On the microeconomic foundations of macro stabilisation: The Hall-Woodford prize in historical perspective
beatricecherrier.wordpress.com/2026/10/12/on-the-microeco…
Beatrice Cherrier
Beatrice Cherrier is a historian of economics and associate professor at CREST, CNRS, and ENSAE/Ecole Polytechnique, France. Her research interests include the history of economics since World War II. She has been cited in the popular media on several topics in the history of economics, including theories of discrimination, the rise of the MIT economics department, and the representation of women in the economics profession. More on Wikipedia
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"While unlikely, we cannot rule out that de-identified data derived from their usage of our products helped improve our models" is a sentence with staggering consequences
OpenAI
@OpenAI
We congratulate Levent Alpöge and Tristan Buckmaster on their remarkable mathematical work.
We (the researchers and the agents) did not see any of their work through any means until they released it publicly — in particular, no specific user data was accessed in order to solve this problem.
While unlikely, we cannot rule out that de-identified data derived from their usage of our products helped improve our models.
However, our proofs differ significantly and even the precise results proved are different in the Euler case (forced vs. unforced).
OpenAI
@OpenAI
We’re sharing a solution to the Navier-Stokes Millennium Prize Problem, one of the deepest problems at the frontier of mathematics.
The proof was produced by a group of agents, using an OpenAI next-generation model significantly more capable than GPT-6 Astra.
The problem concerns whether the description of smooth three-dimensional fluid motion modeled by the Navier-Stokes equations can break down. It has remained unresolved for roughly 90 years. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
NIK
@ns123abc
>math professor spends a year on one of the hardest unsolved problems in math
>"Navier-Stokes"
>his drafts for the whole project went through codex sessions
>openai had his logs in codex
>suddenly rumor leaks AI solved it
>he emails openai to ask what's going on
>openai calls within days
>"funny story, our model also solved it"
>using his exact approach
>asks openai: did you train on my sessions?
>no answer -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven N. Durlauf
@sndurlauf
Delighted that this conversation with the brilliant Beatrice Cherrier @Undercoverhist is now posted. Our discussion includes Beatrice's general vision of the history of thought and its role in economics and her work on the status of women in economics.
History of economic thought is profoundly underappreciated in economics, and the loss is all the greater given the fact that the field is flourishing thanks to a younger generation of star scholars such as Beatrice. Beatrice has been a pioneer in the study of economics as a research community. As such, her work speaks to questions that are foundational to the history and philosophy of science. For example, Beatrice work is integral to understand how ideas Philip Kitcher's The Advancement of Science apply to economics.
Here are some of Beatrice's papers that I have found especially valuable.
"Classifying Economics: A History of the JEL Codes," Journal of Economic Literature, 2017.
explores how and why these codes have evolved, providing a window into the evolution of economics research.
“The Lucky Consistency of Milton Friedman’s Science and Politics, 1933-1963,” in P. Mirowski, T. Stapleford, and R. Van Horn, eds. Building Chicago Economics: New Perspectives on the History of America’s Most Powerful Economic Programme. Cambridge University Press, 2011
is a remarkable paper and gives many insights into how to think about fact/value dichotomy claims. The Friedman that emerges here is neither a scientific saint nor someone immune from effects of his normative commitments on his work as a social scientist.
(with Roger Backhouse) “Samuelson, Gender Biases and Discrimination," European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 2019.
(with Cléo Chassonnery-Zaïgouche and John Singleton) “Economics Is Not a Man's Field”: CSWEP and the First Gender Reckoning in Economics, 1971–1991, History of Political Economy, 2025
are invaluable in understanding how the economics profession has treated and addressed the treatment of women, with messages for contemporary problems.
"The Price of Virtue: Some Hypotheses on How Tractability Has Shaped Economic Models," Oeconomica, forthcoming
is terrific discussion of how this methodological commitment has shaped research.
UChicago | Stone Center on Inequality & Mobility
@UCStoneCenter
Who studies inequality, and does it matter?
Historian of economics Béatrice Cherrier (@Undercoverhist) takes on this question, examining whether the imbalances and hierarchies within the field shape how economists understand inequality.
Listen here → open.spotify.com/episode/57gUhL3eC1BntJcythy9nt -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Would you now please change the history slides in your introductory macro class?
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/would-you-now-pleas…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(we have a new history of macro : osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/2suyd_v1)
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
🚨 We economists at @CrestUmr @IPParisEco are hiring 🚨
We have 3 positions: 1 assistant prof in econometrics (ENSAE), 1 assistant prof in Digital Economics and IO (Telecom) and 1 assistant or associate, all fields (Polytechnique)
econjobmarket.org/positions/11952
Please circulate!
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Feel free to contact any of us on the IPParis hiring committee (Xavier d'Haultfoeuille for the econometrics position, Louis Pape for the digital/IO one, and Matias Nunez, Olivier Loisel and I), or any faculty member at CREST, if you have any question
Deadline November 16 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What does a Nobel Prize on ‘innovation-driven economic growth’ actually reward?
A historian’s perspective on how to deal with the Nobel frenzy
beatricecherrier.wordpress.com/2025/10/13/what-does-a-nob… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maria Bach
@mvsbach
You can either post comments here or to my email, or better yet record a short vocal message and send it to me.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ulysse Lojkine
@ULojkine
New working paper with @AlexandreChirat
where we contrast three views [neoclassical, marxist and institutionalist] on economic power
econpapers.repec.org/paper/drmwpaper/2024-31.htm -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nicola Giocoli
@ngiocoli
With the customary (😕) 2-month delay, a new issue of HEI - History of Economic Ideas has been published.
Available soon here: www.libraweb.net/sommari.php?chiave=61
Journal info here: hei.scholasticahq.com
@Societies_HET @AISPE_2021 @Undercoverhist @BrianCAlbrecht @winir2013 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Out of office for the week
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Mariano Arana
@aranamariano
Estoy investigando sobre la @AAEPoficial y encuentro pocos antecedentes de estudios de asociaciones económicas en América Latina (los 2 de AAEP). ¿Ayuda porfa😊?
@rgbetancourt @ndvoskin @fagnerjmaia @ppryluka @cacrisalves @danielle_guizzo @Pinzon_Fuchs @Undercoverhist @JuanOdisio -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
We are particularly excited to welcome ~30 participants to the @ysi_commons pre-conference workshop one day prior to ISHET 2024.
👉How to write HET theses
👉How to write & publish articles in HET journals
👉How to publish books in HET
👉How to work with archival material
w/ @_ISHET @rgbetancourt @RvdbB2015 @RanaAnwesha @HereticalSraffa @CambridgeUP @SpringerNature -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ingrid H. Kvangraven
@ingridharvold
Here is our commentary on how the 2024 Economics Nobel integrates colonialism into economics, while leaving a colonial worldview intact (with @SurbhiKesar & @devikadutt). To explain how & why they do this, we go back to the colonial origins of economics. www.epw.in/journal/2024/42/commentary/colonial-origins-ec…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Branko Milanovic
@BrankoMilan
After reading @pseudoerasmus excellent thread on the evolution of devt thinking and the role of institutions and @ingridharvold, Kesar, Dutt paper on the same topic (both published within the past 48 hours) I asked myself the following Q: Why did I like AJR early work so much & then lost interest?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Fun because true
Andrea Matranga 🇺🇦🌻
@andreamatranga
The real discovery of AJR was that if you throw economists an IV puzzle to keep the brain occupied, they will sit mostly still while you teach them history.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Speculative but very interesting history of the economics of institutions in development
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Basil Halperin
@BasilHalperin
The best *constructively* critical piece to read on Acemoglu-Johnson-Robinson is "The Skeptic's Guide to Institutions" series from Dietz Vollrath:
The series is great precisely because -- Vollrath writes from the perspective of a 'skeptical fan' of the literature -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Shahram Azhar
@ShahramAzhar
🧵1/5 Acemoglu or Paul Baran’s Prize?
Acemoglu’s argument on settler versus non-settler colonialism was first presented, in almost the same language, by the Marxist economist Paul Baran decades before the publication of AJR 2002 in his book The Political Economy of Growth.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2024 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James A. Robinson “for studies of how institutions are formed and affect prosperity.”
#nobelprize -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Currently re-reading this paper by @DGindis on the origins and significance of Jensen and Meckling's view of the nature and purpose of the firm, and it's so helpful and well-researched
academic.oup.com/oep/article/72/4/966/5899892 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Pas de l’éco, mais cet ouvrage sur l’érotisme dans l’art a nourri bcp d'échanges sur la quête du beau/vrai, le rôle des institutions, les rapports de domination et le crédit en art/science
Rendu superbe, contenu érudit, drôle & kinky
Bravo @WhereverHugo
www.hugopublishing.fr/produits/69-oeuvres-cultes-de-lhist… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A good paper on Hazel Kyrk's then new theoretical and empirical perspective on consumption `
by Manfredi Alberti and Francesco Asso
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Coming soon: one of the best books I've read this year.
For anyone in need of a deep dive into the essence of economists' modeling work
www.cambridge.org/core/books/managing-growth-in-miniature… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Proof that IA embeds politics
(the politics of pockets and women outfit www.vox.com/2016/9/19/12865560/politics-of-pockets-suffra…)
Elizabeth Laraki
@elizlaraki
I'm talking at a conference later this year (on UX+AI).
I just saw an ad for the conference with my photo and was like, wait, that doesn't look right.
Is my bra showing in my profile pic and I've never noticed...? That's weird.
I open my original photo.
No bra showing.
I put the two photos side by side and I'm like WTF...
Someone edited my photo to unbutton my blouse and reveal a made-up hint of a bra or something else underneath. 🤨
Immediately, I email the conference host.
(FYI he is a great, respectable guy with 5 kids at home.)
He is super apologetic and immediately looks into the issue.
He quickly reports back that the woman running their social media used a cropped square image from their website.
She needed it to be more vertical, so she used an AI expand image tool to make the photo taller.
AI invented the bottom part of the image (in which it believed that women's shirts should be unbuttoned further, with some tension around the buttons, and revealing a little hint of something underneath). 🤯
—
FYI the conference organizers were super apologetic and took down all of the content with that photo. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Veteran meteorologist overwhelmed by climate change
Brian Stelter
@brianstelter
NBC6's @JohnMoralesTV is the longest tenured TV meteorologist in south Florida. When he gets this serious, this emotional, on the air, viewers pay attention: x.com/ChrisHushNBC/status/1843323797992251407/video/1
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Gilles Raveaud
@RaveaudGilles
En janvier 2015, Riss m'appelle pour me demander de succéder à Bernard Maris à "Charlie". Près de 10 ans, et plus de 600 articles plus tard, des interviews, quelques reportages, des fous rires et des engueulades, mon histoire au journal se termine avec ce numéro. 💔
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ash Otter
@asherichia
Urrrrrr...All major papers of Victor Ambros are shared with his wife Rosalind Lee....
Does the nobel committee just hate women called "Rosalind"???
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
Congratulations to our 2024 medicine laureate Victor Ambros ✨
This morning he celebrated the news of his prize with his colleague and wife Rosalind Lee, who was also the first author on the 1993 'Cell' paper cited by the Nobel Committee.
#nobelprize -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Catherine Herfeld
@cherfeld
HELP needed from historians of econ: can you point me to research that studied the content of syllabi and/or textbooks in econ after the 1930s until the 1980s at different (possibly but not necessarily) the main institutions (Chicago, MIT, Stanford, etc) with focus on micro? Thx!
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"The vague phrase 'within the profit motive' is simply window dressing, not a viable criterion...but I cannot blame you.... It is apparently what the market is asking for and I cannot blame you if you hive the market what it demands"
The market for ideas
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I only wrote one paper on him in my life, then said 'never again.'
I should have known better, but I'm dreading the comeback -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I only wrote one paper on him in my life, then said 'never again.'
I should have known better, but I'm dreading the comeback -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
How about I ask all the economists with a chair named after a famous predecessor how much they know about their lives, contributions, contexts and legacies ?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
To all the colleagues who answered this with 'thanks but 'the profession' give too much importance to top-5", while being in position to publish in/recruit authors from/edit top-5s,
'the profession' is you
How do you fight top5itis?
Jeff Weaver
@Jeff_Weaver_
I was curious about how “top 5” pubs are distributed across US econ depts so scraped some data for the last 10 years (but note data caveats below). Thought others might also be interested- some was expected, some surprises. Fuller data- docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1vl5L-nRsQyZyL3gkaAJvenLMk…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
*gives*
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pierre Boyer
@pierrecboyer
A lire ! Quel travail et quelques anecdotes (en quelle année l’assiette forfaitaire pour "les personnes participants à une course landaise " a t elle été supprimée ? 😯)
Haut-commissariat à la Stratégie et au Plan
@StrategiePlan
🔎 Comment réduire les trappes à bas salaires ? Le rapport final de la mission menée par @AntoineBozio et @EtienneWasmer envisage différents scénarios d'évolution concernant les dispositifs d'exonérations de cotisations sociales.
À lire👉www.strategie.gouv.fr/publications/mission-bozio-wasmer-p… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maria Bach
@mvsbach
"these cases simply show that the virtue of intellectual humility must be married to that of intellectual courage."
I highly recommend reading & following the advice of this post
Why intellectual humility isn’t always a virtue – aeon.co/essays/why-intellectual-humility-isnt-always-a-vi…
Thanks @clanatab -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Erin Hengel
@erinhengel
In remembrance of Robert M. Solow by Peter Diamond.
www.econometricsociety.org/uploads/Obituaries Past Presid… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
ya quand même des gars qui préfèrent écrire et publier 450 pages de justification plutôt que de s'excuser d'avoir publiquement insulté une femme
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
Je ne sais pas ce qui est le plus consternant, le fait pour Bégaudeau d’épancher son ego par écrit alors que son comportement ordurier devrait l’inciter au silence honteux, que Libé s’en fasse l’écho, ou que le journal ait choisi de mettre des guillemets à « sexistes »
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
ftanguy 🇵🇸🇺🇦🕊
@fabricetanguy
Quand nos élèves de #bacpro #agricole (lycée La Touche - Ploërmel) transformaient les peintures de #lecaravage en tableaux vivants @Fragritwittos @Agri_Gouv @agrikol @AgriSkippy @JeunesAgri @regionbretagne
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
🚨UNIL Lausanne is recruiting an assistant professor in the history of economics
Deadline to apply: 31/10/2024
career5.successfactors.eu/career?career_ns=job_listing&co… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
How the "Ramsey formula" came to define time discounting in economics (1950-2000)
with @P_G_Duarte
Full draft, comments much welcome
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4973044
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(I made a series of blog posts about the paper last summer
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What a better time to launch a series of 10 posts on the history of the formula economists use to model to future (based on a paper with @P_G_Duarte)?
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/how-economists-mode…
S1E1: The uncertain origins of the Ramsey Formula for discounting -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Erin Overbey
@erinoverbey
“women like us fall into two categories: dragons and fools.
you must make sure they think of you as a dragon”
rip Maggie Smith💔 (1934-2024) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
I wrote a short post on the Indian political economist CT Kurien (1931-2024) who, after a PhD from Stanford, dedicated his life to improving the teaching & learning of economics in India.
@ArunKoshy6 @raghunageswaran @rethinkecon @crit
developingeconomics.org/2024/09/06/c-t-kurien-and-rethink… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
" Avant l’IA, les « révolutions » informatiques ont-elles vraiment bouleversé la recherche en économie ?"
(spoiler: oui, mais comment)
theconversation.com/avant-lia-les-revolutions-informatiqu… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Thinking about Hilaree Nelson today. She died just one year ago. Her legacy as a badass role model for women lives on
www.instagram.com/p/DAYRn7aSXeU/?img_index=1
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
*two years ago*
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Pourquoi les économistes se trompent-ils quasiment tous le temps?"
(Spoiler: parce qu'il ne sont ni supposés ni en mesure de construire des boules de cristal)
www.lesechos.fr/economie-france/conjoncture/video-pourquo… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Bourse de recherche en histoire de l'éco décernées par l'@AssoCharlesGide
Jusqu'à 3000 euros
Doctorant.e.s, jeunes chercheuses et chercheurs, non-titulaires peuvent candidater
Deadline 17 octobre
www.charlesgide.fr/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Bourse-de-r… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Itai Sher
@itaisher
“What is probability?” is a genuinely difficult question
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maria Bach
@mvsbach
It has been such an exciting year for my little podcast! I have had incredibly interesting conversations with so many brilliant researchers - not least this one with @Srishting
Thank you for joining me!
Ceteris Never Paribus
@CeterisNParibus
And here's the last episode of the year! Listen to @Srishting talk about her work on the agrarian question in India and the new Indian Society for History of Economic Thought. @Societies_HET #historyofindianeconomics ceterisneverparibus.net/the-agrarian-question-in-india-ep…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
It's soon going to be 10 years @azimpremjiuniv. 🌿 And 10 HET theses have been completed. 🌻
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Catherine Herfeld
@cherfeld
💥#job: Again we expand our team: come to @iphilLUH for a postdoc in (emp.) Phil of Science/Phil of Modeling/&HPS/@SocPhilSciPract to research exciting cases of model transfer, scientific progress, and other things related. Deadl. Sept. 26; #ercstgr @ERC_Research #modeltransfer
MODEL TRANSFER ERC Project
@ModelTransfERC
📢#job And we are hiring again: We now look for a 3y-postdoc in philosophy of science with an interest in the philosophy of modelling/model transfer.
Deadline September 26. 👇
uni-hannover.de/en/jobs/id/7327/
#modeltransfer #ercstgr @iphilLUH -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Is there something more beautiful than Bangalore trees?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
My HET students @azimpremjiuniv got a superb class on the history of applied economics from Beatrice Cherrier earlier today. I learnt so much!
We absolutely need one entire course devoted to the history of recent economics. +1HET course! -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Oral Histories of Economics
@OralHistoryEcon
🧵💻1/ What’s new in our collections? The OHE currently hosts two collections: the “Computerization of economics” and the “Trust in economics” collection. Let’s have a quick tour to the first collection about Computerization!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
In this new paper, an alternative approach to studying taste, demand & consumption is outlined. The social & historical basis of CPE is evident. I find it interesting that these ideas were present long before Veblen.
Download the PDF freely here: www.tandfonline.com/eprint/IZESKKUS7NVJINU9XBZ8/full?targ… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Learn how to write a history of economics paper. 4th session of the online JHET workshop with @pauldudenhefer
Session on Sept 18, deadline to apply tomorrow
See historyofeconomics.org/about-the-society/upcoming-events/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Oral Histories of Economics
@OralHistoryEcon
🧵The OHE project is the first online archive for collecting and sharing interviews about the history of economics. Our oral sources are open-access, via our website (www.oralhistoriesofeconomics.org)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Proc Citant
@Proc_Citant
Prenons tous une minute pour saluer le courage inouï de cette femme.
Agence France-Presse
@afpfr
⚖️ "La honte doit changer de camp": conformément au souhait de la victime, le huis clos a été refusé lundi à Avignon au procès du retraité accusé d'avoir drogué son épouse et recruté des dizaines d'inconnus sur internet pour la violer, pendant dix ans #afpvertical ⤵️
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Diallo Oumy
@DialloOumy4
📻 Pourquoi et comment évaluer le coût d'une vie ? Toutes les vies se valent-elles ? Comment se déroule une opération de libération ? Réponses dans le mag du week-end avec @arielontheweb
@Undercoverhist @trinquand
et le temoignage de Grégoire Kauffmann.
www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/le-magazine-du-… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Colin Camerer
@CFCamerer
one of the greatest lines from a PhD Thesis intro...
"To Professor _____ at ____. You once threw an eraser at me for incorrectly explaining Nash equilibrium. This made me curious how I could get paid to do the same" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
In the wake of the Munro case, the question for us historians is what our professional responsibility is as "biographers." I don't have an answer to this with respect to history of science
www.cbc.ca/news/entertainment/alice-munro-biographies-1.7… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Thank you for the invitation, @alexmthomas . I'm thrilled to be given the opportunity to discuss various projects in the history of economics with colleagues in Bengaluru
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
I am super delighted to announce that Beatrice Cherrier (@Undercoverhist) is visiting @azimpremjiuniv @EconInContext as the International Scholar-in-Resdence this September.
Several talks have been scheduled on campus & in the city. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Final reveal and reflections on the history of the Ramsey formula for discounting the future
The image is the reduced-form paper, which I'll now have to erase from my board. A bit sad.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E10: “The consensus unraveled”
Epilogue
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e10-the-consensus… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Final reveal and reflections on the history of the Ramsey formula for discounting the future
The image is the reduced-form paper, which I'll now have to erase from my board. A bit sad.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E10: “The consensus unraveled”
Epilogue
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e10-the-consensus…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The series was longer and more painful to write than I had anticipated, but I still managed to finish before France has a new prime minister, so the pain is in the context, I guess
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What a better time to launch a series of 10 posts on the history of the formula economists use to model to future (based on a paper with @P_G_Duarte)?
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/how-economists-mode…
S1E1: The uncertain origins of the Ramsey Formula for discounting
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E2: "The number game"
Discounting struggles in the 1950s and 1960s
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e2-the-number-game
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E3: “They do it in completely arbitrary ways”
Discounting in optimal growth theory
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e3-they-do-it-in-…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E4: The equation “implicit in Ramsey”
Back to public investment decisions
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/the-equation-implic…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E5: “Proof for a case where discounting advances the doomsday”
Discounting in 1970s energy models
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e5-proof-for-a-ca…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E6: “Ramsey does not believe in a time-discount rate bigger than zero; that makes three of us”
Ethics strikes back
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e6-ramsey-does-no…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E7: Not "operational"
A consensus without the Ramsey formula
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e7-not-operational
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E8: “By popular demand”
The Ramsey formula for discounting comes to IPCC
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/by-popular-demand
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E9. "The paper is based on a prescriptive rather that descriptive view of political economy"
One equation, two approaches
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e9-the-paper-is-b…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E10: “The consensus unraveled”
Epilogue
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e10-the-consensus… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Me all week, working on the history of discounting
youtube.com/shorts/3kTQhFMR7do -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Here's super complicated econometric model explaining why economists publish model X, endorse technique Y, award prize Z"
vs
"here are the archives" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Summer game: whodunnit?, econ referee 2 edition
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E9. "The paper is based on a prescriptive rather that descriptive view of political economy"
One equation, two approaches
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e9-the-paper-is-b… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Applied economists Historians of applied econ
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Warren Sharp
@SharpFootball
insane aura
51-yr old Yusuf Dikec of Turkey shows up to the Olympics for shooting without special lenses…
without ear protection…
hand in his pocket & both eyes open…
and casually takes home a silver medal -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Summer game: whodunnit?, econ referee 2 edition
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E9. "The paper is based on a prescriptive rather that descriptive view of political economy"
One equation, two approaches
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e9-the-paper-is-b…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Accidentally casting Tom Schelling in one of my research paper at last feels weirdly satisfying
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Dr. Serge Zaka (Dr. Zarge)
@SergeZaka
Aujourd'hui, les 40°C vont de nouveau fleurir en France. L'anomalie journalière montera jusqu'à +12°C. C'est conséquent. On pourrait vivre le 30 juillet le plus chaud depuis 1930 (à minima).
