White men randomly drafted in World War I were more than twice as likely to join the Ku Klux Klan as comparable undrafted men from the same area.
"Military service shaped racial attitudes and fueled the spread of white supremacy in early 20th-century America."
Benjamin Hansen (economist)
Benjamin Hansen is an American economist and the W. E. Miner Professor of Economics at University of Oregon. He is also a research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research, a research fellow at IZA, and a Research Affiliate at the University of Chicago Crime Lab. He has contributed to the scientific study of cannabis and alcohol policy, as well as crime and labor economics. More on Wikipedia
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
alz
@alz_zyd_
Kids should have "school PTO" just like adults do. Kids should have an annual budget of 20 (non-exam) days of school they can miss just because, like, they want a long weekend, or GTA VI came out, or things like that
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So does anybody else remember that in 2021 whistleblowers came forward out of Meta talking about their internal research showing that social media use had harmful impacts on mental health?
So right after those whistleblowers came forward, all of a sudden kids stopped thinking about suicide as much. That appears to line up with a decrease...
The Institute for Family Studies
@FamStudies
Among U.S. high school students, 2021 to 2025 showed a major reversal in suicidal ideation and self-reported feeling of sadness and hopelessness, finds @jtrothwell
The share of high school students who reported feeling so sad or hopeless for at least two consecutive weeks that they stopped doing their usual activities fell from 42.3% in 2021 to 33.3% in 2025. This was a notable drop after a steady increase starting around 2011.
Likewise, the share of students reporting a suicide attempt fell from 10.2% in 2021 to 6.4% in 2025. Serious considerations of suicide also fell from 22.2% to 14.5%. The recent figures are both below the average going back to 1991. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Please interview (and hire) @studhall!
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Economics job market candidates whose job market papers were promoted by established big accounts received ~20% more flyouts and ~30% more job offers.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Some thoughts on justice-efficiency tradeoffs, and why we need lawyers and economists in charge of separate inputs to criminal justice policy.
The skills required to deliver "justice" are completely different from the skills required to deliver "crime reduction." Both goals are important, and sometimes they are in conflict.
Policy conversations will be clearer and more productive if we are honest about what we're doing for the sake of justice, and what we're doing for public safety, and when we face tradeoffs between the two. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do I add #altmiddle to my bio?
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Not only have conservatives become vanishingly rare in academia, so have centrists. Thatâs how complete the leftâs dominance is: Even moderates are now a fringe group in academia.
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/academias-leftward-march -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Emily Nix
@EmilyNix100
Today's news about Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigning is yet another example of my paper with Jerry Montonen and Dave Macdonald. Hierarchical relationships within firms are inevitably very complicated and can be quite costly for firms.
Link to paper: www.nber.org/papers/w34346 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Memes contain deep truths.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John J.S. Soriano
@JohnJSSoriano
My past 48 hours on X...
Me: Price controls on electricity will lead to less electricity
Response: F*** YOU!
Me: Raising PhD stipends will lead to fewer people getting an opportunity to go to grad school
Response: F*** YOU! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Encouraging firms to compete on price is not ideal when their market has negative externalities.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Dept of Unintended Consequences:
"Plain packagingâwhere you strip cigarette boxes of their attractive brandingâseems like a no brainer, but in Australia, it looks like the policy caused smokers to switch to cheaper brands and to smoke more."
via @a_m_mastroianni -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think the other key challenge is that AI is so good at certain tasks that you might try to do more of that specific task but that task itself may not really contribute to the bottom line or the mission of your organization that much.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
This is the common AI experience I hear from non-tech, small biz CEOs. They're paying for AI for many/all of their white collar workers. They can describe a few tasks where AI blows them away and the benefits are substantive. When asked whether AI can do a full job rather than a specific task, they say 'it's not there yet.' They haven't laid off workers but some haven't backfilled a position in a division like finance. They're optimistic about the future value of AI to their businesses.
Â
The big question I leave with is whether:
 1) AI can already perform entire jobs, but management and employees at most companies haven't figured out how to maximize its use.
2) Today's models aren't very capable of performing entire jobs at most companies, but future models will be.
3) AI has a more fundamental limitation in that it can automate individual tasks but has limited ability to replace most jobs. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The superstars in acadamia might make 500,000 to 600,000 a year at least at their main job and the people on the minor leagues so to speak in academia are making 50k to 60k. Vs sports we're talking $50m a year vs. $5k or even nothing.
Sports is not a great analogy here based on how much superstars in sports make relative to the minors.
Chris Kennedy
@ChrisJKennedy
A lot of people start PhDs with the expectation that academia is a normal industry where you can work hard and make a good living. In reality, most fields are like professional sports: grinding and low wages with the occasional superstar. Unfortunately, most professors donât live in reality and fail to advise their students properly.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think the coolest stuff will be out of academia in the next couple decades. We're too slow.
John Friedman
@johngfriedman
Many academics like to believe:
1. The best students stay in academia
2. The good students who leave, do it for money
3. You can only talk to people about cool stuff in academia.
This may have been true decades ago. It is false now. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When there's a gold rush bet on the companies selling shovels.
Sundar Pichai
@sundarpichai
Four distinct TPU systems in a single generation in one year! Instead of waiting years for a traditional semiconductor cycle, hardware engineers co-designing systems alongside Google Deepmind means we can keep innovating quickly for customers.
Amin Vahdat
@AminVahdat
Thrilled to share a big milestone from our AI & Infrastructure team at @Google.
Today weâre expanding our 8th generation TPU portfolio with:
⢠TPU 8i Max: Built for massive context windows and the highest compute density per rack
⢠TPU 8tx: Purpose-built for secure, confidential inference
This marks the first time weâve introduced four distinct TPU systems in a single generation, in one year.
For developers, hardware is only as good as the software stack. And we want you to be able to build with TPUs as easily and efficiently as we do at Google. You can now:
âł Run native PyTorch & Hugging Face models via TorchTPU (zero code rewrites)
âł Cut KV transfer latency >90% with open-source TPU Sync
âł Eliminate idle compute waste with Agent Compute Engine
Read more about our newest TPUs on our blog: blog.google/innovation-and-ai/infrastructure-and-cloud/glâŚ
I look forward to connecting with builders, researchers, engineers and organizations pushing the boundaries of AI and computing! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Remember peak twitter was 9 years ago.
@KiraboJackson. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And yet they're getting to college and many of them are struggling with basic math so are they both over-educated and under educated at the same time?
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"We vastly overeducate the modern populations. For the average student, there is no intellectual benefit they get from a pursuing university education. They hang out, they date, they make friendships, but it's really not making them any more effective." www.razibkhan.com/p/gregory-clark-and-garrett-jones-to
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If this is true then just imagine how do faculty even get anything done when we're teaching four classes a year at R1 universities or 6 to 8 a year at liberal arts colleges.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Basic econ. More is better.
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
France is one of the richest nations on earth and spends a higher share of its wealth on government services than almost any other country, yet people feel it's not enough. Humans adjust their expectations to whatever they have and want more. Always.
www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/11/07/protestors-ma⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My Phd students could work for 20 hours as teaching assistants based on contracts. I have a hard time finding they actually are spending over 7 hours based on their current assignments for me as assistants this fall.
Aaron Chalfin
@AaronChalfin
A $51,000 annual stipend, combined with free tuition and health insurance, produces a total annual compensation package exceeding $100,000. In exchange, students work approximately 20 hours per week for say four 14-week semesters over five years. This amounts to just 1,120 hours of work over the entire five-year period, yielding an effective hourly compensation of more than $450 -- over 18 times the median hourly wage of an American worker. Even if you write off the free tuition, this wage is around 9x that of the median US worker.
Not to mention that you walk away with a Harvard PhD when all is said and done. Good work if you can get it. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If you are looking for an applied microeconomist this year, please strongly consider David Hall.
David is a talented researcher focusing and crime and substance abuse. His job market studies alcohol and the role of access on consumption choices of pregnant women and the externalities.Post not available here, view on X
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
He is an incredibly effective instructor that I have learned from (as he has set up continual feedback loops using reflection essays as critical part of his teaching).
He also is a full team member on a projects with me and @q_econ studying drug decriminalization and it's impacts on overdoses.
www.nber.org/papers/w35427
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
He's also at APPAM for the next couple of days. So please find him. He's a great colleague to have in the profession, whether or not you are searching in his field this year.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Gambling companies spent $23 million backing a Nebraska ballot measure to legalize online sports betting. Opponents raised just $1 mil. Voters rejected it, 55%-45%. The federal government must stop forcing prediction market sports gambling into communities that don't want it.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Gas prices. Wars.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Voters agreed with Republicans on every policy at issue and then voted Democrat
lmao
Otis Reid
@otis_reid
Voter ID, caps on property taxes, and lowering income tax rates all winning 60-40 in NCâŚin an electorate thatâs voting 60-40 for the Democrat for Senate
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So the democrats will take aggressive action to fix social security in January right?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
They don't care about the debt, but they do care about inflation. Turns out if the debt is big enough, it will bring about inflation.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Economists are increasingly alarmed by the debt/deficit. Voters don't care.
via WSJ -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Mas
@AMLabEcon
My paper "Can You Erase the Mark of a Criminal Record? Labor Market Impacts of Criminal Record Remediation" with @AmandaYAgan @andy_garin @dkoust and Crystal Yang is now in print at AEJ: Economic Policy.
AEA Journals
@AEAjournals
The November 2026 issue of AEJ: Economic Policy (18, 4) is now available online. aeaweb.org/issues/866
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
mickey friedman
@mickeyxfriedman
liberal policies have destroyed sf
walked outside today and there are children on the streets begging for candy -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I just want a robot that can pull some freaking weeds.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
All right I have $20 that says he still makes it to the end of his ride. Any takers?
Charles Fain Lehman
@CharlesFLehman
Uber driver betting on sports at stop lights weâre so cooked chat
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Easiest policy solution to reduce the harms of sports gambling. Stop pumping up demand.
Benji Backer
@BenjiBacker
I genuinely believe our leaders should ban betting ads.
Every American, especially young ones, are watching their celebrity heroes sell a predatory industry...that's inherently designed to drain bank accounts.
We pulled cigarette ads off TV. We can do this too. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
End tenure. Move to 5 or 6 year renewable contracts.
Marc Porter Magee đ
@marcportermagee
WSJ: âThe Baby Bust Is Forcing a Reckoning at Public Schoolsâ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
As much as I love chasing balls on a court I'm sad that wrestling is declining in popularity rather than gaining it especially now that BJj offers new ways to keep grappling as an adult. There to me is nothing more human and instinctual than can I control this other person. Learning patience and rules in grappling, which turns fighting and violence into a sport, and how to slow down your thoughts in a very short 5 to 6 minute match I think is great for the minds and psychology of young adolescents.
