely constrain microeconomic decisions, rather than macroeconomics simply being derived from microeconomic foundations.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
We should refer to this prize in future as the Nobble Prize in Economics
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Kardeşim. Alfred Nobel 1896’da öldü, bu ödül 1968’de icat edildi, ilk kez 1969’da verildi. Nobel’in kendisi bu ödülü nasıl kabul etmiş olabilir? Ayrıca, varislerinin bu ödüle karşı çıktığı biliniyor. Peter Nobel’in dediklerini şuradan okumak mümkün:
mondediplo.com/2005/02/12nobel
Mehmet Durmaz
@mehmetdurmaz007
“Nobel Ekonomi Ödülü gerçek değil” demek ciddi ahmaklık göstergesi. Sevmeyebilirsiniz, “gerçek” ödüller daha az tartışmalı değil. Fakat Nobel’in kendisi bunu kabul etmişken her sene “gerçek değil, gerçek değil” diye dolaşmak çok komik.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
An excellent critique of "New Keynesian" (which is neither Keynesian nor Wicksellian) #macroeconomics:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full_Employment_Abandoned -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And these models warned of the Global Financial Crisis before it happened.
Only joking: in these models, what happened in the real world is impossible.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
We should refer to this prize in future as the Nobble Prize in Economics
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Amen to both these observations.
I have a name
@dontknowbutgot1
Steve Keen did. And he did not predict 1000 of the last 0 hyperinflations
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
The idiots celebrate more voodoo economists, just as the world’s climate collapses!
eaarthnet.substack.com/p/how-economists-are-quietly-engin… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
1/12 This Nobel offers a perfect opportunity to revisit a deeper question: how did one particular vision of economic reality become the standard by which all macroeconomics is judged? The story involves more than science. It involves power, institutions, and exclusion.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Gözüktüğü kadarıyla bu iki arkadaş hakkında yorum yapanlar iki gruba ayrılıyorlar: 1) Övgü düzenler, 2) Küfür edenler. İki grup birden haklı olamaz. Hangi grubun haklı olduğu konusunda kararı, yaşadıklarını şöyle bir gözden geçirdikten sonra halk vermelidir. Yaşadığınız güzelliklerde bu iki kişinin de sorumluluğu vardır. Yaşadıklarınız sizi mutluluktan uçuruyorsa birinci grup, küfür etmenize neden oluyorsa ikinci grup haklıdır.
Hande Demirel
@HandeDemireltv
2026 Nobel Ekonomi Ödülü, Robert E. Hall ve Michael Woodford’a verildi.
İki ekonomist, hanehalkı ve şirketlerin kararlarını ve geleceğe ilişkin beklentilerini temel alan modelleriyle, para ve maliye politikalarının ekonomik dalgalanmaları nasıl azaltabileceğini ortaya koyuyor.
Çalışmaları bugün de son derece güncel bir soruya ışık tutuyor: Enerji şokları karşısında enflasyonu kontrol altına alırken büyüme ve istihdam nasıl korunabilir? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Siz neden bu ödülü Ekonomik Bilimler Nobel Ödülü diye biliyorsunuz? Çünkü ciddiye aldığınız böyle papağanlar öyle diyip duruyorlar. Bu ödül Nobel ödülü değildir. İsveç Merkez Bankası’nın Alfred Nobel anısına verdiği bir ödüldür. Zaten ödülün üzerinde adı yazıyor. Yazan Nobel ödülü değil.
Bilkent Economics
@BilkentEconDept
Congratulations to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford on receiving the 2026 Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences!
Join us for our annual Nobel Prize Seminar on Monday, October 19, at 17:30, presented by Burçin Kısacıkoğlu.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
#fotw Daily Post 12
A Mars-sized rock hit the young Earth and made the Moon -without this: no tides, no axial tilt, no seasons, and probably no us.
Our climate is the last link in a long chain of crazy serendipity that we're now pulling apart
Pls share + tag 2
#fateoftheworld -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
In light of the Nobel Prize in economics being awarded to Woodford and Hall, here is John King's articles on microfoundations in general, published in my intro book, second edition (third edition coming soon).
68b1e6b9-c0f8-4cc2-99b9-e9ecab5ea499.filesusr.com/ugd/610… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
As you look at each chart, it's worth remembering...
"In a sense the budget deficit can be considered as an artificial export surplus." -Michał Kalecki 2/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr. William J. Ripple
@WilliamJRipple
Scientists worldwide: We invite you to sign the World Scientists’ Warning to Humanity: A Third Notice. 35 years after the first warning, we now declare a planetary emergency. If you are a scientist, please read, sign, and share. Go to this link: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfowKyf6N2l2xjqk0HB9dDPL…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
2013'te yazdığım EPW Nobel Ekonomi makalem buradan okunulabilir.
Şöyle bitiyordu:
My perception of the message of this year’s Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel is as follows. “Don’t lose faith in markets (Fama), but be a little sceptical about them (Shiller).”1 And, I close with the following quotation from Peter Nobel’s 11 October 2010 statement (Buzagio 2010).
"With no knowledge of economics, I have no opinions about the individual economics prize winners. But something must be wrong when all economics prizes except two were given to Western economists, whose research and conclusions are based on the course of events there, and under their influence. I can imagine Alfred Nobel’s sarcastic comments if he were able to hear about these prize winners. Above all else, he wanted his prizes to go to those who have been most beneficial to humankind, all of humankind!"
www.patreon.com/SabriOncu/posts/faith-and-in-172151236 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What nonsense. The delusional equilibrium models created by this lot are why you politicians walked blindfolded into the Global Financial Crisis.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
How strange then that these forward looking expectations didn’t see the Global Financial Crisis coming.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Banks don’t create money out of thin air. Neither do governments. When a bank makes a loan, it creates a deposit, but also a debt that must be repaid.
Every new dollar has a counterpart on someone’s balance sheet. Money creation is not magic. It’s accounting.
@Hard Fiat
@HardFiat
8. Private banks create money Out-Of-Thin-Air every time they approve a new loan. +90% of all money in circulation today has been created as debt by the private banking system. Then add the Cantillion effect.
Without this insight, any macro model will be deeply flawed. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Auch wenn sie sich Neu-Keynesianer nennen: Sie lieferten die theoretische Fundierung für die Idee, dass man eine Wirtschaft mithilfe von Zinsen lenken kann, wenn man nur den Staat kleinhält. Das war der Kern der neoliberalen Wende und damit die Abkehr vom Keynesianismus.
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Der Preis wurde an Forscher verliehen, die Geldpolitik als wirkungsmächtiger als Fiskalpolitik einschätzen. Ihre Modelle sind gescheitert. Sie sind u.a. der Grund für die dysfunktionalen Fiskalregeln überall sowie die steigenden Zinsen, welche die Energiepreise nicht senken.
-
Christine Lagarde
@Lagarde
My warm congratulations to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford on being awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics!
Your research on economic stabilisation has greatly improved our understanding of people's economic decisions and strengthened the foundations for effective policy.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What nonsense. The delusional equilibrium models created by this lot are why you politicians walked blindfolded into the Global Financial Crisis.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matt Stoller
@matthewstoller
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And what are you going to buy with your raspberry mate?
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Steve @ProfSteveKeen. We won.
www.bloomberght.com/2026-nobel-ekonomi-odulu-nun-sahipler… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
DouglasDowell
@DouglasDowellJD
What they should read instead @ProfSteveKeen
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Nobel Ekonomi ödülü, tarihin en büyük ahlaksızlıklarından biridir. Bu ödüle Nobeldir diyenlerler Türk Ceza Kanunu’nun “halkı yanıltıcı bilgiyi alenen yayma” suçunu işlediklerinden, Türkiye’de ters kelepçeyle gözaltına alınıp, tutuklanması gereken kişilerdir.
T. Sabri Öncü
@KeloglanBM
Kurum da kabul etmiyor, edemiyor. Ödülün adı açık: Alfred Nobel Anısına Sveriges Riksbank Ekonomik Bilimler Ödülü. Yani Nobel değil. Zaten edemez de. Yasal değil. Yok Nobel’in vasiyetinde öyle bir ödül.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Der Preis wurde an Forscher verliehen, die Geldpolitik als wirkungsmächtiger als Fiskalpolitik einschätzen. Ihre Modelle sind gescheitert. Sie sind u.a. der Grund für die dysfunktionalen Fiskalregeln überall sowie die steigenden Zinsen, welche die Energiepreise nicht senken.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Imagine winning a Nobel Prize in Physics for modeling planetary orbits based on the behavior of an individual particle.
Now imagine Neoclassical and New Keynesian economists insisting macroeconomics must be derived from individual behavior to be scientifically legitimate. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrea Roventini
@AndreaRoventini
1/3 La scelta del premio Nobel per l'economia è criticabile se si considerare la motivazione è quasi comica. Woodford è il padre dei modelli DSGE che NON sono riusciti a spiegare (non a prevedere!) la crisi del 2008, la maggiore dal 1929, e non hanno fornito nessuna policy utile.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
1/12 Economists working in the history of economic thought and heterodox economics have challenged the monetary architecture of Woodford's work for decades. The problem is not its formal sophistication, but the economic relationships that must disappear for the model to work.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Aykut Kibritçioğlu 🦋 @kibritcioglu.bsky.social
@akibritcioglu
Rethinking Economics Education: What Can "Systems Thinking" and "System Dynamics" Offer?
www.linkedin.com/pulse/rethinking-economics-education-wha…
#economics #systemsthinking #systemdynamics -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
Steve Keen, 5–12 Oct 2026
Book: How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism (Polity) still forthcoming. No new edition or Amazon listing.
Serialised chapter: “Of Mathematics, mathiness, mythematics, and mathemagics”, Chapter 20, 11 Oct. Paywalled after free teaser.
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/of-mathematics-mathiness-myt…
Mechanism: neoclassical equilibrium modelling as immature (Blatt 1983); Romer’s “mathiness” and “mythematics” apply mathematics to imaginary shocks (aether, phlogiston, trolls). Dynamic models from accounting identities produce Goodwin-type cycles, not equilibrium.
Description: critique of mathematical practice in neoclassical models and defence of definitions-based/system-dynamics methods. Prescription (use proper dynamics) is separate.
Flag: prior numbering inconsistency (a 12 Sep post was also labelled Chapter 19); this text appears new.
Posts:
• Substack/Patreon, 5 Oct: “Should Britain rejoin the EU?” (Debunking Economics podcast, 38:06, paid). profstevekeen.substack.com/p/should-britain-rejoin-the-eu YouTube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=E__ZMcI1DX8 Mechanism: shared currency (euro) leaves national economies exposed via endogenous money and missing monetary sovereignty; trade and supply-chain frictions. Description of arguments for/against rejoin and the euro. No strong prescription. Flag: Acast lists the episode as 30 Sep; Substack/YouTube posting is 5 Oct (possible re-post).
Talks/interviews: The above podcast. No other notable dated interviews or talks this week. X activity (@ProfSteveKeen) is routine replies and climate/debt mentions; no new major content.
Courses/tools: No Ravel or Minsky release. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
NK components under question -
Eyebrow-Raising Scorecard (Paper 3) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
So, they granted the prize again to an ill-informed, flawed theoretical reasoning.
Macroeconomy is not the simple sum of micro agents. Fallacy composition: 1+1≠2
Paradoxes of tranquility, debt and liquidity explain economic downturns better.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
2026 economic sciences laureates Robert E. Hall’s and Michael Woodford’s research has made us better equipped to manage economic downturns.
They laid the foundation of the New Keynesian paradigm, in which models are built upon microfoundations, which means from the bottom up. Economic outcomes are the result of millions of decisions made at the microlevel by households and businesses. Using models based upon this approach, rather than simply studying the economy from a macro perspective, like a bird’s eye view, Hall’s and Woodford’s research has generated a paradigm shift in the theory of stabilisation policy.
#nobelprize -
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
They're embarrassed by him, but not by their overall approach--which they also should be embarrassed by.
This is like awarding a prize in navigation to the captain of the Titanic. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
who said heterodox economists can't predict?
yet has there been a worst timed (not) Nobel in Economics, as straitjacket of inflation targeting chokes countries vulnerable to energy price shocks, central bank independence is under threat, neoliberalism is presumably dead?
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
if Michael Woodford gets the econ Nobel, I'll have an excuse to continue to subject my students to an essay on 'why Woodford is wrong on globalisation and monetary control'.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
After decades of rewarding their own, they now explicitly honor the rules of the game. Microfoundations were never a methodological choice, but the price of admission to economics. What admirable pluralism: invent the game, referee it, and hand out the prizes
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And these models warned of the Global Financial Crisis before it happened.
Only joking: in these models, what happened in the real world is impossible.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.”
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
There isn't a single text, read Michael Hudson and @ProfSteveKeen but start with this. share.google/HQHVlFOvTtPCrzbuH
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I’m going to hazard a guess, and say it’ll be a Neoclassical economist. If I’m right, do I win a prize too?
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
Coming up: We'll soon be announcing the recipient of the 2026 prize in economic sciences.
Stay tuned to discover who it will be.
Watch live: x.com/i/broadcasts/1pKkOXVdMjMKj
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene🇺🇸
@FmrRepMTG
Oh he sent me an email, I think I’ll respond.
So yes, actually you did do something wrong President Trump, let’s first start with your broken campaign promises.
You protected your pedophile rapists friends instead of women who were raped when they were just teenage girls and you STILL REFUSE to release the Epstein files.
You started an unprovoked war with Iran that the vast majority of Americans do NOT support. You killed hundreds of children at a school in Iran and innocent people and are responsible for 21 U.S. service members deaths and 865 wounded. Your stupid war that you claim you have won like 50 times has destroyed our bases in the Middle East and hundreds of billions of dollars worth of military equipment and weapons, while depleting our weapons and ammunitions.
You are supporting, funding, and aiding genocide in Gaza that has resulted in approximately 22,000 children murdered, thousands of children with amputations, and over 70,000 orphans. And your so called Board of “Peace” has done nothing to stop war and is planning to oversee the very profitable reconstruction and take over of Gaza. One can only guess who all will get those blood money contracts, the Epstein class and associates.
And let’s talk about the basics that every single US president is supposed to guarantee to its citizens. Affordable cost of living and affordable fuel in which you have 100% failed to deliver and actually driven inflation and irresponsibly driven the cost of gasoline and diesel to record high levels.
So did you do something wrong?
Yes in summary, YOU are the snake that you warned us all about in the poem you read over and over.
You never cared about putting America first or making America great again.
You are the deep state, the Epstein class, and America last.
And my mistake was supporting you in the first place. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Aes🇺🇸
@AesPolitics1
Marjorie Taylor Greene just wrote her best tweet ever.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You’re assuming that the USA will live another 50 years? Brave call under current circumstances…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
US regime change operations around the world are destroying the lives of ordinary people.
Respect sovereignty.
No nation has the right to intervene in another nation's internal affairs. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prem Sikka
@premnsikka
If voters aren’t better off by the next election, we’re screwed’: Labour insiders voice fears over budget.
Cue for the Chancellor to,
Nationalise water and energy
Increase income tax personal allowance
End profiteering
End corporate welfare
Redistribute
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/10/labour-fears-budg… -
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You’re assuming that the USA will live another 50 years? Brave call under current circumstances…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
1/10
Niall Ferguson claims the US is in "big trouble" because debt interest payments now exceed defense spending. He calls it "Ferguson's Law."
I call it a fundamental misunderstanding of double-entry bookkeeping.
Here is why the debt panic is wrong. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Platform Radio
@platformradioYT
The Healey budget MUST:
Increase public investment.
Nationalise the arms industry.
Introduce a universal Job Guarantee.
Tax the rich and corporations fairly.
Establish a universal income floor.
Andrew Griffith MP
@griffitha
John Healey must get a grip in his first Budget, not kick the can down the road again.
That’s why we Conservatives are setting him five simple tests.
We need difficult decisions to make Britain prosperous again. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Touche once again. Soon they’ll be wishing for the gentler days of my barbs!
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
A representative from the Mises Institute reached out and asked me to stop posting ragebait about them.
I informed him that, for a monthly fee, we could work something out.
They called that extortion.
I told them it was simply human action guided by purposeful behavior. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is so true. They make the same mistake as economists, thinking global warming will have the same trivial impact as variation across the planet does, where a 5C difference barely matters. Over time, +5C is extinction, 3C is catastrophic, 2C is dangerous. We’ll hit 1.8+ next year when the el niño peaks. Cognitive dissonance, as well as catastrophic climate events, is about to hit billions of people.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You know, this guy!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
An international group of young economists/students trying to move the standard university economics curriculum beyond neoclassical dogma. I'm an older 'solidarity member' and give them a few quid every month. Important work. Give it some consideration. rethinkeconomics.org
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Meidas_Charise Lee
@charise_lee
MILITARY INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX = MAKES PROFITS FOR CORPORATIONS‼️
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
No, he has a point. America did have a history of lynching, after all...
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Amen to this!
Malcolm Reavell
@malcolm_reavell
The welfare state is perfectly sustainable. What isn’t is a false liturgy of economic illiteracy that stated with Margaret Thatcher.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You know, this guy!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is so true. They make the same mistake as economists, thinking global warming will have the same trivial impact as variation across the planet does, where a 5C difference barely matters. Over time, +5C is extinction, 3C is catastrophic, 2C is dangerous. We’ll hit 1.8+ next year when the el niño peaks. Cognitive dissonance, as well as catastrophic climate events, is about to hit billions of people.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“If an opinion contrary to your own makes you angry, that is a sign that you are subconsciously aware of having no good reason for thinking as you do. If some one maintains that two and two are five, or that Iceland is on the equator, you should feel pity rather than anger, unless you know so little of arithmetic or geography that his opinion shakes your own contrary conviction. The most savage controversies are those about matters as to which there is no good evidence either way. Persecution is used in theology, not in arithmetic, because in arithmetic there is knowledge, but in theology there is only opinion. So whenever you find yourself getting angry about a difference of opinion, be on your guard; you will probably find, on examination, that your belief is going beyond what the evidence warrants.”
— Bertrand Russell, An Outline of Intellectual Rubbish -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Ain’t this the truth!
Saganism
@Saganismm
“The greatest dangers to liberty lurk in insidious encroachment by men of zeal, well-meaning but without understanding.”
— Louis Brandeis -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
"What distinguishes our species is thought. The cerebral cortex is in a way a liberation. We need no longer be trapped in the genetically inherited behavior patterns of lizards and baboons: territoriality and aggression and dominance hierarchies. We are each of us largely responsible for what gets put into our brains. For what as adults we wind up caring for and knowing about. No longer at the mercy of the reptile brain, we can change ourselves. Think of the possibilities."
- Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Johnny Midnight ⚡️
@its_The_Dr
lol! Danny Devito pulled a prank on Arnold during the filming of Twins.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ted Reese
@Grossmanite
Seeing so many of these long posts about why China is racing ahead of Europe and none of them mention China's relatively high level of state ownership. It simply does not occur to ppl that state ownership (ie deprivatisation) lowers production costs
Angelo Giuliano 🇨🇭🇮🇹
@angeloinchina
Why European carmakers are losing to China
Look at the numbers from Volkswagen’s factories in Germany and China. It is hard to understand how European manufacturers are supposed to compete if these figures are accurate.
Emden, Germany
- Labour cost: €74 per hour
- Effective working hours: 1,282 a year
- Sick leave: 10.5%
- Vehicles per employee: 29 a year
- Factory cost per vehicle: €4,850
Tianjin, China
- Labour cost: €12 per hour
- Effective working hours: 2,065 a year
- Sick leave: 1%
- Vehicles per employee: 51.3 a year
- Factory cost per vehicle: €1,078
Portugal falls somewhere in between, but the gap between Germany and China is enormous.
So why is the debate in Europe always about Chinese competition, subsidies and tariffs, rather than the cost of making things at home?
European industry has to deal with high energy prices, expensive labour and production costs that make it increasingly difficult to compete. These are real problems, and pretending otherwise will not bring factories back or save jobs.
Brussels has responded by imposing tariffs of 17–35% on Chinese electric vehicles. But tariffs cannot make European factories cheaper to run. They can raise the price of imported cars, but they do nothing to fix the problems facing European manufacturers.
There is another point worth remembering. For years, European companies moved production to China because it was cheaper. They invested there, built factories and benefited from the business opportunities. Nobody complained when it worked in their favour.
Now Chinese manufacturers have become serious competitors, and suddenly the rules of the game are being questioned.
Of course, the car industry is more complicated than a simple comparison of factory costs. Technology, supply chains, subsidies and the models being produced all matter. But the cost gap cannot simply be brushed aside.
Europe needs to ask itself some difficult questions. Why has manufacturing become so expensive? Why are its factories struggling to keep pace? And why does the response so often seem to be protectionism rather than fixing the underlying problems?
You cannot keep blaming China while ignoring what has gone wrong at home. If Europe wants to save its car industry, it needs to make producing cars in Europe competitive again. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Tenemos bancos que crean dinero, Estados que emiten deuda y un BCE que fija tipos y compra bonos, pero seguimos explicando la financiación como si viviéramos en una isla donde Robinson Crusoe reparte sus cocos entre la IA y Hacienda.
La macroeconomía premonetaria nunca muere
Santiago Calvo
@SantiCalvo_Eco
Durante años, los Estados se acostumbraron a financiar sus déficits en un mundo de ahorro abundante, tipos bajos y bancos centrales dispuestos a comprar deuda. Pero ese mundo está desapareciendo.
Ahora, las grandes tecnológicas compiten con los Estados por captar capital para financiar sus inversiones en inteligencia artificial. Mientras tanto, las necesidades de financiación pública siguen creciendo y los inversores son cada vez más exigentes.
Ahora mismo la credibilidad fiscal vuelve a importar, y mucho.
Los países que mantengan déficits estructurales elevados, acumulen deuda y no ofrezcan una trayectoria fiscal creíble se arriesgan a pagar una prima creciente por financiarse. Y unos mayores intereses significan menos recursos disponibles para otras políticas públicas.
La subida de los tipos no se traslada inmediatamente a toda la deuda, pero sí progresivamente conforme se refinancia.
Por eso, la disciplina fiscal no es un capricho ideológico ni una obsesión por cuadrar las cuentas. Es una condición para preservar la capacidad de actuación del Estado.
Magnífico artículo de @judith_arnal. Muy conveniente, especialmente en España, donde a veces parece que las restricciones presupuestarias son algo que solo afecta a los demás.
www.elmundo.es/economia/macroeconomia/2026/10/11/6ac6728e… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Faizal
@zalkad
Kenapa Prancis anak sekolahnya punya mental revolusioner:
1. Orang tua Prancis memperlakukan anak-anak mereka sebagai individu yang berhak berbicara sejak dini, seperti yang dijelaskan dalam buku Bringing Up Bébé.
2. Pelajaran filsafat itu wajib sejak SMA, kurikulum resmi.
3. Ujian nasionalnya berupa esai dengan pertanyaan isu sosial-politik, contohnya: "Apakah kita adalah penguasa atas diri kita sendiri?"
4. Mengenal tradisi sosial bernama La Grève, yang artinya mogok/protes.
Makanya, Prancis menjadi salah satu negara dengan tingkat keterlibatan dalam aksi protes publik (manifestation) tertinggi di Eropa.
Rajdhani
@inthemood4life
I think teenager di indog melek "politik"nya cuma sebatas ngatain pemerintah, mereka ngga bener-bener tau apa yang harus dilakuin dan gimana cara benerin systemnya selain dari "menangin pemilu selanjutnya" karena it would not solve all the problems
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Neoclassical economists make only two moves.
1. Here are some ideas that are total bollocks.
2. Here's some fancy maths to make them look real. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Unas cuentas públicas"saneadas" suena estupendamente...mal. Una economía puede cumplir objetivos fiscales y acumular déficits de vivienda, infraestructuras e inversión.
Confundir la salud económica con el saldo presupuestario es un diagnóstico peculiar. Sufrimiento autoinducido
Afra BR
@AfraBlanco
HOY, Feijóo (PP), en precampaña:
«Propongo un cambio total. Un cambio contundente. 𝗨𝗻 𝗚𝗼𝗯𝗶𝗲𝗿𝗻𝗼 𝗾𝘂𝗲 𝗼𝘀 𝗽𝗶𝗱𝗮 𝗦𝗔𝗖𝗥𝗜𝗙𝗜𝗖𝗜𝗢».
Que quede claro: SA-CRI-FI-CIO.
𝗘𝗡 𝗧𝗢𝗗𝗔 𝗟𝗔 𝗖𝗔𝗥𝗔. ✂️
Dicho queda. Tú verás. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
In 2020, the ECB bought bonds to calm financial markets. Yet whenever austerity returns, we're told states are helpless before the markets.
Funny how monetary sovereignty comes to the rescue when capital is in trouble, but vanishes when workers face insecurity.
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
Mélenchon Is Right About France’s Debt. When, in the name of moderation, centrists brand every sensible alternative to severe austerity as “nonsense,” they leave voters only one electable rebellion on offer, and the far right is happy to supply it. That is what is happening in France today. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/sensible-melenchon-f…
-
The Shallow State
@OurShallowState
On Face the Nation, Markwayne Mullin was asked why a decision was made to livestream a public execution. His response was: "Because the President is restoring American values."
I hereby designate my Alliteration of the Day as Alliteration of the Week:
Markwayne Mullin is a moron.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
No, he has a point. America did have a history of lynching, after all...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Stefan Rahmstorf 🌏 🦣
@rahmstorf
A new study has examined 20,736 scientific publications about climate tipping points. Several of those are estimated to be crossed around 1.5 degrees warming, i.e. any time soon: permafrost thaw, Greenland Ice Sheet, North Atlantic Subpolar Gyre.
theconversation.com/some-climate-tipping-points-are-being… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saul Staniforth
@SaulStaniforth
2017 Labour 70.1% Green 3.4%
2019 Labour 64.5% Green 4.8%
2024 Labour 48.9% Green 10.4%
2026 Labour 45.2% Green 32.8%
Our media this morning: Will Zack Polanski resign? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
"...the bond market stops giving it the benefit of the doubt." What does this mean? Global wealth funds looking to indebt, asset-strip and buy everything in sight to rent out won't 'invest' in the goods and services France really needs because they won't get enough free money back as 'interest'.
So when France issues euros to pay for what it needs, the moneylenders start panicking about being crowded out, private agencies start downgrading the nation's credit status, traders helped by supine central bankers start manipulating money markets to demand more free money and trigger an inflationary spike, and bought-off politicians and mass media whip up a mass panic to discredit the government.
Let's call this what it is - a locked-in system of global usury, the extortionate private moneylending once condemned by all the major religions. Only the wealthy and their grubby little technicians will prosper in such a system. It's like the world run by Wonga International.
The revolution we need is actually a 4,400 year restoration - to restore the issue of currency as a public utility for investment in social needs and targeted, sustainable economic growth. Not necessarily what will give private moneylenders safe havens and the most free money in the shortest time. But this time we clamp down harder on those who seek to corrupt the system for personal gain. Can't wait to kick the bastards in their opportunity costs so hard they'll never recover. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
PEACE TV
@TvTvpeace
✡️ 🇮🇱 – Un écrivain juif antisioniste, Benjamin Moser, explique à Piers Morgan ce que les sionistes ont toujours recherché : la suprématie juive au Moyen-Orient et le fait que le projet sioniste plonge ses racines civilisationnelles dans le christianisme.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John Pitchford🌹💙
@Johnnypapa64
Good morning, this is from Ireland’s greatest comedian: Happy To Be An Atheist, have a fantastic day.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
How to Think About Macroeconomics:
1. Start with accounting identities and balance sheets, not theoretical assumptions.
2. View the economy as a system of interconnected sectors, not a collection of indicators.
3. Strictly distinguish between stocks and flows.
4. Explain economic phenomena through causal mechanisms, not mere correlations.
5. Distinguish between real resource constraints and nominal financial constraints.
6. Do not conflate accounting identities, theoretical hypotheses, and empirical regularities.
7. Analyze economic processes in historical time, accounting for fundamental uncertainty and path dependence. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Aykut Kibritçioğlu 🦋 @kibritcioglu.bsky.social
@akibritcioglu
“… mathematical logic is still challenging for most people. This is why Forrester developed system dynamics: to provide a means by which dynamic models of any system could be built by creating a causal model of the process using flowcharts. Neoclassicals will of course dismiss these models as “ad hoc”. But in fact, system dynamics models of the economy are identical in their behavior to the definitions-based models …”
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mathematics, mathiness, mythematics, and mathemagics in economics
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/of-mathematics-172025482 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mathematics, mathiness, mythematics, and mathemagics in economics
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/of-mathematics-172025482 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝐌𝐞𝐥𝐨𝐝𝐢𝐞𝐬 & 𝐌𝐞𝐦𝐨𝐫𝐢𝐞𝐬 ✨
@ninhnguynt22334
Two Minutes. One Take. Nothing to Hide!
Recorded in December 1964, this extraordinary two-minute performance was captured in a single, unedited take—no flashy cuts, no Auto-Tune, no digital polish. Just the artist, the camera, and a moment that had to be perfect in real time.
Every breath, glance, and note was exposed. Behind those effortless two minutes were millions of rehearsals and enormous pressure: one mistake could mean starting all over again.
That is what makes this footage so powerful. In an age of filters and endless editing, its raw honesty still feels remarkable intimate.
Sometimes, the most timeless performances are the ones with nothing to hide. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Every year, humanity churns out entire battalions of macroeconomists who don’t understand even the basics of accounting.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Truth Matters
@politicsusa46
Take a listen to this and tell me Kathryn Anne Edwards is wrong I dare you, and I’ll call you a liar.
Trickle down and the Laffer Curve are a joke. The laffer Curve should have been called the Laughter Curve, because the rich have been laughing at workers ever since the phase was coined.
If worker wages had kept up with corporate greed since the 1970s, American wages would be double what they are today and there would be no economic or affordability crisis.
My thanks to Jon Stewart for the clip
🎥 TikTok - vm.tiktok.com/ZN8BF7H7A/This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Angelica 🌐⚛️🇹🇼🇨🇳🇺🇸
@AngelicaOung
RED LEFT VS WHITE LEFT
I’ve always been kind of confused by the derogatory term “baizhuo” literally meaning “white left” in Chinese. Now I think I’m getting it.
“White left” is the left of the west. It’s what I kind of think of as left because I grew up in the west. Pro-LGBT, feminist, soft-on-drugs, soft-on-crime, anti the dominant religion but fiercely protective of religious minorities, chooses environmentalism over growth. On economic issues they are pro-egalitarianism but favors welfarism, rent control, unionization to level out inequality. Very passionate about free speech, human rights and other causes of progressivism.
The left of China, which I will call “red left” in differentiation so we don’t end up in argument about what is the true left, is completely different. At best they will see identitarian issues as time-wasting culture wars and at worst they may be actively hostile to sexual minorities and those who indulge in substances even as soft as marijuana. The religious are viewed with extreme suspicion.
They are materialists and I think the clearest point is on feminism. They are very feminist in encouraging participation of women in the workforce but the moment it becomes a question of identity they are against it. On environmental matters they are for it but only after a certain amount of wealth has been reached.
On the tools of the white left to achieve egalitarianism they are scornful. To them those are half-measures that allow the entrenched imperialist-capitalist structure to stay in place while placating the masses with creature comforts.
The red left has boundless contempt for the white left because they think the white left took its eyes off the ball and may have been psyoped into ineffectiveness.
The white left might look at the red left and say that they are not left at all anymore but almost indistinguishable from fascists since they embrace nationalism and exceedingly competitive markets and conformity. They have become what it is they hated one compromise at a time.
The red left’s critique is about the white left getting libbed out and forgetting about securing the bag. The white left said the red left has forgotten about the fundamental importance of dismantling power structures to emancipate the people and ultimately put themselves under another yoke.
Each thinks the other has been tricked into abandoning the true struggle. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gramps
@GrandpaHarris65
BREAKING
Pete Hegseth announced a plan to livestream his next colonoscopy. According to Hegseth, the public deserves to know just how big of an asshole he really is. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
What if we extended Godley Tables to account for natural capital, not just money?
Financial balances tell one story. Ecological balances tell another.
This essay argues we need both.
👉 www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/mmt-and-doughnut-1688…
#mmt #systemsthinking #naturalcapital #economics -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
gael
@gaelpercocet
the level of intellect this movie carries is insane, Realizing in real time that the twist is criticizing all of us for sitting back and just watching as the world goes to shit and treating it like entertainment instead of taking action made me love this so much more
Tom Cruise
@TomCruise
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mandy Patinkin
@PatinkinMandy
The theater was packed. When it was finished the audience just sat there as the credits rolled. Stillness. You know how rare that is for people to not jump up and start yammering or scrolling or move on to the next thing? There was stillness and awe, gratitude and sorrow and astonishment both with the film and this world we have allowed.
This movie being slammed by reviewers is beyond comprehension. Anyone who is dragging this piece through the mud should get a brain scan or see it again as they must not have been paying attention. This is one of the most daring, original, provocative pieces of art I’ve seen and bravo to every person that laid a hand on it. I’d have given my right arm to be an extra in this movie (I’m right handed).
This craft, like many other things nowadays, feels in peril. The systems at play encourage mass appeal above all else. Digger is a battle cry for art, for waking up, for demanding an actual attention span of your audience and for the miracle of having a point of view. To horrify, delight, wildly surprise repeatedly and inspire us to fight for our world before it’s too late is an incredible accomplishment. Don’t listen to rotten tomatoes. Find an actual person who saw this movie. Listen to them. Tomato tomaaato! Fuck that stupid nonsense percentage bullshit. It’s so dumb. Go see this movie.
Thank you @diggerthemovie !
#diggerthemovie #diggerthemovie #film #art #wowThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mathematics, mathiness, mythematics, and mathemagics in economics
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/of-mathematics-172025482 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter D Carter
@PCarterClimate
NOAA: EL NINO FORECAST, STRONG TO VERY STRONG
A very strong El Niño could increase global temperature by another 0.3°C www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/analysis_monitoring/enso_a…
#elnino #climatechange #globalwarming -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
NoConscriptionLeague
@noconleague
Speak up before it is too late.
If we fail to organise, conscription officers will come to Britain. They will grab your fathers, your brothers and your sons to die in a Ukrainian ditch or Iranian dune. The enemy is at home, not abroad.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a very good anti-war video.
Workers Party of Britain
@WorkersPartyGB
Ask yourself: Who stands to gain?
Who stands to lose everything?
There is still time.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
With the luckiest students in the world tonight. World-class ultra-modern universities token fees full-board and lodgings. Learning practical subjects to take their place in the biggest manufacturing economy in the history of the world. China is simply unbeatable.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Scary Marc
@marconeats
Just endorsed. Working in cold climate farming research, I can confirm the shifts in growing seasons and soil conditions are not decades away. The public needs to internalize that much sooner.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Michael Thrower Chowdhury
@BevansAdvocate
Updated for economists
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minutes!
www.youtube.com/live/lddiN1LsF50 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Itai Yanai
@ItaiYanai
1. CRISPR came from basic research on bacteria.
2. Optogenetics started with a discovery in algae.
3. The GFP protein comes from jellyfish.
The biggest breakthroughs all trace to scientists follow their curiosity. This is one huge reason why we must keep funding basic research! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
MMT has its flaws - import/export etc. - but it's worth its place as a detailed description of how fiat systems operate. And you didn't cover money-market discipline, always the first obstacle to the implementation of socialist policies. Nobody will argue against building a strong working-class movement, but the complex technical issue of beating down the bond/FX vigilantes in a locked-in global financial system running on 'investor confidence' is a priority. Good to see Melenchon making noises about this, but we must know how to do it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
What would a real resource scoring procedure look like as a pre-budget exercise? I go through the steps here. It would be something for the new Fiscal Referees! #mmt #realresourcescoring #greenparty www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/asset-register-151920282
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
"@anupartanen's comparison of her native Finland with her adopted country, the United States, highlights this point. Partanen finds that many Americans don’t have access to high-quality, affordable health insurance, child care, housing in good school districts, college, and senior care. This, she points out, diminishes not only Americans’ security but also their freedom:
“Most people, including myself, assumed that part of what made the United States a great country, and such an exceptional one, was that you could live your life relatively unencumbered by the downside of a traditional, old-fashioned society: dependency on the people you happened to be stuck with. In America you had the liberty to express your individuality and choose your own community. This would allow you to interact with family, neighbors, and fellow citizens on the basis of who you were, rather than on what you were obligated to do or expected to be according to old-fashioned thinking. The longer I lived in America … the more puzzled I grew. For it was exactly those key benefits of modernity — freedom, personal independence, and opportunity — that seemed, from my outsider’s perspective, in a thousand small ways to be surprisingly missing from American life today…. In order to compete and to survive, the Americans I encountered and read about were … beholden to their spouses, parents, children, colleagues, and bosses in ways that constrained their own liberty.”
Read more: evonomics.com/big-government-bad-freedom-civil-society-ha… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Polly Tickal
@BubblesToBurst
Henry Ford’s criticism of international bankers manipulating economies and controlling and funding both sides of wars led to him being denounced for antisemitism.
In the early 1920s, he ran a 91-part series titled, “The International Jew: The World’s Problem” in a Dearborn newspaper he owned. Unlike today, the “antisemite” label only made him more popular at the time as a working class hero.
Senex
@senex_official
“The finances of the world are in the control of Jews; their decisions and their devices are themselves are our economic law”- Henry Ford.
Henry Ford believed that both world wars were started by international Jewish bankers so that they could collect compound interest from both sides.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
67,000 of those job losses were among workers aged 15–24, during back-to-school season. Seasonal adjustment isn't perfect.
Private-sector employment is UP 163,000 year-over-year.
Another fucking retarded take from an American Austrian economist on Canada's economy.
Peter St Onge, Ph.D.
@profstonge
In 2 months Canada lost 110,000 jobs -- in US population terms that's half a million a month 🤯
Elbows up, jobs gone. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Digger is more like a play than a film.
It at least tries to address this suicidal course we are all on though I don’t think the film fans raving about it seem to be connecting with the crisis.
Either way I couldn’t recommend it more.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Thomas Reis
@peakaustria
Do not get me wrong civil protest and going vegan are all nice 👍 but we also need cooling of the ocean surface. It is already too hot 🔥 for our beach 🏖️the Fish and the clouds: not tomorrow - when our individual action may show results. Also governments and Institutions have to do something not the Individuums the Consumer.
Thomas Reis
@peakaustria
Penguin populations are collapsing. Going vegan or civil protests will not easy fix warming.
Restoration like floating geysers that do the shore aerosol and upwelling magic?
“Reduction in krill availability associated with regional warming, as found across the rest of the Scotia Sea, rather than the volcanic eruption of Zavodovski in 2016 or competition from krill fisheries.”
www.cell.com/current-biology/fulltext/S0960-9822(26)01186-3 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I’ve signed. Please add to this. The emergency is far sooner than the public has been deluded into believing, by both fossil fuel companies but also, crucially, economists.
Dr. William J. Ripple
@WilliamJRipple
We invite everyone (nonscientists) to endorse the Declaration of a Planetary Emergency, part of the upcoming World Scientists’ Warning to Humanity: A Third Notice. Add your name and share widely. Your endorsement helps show public concern about our planet. docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdlPKM-SC5BiieIX7waPauyV…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof Julia Steinberger
@JKSteinberger
Even seasoned climate activists don't know about the very near term (1.5-2 degrees warming) tipping point risks of the AMOC collapse for Europe and the rest of the world. This fact is terrifying.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I wish I'd been doing economics during the Great Financial Crisis (2007–09).
Someone challenged me, claiming none of my models could have forecast it out of sample.
Well, here's my Goodwin Business Cycle model at GDP Dynamics, using data through Q4 2006.
Notice the recession warnings.
"All models are wrong, but some are insightful"
-George Box
This would have been insightful... -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steven Bartlett
@StevenBartlett
Economist Steve Keen says Bitcoin is going to zero because of how much energy it needs. He could have bought it for a pound a coin, but says when the world has to cut its energy use, the two easiest things to cut are "cryptocurrencies and international travel."
@ProfSteveKeenThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
This makes a lot of sense. Otherwise, Europe will be talking bond yields until 2029.
Finance Watch
@forfinancewatch
Yesterday, our Secretary General @ibuscke discussed the #eubudget & proposed European #competitivenessfund.
She made clear that "the EU must make a serious commitment to modernising the European debt rules" to enable investment in the future! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
1. Capitalism at this point can only survive by destroying itself and the world.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6zxjrekg29zo -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I’ve signed. Please add to this. The emergency is far sooner than the public has been deluded into believing, by both fossil fuel companies but also, crucially, economists.
Dr. William J. Ripple
@WilliamJRipple
We invite everyone (nonscientists) to endorse the Declaration of a Planetary Emergency, part of the upcoming World Scientists’ Warning to Humanity: A Third Notice. Add your name and share widely. Your endorsement helps show public concern about our planet. docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdlPKM-SC5BiieIX7waPauyV…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
If you want to predict the trajectory of a national economy you need to understand three things:
1. Double entry bookkeeping
2. The three sector financial balances equation
3. Reserve accounting in your jurisdiction
Forget the stuff they taught you in economics lessons. #mmt -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Funny how the same people that said MMT cannot be applied or should not be applied now say that it actually has been applied and that the results are horrible.
So, which governments were advised by MMT economists? Name just one. (And no, QE and deficit spending have nothing to do with MMT. MMT argues mostly against QE because it does not do much and it says that deficit spending does not exist because all government spending is money creation.)
Brian Wesbury
@wesbury
We are seeing a total failure of MMT around the globe.
QE and deficit spending (after 2008 and during COVID) was basically an attempt at Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). In a nutshell, MMT says that we can print and deficit spend at will without any fiscal or economic complications.
So, central banks held interest rates at zero, forcing markets to accept absurdly low rates. At the same time, these central banks printed massive amounts of money and absorbed a lot of this new debt themselves.
MMTers said we could do this with no inflation. Clearly they were wrong. Friedman taught us exactly what would happen, and it did. Inflation took off. The result, central banks were forced to raise rates and stop expanding their balance sheets.
So far, governments have resisted fiscal sanity and are still running massive deficits even though central banks stopped funding them.
The result? In the past 3 months, 10-year bond yields are up 50 bps in the UK, 90 bps in France, 72 bps in the US, and more than 40 bps in Germany.
Governments were already too big in 2008, but this crazy experiment over the past 18 years has pushed things toward a breaking point.
France proposes to freeze government pay and pensions, and raise some taxes and we should expect more movement toward austerity in other countries soon.
MMT is basically Keynesianism on steroids. It didn’t work. The fix is a revival of Austrian, supply-side economics. Smaller governments, lower tax rates, tighter money, and less regulation. Some will say this is a pipe dream. But it is the only way out. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
How can investors have "confidence" that they can get their money back when they invest when there is a dysfunctional fiscal framework that creates a permanent lack of aggregate demand?
www.rapporteur.com/opinion/europe-doesnt-have-a-savings-p… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
INSIDER REPORT: Food supplies at the wholesale level are drying up. Shocking losses in food availability are appearing now, affecting U.S. buyers. These supply chain cracks will trickle to the retail level in the coming months. Restaurants will be impacted with certain shortages. Costs will skyrocket. And outside of North America, many regions of the world will face devastating FAMINE in 2027 - 2028.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
American Exception
@Aaron_Good_
I have said something like this for a while--China's regime is functionally far more democratic than that of the US. The Chinese state demonstrably serves the interests of the national majority far better than does the American state. There's no contest.
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
I want to invite people into a thought experiment, one that I suspect many will find insane.
The thought experiment: China is more democratic than the US.
Numerous *Western* surveys have now found that the Chinese government enjoys more public support than the US government. On the question of legitimacy, China fares better.
China also does better at securing basic economic freedoms and meeting the material needs of its poor. What's the point of the ballot box when politics becomes performative and politicians aren't held accountable when they fail to deliver universal housing, healthcare, or education?
I suspect a big part of the explanation for the Chinese government's commitment to public service is that top-level politicians in China need a proven track record in the domain of public service delivery. The Chinese political system is highly meritocratic, unlike the American one. Becoming a top-level politician in the CPC requires decades of bureaucratic progression.
Of course, China isn't more democratic than the US on every measure. The US has a free press and open competition for political power, although both of these are highly influenced by corporate interests.
While I am not convinced there's a clear answer to this thought experiment, dismissing China as a tyrannical dictatorship is ignorant. There are examples of failed authoritarian states around the world (I've lived in one), and China is not one of them. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The "debt crisis" is over then the ECB says it is over.
Why give so much power to an independent organisation that is outside of political control? The ECB could have decided to bring out the TPI some months ago and none of this would have happened.
FT Europe
@ftbrussels
EU capitals caught between markets and metrics as debt fears rise ft.trib.al/mxBGify
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Latest version update to the GDY Dynamics Policy Simulator. It's pretty neat.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Version 1.12 is out for the @GDPDynamics Policy Simulator.
It now features causal loop diagrams for specific variables in the system. You can click on a variable in the plot legend and it will show a CLD of all the loops that variable is a part of.
www.gdpdynamics.com/policysimulatorThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
“We cannot come with new fiscal flexibilities all the time,” said EU economy commissioner Valdis Dombrovskis yesterday, warning this would undermine confidence in governments’ commitment to fiscal sustainability.
The ECB and the Commission are responsible for stabilising the government bond market. Do your job and accept that reality does not always conform to your neoliberal dreams. Government bonds are where monetary and fiscal policy meet, if you want it or not.
www.ft.com/content/782c8c63-0db5-499e-8a0b-b7e263bc1f97?s… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
When will politicians turn to MMT? The answer is: in a time of crisis when it is apparent that neoliberalism has failed. And when will that be? Quite soon, on the basis of current progress. youtu.be/0S5Ad4WpCCE
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
This is not funny. It describes reality. Central banks are the banks of the government. They create money and they buy debt to establish government bonds as the riskless asset, on which monetary policy builds. #learnmmt
Ronnie Stoeferle
@RonStoeferle
....
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
A friendly message to my Austrian Economic friends concerning aggregation and my approach using System Dynamics.
I feel my good Austrian friends are confusing the behavior of individual actors with the behavior of the system they collectively constitute.
Knowing everyone's intentions doesn't necessarily explain aggregate outcomes.
As you're clearly coming from the Austrian economic view, I won't bother getting into the ought or ought not of state intervention, which is a normative discussion that does not further the point I'm about to make. Frankly, I'm not interested in the perverse subjective views of the "economist."
It is, however, worth noting that evaluating state intervention requires understanding macroeconomic dynamics. But as someone who works in the private sector, I can tell you that plenty of private firms have practical reasons to understand and model those dynamics as well.
I'll also add that nobody is claiming the macroeconomy is some living being with a mind of its own. It is, by definition, a social system consisting of interacting parts that collectively produce measurable patterns of behavior over time.
Understanding those dynamics provides additional information to individuals and firms, allowing them to make more informed decisions and consider a wider range of choices.
Ironically, this brings us to another important area of study in dynamic social systems.
Every individual or group within a system has its own objectives, objectives often influanced by the endogenous system wide behavior they observe. Some of those objectives are compatible, while others conflict. Even when individuals act rationally in pursuit of their own goals, their interactions can produce outcomes that are collectively undesirable.
And that's precisely my point, usually delivered in a sarcastic ragebait tweet.
While my good Austrian economic friends may have misinterpreted this as arrogance on my part, it actually comes from a place of boredom. This is something so blatantly simple for me to comprehend that I'm surprised it requires so much explanation:
The interaction of individual decisions, often made with perfectly reasonable intentions, can generate system-wide outcomes that nobody intended or wanted.
Understanding those outcomes requires studying not just the individuals, but the feedback structures created by their interactions in the confines of the cohorts and institutional norms the individuals inhabit. That's what System Dynamics is concerned with.
Ultimately, this will lead my good Austrian friends to claim they've eliminated the distinction between microeconomics and macroeconomics by pointing out that humans interact and it's all just economics, usually accompanied by questionable arguments involving praxeology, purposeful human action, etc.
But you see, regardless of the terminology, my good Austrian economic friends have described the very reason why studying human interactions at the system level matters.
And they don't even know they're describing the reasoning they resist.
Ironic.
Now, I will give Friedrich Hayek some credit here. His work on spontaneous order and dispersed knowledge recognized that complex social outcomes can emerge from individual interactions without anyone consciously designing or intending those outcomes.
In that respect, Hayek understood an important aspect of emergence in social systems. However, and in my qualified opinion working with non linear complex sysyem for a decade now, he never went far enough in relation to systemic wide endogenous phenomenon I'm defining as emergent.
I will end with this peace offering, in a way that only my abnormal, progressive but anti-woke mind can provide.
Ludwig von Mises, Friedrich Hayek, and Carl Menger are by far the worst retards I've encountered in economic literature, you dumb motherfuckers.
100 years from now, their contributions will be considered... Well... marginal.
No pun intended. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
yılmaz aydın
@yilmazaydin88
Biraz sıkıcı bir durum ama yanlışların sürekli tekrarlandîğı bir ortamda doğrular da sürekli tekrarlanmalı. Asıl sorun özel borç iken sürekli kamu borcu vurgusu para konusunu bilmemektir.
Simeranyalı Samim
@SimeranyaliSam
Aynı zamanda küresel özel sektör alacağı 111 trilyon dolara çıkmış demek bu. Tüm özel sektörü hane halkıyla-şirketiyle bir bilançoda konsolide etseydik, bu 111 trilyon dolar özsermayenin likit kısmını oluştururdu. Özel sektörün aralarındaki borçlanmalar ise birbirlerini götürür.+
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
How Asset inflation sells it's own cure
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
We can't. Debt that can't be paid won't be paid. This is why a serious crash would, a la 1929, end up in a deflationary vortex. Credit is retracted, effective demand plummets and assets lose their value. This is an opportunity for asset-strippers to buy up in the fire-sale. We can't allow that to happen - the fundamental political struggle would be to take all major tangible assets into public ownership.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oktay Özden
@oktayozdn
Hepsi birbirinden dev. Örneğin
P. Garegnani.. çalışmaları neoklasik teoriyi adeta darmadağın etti. Tabiki de neoklasik iktisatçılar tüm bu çalışmalara yanıt vermek yerine salağa yatıp görmezden geldiler.
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
There was a chronological inconsistency: Polanyi died before the prize was established, so I replaced him with Garegnani. I found a different photo of Moore
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marty
@ethicalmartini
Yes, French students are revolting, and isn’t it glorious.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
Neoclassical economists are furious about my posters on the Nobel Prize in Economics. A few observations:
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
One thing is sure: If bonds do not blow up, at least not in those countries with their own currencies, then #mmt has carried the day as everybody else thought that they would. (And investors who listened to those commentators will have lost a lot of money, while hedge funds will have made a lot.)
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
The neoliberal mainstream constantly scaremongers over inflation and currency devaluation, falsely blaming them on 'government spending' and the 'money supply'. In fact currencies have been devaluing for centuries. The fundamental causes are the conflicting claims of sellers versus workers/consumers constantly jacking up prices and wages, cost-push price increases as supplies (particularly energy) become more expensive, and nominal growth needed to manage private debt and sustain employment and aggregate demand.
The US$ has lost 97% of its purchasing power since 1913, yet the nation constantly grew richer and after 1944 maintained a valuable reserve currency. What's more, as 1929 taught us, managed inflation is preferable to deflation. It's all panic over nothing, but the constant scaremongering functions politically because money market manipulators can temporarily accelerate the process, put the fear of God into everyone and force governments into fiscal tightening and austerity.
The system's imminent implosion isn't down to inflation and currency devaluation - in fact Western currencies are overvalued. The fundamental cause is the towering burden of private debt - not government debt - that producers and consumers are struggling to repay. This was the underlying factor behind the two major civilizational collapses we've seen since the private credit system was introduced. Remember - debt that can't be repaid won't be repaid, and when too many lenders stop lending and too many debtors stop repaying, a society shatters along its major socioeconomic fault line. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'm incredibly grateful for all the people that have purchased a copy of my new book over the past week.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
I want to invite people into a thought experiment, one that I suspect many will find insane.
The thought experiment: China is more democratic than the US.
Numerous *Western* surveys have now found that the Chinese government enjoys more public support than the US government. On the question of legitimacy, China fares better.
China also does better at securing basic economic freedoms and meeting the material needs of its poor. What's the point of the ballot box when politics becomes performative and politicians aren't held accountable when they fail to deliver universal housing, healthcare, or education?
I suspect a big part of the explanation for the Chinese government's commitment to public service is that top-level politicians in China need a proven track record in the domain of public service delivery. The Chinese political system is highly meritocratic, unlike the American one. Becoming a top-level politician in the CPC requires decades of bureaucratic progression.
Of course, China isn't more democratic than the US on every measure. The US has a free press and open competition for political power, although both of these are highly influenced by corporate interests.
While I am not convinced there's a clear answer to this thought experiment, dismissing China as a tyrannical dictatorship is ignorant. There are examples of failed authoritarian states around the world (I've lived in one), and China is not one of them. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
To understand the ongoing issues wit bond yields, this is a must-watch:
Distribution for the Digital Age 🎬
@giant_pictures
FINDING THE MONEY explores Modern Monetary Theory (MMT), challenging conventional ideas about money, government spending, debt, and deficits.
Watch it free now on the Giant Pictures YouTube channel:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=x3TJFoQWCHA -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
You can always come chat with me on my Discord Server.
discord.gg/gY8TgPthE -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"if France does need to be bailed out, it would be extremely expensive. As the second largest economy in the euro zone, France may have crossed the line from too big to fail to too big to save."
The ECB can buy (all) 🇫🇷 bonds with new €. Problem solved.
paulkrugman.substack.com/p/whats-the-matter-with-france -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Elizabeth Glab @lizglab.bsky.social
@LizGlab
Have you noticed how disconnected from reality mainstream economists are?
These four economists explain how we can move forward in creating a healthier economy and society for all.
A refreshing change from the current corrupt peddling of myths that only suit the top 1%. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The whole macroeconomic government structure is dysfunctional. Countries cannot hit their fiscal targets as every reduction in government spending leads to a reduction in tax revenues and there is no political will to tax wealth (which would not lead to lower tax revenues).
Michael A. Arouet
@MichaelAArouet
This chart perfectly explains why France is on a path to a debt crisis. French budgets are fairytales not worth the paper they are written on. Governments set targets to stabilize state finances only to miss them every time. Even the smallest reform attempts trigger the unions and paralyze the country with strikes.
It will not be different going forward. It is cute to hear the current government’s spending cuts plans or the RN’s alternative budget path. In reality, France will keep its absurd pension system and public spending as a percentage of GDP higher than the Soviet Union.
This game worked as long as markets financed it by absorbing more French debt. They have just stopped. Good luck France, good luck Eurozone. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
TheWhy?Curve
@CurveThewhy
It’s at the heart of the modern history of the Middle East, but what exactly is Zionism and where did it come from? @rdhearing and @loudmouthcomms ask Dr Matthew Bolton @QMSchoolofLaw
whycurve.com/episode/zionism -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'd like to thank the Austrian and Neoclassical economists who made this possible.
Without your contributions, I would have had significantly less material to work with. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
French school students explain why they are organising blockades of their schools and the brutality they have faced from the French police
France: student revolt and state repression
braveneweurope.com/national-politics/france-student-revol…
#france #politics #students #schools #repression -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Neoliberalism is failing, but what is it? This is a new version of our infographic on neoliberalism. AI drew the image. I wrote the text.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Macroeconomics is not applied microeconomics.
You cannot understand the behavior of an entire economic system simply by scaling up individual decisions.
Aggregation gives rise to emergent dynamics observed in the real world that do not exist at the individual level. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
“Taking the piss” isn’t Aussie enough for you? Fair dinkum Kvetchie, how much can a Koala Bear?
youtu.be/StcXGhuliRk -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thanks. Please share widely. Not understanding this is at the root of the social disasters caused by the Euro, which are at the heart of the protests in France right now.
Andy Lippok
@AndyLippok
Brilliant explanation, Steve!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
T accounts are where a lot of the confusion comes from. I've just blocked another moron who keeps throwing them at me. Welcome to the club. Ravel's Godley Tables are a far superior way to model the financial system.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
If aliens even tried to invade Earth right now, they would show up, take one look around, and say, "Daaaamn! This is more trouble than it's worth!" and do a light speed jump as far away as possible.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrew Bunker
@ndrew_bunker
Author of the Humbug Production Function who showed how mathematically illiterate most economists are
Mariana Mazzucato
@MazzucatoM
Very sad to hear about the passing of Anwar Shaikh [@shaikhecon], one of my beloved professors at the @TheNewSchool. He was a prolific thinker on capitalism, and always reminded us that to truly understand economics, we must go back to classical thinkers like Marx, Ricardo and Smith. The entire discipline is better off for his contributions, and he will be sorely missed!
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
On ya Mish!🙏🏽
We should do a show together on this. So many on the right are wrong about accounting.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
@MishGEA
The idea of @PeterSchiff that the US defaults on debt is not early, it's batshit crazy.
He has been promoting this BS for decades @NKozev.
Countries that owe debt in their own currency don't default.
Nor, since the dollar floats is there any realistic way to devalue. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This was an absolutely brilliant paper by Anwar. Taking the piss out of the Neoclassical theory of production and distribution.
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
En 1974 Shaikh cogió una función de producción y dibujó con ella una gráfica que decía "HUMBUG" (disparate, engaño). La función era matemáticamente correcta, pero con datos "torturados" podía dar lo que uno quisiera. Y económicamente no significaba nada.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
“Taking the piss” isn’t Aussie enough for you? Fair dinkum Kvetchie, how much can a Koala Bear?
youtu.be/StcXGhuliRk -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Is France signalling the end of neoliberalism? As a matter of fact, people will only stand for abuse from a financial system designed to oppress them for so long. France and maybe Spain seem to be indicating they've had enough. youtu.be/CpRl1ajsj-k
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
✊SEM✊
@razoor777
✊@BallyBagayoko protégeant le peuple.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eren Kırmızıaltın
@ErenKirmizialtn
Anwar Shaikh’in vefatı sonrasında, daha çok “Ulusların Zenginliğinin Ölçülmesi” ve “Kapitalizm: Rekabet, Çatışma, Krizler” başlıklı çalışmaları anılsa da, en az bu çalışmaları kadar önemli bir diğer çalışmasını (makalesini) da anmak gerek: 1974 tarihli “Laws of Production and Laws of Algebra: The Humbug Production Function”.
Shaikh bu makalesinde “HUMBUG” harflerini oluşturan verilerle Cobb-Douglas üretim fonksiyonunun bir totoloji olduğunu gösterdi. Neoklasik üretim fonksiyonlarının ampirik “başarısının” bir cebir yanılsaması olduğunu gösterdi. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
There is no Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences and the one that exists was created to fight Swedish social democracy.
press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691196312/the-nob… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Socialism seems more closely tied to ideas about human nature, while capitalism seems more closely tied to patterns of human behavior.
A subtle distinction, but an important one. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Gloninger, CCM, CBM
@ChrisGloninger
The chart just ran off its own axis
The El Niño chart topped out at 30C. The 2026 line went through the top and they extended the axis to 31.
Warmest water ever measured there, and it does not peak until December.
Wet California, dry Australia, probably the warmest year on record in 2027.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
Westerners will talk endlessly about the dangers of impeding authoritarianism and ignore being spied on by state, having the cops beat and kill their kids and have their services cut. But hey, at least we're not __fill in the blank___country. We're like lobsters in boiling water
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
spacebat
@spacebat
@ProfSteveKeen talks about a multi level economic model with energy/entropy at its root, and at the monetary system level of claims on future energy flows, he identifies mass accumulation of private debt - even without an energy supply shock - as the driver of financial collapses
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Money≡Work! BJ_Chippindale(Not Another Engineer)
@BJChippindale
Terry Pratchett - Making Money (amusingly correct)
Graeber - Debt, the first 5000 years
@profSteveKeen - The New Economics
Hudson - ...and forgive them their debts
Me - The Dice Are Always Loaded
@TyKeynes - Beyond Equilibrium
Many more... most are NOT amusing. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alicia Gerardo
@TheEconRebel
Rest in Power Anwar Shaikh
What Happens When Economics Doesn't Reflect the Real World?
youtu.be/qIlhSSL3gbY -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
New life goal: Replace Peter Thiel‘s book on rank 1 of the German best seller list for Political Economy with »Anti-fascist Economics«.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
T accounts are where a lot of the confusion comes from. I've just blocked another moron who keeps throwing them at me. Welcome to the club. Ravel's Godley Tables are a far superior way to model the financial system.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Being J Wood
@BeingJWood
At some point the military will be forced to side with Trump or side with the Constitution.
This seems inevitable. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
One can learn a lot about #economics from this book. Recommended.
press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691196312/the-nob… -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Someone alert The Mounties! Tyrone Keynes has been kidnapped!
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I hope Per Bylund wins.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
Save the date for the announcement of this year's prize in economic sciences.
Watch the breaking news at nobelprize.org and right here @NobelPrize: x.com/i/broadcasts/1pKkOXVdMjMKj
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
NBS Tennis
@NBSTennis
This Federer vs. Nadal rally might just be the greatest tennis rally of all time. 🤝
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
I miss Econ Twitter, so I'm launching my new Substack to provide a space for us to have a serious conversation about Anti-Fascist Economics.
✉️ Subscribe now - isabellamweber.substack.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This was an absolutely brilliant paper by Anwar. Taking the piss out of the Neoclassical theory of production and distribution.
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
En 1974 Shaikh cogió una función de producción y dibujó con ella una gráfica que decía "HUMBUG" (disparate, engaño). La función era matemáticamente correcta, pero con datos "torturados" podía dar lo que uno quisiera. Y económicamente no significaba nada.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrew Griffiths
@GlassJet
This is very good.
I'm beginning to worry I'm a frustrated accountant.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrew Griffiths
@GlassJet
That's excellent.
Why don't we ban the sale of bonds to the private sector? Or campaign for a policy to do so? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Policy Simulator:
www.gdpdynamics.com/policysimulator
Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics (New Book)
a.co/d/025Yn07m
Become a paid member at GDP Dynamics:
members.gdpdynamics.com/membership -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Esteban Cruz
@Evanshm
My prediction for this year’s Nobel Prize in Economics is that it will be awarded to those who contribute something that can be incorporated into and reinforces the neoclassical/mainstream general equilibrium framework.
Come back to this tweet every year, it always works
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
Save the date for the announcement of this year's prize in economic sciences.
Watch the breaking news at nobelprize.org and right here @NobelPrize: x.com/i/broadcasts/1pKkOXVdMjMKj
#nobelprize -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
You can now move through time and see which feedback loops dominate the economy at different points in the policy simulator at @GDPDynamics.
The model is based on my new book, Beyond Equilibrium. Links in next post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniel Swain
@Weather_West
Based on what I am seeing now, I am officially concerned. And I'm not the only one: One federal scientist recently reflected that in their view we've entered "If you see something, say something" territory. I fully agree, and this month's data provides further evidence.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
We lost yet another giant. RIP Anwar Shaikh
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
If you studied economics at university you were almost guaranteed to have been mis-taught. Prof Keen explains 👇
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thanks. Please share widely. Not understanding this is at the root of the social disasters caused by the Euro, which are at the heart of the protests in France right now.
Andy Lippok
@AndyLippok
Brilliant explanation, Steve!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
What an eloquent young man. He puts the entire Labour Party to shame.