Nous sommes cependant ridiculisés par l'anomalie de +28 à +32°C (😳) sur l'Antarctique. Indescriptible.
A l'échelle mondiale, si on fait la somme de toutes les anomalies, elle est record : nous sommes en train de vivre la fin juillet la plus chaude jamais observée sur Terre. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
Même sur les prélèvements obligatoires on ne domine pas comme ça.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
From an "emerging consensus" to a prescriptivists vs descriptivists rift in less than two years
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E8: “By popular demand”
The Ramsey formula for discounting comes to IPCC
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/by-popular-demand -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Cette légende...
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
These 2 threads are English continuation of older exchange on the use of (war related) historical data in econ. It's a good example of dodged scientific debate
x.com/saumjha/status/1816648852533051450
Econ and history teams never *debate* b/c they never try to bridge epistemological divides
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
Why economists should refrain from making sweeping historical arguments, based on sophisticated calculations, when using statistics or data that rely on flawed, false, or misunderstood evidence from the past : a thread (1) 🧶
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
See, for instance, the title of the early exchanges aoc.media/analyse/2021/02/24/de-verdun-a-vichy-et-retour-… and aoc.media/analyse/2021/03/15/vive-leco-histoire-la-statis… ("statistics is not an optional discipline")
(see also devhist.hypotheses.org/3921)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Questions I have are
is it worth teaching these (non) debates
how different this is round from the previous ones (on the rise of cliometrics), see the theses by Rouvray (etheses.lse.ac.uk/36/) and the one just defended by Cyril Jung (theses.fr/2024UPASI003) on North -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
End of the transition period: Ramsey formula here, but not part of the consensus on how to discount
now final set of post on how huge debates on climate modeling changed the game in the mid-1990s
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E7: Not "operational"
A consensus without the Ramsey formula
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e7-not-operational -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
INEM
@EconMethodology
INEM is pleased to announce a call for proposals under the theme FRONTIERS IN PHILOSOPHY OF ECONOMICS. We invite scholars, researchers, and practitioners to submit proposals that advance our understanding and visibility of philosophy of economics: econmethod.org/Call-for-Proposals/Frontiers-in-PE
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
“It’s not about me...it’s abt we the people. [We’ll have to] choose between hope & hate, unity & division,... if we still be believe in honesty, decency, respect”
What a contrast with our president, who has made his 2nd mandate all abt himself, thus deepening hate & divisions
Talking Points Memo
@TPM
Biden speaks from the Oval Office for the first time since dropping out and endorsing VP Kamala Harris: "It's been the honor of my life to serve as your president."
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Some historical context here re the Clark medal, by @Undercoverhist and @ASvorencik
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3004944
Published version here:
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of…
Anna Stansbury
@annastansbury
Among all STEM and social science fields, the concentration of award winners in a few institutions is highest in Economics.
AND it’s the only field where this concentration is rising not falling.
Freeman, Xie, Zhang and Zhou #nbersi -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ben Groom
@ben_d_groom
Utility discount rate zero, yes, but if future richer (poorer) discount rate on consumption is positive (negative) due to intertemporal inequality aversion. So, ethics. Also, fun article : www.nature.com/articles/s41558-023-01681-w
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Enter Rawls
(and then moral philosophers)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E6: “Ramsey does not believe in a time-discount rate bigger than zero; that makes three of us”
Ethics strikes back
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e6-ramsey-does-no… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
On the way to the Ramsey formula, I fell into a rabbit hole
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Zehra Farooq
@ZehraFarooq
I just graduated with my PhD (Economics) & can certify tht it was my advisor, Elliott Isaac, who ensured tht I come out the other end not just with my doctorate, an excellent research pipeline, a good career trajectory but most importantly, with my mental health intact. A thread:
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Irwin Collier
@irwincollier
1952 Econometrics exam for graduate course taught at Johns Hopkins by Carl Christ and Arnold Harberger. Very inclusive notion of what constituted econometrics at mid 20th century. www.irwincollier.com/johns-hopkins-final-exams-for-econom…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Le Grand Continent
@Grand_Continent
Comment construire une coalition dans une Assemblée sans majorité absolue ?
Nous publions un outil clef, un simulateur de coalition—en accès libre.
legrandcontinent.eu/fr/2024/07/07/legislatives-resultats-… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Voilà
www.lesoir.be/600282/article/2024-07-07/petit-tutoriel-de… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
j'ai ça affiché sur ma porte au boulot
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
Historien / prof d'histoire en période de radicalisation politique et d'élections : cette étrange impression d'exercer un métier indispensable, tout en ne servant rigoureusement à rien face à la marée montante du déni de la vérité
-
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
Historien / prof d'histoire en période de radicalisation politique et d'élections : cette étrange impression d'exercer un métier indispensable, tout en ne servant rigoureusement à rien face à la marée montante du déni de la vérité
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
j'ai ça affiché sur ma porte au boulot
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Merci pour la reception du thread (et allons voter), mais il faut revenir aux sujets importants:
on est bien d'accord qu'on n'est pas sur un Didier Bourdon? -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
En terme de sommeil, on est sur un rythme "skipper du Vendée Globe" là
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Inês Hipólito
@ineshipolito
Masterclass, @bayesianboy
Rahul
@trsam97
Can Machine Learning conduct science purely as a positivistic discipline relying on data alone without any theoretical framework?
Philosopher Mel Andrews argues that theory-free science is impossible in principle. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Henrik Plaschke
@HenrikPlaschke
Martin Gardner (au lieu de Garner) dans un article paru dans Scientific Americain (décembre 1981) si quelqu'un veut le retrouver.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/n Pendant cette trêve, vous reprendrez bien un peu d’histoire de la "courbe de Laffer," pour comprendre ce qu’on invoque en citant le nom de cet économiste, et vous préparer ainsi au chaos de ces prochains mois ?
(cette fois, c’est long)
1974 : Arthur Laffer dine avec...Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Cette histoire n’a jusqu’ici aucun rapport avec la recherche universitaire en éco
Ca fait des siècles, voir des millénaires que les écos bossent sur l’effet de l’impôts et expliquent que certains taux sont désincitatifs : Ibn Khaldun, Dupuit-ce-heros, Say, Keynes et d’autres...
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A ce stade, la question, c’est quel impôt, quel taux, quel mécanisme, et un dessin et un bouquin qui ne répondent à rien, on s’en fout!
Même Laffer prend au début ses distances avec la Courbe telle que présentée par Wanniski. Il explique qu’il y a 2 effets d’une baisse d’impôt..Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Quel était l’objectif recherché d’une hausse/baisse d’impôt (peut-être pas d’augmenter les recettes fiscales)?
D’où viennent les preuves empiriques? Quelles données sur quelles réformes fiscales sont utilisées? Ou quelle simulation ?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Merci à @FrancoisGeerolf @RenaudFoucart @EmmPont pour les critiques polies & constructives sur la V1 effacée
Merci pour celles à venir
Je bloque au moindre "c’est ridicule, tu connais rien, t’as rien compris," qu’il s’agisse du troll anonyme ou du chercheur next door
FIN -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alexandre Delaigue
@adelaigue
La courbe de laffer des tweets sur la courbe de laffer. Si personne ne tweete sur la courbe, personne ne la connaît. S’il n’y a que des tweets à ce sujet, c’est ennuyeux et personne ne les lit. Entre les 2 il y a l’optimum du nombre de tweets sur la courbe de laffer.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Mais du coup, on a le droit de tweeter sur l'histoire de la courbe de Laffer pendant la trêve où c'est trop politique ?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Samuel West 💙💛
@exitthelemming
Timpson’s are well-known for employing ex-offenders to help them back into work. They pay their tax. They value their staff. And then there’s this.
CEO James Timpson (who’s also Chair of the Prison Reform Trust) is the new Prisons Minister. Great appointment -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Beaucoup de liens super interessants (certains on déjà bien tournés, d'autres moins)
David Thesmar
@dthesmar
je me demande si c'est ceux que je suis sur X, ou juste X, mais si je vois beaucoup d'appels à faire barrage, je vois très peu d'analyses sur les raisons du vote RN.
si vous voyez des analyses intéressantes, je suis curieux. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Renaud Foucart
@RenaudFoucart
UK election is a "colonel blotto" game. There are 650 constituencies, you want to be first in as many as possible. If you understand the game, you do not campaign easy seats, only marginal ones. That's how you get a landslide with 37% vote share: it's a feature, not a bug.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
J'ai supprimé ce thread sur la courbe de Laffer, utilisé par mes plus proches collègues pur me faire dire des choses politiques alors que ce n'était pas le cas. Je n'ai pas de moyens de lutter contre ça
bravo les gars, vous avez gagné -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Portrait des transitions politiques, parmi d'autres résultats. Etude très interessante sur 1,6 millions de candidatures politiques, 1993-2023, par Elif Bulut et @OlivierGodechot
Olivier Godechot
@OlivierGodechot
Vous sentez que le barrage républicain craque. Pas faux ! Aviez-vous vu les petites fissures qui le zébraient ? Ces mouvements réguliers depuis 30 ans de candidatEs allant des partis “républicains” vers l’extrême droite. Ici, nous les étudions ! 1/n
laviedesidees.fr/Les-fissures-de-la-digue-republicaine -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Only halfway. That's too much writing, what did I think.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Longer, because the 1970s are a mess
Also, one of our two favorite moments in the archives
Feedback welcome
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E5: “Proof for a case where discounting advances the doomsday”
Discounting in 1970s energy models
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e5-proof-for-a-ca… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sam MacAulay
@sam_macaulay
“RAND signed a contract with John von Neumann to produce a general theory of war, to be completed during a small slice of his time: that spent shaving. For his shaving thoughts, von Neumann received $200 a month, an average salary at the time.”
Kevin A. Bryan
@Afinetheorem
Really nice article on RAND. Amazing from 40s to 60s: invented huge swaths of applied math, science, and social science (packet switching, linear programming, Bayesian decision theory, early game theory, cold war policy, windsurfing (!)): asteriskmag.com/issues/06/when-rand-made-magic-in-santa-m…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Longer, because the 1970s are a mess
Also, one of our two favorite moments in the archives
Feedback welcome
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E5: “Proof for a case where discounting advances the doomsday”
Discounting in 1970s energy models
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e5-proof-for-a-ca… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
do blog posts really need links or are nice pictures enough?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Sometimes I forget how much I owe my parents, for all they achieved and passed on to me. My mom sent me this pic today. This is a thread about her.
That’s my mom in lower right. My grandmother, top left, was illiterate and lived in a mud&hay house she built with her husband.1/n -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Vincent Pons
@VinPons
De nombreux candidats se sont désistés, mais 47 troisièmes persistent à se maintenir dans des circonscriptions où le RN peut gagner (source @lemondefr).
28 au centre, 12 à droite, 7 à gauche.
Il leur reste 5 heures pour retrouver le droit chemin. #legislatives2024 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Monday's @MonetaryBlog
"To change or not to change: Forecasting models and economic expertise in central banks"
By @AGoutsmedt @cescoeco @Undercoverhist @jcaacostamacia @fclaveau & Clément Fontan
medium.com/@monetarypolicyinstitute/to-change-or-not-to-c… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Olivier Bouba-Olga
@obouba
📌 Votes aux législatives : explorations géographiques !
J'ai produit quelques analyses des votes au premier tour des élections législatives, à l'échelle des circonscriptions, vous pouvez découvrir ce que cela donne en lisant ce billet de blog blogs.univ-poitiers.fr/o-bouba-olga/2024/07/02/votes-aux-… 🧶 1/8 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
J'avais envie d'y croire, comme boussole pour s'orienter dans le far west des modèles énergie plus climat, mais ça ne fonctionne pas trop, historiquement
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"L'idéologie, c'est chez les autres," economic edition n°198364583
ceci dit, l'étude mentionnée sur les liens entre gouvernement populiste et mauvaise performance eco est extrêmement intéressante:
papier www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20202045
résumé: cepr.org/voxeu/columns/cost-populism-evidence-historyPost not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
et pour les électrices et électeurs de 2024 a qui tout le monde - des politiques aux journalistes et aux chercheurs qui instrumentalisent leur position- dit "voici les faits" et "le centre est le cercle de la raison" à longueur de journée, Weber avait décidément tout prévu
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
maintenant il nous faut moins de chroniques d'économistes qui détiennent la vérité et plus de chroniques de juristes et de politistes qui nous expliquent ce qui peut se passer en 3 ans dans les différents scénarios
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
KingsHPE
@KingsHPE
The second @Kingspol_econ colloquium on the history of economic thought will take place this Thursday and will feature talks from @DGindis, @paidipaty, @AndresMGuiot, @RobertJReamerJr, and John Meadowcroft.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Je pars voter avec la horde du contrevent sur mon kindle et le signet sur mon téléphone en espérant bien faire 1h00 de queue
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
L'extrait complet en anglais est ici
press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/511928.html]
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"J'étais un universitaire, un spécialiste. Puis, soudainement, je me suis retrouvé plongé dans toute cette effervescence alors que l'université était entraînée dans cette nouvelle situation : réunions, conférences, interviews, cérémonies, et surtout, des papiers à remplir...
Anna Colin Lebedev
@colinlebedev
Leçon 1. Un pouvoir liberticide s’installe petit à petit, de manière quasiment imperceptible. Ceux qui ont peur d’un basculement le lendemain d’une arrivée au pouvoir du RN se trompent: le pouvoir liberticide peut être rassurant, modéré et lent. 4/20
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"J'étais un universitaire, un spécialiste. Puis, soudainement, je me suis retrouvé plongé dans toute cette effervescence alors que l'université était entraînée dans cette nouvelle situation : réunions, conférences, interviews, cérémonies, et surtout, des papiers à remplir...
Anna Colin Lebedev
@colinlebedev
Leçon 1. Un pouvoir liberticide s’installe petit à petit, de manière quasiment imperceptible. Ceux qui ont peur d’un basculement le lendemain d’une arrivée au pouvoir du RN se trompent: le pouvoir liberticide peut être rassurant, modéré et lent. 4/20
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Mais la grande occasion choquante, quand 10, 100 ou 1000 personnes se joindront à vous, ne vient jamais. C'est là la difficulté...
Et un jour, trop tard, vos principes, tout d'un coup, vous submergent. Soudain, tout s'effondre, tout à la fois. Vous voyez ce que vous êtes....
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
....ce que vous avez fait, ou, plus précisément, ce que vous n'avez pas fait (car c'était tout ce qui était exigé de la plupart d'entre nous : que nous ne fassions rien). Vous vous souvenez de ces premières réunions de votre département à l'université, quand....
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
..., si quelqu'un s'était levé, d'autres se seraient peut-être levés, mais personne ne l'a fait. Une petite chose... Vous vous souvenez de tout maintenant, et votre cœur se brise. Trop tard. Vous êtes compromis au-delà de toute réparation."
Ceci est un extrait du livre de...
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Milton Mayer,
"They Thought They Were Free
The Germans, 1933-1945"
Paru en 1955, il raconte la montée du nazisme au quotidien, à partir de 10 interviews menés dans la ville de Hesse
Ce livre a changé ma vision de l'histoire politique -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
There's cutenomics, and there are those who don't fuck around
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
and those who need a break
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The titling game in the early years of IIASA was pretty solid
(tomorrow's post) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Last post in "setting the scene" period
Next post is take-off
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E4: The equation “implicit in Ramsey”
Back to public investment decisions
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/the-equation-implic… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Tout le monde dit "c'est une campagne éclair", mais en ressenti c'est la durée du Covid, non?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Archen Minsol is arguably the best economic theorist of the 20th century (here, a Restat paper from 1968)
(no joke here)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
the pseudonym game
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Last post in "setting the scene" period
Next post is take-off
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E4: The equation “implicit in Ramsey”
Back to public investment decisions
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/the-equation-implic… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics
@ErasmusJPE
CFC: The EJPE is calling for contributions to our upcoming special issue: Philosophical Contributions to Degrowth. Deadline August 2025 ejpe.org/journal/announcement
Please share this with anyone that might be interested!
@IngridRobeyns @MichiruNagatsu @onbeingapatient -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
J'ai 102 questions sur les sources de la difficulté des économistes (quelque soit la pétition) à articuler un discours public qui combine politiques de production et politiques de redistribution (ou efficacité/équité):
est-ce juste dans le discours public ou dans les modèles?
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Est-ce que c'est un héritage de la division des tâches héritée des 2 théorèmes du bien-être, de différences épistémologiques (qui est confortable avec la partie normative/welfare de la discipline), de la spécialisation en champ, des types de travail empiriques?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
de la manière dont a évolué l'éco publique ces 70 dernières années?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alexandre Delaigue
@adelaigue
Pour élaborer, les économistes n’ont pas un bon bilan lorsqu’ils se présentent comme experts dans le champ politique. @Undercoverhist a rappelé récemment la position de Perroux sur la performance économique du fascisme ou Hayek et le Chili x.com/undercoverhist/status/1804200895699169699
Alexandre Delaigue
@adelaigue
Puisque c’est la mode de transposer la période actuelle dans les années 30, certaines analyses économiques sont en mode :
« le programme du NSDAP est absurde, même la saisie intégrale des biens des juifs allemands ne suffira pas à financer les dépenses militaires envisagées » -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I just spent 10 minutes trying to articulate that summarizing what Arrow had accomplished by age 43 in a sentence is impossible, yet each of these accomplishments matter for my story
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Roy Cross
@Senex_7319
I’d add that the economics department at the University of Lower Slobbovia remains unrivalled.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Archen Minsol is arguably the best economic theorist of the 20th century (here, a Restat paper from 1968)
(no joke here) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I hate being a French voter right now. But at least I'm not a US voter
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Y a des sociologues malins dans le coin pour télécharger la liste des signataires des 2 pétitions d'écos (www.nouvelobs.com/politique/20240625.OBS90197/les-orienta… et www.lefigaro.fr/vox/economie/seule-une-coalition-allant-d…) et faire de l'ACP bourdieusienne pour voir quelles dimensions les plus saillantes expliquent les ≠ entre les 2 groupes?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Avec ce craquage total de @20Minutes pour illustrer les slides au prochain meeting de l'AFS
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(j'espère que @ZemmourMichael se fait un book)
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Guess whose archives are now open for research with a detailed online finding aid?
HT @CleoCZ
www.lib.uchicago.edu/e/scrc/findingaids/view.php?eadid=IC… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
S1E3: “They do it in completely arbitrary ways”
Discounting in optimal growth theory
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/s1e3-they-do-it-in-… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
J'espère qu'Antoine Levy est juste parti pour se concentrer sur son travail de recherche, et pas à cause des interactions de ces derniers jours. Ce serait vraiment dommage (mais comprehensible)
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Marre des débats où tout le monde se coupe (surtout les journalistes) & s'insulte ?
ce matin sur mon bureau, une reflexion érudite mais abordable, passionnante & courte de @pierrecboyer sur un sujet qui traverse la campagne actuelle sans être discuté: le consentement à l'impôt -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Merci à l'INSEE de rappeler les faits encore, encore et encore
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
.... et encore
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Bien sûr, les faits sont socialement construits
Mais pas n'importe comment -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
These fields are crucial a) for econ as a science, if it wishes to maintain its critical self-awareness, and b) for many audiences outside econ who wish to get a deeper view about this discipline as a whole - beyond popular accounts, intro textbooks, and journalism. 7/7
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
One engages with the history of econ as soon as one tries to seriously think about it as an object of study in its own right. Economics - as a science/practice/intellectual activity/discipline/group of people/cultural phenomenon - deserves attention, historians of econ believe 1/
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Interesting thread that discusses explanations alternative to tractability for why theories that have been proven empirically dubious stick nonetheless
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Rare occasion where I disagree w @ShengwuLi.
Would be great if we lived in Friedman world where theories rose and fell w/ evidence. But truth is theories are very sticky, even if proven wrong over + over. Tractability has a lot to do w this, but so does history. 1/7 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
IU Bloomington
@IUBloomington
A statue honoring the late Nobel Prize-winning distinguished professor Elinor Ostrom is now behind Woodburn Hall. It is the first statue of a woman on the IU Bloomington campus.
Now we can all sit next to her with hopes to gain just a little of her charisma and wisdom. ❤️ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Conseil d'analyse économique
@CAEinfo
🏆Pour honorer la mémoire de Philippe Martin, le @CAEinfo , @InseeFr et @CreditMutuelAF, ont créé un prix pour récompenser la meilleure thèse de sciences économiques.
Directeurs et directrices de thèse, présentez vos candidats avant le 15 septembre
urlz.fr/r0bf -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Florin Bilbiie 🇪🇺 🇺🇦
@FlorinBilbiie
I agree the current "corner solution" is bad (and I walk the walk too: as EER editor I commissioned a volume on the history of HA models).
We do too little history of our own field; this is problematic in many ways (e.g. allow groups/indivs to "rewrite history" self-servingly)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A problem with these discussions is that we don't have the same baseline
Econ: "too much history of econ hurts, fuels reverence"
Historians "how about a history course every 3 years for students and reading a paper every other year on the history of your field?"
Shengwu Li
@ShengwuLi
It's a good thing that economists don't spend much time arguing about what past economists 'really' meant.
Theories should be evaluated against evidence. They don't get special status by venerable ancestry. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A problem with these discussions is that we don't have the same baseline
Econ: "too much history of econ hurts, fuels reverence"
Historians "how about a history course every 3 years for students and reading a paper every other year on the history of your field?"
Shengwu Li
@ShengwuLi
It's a good thing that economists don't spend much time arguing about what past economists 'really' meant.
Theories should be evaluated against evidence. They don't get special status by venerable ancestry. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Entendez-vous l'éco ?
@EntendezvousEco
🗳️ Le pouvoir d'achat est actuellement la principale préoccupation des Français et un levier électoral pour le Rassemblent National.
Le vote RN, historiquement associé à des préoccupations identitaires, est-il aussi devenu un vote économique ? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
David Andolfatto
@dandolfa
The goal is not to polish their thoughts like jewels, but to document the evolution of how social scientists interpreted the world. Our own interpretations are not independent of theirs. How can we understand where we are without knowing where we came from?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Stephen Williamson
@1954swilliamson
1/I once had a colleague, about 30 years ago, who wrote and published papers on history of economic thought. Since then, I have had zero colleagues who do it. At one time history of thought was required in some PhD programs. No more. Did we lose something? Beatrice would say...