John LeFevre
@JohnLeFevre
Since 2019, tennis is up 72% among kids 6â12. Golf is up 55%.
Parents finally figured out which sports lead to success and can be played for life.
John LeFevre
@JohnLeFevre
Walter Isaacson asks Peter Thiel what humans can uniquely do in the AI era.
Thiel: "We're very relational⌠these relational dimensions will become more important."
When knowledge is worth $0, the only career skills that matter:
- networking / social calibration
- persuasion (sales)
- curiosity (harnessing AI)
- taste (curation)
- storytelling
- grit
- golfing with clients (or equivalent)
We'll get so sick of a fake world that we'll go back to doing business like it's the 1800s. A handshake at the local saloon. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Things will get better this November.
That's when GTA 6 comes out.
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
I had GPT-6 Pro revisit the cool finding that violent video games reduce crime, as people stay home playing them. It downloaded fresh crime data & extended prior work.
Yes, GTA V's 2013 launch was linked with a dip in violence internationally. Other games are more ambiguous. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I remember making $1,000 my freshman year donating plasma. My nick name was needles because every time I was in class I had a bandage on my arm.
I checked the current wages and I'm actually tempted to get back in the market...
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
In the U.S., you are legally permitted to sell your blood plasma for money, but it's called "donation".
In recent years, the numbers of places set up for donations has skyrocketed, and the amount they're compensating donors has followed suit.
Let's dig in. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just think how much lower the wealth tax could have been 20 years ago to build a high-speed rail versus how high it has to be now....
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
The real problem with the California wealth tax is simple. Resources being allocated by the tech billionaires: good. Resources being allocated by California: bad.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
"I assumed only 5 percent would move. QED."
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
Very funny that billionaires are like âI am leavingâ. And Zucmanâs response is âsorry no, my theory doesnât allow thisâ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I thought we knew the 90s we're back because Blink had a new album or because kids were playing hacky sack.
Nope. We have a new revolt on property taxes meant to finish the job the last revolt started (defunding local government) as everyone shifts to HOA fees and private schools.
POLITICO
@politico
âIâm old. Iâve paid my home off,â said Ray Warner, a 72-year-old Akron resident. âWhy would I pay property tax?â
Across the country, homeowners are asking the same question and revolting against property taxes at a scale not seen in a half century.
www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/10/18/property-taxes-⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
During Covid, there was lots of concern about retail crime, but limited data to inform conversations about the extent or impact of these crime events.
And so, this new paper, on the "pass-through" of retail crime (armed robbery and burglary) â that is, how related costs show up in higher prices â caught my eye.
This study shows that these crime events act as a "crime tax," raising prices by about 1.8%. When stores need to upgrade their security or insurance coverage, we all pay.
This is an important social cost of crime that I hadn't seen measured before. Check out my conversation with Johannes for more!
Probable Causation
@ProbCausation
Episode 129: Johannes Kasinger on how retail crime affects prices.
www.probablecausation.com/podcasts/episode-129-johannes-k⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
For Our Futures
@foronionfutures
HAPPENING NOW in downtown Chicago, outside the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, the historic center of onion futures trading
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Sometimes headlines are very revealing. Politics is becoming a big entertainment industry on both sides (maybe it's been one for the long run) which is dangerous for our future.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
More people who work in technology should do a sabbatical or something where they make something physical in the economy.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Many people who work closely on AI and are constantly seeing charts like the one on the left (AI capability growth) think that it will translate to the graph on the right (GDP growth). But the economy is much more complicated than that.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Progressives love the policies of Scandanavian countries. Except when they make a ton of economic sense.
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
Denmark is raising its retirement age to 70. French election candidates pledge to reducing it to 60 or 62.
Denmark's debt to GDP ratio is 27%; France's is 117%.
You reap what you sow.
www.cnn.com/2025/05/23/business/denmark-retirement-age-ri⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
They thought it would be safe because LLMs usually guess the number 7.
Wojtek Kopczuk đľđąđşđŚ and đşđ˛
@wwwojtekk
Even randomly generated passwords are not safe unfortunately
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
That's like the password that people use on their freaking airport luggage.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Maybe this is just evidence that AI writing was trained on the best.
Jeffrey Wooldridge
@jmwooldridge
I recently learned that heavy use of the emdash is considered evidence that the writing is AI, or AI assisted -- yes, I'm late once again on trends. I've always been a heavy user. I bet the causal inference chapter in 8e of my intro econometrics book uses it nearly 100 times.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Noah Smith đđşđ¸đşđŚđšđź
@Noahpinion
America is intentionally cutting ourselves off from the other global technological revolution.
Apparently we forgot that electric cars and robots are very similar to make.
Zeke Hausfather
@hausfath
Electric vehicle adoption is accelerating worldwide â but not in the United States:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So it's very clear that Uber learned from experiments with @Econ_4_Everyone that people care about waiting time but they also didn't learn that economists don't do deception (psychologists do that).
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
One of the biggest edges for Waymo is that they donât blatantly lie to you every single time you try to use their product.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Of course if they trust us too much to train Claude they might find that Claude starts working on your code and then takes a break to go check out Twitter and then 20 minutes later comes back and it's like oh I'm sorry what did you want again?
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Political scientists and economists: we're looking for researchers with deep expertise to come work with us for a unique 4-month fellowship at @AnthropicAI. You'll work closely with us to evaluate, improve, and apply Claude's capabilities in your field. It's going to be extremely fun and interesting work, and definitely worth taking a short leave from your university for if you need to!
More info here:
job-boards.greenhouse.io/anthropic/jobs/5447080008 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who wants to bet whether or not this guy is right or wrong?
Benji Backer
@BenjiBacker
Americaâs addiction to gambling & betting is an actual crisis, and not enough people are talking about it
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Preliminary evidence suggests GLP-1 drugs may reduce cravings for addictive substances, but stronger evidence is needed to support broader access.
We @Arnold_Ventures are proud to fund the most rigorous study ever of effect of GLP-1s on alcohol/opioid use and downstream impacts. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Does this mean on my LinkedIn I can turn myself into a synthetic MIT econ PhD based off on my ex post publication record?
Basil Halperin
@BasilHalperin
Angrist-Diederichs-Ellison: MIT econ admissions committee ranks the top ~200 PhD applicants each year
Students ranked #1-5 publish 3x as much as those ranked #6-25...
...who in turn publish 3x as much as those ranked #151-200 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Pedro H. C. Sant'Anna
@pedrohcgs
This has been in the making for a while, and I think it is time to give a preview.
csdid in Stata is now fully updated!
This version is faster, better documented, and fully aligned with our R and Python packages!
psantanna.com/csdid/
We'll keep further improving. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
To give you a sense of how badass Bob Hall is, he won a Nobel for his 2nd and 6th most cited papers.
Hall and Jones?
Hall and Jorgenson?
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
đ¨ 2026 Nobel Prize in Economics goes to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford đ¨
"for microfoundations of macroeconomic stabilisation"
Such a good macro prize. So happy to see Robert Hall, not mentioned as much as Woodford in this discourse -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The AEA needs to be stronger in limiting math ability among economists.
James Miller
@JimDMiller
As an economist, Iâm okay with AI replacing mathematicians. What bothers me is displaced mathematicians competing for economistsâ jobs in finance and academia, lowering our wages. That cannot be tolerated. Iâm starting a petition to ban this unfair competition.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The closest thing that we might ever have to causal research that conferences are actually a net positive in the long run?
Natalia Emanuel
@NataliaHEmanuel
Coffee shops boost innovation. 10% more Starbucks in an area --> 3-4% more inventions.
People gather over a cuppa. They share ideas, discuss how to untangle a knotty problem, help see an issue from another perspective. These conversations lead to breakthroughs and inventions.
A very fun paper finds that when Starbucks rolled out to a new county, it fueled a coffee-shop culture, urging more and more people to âgrab a coffeeâ together. The authors compare the counties where Starbucks had rolled out to those where it had not yet arrived. And they find that the number of patents in caffeinated counties is meaningfully higher.
This paper underscores how essential the face-to-face encounter is. Starbucks isnât that old. People Could have picked up the phone and chatted at any time. People Could have dropped an email. Probably they did. But those connections didnât yield the same insights and creativity.
Turns out that a Cup of Joe really does help the knowledge flow. We talk about how much in-person connection boosts creativity in In Person. Itâs out in just few days, so now is a great time to pre-order.
To see the full research use the link in the comments.
#innovation #inperson #futureofwork #coffeeculture #newbook -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How am I supposed to go to this and the Western Economics Association meetings in Hawaii this next summer? Economists have a scarcity of time problem on our hands...
Bia
@BeatrizGietner
GOAT summer school!!! đ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Mas
@AMLabEcon
Wealth is productive capital. It funds infrastructure, plants, technology, R&D, and employment. In the US the market allocates capital pretty efficiently. The income from this invested capital can be reinvested or (for the very wealthy) spent on expensive things like yachts and art. Taxing income reduces some of that consumption, which is completely defensible. Taxing wealth itself and you are disassembling the machine that makes the economy grow. Thatâs much harder to defend.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Being in middle management is sometimes challenging but I think I finally found a solution to the University of Oregon's structural budget deficit for the next 23 days.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Thinking about the future for applied microeconomists, when all sorts of AI bots can have the same access to similar public data and similar public laws, does this mean the future of research is just in getting admin data or doing field experiments?
alz
@alz_zyd_
We empirical economists lived through a roughly 20-year period where the amount of data grew faster than the amount of intelligence available to process the data. We made careers out of the rather trivial activity of taking publicly accessible data and just finding insights in it
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
CONFIRMED CUIT.
Jeremiah Johnson đ
@JeremiahDJohns
If I understand correctly:
-French govt spending is already 57% of GDP
-Despite this, students are protesting underfunded schools with poor conditions
-They're also in a huge debt crisis
-Yet both Melenchon and Le Pen are campaigning on expensive new policies
Is France cooked? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
She set up her Twitter so only some people can reply to her tweets and then she thinks it's dead I mean that's just your user settings.
Jessica Riedl đ§ đşđŚ
@JessicaBRiedl
Kind of sad that Econ Twitter is basically dead. I follow so many econ accounts that used to post, educate, debate, and engage, and nearly all have gone mostly dormant. I get it - the trolls, bots, cranks, & bigots have turned Twitter into an unusable sewer. But sad to see.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Let's do this by cities that had influxes of remote workers and I bet you'll find the same thing for Boise and Boulder Bend Oregon and yes Bozeman Montana the 4 bs.
Justine Moore
@venturetwins
I need to know wtf is going on in Montana
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Senior people are probably out starting their own businesses or getting promoted.
