Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use
corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens
shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content
published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts
of popular accounts freely available.
Read more.
Carole Hooven
Carole K. Hooven is an evolutionary biologist. She is a nonresident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. She is an associate in the lab of Steven Pinker. More on Wikipedia
✍️ T: The Story of Testosterone. Harvard PhD. 20 years teaching about hormones & behavior, evolution, sex differences at Harvard. Now Senior Fellow @AEI.
Exceptionally clear defense of how to respond to views that we may find offensive, especially in academic settings. Listening and challenging do not mean endorsement. Canceling, abusing, and shutting down never make the views you don’t like disappear. Quite the opposite. @ObhishekSaha
‘Allowing someone to speak is not the same as endorsing their views.’
Professor of Mathematics at Queen Mary University of London Abhishek Saha explains why 170 academics have called for a talk by ‘race-realist’ Nathan Cofnas at Oxford to go ahead.
La testostérone organise le cerveau avant même la naissance, montre Carole Hooven, biologiste à Harvard. The Times : « un livre indispensable pour nous sortir de l’ornière idéologique sur le genre ». Le livre « Testostérone » : fypeditions.com/testosterone-toute-la-verite-sur-lhormone…
Having received hateful comments and harassment, I know how this damages one’s wellbeing. No one deserves personal attacks or threats. I ask that people refrain from directing hateful comments or bullying towards Dr. Knouse. We can hold each other accountable while being humane.
When protestors disrupt classes other students are taking, they are stealing from those students. Students pay tuition to take classes for credit. Other activities that are similarly normal functions of the institution are disrupted, and harm students, researchers, and others. It is possible to work through disagreements without stealing from uninvolved innocent people.
Any Harvard graduate student who participated in this planned class disruption should be disciplined to the fullest extent possible under Harvard’s policies.
The professor tried to move the class and couldn’t. His students were disrupted while trying to complete an in-class exam.
Great review of @ProfAliceS excellent book, Sex, Lies and Statistics: Why We Need Evidence-Based Policies on Sex and Gender.
“Failures to collect vital data, Sullivan argues, are both a consequence of, and a contributing factor to, important social and political trends. Her case study is sex and gender, but there are wider lessons for anyone who values good data, democracy, or truth. Without collecting data on both biological sex and gender identity it is impossible to test the claim that the latter, not the former, determines sporting performance, and this matters for future policy on who should compete in which category. It is impossible to understand the interactions of sex and gender identity in social phenomena like offending rates or earnings. It is also impossible to predict the effects of policy changes, on transgender people or anyone else. The absence of data benefits nobody, except perhaps those with a vested interest in misleading the public to pursue their own agenda. Whatever your views on specific issues, anyone who values the role of statistics in public policy should take seriously Sullivan’s account, and her suggested lessons for a better way forward: ‘Tell it like it is; … Embrace criticism; … Abandon tribalism; … Tolerance is a virtue; …Everyone counts.’” academic.oup.com/jrssig/article/23/6/45/8993955
My TED Talk is live! 🧠 I’m so excited to finally share this with you. What if letting go is the key to gaining control? The neuroscience of control, creativity, and flow—with a little help from Spock and Keith Richards. Full talk below👇 #tedtalk#neuroscience
I understand the world is on fire, but... here's a video of a sex/gender panel discussion I participated in recently with @hoovlet and @byrne_a at the University of Arizona. This site also contains written responses we gave to some audience questions.
On Wednesday, a group of 50 scientists — from 33 institutions, including three at MIT, and nine countries — sent a letter to MIT administrators that said Sabatini’s departure from the university “carried a level of unfairness that did not meet basic standards all institutions should afford their faculty.”
Hard for me to see someone who was a colleague at MIT relishing in my destruction. Particularly since they barely knew me and never bothered--as perhaps scientists should--to check if there was another version of events.
🚨 BOMBSHELL COURT EVIDENCE EXPOSES EXPLOSIVE PRIVATE MESSAGES REVEALING COORDINATION BETWEEN KRISTIN KNOUSE AND MIT PROFESSOR SANGEETA BHATIA IN THE DAVID M. SABATINI ORDEAL.
🔱 NEW REVELATION — Court evidence exposes how Knouse and Bhatia privately celebrated Sabatini’s removal, discussed the potential destruction of his professional career, and anticipated the revocation of his @MIT tenure.
An 80-message exchange between Kristin Knouse and MIT Professor Sangeeta Bhatia, dated August 20–21, 2021, reveals their private reactions immediately following Whitehead Institute and HHMI's severance of ties with Professor @DMSabatini.
The communications contain statements that deserve serious public examination.
🔴 1. “YOU DID IT” — “AND HE’S OUT.”
On August 20, 2021, Bhatia congratulated Knouse:
🔴 “YOU DID IT. You crossed the finish line. It's out in the open. And you're not out in the open. And you're on the faculty. And he's out.”
Knouse responded:
🔴 “You connecting me to Nancy [Hopkins]was the turning point. I will never forget that walk in Lexington.”
🔴 2. “THIS WAS THE OUTCOME I DREAMED OF.”
The following morning, as news coverage spread, Knouse discussed the possibility of Sabatini losing his MIT tenure:
🔴 “Hard to imagine MIT will be left with any choice other than to revoke tenure.”
Bhatia responded:
🔴 “You're right about tenure”
She subsequently wrote:
🔴 “This was the outcome I dreamed of but NEVER certain I would get it.”
Knouse also described her assessment of Whitehead's handling of the matter:
🔴 “And as skeptical as I was of Whitehead's end game, in the end I think the overall process was perfectly executed.”
Bhatia expressed her approval of Whitehead Institute Director Ruth Lehmann:
🔴 “I'm proud of Ruth [Lehmann]”
These exchanges occurred months before MIT's April 2022 tenure-revocation recommendation.
🔴 3. THE PROFESSIONAL CONSEQUENCES — BEYOND WHITEHEAD.
The participants also discussed Sabatini's corporate affiliations and prospects for future employment.
Knouse wrote:
🔴 “I know of one company already speaking with lawyers to remove him on grounds of morality clause.”
She subsequently stated:
🔴 “Hard to imagine how he can be gainfully employed anywhere after the past 24 hours ...”
These were not merely discussions about an institutional investigation. They extended to the potential consequences for Sabatini's career, tenure, corporate affiliations, and future livelihood.
🔴 4. THE DIVERSITY SURVEY AND PROTECTION FROM PUBLIC IDENTIFICATION.
In another particularly consequential exchange, Bhatia wrote:
🔴 “Also the dei survey and subsequent investigation really protects you, which I love. There is not even a scent of whistleblower in all the press.”
This statement takes on particular significance alongside the previously disclosed communications in which Knouse and Nora Kory discussed using Whitehead's diversity survey to conceal an investigation already under consideration (📑 see the original court evidence in the first comment below).
🔴 5. “WE DRANK CHAMPAGNE” — CELEBRATING AS THE NEWS SPREAD.
Perhaps the most striking exchange appears on KK011419.
On August 21, 2021, Knouse declared:
🔴 “I KNOW! Young people took down a relatively young king. Progress, progress, progress.”
Knouse also wrote:
🔴 “Two other women who came forward and I drank champagne while watching the Tweets and articles roll in last night. It felt like campaign headquarters after an election victory. Really special.”
Bhatia responded:
🔴 “That's awesome.”
These exchanges reinforce the serious concerns about coordination and conflicts of interest raised by our previous disclosures. Their significance must be assessed alongside the full documentary record and the subsequent jury verdict.
The scientific community deserves full accountability for any misconduct established by the evidence, including the roles of individuals who participated in or improperly influenced the institutional processes that subjected Professor Sabatini to a devastating ordeal and profoundly damaged his career.
📑 REVIEW THE ORIGINAL COURT EVIDENCE BELOW.
🔱 ScienceGuardians™ Legal and Investigative Team
MORE COURT EVIDENCE. MORE REVELATIONS. STAY TUNED. ⚠️
🔱 Part 5 — Joint Appendix JA004741: Court evidence reveals reported support and pressure involving senior MIT faculty
🚨 Court documents reveal that Kristin Knouse described support from influential MIT faculty members during the proceedings concerning Professor David M. Sabatini.
⚠️ In messages dated 13 October 2021, Knouse identified support attributed to senior MIT figures and described their willingness to approach MIT President Rafael Reif to influence the institutional outcome.
These communications document efforts to mobilize influential individuals within MIT during Sabatini's tenure-review proceedings.
Reasonable people can disagree about sex-based rights. But it is not reasonable to deny the reality of sex or distort the language that describes it (male and female, and man and woman for sexually mature members of our species). It prevents productive communication across disagreement, and results in this kind of ridiculousness. 👇🏽 And I fail to see how it helps trans people.
Highlight reel of Australia’s sex discrimination commissioner, the custodian of women’s rights, saying utter nonsense. It could on for hours but we’ve all got lives to lead so here’s 3 minutes.
Asian-Americans in Harvard’s Incoming Class More Than Double, to 43.2 Percent
Newly released data on the Harvard College class of 2030 say the class is 43.2 percent Asian-American, a record high and more than double the level when Students for Fair Admissions first sued Harvard alleging racial discrimination in admissions.
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 2023 that Harvard was unlawfully using race as a factor in admissions. Since then, the numbers of Hispanic and black students in the incoming Harvard classes have dipped, while the numbers of Asian-Americans have soared.
A movement against injustice, driven by the language of DEI, transformed colleges and universities from protectors of free thoughts into moral police of ideologies.
𝙎𝙥𝙚𝙚𝙘𝙝𝙡𝙚𝙨𝙨 takes a deep dive into the erosion of free speech at colleges & universities from campus protests to government demands by asking questions mainstream media does not want to discuss.
"The passivity of orientation scenarios, the therapy slop-packed consent guidance, and its broader determination to sanitize student life reflect the same conceit: Students are helpless actors in need of supervision." Amelia Barnum '28 @thecrimson
After you are abandoned by a trusted institution and publicly shamed, the headlines and mobs eventually fade. What you are left with is isolation.
People who claimed to be your friends abandon you. Very few will say anything positive about you. People generally pretend you are dead. Others dismiss or worse take credit for your work and try to write you out of history. Vultures swoop in from every direction.
This is what happens when fourth-rate administrators make decisions affecting people’s livelihoods without concern for what they are doing to their lives. These are scientists who were among the best in the world at what they did. They passed up careers in pharma, finance, tech and administration that could have paid them vastly more for their skills.
When I was younger, people in my programs who gave up on science early went on to make fortunes on Wall Street, in biotech, and in Silicon Valley. Those who stayed pursued their passion for the love of it at the cost of millions of dollars.
When an administrator steps in and dismantles that life’s work, far more than a job is erased. Laboratories take years to build, and scientific problems take years to develop and eventually solve. Experiments, research materials, collaborations, and accumulated expertise cannot simply be restarted somewhere else. The field keeps moving while your work is stopped. The time lost is also the time lost that could have been spent making money - that part a court will never be able to figure out because juries are ordinary people not dedicated scientists.
Then comes the gaslighting. People assume it must have been your fault because an institution like MIT or Duke is supposedly so trustworthy and meritorious that it would never do this to someone who was not guilty. Institutional prestige is a substitute for examining the evidence.
I recently attended a meeting on academic freedome at MIT where Dorian Abbot’s name kept coming up as their fallen hero. They cited a cancelled lecture of his at MIT as their rallying cray. It was treated as an institutional catastrophe. It was insane. David was an afterthought among people supposedly concerned about the climate at MIT and self-appointed to change the culture there.
They simply believed MIT’s PR messaging that they have always been focused on merit despite some small missteps like the canceling of a controversial lecture. I had to point out repeatedly that MIT is not the MIT they attended 30–50 years ago. The priorities reflected in its newer hires and leadership have moved far from the scientific excellence they associate with it.
A civil jury ruled in favor of ex-MIT scientist David Sabatini, who was accused by a younger colleague of inappropriate sexual conduct in his Cambridge research lab, and awarded him $6 million in damages. www.bostonglobe.com/2026/10/16/metro/david-sabatini-verdict/
If you're in DC stop by AEI for a conversation about my new book! Attendees can can pick up a free copy of my book and I'll be available to sign or chat with folks after the event.
I'll be sharing a lot more about Generation Uncoupled in the coming days. But for now, I just want to express my profound appreciation to all those involved in getting here. My research team at the Survey Center, AEI colleagues, my editor at Penguin Random House, the publicity team and the 100+ young people who were willing to share their thoughts and experiences on dating, politics, family and so much more.
Unlike almost everyone opining on sex, including me, Geoff Parker, co-author of this recent article, has been a leader on the evolution of the sexes since the 1970's. (Parker has a total of 55K citations, and an h-index of 102.) onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ele.70426
Hi Isaac. I've written one of the most-read scholarly articles on the sex binary and my arguments are cited favorably by the most prominent researchers on the evolution and biology of the sexes.
My DMs are open if you want to make sure you accurately understand the mainstream binary view rooted in gametes, and why attempts to root the sexes in something else will always fail.
I'm working on a "what is a woman" piece, speaking with geneticists, etc. I hope to finish soon. Scientists I've spoken with repeatedly told me the sex binary is incredibly overly simplified, that genetic variation at the chromosomal level is real. Should we not report that?
Today @KarlDeisseroth of @StanfordMed@Stanford won the @NobelPrize for his co-discovery & development of Optogenetics. Here he explains what that is, and how it is unlocking the secrets of brain function & helping to cure diseases. (And he explains that in ~1min).
Hunter-gatherers are romanticized as naturally generous. But this generosity is the result of repeated resource extraction through forceful demands, complaints, ridicule, gossip and ostracism. Equality emerges from self-interest and coercion. theconversation.com/hunter-gatherer-societies-are-often-p…
Hunter-gatherers are romanticized as naturally generous. But this generosity is the result of repeated resource extraction through forceful demands, complaints, ridicule, gossip and ostracism. Equality emerges from self-interest and coercion. theconversation.com/hunter-gatherer-societies-are-often-p…
It's the one-year birthday of my first and last book, and while it was not the smash hit that I wanted, I do regularly get messages from people saying it saved their life—which isn't as good as fame and fortune, but it's still pretty nice.
If you or someone you love has struggled with drinking, it might help.
Hundreds of US universities will close as the perceived value of a degree nosedives. But for the foreseeable future, elite universities will remain free of existential worries; for example, Princeton will still be able to fill its classes with willing payers, and it’s minimally dependent on tuition anyway.
Yet even elite universities will suffer for this trend, which they helped fuel by bowing to political activists. The soft power of US universities is already eroding at home and abroad. So is their place in international rankings, which say little in any one year but mark relative standing across decades.
Spending 4-8 years on a luxurious vacay funded by parents or government turns out to be a thing for low-opportunity-cost people. Anyone in a real profession faces super rigorous credentialing systems post-college in any case.
Recently Steven Crowder (@scrowder) and Prof Randall Kennedy of Harvard Law School held a debate (now with over 300K views) about free speech on campus. My name came up and I felt it warranted a response. Here's the context (also provided in the video link below, which should start at the right place):
1:12 Crowder: You'll say she resigned. She said she was forced out. Kennedy: She was not ousted by Harvard University. Crowder: So, she's a liar. Kennedy: No, she's not a liar. Crowder: We're just not believing the women? Kennedy: She may be mistaken.
Kennedy is a co-president of Harvard's council on academic freedom (@cafharvard), which was formed partly in response to my case. I don't know if Kennedy meant to suggest that he believes that I have not accurately described my case, but that's how it comes across IMHO. I have tried to be careful about how I describe what happened, since I was not fired or "forced" out, as in the tweet I re-posted below.
Crowder raised my case sympathetically, as an example of Harvard’s intolerance of controversial views. I agree with him: it was appropriate to bring up my case in this context, whether Harvard “ousted” me or not. It is one of several clear examples of Harvard’s intolerance of views deemed "harmful," sometimes by administrators themselves, but more often by others who claimed to be harmed, with administrators capitulating. In my view, such intolerance can include being fired, but also circumstances that make it nearly impossible to do one's job: inability to teach one's usual course; one's department chair saying that the best course of action would be to leave; or department chairs sending an email to hundreds of people that names the "perpetrator" and indicates that she is responsible for the impact of her words. I could go on.
Apparently there have been some improvements, but they do not include a reckoning with past mistakes. It seems to me that Harvard still has a long way to go when it comes to free speech on campus.
I want to be clear that @Harvard did not fire me. They did not "remove me" from my position. Another person in the same situation might have stayed on, but I could not. The fact is that I did not feel that I could do my job any longer, and I did feel pushed out; but that is not the same as actually being forced out.
First, my mental health was deteriorating rapidly; and second, it seemed apparent that I would not be supported in pursuing my teaching, research and writing, given the lack of public support from my department and Harvard administrators in response to public attacks on my character. (And I could not even teach my lecture course, since for the first time in 20 years, no grad students would agree to serve as my teaching assistants.)
There's far more to it than that, of course, and I wrote about some of it in this article below: shorturl.at/gIP02
"The last woman to be executed in the US...who transitioned from male to female while in prison, was convicted of stalking, raping and fatally stabbing an ex-girlfriend before transitioning." There are two sexes, and mammals cannot change from one to the other. Sex matters—as does the language we use to describe it—especially for women's safety. This bs from @thetimes helps nobody. @ProfAliceS
The last "woman" to be executed in the US is actually a man. I cannot express how tired I am of this. Nothing makes media outlets write this sort of nonsense, even if governments promote it. What happened to speaking truth to power? www.thetimes.com/article/0d50296a-695a-474f-aa37-1a6a121d…
🧵I am blown away and delighted by the range and quality of endorsements for my forthcoming book "Sex, Lies and Statistics: Why we need evidence-based policy on sex and gender".
Publication announcement! 🚨📚 "Sex, Lies and Statistics: Why We Need Evidence-Based Policy on Sex and Gender"
"Sex, Lies and Statistics" documents the missteps society has made by turning its back on evidence when it comes to sex and gender, and shows that accurate data is vital in providing a path to evidence-based policy.
Sorry! I misremembered Cordelia's support being on bluesky, but it was actually LinkedIn (my critic posted videos and text on several social media platforms that misrepresented my views). Here it is, with a link:
"Cordelia Fine, Professor at the University of Melbourne
Carole and I disagree, quite fundamentally, on a lot of issues (and have debated them in an exchange in Aeon). But to speak up in her defense, what pushed her out of Harvard was not scholarly critique, but social ostracism. This included the director of a diversity task force, acting in that official capacity, publicly labelling Carole's statement that there are two sexes as transphobic, and postgraduates refusing to TA for Carole's class. It is clear from her books and writing that she is well-informed about individuals with differences of sexual development, and I have never come across anything she has said or written that suggests any antipathy whatsoever towards trans people. To the contrary." www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:749135788869…
Thanks for this. You are completely right that Cordelia stands out for her willingness to engage across disagreement in a serious way. Although we disagree profoundly, and our Aeon exchange was quite frustrating, she never resorts to any kind of character assassination like many others who hold similar views about sex differences. She even stood up for me on bluesky when someone with a high profile distorted my views that I had expressed in a talk and also disparaged my character. Cordelia vigorously defended my integrity and encouraged my attacker to respond to my actual views. She deserves respect for her willingness to consistently champion academic freedom, and how she models productive engagement.
Sorry! I misremembered Cordelia's support being on bluesky, but it was actually LinkedIn (my critic posted videos and text on several social media platforms that misrepresented my views). Here it is, with a link:
"Cordelia Fine, Professor at the University of Melbourne
Carole and I disagree, quite fundamentally, on a lot of issues (and have debated them in an exchange in Aeon). But to speak up in her defense, what pushed her out of Harvard was not scholarly critique, but social ostracism. This included the director of a diversity task force, acting in that official capacity, publicly labelling Carole's statement that there are two sexes as transphobic, and postgraduates refusing to TA for Carole's class. It is clear from her books and writing that she is well-informed about individuals with differences of sexual development, and I have never come across anything she has said or written that suggests any antipathy whatsoever towards trans people. To the contrary." www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:749135788869…
Thanks for this. You are completely right that Cordelia stands out for her willingness to engage across disagreement in a serious way. Although we disagree profoundly, and our Aeon exchange was quite frustrating, she never resorts to any kind of character assassination like many others who hold similar views about sex differences. She even stood up for me on bluesky when someone with a high profile distorted my views that I had expressed in a talk and also disparaged my character. Cordelia vigorously defended my integrity and encouraged my attacker to respond to my actual views. She deserves respect for her willingness to consistently champion academic freedom, and how she models productive engagement.
You can count on @hoovlet for clear, concise, fact-based analysis on testosterone (and other sex-hormone issues where she has expertise). I will underscore that she points out developmental and life-time exposure; so important in other conditions also - in utero hypoandrogen-hyperestrogen is implicated in development of endometriosis (@PaolaVigano3 ).
Cremieux asks in his tweet below (with lots of great references) whether testosterone "radically increases risk-taking, aggravation, the propensity to commit violent acts, and so on." I'm glad he's explaining that testosterone's effects are not so clear cut! But I wish he'd given more consideration to the question of whether male-typical levels of testosterone increase the propensity for such behaviors in males. The answer to that question is "yes."
Cremieux is right that there is no clear evidence that male testosterone levels (within the normal T range) predict levels of sexual or aggressive behavior. It's great to get more eyes on that, and to bust the many myths. But the explanations for differences in behavior within a sex are quite different from those concerning differences between the sexes.
Cremieux primarily relies on research that addresses questions like: does a man's T level predict the intensity of his sex drive or the frequency of his violent behavior? The answer, generally, is no. (And he's right that a bigger body, more muscles or deeper voice, which are potentially associated with higher T at critical developmental stages, do impact behavior indirectly, but not in a clear way.)
But he then uses this “within sex” research to answer questions about the source of the gap between the sexes — in aggression, in sex drive, whatever. But answers to questions about how T predicts behavior in one sex do not address questions about the role of testosterone in explaining differences in behavior between the sexes. Such questions—e.g. why are males more violent than females— require different kinds of evidence, answering questions like what T does across development, why it does it, what happens when you manipulate it in other animals, and what do “natural experiments” in humans tell us? It's about the evolution of sexually differentiated reproductive strategies and the hormonal mechanisms that coordinate body and behavior in each sex.
An evolutionary perspective would have improved Cremieux's perspective. He tweeted that "the [sex] gap in violent behavior is far too large to be explained by testosterone levels." But the size of the sex difference is part of the point: 90-95% of all murders are committed by males, pretty much everywhere in the world. (The size of the gap is driven by differences in male behavior, which tends to respond to cultural incentives.) This pattern is not caused by small differences in T level; it is about large and impactful differences between the sexes in testosterone over a lifetime, that exist for a reason.
On average, a human male is exposed to T levels that are about 10-20 times higher than in females. Across development, male brains and bodies go through "critical periods" in early life (in the womb and shortly after birth) and adolescence, during which the brain and body are particularly sensitive to T's actions, which have permanent effects. So even if T is low in adulthood, it has already permanently affected reproductively relevant behaviors.
Evidence suggests that "sex-typical behavior" (with wide variation!) in male animals (including humans) is elicited once T passes something like a relatively low but male-typical threshold T level, at different phases of life. Above that, what seems to matter more is age, health, history, the ecological environment, and social cues and norms. In humans, these can include things like religion; socioeconomic status; availability of fertile females; disease; threats to resources, mates or children; community values; standards of masculinity; and the law.
Higher lifetime T in males (and not necessarily current T) is why many animals show similar sex differences in aggression, including higher rates of rough play. This is true even in humans, in which boys play rougher than girls around the world, even though little boys don't have higher T than girls. The male preference for rough play has been clearly shown to be driven by higher T, specifically in the womb and/or shortly after birth in male animals. Such play is part of a male reproductive strategy, motivating young males to practice status-competition and cooperation skills they will need in adulthood. In girls, those with unusually high T levels in the womb also tend to prefer rougher play.
Testosterone has these effects in males because of evolutionary pressures: males produce sperm rather than eggs, and thus have evolved reproductive strategies that differ from those of females. On average, males have a higher potential rate of reproduction and invest less in parenting, and generally (not always) compete more intensely for mates. Testosterone is the biological mechanism that coordinates the production of sperm with the other physical and behavioral attributes that help males get sperm to egg, given the species and environment.
Again, environment matters tremendously, but it is not the source of the sex differences in basic reproductive behaviors.
You can read more about testosterone and behavior in my book T: The Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides us.
Cremieux asks in his tweet below (with lots of great references) whether testosterone "radically increases risk-taking, aggravation, the propensity to commit violent acts, and so on." I'm glad he's explaining that testosterone's effects are not so clear cut! But I wish he'd given more consideration to the question of whether male-typical levels of testosterone increase the propensity for such behaviors in males. The answer to that question is "yes."
Cremieux is right that there is no clear evidence that male testosterone levels (within the normal T range) predict levels of sexual or aggressive behavior. It's great to get more eyes on that, and to bust the many myths. But the explanations for differences in behavior within a sex are quite different from those concerning differences between the sexes.
Cremieux primarily relies on research that addresses questions like: does a man's T level predict the intensity of his sex drive or the frequency of his violent behavior? The answer, generally, is no. (And he's right that a bigger body, more muscles or deeper voice, which are potentially associated with higher T at critical developmental stages, do impact behavior indirectly, but not in a clear way.)
But he then uses this “within sex” research to answer questions about the source of the gap between the sexes — in aggression, in sex drive, whatever. But answers to questions about how T predicts behavior in one sex do not address questions about the role of testosterone in explaining differences in behavior between the sexes. Such questions—e.g. why are males more violent than females— require different kinds of evidence, answering questions like what T does across development, why it does it, what happens when you manipulate it in other animals, and what do “natural experiments” in humans tell us? It's about the evolution of sexually differentiated reproductive strategies and the hormonal mechanisms that coordinate body and behavior in each sex.
An evolutionary perspective would have improved Cremieux's perspective. He tweeted that "the [sex] gap in violent behavior is far too large to be explained by testosterone levels." But the size of the sex difference is part of the point: 90-95% of all murders are committed by males, pretty much everywhere in the world. (The size of the gap is driven by differences in male behavior, which tends to respond to cultural incentives.) This pattern is not caused by small differences in T level; it is about large and impactful differences between the sexes in testosterone over a lifetime, that exist for a reason.
On average, a human male is exposed to T levels that are about 10-20 times higher than in females. Across development, male brains and bodies go through "critical periods" in early life (in the womb and shortly after birth) and adolescence, during which the brain and body are particularly sensitive to T's actions, which have permanent effects. So even if T is low in adulthood, it has already permanently affected reproductively relevant behaviors.
Evidence suggests that "sex-typical behavior" (with wide variation!) in male animals (including humans) is elicited once T passes something like a relatively low but male-typical threshold T level, at different phases of life. Above that, what seems to matter more is age, health, history, the ecological environment, and social cues and norms. In humans, these can include things like religion; socioeconomic status; availability of fertile females; disease; threats to resources, mates or children; community values; standards of masculinity; and the law.
Higher lifetime T in males (and not necessarily current T) is why many animals show similar sex differences in aggression, including higher rates of rough play. This is true even in humans, in which boys play rougher than girls around the world, even though little boys don't have higher T than girls. The male preference for rough play has been clearly shown to be driven by higher T, specifically in the womb and/or shortly after birth in male animals. Such play is part of a male reproductive strategy, motivating young males to practice status-competition and cooperation skills they will need in adulthood. In girls, those with unusually high T levels in the womb also tend to prefer rougher play.
Testosterone has these effects in males because of evolutionary pressures: males produce sperm rather than eggs, and thus have evolved reproductive strategies that differ from those of females. On average, males have a higher potential rate of reproduction and invest less in parenting, and generally (not always) compete more intensely for mates. Testosterone is the biological mechanism that coordinates the production of sperm with the other physical and behavioral attributes that help males get sperm to egg, given the species and environment.
Again, environment matters tremendously, but it is not the source of the sex differences in basic reproductive behaviors.
You can read more about testosterone and behavior in my book T: The Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides us.
"The five networks that have suspended their pool coverage of President Trump — ABC, CBS, CNN, Fox News, and NBC — just issued a joint statement: “The public has a vital interest in receiving accurate, independent information about its government. No administration should restrict a news organization because it objects to its reporting." Kudos to @FoxNews! Is this uniting of the news media reason for hope? Please let it be! www.nytimes.com/live/2026/09/21/business/trump-white-hous…
NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya, a former colleague of Harvard President Alan Garber, refused a directive from Trump on Friday to cut Harvard’s federal research grants, Politico reported Saturday.
"This approach, putting speed and efficiency by way of automation above all other considerations, comes not from the priorities of intellectual inquiry or scientific experimentation but from the business models of corporations." By Harvard historian Jill Lepore.
What a cover! Coming from Abigail, I am sure the book will be provocative, engaging and deeply researched, and will tell us what's happened to young love, and what it costs us.
Self-censorship and ideological conformity in research has become so normalized that telling the truth now requires incentives.
The new Carob Trust Prize for Academic Courage will award up to $1M each to scholars who have the courage to be intellectually independent, especially when their work counters prevailing viewpoints.
This is a welcome development to reward scholars who follow the evidence rather than the political winds of the moment. The Prize founders pledge a nonpartisan spirit, which will be essential to its impact.
The Carob Trust is launching an academic prize to be awarded to up to five researchers each year. Our goal is to incentivize the pursuit and publication of the truth wherever the facts may lead.
Unfortunately today, many findings go unpublished as researchers fear blowback from colleagues, the university, or large swathes of the public because their findings reveal an uncomfortable truth.
Our goal with the prize is to reward academic courage and excellence. We welcome your submissions.
Info on The Carob Trust and details on the prize can be found at the links below. A summary follows:
•Mission: The Carob Trust Prize honors academics who pursue bold ideas that challenge prevailing orthodoxies—whether political, intellectual, or methodological—and hold the potential to reshape knowledge, policy, or society. The Prize supports scholars whose work is original, rigorous, impactful, and courageous—even when it is unpopular.
Award
◦$1,000,000 awarded over five years ◦Flexible, largely unrestricted support ◦Expect 3-5 awards a year
Selection Criteria:
◦Intellectual Independence ◦Non-Conformist Ideas ◦Impact and Vindication
Other Parameters:
◦Limited to work in the Social Sciences. ◦Only living nominees will be considered. ◦Candidates must be citizens or legal residents of the United States. ◦The Carob Trust Prize for Academic Courage will take a nominee’s life’s work into account. Scholars who are earlier in their careers might be considered for a smaller prize. Timeline
◦Nov. 1: Nomination window closes ◦Spring: Annual Carob Trust Prize Award Ceremony Spirit of the Prize:
Breakthroughs often begin as unpopular ideas. By honoring those who show independence, courage, and resilience, the Carob Trust Prize ensures that today’s controversial insights have the chance to become tomorrow’s common sense.
We're Number 71! (in FIRE's College Free Speech Rankings). A big jump from last year's 245. The Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh claims some of the credit, though we have our work cut out for us. rankings.fire.org/campus/166027-harvard-university?demo=a…
"47 percent of faculty respondents also disagreed that Harvard has a troubling lack of ideological diversity among its faculty, while roughly 31 percent agreed" Majority of FAS Faculty Oppose Harvard’s $10M Viewpoint Diversity Push www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/9/7/faculty-survey-viewpo…
Harvard study by my psychology department colleague Matt Nock predicts most suicide attempts a week in advance - quite a feat. Agitation, not depression, is the most common trigger. current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/harvard-study-predicts-mo…
Wow…Roland Fryer and @BillAckman have created a $1 million prize for academic truth-telling, the Carob Trust Prize for Academic Courage.
“The prize awards $1 million each to as many as five social scientists a year who have demonstrated intellectual independence, published findings that were attacked rather than answered, and been validated by the evidence—despite the professional cost. The selection criteria are designed to distinguish courage from contrarianism: Nominees must show a sustained commitment to following logic and evidence regardless of pressure, a willingness to ask questions others avoid, and work that has shifted academic debate, public discourse or policy—often despite being misread, mischaracterized or vilified at the time of publication.”
"U.S. universities urgently need to reconcile themselves with the public they serve. Again, we hope they will do this by taking up the hard work of reforming their practices to better align with the ideal of nonpartisan truth-seeking." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/08/24/dear-progressi…
"I'm trying to advocate for truth and prioritizing knowledge seeking and open debate"
@hoovlet summarizes key points from her recent lecture at the @NIH titled: "The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It"
My recent @NIH talk 👇🏽 was on why we need to get real about sex. I recommend the lively Q&A (at 50 mins), with NIH scientists in the room and online. (Not all were happy with the gametic definition.) @NIHDirector_Jay was called away, so the conversation was moderated by Rick Woychik [@DirectorNIEHS]. And stay for the supplemental video (at 1:30) that I made to answer some of the online questions we didn't have time for. Also there was some blowback on social media, so I tried to clarify some of my main points in response. videocast.nih.gov/watch/6f87298d-7ab7-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769
NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series: The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It, with @hoovlet. Q&A 50:00, follow-up video addressing more Qs 1:29:30.👇
My recent @NIH talk 👇🏽 was on why we need to get real about sex. I recommend the lively Q&A (at 50 mins), with NIH scientists in the room and online. (Not all were happy with the gametic definition.) @NIHDirector_Jay was called away, so the conversation was moderated by Rick Woychik [@DirectorNIEHS]. And stay for the supplemental video (at 1:30) that I made to answer some of the online questions we didn't have time for. Also there was some blowback on social media, so I tried to clarify some of my main points in response. videocast.nih.gov/watch/6f87298d-7ab7-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769
NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series: The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It, with @hoovlet. Q&A 50:00, follow-up video addressing more Qs 1:29:30.👇
Los autores de este artículo, Carole Hooven y Alex Byrne, sostienen que la biología ha mantenido durante más de un siglo una definición clara y binaria del sexo basada en los gametos: los machos producen gametos pequeños, los espermatozoides, y las hembras producen gametos grandes, los óvulos. No ha habido ningún descubrimiento científico relevante que obligue a revisar esta idea básica. Lo que realmente cambió fue el panorama cultural y político. Desde principios del siglo XXI, el activismo por los derechos transgénero ha sembrado dudas sistemáticas sobre el sexo binario en campos como el derecho, el deporte, la educación y, sobre todo, la medicina. Esto ha terminado afectando negativamente los estándares médicos y el bienestar real de los pacientes.
Pero lo que más me interesa de este artículo, y por eso lo destaco, es el papel que ha jugado la moralización en el silenciamiento del debate sobre estas cuestiones. Hooven y Byrne explican que la moralización se ha convertido en el mecanismo más potente para cerrar discusiones que, en teoría, deberían ser científicas. Ya no se trata solo de discrepar sobre datos o definiciones. El asunto se ha transformado en una cuestión moral de primer orden en la que defender que solo hay dos sexos se presenta como algo moralmente sospechoso, como una posición que niega realidades vividas, que invalida identidades, que genera violencia simbólica y que, en última instancia, daña a personas vulnerables. En cambio, cuestionar o rechazar el binario aparece como un acto de justicia, inclusión y progreso moral.
Cuando una narrativa incorpora un juicio moral fuerte, criticarla ya no es solo señalar un posible error científico o conceptual sino que se interpreta automáticamente como un ataque a valores superiores como la compasión, la equidad o la protección de minorías. Es exactamente el tipo de “blindaje moral” del que suelo hablar cuando escribo sobre estos temas. Las narrativas quedan protegidas porque cualquier intento de examinarlas con rigor se convierte en prueba de mala intención. Si cuestionas la idea de que el sexo es un espectro o que es asignado socialmente, no estás debatiendo biología sino que estás siendo malo moralmente, transfóbico o cómplice de la opresión. Esa dinámica cierra el paso al debate abierto y honesto.
Los autores muestran cómo esto se manifiesta de forma concreta en el mundo académico y médico. En revistas serias como Archives of Sexual Behavior, incluso los investigadores que defienden la visión binaria se sienten obligados a incluir descargos de responsabilidad: “Nada de lo que decimos debe interpretarse como apoyo al sexismo o al odio”. Es como si tuvieran que pedir perdón de antemano por presentar evidencia científica. Mientras tanto, en el otro lado abundan las acusaciones fuertes: que el modelo binario “borra vidas”, “impulsa prejuicios”, “naturaliza la exclusión” o constituye una forma de “violencia epistémica”. Revistas de prestigio como Scientific American, The Lancet o American Scientist han publicado textos que van en esa línea, sugiriendo que insistir en la definición gamética no obedece a razones biológicas sino a motivaciones políticas oscuras.
Esta moralización produce efectos muy prácticos. Genera autocensura porque la mayoría de las personas prefiere no exponerse a ser señaladas públicamente como malas. Crea incentivos profesionales claros ya que es mucho más cómodo y ventajoso alinearse con la visión no binaria o, al menos, no cuestionarla. Y cuando alguien se atreve a disentir, pueden venir las consecuencias reales como campañas en redes, quejas internas, pérdida de reputación o incluso salida de la institución. El caso de la propia Carole Hooven en Harvard es ilustrativo. Tras explicar en televisión la definición biológica clásica del sexo -y aclarar que eso no impedía respetar las identidades de género-, fue acusada públicamente de transfobia por una responsable de diversidad de su departamento. El ambiente se volvió tan hostil que acabó dejando la universidad de Harvard. Otro ejemplo fue la cancelación de un panel antropológico cuyo título incluía la palabra “sexo” de forma clara. Se justificó alegando “daño” a la comunidad trans, como si debatir una categoría biológica fuera en sí mismo un acto agresivo.
En el terreno de la medicina de género, donde las decisiones afectan directamente a menores, esta moralización resulta especialmente preocupante. Cuestionar si es prudente usar bloqueadores de la pubertad o hormonas cruzadas en adolescentes se interpreta con frecuencia como falta de empatía o directamente como odio. Eso ha dificultado enormemente la autocrítica interna que cualquier campo médico serio necesita. Cuando el debate se moraliza tanto, los médicos y investigadores se ven presionados a adoptar el enfoque “afirmativo” aunque la evidencia sea débil o contradictoria. El resultado es que se prioriza la validación inmediata de la identidad sobre la cautela clínica y el principio básico de “primero no hacer daño”.
Hooven y Byrne subrayan una asimetría importante: en el ámbito académico, esta moralización proviene casi siempre de un solo lado. Los que defienden el binario suelen separar claramente la ciencia de las cuestiones de dignidad y derechos. No acusan a sus oponentes de ser malas personas. En cambio, el otro lado mezcla con frecuencia el juicio científico con el juicio moral, lo que hace mucho más difícil el diálogo.
En definitiva, el artículo pone el dedo en la llaga de un problema más amplio que trasciende el tema del sexo y el género. Cuando las narrativas ideológicas se blindan moralmente, la ciencia y la medicina sufren. Se vuelve muy costoso corregir errores, revisar protocolos o seguir la evidencia donde esta lleve. Y los que pagan el precio más alto son, paradójicamente, los pacientes más vulnerables, especialmente los niños y adolescentes con disforia de género que merecen tratamientos prudentes, basados en datos sólidos y no en consignas morales.
Este mecanismo de moralización explica por qué un tema que debería resolverse con evidencia biológica, psicológica y médica se ha convertido en uno de los debates más polarizados y difíciles de mantener con serenidad. Romper ese blindaje no significa carecer de empatía ni negar el sufrimiento real de las personas con disforia. Significa exigir que la ciencia y la medicina puedan funcionar con honestidad intelectual, sin que el miedo a ser moralmente condenados cierre las puertas al escrutinio necesario. Solo así se puede llegar a soluciones que realmente ayuden a la gente en lugar de servir a una narrativa ideológica previa.
From "Sex, Medicine and Moralization" in Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. By @byrne_a and me in special issue edited @jflier, out this month.
"The dry scientific issue of the number and nature of the sexes was recast as a matter of justice, inclusion, validation, and harm prevention, with the outmoded binary position on the wrong side of history. The motives and character of those who defended the sex binary were—and still are—questioned by a prominent faction on the progressive left."
Examples of moralization from, respectively, Scientific American, American Scientist, and The Lancet:
"Given what we know about biology across animals and in humans, efforts to represent human sex as binary based solely on what gametes one produces are not about biology but are about trying to restrict who counts as a full human in society." (Fuentes 2023)
"Worryingly, even within the sciences, the term biological sex has become a transphobic dog whistle. Whereas once some of us used this term to differentiate the biological factors we study from social or cultural ones, it has now been co-opted by those who insist on a sex binary and who deny the relevance or even reality of diverse bodies and of gender identities, roles, and expressions in humans." (Clancy et al. 2024: 81)
"Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fueling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles." (Richardson 2025, 436)
My recent @NIH talk 👇🏽 was on why we need to get real about sex. I recommend the lively Q&A (at 50 mins), with NIH scientists in the room and online. (Not all were happy with the gametic definition.) @NIHDirector_Jay was called away, so the conversation was moderated by Rick Woychik [@DirectorNIEHS]. And stay for the supplemental video (at 1:30) that I made to answer some of the online questions we didn't have time for. Also there was some blowback on social media, so I tried to clarify some of my main points in response. videocast.nih.gov/watch/6f87298d-7ab7-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769
NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series: The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It, with @hoovlet. Q&A 50:00, follow-up video addressing more Qs 1:29:30.👇
"To be honest, I’m scared shitless right now. I have no idea how the next few months or years are going to play out. But that fear beats the indignity of being muzzled."
After 11 years as a sports columnist at the Seattle Times, I have decided to resign. It was entirely my choice, and it was not an easy one. The impetus was the Times declining to run a column I wrote from the perspective of two female student athletes who were opposed to competing against biological males. It was one of several pieces of mine that had been spiked, and I no longer felt like I could properly do my job as a columnist. I lay out the situation in greater detail in the link below, but I want to say that I enjoyed my time with the paper, find the talent there to be immense, and have no animosity toward anyone who works there. It was just time for a change.
🔥"No single finding proves our evolutionary hypothesis. What matters is the convergence of developmental, cross-cultural, performance, and anatomical evidence. Fausto-Sterling does not seriously grapple with that convergence."
This piece is as maddening and fantastic as everyone says (no surprise, @Tyler_A_Harper has a gift for storytelling), but the best part might be this sense-making bit at the end; the hollowing of journalism and the arts flows at least in part from this same dynamic
This is utterly perfect and should stand forever as a go-to representation of a major problem with education in our era. It also happens to give a look-in at what I describe in my piece today about Arday. www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/09/elite-academia-leade…
"The other [plagiarism] examples are similar...we aren’t talking about innocuous phrases commonly seen in dissertations, such as 'I’d like to thank my advisor for their support' or 'Death to America'; or quotations of common definitions..." fakenous.substack.com/p/cambridge-universitys-disgrace
"Steven Pinker’s The Blank Slate Was a Warning We Ignored," write biologist Colin Wright @SwipeWright. [It] seems to have aged in reverse... Pinker’s great achievement in The Blank Slate was not simply showing that genes matter, as many competent scientists have demonstrated before. Rather, it was exposing the way that fear of human nature had distorted entire fields of study...." www.realityslaststand.com/p/steven-pinkers-the-blank-slat…
Glad that we're able to give a home to this kind of thoughtful commentary! We hope you enjoy this piece on teaching great books at @MIT from MIT Concourse's Linda Rabieh. Link in next post.