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Ce gâchis!
Tiphaine de Rocquigny
@tiphainederock
Après (presque) 1500 émissions et onze ans à France Culture, je quitte cette radio que j'aime et ce n'est pas ma décision 👇
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What an obit!
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
You can't save post drafts on substack, can you?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What a better time to launch a series of 10 posts on the history of the formula economists use to model to future (based on a paper with @P_G_Duarte)?
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/how-economists-mode…
S1E1: The uncertain origins of the Ramsey Formula for discounting -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
le nom d'Esther Duflo a circulé à tord et à travers ces derniers jours (y compris dans des échanges que j'ai pu avoir en réponse à certains threads, mea culpa).
Elle dit ici ce qu'elle pense des divers "programmes économiques"
www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/le-biais-d-esth… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Rafael R. Guthmann
@GuthmannR
Pretty much everything in the main textbooks. From competitive supply and demand, to the Slutsky equation, to factor compensation, to Cournot and Bertrand competition.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
you could have a policy of making reports/detailed editorial decisions public after 50 years.
It's long enough so that no ones fear retaliation
It's short enough to disincentive power abuse and trolling as referees
It creates an accountability system that matches AER's power -
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
you could have a policy of making reports/detailed editorial decisions public after 50 years.
It's long enough so that no ones fear retaliation
It's short enough to disincentive power abuse and trolling as referees
It creates an accountability system that matches AER's power -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jeffrey Ely
@Jeffely
I just finished an 8 year stint as theory co-editor of the American Economic Review (two 3-year terms, extended by 1 year plus 1 year mopping up the leftovers). Ask me anything #econtwitter
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
Other disciplines, like biology or engineering -- though they (no less than economics) reshape the world as they study it -- do not view the historical method applied to their discipline as belonging to the discipline.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
Some social sciences -- sociology, history, and part of anthropology -- have a distinctively strong emphasis on a kind of self-consciousness or reflexivity:
the idea that turning their thought on their methods is an essential part of the discipline. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pavlina R Tcherneva
@ptcherneva
Paul influenced generations. He made sure that the real JM Keynes lived in the profession and our scholarship.
I had the honor of organizing the Post Keynesian conference & summer school for several years after he passed the baton to UMKC
RIP Paul Davidson
www.chicagotribune.com/obituaries/paul-davidson-wilm/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
Centuries maybe not but Black-Scholes could be an example of many decades
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Martin Anota
@martin_anota
The quantity theory of money? The half-scissors diagram of labor-market? IS/LM? The general equilibrium in perfect competition? The "invisible-hand" vitues of competition? The stock and productivity of capital? 🤔
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...accuser leurs avocats respectifs de faire de la politique, c’est en sortir
Dans le tweet ci-dessous, O. Blanchard prend, de mon point de vue, une responsabilité politique x.com/ojblanchard1/status/1804052251364762049
Mon avis n’est pas partagé --> pas mal de débats avec des collègues depuis 48h
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
1/6. Tweet thread. Why do I think the economic program of the Nouveau Front Populaire is worse than that of the Rassemblement National?
The nature of the two programs is very different. I have argued that the RN economic program is a Christmas tree, without logic or coherence (previous tweet thread). The NFP economic program is instead mostly internally coherent, based on an epochal redistribution from rich to poor, and from firms to workers. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What are good exemples of this in economics?
Mathieu
@miniapeur
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Est-ce qu'on expliquera plus tard que le temps anormalement maussade et pluvieux de ces derniers mois a influencé les elections et transformé le visage politique du pays, ou est-ce que l'évacuation totale de la crise climatique dans la campagne est due à d'autres facteurs?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Julius Probst, PhD 🌐
@JuliusProbst
I also do mention the historical roots of secular stagnation, including Hansen, Steindl, some post-Keynesians as well as Krugman’s famous liquidity trap paper, of course, as precursors to Summers’ theory in my Econ journal Watch paper from 2019 econjwatch.org/articles/lawrence-summers-deserves-a-nobel…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The Goldin quote was intricate, kudos to the few students who chose to unpack it
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Cool paper on Arrow that implicitly shows, as other have, that general equilibrium theory was a boarding point, not a destination (as for Debreu)
By Yam Maayan
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4713889 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andrea Capussela
@AndreaCapussela
un autre point: B. et Hayek vraisemblablement ont la meme conception de la liberté: celle, dominante, théorisée par Berlin (non-interference), qui est indifferente au regime politique: Berlin dit, comme Hayek, que une dictature peut bien être plus 'liberale' qu'une démocratie
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
First paper to historicize Larry Summers's macroeconomics (his theory of secular stagnation), by R. Backhouse and the late Mauro Boianovsky
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2024.2358127
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(one for @jbmichau )
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Vous aimez la sensation de vertige que vous procure la lecture des comptes d'économistes commentant sur l'actualité?
Essayez ceux des spécialistes en droit const
(âmes sensibles s'abstenir)
Benjamin Morel
@BenjaminMorel63
Il est théoriquement rigoureusement impossible en droit. L'article 12 est explicite, mais la dissolution est prononcée par un décret présidentiel pour lequel le Conseil constitutionnel est incompétent. Par conséquent, personne ne pourrait s'opposer à un président considérant qu'il n'est pas tenu par l'héritage de son prédécesseur.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's been a lot more fun to be a computer scientist than to be a (French) economist or historian this week. I'm jealous
Yann LeCun
@ylecun
Thoughts exist without language.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2eme bonne nouvelle de la semaine
Haut conseil pour le climat
@hc_climat
Le rythme de décarbonation de la 🇫🇷 se rapproche pour la 1ère fois du rythme attendu pour atteindre les objectifs #climat 2030:
👉↘ 2024-2030 requise (nettes): 14,7 à 16,1 Mt éqCO2/an
👉Facteur d’accélération par rapport à 2019-2023 : jusqu’à 1,3x + élevé (soit 30% d'↗️)
1/2 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is a really good exemple of how LLMs operate. For use in the classroom
Find me on bsky @colin-fraser.net
@colin_fraser
Claude still can't solve the impossible one farmer one sheep one boat problem
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
𝐒𝐞𝐧𝐝𝐡𝐢𝐥 𝐌𝐮𝐥𝐥𝐚𝐢𝐧𝐚𝐭𝐡𝐚𝐧
@m_sendhil
Excited to be part of this paper.
We study a question about language models that I find fascinating: have they come to “understand” the world behind the sequences they are trained on?
Keyon Vafa
@keyonV
New paper: How can you tell if a transformer has the right world model?
We trained a transformer to predict directions for NYC taxi rides. The model was good. It could find shortest paths between new points
But had it built a map of NYC? We reconstructed its map and found this: -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
séparer la science et le politique: le cas des économistes sous Vichy
🧶 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
franceinfo
@franceinfo
Législatives 2024 : pourquoi il faut être particulièrement prudent avec les sondages sur ces élections
l.francetvinfo.fr/J8w -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Les expériences fascistes ont apporté des éléments positifs... au fonctionnement de l'éco" (Perroux 1938)
“Je préfère un dictateur libéral à un gouvernement démocratique manquant de libéralisme" (Hayek 1981, Chili)
Que signifie "rester dans son domaine d’expertise" ? 1/N
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
To be clear, there are other central issues at stake in this election, immigration, racism, foreign policy, support for Ukraine, etc, and they may be determinant in how people decide to vote. I try to stay in my lane, the economic aspects of the programs.
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...accuser leurs avocats respectifs de faire de la politique, c’est en sortir
Dans le tweet ci-dessous, O. Blanchard prend, de mon point de vue, une responsabilité politique x.com/ojblanchard1/status/1804052251364762049
Mon avis n’est pas partagé --> pas mal de débats avec des collègues depuis 48h
Olivier Blanchard
@ojblanchard1
1/6. Tweet thread. Why do I think the economic program of the Nouveau Front Populaire is worse than that of the Rassemblement National?
The nature of the two programs is very different. I have argued that the RN economic program is a Christmas tree, without logic or coherence (previous tweet thread). The NFP economic program is instead mostly internally coherent, based on an epochal redistribution from rich to poor, and from firms to workers.Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2.dans ces citations, pas de sigles, des dénominations claires : fascismes, dictatures
Mais
Les travaux linkés ne documentent pas vraiment l’influence de leurs declarations sur les milieux intellectuels, industriels et publics de l’époque
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Perroux et Hayek sont-ils, à l'instant N et ex-post restés dans leur domaine d’expertise? Quelles sont leurs responsabilités ? Peut-on/doit-on faire abstraction du contexte politique en tant qu’économiste ? Pas de consensus, mais il faut y reflechir
FIN -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Mikael Cozic (mikaelcozic.bsky)
@MikaelCozic
...il est tout à fait possible que, aux yeux de l'expert en question, même si le programme A est défendu par de meilleurs experts que le programme B, B ne soit pas meilleur que A (et que A comme B soient mauvais).
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Ce genre de paragraphe est dangereux, car il transfère l’équivalence de Macron entre RN et FP au champ de l’économie universitaire.
Or il y a une différence de NATURE entre les débats sur les programmes eco LR/Macron/FP et ceux sur le programme FN 1/nPost not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...comment chiffrer les effets d’une augmentation/baisse des impôts, des charges sociales, des indemnités chômage ?
Par opposition, 'le programme économique du FN':
1. consiste en une série d’annonces vagues et contradictoires (pas de liste de mesures ni de chiffrage)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2. sans objectif économique affiché
3. repose sur des chiffres que les écos s’accordent à trouver faux (par ex montant de la fraude sociale...
4. et des mécanismes économiques de l’ordre de la pensée magique
Pas de données, mécanismes, où même de projet --> PAS DE DEBAT ECOPost not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Ils sont en désaccord profond avec l’analyse éco de leurs collègues -de mérite scientifique comparable- qui soutiennent le programme du Front Populaire, et trouvent le programme du RN absurde.
Ne pas être plus précis sur cette distinction est irresponsable
FIN
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
j'essayais de préciser ces idées quand je suis tombée là dessus x.com/aldelatte/status/1803854629391774019
j'abandonne, je vais plutôt chroniquer la remontada de l'école autrichienne à la faveur du chaos actuel, après le succès Sud/nord américain
x.com/i/status/1779303075364442585
(reprenez vous, bordel)
John Vallis
@johnkvallis
‘I love private property, and let me tell you something, if you care about your fucking country, read Ludwig Von Mises and the 6 lessons of the Austrian Economic School, motherfuckers!’ - @moicanoufc 🔥
Best post-fight interview of all time??
Safe to say the Overton window has shifted.
LFG.
#ufc300 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
Heureux d’annoncer que @parolesdhist se joint aux efforts pour éclairer le présent par le passé, puisque j’aurai cette semaine le plaisir de recevoir @JeanVigreux,auteur de livres de référence sur le Front populaire, dans le podcast. Vos questions sont bienvenues ci-dessous !
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Oui d'accord
@OuidaccordOK
Ne pas oublier dans les jours à venir que le Front Populaire de 1936 a été impulsé/imposé par le bas.
Les militants ont passé des mois à travailler ensemble, sur le terrain et à mettre la pression sur leurs orgas (partis comme syndicats) pour les pousser à se rassembler.
⤵️ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Shelly Lundberg
@ShellyJLundberg
CSWEP Report, AEA P&P May 1984.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
CSWEP head (E. Bailey) to NBER head (M. Feldstein), 1980
"Of the 57 persons you list as officers/directors of NBER, not one is a woman...the Bureau's research on the family is being done by 10 male research associates despite the fact that many prominent women work in this area" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maitre Eolas🇫🇷
@Maitre_Eolas
Lyes Louffok
@LyesLouffok
Devant la commission d'enquête sur les dysfonctionnements de l'ASE, Juliette Renault, juge des enfants, a dénoncé la souffrance de ses collègues et la charge de travail intenable.
La salle est encore vide.
" On manque de temps si on ne veut pas travailler la nuit. " -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Will Deringer
@WilliamDeringer
My research on discounting calculations, the church, and social conflict in the early modern countryside is featured today @mit news!
news.mit.edu/2024/unexpected-origins-modern-finance-tool-… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
nature
@Nature
What is science?
AI pioneer Yann LeCun and Elon Musk went head-to-head in a debate about modern research that drew thousands of comments go.nature.com/4aDAQ1D -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Congrats Julien. So much deserved!
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
More on scientific credit:
In this recent paper, Sierminska and Oaxaca himself challenge the rise of “Kitagawa-Oaxaca-Blinder" term to name decomposition methods on grounds that OB is ≠ & often more general method than K
What do you think? docs.iza.org/dp16188.pdf
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I turned my recent thoughts on scientific credit into a post
Scientific credit: the case of economics
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/scientific-credit-t… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Just sent this to a student, but I'd like every econ student to have it, so:
-Letter from Nancy Hyde, econ student prepping for finals, to Paul Samuelson, about his textbook. 1970
-His response (which I already tweeted years ago)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
background thread: x.com/Undercoverhist/status/977303031472705538
and paper with Roger Backhouse www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09672567.2019.1632366
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Acknowledging your own gender bias: the case of Paul Samuelson.
1/ Samuelson was known for derogatory remarks on women, the most famous one he wrote in the 1st edition of his 1948 textbook (he was writing about the popular understanding of the consequences of rationing) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
saving this cool epistemology of science data
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Doug Campbell
@TradeandMoney
How credible was the "credibility revolution"? How robust is empirical research in economics? We just replicated a year's worth of the American Economic Review & had economists predict robustness. Here's what we learned. www.econstor.eu/handle/10419/295222
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
nature
@Nature
Three scientist mothers call for a change in how conference childcare costs are reimbursed, drawing on their personal experiences go.nature.com/3X03rLo
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
How to end an abstract
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
Good luck
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Thibaud Giddey
@GiddeyThibaud
CfP: do you research on the history of lawyers and their role in the business world and in the development of capitalism? Please submit a paper proposal by 21 June.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Fascinating paper that has already sparked important discussions about:
1) Efficiency of matching in academic markets
2) General equilibrium effects of social media promotion
3) The role of attention in generating consideration sets for important decisions
Kudos to authors!
Jingyi Qiu
@JingyiQiu4
🚀Our field experiment (@yanchen @alain_cohn & Al Roth) on Twitter shows that social media promotion can boost job market outcomes, especially for women❗️
✅Job market candidates in the treatment group received one additional flyout, with women receiving 0.9 more job offers.
📜WP papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4778120
#econtwitter #economics #jmc #jmp #women -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Jancovici, finalement, c'est un peu le Taylor Swift des ingénieurs (en tournée ce soir à @Polytechnique, à guichet fermé)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
le titre est adapté à l'auditoire
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Julien Gossa
@JulienGossa
[ #veilleesr #lru ] Document de travail acte II de l'autonomie
- suppression de la qualification et généralisation des CPJ
- suppression des 192h/384h et modulation des services
- « assouplissement » des ATER et vacations
- généralisation des EPE et dévolution -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's still time to send your nominations for best article, book and dissertation @AISPE_2021 awards (the Italian association for the history of economics)
Deadline May 31
Diversity in prizes results from diversity in nominations!
www.aispe.eu/en/call-for-aispe-awards-2024-deadline-may-3… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Y’all should really join me in supporting #teamnun. Yes, the coffee mugs are sweet, and yes, you can golf with @DavidAJaeger. But the real benefit is supporting student researchers and the work of the fabulous @AlisonIBeach. Medieval history rocks.
Alison I. Beach
@AlisonIBeach
(USA) -- Influential historian of economic thought whose research focuses on the twentieth century, but whose interests stretch back to Ancient Greece and the Middle Ages! #teamnun loves our allied supporters!
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is a good story
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
On my reading list
Economic thought
@economicthought
New book: Unexpected Revolutionaries: How Central Banks Made and Unmade Economic Orthodoxy, by Manuela Moschella
www.amazon.com/Unexpected-Revolutionaries-Central-Economi… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Roosevelt Economics 🐳
@RUEcon
Grist for the mill
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09332480.2024.2324665 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
For each historian working on how agricultural economists invented the micro-econometric toolbox in the 1920s/1930s, there should now be one working on how econs struggling with training programs reinvented it in the 1980s/1990s
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Soumaya Keynes
@SoumayaKeynes
Introducing: The Economics Show with Soumaya Keynes www.ft.com/content/72303a1d-8774-4ca1-9494-616164c65fe6
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Actuel Moyen Âge
@AgeMoyen
Ces petits gribouillages n'ont l'air de rien... mais ce sont des devoirs scolaires qui datent du Moyen Âge ! Et ces dessins nous en disent très long sur la culture de l'époque.
Un thread ⬇️! (inspiré de celui de @BatallitasX que je remercie) #histoire #medievaltwitter -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
Quelle est la plus grande ou plus belle surprise que vous ayez eue en ouvrant un carton d'archives ou dans un dépouillement de documents?
#teamhistoire #goutdelarchive -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Méda Dominique @dominiquemeda.bsky.social
@dominique_meda
Je n’ai pas la même audience que @GMeurice ou @LaTacfi mais ma chronique du vendredi sur France Culture est également supprimée. Je termine avec une longue série sur…la crise de l’Etat providence. www.radiofrance.fr/franceculture/podcasts/le-pourquoi-du-…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Harcèlement structurel et viols étouffés à Saint-Cyr :
que les dirigeants censés apprendre la bravoure, la rectitude morale et le leadership aux élèves officiers en manquent à ce point est très inquiétant pour le futur de l'armée
www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2024/05/10/a-saint-cyr-le-…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
contrairement aux enseignantes et enseignants de l'école dont on ne peut qu'admirer le courage, le dévouement et la ténacité
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Standing in a small gallery, natural lighting. Here's a sample of what I see in front of me, without moving an inch Where am I?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
SHoET
@Societies_HET
Remembering Mauro Boianovsky #eshet2024
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
So, here is the promised thread on my forthcoming JEL paper with some pictures etc.
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jel.20241699 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Clara Dealberto
@claradealberto
C'est le jour du Met Gala, c'est donc aussi celui de mon désormais classique thread
✨ LES TENUES DU MET GALA AS GRAPHIQUES DE L'INSEE ✨
On commence avec Zendaya as Origine et destination des étudiants en mobilité selon la taille de l’unité urbaine -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Il y a fort fort longtemps dans un coin de la galaxie, une petite historienne soutint vite fait une thèse de 156 pages. Depuis ce jour, chaque année, la déesse des historiens lui rappela son blasphème en lui envoyant au moins une thèse de 700-900 pages à rapporter
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(je sais même pas si en mettant bout a bout tout ce que j'ai jamais écris en histoire, on arrive à 700 pages)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Robert Bigg
@RobertBigg
Insightful - “Historians ask ‘who was the first’ and dig out more distant precursors … What matters is where it began. Economists ask ‘who was the last’ and some strive to establish themselves as proposing the ‘definite’ theory/model/technique, …What matters is where it ended.”
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I turned my recent thoughts on scientific credit into a post
Scientific credit: the case of economics
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/scientific-credit-t… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I turned my recent thoughts on scientific credit into a post
Scientific credit: the case of economics
theundercoverhistorian.substack.com/p/scientific-credit-t…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(which you can also use as a short reading list on the history of game theory)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maria Bach
@mvsbach
Any Indian historians able to help me find the first names of these people?
R. P. Patwardhan
S. N. Mallik
M. B. Kolasker
V. N. Naik
I have looked in lots of books and the internet, but cannot find them for now! @Societies_HET @sharminkhodaiji @alexmthomas @DinyarPatel -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Valentina Erasmo
@ValentinaErasmo
My paper <<'Who are the capability theorists?’: a tale of the origins and development of the capability approach>> is out on the latest issue of the Cambridge Journal of Economics academic.oup.com/cje/article-abstract/48/3/425/7610030
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
T2M@Macro
@T2M_Conference
At this year‘s conference we experimented with online feedback forms for all presented papers. @SilvaDejanir won a price for being the most diligent user of this feature. Congratulations, and thank you for effort! Feel free to imitate @SEDmeeting @EEANews et al 😉
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Juchée comme jamais
@JucheeComJamais
Cher.e.s ami.e.s,
Il y a un an @kinkybambou disparaissait. Nous savons combien elle a été appréciée ici, tant pour ses écrits que ses engagements. Aujourd’hui, nous officialisons la création de l’association « Juchée comme jamais » dédiée à la continuation de son œuvre.(1/16) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
So not only did Von Neumann influence the mathematical apparatus and epistemological approach to game theory, but also a specific notion of "proper discovery" and credit which may have shaped later development in the field
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Von Neumann offered his own (ongoing) genealogy, concluding that
"It is common and tempting fallacy to view the later steps in a mathematical evolution as much more obvious and cogent after the fact than they were beforehand" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What's better than a Hayek take to close a busy week ?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
bonus question: can we historians not take side? Do we need/should we have a "definition of credit"?
(after credit scene: in the 1953 Econometrica issue the Borel controversy is sandwiched b/w Gorman's Community preference fields & Nash's two person cooperative games articles) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...in daily discussing abt who should get credit for what: the one who asked new question/laid new concept
the one who thought abt applying tool X to issue Y
the one who built the model bringing all this together
the one w/ the clearest or most tractable model
What do you think? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
As unpacked by Nessah/Tadzaït/Vahabi, Frechet had exchange translated in French in Revue d'Economie Politique www-jstor-org.inshs.bib.cnrs.fr/stable/24691720?seq=1 *with further rejoinder*
He outlines four stages of discovery
I. the "madly bod project to translate gamers' psychology mathematically
... -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Almost every day these weeks, conversations I had w/ colleagues hinge upon notions of credit and "who discovered X" in economics
So I can't stop chewing over the 1953 Frechet-Von Neumann controversy on whether mathematician Emile Borel "invented" Game Theory -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis Fréget (🇫🇷 account)
@UnEmpiriciste
Is this paper relevant? :)
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20181096 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pedro Duarte
@P_G_Duarte
If you haven’t done so, register for this wonderful writing workshop (online and free)! Deadline is today, May 3rd!
SHoET
@Societies_HET
5th JHET Online Writing Workshops, May 7
The third meeting is scheduled for May 7 (Tuesday), 2024, from 10AM to 11AM EDT time (UTC-4; New York time). If you are interested in the workshop, please fill in the online form:
docs.google.com/forms/d/1_pVWdViVRPEMSlxIBEOHxVF8CaiqQ6No…
Further details below! -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What's the current research on how much heterogeneity in time preferences can drive inequality (in particular in wealth)?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Theo Diamandis
@theo_diamandis
Have been working on network flows which led me down a rabbit hole tracing the history of the max flow problem. The original formulation of this problem wasn’t declassified until 1999 (!), almost 45 years after its formulation
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Thread interessant qui montre des differences de cultures entre SHS et sciences dans les auditions McF. reste a décider si l'éco à le meilleur ou le pire des 2 cultures
Perso, je suis côté mix: supposer le jury bienveillant et réaliste (c'est loin d'être toujours le cas....1/2
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2/2 ..... vous transformer en terminator capable de tout anticiper, de tout connaitre du jury et de répondre à toutes les demandes sera aussi impossible qu'inutile.
