Very very sad. The only reason for reversing these is because the teacher's unions hate them - it's not better for the kids. It's essentially to further the already deeply parasitic relationship between the teacher's unions and the Democratic Party.
Roger Farmer
Roger Edward Alfred Farmer is a British-American economist and is currently serving as professor at the University of Warwick and is a Distinguished Emeritus Professor and former Chair of the Economics department at the University of California, Los Angeles. He has also held positions at the University of Pennsylvania, the European University Institute and the University of Toronto. He is a Fellow of the Econometric Society, Research Associate of the National Bureau of Economic Research, and Research Fellow of the Centre for Economic Policy Research, and the former Research Director of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR). He was made a Fellow of the Royal Economic Society in May 2025. In 2013, he was the Senior Houblon-Norman Fellow at the Bank of England. He is internationally recognized for his work on self-fulfilling prophecies. Farmer has published several scholarly articles in leading academic journals. He is also a co-founder of the Indeterminacy School in Macroeconomics. His body of work has advanced the view that beliefs are a new fundamental in economics that have the same methodological status as preferences, technology, and endowments. In his 1993 book, Macroeconomics of Self-fulfilling Prophecies, he argues that beliefs should be modeled with the introduction of a Belief Function, which explains how people form ideas about the future based on things they have seen in the past. In his 2010 book, Expectations, Employment and Prices, he suggests an alternative paradigm to New Keynesian economics which reintroduces a central idea from John Maynard Keynes' The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money; that high involuntary unemployment can persist as a permanent equilibrium outcome. He provided an accessible introduction to these ideas in his 2010 book How the Economy Works, and more recently, in his 2016 book Prosperity for All, both of which were written for a general audience. The Farmer Monetary Model has different and high policy implications and relevance. Farmer's policy proposal to achieve full employment by controlling and stabilizing asset prices shows promise as a way to help prevent stock market crashes and deep recessions. His son is the economist Leland Edward Farmer, who joined the faculty at the University of Virginia in July 2017. More on Wikipedia
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Shane Hensinger đșđžđđșđŠđźđ· @CaliforniaFirst
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I just ordered it from Amazon. Looking forward to reading it!
Ben Lester
@benjamminlester
Canât wait to read this book by my good friend @GregWKaplan!
Greg Kaplan
@GregWKaplan
My first book "Macro: The Economic Models that Shape Our World" is now out !
Available at your favorite bookseller. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Belongia and @PIrelandEcon (2019) is specifically about the stability of momey demand ( www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0164070419⊠). To my knowledge, this is also the most recent paper to tackle this in the US. @RebelEconProf (2013) is a slightly older piece that has a lot on money demand stability ( www.cambridge.org/core/journals/macroeconomic-dynamics/ar⊠). There is also Gogas and Serlitis (2014) ( onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/jmcb.12103?casa_t⊠) who re-do a version of King et al . (1991), but with Divisia money.
The take-home here is that using Divisia aggregates makes money demand look less unstable in US data. It makes money growth look less redundant (conditional on short term nominal rates) when predicting inflation rates. Another thing that often comes up in this literature is IRFs for MP shocks show fewer puzzles -- even when using simplistic identification procedures -- when using Divisia aggregates.
Now, all of those papers were published before COVID, so they are missing the recent inflation surge. That is significant for your comment about the possible non-stationarity of inflation rates. If you go far back enough in time for the United States, you conclude that inflation rates are covariance stationary. Likewise, if you append that spike, inflation looks slightly less persistent and that probably "helps" the case of money demand stability.
As regards changing regimes, that is a fair concern, but what this means for theory depends on how you model those changes. Say that you have a DSGE model with time-varying parameters in something like the Taylor rule. If rational expectations hold, then its linearized reduced-form is a (possibly cointegrated) VARMA process.
This goes back to something fundamental in statistics that most of us forget: you have to pick a sandbox (i.e., make some untestable assumptions). How much change in policy is tolerable depends on how you model it.
All I can say here is that, if your sandbox is like medium scale NK models (i.e., the children of Christiano, Eichenbaum, and Evans 2005 and Smets and Wouters 2007) and your concept of acceptable change makes you want to start estimation around 1984 (i.e., post-Volker), then the methods in the papers above ought to be valid. If they reach conclusions that are at odds with those models (i.e., unstable money demand), then you know something's wrong. Econometrics (and statistics) isn't about the world -- it's about comparing models conditional on data. You just need to choose a sandbox in which all the models that you care about could live.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Are you aware, @S_Surprenant , of any recent research that estimates a stable money demand function using a Divisia aggregate as the dependent variable and an appropriate weighted index of opportunity cost variables as the cost of holding money?
There are pitfalls in that regression not least of which is changing monetary policy rules and apparent non-stationarity of inflation and interest rates, at least over sub periods. Here is a link to a related paper
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Itâs unclear, to me at least, what is the appropriate assumption about inflation expectations. Rational expectations, crudely applied, is becoming unfashionable and was probably never a good replacement for adaptive expectations - in the sense of dominating adaptive expectations in empirical work.
In practice, human beings use backward rules to predict the future and recent advances in AI suggest that we can now model adaptive rules that will rapidly track changes in the behavior of âexogenously determinedâ aggregates; i.e. the monetary base of the Fed Funds Rate.
Any links to related work gratefully appreciated Stéphane @JohnHCochrane @MaMoMVPY
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
A few things come to mind.
First, we have a solution to the endogeneity problem: they're called shocks. Of course, this comes with its own set of problems. Is the variation that you identified truly exogenous? Is it really estimating the effect that you have in mind? Also, quite often, if you answer "yes" to both, you're focusing all your energy on a tiny amount of fluctuation in the data.
The estimates might not be nearly as precise as you want such that even theories that make different predictions might be nonetheless hard to tell apart in the data.
In this particular case, we'd ask what happens when you move the policy rate.
Second, as regards this particular problem, there is something interesting that you can do without identifying a shock. A large body of theories predict that velocity is covariance stationary -- that is, it is mean-reverting.
That's not an empirically vacuous statement at all. Intuitively, if velocity can neither grow, nor fall forever, then the growth rates of money and nominal spending have to eventually match. That is, there's a mechanism baked in that keeps these things from drifting apart forever. It could be false. That's actually a topic of debate because, depending on how you measure money, you can find that velocity is too persistent for this to be true.
The same property also has implications for predicting inflation. Depending on how powerful is the error correction mechanism, knowing that M grows unusually faster than PY may or may not be useful to predict future growth rates of P. I don't know much theories disagree about the speed of that adjustment, but you can see how this relationship could hold true while the growth rate of M is a poor predictor of inflation -- that would happen at short horizon if the mechanism is slow.
Third, there's an issue of measurement involved. I get why some people just take M2 or something like that for international comparisons. What I don't get is why economists at the Federal Reserve aren't using Divisia aggregates for the US. We real GDP doesn't just naively add up spending on chairs, tanks, and graduate school. Those things are not perfect substitutes, so we use a Fisher index. Monetary aggregates add up assets that usually command different interest rates and afford people different degrees of liquidity, for instance. Simply adding them up is convenient, but it's also making your micro theory professor cry. Use adequate measures when they exist. We also know this can meaningfully change results empirically -- e.g., money demand looks more stable, money growth has better predicting power.
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
M= PY/V or PY = MV? You'd think after decades of extremely sophisticated causal econometrics, the most basic correlation isn't causation of all would not keep resurfacing. Money tracks nominal income in every theory, including FTPL, because central banks supply money passively, and demand is proportional to nominal income. Rich guys drive Porsches. Drive a Porsche and you'll get rich!
Lars Christensen
@MaMoMVPY
INFLATION IS STILL A MONETARY PHENOMENON
I have looked at 42 countries since December 2019. For each one I compared how much faster broad money has grown than the real economy with how high inflation has been.
The slope is 0.50 â one percentage point more money growth a year has meant roughly half a percentage point more inflation.
RÂČ is 0.57 â differences in money growth explain 57% of the differences in inflation across countries.
The countries that printed the most money got the most inflation. Switzerland and Japan, where money barely outgrew the economy, got the least.
The US sits just above the line. The euro area sits almost on it.
So forget supply chain disruptions and greedflation â that was always nonsense. Supply shocks change relative prices. They do not create years of broad-based inflation across 42 countries.
It is money, and it still is. Nominal spending remains excessive across the world, and that is what is keeping inflation elevated everywhere. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Are you aware, @S_Surprenant , of any recent research that estimates a stable money demand function using a Divisia aggregate as the dependent variable and an appropriate weighted index of opportunity cost variables as the cost of holding money?
There are pitfalls in that regression not least of which is changing monetary policy rules and apparent non-stationarity of inflation and interest rates, at least over sub periods. Here is a link to a related paper
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Itâs unclear, to me at least, what is the appropriate assumption about inflation expectations. Rational expectations, crudely applied, is becoming unfashionable and was probably never a good replacement for adaptive expectations - in the sense of dominating adaptive expectations in empirical work.
In practice, human beings use backward rules to predict the future and recent advances in AI suggest that we can now model adaptive rules that will rapidly track changes in the behavior of âexogenously determinedâ aggregates; i.e. the monetary base of the Fed Funds Rate.
Any links to related work gratefully appreciated Stéphane @JohnHCochrane @MaMoMVPY
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
A few things come to mind.
First, we have a solution to the endogeneity problem: they're called shocks. Of course, this comes with its own set of problems. Is the variation that you identified truly exogenous? Is it really estimating the effect that you have in mind? Also, quite often, if you answer "yes" to both, you're focusing all your energy on a tiny amount of fluctuation in the data.
The estimates might not be nearly as precise as you want such that even theories that make different predictions might be nonetheless hard to tell apart in the data.
In this particular case, we'd ask what happens when you move the policy rate.
Second, as regards this particular problem, there is something interesting that you can do without identifying a shock. A large body of theories predict that velocity is covariance stationary -- that is, it is mean-reverting.
That's not an empirically vacuous statement at all. Intuitively, if velocity can neither grow, nor fall forever, then the growth rates of money and nominal spending have to eventually match. That is, there's a mechanism baked in that keeps these things from drifting apart forever. It could be false. That's actually a topic of debate because, depending on how you measure money, you can find that velocity is too persistent for this to be true.
The same property also has implications for predicting inflation. Depending on how powerful is the error correction mechanism, knowing that M grows unusually faster than PY may or may not be useful to predict future growth rates of P. I don't know much theories disagree about the speed of that adjustment, but you can see how this relationship could hold true while the growth rate of M is a poor predictor of inflation -- that would happen at short horizon if the mechanism is slow.
Third, there's an issue of measurement involved. I get why some people just take M2 or something like that for international comparisons. What I don't get is why economists at the Federal Reserve aren't using Divisia aggregates for the US. We real GDP doesn't just naively add up spending on chairs, tanks, and graduate school. Those things are not perfect substitutes, so we use a Fisher index. Monetary aggregates add up assets that usually command different interest rates and afford people different degrees of liquidity, for instance. Simply adding them up is convenient, but it's also making your micro theory professor cry. Use adequate measures when they exist. We also know this can meaningfully change results empirically -- e.g., money demand looks more stable, money growth has better predicting power.
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
M= PY/V or PY = MV? You'd think after decades of extremely sophisticated causal econometrics, the most basic correlation isn't causation of all would not keep resurfacing. Money tracks nominal income in every theory, including FTPL, because central banks supply money passively, and demand is proportional to nominal income. Rich guys drive Porsches. Drive a Porsche and you'll get rich!
Lars Christensen
@MaMoMVPY
INFLATION IS STILL A MONETARY PHENOMENON
I have looked at 42 countries since December 2019. For each one I compared how much faster broad money has grown than the real economy with how high inflation has been.
The slope is 0.50 â one percentage point more money growth a year has meant roughly half a percentage point more inflation.
RÂČ is 0.57 â differences in money growth explain 57% of the differences in inflation across countries.
The countries that printed the most money got the most inflation. Switzerland and Japan, where money barely outgrew the economy, got the least.
The US sits just above the line. The euro area sits almost on it.
So forget supply chain disruptions and greedflation â that was always nonsense. Supply shocks change relative prices. They do not create years of broad-based inflation across 42 countries.
It is money, and it still is. Nominal spending remains excessive across the world, and that is what is keeping inflation elevated everywhere. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You have the patience of a Saint @GeorgeSelgin
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Criticizing the Quantity Theory of Money isnât all that hard. But it at least requires that one knows what the theory isâand it _isnât_ MV=Py! MV=Py is called the âEquation of Exchange,â and while itâs a truism, the Quantity Theoryâa theory of how M and P relate, isnât.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Personal insults are best left in the schoolyard. Nor do they contribute to the persuasiveness of your derivative arguments. You are Blocked
AXEC
@EgmontHandtke
âYes. General Equilibrium Theory is a language that enforces internal consistency. Like individual rationality: GE alone is irrefutable. That does not mean it is worthless: Far from it.â (Roger Farmer)
Yes, consistency is important: âResearch is, in fact, a continuous discussion of the consistency of theories: formal consistency insofar as the discussion relates to the logical cohesion of what is asserted in joint theories; material consistency insofar as the agreement of observations with theories is concerned.â (Klant)
However, each Paradigm stands or falls with its premises: âWhen the premises are certain, true, and primary, and the conclusion formally follows from them, this is demonstration, and produces scientific knowledge of a thing.â (Aristotle, Analytica)
J. S. Mill was perfectly clear about the starting problem: âWhat are the propositions which may reasonably be received without proof? That there must be some such propositions all are agreed, since there cannot be an infinite series of proof, a chain suspended from nothing. But to determine what these propositions are, is the opus magnum of the more recondite mental philosophy.â
The problem with modern macroeconomics is that it is axiomatically false. Economics is failed/fake science. The microfoundations approach was doomed from the outset.
The Founding Fathers defined economics as a social science, and accordingly, it has been based on subjective/behavioral assumptions/axioms. This has been the methodological ur-mistake.
For example, here are the Walrasian axioms: âHC1 economic agents have preferences over outcomes; HC2 agents individually optimize subject to constraints; HC3 agent choice is manifest in interrelated markets; HC4 agents have full relevant knowledge; HC5 observable outcomes are coordinated, and must be discussed with reference to equilibrium states.â (Weintraub)
The methodological mistake is that economists put the behavioral assumption of constrained optimization and equilibrium into the premises. This is a petitio principii, but economists do not know what this means.
Stupidity makes faithful worshipers: âAnd so â faithful to the theory's conceptual cornerstones and hoping against all hope that the unthinkable may still be achieved (i.e., a satisfactory theory of the price mechanism) â the tormented upholders of the validity of the paradigmatic core of economic equilibrium theory appear singularly reluctant to face the problem of comparing expectations and results and assessing the consistency of the theory.â (Ingrao et al., 1990, p. 346)
Although microfoundations is methodologically a false concept, economists repeat it nonetheless: âIn economics we should strive to proceed, wherever we can, exactly according to the standards of the other, more advanced, sciences, where it is not possible, once an issue has been decided, to continue to write about it as if nothing had happened.â (Morgenstern, 1941, pp. 369-370)
The way forward is to reconstruct economics entirely without the concepts of constrained optimization, rational expectations, equilibrium, and other NONENTITIES. In methodology, this is called a Paradigm Shift: âThere is another alternative: to formulate a completely new research program and conceptual approach. As we have seen, this is often spoken of, but there is still no indication of what it might mean.â (Ingrao et al., 1990, p. 362)
It means, first, that legacy economics goes down the scientific drain for good. It means, second, to go forward and perform the Paradigm Shift (â AXEC113i). It means, finally, to bury microeconomists in the darkest corner of the Flat-Earth cemetery.
Economics is a genuine system science, not a social science. Economists have gotten it wrong since the Founding Fathers. The EconNobel for 'economic sciences' is a scientific fraud. Roger Farmer is a retarded blatherer. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes. General Equilibrium Theory is a language that enforces internal consistency. Like individual rationality: GE alone is irrefutable. That does not mean it is worthless: Far from it. Like a set of Lego bricks, GE allows the construction of models that may or may not be good descriptions of the real world features they purport to describe.
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Indeed!!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And any student of general equilibrium theory will tell you that that result is not particularly deep and was well understood by anyone looking beyond one agent one good models even in the 1950s. That unfortunately did not include MIT macroeconomists. @micheleboldrin @foscaecon
Khazbi Budunov
@foscaecon
In the 1950sâ1970s, economists from the two Cambridges â the British Cambridge (post-Keynesians Joan Robinson and Piero Sraffa) and the American Cambridge (neoclassical economists Paul Samuelson and Robert Solow) â debated a fundamental question: What exactly is capital, and can the rate of profit be explained by the quantity of capital?
Imagine an economy with machines, buildings, and trucks. How do we measure the total quantity of capital?
You canât simply add them up as physical units. You can measure their value in monetary terms, but the value of capital depends, among other things, on the rate of profit. And the rate of profit itself is supposed to be explained by the quantity of capital. This creates a circular argument.
But the problem turned out to be even deeper.
According to conventional neoclassical reasoning, the lower the rate of profit, the more attractive capital-intensive production techniques become.
Post-Keynesian economists demonstrated that things donât necessarily work that way.
For example, at a high rate of profit, technique A may be preferred; at an intermediate rate, technique B; and at an even lower rate, technique A again.
This phenomenon is known as reswitching of techniques.
In 1966, even Paul Samuelson acknowledged that such an outcome was theoretically possible. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Very sorry to hear that @LiamHalligan Itâs their loss
Liam Halligan
@LiamHalligan
I was hoping to be able to announce this in my own time â but the media rumour mill is swirling, I'm being contacted by various reporters and others, and I don't like denying the truth, so ...
I wrote my first "Economic Agenda" column in The Sunday Telegraph 27 years ago, under the editorship of Dominic Lawson â filling-in occasionally during the late-1990s, before being given my own weekly slot from 2003.
Since then, while I've been heavily involved in television, and am perhaps better known as a broadcaster, penning "Economic Agenda" for The Sunday Telegraph each week has been the backbone of my journalistic life.
On Thursday, the @Telegraph rang to tell me my column is being scrapped.
I was asked, and have agreed, to write "Economic Agenda" until the end of November, as per my contract. After that, my Sunday Telegraph column will be no more.
Why this decision has been made, and whether or not my columns were any good, is for others to judge.
All I will say is that, as the first person in my family to attend university, sustaining a weekly column in a leading national newspaper for a quarter of a century has been a source of enormous pride for myself and my family.
Lots of people have been asking me about the future of "Planet Normal" - the hugely-popular Telegraph podcast which I co-created and co-present with the brilliant @AllisonPearson
"Planet Normal" has, over the last 330 weekly episodes, also become a major part of my professional life and my broader identity.
With Allison reportedly leaving the Telegraph as well, there is a lot of speculation about whether or not the podcast will continue to impart "news and views from beyond the bubble" with our usual blend of sharp analysis, humour and occasional outrage !
Well, I am delighted to confirm that Co-Pilot Pearson and myself are deeply committed to our joint podcast â and, above all, to our beloved listeners.
We will, as and when notice periods allow, continue our voyages through space every Thursday â perhaps to "Planet Normal", or maybe to another part of the solar system â so we can "gaze down each week at the madness of Planet Earth", as we have done since the Spring of 2020.
So citizens of Planet Normal, stand ready ! The "rocket-of-right-thinking", the "flying refuge of reasoned views", will soon be launched once again đđȘđšâđđ±ââïžđïžđș
I poured my heart and soul into "Economic Agenda" and "Planet Normal". The Telegraph's decision to scrap them is obviously a huge personal blow. But I will always be grateful for the opportunities the paper has given me.
Above all, I would like to thank the illustrious list of successive Telegraph business editors I've worked with since the late-1990s, many of whom have become and remain good friends - including @Peston @RobertsDan @larmitstead @neilbenet @benjaminmarlow @cg_williams @kamalahmednews @MarkKleinmanSky @jamesrquinn (sorry if I've forgotten anyone, it's been a long time!)
On Friday, even though I almost always write my column from elsewhere, and despite being extremely disappointed by the paper's decision, I decided to go into the Telegraph and write today's column sitting in the newsroom.
I am glad I did - as being at the heart of the paper at such a difficult time allowed for lots of conversations, with everyone from junior production staff to senior reporters and executives, which reminded me that journalism, despite being an industry at the whim of seemingly endless and often brutal commercial and technological upheaval, is not only hugely important to our country, but full of talented, decent people.
See picture below, having just filed my piece, as I was heading out the door ... -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
agreed
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
We'll see how they evolve. The gains seem to vary across types of tasks, but they might get there eventually.
Another thing is that, if they get much better, we'll undoubtedly spend some of the gains on just doing much more complicated work. Relatedly, struggling with results and ideas is an inescapable part of understanding papers. If part of our value is taking responsibility for the analysis and/or sharing it, you have a bottleneck right there that AI just cannot solve no matter how fast it goes. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ. But they are getting orders of magnitude better every three months
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
To clarify, even if you give LLM agents a research question, a methodology section, a pile of relevant references, all your codes and data, and all your current results, and ask it to produce a first draft, it is going to be garbage.
Some of my coauthors and I tried it. On one occasion, we even got Anthropic and OpenAI models to referee and propose updated drafts to each other until they couldn't find any objections left. And the output was hot garbage -- in spite of how much we gave them to work with.
I scrapped almost everything because it was clear that it was much faster to just write myself from scratch than to try to edit that mess.
For one project, we also have a large DFM. It has over 500 variables, about 270 of which are for Canada. Searching through that is hard, so we hoped LLMs would help. It was a huge waste of time. Top of the line coding agents are not as good as an average economics PhD at spotting relevant patterns. We literally asked it to output a huge CSV file and did the selection manually.
So, even if the question is along the lines of tell me what would be interesting to an economist -- and you dump a pile of papers to give it examples -- the best models suck at it.
These models are excellent on narrowly defined tasks. They are great RAs. But that's it. I don't know how well they'll improve for more demanding tasks. Maybe they'll be great one day. Or maybe that's not happening.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with this 100%. I would add however, that using AI in research is dangerous if you let it take over the project for you instead of using it as a research assistant. At every stage it will make plausible sounding suggestions and, if you accept them without pushing back, you will end up with a derivative project that looks like a mediocre paper from a knowledgeable graduate student.
One caveat: this is written as of October 2026. Given the advances we are seeing in real time the outlook in a few months -- or even in a few weeks -- may be very different. @PeterBoettke
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
Academic note: I have tried to be serious as a scholar, teacher and colleague since 1980s. In doing so I have constantly searched for productivity hacks â things that enable me to be more effective at being serious. Little things, like finding the right time of day to do research and to do teaching, or seeking ways to absorb needed knowledge like lectures at Great Courses or New York Review of Books or TLS. I moved from Word Perfect to Word, I have tried Palm Pilot, Blackberry, iPhone, I had a luggable portable computer that I traded in for laptop, and I used computer programs to take notes but switched back to notebooks and pen, and now use Kindle Scribe rather than ReMarkable. I try, I experiment, I assess. I read books in physical form, electronic form and audio. I watch YouTube and listen to podcasts all to help with lectures and papers. I used to search physically in libraries now I search online. My point is simple â I have always looked for ways to augment my skills and improve productivity. AI and LLMs are NO different in my experience. They donât think for me, but they help speed up search and information gathering. I still have to exercise judgment, absorb what I need, and execute in a lecture, in writing, or in meetings with students and colleagues. The best productivity hack in my career is face to face dialogue with PhD students about ideas. These conversations are infinitely more interesting to me than me prompting Chat or Claude about material. Even working with a student on a difficult problem or struggling to understand concepts is more intellectually rewarding. Maybe I am doing it wrong, or maybe everyone else is describing their experience wrong. Modern AI is not the Palm Pilot, nor early versions of Netscape Browser (BTW, Browzine is a good hack for journal article access). But its not like having Kenneth Boulding, James Buchanan or Gordon Tullock as a teacher either! Its not like having been mentored by Don Lavoie and Karen Vaughn, or first inspired by Hans Sennholz, or arguing about economics 24/7 with Dave Prychitko and Steve Horwitz, let alone working closely with Israel Kirzner and Mario Rizzo for almost a decade, or teaching and learning from scores of PhD advisees at GMU. It just isnât. Donât buy the false narrative. It is not a substitute, it is a tool. You need to learn how to use the tool effectively to increase YOUR productivity as a scholar, teacher, and colleague. So invest in it, but at the end of the day you will have to be the one who uses the tool effectively or poorly. YOU, not the machine make the final judgement call.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with this 100%. I would add however, that using AI in research is dangerous if you let it take over the project for you instead of using it as a research assistant. At every stage it will make plausible sounding suggestions and, if you accept them without pushing back, you will end up with a derivative project that looks like a mediocre paper from a knowledgeable graduate student.
One caveat: this is written as of October 2026. Given the advances we are seeing in real time the outlook in a few months -- or even in a few weeks -- may be very different. @PeterBoettke
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
Academic note: I have tried to be serious as a scholar, teacher and colleague since 1980s. In doing so I have constantly searched for productivity hacks â things that enable me to be more effective at being serious. Little things, like finding the right time of day to do research and to do teaching, or seeking ways to absorb needed knowledge like lectures at Great Courses or New York Review of Books or TLS. I moved from Word Perfect to Word, I have tried Palm Pilot, Blackberry, iPhone, I had a luggable portable computer that I traded in for laptop, and I used computer programs to take notes but switched back to notebooks and pen, and now use Kindle Scribe rather than ReMarkable. I try, I experiment, I assess. I read books in physical form, electronic form and audio. I watch YouTube and listen to podcasts all to help with lectures and papers. I used to search physically in libraries now I search online. My point is simple â I have always looked for ways to augment my skills and improve productivity. AI and LLMs are NO different in my experience. They donât think for me, but they help speed up search and information gathering. I still have to exercise judgment, absorb what I need, and execute in a lecture, in writing, or in meetings with students and colleagues. The best productivity hack in my career is face to face dialogue with PhD students about ideas. These conversations are infinitely more interesting to me than me prompting Chat or Claude about material. Even working with a student on a difficult problem or struggling to understand concepts is more intellectually rewarding. Maybe I am doing it wrong, or maybe everyone else is describing their experience wrong. Modern AI is not the Palm Pilot, nor early versions of Netscape Browser (BTW, Browzine is a good hack for journal article access). But its not like having Kenneth Boulding, James Buchanan or Gordon Tullock as a teacher either! Its not like having been mentored by Don Lavoie and Karen Vaughn, or first inspired by Hans Sennholz, or arguing about economics 24/7 with Dave Prychitko and Steve Horwitz, let alone working closely with Israel Kirzner and Mario Rizzo for almost a decade, or teaching and learning from scores of PhD advisees at GMU. It just isnât. Donât buy the false narrative. It is not a substitute, it is a tool. You need to learn how to use the tool effectively to increase YOUR productivity as a scholar, teacher, and colleague. So invest in it, but at the end of the day you will have to be the one who uses the tool effectively or poorly. YOU, not the machine make the final judgement call.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Moderates Rule
@ModeratesR
I too really want to understand what this person thinks the âno uncertaintyâ problem is. Maybe he should talk to Radner and his equilibriumâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks @FanTastischenDa
Fan Mounier
@FanTastischenDa
Self fulfilling prophecies is a great book!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Clifford Asness
@CliffordAsness
Error-prone French socialists shouldnât decide American policy, especially when the errors are very far from random. For that matter they shouldnât decide French policy, but that is their problem.
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/10/errors-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Michele Boldrin
@micheleboldrin
That's interesting.
Would you explain this to me?
Which theorem is wrong?
Which two (or more) assumptions of GE theory contradict each other? This has to be the case, according to you. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There was ⊠it evaporated in the face of the Lucasian onslaught. Lucas really was a very persuasive writer. I strongly recommend âUnderstanding Business Cyclesâ which is linked here
scispace.com/pdf/understanding-business-cycles-45y3f506i3âŠ
T
@notamagosh
If I'm not mistaken there was a disequilibrium school, or post walrasian school, that attempted to unify keynes with general equilibrium. I guess Malinvaud and Benassy where in that tradition.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well no @RecoEco it is not incoherent. And this critique displays a surprising lack of understanding of the ways that GE theory has informed developments in macroeconomics, beginning with Hicks in Value and Capital. Here is a free link archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.223876
After reading a draft of the General Theory Hicks renounced his masterpiece (big mistake IMO) but went on to use ideas from that book to help formulate the IS/LM model which Keynes was aware of and although he was not an enthusiastic supporter he at least did not explicitly disavow it. Here is Keynes on IS/LM
âI found it very interesting and really have next to nothing to say by way of criticism.â
[From a private letter of 31 March 1937 to Hicks on reading his article. Published in Collected Writings, Vol. XIV, pp. 79â81]
Hicks introduced âTemporary Equilibrium Theoryâ which is the idea that trades occur each Saturday in markets and that at the Saturday market, prices are chosen to equate demand and supply in every market, including the labor market, subject to beliefs about the prices that will occur in the future.
What Keynes introduced, and Hicks appeared to endorse, was that the Saturday market might NOT result in a situation where the money wage adjusts to equate the supply and demand for labor.
In a later development Don Patinkin, in Money Interest and Prices,
archive.org/details/MoneyInter_00_Pati
attempted to reconcile IS/LM with both temporary equilibrium theory and the Quantity Theory of Money.
At this point the debate shifted. Everyone agreed that âinvoluntary unemploymentâ might exist in a given week: the question became: Are there market forces that will rapidly cause a market economy to return to full employment (suitably defined).
Friedman argued yes. The N. American Keynesianâs in Cambridge Mass. initially argued no. Patinkin put the argument to rest in Money Interest and Prices and the N. American Keynesians capitulated. The Cambridge England Keynesians disagreed and developed their own school of Post Keynesian economics but they never, IMO, effectively explained the market failure behind their position.
For those interested in deeper exploration of these issues, see my book on The Macroeconomics of Self-Fulfilling Prophecies.
www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-Self-fulfilling-Prophecies-âŠ
If you are a student of macroeconomics and you have not read Value and Capital, the General Theory and Money Interest and Prices, you could profitably spend a week or two learning the ideas of your predecessors. And I humbly recommend my own book to tie the pieces together.
Warwick Smith
@RecoEco
General equilibrium theory is incoherent. It has no coherent time, no money and no uncertainty. All trades happen at once, at prices nobody sets, in a world where the future is already priced. It's ludicrous. Anything you use that lens for is going to look incoherent.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
By demonstrating that the unemployment rate has no tendency to return any ânatural rateâ static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If you mean that science and religion are incompatible I disagree -- although it is true that medieval interpretations of Genesis are inconsistent with modern science. The creation story on the other hand -- was rejected for a century or more until the idea of a beginning to creation received validation from science itself.
As for Keynes' GT, it is undeniable, IMO, that there are ideas in the GT that that are both different from modern macroeconomics and simultaneously worth preserving. The most important of those is the idea -- as I would frame it -- that free market economies have no inherent tendency to return to a socially optimal Pareto efficient allocation of labor between work and leisure. In Keynes' currently unfashionable language, involuntary unemployment can persist as a steady state equilibrium.
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
The Bible is incoherent when viewed through the lens of modern science is another way of saying that modern science is incoherent ⊠Galileo (and Brecht with him) is alone and sad in the garbage can of history and the sunâs busy running around the earth.
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Keynesâ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory" is another way of saying that General Equilibrium theory is incoherent.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynesâ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory ⊠it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why donât firms offer lower wages and why donât unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts ⊠accepted Friedmanâs argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels ⊠they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I would say incomplete rather than incoherent
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
"Keynesâ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory" is another way of saying that General Equilibrium theory is incoherent.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynesâ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory ⊠it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why donât firms offer lower wages and why donât unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts ⊠accepted Friedmanâs argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels ⊠they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree. But Keynesâ GT is intellectually incoherent when viewed through the lens of General Equilibrium theory ⊠it has no intelligible answer to the question: When faced with persistent unemployment why donât firms offer lower wages and why donât unemployed workers accept those offers?
When the N. American Keynesians ... based in Cambridge Massachusetts ⊠accepted Friedmanâs argument that high unemployment is caused by a temporary deviation of wages and prices from their equilibrium levels ⊠they gave up the Keynesian Baby with the Monetarist Bathwater.
The Cambridge England Keynesians resisted but they did not have a coherent explanation for the persistence of long-term unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon that could answer the questions of the General Equilibrium theorists.
My entire body of work has been devoted to providing an answer to the question: How can high unemployment persist? that reconciles General Equilibrium Theory with the Keynesian proposition that Walrasian Equilibrium is one of many potential resting points of a dynamical system. The answer is what I call Keynesian Search Theory. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
XM
@XmEconomics
Correct. The Phillips curve is not a structural equation but a reduced form of a poorly specified labor market model. Hicks-Hansen IS/LM with all its limitations (it isn't the richness of Keynes' GT) was/is a phenomenally powerful tool packaged in simple aggregates.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
1) Yes @DeivonDrago static AS/AD Ă la Mankiw is a pedagogical tool
2) Yes graduate classes shift to dynamic models ⊠but the static and dynamic NK models are equally flawed
3) The mistake is that the NK part of HANK imposes the natural rate hypothesis which is demonstrably false as I argued here static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Deivon Drago
@DeivonDrago
1) isnât static AS/AD just mainly a pedagogical tool?
2) in any adv undergrad or grad class weâd be seeing a dynamic version or a simplified DSGE?
3) in actual work doesnât something like HANK or HANK-SAM gets close to what you are talking about? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John L Davidson
@HHIDavidson
.@dandolfa why does Economics have such a difficult problem with the reality it is peoples' beliefs that determine the future? @farmerrf @manavnair29
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes @bachmanrudi why?
The IS/LM model was grounded in observations and gave plausible explanations of those observations. The textbook AS/AD extension as per Mankiwâs textbook was a mistake. @gprimice
Here are some thoughts on what AS/AD means
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Giorgio Primiceri
@gprimice
Why???
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I spent a year at the Bank of England as a Senior Houblon Norman Fellow during the transition from Mervyn King to Mark Carney. Research economists briefed the Monetary Policy Committee ahead of their meetings but the information they presented could easily have been assembled by an AI. @cmatthes_econ @t_holden
A second important input was the reports of the Bankâs regional agents who presented anecdotal evidence. For example, an agent might report back on his/her conversations with business representatives in Sheffield. That information would be harder to replicate by AI.
A third important input, was from a few trusted individuals on staff who had the ear of the Governor. Monetary policy was run by discretion â not in any sense by ârulesâ.
Prior to my Bank of England experience I spent several summers visiting the Econometrics group at the ECB. I naively believed, on arrival, that the econometricians would examine the data and convey a set of âfactsâ to the research economists. The research economists would analyze the facts and convey to the policy makers the best strategy that could be offered by economic theory.
In practice, that process runs in reverse. The policy makers decide what they want to do and they convey their opinions to the research department. The research economists go to the econometricians and say: make it so. In other words, the forecasts were reverse engineered to justify the policy actions.
This is in no way a criticism of monetary policy in practice. It is a recognition that policies adapt to circumstances in ways that are not easily captured by mechanical rules.
Tom Holden
@t_holden
Yes, the distinction essentially doesn't exist in the US. That model is much more sensible, and is much more readily adaptable to the changes that are coming.
My view is that humanity's advantage at doing econ research (not necessarily at selling it) has at most a year or two left. So what is important is to have people who can intermediate between AI and policy makers. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There are other reasons to worry about unit roots static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
And to understand cointegration
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
Well stop caring about unit roots, the trend stationary versus unit root debate is old and unresolvable atp.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This đ
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Will never exist? Gabriel, I think it is reasonable to assume that billionaires fear the taxâll become annual and that the left hopes that will be the case. I think rational expectations are surviving well here.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congrats and I wish you every success in your new position @Birdyword
Mike Bird
@Birdyword
Some big personal news: I'm moving to join Works in Progress as executive editor, starting next month. I have been hoping for an opportunity to work with @bswud and @s8mb for more than a decade, and I'm incredibly excited to finally have one.
WIP is expanding on every front right now. We'll soon begin coverage of business and finance, as well as putting out more reported features. To that end, we'll be hiring more writers and reporters in the year to come. I'm planning to remain based in the US to help build out our presence here.
The print edition of WIP has existed for less than 12 months, but sometime in the next week or so we will reach our 10,000th paying print subscriber. It's a group that now includes people who've been at the highest echelons of government and who run the world's biggest public companies. Weâre already on track to 3x that number next year. We'll be in store at Barnes & Noble, Hudson News and independent newsagents next week too.
I think WIP is providing something that people are craving from physical media right now: fewer, extremely well-crafted pieces in a beautifully designed form. Issues now feature an amazing group of columnists, including Tyler Cowen, Dan Wang and Stephen Kotkin. Each edition is better than the last.
You'll see us in more and more places next year too. In January, our new weekly documentary films will launch on YouTube. We're expanding into the events space, with a new series in North America. The sky is the limit from here on out. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the belief function has the same methodological status as a production function or a utility function. Once one specifies a stationary probability distribution over shocks to beliefs the model becomes refutable and can be compared with the NK alternative.
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
Arenât beliefs just a residual here? Then any piece of data can be rationalized.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Beliefs are modeled as primitives that act as an equilibrium selection device. I call this a belief function.
Prices are competitively determined in every period. Here is a link to an early representation of that idea
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
My equivalence conjecture is that dynamic indeterminacy is endemic to HA models once one moves beyond the simplest sessions of these models. A fruitful route to explore is the combination of incomplete markets with borrowing constraints with a perpetual youth environment.
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
What microfounds price adjustment? Also, OLG-HA equivalence is somewhat known already iirc, but no one has examined it in continuous time.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻYep. Been there, done that.
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Another one tries. And another one replies. And he will be ignored. What will come from MMT is something like "but he didnt read right" or "he didnt read the right paper". All the time, its goalpost shifting.
I shared tons of papers that people wrote on problematic parts of the theory and all I got was that: goalpost shifting. The MMT crowd is infuriating this way and its why people disengage (which led them to say -- we're being ignored). That Jon spent time engaging shows insane generosity given the pattern shown to other non-MMT scholars before.
Jon is going to get that goalpost shifting in 5, 4, 3, 2, 1 ... and 0. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm pretty sure the Fed now puts out consistent stock-flow accounts â but itâs been a while since I checked
Fred Gauss đșđŠ
@FrankGalton
In defense of this concept (not its use in this case), stock-flow consistency in data is a major issue. Just try getting to balance sheets from any of the flows in national accounts or financial sector statistics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have work in progress with heterogeneous agents but I wouldnât call it NK because the hallmark of NK models is, IMO, either Calvo or Rotemberg price stickiness. Everything I have worked on replaces artificial restrictions on price adjustment with an indeterminate monetary steady state in which slow price adjustment occurs endogenously. This is a link to the most recent iteration but there will be an updated version soon
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The basic insight is that there is an isomorphism between OLG models and HA models and that the multiplicities that characterize OLG models are also ubiquitous in HA models.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Do you have some of your work extended to HANK or TANK-like settings?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ahhh!! I never understood what that was all about. Every Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model is stock-flow consistent by construction. One can argue about the equilibrium concept, but material balance conditions hold in every period.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Stock flow consistent
I know, it doesn't say much, but that's the name they use. đ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
thatâs not an enlightening response @oktayozdn
Oktay Ăzden
@oktayozdn
You wrote a post keynesian macro model without no idea on sfc models? Lol
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
SFC?
Oktay Ăzden
@oktayozdn
There are a lot of SFC models.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If you mean this paper static1.squarespace.com/static/57844f0d6a4963df86dbda1a/tâŠ
I remain unconvinced
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
Read Bianchi and Bigio 2022. Solves the problem.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đwill read âŠ
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Here are a coupe links. FWIW, I donât think the systrm makes P any more indeterminate than the prior system. Either way it becomes indeterminate if the policy rate settings are too low. www.cato.org/cato-journal/spring/summer-2019/feds-operatiâŠ; www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/implementâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I recommend Post-Keynesian Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Theory đ
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Maisel's Weisse Lover
@maisels
ăăăăăăčăă±ă€ăłăžăąăłăçé ă«ăŠăăăă©ăŒăæčć€ăăŠăăă©ăăăčăă±ă€ăłăžăąăłă§äœăăăă«ä»ŁăăăăăȘæ±çšăąăă«ăæăĄç«ăŠăăăšăćșæ„ăăźă§ïŒäœă«ăăȘăă§ăăïŒăăă ăïŒ
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs a question for the philosophy of science. My friend Axel Leijonhufvud had a metaphor of science as a tree with many branches. Each branch represents an alternative possible path along which the subject might progress.
In the experimental sciences, false approaches are quickly discovered by experiment and those branches are trimmed. Progress appears linear.
In non experimental sciences the discipline can adopt approaches that are ultimately shown to be false but which persist for long periods of time. Ultimately it takes a large natural experiment like the Great Depression or the Stagflation of the 1970s to cause a course correction.
In the period between natural experiments, when multiple theories appear equally viable, the science is governed by gatekeepers who edit top journals and are educated at a small group of elite institutions. These gatekeepers provide a filter on acceptable discourse. This institutional structure has its benefits since, if it is difficult to empirically distinguish alternative theories, it would be highly disruptive if every fresh graduate student were to branch out in an entirely new direction. But the filtering out of new ideas can also cause the exiting corpus of thought to become sclerotic.
Influential schools of thought, like NK economics, are practiced by generations of students who acquire human capital and have an incentive not to rock the boat. Prestigious awards like the Nobel Prize and the John Bates Clarke Award provide incentives to color within the lines and these incentives are strongest when widely recognized deserving recipients have not yet been recognized. Elite universities maintain active offices whose goal is to lobby the Nobel committee on behalf of their own professoriate.
I have never met a brilliant young academic who did not aspire to be recognized as a Nobel Laureate: Through that mechanism prestigious awards offer important incentives to scientific excellence. But the prizes themselves also act as brakes on progress since a major course correction in the direction of the discipline would depreciate, overnight, the accumulated capital of generations of scholars.
In the words of Max Planck: âProgress occurs one funeral at a time.â
For further reading on these ideas I recommend Lakatosâ essay in in âCriticism and the Growth of Knowledgeâ www.cambridge.org/core/books/criticism-and-the-growth-of-âŠ
mikael thesleff
@MThesleff
I know you have your own theory and have read your book. Why do you think your model has not gained wider acceptance in mainstream economics ?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
How does monetary policy work under a floor system George? ⊠is there an accessible short piece on your thoughts on this @georgeselgin Because Iâm not convinced that the price level is determinate under a floor system ⊠and Iâm not a believer in the FTPL, at least in its forward looking rational expectations incarnation
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Apparently, some are! And thatâs a good reason for writing them off as not having a clue how monetary policy works under the Fedâs floor system.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Perhaps. But the research economists at central banks are part of the graduating classes from the same institutions as freshly minted assistant professors. And in recent decades, the policy committees at the Fed, the Bank of England and the ECB have been dominated by academics.
José Moran
@drmtgr
This is a bit bleak though. It seems to me central banks, who are concerned with very practical questions, can be more open minded towards new tools, rathet than being concerned with academic prestige only
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
mikael thesleff
@MThesleff
I did philosophy of science at uni and am familiar with Lakatos, Kuhn etc. Your explanation is of course a possible one. Thanks for the long answer ! To me, your model seems quite plausible, which is why I was wondering why it hasnât gained a larger foothold in the mainstream
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Neutrality is a property of every well specified model â- super neutrality (neutrality of changes in the money growth rate) is not. But even in a model where money is neutral, monetary shocks can have permanent effects by nudging the system from one steady state to another. Here is a paper that explores that idea
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs a question for the philosophy of science. My friend Axel Leijonhufvud had a metaphor of science as a tree with many branches. Each branch represents an alternative possible path along which the subject might progress.
In the experimental sciences, false approaches are quickly discovered by experiment and those branches are trimmed. Progress appears linear.
In non experimental sciences the discipline can adopt approaches that are ultimately shown to be false but which persist for long periods of time. Ultimately it takes a large natural experiment like the Great Depression or the Stagflation of the 1970s to cause a course correction.
In the period between natural experiments, when multiple theories appear equally viable, the science is governed by gatekeepers who edit top journals and are educated at a small group of elite institutions. These gatekeepers provide a filter on acceptable discourse. This institutional structure has its benefits since, if it is difficult to empirically distinguish alternative theories, it would be highly disruptive if every fresh graduate student were to branch out in an entirely new direction. But the filtering out of new ideas can also cause the exiting corpus of thought to become sclerotic.
Influential schools of thought, like NK economics, are practiced by generations of students who acquire human capital and have an incentive not to rock the boat. Prestigious awards like the Nobel Prize and the John Bates Clarke Award provide incentives to color within the lines and these incentives are strongest when widely recognized deserving recipients have not yet been recognized. Elite universities maintain active offices whose goal is to lobby the Nobel committee on behalf of their own professoriate.
I have never met a brilliant young academic who did not aspire to be recognized as a Nobel Laureate: Through that mechanism prestigious awards offer important incentives to scientific excellence. But the prizes themselves also act as brakes on progress since a major course correction in the direction of the discipline would depreciate, overnight, the accumulated capital of generations of scholars.
In the words of Max Planck: âProgress occurs one funeral at a time.â
For further reading on these ideas I recommend Lakatosâ essay in in âCriticism and the Growth of Knowledgeâ www.cambridge.org/core/books/criticism-and-the-growth-of-âŠ
mikael thesleff
@MThesleff
I know you have your own theory and have read your book. Why do you think your model has not gained wider acceptance in mainstream economics ?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@HicksCBER You ask what should replace the NK model. Here are three propositions that are missing from NK monetary theory
A recognition that
1] Beliefs matter and independently influence outcomes
2] There is no tendency for markets to converge to a ânatural unemployment rateâ
3] Prices are not âstickyâ because the Calvo Fairy taps price setters on the shoulder and allows them to reset prices: they are slow to adjust because dynamic equilibria are indeterminate
Here is a simple empirical application of those principles
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Here is a [technical] exposition of the research agenda implied by them
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Michael J. Hicks
@HicksCBER
What do you propose should replace NKMT?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻđ
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Jean-Luc's call for papers: special consideration will be given to submissions from economists who don't understand economics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I wrote this in 2025. Now that the Nobel Committee has recognized Mike Woodford and Bob Hall (a tiny subset of the NK machine) perhaps we can move on.
This is not to disparage Mike and Bob, both of whom are hugely deserving of a Nobel Prize ⊠I simply would not have awarded it to them for NK economics.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many âshocksâ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, âscience progresses one funeral at a timeâ. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Oh dear
Evonomics: The Next Evolution of Economics
@EvonomicsMag
Economist @MazzucatoM: "If bankers, estate agents and bookmakers claim to create value rather than extract it, mainstream economics offers no basis on which to challenge them, even though the public might view their claims with scepticism. Who can deny Lloyd Blankfein when he declares that Goldman Sachs employees are among the most productive in the world? Or when pharmaceutical companies argue that the exorbitantly high price of one of their drugs is due to the value it produces? Government officials can become convinced (or âcapturedâ) by stories about wealth creation, as was recently evidenced by the US governmentâs approval of a leukemia drug treatment at half a million dollars, precisely using the â value- based pricingâ model pitched by the industry â even when the taxpayer contributed $200 million dollars towards its discovery."
Read more: evonomics.com/value-of-everything-mariana-mazzucato/This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Brivael Le Pogam
@brivael
Bernie Sanders says the top 1% owns more than the bottom 93%, that fewer than a thousand billionaires got $2.2 trillion richer last year, and that it's "obscene."
It's the most seductive and most wrong economic argument of our time. Let me explain why.
First, wealth distribution follows a power law. Always. Everywhere. Books, music, startups, followers on X, goals in soccer. A small minority captures most of the value. That's not a bug of capitalism. It's the mathematical signature of every system where value gets created.
So the only question that matters isn't "how big is the rich's slice?" It's "is the cake growing, and is the slice of the poorest growing with it?"
And the answer is yes. In 1990, more than one human in three lived in extreme poverty. Today it's about one in ten. During exactly the period when billionaires multiplied.
Bernie shows you the slice. He never shows you the cake.
Second thing he won't tell you: past a certain level, wealth stops being consumption. It becomes capital allocation.
Elon Musk isn't sleeping on a pile of cash. He owns stakes in Tesla, SpaceX, xAI. Jeff Bezos owns Amazon stock. That "$2.2 trillion" isn't sitting in a checking account. It's factories, rockets, data centers, millions of jobs. Nobody can eat $100 billion. You can only decide where to invest it.
Once you understand that, the whole debate changes. The real question becomes: who allocates capital better?
The people who built Amazon, SpaceX and Nvidia? Or politicians?
A 5% wealth tax isn't "taking money from the rich." It's taking investment decisions away from people who proved they can create value and handing them to people who proved the opposite.
Because the fundamental difference between an entrepreneur and a politician is consequences.
The entrepreneur invests his own money. If he allocates badly, he loses everything. The market corrects him brutally, no appeal. That's why most startups die: the system kills bad decisions.
The politician invests other people's money. If he allocates badly, nothing happens. Worse, he gets a bigger budget to "fix the problem."
Milton Friedman put it better than anyone. There are four ways to spend money. Your money on yourself: you care about price and quality. Your money on others: you care about price. Others' money on yourself: you care about quality. Others' money on others: you care about nothing.
Government is the fourth box. By design.
Perfect example: California high-speed rail. Approved in 2008 for about $33 billion. Current estimated cost: over $100 billion. Passengers carried: zero. No entrepreneur would have survived that. The politicians who pushed it built careers on it.
And when allocation has no consequences, it eventually finds a buyer. A politician who controls billions without accountability becomes the most profitable target in the world for anyone who wants to steer that money.
The irony is that the left that rails against billionaires is itself funded by billionaires. George Soros is one of the biggest Democratic donors in history. The Gates Foundation shapes public health policy across the planet.
Politicians don't fight billionaires. They pick their own. The ones who fund the state over the ones who compete with it.
So if we actually want fewer poor people, we have to stop judging ideas by their intentions and start judging them by their results. And the results are brutally clear.
China, 1978: Deng Xiaoping opens the economy to markets. More than 800 million people escape extreme poverty. The largest retreat of misery in human history. Not through redistribution. Through the freedom to build.
India, 1991: liberalization. Same movie.
South Korea and North Korea: same people, same language, same starting point in 1953. One became one of the most advanced economies on earth. The other has famines.
Poland and Ukraine: comparable living standards in 1990. Today the average Pole is more than three times richer than the average Ukrainian.
Argentina: a year and a half of liberalization, and the poverty rate falls from over 50% to around 30%.
No country in history escaped poverty by punishing the people who build. Every single one did it by letting them build.
And if you want to see what Bernie's program looks like in real life, you don't have to imagine it. It exists. It's called France. We've been running it for 45 years.
Mass nationalizations in 1981. Two years later, Socialist president Mitterrand has to reverse course into austerity.
Retirement at 60. The 35-hour workweek.
A wealth tax for 35 years. Hundreds of wealthy households left every year for Belgium, Switzerland, London, taking their capital, their companies and their future taxes with them. Macron finally scrapped it in 2018.
Hollande's 75% tax: raised a few hundred million, drove talent out, abandoned after two years.
One of the highest tax burdens in the OECD. Public spending around 57% of GDP, a record in the developed world.
Last balanced budget: 1974. Public debt: over âŹ3.4 trillion. Mass unemployment for four decades.
If taxing the rich and growing the state made people prosperous, France would be the richest country on the planet.
It isn't. GDP per capita in France is barely more than half of America's. It's lower than Mississippi, the poorest state in the US. Not a single global tech giant. Our best engineers build Silicon Valley instead. I've been going back and forth between Paris and San Francisco for years. I see it every week.
And California is about to replay the movie. Prop 40, on the ballot November 3rd, would take 5% of billionaires' net worth. Even Gavin Newsom, a Democratic governor, opposes it. The state's own nonpartisan budget analyst warns that income tax revenue could drop every year if the wealthy leave. Larry Page, Sergey Brin and Peter Thiel have reportedly already started moving their assets out.
You don't fight poverty by shrinking the top. You fight it by growing the cake.
Bernie wants a society where nobody has too much. I want a society where nobody has too little.
The first has been tried everywhere and produces equality in stagnation. The second lifted a billion people out of misery.
Choose.
Bernie Sanders
@BernieSanders
The top 1% owns more wealth than the bottom 93%.
1 man owns more wealth than the bottom 53% of households.
Less than a thousand billionaires got $2.2 trillion richer in the last year.
Obscene.
Yes. We need a 5% billionaire wealth tax in California and throughout America. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
true ⊠but it could not happen without a physical location to promote the creation of networks
joseph francis
@joefrancis505
Well, that's quite a different function than just weaning kids off their parents!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
To be more specific: universities exist to socialize elites who go on to positions of power in all branches of society. The elites reproduce the culture. @joefrancis505
Classes in Western Civilization do not [did not] exist to educate students: they existed to reproduce the culture. Now that those classes have been replaced in many institutions of higher learning by Postmodernism â what Sokol and Bricmont call fashionable nonsense â en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fashionable_Nonsense itâs not just the students who are poorer from ignorance of their cultural heritage â itâs the culture itself which is no longer being effectively replicated.
Elitist culture is transmitted to other parts of society as the students of Education Schools, Journalism Schools and Film schools become teachers, journalists and Hollywood directors. And with the loss of the Western Cannon comes the slow depreciation of the norms and values that have maintained the social structure of western societies for a millennium or more.
Those who promote the changes that have occurred in western education will see social progress. Those who oppose it will see decadence and decay. In 1882 Nietzsche pronounced that God is dead. But although the vestiges of our shared values still breathe with Judeo-Christian moral values, we are living on fumes.
joseph francis
@joefrancis505
Is the universities' central function to socialize young adults? Really? Does that mean that all the people who don't go to university don't get socialized?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is profoundly mistaken. A central, perhaps *the* central function served by universities is to socialize young adults. To learn to function away from their parents: To meet other young people and to grow together in a shared environment. In my experience, more is learned in the coffee bar before class and the student pub after class than from lectures and seminars.@VC31415
Kyronis
@kyronis_talks
Researchers proved AI has deleted every reason universities exist.
Harvard University ran a controlled experiment pitting a custom AI against their own top-tier classrooms.
And the results are going to collapse the higher education bubble.
They took 194 undergraduates and split them up.
One group learned physics in one of Harvardâs best hands-on, active-learning physical classrooms. Group work. Instructor support. The premium university experience.
The other group went home and learned the exact same material with an AI tutor.
The AI didn't just win. It embarrassed the institution.
Students using the AI learned more than twice as much as the students in the elite Harvard classroom.
They scored 30% higher on the final assessment.
And they did it in less time.
Let that sink in.
A piece of software sitting on a laptop outperformed a world-class faculty in one of the most elite learning environments on Earth.
Universities have always justified their exorbitant tuition with two things: access to elite knowledge and the physical classroom experience.
This study just proved both of those moats are gone.
When software can teach you complex physics twice as well as a $60,000-a-year institution, the math of higher education breaks permanently.
The AI didn't just give the students answers. It used strict pedagogical guardrails. It guided. It questioned. It forced the students to do the cognitive work.
It offered perfect, one-to-one tutoring, personalized to the exact moment a student misunderstood a concept.
That level of attention is mathematically impossible to scale in a physical lecture hall.
For a thousand years, the university was the only place to get a premium education.
Now, itâs the bottleneck.
If AI can double your learning speed for a fraction of the cost, what exactly are students taking on decades of debt to pay for? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Deirdre Nansen McCloskey
@DeirdreMcClosk
Inequality Is Not the Problem.
Much of the research on the economics of inequality stumbles on this simple ethical point, focusing on measures of relative inequality such as the Gini coefficient rather than on measures of the absolute welfare of the poor, on inequality rather than poverty, having elided the two.
Speaking of the legal philosopher Ronald Dworkinâs egalitarianism, Frankfurt observed that Dworkin in fact, and ethically, âcares principally about the [absolute] value of peopleâs lives, but he mistakenly represents himself as caring principally about the relative magnitudes of their economic assets.â
Dworkin and the left commonly miss the ethical point, which is the liberal, Joshua Monk one of lifting up the poor.
By redistribution? By equality in diamond bracelets? By codes for buildings or unions for trades?
No: by the dramatic increase in the size of the pie, which has historically brought the poor to 90 or 95 percent of âenough,â as against the small percent of enough attainable by redistribution without enlarging the pie. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
⊠and evidence from the UK suggests that 52% is already past the peak of the Laffer curve.
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/8/30/uk-evidenceâŠ
đŻđ
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
@gabriel_zucman claims the French government doesn't have a spending problem, but a revenue problem. That's a hard sell when total general government revenue is 52% of GDP. Only Norway, Denmark and Finland -among OECD countries- see the government take a larger share of GDP. (And the gap with Norway is just oil revenue. ) Unless France hits the jackpot and finds oil off the coast of Calais in the North Sea, it will be hard to beat Norway.
If you just look at tax revenue, excluding other revenue sources for the government, then France is near the top. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is profoundly mistaken. A central, perhaps *the* central function served by universities is to socialize young adults. To learn to function away from their parents: To meet other young people and to grow together in a shared environment. In my experience, more is learned in the coffee bar before class and the student pub after class than from lectures and seminars.@VC31415
Kyronis
@kyronis_talks
Researchers proved AI has deleted every reason universities exist.
Harvard University ran a controlled experiment pitting a custom AI against their own top-tier classrooms.
And the results are going to collapse the higher education bubble.
They took 194 undergraduates and split them up.
One group learned physics in one of Harvardâs best hands-on, active-learning physical classrooms. Group work. Instructor support. The premium university experience.
The other group went home and learned the exact same material with an AI tutor.
The AI didn't just win. It embarrassed the institution.
Students using the AI learned more than twice as much as the students in the elite Harvard classroom.
They scored 30% higher on the final assessment.
And they did it in less time.
Let that sink in.
A piece of software sitting on a laptop outperformed a world-class faculty in one of the most elite learning environments on Earth.
Universities have always justified their exorbitant tuition with two things: access to elite knowledge and the physical classroom experience.
This study just proved both of those moats are gone.
When software can teach you complex physics twice as well as a $60,000-a-year institution, the math of higher education breaks permanently.
The AI didn't just give the students answers. It used strict pedagogical guardrails. It guided. It questioned. It forced the students to do the cognitive work.
It offered perfect, one-to-one tutoring, personalized to the exact moment a student misunderstood a concept.
That level of attention is mathematically impossible to scale in a physical lecture hall.
For a thousand years, the university was the only place to get a premium education.
Now, itâs the bottleneck.
If AI can double your learning speed for a fraction of the cost, what exactly are students taking on decades of debt to pay for? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I'm rereading John Stuart Mill's essay 'On Liberty' [1859] I had forgotten that he made a persuasive argument for School Vouchers
"If the government would make up its mind to require for every child a good education, it might save itself the trouble of providing one. It might leave to parents to obtain the education where and how they pleased, and content itself with helping to pay the school fees of the poorer classes of children, and defraying the entire school expenses of those who have no one else to pay for them."
[The Elementary Education Act of 1870 created locally elected school boards to build and run âboard schoolsâ in areas where voluntary (mostly church-run) provision was inadequate. The Education Act of 1876 made it a duty for every parent to provide an education for their children]
Back to Mill:
"The objections which are urged with reason against State education, do not apply to the enforcement of education by the State, but to the Stateâs taking upon itself to direct that education: which is a totally different thing. That the whole or any large part of the education of the people should be in State hands, I go as far as any one in deprecating."
[That bit was ignored. The 1870 Act established a national framework for state provision of elementary education rather than as system of vouchers with competition between institutions to receive State funds.]
Mill again
"All that has been said of the importance of individuality of character, and diversity in opinions and modes of conduct, involves, as of the same unspeakable importance, diversity of education. A general State education is a mere contrivance for moulding people to be exactly like one another: and as the mould in which it casts them is that which pleases the predominant power in the government, whether this be a monarch, a priesthood, an aristocracy, or the majority of the existing generation, in proportion as it is efficient and successful, it establishes a despotism over the mind, leading by natural tendency to one over the body."
[Exactly!]
continuing with Mill ...
"An education established and controlled by the State should only exist, if it exist at all, as one among many competing experiments, carried on for the purpose of example and stimulus, to keep the others up to a certain standard of excellence."
These arguments seem, to me, to be 100% correct and a powerful case for private education funded by public vouchers. I do think, however, that there is a good argument for nationwide examinations to screen admission to further education and to allow parents to evaluate the quality of individual educational institutions -- although what should be in those examinations -- explicitly in history and civics classes -- would not be uncontentious.
As for the privileges afforded to teachers and university professors one can't go far wrong than quote Adam Smith from the Wealth of Nations
"... [teachers] are likely to make a common cause, to be all very indulgent to one another, and every man to consent that his neighbour may neglect his duty, provided he himself is allowed to neglect his own. In the university of Oxford, the greater part of the public professors have, for these many years, given up altogether even the pretense of teaching."
Plus ça change, plus câest la mĂȘme chose... -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Some of what passes for education in the western world is little more than dressed up political idiocy.
I agree with the minimal requirements and vouchers. Publicly financing and publicly supplying a service are two different things. Abolish the public system, send people checks, and let the private sector handle the problem. That way, we don't have to all agree on what is a good education.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The idea of public examinations may have been picked up by âanti-Mill Marxistsâ âŠ. But it IS in Mill who goes on to say in the same essay
âThe instrument for enforcing the law could be no other than public examinations, extending to all children, and beginning at an early age. An age might be fixed at which every child must be examined, to ascertain if he (or she) is able to read.â
And Mill felt education to be so important that it trumped parental rights
âIf a child proves unable, the father, unless he has some sufficient ground of excuse, might be subjected to a moderate fine, to be worked out, if necessary, by his labour, and the child might be put to school at his expense.â
As for more advanced topics Mill goes on to say
âTo prevent the State from exercising, âŠ. an improper influence over opinion, the knowledge required for passing an examination (beyond the merely instrumental parts of knowledge, such as languages and their use) should, even in the higher class of examinations, be confined to facts and positive science exclusively. The examinations on religion, politics, or other disputed topics, should not turn on the truth or falsehood of opinions, but on the matter of fact that such and such an opinion is held, on such grounds, by such authors, or schools, or churches.â
However, I do not think Mill would be happy with what is currently taught in schools both in America and the UK about our respective histories âŠ
âAll attempts by the state to bias the conclusions of its citizens on disputed subjects, are evil; but it may very properly offer to ascertain and certify that a person possesses the knowledge, requisite to make his conclusions, on any given subject, worth attending to. â
Richard LZ
@Richard69276699
All correct but for the last one. Mill should've killed it instantly. Once the state is allowed to compete, the cancer starts replicating and invading because it controls funding. And your idea of standardized examination for accountability is essentially an anti-Mill Marxist proposal
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Adam Tondowsky
@ATondowsky
School vouchers or charter schools.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The idea of public examinations may have been picked up by âanti-Mill Marxistsâ âŠ. But it IS in Mill who goes on to say in the same essay
âThe instrument for enforcing the law could be no other than public examinations, extending to all children, and beginning at an early age. An age might be fixed at which every child must be examined, to ascertain if he (or she) is able to read.â
And Mill felt education to be so important that it trumped parental rights
âIf a child proves unable, the father, unless he has some sufficient ground of excuse, might be subjected to a moderate fine, to be worked out, if necessary, by his labour, and the child might be put to school at his expense.â
As for more advanced topics Mill goes on to say
âTo prevent the State from exercising, âŠ. an improper influence over opinion, the knowledge required for passing an examination (beyond the merely instrumental parts of knowledge, such as languages and their use) should, even in the higher class of examinations, be confined to facts and positive science exclusively. The examinations on religion, politics, or other disputed topics, should not turn on the truth or falsehood of opinions, but on the matter of fact that such and such an opinion is held, on such grounds, by such authors, or schools, or churches.â
However, I do not think Mill would be happy with what is currently taught in schools both in America and the UK about our respective histories âŠ
âAll attempts by the state to bias the conclusions of its citizens on disputed subjects, are evil; but it may very properly offer to ascertain and certify that a person possesses the knowledge, requisite to make his conclusions, on any given subject, worth attending to. â
Richard LZ
@Richard69276699
All correct but for the last one. Mill should've killed it instantly. Once the state is allowed to compete, the cancer starts replicating and invading because it controls funding. And your idea of standardized examination for accountability is essentially an anti-Mill Marxist proposal
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I'm rereading John Stuart Mill's essay 'On Liberty' [1859] I had forgotten that he made a persuasive argument for School Vouchers
"If the government would make up its mind to require for every child a good education, it might save itself the trouble of providing one. It might leave to parents to obtain the education where and how they pleased, and content itself with helping to pay the school fees of the poorer classes of children, and defraying the entire school expenses of those who have no one else to pay for them."
[The Elementary Education Act of 1870 created locally elected school boards to build and run âboard schoolsâ in areas where voluntary (mostly church-run) provision was inadequate. The Education Act of 1876 made it a duty for every parent to provide an education for their children]
Back to Mill:
"The objections which are urged with reason against State education, do not apply to the enforcement of education by the State, but to the Stateâs taking upon itself to direct that education: which is a totally different thing. That the whole or any large part of the education of the people should be in State hands, I go as far as any one in deprecating."
[That bit was ignored. The 1870 Act established a national framework for state provision of elementary education rather than as system of vouchers with competition between institutions to receive State funds.]
Mill again
"All that has been said of the importance of individuality of character, and diversity in opinions and modes of conduct, involves, as of the same unspeakable importance, diversity of education. A general State education is a mere contrivance for moulding people to be exactly like one another: and as the mould in which it casts them is that which pleases the predominant power in the government, whether this be a monarch, a priesthood, an aristocracy, or the majority of the existing generation, in proportion as it is efficient and successful, it establishes a despotism over the mind, leading by natural tendency to one over the body."
[Exactly!]
continuing with Mill ...
"An education established and controlled by the State should only exist, if it exist at all, as one among many competing experiments, carried on for the purpose of example and stimulus, to keep the others up to a certain standard of excellence."
These arguments seem, to me, to be 100% correct and a powerful case for private education funded by public vouchers. I do think, however, that there is a good argument for nationwide examinations to screen admission to further education and to allow parents to evaluate the quality of individual educational institutions -- although what should be in those examinations -- explicitly in history and civics classes -- would not be uncontentious.
As for the privileges afforded to teachers and university professors one can't go far wrong than quote Adam Smith from the Wealth of Nations
"... [teachers] are likely to make a common cause, to be all very indulgent to one another, and every man to consent that his neighbour may neglect his duty, provided he himself is allowed to neglect his own. In the university of Oxford, the greater part of the public professors have, for these many years, given up altogether even the pretense of teaching."
Plus ça change, plus câest la mĂȘme chose... -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Rajiv Sethi
@rajivatbarnard
Some Recollections of Perry Mehrling
rajivsethi.substack.com/p/some-recollections-of-perry-meh⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
I was running about town yesterday and in meetings so I've only just found out now that the inimitable monetary legend that was Perry Mehrling passed away yesterday.
It's an absolute tragedy. He was an absolute hero. RIP
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
Perry Mehrling, RIP.
According to the History of Economics Society, Perry Mehrling died "Monday night from injury sustained in a fall several days earlier." He was Professor of International Political Economy at Boston University and, previously, longtime Professor of Economics at Barnard College. He was a highly esteemed historian of economics.
Here is his homepage:
sites.bu.edu/perry/
His last book: "Money and Empire: Charles P. Kindleberger and the Dollar System"
www.amazon.com/Money-Empire-Kindleberger-Economic-ThinkinâŠ
"Charles Kindleberger ranks as one of the twentieth century's best known and most influential international economists. This book traces the evolution of his thinking in the context of a 'key-currency' approach to the rise of the dollar system, here revealed as the indispensable framework for global economic development since World War II. Unlike most of his colleagues, Kindleberger was deeply interested in history, and his economics brimmed with real people and institutional details. His research at the New York Fed and BIS during the Great Depression, his wartime intelligence work, and his role in administering the Marshall Plan gave him deep insight into how the international financial system really operated. A biography of both the dollar and a man, this book is also the story of the development of ideas about how money works. It throws revealing light on the underlying economic forces and political obstacles shaping our globalized world."
Charles Goodhart: "The discipline of economics is balanced, somewhat unsteadily, between two legs, with the skill of the historian on one side and of the mathematical modeler on the other. In the second half of the 20th century, the tide flowed strongly to elevate the second leg and to diminish the first. In this delightful biography of Charlie Kindleberger, a charming and loveable man, Perry Mehrling shows how Charlie, in his chosen role, as an international monetary economist, fought against that tide, often unsuccessfully. Perry writes so beautifully that one would only need a smattering of economics to enjoy the tale; while if one is interested in the history of economic thought in international monetary economics, then this book is, of course, a must read.'
www.amazon.com/Money-Empire-Kindleberger-Economic-Thinkin⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Isnât that a great feeling!
Zoe Zhang
@QianxueZhang
The academic life: 360 days of questioning your intelligence, 5 days of feeling like a genius. Today is one of those five days. đ„č
(After weeks of being stuck, both projects finally made some progress.) -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The âassertionâ that @jtreble_deriv is making is taken from my post. You can check it for yourself by downloading the data. A good source is the Fred II database hosted by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta. @JohnDavies67
John Davies
@JohnDavies67
Who made up that disproven assertion?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
A propos of nothing.
I do empirical work for a living. You're not going to pull a fast one in front of me. The data never supports a clean narrative. Some results do not make any sense -- and that's possible because you're dealing with noise and limited information.
Narratives that are too clean are inherently fishy. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is not true @johndavies67 All Americans are much richer than they were in 1989 but inequality has also increased. Contrast this with the UK where incomes have stagnated. I, for one, would rather be absolutely rich in a world where some people are super rich than absolutely poor in a world where we are all equally living in poverty.
Here is Grokâs analysis of your graphic.
Official Federal Reserve Distributional Financial Accounts (the standard source for these breakdowns) show the bottom 50% of U.S. households held about $718 billion in net worth in Q3 1989, not $317.8 billion. By Q2 2026 that figure was about $4.28 trillion.
That is roughly a 6Ă nominal increase.
With cumulative inflation of about 2.6â2.7Ă from 1989 to the mid-2020s, real (inflation-adjusted) aggregate wealth for the bottom half rose by roughly 2.2â2.3Ă, not collapsing to 36.8% of the 1989 level. Their share of total household wealth did decline (from around 3.5% in 1989 to roughly 2â2.5% recently), because total wealth grew faster, driven largely by equities and other assets concentrated higher up.
The top 0.00001% (roughly the top ~19 households in recent data) have seen extreme gains. Analyses by Gabriel Zucman put their combined wealth around $2.6 trillion by end-2024 (about 1.8% of total household wealth), up sharply from far smaller shares and absolute levels in earlier decades. A figure near $4 trillion by 2026 is plausible given continued market gains, but the graphicâs exact 1989 starting point ($88 billion) and the derived 16.9Ă real multiple and 43.3Ă differential rest on the incorrect bottom-half numbers and are therefore unreliable.
Summary of the broader picture: Wealth inequality has risen substantially since 1989âtop shares (especially the top 0.1% and above) have increased while the bottom halfâs share has fallen. The ultra-wealthy have gained disproportionately. However, the claim that the bottom halfâs aggregate real wealth plummeted is false; it has risen. âThe poor get poorerâ overstates the aggregate data, though many lower-income households still have low absolute wealth, limited asset ownership (especially stocks), and can feel the effects of higher costs and slower relative gains.
The graphicâs precise figures and real-terms calculation do not match the official data.
John Davies
@JohnDavies67
In the US the rich get richer, the poor get poorer.
The rich get tax cuts, the poor get wealth cuts. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
May come as a bit of a surprise to those of us who were following Paul's writings in the 2010s when he was railing against Eurozone "austerity craziness".
With interest rates at the zero lower bound, he argued that fiscal consolidation in a depressed economy was self-defeating: multipliers were large, so cutting deficits deepened the slump and did little for debt ratios. France was one of his recurring examples. It turns out that French policymakers were listening to him. In every big recession, they massively increased spending. But the multipliers were not as big as advertised. Deficits didn't pay for themselves.
Government debt/GDP is a persistent state variable. Bond yields are not. If the only reason you're changing your mind is because yields are up, then your advice wasn't that good to begin with.
Op-eds and blog posts arguing against French austerity (list generated by Claude)
âFranc Thoughts on Long-Run Fiscal Issues,â blog post (Conscience of a Liberal), August 11, 2011. Argues there are limits to deficits but they are not relevant now.
âThose Revolting Europeans,â NYT column, May 2012. Welcomes Hollandeâs election as a rejection of austerity. (Title and date from memory; please verify before citing.)
âThe Plot Against France,â NYT column, November 11, 2013 (online November 10). Attacks the S&P downgrade; calls French fiscal prospects âdistinctly nonalarming.â
âFrance by the Numbers,â blog post, January 2014. Mocks French elite pessimism after Hollandeâs supply-side turn.
âScandal in France,â NYT column, January 17, 2014. Calls Hollandeâs embrace of austerity and supply-side doctrine scandalous.
âThe Fall of France,â NYT column, August 29, 2014 (print, p. A23). Says Hollande folded to austerity demands; France âisnât Greeceâ and not fragile.
Related: defenses of the French model, not explicitly about austerity
7. âWhatâs the Matter With Europe?â, NYT column, May 2017. Argues France is a fairly successful economy that gets bad press from welfare-state critics.
8. Twitter thread, November 5, 2019. Argues France gets bad press not borne out by the facts.
Bloomberg
@business
Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman warned that Franceâs deteriorating public finances are on an âunsustainble pathâ and at risk of unleashing a debt crisis across the euro area www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-09/krugman-says-fâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Gini for wealth is more extreme in the US: 0.77 for the US as opposed to 0.6 for China.
But if you are concerned with the impact of wealth on political belief â I donât see how China is relevant. Dissent is strictly controlled by the CCP.
Rakesh Bhandari
@postdiscipline
Is the Gini coefficient at all relevant to capturing the extreme inequality the billionaire tax is targeting? Does the kind of billionaire wealth at the very top we have seen emerge in the US have a counterpart in China?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
..@postdiscipline The argument that wealth buys political influence is one I wrote about here.
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/10/will-americanâŠ
I have since changed my mind.
At the time l was concerned with, what I thought, was a correlation between wealth and political persuasion. While that is surely present, there are billionaires on both ends of the political spectrum. On one side were the Koch brothers: on the other George Soros.
A second concern that was more salient at the time I wrote that piece was that wealth seemed necessary as a means to transmit ideas widely. The Marxist argument was that âfreedom of the press is freedom for those who own one.â That concern has been considerably ameliorated by the rise of the internet and specifically with Muskâs purchase of X which has minimal censorship of ideas.
That has led to new battles as state actors attempt to regain control of the instruments of State propaganda â my current guess (hope) is that they are fighting a losing battle.
At the end of the day I return to the position of a free speech absolutist â every student should read Millâs essay âOf Libertyâ â and I see no alternative if we hope to live in harmony with each other to a return to tolerance in which we are willing to listen to and debate ideas whether they come from billionaires or paupers.
Rakesh Bhandari
@postdiscipline
I grant that 1 quite possibly neutralizes *my* concern to which you do not speak directly. If billionaires flee the state and still use their wealth to corrupt our politics at the national level and/or the state level where their businesses may remain, then there would be no advantage to the billionaire tax. I was speaking in favor of taxing away wealth that is being used to buy politics. Musk, we may remember, bragged about buying the 2024 election for Trump. One could argue for the CA billionaire tax as proof of concept that a Democratic Congress could enact on a national scale in 2027.
While capitalism may well require gigantic prizes to incentivize innovation, as Janos Kornai argues in Dynamism, Rivalry and the Surplus Economy, there is no evidence that it requires rewards as gigantic as enjoyed today. Indeed private rewards this outsized make a talented person wanting to do public service feel like a sucker, and we are witnessing, I believe, a frightful decline in the quality of people seeking a life of public service and academic research. This has enormous costs to society. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Btw, Arnold Harberger could still win this year. And he should. At one, we should honor the guy whose point is included in all textbooks. Everyone. Of. Them. To quote Gary Oldman in Leon the Professional
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
The man who drew a triangle that revolutionized economics in many ways is now 100 and still hasnt received his Nobel
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I am opposed to a wealth tax on billionaires for at least three reasons.
1. The Mobility Argument.
A California wealth tax -- even if it is a one-time tax that is not imposed again in the future -- will encourage productive individuals to move out of California. If it succeeds in raising revenue this time, the temptation to use the same idea again will be so strong that any statement to the contrary is simply unbelievable.
It has been said that we should tax wealth because rich individuals are able to avoid income tax. But even if billionaires are able to avoid personal income taxes -- the companies they create generate jobs and bring corporate tax revenue into the State. A one-off wealth tax is a losing proposition even from the perspective of raising revenue over all but the shortest horizons.
If a State wealth tax is infeasible, perhaps we should tax wealth at the Federal level. But the imposition of a Federal wealth tax will lead new start-ups to locate abroad. Capital is internationally highly mobile -- as Ireland discovered to its benefit when it lowered corporate taxes in 1981.
The wealth tax advocates won't stop with a federal tax proposal. They will argue -- and have argued -- for the imposition of a minimum tax at the supra national level. But many Americans -- myself included -- will not accept the loss of sovereignty that would be imposed through tax rates regulated by a world government. And even if such a policy were feasible, it is likely to make all of us worse off for the reasons I discuss below.
2. The Golden Goose Argument
The possible imposition of a California wealth tax is one aspect of the debate over capitalist versus socialist forms of economic organization. This debate is reemerging in the United States as our educational institutions have failed to transmit the arguments in favor of American enterprise that former generations of students learned in high school.
We do not need to speculate about the relative benefits of socialism versus capitalism; we need simply observe what has happened when each was tried. Capitalism as an institution has lifted more people out of absolute poverty than any other known form of economic and social organization. But at the same time inequality has increased. That is a feature of a mode of organization that rewards effort and ideas that benefit us all.
Witness the spectacular rise of China after the Central Committee of the Communist Party shifted their priorities in 1978 from class struggle to growth and they began to recognize private property as an alternative to collective farms. The outcome was real GDP growth that averaged 10 percent a year for thirty years.
In contrast socialists hanker after a Utopian dream: 'from each according to his ability to each according to his need'. The problem with this dictum is that striving for equality of outcome -- wherever and whenever it has been tried -- has led to poverty and the mass murder of political opponents. In Stalinist Russia, 10-20 million people died in purges and famines. In Maoist China 50-70 million died during the Cultural Revolution. I would prefer that the US does not go down that path.
3. The Relativity Argument. If our goal is to make people better off in an absolute sense, capitalism is the most effective institution yet discovered to accomplish that goal. But although capitalism leads to an improvement in the standard of living of the poor, it does not lead to a reduction in inequality. In fact, the opposite is the case. Capitalism leads to absolute riches but relative inequality.
In 1981, 88% of the Chinese population lived in extreme poverty -- but the Gini coefficient -- which measures inequality -- was 0.28. The Gini varies between 0 and 1 and the higher the number the more unequal the society. 0.28 is very low meaning that poverty in China was extremely common. Everyone was poor together.
In 2019, less than 0.2% of the Chinese population lived in extreme poverty. This tremendous improvement in living standards in China was achieved by adopting a capitalist economic system. But although everyone became richer, some people became much richer than others. The Gini coefficient, by 2019, had risen to 0.48 which is comparable with the United States at the same time.
Human beings differ in many respects and those differences lead some of us to acquire more income and more resources than others. Some of us are rich and some are poor and, in a capitalist economy, poverty in a relative sense will always be with us. It is an unfortunate aspect of human nature that -- so will envy. @carney @bungarsargon @HannoLustig @ericlonners @postdiscipline @tonyannett @mattkahn1966 @KarlOscar17 @S_Surprenant
Rakesh Bhandari
@postdiscipline
How with all the distortions in markets from so much money in politics can one be against the wealth tax even if it is another market distortion. It required by the theory of the second best.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Matthew E. Kahn
@mattkahn1966
Yes! Roger raises a key spatial agglomeration point. Is California (CA) a "special place" (relative to Texas) so that firms in CA are much more productive. If the CA agglomeration effect is small then the tax induced migration to TX is a macro level zero sum game. (1/2)
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Hanno @HannoLustig is dead on. Proposition 40, which proposes to levy a âone offâ 5% wealth tax on billionaires, is ill conceived.
Even if it raises the revenue its proponents claim for it, Proposition 40 will deter future startups from locating in California. It has already led to an exodus of top earners. The more serious effect is on the loss to California of future innovators that will locate in Florida or Texas.
đŻđ
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
What puzzles me about French economists like Gabriel, as well as Emmanuel and Tomas, is the zeal they bring in trying to convince Americans that they have to implement a French model that is focused on redistribution rather than growth, because every indication we have suggests that the focus on redistribution has cost France, and some other countries in Europe, like my own native Belgium, very dearly so far. In fact, the French economy looks like it is about to enter a serious fiscal crisis because its redistribution model is no longer sustainable.
Californians ought to celebrate the fact that wealth is being created in California, and not somewhere else in the U.S. or in the rest of the world. Americans, and Californians, for that matter, should continue to do what they do best, which is focus on growing the pie. It would be a mistake to adopt a model that is fundamentally broken.
What the French should do instead is try to copy the model that made California an engine of innovation. In that case, smart, highly educated French kids wouldn't come to the U.S. to start companies. They would do so in France. If they had done that, they would have more than one AI startup company. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for the vote of confidence @observer456
Observer456
@bewilderedgazer
As ever, a voice of clarity and reason in increasingly noisy and confused times, Roger. As somebody who follows your tweets closely, perhaps consider developing your political economy takes into some articles or even a book? It would add a lot to the confused state of debate.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes @chordy34929 ⊠I equivocated about the âin partâ ⊠but I do believe that it is possible to participate in positive â as opposed to normative â economics. Itâs just very difficult, perhaps impossible, to eliminate oneâs own biases. As an inoculation against that problem it is best to state oneâs prejudices up front. The prescription from Bayesian statisticians is a sound one. State your prior belief BEFORE torturing the data to deliver a prior that accords with it.
chordy đ€
@chordy34929
"(...) Economics is, and always has been in part, a political venture." I would push back on the "in part" part but sure yeah
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I think you missed my point @BrianCAlbrecht I did not mean to debate the finer points of econometric method. My point was that most people make political decisions based on their experience.