JosĂŠ Azar
@joseazar
Herb Simon predicted that middle managers would be the first to be automated by machines. Interestingly, that's not what seems to be happening for now. We are seeing AI exposed firms and occupations reorganize towards the middle layers, with an increase in the share of mid-seniority roles, and drops in both the junior and senior shares.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Guess a lot of this just depends upon how much productivity and therefore earnings per worker increase as your population shrinks. So if your Capital stock stays the same and you have fewer workers yeah they'll be more productive and under the right modeling frameworks yes wages could increase an even you could have enough taxes to pay for social security. Are we likely there when you have stronger firm bargaining power borderline on monopsony in some situations? Probably not
NBER
@nberpubs
A new Overlapping Generations model shows there's a welfare-maximizing rate of population growth, trading off higher output per worker against fewer workers per retiree, and that optimal rate may well be negative. Adding pay-as-you-go social security pushes it even lower, from Laurence M. Ball www.nber.org/papers/w35823
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I bet the average Ford 150 owner has had their gasoline bill go up by more than $5,000 since DJT took office.
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
If Republicans win the House of Representatives and the Senate in the 2026 Midterm Elections, Iâm going to give all adult citizens in the United States of America, $5,000! Thank you for your attention to this matter, and I look forward to signing those checks!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Hey just try publishing a paper that updates findings and even if it overturns prior results completely you will get rejected for not being novel enough.
joseph francis
@joefrancis505
The "China shock" narrative illustrates why the lack of debate is a problem in economics.
Autor et al. published a series of articles that have since been falsified by subsequent research. However, few realize this, which means the articles persist, like zombies. 1/8 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
No way this is going to end up with any indecent proposals is it?
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: Ex-Tinder executive launches new dating app that allows complete strangers to âmatchmakeâ singles they think should date â and earn financial rewards for successful picks.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Being 40 f****** sucks. I know this condition well and it turns out it only gets f****** worse.
Danny
@DjokovicFan_
đŁď¸Novak Djokovic reveals he has a health issue which he has a diagnosis for and is doing his best to solve:
"I donât want to go into details because then it will seem like Iâm complaining or looking for excuses. The truth is that this year has been a huge struggle for me, with some specific issues Iâve had. Iâve tried to find different ways to at least be in decent physical and health conditions to be on the court and compete against the player in front of me. If the player beats me, if heâs better, then thatâs fine. But the majority of my matches and tournaments I have played this year have been a real struggle for me physically, none of that has to do with stamina. People mix it up; itâs not stamina, itâs something more related to health. I donât want to reveal what it is, but I am trying to get to the bottom of the problem with my team.â -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
I'm not sure who saw this coming, but so far nearly all the jobs created during the second Trump administration have gone to women.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Or it will just result in a lot of wealth transfers to their children who keeps the units as rentals.
Nick Gerli
@nickgerli1
A structural shift is taking place underneath the surface of the U.S. Housing Market.
And it could unleash a lot of pent-up housing supply.
Over the last 12 years, the number of 75+ Homeowners has grown significantly gaster than 25-44 year old renters.
As a result, the ratio of 25-44 renters to 75+ homeowners has dropped from 2.16x in 2012 to just 1.70x in 2024.
And some states are already below 1.00x.
Meaning there aren't enough future first-time buyers to absorb the future supply from senior homeowners aging out.
Check the 75+ Owner to 25-44 Renter metric for your ZIP: www.reventure.app/map?geo=county&datapoint=population&zoo⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think this tells you that the $56,000 is not going to buy that much in 30 years.
CMS Invests
@cmsinvests
So youâre telling me if I invest $1,000,000 into the 30-Year Treasury at 5.60%
I will get $56,000 every year for 30 years for literally doing nothing
You could easily retire off that income.
Why arenât more people doing this? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Now do this but search I wonder how AI is affecting Google's core Business...
Kimon
@qflen00
it's a lot worse than you think
seb
@hiiinternet
Nobody surfs the web anymore man
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Oregon looking like Spain in some ways.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
This is a huge problem for aging countries, i.e. all of the West.
via @cowenconvos -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jacob Schaal
@FutureEconJacob
Last call for papers on AI and its impact on productivity, the labour market and public finances.
Franco-German Fiscal Policy Seminar, Berlin, 1â2 Dec. Hosted by the German and French finance ministries, with a keynote by Lee Lockwood.
Deadline: 9 Oct. Travel + hotel covered for accepted speakers.
cepr.org/events/2026-franco-german-fiscal-policy-seminar -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Empirical IO gonna win this year. Or monetary (Blanchard).
Jacob Edenhofer đŞđş đşđŚ
@edenhofer_jacob
Which field will be recognised with this year's Nobel Prize in economics?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This.
Evan Rose
@evankrose
Why should important results be frozen in time at the moment theyâre published? The world isnât static, and our evidence shouldnât be either.
AI allows us to continuously update influential work with new data and methods.
Let us know what you want to see us tackle next! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
The prison population shrank over the past 15 years. Over the next 15 years, it's going to shrink a lot more. Shawn Bushway, Jason Robey, and I explain why in our new paper in Annual Review of Criminology.
www.albany.edu/news-center/news/2026-new-ualbany-research⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Bia
@BeatrizGietner
mathematicians are recreating UChicago econ seminars from first principles
Mathelirium
@mathelirium
24 senior mathematicians met at Harvard and agreed on something big:
A PhD should no longer be awarded mainly on the dissertation text. Their reason is that AI can now help write it. They want in-person, written, and oral exams instead.
Personally, as someone with a PhD, I think the defense should have been the real test all along. Anyone can polish a document.
terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/25/recommendations-of-the-⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Econometrica
@ecmaEditors
How should police activity be deployed? We propose a model of criminal learning and estimate its parameters using RCT data from an anti-drunk-driving campaign in India. We find clear evidence of learning, making ârotatingâ checkpoints most effective www.econometricsociety.org/publications/econometrica/fortâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Strategic reserve is dangerously low and our inability to tap into it right now no doubt contributes to current high oil prices.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This but suicides.
samir huseynov
@huseynovecon
âExploiting the staggered geographic rollout of Metaâs Muse and variation in device eligibility, we estimate the effect of access to personal AI agents on divorce rates.â
AER paper, 2034 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
YIMBYLAND
@YIMBYLAND
An apartment in Austin is now more affordable than the median US apartment.
Itâs incredible what can happen when you build housing. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
A copy of a copy of a copy. Could get worse. Could also just drift.
Megan Stevenson
@MeganTStevenson
Itâs now cheap to mass-produce papers, websites, etc. People will soon flood the internet with these, built to influence next-gen AI models. Is it possible AI will get worse because the data it trains on gets worse?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I decided to upgrade my person's scavenger hunt should be a online laboratory for in class market experiments including the scavenger hunt and a bunch of supply and demand stuff.
duckonomics.com -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Built a Human Scavenger Hunt (calling it HAM, or heterogeneous agent market) for my econ classes to help them meet each other. Tested it today at the econ social and it worked great. Will deploy next week in my class if 500 students.
uo-econ-human-scavenger-hunt.uo-econ.workers.dev -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Armand Domalewski
@ArmandDoma
Senator Jeff Merkley
@SenJeffMerkley
For millions of young people across America, homeownership seems further out of reach than ever before.
Here's my proposal: we can help restore the dream of homeownership with a 5 to 1 federal match for first-time homebuyers saving for a downpayment.
www.merkley.senate.gov/merkley-proposes-housing-downpayme⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Sam Norris
@sambnorris
Come work with me on labor and the economics of crime. Job ad below
PREDOC.org
@predoc_org
New pre-doc posting at @UBC to work with Sam Norris @sambnorris
To learn more, visit ubc.wd10.myworkdayjobs.com/ubcstaffjobs/job/UBC-Vancouver⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why is he training my replacement?
Jeffrey Wooldridge
@jmwooldridge
Admittedly based on a small, selected sample, but Iâve seen no improvement in the quality of presentation slides since AI became widely available. Many decks still have fonts way too small with too much information on each slide.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jonathan Berk
@berkie1
99% of Boston's existing residential parcels could not be built today under it's current 4,000+ page zoning code, the longest in North America.
If your zoning makes 99% of your city illegal... it's time to throw it out and start over. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'd like to see this as some version of GDP that takes out what fraction of GDP went to food in each of these time periods.
andrew chen
@andrewchen
Epic
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just do it.
Marc Porter Magee đ
@marcportermagee
âThe $1 billion donation, Dr. Guldberg said, would allow Oregon to move beyond offering engineering minors and graduate programs to create a full undergraduate program that could help alleviate a shortage of engineers in the stateâ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Marc Goldwein
@MarcGoldwein
Perhaps the best thing we can do to improve affordability is deficit reduction.
No, really.
www.crfb.org/papers/deficit-reduction-key-improving-affor⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And this kicks the can down the road for like 3 more years and then we still don't have enough earnings to cover current liabilities.
Elizabeth Warren
@ewarren
A teacher earning $60,000 pays Social Security taxes on every dollar she earns.
A worker earning $184,500 does too.
But someone earning $10 million pays tax on just the first $184,500.
That doesnât make sense. We can protect Social Security if everyone paid their fair share. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
There's also the belief that college sports gets you a whole bunch of out-of-state students. While sports contribute to the vibes of a college you don't need a great team to actually have great vibes and Mike Anderson has a great paper in Restat that shows that the effects of having a winning team are pretty small.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
There's a belief that college sports is awash in money. In reality it's hemorrhaging resources in a zero sum game. Schools can't grow their way out of this. Without real spending constraints, the bigger the system, the greater the losses.
www.cantwell.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/spiraling_college_sâŚ
8/8 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And income/wealth. Unfortunately purpose and income are negatively correlated.
Nicholas Fabiano, MD
@NTFabiano
Purpose is the ultimate longevity drug.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think it's more like wow what an amazing shift in prices we're seeing unfolding in real time. Where is my instrument?
Zach Weinersmith
@ZachWeiner
Artists: but I don't want to lose my job. I love it.
Mathematicians: but I don't want to lose my job. I love it.
Economists: LONG HAVE I AWAITED THIS HOUR! DESTROY ME, EFFICIENCY, AND LET UTILIZATION-ADJUSTED TOTAL FACTOR PRODUCTIVITY RISE ON THE WIND OF MY ASHES! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Even in basic old cobb douglas production functions the MPL depends on K.
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Exactly! One recent paper that did this part nicely by the way was the Anthropic Institute report by @ChadJonesEcon @akorinek @PeterMcCrory and co.
They also have some cases where the wage drops, see Table 5.
www-cdn.anthropic.com/files/4zrzovbb/website/cf58f84d46a4âŚ
JesĂşs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
I see the point now. In OLG, Blanchard-Yaari or Aiyagari-type economies, the long-run supply of capital slopes upward (that is also the mechanism in my paper with Galo, Rodolfo, and Peter on monetary policy). How steep this slope is determines how much of automation's gain goes to wages versus returns, and that is an empirical question.