@hoovlet knocked it out of the park at NIH today, giving an extremely scientifically-based and thoughtful talk, which showed enormous respect for others, and for science. She is a national treasure, and a hero to those aching for restoration of trust in science/scientists.
"Associating testosterone with 'lethality' is 'a damaging narrative,' Carole Hooven, [previously an] evolutionary biologist lecturer at Harvard and author of T: The Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us, told me. 'That’s not what testosterone is about. It’s not about killing other humans.''' www.thenation.com/article/society/hegseth-testosterone-di…
Kwame Anthony Appiah’s supplement to the Vanderbilt/WashU report takes up literary studies. Len Gutkin reads it — alongside Gabriel Hankins’s sharper critique. Also in The Review: Alex Byrne on Carole Hooven, legacy admissions in California, and college finances.
The farther I traveled from poverty, the more fashionable it became to romanticize the conditions I had escaped.
I grew up in poverty in Los Angeles and was taken from my mother when I was three. She had immigrated from South Korea, but her life unraveled amid drug addiction. I never met my father and learned only as an adult, through a genetic ancestry test, that he was Mexican. I spent the next several years moving through foster homes and chaotic circumstances.
At seventeen, I enlisted in the United States Air Force. After some setbacks, I arrived at Yale at twenty-five and studied on the GI Bill.
Along the way, I climbed nearly every rung of the American class ladder. I moved from poverty through working-class and lower-middle-class homes. In the military, I encountered the middle class. At Yale, I was surrounded by the upper-middle class and the wealthy.
Moving through these worlds, I noticed that beliefs changed with social class. At Yale, I heard ideas I had never encountered before: abolish the police, empty the prisons, promote polyamory, dismantle traditional marriage, and decriminalize drugs.
These ideas were popular among elites, but their costs often fell on communities like the ones where I grew up. I had seen addiction, abuse, neglect, abandonment, and disorder up close. At Yale and later during my Ph.D. at Cambridge, I studied research on class and social status. It helped me understand what I had witnessed and led me to some startling statistics about social class.
"They will not treat dissent from their opinions as if it amounted to a personal assault. They will be willing to change their minds--and, indeed, their lives...They will be empowered, in other words, to lead examined lives."
Both of us are West Virginians. One of us teaches at Harvard, one at Princeton. One of us is Jewish, the other is Christian. We're friends who are deeply committed to the classic ideals of liberal arts education and profoundly concerned about the state of higher education today.
I offer some general thoughts here on civil discourse, civic friendship,and civil liberties. I'll have more specific things to say about the importance of these things, and how they are related, going forward.
The “near collapse of civic friendship is a catastrophic threat to public life,” @McCormickProf writes. “Restoring it depends on our capacity to practice civil discourse, which in turn requires us to acknowledge our fallibility.” www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/08/truth-relativism-civil-…
"If faculty and students seek to pursue the truth wherever it lies, a university cannot have a political ideology or pursue a particular vision of social change."
As president of Vanderbilt University, Daniel Diermeier has become a powerful voice of reform in higher education. This week he and the chairman of Vanderbilt's board published this highly commendable statement of first principles. Although the document's plea for institutional neutrality won't align with the mission of religiously affiliated schools, it is appropriate and indeed highly desirable for public universities and non-religiously affiliated private institutions like Vanderbilt and Princeton.
Sex Differences Above the Neck (TLDR: they are real & important)
"We should let people be themselves, but in a world where both sexes have equal opportunities and where sex differences aren’t socially harmful. Given the copious data that [@SteveStuWill] presents, who can object to this path?"
"I think philosophy serves justice best by pursuing the truth about justice. And the pursuit of truth about justice requires exposure to a wide range of views on contested moral and political topics."
In 2017, Rebecca Tuvel was an untenured philosopher facing calls for an article of hers to be retracted — and for her to lose her job. Now tenured, she reflects on public shaming, what she regrets, and why she believes the experience made her a better philosopher.
"Harvard's writing Center, under [@RosenzweigJane]'s directorship, has always emphasized the interrelation of writing, speaking, and thinking... these fundamental skills remain central to Harvard College’s stated commitment to 'the transformative power of a liberal arts and sciences education.' Closing [it] and removing its leadership now sends a disturbing signal about how seriously Harvard actually takes that mission." www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/7/29/harvard-writing-cent…
I understand that Harvard needs to lay off a bunch of staff. But this one is a shock and a shame. @RosenzweigJane, who led Harvard's writing center, was an invaluable resource for students and writing education at Harvard. Huge loss.
Harvard laid off its writing center director. Faculty and lower-level admins who believe the "AI is a tool" schtick are standing in their own graves with a shovel. This is not about "embracing the future" it's about replacing people with cheap clankers.
yes, yes YES to vaginal estrogen before you start the cycle of repeated UTIs!! The bacteria can dig in, and antibiotics are bad for your gut (and your sleep). Totally safe for women who had ER+ breast cancer, and I practice what I preach here. Game changer! Do it!
1/ Today marks five years since my appearance on Fox & Friends (first time on TV). Does not feel so long ago. It ultimately cost me my 20 year career at Harvard.
I spoke about why educators must be clear about the biology of sex and resist caving into the mob and sacrificing scientific accuracy.
My case is just one of many casualties of the sex and gender culture wars. If we want to restore trust in our institutions, a good place to start would be acknowledging what went wrong, and admitting that what happened to many of us was unjust, and a plan to ensure it doesn't happen again. www.foxnews.com/video/6265580505001
3/ Below is the only official statement issued by any Harvard administrator about what happened.
It was drafted by a larger group of administrators and co-signed by the chairs of Human Evolutionary Biology and Organismic & Evolutionary Biology. It was sent to hundreds of faculty, students, and staff after administrators—including the chair of OEB and the graduate student director of HEB’s DEI committee—publicly accused me of transphobia because of my views on the binary nature of sex.
One note: the DEI discussion series announced in this email never took place.
4/ While we should be aware of the power of our words, the idea that scholars (or anyone else) should take responsibility for people's reactions to them not only chills open inquiry, it is patronizing. Campus leaders must set the tone for colleagues and students alike: you may disagree; you may be deeply offended by what you hear. That's to be expected. It's an opportunity for curiosity, reflection, rational engagement, personal and intellectual growth. That's education.
I'm lucky to have a job with @AEI, which fosters that culture. Also grateful for an association with Harvard's psych department, thanks to Steve Pinker. And I'm working on my next book, which I'm excited about. It's still early stages, but more on that to come.
And thanks to those of you who've offered support. It helps me through the rough patches and keeps me going!
📢 Join me on August 6 at 1 p.m. ET for the next talk in the NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series, titled “The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It.”
I’ll be joined by Dr. Carole Hooven, a nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and an associate in Harvard University’s Department of Psychology. She’ll explore the biological basis of human sex differences and discuss their implications for scientific research, clinical medicine, athletics, and safety.
"It is essential to be able to accurately name sex when discussing fair sport, facilities and services for women and girls and the right of gay people not to be demonised for their same-sex attraction."
For the avoidance of doubt, I stand by every word I wrote then. For instance: ‘woman isn’t a costume.’ If it surprises you that I say men don’t become women by wearing make up and dresses, you didn’t understand the essay. I’ve been crystal clear all along that I believe people are free to live and present themselves as the opposite sex if that’s what feels comfortable and authentic TO THEM. This appears to have been interpreted (most often, tellingly, by men) as ‘and it naturally follows that I, as a woman, will validate a man’s belief that he is now, to all intents and purposes, the same sex as me, and I will use only the speech he deems appropriate and will be very careful to protect his sensitive ego, no matter the cost to myself in pretending to believe a falsehood, or the loss of my own rights due to this pretence.’
Dress as you like within normal bounds of situational decency, wear lipstick, sequins and a beard if you want, call yourself whatever you like, have sex with any consenting adult you please: I wish you health, happiness and safety. What you don’t get is the power to compel my speech and belief.
When I call a man a man, I am speaking verifiable truth. It is essential to be able to accurately name sex when discussing fair sport, facilities and services for women and girls and the right of gay people not to be demonised for their same-sex attraction. In years to come, a lot of useful idiots are going to awake to the fact that they’ve been complicit in enormous harm done to women, girls, gay people who stood against the insanity, and some extremely vulnerable young people. I don’t doubt we’ll hear a lot of, ‘I thought I was just being kind.’ Such individuals, especially those in positions of power, should be asked why they never had anything to say about the loud, public, widespread unkindness directed against those who refused to adopt their fashionable, elitist beliefs, eg, the detransitioners being bullied and vilified by former ‘allies’, the whistleblowers who tried to stop an unregulated experiment on troubled children, the women who lost their careers and livelihoods by standing up for all women’s rights.
Some people appear to believe it a worse crime for a woman to call a man a man than for trans activists to call loudly and publicly for the assault and assassination of all women who refuse to bend the knee. I have never wished violence or any other kind of harm on a trans-identified person, but, like many other people who’ve defended women’s and girls’ rights over the past few years, I have received thousands of threats of death, rape and torture. The wilful blindness of those who bleat ‘both sides’ will rightly be judged harshly in times to come.
TL;DR Trans women aren’t women, and if that hurts your feelings, be grateful you live in a society where you are just as free to espouse gender ideology as I am to speak the truth. As Orwell said: ‘Freedom is the freedom to say that two plus two make four. If that is granted, all else follows.’
😸🔪"Philosophy is full of alarming theses, like 'morality is bullshit.' That’s a very popular view among ethicists... But soon as you say there are two sexes and almost every human is either male or female, that becomes verboten." archive.ph/1HHCk
"I’ve seen people turn on professors and students that were once their friends and treat them as if they’d transformed into immoral monsters, deserving of only banishment or worse. I’ve felt that directed at me, my co-workers, and my friends. It creates a paranoia that everything can be stripped away from you if you make one wrong move, one wrong comment, one wrong joke. And once you transgress, you can be unpersoned into a caricature of societal evil, an object of scorn — no longer a real person, but an evil abstraction, sometimes a laughable cautionary tale."
Thanks @glukianoff for working to ensure it doesn't happen again.
Thanks Agustín for all the info, and for staying in the game! I looked again at your linked article (Beyond the Binary, The Compounding Complexity of Biological Sex, with @nathanlents), and took a stab at rewriting the third paragraph (I separated main points).
From your article:
"For almost two centuries, many biologists have used gametic sex (sex as it relates to gametes only) as a proxy for biological sex (sex as it relates to bodies, behaviors, populations, and species).
This use of gametes as the sole determinant of sex results in a perspective in which all animals seem to fit neatly into two categories, male or female, based only on which gamete they make. Because gametes are binary in animals, reliance on gametic sex often results in assumptions that the morphologies, behaviors, and strategies related to sex in animals are also best characterized as binary.
In our view, this binary classification of sex in animals is insufficient for capturing the full breadth of biological sexual diversity."
My rewrite:
sex is binary
In sexually reproducing animals, two sexes exist, male and female. Males produce small, mobile gametes and females produce large, immobile ones.
people misunderstand this
Some people may believe that if there are only two sexes, then sex-associated traits must also be binary; e.g., if you're a man you must have XY sex chromosomes, have high testosterone and be relatively aggressive; or if you're a woman you must have XX chromosomes, high estrogen and be nurturing. This belief is incorrect.
most everyone knows that sex-associated traits are not binary
Our view is the consensus view among biologists: the binary classification does not capture the full breadth of diversity within and between the sexes. But it does help us understand where it comes from.
we should be more clear about what the binary means, not less
When people are confused about scientific facts or their implications, we have a responsibility to be as clear as possible about those facts. What we should not do is create more confusion by denying, or appearing to deny, the basic facts that give us a shared starting point for understanding reality and discussing what it means (or should mean) for us humans.
of course people deserve respect, but that is not why I write about sex biology..that a binary view is limted is a biological argument and it's not "mine" it's shared by a lot of biolgists- have at least a look at this artcle and the bibliography www.prosocial.world/posts/beyond-the-binary-the-compoundi…
One of the most misunderstood lessons in statistics is that small average differences can produce large differences in real-world outcomes at the population/societal level.
As an example, when we compare men & women on behavioural, cognitive or psychological traits, the distributions usually overlap substantially. For most individual (univariate) traits, average differences are small, meaning most men & women are more similar than different.
However, prediction improves when we consider many traits simultaneously (multivariate space). A single measure may show extensive overlap, but combining many correlated traits can distinguish groups surprisingly well. This is why multivariate models often outperform any individual measure.
Averages also don’t tell us everything.
Many real world outcomes depend on the tail-ends of the distribution rather than the average. Elite sport, academia, and other highly selective fields draw from a small percentage of the population. Even a modest shift in the mean can produce MUCH larger differences in representation at the extremes.
A second principle is greater male variability (i.e., wider distribution compared to women’s narrower one). Even when average performance is similar, a wider male distribution means more men are represented at both the very highest and very lowest ends.
Together, these principles help explain why some elite occupations or achievements show larger sex differences in society than average scores would suggest. Men are overrepresented in fields such as chess, some areas of mathematics and physics, and many competitive sports. Women are overrepresented in occupations involving interpersonal engagement, including nursing, speech and language therapy, and many areas of education and psychology.
None of this means these differences are entirely biological. Culture, education, opportunity, discrimination and individual preferences all contribute. Nor does it imply that one sex is “better” than the other (“different” doesn’t mean “better”).
The statistical lesson is simply this:
Large differences at the extremes can arise from small average differences, and substantial overlap on individual traits does not rule out strong prediction when many traits are considered together.
One of a flurry of articles in the past couple of years on "aphantasia," a lack of mental imagery. Forty years ago the cognitive neursoscientist Martha Farah & I (while she was a postdoc with me at MIT) were perhaps the first to study such self-identified, neurologically intact people. We found they were 100% normal at tasks that clearly require visual images, e.g., What shape are a beagle's ears? Does the lower-case "H" stick up, hang down, or neitehr? What's darker, a Christmas tree or grass? (They were crushed to discover they were normal.) We concluded that the difference was in metacognition: They falsely assumed that everyone but them had photographic ("eidetic") imagery. We didn't publish our findings, but should have: the effect turns out to be highly replicable, raising the question of what "aphantasia" really is. nautil.us/what-a-picture-of-a-dog-has-to-do-with-reason-a…
Bias in academic hiring is trending but don’t forget after the ‘great social awakening’ a significant purge of established scholars took place, such as in my own field, policing 👇🏻 This is how progressive scholars treated longstanding colleagues of many years.
Cannot emphasize this enough. Academia has lost control of the conversation about itself and needs to grapple with public opinion, not explain, again, what it thinks public opinion would be if they only read the journals. (They will not read the journals.)
From "Sex, Medicine and Moralization" in Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. By @byrne_a and me in special issue edited @jflier, out this month.
"The dry scientific issue of the number and nature of the sexes was recast as a matter of justice, inclusion, validation, and harm prevention, with the outmoded binary position on the wrong side of history. The motives and character of those who defended the sex binary were—and still are—questioned by a prominent faction on the progressive left."
Examples of moralization from, respectively, Scientific American, American Scientist, and The Lancet:
"Given what we know about biology across animals and in humans, efforts to represent human sex as binary based solely on what gametes one produces are not about biology but are about trying to restrict who counts as a full human in society." (Fuentes 2023)
"Worryingly, even within the sciences, the term biological sex has become a transphobic dog whistle. Whereas once some of us used this term to differentiate the biological factors we study from social or cultural ones, it has now been co-opted by those who insist on a sex binary and who deny the relevance or even reality of diverse bodies and of gender identities, roles, and expressions in humans." (Clancy et al. 2024: 81)
"Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fueling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles." (Richardson 2025, 436)
Selective demands for rigor mean prestige academic presses are eager to bend over backwards to publish very poor, thin work as long as it has the right political vibe. Just use some creative formatting to make it look substantial and hand it off to uncritical reviewers who will reflexively greenlight it. It doesn't really matter how good the work is. The most important question is does this make us politically *feel good*?
And then there's the banal over the top praise that is de rigueur for books like this: "stunning," "brilliant," "deeply humane," "deeply heartfelt," "profound." I don't think anyone actually takes this praise seriously. But it signals the formation of consensus among right-thinking academic people, which is the purpose. Imprimaturs aren't just for the traditionally religious.
Lots of people think men evolved to pursue multiple mating with abandon, but that's probably not true; this strategy would likely backfire for many men.
For the average guy, aiming to mate with many women could end in them not reproducing at all.
“Around a third of liberal students think professors should be reported for saying that biological sex is a scientific fact, and that there are two sexes.”
Agustín, it does seem that you are dodging a simple but pertinent question. You have a book titled "Sex is a Spectrum." But you have said elsewhere that "humans have two sexes."
For some reason you seem unwilling to say publicly here on X that there are two and only two sexes. Why could you not say that, while also acknowledging the wide variation in sex-associated traits, and that one's sex does not itself mandate any specific policy or how people may express themselves?
Agustín, thanks for the reply. But my question was simply: Do you believe that there are exactly two sexes? I wasn't asking about the significance (or insignificance) of this issue, or whether more interesting discussions are elsewhere, or what your book is about. So—if you don't mind—what is the answer?
1/ There was a spasm of insanity that peaked in 2020 and 2021. I have friends who got fired. People tried to make me unemployable. There was never any real accountability in media and academia. Asking people to just move on isn't tenable.
Anthropologists would do their discipline’s reputation good if they signaled that they have no confidence in leaders who misrepresent colleagues in disciplinary debates. To understand humans, anthropologists must be able to understand the humans with whom they disagree.
"men are more aggressive than women...Even men tamed by modern society—men who'd never throw a punch in real life—watch more violent movies, play more violent video games, and have more fantasies about killing other people." swiftpress.com/book/a-billion-years-of-sex-differences/
Amazing interview with the head of the American Anthropological Association: "So the idea that there are two sexes is just factually incorrect, and to force biological anthropologists to teach that is the equivalent of turning an astronomy department into an astrology department. So I don’t know why we’re debating that. You may not like it. I don’t know, maybe you want to kill babies that aren’t just XX presenting XX or XY presenting XY"
1/ A new article in @Ecology_Letters by a group of evolutionary biologists—pioneers and leading experts on the evolution of sex. (The article is open access, short, and clear.)
"Biological sex is best defined as a binary classification of male and female reproductive strategies rooted in anisogamy, characterised by the production of two discrete gamete types of different sizes."
"We call for a more differentiated discourse on sex, one that separates the scientific conception of biological sex from societal discussions regarding the diversity of gender expressions and identities in humans."
2/ In 2021, after the publication of my book T: the Story of Testosterone, I said on Fox and Friends that there are two sexes, male and female, defined by whether we produce sperm or eggs. Shortly thereafter things became extremely difficult for me at Harvard (particularly in the ev bio department I'd taught in for ages), and I ended up leaving. Below is a link to my discussion with @convoswColeman about the science, about why I felt I had no choice but to leave my job.
Carolyn Rouse, Princeton Anthropology: "the idea that there are two sexes is just factually incorrect."
Agustín Fuentes, also Princeton Anthropology: "When I say sex is a spectrum, people think, ‘Oh three sexes, five sexes’, no, no, no. 𝐇𝐮𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐬 𝐡𝐚𝐯𝐞 𝐭𝐰𝐨 𝐬𝐞𝐱𝐞𝐬."
American Anthropological Association President Carolyn Rouse: "All you need to do is literally type into Google and see that we know, factually, that there are different types of 'sexes' and 'genders.' You can have XY and you present as a woman, you can have XXY — they’re all variations, genetic variations. So the idea that there are two sexes is just factually incorrect, and to force biological anthropologists to teach that is the equivalent of turning an astronomy department into an astrology department." h/t @robsica /1
American Anthropological Association President Carolyn Rouse: "All you need to do is literally type into Google and see that we know, factually, that there are different types of 'sexes' and 'genders.' You can have XY and you present as a woman, you can have XXY — they’re all variations, genetic variations. So the idea that there are two sexes is just factually incorrect, and to force biological anthropologists to teach that is the equivalent of turning an astronomy department into an astrology department." h/t @robsica /1
Carole Hooven y Alex Byrne argumentan en este artículo que no había ninguna necesidad científica de abandonar la visión tradicional binaria del sexo, como se ha hecho.
El artículo analiza cómo las tendencias culturales y la moralización (la idea de que ciertas posturas científicas son “buenas” o “malas” desde un punto de vista ideológico) han influido negativamente en la medicina y la academia. Según los autores, esto ha llevado a cambios en la terminología y las prácticas médicas (como el uso de expresiones como “sexo asignado al nacer” o la presentación del sexo como un espectro) que no responden a evidencia científica nueva, sino a presiones ideológicas.
Estos cambios, afirman, han perjudicado los estándares médicos, la claridad en la comunicación clínica y, en última instancia, la atención a los pacientes, especialmente en áreas relacionadas con el sexo y la medicina de género.
En esencia, el texto defiende que la ciencia del sexo debe mantenerse separada de consideraciones morales o políticas, y critica lo que consideran una politización de la biología y la medicina.
"What changed? There was no intellectual advance, no relevant discoveries in reproductive biology. No one in gender studies formulated a suddenly convincing case against the sex binary."
Sex differences are real, many are evolved, and they matter! Best of all, they are fascinating. This conversation between @ChrisWillx and @SteveStuWill nails the science, and makes it accessible and fun. If you like the convo, you'll love Steve's great new book, A Billion Years of Sex Differences. prfx.byspotify.com/e/pscrb.fm/rss/p/claritaspod.com/measu…
🤯 Listen to this extraordinary exchange between Camilla Tominey and Labour’s Health Secretary James Murray. It is genuinely jaw-dropping.
Camilla: “You’re quite pro-trans, aren’t you? Do you think a woman can have a penis? Because you did previously?”
Murray: “No, I don’t.”
Camilla: “So you’ve changed your mind?”
Murray: “Yes.”
Camilla: “Why?”
Murray stumbles. He says he’s been thinking about the issue over recent years and would not now say trans women are women.
Camilla hits back: “You must have known that before. You are very well educated. How on earth can you have previously thought that a woman can have a penis?”
He had no real answer. Because there isn’t one.
This is not some backbench MP. This is the Secretary of State for Health, the man responsible for the entire NHS, puberty blocker policy, women’s health services, and child safeguarding.
He spent years either believing or pretending to believe that biological sex is fluid and that women can have penises. Only now, when the Cass Review, court rulings, and public opinion have made that position politically toxic, has he magically “changed his mind”.
Think about the damage done while he held that view. The eroded women’s rights. The confused children fast-tracked toward hormones and surgery. The female prisoners and athletes forced to share spaces with biological males. All enabled or ignored by senior Labour figures like him.
This level of ideological delusion at the very top of government is not just embarrassing, it is dangerous. Basic biology should never have been up for debate, let alone something a Health Secretary had to “evolve” on.
Isn't twitter great? I watched this and enjoyed it very much, @byrne_a Alex Byrne (and his fantastic wife Carol) is one of the smartest people out there and I like him a lot. Imagine their dinner parties... best, D.A. NYC 🗽 ps - vape 'n puppy and Genspect interview on youtube. Perfect combination.😀
One of the most robust findings in human neuroscience is that males have 10–12% greater total brain volume than females (on average). This has been replicated across hundreds of MRI studies and large population cohorts.
The difference is substantial across tissue classes. In the UK Biobank dataset, males exhibited larger total brain volume, cortical surface area, grey matter volume, white matter volume, and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) volume. Mean differences in overall brain measures were typically 8–15%, whereas average cortical thickness was slightly greater in females.
Although body size explains part of the variance, the difference is not fully eliminated after adjustment for height, weight, lean body mass, or allometric scaling, suggesting that brain growth is, at least partly, an independently sexually dimorphic developmental process.
Developmental evidence strongly supports this. For instance, fetal MRI studies demonstrate that male fetuses already exhibit significantly larger intracranial and brain volumes by mid-gestation, before substantial divergence in height or weight. Similar findings have been reported in neonatal MRI cohorts and longitudinal developmental studies, indicating that sex differences in brain growth emerge prenatally and persist throughout development.
The difference also extends beyond gross anatomy. Using unbiased stereological methods, it’s been estimated that males possess approximately 23 billion neocortical neurons, compared with 19 billion in females (approximately 16% more cortical neurons). Males also exhibit 10% greater cortical surface area, consistent with the larger neuron count, whereas females tend to have slightly thicker cortex after correcting for brain size.
The prevailing mechanistic model is that sex chromosome complement and prenatal gonadal hormones interact to regulate early neurodevelopment. Experimental and clinical evidence suggests several complementary mechanisms:
• Sex chromosome effects: X- and Y-linked genes influence neurodevelopment independently of hormones. Studies of sex chromosomes show direct genetic effects on neural proliferation, regional brain growth, and developmental timing.
• Developmental scaling: Early prenatal differences are likely amplified during infancy and adolescence through sexually dimorphic trajectories of cortical surface-area expansion, white-matter maturation, myelination, synaptic pruning, and intracranial growth.
Taken together, the evidence suggests that males and females follow partially distinct neurodevelopmental growth trajectories, beginning before birth and driven by interacting genetic and endocrine mechanisms, rather than brain size simply scaling as a passive consequence of adult body size.
Importantly, these findings should not be conflated with cognitive ability. Brain volume correlates only modestly with intelligence
Fundamentally what people (pretend to?) miss is that the female category is a *sex* category, not a *perfomance* category. Its *existence*, qua category, is partially justified by perfomance differences (M/F), but its eligibility conditions are based on sex, not performance.
"[S]tarting down the road of judicially managed individualized exemptions based on physical capabilities of individual athletes could fundamentally undermine women’s and girls’ sports..."
SCOTUS: "The term 'sex' in the 1972 Title IX statute, the 1974 Javits Amendment, and the 1975 Title IX regulations cannot plausibly be interpreted to refer to anything other than biological sex."
Me: One cannot charitably credit them with trying to restore academic freedom in universities. The extreme assault by the Trump administration on parts of Harvard had nothing to do with the suppression of speech, such as in the science and engineering departments. The agenda is really to cripple civil society organizations that might be centers of opposition, in the same way they had gone after the media, after law firms, and after other branches of government.
Kmele Foster (@kmele) of @wethefifth: If I was going to try to sort of steelman the position of people on the right, they would say: you already lost a lot of those institutions in the sciences proper. You mentioned Nature earlier and the fact that they weren’t unwilling to publish certain things that were inconvenient to them with respect to their political convictions. Does that not justify the Trump administration kind of taking a much harder line?
Me: Well, no. Among the legitimate functions of government stipulated in the Constitution, policing scientific journals is not one of them. But in any case, it wasn’t as if they singled out research projects at Harvard that flouted standards of scientific excellence by prioritizing political correctness over truth. It was an across-the-board zeroing of funding.
Once you become a parent nothing is ever quite the same again, including the brain. These changes begin before the baby is even born, and are still traceable decades later. Explore the brain through the stages of pregnancy and postpartum with our 3D model. Find out more on whether being induced leads to more unwanted medical intervention: econ.st/4xyXJ2Q
"Mothers invested more in direct care and domestic support, bonding and emotional support, social, moral...[lots of other stuff] mating, relationship, wisdom and life guidance. Fathers invested more in athletics and physical training, as well as mechanical and practical skills."
This is a pretty good overview of the main points inThe Sense of Style. (It also has a chapter on "Telling Right from Wrong" -- how to think about prescriptive rules like dangling participles and lie vs lay.)
"men are more willing than women to take risks. Almost by definition, this means a higher chance of great success, but also a higher chance of catastrophic failure...men start more new businesses than women...they succeed more and fail more than women" swiftpress.com/book/a-billion-years-of-sex-differences/
1/ "In the early [1800s], the prevailing idea about how the testes conferred masculine traits was that they worked through the “sympathies,”.. (And the name has lasted—today, the “rest and digest” functions fall under the “parasympathetic” branch of the nervous system, and the…
Listen to this smart woman. It’s why the silent majority is not being heard right now. But history shows us this over & over, yet still we haven’t learnt.
Every university says it supports academic freedom and due process. None are willing to restore the scholars they drove out when doing so was popular.
This is one of the central tests universities continue to avoid. If institutions want the public to believe they have changed, it is not enough to issue statements about academic freedom. Academics who were punished, sidelined, or pushed out for expressing lawful views must be restored and made whole.
Until that happens, claims of reform are difficult to take seriously. I have seen little evidence that universities are willing to revisit these cases or acknowledge the mistakes that were made.
Dear Harvard: It's not too late to right the wrong done to Carole Hooven. Please invite her to return to her teaching post at the University. Not only would it rectify an injustice, it would send a signal that Harvard honors academic freedom and intellectual integrity and no longer caves to mobs.
@hoovlet in her fantastic book, “T: The Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us” lists several behaviours that are driven by testosterone:
1) Aggression and dominance: T promotes competitive, status-seeking, and aggressive behaviors. T is “evolution’s tool to help male animals convert energy into offspring, which often requires aggression.”
2) Risk-taking: Men show greater willingness for physical risks, thrill-seeking, and heroic actions (e.g., ~90% of Carnegie Hero Medals for extreme life-saving risks go to men). This ties to competition and mating effort.
3) Libido and sexual behavior: Stronger drive, interest in sexual novelty/partners, and related motivations.
4) Motivation and energy: Broader effects on ambition, competitiveness, muscle/power-related drive, and overall behavioral activation. T influences threat processing in the brain.
UPDATE: @NASA can confirm a fireball over New England at 2:06 p.m. EDT on Saturday, May 30, 2026. The meteor was about 5 feet (1.6 meters) in diameter with a mass of 5.6 metric tons and entered Earth’s atmosphere at roughly 42,000 mph.
The meteor traveled through the atmosphere from northwest to southeast for 26 miles before breaking up at an altitude of 31 miles and producing a meteorite fall into Cape Cod Bay.
Based on the latest data, the energy released at breakup is estimated to be equivalent to about 230 tons of TNT, which accounts for the sonic boom.
#meteorsighting: Eyewitnesses in New England and @NOAA’s GOES-19 satellite reported a bright fireball on Saturday, May 30, at 2:06 p.m EDT accompanied by a loud noise. The meteor appears to have fragmented at an altitude of 40 miles over northeast MA and southeast NH. The energy released at breakup is estimated to be equivalent to about 300 tons of TNT, which accounts for the loud noise.
Eyewitness accounts supplied by the American Meteor Society.
BREAKING: We can confirm that it was an EXPLODING METEOR that produced a sonic boom over eastern Massachusetts and much of Southern New England at 2:07 p.m. Eastern time.
It was cloudy, so there weren't reliable reports. The American Meteor Society has logged several reports of the boom.
United States Geological Survey data confirms it was NOT an earthquake.
The GOES East weather satellite has a geostationary lightning mapper that can detect infrared light emissions. At 2:07 p.m., it plotted a line of simultaneous lightning strikes in a 50 mile-long line. That would be highly unusual for lightning. While there was lightning south of Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket, this was NOT the correct region of the overall storm for lightning, nonetheless a 50 mile-long stretch of it, to occur.
As such, we are comfortable calling this an EXPLODING METEOR. The satellites detected the infrared light emissions.
A few fragments likely fell to earth, but we're reviewing additional eyewitness data and radar data to determine the exact trajectory. (If it was moving southbound as it exploded, then a spattering of fragments probably fell on the Cape.)
Such a pleasure and honor to share the stage yesterday (May 27) with these thinkers (@slsatel, @byrne_a, @CHSommers & @ImHardcory), discussing whether science (and perhaps most everything else) has become "feminized." Check it out at @LeorSapir's link below.
"Many argue that it’s sexist to say, for example, that women are more parental than men, or that women are more interested in working with people and less interested in working with things. But the accusation can be turned on its head."
Breaking news: Harvard faculty votes to cap the number of A's awarded in course grades, a big step in combatting the grade inflation that has been dumbing down our courses, conveying the wrong message to students, and making universities a national laughingstock.
Meanwhile. far from the frontlines of the culture wars, an astonishing shift has taken place in fatherhood. The gender gap in both paid AND unpaid has closed by 4 hours just since 2019. New research at @aibm_org by Ari Binder: aibm.org/research/the-gender-convergence-restarts-led-by-…
Jon Haidt @jonhaidt is one of the greatest psychologists of the 21st century, having illuminated moral cognition, the relation between emotion and intellect, the perils of politicization and viewpoint homogeneity in social science, and the roots of the youth mental health decline. That NYU students should protest this wise and brilliant man as their commencement speaker is a backhand vindication of his diagnosis of what's wrong in higher ed. Our sometimes coauthor @PamelaParesky explains: Reports of The Death of 'Woke' May Be Greatly Exaggerated www.realcleareducation.com/articles/2026/05/17/reports_of…
Thanks for this episode. Your criticisms of Olson-Kennedy and Chen et al. 2023 were spot-on. The HHS gender dysphoria review discusses Chen et al. in detail. (section 6.2.3). However, you also say that the names of authors were only released "under pressure from critics.” This is not correct. The release of the names was planned from the beginning. More seriously, you say that the authors have "known biases." I am one of them, and would not have agreed to take part if I had thought my co-authors were biased. You don’t give any evidence for the charge of bias, though. If the authors have biases, then these should be visible in the review itself: it should have errors, omissions, misleading claims, etc. In your opinion, are there any problems with the review?
When the people trained to communicate stop communicating, what does that say about the moment we’re in?
Across campuses, the line between scholarship and activism is increasingly blurred — raising deeper questions about the role of ideas, debate, and dissent.
"Mothers provide most direct care, & most socially oriented forms of investment (guidance, emotional support, etc). Fathers provide most physical training, & mechanical skills, & bias this investment toward sons." @CostelloWilliam
1/ 🧵 "SEX BIASES IN PATTERNS OF PARENTAL INVESTMENT"- My latest publication in Human Nature, w labmate @CostelloWilliam & supervisor @ProfDavidBuss Mother-father investment differences aren’t just “mothers do more.” They vary by domain, as do biases toward daughters vs sons...
"For reading and science as personal strengths, they found larger sex differences in more gender equal nations - an example of a common phenomenon known as the gender-equality paradox, and a decisive refutation of the social-constructionist view."
"Any of the consequential problems now addressed by Harvard's committees lack the fuller context required to make the necessary changes. Hence, a broader investigation, similar to Yale’s, would be well-timed for the University." Well done @thecrimson. www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/4/29/editorial-harvard-co…
First a review article, then a book, now a book review—Alex Byrne chronicles the latest surprise rejection of his writing in the philosophy of sex and gender.
"My struggles were less a product of biological certainty and more a messy overlap of environment, temperament, and choice. I have had to learn to be comfortable with that ambiguity."
I was 30 in 2019 when stories of women discovering they were autistic all along began appearing everywhere.
They popularized a newer understanding of autism, with its own “female presentation.” It was framed as a scientific correction to a historical wrong against women, the kind of narrative the press finds irresistible.
Like so many women, I felt immense relief when I was formally diagnosed. It offered an explanation for the mental health crises of my youth and the daily realities of my adult life.
Then I spent a year in the online autism community. What I saw there, especially the way activists treated parents of severely impaired children, turned me into a critic of neurodiversity.
But it was becoming a journalist in 2022, after discovering detransitioners’ stories, that forced me to question narratives about identity and diagnosis, including my own. Journalism also required the social skills autism says I should have lacked.
From there, the rest unraveled: many traits I had come to associate with autism are not uncommon in the general population, but through the “female autism” framework, they looked like a meaningful pattern.
I don’t think my story is unique. The same incentives that kept my diagnosis intact may also help explain why so many women are entering the autism category in adulthood.
Sex differences in reading vs. science as personal academic strengths are larger in more gender-equal nations - the opposite of what we’d expect if the differences were due to strict gender roles or patriarchy.
Linguistic prescription is authoritarian. It’s one of the things trans activists have used, with enormous success. Seeking to control what people are allowed to say is a hallmark of cults and totalitarian regimes.
I do not subscribe to the post modern ideas that changing language changes reality, that redefining something alters its nature, that our conception of a thing is of more importance than observable facts about the thing itself. To me, this kind of thinking is a dead end full of people pontificating and obfuscating, enjoying the sounds of their own voices while the world burns outside.
Some gender critical people seem to think that demanding we all use correct sex pronouns will return the world to sanity. This is an attempt to make the tail wag the dog. You cannot fight linguistic prescription with more linguistic prescription, and no rights campaign can succeed if its adherents are more interested in creating a purity spiral than allowing the smallest space for nuance or for the complexities of human nature and feelings.
Many campuses have become intolerant of views that, not long ago, were considered mainstream. That’s a serious problem, but one that can be fixed with more openness, curiosity, and genuine debate. If you’re in Canada or the UK, watch @speechlessfilm, which explores exactly this issue. 🇨🇦 Canada: CBC Gem @cbcgem or www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Psrh_W_Ew0 🇬🇧 UK: BBC iPlayer @BBCiPlayer Featuring @Rhetors_of_York@hoovlet@Docstockk and more.
"With greater intellectual diversity, and particularly a greater conservative presence, we might better protect our mission of seeking truth (veritas) from a gradual shift towards a greater focus on political activism." By Tyler J. VanderWeele, one of my heroes.
New: @jonkay interviews Ric Esther Bienstock, the creator of "Speechless," the new BBC documentary about the last decade of free speech controversies on university campuses www.youtube.com/watch?v=ikWC6-IHua4
Today we're celebrating a win for academic freedom in England. If you're wondering why universities lost sight of such a foundational value in the last ten years, I'd recommend watching this documentary.
"We should also explore sex differences through the lens of intraindividual strengths rather than limiting analysis to traditional mean scores. Shifting to this perspective could have profound implications for understanding modern phenomena, such as the persistent underrepresentation of women in STEM fields."
Men and women show different relative cognitive strengths across their lifespans | Eric W. Dolan, PsyPost
A recent study published in the Journal of Intelligence provides evidence that men and women tend to possess different relative cognitive strengths, which may help explain why women remain underrepresented in certain scientific and technical fields. The research suggests that when comparing an individual’s skills against their own personal average, women generally show a relative strength in reading, while men show a relative strength in math. These patterns remain consistent across different countries and age groups, offering a new way to understand career choices.
Scientists Marco Balducci and Waseem Haider conducted the study to explore why the gender gap persists in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) careers. Past research on cognitive abilities has typically focused on average test scores, which calculate how well men or women perform compared to each other.
These average differences tend to be very small and fail to explain why large disparities exist in technical professions. Because of this, the researchers wanted to look at a different metric called intraindividual strengths.
Intraindividual strengths measure a person’s abilities compared to their own overall performance, rather than comparing them to the general population. For example, a person might be good at both math and reading, but if their math score is higher than their personal average across all subjects, math is their primary intraindividual strength.
This concept is grounded in expectancy-value theory, a psychological framework suggesting that people choose careers based on what they expect to be best at. According to this idea, a student whose personal best subject is math will likely pursue a technical field, while someone whose personal best is reading might choose an interpersonal profession.
“In my previous research, I analyzed sex differences in intraindividual strengths in high school students, finding very interesting patterns. Overall, girls had an intraindividual strengths in reading while boys had strengths in mathematics or science. However, it remained unclear whether the findings were limited to this specific age group or if they persisted across the lifespan,” explained Balducci, a senior researcher at the University of Turku.
For their new study, the scientists analyzed data from the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies. This large international survey evaluates the cognitive and workplace skills of adults in everyday situations.
The researchers used a final sample of exactly 157,189 individuals from 30 different countries. They divided these participants into five specific age groups: 16 to 24, 25 to 34, 35 to 44, 45 to 54, and 55 and older.
The survey measured skills in three main areas. Literacy evaluated text interpretation and comprehension, while numeracy assessed the capacity to interpret and use mathematical information. Finally, problem-solving measured the ability to use digital tools to perform practical tasks.
The scientists first calculated the average scores for men and women across these three domains. They then calculated the intraindividual strengths by finding each person’s overall average score across all three tests. They subtracted this personal baseline from each specific subject score to see which domain stood out as a relative advantage.
When looking at the standard average scores, the researchers found almost no differences between men and women in literacy and problem-solving. Men performed slightly better in numeracy on average, but the difference was very small.
However, when looking at intraindividual strengths, a completely different pattern emerged. Women consistently demonstrated an intraindividual strength in literacy, while men demonstrated a strength in numeracy. These differences in personal strengths were about twice as large as the differences found in standard average scores. They were also remarkably consistent across all 30 countries analyzed in the dataset.
“We had anticipated the general direction of the findings based on previous research, but the results were still striking,” Balducci told PsyPost. “The disparity between sex differences in mean scores and those in intraindividual strengths was even more pronounced than in our previous analyses.”
The researchers also discovered that these patterns did not change as people grew older. From young adulthood to the age of 55 and beyond, women consistently maintained their relative advantage in literacy, and men maintained theirs in numeracy.
There were no significant differences between men and women when it came to problem-solving as a personal strength. The researchers noted a strong connection at the country level, finding that larger relative literacy strengths in women matched larger relative numeracy strengths in men.
“Sex differences are significantly more pronounced when measured as intraindividual strengths rather than using traditional mean scores,” Balducci summarized. “While differences in mean scores tend to be smaller and highly variable, intraindividual strengths are generally two to three times larger and remarkably consistent across both countries and age groups.”
“In practice, our study reinforces the argument that we should also explore sex differences through the lens of intraindividual strengths rather than limiting analysis to traditional mean scores. Shifting to this perspective could have profound implications for understanding modern phenomena, such as the persistent underrepresentation of women in STEM fields.”
While these patterns provide evidence for a potential factor behind the gender gap in technical fields, the researchers caution against certain misinterpretations. The most common mistake is assuming that group-level trends apply to every single individual.
Although women tend to have personal strengths in literacy at the population level, many individual women possess strong personal strengths in math. The scientists warn against using these findings to stereotype individual abilities or career potential.
“I would urge readers to always remain mindful of the specific level of analysis and avoid attributing group-level trends to individuals,” Balducci said.
The study also comes with limitations related to how the skills were measured. The literacy assessment only evaluated reading comprehension and did not include a writing component, which might involve different cognitive processes. Because the test was relatively low stakes, participants might not have put in their maximum effort, which could influence the results.
The researchers plan to expand on this line of research. “Building on the results of this and other studies, I intend to extend the concept of intraindividual strengths to broader cognitive domains,” Balducci said. “This would help determine whether the patterns we found are a widespread phenomenon across human abilities or are strictly limited to academic skills.”
“This study draws on data from over 157,000 individuals across 30 countries, which we believe gives particular weight to the consistency of the findings. More broadly, this is an area of research that would benefit from being evaluated on empirical grounds, and we hope the scientific conversation around these questions can, at some point, be driven more by data rather than prior ideological assumptions, from any direction.”