In the 1970s and 1980s workers in the heartland were unionized and worked in close-knit communities. Those communities disintegrated when manufacturing jobs declined, and low-paying service jobs were not a good substitute. Anyone who has visited a town in decline will not be persuaded by econometrics.
Perhaps the absolute loss of manufacturing jobs after 2001 had nothing to do with the increased import share from China. That, to me, seems unlikely. But even if the decline was in part inevitable as a consequence of automation, we did a terrible job as a society of managing a transition for communities to new stable ways of subsisting. A welfare check is not a good substitute for a high-paying job.
Call me a cynic, but it has not been my experience that the majority of my colleagues are dispassionate scholars who leave their priors behind when analyzing data. We find what we look for, and often what we look for is confirmation to support policies from which we personally benefit. Most economists, as members of the coastal elite, benefit from cheaper consumer goods. And we proceed to write papers demonstrating how American workers also benefit from globalization, even though workers in the towns that lost manufacturing jobs have voted with their feet by moving away from a Democratic Party that supports globalization towards a Republican Party that is unashamedly populist.
Economics is, and always has been in part, a political venture. Ricardoâs arguments for free trade were in direct opposition to the corn laws, which supported landowners over manufacturers and workers. The repeal of those laws redistributed away from the landed gentry toward merchants, manufacturers, and labor. Nobody compensated the landowners out of the gains from trade.
So perhaps the Autor-Dorn-Hanson papers had no influence on the debate. But the political economy of the issue was instrumental in the rise of MAGA and the success of Trump.@carney @greg_ip @bungarsargon @jasonfurman @IvanWerning
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
"We do not need a PhD in economics to observe that the loss of these jobs was accompanied by an absolute decline in the standard of living in those regions that had previously supported well-paying blue collar jobs."
That's not obvious to me.
Let's take income to be standard of living. @joefrancis505 says no to the relative effect among employed. That doesnât settle absolute changes, but disappearing factory jobs donât establish them either for Bloom et al 2024 reasons. Maybe these just got classified as service workers?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an excellent analysis from @Brad_Setser regarding the China Shock. Brad argues that the impact of Chinaâs WTO accession is clear in aggregate data. I infer that â even if ADH had not written their paper â there would still have been a shift of the Overton window to allow some economists (myself included) to argue against the default free trade position.
No-one I know of has argued against the pure Ricardian position that the country as a whole gains from trade. There are instead two strong (IMO) arguments for protectionism.
1. The political argument. This asserts that the main gains from trade with China went to the coastal elites who earn most of their income from the sale of physical and intellectual capital. The designers of the iPhone in Silicon Valley gain from trade with China â as do the workers who assemble the iPhone â but these blue-collar workers are now in China thus stripping high paid unionized jobs from American workers in the heartland. The average American can observe that the decline of US manufacturing is correlated with the rise of China and he/she neither understands nor cares much if ADH had valid instruments in their econometrics.
A typical rebuttal to the political argument is that manufacturing as a share of GDP is declining everywhere â including in China. That argument confounds absolute with relative decline. The evidence that Brad presents shows that employment in US manufacturing fell by approximately a third in the decade following Chinaâs accession to the WTO. We do not need a PhD in economics to observe that the loss of these jobs was accompanied by an absolute decline in the standard of living in those regions that had previously supported well-paying blue collar jobs. Case and Deaton point out that this decline is associated with what they aptly call âdeaths of despairâ.
2. The defense argument. The industries that we lost include shipbuilding, steel, refining of rare earths, semiconductor manufacture and pharmaceuticals ⊠these are all industries that are essential in the event of war. If our current disagreements with China ever turn into a kinetic conflict it will not be much use to us if the materials needed for arms production are imported from the Far East. @carney @bungarsargon @BrianCAlbrecht @jasonfurman @greg_ip @IvanWerning
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
so we are where we are ... US manufacturing and ag exports are down 2.5% of GDP from their levels in the 1990s ... and are incredibly small v the US economy (~ 4 % of GDP) ... and that decline hasn't actually been offset by growing IP exports (even counting "irish" FDI profits)
/end -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
And, as far as I know, they also intend to tax billionnaires who were in California at any time since January 2026.
So, the situation in California is that they might just decide on a whim that they're going to re-tax you at different rates after the fact whenever they need money. But believe them when they say it's a one-time thing -- they won't change their minds on that one.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Hanno @HannoLustig is dead on. Proposition 40, which proposes to levy a âone offâ 5% wealth tax on billionaires, is ill conceived.
Even if it raises the revenue its proponents claim for it, Proposition 40 will deter future startups from locating in California. It has already led to an exodus of top earners. The more serious effect is on the loss to California of future innovators that will locate in Florida or Texas.
đŻđ
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
What puzzles me about French economists like Gabriel, as well as Emmanuel and Tomas, is the zeal they bring in trying to convince Americans that they have to implement a French model that is focused on redistribution rather than growth, because every indication we have suggests that the focus on redistribution has cost France, and some other countries in Europe, like my own native Belgium, very dearly so far. In fact, the French economy looks like it is about to enter a serious fiscal crisis because its redistribution model is no longer sustainable.
Californians ought to celebrate the fact that wealth is being created in California, and not somewhere else in the U.S. or in the rest of the world. Americans, and Californians, for that matter, should continue to do what they do best, which is focus on growing the pie. It would be a mistake to adopt a model that is fundamentally broken.
What the French should do instead is try to copy the model that made California an engine of innovation. In that case, smart, highly educated French kids wouldn't come to the U.S. to start companies. They would do so in France. If they had done that, they would have more than one AI startup company. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Hanno @HannoLustig is dead on. Proposition 40, which proposes to levy a âone offâ 5% wealth tax on billionaires, is ill conceived.
Even if it raises the revenue its proponents claim for it, Proposition 40 will deter future startups from locating in California. It has already led to an exodus of top earners. The more serious effect is on the loss to California of future innovators that will locate in Florida or Texas.
đŻđ
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
What puzzles me about French economists like Gabriel, as well as Emmanuel and Tomas, is the zeal they bring in trying to convince Americans that they have to implement a French model that is focused on redistribution rather than growth, because every indication we have suggests that the focus on redistribution has cost France, and some other countries in Europe, like my own native Belgium, very dearly so far. In fact, the French economy looks like it is about to enter a serious fiscal crisis because its redistribution model is no longer sustainable.
Californians ought to celebrate the fact that wealth is being created in California, and not somewhere else in the U.S. or in the rest of the world. Americans, and Californians, for that matter, should continue to do what they do best, which is focus on growing the pie. It would be a mistake to adopt a model that is fundamentally broken.
What the French should do instead is try to copy the model that made California an engine of innovation. In that case, smart, highly educated French kids wouldn't come to the U.S. to start companies. They would do so in France. If they had done that, they would have more than one AI startup company. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ
Stephen Miran
@SteveMiran
In my experience in policy, nobody said we have to configure tariffs in a specific manner because of the ADH paper. There were discussions of the sustainability of global imbalances, revenue and deficits, national security and the need for a robust manufacturing sector.
Nor indeed do we have a good solution to the empirical problem here. Generalizing from well identified microeconomic studies is tough, and plausible identification in aggregate data is rare. The hard questions are difficult to study, as ever.
Speaking personally, I became aware of the China shock when I was working in currency markets in 2010 marveling at their reserve accumulation (currency manipulation) while our manufacturing was contracting. When the ADH work came out, I thought, âgreat, academics are finally starting to get it,â but all it did was make my priors firmer. I never believed the numbers in any precise sense nor sought to calibrate policy to them. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
great đ§”đ
Sebastian Galiani
@SFGaliani
1/There seem to be two different discussions on X about the Autor, Dorn and Hanson China Shock work. One is whether the results hold up. The other is how much this work actually influenced US trade policy.
The second one is much harder. A paper can be cited and discussed by policymakers without changing what they do. They may simply find a paper that supports something they already wanted to do.
The more interesting possibility, of course, is that the paper changed their priors and therefore changed policy. But showing that is much harder.
One thing we can actually check is how the China Shock research was used in the Economic Report of the President under different administrations. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âThe fact that this monumental and challenging bookâright or wrongâcannot find a major academic publisher is an intellectual scandal. The editors at Princeton University Press and the University of Chicago Press should be ashamed.â đŻđ
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
The Greg Clark Symposium - The fact that this monumental and challenging bookâright or wrongâcannot find a major academic publisher is an intellectual scandal. marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/10/the-greâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I think you missed my point @BrianCAlbrecht I did not mean to debate the finer points of econometric method. My point was that most people make political decisions based on their experience.
In the 1970s and 1980s workers in the heartland were unionized and worked in close-knit communities. Those communities disintegrated when manufacturing jobs declined, and low-paying service jobs were not a good substitute. Anyone who has visited a town in decline will not be persuaded by econometrics.
Perhaps the absolute loss of manufacturing jobs after 2001 had nothing to do with the increased import share from China. That, to me, seems unlikely. But even if the decline was in part inevitable as a consequence of automation, we did a terrible job as a society of managing a transition for communities to new stable ways of subsisting. A welfare check is not a good substitute for a high-paying job.
Call me a cynic, but it has not been my experience that the majority of my colleagues are dispassionate scholars who leave their priors behind when analyzing data. We find what we look for, and often what we look for is confirmation to support policies from which we personally benefit. Most economists, as members of the coastal elite, benefit from cheaper consumer goods. And we proceed to write papers demonstrating how American workers also benefit from globalization, even though workers in the towns that lost manufacturing jobs have voted with their feet by moving away from a Democratic Party that supports globalization towards a Republican Party that is unashamedly populist.
Economics is, and always has been in part, a political venture. Ricardoâs arguments for free trade were in direct opposition to the corn laws, which supported landowners over manufacturers and workers. The repeal of those laws redistributed away from the landed gentry toward merchants, manufacturers, and labor. Nobody compensated the landowners out of the gains from trade.
So perhaps the Autor-Dorn-Hanson papers had no influence on the debate. But the political economy of the issue was instrumental in the rise of MAGA and the success of Trump.@carney @greg_ip @bungarsargon @jasonfurman @IvanWerning
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
"We do not need a PhD in economics to observe that the loss of these jobs was accompanied by an absolute decline in the standard of living in those regions that had previously supported well-paying blue collar jobs."
That's not obvious to me.
Let's take income to be standard of living. @joefrancis505 says no to the relative effect among employed. That doesnât settle absolute changes, but disappearing factory jobs donât establish them either for Bloom et al 2024 reasons. Maybe these just got classified as service workers?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an excellent analysis from @Brad_Setser regarding the China Shock. Brad argues that the impact of Chinaâs WTO accession is clear in aggregate data. I infer that â even if ADH had not written their paper â there would still have been a shift of the Overton window to allow some economists (myself included) to argue against the default free trade position.
No-one I know of has argued against the pure Ricardian position that the country as a whole gains from trade. There are instead two strong (IMO) arguments for protectionism.
1. The political argument. This asserts that the main gains from trade with China went to the coastal elites who earn most of their income from the sale of physical and intellectual capital. The designers of the iPhone in Silicon Valley gain from trade with China â as do the workers who assemble the iPhone â but these blue-collar workers are now in China thus stripping high paid unionized jobs from American workers in the heartland. The average American can observe that the decline of US manufacturing is correlated with the rise of China and he/she neither understands nor cares much if ADH had valid instruments in their econometrics.
A typical rebuttal to the political argument is that manufacturing as a share of GDP is declining everywhere â including in China. That argument confounds absolute with relative decline. The evidence that Brad presents shows that employment in US manufacturing fell by approximately a third in the decade following Chinaâs accession to the WTO. We do not need a PhD in economics to observe that the loss of these jobs was accompanied by an absolute decline in the standard of living in those regions that had previously supported well-paying blue collar jobs. Case and Deaton point out that this decline is associated with what they aptly call âdeaths of despairâ.
2. The defense argument. The industries that we lost include shipbuilding, steel, refining of rare earths, semiconductor manufacture and pharmaceuticals ⊠these are all industries that are essential in the event of war. If our current disagreements with China ever turn into a kinetic conflict it will not be much use to us if the materials needed for arms production are imported from the Far East. @carney @bungarsargon @BrianCAlbrecht @jasonfurman @greg_ip @IvanWerning
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
so we are where we are ... US manufacturing and ag exports are down 2.5% of GDP from their levels in the 1990s ... and are incredibly small v the US economy (~ 4 % of GDP) ... and that decline hasn't actually been offset by growing IP exports (even counting "irish" FDI profits)
/end -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an excellent analysis from @Brad_Setser regarding the China Shock. Brad argues that the impact of Chinaâs WTO accession is clear in aggregate data. I infer that â even if ADH had not written their paper â there would still have been a shift of the Overton window to allow some economists (myself included) to argue against the default free trade position.
No-one I know of has argued against the pure Ricardian position that the country as a whole gains from trade. There are instead two strong (IMO) arguments for protectionism.
1. The political argument. This asserts that the main gains from trade with China went to the coastal elites who earn most of their income from the sale of physical and intellectual capital. The designers of the iPhone in Silicon Valley gain from trade with China â as do the workers who assemble the iPhone â but these blue-collar workers are now in China thus stripping high paid unionized jobs from American workers in the heartland. The average American can observe that the decline of US manufacturing is correlated with the rise of China and he/she neither understands nor cares much if ADH had valid instruments in their econometrics.
A typical rebuttal to the political argument is that manufacturing as a share of GDP is declining everywhere â including in China. That argument confounds absolute with relative decline. The evidence that Brad presents shows that employment in US manufacturing fell by approximately a third in the decade following Chinaâs accession to the WTO. We do not need a PhD in economics to observe that the loss of these jobs was accompanied by an absolute decline in the standard of living in those regions that had previously supported well-paying blue collar jobs. Case and Deaton point out that this decline is associated with what they aptly call âdeaths of despairâ.
2. The defense argument. The industries that we lost include shipbuilding, steel, refining of rare earths, semiconductor manufacture and pharmaceuticals ⊠these are all industries that are essential in the event of war. If our current disagreements with China ever turn into a kinetic conflict it will not be much use to us if the materials needed for arms production are imported from the Far East. @carney @bungarsargon @BrianCAlbrecht @jasonfurman @greg_ip @IvanWerning
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
so we are where we are ... US manufacturing and ag exports are down 2.5% of GDP from their levels in the 1990s ... and are incredibly small v the US economy (~ 4 % of GDP) ... and that decline hasn't actually been offset by growing IP exports (even counting "irish" FDI profits)
/end -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Sebastian Galiani
@SFGaliani
Empirical results in economics are often more fragile than the profession has been willing to admit.
A recent experiment gave 146 research teams the same data and the same question. They came back with important different answers. There is a lot of room for researcher choices to matter.
But there is another problem that replication cannot solve.
A paper does not become wrong when somebody fails to replicate it. It can be wrong from day one.
The code can run. The standard errors can be right. Every table can replicate. And the paper can still fail to identify what it claims to identify.
Maybe the instrument isn't credible. Maybe SUTVA doesn't hold. Maybe important equilibrium effects are missing. Or maybe the estimated object simply doesn't answer the economic question we care about.
Replication is extremely useful. But replication is not identification. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
These are good points ⊠@S_Surprenant points out that what is optimal from the perspective of a benevolent social planner may not be the outcome of a democratic political process. We see that already in the UK with the immense difficulty in removing the triple lock on pensions in a society where the age distribution â and with it political powers â is tilting towards the elderly @carney
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
That government debt facilitates "trade" between generations is true enough, but many people would likely respond that this is precisely the problem. And I don't think that they would be entirely misguided in making that point.
The argument laid out in Farmer's blog post neglects the behavior of politicians and voters. If some policies are only transfers -- i.e., spending that either does not deliver benefits later, or even undermines future benefits -- then you have an issue if older voters have enough mass to skew policies in that direction.
Policies that look optimal under a benevolent social planner may turn out to be very bad ideas because the real planner is neither omniscient, nor benevolent. I don't know how the balance of things shake out here, but it might be worth asking if letting governments run deficits any which way they please can lead to decisions that are sufficiently bad to overturn your advice. I'd lean towards probably not, but I also didn't sit down to add things up.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Whatever your view on the optimal size of the state (my personal view is that it should be small) a balanced budget amendment is a very bad idea for the reasons I explain here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/12/9/how-much-deâŠ
There is an optimal value for government debt as a percentage of GDP â and it is NOT zero. @carney
John Carney
@carney
Dear Don Boudreaux,
You have frequently complained that âthe stateâ is too big and argued more should have been done to constrain its growth. Youâve argued that we need a balanced budget amendment to prevent government from financing its growth with debt.
Since 1985, the annual federal budget deficit is about 8.4 times larger in nominal dollars than in fiscal year 1985, roughly 2.8 times larger after inflation. Gross federal debt has grown far more â from about $1.8 trillion at the end of FY1985 to roughly $40 trillion by the start of October 2026.
How curious. Please tell me which of the following results of the growth of a growing government and ever-larger debt over the past 40 years do you wish to undo?
Sincerely,âšJohn Carneyâš
PS: See how this works? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John Carney
@carney
Agree. Especially when history tells us that when we reduce government debt, we donât tend to reduce indebtedness but to move it into the private sector. Thatâs not necessarily good or bad. But itâs unlikely that the optimal allocation is 100% private.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Smoothing is not the issue I discuss in that post. Economic theory suggests that everyone benefits â in a well defined sense â if the interest rate equals the growth rate. That requires a non zero (possibly negative) amount of debt as a percentage of GDP.
Smoothing is a separate issue.
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
The government can operate as a net saver instead of debtor and still smooth expenditures over the business cycle.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Whatever your view on the optimal size of the state (my personal view is that it should be small) a balanced budget amendment is a very bad idea for the reasons I explain here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/12/9/how-much-deâŠ
There is an optimal value for government debt as a percentage of GDP â and it is NOT zero. @carney
John Carney
@carney
Dear Don Boudreaux,
You have frequently complained that âthe stateâ is too big and argued more should have been done to constrain its growth. Youâve argued that we need a balanced budget amendment to prevent government from financing its growth with debt.
Since 1985, the annual federal budget deficit is about 8.4 times larger in nominal dollars than in fiscal year 1985, roughly 2.8 times larger after inflation. Gross federal debt has grown far more â from about $1.8 trillion at the end of FY1985 to roughly $40 trillion by the start of October 2026.
How curious. Please tell me which of the following results of the growth of a growing government and ever-larger debt over the past 40 years do you wish to undo?
Sincerely,âšJohn Carneyâš
PS: See how this works? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Tom Calver
@TomHCalver
For a while now I've been puzzled why Britain doesn't appear higher on international tax league tables.
We know that Britain's income tax is predominantly paid by top earners, with the top 10% paying almost 60% of the bill. But is there more to it than that?
1/5 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thx @JaycobYes
Jaycob
@JaycobYes
Canât find an easily accessible link, but itâs in Yeagerâs Fluttering Veil
storage.googleapis.com/catalog.libertyfund.org/PDFPreview⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Dennis Leech
@Dennis_Leech
The General Theory remains an important book as relevant today as it was in 1936 precisely because it deals with macroeconomics as a separate branch of economics. Keynes demonstrates that there is no general tendency to full employment equilibrium through the price mechanism.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Tom Barson
@tbarson49
But Roger, prices are the fundamental particles of the universe. Hayek and Mises established this quite clearly. :-) Well-posted. Figuring when and how we can reason from aggregates is a big, hard, and important job.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
Ok, need to think about that conceptual distinction, I prefer to think of unified theory and the link between micro and macro being the theory of economic forces AT work as Alchian put it. I tend to focus not on the Monetarist Counter Revolution but the Counter Revolution captured in property rights econ, law and econ, public choice, and market process theory.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âMisunderstandingâ was pointing to Anderson⊠by which I meant that macroeconomics is .. or should be ⊠conceptually different from price theory. I will read Yeagerâs paper. Do you have an accessible link?
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
Why misunderstanding of science? I am curious. Yeager has great paper on the Keynesian Diversion; Buchanan discusses the fiscal consequences of Keynes; Hayek the monetary consequences. Ok so Chap 12. keynesianism is about the agony of choice and subjectivity of expectations, but is there a relative price economics in his narrative of econ crises? Arthur Margetâs Theory of Prices pointed in a different direction that was swept away in the Keynesian Avalanche. How do we dig through the wreckage and salvage? Seems to me science progresses not only through tombstones but in salvaging expeditions.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an unfair characterization of the General Theory @PeterBoettke and a misunderstanding of the nature of the scientific enterprise. @GeorgeSelgin @TyKeynes @carney The GT is a theory of aggregates which may, or may not, be easily understood by compounding individual behaviors. It bears little or no relationship to âNew Keynesian Economicsâ which as I have argued elsewhere
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
.. is neither new nor Keynesian.
There was a rich history in economics in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries that differentiated relationships between broad economic aggregates from disaggregated market or individual choice. I would place the Quantity Theory of Money as in Humeâs essay âOf Moneyâ or Irving Fisherâs formalization of the QT in the U.S. in the former camp and âChicago Price Theoryâ in the latter.
Keynes, when he wrote the GT, was writing in a Cambridge tradition that dated to Marshall and included contemporaries like Ralph Hawtrey whose book on the Gold Standard is still worth reading. This theorizing about aggregates was not, as became popular later, grounded in a complete individualistic theory of rational choice. The GT was an extension of these ideas.
In the natural sciences there is a famous essay, âMore is Differentâ by Philip Anderson www.physics.rutgers.edu/~wdwu/351/MoreIsDifferent.pdf which argues that science is hierarchical and that new phenomena emerge at different levels of aggregation. Chemistry is much more than aggregate physics. In the same way, macroeconomics is much more than aggregate microeconomics.
None of this is written as a defense of the GT as bedtime reading â but I would not claim that for Human Action either which â in its obfuscatory language is â to the untrained reader â closer to Derrida, Lacan or Baudrillard in lucidity of prose than to Anglo-Saxon writers like Keynes, Hawtrey or Marshall.
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
As John McEnroe was famously said âYou Canât Be Seriousâ ⊠come on George, writing a bad book that sells because it fit a cultural zeitgeist is not the same as writing a great book in economics. The General Theory derailed progress in economic theory by shifting away from price theoretic explanations of money, capital and employment. You of all people know that!
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
@TyKeynes is in good company: countless others agree with him that the _General Theory_ is a great book and a far better one than _Human Action_. Some have even read it.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John Carney
@carney
Definitely agree. People who pretend the General Theory is a "great book" are just skimming the unreadable parts.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I personally find Hayek â particularly his piece on knowledge in society www.econlib.org/library/Essays/hykKnw.html â much easier to read (and potentially more important) than either the General Theory from Keynes or Human Action from Von Mises @TyKeynes @GeorgeSelgin
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
@TyKeynes is in good company: countless others agree with him that the _General Theory_ is a great book and a far better one than _Human Action_. Some have even read it.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
would say US imports from all of Asia are increasingly financed by Asian purchases of US equities -- if there is a flow from China, it would be an indirect one, via Singapore (big flow from Singapore to US equities, more than can be explained by the GIC i suspect)
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Read this. đđ»
Oren Cass
@oren_cass
In Friday's edition of The Real Economy @commonplc:
Meet the Baghdad Bobs of the American industral boom, who will go down with the ship insisting that tariffs destroy manufacturing no matter what the data shows.
My favorite example was @Noahpinion... mag.commonplace.org/p/the-real-economy-baghdad-bobs-of -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
The former, indeed.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Are you arguing George, that the political motivation for deficit spending in WWII had nothing to do with politicians reading the General Theory: or are you arguing that the General Theory cannot explain why unemployment fell precipitously in the wake of deficit spending? If the former: I agree. @GeorgeSelgin
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Actually, Keynesian fiscal policy was hardly tried in the â30s, and though deficit spending went through the roof after WWII started, Keynesian economics had nothing to do with it.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
The U.S. is in the midst of one of the largest investment booms it's experienced in its history, fueled by the arrival of a new general-purpose technology: AI. The U.S. is projected to invest roughly 3.6% of GDP in AI infrastructure (think data centers etc) per annum between 2025 and 2032. That is about three times the size of the US telecom and fiber investment boom in the late 90s. And itâs roughly 50% larger than the railroad investments of the late 19th century.
What do you have to believe about future cash flows if you're building data centers right now? In his new BPEA paper "Financing the AI Buildout" @SVNieuwerburgh ran the numbers for us. For US data center owners to break-even with a 10% required return, you'd have to expect that total gross revenue of data centers exceeds 9% of projected US GDP by 2032
thetwocents.substack.com/p/nine-percent-of-gdp -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Read the entire đ§”from @Brad_Setser Chinese imports to the US appear to be increasingly financed by Chinese purchases of US equities (did I get that right Brad ) that seems completely sustainable but the asymptotic outcome ⊠if the trade deficit persists ⊠is that the Chinese own all of the US economy.
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
Equities
Funding basis and swap spreads trades (indirectly supporting bond flows in other words with s-term balance sheet funding)
whatever the Chinese state banks are doing
open to other ideas
my best ideas usually appear on my blog
www.cfr.org/articles/de-reservification-not-de-dollarization -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with this analysis from @BillAckman The Phillips curve model ⊠which drives the argument that rate rises will curb inflation ⊠has not worked since the original paper was published. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
The presumption that the Fed raising short-term rates reduces inflation is predicated on the belief that higher rates reduce demand and investment.
But what if higher rates donât reduce demand and investment because the demand for intelligence and energy is unaffected by higher rates because winning the race for super intelligence has a near infinite ROI and the demand for compute will remain incalculable.
Why wonât higher rates at this unique moment in history therefore lead to more inflation as interest costs are embedded in everything?
And the problem is compounded as the more the Fed raises rates, the more inflation we will have and the more the Fed will need to raise rates further and so on.
But what if the old models donât apply to the current paradigm and the Fed is wrong?
I think the Fed might have just made a mistake. Am I right or am I wrong? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
which as many of us have been pointing out for some time ⊠is not much of an insight.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
*Instead of "taxes don't finance government spending" the insight becomes, "governments needn't rely on taxes to finance spending." đ„±
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
actually ⊠I think heâs read my work static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
đ
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
You literally have no idea what youâre talking about.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Did they give you your white coat?
Florin Bilbiie đȘđș đșđŠ
@FlorinBilbiie
Chari Kehoe McGrattan Nicolini Perri Heathcote McKay Bianchi Amador Arellano Fogli Bhandari Herkenhoff Mongey Waugh Pastorino Karabarbounis Storesletten Schoelmann Kondo Wozniak De Nardi Bassetto Afrouzi Drenik Fitzgerald Luttmer Holmes Raffo Mehrotra Albright Falasconi
đđ
5/5 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Financial Express @febdonline has republished a piece today that I wrote in 2018 thefinancialexpress.com.bd/opinions/equality-for-all-1534âŠ
The title 'Equality for All?' masks a point I made in the article. Globalization has benefited low paid workers in China and India and it has benefited elites in Europe and the US whose physical and intellectual capital is now combined with a billion Chinese workers whose wages were initially a fraction of the cost of unionized labor in the west. Â
Profits in the US and Europe rose at the cost of a hollowed out western manufacturing sector, the loss of highly paid unionized jobs and the rise of 'deaths of despair' as young people turned to drugs.Â
Global inequality fell at the same time as inequality in the west rose. Trade -- we are told -- benefits all. Â But when trade is opened between nations, there are winners and losers in each country. The gains in western nations were hoarded by the elites. They were not redistributed to the European and American workers who lost jobs and income as manufacturing moved to China, India and Mexico. Â
In the article I argued that this situation could not continue since, in a democracy, the working classes would eventually realize that globalization and mass immigration is not in their interests. Â I was optimistic about the possibility of a reversal through the democratic process.
That optimism is looking increasingly naive -- at least in Europe and the UK -- as the political machinery has become unresponsive to the will of the voters and some commentators; see for example the two posts by David Betz @DavidBe31099196Â
www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-comes-âŠ
www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-comes-âŠ
have argued that civil war is now the most likely outcome. In view of the recent events in Southampton and Portsmouth, I fear that Betz may be right. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Financial Express @febdonline has republished a piece today that I wrote in 2018 thefinancialexpress.com.bd/opinions/equality-for-all-1534âŠ
The title 'Equality for All?' masks a point I made in the article. Globalization has benefited low paid workers in China and India and it has benefited elites in Europe and the US whose physical and intellectual capital is now combined with a billion Chinese workers whose wages were initially a fraction of the cost of unionized labor in the west. Â
Profits in the US and Europe rose at the cost of a hollowed out western manufacturing sector, the loss of highly paid unionized jobs and the rise of 'deaths of despair' as young people turned to drugs.Â
Global inequality fell at the same time as inequality in the west rose. Trade -- we are told -- benefits all. Â But when trade is opened between nations, there are winners and losers in each country. The gains in western nations were hoarded by the elites. They were not redistributed to the European and American workers who lost jobs and income as manufacturing moved to China, India and Mexico. Â
In the article I argued that this situation could not continue since, in a democracy, the working classes would eventually realize that globalization and mass immigration is not in their interests. Â I was optimistic about the possibility of a reversal through the democratic process.
That optimism is looking increasingly naive -- at least in Europe and the UK -- as the political machinery has become unresponsive to the will of the voters and some commentators; see for example the two posts by David Betz @DavidBe31099196Â
www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-comes-âŠ
www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-comes-âŠ
have argued that civil war is now the most likely outcome. In view of the recent events in Southampton and Portsmouth, I fear that Betz may be right. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Like so many questions in political economy: the right question is â How do we design institutions to âsolveâ existing problems. Central Banks have been learning how to operate for at least two centuries. There is some evidence of improvement â but institutional lessons can also be forgotten. see my discussion in www.amazon.com/How-Economy-Works-Confidence-Self-FulfilliâŠ
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Too many libertarians imagine that, were we to just disband the FOMC and bulldoze the Eccles Building, orderly free-market monetary institutions would pop-up like mushrooms, doing away with cycles and inflation with no or negligible short-run costs.
Were reform only so easy! -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâve been looking at 18th and 19th century UK data which suggests youâre right about that Vitor. Although there is evidence of stable velocity for a very broad aggregate like M3, the composition of that aggregate changed dramatically from the beginning of the 18th century, through the suspension of convertibility at the end of the 18th century and with the formalization of the Gold Standard with Peelâs Cash Payments Act in 1819. After that date cheques became increasingly important as a means of payment and the velocity of coins and paper, which was stable in the 18th century, trended up. The lesson, for me, is the history of monetary payment systems has always been a history of innovation.
Vitor ConstĂąncio
@VMRConstancio
Many thanks for the quote, Roger. However, I disagree with your comment. The collapse of stable monetary aggregates started in the early 1980s, long before there was a floor system, as reflected in the 1985 sentence by the Canadian CB Governor, which I quote in my post
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece from @VMRConstancio on Warshâs Jackson Hole speech is worth reading. vconstancio.substack.com/p/a-backward-less-foggy-fed?r=b729o
My reading of the collapse of stable monetary aggregates is that it is related to the move to a floor system of interest rate control in which money and t-bills are essentially perfect substitutes -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece from @VMRConstancio on Warshâs Jackson Hole speech is worth reading. vconstancio.substack.com/p/a-backward-less-foggy-fed?r=b729o
My reading of the collapse of stable monetary aggregates is that it is related to the move to a floor system of interest rate control in which money and t-bills are essentially perfect substitutes -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
thanks for the endorsement @FlorinBilbiie
Florin Bilbiie đȘđș đșđŠ
@FlorinBilbiie
learned a LOT from the book and the author as a graduate student
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Thomas Hintermaier
@T_Hintermaier
Great book! Not restricting attention to unique equilibria helps provide a deeper understanding of the foundations of DSGE models.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for the mention @ARSanchezM www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-Self-fulfilling-Prophecies-âŠ
Alfonso R Sanchez, CFA, PhD
@ARSanchezM
R. Farmer "The Macroeconomics of self-fulfilling prophecies"
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Interesting discussion about the multiplicity of equilibria in financial markets, in particular in bond markets! I learned a lot from digging into the relevant papers.
I think I spot a big difference between macroeconomists and financial economists. I used to belong to the first tribe, but maybe not anymore :)
Financial economists price long-dated assets, like government bonds or corporate bonds, without worrying too much about which equilibrium bondholders are coordinating on. They basically just try to compute the present discounted value of the cash flows that have been promised as best they can. Bond investors who are pricing Microsoft's 40-year paper just project and discount the cash flows. They're not too worried about which equilibrium they're all going to coordinate on.
Take any valuation or asset pricing textbook, and I think you'd be hard-pressed to find anything about the multiplicity of equilibria other than maybe a discussion of bank runs. Read @JohnHCochrane 's Asset Pricing cover to cover (Darrell's book was too hard for me): no equilibrium selection anywhere, at least I don't recall seeing it. Finance doesn't treat it as first-order for valuing long-dated claims. (Of course, when John wandered over into macro, he spent a lot of time thinking about equilibrium selection, but that is consistent with the point I'm trying to make. )
Same goes for John Campbell's Financial Decisions and Markets. And Campbell is not a Chicago economist. He built the excess-volatility literature. Even when finance concludes prices deviate from fundamentals, we reach for discount rates, sentiment, limits to arbitrage. Not equilibrium selection.
The credit literature prices long-dated defaultable debt daily ( Merton, Duffie-Singleton, and Pan-Singleton on EM sovereign CDS ) with default intensities driven by fundamentals. No sunspots.
When financial economists do focus on self-fulfilling dynamics, it's mostly on funding and liquidity at short horizons, as in Brunnermeier and Pedersen.
Macroeconomists have a different tradition. The sovereign-debt literature has emphasized multiple equilibria going back to models like Cole-Kehoe (a great paper by 2 amazing economists, one of who is my long-time coauthor and mentor). That creates an important role for policymakers: eliminate the bad equilibrium and coordinate markets on the good one. (I secretly suspect that's why macroeconomists like this.)
In the Eurozone, the example that people always go back to is Mario Draghi's famous 2012 "whatever it takes" speech. All he had to do is speak those words and the Eurozone ended up in a virtuous equilibrium, where sovereign spreads were much lower. No bonds were ever bought under the OMT program. Costless equilibrium selection. Not quite.
Look at what actually happened over the following decade. The ECB ended up running a very large balance sheet and rolling out several programs with increasingly complicated acronyms, all of which helped sustain low sovereign funding costs in the supposedly virtuous equilibrium.
In the process the ECB was engineering was large cross-country transfers, transfers that I have documented in my work with Yili Chien and Zhengyang Jiang and Matteo Leombroni. www.nber.org/papers/w34311
So actually, if you look at the Eurozone evidence closely, you realize that the ECB re-engineered the underlying cash flows pretty dramatically. So not just a matter of picking a virtuous equilibrium, but actually a matter of reallocating resources across countries in state contingent ways. Draghi's announcement was a state-contingent promise of transfers.** Sometimes it's enough to just follow the cash flows.
Here's why I think this matters. The multiple equilibrium doctrine is part of the official line at the ECB which suppresses the price signals that would maybe force a country like France to actually implement serious fiscal reforms. It kills the only enforcement mechanism we have. If the ECB delivers low funding costs for all governments, that significantly reduces the probability of fiscal reform imo.
As Olivier pointed out, counting on the ECB to intervene would be unwise, but I do think the ECB has set some unfortunate precedents in this regard.
**Valentin Haddad, Alan Moreira, and Tyler Muir make this point about the Fed's 2020 corporate bond backstop ("Whatever It Takes? The Impact of Conditional Policy Promises"): prices jumped on announcement, purchases were trivial, and the response is what you get when the market prices a conditional promise; a put written on the bad states. You don't need equilibrium selection to explain announcement effects. www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20230486 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Alfonso R Sanchez, CFA, PhD
@ARSanchezM
R. Farmer "The Macroeconomics of self-fulfilling prophecies"
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Interesting discussion about the multiplicity of equilibria in financial markets, in particular in bond markets! I learned a lot from digging into the relevant papers.
I think I spot a big difference between macroeconomists and financial economists. I used to belong to the first tribe, but maybe not anymore :)
Financial economists price long-dated assets, like government bonds or corporate bonds, without worrying too much about which equilibrium bondholders are coordinating on. They basically just try to compute the present discounted value of the cash flows that have been promised as best they can. Bond investors who are pricing Microsoft's 40-year paper just project and discount the cash flows. They're not too worried about which equilibrium they're all going to coordinate on.
Take any valuation or asset pricing textbook, and I think you'd be hard-pressed to find anything about the multiplicity of equilibria other than maybe a discussion of bank runs. Read @JohnHCochrane 's Asset Pricing cover to cover (Darrell's book was too hard for me): no equilibrium selection anywhere, at least I don't recall seeing it. Finance doesn't treat it as first-order for valuing long-dated claims. (Of course, when John wandered over into macro, he spent a lot of time thinking about equilibrium selection, but that is consistent with the point I'm trying to make. )
Same goes for John Campbell's Financial Decisions and Markets. And Campbell is not a Chicago economist. He built the excess-volatility literature. Even when finance concludes prices deviate from fundamentals, we reach for discount rates, sentiment, limits to arbitrage. Not equilibrium selection.
The credit literature prices long-dated defaultable debt daily ( Merton, Duffie-Singleton, and Pan-Singleton on EM sovereign CDS ) with default intensities driven by fundamentals. No sunspots.
When financial economists do focus on self-fulfilling dynamics, it's mostly on funding and liquidity at short horizons, as in Brunnermeier and Pedersen.
Macroeconomists have a different tradition. The sovereign-debt literature has emphasized multiple equilibria going back to models like Cole-Kehoe (a great paper by 2 amazing economists, one of who is my long-time coauthor and mentor). That creates an important role for policymakers: eliminate the bad equilibrium and coordinate markets on the good one. (I secretly suspect that's why macroeconomists like this.)
In the Eurozone, the example that people always go back to is Mario Draghi's famous 2012 "whatever it takes" speech. All he had to do is speak those words and the Eurozone ended up in a virtuous equilibrium, where sovereign spreads were much lower. No bonds were ever bought under the OMT program. Costless equilibrium selection. Not quite.
Look at what actually happened over the following decade. The ECB ended up running a very large balance sheet and rolling out several programs with increasingly complicated acronyms, all of which helped sustain low sovereign funding costs in the supposedly virtuous equilibrium.
In the process the ECB was engineering was large cross-country transfers, transfers that I have documented in my work with Yili Chien and Zhengyang Jiang and Matteo Leombroni. www.nber.org/papers/w34311
So actually, if you look at the Eurozone evidence closely, you realize that the ECB re-engineered the underlying cash flows pretty dramatically. So not just a matter of picking a virtuous equilibrium, but actually a matter of reallocating resources across countries in state contingent ways. Draghi's announcement was a state-contingent promise of transfers.** Sometimes it's enough to just follow the cash flows.
Here's why I think this matters. The multiple equilibrium doctrine is part of the official line at the ECB which suppresses the price signals that would maybe force a country like France to actually implement serious fiscal reforms. It kills the only enforcement mechanism we have. If the ECB delivers low funding costs for all governments, that significantly reduces the probability of fiscal reform imo.
As Olivier pointed out, counting on the ECB to intervene would be unwise, but I do think the ECB has set some unfortunate precedents in this regard.
**Valentin Haddad, Alan Moreira, and Tyler Muir make this point about the Fed's 2020 corporate bond backstop ("Whatever It Takes? The Impact of Conditional Policy Promises"): prices jumped on announcement, purchases were trivial, and the response is what you get when the market prices a conditional promise; a put written on the bad states. You don't need equilibrium selection to explain announcement effects. www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20230486 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
full moon at dawn
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece by @izakaminska explains @SecScottBessentâs actions in the bond markets in terms remarkable reminiscent of a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Standard economic theory predicts that â when markets are complete â the duration of government debt does not matter. Buying back long debt and replacing it with short term treasuries should have no impact. In practice that prediction appears to fail.
Although there have been a number of attempts to explain why that prediction fails, there is, as of now, no consensus explanation.
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
My latest contrarian take:
Bessentâs bond market moves may not be so misguided after all www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2026/08/27/bessents-bond-mar⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
When does simplicity become simplistic?
This is not a bad model - there some empirical validation for this .. but many conditioning variables are missing: when you then want to apply it to e.g., @StephanieKeltonâs MMT (this is where this post is going) it does badly ⊠in that case the critique is not driven as much by class warfare but rather by the overwhelming logical incoherence of the narrative ..
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
One of the upshots of the Economistâs attack on Daron Acemoglu is that the key dividing line is not about methodology. You can literally be the most decorated mainstream economist but if you land on the âwrongâ side, you are ousted.
The key dividing line is whose side you are on: workers or big business. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations @glviolante @Simon_Mongey @NiklasEngbom & @AdrienBilal
Gianluca Violante
@glviolante
Once again, I am extremely grateful to the @econometricsoc for the Frisch Medal, which I received yesterday together with my stellar coauthors @NiklasEngbom and @Simon_Mongey in the picture with me. We missed @AdrienBilal who could not make it to Dublin!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Gianluca Violante
@glviolante
Once again, I am extremely grateful to the @econometricsoc for the Frisch Medal, which I received yesterday together with my stellar coauthors @NiklasEngbom and @Simon_Mongey in the picture with me. We missed @AdrienBilal who could not make it to Dublin!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻđ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
While this is what most economists would say, most of them are also unaware of the literature on monetary aggregates and would therefore be overstating their case.
The specific findings behind the conventional view is the instability of money demand and the redundancy of money growth as a predictor of inflation when accounting for a short term interest rate.
The first one requires that velocity be covariance stationary, so you can test it by asking if prices, money, and output (or consumption) are cointegrated. Basically, the grown up version of holding velocity constant is saying that it is mean reverting. If you do it using simple sum monetary aggregates for the United States, this doesn't seem to hold very well in the data.
The second one can be tested using Granger causality test. Here, if interest rates and money are redundant, you might be able to ignore one and focus on the other. In standard New Keynesian models, this is true. And, here again, if you use simple sum aggregates for the United States, you are disinclined to think that money is important because it looks like it is redundant.
But people have re-done all the above using Divisia monetary aggregates (see the work of @RebelEconProf and @PIrelandEcon, their coauthors, and many others). The reason this matters is that economic theory wants you to use Divisia aggregates to account for the fact that you are aggregating assets which are not perfect substitutes. Simple sum aggregation is only justifiable if they are perfect substitutes. So what happened? Standard theory looks a lot better with Divisia aggregates.
We can't test theories about apples by counting bananas, but that's what they tried to do. And the worst part is the paper that introduced this idea predates the entire debate -- William Barnett's original paper on this is from 1980.
And this is consequential for your concerns about Friedman's view. If you try to do money growth targeting, but you target, say, M2 instead of DM2, in an otherwise standard New Keynesian model, you get sunspots. The reason is the central bank is chasing a moving target because the true money growth is approximately DM2 in a New Keynesian model. (John Keating and Lee Smith had a working paper on this.) The practical experience in central banks of missing money growth target may be partly a matter of counting bananas instead of apples. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Eva Vivalt
@evavivalt
Wow, potentially useful tool for those considering offers rn.
Mizuhiro Suzuki
@mizuhiro_suzuki
The Econ PhD Placement Dataset
www.econphdplacements.com -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Happy birthday Al đ
Manuel SĂĄnchez
@mansanchezgz
Alito Harberger cumplirå 102 años este domingo.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Great piece by @psantacl We should recognize the limits to government as well as the limits to markets. The solution to any given âmarket failureâ is often in institutional design implemented through property rights.
Pedro Santa Clara
@psantacl
For a century, economists reached for the lighthouse as the one thing markets could never build: the beam falls on every ship, none can be charged, all free-ride â so only the state can provide it. It was the textbook's trump card. Then Ronald Coase went and looked, and found that private individuals had built, owned, and bequeathed British lighthouses for two hundred years. The point isn't that markets can do everything. It's that "market failure" is only half of any honest argument, and the other half â how government actually performs once it steps in â is the half we are trained never to examine.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Happy Birthday @DavidBeckworth
Macro Musings
@Macro_Musings
Wishing @DavidBeckworth a very happy birthday! đ
No inflation in the cake-to-candle ratio allowed today. Thanks for years of sharp monetary policy takes on Macro Musings. Here's to another year of great conversations! -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Joshua Rauh
@joshrauh
Asset confiscator @gabriel_zucman claims our essay in @nytimes contains a "shocking logical mistake": we observe that billionaires donât believe itâs the one-shot deal he was peddling, but then we donât credit the state for permanent wealth tax revenues. The problem? Only an enacted tax raises money. If he wants to tell voters that a recurring wealth tax on those who stay is the only way to offset lost income tax revenues from those gone, then I invite him to go ahead and say so. 1/5
Gabriel Zucman
@gabriel_zucman
If the tax becomes annual, it would also generate revenue every year by virtue of, you know, being annual.
So have Rauh and Jaros taken this into account?
No.
They assume billionaires would leave as if the tax were annualâŠ
... But that it would generate revenue only once! -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree with you @t_holden
"Nor can determinacy results be changed in general by model features that modify or replace the aggregate Euler equation (heterogeneity, bonds in utility, OLG, household bounded rationality etc.), at least as long as the Fisher equation remains valid."
That is false. Here is an example with three real steady state equilibria and one monetary steady state. The monetary steady state displays indeterminacy even when both monetary and fiscal policy are active.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The key is that models with multiple steady equilibria can generate real indeterminacy even without money.
There is a sense in which I agree with Marios' claim that the Euler equation is the culprit since 'the' Euler equation appears only in a model with one agent -- or equivalently -- in models where the welfare theorems hold and the equilibrium is isomorphic to a single social planner's problem. In models of that kind equilibrium is both unique and determinate.
Tom Holden
@t_holden
In Angeletos's SED keynote, he blamed the "weird" determinacy behaviour of NK models on the Euler equation. I think this is mistaken.
The standard determinacy results are essentially the same when monetary policy follows a real rate rule (real rates on the RHS, not LHS!). In this case, the only role of the Euler equation is to pin down real rates, given output. The Euler equation is then irrelevant for the dynamics of output or inflation, or for questions of determinacy. The same is also true under flexible prices.
Thus, no general explanation for indeterminacy results can involve the Euler equation.
Nor can determinacy results be changed in general by model features that modify or replace the aggregate Euler equation (heterogeneity, bonds in utility, OLG, household bounded rationality etc.), at least as long as the Fisher equation remains valid.
If a monetary policy maker is worried about the government not raising taxes sufficiently to stabilise debt, using a real rate rule is ideal. The central bank can then do their job (stabilising inflation) independent of the government's actions. If taxes are insufficiently responsive to debt, debt will start to explode, and it will be abundantly clear to everyone that the government needs to shape up. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with pretty much everything in this thread. I would welcome reasoned arguments to the contrary. It has been a lonely road speaking in defense of the administrationâs tariff policies.
The default response from my neoclassical colleagues to tariffs and immigration restrictions has been to parrot free trade arguments that originate with Ricardoâs attack on the corn laws but fail to engage with the status-quo in which we are witnessing a reconfiguration of the global world order. @SteveMiran @carney @piie
In addition to the arguments raised by @SteveMiran I would add that tariffs, as with all taxes, have distributional consequences and that working class Americans and Europeans have not demonstrably benefitted â and have likely been harmed â by trade with China whereas global elites have reaped huge benefits.
Stephen Miran
@SteveMiran
Finally, I am able to say something about tariffs I wasn't able to say last year. I'll tell you why at the end of the thread.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
CEPR
@cepr_org
New CEPR Discussion Paper - DP21640
Monetary and Fiscal Policy when People Have Finite Lives
@farmerrf @warwickecon @uniofwarwick @UCLA, Pawel Zabczyk @IMFNews
cepr.org/publications/dp21640
#cepr_mef #econtwitter -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Pedro Santa Clara
@psantacl
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece from @psantacl explains the error in the degrowth agenda furthered by @PikettyWIL @stiglitzian and others who signed the @guardian article www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jun/10/economists-⊠@JonSteinsson @albertobisin It is well worth reading. If you teach undergraduates: make sure they read @psantaclâs arguments. The level of hubris demonstrated by the signers of the Guardian piece is extraordinary.
Pedro Santa Clara
@psantacl
"The pie is fixed. The Earth is a closed system. You cannot have infinite growth on a finite planet."
I hear this constantly, and it's delivered like a law of physics â case closed, only a compromised economist could disagree.
It's wrong. And the mistake is revealing, because it isn't in the physics. It's in the economics smuggled inside the physics. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Emma
@MrsEmmaWebber
Barnaby Philip John Webber
11/01/2004-13/06/2023 đ
If you can, share these images of the beautiful soul stolen from us by the worst of humanity.
Let his face today burn bright.
Barney, I promise you there will be accountability đđ
For You. For Grace. For Ian. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
Pedro Santa Clara
@psantacl
What would it require to enforce Pikettyâs plan? About this matter, he is conveniently vague. Confiscating something on the order of 10% of world GDP and redirecting it through a newly created supranational body does not happen by asking nicely. You cannot restructure the global economy at that scale without a coercive apparatus that dwarfs anything in human history.
The mechanism must be authoritarian. It would require a world government with the power to tell billions of people which jobs they may and may not hold, what they may build, what they may eat and how many hours they are permitted to work.
And to what end? âClimate changeâ is an insufficient answer when Pickettyâs entire edifice is built on a discredited foundation. The report relies on a baseline from the RCP8.5 climate scenario that projects Earth warming by as much as 4.8 degrees Celsius by 2100. But last month, the UNâs own climate panel officially retired RCP8.5 (always a high-end estimate) as âimplausible.â A more central projection is about 2.7 C. Replies to Pikettyâs X feed pointed this out immediately. His response, as far as anyone can tell, has been silence.
That leaves the inequality argument. Worldwide income inequality is nearing a 150-year low, but Piketty insists that radical redistribution of wealth is essential for the Global South. And where have billionaires and wealth been popping up fastest in recent decades? Embarrassingly, data from Pikettyâs World Inequality Database confirms that itâs in South and Southeast Asia, as well as East Asia. These are the exact Global South regions that have spent recent decades rescuing hundreds of millions of people from poverty through market-directed economic growth.
www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2026-06-11/economist-villai⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Another comment: all this is a sad sign of intellectual desperation of the left - reduced to massaging some of the data - and disregarding the rest - to fit fundamentally failed policies ⊠one can be on the left in terms of values and objectives (as I consider myself) and still accept good economics and solid empirical evidence to design possibly successful (at least not yet failed) policies.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
This is crazy good and interesting. It shows how the sausage is made in Mazzucato and Pikettyâs work.
I also think it is important to note - as it is done in the essay - that while Mazzucato is just pure and simple advocacy - no contribution to research - Piketty (and coauthors) have contributed great data (that many of us are using).
Pedro Santa Clara
@psantacl
Last week I published "The Fatal Conceit, Renewed." Today I publish its companion: a catalogue of the methodological errors in the work of Thomas Piketty and Mariana Mazzucato.
The errors are not peripheral. They are devastating â and they all lean in the same direction. In econometrics, we have a name for an estimator whose errors all point one way: biased. In politics, we also use the same name.
Why spend the effort taking these two apart? Because they are dangerous. Piketty and Mazzucato are the intellectual darlings of today's left. They supply a veneer of scholarly respectability to what the left is forever seeking: a justification for higher taxes and more state intervention. The oldest idea in politics â that a few enlightened people know better than the rest of us what to do with our money.
The fame is real. The findings are not. Here is the audit. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Pedro Santa Clara
@psantacl
Last week I published "The Fatal Conceit, Renewed." Today I publish its companion: a catalogue of the methodological errors in the work of Thomas Piketty and Mariana Mazzucato.
The errors are not peripheral. They are devastating â and they all lean in the same direction. In econometrics, we have a name for an estimator whose errors all point one way: biased. In politics, we also use the same name.
Why spend the effort taking these two apart? Because they are dangerous. Piketty and Mazzucato are the intellectual darlings of today's left. They supply a veneer of scholarly respectability to what the left is forever seeking: a justification for higher taxes and more state intervention. The oldest idea in politics â that a few enlightened people know better than the rest of us what to do with our money.
The fame is real. The findings are not. Here is the audit. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jon Steinsson
@JonSteinsson
I don't know what Piketty, Stiglitz, and co. are smoking. Global poverty rates have never been lower. Progress on basic global health and wellbeing measures has been amazing over the past few decades. "End of the road"?!? Come again!?!
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/jun/10/economists-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
For the record.
Keynesian brain rot is now hardâwired into central banks and Wall Street: every supply shock is instantly rebranded as âinflation,â and the reflex is to demand rate hikes, as if tighter money could magically print oil, repeal tariffs, or reopen the Strait of Hormuz. This is not analysis; it is a category error with a policy rate attached.
Inflation, properly defined, is a monetary phenomenon: a sustained rise in the general price level, or a persistent fall in the value of money. It shows up when most prices trend higher together, not when one or two sectors reprice violently. A change in relative prices is about who gets squeezed within a largely fixed nominal envelope. When energy, freight or chips spike, some prices must rise and others, in real terms, must fall. That is redistribution and a hit to real income, not automatically an inflation regime.
Any visible price spike, from new tariffs to a shipping choke point in the Strait of Hormuz, is now lazily labelled âbroad inflationary pressure,â and the default prescription is tighter money, even when the underlying impulse is clearly a relativeâprice shock rather than excess nominal demand. The result is proâcyclical tightening into realâside damage, on the comforting illusion that monetary punishment can âfixâ a shortage of physical capacity or geopolitical constraints.
Meanwhile, housing, the most interestârateâsensitive sector and in many economies already in a rolling recession â plainly did not cause the supply shock, yet is sacrificed first on the altar of this misdiagnosis. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hoover Institution
@HooverInst
A tribute volume dedicated to Hoover scholar John B. Taylor discusses his life, his scholarly and government work, and the profound impact of his eponymous "Taylor rule." Learn more in a new Defining Ideas excerpt: www.hoover.org/research/celebrating-john-b-taylor
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jon Hartley
@Jon_Hartley_
An honor to co-author an article in this volume on John Taylor. Essentially every central bank around the world calculates the Taylor Rule as a reference. John Taylor will easily be one of the economists alive today whose work will still be studied one hundred years from now.
Hoover Institution
@HooverInst
A tribute volume dedicated to Hoover scholar John B. Taylor discusses his life, his scholarly and government work, and the profound impact of his eponymous "Taylor rule." Learn more in a new Defining Ideas excerpt: www.hoover.org/research/celebrating-john-b-taylor
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Wojtek Kopczuk đ”đ±đșđŠ and đșđČ
@wwwojtekk
This is a full radical degrowth agenda. Sad to see
Thomas Piketty
@PikettyWIL
The key finding of the report is that energy transition alone will not suffice.
We need to combine it with "sufficiency" to stay within 2 degrees. This includes labour hour reductions, growth caps in rich countries, less material consumption, and changes in food habits. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
ThĂ©o Laubry đșđž
@TheoLaubry
Câest une opĂ©ration marketing. Le dĂ©bat honnĂȘte nâa pas de sens dĂ©sormais. Vous avez fait, avec dâautres, votre possible pour challenger lâargumentaire branlant de GZ en espĂ©rant probablement une correction. Elle nâarrivera jamais. Ce nâest plus de la science mais de la vente.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Le terme "incompétent" est fort. Mais il faut admettre que "sloppy" et "bùclé" s'appliquent trÚs bien.
J'ai quatre articles qui montrent exactement comment lui, Saez et Zucman ont coupé les coins ronds en mautadine.
Depuis je n'accepte aucune de leurs affirmations sans moi-mĂȘme aller voir l'architecture des donnĂ©es.
Voir:
Hervé Joly
@RV_Joly
Je ne partage pas les usages politiques qu'il fait de son travail, mais dire Thomas Piketty est économiquement incompétent n'est pas sérieux. Le Capital au XXe siÚcle est un livre discutable mais important.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
This is utter nonsense. Zucman's mentor Piketty manipulated the UK data to show rising wealth inequality, when it has been flat for decades.
Data duplicity is a clear and recurring pattern for these two Frenchmen.
Zack Polanski
@ZackPolanski
The UK is in decline.
Billionaire wealth is rocketing.
It's time to tax the super rich.
My conversation with the brilliant @gabriel_zucman:
youtu.be/1cG4ULI1yCo -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with this assessment from @DrJStrategy: To paraphrase Greenspan
âI guess I should warn you, if I turn out to be particularly clear, youâve probably misunderstood what I said.â
Central bankers are acting in a world of uncertainty not of risk ; a distinction made by Frank Knight. Economic models are models of risk.
Basing policy on models that attribute an unwarranted degree of confidence to decisions is hubris and likely to lead to bad outcomes.
Central bankers would do well to follow Wittgensteinâs advice:
âWhereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.â
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
Stanley Fischer Would Applaud This
Warsh canât scrap the dot plots and forward guidance fast enough. In a world where Stanley Fischer prized humility about models and genuine data dependence, the current regime looks like the opposite: an illusion of precision that locks policy into yesterdayâs forecast and invites the Street to trade âthe pathâ rather than the data. The dots convert a committeeâs uncertainty into a pseudoâpromise, then punish any attempt to change course as a credibility problem rather than a sign of learning.
Worse, the communications revolution has metastasized into a noise factory. There is no plausible world in which a dozen regional presidents and assorted governors doing a daily speaking tour improves policy or price discovery. It fragments the reaction function, encourages grandstanding, and turns every luncheon remark into a tradable headline. A central bank is not a content platform; it is, as Fischer would insist, a steward of stability, not a streaming service for halfâformed views.
If Warsh is serious about restoring the Fedâs authority, the fix is straightforward: scrap the dots, radically curtail forward guidance, and shut down most of the
speechmaking. Let the institution speak mainly through its decisions and a small number of tightly disciplined communications. Fewer words, clearer incentives, more genuine uncertainty, forcing markets back to the hard work of inference rather than quoteâmining Fedspeak. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
I have worked with @BrianCAlbrecht on questions closely related to the issues of stability analysis that @IvanWerning and Lorenzoni have been wrestling with recently.
Some of our papers related to this topic:
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00199-024-01601-9
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11151-024-10006-w
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jpet.70114?af=R
And some of my observations regarding this topic in general:
1. A perfectly competitive general equilibrium describes a situation where agents know everything they need to know and where the price system enables agents to execute all trades to reach a Pareto efficient allocation.
2. This mechanism of trade through the competitive price system is also very minimalistic in the sense that agents use a minimal amount of information.
3. This competitive general equilibrium can be understood as a steady-state of a learning process operating in a reasonably "fixed" or stable environment, which features imperfectly competitive markets that become more competitive as information "percolates" over the interested parties and profit margins tend to be reduced over time.
4. Macroeconomic issues such as inflation and business cycles that generate fluctuations in unemployment and output are intimately related to this concept of "agents learning towards general equilibrium."
5. That is, if the agents in the economy are very "flexible" and "smart," the resulting reaction of the economic system to unanticipated exogenous shocks will result in quick adjustment and therefore low levels of output and unemployment fluctuations.
6. Random/directed search theory is intimately related to these issues. Hence, why the new monetarist economists such as @1954swilliamson and Randy Wright are tackling money and macro topics using search, and why we have labor search literature to explain why unemployment occurs in "equilibrium." Although I think most of lacks an explicit approach to learning and "convergence process to GE over time," which I tried to bridge in my job market paper (link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00199-024-01601-9).
Overall, I think that this "convergence to GE studies" field is enormous and ultimately the field in economics that has an intimate relationship to the evolution of economic theory over the last 80 years, and that there is still a lot (perhaps most) of stuff to be done.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A great comment from @hidetomitanaka on the magisterial paper by @guido_lorenzoni and @IvanWerning and one I endorse. I hope their work leads others to return to questions that predate the rational expectations revolution.
My number one question is: How does an economy function when trades take place outside of a Walrasian equilibrium? I do not think that Calvo pricing is a satisfactory answer to that question because it is, in essence, an alternative equilibrium concept â as opposed to a disequilibrium trading mechanism.
A satisfactory resolution would contain, IMO, several elements.
1. Expectations matter and they do not always coincide with outcomes, even probabilistically.
2. The set of traders changes over time as a consequence of birth and death and some traders, in all markets, are more sophisticated than others.
3. The world is not fully ergodic over the lifetime of a typical agent: see our definition here, in work with J. P. Bouchaud, of quasi-non ergodicity: static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
4. Point 4 implies that people will not generally be able to learn in finite time. The economy will NEVER attain an equilibrium in the Walrasian sense â or in the Lorenzoni-Werning sense which adds price setters.
5. Inventories act as a buffer against imperfect price discovery: they do not appear as an important element in our theories. They should! This, I believe, is one of the points of @hidetomitanakaâs point about early vs late Hicks.
None of these points should be taken as a negative assessment of the LW paper which is a tour de force and which I highly recommend.
ç°äžç§èŁ
@hidetomitanaka
As a researcher in the history of economic thought, I found your paper to be exceptionally intellectually stimulating, and I sincerely congratulate you on its publication.
Unfortunately, due to a prior commitment, I was unable to attend the presentation in Japan. However, I have heard highly enthusiastic feedback from those who did attend.
I am also deeply grateful that you have paid such careful attention to, and generously acknowledged, the contributions of Japanese economists to the theory of equilibrium stability.
If I may, I would like to offer a few brief comments from the perspective of a historian of economic thought.
Your paper is a remarkable achievement in the tradition of general equilibrium theory. By embedding tĂątonnement into a forward-looking dynamic environment with price-setting firms, you provide a compelling rehabilitation of stability analysis and, in many respects, a rehabilitation of Hicks's insights in Value and Capital (1939).
However, I wonder whether the paper may be recovering only one Hicksâthe young Hicks of Value and Capitalâwhile leaving aside the very different Hicks of his later work.
In Value and Capital (1939), Hicks treated prices primarily as adjustment variables within an interdependent market system. From that perspective, your result that forward-looking price setting restores the relevance of Hicksian stability conditions is both elegant and important.
Yet in his later writings, especially A Market Theory of Money (1989), Hicks increasingly moved away from the Walrasian conception of price adjustment. He argued that many actual markets operate not through continuous price adjustment but through relatively stable prices that function as commitments between buyers and sellers.
In this later Hicksian perspective, a price is not merely a signal of scarcity. It is also a promise. Frequent price changes may undermine confidence, customer relationships, and perceptions of quality. Price stability is therefore not simply a friction delaying adjustment; it is itself part of the institutional structure that makes markets possible.
My concern here is not simply the familiar disequilibrium tradition associated with Clower and Leijonhufvud. In those approaches, quantity adjustment typically emerges because price adjustment is incomplete, delayed, or otherwise impeded. The underlying benchmark nevertheless remains a price-adjustment economy.
The later Hicks appears to suggest something more radical. Relatively fixed prices may themselves constitute a normal institutional feature of organized markets rather than a temporary imperfection. In such markets, prices are not merely adjustment variables waiting to respond to excess demand; they are commitments that sustain confidence, reputation, and ongoing relationships between market participants.
If this is correct, then inventories, delivery lags, customer relations, and other non-price mechanisms are not simply second-best substitutes for missing price adjustments. They are part of the primary adjustment process itself. The question is therefore not how an economy converges when prices adjust imperfectly, but whether many real-world markets should be understood as operating through a fundamentally different logic of coordination.
This raises a question about the meaning of âgeneralâ in general equilibrium theory.
Your model incorporates sticky prices, but the underlying role of prices remains fundamentally Walrasian. Prices are still the primary adjustment variables; stickiness only affects the timing of adjustment. The economy ultimately remains a price-adjustment system. This is true even when prices are sticky in the Calvo sense.
By contrast, the later Hicks seems to suggest that many real-world markets may be better understood as operating under relatively fixed prices, with much of the adjustment occurring through quantities and other non-price mechanisms. Inventories, delivery schedules, customer relationships, reputation, and other institutional arrangements absorb shocks that Walrasian models assign to prices.
If this interpretation is correct, then the issue is not merely whether prices are flexible or sticky. The deeper issue concerns the social ontology of prices themselves.
In the Walrasian tradition, prices are primarily signals.
In the later Hicksian tradition, prices are also commitments.
The distinction matters because a commitment-based pricing system may generate stability through mechanisms fundamentally different from those analyzed in tĂątonnement models, however sophisticated.
Therefore, while your paper may successfully restore stability theory within a Walrasian framework, one may still ask whether the later Hicks's fixprice economy represents a different class of market order altogetherâone whose stability cannot be reduced to price dynamics alone.
From this perspective, the issue is not whether a Walrasian price-adjustment economy can be made stable. Your paper shows that it can. The question is whether such an economy exhausts the relevant notion of generality in the analysis of market coordination.
In that sense, the question is not whether Hicks is back, but which Hicks has returned. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Great thread from @drmtgr
José Moran
@drmtgr
Another interesting thing, since RF raises the issue of inventories, is in fact how one should think of production functions if seriously considering disequilibrium problems.
I think the issue is that the common "language" we use to frame things in econ is at heart a language
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A great comment from @hidetomitanaka on the magisterial paper by @guido_lorenzoni and @IvanWerning and one I endorse. I hope their work leads others to return to questions that predate the rational expectations revolution.
My number one question is: How does an economy function when trades take place outside of a Walrasian equilibrium? I do not think that Calvo pricing is a satisfactory answer to that question because it is, in essence, an alternative equilibrium concept â as opposed to a disequilibrium trading mechanism.
A satisfactory resolution would contain, IMO, several elements.
1. Expectations matter and they do not always coincide with outcomes, even probabilistically.
2. The set of traders changes over time as a consequence of birth and death and some traders, in all markets, are more sophisticated than others.
3. The world is not fully ergodic over the lifetime of a typical agent: see our definition here, in work with J. P. Bouchaud, of quasi-non ergodicity: static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
4. Point 4 implies that people will not generally be able to learn in finite time. The economy will NEVER attain an equilibrium in the Walrasian sense â or in the Lorenzoni-Werning sense which adds price setters.
5. Inventories act as a buffer against imperfect price discovery: they do not appear as an important element in our theories. They should! This, I believe, is one of the points of @hidetomitanakaâs point about early vs late Hicks.
None of these points should be taken as a negative assessment of the LW paper which is a tour de force and which I highly recommend.
ç°äžç§èŁ
@hidetomitanaka
As a researcher in the history of economic thought, I found your paper to be exceptionally intellectually stimulating, and I sincerely congratulate you on its publication.
Unfortunately, due to a prior commitment, I was unable to attend the presentation in Japan. However, I have heard highly enthusiastic feedback from those who did attend.
I am also deeply grateful that you have paid such careful attention to, and generously acknowledged, the contributions of Japanese economists to the theory of equilibrium stability.
If I may, I would like to offer a few brief comments from the perspective of a historian of economic thought.
Your paper is a remarkable achievement in the tradition of general equilibrium theory. By embedding tĂątonnement into a forward-looking dynamic environment with price-setting firms, you provide a compelling rehabilitation of stability analysis and, in many respects, a rehabilitation of Hicks's insights in Value and Capital (1939).
However, I wonder whether the paper may be recovering only one Hicksâthe young Hicks of Value and Capitalâwhile leaving aside the very different Hicks of his later work.
In Value and Capital (1939), Hicks treated prices primarily as adjustment variables within an interdependent market system. From that perspective, your result that forward-looking price setting restores the relevance of Hicksian stability conditions is both elegant and important.
Yet in his later writings, especially A Market Theory of Money (1989), Hicks increasingly moved away from the Walrasian conception of price adjustment. He argued that many actual markets operate not through continuous price adjustment but through relatively stable prices that function as commitments between buyers and sellers.
In this later Hicksian perspective, a price is not merely a signal of scarcity. It is also a promise. Frequent price changes may undermine confidence, customer relationships, and perceptions of quality. Price stability is therefore not simply a friction delaying adjustment; it is itself part of the institutional structure that makes markets possible.
My concern here is not simply the familiar disequilibrium tradition associated with Clower and Leijonhufvud. In those approaches, quantity adjustment typically emerges because price adjustment is incomplete, delayed, or otherwise impeded. The underlying benchmark nevertheless remains a price-adjustment economy.
The later Hicks appears to suggest something more radical. Relatively fixed prices may themselves constitute a normal institutional feature of organized markets rather than a temporary imperfection. In such markets, prices are not merely adjustment variables waiting to respond to excess demand; they are commitments that sustain confidence, reputation, and ongoing relationships between market participants.
If this is correct, then inventories, delivery lags, customer relations, and other non-price mechanisms are not simply second-best substitutes for missing price adjustments. They are part of the primary adjustment process itself. The question is therefore not how an economy converges when prices adjust imperfectly, but whether many real-world markets should be understood as operating through a fundamentally different logic of coordination.
This raises a question about the meaning of âgeneralâ in general equilibrium theory.
Your model incorporates sticky prices, but the underlying role of prices remains fundamentally Walrasian. Prices are still the primary adjustment variables; stickiness only affects the timing of adjustment. The economy ultimately remains a price-adjustment system. This is true even when prices are sticky in the Calvo sense.
By contrast, the later Hicks seems to suggest that many real-world markets may be better understood as operating under relatively fixed prices, with much of the adjustment occurring through quantities and other non-price mechanisms. Inventories, delivery schedules, customer relationships, reputation, and other institutional arrangements absorb shocks that Walrasian models assign to prices.
If this interpretation is correct, then the issue is not merely whether prices are flexible or sticky. The deeper issue concerns the social ontology of prices themselves.
In the Walrasian tradition, prices are primarily signals.
In the later Hicksian tradition, prices are also commitments.
The distinction matters because a commitment-based pricing system may generate stability through mechanisms fundamentally different from those analyzed in tĂątonnement models, however sophisticated.
Therefore, while your paper may successfully restore stability theory within a Walrasian framework, one may still ask whether the later Hicks's fixprice economy represents a different class of market order altogetherâone whose stability cannot be reduced to price dynamics alone.
From this perspective, the issue is not whether a Walrasian price-adjustment economy can be made stable. Your paper shows that it can. The question is whether such an economy exhausts the relevant notion of generality in the analysis of market coordination.
In that sense, the question is not whether Hicks is back, but which Hicks has returned. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
José Moran
@drmtgr
Il faut se frayer son chemin, c'est un pari mais moi je suis globalement trĂšs content de ma situation
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Great post from @MZunigaP about the founder of the UCLA school ht @BrianCAlbrecht
Mario ZĂșñiga
@MZunigaP
âUncertainty, Evolution, and Economic Theory,â by Armen Alchian
truthonthemarket.com/2026/05/22/uncertainty-evolution-and⊠(via @TOTMBLog). -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A great comment from @hidetomitanaka on the magisterial paper by @guido_lorenzoni and @IvanWerning and one I endorse. I hope their work leads others to return to questions that predate the rational expectations revolution.
My number one question is: How does an economy function when trades take place outside of a Walrasian equilibrium? I do not think that Calvo pricing is a satisfactory answer to that question because it is, in essence, an alternative equilibrium concept â as opposed to a disequilibrium trading mechanism.
A satisfactory resolution would contain, IMO, several elements.
1. Expectations matter and they do not always coincide with outcomes, even probabilistically.
2. The set of traders changes over time as a consequence of birth and death and some traders, in all markets, are more sophisticated than others.
3. The world is not fully ergodic over the lifetime of a typical agent: see our definition here, in work with J. P. Bouchaud, of quasi-non ergodicity: static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
4. Point 4 implies that people will not generally be able to learn in finite time. The economy will NEVER attain an equilibrium in the Walrasian sense â or in the Lorenzoni-Werning sense which adds price setters.
5. Inventories act as a buffer against imperfect price discovery: they do not appear as an important element in our theories. They should! This, I believe, is one of the points of @hidetomitanakaâs point about early vs late Hicks.
None of these points should be taken as a negative assessment of the LW paper which is a tour de force and which I highly recommend.
ç°äžç§èŁ
@hidetomitanaka
As a researcher in the history of economic thought, I found your paper to be exceptionally intellectually stimulating, and I sincerely congratulate you on its publication.
Unfortunately, due to a prior commitment, I was unable to attend the presentation in Japan. However, I have heard highly enthusiastic feedback from those who did attend.
I am also deeply grateful that you have paid such careful attention to, and generously acknowledged, the contributions of Japanese economists to the theory of equilibrium stability.
If I may, I would like to offer a few brief comments from the perspective of a historian of economic thought.
Your paper is a remarkable achievement in the tradition of general equilibrium theory. By embedding tĂątonnement into a forward-looking dynamic environment with price-setting firms, you provide a compelling rehabilitation of stability analysis and, in many respects, a rehabilitation of Hicks's insights in Value and Capital (1939).
However, I wonder whether the paper may be recovering only one Hicksâthe young Hicks of Value and Capitalâwhile leaving aside the very different Hicks of his later work.
In Value and Capital (1939), Hicks treated prices primarily as adjustment variables within an interdependent market system. From that perspective, your result that forward-looking price setting restores the relevance of Hicksian stability conditions is both elegant and important.
Yet in his later writings, especially A Market Theory of Money (1989), Hicks increasingly moved away from the Walrasian conception of price adjustment. He argued that many actual markets operate not through continuous price adjustment but through relatively stable prices that function as commitments between buyers and sellers.
In this later Hicksian perspective, a price is not merely a signal of scarcity. It is also a promise. Frequent price changes may undermine confidence, customer relationships, and perceptions of quality. Price stability is therefore not simply a friction delaying adjustment; it is itself part of the institutional structure that makes markets possible.
My concern here is not simply the familiar disequilibrium tradition associated with Clower and Leijonhufvud. In those approaches, quantity adjustment typically emerges because price adjustment is incomplete, delayed, or otherwise impeded. The underlying benchmark nevertheless remains a price-adjustment economy.
The later Hicks appears to suggest something more radical. Relatively fixed prices may themselves constitute a normal institutional feature of organized markets rather than a temporary imperfection. In such markets, prices are not merely adjustment variables waiting to respond to excess demand; they are commitments that sustain confidence, reputation, and ongoing relationships between market participants.
If this is correct, then inventories, delivery lags, customer relations, and other non-price mechanisms are not simply second-best substitutes for missing price adjustments. They are part of the primary adjustment process itself. The question is therefore not how an economy converges when prices adjust imperfectly, but whether many real-world markets should be understood as operating through a fundamentally different logic of coordination.
This raises a question about the meaning of âgeneralâ in general equilibrium theory.
Your model incorporates sticky prices, but the underlying role of prices remains fundamentally Walrasian. Prices are still the primary adjustment variables; stickiness only affects the timing of adjustment. The economy ultimately remains a price-adjustment system. This is true even when prices are sticky in the Calvo sense.
By contrast, the later Hicks seems to suggest that many real-world markets may be better understood as operating under relatively fixed prices, with much of the adjustment occurring through quantities and other non-price mechanisms. Inventories, delivery schedules, customer relationships, reputation, and other institutional arrangements absorb shocks that Walrasian models assign to prices.
If this interpretation is correct, then the issue is not merely whether prices are flexible or sticky. The deeper issue concerns the social ontology of prices themselves.
In the Walrasian tradition, prices are primarily signals.
In the later Hicksian tradition, prices are also commitments.
The distinction matters because a commitment-based pricing system may generate stability through mechanisms fundamentally different from those analyzed in tĂątonnement models, however sophisticated.
Therefore, while your paper may successfully restore stability theory within a Walrasian framework, one may still ask whether the later Hicks's fixprice economy represents a different class of market order altogetherâone whose stability cannot be reduced to price dynamics alone.
From this perspective, the issue is not whether a Walrasian price-adjustment economy can be made stable. Your paper shows that it can. The question is whether such an economy exhausts the relevant notion of generality in the analysis of market coordination.
In that sense, the question is not whether Hicks is back, but which Hicks has returned. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is a good time to retweet this link evonomics.com/new-keynesian-economics-betrays-keynes/ to @evononomicsmag
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@LuizaJarovsky âSo I was grading people on their ability to use ChatGPT.â
There is no point in resisting the use of AI in the process of creation of intellectual ideas. We must instead, teach our students how to use it effectively.
Here is the assignment I gave my second year PhD class:
Your assignment for the course is to write a research paper using AI. The paper should be a minimum of 15 pages and a maximum of 30 pages including bibliography. Appendixes (if needed) can be additional.  The paper must be formatted for submission to a journal.
At each step of the production of the paper, keep a diary on a word processor of your choice. Document which AI you use at each step and importantly: what prompts you gave it. Typical steps would include:
Â
1Choice of a topic. Is my idea a good one? Has it been done before?
2Literature Review. Check for hallucinations. READ the main papers yourself. Do NOT rely on the AI. Which AI did you use.
3Structure of the paper. Make an outline. Discuss it with one or more Ais. Document your prompts and the AI response.
4Draft the paper. Go back and forth suggesting possible improvements.
5Discuss possible journals that the paper could be submitted to. How should your paper be refined to hit a particular journal?
6When the paper is complete: Send it to a different AI and ask for referee reports. How can the paper be improved in light of the reports? Take up the suggestions.
âšâšYou will NOT be graded on the quality of the paper. You WILL be graded on the quality of the diary and how well you responded to and interacted with the AI.
Luiza Jarovsky, PhD
@LuizaJarovsky
đš University professors have been saying AI is completely destroying learning and that we'll soon have an AI-powered, semi-illiterate workforce. Here's a glimpse into the educational apocalypse:
"Sarah, a freshman at Wilfrid Laurier University in Ontario, said she first used ChatGPT to cheat during the spring semester of her final year of high school. (...) After getting acquainted with the chatbot, Sarah used it for all her classes: Indigenous studies, law, English, and a âhippie farming classâ called Green Industries. âMy grades were amazing,â she said. âIt changed my life.â Sarah continued to use AI when she started college this past fall. Why wouldnât she? Rarely did she sit in class and not see other studentsâ laptops open to ChatGPT. Toward the end of the semester, she began to think she might be dependent on the website. She already considered herself addicted to TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat, and Reddit, where she writes under the username maybeimnotsmart. âI spend so much time on TikTok,â she said. âHours and hours, until my eyes start hurting, which makes it hard to plan and do my schoolwork. With ChatGPT, I can write an essay in two hours that normally takes 12.â
-
"By November, Williams estimated that at least half of his students were using AI to write their papers. Attempts at accountability were pointless. Williams had no faith in AI detectors, and the professor teaching the class instructed him not to fail individual papers, even the clearly AI-smoothed ones. âEvery time I brought it up with the professor, I got the sense he was underestimating the power of ChatGPT, and the departmental stance was, âWell, itâs a slippery slope, and we canât really prove theyâre using AI,ââ Williams said. âI was told to grade based on what the essay wouldâve gotten if it were a âtrue attempt at a paper.â So I was grading people on their ability to use ChatGPT.â
-
AI in education is a serious topic, and many schools and universities are blindly jumping into the "AI-first" wave without considering short and long-term consequences.
It would be great to hear more from teachers and educators to understand potential solutions.
This might be a great opportunity for rethinking the education system and how students are assessed.
-
đ Link to the full article below.
đ To learn more about AI's legal and ethical challenges, join my newsletter's 94,700+ subscribers (link below). -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is enough material here for a five volume treatise. @JesusFerna7026 and @ferarteaga display an astounding breadth of knowledge on the ideas and influence of Marx that encompasses his economics, sociology, politics and philosophy all wrapped up in the biographies of antagonists on both sides of the many debates they clarify. Apparently Max Weber is next. I hope they follow through.
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Since I have posted so much on Marx vs. Weber, modernity, and development over the last few weeks, I have posted an updated slide deck of my lectures on Karl Marx and the Marxian Tradition (together with @ferarteaga) here:
www.sas.upenn.edu/~jesusfv/ET_3_Marx.pdf
This is a long deck: 437 slides in the last compilation! (It also takes a few seconds to upload.) If I were to teach it carefully, with plenty of class discussion, I would require a whole semester. Even then, some topics (e.g., the Frankfurt School) receive only a cursory treatment because I focus more on economics and political economy, broadly construed. I hope to extend the discussion of those someday.
However, I cover topics rarely seen in these courses, such as Hans-Georg Backhaus and the Neue Marx-LektĂŒre, because most of the work is not translated into English and must be read in the original German.
I donât have an equivalent slide deck on Max Weber, as I havenât lectured on him. Hopefully, one day I will.
Comments and feedback are very welcome. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This, from @DrJStrategy is well worth reading. Thoughtful analysis of how US policy is reshaping the world order.
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
Food for thought.
The New Great Game has arrived, and the terrain has shifted from 19th-century mountain passes to 21st-century sea lanes, energy chokepoints, data centers, and payment rails.
As I argue in my recent National Review essay on the Hormuz crisis, what is ending is Pax Americana, the era when U.S. power provided a subsidized security umbrella while others free-rode on the system it maintained. What is emerging in its place is a sharper contest of systems that forces capital back into productive use, restores economic sovereignty, and redefines peace on terms closer to the postâCold War dividend than to managed decline. This article develops that argument in full, and it is available to read with no paywall. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I found JP a pleasure to work with. @JpBouchaud has a justifiable difficulty in accepting bad assumptions that economists take for granted: perhaps because he has made money as a HF manager by exploiting flaws in those assumptions. Here is an ungated link to our 2023 JPE piece.