Venez préparés, mais sans trahir qui vous êtes, ce que vous avez à offrir, et vos raisons de vouloir ce job) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Tony Yates
@t0nyyates
If you have a gap on your teaching roster next year, I might be able to fill it. Macro, money, finance, metrics, maths for econ. Let me know.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
Today is the 60th anniversary of the first release of BASIC, a family of programming languages meant to making programming more broadly accessible.
This language is all over the history of computing, and a version of it was seen as a must-have for early computers from the Altair 8800 to the Apple II. But it was first run on May 1, 1964 -30 years ago today- on a GE225 mainframe pictured below.
Happy birthday BASIC -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@rapho-l.bsky.social
@Raph_O_L
Le #1ermai 1974, les Nations Unies votaient la résolution sur l'établissement d'un Nouvel ordre économique international. Belle occasion de rappeler ce papier montrant que le #noei était un "chant du cygne" dans l'action commune des pays du Sud 🔽
journals.openedition.org/siecles/11123 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Michele Tertilt
@TertiltMichele
Very much looking forward to the T2M this week in Amsterdam. Will be taking about the economics of women‘s rights.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The program for the "Theory and Methods in Macro" (T2M) annual conference (In Amsterdam this week) is now out.
www.t2m.network/2024/program/
With plenaries by @TertiltMichele and @fatihguvenen -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A wonderful contribution! congrats @Ivan_A_Boldyrev
AEA Journals
@AEAjournals
Forthcoming in the JEL: "Soviet Mathematics and Economic Theory in the Past Century: A Historical Reappraisal" by Ivan Boldyrev. www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jel.20241699&from=f
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
If you want to understand the contexts and influence of the mathematical tools developed by Kantorovich, Pontryagin, and Kolmogorov, read this superb paper
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
YSI History of Economic Thought Working Group
@het_ysi
Run and apply! @ysi_commons @INETeconomics
Please circulate; @Societies_HET @rethinkecon @THETSoc @CenterEconomy @Societies_HET @economicthought @econhistorian @HEIjournal @CleoCZ @Undercoverhist
Young Scholars Initiative
@ysi_commons
Get ready for a new webinar series! 🌓
Apply now to present your work: ysiproject.org/moon
🙏 Thank you to @rgbetancourt, @sattwickdb, Fabio Masini, and Alexandre Reichart -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Laurent Gayer
@Laurent_Gayer
La communauté éducative de #sciencepo se porte très bien, merci.
Et pour info, nous trouvons nos étudiants et nos étudiantes formidables, même celles et ceux qui perturbent les cours quelques heures par an – cela s'appelle la vie universitaire.
Valérie Pécresse
@vpecresse
J’ai décidé de suspendre tous les financements de la Région destinés à @sciencespo tant que la sérénité et la sécurité ne seront pas rétablies dans l’école. Une minorité de radicalisés appelant à la haine antisémite et instrumentalisés par la LFI et ses alliés islamo-gauchistes, ne peuvent pas dicter leur loi à l’ensemble de la communauté éducative.
La Région @iledefrance défend le droit à des débats libres, éclairés et respectueux au sein de l’université francaise, conformes aux valeurs universelles d’humanisme qu’elle porte, et qui sont au coeur de notre pacte républicain.
Face aux renoncements de la direction, la Région appelle à un sursaut d’autorité. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Mark Koyama
@MarkKoyama
Do Individuals Matter in Institutional Economic History? www.markkoyama.com/p/do-individuals-matter-in-institution…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
It's finally here: I got seven secret Federal Reserve books through FOIA. In this piece I provide access to all of them and give a background description of their contents and why they are important.
www.crisesnotes.com/revealed-the-seven-secret-federal-res… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Arrow on Maskin's early achievements (1975)
"there is no display of technical power for its own sake. The technique is solely at the command of the conceptual problems"
Also different names for what has since stabilized as "mechanisms" (aka 'social decisions procedures") -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jason Fletcher
@jasonmfletcher
I am honored to be offered the job of Editor-in-Chief of Health Economics @HECJournalTweet, replacing the excellent Sally Stearns (@GillingsGlobal).
I plan to reject this offer. Why? -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The program for the "Theory and Methods in Macro" (T2M) annual conference (In Amsterdam this week) is now out.
www.t2m.network/2024/program/
With plenaries by @TertiltMichele and @fatihguvenen
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
And for once there's even a session on the history of macro, so meet us there!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Claudio Ferraz
@claudferraz
First time a Latin American economist, first time a female economist. On July 1, 2025, Marina Halac will become the Editor of Econometrica @ecmaEditors
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Just as Joe Stiglitz spills oil on never-extinct debates on markets vs government, a week of discussion has led me to toy with the idea that mechanism design may have essentially resulted in this distinction becoming irrelevant & replaced by an applied focus on "allocation"
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
In windy Philly, wide awake since 3AM
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
updated belief: Philly is a sunny, walkable and breathable city, with lots of cool communities of economists (and particularly cool theorists)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
also, every wall speaks to the history of discounting and modeling in economics, which made discussing the history and relevance of the Ramsey equation especially relevant ;)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Yale Department of Economics
@YaleEconomics
Recognized as a leading American economist under 40, Philipp Strack’s work solves long-standing open questions in economic theory.
Read more about his recent Clark Medal here: economics.yale.edu/news/240410/yale-economist-philipp-str… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andrej Svorenčík
@ASvorencik
The final guest lecture of the Market and their Critics online course by @Penn_Exchange at @penneconomics was delivered by Deidre McCloskey on Equality of Permission. She also spoke to econ history students on Liberalism Caused the Great Enrichment co-hosted by @flandreaumarc
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jeff Powell
@Powell_J_R
The History of Economic Thought Society annual conference 4-6 Sept - abstract proposals by 30 Apr - pls share
@alexmthomas
@AstaMassimo
@Goulven_Rubin
@_kevinroesch
@F_Allisson
@EdithKuiper
@QuentinCouix thets.org.uk/2024-annual-conference/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andrea Matranga 🇺🇦🌻
@andreamatranga
And just like that... :) academic.oup.com/qje/advance-article/doi/10.1093/qje/qjae…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Penn's Exchange
@Penn_Exchange
.@Undercoverhist presenting at Penn’s PISM seminar on the history of the Ramsey formula as used to discuss discounting in economics.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
At the intersection of my research interests and the week's events, an economist I've been researching for a while (Albert Hart) wrote out his own narrative of the campus occupation at the time. Fascinating document thanks to @irwincollier.
www.irwincollier.com/columbia-personal-narrative-of-the-c… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nicolas Petit
@CompetitionProf
The great @StiglerCenter conference yesterday showcased what @ZephyrTeachout called a series of ‘history panels” on antitrust #stiglerantitrust24. A thread on why so much focus on history in US antitrust debates 1/n
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
Economics is an ecosystem and I love most or perhaps even all of it. Theorists. Empiricists. Government statisticians. Ivory tower academics. In the trenches think tankers. Investment bank economists. Government economists. Tweeters. And many more I didn't mention.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
One of my main motivations for founding Our World in Data was to overcome the mad reality in academia that much of the most important research and data is locked away behind paywalls.
I wanted research and data to be a public good, accessible to *everyone*.
If you find our work valuable, I would appreciate if you would pay us a little so that we can make good data and research accessible to everyone.
ourworldindata.org/donate -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
Which brings me back to the idea that there should be good publicly available and updatable bibliographies on the history of econ. Here is my list on the history of financial economics (sth immediately coming to mind, feel free to add)
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
So where to eat the best chocolate cake in Philly?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
Announcement: the new Review of the History of Economic Thought and Methodology (RHETM) is officially open for business and ready to receive submissions.
rhetm.org -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex Campolo
@AlexCampolo
Looks nice! "Writing the History of Computer Visualizations in the Sciences: Production, Uses, Circulation (1940-1990)" at the EHESS in May
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maria Bach
@mvsbach
dear @Societies_HET - anyone know an historian of inflationary theories? @Undercoverhist @CleoCZ @clanatab @F_Allisson
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Congrats to all my historian of economics colleagues in Brazil for making interwar Vienna and the socialist calculation debate lively and relevant enough to be remembered post-fight ?!?!!
John Vallis
@johnkvallis
‘I love private property, and let me tell you something, if you care about your fucking country, read Ludwig Von Mises and the 6 lessons of the Austrian Economic School, motherfuckers!’ - @moicanoufc 🔥
Best post-fight interview of all time??
Safe to say the Overton window has shifted.
LFG.
#ufc300
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
currently rethinking my class outfits
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sharmin Khodaiji
@sharminkhodaiji
The Symposium on Indian Economic Thought organised by @jguideas and #ishet concluded with an amazing set of presentations by @alexmthomas Iman Mitra @RuchiraSen67 @saketmoon @ishanjsr @shahna_p @mvsbach
Entire event accessible on www.youtube.com/watch?v=5s3DYVBwYwg&ab_channel=IDEASOffic… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jules Grandin
@JulesGrandin
Il faut absolument que je vous parle d'une carte.
Enfin, plutôt de 15 cartes.
Dans un projet qui en compte quasiment une centaine.
Ce sont les cartes des « Ancient meanders of the Mississippi river », réalisées en 1944 par Harold Fisk
Elles sont M.A.G.N.I.F.I.Q.U.E.S 😍😍😍 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
Don't write to impress the reader with your intelligence; write to impress them with theirs.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
For those wanting to read more about the origins of Jensen’s work on the firm, with Meckling, following the former’s passing, you can’t go wrong with @DGindis’s excellent paper.
David Gindis
@DGindis
Read about the history of their famous definition of the firm academic.oup.com/oep/article/72/4/966/5899892
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Je monte dans le bus et j'aperçois une de mes étudiantes qui lit studieuse ment l'opus d'@HelenePerivier. La nouvelle génération !
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
lien vers le livre www.pressesdesciencespo.fr/fr/book/?GCOI=27246100423030
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
Furious, every day, that European governments are not doing enough to stop this relentless abomination.
Haggis_UK 🇬🇧 🇪🇺
@Haggis_UK
Aid ships are turning back from Gaza with around 240 tons of undelivered aid after the killing of 7 World Central Kitchen aid workers.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Les Echos
@LesEchos
L'Ensae-Institut Polytechnique de Paris- veut former des milliers d'ingénieurs data www.lesechos.fr/pme-regions/ile-de-france/lensae-institut…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
In the wake of our annual lunch debate on the merits and demerits of having blackboards in every classroom at X, reupping this little gem
Our chalks are not going away, it seems
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Why Mathematicians Are Hoarding This Special Type of Japanese Chalk"
gizmodo.com/why-mathematicians-are-hoarding-this-special-…
read this alongside @MBarany's piece on mathematicians, blackboards and chalk dust mbarany.com/DustyDisciplineBWM15.pdf -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jason Doctor
@jasndoc
Ward Edwards' father was an economist and the dinner conversation sometimes centered around micro theory. When Edwards started graduate school in psychology it occurred to him that these theories were scientifically testable, a precursor to beh econ.
pages.ucsd.edu/~mckenzie/Edwards1954PsychBulletin.pdf
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
Science is built on abstraction. Newtonian physics doesn’t bother with particle physics or details with relativity. Chemistry isn’t micro founded on physics, and bio isn’t based on chemistry.
It’s Econ’s focus on micro foundations which is weird. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pierre Boyer
@pierrecboyer
Peut-on être heureux de payer des impôts ? La réponse est dans mon #livre @editions_PUF. Bonne lecture !
Données, graphiques et annexes sont disponibles
pierrecboyer.com -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Did econs make these assumptions because they believed them true?
-what were Arrow vs Debreu's goals? press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691156644/finding…
-how Coase vs later users viewed transaction costs www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jel.20191060
-how many assumptions stuck for tractability reasons? journals.openedition.org/oeconomia/14116
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Interesting point by richard Werner. The joint probability that all assumptions of neoclassical theory would hold is less than 1%
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Did the rise of experiment challenge these assumptions, then? www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09538259.2020.1841384 and www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09672567.2021.1936107
Whatever happened to those economists modeling disequilibrium? www.abebooks.com/9781107023192/Transforming-Modern-Macroe… and www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014292123001988
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
and a lot more history references in the threads below from my Bachelor course:
Should economic model be realistic: x.com/Undercoverhist/status/1110543180758429696
What's the status of the rationality assumption:
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/The 2 final @Bachelor_X debates were on “Are Economic Agents Rational?”
so here’s a thread on how economists have defined rationality across 20th century.
Focus is on 2 debates: status of expected utility theory (EUT) in 50s & of Kahneman & Tversky’s results in 70s to 90s
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
this is not a criticism of that one slide, whose context I know nothing about, more an amused comment on the online reactions to it
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
franceinfo
@franceinfo
Réchauffement climatique : la fonte des glaces risque d'affecter la mesure du temps
l.francetvinfo.fr/vM6 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jeff Powell
@Powell_J_R
The History of Economic Thought Society annual conference 4-6 Sept - abstract proposals by 30 Apr - pls share @THETSoc @CenterEconomy @Societies_HET @economicthought @econhistorian @het_ysi @HEIjournal @CleoCZ @Undercoverhist thets.org.uk/2024-annual-conference/
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nina Eichacker
@nina_econ
Q for history of economic thought people: are there any major Real Business Cycle theory people out there right now, and are there any recent classic papers/briefs that exemplify the state of the field? (thinking intellectual heirs to Lucas, Prescott, and Kydland, et al)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pierre Boyer
@pierrecboyer
Un grand merci @Cercle_eco pour cet échange ! Podcast #générationEconomie @Louie_Creative
@Polytechnique @IP_Paris_ @IPPinfo @clarabaillot
lecercledeseconomistes.fr/limpot-est-il-politique/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Giovanni Ricco 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@ricco_giovanni
There is a wide gap in the literature on the effects of monetary policy: emerging markets
A new paper with @viegi_nic and Ekaterina Pirozhkova tries to help fill this gap by looking at South Africa
Comments and criticism are gratefully accepted
www.giovanni-ricco.com/single-post/trouble-every-day-mone… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matt Notowidigdo
@ProfNoto
And I think this PNAS paper suggests that at the margin many people don't spend enough to "buy time" www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1706541114
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
this feels so real
Ryan
@ryanbedwards
But I haven't seen any such resources, sorry. Basically, prioritise well, follow all generic advice elsewhere,
and try and find a way to do that with like half the time budget, and like you've been hit in the head with a mallet. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ryan
@ryanbedwards
In my second postdoc, I was surrounded by fellow parents, including at least two on the tenure track, who were super "present" parents and supported me doing this same, which gave me hope that I could have my cake and eat it too, maybe. That helped me deal with it all mentally.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
[HIVE MIND] What are great online resources for young academic parents struggling w/ sleeploss, work-life balance, unpredictable schedules, etc?
My tiny contribution is an episode of the @CeterisNParibus podcast I did a few years ago
ceterisneverparibus.net/parenting-in-academia-episode-20/
What else? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jake
@JLBornstein
Universities are funny. Hey what if we took a medieval institution for training priests and aristocrats and combined it w a hedge fund, sports franchise and resort for teenagers
Oh and it'll be the backbone for fundamental research for our entire civilization -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
[BESOIN D'AIDE] Existe-t-il des references en français sur l'histoire de la comptabilité carbone (calcul d'empreinte carbones par des économistes, pouvoirs publics, groupes civils, liens avec la compta nat)?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Michael Harris
@MichaelH_PhD
In Australia, Max Corden was a master of this stuff. He told amazing stories in pictures.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Daniel Gottlieb
@danielgott
The 𝑛𝑜𝑛-𝑚𝑎𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑚𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑙 mathematical economists.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Visualization or Mathematization? The London School of Economics and “Diagrammatic Economics” in the 1930s
by Yann Giraud
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Forgot the link to the paper on that one: read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
After a good 9-month gestation with @P_G_Duarte, a birth assisted by the more benevolent and skilled team I could think of. Many thanks to @cired8568 for the warm welcome and fruitful discussions
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
*most*
(wouldn't be a real tweet without a rookie English mistake)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
aha thanks for the comparison. We're in the same anxiety stage now that we've been with the heterogeneity paper before ("we tried to cover too many work over too much time and who's gonna read - even less publish- such a long draft with 50 protagonists?")
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
and by the way. You have the best twitter bio. I should steal it, it describes my life so well
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Hotelling and Wilson on Statistical Inference: Local Attitudes and Universal Dreams
by Juan Carvajalino; Thomas Michael Mueller
read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Setting the Stage for Disciplinary Transformations: Riker, McKenzie, and the Case of the University of Rochester
by Gianluca Damiani
read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Bielefeld Game Theory and Indiana Institutional Analysis: Elinor Ostrom and Theories of Common-Pool Resources
by Paul Erickson
read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
MIT and the Origins of the Modern Theory of Asset Pricing
by Roger E. Backhouse
read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Awesome story, awesome data
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
My new paper on the history of Soviet math and its relations to economics is out at HOPE (the final version to appear later this year), I am so happy I started to work on this incredible interesting material! 1/ read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
all the papers from a wonderful special issue on the history of mathematical economics are now live on the HOPE website read.dukeupress.edu/hope/advance-publication
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
And check the introduction by guest editors Juan Carvajalino and Thomas Mueller
read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/doi/10.1215/00182702-111… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
The paper tells a story of 1935 topological conference in Moscow, which brought together (along with other famous people) John von Neumann, Leonid Kantorovich, and Albert Tucker — the progenitors of modern mathematical economics and operations research. 2/
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I didn't know that Jean Tirole had become a philosopher and a historian of "narratives"
TSE
@TSEinfo
[RESEARCH GRANT]
👏Congratulations to Pr. @JeanTirole who received his 3rd Advanced Grant from the @ERC_Research for his project "Harmony Within Society"
Learn more about it here 👉 13xy.mj.am/nl3/9U4hrNF17a4Ubc9UQ-0E4w?hl=en -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
It is so sad that yet another economist, the very entertaining @KhoaVuUmn, decided not to have a public profile after relentless harassment by a platform filled with hate.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Marco Vianna Franco
@mpvfranco
Check this CfP out: "Energy transitions and economic thinking in German-speaking territories, 1800-2000" #etranhet org. by Antoine Missemer and @Henk_JanDekker at @cired8568 Link: www.centre-cired.fr/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/CfP_ETRANH…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Given that the Levitt interview has everyone gossiping about Chicago, perhaps this is a good time to post a link to my forthcoming piece on the origins of the perception that there was a distinctive Chicago school of economics.
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Mariacristina De Nardi
@M_De_Nardi
I very had the very same experience as @lugaricano
Chicago Econ gave me a chance:
- no other department at the same level would take a gamble on me.
- It was transformative in an incredibly positive way.
i would not trade my experience for another.
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
1) On the Econ PhD Program. I went in 1992, graduated in 1998. I did not feel the ambiance was toxic. It was tough work, almost brutal, not toxic. I was given a chance I would not have gotten elsewhere. There was nothing personal about the standards. We were getting trained by the best and that was intellectually invaluable -we got the chance of a lifetime. Here are some profs of my first two years (note 5 nobels):
Macro: Sargent, Lucas, Cochrane, Woodford, Stokey, Townsend.
Micro: Becker, Rosen, Murphy, Scheinkman
Metrics: Hansen, Heckman, Zellner.
It was extremely hard, by far the hardest thing I have ever done. But it should be hard. They were trying to put a bunch of kids at the frontier of knowledge.
It was not for everyone, but we knew what we were getting into. My admired supervisor, Sherwin Rosen, then department chair, gave us a "superstar" (he wrote THE paper after all) talk on the first day. He told us half of us would fail in the first year Core (and exit with an MA, is that so bad?), half of the rest would not make the prelims. Of the 50 we were there, maybe 10 would finish the PhD, most of those would never get any citation.
And yet we persisted. We wanted to learn, and were grateful for the hance.
2/n -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nina Eichacker
@nina_econ
I’m excited to note that URI’s economics department is hiring again! We’re a heterodox friendly department looking for an assistant teaching professor in the fields of economic history and the history of thought! jobs.uri.edu/postings/13139
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Will Deringer
@WilliamDeringer
Beyond excited to share this article, ten years in the making. I think it’s the best work I’ve done.
“Mr. Aecroid’s Tables: Economic Calculations and Social Customs in the Early Modern Countryside,” Jnl of Modern History @ChicagoJournals
Open Access!
www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/728594 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
[HELP NEEDED] Do we have any resource on the history of contract theory?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Levitt dunking on Heckman to start your day
(saying hi to @IsabellaMWeber who got the "old Chicago treatment" at some point)
Nicola Giocoli
@ngiocoli
Wow! That's truly interesting.
@Undercoverhist @Societies_HET
@economicthought @spydermed @AISPE_2021 @BrianCAlbrecht
threadreaderapp.com/thread/1767826478350368845.html
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Joan Robinson's daughter tells me that the houses where Robinson lived in Cambridge and in London will be recognized, and receive a blue plaque. This is such terrific news.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
WP: The Gini Coefficient: Its Origins, by Simone Pellegrino
econpapers.repec.org/paper/turwpapnw/070.htm -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who wrote when to reflect on "the discount rate and the opposition between our moral instincts for zero rate and the Koopmans argument (if you care so much abt future then you don't care about the present)"
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"We find ourselves forced to hunt for a solution in the dark jungles of the second best" (Will Baumol)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
he's describing the choice of a discount rate, but I think really the everyday life of many economists
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
CREST (UMR 9194)
@CrestUmr
🌎 Celebrating International Women's Day at CREST!♀️
🔍Dive into insightful scientific research showcasing innovative projects led by our researchers and PhD students, unravelling gender inequalities in economics and sociology.
💪#iwd2024 #genderequality 🚀www.linkedin.com/feed/update/activity:7171817543484063746 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Oliver Kim
@oliverwkim
What is the best Marx biography?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nicholas Poggioli
@nalanpog
Why can't academics give up flying?
We identified cultural, individual, and organizational reasons academics think we can't decarbonize research production.