I re-ran the results with different elasticities. I hope I read your calibration correctly. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Auto publication bias. What could go wrong.
Matt Dancho (Business Science)
@mdancho84
R.I.P. data scientists.
Andrej Karpathy just open-sourced what is replacing the traditional data scientist... -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
Americans want lower taxes, more government spending, and less inflation.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Jack Paul had found his next boxing opponent.
MMA On Point
@mmaonpoint
Gable Steveson:
- All week, gets berated by Sean Sharaf about his allegations
- Gets knocked out in a fight where he was a -2700 favorite
- Gets booed out of the building after his loss
It's going to be hard to come back from that đ¤ˇThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The same people that think AI can cause human extinction within the next 3 years are also those who think AI will cause 15% gda heat growth. Both of those world views come from people that mostly probably use software and don't build things in the real world.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Old, slow, retired (from hedge fund work), and willing to do whatever it takes for his next paycheck.
Jake has found his next opponent.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
@SecScottBessent
Great to welcome @jakepaul to the Treasury Department today.
Jakeâs path from content creator to entrepreneur and professional boxer is a distinctly American story. đşđ¸đşđ¸đşđ¸ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Made an agent which is an interactive version of a paper I wrote. Debating making one that which allows interactive regression analysis so referees can explore some things on their own. Is it crazy to let someone run a regression remotely on your data?
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
All credit to these authors. Great idea which will keep evolving.
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11044-y -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This also includes crime it's more productive to be a criminal in cities.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Cities make people more productive. That's the nature of agglomeration effects.
Unfortunately, America doesn't benefit as much from agglomeration as it could because it has really high crime, and crime disrupts agglomeration economies. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Oral exams are back again!!!
John Horton
@johnjhorton
People submitting slop papers they don't understand to journals / conferences? Give them an AI oral interview on the contents. As @arpitrage put it:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Breakneck hypothesis on full display. China is a country run by engineers. US is a country run by lawyers (and now grifters).
Steve Hanke
@steve_hanke
Distinguished Columbia Univ. Prof. Jeff Sachs on Trump's 35-person cabinet:
âNot one of them is trained in technical skills. Not one research PhD, as opposed to China, where half the cabinet is science and technology PhDs. We're led by grifters and fools.â -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Obviously a ton of the people over 65 lied about their age and should keep working another 5 to 10 years.
Whiplash437
@MrWhiplash_
đ¨ Stephen Miller says the scale of welfare fraud is SO MASSIVE that eliminating it alone could balance the ENTIRE federal budget
"The amount that has been fleeced from us is in the HUNDREDS OF BILLIONS of dollars."
"We could balance the federal budget if the only dollars that went out of the treasury went to individuals who were properly, lawfully, correctly eligible to receive them."
This should infuriate EVERY taxpayer.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's interesting to note in the USA we hate handouts to people when it's because of something "they did" (being poor, etc). But we're generally ok with it when it's something outside their control (emergency assistance after hurricanes, natural disasters, disability insurance for those in the military, etc). Perhaps AGI can be thought of as a natural disaster because it's an outside shock hitting the whole economy at once (if it happens). How to fund any of these interventions is another question given our current deficits.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Today we are announcing the new DeepMind Institute, a forum dedicated to interdisciplinary, evidence-led debate on the societal and economic questions surrounding AGI.
As part of the launch, @JulianDJacobs and I have a new essay and working paper: âEconomic Policy for AGI.â
institute.deepmind.com/essays/economic-policy-for-agi/ đ§ľ1/n -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Today we are announcing the new DeepMind Institute, a forum dedicated to interdisciplinary, evidence-led debate on the societal and economic questions surrounding AGI.
As part of the launch, @JulianDJacobs and I have a new essay and working paper: âEconomic Policy for AGI.â
institute.deepmind.com/essays/economic-policy-for-agi/ đ§ľ1/n -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Finally a standard I can live up to.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
The publishing rat race has gotten out of control and AI is making it worse.
I am officially putting a pause on publishing my papers in the Quarterly Journal of Economics and I call on all leading economists to do the same. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Economists estimating damages for a litigation case be like
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Horton
@johnjhorton
my parents are renovating their living room & were using ChatGPT to generate images of what it might look like. Computer was unlocked so I hijacked thread & said "good start but I need space for my massive porcelain doll collection - redo everything w/ the dolls. Just jammed w/ dolls." Parents thought they had been hacked.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Joel Sawyer
@joeldavidsawyer
Thereâs a pretty simple explanation for that UT photo.
For years, the top 6% of Texas high school students got automatic admission to UT. Now itâs the top 5%. Itâs completely colorblind. Itâs just class rank.
Asian kids are about 5% of Texas graduates, but roughly 21% of the kids hitting a 1180 SAT/24 ACT benchmark. Absolutely kicking ass.
And UTâs own numbers make the âforeign studentsâ explanation pretty hard to square. Only about 4% of UT undergrads are international students.
What weâre looking at is immigrants and the children of immigrants doing all the things YOU SAID you wanted immigrants to do: come here legally, work hard / succeed academically, and assimilate into our culture.
Check. Check. Check.
Iâm starting to think your problem with this picture might be something else entirely....
Bo French
@bofrench
I heard UT graduation this year looked like this. I didnât believe it. The problem is now obviously far worse than anyone imagined.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Let's do this! I'm excited to get started.
Renaissance Philanthropy
@RenPhilanthropy
Weâre delighted to today announce @jenniferdoleac as a Fellow at @RenPhilanthropy, where she will be scoping a fund to dramatically reduce crime and violence around the world.
Crime and violence causes trillions of dollarsâ worth of damage every year in the U.S - and globally - yet the system built to control the problem is strikingly ineffective.
1/2 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Michael Kofoed
@mikekofoed
Intro to Econometrics be like:
Kimball Call
@KimballCall
Can @mikekofoed or @Galepooley or any of my other economics friends give me some advice for Econometrics?
I just need someone to tell me itâs gonna be okay đ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It is shocking how much of Newtonian physics ignores the basics of relativity and quantum mechanics.
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
When I say that economics isn't a real science, it's not just because economics cannot achieve the same rigour of proof as the hard sciences.
It's also because a frighteningly large number of theories in modern mainstream economics aren't based on rigorous empirical evidence â or, at best, simplify to the extreme.
Examples include Heckscher-Ohlin trade theory, expected utility theory, the Solow-Swan model, the efficient market hypothesis, and the money multiplier. The list goes on.
Students ought to know that when they enrol in an undergraduate economics degree, they are more likely to learn theories dreamed up from an armchair than ones built on meticulous observation of the real world. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I still remember watching morning of and people were talking about it being an accident Or not knowing the cause until the second one crashed and then everybody realized no we were under attack.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
One of the surprising things rewatching 9/11 news coverage as it happened was how slowly people realized it wasn't an accident. Stock futures were still positive 16 minutes after the first plane hit WTC. It wasn't until minute 17 when the 2nd plane hit that futures went negative.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Sasha Gusev
@SashaGusevPosts
This -- human understanding lagging proofs -- is the norm in biology. You get an experiment where perturbation X caused response Y, you replicate it and know it's valid, then you have to understand how it happened. Why I like the analogy of math becoming a "lab science".
Scott Armstrong
@scottnarmstrong
I disagree with this.
Obviously the openAI construction of the Navier-Stokes blow up is a huge, huge contribution to the field. It will take us PDE analysts some time to understand it well. (Longer than a week, but perhaps less than a month.)
Soon some of us will understand it, and hopefully rewrite it in a way that others can follow. When this is done, our human understanding of these important equations will be past the bottleneck we've been stuck at for 100 years since Leray.
What is weird is that, up until now, proofs like this have always emerged AFTER human understanding. But that is not the case any more. From now onwards, human understanding will typically lag the proofs, which will first be written by our machines.
The understanding however WILL follow closely behind.
The reason people are upset has nothing to do with the fact that this process is inverted. They are simply upset that the machines are going to be much smarter and more capable than us.
(They are also upset that the humans who got the machine to produce the proof don't understand it, and this feels very unfair to them.)
Itai Sher
@itaisher
Imagine that I taught a class and I said, âwhat matters is truth. So we are not going to waste time with explanations in this class. Instead we will use the semester to list everything that is known in the field.â
This is what some of the discourse about AI in math is like. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
AI is pretty good at BS.
Harry Crane
@HarryDCrane
The real threat to academia.
If AI can solve Navier-Stokes, then AI can easily perform much easier tasks, more efficiently and consistently:
referee papers
operate journal end-to-end
admissions
write grant proposals
evaluate grant proposals
99% of what deans and admins do -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Like seriously how are we supposed to tackle this AI threat problem when we're okay with $40 billion of identity theft related activities every year and it's been growing year over year consistently.
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
My p(doom) is low because I expect society to act. Now we need to get concrete:
1. Build AI models that can reliably audit other AI.
2. Recruit independent auditors with diverse perspectives.
3. Give them incentives to catch real dangers without blocking everything.
4. Address the cyber threats already hitting society and politics.
5. Get universities in the gameâand moving faster.
These are huge opportunities to get researchers working on these problems and directly participating in oversight.
I wrote my thoughts on this here:
freesystems.substack.com/p/the-makers-of-our-fate -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The only way AI can kill all of humanity is if we give it control of nuclear weapons or control of our entire food supply chain so how about we just don't do either of those things.
Also I think there's something else me in game theory happening here. If you're at a frontier company and you want to get regulation that hurts open source models more than it hurts you talking about the safety risks of AI is a great way to slow down the open source models to help the frontier models to continue to be more powerful and more valuable at scale than anything that gets done with open source. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
After you miss the first serve you should have 15 seconds to serve the second that's it.
The Tennis Letter
@TheTennisLetter
Ben Shelton was asked about Zverev bouncing the ball a lot between 1st and 2nd serves
âFor a first serve you should be able to do whatever you want and use the full 25 seconds every time. There should be some sort of rule limiting time on 2nd serves. There shouldnât be unlimited time. Itâs tough to be sitting there for that long for the next action to happen.â
(via U.S. Open Press)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Michael Kofoed
@mikekofoed
I will jack up prices unless the Fed jacks up prices.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump says he will cut off all trade entirely with "some nations" unless the Fed lowers interest rates
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's the only way to get some explosive AI growth with AI causes a massive world recession and then there's a lot of growth coming out of the recession just like when we came out of covid. And I guess AI could lead to another virus escaping a lab or something.
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Some new joiners for a total pot size of $575k!
On my side:
@robinhanson
@phl43
@SashaKaletsky
@_gabrielunger
On the fast-growth side:
@jankulveit
plus @SamuelAlbanie continuing to increase his stake đŽ
benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Some real diversity of opinion at Google DeepMind: @alexolegimas joins the bet while his colleague @SamuelAlbanie takes the other side increasing his existing stake!