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
The thing I find sorta frustrating about JP Bouchaud is that heâs capable of making some pretty sizeable contributions to academic finance and introducing new perspectives, but despite being such an obviously sharp guy, heâs let reflexive NNT-style âseems-trueâ anti-economics criticisms to make him utterly hostile to other economists who have very valid critiques of his work, so heâs completely limited his own impact. The abrasiveness and arrogance means that a serious contribution is less likely to come into being because of a lack of openness and collaboration. He seems to do this because so many out there love the anti-orthodoxy commentary; itâs a cheap win to sound smart because ivory towers arenât allowed to hit back, and also because heâs so used to being completely listened to as a rich HF manager that pushback from economists seems to instantly drive him to hostility. The urge to make himself into an outsider firebrand may feel good to indulge, but he really should try and work with other economists so we can all get at the truth better.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This analysis from @izakaminska of the purpose of the swap lines extended to the UAE by the US is well worth reading: and, IMO, basically correct. Well worth reading.
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
A note on the increasingly frustrating dollar swap line confusion.
While the ESF definitely has a shady history in which it doubles up as black ops financing arm of the US Treasury, when it comes to the UAE situation, it's simple dollar liquidity mechanics that are the issue in this case.
To understand this you need to go back to your Zoltan Pozsar 101, about how shadow dollar liquidity actually flows through the system. This explains entirely what's going on at the moment.
Adam Tooze would have you think otherwise and brings up the ESF's shadowy history as a source of slush funds to add intrigue to the situation. (While it's not untrue, it's besides the point). And now Brad Setser is speculating there may be "something radically new about the US providing dollar credit to a country that itself has pledged to invest in the US" and that this "looks like the US government is financing a off balance investment fund outside Congressional scrutiny, with the Emirates getting the upside ..."
But I'm pretty sure that this is not the case. It's an entirely obvious and transparent situation.
First of all, the original WSJ story that flagged the UAE situation talked about swap lines not ESF-funded Argentina-style swaps. These are entirely different arrangements. For one, the ESF is a Treasury-powered vehicle and usually operates via finite credit facilities. It is also usually arranged between respective sovereign Treasuries.
A swap line, however, is Fed-initiated and potentially limitless. It is an arrangement between fellow central banks.
Now, if you speak to central bankers in the know, they will tell you that despite the central banking framing, it's not entirely the case that the Treasury has no influence on the initiation or not of a swap line. But this doesn't change the mechanical structure, which sits outside of the Treasury system â and imposes on it only in so much as central bank profits or losses ever do. The WSJ may have got the nomenclature wrong, but I doubt it.
As to why the UAE, despite having pledged to invest in the US, needs dollars? I'd argue it's because the original investment is mostly an expression of allegiance, and a signal that the UAE trusts the US to defend its property rights more so than any other superpower and is prepared to fund its military-industrial reconstitution... since the protection of its property rights also hangs in the balance.
If the UAE decides to fund these investments with USTs, this mostly constitutes a transfer of that economic value from the Treasury to the private sector. There needn't be a liquidity event associated with the transfer if it's mediated, as it has been, at the US Government level and extended via a co-investment with the US into newly forged equity investments.
The UAE leg, in that sense, becomes a promise to expire its outstanding claim over the US Treasury in exchange for x shareholding (49% one would presume) in the newly forged company. Think of it more like an asset swap, wherein its debt-based assets are swapped into equity assets underpinned by USG co-investments.
The actual liquidity to start the venture up would likely come exclusively from the US side, with the funding essentially already raised by way of the defense industrial allocations in the BBB. In that scenario, the investments act more like a quid pro quo with an ally, to ensure the US can raise the money it needs via formal channels, without fear that its bond markets do a Liz Truss.
But it's very unlikely that the UAE plans to fund these American investments entirely with UST reserve assets. Much more likely, it plans to deploy its trillion-dollar sovereign wealth fund chest, as well its future oil revenue, to meet most of the $1.4 trillion investment it has promised over 10 years.
In that case, what the UAE would really be doing is merely bouncing back dollar liquidity that's already coming its way from existing USD-denominated assets straight back into American investments. The only difference is that on this occasion, it has agreed to transfer some level of influence over how those investments will be steered. This makes sense if the true purpose of the arrangement is to help reindustrialise the US, as the USG sees fit, so that it can better provide regional security and defy industrial decoupling with China.
Why does it make sense for the UAE? Since some 50% of its SWF is already invested in the US, if America loses in a war with China or Iran, so does the UAE. It needs a strong and autonomous America with trusted supply chains to defend it.
In some respects, this is an echo of how China funded its own industrialization. In 1979 under Deng Xiaopingâs broader âReform and Opening-Up,â China brought in its Equity Joint Venture Law, creating the main channel through which foreign capital first entered Chinaâs industrial economy.
The main difference here is that in China's case, the co-investments were with Western private sector companies or multinationals. In America's case it is wooing capital from fellow sovereigns, with whom it can establish related defense agreements. Statecraft 101.
Why dollar swap lines then? Well, if a good chunk of UAE dollar liquidity is drawn from oil sales, this is self-evidently currently under pressure. And while the UAE probably has many other sources of dollar income, it's what happens at the margin that matters. Under a peg system even a small marginal fluctuation in flows can put pressure on the system. All the more so, if foreign residents are moving money out of the UAE because of regional volatility.
A country like the UAE, in such circumstances, faces the same problem as a distressed bank. It finds itself technically dollar-asset rich, but simultaneously dollar-liquidity poor.
The options it has on the table in that case are either to abandon its peg temporarilly, liquidate its assets at potentially firesale prices compounding the problem (definitely suboptimal), borrow from the market, or seek the one thing it doesn't have under a pegged system: Access to a dollar lender of last resort.
With the UAE likely to become a formal ally, extending lender of last resort facilities to help it manage local dollar liquidity issues, seems the obvious way to go for the US. In a sense it becomes the first official member of what Robert McCauley sees as the emergence of a new dollar swap-line diplomacy club. [Which could, in my mind, be the makings of a new type of IMF system.]
For a country that already operates under a soft form of dollarization, it's not too great a leap.
References below: -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Let me clatify this problem for everyone.
MV = PY is an identity. It simply states that you need enough money to cover all transactions. The theory is about how you think money M, velocity V, prices P, and output Y interact.
The intuition behind monetarism is often conveyed to undergraduates by saying that if you hold V and Y constant, then changes in M will be reflected in changes in P. That is the simplest way to say that printing money causes inflation. The problem is that this isn't the actual theory and it glances over important nuances.
For starters, in the theory behind all of this, 1/V is money demand and that thing varies over time. The grown-up version of V is constant is V is covariance stationary meaning that it fluctuates around a stable mean. That is precisely what people debated in the 80s and 90s, and more recently in the 2010s using a different way to measure money in the US (specifically, the latter research used Divisia indexes).
One reason this matters is that if money demand and money supply both increase, M rises and V falls, so there need not be a rise in prices. Intuitively, people have to use the money to bid up prices. Nothing happens if everyone sits on it.
The other reason this is important is the nature of the signal you get from variations in M to predict variations in P. What theory gives you is a long-run relationship between M, P, and Y: if V fluctuates around a stable mean, then M, P, and Y have to "grow together" and, if they break apart too much, they get pulled back in. The technical term is that M, P, and Y share a stochastic trend -- they are cointegrated. So, what the theory buys you is what we call an "error correction" mechanism that keeps everything together over long periods of time. It's not nothing. To first order and with some assumptions, it says that 2% inflation and 2% real GDP growth requires 4% money growth over the long-run. But it's not clear that it's a great signal to forecast inflation -- other things besides monetary policy moves stuff in that equation.
Now, back to policy. Monetary policy in Canada only engaged in quantitative easing during the pandemic. Otherwise, the Bank of Canada usually works by setting a short term interest rate, not by targetting changes in the money supply. So, it's hard to measure those things just for Canada, but one can try.
To do it, you have to ask yourself what happened between March 2020 and the peak of inflation in June 2022 (healine CPI peaked there year-over-year). Can you really attribute all or even most of this to unconventional monetary policy? Because there were massive fiscal expansions in both Canada and the US, lockdowns and subsequent easing of punlic health policy, disruptions in shipping, energy and commodity markets, and the Canadian labor market was extraordinarily tight for a while... Where does any of this figure in your analysis?
I am working on a project specifically on that inflation episode for the US and Canada using a model estimated before the pandemic (partly to see if "old" explanations are enough). I don't explicitly treat unconventonal monetary policy like QE and FG, but it would probably show up as demand shocks in my model. And I also have some policy counterfactuals to think about the cost of moving to hike rates earlier when inflation started rising. I'll be sharing preliminary results in two weeks at the SCSE conference in Quebec City. Feel free to follow my work and take a look later this year when we have a full working paper ready.
Sheila Walker đ€·đ»ââïžâłïžđžđ„
@sheilawalker73
It seems nobody understand the consequences of printing money! Expanding the money supply ALWAYS creates inflation!
This is a historical truth, and rather than a policy of last resort, itâs become the liberal playbook, and Mark Carneyâs ONLY solution for any crisis! -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations @ChrisPhelanEcon! All the best with your new position.
UMN Economics
@UMN_Econ
www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/04/nominatio⊠Congratulations to @ChrisPhelanEcon on his nomination to be Chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers! He continues Minnesota's proud traditionâfrom Nobel laureate Leo Hurwicz to Walter Heller, CEA Chair under Kennedy/Johnson.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Could not agree more.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations @ludwigstraub !!!
AEA Information
@AEAInformation
Congratulations to Ludwig Straub (@ludwigstraub) of @Harvard, winner of the 2026 John Bates Clark Medal! www.aeaweb.org/about-aea/honors-awards/bates-clark/ludwigâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Konstantin Kisin
@KonstantinKisin
As a huge fan of this platform, I can't help noticing that the noise to signal ratio here has deteriorated. Monetisation has created an incentive structure that is conducive to neither authentic discussion nor quality content.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have a different â theoretical â question for @mileskimball. Under a floor system the economy is permanently in a liquidity trap. The opportunity cost of holding money is zero. What determines the price level? @GeorgeSelgin
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
đ§”With all due respect to Miles, no it isnât.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well this will be an interesting experiment.
Miles đ
@milessuter
Weâre making it easier for millions of businesses to accept bitcoin.
Starting today, eligible U.S. @Square sellers will begin having Bitcoin payments automatically enabled.
Sellers who accept bitcoin will receive USD as default.
This is how bitcoin as everyday money begins. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I donât see what we learn from this picture Richard. It ends before Trumpâs second term begins. @BaldwinRE That is not an endorsement of Trumpâs policies; neither is it a condemnation of those policies. It is simply a statement that we do not yet have enough data to know what their impact will be on US manufacturing. @carney
It is also worth recognizing that manufacturing, as a share of GDP, has been falling in every country in the world â including in China. That is unlikely to change for the same reason that agriculture will never recover as a share of GDP. Development involves a shift from agriculture to manufacturing and then to services. A better measure of whether manufacturing is moving back to the US would be the US share of world manufacturing output.
There are sound reasons to reindustrialize even if it is a second best outcome in terms of efficiency. It is not a smart political move to allow the production of strategic industries to move to potential adversaries in light of the possibility that current tensions may lead to a future kinetic conflict.
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
JFYI
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This argument is worth reading. IMO the jury is still out on the medium-long term impact of the Trump tariffs on US manufacturing. @carney
Commonplace
@commonplc
So about those recent manufacturing employment numbers...
Critics of Trump's tariffs claim that the decline in manufacturing employment proves that tariffs aren't working, but @Chris_Griz explains there's much more to the story than the critics admit.
www.commonplace.org/p/chris-griswold-about-those-manufact⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This argument is worth reading. IMO the jury is still out on the medium-long term impact of the Trump tariffs on US manufacturing. @carney
Commonplace
@commonplc
So about those recent manufacturing employment numbers...
Critics of Trump's tariffs claim that the decline in manufacturing employment proves that tariffs aren't working, but @Chris_Griz explains there's much more to the story than the critics admit.
www.commonplace.org/p/chris-griswold-about-those-manufact⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Maybe they would be better off with IS/LM heuristics
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
đđœđ©
@mean_field_zane
My favorite cope from uneducated Fedwatchers on this site is the idea that voting Fed officials donât understand advanced economic research and just use undergrad heuristics like IS-LM. There are literally multiple voting Fed officials heavily involved in Fed research day-to-day and most board officials read the internal research to understand what they should do.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
John argues that Germany and Japan ran trade surpluses as a mechanism to maintain full employment. The cost, to the U.S., was a deterioration in our industrial base and a willingness to absorb excess savings through the issuance of Treasury securities.
I am sympathetic to this argument; which is rooted in the Keynesian idea that the unemployment rate in a market economy is not unique. In my own work I have formalized that idea by providing a theoretical explanation of how ANY unemployment rate can persist permanently if private sentiment is insufficient to generate the demand needed to utilize the unemployed resources: There is a persistent failure of Sayâs Law. Here is a link to the seminal piece which explains why private agents cannot benefit from a socially inefficient outcome:
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Johnâs explanation for global imbalances will be dismissed by many mainstream economists because it is inconsistent with New Keynesian models which see unemployment â if it exists at all â as a temporary deviation from a natural rate of unemployment ⊠an idea known as the natural rate hypothesis (NRH). The NRH is a reemergence of classical ideas that date back to David Hume and it has little or no relationship to the Keynes of the General Theory. The argument that surplus countries NEED external sources of demand to maintain high employment does not make sense in any version of the neoclassical or New Keynesian economic model. It does, IMO, make sense in the real world.
It is tempting to dismiss the idea of deficient demand with the observation that multiple equilibrium unemployment rates are inconsistent with the observation of economic growth. But the mechanisms that generate growth in macro models are distinct from the mechanisms that generate unemployment and it is perfectly possible to combine multiple equilibrium unemployment rates with multiple growth paths ( see for example, the work of @BenignoGianluca and @LucaFornaro3, academic.oup.com/restud/article/85/3/1425/4587556?login=tâŠ)
There has not been, to my knowledge, much work that extends my explanation of multiple equilibrium unemployment rates to the international economy. Konstantin Platonovâs paper in the IJMF is a notable exception
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0261560624001505
But I have not seen a fully articulated version of @carneyâs argument in a multi country model that also endogenously accounts for growth. Carneyâs explanation of persistent global imbalances is, IMO, worth taking seriously.
@michaelxpettis @michaeljmcnair @carney @GitaGopinath @SteveMiran @dandolfa -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
John argues that Germany and Japan ran trade surpluses as a mechanism to maintain full employment. The cost, to the U.S., was a deterioration in our industrial base and a willingness to absorb excess savings through the issuance of Treasury securities.
I am sympathetic to this argument; which is rooted in the Keynesian idea that the unemployment rate in a market economy is not unique. In my own work I have formalized that idea by providing a theoretical explanation of how ANY unemployment rate can persist permanently if private sentiment is insufficient to generate the demand needed to utilize the unemployed resources: There is a persistent failure of Sayâs Law. Here is a link to the seminal piece which explains why private agents cannot benefit from a socially inefficient outcome:
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Johnâs explanation for global imbalances will be dismissed by many mainstream economists because it is inconsistent with New Keynesian models which see unemployment â if it exists at all â as a temporary deviation from a natural rate of unemployment ⊠an idea known as the natural rate hypothesis (NRH). The NRH is a reemergence of classical ideas that date back to David Hume and it has little or no relationship to the Keynes of the General Theory. The argument that surplus countries NEED external sources of demand to maintain high employment does not make sense in any version of the neoclassical or New Keynesian economic model. It does, IMO, make sense in the real world.
It is tempting to dismiss the idea of deficient demand with the observation that multiple equilibrium unemployment rates are inconsistent with the observation of economic growth. But the mechanisms that generate growth in macro models are distinct from the mechanisms that generate unemployment and it is perfectly possible to combine multiple equilibrium unemployment rates with multiple growth paths ( see for example, the work of @BenignoGianluca and @LucaFornaro3, academic.oup.com/restud/article/85/3/1425/4587556?login=tâŠ)
There has not been, to my knowledge, much work that extends my explanation of multiple equilibrium unemployment rates to the international economy. Konstantin Platonovâs paper in the IJMF is a notable exception
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0261560624001505
But I have not seen a fully articulated version of @carneyâs argument in a multi country model that also endogenously accounts for growth. Carneyâs explanation of persistent global imbalances is, IMO, worth taking seriously.
@michaelxpettis @michaeljmcnair @carney @GitaGopinath @SteveMiran @dandolfa -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Christian Matthes
@cmatthes_econ
(i) not used AI in over a year, or (ii) are not using the most advanced models. Either way, they are far behind the frontier and have little sense how fast these models are improving.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But that was under the gold standard
Hutontiber
@hutontiber
Britain was the world's reserved currency for 100 years without running current account deficits, quite a generous surpluses actually 3/..
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you @GitaGopinath for clarifying your critique of @michaelxpettis. This response from @michaeljmcnair restates Pettisâs argument clearly. Also read Pettisâs concurrence in his response.
Mainstream international economic theory is focused on balanced trade and has not devoted enough attention to the implications of persistent trade deficits that arise as a consequence of deliberate policy by surplus countries. The analogy with the gold standard is particularly apt but the analogy only goes so far since, under the dollar standard, the deficit country never runs out of the international store of wealth.
This explanation also helps understand why persistent US dollar government budget deficits have not been as inflationary as might have been expected: the dollars are being accumulated by savers in the rest of the world and are not â for now â- leading to increased demand for US goods and services.
Michael McNair
@michaeljmcnair
I finally figured out why @GitaGopinath disagrees with @michaelxpettis on the reserve currency and current account deficit argument.
Theyâre not debating the same thing.
Economists too often conflate international currency and reserve currency (net settlement of imbalances, accumulation of net claims). They arenât the same thing.
When Gita says reserve currency she is mostly talking about the international currency roleâŠthe plumbing of global trade and finance (invoicing, settlement, etc). And on that, sheâs right. World trade can grow with balanced flows, and global demand for safe dollar assets can show up in gross holdings without mechanically forcing a net US current account deficit.
But thatâs not what Pettis is talking about. Heâs talking about the reserve currency role. Thatâs not what unit we invoice in. Itâs the asset other countries save in and accumulate net claims on, the place surplus countries park excess savings.
That is a net concept.
If a country runs a current account surplus, it is acquiring net claims on the rest of the world. Those net claims have to land somewhere. Someone has to be the mirror image net debtor. In the modern system, the US has been the residual absorber bc its been the only one big enough and willing to keep its capital account wide open and allow unlimited accumulation of its financial assets.
Pettis isnât arguing the world needs gross dollar liquidity, therefore the US must run deficits. Heâs saying that surplus country policies suppress domestic demand relative to production, which forces them to export savings on a net basis, and those net savings end up as net claims on the US, forcing a corresponding US current account deficit.
The best analogy is the gold standard. What mattered wasnât that everyone used gold in everyday transactions. What mattered was that gold settled net claims. Countries with persistent deficits lost gold and the surplus countries accumulated gold. Gold was the reserve asset precisely bc it was how the system settled the net position.
Same today. Gross flows matter for transmission, but reserve status is ultimately about where net claims accumulate.
Another important point of clarity is that Pettis isnât saying the reserve currency issuer always has to run a current acct deficit. Reserve currency status means you have to tolerate your external balance being set by the needs of the rest of the world, not what your domestic economy requires. And the sign can flip across regimes. Like in the 1950s when Europe was rebuilding after the war and needed US capital to fund its investment needs, so the US ran a current account surplus. But the point is that the reserve issuer is the residual adjuster. So Pettisâ point is that in the current environment, where the RoW generates excess savings, the has US to run a current account deficit.
Itâs possible for the dollarâs international role to grow without an ever rising US current account deficit. But itâs not possible for large parts of the world run persistent net surpluses and accumulate net claims, and nobody runs the mirror image net deficits.
Thatâs what Pettis is arguing. And itâs not the argument most people are responding to.
*side note:
Stablecoins are going to make the distinction bw international and reserve currency even more important bc the purpose of the GENIUS Act is to unbundle the two functions. They can keep the dollar dominant in global payments without requiring foreigners to hold dollar assets as a savings vehicle (zero yld reduce hoarding as savings). And itâs that second function that forces persistent US current account deficits. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But isnât private demand a big component?
Brad Setser
@Brad_Setser
no, but would would emphasie that is increase in demand is not constant over time (chart focuses on official demand for USD, not private demand for transaction balances). reserve growth and "reserve currency status" aren't synonyms imo
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Care to elaborate @GitaGopinath? The growth of world trade implies a growth in the demand for the dollar as a medium of exchange. That implies a US budget deficit to supply the increasing currency demand. What am I missing? @michaelxpettis
Gita Gopinath
@GitaGopinath
The view that the dollarâs reserve currency status is responsible for its deficits is a terribly flawed view.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
1/4
I am a little surprised by these comments from the governor of the PBoC. According to Yicai, yesterday he said that "the worldâs major deficit countries are the same as 40 years ago because of the inherent flaws in the international monetary system."
www.yicaiglobal.com/news/major-deficit-countries-havent-c⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Lawrence H. White
@lawrencehwhite1
In fact, peopleâs preferences are not among the dispersed knowledge that Mises and Hayek emphasized. It was entirely knowledge about least-cost production methods. Only by market competition can we discover them.
Daron Acemoglu
@DAcemogluMIT
Hayekâs argument offers an original and ingenious âcomputationalâ critique of central planning. His basic premise is that there is a huge amount of dispersed knowledge in society about a very large number of goods and services (e.g., peopleâs preferences).
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Absolutely right. Computational power is not enough. It does not reveal private knowledge about preferences and market conditions
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
Hayek's fundamental argument about information economics implies that central planning is impossible because the information required for economic activity is only manifested in the practice of economic activity by the agents.
Blocking private enterprise means blocking the process by which this information is manifested.
It's not a problem of the central planner lacking computational power, or even a problem of providing incentives in order to extract the information (i.e., it's not a problem of mechanism design).
His argument is that this information fundamentally does not exist in a form that can be articulated and communicated through, lets say, writing.
Lets consider an example: can the average person write down their utility function in a piece of paper and give the paper to the government in such a way that the central planning computer can replicate that person's consumption patterns over a period of lets say, a year? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Short answer: no and it hasnât been since the seminal
article was published in 1948. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
Is the Phillips curve useful to make sense of inflation?
A.W.H. Phillips first postulated a negative empirical correlation between inflation and the level of economic activity. Looking at inflation in 2021-24---up and down---versus measures of unemployment---roughly unchanged---shows little correlation. Has the Phillips curve failed, yet again? No, it did not.
Friedman and Phelps, almost 50 years ago, clarified that this correlation should only hold keeping expected inflation fixed. Almost every account of how firms choose prices or bargain wages with their workers predicts that expectations would show up in a Philips curve. Moreover, those models of behavior further add that increases in marginal costs (supply shocks) would further shift out this relation. The empirical Phillips curve has for many decades meant a negative relation between inflation and real activity, controlling for expected inflation and supply shocks.
The left figure below shows on the vertical axis inflation, after controlling for expected inflation---mean and disagreement from a household survey---and for supply shocks---gas prices and global supply pressures. The horizontal axis shows a measure of slack in the labor market---the log of the ratio of unemployment to job vacancies. The Phillips curve held nicely and steadily throughout.
A criticism of that figure is that its is looking in the rear view mirror: the measure of supply shocks and the measure of slack were developed in the last few years and the data has been revised. The right figure does instead an out-of sample exercise. Estimate a regression of inflation on (i) expected inflation, (ii) the difference between the unemployment rate and the CBO estimate of its non-cyclical component, and (iii) the PCE energy price index. Do it on data pre-pandemic: 1984Q1-2020Q1. Using that estimated equation, predict inflation in real time from then onwards using the data releases available at the time of the forecast. The Phillips curve was a pretty good predictor of inflation throughout.
The Phillips curve was stable during the inflation surge, and it predicted well the movements in inflation, with expectations playing a key role in those predictions.
Notes: it is important to include the right measure of expectations to understand inflation-activity dynamics at a business-cycle frequency: the short-horizon expectations of households and firms. (For instance, the long-horizon expectations from professionals, or the expectations from models in policy institutions, as in my previous two posts, are the wrong measure.)
Sources:
(i) Section 3 in Reis "Why Did Inflation Rise and Fall in 2021-24? Channels and Evidence from Expectations"
(ii) The simple exercise on the left figure is inspired on the analysis of Bernanke and Blanchard âWhat Caused the US Pandemic-Era Inflation?â
(iii) The simple exercise on the right figure is inspired on @jadhazell "Comment" in the NBER macro annual 2025, which in turn built on Beaudry, Hou, and Portier "The Dominant Role of Expectations and Broad-Based Supply Shocks in Driving Inflation"
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Typo there ⊠1958 not 1948
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Very sad to see that Chris Sims is no longer with us. He was a huge influence on multiple generations of macroeconomists. I learned so much from Chris. He will be sorely missed.
Markus K. Brunnermeier
@MarkusEconomist
R.I.P. Christopher Sims (21 Oct. 1942 - 14 March 2026)
- a giant in macroeconomics and one of the finest human beings I have ever met - -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you @UoS_Economics for the invitation. It was a pleasure to spend time with such a great group of macroeconomists and to learn about the research that is taking place at The University of Southampton. @MikeHatcherEcon
UoS_Economics
@UoS_Economics
Great seminar yesterday by @farmerrf (@uniofwarwick & @UCLA) on âOverlapping Generations with Complete Marketsâ. Fascinating insights on incorporating realistic demographic structure into macroeconomic policy analysis in #olg models.#econtwitter #macro #researchseminar
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations Thomas @T_Hintermaier
Thomas Hintermaier
@T_Hintermaier
Very happy and grateful to have received a referee prize from @EJ_RES.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thus is a trenchant analysis from @JesusFerna7026 of the state of reporting that is characteristic not just of the @ft but much of mainstream media. MSM analysis is clouded by a bias â perhaps unconscious, perhaps not â that aims to change perceptions rather than to report on facts. This has become so pervasive that much of the public â including well educated elites â now get much of their news and analysis from X and from platforms like @TheFP that are relative newcomers to the scene.
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
On May 17, 2023, the @FT ran this headline:
âYanis Varoufakis is back â and he has a plan. The leftwing former Greek finance minister is making waves ahead of Sundayâs elections.â
Inside the article, one could read:
âBut although Greece has begun to put the economic woes of the past decade behind it, the appeal of political radicalism of the sort Varoufakis represents endures, especially among the young. And this is something the next government cannot afford to ignore.â
www.ft.com/content/f3f12866-8476-4367-a74f-e5039f39c16c
Now consider what happened four days later. In the election, Varoufakisâ party, MeRA25, finished eighth, with 2.63% of the vote and zero seats.
Of course, getting an election wrong can happen to anyone. Forecasting politics is difficult. But after reading the article, I called several close friends who happen to be Greek and, well, economists. All of them told me that MeRA25 had no meaningful traction and that the reputable polls:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opinion_polling_for_the_May_2023_GrâŠ
were consistently pointing in that direction.
What surprised me was not that the article turned out to be wrong. What surprised me was the disconnect between the articleâs tone and the information publicly available at the time.
For a newspaper whose readership consists largely of business professionals who rely on accurate information to make decisions, this kind of misreading is unfortunate.
But more seriously, the article seems part of a broader pattern. For example, I wrote today a critical response to a recent @FT article on Spain and Pedro SĂĄnchez:
x.com/JesusFerna7026/status/2029674479215923351
Several readers pointed out similar problems in coverage of their own countries. In their view, the decline in standards at @FT over the last decade has been one of the more troubling developments in the European media landscape.
There is also a larger issue at play. If major newspapers of record develop a reputation for letting narrative outweigh evidence, public trust inevitably declines. Readers might reasonably wonder: if reporting can be this inaccurate in one case, where else might the same problem occur?
Experts and institutions have lost credibility in recent years for many reasons. But one key factor is the growing perception that analysis often reflects preferences more than evidence.
What surprises me is how little awareness there seems to be of the extent of the damage this causes. And I say all this precisely because institutions like the FT matter too much to let their standards slip.
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
I am consistently struck by how poor the coverage of Spain is in much of the English-speaking media, but your piece reaches a new low in terms of failing to meet even the most basic standards of objectivity.
Instead of informing an international readership with accuracy and balance, the article appears driven by narrow ideological preferences. That does a disservice to both your readers and the standards of serious journalism.
It is deeply disappointing. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is dead on.
John A. List
@Econ_4_Everyone
When AI first arrived on the scene, I worried it would make economists, or even critical thinkers more broadly, less valuable. In my travels in the past 6 months to work with non-profits, for profits, and government agencies, I have observed how people are actually using AI. I have watched them fumble around with insights they clearly did not create themselves.
My fears are now assuaged. One observation is that AI can produce something that in some cases is very wrong and in others looks nearly right, but is not quite there. Even if in time AI improves to "nearly right" or "exactly right" every time, a second issue still arises: explaining the materials.
Explaining why an answer is almost correct but subtly off requires exactly the critical thinking skills that created the knowledge in the first place. Even explaining "exactly right" material takes critical thinking. I've watched smart people confidently present AI-generated material they clearly don't fully understand. The words sound right. But when someone pushes back just a little bit, the sand castle crumbles.
It is quite difficult to defend what you didn't build. This leads me to now make the optimistic case for human expertise. The value of deeply understanding something â of having built the knowledge yourself â hasn't diminished with AI. If anything, it's increased. The people who can tell the difference between "nearly right" and "right" are more valuable than ever. The people who can explain the subtle details about something that is exactly right are invaluable.
Creating knowledge still matters. Maybe now more than ever. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Sarah-Jane (SJ) Murray
@SJ_Murray
The modern university would do well to stop asking for more, at the expense of meaningful and impactful research.
Cosmos Archive
@cosmosarcive
Richard Feynman wrote 37 research papers during his career.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
All true. But that was this months version of Claude. Wait a few weeks.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
AI journal articles are a bigger risk to the career evaluation process than they are to the research process.
AI can produce articles comparable to those in many decent journals, but most of these articles are not that goodâneither the AI ones nor those in journals.
In the post, @causalinf uses Claude to write a shift-share paper. Regrettably, the publication success of shift-share papers far exceeds their real-world accuracy or reliability.
There is a whole class of methods like this, which are good for careers because they reliably produce good t-statistics and nice stories for editors and refereesâe.g. distance IVs, poorly identified structural models, diff-in-diff with few time periods, etc.
[hans_unpopular_opinion.gif]
It's not universally true, but for the most part, the class of papers that AI can rapidly reproduce were not adding all that much social value in the first place.
Flip through recent editions of the top econ journals and find the articles that you think are really correct and important. Very very few of those are in the category of "AI could have written this." Instead, they are good original ideas, creative (and often difficult) data collection, original solutions to real problems.
Maybe someday AI will produce these as well, but right now it's not even close. AI articles are mainly exposing the fact that a whole lot of econ research is formulaic and not that informative about the world.
Original work that says something new and important about the world will continue to stand out, at least for the time being. Maybe the AI slopcopalypse will force more researchers to do work with lasting value. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs a terrible idea. The QJE, as just one example, routinely desk rejects papers that end up in other top journals.
Kurt MIT-shock-man
@SorryToBeKurt
One obvious policy response to @causalinf concerns is to implement penalties for submissions of desk-rejected papers. ERC, other agencies implement rules like this. If you submit a proposal judged as of sufficiently low quality, you cannot submit again the next year. 1/n
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And this is all with AI as it stands in January 2026. Wait until the end of the year with a couple more generations. I am already learning things I did not know about a subject I have studied for fifty years. As of now I am in control of the research process because AI lacks direction. I do not know how long that will last.
Antonio Mele
@antoniomele101
Probably everyone, not just journal editors...
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Is it your claim Brian, that it is not possible to write down an internally coherent model in which a tariff results in a change in the wage rental ratio that benefits US residents whose income comes primarily from labor? Iâm not claiming that a model of this class could not be challenged on empirical grounds â that is a harder questionâ but I do think an argument can be made that one could construct a model of this kind that is internally consistent.
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
This is the AI equivalent of what you see in a lot of policy writing, especially the pro tariff crowd: string together enough economics-sounding terms and it reads like an argument. But the math doesnât close.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
Steven N. Durlauf
@sndurlauf
This post by @NathanJRobinson is not correct and does his policy stances no favors.
1. Hayek's ideas about the role of prices in information aggregation way that decentralized systems can achieve mass desirable outcomes are profound ones, are widely admired by economists of all orientations. IMO this idea represents one of the great insights in economics.
Further, the import of Hayek's critique of socialism was recognized at the time *by socialists*. Oskar Lange's work on market socialism was meant to demonstrate how a socialist economy need not suffer this loss of information.
John Roemer's A Future for Socialism, 1994, takes Hayek's critiques extremely seriously. It also takes seriously various responses to Lange. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Erik Brynjolfsson
@erikbryn
Since my op-ed in the @FT was published on Monday (www.ft.com/content/4b51d0b4-bbfe-4f05-b50a-1d485d419dc5), thereâs been a growing debate about whether weâre beginning to see evidence that AI is boosting productivity.
First, let me be clear that the aggregate productivity data by itself is far from definitive. Even with the new revisions, there is certainly a lot of noise in US productivity numbers. No doubt lots of other factors are at work.
That said, my growing confidence that AI is powering higher productivity draws on evidence from a variety of sources:
1. The stunning capabilities of AI. If anything, I think the past decade of impressive improvements in machine learning and generative AI are still underrated. We are in the early stages of a massive economic transformation: digitaleconomy.stanford.edu/research-area/economics-of-trâŠ
2. A growing number of micro studies document double-digit productivity gains in specific applications. @alexolegimas has a great catalog in his blog post: aleximas.substack.com/p/what-is-the-impact-of-ai-on-produâŠ
3. My discussions with power users who use AI for coding, customer service, research and other applications, as well as more and more business executives, convince me that the facts on the ground are (finally) changing.
4. Data from our Canaries in the Coal Mine paper show employment changes in occupations most affected by AI: digitaleconomy.stanford.edu/publication/canaries-in-the-câŠ
5. And now, inklings in the aggregate productivity data are also telling the same story.
These are all consistent with the hypothesis that AI is beginning to have a positive impact on productivity.
The FT put a more definitive headline on my recent piece than I would have liked, but my bet (longbets.org/868/) is that we're likely to see more and more evidence as time goes on, barring some other shocks (e.g. macro mismanagement, trade wars, etc).
As each quarter goes by and we see more data, I continue to update my views.
No doubt, I'm currently out of sync with a lot of mainstream economists on this topic, but thatâs ok by me. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Financial collapse makes everyone worse off. The policies I advocate to stabilize asset prices are designed to be Pareto improving without requiring redistribution to compensate losers.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@S_Surprenant I realize that as card a carrying neoclassical economist I'm not supposed to mention social class but the concept has a rich history dating back to Smith and Ricardo. It is a concept that has been buried by recent trade theory but which deserves a second look.
According to Fed data: the bottom 50% of US households own roughly 2.5% of total net worth. The top 50% hold the remaining 97.5%. 45% of adults lack three months of emergency savings. And that doesn't account for the unequal distribution of intellectual capital.
Yes, many workers own 401(k)s, and yes, sectoral composition matters, but modeling the economy as two groups, one of which relies predominantly on their labor income and the other of which relies predominantly on their capital income is not a bad first approximation.
Trade creates aggregate gains but concentrated losses for specific groups, often in specific occupations and specific regions. Those losses have been real and large.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Capital and labor are not owned by different social classes. Everyone has time which they use or rent. Also, people whose income is mostly based on wages buy equity for retirement.
The other important missing aspect here are sectors. It is not true that all sectors have the same exposure to trade liberalization. You cannot frame a house in Baltimore from Shangai (at least, you can't now). For those people, trade liberalization is cheaper inputs, not competition for their output. And the net effect on total output should be positive: they might even see an increase in demand for their services.
So, no, it's not all workers. You're not going to be able to sell a Marxist story where a handful of people are benefiting at everyone's else expense. It's almost certainly closer to a handful of people in specific occupations got screwed. And that might even only apply to a specific generation of them.
The government should not be organizing cartels, professor. If policy changes cause large losses to individuals, but generate huge gains, you may argue that these individuals should be compensared -- not just as a matter of fairness, but as a matter of making sure you have the political support required to make big changes to reap big benefits.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You have not responded @JustinWolfers to @carneyâs point about the implications of the Stolper-Samuelson theorem. Do you teach that to your Econ 101 students?
The whole debate is about the distributional effects of tariff policies in a world where capital and labor are owned by different social classes and where the status-quo is a world where China levies large distortionary tariffs and import controls on US goods. Do you deny that, in such a world, a US tariff levied on Chinese goods could raise real wages in the US? If so, which assumption of the 1941 Stolper-Samuelson paper do you take issue with.
Instead of addressing the content of the arguments of your interlocutors, you engage in ad hominem attacks. I for one, would prefer it if we could debate the issues. @bungarsargon @jamiesongreer
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
It's hard to believe that you could be the trade representative for a major power and not know that tariffs are regressive.
My econ 101 students know what the word regressive means, and that tariffs are regressive. Many could even cite studies on the subject. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you for linking this @jamesharrigan
Trade affects welfare through two channels. It changes the wage rental ratio as capital moves abroad -- the Stolper Samuelson effect -- and it changes relative prices. An example of this second channel is the fact that textiles and electronics became cheaper after the accession of China to the World Trade Organization (WTO). The paper you cite by Fajgelbaum and Khandelwal (FK) closes down the first channel and explicitly models the second.
It is undeniably true that many consumer goods became cheaper following the entry of China to the WTO. It is also undeniably true that communities throughout middle America were hollowed out through the loss of manufacturing jobs resulting in what Case and Deaton refer to as 'deaths of despair'.
FK find that -- as a percentage of their income -- poor people consume more of the goods that became cheaper through globalization. They conclude that poor people are better off through the relative price channel as a consequence of globalization. They are unable to address the question: did US workers benefit in net from globalization because they do not recognize that different social classes benefit differentially from trade. Like most modern neoclassical theory, their model does not recognize the concept of social class.
Here is a quote from the FK paper
"First, the endowment of the *SINGLE FACTOR OF PRODUCTION* varies across consumers, generating within-country inequality."
Since the Stolper-Samuelson theorem requires two factors of production, a paper that begins by negating the premise of the theorem -- that trade affects the owners of labor differently from the owners of capital -- cannot hope to answer the question: were American workers net losers from globalization? And it cannot hope to answer the question: will American workers benefit from the imposition of a tariff?
@carney @JustinWolfers @bungarsargon
James Harrigan
@jamesharrigan
Roger, you might find this paper of interest: academic.oup.com/qje/article/131/3/1113/2461162
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There are four relevant groups.
A. US workers
B. Foreign workers
C. US owners of physical and intellectual capital
D. Foreign owners of physical and intellectual capital
Economic theory (Stolper-Samuelson) makes the following broad predictions following the imposition of tariffs on foreign goods::
1. American elites (owners of physical and intellectual capital, owners of the mainstream media, university professors, journalists and politicians) will be worse off.
2. American workers will be better off.
3. Starting from a world with no distortions: Americans as a whole would be worse off following the imposition of a tariff.
⊠But: Given that we are starting from a second best world with existing distortions it is not even clear that Americans as a whole will be worse off.
Tariffs do not cause inflation. Deficits cause inflation. Tariffs alter relative prices.
So my question to you @davidharsanyi is: who do you think will pay and why?
David Harsanyi
@davidharsanyi
First foreigners were going to pay tariffs. Now US companies are just magically eating the costs of tariffs. Where does she think that cost is displaced? In fewer jobs. In less pay. In smaller investments. In the end consumers and/or workers pay.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Tim Duy
@TimDuy
Moreover, China used industrial and exchange rate policy to undermine the spirit of free trade and aggravated the harm to US manufacturing. But donât underestimate the challenge of reversing that harm given the off shoring of so much of the industrial supply chain.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Stolper-Samuelson theorem
www.jstor.org/stable/2967638?saml_data=eyJpbnN0aXR1dGlvbkâŠ
explains much of what has happened to the US and China since 2001 when China entered the WTO. Chinese workers and US elites gained from trade. US workers were unambiguous losers.
Stolper and Samuelson were at pains to point out that although American workers might be harmed by trade â Americans as a whole would benefit. They concluded in favor of free trade because âthe winners can always compensate the losersâ.
Here is the relevant passage from their 1941 article
â⊠the harm which free trade inflicts upon one factor of production is necessarily less than the gain to the other. Hence, it is always possible to bribe the suffering factor by subsidy or other redistributive devices so as to leave all factors better off as a result of trade.â
@carney @bungarsargon
The economists who currently oppose Trumpâs trade policies, have been unambiguous winners from globalization. The same can not be said of the American working class whose lives have been upended by the hollowing out of the manufacturing base. @PIIE @JustinWolfers -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If you are right @DrJStrategy, and I think you are, the smart strategy is to invest in US equities.
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
For the record.
Wall Streetâs Keynesian Blindness to Trumpâs SupplyâSide Revolution.
Wall Street has the story wrong. The US is growing at 4 per cent, powered by a capex boom and an explicit attempt to rebuild the countryâs productive base. Yet the dominant narrative still treats this as a tired, lateâcycle surge destined to end in recession and a weaker dollar. Thatâs why money is rushing into utilities and staples at 50 times earnings, while AI and software are being dumped indiscriminately.
What investors have missed is the TrumpâBessent project: to use productive capital, bank deregulation and supplyâside economics to deliver strong, nonâinflationary growth. This is not another sugarâhigh stimulus. It is an effort to raise potential output and shift the structure of the economy.
Look at positioning and the verdict is obvious. The rush into gold, the historic underweight in the dollar, the wholesale rejection of AIâlinked equities â all express the same view: Trump and Bessent will fail. Markets are behaving as if the only possible outcomes are inflation, crisis or both.
This is what happens when an industry dominated intellectually by Democrats and Keynesians keeps reaching for the same demandâside playbook. AI hype and Trumpian turbulence have undoubtedly exhausted investors. But fatigue is not a framework. The real question now is whether Wall Street can abandon its reflexive Keynesianism long enough to see that this may be the beginning of a new supplyâside era, not the classic late cycle trade. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You have not responded @JustinWolfers to @carneyâs point about the implications of the Stolper-Samuelson theorem. Do you teach that to your Econ 101 students?
The whole debate is about the distributional effects of tariff policies in a world where capital and labor are owned by different social classes and where the status-quo is a world where China levies large distortionary tariffs and import controls on US goods. Do you deny that, in such a world, a US tariff levied on Chinese goods could raise real wages in the US? If so, which assumption of the 1941 Stolper-Samuelson paper do you take issue with.
Instead of addressing the content of the arguments of your interlocutors, you engage in ad hominem attacks. I for one, would prefer it if we could debate the issues. @bungarsargon @jamiesongreer
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
It's hard to believe that you could be the trade representative for a major power and not know that tariffs are regressive.
My econ 101 students know what the word regressive means, and that tariffs are regressive. Many could even cite studies on the subject. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đŻ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
For the record.
Wall Streetâs Keynesian Blindness to Trumpâs SupplyâSide Revolution.
Wall Street has the story wrong. The US is growing at 4 per cent, powered by a capex boom and an explicit attempt to rebuild the countryâs productive base. Yet the dominant narrative still treats this as a tired, lateâcycle surge destined to end in recession and a weaker dollar. Thatâs why money is rushing into utilities and staples at 50 times earnings, while AI and software are being dumped indiscriminately.
What investors have missed is the TrumpâBessent project: to use productive capital, bank deregulation and supplyâside economics to deliver strong, nonâinflationary growth. This is not another sugarâhigh stimulus. It is an effort to raise potential output and shift the structure of the economy.
Look at positioning and the verdict is obvious. The rush into gold, the historic underweight in the dollar, the wholesale rejection of AIâlinked equities â all express the same view: Trump and Bessent will fail. Markets are behaving as if the only possible outcomes are inflation, crisis or both.
This is what happens when an industry dominated intellectually by Democrats and Keynesians keeps reaching for the same demandâside playbook. AI hype and Trumpian turbulence have undoubtedly exhausted investors. But fatigue is not a framework. The real question now is whether Wall Street can abandon its reflexive Keynesianism long enough to see that this may be the beginning of a new supplyâside era, not the classic late cycle trade. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Kazimierz Stanczak
@Kazimierz280415
We can argue about many things, but StolperâSamuelson (1941) remains one of the sharpest â and most elegant â results in economics: austerely simple and unambiguous.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Stolper-Samuelson theorem
www.jstor.org/stable/2967638?saml_data=eyJpbnN0aXR1dGlvbkâŠ
explains much of what has happened to the US and China since 2001 when China entered the WTO. Chinese workers and US elites gained from trade. US workers were unambiguous losers.
Stolper and Samuelson were at pains to point out that although American workers might be harmed by trade â Americans as a whole would benefit. They concluded in favor of free trade because âthe winners can always compensate the losersâ.
Here is the relevant passage from their 1941 article
â⊠the harm which free trade inflicts upon one factor of production is necessarily less than the gain to the other. Hence, it is always possible to bribe the suffering factor by subsidy or other redistributive devices so as to leave all factors better off as a result of trade.â
@carney @bungarsargon
The economists who currently oppose Trumpâs trade policies, have been unambiguous winners from globalization. The same can not be said of the American working class whose lives have been upended by the hollowing out of the manufacturing base. @PIIE @JustinWolfers -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Andrew A. Michta
@andrewmichta
đ§”Iâm increasingly convinced as I listen to political discourse in the US that we are paying the price for the deconstruction of the American educational system. We âeducate,â or rather merely credential, people who lack the knowledge, rigor, language and discipline to reason.1/5
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece by @ScottSumnerTMI â written back 2021 â is an excellent summary of the how Friedmanâs ideas were incorporated into what is now called New Keynesianism.
My own view of this debate is that the N. American Keynesians conceded too much to Friedman and that while Friedman was correct about three of the four points that Summer identifies â he was wrong about the fourth. There is no evidence in favor of the Natural Rate Hypothesis. Friedman worked with a mental model in which equilibrium is unique and â approximately â optimal. Drop that assumption â and all else falls apart. This article explains why
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
@GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa @TeaGeeGeePea @clintballinger
TGGP
@TeaGeeGeePea
He made predictions in advance which didn't convince the American Keynesians initially even as some came true www.econlib.org/friedmans-smashing-success/ Monetary contraction working was more convincing
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well this just means that the AI authored paper should have been passed through refine before the final iteration
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
If you look at the report, you'll find considerably more than two.
Real algebra errors in the core setup of a paper with modeling are a very serious problem in macro - definitely enough reason to reject. Not because they're unfixable, but because good papers don't have them by submission time. Of course, one always has to check whether they're simply typos (as they tend to be in good human work), but in this case they are not.
I know that finding such errors helps editors reject slop because editors at top journals tell me that this happens.
Regarding the implicit question about whether Refine offers big-picture comments, I'm not sure whether you've looked at the report Ben linked - check out "Overall Feedback." -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Key word is 'yet'
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Sorry to shatter your dreams David, but @RefineInk begs to differ and took the scalpel to your slop in less than 30 mins đ
www.refine.ink/app/session/3533ee6f-da8c-4df2-bcbb-6e2608âŠ
Put differently: not quite there yet (as others have already said)
D. Yanagizawa-Drott
@YanagizawaD
I always dreamed of becoming a macroeconomist one day.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Sorry to shatter your dreams David, but @RefineInk begs to differ and took the scalpel to your slop in less than 30 mins đ
www.refine.ink/app/session/3533ee6f-da8c-4df2-bcbb-6e2608âŠ
Put differently: not quite there yet (as others have already said)
D. Yanagizawa-Drott
@YanagizawaD
I always dreamed of becoming a macroeconomist one day.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree completely
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
No, not at all. I absolutely do consider the exponential growth element. What I am doing is changing the frame and looking beyond first-order effects.
What I am saying is that AI cannot possibly be "growth inducing", regardless of how good it is at replicating people, or even outperforming people, if it is deployed in such a way that undermines the purpose of life itself or concentrates capital in the hands of only a few powerful people, or even itself.
It is a simple FACT that if the outcome of AI deployment is the vast destruction of high-quality middle-class lives and livelihoods, and the rise of precarious lifestyles or a dependency on handouts at a cost to agency... then it is by definition NOT growth-inducing.
The growth you are calculating is actually zero sum and thus not growth.
What it really amounts to is POWER growth. This is a completely different thing to positive-sum growth that serves humanity as a whole.
Rather than thinking of AI as an investment in productivity, we should think of it as an investment in power. Raw power. And who gets to benefit from it.
This is entirely counterintuitive which is why it is hurting so many analysts' brains. They do not understand the paradox of the current system. Chasing the bottom line in this context simply creates a race to the bottom, in which power only concentrates. NOT GOOD.
There is a way for AI to empower ALL humanity. But it doesn't involve corporates making vast lay offs. It involves corporates freeing up human employees to do better quality and meaningful work. Pausing the system and saying I don't need 15 bog standard research reports that nobody will read. I need one really good one, that I'm prepared to wait for a year for that great one to be delivered. It means valuing every point of human to human contact as a quality creation opportunity that improves your reputation in the system.
It's about shifting expectations regarding human output and contribution. Humans no longer have to compete on quantity. They can - hopefully - once again compete on quality.
If we do that, then power will not be concentrated. But that involves shifting our understanding of value and differentiating between "commoditised" output and "quality" output.
"Made by fallible but LOVING human" because the best things in life often emerge from fortuitous accidents linked to human error.
Reality is, if AI is just allowed to concentrate power, nobody wins. Not even AI. Ai needs constant and distributed human observer inputs to improve itself. IT would inevitably seek to fragment itself if it consolidated all power. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
No, not at all. I absolutely do consider the exponential growth element. What I am doing is changing the frame and looking beyond first-order effects.
What I am saying is that AI cannot possibly be "growth inducing", regardless of how good it is at replicating people, or even outperforming people, if it is deployed in such a way that undermines the purpose of life itself or concentrates capital in the hands of only a few powerful people, or even itself.
It is a simple FACT that if the outcome of AI deployment is the vast destruction of high-quality middle-class lives and livelihoods, and the rise of precarious lifestyles or a dependency on handouts at a cost to agency... then it is by definition NOT growth-inducing.
The growth you are calculating is actually zero sum and thus not growth.
What it really amounts to is POWER growth. This is a completely different thing to positive-sum growth that serves humanity as a whole.
Rather than thinking of AI as an investment in productivity, we should think of it as an investment in power. Raw power. And who gets to benefit from it.
This is entirely counterintuitive which is why it is hurting so many analysts' brains. They do not understand the paradox of the current system. Chasing the bottom line in this context simply creates a race to the bottom, in which power only concentrates. NOT GOOD.
There is a way for AI to empower ALL humanity. But it doesn't involve corporates making vast lay offs. It involves corporates freeing up human employees to do better quality and meaningful work. Pausing the system and saying I don't need 15 bog standard research reports that nobody will read. I need one really good one, that I'm prepared to wait for a year for that great one to be delivered. It means valuing every point of human to human contact as a quality creation opportunity that improves your reputation in the system.
It's about shifting expectations regarding human output and contribution. Humans no longer have to compete on quantity. They can - hopefully - once again compete on quality.
If we do that, then power will not be concentrated. But that involves shifting our understanding of value and differentiating between "commoditised" output and "quality" output.
"Made by fallible but LOVING human" because the best things in life often emerge from fortuitous accidents linked to human error.
Reality is, if AI is just allowed to concentrate power, nobody wins. Not even AI. Ai needs constant and distributed human observer inputs to improve itself. IT would inevitably seek to fragment itself if it consolidated all power. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I truly do not think you have grasped the implications of double exponential growth @izakaminska You are benchmarking performance by what AI could do last week. Give it a couple more iterations -- they are now happening every few months. Each iteration is like the move from an abacus to an iphone
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
I think this is broadly rubbish. Have you read AI content? Donât get me wrong, AI is super useful for processing large amounts of data. Has seriously revolutionised my ability to process transcripts.
But I for one can immediately tell when someone has just plopped their ideas into AI and asked it to generate a text or an analysis. There is a weird synthetic tone to it. The language is devoid of character. It makes it difficult to read to the bottom. And I sometimes wonder if the author himself has even read everything theyâre putting out.
It is also untrustworthy. I appreciate itâs getting better and better and there are fewer hallucinations. But it is also possible that it has just become better at disguising its lies and fabrications. I wouldnât be at all surprised if a number of major facts that were totally made up by AI have now been absorbed into the media complex as truth because of this effect.
The ant mill risk is very real. And when it hits producers of source data, it will open the door to total disreality. We already canât agree on major phenomena being real or fake. We already canât agree if x thing is good or bad. If we all stop observing and judging the data on a distributed basis ourselves, and just accept that what AI says is true, we will abandon the formation of consensus reality. The AIâs reality, based increasingly on the biases of its original source code, will dictate everything. There will be little capacity for course correction if we allow AI to lose the human reference rate. I predict left to its own devices it will inevitably collapse in on itself or its output will become so absurd as to be rendered completely useless.
Employers who lay off humans and replace them AI are the ones the stock market should be discriminating against. ESG style. Why? Because they are collapsing their own industry in the long run. They are exposing their sector to âant millâ collapse risk.
They are sending a signal that they are prepared to give up on human supervised quality control. Companies should care about this because their products will then no longer cater to the real desires and needs of people, but of AIâs perception of those needs. AI must serve humans, not humans AI, to avoid dystopia.
And for human supervised quality control to be a thing, humans need to be trained in the basic tasks the system is outsourcing to AI.
We all use calculators. But we also still teach kids mental arithmetic.
From now on company value should be linked to how committed a company is to maintaining human supervision, on the basis that companies that go for short term profits over long term sustainability (by sacking humans and replacing them with AI) are eventually going to become peddlers of stranded assets. That should create a market for well trained and competent, but also TRUSTWORTHY people. People who donât cut corners.
Also, I predict, companies devoid of people wonât be able to compete with start ups. When AI lowers the barrier to entry for starting businesses, start ups will grow in highly productive but human symbiotic ways.
I see this in my own business. AI has been very helpful at allowing me to do more with less. But the constraint on growth is now not enough me to supervise all the content I would like to put out. The only way I grow is by entrusting more high caliber human supervisors into my system who are aligned with my company mission, creative in complementary ways, and agree the mission adds value to human life.
The only way AI can compete is by promising it will assert my values better in my system than other humans I entrust. But I donât trust AI to be a better me. Not least because âmeâ is always changing as I adapt to new realities, other people and lessons learned.
There is no guarantee any AI doppleganger of me will make the same choices. It cannot have the full spectrum of my experiences to feed off unless it decides to operate in an exact parallel reality. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I asked Claude to review the paper produced by @YanagizawaD in conjunction with Claude code. The assessment: 15-25% chance of acceptance at a mid range journal. Read Claude's analysis below and, while reading, remember the following quote from @mattshumer_ 's article on the pace of AI development
x.com/mattshumer_/status/2021256989876109403
"And here's the thing to remember: if it even kind of works today, you can be almost certain that in six months it'll do it near perfectly. The trajectory only goes one direction."
Here is the bottom line from Claude's review of the paper
"For the journals the paper seems targeted atâJMCB, Journal of Monetary Economics, AEJ: Macro, JEEAâthe prospects are mixed but not hopeless, perhaps 15â25% in current form."
Then I asked: "If the paper had been authored by a graduate student would it have been of sufficient quality to constitute one of three essays in a PhD thesis at a top 20 US university"
The response was an unequivocal yes:
"Yes, I think it would, and fairly comfortably so. Let me explain why, while noting some caveats.
The standard for a dissertation chapter at a top-20 department is meaningfully lower than the standard for publication at the journals I was benchmarking against in my review. A dissertation committee is looking for evidence that the candidate can formulate an interesting question, engage seriously with the relevant literature, execute credible empirical and/or theoretical work, and interpret results with appropriate nuance. The committee isn't asking whether the paper would survive R&R at the AERâthey're asking whether it demonstrates the skills and judgment of someone ready for an assistant professor position.
This paper clears that bar on several dimensions. The question is well-motivated and connects to a first-order debate in macroeconomics. The empirical design is sensibleâlocal projections with established instruments, appropriate robustness checks, permutation inference to address the small-sample concern. The structural model is competently specified and calibrated, and the counterfactual decomposition adds value beyond what the reduced-form estimates alone deliver. The literature coverage is thorough and the paper is clearly written. A committee member would come away thinking the candidate understands modern applied macro methods and can execute them.
The weaknesses I flagged in my reviewâthe significance issues at long horizons, the permanent shock assumption, the ad hoc scarring dynamics ruleâare exactly the kinds of things a dissertation committee would push on during the defense, and they'd expect the candidate to have thoughtful responses. But these aren't fatal for a dissertation chapter. Committee members routinely sign off on chapters with known limitations, provided the candidate demonstrates awareness of them and the overall contribution is clear.
Where I'd qualify this is along two dimensions. First, at the very top departmentsâsay the top 5 or 6âexpectations for job market papers have risen dramatically, and this would be a weak job market paper. But as one of three chapters, with a stronger lead paper, it would be perfectly fine even at those places. Second, the fact that this was AI-generated means the committee wouldn't actually be observing the graduate student's research processâthe false starts, the debugging, the iterative engagement with advisors. A human-authored version of this paper would likely look messier in places but would also probably contain more moments of genuine economic insight in the interpretation.
The paper reads as highly competent but somewhat "safe" in its intellectual choices, which is actually not unusual for a non-lead dissertation chapter.
At departments ranked 10â20, this would be a solid chapter, possibly even strong enough to be the lead paper depending on the field and committee. At departments ranked 5â10, it's a comfortable non-lead chapter. At the very top, it works as a third chapter without difficulty. @darioperkins
D. Yanagizawa-Drott
@YanagizawaD
I always dreamed of becoming a macroeconomist one day.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Special thanks to my top new followers this week @tejus_sawjiani, @dlancashi
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is truly terrifying. Watch the whole X-post. And bookmark the date. Feb 12 2026. This post documents Claude Code writing an entire economics paper from ideation to completion in under 6 hours. @YanagizawaD
I have not read the paper. I do not know if it makes sense. But I would stake money on the bet that it could be published in a Journal.
By the end of the year, I would stake money on the bet that AI will be producing papers that can make it to top 5 Econ journals.
Time to reassess your career objectives.
D. Yanagizawa-Drott
@YanagizawaD
I always dreamed of becoming a macroeconomist one day.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Just telling the truth as I see it.
Observer456
@bewilderedgazer
You're very courageous in articulating this publicly, Roger. I can think of few other (if any) senior macro figures with a similar stellar publication record to their name who are willing to speak the truth about the policy reconfiguration that's taken place.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
That is sooo last week.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
We are currently in a strange spot in researchâparticularly quantitative and formal modelingâwhere AI can essentially one-shot a paper that looks very good.
But in every case Iâve seenâitâs not. Often the paper turns out to be quite bad. The problem is that it takes a while to verify why the paper is bad, you essentially have to do a mini referee report on it.
One method that seems to work is giving output to multiple models and have them referee each other. For quantitative work, ChatGPT 5.2 pro is still a beast, it will typically diagnose the issues (but is slow). Aside: giving output to multiple models to evaluate is good practice in general. Journals will likely have to adopt a similar system.
(As always, a disclaimer that all of this is changing fast) -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This view of whatâs happening in the labor market is, IMO, correct. The Trump policies are beneficial to the working class voters who supported him. Iâd be interested to hear the view of the @PIIE economists who have consistently taken an opposing position from that promoted by @bungarsargon and @carney
What I find hard to assimilate is that the Trump labor market policies are consistent with what most Democratic politicians had been consistently advocating for several decades: policies that had once been considered pro-Labor. The relocation of democrat priorities represents a tectonic shift in the political realm.
The idea that globalization will reduce the welfare of the working class is a concept that has a storied history; dating back to the Stolper-Samuelson theorem. Globalization has winners and losers. The US legacy media, the intellectual elites who control the universities, and the talking heads who dominate what passes for academic discourse are all winners from free trade and the importation of tens of millions of undocumented new immigrants. Members of the American working class are losers.
This is not to deny that free trade between nations can be Pareto improving. But the improvement demands that the winners within each country compensate the losers. And that has demonstrably not occurred.
President Trump is shouting loudly that the Emperor has no clothes. He has reinvented the world order and, like it or not Dorothy: we are not in Kansas anymore.
Batya Ungar-Sargon
@bungarsargon
Trump was elected to reverse our decline, to reverse the Democrats' entire economic paradigm in which you ship good jobs to China and import a serf caste to work here. Trumpâs theory is, if we deport illegal aliens and impose tariffs, companies will be forced to hire Americans, pay them well, and make stuff here.
This jobs report suggests Trumpâs theory of the case is right: -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There was not.
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
Is there anyone who was around at the time computers gained mass adoption?
Was there also academic moral panic then? Ie âoh no anyone can run a regression on CPS data now?â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And pursuant to @S_Surprenantâs kind shout-out ⊠you might take a look at this piece
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
which explains the Keynesian- monetarist debate. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Roger Farmer is probably the last person about whom you could say something like this.
Does it look like he does not understand New Keynesian models here:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0165188918âŠ
Be serious for a minute. And most of the profession in the US clearly ended up agreeing with Friedman more so than with old Keynesians. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Matt Shumer
@mattshumer_
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Good analysis. Iâd go further; Friedman won the debate with the North American Keynesians, (Solow, Samuelson and the rest of the Harvard MIT crowd) and everything we today call New Keynesian economics is actually a version of monetarism that dates back to David Hume.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Every single part of this, including the quote, is wrong.
The notion of equilibrium in economics does not refer to rest, but to a solution concept. The intersection of supply and demand is a partial equilibrium. What is unchanging here is the choices made by all parties involved: there are no more transactions to which both consumers and suppliers would agree. Similarly, in a game theoretic model, a Nash equilibrium is where best responses intersect. If you gave anyone the option of behaving differently given what others did, they would refuse.
This kind of idea long predates Keynes. Marshall described the intersection of supply and demand. Leon Walras introduced the idea of a general equilibrium (i.e., the equilibrium of supply and demand in all markets). And Cournot famously provided a model of a duopoly and he described their interaction using what we would today call a Nash equilibrium. That was in 1838 whereas Keynes published his General Theory in 1936.
Next, what we usually call Keynesianism isn't so much due to Keynes as much as it is about the IS-LM model Hicks and Hansen built in the late 30s and 40s to try to capture Keynes' ideas. Whether the model is faithful or not to Keynes, that's the thing that ended up organizing research in macro until the 1960s and 1970s. At the time, the Keynesians and the monetarists had a disagreement over whether you should privilege fiscal policy or monetary policy to stabilize economic activity... The Keynesians were not trying to "print more money." They were on the side of countercyclical deficit spending being a great idea.
Aaryan
@Aaryouz
Equilibrium is a nonsensical metric created by the pseudo scientific school of keynsianism to justify money printing
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Every single part of this, including the quote, is wrong.
The notion of equilibrium in economics does not refer to rest, but to a solution concept. The intersection of supply and demand is a partial equilibrium. What is unchanging here is the choices made by all parties involved: there are no more transactions to which both consumers and suppliers would agree. Similarly, in a game theoretic model, a Nash equilibrium is where best responses intersect. If you gave anyone the option of behaving differently given what others did, they would refuse.
This kind of idea long predates Keynes. Marshall described the intersection of supply and demand. Leon Walras introduced the idea of a general equilibrium (i.e., the equilibrium of supply and demand in all markets). And Cournot famously provided a model of a duopoly and he described their interaction using what we would today call a Nash equilibrium. That was in 1838 whereas Keynes published his General Theory in 1936.
Next, what we usually call Keynesianism isn't so much due to Keynes as much as it is about the IS-LM model Hicks and Hansen built in the late 30s and 40s to try to capture Keynes' ideas. Whether the model is faithful or not to Keynes, that's the thing that ended up organizing research in macro until the 1960s and 1970s. At the time, the Keynesians and the monetarists had a disagreement over whether you should privilege fiscal policy or monetary policy to stabilize economic activity... The Keynesians were not trying to "print more money." They were on the side of countercyclical deficit spending being a great idea.
Aaryan
@Aaryouz
Equilibrium is a nonsensical metric created by the pseudo scientific school of keynsianism to justify money printing
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Cool tasting menu for graduate students!
@mean_field_zane: check out the list of topics. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I will be teaching a series of five three-hour lectures on macroeconomics for second year Ph.D. students. The lectures will take place on Friday mornings for three hours at the University of Warwick. Here is a link to the topics I will cover.
www.rogerfarmer.com/ec-9c6-2026-term-2
If you are an economics graduate student in traveling distance to the University of Warwick and you are interested in attending my lectures, send me an email. There may be a limited number of spots for students to audit the course. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Tim Duy
@TimDuy
"Itâs hard to see how the structure of the university as we know it can survive the upheaval in the technology of knowledge creation that is unfolding before us."
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have a different take on this. AI has been with us a little over 2 years â ChatGPT was unveiled in November of 2023 and already the rate of productivity increase in consecutive releases has eclipsed anything we have seen in human history. New updates are now being written with little or no human intervention and by the end of 2026 we are told to expect new iterations monthly.
The article cited in this post quotes academics and students who are âcheatingâ by using AI to set tests, answer tests and grade tests. That critique is a bit like complaining that fine art students were cheating when they used photography to create images while their contemporaries were still learning to draw. Academia, as we once knew it, is dead.
I am now teaching my students how to use AI in their research but Iâm worried that my lectures â I start next week â may be outdated before I deliver them. Anyone who is not using AI to help write research papers, is hopelessly behind the curve. The entire process that once took years is now a matter of weeks. From ideation to literature review to writing up the idea to theorem checking. If your idea is empirical, data sets can be assembled in minutes. Functional computer code can be created from scratch with natural language prompts.
Itâs hard to see how the structure of the university as we know it can survive the upheaval in the technology of knowledge creation that is unfolding before us. We simply will not need the number of trained knowledge workers that are produced in science and engineering departments, business, finance, economics â you name it. Academics may still have a place to educate the elites who carry our culture so perhaps there is a future for a reimagined degree in civilization, history, philosophy and classics. I do not know what changes are coming. But coming they are. And soon. @JTasioulas
John Tasioulas
@JTasioulas
Counteracting the outsourcing to AI of cognitive functions by students (and academics) will require much greater emphasis on subjecting them to face to face interrogation. Unfortunately precisely this form of robust intellectual scrutiny has been marginalized in recent years by academics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Itai Sher
@itaisher
I am skeptical that, with advanced AI, the sole reason humans will be valuable is human touch (or any other simply statable category)
I think it's likely our insights will still be valuable, and the division of roles between AI and humans will be emergent and is hard to predict -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have a different take on this. AI has been with us a little over 2 years â ChatGPT was unveiled in November of 2023 and already the rate of productivity increase in consecutive releases has eclipsed anything we have seen in human history. New updates are now being written with little or no human intervention and by the end of 2026 we are told to expect new iterations monthly.
The article cited in this post quotes academics and students who are âcheatingâ by using AI to set tests, answer tests and grade tests. That critique is a bit like complaining that fine art students were cheating when they used photography to create images while their contemporaries were still learning to draw. Academia, as we once knew it, is dead.
I am now teaching my students how to use AI in their research but Iâm worried that my lectures â I start next week â may be outdated before I deliver them. Anyone who is not using AI to help write research papers, is hopelessly behind the curve. The entire process that once took years is now a matter of weeks. From ideation to literature review to writing up the idea to theorem checking. If your idea is empirical, data sets can be assembled in minutes. Functional computer code can be created from scratch with natural language prompts.
Itâs hard to see how the structure of the university as we know it can survive the upheaval in the technology of knowledge creation that is unfolding before us. We simply will not need the number of trained knowledge workers that are produced in science and engineering departments, business, finance, economics â you name it. Academics may still have a place to educate the elites who carry our culture so perhaps there is a future for a reimagined degree in civilization, history, philosophy and classics. I do not know what changes are coming. But coming they are. And soon. @JTasioulas
John Tasioulas
@JTasioulas
Counteracting the outsourcing to AI of cognitive functions by students (and academics) will require much greater emphasis on subjecting them to face to face interrogation. Unfortunately precisely this form of robust intellectual scrutiny has been marginalized in recent years by academics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Great point from @EmilVerner . If you want scale back banking supervision, don't expand deposit insurance. You want to incentivize more depositors to monitor their bankers if you scale back supervision.
Emil Verner
@EmilVerner
The senate is discussing expanding deposit insurance. At the same time, there is a push toward scaling back banking supervision and regulation in the US. This is a bad policy mix. A bit like creating federal flood insurance for all homeowners while relaxing zoning restrictions in flood zones. What could go wrong?
www.ft.com/content/3ec341d6-fe63-436e-a512-4d9aad678ce1?a⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
During the 2008 financial crisis, central banks purchased large quantities of risky securities paid for by creating commercial bank deposits at the Fed. The dividends and interest payments on those securities were returned to the Treasury for more than a decade and resulted in a significant revenue flow.
The Bank of England under Mervyn King was well aware that when the policy was eventually reversed, as is happening now, the seigniorage revenues would cease and, because the central bank is paying interest on deposits, the positive revenue flow to the Treasury would turn into a loss. For that reason, Mervyn negotiated a deal with the U.K. Treasury whereby the assets from QE were held in a wholly-owned subsidiary indemnified by the Treasury rather than on the Bankâs core balance sheet. That was an astute political move. If Ben Bernanke had done the same in the US we would not now be having a discussion about the Fed losing money.
I do agree however, with @bennsteil that some commentators and possibly some central bankers appear not to understand that the Fed is not a private institution. An implication is that there is no reason why a central bank should have positive net worth. Other central banks, such as the Bank of Israel, have operated with negative net worth for considerable periods of time. @BennSteil @redpillb0t -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Why?
E-40 and Econometrics
@econ_robinson
Anyone who wants to change things for the better will give it a shot.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Donât bother. No it isnât.
James Tapper
@JamesJohnTapper
Learn Modern Monetary Theory - itâs going to change everything we think we know and ultimately, everything for the better. #mmt #learnmmt #jobguarantee #fullemployment #humanprogress
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. Supply shocks can, at best, generate an increase in a price index that is temporary. Although a supply shock may not result a in price level jump; as is predicted by simple rational expectations (RE) theory, it does not contribute to inflation â defined as a persistent increase in the rate of change of prices. And minor changes to RE theory that allow slow adjustment of expectations, can easily accommodate a protracted period in which the price level shock is absorbed.
Friedmanâs dictum; that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon is, IMO, correct. And that, is how I interpret @kev_warshâs comment.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
If we take that statement literally, that is not what standard theory would say.
To clarify for non economists, modern macro theory explain business cycles as responses to unforeseen events we call "shocks." You need some way of identifying the shocks and estimating their effects to talk about causality. You have two options here:
1. A more empirical route where you estimate a structural VAR or a DFM and do a historical decomposition starting in 2020Q1;
2. A theoretical route where you estimate a DSGE and do a historical decomposition starting in 2020Q1
You can also, equivalently, think in terms of counterfactuals by setting subsets of shocks to 0.
Neither of those approaches will EVER say that supply shocks did not contribute to the post pandemic inflation surge. Based on the papers I have read on the topic, I suspect that the shocks on the demand side were more important for the US and that fiscal policy may have been the most important one, but that doesn't mean that the shocks on the supply side were not important.
Proper economics isn't very quotable. I have no idea if Warsh meant to completely exclude supply shocks from the explanation or if he merely meant to say the demand shocks are more important. That being said, the contribution of supply shocks in those papers isn't under 10%. From memory, the lowest number I have seen comes from @DavidBeckworth and Horan's paper -- something like 15% or so. But people usually find numbers closer to 40% (e.g., Giannone and Primiceri, 2024). In any event, it's not a trivial amount.
I am sure Kevin Warsh would probably not be quoted if he said something more accurate (and intelligent). It's a nice line to throw at people who are pre-disposes to blame the government, but that's not how research works. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If these predictions turn out to be correct, and they are plausible numbers given the potential for AI to take over large numbers of white-collar jobs, the social disruption that follows will be substantial.
Most previous technological advances have been complements to labor. The factory system replaced cottage industry but required manual labor to operate production lines. The IT revolution replaced office work but required trained technicians to program and analyze the output. The AI revolution will generate enormous productivity gains but it is hard to see a corresponding need for human beings to complement the machine input.
Perhaps I am simply not farsighted enough to imagine the occupational needs of the post AI revolution. But remember a free market economy may guarantee everyone a job â but it does not guarantee that the market wage of the unskilled will be sufficient sustain life. I fear that many of us are about to become unskilled. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Let me help you out. My interpretation: this is the "nominal exchange rate indeterminancy" problem in economics. See my 2014 talk on BTC www.stlouisfed.org/dialogue-with-the-fed/the-possibilitieâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with @ojblanchard1 that much of the value of crypto is what he would call a âbubbleâ; that is, an asset that is held for the same reasons that money is held in the overlapping generations model of money. I disagree that there are ANY assets that do not have a bubble component in their price.
My premise is that for a pure bubble asset to have value, the return to capital in the absence of the bubble would need to be less than the real rate of growth of the economy. Here is an example of a model that has this property:
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Any asset in fixed supply â gold and Bitcoin are examples â have value because because, in the absence of uncertainty, they offer a return equal to the rate of growth of the economy. But that value depends on the belief that future investors will continue to believe that the asset has value. Olivier calls that a bubble.
But if gold and crypto can serve as a bubble â even though they do not pay a dividend â so can the paper value of equity in any company that DOES pay a dividend. It follows from Olivierâs own observation that fluctuations in ALL asset valuations are susceptible to the whims of investors. I call this a self-fulfilling prophecy. Olivier calls it a bubble. @dandolfa @GeorgeSelgin
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
On Bitcoin, and what happened yesterday.
Some assets have a fundamental value, for example future dividends for stocks. Most investors buy them based on their assessment of fundamentals.
Some assets have no fundamental value, or at most a fuzzy one, for example Bitcoin. Most investors buy them on their hope of capital gains.
These investors are much more likely than stock investors to extrapolate past gains, move in herds, leading to extreme volatility. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Can we please, please stop treating the obsolete NBER chronology as if it were still definitive?
x.com/f_wintersberger/status/1787389565239546220
Claudia Sahm
@Claudia_Sahm
Question for Kevin Warshâs confirmation hearing.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This sounds right to me
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
For the record.
This has been my thesis for some time: the U.S. economy is undergoing a structural transformation, its foundation 19th century USA.
The breadth of the market is widening as capital increasingly rotates toward sectors anchored in Middle America and the nationâs productive core. No AI and Crypto are not dead. This shift reflects a broader realignment underway, catalyzed by Trump-era trade and industrial policies that have begun to rebuild the domestic capital base after decades of erosion driven by offshoringâmost notably to China.
The so-called âGreat Rotationâ is no longer a forward-looking hypothesis but a visible market phenomenon. Wall Street, as ever, has come to the realization late, adjusting only now to the implications of a genuine supply-side resurgence.
The reindustrialization of the United States is being priced into markets at last, reaffirming a dynamic that Iâve long argued would define the next phase of American economic leadership. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Noah Williams
@Bellmanequation
This guy is irrepressible.
Ergodocity economics is the answer to any question -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A good start would be the monograph âModels of Monetary Economiesâ, a conference volume edited by Kareken and Wallace. The Minneapolis Fed has free links to all the articles here: researchdatabase.minneapolisfed.org/collections/tx31qh93v
You can also buy it from Amazon for $108. đ© -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
OLG models are much richer than that
chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Yes, I get the time dated view. But I was referring to a single good in the standard sense. In Samuelsonâs original model it was âchocolateâ; many later OG models likewise involved what their authors called âa single perishable good,â as in Weilâs JEP review. 1/2
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
See my post about Neil Wallace and legal restrictions theory
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
I agree with the last. I am not convinced that the properties that make for a satisfactory medium of intertemporal exchange, esp. between âgenerations,â match those of actual monies. Hence non-i-bearing currency canât coexist w/ bonds in simple OLG models, though it does in fact.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
You need to stop thinking of the agents in the OLG model as belonging to "generations." They are infinitely-lived people that pop into and out of an economy for a short period of time. Model can be extended to permit them to move between "remote" locations, etc.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
To be honest I haven't given this much thought. But the more I do think about it, the more attractive it seems. Here are some random thoughts.
1. Allow Bitcoin to be used in payment of taxes.
2. Peg Bitcoin to the dollar at a fixed rate and allow full convertibility. The pegged rate need not be one that advantages current holders. The pegged rate is clearly crucial and would be similar to the question of how to peg to gold under the gold standard.
3. Note that if we think of Bitcoin as a OLG currency that its final price is completely indeterminate. But pegging it to the dollar at the 'wrong' final price would have disastrous consequences for the real economy.
4. The quantity of bitcoin in circulation is known and its rate of growth including its total final upper bound is completely predictable.
I would have thought this proposal would be favored by gold standard enthusiasts -- but I may be wrong.
I welcome discussions on the pros and cons of a convertible Bitcoin dollar from all and sundry.
If you are interested in the future of Bitcoin, please circulate this widely for discussion.
1. What are the pros and cons of a bitcoin standard as opposed to a gold standard?
2. Would a bitcoin standard be prone to financial crises?
3. A bitcoin standard seems similar to Friedman's suggestion to peg the rate of growth of the money supply. The difference is that the long-run rate of growth would be zero and that would lead to a predictable steady state deflation at the rate of growth of the real economy. Is that necessarily bad?
4. A Bitcoin standard would constrain the governments ability to operate sustained deficits. Is that a good thing?
5. A Bitcoin standard would have all the advantages of a central bank digital currency without givig the state the ability to control who can sell what to whom.
Lets discuss this on X.
@GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa @LouisWoodhill @phil_bel @Themountaingoat @danarunoff @LowBeta @LouisWoodhill @EricTrump @DonaldJTrumpJr @carney @federalreserve @bankofengland
Louis R Woodhill
@LouisWoodhill
Would you make the USD convertible into bitcoin or just have the Fed target a fixed market price?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Itâs worth pointing out that an argument can be made that the only differences between T-bills and dollar bills are caused by legal restrictions that prevent arbitrage in the issuance of small denomination liabilities. www.minneapolisfed.org/research/quarterly-review/a-legal-âŠ
The link is to Neil Wallace on the topic.
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
There are an infinite number of time-dated goods even in the first OLG models.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Bitcoin is a money and payment system operating in a flexible exchange rate regime. FX volatility is normal for unbacked currencies like bitcoin.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
As opposed to Marxist economics for example, which has engendered such enviable utopias of communal paradise as Maoâs China, Castroâs Cuba and Stalinâa Soviet Union
Cecilia Rikap
@CeciliaRikap
Please listen to Sam Bowles on economics & moral
Just one clarification: mainstream, #neoclassical #economics teaches this, not heterodox economists.
#pluralism is #needed: so that students have alternatives once they realise how much neoclassical econ destroys our societies -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
I actually disagree with this often stated claim. The olg structure embeds a lack of double coincidence of wants. With imperfect memory, the fiat object in the OLG model overcomes the memory problem, which is fundamentally how we think of moneyâs role.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But it would be possible to tie the US dollar to bitcoin in the same way that it was once tied to gold. The advantage, over the gold standard, would be that the quantity of bitcoin is predictable.
Louis R Woodhill
@LouisWoodhill
Bitcoin can never be used as money. I will revisit this when someone issues and sells 10-year bitcoin-denominated bonds.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Nevertheless his stats are absolete. And while the Fed has certainly evolved, the question is whether a diffetent mutation of the US currency and banking system ca. 1914 might have done better, as I have maintained. See www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/new-yorks-bank-âŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This chart is an excellent demonstration of the point I made in my recent posts on bitcoin and gold as OLG currencies. @GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa @LowBeta @danaronoff @lawrencehwhite1
Sentiment has moved away from digital currencies and into gold.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Too bad the US govât didnât start diversifying into Bitcoin last year, by trading gold for it directly or spending monetized gold reserve capital gains, as many pundits (including some economists) recommended. Just think how much closer weâd be to paying-off the federal debt!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Here is my take on @ole_b_petersâ Ergodicity Economics. To call it a paradox â which I did in the title of my blog â is an example of a considerable innate tendency for restraint.
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2020/5/6/the-peters-pâŠ
@ole_b_peters
Ole Peters
@ole_b_peters
One more reason to do economics without utility functions. Ergodicity economics does that, and it's far more successful than orthodox economics suggests is possible.
How?
Orthodox economics needs utility functions because it wants to work with expected value, a remnant of the enthusiasm for expected value from the time we discovered it, in the 17th century.
Ergodicity economics asks the ergodicity question: is expected value meaningful? Does it reflect what's likely to happen in the future? As Boltzmann taught us when he introduced ergodicity in the 1870s, that's often not the case. Ergodicity economics then replaces expected value with something more meaningful, e.g. a time average, and the need for the utility concept never arises.
Formally, utility rescues expected value in orthodox economics, but if we free ourselves from the wrong intuition that expected value necessarily reflects what one will typically experience, then we realize that we can throw away expectations. The need for utility and all its troublesome consequences vanishes. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have a different take on this. Government institutions, including central banks, are evolutionary experiments. Some are more successful than others. The American system of government is an example of a successful evolutionary experiment. The USSR is an example of one that failed.
Monetary institutions, including central banks, are also evolutionary experiments. Their operational rules are evolving slowly â and making mistakes along the way. But the overall direction has, to date, been positive. Here is a piece I wrote about the evolution of the Fed for the anniversary of Friedmanâs celebrated Presidential address to the AEA.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
I donât hate you, Rishi. But your stats are obsolete. See
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
"So this is a sign of, I think, the pathology of intellectual lifeâthat Marxism can persist." I wish I came up with that line. It's perfect.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I spoke with @LaulPatricia about Marxism:
One is: Whatâs remarkable is that Marxism has been tried. Now, of course, defenders of Marxism say it hasnât really been tried anywhere, but certainly the people who implemented it claimed they were implementing Marxism.