Excellent pair of documentaries directed by Ric Esther Bienstock - 'Speechless' - focusing on threats to essential components of academia and democracy: free speech and debate. Powerful interviews include @Docstockk and @hoovlet. Starts with Evergreen campus 2017 and ends with current campus protests. Good to see BBC Storyville broadcasting this commission. Time well spent. www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002v2w6
This is an extraordinary piece of work - one of those featured is Carole Hooven, the Harvard evolutionary biologist who lost her job for saying sex is real ...
Getting to chat about evolutionary psychology and my silly little polls on one of the biggest podcasts in the world with some friends I admire the fuck out of…
"A lot of opposition to Pinker [@sapinker]...derives from people who buy into blank-slateism. ...“progressives” tend to be on the side of seeing differences between people as due very largely to environmental influences. This derives from a Marxist view of people as generally malleable, so that any genetic effect on differences should be ignored, minimized, or even demonized." whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/04/17/more-pinker-dissing-at-…
Large (N=67k) research by Aavik et al finds average men’s sexual desire is substantially higher ;and more stable) than women’s throughout most of the adult life span—peak average ♀ sex drive (age 20-30) is lower than ♂ (<60) average levels:
Thank you, sir. Carole Hooven's book, Testosterone: The Story of the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us, is published by Hachette: www.hachette.co.uk/titles/carole-hooven-2/testosterone/97… :: You can purchase paperback, eBook, or audio formats from amazon.co.uk, Waterstones, bookshop.org UK, and Blackwell’s. Prices range from approximately £3 for Kindle to £13 for paperback.
“I don’t like the ‘woke’ culture on many campuses or how it has restricted what views can be expressed and harmed student learning. But a blanket ban on certain views and research is not the answer. It’s just another kind of ideological capture.”
Finally finally finally … a proper BBC docco about (some of) what happened back then. It’s taken till 2026. The two big books that won the argument came out in 2021: Stock’s “Material Girls” and Joyce’s “Trans”. I’m assuming delay nothing to do with trans lobby inside BBC 🤓
This is an extraordinary piece of work - one of those featured is Carole Hooven, the Harvard evolutionary biologist who lost her job for saying sex is real ...
Egg quality declines with age too. As she ages, a woman’s eggs lose their ability to maintain the correct number of chromosomes. This is because of a decline in proteins that ensure their correct segregation during egg cell division, as shown 👇
Important new finding: For decades there's been abundant evidence for the existence, importance, & heritability of "general intelligence" (despite massive denial in journalism, ed schools, and among intellectual-cultural elites). That is: if you're above average in verbal skills, you're likelier to be above average in math, memory, spatial reasoning, & everything else, & genes are a major (though not the only) reason. But are specific cognitive abilities (verbal, math, etc., separate from g) also heritable? Massive new meta-analysis says yes. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289622000708
🎁 "By 2018, the clusters were occupying different parts of the forest. Then the killing started, and it has not stopped since. [There have been] 28 deaths among the Ngogo apes, including those of 19 infants. The numbers far exceed anything seen before among chimpanzees."
1/ The ovary is the fastest-aging organ in the female body. And almost no one is studying why.I just sat down with @BBParis1984 (@USCLeonardDavis ), who runs one of the only labs in the world mapping ovarian aging. A few things from our conversation I can't stop thinking about:
As a huge fan of this platform, I can't help noticing that the noise to signal ratio here has deteriorated. Monetisation has created an incentive structure that is conducive to neither authentic discussion nor quality content.
Caraballo proceeds, utterly predictably, to act out exactly the kind of behavior that created the chill. Anyone who disagrees, anyone who questions, is a transphobe, a right-wing conspiracist, or otherwise an evil un-person.
I know that still works on some people. But it doesn’t work on me. And it can’t continue to work on people who study issues the public cares about. Because if the public knows, and they surely do know, that experts are terrified of pissing off a political constituency, they will never trust them to be objective about any fact.
It’s an old friend’s birthday today, guy I text every year without needing to be reminded. Went to his Facebook to see how he’s doing, realized he blocked me on every platform.
He’s a clarinet player I went to college with, we admired and pushed each other. We were Tanglewood fellows too, he even flew to my parents’ house in Jersey the night before and we roadtripped up to Massachusetts together. When we got principal jobs in major orchestras we celebrated each other’s wins, as friendly rivals do. My old photo albums are full of pictures of us together.
I shouldn’t be sad or surprised because this has happened so many times, but it still stings. I admire Trump’s ability to turn on disloyal people but that’s not in my nature, I have that “sensitive young man” thing that makes me a good musician. I’m more used to it now than I was before but it never goes away completely.
It’s true I have much better friends now and it’s good to let “soul contracts” expire but social death is not for the faint of heart. Hopefully someday we’ll all look back on this stupid period of social history with great disdain. I’m optimistic we’ll find a better way, that’s one thing I haven’t lost.
"God bless all of you, all of you on the good Earth." One of my fondest childhood memories: the balletic launch, the moving message to all of humanity, the most beautiful photograph ever taken. www.nytimes.com/card/2026/04/01/science/space/nasa-moon-a…
A small number of criminals commit the vast majority of crimes. One famous study found that just “1% of the population [is] accountable for 63% of all violent crime convictions.”
If pornography isn't something many people are willing to talk about openly, we are missing a huge part of the conversation about what’s impacting our young men and boys. I'm grateful that @oso and the team at @aibm_org are undertaking this crucial responsibility by beginning rigorous research on pornography and its effects on young men.
Seems like a good time to re-post my older (now edited) post about athletes with XY DSDs (Disorder, or Difference of Sex Development). Lots of graphs and detail about the relevant biology at the end.
* * * First: People living with DSDs should be treated with compassion and understanding, and receive any heath care they need. These can be challenging conditions for individuals and their families. But when male athletes have DSDs that give them an advantage over females, and they compete in the female category, this raises concerns about safety and fairness, and forces discussion of the relevant physical traits.
Athletes with XY DSDs who have testes (usually internal), XY sex chromosomes, male-typical levels of testosterone, and functional androgen receptors are often described as females with "hyperandrogenism," i.e., abnormally high levels of testosterone. They experience physical benefits of this high testosterone during puberty, which translate into athletic advantages over females. The issue for sports is that athletes with the XY DSD 5-alpha reductase deficiency (5-ARD), may be socialized as female, may be legally female, and may live and identify as female; but they are male.
These individuals are usually born with female-appearing genitalia, which can lead to being sexed as female. Here's why. 5-ARD is caused by a mutation in the gene that codes for the enzyme 5-alpha reductase, which converts testosterone into a more potent androgen, DHT. This androgen interacts with the androgen receptor, like testosterone, and is necessary for the typical development of male external genitalia (penis and scrotum) and the prostate. Without DHT, female-typical external genitalia develop. At the end of this monster post is a graphic of the relevant steroid production pathway, from my book T: The story of Testosterone.
DHT is also responsible for male-pattern baldness and dark, coarse facial hair, which is why people with the condition have smooth skin that can give a feminine appearance.
The “decision makers” are aware that athletes with 5-ARD are male, and that they experience the benefits of male puberty. The requirement to reduce their testosterone to typical female levels isn’t discriminatory, since these are males who are asking to compete in the female category. But more significantly, all the relevant scientific evidence shows that reducing male T in adulthood does not undo the physical benefits of male puberty.
Here's more detail about T, DHT, and male advantage in strength and speed.
I've been asked if men with the DSD 5-ARD (in which ppl cannot convert testosterone into the more potent androgen DHT) experience the typical benefits of male puberty, that would give them an advantage in strength and speed relative to women. This is relevant to questions about whether male athletes with 5-ARD should be allowed to compete in the female category. This is an excellent question, because it could be the case that DHT is necessary for the development and maintenance of male-typical muscle, lean body mass and strength. If that were the case, then people with 5-ARD might not have a typical male advantage, because the lack of DHT would perhaps lead to a more feminine pattern of fat, lean body mass and strength. I've wondered about this myself and have looked into the evidence.
Perhaps the top researcher in this area, Shalendar Bhasin, who is scrupulous in his methods, has examined this very question. The answer appears to be: no, testosterone does not need to be converted to DHT to exert its typical anabolic effects. These findings are reported in his 2012 study, "Effect of Testosterone Supplementation With and Without a Dual 5α-Reductase Inhibitor on Fat-Free Mass in Men With Suppressed Testosterone Production, A Randomized Controlled Trial." (It is linked to below—and since it's paywalled, I've included the graphs that show comparisons between the placebo and DHT— inhibited conditions, with no difference on the various outcomes.)
For more detail, the investigators wanted to examine the effects of suppressing DHT on muscle mass, strength, and sexual function. This important because one of the treatments for benign prostatic hyperplasia and male-pattern baldness is to suppress DHT, but clinicians have been concerned about effects on other outcomes that affect health and quality of life. Participants (healthy men, 18 to 50, with normal T levels) had their T blocked, and were given graded doses of T, along with either placebo or a drug that blocked the conversion of T to DHT. So both groups had T, but only one, the placebo group, also had DHT. After 20 weeks of treatment, changes in lean body mass, muscle, and strength were assessed. There were no significant difference between the placebo and DHT-blocked groups in these outcomes.
For LOTS more detail, here's the relevant text from the results. Please don't ask me questions about the study. Just look at the abstract and results which you can find by Googling. The main point is that while there are predicted effects of the different doses of T received, there were no differences in the outcomes according to whether they had DHT blocked (with dutasteride) or not (placebo). "Fat-Free Mass Fat-free mass and lean body mass increased in a dose-dependent manner in the placebo and dutasteride [THIS IS THE DRUG THAT BLOCKS CONVERSION OF T TO DHT] groups (Figure 2).
The changes in fat-free mass were related to testosterone dose and changes in testosterone concentrations in the placebo and dutasteride groups but did not differ between groups; the dose-adjusted mean difference (placebo minus dutasteride) in fat-free mass was 0.50 kg (95% CI, −0.22 to 1.22 kg; P = .18). There was no significant interaction between testosterone dose and randomization to dutasteride or placebo, indicating a lack of evidence that the relationship of testosterone dose to change in fat-free mass differed between the dutasteride and placebo groups.
The model-based smoothed regression lines, obtained by generalized additive models, describing the relationship between changes in testosterone concentrations and changes in fat-free mass and lean body mass were similar in the placebo and dutasteride groups. Changes in fat mass were negatively related to testosterone dose and concentrations, but the relationship between change in fat mass and dose did not differ significantly between the placebo and dutasteride groups (P = .41; Figure 2)."
"Muscle strength Leg-press and chest-press strength increased dependently by dose in the placebo and dutasteride groups. Increases in leg-press and chest-press strength were greater with larger doses and higher concentrations of testosterone. These relationships did not differ between the placebo and dutasteride groups (Figure 2)."
Really interesting commentary from the authors on the role of DHT in adult men: "Why then did the steroid 5α-reductase system evolve for androgens? Forty-six XY males with steroid 5α-reductase deficiency exhibited ambiguous or female external genitalia at birth and poor prostate development, but underwent normal muscle and bone development during pubertal transition. The phenotype of these patients suggests that steroid 5α-reductase plays an essential role in the development of prostate and phallus by providing local amplification of an androgenic signal without systemic hyperandrogenemia during critical periods of sexual differentiation, illustrating nature's extraordinary ingenuity in creating mechanisms for tissue-selective amplification during development.
We speculate that in adult men, in whom this tissue-specific amplification is not essential because the circulating testosterone concentrations are substantially higher than those in the fetus, testosterone and DHT can interchangeably subserve many androgenic functions. When circulating testosterone concentrations are low, intraprostatic DHT formation may become important in maintaining prostate growth, thus buffering the effects of decreasing testosterone levels, which has been suggested by Marks et al.
Our data are consistent with studies that have reported no effects of 5α-reductase inhibitors on muscle or bone mass. Inferences from these trials are limited by the fact that administration of 5α-reductase inhibitors increases testosterone levels, rendering it difficult to ascribe the outcomes to differences in DHT levels alone. In our trial, inhibition of endogenous testosterone by administration of a gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist eliminated this problem. Additionally, the high-dose dutasteride regimen effectively inhibited both steroid 5α-reductase isoenzymes."
Our next event is on April 6, with @Ayjchan, author (with @mattwridley) of Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19, and recently at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard.
"Without gametes as the universal defining trait, 'male' and 'female' lose all cross-taxon coherence and become nothing more than meaningless labels attached to shifting bundles of correlates." Impressive clarity and restraint on the part of @SwipeWright.
"In the early 1970s, then, Trivers was standing on the shoulders of giants, looking with a gimlet eye over a rich array of poorly explained animal behaviour (not excluding humans, since he had recently binged on novels). In this virgin landscape, the implications of the overlapping conflicts of genetic interests were waiting to be discovered, foreshadowed in scattered passages from Hamilton and Williams. Someone had to see them first, and Trivers was there."
Floored (but not surprised) by @sapinker's tribute to Robert Trivers. Pinker captures the profound significance of Trivers' insights with effortless grace. It's unsentimental, deeply affecting, insightful and informative, and one of the best pieces of writing I’ve read in a long time. (And lots of excellent links.) Worth the @Quillette subscription! quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
'In an astonishing creative burst from 1971 to 1975, Trivers wrote five seminal essays that invoked patterns of genetic overlap to explain each of the major human relationships: male with female, parent with child, sibling with sibling, partner with partner, and a person with himself or herself.
The fallout for science was vast. The fields of sociobiology, evolutionary psychology, behavioural ecology, and Darwinian social science are largely projects that test Trivers’s hypotheses. The ideas took pride of place in E. O. Wilson’s Sociobiology in 1975, Richard Dawkins’s The Selfish Gene in 1976, and many other bestsellers in the next three decades such as Robert Wright’s The Moral Animal (1994) and my own How the Mind Works (1997) and The Blank Slate (2002). In 2007 the ideas earned Trivers the Crafoord Prize, the equivalent of a Nobel for fields not recognised by Nobels.'
Book reviews by philosophers, notoriously, can be scathing, but a sober review of a book on gender identity by the MIT philosopher (and Academic Freedom Council co-founder) Alex Byrne was deemed too dangerous to print. "The philosophy profession has shown itself to be an institution of fragile integrity when put to the test. One can only hope spines will eventually stiffen, and academic law and order is restored." philosophersmag.com/on-being-rejected/
Philosophy welcomes brutal book reviews. That is, unless they are critical of gender orthodoxy. @byrne_a's killed (invited) review is a case in point. Despite appearances, he is not taking his latest rejection sitting down. philosophersmag.com/on-being-rejected/
"Rigorous research on sex-based variation remains vital. It also challenges simplistic and harmful ideologies of the sex binary.” Translation: since what we already know causes harm, we need more research to show why it’s wrong. Plenty of people make weak arguments about science to push a particular social agenda. The bigger problem is the legitimacy that scientific journals lend them. @Evolutionistrue@SwipeWright whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/03/16/another-journal-drinks-…
I agree with this assessment: Trivers explained "the many roots of our suffering" in his analysis of the inherent conflicts of interest in even our most intimate relationships: parent and offspring, sibling and sibling, husband and wife, partner and partner, and the inner and outer domains of the self. All these ideas from a burst of papers (in one case, from a few sentences in a foreword) in the mid-1970s. The implications for the social sciences, and the humanities, are profound.
For decades, scientists were above reproach. Not any more. Joe Nocera investigates the murky world of fraudulent research, and the sleuths exposing dishonest science.
If you want to understand marketing, study evolutionary biology.
Start with Testosterone by Dr Carole Hooven: @hoovlet
Human behaviour makes more sense when you understand that humans are status-seeking primates running an operating system shaped by thousands of generations of survival in much harsher environments than the modern world.
Testosterone explains why status, competition and hierarchy show up so consistently across human cultures.
Status-seeking behaviours are biological, but shaped by culture. People want to move up the ladder — what counts as 'status' changes by market.
Risk tolerance differs on average between men and women. Messaging that emphasises upside, competition or bold claims may resonate differently than messaging centred on trust, security and reliability.
Testosterone amplifies ambition and status striving. Younger men and competitive audiences often respond strongly to messaging about performance, mastery and winning.
Status signalling drives consumption. People buy for utility — but also for what a product says about them.
Hierarchy matters. Humans constantly scan for signals of authority and competence. This is why testimonials, customer logos and market leadership claims work.
Great products often double as status signals. Tools that make users look smarter, faster or more capable tend to sell faster.
Founders signal status. Vision, confidence and authority increase trust in early-stage products.
'Winning' is a powerful narrative. Markets often reward companies that position themselves as category leaders.
Evolutionary psychology still drives modern behaviour. The brain buying your SaaS product was shaped through survival in punishing savannahs and ice ages.
Testosterone is also entertaining, funny and extremely well-written. Highly recommended.
🚨ALERT: Top-ranking ecology journal Ecology Letters has published a "Viewpoint" paper titled "There is No Consensus on Biological Sex."
The authors call the "sex binary" a "simplistic and harmful ideolog[y]."
Yet they then claim that no view of sex (gamete-based, multivariate, and even "sex emininativism" that holds biological sex doesn't exist at all) is necessarily true or untrue, and that biologists should simply specify which definition they're using for practical purposes.
This is nonsensical, because every non-gametic view of sex is logically incoherent and self-refuting because they all rely on gametes as the conceptual anchor.
It claims the gamete-based definition is flawed because it isn't "inclusive of reproductive approached beyond anisogamy" and fails to "classify organisms before sexual maturity or after reproductive cessation as having a sex."
But anisogamy (reproduction via the fusion of gametes of different sizes) isn't meant to apply to isogamous organisms (organisms that reproduce via the fusion of same-sized gametes). Anisogamy and the sexes—male and female—are fully intertwined and inseparable.
Isogamous organisms don't have sexes; they have "mating types." They're different from sexes, and that's why biologists aren't "inclusive" of isogamous organisms when talking about males and females.
And the notion that a gamete-based definition doesn't apply to sexually immature individuals or individuals who have ceased producing gametes ignores that the sexes are defined by having the biological FUNCTION to produce small or large gametes—and things still have a function even when its not being currently realized.
None of us were cited, so they just argued against a strawman.
There's so much more wrong with the paper than I stated above, but an X post isn't the best format. I have reached out to the editors of Ecology Letters asking if they would consider publishing a counter-Viewpoint.
From the start, a key tactic of the gender identitarians has been linguistic prescription, and it's proved shockingly successful. Trans activists' shibboleths and euphemisms have been allowed to penetrate the upper echelons of our culture with devastating consequences to freedom of speech and belief. Huge swathes of liberal media, the arts, academia and publishing have thrown themselves with gusto into the defence of a quasi-religious belief causing provable real world harm, and in their arrogance they've been outraged when people they assumed were part of their In Group have refused to march meekly along in lock step.
Time and again, I've seen and heard well-educated people who consider themselves critical thinkers and bold truth-tellers squirm when put on the spot. 'Well, yes, maybe there's something in what you're saying, but it's hateful/provocative/rude not to use the approved language/pretend people can literally change sex/keep drawing attention to medical malpractice or opportunistic sexual predators. Why can't you be nice? Why won't you pretend? We thought you were one of us! Don't you realise we have sophisticated new words and phrases these days that obviate the necessity of thinking any of this through?'
As the vibe shifts, and a lot of people in the elite professions start trying to reposition themselves, the obvious place to start is, 'it's not that I couldn't see your point, but did you have to say it that way?' We dissenters were supposed to find a way of questioning the chemical castration of children while calling it 'gender affirming care.' We were meant to defend the rights of vulnerable women while also using female pronouns for male rapists. We should have found a way to discuss fairness for women and girls in sport, while pretending that the ineradicable physical advantage men have over women doesn't exist.
Either a man can be a woman, or he can't. Either women deserve rights, or they don't. Either there's a provable medical benefit to transitioning children, or there isn't. Either you're on the side of a totalitarian ideology that seeks to impose falsehoods on society through the threat of ostracisation, shaming and violence, or you're not. The alternative to being 'blunt' - using accurate, factual language to describe what was going on - was to surrender freedom of speech and espouse ideological jargon that obfuscated the issues and the harms caused. We've always needed blunt people, but we need them most of all when being asked to bow down to a naked emperor.
Interesting interview with @Glinner on @GBNEWS a few minutes ago about the trans debate. It's interesting how the tide is turning in his favour. I've seen old friends who shunned him admit he has a point but that he was too blunt. Even that would was unthinkable a few years ago
My chapter from The War on Sience on the desexing of language in women's health has been republished in @Quillette. Exclusively, it is accompanied by figures showing the spread of this language from the US and with a recording of me reading it!
The desexing of language in women’s health research and care is a story of the marginalisation of science, cultural imperialism, and abuse of power. @DrKarleenG
"As an adult, I vowed to help create a world where sissy boys like me could find space in society to be themselves, without any pressure to change—a goal that still feels urgent today. What I know now is that gender nonconformity didn’t disqualify me from being male." 👏🏽 @benappel www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/03/gay-boys-lgbtq-trans/68…
This says it all: “In a time of vigorous discussion about gender diversity, invoking a single biological ‘truth’ can shut down necessary conversations about intersex rights, health research, and inclusive policies.”
One point Mahr misses in their response to @SwipeWright is that facts alone neither shut down conversation nor dictate policy. Humans decide how facts are used, and democratic decision‑making depends on shared facts and open debate, not declaring some facts too harmful to discuss.
"I am not here to write an apologia for a guy [@PeterAttiaMD] who rakes in millions of dollars a year. What I am here to do is defend facts and complexity of character, two crucial aspects of writing and reporting mangled beyond recognition by digital hysteria [about Epstein]. Zakin gets it mostly right on Attia, but wrong on @bariweiss. substack.com/home/post/p-186921888
The University of Toronto is hiring a biology professor. Selection will be limited to candidates who identify as women, trans, nonbinary, Two-Spirit, and gender fluid, racialized persons/visible minorities, Indigenous Peoples, persons with disabilities. The salary range is $138,000 to $153,000.
"We have seen that prenatal and postnatal hormone exposures sculpt brain structure and behavior in predictable, sex-specific ways; that cognitive and physical differences – such as human males’ spatial reasoning advantages and human females’ verbal and empathic strengths – emerge consistently across disparate societies. Moreover, critiques of social constructionism – whether in feminist, philosophical, or institutional contexts reveal an unsettling willingness to subordinate empirical reality to ideological commitments."
Sex is not a social construct but a biological reality. Denying it hurt both men and women. A new review article demonstrate common sex differences and how biology and evolutionary psychology best explain them. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12110-026-09510-7
"At a time when more and more Americans are turning away from expert authority in favor of YouTube quacks and their ilk — and when our own government is pushing scientifically baseless policies on childhood vaccination and climate change — it’s vital that the organizations that represent mainstream science be open, honest and transparent about politically charged issues." @jessesingalwww.nytimes.com/2026/02/24/opinion/medical-associations-y…
"We’ve got good evidence, for instance, that prenatal testosterone helps explain why, on average, men are more aggressive than women, why they’re less parental, and why they’re more interested in things and less interested in people."
"If you think psychological research is always low in quality, and that its results are never robust or surprising, this paper might just change your mind."
🚨BREAKING: NHS-backed puberty blocker trial PAUSED as regulator raises safety concerns. The Medicines & Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) has requested the King’s College trial team amend study protocol, to better reflect risks to children 🧵 assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6998b06d047739fe61…
"Addiction is rhetorically potent, especially when it is presented as a biologically driven phenomenon. As both reality and metaphor, addiction conjures disembodied brains hijacked by a dangerous substance foisted upon the helpless consumer by greedy third parties." @slsatel
"More than half of Harris voters, known for their higher trust in scientific authority, are unwilling to 'trust the experts' when it comes to gender medicine for kids."
.@billmaher has re-released an entertaining 2023 interview with @neiltyson, in which Tyson suggests using "hormone ratios" rather than sex as the basis of sports categories. At the end of my talk with @coldxman 👇🏽, I explain why this makes little sense, and is unfair to women. youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo?t=5086
.@billmaher has re-released an entertaining 2023 interview with @neiltyson, in which Tyson suggests using "hormone ratios" rather than sex as the basis of sports categories. At the end of my talk with @coldxman 👇🏽, I explain why this makes little sense, and is unfair to women. youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo?t=5086
‘I’d Like to Be Normal’: Can Height Surgery Make Them Happy? "A lot of guys like to say, Well, I’m fine with just the way that I am,” said Mr. St. James, who started stature-lengthening last August. “Deep down inside, no they’re not." 🎁www.nytimes.com/2026/02/17/us/height-surgery-limb-lengthe…
I didn't know Grok replied to comments that don't ask it questions. Cool that it gets the argument @byrne_a and I made about "sex assigned at birth." We feel the same way two years later. Article above @grok's reply.
Thanks for the gift link to your NYT op-ed with Alex Byrne. You argue "sex assigned at birth" misleads by suggesting arbitrariness, as sex is biologically determined and observed. The APA defines it as the biological status based on anatomy, using it for respectful dialogue on transgender and intersex experiences. Medical literature notes its origins in 1990s for such cases. Views vary across scientific and social lenses.
A new letter 👇🏽, "Biology is not binary: a letter from biologists, doctors, and other experts," argues that sex is "bimodal," not binary, and that "biological sex" is not a favored term among scientists, and is instead a "political term." I include a paper in the next post that shows that at least one signatory, who happens to be one of my favorite behavioral endocrinologists, actually knows sex is binary, and freely uses the term "biological sex." She signed anyway.
This argument seems less motivated by truth and more by activism; in this case to "restore the rights of trans & non-binary people to access toilets and other spaces that are essential to daily life." So rather than do the sensible thing, which is to start with truth and common sense (sex is real, binary and important), and then engage in good faith about policy issues on which reasonable people can disagree (like, which bathroom should passing trans people use), these authors/signatories start by undermining their credibility and expertise.
In the process, they lose opportunities to show that there is nuance in the science of sex, and that compassion and truth are compatible.
The next post has the link to the actual (sensible) views of a signatory, prominent (and generally excellent) sex differences researcher Margaret McCarthy.
Here's a teaser "Sex is dichotomous, with sex determination in the fertilized zygote stemming from unequal expression of sex chromosomal genes." The letter she signed blatantly contradicts her beliefs. Surely other signatories agree with her about the actual science, but abandon it when it appears to support disfavored policies. I'm sad to see this.
@byrne_a Great talk I just listened to you at Stanford just now. Excellent. (I'm aware of your work in this subject). I DIDN'T know you were British. But like my Mum is, I'll forgive... 🇬🇧 :-) I am a big fan of your wife, her "T" book being one of the best I've read in the last decade and she's a cool chick also. (Long ago I successfully dropped out of med school and now retired I read a lot). All the best, D.A. NYC 🗽 @hoovlet
"When I wrote this book, I wanted it to be useful. It also allowed me to look inward, to take stock of my life and try to rebuild from the ruins. When you hear the facts of the trial, you see this woman and wonder, How is she still standing? I needed to convey that I’m still a woman who stands tall." www.nytimes.com/2026/02/13/magazine/gisele-pelicot-france…
'Female' is a sex term that refers to, and picks out, a particular biological kind. It is essential to our understanding of the world that we have this term with clear meaning and reference. This means that it is just about possible to 'identify as female' but impossible to 'transition to female.' The suspect was not female, but male. It degrades our language to suggest otherwise. @BBC
Lifetime exposure to male levels of testosterone tends to increase propensity for violence. Blocking the hormone in men does not erase its permanent effects.
Women make up less than 3% of mass shooters. (See the detailed, scrollable data @motherjones, link below). Although men are responsible for almost all mass shootings, fewer than one in a million men will ever commit one.
I’ve written extensively about why testosterone increases the propensity for violence (in my book T: The Story of Testosterone), but this is often misunderstood. It’s not about how high a man’s T level is right now; it’s about lifetime exposure to the hormone and how it shapes the male brain and behavior. Testosterone’s effects on the male brain during “critical” developmental stages are permanent. This is all on average!
During these critical periods, the growing male brain is especially sensitive to high T (produced by the testes). This happens in early development, when the fetus is growing in the womb; shortly after birth, when testosterone rises for a few months; and during puberty.
High testosterone during these windows causes permanent changes in brain circuits involved in aggression, dominance, and risk‑taking, and it builds a larger, stronger body that is adapted to carry out those drives (whether they are expressed or not). Boys are already more physically aggressive than girls in childhood, when everyone’s testosterone is low; the sex differences in rough play and behaviors like hitting, pushing, and grabbing are nonetheless large. This is consistent with studies on humans and nonhuman animals, and is evidence for the permanence of those early developmental effects of high T.
In male puberty, testosterone then acts on these already “masculinized” neural structures—also shaped by years of boyhood play and experience—and further solidifies a typically male body and brain, biased toward mating competition and status‑seeking, and less toward nurturance.
Blocking testosterone later in life tends to reduce libido, energy, and some forms of impulsive aggression, but it does not undo a man's developmental history.
The effects of testosterone in the male brain and body, and of a lifetime of experiences shaped by testosterone, are not erased in males on testosterone blockers, including trans-identified ones. Testosterone does not cause any particular behavior, but combined with the “right” social and environmental conditions, it helps explain why men are vastly more likely than women to commit acts of extreme violence.
"The suspect, Jesse Van Rootselaar, was biologically born male and began transitioning to female six years ago. He added that the police would continue identifying her as a female. He said that the authorities were not yet able to say why the suspect had carried out the murder spree, one of the worst in Canadian history. Ms. Van Rootselaar and her family were known to the authorities, Mr. McDonald said, adding that the police had last visited the home in the spring for mental health issues that included self harm." Shame on @nytimes. A woman did not commit this horrific crime. www.nytimes.com/live/2026/02/11/world/canada-shooting-tum…
Most men (adult human males) are not violent, and the same goes for trans-identified ones. But the vast majority of those who are extremely violent are men. Journalists who lie about the sex of perpetrators of violent crime mislead the public, harm public safety (including for trans-identified people), and discredit journalism. Tell the truth. reuters.com/world/canada-mass-shooting-live-least-10-dead…
This is not a minor semantic dispute. In high-profile crimes, accurate reporting matters. Biological sex is a data category used in criminology, public policy, and statistical analysis. Erasing it — or substituting identity categories without clarity — distorts public understanding and, over time, the historical record.
Most men (adult human males) are not violent, and the same goes for trans-identified ones. But the vast majority of those who are extremely violent are men. Journalists who lie about the sex of perpetrators of violent crime mislead the public, harm public safety (including for trans-identified people), and discredit journalism. Tell the truth. reuters.com/world/canada-mass-shooting-live-least-10-dead…
This is not a minor semantic dispute. In high-profile crimes, accurate reporting matters. Biological sex is a data category used in criminology, public policy, and statistical analysis. Erasing it — or substituting identity categories without clarity — distorts public understanding and, over time, the historical record.
"The suspect, Jesse Van Rootselaar, was biologically born male and began transitioning to female six years ago. He added that the police would continue identifying her as a female."
The autism epidemic is a myth: The increase is only in expansive overdiagnosis of kids "on the spectrum," e.g. "Would rather be alone than with others,” “Has difficulty making friends,” and “Is regarded by other children as odd or weird.” Severe cases (no language, socially unresponsive, etc.) have decreased. By my former grad student @AdamOmaryPhDwww.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/02/10/autism-spectru…
I’m back with your yearly reminder that Whitney Houston sang the best National Anthem of all time. People are still pretending it can be beat. It can’t. Just put this on the Jumbotron every year.
"The judgment was intended to resolve years of legal confusion surrounding women’s rights to single-sex services, facilities, associations & sports...that safeguard women’s safety, privacy & dignity." www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/02/un-expert-concern…
Interesting interview w/ Epstein, by S. Bannon, from '19. Below I shared it starting at 1:34, where JE discusses ideas on intelligence, intuition, racial, sex differences. It was part of "PR rehab" before Epstein's July 2019 federal arrest. youtu.be/oIEYmflX090?t=5621
No one actually thinks a double mastectomy is similar to a nose job. That is the sort of stunted, pseudointellectual space you inevitably end up in after you spend years attempting to reputationally napalm good-faith critics and skeptics.
The American Society of Plastic Surgeons has recommended against gender transition surgeries for youths, becoming the first major medical association in the U.S. to narrow its guidance on pediatric gender care. www.washingtonpost.com/health/2026/02/03/plastic-surgeons…
The following email is what I sent my team last night. I sent a similar version to my patients, also.
***
You’ve put your trust, your credibility, and your hard work into what we have built together, and I take that responsibility seriously. You deserve a complete and honest account of what did and did not happen. I apologize that I did not get this out sooner, but I want to be thorough.
The purpose of the DOJ releasing these documents is clear: to identify individuals who participated in criminal activity, enabled it, or witnessed it. I am not in any of those categories, and there is no evidence to the contrary.
To be clear:
1. I was not involved in any criminal activity.
2. My interactions with Epstein had nothing to do with his sexual abuse or exploitation of anyone.
3. I was never on his plane, never on his island, and never present at any sex parties.
That said, I apologize and regret putting myself in a position where emails, some of them embarrassing, tasteless, and indefensible, are now public, and that is on me. I accept that reality and the humiliation that comes with it.
***
I want to start by directly addressing the email thread that I’ve been asked about the most.
In June 2015, I sent Epstein an email with the subject line “Got a fresh shipment.” The email contained a photograph of bottles of metformin, a medication I had just received from the pharmacy for my own use. The subject line referred to the picture of the bottles of medication.
He replied with the words “me too” and attached a photograph of an adult woman. I responded with crude, tasteless banter. Reading that exchange now is very embarrassing, and I will not defend it. I’m ashamed of myself for everything about this. At the time, I understood this exchange as juvenile, not a reference to anything dark or harmful.
At that point in my career, I had little exposure to prominent people, and that level of access was novel to me. Everything about him seemed excessive and exclusive, including the fact that he lived in the largest home in all of Manhattan, owned a Boeing 727, and hosted parties with the most powerful and prominent leaders in business and politics. I treated that access as something to be quiet about rather than discussed freely with others. One line in that exchange, about his life being outrageous and me not being able to tell anyone, is being interpreted as awareness of wrongdoing. That is not how I meant it at all. What I was referring to, poorly and flippantly, was the discretion commanded by those social and professional circles–the idea that you don’t talk about who you meet, the dinners you attend and the power and influence of the people in those settings. What I wrote in that email reads terribly, and I own that.
***
I met Epstein in 2014 through a prominent female healthcare leader while I was raising funds for scientific research. At that time, he was widely known in academic and philanthropic circles as a funder of science and moved openly among credible institutions and public figures.
Between summer 2014 and spring 2019, I met with him on approximately seven or eight occasions at his New York City home, regarding research studies and to meet others he introduced me to. I never visited his island or ranch, and I never flew on any of his planes. When I was at his home, it was either meeting with him directly, meeting with small groups of scientists, doctors, or business leaders, and once at a dinner in 2015 with a number of guests including prominent heads of state. In retrospect, the presence and credibility of such venerable people in different orbits led me to make assumptions about him that clouded my judgment in ways it shouldn’t have.
I was not his doctor, though several times I answered general medical questions and recommended other providers to him.
Shortly after we met, I asked him directly about his 2008 conviction. He characterized it as prostitution-related charges. In 2018, I came to learn this was grossly minimized (more on this below). I was incredibly naïve to believe him. I mistook his social acceptance in the eyes of the credible people I saw him with for acceptability, and that was a serious error in my judgment. To be clear, I never witnessed illegal behavior and never saw anyone who appeared underage in his presence.
***
In November 2018 I read the Miami Herald investigative article. I was repulsed by what I learned. Nauseated. It marked a clear and irreversible line between what I knew before and what I understood afterward.
At that point, I told him directly he needed to accept responsibility for what he did.
Hoping to provide the victims from the Herald piece with support, I contacted a residential trauma facility to understand what funding comprehensive care for many victims would require. (Those communications were between me and the facility and were therefore not part of the document release.) I spoke with him and shared that information and insisted that he fund their care, beginning with residential treatment and followed by lifelong therapy.
In hindsight, even attempting to facilitate accountability was a mistake and once again reflected just how naïve I was at the time. Once the full scope of his actions was clear, disengagement should have been the only appropriate response. My intent does not change that, and I regret not drawing that boundary immediately.
***
Nothing in this letter is meant to minimize the harm suffered by the young women Epstein abused. Their trauma is permanent.
I am not asking for a pass from you. I am not asking anyone to ignore the emails or pretend they aren’t ugly. They simply are.
The man I am today, roughly ten years later, would not write them and would not associate with Epstein at all. Whatever growth I’ve had over the past decade does not erase the emails I wrote then.
I recognize that my actions and words have consequences for the people I care deeply about, including all of you. I regret the cost this has placed on you, and I take responsibility for it.
I won’t ask anyone to defend me or explain this on my behalf. If you have questions or concerns, I’ll address them directly with you, my team.
A pleasure to see Rebecca Goldstein interviewed by @sapinker about her great new book, The Mattering Instinct. What do you do to matter--to justify your existence? Are you a competitor? A heroic driver? A socializer? Or a transcender? Read the book and find out!
The Mattering Instinct by Rebecca Goldstein is witty, smart, endearing and essential. It quickly changed how I understand consciousness, physics, and humanity. It’s also wonderfully and uniquely written, creating a genre of its own I trust will be imitated and studied for decades to come.
Read it to grasp the arbitrariness and wonder of being “matter longing to matter”; for a fresh take on consciousness/mattering in the age of LLMs; or read it just because you enjoy beautiful prose & original thinking.
"I chose progressive lawyering as my career because I wanted to fight for vulnerable people. It’s ironic that my career on the left may be over because I did exactly that." @glennagoldis, fired for contradicting her boss on pediatric gender Rx. www.thefp.com/p/i-was-fired-by-new-yorks-attorney-gender-…
"I used to say I couldn’t imagine being a father. Now it’s nearly all I imagine." In this personal and moving essay, Colin explains why you should have kids, and sooner rather than later.
"We do not need to return to the large, abusive psychiatric asylums of the past, but the law has swung so far toward individual autonomy that the concept of “do no harm” has all but vanished." Extraordinarily good piece about an extraordinarily important topic.
Outrageous treatment of @michaelshermer yesterday (Jan 28) on @BrianLehrer's podcast on @WNYC. Lehrer distorted Shermer's views and failed to treat him with respect, apparently because they disagreed about issues like whether sex is binary and the medical treatment of gender-dysphoric minors.
Lehrer took some listener calls with Shermer on the line, then invited complaints after removing Shermer from the conversation, allowing callers to voice them on air without Shermer present to respond:
Lehrer: “If you’ve been texting or starting to call in because you were offended and you want to tell your own experience or that of a trans person, you can call in.”
In contrast, Shermer remained calm and measured throughout, stating his views clearly, clarifying areas of disagreement, and showing respect for the host.
The relevant part of the transcript is in the next post. The full transcript and audio are available at the link below (trans discussion begins at 16:28, although Shermer mentions it at 4:44).
From the Brian Lehrer show on @WNYC, with @michaelshermer as guest. Below is the transcript of caller's questions and responses. First caller agrees with Shermer, wants him to be president! Things get worse after Shermer leaves the conversation.
Shermer mentioned trans issues first at 4:44: And until recently, most people most of the time trusted most experts and institutions that's taken a big hit since the whole kind of politicization of many woke issues like the trans issues and so on such that a lot of people when they see these statements made by university professors or presidents or scientists and it turns out they're wrong or just crazy they think, well, why should I believe what Harvard scientists tell me about climate change when they can't even tell me what a woman is.
16:20 CALLER’S QUESTIONS:
CALLER: I'm glad you repeated his name. Michael Shermer. I may write you in in my next election for president. We definitely need someone who is truthful and not just self-interested in gaining more power and wealth in this world…And what's happening now is that we are being divided.
America is turning into a third world country because of the liars that have taken over our government and the Democratic Party has let me down because they also are untruthful about certain things. as a very fertile woman um growing up in an age where sex was kind of like you know just out there you kind of did it if you like the person and now they're saying that men can become women and I feel that you are dis just discounting women as a species because in nature there are male and females and now you're trying to make us believe or certain uh psychiatrists or surgeons are trying to make us believe that you can turn a male into a female. A female is more than her anatomy. She is her experience growing up in this world.
[!!] Lehrer: But Mabel, if you're going to go there, trans women would say they had their experience of being a woman before they had any um hormone replacement therapy or, you know, uh surgery uh or anything like that. So, I don't know, you know, maybe you're just biased against a segment of society who you don't like.
Michael, I might have picked up from one of your earlier answers that you're on the same page as Mabel. And a lot of people, you know, who know uh and you know, a lot of people might agree with you, but a lot of people might say, "Come on, why do you have to go to that binary that people's experience proves you want you want evidence?
People's experience proves that transgenderism is real."
Shermer: Okay. So here in my book, I distinguish between subjective truths and objective truths. So subjective truths are internal states. It's true for me. Uh, you know, I like dark chocolate and you like milk chocolate or I like stairway to heaven and you like whatever. Okay.
Or, you know, meditation works for me, maybe it doesn't work for you. They're there. We're just talking about internal subjective state. So, the transgender issue is very much in that realm of and it's not really it's not biological sex at all. Biological sex is absolutely binary. Men cannot become women. Men cannot become pregnant and so forth. I'm referring to that um gynecologist last week who cannot answer Jo Senator Josh Holly's question. Can men get pregnant? I worry about the Democratic Party as being strong and robust in the future to counter, you know, the craziness of the right. You know, the craziness of the left has got to counter the craziness of the right. But if you go too far either way, right or left, that's disturbing for, you know, our mission here as a democracy. So when that happened, why couldn't she? Here's how I would have answered this question.
You know, Senator H Josh
Holly, can men become pregnant? Senator, no. Men cannot become pregnant. Now, I do have some patients I deal with who
are women, biological women, who identify as men. Now, of course, they're not men. So, when they get pregnant,
they're women getting pregnant, but they call themselves men. I want to go along to get along. I can't judge somebody's
internal subjective state. If that's how they feel, that's how they feel. you know, I'm not going to judge that. That
would be a good sort of liberal, progressive, tolerant answer while also acknowledging the reality of biology,
which is it's binary. So, if you want to talk about gender, that's a internal
subjective state, that's a different thing entirely. So, that's how I think about that. Yeah.
So for people who heard you, as I will admit I did, as kind of dismissing the idea that gender is a different state than sex, that's not where you want to land.
SHERMER: Yeah. Gender is different than biological sex. Yes. And the people that study it also say that, you know, that are more open to that. Um yeah, that that's just, you know, again, it's I know some transgender um men who now identify as women. I'm sympathetic to, you know, what they went through. this was a difficult part of their lives. Um, but that's not what we're talking about when we're talking about like say teenagers who are going through puberty and struggling with body bodily dysphoria and then are told or learn online that you know maybe you're in the wrong body. Okay, there's no such thing as the wrong body, but you are your body. There's no you and then your body as if there's a little gendered homunculus floating around, you know, inside you.