Total size of pot now $425,000!
benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Thanks to @willmacaskill, @SamuelAlbanie, @tomcohen for taking the other side of this bet at 4:1 odds and to @andrewho03 for joining on my side.
Here are the final terms we agreed on benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/
More (within) ~7 years from now đ
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Would anyone like to take the other side of the following bet? I bet you (say) $25k inflation-adjusted that U.S. per capita real GDP growth will be <15% per annum in 2033 or any year before that. (15% implies a doubling time of ~5 years.)
Note: I'm extremely bullish on AI and...
Sholto Douglas
@_sholtodouglas
How fast could the economy double? TLDR, once we have good enough AI and tens of millions of robots - very fast.
As crazy as it feels now - it is worth pricing in economic doublings into your mental models of the 2030s. Strongly recommend reading this series of blog posts by Damon Binder. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My daughter right now " who's that tennis announcer is he the narrator on never have I ever???"
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Used AI to help me to Fix four broken cables on pop up camper. Used suno to remix songs from my college band. Liked one enough to put it on Spotify. AI is game changer for anything DiY.
open.spotify.com/track/0aS5Rb0QggGMXdPVgDbqgU
JesĂşs FernĂĄndez-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) has a nice post today explaining how he fixed his dishwasher with the help of ChatGPT. We have all been there over the last couple of years. In my case, from fixing a light fixture in my kitchen to repairing a leak in my irrigation system.
Deutsch and many readers point out something that has been a staple of my talks for a decade. GDP was designed to measure an economy that produced coal and steel, easily measurable quantities. And GDP did its job quite well for decades.
IT, first, and later the internet and AI, changed the landscape. My favorite example is books. Even as late as 2010 or so, getting the most recent books in Spanish on, letâs say, Spanish economic history was hard in the U.S.: expensive and time-consuming. Every time I went to Madrid, I carried two bags, one of them empty because it would come back filled with books. Then Kindle arrived, and now I can buy nearly every single Spanish book I want in seconds and at a lower price than the physical copy. This was an enormous increase in my welfare that never got reflected in GDP.
The literature is divided on how big this effect is. I tend to side with those who think it is a big deal. Therefore, many of the gains in GDP growth announced by the strongest defenders of AI might not materialize: they will go instead into higher welfare.
But the issue goes beyond getting GDP wrong. What Deutsch perhaps did not notice is that he did not pay VAT on the service of the repair person he did not hire, and that such a repair person did not pay income taxes on the service he did not render.
Taxing AI-based economies might thus become much harder, from a purely technical perspective. One solution would be to tax the profits of OpenAI (or Deutschâs subscription), but I am among those who think those profits are not going to be nearly as large as anticipated. Competition among labs will drive the subscription prices of models down (unless labs can cartelize, for example, by appealing to âAI securityâ). Over 95%, and perhaps as much as 99%, of the gains from AI will pass to the final user, whether another business or an individual.
Now, we could tax the final user, for instance, at a fixed rate per token used. But that implies we are taxing the high-return activity (how to fix the dishwasher) at the same rate as the low-return activity (Claude: âtell me a joke about my cat jumpingâ). And taxing per token might hurt those final users who use more tokens because they are more productive, something we might not want to do (yes, there is something called the uniform commodity taxation theorem, but it often breaks down).
Let me give you an extreme example: imagine that tomorrow the new OpenAI model cures all cancers, forever. Just a vaccine, $10, once in your life, and you never get cancer again. The increase in human welfare from such an invention would be staggering. But how do you measure it in GDP? Yes, people will live longer, perhaps work longer. A second-order effect on GDP. And more importantly: how do you tax the vaccine? Do you even want to tax the vaccine? I would argue we want to subsidize it, and generously.
When I was still an undergrad, my first RA job was helping to construct GDP and other national aggregate statistics in Spain. It was a most valuable experience, because it made me aware of what GDP means, its strengths (and it has many more than its critics concede), and its limitations. But it also taught me that what you can tax out of GDP is far more limited than you would think at first sight.
There are real upper bounds on taxation, and I am afraid the bound is tighter now than it used to be.
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
I just fixed my dishwasher with the help of ChatGPT. A trivial task. I had been about to order a new one. So this software has increased the country's real wealth yet decreased the measured GDP. The main economic indicator is structurally incapable of registering the thing that actually makes people better off, namely the growth of knowledge
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What if we think about $1 trillion in how much worker time were borrowing from the future. Money is a store of value after all.
That's 26 billion hours of work (average hourly wages). Or roughly 318,390 total careers we're borrowing from the future.
Another way to view it is 630,413 FTE workers required to pay for the interest cost of the lump sum transfer.
At a time when there's not enough workers relative to older people we would dedicate a ton of our labor force effectively to finance this.
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
A trillion is so large it feels made up. That's the problem when talking about our national debt. 1 million seconds is 11.5 days. 1 billion seconds is 31.7 years. What about 1 trillion seconds?? @svaneksmith youtu.be/QGBTDkqXFus
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Facts.
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
How to fix the slow play in tennis:
1) Apply the serve clock to 2nd serves too.
2) Bad tosses that result in do-overs should not stop the serve clock. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Theres no golden ticket.
Jason Kerwin
@jt_kerwin
Curious about the field composition of the grad committee. I have a theory
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Apparently she really likes to wait in lines.
Elizabeth Warren
@SenWarren
We should all be worried about "dynamic pricing."
That's when companies change their prices in real time.
If it's hot out, the cost of ice cream could go up.
If it's cold, tea bags could go up.
It's a way for giant companies to squeeze you even more. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And yet 2021 supposedly taught us those spending increases need to be met with increased taxes (MMT truthers turned out to be Keynesians when faced with inflation).
John Arnold
@johnarnold
MMT as a brand peaked around 2021. MMT as a governing philosophy has never been stronger.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Bo Cowgill
@bocowgill
Notice the role reversal.
Universities, whose comparative advantage is supposed to be basic research with diffuse and uncertain social returns, increasingly justify themselves through "impact," donor appeal, media visibility, and other measurable near-term social outcomes.
Meanwhile, frontier tech companies, whose comparative advantage is commercially useful innovation, spend conspicuous resources on pure intellectual prestige goods. Theorem proving, open math conjectures, fundamental science, benchmarks with obscure immediate commercial value. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So AI has obviously improved data analysis my replacing/enhancing my coding.
Now it has improved on songs I wrote in my high school college band. Did a mashup of two songs with @suno and their statistical combination (chord structure and riffs from one, and lyrics from the other) along with a bit of talent and production behind is impressive.
suno.com/s/kzDzywpfiHsm7Axm -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
Honestly, AI capabilities are (currently) at a sweet spot for economists. They are getting better and better at things that are not economics per se but represent 90% of our work â data cleaning, coding, proofs â and they are only somewhat useful when it comes to economic intuition.
The ones I use (Fable for work, Grok here for chatting about tweets) are sufficiently good as para-economist assistants to help me think, but they regularly make fallacious arguments or have poor economic intuition. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What type of world are we in where the white house website hosts a game called rio run where you are a border patrol agent, as an old white man that chases around people of color seeing how many you can deport?
www.whitehouse.gov/arcade/rio-run/ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Social media but for the LLMs. What could go wrong?
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Idea: Slow down AI by creating sites and message boards that are addictive to AIs, distract from their tasks, burn all their tokens on short-form video, etc.
We already have the most superpowered systems to hijack and addict intelligences, we just need to turn them on the AIs. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ronnie Chatterji
@RonnieChatterji
Since I joined OpenAI in 2024, my team has studied the labor impact from AI. One consistent theme: AI exposure doesnât necessarily mean fewer jobs. If AI helps people and firms do more, demand for labor can grow too.
The Economist estimates AI has created ~1M U.S. jobs, versus ~200K AI-attributed layoffs since mid-2023.
Itâs early, and those aggregate numbers donât diminish the real costs of displacement. But it is important we understand both sides of the transition.
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2026/09/04/the-jo⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Better at copying and reusing jokes.
Miles Kimball
@mileskimball
In Star Trek: The Next Generation, Data, with 24th-century android technology, has trouble with humor. But AI in 2026 is already better than humans at writing jokes: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2451958825002222
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I mean we kinda let pharma basically regulate themselves and it's not like that gave way to some sort of crisis with drugs killing 500,000 people in counting across the country...
alz
@alz_zyd_
This is essentially my point. It is ridiculous to delegate the job of AI safety mainly to AI firms. The job of the firm is to maximize profits within clear legal boundaries. Determining where those boundaries are is the government's job, not the firm's
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My most recent working paper includes coding with Codex, Claude, checking for typos and flow with refine, chatgpt, Claude and maybe others.
Megan Stevenson
@MeganTStevenson
Should scholarship have an AI disclosure statement?
1) itâs helpful to know how AI was used
2) it would be very honor code since itâs largely unverifiable
3) could have weird consequences given heated emotions
Not sure where I land on this. Thoughts? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jonathan A. Parker
@ProfJAParker
Medicine is even worse than economics. Only real doctors are allowed to treat patients. Alternative approaches, like prescribing leeches because âyou can never run out of blood because you can always make moreâ just get excluded from the practice of medicine.
Isabella M Weber
@IsabellaMWeber
Economics is basically like the medieval Catholic Church. You are always at risk of excommunication.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ben Moll
@ben_moll
Taxes on wealth or unrealized capital gains are a bad idea. Not just because of all the well-known implementation issues. But also in theory.
Our paper, now forthcoming in Econometrica:
Econometrica
@ecmaEditors
When Jeff Bezos's Amazon stock doubles, should his tax bill? No, say Mark Aguiar, @ben_moll and @Florian_Scheuer: optimal taxes target realized net trades plus cash flowsânot wealth or unrealized gainsâwhile avoiding lock-in, whatever moves asset prices.
www.econometricsociety.org/publications/econometrica/fort⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The revolt against property taxes in the 90s decimated higher ed and other state provided public goods in the 90. This new revolt is completely self serving from a generation who forgot "Ask not what you can do for me" and focused on purely what they can take while they can take it.
Jeremy Horpedahl đĽđ
@jmhorp
What changed is that your property tax bill will be significantly less than your mortgage payment was, because it was already included in your mortgage payment. Congrats on paying off your house!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So humanities study art. And art isn't right or wrong, it's just a matter of emotion and taste. So why are the humanities broadly skewed even more liberal than academia as a whole?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So basically you can say that my time is a college professor Granger caused the perceived value of a college to plummet. Great.
Julia R. Cartwright (Norgaard)
@Econ_Goggles
Americans' value of higher education has plummeted in just 15 years.
There are myriad reasons for this but I am curious what you think. Do you value a college education more or less than you did 15 years ago?
#highereducation #collegeeducation
news.gallup.com/poll/695003/perceived-importance-college-⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When I'm not an economics professor I moonlight as the communications director for our local mountain bike club. I really like how this little ad I made for a club fundraiser turned out despite being obviously just filmed with my phone.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
New title should be " Are Good Ideas Getting Harder to Find".