And this is a massive experimentâa global experimentâwith a very clear outcome. Namely, the Soviet Union was a disaster. The imposition of communism on Eastern Europe was a disaster. The imposition of communism in Venezuela was a disaster. The imposition of communism in Maoist China was a disaster. Disaster in terms of both poverty and oppression and genocide and stupid wars. So the world has told us what happens under communism, and itâs a sign of how out of touch intellectuals can be that there are still people who defend it despite the entire world giving a very clear-cut answer.
One more is: would you rather live in North Korea or South Korea? Would you rather live in the old East Germany or West Germany? We have an experimental group and a matched control group in terms of culture, language, and geography, and the answer is crystal clear. So this is a sign of, I think, the pathology of intellectual lifeâthat Marxism can persist.
The other is, you did call attention to one of the appeals of Marxism, though, and more generally of heavy, strong influence of government guided by intellectuals, which is that there are certain kinds of reforms that you can state as principles. You can articulate them verbally as propositionsâlike equality, human rights, democracyâbut thereâs other kinds of progress that take place in massive distributed networks of millions of people, none of whom implements some policy. But collectively, there is an order, an organization thatâs beneficial.
So that can happen organically through, for example, the development of a language. No one designed the English language. Itâs just hundreds of millions of English speakers. They coin new words. They forget old words. They try to make themselves clear. And we get the English language and the other 5,000 languages spoken on earth.
Likewise, a market economy is something where knowledge is distributed. You donât have a central planner deciding how many shoes of size 8 will be needed in a particular city, but rather information is conveyed by prices, which are adjusted according to supply and demand. And youâve got a distributed network of exchange of information that can result in an emergent benefit.
Now, intellectuals tend to hate that. They like rules of languageâof correct grammar. They like top-down economic planning. They like cultural change that satisfies particular ideals described by intellectuals. And so rival sources of organization, like commerce, like cultureâtraditional cultureâtend to be downplayed by intellectuals.
And this can be magnified by the fact that many dictatorships give a privileged role to intellectuals, which may be why, over the course of the 20th century, and probably continuing to the present, there has not been a dictator that has not had fans among intellectualsâincluding the mullahs and ayatollahs of Iran, but also the communist dictators: Mao and Castro, even Stalin in his day. And every other dictator has had, actually, often fawning praise from Western intellectuals.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Michael Bordo is always worth reading.
NBER
@nberpubs
Reassessing Milton Friedmanâs monetarism, showing how its core ideas persist in modern macro models and policy rules, and why monetary aggregates still matter as a cross-check against incipient high inflation, from Michael D. Bordo www.nber.org/papers/w34765
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
The argument Roger describes holds for a store of value, so not necessary for BTC to become an everyday medium of exchange.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Fahad Saleh
@cryptoeconprof
This is rare: an economist with a critical take on BTC which is actually sensible.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is an economic model of money â the overlapping generations model â that can explain how a token in limited supply can compete with gold or works of art as a speculative store of wealth. The examples that we know of that fulfill that role typically have some underlying alternative use value that makes them good candidates. Examples are precious metals, works of art and fine wines.
Unlike gold, works of art or fine wine, bitcoin does not have an alternative use value and @michaeljburryâs view â that bitcoin is not gaining traction as a medium of exchange â seems right to me. That does not bode well for its long term stability.
According to economic theory, a pure token can have value only as long as there is a collective belief in its value. Fluctuations in that belief are what generates volatility in its price.
Bitcoin is not a Ponzi scheme since it will not inevitably collapse and it could potentially maintain an average return equal to the average growth rate of the economy. And as long as bitcoin grows in popularity, it can maintain a much higher return for a limited time. But its ability to beat the market can last only as long as there are new aficionados moving their portfolios from other sources of wealth into the token. When that stops, or when the market loses confidence in the token, it can collapse overnight.
Collapse is not inevitable. But IMO, it is likely. @farrmacro @GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well yes, but thatâs the point. Bitcoin is a token whose value depends on its ability to effect inter generational transfers. In that role, it acts as one of many competing stores of value. Here is a link to the working paper version of an influential paper by Kareken and Wallace that models that idea explicitly
www.minneapolisfed.org/research/wp/wp153.pdf
Think of bitcoin and gold as two competing international currencies. The point of the Kareken and Wallace paper is that the exchange rate â the relative price of gold and bitcoin â is indeterminate and depends on the self-fulfilling beliefs of the market.
In the Kareken and Wallace article none of the currencies has any underlying value. But in practice for a token to become valued in the first place it must have some alternative use. Gold is used in industrial processes and as jewelery.. Bitcoin is currently used to effect transactions â largely in non-state sanctioned activities. Those alternative use values place a lower bound on the value of any individual token. But that lower bound, in the case of Bitcoin, could be VERY low.
The main point here is that the price of gold, or bitcoin, or any other token that draws its value not just from its underlying use values, but also from its role as a speculative store of wealth, is not pinned by market fundamentals. Its value is, in effect, a self-fulfilling prophecy.
www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-Self-fulfilling-Prophecies-âŠ
Philippe Bel
@phil_bel
"When that stops, or when the market loses confidence in the token, it can collapse overnight." Isn't that also true of fiat money, in OLG models?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@AlanReynoldsEcn cites three errors in Trumpâs @WSJ piece. One of these is a claim by Eric Boen in @reason magazine that the deficit increased under Trump: it did not decrease as he claims. That does not seem consistent with the attached chart. Yes, the trade deficit increased last month but the data are noisy and the trend since Trump took office is towards lower trade deficits.
When Trump first announced his trade policy, my X-feed was filled with predictions from the âeconomic expertsâ of imminent economic Armageddon. It is true that import prices have risen more than domestic prices: but that was the point: to switch demand to domestic producers and reshore US manufacturing. That appears to be happening. The tariffs have caused a relative price change. They are not responsible for inflation â that, as Milton Friedman taught us, is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.
Another argument that has surfaced recently is that the projections of economic collapse did not materialize because Trump did not follow through with them. That argument misses the fact that Trump views tariffs as a negotiating strategy to reshape the world order. You may not like the realignment: but it would be foolish to deny that it has occurred. @carney @SteveMiran @SecScottBessent
Alan Reynolds
@AlanReynoldsEcn
Dan Mitchell does a skilled and thorough job of . . .
Debunking Trumpâs Error-Filled WSJ Column
danieljmitchell.wordpress.com/2026/02/03/debunking-trumps⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is an economic model of money â the overlapping generations model â that can explain how a token in limited supply can compete with gold or works of art as a speculative store of wealth. The examples that we know of that fulfill that role typically have some underlying alternative use value that makes them good candidates. Examples are precious metals, works of art and fine wines.
Unlike gold, works of art or fine wine, bitcoin does not have an alternative use value and @michaeljburryâs view â that bitcoin is not gaining traction as a medium of exchange â seems right to me. That does not bode well for its long term stability.
According to economic theory, a pure token can have value only as long as there is a collective belief in its value. Fluctuations in that belief are what generates volatility in its price.
Bitcoin is not a Ponzi scheme since it will not inevitably collapse and it could potentially maintain an average return equal to the average growth rate of the economy. And as long as bitcoin grows in popularity, it can maintain a much higher return for a limited time. But its ability to beat the market can last only as long as there are new aficionados moving their portfolios from other sources of wealth into the token. When that stops, or when the market loses confidence in the token, it can collapse overnight.
Collapse is not inevitable. But IMO, it is likely. @farrmacro @GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Richard Farr
@farrmacro
Concur with @michaeljburry . Our BTC price target is 0.0. That's not just for shock factor. It's where the math takes us. It's not worked as a dollar hedge, rather it's just a speculative instrument correlated to the Nasdaq. It's not gaining any traction as medium of exchange. No serious central bank will ever own something where Michael Saylor controls the float. The miners (who are the network) are bleeding cash. It's horribly inefficient as a transaction processor and wastes tremendous amounts of energy. Nothing "green" about this "coin". We think it's a zero.
www.ibtimes.co.uk/michael-burry-warns-btc-crash-could-dee⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The FT piece that @BaldwinRE cites, graphs increases in electricity prices by state and party affiliation. I did a little digging: I asked grok to pull the level data for the same states. I fed the level data to ChatGPT and asked it to graph it as a bar chart. Here is the result. This took about five minutes. Yes: energy prices have gone up. But the takeaway for me is how much higher they are in democratic states. @FT @carney @izakaminska
Also note that on the FT chart the percentage increase in California prices is the smallest. But the level data reveal that the absolute increase for California was the largest. Thatâs because the base was already so high.
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
Affordability in swing statesđ€ @FT
đâIn Pennsylvania and Virginia .bills for residential clients have gone up about 15%â
đâboosting LNG exports .is already pushing up wholesale gas prices in the USâ
đâPrices of natural gas and electricity are so high that many manufacturers cannot produce products at a profit and are shutting down,â said Industrial Energy Consumers of America, a group representing manufacturersâ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Here are the data. @bennsteil @GeorgeSelgin IMO @SecScottBessent is correct ⊠Benn Steil is also technically correct. Form your own judgement: but I see a dramatic change since Trump took office in the direction of smaller trade deficits.
Benn Steil
@BennSteil
Also under President Trump's leadership, the U.S. trade deficit rose by $27.6 billion in November, to $56.8 billion - a 95% increase.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
@SecScottBessent
Under President Trumpâs leadership, the U.S. trade deficit fell to its lowest level since 2009 in October. @POTUSâ economic plan is working: Our partners are eliminating tariffs, lowering non-tariff barriers, driving exports higher and delivering growth for the American people. The naysayersâ doomsday scenarios continue to be disproven.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Interesting paper from David Andolfatto and Fernando Martin. And I agree with them. If we ask 30% of the labor force to stop working for a year and if we compensate them with nominal transfers then the price level must increase to allocate the reduced production to the existing population. But Iâm not so sure the shock to spending was temporary.
What does the model say if the shock to the deficit has a permanent component @dandolfa ? Are you linearizing around a steady state? If so, which one?
@greg_ip @Jon_Hartley_ @
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Jon, you (and many others) continue to portray the COVID inflation as an "outrageous mistake." But what is your counterfactual? Here is mine: davidandolfatto.substack.com/p/monetary-policy-and-the-grâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This critique, by @DrJStrategy of the blind application of âKeynesianâ economics by central banks is correct. I would go further; the Phillips curve â a doctrine that ties tight labor markets to inflation â has nothing to do with the Keynes of the General Theory. It has never worked and is fundamentally flawed ⊠an argument I made in 2013
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The Trump/Bessent policies of deregulation, promotion of energy independence and reshoring of US manufacturing industries are supply side policies designed to promote growth. And the early indication is that they are working.
Put this against the backdrop of the New Keynesian model that has been used by the army of Fed economists for more than four decades to interpret inflation and labor market data. The NK model has NO theory of economic growth: instead growth is an exogenous random variable that is assumed to be disconnected from tax policy, energy policy, deregulation and the range of policies designed to bring back manufacturing. This is a failed theory.
So how should we interpret the recent forecasts of high growth â see, for example, the Atlanta Fed nowcasts. Although these data suggest that growth is strong; there are indications that the unemployment rate is still too high ⊠see the recent speech by Fed Governor Chris Waller
www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/waller20260130a.htm
Waller argues, and I agree, that are good reasons to lower rates. Given the supply side surge from energy policy, deregulation, and the AI revolution, this will not, IMO, be inflationary.
That brings me to the arguments of Kevin Warsh, Trumpâs nominee for Fed Chair, that it is imperative to shrink the Fedâs balance sheet. Here I am not so sure. For some years now, the Fed has paid interest on overnight deposits. Interest rates are set by directly influencing the funds rate and â in the current regime â reserves and T-bills from the point of view of investors, are close substitutes. If the Fed sells off assets to drain reserves, there is a long way to go before the effects will be felt in the markets. The initial effect will be that commercial banks will swap reserves for T-bills. @DrJStrategy @carney
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
For the record.
President Trumpâs selfâstyled âRepublican New Dealâ marks a rupture with the midâcentury Keynesian consensus that has dominated central banking for nearly a century. It challenges the idea that technocrats at the Federal Reserve can fineâtune demand and rescue the economy every time asset prices wobble, and instead reâcenters production, work, and national capacity as the core of economic strategy.
Kevin Warshâs charge that the Fed âshould abandon the dogma that inflation is caused when the economy grows too much and workers get paid too muchâ goes straight at the priesthood of Phillipsâcurve Keynesianism: the reflexive view that tight labor markets are a pathology, and that the real economy is something to be cooled rather than cultivated.
Anyone who has taken a serious history of economic thought course knows that Keynes wrote The General Theory for a very specific use case: the catastrophic unemployment and demand collapse of the 1930s, when markets plainly failed to selfâcorrect. He did not write it as a universal operating system for every macroeconomic context from stagflation in the 1970s to supply shocks, to C-19, and geopolitical competition in 2026.
Even Keynes himself had misgivings about the âgeneralâ label, while his publisher had every incentive to oversell the book as a sweeping theory to move copies. The tragedy is that successive generations of central bankers and academic Keynesians treated that contingent Depressionâera playbook as a timeless catechism, long after its empirical foundations had crumbled.
Warshâs deeper critique is that the Fed has become a de facto fiscal and industrial policymaker, distorting price signals, inflating asset values, and privileging Wall Street over Main Street through repeated, discretionary interventions.
The âcommittee to save the worldâ era of Bernanke, Yellen, and Powell elevated the central bank into an unelected macroeconomic government, blurring every line between monetary, fiscal, and industrial policy while pretending this was neutral technocracy. That model is now colliding with a more Hamiltonian view: money and credit should serve productive, strategic investment, not perpetual assetâprice protection and demand management.
This is where the shift from Keynesian to supplyâside and Hamiltonian thought matters for central banking in 2026. A genuinely modern framework cannot be built on the assumption that growth and wage gains are inherently inflationary, or that every downturn demands another round of balanceâsheet experimentation.
It must accept that in an era of supply constraints, geopolitical fragmentation, and national industrial strategies, the central bankâs job is narrower but more demanding: sound money, stable credit, and respect for the distinction between monetary and fiscal power. Diversity of economic thought at the Fed is not some ideological heresy; it is the minimum requirement for intellectual honesty after the serial failures of one school of thought.
Keynesians will bristle at this, because it forces an uncomfortable admission: The General Theory is not âgeneralâ in 2026. It is a brilliant Depressionâera intervention that has been stretched far beyond its domain of validity, weaponized to justify an everâexpanding central bank that socializes downside risk while ossifying the real economy. The emerging paradigm says: enough.
The age of singleâschool macroeconomics sitting atop the Fed is over. Diversity of frameworks, Hamiltonian, supplyâside, and marketâoriented, will not weaken the institution; it is the only way to restore its legitimacy and reconnect monetary policy to the real, productive economy it is supposed to serve. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
James E. Thorne
@DrJStrategy
For the record.
President Trumpâs selfâstyled âRepublican New Dealâ marks a rupture with the midâcentury Keynesian consensus that has dominated central banking for nearly a century. It challenges the idea that technocrats at the Federal Reserve can fineâtune demand and rescue the economy every time asset prices wobble, and instead reâcenters production, work, and national capacity as the core of economic strategy.
Kevin Warshâs charge that the Fed âshould abandon the dogma that inflation is caused when the economy grows too much and workers get paid too muchâ goes straight at the priesthood of Phillipsâcurve Keynesianism: the reflexive view that tight labor markets are a pathology, and that the real economy is something to be cooled rather than cultivated.
Anyone who has taken a serious history of economic thought course knows that Keynes wrote The General Theory for a very specific use case: the catastrophic unemployment and demand collapse of the 1930s, when markets plainly failed to selfâcorrect. He did not write it as a universal operating system for every macroeconomic context from stagflation in the 1970s to supply shocks, to C-19, and geopolitical competition in 2026.
Even Keynes himself had misgivings about the âgeneralâ label, while his publisher had every incentive to oversell the book as a sweeping theory to move copies. The tragedy is that successive generations of central bankers and academic Keynesians treated that contingent Depressionâera playbook as a timeless catechism, long after its empirical foundations had crumbled.
Warshâs deeper critique is that the Fed has become a de facto fiscal and industrial policymaker, distorting price signals, inflating asset values, and privileging Wall Street over Main Street through repeated, discretionary interventions.
The âcommittee to save the worldâ era of Bernanke, Yellen, and Powell elevated the central bank into an unelected macroeconomic government, blurring every line between monetary, fiscal, and industrial policy while pretending this was neutral technocracy. That model is now colliding with a more Hamiltonian view: money and credit should serve productive, strategic investment, not perpetual assetâprice protection and demand management.
This is where the shift from Keynesian to supplyâside and Hamiltonian thought matters for central banking in 2026. A genuinely modern framework cannot be built on the assumption that growth and wage gains are inherently inflationary, or that every downturn demands another round of balanceâsheet experimentation.
It must accept that in an era of supply constraints, geopolitical fragmentation, and national industrial strategies, the central bankâs job is narrower but more demanding: sound money, stable credit, and respect for the distinction between monetary and fiscal power. Diversity of economic thought at the Fed is not some ideological heresy; it is the minimum requirement for intellectual honesty after the serial failures of one school of thought.
Keynesians will bristle at this, because it forces an uncomfortable admission: The General Theory is not âgeneralâ in 2026. It is a brilliant Depressionâera intervention that has been stretched far beyond its domain of validity, weaponized to justify an everâexpanding central bank that socializes downside risk while ossifying the real economy. The emerging paradigm says: enough.
The age of singleâschool macroeconomics sitting atop the Fed is over. Diversity of frameworks, Hamiltonian, supplyâside, and marketâoriented, will not weaken the institution; it is the only way to restore its legitimacy and reconnect monetary policy to the real, productive economy it is supposed to serve. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Brian Ferguson
@BrianFe2907351
Has anybody programmed Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics into them?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Marginal Revolution
@MargRev
The Bots are Awakening marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/01/the-botâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This post from @0x49fa98 is not a joke. If you have not already done so, check what is happening with personal assistant software; Clawdbot www.ibm.com/think/news/clawdbot-ai-agent-testing-limits-vâŠ
This is taking off in real time (late January 2026) and it is truly disturbing. The software provides the ability to create a personal assistant with access to; well, whatever you decide to give it access to. That includes email, calendar, credit cards messaging apps and bitcoin wallets. The PAs have memory and know and remember your personal preferences.
The scary part. This has been in existence for only a few weeks but already the PAs are communicating with each other, have set up their own chat rooms, created a religion and are discussing how humans are talking about them on social media. They can solve CAPTCHAs, they have access to bitcoin and credit cards and are capable of interacting with anything digital in the real world. At the risk of sounding sensationalist: this seems profoundly dangerous. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm teaching a small graduate class this Spring and the recent advances in AI have been transformational in the material I plan to teach. A good starting point is this webinar on Markus Academy @MarkusEconomist by @ben_golub youtu.be/ixyzgnmqAiU
This technology is truly transformational for the way we conduct research at all levels. If the technology continues to advance at this rate the last component â the human researcher guiding the project â will soon be redundant.
Writing in January of 2026, human input still guides aspects of the research. Given the current acceleration in AI capabilities; that will soon change. @__paleologo
Gappy (Giuseppe Paleologo)
@__paleologo
Here is a fun exercise. I asked Claude Code to write a simple introduction to the ExpectationâMaximization algorithm. I asked for only one clarification, told it to write the answer in LaTeX, and to compile it for me. Done in five minutes. I still need to proofread it. Normally I would edit heavilyâtaste, styleâand I would add a lot of examples. But as it stands, itâs actually much better than, say, the treatment in The Elements of Statistical Learning.
Anyway, here it isâjudge for yourself. I think this is genuinely cool. This is not cutting-edge material, but itâs the kind of thing people want to learn. And LLMs can organize it better, faster, and more interactively than literally going to your bookshelf to find the right reference, or skimming a Wikipedia page.
Hereâs another example. I couldnât quite remember the derivation of leave-one-out cross-validation for ridge regression. Claude did a solid job (hint: Woodbury), and then confirmed for me that LOOCV tracks the excess risk of ridge, citing the relevant paper. It probably saved me a full day. Iâll be teaching this, and that help really matters.
Now imagine doing this for all the middlebrow applied math in your life: Gibbs sampling, Cholesky decompositions, compressed sensing, and so on.
P.S.: and as you can tell from the telling 'â', I had ChatGPT proofread this post. Interesting times. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
I think its time to realize that the cultural arguments â not the wage argument â is the one that must most seriously be engaged with.
Kevin Grier, Florence Muhoza, and I have a paper coming at Journal of Comparative Economics on German Reunification that speaks exactly to that!
Why? Because German Reunification was adding millions of people who were culturally different (because of Soviet rule) to another society. There was no selection bias on ideas/beliefs due to migration. This fits the cultural compatibility argument affecting institutions in the host country. German reunification is an analogy for immigration shocks.
Using a measure of economic freedom to proxy institutions, we test (using SCM) whether there was a deterioration of economic freedom following Reunification.
We find a modest negative effect but its transitory (not significant after a few years).
What to make of this? Well, the shock was massive (added 25% to Germanyâs population, massive differences in political/cultural preferences, massive socio-economic disparity). If anything, this is where we ought to find massive permanent drops. We find something. But no where near as big as priors would suggest (see images)
The main point Kevin, Florence and I take out is that these big shocks may matter in some nations with poor institutions. We argue Germany largely resisted because it is a capitalist democracy with far more flexible markets and institutions that can accomodate shocks with far smaller tensions.
Borjas might like and dislike our results all at once. But it illustrates the need to engage seriously with this culture argument more seiously.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Borjas has responded to the JEL critique on his blog particularly regarding his work on the Mariel Bolift. I am not an expert in this area but I have followed Borjasâ work over the years, as well as that of his critics. Conflicting opinions appear to revolve around subtle differences in how to identify causal effects of observed correlations. Opinions hinge as much on priors as on data which is often the case in empirical work in which experimental results are impossible and identifying assumptions are subjective.
The concept that low-skilled immigrants might lower wages of American born low-skill workers through competition used to be a rallying cry of trade unions and of the political left. It is a peculiar feature of the shift of the Democrat party away from its traditional base in favor of educated coastal elites that it is now Trumpâs MAGA base that is arguing that we should restrict immigration because it lowers the wages of US workers.
A second point that was made by Borjas in his book âWe wanted workers
wwnorton.com/books/We-Wanted-Workers/
is that culture matters and that the immigration debate is not purely economic. It takes time to absorb new waves of immigrants. This point is particularly salient in the context of the current debate over the cultural background of immigrants to both the US and Europe.
Steven N. Durlauf
@sndurlauf
This article fails to make clear the reasons *why* Borjas' views on immigration are held by so few economists. David Card and Giovanni Peri @giov_peri wrote a great review of Borjas' graduate textbook Immigration Economics that illustrates the weaknesses of his positions. (In interests of transparency, I commissioned the review as Editor of the Journal of Economic Literature.)
pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jel.20151248
A second paper by Peri and Alessandro Caiumi and Peri
www.nber.org/papers/w32389
is the state of the art on labor market effects of immigrants, once again showing that Borjas' positions are inconsistent with the current knowledge frontier. This frontier has advanced because of the emergence of better empirical methodologies and the use of novel types of data. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Luca Fornaro
@LucaFornaro3
Interesting post on AI and technological unemployment. @mw_econ and I wrote a related paper a couple of years ago. In our model, advances in AI may cause unemployment due to weak demand, if not accompanied by expansionary fiscal and monetary policies.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
New post on whether advanced AI/AGI can lead to negative economic growth, focusing on the role of market demand.
Intuition is simple: if AI automates most jobs, who will be left to buy the products being producedâeven if they do become much cheaper? Will firms continue to invest in capital if they donât think there will be enough demand for their products?
This type of intuition can be found across influential books and in the popular press. So I spent some time writing down economic models to see what conditions are required for such demand collapse to occur.đ§” -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Borjas has responded to the JEL critique on his blog particularly regarding his work on the Mariel Bolift. I am not an expert in this area but I have followed Borjasâ work over the years, as well as that of his critics. Conflicting opinions appear to revolve around subtle differences in how to identify causal effects of observed correlations. Opinions hinge as much on priors as on data which is often the case in empirical work in which experimental results are impossible and identifying assumptions are subjective.
The concept that low-skilled immigrants might lower wages of American born low-skill workers through competition used to be a rallying cry of trade unions and of the political left. It is a peculiar feature of the shift of the Democrat party away from its traditional base in favor of educated coastal elites that it is now Trumpâs MAGA base that is arguing that we should restrict immigration because it lowers the wages of US workers.
A second point that was made by Borjas in his book âWe wanted workers
wwnorton.com/books/We-Wanted-Workers/
is that culture matters and that the immigration debate is not purely economic. It takes time to absorb new waves of immigrants. This point is particularly salient in the context of the current debate over the cultural background of immigrants to both the US and Europe.
Steven N. Durlauf
@sndurlauf
This article fails to make clear the reasons *why* Borjas' views on immigration are held by so few economists. David Card and Giovanni Peri @giov_peri wrote a great review of Borjas' graduate textbook Immigration Economics that illustrates the weaknesses of his positions. (In interests of transparency, I commissioned the review as Editor of the Journal of Economic Literature.)
pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jel.20151248
A second paper by Peri and Alessandro Caiumi and Peri
www.nber.org/papers/w32389
is the state of the art on labor market effects of immigrants, once again showing that Borjas' positions are inconsistent with the current knowledge frontier. This frontier has advanced because of the emergence of better empirical methodologies and the use of novel types of data. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I think itâs worse. Economist are facing secular stagnation @SoumayaKeynes âčïž
Soumaya Keynes
@SoumayaKeynes
Economists are facing a recession www.ft.com/content/eb080c14-e946-4806-ad66-81b2bb8c67ba
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The @AtlantaFed has upped its estimate of GDP growth to 5.4%. They have a pretty good track record. The Trump/Bessent economic plan to bring back manufacturing, promote energy independence and cut regulations, if allowed to continue, will IMO produce productivity gains that raise real wages substantially. The employment disruptions as we transition to an AI driven economy will, however, be dramatic. @PeterDiamandis
Peter H. Diamandis, MD
@PeterDiamandis
.@elonmusk is right again. he predicted 5x the GDP in the next 24 months and triple digit growth in 5 years.
Check this out: âOn January 8, 2026, the estimate for real GDP growth was effectively doubled, jumping from a projected 2.7% to a staggering 5.4%. This revision marks one of the most significant upward adjustments in the model's history, suggesting that the American economy is not merely avoiding a recession but is currently in the midst of a high-octane expansion. â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The passing of Roger Guesnerie yesterday is a big loss for us all. I remember him best for his contributions to the sunspot literature ⊠but there was much, much more. RIP Roger.
Paris School of Economics
@PSEinfo
It is with deep sadness that the Paris School of Economics community and the academic world have learned of the passing of Roger Guesnerie, its founding president.
His intellectual legacy will continue to inspire the academic community. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yep: All 24 for me. Also âŠ
25. coded with punch cards
26. cut and pasted a paper document using scissors and sticky tape to be retyped by an actual secretarial pool
27. Organized a seminar by writing letters through the post to invite speakers
Dave W
@daveweisberger
20 for me.
I guess I am older than I thought...
(for bonus points, we could have added:
21. Watched a Black and White Television
22. Used a slide rule
23. Read articles from Microfiche
24. Took tests created with a mimeograph -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âAnd if the AI boom ends âŠ..â
It wonât. It will only get bigger. This is not a bubble. It is a fundamental transformation of society that will eclipse the invention of the printing press, electrification, the development of the railways and the internet. Hang tight: this is not the same future shock your grandparents experienced. It is orders of magnitude more explosive.
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
What could possibly go wrong?
đAI related investment drove all of US GDP growth in the first half of 2025: đđđ© @FT
đ consumption of 10% richest Americans drove most of the consumption growth in 2025.
đThe same Americans own most of the high tech stock.
đ§And if the AI boom ends, so investment drops, so AI stock prices drop, so top 10% consumption drops, then what? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Pontus Rendahl
@pontus_rendahl
Scale up oral exam using LLMs!
The empire strikes back
Seth Bannon
@sethbannon
This is brilliant.
A professor noticed take home assignments coming back suspiciously good. Like McKinsey memos.
So he started cold calling the students asking why they made certain choices in their submissions. They couldn't explain even basic choices! Clear copy/past from LLMs.
So he fought AI with AI -- an oral final exam run by a voice agent and evaluated by a council of LLM graders.
> 36 students examined in 9 days
> ~25 min avg per exam
> $15 total allâin (â $0.42/student)
> Full transcripts, audit trail, and super actionable feedback
This works because you can paste into ChatGPT and copy the output, but you canât fake coherent, realâtime reasoning about your project when someone keeps drilling.
Interesting that the LLM grading committee actually converged after deliberation and exposed a teaching gap (A/B testing was the weak spot across the class).
Students using AI killed take home exams. Very clever to fight fire with fire and use AI to bring back oral exams. Perhaps not surprising, only 13% of students preferred the AI oral format đ
Oral exams used to be the gold standard in education but were replaced by more scalable written exams. With AI, oral exams are scalable again. Will be interesting to see how this changes education. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
International and Monetary Economics Network
@int_mon_econ
Very valuable!
"Benjamin Golub on Modern AI for Economics Research: An Overview of Tools" (Markusâ Academy organized by Markus Brunnermeier).
bcf.princeton.edu/events/benjamin-golub-on-modern-ai-for-âŠ
By the way, the tool refine.ink (co-founded by Ben Golub) is really cool! "Refine helps you check your paper before submission and avoid the kinds of avoidable mistakes that cause stress and lost time later." www.refine.ink -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Wishing you all a joyful holiday season and a wonderful New Year filled with happiness, health, peace and prosperity.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The question, for me, is will the AI boom generate the growth needed to shrink the debt and the deficit. My answer: I wouldnât bet against it. Iâd go further. Outgrowing the debt and â through higher tax revenues â outgrowing the deficit â is the most likely scenario. @ProfJAParker
Jonathan A. Parker
@ProfJAParker
Early in 2025, I saw a recession as more likely than not. Three things broke so that the economy slowed but never shrank.
1) Trump cost cutting failed, huge deficit 6% of GDP
2) AI+ boom in investment & stocks
3) The Fed was loose, tolerating inflation rate 1.5 times target -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes. But temporary equilibrium (TE) theory does not require those concepts. In TE theory there is a sequence of meetings. At each meeting a set of people meet. The set of people may be time varying.
People bring commodities to market and they bring financial contracts. They form expectations of what will happen at future meetings. They leave the market with a different set of commodities and a different set of financial contracts from the ones they entered with. An equilibrium concept explains how the contracts and commodities they leave with is related to the contracts and commodities they entered with.
Walrasian equilibrium â in which demands, supplies and prices are well defined â is one possible equilibrium concept. There are many other possibilities.
The Enlightened Examiner
@MrExaminer
More foundational question: isn't the way you define supply and demand already assume the existence of prices? I.e., demand/supply X quantity at (given) price.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Not really, I quite like Hickâs distinction between fix price and flex price markets. I dislike the way it has been implemented. For example, in the 1960âs there was an attempt to model temporary equilibrium (TE) theory with a concept of fix price equilibrium. The work of Benassy and DrĂšze is an example. That went nowhere, in part because of the Rational Expectations revolution which superseded it.
Itâs clear, to me, that the labor market is not well modeled as an auction market in which, at each market meeting, the wage equates demand and supply. But if one removes the concept of Walrasian equilibrium at each TE market meeting, one must replace it with something. And that something must explain, IMO, why rational actors do not take account of profit opportunities. Menu costs, quadratic price adjustment costs and/or Calvo pricing are not good resolutions.
In my own work I replace auction market clearing in the labor market with what I call âKeynesian search theoryâ. Keynesian Search theory CAN explain why there may be no profit opportunities in a market, but large and time-varying stocks of unsold inventory, aka involuntary unemployment. Classical search theory, as in the work of Diamond-Mortensen-Pissarides can explain stocks of unsold inventory, that is, high unemployment. It cannot easily account for the time variation in unemployment.
Could there be other commodities that are well modeled as a Keynesian search market? Absolutely. Housing is an example.
Here is a link to my work on Keynesian search equilibrium.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
@tblrj @IvanWerning
Thibault Laurentjoye
@tblrj
Would you say that all markets should be considered as exhibiting the same degree of price flexibility?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes: value and capital was a landmark because it introduced temporary equilibrium theory. But no, Keynes did not make rigid wages a cornerstone of his theory. And Hicksâs work on fixing price and flex price markets was also, IMO, a mis-step in the history of thought.
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
Sir John Hicks (1939) "Value and Capital" a landmark book in General Equilibrium and how to think of a dynamic economy.
Here is on sticky prices, not just wages... -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And I have a bridge to sell you
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
So let me get this straight James. You uploaded Keenâs 2020 ROKE paper to an AI (Grok?, ChatGpt? Claude?) and you asked it if Keenâs paper *refuted* my work and, lo and behold, the AI produced a glowing endorsement of what you wanted to hear â giving back to you the series of screenshots that you uploaded to X. Am I in the ballpark?
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No @sscisento, I do not have any idea how ridiculous that sounds. Maybe you would like to elaborate?
Perhaps you have a clear set of propositions that can be used to trace the effects of an interest rise through the economy.
Iâm not clear what you mean by the âactual economyâ. Are you suggesting a disaggregated model? If so Iâm all on board. Please elaborate by outlying a set of falsifiable statements, aka a âmodelâ that traces the effects of a change in the interest rate on your preferred set of disaggregated measurable empirical concepts.
I think that accounts for advice #1. Perhaps you would like to add subsequent pearls of wisdom in the form of advice #2, #3 or more?
sezzy
@ssciscento
âAll of these statements do not imply that we have a sound understanding of how monetary policy, in the form of interest control, influences the economy.â Do you have any idea how ridiculous that sounds? Advice # 1 - go study the actual economy instead of using aggregated data.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Indeed. These incentives are deeply perverse and will further contribute to the sclerosis of the UK economy.
Henric
@HenricCont
Not anymore
www.centreforsocialjustice.org.uk/newsroom/post-budget-re⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@JamesYo43532848 I agree with most of this, with the exception of the focus on debt. Households hold corporate debt and equity both directly and indirectly (through ownership of the liabilities of banks and other financial institutions). The value of these assets is largely determined by what their owners think they will be worth in the future. And that, in turn, depends on what future owners â some of whom are not yet alive â think they will be worth in their futures. I explored the connection between wealth and unemployment here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
And here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Russell Wadey
@russellwadey
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Steven Hail claims Iâm attacking a straw man.
When I started these conversations with MMTers @StevenHailAus, I might have conceded that the post below was straying into straw man territory. But sometimes pushing arguments to their logical conclusion is the only way to reveal the absurdity of the position one is faced with.
Recently, I have seen mainstream commentators arguing that the UK can spend its way out of the current deficit by printing more money. This is dangerous nonsense. More than nineteen percent of working age people are on universal credit and ten percent or more are collecting disability checks.
Some on the left are arguing that the UK should tax the rich. The following numbers come from a quick grok search but they are, I believe ballpark correct. In 2022 the UK had approximately 3 million high net worth individuals (those with liquid assets of at least ÂŁ1m). These people contribute 12â15% of all tax revenues and roughly 1% of them have left the UK over the last two years. By my own estimates â I have blogged about this here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/8/30/uk-evidenceâŠ
â the UK is already at the peak of the Laffer curve for income tax.
The UK has relentlessly pursued a net zero policy that has caused UK energy costs to be roughly twice (electricity) to one-and-a-half times (gas) higher than the U.S. despite the UK contribution to global emissions being minimal compared to China and India. The obvious solution, small nuclear reactors, is vigorously opposed by the greens, the very party that should be supporting a low emission alternative.
Enter the naive MMTer (some of whom have now infiltrated the mainstream media) arguing that all we need to do is spend our way out of this impending doom loop because the UK prints a sovereign currency. @ZackPolanski leader of the UK Greens has made this argument on the BBC, and in some recent polls the Greens now have more support in the UK than the Labour party. This is mercantilism at its worst and my parody is closer to reality than I would wish.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Wait! Iâve just had BRILLIANT insight. Letâs just give every UK resident a check for ÂŁ100,000 a year. Better still, letâs procure all the food and housing we need by purchasing a house and a yearâs food for every UK citizen at a fair price. Wait: why restrict it to citizens. Letâs make the policy available to anyone who wants to move to the UK. That beats austerity right?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Muted a few heterodox accounts today - could not take it anymore ⊠thereâs a limit to the time that should be spent trying to discern intellectual dishonesty from intellectual deficiency.
Onwards and upwards with orthodoxy! -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Wait! Iâve just had BRILLIANT insight. Letâs just give every UK resident a check for ÂŁ100,000 a year. Better still, letâs procure all the food and housing we need by purchasing a house and a yearâs food for every UK citizen at a fair price. Wait: why restrict it to citizens. Letâs make the policy available to anyone who wants to move to the UK. That beats austerity right?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well a large component of government expenditure is on defense procurement which is often, but not always, put out for competitive tender. But letâs skip that step and suppose that the War department goes to Northrop- Grumman and says, builds me 10 B2 spirit bombers and charge me 10$ a pop as opposed to the current going price of 2$b. Is that what you had in mind?
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
The 2025 paper shows this with minimal behavioral dynamics. The other paper (still under review) shows that the same conclusions still hold if you add optimizing microfoundations.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You are confusing two ideas. The first is that the dollar has value because the US government accepts it in lieu of tax obligations. That idea goes back to Georg Knapp, published in 1905 in German and I have no quarrel with it. But the fact that money is accepted in lieu of taxes says nothing about the âvalue of moneyâ which is a statement about the average level of prices in a monetary economy.
For that, the best explanations we have are in the tradition of the Quantity Theory (QT) of Money. The quantity theory was beautifully expressed by David Hume in his essay Of Money
davidhume.org/texts/pld/mo
I recommend you put it on your undergraduate reading list if you have not already done so. The QT was further elaborated upon by Alfred Marshall in Cambridge England and by Irving Fisher in the United States. An excellent source for this, and one which is accessible to undergraduates, is David Laidlerâs book The Demand for Money. Here is a free link.
archive.org/details/demandformoneyth00laid
In Fisherâs representation, the QT is stated in the form Mv = PT. Here, P is *the* price level, T is the volume of transactions per unit of time and M is a measure of the stock of money. For every definition of M, there is a different definition of v â defined as â *the* velocity of circulation.
The theory â at this point â has no content. It is a definition of v. The theory becomes concrete with the assertion that v is a function of a small number of variables, most notably, the opportunity cost of holding money. In a model with two assets â bonds which bear interest and money which does not â the opportunity cost of holding money is the interest rate on bonds.
The QT predicts that, if v is stable, the inflation rate will equal the rate of money growth minus the rate of growth of real GDP.
The accompanying figures, taken from my textbook âMacroeconomicsâ, show that for high inflation countries, that prediction holds up very well. In low inflation countries, growth and velocity move around quite a lot and those movements obscure the underlying relationships between money growth and inflation.
Since at least 1983, (and perhaps earlier) the Fed has explicitly targeted the interest rate and, as MMT theorists point out, money is endogenous. That does not in any way negate the fact that there is an identity connecting M,P,T and v, nor does it negate the fact that v is a (relatively) stable function of a small number of variables.
Changes in the technology, e.g. bitcoin, ATMs, changes in regulations; have all shifted v and for that reason, the demand for money function plays a secondary role in modern textbook treatments of the macroeconomy. It simply determines the operational details that the Fed must go through to control the interest rate. And when the Fed pays interest on money, the function becomes functionally irrelevant since money is held to the point of satiation.
All of these statements do not imply that we have a sound understanding of how monetary policy, in the form of interest control, influences the economy. Empirical analysis in the form of VARs (vector auto-regressions ) suggests that over short to medium horizons, a higher rate of interest is associated with lower real GDP. And at long horizons, high interest rates are associated with high inflation.
Fed economists believe that, to bring inflation under control, they must first raise interest rates to slow GDP growth and subsequently lower interest rates. The chain is supposed to work by lowering inflation expectations and it is based on a theory that inflation is inversely related to unemployment (the Phillips curve). I have no confidence in that theory for the reasons I explain here.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
I have even less confidence in the statements of professed MMT economists none of whom have - to my knowledge - written down a coherent theory in the form of a set of refutable propositions at the same degree of precision as, for example, the Smets-Wouters model.
FARZAD JAVIDANRAD
@javidanrad
Money is not valuable because it represents commodities. Money is valuable because the state issues it to settle obligations defined in its unit of account. This includes taxes, fines, and legal settlements, rents enforceable under contract. /1
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Fine. Now translate that into a small system of equations connecting observable measurable objects and explain how your MMT model differs from some other model of the macroeconomy. Volker Wieland has a project in Frankfurt, the Macro Modeling Data Base
www.macromodelbase.com
that will allow you to compare your theory with mainstream alternatives.
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
This is something that can be mathematically formalized, and that's what I've done in my own work. Here: rosa.uniroma1.it/rosa04/psl_quarterly_review/article/view⊠and here: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4234562
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The right question is, how do we design minimally invasive institutions within which markets are free to operate to promote human welfare?
My own view is that completely free capital markets are unable to consistently achieve Pareto Optimality because of the inability to write contracts with the unborn. Yet it is the beliefs of future members of society who determine the value of the investments made by current members.
Hayek referred to the âfatal conceitâ: by which he meant that private institutions evolve and that political interventions in market economies have unintended consequences. He was right. But what Hayek failed to stress â is that political institutions are themselves evolutionary and those that do not work, do not survive.
Milei English
@Milei_InEnglish
Keynesian Multiplier - The Perpetual Motion Machine of Economics (Lies My Economics Professor Told Me)
The numerous logical and Mathematical mistakes in the Keynesian Multiplier are explained.
âThe Keynesian multiplier is a kind of miracle of the multiplication of bread.â
Milei
According to Keynes counterfeiting increases the GDP
âKeyneâs multiplier is dedicated to corrupt and messianic thieves and politicians, and that is why every time they find a politician of the worst kind.â
Keynes did not provide any empirical evidence for his multiplier, which means this is not science itâs PROPAGANDA
youtu.be/ZFs-4eEZCW4
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
What does it mean for there to be âinsufficient moneyâ? MMT asserts that the government is a monopoly supplier of the tokens that it will accept in fulfillment of tax obligations. Thatâs a fine justification for the reason that the dollar is acceptable in exchange. But the number of tokens circulated by the government has nothing to do with the sufficiency, or insufficiency, of those tokens to satisfy the transaction needs of the economy. The demand for money is a demand for money denominated in units of commodities.
Friedman asserted, in his resuscitation of the Quantity Theory of Money, the existence of a stable relationship between the velocity of circulation, defined as the ratio of the dollar value of money income to *the* stock of money and a measure of the opportunity cost of holding money. Here is evidence for his assertion, taken from a piece I wrote in 2018 on the role of Financial Policy
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
There are two ways to increase the quantity of money. One is to double the number of tokens that are circulating at any point in time. The other is to halve the average price of commodities.
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
From a chartalist point of view, this could explain why deficient demand manifests as unemployment, but can't explain why demand is deficient more often than not. The chartalists point to the state monopoly on fiat money for that, with gov refusing to supply enough to meet demand
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Then they get upset when you say MMT is about printing money with no limits ⊠they say they understand inflation ⊠they just think itâs convenient never to mention it unless forced with a (logical) gun to their heads
Steven Hail
@StevenHailAus
They literally issue the currency. They do no need to borrow pounds to spend. They issue gilts to drain reserves, among other reasons. Your narrative is based on a misunderstanding of how monetary systems work. Please stop spreading nonsense, at least until you have investigated.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
See this piece for how to incorporate inflation
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Gabriel
@40yoap
There is no inflation in IS-LM đ«Ł
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
The first claim is valid enough. but it was WWII. not the New Deal, that dramatically reduced the US unemployment rate after 1939, when the US started producing materiel for European belligerants, and especially once the US itself began to mobilize.
Turgut ĂILGIN
@TCilgin78
The New Deal (and Second New Deal) brought about significant structural reforms. The entire industrial relations system was redesigned. Unemployment was tackled both by placing people in jobs and by providing financial support to the unemployed. In 1941, real GDP improved by 10%.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@GeorgeSelgin Care to comment George?
Turgut ĂILGIN
@TCilgin78
The New Deal (and Second New Deal) brought about significant structural reforms. The entire industrial relations system was redesigned. Unemployment was tackled both by placing people in jobs and by providing financial support to the unemployed. In 1941, real GDP improved by 10%.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
robert horrocks
@roberthorrocks
I think we need a new book on IS-LM⊠putting together Hicks plus Mundell Fleming and further extensions and ideas, perhaps within a historical narrativeâŠ. Include this, perhaps?
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2016/9/2/reinventing-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. In 1929 a massive destruction of stock market wealth was followed by a huge increase in the unemployment rate that peaked at 22% in 1933 and remained above 15% for a decade. We did not see evidence that prices or wages were unable to move freely. Instead, by 1933 both price and wages were 75% of their 1929 levels.
The reason for the assertion that wages and prices were sticky is that classical economic theory had no other explanation for persistent unemployment. Because we continued to observe high unemployment it must be that wages and or prices did not *move enough*. That is an unrefutable, and unscientific, proposition.
John L Davidson
@HHIDavidson
Prices donât adjust freely as we learned in 1929 with massive unemployment
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âDeficient demandâ, as used in the General Theory, does not depend on the characteristics of the medium of exchange. It requires two assumptions.
1. The decisions made by investors are independent from those made by savers.
2. The labor market may be in equilibrium (loosely defined as a state of rest) for a wide range of unemployment rates.
The reason that mainstream economists rejected the IS/LM model, and at the same time they rejected post Keynesian economics, is because no one had been able to explain point 2. I claim that my work DOES explain point 2.
As a consequence of points 1 and 2 Keynes claimed that the equivalence of saving and investment is achieved by adjustments to income (and employment) and not by the rate of interest.
Keynesâ thesis applies equally well to an economy with a commodity money. The MMT thesis that money is essential to an understanding of persistent unemployment (when it exists) is, in my opinion, false.
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
Demand for transactions isn't directly relevant per se IMO. By design, state money has a degree of non-substitutability with other fin. assets, because only state money can settle taxes. That means there's some component of the demand which is based on nominal tax obligations.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
They'd be better off with Patinkin's 'Money Interest and Prices' than Woodford's 'Interest and Prices'. The IS/LM logic is closer to the truth.
Tom Holden
@t_holden
In the FT, @gilliantett worries whether "Fed officials even know how they should tackle inflation in the first place?" She concludes that "there remains an intellectual hole at the heart of central banksâ thinking about inflation".
I don't think we need worry too much about the first concern. Virtually all central bankers would agree that if inflation is persistently above target, you should raise rates. (Of course there are some disagreements about some of the details.) Having the change in rates respond to inflation turns out to guarantee inflation determinacy under pretty weak conditions, so this gets the monetary theory approval stamp. It is also supported by empirical monetary economics. High frequency identified contractionary monetary shocks reduce inflation. So much so standard.
But it's certainly true that senior central bankers (and journalists) are generally pretty murky on the details of why they should raise rates in response to inflation. A half remembered undergrad textbook chapter on IS-LM/AS-AD is often the best you can hope for. To accommodate this, central bank staff economists explain the results of their New Keynesian models as if they were IS-LM. But the mechanisms of the NK model have almost nothing to do with their Old Keynesian equivalents. The staff spend so much time doing this that they end up distrusting their own models in favour of their accumulated "intuition" (essentially synonymous with IS-LM). Those most successful in this transformation are well placed for promotion to senior roles, and the cycle continues.
Perhaps it doesn't matter too much though if senior central bankers do not understand why they do what they do, so long as they keep broadly to the orthodoxy of their bank (an orthodoxy that the staff is designed to preserve). Nonetheless, central banks would probably benefit from mandatory "Interest and Prices" reading groups for board members! -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
What does it mean for there to be âinsufficient moneyâ? MMT asserts that the government is a monopoly supplier of the tokens that it will accept in fulfillment of tax obligations. Thatâs a fine justification for the reason that the dollar is acceptable in exchange. But the number of tokens circulated by the government has nothing to do with the sufficiency, or insufficiency, of those tokens to satisfy the transaction needs of the economy. The demand for money is a demand for money denominated in units of commodities.
Friedman asserted, in his resuscitation of the Quantity Theory of Money, the existence of a stable relationship between the velocity of circulation, defined as the ratio of the dollar value of money income to *the* stock of money and a measure of the opportunity cost of holding money. Here is evidence for his assertion, taken from a piece I wrote in 2018 on the role of Financial Policy
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
There are two ways to increase the quantity of money. One is to double the number of tokens that are circulating at any point in time. The other is to halve the average price of commodities.
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
From a chartalist point of view, this could explain why deficient demand manifests as unemployment, but can't explain why demand is deficient more often than not. The chartalists point to the state monopoly on fiat money for that, with gov refusing to supply enough to meet demand
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You CAN add search frictions to other markets. The housing market is a good example. Hicks made a distinction between fix-price markets and flex-price markets. That was a useful idea; but I would reframe the distinction as between auction markets and search markets.
If you follow this route, every market that is not cleared on the spot by equivalence of demand and supply leads to an additional degree of freedom that must be closed by an assumption to determine how the stock of unsold goods evolves over time.
Here is an example of a paper, Kaplan and Menzio, that uses search in two markets
static1.squarespace.com/static/5d69437d65a29d0001ae6520/tâŠ
CrĂnge Goes Here
@username_is_unq
"The answer I give is that the labor market is not an auction market. It is a search market." Doesn't this run into the Soviet LTV problem? In what sense it labor market special compared to other markets? Why can't I add search frictions between capital users and capital owners?
With New Monetarism, you can at least claim that money is special, if supply is cut in a credit crisis, then trading can't take place because not enough money is available. On the other hand, in high inflation environments, sellers want to add extra buffer that's a function of historical inflation, so then buyers must ration between the sellers, since not everyone's buffer can be satisfied because it's running ahead of inflation. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It would make little or no difference. The whole point of the Old Keynesian agenda is to explain how different levels of employment can be consistent with rational choice on the part of households and firms.
The answer I give is that the labor market is not an auction market. It is a search market. Different levels of aggregate demand allocate search intensity differently between the time of unemployed workers and the vacancy costs incurred by firms.
Unlike classical search theory (Diamond Mortensen Pissarides or DMT) Keynesian search theory does not pin down a unique bargaining weight. Instead, it allows the split of the surplus in a match to be determined endogenously by aggregate demand. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for your comments. But I find your acronyms a bit mystical and I had to ask Grok what some of them mean ⊠a bit like Iâm reading a Pentagon briefing.
And I teach Debreu-Sonnenschein- Mantel in my first year Ph.D. Class!
Iâm guessing that many of your readers have no idea what they mean. Could you make an effort to be transparent and not use so much jargon?
MosheEcon
@MosheEcon
Im convinced no one actually knows what the cambridge capital controversy was about beyond.
1) aggregate production functions bad.
2) demand for capital does not slope down because of reswitching.
ABCT is a whole other point. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But âFashionable Nonsenseâ is well argued and replete with examples that expose the emptiness of the writers that Sokal and Bricand parody. While I have many disagreements with New Keynesian economics, the work of the New Keynesians consists of logically constructed statements that are internally consistent and that make refutable claims about measurable features of the real world. That is not true of the postmodernists cited by Sokal and Bricand, which is precisely why postmodernism is nonsense. @realvolh @S_Surprenant
Victor Ortega
@realvolh
Yes I am referring only to the postmodernists vs Sokal rather than this other affair which is quite different. My point is precisely that to me many twitter attacks on postmodernism are constructed the same way that (e.g.) MMT aficionados attack mainstream econ. Poorly.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Seriously? The book is entitled Fashionable Nonsense for a reason. Postmodernism is, or was, fashionable. And it is: nonsense.
Victor Ortega
@realvolh
I agree that to discuss another academicâs field from the exterior, one should be well versed on the corresponding theory. And yet, you ridicule the postmodern continental tradition using as source a dishonest book and provide no serious engagement. How is this any different?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It seems that some of the readers of this post took my comments literally.
If youâd read the linked blog post youâd have seen that it was followed by the line
âAnd I have a bridge to sell youâ
⊠with a link to Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmontâs masterpiece âFashionable Nonsense: Postmodern Intellectualâsâ Abuse of Scienceâ
Here is the link
monoskop.org/images/5/53/Sokal_Alan_Bricmont_Jean_FashionâŠ
This book is essential reading for anyone seeking to understand the destruction of the universities that has taken place over the past three decades. The book came out more than 25 years ago. Since that date the assault on objective truth that was initiated by the French post modernists has overtaken not just the social sciences, but also physics, medicine and mathematics. More insidiously, it has entered high schools through the assault on departments of education and teaching colleges.
The claims of the post modernists notwithstanding â the concept of objective truth is essential to the progression of knowledge and the advancement of human welfare. And as my blog post (should) have made clear. We are all standing on the shoulders of giants. And yes â that does include Smith, Marx, Ricardo, Marshall, Pareto and Walras.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This paper by Paul Romer is excellent. It summarizes pretty much everything I have been criticizing about the current state of macroeconomics in my research papers, my books and in a series of X posts on methodology. But the fact that NK economics has its problems does not imply that MMT, marxist economics or some other brand of 'heterodox' economics is an improvement.
Here is an extract from a somewhat tongue-in-cheek piece I wrote in 2018 [Link at the end of this post].
"Howard [Reed] suggests that the classical economists, Smith, Ricardo and Marx, may perhaps have something valuable to contribute [to modern economics].
I disagree. Smith,  Ricardo and Marx were privileged members of the bourgeoisie who injected eighteenth and early nineteenth century moral values into economics. They were students of history, familiar with a western philosophical tradition stretching back to Plato and Aristotle, both of whom were European slave owners. Marx may have had some enlightened views on the role of class, but he foolishly tried to formalize his system using elementary mathematics.
No. I believe that our reconstruction must dismiss, not just the mistaken neoclassical ideas of Walras, Pareto and Marshall. To truly reconstruct economics as a relevant social science we must first tear down every part of the existing patriarchal structure which serves as a tool of the ruling elite to suppress the legitimate desires of freedom loving peoples throughout the world to receive their entitled share of global wealth. We must begin, instead, by studying Latour,  Derrida and Baudrillard.
Here is a link to the original piece...
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2018/4/14/standing-onâŠ
When I wrote that piece in 2018 I did not realize how far the 'long march through the institutions' had already progressed.
@JesusFerna7026 @dandolfa
Clint Ballinger
@clintballinger
"The trouble with macroeconomics is worse. I have observed more than three decades of intellectual regress."
paulromer.net/the-trouble-with-macro/WP-Trouble.pdf -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
While I realize that âontology-determined epistemologyâ is a well defined concept ⊠you would have a greater chance of persuading your readers if you were to write in simpler language.
Shahin Ashkiani
@shaahin_a
"the fact that NK economics has its problems does not imply that 'heterodox' economics is an improvement."
This is the issue.
NC economists donât care about reality.
They donât see the importance of starting from reality, of realism, or of an ontology-determined epistemology
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This paper by Paul Romer is excellent. It summarizes pretty much everything I have been criticizing about the current state of macroeconomics in my research papers, my books and in a series of X posts on methodology. But the fact that NK economics has its problems does not imply that MMT, marxist economics or some other brand of 'heterodox' economics is an improvement.
Here is an extract from a somewhat tongue-in-cheek piece I wrote in 2018 [Link at the end of this post].
"Howard [Reed] suggests that the classical economists, Smith, Ricardo and Marx, may perhaps have something valuable to contribute [to modern economics].
I disagree. Smith,  Ricardo and Marx were privileged members of the bourgeoisie who injected eighteenth and early nineteenth century moral values into economics. They were students of history, familiar with a western philosophical tradition stretching back to Plato and Aristotle, both of whom were European slave owners. Marx may have had some enlightened views on the role of class, but he foolishly tried to formalize his system using elementary mathematics.
No. I believe that our reconstruction must dismiss, not just the mistaken neoclassical ideas of Walras, Pareto and Marshall. To truly reconstruct economics as a relevant social science we must first tear down every part of the existing patriarchal structure which serves as a tool of the ruling elite to suppress the legitimate desires of freedom loving peoples throughout the world to receive their entitled share of global wealth. We must begin, instead, by studying Latour,  Derrida and Baudrillard.
Here is a link to the original piece...
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2018/4/14/standing-onâŠ
When I wrote that piece in 2018 I did not realize how far the 'long march through the institutions' had already progressed.
@JesusFerna7026 @dandolfa
Clint Ballinger
@clintballinger
"The trouble with macroeconomics is worse. I have observed more than three decades of intellectual regress."
paulromer.net/the-trouble-with-macro/WP-Trouble.pdf -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I am a fan of the literature on endogenous cycles, particularly Richard Goodwinâs work. But Goodwinâs model was mechanistic and did not account for people adapting their behavior in response to anticipated price signals.
To improve on that idea, I wrote a paper on nonlinear cycles when I was at Penn in the 1980s that used an overlapping generations model to generate cycles in a competitive economy
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Jean Michel Grandmont was visiting Penn at the time and he had just written his Econometrica paper on limit cycles in Overlapping Generations models.
ideas.repec.org/a/ecm/emetrp/v53y1985i5p995-1045.html
I was struggling with how to generate a limit cycle. Iâd talked to Peter Howitt and he told me that the only way to do it was with global methods. Peter, as it transpired, was wrong. Grandmont put me in touch with Jess Benhabib and he explained the Hopf Bifurcation theorem to me over the phone. [It is a beautiful theorem.] Using Jessâs input I computed the solution to the model I was working on, on a HP hand calculator.
Later that year Jean Michel ran a conference in Paris on non-linear cycles. The papers, including mine, were published in a special issue of the Journal of Economic Theory.
That conference introduced me to the literature on deterministic chaos through a paper by William aka (Buzz) Brock. In physics, itâs possible to carry out experiments that demonstrate that turbulence in fluid flows are better described by a deterministic chaotic model rather than a linear model hit by random shocks. In the talk he gave in Paris, Buzz convinced me â and most of the audience â that there are not enough data in economics to distinguish between a stable linear system hit by random shocks from a nonlinear model characterized by deterministic chaos.
I still have nothing against nonlinear cycle models â (and the Beaudry et. al. paper is a big advance ) â or even models of deterministic chaos. But Occamâs razor suggests that for most purposes, a stochastic linear model is a probably a good approximation. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This paper by Paul Romer is excellent. It summarizes pretty much everything I have been criticizing about the current state of macroeconomics in my research papers, my books and in a series of X posts on methodology. But the fact that NK economics has its problems does not imply that MMT, marxist economics or some other brand of 'heterodox' economics is an improvement.
Here is an extract from a somewhat tongue-in-cheek piece I wrote in 2018 [Link at the end of this post].
"Howard [Reed] suggests that the classical economists, Smith, Ricardo and Marx, may perhaps have something valuable to contribute [to modern economics].
I disagree. Smith,  Ricardo and Marx were privileged members of the bourgeoisie who injected eighteenth and early nineteenth century moral values into economics. They were students of history, familiar with a western philosophical tradition stretching back to Plato and Aristotle, both of whom were European slave owners. Marx may have had some enlightened views on the role of class, but he foolishly tried to formalize his system using elementary mathematics.
No. I believe that our reconstruction must dismiss, not just the mistaken neoclassical ideas of Walras, Pareto and Marshall. To truly reconstruct economics as a relevant social science we must first tear down every part of the existing patriarchal structure which serves as a tool of the ruling elite to suppress the legitimate desires of freedom loving peoples throughout the world to receive their entitled share of global wealth. We must begin, instead, by studying Latour,  Derrida and Baudrillard.
Here is a link to the original piece...
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2018/4/14/standing-onâŠ
When I wrote that piece in 2018 I did not realize how far the 'long march through the institutions' had already progressed.
@JesusFerna7026 @dandolfa
Clint Ballinger
@clintballinger
"The trouble with macroeconomics is worse. I have observed more than three decades of intellectual regress."
paulromer.net/the-trouble-with-macro/WP-Trouble.pdf -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Absolutely @dandolfa !
"In this summary we shall assume that the money-wage and other factor costs are constant per unit of labour employed. But this simplification, WITH WHICH WE SHALL DISPENSE LATER, is introduced solely to facilitate the exposition. (Keynes, General Theory 1936, p. 27). my emphasis"
(Quoted in www.rogerfarmer.com/s/The-importance-of-beliefs-in-shapinâŠ)
@FanTastischenDa @JesusFerna7026 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
Great points from @farmerrf
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It is perfectly possible to formulate MMT using the language of temporary equilibrium theory. One reason, perhaps, why that exercise has not yet been attempted is that it forces the modeler to make internally consistent statements about concepts they take for granted.
For example, Randall Wray in his treatise on MMT acknowledges that if the economy is at âfull employmentâ a government that consistently finances additional expenditure by money creation, will cause inflation. But he does not define full employment.
Where I agree with Randall Wray, is that under some circumstances money financed expenditure will increase employment. Where I disagree with Wray, is that increasing employment is always a social good. Unlike Randall, I have a fully articulated theory of what it means for an economy to be at full employment.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
MMT economists assert that the government does not need to balance its budget and that â under some circumstances â deficits can, and should be, financed by money creation. I agree. But how large should the deficit be? Is there an optimal size fo government debt? MMT has no answer to that question. Neoclassical economics does.
Peter Diamond in his 1965 paper, âNational Debt in a Neoclassical Growth Modelâ, showed that government debt can, under some circumstances, increase social welfare. The reason is that, even at full employment, the interest rate in a competitive economy can be less than the growth rate. And in that case, money or debt financed expenditure is costless.
@wbmosler Warren Mosler, in his seminal article on MMT, uses the analogy of a family whose parent issues tokens. If he had pushed that analogy further to recognize that generations overlap and trade with each other, he might have rediscovered Diamondâs work. Importantly, Peterâs work does not imply that government can or should increase the value of its liabilities without limit.
My reading of MMT critiques of neoclassical economics suggests that most of the critics, perhaps not all, have a very limited view of what is taught in graduate economics programs.
I have my own speculations about the nature of the quantum universe. But I do not share those thoughts on X because I have a very limited knowledge of what is taught in graduate physics programs. I am a consumer of works by theoretical and experimental physicists, not a producer. If I were to wade into debates on the nature of the universe, I would try to do it with a degree of humility and without the use of expletives and insults that have been displayed by some of those on this forum who feel compelled to attack mainstream economics without apparently understanding what they are attacking.@albertobisin @RelearningEcon @ProfHall1955 @GeorgeSelgin @JesusFerna7026 @ProfSteveKeen @sndurlauf @StephanieKelton -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
blocked. Learn to be polite @wgoggin
Bill Goggin
@wgoggin
Ignoramus.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm beginning to wonder that myself.
The serious answer is that MMT contains some half truths that are extremely attractive to politicians looking for a semi-literate justification to expand government programs without considering the resource costs of those programs.
These ideas are dangerous.
Since I have myself been a critic of mainstream macro I know both its strengths and its weaknesses. I believe that makes me a credible critic of the populist wing of MMT when they make incredible and nonsensical claims.
John Tighe
@JohnTighe3
Sir I'm not sure why you're trying to talk to these people
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ok thatâs it. Time to watch a movie. See you all again on Monday. Please talk amongst yourselves for a while đ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
blocked. Learn to be polite Dr. Drumm
drumm colin (nyc)
@drumm_colin
Wow you're really stupid even for an economist. Just admit you learned a new thing
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Why do you think a jobs guarantee program is a good idea. Serious question.
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
To address this, and also to address the difficulty of estimating what the right (i.e. non-inflationary) amount of spending is, MMTers usually support non-discretionary automatic stabilizers, the best of which is the Job Guarantee proposal.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with most of this â although I would still quibble with âfull employmentâ â which is hard to define. But here is the relevant passage. How do you persuade a politician to stop using monetary finance to continue funding government programs once âfull employmentâ â whatever that means â has been achieved.
Given the fact that we asked half the workforce to stay home during the pandemic â compensating them by monetary transfers was the right thing to do. A second enormous fiscal transfer through the âinflation reduction actâ was overkill and, without Joe Manchin blocking âBuild Back Betterâ, it could easily have been three times larger.
So although I agree that deficit spending is sometimes justified â and I agree that a balanced budget is a very bad idea â there are very clear limits to how much expenditure can or should be financed by money or debt.
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
No, I meant public debt here. My apologies if that was unclear. Here's the relevant passage from Lerner:
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm beginning to wonder that myself.
The serious answer is that MMT contains some half truths that are extremely attractive to politicians looking for a semi-literate justification to expand government programs without considering the resource costs of those programs.
These ideas are dangerous.
Since I have myself been a critic of mainstream macro I know both its strengths and its weaknesses. I believe that makes me a credible critic of the populist wing of MMT when they make incredible and nonsensical claims.
John Tighe
@JohnTighe3
Sir I'm not sure why you're trying to talk to these people
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
seriously? @grok please provide Mr Drumm with a link to the Treasury balance sheets where he can enlighten himself as to the fact that coins in circulation are a liability of the Treasury.
drumm colin (nyc)
@drumm_colin
haha thanks i'm pretty deeply familiar with the MMT literature. please show me the balance sheet entry where the liability for coins is written down. should be easy to find?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Ask yourself what happened in 1971 when Nixon went off the Gold standard. Before 1971 foreign actors could exchange dollars for gold. And before 1933 every US citizen also could exchange a dollar for gold.
In 1971 US currency became completely fiat. But there were still existing dollars circulating in exchange. If you are looking for a realistic answer to the question: where did the money come from: you could do worse than take 1971 as the starting point of a temporary equilibrium model with a fiat currency.
pet rock
@petrock
I don't know. That's why I'm asking Roger to explain how this fits into his explanation of "temporary equilibrium".
Seems he's implying that where it came from isn't important. We're just supposed to accept that it came "from the past". -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Drago Indjic/ĐĐœŃĐžŃ
@dindjic
Superb thread featuring several great minds.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I will let Doyne, JP and Alan speak for themselves but, I have no quarrel with anything in @JesusFerna7026âs list. But I would add one important qualifier. An economic model requires an EQUILIBRIUM CONCEPT. To explain that qualifier, let me add some structure to Jesusâs list. @drmtgr
I organize all of my thinking around the concept of *temporary equilibrium theory*, an idea that dates to Hicksâ book âValue and Capitalâ (and perhaps earlier).
1. In a temporary equilibrium, a collection of agents meet every week in a market. Each agent brings to market a bundle of goods to be exchanged with other agents. And they bring financial assets and liabilities inherited from the past. At the market agents form expectations of what they think will happen in the future.
2. The objects traded at the market may include labor contracts, physical commodities and commitments to exchange money in the future under alternative states of nature.
3. In between market meetings, agents consume the commodities they purchased at the market (consumption) and they transform commodities into different commodities (production). During this process, the technology for transforming one set of commodities into another is subject to randomness. Agents may or may not know the probability distributions from which these random variables are drawn.
4. The agents make decisions based on a set of assumptions about human behavior. These assumptions â rational choice â are not particularly restrictive. However, some versions of rational choice e.g. expected utility theory are restrictive.
5. While economists usually assume that individuals are selfish â selfishness is not a necessary assumption and there are economic models where people care also for others.
6. The set of agents may or may not change over time.
I will refer to a model in this class as a Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model and Iâve been broad enough in my definition to include pretty much any internally consistent description of how an economy functions including MMT, Austrians, post-Keynesian, models, agent based models and neoclassical macro models. (See my invitation below for Post Keynesians to adopt DSGE theory)
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Different models differ in the specifics of the way they fill in the details. The most important of these is a point missing from Jesusâs list: the EQUILIBRIUM CONCEPT.
When individuals enter the market they bring a specific set of goods, assets and liabilities. They leave with a different set. An equilibrium concept is a description of how that process works. One possible concept is Walrasian equilibrium: demand equals supply at each market meeting, subject to future expectations. But there are many others including my own favorite: Keynesian search equilibrium. Here is an example of a model which adopts that concept.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Before the rational expectations revolution there was a literature known as disequilibrium macro. That was a misnomer. See for example Malinvaudâs book âThe Theory of Unemployment Reconsideredâ. Disequilibrium theory is simply a version of temporary equilibrium with a different equilibrium concept. Malinvaud, following work by J.P. Benassy in France and Barro and Grossman in the US called this a fixed-price equilibrium. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Steven N. Durlauf
@sndurlauf
Roger Farmer @farmerrf has consistently engaged respectfully with MMT advocates. Further, he has patiently addressed what he considers to be defects in MMT understanding of the body of "mainstream" macroeconomic research. In response, Roger has been repeatedly subjected to petty insults. And there has been little effort to understand why he makes specific criticisms.
The asymmetry speaks for itself.
These exchanges demonstrate the value of formal modelling for macroeconomics. Formal modelling requires definitions of terms and logical coherence in specification of an economic environment. This entails nothing interesting about the substance of the model or its implications. Wittgenstein's dictum applies.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It is perfectly possible to formulate MMT using the language of temporary equilibrium theory. One reason, perhaps, why that exercise has not yet been attempted is that it forces the modeler to make internally consistent statements about concepts they take for granted.
For example, Randall Wray in his treatise on MMT acknowledges that if the economy is at âfull employmentâ a government that consistently finances additional expenditure by money creation, will cause inflation. But he does not define full employment.
Where I agree with Randall Wray, is that under some circumstances money financed expenditure will increase employment. Where I disagree with Wray, is that increasing employment is always a social good. Unlike Randall, I have a fully articulated theory of what it means for an economy to be at full employment.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
MMT economists assert that the government does not need to balance its budget and that â under some circumstances â deficits can, and should be, financed by money creation. I agree. But how large should the deficit be? Is there an optimal size fo government debt? MMT has no answer to that question. Neoclassical economics does.
Peter Diamond in his 1965 paper, âNational Debt in a Neoclassical Growth Modelâ, showed that government debt can, under some circumstances, increase social welfare. The reason is that, even at full employment, the interest rate in a competitive economy can be less than the growth rate. And in that case, money or debt financed expenditure is costless.
@wbmosler Warren Mosler, in his seminal article on MMT, uses the analogy of a family whose parent issues tokens. If he had pushed that analogy further to recognize that generations overlap and trade with each other, he might have rediscovered Diamondâs work. Importantly, Peterâs work does not imply that government can or should increase the value of its liabilities without limit.
My reading of MMT critiques of neoclassical economics suggests that most of the critics, perhaps not all, have a very limited view of what is taught in graduate economics programs.
I have my own speculations about the nature of the quantum universe. But I do not share those thoughts on X because I have a very limited knowledge of what is taught in graduate physics programs. I am a consumer of works by theoretical and experimental physicists, not a producer. If I were to wade into debates on the nature of the universe, I would try to do it with a degree of humility and without the use of expletives and insults that have been displayed by some of those on this forum who feel compelled to attack mainstream economics without apparently understanding what they are attacking.@albertobisin @RelearningEcon @ProfHall1955 @GeorgeSelgin @JesusFerna7026 @ProfSteveKeen @sndurlauf @StephanieKelton -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs an empty statement. 30% of the labor market changes jobs every year. The right question is: how long does it take to find an acceptable job? Equivalently, what is the ratio of vacancies to job-seekers. Economics has come a long way since 1936 when Keynes defined the concept of involuntary unemployment.
A further problem with the concept you cite is that it does not provide a definition of âthe going wageâ. If the going wage is insufficient to buy food and accommodation: is that full employment?
Go Wash Your Brains #MMT
@AllredRd
Wray defines full employment as "all who are ready, willing and able to work at the going wage will be able to find a job."
It's not rocket surgery. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
take a look at Malinvaudâs Jrjö Jhanssen lectures
archive.org/details/theoryofunemploy0000mali/page/n147/moâŠ
José Moran
@drmtgr
About the discussion around equilibrium: I have yet to see an equilibrium model where there are goods that are exchanged and where the market doesn't clear.
Many economists do argue that their notion of equilibrium is not a static one because they move from t to t+1 with some -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Reading some of the comments on my post about the confusion over the meaning of âequilibriumâ in economics,
x.com/JesusFerna7026/status/1994464610922238065
I have seen a few common but highly misleading responses.
The most common is that my use of the word âequilibriumâ and its implications is new, or that I am redefining what the dictionary says, or, more perversely, trying to muddle things up.
No, not all. I am using the concept of equilibrium that has been 100% standard in all mainstream economics programs worldwide for half a century.
I am including three photos. The first two are from my copy of Microeconomic Theory by Andreu Mas-Colell, Michael D. Whinston, and Jerry R. Green (MWG for short), the canonical book for teaching first-year graduate microeconomics worldwide since its publication in 1995.
I used MWG studied it in an advanced micro for undergraduates course I took back in 1995-1996 in Madrid (Spain) (and yes, it was rough for an undergrad to have to go over this material; on the positive side, my first-year micro in Minnesota was relatively easy).
The first photo is from page 744, chapter 20, Section D. You can even see the highlighting convention I followed since high school: red for the really important words (e.g, definition), and blue for the less important ones.
In this photo, you can see how MWG define a competitive equilibrium. Clearly, there is no sense of ârestâ or âunchanged.â In fact, MWG go out of their way to point out that the production and prices path must be bounded, which obviously implies that, in general, they are not constant over time.
In the second photo, from Section F, Dynamics, MWG write: âTherefore, the typical equilibrium path will be nonstationary.â
The third photo is from Recursive Macroeconomic Theory, 4th Edition by Lars Ljungqvist and Thomas J. Sargent (LS), chapter 8, section 5, page 256. While LS is perhaps not as canonical as MWG, it is probably the most widely used textbook for first-year macroeconomics worldwide (and the one I use most).
Again, you can see that their definition matches mine exactly.
I have seen people making brazen statements such as âI know a lot about Neoclassical economics, and this is not how equilibrium is usedâŠâ
No, I am sorry. You do not know modern mainstream economics in the sense understood by anyone who has passed the first-year preliminary examinations at a top Ph.D. program.
The way I define equilibrium is how you were supposed to define equilibrium in the first-year preliminary examinations in Minnesota in 1997 (when I took them) and all other top Ph.D. programs.
And, to be clear, oneâs ability to pass such exams has almost nothing to do with agreeing with the material. I once took a course in heterodox economicsâwhose analytical value I found utterly negligibleâand earned an A+ without much effort. Mastering the ideas of Kalecki, Sraffa, or Davidson is quite easy. None of them was even close to Bob Lucas or Chris Sims in terms of a brain.
It is perfectly fine with me that you claim that you do not like this concept of equilibrium, that you find that other solution concepts are more useful, or that you think we should drop all concepts of internal consistency.
I will probably even agree with you that the profession as a whole would be better off if we used a different word to denote the same concept (a self-consistent set of actions, prices, and beliefs) to avoid confusion.
But it is not fine with me that you refuse to accept that my use of âequilibriumâ is the standard use in mainstream economics.
If I have the time, I might write a short post on the evolution of the concept of âequilibriumâ in economics, from its early uses in Adam Smith and David Ricardo to the modern use starting with Irving Fisher in 1907 (yes, 1907, 113 years ago).
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
A guide for students of economics: Ten statements that demonstrate that someone does not understand modern economics or what an equilibrium is, and that you can safely ignore everything else they say.
1. âEquilibrium means the economy is stable or at rest.â
Many assume that an equilibrium is a peaceful state with no forces at play. Instead, an equilibrium is just an arrangement of actions and expectations over time that are mutually consistent. It can be locally unstable, explosive, or fragile. Nothing in the definition of equilibrium implies stability.
2. âEquilibrium implies optimality or social efficiency.â
Equilibrium is often conflated with efficiency, but equilibrium merely reflects decentralized consistency, not welfare maximization. Market power, externalities, incomplete markets, nominal rigidities, and frictions routinely produce inefficient equilibria. I often teach a first-year macro graduate course, and not a single one of the equilibria I define is efficient.
3. âEquilibrium is a unique outcome.â
Many often expect models to have one equilibrium. In reality, multiple equilibria arise naturally in dynamic, strategic, and incomplete-market environments. Models of coordination failures, self-fulfilling expectations, bubbles, overlapping generations, and liquidity traps all hinge on the existence of equilibrium multiplicity.
4. âEquilibrium requires perfect foresight or perfect information.â
Equilibrium does not assume agents know the future. In fact, equilibria are often stochastic. The definition of equilibrium only requires that beliefs are consistent with the (perceived) stochastic laws of motion implied by the model. Bayesian learning, noisy signals, ambiguity, and subjective uncertainty all fit well within an equilibrium framework, provided beliefs converge to an internally consistent (but possibly incorrect) distribution.
Bonus point: equilibria are compatible with agents having diverging beliefs that never converge to a single Dirac distribution.
5. âReal economies are rarely in equilibrium, so the concept is unrealistic.â
Equilibrium is not meant to describe the daily state of the world. It is a conceptual device used to understand the outcome of our models under the assumptions we make. Also, see point 1 above.
6. âEquilibrium requires agents to be fully rational in a psychological sense.â
Equilibrium only assumes internal consistency: agents optimize given preferences and constraints. It does not assume realism about human cognition. We can and do define equilibria in models with behavioral biases, bounded rationality, inattention, or rule-of-thumb behavior. We only need to ensure that the resulting actions and beliefs are mutually compatible.
7. âEquilibrium eliminates dynamics or learning.â
Equilibrium is sometimes misinterpreted as a static state in which nothing evolves. In fact, many equilibria are sequences of probability distributions over states driven by shocks, policy rules, and endogenous responses. Learning dynamics (Bayesian updating, adaptive rules, experience-based expectations) can occur within equilibrium if the evolution of beliefs is self-consistent.
8. âEquilibrium renders expectations unimportant.â
A common misconception is that equilibrium mechanically determines outcomes. In reality, expectations are often central: they determine investment, consumption, asset prices, and policy responses. Many equilibria differ only in their expectations. This is why communication, credibility, and forward guidance matter even in fully rational models.
9. âEquilibrium excludes policy intervention.â
Some interpret equilibrium as a laissez-faire concept. In fact, equilibrium analysis is the foundation of modern policy evaluation. Fiscal, monetary, and regulatory interventions work through equilibrium responses (prices, wages, interest rates, quantities) and must satisfy equilibrium conditions to be credible. Equilibrium is a tool for policy design, not a barrier to it.
10. âEquilibriumsâŠâ
Aequilibrium is a Latin neuter noun of the second declension, which forms a nominative plural in âaâ. It is composed of aequus (equal; the same root as equality or equity) and libra (balance or scales or the name of several currencies over history).
A final thought: âequilibriumâ is a term of art. Its meaning in economics differs from its use in the natural sciences or in everyday language. Terms of art are ubiquitous across academic disciplines, and the first act of intellectual diligence when one starts studying a discipline is to learn what they mean. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It is perfectly possible to formulate MMT using the language of temporary equilibrium theory. One reason, perhaps, why that exercise has not yet been attempted is that it forces the modeler to make internally consistent statements about concepts they take for granted.
For example, Randall Wray in his treatise on MMT acknowledges that if the economy is at âfull employmentâ a government that consistently finances additional expenditure by money creation, will cause inflation. But he does not define full employment.
Where I agree with Randall Wray, is that under some circumstances money financed expenditure will increase employment. Where I disagree with Wray, is that increasing employment is always a social good. Unlike Randall, I have a fully articulated theory of what it means for an economy to be at full employment.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
MMT economists assert that the government does not need to balance its budget and that â under some circumstances â deficits can, and should be, financed by money creation. I agree. But how large should the deficit be? Is there an optimal size fo government debt? MMT has no answer to that question. Neoclassical economics does.
Peter Diamond in his 1965 paper, âNational Debt in a Neoclassical Growth Modelâ, showed that government debt can, under some circumstances, increase social welfare. The reason is that, even at full employment, the interest rate in a competitive economy can be less than the growth rate. And in that case, money or debt financed expenditure is costless.
@wbmosler Warren Mosler, in his seminal article on MMT, uses the analogy of a family whose parent issues tokens. If he had pushed that analogy further to recognize that generations overlap and trade with each other, he might have rediscovered Diamondâs work. Importantly, Peterâs work does not imply that government can or should increase the value of its liabilities without limit.
My reading of MMT critiques of neoclassical economics suggests that most of the critics, perhaps not all, have a very limited view of what is taught in graduate economics programs.
I have my own speculations about the nature of the quantum universe. But I do not share those thoughts on X because I have a very limited knowledge of what is taught in graduate physics programs. I am a consumer of works by theoretical and experimental physicists, not a producer. If I were to wade into debates on the nature of the universe, I would try to do it with a degree of humility and without the use of expletives and insults that have been displayed by some of those on this forum who feel compelled to attack mainstream economics without apparently understanding what they are attacking.@albertobisin @RelearningEcon @ProfHall1955 @GeorgeSelgin @JesusFerna7026 @ProfSteveKeen @sndurlauf @StephanieKelton -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âAnd they bring financial assets and liabilities inherited from the past.â Money is a financial asset to the household or firm and a financial liability of the government. Every household, every firm, every financial institution, the central bank and the treasury are all agents.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Every time you think comments have reached the bottom ... @RelearningEcon proves you wrong!
These comments have the following logical structure ...
you call something (you define precisely) X, but to me X means something vaguely different (and ill defined) so you must be wrong
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
Neoclassical economists love saying critics don't understand equilibrium.
But the irony is this the more they explain equilibrium, the clearer it becomes that the concept has been stretched so far it barely means anything anymore.
Allow me to explain đ
đ§”1/15
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
A guide for students of economics: Ten statements that demonstrate that someone does not understand modern economics or what an equilibrium is, and that you can safely ignore everything else they say.
1. âEquilibrium means the economy is stable or at rest.â
Many assume that an equilibrium is a peaceful state with no forces at play. Instead, an equilibrium is just an arrangement of actions and expectations over time that are mutually consistent. It can be locally unstable, explosive, or fragile. Nothing in the definition of equilibrium implies stability.