That that no such thing. You're just your body. Now, some people for whatever hormonal differences or variations, you know, identify more male or more female or whatever. All of that again, if we stick it stay with the internal subjective truths, that's fine. But to then say, but this could be true for you too. And then to for minors to be told um we're going to transition you and this will help you with your depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, whatever it is that these teenagers are going through. Uh then that becomes that's where it crosses the line where the facts actually matter.
You know, you cannot pause puberty. You can't. That's not how it works. I mean, you can, but then there's going to be irreparable damage um changes going forward.
LEHRER: Well, scientists, this is not at all where I thought this segment was going to go. Um, but people um who are going through that gender dysphoria who are teenagers, you're framing it as if some kind of psychological establishment or something has an agenda. This is what the right-wing says, right? that it's gender ideology as opposed to a lot of well-meaning um psychology you know psychology uh practitioners and in conjunction with the parents of the teenagers looking for what's best for the individual teenager and that might be different for one person than it might be for another person.
And it sounds like you're being very dismissive of a of a group and accusing them of the kind of what's the word? Uh recruitment um that I wouldn't have expected from you.
SHERMER: No, I agree with you, Brian. Now, so I didn't think we were going to go this direction either. So, let me articulate it a little more carefully. There is such a thing as gender dysphoria. That's real. It's been around for a long time. We've known about it. It's a vanishingly small number less well less than 1% probably less than 1 half of 1% that experience this. Around about a decade ago there began a uh larger movement of what's called rapid onset gender dysphoria. And this is not young children which is what the gender dysphoria was originally um designed or discovered about. But these are teenagers or you know young adolescents just starting puberty or going through puberty in which there's something this is called the social contagion hypothesis.
I don't buy into at all any of the top down they're trying to recruit kids and change their gender. These you know that's a very conspiratorial thing that I don't buy.
No, I think I agree with you. These are well-meaning parents, doctors, nurses, teachers, school counselors, and so forth. or even the people online on Facebook that are um designing these websites, you know, they're trying to help people. I think for the most part, these are good people trying to do the right thing.
So then it does become a factual matter of what's true.
I mean, can you actually pause puberty and then turn it back on again if you change your mind? No, you can't. You know, and so things like that. Can you actually change sex? No, you can't. Um if you know if sex is defined as you know the gametes that your body makes either sperm or eggs then you can't change that. That's not I think there are doctors who do this for a living who would disagree with you that you can't pause something and turn it back on again.
LEHRER: Um but I don't want to go round and round on that with you. One other thing on this. Uh a number of people pointing out when you say sex is a binary if even if not gender uh please correct him says one text that sex is not an absolute binary interex people exist. So that's the I in LGBTQIA and you know there are people like that you acknowledge that right?
SHERMER: I would I would just point out that the in many northern European
countries and in the UK now they have stopped all this because the science has changed. You know when this began a
decade ago we just didn't know much about this. Now we do. The United States is slower because we don't have you know
a federal mandate on this. It's state by state. Some states you know are more encouraging of it. Some are more
skeptical of it and so on. So it's kind of a moving target in that sense. Um and in case again let's distinguish
between internal subjective truth this is what I feel inside okay um how
would I know you know you have your truth but objective truth that is can you actually change biological sex you
can't there's no third sex interex is so they're referring to XY or XXY
conditions Kleinfelder syndrome Turner syndrome there's a bunch of these but in the same way that there's people born
with six fingers uh that doesn't mean our species has finger is on a finger
spectrum. You know the vast majority of people are you know have five fingers. The vast majority of people are male or
female. There's no in between. There's no third and minorities exist and minorities exist. Yeah. So what
should we do about it? Okay. How about um this is called watchful waiting. So
the teenager is struggling with you know gender dysphoria and other issues. We now know a lot of the these kids are on
the spectrum. they have some autism issues. Um, they have some normal adolescence issues. Okay, watchful
waiting. Let's get them the help they need, the counseling and so on. Don't inject them with hormones because that
could change their body permanently going forward. And we don't allow these kids to get tattoos without parental
consent. We don't allow them to vote. We don't allow them to drive or smoke or drink. Why would you allow them to
change their bodies? This is really a risky thing to do because and now we're getting a lot of the detransitioners are
going where were the adults in my life when I was a kid. I should have never been allowed to do
this. And that's now that's now a growing movement. Anyway, Brian, this will all be sorted out in these lawsuits
that are coming. Um, you know, and then in the courts they'll have to bring in scientific experts.
LEHRER: Yes. Well, and you're here uh supposedly representing science. the legal questions are the legal questions and the science is sometimes very different from what politics and the law determined to be allowable. And um I will just say as we wrap this up that uh yeah that's not what at all what I expected this conversation to turn into.
But so it did.
And we leave it with Michael Shurmer, publisher of Skeptic Magazine, the executive director of the Skeptic Society and author of a new book, Truth: What It Is, How to Find It, and Why It Still Matters. Thank you for joining us. Oh, thank
[music]
SHERMER LEAVES CALL
LEHRER: I know a lot of people want to respond to that last stretch with the last guest and you can do that, too.
So, if you've been texting or starting to call in uh because you were offended and you want to tell your own experience or that of a trans person, you know, you can call in too in these last 10 minutes.
Equal time. 212433 WNYC 4339692.
Megan in Maplewood, you're on WNYC. Thank you for calling in.
Hi, Brian. Thanks for taking my call to just quickly address what that last guest
just said about um trans youth and access to hormones and detransitioning.
Um as a parent of a trans child who has fully transitioned to the person that they want to be. I really wish that
people that don't have trans children would stop talking about their experiences and their needs.
Um, there's nothing that compares to watching your child suffer.
Adolescence is already hard enough and watching them suffer through not being able to be who they truly are. and then
going through the process of transitioning and seeing them come out of that and the brightness and joy that
comes into their lives and the clarity that they have after being able to transition.
Nobody can understand that but the child and the parent. And of course there are
times when people feel differently and it might change their minds. But
I don't think that we should be giving a platform to pseudocientists telling us what trans kids need when
they are not the parent of a trans child and have never been through um the experiences that our children are
going through. They need more support now than ever. And interestingly, the
book was supposed to be in support of science. And my understanding is, and from my own
um looking at it, the topic wasn't even in the book, but that's where he went. And Megan,
thank you for adding your voice.
NEW CALLER: Jason in Queens, you're on WNYC.
Hello, Jason.
Hello. Um, I'm so glad that you opened up the phones back because I'm sure you had a deluge of calls about
the just list of falsehoods and ridiculous statements that this guy who's supposedly talking about being a
logical skeptic and then just to say a bunch of false nonsense. I don't even
know where to start. I mean, implying that that transgender kids are somehow
psychologically having problems or that they're all just autistic or all just that it's some kind of disease even.
It's just total nonsense. He also implied that the kids are just going out and getting hormone therapy what like on
the street from a drug dealer or something like they're not doing it with parental consent which is just also
total nonsense. of course courses with the parents consent and what's going on in this country right now because of idiotic pseudocientists like this guy giving support is that the government is clamping down on families making the choice my own uh brother and his wife I have a niece who's transgender they're going through this right now where
they're seeing their health care completely pulled under the rug from them and they can't even make the
decision they've made the decision very carefully with their daughter who has made this decision at a young age and
has stayed that way has transition back like another nonsense myth that this guy said
and because of people like him giving it some kind of pseudocientific backup
they're having they're being attacked for making personal decisions for their family. I mean this guy is just not I'm
so glad you pushed back. I'll let other speakers go on. I'm just I'm so glad that you opened up the phone.
Thank you
Jason. Thank you very much.
And interestingly I'm getting push back too. A listener writes
I was offended by Brian. Um, sounds very much like you have a vested interest in promoting sex change. Did you give your guest proper deference?
And another one,
sorry Brian, but the skeptic I was reasonable.
Um, Linda in New Orleans, you're on WNYC. Hi, Linda.
LINDA: Hi. I have a trans grandchild and uh who transitioned male to female and um she is very happy now. I was just about to follow Michael Shurmer on X when I heard
the caller go make a U-turn and talk about trans and his equivocating and
then not giving you an answer and almost ending up by saying well we'll let we'll
see how it plays out a as if he's the final judge and jury was so offensive
and so condescending and of course I'm not going to follow him and I'm so
surprised and disappointed and shocked at this guest and thank you for taking all the calls and not talking about
snow. Thank you very much, Linda.
Let's see. I think we have time for one more. Can I
go to Jessica online? Claire, is that line uh available? Jessica, you're on
WNYC.
Jessica: Hello. Hi. Yes, I'm also the mom of a transgendered um adult now child. And I
would like to echo you, the mom from uh Maplewood. You know, she's my neighbor where we live nearby each other.
And um I'd like to back up some of what she said with science. Um we have been
performing transgendered medical care and surgical care for something like 90 years now. We're very good at it.
It has it has almost zero morbidity. It has something like zero mortality. If
any other treatment uh for any other um human condition were so successful, we
would be shouting it from the rooftops because people find feel uncomfortable or something around transgender people.
It's become politicized and we don't celebrate it the way we celebrate other medical successes. Um, as for treating
it therapeutically, you know, gender dysphoria therapeutically, which the which the guest suggested, that has very
often resulted in disaster, including the death of the patient. And so that's
an unacceptable outcome. And yet, the outcome of transgendered medical care
and surgical care is so much the opposite and so much more often results in happiness.
And Jessica, I have to leave it there because the show is over.
And I'm just going to say thank you for your calls. Brian Lara and WNYC. Stay tuned for all of it. [music]
On Thursday, a federal judge unsealed internal government documents shining a light into how the Trump administration targeted pro-Palestinian foreign students — who were all legally present in the United States — for deportation.
Now we know that the government’s case was built not on criminal activity, but on the opinions expressed.
There are few things more un-American than masked agents throwing dissenters in the back of a van because the government doesn’t like what they have to say. But these documents prove that it was the students’ opinions alone, and not any criminal activity, that led to handcuffs and deportation proceedings.
The First Amendment means the government cannot punish speakers for their opinions, but that is exactly what the government is doing.
This can’t happen in a free society.
It can’t happen in a free America.
FIRE will continue to fight this egregious violation of the Constitution every step of the way.
Physical activity and the reduction of all-cause mortality, from 2 very large prospective cohorts 1. The relationship is non-linear, suggesting a threshold effect for many types of exercise as seen below
There are two places in the world where I’ve thought for decades the world might end. One is North Korea, which is why I ferociously opposed it getting nukes. Unfortunately, that ship has sailed. The other is Iran, where a nightmare theocracy rules over a population that doesn’t want it, and the theocrat-in-chief is in a hurry to get nukes that I believe he will actually use.
We were offered a chance to support the Iranian people many years ago, and we missed it. This may be the last chance we ever have to help free the Iranian people—and we can barely pay attention. If the uprising fails, the world will be a far less safe place.
Bari may have made some mistakes--it would be surprising if she hadn't, taking over the helm of a large organization like CBS News. But a lot of the sniping is people who don't like her politics. And Sey is right that this always happens in turnarounds: people fight to keep things like they were, even if it wasn't working.
When I became the Chief Marketing Officer at Levi's, at about 2 months in, I had some mid-level know it all come into my office to tell me everyone hated me, I was steering the ship into oblivion. She told me everyone knew I was doing a terrible job. (The brand had been in decline for over 10 years.)
What I had done in my first two months:
1) Say no one could go on trips anymore unless they had a role at the photo shoot or event. No more boondoggles.
2) No drinking at events or concerts we were hosting. We were there to work, not party.
2) Say Marketing needed to feature actual product in the ads.
3) Say we needed to move away from dark and moody and into the realm of fun - because people have fun in jeans.
Awful, right?!
She wanted me to know, she said, she was trying to help. (She put her feet on my desk while saying this.)
Needless to say, this was not a person who was very good at her job. And I wasn't doing mine to be liked so I didn't care if "everybody hated me". I was trying to turn a business around that had been flailing. I took the responsibility seriously.
Six years later, we had a very successful IPO.
2 years after that I became the brand president.
These people complaining about new leadership are lame. They always do it. They want it how it was, even if how it was wasn't working. And it's even lamer that @Variety writes about this like it's news.
When police show up at your door because you criticized the government on social media, then you understand how fragile constitutionally protected free speech really is. Watch the video, read the powerful letter that @TheFIREorg sent to the Miami Beach Police Dept. in response to this incident. 👇🏽
This video is making the rounds — and it’s one every American should see.
Law enforcement showing up on Americans’ doorsteps for lawful political speech — speech that doesn’t even remotely rise to the level of incitement — is absolutely intolerable in a free society.
The Miami Beach mayor’s office is now flagging citizen’s Facebook posts and sending police to their doors to intimidate them for criticism of the mayor.
I resigned from the board of advisors of the University of Austin (UATX, not to be confused w U T Austin) within weeks of their inaugural announcement, because they "had no coherent vision of what higher education in the 21st century ought to be. Instead, they created UnWoke U led by a Faculty of the Canceled." Also: science was an afterthought. And they were so knee-jerk anti-woke that they were unprepared for the genuine issues that led to woke overreach, like sexual harassment. Four years later, my worst fears came true. Expose in Politico: They Wanted a University Without Cancel Culture. Then Dissenters Were Ousted. www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/01/16/civil-war-unive… via @politico
🐈💕 "Is it acceptable to love your dog or cat as much as a close family member? A quick answer is that it surely depends on what the pet is like — or indeed the family member." @Docstockk unherd.com/2026/01/the-pain-of-pet-grief/
"Male athletic advantage doesn’t depend solely on adult testosterone levels. Physiological differences that lead to performance gaps appear well before puberty, even in newborns. Puberty merely amplifies them." @SwipeWrightwww.wsj.com/opinion/the-transgender-sports-deception-33b7…
A Norwegian lesbian artist posted that “men can’t be lesbians.” The police opened a hate-speech investigation with a possible 3-year sentence. The message is clear: disagree with state orthodoxy, risk prosecution.
I find it fascinating to watch these two videos, of the ACLU attorney followed by the ADF attorney, with the sound off just to watch the extreme contrast in their body language. One is a posture of rueful resignation and the other of an almost imperious confidence.
The attorney representing a trans athlete in West Virginia argued to the Supreme Court that the definition of 'sex' should not be used when ruling on how to enforce Title IX during oral arguments today. I asked the ACLU's Joshua Block what his definition of 'sex' is after the hearing, and he did not provide his definition, and insisted it's not what's at issue in the case. He then dodged any further questions.
"The sex–gender distinction has become hugely popular in recent years, and many consider it indispensable. Personally, I’m not a fan. More precisely, I’m not a fan of the concept of gender, which I think confuses more than it enlightens." @SteveStuWillopen.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/why-im-not-a…
Transgender advocate Kate Sosin argues the the high court has been telling transgender people again and again that their "rights matter less than everybody else's."
No. They have the same rights as all other males and females. They just don't have *new and additional* rights based on a subjective identity that conflicts with sex-based rights.
Yesterday on @NPR's All Things Considered, @sarahmccammon interviewed Kate Sosin, a “transgender hard news and investigative reporter,” about the Supreme Court cases involving laws that prohibit transwomen (i.e., males) from competing in female sports categories.
The full text is below, along with the audio link, but here's a sample: "You know, we have cases of transgender people where they come in fifth, and that is still seen as a negative thing. Transgender people have a right to exist and to live." For starters, laws that restrict participation in female sports to females do not deny anyone's right to live or exist.
Just last March, in congressional testimony, NPR president @krmaher pledged: “NPR must be scrupulously impartial in our news coverage, and adhere to the highest of journalistic standards.” This is just the kind of issue where NPR could set the high journalistic standard, instead of a new low that betrays the public they've pledged to serve. In what possible universe is this journalism rather than pure activism?
This week, the Supreme Court will hear arguments from two separate cases weighing the rights of transgender athletes. Little v. Hecox challenges Idaho's ban on trans athletes playing on women's and girls' sports teams. West Virginia v. B.P.J. challenges a similar ban in West Virginia. Kate Sosin covers LGBTQ issues for the nonprofit newsroom The 19th and has been following these cases closely. They're here to give us a preview. Welcome.
KATE SOSIN: Thanks for having me.
MCCAMMON: So, in essence, what are these two cases about?
SOSIN: So conservatives have increasingly argued that transgender women and girls have an unfair advantage in sports, that their hormone levels make them stronger and faster, and for that reason, they say, trans women should be banned from competition. These two girls, Lindsay Hecox and Becky Pepper-Jackson, were banned from playing sports in their respective states by these state bans, and 27 states have these bans. And now the question is, will the Supreme Court back these bans and find that they are constitutional or not?
MCCAMMON: Yeah. You just said more than two dozen states have laws like this. So why these two cases? How did they make their way to the Supreme Court?
SOSIN: So Lindsay Hecox is a student at Boise State University. She tried out for her track and field team, and she didn't even make the team. She was on a club team. And she was banned from that when the state passed its ban. And so she sued saying, this is clearly not fair. She was not taking the spot of anybody. And Becky Pepper-Jackson is also an interesting case because she's a 15-year-old West Virginia student who transitioned before ever undergoing male puberty. So her state ban banned her, and they're saying it's so clear that she doesn't have an unfair advantage.
MCCAMMON: Isn't one of the concerns not just about taking spots on teams, but also a competitive advantage against their opponents, a potential advantage?
SOSIN: Certainly, yes. But what we found is that the research just simply doesn't back this up. And in part because there is limited research. There's a 2021 study published in the Journal of Sports Medicine that found no basis in existing research for banning trans women from sports. And a 2021 study funded by the International Olympic Committee, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, concluded that transgender women likely had several physical disadvantages compared with their cisgender peers. And this is after medical transition. So there's very limited research, but the research that exists just doesn't support banning transgender women or girls at this point.
MCCAMMON: Now, these are not the first cases before the Supreme Court that have involved transgender issues. Based on what we've seen from the court before, what are you expecting to happen at this week's arguments?
SOSIN: You know, last June, the court ruled against transgender youth in the Skrmetti decision. It was a 6-3 decision against transgender youth getting access to gender-affirming care in that case. And based on that, a lot of advocates are expecting a similar 6-3 ruling against transgender athletes. And that likely kicks us to a situation that we're looking at, like Roe, where it goes back to states, and states continue to ban trans athletes on a state-by-state basis. And states that were friendly to trans people continue to be friendly to them, and states that were banning trans people continue to ban them.
You know, the rest of the country will remain as it is, but I think the bigger implication that we would see is that having your Supreme Court come back and tell you again and again and again that your rights matter less than everybody else's is a really damaging thing for a lot of transgender individuals. We're seeing a slow chipping away of transgender dignity, equality and also the law, very, very slowly.
MCCAMMON: And I wonder if you can just put this in context for us. I mean, who's affected by these laws? How many people are we talking about? And what is the impact?
SOSIN: Yeah. It's not known how many trans athletes are competing in grade schools, college or even professional sports, but advocates have insisted that they represent a tiny fraction of competitors. NCAA President Charlie Baker in 2024 stated that out of 500,000 college athletes in the country, openly trans people accounted for less than 10 athletes. So we're talking about probably a handful of women and girls.
MCCAMMON: And what does it mean for these athletes to be told they can't participate?
SOSIN: You know, especially in grade schools or even college athletics, these are kids who are trying to join and be part of their extracurricular activities. They're not necessarily out to win a competition. You know, we have cases of transgender people where they come in fifth, and that is still seen as a negative thing. Transgender people have a right to exist and to live, and transgender women have competed in sports for decades. We're just now addressing the reality of it.
MCCAMMON: That was journalist Kate Sosin. Thank you so much for your reporting.
Yesterday on @NPR's All Things Considered, @sarahmccammon interviewed Kate Sosin, a “transgender hard news and investigative reporter,” about the Supreme Court cases involving laws that prohibit transwomen (i.e., males) from competing in female sports categories.
The full text is below, along with the audio link, but here's a sample: "You know, we have cases of transgender people where they come in fifth, and that is still seen as a negative thing. Transgender people have a right to exist and to live." For starters, laws that restrict participation in female sports to females do not deny anyone's right to live or exist.
Just last March, in congressional testimony, NPR president @krmaher pledged: “NPR must be scrupulously impartial in our news coverage, and adhere to the highest of journalistic standards.” This is just the kind of issue where NPR could set the high journalistic standard, instead of a new low that betrays the public they've pledged to serve. In what possible universe is this journalism rather than pure activism?
This week, the Supreme Court will hear arguments from two separate cases weighing the rights of transgender athletes. Little v. Hecox challenges Idaho's ban on trans athletes playing on women's and girls' sports teams. West Virginia v. B.P.J. challenges a similar ban in West Virginia. Kate Sosin covers LGBTQ issues for the nonprofit newsroom The 19th and has been following these cases closely. They're here to give us a preview. Welcome.
KATE SOSIN: Thanks for having me.
MCCAMMON: So, in essence, what are these two cases about?
SOSIN: So conservatives have increasingly argued that transgender women and girls have an unfair advantage in sports, that their hormone levels make them stronger and faster, and for that reason, they say, trans women should be banned from competition. These two girls, Lindsay Hecox and Becky Pepper-Jackson, were banned from playing sports in their respective states by these state bans, and 27 states have these bans. And now the question is, will the Supreme Court back these bans and find that they are constitutional or not?
MCCAMMON: Yeah. You just said more than two dozen states have laws like this. So why these two cases? How did they make their way to the Supreme Court?
SOSIN: So Lindsay Hecox is a student at Boise State University. She tried out for her track and field team, and she didn't even make the team. She was on a club team. And she was banned from that when the state passed its ban. And so she sued saying, this is clearly not fair. She was not taking the spot of anybody. And Becky Pepper-Jackson is also an interesting case because she's a 15-year-old West Virginia student who transitioned before ever undergoing male puberty. So her state ban banned her, and they're saying it's so clear that she doesn't have an unfair advantage.
MCCAMMON: Isn't one of the concerns not just about taking spots on teams, but also a competitive advantage against their opponents, a potential advantage?
SOSIN: Certainly, yes. But what we found is that the research just simply doesn't back this up. And in part because there is limited research. There's a 2021 study published in the Journal of Sports Medicine that found no basis in existing research for banning trans women from sports. And a 2021 study funded by the International Olympic Committee, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, concluded that transgender women likely had several physical disadvantages compared with their cisgender peers. And this is after medical transition. So there's very limited research, but the research that exists just doesn't support banning transgender women or girls at this point.
MCCAMMON: Now, these are not the first cases before the Supreme Court that have involved transgender issues. Based on what we've seen from the court before, what are you expecting to happen at this week's arguments?
SOSIN: You know, last June, the court ruled against transgender youth in the Skrmetti decision. It was a 6-3 decision against transgender youth getting access to gender-affirming care in that case. And based on that, a lot of advocates are expecting a similar 6-3 ruling against transgender athletes. And that likely kicks us to a situation that we're looking at, like Roe, where it goes back to states, and states continue to ban trans athletes on a state-by-state basis. And states that were friendly to trans people continue to be friendly to them, and states that were banning trans people continue to ban them.
You know, the rest of the country will remain as it is, but I think the bigger implication that we would see is that having your Supreme Court come back and tell you again and again and again that your rights matter less than everybody else's is a really damaging thing for a lot of transgender individuals. We're seeing a slow chipping away of transgender dignity, equality and also the law, very, very slowly.
MCCAMMON: And I wonder if you can just put this in context for us. I mean, who's affected by these laws? How many people are we talking about? And what is the impact?
SOSIN: Yeah. It's not known how many trans athletes are competing in grade schools, college or even professional sports, but advocates have insisted that they represent a tiny fraction of competitors. NCAA President Charlie Baker in 2024 stated that out of 500,000 college athletes in the country, openly trans people accounted for less than 10 athletes. So we're talking about probably a handful of women and girls.
MCCAMMON: And what does it mean for these athletes to be told they can't participate?
SOSIN: You know, especially in grade schools or even college athletics, these are kids who are trying to join and be part of their extracurricular activities. They're not necessarily out to win a competition. You know, we have cases of transgender people where they come in fifth, and that is still seen as a negative thing. Transgender people have a right to exist and to live, and transgender women have competed in sports for decades. We're just now addressing the reality of it.
MCCAMMON: That was journalist Kate Sosin. Thank you so much for your reporting.
"Illinois, California, New York, Washington, and New Jersey have each already documented alleged rapes resulting from forced cohabitation of female prisoners with males identifying as transgender." HT @benappel thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/5674651-mci-framingh…
BREAKING: Wife of Renee Good, Becca Good, has just released a statement. :
“First, I want to extend my gratitude to all the people who have reached out from across the country and around the world to support our family. This kindness of strangers is the most fitting tribute because if you ever encountered my wife, Renee Nicole Macklin Good, you know that above all else, she was kind. In fact, kindness radiated out of her.
Renee sparkled. She literally sparkled. I mean, she didn’t wear glitter but I swear she had sparkles coming out of her pores. All the time. You might think it was just my love talking but her family said the same thing. Renee was made of sunshine. Renee lived by an overarching belief: there is kindness in the world and we need to do everything we can to find it where it resides and nurture it where it needs to grow.
Renee was a Christian who knew that all religions teach the same essential truth: we are here to love each other, care for each other, and keep each other safe and whole. Like people have done across place and time, we moved to make a better life for ourselves. We chose Minnesota to make our home. Our whole extended road trip here, we held hands in the car while our son drew all over the windows to pass the time and the miles.
What we found when we got here was a vibrant and welcoming community, we made friends and spread joy. And while any place we were together was home, there was a strong shared sense here in Minneapolis that we were looking out for each other. Here, I had finally found peace and safe harbor. That has been taken from me forever. We were raising our son to believe that no matter where you come from or what you look like, all of us deserve compassion and kindness. Renee lived this belief every day. She is pure love. She is pure joy. She is pure sunshine. On Wednesday, January 7th, we stopped to support our neighbors. We had whistles. They had guns.
Renee leaves behind three extraordinary children; the youngest is just six years old and already lost his father. I am now left to raise our son and to continue teaching him, as Renee believed, that there are people building a better world for him. That the people who did this had fear and anger in their hearts, and we need to show them a better way.
We thank you for the privacy you are granting our family as we grieve. We thank you for ensuring that Renee’s legacy is one of kindness and love. We honor her memory by living her values: rejecting hate and choosing compassion, turning away from fear and pursuing peace, refusing division and knowing we must come together to build a world where we all come home safe to the people we love.”
We aren’t going to do many medical updates on here, but a bunch of friends have requested a status report and kindly asked what to pray for, so a few quick observations…
* Some folks are very helpful — such as our tireless team at MD Anderson. We were accepted into a clinical trial at Houston’s amazing cancer hospital around New Year’s. We’ve just completed our first week of experimental chemo.
* Some folks are less helpful — such as whatever jackwagons signed me up for tickets to loads of upcoming Nickelback events. (Although I do tip my cap to the cheery optimism of the dudes who bought me concert tickets for April “2027.”)
* Some folks have a heavenly bedside manner — such as the MD Anderson research nurses who’ve helped dial in my anti-nausea mix of drugs, radically reducing my daily puke count (“DPC”) over the past 72 hours.
* Some folks have a less heavenly bedside manner – such as my tender(?) bride who in the wee hours last night exclaimed: “Can you imagine if we make big progress on both the nausau and the spinal tumor pain?! All we’d have left is your increasingly ugly mug.” (She’s a keeper…)
More fundamentally, please hear Melissa’s and my gratitude for the outpouring of love and kindness over the three weeks since my diagnosis. We are blessed in so many ways, so I’m not surprised at how moved we’ve been by these prayers, but do know that we’ve been very moved.
I’m #notdeadyet (hat tip: Monty Python), so let me close with three prayer requests: 1. That our kids will trust in the Lord‘s Fatherly kindness and sovereign timing. 2. That the spinal tumor and the nausea can be managed enough to make me a moderately-chipper patient, finding energy to soldier well with my neighbors at the blood draws and drudgery. 3. That I will be able – to borrow the old Puritan phrase – to “redeem the time.” That is, to try to serve and love our neighbors with little bits of work — or writing and speaking projects here and there. Time is the great equalizer, but not all time is equal — you can play a lot of basketball in the last 60 seconds (especially if you’re as newly dominant in basketball as Nebraska). We’re going to give cancer a run for its money and see what can be learned in the process. As we figure out the rhythms of chemo, I’m going to endeavor to do whatever work I’ve been given to do…and try to love and serve (and not puke).
This is a tough note to write, but since a bunch of you have started to suspect something, I’ll cut to the chase: Last week I was diagnosed with metastasized, stage-four pancreatic cancer, and am gonna die.
Advanced pancreatic is nasty stuff; it’s a death sentence. But I already had a death sentence before last week too — we all do.
I’m blessed with amazing siblings and half-a-dozen buddies that are genuinely brothers. As one of them put it, “Sure, you’re on the clock, but we’re all on the clock.” Death is a wicked thief, and the bastard pursues us all.
Still, I’ve got less time than I’d prefer. This is hard for someone wired to work and build, but harder still as a husband and a dad. I can’t begin to describe how great my people are. During the past year, as we’d temporarily stepped back from public life and built new family rhythms, Melissa and I have grown even closer — and that on top of three decades of the best friend a man could ever have. Seven months ago, Corrie was commissioned into the Air Force and she’s off at instrument and multi-engine rounds of flight school. Last week, Alex kicked butt graduating from college a semester early even while teaching gen chem, organic, and physics (she’s a freak). This summer, 14-year-old Breck started learning to drive. (Okay, we’ve been driving off-book for six years — but now we’ve got paper to make it street-legal.) I couldn’t be more grateful to constantly get to bear-hug this motley crew of sinners and saints.
There’s not a good time to tell your peeps you’re now marching to the beat of a faster drummer — but the season of advent isn’t the worst. As a Christian, the weeks running up to Christmas are a time to orient our hearts toward the hope of what’s to come.
Not an abstract hope in fanciful human goodness; not hope in vague hallmark-sappy spirituality; not a bootstrapped hope in our own strength (what foolishness is the evaporating-muscle I once prided myself in). Nope — often we lazily say “hope” when what we mean is “optimism.” To be clear, optimism is great, and it’s absolutely necessary, but it’s insufficient. It’s not the kinda thing that holds up when you tell your daughters you’re not going to walk them down the aisle. Nor telling your mom and pops they’re gonna bury their son.
A well-lived life demands more reality — stiffer stuff. That’s why, during advent, even while still walking in darkness, we shout our hope — often properly with a gravelly voice soldiering through tears.
Such is the calling of the pilgrim. Those who know ourselves to need a Physician should dang well look forward to enduring beauty and eventual fulfillment. That is, we hope in a real Deliverer — a rescuing God, born at a real time, in a real place. But the eternal city — with foundations and without cancer — is not yet.
Remembering Isaiah’s prophecies of what’s to come doesn’t dull the pain of current sufferings. But it does put it in eternity’s perspective: “When we've been there 10,000 years…We've no less days to sing God's praise.”
I’ll have more to say. I’m not going down without a fight. One sub-part of God’s grace is found in the jawdropping advances science has made the past few years in immunotherapy and more. Death and dying aren’t the same — the process of dying is still something to be lived. We’re zealously embracing a lot of gallows humor in our house, and I’ve pledged to do my part to run through the irreverent tape.
But for now, as our family faces the reality of treatments, but more importantly as we celebrate Christmas, we wish you peace: “The people walking in darkness have seen a great light; on those living in the land of deep darkness a light has dawned….For to us a son is given” (Isaiah 9).
With great gratitude, and with gravelly-but-hopeful voices, Ben — and the Sasses
"We found that posts pinning the blame [for male loneliness] on men, denying an epidemic exists, or suggesting that men “deserve it” received the most likes and reposts, with satirical or ironic posts trailing in popularity." open.substack.com/pub/youngmenresearchinitiative/p/what-i…
Anyone thinking about taking cross-sex hormones should readworth @hoovlet’s great book, “T: The Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us.”
"Rejecting the gamete definition of sex would mean casually throwing away more than a century’s worth of rigorous science. We should insist on much stronger arguments than those we’ve been offered so far before contemplating such a rash move." @SteveStuWill
"This is the sixth excerpt from my forthcoming book, A Billion Years of Sex Differences. You can access the full collection here, and preorder the book here. In this installment, I explore three common challenges to the validity of the sex binary and the concepts of “female” and “male.” 1Intersex conditions: conditions in which people - or other animals - have a mixture of female-typical and male-typical traits 2Hermaphroditic species:species in which individuals have both female and male reproductive functions, or change sex during the course of their lifetimes 3Within-sex variation: the fact that, within each so-called sex, we see enormous variation in every trait, and substantial overlap between the sexes I explain why none of these phenomena undermine the female-male distinction - and indeed why they only make sense if we assume the distinction’s validity. I also argue that we can fully acknowledge biological diversity without abandoning the concepts of “female” and “male,” and that rejecting the sex binary doesn’t make biology more humane or accurate, but only less intelligible. First things first, though: My book now has a cover! Check it out…"
This is incredible. It’s one of the most powerful essays I’ve ever read. I can understand a mother’s instinct not to write this story into the record until there was no possible chance of a different ending. What sorrow.
Very good essay on how academics brought Trump's persecution on themselves.
“For 25 years, we documented the free-speech crisis on campus while a lot of higher education either denied it, rationalized it, or treated it as a moral victory. We warned that turning universities into ideological enforcement machines would generate backlash. Not because we wanted backlash, but because anyone with eyes could see that a system that punishes dissent while claiming to pursue truth is not stable. It was going to trigger a reaction.”
For years @TheFIREorg warned that turning universities into ideological enforcement machines would generate backlash. In 2025, the backlash arrived w/ the government now leading the charge against campus speech. My latest in @thedispatch
Why has @nytopinion been so unwilling to publish dissenting liberals on gender issues? Pamela Paul explained that it "discomfited and troubled Opinion leadership" when liberals "deviated from what they understood to be acceptable positions on the left."
Essential reading if you or loved ones want kids. (tldr: don't wait.) "Young women & men are being comforted by the false premise that childbearing may be delayed without consequences. The science says differently." 🙏🏽 Dr. Sarah Poggi & @TheFP www.thefp.com/p/what-ive-learned-from-watching-people?r=f…
We are primates, with a third of our brain dedicated to vision. Graphics are the most effective way to communicate quantitative, spatial, and causal information, but they are as hard to master as clear and stylish prose. Here's an excellent guide to data visualization by Saloni Dattani @saloniumopen.substack.com/pub/salonium/p/salonis-guide-to-data-vi…
The insistence that there are no genetic differences between ethnic groups, or that all differences must be purely social, is not consistent with science. And the insistence carries obvious disturbing implications. It suggests that if real biological differences did exist, then mistreatment based on those differences might be less serious or less morally repugnant. That conclusion is obviously mistaken. From an ethical standpoint, it makes no difference at all whether genetic differences between groups exist. The moral principle remains unchanged: it is wrong, under any circumstances and for any reason, for people to persecute, expel, or murder their neighbors in an effort to eliminate them. This is true whether groups are biologically indistinguishable or easily told apart or if differences are largely environmental or genetic in origin.
Tbh these are all questions I’d expect from any plugged-in editor if I were writing a piece on this issue. And if addressing those edits delayed the piece (as it always does), that would not mean the piece was “pulled” or “killed”.
Professor Alice Sullivan says the University of Bristol failed to protect her freedom of speech after a talk she gave was disrupted by a trans rights protest. The university says the talk went ahead safely in line with its ‘strong commitment to upholding free speech’.
I wrote about 5-ARD, the disorder that Prof Masters discussed on @joerogan. Joe seemed shocked by Masters' claims, including that humans can change sex at puberty. They can't. Find out why it *could* look that way, in this excerpt from my book, T: the Story of Testosterone. 👇🏽
Anthropologist Michael P. Masters made two false claims on @joerogan’s latest episode.
First, he incorrectly claimed that “we all start out as females.” This is a widespread misconception. In reality, humans begin development in a sexually undifferentiated state with bipotential gonads. Sexual differentiation occurs around weeks 6–8 of embryonic development.
Second, he referred to an “island in the Pacific” where children are supposedly born female and then turn into males at puberty. He claimed these children “are girls” and that their “ovaries descend as testicles” during puberty.
The place he is referring to is likely Papua New Guinea, but this is more often associated with a village named Salinas in the Dominican Republic. More importantly, he is misrepresenting the condition. It affects around 1 in 170 male births in Papua New Guinea, and about 1 in 90 male births in Salinas, and these children are NOT girls. They are boys (male) who merely appear female at birth due to a rare genetic condition called 5-alpha-reductase deficiency. This condition prevents the body from producing dihydrotestosterone (DHT) in utero, which is necessary for the development of male external genitalia.
This is the same condition that male athletes Caster Semenya and Imane Khelif have.
Contrary to what Masters says, these individuals are NOT born with “ovaries” that later “descend as testicles.” They are born with normal internal testes, which descend at puberty, at which point they also develop a penis. They are simply boys with a DSD that frequently gets them incorrectly recorded as female at birth.
Anthropologist Michael P. Masters made two false claims on @joerogan’s latest episode.
First, he incorrectly claimed that “we all start out as females.” This is a widespread misconception. In reality, humans begin development in a sexually undifferentiated state with bipotential gonads. Sexual differentiation occurs around weeks 6–8 of embryonic development.
Second, he referred to an “island in the Pacific” where children are supposedly born female and then turn into males at puberty. He claimed these children “are girls” and that their “ovaries descend as testicles” during puberty.
The place he is referring to is likely Papua New Guinea, but this is more often associated with a village named Salinas in the Dominican Republic. More importantly, he is misrepresenting the condition. It affects around 1 in 170 male births in Papua New Guinea, and about 1 in 90 male births in Salinas, and these children are NOT girls. They are boys (male) who merely appear female at birth due to a rare genetic condition called 5-alpha-reductase deficiency. This condition prevents the body from producing dihydrotestosterone (DHT) in utero, which is necessary for the development of male external genitalia.
This is the same condition that male athletes Caster Semenya and Imane Khelif have.
Contrary to what Masters says, these individuals are NOT born with “ovaries” that later “descend as testicles.” They are born with normal internal testes, which descend at puberty, at which point they also develop a penis. They are simply boys with a DSD that frequently gets them incorrectly recorded as female at birth.
Gay male couples—two men in a relationship—have the lowest breakup rates, which is striking given that gay men also have the highest rates of what evolutionary psychologists call extra-dyadic mating, a technical term for sex outside the primary relationship: infidelity, or cheating. In other words, they have the lowest breakup rates despite the highest levels of non-monogamous behavior.
After gay male couples, heterosexual couples—one man and one woman—have the next lowest breakup rates.
Interestingly, the highest breakup rates are found among female–female couples. Lesbian couples, on average, dissolve relationships more frequently than either gay male or heterosexual couples. One likely reason is that, across relationship types, women are more likely than men to initiate breakups. In heterosexual marriages, women initiate 60 to 70 percent of divorces. When you have two women in a relationship, you effectively double the likelihood that at least one partner will initiate a breakup, which raises the overall probability of relationship dissolution.
I spoke with HxA (@HdxAcademy) President John Tomasi for @HAFFS_Harvard on academic freedom, lack of knowledge about it, and graduate students:
“They are the major point of contact that many of our undergraduates have. They see their graduate student teaching fellows more than they see a lot of professors, unfortunately. And it’s the graduate students, countrywide, who’ve been, I think, responsible—or just clueless—about issues of academic freedom: things like suppressing certain opinions or penalizing the student papers; dismissing sections so that students can attend protests; allowing students to refuse to cooperate with Israeli students on joint projects; things where my sense is that it just never even occurred to them that this could be an issue, that graduate education is anything other than pushing their own political agendas. Bringing graduate students into the discussions on academic freedom is a longer-term project that we’re going to try to advance.”
Checklist for the virtuous skeptic: "Did I carefully consider my opponent’s arguments and not dismiss them out of hand? Did I interpret what my opponent said in the most charitable way before mounting a response? Did I seriously entertain the possibility that I might be wrong?" @slsatelopen.substack.com/pub/sallysatel/p/are-bad-researchers-ba…
On treating gender dysphoric minors with drugs and/or surgery: "Unfortunately, in the US, the issue has become politically polarized. But there's nothing intrinsically political about this issue. It is straightforwardly a medical issue, and shouldn't be split along party lines." @byrne_a
🔥 Exceptionally clear and compelling discussion, led by @DrJBhattacharya, with the authors of the HHS review of medical treatment for pediatric gender dysphoria. TLDR: the evidence base for benefits of drugs & surgery is weak, while harms (e.g., infertility) are clear. Methods were meticulous, they sought out critics, and no substantive challenges emerged. Listen and understand how ridiculous the charge of transphobia is. Attack evidence and arguments, not motives. Links to listen or watch 👇🏽. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/hhs-nih-evidence-review-on-… Youtube: youtu.be/nC9UP5yi7HY?t=27
"Older white men in charge of these institutions mostly kept their jobs....they embraced the moral claims of wokeness and made sure that the employment effects fell on the rising generation instead of on them." www.nytimes.com/2025/12/16/opinion/young-white-men-discri…
"So we still have so much to learn about how genes, hormones and culture all interact to produce sex differences in behavior. But all of the evidence we do have points in the same direction. And that is that differences in testosterone and evolutionary pressures explain why boys more than girls think it's a great idea to tackle their friends."
How Testosterone and Culture Shape Behavior | Carole Hooven @hoovlet | TED
"American higher-education system can’t really articulate what it is they’re trying to do. So as various controversies pop up — about disability accommodations or viewpoint discrimination or admissions — there’s not a coherent response because there are no guiding principles to refer back to." open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/american-higher-e…
Bombshell: Oliver Sacks (a humane man & a fine essayist) made up many of the details in his famous case studies, deluding neuroscientists, psychologists, & general readers for decades. The man who mistook his wife for a hat? The autistic twins who generated multi-digit prime numbers? The institutionalized, paralyzed man who tapped out allusions to Rilke? Made up to embellish the stories. Probably also: the aphasic patients who detected lies better than neurologically intact people, including Ronald Reagan's insincerity. www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/12/15/oliver-sacks-put-hi…
Public Hangings and the Politics of Virtue | Beautiful, brilliant, eloquent, tough-minded essay by Claire Lehmann on why public cruelty and lawless killing are neither effective nor manly. The celebration of gratuitous viciousness by the new MAGA right is sickening (and makes me glad I quickly bailed from UATX). Bravo, @clairlemonquillette.com/2025/12/09/public-execution-and-masculine-v…
"I was a red state governor. What I saw at Harvard surprised me." | Eric Holcomb refutes Harvard Derangement Syndrome on the right: "Friends warned me that a den of woke lions would maul me or try to turn me into one of them. Neither happened. I suffered no grievous insults, surrendered none of my conservative principles and witnessed no disruptive behavior on a quiet campus." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/12/08/harvard-eric-h…
According to a recent survey, the percentage of college students who listen to NPR is now 2 percent, down from 40 percent two decades ago.
The sudden cascade toward relentless race and gender propaganda that the network underwent in the mid 2010's was justified by referencing the need for generational change. Generation Z is more than half-nonwhite and nearly 30 percent LGBTQ identified. But it seems woke identitarianism appeals least of all to them.
