This New York Times op-ed prompts me to again urge the University of Chicago @UChicago to follow the decisions taken by Ivy League institutions and reinstitute mandatory standardized test scores as part of application requirements. The current UChicago policy not only is test-optional but is advertised as following a "No Harm" principle, i.e. submitted test scores can only favorably affect admission prospects of a candidate, and not diminish them relative to assessment that would have been made without the scores.
My reasons:
1. Test scores encode information that is relevant to future student performance. Careful and nuanced evidence for elite institutions is found in
John Friedman, Bruce Sacerdote, Douglas Staiger, and Michele Tine, "Standardized Test Scores and Academic Performance at Ivy Plus Colleges" American Economic Association Papers and Proceedings, 2025.
Raj Chetty, David Deming, and John Friedman "Diversifying Society’s Leaders? The Determinants and Causal Effects of Admission to Highly Selective Private Colleges," Quarterly Journal of Economics 2026
These studies echo public statements on information value by the university leaders whose institutions have brought mandatory test scores back.
2. Failure to require test scores can be inegalitarian. Arguments that the SAT works to the detriment of students from disadvantaged families are flawed and there are good reasons to think that dropping mandatory test scores harms the disadvantaged. One reason is that the absence of test scores can give more weight to factors that are even more closely associated with socioeconomic status. This interesting paper demonstrates this possibility with respect to personal statements
J. Alvero, Sonia Giebel, Ben Gebre-Medhin, anthony lising antonio, Mitchell Stevens, and Benjamin Domingue, "Essay Content and Style are Strongly Related to Household Income and SAT scores: Evidence from 60,000 Undergraduate Applications," Science Advances 2021.
Another example is Advanced Placement exams.
Roby Chatterji, Neil Campbell, and Abby Quirk, "Closing Advanced Coursework Equity Gaps for all Students," Center for American Progress 2021
found that 15% of schools do not offer any AP classes and that there were large differences in AP enrollment by race and ethnicity.
Stephanie Owen, "The Advanced Placement Program and Educational Inequality," Education Finance and Policy 2025
To be clear, I think AP classes are very valuable and should be offered to all high schoolers. The inequality dimensions need to be addressed by improving student preparation and enrollment, i.e. levelling up rather than levelling down. My point here is that absence of standardized test scores removes a channel by which students can demonstrate their potential.
3. Test optional policies can also be inegalitarian in their effects. The recent study
Bruce Sacerdote, Douglas Staiger and Michele Tine, "How Test Optional Policies in College Admissions Disproportionately Harm High Achieving Applicants from Disadvantaged Backgrounds," American Economic Review: Insights, forthcoming
shows that disadvantaged students underreport SAT scores and hurt admissions chances at Dartmouth.
4. The claim that the information content of a given SAT score differs across students with different socioeconomic backgrounds (with which I am sympathetic) is not an argument against mandatory test scores. It is an argument for holistic admissions, nothing more.
5. Meritocracy and egalitarianism can act as complements and not substitutes. The assumption that they are substitutes is what I suspect has been in play in UChicago's current policy. Meritocratic admissions may enhance egalitarian objectives once once thinks of the social and dynamic effects of individual admissions, and this is so without an explicit egalitarian dimension to the outcomes that define comparative merit across students. This does not mean that they also need to comove positively, but rather that there is ample scope for them to do so. Further, by taking affirmative efforts to address the consequences of disparities in background due to high school quality, one can ensure that maximizing the value added of UC attendance (a standard meritocratic objective) also reduces the role on circumstances in producing inequality. I discuss these issues in
Affirmative Action, Meritocracy, and Efficiency, Politics, Philosophy, & Economics, 2008
Meritocracy and Its Discontents, Public Choice 2026
and
Retrospective Versus Prospective Meritocracy, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 2026
www.nytimes.com/2026/07/06/opinion/university-california-…