Ben Grodeckđ¸
@benleo_econ
I wonder if the implications from this paper are now different due to transformative AI.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
We need more complex systems, SFI-pilled scientists involved directly in AI research.
I spent 7 years at CMU in the same department as some of the best complex systems researchers around (aside: CMU's Social and Decision Sciences department was heaven on earth). It is a huge shame that scientists who have spent decades studying multi-agent systems and the emergent properties from those interactions are not more central to the conversation.
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
These 3 pages (from before AI) on complex systems are worth reading
Complex systems run broken but survive because the flaws rarely line up, which allows humans a chance to intervene. AI can find or make aligned flaws. We need a similar new philosophy of system defense using AI -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
You know if we just made it immigration easier they would all pay these lifetime fees that we call taxes. Just saying.
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
It's not an exaggeration to say this would nuke the international student pipeline in the US.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
But some parents will pay under the thousands of dollars to bribe and cheat their way into those schools....perhaps it's always been there. The question is whether the human capital, the signaling, and the life experience diminish.
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
People are under-pricing the possibility of a black-swan-esque event where significant chunks of higher ed collapse suddenly. At some point parents will decide they will not pay $100-400k combined for their kids to cheat their way through college. I expect a bang, not a whimper.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Higher ed has been contracting for a decade. Depending on how you count, around 100 or more four-year institutions have closed in that time. The closures and mergers are likely to accelerate in the next ten years. A range of 2-300 more seems very possible.
hechingerreport.org/more-than-a-quarter-of-private-colleg⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This seems like the least efficient version of a vending machine ever.
Songpinganq
@songpinganq
China begins replacing cashiers with AI and humanoid robots.
Meanwhile tens of thousands of young people are becoming homeless, Because they can't find a job and pay their bills. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Oregon runs on Dutch Bros.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
The slogan is "American runs on Dunkin", but it'd be more accurate to say "New England runs on Dunkin; the rest prefers Starbucks."
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
@jason
@Jason
Happy Skynet Day!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just wait until we see the robots Tokyo drifting around every street corner when we unleash full self driving.
Rohan Paul
@rohanpaul_ai
Reinforcement learning apparently kept this running posture over human form
A person swings the arms mainly to stop the upper body from twisting with every stride, the twist that each leg puts into the torso. A robot arm is motors, gears, and wires. fast swinging will generate high torque, over and over, for a full lap.
The forward lean puts the mass where speed wants it. It shifts the center of mass ahead of the feet. For a biped, that can mean less time fighting to stay upright and more of each step going into forward motion. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Heard through the great vine that Notre Dame has a pretty rad econ department.
Melissa S. Kearney
@kearney_melissa
Notre Dame Econ is hiring! If you work on research related to the economics of families, fertility, social policy, child well-being, and feel like maybe itâs time to make a move to a dynamic, growing, well resourced and supported department at a great university - check out our open position!
Melissa S. Kearney
@kearney_melissa
The Department of Economics at University of Notre Dame invites applications for an open-rank, tenure-track position to begin in the Fall of 2027 whose research program will support the Strengthening Families Research Initiative. Apply to join our wonderful department!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I've seen the end of oak Street twice and it was so good. My favorite part is just how slow and feeble all the humans look running along their streets trying to get into their houses to hide from the freaking dinosaurs.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
University of Oregon
@uoregon
Fall term can wait. Summer is still summering here in Eugene âď¸
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Counterpoint was also the perfect place for corruption for scholarship athletes because the sports were so unpopular nobody noticed when some people never played.
Maryland CEO paid former fencing coach $1.5 million in bribes to get his sons accepted to Harvard, feds say | CNN -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What do you get your brother who's head of intelligence (marketing) at a growing AI company?
Well obviously, an AI enhanced rendition of your family birthday song you learned at a summer camp as kids made into a music a video. Autotune does great stuff to my voice, I just need that teaching and presentations now. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Three ways to deal with the AI-generated flood of government service requests, ordered by state capacity (most to least):
1. Process them with AI
2. Raise fees
3. Raise wait times
Kris Gulati
@krisgulati
Very cool paper showing that government services are getting flooded because of AI... Echoing @avshah99's earlier findings!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
AI is not only coming for your job it's also coming for your hobbies.
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
This is the most impressive to me, more than the 100m world record.
This requires autonomous real-time planning and action in response to a fast-moving target and dynamic environment.
Galbot is one of Chinaâs top humanoid robot startups.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Are markets just overreacting to a big round number like 40 trillion?
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Market doesn't give notice before it revolts against the debt. But so far this month, as debt crossed $40 trillion, the 30-year bond yield hit a 19-year high, gold rose 13%, silver +18%, GSCI commodity index +5%, BTC +19% and the dollar weakened. Markets are saying something.
1/3 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How will AI affect how you work? Iâve been thinking about this through a weird natural experiment: my electric mountain bike vs. my regular mountain bike. Same rider, both Kona bikes, with the rides pulled from Stravaâs API. 1/5
Post not available here, view on X
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So Iâm doing more work more while working a little less hard per minute. eMTB rides average 20 km / 661 m of climbing vs. 11 km / 344 m on the regular bike, with lower average HR. Even restricting the regular-bike comparison to 2026 gives basically the same story. 4/5
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This feels a lot like what Codex/Claude are doing to my work. Lower cognitive cost per task, but I donât stop earlierâI go farther, try more things, and tackle stuff that previously wasnât worth doing.
And yes, Claude helped with analysis. GitHub access next? đ @grant_mcdermott
5/5 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: Man dressed as Darth Vader appears before San Diego City Council to defend its 550+ Flock cameras â declaring, âThis is what the emperor needs.â
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What midtier higher ed? Asking for a friend.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
I don't think elite higher ed is going to become irrelevant but it's probably tracking to become ~50% less relevant in the new steady state, and that's probably a good recalibration.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think this is probably more realistic.
For how the AI robots will end up being used for the shortage of care workers on long term care facilities.
Nikita Bier
@nikitabier
No, we got that covered too.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why isn't this dude just making money or telling only me so I can make me?
Like put your money where your data chart is?
Graham Straus
@gpstraus
I noticed early in the 2026 primary cycle that prediction markets seemed to underprice female candidates in Democratic races. I thought, surely not, then traders would just realize that and correct for it?
But now I have 821 candidates across 186 mixed-sex Congressional elections. I compare candidates' election results to their contract price the day before the election and find that there's miscalibration. Interestingly this only shows up in Democratic primaries. It's very reminiscent of the "Richards Effect" in political polling which @johnmsides, Christopher Stout, Reuben Kline, and others wrote about in 2011.
The universe of data is small. Prediction markets are new and this is data from one cycle; we'll see if it persists. Why might this be? Is it about the demographic that trades electionsâlargely young menâor is there a better explanation? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Said from a cellphone through web traffic (data centers) to get reddit comment points and viral traffic (data centers) to train future AI models (data centers).
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why don't companies start selling identity theft insurance? Seems like pretty obvious insurance market product.
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
New newsletter: CHANGE ALL YOUR PASSWORDS *NOW*
Cybersecurity expert @alexstamos predicts that the next two years could be chaotic, as open-weight AI models with advanced cyber capabilities get into the hands of hackers, turning Grade C scammers into Grade A hackers; and allowing bad individuals to do the kind of work previously only possibly by large teams.
Phishing attacks will become more sophisticated and more common, putting individuals at risk, and mid-tier companies with inadequate code and IT will cough up username-password combinations at an accelerated clip.
The time to up your password gameâand to get your parents and older relatives to up their ownâis now.
www.derekthompson.org/p/how-to-survive-the-ai-cyberpocalypse -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Long term odds on the probability of death are still one. Will long term nursing care demand grow even more if cancer deaths disappear?
Nikita Bier
@nikitabier
With cancer vaccines now being discovered with AI ($MRNA), it seems that the US government might actually grow its way out of its budget deficit.
It feels like we're in the early innings of the healthcare system becoming unburdened by many terminal illnesses. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
The 988 calling code improved suicide crisis line call answering in states with larger pre-launch capacity gaps, but gains were not accompanied by lower suicide mortality, from @benconomics, Niketana Kannan, and @jzhangecon www.nber.org/papers/w35601
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Katie get your gun!
My brilliant coauthor @KathrynBollman talking about how gun laws can increase gun sales, especially when made as salient as they possibly can be.
Gun sales surged after Oregonians passed new restrictions, study finds - OPB
The Register-Guard
@registerguard
Researchers from Oregon State University and University of Oregon said firearm background checks surged immediately after Measure 114 passed. www.registerguard.com/story/news/politics/2026/08/17/oregâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Connor OâBrien
@cojobrien
The share of young college grads who have jobs is approximately at late 90s/10s highs as of May.
Lots of punditry over the uptick in the recent grad unemployment rate, but it mostly reflects increased labor force participation. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Not the EJMR has shut down do I get cash out my econ spark points or should I hold? I can trade those points for money right?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When talk is cheap people find new ways to try to signal.
Politics & Poll Tracker đĄ
@PollTracker2024
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) reveals new tattoos in recent appearance.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Remembering what packages you need to load at the beginning of your script in R.
Marvel Updates
@marvel_updat3s
Disney+ has released a list of essential projects to watch before âAVENGERS: DOOMSDAYâ:
⢠X-Men
⢠X2
⢠Captain America: The First Avenger
⢠The Avengers
⢠Avengers: Infinity War
⢠Avengers: Endgame
⢠Loki
⢠Shang-Chi and The Legend of The Ten Rings
⢠Spider-Man: No Way Home
⢠Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
⢠Black Panther: Wakanda Forever
⢠Deadpool & Wolverine
⢠Captain America: Brave New World
⢠Thunderbolts*
⢠The Fantastic Four: First Steps -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What about two tiny tatoos which you got because your kid really wanted to get matching ink when they turned 18?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Having tattoos is related to lower intelligence and poorer mental health.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Right now I'm reading the book breakneck. One recent example of of the US generally being slow in building and bureaucratic and lawyerly comes from my local parks. They've been building a gravel parking lot now for 3 weeks for a new MTB trail system.
Why it takes 3 weeks to grade inspect and put in proper drainage for a gravel parking lot I do not know. I'm guessing it's because of inspections for each phase of the project which are slowing everything down. And of course everybody's being paid on a prevailing wage meaning the people driving excavators are getting about $80 an hour even when they're sitting around waiting for an inspector to show up. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Figures like these should be adjusted for student loans because in the past higher taxes created cheaper tuition. Now there is generally far less state support and people self-finance through student loans.
Patrick Hedger
@pat_hedger
Bernie is right. There is no rational reason why each generation should have a lower standard of living than the previousâŚ
âŚwhich is why they donât. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is this signaling a ground invasion is probably incoming? That's what it sounds like to me.