What could it possibly be about 5 years of being dogpiled by gender goblins and wokescolded by the actor brats she made into millionaires that has made the formerly mild-mannered Rowling slightly more acerbic in tone than when she first posted on this topic
From 2021 when I still had my job at Harvard, in the middle of my cancellation. For those who knew how wrong it was & could've helped, but just stood by silently (or worse). You know who you are. It's not too late to speak out in support of those who were unjustly targeted.
I loved Carole’s book T: The Story of Testosterone… It made a huge impact on my understanding not only of the trans issue, but of… everything. If you haven’t read it yet, I highly recommend!
Jean Twenge (author of 10 RULES, GENERATIONS)@jean_twenge
💯 I would only add: This doesn't even count the issues with taking that Chromebook home and watching YouTube & streaming instead of doing homework, reading, journaling, or just getting to that state of boredom where kids discover what they're passionate about.
--I think teachers should have a computer in the classroom and way to show images and videos, if they choose to.
--I think @khanacademy has proven its worth, abundantly. I wish it could be offered on a dedicated device, with no distractions.
--In my several posts about ed tech, teachers often add comments. They rarely praise or defend ed tech.
--I think schools should have a computer room (as at the Waldorf schools that some tech execs seek out for the low-tech classrooms). Students need to learn to use computers and the internet.
--The most damaging mistake seems to have been the 1:1 devices -- putting a Chromebook or tablet on each student's desk. As a UNESCO report said in 2023, the distraction effects seem to exceed whatever benefits a few of the apps might have: www.unesco.org/gem-report/en/publication/technology
--I don't doubt that some apps which gamify learning have been proven to produce faster or better learning than older methods. BUT: if you gamify a third of the school day, the dopamine effects would cause the other 2/3 to seem more boring. So the net effect in a real classroom may be negative even if some apps showed consistent benefits in controlled tests.
--The big question we need answered is: does giving each student their own device, to use during much of the school day, end up promoting or interfering with education over the course of a year? Horvath's graph suggests that in real classrooms, it interferes.
--Putting devices on every student's desk seems to be the second giant uncontrolled experiment that the tech giants ran on our children, without our informed consent. (Smartphones and social media was the first.) They are already starting up the next one: chatbots for kids, and these will be pushed into schools too despite the already obvious harms.
🔥"Sometimes in the effort to fix problems with humanity, we think if we can just shut the right people up, these problems are going to go away. And it never, ever works." 🎁 listen.
As a professor, I have taught some genuinely disabled students who needed special accommodations for the opportunity to learn. But most of my officially “disabled” students have had no obvious disability at all. Some years ago, I had a student entitled to extra time on tests. Yet he was always the first to finish, and he always scored at or near the top. I’m 99% sure that his extra time was for competitive advantage, in case he needed it.
This is a great piece with some mind-boggling statistics.
- At Brown and Harvard, more than 20% of undergraduates are registered as disabled - At Amherst: more than 30 percent - At Stanford: nearly 40 percent
Soon, many of these schools "may have more students receiving [disability] accommodations than not, a scenario that would have seemed absurd just a decade ago."
As students and their parents have recognized the benefits of claiming disability—extended time on tests, housing accommodations, etc—the rates of disability at colleges, and especially at elite colleges, has exploded.
America used to stigmatize disability too severely. Now elite institutions reward it too liberally. It simply does not make any sense to have a policy that declares half of the students at Stanford cognitively disabled and in need of accommodations.
This is what happens when we fail to consider the interaction of sex-linked inherited biology (XY > high T) & socialization (sex roles). Doing our best to understand these interactions will best equip us to meet the different needs (on average) of each sex.
Just to be clear: I meant "this article" is what happens when we ignore biological bases of sex differences. The author assumes all are due to socialization, so if we want to change sex-linked outcomes, we simply have to socialize the boys out of "problematic" behaviors that--on average--may be more natural to them.
Can't recommend this discussion enough for those that are engaged on this issue (which SHOULD BE ALL OF YOU BTW!). Very accessible by normies who just want to better understand the facts around sexual biology. A hot topic here in WA for the next year, so thx @hoovlet!
Recently I had a great conversation with @coldxman (Coleman Hughes). I was not "kicked out" of Harvard...more like, pushed out. So here's some of that backstory, and happily, more of the story of testosterone & how it helps explain sex differences. youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo
As one of the authors of the HHS report, please allow me to chime in.
The peer-review process was similar to what is commonly used in scientific publication. HHS reached out to multiple parties, including leading advocates of pediatric transition, and asked them to review the report for accuracy. All but the American Academy of Pediatrics and the Endocrine Society understood the task and performed it. The American Psychiatric Association, a supporter of pediatric transition and critic of the HHS report, submitted a review.
What "process," specifically, do you think AAP and ES were unaware of, such that it made participating in peer-review impossible for them (but not, apparently, for the APA)? And if they wanted to participate but were confused about the process, why didn't they send any clarifying questions to HHS? Seems like a no-brainer for an organization that is confident that medical research supports pediatric medical transition.
Regarding the studies the APA "submitted" in its peer-review, we addressed these in our response to that review, which can be found in the Supplement.
In brief, APA identified 16 studies which it said we overlooked. We didn't: the APA seemed to have overlooked or ignored the evidence review. 12 of the studies cited by the APA were in fact included in the umbrella review SRs. Of the remaining 4, 3 were irrelevant to the topic (because they involved only adults or were not about medical transition), and one was published after the HHS report came out in May (though we did analyze the study subsequently and our analysis was published as part of the final version of the review).
I will include screenshots from the Supplement of the studies you are alluding to in the next post, for interested readers to see.
Some of the studies cited by critics of the report (APA, Dowshen et al., Rider et al.) are discussed in great detail in the HHS review itself. (See, for example, point #5 in the Dowshen et al. critique, and our response to it, both in the Supplement.) It's noteworthy that none of the critics actually engaged with our analysis of these studies. They simply reasserted their existence.
There was no transparency regarding the review process that HHS would allow, and multiple organizations did submit several peer reviewed studies related to risks/benefits.
Recently I had a great conversation with @coldxman (Coleman Hughes). I was not "kicked out" of Harvard...more like, pushed out. So here's some of that backstory, and happily, more of the story of testosterone & how it helps explain sex differences. youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo
The ghost in me, by @HeatherEHeying. "I saw the two bald eagles who are often by the lighthouse and I remembered that I love raptors. They work for no one. They are pair-bonded, weaving eternally with one another, both entwined and independent. I remembered those things, but I also could not remember why I cared." You don't have to be physically ill to understand. open.substack.com/pub/naturalselections/p/the-ghost-in-me
This clip is from episode # 374 of The Drive which was released on 12/1/25.
In the full episode, we cover:
-A stark contrast of male social bonding compared to females, and evolutionary parallels in chimpanzees -Why females evolved different behavioral strategies: nurturing, risk aversion, and the cultural norms that override biology -Why males commit disproportionately more violent crime, and how cultural and environmental forces shape aggression -How evolution, health, lifestyle, and androgen receptor biology shape modern testosterone replacement therapy (TRT)
Watch or listen (Ep. # 374) to the full episode on my website or your favorite podcast player.
" When universities fail to expose students to competing perspectives and don’t help them cultivate critical thinking, we shouldn’t be surprised that young people fall for dangerous ideas of the right or left. It’s up to universities to address what has gone wrong within their walls and to restore the values and practices that make for genuine liberal arts learning—and thoughtful, responsible citizens." @McCormickProf
A powerful article about the cancellation of Randy Thornhill & Craig T. Palmer for forwarding the heretical hypothesis that rape is actually about sex.
🚨NEW: MIT philosopher @byrne_a has written a rigorous, point-by-point response to @Anthrofuentes and @nathanlents' latest attempt to muddy the science of sex.
Byrne systematically dismantles their arguments on hermaphroditism, variation, "biocultural" jargon, and the redefinition of sex itself with precision.
If you want a clear, no-nonsense explanation of why the sex binary still stands, this is it.
Read Colin's whole tweet. The eLife paper commits thefallacy of claiming that sex isn't binary because some traits (height, gene expression, etc.) overlap between males and females . But that's no argument against the sex binary, for biological sex is based on gametic differences
🚨A new paper in eLife claims that overlapping patterns of gene expression in male and female tissues “defy” a binary model of sex.
It doesn’t. In fact, the authors' arguments are so bad that they rely on the very binary they say is an “illusion.”
For years, activists and a handful of ideologically captured scientists have tried to manufacture the impression that a paradigm shift occurred in biology declaring that sex is no longer viewed as a binary but as a spectrum.
But this scientific revolution never actually happened. Biologists made no new discoveries that fundamentally changed our understanding of sex.
My new essay explains why this latest study fails for the same reason most others do:
- It confuses downstream traits that vary by degree with the reproductive function that defines the sexes.
- It depends on knowing who is male and who is female before measuring anything.
- And it uses overlapping variation in one trait to claim that the categories themselves are fuzzy.
The authors totally ruined their otherwise solid and interesting study by unnecessarily framing it in the language of culture-war rhetoric.
“Andrew Berry’s roast made me pee my pants,” attendee Fred L. Klein ’28 said jokingly. “It’s the funniest thing I’ve ever watched.” I bash Harvard, but it's not all bad! Students are lucky to have teachers & mentors like Andrew, and we were lucky to have incredible students.
"Scott Leibowitz, a psychiatrist and board member of the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, an organization that sets protocols for transition treatment that were heavily criticized in the [HHS Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria] report, declined to comment on the report’s conclusions. But he described it as unreliable overall because the authors and peer reviewers lack clinical experience caring for transgender youths." @ScottLeibowitz
I'll have more to say about the HHS Review on pediatric gender dysphoria, to which I was a contributor, but for now, I encourage everyone to avoid forming opinions based on what others say. Read the peer reviews and our responses in the Supplement and make up your own mind. 1/2
The final version of the HHS Gender Dysphoria Review was released today, following external peer review. The peer reviews and our replies are in a 200+ pp. Supplement. 25 harsh critics and 7 supportive ones. Read the Supplement and make up your own mind.
Unmasked At Last: The 9 Authors of the Trump Administration Report On Pediatric Gender Medicine. So Who Are They?
🧵👇The coauthors, all skeptics or opponents of pediatric gender medicine, were finally revealed today after HHS published the final, peer-reviewed report.
.@HHS review of evidence for pediatric medical transition is now complete, & authors' names released. "These are not ideological cranks; they [incl. @LeorSapir & @byrne_a] are thoughtful researchers. Their core finding — that the evidence for these interventions is highly uncertain — echoes the results of systematic reviews in other countries. None of the peer reviews of the HHS report ultimately rebut that conclusion." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/11/19/transgender-pe…
Chimp violence in the news this month: the first observed lethal coalitional attack by bonobos, and now, evidence that killing members of a neighboring group doubled the fertility of local chimp females and boosted the survival of their infants. From @briwood1 et al:
The first (?) observed lethal coalitional attack by wild bonobos, a species with a reputation for making love, not war. A group of females apparently killed a male group-member:
"Williams and Ceci sent fake job applications to more than 800 faculty members in engineering, economics, biology, and psychology... As shown in the graph below, faculty expressed a strong preference for the female candidates - a 2:1 preference overall."
Someone needs to collect data on all the scholars who retired early because of wokeness; courses not taught; projects shelved or never started; readings removed from syllabi; mediocre readings added for protection from wokeness; etc. etc. Wokeness has had calamitous consequences.
"I look back on that time with considerable shame at my unwillingness to really speak out...Yet I did nothing...If I’d been drummed out, it would have been more miserable, but then I would have been able to leave." Yes, being drummed out is more miserable. www.chronicle.com/article/why-jill-lepore-nearly-quit-har…
"Pornography is static media for passive consumption. A.I. lovers pose a far greater threat, operating more like human escorts without agency, boundaries or time limits. [These should be classified] not simply as another form of media, but as a dependency-fostering product with known psychological risks, like gambling or tobacco." www.nytimes.com/2025/11/17/opinion/her-film-chatbots-roma…
"Last year, in a guide to reporting on sex and gender, BBC presenters were told to challenge guests who accuse others of transphobia after the broadcaster admitted that news reports on JK Rowling did not meet its editorial standards." archive.ph/2025.11.15-232524/https://www.thetimes.com/uk/…
Couple things to say here, although I can't help with the actual question that you asked.
First, I doubt that Bret (or I) ever specified that gender studies departments in particular acted as a kind of affirmative action within academia, but rather that they, like *all* of the grievance studies fields that have been newly made up, accomplish that goal. To the degree that the various "Grievance Studies" disciplines have any reality to them, they are downstream of anthropology and sociology and psychology, which are themselves downstream of biology, so the connection to biology is looser to begin with. And even the "legitimate" social sciences have, for a very long time, liked to pretend that they have no relationship to biology at all.
Second, the distinction that I make between sex and gender--which I have done in many articles, on podcasts, in lectures, and in our book--is based on the biological framing of "sex" vs "sex role." In non-human animals, "sex role" is used to describe the sex-typical behaviors of a particular species; what we call "sex role" in non-human animals is what is being called "gender" in humans. Bret's framing of the distinction is slightly different and tighter: he says sex is the hardware, gender the software. Either way, there's a causal relationship. And while it might be useful to collapse the two categories in some circumstances--just like it might be useful to collapse the categories of brain and mind into one--there will certainly remain circumstances where it's useful to be able to describe sex--which is about gamete size and motility and, in mammals and birds, immutable--as different from sex-typical behaviors, which can, after all, sometimes be adopted by the opposite sex.
One more thing--I never speak of humans have a "gender," or being "gendered," because of the way it has been adopted and abused. Because I have studied sex roles in other animals, and know them to be real, I don't object to thinking about sex roles in humans, though, or to saying, for instance, that people (like me) can be gender non-conforming. The language obviously gets messy once you're using words that have been weaponized by an activist army who have no allegiance to reality.
The Chief Constable tells the committee that last month, Police Scotland took the decision that we "record a person's biological sex, and where relevant, their transgender status, of suspects and victims of all crimes and offences".
Police Scotland Chief Constable Jo Farrell: "A man who rapes or attempts to rape a woman, girl or other victim is, should be, and will be recorded by Police Scotland as a male."
"Let me be clear - my priority is to protect victims."
I think @coldxman Coleman got a good interview out of me! Mostly about testosterone and sex differences. Looks like there was an issue with the link below (probably my fault, but thanks @sapinker for the tweet!) so, try this one: youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo
Coleman Hughes interviews Carole Hooven, my biologist colleague who was Exhibit A for Harvard's academic freedom problem (and a major reason we started the Council on Academic Freedom @cafh 2 1/2 years ago): Her life at Harvard was made untenable after saying there were two sexes. youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo via @YouTube
"Scientific evidence showed there were physical advantages to being...male that remained with athletes, including those who had taken treatment to reduce testosterone." Thanks to the brave women & scientists who pushed for the return of fairness & sanity. www.thetimes.com/sport/olympics/article/olympic-ioc-trans…
This book left me alternately infuriated and devastated, but more than anything it was so incredibly gratifying to read. What an insane time we have been through! And @benappel was right there in the epicenter.
Also hard to put down! I had an old-school weekend, on the couch with my nose buried in a book. Highly recommend!😍😍😍
🚨BREAKING: My Commentary in Archives of Sexual Behavior—“Why There Are Exactly Two Sexes”—has been published!
In it, I explain why biological sex is binary in all anisogamous species, defined strictly by the type of gamete (sperm or ova) an organism’s reproductive system has the biological function to produce.
The paper also debunks five activist-inspired models that try to redefine sex:
1. Mating-type model – confuses microbial compatibility types with sexes.
2. Karyotype model – mistakes chromosomal variations for additional sexes.
3. Spectrum model – misuses DSDs to claim sex is continuous.
4. Polythetic model – redefines the sexes as “clusters” of traits rather than categories rooted in reproductive function. (this model is self-refuting, read the paper to understand why)
5. Multilevel model – wrongly distributes “sex” across traits (genes, hormones, behavior) instead of gametes. (this model is also self-refuting)
Across all organisms with anisogamy, there are only two fundamental strategies based on reproductive function: male and female. Everything else—chromosomes, hormones, morphology—is derivative, not definitional.
If you're looking for an academic paper to cite laying out the empirical case for why sex is binary and why all other models either totally fail or actually presuppose the binary gametic model, this is it. 🔗link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-025-03348-3
I'm constantly amazed & confused by the use of ad-hominems—on public platforms—by academics. Especially when it's a philosopher, I try to understand the motivation and provide a bit of feedback via email. It generally fails, as it did here, spectacularly. Today's example is from a UVM philosopher, who completely shut me down, writing only "Please do not contact me again."
Below is: 1. His initial Bluesky post 2. My email response 3. His reply 4. His follow-up Bluesky post threatening to share my email if I contacted him again. The only email I sent him is the one below.
So I'm heading him off and just revealing my nastiness right here to all on X. Links at the end.
this is not to deny that there are also biologists who prominently support transphobia. it seems to me that many of the prominent names have left the field for the full-time grift (Colin Wright, Weinstein & Heying who were always cranks, Carole Hooven, Dawkins too). could be selection bias though"
2. My email to Weiner in response:
On Nov 4, 2025, at 12:01 PM, Hooven, Carole Kennedy <hooven@fas.harvard.edu> wrote:
Dear Professor Weiner,
I am writing in regard to your Bluesky post of November 1, in which you included me among “biologists who prominently support transphobia.” You also speculated that I (and others) “have left the field for the full-time grift,” and call us “cranks."
I was hoping you could, at a minimum, clarify these rather uncharitable comments. First, could you please explain why you believe I “support transphobia”? Perhaps you mean that I have supported individuals you regard as transphobic, rather than that I am myself transphobic—but I’d appreciate your elaboration.
Second, what leads you to conclude that I’ve left academia for “full-time grift”? If that were the case, it would have been a stupid move, given that leaving a career I loved resulted in the loss of most of my previous income.
Finally, do you ever worry about what this kind of public rhetoric models for your philosophy students? Essentially calling people like me, Richard Dawkins [@RichardDawkins] or Colin Wright [@SwipeWright] “transphobic cranks and grifters,” as a response to disagreement about substantive and controversial issues?
Thank you for your time. Best, Carole Hooven
3. Weiner's response to my email:
From: Matt Weiner <Matt.Weiner@uvm.edu> Date: Tuesday, November 4, 2025 at 12:13 PM To: Hooven, Carole Kennedy <hooven@fas.harvard.edu> Subject: Re: Your recent Bluesky post
Allerlei biologische factoren bepalen hoe je je gedraagt. Dat daarbij een belangrijke rol is weggelegd voor testosteron legt @hoovlet uit in dit geweldige gesprek. Een verhelderend college evolutiebiologie, maar ook geschiedschrijving: de kwalijke gevolgen van cancel culture.
Today on Conversations with @Coldxman, former Harvard biologist @Hoovlet explains sex differences, how testosterone shapes bodies and behavior, and what happens when science collides with ideology.
Sports categories based on hormone levels really is ridiculous. For one thing, male (high T) puberty provides permanent & significant advantages, eg in height, lung capacity & musculature. These do not vanish when testosterone is later blocked and levels are in the female range.
Neil deGrasse Tyson recently suggested separating sports by hormone levels instead of sex. Evolutionary biologist @Hoovlet calls that idea “a terrible, terrible, terrible” one.
Why? Because the performance gap between male and female athletes isn’t erased by lowering testosterone after puberty.
“There are high school boys who can beat female Olympic champions in many events.”
Has a great time with @coldxman. Started with my Harvard debacle, then dove into the juicy science of sex differences. The easiest (but most fun) question was my view on whether sports categories should be based on hormones rather than sex, as recently suggested by a famous (male) astrophysicist (non-athlete). www.thefp.com/p/hormones-ideology-and-the-cost-of
Has a great time with @coldxman. Started with my Harvard debacle, then dove into the juicy science of sex differences. The easiest (but most fun) question was my view on whether sports categories should be based on hormones rather than sex, as recently suggested by a famous (male) astrophysicist (non-athlete). www.thefp.com/p/hormones-ideology-and-the-cost-of
"Some women on high-dose testosterone experience a level of arousal so intense that they find it uncomfortable." In print version of the NYT Mag today! @susandominus
🧵1/3 Women and testosterone in NYT! Thrilled to have been able to help out with some background research for this excellent article, and to see my book—T, the Story of Testosterone—get a shout out! By @susandominus, who was curious, open, fun & rigorous. www.nytimes.com/2025/10/22/magazine/testosterone-women-he…
The most violent stage of life is toddlerhood (a finding by the Canadian psychologist Richard Tremblay I cited in The Blank Slate and The Better Angels of Our Nature).
"When institutions align with human nature, they can guide self-interest into cooperation, aggression into justice, & tribalism into civic identity. When they ignore it, they risk collapse, corruption, or unintended negative consequences." @adam0mary humanprogress.org/what-you-need-to-know-about-humans-to-a…
Thanks! We also used T - along with Troubled by @robkhenderson (who I believe is where I first heard of your book) - as one of the foundations for our nature vs nurture mental model -
Three of the academics named in this post are previous recipients of our Hero of Intellectual Freedom award. Carole Hooven describes the suffocating atmosphere of "informal censorship" at so many campuses:
“T: The Story of Testosterone”... is one of the best books I’ve read in years. With a blend of scientific rigor, thoughtful intellectual exploration & laugh-out-loud humor, Hooven provides a comprehensive exploration of testosterone." 🙏🏽@AskeladdenTXaskeladdencapital.com/t-the-story-of-testosterone-by-caro…
These Harvard students…did not react well to the report on grade inflation:
“The whole entire day, I was crying. I skipped classes on Monday, and I was just sobbing in bed because I felt like I try so hard in my classes, and my grades aren’t even the best. It just felt soul-crushing.”
“What makes a Harvard student a Harvard student is their engagement in extracurriculars. Now we have to throw that all away and pursue just academics. I believe that attacks the very notion of what Harvard is.”
“I can’t reach my maximum level of enjoyment just learning the material because I’m so anxious about the midterm, so anxious about the papers, and because I know it’s so harshly graded. If that standard is raised even more, it’s unrealistic to assume that people will enjoy their classes.”
Many institutions that used to be dominated by men are now at gender parity, or even majority-female. This is particularly true in academia. How will this change these institutions? More importantly, how will it change society?
The recent spate of discussion over “feminization” or “the great feminization” includes some actual research on this question and a lot of searingly hot takes. Let’s try to separate the wheat from the chaff.
The current surge of interest in this issue apparently started with a speech Helen Andrews gave at the National Conservatism Conference in September. She adapted it into an essay in Compact that spread far and wide — or far and wide enough, at least, that David French wrote a critical response to it for his New York Times newsletter. Andrews cited an article the social psychologists Cory Clark and Bo Winegard wrote on this subject for Quillette in 2022. Clark has also published academic research on the question. Richard Hanania is very skeptical and ties the shoddy reasoning (as he sees it) animating feminization claims to broader problems with anti-intellectualism on the right.
I won’t leave you in suspense: While I think it’s well and good to highlight sizable sex differences in attitudes and behavior and to speculate about what they might mean as institutions become more female, I find a lot of the theorizing going on here bizarre. In many cases, proponents of the “feminization” theory (theories, really) are making the exact same sorts of leaps of logic and wildly overconfident claims they’d usually accuse “woke” researchers of making.
But I want to put this controversy into context. Because part of what makes this an interesting story is that academia, on the whole, has not done a good job taking sex differences seriously. In certain ways, the present proponents of “feminization” theory simply reflect the pendulum swinging back and wildly overshooting a reasonable center point. So all of this is easier to understand if we zoom out to better understand the broader context
Don’t You Dare Write Anything On That Slate! In most corners of academia where those on the political left dominate — so in most corners of academia — the idea that biological factors could contribute to sex differences between men and women is seen as pseudoscientific, if not offensive.
The specifics vary from field to field. But in many areas, it’s considered a fact that biology couldn’t be responsible for these differences — rather, the differences arise solely due to external factors like cultural pressures, most notably discrimination against women.
To take just one example, regular readers of this newsletter might recall the recent news coverage over “mankeeping,” or the idea that women shoulder a disproportionate amount of the load for ensuring their male partners maintain decent social ties.
In the academic article that kicked off that discussion, the authors claimed, without citation, that “Difficulties with making or maintaining close bonds between men is not attributable to biological gender differences but instead to stringent ideological barriers that men face in the formation of nonromantic social ties,” emphasis mine. The lead author is a social psychologist and her co-author is a sociologist in training, and this view is fairly standard across many areas of academia. It’s actually a pretty radical theory, given what we know about the psychological effects of sex hormones; one could easily argue that the default assumption should be that biology does contribute to behavioral differences between men and women. And yet within certain academic bubbles, you don’t even really need to defend the blank slate view — everyone knows it’s true.
This has been a sore spot for some academics for a long time — and not just conservative ones. Steven Pinker has written about it a lot, most notably in his important 2005 book The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature, and other academics, like my friend Carole Hooven, have tried to beat the drum that men and women are different, that those differences have at least partial biological roots, and that it’s okay to say so.
The false “consensus” criticized by Pinker, Hooven, and others has been enforced not through some sort of breakthrough showing that biological differences have no psychological impact (it’s hard to imagine what some sort of breakthrough would even look like), but through moral suasion and bullying. If you argue that biology can explain male-female differences, in short, you’re either a misogynist or a misogynist-in-training. You’re saying, or at least implying, that women are inferior to males, and after thousands of years of patriarchal rule that is only just now beginning to crack, the last thing we need is for these ideas to become scientifically respectable.
Of course none of these claims flow directly from the mere observation that it’s likely biological factors help contribute to sex differences, and yet that hasn’t stopped the blank slaters from, in some cases, exacting a heavy toll on those who make certain arguments about sex differences.
The Larry Summers “scandal” is a prime example. Helen Andrews treats it as a uniquely important moment, arguing that “The entire ‘woke’ era could be extrapolated from that moment, from the details of how Summers was cancelled and, most of all, who did the cancelling: women.” Subscribe to read the rest!
Yup, the excellent book 'Testosterone' by @hoovlet explains this interesting phenomenon.
Most mammals have testosterone levels that peak during mating season, then drop afterwards. Human males are unusual in that we maintain fairly consistent levels throughout the year.
— Deer with artificially-maintained T-levels continued to fight/defend territory and neglected their young.
— Lizards with artificially-maintained T continued to scrap and entered the next mating season in poor physical condition.
One advantage with humans is self-awareness.
Tonnes of guys I know are on TRT and have elevated levels of testosterone and competitive behaviour.
We understand, 'I feel motivated to do stupid, dumb, alpha-male things that will not serve me or my family'.
We can observe our own primal, competitive instincts, laugh at them and choose to be peaceful and caring.
Moreover, to channel our competitive behaviours into useful creative work.
"Today’s posturing is a day late, a dollar short, and, unfortunately, far too politically expedient to take seriously. It’s not that I disagree with what elite campus presidents have said over the past week or two—it’s that these leaders have no standing to say it with a straight face." @rickhess99@AEIwww.aei.org/op-eds/campus-leaders-conveniently-find-the-s…
Excellent list of articles that explain the evidence showing that while sex-associated traits are on a spectrum (even chromosomes, features of genitals, beards and identities), there are still only 2 sexes, male and female!
"The secret of freedom is courage. Right now is the time to invite speakers with opposed and controversial views, to set challenging texts, to teach syllabi that are disruptive and uncomfortable. Now is the time to speak out where once you might have been wary. "
"We propose that the SJC promulgate the following rule: Supreme Judicial Court Rule 5: Ensuring free expression and clarity regarding the meaning of pronouns. In the course of legal proceedings, no judge shall prohibit or discourage any party, attorney, or witness from using sex-based language, including pronouns or descriptors."
The @Stanford faculty senate shamed itself when it declared @ScottAtlas_IT's anti-lockdown, anti-school closure views "anathema" in 2020. Dr. Scott Atlas was right, and the faculty senate wrong.
On Thursday, the faculty senate voted to restrain itself from rebuking individual faculty members in the future. This vote represents an implied rebuke of its own 2020 action and is a step forward.
Top universities like Stanford are starting to relearn why institutional neutrality is wise and absolutely necessary for academic freedom to thrive. That's good.
But to make things right, the Stanford faculty senate should officially rescind its rebuke of Dr. Atlas and issue him a sincere apology.
If you're wondering about the helicopters over Harvard right now, I believe it's in response to a recent shooting (around 11 am). Suspect is on the loose and you're supposed to shelter in place if you're in the area. "Harvard Alert Cambridge Police are reporting that an unidentified male on a bicycle just shot at another person on Sherman Street. The suspect is on a bicycle heading toward Garden Street. Please avoid the area and shelter in place."
"Cambridge Police has communicated that there is no ongoing public safety risk at this time. The shelter in place is lifted. Please continue to be vigilant and report any suspicious activity to the HUPD at 617-495-1212."
The comments on yesterday's excellent NYT article on women who take high levels of T (link below) are fascinating and revealing. Here's part of one, reflecting a widespread misconception: "Hormones are pretty safe as far as drugs go: they aren't toxic, we have biological pathways for metabolism, the side effects are enjoyable, every effect is reversible in principle."
I responded, and I'll paste it below. I'd like to get the word out that hormones are far from harmless chemicals. They keep us alive and support reproduction, but they can also harm or even kill us. Altering our naturally-produced hormones has profound, systemic effects, and should be undertaken only with a solid understanding of the many potential risks (and there's still so much we don't know!). There's much more evidence about potential harms; this is a tiny snapshot.
"Naturally produced hormones in healthy people are generally safe, but I would not say the same is true for exogenous ones. Your nephew [a male who identifies as trans and is apparently on estrogen] might be happy, but for many, some permanent effects are undesirable or even tragic.
For example, taking high levels of exogenous T can induce potentially permanent sterility in adults of both sexes, and it will induce sterility in females when taken prior to the development of the reproductive system. Exogenous estrogen with T suppression in a pre-pubertal male (who moves right from puberty blockers to cross-sex hormones) will similarly result in a loss of fertility, with impairment of erectile and ejaculatory function. This may be desired, but it is permanent nonetheless. And taking "steroids" in adulthood also comes with a list of toxic effects, including liver damage.
As for "hormones," naturally high cortisol—say, from chronic stress—can suppress the immune and reproductive systems in addition to leading to muscle wasting; and too much insulin will kill you.
I agree that cross-sex hormones can help us understand the opposite sex, and that’s one benefit (and there are others). But many effects of hormones of all kinds are undesirable and/or irreversible. So while they do lots of good, we should take seriously their power and potential for harm."
🧵1/3 Women and testosterone in NYT! Thrilled to have been able to help out with some background research for this excellent article, and to see my book—T, the Story of Testosterone—get a shout out! By @susandominus, who was curious, open, fun & rigorous. www.nytimes.com/2025/10/22/magazine/testosterone-women-he…
🧵1/3 Women and testosterone in NYT! Thrilled to have been able to help out with some background research for this excellent article, and to see my book—T, the Story of Testosterone—get a shout out! By @susandominus, who was curious, open, fun & rigorous. www.nytimes.com/2025/10/22/magazine/testosterone-women-he…
2/3 “I wanted to have sex with my husband, I was just too pissed off at him to do it.”
TLDR: when women take T, they can experience some life-changing effects they love: high libido, improved mood, energy & drive to get stuff done. While many women will feel some improvements on a lower dose, the profound changes most often require a level of T well above the natural range for women. Such high T tends to come with some unwanted side effects, like: too much "manly" hair on the face & body; loss of it on the head; acne; irritability; and a distracting obsession with sex. Women on high T have described getting a glimpse into how the "other half" lives (I write about this in T).
3/3 More info (open access), from the "Global Consensus Position Statement on the Use of Testosterone Therapy for Women," by a team led by Susan Davis (quoted in the article), an Australian researcher and leading expert in T on women: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6821450/
“I wanted to have sex with my husband, I was just too pissed off at him to do it.”
TLDR: when women take T, they can experience some life-changing effects they love: high libido, improved mood, energy & drive to get stuff done. While many women will feel some improvements on a lower dose, the profound effects most often require a level of T well above the natural range for women. Such high T tends to come with some unwanted side effects, like: too much "manly" hair on the face & body; loss of it on the head; acne; irritability; and a distracting obsession with sex. Women on high T have described getting a glimpse into how the "other half" lives (I write about this in T).
More info (open access), from the "Global Consensus Position Statement on the Use of Testosterone Therapy for Women," by a team led by Susan Davis (quoted in the article), an Australian researcher and leading expert in T on women: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6821450/
My understanding is that findings like that are reverse causation--people in poor health often stop drinking because of it. This links to some recent reports saying even moderate drinking is bad for you (and quotes @KeithNHumphreys who might know more). med.stanford.edu/news/insights/2025/08/alcohol-consumptio…
"We observed a significant association between mild to moderate drinking w/ decreased risk of all-cause mortality." I'd reduced to 2 drinks/wk (for health), but this study suggests I can return to 1/day. What is the best evidence against doing this? www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-55434-6.pdf
Why yes, we DO defend people all across the spectrum—proudly!Because if you don’t, you’re not really standing for principle; you’re just a political project and a an actual threat to the academic freedom and free speech rights of those you happen to despise.
But hey, if you’d like, you can donate specifically just for the endless times we defend professors on the left. We have plenty of those cases too!
What do you say? Can I pencil you in for a $50 monthly recurring gift just for the times we’re doing your job for you? We might even throw in a FIRE tote bag!
Thanks, @hoovlet, for amplifying @ImHardcory's enlightening (befitting a journal article) and yet accessible read.
I see it as a good, timely companion to @herandrews' recent, viral essay on the "Great Feminization."
I'd love to see more researchers disseminate their work – not only abstracts of (copyrighted) peer-reviewed articles, but also working papers and ideas – more broadly this way. (Enough researcher/professor friends, mostly '80s kids, are proudly, understandably, off social media.)
They'd be similarly refreshing antidotes to slop regurgitated by so-called influencers and ill-informed culture warriors – more so in non-Stem fields in which it may be harder to invalidate opinions passed off as theories.
Re. your study, @ImHardcory: While academia has presented a useful case, I'd be interested, even if worried (like Helen Andrews), in seeing more such studies about how female ascendancy has been changing other domains, including business, media/entertainment, and law/politics.
I also hope to see more commentary on the downstream effects (e.g., men's shying away from certain fields and vocations) and societal consequences. Also, of the forms and effects of predictable backlash and even a pendulum swing. (The political ascendancy of @realDonaldTrump, for better or worse, is arguably one form.)
While women may have historically had more private power and men more public power, across cultures, there may be something to learn from the particular distribution of power in certain matrilineal (not quite matriarchal) cultures, too. India has had some of those. See screenshot.
Also, what we have seen is that when women have risen to positions of power in structures and cultures reflecting the "values, priorities, and operational modes of men," i.e., in a "man's world," it is typically by embodying those operational modes to an extreme. E.g., Margaret Thatcher, Golda Meir, Indira Gandhi, and @HillaryClinton.
I hope not to see, in increasingly feminized institutions and cultures, men's seeing it as necessary, to thrive, to embody female operational modes to an extreme.
It has been unhealthy enough for society – and even male-female relationships and families – that natural masculinity has been getting tarred with the broad brush of "toxic" masculinity in recent years.
"Visualize the alternative" is advice that more of us would do well to heed.
While countless women may be celebrating the Great Feminization, understandably, I doubt that most women will want a world in which men choose, en masse or even in sizable fractions, not to strive for ascendancy, not to step up, and not to lead.
Solidarity with Michael Ben-Gad, Professor of Economics at City University.
Students are demanding his sacking simply because he is an Israeli Jew who has done (mandatory) military service.
The antisemitic harassment he is being subjected to is horrifying. I hesitate to amplify it, but British academics need to understand what is happening.
"Women have stronger desires to punish, name call, publicly shame, ostracize, strip of prestige and power, and fire scholars who forward morally undesirable ideas." Resist the urge to look away or deny. Do consider the research and argument.
1. What happens when women, for the first time in history, gain real cultural power? I explore this question in “From Worriers to Warriors: The Cultural Rise of Women,” now in press at @JConIdeas:
Professors Need to Diversify What They Teach: A quantitative survey of college syllabi show that they are massively tilted toward a few tendentious left-wing sources, especially on race & crime and on Israel-Palestine. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/we-analyzed-universit…
A sobering essay by a Harvard evolutionary biologist on how elite academia has turned disagreement about basic biology into moral warfare. Scientists who say there are two sexes aren’t just “wrong” anymore — they’re accused of being politically dangerous, tools of the political right designed to harm gender minorities. 🔗 www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/there-are-onl…
True story: In 2005 when Larry Summers was fired I was one of the only grad students in my PhD program who thought it was total BS and thought everyone needed to get a grip.
What if wokeness and cancel culture are rooted —not in Marxism or postmodernism—but in the feminization of culture? Fascinating essay by @herandrews Link below.
Richard Dawkins explains why the gamete-based sex concept not only applies universally, but lists 14 phenomena that can't be understood without it. Thus the concept is not just universal, but utilitarian: no other concept can explain those phenomena.
📊Please participate, and share my research!📊 HAVE SIBLINGS? Take my 10-15 minute online survey study investigating decisions in response to sibling injury. Must have at least one 12+yo biological brother/sister. *LINK IN FIRST COMMENT* PLEASE RETWEET / SHARE WIDELY
The first time one of your children is seriously ill or hurt, you pass through a portal into a new world. You learn to recognize fear in its purest form—hot and metallic, writes Abigail Shrier for The Free Press. www.thefp.com/p/abigail-shrier-when-your-child-is-sick?ta…
"For the first time, you understand that you would rip the face from any adult who would intentionally hurt them. You would do it gladly. Go ahead, you think. Try me."
When everyone knows that everyone knows... Photos courtesy of Michelle and Justin, soon to be newlyweds (I'm the officiant!), Glorya Kaufman Performing Arts Center in West LA. A great convo on all things common knowledge.
Today's the day to raise several glasses to @bariweiss, @NellieBowles, and everyone who helped make @TheFP the hottest property in American journalism.
Amazing. Most speeches from the last NatCon have a few dozen views. “The Great Feminization” is now approaching 100,000. I’m truly grateful to see this important message spreading. A few additional thoughts:
My NatCon speech on the Great Feminization is up to 28K views in one week, by the way. I’m pleasantly surprised by the positive reception and grateful to the many writers and anons whose work on feminization I was able to draw on. youtube.com/watch?v=EWLbq7PlrIA
The most important study on American attitudes toward political violence to date, conducted by the Skeptic Research Center. RT widely as the results are striking and revealing: www.skeptic.com/r/f82739c0?m=181f5dbf-e6ea-4838-af95-b2f0…
"36% of those with a graduate...degree agreed at least somewhat with... “If you are protesting something unjust, it is reasonable to damage property,” while 40% agreed that “Violence is often necessary to create social change.”" @TheSkepticMag research.skeptic.com/support-for-political-violence-among…
.@RichardDawkins highlights an example of pressure to desex language from my chapter in The War on Science. Another egregious example included is a letter to a Lancet journal urging WHO not to overlook breastfeeding women in DRC. An editor asked us to add "chestfeeding parents"
Loretta. The world of trans-activism is one big Monty Python sketch – except that its po-faced pomposity drains it of all humour. Referee of paper on endometriosis requested “women” be replaced by “people with female-identified reproductive organs.” Quoted in The War on Science.
"Locked away in the ivory tower remain many intelligent and intellectually curious men and women, working hard on important and interesting questions. They must be incentivized to fight back against what many no doubt privately recognize to be a stifling and pernicious culture of complacence."
Of Note: "The gametic definition matters in science. It’s the only one that applies across all sexually reproducing species. It is indispensable in evolutionary biology, medicine, and public health." @hoovlet www.aei.org/articles/there-are-only-two-gametes/
It is pub day for my first and last book, Drink Your Way Sober: The Science-Based Method to Break Free From Alcohol. I am marking this momentous occasion by… recording a podcast and taking Moose for a walk. Please buy it! drinkyourwaysober.com
Hello everyone. My book, "Drink Your Way Sober: The Science-Based Method to Break Free From Alcohol," is out tomorrow. I've done a bunch of interviews lately and I'm going to post them in this thread rather than repeatedly spamming you, and in exchange I would really appreciate if you buy 10 or 12 copies of my book. Thank you. Glad we're agreed on that. www.drinkyourwaysober.com
📊Please participate, and share my study!📊 PARENTS! Take my 10-15 minute online survey study investigating decisions in response to offspring injury. Must have at least one 12+yo biological son/daughter. *LINK IN FIRST COMMENT* PLEASE RETWEET / SHARE WIDELY
"Mr. Kirk was the innocent victim of a coldblooded killer...who should be held to account by the criminal justice system. Cooler heads on the right must push back against the all-too-human temptation to lash out against their apparent enemies." @sapinkerwww.nytimes.com/2025/09/28/opinion/charlie-kirk-republica…
La bióloga Carole Hooven, autora de T: The story of testosterone y colega de Dawkins, Pinker y C. Wright ha publicado un artículo en Tablet Magazine donde afirma que solo hay dos gametos.
Excellent. @F_Sid_Dougan clearly and concisely answers the question of why we have two —and only two—gamete types, and thus, two sexes. The explanation is fascinating and powerful, particularly for understanding the origins of "traditional" sex roles.
🧵 1/15 - "THERE ARE ONLY TWO SEXES AND THERE CAN NEVER BE MORE" - my publication in Archives of Sexual Behavior. Thread with link and very brief summaries of the main points I cover in the paper...
A big article in Tablet by Carole Hooven on why sex is binary, and the aggressive demeanor and ideological motives of the "spectrum" people. They do not seeks truth, but the appearance of virtue when they're seen as buttressing the oppressed.
"You can of course use science to better the world in a direction that you want. Innovations in medicine, like mRNA vaccines, is one example. But what you can’t do, and what Richardson and Fuentes are trying to do, is to bend science out of shape, pretending that it conforms to and buttresses a particular ideology." @Evolutionistruewhyevolutionistrue.com/2025/09/26/carole-hooven-in-tablet…
Carole Hooven trata aquí el tema de que sólo hay dos sexos. Por decir eso la obligaron a irse de Harvard. Pero, como ella cuenta muy bien, el problema no es que la acusen de estar equivocada y que los que piensan diferente aporten sus argumentos, no. La cuestión es que, como es típico del wokismo, sufre una condena moral. No puede pensar de buena fe, es decir por razones científicas, que hay dos sexos, basándose en la evidencia. No, sus oponentes le atribuyen motivos políticos y morales siniestros, acusándola de usar esta postura científica para promover agendas discriminatorias.