2. âEquilibrium implies optimality or social efficiency.â
Equilibrium is often conflated with efficiency, but equilibrium merely reflects decentralized consistency, not welfare maximization. Market power, externalities, incomplete markets, nominal rigidities, and frictions routinely produce inefficient equilibria. I often teach a first-year macro graduate course, and not a single one of the equilibria I define is efficient.
3. âEquilibrium is a unique outcome.â
Many often expect models to have one equilibrium. In reality, multiple equilibria arise naturally in dynamic, strategic, and incomplete-market environments. Models of coordination failures, self-fulfilling expectations, bubbles, overlapping generations, and liquidity traps all hinge on the existence of equilibrium multiplicity.
4. âEquilibrium requires perfect foresight or perfect information.â
Equilibrium does not assume agents know the future. In fact, equilibria are often stochastic. The definition of equilibrium only requires that beliefs are consistent with the (perceived) stochastic laws of motion implied by the model. Bayesian learning, noisy signals, ambiguity, and subjective uncertainty all fit well within an equilibrium framework, provided beliefs converge to an internally consistent (but possibly incorrect) distribution.
Bonus point: equilibria are compatible with agents having diverging beliefs that never converge to a single Dirac distribution.
5. âReal economies are rarely in equilibrium, so the concept is unrealistic.â
Equilibrium is not meant to describe the daily state of the world. It is a conceptual device used to understand the outcome of our models under the assumptions we make. Also, see point 1 above.
6. âEquilibrium requires agents to be fully rational in a psychological sense.â
Equilibrium only assumes internal consistency: agents optimize given preferences and constraints. It does not assume realism about human cognition. We can and do define equilibria in models with behavioral biases, bounded rationality, inattention, or rule-of-thumb behavior. We only need to ensure that the resulting actions and beliefs are mutually compatible.
7. âEquilibrium eliminates dynamics or learning.â
Equilibrium is sometimes misinterpreted as a static state in which nothing evolves. In fact, many equilibria are sequences of probability distributions over states driven by shocks, policy rules, and endogenous responses. Learning dynamics (Bayesian updating, adaptive rules, experience-based expectations) can occur within equilibrium if the evolution of beliefs is self-consistent.
8. âEquilibrium renders expectations unimportant.â
A common misconception is that equilibrium mechanically determines outcomes. In reality, expectations are often central: they determine investment, consumption, asset prices, and policy responses. Many equilibria differ only in their expectations. This is why communication, credibility, and forward guidance matter even in fully rational models.
9. âEquilibrium excludes policy intervention.â
Some interpret equilibrium as a laissez-faire concept. In fact, equilibrium analysis is the foundation of modern policy evaluation. Fiscal, monetary, and regulatory interventions work through equilibrium responses (prices, wages, interest rates, quantities) and must satisfy equilibrium conditions to be credible. Equilibrium is a tool for policy design, not a barrier to it.
10. âEquilibriumsâŠâ
Aequilibrium is a Latin neuter noun of the second declension, which forms a nominative plural in âaâ. It is composed of aequus (equal; the same root as equality or equity) and libra (balance or scales or the name of several currencies over history).
A final thought: âequilibriumâ is a term of art. Its meaning in economics differs from its use in the natural sciences or in everyday language. Terms of art are ubiquitous across academic disciplines, and the first act of intellectual diligence when one starts studying a discipline is to learn what they mean. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I will let Doyne, JP and Alan speak for themselves but, I have no quarrel with anything in @JesusFerna7026âs list. But I would add one important qualifier. An economic model requires an EQUILIBRIUM CONCEPT. To explain that qualifier, let me add some structure to Jesusâs list. @drmtgr
I organize all of my thinking around the concept of *temporary equilibrium theory*, an idea that dates to Hicksâ book âValue and Capitalâ (and perhaps earlier).
1. In a temporary equilibrium, a collection of agents meet every week in a market. Each agent brings to market a bundle of goods to be exchanged with other agents. And they bring financial assets and liabilities inherited from the past. At the market agents form expectations of what they think will happen in the future.
2. The objects traded at the market may include labor contracts, physical commodities and commitments to exchange money in the future under alternative states of nature.
3. In between market meetings, agents consume the commodities they purchased at the market (consumption) and they transform commodities into different commodities (production). During this process, the technology for transforming one set of commodities into another is subject to randomness. Agents may or may not know the probability distributions from which these random variables are drawn.
4. The agents make decisions based on a set of assumptions about human behavior. These assumptions â rational choice â are not particularly restrictive. However, some versions of rational choice e.g. expected utility theory are restrictive.
5. While economists usually assume that individuals are selfish â selfishness is not a necessary assumption and there are economic models where people care also for others.
6. The set of agents may or may not change over time.
I will refer to a model in this class as a Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium model and Iâve been broad enough in my definition to include pretty much any internally consistent description of how an economy functions including MMT, Austrians, post-Keynesian, models, agent based models and neoclassical macro models. (See my invitation below for Post Keynesians to adopt DSGE theory)
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Different models differ in the specifics of the way they fill in the details. The most important of these is a point missing from Jesusâs list: the EQUILIBRIUM CONCEPT.
When individuals enter the market they bring a specific set of goods, assets and liabilities. They leave with a different set. An equilibrium concept is a description of how that process works. One possible concept is Walrasian equilibrium: demand equals supply at each market meeting, subject to future expectations. But there are many others including my own favorite: Keynesian search equilibrium. Here is an example of a model which adopts that concept.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Before the rational expectations revolution there was a literature known as disequilibrium macro. That was a misnomer. See for example Malinvaudâs book âThe Theory of Unemployment Reconsideredâ. Disequilibrium theory is simply a version of temporary equilibrium with a different equilibrium concept. Malinvaud, following work by J.P. Benassy in France and Barro and Grossman in the US called this a fixed-price equilibrium. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
An excellent quiz from @JesusFerna7026 Test your understanding of the terminology of economics.
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
A guide for students of economics: Ten statements that demonstrate that someone does not understand modern economics or what an equilibrium is, and that you can safely ignore everything else they say.
1. âEquilibrium means the economy is stable or at rest.â
Many assume that an equilibrium is a peaceful state with no forces at play. Instead, an equilibrium is just an arrangement of actions and expectations over time that are mutually consistent. It can be locally unstable, explosive, or fragile. Nothing in the definition of equilibrium implies stability.
2. âEquilibrium implies optimality or social efficiency.â
Equilibrium is often conflated with efficiency, but equilibrium merely reflects decentralized consistency, not welfare maximization. Market power, externalities, incomplete markets, nominal rigidities, and frictions routinely produce inefficient equilibria. I often teach a first-year macro graduate course, and not a single one of the equilibria I define is efficient.
3. âEquilibrium is a unique outcome.â
Many often expect models to have one equilibrium. In reality, multiple equilibria arise naturally in dynamic, strategic, and incomplete-market environments. Models of coordination failures, self-fulfilling expectations, bubbles, overlapping generations, and liquidity traps all hinge on the existence of equilibrium multiplicity.
4. âEquilibrium requires perfect foresight or perfect information.â
Equilibrium does not assume agents know the future. In fact, equilibria are often stochastic. The definition of equilibrium only requires that beliefs are consistent with the (perceived) stochastic laws of motion implied by the model. Bayesian learning, noisy signals, ambiguity, and subjective uncertainty all fit well within an equilibrium framework, provided beliefs converge to an internally consistent (but possibly incorrect) distribution.
Bonus point: equilibria are compatible with agents having diverging beliefs that never converge to a single Dirac distribution.
5. âReal economies are rarely in equilibrium, so the concept is unrealistic.â
Equilibrium is not meant to describe the daily state of the world. It is a conceptual device used to understand the outcome of our models under the assumptions we make. Also, see point 1 above.
6. âEquilibrium requires agents to be fully rational in a psychological sense.â
Equilibrium only assumes internal consistency: agents optimize given preferences and constraints. It does not assume realism about human cognition. We can and do define equilibria in models with behavioral biases, bounded rationality, inattention, or rule-of-thumb behavior. We only need to ensure that the resulting actions and beliefs are mutually compatible.
7. âEquilibrium eliminates dynamics or learning.â
Equilibrium is sometimes misinterpreted as a static state in which nothing evolves. In fact, many equilibria are sequences of probability distributions over states driven by shocks, policy rules, and endogenous responses. Learning dynamics (Bayesian updating, adaptive rules, experience-based expectations) can occur within equilibrium if the evolution of beliefs is self-consistent.
8. âEquilibrium renders expectations unimportant.â
A common misconception is that equilibrium mechanically determines outcomes. In reality, expectations are often central: they determine investment, consumption, asset prices, and policy responses. Many equilibria differ only in their expectations. This is why communication, credibility, and forward guidance matter even in fully rational models.
9. âEquilibrium excludes policy intervention.â
Some interpret equilibrium as a laissez-faire concept. In fact, equilibrium analysis is the foundation of modern policy evaluation. Fiscal, monetary, and regulatory interventions work through equilibrium responses (prices, wages, interest rates, quantities) and must satisfy equilibrium conditions to be credible. Equilibrium is a tool for policy design, not a barrier to it.
10. âEquilibriumsâŠâ
Aequilibrium is a Latin neuter noun of the second declension, which forms a nominative plural in âaâ. It is composed of aequus (equal; the same root as equality or equity) and libra (balance or scales or the name of several currencies over history).
A final thought: âequilibriumâ is a term of art. Its meaning in economics differs from its use in the natural sciences or in everyday language. Terms of art are ubiquitous across academic disciplines, and the first act of intellectual diligence when one starts studying a discipline is to learn what they mean. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The U.S. government pays interest on reserves at essentially the same rate as T-bills. So currently, money (reserves) and debt are perfect substitutes. A large stock of interest bearing reserves is just as much of a problem for government finances as a large stock of T-bills. The Treasury must run a deficit to pay interest on each of these forms of government liabilities.
If in addition, the government runs a primary deficit, the stock of outstanding debt â or equivalently the stock of interest bearing reserves â will increase every year. In the US, interest payments on the debt currently exceed defense spending. Since 2020, the primary deficit has averaged 4% of GDP. MMT magical thinking notwithstanding â this IS unsustainable.
Why is this unsustainable? Because somebody must be willing to hold the increased debt. Debt is a liability of the Treasury. It is an asset to the private sector. And there are no plausible scenario in which the private sector will continue to increase its asset holdings indefinitely.
You assert that, âif you donât like debt: donât issue anyâ. One interpretation; of this statement â and I donât know if this is what you meantâ is that the Fed should stop paying interest on reserves as it did before 2007. That scenario would cause a large drop in the demand for money as investors move assets from â what would become â non-interest bearing reserves into T-bills. But if everyone tries to get rid of money at the same time the effect will be the same as if there were a big increase in its supply. A large and rapid inflation.
It IS possible to run a permanent primary deficit. I have written about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
But there are limits. And we are perilously close to hitting those limits.
Steven Hail
@StevenHailAus
If you don't like government debt, don't issue any. What QE should have shown you is reserve creation is not in itself inflationary. Issuing bonds is a choice. The debt scare narrative is born out of ignorance.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Grazie
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
The man is fighting like a knight against the forces of evil! (No irony)
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I wrote a paper with @AmartyaLahiri 25 years ago where we looked at the implications of education for economic growth.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Our work is â I believe â still relevant. It explains two facts that exogenous growth models have trouble with. 1. Investment is highly correlated with growth. 2. Savings and investment are closely correlated across counties, a fact pointed out by Feldstein and Horioka.
There are two approaches to endogenous growth. Neoclassical economics assumes that output is produced by a reproducible factor â capital â and a fixed factor â labor. Growth is limited by the number of workers. But we observe continuous increases in output per head.
The exogenous growth approach â based on the Solow model â gets around this constraint by positing exogenous technological change. Itâs as if each worker becomes continually more productive over time. The downside of this assumption is that productivity growth is not explained. It is an exogenous constant.
The endogenous growth model â of which the Aghion-Howitt Nobel prize is an example â models the process by which new technologies are created. @LucaFornaro3âs work is also in this category. @DavidBeckworth
My paper with Amartya is an alternative way to get around the limits of the Solow model; we assume labor productivity is increased through education.
Luca Fornaro
@LucaFornaro3
That's true, but things are changing. A growing literature is studying the interactions between macroeconomic policies and productivity growth. I call it 'medium run macroeconomics'. We talked about it with @DavidBeckworth here www.mercatus.org/macro-musings/luca-fornaro-hysteresis-enâŠ
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Although growth is central to political discussions over economic policy, it is a dirty little secret that almost all neoclassical macro modeling â including but not limited to NK models â assumes that the underlying growth rate of the economy is an exogenous constant.
@LucaFornaro3âs work is an exception. It incorporates insights from both indeterminacy and endogenous growth theory and is well worth reading.
Luca Fornaro
@LucaFornaro3
Here's a possible explanation. Higher exports from China crowd out production of high-tech goods and innovation in the rest of the world. Over the medium term, GDP in the rest of the world drops because of lower productivity growth.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Is there no bottom to the depths of ignorance I must reckon with on this forum? Or is it just that even some otherwise intelligent people will say anything to dismiss an argument reason wonât allow them to actually refute?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Although growth is central to political discussions over economic policy, it is a dirty little secret that almost all neoclassical macro modeling â including but not limited to NK models â assumes that the underlying growth rate of the economy is an exogenous constant.
@LucaFornaro3âs work is an exception. It incorporates insights from both indeterminacy and endogenous growth theory and is well worth reading.
Luca Fornaro
@LucaFornaro3
Here's a possible explanation. Higher exports from China crowd out production of high-tech goods and innovation in the rest of the world. Over the medium term, GDP in the rest of the world drops because of lower productivity growth.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ Available instantly in Kindle edition for the price of just four Venti Lattes
www.amazon.com/dp/B01LT4MW56?tag=oupacademicus-20&psc=1&dâŠ
robert horrocks
@roberthorrocks
YupâŠ. bought @farmerrf book.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
On thinking more deeply, it is the last of those links that provides the clearest exposition of where I differ from both the New Keynesians and the MMTers.
I wrote âThe Role of Financial Policyâ as an invited piece for The Review of Keynesian Economics for an edition published to commemorate Milton Friedmanâs Presidential Address in which he introduced the Natural Rate Hypothesis.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Although the paper has a few simple equations, it is mainly a verbal exposition of my key ideas. Itâs written at the same level as the @wbmosler article that I critiqued on X. I would welcome constructive criticism from anyone who might disagree with the views I lay out in this piece. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Sure
1. Confidence crashes and animal spirits
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
2. Old Keynesian Economics
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
3. Aggregate Demand and Supply
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
4. Animal Spirits, Financial Crises and Persistent Unemployment
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
5. The Evolution of Endogenous Business Cycles
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
6. the Role of Financial Policy
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
There are more but thatâs a start -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đWe aim to please @fr_amodeo @albertobisin
Francesco Amodeo
@fr_amodeo
100% the best and most inspiring content on here since Twitter became X...
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It is never true that everyone is working. The labor market is in constant churn.
www.richmondfed.org/publications/research/economic_brief/âŠ
Eric Z
@CascadiaEric
Search costs are minimal,
0 unemployment is not automatic is not an argument for doing nothing, & avoiding higher wages is only a good reason for a segment of society.
Seems like a weak argument compared to everyone is better off when everyone is working.
Physical matters more -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
So do please reveal to me the âsource of the price levelâ. Is this the same as a theory of the price level?
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
aka 'Underconsumption Theory'
All MMT does is reorient the narrative with the initial assumption of coercive taxation+state single supplier of the tax credit/currency.
It's a giant baby step that also reveals the source of the price level, etc. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
What is residual unemployment? How do I know when I reach full employment?
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
Tax liabilities create what we define as unemployment- people looking for paid work. Gov spending then hires those the tax liabilities caused to become unemployed. Residual unemployment=insufficient net spending.
moslereconomics.com/mmt-white-paper/ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have no idea what you just said. All Iâm asking is what, in your opinion, determines the average price at which commodities exchange for money? To put it another way, if government increases expenditure, at what point does the increase begin to be inflationary?
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
Yes, mainstream uses relative value models that 'infinitely regress' to 'the price level' which is deemed 'historic' as they have yet to realize that the source of the price level is coercive taxation, etc.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
My response to @wbmosler Yes; there is quite a bit I disagree with. @StevenHailAus
Soft Currency Economics has four main components.
1. Mainstream economists get the mechanics of monetary-debt management wrong.
2. To explain government debt it provides a household analogy of a parent distributing âbusiness cardsâ.
3. Savings and investment are equilibrated by income â not by interest rates.
4. Full employment can and should be maintained by a government employment scheme.
1. On Topic 1 we are largely in agreement: â although mainstream economists are not as naĂŻve as you intimate. However, the mechanics of money management you describe have not been in place since April of 2008 when the Fed began to pay interest on reserves. Since that date, reserves and T-bills have become very close substitutes.
You say that debt IS money. I agree that debt and money are essentially the same object. And since April of 2008, itâs not a bad approximation to say that its âas ifâ interest bearing money now functions as a medium of exchange. But note that mainstream macroeconomics have dropped money entirely form their theoretical models and instead, they model monetary policy as the choice of an interest rate rule.
In modern mainstream models, the mechanics of how the Fed Funds rate is set, does not influence output, employment, GDP, consumption, capital or investment. I donât see any problem with that. I would guess that you probably do. But since you have not articulated a complete model in which the channels by which money (as opposed to spending) affect the economy are fully spelled out, I cannot know if that proposition is central to your claims. You appear to be assuming Ricardian equivalence + money=debt.
2. Your household analogy is profoundly misleading. Birth and death matters and the consequences of excessive debt/money finance ARE borne by future generations. Itâs ironic that you use the household analogy in your article since one of the main critiques of the representative agent (RA) model is that governments do NOT face the same constraints as households. In that model it doesnât matter whether government purchases are funded by debt or taxes; the representative agent recognizes that government will need to tax at some date in the future. (Thats Ricardian equivalence). This is profoundly wrong and, IMO, itâs not even a good approximation.
Neoclassical macroeconomists have long used a second model â the overlapping generations OLG model â that captures the idea that debt is a burden on future generations. That model, correctly in my view, asserts that there is a limit to debt financing. The OLG model can be, and has been, incorporated into mainstream modeling although not as much as it should be. One of its main defenders is Larry Kotlikoff who participated in the panel discussion that I organized on MMT and that you participated in.
3. Topic 3 is a restatement of the Hicks-Hansen interpretation of the General Theory. What that interpretation lacked was an explanation of the concept of involuntary unemployment that was consistent with mainstream microeconomics. This is the problem that Patinkin struggled with in Money Interest and Prices. You make no attempt to address that issue yet you use the concept of âfull employmentâ as if it were observable and you assert that it it should be a goal of policy. In a section entitled: âHow the Government Spends and Borrows As Much As It Does Without Causing Hyperinflationâ you provide a textbook interpretation of Keynes but you fail to grapple with any of the conundrums raised by that interpretation and that economists have been struggling with for ninety years.
If you are to make policy pronouncements, as you do, it is important that you document the full implications of your ideas. What determines the price level? What is meant by full employment and how would I know it if I see it? What determines the rate of inflation. What is the dynamic path by which the economy adjusts following a change in the Fed Funds rate? The New Keynesians have at least tried to answer these questions â although I believe that their answers are wrong. But to explain WHY they are wrong it is important to propose a complete alternative theory. âSoft Currency Economicsâ does not do that. I have done that in my own work. See, for example, Prosperity for All, Oxford University Press 2017.
global.oup.com/academic/product/prosperity-for-all-978019âŠ
4. In Topic 4 you propose that government provide jobs for the unemployed. You have a great deal more trust in the ability of government to solve a problem than I do. Stephen Moore misattributes the following quote to Milton Friedman, (although it is likely much older)
âAt one of our dinners, Milton recalled traveling to an Asian country in the 1960s and visiting a worksite where a new canal was being built. He was shocked to see that, instead of modern tractors and earth movers, the workers had shovels. He asked why there were so few machines. The government bureaucrat explained: âYou donât understand. This is a jobs program.â To which Milton replied: âOh, I thought you were trying to build a canal. If itâs jobs you want, then you should give these workers spoons, not shovels.â
In âProsperity for Allâ I argue for the design of an institution, similar to the Fed, that manages the value of an index fund. That idea is backed up by empirical work which shows that animal spirits, manifested in the stock market, causes recessions
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
You asked if there is anything in your work I disagree with. I have tried to answer that question. Perhaps you will do me the honor of reading some of my work and addressing the same question?
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
Is there anything I said you currently don't agree with?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You should read my work â I provided links â before making uninformed statements like this. If we push measured unemployment to zero we will simultaneously reduce the production of goods and services. There is an optimal level of unemployment.
Fabio Filasieno âïž
@FilasienoF
âBut it does require a theory of how different levels of unemployment can persist.â
There is only one acceptable level of unemployment: 0.
Unemployment is a crime against humanity, and MMT, with the job guarantee program, has called out that the king is naked.
Involuntary unemployment is like inflicting torture and it is a political decision. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Here are the data. I didnât check other measures of inflation but I doubt if they are that different. @jasonfurman @StephanieKelton @musharbash_b @AlecStapp the graph suggests that inflation began to fall after the Fed started tightening. Correlation is not causation but âŠ. maybe Jason was right to be skeptical. At low frequency inflation is positively correlated with inflation. But as this graph shows, at medium to high frequencies the correlation is negative.
Basel Musharbash
@musharbash_b
A confidently ignorant reply by Jason Furman that was later proven remarkably wrong
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
While I agree with much of this post ⊠I donât see the connection to the Cambridge capital controversy. Here is a theory of unemployment that reconciles âinvoluntary unemploymentâ with microeconomics. @heterodox_econs
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Graham White
@heterodox_econs
"Although the money supply is endogenous under the current regime ⊠it is not clear that that means much... there are â eventually â hard resource constraints. Large deficits â financed by money creationâ are inflationary."
Is this not a proposition about a tendency to full-employment? This has always been the issue with the mainstream of the profession across it's various forms: the claim that demand does not provide an independent constraint on output and output capacity, except in the short-period or where prices (of commodities and/or factors) are not sufficiently flexible and/or agents are misinformed.
The most serious critique of this notion remains the implications of the capital-theoretic debates from the 1950's - 70's, whether the orthodoxy be Wicksell, the neo-classical synthesis of the 50's or New Keynesianism - the argument that the effective constraint on output levels and growth remains the supply of "factors of production" remains a house of cards. @USydneyEcon -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well a case can be made for that view. I make that case here.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
But it does require a theory of how different levels of unemployment can persist. The reason this matters is the way that fiscal and monetary policy interact is model specific.
tantaene animis caelestibus irae?
@gnomoderno
the whole point for postkeynesians is that money is not neutral even in the long run
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Cory Langlais
@Cory_Langlais
Good point. Fisher noted this: "... banking is a device for the coining into dollars land, stoves, and other [illiquid] wealth not otherwise generally exchangeable." (The Purchasing Power of Money, 1922, p. 41)
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And the beauty of that process is that when the bank lends to a firm or a household to buy a capital asset, it simultaneously verifies that the asset exists thus allowing a claim on the asset to circulate as a medium of exchange.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Thereâs no contradiction: Creating new IOUs is an essential part of intermediation. Instead of Joe lending cash to Bob on Bobâs IOU, Joe lends to a bank that lends to Bob, w/ the bankâs IOUs also serving as money. Thus bank intermediation and money creation go hand-in-hand.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
"Warren Mosley, âSoft Currency Economicsâ, 1993, Chapter 7."
Should be:
Warren Mosler, 'Soft Currency Economics,' Introduction
;)
WITH EDITS - Copy of Soft Currency Economics by Warren B -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
My frustration with poorly argued attacks on mainstream monetary economics has generated quite a bit of push back from critics of the status quo âŠ
What if I were to organize a debate between Warren Mosley, Stephanie Kelton and Randall Wray and, oh I donât know, maybe a former Fed President, a Vice President of the ECB and a former US presidential candidate ⊠moderated by myself and a member of the MPC
Oh wait ⊠I did
youtu.be/xQFImP5VDrQ
So to my critics on X: yes, I do understand the arguments of the MMT school. Can you say the same about your knowledge of my body of work? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
My frustration with poorly argued attacks on mainstream monetary economics has generated quite a bit of push back from critics of the status quo âŠ
What if I were to organize a debate between Warren Mosley, Stephanie Kelton and Randall Wray and, oh I donât know, maybe a former Fed President, a Vice President of the ECB and a former US presidential candidate ⊠moderated by myself and a member of the MPC
Oh wait ⊠I did
youtu.be/xQFImP5VDrQ
So to my critics on X: yes, I do understand the arguments of the MMT school. Can you say the same about your knowledge of my body of work? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âThe essence of the political process is coming to terms with the inherent trade-offs we face in a world of limited resources and unlimited wants. The idea that people can improve their lives by depriving themselves of surplus goods and services contradicts both common sense and any respectable economic theory. When there are widespread unemployed resources as there are today in the United States, the trade-off costs are often minimal, yet mistakenly deemed unaffordable.â
Warren Mosley, âSoft Currency Economicsâ, 1993, Chapter 7.
The irony here is that I have some sympathy for this statement. I have written extensively on theories of inefficient allocation of resources that leads to there being many possible âequilibriumâ unemployment rates. What I have no time for â and I do not include @wbmosler in this category â is expletive laden diatribes that fail to engage with a body of scholarship that has addressed, and is addressing issues of monetary theory and policy as part of its core enterprise. @econ_robinson @clintballinger @RelearningEcon
E-40 and Econometrics
@econ_robinson
It'd be helpful if you could cite an MMTer claiming resource constraints don't matter.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Does this apply to the Riemann hypothesis? If itâs beautiful, that beauty is certainly not apparent to the struggling observer (that would be me) trying to grasp its meaning.
Florin Bilbiie đȘđș đșđŠ
@FlorinBilbiie
If it's not beautiful, it most probably isn't correct.
(talking about mathematics/analytics, and this is probably the only thing I learned for sure and can share) -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm not sure who this critique is levied at @relearningeconomics . The economists I interact with, even those I profoundly disagree with on substance, do not bear much resemblance to the caricature you portray in this series of Xposts.
You put out two views of money creation as if they were contradictory. 1. Banks lend savings. 2. Banks create deposits. But both of these statements are true and I donât know of any neoclassical economist who would claim otherwise.
We do not teach a single history independent theory of money. Graduate macroeconomics programs teach that the way that money influences the real economy depends on the monetary regime. And regimes can and do change.
Before 1933 the US was on the gold standard and since 1971 we have been on a pure fiat regime.
Before 2008, the Fed did not pay interest on reserves and they required reserves against both checking accounts and deposit accounts. Since 2008 they do pay interest and reserves and T-bills have become â essentially â perfect substitutes The economy operates very differently under these two regimes.
Although the money supply is endogenous under the current regime ⊠it is not clear that that means much. And ⊠the delusions of the MMTers notwithstanding ⊠there are â eventually â hard resource constraints. Large deficits â financed by money creationâ are inflationary.
As for the claim that government finance is equivalent to household finance â this used to be called the âTreasury Viewâ â I do not believe there is a single public finance syllabus or graduate macroeconomics class that does not debunk this proposition.
You levy the tedious claim that economists teach that all choices are made by a representative agent. This assertion displays a profound ignorance of the state of the discipline. Even twenty years ago, there were competing models and for at least fifteen years there has been an active program that studies heterogenous agents.
But the number of agents is, in any event, not the important question. What separates schools of thought amongst neoclassical economists (admittedly a subgroup of all economists) is assumptions about market structure. Who can trade what with whom.
So, to quote Wittgenstein, âWovon man nicht sprechen kann, darĂŒber muĂ man schweigen."
Mr. Keynes
@TyKeynes
You'd think the field that studies money would have a solid grasp of how it works.
But mainstream economics still teaches that banks are intermediaries, loans come from savings, and governments can run out of money.
None of that sh#t holds up.
đ§”1/12 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have made the claim, in a series of recent posts, that science is more like a tree than a linear progression and that economics, and macroeconomics in particular, can get stuck on the wrong branch of the tree.
Pascal Michaillat shared a link to a paper of his with George Akerlof which formalizes that idea.
pascalmichaillat.org/10/
Here is the abstract of their paper
âWe develop a model describing how false paradigms may persist, hindering scientific progress. The model features two paradigms, one describing reality better than the other. Tenured scientists display homophily: they favor tenure candidates who adhere to their paradigm. As in statistics, power is the probability (absent any bias) of denying tenure to scientists adhering to the false paradigm. The model shows that because of homophily, when power is low, the false paradigm may prevail. Then only an increase in power can ignite convergence to the true paradigm. Historical case studies suggest that low power comes either from lack of empirical evidence, or from reluctance to base tenure decisions on available evidence.â
All that is required to get âstuckâ in a false paradigm is that the gatekeepers of a science have a slight preference for ideas they agree with and that false idea are hard to falsify.
@S_Surprenant @haugejostein -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
We still have estimates ... e.g. from Lebergott
The long depression did not begin until 1873
Joseph Gagnon
@GagnonMacro
The 1870s were not a happy time. U was not published back then, but it was estimated at over 8%. Friedman called it the Long Depression and the NBER says it is the longest US recession. Rapid growth is not the same as growth above potential. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
To quote @JonSteinsson
"So, I think the empirical underpinnings of the NK program have been growing stronger relatively rapidly over the past few decades."
Ptolemy also solidified the empirical underpinnings of his theory that the earth is at the centre of the solar system by adding a set of epicycles to a theory of eccentric motion.
The NK epicycles are of the same nature.
global.oup.com/academic/product/prosperity-for-all-978019âŠ
Jon Steinsson
@JonSteinsson
On the Great Depression: I think the most compelling evidence is historical, narrative, and sociological. Basically, the notion that the people in the bread lines and living in Hoovervilles were not on vacation. These people were desperate due to a breakdown of the economic system.
On monetary non-neutrality: We have come a long way from money Granger-causing output. I very much like Romer and Romer (2004) and Aruoba and Drechsel's (2024) version of that idea. I also like the high-frequency literature (e.g., my 2018 paper and other related papers).
On demand affecting output when monetary policy is accommodative: One way to assess this empirical claim is to use cross-sectional evidence at the state level. Emi andI do this, for example, in our 2014 fiscal stimulus paper.
I didn't mention sticky prices in my last post. But there is quite a bit of evidence on the Phillips curve being rather flat. Again, I'll just cite my own work. In this case, my 2022 QJE paper.
So, I think the empirical underpinnings of the NK program have been growing stronger relatively rapidly over the past few decades.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you Jon @JonSteinsson for this detailed response. We agree about all three of your statements although they are not all of the same ontological category. Point 1 comes closest to a theoretical component of a research program. Points 2 and 3 are falsifiable statements but they do not have much bite as experiments to tell apart one research program from another.
Consider Point 2. This can be made precise. For example, we know that the Fed Funds Rate Granger causes GDP. Since the Fed Funds Rate is unquestionably an instrument of monetary policy: this statement is a way to operationalize point number 2.
I understand what you mean by point 3 and I believe there is a way to make the statement precise but that would require us to agree on how to identify a demand shock and how to define âaccommodateâ. But that should not be difficult and I agree about what I think we would find.
Point 1 is harder to verify since a person wedded to the market clearing assumption might assert that there are assumptions one might make about labor supply and demand elasticities that enable the market clearing approach to explain these data. To some economists, the first welfare theorem is a tautology. Iâm not sure if Ed Prescott ever made this argument, but if not, he came close.
To the extent we disagree, I suspect those disagreements could be resolved by discussion. I place much more weight on beliefs as a driver of markets and whereas you are content with two steady states â I think that there is an open set of equilibria selected by beliefs.
My view is much closer to the Cambridge England position of the 1960s as opposed to the Cambridge Massachusetts position. The Cambridge Mass position eventually evolved into what we call New Keynesianism. Joan Robinson had a better name. She called it bastard Keynesianism.
The early presentation of Keynesian economics in the form of the IS/LM model claimed that high unemployment could exist as a steady state equilibrium if demand was low. Patinkin combined general equilibrium theory and monetary theory and he showed, through the wealth effect, that this argument could not be sustained.
Patinkinâs argument led to Samuelsonâs âneoclassical synthesisâ which added the Phillips curve to link the disequilibrium short-run with the steady-state long run. The consensus model that evolved was embraced by Cambridge Mass Keynesians and Chicago monetarists alike and, when institutionalized by Mankiwâs textbook: it became gospel truth.
I believe that Samuelson made a big mistake when he introduced the neoclassical synthesis and that there is a much better way of unifying money and value theory. That is the view I have been promoting in my books and papers for the last couple of decades. But the further we move from the point when Cambridge Mass and Cambridge England diverged, the harder it is to find an audience that has been schooled in the earlier debate.
I am a big fan of your body of work and I appreciate your openness to alternative approaches. It demonstrates that, like Mervyn King, you are not a New Keynesian.
Jon Steinsson
@JonSteinsson
I have to say that I do not think of the three tenets Roger mentions as the "hard core of the NK program". To me, the core issues are empirical: 1) the Great Depression was not a Great Vacation. 2) Monetary policy has real effects. 3) Demand shocks seem to have sizable effects on output when monetary policy is accommodative.
It is true that price/wage rigidity is the defining feature of the NK model. But I am open to other frameworks that explain the core empirical facts. I guess I do think models with price/wage rigidity are the models that currently can most naturally explain the data. And of course Roger is right that one is biased towards what one knows well.
But the other tenets he mentions are not near and dear to my heart. I actually have a paper on the "plucking model", which one can view as a critique of the natural rate hypothesis. And @GautiEggertsson has a recent paper about an inverse-L Phillips curve, which can also be viewed as a critique of the natural rate hypothesis (I think, not sure Gauti agrees).
I also don't agree with Roger about the point about fundamental shocks. I think Diamond-Dybvig type bank runs are an important problem. That is an example of a non-fundamental shock. Such shocks probably explain a very sizeable fraction of business cycles in the 19th century and all the way through 1933.
I think related belief shocks are probably very important in financial markets more generally (e.g., bubbles in the stock market and housing market). But Roger is correct that stories along these lines have had a hard time gaining traction in macro.
Anyway, I think it is likely that Roger views me as one of the "epigones" that protect the NK program. (Had to look that word up.) But he is not correct about what I consider core to this program (to the extent there is a program). And perhaps I am more open minded that he thinks I am. Or perhaps I just think I am more open minded. But everyone thinks they are an above average driver, I guess.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@GautiEggertsson and @JonSteinsson have responded to my critique of the New Keynesian (NK) model. Let me explain why we interpret the same facts differently. First: a digression into the philosophy of science.
Most economists are aware of Karl Popper. In his book Conjectures and Refutations, Popper put forward a view of scientific progress that underlies, I believe, the positions of @R2Rsquared, Gauti and Jon. According to this view, scientists make a series of conjectures which are confronted with evidence. Conjectures can be falsified; they can never be proven. Science progresses in a linear fashion by building up a body of propositions that have not yet been demonstrated to be incorrect.
Thomas Kuhn disagreed with Popper and argued instead that science is a set of competing paradigms. Lakatos, building on Kuhn, developed a middle ground that he calls the methodology of Scientific Research Programs (SRPs).
A SRP is a set of propositions that may be divided into two groups. Propositions in the hard core of the program can never be falsified. Propositions in the protective belt are modified or selectively replaced when the program is confronted with contradictory evidence. No single hypothesis can ever be refuted by data since all hypotheses are joint hypotheses.
Let me elaborate on what I perceive to be the hard core of the NK program.
1. The Natural Rate Hypothesis. There exists a unique natural rate of unemployment which is, according to Milton Friedman,
ââŠthe level [of unemployment] that would be ground out by the Walrasian system of general equilibrium equations, provided there is imbedded in them the actual structural characteristics of the labor and commodity markets, including market imperfections, stochastic variability in demands and supplies, the cost of gathering information about job vacancies and labor availabilities, the costs of mobility, and so on.â
2. The economy is fluctuating around the natural rate of unemployment because some prices and wages are slow to adjust to their correct Walrasian levels.
3. All deviations from the benchmark non-stochastic general equilibrium model are caused by random perturbations in 'fundamentals'. In the strong form of the program, the fundamentals of the economy include only technology, preferences and endowments. In weaker forms, to which I myself have contributed in my papers with Jess Benhabib and Jang-Ting Guo, they also include random fluctuations in beliefs.
There are other propositions that the New Keynesians are willing to jettison. Among these are the representative agent assumption and, more recently, the rational expectations assumption (see Ben Moll's recent working paper).
When Gauti asserts that my 'basic model' is a straw man, he means that the four claims I make that cause me to be a NK apostate can all be accommodated within the NK paradigm by modifying its protective belt while preserving its hard core. Since Gauti has failed to cite concrete examples of how he would address my claims, I will provide an example of how a New Keynesian economist might proceed.
Consider my statement that consumption and leisure, aka unemployment, are predicted to move in the same direction but in the data they move in different directions. That proposition rests on the assumption that leisure and consumption are both normal goods and, it is possible to contort utility functions to protect the natural rate hypothesis. In my own work, I have shown that a more natural way to understand the employment consumption correlation is to retain the normality of consumption and leisure and to revert to an idea from Keynes' General Theory: that there is a continuum of steady state unemployment rates. See my exposition of this idea here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The NK program has a strong hold on the profession because a body of its adherents have built up considerable human capital in its development and a significant reassessment of the agenda would depreciate the value their ideas. As with any SRP, the early contributors have propagated their agenda at leading universities to new generations of students who are now employed at institutions throughout Europe and North America. Many of these former students are researchers and policy makers in the Federal Reserve system, the European Central Bank and the Bank of England. In academia, a cadre of epigones protect the NK program through their editorships at top journals and through their leadership at think tanks and policy institutes.
Will this change any time soon? The continued inability of central bank models to provide effective guides to monetary policy suggests that there is fertile ground for innovation in ideas. The required innovation could come from established academics. But that would require a considerable change in patterns of thought. A more likely scenario is that a new generation of students will be more willing to strike out in a different direction. To paraphrase Max Planck; science progresses one funeral at a time.
Gauti Eggertsson đșđŠ
@GautiEggertsson
Too many straw men heređ. Of course you know that âbaselineâ means the most elementary version. Point 1-4 have all been incorporated and studied in detail. Including the Great Depression.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you Jon @JonSteinsson for this detailed response. We agree about all three of your statements although they are not all of the same ontological category. Point 1 comes closest to a theoretical component of a research program. Points 2 and 3 are falsifiable statements but they do not have much bite as experiments to tell apart one research program from another.
Consider Point 2. This can be made precise. For example, we know that the Fed Funds Rate Granger causes GDP. Since the Fed Funds Rate is unquestionably an instrument of monetary policy: this statement is a way to operationalize point number 2.
I understand what you mean by point 3 and I believe there is a way to make the statement precise but that would require us to agree on how to identify a demand shock and how to define âaccommodateâ. But that should not be difficult and I agree about what I think we would find.
Point 1 is harder to verify since a person wedded to the market clearing assumption might assert that there are assumptions one might make about labor supply and demand elasticities that enable the market clearing approach to explain these data. To some economists, the first welfare theorem is a tautology. Iâm not sure if Ed Prescott ever made this argument, but if not, he came close.
To the extent we disagree, I suspect those disagreements could be resolved by discussion. I place much more weight on beliefs as a driver of markets and whereas you are content with two steady states â I think that there is an open set of equilibria selected by beliefs.
My view is much closer to the Cambridge England position of the 1960s as opposed to the Cambridge Massachusetts position. The Cambridge Mass position eventually evolved into what we call New Keynesianism. Joan Robinson had a better name. She called it bastard Keynesianism.
The early presentation of Keynesian economics in the form of the IS/LM model claimed that high unemployment could exist as a steady state equilibrium if demand was low. Patinkin combined general equilibrium theory and monetary theory and he showed, through the wealth effect, that this argument could not be sustained.
Patinkinâs argument led to Samuelsonâs âneoclassical synthesisâ which added the Phillips curve to link the disequilibrium short-run with the steady-state long run. The consensus model that evolved was embraced by Cambridge Mass Keynesians and Chicago monetarists alike and, when institutionalized by Mankiwâs textbook: it became gospel truth.
I believe that Samuelson made a big mistake when he introduced the neoclassical synthesis and that there is a much better way of unifying money and value theory. That is the view I have been promoting in my books and papers for the last couple of decades. But the further we move from the point when Cambridge Mass and Cambridge England diverged, the harder it is to find an audience that has been schooled in the earlier debate.
I am a big fan of your body of work and I appreciate your openness to alternative approaches. It demonstrates that, like Mervyn King, you are not a New Keynesian.
Jon Steinsson
@JonSteinsson
I have to say that I do not think of the three tenets Roger mentions as the "hard core of the NK program". To me, the core issues are empirical: 1) the Great Depression was not a Great Vacation. 2) Monetary policy has real effects. 3) Demand shocks seem to have sizable effects on output when monetary policy is accommodative.
It is true that price/wage rigidity is the defining feature of the NK model. But I am open to other frameworks that explain the core empirical facts. I guess I do think models with price/wage rigidity are the models that currently can most naturally explain the data. And of course Roger is right that one is biased towards what one knows well.
But the other tenets he mentions are not near and dear to my heart. I actually have a paper on the "plucking model", which one can view as a critique of the natural rate hypothesis. And @GautiEggertsson has a recent paper about an inverse-L Phillips curve, which can also be viewed as a critique of the natural rate hypothesis (I think, not sure Gauti agrees).
I also don't agree with Roger about the point about fundamental shocks. I think Diamond-Dybvig type bank runs are an important problem. That is an example of a non-fundamental shock. Such shocks probably explain a very sizeable fraction of business cycles in the 19th century and all the way through 1933.
I think related belief shocks are probably very important in financial markets more generally (e.g., bubbles in the stock market and housing market). But Roger is correct that stories along these lines have had a hard time gaining traction in macro.
Anyway, I think it is likely that Roger views me as one of the "epigones" that protect the NK program. (Had to look that word up.) But he is not correct about what I consider core to this program (to the extent there is a program). And perhaps I am more open minded that he thinks I am. Or perhaps I just think I am more open minded. But everyone thinks they are an above average driver, I guess.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@GautiEggertsson and @JonSteinsson have responded to my critique of the New Keynesian (NK) model. Let me explain why we interpret the same facts differently. First: a digression into the philosophy of science.
Most economists are aware of Karl Popper. In his book Conjectures and Refutations, Popper put forward a view of scientific progress that underlies, I believe, the positions of @R2Rsquared, Gauti and Jon. According to this view, scientists make a series of conjectures which are confronted with evidence. Conjectures can be falsified; they can never be proven. Science progresses in a linear fashion by building up a body of propositions that have not yet been demonstrated to be incorrect.
Thomas Kuhn disagreed with Popper and argued instead that science is a set of competing paradigms. Lakatos, building on Kuhn, developed a middle ground that he calls the methodology of Scientific Research Programs (SRPs).
A SRP is a set of propositions that may be divided into two groups. Propositions in the hard core of the program can never be falsified. Propositions in the protective belt are modified or selectively replaced when the program is confronted with contradictory evidence. No single hypothesis can ever be refuted by data since all hypotheses are joint hypotheses.
Let me elaborate on what I perceive to be the hard core of the NK program.
1. The Natural Rate Hypothesis. There exists a unique natural rate of unemployment which is, according to Milton Friedman,
ââŠthe level [of unemployment] that would be ground out by the Walrasian system of general equilibrium equations, provided there is imbedded in them the actual structural characteristics of the labor and commodity markets, including market imperfections, stochastic variability in demands and supplies, the cost of gathering information about job vacancies and labor availabilities, the costs of mobility, and so on.â
2. The economy is fluctuating around the natural rate of unemployment because some prices and wages are slow to adjust to their correct Walrasian levels.
3. All deviations from the benchmark non-stochastic general equilibrium model are caused by random perturbations in 'fundamentals'. In the strong form of the program, the fundamentals of the economy include only technology, preferences and endowments. In weaker forms, to which I myself have contributed in my papers with Jess Benhabib and Jang-Ting Guo, they also include random fluctuations in beliefs.
There are other propositions that the New Keynesians are willing to jettison. Among these are the representative agent assumption and, more recently, the rational expectations assumption (see Ben Moll's recent working paper).
When Gauti asserts that my 'basic model' is a straw man, he means that the four claims I make that cause me to be a NK apostate can all be accommodated within the NK paradigm by modifying its protective belt while preserving its hard core. Since Gauti has failed to cite concrete examples of how he would address my claims, I will provide an example of how a New Keynesian economist might proceed.
Consider my statement that consumption and leisure, aka unemployment, are predicted to move in the same direction but in the data they move in different directions. That proposition rests on the assumption that leisure and consumption are both normal goods and, it is possible to contort utility functions to protect the natural rate hypothesis. In my own work, I have shown that a more natural way to understand the employment consumption correlation is to retain the normality of consumption and leisure and to revert to an idea from Keynes' General Theory: that there is a continuum of steady state unemployment rates. See my exposition of this idea here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The NK program has a strong hold on the profession because a body of its adherents have built up considerable human capital in its development and a significant reassessment of the agenda would depreciate the value their ideas. As with any SRP, the early contributors have propagated their agenda at leading universities to new generations of students who are now employed at institutions throughout Europe and North America. Many of these former students are researchers and policy makers in the Federal Reserve system, the European Central Bank and the Bank of England. In academia, a cadre of epigones protect the NK program through their editorships at top journals and through their leadership at think tanks and policy institutes.
Will this change any time soon? The continued inability of central bank models to provide effective guides to monetary policy suggests that there is fertile ground for innovation in ideas. The required innovation could come from established academics. But that would require a considerable change in patterns of thought. A more likely scenario is that a new generation of students will be more willing to strike out in a different direction. To paraphrase Max Planck; science progresses one funeral at a time.
Gauti Eggertsson đșđŠ
@GautiEggertsson
Too many straw men heređ. Of course you know that âbaselineâ means the most elementary version. Point 1-4 have all been incorporated and studied in detail. Including the Great Depression.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@GagnonMacro argues that:
1. âPrices are much more sticky downward than upwardâ.
Here are my responsesâŠ
If you mean that price changes are asymmetric, I agree. (I have no observable working definition of âstickyâ.) But that is hardly surprising in a fiat money regime where the money supply is growing faster than GDP growth.
2. âThis stickiness does not cause unemployment, demand shocks do, but it makes unemployment more persistent.â
Let me start with the assertion that âdemand shocks cause unemploymentâ. You are not specific about what you mean by a âdemand shockâ so let me offer a conjecture as to what that MIGHT mean.
Changes in the money interest rate Granger cause changes in the unemployment rate.
(If that is not what you mean then you need to be more specific). If this IS what you mean: I agree. This is a factual statement that characterizes observable features we observe in data.
Moving on to the statement that â⊠stickiness does not cause unemploymentâ. Since you do not define what you mean by âstickinessâ nor how I might observe it this statement appears vacuous.
3. â the massive price falls in 1929-1933 were driven by a massive rise in unemploymentâ. The word âdrivenâ implies a causal connection but you already asserted that the change in unemployment was CAUSED by a âdemand shockâ. I agree that unemployment is correlated with deflation. I do not know on what basis you assert causation.
Turning to your subsequent post.
âThe theory is falsifiable. If U falls to a low level and W starts to fall, theory is rejected. I am unaware of any such occurrence. W fell in Japan in the 2000s, but that was in the context of historically high U.â
I think that by âthe theoryâ you mean the assertion that unemployment increases following a shock to âdemandâ [as yet undefined] BECAUSE money wages and or money prices are inflexible downwards. Your post implies that if a NK economist were to observe very low unemployment in conjunction with falling money wages that this economist would agree that âthe theoryâ had been falsified. I disagree.
We have ample evidence of periods of falling wages, low unemployment and rapid growth. The US from 1870-1880 is one such example. The existence of this evidence has not caused any New Keynesian â as far as I am aware â to reject the NK assertion that wages are inflexible downwards. Of course it also possible, since we do not teach economic history any more in graduate school, that most NK macroeconomists are unaware of this evidence.
@GagnonMacro @R2Rsquared @GautiEggertsson @JonSteinsson
Joseph Gagnon
@GagnonMacro
Prices are much more sticky downward than upward. This stickiness does not cause unemployment, demand shocks do, but it makes U more persistent. The massive price falls in 1929-33 were driven by a massive rise in U. 1/2
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If your theory is based on the assumption that high unemployment is caused by wage and price stickiness, you MUST conclude that the substantial wage and price movements which occurred between 1929 and 1933 were insufficient to clear markets.
By 1933 prices and wages had both fallen to 75% of their 1929 levels. If they had fallen to 50% of their 1929 levels, an observer who was observing the data through the lens of the sticky price paradigm would STILL have concluded that wages were not flexible enough.
To an observer for whom sticky prices are in the hard core of their agenda; no degree of observed price flexibility can refute the sticky-price axiom.
astonished kvali
@dshestakov
I think there is a lot of evidence of wages not being flexible enough during Great Depression, e.g. this: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-economic-histoâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@JonSteinsson @GautiEggertsson
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is from a paper of mine in the Oxford Review of Economic Policy in 2021
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The unemployment rate is measured on the right axis on an inverted scale. The log of the money wage is measured on the left axis. Details of how I constructed the wage index are available here www.rogerfarmer.com/s/Data-for-JEDC-Paper.xlsx
Pontus Rendahl
@pontus_rendahl
Do you have a reference for that type of nominal wage flexibility in the Great Depression?
Because there are other views
www.jstor.org/stable/2937864 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is from a paper of mine in the Oxford Review of Economic Policy in 2021
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The unemployment rate is measured on the right axis on an inverted scale. The log of the money wage is measured on the left axis. Details of how I constructed the wage index are available here www.rogerfarmer.com/s/Data-for-JEDC-Paper.xlsx
Pontus Rendahl
@pontus_rendahl
Do you have a reference for that type of nominal wage flexibility in the Great Depression?
Because there are other views
www.jstor.org/stable/2937864 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@GautiEggertsson and @JonSteinsson have responded to my critique of the New Keynesian (NK) model. Let me explain why we interpret the same facts differently. First: a digression into the philosophy of science.
Most economists are aware of Karl Popper. In his book Conjectures and Refutations, Popper put forward a view of scientific progress that underlies, I believe, the positions of @R2Rsquared, Gauti and Jon. According to this view, scientists make a series of conjectures which are confronted with evidence. Conjectures can be falsified; they can never be proven. Science progresses in a linear fashion by building up a body of propositions that have not yet been demonstrated to be incorrect.
Thomas Kuhn disagreed with Popper and argued instead that science is a set of competing paradigms. Lakatos, building on Kuhn, developed a middle ground that he calls the methodology of Scientific Research Programs (SRPs).
A SRP is a set of propositions that may be divided into two groups. Propositions in the hard core of the program can never be falsified. Propositions in the protective belt are modified or selectively replaced when the program is confronted with contradictory evidence. No single hypothesis can ever be refuted by data since all hypotheses are joint hypotheses.
Let me elaborate on what I perceive to be the hard core of the NK program.
1. The Natural Rate Hypothesis. There exists a unique natural rate of unemployment which is, according to Milton Friedman,
ââŠthe level [of unemployment] that would be ground out by the Walrasian system of general equilibrium equations, provided there is imbedded in them the actual structural characteristics of the labor and commodity markets, including market imperfections, stochastic variability in demands and supplies, the cost of gathering information about job vacancies and labor availabilities, the costs of mobility, and so on.â
2. The economy is fluctuating around the natural rate of unemployment because some prices and wages are slow to adjust to their correct Walrasian levels.
3. All deviations from the benchmark non-stochastic general equilibrium model are caused by random perturbations in 'fundamentals'. In the strong form of the program, the fundamentals of the economy include only technology, preferences and endowments. In weaker forms, to which I myself have contributed in my papers with Jess Benhabib and Jang-Ting Guo, they also include random fluctuations in beliefs.
There are other propositions that the New Keynesians are willing to jettison. Among these are the representative agent assumption and, more recently, the rational expectations assumption (see Ben Moll's recent working paper).
When Gauti asserts that my 'basic model' is a straw man, he means that the four claims I make that cause me to be a NK apostate can all be accommodated within the NK paradigm by modifying its protective belt while preserving its hard core. Since Gauti has failed to cite concrete examples of how he would address my claims, I will provide an example of how a New Keynesian economist might proceed.
Consider my statement that consumption and leisure, aka unemployment, are predicted to move in the same direction but in the data they move in different directions. That proposition rests on the assumption that leisure and consumption are both normal goods and, it is possible to contort utility functions to protect the natural rate hypothesis. In my own work, I have shown that a more natural way to understand the employment consumption correlation is to retain the normality of consumption and leisure and to revert to an idea from Keynes' General Theory: that there is a continuum of steady state unemployment rates. See my exposition of this idea here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The NK program has a strong hold on the profession because a body of its adherents have built up considerable human capital in its development and a significant reassessment of the agenda would depreciate the value their ideas. As with any SRP, the early contributors have propagated their agenda at leading universities to new generations of students who are now employed at institutions throughout Europe and North America. Many of these former students are researchers and policy makers in the Federal Reserve system, the European Central Bank and the Bank of England. In academia, a cadre of epigones protect the NK program through their editorships at top journals and through their leadership at think tanks and policy institutes.
Will this change any time soon? The continued inability of central bank models to provide effective guides to monetary policy suggests that there is fertile ground for innovation in ideas. The required innovation could come from established academics. But that would require a considerable change in patterns of thought. A more likely scenario is that a new generation of students will be more willing to strike out in a different direction. To paraphrase Max Planck; science progresses one funeral at a time.
Gauti Eggertsson đșđŠ
@GautiEggertsson
Too many straw men heređ. Of course you know that âbaselineâ means the most elementary version. Point 1-4 have all been incorporated and studied in detail. Including the Great Depression.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I just wrote a paper about this
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
The main takeaway fom the paper is that the Bewley model is very similar to the 2-period OLG model. It has two steady state equilibria: one is determinate the other is indeterminate of degree 1.
More importantly: if borrowing constraints and incomplete markets are important, as they are in the Bewley model, what does that imply for a theory of aggregate consumption?
In the representative agent model -- if preferences are logarithmic -- consumption is a linear function of wealth. Wealth has two components; the current value of financial assets and the discounted present value of all future wage income. This second component is called human wealth.
In the Bewley model, the dependence of consumption on human wealth is absent because of the presence of incomplete markets and borrowing constraints. Jack Schectman showed that under some reasonable additional assumptions about the rate of return, consumption is a non-decreasing function of current assets. Human wealth disappears from the calculation. In calibrated examples (see my working paper) the consumption function is close to linear in wealth.
Importantly, this result applies to a single individual. If the result can be shown to apply to the aggregate of all consumers -- and I think this will be true -- it implies that the Euler equation should be replaced by an aggregate consumption function that is an approximate linear function of current assets.
In other words, consumption should be modeled as a function of current wealth. This mirrors the state of macroeconomics in the 1960s when Friedman introduced the permanent income hypothesis and Ando and Modigliani introduced the Lifecycle hypothesis. The Euler equation as a characterization of aggregate consumption was a mistake.
This does not necessarily mean we should give up on rational expectations. It is not only future consumption and future income that enter DSGE models it is also future prices. What it does suggest is that two of these variables, consumption and income, do not belong in an aggregate model.ed đčđłđšđłđșđł
what do you think of the bewley model? @drmtgr
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@JonSteinsson raises an interesting conceptual question. Is the framework we use to understand the price of a commodity in a single market subject to the same critique as one might levy against the representative agent New Keynesian (RANK) model?
The theory of demand and supply is an organizing framework that is akin to the idea in physics of action at a distance. Action at a distance does not become refutable until it is fleshed out with the inverse square law. In the same way, the theory of demand and supply does not become applicable until it is quantified in a specific instance.
The theory of demand and supply is not distinct from NK economics. It is one of its constituent parts. Any specific application of the theory will be more or less useful depending on the skill with which it is applied.
The NK model rests on a number of assumptions that are either demonstrably false or, implausible as explanations of the phenomena they purport to understand.
1. The baseline model assumes sticky wages or prices. In the Great Depression -- the largest recession of the last 200 years -- wages and prices both fell substantially. The money wage and the money price level in 1933 were each approximately 75% of their 1929 magnitudes.
2. The baseline model assumes that the economy fluctuates around a constant natural rate of unemployment. All attempts to measure this 'natural rate' find that it is a moving target.
3. The baseline model has no unemployment. Instead labor hours are adjusted voluntarily in response to received movements in relative prices.
4. Like the Real Business Cycle model, the NK model implies that consumption and leisure -- aka unemployment -- should move in the same direction. In the data they move in opposite directions.
So my answer to Jon is: the theory of demand and supply is irrefutable. It is a language used to model specific markets. A good application of the language should help understand the phenomena to which it is applied. Applications of the model to US monetary policy have proven spectacularly unsuccessful and the model is a hindrance to the operation of central banks.
One anecdote to that effect which I mention in my JEL review of Mervyn King's book
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
-- I once had the temerity to accuse Mervyn of being a New Keynesian. He made clear, in no uncertain terms, that NK economics was not considered by the MPC at the time to be useful guide to policy.
Jon Steinsson
@JonSteinsson
A lot of critiques of the NK model apply just as well to supply and demand in any market: Every time something happens in said market, you need to add a unique sequence of shocks to explain what happened. Does that mean supply and demand is not a useful framework?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
What The Inflation Model said would happen in 2024 and what actually happened.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I had in mind Truman Bewleyâs attempt to formalize the PIH in an incomplete markets model with borrowing constraints.
Servet DĂŒĆmanı
@Ali2022432
Permanent income hypo comes from forward looking behavior that gives rise to Euler Eq. They are the same thing, what difference do you mean?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an important result which suggests, to me, that a version of Friedmanâs permanent income hypothesis may be a good substitute for the Euler equation in an aggregate model. @captgouda24
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
In one of the more jaw-dropping papers of the year, these economists used the complete consumption data of every single person in Norway from 2006-2018 to answer the biggest question in contemporary macroeconomics: how much does inequality matter? Maybe -- not so much! 1/
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Milan Brahmbhatt
@MilanBrahmbha11
Interesting comments by Roger Farmer on the nature of scientific progress. It is not steady progress on one given road. Rather, it is finding one's way through a garden of forking paths. Some directions turn out a mistake. We have to backtrack and try another way.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for the endorsement @R2Rsquared âŠ
Where we differ is over the view of progress in science, and economic science in particular, as a linear progression that makes progress towards âtruthâ. It is better characterized as a tree in which often, we move along the wrong branch and must retrace our steps to make progress. The current state of macroeconomics, and the NK paradigm in particular, is one such misstep.
If science were a single linear progression from ignorance towards truth, the role of prestigious prizes to reward progress would have an unequivocally positive impact on the growth of knowledge. But if science makes missteps and often retraces its path, as is the case not just in economics but also in the physical sciences, then prestigious awards can work to restrain progress. The profession develops cadres of interest groups who are heavily invested in a specific approach which with the benefit of hindsight may be seen to be the wrong way forward.
There are many examples of such mistakes, not just in economics but also in the natural sciences. In 1697 Georg Stahl formalized the theory of phlogiston to explain combustion. That theory was later found to be false and is no longer taught as part of scientific knowledge. Phlogiston was not an element in the linear progress of chemistry towards an explanation of fire. It was a dead end.
My own view of the NK paradigm is that it has become an obstacle to progress and that some or all of its key pieces are preventing the reassessment that is necessary to move forward. If the Nobel prize had existed in 1697 I would not have recommended that a prize be awarded for the theory of Phlogiston. I feel much the same way today about many of the key components of NK economics.
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
I recommend people read the sequence of posts by @farmerrf with a critical view of the NK model. I did not engage in the debate with them and many other great ones on this topic here on @X just because my views are too nuanced for this forum (or, perhaps, I'm just too confused to express them sharply).
There is one point where I disagree with @farmerrf and others, and it bears on the initial point I made on deserving recognition in science (say via a Nobel prize). Most of the models and ideas that we have today as alternatives to the 3-equation NK models came about to improve on that model. I would not refuse honors to the Solow model because Romer showed it missed the endogeneity of growth, or take the prize away from Romer because he assumed away institutions (to refer to three actual prizes). Likewise, it is very hard to walk into a seminar today on the topic of how monetary policy affects the economy and not recognize the pervasive use of the ideas advanced by Taylor, Blanchard, Mankiw, Ball, Romer in the 80s, or by Woodford, Christiano, Eichenbaum, Gali, Gertler in the 90s (among many many others).
With its many turns, right and wrong, this is what I think progress in science is about. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for the endorsement @R2Rsquared âŠ
Where we differ is over the view of progress in science, and economic science in particular, as a linear progression that makes progress towards âtruthâ. It is better characterized as a tree in which often, we move along the wrong branch and must retrace our steps to make progress. The current state of macroeconomics, and the NK paradigm in particular, is one such misstep.
If science were a single linear progression from ignorance towards truth, the role of prestigious prizes to reward progress would have an unequivocally positive impact on the growth of knowledge. But if science makes missteps and often retraces its path, as is the case not just in economics but also in the physical sciences, then prestigious awards can work to restrain progress. The profession develops cadres of interest groups who are heavily invested in a specific approach which with the benefit of hindsight may be seen to be the wrong way forward.
There are many examples of such mistakes, not just in economics but also in the natural sciences. In 1697 Georg Stahl formalized the theory of phlogiston to explain combustion. That theory was later found to be false and is no longer taught as part of scientific knowledge. Phlogiston was not an element in the linear progress of chemistry towards an explanation of fire. It was a dead end.
My own view of the NK paradigm is that it has become an obstacle to progress and that some or all of its key pieces are preventing the reassessment that is necessary to move forward. If the Nobel prize had existed in 1697 I would not have recommended that a prize be awarded for the theory of Phlogiston. I feel much the same way today about many of the key components of NK economics.
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
I recommend people read the sequence of posts by @farmerrf with a critical view of the NK model. I did not engage in the debate with them and many other great ones on this topic here on @X just because my views are too nuanced for this forum (or, perhaps, I'm just too confused to express them sharply).
There is one point where I disagree with @farmerrf and others, and it bears on the initial point I made on deserving recognition in science (say via a Nobel prize). Most of the models and ideas that we have today as alternatives to the 3-equation NK models came about to improve on that model. I would not refuse honors to the Solow model because Romer showed it missed the endogeneity of growth, or take the prize away from Romer because he assumed away institutions (to refer to three actual prizes). Likewise, it is very hard to walk into a seminar today on the topic of how monetary policy affects the economy and not recognize the pervasive use of the ideas advanced by Taylor, Blanchard, Mankiw, Ball, Romer in the 80s, or by Woodford, Christiano, Eichenbaum, Gali, Gertler in the 90s (among many many others).
With its many turns, right and wrong, this is what I think progress in science is about. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
People make financial choices every day. A good model of how they make those choices should explain how they allocate their portfolios between assets with different risk characteristics. Expected utility theory is one such theory. What are the predictions of Ergodicity economics for portfolio choice? @ole_b_peters @adammessinger @ProfSteveKeen @Chris196883
Adam Messinger
@adam_messinger
Honest Q: why not use logâwealth/timeâaverage growth (Kelly) baseline â then utility handles finite horizon, constraints, or model risk? It resolves St. Petersburg and fits multiplicative dynamics. Whatâs the case for EVâofâmoney as the null?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Please let me know if you think I mischaracterized your work in my blog
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2020/5/6/the-peters-pâŠ
where I discuss your conceptual experiment of gambles in which the decision maker is forced to reinvest his wealth at every stage? Your example does not, to me, seem to hinge on non-ergodicity.
Ole Peters
@ole_b_peters
I fully agree with @adam_messinger. Iâm not sure if utility is ever a useful quantitative concept, but from the correct baseline, there may be plausible use cases.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
Great debate indeed. I've enjoyed reading some of @farmerrf posts. One of the few well-informed criticism of the NK model here on Twitter
John Barrdear
@JohnBarrdear
I've really enjoyed reading @R2Rsquared's admiration of the NK model and @farmerrf's critique of it, and I love that, for all its faults, X/Twitter lets intra-discipline debates be conducted in the open.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the NK model is neither elegant nor useful.
The IS/LM model was useful â but incomplete â because its core equations summarize observable empirical relationships between aggregates. The attempt to graft a forward looking âPhillips curveâ onto the model was an unmitigated disaster. @jasonfurman @FrancoisGeerolf @monacelt
1. The Euler equation is an elegant description of the first order condition of a representative agent with perfect foresight. That agent does not exist. A much better foundation for understanding how consumption moves over time was Friedmanâs permanent income hypothesis. And since the work of Truman Bewley, we have a firm foundation for that equation that is grounded in borrowing constraints and incomplete markets in a heterogeneous agent model.
2. The NK Phillips curve does not characterize any observable empirical regularity. It never has. The original Phillips curve, a connection between wage inflation and unemployment in UK data, disappeared soon after Phillips published his eponymous article. The reason it takes a semester to teach the NK Phillips curve is that it requires a set of ugly non refutable theoretical contortions that only a mother could love.
3. The NK model has no unemployment. People voluntarily change their labor supply behavior in response to âshocksâ, the consequences of which are correctly forecast. That assumption does not fit with what we know about labor markets. I blogged about that here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/12/real-businessâŠ
4. The NK model assumes that employment (not unemployment) fluctuates around a stationary ânatural rate of unemploymentâ. I wrote about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Fed economists spend countless hours attempting to estimate this ânatural rateâ. This is a Sisyphean task since the unemployment rate in data is essentially a random walk.
The correct strategy at this point is to abandon much of the rational expectations revolution and to reconstruct macroeconomics beginning with what we knew circa 1960. This, I believe, is already beginning. There is a large body of theorists working on Bewley models and that group has concluded that rational expectations was a misstep. See, for example, the recent working paper by @ben_moll
benjaminmoll.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/challenge.pdf
I am not as convinced as Ben, that our models must be nonlinear with global solution methods since, if Benâs approach is successful, even linearized models in aggregates will likely display very different properties from either NK or classical RBC economies. But dropping the full implications of rational expectations is a promising way forward.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I donât like the word âscienceâ for this sort of thing.
But this is a very useful way to understand the world, consider some of the most important macroeconomic policy debates, and a flexible framework that you can build on to add different nuances and complexities. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree that a single model cannot explain; every episode. But the word âepisodeâ is doing a lot of work here.
The natural sciences do not have a single model to explain all physical phenomena. Quantum theory helps understand the behavior of light at the micro level: general relativity helps explain its behavior at the macro level. So, far, there is no âtheory of everythingâ. But physicists *do* have a set of rules embodied in Newtonian mechanics that enable them to understand a broad set of phenomena within distance and time scales that are within the bounds of everyday experience. IMO, it is not too much to expect the same of a theory of business cycles.
In my earlier post on this topic, by âepisodeâ I was referring to specific examples of economic booms and recessions, aka âbusiness cyclesâ. And unlike Lucas, I do not think it is too much to ask that a theory of business cycles should explain, not only the period between the end of WWII and the Great Recession of 2007-2009, it should also explain big events like the Great Depression and the impact of Covid on employment and inflation. A theory that cannot meet this bar is not a theory; it is a post-hoc descriptive parable.
The NK model does not even work well as a theory of ânormal fluctuationsâ for the reasons I have documented elsewhere. It certainly did not do a good job of understanding the Great Recession.
Perhaps I am asking too much of a theory? But I am playing by the same rules as the New Keynesians. They do not claim that we need a different theory to explain the data between WWII and the Great Recession, and a separate theory for the Great Recession. They claim instead that a unified theory can explain both periods but they had simply neglected to include financial variables in their previous model. An episode that contradicts their model does not cause them to reject the core assumptions of the NK theory; instead it causes them to modify its protective belt. In the language of Lakatos, it is a degenerative research program. @itamarcaspi @rodrikdani
Itamar Caspi
@itamarcaspi
Expecting a single model to explain every economic episode is not scientific rigor. It is the illusion of simplicity.
As @rodrikdani argues in Economics Rules, economics advances through a toolkit of conditional models. Progress comes from knowing which model and mechanism fits which environment, what its assumptions imply, and when those assumptions stop being credible and useful .The craft is matching structure to setting rather than defending one framework against ehatever reality brings.
This holds in micro and macro alike. In micro, perfect competition, efficiency wages, and behavioral models each illuminate different mechanisms of choice and market power. In macro, the quantity theory is a long-run anchor, the New Keynesian model describes stable low-inflation regimes with disciplined fiscal policy, and the unpleasant arithmetics/ Fiscal Theory of the Price Level is most relevant when fiscal dynamics drive inflation, as in many Latin American episodes. Closed economy for the US, open for Canada.
A pragmatic research program in economics builds conditional knowledge and updates its models when conditions change. That is how economics stays scientific rather than dogmatic.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If we need a different model for each episode we are historians, not economists. The hope of economics as a science is that we can distill a simple structure that successfully explains consecutive episodes with a single model. And if our research agenda is progressive, in the sense of Lakatos,
grokipedia.com/page/Imre_Lakatos
we should occasionally have predictive successes. A research agenda that fails to do that, again in the sense of Lakatos, is degenerative. The NK research program is clearly degenerative since each new episode requires a modification of its protective belt. In my view, this stems from an unwillingness to drop the natural rate hypothesis from the hardcore of the program. @GuthmannR
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
One thing about business cycle macroeconomics is that, in recent decades, each recession has been different from the previous one, thus requiring a different kind of model to explain.
1) The COVID recession is an obvious case of a negative exogenous shock.
2) Brazil experienced a massive 2015-2016 recession associated with fiscal irresponsibility and increased political uncertainty due to an impeachment.
3) The 2008-2009 Great Recession was due to a financial crisis (can be understood as a sector-specific negative shock).
4) Brazil experienced a recession in 2002-2003 following electoral political uncertainty.
Given these facts, I don't see much relevance in a business cycle model based on price rigidities in the first place (i.e., the NK model), which could be relevant for a macroeconomic environment centered on aggregate demand-driven business cycles.
However, the historical phenomenon of the aggregate demand-driven business cycle is now a thing of the past. It applied to the 19th and early 20th centuries, when cyclical economic behavior was associated with the banking system expanding the supply of money and credit until a recession hit. It's also a phenomenon that Lucas (1972) explained much more elegantly than any model before or after.
In regards to empirical calibration of these models, I should point out that when COVID hit, the DSGE models of the IMF projected Brazilian GDP to contract by 9% and it officially contracted by 4.5%. Errors of this magnitude (i.e., 100%) are quite standard and not very different from informal estimates based on intuition.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the NK model is neither elegant nor useful.
The IS/LM model was useful â but incomplete â because its core equations summarize observable empirical relationships between aggregates. The attempt to graft a forward looking âPhillips curveâ onto the model was an unmitigated disaster. @jasonfurman @FrancoisGeerolf @monacelt
1. The Euler equation is an elegant description of the first order condition of a representative agent with perfect foresight. That agent does not exist. A much better foundation for understanding how consumption moves over time was Friedmanâs permanent income hypothesis. And since the work of Truman Bewley, we have a firm foundation for that equation that is grounded in borrowing constraints and incomplete markets in a heterogeneous agent model.
2. The NK Phillips curve does not characterize any observable empirical regularity. It never has. The original Phillips curve, a connection between wage inflation and unemployment in UK data, disappeared soon after Phillips published his eponymous article. The reason it takes a semester to teach the NK Phillips curve is that it requires a set of ugly non refutable theoretical contortions that only a mother could love.
3. The NK model has no unemployment. People voluntarily change their labor supply behavior in response to âshocksâ, the consequences of which are correctly forecast. That assumption does not fit with what we know about labor markets. I blogged about that here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/12/real-businessâŠ
4. The NK model assumes that employment (not unemployment) fluctuates around a stationary ânatural rate of unemploymentâ. I wrote about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Fed economists spend countless hours attempting to estimate this ânatural rateâ. This is a Sisyphean task since the unemployment rate in data is essentially a random walk.
The correct strategy at this point is to abandon much of the rational expectations revolution and to reconstruct macroeconomics beginning with what we knew circa 1960. This, I believe, is already beginning. There is a large body of theorists working on Bewley models and that group has concluded that rational expectations was a misstep. See, for example, the recent working paper by @ben_moll
benjaminmoll.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/challenge.pdf
I am not as convinced as Ben, that our models must be nonlinear with global solution methods since, if Benâs approach is successful, even linearized models in aggregates will likely display very different properties from either NK or classical RBC economies. But dropping the full implications of rational expectations is a promising way forward.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I donât like the word âscienceâ for this sort of thing.
But this is a very useful way to understand the world, consider some of the most important macroeconomic policy debates, and a flexible framework that you can build on to add different nuances and complexities. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I personally cannot make much sense of Oleâs views. See my critique of Ole Peterâs work here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2020/5/6/the-peters-pâŠ
@ProfSteveKeen @Chris196883
Prof. Steve Keen
@ProfSteveKeen
Then you should definitely also read Peters, O. (2019). "The ergodicity problem in economics." Nature Physics 15(12): 1216â1221. doi.org/10.1038/s41567-019-0732-0
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with most of this. But if only 10-20% of economists understand the NK model, we are doing a very bad job of educating Ph.D. Economists since its itâs taught as part of the core in every major Ph.D. program.
Even those students who retain a healthy degree of skepticism soon change their tune when they hit the publication wall. Rejecting the NK model will tank your career. The gatekeepers at the top five journals impose a more successful defense against heresy than was ever achieved by the Spanish Inquisition.
alz
@alz_zyd_
OK guys, come on. Maybe 10-20% of economists understand the NK model. Few people actually seem to use it (modern HA models that market themselves as NK have qualitatively different forces, sources of "stickiness"). The assumptions make no sense, the results are questionable
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If we need a different model for each episode we are historians, not economists. The hope of economics as a science is that we can distill a simple structure that successfully explains consecutive episodes with a single model. And if our research agenda is progressive, in the sense of Lakatos,
grokipedia.com/page/Imre_Lakatos
we should occasionally have predictive successes. A research agenda that fails to do that, again in the sense of Lakatos, is degenerative. The NK research program is clearly degenerative since each new episode requires a modification of its protective belt. In my view, this stems from an unwillingness to drop the natural rate hypothesis from the hardcore of the program. @GuthmannR
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
One thing about business cycle macroeconomics is that, in recent decades, each recession has been different from the previous one, thus requiring a different kind of model to explain.
1) The COVID recession is an obvious case of a negative exogenous shock.
2) Brazil experienced a massive 2015-2016 recession associated with fiscal irresponsibility and increased political uncertainty due to an impeachment.
3) The 2008-2009 Great Recession was due to a financial crisis (can be understood as a sector-specific negative shock).
4) Brazil experienced a recession in 2002-2003 following electoral political uncertainty.
Given these facts, I don't see much relevance in a business cycle model based on price rigidities in the first place (i.e., the NK model), which could be relevant for a macroeconomic environment centered on aggregate demand-driven business cycles.
However, the historical phenomenon of the aggregate demand-driven business cycle is now a thing of the past. It applied to the 19th and early 20th centuries, when cyclical economic behavior was associated with the banking system expanding the supply of money and credit until a recession hit. It's also a phenomenon that Lucas (1972) explained much more elegantly than any model before or after.
In regards to empirical calibration of these models, I should point out that when COVID hit, the DSGE models of the IMF projected Brazilian GDP to contract by 9% and it officially contracted by 4.5%. Errors of this magnitude (i.e., 100%) are quite standard and not very different from informal estimates based on intuition.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the NK model is neither elegant nor useful.
The IS/LM model was useful â but incomplete â because its core equations summarize observable empirical relationships between aggregates. The attempt to graft a forward looking âPhillips curveâ onto the model was an unmitigated disaster. @jasonfurman @FrancoisGeerolf @monacelt
1. The Euler equation is an elegant description of the first order condition of a representative agent with perfect foresight. That agent does not exist. A much better foundation for understanding how consumption moves over time was Friedmanâs permanent income hypothesis. And since the work of Truman Bewley, we have a firm foundation for that equation that is grounded in borrowing constraints and incomplete markets in a heterogeneous agent model.
2. The NK Phillips curve does not characterize any observable empirical regularity. It never has. The original Phillips curve, a connection between wage inflation and unemployment in UK data, disappeared soon after Phillips published his eponymous article. The reason it takes a semester to teach the NK Phillips curve is that it requires a set of ugly non refutable theoretical contortions that only a mother could love.
3. The NK model has no unemployment. People voluntarily change their labor supply behavior in response to âshocksâ, the consequences of which are correctly forecast. That assumption does not fit with what we know about labor markets. I blogged about that here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/12/real-businessâŠ
4. The NK model assumes that employment (not unemployment) fluctuates around a stationary ânatural rate of unemploymentâ. I wrote about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Fed economists spend countless hours attempting to estimate this ânatural rateâ. This is a Sisyphean task since the unemployment rate in data is essentially a random walk.
The correct strategy at this point is to abandon much of the rational expectations revolution and to reconstruct macroeconomics beginning with what we knew circa 1960. This, I believe, is already beginning. There is a large body of theorists working on Bewley models and that group has concluded that rational expectations was a misstep. See, for example, the recent working paper by @ben_moll
benjaminmoll.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/challenge.pdf
I am not as convinced as Ben, that our models must be nonlinear with global solution methods since, if Benâs approach is successful, even linearized models in aggregates will likely display very different properties from either NK or classical RBC economies. But dropping the full implications of rational expectations is a promising way forward.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I donât like the word âscienceâ for this sort of thing.
But this is a very useful way to understand the world, consider some of the most important macroeconomic policy debates, and a flexible framework that you can build on to add different nuances and complexities. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Gertler and Trigari is an example of what I refer to as Classical Search Theory. See sections V and VI of this paper
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
To explain persistence in estimates of the natural rate of unemployment, these theories must assume that labor market fundamentals are non-stationary. That is an unappealing explanation for periods of prolonged high unemployment, as occurred, for example, during the Great Depression. My alternative, Keynesian Search Theory, explains these periods as movements along a continuum of *equilibrium* unemployment rates driven by movements in animal spirits.
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
Regarding lack of unemployment in basic NK model, there are very interesting extensions with search frictions developed by M. Gertler, A. Trigari, C. Walsh, and others. So there is a lot of good work that has been done over time to solve unappealing features of the basic NK mod
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
José Moran
@drmtgr
indeed! if you model the actual learning process in a simple model with changing stuff, like @farmerrf and JP Bouchaud did, and carefully split the difference between "true" expectations and "agent" expectations, things are not trivial at all, see arxiv.org/abs/2012.09445
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Milan Brahmbhatt
@MilanBrahmbha11
Over the years, economist Roger Farmer has mounted what is probably the most theoretically and empirically well-grounded refutation of the mainstream "New Keynesian" (NK) macroeconomic model so far. Follow the links in the post for enlightenment.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the NK model is neither elegant nor useful.
The IS/LM model was useful â but incomplete â because its core equations summarize observable empirical relationships between aggregates. The attempt to graft a forward looking âPhillips curveâ onto the model was an unmitigated disaster. @jasonfurman @FrancoisGeerolf @monacelt
1. The Euler equation is an elegant description of the first order condition of a representative agent with perfect foresight. That agent does not exist. A much better foundation for understanding how consumption moves over time was Friedmanâs permanent income hypothesis. And since the work of Truman Bewley, we have a firm foundation for that equation that is grounded in borrowing constraints and incomplete markets in a heterogeneous agent model.
2. The NK Phillips curve does not characterize any observable empirical regularity. It never has. The original Phillips curve, a connection between wage inflation and unemployment in UK data, disappeared soon after Phillips published his eponymous article. The reason it takes a semester to teach the NK Phillips curve is that it requires a set of ugly non refutable theoretical contortions that only a mother could love.
3. The NK model has no unemployment. People voluntarily change their labor supply behavior in response to âshocksâ, the consequences of which are correctly forecast. That assumption does not fit with what we know about labor markets. I blogged about that here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/12/real-businessâŠ
4. The NK model assumes that employment (not unemployment) fluctuates around a stationary ânatural rate of unemploymentâ. I wrote about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Fed economists spend countless hours attempting to estimate this ânatural rateâ. This is a Sisyphean task since the unemployment rate in data is essentially a random walk.
The correct strategy at this point is to abandon much of the rational expectations revolution and to reconstruct macroeconomics beginning with what we knew circa 1960. This, I believe, is already beginning. There is a large body of theorists working on Bewley models and that group has concluded that rational expectations was a misstep. See, for example, the recent working paper by @ben_moll
benjaminmoll.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/challenge.pdf
I am not as convinced as Ben, that our models must be nonlinear with global solution methods since, if Benâs approach is successful, even linearized models in aggregates will likely display very different properties from either NK or classical RBC economies. But dropping the full implications of rational expectations is a promising way forward.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I donât like the word âscienceâ for this sort of thing.
But this is a very useful way to understand the world, consider some of the most important macroeconomic policy debates, and a flexible framework that you can build on to add different nuances and complexities. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Let me explain why I believe modern economics is such a powerful tool for understanding the world. Iâll do this by discussing a great paper by Simone Cerreia-Vioglio, @UncertainLars, Fabio Maccheroni, and Massimo Marinacci, âMaking Decisions Under Model Misspecification,â published in the Review of Economic Studies a few months ago.
Imagine I want to drive from UC San Diego to UCLA, but Iâve never driven that route before. I need to build a âmodel of the worldâ to guide me, which we usually call a map. Maps are simplified representations of reality. They canât include every detail if theyâre to be useful. Borges, in his short story On Exactitude in Science, makes this point beautifully. (In practice, I donât draw the map myselfâI use an appâbut someone still had to make it.)
Because maps simplify, I canât fully rely on them. Maybe last nightâs storm knocked down a tree and closed a street, or thereâs construction and the ramp off the highway in LA is shut down.
This uncertainty matters. Suppose Iâm driving to UCLA for an important talk at 11 a.m. If the ramp is closed, I might need 15 extra minutes. When should I set my alarm to arrive on time, while still getting enough sleep to give a good talk?