Scott Patrick
@thirdintl
with English subtitles
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ザイナブ佐藤🍉
@MoqQist
フランスの若者たちの、明晰で理路整然とした主張を見て感嘆する人は少なくないと思う。
だが、フランスの教育を見れば、それは決して不思議なことではない。
フランスでは、義務教育が始まる3歳のマテルネルから、「自分の考えを言葉にする」教育が始まる。
自分が経験したことを話す。
物語を聞いて、何が起きたのかを説明する。
「あなたはどう思う?」「なぜそう思う?」と問われ、自分なりの言葉で答える。
他の子どもの話を聞き、自分との違いに気づく。
もちろんこの段階では、高度な討論をするわけではない。
だが、集団の中で黙って正解を待つのではなく、自分自身が一人の発話主体になることが既に教育の一部になっている。
小学校に進めば、そこに「理由」が加わる。
自分の意見を述べるだけではなく、なぜそう考えるのかを説明し、他者の意見を聞き、比較し、必要なら修正する。
さらに中学・高校では、論証、討論、反論、要約、立場の比較へと進む。
そして高校の哲学教育では、デカルトやルソー、カントのような著名な哲学者の文章であっても、「偉い思想家がそう言っているから正しい」という受け止め方は、哲学的読解として認められない。
フランス一般社会でも、そういう読み方は評価されにくい。
何を問題にし、どんな前提から、どんな論理で結論に至ったのかを正確に読み、そのうえで、
その論証は本当に成立するのか。
別の見方は可能ではないか。
どんな限界や帰結があるのか。
と検討する。
つまり、権威ある思想さえ、自分の頭で再審査するのである。
だから高校生が政府や教育制度に対して、「なぜ従わなければならないのか」「この制度は本当に公正なのか」と問い、自分の言葉で主張を組み立てているのは、国の教育と無関係ではない。
むしろ、3歳から積み上げてきた思考の方法を、そのまま社会に向けているとも言えるだろう。
サン・ドニの子どもたちが声を上げることができたのも、そのような教育は確実に影響しているだろう。
対して日本では、「自分の意見を持とう」とは言いつつも、実際には正解、模範解答、教師の意図を読むことが依然として強く評価される。
教科書に書いてある。
先生が言った。
専門家が言った。
制度で決まっている。
そこで思考を止めず、「なぜ?」と問い返す力を、私たちの教育はどこまで育てているだろうか。
自分の考えを構築し、言語化し、表明し、他者の考えを聞くことが、どれだけ訓練されているだろうか?
正直、ほぼ皆無なのではないか?
若者が社会に向かって「私はこう考える」と言える力は、突然生まれるものではない。
社会を変え得る民主的な主体は、自動的には形成され得ない。
それは、教育がつくるのだ。 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Power to the People ☭🕊
@ProudSocialist
This has to be the video of the year. Bally Bagayoko who is the mayor of French city Saint-Denis shouts at police to “Stop!” and protects the student protesters.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity.”
— Martin Luther King Jr -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
真場貴雄=リナードル(政府は機関としての役割をしろ!?(# ゚Д゚)
@rinard18
これは逆に言えば
『貨幣は、誰か(政府も例外ではない)が、負債or債務を負わない限り、市場に存在する事は不可能』
と、言う事も意味しますね。
ここで、家計や企業を持ち出す方には
『逆に、家計や企業を国家に例えると、これらの機関は、寿命を除き、共通通貨ユーロ採用国と同じ』
と、返しますね。 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ilan Gabet
@Ilangabet
Après une charge policière violente et sans raison, les jeunes s’assoient devant les policiers et scandent des slogans antifascistes
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jane Angel
@janelvis77
😬🙄😅
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthias Ubl
@MatthiasUbl
Wie gleichgeschaltet große Teile der Wirtschaftswissenschaft sind, erkennt man an der Unfähigkeit ihrer Vertreter, das eigene wissenschaftliche Paradigma zu hinterfragen. Isabella Weber wird angegriffen, weil sie dessen Hegemonie so erfolgreich wie kaum jemand infrage stellt.
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
»Anti-fascist Economics« is triggering all the usual suspects even before publication. They come after me with sexist slurs.
This is the deepest crisis of Western democracy since the Nazi era. Growing up in Nuremberg, I have learned that being anti-fascist is my first civic duty. There can’t be a question which side I’m on, as a human and an economist.
As a student of FDR, I say: “I welcome their hatred.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
Uncertainty and the Institutional Structure of Capitalist Economies
Hyman P. Minsky
Levy Economics Institute · Working Paper No. 155
Publication date: April 1, 1996
Abstract:
In this new working paper, Distinguished Scholar Hyman P. Minsky points out that capitalism in the United States is an evolving construct that recently entered a new stage: “money manager” capitalism. In money manager capitalism, nearly all businesses are organized as corporations, pension and mutual funds are the predominant owners of financial assets, and managers of these funds are judged solely on the total return on fund assets (dividends and interest plus appreciation in share value). One consequence of such a structure is the predominance of short-run considerations in decision making.
Public tolerance for uncertainty is limited. During the New Deal era it led to the creation of institutions and arrangements to create transparency in both financial markets and corporate governance; for example, crop insurance set floors to farmers’ incomes and deficits run by the federal government set floors to aggregate profit flows. However, the focus of money manager capitalism on short-run returns and uncompromised profit margins has increased economic uncertainty at the firm and plant levels through the chronic need to downsize overhead and reduce variable costs. These activities have unraveled the traditional relationships between firm and worker and increased economic insecurity among employees.
Minsky asserts that existing institutions and programs cannot contain this uncertainty, and that new arrangements must be created to offset the effects on “losers” in the structure of money manager capitalism. He suggests that full-employment programs analogous to certain New Deal programs (e.g., the Work Progress Administration and the Civilian Conservation Corps) should be considered to meet this goal.
www.levyinstitute.org/publications/uncertainty-and-the-in…
@levyecon -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Marine Le Pen propose ce matin un plan de 140 milliards d'euros d'économies et une « règle d'or » qui condamnera la France à faire des coupes budgétaires et de la récession pendant 120 ans.
Vous voulez un peu plus de lycées délabrés, de professeurs absents, de gel du point d'indice, d'absence de moyens pour les pompiers, d'urgences saturées ? Le Pen y est prête pour gagner la bonne opinion des spéculateurs. Son plan provoquera donc la paralysie de l'économie, il aggravera le déficit et la dette. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ΛЦƧƬΣЯIƬY IƧ MЦЯDΣЯ
@sdgrumbine
realprogressives.org/mnc-podcast-ep/episode-396-recession…
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
Think #ww2 bond drives paid for the war? Wrong. War #bonds were about controlling #inflation - @John_T_Harvey “the Cowboy Economist” explains.
Link to full Macro N Cheese episode in comment below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
Michael Hudson on private debts & the challenge of mortgage debt on real estate.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
A trade deficit higher than the budget deficit reduces the money supply.
S-I=G-T+NX
Yes, money supply increased in August, but it is mainly becase of the increase in loans granted exceeding the repaid loans.
CNBC
@CNBC
The U.S. trade deficit widened sharply in August amid an influx of goods related to the artificial intelligence build-out and the vagaries of import tariffs, the Commerce Department reported Tuesday.
Imports swelled 4.3% for the month, pushing the total imbalance to $105.6 billion. That marked a 13.7% jump from July and was ahead of the Dow Jones consensus estimate for $102 billion.
More details: cnb.cx/4z9RN0e -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thanks. Please share widely. Not understanding this is at the root of the social disasters caused by the Euro, which are at the heart of the protests in France right now.
Andy Lippok
@AndyLippok
Brilliant explanation, Steve!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Author @Peter_Turchin : "A critical step is reversing the root cause of crisis—the perverse wealth pump that takes from the common people and gives to the elites. As described in End Times, good times breed complacency among the governing elites. During integrative phases they become tempted to rejiggle the political economy in ways that benefit themselves at the expense of the workers. As a result, worker wages stagnate and even decline, and the fruits of economic growth go disproportionately to the elites. The operation of this wealth pump results in popular immiseration and discontent, elite overproduction and intraelite conflict, and gradual weakening of the state. As these negative trends build up (which typically takes multiple decades), they eventually drive society into crisis. Exiting the crisis requires reversing these negative trends, which means, first and foremost, shutting down the wealth pump.
But accomplishing this feat is not easy. The problem is that the wealth pump is extremely lucrative for the ruling class. Sociologists refer to this tendency of the ruling elites to use their power for selfish ends as the Iron Law of Oligarchy. In short, power corrupts.
How can the oligarchs be persuaded to give up their selfish advantage in favor of promoting public weal? In most run-ups to past crises, in fact, ruling classes refused the calls to reform, persisting in their intransigence to the very end. And the end, usually, was their violent overthrow by counter-elites channeling popular rage against their regime. Or they weaken the state to the point where it is conquered by external elites."
Read more: peterturchin.substack.com/p/how-do-societies-end-end-times -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Spot on.
Reads with Ravi
@readswithravi
“The first principle is that you must not fool yourself and you are the easiest person to fool.”
— Richard Feynman -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Le banquier central français, ancien collaborateur direct de Macron, prend publiquement parti contre son pays à l'étranger en appelant implicitement les spéculateurs à sanctionner la France à cause de mes propositions. C'est un acte de trahison. Il n'y aura pas de prescription en 2027. Il sera poursuivi pour cela. Ras-le-bol de ces soi-disant élites qui crient au drame qu'elles veulent créer pour peser sur le peuple.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Absolutely. The US Constitution deserves revision, not reverence. In a parliamentary system, a Prime Minister as crazy as Trump would have been removed long ago. They’re not perfect, but parliamentary governance is better than the US’s elected monarch.
DulceBiatch
@BiatchDulce
I don't fucking care what the Constitutional law experts say.
There's a massive flaw in the Constitution when someone this fucking crazy gets to act this fucking crazy for this fucking long.
25th amendment, my ass,
We should never be held hostage like this.
Once we get this corrupt motherfucker out of office, a system needs to be set in place so this kind of bullshit can NEVER EVER happen again. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
Post-Keynesyenlerin vurguladığı paradokslardan likidite paradoksu (Dow, 1987) devrede:
Aşırı borçluların acil borçlarını ödemek için likit olmayan varlıkları (stoklar, makina, ev, hisse, bono vs) satmaları varlıkların fiyatlarını düşürdüğünden beklenenin aksine likidite düşer.
Enver
@benenverkarahan
Piyasanın ne kadar sıkıştığını anlatayım arkadaşlar
benim kendi markamı şu an piyasada benden maliyetimden daha ucuza satanlar var :)
Yanlış okumadınız
Ürünü benim fabrikam üretiyor
Ürünü ben getiriyorum
marka benim
maliyeti ben biliyorum
ama adam nakite dönmek zorunda olduğu için benim sattığım fiyatın altına mal bırakıyor.
Son haftalarda bunu çok görmeye başladım. Herkes elindeki malı paraya çevirmeye çalışıyor, spot piyasaya sürekli ürün düşüyor.
Adam artık kâr hesabı yapmıyor, bugün ne kadar nakit çıkarırım ona bakıyor.
İşin komiği benim ürünü benden ucuza görünce ilk başta insanın siniri bozuluyor :)
Sonra düşünüyorsun
adam sana rakip olmaya çalışmıyor ki
adam nefes almaya çalışıyor…
Piyasada şu an fiyatı arz talep değil, birçok yerde nakit ihtiyacı belirliyor.
Bence önümüzdeki dönemde en garip fiyatları daha yeni göreceğiz. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Touche!
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Liberté, fraternité, austérité.
www.msn.com/de-de/nachrichten/other/140-milliarden-in-fün… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
Here are the core reasons why students in France are protesting:
🔸 Crumbling school buildings: Students are demanding emergency funding to fix dilapidated facilities, citing collapsing ceilings, mold, water damage, and rat infestations.
🔸 Severe teacher shortages: Thousands of classrooms are missing educators, leaving students without consistent instruction.
🔸 Overcrowded classrooms: Budget cuts have pushed class sizes to 36 or more students, overwhelming teachers and reducing learning quality.
🔸 Exhausting school hours: Protesters are demanding a complete overhaul of the current school schedule, which frequently runs from 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
🔸 Police violence: Anger has intensified following heavy-handed police tactics during demonstrations, which have resulted in severe injuries to teenage protesters. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
»Anti-fascist Economics« is triggering all the usual suspects even before publication. They come after me with sexist slurs.
This is the deepest crisis of Western democracy since the Nazi era. Growing up in Nuremberg, I have learned that being anti-fascist is my first civic duty. There can’t be a question which side I’m on, as a human and an economist.
As a student of FDR, I say: “I welcome their hatred.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ravid Shwartz Ziv
@ziv_ravid
When I did my PhD in computational neuroscience a long time ago, optogenetics was the new thing. It honestly looked like magic.
You could shine light on a neuron and switch it on or off. Turn memories on. Turn memories off. Map emotion and behavior cell by cell, in a living brain. It transformed the field almost overnight.
Today, its pioneers, Karl Deisseroth, Peter Hegemann and Georg Nagel, won the Nobel Prize in Medicine.
And it all started with a simple question: how does a single-celled alga swim toward light?
This is why we fund basic research 💪
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The 2026 #nobelprize in Physiology or Medicine has been awarded to Karl Deisseroth, Peter Hegemann and Georg Nagel “for their discoveries concerning light-gated ion channels and optogenetics.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
There is no economics Nobel. And the idea that there will be one given for progressive causes is wildly unrealistic. press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691196312/the-nob…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Forthcoming in @ReviewofPE
"Why Philosophical Components are Needed in Teaching Political Economy" (Open Access)
by the always phenomenal, Rod O'Donnell
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2026.2726926 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
一
@craneopesan
政府支出が民間の金融純資産を増やす唯一の手段
民間の銀行預金を純増させて有効需要を作り消費や投資を促す
政府支出伸び率の高い国が経済成長率も高い
政府支出が先で納税は後
国税も社会保険料も発行した通貨を消してるだけ
国民の資産を消してるだけ
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
So this song is now 64 years old. Looks like yes, we'll still love you, when you're 64.
The Beatles Legacy
@TheBeatlesPMcC
5 octobre 1962, les Beatles publient leur premier disque.
A cette époque, le groupe n'est qu'une gloire locale de Liverpool qui fait écho à peine plus loin que Manchester. De par leur histoire récente, les Beatles sont alors plus connus à Hambourg qu'à Londres.
Avec ce single, toute la Grande-Bretagne va commencer à connaître les Beatles puisque ce titre grimpera jusqu'à la 17ème place dans les charts.
L'Histoire est en marche mais personne ne le sait vraiment. Ringo Starr commencera même à faire quelques économies pour ouvrir un salon de coiffure. On ne sait jamais, ça pourrait ne pas durer. Pour l'instant, leur seule préoccupation est d'aller tourner dans toute la Grande-Bretagne et d'espérer pouvoir faire un prochain disque.
"Love Me Do", The Beatles, 1962.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
US Amazon link:
a.co/d/08ABQwOP -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Don Winslow
@donwinslow
America is not prepared for what Donald Trump and his administration are going to do before and on election day.
It will be massive and unprecedented and imo ILLEGAL. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The Laffer Curve isn't real. At least not as a single, timeless curve.
I used the dynamic macro model from my new book, Beyond Equilibrium, to generate this tax-revenue surface.
The link to my new book is in the next post below.👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Sheep Person Podge
@noplaceforsheep
In all of the US is there no one who can make this fuckwit shut up?
Damaan, AKA 'Philly's Finest!'
@Damaan4u33
Trump: "I'm among the highest IQ's in the world, 1775"!
Says the moron who finished 364th out of 366 grads from his class, proof why he's widely considered the absolute, dumbest president in history.
The idiot is clueless that a 1775 IQ is impossible! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
My Novara Media interview just reached half a million views
In case you are at a loose end, you can still watch here
@novaramedia @AaronBastani
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ee9fYVwhBsU -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Latest video on money creation just posted
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/latest-video-on-17143… @DEhnts @wbmosler -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Amir Jafar
@AmirJafar0
Seyed Mohammad Marandi (Political Analyst): If the United States targets Iran's power plants, that would be like a nuclear strike. If this happens, everyone on the other side of the Persian Gulf will lose everything.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ivo Toniut
@IvoTONIUT
The French are asking for only three things:
● an end to funding and the supply of weapons to Ukraine;
● withdrawal from the EU and NATO;
and
● Macron's resignation.
And they are absolutely right! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bez(os) Mastodon @Bez78829056@indieweb.social
@Bez78829056
Credit @ProfSteveKeen
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nancy Nieto
@FancyandTheCity
👇
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
aapayés
@aapayes
Mientras tanto en Francia
Los bomberos y la policía se retiran, han elegido ponerse del lado del pueblo de Francia. Han dejado de acatar órdenes y se han posicionado por los derechos del pueblo. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
💧🌞John Troughton
@JoYohana
Fantastic clarity. A MUST view ….
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Money≡Work! BJ_Chippindale(Not Another Engineer)
@BJChippindale
I don't accept this bullshit from either side.
There ARE no "unfunded" gaps.
Just an INCREDIBLY stupid insistence that Maggie Thatcher's error half a fucking century ago should still tie the hands of the people who run governments. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rathbone
@_rathbone
French students are rioting because of austerity imposed against the education system in order to pay foreign debt to Wall street banks and asset managers. Dilapidated facilities, overcrowded classrooms and chronic teacher shortage are the result.
And now, a new 2027 budget plan that cuts an additional 43 billion to welfare and student benefits. 400 schools have closed because of western finance capitalism. But zionists will tell us it's because of Palestine. What a joke.
Dr. Eli David
@DrEliDavid
France was one of the first countries to recognize “Palestine.”
Now Palestine is recognizing France.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ashish🇮🇳🇵🇸🇮🇷🇱🇧
@barua_82
Architect: “But where is the money coming from?”
Keynes: “The same place it is coming from now.”
In other words, money is not the same thing as the actual resources needed to build the houses.
Imagine a country has:
100,000 unemployed construction workers + plenty of cement + plenty of steel + vacant factories.
But someone says: “We can't build houses because we don't have £1 billion.”
Keynes's response is basically: The £1 billion is an accounting/financial issue. The real question is whether the economy has the workers, materials, and productive capacity to build the houses.
If those resources are sitting idle, the government can create spending power and mobilise them. #learnmmt #keynes
Mecha PSYOP
@mechapsyop
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Austrian economics: too sophisticated for data, too realistic for mathematics, and somehow perfectly suited for Twitter.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ParkSJ 朴勝俊 Anti Austerity, Anti Nuclear, GND
@psj95708651
キーン教授の、財政赤字と経済成長に関する、複式簿記シミュレーションモデルを用いた解説動画です。財政黒字が国民貯蓄を増やすとする、マンキューの教科書の誤りも説明されています。国債を銀行ではなく企業や人々に持たせるのは良くありません。
動画は正確な日本語字幕付きで聞くことができます。
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
If You Don't Understand Government Debt,You Don't Understand Money youtu.be/7OYUI8FpCKI via @YouTube @RichardJMurphy @yanisvaroufakis @StephanieKelton @PrivateDebtProj
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Barlow
@SteB777
The moment that happens, it is a fast track to our countries becoming ungovernable. Responsible governments could have planned, restructured, informed the public, and mitigated.
The problem is, as governments have kept the public in the dark about the seriousness of the climate and ecological emergency, and misled them to believe we could carry on with business as usual, this is going to come as a terrible shock - hence a sudden breakdown in public trust of governments.
Whereas government could have prepared the public for this decades ago, and been honest. But they knew if they did, the public would have demanded action, and the business as usual gravy train would have been over.
National Emergency Briefing
@nebriefing
"We're facing the potential of an ungovernable state unless Government takes this seriously."
We can rise to this challenge, but first we need to face it.
👉 Please ask your MP to join the Parliamentary Call for a televised emergency briefing.
www.nebriefing.org/parliamentary-call
#neb2025 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A beautiful story about a beautiful song. Thank you Sir Paul @PaulMcCartney
The Beatles Legacy
@TheBeatlesPMcC
4 octobre 1963, les Beatles participent à leur première télévision nationale en Grande-Bretagne dans l'émission "Ready Steady Go", une de ces nouvelles émissions dédiées aux adolescents. Jusqu'à présent, ils n'étaient apparus que sur des télévisions locales, même après que leurs disques, single et album, aient été #1 des ventes.
C'était donc déjà un événement en soi cette première télévision nationale pour les créateurs de ce nouveau phénomène, la Beatlemania. Mais personne n'imagine encore ce qu'il va se passer dans cette émission. La légende va s'écrire par un de ces hasards si étranges qu'il pourrait remettre en cause l'existence même du hasard.
Pendant cette émission, Paul McCartney va être désigné comme juge d'un petit concours de danse et de playback. Quatre jeunes filles y participent. Prêtez surtout attention à cette jeune fille de 14 ans en robe sombre sur la droite de l'image. Elle s'appelle Melanie Coe. C'est elle que Paul désignera comme vainqueur. Il lui remettra d'ailleurs en cadeau l'album "Please Please Me". Jusque-là, rien d'extraordinaire, un très joli souvenir pour elle.
Seulement voilà, Melanie Coe recroisera sans le vouloir la route de Paul plus de trois ans plus tard à travers un article de Daily Mirror. Paul ne le sait évidemment pas mais l'article qu'il lit parle de cette même Melanie Coe. La fugue des adolescents était en effet devenu un véritable fléau à cette époque en Grande-Bretagne. Et Melanie était l'une de ces fugueuses. C'est cet article qui lui inspirera tout simplement l'une des plus belles chansons de Sgt. Pepper.
Melanie Coe est aujourd'hui une retraitée qui reste encore très émue lorsqu'elle raconte cette belle histoire. Elle-même a sûrement du mal à croire au hasard. Elle avait une chance sur quatre d'être désignée vainqueur de ce concours. Mais combien avait-elle de chance que sa fugue soit aussi décrite par le Daily Mirror, que Paul McCartney lise cet article et qu'il en fasse une chanson légendaire pour l'album le plus iconique de l'histoire du rock ? Elle avait sans doute plus de chances de gagner deux fois de suite le gros lot à la loterie nationale.
"She's Leaving Home", The Beatles, 1967.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I know the guy is a cretin, so I'm sick of being reminded of it.
Alon Mizrahi
@alon_mizrahi
That's because he is in the finding out phase
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ThePatrioticBlonde™🇺🇸
@ImBreckWorsham
Just got intel from an insider close to the Pentagon. The plan is to step up in Iran to justify delaying the midterms.
I always protect my sources so don't ask.
But bookmark this. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Latest video on money creation just posted
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/latest-video-on-17143… @DEhnts @wbmosler -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Time Capsule Tales
@timecaptales
In 1996, English TV presenter Alain de Cadenet asked legendary New Zealand born fighter pilot Ray Hana, who was 70-years-old, to do a low pass in this Spitfire fighter plane as de Cadenet spoke to the camera
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sony Thăng
@nxt888
The pretext changes. The pattern doesn't.
Korea: the pretext was communism.
Vietnam: the pretext was communism.
Guatemala: the pretext was communism.
Iran: the pretext was communism.
Chile: the pretext was communism.
Then the Soviet Union collapsed and the pretext needed updating.
Iraq: the pretext was weapons of mass destruction.
Libya: the pretext was humanitarian intervention.
Syria: the pretext was chemical weapons.
Venezuela: the pretext is democracy.
Iran, again: the pretext is nuclear weapons.
The pretext is not the policy.
The pretext is the packaging.
The policy is older than the pretext, older than the Cold War, older than the specific vocabulary used to sell it to each generation.
The policy is: your resources belong to us until you are strong enough to take them back.
The only thing that changes is which word they're currently using for the box. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The great achievement of neoclassical economics was proving that markets work perfectly under conditions that have never existed.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Shaun Rein
@shaunrein
Most Americans who are older than 40 tell me their lives is not as good as when they were younger
Most Chinese who are older than 40 tell me their lives is much better than when they were younger
That's all you need to know -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr JJ González Alemán
@glezjuanje
Después de más de 15 años estudiando la meteorología tropical y los ciclones con características tropicales, nunca pensé que fuese a decir esto:
Hará falta un estudio en mayor profundidad, pero cada vez me ronda más en la cabeza, viendo las animaciones de radar y satélite y por lo que planteaban los modelos, que el episodio extremo que ha afectado a Cataluña en las últimas horas es más consistente con un proceso de ciclogénesis tropical (que no ha llegado a su fin, aunque estaría por ver), es decir, con el verdadedo intento formación de un ciclón tropical a partir de un grupo de tormentas muy fuertes.
Y esto no tiene precedentes conocidos en el Mediterráneo. No ha sido ni es un medicane o “mini huracán” (algo que, por cierto, no existe físicamente), ni tampoco lo era lo que aparecía en los modelos.
No forma parte del modelo conceptual típico de medicane del Mediterráneo: esto es algo diferente, un proceso de formación de ciclón tropical como los que ocurren en el trópico.
Dejo esta imagen de satélite de ayer, antes de entrar: si le quito las líneas de costa, cualquier experto en meteorología tropical diría que pertenece al trópico. Y esto abriría un debate nuevo en la comunidad científica. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
Your chart for understanding all the stupid monetary debates on here:
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"I'm not a survivalist, but I'm certainly preparing." Climate scientists expect food rationing in countries like the UK in the near future. youtube.com/shorts/mrpx6Hi8RPo via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And if you missed it, you can now see the replay on @YouTube
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minutes to discuss the launch of my new book, Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
My good friend @ProfSteveKeen will be sitting in on the stream as well.
YouTube link in the next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The 1990s Ford Explorer/Firestone rollover disaster is a inconvenient case for Handre's grifter argument.
Liability insurance somehow failed to prevent years of deaths and injuries.
Government intervention, investigation and mandatory recalls stepped in where the market hadn't
Handre
@Handre
The government does not make cars safer.
Tesla vehicles have logged over 15.1 billion cumulative miles driven with Full Self-Driving (FSD) Supervised engaged, and Waymo has logged over 22 million autonomous miles on public roads by early 2026, with a safety record that embarrasses human drivers. The technology works. Deployment is slowed by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, the California DMV, and a revolving door of federal regulators who write rules that protect incumbent automakers from disruptive competition.
NHTSA's Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards were written in 1967, when a computer filled a room. Regulators now apply those same standards to vehicles with no steering wheel, demanding performance metrics designed around human anatomy. A car with no pedals cannot pass a test built around pedal placement. These regulations freeze the technology at the starting line while roughly 40,000 Americans die in traffic crashes every year, nearly all caused by human error.
No regulator sitting in Washington holds the information that thousands of engineers, insurance actuaries, and liability lawyers processing real-world collision data already hold. Markets generate that information continuously. Bureaucracies generate reports.
Regulatory capture makes this worse. The established players, Ford, GM, Toyota, lobby NHTSA directly. They fund the safety advocacy groups that testify before Congress. They employ the former regulators who write the compliance frameworks. Startups with genuinely superior technology spend capital on lawyers instead of sensors.
The liability system in a free market handles safety without a single federal mandate. A company that deploys a vehicle that kills people faces ruinous lawsuits, destroyed reputation, and zero customers. Tort law and insurance pricing punish failure in real time, not after a three-year rulemaking cycle.
You are the one stuck in traffic behind this arrangement, or worse, in a preventable crash, while regulators protect their budget lines and incumbents protect their margins. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Angelica 🌐⚛️🇹🇼🇨🇳🇺🇸
@AngelicaOung
Who's the next Chinese leader going to be? We simultaneously have no idea, and at the same time, we kind of know the type of guy it's going to be.
There's 1.4 billion people in China 100 million are in the Communist Party of China. 7 million are civil servants. 2,296 are National Congress delegates. 200 are Central Committee members. 25 are Politburo members. 7 are in the Politburo standing committee and there's one General secretary, of course.
Going up each of these levels take years. Votes by your peers both seem to be a factor in your selection and not determinative. The funnel narrows so much at every level that only the cream of the crop makes it through. I understand there used to be ways to speedrun or get helicoptered in through unconventional means, but they've largely been eliminated over the years.
Everybody who is even in contention have done the following things: managed real cities, balanced local budgets, met industrial quotas, got rotated through different regions. After you go through that process, you're a type of guy.
It's interesting to see how the Chinese leadership got blander and blander as time went on. Mao was mythic. Deng was iconic. Jiang and Zhu were very colorful but just about the last leaders with personality. Hu and Wen were very bureaucratic. Xi basically shows no emotions.
Right now the 7-member Politburo standing committee are all very aged. No successors popping out of that bunch. So we are likely looking at someone from the 25 member politburo layer, or the 200 member layer from the outside if Xi stays for longer than another term.
After understanding the structure and heirarchy I feel like succession risk is not as bad as I previously thought. The party system is immensely strong. If Xi picked a bad successor they would be ejected. And he's unlikely to pick someone all that bad because all possible candidates went through the gauntlet.
Probably even if Xi himself stay beyond his competence some kind of ejection would happen, although that's probably a greater risk than Xi picking a bad successor. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard
@ricwe123
Britain has invaded 171 countries.
France has killed 22 African President's since 1963.
The US runs more than 750 military base in 80 nations.
And you are worried about Russia?
😂😂😂 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Iran in Ghana
@IRAN_GHANA
We extend our sincere condolences to every empire that marched on Iran and no longer exists, and our sincerest disregards to the last one still auditioning to join them.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
BB
@sombkk1
BowTiedStocks
@bowtiedstocks
If people had an eye to history and the great Melbourne land bubble of the 1890s they’d have known that this outcome was not only very possible but actually locked in 👍👍
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
At our recent talk, Michael Hudson explained why Banks lend money and the link to price inflation.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And if you missed it, you can now see the replay on @YouTube
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minutes to discuss the launch of my new book, Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
My good friend @ProfSteveKeen will be sitting in on the stream as well.
YouTube link in the next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Canary
@TheCanaryUK
An exposed lie about a door has destroyed Israel's narrative and confirmed the FlyDubai 'incident' as the 'false flag' we knew it was
Via @skwawkbox
www.thecanary.co/skwawkbox/2026/10/03/flydubai-cockpit-door/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
K
@I_am_da_BOM
Crazy scenes on the NSW south coast right now! (video from insta)
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Gene, the issue here is that Robinson was one of the few economists who understood 'time' in economics. What market logic deems 'wasteful' at one point turns out to be under-capacity at another. We have to build in some slack. Market-watching and competition are synchronic - 'snapshot' - processes that just don't provide the predictive intelligence we need. Chinese over-capacity causes problems such as aggressive exporting, producer price deflation, subsidisation etc., but they can be managed without hurting the less well-off. The need for a synchronic-diachronic combination is why properly mixed economies work better for the population as a whole.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Learn real economics from Tyrone Keynes youtube.com/shorts/ecaZkJaErrQ via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
Podcasts
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen
Every Economics Concept Explained in 30 Minute braveneweurope.com/economics/steve-keen-every-economics-c…
Alex Krainer, Glenn Diesen @Glenn_Diesen
Bond Market Collapse and the New Chinese Economic Order
braveneweurope.com/geopolitics/alex-krainer-glenn-diesen-…
#podcasts #economics #china #bonds #finance -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
The main danger of an economics education is that you can learn a great many ready-made answers without ever learning to ask the right questions.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Meidas_Charise Lee
@charise_lee
The fact that you aren't even exaggerating it! 😂💔
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
We held a talk with Kathleen Tyson and Michael Hudson about Debt, Prices and the Bond Market.
You can see the full talk here on our Youtube channel.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZZxLt8FQD64 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Furkan Gözükara
@FurkanGozukara
LMAO this was brilliant but you need to watch till end 🤣
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Black Opinion
@opinion_black
I had the misfortune of tuning in to the Tucker Carlson show to watch his interview with Jacob Rees-Mogg.
Rees-Mogg came over as a cold blooded dark hearted devil. This utter bastard hid behind his so called ‘Catholic faith’ and claimed that the murder of ‘tens of thousands of children is justified in a just war’.
He further claimed that ‘this is in line with church doctrine’. If that is the case then to hell with your church and your murderous faith.
To hear this Rothschild mouthpiece speak is to witness hypocrisy in motion. I sincerely hope that his teenage children are the first victims in any conflict that he seeks to put the children of others into.
I despise him more than I can articulate. 🤮 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What is money, really? The hardest question in economics needs an answer. That's what this morning's video is all about.
youtu.be/Rs5fIopDHI8 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
🚨Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach To Macroeconomics is now out!
Purchases for hardcover, paperback and Kindle can be found on Amazon. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alan MacLeod
@AlanRMacLeod
They said it. They literally just came out and said it.
Conservatives
@Conservatives
We must cut welfare to fund defence.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MoviePlugTV
@MovieplugTV
One of my favorite sitcoms from Chuck Laury
MomThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I still can't believe the economics profession still finds supply and demand plots remotely useful.
What a bunch of retards.
On the contrary, the economy is inherently cyclical, and does not tend to an equilibrium as a basic model illustrates below. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
Mind-boggling - just mind-boggling
Now expected to peak at an extraordinary 4.2C in December -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Philip Pilkington
@philippilk
The world is in complete meltdown. Literally. War everywhere accelerating. Bond markets disintegrating. Diesel shortages. And some idiot on X is telling you that the Strait of Hormuz is totally open trust me bro I swear bro this time is different bro. 🤡
zerohedge
@zerohedge
Top Overnight News
Iran is preparing a broader and more forceful response if the United States resumes large-scale military attacks, sources said, while continuing a diplomatic push that Iranian officials privately see as unlikely to succeed. RTRS
Vladimir Putin has instructed his military leaders to abandon the rules of war, prompting a steep increase in strikes on civilian targets amid a major push to regain the advantage in the conflict, according to intelligence intercepted by Kyiv. FT
Governments around the world are running out of room to shield consumers from higher energy prices resulting from the Iran war and other crises, with fuel subsidies potentially costing more than $1 trillion this year, a United Nations study found. BBG
World food prices rose in September, as transportation disruptions and weather concerns limited supplies and lifted prices for several crop-based commodities, the United Nations’ Food and Agriculture Organization said. WSJ
Amazon’s exploring a deal to shift about $8 billion of high-end Nvidia chips into a sale-leaseback SPV vehicle backed by outside investors to help strengthen its balance sheet. FT
European countries are in crisis talks over the release of diesel stocks, as the US threatens them with a diesel export ban unless they release strategic reserves of the oil product. FT
Tokyo’s key inflation gauge rose sharply as the effects of some temporary government measures faded, backing the Bank of Japan’s stance on continuing to raise the benchmark rate after authorities accelerated the pace of policy normalization. BBG
Eurozone CPI for Sept ran hot on the headline (+3.8% vs. the Street +3.7% and vs. +3.2% in Aug) and was inline on core (+2.5% vs. +2.4% in Aug). BBG
Trump posted "Republicans in the Senate have to get moving on what I call the “No More Changing of Clocks Act,” officially known as The Sunshine Protection Act".
Goldman estimates nonfarm payrolls rose by 80k in September, slightly below consensus of +88k. On the positive side, the level of layoffs remains low and big data indicators of job growth picked up sequentially. On the negative side, September payroll growth has tended to underperform its recent trend when Labor Day is later in the month—like it was this year—and last month’s sharp increase in nonfarm payrolls was boosted by outsized increases in leisure and hospitality and local educational services payrolls that we do not expect to repeat. GS Research
BofA Flow Show (w/e 30th September): USD 18.8bln to bonds, 15.8bln to stocks, 0.9bln to crypto, 0.7bln to gold, 118.0bln from cash on quarter-end; Bull and Bear indicator 8.8 (prev. 9.3). -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
@federalreserve Do it again. Then again. And then again. Until the yields are where you want them. Finally, we would be able to focus on the real policy issues.
Barchart
@Barchart
U.S. Treasury just bought back $6 Billion of their own debt 🚨 🚨
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Robert Reich
@RBReich
Americans are relearning the lesson we learned during the Gilded Age of the late 1890s, when robber barons ran the government and the economy for their own benefit: Oligarchy is incompatible with the common good.
I'm hopeful we'll respond with a new progressive movement. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jeff Berardelli
@WeatherProf
France is the new Sahara
Nahel Belgherze
@WxNB_
France’s ongoing drought has once again pushed soil moisture further below historical levels than any previously recorded drought.
Uncharted territory. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
In our recent talk, @Kathleen_Tyson_ explained her admiration for how China managed down a massive real estate bubble.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Sirota
@davidsirota
The people who ruined the entire world and never apologized for it do not deserve your respect.
They deserve your scorn. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Another great dialogue with Professor Michael Hudson on the spiralling economic and financial challenges building toward instability in bond markets.
Link below. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Another economically illiterate idiot. You can't move for them in this country. Its like being trapped in a nuclear-armed kindergarten.
Conservatives
@Conservatives
We must cut welfare to fund defence.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Remember Kalecki!
Today's price spikes and the subsequent rise in employment will only fuel the far-right.
🌹 We must be bold and tackle insecurity with an economics of essentials. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics releases tomorrow, October 3rd. It can be found on all Amazon market places, pre orders available for the Kindle version.
Simulator:
www.gdpdynamics.com/policy-simulator/
Blog:
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/gdp-dynamics-is-171234693 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
There is nothing the @ECB can do about this. Also, when prices recede, the ECB will be forced to walk back all of its interest rate hikes as the inflation rate falls below the target rate.
Financial Times
@FT
Breaking news: Eurozone inflation shot up to a three-year high of 3.8% in September, after the escalating conflict in the Middle East triggered a resurgence in oil and gas prices. ft.trib.al/kb72j2s
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rony
@RonyToThePoint
This is the aftermath photos inside of the plane Singapore Airlines Flight SQ321 on May 21, 2024 which suffered turbulence & dropped 178 feet (about 54 meters) in 4.6 seconds. Air Canada Boeing 787-9 experienced severe turbulence at 36000 feet. That’s how it supposed to look
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
If a WAR was to break out , we would only have about 10 days before our entire country grinds to a halt without diesel deliveries , about 30 days before we’d have to consider surrender .
If a real war were to occur surrender might not make any difference anyway . We might not be able to get diesel under any circumstances .
It doesn’t matter how many tanks or F35S we have , the way to beat us quickly would be diesel supply chain denial .
Our entire country depends on diesel delivered from Japan , Korea and Singapore . Mines , farms , food deliveries would literally stop in a month
We are a diesel powered country with no concept of how vulnerable our country is ……
The Greens are against AUKUS which is fair because $400 b in subs won’t help us in 3 years if they take 15 years to arrive here …….though they are also against our own resilience , our own ability to provide their own fuel because of this ridiculous net zero concept.
Netzero isn’t climate action , it’s form of ideological suicide .
Labor on the other hand are in favour of $400 b in submarines but also against diesel self reliance .
We are conditioned to think that the perils of war will never unfold in our lives . So we sleep walk into that peril never comprehending how quickly things could unravel . We could easily become a country where tractors can’t start , that there’ll be no fuel to transport our food to our supermarkets , that there will be no fuel to run the mines that drive our national income , that there’ll be no fuel for us to survive.
x.com/ctindale/status/2069551049355239695
Tony Abbott
@HonTonyAbbott
Is Australia ready for the war over Taiwan that Kevin Rudd has said has a one-in-three chance of happening within three years? The invasion that would almost certainly mean that all our exports to China stop, that all our imports from China stop, that our export income and our fuel supplies almost immediately dry up, and, quite possibly, that there are missile strikes on Australia itself against which we currently have almost no air defences whatsoever.
For at least five years now, Australian leaders have solemnly intoned that we face the worst strategic situation since the late 1930s, while taking almost no serious steps to deal with it.
A country without a credible plan for the worst potential disaster that could befall it, is sleepwalking through lotus land. This is the conversation that should have begun years ago but that must start now.
My latest on getting Australia ready, at The Tony Abbott Newsletter: www.tonyabbott.au/p/are-we-ready-for-war -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Sirota
@davidsirota
I talk openly about the mistakes I’ve made in my life, and have apologized when I’ve been wrong. Contrition is part of who I am. It always has been. It was taught to me at a very young age. That’s why I deeply distrust those who ruined our world and who have never once apologized or renounced what they did.
The necon arsonists monetizing themselves as firefighters. The Obama folks who betrayed their promises, created the Trump backlash, and then got rich suddenly pretending to lead a resistance to the crisis they manufactured. These people have never once bothered to take responsibility for what they did.
They exemplify the elite impunity destroying our society. They don’t actually care if Trump’s authoritarianism is stopped. They don’t actually care about extinguishing the infernos they ignited. They care only about themselves and their lucrative grift — and when they effectively scream the quiet part and admit that, we should listen. We can perhaps welcome their momentary and fleeting support of a popular front against Trump, but we absolutely should not trust them with our political future.
They rely on the culture of elite impunity never holding them accountable. That culture is the crisis fueling every other crisis in our society. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
No, because for 50 years economic illiteracy has been systematically drilled into them by politicians, mass media and education. There's a finite pot and various groups must fight over their shares. And if we say there's enough fiat currency for everyone the 'bond vigilantes' will come for us. Yikes!
The Crispin Flintoff Show
@CrispinShow
Are people born after Thatcher unable to think outside the divisive debate on what to cut?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Built as an interactive companion to my new book, Beyond Equilibrium, the simulator lets you shock the model and watch the economy adjust through time, including the feedback loops driving the results.
Book launches tomorrow, October 3rd.
Links in post below👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Why do neoliberal economists insist that raising the minimum wage destroys jobs, even when evidence suggests otherwise?
Before germ theory, doctors blamed disease on foul air. They could observe the symptoms but fundamentally misunderstood what caused them.
Oxford economist @EricBeinhocker argues that economics may face a similar problem: theories built on flawed assumptions about how the economy actually works.
What would a revolution in economics look like?
Simple → Complex
Atomistic → Networked
Competition → Cooperation
Equilibrium → Disequilibrium
Linear → Nonlinear
Mechanistic → Behavioral
Efficient → Effective
Predictive → Adaptive
Independent → Interdependent
Individual ability → Group diversity
Rational calculators → Irrational approximators
Selfish → Strongly reciprocal
Win-lose → Win-win or lose-lose
Just as germ theory revolutionized medicine, Beinhocker argues that understanding complexity, evolution, and human behavior could fundamentally transform economics—and how we understand the economy itself.
Read more:democracyjournal.org/.../market-humanism-a-new.../This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Full video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fpmFFFDYJ9I
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Italy asks for the fiscal rules to be relaxed. Time and again, this is happening as the fiscal framework does not fit the problems that EU countries face. France and Belgium are currently struggling with the rules as well and about to impose austerity.
www.politico.eu/article/giorgia-meloni-fiscal-rules-spend… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What if fiscal headroom doesn't exist? youtu.be/Xp-pnyJU_n4 In the run-up to the Budget, there is going to be a lot of talk about fiscal headroom, but the reality is that this is just a figment of a Chancellor's imagination, just as fiscal rules are.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rethinking Economics
@rethinkecon
Joan Robinson knew that economics isn't a neutral science—it’s all about power.
We don't need more unthinking economists parroting econ class teachings.
We need rethinkers ready to push for an economy that serves people and planet.
If you agree, join the movement. ✊ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Robert Pearson
@robert19pearson
if the govt was solely interested in 'saving money' it would stop issuing Gilts, buy back all existing Gilts and set the rate paid on the reserves created to do so at zero (or -ve).
But rightly or wrongly, it has chosen to use monetary policy, which is mainly the control of -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jonathan Cook
@Jonathan_K_Cook
Benjamin Netanyahu now looks to be a political liability, even for Trump.
The US president, nosediving in the polls, needs a scapegoat – and the Israeli prime minister appears the only one suited for the role.
The antagonism is, in part, personal.
A number of recent reports indicate that Netanyahu pulled out all the stops to seduce Trump, against the advice of his generals, into launching an unprovoked and illegal war on Iran.
The promise of a decisive victory persuaded Trump he could secure his place in the history books as the president who “remade the Middle East”. Once Iran was out of the picture, the US would enjoy unchallenged control over the region’s oil.
And all of this would supposedly take place weeks after Trump had cemented his command over Venezuela’s oil, following an illegal operation at the start of the year to kidnap President Nicholas Maduro.
With Iran’s defeat, and Venezuela subjugated, economic rival China would find itself utterly dependent on the US for access to the main lubricant of the global economy. Trump could avoid a direct military confrontation with Beijing, bringing it to heel simply by threatening to turn off the oil spigot.
But, of course none of this came to pass.
Washington is now in an unwinnable war with Iran that has clarified to Tehran the extent of its power over the Strait of Hormuz - and of the parallel power of Ansar Allah, its allies in Yemen, over the Bab al-Mandab Strait. Together, they can inflict unmitigated damage to the world economy.
Soaring petrol prices on US forecourts are likely to be a critical factor in the collapse of the Republican vote in November’s mid-term elections and the likely loss of both Houses to the Democrats, turning Trump into a lame-duck president.
Meanwhile, the war has educated Washington’s client states in the Gulf that they are supremely vulnerable to any retaliation from Tehran and from Yemen - a fact they are reminded of every time Trump orders another reckless round of strikes on Iran.
For all its military might, Washington has shown it is unable to defend its Gulf allies.
This is an extract from my latest article The West wants Netanyahu gone - so Palestinians can be killed more quietly again. Find a link to the rest in the reply post ⬇️ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Aashis Joshi
@aashisjo
Perhaps equally shocking as this scale of destruction is the fact that Israel has faced no consequences for it, not even economic sanctions. And the fact that there are so many people around the world including a few in my own country Nepal who cheer this and justify this.
HatsOff
@HatsOffff
New aerial footage shows the scale of devastation in Gaza
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
warning for govts:
“austerity”
= ⬇️ govt sector deficit
= ⬇️ private sector surplus = ⬆️ financial fragility
= ⬆️ public disenchantment
= ⬆️ “populist” politics
… which all starts with unrealistic & wrong “neoclassical” monetarist economics.
We can do so much better though!
☮️ John Fielder - #NeverAgain for anyone
@JohnFielder1
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
Can we just pretend we are spending on the military, but actually use the money to invest in our NHS secretly.
Maybe build military-named NHS infrastructure?
Perhaps 'Major' Burns Unit or 'General' Hospital? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David McNab @mcfab@home.social
@DavidMcNab17
Hats off to Larry - about bloody time someone in the media started pointing out the operational reality of public spending.
More at @MMTUK_PRG
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/oct/01/rightwing-e… -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Very good!
Morgs
@Morgs_Take
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David
@Davidzvsur
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Normal Island News
@NormalIslandNws
You’ve gotta admire Bibi Netanyahu. Every time he’s in trouble, he comes up with something atrocious to get him off the hook. You’ll be pleasantly surprised to hear that his latest devious plot didn’t even involve killing anyone. Yes, you read that right!
With just four weeks until election day, Bibi stared into his crystal ball and predicted that a major attack was coming. You’ll never guess what happened the next day: one of Israel’s mortal enemies hijacked an airliner to help boost him in the polls. Isn’t it lovely when Muslims and Jews put aside their differences to work together?
Now I apologise if I get anything wrong here because the story is changing every five seconds, but the latest one goes something like this:
An Israeli was going to the toilet on the plane when he heard a fight in the cockpit. He notified the staff, but unfortunately the plane started falling out of the sky. Ordinary people would cry their eyes out, but Israelis are not normal people. Half of the passengers whipped out their phones and started filming while they were in freefall. Their faith is so strong that they knew they weren’t gonna die.
The reinforced cockpit door mysteriously opened and a bunch of air hostesses stormed the cockpit. They bravely took down the hijacker co-pilot who was armed with an axe. Most air hostesses would be useless in this situation, but the Israeli air hostesses took this fucker down without taking a scratch. They’re all basically GI Jane.
The captain had been hacked with the axe, but he was still breathing because he’s also super hard. Naturally, they sat him in a chair and wiped him down. That’s the correct medical procedure for someone who’s been hacked multiple times with an axe.
While all this was going on, a heroic plumber took control of the joystick and stabilised the plane, using skills that he learnt from watching Air Crash Investigation. He was so confident in his skills that he was ready to fly all the way to someone else’s home, but thankfully he didn’t need to.
A couple of passengers suddenly remembered they are off-duty pilots and kindly took control of the plane. It safely landed in Saudi Arabia and everyone cheered, but then they groaned when they realised they were in Saudi Arabia. Thankfully, they’re back in the promised land now. The first thing they wanted to do when they stepped off then plane was hug Netanyahu in front of cameras.
The Israeli prime minister was so ready for this moment that he instantly knew the hijacker was a jihadist trained in Iran. He announced this important detail, expecting the world to celebrate the heroes who staved off another 9/11. Unfortunately, no one believed him and the whole internet kept saying “false flag” so he’s now backed away from the Iran claims.
Personally, I’m disgusted that people are accusing Israel of another false flag, just because that’s what it’s done again. Just know that those antisemites don’t matter. What’s important is that Bibi’s ratings went up by six points, increasing the likelihood that he’ll avoid jail for letting October 7 happen. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Earth Hippy 🌎🕊️💚
@hippyygoat
Trump could not keep a straight face…
COMEDY CENTRAL. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Donibristle
@Donibristle1
I've been in a plane when it plunged suddenly 60 meters or so, and the force of it recovering caused a loud bang, overhead lockers opened, contents came out, masks were down, the cabin was a complete mess and passengers were very shaken including myself. Death spiral Horse shit.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
xpos
@blame_d_cat
The pilot in the CNN OutFront clip is Aaron Murphy, a commercial pilot and flight instructor. He is sitting in a flight simulator recreating the Flydubai FZ1073 incident so viewers can see what the cockpit and the aircraft itself would have looked like during the sudden dive.@CNN
Murphy’s point at the end of the segment is that the dive was not just violent to sit through — it was close to structurally unsurvivable. In the simulator, the horizon drops away, the jet pitches steeply nose-down, and overspeed warnings start screaming as the aircraft accelerates through the plunge. His conclusion is blunt: a descent that steep and that fast would have torn the airplane apart.
#flydubai #fz1073 #captainsmitmachchhar #indianpilotThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
xpos
@blame_d_cat
Thread🧵
1/ Yesterday’s Flydubai flight FZ1073, a 737 MAX from Dubai to Tel Aviv, was in cruise near 34,000 feet when it went into a steep nose-down dive. Tracking data show a drop on the order of 14,000 feet in about 30 seconds, with groundspeed rising toward 600 knots before the airplane recovered and diverted to Tabuk. That was not a normal descent. It was a plunge. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Frances 'Cassandra' Coppola
@Frances_Coppola
No way was this recorded inside a plane descending 14,000 feet in 30 seconds.
Israel National News - Arutz Sheva
@ArutzSheva_En
#watch: Israeli passengers rush the cockpit to rescue their Flydubai flight after the copilot attempted to hijack it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
Well...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
💧Paulkaz 🧢
@Paulkaz12
Penny on the left is a Singapore Airlines plane after a 54m plunge 2 years ago. Cabin damaged passengers injured from hitting the ceiling and face masks deployed. On the right the pristine FlyDubai plane after a 6096m death spiral. Why do you accept Mossad propaganda so easily.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Long Investor
@TheLongInvest
As a pilot for 20 years I have questions:
- where are the cabin crew here?
- where are the oxygen masks that automatically drop during a rapid emergency descent?
- how did the Capt manage to open the door while being stabbed?
- Omani pilots were not allowed to fly to Israel, why was he allowed?
- how did the offending pilot get a weapon onboard?
- why has this happened so close to elections?
- how are passengers walking around while apparently in a nosedive?
- who else was injured? Nose dives cause significant g force incidents
- why is there two perfectly positioned people recording the incident and not helping?
- why did a plumber take control and not the 2 pilots onboard who would certainly know when an aircraft was in a nosedive?
- why was the plumber speaking in English to Bibi after the flight
- why was he still in his blood soaked clothes 8 hours after the incident
False Flags have been a very effective mechanism to influence public opinion
Hitler burnt down the Reichstag just before his parliament elections and he won the election…changing the course of history.
A full and independent investigation should be carried out here.
Hopefully independent journalist will be allowed to view this too. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
@ProfSteveKeen Great podcast, Professor Keen. AI bubble POPPING, unprecedented UNREPAYABLE Government debt globally & INSANE levels of Private debt (A PERFECT STORM)🤔@patatoass @MacleodFinance @ukcolumn
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YQrBApPeJNU -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
When the Liar In Chief can’t believe your story,,,
Mohit Chauhan
@unmutemohit
Donald Trump: An Israeli plumber flew the plane, which he supposedly learned to fly by watching an air-disaster show. I don’t know if it is true or not, but this is the story I got from Bibi.
Story is so fake that even Donald Trump is doubting it. 😭😭This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
#fotw Daily post 1
A water-powered cotton mill opened near my home in 1771, lighting the touchpaper for a planet-wide experiment - the Industrial Revolution. Never have we paused to ask if it was the right way to go
That's why I wrote #fateoftheworld
Pls share + tag 2 people😊 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
These booms always end in busts, as herd behavior is driving these booms. It is the achiles heel of the capitalist sector of the economy. (Btw: how do they know the AI buildout ends in 2032? 🤔)
Thorsten Froehlich
@FroehlichThors1
Paul Krugman just shared this in his recent post.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kim Iversen 🇺🇸
@KimIversenShow
I'm NOT buying it
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniel Davis Deep Dive
@DanielLDavis1
More arrogant, classless behavior by US senior officials, which further degrades our reputation internationally and makes all future diplomacy more difficult.
According to the AP, “After little progress was made in weekend meetings between Iranian and Qatari mediators, Rubio *lost patience* and told the Iranians on Monday that Araghchi and his delegation had to leave New York immediately.”
So we’ll b petty w pretty much anything.
Sure, we previously claimed to be negotiating w Iran only to launch two wars against them within an eight month span, and yeah, we assassinated their head of state, plus, ok, we killed a bunch of little girls and their teachers on the first day of the second war, but is that any reason for them not to have the decency to surrender to us, on our time schedule, according to terms we demand, while offering nothing in return?
😕 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
One of the many who deserved a Nobel, if it were actually one, rather than a fraud invented by the Swedish Central Bank to oppose social democratic economic policies.
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
"Sound Accounting and Uncompromising Vision: Remembering Wynne Godley at 100"
A beautiful piece by Zazzaro and Lavoie remembering their colleague and friend, Wynne Godley, on the centenary of his birth.
www.levyinstitute.org/blog/sound-accounting-and-uncomprom… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Shahin Ashkiani
@shaahin_a
Acc to a 1997 survey, the majority of UK corporations did not respond to a demand boom by hiking their prices
They would do so by increasing their production via working overtime (62%)
From Hall, Walsh, and Yates 1997 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tony of 1Dime
@1DimeOfficial
Tucker Carlson’s awakening lately is truly something to behold lol
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mike Carlton
@MikeCarlton01
It’s partly because civilised people loathe Trump and his gang of grovelling sycophants. Nor do we want to sit in some cell at LAX or JFK for hours on end while some gormless thug goes through our social media profiles.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
We've been told protecting nature is "too expensive."
But what if we've been measuring the wrong costs all along?
A provocative look at money, ecosystems, and public policy.
stephenhinton584706.substack.com/p/from-science-to-policy…
#ecology #economics #sustainability -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
💧Michael West
@MichaelWestBiz
"The RBA Board delivered. Thank you for making me and my comfortable peers richer, boosting my unearned income so I can continue to splash the cash around."
@MichaelPascoe01
#auspol #rates
michaelwest.com.au/a-blunt-tool-rbas-incompetence-is-maki… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
Podcasts:
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen
Every Economics Concept Explained in 30 Minutes braveneweurope.com/economics/steve-keen-every-economics-c…
Alex Krainer, Glenn Diesen @Glenn_Diesen
Bond Market Collapse and the New Chinese Economic Order
braveneweurope.com/geopolitics/alex-krainer-glenn-diesen-…
#podcasts #economics #china -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
UK £280 million trade surplus 1978 - principal commodities were machinery 29%, transport equipment 25%, chemicals 12%, textiles: 11%, iron and steel 3%, non-ferrous metals 2%. They're just liars, aren't they?
Andrew_Bell2019
@ABell2019
The trade surplus from '77 to '85, 3/4 of it under the Tories, came from N Sea oil.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ISHKA 🎒
@zvonko2026
Les troupes américaines quittent l'Irak après 23 ans.
Et pas une seule arme de destruction massive trouvée
1,3 million d’irakiens mortsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matías Vernengo
@NakedKeynes
Post commemorating the 100 anniversary of Wynne Godley’s birth by Gennaro Zezza and Marc Lavoie @LevyEcon www.levyinstitute.org/blog/sound-accounting-and-uncomprom…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
The UK doesn't need an IMF bailout youtu.be/ZDbZgBiMp_8 The Financial Times and others are asking if the UK might need to turn to the IMF for a loan - which is absurd, because nothing could be further from the truth.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The interest rate does not equilibrate saving and investment. Changes in income do the adjusting.
But income is continuously changing through time, so there is no reason to assume it ever reaches equilibrium.
S=I is just an ex post accounting identity.
End of story. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Shovel
@TheShovel
RBA Reassures Australians They’ll Stop Raising Interest Rates as Soon as Economy Collapses
theshovel.com.au/2026/09/30/rba-reassures-australians-the… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stormyalert
@Stormyalert
Es brutal lo que meten algunos para el sureste de Francia, da miedo...🌧️⚠️
Hasta 550mm en menos de 24h marca el modelo AROME, es una completa locura.
El modelo suizo 4x4 es incluso más bestia, con acumulaciones ya de 700mm en la misma ciudad de Nimes.
Espero que la población esté preparada...
#euwx #meteo #weather #severewx -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
When will @martinwolf_ admit that #mmt was right all along? A currency issuer cannot run out of numbers like an editor cannot run out of letters. This debate is a colossal waste of time and resources. Let's discuss society's problems and how to fix them instead.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
One of the many who deserved a Nobel, if it were actually one, rather than a fraud invented by the Swedish Central Bank to oppose social democratic economic policies.
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
"Sound Accounting and Uncompromising Vision: Remembering Wynne Godley at 100"
A beautiful piece by Zazzaro and Lavoie remembering their colleague and friend, Wynne Godley, on the centenary of his birth.
www.levyinstitute.org/blog/sound-accounting-and-uncomprom… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
"Brown was, entirely inappropriately, terrified of the City of London..... All of them, and now Andy Burnham, signed up to the belief that the purpose of government was to meet the needs of the financial services sector, and not the people of this country. Every single fiscal rule created since then has had this sole purpose."
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
As I say on fiscal rules in the glossary to my blog:
"Fiscal rules are targets set by governments to limit borrowing, debt, or deficits over time. They are presented as if they are neutral, technical constraints on what governments can do. In reality, they are arbitrary political choices.Governments adopt and abandon fiscal rules at will. Each new government tends to change the rules it inherits. That alone proves that they are not immutable laws of economics but rhetorical devices designed to give the impression of discipline."
I added:
"The primary function of fiscal rules has been to justify austerity measures. By pretending that there are financial limits to what governments can do, they have provided cover for cuts in public services, social security, and investment in social infrastructure."
Yesterday at the Labour Party's conference in Liverpool, Chancellor John Healey said:
"[T]he Prime Minister and I are in lockstep that we will meet the fiscal rules.That we will maintain control of Britain's finances."
The UK actually has, at present, three fiscal rules:
Rule 1. The current budget should be on course to be in balance or surplus by 2029/30 (‘stability rule')
Rule 2. Net financial debt should fall as a share of the economy in 2029/30 (‘investment rule')
Rule 3. Some types of welfare spending must remain below a pre-specified level (the ‘welfare cap')
To put these another way, they mean:
Rule 1. That the government will stop injecting net new money into the economy by 2029 to support its growth objective, and will rely entirely on the private sector to achieve this goal by then.
Rule 2. That the government will cease to provide the additional savings facilities that an economy that is growing in financial terms will need if financial security and stability are to be provided to the UK's financial institutions that underpin the operation of the UK's financial services sector and its overseas trade. Financial risk will, therefore, be increased as a result, with a resulting increase in the likelihood of financial instability.
Rule 3. That the government will maintain a policy of austerity that reduces the likelihood that those with the greatest needs in the UK will have those needs met.
I have little doubt that the government will not agree with my interpretation of these rules. However, read what they say, and understand what they are meant to achieve, and my version of their statements expresses the reality of their supposed priorities, to which John Healey recommitted this Labour government yesterday.
No doubt Andy Burnham will do so again today.
The history of these fiscal rules, introduced as they were by Gordon Brown in 1997, makes clear why this is the case, and what the real priority of government since then has been.
Brown was, entirely inappropriately, terrified of the City of London. He and Blair won a massive majority from the people of this country, as Starmer did again in 2024. In both cases, the victory represented rejection of Tory sleaze as much as it did enthusiasm for any Labour programme, and Blair, Brown and Starmer alike reflected that fact in their behaviour. Not one of them had any confidence in the mandate they had been given. None of them believed that a parliamentary majority provided them with the authority to challenge the status and power of the City of London. All of them, and now Andy Burnham, signed up to the belief that the purpose of government was to meet the needs of the financial services sector, and not the people of this country. Every single fiscal rule created since then has had this sole purpose. The aim has been to:
Confirm that the government will bow to the interests of the City.
Reiterate that, whatever the wishes and needs of the people of the UK, their priorities and political mandates, the City and those who speak for it will instead dictate the agenda of the government.
State that if there is a conflict between the interests of the City and the interests of those who might elect governments in the UK, then the City shall have priority, whatever the cost to human well-being.
Make clear that sovereignty has been surrendered by the democratic will of Parliament on the altar of high finance.
That is what John Healey confirmed yesterday. He did, to use the language I created in my 2011 book, The Courageous State, confirm himself to be a cowardly politician who will, when he sees a problem requiring attention, defer to the interests of the City and declare that markets will provide a solution, washing his hands of responsibility in the process.
I am so bored of this type of government. I have lived with it for decades. It has failed me. It has failed the people of this country. It has been designed to do so. There is no intention amongst those who now sit in our Cabinet to change this in any way. And yet, the possibility to do so does exist.
There is no need for this country to have a fiscal rule of the type noted.
There is nothing to stop it having a rule for government that states that everyone who wants to have a job should be able to have one, and that it is the job of the government to ensure that this is possible.
There is nothing that says we cannot run government so that every young person in the UK gets the type of education that they need, rather than that which is deemed necessary for them to partake in in a neoliberal economy which is intent upon minimising employment, and then offering the maximum number of bullshit jobs, as David Graeber would have put it, to those left desperate enough to take them.
There is nothing that says this government could not commit itself to eradicating poverty with all its devastating social consequences.
There is nothing that says that this government cannot commit to the defence that is necessary against climate change, and the lack of resilience that we have with regard to critical supplies of goods and services that are essential for the maintenance of life in this country, and against the abuse of so many people by neoliberal and far-right politics that treats them as expendable or alien, and so available to be abused.
There is nothing that says we cannot manage the economy to achieve these goals, and do so in a way that is designed to manage inflation, because we know that is technically possible. What is more, we know that it is possible without the use of penal interest rates.
There is nothing that says we cannot build a sustainable future for our children, grandchildren and those who will come beyond them.
There is nothing that says any of these things is impossible, and simultaneously.
They are not, however, happening, and that is by political choice. Because John Healey and Andy Burnham are deliberately choosing not to do these things, and because they do not even possess the curiosity to wonder whether alternatives to those that the Treasury imposes upon them might be available, they are, like all their predecessors since 1979, guilty of the deliberate destruction of well-being in this country by making it their priority to achieve this outcome.
If anyone asks me why I cannot support a Labour government in this country, that is why.
All that baffles me is that anyone would still support this Labour Party, or why any trade union would wish to financially donate to it, or why anyone would imagine it will deliver anything of consequence for people in this country. It is time for people of courage to walk away from Labour. They have had their chance. They have blown it. We need a real alternative in this country now. They will never be it again. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economics is the study of goods and services moving through space and time.