Have you ever heard of a cell that's halfway between an egg and a sperm? Carole Hooven @hoovlet explains why there are only two biological sexes. (This scientific banality, perversely denied by some gender activists, has nothing to do with trans rights or women's rights, since those are moral and political issues, not a scientific ones.) www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/there-ar…
Have you ever heard of a cell that's halfway between an egg and a sperm? Carole Hooven @hoovlet explains why there are only two biological sexes. (This scientific banality, perversely denied by some gender activists, has nothing to do with trans rights or women's rights, since those are moral and political issues, not a scientific ones.) www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/there-ar…
Fresh from my lab mate @F_Sid_Dougan publishing his paper explaining why there are only two sexes and why there can never be any more, my good friend @hoovlet publishes this terrific piece on recent controversies on the topic.
"Campuses must be less like neighborhoods in which people are bombarded by signals about what they should believe and more like places in which there is no doubt that discovering truth is the top priority." www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/there-ar…
Free MITx course, Minds & Machines, starts Thursday Sept 25. Consciousness, dualism, the Chinese Room, the Turing test, color, perception, and more. Enroll here: mitxonline.mit.edu/courses/course-v1:MITxT+24.09x/.
"The norms of our liberal-democratic republican politics are not intended to quiet us down but to ensure that we respond to arguments with arguments, that we work to persuade & not to dictate. This can be immensely frustrating." By Yuval Levin @AEI the-assassins-other-target.tiiny.co
Russ Roberts, host of @EconTalker, and I discuss aspects of college life: snitching, microaggressions, and claims of loneliness. Full episode out soon.
So your theory is that by calling the vast majority of Americans — millions of whom largely agree with you on other weighty matters — “enthusiastic” fascists because even the slightest disagreement with you on this point makes a person irredeemably evil or villainous you will somehow win your larger struggle? In other words, you think this is the approach to being able to influence the historical narrative in the way you describe. Do I have that right?
Last week, @Reuters published an article on the Charlie Kirk assassination that falsely attributed a quote to Rachel Kleinfeld, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. The article claimed Kleinfeld said “the bullet casings’ symbology suggested the shooter was affiliated with the Groyper movement, tied to far-right activist Nick Fuentes.” Kleinfeld never made this statement. After she complained, Reuters quietly removed the quote without acknowledging the error. Only after Kleinfeld and her colleagues demanded a formal retraction did Reuters comply—three days later. www.reuters.com/world/us/accused-sniper-jailed-charlie-ki… Read Kleinfeld’s alarming thread below:
"Our political adversaries will still be here tomorrow; they will be part of any future we build. Any politics not premised in that reality will be dangerously delusional and can only point us down." @TheFP
I don't why it's still shocking to me how out of touch leftists are with normies and normal values but no, we don't want people celebrating political assassinations anywhere near our kids.
"There are four new sexes you hadn’t even heard of! Very complex, very complex, you see. This does not make the liberal sound smart. It makes him sound like an idiot who’s easily drawn to fashionable-but-silly ideas." I was happy to contribute to this, by @jbarro.
Two great minds (Niall Ferguson & Andrew Sullivan), disagreeing, with humor and clarity. Can't recommend this conversation highly enough.
"That's what history is like. So you and I have had this conversation. I lean to the Republic is going to be fine. You lean to this is probably terminal." @nfergus "No, I'm worried sick. That's what I'm leaning towards. And it's the job of people like me to raise concerns and to point stuff out. It's, it's not a prediction. Yeah." @sullydish
I didn't know Charlie personally. But he did send me a kind message last year. "I love all people" is what he said. If that is any indication of who the man was, then this country has lost someone special today.
Partisan politics did not stand in the way of him paying me a compliment, and it should not stand in the way of mourning him either.
We cannot become a society where expressing political views, even controversial ones, leads to violence. Whatever you think of his politics, Charlie was a decent man, a patriot, and a brave defender of his values. My heart goes out to his wife and his kids.
Freddie is looking down and giving y'all a standing ovation. That's spectacular!😍💗 The most INSANE Bohemian Rhapsody Flashmob you will ever see!! With 30 musicians and singers in the STREET of Paris 😍 Cre : Julien Cohen Pianist
This exchange is one of the most fascinating in the history of the transgender issue.
Even though it may be subtle, the guy being interviewed is considered the "founder" of modern evidenced based medicine and recently capitulated to trans activists in a truly embarrassing act of self flagellation.
Mia and Stella having the chance to interview this guy on camera is a veritable gold mine.
Maher: Have college students changed in recent years? Do they have trouble keeping up with the amount of reading that used to be required?
Me: The answer is yes, they have declined. I can see it in my own class, which I've taught for 22 years. So we had a meeting with the dean at Harvard because grades keep getting higher. 80% of students get an A. The average GPA is 3.8 out of 4.
Maher: Grade inflation, they call it.
Me: No, they don't. The dean said, we prefer to call it "grade compression."
Maher: Oh (with a hand clap, head roll back, and sigh).
Me: Maybe our students are just getting better and better. So I knew this was malarkey, so I actually had the data, because I've been giving kind of the same exam for 22 years, and it's multiple choice, so it's subjective. So there's a constant benchmark, and performance has been going down, at least in my class. 10 percentage points from 2004 to now. So the standards have been going down. Students do read less. I think they spend more time on extracurriculars than on classwork, and I just know that...
Maher: Scrolling, scrolling.
Me: That's when they're in the room, yes.
Maher: I have to tell you, they're not going to read your book, not because it's not great. It is. It's a book. They won't read this. I read a letter that a student wrote to the Crimson, saying you can get out of this university without having fully read a whole book.
Me: That might be true. Now I've got to say, there are a lot of really brilliant, really studious Harvard students, like intimidatingly smart. But there's also a lot for whom it's kind of a luxury cruise, and academics is just one of the activities. So our dean, to be fair, our dean has noticed, and she has changed the guidelines going forward. She's actually told students--you wouldn't think this would be a shock--academics is your first priority. Now the fact that she had to say that, this is a kind of a radical new policy. She said that it's okay for professors to take attendance in lectures, which I'm going to start doing. That it's okay to ban electronic devices, which I might start doing. Because we actually know that taking notes leads to better memory than using a screen. Just a principle of cognitive psychology, when you have to think hard about something, when you've got to process its meaning, when it's not just a bunch of words, then you actually remember better. Just the process of writing puts it in your brain. But a lot of them have screens. There are electronic note-taking devices, but they're not as fluid and easy as the old-fashioned pen and paper. So my teaching assistants are going to hate this, because we're going to have to schlep handouts to class every time.
I knew exactly what I was getting into and if nobody ever bought another of my books I’d have been just fine, but I cannot forgive wealthy liberals prepared to watch in silence as women with everything to lose were flayed alive by vicious activists and captured institutions.
"Assuming that Linehan’s account is correct, then his arrest is totalitarian, absurd, and a waste of police time. It is also symptomatic of a wider chill on free speech in Europe, where the selective deployment of laws over hate speech, offense, and incitement has turned the police into the enforcers of progressive values and given them enormous discretionary power."
🚨NEW: Princeton anthropologist @Anthrofuentes has written a book meant to demolish “the binary view” of sex. But philosopher @TomasBogardus shows that he not only misunderstands basic biology, but ends up providing premises that actually support the sex binary.
Fuentes' main arguments—whether from "mating types," sparrows, or disorders of sexual development—don’t prove there are more than two sexes.
In the end, Fuentes' thesis collapses into a motte-and-bailey: he oscillates between bold, false claims ("there are more than two sexes") and modest, uncontroversial ones ("males and females share traits").
The AMA and APA may endorse “sex assigned at birth,” and we can be polite. But swapping “sex” for “assigned sex” makes it sound arbitrary—like a seating chart. Sex isn’t a vibe; it’s a biological category with real medical impacts.@hoovlet @byrne_a@AEIgeneticliteracyproject.org/2025/09/02/viewpoint-its-time-…
Evidence that woke isn't dead, peer review is problematic, and science needs to address deep problems in its culture: A grad student at Harvard conducted the first systematic, data-based study to document & explain the rise in gender dysphoria. His paper was rejected from a leading journal because, among other things, "Throughout the manuscript, the authors use language that is considered prejudicial and outdated (e.g., "natal sex" as opposed to "sex assigned at birth"). It is critical to follow best practice and guidelines surrounding gender inclusive language, particularly for research specifically on the topic of gender incongruence, expression, and identity."
"If we want to understand what it means to be a male human, and the ways in which boys and men are different from girls and women, we need to understand T." - Carole Hooven
"The effect of an open letter of that sort is simply to deter anyone else from dipping their toes into the third rail topic [of transgender medicine]."
MIT Philosophy Professor Alex Byrne (@byrne_a) told his side of the story on Radio Free Campus:
It appears the woman who called a child a racial epithet in Minnesota has been charged with disorderly conduct.
Like it or not, racist speech is protected under the First Amendment—and yes, it should be.
In a free society, we’re supposed to handle these issues through persuasion and social opprobrium if necessary—not through the force of law and the implicit threat of violence that represents.
Unfortunately, we’ve exhausted people on social opprobrium over the last 11 years, often on truly trivial matters. So there’s a good chance it won’t work anymore. We did warn everyone!
The UK is now serving as a chilling example of where this ends, and that's with thousands of people arrested in just a matter of months, even for speech that's about a matter of public or international importance. If bigots want to tell you they are bigots, let them. But let's not pretend we're any safer for not knowing what people really think.
@hoovlet excellent podcast discourse with @JonahDispatch . He needs to do much more of that on @JonahRemnant in my opinion. Ground truth matters. Stereotypes have a basis in reality.
It’s great to see us acknowledged for our dogged commitment to nonpartisan free speech defense, but this is who we’ve always been. And you won't find a group of more principled & talented people than what we have at @theFIREorg. I could not be prouder of them.
I was quiet for years in the face of all this inanity, looking for a job, didn't have tenure, etc. But after seeing how our universities have been rocked, if we are to have any hope of fixing them, we have to speak up more, much more.
"Often university administrations indulge students who think that it's a legitimate form of expression to occupy buildings and eject deans from their offices, to obstruct passageways, to invade classrooms chanting slogans over bullhorns. Even if you are a First Amendment advocate, there are legitimate restrictions on time, place, and manner of expression of speech. I'm fully in favor of public expression of opinions, but that doesn't mean that I want someone invading my bedroom chanting, you know, build the wall at 3 a.m. There are legitimate grounds for preserving private spaces, and universities ought to have a consistent policy of not allowing students to shut down the university, invade classrooms, take over libraries, and so on."
.@sciam Seriously, are you back to the days of Laura Helmuth, denying the binary of sex, or at least distorting it, pretending that it's meant to apply to all aspects of sex, including behavior. IT IS ABOUT GAMETES, for crying out loud! This podcast is deeply misleading.
“I have nothing against diversity, equity, and inclusion. But as Voltaire said about the Holy Roman Empire: it was neither holy, nor Roman, nor an empire.”
In 2021, I publicly stated that sex is binary and based on the production of eggs vs. sperm, and this was met with harsh criticism from within Harvard. In addition to being described as harmful, my view was also—supposedly—scientifically incorrect. The evidence seemed to boil down to the idea that “life is too diverse and complex” to accommodate a sex binary.
The arguments made against my "binary view" were the same ones @pastasnack_e so clearly described in her 2022 article Life is Diverse—So What, which @dfkodsi linked to 👇🏽 in his thread.
I’ll give three examples that illustrate how these arguments were (and still are) used against the sex binary. All come from a 2021 @thecrimson article 👇🏽 covering the accusations against me at the time.
First, from a recent alumna of the graduate program in my department—an evolutionary biologist:
“I just think taking a reductive approach and trying to distill it down to one factor when there are clearly many, it’s just overly simplistic and really erases a lot of the beauty of human variation."
Second, from the head of Harvard's GenderSci lab:
“Set aside gender, sex itself is super complex...It is a developmentally dynamic construct made up of multiple components and variables and factors.”
And third, from the graduate student director of our department's DEI task force at the time (who had also called my views dangerous and transphobic on Twitter):
"[The taskforce director] likewise argued for an understanding of sex beyond the binary of 'male' and 'female' to account for human biological variation. [She told the Crimson:]
'This variation can only be fully understood if we consider biological sex as interactions between chromosomes, gametes, gonads, and hormones, which each exist on a continuum in humans...I believe that scientists can have a positive impact on society by communicating this nuance to the public.'"
So thank you, @dfkodsi, for reminding me of Pasternak’s excellent article. Yes—nature contains immense, fascinating, and beautiful variation within male and female phenotypes. But there are still only two sexes. And that reality is itself powerful and fascinating. Unfortunately, Pasternak’s article feels more relevant today than ever.
Will women ever match's men's chess performance? Should males be allowed to compete in female-only chess categories? From @ChessBase: "a 17-year-old player in Germany won the national girls’ under-18 tournament. The head of the German commission for women’s chess was less thrilled. The winner, you know, who identifies and officially categorizes as female, was born as a boy. Dominic Lawson... in his words 'managed to smuggle in chess as the subject' in his Sunday Times column. Shameless self promotion, from the Times article (supplied in full on ChessBase):
"So, get more women playing chess, and, over time, they will match men at the very top. That would be wonderful to see, but, alas, the argument was demolished by Carole Hooven, an evolutionary biologist and the author of T: The Story of Testosterone. She pointed out [in @Quillette, link in comments] : 'Unlike in the chess world, women dominate the recreational ranks of Scrabble, accounting for about 85 per cent of all recreational players...women should be dominating the elite Scrabble ranks. But they’re not. Instead, men dominate Scrabble’s upper tiers, as they do in chess.'" en.chessbase.com/post/full-lawson-on-genders-in-chess
Why Do Men Dominate Chess? [Includes an open access video based on my article.] FIDE’s new policy governing who can compete in women’s categories highlights the persistent sex imbalance at the game’s elite levels. quillette.com/2024/03/22/why-do-men-dominate-chess/
What is "sex essentialism"? After spending many hours trying to find the answer, as part of my research for my back and forth with Cordelia Fine in @aeonmag, I can say I wholeheartedly agree with @RonaDinur's view, in her post 👇🏽.
Our Aeon article is worth a read if you're curious about different approaches to the subject of sex differences, and especially if you're interested how accusations of sex essentialism can affect debate. The quote below is from the article, towards the end:
"What all this adds up to is that I [Carole] don’t hold the essentialist views about sex that you ascribe to me. In order to understand why that’s the case, we should be on the same page about how you define such views. Here’s one example, from your [Cordelia's] book Testosterone Rex [Cordelia's definition of essentialism]:
"Amid all the ‘noise’ of individual differences, a male or female ‘essence’ can be extracted: characteristics of maleness and femaleness that are natural, immutable, discrete, historically and cross-culturally invariant, and grounded in deep-seated, biological factors.'"
Answer: Nobody knows what "essentialize" is, and no one knows what "sex essentialism" or "biological essentialism" is in particular.
This is because the term was used as a form of academic pejorative meant to police the boundaries of acceptable thought to begin with. It isn't meant to convey meaning or information.
What Amy is suffering is political persecution, pure and simple
Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms@JCCFCanada
BREAKING NEWS
The British Columbia College of Nurses and Midwives has ordered Amy Hamm @preta_6 to pay $93,639.80 and will suspend her nursing license for one month.
According to the College's Discipline Committee, this staggering penalty is "reasonable and necessary," "not...punitive," "nor so high that it will deter others from raising reasonable defences."
This is the state of freedom of expression in Canada.
Amy's protracted battle with the College began in 2020, after she publicly defended the right of women to access female-only spaces, such as washrooms, crisis centres, sporting events, and prisons.
Here's what Amy has to say: “The College has chosen to punish me for statements that are not hateful, but truthful. I’m appealing [to the BC Supreme Court] because biological reality matters, and so does freedom of expression. I want to express my thanks to the thousands of Canadians who continue to fund my legal case through donations to the Justice Centre.”
Some Thoughts On “Mankeeping” by @jessesingal (w/ quote from me) "This combination — obviously the patriarchy has an explanatory role here, & obviously biology doesn’t — represents a severe manifestation of bias on the part of the researchers." jessesingal.substack.com/p/some-thoughts-on-mankeeping?tr…
Join us at 9:30PM PT for another Origins Podcast mini-series premiere, covering the War on Science w/@LKrauss1, @byrne_a, and Moti Gorin! Watch free on YouTube or get exclusive content and ad-free video on Substack: www.youtube.com/watch?v=hcJeAarichc | A new episode drops every day!
Yeah, men being highly driven by sex is not a "cultural narrative." I've been trying to get queer theorists to accept that we're a sexually reproducing species for years now & that they cannot socially engineer away things like heterosexuality. This is the same kind of error. 1/2
Our culture is so hypersexualized that the idea of a celibate priest leaves people in disbelief—as if it’s impossible. That’s heartbreaking. Have we really forgotten that self-control and virtue are within reach?
Look at Jesus Christ. The most perfect man to ever walk the earth was celibate and sinless before He was crucified for our sins. Shouldn’t He be the supreme model for manhood? Self-mastery. Discipline. Total self-gift—all out of love.
Priests choose celibacy so their hearts can belong entirely to God. As St. Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 7:32-35:
“I want you to be free from anxieties. The unmarried man is anxious about the things of the Lord, how to please the Lord. But the married man is anxious about worldly things, how to please his wife, and his interests are divided... I say this for your own benefit... to secure your undivided devotion to the Lord.”
Abstinence isn’t just for priests—intermittent abstinence can also be a beautiful practice within marriage if a couple has a serious reason to delay bringing a baby into the world. When practicing Natural Family Planning (NFP), spouses can grow in self-mastery, deepen their love, and remain faithful to God’s design for marriage.
Christ is the model. Love is the reason. Holiness is the goal.
New experience today, being accused of lying by a journalist in @NYMag. It seems the journalist did not check my reference list and so got things totally wrong. I'm in good company with @RichardDawkins though. I have requested a correction and apology.
The "howler" (Jones' term) is not ours, but hers. She also convicts @RichardDawkins and @DrKarleenG (both writing on sex/gender topics) of "bullshit." Let's see. /5
.@Evolutionistrue, I believe you have some counterevidence for the first claim, but thank you nonetheless: "If you know Carole, you’ll know the she’s eminently civil and polite. She just wasn’t ideologically correct."
The Lancet publishes an ad hominem and misleading review of a new book saying that sex IN MANY ANIMAS SPECIES sex is a spectrum. But all the examples given of "nonbinary" sex adhere perfectly to the gametic-based sex concept.
🧵1/4 A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one?
BTW, @Anthrofuentes publicist for his new book, Sex is a Spectrum, pitched me to have him on my show (he was on for his prior book). I agreed to do it if @SwipeWright was also on to debate the thesis. He declined without reason. The offer still stands Agustin. How about it?
We evolutionary biologists (@SwipeWright , @Evolutionistrue , @FondOfBeetles and others) are fascinated by the immense diversity in body and behavior of male and female organisms. We also understand that mammals come in two sexes, male and female, and that these are reproductive categories that are defined by the body plan for the production of either large or small gametes.
@Anthrofuentes knows what we think about all this, so I am confused about why he says in @sciam that scientists like us “maintain that whether our bodies make ova or sperm are all we need to know about sex.” Relatedly, he says that “producing ova or sperm does not tell us everything…about an individual’s childcare capacity, homemaking tendencies, sexual attractions, interest in literature…” Um…who is saying that gametes dictate any of this? That sex is binary is obviously compatible with traits like interest in literature varying widely between the two sexes. It is also compatible with the existence of significant differences between the sexes.
Unfortunately, Fuentes has tarred all the members of a diverse group with the same brush, denigrating the motives of those who assert that sex is real, biological, binary and meaningful for social policy. “They are arguing for a specific political, and discriminatory, definition of what is ‘natural’ and ‘right’ for humans based on a false representation of biology…[and] dishonest ascriptions of what biology is are being deployed to restrict women’s bodily autonomy…and to attack the rights of transexual and transgender people.”
Sex matters because even though bodies and behavior vary, being male or female does predict a lot. Women in particular understand this, because we are more physically vulnerable than men. We care about gender-diverse people and their basic human rights, and we are *also* concerned about safety and fairness in places like prison cells and women’s sports. These issues can be debated sensibly without relying on “a false representation of biology.”
Oy! The Lancet impugns the gametic definition of biological sex because it is said to be injurious to humanity. It is not: it is a generalization based on over a century’s worth of observation of what all animals and plants have in common. Read all of Hooven’s tweet.
🧵1/4 A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one?
It just ran a book review arguing that focusing on sperm/eggs as male/female is bad bcuz it promotes "gametic" bigotry, & so “fuels unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles”
🧵1/4 A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one?
🧵1/4 A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one?
I don't know what to say. How can Carole stay so calm and reasonable in the face of unreason that is overtaking institutions? How can any of us? How can we fight back?
🧵1/4 A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one?
🧵1/4 A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one?
The@OriginsProject podcast War on Science interviews continue, to celebrate release of the book. 20 podcasts in 20 days. Day 11. Biologist Canceled at Harvard for Defending Science w @hoovlet. Premiering now! www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cl3ktvCP9P0
@jburnmurdoch joins me to discuss gendered polarisation.
- Does this hold worldwide? - Which groups are most polarised? - Is this due to economic frustrations or online persuasion? - What are the possible solutions?
"Gender-dysphoric youth deserve a comprehensive and clinically judicious textbook from the country’s premiere psychiatric association, not a volume that omits essential facts and perspectives in the service of a political agenda." @slsatelwww.aei.org/articles/social-justice-encroachment-into-med…
This week's column for @TheNewWorldmag is on the Sandie Peggie case and how NHS managers became so captured by an elite ideology that they waged a nasty witch hunt against a woman trying to uphold her legal right to a single-sex changing room at work.
Congratulations to @LKrauss1 (& all of the contributors) on today's release of the The War on Science. It's an honor to be included in this fight for truth over ideology. Check out interviews with the authors on Lawrence's pod, @OriginsProject. Mine airs this Sat (Aug 2).
Celebrating the release of The War on Science today in the US and Canada in print and ebook (audiobook to be released in a week or so). Pick it up. We need to fight back and win this war so scholarship in academia can once again be unfettered. www.amazon.com/War-Science-Thirty-Nine-Scientists-Scienti…
I keep getting tagged in messages where people point to offensive speech and say, “Surely this isn’t free speech, Lukianoff!?”
They’re missing the point.
Speech isn’t protected so you can say only pleasant or popular things. It’s not protected just because it’s a fundamental human right that are truly free or democratic society is impossible without.
It’s rightfully protected because societies have repeatedly discovered the value of knowing what people really think. That value cannot be overstated.
Throughout history, kings, queens, aristocrats, and elites who underestimated the importance of that knowledge have often paid a steep price.
Simply, you are not safer for knowing less about what people truly think.
This is the central theme of my TED talk—check it out at the link below. It’s my simplest and clearest explanation of what I call the pure informational theory of freedom of speech.
What's going on at Pima County Library? There were multiple copies of "On the Warpath: My Battles with Indians, Pretendians, and Woke Warriors" that were frequently checked out. Then, my book disappeared from the catalog; I was told the only copy was at a library undergoing renovation and so not available. Upon my insistence, they ordered a new copy. The new copy is now unavailable, because it's "in repair". I suspect that this is a form of censorship -- either by librarians or by users who are defacing the book.
Trust in mainstream media has never been lower, but the management class has decreed that violent and sexual crimes committed by men must be reported as female crimes if that's how the perpetrators identify. A strategy that's sure to rebuild credibility. www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy5w6rw33yro
A new book on the ideological threats to science (from the Left). And yes, we know that right now the Right poses a much more serious danger to science. But that doesn't exculpate progressives.
"Supporting chestfeeding is the official positionof La Leche League - the world’s oldest...international breastfeeding organization. Trustees who objected were suspended. Directors resigned. And their 94 year old founder, ...walked out over it, 68 years after its founding." 👇🏽
Prioritizing inclusivity in healthcare should not come at the expense of patient harm. Yet, that’s exactly what is happening. I run a maternity-care hospital and public health non-profit in India. I founded them so that more Indian women would have access to Western-style ethical and evidence-based medicine. So I have been dismayed to watch the West abandon those principles. Link below.
.@nytimes must end this kind of bias: "...when a female fencer declined to compete against her transgender opponent at a midlevel meet." The fencer declined to compete against her male opponent. It's not about bigotry— keeping trans people out of female sports. It's about fairness & safety—keeping males out. But nowhere in the article does the word "male" appear. www.nytimes.com/2025/07/22/us/politics/us-olympics-trans-…
One cost of the Great Awokening was that people spent too much time managing their own reputations within institutions and professional circles, and not enough time thinking about how they were coming off outside it:
"Among those who can overcome the trauma of having the issue raised, one favored gambit is to act as if it is an unreasonable expectation for academics to know whether or not there are male women." Damning, highly entertaining. Well worth your time. philosophersmag.com/philosophical-malpractice/
A primary school in London has launched a project in which it highlights well known men to boys to give them role models to aspire to be like so they can grow up to be successful men. The first 'man' selected was Elliot Page www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/07/19/primary-school-trans-…
Notable: "We believe that this reply is the first peer-reviewed academic paper to state explicitly that Caster Semenya, and similarly placed athletes, are male, not female ..."
"We need to cultivate a love of truth for its own sake and the courage to speak our minds and to follow the truth wherever it may lead us — even when it leads us into difficult waters where our disagreements are deep and unsettling." 🙏🏽 @jennfrey
In case you missed Jennifer Frey’s New York Times article that is setting the internet on fire — here’s a summary of her powerful critique of how universities are failing students who want a true liberal arts education.
About the Coldplay concert incident (link in next post) with Andy and Kristin. Check out the "leadership team" at Astronomer. One woman (Kristin), and she happens to be the "people officer." www.astronomer.io/about-us/
Wow, some scholars are hiding messages in their manuscripts to LLMs who may be used to review the paper. If there is a way to cheat, people will find it.
What might stop men from engaging in therapy for pornography addiction?
"Women make up around 80% of clinical psychologists (BPS, 2024) and 74% of UKCP registered psychotherapists (BACP, 2017). This gender imbalance may introduce additional barriers for male clients, particularly when disclosing sensitive sexual issues and forming a strong therapeutic alliance."
"I'd much rather be a great father than a great golfer... professional athletes work really hard for something that is so fleeting... at the end of the day it is just not what satisfies me."
Stay away from Sex at Harvard Here's my talk in which I describe what led to my departure from the teaching job I loved. From at the USC Censorship in the Sciences Conference earlier this year. (Some people are asking. Also see my article in @TheFP.) youtu.be/4I9gP--0tXM
One of my favorite podcast appearances. Lots of juicy facts about testosterone, science of sex & sex differences, & why we need to tell the truth about all of it. From @DubladJitender's Reason with Science pod. (Clip 👇🏽, full video next post.)
I always feel relaxed and comfortable 😬 around @meghan_daum. Yes there was more to it than nipples and the male gaze. But you should watch the whole thing anyway.
This week's podcast interview with Carole Hooven @hoovlet is SO GOOD. We talk testosterone, the feminization of society, the demonization of men, and debate the idea that women "hate" men. (I say they're faking.)
Agree with the issue you pointed out. But check the comments. The most recommended ones love snubbing and many criticize Litt (the author) for advocating engagement. The "other side" is just stupid, brainwashed, morally inferior. Ugh.
Since I've burst my left-wing bubble, I've gotten to know (and like!) a bunch of people (right-wingers!) who voted for Trump. In fact they have been less judgemental, more open-minded and better-informed than many of my left-wing friends.
One comment gets it: "It's astonishing how many commenters aren't getting the point of this essay: being a pill doesn't work. In fact, the nastier you are, the more you drive people farther right. You are accomplishing nothing, except for deepening division. Amazing that in the name of 'human decency' many people here seem happy to not see the humans on the right. Instead, they here seem intent on doing their part in pulling people apart. What's worse is that they think their taking the high road in doing so."
Agree with the issue you pointed out. But check the comments. The most recommended ones love snubbing and many criticize Litt (the author) for advocating engagement. The "other side" is just stupid, brainwashed, morally inferior. Ugh.
Since I've burst my left-wing bubble, I've gotten to know (and like!) a bunch of people (right-wingers!) who voted for Trump. In fact they have been less judgemental, more open-minded and better-informed than many of my left-wing friends.
One comment gets it: "It's astonishing how many commenters aren't getting the point of this essay: being a pill doesn't work. In fact, the nastier you are, the more you drive people farther right. You are accomplishing nothing, except for deepening division. Amazing that in the name of 'human decency' many people here seem happy to not see the humans on the right. Instead, they here seem intent on doing their part in pulling people apart. What's worse is that they think their taking the high road in doing so."
The idea that this was an almost universal good-faith intellectual error doesn’t pass the giggle test. The cowardly self-censorship has extended far beyond words, to thoughts, so that the requisite avowals could be made with an eerily ersatz sincerity
🧵"World Athletics drew up its rules in 2018 forcing Semenya and other female athletes with Differences in Sex Development to suppress their testosterone to be eligible for international women’s events." ABC News, today, reporting on a new ruling from the European Court of Human Rights. I'm less concerned with the ruling (you can read about it below) and more concerned with the reporting.
Semenya deserves to be treated with respect and dignity. But Semenya is fighting to compete as a female, against females, at the highest levels of sport. Given this, although it may be uncomfortable, the details of Semenya's condition deserve to be understood and accurately represented in the press and elsewhere. The narrative—that Semenya is a female who has been discriminated against because she happens to be blessed with naturally high testosterone levels—is false.
Semenya reaps the benefits of naturally produced male-typical testosterone because Semenya is male. Semenya has confirmed (see the next post) having XY sex chromosomes, undescended testicles, typical male testosterone levels, and what appears to be a vagina (albeit one that does not connect to a cervix, and without a uterus or fallopian tubes). This is all consistent with the condition called 5ARD (5-alpha reductase deficiency).
5ARD is caused by the lack of an enzyme (5-alpha reductase) that normally catalyzes the conversion of testosterone into to a more potent androgen, dihydrotestosterone, or DHT. DHT is what promotes the development of a penis and scrotum and the descent of the testes into the scrotum in fetal development, and in puberty, causes the growth of thick, dark and dense facial hair, acne, male-pattern baldness, and more. Without DHT, some aspects of physical appearance are feminized, like the skin, and certainly external genitalia.
Affected individuals have a body that responds to male levels of testosterone in all the ways that give males large physical advantages over females in sports: size, strength, power, hemoglobin, etc. (see last post in the thread). The female category exists specifically to protect the ability of females to have a shot at winning.
Accurate reporting on sex matters, especially when it comes to policies designed to protect women, whether in sports, prisons, or on the street.
Confirmation that a lack of DHT (the missing androgen in 5ARD) does not reduce strength (from a previous post):
TLDR: "Our data are consistent with studies that have reported no effects of 5α-reductase inhibitors on muscle or bone mass."
I've been asked if men with the DSD 5-ARD (in which ppl cannot convert testosterone into the more potent androgen DHT) experience the typical benefits of male puberty, that would give them an advantage in strength and speed relative to women. This is relevant to questions about whether male athletes with 5-ARD should be allowed to compete in the female category.
This is an excellent question, because it could be the case that DHT is necessary for the development and maintenance of male-typical muscle, lean body mass and strength. If that were the case, then people with 5-ARD might not have a typical male advantage, because the lack of DHT would perhaps lead to a more feminine pattern of fat, lean body mass and strength. I've wondered about this myself and have looked into the evidence.
Perhaps the top researcher in this area, Shalendar Bhasin, who is scrupulous in his methods, has examined this very question. The answer appears to be: no, testosterone does not need to be converted to DHT to exert its typical anabolic effects. These findings are reported in his 2012 study, "Effect of Testosterone Supplementation With and Without a Dual 5α-Reductase Inhibitor on Fat-Free Mass in Men With Suppressed Testosterone Production, A Randomized Controlled Trial." (It is linked to below—and since it's paywalled, I've included the graphs that show comparisons between the placebo and DHT— inhibited conditions, with no difference on the various outcomes.)
The investigators wanted to examine the effects of suppressing DHT on muscle mass, strength, and sexual function. This important because one of the treatments for benign prostatic hyperplasia and male-pattern baldness is to suppress DHT, but clinicians have been concerned about effects on other outcomes that affect health and quality of life. Participants (healthy men, 18 to 50, with normal T levels) had their T blocked, and were given graded doses of T, along with either placebo or a drug that blocked the conversion of T to DHT. So both groups had T, but only one, the placebo group, also had DHT.
After 20 weeks of treatment, changes in lean body mass, muscle, and strength were assessed. There were no significant difference between the placebo and DHT-blocked groups in these outcomes.
For LOTS more detail, here's the relevant text from the results. Please don't ask me questions about the study. Just look at the abstract and results which you can find by Googling. The main point is that while there are predicted effects of the different doses of T received, there were no differences in the outcomes according to whether they had DHT blocked (with dutasteride) or not (placebo).
"Fat-Free Mass Fat-free mass and lean body mass increased in a dose-dependent manner in the placebo and dutasteride [THIS IS THE DRUG THAT BLOCKS CONVERSION OF T TO DHT] groups (Figure 2). The changes in fat-free mass were related to testosterone dose and changes in testosterone concentrations in the placebo and dutasteride groups but did not differ between groups; the dose-adjusted mean difference (placebo minus dutasteride) in fat-free mass was 0.50 kg (95% CI, −0.22 to 1.22 kg; P = .18).
There was no significant interaction between testosterone dose and randomization to dutasteride or placebo, indicating a lack of evidence that the relationship of testosterone dose to change in fat-free mass differed between the dutasteride and placebo groups.
The model-based smoothed regression lines, obtained by generalized additive models, describing the relationship between changes in testosterone concentrations and changes in fat-free mass and lean body mass were similar in the placebo and dutasteride groups. Changes in fat mass were negatively related to testosterone dose and concentrations, but the relationship between change in fat mass and dose did not differ significantly between the placebo and dutasteride groups (P = .41; Figure 2)."
"Muscle strength Leg-press and chest-press strength increased dependently by dose in the placebo and dutasteride groups. Increases in leg-press and chest-press strength were greater with larger doses and higher concentrations of testosterone. These relationships did not differ between the placebo and dutasteride groups (Figure 2)."
Really interesting commentary from the authors on the role of DHT in adult men: "Why then did the steroid 5α-reductase system evolve for androgens?
Forty-six XY males with steroid 5α-reductase deficiency exhibited ambiguous or female external genitalia at birth and poor prostate development, but underwent normal muscle and bone development during pubertal transition. The phenotype of these patients suggests that steroid 5α-reductase plays an essential role in the development of prostate and phallus by providing local amplification of an androgenic signal without systemic hyperandrogenemia during critical periods of sexual differentiation, illustrating nature's extraordinary ingenuity in creating mechanisms for tissue-selective amplification during development.
We speculate that in adult men, in whom this tissue-specific amplification is not essential because the circulating testosterone concentrations are substantially higher than those in the fetus, testosterone and DHT can interchangeably subserve many androgenic functions. When circulating testosterone concentrations are low, intraprostatic DHT formation may become important in maintaining prostate growth, thus buffering the effects of decreasing testosterone levels, which has been suggested by Marks et al.
Our data are consistent with studies that have reported no effects of 5α-reductase inhibitors on muscle or bone mass. Inferences from these trials are limited by the fact that administration of 5α-reductase inhibitors increases testosterone levels, rendering it difficult to ascribe the outcomes to differences in DHT levels alone. In our trial, inhibition of endogenous testosterone by administration of a gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist eliminated this problem. Additionally, the high-dose dutasteride regimen effectively inhibited both steroid 5α-reductase isoenzymes."
It frequently amazes me how some people saw wokeness so clearly 30+ years ago, and how little the core (insane) tenets have changed yet somehow managed to gain widespread acceptance.
Identity politics as a substitute for religion. "Diversity" as a slogan that means the opposite. The retreat from reality itself. It was all there in 1995, and well before.
This is from The Revolt of the Elites (1995) by Christopher Lasch.
Cancel culture is back: MIT philosopher Alex Byrne gets dogpiled for helping write the HHS report on pediatric gender medicine in the US. But the 200+ academics who went after him are doing so for misguided reasons.
whyevolutionistrue.com/2025/07/07/alex-byrnes-colleagues-… This is horrible. I don't know Alex Byrne but I've read his book and it's excellent. One way to show contempt for these mindless sheep is to buy it. The accusation of complicity with Trump is as silly as, "You love dogs? Therefore you support Hitler."
Yet another open letter denouncing an academic. As Prof Byrne says "Encouraging individuals on social media to join a public condemnation of a colleague is inimical to the mission of the university".
My recent report into barriers to research on sex and gender has a lengthy appendix collating such letters www.sullivanreview.uk/barriers.pdf
I hope pretty soon we will look back on them as an odd historical phenomenon.
MIT philosophy professor Alex Byrne (COI:@byrne_a = my husband) was recently the target of an open letter, originating from within his own department. (His reply is below.) It accused him of perpetuating "harm toward the trans community"; violating "professional academic ethics"; & "unconscionable" behavior, including "collaborating" with the Trump admin. He was one of the 9 authors of the HHS report, Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria (linked to in his reply 👇🏽). web.mit.edu/abyrne/www/DearColleagues070325.pdf
Basically the "argument" is: How dare you disagree with right-thinking people like us?!!! They're not really interested in debating; they're performing. They're trying to amass a large number of signatures to their declaration of anathema. Why? To intimidate Alex and make him a pariah--thus sending a signal to others of what their fate will be if they step out of line. It's all about enforcing the party line. The correct response--Alex doesn't need me or anyone else to tell him this--is defiance. If his critics have reasons, evidence, and arguments in rebuttal to the work he and his colleagues produced, let them bring them forward. Otherwise, there's nothing to discuss.
Alex Bryne’s response is a masterpiece of restraint, logic: their collective letter did not refute scientific evidence (concerns of chemical or surgical procedures in minors); in this biopsychosocial question, ethicists’ inputs are valued; Bryne has broad expertise in the field.
MIT philosophy professor Alex Byrne (COI:@byrne_a = my husband) was recently the target of an open letter, originating from within his own department. (His reply is below.) It accused him of perpetuating "harm toward the trans community"; violating "professional academic ethics"; & "unconscionable" behavior, including "collaborating" with the Trump admin. He was one of the 9 authors of the HHS report, Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria (linked to in his reply 👇🏽). web.mit.edu/abyrne/www/DearColleagues070325.pdf
Basically the "argument" is: How dare you disagree with right-thinking people like us?!!! They're not really interested in debating; they're performing. They're trying to amass a large number of signatures to their declaration of anathema. Why? To intimidate Alex and make him a pariah--thus sending a signal to others of what their fate will be if they step out of line. It's all about enforcing the party line. The correct response--Alex doesn't need me or anyone else to tell him this--is defiance. If his critics have reasons, evidence, and arguments in rebuttal to the work he and his colleagues produced, let them bring them forward. Otherwise, there's nothing to discuss.
I should have noted that the link to the "live" open letter is the first link in Alex's reply ("open letter"), not the letter appended to Alex's reply (which has no signatures). Plenty of "anonymous" signers! What the hell.
Meghan Daum called, so of course I (and the rest of the group) answered. This will definitely be a lively weekend and I'm honored to be a part of it. Hope you can join us!
Some of what we'll cover over the two days (all off the record): Does masculinity matter? Is a city only as good as its policing? Does the mental health field need mental help? How will history look back on the gender movement? Should art care about our feelings?
Follow-up to my earlier post regarding “Phallus-Preserving Vaginoplasty: This procedure creates a fully functional vagina without surgically removing the penis.” Link in reply.
The countdown begins! 29 days till The War on Science appears! A devastating exposition by an amazing group of authors of the internal culture war in Universities that has provoked such an extreme back reaction against science by the current US admin. alturl.com/qq7fa
"Sex is a fundamental category in human research..When certain facts become unspeakable...it compromises the integrity of scholarship. This weakens public trust in universities, science & scholarship, & ultimately undermines democracy." @ProfAliceS www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/universities-…
BREAKING: Minnesota court allows @MayoClinic professor Dr. Michael Joyner’s retaliation claims to move forward.
Joyner, a prominent physiology expert, was punished for refusing to parrot “prescribed messaging” on public health and sports science when speaking to the press.
BREAKING: Dr. Michael Joyner’s case against the Mayo Clinic, which is funded and supported by the AFA, has been approved by a judge to move forward to a jury trial in September.
The ruling is the latest development in a case dating back to 2023, when Dr. Joyner alleges that the Mayo Clinic violated its contractual obligations by punishing him over comments he made to the media about sex-specific differences in sports performance and about the use of convalescent plasma in the treatment of COVID-19.
Solving universities' problems demands "a commitment by university leaders to ensuring that seminar rooms and lecture halls are not 'safe spaces,' but rather Socratic Spaces, where students are made to wrestle with ideas that challenge their preconceived assumptions and deeply-held beliefs — indeed, ideas which may make them feel uncomfortable." 🙏🏽 @McCormickProf & @CornelWestwww.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/06/30/universities-t…
An MIT philosopher, Alex Byrne, takes on gender ideology via the Trump Administration's report on how "gender affirming care" flunks “medical ethics 101" for risk/benefit.
🎁 article: The Supreme Court's questioning on youth gender medicine has provided "uncomfortable insight into how advocacy groups and medical associations have tamped down their own concerns about its evidence base," @helenlewis writes: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/06/transgender-you…
Grad students in philosophy post open letter that inadvertently helps understand why the Trump administration is doing some combination of attempting to reform academia and simply engaging in a vindictive attack on it. #thebeatingswillcontinue Link to letter in reply. From the letter: "The past few months have witnessed the Trump administration engage in the kidnapping of international graduate students from the streets, the deportation of innocent people to dangerous foreign prisons without due process, the cutting of lifesaving aid to millions across the world, and the undermining of the independence of colleges and universities across the country. We find these actions appalling, unethical, and undemocratic.
For these reasons, we believe it is deeply myopic for any academic to collaborate with the Trump administration in this moment, regardless of one’s particular views about gender. However misguided one may think “gender ideology” is, it is simply unconscionable to for that reason, make common cause with an administration so engaged."
🧵“Philosopher [MIT prof Alex Byrne] Wraps Cooperation with Trump in Flag of Academic Freedom.” That's the headline of UNC philosophy professor Justin Weinberg's June 26 post on his philosophy news site, Daily Nous (@DailyNousEditor). I'm posting comments here since Weinberg has chosen to not to open them on this particular post.