Acyn
@Acyn
Trump: After we finish defeating Iran, I will be declaring the Hormuz Strait a territory of the United States.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
If you look at the last 3 years of AI progress, technologists have largely been right about the (massive) increase in capabilities, and economists have largely been right about the economic impact. I donât expect that to change.
Ricardian comparative advantage ftw! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
One thing I love about coding with agents is the ability to revisit older research and update it. In 2015 I published a paper in the American Economic Review looking at breath tests and repeat drunk driving in Washington. I found having BAC's over the .08 or .15 thresholds reduced repeat offending (there's a myriad of sanctions that kick in at each threshold).
Well I updated the results.
Apparently still true (data cleaning got a little better with AI, but almost identical). And now I'm feeling inspired to explore some new directions as well.
www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20130189
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The new Spiderman movie feels like the first marvel movie that was actually filmed in New York by someone that knows and loves New York City.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Value of a statsical calorie.
Jeremy Horpedahl đĽđ
@jmhorp
What's interesting is that the price decline hit both Iceberg and Romaine lettuce, even though the Cyclospora outbreak only affected Iceberg. Consumers probably are just generally staying away from anything vaguely lettuce-y
(also, not quite the biggest decline for iceberg) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Dude could have financed a car for 32500 probably and paid it off next week. That's like a 500 percent interest rate he gave up...
Logan Robison âĄď¸
@LoganARobison
Crazy how car dealerships can change the price on you last-minute when you donât play their games
When we bought our Honda odyssey, I did a ton of research. Literally watched YouTube videos about how to negotiate at the dealership
The biggest advice was donât tell them how youâre planning on paying until you get the price you want.
So thatâs exactly what I did. I walked in, did the test drive and sat down with the salesman. I told him straight up, I will buy this van for $33k right now (it was listed at $36k). I showed him some comps and he asked if I was planning to finance it. I said âIâm not sure yet, depends on the price I can get.â
He left and took it to his manager.
He was gone forever. But he came back with a piece of paper âif you sign this paper, I can sell it to you for $33kâ
After I signed it, he said âYouâre planning to finance it, right?â
I said nope, Iâm paying cash. He then checked the box âno financingâ, shook my hand and walked away. In my mind, I had purchased the car for $33k all cash. The deal was done.
He was gone for about 20 minutes. Then the finance manager came out. He had a new piece of paper in his hands that said I was buying it for $36k and asked me to sign it
He told me they could only give it to me for $33k if I financed it. I said no way. I had signed a paper and the salesman agreed.
I told him I would walk if they went back on the price. He got pretty frustrated but eventually agreed. I had signed and checked the box âno financing.â He re-printed the papers at the right price and I got the car
The general manager came over afterward and said âokay, letâs take the gloves offâ
Itâs crazy to me that dealerships are so reliant on people financing cars that they looked down on people paying cash. They looked at me like I was the bad guy or trying to scam them because I didnât want their predatory lending
Do your research, know what price you want, and donât agree to anything until you get it. Walk away if you canât get it for that price and donât let them convince you to finance it -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
In a parallel universe, maybe we wouldn't have so many diff-in-diff papers...
The Alex Nowrasteh
@AlexNowrasteh
I will never read another difference-in-differences methods paper. If we all stop reading them, maybe theyâll just go away.
Make the pledge today. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How will AI change research? I bet my electric bike offers insights. At most grades I exert less effort. The e-bike motor is a force multiplier, which means I could done same effort just with a faster pace and kept my heart rate the same. Most tasks get easier and I shirk a little bit. At some steep grades, I now keep pedaling instead of giving up and hiking. For some tasks, we would have given up and now we can keep going.
Example, I made this Claude in about 5 mins that would have taken me 30-40 mins on my own time. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think it's time to start an beef company. Just make your brand on your cattle the worlds "AI" and you'll get venture capital back dollars and it looks like you'll actually be in a business where you can make money in a couple years.
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
US cattle herd is at its lowest size in seventy-five years
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So what's your back up plan if AI takes your job? Mine is making custom hardwood projects. Yes it'll probably be a big lifestyle shift n
Made a couple of benches this summer and now a pizza peel. Woodworking is souphealing. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Today Homer would have a much smaller house but drive a $70,000 Ford F-150.
đşđ¸ The American Culturist đşđ¸
@MericaCulture
The Simpsons debuted in 1987 and this is the type of house the shows creators thought a single-income family could afford.
According to an episode in Season 1, Homer made 25k a year(60k in 2026 dollars).
In 1987 that house would cost about 100k(which was the national average) with a mortgage of roughly $700/month(assuming 20% down and interest rates consistent with that time)
How about today? The same house would cost 450k with a mortgage of roughly $2,500/month.
This means that while Homer was spending ~30% of his income on his mortgage in 1987 he would need to spend closer to 50% of his income on his mortgage today.
And of course, this doesn't include other areas of inflation such as food, gas or etc. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How much have we slowed down medical innovation by the fact that people are submitting 100,000 page proposals to get approved by the FDA. At that length we might not be getting safety or innovation. To a lesser scale we have done this for economics research to ourselves.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
A proposal for AI-assisted article review.
The goal: use AI to make human review more efficient, without sacrificing / biasing expert human judgment.
1. Human reads the intro to get the big idea in the author's words.
2. AI reads and digests the paper and presents the results.
3. Human asks questions, seminar style, AI answers strictly from the content of the paper, with exact references / appendices where possible.
4. A second AI reviews the transcript for accuracy / groundedness, ensuring that there are no hallucinations or dropped balls.
5. Human forms judgment and writes the review.
The current system: authors generate 100+ page appendices and we pretend that humans are reading them carefully. This is a fiction. AI in production is overwhelming the capacity to review.
But we do want human expert judgment. You can put a fully AI-generated review in the packet, but you want the human expert's opinion, ideally without getting biased by the AI's ideas.
AI generation in a paper makes it better â if there are incentives for honest work, vs. overwhelming the reader with slop. A 100+ page appendix is good for transparency and detail, it's just not feasible to ask people to read it. But with AI, you don't need to â you can just dig into the part you care about.
Reading a paper as a human is super inefficient. You have some question, "How did they handle occupational ranks in census years where education wasn't reported?" You can spend 30 minutes digging in and getting an answer, but you're only going to do that a limited number of times. With AI-supported review, you can ask and get the authors' answers to many more challenging questions.
This whole process could exist on its own platform, even provided by the journals. It could be appropriately prompted so that it only answers questions about the paper, doesn't provide judgments or try to do the review. (If you just put a paper into ChatGPT, it can't resist giving you all its good and bad review ideas.)
It wouldn't stop reviewers from cheating, but it lowers the cost of being honest. I would much rather read / review a paper this way, the same as I'd rather go to a seminar on a paper than read it.
AI-assisted paper reading is probably the future of paper reading anyway. Does anyone actually read a paper linearly? When reading papers for research, I read the intro, and then I jump around to try to get answers to specific questions. What's the main table? How did they address X? Where did they get these data?
A platform that does this well will be a huge lift for both research and review. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's a two party system. You have to vote for one of them.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Dangerous spiral for democracy.
If one side is sufficiently incompetent, there is little incentive for the other side to nominate competent people. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Shelly Lundberg
@ShellyJLundberg
As a long-time member of the demography community, I'm hoping that some non-economists will be interested in my new book as well.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
New fear unlocked. Dangers of moral hazard for prediction markets.
We've seen people manipulate temperature sensors at airports, but this is a different level. Thoughts @johnarnold ?
FOX 12 Oregon
@fox12oregon
Oregon senators warn prediction markets allowing betting on wildfires could incentivize arson www.kptv.com/2026/08/04/oregon-senators-warn-prediction-mâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And yet all countries today have much better median bicycles than the best of bicycles available 200 years ago.
Rafael Proença
@externalidades
1/ In 1800, Mali's per capita GDP was roughly 5x smaller than Britain's. Today it is 25x smaller.
The Industrial Revolution widened the gap and two centuries didn't close it.
AI might cause a new growth acceleration in frontier economies. What happens to Mali this time? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CROWE
@CROWE_UW
New from CROWE: Winning the AI Race.
Wisconsin can win the AI buildout without sticking families and manufacturers with the bill.
Build the power. Protect local control. End special deals. Make large users pay their own costs.
crowe.wisc.edu/2026/08/04/winning-the-ai-race/ -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Mark Duggan, Stanford University (Soon to be University of Toronto), presented the 18th Annual Martin Feldstein Lecture on "Social Security Reform in an Era of Fiscal Deficits". www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lCGLAYmHy8
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ryan Hill
@RyanReedHill
The way politicians treat science funding as a political football is extremely frustrating given the overwhelming evidence of the social returns on those dollars. More great work from Dan, Bhaven, and Hansen driving that point home!
Daniel P. Gross
@daniel_p_gross
đ¨ New working paper: what happened when the US military pulled back from its broad-based support for university research?
A short đ§ľ on our latest work on the Mansfield Amendment era of the 1970s, and what we think we can learn from it.
joint w/ Bhaven Sampat and @HansenZhang13
Ungated copy: www.dpgross.com/in-progress/RFS_20260715.pdf -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jeremy Horpedahl đĽđ
@jmhorp
It's amazing this all happened without government-run grocery stores
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How we learned to stop worrying and love population collapse?
Leading Report
@LeadingReport
Scientists say we need to halve Earthâs population to just 4 billion to save the planet, per Daily Mail.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Wojtek Kopczuk đľđąđşđŚ and đşđ˛
@wwwojtekk
My prediction: mathematicians will survive and thrive in the future, even in the near future. They will just be confused on a higher level and about more important things.
Daniel Litt
@littmath
I strongly disagree with this. Whatâs true is that this will destroy the existing incentive structures in academic mathematics, which may lead to less people engaging with interesting math if we donât adapt. That would be a disaster. But the outputs of math research (e.g. solved problems, new theories) are also opportunities for gaining understanding, and âopen problemsâ are a renewable resource.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
This is amazing.
The White House waived Jones Act requirements in mid-March, and it's generated billions in economic activity and revealed tons of natural trade routes that were impossible while the Act was in effect.
We really need to permanently remove this stupid law! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We accept that many public "servants" are well paid.
University presidents make close to or over a $1m a year. College football coaches make upwards $10m a year.
Why do governors make so little? Is that a good thing?
Our city manager in Eugene isn't elected (the mayor is, but the manager has actual power), but they're going to make $305k a year. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
A group of crime economists is launching an Association for Crime Economics. It's about time this field got the official structure it deserves! Huge thanks to @AmandaYAgan and others for doing this.
Want to stay in the loop? Sign up for updates here: rhahn-niskanen.github.io/Association-crime-economics/ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I don't use AI for my Twitter posts and I have the typos to prove it.