Especially relevant as more conferences & workshops return to offline-only formats.
nicholaspoggioli.files.wordpress.com/2023/08/poggioli-and… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"It would seem that the greater intrinsic value attached to life and health as against plentiful goods and services would give greater weight to the ethical consideration mentioned earlier"
Econs struggling with how nuclear threat affects their discounting framework (1970s) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
When the biographical notice of the protagonists of your story make you envious
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Rose may have been a fancy nuclear engineering professor, but he has obviously never heard about the notion of a "social discount rate"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
okay
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Johanna Thoma
@johannamthoma1
“Women silenced across ranks: LSE’s mishandled sexual misconduct investigation into professor”
I made a contribution to this, in the hope something will change.
thebeaverlse.co.uk/sexual-misconduct-investigation/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Justin Sandefur
@JustinSandefur
The Economist revisits the RCT wars
www.economist.com/1843/2024/03/01/how-poor-kenyans-became… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Stefan Eich
@stefeich
Just got the proofs, should be online very soon and out in @AJPS_Editor! Keynes and politics of time, or why we are not all dead in the long run.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Federica Genovese
@fgenovese__
Brief academic story.
July 2022: I am encouraged to apply for a job in Germany. I apply.
February 2023: A semi-cryptic email invites me to send more documents to be considered as part of the short list. Documents are essentially the same as sent in 2022, but yeah ok fine. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Je pense que l'AFEP et l'AFSE devrait créer un prix joint special pour Michael Zemmour
j'dis ça j'dis rien ⏚
@jdicajdisrien
Un jour faudra parler de Michael Zemmour, Maître de conférences en économie et chercheur, qui met ippon sur ippon à n'importe quel gugus éditorialiste ou membre du gouvernement depuis la réforme des retraites.
C'est du grand art.
Personne ne lui arrive à la cheville.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
devraient
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jonathan A. Parker
@ProfJAParker
This!!! I teach students the robustness section should show “this far and no further” by pushing (heterogeneity, weaker assumptions, whatever) until the main finding breaks. The best papers have models that are rejected and/or results that are quite statistically insignificant.
Jonathan Roth
@jondr44
As a PS, I'll add that an odd feature of current empirical work IMO is the tendency to show robustness but not non-robustness
Nearly all analyses require assumptions to draw conclusions
Tell me the 1-2 assumptions that are critical, not just the 20 asm's that don't matter! -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
The CfP for ISHET's first annual conference is here! 🥁 Like our previous events, we particularly welcome submissions from BA/MA/PhD students. 🌿
📅 28-29 October, 2024 @HydUniv, Hyderabad
More details here: sites.google.com/view/ishet/ishet-2024
Keynotes by @rgbetancourt & @RvdbB2015! 🤩 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Great highlights on the difference between the Mansky and the Card-Angrist-Krueger approach to econometrics
Yannay Spitzer
@YannayASpitzer
@Undercoverhist
Here's one way to compare the two approaches (I was once an RA with Angrist and then a student of Manski):
>
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Arrgggg, *Manski* again
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
More awesome highlights on the difference between the Mansky and the Card-Angrist-Krueger approach to econometrics
twitter still has some magic it seems!
Jonathan Roth
@jondr44
I would say the key idea of Manski's work is:
A reasonable set of assumptions may not allow us to learn about a parameter exactly, but it might allow us to obtain bounds on that parameter
This allows to make clearer the mapping between assumptions and conclusions 1/
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Sorry, *Manski*
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
I like this Jonathan. I’m not an econometrician but use Manski’s conceptual insights a lot in my work.
Our Inaccurate Statistical Discrimination paper can be interpreted as Manski’s idea that preferences can’t be identified when rational expectations (strong assumption) fails -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jonathan Roth
@jondr44
I'm afraid many have mistakenly taken away that we should impose weak assumptions and conclude we can learn nothing.
But the idea is not that we should stop there.
4/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
Assumptions shape outcomes as much as data. Humility is essential.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
After a lecture on the history of Ashenfelter-Angrist-Lalonde-Card-Krueger approaches to inference, how would summarize quickly's Manski's conceptual and empirical stance in a few sentences to econ Ma and early PhD students who don't know it?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Thank for the responses. That's very useful. But I'm struck that more 2 lines summaries of Mansky emphasize negative results (caution, you can't do that) etc, and it may raises the difficulty of teaching those stuff to students and disseminating the approach. Maybe. Just 2 cents
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matt Notowidigdo
@ProfNoto
If I can make a joke as a former colleague, I'd summarize his conceptual stance as "knowledge is impossible" nihilism ;-)
To be more serious I'd say his stance is nicely summarized in this interview he gave to the Washington Post several years ago: www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/02/19/admit… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matt Notowidigdo
@ProfNoto
Getting researchers & government agencies to "admit what we don't know" is a good summary IMO
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Daniel Reck
@danhreck
Those assumptions are all way too strong because they’re derived with a focus on identifying a parameter exactly. What if we made some weaker assumptions and identified bounds for parameters instead? Turns out economic theory gives us lots of structured ways to do this.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sientifiko
@sientifiko1
Just embrace uncertainty and learn to deal with it
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Rory McGee
@mcgeeconomics
Manski’s Law of Decreasing Credibility:
"The credibility of inference decreases with the strength
of the assumptions maintained"
(from Policy Analysis with Incredible Certitude, by Charles F. Manski)
Credit to Ian Crawford for teaching UGs this in such a memorable way -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is a great topic, in case you have proposals on the history of how to model quality in economics
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Marion Gaspard
@Marion_Gaspard
Grâce à @frbessis, le Master SES - "Théories et Histoire de l'économie dans la société" a désormais son carnet hypothèses : seslyon2.hypotheses.org/a-propos Have a look!
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Les petites filles sont des punks"
CANAL+
@canalplus
"Ayons le courage de dire tout haut ce que tout le monde pense tout bas..."
Le discours engagé de Judith Godrèche sur la scène des #césar2024.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I should know this but can't remember. Have Tom Schelling's archives been deposited somewhere?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Colin-Jaeger Nathanaël
@Jaeger_bombe
A fantastic paper I sadly had not read for my dissertation. It is a very well-thought explanation of the challenges any interventionist political theory should face, beyond central planning theories.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
MSF International
@MSF
“There is no health system to speak of left in #gaza. Israel’s military has dismantled hospital after hospital. What remains is so little in the face of such carnage.”
MSF Secretary General Chris Lockyear briefs the @UN Security Council. Read more 👇
www.msf.org/msf-briefing-gaza-un-security-council -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"I am anxious that the book's ideas will only lead to dead ends"
John Rawls to Partha Dasgupta, 1973, on the Theory of Justice -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pedro Faria
@pedrovcfaria
Mauro foi um dos grandes nomes globais da história do pensamento econômico. Foi responsável, junto com outros/as colegas, por internacionalizar a disciplina no Brasil. É uma pena que tenha partido tão cedo. Que descanse em paz.
Economic thought
@economicthought
We are saddened by the news of the passing of Professor Mauro Boianovsky. He was a valued and lively member of the HET community and will be greatly missed.
RIP. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is so, so sad. Mauro was a prolific historian of macroeconomics
Economic thought
@economicthought
We are saddened by the news of the passing of Professor Mauro Boianovsky. He was a valued and lively member of the HET community and will be greatly missed.
RIP.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The best we can do to honor him is to read and cite his work.
His history of disequilibrium macro with Roger Backhouse
and their coauthored paper on the history of the "secular stagnation" concept papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2602903
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I also drew a lot of inspiration from his paper on the rise of growth at MIT (w/ Kevin Hoover) public.econ.duke.edu/~kdh9/Source Materials/Research/Boia…
and his recent work on Lucas's 1980/1990s work on rational expectations www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1350178X.2022.2033299 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
New book: Research in the History of Economic Thought and Methodology: Including a Symposium on Hazel Kyrk's A Theory of Consumption 100 Years after Publication, Guest edited by Rebeca Gomez Betancourt
www.amazon.com/Research-History-Economic-Thought-Methodol… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Recently published in AER:
"Unpacking P-hacking and Publication Bias" by Abel Brodeur, Scott Carrell, David Figlio, & Lester Lusher
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20210795 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Garry Kasparov
@Kasparov63
Putin tried and failed to murder Navalny quickly and secretly with poison, and now he has murdered him slowly and publicly in prison. He was killed for exposing Putin and his mafia as the crooks and thieves they are. My thoughts are with the brave man's wife and children.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
Does anyone know of any scholarship on what the Federal Reserve's view on the "Keynes and White plans" and thus subsequently bretton woods was? I can't find anything in a preliminary search
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
André Loez (en veille, sur bluesky)
@andreloez
"Lors d’une ascension en montagne, quand la paroi qu’on escalade est difficile, on aime savoir qui vous assure... Dans mon travail de recherche, plus d’une fois Pierre a joué ce rôle d’« assureur »."
JP Vernant, "Préface", *Pierre Vidal-Naquet, un historien dans la cité* -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
INEM
@EconMethodology
**Save the date ** The 17th INEM conference will be held at the beautiful campus of the University of Bayreuth, Germany, from September 17-19, 2025. The program committee is chaired by @cherfeld and @lecouteuxg; more information will follow soon
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
Article: History of Economics in the Light of Meghnad Desai’s Poverty of Political Economy, by Ajit Sinha
journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00194662231223688 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Erin Hengel
@erinhengel
I would like to remind people on here that many (and probably most!) applied empirical economists—including myself—still do the vast majority of our own grunt work (e.g., data cleaning and literature surveys).
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Had to reopen old Marschak archives, so many gems here "
'Ceteris Paribus': a refuge for lazy irresponsibles" (1948) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
JMC 🌹🏴
@red_dilettante
Just saw this, but my essay Wobbly Economics -- while too long in total -- has a section called What's So Heterodox About Heterodox Economics? that should be (including all its subsections, ending at Blowing up the Price Mechanism) exactly the right size.
strangematters.coop/frederic-s-lee-profile-part-one/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Peter Boettke
@PeterBoettke
2024 Summer Institute | Center for the History of Political Economy hope.econ.duke.edu/2024-summer-institute
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Baptiste Gianeselli
@BGianeselli
💐 Le bouquet des charpentiers. La charpente de Notre-Dame est achevée !
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Clément de Chaisemartin
@CdeChaisemartin
Wow, Esther Duflo is becoming the new head of PSE!
Thomas Piketty
@PikettyWIL
Excellente nouvelle pour l'Ecole d'économie de Paris!
www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2024/01/12/esther-duflo-p… via @lemondefr -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Martin Anota
@martin_anota
In memoriam : Brève introduction à la macroéconomie de Solow (1924-2023)
(A la marge)
blogs.alternatives-economiques.fr/anota/2024/01/04/in-mem… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
SHoET
@Societies_HET
HES at @ASSAMeeting 2024!
Below the four HES sessions at AEA/ASSA in San Antonio, TX, January 5-7, 2024
More information about the ASSA meeting can be found at www.aeaweb.org/Annual_Meeting/index.php. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Diane Marie
@Dee_Camacho
Bored in the hospital so I put all my symptoms into ChatGPT & asked it to list the most likely dx’s in order. Of course, anxiety was at the top of the list. So I ran it again but as a male pt, and to absolutely no ones surprise, anxiety wasn’t even ON the list of possible dx’s 🙃
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ethan BdM
@ethanbdm
I wrote some thoughts on the congressional hearings, free speech, leadership, and campus culture @BostonReview.
Much appreciation to Scott Ashworth, @itaisher, @jcohen570, and @mlordlordm who offered much needed feedback, pushback, and advice.
www.bostonreview.net/articles/the-future-of-speech-on-cam… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
La preuve que Paris c'est le Mordor
Guillaume Ncld
@ordrespontane
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's time to say it again
econ textbook present selected *ideas* as if they were obvious, w/o underlying rationale or context
Reading past econ work + history tells you context, modeling motives (society's demands, tractability, data availability...), practices, and debates
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
It's time to say it again:
There is no need to read the classics because the textbook treatments of their ideas are perfectly sufficient.
Have you ever met a physicist who said that you should read Newton's Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica?Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A reminiscence piece, an obit, a tribute, are subjective pieces (that's actually the point)
thinking interview=history is just like thinking correlation=causation
An interview is a bunch of (sometimes fun, deep, informative, provoking) data, collected with biais, so...
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...the closest to your interviewees and the less trained in oral history, the more biased the (fun rich fascinating) data
I'll stop there, not a good time for these convos, the year has been tough on everyone. Have a nice holiday all -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's finally out, and if you need one introductory book to the history of economics, it's this one
www.penguin.co.uk/books/23148/the-penguin-history-of-econ… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
Maybe but only if the list of textbooks also includes textbooks on the history of economic thought.
The main issue with reading classics is that it takes so much time to read one, so you end up only reading a few and know too little about the other ones. It’s just not time efficient.
The main issue with just reading textbooks is that you do not understand context and meaning, and you end up stuck in paradigms.
The right balance is to read books about the history of economic and political thoughts. And maybe a few classics once in a while to know what it looks like.
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
It's time to say it again:
There is no need to read the classics because the textbook treatments of their ideas are perfectly sufficient.
Have you ever met a physicist who said that you should read Newton's Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
INEM
@EconMethodology
The Third Lake Como INEM Summer School in Philosophy of Economics will be held in Como, Italy, June 23-28, 2024. PhD students, young scholars (PhD degree obtained after January 2020), and advanced master students are welcome to apply via the website ebmp2024.lakecomoschool.org
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jean-Marc Vittori
@jmvittori
Proportions d'étrangers à Toulouse School of Economics, indiquées par son directeur général @CGollier:
30%▶️enseignants-chercheurs
40%▶️étudiants en master
86% ▶️doctorants
Conclusion: "la loi du 19 décembre met en danger les institutions académiques françaises." -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Princeton Economics
@PrincetonEcon
In March we had the privilege of hosting Bob Solow for a conversation w/ Orley Ashenfelter. Solow spoke dynamically about his early life, dropping out of Harvard to join the Army, & much more.
Our thoughts are with his family, friends, & colleagues.
🎙️ irs100.princeton.edu/podcasts/robert-solow-2023 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Eli Cook
@Eli_B_Cook
Exactly. That's what I love studying the history of economic thought. You have to figure out why certain ideas "stuck" when they did and it's almost never simply because they actually explained society in a much better way!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"I am not terribly impressed with people who aren't economists, not all of those either.
Stigler doesn't take his laisser faire dead seriously every minute of the day
Milton Friedman is of course just the opposite. Not a saving spark of humor in him" (Solow to Samuelson, 1957) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Solow discussing Econometrica's next editor with Hahn, 1967:
"if blandness is a desirable characteristic for an editor, those two [Frank Fisher and Dale Jorgenson] leave something to be desired. Either of them could ruffle the feathers of an alligator." -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Solow's archives are 95% hangouts.
Reflecting on how to disseminate mathematical econ in 1952, in a time of resistance:
"no matter how hard you try you can't make modern music sound like my Old Kentucky Home" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Having fun re-reading the Solow-Robinson correspondence. Excerpts:
(note 1: just gossiping here. For serious account of relationships between 2 Cambridges over 30y, see paulromer.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/History-of-Polit…)
(note 2: why is the only pic of young Robinson so gendered?) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Come on, now. Nobody ever claimed that prices could generally be derived from the equation of physical production alone"
(Solow to Robinson, 1960) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Back to the fray. Every time I think we're getting to understand each other, you go all oracular on me again."
(Solow to Robinson, 1960) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is Solow's wrap up of the 1978 Fed conference in which Lucas & Sargent presented "after Keynesian macro" (topic was "After Phillips curve")
"The discussion is very abstract...the bullets are real and they may soon be fired at you by the Federal Reserve" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Great new paper by Jeff Biddle on the origins of the CES production function:
www.researchgate.net/publication/342612626_The_Origins_of… [open access]
with cool archival material with Arrow/Minhas/Chenery and Solow coming together, and the independent discovery by Swan... -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
who needs an art quote when Solow has given us a "model-as-sneakers" one?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Solow-Baumol 1991 op-ed was written in response to an WSJ article accusing guidelines to avid racists & sexist bias in econ of "political correctedness"
Handwritten note by Baumol: "it is he who has adopted the shrill tone & overheated language of the intellectual terrorist"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"As the unemployment rate of white teenagers rises, that of black teenagers rises abt twice as much. How a discussion of unemployment claim to be reasonably complete if it ignores this painful fact"
This was written in 1991 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
How to start a referee report:
"It makes me feel like the sailor in the ladies' Turkish bath -- I hardly know where to begin"
(Solow, 1961) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"I need only listen to Milton Friedman talk for a minute and my mind floods with thoughts of increasing returns to scale, oligopolistic interdependence...intergenerational inequity...There is almost no cure for it, except to listen for a minute to JK Galbraith...." (Solow, 1980)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1968-1975 saw momentum in urban econ theory, resulting in special issue in Bell journal in 1973
The introductory survey essay, by Mills & McKinnon, carried a Solow epigraph:
"all theory depends on assumptions which are not quite true. That is what makes it theory" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"There is a long-standing tension in eco- nomics between belief in the advantages of the market mechanism and awareness of its imperfections...There is a large element of Rohrschach test in the way each of us responds to this tension" (Solow, 1980)
www.jstor.org/stable/1814733?seq=1 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
SHoET
@Societies_HET
#hes2024 The HES will hold its 51st meeting (and 50th anniversary of the founding of the Society) from July 14 to 18, 2024 at the Universidad del Desarrollo, in Santiago, Chile. We invite individual paper and session submissions through our website.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
franceinfo
@franceinfo
Projet de loi immigration : "C'est une catastrophe", s'indigne la communauté de l'enseignement supérieur
www.francetvinfo.fr/societe/immigration/reportage-projet-… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sarah Wolfolds
@SarahWolfolds
My mission to secure the program of the Third World Congress of the Econometric Society in 1975 in Toronto has hit an impasse. You can see below I have the tentative program, but I need the detailed program. Anyone have a lead?? Thanks!!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Etienne Wasmer
@EtienneWasmer
Philippe Martin est parti. C’était inattendu et c’est un sentiment de tristesse et d’injustice qui domine. Il avait énormément contribué aux débats économiques en France et en Europe, avec un sens exceptionnel de la synthèse et de justesse des diagnostics. Plusieurs notes du Conseil d’Analyse Economique, qu’il a dirigé de nombreuses années, marquent notre époque et conditionnent nos politiques économiques. Notamment celles avec Alain Trannoy, celles avec Thierry Mayer, son collègue proche, à qui j’adresse mes plus sincères condoléances, ainsi qu’à ses proches, ses collègues de Sciences Po et tous les étudiants. Un talent rare chez Philippe était son sens du collectif et sa capacité d’animation. Sciences Po lui doit énormément. Voyage en paix, mon ami
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Xavier Jaravel
@XJaravel
C’est avec une immense tristesse que j’apprends ce soir la disparition de Philippe Martin. Nous savons tous qu’il était un brillant professeur d’économie et qu’il a beaucoup œuvré pour rapprocher la science économique des politiques publiques, notamment au @CAEinfo
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sciences Po
@sciencespo
Sciences Po a la grande douleur de faire part du décès de Philippe Martin.
Économiste brillant et reconnu, doyen de l'@EAPScPo depuis février 2022, il fut une figure éminente de notre institution, dont il était diplômé et à laquelle il consacra une partie de sa carrière. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nicola Giocoli
@ngiocoli
FYI @Societies_HET @economicthought @AISPE_2021 @Undercoverhist @EdoardoPeruzzi1
Uskali Mäki: Homo Economicus │ ReSES AD Lecture
reses-argumenta.fi?p=1000 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andrej Svorenčík
@ASvorencik
Honest Q: Could someone pls explain why is the scientific committee of @EFA_org European Finance Association's 2024 meeting entirely made up of Chicago economists? #diversity And what is the Track Chairs' role? #econtwitter efa2024.efa-meetings.org/submission/program-committee/
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maria Bach
@mvsbach
And last but not least, my baby, my book!
Forthcoming in 2024 with @CambridgeUP
Relocating Development Economics: The first generation of modern Indian economists
(a few are pictured below)
I am both super excited and terrified to hear what you all think! -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1972:
-AEA administration: "dear @AEACSWEP chair, we promised to organize childcare at next meeting in 3 months"
-Carolyn Shall Bell : "why do you think I or any of my Committee has any particular responsibility. True, women bear children. Men also have something to do w/ it" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Job market candidates: thank you to everyone who applied. So many impressive applications. We have now scheduled our full first batch of interviews for next week
If you haven’t been called, do not read anything into it. Hiring is about finding best fit, lots of idiosyncracies
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
🚨We at @CrestUmr are hiring🚨
we have several positions at assistant/associate level, any field econjobmarket.org/positions/9867
Our lab results from the merger of the dpts of econ of @polytechnique (France’s 1er engineering school) and @ENSAEparis (which trains public statisticians)... -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
publishing a history paper in a "general interest" economic journal
David
@paskana_
what do you think is harder than this?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Goes both in the introduction of my
"data are socially constructed: a history"
and my
"is economics ideological: how economists have discussed the problem"
lectures
Wojtek Kopczuk 🇵🇱🇺🇦 and 🇺🇲
@wwwojtekk
Who said that economics is not exciting?
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2023/11/30/income… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Salut @SNCFVoyageurs, ton site de déclaration de perte d'objet dans un train est en dérangement. Tu peux faire quelque chose ? Merci !
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
All open access (as always in Oeconomia)
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's finally out, and if you need one introductory book to the history of economics, it's this one
www.penguin.co.uk/books/23148/the-penguin-history-of-econ…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(the updated version of Roger Backhouse's classic)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Michael White
@MWClimateSci
I’ve handled the review of > 1000 papers at @nature. Over time, you notice aspects of presentation on which reviewers tend to comment. In the interests of minimizing hassles during review, I offer the following suggestions (a bit targeted to climate papers).
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Vous êtes vieux comment?
j'étais obligé de mendier des figurines à crayon Kiki phosphorescentes à mes copines car mes parents n'achetaient pas de lessive bonux
Alexandre Delaigue
@adelaigue
Le numéro de téléphone de mes parents avait 6 chiffres
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Rustam Jamilov
@RustamJamilov
😌
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Interesting approach!
Darwyyn Deyo
@darwyyndeyo
Heading to #sea2023 and need something to read on the plane that's a little different? You can now read my working paper identifying 163 #womenineconomics, whose work dates back to 1918, using citations from the #nobelprizeecon lectures over @SSRN! #econtwitter
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Just read 160 such recs yesterday and cannot agree more. Recruiters don't just look for quality to make their short-lists. They look for quality conditional on likeliness to come to their institution. So applicants need to be mindful about signals they're sending (or not sending)
Martin Halla
@HallaMartin
#econjobmarket — I am really surprised by the significant percentage of cover letters that are completely canned (& even misname the job posting institution etc.) It takes very little effort to tailor a CL to a specific job posting/institution. Given the sheer volume of
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Charlie Joyez
@cjoyez
Which very famous economist could start a paper in 1953 by quoting in French a recipe cookbook ? (Few hints remain)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Christoph Niemann
@abstractsunday
My cover for today's A.I. issue of The New Yorker
more: www.christophniemann.com/detail/nyercover/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andrej Svorenčík
@ASvorencik
Reminder: the deadline for submitting abstracts for the next HISRECO conference is this Wednesday (Nov 15)!