What's Byrne's sin? He served as one of nine co-authors on the recently released HHS report “Treatment for Pediatric Gender Dysphoria: Review of Evidence and Best Practices.” (Available on the HHS website.) Weinberg clearly disagrees with Byrne (who, for the record, did not vote for Trump) about whether serving as a co-author of the report was the right thing to do. I happen to have intimate knowledge of Byrne’s motives—I'll refer to him as “Alex” from here on—because I’m married to him. We talked extensively about his decision, and I came to fully understand and respect the choice he made, even if I might have made a different one. Alex believed that his participation would help to ensure that the report was of the highest possible quality, and that it would be a useful resource for parents in particular who are looking for clear information about the costs and benefits of medical treatment of their children's gender dysphoria. Overall Alex believes that medical practices (especially those involving children) should be based on strong evidence, produced and discussed in an open environment free of harassment and threats of reputational damage. Especially after working on the report, he is convinced that the evidence supporting medicalization of gender dysphoric kids (AKA "gender affirming care") is weak. After Alex’s name was leaked as a co-author, Weinberg wrote (in his May 6 post) that it would be “appalling” for a philosopher to participate in such a project. Doing would mean that the philosopher had “decided to help Trump” with his “selfish and authoritarian ambitions,” “cruelty” regarding “immigrants, government employees, the disabled, and the domestic and global poor,” and “transgender women and men.” So perhaps authors should have been limited to extreme right wingers? After Alex confirmed his participation in a June 26 OpEd in @WaPo OpEd, www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/06/26/hhs-review-ano…
BTW here is what the @washingtonpost editorial board had to say about the HHS report: "Clocking in at more than 400 pages, including appendixes, the HHS report is a careful, thorough and definitely skeptical tour through the subject, including the history of gender medicine, the evolution of pediatric interventions, the evidence for pediatric medical transition, and the ethical conundrums that researchers and practitioners face. Critics have been scathing about what they see as the report’s bias and shortcomings. But it makes a legitimate case for caution that policymakers need to wrestle with." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/05/11/transgender-ca…
Weinberg has said that he does not “use Daily Nous as a platform for humiliating people or hurling insults at them.” (From an interview with Weinberg (at whatisitliketobeaphilosopher.com), and that “disagreement is misunderstood and underappreciated, and readers are welcome to disagree with me.” (From his personal website, hisname [no spaces] dot org.) Yet he did not open comments on the post that essentially accused Byrne of using academic freedom as a smokescreen for helping Trump advance selfish and cruel policies, thereby bringing further harm to the most vulnerable among us. This from the philosopher who advocates for respectful engagement, humility, and who “welcomes comments” on his views and posts. In his June 26 post, Weinberg wrote that “To oppose joining with the powers that be in their push for a callous, dehumanizing, agenda is not thereby to oppose free and open inquiry.” But Alex never claimed that academic freedom has been violated; rather he described a culture in academic philosophy and elsewhere in which good-faith dissenters are compared to Nazis, and in which philosophers, rather than engaging with arguments, express outrage and make public accusations about motives. This is not the way to create a culture of free and open inquiry. Ask @docstock or @aytchellesse. On his personal website, Weinberg wrote that “during challenging times it can be useful to remind yourself of how you’d like to be.” These five “aspects of character” are especially important for “good philosophers” to have (we should all have them, of course): "Humility – knowledge of the limits of one’s knowledge, including one’s knowledge of those limits Curiosity – the propensity to be dissatisfied with one’s lack of understanding, but not discouraged by it Charity – the disposition to first seek the wisdom in what others say Courage – the strength to not mistake uncertainty for danger Grace – gratitude to those who help save us from ourselves" And these are indeed challenging times. So Justin—@DailyNousEditor—I (and @byrne_a, who is at a conference, but I'm sure would agree) welcome your engagement.
For those who think "woke" still controls everything on the left, it's simply inconceivable that an essay by Alex Byrne on trans issues could have appeared in the Washington Post in 2020.
Good piece, worth reading. The top "recommended" comments all praise it.
“A willingness to question assumptions, to seek new evidence, and to resist pressure to conform from our in-group. That is exactly what has been missing from the debate over youth gender medicine, and we liberals must take some blame. The more liberals who can rise above tribal loyalties and publicly dissent, the better.” @byrne_awww.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/06/26/hhs-review-ano…
“A willingness to question assumptions, to seek new evidence, and to resist pressure to conform from our in-group. That is exactly what has been missing from the debate over youth gender medicine, and we liberals must take some blame. The more liberals who can rise above tribal loyalties and publicly dissent, the better.” @byrne_awww.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/06/26/hhs-review-ano…
"Free speech makes you safer. Free speech cures violence. Free speech protects the powerless. And even 'bad' people can have good ideas." My talk from April at @TEDTalks 2025 in Vancouver is live!
"Maybe there’s a chance for what’s left of the former gay groups to recover their liberal principles, support free speech, engage opponents, respect religious dissent, use plain English, and trust rigorous, evidence-based science again. If we can do that, and help kids in gender distress without irreversibly and prematurely medicalizing them, we can begin to regain the broader public trust we have recently lost. Know hope." @sullydishopen.substack.com/pub/andrewsullivan/p/strangio-things?r=…
NEW: The Harvard Law Review axes 85% of pieces using a rubric that asks about "author diversity." It even axed a piece by an Asian scholar after editors complained that there were "not enough Black" authors.
We analyzed 500 new documents from HLR. What we found was shocking.🧵
NEW: Harvard Dean of Social Science Lawrence Bobo will no longer serve as dean.
Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences Hopi Hoekstra announced in an email that Bobo “has made the difficult decision to step down as Dean of Social Science in order to focus on pressing family matters. He will be on sabbatical during the 2025–26 academic year.”
Bobo had already taken an unexpected leave this spring due to “unanticipated personal matters.”
All of this comes after he was heavily criticized last year for publishing an op-ed in which he argued that faculty who criticize Harvard publicly should be punished.
📢 1/ The Metaphor of Gender is here! I’ve spent 9 years in the therapy room with gender-questioning youth
These intelligent, sensitive teens are trying to sort things out—but they’ve gotten swept into a culture of black-and-white thinking, self-diagnosis, and a fixation on changing their bodies
Congratulations to Luke Glowacki for winning the 2025 HBES Early Career Award for Distinguished Scientific Contribution, which recognizes excellent young scientists (<10 yrs post-PhD) who have made distinguished theoretical and/or empirical contributions to the field
I'm very honored to receive this award. A lot of hard, challenging work went into this research but i think i learned something about human nature and our evolution. Thank you @HumBehEvoSoc and colleagues.
Congratulations to Luke Glowacki for winning the 2025 HBES Early Career Award for Distinguished Scientific Contribution, which recognizes excellent young scientists (<10 yrs post-PhD) who have made distinguished theoretical and/or empirical contributions to the field
Blew the whistle in @WSJopinion on ideological rigidity in therapy training. A week later, I am fired from my internship with the regret of my boss. This field is in crisis. The public needs to know.
In the 1920s, British philosopher Bertrand Russell wagered a prediction about what a welfare state would do to a society:
"If this should occur, we must expect a complete breakdown of traditional morality, since there will no longer be any reason why a mother should wish the paternity of her child to be indubitable… Whether the effect upon men would be good or bad, I do not venture to say. It would eliminate from their lives the only emotion equal in importance to sex love. It would make sex love itself more trivial. It would make it far more difficult to take an interest in anything after one’s own death. It would make men less active and probably cause them to retire earlier from work. It would diminish their interest in history and their sense of the continuity of historical tradition… My belief is, though I put it forward with some hesitation, that the elimination of paternity as a recognized social revelation would tend to make men’s emotional life trivial and thin, causing in the end a slowly growing boredom and despair, in which procreation would gradually die out, leaving the human race to be replenished by stocks that had preserved the older convention."
"Rather than binding citizens through shared ancestry, religion, or ethnic identity, ["constitutional patriotism"] is rooted in a shared commitment to liberal principles such as equality before the law, freedom of conscience, and democratic governance."
Nice piece by Roger Partridge. The deep moral foundations of classical liberalism were hollowed by postmodernism. Community, ritual, universal morality and heroes without Iron Age deities: quillette.com/2025/06/10/classical-liberalism-without-str…
Carole Hooven reposted
Phil Mitchell:Specialist Working With Abused Males@PhilMitchell83
1/2 Thinking it’s OK to go into schools, target just boys, encourage respect, & highlight a type of extreme harm perpetrated by the minority of boys, whilst saying nothing to girls about being respectful, shows a level of bias & neglectful that is at abusive levels
YES! "If America’s universities truly wish to reclaim the public trust, they must do more than simply paying lip service to “academic freedom.” They need transparent admissions and hiring practices, genuine engagement with dissenting viewpoints, and regular, public reporting on how they’re meeting their civic obligations." Thank you @joshrauh & Gregory Kearney open.substack.com/pub/libertylensecon/p/harvard-and-the-c…
YES! "If America’s universities truly wish to reclaim the public trust, they must do more than simply paying lip service to “academic freedom.” They need transparent admissions and hiring practices, genuine engagement with dissenting viewpoints, and regular, public reporting on how they’re meeting their civic obligations." Thank you @joshrauh & Gregory Kearney open.substack.com/pub/libertylensecon/p/harvard-and-the-c…
I wrote this months ago, but watching recent AAUP statements it could’ve been written today. Here’s how the group lost its soul on free speech and academic freedom:
Democrats are spending $20m to figure out how to appeal to men (left image, NYT). They plan to “study the syntax, language and content that gains attention and virality” among men online.
I’m reminded of this passage (right) from a 2001 essay by David Brooks in the Atlantic.
“manosphere influencers approached young men from a perceived place of love and affection. ‘I like you,’ was the message. ‘I want you to live a good life. Let me show you how.’
The contrast with the approach of the cultural left was profound.”
If women's rights aren't based on sex they aren't based on anything. It is so profoundly upsetting that this is the goal being fought for by so many: the replacement of rights/ freedoms/ entitlements/ services rooted in biological sexual differences & their social effects.. 1/2
From @EmilyYoffe, on aging out of ambition. Just read it.
"One frequent sentiment is the relief many of them feel at being released from the hunger that drove them so hard for so many years. There is something soothing about knowing that whatever we accomplished—and whatever we didn’t—it’s done. But we are not quite done, and if we’re lucky enough to hold off the abyss for a while, we have the chance to figure out another way to be." @TheFP open.substack.com/pub/bariweiss/p/ambition-will-only-get-…
I know my view of Harvard is distorted by a cloud of hurt and anger, but @sapinker’s perspective here helps. Gift article 👇🏽 The "cancellations" of people like Tyler VanderWeele, @Kkitparker, Ronald Sullivan & me "are not just injustices against individuals. Honest scholarly inquiry is difficult if researchers constantly have to watch their backs lest a professional remark expose them to character assassination...But a woke madrasa? This is black-and-white splitting, in need of behavior therapy." www.nytimes.com/2025/05/23/opinion/harvard-university-tru…
BREAKING: FIRE statement on Trump administration revoking Harvard’s Student and Exchange Visitor Program certification
The Department of Homeland Security’s decision to escalate its assault against Harvard University by revoking its ability to enroll international students is retaliatory and unlawful.
Secretary Noem’s letter warns that the Trump administration seeks to “root out the evils of anti-Americanism and antisemitism in society and campuses.” But little is more un-American than a federal bureaucrat demanding that a private university demonstrate its ideological fealty to the government under pain of punishment.
The Department’s demand that Harvard produce audio and video footage of all protest activity involving international students over the last five years is gravely alarming. This sweeping fishing expedition reaches protected expression and must be flatly rejected.
The Department is already arresting and seeking to deport students for engaging in protected political activity it disfavors. Were Harvard to capitulate to Secretary Noem’s unlawful demands, more students could face such consequences. The administration’s demand for a surveillance state at Harvard is anathema to American freedom.
The administration seems hellbent on employing every means at its disposal — no matter how unlawful or unconstitutional — to retaliate against Harvard and other colleges and universities for speech it doesn’t like.
This has to stop.
Since 1999, FIRE has fought for free speech and academic freedom at Harvard and campuses nationwide, and we will continue to do so. We know there is work to do. Whatever Harvard’s past failings, core campus rights cannot and will not be secured by surveillance, retaliation, and censorship.
No American should accept the federal government punishing its political opponents by demanding ideological conformity, surveilling and retaliating against protected speech, and violating the First Amendment.
This administration is holding Harvard accountable for fostering violence, antisemitism, and coordinating with the Chinese Communist Party on its campus.
It is a privilege, not a right, for universities to enroll foreign students and benefit from their higher tuition payments to help pad their multibillion-dollar endowments.
Harvard had plenty of opportunity to do the right thing. It refused.
They have lost their Student and Exchange Visitor Program certification as a result of their failure to adhere to the law.
Let this serve as a warning to all universities and academic institutions across the country.
BREAKING: The Department of Homeland Security just told @Harvard it will lose its ability to enroll international students if it doesn't comply with a list of demands within 72 hours.
Among those demands is an astounding requirement that Harvard hand over "all audio or video footage, in the possession of Harvard University, of any protest activity involving a nonimmigrant student on a Harvard University campus in the last five years."
Not just illegal activity. **Protest activity**. Including protected speech. Including if American citizens are involved.
The government also threatens Harvard with criminal prosecution if it provides "materially false, fictitious, or fraudulent information."
The first page of the letter ends by stating that the Trump administration "will enforce the law and root out the evils of anti-Americanism."
But there's nothing American about the government's demands.
The Trump administration is adopting the tactics of Peruvian strongman Óscar Benavides, who once said, "For my friends, everything; for my enemies, the law."
Harvard insisted the administration not violate its First Amendment rights. It filed a lawsuit last month to vindicate those rights.
In return, it's received more of "the law." — and more unconstitutional demands.
My latest column is a message to my fellow journalists: "The only way out is to face the truth. The president was not fine, was not even within shouting distance of fine — and until we examine our own failure to report that fact, neither are we."
"Behind every photo of an 'affirming' parent stands a person with a story—a person who may be terrified, a person who may feel isolated, a person who likely believes, in that moment, that they are saving their child’s life." genspect.org/the-narrative-around-affirming-parents-doesn…
Just reposting my own post in case this video, from my talk at the Censorship in the Sciences conference (Stay Away from Sex and Harvard) wasn't properly displayed! youtu.be/4I9gP--0tXM?t=13
Just got an email from Harvard Pres Alan Garber, asking for support. "I am grateful to everyone who stands with Harvard...Now is the time to speak up & lend your support to institutions that have contributed so much to our nation & our world. Your commitment to the University makes a tremendous difference."
See my recent talk 👇🏽about what happened.
Yes, Trump is overstepping, and there's lots worth saving. I also know I'm not alone in feeling that I can't stomach the hypocrisy of now being called on to do everything I can to help Harvard. Had yet another nightmare last night about being back in class with my students. Something horrible usually happens at the end (it's never the students' fault). Often it's people I trusted turning into monsters. Sorry, that's the actual dream.
Where are the apologies to those they wronged? Where is the evidence of real reform? Garber's email in the next post. Then an article from @TheFP on why I left Harvard. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4I9gP--0tXM
Just got an email from Harvard Pres Alan Garber, asking for support. "I am grateful to everyone who stands with Harvard...Now is the time to speak up & lend your support to institutions that have contributed so much to our nation & our world. Your commitment to the University makes a tremendous difference."
See my recent talk 👇🏽about what happened.
Yes, Trump is overstepping, and there's lots worth saving. I also know I'm not alone in feeling that I can't stomach the hypocrisy of now being called on to do everything I can to help Harvard. Had yet another nightmare last night about being back in class with my students. Something horrible usually happens at the end (it's never the students' fault). Often it's people I trusted turning into monsters. Sorry, that's the actual dream.
Where are the apologies to those they wronged? Where is the evidence of real reform? Garber's email in the next post. Then an article from @TheFP on why I left Harvard. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4I9gP--0tXM
Yesterday, the @LGBCourage Coalition hosted a 'Born in the Right Body' forum at MIT, with a dinner after. This crowd was waiting for us when we arrived. Thank you Glass House restaurant for supporting free speech and standing up to the mob, and to Cambridge PD! @libsoftiktok
FILED: FIRE supports Rep. Laurel Libby's appeal of her censure by the Maine Legislature, which prevents her from voting or speaking on the floor of the state's House of Representatives.
Maine's Democratic majority banned Rep. Libby from the floor because they didn't like her First Amendment-protected social media post on trans teens in female sports — a matter of intense public debate.
"The NIH...convinced governments around the world that the only way to save lives was to follow the lockdown path and that they needed extraordinary, almost dictatorial powers, suppressing free speech, suppressing freedom of movement, suppressing the principle of informed consent in medical decision-making, controlling nearly every single aspect of society, designating who’s essential and who’s not essential, closing churches, closing businesses." @NIHDirector_Jay
"Bigots like to cite studies that show that the upper body strength of the average man is 90 per cent higher than that of a woman. But this is because girls are socialised to believe that they can’t lift heavy things." @TitaniaMcGrath thecritic.co.uk/why-cis-women-are-bad-at-sports/
The claim that greater male strength and power is a sexist myth is just one of many that needs to take the kind of skewering that only Titania (@andrewdoyle_com) can deliver. I have been a Titania fan for years!
A new letter 👇🏽, "Biology is not binary: a letter from biologists, doctors, and other experts," argues that sex is "bimodal," not binary, and that "biological sex" is not a favored term among scientists, and is instead a "political term." I include a paper in the next post that shows that at least one signatory, who happens to be one of my favorite behavioral endocrinologists, actually knows sex is binary, and freely uses the term "biological sex." She signed anyway.
This argument seems less motivated by truth and more by activism; in this case to "restore the rights of trans & non-binary people to access toilets and other spaces that are essential to daily life." So rather than do the sensible thing, which is to start with truth and common sense (sex is real, binary and important), and then engage in good faith about policy issues on which reasonable people can disagree (like, which bathroom should passing trans people use), these authors/signatories start by undermining their credibility and expertise.
In the process, they lose opportunities to show that there is nuance in the science of sex, and that compassion and truth are compatible.
The next post has the link to the actual (sensible) views of a signatory, prominent (and generally excellent) sex differences researcher Margaret McCarthy.
Here's a teaser "Sex is dichotomous, with sex determination in the fertilized zygote stemming from unequal expression of sex chromosomal genes." The letter she signed blatantly contradicts her beliefs. Surely other signatories agree with her about the actual science, but abandon it when it appears to support disfavored policies. I'm sad to see this.
A few choice quotes from the paper 👇🏽"Considering Sex as a Biological Variable in Basic and Clinical Studies: An Endocrine Society Scientific Statement." By Margaret McCarthy and others.
"Sex is a biological concept...most vertebrates and all mammals have 2 distinct sexes."
"The classical biological definition of the 2 sexes is that females have ovaries and make larger female gametes (eggs), whereas males have testes and make smaller male gametes (sperm); the 2 gametes fertilize to form the zygote, which has the potential to become a new individual. The advantage of this simple definition is first that it can be applied universally to any species of sexually reproducing organism."
"Biological sex is dichotomous because of the different roles of each sex in reproduction. For scientific research, it is important to define biological sex and distinguish it from other meanings." The paper is (almost all) an excellent resource on the biological basis of sex differences, and well worth a read. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8348944/
Free speech defenders are familiar with the common “zombie arguments” (args that just won’t die) against free speech: e.g. “words are violence,” “hate speech ≠ free speech,” & “free speech is rightwing.” In The War On Words: 10 Arguments Against Free Speech—And Why They Fail (due out July 1) Nadine Strossen and I will hopefully debunk those pesky fallacies once and for all.
Well done @washingtonpost for publishing an unbiased editorial on the quality of the recent HHS report on pediatric medical transition.
"In studying the use of hormones, puberty blockers and surgery, researchers should have started with small, randomized, controlled trials and, if those were successful, gradually expanded the patient population through more such trials to establish effectiveness and refine best practices. Instead, encouraging results from small trials that were neither randomized nor controlled helped fuel a growing number of interventions at clinics around the world, where practice may vary significantly from the studied protocol."
Washington Post editorial board: “the HHS report is a careful, thorough and definitely skeptical tour through the subject… it makes a legitimate case for caution that policymakers need to wrestle with.”
The land acknowledgement practice is weirdly a left-wing expression of the right-wing "blood and soil" idea that land will always belong to those who have ancestral ties, regardless of the current social or political reality.
Friends, I finally have my new and official @NIH @X account. It's been a wild ride this past month since I started my new job as NIH Director, and we've accomplished a lot. Please follow me at @NIHDirector_Jay.
And the winners of the MIT "gender gap" debate are: @ImHardcory & @CHSommers, who understand that gene- environment interactions, not simply "barriers" & "discrimination," explain why we don't have 50-50 representation across STEM professions. A lively, interesting debate, and a great night with two of my heroes. (Note the height "gender gap" due to @byrne_a. With the excellent moderator Linda Rabieh.)
And the winners of the MIT "gender gap" debate are: @ImHardcory & @CHSommers, who understand that gene- environment interactions, not simply "barriers" & "discrimination," explain why we don't have 50-50 representation across STEM professions. A lively, interesting debate, and a great night with two of my heroes. (Note the height "gender gap" due to @byrne_a. With the excellent moderator Linda Rabieh.)
Noteworthy: Harvard President Alan Garber has now done interviews with the NYT, WSJ, Boston Globe, and NBC but has repeatedly declined requests from the school's paper @thecrimson.
(Harvard pres usually does regular interviews with The Crimson. Garber has broken that precedent.)
“In the HHS report, the authors regret the politicization of the topic. While they do not offer specific policy proposals, they note that other countries have come to the same conclusions and responded with a much-needed course correction.” www.thefp.com/p/evidence-for-pediatric-gender-transitions
When females take male levels of testosterone they do not become just like the average man psychologically. Same for men who block testosterone and take estrogen. Taking cross-sex hormones brings many welcome changes in, eg, sexuality and emotionality, but doesn't completely undo earlier sex-relevant hormonal and social effects on psychological development.
You're excluding the permanent effects of perinatal testosterone on brain development (masculinization). Boys and girls are quite different on average well before puberty even though their T does not differ in early childhood. In males, pubertal T acts in a previously masculinized brain. It will have very different effects in a person not exposed to high levels of T early in life. And one's social history--psychological, sexual, and so on also matter. Adding T later in life does increase libido in females, but it does not induce all aspects of typically masculine behavior.
You're excluding the permanent effects of perinatal testosterone on brain development (masculinization). Boys and girls are quite different on average well before puberty even though their T does not differ in early childhood. In males, pubertal T acts in a previously masculinized brain. It will have very different effects in a person not exposed to high levels of T early in life. And one's social history--psychological, sexual, and so on also matter. Adding T later in life does increase libido in females, but it does not induce all aspects of typically masculine behavior.
Goodness. Just reading the response to the HHS gender dysphoria report, from the American Academy of Pediatrics’ president.
Nothing says “I don’t know how evidence-based medicine works” louder than the demand to “consider the totality of available data.”
In evidence-based medicine (as in science), it is the *quality* and not the *quantity* of studies that show the most likely accurate answer.
Because they are cheaper and faster to produce, low quality studies almost always outnumber high quality studies. (This is why the “pyramid of evidence” is depicted as a pyramid, with greater volume at the base than the top.)
Because low quality studies (mostly surveys, in this case) are more subject to bias, getting to the right answer requires filtering them out and focusing on the high quality ones. One wants to re-add the more biased studies only when one’s opinion depends on that bias rather than on the evidence it obscures. www.aap.org/en/news-room/news-releases/aap/2025/aap-state…
Excellent commentary by @jessesingal on HHS report on gender medicine. "The answer to overpoliticized science is not more overpoliticized science...an important document that provides open-minded readers with a clear & nuanced overview of the debate." thedispatch.com/article/transgender-youth-hhs-report/
Just released: HHS review of evidence for puberty blockers & cross-sex hormones to treat gender dysphoria in kids. Finds "evidence pointing to significant risks—including irreversible harms such as infertility—while finding very weak evidence of benefit." www.hhs.gov/press-room/gender-dysphoria-report-release.html
Just released: HHS review of evidence for puberty blockers & cross-sex hormones to treat gender dysphoria in kids. Finds "evidence pointing to significant risks—including irreversible harms such as infertility—while finding very weak evidence of benefit." www.hhs.gov/press-room/gender-dysphoria-report-release.html
Below is the full text of the letter from Harvard's new Community and Campus Life Officer (our old Chief DEI Officer).
April 28, 2025
Dear Members of the Harvard Community,
For nearly four centuries, faculty, staff, students, and researchers have come to Harvard to learn, connect, and become part of an institution dedicated to expanding the boundaries of human knowledge. With this enduring vision in mind, our commitment to building a community comprised of individuals from a wide range of backgrounds, perspectives, and experiences is vital to our success. In President Garber’s recent message The Promise of Higher Education, he reaffirmed that we must continue “to work together to find ways, consistent with law, to foster and support a vibrant community that exemplifies, respects, and embraces difference” and, in doing so, “also continue to comply with Students For Fair Admissions v. Harvard, which ruled that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act makes it unlawful for universities to make decisions ‘on the basis of race.’”
This is the work ahead. It requires us to learn from and be responsive to our community and to reimagine our work in ways that meet our current needs and goals. It requires us to find new ways to bring people of different backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives together as one community, focusing on the unique experiences and contributions of the individual and not the broad demographic groups to which they belong. It requires us to build a culture in which our differences and disagreements serve as a source of learning and growth, moving away from polarization and toward empathy and understanding.
This emphasis reflects important findings from the recently administered 2024 Pulse Survey, our first campus-wide pulse assessment since 2019. I am grateful to everyone who took the time to share their experiences, which will shape our approach moving forward. Thousands of people from across the University provided insight into what it feels like to learn, teach, work, and live at Harvard. Though a large percentage of people reported a sense of belonging at Harvard, it was telling that a lower percentage reported forming relationships with people holding different viewpoints or registered a sense of comfort expressing their opinions to others. (I encourage you to read the full report and to look at the findings in Appendix B).
What does this tell us? Here at Harvard, we have built a community of excellence composed of individuals from all walks of life. Our challenge today is to help all within that community to realize the benefits of learning, working, and living alongside others who come from various backgrounds, have had different experiences, and hold diverse viewpoints. To be sure, a vital element of the work ahead will be, as ever, to ensure that each individual in our community is free from discrimination and harassment and that all are guaranteed equal access to educational opportunities. But to build a culture of mutual respect, we must also do more. We must sharpen our focus on fostering connections across difference, creating spaces for dialogue, and cultivating a culture of belonging—not as an abstract ideal, but as a lived experience for all.
To capture this emphasis and this mission, our office will become Community and Campus Life, effective immediately. Going forward, our new Office will redouble its emphasis on:
Providing a forum for schools to come together to share best practices on how to build a culture of belonging for all members of the Harvard Community.
Expanding and supporting programs that give members of our community greater opportunities to engage across difference.
Enhancing support for first-generation and low-income students.
In the weeks and months ahead, we will take steps to make this change concrete and to work with all of Harvard’s schools and units to implement these vital objectives, including shared efforts to reexamine and reshape the missions and programs of offices across the university. Much of that work is already under way in our schools. I look forward to continuing this essential work in partnership with you. Together, we can shape a Harvard anchored in excellence, animated by difference, and strengthened by shared purpose.
In community,
Sherri Ann Charleston Chief Community and Campus Life Officer
P.S. You can learn more about the Pulse survey findings and changes to our office in the Harvard Gazette.
🔥"Good practice, the “default target of any sex question should be sex”; & questions about gender identity should be asked separately. Sex (male or female) is determined by gametes at conception with phenotype influenced by chromosomes, hormones, and reproductive organs. A few people are found to have one of a small number of clinically recognised variations in sex development after expert investigation. These individuals nonetheless have a sex, either male or female."
Most people don't actually know the lengths parents will go to try to raise an academic superstar. In this post, I will detail the life of the average thoroughbred in STEM PhD programs at a top university. The thoroughbred lives a difficult life full of enormous amounts of pressure. The thoroughbred's parents have oriented the next 18 years of their family life to evolve around the academic success of their children. The thoroughbred's parents don't simply move houses within their country so their kids can go to the best school in the district; they do a nationwide search to decide where to raise their children based on the schools in that area.
The thoroughbred's parents tell their kids that getting straight A's in school isn't enough because the kids in their class are "normal," and to cut it, they are going to have to strive far beyond what's taught in a classroom. They usually have various tutors starting in elementary school, do math and language courses after school, and engage in summer enrichment activities. They make sure their kids get into the gifted and talented programs in their kids' school, and if their kid doesn't make the cut, they hound the school as hard as possible to make sure their kid stays with the leaders of the pack.
Their parents give them extra homework during the summer so that they can test out of as many subjects as possible during the school year. Their parents know the algebra readiness exam is in 6th grade and that their child needs to score above a 90% to be able to take algebra 3 years early. They have their child prepare for this exam as early as their kid can handle the material. For these children, school should be a breeze, and they learn the real stuff during their studies outside of the classroom.
By middle school, they are spending summers at various math and science camps and doing STEM after school programs. I cannot stress how common math camp is. Most people I have met in STEM PhD programs have gone to math camp, and basically all know each other from their early days going to various math camps as kids. Moreover, in middle school, a lot of the parents start on SAT prep and hope they can do the bulk of their preparation before high school because in high school they have more difficult things to worry about. I know a lot of folks who got the SAT score they used for college in 8th grade. Some kids even have dubious non-profits that they started in middle school that they build up throughout high school in order to project sincere interest in outreach over a long time period—god forbid college admissions programs think you just created a non-profit to get into college. If the high school they want their kid to attend requires testing, they start their kids in test prep classes a few years prior to the high school admissions exam.
In high school, they are maxing out AP courses and taking the hardest possible courses available. Usually by junior year, they are taking at least one course at a nearby college. They are entering science competitions and scoring very well at the national and international level. Many of the students who do well at Intel science competitions or Science Olympiads have parents in that exact field of study who can help guide them towards more sophisticated ideas. I know someone who won the Intel science competition by doing a project in spectroscopy whose parents worked on spectroscopy professionally. That being said, the parents aren't doing the projects for them—they know that would ultimately hurt their child—they can just steer them towards actual cutting-edge science and tell them which projects are promising.
By high school, all of the thoroughbreds are together at various prestigious public and private schools. Scattered amongst the thoroughbreds are incredibly smart kids who got lucky, and a few people who are struggling in that academic situation who just got lucky during the admissions process. The kids who aren't thoroughbreds have no idea what's going on underneath the surface. They think the thoroughbreds are simply geniuses - they just have so much better mastery of the material and seem to learn everything more quickly than they do. They have no idea what they are stacked up against. They simply do their assignments, try to get good grades, and do a good job in the clubs at school.
If a thoroughbred finds themselves struggling in school for whatever reason, they get a tutor and work on it incredibly hard outside of school, though the parents would see that as a personal failure as they should already be so far ahead of their peers that it shouldn't be possible.
When the thoroughbreds apply to college, they end up all over, not just fancy institutions. This is primarily because colleges have unofficial admissions quotas for how many students they can admit from each high school. So the top 10% of the thoroughbreds from the top 10% of high schools fill up prestigious universities, and the rest go elsewhere. But do not fret; those who go elsewhere kill it in college and become academic superstars at their respective universities.
Once PhD programs come around, the thoroughbreds all end up back together. They all know each other from math camp, science competitions, and shared social circles from prestigious high schools. They have an academic base that's just incredibly hard to compete with if you did not have similar academic training. The additional dexterity you get with that much additional exposure to material is hard to overstate. Of the 50 students admitted to a physics PhD program at my university, most of their parents have PhDs, and all but one student took calculus in high school.
Their parents are not necessarily wealthy; they simply prioritized their child's education to an extent most families don't even realize is on the table. Very few people seem to realize just how far families are willing to go to ensure their kids succeed academically, and I hope this post shines some light towards what is going on under the surface of what it actually takes to raise a thoroughbred.
"The left used Title IX & DEI rules to set expansive precedents protecting “vulnerable” students, as when administrators drove biologist Carole Hooven out of Harvard for allegedly creating a hostile climate for trans students and their allies by teaching that biological sex is binary." www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2025/04/21/trump-free-spee…
"The unanimous decision of this court is that the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in The Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex." 🙌🎉🥳
"You’re sick and evil and I’ll remember you when you die so I can find your grave to piss upon." Wanted to share the email I just received. This bit is so presumptuous! Negativity and anger aren't healthy, so perhaps (even though I'm almost 60) I'll outlive this individual and rob them of their grave-pissing opportunity. But fantasize away, whatever blows your skirt up.
"You’re a disgusting transphobic pig I hope you have fun with the blood on your hands collaborating with bigots destroying America on Fox News because you think trannies are icky and respecting a trans person who doesn’t want to be misgendered during a fucking medical examination is woke. I’m glad you found a way to cash in on the destruction of trans people in a time where we are historically marginalized, unable to access correct gender passports that can get us out of a country trying to ban our medical care. I know dozens of trans people in my area, a small town, and every single one of us is in fear of our lives because hideous hearted people like you chose make believe issues over empathy for people who already have nothing. You’ll never be erased as a woman, nobody has ever erased you the way myself and the trans people I hold dear have been erased by a conservative mind virus intent on destroying trans people. "Biological sex” as a weapon to attack trans people is all you’re defending and I find it abhorrent. You’re sick and diseased in the mind and the only hope you have as a human being is to shut the fuck up about trans people for the rest of your life. You’re sick and evil and I’ll remember you when you die so I can find your grave to piss upon."
Dude if you're gonna respond to journalists on Twitter anyway, why not come on my podcast we can actually have a conversation about this? If you have an iota of courage you'll make your case to a generally skeptical audience rather than lob bombs on Twitter.
www.thetimes.com/uk/society/article/supreme-court-live-wo… Supreme Court rules that a woman is legally defined as . . . a woman. Congratulations. And “The concept of sex is binary, a person is either a woman or a man”. Yes, the science was settled in the Precambrian. Nice that the law has finally caught up.
Every single one of us has a profound interest in government at every level strictly observing due process of law. All of us should be deeply concerned by any violation of anyone's due process rights, whether in criminal or administrative matters. We might like what government can more efficiently accomplish by disregarding proper legal procedures today. But we will rue the day we licensed such governmental misconduct when, tomorrow, a different government disregards legal procedures to achieve quickly results we abhor. The government in power, whatever it is, will not always be in power. There will "arise a pharaoh who remembereded not Joseph." If we want due process for ourselves and in defense of things we cherish and believe in, we must insist on due process for everyone.
🧵President Garber/Harvard rightly refuses to comply with outrageous demands from the Trump administration (letter below, followed by Garber's response). Garber writes: “Veritas... compels us to take up the difficult work of acknowledging our flaws.” The demands aren't the solution, but I don't see evidence that Harvard leadership fully understands—or is willing to seriously grapple with— the depth of the real problems. For instance, it has never publicly acknowledged or apologized for its mistakes, nor their impact on members of the community. Trump demand letter: harvard.edu/research-funding/wp-content/uploads/sites/16/………
Hi Beth, this is a great question and I've wondered about it too. Certainly the larger Adam's apple in adult men is due to male-typical levels of T in puberty, but I don't think there's much if any research on relative T level and Adam's apple size in adolescents. I haven't seen such research on adults either. If anyone knows of studies please comment! There is evidence that men with relatively high T have lower voices on average, but it's not a huge effect. This is a good excuse to post some info on T and the development Adam's apple from my book! 👇🏽
Hi Beth, this is a great question and I've wondered about it too. Certainly the larger Adam's apple in adult men is due to male-typical levels of T in puberty, but I don't think there's much if any research on relative T level and Adam's apple size in adolescents. I haven't seen such research on adults either. If anyone knows of studies please comment! There is evidence that men with relatively high T have lower voices on average, but it's not a huge effect. This is a good excuse to post some info on T and the development Adam's apple from my book! 👇🏽
.@sullydish seems (justifiably) enraptured by White Lotus writer, producer & director Mike White. Juicy and "edgy" (you have to listen to get the joke.)
This is good - a written debate between Cordelia Fine and @hoovlet about sex differences and testosterone. Worth reading for the case studies alone, especially the oil rig at the start. aeon.co/essays/a-psychologist-and-biologist-debate-the-si… A few comments on it - 🧵..
Carole Hooven (predictably) wins this exchange with Cordelia Fine.
Also worth reading is the 2019 exchange (written up as two separate articles) between Fine et al and Del Giudice et al, on the role of biology in sex-differences in brain and behaviour. I referred to these two articles in my European Review paper on EDI (screenshot and link below). No prizes for guessing who I think won that exchange!
However, Cordelia Fine is to be commended for being willing to debate, and for consistently supporting academic freedom. Unfortunately, many others who minimise the role of biological and evolutionary factors in the observed psychological differences between the sexes prefer the no-debate/cancel-culture approach.
Cordelia Fine and I disagree about the degree to which differences in sexual selection and testosterone contribute to behavioral sex differences humans. In this "spirited" exchange (link in comments), we probe the source of our divergent views. It's been a few years in the making, and I wasn't sure it would see the light of day. Thanks to Aeon (especially Sally Davies) and Cordelia for sticking with it!
Written debate on the role of biology and culture in shaping sex differences b/t @hoovlet and Cordelia Fine. Great format and worth reading, we need more in this vein. @aeonmag
Thanks for your question ("what is your explanation of why testosterone, despite being present in all men, causes/explains aggression in only some men.")
Let’s take a look at height to start with something innocuous (I hope). I assume you would agree that men are, on average, taller than women. That’s a sex difference in height, and I hope I could utter the sentence “men are taller than women” without being accused of being a “height essentialist” or something. (I do always try to explain that I’m talking about sex differences on average, so that in a discussion I don’t have to keep repeating it.) So: while men are taller than women on average, some women are taller than most men. Knowing an individual’s sex doesn’t tell you how tall they are, or even whether their height falls within the typical range for their sex.
It so happens that men’s higher testosterone levels help explain why they tend to be taller than women. But men with typical testosterone exposure can still be quite short — within, or even at the low end of, the typical female range. Even with all this variation and overlap, there’s still a meaningful sex difference in height that deserves explanation. One such explanation is the large sex difference in testosterone levels. This is consistent with the idea that an individual’s T level doesn’t accurately predict whether their height will be sex-typical. The same principle applies to behavioral differences.
Take play. Boys engage in more rough-and-tumble play than girls, on average. This difference appears to be driven by male-typical levels of testosterone in utero, but not all boys exposed to such levels prefer rough play. Why? We don’t know! What we do know is that there’s a great deal of variation in how genes, hormones, and environment interact. Knowing a boy’s testosterone exposure doesn’t tell us everything about how he’ll like to play. The hormone is not all-powerful, doesn’t dominate behavioral preferences or predispositions in individuals, and people vary in how it interacts with other physical, psychological, and environmental factors.
Another example: on average, females who take male-typical levels of testosterone as part of a gender transition experience a sharp increase in libido — but this isn’t true of all such individuals. The experiences of people exposed to high levels of a substance may differ from those exposed to much lower levels, but we still can’t always predict how any one person will respond. People vary.
Just as we can’t accurately predict height from testosterone levels, we can’t accurately predict whether someone will display a “sex-typical” pattern of behavior in areas like play, sexual orientation, libido, or aggression. But knowing whether someone had male-typical testosterone exposure throughout their life does allow us to make some good guesses.
To be clear: we know the environment shapes sex-typical behavior in many ways — ramping it up, toning it down, or influencing it in unpredictable directions. Women (like men) can be extremely violent when that’s encouraged and culturally supported (as in wartime); men can be extremely nurturing; and people can be more peaceful overall when peace is strongly valued. But we still see large and fairly consistent patterns of sex differences across most cultures.
Cordelia clearly defines gender essentialism as the belief in discrete, universal, immutable, and cross-culturally invariant sex differences. That’s not what I’m arguing. Cordelia has focused a great deal on gender essentialism and how it affects people’s perception of what’s possible for gender equality. But I think our conversation could have been more productive with more attention to the central issue Cordelia and I disagree on: the relevance of inherited biology to human behavioral sex differences.
Something good came out of all this—check out the fantastic book on @lancearmstrong's couch (at the 6 minute mark in the vid). It's called T: the Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us. He's got his facts straight. Thank you Lance, and John Oliver for the promo!
Something good came out of all this—check out the fantastic book on @lancearmstrong's couch (at the 6 minute mark in the vid). It's called T: the Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us. He's got his facts straight. Thank you Lance, and John Oliver for the promo!
Recientemente, la psicóloga Cordelia Fine y la bióloga Carole Hooven mantuvieron un interesante diálogo sobre el impacto de la testosterona en las diferencias de género. Cabe señalar que ambas científicas han mostrado tener perspectivas diferentes. 👉 aeon.co/essays/a-psychologist-and-biologist-debate-the-si…
While staying at "The White Lotus" was tragic for Rick and Chelsea, Walton Goggins says his relationship with co-star Aimee Lou Wood is a lot less toxic.
"It’s exceptions like the phalarope that prove the rule: for the sex that invests the least in parenting, competition for access to mates is often more fierce than the other way around. That results in greater sexual selection pressure operating on the less investing parent".
Cordelia Fine and I disagree about the degree to which differences in sexual selection and testosterone contribute to behavioral sex differences humans. In this "spirited" exchange (link in comments), we probe the source of our divergent views. It's been a few years in the making, and I wasn't sure it would see the light of day. Thanks to Aeon (especially Sally Davies) and Cordelia for sticking with it!
Written debate on the role of biology and culture in shaping sex differences b/t @hoovlet and Cordelia Fine. Great format and worth reading, we need more in this vein. @aeonmag
Hooven wins this exchange, I think, as Fine attacks a number of straw people and mistakenly calls Hooven an "essentialist." Fine is an advocate of cherry-picking data, and, though she'd deny it, really seems to believe that there are no evolved differences between men and women.
Cordelia Fine and I disagree about the degree to which differences in sexual selection and testosterone contribute to behavioral sex differences humans. In this "spirited" exchange (link in comments), we probe the source of our divergent views. It's been a few years in the making, and I wasn't sure it would see the light of day. Thanks to Aeon (especially Sally Davies) and Cordelia for sticking with it!
Written debate on the role of biology and culture in shaping sex differences b/t @hoovlet and Cordelia Fine. Great format and worth reading, we need more in this vein. @aeonmag
Cordelia Fine and I disagree about the degree to which differences in sexual selection and testosterone contribute to behavioral sex differences humans. In this "spirited" exchange (link in comments), we probe the source of our divergent views. It's been a few years in the making, and I wasn't sure it would see the light of day. Thanks to Aeon (especially Sally Davies) and Cordelia for sticking with it!
Written debate on the role of biology and culture in shaping sex differences b/t @hoovlet and Cordelia Fine. Great format and worth reading, we need more in this vein. @aeonmag
Thanks for your question ("what is your explanation of why testosterone, despite being present in all men, causes/explains aggression in only some men.")
Let’s take a look at height to start with something innocuous (I hope). I assume you would agree that men are, on average, taller than women. That’s a sex difference in height, and I hope I could utter the sentence “men are taller than women” without being accused of being a “height essentialist” or something. (I do always try to explain that I’m talking about sex differences on average, so that in a discussion I don’t have to keep repeating it.) So: while men are taller than women on average, some women are taller than most men. Knowing an individual’s sex doesn’t tell you how tall they are, or even whether their height falls within the typical range for their sex.