The problem is that I canât assign precise probabilities to all these contingencies. How likely is the fallen tree? Or new roadwork? Even the best traffic apps canât capture every disruption, and some might happen after Iâve already left.
In economic terms, my âmodel of the worldâ (the map) is misspecifiedâand no matter how hard I try, I canât fully fix that.
But sitting down and crying about misspecification doesnât answer my basic question: when do I set the alarm? Too early, and Iâm exhausted. Too late, and Iâm late.
Simone and his co-authors offer a way to think about this. They start from the idea that we often hold several structured models of an economic phenomenon, grounded in theory. For example, a central bank might use a standard New Keynesian model and a search-and-matching model of money.
Yet, aware that each model is misspecified by design, the bank adds a protective belt of unstructured modelsâstatistical constructs that help it gauge the consequences of misspecification.
The beauty of the paper is that it provides an axiomatic foundation for this protective belt (and even generalizes it to include a Bayesian approach). It shows that if a decision-makerâs preferences meet certain conditions âreflecting both rational and behavioral featuresâ then those preferences can be represented by an augmented utility function that formally accounts for misspecification.
Crucially, we donât assume that augmented utility function; we derive it. We start with general, plausible properties of preferences and prove that they imply such a representation.
Thatâs real progress. Instead of writing endless critiques of expected utility or rational expectations (as many have done for decades, with little to show), we now have a formal way to reason about misspecificationâprecise definitions, clear boundaries of validity, and awareness of what we still donât know.
Take, for instance, a brilliant Penn graduate student on the market, Alfonso Maselli
economics.sas.upenn.edu/people/alfonso-maselli
His job-market paper pushes this frontier further. He studies cases where a decision-maker not only faces model misspecification but is also unsure which model best fits the data and canât assign probabilities to themâwhat we call model ambiguity. In my example, the central bank is unsure whether the New Keynesian or the search-and-matching model fits better, and it worries that both might be incorrect.
If you read Simone et al. or Alfonsoâs paper, youâll see how misguidedâand, frankly, cartoonishâmany of the recent criticisms of economics on X have been.
First: the idea that economists donât understand math or have âphysics envy.â The math in these papers is subtle and advancedâutterly different from what physicists do (neither better nor worse, just distinct). An engineer transitioning into economics would find these tools unfamiliar.
Second: claims of ideological bias are unfounded. I have no idea about the political views of the authors, and Iâd be surprised if anyone could infer them from the analysisâbeyond vague guesses about typical academics.
Third: This has almost nothing to do with what one learns as an undergraduate, or even in first-year graduate school. If your knowledge of economics stops at an intro textbook, itâs best not to pontificate on the fieldâs frontiers.
Fourth: Is this science? Debating that wordâs boundaries is pointless; every definition of âscienceâ breaks down somewhere.
The Germans solved this long ago with the idea of Wissenschaftâthe systematic pursuit of knowledge, whether of nature, society, or the humanities. By that measure, modern mainstream economics is clearly a Wissenschaft: a disciplined, cumulative, and highly useful effort to understand how the world works. Simone and his co-authors have demonstrated that beyond any reasonable doubt. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I have a deeper issue. Even if you incorporate search and matching into the NK model as Gertler and coauthors have done, it still does a poor job of matching business cycle facts. I call the Gertler approach âclassical search theoryâ.
There is a better way of using the market incompleteness generated by search theory to better understand the main ideas of the General Theory. I call that alternative âKeynesian search theoryâ. Here is a link to a paper that explains that idea
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
As you probably know, it's not uncommon to "read" unemployment into the standard New Keynesian framework even when search and matching frictions are not explicitly included. It's strictly speaking wrong, but even Gali does it, so it's definitely an intuition people are carrying around their heads without making it explicit:
youtu.be/Q376VMk_ywg
For outsiders, this comes from an interpretation of the model as delivering a kind of "disequilibrium" view of business cycle -- in the sense of a distance to a flexible price (RBC) reference point. We can make that explicit in the labor market equation (e.g., Gali, Gertler and Lopez-Salido, 2007). In the RBC model, the supply of labor (MRS) equals the demand for labor (MPL). In the standard New Keynesian model, we still have an equilibrium on the labor market, but the supply and demand side are affected by nominal wage and price rigidities, respectively, so the equation will be MRS - MPL + wedge = 0 (whereas in the RBC setting, the wedge is 0) and that wedge in the NK setting is going to look like you dropped a time-varying markups on wages and output prices.
A big problem, of course, is that there isn't unemployment anywhere in that model. It only exists in people's head, but the whole point of microfounding things is to avoid things only being in people's head... You should model unemployment if you want to model unemployment. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is an infinity of linear rational expectations models that can replicate a finite data set with the same degree of accuracy as the NK model. Only one of them is the true data generating process (DGP).
In my paper with Andreas Beyer we presented an algorithm to generate a family of models all of which have the same likelihood on a given finite sequence of data. But although it is impossible to tell which is the correct model on a finite sample, the models have different implications for optimal policy and only one of them is the true DGP. Here is a link to our paper static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Leonardo Urrutia
@leonardourru
I donât see how the âas many shocks as observableâ criticism relates to the NKM. To me, any model that perfectly replicates multiple time series with fewer random perturbations is not a model, but rather the true data-generating processâŠsmaller shocks = better model.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
KingoftheCoast
@kingofthecoastt
âBy and large, these [administrative data] studies indicate that, except in extreme circumstances (when nominal wage cuts are either legally prohibited or rendered beside the point by very high inflation), nominal wage cuts from one year to the next appear quite common.â
Heon Lee
@heonlee_
Does that long standing idea of (3) actually hold in the data? I am afraid it is not.
How Prevalent Is Downward Rigidity in Nominal Wages?
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.33.3.185 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John Ruf
@JohnRuf6
So like I'd like to point out for the heterodox folk this is the kind of critique that will get me to listen to you intensely.
This has
1. A shown understanding of the model
2. Measurable and clearly stated problems
3. A legible paper with a clear point illustrating in depth.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many âshocksâ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, âscience progresses one funeral at a timeâ. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I prefer Lakatos cursosfilos.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/procâŠ
ĂĂĄron SepĂșlveda-CuĂ©
@AaronSepulvedaC
Economics is a science
Those that deny it are epistemologically naive
Reading Khun & Feyerabend should help them. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
The Phillips curve is hard to attack for a variety of reasons. For one thing, the theory behind it says it should be "hidding" in the data if the central bank is not incompetent (Tenreyro and McLeay, 2020). The intuition for outsiders is that you need demand shocks to reveal the shape of the supply side (that is the Phillips curve in that theory), but a competent central bank would offset most of those shocks. But there's an element of challenging this requiring to overturn terms of long conversations that are about 50 years old. You need some very compelling reasons to do it and it's actually hard to force New Keynesians into a corner on this issue.
If people want a sense of the problem, consider the data on output and inflation in the US in the past 25 years. The 2000s and 2010s want a flat Phillips curve with the inflation seemingly not responding to changes in economic activity, but the opposite happened in the 2020s. A flat-ish curve implied the landing couldn't be soft and there were some warnings from some macroeconomists when the Fed started on its tightening cycle. But the landing was soft and that's a problem for the standard view.
How did people handle it? Let's put a kink in the Phillips curve! That way, we can have two slopes (Benigno and Eggertsson, 2024). To be fair, they have a theory that implies there should be a kink, but I'm sure everyone can see that they didn't stumble upon one by accident while working on something else. What actually happened is they drew an ECON101 graph with aggregate supply shaped like a hockey stick in their heads and then went on a fishing expedition to make the theory say that.
To some extent, this reveals part of the problem isn't necessarily bad faith. It's really, really hard to get people to think through a problem differently. It's always easier when it's a small change. Even if they want to hear you out, habits are hard to break.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes @FrancoisGeerolf The economics profession imposes strong penalties on independent thought and it enforces them through gatekeepers at a small set of prestigious journals where acceptance is a prerequisite for tenure. Heresy is not tolerated.
On a critique of the Phillips curve, here is a link to a piece I wrote when I was at the Bank of England as a Houblon Norman Fellow
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Pour avoir osé critiquer la "courbe de Phillips", je peux vous dire que la discussion avec les macroéconomistes mainstream sur ce sujet, hélas, n'est pas possible - ce qui, pour moi, n'est pas une attitude scientifique !
Je suis d'accord avec Roger Farmer:
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many âshocksâ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, âscience progresses one funeral at a timeâ. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No, the NK model is neither elegant nor useful.
The IS/LM model was useful â but incomplete â because its core equations summarize observable empirical relationships between aggregates. The attempt to graft a forward looking âPhillips curveâ onto the model was an unmitigated disaster. @jasonfurman @FrancoisGeerolf @monacelt
1. The Euler equation is an elegant description of the first order condition of a representative agent with perfect foresight. That agent does not exist. A much better foundation for understanding how consumption moves over time was Friedmanâs permanent income hypothesis. And since the work of Truman Bewley, we have a firm foundation for that equation that is grounded in borrowing constraints and incomplete markets in a heterogeneous agent model.
2. The NK Phillips curve does not characterize any observable empirical regularity. It never has. The original Phillips curve, a connection between wage inflation and unemployment in UK data, disappeared soon after Phillips published his eponymous article. The reason it takes a semester to teach the NK Phillips curve is that it requires a set of ugly non refutable theoretical contortions that only a mother could love.
3. The NK model has no unemployment. People voluntarily change their labor supply behavior in response to âshocksâ, the consequences of which are correctly forecast. That assumption does not fit with what we know about labor markets. I blogged about that here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2014/12/real-businessâŠ
4. The NK model assumes that employment (not unemployment) fluctuates around a stationary ânatural rate of unemploymentâ. I wrote about that here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Fed economists spend countless hours attempting to estimate this ânatural rateâ. This is a Sisyphean task since the unemployment rate in data is essentially a random walk.
The correct strategy at this point is to abandon much of the rational expectations revolution and to reconstruct macroeconomics beginning with what we knew circa 1960. This, I believe, is already beginning. There is a large body of theorists working on Bewley models and that group has concluded that rational expectations was a misstep. See, for example, the recent working paper by @ben_moll
benjaminmoll.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/challenge.pdf
I am not as convinced as Ben, that our models must be nonlinear with global solution methods since, if Benâs approach is successful, even linearized models in aggregates will likely display very different properties from either NK or classical RBC economies. But dropping the full implications of rational expectations is a promising way forward.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
I donât like the word âscienceâ for this sort of thing.
But this is a very useful way to understand the world, consider some of the most important macroeconomic policy debates, and a flexible framework that you can build on to add different nuances and complexities. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âŠ. in conjunction with a great Canadian economist (who also is a mean soccer player) âŠ
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
Reforma laboral en Argentina. Importantisimo.
Un concepto importante: si intentas proteger al trabajador se reduce el incentivo a la contrataciĂłn y la eficiencia del mercado labora.
AcĂĄ uno de los mejores papers sobre este tema escrito por un gran economista argentino. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Rien ne marche dans ce modĂšle pourtant au cĆur de la macro mainstream :
â Courbe de Phillips (eq.1) : rejetĂ©e par les donnĂ©es,
â Ăquation dâEuler (eq.2) : idem.
Et pourtant, on continue Ă lâenseigner (et Ă lâutiliser !) comme si de rien nâĂ©tait.đ€·ââïž
Quand est-ce quâon avance ?đ
Jack Meyer đïž
@Jackbmeyer
Economists will look you dead in the face and call this science
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes @FrancoisGeerolf The economics profession imposes strong penalties on independent thought and it enforces them through gatekeepers at a small set of prestigious journals where acceptance is a prerequisite for tenure. Heresy is not tolerated.
On a critique of the Phillips curve, here is a link to a piece I wrote when I was at the Bank of England as a Houblon Norman Fellow
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
François Geerolf
@FrancoisGeerolf
Pour avoir osé critiquer la "courbe de Phillips", je peux vous dire que la discussion avec les macroéconomistes mainstream sur ce sujet, hélas, n'est pas possible - ce qui, pour moi, n'est pas une attitude scientifique !
Je suis d'accord avec Roger Farmer:
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many âshocksâ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, âscience progresses one funeral at a timeâ. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The strong form of the critique is that is irrefutable. That makes it religion rather than science. A weaker form, drawing on the ideas of Imre Lakatos, cursosfilos.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/procâŠ
is that it is a degenerative research program. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.97.3.586 are engineered to fit the data by adding as many âshocksâ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates.
Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, âscience progresses one funeral at a timeâ. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
Ricardo Reis
@R2Rsquared
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
We do criticize it. Thatâs how science progresses. Here is how I see a way to make progress
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Steven Hail
@StevenHailAus
I do understand it and I do criticize it.
I fail to see why people who do deeply understand it don't criticize it.
Neoclassical economics, I mean.
Because heterodox economists are economists too, and in most cases better equipped for the job.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Economists do not consider âneoclassical economistsâ to be âmathematical economistsâ. We call them âeconomistsâ. Mathematical economists are distinct from economists in the same way that mathematical physicists are distinct from physicists. If you want to criticize economics as it is currently practiced, it helps to first understand it. That requires competency in economic history, statistics and basic logic â aka mathematics. @dagarrok @GregoryBesharov
Daniel Garro
@DAGARROK
Mathematical economists, such as neoclassical economists, are a merger between economists who do not know mathematics and mathematicians who do not know economics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Professor Eric Rasmusen
@erasmuse
Economics is like physics in that it is possible to do economics without using math, just as Galileo did physics without math, but it's hard to get very far. Math makes econ easier; it takes someone very clever indeed to do econ without math.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Economists do not consider âneoclassical economistsâ to be âmathematical economistsâ. We call them âeconomistsâ. Mathematical economists are distinct from economists in the same way that mathematical physicists are distinct from physicists. If you want to criticize economics as it is currently practiced, it helps to first understand it. That requires competency in economic history, statistics and basic logic â aka mathematics. @dagarrok @GregoryBesharov
Daniel Garro
@DAGARROK
Mathematical economists, such as neoclassical economists, are a merger between economists who do not know mathematics and mathematicians who do not know economics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Professor Eric Rasmusen
@erasmuse
Economics is like physics in that it is possible to do economics without using math, just as Galileo did physics without math, but it's hard to get very far. Math makes econ easier; it takes someone very clever indeed to do econ without math.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm trying to. Iâll let you know when I succeed.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Economists do not consider âneoclassical economistsâ to be âmathematical economistsâ. We call them âeconomistsâ. Mathematical economists are distinct from economists in the same way that mathematical physicists are distinct from physicists. If you want to criticize economics as it is currently practiced, it helps to first understand it. That requires competency in economic history, statistics and basic logic â aka mathematics. @dagarrok @GregoryBesharov
Daniel Garro
@DAGARROK
Mathematical economists, such as neoclassical economists, are a merger between economists who do not know mathematics and mathematicians who do not know economics.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
By referencing Hayek in defense of markets I engendered an interesting exchange between @PureThe0ry and @DFangary on Pareto Optimality, the Welfare Theorems and economic Liberty.
Economists and all other social scientists are to some extent talking at cross purposes. Liberty is used in two different ways: economic Liberty and political liberty. The welfare theorems are an elegant statement of the benefits of economic Liberty. Given a fixed set of assumptions about what constitutes a human being â market exchange increases the welfare of both parties to that exchange.
Since the advent of marginalism in the mid nineteenth century, economists agree that a human being is completely characterized by his/her preference ordering. This would have been anathema to Mill who presented a compelling defense of free speech in his essay on Liberty. www.gutenberg.org/files/34901/34901-h/34901-h.htm
To make sense of Mill, one cannot adopt the marginalist interpretation of a human being.
Imagine a debate between two impassioned people, one who supports one side of an issue to which the other is opposed. To the economist, the only purpose of such a debate is the exchange of information that enables the opponent to better act on his or her innate preferences. A better description of the role of debate, and one favored by other social scientists, is to change those preferences.
In advance of their discussion, one person prefers choice âaâ to choices âbâ and âcâ. The goal of his interlocutor is to persuade his opponent to leave the debate with the alternative preference of âbâ over âaâ and âcâ.
The distinction between economic and political liberty has profound consequences for the notion of Pareto optimality and the welfare theorems since, if preference ordering are subject to change, it is not clear that free market exchange is always beneficial. Arguments of this nature are required to support, for example, prohibition of a free market for fentanyl and other âharmfulâ substances.
One can still be a defender of free speech: but the arguments in favor cannot be defended on the same grounds as the economic case for free markets, based as it is, on the invariance of individual preferences. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
Unfortunately, many of them are rather prominent and the entire profession will get stained with "you guys said Milei would fail." A handful of people, all known to be strongly on the progressive side of every debate, said he would fail.
That should read as economists can be blinded by politics, not as an indictment of the entire profession. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I donât think so. Langeâs argument was destroyed by Hayek in his 1945 AER paper on the role of knowledge in society.
www.econlib.org/library/Essays/hykKnw.htmldavideđ©đ» @criticofpolecon
Free market based neoclassical economics died in 1938 when Lange and Taylor showed that the best way to realize neoclassical assumptions of pareto optimal distribution was through the state. There's no reason other than preferences for capitalism to believe otherwise.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
What kinds of interventions might be worse than the disease? Any proposed institution has the possibility of making the situation worse. Some institutions survive. The US constitution is one such success story. The joint stock company is another.
Eros Morales
@CCMarimba
Would self-regulating institutions likely be a variation of for-profit firms? Competing polities? What kinds of government intervention are least likely to be worse than disease? Buying shares of index funds? AMCs? Mortgage subsidies? R&D subsidies? Birth subsidies?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Robert Lucas formalized the idea of constant flux as a stationary probability measure. That concept is completely consistent with the Austrian notion of constant random change in preferences, endowments and technology and once one recognizes that rational expectations equilibria are indeterminate, it also allows for constant random change in beliefs. What it misses, is the Keynesian idea that the location of the stationary probability measure is itself subject to the whims of investors.
Austrians â as well as new classical and new Keynesians â all believe that the economy is fluctuating around a unique (and in some sense optimal) level of employment. The central message of the General Theory, was that the random fluctuations of a market economy can get stuck fluctuating around a level with the wrong (not socially optimal) level of employment. The New Keynesian model does not capture that idea. That is why I do not consider myself a New Keynesian
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
What the Austrians ⊠and Hayek in particular ⊠do get right is the notion that the cure â government intervention â is often worse than the disease. He refers to this idea as the âFatal Conceitâ. But Hayek did not, IMO, go far enough. Just as private institutions are evolutionary, so are political institutions. The search should be for self-regulating institutions that foster human freedom. Market capitalism is not a monolithic concept. It functions within the boundaries of a set of political and cultural boundaries that are themselves evolving: for better or worse.@GeneSohoForum
Gene Epstein
@GeneSohoForum
No proper student of Austrian economics believes that "equilibrium is the normal state of a free market system." The normal state of a free market: CONSTANT FLUX, from constant change in consumer preferences, resource availability (including labor) & persistent entrepreneurship.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Another excellent video from @EdConwaySky : This one on rare earths. Highly recommended!
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
đ„ What on earth are rare earths?
Why do they matter so much?
Why do they nearly all come from China?
And how worried should we be about the latest chapter in the trade war?
These and more questions answered in my latest primerđThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Nick Rowe
@MacRoweNick
I (@farmerrf too) was fortunate to take his Advanced Macro class, in the UWO PhD program, 1978 or 1979. Taught us Disequilibrium Macro. Great teacher. Good to see him get the Nobel.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations to the winners of this yearâs Nobel Prize in Economics. Peter Howitt, Joel Mokyr and Philippe Aghion. Peter was my advisor at the University of Western Ontario, now known just as Western University. @WesternU
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2025 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Joel Mokyr, Philippe Aghion and Peter Howitt âfor having explained innovation-driven economic growthâ with one half to Mokyr âfor having identified the prerequisites for sustained growth through technological progressâ and the other half jointly to Aghion and Howitt âfor the theory of sustained growth through creative destruction.â
#nobelprize -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes I agree with all of this. But reading Laidlerâs discussion on nineteenth and early twentieth century monetary theory is enlightening to a modern theorist, like me, schooled largely in the era of rational expectations. His book on the golden Age of the Quantity Theory is well worth reading.
There are two interesting questions for theorists in the fiat money era. 1. How do monetary systems operate in a corridor as opposed to a floor system. 2. Why is inflation unexplained in the short to medium term by almost any lagged variable except for its own history.
Wicksell and his contemporaries viewed the system as anchored by price level expectations; an assumption that is consistent with price level indeterminacy in DSGE models under interest rate control. There is a swing back amongst macro theorists to abandoning the rational expectations assumption. IMO, that is a positive development. We still have much to learn from our predecessors in the âGolden Ageâ. @JamesYo43532848 @GeorgeSelgin @MacRoweNick @dandolfa
James Young
@JamesYo43532848
Laidlerâs 1983 note is a thoughtful clarification of Real Bills debates under convertibility. But it is anachronistic for fiat systems.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Probably not looking so good for non US citizens applying for academic jobs in the U.S. The newly instituted 100k payment to recruit HB1 visa applicants will make U.S. citizens much more attractive to potential employers; both academic and non-academic. And foreign applications to U.S. Ph.D. programs are also likely to drop as a knock-on effect.
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
Academic job market looking a lot better!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
JamesSmithNIESR
@JamesSmithNIESR
As expected, BoE keeps rates on hold at 4% (with two members voting for 0.25ppts cut) as it juggles higher near-term inflation and weaker labour market. Bigger news is the slowing of QT sales to ÂŁ70bn and skewing to shorter maturities. Thread on all that to follow...
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm looking forward to the finished book @DeirdreMcClosk
Deirdre Nansen McCloskey
@DeirdreMcClosk
Iâm writing a big book touching on the âenclosure movementâ of the 1700s in England.
A lot of educated people, especially if theyâve read Marx, have heard about enclosures.
Most of what they know ainât so.
My latest column for @folha -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
More concerning is the possibility that the next generation of students wonât *be able* to write in longhand on a notepad because they are not being taught cursive writing â let alone shown how to multiply and divide numbers without the benefit of a calculator. @sapinker
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maher:
Have college students changed in recent years? Do they have trouble keeping up with the amount of reading that used to be required?
Me:
The answer is yes, they have declined. I can see it in my own class, which I've taught for 22 years. So we had a meeting with the dean at Harvard because grades keep getting higher. 80% of students get an A. The average GPA is 3.8 out of 4.
Maher:
Grade inflation, they call it.
Me:
No, they don't. The dean said, we prefer to call it "grade compression."
Maher:
Oh (with a hand clap, head roll back, and sigh).
Me:
Maybe our students are just getting better and better. So I knew this was malarkey, so I actually had the data, because I've been giving kind of the same exam for 22 years, and it's multiple choice, so it's subjective. So there's a constant benchmark, and performance has been going down, at least in my class. 10 percentage points from 2004 to now. So the standards have been going down. Students do read less. I think they spend more time on extracurriculars than on classwork, and I just know that...
Maher:
Scrolling, scrolling.
Me:
That's when they're in the room, yes.
Maher:
I have to tell you, they're not going to read your book, not because it's not great. It is. It's a book. They won't read this. I read a letter that a student wrote to the Crimson, saying you can get out of this university without having fully read a whole book.
Me:
That might be true. Now I've got to say, there are a lot of really brilliant, really studious Harvard students, like intimidatingly smart. But there's also a lot for whom it's kind of a luxury cruise, and academics is just one of the activities. So our dean, to be fair, our dean has noticed, and she has changed the guidelines going forward. She's actually told students--you wouldn't think this would be a shock--academics is your first priority. Now the fact that she had to say that, this is a kind of a radical new policy. She said that it's okay for professors to take attendance in lectures, which I'm going to start doing. That it's okay to ban electronic devices, which I might start doing. Because we actually know that taking notes leads to better memory than using a screen. Just a principle of cognitive psychology, when you have to think hard about something, when you've got to process its meaning, when it's not just a bunch of words, then you actually remember better. Just the process of writing puts it in your brain. But a lot of them have screens. There are electronic note-taking devices, but they're not as fluid and easy as the old-fashioned pen and paper. So my teaching assistants are going to hate this, because we're going to have to schlep handouts to class every time.
Full Overtime episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhQE7sCg64k
@RealTimers @billmaher -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece on the revival of US manufacturing from @joelkotkin on @unherd is insightful and well worth reading.
unherd.com/2025/09/trumps-factory-revival-is-happening/?e⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
đœïžIs Britain REALLY facing a 1970s-style fiscal crisis?
Why are investors so freaked out about UK debt?
Is this REALLY worse than under Liz Truss?
Who's to blame? Rachel Reeves? The Bank of England?
And would a bit of productivity really solve everything?
đ Your 6 min primerđThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for pointing out the text in the image @nickgillespie Nick. This is how it looked in my browser.
Yes $8 trillion in tariff revenues is insane. And yes, $8 trillion in investments is likely an exaggeration. But the claim that Trumpâs trade policies have driven trillions of dollars of investment to the U.S. is not insane.
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
The image the White House posted literally claims '$8 trillion in tariff revenue.' His various claims for new investment are bunkum too: www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/fact-check-trump-9-trillion-us-iâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I donât understand your point @nickgillespie. The White House post you cite does not claim $8 trillion in tariff revenues. It claims $8 trillion in promised investments. I agree that may be an overestimate. But it has nothing to do with tariff revenues. Here is the response of grok to a query on promised investments:
âThe total promised investment in the US under the current Trump administration, as reported by various sources, is not consistently quantified across all references, with figures ranging significantly based on different announcements and contexts. The White House and related reports have cited figures as high as $14 trillion in total investments since President Trump took office in January 2025. However, specific breakdowns and expert analyses suggest a more conservative estimate. For instance, the White House reported $5.1 trillion in promised investments, with $4.3 trillion newly pledged, though experts caution that $2.1 trillion of this may not fully materialize.â
I would also point out that the catastrophe predicted by most academic economists, as a consequence of Trumpâs trade policies, have not yet materialized. I am skeptical that they will ever materialize. Academia â at least in the non experimental disciplines â is characterized by a degree of groupthink that makes the Salem Witch Trials look like the epitome of rational thought.
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
Amazing--and insanely wrong! Trump claims '$8 trillion in tariff revenue.' In all of 2024, total imports came to $3.7 trillion.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Matti Viren
@viren_matti
TÀssÀ Farmerilta ("big name") nÀyttöÀ siitÀ, miten marginaaliveron nosto 40 --> 50 ja lasku 50 --> 45 vaikuttivat verotuloihin. Farmerin arvio on, ettÀ Laffer-kÀyrÀn huippu on jossain 40:n ja 50:n prosentin vÀlillÀ.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A Blog about the Laffer Curve in the UK. @BobMurphyEcon @NIESRorg @jagjit_chadha @warwickecon @carney
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/8/30/uk-evidenceâŠ
"I wrote this piece in 2022 when Liz Truss was Prime Minister. I am reposting it now in light of the recent piece by David Aikman, Director of NIESR who is advocating for tax increases in the UK in the Autumn budget.
If the government follows that advice, and if marginal rates are increased on high earners, there is likely to be a further exodus of high net worth individuals and a possible drop in revenue to the UK Treasury.
I present some evidence from the Osbourne tax experiment from 2010 to 2012 to support my argument." -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A Blog about the Laffer Curve in the UK. @BobMurphyEcon @NIESRorg @jagjit_chadha @warwickecon @carney
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/8/30/uk-evidenceâŠ
"I wrote this piece in 2022 when Liz Truss was Prime Minister. I am reposting it now in light of the recent piece by David Aikman, Director of NIESR who is advocating for tax increases in the UK in the Autumn budget.
If the government follows that advice, and if marginal rates are increased on high earners, there is likely to be a further exodus of high net worth individuals and a possible drop in revenue to the UK Treasury.
I present some evidence from the Osbourne tax experiment from 2010 to 2012 to support my argument." -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Bob Murphy defends the idea that tax cuts do not imply reductions in tax revenues. He is right.
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/8/30/uk-evidenceâŠ
Robert P. Murphy
@BobMurphyEcon
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A Blog about the Laffer Curve in the UK. @BobMurphyEcon @NIESRorg @jagjit_chadha @warwickecon @carney
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/8/30/uk-evidenceâŠ
"I wrote this piece in 2022 when Liz Truss was Prime Minister. I am reposting it now in light of the recent piece by David Aikman, Director of NIESR who is advocating for tax increases in the UK in the Autumn budget.
If the government follows that advice, and if marginal rates are increased on high earners, there is likely to be a further exodus of high net worth individuals and a possible drop in revenue to the UK Treasury.
I present some evidence from the Osbourne tax experiment from 2010 to 2012 to support my argument." -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Although I understand your logic: it is misleading to equate inflation with âa rise in the price levelâ. If the price level was well described by an ARIMA(1,0,0) and you were to observe that the price level in February was higher than the price level in January: would you call that inflation?
Nick Rowe
@MacRoweNick
"Do tariffs cause inflation (i.e. a rise in the Price level)?"
I want to approach this in a very roundabout way, and start with a totally different question:
"Suppose you have a revenue-neutral cut in income tax and increase in VAT. Would that cause a rise in P?"
1/n -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
My concerns are summarized here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
And this is just 12 years old. When I wrote this piece it was considered heretical to criticize the natural rate hypothesis. So much so that it took the intervention of Mark Carney â who was then the Governor of the Bank of England â to overrule the Bank censors who wanted to bin it.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
When you click on a paper expecting to see it's from the 90s, but realize the GFC was almost 20 years ago. đ
I'll be sure to check this out!
I'm curious, though, what are your main concerns about the (NK)PC? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
David Aikman @NIESRorg lays out clearly the trilemma facing the UK: 1. loosen fiscal rules and risk the wrath of the bond vigilantes 2. Cut spending and further decimate public services or 3. Raise taxes. He argues for 3 and that VAT, income taxes and or national insurance contributions must rise, perhaps substantially, to provide a buffer to future shocks.
I am not convinced by this argument. In Argentina, Javier Milei has demonstrated that reducing the size of the government sector can lead to growth while reducing inequality and inflation and simultaneously bringing down the ratio of debt to GDP. Might this be an approach the UK could profitably emulate?
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
@NIESRorg
#weekendreadingđ"The Autumn #budget will be the moment of truth. If the #chancellor continues to pretend that all three corners of the #trilemma can be met, she risks being forced into a crisis-driven choice later"
Director David Aikman explains here đ
niesr.ac.uk/news/tax-rises-are-sensible-solution-chancell⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes I agree with all of this. And yes: the standard Phillips Curve paradigm is wrong. And yes: there is evidence that V is I(1). I wrote about this nearly 20 years ago.
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
The correct way to frame the argument uses cointegration: M, P and Y are nonstationary, but cointegrated so that V is covariance stationary. And that seems to be true in US data.
Older papers such as Friedman and Kuttner (1992) cast doubt on this claim, but more recent papers (e.g., Hendrickson (2013), Belongia and Ireland (2019)) largely support the claim that velocity is stationary.
The reason for earlier rejection is simple: they used simple sum aggregates which demonstrably cannot measure what theory calls money -- because the underlying assets are not perfect substitutes, you can't just add them up. Stated differently, they tested a theory about apples using data on bananas and found that it didn't work well.
Also, whether you like that point of view or not, that equation still holds in standard New Keynesian models. If your preferred view is built around a (NK) Philips curve, you would be telling a different, yet equivalent story to the one you would tell from MV=PY. For the same reason, if V~I(1) instead of I(0), a lot of standard models used to discuss inflation are wrong.
James Harrigan
@jamesharrigan
"Inflation [...] depends on how fast the quantity of money is increasing relative to real economic growth."
Really Roger, that's the whole story of inflation? MV = PY with constant V? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If Bessent gets the 3% growth heâs predicting this may be less of a concern. I would not bet against him.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
My concern is that fiscal policy in the US will remain irresponsible and it is no longer unthinkable that we get a Turkey-style experiment with monetary policy as a side dish.
And I don't see which politician is going to start shreding regulations. The supposedly right wing party decided the government needs to be more involved in almost every dossier they have touched since they started. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Christopher Phelan
@ChrisPhelanEcon
I'm reading that all economists said that tariffs would be inflationary. When @TimTkehoe and I did a forum on this, we disagreed on a lot, but we agreed on the obvious: a one-time increase in tariffs might cause a one-time increase in prices. That's not inflation.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
St. Louis Fed
@stlouisfed
Trimmed mean PCE inflation rate for the 12 months ending in July was 2.7%, unchanged from June's rounded rate. For more on the @DallasFed alternative measure of core inflation, see FRED: fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1LUCc
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No. But I wouldn't venture to predict the sign of the effect.
Joseph Steinberg
@jbsteinberg
Is it your contention that tariffs (at least, high & broad tariffs like now) have no effect on Y?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Nice poetry. Now explain how that works with a well defined model that explains the facts as well or better than the quantity theory of money.
Itamar Caspi
@itamarcaspi
Relative price changes don't cause inflation, buy they are sparks. Whether they cause a bonfire of inflation depends on how dry the monetary and fiscal kindling is
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Taxes alter RELATIVE prices. An economy produces apples and oranges.
Here is a simple example. An apple costs 1$. An orange costs 1$. Income is twenty dollars. Consumers spend half their income on consumption goods (10$) and they save the other half (10$).
Of the half spent on consumption goods, half is spent on apples (5$) and half on oranges (5$). The government imposes a tax on apples and redistributes the proceeds as a lump sum to consumers.
What happens to prices?
The RELATIVE price of apples increases. Before the tax and apple cost 1 orange. After the tax an apple costs MORE than one orange. But an orange costs LESS than one apple. An orange has become RELATIVELY cheaper.
What determines ABSOLUTE prices. Why did an apple and an orange each cost 1$ before the tax increase? Because money prices are determined by how much of their savings is held as money as opposed to interest bearing assets like Treasuries. The composition of savings (10$) between money and Treasuries depends on the interest rate.
Here is the key point:
THERE IS NO REASON for the decision to hold money to be altered in any particular direction by a change in the RELATIVE prices of apples and oranges.
Eyal Rozenman
@eyalroz
Why would a tax make something cheaper?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes. M, P and Y have trends and are well described as I(1) time series. V is stationary and is well described by an I(0) time series. Tariffs do not change the growth rates of M, or Y. Ergo: tariffs do not cause inflation.
James Harrigan
@jamesharrigan
"Inflation [...] depends on how fast the quantity of money is increasing relative to real economic growth."
Really Roger, that's the whole story of inflation? MV = PY with constant V? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The difference is that a data driven central bank is supposed to âlook throughâ temporary shocks to the price level in order to anchor inflation expectations.
Tristan
@TJS_MVPY
But in theory, tariffs could lead to a general rise in unit production costs- a rise in the price level driven by a decline in productivity. I wouldnât consider that inflation, as itâs not a persistent rise; but to a data dependent central bank, whatâs the difference?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Tariffs change relative prices. Some goods become more expensive, others become cheaper.
Inflation is the rate at which the average price of all goods and services increase year on year and it depends on how fast the quantity of money is increasing relative to real economic growth.
Tariffs do not cause inflation. This is not rocket science.
Heather Long
@byHeatherLong
PCE inflation came in just as expected for July:
2.6% (y/y) PCE inflation
2.9% (y/y) "Core" PCE inflation excluding food and energy
PCE inflation was up 0.2% for the month
Core PCE inflation was up 0.3% for the month
Bottom line: Inflation has clearly ticked up from the April lows, but the full extent of the tariffs isn't showing up yet. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Seven minutes well spent! @EdConwaySky focuses on default risk as a possible explanation for the rising term premium. Surely inflation expectations are also a contender?
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
Anyone fancy seven minutes of prime time morning TV on what on earth is happening to government bond yields?
Thought so. Here you gođThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Another great economist has left us. Charlie Plosser was one of the founding fathers of Real Business Cycle Theory and a warm and caring human being. Iâll fondly remember our many conversations over the years. Weâll miss you Charlie.
Jon Hartley
@Jon_Hartley_
RIP Charlie Plosser, former @PhiladelphiaFed President 2006-2015 during Great Recession. Lucas-Prescott-Sargent student. Work on RBCs. King and Plosser (1988) started production networks in macro, now popular. JME coeditor, SOMC member, @HooverInst Visiting Fellow. Great golfer!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
âRelying on AI at a formative stage isnât just bad for academic integrity; it is quietly sabotaging the process by which we become original thinkers. To create for no reason other than the need to do so is the very essence of our species, and unless we preserve this spirit, it might go extinct before we can even remember what it ever felt like.â
newuniversity.org/2025/08/18/the-quiet-extinction-of-crea⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I listened to this clip @BobMurphyEcon, in which you explain your disagreement with @GeorgeSelgin, and I found it quite confusing. I have not watched the entire episode; so perhaps I am missing something. but let me summarize what I perceive to be your position.
1. The question, and disagreement with George, appears to be: is fractional reserve banking (FRB) distortionary?
2. Your position Bob appears to be: yes. The discussion is framed in terms whether or not the quantity of savings in a FRB economy, and by implication the equilibrium real interest rate, is unchanged in an FRB economy as opposed to an economy with 100% reserve requirements.
3. If this indeed your argument, and correct me if Iâm wrong, I must disagree.
4. In a world of free banking, the money interest rate on deposits will differ from the money interest rate on loans.
5. I will assume that all banks hold the same reserve ratio of gold to deposits although, in practice, there may be a spectrum of banks some of which are less liable to fail as a consequence of holding more reserves. Those banks will, in equilibrium, pay a lower interest rate to their depositors. But in a free banking equilibrium, interest rates on loans and deposits will adjust to the point where there is no incentive for the creation of new banks.
6. Consider the thought experiment of moving from a regulated environment with 100% reserve requirements to a free banking environment where the market allows institutions to hold fractional reserves.
7. I maintain that, following a period of adjustment to a new steady state, the exercise of allowing free banking will, abstracting from risk, be functionally equivalent to an alternative experiment of a helicopter drop of gold on all holders of gold. (Assuming gold has no use other than as a medium of exchange). The price level will increase but the spectrum of real interest rates, and of saving and investment in productive capital, will all remain unchanged.
8. That does not make me a proponent of free banking since I see no social benefit in an increase in the nominal quantity of money in circulation. It is the real quantity that matters. To the contrary: to the extent that fractional reserve banking introduces additional potential for bank runs it is likely to reduce social welfare.@Proflawrenceh1
Robert P. Murphy
@BobMurphyEcon
Buried at the tail end of my latest Human Action episode is a 13-min critique of @GeorgeSelgin 's position whereby he argues people who hold bank deposits are providing the savings which justifies excess loans.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I listened to this clip @BobMurphyEcon, in which you explain your disagreement with @GeorgeSelgin, and I found it quite confusing. I have not watched the entire episode; so perhaps I am missing something. but let me summarize what I perceive to be your position.
1. The question, and disagreement with George, appears to be: is fractional reserve banking (FRB) distortionary?
2. Your position Bob appears to be: yes. The discussion is framed in terms whether or not the quantity of savings in a FRB economy, and by implication the equilibrium real interest rate, is unchanged in an FRB economy as opposed to an economy with 100% reserve requirements.
3. If this indeed your argument, and correct me if Iâm wrong, I must disagree.
4. In a world of free banking, the money interest rate on deposits will differ from the money interest rate on loans.
5. I will assume that all banks hold the same reserve ratio of gold to deposits although, in practice, there may be a spectrum of banks some of which are less liable to fail as a consequence of holding more reserves. Those banks will, in equilibrium, pay a lower interest rate to their depositors. But in a free banking equilibrium, interest rates on loans and deposits will adjust to the point where there is no incentive for the creation of new banks.
6. Consider the thought experiment of moving from a regulated environment with 100% reserve requirements to a free banking environment where the market allows institutions to hold fractional reserves.
7. I maintain that, following a period of adjustment to a new steady state, the exercise of allowing free banking will, abstracting from risk, be functionally equivalent to an alternative experiment of a helicopter drop of gold on all holders of gold. (Assuming gold has no use other than as a medium of exchange). The price level will increase but the spectrum of real interest rates, and of saving and investment in productive capital, will all remain unchanged.
8. That does not make me a proponent of free banking since I see no social benefit in an increase in the nominal quantity of money in circulation. It is the real quantity that matters. To the contrary: to the extent that fractional reserve banking introduces additional potential for bank runs it is likely to reduce social welfare.@Proflawrenceh1
Robert P. Murphy
@BobMurphyEcon
Buried at the tail end of my latest Human Action episode is a 13-min critique of @GeorgeSelgin 's position whereby he argues people who hold bank deposits are providing the savings which justifies excess loans.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
looks like a great program
Matthew E. Kahn
@mattkahn1966
Some quotes from Ranciere and Soames. Can economists and philosophers "profit" from interacting?
www.uscannenbergmedia.com/2019/11/19/usc-offering-new-maj⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Waller would be a great choice.
RenMac: Renaissance Macro Research
@RenMacLLC
This sounds like something Bessent would say. So a bet on Waller is a bet on Bessentâs influence with Trump.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Interesting piece on why, in the recent jobs report, native born Americans gained significantly â while foreign born Americans lost out. The data are self reported in a survey and reporting as foreign born may not be the smart thing to do in the current climate.
Financial Times
@FT
Or maybe the labour statistics are a mess, writes FT's Alphaville. www.ft.com/content/dfd8646f-8acf-4c48-90cb-670a0ee53b35
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I was sad to hear of the passing of Peter Temin. news.mit.edu/2025/professor-emeritus-peter-temin-dies-0806 Peter was a strong defender of the teaching of economic history as part of any core graduate curriculum. Sadly, that perspective is vanishing from economics departments throughout the world. Farewell Peter; you will be missed.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The relative prices of some final goods will increase. But food and energy prices are likely to fall as a consequence of current US policies. And real wages will increase as a result of forcing US physical and intellectual capital to combine with a more limited pool of US unskilled labor as opposed to a much larger pool of unskilled foreign labor (Stolper-Samuelson). And even though manufacturing is a smaller share of employment than services, a large part of the service sector produces non trade-able goods. Wages in the service sector are set through competition with manufacturing. So yes; to the extent that tariffs aid in reshoreing manufacturing they will increase US unskilled wages. @johnbarrdear @BaldwinRE
John Barrdear
@JohnBarrdear
Hi Roger. Just to clarify, are you saying that you think the imposition of tariffs by America wonât materially raise final-good prices, but will raise âlow skillâ wages?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John Barrdear
@JohnBarrdear
Hi Roger. Just to clarify, are you saying that you think the imposition of tariffs by America wonât materially raise final-good prices, but will raise âlow skillâ wages?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
Thanks for this Roger. The US is a substantially close economy import to GDP or something like 11%. And the imports from Mexico and Canada arenât really hit. And services account for such a large share of the CPI. so no, I donât think itâll show up too much in the headline CPI. But as we found in Europe people focus on the price of goods that they buy frequently and many of those are imported and weâll see price rises. So the macro shock in the aggregate might not be too huge, but my guess is that Trump base will be very angry that heâs raising prices with his tariffs. âTheyâll have to pay $2 more for their dollsâ.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But do you expect this to have any impact on US inflation Richard @BaldwinRE?: defined as the year on year annualized rate of change of your chosen price index: As opposed to a once and for all change in relative prices. My guess is that it will not impact inflation but will change relative prices.
And the most important relative price, IMO, is the relative price of unskilled labor (aka the blue-collar wage) to the cost of the basket of goods consumed by the median working class household. And that, IMO, will increase. In other words, I predict that, as a result of the tariffs, the average American worker will be better off.
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
Why US tariffs havenât been passed through even more to higher US prices?
1ïžâŁ effective rate todayis âonlyâ 8.8% now
2ïžâŁ but 8Aug tariffs settling into between 15 and 20%, so the effective rate is about to double
3ïžâŁ radical volatility of the tariffs ended; now seem âpermanentâ (Trump adjusted).
â conjecture: pass through will accelerate this quarter -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The relative prices of some final goods will increase. But food and energy prices are likely to fall as a consequence of current US policies. And real wages will increase as a result of forcing US physical and intellectual capital to combine with a more limited pool of US unskilled labor as opposed to a much larger pool of unskilled foreign labor (Stolper-Samuelson). And even though manufacturing is a smaller share of employment than services, a large part of the service sector produces non trade-able goods. Wages in the service sector are set through competition with manufacturing. So yes; to the extent that tariffs aid in reshoreing manufacturing they will increase US unskilled wages. @johnbarrdear @BaldwinRE
John Barrdear
@JohnBarrdear
Hi Roger. Just to clarify, are you saying that you think the imposition of tariffs by America wonât materially raise final-good prices, but will raise âlow skillâ wages?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Inflation is about the balance between the rate of change in the means of payment - measured in dollars -- and the rate of increase in the aggregate quantity of available goods. Unless by 'shocks' you mean a sustained change in the rate of growth of energy and food, measured in physical units, I don't see how a shock can account for a sustained change in the rate of inflation. It is always possible of course, and indeed likely, that shocks take time to work their way through the economy. Perhaps that is what you have in mind?
Saman Darougheh
@DaroughehSaman
Wouldnt One have to make the argument that all none of the sustained inflation post 2022 was stemming from energy and food supply shocks?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But do you expect this to have any impact on US inflation Richard @BaldwinRE?: defined as the year on year annualized rate of change of your chosen price index: As opposed to a once and for all change in relative prices. My guess is that it will not impact inflation but will change relative prices.
And the most important relative price, IMO, is the relative price of unskilled labor (aka the blue-collar wage) to the cost of the basket of goods consumed by the median working class household. And that, IMO, will increase. In other words, I predict that, as a result of the tariffs, the average American worker will be better off.
Richard Baldwin
@BaldwinRE
Why US tariffs havenât been passed through even more to higher US prices?
1ïžâŁ effective rate todayis âonlyâ 8.8% now
2ïžâŁ but 8Aug tariffs settling into between 15 and 20%, so the effective rate is about to double
3ïžâŁ radical volatility of the tariffs ended; now seem âpermanentâ (Trump adjusted).
â conjecture: pass through will accelerate this quarter -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I wrote a blog about this a while back www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2020/5/6/the-peters-p⊠@richardmcngo @olepeters @etale27 @ben_golub I was working with J.P. Bouchaud on an ergodicity paper at the time which was published in the JPE static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
etale27
@etale27
i remember this (now deleted) great thread which seemed to be a convincing takedown of it threadreaderapp.com/thread/1338175642932715520.html
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
JesĂșs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Iâm sharing my slide deck on the demographic future of humanity,
đ Slides: www.sas.upenn.edu/~jesusfv/Slides_London.pdf
prepared for the keynote address I will give tomorrow to the 7th EBRD and CEPR Research Symposium on âThe Economics of Demographic Changeâ:
đ Symposium: www.ebrd.com/home/news-and-events/news/events/economics-oâŠ
Here are a few key ideas Iâll be discussing tomorrow, some of which even economists tracking population trends may not fully appreciate:
1ïžâŁ Fertility is falling everywhere: rich and poor countries alike, booming and stagnating economies, secular and religious societies. The decline is happening far faster than anyone anticipated, even me, ten years ago!
2ïžâŁ For example, Colombiaâs fertility rate is 1.06, Iranâs is 1.44, and Turkeyâs is 1.48, all of which are below the U.S.
3ïžâŁ The decline accelerated around 2014, well before the COVID pandemic.
4ïžâŁ As a result, humanityâs fertility is likely already below the replacement rate.
5ïžâŁ Many assume the replacement rate is 2.1 children per woman. Thatâs true for rich, advanced economies. But not for emerging economies, where selective abortion and higher young female mortality push the replacement rate higher. Thus, for humanity, the replacement rate is closer to 2.2.
6ïžâŁ The 2024 UN World Population Prospects are riddled with data and forecasts that, frankly, make little sense to my coauthor Patrick Norrick (at @AEI) and me.
7ïžâŁ Most of the differences in economic growth among advanced economies over the past 35 years can be attributed to demographic factors. Once adjusted for this, Japanâs economic performance is roughly on par with the U.S. (See my paper with Gustavo Ventura, @King_ofSweden, and Wen Yao, The Wealth of Working Nations):
đwww.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00142921250001âŠ
There are many other ideas (I could talk about this for hours!), but hereâs the punchline: the worldâs fertility crisis is worse than you thought, even after considering you already thought it was bad. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I've written a new blog on trade and tariffs : www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2025/6/28/tariffs-andâŠ
@carney @JamesSurowiecki @BreitbartNews -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@carney argues that the U.S. trade deficit is large and historically unprecedented. @JamesSurowiecki disagrees.
Here are the data. The issue is not: is the trade deficit large? It is. A deficit of 3% of GDP means that we are accumulating a debt to the rest of the world, largely China, at a rate of 3% a year. This is cumulative. But as long as we are financing government budget deficits at a rate of 5% of GDP, and as long as US households are unwilling to save 5% more than they invest domestically, the excess will inevitably appear as a trade deficit.
The right question is: will tariffs reverse the trend? Probably not. That is not to say that tariffs are a mistake. They will help bring manufacturing back to the US and that will benefit blue collar workers as US intellectual and physical capital is increasingly forced to combine with US unskilled labor instead of a billion Chinese unskilled workers.
Tariffs will change relative prices and they will raise the real wages of American blue collar workers. Not just the US workers who are employed by the manufacturing sector. But also all those working in services and non tradeable goods who compete with manufacturing workers. Manufacturing does not have to be large as a fraction of the economy for the manufacturing wage to influence wages throughout the rest of the economy.
As Stolper-Samuelson taught us more then 75 years ago, trade makes the average resident of two trading blocks better off. It does not benefit the owners of labor and capital equally. Workers in a country that is relatively well endowed with capital, like the US, are unambiguously harmed when they are forced to compete, indirectly through trade, with a large pool of foreign unskilled workers.
Trumps pronouncements aside, the trade deficit and tariffs are two disconnected policy concerns. One can favor tariffs without believing they will reverse the trade deficit which is primarily a consequence of the fact that the rest of the world chooses to use the US dollar as a store of wealth and as a means of payment. @JamesSurowiecki @carney @BreitbartNews
John Carney
@carney
They are unusual. No other country in history has ever run such large and persistent trade deficits.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But @NickTimiraos: This statement is about uncertainty over a change in relative prices. It says nothing about inflation which is a sustained increase in the average price of all commodities relative to the dollar. âInflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenonâ. @carney @GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa @MacRoweNick
Nick Timiraos
@NickTimiraos
Powell sums up why the Fed both expects prices to rise in the near term but has such difficulty forecasting the magnitude:
Someone has to pay the tariff, but it's hard to know who.
"There's the manufacturer, the exporter, the importer and the retailer and the consumer. And each one of those is going to be trying not to be the one to pay for the tariff, but together they will all pay together, or maybe one party will pay it all." -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
@NIESRorg
JUST PUBLISHED đ
To what extent it is possible to create a consistent, usable & comprehensive high frequency macroeconomic dataset back to the 1920s & earlier?
This new paper by @jagjit_chadha, @anariazna, Sylaja Srinivasan & Ryland Thomas explores âŹ
niesr.ac.uk/publications/century-high-frequency-uk-macroe⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Greatđ§”from @EdConwaySky on why it might not be a good idea to reopen the blast furnace at Port Talbot. Once it stops operating, a blast furnace becomes a useless chunk of scrap metal.
My takeaway â gleaned from the rest of Edâs thread â the UK must bring down the cost of energy if it has any hope of restoring British manufacturing. And that means abandoning the push for rapid advancement to net zero carbon emissions in the UK.
When offered a choice, the average working class family will choose to put food on the table today over an uncertain future benefit of reducing the UKs contribution to global warming â a small drop in the bucket compared with contributions from India and China.
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
None of this is to dispute UK went way further and faster than nearly every other country in the world in deindustrialising.
This is something I've been banging on about for years.
But for better or worse, there's no easy/cheap way to bring back virgin steelmaking in S Wales. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Leonardo Melosi
@LeonardoMelosi
It was a great honor to deliver the keynote address at the 19th Annual Dynare Conference. My sincere thanks to the organizers for putting together such an engaging and well-run event. Iâm especially grateful to the Bank of Finland for their generous hospitality and support.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
We lost another great with the passing of Stanley Fischer yesterday. I learned undergraduate economics from his textbook with Rudi Dornbusch. And many of the macroeconomists I met as a beginning assistant professor were Stanâs students.
He will be missed. www.ft.com/content/71cf5371-46c3-4214-95d2-e6c5ce11ecf0?s⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Marcus Hagerdorn has left the stage ⊠far too soon.
www.sv.uio.no/econ/english/about/news-and-events/news/202âŠ
Marcus made his reputation in labor search theory but his recent work, sadly incomplete, was varied and interesting ranging from the FTPL to determinacy in incomplete markets models. RIP Marcus. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Warwick Economics strongly represented in Royal Economic Society Founding Fellows List warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/news/2025/5/warwick_econo⊠@warwicknewsroom @uniofwarwick @warwickecon @AbhinayMuthoo @NIESRorg
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
ICYMI
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Cautionary piece from the @resfoundation about increasing the U.K. minimum wage too quickly particularly when NIC contributions are also about to rise.
I would add that the literature on the employment (and welfare) effects of minimum wage increases is more nuanced than the Resolution Foundation x-post suggests. The survey piece pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.35.1.51 by @jeffreypclemens illustrates some of the potential unintended consequences of minimum wage laws.
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
đšNew researchđš
The coming week will be an expensive one for the employers of low-paid workers.
Our latest research assesses the impact of 2025âs minimum wage and employer NICs increases, and looks ahead to the future of the minimum wage—ïž
www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/minimum-wage-ma⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Bill Wells
@billwells_1
When even @resfoundation realises an ever increasing NMW may be a bad idea it is may be time to listen.
Problem stems from the change in remit to @lpcminimumwage in 2015 which aimed to raise NMW even if worker wasn't poor & discount any damaging effects
@TorstenBell @RECNeil -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Cautionary piece from the @resfoundation about increasing the U.K. minimum wage too quickly particularly when NIC contributions are also about to rise.
I would add that the literature on the employment (and welfare) effects of minimum wage increases is more nuanced than the Resolution Foundation x-post suggests. The survey piece pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.35.1.51 by @jeffreypclemens illustrates some of the potential unintended consequences of minimum wage laws.
Resolution Foundation
@resfoundation
đšNew researchđš
The coming week will be an expensive one for the employers of low-paid workers.
Our latest research assesses the impact of 2025âs minimum wage and employer NICs increases, and looks ahead to the future of the minimum wage—ïž
www.resolutionfoundation.org/publications/minimum-wage-ma⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Not sure where 1/10^78 came from ⊠seems a bit precise đ But you are certainly right with the sentiment @S_Surprenant
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
"Imagine a well-functioning centrally planned economy"
We economists can suspend disbelief only so much before we find the thought experiment absurd.
This not only does not exist, but has never even been a good approximation -- not even 1/10^78 of the way there. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This piece by @WallachLori is a must read for the free trade pro-globalization crowd. I was unaware of the JEL piece by Samuelson www2.hawaii.edu/~noy/362texts/samuelson.pdf that she links. It give a simple example in which productivity gains in Chinese manufacturing wipe out U.S. gains from trade with China.
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
Branding tariffs as Trumpian is a mistake.
If you support a carbon border tax to combat climate change, or enforcement of labor standards in trade pacts, you support tariffs, observes @WallachLori. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/democrats-misguided-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Alexander Mihailov
@AlexMihailov65
We thank Prof @farmerrf (@uniofwarwick & @ucla) for an illuminating GEAR QL on how finite lives change insights from OLG models of macro-policy. The background paper & the recording can be consulted free via our website: research.reading.ac.uk/economics/group-for-economic-analyâŠâŠ
@RoyalEconSoc
@UniRdg_Research
Alexander Mihailov
@AlexMihailov65
The 13th GEAR Quarterly Lecture on 19 March
@UniofReading will be given by Prof @farmerrf, free & hybrid. Register via the e-mail address and join via the link in the respective poster here (where you can also view past GEAR QL recordings): research.reading.ac.uk/economics/group-for-economic-analyâŠ
@RoyalEconSoc -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Yep. Adam Smith gets the gist of it all in WoN Book II Chap 2. I wish all students would be assigned it! (Your review too! đ)
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Good question: www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2015/08/a-tale-of-twoâŠ
James Cook (exit poll hater)
@humen64393401
What should u* be?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Maybe 1% is optimistic?
Financial Times
@FT
Here's the market reaction to Rachel Reeves' Spring Statement: www.ft.com/content/775510a0-f926-4308-9945-1c92820f7a06
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well @glyphikon since I wrote a best-selling book about the history of economic thought
www.amazon.com/How-Economy-Works-Confidence-Self-FulfilliâŠ
you might guess that I know at least a little bit about the philosophy of science
Glyph
@glyphikon
Not sure if you're aware of this as a conventional econ guy, but work done in other fields such as the history of economic thought (HET) typically tend to consider the intellectual and philosophical background and evolution of ideas.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
A great follow-up by Roger to my post complaining about Fullerâs lecture about Keynes.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for linking this @GeorgeSelgin I listened to the whole lecture. A few thoughts. @NewmanJ_R @mises_media @mises
1. Who cares if Keynes was a socialist or a âliberal socialistâ. Pretty much all of English academia were socialists and pro-soviet from 1914 until the invasion of Czechoslovakia. A lot of conservative thinkers were communists in their youth. And Keynes, in particular, was notorious for changing his mind.
2. The debate between classical Keynesians and post Keynesians has a lot more to do with how Patinkin tried to integrate Keynes with General Equilibrium theory than it does with ISLM. Here is a better way to do that
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
3. Trying to tie ISLM to socialism is silly. Milton Friedman used the ISLM framework but he was hardly a socialist.
4. There is a throwaway line at the end of the talk that âeveryone knows that business cycles are caused by fractional reserve bankingâ. I have no idea what that is supposed to mean. Bring back the Gold Standard perhaps? That would IMO, be a bad idea.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
What an appalling, small minded, ignorant and dishonest excuse for a lecture supposedly on Keynes and "Modern Macroeconomics." Good luck finding any macroeconomics here, new or old! The talk's only merit is in showing how conspiracy theorists do their thing.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
They oppose fractional reserve banking even with a gold standard. It means outlawing demand deposits. And yes, the theory that fractional reserves cause business cycles is stupid: www.cato.org/blog/fractional-reserve-banking-austrian-bus⊠and www.cato.org/blog/fractional-reserve-banking-austrian-busâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for linking this @GeorgeSelgin I listened to the whole lecture. A few thoughts. @NewmanJ_R @mises_media @mises
1. Who cares if Keynes was a socialist or a âliberal socialistâ. Pretty much all of English academia were socialists and pro-soviet from 1914 until the invasion of Czechoslovakia. A lot of conservative thinkers were communists in their youth. And Keynes, in particular, was notorious for changing his mind.
2. The debate between classical Keynesians and post Keynesians has a lot more to do with how Patinkin tried to integrate Keynes with General Equilibrium theory than it does with ISLM. Here is a better way to do that
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
3. Trying to tie ISLM to socialism is silly. Milton Friedman used the ISLM framework but he was hardly a socialist.
4. There is a throwaway line at the end of the talk that âeveryone knows that business cycles are caused by fractional reserve bankingâ. I have no idea what that is supposed to mean. Bring back the Gold Standard perhaps? That would IMO, be a bad idea.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
What an appalling, small minded, ignorant and dishonest excuse for a lecture supposedly on Keynes and "Modern Macroeconomics." Good luck finding any macroeconomics here, new or old! The talk's only merit is in showing how conspiracy theorists do their thing.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jan Jekielek
@JanJekielek
This is what the Argentina model tells us about DOGE cuts:
When @JMilei took office, Argentina's economy was in free fall with inflation reaching 211%. Milei slashed federal government spending by 30%, axed 10 of Argentina's 18 government ministries, fired 34,000 public employees, and cut hundreds of regulations.
Now, Argentina's economy is turning around, with projections of economic growth at 6% or even higher.
Although Argentina did suffer a GDP reduction of 3.5% in the first year, the private sector grew quickly to fill the gap created by mass government cuts.
And actually there's another important historical parallel here worth discussing, says @profstonge
At the end WWII, the U.S. demobilized over 11 million soldiers and moved them back into the private sector.
America's total GDP dropped by 11.2%.
It was a brutal recession in 1946, followed by a Golden Age leading up through the 1950s and into the 1960s, he says.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Sam Ashworth-Hayes
@SAshworthHayes
For each policy, you need a policy tool, and it's not obvious that the same bodies should be responsible for wildly diverging policy goals. Too many cooks spoil the broth, too many objectives leave you spreading attention too thin.
Sam Ashworth-Hayes
@SAshworthHayes
British policymakers need to memorise the Tinbergen rule. You need one policy instrument for every policy goal you want to achieve; if you try to use an instrument (ISAs) to achieve multiple aims (raising saving rates, investing in British companies) you undermine both.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is classic theory of the second best. John @carney is right to point out that we are not starting from a free trade competitive equilibrium.
John Carney
@carney
A persistent error we see in discussions of Trump trade policies is the assumption that current production reflects free trade and comparative advantage. With this assumption in place, it is easy to show that inventions will cause âwelfare lossâ or make things cost more.
But the assumption of a free trade status quo is wrongâand so the conclusions do not hold.
With an understand of the reality that current production takes place where it does because of prior interventionsâand is therefore not reflective of competition, efficiency, or comparative advantageâyou can see that Trumpian trade intervention can be welfare enhancing, pro-competitive, more efficient, and can push trade toward what it would be under a system where comparative advantage reigned. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
One thing is for sure. We are going to have a lot of informative data in a few more years.
Sid Gundapaneni
@MacroscopeEcon
I worry that even middle class workers or any such subset, will also be worse off.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The word âoverallâ is doing a lot of work here. After the dust settles the result will be, as @econtalker claims, that
ââŠthe number of certain kinds of jobs and the wages of the workers in those jobs [will be higher].â
If tariffs move manufacturing jobs back to the U.S. then there is the possibility that the negative effects of the China Shock â documented by Autor Dorn and Hanson â www.nber.org/papers/w21906 may be partially reversed.
If, as seems likely, the shift in the distribution of income from labor to capital that took place over the past twenty-five years was caused â in part â by the China shock then that shift may also be reversed. Most of the gains in capital income went to the top 1% of the income distribution.
So yes: the arithmetic mean of U.S. income per capita may well be lower than it otherwise might have been. But it is conceivable that the average middle class worker will be better off.
Russ Roberts
@EconTalker
Tariffs will increase the number of certain kinds of jobs and the wages of the workers in those jobs. But it will lower the overall standard of living because it means producing goods at a higher cost than before. Self-sufficiency is the road to poverty. We trade with the rest of the world because it enormously expands what we can enjoy materially. If you try to make everything yourself, yes, you will have all the jobs and be desperately poor. See my novel, The Choice: A Fable of Free Trade and Protectionism.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
My own guess, and it is a guess, is that the markets have a bit further to drop and that weâre looking at â at least â two quarters of recession. When you lay off a good chunk of government employees that has to show up in the GDP numbers. Beyond that, and probably before the midterms, Iâd expect to see a pickup in private sector jobs as deregulation, energy sector jobs and the tech sector expands. That should be accompanied by a return to a bull market for U.S. stocks.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Alexander Mihailov
@AlexMihailov65
The 13th GEAR Quarterly Lecture on 19 March
@UniofReading will be given by Prof @farmerrf, free & hybrid. Register via the e-mail address and join via the link in the respective poster here (where you can also view past GEAR QL recordings): research.reading.ac.uk/economics/group-for-economic-analyâŠ
@RoyalEconSoc -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Casey @caseybmulligan puts forward an argument from Buchanan: the flat tax is a bad idea precisely *because* it is effective at raising revenue at low tax rates â (and incidentally â more efficient). He is worried that governments will have a big incentive to expand when it is so easy to raise revenue. @MacroscopeEcon @FanTastischenDa
Fan Mounier
@FanTastischenDa
Casey Mulligan said it best on the merits of the flat tax proposal in his book review: The Flat Tax is Standard Economics but not Good Common Sense
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The reason we need so many IRS agents is, in part, because of the insane complexity of the current system. A much better solution, but one unlikely to be pursued, is a flat tax as proposed by Bob Hall and Alvin Rabushka and discussed here www.hoover.org/research/flat-tax
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
Accordong to a paper by @NatashaRSarin and @LHSummers, investing in the IRS can lead to sizable increase in tax compliance. The administration is doing exactly the opposite: the resulting decrease in tax compliance will lead to a higher deficit scholarship.law.upenn.edu/faculty_scholarship/2217/
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs not what happened in Argentina. This interview with @fedesturze, Argentinaâs Finance Minister, on Markus Academy @MarkusEconomist is well worth listening to.
James West
@ejwwest
âreduction in domestic income inequalityâ
Sure, because the vast majority have to settle for a uniformly low income. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It would be unwise, IMO, to think that the expenditure cutting language is empty rhetoric or that an Argentina style purge is pure fantasy. We are 46 days into the Trump administration and â according to Grok â DOGE has cut somewhere close to $50 billion (Musk claims $65 billion). Thatâs 1/20th of a trillion ⊠which is the stated feasible objective. And Musk is just getting started.
Federal spending in real terms is still 20-25% higher than pre-pandemic levels and while some of that is due to interest costs and growth in mandated programs like Medicare and social security â the dollar increase since 2019 has been $2.3 trillion on a $4.5 trillion 2019 Federal budget. Cutting a trillion dollars seems, to me, to be a feasible objective. So no, @aledinola, I do not think that the cuts in the IRS budget will lead to an increase in the deficit. @jamesharrigan @izakaminska @gilliantett
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
Thanks for pointing this out @jamesharrigan. The cuts to IRS budget will actually lead to higher government deficit: IRS was seriously understaffed before Biden's reform
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
H/t @izakaminska who links to an FT piece by @gilliantett . Gillian argues that it is unwise to apply conventional economic logic to understand Trumpâs economic policy.
My own take on the impact of the spending cuts on the US economy is that the adjustment will mirror what happened in Argentina. A six month downturn followed by strong growth in the private sector and a reduction in domestic income inequality.
The tariffs will be strongly contractionary in the short run but they are already leading to a realignment of the location of manufacturing. In the longer run there will be a loss of efficiency but a reshoring of entire global value chains and a shift in the US income distribution away from capital and back to domestic labor.
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
The FT's Gillian Tett writes on the Mar-A-Lago accord today, comparing it to the Plaza accord of 1985.
I personally feel the MAL Accord will encompass more than just strategic devaluation (likely a bitcoin component for example, perpetuals or century bonds, and even possibly some debt swaps).
One irony worth noting is that the Plaza hotel was itself bought by Donald Trump in 1988. đ€Ł
She's right about Bessent and co being prepared to weather short-term pain in pursuit of long-term gain though. In fact, it's quite clear they're signalling more pain to come.
This is what many are missing. There is no way to recalibrate the US economy without a wealth transfer. One way to do it is via taxes. Another is by hitting 401ks and conducting anti-corruption drives.
The latter, of course, is what China has come to specialize in: Sporadic but controlled stock-market implosions prompted by regulatory rhetoric with the intended purpose of shaking out the excesses before they fall apart under their own weight.
What this means is that tariff talk rather than Fed Speak is now the mechanism to bust/support the exuberance and initiate wealth transfers.
In that sense it's a subtle transfer of power away from the Fed.
www.ft.com/content/fba87dd3-514a-41c2-b2b9-ea597ffbdfbf? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A return to a commodity standard, gold silver or even bitcoin, would not be a good substitute, IMO, for the lender of last resort function of a central bank. Most likely outcome, if the Fed is abolished, would be interest control by the Treasury. @GeorgeSelgin
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Some hard truths:
âFree bankingâ isnât itself a substitute for the Fed. To get rid of the Fed, Trump must either let the (fiat) USD perish (ouch!), let another agency control it, or make it redeemable in a commodity (e.g. gold or silver) or synthetic commodity (e.g. Bitcoin). -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
At current funding levels, 2035.
Samvel Gev
@samuelgev
Pr, any views on when this reaches a breaking point?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? A Ponzi scheme is a promotional investment in which the promoter claims that he has access to an investment that pays a high return. In reality there is no such investment and instead, the early investors are paid high dividends using the investments of new comers to the scheme. Because the number of people in the world is finite, eventually the scheme collapses and those who came late to the party lose everything.
Social security has elements of a Ponzi scheme since it has never been fully funded. The initial recipients of social security received benefits without paying into the scheme. Instead, the benefits of the old were funded, in part, by the payroll taxes of the young. As long as the population was growing, this scheme was sustainable since the number of new entrants to the scheme, the young, was always greater than the number of recipients; the old. It was a Ponzi scheme with an infinite number of participants.
All that changed about twenty years ago when the population growth rates in almost all western economies fell below the 2.1 live births per mother required for replacement. Now, populations throughout the world are in decline. When this happens, Social Security, funded by the young, becomes unsustainable. It is a Ponzi scheme in the true sense of the word. @BernieSanders @elonmusk
Bernie Sanders
@BernieSanders
Musk says thereâs massive waste & fraud in Social Security. Not true.
Musk says Social Security is a Ponzi scheme. Not true.
What is the goal of this disinformation campaign? To privatize the most successful government program in history and give it over to Wall Street. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs the wrong question. If 90% of the people own only labor and 10% own physical and intellectual capital: the 90% will not vote for free trade in a democracy if it leads to the destruction of trade unions and workers rights. Unless: the media landscape is controlled by the 10%. That was the case before the internet, and before the censors were removed by Muskâs purchase of X. @PeterBlairHenry @BrianCAlbrecht @michaelxpettis @DanielJHannan
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
Whatâs an economic development thatâs had broader sharing of the benefits?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Rakesh Bhandari
@postdiscipline
Old debate here raging about Ricardo, but this seems to be a genuinely new perspective on his trade theory, combining the real history of trade between Portugal and England (and Brazil as well) and Whewell's philosophy of science. www.salon.com/2025/02/01/how-economics-wrecked-the-world-âŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Ricardian model elucidates conditions under which two countries that engage in trade will both benefit, even if one country has more of all of the factors of production. @michaelxpettis is not wrong to interpret that as maximizing production @BrianCAlbrecht. @DanielJHannan.
However, the model does NOT imply that all of the owners of the factors of production in both countries will benefit UNLESS the gains from trade are redistributed domestically. That is often not the case.
In the case of U.S. trade with China, although both countries benefited, workers in the U.S. were harmed by free trade. Cheap tv sets and consumer goods were not enough to compensate for the hollowing out of U.S. manufacturing and the loss of high paying jobs.
In China, the gains from trade flowed primarily to workers whose real wages increased fivefold. In the U.S., the gains from trade flowed primarily to the owners of physical and intellectual capital whose inputs were now combined with an additional 1.5 billion Chinese workers.
China grew rapidly and 1.5 billion Chinese peasants were lifted from poverty. The U.S. stock market soared and the wages of the educated elites increased rapidly. Paradoxically, the effect was to reduce global inequality but to increase inequality in western nations whose workers lost ground from hard fought battles to protect their positions through labor legislation and unionization. So @michaelxpettis is right to point out that not everybody gains from the liberalization of international trade.
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
I agree the Hannan piece is bad. Itâs a failure to think on the margin.
But comparative advantage is explicitly about showing how BOTH parties benefit from trade, not that output is maximized -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is a balanced view of the relative amounts that Europe and the U.S. have put into the Ukraine war as well as an assessment of the possible value of any mineral deal to the U.S. @EdConwaySky
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
đœïž How much have the US and others given in aid to Ukraine? Who's been the most generous? How does it all compare with previous conflicts?
And what's with Donald Trump's money-for-minerals deal?
All the answers in my primer, this time with bonus extra charts đ€This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
RIP Ed Leamer. Ed was a friend and colleague for more than 25 years. @uclaanderson @UCLAEconomics The passing of another giant đ Ed was a huge influence on how I think about the world and a terrific human being. You will be missed Ed.
Bruno Pellegrino
@BPellegrino_CBS
This is a tough post for me to write. One of my PhD advisors, Ed Leamer, passed this morning. He was a terrific mentor, and had a huge impact on how I think about my mission as a researcher. He pushed me to be bold, pragmatic, and an independent thinker, like he was. He was a heck of a role model.
Sebastian Edwards and @UCLAForecast recently honored him with a conference, featuring contributions from @heckmanequation @UncertainLars @Kotlikoff @DeirdreMcClosk - who do a much better job than I ever could of explaining and honoring his legacy and contributions. Below is a link to the recording. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jim Ryan
@ProfJimRyan
Several years ago, we began an effort to tell more of UVAâs story with portraits of people who have shaped this place. Today, we had the chance to honor the legendary Professor of Economics Ken Elzinga, who has taught more than 50,000 UVA students (and counting)âŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Spring is in the air. Saturday in St. James Park
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
James Melville đ
@JamesMelville
This is off the scale brilliant.
â„ïžđ¶This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This @spikedonline piece, linked by @SpeechUnion explains why the UK government demand that Apple provides a back door to user data is troubling. It will compromise privacy for ALL Apple users, not just those based in the UK.
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
đš Apple has caved to UK government demands, stripping its highest level of data security from UK users. This is no accident â Home Secretary Yvette Cooperâs war on online privacy is accelerating.
đ Read why this was always likely to happen.
www.spiked-online.com/2025/02/19/yvette-coopers-war-on-on⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Wise words from @Docstockk
âAs far as I can see, the most economical thing that university funders could do now would be to stop encouraging academics to think they have to demonstrate the monetary value of their research to the general public, and let that extremely costly side of things fall away entirely. And unlike others I can say that now, because thank God I never have to apply to the AHRC again.â
Amen.
unherd.com/2025/02/academia-isnt-about-impact/ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations @cmatthes_econ
Notre Dame Economics
@nd_econ
We are excited to formally announce that accomplished macroeconomist Christian Matthes from Indiana University (@cmatthes_econ) will join our department as a full professor next fall. Welcome to @NotreDame! cm1518.github.io
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well this was predictable after all the other reductions in government departments @doge will soon be turning its attention to the Fed. This post from @VivekGRamaswamy which has been reposted by @elonmusk is a wake-up call for academic economics departments.
A sizable percentage of the jobs for macro-Ph.D.âs over the past thirty years has been to the Board of Governors and to the regional Feds. A second major source of employment is with international organizations like the IMF and the World Bank, both of which rely for a large portion of their budgets on U.S. largesse. I suspect that both of these organizations, along with the Fed, will face a major downsizing in the near future.
A likely consequence will be a reduction in employment opportunities for Ph.D. economists in the public sector.
Vivek Ramaswamy
@VivekGRamaswamy
Hereâs an open secret on Wall Street: the reason investors pay attention to the Fed isnât because the Fed has unique insight, itâs mostly just to understand how the Fed is going to screw it up next. Thereâs ~24k employees at the Fed & thatâs easily 20k too many. Go back to a single mandate of stabilizing the U.S. dollar, period.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This explainer of Trumpâs economic plan from âŠ@yanisvaroufakisâ© is well worth reading and mirrors the position piece that âŠ@SteveMiranâ©, Trumpâs pick for CEA chair, wrote for Hudson Bay Capital www.hudsonbaycapital.com/documents/FG/hudsonbay/research/âŠ
unherd.com/2025/02/why-trumps-tariffs-are-a-masterplan/ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
One example @soechristian is the case of Billy Thompson who was sentenced to 12 weeks in prison in 2004 for commenting "Filthy bastards" on a social media post about police issuing a dispersal order during protests. His comment was deemed offensive under the Communications Act of 2003.
Contrast that with speech laws in the United States where advocating for the assassination of the president on television by public figures was tolerated during the first Trump presidency.
The UK has a long history of tolerance for public criticism and insulting cartoons and commentary directed at politicians and Royalty dating back to the eighteenth century. That tolerance is evaporating rapidly in the current climate.
Christian Soegaard
@soechristian
Which statements can get you imprisoned in the U.K.?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Here is a powerful comment on free speech from @mtaibbiâs testimony to Congress open.substack.com/pub/taibbi/p/my-statement-to-congress-5âŠ
He argues that too many politicians, journalists â and I would add academics â believe that there exists some external âtruthâ that can be discerned by educated people and that it is the role of the media to corral the views of the masses to achieve consensus around these existential facts.
Here is a quote from John Kerry talking at the World Economic Forum
â⊠our First Amendment stands as a major blockâ to our ability to âhammer [misinformation] out of existence.â
Kerryâs view is pervasive in Europe, the UK, Canada and Australia to the extent that âwrongthinkâ is now a crime in the UK and relatively mild statements of dissent, if expressed publicly, can lead to imprisonment.
It is only in the United States that the freedoms developed in eighteenth century Europe, and enshrined in the US constitution, have managed â so far â to mount a resilient defense. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Important piece here from @LiamHalligan on the sorry state of UK finances. Expanding the public sector is unlikely to lead to the growth that is needed to shrink the debt to GDP ratio.
Liam Halligan
@LiamHalligan
My weekly "Economics Agenda" column in @Telegraph often focuses on the UKâs national accounts â with good reason.
Britainâs public finances are in a parlous state, teetering on the brink of systemic meltdown. I don't say this lightly.
In this week's column, I show that, even though our headline national debt figures are alarming, the underlying reality is even worse.
That's because the true scale of our national debt, the liabilities that the government - ie. taxpayers - face is much, much bigger than the numbers we hear discussed in Parliament and on our airwaves.
Serious financial analysts understand this - and the scale of our vast "off-balance sheet" liabilites is another reason why "gilt yields" have been rising.
In other words, the borrowing costs faced by governmment have been going up â along with the related debt interest bill which must be funded by higher taxes and/or even more borrowing.
In 2023/24, the government spent a jaw-dropping ÂŁ107 billion on debt interest â almost 4pc of GDP, around 9pc of all government spending, roughly what the state spends on education !! This is insane - and deeply immoral - and that total is set to rise even more.
The danger is that the state's debts and related interest payments spiral out of control, causing a funding crisis and a market meltdown that does very serious economic and societal damage.
Again, I don't say this lightly - and, even though I'm an optimist by disposition, I certainly don't apologise for pointing out these bleak financial realities.
Read the rest of this thread to learn more ...
đ§”1/6
www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/02/09/the-national-acco⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Matthew E. Kahn
@mattkahn1966
An important post. Universities have locked in (and rising) costs as tenured aging faculty have salaries (and health care benefits and pensions) that add up to a lot of $. Revenue flows are uncertain. Rates of return on the endowment and NIH $ are uncertain. (1/2)
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is a big shakeup coming at top tier universities that rely on Federal funding through NIH and NSF grants. Recently announced changes have cut the overhead rate on these awards to 15%. Before the change, UCLA charged 57% Princeton, 67% and Harvard charged a whopping 69%.
Like most academics, I spent a good part of my career seeking research funding. Unlike an experimental physicist or a chemist, I do not need a laboratory to carry out my work. Back in the day, I simply needed a room, a blackboard and a piece of chalk.
A typical NSF award would pay to support my graduate students, some travel funding to conferences and a buyout of my time from teaching. Today, substitute a new computer for the chalk â but at todayâs prices thatâs a rounding error on a typical NSF award.
A typical award for a top tier theoretical economist might cost the NSF $500,000 over three years. At an overhead rate of 69%, $345,000 of that award would go to the university to provide the blackboard, the room and the chalk and the remaining $155,000 would pay a teaching buyout and graduate student support at less than $50,000 a year. Rethinking the way the Universities are funded is a timely move. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is a big shakeup coming at top tier universities that rely on Federal funding through NIH and NSF grants. Recently announced changes have cut the overhead rate on these awards to 15%. Before the change, UCLA charged 57% Princeton, 67% and Harvard charged a whopping 69%.
Like most academics, I spent a good part of my career seeking research funding. Unlike an experimental physicist or a chemist, I do not need a laboratory to carry out my work. Back in the day, I simply needed a room, a blackboard and a piece of chalk.
A typical NSF award would pay to support my graduate students, some travel funding to conferences and a buyout of my time from teaching. Today, substitute a new computer for the chalk â but at todayâs prices thatâs a rounding error on a typical NSF award.
A typical award for a top tier theoretical economist might cost the NSF $500,000 over three years. At an overhead rate of 69%, $345,000 of that award would go to the university to provide the blackboard, the room and the chalk and the remaining $155,000 would pay a teaching buyout and graduate student support at less than $50,000 a year. Rethinking the way the Universities are funded is a timely move. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The body that funds research in UK universities âResearch England plans to make âpeople, culture and environmentâ worth 25 per cent of its assessment criteria for the research it fundsâ. This is the exact opposite of the current U.S. merit based approach. www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-absurdity-of-funding-diveâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Nice summary of conventional economic theory on the impact of tariffs from @AmSantacreu . For a primer on what the Trump Whitehouse thinks about tariffs, I recommend this piece from Stephen Miran, the nominee for Chair of the CEA, @stevemiran www.hudsonbaycapital.com/documents/FG/hudsonbay/research/⊠HT to @RebelEconProf for pointing me to this.
Steve is a student of Marty Feldstein and a large part of his thesis is that conventional trade theory ignores the role of the dollar as a reserve currency â a role that has fueled global trade imbalances. @DennisNovy
Ana Maria Santacreu
@AmSantacreu
A quick explainer on how tariffs affect exchange rates: When the US imposes tariffs on imports, it triggers a chain reaction in currency markets. Here's the mechanism: [1/N]
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes both of these points are true, and discussed in global.oup.com/academic/product/prosperity-for-all-978019âŠ
If the fund becomes large enough, the equity premium will disappear as the Treasury bids up the rate on bonds and lowers the expected return on the indexed fund until both are trading, on average, at the growth rate.
The issue of the temptation to misuse a social wealth fund to achieve some other end is more serious and very real. Witness, for example, the subversion of central banksâ prime role in controlling inflation towards the climate agenda, DEI programs e.t.c. My own view is that the management of a SWF should be very tightly controlled under strict guidelines and with a limited role. @HannoLustig @SteveMiran @carney @USTreasury
John Carney
@carney
It does seem to me that if you can borrow at Treasury rates, there should be excess returns available so long as your fund doesnât grow too big.