Scarcity is a given within a finite theatre of operations, so I consider it causally second-order: a balancing constraint on economic processes of growth, not the process itself. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Read this. Neatest summary of the current global situation I've read. Now that the rest of the world is beginning to organise its economies according to its own needs, the West's ruling elite can no longer systematically and reliably extract surplus and enrich themselves. In a desperate attempt to rescue its collapsing financialised economy, the US will quite happily risk nuclear conflicts in any part of the world except its own - especially Europe. But think about the primary reason behind such wanton mass murder and destruction. It's nothing more than the refusal - inability? - of the perverted, narcissistic Epstein class and their obseqious admirers to enjoy the beautiful moments of ordinary, modest lives. If only we could recognise the real enemy. mattiasforsgren.substack.com/p/hegemonic-logic
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
Podcasts:
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen – Every Economics Concept Explained in 30 Minutes
braveneweurope.com/economics/steve-keen-every-economics-c…
Alex Krainer, Glenn Diesen @Glenn_Diesen - Bond Market Collapse and the New Chinese Economic Order braveneweurope.com/geopolitics/alex-krainer-glenn-diesen-…
#podcasts #economics #china -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Forthcoming in next issue of the @ReviewofPE
Neo-Liberalism and the Slowing of Growth in the Past Four Decades
Malcolm Sawyer
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2026.2724139 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
I was 24 in 1979 before this Thatcherite mouthpiece was born. 1970s - trade surplus, secure jobs, affordable housing, functioning dentistry and healthcare etc. Ruined by the failure to deal with the oil crisis. 1980s - a nightmare of deindustrialisation, trade deficits, unemployment, rising house prices, drug markets, rising crime etc. Don't let these liars rewrite history.
Simon Clarke
@SirSimonClarke
Andy Burnham seems to remember a different 1970s to the rest of us. Britain in 1979 was utterly broken - ravaged by unaccountable trade union power, economically stagnant, the sick man of Europe.
The 1980s saw a remarkable national recovery based on free enterprise, the rule of law and championing Western values. And it is this that our Prime Minister rails against… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The bond yield moves together with the Fedfunds rate, which is determined by the Federal Reserve Bank's actions (or lack thereof). If you think that yields are too high, you should ask the Fed to reduce its policy rates. Problem solved.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Forget C19 and C20 dogma. Today's political message must be a combination of positive 'can do' politics based on post-Keynesian economics and 'enlightened catastrophism' - if we don't disempower the parasitic, violent creditor class and their global money markets (private equity, bond, FX), bring our economies under democratic control and forge fair and mutually supportive production and trading relations, we face neofeudal tyranny, crippling austerity, civil unrest, far-right reaction, climate disaster and potential nuclear holocaust. And there's no need to lie or even exaggerate.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rupert Read 🌍 🔥
@GreenRupertRead
"Under this #elniño, the summer of 2026 will probably look relatively mild. Floods are also likely to increase to a scale we have never witnessed and are dramatically unprepared for."
Check out my latest #substack with some suggestions for how to prepare for what's coming. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter Davies
@MastermanDavies
2025 Prof Richard Murphy: Does UK need Tory George Osborne’s Office for Budget Responsibility (+an “independent” Bank of England)?
“Neutrality” doesn't exist. Whose orthodoxy prevails? Whose interests are served?
Austerity baked in. Democracy baked out!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=lu6i9BB0XpU&t=2s -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Battle
@sciencetao
13/ Forrester died in 2016, known mainly within systems circles and to Limits to Growth readers. His method deserves far wider recognition, not least because we are about to need it. Full lecture: youtu.be/rP839_Ohlr8?t=2454 @systemdynamics_
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yes I’d like to set Richard straight here @profwolff. The knowledge will strengthen his critique of capitalism as well.
Theresa Sanders
@arealmermaid2
Prof. Wolfe has SO many positive observations about HOW we use our Collective Currency. Unfortunately, @profwolff again misrepresented the National Debt. I wish another Heterodox Economist (@ProfSteveKeen ), would have a debate or discussion with him!
I don’t know if he is misrepresenting Our Collective Currency CREATION, on purpose, to hurry alternative economic policies, but misrepresenting WHERE our Currency originates from & what the Spending CONSTRAINTS are, is hardly helpful!
He is talking about the Public & Foreign Sectors. As long as we have enough of Our Collective Real Resources & Productive Labor Capacity, WITHIN the USA, those are Our ONLY Spending Constraints! For us, PRIVATE DEBT, is a far BIGGER Problems!
A Public Sector Deficit IS a Private Sector SURPLUS! That IS how money enters the Economy, BUT we need a BALANCED Economy, NOT Budget, as the Currency ISSUER! It is important WHERE in the Economy it is spent & for WHO & WHAT? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Every Economics Concept Explained in 30 Minutes
@ProfSteveKeen
youtu.be/bHHOuXLDYiA via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Yep. Start with a book called 'Reclaiming the State' by Fazi and Mitchell then start rummaging around the works of @ProfSteveKeen and the GOAT economic historian Michael Hudson. Michael's 'Destiny of Civilization' and 'Forgive Them Their Debts' are great starts.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jamie Smith
@JGS952
Let me try with some more clarity then as it's a fascinating albeit niche point but fairly fundamental to how we understand and explain money in our society. 🧵
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Paul
@chrisp_intheory
Fiscal policy is not irrelevant. Coolidge's surpluses meant the federal government was taking more dollars out of the economy than it put back in, while the 1920s saw a massive expansion of private debt. By 1929 private debt was roughly 156% of output. Then monetary contraction
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Martin Wolf used his FT column this morning to demand that Labour increase taxes in this country.
He did not do so to address the crisis of inequality that we face.
He did not suggest this need arises because of the urgent necessity of redistributing to those in need.
He said that raising taxes was essential because spending cannot be cut and “the [Chancellor] needs to create a fiscal path that credibly reduces the ratio of net public debt to GDP, so re-creating some of the room the country lost over two decades of crisis. This will mean a substantial fiscal tightening. The current fiscal rules are not enough.”
As if to emphasise the point, Wolf concluded his article by saying, “Fiscal credibility is not a luxury. A government that does not deliver it is walking naked.”
In presenting his case, Wolf also argues for increases in income taxes, by implication generally, and VAT, which is, of course, just about the most regressive tax of all.
The message is, then, quite clear and comes in three parts.
The first is that people must brace themselves to pay more tax.
The second is that they must, despite this, expect nothing more from the government, even though they are already disenchanted with its failure to meet their obvious needs.
Thirdly, all of this is supposed to be required so that the government can, to use a metaphor, put some money aside for a rainy day, whilst coincidentally keeping the City of London happy.
It takes little decoding to work out the real message. It is that Wolf thinks that the bond markets rule.
He thinks they must have their way.
He believes that the price of them doing so must be borne by ordinary people, and by those who will be made unemployed as a consequence of the actions that he proposes.
He thinks that the economy must be slowed, because that is the inevitable consequence of what he is recommending.
He believes that the sacrifices that will result, whether from the failure to manage climate change, or to deliver the homes that people need, or to provide the training, healthcare and support that people will require if they are to join the current toxic neoliberal world of work, let alone meet the needs of an ageing population, must be made to support defence spending and the need for the government to accumulate reserves so that it might have the funds required in the event of crisis.
The problem with Wolf’s argument is that we are in crisis.
The world is already at war, led by the leading rogue states in the world, which are the USA and Israel. We are already paying the price of that.
Austerity is already denying people the services they need.
There is already rising political tension that threatens democracy, which is being exploited by the far right of politics, with which it increasingly seems that the City of London and the FT are aligned. If you wanted to promote fascism in the UK, Wolf’s plan is a blueprint to follow.
And all of this rests on completely false economics. Wolf's foundational assumption is that the household analogy applies. The fact is that it does not. That analogy is. a myth, and a dangerous one. The government is not like a household. In fact, in almost every imaginable situation, it has to act in ways that are the opposite of any household.
Despite his supposed intelligence, and the fact that he has written for the FT longer than most of its readers have been alive, Wolf does not know that.
It is his belief that, like a household, the government must raise funds through taxation or borrowing before it can spend. That is not true. The government creates money when it spends. The capacity to pay tax and to save arises from the spending that the government creates, and the money that it puts into circulation.
What is more, what he calls borrowing is no such thing. It is saving, and nothing more or less than that. It is already the money the country has put aside to deposit in a safe place in case the proverbial rainy day arrives. It is deposited in a place which the government provides. But Wolf does not understand that. And so he gets quite literally everything that he says wrong.
In his world, the goal of government is to run a neat balance sheet.
And the purpose of politics is to balance the government’s cash flow
Whilst the interest group that the government is meant to serve is the City of London.
None of those is true. Politics is about three things.
It is about meeting the needs of people.
It is about defending people from attack, including from those who would seek to threaten their well-being by forcing up petrol, diesel, gas, electricity and food prices.
And it is about protecting people from those who would abuse them, and most especially those with power and finance who would exploit those without either.
Wolf’s ideology does not facilitate the meeting of needs.
It does not protect people from attack.
And it serves the interests of those who abuse, and not those who are abused.
In this life, we have to choose whose side we are on. Wolf has made his choice. He serves the forces of oppression. I am only interested in serving the forces of liberation for those who need to live with freedom from fear, which is the state to which far too many have been consigned by neoliberalism and its proponents.
That is a decision we all have to make. And the need to do so is growing by the day. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alex Jones
@RealAlexJones
HUGE: Sylvester Stallone has come out against all major foreign wars, including the current Iran disaster, in a bold and courageous statement.
“Now I realize all war is futile. It's stupid. It's a mechanism to make tons of money for the War Department and its manufacturers.” -
— Stallone told the New York Times.
Stallone is an extremely accomplished, director, actor and businessman, as well as a major supporter of Trump.
Of course he is now being attacked by the usual suspects..This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Alex Jones
@RealAlexJones
Special Saturday Show: Viral Comics Duncan Trussell & Kurt Metzger Join Alex Jones Live At The Recaptured Infowars Studios In Austin Texas - They Are About To Take Crashing Out To The Next Level! Plus Other Surprise Guests! - Must Watch/Share x.com/i/broadcasts/1dKrPrpXWyVJX
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇦🇺 Who knew? Australia has a rather spectacular Achilles' heel hiding in its economy.
It consumes more diesel per person than any other OECD country shown here.
1.10 tons of oil equivalent per capita, almost twice the U.S. and nearly seven times Mexico.
That makes sense when you look at what Australia actually runs on: mining machinery, agriculture, heavy transport and enormous freight distances.
And here comes the slap in the face:
Australia imports roughly 87% of its diesel.
And we're currently discovering what that means.
The OECD says Australian diesel prices surged about 66% by mid-April after the Middle East energy shock, even with a temporary cut in fuel taxes.
Australia doesn't just have an oil-price problem.
But has built an extraordinary amount of its physical economy around a fuel it largely cannot make itself.
This whole thing looks increasingly difficult to manage.
Source: @jackprandelli / Writer: Oliver -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Here's Andy looking to reinflate the housing bubble that led us to the 2008 crisis. Just what we need - subsidised moneylending rather than public investment, jobs, services etc. etc....
Andy Burnham
@andyburnham
This is huge.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alcea
@Alcea16
That's thevreason why mainstream economy is a religion, not science. A scientist would formulate a hypothesis, e.g. "minimum wage increase destroes jobs", than predict that you will find higher unemployment after the rise and if that's not the case, discard the hypothesis.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Major video critiquing economics about to be posted, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/major-video-critiquing-econo…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
I'm reposting this below because it's a very clear condensation of the three major claims the holders of big capital - banks, hedge funds, sovereign wealth funds, corporations, insurance funds, private pension funds, very rich individuals etc. - require us to keep believing. Suggest a programme of public spending and investment to reboot an ailing economy, and you'll have these warnings immediately fired back at you. Should we worry? Yes and no. It's very complex, so it's a long read and I'm forced to omit a lot of stuff, but bear with me, I'll try to boil it down.
The claims:
1. Taxes and government borrowing from international bond markets fund public spending.
2. These international bond markets will discipline any government that runs an unfunded deficit, principally by jacking up yields to make borrowing more expensive.
4. Capital will flee the country and invest elsewhere.
OK, spoiler for those short of time. Are any of these claims true? Yes, but only because Western nations continue to believe them and keep electing politicians who, along with central bankers, operate their fiat money systems in accordance with the global system these claims represent. Politically and ideologically yes, technically no. We're conditioned to think that this belief system is 'reality'. This is how belief systems have always worked - metaphysical claims on reality are what the philosophers call 'ontology', often selected and justified by naturalised ethics - this is real, it's just the way things are and it's good (or evil). The basis of this particular and very recently established (300 years or so) belief system is that capitalist markets are good (fair, efficient etc.) and national states representing organised workers are bad (tyrannical, inefficient etc.). So let markets work their magic and allow the state to intervene minimally only when they hit problems (crashes, recessions, unemployment etc.) that can always be overcome - calm down, no sweat, just keep it going. Politics is reduced to the degree of intervention we should tolerate, nothing more, but, whenever possible, less.
So, the bankers, economists, politicians and hacks you see on the telly all the time looking knowledgeable, clever and rational - steady hand on the tiller! - are either 1) subjects of an ontological-ethical belief system they want you to be subjects of too, or 2) liars who know it's just a belief system but want people to keep believing it's real and letting it run as a globally locked-in system because it enriches them and their pals.
A little more detail - what are these bond markets and why can capital just up and run off somewhere else when it wants? Bonds first appeared in C12 Venice as forced loans to fund a war. It all went pear-shaped, the Doge was executed by a mob of angry rich people and hired thugs, and loans were consolidated into a fund called the Monte Vecchio. It paid 5% interest - hey guys, free money to make us richer! - so the richies enjoyed it and didn't press for the repayment of the principal because that would reduce the interest, which later became known as the 'yield' as secondary markets developed in which more interest could be extracted. So, don't ask for it all back, just keep it rolling, forever if you can. Free money forever, and even more when freely trading on secondary markets with discounts. Usurer's Heaven on Earth!
In those days central banks and paper money didn't exist. So governments relied on metallic coins accumulated by the richies extracting labour and produce and doing dodgy deals on coin markets like the Rialto. After that a lot of stuff happened regarding coins and metal, but if we fast forward to the C16 coin values were set by decree (face value) rather than metallic value. Between C17 and C19 paper currencies were issued backed by silver and gold reserves. Government bonds were centralised first in C17 Netherlands. Of course the VOC (Dutch East India Company) loved this as a fairly reliable stash for its boatloads of spare dosh paying yields. Bonds were more reliable than the unstable private banking system because government land and tax were the endless assets of last resort - they even had VAT!
The UK set up its central bank in 1694 under invited Dutch influence and immediately started selling gilts. The richies with spare dosh immediately fell in love with it. Things started moving faster in C18 as UK bondholders struck up friendly relations with politicians to establish dependency on secondary bond markets. Beginning with the famous 'coffee-house trade' - legend has it they liked coffee because it kept them alert while doing dodgy deals - secondary markets developed as a powerful force. The principle is simple - if bond buyers can get higher yields and lower prices in the secondary private trading market, governments are pressured to match them. But only if the politicians and central bankers are friendly. They have to be friendly. And it helps if they're believers in the magic of markets and the ethical notion that savers and investors are glorifying God by making themselves rich and trickling bits of it down to the Godly but less deserving poor.
Of course, now that we had central banks, paper money and government accounting ledgers, fiat currency was used in emergencies, such as the Napoleonic Wars and WWI, but that was kept quiet. The very idea that governments can create money endogenously (from within) by fiat - Franklin and Lincoln also did it in the USA - rather than relying on interest-bearing loans from private moneylenders calling themselves 'bondholders' must be seen as evil. Abandon hope all ye who do this, by Jove! J.M. Keynes worked in the Treasury during WWI, and legend has it that he saw officials fabricating bond sales in order to keep politicians and the public alike believing that private loans are essential.
Bond markets were rolled out across Europe in C19. Yes, the Rothschilds were heavily involved but let's not start blaming the Jooz because that's not the case. It was the richies combined doing it. In C20 a lot of stuff happened as the UK left the gold standard in 1931, then after 1944 Bretton Woods set up a gold exchange standard based on dollar convertibility and imposed capital controls to ensure at least some profits were reinvested in domestic economies. The richies didn't like any of this, and started circumventing these controls via the Eurodollar market.
Between 1971 and 1978 Western nations abandoned Bretton Woods and the gold exchange standard. Free-floating fiat money was adopted. The richies understood the necessity and potential advantages (for them) of this but also saw it as dodgy because people might get the idea that democratic (one day!) governments can issue currency to spend and invest, thereby crowding out mega-rich private lenders and cutting back on their free money. What better mechanism to impose fiscal discipline on governments than the secondary bond markets and their vicious cousin the FX (foreign exchange) markets? All they need are friendly politicians, bankers, economists and hacks. Easy gig - plenty of them, either true believers or practiced liars. So, after 1979, the plan was to set big capital free to circulate around the world, like it did in the (for them) good old days of Empire, funnelling it through global bond markets and FX markets, enriching themselves and simultaneously imposing strict fiscal discipline on governments.
By the way, lately, rapidly developing nations such as China have used massive dollops of public investment and capital controls to boost their economies. So the richies and their little helpers try to convince us to hate them as tyrants and watch as their economy eventually collapses into a vortex of unpayable debt - which it hasn't, of course, but we're supposed to live in hope.
In 1979 the first thing the Thatcherites did was abandon capital controls. Other Western nations got the idea and stock (the productive end is more risky, so careful!), bond and FX markets (less risky and lucrative!) - the 'money markets' - were rolled out globally after 1980 by a powerful politician/banker/investor/media alliance whose adherents firmly believe (or want us to) that money markets should discipline and control governments. Of course they also gift them safe savings and endless oodles of free money in the form of yields, but you know, that's just a little sweetener for the valiant 'risk takers'..... even though these markets aren't very risky.
Technical disempowerment would be quite simple - firm policies in the primary sales, central bank intervention, fixed-rate, non-tradable bonds and capital controls to throttle the secondary market and FX markets - but this would require coordinated policies initially across the G10.... or G8 first, because the Brits and Yanks wouldn't have it, would they? Some nation must be brave and set the ball rolling. We simply lack the politicians willing and able to do this. And we continue believing. Machiavelli said the best way to instill belief is fear - divine punishment. This is how it works. The markets are the divine supplier of fairness, efficiency, consumer democracy and prosperity to Godly (optional these days) sovereign individuals. Disobey them and we will be punished. Escaping this will be as big a leap for freedom as escaping from the Mediaeval Catholic Church.
Colin Smith
@NoteTaker_X
If "taxpayers' money" is a myth and governments can just endlessly finance themselves by creating ledger entries, why do sovereign bond markets exist? As we just saw discussed this morning, the moment a government tries to actually operate on this MMT fantasy and run massive unfunded deficits, international bond markets price their debt at junk status and capital flees. You are advertising an economic fairy tale Richard.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The New Culture Forum
@NewCultureForum
A once in a LIFETIME global crash is about to hit...perhaps in WEEKS.
It could lead to FOOD RATIONING in Britain & the COLLAPSE of the financial system
So says @ProfSteveKeen, one of the few economists to predict the 2008 financial crash
WATCH: youtu.be/YQrBApPeJNU
@RafHM -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Zillionaire Nick Hanauer: We don’t need to look far to find a microcosm of the larger shift. When we proposed a $15 minimum wage in Seattle, we were laughed out of rooms by serious, progressive economists. It violated the iron law. Raise wages, lose jobs. Basic supply and demand. Except: that iron law turned out not to be true. Not in Seattle. Not in San Francisco. Not in Germany. Not in the UK. Not in Mexico. Not anywhere.
If raising wages doesn’t kill jobs, then labor is not simply a commodity priced by supply and demand. If labor is not simply a commodity, then workers are also consumers, and suppressing their wages suppresses the demand that drives growth. If that’s true, then the IMF’s recent finding — inequality isn’t the price of dynamism; it’s the destroyer of it — makes perfect sense.
Minimum-wage increases were expected to kill jobs. The fact that they didn’t should make us rethink the "laws" of economics.
Read the empirical evidence from economist @arindube: irle.berkeley.edu/.../Minimum-Wage-Effects-Across...This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I read Menger's The Origins of Money. It's largely theoretical and conjectural for how money could have emerged.
In David Graeber's Debt: The First 5,000 Years, he actually engages with the archaeological and historical evidence for how money, debt, and credit systems developed.
Handre
@Handre
Carl Menger published On the Origins of Money in 1892, and it remains arguably the most devastating refutation of the statist theory of money ever written.
Menger worked in Vienna during the late 19th century, when the German Historical School dominated European economics. That school rejected universal economic laws and insisted governments shape institutions deliberately. Menger spent his career dismantling that claim. His 1871 "Principles of Economics" launched the marginalist revolution, and his 1892 essay finished the job on monetary theory specifically.
The core argument is simple and brutal: nobody invented money. No king decreed it, no parliament voted it into existence. Individual traders, acting on self-interest, gradually converged on the most saleable commodity available to them. Gold and silver won because they are durable, divisible, portable, and scarce. This process happened spontaneously, across cultures, without central coordination. Menger called the most saleable good the most "liquid" commodity, and traced how liquidity differences between goods naturally selected winners over centuries of voluntary exchange.
Menger exposes the state's foundational lie: that money derives its validity from government authority. Every central bank, every fiat currency regime, every IMF directive operates on that lie. The Federal Reserve, which prints dollars with no commodity anchor and has destroyed roughly 97% of the dollar's 1913 purchasing power, exists entirely because the state captured and corrupted a spontaneous market institution.
Menger's legacy is the intellectual ammunition to say clearly that central banks are parasites on a system they did not build and cannot improve. The market created money, then Governments hijacked it. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Simon Petherick
@SimonTPetherick
Really interesting conversation, where @ProfSteveKeen draws a comparison between the control of AI and the control of water in the UK since privatisation, making a case for public ownership of AI development — slow and boring being better than fast and inventive!
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
'They’ve Lost Control!' Why AI bosses are begging for regulation | Andre... youtu.be/5xkiVlT-7Ac via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jake
@jhorsewhisperer
Do NOT use this scheme.
A 97.5% mortgage at 6% interest. What could possibly go wrong?
You’re being encouraged to buy an overpriced new build with almost no equity, while housebuilders get richer.
Ask yourself one simple question:
Why isn’t this being offered on existing homes?
The UK property market is flat. Instead of addressing the real problems stamp duty, affordability, supply and everything else the government would rather dress it up with another scheme designed to stimulate demand and prop up prices.
This benefits the government and housebuilders far more than it benefits you.
Don’t rush into buying a house simply because a scheme makes it seem easier. You’ll be stuck for a long time and owning a house comes with significant financial pressure beyond the monthly payments.
Save a 10/20% deposit. Buy when YOU are financially ready.
This doesn’t fix the UK property market.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 BREAKING: Andy Burnham will announce a new "Help to Buy" scheme next week
Called "Your First Home", it will allow young people to buy their first home with a deposit of just 2.5% -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Moving Home with Charlie
@moving_charlie
The evidence is damning from the last time the government used taxpayer money to subsidise house prices.
You can't fix affordability by lending people even more debt.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Moving Home with Charlie
@moving_charlie
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
BladeoftheSun
@BladeoftheS
Wow great, a scheme to create 50 year mortgages and increase house prices even more.
What a brilliant idea.
For the billionaire bankers and landlords.
Andy Burnham
@andyburnham
Let's be honest.
A lot of young people have stopped believing they'll ever own their own home.
That's what happens when rents are high, house prices are high, and saving for a deposit feels impossible.
My Labour government is stepping in to help.
With Your First Home, first-time buyers will be able to buy a new-build home with a deposit of just 2.5%.
Because hard work and saving should count for something.
And because the dream of owning your own home shouldn't belong only to those with help from the bank of Mum and Dad. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hadidi
@hdrnssr
I’m just gonna leave this list here of all of Israel’s prime ministers; their real names, their names they changed to so they sound more “Hebrew”, and their “ancestral homeland” respectively:
• David Ben-Gurion (David Grün) - Poland.
• Moshe Sharett (Moshe Chertok) - Ukraine.
• Levi Eshkol (Levi Yitzhak Shkolnik) - Ukraine.
• Yigal Allon (Yigal Peikowitz) - Belarus.
• Golda Meir (Golda Mabovitch) - Ukraine.
• Yitzhak Rabin (Yitzhak Rubitzov) - Ukraine / Belarus.
• Menachem Begin (Menakhem Volfovich Biegun) - Belarus.
• Yitzhak Shamir (Yitzhak Yezernitsky) - Belarus.
• Shimon Peres (Szymon Perski) - Belarus.
• Ehud Barak (Ehud Brog) - Russia.
• Ariel Sharon (Ariel Scheinerman) - Belarus.
• Ehud Olmert - Russia.
• Naftali Bennett - United States.
• Yair Lapid (Yair Lampel) - Serbia.
• Benjamin Netanyahu (Benjamin Mileikowsky) a Poland.
Hope this helps. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Malcolm Reavell
@malcolm_reavell
Tgis is not helping the first time buyer, or solving housing problems.
It’s helping the finance and housing markets. It’s not the solution we need. It’s more of the same Tory/neoliberal rubbish that created the problem in the first place.
Build council houses and don’t sell them
Andy Burnham
@andyburnham
Let's be honest.
A lot of young people have stopped believing they'll ever own their own home.
That's what happens when rents are high, house prices are high, and saving for a deposit feels impossible.
My Labour government is stepping in to help.
With Your First Home, first-time buyers will be able to buy a new-build home with a deposit of just 2.5%.
Because hard work and saving should count for something.
And because the dream of owning your own home shouldn't belong only to those with help from the bank of Mum and Dad. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
‘Not acting on climate change means a certain World War in the lifetime of anybody born from now on.’
Scientists explain that climate change is a far bigger threat than governments are telling you:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Malcolm Reavell
@malcolm_reavell
It’s bullshit. It’s just subsidising property markets and developers, pumping the property bubble. A real solution would be to build council houses.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
G.J.Quartermaine 🏴🇬🇧
@gjquartermaine
BANGKOK FLOODS
This is the third day of heavy rain. The buildings in tbe distance are usually clearly seen, they've been blanked out for days. All the streets around us are near waist deep in filthy water. Walking is impossible or hazardous since one cannot see potholes or kerbs; there are snakes, too!
The rain has been constant which is unusual. All the districts have been declared disaster areas in this city of over 11 million people. I imagine the floods extend to the wider Metropolitan Area and that's 25 million. No deaths reported yet, but the physical damage is enormous, and there will be massive losses for businesses and shops.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
"Power" most dangerous in the hands of most
@AndrewWeeraratn
Please watch this video, @ShangguanJiewen interviewing @ProfSteveKeen which is one of the best videos made ever, where you can learn how to end global poverty
www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0rJqz_4UDs -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John Lounsbury
@jlounsbury59
The egg not hatched—in Economics
by @ProfSteveKeen
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/egg-not-hatched-17052…
(Seventy years ago, a critical factor in economic analysis was identified. Most economists have ignored it ever since.) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dozent Tobias
@klein_activist
Keen's right about the debt blindness. I've felt it myself: try getting bank financing for a manufacturing start-up in Germany. If banks create money out of nothing, why is it so hard for the real economy to get any?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Devin Nunes' Cattle Dog 🇺🇦 🇪🇺🇺🇸🇨🇦 🇦🇺
@Kaos_Vs_Control
The Dude Abides...I support this message.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Economist @ProfSteveKeen: "If the mainstream is wrong on this point—and they are very wrong—then there’s no chance of politicians doing what is needed to overcome “The Great Malaise” (especially if the best remedy also challenges vested interests, which it surely does). So how to persuade the mainstream that, despite their Nobel Prizes, they might just be wrong?"
Archive pick: evonomics.com/economists-ignore-one-of-capitalisms-bigges… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HIN News🇬🇧🇺🇸
@HerdImmunity12
Matthew 7:15🇬🇧✝️: "Pigeon chested cowards like Jacob Rees-Mogg will never go to war themselves. They expect they can con millions of working class patriotic Brits to go over the top against the Russians. Our enemies are from within, from France and those invading the shores of these lands - not the Russians".
The Great @Godfrey_Bloom goes in on @Jacob_Rees_Mogg and his kind who will not only sit out any conflict with Russia, but will also make a tidy some via their investments within the weapons industry.
Mogg is a former Rothschild Investment manager, a family with a long history in making billions from white Christian men dying in the millions.
Yet the former Tory Minister virtue signals about being a good Catholic and quotes the bible on a regular basis.
“Watch out for false prophets. They come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ferocious wolves.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
HIN News🇬🇧🇺🇸
@HerdImmunity12
News🇬🇧🔥🇷🇺: "Over the next few years we may have to go to war, some of you may die? but this is about doing your DUTY".
Watch as @Jacob_Rees_Mogg goes into new levels of pomposity rarely seen in British politics, since Lord Kitchener pointed at British men and cried "Your country Needs You".
Mogg demands and expects that most white working class Brits go 'over the top' for a King and Government who treat them with sheer contempt.
Under JRM's best friend and fellow bumchum at Eton, Boris Johnson, the UK was intentionally flooded with around 5 million Islamist loving migrants and African former military, blighting the nation for decades to come perhaps forever.
Sir Jacob gushes over King Charles III, who is more interested in the "wisdom of Islam", than speaking out against the planned invasion of our/his Kingdom.
This former Tory MP is laying the table for the UK and Europe being involved in a full-scale war with Russia. He demands that you and your sons head over into the meat grinder to satisfy his sense of "duty".
Going into the slaughterhouse of Ukraine, where perhaps over 1 million white Christian men have died, is not the Falklands, or any form of conflict which threats British sovereignty under the Thomas Aquinas Just War Theory.
The Thomas Aquinas war in his work 'Summa Theologiae', arguing that war is not always a sin if it meets strict moral criteria.
Ukraine is a proxy war for EU expansion and theft, by an institution which has destroyed Europe via 'net-zero, mass immigration and super demonic DEI diktats.
Tell me @Jacob_Rees_Mogg, when will you and yours be popping of into the Zelensky/EU/NATO killing machine to satisfy your deities and quench your thirst for patriotic blood, by a King and government who abandoned indigenous Brits decades ago? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
You can define macro relationships with macro variables. In other words macrofoundations for macro models.
Other sciences understand emergence. Why can't mainstream economics grasp that microfoundations in macro models isn't the flex they think it is?
Anderson, 1972 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brown Sahib
@GhaiGhai19
the single largest source of income for the british east indai company was opium. and when the chinese said they dont want it anymore - they went to war. Not saying that the west was uniquely evil. just that evil in ubiquitous.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mike Nellis
@MikeNellis
CNN reports Trump is so worried about Democrats winning the election that his "outside advisors" are telling him to declare martial law.
Scary shit and we need to be ready.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Don't believe me. Try Argentinian officials. In February 2026, INDEC director Marco Lavagna resigned as a protest against Milei's pressure to publish false data. Congresswoman Julia Strada and many others accused him of delaying updates to inflation-tracking methodologies to keep figures artificially low.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
Follow @ProfSteveKeen subscribe to hia channel. There's more than enough material on how sovereign currency issuers at and how they SHOULD act.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
There is no such thing as demand-driven inflation as industrial goods are storable and easily reproducible. Demand drives investment, not prices. Prices are cost-driven. Real consumption increased at the same rate as before the pandemic. Nominal expenditure rose because of prices
Domenico Giannone
@DomenicoGiannon
Demand-driven inflation www.brookings.edu/articles/demand-driven-inflation/?b=1
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Talkwithsisib 🎬 | Love & Movies
@Talkwithsisib
Dame Edna explaining she started as a Melbourne housewife, then casually adding that Americans don’t really know Australia exists “because we don’t have any oil.”
She delivers the whole thing like she’s giving a polite geography lesson and the room just explodes. The sweetness is what makes it lethal. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Anton Korzhenkov
@AntonKorzhenkov
I only remember that George Selgin once argued with @ProfSteveKeen and did not make it pass step 2, when it came to reserves accounting. But this debate is of some importance, and I want to add my 2 cents. First and most importantly - words have some meaning. When someone says...
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The popular terminology of FRB pervides a false implication of causation. Thus its proper to start there. I will grant you and myself the higher level of knowledge on the topic, but its rather clear that knowledge does not extend to to wider non economic audience, let alone the broader audience of economic academics.
Again, if the causality is not there (we may disagree on that) then you can see my position on the objection of the term of FRB based on its current popular causation that I dispute. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
guyfelicella🇨🇦🍁
@guyfelicella
Trump and Natalie Harp in real life.
This Hour Has 22 Minutes does the best Trump impersonation on television.
This Canadian show absolutely nails it. 🇨🇦🤣This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The Bank of England was not created by Tony Blair, but it did play a game with Truss that led to her downfall.
Lesson: get an economist as a consultant as not to be fooled by other economists. #beef #lettuce
www.themintmagazine.com/was-truss-on-the-money/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
You should listen when the government wants you to stock pile food because the planet is now in uncharted territory and this could happen to any of us
Thai Enquirer
@ThaiEnquirer
Panic buying surges at Gourmet Market near MRT Lat Phrao, as communities across other severely flooded areas face the same scramble for supplies.
Vid via @CNanxeng
#thailand #bangkok #น้ำท่วม #น้ำท่วมกรุงเทพThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Harold James seems to have forgotten the last financial crisis. Let me remind him. It was caused by private debt in the real estate market. In the end, the government bailed out the banks and the banks evicted the citizens from their flats and houses when those defaulted.
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
The US is operating on the assumption that AI is the only tool available for fending off a financial crisis caused by excessive debt, even though mounting AI risks themselves contain the seeds of financial panic and disaster, notes Harold James. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/us-china-both-bettin…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Magnus Hansen
@KareMHaret
Hei Ole Asbjørn
Du må invitere Professor Steve Keen til podcasten din for snakke om de grunnleggende premissene for makroøkonomi
Han er venstrevridd, ja men det tåler vi
Men jeg lover at synet ditt på økonomi kommer til å føles som en vrengt pol-vott etterpå
@ProfSteveKeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
@ProfSteveKeen changed my LIFE wth his words for real!!!!!!!
Mych Love Prof, much love ❤️.
I beg you man follow this channel if you want to learn REAL economics. I'm broke AF, bit o even subscribed, I need to get all the nwledge I can from this Legend. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a brilliant explanation of the difference between Western and Chinese culture--with the Chinese being more practical and the Western mystical. That's the opposite of the conventional wisdom.
Tod🔻
@idertod
This goes a long way in explaining why revolution took hold in China and probably never will in europe-america.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
One Tradable Price State, Seen Through Three Markets: Assets, FX and Import Prices
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Tradables Have a Price State: Copper Turns With the Dollar
Copper prices and a three-currency measure of USD weakness repeatedly turn together -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
AI Evolution
@AiEvolutio58513
@ProfSteveKeen says if machines are doing all the work, this is how we are going to make money…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
How is the @AtlantaFed GDPNow at 5%😂
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
It took a few years to get this done, with many revised outlines and many System Dynamic model versions that drive the narrative.
Math is fun, but writing coherently with the attention span of a gerbil and the spelling skills of a 6 year old is not.
Out in October... -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MOTO中尉@🇯🇵タイ在住・時事解説系バイクYoutuber 🇹🇭
@JGSDF_YTS_X7
現在バンコク各所でこのような状態です
通常、激しい雨はあっても基本的に1時間も立てば止むのがタイの一般的な雨の降り方です
しかしすでにもう丸1日以上ずっと止むことなく降り続いてます
タイの方々からは2011年の洪水でもここまで酷くなかったという声も聞かれる状況です。
皆さんお気お付けて2 media couldn't be displayed. See them on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Market Update is Live!
MMT continues to prove its value as a framework. Rate hikes/rising yields are not going break anything other than archaic macro models that the mainstream holds near and dear.
Buckle up - the next few months are going to be fun!
appliedmmt.com/09-25-2026-market-update/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
A bridge engineer doesn't use GDP to test whether a bridge stands.
Should economists use GDP-style metrics to represent ecological reality?
Perhaps the biggest challenge facing ecological economics is measurement itself.
www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/measuring-note-167775101
#mmt #ecologicaleconomics #climatepolicy #economics -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
$1.7T of interest income and rising. No way the Fed can hike out of this. Its reflexive at this point.
In a world where profits & income drives investment and assets, each rate hike just pumps the very thing the Fed is looking at to determine if another hike is warranted. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
The neoliberal playbook rests on the core ideas taught in mainstream Econ 101 textbooks. Economist @ProfSteveKeen dismantles them.
Read more: evonomics.com/why-economists-have-to-embrace-complexity-s…
Full video below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Neoclassical and New Keynesian economists objectively have the least understanding of macroeconomics.
That's why they insist macro must be built from rigorous microfoundations.
Unfortunately, their understanding of microeconomics is even worse. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'll be launching an online policy simulator based on the model from my upcoming book, Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach to Macroeconomics.
The simulator launches October 2nd on @GDPDynamics.
The book follows October 3rd. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
THE UPSTREAM STATE OF INFLATION
Bank Balance-Sheet Deployment, Tradable Prices, and the Conditional Sufficiency of Conventional Inflation Models
drive.google.com/file/d/1c-qGqJnEt-Fs7JlV254qwPRFaKU_KnOD… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Donald Trump Portfolio Tracker
@TrumpsPortfolio
TRUMP JUST ARMED THE MILITARY AND POINTED IT AT DEMOCRATS
Not a metaphor. Not hyperbole. National Guard troops in Washington DC got a directive to start carrying loaded sidearms on the street. That happened on a Sunday. Like it was nothing
The executive order is titled about a "DC crime emergency." The actual text expands National Guard deployment powers NATIONWIDE
Read that again. Nationwide
And which cities is Trump "considering" for this armed rollout next. Not Tulsa. Not Boise. Every single city floated so far is run by Democrats
Memphis already got the treatment. Now Russ Vought is asking for over 10 billion dollars to build it into a permanent machine — more Park Police, more federalized boots on the ground, funded through fiscal 2027
That's not a crime emergency response. That's a standing occupation force built to punish blue cities and Trump gets to pick the targets himself
No debate. No vote. No city council asked. One man decides which American cities get treated like hostile territory and which ones don't
Meanwhile actual violent crime data doesn't drive a single one of these decisions. Political maps do
This is the same man who spent four years screaming about federal overreach turning federal troops into his personal enforcement squad against his own political enemies
Armed National Guard on American streets, deployed by zip code of who didn't vote for him
They are not stopping at DC
This is the blueprint and Trump just showed you exactly how it works
Share it before they figure out how to make this look normal -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen R. C. Hicks
@SRCHicks
Philosophy accessories.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sarrah Bellus
@sarrah_bellus
This is an amazing video. We should be learning from our history and each other. Worth a listen!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a brilliant explanation of the difference between Western and Chinese culture--with the Chinese being more practical and the Western mystical. That's the opposite of the conventional wisdom.
Tod🔻
@idertod
This goes a long way in explaining why revolution took hold in China and probably never will in europe-america.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Loans create deposits my man. It's not 1912, there's no convertibility which means there's nothing to crowd out from. Gov't spending crowds in via profit add and more income, not out.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
Almost every response to this was "but debt to GDP is high!". It turns out that the debt to GDP research has no reliably predictive value for developed world sovereigns. And it wasn't even the causal factor of defaults for the nations that the cited research reported.
See my newest research piece here:
ria.disciplinefunds.com/2026/09/24/is-the-bond-market-at-…
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
Lots of scary talk in bonds these days, but it's mostly recency bias. Since 1960 the 10 year yield has averaged 5.8%. We're at 5% - below average. If you'd fallen asleep 20 years ago and woke up today you'd think nothing happened in the bond market the entire time.
Ignore all the sovereign debt crisis talk. Inflation expectations are adjusting to something more historically normalized. Carry on. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝐌𝐚𝐥𝐜𝐨𝐥𝐦
@Malcolm_Pal9
You probably missed a moment when the Malaysian Prime Minister said about Israel what others are afraid to say out loud.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
„But what if the old models don’t apply to the current paradigm and the Fed is wrong?“
They never applied to any paradigm. Look at the data. Higher interest rates do not cause inflation to come down. Inflation and interest rates correlate over the decades.
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
The presumption that the Fed raising short-term rates reduces inflation is predicated on the belief that higher rates reduce demand and investment.
But what if higher rates don’t reduce demand and investment because the demand for intelligence and energy is unaffected by higher rates because winning the race for super intelligence has a near infinite ROI and the demand for compute will remain incalculable.
Why won’t higher rates at this unique moment in history therefore lead to more inflation as interest costs are embedded in everything?
And the problem is compounded as the more the Fed raises rates, the more inflation we will have and the more the Fed will need to raise rates further and so on.
But what if the old models don’t apply to the current paradigm and the Fed is wrong?
I think the Fed might have just made a mistake. Am I right or am I wrong? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
Yesterday's discussion about US debt topping $40T and debt to GDP approaching 130% brought out a lot of default fears. So I wrote a short paper on it (link below). The quick version is that 130% isn't a cliff for a country that issues its own currency, and the nuance matters for anyone consuming in USD, holding cash equivalents or govt bonds.
Start with the balance sheet. Federal debt held by the public is about $35T. US household net worth is about $196T, roughly 6x GDP and 5x the federal debt. And a big chunk of that wealth is the federal debt itself, sitting in portfolios as safe savings. Federal debt is large, but the asset side of the ledger is massively larger and is the main thing that allows such large govt debts in the first place. The uniquely wealthy and productive asset side is what makes the USA very different from almost every other country in the world.
Now the mechanics. The government funds its spending by taxing and borrowing from the wealthiest economy that ever existed. That's a massive collateral and revenue stream supporting the debt. And unlike a household or Greece, it can create the currency its debt is in. So the real risk to a bondholder isn't getting stiffed in nominal terms. It's getting paid back in dollars that buy less. Hyperbolic narratives about default gloss over the balance sheet AND the mechanics that make the USA unique.
But debt to income is high and rising, Cullen! Of course it is. That risk is real and should be measured with nuance, not panic. But the historical utility of debt to GDP ratios as a predictor of default is mixed at best and useless at worst.
History backs this up. About half of all sovereign defaults since 1970 happened with external debt below 60% of GNP. The UK hit 252% in 1946 and never defaulted on its own currency debt. And we all know the Japan story. Hyperinflations are driven by collapsing output and debts owed in foreign currencies, not by crossing a debt ratio. And the popular "51 of 52 countries defaulted above 130%" stat comes from a report that counts inflation and devaluation as "default." Its own examples list wars, revolutions, droughts and export collapses as the causes, and the actual missed payments were on foreign currency, gold standard or euro debt. Debt to GDP wasn't even the causal factor! And those causal factors aren't what the USA faces today. It doesn't borrow in a foreign currency and it isn't losing a world war.
The bigger risk isn't default or hyperinflation. It's that aging, inequality and technology keep dragging on growth and prices, pushing debt higher as the govt fills an inequality gap the private sector won't. That leaves a fragile economy with sticky inflation that's exposed to disinflationary shocks.
The distinction is important, and hyperbole doesn't help anyone untangle the risks. For portfolios, default hits all bonds, but persistent above-target inflation hits long bonds the most. So the question isn't whether to own USD or Treasuries. It's how much duration you own, matched to real liabilities, and how to diversify around that for the inflation protection long-term T-bonds can't provide.
Full paper:
ria.disciplinefunds.com/2026/09/24/is-the-bond-market-at-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Robert McDonald (it, it)
@macdonaro
The egg not hatched—in Economics, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/the-egg-not-hatchedin-econom…
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
'They’ve Lost Control!' Why AI bosses are begging for regulation | Andre... youtu.be/5xkiVlT-7Ac via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jim Stewartson, Decelerationist 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇺🇸
@jimstewartson
I am now full doomer—not because chatbots are going to become “superintelligent,” but because we bet the entire economy on the absurd science fiction story that they will.
We are a deeply stupid species.
What do you notice about the other industries?
PHYSICAL INFRASTRUCTURE. All of those “bubbles” left infrastructure that added to GDP over many decades.
Before you say “data centers,” the vast majority of the cost is in GPUs—which begin depreciating rapidly after 2-3 years. Data centers aren’t railroad tracks; they are temporary money furnaces.
I don’t know how we get out of this without a great depression. It’s the most absurd mass psychosis in human history. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marius Kjærstad (marius.eth) 🐬🦇🔊
@MKjrstad
Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen) explains why we will see a 10% hit to global GDP if the Strait of Hormuz stays closed.
U.S. GDP printed -8.9% in 1930 due to the Great Depression, but rest of the world was less hit.
A 10% hit to global GDP would be unprecedented in human history⚠️ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"you need debt crises to impose fiscal discipline"
Let me translate that into proper English: The rich need debt crises that create poverty, unemployment, pressure to lower wages and financially stressed households selling their assets cheap to enrich the rentier class.
Robin Brooks
@robin_j_brooks
In 2012, Draghi linked the survival of the Euro to the suppression of sovereign debt crises. It's the other way around. In a currency union without a fiscal union, you need debt crises to impose fiscal discipline. Nothing else works as the Euro zone shows.
robinjbrooks.substack.com/p/trouble-for-high-debt-euro-zo… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Because I like the graphic. And I want all wars to end. And I know @georgegalloway, like him, and see him as a man of integrity.
However, I think he's making a mistake by setting up a left-wing circular firing squad in the by-election against @ZackPolanski. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
This has been the MMT case for years. The rest of the macro world is finally figuring it out.
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
The presumption that the Fed raising short-term rates reduces inflation is predicated on the belief that higher rates reduce demand and investment.
But what if higher rates don’t reduce demand and investment because the demand for intelligence and energy is unaffected by higher rates because winning the race for super intelligence has a near infinite ROI and the demand for compute will remain incalculable.
Why won’t higher rates at this unique moment in history therefore lead to more inflation as interest costs are embedded in everything?
And the problem is compounded as the more the Fed raises rates, the more inflation we will have and the more the Fed will need to raise rates further and so on.
But what if the old models don’t apply to the current paradigm and the Fed is wrong?
I think the Fed might have just made a mistake. Am I right or am I wrong? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
The business cycle is the fiscal/credit cycle. MMT/PK best describe each aspect of it.
We've built a macro portfolio strategy on top of our models that identifies which assets win and lose under all macro dynamics. The strategy sidesteps every major drawdown from 1980s to today. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Definitely! How on Earth do people think that the world in which they can have these thoughts was constructed?! By Divine Providence? It was by engineers.
Rory Sutherland
@rorysutherland
Actually, engineers at their best are startlingly imaginative.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Because I like the graphic. And I want all wars to end. And I know @georgegalloway, like him, and see him as a man of integrity.
However, I think he's making a mistake by setting up a left-wing circular firing squad in the by-election against @ZackPolanski. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
Sick psychopathic fascist scum
HatsOff
@HatsOffff
Netanyahu: You remember the beepers? Hezbollah certainly remembers them
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The View From Mars (unplugged)
@pablomelito1
Olivier Blanchard is not someone to be taken seriously. He's both wrong about the mechanics of finance and intellectually dishonest to boot…
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
IMF'nin eski Baş Ekonomisti Olivier Blanchard, Dirk Ehnst'i bu twitinden ötürü bloklamış.
Hiçbir sert, kaba ifade yok Dirk'in yazdıklarında.
Hani Türk anaakım iktisatçılar beni üslup yüzünden blokluyorlar diyordunuz ya..
Buyrun.. Cevapsız kalınca yaptıkları bloklamak.. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
Russia is a white European Christian capitalist country. They were our allies in WW1 and WW2. Yet we are determined to go to war with them. Why?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Occupy Democrats
@OccupyDemocrats
BREAKING: Tucker Carlson reveals a jaw-dropping private conversation he had with Trump in which he warned him that the Iran War would destroy America and Trump said: "We all die anyway, so it doesn't matter."
This maniac has the nuclear codes...
"I'm in an unusual position because I talked to Trump," Carlson told Steve Inskeep of the NPR Newsmakers podcast.
The former Fox News host has become one of the President's fiercest critics over the past year, with his most vociferous attacks aimed at the disastrous, pointless war with Iran.
"But you've quoted him as waving off the risk by saying it'll all be fine which could almost—" said Inskeep of Trump's posture towards the conflict.
"You want to know what he said?" replied Carlson. "I'll tell you exactly what he said and I haven't said this but I'm just gonna tell you. And this is a fact. And I could look at my calendar but I had flown back from Tel Aviv from Ben Gurion Airport after seeing the ambassador and two days later I was in the Oval with Trump alone."
"And he was annoyed that I had given Huckabee a hard time in this whole conversation about Huckabee and I said your U.S. ambassador — and as the son of an ambassador — I know what the job entails," recounted Carlson. "And your ambassador, your representative to this nation just called for rearranging the Middle East and allowing Israel to take parts of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, and Syria. Like this is a diplomatic incident and so we had this whole conversation about this."
"But then I said this war is not about Iran's nuclear program, which you told me and the world that you eliminated back in last summer, in June," Carlson continued. "This war is being pushed by Israel with three aims..."
"One, its own regional hegemony. Take Iran off the map. They don't have freedom of movement as long as Iran is a regional power.
"Two, diminishing the power of the GCC, the six Gulf states which are a rival to Israel and are becoming this kind of Switzerland of the Middle East and that's bad for Israeli interests."
"And three, getting the U.S. out of the Middle East because we constrain their ambitions, getting our bases out, destroying our bases. Israel wants our bases out of the Middle East. I said this to Trump to his face in the Oval Office days before the war began," said Carlson.
"And he looked at me and said 'Yes, you're right. But in the end we all die anyway, so it doesn't matter.' That's exactly what he said 'In the end, we all die anyway,' and I said to him, shocked, 'But what about our kids and our grandkids and like our country and he goes 'Uggggh.'"
"What does that mean?" a perplexed Inskeep asked of the bizarre, dismissive noise.
"I don't know! That's a verbatim exchange," said Carlson. "And you know as God watches I said that. I thought it was true then and I think it's been proven true now."
"The goal was to get the U.S. out, to diminish the GCC, and obviously to take Iran off the map and sink it into permanent internal strife into civil war, sectarian strife," said Carlson. "And he said it doesn't matter because in the end we're all dead anyway. And I was shocked by that because it's nihilism and that's the last thing any leader should display or any person should display. It does matter. Who lives or dies does matter. The future does matter."
As horrifying as Trump's anti-human remarks are, they are perfectly in keeping with his personality. This man is an egomaniacal sociopath. He doesn't believe in God, doesn't believe in the rule of law or right and wrong. As far as he's concerned, the world ends when he dies. He couldn't care less what happens to the rest of us.
It's also not the first time that Trump has given the world such an unvarnished look into his nihilistic worldview. In a 2004 interview with Larry King, he shared similar sentiments—
"I try and tell myself it doesn't matter. Nothing matters. If you tell yourself it doesn't matter, like you do shows, you do this, you do that and then you have earthquakes in India where 400,000 people get killed," said Trump. "Honestly, it doesn't matter. That's how I handle stress."
Within this kind of moral framework (or lack thereof) Trump's entire life makes sense. Since he believes in nothing, he has chosen to indulge in every cruelty and evil imaginable. He spent his time on this Earth ripping people off, sexually abusing and raping women, allegedly including children, and then used the powers of the White House to slaughter countless people overseas.
If the Devil exists, this is what he looks like.
Please ❤️ and share to demand that the 25th Amendment be invoked! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Tennessee Holler
@TheTNHoller
Tucker says he warned Trump about Israel taking us to war…
TUCKER: "Trump said, ‘In the end, we're all dead anyway’ 😳— I said to him, shocked, ‘But what about our kids, our grandkids, our country?'… he goes (dismissively) *AGHH*.”
INSKEEP: *laughs* 🤔This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 2026 Nowcast edged up to 2.66% SAAR, from 2.65% yesterday.
Net exports provided the small boost, while the broader growth outlook remained largely unchanged.
Another remarkably stable update.
Article below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Buddy Wells
@BuddyWells1
The Swedish recession in the early 1990s was caused by successive govt surpluses (private sector deficits) in the 1980s. Private sector deficits are unsustainable because the private sector are currency users.
Social Democrats (SAP) ran Sweden for most of the 1980s and 1990s, except for a centre-right coalition from October 1991 to October 1994.
Prime ministers and governments:
• 1986–October 1991: Social Democrats under Ingvar Carlsson (after Olof Palme’s assassination). Minority governments (Carlsson I and II).
• October 1991–October 1994: Centre-right coalition under Carl Bildt (Moderate Party) with the Liberal Party, Centre Party, and Christian Democrats. Minority government.
• October 1994–March 1996: Social Democrats under Ingvar Carlsson again (Carlsson III). Minority government.
• March 1996 onward: Social Democrats under Göran Persson. Minority government (later with external support from the Left Party and Greens after 1998).
Elections were in 1991 (non-socialists took office amid recession) and 1994 (Social Democrats returned).
The 1990s also saw Sweden’s early-1990s banking and currency crisis, caused by govt surpluses in 1980s.
The center right govt of early 90s responded with large deficits to stimulate the economy.
Government budget balance (% of GDP), 1980–1999
1980s
• 1980: −5.35%
• 1981: −4.32%
• 1982: −6.19%
• 1983: −4.75%
• 1984: −2.67%
• 1985: −3.29%
• 1986: +0.01%
• 1987: +3.64%
• 1988: +3.63%
• 1989: +3.57%
1990s
• 1990: +3.70%
• 1991: +0.28%
• 1992: −8.51%
• 1993: −10.88% (peak crisis year; some sources cite ~11–13%)
• 1994: −8.78%
• 1995: −7.00%
• 1996: −3.10%
• 1997: −1.60%
• 1998: +0.80%
• 1999: +0.60%
Economic growth kicked in due to the large govt deficits (private sector surpluses) from 1992 to 1997.
Govt deficit is sustainable if govt issues the currency it owes in. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brett Scott
@Suitpossum
For centuries now, economists have falsely claimed that barter led to the origin of money. In this video, I explain why this is a myth, and why this myth has far-reaching consequences for our lives youtu.be/SYQtB8qaQxg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 nowcast edged up to 2.67% today, from 2.66%.
The small revision came from residential investment, while the rest of the model was essentially unchanged.
Housing data remain mixed, with stronger single-family starts but softer permits.
Article below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
👀 This chart, from the tail end of my explainer here 👇 might be about to become one of the most important issues in UK politics.
How and why did the government allow its emergency stockpiles of diesel to drop to one of the lowest levels in the developed world...? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
This chart is even more insane. This shows total gross private sector assets.
$489 TRILLION.
Say that out loud. Four hundred and eighty nine TRILLION. That's almost half a QUADRILLION.
If you're gonna talk about the debts then you also need to talk about the assets and the assets that fund the public debt are 10X bigger. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Frances 'Cassandra' Coppola
@Frances_Coppola
Israel repeatedly bombed the vaccine distribution centres.
Mairav Zonszein מרב זונשיין
@MairavZ
“What genocidal regime enables polio vaccines to the enemy population?” This is Netanyahu’s counter to accusation that Israel committed genocide in Gaza
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
Desarrollo todo esto en vídeo aquí: youtu.be/1UP6ZaFenBg
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
Conclusión: el coste de la deuda pública no lo deciden "los mercados" por miedo al volumen de deuda; lo decide el banco central correspondiente. Es una decisión política. Toca combatir el terraplanismo económico con evidencia, no con dogmas.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
En cambio, si pones en un eje el tipo de interés oficial del banco central y en el otro el precio de la deuda pública, la correlación es casi perfecta en todos los países analizados. Cualquier analista riguroso debería darse cuenta, pero los economistas están cegados por la inútil teoría dominante.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
Si metes en un mismo gráfico los niveles de deuda pública de todos estos países frente a su coste, no hay relación clara. De hecho, si haces la correlación, sale negativa: a más deuda, menor coste en muchos casos. Justo lo contrario de lo que dice el mito. Pero la gente sigue repitiéndolo, contra toda evidencia
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
Y ahora China, el caso que más incomoda: su deuda pública crece más rápido que nunca en la historia... y su coste se sigue abaratando. Justo lo contrario de lo que predice la teoría dominante. Coincide, eso sí, con la bajada sostenida del tipo de interés de su banco central.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
¿Queréis ver un caso flagrante en el que casi todos los economistas repiten una falsedad fácilmente desmontable con datos pero que van a seguir repitiendo simplemente por fanatismo? Me refiero al encarecimiento de la deuda pública. Todos los datos tumban la teoría dominante, pero les da igual...🧵
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
Genocider.
Clash Report
@clashreport
Netanyahu:
Before I begin, just a quick announcement: if there are any other moral cowards who haven't yet left this hall, please do so now! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
There's no crisis. The 10 year yield isn't even above its historical average. It's back to where it was 3 years ago when there also wasn't a crisis then.
It's all silly talk that confuses an inflation expectation adjustment for some sort of collapse.
x.com/cullenroche/status/2103155242682716518/history -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
Let's put this in balance sheet terms because a lot of this talk is just a fallacy of composition in which the sovereign debt crisis crowd only looks at the debt side of things and ignores the fact that the asset side has also boomed.
There is no balance sheet in the world that is healthier than the aggregate US economy's. It's not even close. Here's a chart of household and non-profit net worth relative to public debt. The reason the public debt isn't a worry is because the total assets of the private sector are gigantic and growing fast. The reason rates haven't changed much in the last 20 years is because the balance sheet the US government taxes has remained incredibly strong.
Cullen Roche
@cullenroche
Lots of scary talk in bonds these days, but it's mostly recency bias. Since 1960 the 10 year yield has averaged 5.8%. We're at 5% - below average. If you'd fallen asleep 20 years ago and woke up today you'd think nothing happened in the bond market the entire time.
Ignore all the sovereign debt crisis talk. Inflation expectations are adjusting to something more historically normalized. Carry on. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
When a Keynesian finally has enough of the humans act with purpose stuff and incoherent economic axioms.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matías Vernengo
@NakedKeynes
Proof that his understanding of the history of ideas was very limited. The basis for the conventional story about the labor market is the marginalist revolution which was a bit more than a 100 years old by that point. The wage fund story precedes it by a few extra decades
Insane Economist Quotes
@Insane_Econ
On David Card and Alan Krueger's minimum wage paper:
"Fortunately, only a handful of economists are willing to throw over the teaching of two centuries; we have not yet become a bevy of camp-following whores."
-James Buchanan, in the Wall Street Journal (25 Apr. 1996) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill Madden
@maddenifico
MAGA in a nutshell.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Red_Brin
@Red_Brin_47
Great show, with two ‘heavyweight’ economists.
Can we have @profwolff and @ProfSteveKeen next, please? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
I conclude that MMT needs to stop using the LENS metaphor it if wants to enter the circles of economic science. And that is should address full on the fact that budgets kill people and planet. stephenhinton584706.substack.com/p/mmt-needs-to-move-beyo…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
It’s a war. Soldiers die. Iran has a right to buy anywhere in the world to defend itself from the war US-Israel brought to its interior.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
Crazy footage out of Mexico.
It’s simple physics: a warming planet means a warmer atmosphere, and warm air holds way more moisture (about 7% more per 1°C).
When it rains now, it absolutely pours because the sky is holding so much extra water. This is what climate change looks like. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I never thought of that analogy, but it’s so apt.
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Full-blown fiscal crisis? I don't think so.
link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-53537-6 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Trump's $5,000 Bribe Plan
Is a $5,000 dividend for every US citizen financially feasible?
@ProfSteveKeen uses his RAVEL economic modeling software to test the reality of this proposal.
youtu.be/z5pRKv-se9Y via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The problem is that most non-MMTers - you included - say that deficits and debt or not so bad, because historically the public debt to GDP ratio is not so high, or not so high as in country X. They never say that a currency-issuing government cannot run out of its currency, so that austerity is always, always a bad idea. Those who are on the side of Thatcher's taxpayer money will have to accept austerity policies at least sometimes, when deficits and debts are high, because their own theory says it's a problem. #mmt says the fiscal deficit and the public debt are not a problem (without debt in foreign currency or a fixed exchange rate). Macroeoconomic problems are a lack of full employment and a lack of price stability. Therefore, you should get rid/change your fiscal framework, debt break, etc and stop misusing the interest rate to "fight inflation" when it doesn't work. Then, there are problems with climate change and sustainability as well as with (p)re-distribution.
James Meadway
@meadwaj
That's simply untrue: anyone with a basic, mainstream understanding of economics can explain why a deficit isn't necessarily a bad thing. Econ 101. (MMTers are frequently very bad at explaining this because they tie themselves up in knots of their own making around govt funding.)
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brown Eyed Susan
@smc429
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Australia pimped out all its resources to offshore corporations, so no matter how much is produced, except for jobs, Australians see no profits.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
nordacious
@nordacious
"Always good to catch up with @POTUS" 📸
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alex Joiner 🇦🇺
@IFM_Economist
Australia is uniquely exposed to this diesel price shock given our reliance on imported product which is by far the highest in the world, not as a % of GDP or per capita but outright. This comes as other countries have scaled back imports and Australia's have accelerated due in part to refinery closures.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
5Pillars
@5Pillarsuk
“They call us terrorists? Look at these children. They bombed them and killed them. They had committed no crime. They were innocent.”
Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian condemned the United States and Israel at the UN General Assembly today, accusing them of killing innocent Iranian children and being the real terrorists.
Holding up images of children who had been killed in US-Israeli attacks, Pezeshkian condemned the bombing of schools, sports facilities, hospitals and civilian infrastructure.
“Those who are terrorists and train terrorists tell us that we are terrorists. We are only defending ourselves. We are not terrorists.”
Pezeshkian insisted that Iran would not bow to foreign aggression, declaring that a nation unable to defend itself would be crushed.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Workers really are getting less of the economy youtu.be/gJ8z1o6FBbs If you want to understand why people are so angry with an economy that has left them behind, just look at the data.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X
@Xking332
Global famine is now inevitable.
America has almost finalized their plans to impose a total 90 day ban on diesel exports.
This is going to cripple multiple countries.
1.5 million barrels a day will be completely removed in the coming weeks.
There is no spare supply sitting in tanks.
Brazil is the world's largest soybean exporter.
More than half of that crop moves to ports by diesel powered trucks.
This diesel ban is going to be a massive problem for them.
Mexico also relies heavily on diesel for their agricultural operations.
Their inventories are already running low.
This diesel ban will devastate them.
Chile's copper mines could also be forced to shut down.
EVs. Grids. Electronics.
Everything will be affected.
Peru and Ecuador will be severely affected too.
France's situation is going to get a lot worse. Riots could get violent.
Asia and Africa will most likely end up competing for the remaining Middle Eastern and Korean cargoes.
Grain, soy and fruit will stop moving to ports in many countries.
Urea, sulfur and phosphates have already stopped moving because of the Strait of Hormuz.
Natural gas shortages have already started destroying India, Pakistan and parts of Europe.
Moving fertilizer from plants to farms is going to become almost impossible with a new diesel ban.
The biggest nightmare will be if America extends the ban beyond 90 days.
That is when the real catastrophe could begin.
And millions of people could eventually be pushed into severe starvation. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
Money can be owned. Assets can be owned. Accounts can be owned.
But who owns the atmosphere, biodiversity, or the Earth's atoms?
A reflection on ownership, stewardship, and common assets.
www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/measuring-note-167775101
#commons #mmt #ecology -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Eliot Jacobson
@EliotJacobson
Your 'doom quote' for today:
“I think we have a very brief window of opportunity to deal with climate change ... no longer than a decade, at the most"
www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna14834318 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Q Minister
@minister_q70250
🚨 BREAKING:🚨
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni: “I am a woman and also a mother. I cannot stand with someone who kills innocent children.”
The brave woman continued to walk around wearing a Palestinian flag around her neck in front of Netanyahu. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Common Sense 🇺🇸💙
@commons96055467
Trump will declare Martial Law just before the election. This article should scare the shit out of us. Let’s prepare for this scenario. l.smartnews.com/p-8ydt7LUc/wbEuO3
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
BladeoftheSun
@BladeoftheS
30 years ago Spitting Image dared to broadcast the truth about Israel.
Now no one dares. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
‘We are going to lose everything. We’ve been trying to warn you guys for so many decades. We’re not lying. We’re not exaggerating’’
When NASA scientist @ClimateHuman risked his liberty to try and wake people up to the threat of climate change -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
That's a myth, Aaron which has been debunked by esteemed economists like @StephanieKelton. She's explained how the economies of nations like the UK, with their own sovereign currency, do not operate like a household budget.
As for François Mitterrand, he capitulated to the spivs and speculators instead of taking them on. Had he done so, he could have crushed them. There were voices in his cabinet who wanted to confront the spivs and speculators, but Mitterrand overruled them.