The 16th History of Recent Economics Conference will be held at the UPenn in Philadelphia on May 3-4, 2024. hisreco.wordpress.com/2023/06/21/call-for-papers-16th-his…
@P_G_Duarte @Societies_HET -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
DSE UniBo Economics
@DSE_Unibo
The DSE at Unibo is looking for tenure-track assistant professors, preferentially in the areas of Microeconomic Theory, Macroeconomics, and Environmental Economics. We will interview candidates at the European Job Market for Economists. Application: econjobmarket.org/positions/10196.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
“Gender differences in graduate student views on the professional climate in economics"
by Ann Mari May, Mary G. McGarvey, Muazzam Toshmatova
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/coep.12630 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Le Monde
@lemondefr
Jeune chercheuse ou chercheur, à quoi rêvez-vous ? www.lemonde.fr/sciences/appel-temoignages/2023/11/13/jeun…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
3. People vastly overestimate gender bias in hiring decisions: They overestimate how much gender bias women face in male-dominated and gender-balanced fields, and they overestimate how much gender bias men face in female-dominated fields.
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/fifty-years-of-gender-bias -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Just sent an email to a Nobel econ, who probably wrote an entire paper while I was drafting and redrafting my email.
This is reminded me of this cartoon #foreverastudent
I have a second one to write. See you in 3 days.Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This last straw is a perfect illustration of how the whole week went. I should call it quits I think
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2nd update: got a polite no (a first for me) in 17 words.
have a nice week! -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
CREST (UMR 9194)
@CrestUmr
🚨#econjobmarket 🎓
Does it make sense for economic agents to inform about something they want to hide?
In her #jobmarketpaper @MKirneva uncovers a new role for information provision.
👉 crest.science/opportunities-2/margarita-kirneva-job-marke…
#econtwitter #research #jmp -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
CREST (UMR 9194)
@CrestUmr
🚨#econjobmarket 🎓
What new types of markets originate from #digitalinnovation? How is technology changing #finance? @MicheleFabi90 addresses these questions in his research🌐 #fintech 🖥️ #digitaleconomics 🌍 #crowdfunding 🚀 #blockchain 🔗 #defi 📲
👉crest.science/opportunities-2/michele-fabi-job-market-can… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
CREST (UMR 9194)
@CrestUmr
🚨#econjobmarket 🎓
Curious to know more about DeFi markets? Dive into the market microstructure of these innovative markets in @MyriamKassoul's #jobmarketpaper 📈🔍 #defi #financialeconometrics #dexit
#econtwitter
👉 crest.science/opportunities-2/myriam-kassoul-job-market-c… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sandro Ambuehl
@SandroAmbuehl
What is the main role of economics journals in the 2020ies and beyond?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Martha Starr
@marthastarr_dc
this JEI article by Fred Lee has interesting historical material on 1960s-1970s: citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=c2…)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
fabio flumian
@FFlumian
What about this work by Marc Lavoie:
www.boeckler.de/pdf/v_2009_08_03_lavoie_lecture_part1.pdf -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
CREST (UMR 9194)
@CrestUmr
📢🎓✨ @CrestUmr is pleased to introduce its 2023-2024 #econjobmarket Candidates :
👉eco.crest.science/job-market-candidates/
Over the next few days we will present each of them and their #jobmarketpaper !
Stay tuned! #econtwitter
@IP_Paris_ @Polytechnique @ENSAEparis @IPParisEco @XDepEco -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Noah Kaufman
@noahqk
20 years in the making, we have a modern set of guidelines for economic analysis with a finalized Circular A-4.
I'm so proud of our government nerds. There was major pushback on the progress in the draft, and at first glance, they mostly held the line👏 www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/CircularA-4… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Asker Voldsgaard
@AskerVoldsgaard
Although it is not a history paper, your students may be interested in @exploringecon's page for exploring and comparing various schools of economic thought. The descriptions contain some historical perspectives.
www.exploring-economics.org/en/orientation/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Cambridge Economics
@CambUP_Econ
Pricing the Priceless by H. Spencer Banzhaf
This book tells how economics shifted from developing resources to valuing and incentivizing the preservation of natural environments.
📚 cup.org/46P9YKV -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Libertad González
@LibertadGonLu
I would really like to know more about this 🤔
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andrea Matranga 🇺🇦🌻
@andreamatranga
webapps.unito.it/albo_ateneo/ it's number 5412 in this list
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economics UniTO
@EconomicsUnito
One year POST-DOC position.
Project: "The economic thought of Italian female economists (1900-1950): academic career and gender barriers" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Oriol Vallès Codina
@ecoclassical
EK Hunt's book on history of econ thought is great. The problem may well be that "heterodox econ" was a label coined by Lee himself... Maybe check the work of Andrew Mearman scholar.google.co.uk/citations?hl=en&user=8DOqCxYAAAAJ
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Aaron Benanav
@abenanav
It’s a specific view, like all such views, but maybe one of the early chapters in Geoffrey Hodgson’s book about heterodox economics?
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
thanks. but the better paper is "On the Theoretical and Institutional Roots of Post-Keynesian Economics"
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2022.2091335 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Also, the authoratative history of the creation of the Cambridge Journal of Economics -- downloaded more than 3500 times.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09538259.2022.2104027 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis-Philippe Rochon
@Lprochon
Also, if interested, my paper on the history of circuit approach in France, in a forthcoming book by John King.
68b1e6b9-c0f8-4cc2-99b9-e9ecab5ea499.filesusr.com/ugd/610… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matthew T Panhans
@matthewpanhans
My absolute favorite book on this is William Coleman's Economics and Its Enemies: Two Centuries of Anti-Economics. www.amazon.com/Economics-Its-Enemies-Centuries-Anti-Econo…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Not a perfect fit, perhaps, but likely as close as you are going to get. From the master himself …
www.socscistaff.bham.ac.uk/backhouse/homepage/hmea/hmea28… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Gregory Vanel
@GregoryVanel
Geoffrey M. Hodgson (2021) Debating the Future of Heterodox Economics,
Journal of Economic Issues, 55:3, 603-614, DOI: 10.1080/00213624.2021.1945874 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
[HELP NEEDED]
Is there a 30-pages max paper that narrates the history of heterodox economics? Fred Lee has a great book, but too long for my intended use, Roger Backhouse has papers, but too focused on reactions to Samuelson.
Any other idea?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(I have plennnnnty of references on the history of various heterodox approaches - feminist, Austrian, post-Keynesian, radical, ecological, etc, so that's no what I'm looking for. I need a short "aggregate" narrative on non-mainstream perspectives)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Marion Leturcq
@MarionLeturcq
Je serai sur @franceculture dans @EntendezvousEco demain à 14h pour parler inégalités salariales 💸entre les 🚺 et les 🚹. À vos podcast ! 🎙️
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
The Ocean Cleanup
@TheOceanCleanup
"I got this chance to do something, and I am humbled that I did" - Flemming Sloth Andersen is a legend of The Ocean Cleanup. Hear his stories from over one year in the GPGP in our latest podcast: theoceancleanup.com/podcasts/offshore-legend-our-major-in…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
REMINDER: the application deadline for our job openings are in just a week (Wed Nov 15)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
🚨We at @CrestUmr are hiring🚨
we have several positions at assistant/associate level, any field econjobmarket.org/positions/9867
Our lab results from the merger of the dpts of econ of @polytechnique (France’s 1er engineering school) and @ENSAEparis (which trains public statisticians)... -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
The PPE Society
@theppesociety
Call for Papers:
Economic Methodology: Models, Measurement, and Interventions
Stanford University, March 8-9, 2024.
philevents.org/event/show/114198 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
IPCC
@IPCC_CH
📣 Call for experts
#ipcc is calling member governments and observer organizations to nominate experts to draft the outline for the Special Report on Climate Change and Cities.
Nominations should be submitted by 17 Nov 2023.
Details 🔗 www.ipcc.ch/2023/10/27/nomination-experts-climate-change-… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matéo Teixeira
@MateoTeixeira26
6/14 En février 1944 un convoi de billets est braqué, le butin s’élève à un milliard de francs en coupures de 1000 francs « type 1942 » ! La sécurité des convois est particulière en cette période…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matéo Teixeira
@MateoTeixeira26
Mon article publié dans Histoire, économie et société. On y parle de Banque de France, de faux billets et de braquages. Un thread pour résumer cela :
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
La bonne vieille blague du Bastia-Toulon transformé en Ile rousse-Nice, où l'on apprend que le port de Nice ferme, mais c'est pas grave, on débarquera cette nuit à Livourne
Corse-Matin
@Corse_Matin
Tempête Domingos : la Corse en vigilance orange "pluie inondation" ce samedi soir ⬇️
sur.corsematin.com/ZBc -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
Article: Six Decades of Economic Research at the Bank of England, by Juan Acosta, Beatrice Cherrier, François Claveau, Clément Fontan, Aurélien Goutsmedt & Francesco Sergi
read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article/56/1/1/382434/Six-Decade… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Corse-Matin
@Corse_Matin
Tempête Ciaran : après une coupure d'électricité générale de 19 heures, la pointe du Cap Corse retrouve la lumière
sur.corsematin.com/TLm -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
SHoET
@Societies_HET
The Center for the History of Political Economy at Duke University is now accepting applications for the 2024-25 Visiting Scholars program.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
FRASER
@FedFRASER
October 30, 1950: Chairman McCabe sends along this riddle to John Snyder, the Secretary of the Treasury, in hopes he "might get a chuckle from reading it" fraser.stlouisfed.org/archival/1348/item/73058
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Catherine Herfeld
@cherfeld
Here is the link to the whole special issue edited w @AGoutsmedt & @claveau_f🙏: journals.openedition.org/oeconomia/13844
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Catherine Herfeld
@cherfeld
💥Our SI on Quantitative & Computational Approaches in the Social Studies of Economics is out in OEconomia incl papers on the Gender Gap in UK econ, patterns in the literature on trust, or the state of neuroeconomics by @erinhengel @NCamilotto @alxndr_trc @ThierryRossier &others
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Making decisions about nuclear reactors, 1976
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Tyler DesRoches 🇨🇦 🇳🇱 🇺🇸🌵❤️
@desroches_tyler
📢Check out the INEM 2021 conference special issue of Journal of Economic Methodology! @EconMethodology www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/1350178X.2023.2268629
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jules Grandin
@JulesGrandin
🗺📏 Voici une carte de Corse.
Elle a l'air vraiment toute simple, et elle l'est. Mais elle nous apprend aussi beaucoup de choses si on se pose les bonnes questions.
Petit voyage au pays des échelles, des fractales cartographiques et du trait de côte ⬇️ -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"If we cannot reliably judge how potential geophysical changes will affect civilization, can we use the plain vanilla cost-benefit analysis (or even the Haagen Dazs variety in dynamic optimization models)?"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is a quote from William Nordhaus's 1994 IIASA piece with a very cool title
His answer to the question above was yes -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Julien Pain
@JulienPain
Nous publions aujourd’hui une tribune dans @lemondefr pour appeler à une journée sans Twitter le 27 octobre, date de la prise de contrôle du réseau par E. Musk. RT si vous voulez participer.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Oeconomicus
@Oeconomicus_fr
🗣️ "La question de la démographie est cruciale, car elle influe sur le plan macroéconomique." Découvrez l'analyse approfondie de Pauline Rossi (@Polytechnique @cepr_org @CrestUmr) dans son interview avec @Pierre__Rx dans Oeconomicus
👉oeconomicus.fr/economie-du-developpement-et-demographie-l… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
We received close to 600 applications from across 🇮🇳!!! 😯💥🙌🏽
It was totally unexpected & sadly only limited spots were available. But the demand for HET is truly inspiring. 🦋
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
Super happy to share this workshop announcement @MIDS_Chennai for HET teachers & students. Looking forward to seeing several of you there.
Apply here: www.mids.ac.in/assets/doc/HET-Nov-2023.pdf
@Societies_HET @rethinkecon_in @KNRajEconClub -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Irwin Collier
@irwincollier
A Golden Oldie from Economics in the Rear-view Mirror. The script of The Wizard of E52 performedby the graduate inmates of MIT. My cowardly lion stole the show. www.irwincollier.com/mit-the-wizard-of-e52-383c-grad-stud…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Congrats to Herrade Igersheim, Michele Alacevich, Gianluca Damiani and Annie Cot for winning best paper, book, dissertation and distinguished fellow @AISPE_2021 awards tonight
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Rawls and the econmists: the (im)possible dialogue.
Super cool paper by Herrade Igersheim
www.cairn.info/revue-economique-2022-6-page-1013.htm?cont… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Dr. Juliette
@FerryDanini
Mon livre "Pilules roses" sort mercredi ✨ ! C'est une enquête philosophique et historique sur le Spasfon, un médicament prescrit par millions en France, en majorité à des femmes et sur la base de... pas grand chose.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Markus K. Brunnermeier
@MarkusEconomist
Webinar @LHSummers and @DeatonAngus on “Is Economic Failure a failure of EconomicS”. youtu.be/4rbCC6GWC_8 via @YouTube
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Fall 2023 competition so far
Conference ceiling 2 - my slides 0
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
When your conference slides are competing with the ceiling for attention
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Maha Ali
@MahaAliUqaili
At the ‘Association for the History of Economic Thought’ Conference in Palermo, where Beatrice Cherrier @Undercoverhist, in her keynote address, speaks about “centers and peripheries”, decolonizing economic thinking and resituating women in the history of economic thought.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Reviewer 2, circa 1150
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Talk prep with a view
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
AISPE
@AISPE_2021
Non vediamo l'ora!
Economic thought
@economicthought
Conference: check the program of AISPE SISE upcoming conference
Palermo, Italy, October 19-21
www.aispe.eu/it/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/ProgrammaConve… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Antoine Levy
@LevyAntoine
C’est l’histoire d’un économiste, d’un historien et d’un politiste qui rentrent dans un bar et s’y mettent à trois pour lire le travail de Julia Cagé et Thomas Piketty sur le conflit politique legrandcontinent.eu/fr/2023/10/15/pourquoi-vote-t-on-une-…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Dr.Bagarre
@docteurbagarre
Pas mal de tweets tournent en mode " ça me rend fou, pourquoi personne est intervenu face au mec au couteau "
Il faut donc rappeler quelques petites choses -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Dr. Serge Zaka (Dr. Zarge)
@SergeZaka
La France vient de battre sont 2525ème (!) record de chaleur mensuel de 2023 (contre seulement 26 de froid🙄) avec 31.0°C à Strasbourg, un 13 octobre bon sang ! C'est 15°C au-dessus des normes. Cet OVNI statistique repousse de 21 jours les 30°C les plus tardifs ! 21 jours !
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"NPR Traffic has dropped by only 1% point as a result of leaving Twitter"
Meanwhile, opening X is getting piles of war disinformation, unwanted videos of French teachers slaughtered live, of butchered Israeli & bombed Gazaoui
See you under bluer sky?
niemanreports.org/articles/npr-twitter-musk/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
New book: A History of Economic Thought in France, edited by Gilbert Faccarello & Claire Silvant
www.amazon.com/History-Economic-Thought-France-Routledge/… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Tyler DesRoches 🇨🇦 🇳🇱 🇺🇸🌵❤️
@desroches_tyler
Great blog post by my @ASU_SOS @ASUCollegeofGF colleague, Diane Pataki.
"5 steps for turning climate anxiety into meaningful action"
www.greeningscience.info/post/5-steps-for-turning-climate… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Antoine Levy
@LevyAntoine
We're recruiting at Haas - come join our great urban economics and real estate group!
aprecruit.berkeley.edu/JPF04084 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Lukas Freund
@_LukasFreund_
Thanks! Very good articles indeed.
I randomly got into a rabbit role regarding the history of economic thought, setting aside the content: If and how did the work initially published in Japanese, by Morishima, influence English-language research (and perhaps later En->Jpn)? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Lukas Freund
@_LukasFreund_
#econtwitter: Does anyone know if there's an English version of Morishima's (1967) "A few suggestions of the theory of elasticity"? I've only seen references to the Japanese version published in Keizai Hyoron.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Entendez-vous l'éco ?
@EntendezvousEco
🏆 Claudia Goldin, pionnière de l'économie féministe, a reçu en début de semaine le prix Nobel d'économie pour ses travaux sur l'évolution de l'accès des Américaines au marché du travail.
👉 On en parle avec @HelenePerivier, Céline Bessière et @ClemVaneff. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Entre-Temps
@entre_temps_cdf
[#creer]
Que répondre au romancier qui demande cmt faire sauter un pont en 1940 ? 🤔Ds "L'historienne et le romancier", Camille Cleret évoque pour ET son travail avec Pierre Lemaitre🤓. Dans un 1er épisode elle revient sur l'origine de cette collaboration
entre-temps.net/lhistorienne-et-le-romancier-les-arcanes-… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
In 1984, Stanford economists tried to hire someone in "feminist studies", by which they in fact meant "gender economics." The search committee concluded that "two names came to the top of the list"
Which ones, and on which criteria were their work evaluated? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Edoardo Peruzzi
@EdoardoPeruzzi1
My paper 'Models on Trial: Antitrust Experts Face Daubert Challenges' is out in the Journal of Economic Methodology.
I studied the application of economic models in legal cases and their evaluation under Daubert standard.
50 free online copies here: www.tandfonline.com/eprint/8R5G2VJDH88DURSKTV57/full?targ… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A hack when you're a shy student from average program unable to talk to professors at conferences is to send email questions a few days ahead
Often, professor will respond saying how well they cut through core of the issue & do you want to me to discuss them during conference
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
maybe it only works in small unprestigious communities like history of econ, but works there and probably in a few others fields.
Other hacks include reading Calvin and Hobbes comics during breaks or playing with a Rubik's cube, but these should be used with caution
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(do you want to *meet*)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Branko Milanovic
@BrankoMilan
"Visions of Inequality" is today officially out. October 10.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
N. Emrah Aydınonat
@aydinonat
Tomorrow! 👇
Send an email to contact@reses-argumenta.fi to receive the Zoom link!
ReSES - Rethinking the Serviceability of Economics
@ReSESargumenta
ReSES ID Seminar on 11.10.2023
California Dreamin’: Economists Become Expert Epistemologists for Platform Capitalism
Edward Nik-Khah (@RoanokeCollege)
Discussant: Béatrice Cherrier (@Undercoverhist, @CNRS, @CrestUmr, @Xdepeco)
🔥Get ready for a friendly yet heated debate!
✉️To join us: contact@reses-argumenta.fi
reses-argumenta.fi?p=913 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Great quote by Koopmans on tractability traps (or trampolines?), wish I had remembered it earlier
"Tools...may even come to dominate an entire period or school of thought. Our servants may thus become our guides, for better or for worse, depending on the accidents of the case" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
That's part of it. Also another distinction is between people who take technology as given and want prices to reallocate; and people who want to shift that technology
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
In general there’s a bit of a divide between “static” optimization folks who believe more in the role of product prices to allocate scarce goods; and “dynamic” optimizers who care more about inter temporal pricing and innovation
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Tyler DesRoches 🇨🇦 🇳🇱 🇺🇸🌵❤️
@desroches_tyler
This might help when thinking about deontological reasoning and formal models of environmental decision making www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00048402.2016.1182196
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Présentation de l'ouvrage aujourd'hui de 17h30 à 19h pour le séminaire H2M (histoire macro et monnaie)
Ca se passe en salle 114 de la Maison des Sciences Economiques.
Quoi de mieux pour terminer la semaine en beauté?
Thomas Angeletti
@ThAngeletti
Mon enquête sur l'invention de l'économie française est désormais disponible dans toutes les bonnes librairies !
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2 questions:
1) Is there any history of how and why some economists have gone more into abatement vs mitigation vs adaptation research on carbon emissions ?
(or maybe most specialists of the topic did research on all three, separately, or at the same time?)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is one longstanding pillars of how to interpret time-discounting in econ models
Has any econ written models relying on assumption that future generations are likely to be less wealthy (not as a policy, as in degrowth, as a fact. Not just in env research, maybe war related?)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(and no, I'm not a millenarist for asking this. these are serious research questions)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Prof. Ryan Katz-Rosene
@ryankatzrosene
This year’s insane heat has coincided with (perhaps driven?) a bit of a wedge between two leading “climate urgency science narratives”…
🧵 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Eddie and I disagree on pretty much everything on the history of market design, but we always disagree joyfully. This is going to be a fun conversation
N. Emrah Aydınonat
@aydinonat
Exciting ReSES ID Seminar next week!
Speaker: Edward Nik-Khah (@RoanokeCollege) Discussant: Béatrice Cherrier (@Undercoverhist,
@CNRS, @CrestUmr, @Xdepeco)
🔥Get ready for a friendly yet heated debate! :)
ℹ️reses-argumenta.fi?p=913
✉️To join us: contact@reses-argumenta.fi -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A very important epistemological questions that pervades a lot of work by economists working on topics with explicit ethical underpinnings currently
Nicolas Treich
@Treich13
Agreed (and @EspinosaRomain and I often have had this remark). One problem is that we aim for quantification, because we want to explore some tradeoffs (eg, more for animals, less for humans). Should we forget quantifification using deontological or virtue ethics? If not, how?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Long time ago, working on 1st paper as grad student
Advisor: "I see you don't have footnotes in your draft. Why?"
me: "that's bc I don't understand what they are for"
Advisor (laughter, then kind voice): "keep writing and don't worry, you'll find soon enough"
He was so right -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nicolas Treich
@Treich13
1 ANTHROPOCENTRISM
This is a problem, and a blindspot, in economics (and in other disciplines)
It is time to go beyond anthropocentrism, and it is possible
A thread to explain why -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Daniel Steinmetz-Jenkins
@daniel_dsj2110
Job: Assistant Professor in Hegel: www.higheredjobs.com/faculty/details.cfm?JobCode=17855878…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Call for Papers: Special Issue of the European Economic Review in memory of Nora Szech
Deadline: Dec 16 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Fed Reserve History
@FedHistory
Keep up with our latest updates right on the Fed History site with our What's New page www.federalreservehistory.org/whats_new
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Isn't this horrible new feature just meant to generate engagement and clicks (if only to see what the article linked is about, its title), hence revenue for those who monetize their account?