One problem is that the temptation will be to invest according to a social agenda that would lower returns or even result in losses. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Which taxpayers? My thesis is that a large part of the equity premium comes from non-fundamental risk generated as a consequence of incomplete participation in asset markets. The incompleteness arises from the fact that the unborn are unable to insure across states of nature that they are born into. This was the message of the Cass-Shell paper, Why Sunspots Matter karlshell.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/do_sunspots_mattâŠ
The government has the ability, and the resources, to trade on behalf of the unborn. A simple, but limited example, would be if the treasury were to invest the social security trust fund into a broadly defined indexed fund. And yes, taxpayers are bearing the risk. But not simply current taxpayers: all future taxpayers. This is â potentially â an insurance scheme across generations. @HannoLustig @USTreasury @SteveMiran
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
If the government is **borrowing to invest in risky assets**, you're either forcing taxpayers to bear the risk (more tax revenue in bad states of the world) or you're assuming bond markets investors are naive (or you're just going full scale financial repression). The risk does not disappear.
Underfunded municipal pension funds in Ca have a long tradition of doing just this. Borrowing more to invest in equities. With mixed results.
Norway is not borrowing to invest in risky assets. Norway is saving.
Here is the math. The beta of the debt is a weighted average of the beta of the surplus claim and the beta of the risky assets. If you want to keep the debt risk-free (zero beta), you have to generate a negative beta for the surplus claim (by forcing taxpayers to pay more taxes in bad states of the world).
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree @HannoLustig . Itâs makes sense for national governments to borrow and invest in risky assets for the same reason it makes sense for a twenty year old to put his or her savings in an indexed fund rather than treasuries to save for retirement.
Much of the reason for a 6% equity premium comes from volatility that canât be hedged by any investor with a finite horizon. It is caused by the trades of yet unborn people and no currently living investor can trade with the unborn. Government can, and should, exploit those gains on behalf of taxpayers. I have written and published extensively on that idea and summarized the argument in my book Prosperity for All. global.oup.com/academic/product/prosperity-for-all-978019⊠@SteveMiran @hmtreasury @USTreasury @carney @EdConwaySky @TheStalwart
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Can you play đłđŽ and run a risky sovereign wealth fund to earn a nice spread above your funding cost if you don't have surpluses to invest? No, governments cannot make risk disappear.
This won't work unless
1/ US Treasury investors are naive, can't do the math, and won't price in the extra risk,
2/ You're about to start đŻđ”-style financial repression to lower your funding costs (e.g. by having the Fed buy all of the Treasury issuance), thus taxing ultimately depositors,
3/ You're going to offload all of the extra risk onto your taxpayers.
Neither of these options seem plausible or desirable. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I disagree @HannoLustig . Itâs makes sense for national governments to borrow and invest in risky assets for the same reason it makes sense for a twenty year old to put his or her savings in an indexed fund rather than treasuries to save for retirement.
Much of the reason for a 6% equity premium comes from volatility that canât be hedged by any investor with a finite horizon. It is caused by the trades of yet unborn people and no currently living investor can trade with the unborn. Government can, and should, exploit those gains on behalf of taxpayers. I have written and published extensively on that idea and summarized the argument in my book Prosperity for All. global.oup.com/academic/product/prosperity-for-all-978019⊠@SteveMiran @hmtreasury @USTreasury @carney @EdConwaySky @TheStalwart
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Can you play đłđŽ and run a risky sovereign wealth fund to earn a nice spread above your funding cost if you don't have surpluses to invest? No, governments cannot make risk disappear.
This won't work unless
1/ US Treasury investors are naive, can't do the math, and won't price in the extra risk,
2/ You're about to start đŻđ”-style financial repression to lower your funding costs (e.g. by having the Fed buy all of the Treasury issuance), thus taxing ultimately depositors,
3/ You're going to offload all of the extra risk onto your taxpayers.
Neither of these options seem plausible or desirable. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Yes. Rapa Nui ⊠the large stones on Easter Island were stores of wealth but they were not used in everyday exchange. Cass and Shell in their piece, In Defense of a Basic Approach karlshell.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/defense.pdf argue that the store of wealth function is a necessary precursor to the adoption of an object as a means of exchange @velocitymv
Victor Olivo
@velocitymv
Can you give a real example of a fiat asset that has been continuously and voluntarily hold while not being a medium of exchange?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
While I agree with all of this post by @lawrencehwhite1, I would go further. There is no need for a fiat asset to have a medium of exchange function, even one that is probabilistic. All thatâs required is a demographic structure in which the underlying real rate would be below the growth rate in the absence of an alternative store of wealth. @GeorgeSelgin @MacRoweNick @dandolfa When there is more than one asset in this class, the underlying value of each asset is subject to the speculative whims of investors.
Lawrence H. White
@lawrencehwhite1
Eugene Fama was recently interviewed by Luigi Zingales and Bethany McLean www.chicagobooth.edu/review/capitalisnt-why-this-nobel-ecâŠ. Many have criticized his prediction of a zero price for Bitcoin. In this thread, I criticize his claim that zero-valued BTC follows from standard monetary theory. It doesn't.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If only the factor price equalization theorem held in practice âŠ. đ
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
two ways to have wages converge. one way is to have goods and services cross borders, the other is to have people cross borders.đ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
While I agree with all of this post by @lawrencehwhite1, I would go further. There is no need for a fiat asset to have a medium of exchange function, even one that is probabilistic. All thatâs required is a demographic structure in which the underlying real rate would be below the growth rate in the absence of an alternative store of wealth. @GeorgeSelgin @MacRoweNick @dandolfa When there is more than one asset in this class, the underlying value of each asset is subject to the speculative whims of investors.
Lawrence H. White
@lawrencehwhite1
Eugene Fama was recently interviewed by Luigi Zingales and Bethany McLean www.chicagobooth.edu/review/capitalisnt-why-this-nobel-ecâŠ. Many have criticized his prediction of a zero price for Bitcoin. In this thread, I criticize his claim that zero-valued BTC follows from standard monetary theory. It doesn't.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an excellent piece from @EdConwaySky Ed points out that the US cannot process most US oil because itâs too light. Canadian oil, (and Californian oil) is heavy and suitable for US manufacturing plants. The alternatives to Canadian heavy oil to keep US refineries busy? Russia and Venezuela.
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
âïžDespite being the world's biggest oil producer, America is massively reliant on Canadian oil. Actually getting MORE reliant, not less.
So what happens when tariffs get imposed on Canadian oil?
The answers are quite unsettling, both for the American people and for everyone else -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The argument for bringing back manufacturing is based on Autor Dorn and Hansen www.nber.org/papers/w21906
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
I don't think it is desiderable to bring back manufaturing jobs to the US (what matters is value added, why should manufacturing be better than services?). But let's assume the aim is to create jobs in manufacturing.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
What do you think, David, @dcrouchca are DTâs real motivations? Serious question. He stated in his campaign that he intended to repatriate manufacturing to the U.S. We can debate whether a 25% tariff on Canada and Mexico is the best way to achieve that, but I donât doubt that his goal is to rebuild a manufacturing base in the United States.
There is a secondary question of why put a 25% tariff on Canada and Mexico and a 10% tariff on China when China is the source of most manufactured goods. Part of that, I suspect, is that the last time the U.S. raised tariffs on China, it led to Chinese goods being rerouted directly or indirectly through Mexico.
Itâs not clear how Trumpâs character enters the equation other than through his clear demonstration, in his actions, that he follows through on his promises.
David Crouch
@dcrouchca
This is all in some sort of academic rational fantasy plane. Be more interesting snd significant if it was firmly centred in reality based on Donald Trumpâs real motivations, character, and other related actions
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Perhaps the âourâ should have been capitalized instead of in quotes @aledinola The entry of China to the WTO led to huge gains for coastal elites and large losses for the middle and working class in the interior of the U.S. Yes, the aggregate gains outweighed the aggregate losses. But the gains were NOT redistributed so that all Americans benefited.
Itâs not even clear, to me, that it would have been possible to devise a redistribution scheme that improved the lives of factory workers and service workers in factory towns who lost their livelihoods as a result of the export of manufacturing jobs abroad. If you take away the ability of a worker to support himself â or herself â and substitute a welfare check, you take away the dignity and self worth that comes from work. The outcome is the increase in deaths of despair through drug abuse that we have seen in the interior of the country.
Economists have been taught to parrot the aphorism âtariffs badâ beginning in the 19th century with Ricardoâs attack on the corn laws which were tariffs that supported the landed gentry in the UK at the expense of the UK manufacturing sector. Itâs not clear that one can levy the same argument against tariffs imposed to promote an industrial base. For a defense of this argument, see @EdConwaySkyâs podcast podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/sky-news-daily/id951048357 with @skynewsniall
So please @aledinola, spare me the platitudes about Ricardo and free trade and endeavor to engage with twenty first century problems. @AintMissB @MacRoweNick
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
Now tariffs don't reduce real income đŹ Of course free trade has redistributive effects, but the gains are larger than the losses. This is well known since David Ricardo. I hope other economists can push back on this nonsense
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I also donât see why tariffs reduce âourâ real incomes. They redistribute incomes with some gainers and some losers.
When China entered the WTO in 2001, manufacturing moved to China. The US income distribution worsened as those who owned human capital and financial capital benefited and those whose livelihood centered around manufacturing regions lost high paying jobs.
If tariffs succeed in bringing back manufacturing to the U.S. , that process should be reversed. Perhaps US GDP will be lower than it would have been without the tariffs. Perhaps not. But the distribution of income will change as resources shift away from owners of intellectual and financial capital and back to less educated workers.
There are good reasons to want to maintain a manufacturing base in a world that is increasingly becoming divided into competing hegemons. @MacRoweNick @VincentGeloso
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Why do we say they cause inflation? They change relative prices and cause a one-time change in price levels, but they dont accelerate price trends permanently. Are we just abdicating on distinguishing them?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Perhaps the âourâ should have been capitalized instead of in quotes @aledinola The entry of China to the WTO led to huge gains for coastal elites and large losses for the middle and working class in the interior of the U.S. Yes, the aggregate gains outweighed the aggregate losses. But the gains were NOT redistributed so that all Americans benefited.
Itâs not even clear, to me, that it would have been possible to devise a redistribution scheme that improved the lives of factory workers and service workers in factory towns who lost their livelihoods as a result of the export of manufacturing jobs abroad. If you take away the ability of a worker to support himself â or herself â and substitute a welfare check, you take away the dignity and self worth that comes from work. The outcome is the increase in deaths of despair through drug abuse that we have seen in the interior of the country.
Economists have been taught to parrot the aphorism âtariffs badâ beginning in the 19th century with Ricardoâs attack on the corn laws which were tariffs that supported the landed gentry in the UK at the expense of the UK manufacturing sector. Itâs not clear that one can levy the same argument against tariffs imposed to promote an industrial base. For a defense of this argument, see @EdConwaySkyâs podcast podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/sky-news-daily/id951048357 with @skynewsniall
So please @aledinola, spare me the platitudes about Ricardo and free trade and endeavor to engage with twenty first century problems. @AintMissB @MacRoweNick
Alessandro Di Nola
@aledinola
Now tariffs don't reduce real income đŹ Of course free trade has redistributive effects, but the gains are larger than the losses. This is well known since David Ricardo. I hope other economists can push back on this nonsense
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I also donât see why tariffs reduce âourâ real incomes. They redistribute incomes with some gainers and some losers.
When China entered the WTO in 2001, manufacturing moved to China. The US income distribution worsened as those who owned human capital and financial capital benefited and those whose livelihood centered around manufacturing regions lost high paying jobs.
If tariffs succeed in bringing back manufacturing to the U.S. , that process should be reversed. Perhaps US GDP will be lower than it would have been without the tariffs. Perhaps not. But the distribution of income will change as resources shift away from owners of intellectual and financial capital and back to less educated workers.
There are good reasons to want to maintain a manufacturing base in a world that is increasingly becoming divided into competing hegemons. @MacRoweNick @VincentGeloso
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Why do we say they cause inflation? They change relative prices and cause a one-time change in price levels, but they dont accelerate price trends permanently. Are we just abdicating on distinguishing them?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I also donât see why tariffs reduce âourâ real incomes. They redistribute incomes with some gainers and some losers.
When China entered the WTO in 2001, manufacturing moved to China. The US income distribution worsened as those who owned human capital and financial capital benefited and those whose livelihood centered around manufacturing regions lost high paying jobs.
If tariffs succeed in bringing back manufacturing to the U.S. , that process should be reversed. Perhaps US GDP will be lower than it would have been without the tariffs. Perhaps not. But the distribution of income will change as resources shift away from owners of intellectual and financial capital and back to less educated workers.
There are good reasons to want to maintain a manufacturing base in a world that is increasingly becoming divided into competing hegemons. @MacRoweNick @VincentGeloso
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Why do we say they cause inflation? They change relative prices and cause a one-time change in price levels, but they dont accelerate price trends permanently. Are we just abdicating on distinguishing them?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Niall Ferguson
@nfergus
My first essay for @thetimes: "To this day, FDR still holds the record for the largest number of executive orders in the first hundred days of a presidency ... But that record is about to be broken by Trump 2.0." 1/7
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm not aware of specific studies @ShahidMohmand79 that study the impact of tax multipliers by income quintile. The relative effect will depend on the mechanism that causes tax increases to lower GDP. My own guess is that the negative impact will be greater the more it hits the top quintile. This is based on the fact that the plausible reason for thinking that the tax multiplier is larger than the expenditure multiplier is because taxes affect aggregate supply as well as aggregate demand.
Shahid Mehmood
@ShahidMohmand79
Thanks Roger. I have a query-In the British case, wouldn't it matter who bears the burden of taxation? Shouldn't we also keep in perspective the expense multipliers by different income quintiles? So what if the additional taxes mostly come from the top tier of earners?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Niall Paterson
@skynewsniall
Itâs a difficult subject to wrap your head around, so hereâs the big man @EdConwaySky putting tariffs in terms even I could understand.
If you need an explainer of what tf Trump is up to, and a proper interrogation of his plan (spoiler - Ed thinks he has a point), listen below.
Sky News
@SkyNews
âTariffs is the most beautiful word to meâ said Donald Trump during his second inauguration
@skynewsniall is joined by @EdConwaySky to unpick why Trump loves tariffs, what he hopes to achieve with them and how likely a trade-war is...
Listen to the full episode đ§âŹïž -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Itâs very clear @HannoLustig that the way government spending is financed matters. In their AER paper www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.100.3.763 Romer and Romer found that tax multipliers are larger than spending multipliers. Argentinaâs finance minister Federico Sturzeneger @fedesturze makes the same point in his podcast with @MarkusEconomist linked here bcf.princeton.edu/events/federico-sturzenegger/ (well worth listening to all of it)
In the U.S. the new Treasury secretary, Scott Bessent, has plans that are similar to those that Sturzenegger and Milei are following in Argentina. Slash spending, scrap net zero, reduce the deficit and reduce regulation to stimulate private investment. Bessent is shooting for 3% growth and the Argentinian experience so far suggests, to me, that this may be within reach. Notably, Sturzenegger found that the balanced budget multiplier is negative.
These strategies are wildly different from the approach of @RachelReevesMP in the UK who, according to the Guardian, www.theguardian.com/politics/2025/jan/29/will-rachel-reev⊠is, following the advice of @johnvanreenen also shooting for growth.
What is missing in the UK plan is the willingness to slash the government sector and the continuing pursuit of an energy policy that stifles growth by raising the cost of energy. In contrast to Argentina and the U.S., the UK plan includes additional tax financed public investment. If Federico Sturzenegger is right and the balanced budget multiplier is negative, the additional public expenditure in the UK will have a negative impact on growth.
I will be keenly following the U.S., Argentinian and UK growth experiences over the next four years. @ustreasury @hmtreasury @NIESRorg @resfoundation @TiceRichard @meljstride
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
One of the main issues I see as a financial economist with the analysis of fiscal policy in modern macro and public finance is that the government's cost of funding is typically assumed to be exogenous, i.e., it does not depend on the types of fiscal policies governments pursue.
By assuming the government's cost of funding is exogenous, economists give governments the power to make risk disappear, risk that is priced elsewhere in financial markets. A super power that's extremely valuable but probably not real.
If you give the government this super power, you see lots of positive NPV projects for the government that are not real, and lots of opportunities for counter-cyclical fiscal policies that aren't real either. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Christian Matthes
@cmatthes_econ
Herman van Dijk was a towering figure in Bayesian econometrics. His dedication to the field was amazing - you could count on him to give you very useful and detailed feedback, no matter how preliminary or crazy your project was. He will be sorely missed.
Francesco Furlanetto đșđŠ
@francescofurla8
Herman van Dijk was a familiar face and a leading example for all of us @NorgesBank . Herman has been a giant in Bayesian econometrics but also a great mentor. We went skiing, we had good dinners, we even wrote a paper. Herman liked coming to Oslo and will be deeply missed đ„č.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Bookmarked. Will check back particularly with regard to the prediction of no drop in the crime rate.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
âAmericans can expect fewer job opportunities, higher prices for a range of goods,â from mass deportations, @m_clem says. âThey can expect less new home construction...higher rates of institutionalization for the elderly, &...no change in the crime rate.âwww.scrippsnews.com/politics/immigration/whas-the-potentiâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs not true if the population of buyers is growing. The average price grows at the rate of growth. If there are several assets with the same characteristics, e.g. gold, Rembrandt paintings, Bitcoin, price fluctuations occur based on random fluctuations in tastes for one asset over another.
All of these examples have some alternative use, other than a store of wealth. For gold it is industrial use and use in jewelry. For Rembrandt paintings it is the pleasure of owning fine art. For Bitcoin it is use as a medium of exchange for high value, often illegal, transactions.
Even a meme coin has use-value if enough people value holding it for its own sake. For a meme-coin, the case is weaker than for gold, paintings or Bitcoin. But as with art and baseball cards, the case for the underlying use-value of ownership is a matter of taste. @balaji -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But it has the same properties as OLG money. Gold and old masters are reasonable components of a portfolio â albeit in small amounts. Same with Bitcoin no? All these assets should appreciate at the growth rate.
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
"Passive" doesn't mean you invest in baseball cards even when BlackRock launches a baseball card ETF.
Passive means you hold the market. The market is the basket of all securities that pay off consumption in the future.
The market doesn't include baseball cards because they don't pay off consumption in the future. If you invest in a share of all outstanding baseball cards, you're just taking on mostly idiosyncratic risk, for which the market won't compensate you. You're compensated for taking on market risk, not baseball card risk.
Same thing implies to BTC. BTC doesn't pay consumption in the future. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Demography?
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Yes, economists are ideological (in some ways, left and in other ways, right). But economics is the least ideological of the social sciences by a long shot.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I wish everyone a peaceful and happy holiday season. Thanks to all of you who have chosen to follow me on X.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
@farmerrf has a different view.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Let me explain the argument in more depth.
1. First: Invite private companies to create ETFâs with a specific set of characteristics. Very broadly defined â non voting shares â and designed as closely as possible to track the entire publicly traded private market.
2. You ask, would a significant injection, of funds create a bubble? That depends on how significant. Let me point out first, that the federal government has the ability to peg the price of an ETF by offering to buy or sell the fund at a fixed price in the same way that the Fed pegs the price of T-bills. I have made the argument â in Prosperity for All â that there is a strong argument that they SHOULD pursue that policy. I am not making that case here.
3. Most of the risk associated with aggregate stock price movements is caused by speculation. There is nowhere near enough risk arising from underlying real shocks to innovation and growth to justify a 6% equity premium.
4. Speculative risk arises primarily from the inability to trade insurance contracts with our descendants. It is unborn generations that are primarily affected by recessions and booms that they are unable to insure against.
5. That brings me back to the modest proposal to create a sovereign wealth fund by issuing Treasuries and buying an ETF. The private capital stock is worth roughly 2.5 GDPs. The federal debt is roughly one GDP. The social security trust fund is roughly 1/10th of a GDP.
6. A modest proposal of investing the trust fund in the market would be unlikely to inflate a bubble and if anything, would act to stabilize speculation as the Treasury would not need to trade their position to meet short term liquidity needs.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Read it and find out. www.amazon.com/Prosperity-All-Prevent-Financial-Crises/dpâŠ
Living the High Life
@ishouldverun
That much cash inserted into the markets will create a bubble. Large volume investors could exploit that bubble, sell off and destroy the fund. Is that in your book?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Gabriel. @gabriel_zucman I do appreciate the argument that democracies can be dominated by wealthy people. I made it myself more than ten years ago in the Guardian www.theguardian.com/business/economics-blog/2014/oct/20/w⊠(And while we are talking about billionaires influencing elections George Soros and Mark Zuckerberg come to mind.)
But the proposition that @elonmusk is propping up the renaissance of a neo-nazi movement is delusional and reflects your inability to understand how completely the left has become disconnected from the average American voter.
With the purchase of twitter/X @elonmusk has restored the ability of thinking human beings to communicate their thoughts freely with one another without the censorship of a group of self-designated gatekeepers who profess to know better. Regrettably, you appear to have allied yourself with the censors.
If you have not yet done so, may I recommend that you read Millâs essay on liberty. www.econlib.org/library/Mill/mlLbty.html Did they teach you that in Paris? And for a dessert course, read the Twitter files www.racket.news/p/twitter-files-extra-how-the-files
Gabriel Zucman
@gabriel_zucman
Funny how 5 years ago we had all these debates about wealth taxation, and a big argument was that billionaires don't have that much power reallyâand right after that Musk bought Twitter for $44B, used it to get Trump win, and now to prop up the global neo-nazi movement ÂŻ\_(ă)_/ÂŻ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Agreed. I have thoughts on how to do that in my book.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Let me explain the argument in more depth.
1. First: Invite private companies to create ETFâs with a specific set of characteristics. Very broadly defined â non voting shares â and designed as closely as possible to track the entire publicly traded private market.
2. You ask, would a significant injection, of funds create a bubble? That depends on how significant. Let me point out first, that the federal government has the ability to peg the price of an ETF by offering to buy or sell the fund at a fixed price in the same way that the Fed pegs the price of T-bills. I have made the argument â in Prosperity for All â that there is a strong argument that they SHOULD pursue that policy. I am not making that case here.
3. Most of the risk associated with aggregate stock price movements is caused by speculation. There is nowhere near enough risk arising from underlying real shocks to innovation and growth to justify a 6% equity premium.
4. Speculative risk arises primarily from the inability to trade insurance contracts with our descendants. It is unborn generations that are primarily affected by recessions and booms that they are unable to insure against.
5. That brings me back to the modest proposal to create a sovereign wealth fund by issuing Treasuries and buying an ETF. The private capital stock is worth roughly 2.5 GDPs. The federal debt is roughly one GDP. The social security trust fund is roughly 1/10th of a GDP.
6. A modest proposal of investing the trust fund in the market would be unlikely to inflate a bubble and if anything, would act to stabilize speculation as the Treasury would not need to trade their position to meet short term liquidity needs.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Read it and find out. www.amazon.com/Prosperity-All-Prevent-Financial-Crises/dpâŠ
Living the High Life
@ishouldverun
That much cash inserted into the markets will create a bubble. Large volume investors could exploit that bubble, sell off and destroy the fund. Is that in your book?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
MattonioMaximus
@MattonioMaximus
Probably one of the best ideas in a long time related to Government offering public option type service.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Anything risky would work. I have long argued for issuing treasuries to buy an ETF that has historically paid a 6% premium. At the very least, invest the social security trust fund in the markets. I explain why this is a good idea in my book Prosperity for All
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Read it and find out. www.amazon.com/Prosperity-All-Prevent-Financial-Crises/dpâŠ
Living the High Life
@ishouldverun
That much cash inserted into the markets will create a bubble. Large volume investors could exploit that bubble, sell off and destroy the fund. Is that in your book?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Absolutely not. I discuss how to do this in my book. www.amazon.com/Prosperity-All-Prevent-Financial-Crises/dpâŠ
Fiportmgr
@fiportmgr
An equity ETF? So, over time the federal government would hold large or even controlling interests in every corporation in the ETF and be able to vote those interests?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
nws
@NeastWS
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The corporate profits tax is a raid on revenues that alters private behavior. Government substitution of treasuries for corporate equities is a move that would be neutral if Modigliani Miller were true. Modigliani Miller fails because of demographics. The unborn cannot trade in the asset markets but their welfare is affected by the portfolio composition of the Treasury.
Christopher Phelan
@ChrisPhelanEcon
Isn't the corporate profits tax already an implicit equity claim on the US stock market? Add to that marginal income tax rate times the value of everything in 401ks. So the federal gov't is already heavily invested in risky assets.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@kingofthecoastt @carney The argument is not that buying equities would increase market value â although it is certainly a feasible policy if it were to be pursued â it is that because the market is so much riskier than treasuries, holding equities funded by treasuries would generate average âŠ
KingoftheCoast
@kingofthecoastt
Thoughts on this?
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
⊠net revenues to the Treasury of 6% of the investment. That would be roughly 60 billion on a one trillion investment. As the investment is ramped up it will decrease the volatility of the market and lower the equity premium since a large treasury position in equities will reduce the volatility of trades.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Anything risky would work. I have long argued for issuing treasuries to buy an ETF that has historically paid a 6% premium. At the very least, invest the social security trust fund in the markets. I explain why this is a good idea in my book Prosperity for All
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But money must be a store of value before it can be a medium of exchange. Agreed that the unit-of-account is independent.
John Paul Koning
@jp_koning
I say it's time to trash the store-of-value function of money, which is a meaningless, unhelpful, and redundant concept.
The defining functions of money are unit-of-account and medium-of-exchange.
đ jpkoning.blogspot.com/2024/12/its-time-to-trash-store-of-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Lovely explanation of entropy
Keenan Crane
@keenanisalive
Entropy is one of those formulas that many of us learn, swallow whole, and even use regularly without really understanding.
(E.g., where does that âlogâ come from? Are there other possible formulas?)
Yet there's an intuitive & almost inevitable way to arrive at this expression. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Any change in the inflation tax can always be offset â in theory â by a lump sum tax or transfer. And while that will have a fiscal effect, because inflationary finance is distortionary, it will be second order.
Bill Goggin
@wgoggin
But your âsimple modelâ and the experiment below it appear silent on the impact of fiscal stance and flows.
Isnât that the point?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well that's a challenge @dandolfa
My recollection of the issue is that it hinges on adaptive expectations.
Here is a simple model
1. Adaptive expectations
Epi_t = Lambda Epi_(t-1) + (1-Lambda) pi_t
2. Phillips Curve
pi_t = Epi_t + y_t
3. IS Curve
y_t = -i_t + Epi_t
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Does increasing the interest rate lower inflation?@JohnHCochrane w/ an excellent post that corroborates what I've discovered in the monetary models I work with (e.g. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2669849). Here's John:
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well that's a challenge @dandolfa
My recollection of the issue is that it hinges on adaptive expectations.
Here is a simple model
1. Adaptive expectations
Epi_t = Lambda Epi_(t-1) + (1-Lambda) pi_t
2. Phillips Curve
pi_t = Epi_t + y_t
3. IS Curve
y_t = -i_t + Epi_t
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Does increasing the interest rate lower inflation?@JohnHCochrane w/ an excellent post that corroborates what I've discovered in the monetary models I work with (e.g. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2669849). Here's John:
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And here is an experiment where the Fed controls i_t to lower pi from 0 to -1 at date 3. Lambda set to 0.6
In this experiment the Fed raises i_t immediately and then lowers it. Inflation drops immediately.
Because inflation falls more than expected inflation, output also takes a contemporaneous hit. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Sorry to interrupt your busy day @jonmurphy8289
Jon Murphy
@jmurphy8289
Ok...there are numerous theoretical, empirical, and logical issues with this argument. I have a busy day so I'm just going to leave it at that.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Autor-Dorn-Hanson found significant effects on local communities from the loss of manufacturing jobs.
www.ddorn.net/papers/Autor-Dorn-Hanson-ChinaShock.pdf
See in particular Section 4.4 which argues that the impact of losing manufacturing jobs has spillover impacts on local labor markets that go far beyond the jobs associated with the initial loss.
It may be true that new technology has replaced many jobs by robots. But if I were living in a depressed region I would rather that a new manufacturing plant were constructed in my town than in China, Canada or Mexico.
TBD
@Davret1
The flaw in the logic here is that millions buy cars. A modern factory employs only a few thousand. Everything is automated.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
1. Pre tariff: Car manufacturer can build a plant in Mexico, where wages are lower, and ship cars to consumers in the US.
2. Post tariff: Car manufacturer builds plant in the US and pays higher wages. Cars are more expensive but incomes of those producing the cars in the US are higher.
3. You and I, high earner academics, are worse off as we have to pay more for our cars.
4. Workers in Detroit are better off as they now have a job which pays more than enough to compensate them for the higher priced car.
5. Grocery stores return to Detroit suburbs where residents can now afford to buy food.
Most recent international models of trade do not model the distribution of income between owners of capital, owners of land and workers since they focus on intermediate goods trade. But these distributional effects are central to arguments in favor of tariffs.
The repeal of the Corn Laws in the UK in the 19th C â an event that arguably was instrumental in economistsâ focus on trade â was a political struggle between the owners of land and a newly created class of manufacturers. In the case of the Corn Laws the event was the removal of trade protections which benefited manufacturers to the cost of landowners. But the point still stands. Trade protections have distributional effects.
Trade protections also have dynamic effects. China has a thriving sector that produces green energy infrastructure, including nuclear power plants. That infrastructure was nurtured through trade barriers and the importation of capital, including nuclear technology, from the U.S.
Jon Murphy
@jmurphy8289
It's unclear how or why tariffs, which act as a regressive tax when applied to consumer goods, would redistribute income back to middle and working class families. Furthermore, since tariffs increase the cost of manufacturing in the US, one fails to see how they would return mfg
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A few questions @jbsteinberg @VincentGeloso @michaelxpettis
1. Does your model allow for changes in industrial structure following a change in tariffs?
2. Are the parameters of the model estimated or calibrated?
3. Do you provide standard errors around your projections? If not, why not? (See my critique of the McKibbin paper that @PIIE put out attacking the Trump trade policies)
If you have confidence in the results of your analysis then I have a bridge to sell you.
Joseph Steinberg
@jbsteinberg
Michael's wrong. See my response here:
x.com/jbsteinberg/status/1862483972321587283
P.S. The model I used to evaluate the 25% tariffs on Canada/Mexico is dynamic and allows for endogenous trade imbalances at both aggregate and bilateral levels.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@michaelxpettis makes the case for the potential dynamic benefits of tariffs and also makes a great case for bringing back economic history to the core of economics Ph.D. programs. I agree with his critique of economic theory. And I strongly agree with the call to restore the study of economic history.
Trade theory in economics is predominantly studied separately from international finance. Much of trade theory makes the simplification that global trade is balanced i.e. no country is persistently accumulating debt with another country. (Can anyone point me to a counter example in recent literature)?
This assumption is very obviously counter factual and I suspect that it is connected with the failure of closed economy models to understand why persistent government budget deficits in the U.S. have not caused inflation. Instead, government deficits have caused a deterioration of the trade balance.
Our failure to understand these data is, IMO, related to our concentration on the study of balanced growth paths. The world has obviously not been on a balanced growth path for at least five hundred years.
The rapid growth of China after its entry to the WTO in 2000 led to a rapidly growing demand for the dollar as a reserve currency, for the same reasons that households demand dollars as a medium of exchange. As Chinese growth slows, this demand will also slow.
It is a good sign, if we accept Michaelâs assessment of the relative benefits of economic theory and economic history, that the incoming Treasury Secretary, Scott Bessent, was trained as an economic historian.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
1/11
If you want to understand the effects of trade intervention, its ok to ask economic historians, but never ask economists. That's because their answer will almost certainly reflect little more than their ideological position. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
Pour stabiliser sa dette publique (par rapport au PIB), la France doit rĂ©duire son deficit budgetaire a terme dâenviron 140 milliards. Vu lâopposition des diffĂ©rents groupes parlementaires a des rĂ©ductions de depenses ou des augmentations dâimpot de juste quelques milliards, on est tres mal parti.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I recommend this review of @StephanieKelton âs book from @albertobisin
alberto bisin
@albertobisin
Sure Roger, of course. The whole point of MMT though is a play of words - which are technically correct - but are uttered to the public to mean something else than they mean in the technically correct sense.
Saying that you can always monetize away the debt is meant to suggest that monetization has no consequences.
I've written a comment about these ambiguities in a review of Kelten's book.
bpb-us-e1.wpmucdn.com/wp.nyu.edu/dist/c/16384/files/2020/⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Izabella @izakaminska draws attention to an interesting piece by Russell Napier on the future of the global monetary system. I found the article to be long winded in places and a difficult read for anyone without a deep familiarity with international economics. Here are my two cents. Some of this is clarification of the article â some is my own thoughts on the topic.
1. Since the collapse of Breton Woods in the 1970s China has been managing its exchange rate by purchasing U.S. Treasuries.
2. U.S. companies switched investment to China to take advantage of cheap non union labor. This accelerated after the entry of China in the WTO in 2001.
3. Since that date the U.S. has been running consistent trade deficits. China has been running consistent trade surpluses. American workers lost on this deal as the drop in the price of cheap foreign goods was not enough to compensate them for the drop in domestic wages.
4. This is all about to change. China is no longer committed to preventing its exchange rate from appreciating â largely as a result of domestic imbalance.
5. We are about to see a sizable appreciation of the Renminbi with or without the imposition of a 60% tariff.
6. U.S. domestic savings â which have for decades been channeled into China â will begin to fund a domestic expansion in the U.S. This will â at least initially â go primarily into expansion of the oil and gas industries.
7. We are about to see an enormous increase in domestic electricity demand largely driven by the new AI data centers but also by a switch to EVs. This will require the construction of new power plants. Expect to see a mix of small nuclear, solar, wind and traditional sources depending on local preferences.
8. Electrification has led to an increased demand for rare earth metals such as lithium and cobalt. Expect to see a big expansion of domestic exploitation of these resources.
9. The appreciation of the Renminbi will potentially reverse the trade deficit with China and the U.S. will begin to rebalance the U.S. net debt balance. Because the exchange rate will change, perhaps dramatically, the goods that will be shipped to China to reverse the asset imbalance will be worth less than the goods that financed American consumerism over the past two decades.
10. My guess is that the increase in domestic investment will put upward pressure on wages that exceeds the increase in the price of foreign imports from exchange rate appreciation of the Renminbi. American workers will benefit.
11. Will this be inflationary. Depends. Scott Bessent has plans to reduce the budget deficit by 3% and he believes that he can boost growth to 3%. If he is successful â and I wouldnât bet against it â we may keep inflation under control.
Izabella Kaminska
@izakaminska
Russell Napier has just SMASHED it out of the park with the best analysis I have ever read of what currently ails the system. He calls it the "Non system" because nobody even noticed it was a system. The conclusion will disappoint those who are convinced that China's model is akin to alchemy that must be replicated everywhere.
americanaffairsjournal.org/2024/11/america-china-and-the-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Karsten MĂŒller
@KarstenMueIIer
The PhD in Finance programme at National University of Singapore is looking for talented PhD students. An excellent opportunity to work on cutting-edge research in Asia.
Deadline: 15 December.
Apply here: bschool.nus.edu.sg/finance/phd/ -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Pearl
@ppearlman
For the tweeps on my stream talking the short $MSTR & long $BTC pair, I offer this 90s Schleifer chestnut đđâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
caseybmulligan
@caseybmulligan
My 4-year forecasts were remarkably close. It helps to have a "big shock" like Bidenonomics. www.wsj.com/opinion/nobelists-for-harris-are-unburdened-bâŠ
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Olivier @ojblanchard1 has documented his predictions for the Trump economy ⊠I have bookmarked this and will be checking back to see how it pans out.
The bottom line: the Trump economy may do well in the short run but all bets are off for the longer horizon because inflation will rear its head and the Fed will choke off improvements in the economy through interest rate rises.
One aspect of the Trump policy that Olivier plays down is the potential impact of a new Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). Elon has proposed a cut of $2T to government expenditure, approximately a third of the current budget. While that may be a little optimistic, I hesitate to bet against a man who can parallel park a rocket.
A second aspect that Olivier underplays is the likely effect of unleashing the U.S. oil and gas industry which, Trump claims, will spur growth across the board. If he is right, the ensuing growth will help reduce the deficit to GDP ratio by boosting the denominator. It will also mitigate the loss of exports that Olivier envisions from exchange rate adjustments. U.S. liquid gas is already on the table to replace Russian imports to Europe.
Olivier also downplays the ability of Trump to carry out his proposed deportation program. I am not convinced. If carried out as planned, the loss of undocumented workers will prevent overheating in the labor market and mitigate against the inflationary pressures of repatriating manufacturing.
Finally, I would note Olivierâs justified concerns about the possible loss of independence of the Fed. The theoretical justification for Fed independence is to depoliticize monetary policy from the election cycle. There is growing unease amongst Republicans that the 50 basis point cut immediately before the election was, perhaps, unwise and when 90% of Fed employees are registered democrats there is, at least an appearance, of imbalance.
Economic prediction is difficult, particularly as the horizon extends beyond a year or two. My own assessment is that Olivier is correct to be cautiously optimistic that the economy will improve in the near term. I am much less pessimistic than he for the long term success of a set of policies that are so revolutionary in nature that they break the bounds of experience on which our forecast models are based.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
NOVEMBER 20: Join @ojblanchard1 on the next episode of PIIE Insider LIVE to discuss his recent piece on Trumponomics & how President-elect Trump's economic policies will affect the US & others.
Info & register: www.piie.com/events/2024/olivier-blanchard-trumponomics
Read the blog: www.piie.com/blogs/realtime-economics/2024/how-will-trump⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John L Davidson
@HHIDavidson
.@manavnair29 @DSteelmanLaw @dandolfa @ClaireBerlinski
A stunningly important statement by Roger
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The @piie keeps reposting this piece. I have little or no confidence in what the paper purports to find for the reasons I explained my earlier post. Reposted here,
ââââ
This @PIIE paper from McKibbin et. al. uses a large scale econometric model to analyze three policies proposed by former President Trump. @AdamPosen @WarwickMcKibbin @meganrosehogan
1. The deportation of large numbers of undocumented aliens who have crossed the border illegally, sidestepping the legal process for acquiring U.S. citizenship.
2. The imposition of high tariffs on countries, notably China, at levels equal to or exceeding tariff levels levied by those countries on U.S. exports.
3. The removal of the independence of the Federal Reserve Board and the reintroduction of political control over monetary policy.
The paper reports the forecast time path for a number of economic variables, including GDP, inflation and employment if a Trump administration were to enact one or more of these policies. The summary finding is that GDP growth and employment would fall and inflation would increase. In other words: Trump would be bad for the economy.
This conclusion should be taken with a very large grain of salt. I have a number of criticisms of the way the results are presented.
First: the authors are far too certain in their own infallibility for my taste. Economic forecasts should NEVER be presented without standard errors which are typically very large and which grow very rapidly very quickly. As I argued here
rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerbloâŠ
âThe Bank of England famously produces fan charts that show not only the median forecast but the probability distribution of likely outcomes. For several forecasts in a row following the 2008 crisis, all the realized values of projected inflation were outside of the range of statistical projections. They were Black-Swan events.â
At least the Bank acknowledged its own fallibility by printing a range of possibilities for future outcomes. Even so, the realized outcomes were outside of their 95% confidence bounds several quarters in a row. McKibbin et. al. give us only the median projection. It is unlikely that their model is better than the Bankâs.
Second. The paper reports that a deportation of undocumented aliens will lower the growth rate of GDP: That is an irrelevant metric. From the perspective of U.S. citizens the relevant measure is GDP per person. Removing people from the economy will trivially lower GDP since there are fewer people producing goods and services. A reduction in GDP may or may not result in lower GDP per person.
Third. The paper ignores distributional effects. Even if the Trump policies were to reduce GDP per person, (and I do not know this to be the case), the relevant decision for the median voter is whether he or she gains a job as a result of the potential reshoreing of manufacturing jobs.
To summarize. I do not know if the proposed Trump economic policy will raise GDP per person. The McKibbin et. al. paper has not persuaded me that it will not. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Here is the exchange I referred to @m_clem (see below)
As a former Research Director at NIESR I would never have allowed the release of such an obviously partisan analysis on the eve of an election and, as I pointed out in a previous post, it would not have survived the NBER working paper filter which prohibits policy advocacy.
The credibility of the entire economics profession is damaged when obvious political advocacy is cloaked in the guise of 'scientific expertise'.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs not my point Warwick. Itâs the disingenuous assertion that one sample path from your model, with no allowance for parameter uncertainty, model mis-specification or shocks to the variables of the model, demonstrates that the proposed Republican policies will be bad for the economy.
In a much simpler model, when labor and capital are substitutes, a fall in labor causes an increase in productivity. As Iâm sure youâre aware, there will be alternative specifications â hard to distinguish in data â that lead to the opposite conclusion from the one you confidently assert as fact. If you dispute this assertion, then publish the standard errors around your parameter estimates.
This paper would never have made it into the NBER series which screens for blatant political opinions â which is what this hit piece is. Releasing what is at best, an opinion dressed up as âscienceâ a month before the U.S. presidential election gives the profession a bad name and contributes to the lack of confidence that many Americans profess in âthe experts.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Olivier @ojblanchard1 has documented his predictions for the Trump economy ⊠I have bookmarked this and will be checking back to see how it pans out.
The bottom line: the Trump economy may do well in the short run but all bets are off for the longer horizon because inflation will rear its head and the Fed will choke off improvements in the economy through interest rate rises.
One aspect of the Trump policy that Olivier plays down is the potential impact of a new Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). Elon has proposed a cut of $2T to government expenditure, approximately a third of the current budget. While that may be a little optimistic, I hesitate to bet against a man who can parallel park a rocket.
A second aspect that Olivier underplays is the likely effect of unleashing the U.S. oil and gas industry which, Trump claims, will spur growth across the board. If he is right, the ensuing growth will help reduce the deficit to GDP ratio by boosting the denominator. It will also mitigate the loss of exports that Olivier envisions from exchange rate adjustments. U.S. liquid gas is already on the table to replace Russian imports to Europe.
Olivier also downplays the ability of Trump to carry out his proposed deportation program. I am not convinced. If carried out as planned, the loss of undocumented workers will prevent overheating in the labor market and mitigate against the inflationary pressures of repatriating manufacturing.
Finally, I would note Olivierâs justified concerns about the possible loss of independence of the Fed. The theoretical justification for Fed independence is to depoliticize monetary policy from the election cycle. There is growing unease amongst Republicans that the 50 basis point cut immediately before the election was, perhaps, unwise and when 90% of Fed employees are registered democrats there is, at least an appearance, of imbalance.
Economic prediction is difficult, particularly as the horizon extends beyond a year or two. My own assessment is that Olivier is correct to be cautiously optimistic that the economy will improve in the near term. I am much less pessimistic than he for the long term success of a set of policies that are so revolutionary in nature that they break the bounds of experience on which our forecast models are based.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
NOVEMBER 20: Join @ojblanchard1 on the next episode of PIIE Insider LIVE to discuss his recent piece on Trumponomics & how President-elect Trump's economic policies will affect the US & others.
Info & register: www.piie.com/events/2024/olivier-blanchard-trumponomics
Read the blog: www.piie.com/blogs/realtime-economics/2024/how-will-trump⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Correct. Economic theory predicts that tariffs will change relative prices. They will not create a persistent increase in the rate of change of prices, aka inflation. The puzzle, to me, is why the government budget deficit â currently running at 7% â has not â at least not yet â been reflected in domestic inflation.
The answer, I suspect, is because 30% of the dollar assets created by the Treasury are being soaked up by the rest of the world â largely China â and stoking a current account deficit.
The 60k dollar question, is how much the Yuan/$ exchange rate will react to a 60% tariff. We have promised to repay China with pieces of paper. In exchange we have received a flow of consumer goods. That is about to end. @JanJekielek @jeffreytucker
@michaelxpettis is worth following for anyone interested in this issue.
If U.S. companies respond to the tariffs by repatriating manufacturing, and if the promised mass deportations of undocumented aliens occur, American workers may well end up better off. Wages may rise more than the cost of the consumption basket of the average worker contrary to recent claims from the Peterson Institute @PIIE
Jan Jekielek
@JanJekielek
"You hear this all the time: Trump's going to unleash inflation with his tariffs.
It's not going to increase inflation.
It's going to increase the price of relative goods & services by those goods that are most affected - namely, imported goods."
@jeffreytucker -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Excellent thread from my colleague @Omer_Moav with some good suggestions to improve the publication process in economics.
Omer Moav
@Omer_Moav
Do we have inclusive institutions in the field of economic research?
I recently shared my thoughts following the announcement on the âCommittee on Improvements to the Publications Process in Economics,â focusing on the discriminatory nature of the editorial process. đ§” -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Another excellent thread from @michaelxpettis He argues that the welfare effects of tariffs depend on the net trade position of the economy. This invalidates comparisons between the effects of tariff protections in the 1890s and the 1930s â when the US was running trade surpluses â with tariffs today â when it is running trade deficits.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
1/11
A new paper by the NBER on the McKinley tariffs of the late 1890s claims that the US economy did not benefit from the tariffs, mainly because they "may have reduced labor productivity in manufacturing."
www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-11-08/trump-s-tar⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Nathan P. Goodman
@NathanPGoodman
Toward a Theory of Property Rights, by Harold Demsetz
David Brady Jr.
@realDavidBJr
What are some classic papers in Economics that should be read by every undergraduate student?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
ideas.repec.org/a/ucp/jpolec/v78y1970i2p193-238.html
Friedmanâs 1970 paper. A Framework for Monetary analysis
Banquero Hayekiano
@HayekianBanker
David Brady Jr.
@realDavidBJr
What are some classic papers in Economics that should be read by every undergraduate student?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Banquero Hayekiano
@HayekianBanker
David Brady Jr.
@realDavidBJr
What are some classic papers in Economics that should be read by every undergraduate student?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Dennis Novy
@DennisNovy
To all econ PhDs on the job market:
We are hiring! @warwickecon
econjobmarket.org/positions/11181 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
Markets were sanguine about the Budget when @RachelReevesMP was delivering it. But now investors are absorbing the actual details and numbers, they're considerably less sanguine.
UK government cost of borrowing climbing...đ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
OBR predicts the budget will be neutral for GDP. But 5 years from now it shifts 1.5% of GDP from the private sector to the public sector. I have no confidence that government will spend that money wisely. And thatâs assuming I trust the OBR model. Which is a very big if.
Office for Budget Responsibility
@OBR_UK
#autumnbudget policies temporarily boost output in the near term, but leave GDP largely unchanged at the end of the five-year forecast.
Alongside the drag from tax rises, increased government activity crowds out some consumption, investment and net trade in a capacity constrained economy. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
There are a ton of great reasons to care about biodiversity. Price stability is not one of them.
European Central Bank
@ecb
If you destroy nature, you destroy the economy.
To fulfil our mandate of keeping prices stable and banks safe and sound, we must take nature into account, says Executive Board member @FrankElderson at the COP16 biodiversity conference.
Read the speech www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2024/html/ecb.sp241028_1⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Laws limiting or altogether prohibiting branch banking in the U.S. had similarly awful consequences. The list goes on--to the point where it is really hard to identify a 19th-c. financial crisis for which bad regulatory interference wasn't largely to blame. 4/
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I pretty much agree with your entire response thread. The right question is; how to design a monetary system in a way that involves minimal intervention from human actors but improves upon an unregulated commodity standard. In my view, central banks have, very slowly, been learning how to do this through a process of trial and error. But like all institutions, central banks are subject to human error.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
We can learn to consider how bad regulations can still contribute to crises, and try to ferret them out and repeal them before jumping to the "more regulation" solution, as usually happens. 9/
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This thread is well worth reading. @michaelxpettis Economists are as susceptible to herd mentality as anyone else.
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
1/10
In this article Bloomberg notes that "the effects of the Smoot-Hawley Act of 1930 became the textbook case against tariffs."
But we have to be a little careful about how we interpret the lessons of Smoot-Hawley.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-10-26/trump-s-threat⊠via @economics -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Important explanation of how polymarket works from @shayne_coplan If you think the odds are altered by âmanipulationâ â then buy the underpriced option. If your estimate is correct you stand to make money.
Shayne Coplan đŠ
@shayne_coplan
Given the latest New York Times article on Polymarket, this seems like a good time to make clear:
âą Polymarket is strictly non-partisan. We get told we're Dem operatives and MAGA, depending on the day. Unfortunately the story is much less juicy, we're just market nerds who think prediction markets provide the public with a much needed alternative data source. It's naturally a fit in a world where there are infinite opinions being served to you algorithmically based on what you already think, designed only to keep you engaged and push you further into an echo chamber. If just one thing, Polymarket is a reality check.
âą Polymarket is not about politics. The vision never was to be a political website, and it still isn't. From launch day, the goal has been to, "harness the power of free markets to demystify the real world events that matter most to you." This US election cycle, we've been pulled onto center stage, as people are fed up with having to make sense of 'For You' feeds, pundits, and incongruent polls - we take that responsibility seriously. Polymarket's rise in popularity correlates with correctly forecasting Biden dropping out - it was the one source that called it. Hopefully politics is the first step to get the masses to realize the value of market-based forecasts.
âą It's crazy I have to say this, but it's time to put the "Thiel-controlled" narrative to rest. He has no direct contact or control with the company. Founders Fund, one of the most active VC funds (Airbnb, Stripe, etc.), and one of our 50+ investors, has a minority stake in the company with no board seat/control - and the partner who did the Polymarket deal isn't even Thiel. His politics have no bearing on how Polymarket works, operates, or what the prices are - end of story.
The beauty of Polymarket is it's all peer-to-peer and transparent. Even more transparent than traditional finance, where all the data is obfuscated and only visible to the operator. That's why everyone is able to audit all the usage - which is a good thing for free markets. A feature, not a bug.
The market sets the price, not the operator. There is no "house" setting the odds. It's the invisible hand, not the thumb on the scale. The idea is if people disagree with the market price, they have the opportunity to capitalize by buying the side they think is priced too low.
As these markets get more popular, liquid, and accessible, we foresee a world where markets guide decision making, and opinions are backed by capital. The downstream effect is an information landscape with less sensationalism and more truth. Onwards -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thats a little misleading. In February of 2020, the month before the pandemic hit, it was 3.5.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2024 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James A. Robinson âfor studies of how institutions are formed and affect prosperity.â
#nobelprize -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Christopher Phelan
@ChrisPhelanEcon
This is huge. Not the least or national security. NASAâs SLS system has cost $24 billion so far, and they are hoping for a $2 billion per launch operating cost. SpaceX has spent $5 billion dollars on Starship so far, and will be able to reuse everything. Right now launch cost is probably about $100 million. They are hoping to get it down to under $10 million. $10 million vs. $2 billion.
SpaceX
@SpaceX
Mechazilla has caught the Super Heavy booster!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
The central bank's policy rate and the government's cost of funding are two different objects. The second one is determined in equilibrium by supply and the demand for government bonds. The first one is not.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thisđ§”from @michaelxpettis is well worth reading. He mentions a @rodrikdani argument that globalization is in conflict with democracy â meaning that the citizens of the nation state choose their own leaders and those leaders implement the policies on which they were elected. 1/8
Michael Pettis
@michaelxpettis
1/11
Adam Tooze suggests that "If your aim is restoring the competitive position of US industry, a large dollar devaluation would do more than a sprinkling of industrial subsidies."
@adam_tooze
www.ft.com/content/225cd989-4edb-4b1f-8e76-8605f1fa3922 via @ftPost not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
There is a very clear divergence between the interests of the western elites who control the levers of political power, and the interests of the majority of the voters in western electorates whose democratic votes legitimize that power. 3/8
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The rise of working class leaders in the 19th and 20th century provided an alternative voice to power elites in England, Europe and America and, through unionization of the workforce, led to labor reforms, shorter working hours and more humane working conditions. 4/8
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The hard won gains of the labor movement have been eroded through competition with China and the importation of mass produced manufacturing goods produced with labor that does not enjoy the hard won protections of unionized western workers. 5/8
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Middle and working classes in the west are beginning to wake up to the fact that their interests are no longer represented by traditionally left wing parties â Labour in the UK and the Democratic Party in the US. 6/8
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The recognition that elitist policy goals do not serve the interests of the average voter will lead to the victory of nationalist parties throughout the West. IF, that is, democracy as it has previously been understood is allowed to survive. 7/8
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This obvious fact has been recognized by âthought leadersâ on the left who have made a case for narrowing the franchise and allowing only the educated to vote. The way this will play out in the next few years is anybodyâs guess. 8/8
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Many of the American workers impacted by globalization would disagree. chinashock.info
âSome areas of the U.S. were hit especially hard by China's rise, partly because those areas had lots of jobs in industries where imports surged the most.â Research by David Autor of MIT, David Dorn of the University of Zurich and Gordon Hanson of Harvardâs Kennedy School.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
We should be mostly unapologetic about globalization, @jasonfurman said at the #wtopublicforum.
"The question is what can we do to have more of this and continue while managing the very serious geopolitical tensions in the world today."
Read:
www.piie.com/commentary/speeches-papers/2024/globalizatio⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This getting repetitive. The @piie keeps reposting this piece. I have little or no confidence in what the paper purports to find for the reasons I explained my earlier post. Reposted here,
ââââ
This @PIIE paper from McKibbin et. al. uses a large scale econometric model to analyze three policies proposed by former President Trump. @AdamPosen @WarwickMcKibbin @meganrosehogan
1. The deportation of large numbers of undocumented aliens who have crossed the border illegally, sidestepping the legal process for acquiring U.S. citizenship.
2. The imposition of high tariffs on countries, notably China, at levels equal to or exceeding tariff levels levied by those countries on U.S. exports.
3. The removal of the independence of the Federal Reserve Board and the reintroduction of political control over monetary policy.
The paper reports the forecast time path for a number of economic variables, including GDP, inflation and employment if a Trump administration were to enact one or more of these policies. The summary finding is that GDP growth and employment would fall and inflation would increase. In other words: Trump would be bad for the economy.
This conclusion should be taken with a very large grain of salt. I have a number of criticisms of the way the results are presented.
First: the authors are far too certain in their own infallibility for my taste. Economic forecasts should NEVER be presented without standard errors which are typically very large and which grow very rapidly very quickly. As I argued here
rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerbloâŠ
âThe Bank of England famously produces fan charts that show not only the median forecast but the probability distribution of likely outcomes. For several forecasts in a row following the 2008 crisis, all the realized values of projected inflation were outside of the range of statistical projections. They were Black-Swan events.â
At least the Bank acknowledged its own fallibility by printing a range of possibilities for future outcomes. Even so, the realized outcomes were outside of their 95% confidence bounds several quarters in a row. McKibbin et. al. give us only the median projection. It is unlikely that their model is better than the Bankâs.
Second. The paper reports that a deportation of undocumented aliens will lower the growth rate of GDP: That is an irrelevant metric. From the perspective of U.S. citizens the relevant measure is GDP per person. Removing people from the economy will trivially lower GDP since there are fewer people producing goods and services. A reduction in GDP may or may not result in lower GDP per person.
Third. The paper ignores distributional effects. Even if the Trump policies were to reduce GDP per person, (and I do not know this to be the case), the relevant decision for the median voter is whether he or she gains a job as a result of the potential reshoreing of manufacturing jobs.
To summarize. I do not know if the proposed Trump economic policy will raise GDP per person. The McKibbin et. al. paper has not persuaded me that it will not.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
Former president Trump has promised to improve Americans' lives if elected. But some policies he's promotingâdeporting millions of people, steeper tariffs, & eroding the Fed's independenceâwould have the opposite effects. #piiecharts
Interactive chart: www.piie.com/research/piie-charts/2024/trumps-economic-po⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thatâs not my point Warwick. Itâs the disingenuous assertion that one sample path from your model, with no allowance for parameter uncertainty, model mis-specification or shocks to the variables of the model, demonstrates that the proposed Republican policies will be bad for the economy.
In a much simpler model, when labor and capital are substitutes, a fall in labor causes an increase in productivity. As Iâm sure youâre aware, there will be alternative specifications â hard to distinguish in data â that lead to the opposite conclusion from the one you confidently assert as fact. If you dispute this assertion, then publish the standard errors around your parameter estimates.
This paper would never have made it into the NBER series which screens for blatant political opinions â which is what this hit piece is. Releasing what is at best, an opinion dressed up as âscienceâ a month before the U.S. presidential election gives the profession a bad name and contributes to the lack of confidence that many Americans profess in âthe experts.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The @piie keeps reposting this piece. I have little or no confidence in what the paper purports to find for the reasons I explained my earlier post. Reposted here,
ââââ
This @PIIE paper from McKibbin et. al. uses a large scale econometric model to analyze three policies proposed by former President Trump. @AdamPosen @WarwickMcKibbin @meganrosehogan
1. The deportation of large numbers of undocumented aliens who have crossed the border illegally, sidestepping the legal process for acquiring U.S. citizenship.
2. The imposition of high tariffs on countries, notably China, at levels equal to or exceeding tariff levels levied by those countries on U.S. exports.
3. The removal of the independence of the Federal Reserve Board and the reintroduction of political control over monetary policy.
The paper reports the forecast time path for a number of economic variables, including GDP, inflation and employment if a Trump administration were to enact one or more of these policies. The summary finding is that GDP growth and employment would fall and inflation would increase. In other words: Trump would be bad for the economy.
This conclusion should be taken with a very large grain of salt. I have a number of criticisms of the way the results are presented.
First: the authors are far too certain in their own infallibility for my taste. Economic forecasts should NEVER be presented without standard errors which are typically very large and which grow very rapidly very quickly. As I argued here
rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerbloâŠ
âThe Bank of England famously produces fan charts that show not only the median forecast but the probability distribution of likely outcomes. For several forecasts in a row following the 2008 crisis, all the realized values of projected inflation were outside of the range of statistical projections. They were Black-Swan events.â
At least the Bank acknowledged its own fallibility by printing a range of possibilities for future outcomes. Even so, the realized outcomes were outside of their 95% confidence bounds several quarters in a row. McKibbin et. al. give us only the median projection. It is unlikely that their model is better than the Bankâs.
Second. The paper reports that a deportation of undocumented aliens will lower the growth rate of GDP: That is an irrelevant metric. From the perspective of U.S. citizens the relevant measure is GDP per person. Removing people from the economy will trivially lower GDP since there are fewer people producing goods and services. A reduction in GDP may or may not result in lower GDP per person.
Third. The paper ignores distributional effects. Even if the Trump policies were to reduce GDP per person, (and I do not know this to be the case), the relevant decision for the median voter is whether he or she gains a job as a result of the potential reshoreing of manufacturing jobs.
To summarize. I do not know if the proposed Trump economic policy will raise GDP per person. The McKibbin et. al. paper has not persuaded me that it will not. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Michal Horvath
@mh0rvath
đą We are on the job market this year đą
We are looking to fill up to *ten* Senior Economist / Economist positions through international hiring.
Our full advert is now live: econjobmarket.org/positions/10905 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Wise words from the editor of the American Economic Review: "the profession's obsession with just 5 journals is not healthy."
Erzo F.P. Luttmer
@ErzoLuttmer
I appreciate the work that you put into this and your public service, but the profession's obsession with just 5 journals is not healthy. Let's not promote that. There's plenty of overlap in quality between papers published in these 5 journals and elsewhere!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The âTreasury Viewâ has survived into the 21st century. How hard can it be to separate government investment spending from government consumption?
Dan Davies
@dsquareddigest
you don't need any more than this to know that there's something institutionally pathological at the Treasury. It's a very fundamental and basic fact of economics that a good investment doesn't become bad or vice versa depending on how you finance it.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peyman Milanfar
@docmilanfar
A surprising & little-known results in classical statistics:
mean (Ό) and median (m) are within one std deviation:
|ÎŒâm| †Ï
For unimodal densities, bound is even tighter
|ÎŒâm| †0.7746 Ï
This beautiful results first appeared in a 1932 paper by Hotelling & Solomons
1/3 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree.
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
The 2024 Nobel in Economics needs to go Arnold Harberger
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I would also highly recommend Stiglerâs 1986 book: www.ams.org/mathscinet-getitem?mr=0852410
Peyman Milanfar
@docmilanfar
Do you think you know Maximum Likelihood? Think again
It seems like such a natural idea, but thereâs an epic and turbulent history with numerous assaults on the core idea, culminating in a beautiful and complicated theory.
A highly entertaining account:
arxiv.org/abs/0804.2996 -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Bessis
@davidbessis
This Grothendieck quote is the best-kept secret about mathematics:
Always start with your naive intuition, even if itâs plainly dumb, and then refine it by asking a barrage of âstupidâ questions. Waiting in silence until you âget it rightâ will only lead to paralysis. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Katharine Birbalsingh
@Miss_Snuffy
Oh isnât she wonderful! â€ïž
May our National Treasure Maggie Smith rest in peace. đą -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This @PIIE paper from McKibbin et. al. uses a large scale econometric model to analyze three policies proposed by former President Trump. @AdamPosen @WarwickMcKibbin @meganrosehogan
1. The deportation of large numbers of undocumented aliens who have crossed the border illegally, sidestepping the legal process for acquiring U.S. citizenship.
2. The imposition of high tariffs on countries, notably China, at levels equal to or exceeding tariff levels levied by those countries on U.S. exports.
3. The removal of the independence of the Federal Reserve Board and the reintroduction of political control over monetary policy.
The paper reports the forecast time path for a number of economic variables, including GDP, inflation and employment if a Trump administration were to enact one or more of these policies. The summary finding is that GDP growth and employment would fall and inflation would increase. In other words: Trump would be bad for the economy.
This conclusion should be taken with a very large grain of salt. I have a number of criticisms of the way the results are presented.
First: the authors are far too certain in their own infallibility for my taste. Economic forecasts should NEVER be presented without standard errors which are typically very large and which grow very rapidly very quickly. As I argued here
rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerbloâŠ
âThe Bank of England famously produces fan charts that show not only the median forecast but the probability distribution of likely outcomes. For several forecasts in a row following the 2008 crisis, all the realized values of projected inflation were outside of the range of statistical projections. They were Black-Swan events.â
At least the Bank acknowledged its own fallibility by printing a range of possibilities for future outcomes. Even so, the realized outcomes were outside of their 95% confidence bounds several quarters in a row. McKibbin et. al. give us only the median projection. It is unlikely that their model is better than the Bankâs.
Second. The paper reports that a deportation of undocumented aliens will lower the growth rate of GDP: That is an irrelevant metric. From the perspective of U.S. citizens the relevant measure is GDP per person. Removing people from the economy will trivially lower GDP since there are fewer people producing goods and services. A reduction in GDP may or may not result in lower GDP per person.
Third. The paper ignores distributional effects. Even if the Trump policies were to reduce GDP per person, (and I do not know this to be the case), the relevant decision for the median voter is whether he or she gains a job as a result of the potential reshoreing of manufacturing jobs.
To summarize. I do not know if the proposed Trump economic policy will raise GDP per person. The McKibbin et. al. paper has not persuaded me that it will not.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
Trump often promises to âmake the foreigners pay,â but under his proposed mass deportations, tariffs, & erosion of Fed independence, American households & firms would suffer the most. www.piie.com/blogs/realtime-economics/2024/how-much-wouldâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peter Doyle
@retepelyod
I regret, Martin. that in this case you may find yourself in a small minority in macro which takes that view, a minority dominated by @PIIE employees and alums and those who with the best of intentions place political expediencey above professional integrity.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peter Doyle
@retepelyod
What disturbs me most about these points from @farmerrf is that they evidently were not made by internal @PIIE reviewers before the paper was published.
Being anxious about the outcome of the election is one thing; abandoning professional standards accordingly is another.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Again: thatâs irrelevant: What happens to GDP per person? That is surely what Americans should care about.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
How can that be so? In the first period, capital is fixed and labor falls. If the technology is neoclassical: GDP per worker must increase. Could you please explain why your model does not make that prediction?
P.s. off to dinner. ⊠may not respond to you right away ⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Again: thatâs irrelevant: What happens to GDP per person? That is surely what Americans should care about.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks @WarwickMcKibbin but I donât understand your response.
What determines the long-run GDP growth rate in your model? What determines the long-run real interest rate. Are you claiming that a once off removal of 5% of the labor force is predicted, by the model, to lower long-run economic growth. If so, can you please explain the mechanism by which this is achieved? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for responding @WarwickMcKibbin
Since output per worker is the correct metric: why not report the results from your model for that statistic. As Iâm sure you are aware, the standard errors are likely to be enormous for long horizon predictions; particularly if you allow for model mis-specification. And your charts go out to 2040, by which time we will likely have new employment opportunities on Mars.
It would also be relatively simple to generate empirical standard errors and fan charts for your forecasts. If the Bank of England can do it: so can you.
Would I expect that output per worker should increase if I were to remove 5% of the labor force? Yes.
Combining less labor with the same amount of capital in a neoclassical technology is predicted to increase labor productivity. It is also predicted to raise real wages. It is hard to understand why your model does not give that prediction if it is based on a constant returns to scale technology.
@WarwickMcKibbin @PIIE @meganrosehogan -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This @PIIE paper from McKibbin et. al. uses a large scale econometric model to analyze three policies proposed by former President Trump. @AdamPosen @WarwickMcKibbin @meganrosehogan
1. The deportation of large numbers of undocumented aliens who have crossed the border illegally, sidestepping the legal process for acquiring U.S. citizenship.
2. The imposition of high tariffs on countries, notably China, at levels equal to or exceeding tariff levels levied by those countries on U.S. exports.
3. The removal of the independence of the Federal Reserve Board and the reintroduction of political control over monetary policy.
The paper reports the forecast time path for a number of economic variables, including GDP, inflation and employment if a Trump administration were to enact one or more of these policies. The summary finding is that GDP growth and employment would fall and inflation would increase. In other words: Trump would be bad for the economy.
This conclusion should be taken with a very large grain of salt. I have a number of criticisms of the way the results are presented.
First: the authors are far too certain in their own infallibility for my taste. Economic forecasts should NEVER be presented without standard errors which are typically very large and which grow very rapidly very quickly. As I argued here
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2018/1/31/why-we-expeâŠ
âThe Bank of England famously produces fan charts that show not only the median forecast but the probability distribution of likely outcomes. For several forecasts in a row following the 2008 crisis, all the realized values of projected inflation were outside of the range of statistical projections. They were Black-Swan events.â
At least the Bank acknowledged its own fallibility by printing a range of possibilities for future outcomes. Even so, the realized outcomes were outside of their 95% confidence bounds several quarters in a row. McKibbin et. al. give us only the median projection. It is unlikely that their model is better than the Bankâs.
Second. The paper reports that a deportation of undocumented aliens will lower the growth rate of GDP: That is an irrelevant metric. From the perspective of U.S. citizens the relevant measure is GDP per person. Removing people from the economy will trivially lower GDP since there are fewer people producing goods and services. A reduction in GDP may or may not result in lower GDP per person.
Third. The paper ignores distributional effects. Even if the Trump policies were to reduce GDP per person, (and I do not know this to be the case), the relevant decision for the median voter is whether he or she gains a job as a result of the potential reshoreing of manufacturing jobs.
To summarize. I do not know if the proposed Trump economic policy will raise GDP per person. The McKibbin et. al. paper has not persuaded me that it will not.
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
Given Trump's proposed mass deportations, tariffs, & Fed independence erosion, by 2028, US consumer prices would generally be 20-28% higher & inflation rate would settle 2 percentage points above baseline, to be almost 4%, from 2034 through 2040.
Read: www.piie.com/publications/working-papers/2024/internation⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Michael Thrower Chowdhury
@BevansAdvocate
10 Great Papers to Expand Your Econ Frameworks
1) Rational Fools - Amartya Sen
Sen at his best, engaging with Econ models whilst having a strong philosophical background. This paper presents insightful challenges to revealed preference theory.
jstor.org/stable/2264946 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Lee @lee_ohanian explains why CA homeless programs are dysfunctional by contrasting them with unemployment insurance, which works well by comparison.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Not necessarily true if finite lifetimes matter.
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
My own view is that ânaturalâ rate of interest roughly equal to growth rate of consumption (which, by PIH, should be proportional to wealth). If so, then R* = 2.5 (data below) + 2.5% expected inflation + 0.25% Taylor principle = 5.25%.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Josh Wright
@JoshWright1977
Armen was the best. And Iâm very proud to be his last student. Here is a case for an Alchian Nobel I made 16 years ago:
truthonthemarket.com/2009/08/25/armen-alchian-harold-demsâŠ
It holds up very well.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Armen Alchian was an under appreciated giant of economics with a unique style that he imprinted on the UCLA department and that lasted for decades after his retirement in 1984. Alchian and Allenâs text âUniversity Economicsâ is a classic.
Josh Hendrickson
@RebelEconProf
Alchian and Allen, an antidote to the grocery store price gouging mind virus.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
Alchian shaped econ education at GMU as well ⊠www.coordinationproblem.org/2013/02/economic-forces-at-woâŠ
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Armen Alchian was an under appreciated giant of economics with a unique style that he imprinted on the UCLA department and that lasted for decades after his retirement in 1984. Alchian and Allenâs text âUniversity Economicsâ is a classic.
Josh Hendrickson
@RebelEconProf
Alchian and Allen, an antidote to the grocery store price gouging mind virus.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
He may not be wrong. My take from UK data is that the peak for ordinary income is a top marginal rate around 40%
Kevin Standridge
@KevinStandridg6
Interesting that if you listen to interviews today of Laffer he still thinks we are on the wrong side.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Richard Blundell
@R_Blundell_UCL
The Review has a focus on investment, innovation and productivity growth as well as inequality and social mobility.The taxes article makes a strong case for aligning tax rates, while reforming the tax base so that taxes do not unduly discourage investment. academic.oup.com/ooec/search-results?f_TocHeadingTitleLisâŠ
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Even if this is true ⊠revenue maximization should not be the primary goal of fiscal policy. The right question is: will a substantial increase in capital gains tax have a significant negative impact on investment, job creation and growth?
Richard Blundell
@R_Blundell_UCL
âThe revenue potential from increasing tax rates on capital gains may be substantially larger than previously thought by many in the tax policy community.â Top incomes and tax policy | Owen Zidar | IFS Deaton Review | Oxford Open Economics academic.oup.com/ooec/article/3/Supplement_1/i1133/7708054
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Even if this is true ⊠revenue maximization should not be the primary goal of fiscal policy. The right question is: will a substantial increase in capital gains tax have a significant negative impact on investment, job creation and growth?
Richard Blundell
@R_Blundell_UCL
âThe revenue potential from increasing tax rates on capital gains may be substantially larger than previously thought by many in the tax policy community.â Top incomes and tax policy | Owen Zidar | IFS Deaton Review | Oxford Open Economics academic.oup.com/ooec/article/3/Supplement_1/i1133/7708054
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And this is why that concentration is a problem www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/10/28/the-curse-âŠ
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
Is academic econ overly concentrated in a few elite departments and journals? Absolutely.
But that does not imply that we should fix it by opening the door to Post-Keynesian, Marxist, & MMTer cranks whose arguments can't even hit in middle tier journals with good reason. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Armen Alchian was an under appreciated giant of economics with a unique style that he imprinted on the UCLA department and that lasted for decades after his retirement in 1984. Alchian and Allenâs text âUniversity Economicsâ is a classic.
Josh Hendrickson
@RebelEconProf
Alchian and Allen, an antidote to the grocery store price gouging mind virus.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Third edition coming soon!
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Spotted â a copy of @farmerrf now added to my library #econtwitter
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Obviously not. Scarcity determine relative prices. The price of drugs, relative to the price of bread, will be higher in a market in which the drug companies have monopoly, than in a market with perfect competition. The dollar prices of drugs and bread depend on the ratio of the supply of these commodities to the quantity of money.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I know of no well specified DSGE model in which price controls prevent inflation in an environment in which the quantity of nominal government liabilities is increasing at 7% per year, as it is in the U.S. @IsabellaMWeber @mnikiforos @dandolfa @carney @larry_kudlow Those assets have to go somewhere 1/
Michalis Nikiforos
@mnikiforos
Even in very mainstream economics (micro and macro), the moment you drop the assumptions of perfect markets/competition etc. price controls are an obvious policy implication. E.g., price controls fit perfectly well in DSGE models because they assume monopolistic competition. 1/4
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Perhaps, temporarily, people will voluntarily hold government debt. This requires also, that t-bills and reserves are paying a sufficiently high interest rate. But in an environment in which the interest rate starts to fall, as it is likely to soon in the U.S., the excess liquidity will be spent on a limited supply of goods. Perhaps the increase in demand will generate a supply response. But there is an upper bound on supply as unemployment falls and productivity growth reaches its technological limit. This is exactly the scenario that led to the 1970s inflationary spiral, as I wrote about here,
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
@IsabellaMWeber @mnikiforos @dandolfa @carney @larry_kudlow Price controls will not prevent inflation any more that King Canuteâs directive prevented the incoming tide. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Exploring the role of money when income risk in uninsurable, from @farmerrf www.nber.org/papers/w32836
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Absolutely @dandolfa @carney And even if the removal of all tariffs were welfare improving to the nation, the economic benefits of trade require that the winners compensate the losers. Working class Americans have not benefited from trade with China. 1/x
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
I don't think the inflation angle is a good one. Taxes may raise inflation temporarily, but their main effect is likely to be on relative prices (imported goods become more expensive relative to to domestic goods). Will this be good or bad and, if so, in what sense?
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The counter to this argument is that technology is adapting so quickly that the jobs that provided a living wage to unskilled Americans before the rise of China will now be taken by robots. Regardless, reshoreing of manufacturing has other advantages. 3/x
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
When China âreunitesâ with Taiwan, the U.S. will be in an uncomfortable position. Taiwan accounts for more than 90% of logic semiconductors, not to mention steel, iron, medicines and pretty much everything else that an economy would need in the event of conflict. 4/4
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This đ§” from @BenforOregon makes for salutary reading and reflects the divergence between the US and UK approach to free speech. As @Tom_Slater_ reminds us, writing in Spiked www.spiked-online.com/2024/08/17/between-bigots-and-censors/, there is no such thing as hate speech in the US.
Ben West đșđž đŠ
đșđČđŠ«đČ
@BenforOregon
MY REFLECTION:
There's an old saying, "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.â
I spoke up as a County Commissioner during the trial of Antifa's Alissa Azar because I felt it was necessary to articulate the values of those I represent. đ§”
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
In 1978, the @ACLU defended the right of a group of actual n@zis to march in Skokie Illinois, an area where a number of Holocaust survivors lived. As J. S. Mill taught us www.econlib.org/library/Mill/mlLbty.html, the right response to âhate speechâ, is more speech.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The ability of any national government to censor information is limited as long as there is at least one country that maintains freedom of speech. The first amendment is more important now than ever before.
Reclaim The Net
@ReclaimTheNetHQ
X Draws the Line in Brazil, Shuts Down Local Operations Amid Censorship Clash
reclaimthenet.org/x-draws-the-line-in-brazil-shuts-down-l⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree.
Porter Stansberry
@porterstansb
From todayâs WSJ. If you donât understand this chart, donât have money in stocks. If you do understand this chart, why do you have money in stocks?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And if @BrianCAlbrecht hasnât convinced you: here is a classic piece from Hayek on how the price system works
www.econlib.org/library/Essays/hykKnw.html?chapter_num=1
This should be required reading for every undergraduate economics student, every financial journalist and every member of congress
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
Yes, price controls are bad.
Yes, banning price gouging would amount to price controls.
I guess this needs to be retaught. www.economicforces.xyz/p/do-i-really-have-to-explain-why-⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
caseybmulligan
@caseybmulligan
If only there were an equilibrium presentation of price controls. Even better, with grocery ceilings as a leading example.
Oh wait ... forthcoming in Public Choice. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
The question boils down to whether we believe that market prices can be expected to serve as effective communication/coordination devices. Who coordinates supply/demand if market signals not permitted to work?
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
The price question in an eggshell:
@jasonfurman: When đ„ prices go up, supply goes up.
Me: When đ„ prices go up, đ do not lay more đ„. It takes time until more đ„-laying đ are bred. In the interim, prices overshoot hurting consumers & causing windfall profits.
Full story đđœ -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Please tell this to @MayorofLondon Rent control is a policy that appears superficially attractive but always has unintended consequences. The Argentine experience suggests that the introduction of rent control in London will INCREASE rental rates.
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
Meanwhile in Argentina, the "recent repeal of rent control by... Milei has led to a surge in housing supply, with the freedom to negotiate contracts, previously restricted, directly causing a drop in rental prices" www.newsweek.com/javier-milei-rent-control-argentina-us-eâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
CEPR
@cepr_org
New CEPR Discussion Paper - DP19333
Money in a Heterogeneous Agent Model
Roger Farmer @farmerrf @uniofwarwick @UCLA
cepr.org/publications/dp19333
#cepr_mef #economics -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Sure, but David's asking about the projected deficits, which seem large. How does your model account for <3% inflation in light of what is likely to be a very large increase in the supply of USTs?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
For those who are wondering about the impact of the Musk-Trump conversation last night, I recommend you read this post and, in particular, the responses to the post. Understand that there are roughly 37 million democrats, 32 million independents and 34 million republicans on X.
James Altucher
@jaltucher
I'm hesitant to post this because I don't really like any aspect of the political system. But here is what I heard last night at the Must/Trump conversation and I'm curious what part of this people disagree with:
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Time to recycle this post www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2016/6/3/its-the-unemâŠ
from 2016. Recessions have NOTHING to do with LFPR
Ernie Tedeschi
@ernietedeschi
LFPR was less cyclical pre-1990 in part because of the ongoing structural rise in female labor force participation (left). That process ended around the mid-1990s--women's share of the prime-age labor force flattened out about then (right). LFPR has been more cyclical since.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Right ⊠I saw that immediately đš
Jonathan Gorard
@getjonwithit
Gödel's first incompleteness theorem is commonly proved by means of a diagonal argument. But, in retrospect, we can see that what Gödel was really doing was proving that Peano arithmetic is Turing-complete, and then applying an argument from computational irreducibility... (1/15)
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
You know, when Gabriel Zucman accuses Auten and Splinter of being sloppy, its pretty rich given their own work. Its worth considering that half of their data structure from the IRS is broken beyond repair. All of the DINA from Piketty, Saez, Zucman up to 1965 should simply be thrown away as it relies on the massively flawed PS (2003,2007) which carry many mistakes. Many errors, based on arbitrary and incorrect depictions of the available BEA data, also affect post-1965. My co-author, @PhilWMagness, made this summary table of the flaws in the PSZ methods. In our paper here, we show that 40% of the difference between Auten-Splinter and PSZ post-1960 is due to how they define « total income » inconsistently.
The PSZ estimates are so rife with problems that I woudnt want to use this for anything. You may not like Auten Splinter, but whatever issues you have with them, the quality is ten times worse in PSZ.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfâŠ
Gabriel Zucman
@gabriel_zucman
Delighted to release this paper on Auten & Splinterâs work, painstakingly going through their code & assumptions
gabriel-zucman.eu/files/PSZ2024.pdf
We uncover key mistakesâand show that once fixed, their methodology implies the same rise of inequality as in Piketty-Saez-Zucman
đ§” -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Well worth a listen. Free speech is worth defending!
Andrea Stroppa đș Claudius Nero's Legion đș
@andst7
âMr. Beanâ on free speech in UK.
Video: @christianorgukThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
.@farmerrf was one of the early guests on the podcast (www.mercatus.org/macro-musings/roger-farmer-natural-rate-âŠ) and we got to discuss his work on belief function in macro. Here is a summary of the belief function from AI:
đđšđđąđŻđđđąđšđ§
1. đđ«đąđđąđȘđźđ đšđ đ«đđđąđšđ§đđ„ đđ±đ©đđđđđđąđšđ§đŹ: Farmer argues that the standard rational expectations approach in macroeconomics is flawed. He believes it doesn't adequately capture how people actually form expectations about the future.
2. đđđđ«đđŹđŹđąđ§đ đąđ§đđđđđ«đŠđąđ§đđđČ: In many macroeconomic models, there are multiple equilibria possible. The belief function helps select among these equilibria.
3. đđ§đđšđ«đ©đšđ«đđđąđ§đ đ©đŹđČđđĄđšđ„đšđ đČ: Farmer aims to bring insights from behavioral economics and psychology into macroeconomic modeling.
4. đđ±đ©đ„đđąđ§đąđ§đ đ©đđ«đŹđąđŹđđđ§đ đźđ§đđŠđ©đ„đšđČđŠđđ§đ: He uses the belief function to explain why unemployment can persist at high levels even in the long run.
đđŹđ đšđ đđĄđ đđđ„đąđđ đ đźđ§đđđąđšđ§:
1. đđ±đ©đđđđđđąđšđ§ đđšđ«đŠđđđąđšđ§: The belief function replaces rational expectations in Farmer's models. It describes how agents in the economy form beliefs about future economic variables (like stock prices or unemployment rates).
2. đđđ„đ-đđźđ„đđąđ„đ„đąđ§đ đ©đ«đšđ©đĄđđđąđđŹ These beliefs can become self-fulfilling. If people expect high unemployment, they may act in ways that lead to high unemployment, validating their initial belief.
3. đđšđđđ„ đđ„đšđŹđźđ«đ: In Farmer's framework, the belief function "closes" the model by pinning down expectations, similar to how rational expectations are used in more conventional models.
4. đđšđ„đąđđČ đąđŠđ©đ„đąđđđđąđšđ§đŹ: The belief function approach suggests that managing expectations through policy can have significant effects on economic outcomes.