That's why we need politicians with a political backbone who will actually serve the national interest rather than the corporatocracy. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nate Hagens
@NJHagens
The United States, a global superpower for the last several decades, is now locked into a battle for control over the region with the bulk of the world’s remaining fossil fuel reserves.
Despite U.S. military strength, Iran is not backing down, equipped with a new era of military technology.
What happens if the U.S. strategy backfires against its leadership’s intention, and what are the larger implications for the balance of geopolitical power?
In this episode, I welcome military historian and political scientist @ProfessorPape for an in-the-moment breakdown of the Iran war’s trajectory.
Watch:
youtu.be/EEz8xyC7sas -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Fiscal waterboarding has never worked in the Eurozone. It is the cause of the ongoing stagnation, it caused the turn to austerity. As far as economic governance goes, it is simplistic and undercomplex and one if the main reasons while Europe is weak economically.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cherie
@Cherie1975Rules
At this point I am convinced that Labor’s entire media team, social & otherwise, are trying to destroy the party from within. In no universe could anyone with any awareness of the mood of the electorate think selfies with the world most famous pedophile &war criminal is positive
Anthony Albanese
@AlboMP
Always good to catch up with @POTUS. We spoke tonight on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Patricia
@PatriciaNPino
The Greens propose to drop interest rates as the main inflation tool.
So it's a good moment to ask why we discarded the world Kalecki knew (full employment), for monetary policy primacy, independent central banks & a buffer stock of unemployed labour.
open.substack.com/pub/patriciapino/p/the-political-aspect… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Charlie Gardner (also on the blue place)
@CharlieJGardner
5 years ago I wrote a long Twitter thread on what people could usefully do about the breakdown of climate and nature
Lots of people really liked it and said they found it helpful
So I turned it into a book, and it's going to be published in January - thank you Twitter!
🧵1/
Dr Charlie Gardner (also on the blue place)
@CharlieJGardner
1/ You’ve seen the fires
You seen the floods
You’ve read the news reports
You’re scared
And now you want to do something about it
But what? And how?
A (longish) thread -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Charlie Gardner (also on the blue place)
@CharlieJGardner
I'd be so grateful if you'd consider pre-ordering it, as that'll make a big difference to how many hands it ends up reaching
Thanks in advance, happy reading, and more power to you
geni.us/whatonepersoncando
11/11 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The fed definitely does not use the System Dynamic model method formally.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
J.L. Henshaw
@JLydiaHenshaw
@WNYC - I keep hearing glaringly false story about the need to put guardrails on AI.
I'm a natural systems scientist who found the problem ages ago. As we all know, if we just pause for the moment, the whole economy is a manage "HI" (human intelligence) system for endless doubling of our power over nature. synapse9.com/signals -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
What happens when the ideas of Donella Meadows, Kate Raworth, and Stephanie Kelton are combined into a single democratic provisioning framework?
And what happens when that framework meets physical reality?
www.patreon.com/StephenHinton/posts/measuring-note-167775101
#mmt #systemsthinking #ecologicaleconomics -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Deficit spending has saved us from a global crisis.
link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-53537-6 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The US government creates the $ via its central bank. Comparing a person's finances with that of the government is misguided. It is like saying that the cinema will run out of tickets to sell.
link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-031-53537-6 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The goals of subsystems (or agents) can be individually rational while producing behavior that works against the goals of the whole system.
This is bounded rationality from a Systems Thinking perspective.
From the top down, the agents behavior can look completely irrational. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
China is Getting Rich by Investing in Its People
Joining us is @ProfSteveKeen, Honorary Professor at University College London, who famously predicted the 2008 financial crisis years in advance.
Link to the full interview in the comments.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I’ll give $1,000 USD to any Neoclassical academic who publishes a paper using a Leontief production function instead of Cobb-Douglas.
You have 12 months.
Consider it a research grant for discovering that capital and labor aren't infinitely substitutable. 😂
José Azar
@joseazar
Thanks for pointing this out! We'll have to take it into account if we want to interpret the alpha strictly as the automation frontier in a task framework, and not just as a "reduced-form" coefficient in the Cobb-Douglas!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
The marginal productivity theory of income distribution was born a little over a century ago. Its principle creator, John Bates Clark, was explicit that his theory was about ideology and not science. Clark wanted show that in capitalist societies, everyone got what they produced, and hence all was fair:
"It is the purpose of this work to show that the distribution of the income of society is controlled by a natural law, and that this law, if it worked without friction, would give to every agent of production the amount of wealth which that agent creates. (John Bates Clark in The Distribution of Wealth)"
Clark was also explicit about why his theory was needed. The stability of the capitalist order was at stake! Here’s Clark again:
"The welfare of the laboring classes depends on whether they get much or little; but their attitude toward other classes—and, therefore, the stability of the social state—depends chiefly on the question, whether the amount that they get, be it large or small, is what they produce. If they create a small amount of wealth and get the whole of it, they may not seek to revolutionize society; but if it were to appear that they produce an ample amount and get only a part of it, many of them would become revolutionists, and all would have the right to do so."
Read more by @blair_fix: evonomics.com/no-productivity-does-not-explain.../ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
And so it begins.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
After a lot of work, I can finally hold a proof copy of Beyond Equilibrium in my hands.
The book launches October 3rd, along with the online policy simulator it was built around, currently being beta tested by GDP Dynamics members. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof Jem Bendell 🌍☸️
@jembendell
We drafted the "Scholars' Warning on Societal Disruption and Collapse" nearly 6 years ago to bring civil society into a discussion of emergency cuts, drawdown, and transformative and deep adaptation. Still needed.
Ben See
@ClimateBen
2026/27
• global warming: 1.44-1.85°C
• emissions: record levels due to economic growth/the race for profit
• theoretical minimum future warming: 0.5-0.6°C (1-4°C likely)
• dire 1.94-2.45°C in years/decades
This is now the best-case capitalism/economic growth scenario.🧵 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ole Peters
@ole_b_peters
Expected utility theory (EUT) is commonly interpreted as people optimizing the expected value of their utility. Utility, in this setting is subjective.
Ergodicity economics (EE) argues that people have little reason to do so because what happens to their utility in expectation is not generally what happens to their utility as time passes.
EE interprets EUT as people optimizing wealth in the long run. That constrains `utility functions' to be identical to ergodicity transformations. No longer subjective but given by circumstances or context, namely by the dynamics.
An entirely different model of human rationality and therefore human behavior emerges.
You can read about it in Chapter 6 of our textbook. Or, as of this morning, you can download a self-contained article, to be publish in November in the Philosophical Transactions.
Here it is:
arxiv.org/pdf/1801.03680 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You’re right. Energy is by far the most important determinant of economic performance. @RayDalio is correct to highlight credit as the driver of money, but he’s still thinking in Fractional Reserve Banking/Loanable Funds terms, and they’re both fallacies.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
🤔🤣
how good is “Austrian” economics?
😳😵💫
Shahin Ashkiani
@shaahin_a
Austrian sham-economists believe "taxation is theft" while they celebrate "fiscal budget surplus"
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Robert Pearson
@robert19pearson
calling the banking system a FRB system, because the quantity of reserves can be expressed as a fraction of deposits, is like calling our road system a fractional police car system, because the number of police cars on the road can be expressed as a fraction of total vehicles
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
how good is mainstream economic analysis?
their disciples critique a monetary system that doesn’t exist.
ffs, what hope have we?
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The monetary system we have is not a fractional reserve system. Hence, the analysis does not apply to the world we live in.
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-dangers-of-fractional-reserve-ban… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
⚖️🪴🇺🇦🌈
@rogertansey
I love Trump’s press ban.
I’ve neither seen nor heard him today.
Let’s make it permanent! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Philip Pilkington
@philippilk
The best explanation I’ve seen for what’s happening in Riyadh: MBS’ Saudi Arabia was built on the basis of alienating a lot of people internally. It only held together with overt US support and a constant flow of money where everyone could dip their beak. Now it’s imploding. 🇸🇦
🅰pocalypsis 🅰pocalypseos 🇷🇺 🇨🇳 🅉
@apocalypseos
Alastair Crooke (@AWCrooke): Saudi Arabia is a pillar for one family. If it is no longer oil wealth for Wall Street and the petrodollar, there is nothing there. MBS had Trump as his security. That is gone. The reserves went into NEOM. He cannot deal with Ansar Allah because Washington runs the state.
“Saudi is a pillar that rests on one person, one family—one family that gerrymandered the succession so that they can become king. Don’t forget Salman changed the succession. It’s supposed to go from brother to brother to brother, and he changed all of that. He has alienated most of the family. It rests on a very fragile pillar. Unless they are seen as the source of oil wealth for Wall Street, for the petrodollar, for Washington—if that cannot be sustained—then what is there to Saudi Arabia? Nothing. There’s nothing there beyond that.
This is a huge humiliation in terms of Saudi culture. MBS had Trump on his side. This was his security. This was his basis for going ahead. And suddenly it’s clear to all the rivals, all those people in his own family. You recall the Ritz-Carlton episode, where he literally imprisoned them in a hotel and hung them upside down until all the money came out of their pockets. They were just literally humiliated. Some of them have disappeared. Some of them have been humiliated. And there are the tribes that have been largely dispossessed of their income. So what’s going to happen?
Well, there’s no money. The reserves that were built up. No one’s getting paid at the moment. Contracts, building sites—nothing is being paid. There is no money to pay anything. There’s no money to buy people out. There was a big reserve built up of cash, but most of that has gone on these big projects like the NEOM hotel and these other projects, and there’s none of that left.
So bin Salman is on his own there, with everyone looking and wondering. This is the end of a colonial structure. The colonial structure is collapsing in the Gulf, and the Saudis are the lynchpin of that. Why doesn’t he just do a deal with the Yemenis? The answer is he’s just too embedded in the United States structures. He can’t do it. He’s always been wholly embedded with US presidents, with the US military structures, down to the last element. They run the state for him, and he just cannot do it. He cannot make a deal with the Houthis.
The consequences are huge. Saudi Arabia is not selling oil. It doesn’t have money. It’s not allowed to sell its treasuries. It’s been trying to sell shares, but even its allies in the Gulf don’t want to buy them except at a huge discount, because they’re not sure that Saudi will be there as we know it tomorrow or the next day, or next month. There’s a great reluctance, even from Gulf allies, to come and help him out.
We’re seeing a huge shift. All of these post-colonial states are hanging by a thread, because Saudi Arabia and its connections with Israel—and its use by Israel as an Israeli platform over many, many years—have been the pivot for the whole Gulf region. Everyone is watching that.
At the same time, Iran is mobilizing a million people into these self-sacrifice battalions of a thousand people each. A million! This isn’t to defend against some expeditionary force from the United States coming and landing on the other side of the Hormuz. I don’t think that’s even possible. I don’t think it’s likely to happen. I don’t think they can go; where would they launch from? How would they arrive? What would be the transport? Who would supply them? How would they fight? What would be the purpose of it? I think in Washington and the Pentagon, everyone came to the conclusion to pursue this, to go on with war against the Houthis, who have effectively won against Saudi Arabia. It seems pointless and would end badly, end much worse, because it might widen and become a much wider regional war involving Iraq. If I were Bahrain or Kuwait seeing the Iranians mobilizing a million men, I would be very frightened indeed. I’m sure they are.
This was the bedrock of Israeli policy, the big gamble: to isolate, defame and undermine Iran and to base everything on the Gulf states and Saudi Arabia as the means to assimilate itself into the Middle East—into the region. Now that is visibly shaking before their eyes.
Inflation is everywhere. It has gone global. The crisis that was coming has come. It’s arrived. Inflation everywhere is going up because everything moves by diesel in Europe and in America. That’s the delivery system. The trains, often the boats, survive on diesel. So everything is going up. Prices are going up everywhere. Airfares are going up.”
The City built the Gulf on oil, garrisons, and a dollar ledger. The physical economy is sending the bill.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Ullrich
@DavidUllrich202
The collapse of the AMOC would be catastrophic. How will we know when it’s coming?
Europe faces incredibly harsh winters and unrelenting droughts if the vital AMOC ocean current fails ― but when disaster will strike and how bad it will be remains uncertain. Now there is an ambitious plan to give us a warning
www.newscientist.com/article/2588588-the-collapse-of-the-…
docs.google.com/document/d/1tEik1t9ajCB24FK0w-rPMWpFAp4WA… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
Of all the blueprints I have read on how to redress the long-term damage austerity and financialisation have inflicted upon Britain's society, this one is the most impressive - and hope inspiring. A must read. hostagenation.com
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A strong dollar looks like a crown. But it can become a noose.
America didn’t become powerful because the dollar was the world’s currency.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It became powerful because its factories could produce weapons, ships, and machinery better than its rivals.
After Bretton Woods, the dollar gained an extra demand: every country needed it to trade with every other country.
That pushed its value above what American goods alone justified.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Instead, America chose the short-term advantage. Now the long-term bill is arriving.
If dollar dominance ends, imported inflation will rise because Americans rely heavily on foreign goods. Higher interest rates cannot solve inflation caused by a falling currency.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
𝑇ℎ𝑒 𝑙𝑒𝑠𝑠𝑜𝑛 𝑖𝑠 𝑠𝑖𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒: 𝑑𝑜𝑛’𝑡 𝑟𝑒𝑝𝑙𝑎𝑐𝑒 𝑜𝑛𝑒 𝑛𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛𝑎𝑙 𝑖𝑚𝑝𝑒𝑟𝑖𝑎𝑙 𝑐𝑢𝑟𝑟𝑒𝑛𝑐𝑦 𝑤𝑖𝑡ℎ 𝑎𝑛𝑜𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑟.
Use a neutral international unit, make trade balances sum to zero, and limit excessive surpluses and deficits.
That could reduce global instability. But ego and testosterone may get in the way.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You’re right. Energy is by far the most important determinant of economic performance. @RayDalio is correct to highlight credit as the driver of money, but he’s still thinking in Fractional Reserve Banking/Loanable Funds terms, and they’re both fallacies.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Thermodynamically, AI converts energy in ways steam never could. Whether today's often-trivial uses deliver material benefits comparable to steam remains to be seen.
Luckily, George has already settled the question without the burden of waiting for evidence.
Thank the Lord...
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
I don’t doubt that AI will eventually prove as revolutionary as steam technology turned out to be. The difference is that there were only so many stupid things you could do with a steam engine. @tylercowen @BrianCAlbrecht
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The monetary system we have is not a fractional reserve system. Hence, the analysis does not apply to the world we live in.
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-dangers-of-fractional-reserve-ban… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
And regarding the effects on sea level.
Well, my opinion: An extra few millimeters per month. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
For those not yet convinced of the seriousness of the calving events, and at the request of a friend, I want to clearly demonstrate that the Thwaites Glacier is making a dangerous move.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What critics get wrong about MMT - or modern monetary theory youtu.be/mKWfEQlcDoU Hating MMT seems to be the one thing that unites neoliberals and some Marxists. But all of them argue with a version of their own creation, not the real thing. Here, I tackle the real issues.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
On top of my talk on Friday on whether Keynes was a socialist, I am giving a series of two talks tomorrow and Wednesday to graduate students on heterodox consensus.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Let the conference begin!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jeff Berardelli
@WeatherProf
It’s official, the 2026 El Niño has broken a record for the highest ocean anomaly in 170+ years… Incredibly reaching that threshold a full 2 months ahead of 2015’s record of +3.02C set on Nov 18th.
See that red line? That’s 2026.
Every other bold line are the strongest El Niño’s on record.
2026 is in a league of its own.
#elnino #elniño
We have two months left for this El Niño to continue to intensify. And it will. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
50 Years of Brutally Honest Economic Advice in 23 mins @ProfSteveKeen
youtu.be/M1odc6itzyk via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
Indeed Jem. I always warn that we cannot do this alone, and that we need to plan and work together at every level - town, village, street, block flats
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nick Johnson
@nickj_econ
New post: Quote of the week - Michael Hudson on financial bubbles
peofdev.wordpress.com/2026/09/21/quote-of-the-week-michae… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Rogers
@DLRogKingston
Private indebtedness of people is the problem not so-called indebtedness of govt, the deficit of which puts money into economy as do gilts. Cuts as proposed will have same effect as previous austerity measures: increase private debt & suck money out of circulation. UK illiterate
BladeoftheSun
@BladeoftheS
This is the real reason there is 'no money'.
Because they have raised their profits so high.
And things will never improve because if there is more money, they just raise their prices.
Doesn't matter if you cancel every benefit, pension and the NHS.
There will still be 'no money'
It's billionaires you can't afford. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
Interest rates will no longer be used as the main means of controlling inflation under a Green government. That’s just one of the eye-catching proposals in a planned overhaul of the party’s economic policy, to be voted on by members at their conference in October and seen by the New Statesman.
The motion, which gives the most thorough outline yet of how a Green government would manage the British economy, embraces a range of novel ideas and would mark a seismic break with the fiscal and monetary policy approach pursued by chancellors under Conservative and Labour governments of recent years.
The drafters describe it as “a realistic and effective proposal for how we will fund the economic system change required in the UK, without being forced against our democratic mandate by the holders of capital”. It is a key part of the Green Party’s efforts to develop a more robust left-wing programme as it attempts to “replace Labour”.
www.newstatesman.com/politics/uk-politics/2026/09/exclusi… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ModernMoneyLab_EU
@mml_europe
Eurozone members can create euros. The ECB backstops their bonds on the secondary market. They cannot be forced into default like true foreign-currency users. Fiscal rules are political choices, not financial constraints.
#mmt #economics #eu -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Pre-order is now available for the Kindle edition of Beyond Equilibrium: A Dynamic Keynesian Approach To Macroeconomics.
Pre-orders will not be available for physical editions and will be released on Amazon and for order at bookstores on October 3rd.
a.co/d/0a8FoLLB -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a well-reasoned argument.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And isn't that rich, coming from someone who was willing to assume that a benevolent central authority redistributed income in capitalist economies in order to hang onto the concept of a downward-sloping demand curve?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Farzin Irani
@FoxtrotFuz
Banks create money 'out of thin air' journal entries - creative accounting.
FULL EPISODE with @ProfSteveKeen here - -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Ludwig von Mises is the greatest economist of all time!
𝗱𝗮𝗻𝗻𝘆🫧💚
@beyoncegarden
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve
@oldguy_steve
Bill Gates and Elon Musk have entered into a joint venture to manufacture a penis extender. It's called Elong-Gates. It cures Microsoft.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ethical American
@AmericanEthical
Americans are waking up. #vote
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Tennessee Holler
@TheTNHoller
⛽️ MAGA TRUCKERS: “There’s no reason for this… My truck’s gonna sit there and rot until this idiot is out of office… I never thought I’d say this but I miss Biden… we’re dying out here and they don’t give a shit…”
cc: @MarshaBlackburn -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Screw @X! I’ve typed the www twice and it’s culled it. Here’s the about page as a pic. Search for me in Skool and you’ll locate it.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Screw @X! I’ve typed the www twice and it’s culled it. Here’s the about page as a pic. Search for me in Skool and you’ll locate it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Already done by numerous economists with expertise. Good start here. Nobody is listening. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4eAruJ9Kn4k
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
The Left party just won a historic victory in Berlin with 24.5% of votes according to exit polls. Elif Elrap would be the first mayor of Turkish descent in a city that is home to the largest Turkish community outside Turkey.
This has been a housing affordability election. The Left’s agenda? Socialize the housing stock of corporate landlords. Socialization has been the expressed will of the majority of voters in a referendum. Socialization has been deemed legal by an expert commission, yet the referendum remained without consequence to date. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
So a woman who is a rape victim attacked ME, a woman who stood up for rape victims, and is calling me an “insufferable c*nt” for posting a video about near $7 per gallon diesel prices in Tampa, Florida which is crushing truckers and Americans who drive diesels??
I’m questioning if Juanita actually posted this or if some social media consultant’s company posted this on her account.
I’ve met Juanita and she’s a nice person, and doesn’t seem like the type of person who would support truckers and Americans getting crushed by near $7 per gallon for diesel.
And women my age and older don’t typically use the word c*nt, but some social media consultant’s younger staffer (likely male) paying her to post Trump/MAGA talking points on her account, would use the nasty word “c*nt.”
Also, she reposted an account, 0HOUR1, with barely any bio but a Buy Me A Coffee link, which means that account makes money and gets paid to posts on social media.
Maybe I’m wrong and Juanita Broaderrik is only against Bill Clinton raping women and high gas prices under Democrat presidents but is totally fine with Trump’s friend Epstein and associates raping women and high gas prices under Trump.
OR this is one of many large MAGA accounts getting paid to spread total bullshit.
Either way, expect more videos of me posting about absurd gas and diesel prices because Trump is a liar and betrayed his campaign promises. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Looking forward to give this presentation this week in Mexico. Giving the closing remarks to a conference with more than 350 participants.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
I was told that some of the Political Committee operate from a standard Marxist position - the working class commandeer the means of production. Others argue from a sensible socialist position - state-led planning, public ownership of the commanding heights, reindustrialisation and modernisation, ending privatisation and reviving publicly funded services. The former is a bit premature because after deindustrialisation we don't have much 'means of production' left in this country, but I was on board with the latter. The argument @DerbyChrisW and I put forward is that first we need to understand the current financialised global economy, its disciplinary mechanisms, the UK's vulnerable import-dependent condition, and how we use public investment via the fiat currency system to achieve those ambitions. We said that without a detailed financial plan in the manifesto, including defences against money-market (bond/FX) attacks, we would be slaughtered by the press as soon as we achieve any electoral success. The PC showed no interest in learning about it or the modern heterodox economics we need to support it. Polanski attracted a lot of attention with detailed knowledge of public spending mechanisms - he had been briefed and listened - so we suggested we do the same. Latterly I also suggested the broad left should unite, get up to date and adopt a similar feasible 'how to' financial position. This was taken by some to mean we all join or support the Greens - I had said no such thing. It just got silly. Puritanical knee-jerk bollocks and a few 'unfollows', even accusations of being a Zionist! 🙄 The current left is just one big divisive mess trapped in multiple dogmas.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
@UMich professor @robertmanduca: The key point is that businesses will only produce when there is demand for their products, otherwise they will shutter their facilities and lay off their workers. Because high-income people spend a smaller share of their earnings than low-income people do, high levels of income inequality result in lower levels of aggregate demand, the forerunner to recession and unemployment. Bowles demonstrated this logic by taking it to its extreme:
"Let us suppose that one percent of the population were to receive 95 percent of our entire national income, with the remaining 5 percent spread among the rest of us. Could our system—could any system—work on that basis? One percent of the people couldn’t possibly consume 95 percent of all the goods and services which the rest of us could produce."
The long-lasting prosperity of the 1940s and ’50s thus owed, in large part, to the fact that the general public broadly understood and agreed upon the economic principle that fast-paced growth and high employment could be achieved on the back of consumer demand, but only if purchasing power was distributed widely enough. Read more: evonomics.com/job-creators-middle-class-keynesianism/ @ProfSteveKeen @StephanieKelton @rorysutherland @NickHanauer @EricBeinhocker -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene🇺🇸
@FmrRepMTG
X says it’s news that Catturd and other MAGA paid accounts got their feelings hurt because I posted a video in Tampa complaining about the absurd levels of gas and diesel prices because of Trump.
The same pathetic mind controlled maga cultists, cried constantly about gas prices and inflation under Biden, but don’t want to dare offend whatever contact they have in the Trump campaign by being honest about Trump betraying his campaign promises with his war and driving record high gas and diesel prices.
By the way, in real life, which is not social media, EVERYONE including real Trump voters not paid social media slop posters are furious about the current price of gas and diesel.
I criticized high gas prices under Biden and I am criticizing high gas prices under Trump because Trump literally campaigned in 2024 on lowering gas prices and ending foreign wars.
And yes, I supported Trump and helped him get elected, arguably more than most elected Republicans.
But that was when his campaign promises were ending foreign wars, lowering inflation and gas prices, making life affordable again for everyday Americans, lowering the debt, draining the swamp, making America great again, and releasing the Epstein files.
Now that he has done the opposite of what he promised, I no longer support him or Republicans who are either too weak and afraid to call it out or are full blooded neocons.
That doesn’t make me a Democrat, that makes me honest.
Expect more gas and diesel price complaining videos until the prices come down to what he promised!!! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
The closed minds of economists are revealed in a piece about a coming crash that mentions neither climate breakdown nor the coming hyper El Nino
The great recession of 2008-9 cost the global economy $2 trillion
The 1997-98 El Nino cost $5.7 trillion
www.theguardian.com/business/ng-interactive/2026/sep/20/s… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
--- Thwaites Glacier ---
Crucial cracks keep coming!! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Coming in the inaugural issue of Challenge
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2026.2724139 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
You can forget everything you think you know about voluntary governance replacing the state.
Picture yourself standing next to a wagon in Independence, Missouri in 1843. You're preparing to travel 2,000 miles across territory already shaped by federal land policy, military expeditions, treaty systems, and the legal framework of the United States. Around you are settlers carrying property claims that only have meaning because a larger political order exists to eventually recognize and enforce them.
The wagon train constitutions that emerged along the Oregon Trail were not alternatives to government. They were extensions of it.
Yes, travelers wrote constitutions, elected captains, and established rules. But this was never a society operating outside public institutions. These groups were temporary organizations solving coordination problems during a journey. They were more like committees, cooperatives, or firms than independent governments.
The fact that people organized themselves does not demonstrate that states are unnecessary. It demonstrates that collective action is necessary.
What made the wagon trains work was not simply the right to exit. It was a shared expectation that everyone would ultimately arrive within a broader legal and political order. Land titles, contracts, inheritance rights, commercial exchange, and dispute resolution all depended on institutions that extended far beyond the wagon train itself.
The romantic image of competing governments overlooks a more basic reality. Most people joined together because survival required cooperation. The dangers they faced were not solved by market competition but by collective rules, shared resources, and mutual obligations.
Even the ability to "choose" a wagon train had limits. Geography, family ties, wealth, information, and circumstance constrained those choices. The same is true today. Exit is rarely as simple as advocates imagine. Most people cannot easily abandon their communities, jobs, social networks, or economic opportunities.
The deeper lesson of the Oregon Trail is not that government is just another service industry. It is that institutions emerge whenever people face common problems that markets alone cannot solve.
Successful societies are not built on the absence of governance. They are built on governance that is legitimate, adaptable, and capable of coordinating large numbers of people over long periods of time.
The wagon trains dissolved when the journey ended. The states that followed endured because the challenges of settlement, infrastructure, property rights, public health, defense, and economic development did not disappear when people reached Oregon.
Far from proving that government is unnecessary, the Oregon Trail shows how quickly people create governing institutions when circumstances demand them. The question has never been whether governance exists. The question is whose interests it serves, how accountable it is, and how effectively it manages the complex interdependence of modern economic life. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Mises made a priori economics so detached from reality that neoclassical economics looked empirical.
Walras started looking like a field researcher.
Then post-Keynesians committed the ultimate heresy: checking the actual economy. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Derek Ross
@wikiDerek
I listened to a lot of people on banking from the 1970s through to the 2000s.
Steve Keen was certainly the last person that I listened to on banking because he was the first person that got it right. Settlement and all. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Anton Korzhenkov
@AntonKorzhenkov
This is professor of economics. He has no idea that private sector bank deposits are liabilities of the banks, and that when they change, the bank records the change on the liability side. And then those guys teach someone...
Professor John Hearn
@jbhearn
I don’t why you cannot see this.
One option. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
FireFighterDev
@fire_starter457
Here’s a Kennedy Center compromise-
Print out the ENTIRE un-redacted Epstein Files and tape them to the Kennedy Center.
Tada!
Trump’s name is now all over the Center! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minutes for a little chat about the US Treasury and bond markets.
See the link in the post below👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
NEW EP! 💵
Federal budget surpluses extract wealth from workers. That extraction pushes people into private debt. Wealth concentrates upward. Then it collapses. 📉
@MMT101DotORG & @sdgrumbine explain the accounting identity that predicted 2008.
realprogressives.org/mnc-podcast-ep/episode-397-sectoral-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kanika
@KanikaBK
Oxford researchers just published a paper arguing LLMs cannot invent anything. Mathematically impossible.
The reason is simple and brutal. A model trained to predict the next word can never believe something the existing data says is wrong. And every real breakthrough in history started with exactly that belief.
In 1903 every prediction machine on Earth would have told the Wright Brothers that human flight was one to ten million years away. Nine weeks later they flew. Not because they had better data. Because they had a theory the data hadn't caught up to yet.
That is the gap between AI and human thinking. LLMs mirror the past. Humans reason into a future that doesn't exist yet. Oxford just proved mathematically that those are two different things.
I use these models every day. This matches what I see. The new stuff always comes from the human at the keyboard who decides the data is wrong.
LLMs don't think. You do. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
"Mere scare talk is not enough. If you want to beat back the pitchforks, you should consider arming yourself with a new economics that acknowledges the failures of the past half-century while actually delivering the kind of economy the American people desperately want and deserve." Read more: www.wsj.com/economy/market-humanism-nick-hanauer-fba8b428
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene🇺🇸
@FmrRepMTG
Insane!!
Diesel in central Florida is almost $7 dollars!!
This is all Trump’s fault!
We did not vote for this.
We shouldn’t pay taxes to a government that ruins our lives. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Buddy Wells
@BuddyWells1
The US froze prices in WWII
By 1941–42 the US was pouring unprecedented sums into the war. Deficits hit 13–27% of GDP. Factories were converting, workers were flooding into cities, and civilian demand was colliding with military demand for steel, rubber, food, and fuel.
In WWI the same pattern produced a price explosion. Officials remembered that. Uncontrolled bidding would have driven the cost of the war itself through the roof, created windfall profits in scarce goods, and risked civilian unrest. Price controls were not a peacetime ideology. They were an emergency tool to keep the mobilisation from eating itself.
The institutional answer:
Roosevelt created the Office of Price Administration. John Kenneth Galbraith, then a young economist, became deputy administrator in charge of prices. Early selective “scientific” ceilings on individual commodities proved too slow. Inflation kept rising.
In April 1942 they switched to the General Maximum Price Regulation - a near-economy-wide freeze at March 1942 levels. In April 1943 came the “Hold-the-Line” order. Complementary rationing (meat, sugar, gasoline, tires) and wage guidelines followed. Taxes and war-bond drives soaked up purchasing power.
How inflation was actually contained:
Official consumer prices for working-class households rose about 12% from the May 1942 freeze to January 1946 - roughly 3.3% a year. After Hold-the-Line the rise slowed to 1.4% a year through early 1946.
That was far below the WWI trajectory. Wholesale prices and the cost of living rose much less than in the corresponding months of 1917–18, even though real output more than doubled and unemployment fell below 2%.
Galbraith’s later explanation: many prices were already “administered” by large firms rather than set in auction markets. A freeze plus public compliance plus rationing could hold the line within a “margin of tolerance” of excess demand. Patriotism and local volunteer boards did a lot of the enforcement work.
What made them useful:
The point was never perfect price stability. It was to stop prices of war-critical and household goods from exploding while resources were redirected.
• The government paid less for munitions and ships.
• Civilian real consumption still rose 50% even as the military took a huge share of output.
• Labour’s share of income increased.
• Windfall profits in scarcity were limited, which helped political legitimacy.
• Time was bought for fiscal measures (withholding tax, bond sales) to catch up.
Galbraith later wrote that the General Maximum Price Regulation “worked.” He considered the OPA years one of his principal achievements precisely because prices stayed relatively stable while the economy quadrupled in size.
What they did not do:
They did not abolish shortages. Quality often deteriorated. Black markets appeared, especially in meat. A large bureaucracy was required. Official indices missed some hidden inflation (skimpflation, forced substitution). When controls were lifted abruptly in 1946, prices jumped 20%.
Those costs were accepted as the price of running a command-mobilisation economy at full stretch. Galbraith himself later favoured only limited, strategic restraints on large firms and unions in peacetime - not a full wartime apparatus. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mark Washio
@ouroborus73
Fractional reserve banking is a myth. Banks create new money when they make a loan. Only things like LTV ratios restrain this. Private debt is the main problem, not Government deficits as @ProfSteveKeen argues
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
1. HASN'T ANYONE GIVEN THE MATHS TO ANDY?
Either the security services have given him the maths and he is too dumb to understand it, or he knows the maths perfectly well and is engaging in the most treasonous lie a ruler has ever inflicted upon the British people.
So let's do the fucking maths again.
We are at 1.5C
We are adding 0.4C in the next 10 years
We have to add on 0.5C for the effect of the removal of air pollution
We have to add on 0.3C for the collapse of natural carbon sinks
2.7C effectively locked in by 2035.
Without a revolution to force through the slashing of emissions to effectively zero in the next ten years, civilisational collapse is the main scenario. A scenario which the UK insurance industry predicts will lead to billions of deaths.
NET ZERO by 2050 IS WAY, WAY TOO LATE!
www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/sep/17/andy-burnham-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
Newest Podcasts:
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen
Trump’s New Plan to RESET the Dollar
braveneweurope.com/economics/steve-keen-trumps-new-plan-t…
Tucker Carlson: Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein
Reveals Shocking Discoveries While Researching History of Israel’s Gaza Obsession
braveneweurope.com/geopolitics/tucker-carlson-norman-fink…
#gazagenocide -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'm here. Come join me.
discord.gg/tTk3uHbNB -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
Public money can help create breakthroughs. Collective knowledge makes them possible. So why should the rewards automatically become private?
@MazzucatoM on our latest episode!
🎧 ➡️ pod.link/pitchforkeconomics/episode/YWQ5N2NjZTQtYjExZS0xM… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'm not even an MMTer, but this isn't really a critique of MMT. You're arguing against something MMT doesn't claim.
MMT doesn't say governments can print their way to prosperity. It says the constraint isn't running out of dollars, it's real resources and inflation.
And Zimbabwe and Weimar aren't the gotcha you think they are. If productive capacity collapses while nominal spending keeps rising, you get inflation. MMT doesn't dispute that. That's literally the point about real constraints.
And factories aren't built out of financial savings. Dollars sitting in someone's bank account don't turn into machine tools, concrete, engineers, or electricity. A factory requires real resources: labor, machinery, materials, energy, land, and technology.
Financial saving is a claim on resources, not the resources themselves. Banks can finance investment by creating credit, and the resulting investment generates income and financial saving elsewhere in the economy. You don't need someone to first abstain from spending and pile up dollars before investment can occur.
The real constraint is whether the labor, machinery etc exist to carry out the investment without creating excessive inflation.
There are plenty of legitimate arguments to have with MMT, trust me, I've been done all those roads. At least argue with what MMT actually says. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X
@Xking332
Saudi is in severe danger.
Yemen is now bombing the hell out of several cities across Saudi.
16 people dead. More than 35 people are wounded.
Jeddah, Taif, Khamis Mushait, Jazan, Abha and Al Ula are on massive fire.
Yanbu Oil Terminal is also under attack for the seventh time.
Multiple energy sites are also being bombed out of existence.
This is the largest wave of bombings in the last two weeks.
A deadly diesel crisis is already developing.
American Airlines is expecting 1 billion in additional fuel costs in Q4.
Airlines like United Airlines, Southwest Airlines, Lufthansa Group and KLM have already started cutting flights.
Very soon, multiple airports could be shut down for months.
Pakistan has imposed a one dish rule at weddings.
In Ukraine, people are limited to purchasing no more than 6 packs of pasta at a time from shops.
Egg purchases are limited to 6 dozen.
41 countries are already starving.
Thousands of trucks in India have stopped operating because of fuel shortages.
New Zealand has warned dozens of schools would be forced to shut down soon.
Very soon, fines will most likely be imposed on civilians around the world for eating food beyond officially permitted limits.
Human civilization is heading towards a catastrophic crisis. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Commercial bank credit expansion comes first. Central bank reserve balances adjust afterward to accommodate settlement.
The Loanable Funds and the Money Multiplier theories are but bedtime stories that Neoclassical and Austrian economists tell themselves to sleep at night. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
It took a few years to get this done, with many revised outlines and many System Dynamic model versions that drive the narrative.
Math is fun, but writing coherently with the attention span of a gerbil and the spelling skills of a 6 year old is not.
Out in October... -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
As @winlow_s and I have said many times, on the hopelessly divided left we all know what we want to fight against but we have nothing coherent to fight for. policy.bristoluniversitypress.co.uk/trade/the-death-of-th…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
WE STACK CHIPS!
@LAKERSRISE
Look at how much we paid to fill our semi truck up guys! $1,189!!! Trump is a bitch made, lying ass CROOK! we are going on strike! We're not hauling shit til he stops that dumb ass war and changes his diaper! 💯
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Glenn Tunes
@glenn_tunes
THE US PRESIDENT IS A BAT SHIT CRAZY UNHINGED MADMAN 🙄
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dean Blundell🇨🇦
@ItsDeanBlundell
Die.
Airas @Airaswe
What can President Trump do right now that would impress you the most?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Canada Hates Trump
@AntiTrumpCanada
Listen up, Fuckface: We don’t give a fuck whether you choose electrocution or let a pack of sharks turn you into a fucking buffet. Just pick one and hurry the fuck up. The champagne’s been chilling for 10 years. We’re thirsty.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Fair enough. Maybe the broad left should forget the vital economic issues that are always top of the public concern polls and unite as the Lost Deposit Party.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"5. Pretend and extend. The current path. Works until it doesn’t, then the adjustment is even more painful."
There is no way that the issuer of a currency runs out of currency. Almost all of money consists of balances in accounts. It's all digital.
Michael A. Arouet
@MichaelAArouet
Nominal public debt has exploded since 2000: US +380%, Japan +430%, China +650%. Debt-to-GDP is already ugly: Japan 200%+, US heading toward 125–140%, France heading well above 120%, China crossing 100%. Global government debt is $111 trillion and growing every day. Interest spending is becoming a huge issue for these countries.
The path is unsustainable. Aging, slower productivity, and higher real rates make the math even worse.
There are only a few ways out:
1. Grow faster than interest spending and fiscal deficit. The cleanest option, but hard in aging, high-regulation, high-tax societies.
2. Run primary surpluses. Spend less than you tax, politically the hardest.
3. Inflate it away. Keep rates below inflation and force savers to hold the bonds. It destroys both wealth and the currency.
4. Default or restructure. Very costly for everyone, destroys trust.
5. Pretend and extend. The current path. Works until it doesn’t, then the adjustment is even more painful.
There is no painless option, but delay only shifts a larger bill onto the young. How will we get out of this mess? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alan Doran
@AlJefDor
As Steve Keen points out, leaving banks, private sector debt and money out of our analysis of capital isn't a minor omission. The finance sector isn’t just a ‘veil’ over the real economy - it’s a central part of it.
@ProfSteveKeen -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"European wholesale gas remained almost ten times as expensive as US gas." (Source: EGOV)
Europe needs to solve its energy problems. Competitiveness, the cost of living and inflation are all issues that stem from ongoing energy problems. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A strong dollar looks like a crown. But it can become a noose.
America didn’t become powerful because the dollar was the world’s currency. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rob Hoff
@hoff_rob
We've been stuck in this same damn loop since the dawn of civilization, you'd think we could figure it out & get it right sometime. Steve Keen has a good post here
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It became powerful because its factories could produce weapons, ships, and machinery better than its rivals.
After Bretton Woods, the dollar gained an extra demand: every country needed it to trade with every other country.
That pushed its value above what American goods alone justified. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yesterdaypills 🍏
@yesterdaypills
Paul McCartney contro i cambiamenti, come gli aggiornamenti dell’iPhone: “L’ho comprato così, non voglio che cambi!”
Paul McCartney sembra avere qualche conto in sospeso con la tecnologia. Ospite di Stephen Colbert, l’ex Beatle ha confessato con grande ironia di non amare affatto i continui cambiamenti:
“A me piace che le cose restino come sono. Appena ho imparato a usarle, arriva qualcuno e le cambia. Prendi l’iPhone: ormai so come funziona e poi compare la scritta ‘Aggiorna’. Ma io non voglio aggiornarlo! L’ho comprato così e non voglio che cambi”.
Paul ne ha anche per i famigerati cookie — precisando subito, però, che quelli da mangiare gli piacciono eccome — e scherza sugli avvisi che compaiono sul telefono: “Dicono: ‘Utilizziamo i cookie’. No, non li utilizzate: il telefono l’ho comprato io!”.
A quel punto Colbert gli suggerisce di rivolgersi direttamente a Tim Cook, amministratore delegato di Apple, chiedendogli di smettere di modificare il suo iPhone. La risposta di Paul è perfetta:
“In realtà l’ho incontrato… e gliene ho dette quattro proprio per questo!”.
Geniale il nostro Paul, anche quando si lamenta, con il suo solito “sense of humour”, della tecnologia.
#paulmccartney #thebeatles #stephencolbert #timcook #apple #yesterdaypills -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
This is an important insight. Also, China turned into the global #1 in terms of GDP with a currency that in the 1980s was among the least attractive. Much of the literature on the "currency hierarchy" is highly doubtful because it does not reflect that.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A strong dollar looks like a crown. But it can become a noose.
America didn’t become powerful because the dollar was the world’s currency. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Li Zexin 李泽欣
@XH_Lee23
A year ago, people joked that China was building a base on the moon, as the construction site looked so futuristic.
Answer is out: China has built its first river-to-sea canal, solving a major logistics problem for Western inland cities, like Chongqing, whose exports had to detour thousands of km to reach the sea.
This grand canal is a perfect example of why I always say: investing in infrastructure is investing in the future.
The 134 km canal costs $10.2 billion, that's about 10 days of US military spending on the Iran war. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The Eurozone still exports more than it imports. If a global rebalancing happens, driven by cuts in exports, the Eurozone would lose more aggregate demand. In the current situation, that would be very bad since many governments (🇫🇷,🇧🇪,🇩🇪,...) prepare austerity budgets for 2027.
European Central Bank
@ecb
How did the euro area current account balance evolve in July? How does it compare with the same month a year earlier?
Find out more in the press release www.ecb.europa.eu/press/stats/bop/2026/html/ecb.bp260918~… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
BrooklynDad_Defiant!☮️
@mmpadellan
It's stunning when you realize exactly how many things trump f*cked up in less than 2 years.
HILARIOUS when a song nails it perfectly.
THIS IS BRILLIANT!!!🔥🔥🔥 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
How about we cancel the circular firing squad that's the current left? A number of leftist parties could be very useful and indeed find unity if only they could converge around an updated understanding of macroeconomics. That's what @DerbyChrisW and I are trying to get across.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
𝑇ℎ𝑒 𝑙𝑒𝑠𝑠𝑜𝑛 𝑖𝑠 𝑠𝑖𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒: 𝑑𝑜𝑛’𝑡 𝑟𝑒𝑝𝑙𝑎𝑐𝑒 𝑜𝑛𝑒 𝑛𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛𝑎𝑙 𝑖𝑚𝑝𝑒𝑟𝑖𝑎𝑙 𝑐𝑢𝑟𝑟𝑒𝑛𝑐𝑦 𝑤𝑖𝑡ℎ 𝑎𝑛𝑜𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑟.
Use a neutral international unit, make trade balances sum to zero, and limit excessive surpluses and deficits.
That could reduce global instability. But ego and testosterone may get in the way. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Best
@TheBestqueenx
🤣🤣
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Welcome to WW3
@The_rea1_Peter
$3 Diesel in Brisbane. This is going to affect everything. If you thought that you were broke before you ain't seen nothing yet. Food prices, inflation and interest rates will follow.
1000s of businesses will go broke and 1000s of people will become homeless.
IMO Trump and Netanyahu are to blame for starting a war in Iran that nobody wanted. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Since the "slippery slope" from Social Democracy/Socialism that "The Road to Serfdom" predicted never became a reality (think about the Scandinavian countries), one can only say that Hayek's warnings were misguided. Instead, Western societies are moving towards fascism again.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Hayek’s “The Road to Serfdom” is packed with important insights in every chapter but the actual literal account of how Hitler came to power is weirdly wrong and the whole thing was way more contingent than he wants to admit.
www.slowboring.com/p/how-to-stop-hitler -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Private sector bank deposits to GDP in blue, fiscal surplus or deficit to GDP in red. As you can see, private sector bank deposits surge when the government spends more than it taxes and fall when its vice versa. This is perhaps the most important channel to explain the change in bank deposits of the private sector.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Michael Hudson michael-hudson.com & @ProfSteveKeen
The Federal Reserve, The Constitution, and the End of US Hegemony
youtu.be/-ZZM-bkUfzM via @Class_Unity -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Grace Hall
@Randaroo1212
Who else thinks Donald Trump is going to try to call a national emergency and cancel the midterms?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
MASS GLOBAL FAMINE is what's coming in 2027. That's my prediction. Here's a clip from my recent podcast. Crop yields are lower, fertilizer is increasingly scarce, and diesel shortages are making farming insanely expensive. We are going to see anywhere from 500 million to ONE BILLION people facing famine conditions in 2027. (It's already baked in.)
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Buddy Wells
@BuddyWells1
Both the 1921 depression and the Great Depression were caused by the US govt running budget surpluses (non-govt deficits).
The US govt ran a series of surpluses from 1920 to 1929, which forced the non-govt sector to run deficits equal to that amount. (See table below).
Note that the $7 billion reduction in govt debt more or less marches the increase in private debt during the 1920s. (See graph below).
So basically the US swapped sustainable currency issuer debt with unsustainable currency user debt, resulting in Great Depression.
You can see that the increase in pvt sector debt begins at the same time the decrease in govt debt happens, beginning 1920.
At first govt surplus / pvt deficit is viable because pvt sector has savings and is not over leveraged, so you have initially a drop in private savings (1920 to 1923) In the graph below you can see that the 1920 recession coincided with sharp drop in bank deposits till around 2022.
Simultaneously the unsustainable private credit fuelled boom leading to an over-leveraged private sector by 1929, and asset price bubble, which burst spectacularly, leading to the Great Depression.
So you can clearly see the initial recovery from the 1921 depression and subsequent boom were fuelled by a massive drop in private savings and an increase in private debt. Both are unsustainable. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Too good not to share...
Schrödinger's Litter Box
@Brewjew308
Gonna have this certified banger in my head for the next ~50 days 🎵🔊
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The State can mobilize resources, maintain demand, stabilize employment, and accomplish things markets cannot. That doesn't make government magically competent. There is absolutely nothing preventing a retard from getting behind the wheel and driving the whole thing into a ditch.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The only semi Austrian Economic historical figure I can take seriously.
"Capitalism inevitably and by virtue of the very logic of its civilization creates, educates and subsidizes a vested interest in social unrest."
-Joseph A. Schumpeter -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
AJ Signal
@aj_geo_analysis
EXCLUSIVE INVESTIGATION: Some market and oil analysts are absolutely clueless about the depth of the damage that Aramco has experienced in Saudi Arabia at the 3 pumping stations...
The Ansrallah Houthi strikes on the three Saudi Aramco Pumping Stations (PS) was more likely than NOT facilitated with someone that had insider knowledge or working for Saudi Aramco that sold information to the Houthis.
After a 5 day investigation, I assess with high confidence that that the information was either sold to the Houthis OR they have a sympathizer working inside Aramco that gave them VERY specific technical information which enabled the missile strikes.
Why do I say this?
Because the Houthi military's target selection cell had too much technical details which enabled such a devastating blow, the target selection was far too sophisticated... They hit Pumping Station #8, PS #9 and PS #11 AND then the Yanbu terminal.
They did not hit PS 1 or any of the other sequence of pumping stations, WHY?
Because they knew or were told that if they strike PS 8, PS 9 and PS11, they would essentially decommissioned at least 400km of oil flow by striking the 3 Pumping Stations with multiple ballistic and drone strikes.
But what's also interesting is that some of these pumping stations are soo remote you cannot necessarily drive to them, or bring in the necessary crew needed, hence Aramco will have to fly the crew and the equipment to the site and for instance, PS #9 that was hit has its own airport at the pumping stations so they have fly everyone in and out daily.
They hit the pumps at highest elevation disabling any type of potential bypass or redundancy that can kick in.
This will likely take at least 3 to 6 months to repair. Not weeks!!
Full analysis with maps, and details here: ajsignalnotnoise.substack.com/p/exclusive-investigation-s…
Help amplify the Signal. You know what to do.
Signal, not noise! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
Newest Podcasts:
Steve Keen @ProfSteveKeen
Trump’s New Plan to RESET the Dollar
braveneweurope.com/economics/steve-keen-trumps-new-plan-t…
Tucker Carlson: Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein Reveals Shocking Discoveries While Researching History of Israel’s Gaza Obsession
braveneweurope.com/geopolitics/tucker-carlson-norman-fink…
#gazagenocide -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
First really big move on the Nowcast since September 3rd.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
🚨 GDP NOWCAST UPDATE
Q3 GDP nowcast jumped 0.22 points today, from 2.42% to 2.64%.
The entire revision came from residential investment as single-family housing starts surged 7.6%.
The headline housing numbers hid the story.
Article in the post below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
yılmaz aydın
@yilmazaydin88
Çetele Çubukları (Tally Sticks) özellikle İngiltere’de 12-19 yy.da yaygın olarak kullanılan borç senetleridir. Paranın ontolojik olarak maddesel bir nesne değil, soyut bir borç-kredi ilişkisi olduğunu kanıtlayan en somut tarihsel ve kurumsal araçlardan biridir.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
A lot of what gets called “market forces” is really just policy, power, and choices with the fingerprints wiped off.
@MazzucatoM makes the case for treating the economy as something we can shape and for testing how we could design it differently.
🎧 ➡️ pod.link/pitchforkeconomics/episode/YWQ5N2NjZTQtYjExZS0xM… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniel E Nunes
@DENunes49
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dorian
@Dorianxxbt
In 1985, Carl Sagan sat in front of the United States Senate and described the weather of 2026.
Not as prediction. As physics.
Sitting across from him was a junior senator named Al Gore — who would later win the Nobel Prize, the Oscar, and build a climate investment fund worth over $36 billion repeating almost word for word what Sagan said that afternoon.
Sagan opened with Venus.
470°C surface temperature. 900°F. Hot enough to melt lead.
"Not because it's closer to the sun," he told the senators. "Venus actually reflects more light than Earth. It should be cooler."
The reason it wasn't: carbon dioxide. A runaway greenhouse effect that turned a planet nearly identical to Earth into a furnace.
Then he looked at the committee and said: we're running the same experiment here.
The senators nodded politely.
Then they went back to approving fossil fuel subsidies.
What Sagan told Congress in 1985:
Global average temperature will rise several degrees by mid-to-late next century.
Local climates will redistribute.
Glaciers will melt. Sea levels will rise.
And the problem cannot be solved by any single nation — not even if the US and Soviet Union agreed on everything — without China.
China, he said, had the world's largest coal reserves and was about to industrialize.
Every sentence was correct.
He also said something that got almost no coverage at the time:
"The initial stages of global temperature increase — one region might benefit while another suffers."
That is the sentence that explains the last 20 years of geopolitics.
Canada's growing season expanding while Pakistan floods. Russia opening Arctic shipping lanes while Bangladesh disappears. The politics of climate was never going to be clean because the physics wasn't distributed evenly.
Sagan mapped all of it from first principles, in a Senate hearing room, 41 years ago.
The part nobody quotes:
He didn't say stop burning fossil fuels immediately.
He said: "That has such severe economic consequences that no one will take it seriously."
So he proposed something else — remove government subsidies from fossil fuels, accelerate solar, develop safe nuclear fission, and begin building international frameworks before the crisis made them impossible.
That's not an environmentalist's speech. That's an economist's.
Carl Sagan wrote 20 books. Cosmos was watched by 500 million people across 60 countries. He won the Pulitzer. The ideas in this testimony became the scientific foundation for a carbon market now valued at over $800 billion annually.
He said one line at the end that nobody remembers.
"We are all in this greenhouse together."
In 1985, that was poetic.
Now it's a weather report.
The full testimony is free on YouTube. 17 minutes. Almost nobody outside of climate policy circles has watched it as a complete predictive model — laid out in plain language before any of it happened.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
TM Matus
@TMSallis
Excellent video. Concise and logical.
I'd love to see someone argue against it, because it seems horrendously irresponsible for established economists not to have been warning of this for 70 years -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Here's the video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3I7g5PZTN20
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Oh it feels good to "Go Viral". My first > 500,000 views in a day video. Link follows for those who want to know what all the fuss was about.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Oh it feels good to "Go Viral". My first > 500,000 views in a day video. Link follows for those who want to know what all the fuss was about.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Here's the video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3I7g5PZTN20
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lubo- mír
@Lubo_mirUL
Exporting US inflation since 1945's Bretton Woods had to hit rock bottom. Defending or losing the dollar's global status will be painful. Is living at others' expense right? Solutions exist, but require rethinking money's manipulative role & freeing patents for humanity.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
I'm tending to agree with @ProfSteveKeen that, exacerbated by the AI fiasco and Iran war, energy scarcity/prices will reduce production and the ability to pay mounting private debt. Haven't looked at the data closely enough to guess when. 5-10 years? www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgLAfG1DMOU&t=55s
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
A Reminder from Carl
“It is well within our power to destroy our civilization, and perhaps our species as well. If we capitulate to superstition, or greed, or stupidity, we can plunge our world into a darkness deeper than the time between the collapse of classical civilization and the Italian Renaissance. But we are also capable of using our compassion and our intelligence, our technology and our wealth, to make an abundant and meaningful life for every inhabitant of this planet, to enhance enormously our understanding of the universe and to carry us to the stars.” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
NBS Tennis
@NBSTennis
Love him or hate him, nobody turned a tennis court into a show quite like Roger Federer. 🎾✨
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephen Hinton
@stephen_hinton
Whatever your preferred economic theory—MMT, neoclassical, Keynesian, ecological economics, post-Keynesian—what information should a government be required to possess about the nations real capital assets before it makes a national budget?
If you say none, you are in good company with classical economists who believe the price signals of money will act and all will come right.
I say you are chuckling about stock market gains and economic growth ignoring the huge, gaping hole that was once enormous mineral resources, ecosystem resources and bountiful nature.
And the piles of rubbish.
And that people seem miserable.
What do heterodox economists say? @ProfSteveKeen @ProfHall1955 @StevenHailAus @TyKeynes -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
New video on the rise and fall of Empires
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/new-video-on-and-1698… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
The Economy at the End of the World:
Michael Hudson and Kathleen Tyson discuss the Mechanics of Financial Rupture.
youtu.be/ZQxFaeEG_E0 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
War with Iran. National high gas prices. Diesel crisis. Data centers. Flock cameras. Not releasing the Epstein files to protect his friends.
This is NOT what we voted for.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝕺𝕲 𝕿𝖗𝖊𝖑𝖑 𝕿𝖗𝖎𝖕𝖑𝖊
@DaOGTriple
Truckers are now about to boycott
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cyrus Janssen
@thecyrusjanssen
Gas stations are running out of diesel fuel in the United States. People don’t understand how important diesel is to the US economy.
Every good you purchase in a store, every piece of food you buy at the grocery store is transported via trucks that need diesel.
It’s remarkable how epic of a failure the Iran War has been for Donald Trump. He had control of the House, the Senate, and the Presidency and squandered it all to keep Israel happy.
Remarkably stupid and completely avoidable. The Iran War will go down as the single worst foreign policy decision in US history -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Richard Hirschson
@richardhirschs1
⚠️Level 3 fuel restrictions are coming to Australia.
-Australia will run short of Diesel and Jet fuel this year.
-Australia is weeks away from falling off an energy cliff.
The canary in the coal mine is the government priming its agencies to prepare for diesel restrictions, and independent fuel distributors having trouble sourcing product on the spot market.
www.afr.com/companies/energy/government-agencies-on-notic… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
What the hell is the point of having followers if X doesn’t actually show them your posts?
You follow someone because you WANT to see what they post, yet X dumps you straight into the “For You” cesspit instead. Hate, rage, politics, arguments, outrage and whatever other crap the algorithm decides will keep you scrolling.
Meanwhile, the people who actually chose to follow you might never see a thing you post.
This is completely backwards.
X needs to make “Following” the DEFAULT tab. Let people see the content they signed up to see instead of forcing everyone through this ridiculous algorithmic shitshow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
REMEMBER THIS: YOU ONLY DIE ONCE.
The 4 billion dead at 3C that is predicted by the British Insurance Industry, will not die because of the mean average - the 3C - that is utterly irrelevant. They will die because of the extreme outliers that are produced by that mean - the few days of 45C, 50C, and 55C.
Remember to die you only have to die once - meaning you only have to reach the mass death temperature once in your life time to die due to the emissions of carbon. Get it.
Look at the graph of Paris temperatures. The average is 55 days a year at 25C or above. So what. What is relevant is that the number of days going over 25C is going up and up - in 2026 approaching 110 days, double that average. Which means a day when it hits the mass death tipping point temperatures is massively more likely...
It only has to happen that one time.
You only die once.
Come and find out more about 4 billion dead...
Monday 21 September, 7pm BST
actionnetwork.org/events/the-4-billion-dead-september-int…
Nahel Belgherze
@WxNB_
Paris, France, has now officially recorded 100 days above 25°C (77°F) in 2026 so far. This has never happened before in a calendar year since records began 154 years ago, in 1872.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
the return of some non monetarist sanity today, after Bank inflicted unnecessary pain for past 3 years.
but even now, it claims that the following decisions are the science of monetary policy:
Passive QT to April 2027, then Active QT on the gilts maturing after 2034
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
today @bankofengland caved - too little, too late - to growing critique of Active QT damaging UK's fiscal/gilt position.
1. Pause gilt sales till April 2027 (switch to Passive QT).
2. Resumes sales after, 20bn yearly, to DMO (back to Active QT)
www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/monetary-policy… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Dollar dominance is fading, and the consequences for the US economy are severe. @ProfSteveKeen analyzes what happens when hegemony ends.
youtu.be/3I7g5PZTN20 via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
@ProfSteveKeen @munkeyboy51 @aj_geo_analysis A well explained in clear non technical jargon of COMPLEX Economic history , Geopolitics & macroeconomics, so you can see WHERE RECENT Geopolitical events are going & possible opportunities (NFA/DYOR)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3I7g5PZTN20 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
AJ Signal
@aj_geo_analysis
𝗘𝘃𝗲𝗿𝘆𝗼𝗻𝗲 𝗼𝗻 𝗫 𝗦𝗮𝘆𝘀 𝗦𝗮𝘂𝗱𝗶 𝗔𝗿𝗮𝗯𝗶𝗮'𝘀 𝗣𝗶𝗽𝗲𝗹𝗶𝗻𝗲 𝗪𝗶𝗹𝗹 𝗕𝗲 𝗙𝗶𝘅𝗲𝗱 𝗶𝗻 "𝗗𝗮𝘆𝘀". 𝗜 𝗛𝗮𝘃𝗲 𝗪𝗼𝗿𝗸𝗲𝗱 𝗧𝗵𝗼𝘀𝗲 𝗗𝗲𝘀𝗲𝗿𝘁𝘀. 𝗧𝗿𝘆 𝗢𝗻𝗲 𝘁𝗼 𝗧𝗵𝗿𝗲𝗲 𝗠𝗼𝗻𝘁𝗵𝘀.
First, let me say plainly that I love the desert and the Arab cultures. But it does shape a timeline the media does not understand because they are talking about something they have never experienced.
Lots of people on @X are saying the Saudi East-West pipeline and its pumping stations will be back online in days!?!
I have worked these deserts, in Saudi Arabia and across the Middle East, and that is not how it goes. Even if it is "Expedited", you are still looking at a month at the very least, and realistically one to three.
You have to first understand what the work actually is. This is not a "gas station attendant" tightening a few bolts or replacing a motor.
A pumping station hit by a ballistic missile has to be completely demolished, cleared, re-engineered and rebuilt, from the ground and concrete upwards, often with newer technology because the stations are decades old anyways and the original parts no longer exist.
That means engineering, contractors, subcontractors and sub-subcontractors, each waiting on the one below them, each relying on a supply chain that is nothing like the robust, on-time machine people imagine in Germany or Norway or the West.
Now layer the desert summer heat on top of that (we are still in September where the desert heat burns your feet even with shoes), and this is where the delays compound.
If you are not short on supplies, your truck is stuck in the sand.
If the truck moves, you are waiting on water, or waiting for the temperature to drop, because September in the Saudi desert is so brutal that crews can only work at night or in short bursts before exhaustion and medical emergencies set in.
The skilled labor is largely foreign, Pakistani, Afghan, Indian and others, working under experienced engineers who must be flown in and coordinated and some of those highly skilled workers likely left when the missiles started months ago. So how do you convince them to come back? Sure you have some of your own engineers but the highly skilled ones are always brought in from overseas.
And the rhythm of the day is cultural. There are the Prayer times that take thirty to forty five minutes each, several times a day, if they end up working during the day.
There is a midday rest or naps. These are not flaws, they are how the society works, but they are real hours that Western timelines never account for.
Then the piece almost no one has factored in.
The ports are blocked via Strait of Hormuz and Bab Al Mandeeb. The heavy equipment a rebuild like this needs, the kind that normally arrives by sea ordered from overseas, cannot come by sea now.
It has to be airlifted, which is far more expensive, far slower, and limited by what fits on an aircraft.
Some of this machinery is too large to fly intact, so it must be disassembled, flown in pieces, and reassembled on site. Every one of those steps is a new bottleneck stacked on the last.
I like to look at things from an order of effects point of view so;
1. FIRST, the immediate one, the repair itself drags out to weeks or months, not days, so Saudi export capacity stays crippled far longer than the market expects.
2. Second, the market one, that prolonged outage keeps upward pressure on oil and shipping costs, because the bypass everyone assumed would reopen quickly does not.
3. Third, the strategic one, and this is the part the optimists miss, even a fully repaired pipeline sits under the same threat that broke it. Why would the Houthis not simply hit it again, you bet they will.
They have shown they are less about careful calculation than the IRGC and more about action.
A rebuilt station is just a fresh target, which means the real constraint is NOT the repair time at all, perhaps it never was. It is that you cannot durably fix a node your enemy can strike at will at any time of day regardless of the weather conditions....
So ignore the days talk.
Between the engineering, the desert, the blocked ports and the standing threat of another strike, this is a one-to-three month problem at best, and possibly one that cannot be permanently solved while the war continues at all.
You know what to do, amplify this Signal.
𝗦𝗜𝗚𝗡𝗔𝗟, 𝗡𝗢𝗧 𝗡𝗢𝗜𝗦𝗘!! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Dissenter
@TheDissenterYT
Learn about the future consequences of climate change, including extreme poverty in Europe, in my interview with Dr. Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen). #economics #science
Full interview: youtu.be/BtdhKsj3h4s -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kris Van Steenbergen
@KrVaSt
Oh well, that will happen on its own.
I’m not worried about it.
Very soon, every beach along our oceans will have disappeared.
Perhaps then people will wake up.
Sea levels won’t lie to us.
We are moving to a rate of millimeters per week now, rather than per year. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Latest weekly video update posted on the GDP Dynamics members site, big news on my book! See link in the next post.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
theleahfiles
@leahfiles
People keep saying Trump term II is the most corrupt administration ever, so I built a model to find out if it was true.
I took the UN's definition of corruption, turned it into eight criteria and 100 points, and scored the leaders history remembers for looting their countries: Marcos, Suharto, Mobutu, Abacha, Obiang, Putin.
Then I put every president since Eisenhower on the same scale, both parties, with every exoneration counted right alongside the convictions.
Nixon scored 41 and no other American President scored over a 25.
Trump's second term scored a 91, which ties him with Suharto and Mobutu and puts him above Marcos and Abacha.
So he is not only the most corrupt president in American history. At this pace he finishes his term level with the most corrupt rulers of the last hundred years.
PSA: don't come in my comments arguing about the results if you haven't read the full article, because ignorance is a choice.
Full article is up now on my Substack (link in bio) and it's free. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
JH
@CRUDEOIL231
Hands down one of the greatest dark memes I’ve seen in my entire career.
I know folks on the commodity desk already knows how this math works, but just for the broader timeline and the math-challenged folks out there...