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
.@elonmusk really, don’t do this. X users have developed a language, a protocol, for referencing article headers and this breaks the language and makes communication more difficult
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Economic thought
@economicthought
Workshop: "The Wealth of Notions" in Economic Thought: Teaching & Research
November 27 - 28 2023
Turin, Italy
ysi.ineteconomics.org/project/64f9ca09a6143e02e18536a9/ev… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
🚨We at @CrestUmr are hiring🚨
we have several positions at assistant/associate level, any field econjobmarket.org/positions/9867
Our lab results from the merger of the dpts of econ of @polytechnique (France’s 1er engineering school) and @ENSAEparis (which trains public statisticians)...Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
We have amazing students (2022/23 placement x.com/CdeChaisemartin/status/1639243190384357381)
Email/DM me or any of the colleagues around (@UhlendorffA @aless_riboni @matiasnunez17 @pierrecboyer @CombeJu @rolandrathelot @ricco_giovanni @BGarbinti @SaraSgnr @LeroutierM) if you have any questions
Clément de Chaisemartin
@CdeChaisemartin
The placement of econ grad students from
@ENSAEparis @CrestUmr is astonishing: @PaulineCarry at @PrincetonEcon, Germain Gauthier at @Unibocconi, @martin_mugnier at @PSEinfo, @ElioNimier at @CornellEcon, and there may be more... Congrats!!!
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
also @O_Goss_ (if he hasn't fully moved to bluer skies) for questions on the theory group at CREST. Who else around on twitter did I forgot?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This post on motherhood and academia by @rsfrankl is so beautiful
"This tug-of-war between motherhood (and domesticity) and independance has been the most enduring tension in my adult life"
rachelfranklin.substack.com/p/bringing-up-babies -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"what is a field?" interesting take by Jeffrey Lockhart on a question I've long struggled with (HT @CleoCZ )
scatter.wordpress.com/2022/01/12/what-is-a-field/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Arne Uhlendorff
@UhlendorffA
#econtwitter, the Econ department of @IP_Paris_ @CrestUmr is looking for Assistant and Associate Professors in Economics.
Applicants from all fields are welcome!
econjobmarket.org/positions/9867
Email me if you have any question about the positions! -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
CREST (UMR 9194)
@CrestUmr
🎉 Exciting News! 🎉
@SaraSgnr has recently joined CREST and @Polytechnique as Assistant Professor of Economics. We are thrilled to have her as part of our team!
Fields of Research:
Labor Economics, Public Economics, Technological Change, Migration
#newhire #welcometotheteam -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/n Les discussions autour du nouveau Cagé-Piketty et du vote rural rejouent de récentes controverses montrant le gouffre méthodologique qui sépare les historiens et les économistes qui travaillent sur l'histoire politique française
Dans l'obs, www.nouvelobs.com/opinions/20231003.OBS79001/cage-et-pike…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2/2 comme un echo d'une controverse de 2021 sur les liens entre les combattants de Verdun et le soutien au régime de Vichy (HT @BrissetNicolas1)
devhist.hypotheses.org/3921
Dans les deux cas, les historien.n.e.s parlent mesure et quantification, les économistes répondent économétrie
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(débats auxquels il faut ajouter une couche un peu floue mais bien présente de passe d'armes sur l'imperalisme méthodologique des économistes, qui ne va pas sans rappeler les années 1970 et 1980 aux US...)
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The Miyazaki-Malm crossover I didn't expect: "So now instead of painstakingly animating a beautiful metaphor for environmentalism, my next big project will be detonating an improvised pipe bomb on the load-bearing walls of a sheet metal plant in Amazon"
hard-drive.net/hd/entertainment/hayao-miyazaki-cutesy-mov… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Bruno Palier
@BPalier
Pour les professions au chevet du travail
A votre disposition en DM pour organiser événements. 60 contributeurs prêts à venir présenter leurs travaux!
@SouffrTravail @Anact_ @istnf @INRSfrance @cgt_tefp @direcctefrance -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
@ivanboldyrev.bsky.social
@Ivan_A_Boldyrev
#sociologyofeconomics
press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691247625/economi… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
mon rêve de gosse, c'était de devenir Jedi, mais c'est tres tres cool quand même
Gilles Raveaud
@RaveaudGilles
Les amis de Blast m'ont permis de vivre un rêve de gosse : ma petite émission d'économie à moi. Ils et elles ont fait un travail de dingue. Cela dure 15 mn. J'espère que ça vous intéressera. @blast_france❤️
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Tyler DesRoches 🇨🇦 🇳🇱 🇺🇸🌵❤️
@desroches_tyler
Good news story by @KHayhoe
Global emissions are turning the corner www.talkingclimate.ca/p/global-emissions-are-turning-the -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Out next week. Timely.
Katalin Kariko
@kkariko
Happening now! Barnes & Noble Rewards and Premium Members get 25% off preorders between Sep 6-8. Premium Members get an additional 10% off physical books. Preorder your copy of BREAKING THROUGH now! Use code PREORDER25 at checkout. www.barnesandnoble.com/w/breaking-through-katalin-karik/1…
#bnpreorder @BNBuzz -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Richard H Thaler
@R_Thaler
The work that won today's Nobel in medicine (and saved millions of lives) "was summarily rejected by the journals Nature and Science". Keep trying. Journals are often resistant to new ideas.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Robert Bigg
@RobertBigg
Hansen proofs have finally arrived! That gives a sense of reality, but nonetheless still scary to turn them round in time! In the meantime here’s the cover and contents to whet your appetite🤞…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Zoé Ziani, Ph.D.
@ZoeZiani
Yes... I had to censor my work without which my committee wouldn't sign it... But the great thing with Internet is that you can post the original version and even add a disclaimer explaining why it differs from the published version…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Historic Vids
@historyinmemes
This is Marion Stokes, a Philadelphia librarian who began taping whatever was on television from 1975 until her death in 2012. She made a total of 71,000 VHS and Betamax tapes, which is the most comprehensive collection of television during this era.
She was able to pay for her recordings and storage space by investing early in Apple stock. Although she had never sent a single email, she managed to convince her friends and family to purchase Apple stock. Towards the end of her life, she had made so much money that she was able to store her tapes in nine apartments she had purchased over the years.
According to film director Matt Wolf, Marion Stokes "was interested in access to information, documenting media, making sure people had the information they needed to make good decisions."
Due to her political activism in her early years, Stokes was convinced that the government was keeping surveillance on her every move, and she became extremely cautious about her recordings.
She had every right to be paranoid as she lived through the Philadelphia MOVE bombing in 1985, in which the FBI and Philadelphia police used a helicopter to drop bombs during an armed standoff with MOVE members. The bombs started a fire that eventually destroyed 61 houses and killed 11 people.
Her work is currently being digitized by the Internet Archive, a non-profit library of millions of free books, movies, software, music, websites, and more. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
. @nicolasbrisset defended his habilitation, and his views for the future of history of econ with great poise, intellectual maturity, erudition and commitment. Future HET grad students are lucky to have him onboard
Patrice Bougette
@PBougette
Nicolas Brisset (@BrissetNicolas1) soutient son HDR intitulée "Pour une histoire sociale de la pensée économique" @Univ_CotedAzur @GREDEG_UMR @CNRS_DR20 @EUR_ELMI @mdpl06 @Undercoverhist @AnnieLouCot
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
What kind of information on climate change do people need?
See below in responses
Zoë Schlanger
@zoeschlanger
I start at @TheAtlantic next week covering climate change. I'd love to know what kind of stories you'd like to read, and what questions you'd like to see answered.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
All current & former @AEAInformation members who received a reminder today to fill the
2nd AEA Member Survey on the Professional Climate in Economics
PLEASE take 10 minutes to do so. AEA leadership needs to take stock, understand where we are and what still needs to be done -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Shit our chronology is wrong, episode 2941
Nature Portfolio
@NaturePortfolio
An ancient wooden structure found at Kalambo Falls, Zambia—dated to about 476,000 years ago—may represent the earliest use of wood in construction, according to a paper in @Nature. go.nature.com/44VppPL
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Daniel J. Nicholson
@NicholsonHPBio
One of my intellectual idols passed away yesterday. Nobody has managed to integrate the history and philosophy of biology as effectively and as elegantly as Evelyn Fox Keller. Her work from the 90s/00s is unrivalled and has long served as a model and inspiration for my own. RIP.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The only thing holding me back from completely moving to the other place is the lack of DMs to further public convos, that some of my fav people here haven't moved yet and also that @AgnesCallard is now into Zola, but only on twitter it seems
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Martin Lenz
@Going_Loopy
Justin Smith-Ruiu in a great conversation with @AgnesCallard on Émile Zola
www.the-hinternet.com/p/in-conversation-with-agnes-callard -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
For those who care, I seem to now also be @spydermed (etc) at the place where the sky is blue.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
L'espace, impensé de l'économie, épisode 274495
metropolitiques.eu/Une-histoire-du-conflit-politique-sans… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Sabina Leonelli
@SabinaLeonelli
Women’s Caucus #epsa23 elects Maria Jimenez-Buedo as new Senior Co-Chair, succeeding amazing @johannamthoma1 and flanking brilliant @AzitaChellappoo - great to see the Caucus continuing in great hands, and grateful for their fundamental work in improving our working environment
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Archives centers who don't propose paid archives scanning services, know that a lot of us here have administrations that allow us to pay for *services* from institutional vendors but not *wages* abroad. "Hire a local student to do the scanning" is therefore not an option
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
And assuming we have the money, transatlantic flights to copy three folders here and there is not the best use of our carbon budgets
(so frustrating) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I've been thinking about it for 6 months and I still don't understand how to characterize Koopmans's argument for discounting
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Nathan Tankus
@NathanTankus
I finally read @D_Kuehn paper yesterday.I can't emphasize enough how incredible it is. It's one of the best history of economics papers I've ever read. It's amazing reading whether from the econ point of view,the left wing history point of view or simply the Angela Davis fan PoV
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
the art of introducing your econ theory case study
cmu.edu/dietrich/sds/docs/loewenstein/mountaineering.pdf
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
from this gem:
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Great summary by @rgbetancourt of a collective trend, in history of economics, toward exploring and taking more systematically into account the work of women in economics
Institute for New Economic Thinking
@INETeconomics
Rebeca Gomez Betancourt @univ_lyon2 explores the rich legacy of women in economics
👉youtu.be/ws5C_abtn9g👀
These pioneering women not only advocated for equality in the workplace but also emphasized the national economic benefits of involving women in labor spaces
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
one exemple among others, just from this week, is @CleoCZ and @AGoutsmedt's work on Barbara Bergmann's marginalized path into the microfoundations of macroeconomics, leading her to develop microsimulation models to study distribution effect of policies
osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/ynmbe/ -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Economist trying to find the right example, 1960s (Tullock here)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Matt Binder
@MattBinder
update: more than 53,500 users joined Bluesky yesterday, setting a record for new signups on the site in a single-day
roughly 5% of Bluesky's entire user base joined the platform just 24 hours after Elon Musk said he would charge all Twitter / X users a fee to use the service
Matt Binder
@MattBinder
one day after Elon Musk said he would start charging all users for X, Bluesky is seeing its biggest single-day in new user signups mashable.com/article/bluesky-record-new-signups-after-mus…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Hey, I think that’s me!
(It is hard to tell, though, as there is not a word about a certain theorem in the paper.)
Economic thought
@economicthought
Article: Theorising public expenditures: welfare theorems, market failures, and the turn from “public finance” to “public economics”, by Steven G. Medema
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09672567.2023.2248320 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
How Nobel committees think about scientific credit
vs
how historians of science write about scientific credit -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Simon Bowmaker
@SimonBowmaker
In the 1970s, PhD programs in economics in the US abandoned the requirement that students take a course in the history of economic thought. Steve Medema’s take in 2009 on the costs to the profession of that decision:
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Bullshit in the Sustainability and Transitions Literature:
a Provocation, by Julian Kirchher
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s43615-022-00175-9 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A paper that raises tons of interesting questions on how scientific credit is and should be assigned in different disciplines, including economics
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
just wrote 3p of long convoluted multi-verb adverb-overpopulated French sentences to say
"writing histories of economists under Vichy is badass, difficult, needed and overdue. This historian should be allowed to supervise PHD students"
What are we academics doing to ourselves? -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Gregory Claeys
@gregclaeys
La raison pour laquelle je partage cette nouvelle aussi tôt est que @Strategie_Gouv est déjà à la recherche d'un directeur adjoint du département pour me seconder dans mon nouveau rôle. Les détails du poste et qualifications requises sont dispo ici : www.strategie.gouv.fr/offre-demploi/adjointe-directeur-de… 3/N
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
OSINT goes to economics
Jesse Nickles
@jessuppi
I believe in EJMR's right to exist, and I believe in David's right to be a flaming coward. I don't think ISPs or web hosts or governments should be involved in regulating speech, but I also believe in the right of other people to expose his identity, and level the playing field.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Sometimes we seem to act as if people just rolled out of bed one morning and decided to write/invent X. That is seldom how science works. On vNM, the historical analysis of Robert Leonard and of Juan Carvajalino is very instructive. (2/2)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Shengwu Li
@ShengwuLi
Having angered the humanities-econs, let me now anger their complement.
I think that every PhD student should learn about the history of economic thought. Either by reading primary texts or by reading the work of relevant historians. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Jim Carrey's impersonation of some economists is, I have to confess, on point
(we need more Denzel Washingtons in our field) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The Discovery of the Faustmann Formula (which seemingly should be the Houghton formula, and which is sometimes credited as the origin of discounting in econ) in Natural Resource Economics, by Esa-Jussi Viitala [gated] read.dukeupress.edu/hope/article-abstract/45/3/523/12571/…
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
As argued in Liliana Doganova's forthcoming book, which I expect to be superb press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9781942130918/discoun…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Elliott Ash
@ellliottt
Nice writeup in the Economist about the history of law and economics, including a discussion of our paper "Ideas have Consequences".
Paper link: elliottash.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Ash-Chen-Naidu-…
The Economist US
@EconUS
The “law-and-economics” movement made the courts more reasoned and rigorous. It also changed the verdicts that judges handed out econ.st/3sFiPzs
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Questions de la meuf qui sort de sa grotte après des années pour les gens du CNU (ou informés):
1) est-ce qu'il faut toujours une qualif pour candidater à des postes PU
2) Une qualif PU obtenue en 2017 est-elle valable en permanence ou juste 4 ans comme celle des Mcf?
merci! -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The right online historian to answer all this is @MuellerThomas12, who just published w/ Raphael Fevre a history of Boiteux's contribution among a larger body of French work on marginal cost pricing www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09672567.2023.2248315
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
In this Econometrica issue from 1956, all articles except one are in English.
www.jstor.org/stable/i332537
But Marcel Boiteux's seminal article is in French and there is no translation in the journal. Who refereed the paper? How did readers understand it?
@Undercoverhist
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Meet the remarkable man behind Ramsey-Boiteux pricing
Boiteux (Econometrica 1956) -
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
In this Econometrica issue from 1956, all articles except one are in English.
www.jstor.org/stable/i332537
But Marcel Boiteux's seminal article is in French and there is no translation in the journal. Who refereed the paper? How did readers understand it?
@Undercoverhist
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Meet the remarkable man behind Ramsey-Boiteux pricing
Boiteux (Econometrica 1956)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The right online historian to answer all this is @MuellerThomas12, who just published w/ Raphael Fevre a history of Boiteux's contribution among a larger body of French work on marginal cost pricing www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09672567.2023.2248315
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Vickrey teaching basic issues in utilitarian philosophy, 1979
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Pete Savin
@pete_savin
A day walking in beautiful #shibdendale near Halifax and stumbled upon Low Hagstock Farm and outbuilding, it’s on the 1842 map but nature has reclaimed this site in few human lifetimes
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Fall of Civilizations
@Fall_of_Civ_Pod
🐘🐘 EPISODE 17 IS NOW LIVE 🐘🐘
In this episode, we take a look at one of the most dramatic stories from the ancient world - the rise and fall of the Phoenician empire of Carthage.
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/62mDIQKdTH8Fh1uc2IgzBy
YouTube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=2mqX9twdyYo&ab_channel=FallofCivi… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Otis Reid
@otis_reid
The paper is motivated by a (somewhat shocking, IMO!) point from Emi Nakamura and @JonSteinsson JEP article (pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.32.3.59). Most economists use narrative arguments for monetary policy, not modern identification.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Louis Pape
@Pape_econ
The Boiteux of 'Ramsay-Boiteux Pricing' has passed away... wow!
www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2023/09/08/l-ancien-presi… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steffen Huck
@steffenhuck
My tribute to Nora.
www.wzb.eu/en/research/markets-and-choice/economics-of-ch… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This started as a joke with @desroches_tyler, but studying the history & philosophy of forest econ and management actually seems like a greater project each minute following this sokal-esque wildfire case
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
More specifically, Brown argues that he somewhat sokaled Nature, while its editors deny that this is an appropriate reading of the situation
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
And a lot of the disagreement is related to the role editorial lines vs tractability-realism tradeoffs standards www.carbonbrief.org/factcheck-scientists-pour-cold-water-…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Sitting row 1 in a low cost plane with so much space for my legs without paying for it and I feel that I've stolen something.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
2 days of philo of econ conference sends the historian into dark contrarian intellectual corners: "colleagues, have you considered that models with a lot of conceptual ambiguity have been historically much more enduring that those built on philosophically-consistent concepts?"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(so no, you may not get rid of social welfare functions anytime soon)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ella Needler
@EllaNeedler
‼️ Synthetic controls in HET ‼️
Did that get your attention? Want to understand more about how to criticize or use synthetic controls for case studies in the history of economic thought? Then I’ve got you covered /1
sites.google.com/view/ella-needler/synthetic-controls-in-… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
When your conference slides are competing with the ceiling for attention
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Most academic hotel ever
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ivan Moscati
@gaddus2016
🧵1/3: Glad to share that my new book on “The History and Methodology of Expected Utility” is out for Cambridge UP, series Elements in Decision Theory and Philosophy,
and that it is freely available at CUP website until September 11:
www.cambridge.org/core/elements/history-and-methodology-o… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Attending a workshop where presenter has pb recovering key old overlooked refs. I sympathize, so asking for a friend:
does anyone has a copy of
Cohen & Jaffray (1981): Experimental results on decision making under uncertainty (Methods of Operations Research Proceedings 44) -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Tymofiy Mylovanov
@Mylovanov
What's the Value of Universities in Wartime?
I'm leading a top university in Ukraine and find myself questioning the role of education in wartime. Is there any value? Should we shift focus to defense and forget about education and science? 1/ -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
[REF NEEDED] I've spent past days reading tons of philo work on how IPCC decision and writing processes (and reports) breed epistemic inequality/paternalism and how value management could change that
but
is there any *history* of IPCC, its decision processes, debates etc?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(in general or maybe case studies on the operations of specific groups, the writing of some chapters, etc)
Thx -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's a great paper that complements Igersheim's investigation of the relationships between Rawls & economists (x.com/Undercoverhist/status/1661873722825777154)
It helps understand what kind of moral philosophy input economists were and weren't willing to add to their models since the 1970s
Danielle Guizzo
@danielle_guizzo
Are economists interested in ethics and moral philosophy? Carles Paré-Ogg and I explore interdisciplinary exchanges between public economists and John Rawls in the US in an article fresh from the oven at the European J. of the History of Economic Thought: 🧵👇
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Saloni
@salonium
Fantastic post by @antonhowes on whether history has a reproducibility crisis.
I've been digging up history of science anecdotes & stats, and it's astounding how many (1) have no citation, (2) trace back to nowhere, or (3) contradict the original source.
www.ageofinvention.xyz/p/age-of-invention-does-history-have -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Isabel Schnabel 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@Isabel_Schnabel
I am so sad to hear that Nora has left us far too early. As economists, we will miss her originality and wit, as her colleagues and friends, we will miss her kind personality. Rest in peace, Nora, we will not forget you.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Andreas Umland
@UmlandAndreas
The usual end of a Wagner opera: Everybody is dead...
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
promising archive-based book out tomorrow
guardianbookshop.com/42-9781800182684 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alexandre Delaigue
@adelaigue
L’édition originale des principes mathématiques de la théorie des richesses de cournot, au milieu des manuels de base quelconques dans les rayons de la
bibliothèque de saint Cyr -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Le role central de Moscou (et de Cohen) dans cette nouvelle génération d'économistes français nobelisables et nobélisés, 1993-1994
www.nouvelobs.com/idees/20230822.OBS77178/esther-duflo-sa… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Lund Centre for the History of Knowledge (LUCK)
@nhknowledge
Our history of knowledge trilogy is completed!
All three volumes are available OPEN ACCESS. But we have also a limited number of printed copies of the fresh third volume “Knowledge Actors” that we offer for FREE.
Read more here: newhistoryofknowledge.com/2023/08/16/the-history-of-knowl… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Quand art et sciences économiques s’associaient pour parler au plus grand nombre" par Yann Giraud et Loic Charles (avec pleins de beaux visuels comme il se doit)
theconversation.com/quand-art-et-sciences-economiques-sas… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Started working on this one ten years ago. I rather like it and am grateful to all of the people who provided useful feedback along the way. The inspiration came from a letter from Herb Stein to Stigler … (1/2) www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-history-of…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Position of Curator of the Economists’ Papers Archive at Duke university now open
Curate the largest collection of economists' archives worldwide, become our most beloved librarian
For library scientists & archive admin specialists, ideally with some knowledge of economics
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Attention historians of economics with archival interests: Job opening!
🧵
Can you please amplify, @Undercoverhist?
Curator of the Economists’ Papers Archive | Duke University Libraries library.duke.edu/about/jobs/curatoreconomics
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Historians of economics need to find their "oiseau rare", so economists, historians and librarians, please spread!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Feel free to reach out to me or to Bruce Caldwell via email if you are interested and would like more information. Contact info on the Center’s website:
hope.econ.duke.edu -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Steven Medema
@spydermed
Attention historians of economics with archival interests: Job opening!
🧵
Can you please amplify, @Undercoverhist?
Curator of the Economists’ Papers Archive | Duke University Libraries library.duke.edu/about/jobs/curatoreconomics -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Happy Researchers
@hapyresearchers
Academia to women in academia.....
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Daniel Cohen (1953-2023), economiste enthousiasmé et enthousiasmant
par @LevyAntoine et Elena Maximin
legrandcontinent.eu/fr/2023/08/21/un-grand-generaliste-da… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
J. Couppey-Soubeyran
@jcs_mbf
Un concentré d’intelligence et de bienveillance, une ouverture d’esprit et une pédagogie hors pair, c’est une perte immense.
La mort de l’économiste Daniel Cohen, une pensée en marche et un exceptionnel professeur – via @lemondefr www.lemonde.fr/disparitions/article/2023/08/21/la-mort-de… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Etienne Wasmer
@EtienneWasmer
Quelle tristesse et quel choc d’apprendre la disparition de Daniel Cohen, qui m’avait fait découvrir l’économie à l’X, puis au Delta et associé à ses réflexions sur le marché du travail et la
macroéconomie. Eclectique, brillant, jamais sectaire, toujours enthousiaste, un intellectuel engagé, qui adorait le débat d’idées, qui rendait la recherche vivante et passionnante. Mes condoléances à ses proches. -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Shengwu Li
@ShengwuLi
I donated $1,000 to support @DataColada’s defense against Gino’s ridiculous lawsuit. Believers in open science must stand together.