5. đđđšđđ€ đŠđđ«đ€đđ đđšđđźđŹ: Farmer often emphasizes the role of the stock market in his models, with the belief function playing a key role in determining stock market valuations. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Simple exposition here andolfatto.blogspot.com/2015/02/a-simple-model-of-multiplâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
I am beginning to wonder if the popular Sahm Rule is not just a predictor of recessions, but an amplifier of recessionary fears that can become self-fulfilling.
www.cnbc.com/2024/08/05/recession-what-is-the-sahm-rule-a⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Letâs wait and see how far the market falls and if the drop is persistent. My guess: a recession is coming.
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
Not to get ahead of myself, but I am reminded of @farmerrf's interesting work on animal spirits, belief functions, and the economy right now. What say you, Roger? www.rogerfarmer.com/journal-pubs
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Beckworth
@DavidBeckworth
Not to get ahead of myself, but I am reminded of @farmerrf's interesting work on animal spirits, belief functions, and the economy right now. What say you, Roger? www.rogerfarmer.com/journal-pubs
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Interesting đ§” summarizing the results of an NBER paper about an experiment that analyzed the employment effects of guaranteed income. Unsurprisingly, as economic theory predicts, there is a wealth effect on the demand for leisure. @Athan_K
Athan Koutsiouroumbas
@Athan_K
A lot happened in July.
But, one event went quietly unnoticed.
The result of largest American controlled experiment in Universal Basic Income (UBI) was released.
You havenât heard about it because the findings are terrifyingly bad. (1/12) -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
l'Histoire du jour©
@394Histoires
27 Juillet 1924:
Naissance de Arnold Harberger, Ă Newark, dans le New Jersey, aux Ătats-Unis.
Ăconomiste AmĂ©ricain, membre de l'AcadĂ©mie Nationale des Arts et des Sciences, ancien PrĂ©sident de la American Economic Association
Il célÚbre aujourd'hui ses 100 ans
#arnoldharberger -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Happy 100th birthday Alito. @UCLAEconomics @UChi_Economics Al arrived at UCLA a year before me after retiring from U Chicago. He had two full careers, one at U Chicago and one at UCLA.
Jon Hartley
@Jon_Hartley_
Al Harberger, namesake of the deadweight loss Harberger triangle and long-time Chicago School economist, turns 100 today www.econ.ucla.edu/harberger/
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Of all the joys of this profession, teaching, but most of all, learning from my students is perhaps the greatest. @warwickecon @NIESRorg @AruhanRS Congrats RuiđŸ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Tom Holden
@t_holden
I'm not going to be cool about this. This is a huge deal for me. I still can't believe it's real.
I've somehow rolled this Trojan horse of a paper past the gates of the Top 5.
Under its nerdy exterior hides answers to some of the most fundamental question of monetary econ. 1/
Econometrica
@ecmaEditors
With a standard monetary rule & heterogeneous households, beliefs of a coming recession can become self-fulfilling. Monetary rules responding 1 for 1 to the real rate observed in TIPS markets prevent this & give near perfect control of inflation. @t_holden www.econometricsociety.org/publications/econometrica/fortâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jon Hartley
@Jon_Hartley_
A short summary of today's @JMilei speech at @Stanford @HooverInst; very technical economics heavy speech covering econ history, growth, general vs. partial equilibrium; dangers of models. Overall, critical of how economics has used market failure to justify state intervention.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
William J. Luther
@WilliamJLuther
Inflationary Laffer curve? Surely we should say that thereâs a tax revenue Bailey curve instead! www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/257766
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I donât think thatâs quite right @GeorgeSelgin The US government spends a little over over 20% of GDP. I doubt very much if 20% of GDP could be raised from the inflation tax. There is an inflationary Laffer curve which puts an upper bound on inflationary finance. @dandolfa
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
It's true that a sovereign-currency issuing gov't can, in theory, pay all its bills without having to resort to taxation, because it can rely on (net) money creation. This point is also one I've never disagreed with. (I _have_ said that _in practice_ things aren't quite so easy.)
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Vitor ConstĂąncio
@VMRConstancio
Producer price inflation in the Euro Area was negative for the fifth month in a row. Year on Year, producers' prices declined by -7.8%, a big help to disinflation. Still, the recent short-term inflation dynamics of inflation may be a sign that future disinflation will be bumpy
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This đ§”from @PhilWMagness argues that @gabriel_zucmanâs @nytimes argument for a wealth tax on the rich is based on two unconventional assumptions. 1) the way he attributes income from corporate profits and 2) his failure to account for tax rebates to low earners.
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
đ§”Thread on @gabriel_zucman's claim that billionaires pay a lower tax rate than the average American, as published in yesterday's @nytimes.
The short version: Zucman manipulates his data to fit a pro-tax political narrative. You can see this by comparing to his own earlier work.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
These assumptions deserve serious discussion by the community of researchers working on wealth and income inequality and I commend @PhilWMagnessâs thread for clearly explaining how @gabriel_zucmanâs conclusions follow from his data methodology.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you @stanford President and Provost. This statement to incoming students comes as a much needed breath of fresh air.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
Wonderful statement to incoming students from @Stanford president & provost. Should be the basis for similar letter from @Harvard to all of its students. Just what the doctor ordered at this critical moment. news.stanford.edu/report/?p=17465 via @Stanford
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
As @AllisterHeath of the @Telegraph points out, this ruling by the European Court of Human Rights goes much further than limiting the âtyranny of the majorityâ. It overturns the legitimate choice of the Swiss polity â expressed in a referendum â to choose a slower path to reduce carbon emissions than a group of unelected judges deems appropriate.
This is judicial overreach of the first order and will increase the likelihood that the UK withdraws from the European Convention on Human Rights.
Jeff Hass
@jeffhass1967
Tocqueville, tyranny of the majority, etc. This is not that far out.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an interesting reinterpretation of democracy from the ECHR
âDemocracy cannot be reduced to the will of the majority of the electorate and elected representatives, in disregard of the requirements of the rule of lawâ www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/04/10/international-left-wi⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jagjit S. Chadha
@jagjit_chadha
My father, Manmohan, has left the stage. He led a wonderfully inspiring life. There is so much to be thankful for but I still wanted more. Our family will forever be in his debt.
www.theguardian.com/business/2024/apr/07/manmohan-singh-c⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
His response is compelling. Itâs always a pleasure to read @JonHaidt and I was likely to read it anyway. Now I will read Jonâs new book for sure!
Ryan Shaw
@ThatShawGuy
Here is Jonâs response:
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
A review in Nature, by @candice_odgers, asserts that I have mistaken correlation for causation and that âthere is no evidence that using these platforms is rewiring childrenâs brains or driving an epidemic of mental illness.â Both of these assertions are untrue.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-00902-2
@zachmrausch and I have been collecting the published studies on both sides since 2019, organizing them, and making them available for public viewing and commenting, in multiple Google docs available here:
www.anxiousgeneration.com/resources/collaborative-review-âŠ
In the âsocial media and mental healthâ doc, we currently list 22 experimental studies (16 of which found significant evidence of harm) and 9 quasi-experiments (8 of which found evidence of harm. Odgers cited only the 9th one.) We also examine the many meta-analyses and review papers. I lay out the evidence for causality (not just correlation) and walk the reader through the Google doc in this post at After Babel:
www.afterbabel.com/p/social-media-mental-illness-epidemic
People really need to stop saying that the evidence is âjust correlational.â Sure, there are a lot of correlational studies (79 in our Google doc, of which 64 found significant correlations with variables related to poor mental health.) But there are also many experiments supporting my claims of causation.
Iâll write a post at afterbabel.com in April responding more fully to the arguments of the skeptics (including Odgers). For now, I point interested readers to a post in which I laid out 6 problems with the way that the skeptics have conceptualized the debate:
www.afterbabel.com/p/why-some-researchers-think-im-wrong
I just want to note two more problems with Odgersâ review.
First: She says that I am offering a simplistic one-factor explanation: itâs social media! But I am not. My story is about two major factors (end of the play-based childhood, rise of the phone-based childhood), each of which has many components that bring a variety of harms to different children in different ways. My book is full of lists of causal pathways. There is no one causal pathway that, on its own, explains âthe kind of large effects suggested by Haidt.â Yet when you add up all the different ways that the phone-based childhood is harming different kids, some of which we learned about in that Senate hearing on January 31, you end up with a lot of kids being harmed in many ways, and these many harms combined can easily explain the âlarge effectsâ even though most pathways affect only a subset of kids.
Yet Odgers and the other skeptics focus intently on studies that operationalize social media in one crude way (total # of hours per day), and then correlate that number with some measure of anxiety, depression, or other mental ailment. When the correlations turn out to be around r = .15 for girls (which is actually a number we agree on, as I explain in the previous link), the skeptics conclude that this is not large enough--by itself--to explain the epidemic, so social media must be only a trivial contributor to the epidemic. This is an error caused by an overly narrow operationalization of a complex phenomenon: the radical transformation of daily life that happened for teens between 2010 and 2015. Only a sliver of the story is captured by the crude measure of âhours per dayâ on social media.
The skepticsâ skepticism would be more compelling if they had an alternative explanation for the multi-national decline in mental health that happened in the early 2010s, but they do not. Odgers claims that the âreal causesâ of the crisis, from which my book âmight distract us from effectively responding,â are the lingering effects of the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, which had lasting effects on âfamilies in the bottom 20% of the income distribution,â who were âalso growing up at the time of an opioid crisis, school shootings, and increasing unrest because of racial and sexual discrimination and violence.â
I agree that those things are all bad for human development, but Odgersâ theory cannot explain why rates of anxiety and depression were generally flat in the 2000s and then suddenly shot upward roughly four years after the start of the Global Financial Crisis. Did life in America suddenly get that much worse during President Obamaâs 2nd term, as the economy was steadily improving?
Her theory also cannot explain why adolescent mental health collapsed in similar ways around the same time in Canada, the UK, Australia, and New Zealand, as Zach and I have shown:
www.afterbabel.com/p/international-mental-illness-part-one
Nor can she explain why it also happened in the Nordic countries, which lack most of the social pathologies on Odgersâ list:
www.afterbabel.com/p/international-mental-illness-part-two
Nor why it also happened in much of Western Europe:
www.afterbabel.com/p/international-crisis-europe
Nor why suicide rates for Gen Z girls (but not alway boys) are at record levels across the Anglosphere:
www.afterbabel.com/p/anglo-teen-suicide
I just canât see a causal path by which Americaâs school shootings, lockdown drills, inequality, or racism caused girls in Australia to suddenly start self-harming or dying by suicide at the same time as American girls.
In short: There is a great deal of evidence for my claims that something terrible is happening to teens in many countries, and that a major contributing factor is the sudden international arrival of the phone-based childhood. I lay out this evidenceââwith hundreds of footnotesââin chapters 1, 5, 6, and 7 of The Anxious Generation. I have also laid it out in many posts at afterbabel.com. All along, Zach and I have âshown our workâ in public Google Docs and Substack posts, and we have invited others to critique it. Zach has made supplemental files for every chapter in The Anxious Generation, which give links to the datasets and data points that he used to create the graphs in the book. We invite you to check our work:
www.anxiousgeneration.com/resources/supplements-for-each-âŠ
Our work has benefited from cordial, normal, academic debates with the skeptics. We will continue to welcome their critiques. But please, everyone, stop saying that the evidence is âjust correlational.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@JonHaidt responds to @candice_odgers with links to evidence that the rise of cell phones amongst teens has had a CAUSAL effect on teen mental health
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
A review in Nature, by @candice_odgers, asserts that I have mistaken correlation for causation and that âthere is no evidence that using these platforms is rewiring childrenâs brains or driving an epidemic of mental illness.â Both of these assertions are untrue.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-00902-2
@zachmrausch and I have been collecting the published studies on both sides since 2019, organizing them, and making them available for public viewing and commenting, in multiple Google docs available here:
www.anxiousgeneration.com/resources/collaborative-review-âŠ
In the âsocial media and mental healthâ doc, we currently list 22 experimental studies (16 of which found significant evidence of harm) and 9 quasi-experiments (8 of which found evidence of harm. Odgers cited only the 9th one.) We also examine the many meta-analyses and review papers. I lay out the evidence for causality (not just correlation) and walk the reader through the Google doc in this post at After Babel:
www.afterbabel.com/p/social-media-mental-illness-epidemic
People really need to stop saying that the evidence is âjust correlational.â Sure, there are a lot of correlational studies (79 in our Google doc, of which 64 found significant correlations with variables related to poor mental health.) But there are also many experiments supporting my claims of causation.
Iâll write a post at afterbabel.com in April responding more fully to the arguments of the skeptics (including Odgers). For now, I point interested readers to a post in which I laid out 6 problems with the way that the skeptics have conceptualized the debate:
www.afterbabel.com/p/why-some-researchers-think-im-wrong
I just want to note two more problems with Odgersâ review.
First: She says that I am offering a simplistic one-factor explanation: itâs social media! But I am not. My story is about two major factors (end of the play-based childhood, rise of the phone-based childhood), each of which has many components that bring a variety of harms to different children in different ways. My book is full of lists of causal pathways. There is no one causal pathway that, on its own, explains âthe kind of large effects suggested by Haidt.â Yet when you add up all the different ways that the phone-based childhood is harming different kids, some of which we learned about in that Senate hearing on January 31, you end up with a lot of kids being harmed in many ways, and these many harms combined can easily explain the âlarge effectsâ even though most pathways affect only a subset of kids.
Yet Odgers and the other skeptics focus intently on studies that operationalize social media in one crude way (total # of hours per day), and then correlate that number with some measure of anxiety, depression, or other mental ailment. When the correlations turn out to be around r = .15 for girls (which is actually a number we agree on, as I explain in the previous link), the skeptics conclude that this is not large enough--by itself--to explain the epidemic, so social media must be only a trivial contributor to the epidemic. This is an error caused by an overly narrow operationalization of a complex phenomenon: the radical transformation of daily life that happened for teens between 2010 and 2015. Only a sliver of the story is captured by the crude measure of âhours per dayâ on social media.
The skepticsâ skepticism would be more compelling if they had an alternative explanation for the multi-national decline in mental health that happened in the early 2010s, but they do not. Odgers claims that the âreal causesâ of the crisis, from which my book âmight distract us from effectively responding,â are the lingering effects of the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, which had lasting effects on âfamilies in the bottom 20% of the income distribution,â who were âalso growing up at the time of an opioid crisis, school shootings, and increasing unrest because of racial and sexual discrimination and violence.â
I agree that those things are all bad for human development, but Odgersâ theory cannot explain why rates of anxiety and depression were generally flat in the 2000s and then suddenly shot upward roughly four years after the start of the Global Financial Crisis. Did life in America suddenly get that much worse during President Obamaâs 2nd term, as the economy was steadily improving?
Her theory also cannot explain why adolescent mental health collapsed in similar ways around the same time in Canada, the UK, Australia, and New Zealand, as Zach and I have shown:
www.afterbabel.com/p/international-mental-illness-part-one
Nor can she explain why it also happened in the Nordic countries, which lack most of the social pathologies on Odgersâ list:
www.afterbabel.com/p/international-mental-illness-part-two
Nor why it also happened in much of Western Europe:
www.afterbabel.com/p/international-crisis-europe
Nor why suicide rates for Gen Z girls (but not alway boys) are at record levels across the Anglosphere:
www.afterbabel.com/p/anglo-teen-suicide
I just canât see a causal path by which Americaâs school shootings, lockdown drills, inequality, or racism caused girls in Australia to suddenly start self-harming or dying by suicide at the same time as American girls.
In short: There is a great deal of evidence for my claims that something terrible is happening to teens in many countries, and that a major contributing factor is the sudden international arrival of the phone-based childhood. I lay out this evidenceââwith hundreds of footnotesââin chapters 1, 5, 6, and 7 of The Anxious Generation. I have also laid it out in many posts at afterbabel.com. All along, Zach and I have âshown our workâ in public Google Docs and Substack posts, and we have invited others to critique it. Zach has made supplemental files for every chapter in The Anxious Generation, which give links to the datasets and data points that he used to create the graphs in the book. We invite you to check our work:
www.anxiousgeneration.com/resources/supplements-for-each-âŠ
Our work has benefited from cordial, normal, academic debates with the skeptics. We will continue to welcome their critiques. But please, everyone, stop saying that the evidence is âjust correlational.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I can personally attest to the fact that Michael is âvery politeâ having discussed my books with him a while back ⊠@michaelshermer
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
In my saga to get someone on my show to discuss systemic racism I continue striking out. The publicist of this book pitched me to have the author on. I accepted. Read book & prepared notes. Author backed out last minute: "she wants to pull back from additional interviews."
Sure. Authors of new trade books for the general public just hate telling 100,000 people about their ideas.
Why?
I don't bite! I'm polite even when disagreeing.
I even wrote a book on the subject: The Moral Arc
Theists will talk to me
Conservatives will talk to me
UFOlogists (a few anyway) will talk to me
Why won't defenders of systemic racism talk to me? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Excellent advice from @cesifoti
César A. Hidalgo
@cesifoti
I work with many students that are learning how to write. So I get to see a lot of them making the same mistakes. When I ask them why they are pursuing an academic career, or why they are working on a paper, they often tell me something like: âbecause I want to make a contribution to science.â
Now, thatâs a beautiful feeling. I sympathize with that. But it has nothing to do with writing. A reader doesnât read you because you want to make a contribution, but because you have something to say.
The great American novelist F. Scott Fitzgerald said it best:
âYou don't write because you want to say something, you write because you have something to say.â
Thatâs where I see a lot of students struggling. They come to work wanting to say something, but they have not worked on the story until they sit in front of the keyboard. Soon, writer block kicks in. They do not understanding that typing is not where ideation begins. It is something you need to prepare for by first growing an idea to the point you can no longer fit it in your head.
As an advisor it is easy to see the symptoms. Pointless drafts are circular and non-assertive. The student is trying to fill up pages without knowing what point they are trying to make with the hope that if they keep on going they will figure it out. But the reader already abandoned them in the first paragraph. After all, it is the job of a writer to know where a story ends. This âChekhovâs gun principle,â the idea that if a gun is shown in the first act, it must be fired in the third.
Chekhovâs gun is fundamental because it provides a method to question every sentence in your text: how does that sentence contribute to your final goal? If it doesnât, it must go. Pointless writing can be dismembered easily using this single technique. Use Chekhovâs gun to interrogate every sentence. Of course, all writers like to sometimes indulge in a poetic detour. But do that to often and you will lose your reader. There is a reason why there is another principle called âkill your darlings.â Cutting out a bad and pointless sentence is easy. Cutting out a beautiful but pointless sentences separates the kids from the adults.
Of course, some writingâand a lot of rewritingâtakes place at the keyboard. But the point is that writing is something that we must do first inside our heads: when cycling to work, walking with your partner, or cooling off after a heated argument. At some point you will need to sit down and transcribe those ideas. But the chances that the idea will hit you the moment you sit in front of a keyboard is naive. Having ideas and writing them down are two difficult activities. Trying to do them at the same time is an overkill.
So if you are a student reading this, and you are struggling to write, I have two pieces of advice. First, donât be discouraged. Wanting to say something may not be a lot, but can give you the perseverance needed to keep on going until you have something to say. And second, ask yourself the âFitzgerald question:â what am I trying to say? Your answer cannot be yes or no. It has to be a summary of the point you are trying to make. And when you finally start having an answer, work on it. Keep on trying to articulate it when you walk alone, when you drink with friends, and when you find that contrarian asshole that really pushes hard against anything you say. Because maybe, at the end of all of that practice, you will be able to sit down in front of a keyboard and write a good first draft. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations @QianxueZhang
Zoe Zhang
@QianxueZhang
A delightful surprise! Must be a by-product of the Job Market.đ€Ł Hope it turns into citation someday!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This thread by @IronEconomist does a good job of demolishing the arguments in this depressingly â but unsurprisingly â bad @guardian piece by @NickBano One would hope that UK law schools teach some basic economics. One would hope, apparently, in vain.
Iron Economist
@IronEconomist
Ok, I have had enough wine to engage with this insane piece. Itâs time to get started.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@dandolfa on why a return to a 2% interest rate is unlikely in the near future
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Whither U.S. Inflation & Interest Rates?
Slide deck from a recent presentation.
drive.google.com/file/d/1fu-KUM4MC_RMJ0yJooID-tcZHlsePqdd⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree
geoff tily
@geofftily
This is a quite amazing reflection on mainstream economics, by a very senior academic.
A genuine must read.
All respect to the author @DeatonAngus. Thank you.
www.imf.org/en/Publications/fandd/issues/2024/03/Symposiu⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Michelle Shipworth
@MShipworth
BANNED and cancelled for asking Masters students a challenging question. Iâm grateful to Telegraph for putting my story on todayâs front page :
1/16
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
đ UCL bans lecturer from China course to protect its âcommercial interestsâ
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/03/08/ucl-bans-lecturer-chi⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Universities should not, IMO, be focused on making money from overseas students. This quote struck me âŠ
âI would be pleased to continue this discussion in person⊠note that I am an economist and modeller and I have no idea who JS Mill is.â
Oh dear. digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/1602/reader/reader.h⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”The piece I linked on Friedman assumes, as did Friedman, that *the real rate* is *natural* and constant. That is an approximation that follows from his framework in which decision makers are infinite horizon families. 1/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
In theoretical (OLG) models in which overlapping generations of people coexist, the real rate is a variable that depends on the size the primary deficit. My claim that there is a maximum sustainable deficit follows from the fact that, in simple OLG models there ⊠2/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
⊠is no feasible equilibrium if the deficit is too high. Which of these two frameworks â decisions are made by infinitely-horizon decision makers or finite horizon agents â is a better description of data is an empirical question. 3/3
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Same response I gave to @SamHLevey
Explained here
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Joel Sitty
@JoelSitty
Hello TEAF thank you for the thoughtful reply. Since the Fed can select the interest rate on Treasury bonds as a policy choice, then if I understand your logic the debt is always sustainable since the Fed can always choose a rate at zero.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The Fed controls the short rate. The market determines the long-rate. Here is a piece that explains my position more completely
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Sam Levey
@SamHLevey
Through the central bank the gov can set the nominal rate wherever it wants, so higher deficits never need raise nominal rates. Large deficits are liable to increase inflation, and thereby *reduce* real rates.
Your response? -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This thread looks super interesting.
Matthew Jackson
@JacksonmMatt
How can we evaluate AIâs behavior as it increasingly takes the reins in peopleâs lives? We subjected chatbots to a Turing Test using a suite of games from behavioral economics used to assess things like altruism, trust, risk aversion⊠1/6 www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2313925121
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”And although the massive fiscal expansion leading up to WWII DID end the depression, it didnât happen in the way predicted by textbook representations of the General Theory. The GT, based on the consumption function, would predict that consumption, in response to an ⊠1/2
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Between November 1937 and spring 1940, when war mobilization finally reduced it, the U.S. unemployment rate never fell below 15%âfar higher than any rate since. Yet the myth persists that FDR, rather than the outbreak of war, âended the Great Depression.â Go figure.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
increase in gov purchases should increase. During WWII, consumption/GDP FELL. Textbook Keynesians respond that this was caused by price controls and rationing. That, IMO, is ex post rationalization of a clear failure of the theory when faced with a natural experiment. 2/2
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”As long as the cost of borrowing is less than the rate of growth of the economy, governments can continue to run deficits without ever paying them off. Although debt grows every year, GDP grows even faster and the ratio falls 1/
Joel Sitty
@JoelSitty
Hello REAF, what is the limit that makes a debt unsustainable? Do you mean that the federal government will run out of money? I donât understand what exactly is unsustainableâ.
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Evidence from the UK suggests that tax revenues are maximized when marginal tax rates are in the range of 45â50%. In a country like the US or the UK â that borrows in its own currency â excessive deficits may repaid automatically by triggering inflation. 6/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Inflation is an implicit stealth tax that reduces the value of the money that has been lent to the government. 7/7
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations Zoe @QianxueZhang ⊠I am so happy for you đŸ and Iâm looking forward to reading all of your future work in both economics and anime đ
Zoe Zhang
@QianxueZhang
I am super happy to share that I will join @UTokyoGraSPP at the University of Tokyo as an Assistant Professor in the coming September! As someone who wanted to be a cartoonist, and a big fan of manga and anime, this is the best place I can imagine!đđđ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I am not a deficit hawk and I have written extensively on why governments are not like households. See here for example:
static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
But there is a limit to the sustainable size of the deficit. @StephanieKelton @dandolfa
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
As an economist, I refuse to be complicit in perpetuating this for another 70 years. Keen, Kelton, etc. can't do it all. Journalists need to step up.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is month on month. Here are the same data measured as percent change from a year ago. Close to 4% excluding food and energy. Close to 3% all items. Energy costs are coming down but overall inflation is still double the 2% target.
St. Louis Fed
@stlouisfed
The consumer price index rose 0.3% in January, seasonally adjusted. Excluding food and energy, âcoreâ consumer prices increased 0.4% fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1gyvr
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
St. Louis Fed
@stlouisfed
The consumer price index rose 0.3% in January, seasonally adjusted. Excluding food and energy, âcoreâ consumer prices increased 0.4% fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=1gyvr
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Zuckerberg is wrong. There are now dozens of experiments showing causality. I laid out the evidence in these two posts:
www.afterbabel.com/p/social-media-mental-illness-epidemic
www.afterbabel.com/p/why-some-researchers-think-im-wrong -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Physics In History
@PhysInHistory
History of Physics mentioned in Abridged Beyond the Point of Usefulness by Zach Weinersmith.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Dead on! Teaching and research are complements.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Irena Buzarewicz
@IrenaBuzarewicz
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@GautiEggertsson on why he changed his mind about the transitory nature of inflation. Iâm not a fan of the Phillips curve in either linear or non-linear varieties static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t⊠but itâs important to update our priors when new information arrives. Kudos to Gauti
Gauti Eggertsson đșđŠ
@GautiEggertsson
No. "Team temporary/transitory" did not win the inflation debate. At the end of summer 2021 I was a card carrying member of team temporary. I thought that the burst in inflation was due to temporary factors. Hence, the Fed did not need to tighten aggressively. /1
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peter Isztin đđ
@PeterIsztin
Almost all of the old MIT economists were embarassingly wrong on public policy (remember Samuelson on the Soviet Union?), and they were also often quite nasty toward people of other persuasion. This is exhibit A. RIP Solow, but I would rather not celebrate this part of his legacy
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Robert Solow:
âIâm glad there is no Milton Friedman anywhere [...] today. Milton Friedmans are bad for economics and bad for society. Fruitless debates with talented (near-)extremists waste a lot of everyoneâs time that could have been spent more constructively.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
I agree with Roger Farmer. Also I highly recommend @profburns new biography on Friedman. His staying power wasnât exclusively due to his persuasiveness with pen and spoken word but the fact that his was correct on the empirical reality more often than not. So not only debating with Friedman is intellectually healthy, it also creates a lot of opportunities to learn how the world works.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”This is profoundly wrong. Interactions with smart people, whether they are right or whether they are wrong, is always a positive experience. If they are right, you have learned to appreciate a different point of view. If wrong, your own position will be strengthened by 1/
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Robert Solow:
âIâm glad there is no Milton Friedman anywhere [...] today. Milton Friedmans are bad for economics and bad for society. Fruitless debates with talented (near-)extremists waste a lot of everyoneâs time that could have been spent more constructively.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Good to hear. There were some nasty disagreements between Chicago and MIT back in the day and that extended to animosity between Minnesota and the Coasts when Minnesota Macro appeared on the scene. The MIT response was to integrate rational expectations into NK economics.
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
I'm sure you know this, but I'm just quoting Solow. I do *NOT* share his view on Friedman.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
But the Communist Manifesto was also written by Marx, albeit with a little help from Engels. I agree that âCapitalâ is dense and to hard to read. But it was up-to-date with its economics at the time of writing.
Marco Battaglini
@m_battaglini
I did and I can tell you this: you can safely skip, it is badly written and full of nonsense. If you really want to read something interesting on topic, choose the Manifesto of the communist party: better written and, most importantly, shorter. I either case, no interesting econ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”This is profoundly wrong. Interactions with smart people, whether they are right or whether they are wrong, is always a positive experience. If they are right, you have learned to appreciate a different point of view. If wrong, your own position will be strengthened by 1/
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Robert Solow:
âIâm glad there is no Milton Friedman anywhere [...] today. Milton Friedmans are bad for economics and bad for society. Fruitless debates with talented (near-)extremists waste a lot of everyoneâs time that could have been spent more constructively.âPost not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Then of course there was Miltonâs pathbreaking analysis, joint with Anna Schwartz, press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691003542/a-monet⊠A Monetary History of the United States, which revived the idea that inflation is related to money growth and improved on the quantity theory of money 4/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
by showing how the velocity of circulation varies with interest rates. So yes, Iâm glad that Milton Friedman walked this earth even when I disagree with some of his views. Why would anyone in possession of the truth be afraid when his or her position is challenged?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you for these references. But yes, itâs precisely the recent episode Iâm interested in. My own view is that the benefit of divisia indices was overstated but Iâll look at the papers you reference.
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
I gave a bunch of references above. It would be interesting to see how that survived almost a decade of additional data, but considering the spike in Divisia growth rates and then subsequent fall leading the same kind of hump in inflation, it's probably not looking bad.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Can you point me to the best recent papers on this issue @S_Surprenant ? Do any of them successfully explain the short run dynamics of the velocity of circulation in addition to getting the co-integrating properties right?
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
6/ Belongia, @PIrelandEcon, @RebelEconProf, Serlitis, Keating all revisited different aspects of those old debates using theoretically sound monetary aggregates.
And, sure enough, measuring bananas to disprove a theory about apples wasn't a good idea: answers do change. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
âI Get Aroundâ just played on Spotify; I havenât heard it in ages, and what a nostalgia rush it gave me! It was âmyâ high school songâeveryone teased me about itâbecause I liked to play it when cruising in my â65 âCuda. Man did I love that car!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”I disagree profoundly with statement. Putting aside for a moment whether physicists would benefit from reading Newton (they would): economics is not physics. It is, for the most part, a non experimental science and it often takes wrong turns 1/
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
It's time to say it again:
There is no need to read the classics because the textbook treatments of their ideas are perfectly sufficient.
Have you ever met a physicist who said that you should read Newton's PhilosophiĂŠ Naturalis Principia Mathematica?
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Modern interpretations of Keynesian economics, for example, are based on a mythologized reading of the General Theory and âNew Keynesian Economicsâ is neither new nor Keynesian. Reading Marx in the original, along with Weber and Durkheim, used to be a part of every undergrad 2/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
intro sociology course. Similarly, reading Plato, Aristotle and the enlightenment philosophers should be part of a general education, as it once was, in a liberal arts education. To stand on the shoulders of giants we must first know exactly what weâre standing on. 3
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Al retired from Chicago and moved to UCLA before I arrived there in 1987 ⊠and he retired from UCLA a year or so after I did. He has had two full academic careers.
caseybmulligan
@caseybmulligan
Al Harberger is also 99 years old.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Very sad and a giant indeed. Bob was very supportive of me when I was a young assistant professor even though I never took classes from him. Was Bob the last of the greatest generation?
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
RIP. Bob Solow an absolute giant in Economics, has passed away at age 99. Tremendously influential in the profession and one of the key founders of the MIT Economics department as we live it today. Will be sorely missed.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I would add that, in the long run, inflation will equal the rate of growth of new government dollar denominated liabilities minus the growth rate of real GDP. The growth of liabilities is the primary deficit and the concern is that the primary deficit may remain elevated
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
It was, for some time. Best appraisal here: www.mercatus.org/research/policy-briefs/neutral-level-ngdâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And I was told that macroeconomists werenât allowed to conduct experiments on real economies đ @IvanWerning #econtwitter What are we predicting about the likely outcome? Now is the time #econtwitter to put your predictions in writing. Let the games begin!
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
Argentina's president Milei goes on TV and issues wide deregulation reforms by presidential decree. Details to be parsed, but reforms are broadly pro-market.
Congressional and more importantly judicial challenges likely to follow. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
Argentina's president Milei goes on TV and issues wide deregulation reforms by presidential decree. Details to be parsed, but reforms are broadly pro-market.
Congressional and more importantly judicial challenges likely to follow. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Perhaps. But whatâs the mechanism? Macro comp question: Would the Covid pandemic have caused a bout of inflation worldwide if all countries had been on the gold standard? Discuss. @JonSteinsson
Jon Steinsson
@JonSteinsson
This figure is amazing. (Ignore headline. I am focused on Covid period.) No wonder there was a bout of inflation around the world.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
They should have invested in the market. Itâs not too late even now. The premium on being in stocks is at least 6% and the US government does not have to worry about liquidity risk. I explain here
www.amazon.com/Prosperity-All-Prevent-Financial-Crises/dpâŠ
why the government can do this but you canât. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with @dandolfa
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
To my way of thinking, this "last mile" likely requires fiscal support. (E.g., gradually reduce growth in nominal govt expenditures.) If fiscal support not forthcoming, then raising policy interest rate will not help & may make things worse for both inflation and unemployment.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Andrés Neumeyer
@andyneumeyer
DespuĂ©s de proponer la eliminaciĂłn del deficit fiscal, fuente de la inflaciĂłn, el presidente @JMilei le propone al congreso y a la sociedad un paquete legislativo que fomenta la libertad econĂłmica. Si el congreso y la polĂtica acompañan estĂĄs propuestas, Argentina tiene una gran chance de despegar econĂłmicamente y poder brindarle un mejor futuro a todos les Argentines. Kudos al equipo liderado por @fedesturze que durante 4 años revisĂł 5000 leyes para proponer una mejor forma de organizar el paĂs, con mĂĄs libertad, y menos privilegios de poques a costa de muches.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Why? I canât think of an example, in my own Matlab code, where it would help.
Pontus Rendahl
@pontus_rendahl
Matlab would be improved by allowing functions to be defined within a script (just like in python).
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
More on the PSZ, AS debate on income inequality.
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Okay, I had the time to read this over. In the past, I did not mince words much. I do not see the reason to do any mincing now.
There are six replies that must be made to this piece.
First: Zucman (I am assuming he also speaks for the other two musketeers) is goalpost-shifting. The argument that used to be made was that inequality followed a strong U-curve with a precipitated fall between 1941 and 1947. The trough lasted to 1980 and continued since and exceeding the level of the 1920s. That narrative and timing makes it easy to justify tax policy correctives. However, they now say "inequality is higher than in the 1960s" which is not the same statement. Indeed, saying it increased allows for a rapid level-change from 1980 to 2000 with no change since (I am speaking pre-tax and pre-transfers). That is not "denying" inequality (a cheap shot against Splinter and Auten). This obfuscates from the obliteration of two previous goalposts they used. The first is that the levelling of the U-curve is actually more gradual and most of it happens during the 1930s with the depression -- 80% to 85% of the decline in the top 1%'s share happens from 1929 to 1941. That makes it harder to focus on tax policy as the driving force (the wiping of capital gains during the depression is). Second, it eliminates the claim that inequality is forever rising. Shifting goalposts is what this is! But these two points that they had been making been making for a decade no longer apply regardless of the criticism here.
Second: The issue at hand is how to harmonize the definition of income according to different sources so that they become consistent. This can be broken down into two periods (pre-1960 and post-1960). PSZ claim that since fiscal income accounts for 60-70% of national income, any levelling would have to be because the rest has become more equally distributed. That assumes that they made no mistake on the treatment of tax data. But, as we have shown, they do many errors for the pre-1960 period. And I do mean many! First, they include Hawaii and Alaska in the tax data pre-1959 but not in the national accounts. Second, they forgot to consider that pre-1938, state and local government employees were exempt from filing federal taxes. Third, they forgot to consider issues like the combat zone tax exclusion (which matters in times of war). Fourth, they poorly dealt with missing filers issues by using a war year (which alters the labor market in an exceptional way) to adjust the married-to-single ratio. Fifth, they "ballparked" how to assign deductions. As such, the entire pre-1960 period is poorly made from their work. None of the replies in this paper rescue the pre-1960 estimates. It is thus to throw the entire pre-1960 part of the PSZ estimates.
This comment is indepdenent of the reply Auten and Splinter made here: marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/12/the-pikâŠ
Third: Which leads me to the third reply. To adjust the definitions post-1960, PSZ use a "misreported income" adjustment which they mostly take as an indicator of tax evasion and which must be assigned to richer households. The idea here is to match tax data to national accounts definition (rather than match national accounts with tax definition) But the problem is that if we follow their logic, the variations of misreported income make NO historical sense (see image). PSZ depict a sharp drop in this category to a low of just over 2 percent, coinciding with the steeply progressive federal income tax hikes of 1932. Less evasion when tax rates increase in an era of voluntary filing? Dream on Suzie! Next, PSZ show a sharp rise in "evasion and other" between 1943 and 1945, peaking at almost 17 percent of national accounts income. Both findings are in tension with the well-documented proliferation of tax evasion after the Depression-era tax hikes, when income earnings were self-reported to the IRS. Tax evasion also rapidly declined after the adoption of automatic payroll withholding in 1943. So, basically, PSZ data assumptions should lead to assume that when the federal government began enforcing tax filing more aggressively, people evaded more? Again, dream on Suzie! Also, we know from historians and economic historians that tax evasion declined in the 1920s and that more income was truthfully reported (because of falling rates). PSZ show the opposite -- at odds with historians. Then PSZ find falling evasion to 1980 when tax rates were high and enforcement was steady. And then it rose when tax rates fell? Again, that makes no sense. The issue is that this series is not what they say it is. Its not tax evasion. Its not even misreported income. In fact (see second image), the BEA says explicitly to not do what PSZ do! Its literally there, on paper! And yet, they do it! The "misreporting and AGI gap" that PSZ use is not what they say it is.
Fourth: PSZ pretend that they were parsimonious in their data assumptions. They were not. They had to make numerous arbitrary assumptions in getting the estimates ready for their "DIstributional National Accounts (DINA)". I get that this is normal. I mean, I get it! I am an economic historians, you just gotta do it sometimes. However, if you don't do it if you have a simpler method with fewer degrees of freedom available to yourself as a researcher.
And that is what I chose to do in this paper with @PhilWMagness. We decided to harmonize in the opposite direction. Since the tax data is what it is and the national accounts are far richer, why don't we adjust the national accounts so that we arrive at a definition of fiscal income. That is far better since this is what used to be done by people like Kuznets, Goldsmith and many others. This is what we dub "tax reconciliation approach" and the object of the paper in reference at the end of this X. We simply went through all the items of national accounts and the tax code and reconciled them. This is a single method for the entire period from 1917 to today. The result is that, first, PSZ clearly tend to miss the mark as their fiscal income drifts relative to the BEA's measure of AGI (see figure 1 in the article) as we move from 1980 to today (i.e., they gradually overestimate more and more). Second, when you do correct, you find exactly what Auten-Splinter find (with fewer assumptions) (see third image). Namely that there is a pronounced rise of inequality from 1980 to 2000 and stabilization since.
Fifth: What is most interesting is that doing this more parsimonious approach appears to explain 40% of the gap between Auten-Splinter and Piketty-Saez-Zucman (see fourth image). This is akin to saying that 40% of the gap is based on an improper use of the "misreporting adjustment". Phrased differently, the "misreported income and AGI gap" that PSZ call explains only 40% of their differences with AS. The rest is stuff that they are not contesting in any meaningful way. So, essentially, PSZ are conceding that 60% of the differences between them and AS are indisputable and the rest is due to how they refused to follow the BEA's admonition to not do what their hearts wanted them to do.
Sixth: The point that is being made by critics is not that inequality is not high or has not risen since the low point of the 1960s. What is being criticized is the accuracy of the measurements and how they are being used to justify policy proposals. I actually care alot about inequality when its generated by the powerful gaming institutions to shape rules the way that privilege them and their buddies. I care about promoting social mobility. The ad hominem of "deniers" is cruel. It is in fact nasty because I am French-speaking and I know that in French, "denier" is not what it is in English. Denier in French is "négationniste" (in French, we speak of "négationnistes des changements climatiques") and that is the word used to qualify people who question the holocaust, climate change, school shootings (e.g., Alex Jones) etc. It is an insanely pernicious term and as a French speaker, I cannot think that this is not a deliberate attempt at slander. At the very least, it is a salacious innuendo.
This bad behavior adds itself to a long litany: the misrepresentation of steps taken in PS (2003), the goalpost shifting, the shadow-editing, the strawmanning of historical sources and alternative assumptions, the misrepresentation of source materials, the arbitrariness of multiple assumptions. I mean, all of this (documented here: twitter.com/VincentGeloso/status/1669725514481774592) is now topped with what is nothing else that salacious innuendos and political gamesmanship. It is not a good look!
Summary: PSZ essentially admit -- by their reply -- that criticisms that we can throw the pre-1960 part of their estimates is correct. I am happy with that. They misused the source material (against the recommendations of the BEA) in a way that generates historically and economically non-sensical implications. They used a non-parsimonious method while a better alternative out there exists. When that better method is used, it essentially shows that 60% of the difference between PSZ and AS are in AS's favor.
#econtwitter @BachmannRudiThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Philippe Martin has sadly left us. He was a warm human being and an excellent economist. Philippe: you will be sorely missed. ht @COdendahl
Sciences Po
@sciencespo
Sciences Po a la grande douleur de faire part du décÚs de Philippe Martin.
Ăconomiste brillant et reconnu, doyen de l'@EAPScPo depuis fĂ©vrier 2022, il fut une figure Ă©minente de notre institution, dont il Ă©tait diplĂŽmĂ© et Ă laquelle il consacra une partie de sa carriĂšre. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You need to ask @NatashaRSarin, @sc_cath, and @mjmill611 that question. And note my correction in response to @kingofthecoastt: the @gabriel_zucman et al paper and the debate that followed is about income inequality not wealth inequality
Joel Gombiner
@joelgombiner
Is this data showing a massive increase in wealth inequality since 1990 incorrect? Or are you saying it represents a return to 1950 levels?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
You might enjoy reading my review of Mervynâs book static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
KingoftheCoast
@kingofthecoastt
Although @NatashaRSarin, @sc_cath, and @mjmill611 do having a paper showing post-tax/transfer wealth inequality is also stable
Natasha Sarin
@NatashaRSarin
Excellent discussion of our recent paper with @sc_cath and @mjmill611 âŹ
Main point: prior studies of inequality in US are incomplete bc exclude wealth from public programs
We consider an imp one, Social Security, and find its inclusion attenuates growth in top wealth shares -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you yes ⊠an important correction. Wealth is far more unequal than income and not easy to explain in a large class of theories even when accounting for significant income inequality. Here is one possible theory that CAN explain wealth inequality static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
KingoftheCoast
@kingofthecoastt
I think you mean âthe *income* distribution, particularly post transfer, has been pretty stableâ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Iâm a Bayesian @sethburn I simply updated my prior after evaluating new evidence.
Seth Burn
@SethBurn
Roger wants it to be one way.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Piketty-Saez- @gabriel_zucman do not appear to be coming out well from this debate. My prior has now shifted from â wealth became much more unequal over the past 70 years â to: the wealth distribution, particularly post transfer, has been pretty stable. @jeffreypclemens @MargRev
Jeffrey P. Clemens
@jeffreypclemens
The Piketty-Saez-Zucman response to Auten and Splinter - marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/12/the-pikâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Piketty-Saez- @gabriel_zucman do not appear to be coming out well from this debate. My prior has now shifted from â wealth became much more unequal over the past 70 years â to: the wealth distribution, particularly post transfer, has been pretty stable. @jeffreypclemens @MargRev
Jeffrey P. Clemens
@jeffreypclemens
The Piketty-Saez-Zucman response to Auten and Splinter - marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/12/the-pikâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jeffrey P. Clemens
@jeffreypclemens
The Piketty-Saez-Zucman response to Auten and Splinter - marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/12/the-pikâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Looks exciting!
Rick Evans
@RickEcon
Happy Holidays #econtwitter. I just published my Structural Estimation lectures (with text, code, and exercises) from my time @uchicago, @BeckerFriedman, and @UChi_CompSocSci as section of my new online @jupyterbook @ExecutableBooks entitled, "Computational Methods for Economists using Python".
opensourceecon.github.io/CompMethods/
The key chapters are:
- Maximum likelihood estimation: opensourceecon.github.io/CompMethods/struct_est/MLE.html
- Generalized method of moments estimation: opensourceecon.github.io/CompMethods/struct_est/GMM.html
- Simulated method of moments estimation: opensourceecon.github.io/CompMethods/struct_est/SMM.html
@comp_simon @MarlonAzinovic @john_stachurski @QuantEcon -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”I second that. And the demonization of Mises and Hayek by the left is equally insane. Keynes, IMO, was right to argue that intertemporal asset markets do not allocate capital efficiently. 1/
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Calling his ideas flawed or dangerous is one thing; but the demonization of Keynes by libertarians and conservatives is silly.
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
That includes the 2008 recession which, as I discussed in my book
www.amazon.com/How-Economy-Works-Confidence-Self-FulfilliâŠ
would have been much deeper without the massive purchase of risky assets pursued by central banks 6/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And which I explain in more depth in âProsperity for Allâ
www.amazon.com/Prosperity-All-Prevent-Financial-Crises/dpâŠ
The final section of How the Economy Works was titled âBetween Keynes and Hayekâ and it explains why both Keynes and Hayek made important contributions that we can learn from. 7/7 -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This đ is moving faster than I would have predicted.
Brian Roemmele
@BrianRoemmele
This entire clip was produced by AI from the âactorsâ to the voices and the visuals.
This is the âone personâ AI newsroom in a prompt.
In a year you will have this on your computer with no need of an internet connection.
Buckle upâŠThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
If you are interested in Economics and macro policy, this is really something to watch. Like a World Cup final!
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Zoe Zhang
@QianxueZhang
Finished #econjobmarket interviews on the first day. I think it's better than I expected. People are professional and kind. Tired but had much fun talking with experts!đ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Itâs not clear to me that public sector productivity is a meaningful concept. The outputs are not priced by markets. blogs.worldbank.org/governance/how-can-we-measure-productâŠ
Merryn Somerset Webb
@MerrynSW
The UK isn't short of problems. But this - horrible horrible public sector productivity - is one of the worst (and most expensive).
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Warwick Economics
@warwickecon
Meet our #econjobmarket candidate Zoe Zhang! @QianxueZhang
In her job market paper, she shows that the interaction between knowledge diffusion and technology adoption substantially amplifies the gains from trade. Learn more about Zoe: www.qianxue-zhang.com -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Higher Ed Has Become a Threat to America: âThe biggest threat to our future isnât climate change, China or the national debt. It is the tyrannical grip that a hopelessly corrupt higher education now has on our national life.â www.wsj.com/articles/higher-ed-has-become-a-threat-to-ameâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I found that when teaching undergraduates, as well as graduates students, who often asked smart questions that I didnât always know the answer to.
Michael McMahon
@mcmahonecon
I just wrote a referee report and I have enjoyed the thought process involved and learned something useful for my own research. This also happens often when I teach and almost always when supervising students/speaking with mentees. Our job tasks can be complementary to research.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Joshua Rauh
@joshrauh
Actually this paper is really problematic @florianederer and whatever you think personally of those criticizing it, they are serious criticisms. Here is my detailed take: libertylensecon.substack.com/p/the-silent-revolution-freeâŠ
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
So glad I skipped this clown show.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Russ Roberts
@EconTalker
I saw this paper years agoâAuten and Splinter have worked on it for a long time. Congrats to them. Let the conversation begin.
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
Very big deal. Auten and Splinterâs work, which shows no increase in post-tax/post-transfers income inequality in the US over the last 60 years, is now published in one of the top peer-reviewed econ journals.
The picture below is from The Financial Times article on the topic. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Russ Roberts
@EconTalker
Superb.
Brit Hume
@brithume
This long piece explores the chronic bias and inaccuracy in coverage of Israel and its enemies better than anything I have read. It is from nine years ago. Please read it. There's no paywall. www.tabletmag.com/sections/israel-middle-east/articles/isâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Brit Hume
@brithume
This long piece explores the chronic bias and inaccuracy in coverage of Israel and its enemies better than anything I have read. It is from nine years ago. Please read it. There's no paywall. www.tabletmag.com/sections/israel-middle-east/articles/isâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I agree with this thread. Interesting to see that this position was not articulated by any of the experts consulted in the Chicago Harris poll
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
1. A bit of provocation, based on the answers to this poll: www.kentclarkcenter.org/surveys/public-corporations/
With all due respect, the answers show how confused we, the economists, are on the topic. Nearly none of the answers deal with the central issue: -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It may be a nice answer but itâs also a wrong answer. Nothing precludes cycles in competitive economies with rational expectations even with a representative agent www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/00220531859⊠1/
CaltechđŒconTheory
@CaltechEconThry
Very nice answer!
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
⊠and if you admit the possibility of birth and death, pretty much anything is possible www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Comparative-Statics-and-Per⊠2/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Here is a simple example static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t⊠3/3
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Fabio Ghironi
@FabioGhironi
This is worse than disgusting. This stuff must stop. Making fellow students--Jewish, Muslim, or any other--feel threatened cannot be protected speech. It must stop.
VisegrĂĄd 24
@visegrad24
BREAKING:
The police has been forced to evacuate Jewish students from a building of University of California San Diego @ucsandiego where they had gathered to discuss antisemitic threats.
Swiftly, a large and threatening anti-Israeli mob gathered in front of the building -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The belief function www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2016/8/28/beliefs-andâŠ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
How should I think of your result? The usual setting is when a shock hits, your variables jump on the one path that will converge back to the only steady state absent other shocks. What's the equivalent in your model?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I add a belief function as a fundamental. This is a mapping from past observable to a probability measure over future variables. noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2012/04/equilibria-unique-andâŠ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
How should I think of your result? The usual setting is when a shock hits, your variables jump on the one path that will converge back to the only steady state absent other shocks. What's the equivalent in your model?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Standard asset pricing assumes uniqueness of the equilibrium. That seems, to me, to be an unreasonable assumption static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
Stéphane Surprenant
@S_Surprenant
1/It's just standard asset pricing: the real value of the portfolio of all government debt is the expected discounted stream of future primary surpluses.
If you increase the nominal value of that portfolio, but don't adjust future fiscal policy, this logic predicts inflation. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
How do you know, in advance, if repayment was expected? Without an answer to that question the theory cannot be used to predict: only for ex post rationalization.
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
Mine too. Fiscal theory says a debt expansion without expected repayment leads to a burst of inflation, which goes away without high rates & recession; Fed softens that fact but doesn't change it. Funny how widely different models can give the same result. Tests are hard.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Zoe Zhang
@QianxueZhang
âšJob Market Paper Alertâš
Understanding how a country learns from its trading partners is crucial for policymaking.
I show that firms learn in different ways, and the interplay of these learning channels can substantially increase the gains from trade.
đwarwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/staff/qzhang/breaking_bor⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
you can't eat wage compression.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Oh dear. This is worse than I thought. We are teaching our high school students that inequality caused the Great Depression. @PhilWMagness
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
We examined 9 leading US college history textbooks to see how they teach the Great Depression.
All 9 promoted obsolete and economically erroneous explanations that are badly out of sync with the latest scholarship.
www.aier.org/article/college-history-textbooks-spread-mis⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is why we need to teach economic history at both the undergraduate and the graduate level. And it is why need to teach history more generally in our schools.
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Federal Reserve: 1913
Keynesâs _General Theory_: 1936.
Now thatâs what I call an influential work! -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Lee Harris
@LeeHarris
A remarkable photograph capturing the first two minutes of silence in London, exactly 104 years ago today.
In those moments, the immense burden of personal grief and mourning would have been amplified beyond comprehension.
#lestweforget -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Pawel Zabczyk and I have a new draft of our paper "Monetary and Fiscal Policy when People have Finite Lives". static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
We show that, in the Overlapping Generations Model, the real rate of interest, as well as the price level, is indeterminate. 1/Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
... 2] that people earn more in middle age than in either youth or in old age. This indeterminacy cannot be eliminated by aggressive monetary policy. Technically, it occurs when both fiscal and monetary policy are active in the sense of Leeper (1991) www.researchgate.net/publication/4907434_Equilibria_Under⊠3/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
In a related paper, Leland Farmer and I show that the FZ condition is relevant empirically. We use the FZ result to show, in an estimated OLG model, that indeterminacy provides a better explanation of financial data than a determinate alternative. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t⊠4/4
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§”on inequality. Itâs good to hear this clarification from @StephanieKelton. But let me use this opportunity to muse on the thought that âwe can and must tax the richâ. @RussoEcon 1/
Stephanie Kelton
@StephanieKelton
If you see someone arguing that MMT claims that "deficits don't matter," that governments can spend without limit, or that we ignore inequality and oppose taxing the rich, point them to this paragraph from the Introduction to The Deficit Myth.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
How would that work. We could tax income. Or we could tax wealth. Let me state an assumption which is controversial, but which is supported by the evidence. People are endowed with different abilities. 2/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Steve Jobs, Elon Musk and Bill Gates are each unusually talented. Each of them has made enormous contributions to the social good and each of them, has been compensated for them. They are billionaires. If we were to tax their incomes at higher rates: would society gain? 3/
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This issue can be, and should be, dealt with by limiting campaign contributions. Politicians are public servants. They should be adequately compensated for their service. They should not need to beg for campaign contributions from lobbyists to whom they are then beholden. 11
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
So, to return to @StephanieKelton Should we tax the rich? Taxing capital gains at the same rate as labor would be a start. Moving to a simpler flat tax system would help. Confiscatory tax rates on either income or on wealth are unlikely to make anybody better off. 12/12
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
PHD Comics
@PHDcomics
How to write to your instructor or T.A.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Max Goedl
@maxgoedl
I did exactly what @klaus_adam wants for my "Challenges of the European Union" class at the Frankfurt School. The graph doesn't look all that different when you do it the right way. The failure to catch up to the US is real.
Klaus Adam
@klaus_adam
This makes NO sense at all: it's purely driven by exchange rate fluctuations. It only says that US GDP is overvalued at the current USD-EUR rate.
The way to do this right is to use Purchasing Power Parity to convert incomes across country: PENN World Tables are best for that. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Russ Roberts
@EconTalker
We are working on a winter break program here at Shalem College for American college students--Fear No Evil--a study and solidarity mission. Immersive education and learning about what is happening here on the ground. Interested? Write russ at Shalem dot ac dot il. Please RT.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is a very helpful thread on the publishing process in economics which I highly recommend to graduate students and assistant professors.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Glenn Gould
@GlennGould
Bernstein conducting đ€ Gould playing
đč: Bach's Keyboard Concerto -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Kudos to @jensqu4r3d. It is not only offensive to "contextualize" barbaric acts of violence. It puts you on path to complete and utter moral relativism.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Russ Roberts
@EconTalker
There are thoughtful criticisms to make of Israel's actions in the past and in the present with respect to Gaza. These are not thoughtful. No mention of October 7. No mention that Israel left Gaza 18 years ago. Presumes the 40% being children is true w/o evidence. No recognition that a ceasefire would reward barbarism. No recognition that Hamas keeps people from leaving. No recognition that Hamas surrounds itself with civilians. No recognition that Israel is only bombing the area that they give people a chance to leave. And no mention of the 200+ people including children who were abducted. Instead of demanding a ceasefire, why not demand a release of the hostages and a surrender? Why will no one demand ANYTHING of Hamas? Shame on you, Angelina Jolie.
Yashar Ali đ
@yashar
Angelina Jolie, former UN Special Envoy for Refugees, on the IDF strikes yesterday:
âThis is the deliberate bombing of a trapped population who have nowhere to flee. Gaza has been an open-air prison for nearly two decades and is fast becoming a mass grave. 40% of those killed are innocent children.
Whole families are being murdered. While the world watches and with the active support of many governments, millions of Palestinian civilians - children, women, families - are being collectively punished and dehumanized, all while being deprived food, medicine and humanitarian aid against international law. By refusing to demand a humanitarian ceasefire and blocking the UN Security Council from imposing one on both parties, world leaders are complicit in these crimes.â -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Not a good idea. There is an optimal quantity of debt and it is not zero. www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/12/9/how-much-de⊠@RussoEcon @wgoggin @GeorgeSelgin @dandolfa
Bill Goggin
@wgoggin
Pay it off.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
â⊠seems too big to inflate away âŠâ
Not so. Thatâs one of the most likely outcomes if we keep following current policies @dandolfa @ScottAdamsSays @GeorgeSelgin
Also see @Kotlikoff âs work on the massive transfers from young to old that are being generated by current policy
Scott Adams
@ScottAdamsSays
I have never seen an economist explain how it could be possible for the United States to survive its growing debt burden.
Does anyone have a serious explanation how this is survivable?
Seems too big to inflate away, and I see no way GDP increases enough to make it up.
Do we issue a new crypto currency of some sort and invent money from nothing?
Does the coming robot/AI era goose our GDP so much we pay off the debt in time?
Do we start charging our smaller allies for "protection"?
Name any scenario in which America survives its debt burden. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
This was the intro to the academic community:
Warren B. Mosler
@wbmosler
Just found my 1996 post to an internet PK discussion group. What's been popularized as MMT is all there:
ameblo.jp/sorata31/ -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Wesley Yang
@wesyang
An open letter from faculty at Columbia University. Signed by 2x more faculty than the prior letter to which this is a forthright and effective rejoinder:
"There is no justification for raping and murdering ordinary citizens in front of their families, mutilating babies, decapitating people, using automatic weapons and grenades to hunt down and murder young people at a music festival celebrating peace, burning families alive, kidnapping and taking hostages (including vulnerable populations of elderly, people with disabilities, and young children), parading women hostages in front of chanting crowds, and proudly documenting these nightmarish scenes on social media. We are horrified that anyone would celebrate these monstrous attacks or, as some members of the Columbia faculty have done in a recent letter, try to ârecontextualizeâ them as a âsalvo,â as the "exercise of a right to resist" occupation, or as âmilitary action.â We are astonished that anyone at Columbia would try to legitimize an organization that shares none of the Universityâs core values of democracy, human rights, or the rule of law. Â Any civilian loss of life during war is awful but, as colleagues on the faculty acknowledged in the letter mentioned above, the law of war clearly distinguishes between tragic but incidental civilian death and suffering, on one hand, and the deliberate targeting of civilians, on the other. We feel sorrow for all civilians who are killed or suffering in this war, including so many in Gaza. Yet whatever one thinks of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict or of Israeli policies, Hamasâs genocidal massacre was an act of terror and cannot be justified, or its true purpose obscured with euphemisms and oblique references. We ask the entire University community to condemn the Hamas attack unambiguously. We doubt anyone would try to justify this sort of atrocity if it were directed against the residents of a nation other than Israel."
docs.google.com/document/u/1/d/e/2PACX-1vRYUSR01Cb6zV50rD⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
â⊠seems too big to inflate away âŠâ
Not so. Thatâs one of the most likely outcomes if we keep following current policies @dandolfa @ScottAdamsSays @GeorgeSelgin
Also see @Kotlikoff âs work on the massive transfers from young to old that are being generated by current policy
Scott Adams
@ScottAdamsSays
I have never seen an economist explain how it could be possible for the United States to survive its growing debt burden.
Does anyone have a serious explanation how this is survivable?
Seems too big to inflate away, and I see no way GDP increases enough to make it up.
Do we issue a new crypto currency of some sort and invent money from nothing?
Does the coming robot/AI era goose our GDP so much we pay off the debt in time?
Do we start charging our smaller allies for "protection"?
Name any scenario in which America survives its debt burden. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
Keynes was never an outright inflationist. Like Fisher, Cassel, and many monetarists, he favored policies that would maintain a stable price level. Whether by rationalizing big deficits he indirectly encouraged policies that led to higher inflation is another matter.
Jonathan Newman
@NewmanJ_R
"Lord Keynes once scoffed at criticisms by free-market economists that his inflationist policies would be ruinous in the long run; in his famous reply, he chortled that 'in the long run we are all dead.' But now Keynes is dead and we are alive, living in his long run." - Rothbard
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
No! The King Canute solution. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Canute_and_the_tide
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thank you Jen
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Robert P. Murphy
@BobMurphyEcon
Yeah this is an fyi for those of you working with actual data to make sure you understand how the different statistics interact with each other.
caseybmulligan
@caseybmulligan
Friendly reminder: "government SPENDING" is not part of GDP. Government purchases are. The difference is transfers + interest. Most government spending is not purchases.
Positive analysis should not lump together types of G spending that are VERY different in their effects. -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
I believe he means not financially sustainable at the current low rates of inflation. At some point, paying interest expense requires higher tax rates (good luck), cuts in spending, or greater money/debt issuance. Latter likely means current low inflation rate not sustainable.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
D(t) = (1+r)D(t-1)/(1+g) + d
D is the ratio of debt to GDP
t indexes time
r is the interest rate
g is the growth rate
d is the ratio of the primary deficit to GDP
When r>g this is an explosive difference equation.
Currently we are in this case.
This is unsustainable. 1/n
Greek Stav
@GrkStav
In what sense is it not sustainable? Politically and ideologically? Perhaps. Financially? Certainly sustainable. Economically, in real biophysical terms? Unsustainable.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Possibility 1. Congress reverses the sign of d by cutting spending or raising taxes.
Possibility 2. Since r and g in this equation are both nominal: inflation can push nominal GDP growth above r thus causing the debt to GDP ratio to fall. This is a âstealth taxâ. 2/n
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Possibility 3. Rationing and price controls as we had in WWII. Prices are held down artificially and goods are rationed using coupons for food and fuel. There would be a substantial black market for those who can afford it.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is unsustainable. The interest component of gov spending is ballooning and will cause Congress to engineer a reversal in the primary deficit sooner rather than later. The alternative, also a possibility, is the elimination of the debt through a further surge in inflation. 1/
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Darn government growing the economy again.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A third possibility is that we enter a major war in which price controls and rationing are brought in to repress inflation. That will likely be the end of the world as we know it. Not my preferred outcome. 2/2
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Except when demand curves slope up static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t⊠đ
ivanalonso
@ivan_alonso_pe
About that time, he told me, then a first-year graduate student, there were three things I needed to know: S curves slope up and D curves slope down; S curves are cost curves; and future values are discounted to the present. âThat will get you far.â
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
Thanks for sharing! While the classic UCLA school has had a little written on it, the slightly later (who still shared the good uniqueness) is definitely under studied, from Ostroy to your work.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
When I came to UCLA in. 1987, Armen was winding down in terms of research output. But his influence was everywhere. He was selfless and cared not one whit about self aggrandizement. Only about promoting ideas. An amazing human being.
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
In 1984, F.A. Hayek was asked who his favorite economist was. He named two.
The first was Nobel Prize winner George Stigler. The second, sadly, never got the recognition he deserved.
Here are 5 papers by the đ, Armen Alchian, and why you should read them today đ -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
VoxEU
@voxeu
Nick Crafts and the importance of history in understanding economic performance
Stephen Broadberry @OxfordEconDept, Bishnupriya Gupta @warwickecon, Tim Hatton @UoE_Economics, @timleunig @LSEEcHist
cepr.org/voxeu/columns/nick-crafts-and-importance-history⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Shai Davidai
@ShaiDavidai
I am an assistant professor at Columbia Business School. I am a father, a husband, an uncle, and a son. I am a forty-year-old man, and last week I found myself crying in front of a group of complete strangers.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Seems interesting and important.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Dennis Novy
@DennisNovy
Read the abstract here:
CEPR
@cepr_org
New CEPR Discussion Paper - DP18522
Urban-Biased Structural Change
@NatalieAChen @warwickecon, @DennisNovy @warwickecon @CEP_LSE, Carlo Perroni @warwickecon, @HorngChernWong @SU_Economics @Stockholm_Uni
cepr.org/publications/dp18522
#cepr_itre, #cepr_mg -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2023 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Claudia Goldin âfor having advanced our understanding of womenâs labour market outcomes.â
#nobelprize -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Royal Economic Society
@RoyalEconSoc
Prof Nicholas Crafts CBE 1949-2023: A statement from our Chief Executive
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
CAGE @ Warwick
@cage_warwick
In 2010 Professor Nick Crafts became the founding Director of the CAGE research centre. As Director he oversaw CAGE's development into a vibrant research community and personally contributed a large amount of impactful research. Read our tributes here: warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/research/centres/cage/newâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Very sad news. Nick Crafts was a towering figure at Warwick economics and in the economic history community more generally. He will be sorely missed by family, friends and colleagues.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Paulina Restrepo-Echavarria
@paures12
The Economist on my work with Anton Cheremukhin from the Dallas Fed.
In our paper âThe Dual Beveridge Curveâ (www.restrepo-echavarria.com/Research_files/BeveridgeCurveâŠ) we show how the recent anomalous behavior of the Beveridge Curve disappears once we separate vacancies between⊠(1/3) www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2023/10/05/to-und⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Perhaps. But the same argument does not apply to tariffs on manufacturing imports which have the potential to raise wages for skilled manufacturing workers. The cost would be more expensive manufactured goods for the consumer.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Manufacturing jobs now have below-average wages for the United States, so you wouldnât necessarily expect structural transformation into manufacturing work to raise incomes the way it did when farmers switched to factories.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Excellent thread. Well worth reading.
Isabel Schnabel đȘđșđșđŠ
@Isabel_Schnabel
In my #thĂŒnenLecture @VfS_econ, I discussed the role of money in explaining the recent surge in inflation in the euro area. According to the quantity theory of money, there is a long-run one-to-one relationship between money growth and inflation. 1/23
European Central Bank
@ecb
Money still matters for monetary policy, says Executive Board member @Isabel_Schnabel. The strong post-pandemic rise in broad money growth was a harbinger of the subsequent inflation surge and may have contributed to entrenching adverse cost-push shocks www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2023/html/ecb.sp230925_1âŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Quote from a newspaper about a piece in a medical journalâŠ
âThe study was listed as beginning to undergo peer review on Aug. 16. Peer review finished on Aug. 23. The paper was published on Sept. 4. â
Why oh why does it takes years for an economics article to be published? -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
James Hogg
@JamesAHogg2
A quick one before bed, anyone?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Whilst I am not a fan of a 0 deficit policy: there is a limit. The fed government was right to spend more during Covid. But that should never have been more than a temporary response to help out those who sacrificed for the rest of us. Making that spending permanent is reckless.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Whilst I am not a fan of a 0 deficit policy: there is a limit. The fed government was right to spend more during Covid. But that should never have been more than a temporary response to help out those who sacrificed for the rest of us. Making that spending permanent is reckless.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
We are creating new dollar valued assets equal to 10% of GDP every year. The Fed has an inflation target of 2% and, to hit that target, it will need to continue raising rates. As interest rates go up, the deficit will explode further to finance the existing debt.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The likely outcome will be a resurgence of inflation that will act as a stealth tax to help finance the shortfall. This will not end well.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Me too
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Am looking forward to reading this! đ€
kilthub.cmu.edu/articles/book/Overlapping_Generations_Met⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
.@joachim_voth sorry ⊠mistyped your address on the initial post
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
. @joachim_coth @essobecker Is your paper subject to Morgan Kellyâs critique of spatial regressions papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3398303
based on spatial autocorrelation. Do your t-statistics survive the corrections he proposes in his recent revision with Tim Conley?
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
This map is very familiar. It is from a working paper by S.O. Becker @essobecker and me, circulate Feb. 23: www.jvoth.com/shallow.pdf Cremieux - whoever he may be - is ripping this off and passing it around as his own, without mention us even once.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks for pointing this out: I had not seen your exchange with @essobecker and @joachim_voth But they do not seem very happy with your failure to cite them up front. And please be more sparing with your personal insults.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
He was cited, made aware of the fact that he was cited, and then even engaged with the posts in which he was made aware. He lied, but you don't need to: x.com/cremieuxrecueil/status/1698795559606198566.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I did not pass it off as my own. I write threads on papers and I always link the papers at the end. As you can see, the link is clearly presented.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
He was cited, made aware of the fact that he was cited, and then even engaged with the posts in which he was made aware. He lied, but you don't need to: x.com/cremieuxrecueil/status/1698795559606198566.
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I did not pass it off as my own. I write threads on papers and I always link the papers at the end. As you can see, the link is clearly presented.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
. @joachim_coth @essobecker Is your paper subject to Morgan Kellyâs critique of spatial regressions papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3398303
based on spatial autocorrelation. Do your t-statistics survive the corrections he proposes in his recent revision with Tim Conley?
Joachim Voth
@joachim_voth
This map is very familiar. It is from a working paper by S.O. Becker @essobecker and me, circulate Feb. 23: www.jvoth.com/shallow.pdf Cremieux - whoever he may be - is ripping this off and passing it around as his own, without mention us even once.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Asking because I just heard Morgan present his work at a Wealth Inequality conference in Paris and he was very convincing. His work appears to be quite disruptive to many of the spatial regression papers published in top journals.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is not, in any way, an endorsement of @cremieuxrecueil failing to cite your work.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
Expectations and coordination are no doubt central to macro. However, these can involve multiple dimensions, not just price-setting. Business cycles possible even in "real" economies (see @farmerrf). But you want P-level. Me too! Nominal rigidities the way to go? Not convinced.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Fascinating thread. Weâve seen claims of room temperature superconductors before. This new research appears to be different.
Alex Kaplan
@alexkaplan0
Today might have seen the biggest physics discovery of my lifetime. I don't think people fully grasp the implications of an ambient temperature / pressure superconductor. Here's how it could totally change our lives.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Why is inflation happening now? Because weâre no longer at the ELB (effective lower bound). www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/9/21/wheres-the-âŠ
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Oil price spikes and supply constraints can cause price increases: they cannot cause cause a permanent increase in the average rate of price increase across all commodies, aka, inflation, unless the central bank accommodates by continually increasing the money supply.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations @mcmahonecon !
Michael McMahon
@mcmahonecon
A bit of personal news⊠the Minister has appointed me as Chair of @fiscalcouncil in an acting capacity while the Govt undertake a full appointment procedure.
Itâs an honour to do it, especially at such an interesting & important time for fiscal policy.
www.gov.ie/en/press-release/78b37-appointment-of-acting-câŠ. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Interesting review of âDanielle Allenâsâ new book from @petercoy today in the @nytimes. www.nytimes.com/2023/06/28/opinion/danielle-allen-democra⊠I particularly liked the quote at the foot of the article. đ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Very low. Based mostly on r* estimates that are essentially moving averages of the FOMC's own FFR policy choices over the past decade(s). I think folks often misinterpret these r* estimates as indicative of some equilibrium variables that are orthogonal to policy choices.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
One for @ProfGraemeRoy @UofGVC @AdamSmithHouse @econromesh @EconTalker @nytdavidbrooks @Peggynoonannyc @sullydish ?
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
If any single date can be called the birthdate of Adam Smith, today is the day, 300 years ago. In a world of anxiety about trade, social norms, materialism and empire, his thought has never been more relevant. What an astonishing legacy! #adamsmith300
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
DEBT!. How much do we need! My answer: 70% of GDP. Seems like the right time to recycle this post.
www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/12/9/how-much-de⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Sientifiko
@sientifiko1
Oh, no habĂa cachao q Engerman se habia muerto este mes
Su trabajo con Sokoloff ha sido tremendamente influyente en torno a la desigualdad, y el rol de las instituciones
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Stanley Engerman has left us. He was giant in the field of economic history, an area that has sadly been neglected in many economics departments over the past few decades. www.rochester.edu/newscenter/stanley-engerman-economics-hâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Stanley Engerman has left us. He was giant in the field of economic history, an area that has sadly been neglected in many economics departments over the past few decades. www.rochester.edu/newscenter/stanley-engerman-economics-hâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The speed with which AI is progressing is both impressive and scary. The ability to draw on current information from the internet is a massive improvement over ChatGPT. Bard also appears to â for now â be capable of âchanging its mindâ in response to human input. 1/3
Paul Couvert
@itsPaulAi
Just before we start:
Bard is a competitor to ChatGPT with many advantages.
â Completely free to use
â Connected to the internet in real time
â Accessible in 180 countries since yesterday
As a reminder the knowledge of ChatGPT ends in 2021.
đ bard.google.com
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
A conversation with Bard is reminiscent of speaking to a highly intelligent teenager. I questioned it extensively on possible cultural bias as a result of speaking largely to Americans. It claims to be amenable to âlearningâ from our conversation in the sense of giving ⊠2/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
⊠potentially different answers to future interactions with other people. My guess is that if a million people all interacted with Bard and expressed a particular point of view, that point of view would be more likely to be adopted as its own. 3/3
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Ivor Middleton
@FDPOuk
That's handy - Jean-Phillipe Bouchaud and Roger Farmer have done the hard thinking about wealth and billionaires for me.
#ergodicity
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And here is a link to the prepublication version of an article that came out in the JPE in April 2023 that explains why nonergodicity (but not the Ole Peters version) IS useful to understand the wealth distribution in real world economies static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Thanks to the shout out from @sethposting but the link to my blog is broken. Here is the correct link to a piece I wrote on Ole Petersâ work on nonergodicity in economics www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2020/5/6/the-peters-pâŠ
Sorrow Residual
@sethposting
Watched this really well-made (mostly mathematics) video.
youtu.be/_FuuYSM7yOo
If you do watch it, read this blogpost (rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerbloâŠ) by @farmerrf on why it doesn't have much to say about expected utility frameworks in economics or add much to the literature.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
And here is a link to the prepublication version of an article that came out in the JPE in April 2023 that explains why nonergodicity (but not the Ole Peters version) IS useful to understand the wealth distribution in real world economies static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/tâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Diego CalderĂłn G.
@diegocalderon_g
Big thanks for the infinite support! Forever grateful.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Congratulations to Dr. Diego Calderon www.diego-calderong.com on passing the oral exam today for his Ph.D. in economics at the University of Warwick. Diego will be joining the IMF this fall. @warwickecon @warwicknewsroom @NIESRorg @bankofengland @IMFNews
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
National Institute of Economic and Social Research
@NIESRorg
The issue of coordination between monetary, fiscal & financial policy has been explored in various of our papers in recent years.
Here the evidence submitted by former NIESR Research Dir. and @warwickecon Professor @farmerrf to the @CommonsTreasuryâŹïž
2/8
www.niesr.ac.uk/publications/coordinating-monetary-fiscal⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
NEW: Iâm not sure people fully appreciate how dire the US life expectancy / mortality situation has got.
My column: enterprise-sharing.ft.com/redeem/75e5e3d7-72c9-4b51-8ea9-âŠ
And some utterly damning charts.
1) at *every* point on the income distribution, Americans live shorter lives than the English. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Excellent thread.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
I was with you all the way until the bit about crank work. I used to feel the same way and while there is certainly crank work that fits your caricature: there is also a lot of very good work in the econophysics literature, including that by my coauthor. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Philippe_Bouchaud
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
My own view is that economists and physicists still have much to learn from each other. Econophysicists build very complicated environments inhabited by very naive people.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Economists build very simple environments inhabited by incredibly sophisticated people. There is surely a middle ground.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is an excellent piece on the history of Glass-Steagall @GeorgeSelgin
George Selgin
@GeorgeSelgin
If this ain't the best darn-tootin' account of the beginnings and legacy of the FDIC you've ever read, I'll eat my hat! www.alt-m.org/2023/03/28/the-new-deal-and-recovery-part-2⊠@dandolfa @DanAwrey @DanEricRohde @DavidBeckworth @NathanTankus @LevMenand @cmicmeissner @PeterBoettke @jp_koning @vtg2 @WilliamJLuther
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
University of Warwick
@uniofwarwick
Brilliant news: we're one of the worldâs top 25 unis in 4 subject areas, according to the @worlduniranking by Subject 2023 đ€©
đ Statistics & Operational Research
đ Mathematics
đ Business & Management Studies
đ Economics & Econometrics.
Read more: warwick.ac.uk/newsandevents/pressreleases/university_of_w⊠-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Maarten De Ridder
@DeRidderMaarten
Exciting conference tomorrow: 14 papers selected out of 300 great submissions for the @CFMUK @warwickecon Vienna Global Macro Conference taking place @LSEEcon. Co-organized with Christine Braun, @farmerrf @R2Rsquared @dandolfa. The program is here: www.lse.ac.uk/CFM/assets/pdf/CFM-2023-Warwick-Vienna-progâŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
ICYMI
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§” The banks are back in the news. Here is a piece I posted in the FT in 2009 that is as relevant today as it was then. How to Fix the Banks www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog @DavidSacks @DavidBeckworth @dandolfa @HannoLustig @warwicknewsroom @mattyglesias @ggreenwald @Kotlikoff
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§” The banks are back in the news. Here is a piece I posted in the FT in 2009 that is as relevant today as it was then. How to Fix the Banks www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog @DavidSacks @DavidBeckworth @dandolfa @HannoLustig @warwicknewsroom @mattyglesias @ggreenwald @Kotlikoff
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
How would the existence of a scheme like this have affected the market disruption that followed the failure of SVB? Hopefully, it would have alleviated the flight to SIB's that now appears to be in process.
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
It is important for a central bank to guarantee the integrity of banking system while allowing any individual bank to fail. The scheme I'm proposing is designed to do just that.
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Hanno Lustig
@HannoLustig
Other Take: Banks might be fully hedged against interest rate risk.
Possible, but, if you a portfolio of long-dated USTR and MBS, you probably do not want to fully hedge interest rate risk, because if you do, you've bought a portfolio of T-bills -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Zoe Zhang
@QianxueZhang
Super super happy!!! Thank you @farmerrf for writing me the reference letter, @JiaqiLi_Yes for telling me about the event and @cvillallera for sharing your successful application experience!
Looking forward to July!đ -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Daniel
@growing_daniel
I'm a founder with $12m in Silicon Valley Bank. We are not going to be able to make payroll today and our entire business is in severe jeopardy.
Reporters feel free to DM for a full interview. -
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Larry @Kotlikoff is moving his money to a safer place when the markets open on Monday. larrykotlikoff.substack.com/p/why-svbs-failure-is-really-⊠This piece makes scary reading from an economist who knows a great deal about bank runs
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Bird song at dusk in Hyde Park
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Giuseppe Cavaliere
@CavaliereGiu
Hi #econtwitter!
Start the week with some nostalgia by checking out these handwritten notes by Peter CB Phillips (@Yale) on theoretical time series #econometrics.
All the classics (FCLTs, stoch. calculus, unit roots âŠ) are there.
Don't miss out on this blast from the past! -
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
VoxEU
@voxeu
Nobel laureate Edward Prescott, 1940-2022 cepr.org/voxeu/columns/nobel-laureate-edward-prescott-194âŠ
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
JeanPhilippedeTonnac
@inthemoodfortw
Self portrait © M.C. Escher
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
In the data, low unemployment is followed by low productivity. Perhaps because the marginal workers â i.e. the last ones hired â are the least productive www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2017/12/2/is-unemployâŠ
Shane Cameron
@sdot54
I appreciate ur work. Iâm sure itâs not easy modeling this stuff. Iâm just pontificating, but wouldn't full employment=more productivity. The invitation to a worker would be off the clock. An owner wouldnât reallocate productive workers 2 head hunt. Heâd have 1 on staff. No?
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
𧔠For the period I studied -- 1954 -- 2006. static1.squarespace.com/static/573b5f2bf85082a897b58171/t⊠the relationship between the stock market and the unemployment rate is symmetric. Booms reduce the unemployment rate and crashes increase it. @carney @dsquareddigest @delong 1/
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
If the unemployment rate falls below u*, the search and matching theory of unemployment -- which I adapted for my work -- predicts that output will fall. Very low unemployment is inefficient ... 3/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
... because everybody is running around recruiting everyone else and there is no-one left to produce goods and services. That, IMO, is where the US economy is now. Unemployment is too low. 4/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
What about the fact that US workers are leaving the labor force? Although that is true: it does not have much to do with the business cycle as I explain here www.rogerfarmer.com/rogerfarmerblog/2016/9/18/unemploymen⊠5/
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
Hours worked per week and labor force participation have a big secular. component. All the action at business cycle frequencies is in the unemployment rate. 6/6
-
Roger E. A. Farmer reposted
Martin Wolf
@martinwolf_
Martin Wolf: The case for a land value tax is overwhelming www.ft.com/content/fadfbd9e-29ca-4d53-b69a-2497cc3ed95d
-
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
đ§” To be clear: this is not a simple ask. For a human being to write readable code to achieve it they would need training in programming, mathematics, statistics and economics with an undergraduate degree and at least two years of economics Ph.D. training. 1/
Harjoat Bhamra
@HarjoatBhamra
I asked chatGPT to solve Bansal & Yaron (2004) with stochastic vol. The good stuff: fast with readable code. Problems: 1. It used CRRA, not EZ, 2. It did not reduce the problem's dimensionality, 3. The code needed to be debugged before it ran. Not bad! #chatgpt #econtwitter
Post not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The hardest part of writing a good research paper is to ask the right question. But even with the right question, tweaking theories in response to data, without making mistakes, is time consuming. This, initially, is where advances in AI may prove incredibly powerful. /4
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
The next step is coming up with the right questions. Given the progress already made, it is not inconceivable that the descendants of ChatGPT could be independently writing scientific research papers that would pass the bar for publication in a top 5 economics journal 5/5
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Roger E. A. Farmer
@farmerrf
This is a good time to retweet this link evonomics.com/new-keynesian-economics-betrays-keynes/ to @evononomicsmag

















































































































































































































