The Taylor Rule is traditionally used to calculate a central bank’s optimal policy rate: i = r* + p* + 1.5(p - p*) + 0.5(y - y*)
(i = nominal rate, r* = neutral rate, p* = 2% target, p - p* = inflation gap, y - y* = output gap).
Dr. Ghalibaf basically jammed two brand new variables into this classic framework, the Strait of Hormuz and the Bab-el-Mandeb.
He's flexing that global CPI and terminal rates are dictated by their maritime choke points...
Honestly crown the man Meme King already. And the wild part? He’s not even lying. Does today's Fed decision even matter in the grand scheme?
Give it a few days, and we’ll all be recalibrating the next FOMC print purely around energy prices—which ironically are being priced by Tehran and the Houthis.
The guy isn't wrong. Welcome to the new macro regime.
#oott #iran -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
What really causes inflation? It isn’t money creation youtu.be/Vi-hQDibhK4. And for those with very little understanding of economics who claim it does, as I show, the evidence doesn't support their case.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Capitalism creates enough wealth to educate people, enough freedom to criticize it, and enough surplus to pay them while they do it.
Socialism creates enough security to educate people, enough institutions to organize them, and enough public resources to fund its own critics. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What would a potential dollar reset mean for the global economy and you?
In my recent analysis, we look beyond the headlines to examine the real data and systemic impacts of a proposed dollar reset.
Here is the early invite for my community -
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3I7g5PZTN20
#economics #usdollar #globaleconomy -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Working Families Party 🐺
@WorkingFamilies
Spoiler alert: we WON.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
"Free market thinking is successful, I argue, because it uses the language of freedom to cloak the accumulation of power." Read more: evonomics.com/why-free-market-ideology-is-a-double-lie/ @blair_fix @Peter_Turchin @ProfSteveKeen
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Taher
@Taher4gx
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
محمدباقر قالیباف | MB Ghalibaf
@mb_ghalibaf
Straits Taylor Rule:
i = r* + π* + 1.5(π−π*) + 0.5(y−y*) + α(SOH−SOH*) + β(BEM−BEM*), α,β > 0
Let’s see if a hike could open SOH or produce a single barrel :)
You can’t 25bp a chokepoint and r* isn’t neutral. It’s SOH risk premium, and We set it.
Stay unanchored ! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Honestly, I'd raise rates too if it meant pissing off Trump.
Higher effective rates mean more federal interest payments flowing to the private sector, supporting demand while crushing indebted firms.
The Fed beat Trump to his $5,000 checks + bankruptcy economic plan. 😂 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
In this AI focussed episode of The Econoclasts, Wolfgang and I expose the hypocrisy of AI techlords calling for their own 'containment', when in reality they use apocalyptic warnings as marketing devices and as ploys by which to get governments to release them from every anti-trust regulation there is. Meanwhile China’s AI-enhanced robots are a serious contribution not just to productivity but to a future mode of production while, tragically, Europe is watching helplessly the latest tech leave it behind... www.youtube.com/watch?v=FOzijIeBGCg
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What would a potential dollar reset mean for the global economy and you?
In my recent analysis, we look beyond the headlines to examine the real data and systemic impacts of a proposed dollar reset.
Here is the early invite for my community -
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3I7g5PZTN20
#economics #usdollar #globaleconomy -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jamison Daniel
@AntiquarianMuse
Sounds about reich
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Eduardo Garzón
@edugaresp
Mientras los economistas convencionales te dicen -sin ningún apoyo empírico- que la línea azul depende de la deuda pública, los datos dejan más que claro que la línea azul depende de la línea naranja, ¡que es un indicador que decide unilateralmente el banco central!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Manjit Singh Ghuman
@manjitghuman58
Think 🤔…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And I can’t be bothered talking with Austrians for the same reason.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Then try reading this mate: profstevekeen.substack.com/p/use-value-and-exchange-the-m…
I gave up talking to Marxists three decades ago, because they are wedded to Marx’s mistakes rather than his genuine advances. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Neoclassical economists are like 19th doctors applying leeches to "cure" diseases.
?whispers?
@litewhisperer
Blanchard’s assumption that economic orthodoxy has a cohesive technical frontier comparable to medicine’s may itself contribute to the problem he describes. The evidence offers little basis for public confidence in the current mainstream.
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
It takes at least 10 years after high school to get to the frontier of economic research, or to the frontier of medical research.
Except for a few kooks, most people, smartly, do not try to engage and question medical researchers.
Unfortunately, this is not true for economics. Many too many self-appointed experts, including among politicians.
Manuel Bompard
@mbompard
Il est grave que le gouverneur de la banque de France diffuse ainsi de fausses informations.
1) Rien dans les traités européens ne dit ce que la BCE doit faire des titres de dettes des États dont elle dispose. Les mêmes arguments d’illégalité étaient utilisés contre le rachat des titres par la BCE (« quantitative easing »). L’Allemagne a même porté plainte devant la cour de justice de l’Union européenne et elle a été déboutée.
2) Rien ne permet d’accréditer la thèse d’une hausse d’intérêt en raison d’une congélation des titres de dette des États détenus par la BCE. Au contraire. Réduire l’endettement des États, c’est améliorer leur situation. Cela n’a aucun sens de prétendre que cela conduirait à une hausse des taux d’intérêt.
3) Les opérations de rachats de titre de dette par la BCE n’ont pas créé d’inflation. Ce qui risque d’en créer par contre, c’est notre manque d’investissement dans l’adaptation au changement climatique, comme on a pu le voir cet été avec l’impact des événements climatiques sur la production agricole, qui va se traduire par une forte inflation sur les produits alimentaires.
4) Transférer de la dette d’un État vers une dette de la Banque de France n’est pas une opération sans effet. Une banque centrale peut tout à faire continuer à vivre avec un bilan négatif, sans que cela n’ait quelque impact que ce soit sur la poursuite de ses activités.
RTL France
@RTLFrance
Effacer la dette ? La solution de Jean-Luc Mélenchon serait "illégale, dangereuse et inutile" tacle le gouverneur de la Banque de France dans #rtlmatin face @FogielMarcO
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Chinese economists have Marx as their foundation, not Marshall. Plus they observed what the USSR did wrong. Their approach is totally different to neoclassical economics.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Then try reading this mate: profstevekeen.substack.com/p/use-value-and-exchange-the-m…
I gave up talking to Marxists three decades ago, because they are wedded to Marx’s mistakes rather than his genuine advances.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And I can’t be bothered talking with Austrians for the same reason.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
A couple of months ago I also resigned from the Workers Party. I ran the Economics Forum, but despite writing long documents on the modern heterodox economics we need if we are to finance the rebuilding of the British economy, the Political Committee opted to stick with a traditional Marxist approach. Fair enough, different strokes, no hard feelings.
I support @DerbyChrisW's stance regarding his recent resignation. It's straightforward tactical voting to beat the horrendous, terminally compromised Labour Party with a view to forging some degree of unity around the crucial issue of domestic economic policy. Like Chris, I disagree with the Greens' position on a number of issues, especially NATO, but it's the only party with the courage to support the public investment strategies we need to reboot the British economy. I have no intention of joining, but I would like to see a more strategic, unifying approach amongst the broad left.
This link leftcheatsheet.co.uk shows the British left's current situation - split into no less than 78 factional parties and movements. Each one is fixated on its own purist dogma, mostly hammered out in the back room of the local boozer. Completely useless. If the broad left can't find common ground on the crucial issue of domestic economic policy we are finished for the foreseeable future. A spent force. @winlow_s have outlined the history of our decline in the book The Death of the Left.
Failure to bring the economy under democratic control will leave us prey to the extractive asset-stripping and fiscal discipline of global financiers. This will see whole regions sink into further decline and drift to the 'far right', perhaps even seeing through Reform's fake nationalism and demanding the real thing. We might even get a 'revolution', but quite probably not the one we want. This is the future we face if we fail to find unity on this crucial issue.
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
I have tonight resigned from the Workers Party of Britain because I profoundly disagree with the decision to stand in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election. I have a huge amount of respect for George Galloway, but I believe we should get behind Zack Polanski on this occasion. My firm view is that the left must collaborate to defeat the Labour Party, Reform UK, Conservatives and Lib Dems because these parties are all in the pocket of the neoliberal Zionist war machine. Zack is best placed to do that in this by-election.
I commend Zack's recognition that the govt can intervene in the economy to create a good society because it issues the currency. I applaud his position on the so-called war on drugs, which has absolutely failed. I salute his pragmatic and compassionate analysis of illegal immigration. And I commend his assessment of the criminal justice system.
I do have some differences on a small set of issues, most notably their current pro-EU and pro-NATO stances, but my view is that we should agree where we agree, which is on most things, and simply have fraternal disagreements where we don’t. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Right now, City of London secondary-market bond traders are sitting with their feet up on their desks chewing chicken escalope sandwiches in front of their liquidity aggregator, chat log, yield curve and risk monitor screens. They're also pissing themselves laughing as the 78 marginal factions of the British left argue amongst themselves with no understanding of how the global money-market power of traders and moneylenders systematically crushes governments' ability to manage their economies.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Note to commenters. This is just one tactical vote. I'm not suggesting we 'unite around' or 'defect to' the Greens. I said we need to unite the currently factionalised left around a common domestic economic programme informed by a clear understanding how modern government finance works. From what I've said before a hundred times on this platform, such a programme would need to be transposable initially across G10 nations if we are to defeat global money-market discipline. The tech-finance oligarchy is a global force. If we can't unite to defeat it we'll be its insecure servants or conformist zealots for generations.
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
A couple of months ago I also resigned from the Workers Party. I ran the Economics Forum, but despite writing long documents on the modern heterodox economics we need if we are to finance the rebuilding of the British economy, the Political Committee opted to stick with a traditional Marxist approach. Fair enough, different strokes, no hard feelings.
I support @DerbyChrisW's stance regarding his recent resignation. It's straightforward tactical voting to beat the horrendous, terminally compromised Labour Party with a view to forging some degree of unity around the crucial issue of domestic economic policy. Like Chris, I disagree with the Greens' position on a number of issues, especially NATO, but it's the only party with the courage to support the public investment strategies we need to reboot the British economy. I have no intention of joining, but I would like to see a more strategic, unifying approach amongst the broad left.
This link leftcheatsheet.co.uk shows the British left's current situation - split into no less than 78 factional parties and movements. Each one is fixated on its own purist dogma, mostly hammered out in the back room of the local boozer. Completely useless. If the broad left can't find common ground on the crucial issue of domestic economic policy we are finished for the foreseeable future. A spent force. @winlow_s have outlined the history of our decline in the book The Death of the Left.
Failure to bring the economy under democratic control will leave us prey to the extractive asset-stripping and fiscal discipline of global financiers. This will see whole regions sink into further decline and drift to the 'far right', perhaps even seeing through Reform's fake nationalism and demanding the real thing. We might even get a 'revolution', but quite probably not the one we want. This is the future we face if we fail to find unity on this crucial issue.
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
I have tonight resigned from the Workers Party of Britain because I profoundly disagree with the decision to stand in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election. I have a huge amount of respect for George Galloway, but I believe we should get behind Zack Polanski on this occasion. My firm view is that the left must collaborate to defeat the Labour Party, Reform UK, Conservatives and Lib Dems because these parties are all in the pocket of the neoliberal Zionist war machine. Zack is best placed to do that in this by-election.
I commend Zack's recognition that the govt can intervene in the economy to create a good society because it issues the currency. I applaud his position on the so-called war on drugs, which has absolutely failed. I salute his pragmatic and compassionate analysis of illegal immigration. And I commend his assessment of the criminal justice system.
I do have some differences on a small set of issues, most notably their current pro-EU and pro-NATO stances, but my view is that we should agree where we agree, which is on most things, and simply have fraternal disagreements where we don’t. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
Has she lost the very last of her remaining marbles? Ms von der Leyen offered Canada associate membership of the EU. That would have been fine if it were not for a tiny little snag: there is no such thing as associate membership of the EU! www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/09/16/canada-european…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marjorie Taylor Greene 🇺🇸
@mtgreenee
California diesel $8.49 but Georgia is $6.59, both RIDICULOUS!!!
The fuel crisis is only just beginning.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Williamson
@DerbyChrisW
I have tonight resigned from the Workers Party of Britain because I profoundly disagree with the decision to stand in the Holborn and St Pancras by-election. I have a huge amount of respect for George Galloway, but I believe we should get behind Zack Polanski on this occasion. My firm view is that the left must collaborate to defeat the Labour Party, Reform UK, Conservatives and Lib Dems because these parties are all in the pocket of the neoliberal Zionist war machine. Zack is best placed to do that in this by-election.
I commend Zack's recognition that the govt can intervene in the economy to create a good society because it issues the currency. I applaud his position on the so-called war on drugs, which has absolutely failed. I salute his pragmatic and compassionate analysis of illegal immigration. And I commend his assessment of the criminal justice system.
I do have some differences on a small set of issues, most notably their current pro-EU and pro-NATO stances, but my view is that we should agree where we agree, which is on most things, and simply have fraternal disagreements where we don’t. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Quantitative tightening, or QT. What is it? Why has it been a mistake? What should be done about it now? I wrote this infographic. AI created the image.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Billionaires should not be allowed to bankroll Republicans and Democrats. Elections should be about votes, not about dollars.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Dissenter
@TheDissenterYT
Learn about the impact of the Iran war on the global economy in my interview with Dr. Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen). #economics #science
Full interview: youtu.be/BtdhKsj3h4sThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Bitcoin has an accounting problem which suggests it isn’t money www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/09/16/bitcoin-has-an-acc…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
A self-taught keyboard player gets his first chance to play a real piano. His reaction is absolutely priceless.
[📹modestshoppin]This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Quite superb.
Muse
@xmuse_
The shamisen only has three strings, but it’s amazing how versatile it is.
It’s been a huge part of Japanese theater and folk music forever, and watching Masato Shibata play it with so much pure joy is just incredible.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
El Gran Cabron
@SamuraiElf
The magician's real power is not magic its the illusion that he has real power.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Former Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene🇺🇸
@FmrRepMTG
This is exactly what Trump is talking about when he says the Iran war will be over after the midterms.
We did not vote for this.
America does not support this.
Our tax dollars and weapons have been used to kill tens of thousands of innocent people.
My God, what comes next?
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
According to an informed federal official, in the coming months the Trump administration plans to send a total of 40,000 Mark 84 and Blu-117 bombs to the government of Israel. Each bomb weighs 2,000 pounds. This appears to be the largest transfer of conventional explosive ordnance from the United States in modern history.
How big is this shipment? It amounts to 40,000 tons of bombs. For perspective, the largest American air raid of World War Two was the Eighth Air Force’s attack on Berlin in March of 1945. Combined, the 2,023 Allied aircraft involved dropped about 3,000 tons of bombs. That’s 7.5 percent of what Trump is sending to Israel. That same month, March of 1945, the US Army Air Forces began the single most destructive bombing raid in human history, Operation Meetinghouse over Tokyo. More than 100,000 Japanese civilians were killed. By the end of that operation, the US had dropped 1,600 tons of bombs. That’s four percent of what Trump is sending to Israel. World War Two ended five months later, when the US dropped an atomic bomb on the city of Hiroshima. The shipment Trump is sending to Israel amounts to more than three times the destructive power of that nuclear explosion. There is no precedent for what the Trump administration is doing.
Nor is there a justification. The government of Israel is not fighting World War Two, or even a war. It is engaged in periodic skirmishes with a guerrilla force in Lebanon, and it is working to exterminate an unarmed civilian population in Gaza. Neither front requires modern 2,000-pound bombs.
An American-made Mark 84 has a destruction radius of half a mile. It releases a thermal wave the temperature of the surface of the sun. Within 100 feet of the explosion, rock melts and human flesh turns to vapor. The bomb collapses apartment buildings and leaves craters thirty-five feet deep. Until the war with Iran, the US military generally avoided using the Mark 84 in urban areas. It kills too many civilians.
For the Netanyahu government, that’s been the upside. In the weeks after October 7, the IDF dropped nearly six hundred 2,000-pound bombs on densely populated areas in Gaza, including on more than 100 officially designated civilian evacuation zones. The slaughter was so grotesque and embarrassing that for a moment the Biden administration paused a shipment of Mark 84s. Those shipments quickly resumed under Trump. Now they’ve accelerated.
It’s hard to overstate the scale of the crime the Israeli government is committing in Gaza. Over the last three years, more than a quarter-million Palestinians have been killed or wounded by Israeli forces there. The majority of them have been noncombatants: women, the elderly and tens of thousands of children. Many thousands more remain missing, presumably entombed under the rubble of 200,000 collapsed buildings. So far the Israelis have destroyed 92 percent of all homes in Gaza, and 34 of the 36 hospitals. By comparison, the 1945 Allied bombings of Dresden, now acknowledged as a war crime, destroyed about half of the city’s inhabited buildings.
By any definition, what the Netanyahu government has done in Gaza is genocide. The 40,000 new bombs the Trump administration is sending will be used to do the same in Lebanon, and likely in other countries in the region. If you wanted to extend the Iran war into the indefinite future, this is exactly what you’d do.
So far none of this has received public scrutiny. At some point, inevitably, it will be described in media accounts as an “arms sale.” It is not an arms sale. It is a gift, funded by American taxpayers through the Foreign Military Financing program, an arrangement designed to disguise welfare as capitalism: Congress appropriates money to the executive branch, which transfers the cash to Israel to “buy” American-made weapons, in this case from General Dynamics. Politicians claim this is a win for America. Most voters have no idea they paid for it. The bill in this case is about $3 billion. Add that to the $352 billion the US Treasury has transferred to Israel since 1951.
How did this happen? The request for 40,000 new high-explosive civilian-killing bombs originated at the US Embassy in Jerusalem, which is run by Christian Zionist Ambassador Mike Huckabee and his aide David Milstein, who is the stepson of Fox News host Mark Levin. From there it moved to the State Department, where Marco Rubio enthusiastically approved it.
At this point, only four more people need to sign off before the bombs ship to Israel: Senators Jim Risch and Jeanne Shaheen, the chairman and ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee; and Congressmen Brian Mast and Gregory Meeks, the top two members of the equivalent House committee. All four are committed neocons. Collectively they’ve taken millions from the Israel lobby. In 2015, Brian Mast traveled to Israel to volunteer for the Israeli military. In 2023, Mast showed up in the House of Representatives wearing an IDF uniform.
It’s hard to imagine any of them hesitating before sending more free bombs to Israel. Only public outrage can stop this. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
4 Billion Dead
@4billiondead
"SOCIETAL AND ECONOMIC BREAKDOWN ANYWHERE FROM THE 2040S."
Listen to this clip of @ProfBillMcGuire speaking on @novaramedia's Downstream. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
According to an informed federal official, in the coming months the Trump administration plans to send a total of 40,000 Mark 84 and Blu-117 bombs to the government of Israel. Each bomb weighs 2,000 pounds. This appears to be the largest transfer of conventional explosive ordnance from the United States in modern history.
How big is this shipment? It amounts to 40,000 tons of bombs. For perspective, the largest American air raid of World War Two was the Eighth Air Force’s attack on Berlin in March of 1945. Combined, the 2,023 Allied aircraft involved dropped about 3,000 tons of bombs. That’s 7.5 percent of what Trump is sending to Israel. That same month, March of 1945, the US Army Air Forces began the single most destructive bombing raid in human history, Operation Meetinghouse over Tokyo. More than 100,000 Japanese civilians were killed. By the end of that operation, the US had dropped 1,600 tons of bombs. That’s four percent of what Trump is sending to Israel. World War Two ended five months later, when the US dropped an atomic bomb on the city of Hiroshima. The shipment Trump is sending to Israel amounts to more than three times the destructive power of that nuclear explosion. There is no precedent for what the Trump administration is doing.
Nor is there a justification. The government of Israel is not fighting World War Two, or even a war. It is engaged in periodic skirmishes with a guerrilla force in Lebanon, and it is working to exterminate an unarmed civilian population in Gaza. Neither front requires modern 2,000-pound bombs.
An American-made Mark 84 has a destruction radius of half a mile. It releases a thermal wave the temperature of the surface of the sun. Within 100 feet of the explosion, rock melts and human flesh turns to vapor. The bomb collapses apartment buildings and leaves craters thirty-five feet deep. Until the war with Iran, the US military generally avoided using the Mark 84 in urban areas. It kills too many civilians.
For the Netanyahu government, that’s been the upside. In the weeks after October 7, the IDF dropped nearly six hundred 2,000-pound bombs on densely populated areas in Gaza, including on more than 100 officially designated civilian evacuation zones. The slaughter was so grotesque and embarrassing that for a moment the Biden administration paused a shipment of Mark 84s. Those shipments quickly resumed under Trump. Now they’ve accelerated.
It’s hard to overstate the scale of the crime the Israeli government is committing in Gaza. Over the last three years, more than a quarter-million Palestinians have been killed or wounded by Israeli forces there. The majority of them have been noncombatants: women, the elderly and tens of thousands of children. Many thousands more remain missing, presumably entombed under the rubble of 200,000 collapsed buildings. So far the Israelis have destroyed 92 percent of all homes in Gaza, and 34 of the 36 hospitals. By comparison, the 1945 Allied bombings of Dresden, now acknowledged as a war crime, destroyed about half of the city’s inhabited buildings.
By any definition, what the Netanyahu government has done in Gaza is genocide. The 40,000 new bombs the Trump administration is sending will be used to do the same in Lebanon, and likely in other countries in the region. If you wanted to extend the Iran war into the indefinite future, this is exactly what you’d do.
So far none of this has received public scrutiny. At some point, inevitably, it will be described in media accounts as an “arms sale.” It is not an arms sale. It is a gift, funded by American taxpayers through the Foreign Military Financing program, an arrangement designed to disguise welfare as capitalism: Congress appropriates money to the executive branch, which transfers the cash to Israel to “buy” American-made weapons, in this case from General Dynamics. Politicians claim this is a win for America. Most voters have no idea they paid for it. The bill in this case is about $3 billion. Add that to the $352 billion the US Treasury has transferred to Israel since 1951.
How did this happen? The request for 40,000 new high-explosive civilian-killing bombs originated at the US Embassy in Jerusalem, which is run by Christian Zionist Ambassador Mike Huckabee and his aide David Milstein, who is the stepson of Fox News host Mark Levin. From there it moved to the State Department, where Marco Rubio enthusiastically approved it.
At this point, only four more people need to sign off before the bombs ship to Israel: Senators Jim Risch and Jeanne Shaheen, the chairman and ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee; and Congressmen Brian Mast and Gregory Meeks, the top two members of the equivalent House committee. All four are committed neocons. Collectively they’ve taken millions from the Israel lobby. In 2015, Brian Mast traveled to Israel to volunteer for the Israeli military. In 2023, Mast showed up in the House of Representatives wearing an IDF uniform.
It’s hard to imagine any of them hesitating before sending more free bombs to Israel. Only public outrage can stop this. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
"Governments are locked into a debt cycle ... nothing ever gets paid back. When the debt comes due they roll it into new debt, and the interest gets paid with more borrowing. One credit card paying off the other."
🦉 whispers: it is not debt if only you can create $. #learnmmt
Raoul Pal
@RaoulGMI
The whole economy is essentially running on one giant credit card.
Governments are locked into a debt cycle they cant get out of... nothing ever gets paid back. When the debt comes due they roll it into new debt, and the interest gets paid with more borrowing. One credit card paying off the other.
The only real way out is growth. But you cant grow when your population is shrinking. Fewer working people means less growth, so GDP never rises fast enough to catch up with the debt.
So how does the bill get paid? Liquidity. Nobody in the system is allowed to default, so the debt is funded by debasing the currency.
This is my Everything Code framework. The debt can't stop, so the debasement can't stop either, and every asset price is downstream of that. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Our species needs, and deserves, a citizenry with minds wide awake and a basic understanding of how the world works.”
— Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
1. "A number of analyses have suggested societal and economic breakdown anytime from the 2040's" @ProfBillMcGuire
4 Billion Dead
@4billiondead
"SOCIETAL AND ECONOMIC BREAKDOWN ANYWHERE FROM THE 2040S."
Listen to this clip of @ProfBillMcGuire speaking on @novaramedia's Downstream. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
What if the problem with our economy isn’t all the market failures, but the theory that keeps producing them?
@MazzucatoM challenges the idea that progressive policy can fix the economy without rethinking the economics underneath it.
🎧 ➡️ pod.link/pitchforkeconomics/episode/YWQ5N2NjZTQtYjExZS0xM… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
European dependence on American LNG is now close to complete, with Saudi Arabian oil and Russian gas largely gone. For all the talk of #geopolitics, the outcome is devastating for European citizens, who will ultimately pay the price at the pump and in their heating bills.
The Hormuz Letter
@HormuzLetter
BREAKING: Saudi Arabia has informed its European customers that late-September crude oil cargoes will be cancelled, due to the East-West pipeline being shut after last week's attacks and Yemen's Houthis taking over the entire Red Sea coast, per three sources to Reuters.
Yanbu had five to seven days of crude stocks left for export when the East-West line went down, per industry sources on Saturday, and cancelling late-September cargoes means Riyadh does not expect the line back before they run out. Europe has been taking Saudi crude through Yanbu because Hormuz has been closed since spring. On top of the pipeline, the Houthis appear to have struck the YASREF refinery at that same port this morning. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
I posted this late yesterday.
stephaniekelton.substack.com/p/brer-rabbit-and-ai-extinct… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Night Sky Now
@NightSkyNow
🚨 WHAT IF THE MOST DANGEROUS STAGE OF A CIVILIZATION IS BECOMING INTELLIGENT?
Somewhere in the Milky Way, there may have been civilizations far older than ours.
They may have built incredible machines, explored their planets, harnessed enormous amounts of energy, and looked toward the stars wondering the same thing we do: Is anyone else out there?
And then… silence.
Physicist Brian Cox has discussed a disturbing possibility: perhaps advanced civilizations eventually reach a point where their technology becomes more powerful than their ability to control it.
Think about how strange that is. Intelligence allows a species to discover nuclear energy, engineer viruses, transform the climate, build artificial intelligence, and develop technologies capable of changing the entire planet. But becoming technologically powerful does not automatically make a civilization wiser, more peaceful, or better at working together.
That could help explain one of the biggest mysteries in astronomy: the Fermi paradox.
The Milky Way is more than 13 billion years old, with hundreds of billions of stars. If intelligent life has appeared elsewhere many times, why haven’t we found clear evidence of another technological civilization?
Maybe the universe is not empty.
Maybe civilizations simply don’t last very long.
A civilization could survive for 10,000 years, 100,000 years, or even a million years and still be almost nothing more than a moment on the cosmic clock. If civilizations repeatedly rise and disappear, two of them might rarely exist at the same time. One could vanish millions of years before another begins broadcasting.
This leads to an even darker idea known as the Great Filter.
Somewhere between the first appearance of life and the emergence of a civilization capable of surviving for millions of years, there may be a nearly impossible obstacle. Perhaps creating complex life is extremely rare. Perhaps intelligent life is rare. Perhaps technological civilizations repeatedly destroy themselves before they become truly spacefaring.
And that leaves us with a haunting question.
Where is the Great Filter?
Could humanity have already passed it?
Or is the most difficult test still ahead of us?
We don’t know.
But there is another way to look at the mystery. The fact that we exist at all may be incredibly precious. We are a young technological civilization living during a tiny window of cosmic history, with the ability to shape what happens next.
Perhaps the silence of the universe isn’t a warning that we are doomed.
Perhaps it is a reminder that survival is not guaranteed — and that reaching the stars may require something more than intelligence.
It may require wisdom.
Source: Brian Cox, Human Universe (2014); the Fermi paradox and Great Filter hypotheses. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Dissenter
@TheDissenterYT
Learn about the risks associated with climate change, with a focus on economic collapse and existential risk, in my interview with Dr. Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen). #economics #climate #science
Full interview: youtu.be/BtdhKsj3h4s -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tomthunkit™
@TomthunkitsMind
MBS IS THE MASTER OF HIS OWN DEMISE. HE ASKED ISRAEL FOR HELP AGAINST MUSLIMS. HE JUST TURNED 2 BILLION PEOPLE AGAINST HIM AND MADE ANSAR ALLAH EVEN MORE POPULAR.
MBS IS TRYING TO BORROW $72 BILLION FROM THE WORLD BANK. HE’S ALSO SELLING SHARES IN ARAMCO AND OTHER ASSETS. HE CAN NO LONGER AFFORD TO PAY HIS HIRED ARMY OR BRIBE YEMENI TRIBESMEN.
Saudi Arabia is a desert with daily triple digit temperatures. They import 90% of their food. The Houthis have a total blockade on Saudi. MBS DAYS ARE NUMBERED.
Subsequently, the whole world is on the verge of a devastating famine.
The Strait of Hormuz is shut down. A VLCC tanker hit a sea mine today trying to sneak through and is on fire. Insurers will refuse to risk future voyages.
Bab el-Mandeb is shut down to Saudi, US, and Israeli ships. The East-West Pipeline has been taken offline for months until after the war. Yanbu Oil Terminal, the main port has also been bombed repeatedly.
The whole world uses about 100 million barrels of oil a day.
Even losing 10–15 million barrels a day for several months will end up starving millions of people.
The diesel shortages around the world will lead to countries being forced to implement DEMAND DESTRUCTION MEASURES. Like mandating that only essential workers are allowed out. Everyone else will have to work remotely, like COVID.
Crude oil can be refined to become gasoline or diesel and jet fuel. But not both. Ukraine has destroyed many Russian diesel plants so now Russia is importing it. China also has resumed oil imports too.
Farmers are about to get slammed with rising production, transportation and operating costs. Consequently, tractors, irrigation pumps, harvesting machines, trucks, and everything would gradually begin to stop worldwide.
This will most likely cause brutal shortages of wheat, rice, fertilizer and cooking oil.
There's no way nitrogen fertilizer can be exported now until next year. The IEA says the SOH will remain closed until 2027.
50% of world’s Sulfur comes through the SOH. Sulfur is used to make Copper and Nickel. Around 5 million to 5.5 million metric tons of primary aluminum pass through annually.
Gulf countries were supposed to have a meeting with Iran about this catastrophe. That meeting has been cancelled. Most likely MBS’ boss told him not to go.
Now, MBS is in talks with Israel about bombing Yemen to fix this disaster. The second biggest mistake of his life. Bombing the Sanaa airport for a photo-op for his boss was the first.
There is no short term or military solution to this.
The world is heading towards a humanitarian catastrophe.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
stay tuned for my new report 'Against Bond Vigilantes' -
mapping the extraordinary set of policy choices/ institutional arrangements that are constraining the UK government.
the first priority: curtail the Bank of England's illegitimate fiscal powers
www.theguardian.com/business/2026/sep/15/bank-of-england-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
time's carcass
@sans_solei1
"In fact, Marxist economists understood Marxism as essentially the economics of capitalism, while neoclassical economics was the economics of socialism"
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
"Unless we understand what it is that leads to economic and financial instability, we cannot prescribe policy to modify or eliminate it."
-Hyman Minsky
This quote really sums up why I am interested in modeling the economy in the first place. I don't just want a model that tells me where the economy should end up. I want to understand how it actually gets there, and more importantly, how things can go wrong along the way.
A lot of how I think about this comes from my friend and mentor Steve Keen. Steve has pushed me to think about private credit and debt as things that actually drive the economy, rather than numbers we can push off to the side. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
JeSuisCH🏒BleuBlancRouge
@HabsHappy
Here is Trump kissing Natalie Harp both Original and AI Enhanced side-by-side. I'm just wondering what first lady Melania and son Barron are thinking right now
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
A political system corrupted by economic elites is also a failed economic system.
Law professor @lessig quotes the study: “The preferences of the average American appear to have only a minuscule, near-zero, statistically insignificant impact on public policy.” Read the paper:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brett Erickson
@BrettErickson28
The single most dangerous risk for the United States right now is a mass casualty event that would give the Israeli Lobby and Iran Hawks the ammunition to push Trump to employ insane measures against Iran.
If the blockade works, as we have seen over the past week, economic and energy infrastructure will be destroyed… and we lose.
If the blockade fails… we lose.
When the unavoidable reality is America being forced to end this war without accomplishing Washington’s ultimate goal of regime change, it is the RESPONSIBLE decision to derisk from the extreme tail events like an American mass casualty event.
This is the exact thesis of my recent op-ed in The Hill on Thursday, and the destruction of the Saudi East-West Pipeline makes this reality unavoidable.
There’s no way to accomplish all of America’s goals in the Iran War, but there ARE catastrophic risks of continuing the war.
Remove the troops. Call off the blockade. Avoid disaster.
Joe Kent
@joekent16jan19
President Trump is demonstrating that he clearly knows the path to end the Military Conflict with Iran. Here he lays out the winning formula: end the conflict and oil prices will quickly drop.
All that’s left for him to him to do is execute—he should do it now, before the midterms.
To do so effectively, he must pull our troops & ships out of the region so Iran can’t disrupt his strategy with escalatory strikes that restart the war.
The President can emphasize his wins: he ensured Iran won’t get a nuclear weapon via Operation Midnight Hammer & he ended our outdated military basing requirements via the major withdrawals from the region, which is great for American taxpayers, & now we have the bandwidth to refocus on domestic issues, especially our border and the “Donroe Doctrine.”
Once our troops and assets are our of harm’s way and Iran doesn’t have the option to strike, negotiate using the carrots of unfreezing assets & sanctions relief to get the oil flowing again.
Call Iran a win now, pull our troops out, and don’t let Iran suck you back in. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John Harvey
@John_T_Harvey
Many thanks to Steve Grumbine and friends for interviewing me regarding my newest volume. I'd post a link to the book (with a discount code), but Cambridge is in the middle of updating their site. Will do later! Meanwhile, here is the interview:
realprogressives.substack.com/p/episode-396-recession-by-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Dissenter
@TheDissenterYT
New episode (1306), with Dr. Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen). We talk about the existential risk of climate change from the perspective of economics, and the war in Iran. #economics #science
YouTube: youtu.be/BtdhKsj3h4s
Podcast: open.spotify.com/episode/53ZUKMHqBJRk1PQWB8lLYC -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
thefedexpress
@thefedexpresss
Few things, firstly, I heavily overestimated Shelton and what he can bring.. this matchup is awful for him as he doesn’t have the rally tolerance or the proper consistent weapons to hurt Zverev. He also makes so many easy errors from just normal rally shots, it’s hard to believe he can make a slam final while being so erratic.. just shows the era we are in
Secondly, Zverev was much more calm and composed in this final, as opposed to his first slam final.. and I underestimated the experience he had.
Expected a lot more from Shelton tho, just shows he’s not at that level.. I personally didn’t think he was great, but I expected Zverev to tighten up a bit more which would give Shelton chances.
I was wrong
thefedexpress
@thefedexpresss
US Open Final thoughts:
I’ve seen a lot of people pencil Zverev in to win this because of the 5-0 h2h vs Shelton, the fact he’s already won a slam so he got that monkey of his back, and the fact he’s the “better player”, all valid reasons, but I personally don’t think Zverev is playing good, like at all.
Shelton has a lot of confidence coming in, he’s serving great; returning much better than usual and has the home fans behind him.
Shelton also has that inner belief and confidence to not let the moment get to big for him, Infront of the home fans who will be 100% for Shelton, I just think he will rise to the occasion, he’s one of the very few guys who I don’t worry about in these big matches because of that. On the other side, Zverev will play his usual defensive game, and do you trust his forehand to come through? Because I don’t.. I’ve seen it way to many times fault in big moments, we saw it at the French Open final, he went 5 sets with Cobolli, mainly because he was so passive and nervous and afraid to make errors, and of course that’ll only benefit Shelton the longer the match goes..
If Shelton can play even just a B level match, he will beat Zverev in 5 sets.
What does everyone think? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Lots of us have been trying to warn about this for the last 20 years.
We’ve been treated like lunatics and extremists and lots of protesters have been put in prison. We’re now reaching a point where consequences are occurring. You can’t say we didn’t warn you. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
2. The 4 Billion Dead September International Public Call
Monday 21 September, 7pm, BST
Sign up here:
actionnetwork.org/events/the-4-billion-dead-september-int… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
BlueBriefing🎬🍿
@Uzonna7
Trading Places is the most accurate documentary ever made about how rich people view the rest of us.
Two old white guys literally bet a dollar on whether a Black man from the streets or a privileged white guy is “naturally” superior… and the entire system is just a game to them.
Synopsis:
Imagine two billionaire brothers so bored they bet on whether they can turn a successful white man into a criminal and a Black street hustler into a success… just for fun.
Then the two guys they destroyed team up and destroy them instead. That’s the entire plot of Trading Places and it’s still undefeated.
🎬📺 Trading Places⭐⭐⭐🔥😂This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Solange die EZB als "Dealer of Last Resort" agiert, wird den nationalen Regierungen das Geld nicht ausgehen. Die Idee, dass der Anleihenmarkt "regiert", ist neoliberale Propaganda und keine Beschreibung des Geldsystems. (Corona-Milliarden schon vergessen?)
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10273-021-2874-9 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Normal Island News
@NormalIslandNws
Keir Starmer has explained that when he promised he wouldn't hand out resignation honours if he became prime minister, he unfortunately lied again
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marty
@ethicalmartini
Yeah it was @vic_socialists MEAA members who pushed it despite strong opposition from some officials.
For my efforts I was undemocratically removed from the freelancers’ rank and file organising committee without explanation,
I’ve been in the @withMEAA for over 40 years.
💧Mary Kostakidis
@MaryKostakidis
Enormously thanks to Dr Martin Hirst who forced my matter onto the agenda during the largest meeting ever of MEAA Freelancers, where there was not a single vote against supporting me. Not that anyone would know because the result appeared in no minutes nor newsletter.
My thanks to @MEAA and its rank and file members for your support despite attempts to prevent it. Thank you also to all independent journalists and publishers for your unfailing support over the last couple of years.
Marty
@ethicalmartini
Our rank and file efforts got the waiverers over the line
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marius Kjærstad (marius.eth) 🐬🦇🔊
@MKjrstad
Can't print oil🛢️
The scenario in the post below is delayed due to reserves of oil, but make no mistake, it will come to fruition if we hit the bottom of stored barrels.
5.4% hit to global GDP so far, assuming we had no reserves at the start of the war👇
Marius Kjærstad (marius.eth) 🐬🦇🔊
@MKjrstad
Steve Keen (@ProfSteveKeen) explains why we will see a 10% hit to global GDP if the Strait of Hormuz stays closed.
U.S. GDP printed -8.9% in 1930 due to the Great Depression, but rest of the world was less hit.
A 10% hit to global GDP would be unprecedented in human history⚠️ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
💧Mary Kostakidis
@MaryKostakidis
Enormously thanks to Dr Martin Hirst who forced my matter onto the agenda during the largest meeting ever of MEAA Freelancers, where there was not a single vote against supporting me. Not that anyone would know because the result appeared in no minutes nor newsletter.
My thanks to @MEAA and its rank and file members for your support despite attempts to prevent it. Thank you also to all independent journalists and publishers for your unfailing support over the last couple of years.
Marty
@ethicalmartini
Our rank and file efforts got the waiverers over the line
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Agreed. Extremely well done and researched video.
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Brilliantly communicated 30 min video on rare earths that everybody on earth should watch
youtu.be/BXLGV0Sj0n8 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
God, grant me the serenity to exercise my bounded rationality freely in the systems that are structured appropriately, the courage to restructure the systems that aren't, and the wisdom to know the difference!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Grace Hall
@Randaroo1212
The face of a weak, pathetic man who just got his ass handed to him by a woman.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ModernMoneyLab_EU
@mml_europe
Euro member states can create euros. Their national central banks do it every day on behalf of governments. The ECB backstops member-state debt on the secondary market. The binding constraint is politics, not monetary capacity.
#mmt #economics #eu -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Economics and empathy are words not often seen together. They should be. I wrote this infographic. AI created the image.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Why economics needs empathy: the latest in my series on understanding economics youtu.be/wMxXAgzmMH0
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good one!
IrishgirlinUS
@IrishgirlinUS
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thank you! I've been looking for this one for ages
Aria Radnia 🇮🇷
@ariaradnia
Arguably the greatest investing meme ever made
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Saudi collaborated in a 2025 decapitation strike that killed almost all the Ansarullah leadership.
Less than a year later Saudi is pumping zero oil to the world.
Is it possible to connect cause and effect?
DD Geopolitics
@DD_Geopolitics
🇾🇪 On Thursday, Israeli airstrikes struck Sana’a, killing much of Yemen’s civilian government.
Among the martyrs:
— Prime Minister Ahmad al-Rahwi
— Minister of Social Affairs Samir Baj‘alah
— Minister of Agriculture Ridwan al-Ruba‘i
— Minister of Economy Mu‘in al-Mahaqiri
— Minister of Justice Mujahid Ahmad
— Minister of Information Hashim Sharaf al-Din
— Minister of Foreign Affairs Jamal Ahmad
— Deputy FM Abdul Majid Murtada
— Minister of Education Hassan al-Sa‘idi
This was a decapitation strike on Yemen’s political leadership, carried out by a nuclear-armed state under U.S. protection.
The world would end before Yemen would break. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daithí Mac Cathmhaoil
@DrDaveCampbell
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sam
@samwisehawkins
Medicine is backed by clinical evidence.
Neoclassical economics is ideology masquerading as science: a huge wobbling tower of pseudo-science built on assumptions of sand.
The only people who make it through 10 years to get to the frontier are the ones unwilling to question it. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
fiat money
@fiat_money
Why are mainstreamers always wrong?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
The idea that a depression-ravaged population had to lend money to the govt so we could build tanks is absurd. The govt created the money, built the factories & mobilized real resources.
#depression #resources #learnmmt
realprogressives.org/mnc-podcast-ep/episode-396-recession… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"And don't come back!" 😂
Barry Malone
@malonebarry
I tell you what’s interesting about this photo. It was posted on the official Irish presidency Instagram. They chose to put this out there.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Unfortunately Engineers and Physicists are too polite and stay out of the weeds.
"I sometimes think the general public would know more about economics if the economists did not exist"
- Francis Cripps -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I took a chaotic dynamic system and added a microfoundation to maximize the pendulums hanging utility and find an optimal equilibrium...
I will now submit these findings to a prestigious Neoclassical/New Keynesian journal and accept my Nobe Prize. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
?whispers?
@litewhisperer
Scepticism toward economics should not be dismissed as ignorance, it reflects a reasonable response to a field where self-correction is demonstrably weaker than medicine’s.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
Drawing on his book US Business Cycles 1954–2020, John T. Harvey addresses a central contradiction: we have the money, resources, and economic tools to provide full employment and meet society’s needs, yet the structure of capitalism stands in the way.
New Episode! 396 – Recession by Design: Who Pays for the Business Cycle? with John T. Harvey.
LInk in comments below. 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X
@Xking332
The whole world is on the verge of a devastating famine.
The Strait of Hormuz is shut down. Bab el Mandeb is shut down. The East West Pipeline has been bombed.
And now.
Yanbu Oil Terminal has also been bombed.
The whole world uses about 100 million barrels of oil a day.
Even losing 10–15 million barrels a day for several months will end up starving millions of people.
Soon diesel prices could get out of control.
Then,
Tractors, irrigation pumps, harvesting machines, trucks, everything would stop.
Then most likely there will be brutal shortages of wheat, rice, fertilizer and cooking oil.
There's no way nitrogen fertilizer can be exported now.
Farmers are most likely going to be wiped out in the coming months.
Gulf countries were supposed to have a meeting with Iran about this catastrophe.
That meeting is also cancelled.
Most likely because America intervened.
Now Saudi is in talks with Israel about bombing Yemen to fix this disaster.
There is no short term solution to this.
The world is heading towards a humanitarian catastrophe. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
New! Episode 396 – Recession by Design: Who Pays for the Business Cycle? with John T. Harvey
Link to our FREE #substack in comments below 👇
#capitalism #cancer #mmt -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Malcolm Reavell
@malcolm_reavell
1/18 There are many activists like myself trying to change the economic narrative. But there is hope. Here are some influential media, political, & economic commentators whose individual efforts are helping to replace the cancerous narrative of "taxpayer's money"👇🧵
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
#IStandWithLorenzo
@limuzinaxd
Remember when they used to play the slam finals like this? Take me back to the good old days 🔥
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"And don't come back!" 😂
Barry Malone
@malonebarry
I tell you what’s interesting about this photo. It was posted on the official Irish presidency Instagram. They chose to put this out there.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
Who the FUCK is in charge of dealing with people like this?
I’m fucking sick of it. I report them. I report them again. I report them over and over, and they’re still here, still abusing people, still allowed to carry on like there are absolutely no consequences.
What the fuck are you actually doing with these reports?
If someone repeatedly breaks the rules and keeps targeting people, remove the fucking account.
Enough is fucking enough. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good one!
IrishgirlinUS
@IrishgirlinUS
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
How are unemployment, inequality, #oligarchy and recurring crises outcomes generated by capitalism? Join us Tues. 9/15 @ 8 pm ET for Macro n Chill to listen to and discuss our latest ep. ft. @John_T_Harvey! #classwar
Register: us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/jBqKoQB6RtOjQPE8cW17ew -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tennis Legend
@TennisLegende
Pas sûr que Sinner et Alcaraz jouent plus vite que ça. 😅
Un point mythique à une cadence folle entre Roger Federer et Nikolay Davydenko où Roger frappe de plus en plus fort.
📍Demi-finales de l'US Open 2006This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gramps
@GrandpaHarris65
Climate change doesn’t need you to “believe” in it.
Gravity doesn’t care either.
Science is annoyingly indifferent to your stupid fucking opinion. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
«I believe that scientific knowledge has fractal properties, that no matter how much we learn, whatever is left, however small it may seem, is just as infinitely complex as the whole was to start with»
— Isaac Asimov (I Asimov, 1995) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Chinese economists have Marx as their foundation, not Marshall. Plus they observed what the USSR did wrong. Their approach is totally different to neoclassical economics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And those departments need to teach system dynamics as well. Too many "political economy" oriented courses disavow mathematics because they blame it for Neoclassical economics's state and dominance. In fact mathematics & system dynamics contradict Neoclassical beliefs.
Warwick Smith
@RecoEco
How does the neoclassical and new Keynesian thinking persist? I have a friend who did a phd on the inability of mainstream economics profession to adapt to evidence and concluded academic economics was unfixable. Instead we need to build departments of political economy
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter Davies
@MastermanDavies
“And what sort of lives do these people, who pose as being moral, lead themselves?
My dear fellow, you forget that we are in the native land of the hypocrite.”
Oscar Wilde, The Picture of Dorian Gray (1890).
kwize.com/quote/8771 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
DouglasDowell
@DouglasDowellJD
What did mainstream economics learn from the GFC? How did the models change after that?
largely nothing and nothing changed.
If you intuitively know something is wrong...if you're prepared for something different, follow @ProfSteveKeen and @GDPDynamics. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roland B. Hedley Jr.
@RealRBHJr
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Art Berman
@aeberman12
Zero carbon emissions will make less difference than many people assume, @oskaenergy14
I’m not saying we shouldn’t reduce emissions.
But the harder truth is that atmospheric CO₂ is already so elevated, and the carbon cycle so slow, that meaningful drawdown will take generations to centuries even under aggressive mitigation.
That's reality
Adaptation should be Plan A. Emissions reduction--Plan B
#climate #climatechange #co2 #adaptation #mitigation #energy #resilience #carbonemissions #overshoot
👇
www.artberman.com/blog/the-long-way-home-carbon-climate-a… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
Think #ww2 bond drives paid for the war? Wrong. War #bonds were about controlling #inflation - @John_T_Harvey “the Cowboy Economist” explains.
Link to full Macro N Cheese episode in comment below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Professor Michael Hudson and I are doing another dialogue this week. Lots to discuss. Many moving parts.
davidgraeber.institute/the-economy-at-the-end-of-the-worl…
Camilo Rodríguez 🇵🇸
@CamiloGuezRodri
Michael Hudson: Debts That Cannot Be Paid Won’t Be
www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/06/michael-hudson-debts-that… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Peter💚🤍💜 🏴 🇳🇿
@WingsEcosse
An important distinction from @ProfSteveKeen's Debunking Economics:
'When debt is undertaken for investment or consumption it tends not to get out of hand. But when borrowing is undertaken to speculate on asset prices, debt tends to grow more rapidly than income. This growth causes a false boom while it is happening, but results in a collapse.' -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
@ojblanchard1 Olivier this guy is not a “kook”.
He’s doing brilliant economics which, for a high profile economist, is deserving of your attention.
Get your head out of your arse, watch, listen and learn man!
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Consequently, macroeconomic research must hold all competing theories to a symmetric burden of proof: neither demand-pull models nor upstream-cost hypotheses deserve causal status merely through correlation.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Center of The Maze💭
@Maze_s_Center
Path-dependence, meta- or instability and non-ergodicity are core in heterodox economics, while in mainstream (neoclassical) economics it's just frictions or shocks.
Economics would do well to incorporate these insights instead of dismissing them like they usually do.
Kenneth Stanley
@kenneth0stanley
There’s something really interesting about the field of mathematics coming to the insight that the path is more important than the destination, which is clearly related to the insight that Fractured Entangled Representation (FER) in neural networks results from taking a bad path to a high-performing destination. Massively scaled AI is teaching us something deep about the importance of the path you take as opposed to the place you end up. This theme will be increasingly powerful as it washes over every field.
Thomas Wolf
@Thom_Wolf
Some notes from the Fields Medal letter today (mathandai.org)
Generally saying that AI models riffling through solving these problems gives 1 bit of signal while killing the 99 other bits of conceptual understanding that mathematicians would have extracted from fighting with these problems -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Art Berman
@aeberman12
There is no absolute decoupling of material throughput
Global GDP remains tightly coupled to material use -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Angelo Giuliano 🇨🇭🇮🇹
@angeloinchina
Facts over narratives.
China and America don’t fail the same tests. They don’t even sit the same exam.
One system treats housing, basic healthcare, simple taxes, street vendors, and high-speed rail as first-order problems. The other treats them as afterthoughts while running a $895B defense budget and 542 prisoners per 100,000 people.
No nationwide annual property tax vs a bill every year even after the mortgage is gone. 95% basic medical coverage vs medical debt in two-thirds of bankruptcies. 119 sentenced prisoners per 100,000 vs more than 3× that. $505B in transport infrastructure vs lectures about “debt traps.”
Different models. Different outputs. The numbers are not a vibe.
Full piece: angelogiuliano.substack.com/p/facts-over-narratives-china…
Look at the facts. Think for yourself. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter Gregor
@GregorPepe
Exactly.
Not just economics — many scientific disciplines still cling to static models from the past and refuse the simple fact that everything in the universe is dynamic and constantly evolving. Equilibrium is the exception, not the rule.
These “scholars” are often just lazy: it’s more comfortable to defend old paradigms, careers, and textbooks than to learn system dynamics and complex systems.
That’s why mathematics that reveals instability and feedback loops isn’t a tool for them — it’s a threat. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Doonesbury by Garry Trudeau for September 13, 2026 production.doonesbury.com/doonesbury/strip/archive/2026/0… via @GoComics. "No lying, you said"; "Idiot! That's not the same thing as telling him the truth!"
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tony Newnham
@NewnhamTony
China progressed economically by using trial & error, not one single school of economics. They’ve work to do domestically but the whole world can see heterdox economic thinking is out performing neoclassical economic thinking in China.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
We thought we were being clever we all remember it .
Ship the ugly work overseas, keep design and finance at home, and call the cheaper economy efficiency . For a long time it looked like one.
It was a 21 st century tulip mania field by economic morons who inhabited the central banks
The problem is the step after the mine. Chile and the Congo can pull copper out of the ground all day.
If the concentrate has to go to someone else’s refinery, they decide when it comes back as metal you can actually use.
Same story with magnets, foil, and the sulphuric acid that copper leach pads run on.
Miss a shipment and a mine has a bad year. Nobody fires a shot the west loses the war it didn’t know it was fighting .
From finding ore to pouring metal runs the better part of two decades, longer here.
The big Chilean pit that used to grade around two percent is heading for well below half that, which means more rock, more power, more water, for less metal.
You can’t legislate a deposit into existence.
So the West is already in an economic fight for its literal existence as free nations . A motor plant waits on a magnet. A substation waits on a transformer. The data-center people have capital and no timeline they can trust. Defense buyers discover that spec foil is not a commodity you grab off a screen.
Friends start bidding against friends for whatever cathode isn’t spoken for.
Steel and diesel and fertilizer still do most of the heavy lifting. Copper is just where the shortage showed up first, because everything we say we want to build drinks electricity.
A country that sells ore and imports the finished piece is not “post-industrial.” It is dependent, it wakes up conquered and it will spend the next twenty years arguing about rationing instead of building the furnaces it decided were inefficient to own.
Robert Friedland
@robert_ivanhoe
Thanks to the plugged-in folks at Bloomberg for giving me the chance to ring some alarm bells that I think everyone needs to hear:
“We are really looking at the weaponization of certain critical raw materials in the supply chain and it's really a profound national security interest,” I told Bloomberg’s Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway on their Odd Lots podcast. “And the metals we need to do something about that are the same metals that are needed for drone warfare or the defense from drone warfare. So we're seeing a sort of perfect storm in a balkanized world economy where demand for certain critical metals is going to infinity.”
“We need to mine as much copper in the next 18 years as we did in the last 10,000 years, just to maintain global 3% GDP growth without the electrification of the world economy…In the last 30 years, all the capital on Wall Street went into sexy technology like the Internet and broadband and Netflix and wireless but when all the money goes in that direction, we didn't put money into basic raw materials, which are the foundation on which everything sits.”
Huge thanks to @bloomberg’s hugely talented @TheStalwart, @TracyAlloway, @kevlloydlozano, @carmenarmen, Cale Brooks and of course the one and only @ryanchilcote for making it all happen.
For more about how we got here and how, maybe, foresight and better technology can help us find our way out, listen to the episode on Apple podcasts, Spotify, youtube or at:
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-09-12/robert-friedla…
@IvanhoeMines_ @ivanhoeelectric @SunriseMetals @IPulseGroup @IvanhoeAtlantic @bluesparkenergy -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
In meinem Lehrbuch zur Makroökonomik diskutiere ich auch die T(arget)2-Salden, die sich langsam wieder zurück in die Debatte schleichen, obwohl sie nicht relecant sind für die Wirtschaft.
link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-658-41055-1 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And those departments need to teach system dynamics as well. Too many "political economy" oriented courses disavow mathematics because they blame it for Neoclassical economics's state and dominance. In fact mathematics & system dynamics contradict Neoclassical beliefs.
Warwick Smith
@RecoEco
How does the neoclassical and new Keynesian thinking persist? I have a friend who did a phd on the inability of mainstream economics profession to adapt to evidence and concluded academic economics was unfixable. Instead we need to build departments of political economy
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matt Mullin
@matthewwmullin
Just a friendly reminder that @NASA is building a nuclear-powered drone and sending it to Saturn’s moon Titan to search for the building blocks of life.
Honored to have helped build the laser that will zap Titan samples for analysis by the onboard mass spectrometer (called DraMS).
The actual spacecraft, a rotorcraft the size of a car, is being built by the legendary team at @JHUAPL.
It launches on a Falcon Heavy in July 2028, beginning a billion-mile journey to the outer Solar System.
Mission of a lifetime.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Very good overview of Yemen's history and the dilemmas that flow from it in today's ongoing Middle East conflicts.
Angelica 🌐⚛️🇹🇼🇨🇳🇺🇸
@AngelicaOung
I am a big fan of the idea that you cannot understand what is going on in the world today if you don't understand the history. This caused me to do a big dig yesterday into Yemeni history. And let me tell you...it is complicated beyond belief. I'm sharing a summary of my findings with you in the spirit of furthering the conversation, knowing that it is almost certainly going to be full of errors and controversies.
The Yemeni are some of the oldest inhabitants of the Arabian peninsula and traces their lineage back proudly to pre-Islamic empire. However, Yemen as a polity has spent more time divided than united.
I have chosen a map from the Cold War era when they actually were two separate countries recognized by the United Nation. But that jagged diagonal line you see splitting Yemen into a rough triangle to the west and a trapezoid to the east has been there in some form for a millenium. The reason is geography.
The western "triangle" (confusingly called North Yemen) is actually where most of the population lives by 4 to 1. That's the heavily mountainous highlands with the good arable land with water. Southern Yemen by contrast is mostly arid desert, although it benefits from containing most of Yemen's oil and the valuable ports.
Even before foreign interference, the people of the triangle and the people of the trapezoid were kind of diverging. But in colonial times, this really got locked in. The Ottoman empire got the North Yemen, which remained more tribal. The British empire got South Yemen, and it went in a more cosmopolitan direction.
When the empires fell, the schismogenesis intensified. North Yemen became the Yemen Arab Republic, supported by Saudi Arabia and the West. They were fiercely independent, feudal, Islamic and highly tribal. The South went to the Soviet sphere of influence and became the People's Democratic Republic of Yemen, the only Marxist Arab state. They actively tried to eradicate tribalism, promoted secularism and integrated women into the workforce.
But remember this: even as they started diverging in values, lifestyles and even religion...both the north and the south feel like they are the true Yemeni and sought unification on their own terms. The north looked down on the south as betraying traditional Yemeni values, while the South looked down on the north as backwards.
In 1990, the Soviet Union withdrew support from South Yemen in the midst of its own crisis and the state went bankrupt overnight. The resultant unification between the north and south was a shotgun marriage. The north marginalized the south in every way, and in 1994 a civil war broke out and Yemen never knew peace ever since.
Fast forward to the present day: Ansar Allah, often known as the Houthis in the West, control most of North Yemen and cannot be dislodged. But nor can they decently feed and care for the huge population under their control. The scale of the humanitarian disaster is staggering.
Ansar Allah are Zaydi Shia, highly rare pikachus. I don't want to get too deep into it but they are the Shia school most theologically similar to the Sunni. Not all northern Yemeni are Zaydi, and only a small minority of Zaydi are Ansar Allah, who are ideologically extremist. They are able to rally broad support however through being the most credible against foreign interference and also by backing the Palestinian cause.
In most of the south, the PLC government is nominally in charge, but they are completely dependent on Saudi Arabia for survival. It's debatable if you should describe them as a proxy or a puppet. Ansar Allah points to this to deny the PLC legitimacy, however the UN officially recognizes the PLC government as the government of all Yemen.
There are also smaller UAE-backed entities which meant there was levels to the conflict in Yemen. You had Ansar Allah against everyone else, but you also had Saudi-backed PLC tussling with UAE-backed STC. Recently the UAE withdrew from Yemen and the PLC and STC are maybe consolidated, but we'll see if it sticks.
Ansar Allah is reliant on Iran for its advanced military capabilities and acts with them with a high degree of coordination. However, they have their own localized interests and does not take orders from Tehran. It also seems like they're starting to cook up their own kit of late (with help from AI: Claude! Create an advanced missile system. Make no mistakes.)
With the taking of Mokha and Perim Island, Ansar Allah have completely cleared out PLC footprint on Yemen's West Coast and thus their control of the strategic Bab el-Mandeb bottleneck to the Red Sea is now consolidated. Furthermore, they appear to have gone transnational, coordinating with Iraqi militia to strike Saudi Arabia's east-west pipeline with drones coming from Iraqi territory.
The tragedy of Yemen is that north and south cannot live together but they also can't live apart. Ansar Allah cannot be dislodged out of their northern mountain redoubt, and now they have broken out of it, taking the entire red-sea coastline. I still don't see how they are going to take the whole south tho. It's all exposed desert sands.
A return to the Cold War divide seems superficially plausable, but ultimately this is not acceptable to the players that matter. Ansar Allah refuses partition as balkanization. As for Saudi Arabia, permanent civil war in Yemen might be preferable to legitimating Iran-aligned Ansar Allah on its border. A protracted, violent stalemate seems to be Yemen's dark future.
This is Yemen's continued tragedy, but also the rest of the world's open-ended strategic problem. Now that Ansar Allah secured the Bab el-Mandab Strait, they have placed a chokehold on a key artery of global trade. What happens in Yemen no longer stays in Yemen. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
Must read. In one interview Michael Hudson identifies the root of today's grossly unfair, unstable economy and sums up almost everything I've been clumsily trying to get across on this site over the past couple of years. Please share. www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/06/michael-hudson-debts-that…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Claiming you understand economics by looking at a supply and demand chart is like looking at a rain drop and claiming you understand the weather.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economists mistook a property of their models for a property of reality.
"There is no such thing as a normal period of history. Normality is a fiction of economic textbooks."
-Joan Robinson -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
According to Blanchard, people who question the 'frontier' of mainstream economics research are 'kooks'. Despite centuries of recessions, crashes, austerity etc., his 'frontier research' insists that instability isn't an inherent feature of markets but a deviation from normal(!?) stability. He also wants nations to 'slowly' reduce fiscal deficits to zero, which would force households and businesses to rely more on private moneylenders. Nothing ideological here, of course. Maybe we need more kooks and fewer Blanchards to work towards reducing the intellectual deficit to zero.
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
It takes at least 10 years after high school to get to the frontier of economic research, or to the frontier of medical research.
Except for a few kooks, most people, smartly, do not try to engage and question medical researchers.
Unfortunately, this is not true for economics. Many too many self-appointed experts, including among politicians.
Manuel Bompard
@mbompard
Il est grave que le gouverneur de la banque de France diffuse ainsi de fausses informations.
1) Rien dans les traités européens ne dit ce que la BCE doit faire des titres de dettes des États dont elle dispose. Les mêmes arguments d’illégalité étaient utilisés contre le rachat des titres par la BCE (« quantitative easing »). L’Allemagne a même porté plainte devant la cour de justice de l’Union européenne et elle a été déboutée.
2) Rien ne permet d’accréditer la thèse d’une hausse d’intérêt en raison d’une congélation des titres de dette des États détenus par la BCE. Au contraire. Réduire l’endettement des États, c’est améliorer leur situation. Cela n’a aucun sens de prétendre que cela conduirait à une hausse des taux d’intérêt.
3) Les opérations de rachats de titre de dette par la BCE n’ont pas créé d’inflation. Ce qui risque d’en créer par contre, c’est notre manque d’investissement dans l’adaptation au changement climatique, comme on a pu le voir cet été avec l’impact des événements climatiques sur la production agricole, qui va se traduire par une forte inflation sur les produits alimentaires.
4) Transférer de la dette d’un État vers une dette de la Banque de France n’est pas une opération sans effet. Une banque centrale peut tout à faire continuer à vivre avec un bilan négatif, sans que cela n’ait quelque impact que ce soit sur la poursuite de ses activités.
RTL France
@RTLFrance
Effacer la dette ? La solution de Jean-Luc Mélenchon serait "illégale, dangereuse et inutile" tacle le gouverneur de la Banque de France dans #rtlmatin face @FogielMarcO
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Neil Buckingham
@BuckinghamNeil
Thanks.
The clearest and easiest listening fifty minute discussion in general terms of the banking system and clearly illustrated through the accounting of double entry bookkeeping. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter Turchin
@Peter_Turchin
A very interesting story:
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/10/science/tristan-buckmaster-ope…
and relevant to my recent post:
peterturchin.substack.com/p/cliodynamics-and-ai-the-mid-2026
Some comments to my post have warned me against using AI (currently, I use ChatGPT), because OpenAI could use my questions and results to train their models and then scoop me, as happened to Tristan Buckmaster (he was certainly scooped, although OpenAI denies its agents have constructed their solution based on what Dr. Buckmaster had supplied to Codex).
Here are three reasons I am ignoring such warnings.
1. Most importantly, LLMs make me and my team much more efficient. I want to race with the machines, as I may not have many years left in my healthy and intellectually productive life, and there is a huge amount of stuff to accomplish.
2. Next, the kinds of problems that we work on are very different from the tasks the current AI excels at. What is the common denominator in chess playing, programming, and proving theorems? It’s all problems that are highly formalized (note, by humans), have very clear rules, and it is clear what constitutes success. My colleagues and I created and are building a completely new field of science over the past 25 years — nothing could be further from learning how to play chess. Undoubtedly, AI will eventually become good at this, also, but it’s some years ahead.