Frankly, @HarvardHBS should step up and cover their costs. Leif, Joe, and Uri have done them an immeasurable service.
simine vazire
@siminevazire
Be a part of the change you wish to see in the world:
Donate to help support the legal expenses of Data Colada.
They're being sued by Prof Gino after posting careful, meticulous blog posts raising concerns about data integrity in 4 papers.
Donate here: gofund.me/70c497b1 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Rohan. Home of the horse-lords."
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Ashwini_Deshpande
@_ADeshpande
This is the official statement of the Department of Economics at Ashoka.
@rodrikdani @SonaldeDesai @N_Kabeer @tajmahalfoxtrot @rbalakra @IAFFE
Economics @ Ashoka
@EconAtAshoka
Open letter to the governing body of Ashoka University from the economics department
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Very bad and fascinating. Paper link and abstract for those who can't tolerate cute video explainers.
wrap.warwick.ac.uk/171014/7/WRAP-twerp-1433-Sudarshan-22.pdf
Anant Sudarshan
@anantsudarshan
@Eyal_Frank and I show the sudden extinction of vultures in India due to the painkiller diclofenac led to a ~4% increase in all-cause mortality. Why? Econimate explains in video. PS: Working paper on SSRN. Being *revised* so comments welcome but code online only once accepted.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Racism, Segregation, Acceptance: American Economics and Black Issues, 1890-1945
By Malcom Rutherford
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4528215&dgcid… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
FRASER
@FedFRASER
This 1976 Bulletin from the @BLS_gov gives a brief history of the US labor movement fraser.stlouisfed.org/title/4413
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Daniele Tavani
@danieletavani
I remember, and he's one of my heroes. He left U Chicago and the US in opposition to the war in Vietnam. He was not only a phenomenal scholar but also a great mentor: his summer research group had Stiglitz, Akerlof, Nordhaus (as well as my own mentor Duncan Foley) as regulars.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/There’s this economist few remember, who wrote the 1st 2-sectors growth model, brought Pontryagin to econ, played rugby w/ Inada, argue over Marxism & Keynes w/ Solow & Kahn, rediscovered Veblen & ended up contributing to a papal encyclical.
His name is Hiro Uzawa (宇沢弘文) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
I think I should list proofs that it was Uzawa who single-handedly engineered the optimal control revolution in economics
Exhibit 1
(twitter disclaimer: yes, I *know* this is an exaggeration)
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/There’s this economist few remember, who wrote the 1st 2-sectors growth model, brought Pontryagin to econ, played rugby w/ Inada, argue over Marxism & Keynes w/ Solow & Kahn, rediscovered Veblen & ended up contributing to a papal encyclical.
His name is Hiro Uzawa (宇沢弘文)Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Cass and Dasgupta's student recollections of Uzawa:
"He had what one can only call presence. His face reflected a languor akin to philosophic calm, and a restlessness which comes with problems remaining unsolved"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Spear and Young also document Uzawa's background influence on both Cass and Koopmans in the development of the Ramsey-Cass-Koopmans growth model (which they argue also owe a lot to Malinvaud's influence and should be renamed)
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/macroeconomic-dynamics/ar… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
More crazy Hahn stories
Dasgupta defended his Cambridge thesis the day before his wedding, Hahn was external examiner
Hahn said he got a proof wrong
Dasgupta found *Hahn's* proof was wrong, rushed to his home hours before his wedding to settle the matter
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Hahn: "you must learn that Uncle is never wrong"
Dasgupta: I didn't wish to dispute this, I was going to be late for my wedding
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Frank Hahn was terrifying"
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Simone Vannuccini
@svannuccini
Bring back Victorian morality to econ!
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Cambridge, mid-1960s
"the thought that research in econ could be pleasurable, and that it could be the sole reason for you doing it would have filled Cambridge economists with horror. If one desired intellectual enjoyment, one should math, econ was only for the morally upright" -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
I've spent much of the past few weeks plowing through the resources that universities are pushing out to faculty as a response to the rise of generative AI (ie ChatGPT).
Without calling out any institution, I'm utterly pessimistic about the responses I've seen. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who wrote when: "good mildly unconventional work that I know of does have trouve getting published in major journals and counts against their authors in appointments and tenure"
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Roxana Gutiérrez-Romero
@Roxanagutz
Prof. Mirrlees is widely known for his generosity towards all his students. He chose his words carefully so as not to offend, did not provide too much input so that the student could reflect. Amazing economist. But above all, he was an exceptional human being. I miss him dearly.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
When your advisor is not unhappy:
"Mirrlees said it wasn't unsatisfactory work. Coming from him this meant I should receive a medal or something" (Dasgupta) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Cambridge, mid-1960s
"the thought that research in econ could be pleasurable, and that it could be the sole reason for you doing it would have filled Cambridge economists with horror. If one desired intellectual enjoyment, one should math, econ was only for the morally upright"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(the footnote reads "there was one exception to this: Frank Hahn")
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
The art of writing an abstract
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(with a hatchet)
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...his definition of aggregation is inconsistent even with the longstanding tradition of studying, theoretically & empirically, these questions at Cambridge (Stone, Houthakker and Prais, Orcutt, Deaton..). Not even clear if he's targeting Ramsey's RA or Prescott's RA
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
You've earned a screenshot of the title/abstract of the paper that comes immediately after Hahn's in the Kurz festschrift that I'm currently reading. Enjoy!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Alex M. Thomas
@alexmthomas
My article 'Recent Histories of Indian Economic Thought' is open access.
www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jshet/64/2/64_19/_article/-c…
@Societies_HET @economicthought @azimpremjiuniv -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
This thread is a wonderful discussion full of praise and helpful comments of our EJMR paper by security and privacy experts.
hachyderm.io/@leak/110846114763984440 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Gauthier Vermandel
@gVermandel
This is typically why we should cite at least the dynare user guide in our papers as a non pecuniary payoff for all the work that has been done by @MichelJuillard and Stéphane.
Bob Tetlow
@BobTetlow
Incentives for producing code in general are distorted in the sense that an idea, like, say, Calvo price stickiness,will pile up citations by the thousands, but writing code that others use often only gets a "thank you" in a footnote.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Lars Vilhuber 🇺🇦
@larsvil
In case this is useful (didn't see it in your working paper): Here's a very rough set of stats on how often Dynare is used in Econ papers since 2005 (presence of ".mod" files in replication packages): 190 papers, 1.72% of 11k articles in 17 top-ish journals (thx @sean_ulm for DB)
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Shani Cohen
@shani_cn
A fantastic episode of @MostlyAdmiring from last month, interviewing the 98 years old Robert Solow
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/108-ninety-eight-years-of-e… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Jean-Baptiste Michau
@jbmichau
Quel est l'efficacité de nos efforts climatiques sachant que la 🇫🇷 est responsable de 1% des émissions? Cet article répond par des arguments moralisateurs.
Avec @O_Goss_, nous proposons une réponse efficace aux 1%. Vive la théorie des jeux!
www.lefigaro.fr/vox/societe/secheresse-et-si-on-gerait-le…
France Inter
@franceinter
"La France ne pèse qu’1% des gaz à effet de serre" : pourquoi c’est un argument à la con ➡️ l.franceinter.fr/4Dh
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Great thread on current vs desirable citations practices for softwares & databases
Raises a lot of fascinating questions on ≠ in citation cultures for
-softwares vs databases
-econ vs other sciences
-older softwares vs Stata/R packages : have authors become more identifiable?
Lars Vilhuber 🇺🇦
@larsvil
Data(bases) are being more and more cited - as @AeaData I monitor this, see the long list of examples at social-science-data-editors.github.io/guidance/Data_citat…. Software citations are almost totally absent in Econ, but present in other disciplines. See blog.apastyle.org/apastyle/2015/01/how-to-cite-software-i…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Lars Vilhuber 🇺🇦
@larsvil
Now if software like this were consistently cited, it would be much easier to write such a great paper! #softwarecitations. In addition, important that it is open source (#transparency = trustworthy) + open access/ free (encourages adoption)!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Bob Tetlow
@BobTetlow
Incentives for producing code in general are distorted in the sense that an idea, like, say, Calvo price stickiness,will pile up citations by the thousands, but writing code that others use often only gets a "thank you" in a footnote.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Bob Tetlow
@BobTetlow
Certainly Michel Juilliard deserves more credit in the profession than he already gets for being the driving force behind Dynare. He's also one of the progenitors of the stacked-time nonlinear solution method of RE models (alongside Boucekkine and Laffarge).
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Federico Gavazzonì
@fgavazzoni
Dynare is so good that it is used as a backtest for the reliability and truthfulness of global methods. Ridiculously good achievement.
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"How Misreading Adam Smith Helped Spawn Deaths of Despair"
very interesting piece by an economist who read a lot of old economists AND a lot of work by historians HT @kelleher_
www.bostonreview.net/articles/how-misreading-adam-smith-h… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is the most comprehensive paper I've read on how what's often called "disequilibrium macro" but should be called "GE model with rationing" became a European specialty
Huge work by R. Plassard and M. Renault
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4065766 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's "raining" positions for historians of science lately (raining as in 'summer rain that keeps groundwater tables dry' but still)
AHA Career Center
@HistoryJobs
Posted Today: Assistant Professor in History of Science | Washington University in St Louis careers.historians.org/jobs/rss/18945624/assistant-profes…
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
AHA Career Center
@HistoryJobs
Posted Today: Tenure-Track Professor in History of Modern Technology | Harvard University careers.historians.org/jobs/rss/18945827/tenure-track-pro…
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A history of the Life Cycle Hypothesis, by Alice Martini and Lucas Spataro
(an influential model is a tractable model, 254th edition)
www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09672567.2023.2238858… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Scarcity, then and now
www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674987081&conten… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
.@lovera90, jeune historien et philosophe de l'éco, lance un nouveau podcast.
Pour commencer, 6 épisodes sur la 2eme édition de la thèse de Kenneth Arrow, «Social Choice and Individual Values»
l-heure-d-unepauseconomique.fr/2023/07/23/la-premiere-ser… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who are the general equilibrium theorists (training, institutions, communities, topics),
by Olessia Kirtchik and Ivan Boldyrev
osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/er2va/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
César A. Hidalgo
@cesifoti
**New Paper**
Economic complexity methods are popular tools in industrial policy. Yet, despite their widespread adoption, these methods are sometimes misunderstood. In this new paper, I explain & explore the policy implications of economic complexity. /1
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S00487333230014… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Economic thought
@economicthought
WP: Toward a “Prodigious Revival of French Economics”? Allais, Debreu, and the Dead Loss Controversy (1943–51), by Raphaël Fèvre & Thomas Michael Mueller
hal.science/hal-04119618/ -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Azim Premji University
@azimpremjiuniv
Annoucing a 1st ever conference in India exclusively dedicated to the history of economic thought (HET) with wide ranging themes : African to Indian economic thought; Ambedkar to Sraffa; Keynesian to Feminist economics; Kautilya to Khaldun
Register at shorturl.at/rN134 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Benoît Cœuré
@BCoeure
A wonderful tribute to Dynare’s central contribution to dynamic macro modelling, and decision making (including in many central banks around the world),
- and to the @CEPREMAP as incubator of this global public good.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who create new paradigms in economics? Not just famed theorists & modelers
But also lesser-known econs who write computational algorithms & design software
@cescoeco , A.Saidi & I wrote a history of how DSGEs became dominant. It's the history of Dynare
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4531026 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Juan F Jimeno
@jfjimenoserrano
Los economistas hacemos lo que hacemos porque podemos. Y si podemos es porque tenemos modelos y formas de computarlos
y estimarlos. Tan importantes son los que desarrollan modelos como los que crean los instrumentos para utilizarlos. #dynare en macro es un magnífico ejemplo.
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who create new paradigms in economics? Not just famed theorists & modelers
But also lesser-known econs who write computational algorithms & design software
@cescoeco , A.Saidi & I wrote a history of how DSGEs became dominant. It's the history of Dynare
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4531026 -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Christian Matthes
@cmatthes_econ
I guess I owe Michel Juilliard a great of gratitude!
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Christian Matthes
@cmatthes_econ
(II) the Dynare conference in 2010 was actually the first conference I ever presented at, and (III) when I was on the job market in 2010 I had a flyout for a position in Paris that, if I remember correctly, was also supposed to lead to some participation in the Dynare team.
-
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Christian Matthes
@cmatthes_econ
Reading this paper brought back a lot of memories: (I) Tom Sargent over the course of a few years asked some of his RAs to help him solve various models in Dynare to showcase its flexibility, leading to “Practicing Dynare”:
cm1518.github.io/files/PD.pdf
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who create new paradigms in economics? Not just famed theorists & modelers
But also lesser-known econs who write computational algorithms & design software
@cescoeco , A.Saidi & I wrote a history of how DSGEs became dominant. It's the history of Dynare
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4531026 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
this was the last paper on the history of macro I had in the pipeline
Long live the history of applied microeconomics now! -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Who create new paradigms in economics? Not just famed theorists & modelers
But also lesser-known econs who write computational algorithms & design software
@cescoeco , A.Saidi & I wrote a history of how DSGEs became dominant. It's the history of Dynare
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4531026
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
will write a thread later. Paper in one slide
Core idea is that it takes all sorts of work to make new class of model dominant; thin narratives ("Lucas-Sargent had bold idea & wrote pathbreaking model") though true, are not so helpful to understand how econ as a discipline works
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
(PS: we don't have RA in history of economics. We are the ones to blame )
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Peut-on être amis quand on n’a pas les mêmes idées (de la science sociale à la politique) ?
Extrait d'une série d'été le Monde avec du "Corn Law" et du "Chicago school of economics" dedans!
www.lemonde.fr/series-d-ete/article/2023/08/03/peut-on-et… -
Beatrice Cherrier reposted
Urban Economics Association
@UrbanEconomics
A bit of UEA history: urbaneconomics.org/about/history.html describes the Origins of the Urban Economics Association. Thanks to Vernon Henderson.
We've grown a lot from a few sessions at NARSC meetings in the 1990s. -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Special Osiris issue on historicizing algorithmic culture (the cover is gorgeous) www.journals.uchicago.edu/toc/osiris/current
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
with a paper by Honghong Tinn on computer metaphors in Leontief's input-output www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/725091
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Rawls and the econmists: the (im)possible dialogue.
Super cool paper by Herrade Igersheim
www.cairn.info/revue-economique-2022-6-page-1013.htm?cont… -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Vickrey teaching basic issues in utilitarian philosophy, 1979
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Solow-Baumol 1991 op-ed was written in response to an WSJ article accusing guidelines to avid racists & sexist bias in econ of "political correctedness"
Handwritten note by Baumol: "it is he who has adopted the shrill tone & overheated language of the intellectual terrorist"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"As the unemployment rate of white teenagers rises, that of black teenagers rises abt twice as much. How a discussion of unemployment claim to be reasonably complete if it ignores this painful fact"
This was written in 1991 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"As the unemployment rate of white teenagers rises, that of black teenagers rises abt twice as much. How a discussion of unemployment claim to be reasonably complete if it ignores this painful fact"
This was written in 1991 -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Almost every day these weeks, conversations I had w/ colleagues hinge upon notions of credit and "who discovered X" in economics
So I can't stop chewing over the 1953 Frechet-Von Neumann controversy on whether mathematician Emile Borel "invented" Game TheoryPost not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Von Neumann offered his own (ongoing) genealogy, concluding that
"It is common and tempting fallacy to view the later steps in a mathematical evolution as much more obvious and cogent after the fact than they were beforehand"
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
As unpacked by Nessah/Tadzaït/Vahabi, Frechet had exchange translated in French in Revue d'Economie Politique www-jstor-org.inshs.bib.cnrs.fr/stable/24691720?seq=1 *with further rejoinder*
He outlines four stages of discovery
I. the "madly bod project to translate gamers' psychology mathematically
...Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
...in daily discussing abt who should get credit for what: the one who asked new question/laid new concept
the one who thought abt applying tool X to issue Y
the one who built the model bringing all this together
the one w/ the clearest or most tractable model
What do you think?
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
bonus question: can we historians not take side? Do we need/should we have a "definition of credit"?
(after credit scene: in the 1953 Econometrica issue the Borel controversy is sandwiched b/w Gorman's Community preference fields & Nash's two person cooperative games articles) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Great new paper by Jeff Biddle on the origins of the CES production function:
www.researchgate.net/publication/342612626_The_Origins_of… [open access]
with cool archival material with Arrow/Minhas/Chenery and Solow coming together, and the independent discovery by Swan... -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
In 1984, Stanford economists tried to hire someone in "feminist studies", by which they in fact meant "gender economics." The search committee concluded that "two names came to the top of the list"
Which ones, and on which criteria were their work evaluated? -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
It's about time that historians & sociologists write serious account of the development, characteristics & intellectual/institutional impact of #econtwitter on the discipline (interviews, network, text-mining, etc) io.mongeau.net/repec-twitter-network/
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1968-1975 saw momentum in urban econ theory, resulting in special issue in Bell journal in 1973
The introductory survey essay, by Mills & McKinnon, carried a Solow epigraph:
"all theory depends on assumptions which are not quite true. That is what makes it theory" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1972:
-AEA administration: "dear @AEACSWEP chair, we promised to organize childcare at next meeting in 3 months"
-Carolyn Shall Bell : "why do you think I or any of my Committee has any particular responsibility. True, women bear children. Men also have something to do w/ it" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"There is a long-standing tension in eco- nomics between belief in the advantages of the market mechanism and awareness of its imperfections...There is a large element of Rohrschach test in the way each of us responds to this tension" (Solow, 1980)
www.jstor.org/stable/1814733?seq=1
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"I need only listen to Milton Friedman talk for a minute and my mind floods with thoughts of increasing returns to scale, oligopolistic interdependence...intergenerational inequity...There is almost no cure for it, except to listen for a minute to JK Galbraith...." (Solow, 1980)
-
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
How to start a referee report:
"It makes me feel like the sailor in the ladies' Turkish bath -- I hardly know where to begin"
(Solow, 1961) -
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
who needs an art quote when Solow has given us a "model-as-sneakers" one?
-
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/The 2 final @Bachelor_X debates were on “Are Economic Agents Rational?”
so here’s a thread on how economists have defined rationality across 20th century.
Focus is on 2 debates: status of expected utility theory (EUT) in 50s & of Kahneman & Tversky’s results in 70s to 90s -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Why Mathematicians Are Hoarding This Special Type of Japanese Chalk"
gizmodo.com/why-mathematicians-are-hoarding-this-special-…
read this alongside @MBarany's piece on mathematicians, blackboards and chalk dust mbarany.com/DustyDisciplineBWM15.pdf -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/ Ex-post livetweet on gender problem session
@BetseyStevenson :"we’re not discussing WHETHER there’s a problem but how to solve.” CSWEP data point to a lack of progress in women econ’s ability to climb the ladder in academia, while other fields have managed to continue. Why? -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
1/There’s this economist few remember, who wrote the 1st 2-sectors growth model, brought Pontryagin to econ, played rugby w/ Inada, argue over Marxism & Keynes w/ Solow & Kahn, rediscovered Veblen & ended up contributing to a papal encyclical.
His name is Hiro Uzawa (宇沢弘文) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
This is Solow's wrap up of the 1978 Fed conference in which Lucas & Sargent presented "after Keynesian macro" (topic was "After Phillips curve")
"The discussion is very abstract...the bullets are real and they may soon be fired at you by the Federal Reserve" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Having fun re-reading the Solow-Robinson correspondence. Excerpts:
(note 1: just gossiping here. For serious account of relationships between 2 Cambridges over 30y, see paulromer.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/History-of-Polit…)
(note 2: why is the only pic of young Robinson so gendered?)Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Come on, now. Nobody ever claimed that prices could generally be derived from the equation of physical production alone"
(Solow to Robinson, 1960)Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"Back to the fray. Every time I think we're getting to understand each other, you go all oracular on me again."
(Solow to Robinson, 1960) -
Post not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Solow's archives are 95% hangouts.
Reflecting on how to disseminate mathematical econ in 1952, in a time of resistance:
"no matter how hard you try you can't make modern music sound like my Old Kentucky Home" -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Solow discussing Econometrica's next editor with Hahn, 1967:
"if blandness is a desirable characteristic for an editor, those two [Frank Fisher and Dale Jorgenson] leave something to be desired. Either of them could ruffle the feathers of an alligator." -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
"I am not terribly impressed with people who aren't economists, not all of those either.
Stigler doesn't take his laisser faire dead seriously every minute of the day
Milton Friedman is of course just the opposite. Not a saving spark of humor in him" (Solow to Samuelson, 1957) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Acknowledging your own gender bias: the case of Paul Samuelson.
1/ Samuelson was known for derogatory remarks on women, the most famous one he wrote in the 1st edition of his 1948 textbook (he was writing about the popular understanding of the consequences of rationing) -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Anniversary issues shouldn't (merely) be opportunities to self-congratulate, but to provide fact-based histories of development of said journal, field, associated department.
Some econs have done this extremely well (see AJAE's 100th anniversary issue www.jstor.org/stable/i40028051?refreqid=excelsior%3A31d0d…) -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
A list of all sorts of people who sometimes tweet about history of economics. Shout if I forgot someone
x.com/Undercoverhist/lists/history-of-economics -
Beatrice Cherrier
@Undercoverhist
Netherlands to experiment replacing grants w/ direct redistribution of research budget shares by scientists www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/04/new-system-scientists-nev…






































































































































































































































































































































































































































