It so happens that men’s higher testosterone levels help explain why they tend to be taller than women. But men with typical testosterone exposure can still be quite short — within, or even at the low end of, the typical female range. Even with all this variation and overlap, there’s still a meaningful sex difference in height that deserves explanation. One such explanation is the large sex difference in testosterone levels. This is consistent with the idea that an individual’s T level doesn’t accurately predict whether their height will be sex-typical. The same principle applies to behavioral differences.
Take play. Boys engage in more rough-and-tumble play than girls, on average. This difference appears to be driven by male-typical levels of testosterone in utero, but not all boys exposed to such levels prefer rough play. Why? We don’t know! What we do know is that there’s a great deal of variation in how genes, hormones, and environment interact. Knowing a boy’s testosterone exposure doesn’t tell us everything about how he’ll like to play. The hormone is not all-powerful, doesn’t dominate behavioral preferences or predispositions in individuals, and people vary in how it interacts with other physical, psychological, and environmental factors.
Another example: on average, females who take male-typical levels of testosterone as part of a gender transition experience a sharp increase in libido — but this isn’t true of all such individuals. The experiences of people exposed to high levels of a substance may differ from those exposed to much lower levels, but we still can’t always predict how any one person will respond. People vary.
Just as we can’t accurately predict height from testosterone levels, we can’t accurately predict whether someone will display a “sex-typical” pattern of behavior in areas like play, sexual orientation, libido, or aggression. But knowing whether someone had male-typical testosterone exposure throughout their life does allow us to make some good guesses.
To be clear: we know the environment shapes sex-typical behavior in many ways — ramping it up, toning it down, or influencing it in unpredictable directions. Women (like men) can be extremely violent when that’s encouraged and culturally supported (as in wartime); men can be extremely nurturing; and people can be more peaceful overall when peace is strongly valued. But we still see large and fairly consistent patterns of sex differences across most cultures.
Cordelia clearly defines gender essentialism as the belief in discrete, universal, immutable, and cross-culturally invariant sex differences. That’s not what I’m arguing. Cordelia has focused a great deal on gender essentialism and how it affects people’s perception of what’s possible for gender equality. But I think our conversation could have been more productive with more attention to the central issue Cordelia and I disagree on: the relevance of inherited biology to human behavioral sex differences.
"Cordelia has offered no strong hypothesis that explains the fact that, across time and place, men are more likely than women to decide to throw that punch... Killing off T-Rex entirely serves only to shoot ourselves in the foot" -@hoovletaeon.co/essays/a-psychologist-and-biologist-debate-the-si…
"I found all the talk about whether people can ever really leave their worst selves and bad choices behind to be incredibly moving, lending a deeper, more haunting meaning to all of this show’s usual kinky sex and barely contained violence." www.nytimes.com/2025/04/06/arts/television/white-lotus-re…
the vulnerability of universities to Trump's attack on AF from the outside was created by the decades of subversion from the inside that they describe. Too few academics recognise that it is their tolerance of monoculture, intimidation and self-censorship that led to this point.
"A politics in which elite liberals told ordinary white Americans that they had to make sacrifices — from which elites themselves were largely exempt — in order to compensate for historical injustices was an invitation to disaster." www.nytimes.com/2025/03/24/books/review/james-traub-class…
Opinion | Columbia, Harvard, Princeton chairs on academic freedom "We call on universities to pursue two goals simultaneously: resisting inappropriate governmental intrusion, and implementing rigorous internal reform. (Full text in comments.) www.bostonglobe.com/2025/04/04/opinion/universities-acade…
Emmanuel Bourbouhakis is associate professor of Classics at Princeton University. Jacqueline Gottlieb is professor of neuroscience at Columbia University. Tarek Masoud is professor of democracy and governance at Harvard University. Steven Pinker is professor of psychology at Harvard University. Jon Rieder is professor of sociology at Barnard College and Columbia University. As chairs of the Academic Freedom Councils at Columbia, Harvard, and Princeton universities, we are alarmed at the threats to academic freedom currently faced by American universities. Universities are now confronted with extraordinary intrusions into their affairs by the federal government. At the same time, many threats to academic freedom emanate from within universities themselves. In this moment of crisis, we have an opportunity to address both threats, and to recommit the universities to their mission of advancing and disseminating knowledge. American universities are the envy of the world. They have made scientific breakthroughs that thrill the imagination, developed medical treatments that alleviate human suffering, invented technologies that fuel economic growth and improve the quality of life, distinguished effective policies from counterproductive ones, and enriched our appreciation of our culture and history. The threat from the outside The ability of universities to create this abundance of knowledge depends on a bedrock principle: freedom from political interference. No one is infallible, and scholars can only examine which ideas are sound and which are mistaken if they follow the evidence and arguments wherever they lead, free of coercion by politicians and bureaucrats. f course, universities depend on taxpayer money and are thus subject to federal regulation. Past examples include deployment of the National Guard to desegregate Southern universities in the 1960s, the threat to withhold federal dollars to force universities to expand women’s athletics in the 1990s, and the Obama administration’s more controversial use of that threat two decades later to compel universities to adopt new standards for prosecuting sexual misconduct under Title IX.
Such regulation, however, must be applied with precision and careful consideration of its effects. As both sides of the political spectrum recognize, hasty and excessive government regulation can lead to waste, injustice, and perverse consequences. (Recent newsworthy examples include the bogging down of affordable housing, high-speed rail, and a modern electricity grid by green tape and NIMBY obstruction.) Today we are witnessing a drastic overreach in the current administration’s withdrawal of $400 million dollars in research funds from Columbia University (followed by similar sanctions and demands imposed on Princeton and Harvard). These punitive measures, implemented hastily and without good-faith negotiation or respect for due process, imperil vital biomedical science while doing little to further the civil rights goals which the measures purportedly seek to advance. Defunding cancer research is not an effective way to combat campus antisemitism. Moreover, the government’s micromanaging of specific changes to Columbia’s internal functioning, including its disciplinary processes, definition of permissible speech, and curricular programs, is likely to backfire. The government’s demands threaten to install new speech codes just as universities are trying to expand their freedom of speech, to add administrators and compliance officers to an already bloated bureaucracy, and to make it hard for universities to pursue needed reforms lest they appear to be assenting to coercion from Washington. These demands also embolden future federal administrations to impose their own political agendas on universities they wish to manipulate. The threat from within Although universities are under threat from the outside, we must not avert our eyes from the threats to academic freedom that come from the inside. The three organizations we cochair emerged well before the present moment in shared recognition of a crisis of academic freedom on our campuses. While differing in our politics and much else, we recognized that our campuses had become intellectually cramped, with insufficient diversity in the range of ideas and viewpoints we teach and research. We witnessed the cancellation of speakers with unpopular views, saw some departments devolve into monocultures inhospitable to contrary opinions, and watched in dismay as well-meaning administrators implemented identity-focused policies that hardened boundaries between groups instead of dissolving them. Lately, we have seen universities fail to adequately address antisemitism, tolerate protests that cross the line from expression to disruption and coercion, violate their own well-founded rules, and apply antidiscrimination and harassment rules inconsistently. The result is a spiral of silence in which students and faculty censor themselves, leaving public discourse to the loudest and most zealous voices. The way forward We call on universities to pursue two goals simultaneously: resisting inappropriate governmental intrusion, and implementing rigorous internal reform. Regarding the first goal, we must challenge the dangerous threats to th e independence of universities. While acknowledging the government’s legitimate interests in protecting students’ civil rights, we should deploy all the political and legal means at our disposal to demand due process, good-faith negotiation, and specifically tailored regulations and remedies as mandated by the law. We should oppose mandates that would limit academic freedom and increase administrative bloat. We should unite with other universities in a common endeavor to preserve their independence. And we should engage our alumni to join us in this effort. These actions should be reinforced with a campaign of persuasion to remind our congressional representatives, the media, and the public of what universities contribute to America’s health, its economy, its security, and its culture and civil society. We also call on our universities to protect and assist foreign students who are legally threatened solely for constitutionally protected speech, and on our government to respect constitutional safeguards of civil rights and due process. Regarding internal reform, universities must recommit themselves to the ideals of institutional neutrality, academic freedom, and civil discourse. The university and its divisions should refrain from taking political positions on issues unrelated to the university itself, leaving such expression to its faculty and students. It must protect the free speech rights of faculty and students, consistently and without regard to viewpoint. And it should ensure that members of the community to treat one another with civility, humility, charity, and curiosity. To these ends, the university must not be afraid to impose consequences on those who infringe on its neutrality or on the rights of others. Coercion, disruption, and intimidation are not the same as speech. When disciplinary procedures are called for, they must be applied speedily, rigorously, with due process, and without prejudice regarding viewpoint. We have not hesitated to point out the problems with our institutions, but we remain convinced of their excellence and resilience. Viral incidents notwithstanding, most of what happens at our universities consist of scholars making discoveries and students learning about them. There is broad awareness on our campuses that changes are necessary, and many are well underway. We are confident that universities can recommit themselves to their missions and regain the trust of our fellow citizens without coercive intrusion that endangers these special American institutions and, with them, the public interest.
1. Does research by @CaraOcobock@Anthrofuentes & others, widely reported in SciAm & elsewhere, finally dispel hunter-gatherer myths that have persisted since the 60's?
"I worry that this [withholding of $9 billion] could include N.I.H. grants awarded to Harvard Medical School-affiliated hospitals and institutions such as Mass General Brigham, the Dana Farber Cancer Institute and Boston Children’s Hospital." @jflier, former dean of HMS.
Harvard has now received the Trump admin's letter outlining "immediate next steps that we regard as necessary for Harvard University’s continued financial relationship [$9 billion] with the United States government," including "all efforts should be made to shutter [DEI] programs." Full letter @thecrimson. www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/4/harvard-federal-fundi…
Bad, indeed, for the NYT. Pamela is a sane and sensible person. She respects evidence and does business in the currency of reasoned arguments. She has a perspective, just as we all do, but she's not a dogmatist or an ideologue. She's interested in getting at the truth of things.
"To maintain the moral high ground, which universities have in large part lost, they need a much more aggressive reform agenda focused on antisemitism, celebrating excellence rather than venerating identity, pursuing truth rather than particular notions of social justice and promoting diversity of perspective as the most important dimension of diversity." Thank you @LHSummers www.nytimes.com/2025/04/03/opinion/larry-summers-harvard-…
Pamela Paul's farewell to the NYT.👇🏽 Bad for the Times, good for her. From the comments: "Well . . . damn. This is a sad day for those of us who crave the equanimity, objectivity and candor Ms. Paul brings to the table. Thank you so much for your excellent work, often in the face of shrill and dogmatic reaction from the purity police. I can only speak for myself that I want and need more of this clear-headed and cogent argument." I'll look forward to seeing more of her work elsewhere soon. www.nytimes.com/2025/04/03/opinion/pamela-paul-truth.html…
"If we are to preserve our value & our meaning, we cannot let our caution overtake our purpose...Only by defending democratic values and norms and educating our students to carry them forward in all their complexity and challenge will we safeguard the future of our institutions — and our nation." Michael I. Kotlikoff, Cornell University president. I'm looking forward to my talk at Cornell (live-streamed) on April 29! Details to come. www.nytimes.com/2025/03/31/opinion/ideas-universities-con…
Here is a 24-year-old Tracy Chapman forced to fill in at the last minute and leaving Wembley Stadium in silence with only a guitar and her voice (1988)
PLEASE TAKE PART IN MY ONLINE STUDY! Takes roughly 10 minutes. Is completely anonymous. - Please participate alone (NOT in a pair or group) - Must be between 18-40 years old. - Must be in a heterosexual (straight), monogamous relationship.
"The portrait of college campuses as places suffused with one-sided ideology may be a caricature. But a caricature is an exaggerated portrait of something real. Recognizing that underlying reality would better position colleges and universities to defend our independence."
"It seems that the only beneficiaries of land acknowledgments are the institutions themselves...they can flex their superiority over close-minded peers that prefer not to hollowly virtue signal." Refreshing. By Harvard junior Henry P. Moss. @thecrimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/3/26/moss-harvard-land-ac…
"The fundamental idea that preserving free speech for those we disagree with is precisely what protects our own free speech from those who disagree with us. These commitments to fundamental principles will not only allow us to communicate more openly and effectively, they will also remind us of the wide range of common ground we actually occupy despite our differences." @glukianoff@StrangelEdweirdeternallyradicalidea.com/p/the-misinformation-crisis-isnt…
"Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, the newly confirmed director of the NIH, is a health policy expert well equipped to evaluate the methodological problems underlying the youth gender medicine debate. He could steer his boss’s hand away from the chain saw and toward the scalpel." @jessesingal@DrJBhattacharya 🎁 👇🏽www.nytimes.com/2025/03/27/opinion/trump-transgender-yout…
Congrats to friend and colleague @DrJBhattacharya on confirmation to head @NIH. Jay stands for critical thinking, rigorous research, and the free scientific debate - all much needed changes to the previous era. Make NIH Great Again!🥂
NYT: Track and Field to Be First Olympic Sport Requiring DNA Sex Tests for Women
"The change affects women with atypical genetics who have been able to compete if they suppressed their testosterone levels."
"Women with atypical genetics?" Is anyone still confused about why there is a conservative backlash about all this? Not all people with DSDs are clearly male, but that's simply not the case for the people with the DSDs that are over-represented in elite sports. I don't like having to push this issue, but the correct word here, especially since accurate information is necessary to form educated opinions on policy, is "male."
🧵World Athletics (the international governing body for track & field competitions & world records) will now require genetic testing to verify female sex. The Guardian says doing this will also "bar athletes with a difference of sex development (DSD) – who are reported female at birth but undergo the physiological benefits of male puberty – from the female category." This is a misleading comment, and it's brought to you by the erosion of clear & shared language. Unfortunately there's been full buy-in from progressive outlets like the Guardian. www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/mar/25/world-athletics-man…
Biased language and reporting misleads people about reality, making it even harder for us to engage across disagreement. It also reduces trust in democratic institutions, leading us to hunker down in our own tribes, increasing resentment and extremism. Telling the truth and using language that clearly reflects it allows interested parties to, ideally, share reliable information and participate meaningfully in important conversations. We're not always going to get our way, but there's something to be said for feeling heard (and one hopes, respected). Here's an open access article that @byrne_aand I wrote about a year ago relevant to all of this.
NYT: Track and Field to Be First Olympic Sport Requiring DNA Sex Tests for Women
"The change affects women with atypical genetics who have been able to compete if they suppressed their testosterone levels."
"Women with atypical genetics?" Is anyone still confused about why there is a conservative backlash about all this? Not all people with DSDs are clearly male, but that's simply not the case for the people with the DSDs that are over-represented in elite sports. I don't like having to push this issue, but the correct word here, especially since accurate information is necessary to form educated opinions on policy, is "male."
"'Adaptable' offers an engrossing, richly informative exploration of human biological diversity. By revealing how our variable bodies respond to a wide range of environments, it challenges us to rethink universal health benchmarks." Can't wait!! @HermanPontzer
You see this response pretty regularly, that avg sex differences are mathematical abstractions and not meaningful for individual people / cases. It would make this complex and heated issue easier if that were true, but that's not how these distributions work... 🧵1/
Carole Hooven reposted
Phil Mitchell:Specialist Working With Abused Males@PhilMitchell83
1/3 Whilst there are some parts of this article I am pleased to see (see next few tweets) I am disappointed with the undertones implying 'boys need to be better'
Butler (featured in the clip👇🏽) is "one of the great philosophers of our time" according to Jason Stanley, Jacob Urowsky professor of philosophy at Yale University.
Sperm erasure! Renowned philosopher Judith Butler: "all humans come from the larger gamete" which, if females/males are the ones that produce eggs/sperm, "implies that everyone is originally female." 👇🏽 youtube.com/clip/Ugkxyz8pjTvtvEwY87t6rPU4-4z0XsxmRbUi
NEW letter to Columbia from Trump admin lists demands for “continued financial relationship” with the US government”:
—Suspend or expel students for Hamilton Hall protest —“Time, place, and manner rules” —Mask ban —Address “anti-Zionist” discrimination —Reform admissions —MORE
"If masculinity is all culture, then a man need only think his way out of his sex drive, competitiveness, and aggression...But this will just result in exasperation, failure, and bitterness, because a man can’t think himself out of his body." open.substack.com/pub/sacredtension/p/do-we-really-hate-t…@stephenblong
Evading direct and reasonable questions from your host is an art, and clearly Troy Edgar has a long way to go. Thank you @NPRMichel for pushing for answers. I'd love to hear them.
NPR's Michel Martin fully exposes the ignorance of Homeland Security's Troy Edgar, who's unable to answer the most rudimentary questions about, or offer a single factual justification for, Mahmoud Khalil's arrest and detention.
Revue de T de Carole Hooven: les différences entre les sexes sont essentiellement biologiques, et les traits masculins sont dus au taux élevé de testostérone. Je vous invite à vous abonner au compte X de l'auteure : @hoovlet
"Gavin Newsom breaks with Democrats on trans athletes in sports" "Newsom agreed that the most politically destructive attack ads from Trump’s campaign featured Kamala Harris’ support for providing taxpayer-funded gender transition-related medical care for detained immigrants and federal prisoners...upward of 90 percent of Americans disagreed with Harris’ position...Then you had the video [of Harris] as a validator. Brutal." www.politico.com/news/2025/03/06/gavin-newsom-breaks-with…
“We must open the way for our individual faculty’s expertise, intelligence, scholarship and wisdom to inform our state and society in their own voice, free from institutional interference." www.nytimes.com/2025/03/11/us/institutional-neutrality-un…
Just published with @CiaraOnly1 a letter to the editor responding to a paper on stillbirth using desexed language. It is important to recognise the different experiences of women and men in relation to pregnancy complications, stillbirth, premature birth. bcmj.org/sites/default/files/BCMJ_Vol67_No2_complete.pdf
My quote in today's Times (UK) piece "Joe Rogan and the 'manosphere' glorify testosterone": “We send men to war and expect them to fight and be tough and strong and to protect our families and protect our countries. But those are also the qualities that we punish men for and that we label as toxic. I wonder if what we’re seeing now is a backlash because we have these shamelessly masculine leaders, and men now have permission to really assert their version of masculinity and say, ‘This is who I am.'" @joeroganwww.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/joe-rogan-and-the-…
This 1000%. I too used to think male strength was mostly about size until my super-skinny college boyfriend, who actually weighed less than me, effortlessly pinned me in a (playful) wrestling match, then held me down with one arm while he ostentatiously took a bite of his sandwich
My observation is that very many women genuinely do not have an intuitive sense of how much stronger men are than women, because men have not used their strength against them &, when playing, hold back their strength. 1/
"While everyone seems to be concerned about whether girls are performing well in STEM classes, no one seems all that troubled by the fact that boys are consistently underperforming in reading and writing." www.wsj.com/lifestyle/workplace/why-are-girls-less-likely…
My quote in today's Times (UK) piece "Joe Rogan and the 'manosphere' glorify testosterone": “We send men to war and expect them to fight and be tough and strong and to protect our families and protect our countries. But those are also the qualities that we punish men for and that we label as toxic. I wonder if what we’re seeing now is a backlash because we have these shamelessly masculine leaders, and men now have permission to really assert their version of masculinity and say, ‘This is who I am’.” @joeroganhq@Ben_Spencerwww.thetimes.com/uk/healthcare/article/joe-rogan-and-the-…
Interesting that some Senators criticized @DrJBhattacharya for saying he would fund research at the @NIH to show that vaccines do not cause autism. The critics argued that this was 'settled science.'
Yes, there is compelling evidence against the vaccine-autism relationship. However, a large swath of the public do not believe it. Because of public skepticism, it is not settled science.
There is a need for further research intentending to convince the public regarding vaccine safety. It is not good enough to say "I am a scientist at a prestigious university, and you should believe what I say because of who I am."
That does not work anymore, especially after the pandemic when science's reputation took a big hit...
The fact that the argument in the US on female sport has fallen into an R/D partisan split is absurd. There is no clear ideological or principled basis for it. It needs explanation. (There is, for example, a marked difference with the way things have fallen over here)
"I will establish a culture of respect for free speech in science & scientific dissent at the NIH.. Dissent is very essence of science. I will foster a culture where NIH leadership will actively encourage diff perspectives.. and allow expression of disagreement” —@DrJBhattacharya
Free speech on college campuses is a proud American tradition, and — on public campuses — protected by the First Amendment. President Trump's message this morning, combined with other recent executive orders threatening punishment for protected speech, is deeply chilling. 🧵
🧵1/2 The Guardian columnist who wrote yesterday's op-ed about Trump's executive order reached out to me Friday morning for some "expert commentary."
TLDR: I provided her with plenty of scientific evidence/argument/detailed commentary in answer to her questions about Trump's executive order (YES it is scientifically sound) and the idea that everyone starts out female (UNsound). All of that was ignored, which is not unusual. (She did say that she would follow up next week with a more comprehensive piece that might include my perspective...we'll see!)
Given how extensive our communications were, I did expect that some of my perspective would be included. But it was the opposite. Here's a sample quote from her piece: "Most scientists now reject the idea that sex is strictly binary. The likes of Nature, possibly one of the most prestigious scientific journals in the world, has noted that 'the research and medical community now sees sex as more complex than male and female'." I know that my expectations were misplaced. I sill need to learn my lesson. I'm sharing some of our correspondence, below, so that you can have some insight into how journalists can select some "experts" over others.
Here are her original questions (be sure to read her Guardian article):
There has been commentary suggesting that the wording of this order technically classifies everyone as a woman. See: "Basically, the early, default configuration of a human foetus is female. If we were to assign a sex at conception as per Trump's executive order, all of them would be female." mashable.com/article/trump-executive-order-sex-female-mal…
I was hoping to get some expert commentary from you on whether 1) that assessment that the EO technically classifies everyone as female is correct. 2) the scientific merits of the EO more generally."
"In Butler’s phantasmagoric world, the oceans are boiling, bisexuals lie dying in the streets, and the empty shelves of school libraries gather dust. On a hillside, J. K. Rowling stands between Vladimir Putin and the Pope, the papal cassock flapping in the breeze. The trio gaze with grim satisfaction at the devastation below, under a glowering sky." By @byrne_a for @FairerSexFD, featuring @jk_rowling & @Pontifex. fairerdisputations.substack.com/p/fairer-disputations-yea…
"The sexual division of labour likely co-evolved with increased sex differences in spatial behaviour and landscape use....Some basic measures of spatial cognition, including three-dimensional mental rotation and dead reckoning, have been studied in many human populations, and research to date shows that in these two measures, average male scores are characteristically higher than those of women."
I think about these figures a lot when I try to understand our species. Landscape use by Hadza hunter-gatherers. 75% of land is visited by only men, 11% by women only. 13% visited by both men and women. @briwood1 www.nature.com/articles/s41562-020-01002-7
I posted yesterday about 5-ARD, a disorder (or difference) of sex development. I don't think anything I've posted here has ever received more attention (millions of views, over 10K likes, and rising, media inquiries, which I've turned down).
First: why didn't I mention that I have a book for anyone interested in sex differences, testosterone, DSDs, etc.? Did not occur to me. Dumb, I know. But it's a great book! Go buy it! It's called T: the Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us. a.co/d/0yhZsGB
Second: I know I could have written more concisely, but I wanted to get relevant info out there on this particular DSD, in a way that is interesting (to me) and accurate. I love all the detailed stuff, and like 10 other people do too, so that's what I included.
Third: I don't know what condition any boxers who probably shouldn't be competing in the female category have. I provided info on one condition that fits the info I do have (athletes with XY chromosomes, an apparent significant advantage in strength and power, not identifying as transgender, competing in the female category), and which is relatively common in these rare situations.
And fourth. Some people were confused about various aspects of this DSD, which is understandable, since my tweet about it was too long for most people to read carefully (or even finish), and I used language and concepts that non-scientists might not be used to. But if you're interested, here's what I hope is some clarifying info. Yes it's detailed!
Males with 5-ARD do not have a uterus or other female internal structures, but they do have what looks like a vagina, so are often sexed as females. However they are males with normal testes, which produce typical male hormones. Those hormones, among other things, prevent the development of female internal reproductive structures (like the uterus and cervix).
In embryonic development, we all start out with two sets of primordial duct systems, one set that will develop into the male internal reproductive stuff (the Wolffian ducts, which become the epididymis, vas deferens and seminal vesicles), and another that develops into the female internal stuff (the Müllerian ducts, which become the upper part of the vagina, cervix, uterus and fallopian tubes, pic at the end).
In males, fetal testes don't only produce testosterone! They also make Anti-Mullerian Hormone (AMH), which is crucial for getting rid of the Mullerian ducts, and thus, ensuring that the eventual uterus, etc. don't develop. If there's no testes and no AMH, that female internal stuff will develop.
Males need high levels of T for male-typical development of all the male reproductive structures. Without T production and action, the external (penis and scrotum) and internal (described above) genitalia won't develop. But as I wrote in my monster tweet yesterday, T alone isn't enough for development of the penis and scrotum (and prostate): for that, T must be converted into DHT (a more potent androgen, production pathway below), and people with 5-ARD don't make the necessary enzyme to carry out that conversion. So they end up with what appears to be a vagina.
FYI, some males inherit a genetic mutation that means they can't produce AMH. They are typical males, but have a nonfunctional uterus and fallopian tubes inside their abdomen. The condition often not discovered until adulthood (it's called Persistent Müllerian Duct Syndrome). AMH is an important hormone for males, but hardly anyone even knows it exists.
Also, the testes generally don't descend into the scrotum before birth (as usual) without DHT, but they often do at puberty when testosterone levels reach high concentrations. So males with 5-ARD may be "sexed" as female, due to the female-appearing external genitalia.
But brain and the rest of the body are typically male. Most people with the condition will "transition" to living as a male once they realize they are male, and this often happens at puberty, when the testes descend and the body develops in a typically masculine way.
Seems like a good time to re-post my older (now edited) post about athletes with XY DSDs (Disorder, or Difference of Sex Development). Lots of graphs and detail about the relevant biology at the end.
* * * First: People living with DSDs should be treated with compassion and understanding, and receive any heath care they need. These can be challenging conditions for individuals and their families. But when male athletes have DSDs that give them an advantage over females, and they compete in the female category, this raises concerns about safety and fairness, and forces discussion of the relevant physical traits.
Athletes with XY DSDs who have testes (usually internal), XY sex chromosomes, male-typical levels of testosterone, and functional androgen receptors are often described as females with "hyperandrogenism," i.e., abnormally high levels of testosterone. They experience physical benefits of this high testosterone during puberty, which translate into athletic advantages over females. The issue for sports is that athletes with the XY DSD 5-alpha reductase deficiency (5-ARD), may be socialized as female, may be legally female, and may live and identify as female; but they are male.
These individuals are usually born with female-appearing genitalia, which can lead to being sexed as female. Here's why. 5-ARD is caused by a mutation in the gene that codes for the enzyme 5-alpha reductase, which converts testosterone into a more potent androgen, DHT. This androgen interacts with the androgen receptor, like testosterone, and is necessary for the typical development of male external genitalia (penis and scrotum) and the prostate. Without DHT, female-typical external genitalia develop. At the end of this monster post is a graphic of the relevant steroid production pathway, from my book T: The story of Testosterone.
DHT is also responsible for male-pattern baldness and dark, coarse facial hair, which is why people with the condition have smooth skin that can give a feminine appearance.
The “decision makers” are aware that athletes with 5-ARD are male, and that they experience the benefits of male puberty. The requirement to reduce their testosterone to typical female levels isn’t discriminatory, since these are males who are asking to compete in the female category. But more significantly, all the relevant scientific evidence shows that reducing male T in adulthood does not undo the physical benefits of male puberty.
Here's more detail about T, DHT, and male advantage in strength and speed.
I've been asked if men with the DSD 5-ARD (in which ppl cannot convert testosterone into the more potent androgen DHT) experience the typical benefits of male puberty, that would give them an advantage in strength and speed relative to women. This is relevant to questions about whether male athletes with 5-ARD should be allowed to compete in the female category. This is an excellent question, because it could be the case that DHT is necessary for the development and maintenance of male-typical muscle, lean body mass and strength. If that were the case, then people with 5-ARD might not have a typical male advantage, because the lack of DHT would perhaps lead to a more feminine pattern of fat, lean body mass and strength. I've wondered about this myself and have looked into the evidence.
Perhaps the top researcher in this area, Shalendar Bhasin, who is scrupulous in his methods, has examined this very question. The answer appears to be: no, testosterone does not need to be converted to DHT to exert its typical anabolic effects. These findings are reported in his 2012 study, "Effect of Testosterone Supplementation With and Without a Dual 5α-Reductase Inhibitor on Fat-Free Mass in Men With Suppressed Testosterone Production, A Randomized Controlled Trial." (It is linked to below—and since it's paywalled, I've included the graphs that show comparisons between the placebo and DHT— inhibited conditions, with no difference on the various outcomes.)
For more detail, the investigators wanted to examine the effects of suppressing DHT on muscle mass, strength, and sexual function. This important because one of the treatments for benign prostatic hyperplasia and male-pattern baldness is to suppress DHT, but clinicians have been concerned about effects on other outcomes that affect health and quality of life. Participants (healthy men, 18 to 50, with normal T levels) had their T blocked, and were given graded doses of T, along with either placebo or a drug that blocked the conversion of T to DHT. So both groups had T, but only one, the placebo group, also had DHT. After 20 weeks of treatment, changes in lean body mass, muscle, and strength were assessed. There were no significant difference between the placebo and DHT-blocked groups in these outcomes.
For LOTS more detail, here's the relevant text from the results. Please don't ask me questions about the study. Just look at the abstract and results which you can find by Googling. The main point is that while there are predicted effects of the different doses of T received, there were no differences in the outcomes according to whether they had DHT blocked (with dutasteride) or not (placebo). "Fat-Free Mass Fat-free mass and lean body mass increased in a dose-dependent manner in the placebo and dutasteride [THIS IS THE DRUG THAT BLOCKS CONVERSION OF T TO DHT] groups (Figure 2).
The changes in fat-free mass were related to testosterone dose and changes in testosterone concentrations in the placebo and dutasteride groups but did not differ between groups; the dose-adjusted mean difference (placebo minus dutasteride) in fat-free mass was 0.50 kg (95% CI, −0.22 to 1.22 kg; P = .18). There was no significant interaction between testosterone dose and randomization to dutasteride or placebo, indicating a lack of evidence that the relationship of testosterone dose to change in fat-free mass differed between the dutasteride and placebo groups.
The model-based smoothed regression lines, obtained by generalized additive models, describing the relationship between changes in testosterone concentrations and changes in fat-free mass and lean body mass were similar in the placebo and dutasteride groups. Changes in fat mass were negatively related to testosterone dose and concentrations, but the relationship between change in fat mass and dose did not differ significantly between the placebo and dutasteride groups (P = .41; Figure 2)."
"Muscle strength Leg-press and chest-press strength increased dependently by dose in the placebo and dutasteride groups. Increases in leg-press and chest-press strength were greater with larger doses and higher concentrations of testosterone. These relationships did not differ between the placebo and dutasteride groups (Figure 2)."
Really interesting commentary from the authors on the role of DHT in adult men: "Why then did the steroid 5α-reductase system evolve for androgens? Forty-six XY males with steroid 5α-reductase deficiency exhibited ambiguous or female external genitalia at birth and poor prostate development, but underwent normal muscle and bone development during pubertal transition. The phenotype of these patients suggests that steroid 5α-reductase plays an essential role in the development of prostate and phallus by providing local amplification of an androgenic signal without systemic hyperandrogenemia during critical periods of sexual differentiation, illustrating nature's extraordinary ingenuity in creating mechanisms for tissue-selective amplification during development.
We speculate that in adult men, in whom this tissue-specific amplification is not essential because the circulating testosterone concentrations are substantially higher than those in the fetus, testosterone and DHT can interchangeably subserve many androgenic functions. When circulating testosterone concentrations are low, intraprostatic DHT formation may become important in maintaining prostate growth, thus buffering the effects of decreasing testosterone levels, which has been suggested by Marks et al.
Our data are consistent with studies that have reported no effects of 5α-reductase inhibitors on muscle or bone mass. Inferences from these trials are limited by the fact that administration of 5α-reductase inhibitors increases testosterone levels, rendering it difficult to ascribe the outcomes to differences in DHT levels alone. In our trial, inhibition of endogenous testosterone by administration of a gonadotropin-releasing hormone agonist eliminated this problem. Additionally, the high-dose dutasteride regimen effectively inhibited both steroid 5α-reductase isoenzymes."
"The entire school already knows that Lily is now 'Tyler.' Teachers will cheerfully share that information with each other, school mental health staff, administrators, and other students. The only ones who don’t get to know are the parents." @AbigailShrier
"Where great questions of democracy are concerned, the university should be institutionally neutral...because taking positions as an institution threatens univ's distinct competence: subjecting society's orthodoxies to empirical & theoretical scrutiny." www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/beyond-academ…
Talked about testosterone @TEDTalks. Met incredible people, saw fascinating, life-changing talks, filled up on love & support, & stocked up on free snack bars. Thanks to @PamelaParesky for getting my foot in the door, to @TEDchris, & everyone at TED who worked hard to make it a magical experience.
Feeling very proud of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard (@cafharvard) & our new statement, which @harvard should adopt. Here's a bit:
"Every member of the academic community should be free from fear of reprisal for positions they defend, questions they ask, or ideas they entertain...[and] should enjoy full standing to speak and be heard, regardless of background or social position...We also have a moral duty to listen, and to approach disagreement in a spirit of genuine curiosity, motivated by the desire to learn from each other, and open to the possibility that any of us, at any time, might be wrong." 👇🏽
Insights from Kit Parker (@Kkitparker), @harvard professor and a Colonel in the @USArmyReserve who has served two tours in Afghanistan. From an email, with permission:
"We are not a closed system. Harvard operates under the umbrella of the freedoms afforded by the strenuous efforts of Americans who will never set foot on our campus; and then Harvard tells those same Americans to shut up when they voice their expectations of how we should operate.
What our president got in Congress last week reflects a lot of what the nation is thinking. We, as an institution, must win back the trust of the American people. We do that with some top to bottom housekeeping that is not going to be comfortable for many. That includes diversifying our faculty, staff, administration, and student body in ways that are not apparent in a website photograph. It is going to take a commitment to liberal thought, not leftist orientation thought."
Eloquent and heartbreaking. From Harvard Law Professor Mark Ramseyer's email to a Harvard list (with permission). I came for my PhD in '99, he came as a prof in '98. We were each publicly attacked for our views in '21. "Harvard is a vastly less tolerant place than it was when I arrived in 1998. The intolerance is a function of an increasingly large fraction of our colleagues. And we – the rest of us on the Harvard faculty – let it happen. The cancelling, the punishments, the DEI bureaucracy, the DEI statements, the endless list that we could all recite – all this happened on our watch. We saw it happen, but we did nothing. We were too busy. We were scared to speak up. We – we on the faculty – let Harvard become what it is. The Harvard that we have is the result of our own collective moral failure. The alumni who are furious are not trying to turn Harvard into something we do not want. They are trying to rescue Harvard from what we let it become. We as a faculty failed. That is why the alumni are speaking up. That is why we formed the Council on Academic Freedom in the first place." @cafharvard@sapinker
.@Anthrofuentes says (below) that failure to entertain “diverse voices” on sex and gender reflects ignorance and is anti-intellectual. Here are some of his thoughts about a panel he helped to get cancelled (which I was to participate in, along with @eweissunburied and others, see @canceledanthro).
“We are writing in support of the American Anthropological Association’s decision to withdraw the 'Let’s Talk About Sex, Baby' session from the Annual Meeting....Implicit in the session abstract and several of the individual abstracts is the assumption that sex is a biological binary; a concept that is rejected by current biological anthropology and human biology, and highly disputed across contemporary biology.”
A very prominent Academic/Intellectual organization (not my Uni) rejected a major integrative and highly interdisciplinary/diverse voices project on Gender/Sex because “it is not the right time for this/Too hot of a topic.” Fear and ignorance are powerful and anti-intellectual.
I want to be clear that @Harvard did not fire me. They did not "remove me" from my position. Another person in the same situation might have stayed on, but I could not. The fact is that I did not feel that I could do my job any longer, and I did feel pushed out; but that is not the same as actually being forced out.
First, my mental health was deteriorating rapidly; and second, it seemed apparent that I would not be supported in pursuing my teaching, research and writing, given the lack of public support from my department and Harvard administrators in response to public attacks on my character. (And I could not even teach my lecture course, since for the first time in 20 years, no grad students would agree to serve as my teaching assistants.)
There's far more to it than that, of course, and I wrote about some of it in this article below: shorturl.at/gIP02
.@jessesingal just closed giveaway of “Trouble With Gender" by @byrne_A. Singal says Byrne "can seriously write for a lay audience," & "succeeds wildly" in "making arguments about sex & gender & gender identity based on careful definitions & rigorous philosophical thinking." substack.com/home/post/p-139019406?source=queue…
Good news is you can still pre-order the book, #1 new release in Philosophy on Amazon & perfect holiday gift (released Jan 3). a.co/d/cxPdJlp
We evolutionary biologists (@SwipeWright , @Evolutionistrue , @FondOfBeetles and others) are fascinated by the immense diversity in body and behavior of male and female organisms. We also understand that mammals come in two sexes, male and female, and that these are reproductive categories that are defined by the body plan for the production of either large or small gametes.
@Anthrofuentes knows what we think about all this, so I am confused about why he says in @sciam that scientists like us “maintain that whether our bodies make ova or sperm are all we need to know about sex.” Relatedly, he says that “producing ova or sperm does not tell us everything…about an individual’s childcare capacity, homemaking tendencies, sexual attractions, interest in literature…” Um…who is saying that gametes dictate any of this? That sex is binary is obviously compatible with traits like interest in literature varying widely between the two sexes. It is also compatible with the existence of significant differences between the sexes.
Unfortunately, Fuentes has tarred all the members of a diverse group with the same brush, denigrating the motives of those who assert that sex is real, biological, binary and meaningful for social policy. “They are arguing for a specific political, and discriminatory, definition of what is ‘natural’ and ‘right’ for humans based on a false representation of biology…[and] dishonest ascriptions of what biology is are being deployed to restrict women’s bodily autonomy…and to attack the rights of transexual and transgender people.”
Sex matters because even though bodies and behavior vary, being male or female does predict a lot. Women in particular understand this, because we are more physically vulnerable than men. We care about gender-diverse people and their basic human rights, and we are *also* concerned about safety and fairness in places like prison cells and women’s sports. These issues can be debated sensibly without relying on “a false representation of biology.”
"As a feminist analyst, I have to note, I have literally never seen a study that asks women if they find penis size a marker of sexual attractiveness. Male scientists don't want to run that study." @jordanbpeterson@naomirwolf
"You can put away the world’s smallest violin. Polity, a well-regarded academic UK press, agreed to take the book on...Trouble w/ Gender: Sex Facts, Gender Fictions (w/ @ninapaley cover art) should be out in the UK in Oct & later in the US." @byrne_aquillette.com/2023/04/17/philosophys-no-go-zone/
“suicide rate among minors seeking medical transition between 2010 & 20 was 0.03%—nothing close to the 41% risk commonly cited by US activists…in a large Swedish study, suicide increased among adults who had received gender reassignment treatments.” www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/finland-youth…
Dr. Sari van Anders is an influential endocrinologist who runs an endocrinology lab (not in the humanities as some have assumed) at Queen's uni and is well published and cited on matters of hormones and gender (including in the popular press).
TLDR: in a new and startling paper, van Anders claims, among other things, that men and women don’t differ in estradiol levels, but we do. Dr. van Anders has blocked her account after getting slammed in response to the article. psycnet.apa.org/record/2023-15924-001
I took a long time with this reply, read her paper carefully and followed up on references, and was looking forward to finally posting it, but her account is now locked, so I’m posting it here. It’s worth checking out her tweet thread, and the paper if you have access, even if you're not into this stuff. This is the state of science today.
@SarivanAnders: Thanks for alerting me to this interesting article. I found your definition of sex, and other statements quite confusing but I'll start with something concrete. You repeat a claim that levels of estradiol (E) do not differ by sex (apparently to combat the idea E is "the essence of womanhood"), but this is contradicted by the evidence. (You've done something similar with claims about overlap in testosterone levels.) You cite 3 papers to support your claim: 1st is Leining '10, which does not even have the word "estradiol" in it. They do not measure it. 2nd is Hyde '19, which is not a research paper. The “evidence” from that paper is simply a repeat of the claim about a lack of sex differences in E, again citing the irrelevant Liening article, along with 3rd article you cite in your current paper to support the claim, van Anders '10.
So despite the numerous studies that were designed using the best methods to determine "reference ranges" of reproductive hormones (which rely on mass spectrometry, the gold standard for steroid measurement), the only potentially relevant evidence to support your claim is your own paper, which was not designed to determine sex differences in E, but how chewing gum affects results (for salivary assays) using radio immuno-assay "RIA"). While you reported E values for both sexes, you did not report a statistical analysis of sex differences in E.
We have plenty of solid evidence about sex differences in hormone levels from studies that were specifically designed to measure them, using the best methods to do so. These studies (I'm including 2, but there are others) consistently show robust sex differences in T and E. For example, see the first graph below, from "High-sensitivity quantification of serum androstenedione, testosterone, dihydrotestosterone, estrone and estradiol by gas chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry with sex- and puberty-specific reference intervals" by Ankarberg-Lindgren '18.
Note the sex differences in the Y axis values & vastly higher levels for females. Second bar graph (similar findings, but with adults) is from "High-Sensitivity Tandem Mass Spectrometry Assay for Serum Estrone and Estradiol" by Kushnir, M. '08 (menopausal women do often have similar levels of E to men).
Nobody’s femininity (or masculinity) is dictated by their hormone levels. But we convey the opposite message when we work so hard to show that men and women’s real biological differences don’t exist.
Where are standard medical procedures for the treatment of children who identify as trans? Apparently, nowhere. Listen to the shocking testimony from someone on the inside, interviewed by the "secret weapon" of the Free Press, Emily Yoffe. youtu.be/_6sPG7gleOs via @YouTube
"many female academics...refuse to be silenced in their pursuit of truth & intellectual freedom. [They] represent a wide range of views, but each ...has argued, often at great personal cost, against one or more of the dominant perspectives in academia." Also @amychua. 🙏🏽 Maggie!
“The effect of all this is that today we are defining people — especially children — by gender more than ever before, rather than trying to free both sexes from gender stereotypes.” Click the “some go so far” link in the article! www.nytimes.com/2022/12/04/opinion/free-to-be-you-and-me-…
I described some of the trouble I’ve had at Harvard in response to speaking about the binary nature of sex, & I make some recommendations about how universities might better handle these kinds of situations in the future. We are telling our stories because #academicfreedom, 2/
Long 🧵 In his article entitled “Biological Science Rejects the Sex Binary, and That’s Good for Humanity,” Princeton anthropologist Agustin Fuentes informs us that “Science points to a more accurate and hopeful way to understand the biology of sex… www.sapiens.org/biology/biological-science-rejects-the-se…