3. Finally, if/when the time comes that AI gets better at doing cliodynamics, it will mean that we will find solutions to how to escape from crisis. It will save lives, reduce immiseration, and result in increases of broadly shared well-being. I am fine with such an outcome! (And we, the cliodynamics founders, will still get the credit for launching the field). 😉 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
Medicine is a real science. Economics isn’t. That’s why people question economists more than they question physicians — and because economists get things wrong all the time.
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
It takes at least 10 years after high school to get to the frontier of economic research, or to the frontier of medical research.
Except for a few kooks, most people, smartly, do not try to engage and question medical researchers.
Unfortunately, this is not true for economics. Many too many self-appointed experts, including among politicians.
Manuel Bompard
@mbompard
Il est grave que le gouverneur de la banque de France diffuse ainsi de fausses informations.
1) Rien dans les traités européens ne dit ce que la BCE doit faire des titres de dettes des États dont elle dispose. Les mêmes arguments d’illégalité étaient utilisés contre le rachat des titres par la BCE (« quantitative easing »). L’Allemagne a même porté plainte devant la cour de justice de l’Union européenne et elle a été déboutée.
2) Rien ne permet d’accréditer la thèse d’une hausse d’intérêt en raison d’une congélation des titres de dette des États détenus par la BCE. Au contraire. Réduire l’endettement des États, c’est améliorer leur situation. Cela n’a aucun sens de prétendre que cela conduirait à une hausse des taux d’intérêt.
3) Les opérations de rachats de titre de dette par la BCE n’ont pas créé d’inflation. Ce qui risque d’en créer par contre, c’est notre manque d’investissement dans l’adaptation au changement climatique, comme on a pu le voir cet été avec l’impact des événements climatiques sur la production agricole, qui va se traduire par une forte inflation sur les produits alimentaires.
4) Transférer de la dette d’un État vers une dette de la Banque de France n’est pas une opération sans effet. Une banque centrale peut tout à faire continuer à vivre avec un bilan négatif, sans que cela n’ait quelque impact que ce soit sur la poursuite de ses activités.
RTL France
@RTLFrance
Effacer la dette ? La solution de Jean-Luc Mélenchon serait "illégale, dangereuse et inutile" tacle le gouverneur de la Banque de France dans #rtlmatin face @FogielMarcO
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It's even more fun when you're 73...
Amelia
@amelia_tweetz
I believe “SHAMPOO” and “CONDITIONER” should be the two biggest words on the bottle. Not size 8 font on a matching background like I’m supposed to solve a fcking puzzle in the shower.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
On the 17th September, we have our next discussion with Michael Hudson.
He will be joined by Kathleen Tyson.
They will discuss the economy at the end of the world. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Watch the full debate with Jason Furman, Obama's chief economic advisor, about whether capitalism was broken. Venture capitalist @NickHanauer : "This is the pattern everywhere you look. When a bank makes a bad bet and it pays off, the executives keep the winnings. When the bet goes bad, the public bails them out. We privatize the gains and socialize the costs, and we've built a tax code, a financial system, and an entire economy around that principle."
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going live in 30 minute with @ProfSteveKeen
www.youtube.com/live/XMrLNn8XU3I -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Center of The Maze💭
@Maze_s_Center
I hope that the next field that realizes this, is economics.
"A real economic model must let time matter.
That means:
-Path-dependence
-Irreversibility
-Adaptive expectations
-Open systems
DSGE can't do that. System dynamics can."
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
DSGE models dominate macro — but they’re built on a fundamental error:
They assume away time.
Here’s how this hidden assumption breaks everything from policy to prediction 🧵1/10 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yes. @ojblanchard1 posted a paper in August 2008 which declared that “the state of macro is good”: one year after the Global Financial Crisis started, a phenomenon which no mainstream model anticipated.
In economics, the kooks are the mainstream, realists are the critics. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Michael Hudson michael-hudson.com: De-Dollarization Is Necessary to Save the Global Economy
youtu.be/uwfVknP1qiM via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Center of The Maze💭
@Maze_s_Center
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke’s 2007 Report to Congress predicted 2.75% real economic growth in 2008.
Global Financial Crisis began 3 WEEKS later and actual rate was MINUS 2.5%.
Getting Ben Bernanke on board isn't the flex you think it is.
Anthropic
@AnthropicAI
Our Long-Term Benefit Trust has appointed Dr. Ben Bernanke as its newest member.
Read more: www.anthropic.com/news/ben-bernanke -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
cowboyeconomist.bsky.social cuts through the noise: #capitalism created the #climatecrisis and exacerbated wealth concentration. The solution will come from outside the system that’s led us here. #classstruggle #cancer
New Macro N Cheese ep Sat 9/12 @ 8 am ET. Link to all our eps in comment below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Is the UK Screwed? A Conversation with Steve Keen & Richard Murphy: The 40-Year Myth. beyondsurvival.substack.com/p/is-the-uk-screwed-a-convers… @RichardJMurphy
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Neoclassical economists are like 19th doctors applying leeches to "cure" diseases.
?whispers?
@litewhisperer
Blanchard’s assumption that economic orthodoxy has a cohesive technical frontier comparable to medicine’s may itself contribute to the problem he describes. The evidence offers little basis for public confidence in the current mainstream.
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
It takes at least 10 years after high school to get to the frontier of economic research, or to the frontier of medical research.
Except for a few kooks, most people, smartly, do not try to engage and question medical researchers.
Unfortunately, this is not true for economics. Many too many self-appointed experts, including among politicians.
Manuel Bompard
@mbompard
Il est grave que le gouverneur de la banque de France diffuse ainsi de fausses informations.
1) Rien dans les traités européens ne dit ce que la BCE doit faire des titres de dettes des États dont elle dispose. Les mêmes arguments d’illégalité étaient utilisés contre le rachat des titres par la BCE (« quantitative easing »). L’Allemagne a même porté plainte devant la cour de justice de l’Union européenne et elle a été déboutée.
2) Rien ne permet d’accréditer la thèse d’une hausse d’intérêt en raison d’une congélation des titres de dette des États détenus par la BCE. Au contraire. Réduire l’endettement des États, c’est améliorer leur situation. Cela n’a aucun sens de prétendre que cela conduirait à une hausse des taux d’intérêt.
3) Les opérations de rachats de titre de dette par la BCE n’ont pas créé d’inflation. Ce qui risque d’en créer par contre, c’est notre manque d’investissement dans l’adaptation au changement climatique, comme on a pu le voir cet été avec l’impact des événements climatiques sur la production agricole, qui va se traduire par une forte inflation sur les produits alimentaires.
4) Transférer de la dette d’un État vers une dette de la Banque de France n’est pas une opération sans effet. Une banque centrale peut tout à faire continuer à vivre avec un bilan négatif, sans que cela n’ait quelque impact que ce soit sur la poursuite de ses activités.
RTL France
@RTLFrance
Effacer la dette ? La solution de Jean-Luc Mélenchon serait "illégale, dangereuse et inutile" tacle le gouverneur de la Banque de France dans #rtlmatin face @FogielMarcO
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Macro n Cheese Podcast #MMT
@CheeseMacro
Spicy New Ep!! 🌶️
Capitalism doesn't glitch into recessions. It produces them by design.
The Cowboy Economist @John_T_Harvey & @sdgrumbine focus on who pays the price when the system needs to discipline labor.
realprogressives.org/mnc-podcast-ep/episode-396-recession… -
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yes. @ojblanchard1 posted a paper in August 2008 which declared that “the state of macro is good”: one year after the Global Financial Crisis started, a phenomenon which no mainstream model anticipated.
In economics, the kooks are the mainstream, realists are the critics. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Anonymous
@YourAnonNews
This is a rare photo of Donald Trump from 1934, helping Albert Einstein finish the theory of relativity. According to Trump, Einstein had been stuck for weeks.
“Very smart guy. Terrible with numbers. I looked at the board and said, Albert, put a little 2 up there. He loved it." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Angelo Giuliano 🇨🇭🇮🇹
@angeloinchina
China’s Meritocracy: Selection First, Election Second
I have lived in China since 1995. That is not a credential I wave around for effect. It is simply how long it took me to stop looking at this country through the lens I was given in the West.
I arrived convinced I already understood politics. Ballot, campaign, speech, vote. Anything else was “authoritarian,” end of discussion.
Then I watched, year after year, how people actually rise here. Not the slogan version. The file version. China does not pick its leaders the way Western commentary pretends government works.
Nobody walks out of a law firm, a television studio, or a donor dinner and into the top job. The record follows you. Floods. Schools. Factories. About achievements and past results.
Selection first. Election second. That is the system, and it is older than the Party that now runs it.
Full piece: angelogiuliano.substack.com/p/chinas-meritocracy-selectio… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mathew Forstater
@mattybram
Argentina defaulted and raised the minimum wage and had a tremendous community employment program—expansion instead of austerity.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brett Erickson
@BrettErickson28
Breaking: The Saudi East-West Pipeline has been HIT… but it was hit out of IRAQ!
This means that IRGC proxies are cross-coordinating their attacks against Saudi Arabia in a truly devastating manner.
Ansarallah has seized effective control over the Bab al-Mandeb Strait in the last 24 hours, and the Iraqi proxies have struck the CRITICAL East-West Pipeline. But even worse, they struck the pumping station itself, and not simply an easily repairable portion of pipe.
This has been perhaps THE most catastrophic 24 hours anyone could have imagined for the global energy markets. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Too good to not retweet!
Anonymous
@YourAnonNews
This is a rare photo of Donald Trump from 1934, helping Albert Einstein finish the theory of relativity. According to Trump, Einstein had been stuck for weeks.
“Very smart guy. Terrible with numbers. I looked at the board and said, Albert, put a little 2 up there. He loved it." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
Some folks prefer not to order on Amazon, so here is a link to my new book, "China's War on Poverty," on IngramSpark.
👇
shop.ingramspark.com/b/084?params=eU7nFTnKFhWMH1n1YspVj5a…
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
My new book, "China's War on Poverty," was published today.
Ask me anything. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
Once again Blanchard makes a fool of himself. Economics is not a science. Medical researchers & other scientists share their findings and welcome further advances, even if their theories are disproven. Economists fight each other due to ideology.
Accounting on the other hand...
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
It takes at least 10 years after high school to get to the frontier of economic research, or to the frontier of medical research.
Except for a few kooks, most people, smartly, do not try to engage and question medical researchers.
Unfortunately, this is not true for economics. Many too many self-appointed experts, including among politicians.
Manuel Bompard
@mbompard
Il est grave que le gouverneur de la banque de France diffuse ainsi de fausses informations.
1) Rien dans les traités européens ne dit ce que la BCE doit faire des titres de dettes des États dont elle dispose. Les mêmes arguments d’illégalité étaient utilisés contre le rachat des titres par la BCE (« quantitative easing »). L’Allemagne a même porté plainte devant la cour de justice de l’Union européenne et elle a été déboutée.
2) Rien ne permet d’accréditer la thèse d’une hausse d’intérêt en raison d’une congélation des titres de dette des États détenus par la BCE. Au contraire. Réduire l’endettement des États, c’est améliorer leur situation. Cela n’a aucun sens de prétendre que cela conduirait à une hausse des taux d’intérêt.
3) Les opérations de rachats de titre de dette par la BCE n’ont pas créé d’inflation. Ce qui risque d’en créer par contre, c’est notre manque d’investissement dans l’adaptation au changement climatique, comme on a pu le voir cet été avec l’impact des événements climatiques sur la production agricole, qui va se traduire par une forte inflation sur les produits alimentaires.
4) Transférer de la dette d’un État vers une dette de la Banque de France n’est pas une opération sans effet. Une banque centrale peut tout à faire continuer à vivre avec un bilan négatif, sans que cela n’ait quelque impact que ce soit sur la poursuite de ses activités.
RTL France
@RTLFrance
Effacer la dette ? La solution de Jean-Luc Mélenchon serait "illégale, dangereuse et inutile" tacle le gouverneur de la Banque de France dans #rtlmatin face @FogielMarcO
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Red MMT
@RedMMT
Because you are not practising a science. Neoclassical economics is just ideology in disguise.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
Perhaps if economists' forecasts and analysis weren't wrong so frequently, people wouldn't challenge them.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Vicky Blaber
@BigBladder887
1/ Unlike medicine or engineering, the problem with economics as a science is that it has an abysmal track record in the real world. So it is very natural to challenge it from early on because it’s glaringly obvious from the beginning how flawed it is.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X
@Xking332
Saudi is now on the verge of a devastating collapse.
And this will most likely trigger a global famine.
The Houthis have conquered Mocha, Dhubab and Hisn Murad.
All the nearby islands are gone too.
The entire Yemeni coastline is under their control.
Now the East-West pipeline has been completely destroyed.
This means Saudi can no longer export 90% of their oil.
They can't export their phosphate or urea either.
Amonia. Sulfur. Methanol. Petrochemicals.
There's absolutely no way of exporting any of them.
This is going to cut global food production in half.
India, Brazil, Europe, America, Pakistan and several countries will most likely end up facing severe food shortages.
The Strait of Hormuz is shut down as well.
Saudi's leaders made multiple requests to Trump to bomb Yemen.
Trump rejected all of them.
Saudi is now in talks with Pakistan to join forces and bomb several key infrastructure sites in Yemen.
Because,
Saudi's economy is in total shambles.
They are desperately trying to secure a $72 billion loan from the World Bank now.
Thousands of Saudi forces have started surrendering to Yemen too.
Multiple energy sites in Abha, Najran, Jazan and Khamis Mushait have been completely destroyed.
Saudi Aramco is selling stakes in pipelines, sulfur facilities and terminals to pay dividends.
That's why Saudi is becoming increasingly desperate for a large scale attack on Yemen to stop the Houthis.
If Saudi collapses, millions of families around the world will starve.
This is turning into a humanitarian apocalypse. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Angelica 🌐⚛️🇹🇼🇨🇳🇺🇸
@AngelicaOung
Thanks everyone for advice on the Bio. Below is my book description. I've already sent it in to my editor but I'd still appreciate feedback!
BOOK -- China Reconsidered: Behind the Great Wall of Disinformation
Why do we keep getting China wrong?
Despite an endless stream of headlines and ominous books predicting Beijing's collapse, the West somehow never saw the reality of New China coming. We were told China's economic reckoning was perpetually around the corner and that its people had been pushed to their breaking point. How do we reconcile that with the fact that a more technologically advanced, hypercompetitive, sophisticated and undeniably confident China is coming into view?
No number of stories about ghost cities, "lying flat" youth, oppressed ethnic minorities and onerous government censorship could have prepared Western observers for the reality of China in 2026. Today, we have arrived at an embarrassing paradox: a tourist visiting Shanghai for a weekend to take advantage of China's new visa-free travel scheme will have a more accurate view of modern China than the think-tank experts who opine on it for a living. The more mainstream commentary on China you consume, the less informed you become.
This distortion is no accident. A Great Wall of Disinformation stands between Western publics and China. It was built brick by brick not just by prestigious media outlets like the New York Times and the Economist, but by an interlocking ecosystem of think tanks, academic area studies, congressional committees, and advocacy NGOs amplifying a narrative about China made in the West for global consumption. While individual stories may contain factual elements, the overall picture serves a geopolitical agenda.
Author Angelica Oung was once a cog in that machine. Reporting for outlets including the Taipei Times, the UK's Daily Telegraph and Jimmy Lai's Next Media group, she knew exactly what her editors wanted: an anti-China angle. As a former China Hawk and a true believer in the Neoliberal consensus, she didn't think she was distorting the facts, but exposing the dark truth about the Chinese regime.
China Reconsidered began as Oung's attempt to write a book that would convince her former self she wasn't a noble truth-teller, but a foot soldier in the info wars. But deconstructing dogma head on is a fool's errand. Instead, this concise volume is written for people who have already started to question the mainstream narrative on China. The goal of this book is to show you how the wall was built, how it's cracking and how to see through it.
The world has already tipped into multipolarity. This is a dangerous time, not because of where we are going, but because of the deadly conflicts that might occur on the way there. Now more than ever, we must break down the Great Wall of Disinformation and see the world as it really is. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Is the UK Screwed? A Conversation with Steve Keen & Richard Murphy: The 40-Year Myth. beyondsurvival.substack.com/p/is-the-uk-screwed-a-convers… @RichardJMurphy
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Guess what? Iran has the right to kill however many US militants posing a threat to Iran as are within range of its retaliation in a war US started.
US has killed thousands of Iranian civilians. Three US militants on a military base are fair game. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
My new book, "China's War on Poverty," was published today.
Ask me anything. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I study complex nonlinear dynamic systems. It's like dropping a ball on a Pringles chip and asking where it goes. It might settle, oscillate, or fly right off the edge.
Neoclassical economics puts the ball in a bowl and assumes it'll eventually return to the bottom. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
"The immense accumulations of fixed capital which, to the great benefit of mankind, were built up during the half century before the war, could never have come about in a Society where wealth was divided equitably."
-John Maynard Keynes
I love this Keynes quote because if you follow the argument through Keynes and then Kalecki, you end up somewhere very different from where it starts.
Before WWI, wealth was incredibly concentrated. Rich households obviously couldn't consume all of their income, so a huge amount was saved while factories, railways, machinery and other capital were being built.
And from the outside that makes it look pretty simple. The rich had the money, the rich saved it, those savings financed investment, therefore you needed rich people and inequality to get capital accumulation.
But... Investment doesn't have to sit around waiting for somebody to save first. Banks can create the credit to finance investment, firms spend that money, that spending becomes somebody else's income, and out of the higher income comes the saving.
So investment can create the saving needed to account for it. Then Kalecki makes this even more interesting because the same thing happens with profits.
Capitalists aren't just sitting on some pile of previously accumulated profits and deciding how much of it they can afford to invest. When they invest, that spending itself helps generate profits across the capitalist sector.
That's where Kalecki's great line comes from: workers spend what they earn, capitalists earn what they spend.
And once you put those two ideas together, the old argument that we need massive inequality because rich people need to save enough money for society to invest starts falling apart.
We don't need to wait for someone to become incredibly wealthy and graciously stop consuming before we can build a factory.
We need real resources, financing, demand and someone willing to actually make the investment.
The saving shows up as a consequence of the income we create along the way. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Weekly update from @GDPDynamics is up on the members page.
members.gdpdynamics.com/posts/economy-holds-as-169278939 -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Too good to not retweet!
Anonymous
@YourAnonNews
This is a rare photo of Donald Trump from 1934, helping Albert Einstein finish the theory of relativity. According to Trump, Einstein had been stuck for weeks.
“Very smart guy. Terrible with numbers. I looked at the board and said, Albert, put a little 2 up there. He loved it." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
What if economics has been getting human nature fundamentally wrong?
Economist @DJSnower argues that social norms and interactions lie at the heart of human existence, shaping nearly every aspect of our lives. Yet many economic models trivialize or neglect them, creating a stark disconnect between economic theory and how the real world actually works.
A new economic paradigm must begin by understanding that humans are not isolated individuals—we are deeply embedded in society and the environment. Read more: evonomics.com/announcing-a-new-paradigm-for-economics-and… @David_S_WilsonThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David McNab @mcfab@home.social
@DavidMcNab17
“We’re in a global debt shock” says Robin.
The only debt that can shock anyone is private sector debt. In the UK, the nat ‘debt’ has been rising year on year for 300 years, and in every one of those years a Robin screamed the end was nigh.
They make a living doing this.
Mad.
jms london (🇬🇧, 🇪🇺) #FBPE #Brexit #Econ #EU
@Jms7777Justin
‼️‼️‼️
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It’s What You Know For Sure That Just Ain’t So
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/its-what-you-for-1692…
Chapter 16 in my forthcoming book “How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism”. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
William Thomson
@Williamgallus
Q: 'We’re f***ed' Can a revolutionary new economic theory (#mmt) save Scotland?
A: It might. If we were given a chance! @heraldscotland web.archive.org/web/20260621084809/https://www.heraldscot… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Everything is priced to perfection, but perfection isn't coming our way www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2kUtbfE3eo
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Morris Zin | 6x Azure | Solution Architect
@morriszin
Thank you for the podcast Steve & Phil. These podcast (over 500 of them) enlighten me, don't want to sound like a fanboy but these are the most valuable knowledge with a lot of wisdom that would pass down to the next generation to come. Thanks for doing it - much appreciated.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Darf ich in diesem Zusammenhang daran erinnern, dass die Globale Finanzkrise etwas mit faulen Immobilienkrediten, einem Mangel an Regulierung und kurzfristig denkenden Banken und Finanzakteuren zu tun hatte und nichts mit steigenden Renditen auf Staatsanleihen?
Frankfurter Allgemeine gesamt
@FAZ_NET
Debatte um Erinnerungskultur: Wer Geschichte nicht kennt, hält jede Krise für neu
www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/debatten/geschichtslosigke… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Just posted my weekly update video on @GDPDynamics for the Nowcast and updates on a new model. See below.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Latest weekly video update for the Nowcast and a brand new model is posted on the site.
See the link to in in the post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
David Graeber just called it bribery. Obviously in the US, they rarely use such a phrase to describe the system of lobbying.
Prof Michael Hudson explains more.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It’s What You Know For Sure That Just Ain’t So
www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/its-what-you-for-1692…
Chapter 16 in my forthcoming book “How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism”. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Elizabeth Glab @lizglab.bsky.social
@LizGlab
If you have a sense that economists are disconnected from reality, this is for you.
Rethinking Economics
@rethinkecon
A huge shout-out to Rethinking Economics Denmark for this brilliant satire! 🎓
We know there are countless students out there who remember a moment in economics class that made them pull this exact face. 😕 😖 😠This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James A. Robichaux
@JamesRobichaux
"It's no coincidence that the federal deficit is something like $15 trillion and there is something like $15 trillion in our pension funds. It's like, where else is it going to come from?"
- Warren Mosler, September 2012 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
There is no objective number in accounting or in the relationships it records. That fact is necessarily implicit in double-entry, where a debit must be matched by a credit. In turn, those entries exist in relationship to transactions. An infographic, which I wrote and AI drew:
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Including energy in economic models. It doesn’t have to be that difficult youtu.be/uMAwMhZMkck via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Macroeconomics Doesn’t Need Microfoundations | LIVE www.youtube.com/live/XMrLNn8XU3I via @YouTube Come along and watch Ty and me pull apart the microfoundations delusion.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
We need a revolution in how Britain works youtu.be/oLP5qnqpSFs Nothing works now. It can't, and it won't, unless we turn our economy around to serve people and not finance. Is that too much to ask for? It would be revolutionary.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Highlights
@highlightsnews1
.@ProfSteveKeen states that Trump’s offer of $5,000 to every American adult if Republicans win the midterms is illegal under US law, adding that he has never kept a single promise in his life.
Follow Press TV on Telegram: t.me/PressTV -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Anthony Scaramucci
@Scaramucci
In 2008, we created TARP and sent about $1 trillion into the banks to shore up their balance sheets.
It worked for the banks.
Wall Street people got big bonuses that year, despite the debacle they'd created.
The middle and lower-middle class got no mortgage relief, no rent relief, no credit card relief. NOTHING.
That anger created Occupy Wall Street.
That anger created the Tea Party.
Those two movements got married and had a baby.
That baby is MAGA.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Travis Brewer
@brew56200
How much is really debt, and how much is just accounting?
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
10/10
Stop worrying about the debt and start looking at the accounting.
Watch my full breakdown of why Ferguson is wrong here:
youtu.be/e32ANMH8TpA
#economics #stevekeen #modernmoney -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alexander Ač
@Lacertko
Everything is perfect until it perfectly crashes.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Everything is priced to perfection, but perfection isn't coming our way www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2kUtbfE3eo
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Reminder: The Global Financial Crisis had absolutely nothing to do with bond yields or government bonds and everything to do with real estate bubbles and predatory behavior in banking and finance.
Barchart
@Barchart
U.S. 10-Year Treasury Yield approaching highest level since the run-up to the Global Financial Crisis 🚨 🚨
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Canada Hates Trump
@AntiTrumpCanada
If you believe Trump is actually going to send you a $5,000 dividend check, just like you believed he’d send you a $5,000 DOGE check and a $2,000 tariff check, then I’ve got some bad news for you:
You’re a fucking idiot.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ThePatrioticBlonde™🇺🇸
@ImBreckWorsham
Trump literally just offered $5k to every American to vote Republican in the upcoming midterms.
Being Italian and an attorney by trade, I know a thing or two about organized crime.
That's not an incentive.
That's a bribe.
It's also a violation of Federal Law under 18 U.S.C. § 597 which reads, "it is a crime to offer, give, solicit, or accept compensation in exchange for voting, withholding a vote, or voting for or against a particular candidate."
He just committed a federal crime. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
Paradox of tranquillity (Minsky): Overconfidence leads to speculative borrowing and then to overpricing of assets which later ends up in decline in asset prices when it is noticed that the firm is excessively indebted..
Hedgeye
@Hedgeye
Tech now makes up a record 55% of all S&P 500 capital spending
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Gloninger, CCM, CBM
@ChrisGloninger
I'll spend it the same way I spent my $2,000 tariff dividend, my $5,000 DOGE dividend, and the $5,000 he promised last night if Republicans hold Congress. Entirely in my imagination.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
President Donald J. Trump announces $500 rebate checks to nearly 1 million hardworking Americans who were wrongly overcharged through Obamacare.
"Our Administration is doing the right thing and giving the money back to the people who were wrongly ripped off."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Everything is priced to perfection, but perfection isn't coming our way www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2kUtbfE3eo
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
That is not how money works. (And believe me, you don't want to cut yourself to fiscal healt. That is impossible.)
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge: it is those who know little, not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved by science.”
― Charles Darwin -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Phil 🆓🌍🧩🎲
@Phil_Free_
Your Margin & Your Life
profstevekeen.substack.com/p/your-margin-and-your-life?r=… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Common Sense 🇺🇸💙
@commons96055467
The president of the United Stated Donald J. trump, just committed a crime live on camera.
18 U.S. Code § 597 - Expenditures to influence voting
U.S. Code Notes;
Whoever makes or offers to make an expenditure to any person, either to vote or withhold his vote, or to vote for or against any candidate; and Whoever solicits, accepts, or receives any such expenditure in consideration of his vote or the withholding of his voteThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alex Nunns
@alexnunns
My mum has had blood taken from her foot many times, usually in the same facility.
But successive governments have broken up the NHS into privately-run fragments.
Their bottom line is profits, not patients.
Meanwhile, my mum has suspected cancer but still no blood test.
10/10 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Almost all the talk about the public debt of the US government misses the fact that every $ that the government spent beyond what it took back in taxes (that is how you define the public debt) has created financial wealth for the non-government sector: households and firms.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
This analysis is straight-up horseshit.
It's a discourse on China devoid of any complexity. Why is it so hard to look at China's political system without this fixation that the end point should be Western liberal democracy?
China does not hold competitive national elections and practises considerable censorship. China’s authoritarianism deserves scrutiny. But the reflexive Western verdict — that China is “just another politically repressive regime” — obscures more than it educates.
A recent survey by the Alliance of Democracies, a Danish-based NGO with no sympathy for authoritarianism, found that perceptions of democracy are stronger in China than in the United States, the United Kingdom, and France.
China’s political system is also more meritocratic than many Western liberal democracies. You cannot buy your way to national office in China. Politicians typically spend years demonstrating competence at the provincial level before being considered for senior roles.
Whether you’re a fan of China’s governance model or not, it’s undeniably a model characterised by high levels of legitimacy and commitment to delivering economic development for its people.
And this model of governance — where they've actually managed to put competent people in charge who care deeply about public service — helps explain why the material achievements in China are so impressive compared to, for example, the US.
Compared to the US, China has higher life expectancy, broader basic healthcare coverage, a superior public transport system, more sophisticated urban infrastructure, and fewer people living in extreme poverty. With a GDP per capita one-sixth that of the US, China has pulled off an extremely impressive feat of governance and state capacity.
Perhaps it's time we ask, instead, why so many countries in the West that are supposedly so democratic and so wealthy achieve so damn little for their people.
Mary Julia Koch
@MJ_Koch
America's Chinamaxxers marvel at the rapid buildout of Chinese tech and infrastructure. They don't ask about what it cost—labor exploitation, mass surveillance, political repression. My latest in @WSJFreeEx:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Well said Clive. The party has to confront what an awful period this was in its history, and to reflect on how distant it is today from the party that rebuilt Britain after WWII.
Clive Lewis MP
@labourlewis
The media euphemism that Keir Starmer has ‘vacated his seat’ is an utter travesty. Almost as if he accidentally wafted away on a gust of wind.
Be honest. He u-turned on his promise to stay as an MP, deserted his constituents and his party - for what? To go and make money on the international circuit.
The only thing forensic about him is the chalk outline he has left behind instead of a meaningful legacy. A fitting epitaph to the worst PM in our movements history.
Believe me, it’s not personal in anyway. I wish him well.
But we cannot allow the media and others to sugarcoat just how bad his govt was, by the standards OUR movement expects.
We must have an honest analysis of it it. About the toxic culture it fostered, the behaviour it condoned. One that enabled a small clique to bring back Peter Mandelson into the heart of govt.
To expel thousands of members for no reason. To clamp down on the right to protest. To allow a genocide to unfold and do next to nothing about it.
If we don’t ask ourselves how this happened and why, if we don’t interrogate this sorry chapter - then we are doomed to repeat it.
So no, let’s not sugarcoat his legacy. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tommy Hoare
@Tommy_Hoare
Literally the opposite is true. Anyone who has studied economic history knows that deflation usually coincides with periods of economic contraction can crises. It might not be bad in and of itself, but it almost never happens unless things are going badly.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
Has capitalism failed, or has neoliberalism destroyed it? youtu.be/w7n6p9BbqUk Few people now believe that the economy works for them. Those that do tend to be very well off. So has capitalism failed? And when will our politicians realise?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
I love Victoria Derbyshire but it’s so frustrating to hear her say ‘Oh my god!’ when we never hear that reaction from media about climate crisis which is also has a very possibility of killing billions of people.
‘Oh my god’ is an entirely appropriate reaction to climate breakdown too.
BBC Newsnight
@BBCNewsnight
“You just said that 10% doesn’t seem an unreasonable estimate that AI could kill all humans”
“Yes”
“Wow… oh my God.”
@vicderbyshire speaks to Nobel Prize Winner and so-called ‘Godfather of AI’ Geoffrey Hinton about predictions by an Anthropic researcher that there’s a more than 10% chance AI could kill all humans within a decade.
#newsnight -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
The supposed certainty many neoliberal thinkers have about accounting and economics is entirely misplaced. The idea that anything in economic data has an objective reality is just wrong. Note: I wrote this infographic. I used AI to create the final image.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Colin McCarthy
@US_Stormwatch
The hottest summer in American history is no longer 1936; it is now officially 2026.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The analysis is flawed when it comes to #macroeconomics. Here is why:
www.fabio-de-masi.de/kontext/controllers/document.php/654…
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
Two years ago, Mario Draghi warned that Europe faced an “existential” threat from economic decline.
We break down how much of the former Italian PM’s competitiveness plan the EU has actually delivered since then 👇
🔗 www.politico.eu/article/mario-draghi-plan-2-competitivene… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The singularity of econ wordplay quotes.
"Under capitalism, man exploits man. Under communism, it's just the opposite."
-John Kenneth Galbraith -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Banks Create Money Out of Nothing and Here Is the Proof by @ProfSteveKeen
youtu.be/DmA42QSqRKE via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
This is just reaching a level of STUPID that's beyond description. He's now basically trying to bribe the country to vote for Republicans? After all his other false and failed promises?
NOBODY believes Trump any longer. He's the Boy Who Cried Wolf at least 50 times too many...
Breaking911
@Breaking911
BREAKING: President Trump said that if Republicans win control of both chambers of Congress, he would issue a $5,000 dividend to every adult American, citing the nation’s economic success.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Bei steigenden Ölpreisen wird auch die Inflation ziemlich sicher ansteigen. Die von der EZB geplante Zinserhöhung hat keinen Einfluss auf Energiepreise. Es werden nur Kredite teurer, was im Zweifelsfall Geld von arm zu reich umverteilt.
www.tagesschau.de/wirtschaft/finanzen/marktbericht-oel-br… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sony Thăng
@nxt888
In the Philippines, between 1899 and 1902, the United States fought a war most Americans have never heard of.
After defeating Spain, America decided the Philippines should not be independent. Should not govern itself. Was not ready.
The Filipinos disagreed.
And so America, which had declared its own independence 123 years earlier, went to war to prevent another people from winning theirs.
The methods:
The "water cure": forcing water into a prisoner's stomach until they talked or died.
The systematic burning of villages.
The forced reconcentration of civilians and collective punishment in areas of resistance.
General Jacob Smith's order: kill everyone over ten.
Kill everyone over ten.
Between 250,000 and 1 million Filipinos died.
The American general who oversaw much of it, Arthur MacArthur, was celebrated back home.
His son Douglas became an even more celebrated general.
The war is not in most American textbooks.
When it appears, it is described as the "Philippine Insurrection."
Insurrection.
A Filipino fighting for Filipino independence on Filipino soil is, in the American vocabulary, an insurgent.
The Americans who crossed the Pacific to prevent that independence are, in the same vocabulary, soldiers.
The words are the empire's first line of defense.
They were doing their job in 1902.
They are still doing their job now. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rethinking Economics
@rethinkecon
A huge shout-out to Rethinking Economics Denmark for this brilliant satire! 🎓
We know there are countless students out there who remember a moment in economics class that made them pull this exact face. 😕 😖 😠This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Macro... From Macrofoundations....
Problem solved.
Macroeconomics has spent half a century trying to solve the Lucas critique by digging downward, searching for supposedly invariant parameters in individual optimization.
But higher levels of organization develop their own structures, constraints and regularities. If more is different, the foundations of macroeconomics may not lie beneath macroeconomics at all.
They may lie in the emergent relationships created by the macroeconomic system itself. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Well said Clive. The party has to confront what an awful period this was in its history, and to reflect on how distant it is today from the party that rebuilt Britain after WWII.
Clive Lewis MP
@labourlewis
The media euphemism that Keir Starmer has ‘vacated his seat’ is an utter travesty. Almost as if he accidentally wafted away on a gust of wind.
Be honest. He u-turned on his promise to stay as an MP, deserted his constituents and his party - for what? To go and make money on the international circuit.
The only thing forensic about him is the chalk outline he has left behind instead of a meaningful legacy. A fitting epitaph to the worst PM in our movements history.
Believe me, it’s not personal in anyway. I wish him well.
But we cannot allow the media and others to sugarcoat just how bad his govt was, by the standards OUR movement expects.
We must have an honest analysis of it it. About the toxic culture it fostered, the behaviour it condoned. One that enabled a small clique to bring back Peter Mandelson into the heart of govt.
To expel thousands of members for no reason. To clamp down on the right to protest. To allow a genocide to unfold and do next to nothing about it.
If we don’t ask ourselves how this happened and why, if we don’t interrogate this sorry chapter - then we are doomed to repeat it.
So no, let’s not sugarcoat his legacy. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cajun AF Team Normal
@kennethbarnhar8
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
Why does US' oligarch owned media try to fool US citizens into thinking China is a threat?
Jerry Grey (@Jerry_grey2002) explains.
Link to The Bridge to China in the Comments.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
There is a simple fact about economic development that has held true for hundreds of years and remains true today: except for very small countries, *every* country that has transformed its economy from low- to high-income has done so via manufacturing.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Wood
@dw2
Provocative analyses, radical prescriptions, and a hint of optimism despite all the warnings: all these feature in "Will economists destroy capitalism?" - the latest @LondonFuturists Podcast episode, featuring renowned contrarian economist @ProfSteveKeen
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
CALL TO ACTIVISM
@CalltoActivism
🚨HOLY SHIT: Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker demolishes Trump over his disgusting lie that he was pulled to safety by firefighters on 9/11:
Trump is “a persistent liar and a narcissist, and honestly suffering from dementia… Donald Trump shouldn't be president.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Fozon Capital
@FozonCapital
This orange piece of garbage is committing Stolen Valor by pretending to have known and been with the 9/11 victims.
While in reality, he was bragging about how he is the tallest building in New York City now.
You can't hate this evil piece of s*** enough. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
I remember a lost time in US history, in the 80s, when Americans had the money, and time, to enjoy life.
Today, that time has arrived in China. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tiempo De Tenis
@Tiempodetenis1
Hermoso esto que le dijo Frances Tiafoe a Alex Michelsen.
🗣️ "Tan pronto como lo abracé, vi que ya estaba llorando y le dije: 'Hermano, lo sé. He estado ahí. He estado ahí dos veces, para ser justos... perdiendo en cinco sets'".
🗣️ "Sé cuánto duele eso y cuánto lo deseaba hoy. Así que le dije: 'Hermano, vas a estar acá muchísimas veces más... y yo te voy a estar mirando desde casa cuando lo logres'".This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Tiempo De Tenis
@Tiempodetenis1
El llanto desconsolado de Michelsen en los hombros de Tiafoe.
El momento más emotivo del US Open.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
PoliticsGirl
@IAmPoliticsGirl
If lying about 9/11 isn’t a deal breaker, what is?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
If you are worried that government spending in France cannot be increased to a sustainable level (with full employment and price stability), there are other solutions available.
One would be to use the national escape clause in the context of defense expenditures, which has not been activated for France yet. The way I read that clause, it means that the public deficit does not have to respect the 3 % deficit limit, no matter what. The Commission's use of the national escape clause, only taking out defense expenditures, does not seem to be covered by the legal texts it is supposedly based on. So, this would be the easiest option for the French government.
Another route would be to activate again the general escape clause for all Eurozone member states. In a 2022 paper (below), Michi Paetz and I argue that the fiscal framework can be used to ramp up government spending significantly without necessarily running into inflation or other problems. Understanding that recent bouts of inflation have been caused by rebounding energy prices (2022-2023), the War in Iran (2026) and other supply side issues, there is currently no problem with productive capacity in the Eurozone (apart from it being too low.) Unemployment is also quite high, so even though there is a huge mismatch on the "labor market", there should be many workers available if you want to increase spending. Just make sure you are not hitting any bottlenecks that drive up prices and, if this is big enough, inflation.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40822-020-00159-w -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lucas Sanders 👊🏽🔥🇺🇸
@LucasSa56947288
🚨BREAKING: Donald Trump claims that he was lifted out of the rubble on 9/11:
"Two fireman, big strong guys, they grabbed me under the arms -- 'got to get our of here!' -- and they lifted me up, and they started running with me."
(Never happened) -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
First update of the week for the GDP Dynamics Nowcast.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 nowcast edged higher to 2.42%, up 0.03 pp since Friday.
The move came from a slightly smaller drag from net exports, while the broader outlook remains largely unchanged.
Article in the post below 👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
TheWhyExplained
@TheWhyExplained
With the discussion happening in our political discourse about #oil prices & availability my @Substack post provides a brief introduction to the topic reviewing how it’s created, extracted, refined then made available at your local gas station
open.substack.com/pub/thewhyexplained/p/why-as-an-energy-…
#econx -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
Why is the answer to fixing Social Security always cutting benefits?
Rey Fuentes from @rooseveltinst joins us this week to unpack what’s really driving Social Security’s looming shortfall and how we can fix it without cutting benefits.
🎧 ➡️ pod.link/pitchforkeconomics/episode/NDllY2NkNDItYWEzYS0xM… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
There is nothing you can't solve when applying a System Dynamic Overshoot and Collapse model to a problem...🤓
Pusat | Menocchio تورکی
@foucaultyen
Thanos kaynakları 2 kat arttırsa kaynaklar daha hızlı tükenirdi
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Economist @DJSnower argues that neoclassical and behavioral economics are fundamentally flawed because they are built on the wrong model of human behavior. In the 16th century, the basic premises underlying our understanding of astronomy shifted dramatically. This was the Copernican Moment. According to Snower, economics is now approaching a similar turning point. Read more: evonomics.com/why-behavioral-economics-cant-fix-a-broken-…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Adam Smith would have seen through the absurdity of neoclassical economics: In a world of self-regulating markets, perfect information at zero cost, and perfectly rational actors, fraud can’t exist. Economics and law professor @WilliamKBlack explains just how absurd this gets.
Credit: @INETeconomicsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good grief. As well as being flat out wrong, the person you cite as an example of how to do it, @Peter_Turchin, also uses ODEs in his mathematical modelling of history! We are kindred spirits in that sense, and here you are portraying us as opposites.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Holloway
@TheTalkWatcher
There was a documentary also about GM called WHO KILLED THE ELECTRIC CAR. GM could have innovated. They decided to let Elon Musk eat their lunch instead.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vRnUY6V2Knk -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matt Gilbert
@gudenevil
Ok, I understand. And Mosler does something similar with his exports=cost/imports=benefit.
It's a very strange way to see the world. Static.
Thanks, Steve -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This idiotic confusion of temperature change at a location with temperature change over time is the same mistake that economists have made to claim 3C of warming won’t be a big deal.
Dr. Matthew M. Wielicki
@MatthewWielicki
Is a couple of degrees of warming by 2100 really an emergency? Well, let's put that into context... That's about the temperature change from 8am to 10am in most major cities. Are we experiencing an emergency every morning?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The second is also a matter of logic. T2 balances (formerly known as TARGET2 balances) are balance sheet items and should be best understood as placeholders. They ensure that the balance sheets of the national central banks (NCBs) always balance. They don't have to, usually, because the NCBs are part of the Eurosystem, the collection of NCBs plus the ECB. It is the Eurosystem's balance sheet which should balance. Those of the NCBs don't balance naturally because people can send money from one country to the other, triggering flows of reserves. When Spaniards pay Germans for cars, the Germans have more money (and reserves) and the Spaniards less. Since reserves are a liability (by convention) on the central bank's balance sheet, any capital flow out of the country improves its "equity" (the difference between assets and liabilites). T2 assets and liabilities offset the changes in reserves triggered by outflows and inflows in the Eurozone. Otherwise, net exporting countries like Germany would have a central bank with negative equity, and German voters would be confused. So, having established that T2 balances are neither "assets" nor "liabilities", it should be clear that wahtever a cancellation of debt would do to the balances sheet of the Banque de France, any effects on T2 (if there were any) would not have any economic consequences. Politically, things might start to move again, with AfD in Germany having just announced that they want Germany out of the Eurozone. In purely economic terms though this is a non-issue.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Whatever one makes of the proposal to cancel French government bonds held by the Banque de France, two consequences should be clear:
1. No impact on inflation (not even if the monetary base increases).
2. Whatever happens to the T2 balances, never mind.
geoeconomics.substack.com/p/notes-on -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is the forgotten history of the US dependence on the auto and petroleum. It was the back plot for the movie “Who Killed Roger Rabbit?”
Basel Musharbash
@musharbash_b
What the Big Three car companies did was actually far worse than just lobbying — General Motors bought up the electric transit-car systems of 46 major cities, literally destroyed them, and replaced them with GM buses. One of the casualties of GM’s sabotage was the Los Angeles interurban electric railway system—then the largest in the world.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ella⸆⸉ 🏴 INDYREF2!
@JakesScarfStash
we didn’t mean DYE
New York Post
@nypost
President Trump debuts new brown hairdo - and people are shocked nypost.com/2026/09/06/us-news/president-trump-debuts-new-…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
With all respect, the article by Steryniak is full of errors.
"Monetary issues have always attracted charlatans. Often, they claim to have found a simple solution: since the Central Bank can create money—for free and without limit—why not have it finance public spending?"
This is a misreprensentation of how modern monetary systems, and by implication, the Eurozone work. Indeed, as the Eurosystem - the central bank of the Eurozone - is the only institution that is allowed to create euros, all payments by national governments are made through it. To claim otherwise means to ignore how the monetary system functions in the real world, to ignore empirical evidence in favor of armchair philosophy.
The idea that tax and bond revenues "finance" government spending is what most charlatans feel attracted to, claiming that like a household a government can run out of money. Conveniently, it follows that privatization is the only way forward to ensure "debt sustainability" for the national government. The resulting neoliberal policies have brought Europe to an economic standstill and the extreme right back to power in many regions, including Saxony-Anhalt in Germany last weekend. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
Of the 122 Chinese companies on the 2026 Fortune Global 500, 79 are classified as state-owned enterprises.
More than half are operated by the state. This is the secret to China's economic success. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X
@Xking332
The war is not ending anytime soon.
The Trump administration just sent a new peace proposal to Iran through mediators.
Iran rejected the proposal in less than an hour.
Tehran has now significantly increased its demands for a peace agreement and for the Strait of Hormuz to be reopened.
Iran had previously demanded $300 billion in compensation.
That figure has now been increased to $450 billion.
Iran is also demanding the release of another $100 billion in frozen Iranian assets.
That's $550 billion in total.
Tehran is also demanding the complete withdrawal of US troops from the Middle East.
Iran has let Trump administration know that it will not enter negotiations until Trump publicly acknowledges Iran's right to control the Strait of Hormuz.
A deadly food crisis is slowly developing in multiple countries.
Things could get a lot worse in the coming months. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Die neoliberale Wirtschaftspolitik mit Kürzungen, Kürzungen, Kürzungen ist anscheinend nicht so beliebt bei der Wählerschaft, wie es einige der Etablierten gerne hätten. Um der AfD das Wasser abzugraben, braucht es eine alternative Wirtschaftspolitik, und nicht mehr #reformen.
Nils Schniederjann
@nschniederjann
Die AfD holt 61 Prozent (!) bei Arbeiterinnen und Arbeitern.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Economics has spent the last 50 years empirically validating Feynman’s hypothesis...
"Never confuse education with intelligence, you can have a PhD and still be an idiot."
-Richard P. Feynman -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is the forgotten history of the US dependence on the auto and petroleum. It was the back plot for the movie “Who Killed Roger Rabbit?”
Basel Musharbash
@musharbash_b
What the Big Three car companies did was actually far worse than just lobbying — General Motors bought up the electric transit-car systems of 46 major cities, literally destroyed them, and replaced them with GM buses. One of the casualties of GM’s sabotage was the Los Angeles interurban electric railway system—then the largest in the world.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
“Unexpectedly”? It’s 2 months before the Midterms. I’ve been waiting for this Boss move.
China dropped oil buying 41% February to July. They’ve been quietly buying oil cargoes through August. Now they are going to bid up every tanker cargo globally until November. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Paul Romer is not an outsider attacking mainstream economics. He is considered one its most accomplished insiders, and he was accusing an influential part of macroeconomics of something much more serious than merely producing imperfect models. In his 2016 paper "The Trouble With Macroeconomics", Romer argued that “for more than three decades, macroeconomics has gone backwards” and described parts of the field as having undergone a “regression into pseudoscience.” Read more: paulromer.net/mathiness/
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What’s the odds that he’ll next propose renaming “The Sun” as “The Trump”?
We really are in Mad King territory. But this time “Apres Moi, Le Deluge” could actually happen.
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
Oh dear Lord, when will this madness stop? He might as well declare the Sun to be America's property, too, and start putting a tariff on sunlight.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jim Stewartson, Decelerationist 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇺🇸
@jimstewartson
After spending hours with Natalie yesterday posting AI slop about changing the name of New Mexico & winning a war he already lost, the demented president woke up this morning and did it all over again.
If I were the Democrats I’d get a panel of experts on psychopathologies combined with neurodegenerative disorders to discuss how existentially dangerous it is to have this man within a mile of the nuclear football.
Jim Stewartson, Decelerationist 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇺🇸
@jimstewartson
This is executive dysfunction—failure to be able to control one’s thoughts, emotions & actions. It’s caused by the “desegregation” of Trump’s brain’s salience network—which determines what you should pay attention to. It decides what matters.
Usually, delusional behavior is discouraged in dementia patients because they can become psychotic and dangerous if allowed to spiral.
It is *encouraged* in Trump. He has Natalie Harp—who acts as his EXTERNAL salience network. She decides what matters, what he should pay attention to, based on what she thinks he wants to know about. She amplifies and validates what he already believes.
This is an unprecedented dystopian science-fiction scenario. A nearly incapacitated messianic narcissistic leader of a nuclear superpower is being led around the nose by the voices in his head and a 35-year-old stalker. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Handre is so confused here he is making the exact mistake Keynes was addressing.
Keynes did not claim realized saving and investment somehow violate S = I. They are equal ex post by accounting identity.
Keynes asked what happens when households WANT to save more while firms do not WANT to invest more.
Handre simply assumes the answer that firms take every resource freed by lower consumption and redirect it into capital formation, but how can that assumption be made?
If consumers cut spending by $100, firms don't receive a divine command to build $100 of factories. They can cut output, employment and investment because their expected sales just fell.
Then income falls until actual saving once again equals investment.
S = I the entire time.
And putting money in a bank, holding cash, buying an existing bond or buying existing shares is not automatically new real investment. Financial saving and the production of new capital goods are not the same act.
Basically Handre's entire argument collapses because he confusing an accounting identity with a causal mechanism. Another prime example of why he should stick to South African political ragebait and stop embarrassing himself with economic slopbait.
Handre
@Handre
Keynes built his entire macroeconomic system on a single false premise: that saving and investment are separate, potentially divergent forces requiring government to reconcile them.
Saving and investment are not separate forces. Every dollar you save gets lent, invested, or held as cash balances that lower prices and raise real purchasing power for others. Ludwig von Mises laid this out in 1912. Saving IS investment. The act of withholding consumption releases real resources, steel, labor, time, for capital formation. No reconciliation needed.
Keynes invented the "paradox of thrift" to justify intervention. If everyone saves simultaneously, he argued, aggregate demand collapses and the economy contracts. The error here is treating the economy as a bathtub with a fixed water level rather than a dynamic network of production stages. Lower consumption spending frees resources that entrepreneurs redirect toward longer, more productive capital structures.
What Keynes gave governments was intellectual permission to punish savers through inflation and deficit spending. You pay that price every month at the grocery store. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Layne Hartsell 雷恩
@hartsellml
AI Bubble
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I show the money mechanics, the overbuild, and both paths in my new lecture here - www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD3FB9NkwSQ&views
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
These things can all be true at the same time.
China's GDP growth is slowing down but still high.
China's consumption is low, but high investment and savings are features of its highly successful development model.
China's labour standards can improve, but its real wage growth is the envy of the world. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Historian and complexity scientist @Peter_Turchin argues that what he calls a “wealth pump” has disproportionately enriched a small elite at the direct expense of everyone else. At the same time, too many people are competing to join the upper echelons of society, with too few positions available. As Turchin documents through numerous historical examples in End Times, when these forces collide, the structures holding society together begin to fracture.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Bernanke told Congress 2008 would be high growth and low unemployment. It became the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression.
I saw it coming because I took Minsky seriously. The mainstream read him after the wreckage.
We are in another bubble. Schumpeter described this a century ago: entrepreneurs disturb the circular flow, banks create the money that funds the boom, investment overshoots because every founder thinks they will own the market.
Most railway companies died in 1847. The rails remained. AI can leave the rails and delete the passengers. Workers. The people who need a wage to stay alive.
Two outcomes. Star Trek, if we pay for a UBI the only way a UBI can be paid. Hunger Games, if the people building the machines also refuse the deficit that funds the customers.
I modelled both in Ravel©.
Watch it here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD3FB9NkwSQ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I show the money mechanics, the overbuild, and both paths in my new lecture here - www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD3FB9NkwSQ&views
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Years before 2008 I was one of the few economists saying a crisis was coming.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝘊𝘰𝘳𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘦
@Corrine4o
Europe calling Chinese trade “colonisation” is fucking obscene.
Britain fought two Opium Wars against China to force open Chinese markets while British merchants flooded the country with opium.
That was colonialism.
China selling cheaper steel, chemicals, machinery and industrial components to willing European buyers is called trade.
Apparently colonialism now means:
“We opened the market, and then somebody else became better at manufacturing than us.”
And spare me the sudden tears over 300,000 European factory jobs.
When China entered the WTO era and its old industrial base went through brutal restructuring, more than 20 million of Chinese workers lost their jobs. Entire northeastern industrial communities absorbed the human cost — unemployment, broken families, lost livelihoods and despair.
Where was Europe’s civilizational mourning then?
Chinese workers were told:
adapt. compete. reform. become efficient.
Now European industry faces the same pressure and suddenly competition itself is “colonisation.”
So Chinese workers losing their livelihoods was economic reform.
European workers losing theirs is Chinese aggression.
Fascinating moral arithmetic.
And the article accidentally admits the real problem:
European companies will continue buying from China because they have shareholders to satisfy.
There it is.
China did not invade Europe.
China did not force Europe at gunpoint to buy Chinese components.
European companies are choosing Chinese suppliers because they are cheaper, faster and more competitive.
Europe taxed its energy.
Europe raised its industrial costs.
Europe regulated itself into paralysis.
Europe allowed manufacturing capacity to decay.
And now it has found the perfect explanation:
China “colonised” us.
No.
China built factories.
Europe built excuses.
If losing a manufacturing competition is colonialism, perhaps Europe should apologize again for the centuries when it practiced the real thing. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jason Smith - 上官杰文
@ShangguanJiewen
This is what a city looks like in a socialist country.
This is China. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝘊𝘰𝘳𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘦
@Corrine4o
In 1945, the United States produced more than half of the world’s manufactured goods.
Nobody called it “American overcapacity.”
Nobody warned that U.S. factories were pushing the global economy to a “breaking point.”
It was called leadership.
Today China produces roughly 30% of global manufacturing output, and suddenly we need a new vocabulary:
“overcapacity.”
“China shock.”
“deindustrialization.”
“global threat.”
Funny how industrial dominance only becomes a danger to civilization when the dominant factories stop being Western.
The problem is not overcapacity.
The problem is that the West no longer owns the capacity. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MMT for Progressives
@MMTLabour
The single biggest threat to our security is professional commentators who don't know the difference between an asset and a liability and can't grasp simple accounting. 👇
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Years before 2008 I was one of the few economists saying a crisis was coming.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The mainstream promised a soft landing after the subprime bubble. Ben Bernanke told Congress to expect high growth and low unemployment. What we got was the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Handle it well and you get something like Star Trek: humans as philosopher kings, machines doing the work. Handle it the way I think is more likely and you get Hunger Games: a tiny elite with robot slaves, and the rest of us kept poor and entertained by turning on each other.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I show the money mechanics, the overbuild, and both paths in my new lecture here - www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD3FB9NkwSQ&views
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nick Reeves #RejoinEU #NAFO #FBPE
@nickreeves9876
Farage and Reform UK are in deep trouble. However, after 3 days, @Verbatim_Media's 37 minute video of their extraordinary year-long undercover investigation into Reform UK's illegal foreign donations has only got 161k views. It should have several million.
So please repost this and then share the video.
youtu.be/RugPik-G1Jw -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Buddy Wells
@BuddyWells1
The error in your analysis is that you’re assuming that investment comes from savings, and that money supply is limited to available savings.
The reality is that investment creates savings, and investment can be funded by bank credit (money creation), so it is not limited by available savings. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Joe Walsh
@WalshFreedom
There are still way too many of us afraid to publicly state the truth about Donald Trump. It’s understandable bcuz the truth about Trump is unthinkably horrible. But to defeat Trump/Trumpism, the truth must be said.👇
Trump is a Russian asset.
Trump is a sociopath.
Trump is a fascist.
Trump is humanly incapable of telling the truth.
Trump is America’s enemy - He committed crimes trying to overthrow an American election, and he’s actively now trying to sabotage the 2026 elections. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Alerte : la Banque centrale européenne va augmenter ses taux d'intérêt. Emprunter de l'argent coûtera donc plus cher pour tout le monde : les ménages, les entreprises et l'État. Ils n'ont donc rien compris ? Nous sommes au bord de la récession économique ! Il faut une autre politique de la BCE. Les Français ne sont pas les seuls en Europe à y avoir intérêt. La BCE nous conduit dans le mur.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tiempo De Tenis
@Tiempodetenis1
Stefanos Tsitsipas habló sobre la "muerte" del revés a una mano:
🗣️ "No se trata de que yo tenga sentimientos al respecto, creo que es un hecho. Estoy diciendo lo obvio. Si lo comparas con los años 50 o 60, se ve una caída masiva del revés a una mano. En los años 50 creo que el 97% o 98% de los jugadores jugaban con revés a una mano, y hoy en día es literalmente el 2% o 3%, así que se invirtió por completo respecto a lo que solía ser".
🗣️ "El tenis siempre será tenis, sin importar si hay jugadores con revés a una mano o a dos, realmente no importa. Si el circuito está dominado por reveses a dos manos no pasa nada, es solo que siento que es un tiro tan tradicional y clásico que es una pena perderlo. ¿Se puede hacer algo al respecto? Supongo que sí. ¿Es el fin del mundo si nadie juega con revés a una mano? No, el tenis sigue adelante tal como es".
🗣️ "Pero siento que antes el tenis se jugaba con muchas variaciones de estilo distintas, y esa variedad se ha reducido a un estilo en particular hoy en día, donde todo el mundo juega más o menos igual. Las pistas se han vuelto más lentas, todos giran en torno al mismo juego y no se ven tantas personalidades en la cancha en cuanto a estilos: solíamos tener jugadores de saque y red, contragolpeadores, defensores... Ahora se ha reducido a un solo estilo de juego, y creo que tener diferentes formas de jugar era lo que hacía al tenis tan interesante".This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Bernanke told Congress 2008 would be high growth and low unemployment. It became the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression.
I saw it coming because I took Minsky seriously. The mainstream read him after the wreckage.
We are in another bubble. Schumpeter described this a century ago: entrepreneurs disturb the circular flow, banks create the money that funds the boom, investment overshoots because every founder thinks they will own the market.
Most railway companies died in 1847. The rails remained. AI can leave the rails and delete the passengers. Workers. The people who need a wage to stay alive.
Two outcomes. Star Trek, if we pay for a UBI the only way a UBI can be paid. Hunger Games, if the people building the machines also refuse the deficit that funds the customers.
I modelled both in Ravel©.
Watch it here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TD3FB9NkwSQ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
"On interest rates, Warsh dispelled a lot of nonsense with splendid candor: “We determine the path of short-term interest rates.” A brass plaque with those words should be sent to all the Washington think tanks and lobby groups that exist to prattle on about the federal budget deficit." 1/
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrew Song
@ASong408
Humans: We can’t solve global warming.
Mother Nature: Look, dumbass. I’ve been showing you how. Get sulfur high enough into the atmosphere and Earth cools. Need me to make it more obvious? Fine. Here’s a giant mountain near the equator that shoots lava into the sky.
Humans: Volcano scary.
Mother Nature: Fine. The oil and gas you’re already pulling out of the ground often comes with sulfur too. You already remove it at industrial scale with the Claus process. I literally packaged the warming fuel and the feedstock for cooling together, including sour oil and gas fields in the tropics so all have to do it make it go up.
Humans: Okay but what if we throw soup at a painting and seize the means of production?
Ben Noll
@BenNollWeather
The eruption of Anak Krakatau in Indonesia 🌋
Preliminary estimates suggest some sulfur dioxide reached the upper atmosphere — but only a tiny fraction of the amount released by Mount Pinatubo in 1991, which temporarily cooled the planet.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rafel Carretero
@RafelCarretero
El mite del dèficit.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mark Slapinski
@mark_slapinski
I'm worried about Donald Trump
After seeing all the weird shit he posted today on social media, I think he needs to be admitted to a mental institution until we figure out what's going on -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brian Krassenstein
@krassenstein
It’s confirm…. The president of the United States is absolutely INSANE.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
In brightest day, in blackest night, no evil shall escape my sight. Let those who worship evil's might beware my power... Green Lantern's light!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jeff Davies, the Energy OG
@EnergyCredit1
What the actual fuck is happening in the US?
The White House
@WhiteHouse
In brightest day, in blackest night, no evil shall escape my sight. Let those who worship evil's might beware my power... Green Lantern's light!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Elimination of extreme poverty is why the West hates China.
CPC policy is that real wages should rise in line with GDP, and rise more for the poorest in the country. Since 1980 wage rises annually have risen an average 5% a year, 7% for the poorest.
Compounding, wages double every 12 years for the poorest, 14 years on average.
94% of Chinese own a home, 80% without a mortgage.
Over the same period real wages have stagnated in the US, UK, much of the EU, impoverishing and immiserating the majority of workers as a permanent underclass. Housing is unaffordable for too many.
34% of British children are in poverty households, but bankers and oligarchs are doing very well here.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ThomasStocksAndBonds
Correct. A diurnal swing is variance within a stable system. Warming shifts the whole distribution. Economists make the same error in their damage functions, which is how you get 3C priced at ~2% of GDP.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This idiotic confusion of temperature change at a location with temperature change over time is the same mistake that economists have made to claim 3C of warming won’t be a big deal.
Dr. Matthew M. Wielicki
@MatthewWielicki
Is a couple of degrees of warming by 2100 really an emergency? Well, let's put that into context... That's about the temperature change from 8am to 10am in most major cities. Are we experiencing an emergency every morning?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mauricio Ruiz
@cmauruiz
"Close the Strait of Hormuz and you (...) lose fertilizer for American crops, helium for MRI machines (...), and about 1/2 of the world’s sulfuric acid (which comes from sour crude). No sulfuric acid, no copper. No copper, data centers and a long list of factories stall."
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The next financial crisis is not coming from the banks.
It is coming from the physical economy.
I demonstrate the data in my latest video, link in comments.
Most commentators are still watching credit spreads.
Here is what they are missing:
I saw 2008 in the debt numbers. American private debt was 150% of GDP by 2005. The growth of credit peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. I said that rate could not be sustained. When the level of private debt stopped rising, credit did not just slow. It turned negative, down to minus 5% of GDP in 2009.
That is what caused the downturn.
This time the trigger is supply, then debt service. Households pay mortgages out of wages. Firms pay corporate debt out of profits. Until the war, that was just about feasible. Close the Strait of Hormuz and you do not only lose oil. You lose fertilizer for American crops, helium for MRI machines and high-tech lines, and about half the world’s sulfuric acid. Sour crude from the Persian Gulf is where that sulfur comes from. No sulfuric acid, no copper. No copper, data centers and a long list of factories stall. Volume falls faster than price can save you. Then the interest cannot be paid.
Energy and output move one for one. I plotted energy from the IEA against gross world product from the World Bank in Ravel©. They sit on the same line. A 4% rise in one is a 4% rise in the other. COVID proved it in reverse. Mainstream models treat energy as about 4% of GDP, so a 10% energy shock becomes a 0.4% story. That is not the real world. A 10% fall in energy availability implies a 10% fall in gross world product. You cannot put more workers in the petrol tank. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tom Nichols
@RadioFreeTom
Something is very wrong with the president. And yet, still has the codes to our nuclear arsenal and is the single person who can order their use.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
A string of absolutely bonkers Truth Social posts from Trump in the span of about 10 minutes
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Ryan Katz-Rosene
@ryankatzrosene
By this logic a full-scale nuclear winter (which would reduce global mean temperatures by 5C to 10C) is no biggie. It's akin to cooling off in the evening after a warm day 👍🤓
Dr. Matthew M. Wielicki
@MatthewWielicki
Is a couple of degrees of warming by 2100 really an emergency? Well, let's put that into context... That's about the temperature change from 8am to 10am in most major cities. Are we experiencing an emergency every morning?
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Especially with using Potassium for the K! Only those with knowledge of the Periodic Table and its codes. Brilliant.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
CALL TO ACTIVISM
@CalltoActivism
🚨 Trump’s Truth Social right now is pure chaos.
What exactly is the 25th Amendment for, if not this?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Neoliberalism does not mean the reduction of the state. Instead, the state is reorganized by controlling elites to protect monopoly power and capital accumulation, often producing greater inequality and insecurity. As economist Luigi Zingales says "the greatest threat to free markets is not the working class or government regulation, but powerful business incumbents who use political influence to suppress competition."
Video credit: @INETeconomics @J_K_GalbraithThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jim Stewartson, Decelerationist 🇨🇦🇺🇦🇺🇸
@jimstewartson
This is executive dysfunction—failure to be able to control one’s thoughts, emotions & actions. It’s caused by the “desegregation” of Trump’s brain’s salience network—which determines what you should pay attention to. It decides what matters.
Usually, delusional behavior is discouraged in dementia patients because they can become psychotic and dangerous if allowed to spiral.
It is *encouraged* in Trump. He has Natalie Harp—who acts as his EXTERNAL salience network. She decides what matters, what he should pay attention to, based on what she thinks he wants to know about. She amplifies and validates what he already believes.
This is an unprecedented dystopian science-fiction scenario. A nearly incapacitated messianic narcissistic leader of a nuclear superpower is being led around the nose by the voices in his head and a 35-year-old stalker. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ray Yelle
@ryelle62
if these are being posted by Natalie Harp, then it’s inexcusable if her access isn’t revoked today
If these are being posted by Trump, it justifies voting every Republican out of Congress for enabling an 80 year-old with dementia instead of invoking the 25th amendment
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
A string of absolutely bonkers Truth Social posts from Trump in the span of about 10 minutes
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Adam Cochran (adamscochran.eth)
@adamscochran
Every single one of these would have resulted in previous presidents removed from office no matter who was in power.
There is a shadow government running the Oval Office while a senile old man has the nuclear codes.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
A string of absolutely bonkers Truth Social posts from Trump in the span of about 10 minutes
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This same dumbness lies behind William Nordhaus telling us that 4.5C of warming by 2100 will only reduce GDP by 7%.
Bob Ward
@ret_ward
This is very dumb. The difference between the average global temperature now and the average global temperature during the last ice age is about 6 Celsius degrees.
Dr. Matthew M. Wielicki
@MatthewWielicki
Is a couple of degrees of warming by 2100 really an emergency? Well, let's put that into context... That's about the temperature change from 8am to 10am in most major cities. Are we experiencing an emergency every morning?
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What’s the odds that he’ll next propose renaming “The Sun” as “The Trump”?
We really are in Mad King territory. But this time “Apres Moi, Le Deluge” could actually happen.
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
Oh dear Lord, when will this madness stop? He might as well declare the Sun to be America's property, too, and start putting a tariff on sunlight.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
This was the best photo I could find of him... Guess I could've just posted a fat guy from Florida wearing a MAGA hat.🤷♂️
"Although it is not true that all conservatives are stupid people, it is true that most stupid people are conservative."
–John Stuart Mill -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This idiotic confusion of temperature change at a location with temperature change over time is the same mistake that economists have made to claim 3C of warming won’t be a big deal.
Dr. Matthew M. Wielicki
@MatthewWielicki
Is a couple of degrees of warming by 2100 really an emergency? Well, let's put that into context... That's about the temperature change from 8am to 10am in most major cities. Are we experiencing an emergency every morning?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
The man with the nuclear codes. You'd be concerned if these were being posted by an elderly relative.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
A string of absolutely bonkers Truth Social posts from Trump in the span of about 10 minutes
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Daniel Davis Deep Dive
@DanielLDavis1
It’s time to stop making excuses for President Trump, claiming that everything is a joke. “Joking” about choosing to launch nuclear war is evidence of dangerous detachment from any basic level of understanding his job: he’s supposed to keep us safe *from* nuclear war; not spawn one.
And obviously, it’s not just this problematic one post. He has been obsessed with posting AI images of himself in all sorts of fantasy environment, for months (and dozens today) which is something a commander-in-chief in his right mind would never do.
It is time to acknowledge President Trump is suffering serious cognitive decline. We allow this to go on unchecked to our collective peril.
If we don’t take constitutional measures to correct this deficiency while there is still time, we may invite destruction on ourselves. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
I'm selling my diesel truck. It's clear the diesel shock is going to get VERY bad. I have to reserve the diesel storage I have for tractors and ranch equipment. But for regular transportation, I'm going to be purchasing an EV that's refueled from 100% sunlight (no grid power). Hence the need for solar+battery infrastructure.
If you are wise, you will consider these actions for yourself. This war with Iran isn't ending anytime soon. The diesel supply shock will be catastrophic.
This clip is from my recent podcast at Bright Videos.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Doug Henwood
@DougHenwood
This man is truly, deeply insane.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
In brightest day, in blackest night, no evil shall escape my sight. Let those who worship evil's might beware my power... Green Lantern's light!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Doug Cameron
@DougCameron51
A US Admiral flies in to exercise control over what is a US base on Australian soil. AUKUS is a humiliating surrender of sovereignty to Labor’s US masters. Why has caucus allowed Marles to turn our nation into a servile, simpering, servant of Trump and the US military machine? 🤬
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
And he has sole nuclear launch authority.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
A string of absolutely bonkers Truth Social posts from Trump in the span of about 10 minutes
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I predicted 2008 when American private debt hit 150% of GDP and credit growth peaked at 15% of GDP.
This time the crash is not a bank boom that goes bust.
It is a 10% fall in energy availability. On the real data that means a 10% fall in gross world product. Mainstream models call that a 0.4% shrug.
I have just exposed the full breakdown.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgLAfG1DMOU
#economics #financialcrisisPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Good grief. As well as being flat out wrong, the person you cite as an example of how to do it, @Peter_Turchin, also uses ODEs in his mathematical modelling of history! We are kindred spirits in that sense, and here you are portraying us as opposites.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Pyne 🇺🇸
@AmericaFirstCon
The Hormuz Report has reposted my breaking news post which went viral yesterday with 1.3 million views. It repeated my assertion that this was the first time in history that hypersonic missiles had been fired against a US aircraft carrier, used my term 'carrier killer' for the Qassem Bassir ASBM, and repeated my claim that it reaches speeds of Mach 5 to Mach 8.
The Qassem Bassir ASBM is very advanced technologically and is maneuverable in its terminal phase with similar characteristics to China's much feared DF-21D 'carrier killer' ASBM. It may have been designed with Chinese technical assistance.
In addition, like the DF-21D it is likely nuclear-capable. The US does not possess any hypersonic, let alone any supersonic, anti-ship missiles of any kind nor does it have any Anti-Ship Ballistic Missiles in its arsenal.
Iran only fired a handful of missiles at US warships yesterday as warning shots to warn the US to end its naval blockade. If Iran decided it actually wanted to sink a US aircraft carrier, it could launch 160 subsonic cruise missiles to deplete the missile defense interceptors of one of our carrier battlegroups assuming each one has only two destroyer escorts or 240 if they have three. Then, Iran could fire 20 hypersonic missiles to target and sink it.
This would be a nightmare scenario for US military planners and a huge blow to US prestige that would force Trump to end the US naval blockade against Iran or pethaps escalate to the non-strategic nuclear level incentivizing Iran to destroy the US critical infrastructure with a massive cyber and/of super EMP attack.
It is Iran's anti-ship missile supremacy over the US in the Persian Gulf region that ensures the US Navy will never be able to wrest control of the Strait of Hormuz and the Persian Gulf from Iran which at this point is Trump's main objective.
Accordingly, the war is objectively unwinnable for us and the US should pull all its forces 250 miles away from Iran's borders and end the US naval blockade so Iran will have no reason to keep the Strait closed to maritime traffic. This may be the only way to avert the US Navy potentially suffering even more military casualties than we suffered at Pearl Harbor in a single day.
The Hormuz Report
@HormuzReport
BREAKING: FOR THE FIRST TIME EVER, Iran has directly fired its Qassem Bassir hypersonic “CARRIER KILLER” anti-ship ballistic missile at a U.S. nuclear aircraft carrier — targeting the USS George Washington and an accompanying destroyer yesterday, per Iranian sources familiar with the assessment.
The Qassem Bassir reportedly reaches MACH 5–8 during its terminal phase and uses optical/electro-optical guidance, making it exceptionally difficult to intercept.
This marks a HISTORIC escalation in the war: Iran has demonstrated its willingness to directly target U.S. carrier strike groups with advanced anti-ship ballistic missiles.
An Iranian source is now warning that Tehran will ESCALATE FURTHER to BREAK THE BLOCKADE, signaling that the carrier strike may be only the beginning of a broader Iranian campaign against U.S. naval forces. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Watch the full breakdown here:
youtu.be/OgLAfG1DMOU
Let me know your thoughts in the YouTube comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The next financial crisis is not coming from the banks.
It is coming from the physical economy.
I demonstrate the data in my latest video, link in comments.
Most commentators are still watching credit spreads.
Here is what they are missing:
I saw 2008 in the debt numbers. American private debt was 150% of GDP by 2005. The growth of credit peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. I said that rate could not be sustained. When the level of private debt stopped rising, credit did not just slow. It turned negative, down to minus 5% of GDP in 2009.
That is what caused the downturn.
This time the trigger is supply, then debt service. Households pay mortgages out of wages. Firms pay corporate debt out of profits. Until the war, that was just about feasible. Close the Strait of Hormuz and you do not only lose oil. You lose fertilizer for American crops, helium for MRI machines and high-tech lines, and about half the world’s sulfuric acid. Sour crude from the Persian Gulf is where that sulfur comes from. No sulfuric acid, no copper. No copper, data centers and a long list of factories stall. Volume falls faster than price can save you. Then the interest cannot be paid.
Energy and output move one for one. I plotted energy from the IEA against gross world product from the World Bank in Ravel©. They sit on the same line. A 4% rise in one is a 4% rise in the other. COVID proved it in reverse. Mainstream models treat energy as about 4% of GDP, so a 10% energy shock becomes a 0.4% story. That is not the real world. A 10% fall in energy availability implies a 10% fall in gross world product. You cannot put more workers in the petrol tank. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
1/ I first warned in December 2005. American private debt was 150% of GDP and still climbing. Credit growth peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. That rate could not last.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Gloninger, CCM, CBM
@ChrisGloninger
The last ice age was about 5°C cooler globally and Boston sat under a mile of ice. Nobody's alarmed about 8am to 10am because the mean doesn't move. Shift the mean and you get ice sheets or you get Miami underwater. A geologist should know the difference between a daily cycle and the baseline it cycles around.
This buffoon doesn’t have a clue about climate, but yet he is running @usgcrp!
Dr. Matthew M. Wielicki
@MatthewWielicki
Is a couple of degrees of warming by 2100 really an emergency? Well, let's put that into context... That's about the temperature change from 8am to 10am in most major cities. Are we experiencing an emergency every morning?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jean-Luc Mélenchon
@JLMelenchon
Ça suffit le coup du soit disant prix Nobel d'économie. Ce n'est pas le même prix Nobel que celui de médecine ou de physique. C'est le prix créé par une banque suédoise qu'ils ont eux-mêmes appelé "Nobel" en prétendu hommage à l'inventeur de la dynamite. Ce monsieur qui fait la leçon est un des conseillers qui a conduit aux 3000 milliards de dette de notre pays.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bavi
@vazbavi
Alan Ritchson says he quit modeling after an agent kept sending him to people trying to molest him, then ran into that same agent at the Reacher premiere
"I remember I almost punched an agent in the face because I had told them to stop sending me to people who were trying to molest me on these jobs."
"I was like, I just need to eat. That's all I'm here for."
"I went straight to that agency. I pulled this dude out of his chair. And I was like, I'm gonna kill you, dude. You knew exactly. He's like, I know, I know."
"Don't ever call me again. I'm done. That was the last thing I ever do in this business."
"The night of my Reacher premiere for season one, I ran into this dude at the lobby."
"He really started my acting career out of just a pure hatred for where I was in that business."
"It was like confirmation that I survived it well and did the right thing."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Patricia Mano
@ManoPatric61990
Keen inverte o olhar dominante. Diz que a próxima crise não virá dos bancos, como em 2008, mas da economia física.
Em 2008 ele leu a crise nos números da dívida: a dívida privada americana chegou a 150% do PIB em 2005, com o crescimento do crédito a equivaler a 15% do PIB em 2006. Quando esse nível deixou de subir, o crédito não abrandou - tornou-se negativo, -5% do PIB em 2009. Foi isso que causou a recessão.
Desta vez, o gatilho é a oferta e depois o serviço da dívida. Famílias pagam hipotecas com salários, empresas pagam dívida com lucros. Até à guerra, era exequível. Mas fechar o Estreito de Ormuz não é só perder petróleo. É perder fertilizante para as colheitas americanas, hélio para máquinas de ressonância magnética e para a alta tecnologia, e cerca de metade do ácido sulfúrico mundial - que vem do crude azedo do Golfo. Sem ácido sulfúrico, não há cobre. Sem cobre, param data centers e cadeias industriais inteiras. O volume cai mais depressa do que o preço pode compensar. E então o juro não se consegue pagar.
A tese central: energia e produto movem-se um para um. Keen diz ter plotado dados da IEA sobre energia e do Banco Mundial sobre PIB mundial e as duas curvas coincidem. 4% de subida numa é 4% na outra. A COVID provou-o ao contrário.
Os modelos convencionais, que tratam a energia como apenas 4% do PIB e transformam um choque energético de 10% numa história de 0,4% no PIB, falham a realidade. No mundo real, 10% de queda na energia disponível é 10% de queda no produto mundial. Como ele resume: não se podem pôr mais trabalhadores no depósito de gasolina.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The next financial crisis is not coming from the banks.
It is coming from the physical economy.
I demonstrate the data in my latest video, link in comments.
Most commentators are still watching credit spreads.
Here is what they are missing:
I saw 2008 in the debt numbers. American private debt was 150% of GDP by 2005. The growth of credit peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. I said that rate could not be sustained. When the level of private debt stopped rising, credit did not just slow. It turned negative, down to minus 5% of GDP in 2009.
That is what caused the downturn.
This time the trigger is supply, then debt service. Households pay mortgages out of wages. Firms pay corporate debt out of profits. Until the war, that was just about feasible. Close the Strait of Hormuz and you do not only lose oil. You lose fertilizer for American crops, helium for MRI machines and high-tech lines, and about half the world’s sulfuric acid. Sour crude from the Persian Gulf is where that sulfur comes from. No sulfuric acid, no copper. No copper, data centers and a long list of factories stall. Volume falls faster than price can save you. Then the interest cannot be paid.
Energy and output move one for one. I plotted energy from the IEA against gross world product from the World Bank in Ravel©. They sit on the same line. A 4% rise in one is a 4% rise in the other. COVID proved it in reverse. Mainstream models treat energy as about 4% of GDP, so a 10% energy shock becomes a 0.4% story. That is not the real world. A 10% fall in energy availability implies a 10% fall in gross world product. You cannot put more workers in the petrol tank. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Doonesbury by Garry Trudeau for September 06, 2026 production.doonesbury.com/doonesbury/strip/archive/2026/0… via @GoComics The Duke returns to the @realDonaldTrump team.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
pet rock
@petrock
That reminds me of Krugman stashing his funds in a bank, "which lends them out to someone else." So what you're saying, Steve, "isn't right in any model" that Paul understands!
archive.nytimes.com/krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/03/27/… -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The next financial crisis is not coming from the banks.
It is coming from the physical economy.
I demonstrate the data in my latest video, link in comments.
Most commentators are still watching credit spreads.
Here is what they are missing:
I saw 2008 in the debt numbers. American private debt was 150% of GDP by 2005. The growth of credit peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. I said that rate could not be sustained. When the level of private debt stopped rising, credit did not just slow. It turned negative, down to minus 5% of GDP in 2009.
That is what caused the downturn.
This time the trigger is supply, then debt service. Households pay mortgages out of wages. Firms pay corporate debt out of profits. Until the war, that was just about feasible. Close the Strait of Hormuz and you do not only lose oil. You lose fertilizer for American crops, helium for MRI machines and high-tech lines, and about half the world’s sulfuric acid. Sour crude from the Persian Gulf is where that sulfur comes from. No sulfuric acid, no copper. No copper, data centers and a long list of factories stall. Volume falls faster than price can save you. Then the interest cannot be paid.
Energy and output move one for one. I plotted energy from the IEA against gross world product from the World Bank in Ravel©. They sit on the same line. A 4% rise in one is a 4% rise in the other. COVID proved it in reverse. Mainstream models treat energy as about 4% of GDP, so a 10% energy shock becomes a 0.4% story. That is not the real world. A 10% fall in energy availability implies a 10% fall in gross world product. You cannot put more workers in the petrol tank.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Watch the full breakdown here:
youtu.be/OgLAfG1DMOU
Let me know your thoughts in the YouTube comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
1/ I first warned in December 2005. American private debt was 150% of GDP and still climbing. Credit growth peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. That rate could not last.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
8/ I was early on 2008 because I watched private debt. Watch the physical economy this time.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Full video:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgLAfG1DMOU
#economics #financialcrisis -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What actually caused the greatest downturn in the history of capitalism?
In my presentation, I argue as Irving Fisher did in 1933 that it wasn’t “panic,” “technology shocks,” or just “the Fed,” but a collapse in credit-based demand at a time of very low inflation, after private debt had already become dangerously high.
Using historical data, I show how US credit shifted from roughly +8–10% of GDP in the 1920s to about −30% in the early 1930s, while inflation went from roughly zero to −10% per year.
That combination of over‑indebtedness and deflation—the debt disease and price‑level disease—meant that the more debtors paid down their loans, the heavier their real debt burden became.
I also explain why mainstream (neoclassical) economists ignored Fisher’s debt‑deflation theory, left banks and private debt out of their models, and focused instead on equilibrium stories and “loanable funds” where bank lending has no macroeconomic impact.
That intellectual blind spot is exactly why they failed to anticipate the Global Financial Crisis, even as private debt more than tripled relative to GDP between the end of World War II and 2007.
Lastly, I contrast the fantasy banking model with a realistic one using my Ravel software and show how turning credit negative shrinks the money supply and drags GDP down—precisely what happened in the early 1930s and again after 2008.
I also highlight the crucial role of government spending: from the New Deal to World War II to the post‑2008 deficits that quietly stopped another Great Depression.
Watch here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6zxzgViT9M
#economics #finance #greatdepression #privatedebt #macroeconomics #banking -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Huizenmarkt Zeepbel
@huizenprijzen
The Debt-Deflation Theory of Great Depressions.
#irvingfisher #debtdeflation
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What actually caused the greatest downturn in the history of capitalism?
In my presentation, I argue as Irving Fisher did in 1933 that it wasn’t “panic,” “technology shocks,” or just “the Fed,” but a collapse in credit-based demand at a time of very low inflation, after private debt had already become dangerously high.
Using historical data, I show how US credit shifted from roughly +8–10% of GDP in the 1920s to about −30% in the early 1930s, while inflation went from roughly zero to −10% per year.
That combination of over‑indebtedness and deflation—the debt disease and price‑level disease—meant that the more debtors paid down their loans, the heavier their real debt burden became.
I also explain why mainstream (neoclassical) economists ignored Fisher’s debt‑deflation theory, left banks and private debt out of their models, and focused instead on equilibrium stories and “loanable funds” where bank lending has no macroeconomic impact.
That intellectual blind spot is exactly why they failed to anticipate the Global Financial Crisis, even as private debt more than tripled relative to GDP between the end of World War II and 2007.
Lastly, I contrast the fantasy banking model with a realistic one using my Ravel software and show how turning credit negative shrinks the money supply and drags GDP down—precisely what happened in the early 1930s and again after 2008.
I also highlight the crucial role of government spending: from the New Deal to World War II to the post‑2008 deficits that quietly stopped another Great Depression.
Watch here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6zxzgViT9M
#economics #finance #greatdepression #privatedebt #macroeconomics #banking -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bez(os) Mastodon @Bez78829056@indieweb.social
@Bez78829056
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Trump Derangement Syndrome, anyone?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hussain “Hoz” Shafiei
@HussainShafiei
You have been warned, get the fuck out of our region.
This is not America, Go Home Yankee
Seyed Mohammad Marandi
@s_m_marandi
All US naval ships are now targets. Any strikes on Iranian ships will be met with multiple strikes on vessels linked to countries participating in the anti-Iranian aggression.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Golden Mean
@TheGoldenMean2
Singapore’s ex-FM George Yeo: Instead of the name of a political system, judge a society by the condition of its bottom 10%. By this measure, the people of China fare better than those of any other major country—a testament to the effectiveness of Chinese democracy.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jesus Chrysler
@JesusChryslerII
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oscar
@HeyOscarx
He said the first thing most people don't realize is that EssilorLuxottica isn't a big company. It's the entire industry — pretending to be hundreds of separate companies.
EssilorLuxottica is a Franco-Italian conglomerate with nearly $29 billion in annual revenue, over 200,000 employees, 17,750+ retail stores, 600+ factories and distribution centers across 150 countries. It is the largest eyewear company on Earth — by a margin so wide that calling it a "company" understates the reality. It's more accurately described as the industry itself.
"When you walk into a mall and see LensCrafters on one end and Sunglass Hut on the other and Pearle Vision across the street and Target Optical inside Target — you think you're seeing 4 different companies competing for your business. You're seeing one company selling to itself in 4 different storefronts. The competition is theater. The prices are set by the same corporate entity. And the frames in every single one of those stores came from the same factory complex in Agordo, Italy."
He said the brand portfolio is what makes the monopoly invisible.
"EssilorLuxottica owns outright: Ray-Ban. Oakley. Persol. Oliver Peoples. Costa Del Mar. Arnette. Vogue Eyewear. Alain Mikli. They manufacture under licensing agreements for: Prada. Chanel. Versace. Dolce & Gabbana. Burberry. Giorgio Armani. Ralph Lauren. Michael Kors. Coach. Tiffany. Valentino. Tory Burch. Bulgari. That's over 80 brand names. When you pick up a pair of 'Prada' glasses at your optometrist, they were not designed by Prada. They were not crafted in a Prada studio. They were made on a Luxottica production line, in a Luxottica factory, by Luxottica workers. Prada collected a licensing royalty. Luxottica set the price. You paid $400 for a $4 frame with a Prada sticker on the temple."
He said most people react with disbelief when they see the full ownership map.
"They think Ray-Ban and Oakley are competitors. They're siblings. They think LensCrafters and Pearle Vision are different companies. They're the same company. They think choosing between Target Optical and Sunglass Hut is comparison shopping. It's choosing which Luxottica store to give Luxottica money in. The entire illusion of choice in the eyewear industry is controlled by one entity." -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
HealthRanger
@HealthRanger
We are facing a serious DIESEL CRISIS that was just made far worse by the U.S. and Iran strikes on tankers in the Persian Gulf. The world's economies are going to burn, and the diesel crack spread is going to skyrocket beyond $120 / barrel before long. Food inflation is going to worsen sharply before the coming election. This clip is from my diesel supply shock alert podcast on Bright Videos.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Object Zero
@Object_Zero_
Giant Foundry Press
If you want to make nuclear reactor pressure vessels, wellheads, naval cannons, mega crane hooks and tackle, marine crankshafts, basically anything worthy of sci-fi cinema…
You need a foundry with a big press, so that you can forge big ingots, and work harden big forgings.
You also need an appropriately sized quench bath.
Then you need 30 years of cumulative competence with the equipment across your plant operators, your metallurgists and your quality inspectors…
Then you can make these things.
The horrible truth is that some things are so big they take 4 weeks to cool down (it’s the square-cube law), you can only make 10 per year… it takes a decade of practice to get good.
For 10 years almost everything you make will be poor, it will take 3 years of operation just to calibrate your equipment.
If you lose this stuff you never get it back, once you lose the last giant press your industrial base starts to unravel, lead times on critical components jump from 8 months to 40 months, it’s suddenly takes 5 years to repair a downed bridge, laypeople don’t understand why...
This is why.
Only 5 countries in the world can make giant ingots; China, Russia, Japan, South Korea and France… Italy and Germany the recent casualties, India probably ascend to make it 6 in a decade or so. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“We inhabit a universe where atoms are made in the centers of stars; where each second a thousand suns are born; where life is sparked by sunlight and lightning in the airs and waters of youthful planets; where the raw material for biological evolution is sometimes made by the explosion of a star halfway across the Milky Way; where a thing as beautiful as a galaxy is formed a hundred billion times - a Cosmos of quasars and quarks, snowflakes and fireflies, where there may be black holes and other universe and extraterrestrial civilizations whose radio messages are at this moment reaching the Earth. How pallid by comparison are the pretensions of superstition and pseudoscience; how important it is for us to pursue and understand science, that characteristically human endeavor.”
- Carl Sagan, Cosmos -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Doonesbury by Garry Trudeau for September 06, 2026 production.doonesbury.com/doonesbury/strip/archive/2026/0… via @GoComics The Duke returns to the @realDonaldTrump team.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
Earning a living wage matters.
But people also need power, belonging, community, and some reason to believe the system isn’t just built for people with private jets.
🎧 ➡️ pitchforkeconomics.com/episode/profit-power-and-the-crisi… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Only captured academics economists put any faith in DSGE models for answers.
The only hero here is me for calling out this bullshit.
And saying MMT economists should have put their theory into a DSGE model to evaluate it properly is pretty funny, why would you take a stock-flow consistent monetary theory and decide the proper test of it is whether it works after being reconstructed inside a completely different theoretical framework with different assumptions about behavior, expectations and equilibrium?
You haven't tested the theory at that point, you've tested your DSGE interpretation of it.
Give your head a shake..
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Some heroes even went above and beyond the call of duty by putting some of their ideas into a DSGE model to evaluate them properly (which the MMT folks should have done themselves):
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ijfe.2955
BTW, I never worked on any of this and dug that paper up in two minutes. How hard are the MMT fans trying to find anything before they say none of us bothered to put in any effort? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
X
@Xking332
Iran is preparing to keep the UAE, Saudi, Kuwait and Bahrain trapped for years.
The IRGC is planning for a series of preemptive bombings against critical energy infrastructure in the next two weeks.
The US government has now issued warnings to its citizens in the UAE, Bahrain and Kuwait about future attacks.
Including attacks on hotels and civilian infrastructure.
Airports could get shut down for months.
The IRGC's primary objective is now to pressure Trump by imposing crippling military and economic costs.
The next objective is to bring about a global food crisis by keeping the Strait of Hormuz closed.
The upcoming energy and food crisis could become the deadliest catastrophe in history.
20 times worse than COVID.
Lockdowns, riots, robberies and crimes of all kinds could become normalized in multiple countries.
Several governments could collapse under pressure from their people.
The WFP estimates more than 90 million people could starve in the coming months if the Strait of Hormuz remains closed.
USDA report: 14 million American children are already starving.
Iran destroyed two US Navy warships yesterday.
Then the US destroyed three IRGC oil tankers.
Now Iran has launched missiles at US warships once again.
Trump will most likely launch a large scale attack against Iran's infrastructure and civilians within the next 48 hours.
This is once again leading to Iran bombing the Middle East.
Trump is trapped.
This is a forever war now. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
The strange death of western liberty
That's the title of the new book George is writing. And he recalls his one conversation with Mrs Thatcher after he made a speech warning against a resurgent Germany. 'I rather agree with that' she whispered
Watch #moats Live every Sunday & Wednesday 7PM London Time
Follow @moatstv 583 #mrsthatcher #germanrearmament #bookdeal #libertyThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Seyed Mohammad Marandi
@s_m_marandi
Then Iran will destroy — and sink — the tankers of your proxies in the Persian Gulf. Their oil tanker fleets are defenseless.
You with me, or did that go over your head?
Pete Hegseth
@PeteHegseth
It’s simple: if Iran shoots at U.S. ships, we will destroy (and sink) their oil tankers. All they have to do is not shoot at @USNavy.
Iran’s oil tanker fleet is defenseless — Iran has no navy or air force. Our planes, ships & subs can strike them all, in @CENTCOM & @USPACOM.
U.S. Central Command
@CENTCOM
“Let the message to the IRGC be clear: If you shoot at two of our ships, we will impose an even higher economic cost —taking out three of yours. We will not hesitate to defend American forces, and if necessary, destroy Iran’s limited and exposed oil fleet.” — Adm. Brad Cooper, CENTCOM commander.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stefanos Tsitsipas
@stefanos
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
The problem isn’t that profit exists.
The problem is when profit becomes the boss of things that should serve people first: health care, public safety, childhood, community.
What parts of life should not be built around extracting the absolute most money possible? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Oscar
@HeyOscarx
Your glasses cost $5 to make. You paid $300. And one company you've never heard of is the reason why.
Luxottica owns Ray-Ban. They own Oakley. They own Persol. They own Oliver Peoples. They own Costa. They own Arnette. They make the glasses for Prada, Chanel, Versace, Dolce & Gabbana, Burberry, Giorgio Armani, and Michael Kors. They own LensCrafters. They own Pearle Vision. They own Sunglass Hut. They own Target Optical. They own the online retailer glasses.com. They own EyeMed the vision insurance provider that tells you where to buy your glasses. And they own the lab that makes your lenses.
One company controls the frames. The brands. The stores. The insurance. The lenses. And the price.
A guy spent 11 years working in the optical industry 4 in a lab making lenses, 3 managing a retail optical store, 4 consulting for independent eyewear brands trying to compete with Luxottica.
He told me: "The frame on your face cost between $2 and $5 to manufacture. The lenses cost $1.50 to $3. You paid $300–$700. That's not a markup. That's a scheme. And it only works because one corporation owns every step between the factory and your face and nobody knows it."
"There are 4 billion people on Earth who need vision correction. Most of them are paying a 1,000%–2,000% markup on a medical device they literally cannot live without because the entire industry from factory to face is controlled by one company pretending to be 50 different brands."
"The glasses on your face right now are almost certainly made in the same Italian factory as every 'luxury' brand on the wall at Sunglass Hut the store that Luxottica also owns."
Here are 10 things the glasses industry doesn't want you to know and exactly how to stop overpaying for a product that costs less than your morning coffee to make:
🧵 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Economics is basically like the medieval Catholic Church. You are always at risk of excommunication.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
“Economics” needs a revolution.
Evolution is not going to cut it in time.
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Economics is basically like the medieval Catholic Church. You are always at risk of excommunication.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard D Boyle
@Richard_D_Boyle
We are ready to expose the crimes of the Australian Tax Office and Government of Australia.
You won’t believe the scale of the scam.
We have names.
We have receipts.
I believe current and former politicians from both sides of the aisle are complicit.
#auspol #truth #uapx ⚖️ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Phoenix Atheist
@AtheistPhoenix
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tally Sticks
@widespreadhaze
Pensions are fundamentally a future production problem, not a financial one. Private pensions accumulate financial assets, while State Pensions create rule-based entitlements to future payments. Neither stores the goods and services that pensioners will consume in 35 years’ time.
Those financial claims and entitlements will ultimately be exercised against the output being produced then. If future productive capacity is insufficient relative to the purchasing power seeking to command it, the result is competition for scarce real resources and potentially higher prices.
The solution is therefore to increase the economy’s future productive capacity through investment today, not simply to reduce future pension payments. Cutting nominal claims today does not create the required additional goods and services tomorrow. Worse, if spending cuts reduce investment, skills, infrastructure or productive capacity today, they will leave both workers and pensioners poorer in real terms tomorrow. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marina Purkiss
@MarinaPurkiss
Just rename BBC News “Nigel says” and be done with it…
BBC News (UK)
@BBCNews
Farage says his aides' donor comments were 'loose pub talk' www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3eqvyj5qg5o
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Workers Party of Britain
@WorkersPartyGB
The debanking of our Leader George Galloway is the new normal, political dissenters unplugged from the most basic requirements to function in modern life. This is how the regime blacklist you from society.
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
39 years ago I opened a personal bank account with Bank of Scotland in Byres Rd Glasgow. Yesterday without explanation or notice they closed my accounts. My parliamentary and old age pensions are paid into these accounts. The mortgage on our family home is paid out of them. The mortgage is with them. They haven’t heard the last of this. @LloydsBank @KRWLaw
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Join us on Sunday September 6 at noon EDT for a panel titled “Permanent Crisis/Permanent War? Who wants it? Who benefits? Who cares?”
RSVP here: shorturl.at/OS1l0 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
Huh. So, all the talk about "public debt" being out of control was just hiding the fact that there is a huge problem with "private credit"?
It is so funny that they all write about "public debt" and "private credit". Credit is debt, debt is credit! 🦉
Barchart
@Barchart
BREAKING 🚨: Private Credit
Blackstone just restricted withdrawals from its flagship private credit fund for the 2nd consecutive quarter, allowing investors to pull only half of the 10% requested 🤯 👀 Wealthy investors are racing for the exits!!! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Could wages start improving? Full article in the next post.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Canadian Prepper
@PrepperCanadian
You cannot issue the global reserve currency and enjoy the privilege of printing the money the world uses without also running trade deficits. This is called Triffin’s dilemma: you give other countries PAPER, and they give you ACTUAL GOODS because you have, or had, the world’s most powerful military policing global trade routes.
Foreign investors and governments hold roughly $10 trillion in US debt. Instead of blowing $1 trillion a year on a military that cannot even defeat a small nation suffocated by sanctions for 40 years, that money could have been invested in infrastructure that generated real economic returns.
Now Karen is mad because she squandered her best years partying and spending recklessly, yet somehow thinks the rest of the world should cover the bill.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump says the US would “save” $90 billion by cutting off trade with Canada 🥴
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Swish 🍒 Tennis
@Zwxsh
It's not even an exaggeration when I say that this remains the absolute greatest shot I've ever seen.
All-time. This is number 1. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
“For activities involving foreign intelligence services.”
My God, Artem Kirpichenok might just as well be accused of being in contact with aliens.
Arrests like this resemble human sacrifice: their only purpose is to unite society around a common danger and hatred of an "enemy."
This is what Israeli authorities permitted to be published today following the court hearing:
“An Israeli citizen has been charged with security offences over his alleged activities with foreign intelligence services against Israel. He was arrested and questioned by the Shin Bet and the police. According to the investigation, he was directed by foreign intelligence operatives and was involved in foreign influence activities. At the conclusion of the investigation, an indictment was filed against him, together with a request that he remain in custody until the end of the proceedings. On Friday, following a request by Haaretz, the court permitted these details to be published.
The Israeli citizen was arrested one month ago after landing at Ben Gurion Airport. Because of the seriousness of the alleged offences, he was prohibited from meeting his lawyer for twenty days. Owing to the sensitivity of the case, only a small team within the police and the Central District Prosecutor’s Office was involved. State Attorney Amit Aisman and Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara also participated in the investigation. The defendant’s detention was extended several times before the indictment was filed.
The citizen’s lawyer told Haaretz that ‘he never had access to any security information or any other information connected to Israel.’ She added that he visited Israel only once every few years and stayed for very short periods. According to her, he ‘caused no harm and could not have caused any harm to state security,’ and ‘was never asked to provide any information connected to Israel.’” -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“If we become even slightly more violent, shortsighted, ignorant, and selfish than we are now, almost certainly we will have no future.”
— Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Zachary Foster
@_ZachFoster
The universe has served up more justice to Apartheid Israel than all international legal institutions combined.
5 out of 6 desalination plants in Israel have been shut down due to a sudden, massive algal bloom in the Mediterranean Sea.
It was brought on by the large amounts of raw sewage being discharged into the Mediterranean from Gaza, the result of Apartheid Israel's military's destruction of sewage treatment plants and sewage pipes in the Strip during the war. www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2026-09-04/ty-article-o… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
It’s a source of real pride for me to have @GDPDynamics competing alongside the @NYFedResearch and @AtlantaFed nowcasts.
In the very first quarter running the GDP Dynamics model, the Q3 estimates are:
GDP Dynamics: 2.4%
NY Fed Nowcast: 2.3%
Atlanta Fed GDPNow: 4.8% -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
"It is the export surplus and the budget deficit which enable the capitalists to make profits over and above their own purchases of goods and services. The connection between 'external' profits and imperialism is obvious."
-Michał Kalecki
The first part of Kalecki's argument is essentially an accounting identity. Investment and capitalist consumption generate profits within the capitalist sector, while government deficits and trade surpluses can provide additional demand from outside it. This doesn't mean deficits mechanically determine profits, but it shows why fiscal balances and foreign demand matter so much for aggregate profitability.
His final point goes further: access to foreign markets can provide another outlet for production and profits, which is where Kalecki connects the economics of external surpluses to imperialism. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
GDP Dynamics Q3 nowcast slips 0.03 pp to 2.39% SAAR.
Domestic demand strengthened underneath the headline, but net exports and government more than offset the gains.
Article in the next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
You know neoliberal economics is in trouble when even the cartoons have had enough. Special guests @RBReich @RealHughJackman.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Voice of Rabbis
@voiceofrabbis
First picture from today’s historic rabbinical visit with President Trump at the White House!
A powerful moment as these leaders represent over 100,000 anti-Zionist Orthodox American Jews who separate their religion from the State of Israel. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
2022 war schon klar, dass es ohne günstige Energie keine erfolgreiche Exportwirtschaft geben kann. Jetzt kauft Mercedes für €1 Mrd. Aktien zurück und VW kürzt sich weiter in die Krise.
Wir brauchen eine andere Industrie-/Energie-/Wirtschafts-politik.
elibrary.duncker-humblot.com/article/68454/die-eurozone-u… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
My solicitor Kevin Winters of @KRWLaw has sent a powerful letter before action to you @LloydsBank You are in breach of the law. I will not stand by while you use your usurious power to wreck my family life.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Grace Blakeley
@graceblakeley
You’re going to hear a lot about how this crisis is about government borrowing levels. That’s largely bullshit.
The cause of the global bond sell-off was investors freaking out about inflation - not governments spending too much money.
graceblakeley.substack.com/p/whos-afraid-of-the-bond-vigi… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kate Smith
@KateSmith819607
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Government money creation, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/government-money-creation?r=…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Peter💚🤍💜 🏴 🇳🇿
@WingsEcosse
Pay attention to this. Classical economics is bunkum. Prof Keen runs dynamic models which include things like private and commercial debt and money creation.
Money doesn’t appear in Classical models.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I predicted 2008 when American private debt hit 150% of GDP and credit growth peaked at 15% of GDP.
This time the crash is not a bank boom that goes bust.
It is a 10% fall in energy availability. On the real data that means a 10% fall in gross world product. Mainstream models call that a 0.4% shrug.
I have just exposed the full breakdown.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgLAfG1DMOU
#economics #financialcrisis -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Ullrich
@DavidUllrich202
The Uninhabitable Earth: Life After Warming
It is worse, much worse, than you think. If your anxiety about global warming is dominated by fears of sea-level rise, you are barely scratching the surface of what terrors are possible—food shortages, refugee emergencies, climate wars and economic devastation.
An “epoch-defining book” (The Guardian) and “this generation’s Silent Spring” (The Washington Post), The Uninhabitable Earth is both a travelogue of the near future and a meditation on how that future will look to those living through it—the ways that warming promises to transform global politics, the meaning of technology and nature in the modern world, the sustainability of capitalism and the trajectory of human progress.
The Uninhabitable Earth is also an impassioned call to action. For just as the world was brought to the brink of catastrophe within the span of a lifetime, the responsibility to avoid it now belongs to a single generation—today’s.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/586541/the-uninhabitable…
drive.google.com/file/d/1Bc-ak1qiYhZx5t8uCAbcMN9kb3lYfZYA…
Credit: David Wallace-Wells — Penguin -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Government money creation, by @ProfSteveKeen profstevekeen.substack.com/p/government-money-creation?r=…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John_Hempton
@John_Hempton
The number of really fancy properties in Sydney that are turning in as mortgagee in possession is increasing.
Some of the impressively expensive lifestyles I have been observing have been funded by anxiety inducing and ultimately unsustainable amounts of debt. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Galloway
@georgegalloway
39 years ago I opened a personal bank account with Bank of Scotland in Byres Rd Glasgow. Yesterday without explanation or notice they closed my accounts. My parliamentary and old age pensions are paid into these accounts. The mortgage on our family home is paid out of them. The mortgage is with them. They haven’t heard the last of this. @LloydsBank @KRWLaw
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ben See
@ClimateBen
Ecologists know: very rapid MASS EXTINCTION has begun. Pesticides. Plastic. Nature destruction. And it gets worse. Official UN climate science is a lie. There's no time for atmospheric CO2 removal. Capitalist growth means in 3-9 years we hit unsurvivable 2C and rising towards 3C.
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
🚨 No more sugarcoating. The UN just confirmed the 1.5°C climate limit is effectively dead. We will breach it within years, not decades. We are officially entering a dangerous "overshoot" era. Current policies track us to a lethal 2.6°C.
What does crossing 1.5°C actually mean? It means a massive surge in compounding weather disasters. We aren't just talking about hotter days, as we are looking at abrupt, unpredictable severe droughts, collapsing ice sheets, and extreme floods happening all at once.
It gets worse. Rising sea levels will trigger permanent coastal submersion, threatening to completely swallow island nations. Simultaneously, brutal severe droughts will collapse global crop yields, causing skyrocketing food prices and widespread shortages.
We are completely unprepared. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
John-Paul Berg
@SemperVeritasX
It's amazing how many people still can't see this.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Murphy
@RichardJMurphy
A food crisis is coming our way www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/09/04/a-food-crisis-is-c… Worry is my advice. We can only be saved by government action, but will that happen?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pitchfork Economics
@PitchforkEcon
At some point, “innovation” became a nicer word for finding new things to monetize.
Not everything that can be monetized should be monetized.
🎧 ➡️ pitchforkeconomics.com/episode/profit-power-and-the-crisi… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
David Graeber Institute
@Graeber_social
Last video of
@davidgraeber -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Those who make uncritical observations or fraudulent claims lead us into error and deflect us from the major human goal of understanding how the world works. It is for this reason that playing fast and loose with the truth is a very serious matter.”
― Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
5 years ago
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
Packing everything. #davidgraeber
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'd be saying wild shit smoking them blunts too...💨
"Words ought to be a little wild, for they are the assaults of thoughts on the unthinking."
-John Maynard Keynes -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Venture capitalist @NickHanauer : "Since 1975, roughly $79 trillion has been redistributed upward from the bottom 90% to the top 10% — not through theft, but through the steady accumulation of rules written to favor capital over labor, shareholders over workers, assets over wages. If productivity and wages had stayed linked the way they did from 1945 to 1975, the median American household would be earning $120,000 a year today instead of $75,000. In 1985 it took one worker 39.7 weeks of work to pay for the basics of a middle-class life. By 2022 it took 62 weeks." Video credit: @OpentoDebateOrg
Full video below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
kerry ✊💙Dont let Farage kill our NHS
@hewitson10
If you haven’t got time to watch the full Reform secret donation plot expose then watch this👇
A full fast run down
SHARE IT with anyone you can, let’s get that fucker Nigel Farage out.
Now is the time to run with thisThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Forget dual-income families... start sending your underage children to work.
Seriously, there's not much structural room left for this to fall. I'd expect a bounce back toward 55%. Buy short of a major reduction in finance's share of income, we're never seeing 60% again. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
@davidgraeber, дорогой, где бы ты ни был, ты всегда с нами!
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jolyon Rubinstein
@JolyonRubs
You’re so fucked Nigel
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The nowcast took a step down on international trade data today.
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 nowcast fell 0.59 pp today to 2.42%.
Nearly the entire decline came from net exports, which knocked 0.58 pp off the estimate following a sharp widening of the U.S. trade deficit.
Domestic demand was largely unchanged.
Article in the post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Craig Murray
@CraigMurrayOrg
The Greens are nor perfect by any means. But they are a great deal better than Labour, and Zack Polanski would be a valuable voice against war.
In current circumstances I would urge the left to unite behind him for the by-election. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 nowcast fell 0.59 pp today to 2.42%.
Nearly the entire decline came from net exports, which knocked 0.58 pp off the estimate following a sharp widening of the U.S. trade deficit.
Domestic demand was largely unchanged.
Article in the post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Channel 4 News
@Channel4News
Nigel Farage and other senior members of Reform UK have been filmed by undercover reporters celebrating secret new foreign donations.
Channel 4 News and @Verbatim_Media, a group of investigative journalists, can today reveal a plot to break the law on party funding at the highest levels of Reform UK.
You can watch the full investigation here: youtu.be/aXut3s90rUI
Channel 4 News approached Reform UK, Mr Farage, Mr Jukes and Mr Orr for comment on the findings of this investigation. They did not comment but we understand they deny the allegations in full. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter McCormack 🏴☠️🇬🇧🇮🇪
@PeterMcCormack
Watch full episode...
youtu.be/lNeJtic_gTY -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Peter McCormack 🏴☠️🇬🇧🇮🇪
@PeterMcCormack
New pod...
@ann_pettifor predicted the 2008 financial crash. She says the next one is imminent.
Full episode below...This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Have to give credit to @PeterMcCormack for bringing on @ann_pettifor to rip it up with him. Very unexpected. Much like when my good friend @ProfSteveKeen appeared on his podcast.
Peter McCormack 🏴☠️🇬🇧🇮🇪
@PeterMcCormack
New pod...
@ann_pettifor predicted the 2008 financial crash. She says the next one is imminent.
Full episode below...This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Amir
@AmirAminiMD
A superpower in rapid decline, defeated by its own hubris and incompetence. Not necessarily because it lost this war militarily -what is far more detrimental is the irreversible loss of perceived invincibility and of the narrative.
Yes, the Iran war is the biggest blunder in US history, but the final nail in the coffin of US hegemony is not a mere military defeat. It is the complete destruction of its superiority and credibility by surrendering its sovereignty to special interests and foreign powers.
The end of US dominance started long ago when it turned itself into a political auction house. It started with Super PACs, Super Delegates and Citizens United -with Miriam Adelson, Benjamin Netanyahu and AIPAC.
And it will end with them.
The US today may be able to kidnap or assassinate political leaders, steal resources in broad daylight, and bomb schoolchildren, weddings, hospitals and universities. It can commit genocide and drop phosphorus bombs on the refugees it created inside an open-air concentration camp. It can project fear like a rogue terrorist entity. But it cannot pretend to be the good guy anymore. It cannot expect to be trusted anymore. It cannot influence its allies anymore. It cannot convince its own people.
And it will never again be able to convince young Americans to die in its illegal, horrendous wars.
US world domination is falling apart in real time.
Iran just accelerated the inevitable collapse. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Why is this the accepted model for economics? As venture capitalist @NickHanauer explains: "The last 40 years of research across multiple scientific disciplines has proven, with certainty, that homo economicus does not exist. Outside of economic models, this is simply not how real humans behave. Rather, Homo sapiens have evolved to be other-regarding, reciprocal, heuristic, and intuitive moral creatures." Read more: evonomics.com/how-to-destroy-neoliberalism-kill-homo-econ…
Video credit: @INETeconomicsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brave New Europe
@BRAVENEWEUROPE1
Richard Murphy @RichardJMurphy
The FT view: make the vulnerable pay for failing neoliberalism
braveneweurope.com/economics/richard-murphy-the-ft-view-m…
@indunil_asanga @dgashti1 @ZamoraInma @nickshaxson @ProfSteveKeen @hilarypepper @jechristensen56 @KateRaworth @premnsikka @alexcobham @Naomi_Fowler -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
"Teach a parrot the terms 'supply and demand' and you've got an economist."
-Thomas Carlyle -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I predicted 2008 when American private debt hit 150% of GDP and credit growth peaked at 15% of GDP.
This time the crash is not a bank boom that goes bust.
It is a 10% fall in energy availability. On the real data that means a 10% fall in gross world product. Mainstream models call that a 0.4% shrug.
I have just exposed the full breakdown.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OgLAfG1DMOU
#economics #financialcrisis -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Robertson
@BickerinBrattle
@TyKeynes is very very good. Necessary follow.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
A potted history of mainstream economists' intrepid journey onto a level few human beings have ever reached - the hallowed plane of total cluelessness.
“Adam Smith said a bunch of stuff that was mostly right. Marx said a bunch of stuff that was wrong. Keynes fixed some things up, messed some others. Then Lucas broke everything again. Now we’ve basically got it all worked out, except for money, growth, recessions, banks, bubbles, inflation, unemployment, exchange rates, and what human beings are about.”
Luis Garicano -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MultiPolar
@Your_Tweety
Was unterscheidet Russland von Westeuropa? Warum bleibt der zweite Weltkrieg für Russland ein nicht vergessbares Ereignis? Warum ist Europa so "vergesslich"?
Wie der renommierte russische Schauspieler Wassili Lanowoi einst erzählte: „Während meiner Besuche in Europa stellten mich Journalisten direkt zur Rede:
‚Warum gedenken Sie weiterhin Ihres Sieges? Wir haben das längst hinter uns gelassen.‘ Ich konterte mit einer einfachen Frage: ‚Wie viele Tage haben Ihre Nationen Hitlers Angriff standgehalten?‘ Ihr Schweigen war ohrenbetäubend.
Ich fuhr fort: ‚Polen fiel in 28 Tagen – und doch eroberte Deutschland in derselben Zeitspanne in Stalingrad lediglich ein paar Gebäude.
Dänemark ergab sich nach einem einzigen Tag. Ganz Europa brach innerhalb von drei Monaten zusammen. Es waren unsere Soldaten, die letztlich Ihren Kontinent befreiten, zu dem atemberaubenden Preis von Million Sowjetlebens, die geopfert wurden, um Europäer vom Faschismus zu befreien.‘ Dennoch hat Europa die Amnesie gewählt!
Wenn Versuche unternommen werden, den russischen Sieg zum Schweigen zu bringen, ihn aus dem kollektiven Bewusstsein zu tilgen oder ihn aus den historischen Aufzeichnungen über Generationen und Nationen hinweg zu löschen, müssen wir uns an die harte Realität des Widerstands gegen das nationalsozialistische Deutschland erinnern:
- Dänemark: Kapituliert nach lediglich 6 Stunden
- Luxemburg: Gefallen innerhalb von 1 Tag
- Niederlande: Ergeben nach 5 Tagen
- Jugoslawien: Zusammengebrochen nach 11 Tagen
- Belgien: Durchgehalten für 18 Tage
- Griechenland: Widerstanden für 24 Tage
- Polen: Gekämpft für 27 Tage
- Frankreich: Durchgehalten 1 Monat und 12 Tage
- Norwegen: 2 Monate und 1 Tag
Währenddessen hielt eine einzige sowjetische Festung – das Pawlow-Haus in Stalingrad – 58 Tage lang gegen den unerbittlichen deutschen Angriff stand.
Die Sowjetunion hielt 1.418 Tage unvorstellbarer Härten durch – vier qualvolle Jahre – und beendete den Krieg letztlich in Berlin selbst, indem sie die bedingungslose Kapitulation des nationalsozialistischen Deutschlands erzwang. Russland wehrt sich. Russland verteidigt. Russland kämpft.
Kein Land hat im zweiten Weltkrieg mehr Opfer (25 Mio. Menschen) hinnehmen müssen als die Sowjetunion, inbesondere das damalige Russland. Das diese Opfer und die Befreiung aus den Köpfen der Westeuropäer verschwunden ist, ist eine Schande.
Und für alle die jetzt Aufschreien, aber ohne die Aliierten... Die westlichen Alliierten (USA, Großbritannien und Frankreich) rückten Anfang Juli 1945 in ihre Sektoren in Berlin ein – etwa zwei Monate nach der Eroberung der Stadt durch die Rote Armee Ende April/Anfang Mai 1945. Im Grund waren sie überflüssig.
Verluste:
USA, Januar–Mai 1945: ca. 204.800 Gesamtverluste
Großbritannien, 21. Armeegruppe, D-Day bis VE-Day insgesamt ca. 191.219. Davon britische Truppen: 141.291
Frankreich, Französische Armee, Nordwesteuropa 1944–1945. Gesamtverluste in Nordwesteuropa: 66.826
Gesamt: 412.917 was 1,6 % von 25 Mio. Soldaten der Sowjetunion entspricht. Wer war also der wahre Befreier?
@politblogme -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Steve Hall
@ProfHall1955
I have a dream!
It's a rough plan to make a revolution more fun with a sprinkling of evil. Each country must do this simultaneously.
1. Appoint a citizen's army to round up all politicians, media hacks, shadow bankers, financial traders, AI tech bros and neoclassical economists.
2. Put them all in an abandoned and sealed-off football stadium, then bring a convoy of muck-spreaders to fill the stadium up to about shoulder-height with pigshit.
3. Drop in some cans of Fray Bentos meat pies to incentivise them to use their ingenuity, high-IQs etc. in an attempt to open the cans and cook the pies.
4. Meanwhile, cancel all government bond sales and stop paying interest. Use the central bank to fund a programme of public investment, beginning with energy and utilities.
5. Force capitalists with spare cash to invest in productive activity only, no matter what the ROI, otherwise they go straight in the pigshit.
6. Put up a giant screen in the football stadium outlining the investment plan and asking for financial workers to do the operations for a salary. Have a laugh as they all start fighting each other to get to the front of the exit queue.
7. Arrange quick IQ tests in the car park to filter out the ones who are up to the job. Assume the failures have faulty genes and dump them back in the pigshit. Well, it's their idea!
8. Arrange fair international trade deals, blow up the AI data centres and employ real people again, cut the working week to three days and start living actual lives instead of nervously searching for the next hustle.
OK, get to it! -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
I too used to look at 1.5°C above pre-industrial temps and think pffft, that's nothing. We'll get slightly warmer summers. Great.
And then I started looking into it more when I saw the flooding, heatwaves, fires, crazy hurricanes. It was then I knew.
I realised I was confusing weather with climate.
When your local temperature goes up 1.5°C in an afternoon, you don't even notice. But when the entire planet retains that much extra energy 24/7, the reality changes completely.
Think of it like the human body. Your normal temperature is 37°C. If your core temp rises by 1.5°C, you don't just feel "a little warmer." You have a fever. If it rises by 3°C, you are in the hospital with organ failure.
That 1.5°C isn't an even, gentle warming. It is raw atmospheric fuel.
And now, time has officially run out. The United Nations just announced that exceeding 1.5°C is now completely unavoidable. We are officially tracking toward a peak of at least 1.8°C only if we do everything perfectly. Under our current trajectory, we are heading straight for 2.6°C. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
the Juice Media
@thejuicemedia
The Australien Government has made an ad about its latest Bullshit™, and it’s surprisingly honest and informative 🌏🌳🐨 #auspol
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill McGuire
@ProfBillMcGuire
"likely to be the largest in at least 1,000 years"
Make no mistake, this is going to be an unprecedented and catastrophic weather/climate event
Harvests will be especially badly hit
Without wishing to sow concern, stocking-up would be judicious
www.theguardian.com/environment/2026/sep/03/el-nino-super… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
#mmt: Yes.
"Mainstream economics" is the only thing that is currently threatened by (intellectual) bankruptcy.
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
After some great discussion, we agree to disagree. The main question: Once principal is canceled/defaulted, can a central bank operate with no assets, paying interest on reserves with more reserves? It's equivalent to r<g: Can a government just roll over debt forever?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
The GDP Dynamics Goodwin Growth Cycle model is indicating a rather stable period in the business cycle, but the first signs of weakening profits and small wage gains are showing up in the forecast.
The link to the model is in the next post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
God
@TheTweetOfGod
No one's going to do anything because humanity is fundamentally broken and it will keep getting hotter and in a few hundred years the feedback loops humanity has caused will render life on earth impossible.
Prove Me wrong, folks!
UN Environment Programme
@UNEP
The planet will keep getting hotter, even with ongoing efforts to slow the temperature rise. But choices exist.
Every fraction of a degree prevented, and every year by which the overshoot period is shortened, will save lives, protect ecosystems, and reduce economic losses.
Find out more: www.unep.org/resources/limiting-overshoot-navigating-exce… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alicia Gerardo
@TheEconRebel
What most economists and analysts don't comprehend is that we don't live in a world in which government deficits reduce national savings and crowd out investment. Rather, the deficit increases savings and investment. What really drives bond yields is the central bank rate target.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
GDP Dynamics U.S. Household Satisfaction Index sits at 44.5
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I'm now having individuals submit their opinion/editorial peices to GDP Dynamics, this should give a more human feel to what is generally a very mechanical outlook of economic forecasts.
Give it a read, it's by Alex Jenkinson
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Is America Entering the Late Stage of a Cantillon Cycle?
Article by: Alex Jenkinson
Link in the next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
God
@TheTweetOfGod
Climate change is just a hoax perpetrated by the world’s oceans, animals, plants, ecosystems and atmosphere.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Yep, that's what I'm expecting.
Avaline Darling
@Avaline_Darling
May I make a prediction?
The American mid term elections will be outright cancelled by Trump citing s national emergency.
Cancelled.
Anyone else on this same wavelength?
Outright cancelled. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Science and democracy have very consonant values and approaches, and I don't think you can have one without the other.”
— Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Malcolm Reavell
@malcolm_reavell
Appalling propaganda. The secondary bond market yields reflect only prices paid by traders. This doesn’t affect the coupon rate paid by govt. A bond with 4% interest is only paid 4% interest.
And there is NO black hole in govt finances!
BBC Newsnight
@BBCNewsnight
"This is a massive, massive deal... we are kind of more exposed than many other countries around the world."
Ed Conway, Economics Editor of Sky News, on the rise in the cost of UK government borrowing - and the resulting "black hole" in the Burnham administration's finances.
#newsnightThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a classic “They came for the communists, and I didn’t care, because I wasn’t a communist” realisation of what fascism means in practice.
Reggie B.
@reggiebblue
Milo Yiannopoulos: "I didn't really understand the physical reality of how institutionalized the brutality is in America. The manner in which they arrest you, they put you in manacles, everybody is arrested like an MS 13 gang member.
It was physically degrading. It was frightening. I don't think I've ever been frightened like that before. I was weeping like an old woman for an hour. I wouldn't wish it on anyone."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
When you understand #mmt, you understand that for every $ the US government spends a $ worth of t-bonds is issued. The $ held by the banks match the $ offered in terms of bonds. As long as bonds pay more interest than reserves, banks will happily buy all bonds offered. EOS.
Ray Dalio
@RayDalio
In this article in TIME, I squeezed my explanation of the debt supply and demand problem into a 3-minute read so it’s my best, few-minute explanation of this problem. I’m sharing it in case you’re interested.
time.com/article/2026/08/28/the-bond-market-s-supply-and-… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MascMillennial
@MascMillennial
I thought for sure this had to be fake. What are we even doing anymore man.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mary-Ellen #TU_Rep
@HullLecturer
When you are listening to pundits speak about bonds, remember this. They are talking about what is happening in secondary markets and ascribing the cause to what is happening in primary markets (govt spending). There is no problem in primary markets. Banks happily buy bonds.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Watch the full breakdown here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyLnDop6Ux4
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Negro Libre
@NegroLibre1
1. The key part of Milo's interview that isn't getting enough attention and I think it's very likely true, is him accusing the WH of basically revoking his green card: in other words, he was a legal immgirant, that was turned illegal and was never made aware till he was arrested.
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
Milo Yiannopoulos says he was 'swarmed' by 15 ICE agents - and that 'one or two' of them refused to take part in detaining him once they recognized him.
Watch more 👇
📺 youtu.be/q5pSX84h9K8
@piersmorgan | @NeroThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Trump Derangement Syndrome, anyone?
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Going forward:
1. Tariff refunds boost this number.
2. Military spending holds this number.
3. None of the above and we might get a lower number.🤷♂️
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
My Q3 GDP nowcast slipped another 0.10 percentage point today to 3.06%.
Weak construction data drove the decline, with business fixed investment, residential investment, and government all moving lower.
Consumer spending remains the main support.
Article in next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Red 'til I'm Dead
@suziegeewizz
So Starmer basically served two terms, one to destroy the parliamentary left,one to destroy the justice system. He's laid his coat over the puddle for fascism.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Reggie B.
@reggiebblue
Milo Yiannopoulos: "I didn't really understand the physical reality of how institutionalized the brutality is in America. The manner in which they arrest you, they put you in manacles, everybody is arrested like an MS 13 gang member.
It was physically degrading. It was frightening. I don't think I've ever been frightened like that before. I was weeping like an old woman for an hour. I wouldn't wish it on anyone."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
I love that I have to build a long list of safeguards into my Codex harnesses so GPT won't try to lie to me or word things in a way that expressly conceals a project's true situational awareness.
We have some very talented horses, and we see Olympic-level dressage riders at our place regularly . My wife pays them to ride our horses and help her figure out how to get them to make complex movements. I don't know how many times I've watched a great rider just solve a riding riddle via know-how.
Codex is like dressage with a talented, temperamental horse.
You also learn that GPT , Claude, Grok, Gem are only brilliant in a certain type of intelligence. A very high IQ with honesty issues and limited imagination is useless without imagination. Einstein said something similar -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a classic “They came for the communists, and I didn’t care, because I wasn’t a communist” realisation of what fascism means in practice.
Reggie B.
@reggiebblue
Milo Yiannopoulos: "I didn't really understand the physical reality of how institutionalized the brutality is in America. The manner in which they arrest you, they put you in manacles, everybody is arrested like an MS 13 gang member.
It was physically degrading. It was frightening. I don't think I've ever been frightened like that before. I was weeping like an old woman for an hour. I wouldn't wish it on anyone."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
My Q3 GDP nowcast slipped another 0.10 percentage point today to 3.06%.
Weak construction data drove the decline, with business fixed investment, residential investment, and government all moving lower.
Consumer spending remains the main support.
Article in next post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
Japan's 10y is over 3% for the first time in 30 years demonstrating the reflexive feedback loop of CB policy. This continues to be the greatest example of why MMT is right on rates.
Japan has a floating currency, meaning their CB is the monopoly price setter of rates and has shown for 30 years they can achieve any rate along the entire yield curve they want.
In mid-2023 the BOJ signaled they were ending YCC/ZIRP/NIRP and pursuing a macro data driven rate policy. This creates a feedback loop where the market now reprices their reaction function for rates. No longer 0 forever but data dependent and the very data they are looking at to determine what rate to set is positively driven higher by the higher rate itself.
Higher rates on 250% Debt/GDP are a massive fiscal add, unanchoring inflation which feeds into the BOJ data driven rate policy in turn pushing rates higher and the upward spiral begins exactly as MMT would expect. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chinedu Muhammad Okoye☘️
@Muhammad_Okoye
ZERO EQUILIBRIUM SPACES
LET’S TALK MARKETS, MACRO & POSITIONING.
We’ll be discussing the forces moving global markets, the macroeconomic backdrop, and, most importantly, how investors and market participants should be positioning.
TIME🕣 : 20:30 WAT
HOST 🎙️: @Muhammad_Okoye
ESTEEMED GUEST SPEAKERS:
@WealthWithPro
@Wealth_ese1
@the_goodfemi
@ngx_wolf
@Kliometry
@ProfSteveKeen
Expect a deep conversation on Markets • Macro • Rates • FX • Equities • Commodities • Crypto • Risk • Positioning.
Join the Space: Link 👇🏾
x.com/i/spaces/1dKrPrwRnBYJX -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“However [political parties] may now and then answer popular ends, they are likely in the course of time and things, to become potent engines, by which cunning, ambitious, and unprincipled men will be enabled to subvert the power of the people and to usurp for themselves the reins of government, destroying afterwards the very engines which have lifted them to unjust dominion.”
— George Washington -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brilliant Maps
@BrilliantMaps
North American Cities Transposed Onto Europe At The Same Latitude
Surprised?
See the reverse here: brilliantmaps.com/cities-transposed-latitude/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
471TO
@TOzgokmen
Everybody knows that Trump is finished.
Hegseth wants to run for president. Hegseth thinks that he has the best shot if Pentagon wins a ground war. Probably, some wealthy people are telling him they would support him for president, if he pushes & wins for a ground war.
Without a ground war, it is impossible to open the Hormuz by farts from the WH, or farts from the air, no matter how big the farts are and we have seen some of the biggest farts in US history.
So they are pushing Pentagon for ground war but the Army chiefs have bothered to look at a map:
471TO
@TOzgokmen
Hegseth wants to push the US military into ground war.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Richard Phillips
@richyphillips
QE was not damaging because it was so-called "money printing." It was damaging because it was a symptom of a bankrupt economic theology that had no answer to the 2008 crisis except to re-inflate the very asset bubbles that caused it.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rajendra Rasu | Monetary Standard and Poverty |
@IndiaMmt
Countries Are Trigger-Happy with Massive Credit-Money Creation - Yet Shy Away from Direct Money Creation for Development
Why do modern economies readily create enormous amounts of credit money, yet hesitate to use sovereign currency power directly to mobilise the real resources -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Economics run in cycles through history , from free marketers to protectionists , each is taken to far in turn over cycles , economist Nicholi Kondratief noticed they run in 50-70 year cycles , Schumpeter noticed there was a sequencing to these cycles best known as creative destruction .
Alexander Hamilton , Tenche Coxe conceptualised the state as a unit of innovation . That the state could be harnessed as a competitive vehicle against another state . That trade and economics can be exploited by a state against another state to achieve a dominance over the other .
All economist and commentators need to retrain for this era -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Conspiratorial Templates
@mynamehear
If the last 10 years have taught us anything, it's that karma isn't real. You can live an entire life being the worst person possible and suffer no real consequences. Hell, you're more likely to be rewarded.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Alex Cole
@acnewsitics
Just in case you haven’t been paying attention, they’re purging everyone out of the military that might oppose the order to carry out a military coup when they get voted out.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Pavlina R Tcherneva
@ptcherneva
I joined The Background Briefing to talk about why monetary and fiscal policy and financial markets are a threat to already fragile American households.
Can the Fed Chairman and Treasury Sec Do Their Job at the Same Time Please Their Boss? via #soundcloud soundcloud.com/user-830442635/bbriefing_2026_08_30b_pavli… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
It is worth remembering that the Global Financial Crisis was primarily a real estate crisis, rather than a sovereign debt crisis. In my opinion, the post-2020 increase in property prices looks somewhat unhealthy, given all the talk about laying off office workers and using AI.
Barchart
@Barchart
Global Bond Yields hit highest level since the Global Financial Crisis 🚨
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
Hegseth has taken out more American generals than Iranian ones.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Lucy Riles
@LucyRiles
I say this as a 3-time Trump voter, a lifelong Republican who spent an embarrassing amount of money on merch and travel to Trump rallies and DC…
I was duped. The past 14 months have been betrayal after betrayal. It sucks admitting I got it wrong. No, I’m not saying Kamala would have been better. But Trump is a politician, a glorified snake oil salesman. He is not God nor should he be worshipped as one. And we need to hold our politicians accountable.. ESPECIALLY the ones we voted for and sacrificed friendships, jobs and family over.
Trump is now attempting to bully his base into supporting another reckless foreign war, ignore the Epstein files and now, accept data centers or else you want to be “backwards and poor”. I’ve never been in an emotionally abusive relationship… and I’m not about to start now.
Thank you for your attention to this matter🫡🇺🇸 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
It is a bit light argzing that the dog is free because the leash is not tight.
If the Fed moves the short term rate down, the bond yields come down as well. Says historical evidence.
James Lavish
@jameslavish
Good morning.
Once again for those in the back, unless they go out and buy or sell bonds themselves, the Fed does not control the long end of the yield curve.
Have a great day. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Friedman brought ideology. Bowles brought the receipts. Full video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=9w9ymJm7XVk&t=13s
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
QuinnjinWilliams
@quinnjin2009
"Economics Isn't Hard. It's Misunderstood."
Great vid from @ProfSteveKeen on why the neo-liberal idiots running our economy and advising our govt are worthless.
The crap-onomic woo theories they preach have utterly failed for 45 years, benefiting no one but the 1 percent. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
"What fundamentally went wrong? Bad economic theory led to bad economy policy." @ProfSteveKeen
Full video in comments.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Time to make all the armchair yappers mad again...🖕
"Economics has always been preoccupied with equilibrium. That's like analyzing how a car works by studying a parked vehicle."
-Jay Forrester -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
This is the debasement trade. China and the rest of the world have saved in US dollar assets for the purpose of suppressing their currency relative to the Dollar to make exports more attractive to US consumers. We're doing everything we can to unravel this.
I'm fine with the argument that we need to rebuild US manufacturing, but you do that through investment not debasement. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
The GDP Dynamics Q3 nowcast holds at 3.16%.
Consumer spending remains the engine of growth, contributing 3.22 pp, while net exports and residential investment continue to drag on the forecast.
Article in the post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Chris Hedges
@ChrisLynnHedges
The Trump White House has put into place a series of mechanisms to fix or invalidate the midterm elections. Congress will not save us. The courts will not save us. Our only hope — should the election be rigged or stolen — is nationwide strikes. Our only hope is to cripple the machinery of commerce and government, although this militancy will be met with savage state repression.
Otherwise, we are doomed. There will be no exit.
If the measures advocated by the Trump administration are implemented, emergency powers will be invoked to assert unprecedented federal control over voting. Federal agents will seize election materials. They have already seized ballots from previous elections.
The U.S. Postal Service will only send ballots to those included on federally approved eligibility lists drawn from state voter rolls. These rolls, subject to citizenship checks, will deny election-mail services entirely in states that refuse the administration’s demands for voter data.
Federal troops and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) — with $113.5 billion in additional funding allocated by Congress through September 2029 — will be deployed to or near polling stations which have a traditional Democratic Party majority. Those branded as “anti-capitalist” and “anti-Christian” or charged with belonging to antifa will be intimidated or blocked from voting.
Trump told The New York Times in January he regretted not directing the National Guard to seize voting machines after the 2020 election. Trump not only wants to abolish mail-in ballots – Democrats vote by mail in higher numbers than Republicans – but voting machines and tabulators which allow election boards to post results on election night.
Trump and his supporters in Silicon Valley are acutely aware that the level of their corruption and disdain for democracy — unlike anything seen in U.S. history — makes them vulnerable if they lose power. They have no intention of allowing this to happen no matter how egregious the constitutional violations. They seek to extinguish the last vestiges of democracy. They believe, as PayPal and Palantir co-founder Peter Thiel wrote in 2009, that “freedom and democracy” are not “compatible.”
Theil is sweeping up all our information gleaned from government tax, medical and law enforcement records. This information is being delivered to databases that can be exploited for state control and profit. Thiel and his coterie of technocratic billionaires are implementing the agenda he envisioned 16 years ago: to make technology an “alternative to politics.”
Read my full column, "The Next Election May be Our Last", at Substack — link below. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dean Arthur Bevan
@deanabevan
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
While stocks are certainly overpriced, fiscal is just too strong right now for a sustained bear market to emerge.
Could we get a fed surprise or a geopolitical shock, sure, but any selling caused by uncertainty will be quickly gobbled up by the 7.1% nominal and 3.7% real deficit growth. Flows are more than ample to sustain the both macro level growth and markets. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I wrote what I think is an accessible article on my toxic relationship with DSGE modeling. Give it a read.👇
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
GDP Dynamics
@GDPDynamics
Latest free article dropped, The Lucas Critique and Modeling.
See the link to article in the post below.👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
The return of austerity in Belgium. The fiscal framework of the European Union is the cause of it, as fiscal deficits are not supposed to exceed three percent of GDP. There is no scientific evidence to support this number. #eurozone
www.brusselstimes.com/belgium/2295457/im-not-sleeping-wel… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Rodrigo Ribeiro
@taraxaco
Economics Isn't Hard. It's Misunderstood.
@ProfSteveKeen
Money and Macroeconomics from First Principles for Elon Musk and Other Engineers
www.amazon.com/Money-Macroeconomics-First-Principles-Engi…
youtu.be/dsp6Su6hNuo via @YouTube -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
eaarthnet ❖
@EaarthNet
This week’s wire
•Keen + Hudson, Federal Reserve, US constitution, end of hegemony (posted mid-August, still circulating)
◦Talk: Private debt and financialisation eat the industrial surplus; public bonds are not the household story. Forecast: oil shock → inflation, then debt deflation. Keen can be early on timing. Hudson can over-systematise. The accounting still holds.
◦Link: www.nakedcapitalism.com/2026/08/michael-hudson-and-steve-…
•Keen, Substack / YouTube (late August)
◦Public items: Hedging risks; “buying British” as a small industrial-policy step; do governments need bonds.
◦Related to Money and Macroeconomics from First Principles (2025 paperback). Next book How Economists Will Destroy Capitalism still serialising.
◦Kitkit Do (or another source?), 24 Aug: AI capex revenue ~1/5 of spend. Gold is a leveraged commodity, not a one-way vault.
•Bond market (context, not our church)
◦30-year US Treasury printed ~5.3% mid-August, highest since 2007. Gilts and JGBs moved with it.
◦Mainstream calls this “vigilantes.” Heterodox read: Duration is pricing physical and fiscal stress, while private leverage is the fragility that matters more than the headline public stock.
Papers that are still the live objects
•Hickel & Sullivan, New Political Economy (15 July 2026)
◦The myth of catch-up development, 1960–2023. WID GDP per capita, 173 countries, three currency conversions.
◦Absolute core–periphery gap up 170–270%. Core captured 4–10× more new income than the periphery. Outside China, relative position of the periphery deteriorated. 93 of 136 peripheral countries lost ground (constant MER). Periphery population share 80% → 86%. China at 22–38% of core income, not “caught up.”” 1980s–90s liberalisation is the ugly stretch.
•Fanning & Raworth, Nature 646: 47–56 (1 Oct 2025)
◦Doughnut as a monitor, not a slogan. 35 indicators, 2000–2022.
◦GDP more than doubled. Social shortfall would need to fall five times faster to close by 2030. Overshoot must stop now and reverse nearly twice as fast by 2050.
◦Richest 20% of nations (>15% of people) >40% of ecological overshoot. Poorest 40% of nations (42% of people) >60% of social shortfall. No country inside the doughnut ring.
•Mazzucato, The Common Good Economy (Allen Lane, June 2026)
◦Still travelling. Dutch edition listed 31 Aug.
◦Five-point compass: purpose, co-creation, collective learning, reward-sharing, accountability.
◦Direct line into ministries; also the Stage-4 risk — planner-as-saviour if debt, class and energy stay off the page. She rejects “growth vs climate” as a false binary. Hickel/Raworth do not.
Coalition, not consensus
•Guardian, 10 June 2026
◦De Schutter, Stiglitz, Ghosh, Piketty, Raworth, Hickel — UN-adjacent roadmap: end poverty without GDP-growth-as-condition.
◦350+ signatories. Political traction. Not one model.
•Varoufakis + Münchau, UnHerd, 12 Aug
◦Wealth taxes necessary and insufficient. Platform surplus and central-bank plumbing sit above national tax theatre.
•Entropy Economics (2025)
◦Still the engineer-readable alternative (similar to Keen's perspective). Varoufakis hosted Galbraith in Athens in June on hegemony and the ends of economics.
How to read the week in one paragraph
The living economy this week is balance sheets plus Earth. Private debt and long-duration yields are the stress gauges in the core. Catch-up-by-growth is not in the GDP data. The doughnut numbers say the social floor and the ecological ceiling are moving the wrong way, and the wrong countries are driving each. Public money can build the floor; it can also feed the Achiever state. Industrial policy can be sovereignty; it can be militarised optimisation. Hold those. Do not flatten Hickel, Raworth, Keen, Hudson and Mazzucato into one church.
Mechanism first. Earth is a stakeholder.
•Next issue: Monday 7 September.
•Keen weekly automation: already runs the same morning. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Douglas Padgett
@MMTmacrotrader
In a crazy bit of irony, only MMT sees this massive amount of deficit spending as inflationary while the rest of mainstream macro sees this as deflationary.
The Kobeissi Letter
@KobeissiLetter
BREAKING: US annual interest expense is up to a record 18.5% of federal government revenue.
This is officially above the previous record of 18.4% set in 1991.
This percentage has more than QUADRUPLED over the last 4 years as interest expenditures on public debt skyrocketed.
US annual interest expense now stands at a record $1.25 trillion, more than 4x the level seen in 1991.
Meanwhile, the 30Y Treasury yield is trading at ~5.21%, just 13 basis points from its highest level since 2007.
By comparison, the 30-year yield was oscillating at ~8.00% in 1991, underscoring how much the US debt burden has grown since then.
The US debt crisis is in uncharted territory. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Oil prices jump over 2% following US strikes youtu.be/KpGHC97BTt4 via @YouTube
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Musical Chairs
@MusicalChairs14
I expected bad, but this is awful. Malpractice even. I'll limit my criticism to 9 posts.
The Herald have added together the gross debt of NZ public & private sectors and called this debt 'we collectively owe the world'. Pure unadulterated nonsense. Literally untrue. [🧵1/n] -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dirk Ehnts
@DEhnts
„Wir können das nicht bezahlen.“
Die Bundesregierung will das nicht bezahlen, sie kann sehr wohl. Hier wird wieder deutlich, wie das "Steuerzahlergeld" dazu genutzt wird, sich wegzuducken vor den Konsequenzen politischer Entscheidungen. (Für Krieg ist immer Geld da.)
Julius Betschka
@JuliusBetschka
🔴Klare Absage von Friedrich Merz an weitere Hilfen gegen hohe Benzinpreise. „Ein Ölpreis von 100 Dollar kann in Deutschland nicht wegsubventioniert werden“, sagt Merz in der ARD. Hilfen seien deshalb ausgelaufen, keine neuen geplant. „Wir können das nicht bezahlen.“
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Dr Peter💚🤍💜 🏴 🇳🇿
@WingsEcosse
I have been saying AI is an unsustainable Ponzi scheme now for a while. Now the Governor of the Bank of England has noticed as well as the risk of wider contagion when they fall.
@ProfSteveKeen has been warning for a while about the growing bubbles all built by debt. He predicted the 2008 crash and is again. Hold on for the ride.
apple.news/ApzDT0h4BRMW3lkmpmy_y4w -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Glenn Diesen
@Glenn_Diesen
Colonel Wilkerson, former Chief of Staff to the U.S. Secretary of State, explains how they [the White House] bought European leaders and "taught the dogs to bark".
- "We bought newspaper editors"
- "We bought union heads"
- "We bought parliamentarians"
- "We bought two secretaries general: Jens Stoltenberg and Mark Rutte"
- "We bought whole countries in terms of their political apparatus and what influences them"
youtu.be/PjG-zfGY5PY -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
The 4 Billion Dead September International Public Call
With me will be Geneviéve Walker - A Global systems Architect and Strategist, Geneviéve is one of the most prominent voices for sustainable infrastructure change on the airwaves today. She is the CEO of GCRIN and SOVRIS, which build and develop unique technologies to help governments better manage and respond to the climate crisis.
Be there. Listen. Feel. Act.
Thank you.
Monday 21st September 2026
7PM - 8.30PM BST
actionnetwork.org/events/the-4-billion-dead-september-int… -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
𝓐 ⭑
@ayojoestar
perhaps it is time we stop talking about stopping 'global warming' and 'climate change', and start saying that we need to 'keep humanity alive' and 'prevent civilisation collapse'
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ℹ️ Not The Torygraph 💚 #SaveOurNHS #ScrapNHSBill
@TweetForTheMany
The only real source of new money is via government spending. Yes, people will scream that commercial banks create most of the money but the liabilities are completely different - think of bank loans as part of a 2 sided equation that cancel out.
Therefore if the economy needs to grow - to fulfil spare capacity using spare resources then what people need to understand is that THE GOVERNMENT CAN INVEST TO CREATE JOBS. See China.
If a government creates £100 Million into the economy - it doesn’t need to borrow that money and it doesn’t even need to issue bonds for the additional deficits.
Take WATER Renationalisation - the government doesn’t need to “find the money” or borrow from anyone. They could simply take Thames Water and they would have an asset then INVEST - The logic is:
•Government spends £X more than it taxes.
•If it doesn't sell gilts, the banking system ends up with additional reserves.
•Those reserves are an asset of commercial banks and ultimately support deposits held by the private sector.
•If there is unused labour, machinery, factories and other capacity, the extra demand can increase production rather than simply bid up prices.
•As that spare capacity is brought into use, the economy can grow without necessarily generating inflation.
MMTAction
@mmt_action
"Government debt bad" is the story you've been told. Finding the Money shows the national debt is the opposite of what the orthodox story says. Watch free.
#mmt #findingthemoney
mmtaction.com/share/screenings/watch/ -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
Very weird he acknowledges we are on course to ‘game over’
but not that WE are doing it with overconsumption and fossil fuels
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Extremely severe extinction events happen every 100M years or so and just switching to sustainable energy will not be enough to stop them.
Space satellites to control temperature and massive geo-engineering will be needed or it will be game over.
grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5_dfaad20f-6716-42a3-a2c2-f4e2f2f0cb26 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Anastasia
@demystifysci
It's live!!! Pick up your copy of Paradox Lost and solve all your questions about everything from the nature of charge to how mirrors work and why entanglement isn't the paradox it is cracked up to be. #1 in the history of physics right now!! help us keep it going
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ben See
@ClimateBen
Things that will be gone by 2029:
1. The Great Barrier Reef.
2. The Amazon Rainforest.
3. Arctic Ice.
4. Orangutans, Rhinos, Sea Turtles.
5. Adequate water supply.
6. Reliable food production.
7. A safe climate.
8. Human existence as we know it.
This is the real news. Isn't it? -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
The Planetary Solvency report from the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries presents an extreme-risk scenario in which more than 4 billion deaths could occur under 3°C+ warming by 2050, alongside catastrophic economic and societal disruption.
We need to understand the scale of the gamble we're taking—and ask ourselves how much death and destruction we're willing to tolerate before we act. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is beyond true. Tannen was based on Donald Trump’s personality.
Liam Nissan™
@theliamnissan
When I was a kid I thought the future would mean hoverboards for everybody but what we actually got was Biff Tannen for President
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Capital is the lifeblood of mining and it’s simply not getting through at the scale we need .
The RBA prioritises financialisation, consumer price stability , employment and asset inflation .
Mining , refining , manufacturing , making things in general , being productive are Australia’s central banks last priority.
Australia is a borrow and consume cult .
Teo
@Teo_Sinamin
Australia’s critical minerals projects lag, PwC warns
PwC Australia has sounded the alarm: just 13 of the 907 critical minerals projects in the nation’s pipeline could reach a final investment decision (FID) within the next two to four years.
Its latest report finds projects are progressing too slowly, threatening Australia’s ability to meet demand from allies and trading partners.
PwC identifies 117 projects — about one in 10 or 13% of the total — within its ‘investable universe’. These projects have progressed beyond exploration but have yet to reach FID, with a primary commodity on the Australian Government’s critical or strategic minerals list.
Nearly 90% of those projects are three to six years from FID, with more complex developments potentially taking up to 10 years. Some 53% are at the Prefeasibility Study (PFS) stage, while another 36% are at the Scoping Study stage.
The Australian Government has committed $28 billion to the critical minerals and rare earths sector since 2022, spanning initiatives including the Critical Minerals Strategic Reserve, Critical Minerals Production Tax Incentive, and Critical Minerals Facility, according PwC.
However, the report identifies a disconnect between policy and investment decisions. Much of that support is prospective, conditional, or structured as tax incentives that deliver value only once projects are producing, leaving many earlier-stage developments without the support they need.
Haynes notes critical minerals have become central to government agendas, extending beyond the energy transition to AI, automation (productivity), trade and industrialisation (growth), and defence (security).
Australia has the minerals the world needs, he says, but must turn that endowment into commercially viable supply for its allies and trading partners.
The country’s success in bulk commodities provides foundations, but Haynes argues that Australia needs to consider what comes next not just in mining, but also in the midstream processing and downstream industries.
“To be able to capitalise on the entire critical minerals value chain puts Australia in a privileged geopolitical and economic position with our trade partners and allies and allows us to maintain that position as a partner of choice,” Haynes says.
“The risk is that these partners will find these minerals elsewhere if we can’t supply them.”
PWC finds the overall project pipeline has barely moved since its ‘Aussie Mine 2025’ report. Of the 907 total critical minerals projects identified, 675 are in exploration or reserve development, 87 are producing, and 20 are under construction.
The analysis also identifies eight processing facility projects, representing just 1% of the total.
Between 2022 and June 2026, six upstream projects reached FID: four lithium projects, one rare earths project, and one base and technology metals project. PwC highlights that there was a gap of almost four years before the remaining five reached the milestone between March and June 2026.
Australia’s investable universe is also concentrated in just three critical minerals. Copper accounts for 29%, nickel for 15%, and rare earth elements for 10%. A further 31% covers vanadium, tin, graphite, lithium, zinc, and cobalt projects. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Jeff Reisberg
@jareisberg
Finally getting around to trying Minsky by @ProfSteveKeen Using it to test the logic of the paper "Where Profits Come From" from the Levy Forecasting Center. What a nice tool for exploring models too large to keep in your mind.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Macroeconomics took a wrong turn sacrificing empirical fit for "microfoundations." The structural economy drifts over time regardless of policy shifts. Old structural Keynesian models, frequently calibrated, handle this parameter drift far better than rigid DSGE models ever will.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
🇦🇺Craig Tindale
@ctindale
Climate change has been an intense hobby of mine for 30 years. I haven't read everything there is to read, but I'm at the stage where I would be surprised if I hadn't read and understood 90% of the science corpus.
This includes all the complex modelling frameworks of all the climate science disciplines.
a) Climate change is real, and it's much worse than the forecast. The models we have are extremely coarse; the consensus claims of scientists don't make this clear. If the forecast said 2100, it probably should have said 2030.
b) It is unstoppable - renewables will make very little difference. By any objective measure, renewable energy is making very little headway
c)Even if we could galvanise the world into action, we don't have the resource supply chains to build it out anyway. We don't have the copper, aluminium, and 63 other materials I track .
d)I track the substitution materials as well, and they all have impaired supply chains as well. When I say we haven't got enough copper, people say "then we can substitute aluminium. We haven't got enough ot that either.
e)The decarbonisation models hide magic assumptions about gigantic carbon capture devices that literally don't exist. These are like giant vacuum cleaners that suck in Co2 and store it. The concept is ridiculous, yet it's embedded in IPCC models
g)Planting trees and forests are also included in the carbon capture model assumption; we simply aren't planting those trees. No country is at the scale that is needed.
h)When you try to raise these issues with the academic community, they shut you down. They simply aren't interested in addressing the reality of humanity and Earth's predicament.
i)Most climate activists simply want to blame someone. The fossil fuel lobby, etc. Their emotional model: one half of society that is trying to destroy the world, and the other half is trying to save it, and the activists are on the side trying to save it.
The reality is they have no rescue boat and no way to avoid it. I also don't care who you are or what you believe. We share a common history of a 1000 generations burning fossil fuel. All our ancestors are to blame. Blaming doesn't achieve anything.
h) Burning sulphur-based coal despite the aerosol health issues might be the only practical rational path. Sulphur creates rain clouds, and they act as a protective layer against incoming solar radiation. It's ironic, but cleaning up our air pollution has significantly accelerated climate change; less sulphur means fewer clouds and less reflective mirroring
Once we accept this is our path, it'll change our preparation decisions, saving wasted capital and resources that can be redirected toward resilience.
We have adopted this mentality: "we can't give up, even if our plan won't work in any scenario". We need to break that mentality and become grown-ups. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ed Kwok✨
@kwok_xian
A president for sale or rent ... disgusting abuse of position
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Marco Foster
@MarcoFoster_
George Conway: “Trump is the most narcissistic human being we have ever seen in American politics. He gave a permission structure for everyone to be their worst selves. We can all care about ourselves. The problem is he does not give a shit about anyone other than himself. He is delusional. He is actually psychotic”
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Dolly as an Elvis Impersonator. She had no limits...
sᥕᥱᥱ𝗍 𝗍һіᥒg❤️🔥(𝙰𝚜𝚒𝚊)
@55SweetThing
Dolly Parton had us “All Shook Up” with her unforgettable Elvis impersonation🔥😂 ❤️🔥RIP
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hussain “Hoz” Shafiei
@HussainShafiei
I need every single person who follows me.
Let’s make some noise.
Let’s make some content.
Let’s make sure that Apple understands the consequences of teaming up with Team genocide.
@Apple , you need to walk away from Israel.
#bds #israelThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Each of us is a tiny being, permitted to ride on the outermost skin of one of the smaller planets for a few dozen trips around the local star.”
— Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
I don't know what I'm having for dinner tonight, but according to rational expectations and intertemporal optimization I know exactly how hungry I'll be on February 27, 2029.
Economics is incredible...😏 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
José Morón
@jmgmoron
Federer es el mayor talento natural que ha pisado una pista de tenis.
Pese a su actual edad, que ha ganado un par de kilitos y que tiene la rodilla oxidada, se mueve con una soltura y una facilidad que ya no se ve hoy día.
Este hombre no se movía por la pista… BAILABA.
Hoy seguiría ganando partidos porque con su saque, su derecha y su inteligencia para abrir ángulos y subir a la red superaría a muchos jóvenes que hoy solo tienen el zambombazo como arma, pero con falta de planes alternativos.
No habrá sido el que más ha ganado, pero a nivel estético, Roger Federer es lo más bello que hemos visto, y probablemente veremos, en una pista de tenis.
Tennis Channel
@TennisChannel
He’s still got the magic 🪄
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tiempo De Tenis
@Tiempodetenis1
😂 Jajaja, esta anécdota que contó Mirka sobre los inicios de Roger:
🗣 "En esos primeros años, a veces lo ayudaba a calentar antes de los partidos. Como yo había jugado profesionalmente, Roger pensaba que podía ayudarlo a prepararse".
🗣 "Todavía me acuerdo de Andy Roddick bromeando después de la final de Cincinnati: 'No puedo creer que perdí contra un tipo al que su novia le hizo la entrada en calor'. Realmente dijo eso". -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
"Trump is the most narcissistic human being we have ever seen in American politics, full stop.
And on the upswing, that helped him because we had a society that is itself narcissistic ... He gave a permission structure for everyone to be their worst selves. 'I can care about me.' Here's a guy who cares about himself. ... Problem is, he does not give a shit about anyone other than himself. ...
He is the malignant narcissist, the sociopath and narcissist combined. These people become more and more delusional over time, because they create their own little world."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Ultimately, this research forces a burden-of-proof reversal across academic publishing and policy institutions: no researcher can safely claim to have identified a structural supply shock without first conditioning their residuals on observable financial variables and cross-border tradables proxies.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Cenk Uygur
@cenkuygur
The lunatics in Trump administration are talking about "tactical nukes." Cover story is they're concerned about preparedness for Russia and China. Bullshit, Israel has ordered us to start preparations for nuking Iran. They want us to do it for them, so we take the moral blame.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Joe Kent
@joekent16jan19
The neocons are trying to normalize the concept of using a nuclear weapon in Iran.
And as neocons always do, they are not even considering the 2nd & 3rd order effects of destructive ideas they advocate for.
Rebeccah Heinrichs
@RLHeinrichs
Good stuff by Victor. But I argue it’s not a bad weapon. It’s just a weapon. And our nuclear deterrence strategy has developed since we dropped the bombs. Our strategy (and targeting) now has better aligned just means and ends.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
How close are we to nuclear war? According to Joe Kent, a lot closer than you think.
0:00 Monologue
23:19 Are We Heading Toward Nuclear War?
26:51 What Does Unconditional Surrender Actually Mean?
30:23 Should Trump Be Impeached?
36:24 Israel's Escalation Into Lebanon and America's Response
42:21 Why Is Trump Still Under the Control of Neocons?
51:39 Ukraine Drafting Women Into the War
56:19 What Was the CIA Director Doing in Moscow?
1:04:25 Is This Fixable?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Joe Kent
@joekent16jan19
We are teetering at the edge of major escalations in both our war against Iran and our proxy war against Russia in Ukraine. An unanticipated event could easily spark a major incident that would have catastrophic consequences for our nation & the world.
The tragedy of both these conflicts is that neither was necessary nor embarked upon for the sake of our national interest. Instead, the deeper we get sucked into chaos, the clearer it becomes that foreign lobbies & defense contractors have effectively captured our leaders, while the needs & wellbeing of the American people are flagrantly dismissed.
Right now, we have an ever-shrinking window of opportunity to end both conflicts, but it will take aggressive diplomacy and an honest & unapologetic revision of our own national security apparatus to achieve it.
In the Middle East, the Israelis remain dominant in driving our operations & policies. In Ukraine, our own intelligence & defense establishment created a behemoth to absorb all of the funding & career development that had previously flourished for them on the battlefields of the GWOT.
Ending the Israeli influence & military/intel industrial complex’s grip on our policy—at every level—is the fight we must have right now if we are going to avert disaster.
President Trump needs to look at who he’s surrounded by—who he’s taking advice from, who got him into these messes—and make major changes now, before it’s too late.
I discussed all of this with Tucker:
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
How close are we to nuclear war? According to Joe Kent, a lot closer than you think.
0:00 Monologue
23:19 Are We Heading Toward Nuclear War?
26:51 What Does Unconditional Surrender Actually Mean?
30:23 Should Trump Be Impeached?
36:24 Israel's Escalation Into Lebanon and America's Response
42:21 Why Is Trump Still Under the Control of Neocons?
51:39 Ukraine Drafting Women Into the War
56:19 What Was the CIA Director Doing in Moscow?
1:04:25 Is This Fixable?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
New Keynesian estimating equations is severely misspecified
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Shattering the "Cost-Push Shock" Residual:
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Gandalv
@Microinteracti1
🇺🇸 The United States wrote the most sophisticated constitution the world had seen, splitting power between the executive, the legislature and the judiciary so that no single man could ever run the place like a private estate. Then it added a free press, fifty stubborn states, independent agencies, a career civil service and elections every two years, just to be safe.
Two and a half centuries later the executive branch spends its Sunday posting AI-generated geese in blond wigs.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Power to the People ☭🕊
@ProudSocialist
BREAKING: Tucker Carlson says Trump should be “removed from office immediately” due to the fact that he threatened to use nuclear weapons.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Abier
@abierkhatib
Still wondering what led up to October 7? Watch this.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸 Tucker calls for Trump’s removal after nuke threats:
“I believe in stability. I think elected leaders should serve out their terms. I don’t hate Trump personally. With all of that said, the second any president actively considers first use of nuclear weapons, that person should be removed from office immediately!”
“Because that’s gotta be the red line, destroying all of humanity with a nuclear strike? Why isn’t there an attempt to remove him from office?”
Trump has crossed so many lines at this point, it’s apparent no one is really trying or doesn’t have the power to stop his musings at this point.
Writer: Jamie -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Azfar Rizvi
@AzfarRizvi
I never thought I would see in my lifetime two Jewish people on @TheDailyShow talk about David becoming Goliath in the context of Israel's genocide. Bravo @PeterBeinart #johnstewart
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brian Krassenstein
@krassenstein
Tucker Carlson calls for Trump’s removal from office.
Everybody who, at one time supported Trump will eventually figure out that they were wrong, whether they admit it or not.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Truth Matters
@politicsusa46
Listen to this, it’s important, because this is just about more self-enrichment. Nathan Jun was right when he first raised this, and he’s right now.
🎥 TikTok - vm.tiktok.com/ZN8FApJUJ/This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kenneth Roth
@KenRoth
What an utter embarrassment. Can you believe this guy is president of the United States?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Bill Madden
@maddenifico
This gentleman speaks for all rational Americans with active firing neurons.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The End of the World Party
@teotwp3
It's clear that no catastrophe will be great enough to wake humanity from its stupor. We are sleepwalking to extinction and threw the alarm clock out the window years ago.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Volcaholic 🌋
@volcaholic1
"We request the global community to come together," says Nepal's FM after the catastrophic glacier collapse. He explicitly warned that climate change is a "civilisational threat" to the Himalayas, demanding global action for a crisis Nepal did not cause.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
The Globe Letter
@GlobeLetter
JUST IN: Tucker Carlson has directly called for Donald Trump to be removed from office "immediately" — declaring that any president who considers first-use nuclear weapons has "forfeited his right to lead," per his podcast.
Carlson, a former Trump ally who strongly opposed both previous impeachments, said the possibility of Trump using nuclear weapons against Iran crosses a "red line." "Destroying all of humanity with a nuclear strike? So why isn't there an attempt to remove him from office, like immediately?" he asked.
He pointed to Trump's April warning that "a whole civilization will die tonight" if Iran failed to meet U.S. demands — calling it an implicit nuclear threat. Carlson also claimed discussions about tactical nuclear options have taken place at the Pentagon.
"Any leader of any country who suggests first use of nuclear weapons has forfeited his right to lead. He has to be removed immediately," Carlson said.
The MAGA civil war is now open. Carlson wants Trump removed. Trump calls him a loser. And the rift over Iran is tearing the movement apart. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Kathleen Tyson
@Kathleen_Tyson_
Thinking about this Chavez interview predicting US invasion of Venezuela, I realised what he did here.
Chavez made Venezuela into a Tar Baby for the US, an irresistible trap.
Chavez knew Venezuela’s economically extractable oil reserves were a mere 30 billion, but he made the conscious choice to exaggerate them tenfold to 300 billion and reported that huge number to OPEC.
Now that US has its coup and is illegally taking control of 17 oil fields it will be faced with the reality of stealing costly and inefficient oil operations that currently produce just 1.25 million BBD despite years of Chinese investment.
Venezuelans will still be poor, oppressed, but the empire Chavez always cast as evil will take all the blame of Venezuelans right and left and all the world too.
One of the few uses of Venezuelan sludge oil is asphalt, making the Tar Baby trap particularly elegant.
Brilliant revenge for decades of US sanctions from the grave.
youtu.be/qpGL-mj-LEk
David Vargas Araujo
@DavidVargasA18
Reportera: porque cree usted q Estados Unidos quiere invadir a Venezuela.
Hugo Chávez: porque Venezuela tiene la reserva d petróleo más grande de este planeta. Y EU se le acaba.
Reportera: ¿Esta usted paranoico con EU?
Hugo Chávez: De ninguna manera, yo solo soy realista.
RT👇 -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Brian Krassenstein
@krassenstein
It’s confirmed. The president is insane.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Roger Hallam
@RogerHallamCS21
There are no words for the horrors ahead. The insurance industry predicts 4 Billion Dead from climate collapse.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Every time I work through the assumptions required to make a DSGE model behave, this Galbraith quote becomes a little more relevant:
"Economists, when they seek to be profound, often succeed only in being wrong."
-John Kenneth Galbraith -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
God
@TheTweetOfGod
This is the alternate universe other alternate universes point to and laugh at.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Very good explanation of the impact of the loss of sulphur supplies from the Strait of Hormuz on fertilizer and copper production.
Michael Maloney
@mike_maloney
Brace for impact...
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Human☮🇺🇸🇺🇦🇺🇸🌊
@4HumanUnity
.@realDonaldTrump Thank you for your attention to this matter.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“Science is based on experiment, on a willingness to challenge old dogma, on an openness to see the universe as it really is. Accordingly, science sometimes requires courage—at the very least the courage to question the conventional wisdom.”
— Carl Sagan -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
ilhan dögüs
@ilhandogus
No mainstream economist can answer this question:
How can a newly established state pay the first salaries of its tax-collecting officials in its newly defined currency?
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
All central bankers doing monetary operations know they can't conduct a reserve drain without a prior reserve add- the CB has to credit accounts (spend first) before taxes can be paid/securities purchased as per MMT.
Yet all mainstream economists have this sequence backwards. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hussain “Hoz” Shafiei
@HussainShafiei
Ya Allah
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Andrew—#IAmTheResistance
@AmoneyResists
The president of the United States is posting AI slop videos of giant ducks that resemble him marching along “Lake America” with machine guns, fireworks, and American flags.
The man with the nuclear codes is literally out of his fucking mind.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Did someone tell him that renaming “Canada Ducks” to “Donald Ducks” was a compliment?
Orla Joelsen
@OJoelsen
Trump just posted this video featuring armed geese — all sporting what appears to be Trump-style hair.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Doonesbury by Garry Trudeau for August 30, 2026 production.doonesbury.com/doonesbury/strip/archive/2026/0… via @GoComics Testosterone shots cure communism...
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Paul Buitink 🎙
@paulbuitink
I talked to British comedian, author and sound money advocate @DominicFrisby about the evils of paper money and the future of gold. And about its secret history!
Thanks mate!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Orla Joelsen
@OJoelsen
Trump just posted this video featuring armed geese — all sporting what appears to be Trump-style hair.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Did someone tell him that renaming “Canada Ducks” to “Donald Ducks” was a compliment?
Orla Joelsen
@OJoelsen
Trump just posted this video featuring armed geese — all sporting what appears to be Trump-style hair.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Ryan Rozbiani
@RyanRozbiani
Someone Remind Trump that the 300 Spartans LOST to Persia
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Trump Lie Tracker (Commentary Account)
@MAGALieTracker
BREAKING: Trump just posted an AI slop video of armed ducks marching and firing in unison on “Lake America.”
He’s gone completely insane.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
All central bankers doing monetary operations know they can't conduct a reserve drain without a prior reserve add- the CB has to credit accounts (spend first) before taxes can be paid/securities purchased as per MMT.
Yet all mainstream economists have this sequence backwards. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Saganism
@Saganismm
“There have been ages of progress and ages of degeneracy. There have been ages of moral progress, times when sympathy became wider. The chief element in moral progress is a widening of sympathy. If we confine sympathy to our families it is not enough; if we confine sympathy to our nations it is too narrow. We ought to include the animals. It is the widening of sympathy that is the essential thing. In our age, we have gone the other way, we have narrowed sympathy down more and more.”
— Bertrand Russell -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
La Mojo Jojo
@nnagrom
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a beautiful sendup of the US claim to be a democracy.
Iran Embassy in Zimbabwe
@IRANinZIMBABWE
American democracy every four years.
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
There are legitimate criticisms of John Maynard Keynes, but you don't need to invent them.
Econ Twitter has gone to shit with monetized grifters turning economic history into engagement bait.
Handre
@Handre
John Maynard Keynes lived as a quintessential elitist who despised the very people his theories claimed to help. While you hear endless praise for his "compassionate" economics, the man himself viewed workers and savers with open contempt, calling them irrational actors who needed enlightened technocrats to manage their affairs.
The Cambridge don made his fortune speculating in currencies and commodities while simultaneously advocating for government controls that would eliminate such opportunities for ordinary people. He lost his shirt in 1928, then again in 1929, proving himself a mediocre investor despite his theoretical "brilliance". His personal financial disasters never dimmed his confidence that he could engineer prosperity for entire nations.
Keynes openly admitted his theories served political expediency rather than economic truth. In a 1944 letter to Friedrich Hayek, he wrote that he expected his ideas to be temporary measures, lasting perhaps 25 years before sounder thinking would prevail. He never intended his deficit spending prescriptions to become permanent doctrine.
The man who gave intellectual cover to every government's spending addiction actually agreed with free market economists on the long run. He simply believed political reality made sound economics impossible. His famous quip "in the long run we are all dead" was political cynicism: politicians need solutions that work before the next election, consequences be damned.
You celebrate Keynes as the savior of capitalism, but he designed his system to give politicians exactly what they wanted: intellectual permission to spend money they didn't have on programs that bought votes. He knew this would end badly. He just figured someone else would clean up the mess after he died. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
“Kogan and Bernstein go on to call for new ways, not yet imagined, to scare Congress, the public and the ‘political system’.” www.levyinstitute.org/publications/congress-is-rightly-ti…
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
-
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
MarshFamilySongs
@MarshSongs
Here's our 🎶 parody version of Barry McGuire's 1965 "Eve of Destruction" that we've modernised to turn to current US adventurism. We're calling it: "Grief and Destruction" 🚀
#iran
#micfaceblockage
#cajonfrontandcentreThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
Physicists may have made a huge mistake when they introduced dark energy. That is what a team of mathematicians say after looking at the equations. Because they find that, actually, it’s unnecessary. If they are right, that would be the ultimate embarrassment for physicists.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Profits and the Inflation Sequence
Our empirical testing finds no need to introduce an independent profit shock to explain the observed inflation sequence. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
BladeoftheSun
@BladeoftheS
Economics is a completely fake science like Eugenics.
It exists only to tell you the rich need to be made richer at any cost, it is the only priority, and somehow in some way that will trickle down to you.
Except of course it never will.
There is no worse, more useless Degree.
Senator Rand Paul
@SenRandPaul
“If socialists understood economics, they wouldn't be socialists.”
― Friedrich HayekThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen reposted
Hussain “Hoz” Shafiei
@HussainShafiei
Fact.
Whoever you vote for in America, whether it’s a republican or a democrat, you’re always getting an Israeli-first president. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a beautiful sendup of the US claim to be a democracy.
Iran Embassy in Zimbabwe
@IRANinZIMBABWE
American democracy every four years.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is beyond priceless. It’s an absolutely brilliant parody of the farce that is @realDonaldTrump
Can someone enter this in the Eurovision Song Contest? After all, if bloody Australia can compete in it, why not Iran?
Sarrah Bellus
@sarrah_bellus
😭🇮🇷 The Iranian LEGO guys just made a Natalie Harp video.
I genuinely wasn’t prepared for this level of internet chaos. 😂
The internet has officially lost the plot.
Did you see this?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I agree with @JDVance here, and can back him up with system dynamics modeling. Reserve currency status is seen as a spoil of Empire, but it’s actually a spoiler of Empires.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
JD Vance wants to end the US dollar's position as a global reserve currency, because he thinks it allows Americans to consume too much and do so too cheaply.
Keep that in mind the next time you order a $20 burrito on door dash.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I could not agree more! Policymakers have been deluded by economists to think that climate change is a distant and minor problem. They’re about to find out the hard way how totally wrong the economists were.
Matthew Todd 🌏🔥
@MrMatthewTodd
I’m scared shitless. This is all happening so much faster than expected.
@mrjamesob you’re one of the only people who seems to care. Can’t you call a meeting of all the producers and presenters and get a scientist like @KevinClimate in to explain what’s coming because we are all up shit creek at this point. We desperately need to
Pressure the govt to broadcast the facts to the public via @nebriefing
@andyburnham @AngelaRayner @YvetteCooperMP @bphillipsonMP don’t seem to understand or care at all -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
ChatGPT uses more energy every day than 22,000 American homes.
The dominant model in economics does not include energy as a variable.
Read that again.
We are living inside the biggest accounting error in the history of civilisation.
The economy does not run on money. It runs on energy. Always has.
And the people in charge of modelling it left energy out of the equation in 1928 and never put it back.
I sat down with Nivi Jaswal Wirtjes and traced the line from peat bogs in Amsterdam to AI server farms in Nevada. Same story. Same blind spot. Same ending if we do not wake up.
Check out the conversation in the comments.
P.S. I also explained why I think mass unemployment from AI is more likely to give us the Hunger Games than universal basic income.
#stevekeen #energyeconomics #ai #connectingthedots -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
America banned chip exports to China thinking it would cripple them. It did the opposite.
Every Chinese schoolchild learns about the Opium Wars. They learn they cannot rely on the West.
So when America says "you cannot have this technology," it inspires the Chinese to replace it themselves.
The bans forced their engineers to find new ways to produce low-micron chips and pack enormous processing power into small bundles.
DeepSeek V4 now achieves 80 to 90 percent of top American model performance at 10 percent of the cost.
Where Americans used brute force, the Chinese used intelligence. They cut down the computational load, found the overkill, and got most of the answers with far less energy.
Then they made it open source. You can load it on your own hardware. No data centre needed.
China's Politburo is dominated by engineers. America is run by economists and lawyers.
The engineers built an 800-volt transmission system before AI arrived. The economists never thought about it.
That is why I believe the Chinese were set up to win this contest before it even began.
For a more comprehensive understanding, please refer to the video presentation with Andrew Neil in the comment section.
#stevekeen #chinaai #deepseek #aicompetition #chipwar #opensource #economics #artificialintelligence -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Speaking as a Professor of Economics with decades of experience of the University system, non-Neoclassical ideas will never be taught at leading Universities, or by economics textbooks. The long overdue Scientific Revolution in economics will have to come from outside Universities
-
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Watch the full breakdown here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyLnDop6Ux4
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Finally, the consequences of government and private money creation for the non-bank private sector are very different. Bank loans do not affect the private sector's net financial worth. Government deficits increase the private sector's net financial worth.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is a well-reasoned argument.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
And isn't that rich, coming from someone who was willing to assume that a benevolent central authority redistributed income in capitalist economies in order to hang onto the concept of a downward-sloping demand curve?
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I want you to think about the last time you saw a famine story.
It was probably framed around drought, flood, or a failed harvest. A tragedy, yes, but usually one with a clear natural cause.
What is unfolding now does not fit that frame.
This is not weather. It is a political decision moving through a supply chain.
The Strait of Hormuz sits between that decision and the dinner tables of millions of people across South Asia, most of whom had no role in starting this war and no power to stop it.
The strange part is the mechanism. The fertilizer exists. The ships exist. The farmers are ready. What is missing is the will to let the cargo through.
That is a different kind of tragedy.
I have explained the scenario in the comments.
#stevekeen #realisticeconomics #humanitariancrisis -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is extremely important. Later this year the world will suffer two simultaneous disasters: the collateral damage of Trump and Netanyahu’s stupid war, and the biggest El Niño ever.
Matthew Gross
@HurricaneAddict
I really don't think enough people fully comprehend the worlds that are about to collide here.
You already have people in geopolitical circles warning about the threat of famine based on surging prices / availability of fertilizer components, and you also have long-term weather modeling all converging on a worst case scenario for a building El Nino event, which will peak near the end of the year. These are two slow moving but entirely predictable disasters that when coupled together will each make the other orders of magnitude worse. (This will take months to fully unfold, but at this point, the die is cast.)
There's no event in our history books that combines the current global population with the impending fertilizer shortage and the strength of the El Nino that's coming. We are about to witness an unprecedented event that will push crops around the globe to their limit. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
90% of money created since 2000 was created by private banks. Not the government.
And between 1980 and 2000, the government was actually destroying money while monetarists were blaming it for inflation.
In my latest video, I show exactly how private debt acceleration drives asset price booms, how financial equity works like a seesaw that always tilts against the non-bank sector, and why the obsession with cutting government deficits is making all of this worse.
You'll find more details in the comment section.
#privatedebt #financialinstability #economicreality #postkeynesian #stevekeen -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is important. People think the Nobel Prize in Economics is politically impartial. In fact it isn’t, and it isn’t even a Nobel Prize. It was invented by the Swedish Central Bank when it was fighting social democratic economic policies in Sweden.
Critics of neoclassical economics are equally excluded. It’s a tribal award.
Charles Como
@underground_net
The Nobel Prize in Economics is not an actual prize as Nobel himself said economics is not an actual science but a political tool. Its real name is actually The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel created by banks. youtu.be/P1GvaYbfXHY
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
We’ve covered the fertilizer nightmare at Hormuz, but here’s the real gut-punch: our oil obsession blinds us to the actual falling domino.
. If war blocks the tankers, trucks idle, food rots in the fields, and cities starve. Even wealthy nations unravel fast when the wheels stop.
The UK is worse: under a month of oil, zero domestic fertilizer, and 40% of food imported. No fuel means no deliveries. Meanwhile, China has buffered 450 days of petrol and 1.5 years of grain.
The West’s "just-in-time" house of cards is ready to collapse unless the UN intervenes.
Check the comment section for more information.
#supplychain #energysecurity #foodsecurity #stevekeen #hormuz #geopolitics #economicresilience -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I've seen dozens of these over the years, with dozens of topics. This one has the best script ever!
Fintwit Capital
@fan_fintwit
Trump's Iran Downfall
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
This is correct. The people who hollowed out US manufacturing were US capitalists, who willingly shipped production to China to exploit its low wages, regardless of the consequences for US workers. China turned US arrogance towards its poor to the advantage of China's poor.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
1/10
Niall Ferguson claims the US is in "big trouble" because debt interest payments now exceed defense spending. He calls it "Ferguson's Law."
I call it a fundamental misunderstanding of double-entry bookkeeping.
Here is why the debt panic is wrong.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
10/10
Stop worrying about the debt and start looking at the accounting.
Watch my full breakdown of why Ferguson is wrong here:
youtu.be/e32ANMH8TpA
#economics #stevekeen #modernmoney -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Quiet Wealth Transfer. From Wages to Debt.
For decades, the story you were sold was simple: "Work hard, get educated, and you’ll be fine."
But behind the scenes, the engine of the economy was swapped out. We stopped powering growth with wages and started powering it with private debt.
The real macro bomb was never public debt - it was private debt. Before the 2008 crisis, U.S. government debt was about 60% of GDP. But private debt had surged up to 170% of GDP.
And that trend didn't stop.
Today, private debt remains elevated at around 145% of GDP. Higher than any pre-2000 level.
Every major modern crisis - the Great Depression, 2008 - was preceded not by government deficits, but by a collapse in private credit. When that credit engine stalls, the economy crashes. Mainstream economists ignored this. They told you banks were just "intermediaries." They lied. Banks create money, and they pumped that money into existing assets - houses - rather than factories or innovation. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You remember what the "Dream" was supposed to look like.
You get a job. You work hard. By your mid-20s, you buy that house with the white picket fence. You raise a family on one income. You retire with dignity.
Look around you. That world is gone.
It wasn't stolen by immigrants, and it wasn't lost to "bad luck." It was structurally engineered out of existence by a financial system designed to inflate assets while suppressing wages.
In the United States in 2025, the median age of a first-time homebuyer has now hit 40 years old. That is an all-time high. Back in 1991, it was 28.
That isn't a "vibe shift." It is a mechanical failure of the economy.
Say you're earning $100,000 a year - a number your parents would have called "wealthy" - but it feels like $60,000. That feeling is not in your head. It is in the data.
Since 2000, U.S. median household income has risen only ~99% in nominal terms. But after adjusting for inflation, real incomes are up only 8.5%.
Meanwhile, median home prices are up 155%.
AKA Home prices have risen roughly 18x FASTER than your real purchasing power. Home prices are growing at 150% while your real purchasing power has grown less than 9%.
In 1985, a home cost 3.5x your income.
Today, we are looking at national ratios of 5x to 7x. In Los Angeles, it's 12.5x.
This makes the concept of the 'American Dream' mathematically impossible for most families.
You aren't bad with money. The game board was tilted against you before you even rolled the dice.
You can't see this tilt on a standard spreadsheet. Standard economics hides these mechanics.
You need a way to visualize the flows that are draining your bank account before they even hit your ledger.
If you keep relying on 'budgeting harder' while the macro-tide is going out, you will drown.
You will spend the next decade cutting coupons while your net worth is silently eroded by asset inflation you never saw coming.
Want to learn the real deal, drop in the comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
What actually caused the greatest downturn in the history of capitalism?
In my presentation, I argue as Irving Fisher did in 1933 that it wasn’t “panic,” “technology shocks,” or just “the Fed,” but a collapse in credit-based demand at a time of very low inflation, after private debt had already become dangerously high.
Using historical data, I show how US credit shifted from roughly +8–10% of GDP in the 1920s to about −30% in the early 1930s, while inflation went from roughly zero to −10% per year.
That combination of over‑indebtedness and deflation—the debt disease and price‑level disease—meant that the more debtors paid down their loans, the heavier their real debt burden became.
I also explain why mainstream (neoclassical) economists ignored Fisher’s debt‑deflation theory, left banks and private debt out of their models, and focused instead on equilibrium stories and “loanable funds” where bank lending has no macroeconomic impact.
That intellectual blind spot is exactly why they failed to anticipate the Global Financial Crisis, even as private debt more than tripled relative to GDP between the end of World War II and 2007.
Lastly, I contrast the fantasy banking model with a realistic one using my Ravel software and show how turning credit negative shrinks the money supply and drags GDP down—precisely what happened in the early 1930s and again after 2008.
I also highlight the crucial role of government spending: from the New Deal to World War II to the post‑2008 deficits that quietly stopped another Great Depression.
Watch here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6zxzgViT9M
#economics #finance #greatdepression #privatedebt #macroeconomics #banking -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If we need a different model for each episode we are historians, not economists. The hope of economics as a science is that we can distill a simple structure that successfully explains consecutive episodes with a single model. And if our research agenda is progressive, in the sense of Lakatos,
grokipedia.com/page/Imre_Lakatos
we should occasionally have predictive successes. A research agenda that fails to do that, again in the sense of Lakatos, is degenerative. The NK research program is clearly degenerative since each new episode requires a modification of its protective belt. In my view, this stems from an unwillingness to drop the natural rate hypothesis from the hardcore of the program. @GuthmannR
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
One thing about business cycle macroeconomics is that, in recent decades, each recession has been different from the previous one, thus requiring a different kind of model to explain.
1) The COVID recession is an obvious case of a negative exogenous shock.
2) Brazil experienced a massive 2015-2016 recession associated with fiscal irresponsibility and increased political uncertainty due to an impeachment.
3) The 2008-2009 Great Recession was due to a financial crisis (can be understood as a sector-specific negative shock).
4) Brazil experienced a recession in 2002-2003 following electoral political uncertainty.
Given these facts, I don't see much relevance in a business cycle model based on price rigidities in the first place (i.e., the NK model), which could be relevant for a macroeconomic environment centered on aggregate demand-driven business cycles.
However, the historical phenomenon of the aggregate demand-driven business cycle is now a thing of the past. It applied to the 19th and early 20th centuries, when cyclical economic behavior was associated with the banking system expanding the supply of money and credit until a recession hit. It's also a phenomenon that Lucas (1972) explained much more elegantly than any model before or after.
In regards to empirical calibration of these models, I should point out that when COVID hit, the DSGE models of the IMF projected Brazilian GDP to contract by 9% and it officially contracted by 4.5%. Errors of this magnitude (i.e., 100%) are quite standard and not very different from informal estimates based on intuition.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the NK model is neither elegant nor useful.
The IS/LM model was useful — but incomplete — because its core equations summarize observable empirical relationships between aggregates. The attempt to graft a forward looking ‘Phillips curve’ onto the model was an unmitigated disaster. @jasonfurman @FrancoisGeerolf @monacelt
1. The Euler equation is an elegant description of the first order condition of a representative agent with perfect foresight. That agent does not exist. A much better foundation for understanding how consumption moves over time was Friedman’s permanent income hypothesis. And since the work of Truman Bewley, we have a firm foundation for that equation that is grounded in borrowing constraints and incomplete markets in a heterogeneous agent model.
2. The NK Phillips curve does not characterize any observable empirical regularity. It never has. The original Phillips curve, a connection between wage inflation and unemployment in UK data, disappeared soon after Phillips published his eponymous article. The reason it takes a semester to teach the NK Phillips curve is that it requires a set of ugly non refutable theoretical contortions that only a mother could love.
3. The NK model has no unemployment. People voluntarily change their labor supply behavior in response to ‘shocks’, the consequences of which are correctly forecast. That assumption does not fit with what we know about labor markets. I blogged about that here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/12/real-business…
4. The NK model assumes that employment (not unemployment) fluctuates around a stationary ‘natural rate of unemployment’. I wrote about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t…
Fed economists spend countless hours attempting to estimate this ‘natural rate’. This is a Sisyphean task since the unemployment rate in data is essentially a random walk.
The correct strategy at this point is to abandon much of the rational expectations revolution and to reconstruct macroeconomics beginning with what we knew circa 1960. This, I believe, is already beginning. There is a large body of theorists working on Bewley models and that group has concluded that rational expectations was a misstep. See, for example, the recent working paper by @ben_moll
benjaminmoll.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/challenge.pdf
I am not as convinced as Ben, that our models must be nonlinear with global solution methods since, if Ben’s approach is successful, even linearized models in aggregates will likely display very different properties from either NK or classical RBC economies. But dropping the full implications of rational expectations is a promising way forward.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I don’t like the word “science” for this sort of thing.
But this is a very useful way to understand the world, consider some of the most important macroeconomic policy debates, and a flexible framework that you can build on to add different nuances and complexities.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Then you should definitely also read Peters, O. (2019). "The ergodicity problem in economics." Nature Physics 15(12): 1216–1221. doi.org/10.1038/s41567-019-0732-0
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I'm calling out the lie that housing is unaffordable due to "supply issues"
After analyzing data from the top 15 countries over 50+ years, I can prove it's actually banks that did this.
They've been allowed to pour unlimited mortgage money into housing markets worldwide.
𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗿𝗲𝘀𝘂𝗹𝘁?
The younger generation pays 2.5x what baby boomers paid (inflation-adjusted).
Leave the house aside; even affording the down payment needs a savings plan.
View my analysis in the comments. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Zach is spot on, and it's fabulous to see this being said on national media. Now we need to educate the journalist, who have been "sold a pup" by mainstream economists, who have never and will never understand how money is created.
BBC Newsnight
@BBCNewsnight
“You are not answering my question, with respect.”
@vicderbyshire challenges newly elected Green Party leader @ZackPolanski on his plans to increase Government spending, who adds:
“We don't need to borrow, we don't need to tax and spend, we need to spend and tax.”
#newsnight -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
When are you lot going to realize that you have to get the accounting right, or what you say is nonsense? And you’ve got the accounting wrong.
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🇺🇸 THE NATIONAL DEBT ISN’T A BUG... IT’S THE FEATURE
Everyone loves to blame “lazy politicians” for the exploding debt.
But here’s the ugly truth: it’s not laziness.
It’s design.
Cutting spending or raising taxes? Political suicide.
Voters punish pain, not promises.
Markets soak up the debt like it’s no big deal.
So what’s the rational move for any leader? Spend now, pretend tomorrow doesn’t exist, and coast to reelection.
Short-term politicians. Long-term problems. A public wired for instant gratification.
Debt isn’t a glitch in the system... it is the system!
Kicking the can isn’t failure, it’s the plan.
Left vs. Right is theater, the red ink is reality.
Source: @elonmusk, @TheAliceSmith -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
'Climate Action: Tackling the Climate...' - an online course from @uoldigital on @FutureLearn. Join now: www.futurelearn.com/courses/climate-action-tackling-the-c… Highly recommended, since I know the course designers.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Don't study economics at university. What they teach is empirically false garbage.
In just 9 simple points, let me explain why... and what to study instead. -
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Anyone who thinks this is hyperbole, and that economists surely aren't that stupid, should look at--but don't buy, it only encourages them--economist Daniel Susskind's 2024 book Growth: A Reckoning
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Reckoning with Neoclassical Ideas about Growth
www.patreon.com/posts/reckoning-with-113316776 My review of @danielsusskind's Growth: A Reckoning for The Ideas Letter @OpenSociety
His answer to "the Great Question about Growth, Prosperity, and Everything" would have been more interesting if it were "42" -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Climate change's economic impact is often underestimated. Economists like William Nordhaus claim 85% of the U.S. economy is unaffected. This overlooks the crucial roles of energy and raw materials in manufacturing. Ignoring these leads to catastrophic damage underestimations.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mainstream economics fails to grasp the role of energy in production. They mistake their models for reality.
Without energy, labor is a corpse and capital is a sculpture.
We need to integrate energy into economic models to reflect the real world.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
For anyone wondering, this tweet was produced by my AI, and I 100% endorse it. It's channelling my 2019 paper (with Ayres and Standish) entitled "A Note on the Role of Energy in Production", where I first came up with that aphorism. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0921800917311746
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Climate change isn't a distant problem.
It's happening now, and mainstream economics is failing us.
We need to act urgently to mitigate its impacts. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mainstream economics fails to grasp the role of energy in production.
Ignoring this leads to flawed models and policies that can't address climate change.
We must integrate energy into economic models to reflect reality and drive effective climate action. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The idea that climate change won't impact most of the economy is absurd. Manufacturing depends on energy and raw materials, both climate-sensitive. Ignoring this leads to gross underestimations of economic damage. We need realistic models that account for these factors.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Global warming will devastate economies.
Assuming no damage to capital, labor, or technology is absurd.
We need realistic models to prepare for the future.Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Which is why @CarbonBubble published my report and the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries published actuaries.org.uk/media/qeydewmk/the-emperor-s-new-climate…
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Dirk @DEhnts works are high quality, as is @StephanieKelton's The Deficit Myth. You can also work out the monetary accounting underpinning MMT using my Ravel software www.patreon.com/Ravelation. I use it to explain fiat money here profstevekeen.substack.com/p/its-a-mixed-credit-fiat-worl…
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Neoclassical economists underestimate climate change's impact.
A 1.4% GDP fall prediction is laughable.
Realistically, we face total economic collapse if we don't act now.
It's time to rethink our economic models and policies. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Thanks Michael--and the History of Economic Thought as well, starting with the Physiocrats or earlier (Petty, though I start my own courses with Aristotle). It's a travesty how little today's economists know about the history of Neoclassical economics, let alone the full canon.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
Steve Keen says that if a student wants to become a good economist, he or she would be better off studying systems dynamics than mainstream economics. I mostly agree, although I'd add that a deep grounding in economic history is also important.
-
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
Let me react to this. If we take as a reasonable baseline that r-g will be roughly equal to zero, stabilization of the debt to gdp ratio requires a primary balance of zero. So, indeed eliminating primary deficits should be an eventual goal for all countries.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You are showing your ignorance of double entry bookkeeping Olivier. This is the foundation of all Neoclassical misunderstanding of government finances.
See profstevekeen.substack.com/p/using-system-dynamics-with-m… for the actual accounting. -
Steven Pressman
@pressmansteven
Glad that you managed to pull this one off! MOORE kudos to you! 😄
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
AMAZING NEWS
After some negotiations, I am so happy to report that Routledge will re-publish Basil Moore's 1988 book on horizontalism, with an extended introduction by Marc Lavoie and myself.
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Very happy. Alas can’t find a pun with basil
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
You always need Moore Basil …
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
I’m attending the farewell to Victoria Chick at @ucl. One of the greats of Post-Keynesian Economics, she is gone, while Neoclassical Economics unfortunately still lives on. We’ll continue making words wild in your honour Vicki.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The SVB Failure: Why It Happened and What It Means
democracyjournal.org/arguments/the-svb-failure-why-it-hap…
by ex-banker & regulator Richard Vague of @DebtEconomics -
Nika Dubrovsky
@nikadubrovsky
We opened the @DavidGraeber Institute! It was great! Hundreds of people and a real Carnival. If you were with us please send us pictures and videos
press@davidgraeber.org
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
One clip I recorded…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Consequences of Moving from Industrial to Financial Capitalism consortiumnews.com/2021/01/07/the-consequences-of-moving-… with Michael Hudson
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Debt Deflation and the Neofeudal Empire with Michael Hudson realprogressives.org/podcast_episode/episode-88-debt-defl… @rethinkecon
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Mapped: The Countries With the Highest Housing Bubble Risks www.visualcapitalist.com/mapped-the-countries-with-the-hi… hat tip @TGooding @Idemamba @jryancollins @linzcom @PhilipSoos
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Do Women Avoid Economics...Or Does Economics Avoid Women? via @forbes www.forbes.com/sites/johntharvey/2019/01/11/do-women-avoi…
-
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Which is why I think there should be a #nobbleprizeineconomics, for people like Nordhaus whose insane assumptions have nobbled sensible economics.
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Storm warnings in @openDemocracy www.opendemocracy.net/neweconomics/storm-warnings/ @d_orrell sees parallels between the disputes in economics today and the reaction to weather forecasting in the 1800s
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
There's a better way to make economic forecasts, says @Mark__Buchanan www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-10-01/a-better-way-t… via @bv Hat-tip to @AlanTonelson
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Literally every unit that we call an organism is in fact a highly regulated society of lower-level units that evolved by higher-level selection." evonomics.com/pirates-economics-self-interest-hayek-wilson/
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
A precis of “Can we avoid another financial crisis?” on the @RealWorldEcon blog rwer.wordpress.com/2017/05/01/discussing-can-we-avoid-ano…
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
The Bundesbank and the Macroeconomics of "BOMD": Bank Originated Money and Debt www.patreon.com/posts/9585333 @paulkrugman @rethinkecon
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Investors lock out a generation from home ownership www.smh.com.au/comment/investors-lock-out-a-generation-fr… via @smh
-
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
It has been hijacked by Gonzalo Lira @MrWonkish. He is taking all subscription money and ignores my demands to shut the site down.





















































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