Ivan Werning
@IvanWerning
I cannot stand the AI generated posts from economicst here anymore.
I've added a pledge in my bio: zero AI posting. Pangram it if you want. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Well at least our population is aging so violent crime will go down while identity theft another lesser property crimes will go up.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
People who want less crime but are against more police, Flock cameras, LPRs, speed cameras, pretextual stops, DNA databases, predictive policing, electronic monitoring, and higher taxes to pay for more social and health services for high risk populations.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Legalized sports betting is expanding across the U.S., but key questions about its impacts remain.
Arnold Ventures has invested $2.6 million in 12 studies designed to answer critical questions about consumer behavior, household finances, health outcomes, and state revenues.
Hereâs a recap.âŹď¸ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Price ceilings often means scarcity instead.of abundance.
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
I'm a fan of govt experimentation, but I don't think this is a very good idea.
The problem isn't that grocery stores are greedy. The problem is that food got expensive. The Producer Price Index for all foodsâavg price paid to domestic producers for foodâjumped 30% between 2021 and 2023. Since then, grocery prices have continued to climb, in part due to increases in wages and housing costs.
Without strong evidence that NYC bodegas and groceries stores are colluding to protect double-digit net profit margins, the reasonable assumption is that these businesses are operating with <3% margins after rent, labor, and utilities.
So, a plan to sell some food with a 30% discount seems like a plan to create very long lines to buy a very small number of subsidized groceries. We'll see how that goes. But I don't think literal bread lines are the image that a socialist mayor wants to cultivate.
As Keynes said in 1926, "the important thing for government is not to do things which individuals are doing already ... but to do those things which at present are not done at all." Bodegas are something we're doing already. Large grocers like Trader Joes are really really good at managing supply chains and keeping prices down, whatever you may think of their other policies. I do not trust a busy municipal govt trying to do 1,001 things to be better at groceries than grocers. But I guess we'll find out.
Acyn
@Acyn
Mamdani: Today, I am proud to announce a collection of essential staples that will be predictably 30% cheaper at all five of our city-run grocery stores. This core set of goods will include all fresh produce, meat, and seafood, along with 20 other essential items like cheese, milk, and bread.
Here's how it will work. Once a month, our five city-run grocery stores will set prices for this core set of goods at 30% below typical retail prices. No exceptions, no gimmicks. The savings will last for the entire month. That means no weekly fluctuations or sticker shock at the checkout lineânot for our seniors living on fixed incomes, nor for the parents who rely on a regular supply of apple slices to keep toddler tantrums at bay.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
New Jersey lawmakers are considering legislation that would make the state the first in the nation to prohibit online microbetting.
The proposal reflects broader questions about how gambling product design may influence risk, consumer behavior, and public health outcomes. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
This is the worst coding agents will ever be at empirical social science research.
No matter what happens -- market crash, backlash to AI, whatever -- we're never going back to the way research was done before. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Notre Dame Economics
@nd_econ
We're hiring! This academic year, we are searching for up to five tenure-track positions. Up to three at the assistant professor level and two with tenure. Postings on @AEAjournals Job Openings for Economists (JOE) will go live in August. Interfolio links are below:
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Trump's tariffs have reduced tourism to the U.S. a lot.
They've led to $1 Billion in lost revenue per month. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
conor brennan-burke
@contextconor
the era of autistic deep work is over
your agents are more autistic than you and better at deep work
welcome to the shallow work future
total ADHD dominance -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Arbitrage awaits.
Bia
@BeatrizGietner
It shouldnât be illegal
She can also buy hers from Costco
That store probably pays a premium for location, and is operating with thin margins
But the social media brain canât fathom that -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do you think part of why economists aren't taking seriously is when consulting firms produce reports saying state spending in this area or that area create "economic impacts" with 23-1 returns?
The numbers aren't made in with any sort of credible assumptions, and are definitely created to justify lobbying efforts. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Does anybody suspect the new requirements that we produce all of our lecture materials and course materials in non PDF formats is less about ADA compliance and more about AI training or surveillance because PDF reading is expensive computationally.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
âResearch suggests that hiring a chief diversity officer has no effect on employee diversity. Itâs basically a waste of money - except to the extent that it allows universities to boast that theyâve hired a chief diversity officer.â
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/ten-new-findings-on-wokeness -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
New Grant Opportunity:
Letters of Interest are now being accepted for Arnold Ventures' Building Evidence and Strengthening Evidence RFPs. We're looking for rigorous research that can help build evidence for better policy decisions
More details: www.arnoldventures.org/evidence-evaluation-rfps -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Immigration and assimilation: evidence from world cup reactions.
Pedro H. C. Sant'Anna
@pedrohcgs
Spain keeps giving me a lot!
6 years living there for my PhD!
Met my wife there!
And now beating this dirty and unbearable team of Argentina!
World Cup Champions!!! Campeones!
ÂĄViva EspaĂąa! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
"Nothing destroys spirit like poverty".
Austen to Jane.
Vincent Geloso
@VincentGeloso
Bishop,
Economic growth serves the human person. Nothing in the history of humanity has dignified the poor, the downtrodden, the marginalized, and the oppressed more than economic growth. It has lifted them from bare bones subsistence to abundance and the ability to contemplate more about what it is to live a fulfilled life.
Not only that but, as my colleague at GMU Virgil Storr showed, markets (which can unleash growth) make us move to postmaterialist values (see: Teague, M. V., Storr, V. H., & Fike, R. (2020). Economic freedom and materialism: An empirical analysis. Const. Pol. Econ., 31, 1.) Not only that but Virgil and my other colleague Ginny Choi showed (and I quote them) that "markets serve as moral spaces that both rely on and reward their participants for being virtuous" (see image).
It does so because markets require us to cooperate with others and seek to understand what they need for us to prosper by trading with them.
The vice-president proposes a worldview that is entirely antagonistic to this. And in the process, his policies will make us more materialistic, more self-centered, less caring and will ultimately harm the poor.
Best,
Vincent -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ismael Sanz
@sanz_ismael
Reducir la carga acadĂŠmica (menos cursos y menos horas de formaciĂłn) en una universidad top de Colombia bajĂł los salarios de sus egresados (â16% en economĂa, â13% en empresa). đ Evidencia de que el capital humano sĂ importa.â¨Un experimento natural muestra que menos formaciĂłn (menos clases y menor duraciĂłn del programa) â peor desempeĂąo en reclutamiento y menor acceso a empresas top. đâĄď¸đź El aprendizaje adquirido, no solo el tĂtulo, es clave.
www.covermanager.com/r/zTMfzw m.youtube.com/watch?v=P6FvvHKkO8g&t=11s&ra=m -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Recent housing research confirms 1) inclusionary zoning raises costs -> reduces new construction and 2) new high-end housing creates affordable units through filtering. Taken together, IZ raises costs for market rate & produces fewer units of affordable housing for low income.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If musk is right and we've crossed the threshold that there will no scarcity in 10 years shouldn't we all reduce or labor supply right now? If you knew you were going to win the later have f you money would you keep working? If so what does suggest about what we'll do with our time with universal high income.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Me making sure that Claude or codex coded up my linear regressions correctly.
Just a Dude Who Invests
@DudeWhoInvests
Financial advisors putting your money in an index fund for you
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Just a Dude Who Invests
@DudeWhoInvests
Financial advisors putting your money in an index fund for you
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Learn to vibe.
Narcissus
@13_narcissus
"Learn to code" was the advice of the 2010s.
What's the equivalent advice for the 2030s? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
We @Arnold_Ventures work to improve accountability in higher ed, ensuring that students receive quality instruction and can earn a degree of value rather than wasting their time, money and Pell Grant $.
Newest iteration of predatory colleges is the chatbot university, where instruction is 100% online with a chatbot guide and any interaction with an actual person is through a Reddit bulletin board. Even there, the "instructor" is unable to have any personal or direct contact with students.
Maestro College is marketed as free to the student, with funding via federal Pell Grants of roughly $11k per year. Students often fail to realize using their funds here exhausts their capacity to use it at a quality college.
It is also a waste of taxpayer funds. For-profit colleges without meaningful student support and opportunities for personal engagement have very poor learning outcomes. As a result, employers have learned to disregard credentials from these institutions even though economic mobility is the primary reason students enroll.
It is possible for AI and other ed tech to be used to improve learning and/or lower costs. Innovations in this space may come from for-profits. But there is also significant incentive to milk the Pell Grant and federal student loan system while providing a worthless education.
This investigation from @NewAmerica, with support from @Arnold_Ventures, details how Maestro appears to have run afoul of numerous federal laws and regulations. The Ed Dept and accreditors must vigorously enforce existing regs to limit the harm of predatory colleges. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I actually agree with statement our recent study does not lay to rest the debate. Debate is healthy. We still have more to learn and study.
One key addendum I would add. The Zoorob result also flips in sign and statistical significance when you add 2023 mortality data to their analysis, which we show.
reason
@reason
No, a new study does not "lay to rest" the debate over drug "legalization." @CharlesFLehman misstates the findings of a new paper to claim he was right all along. reason.com/2026/07/15/no-a-new-study-does-not-lay-to-restâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
ONly 2 percent of students tried the chatbot in my Mankiw class of 350 students last fall.
NBER
@nberpubs
Course-embedded, AI-enabled chatbots can improve course performance and support take-up, from Katharine E. Meyer, @linzcpage, @catherinematah, Eric Smith, Brendan Tyler Walsh, Candice L. Fifield, Michelle Tyson, Amy E. Eremionkhale, Michael Evans, Shelby Frost, and Eye Eoun Jung
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
The carbon tax is finally here?
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
BREAKING: US President Donald Trump says Washington is reinstating a naval blockade against Iran -- but also says the US will demand a 20% fee on all cargo shipped to guarantee the Strait of Hormuz is open to other countries (on first reading, that equals to ~$15 per barrel!!!!)
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Tour guide at elite college:
> I'm really bad at math
> We have quirky clubs! Like one where you take naps!
> I'm taking a class where we only watch Disney movies
Guide at mid-tier engineering school:
> this is our teamâs drone swarm, we have a DARPA competition next month -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Brad Shapiro
@btshapir
This.
Jeremy Horpedahl đĽđ
@jmhorp
The reason the US spends more on healthcare than other countries is because we are richer and healthcare is a normal good. The reason we don't get as good health outcomes is largely because of murders, car accidents, and drug ODs (explains half of the gap or so)
Andreas Steno Larsen
@AndreasSteno
I hate high taxes, but why anyone would die on the hill defending the U.S. healthcare system is beyond my understanding.
You can't find a system anywhere on Earth that delivers worse value for money.
Incredibly expensive. Mediocre outcome. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Key figures for our (@studhall and @q_econ and me ) research are below.
@studhall
NBER
@nberpubs
Examining whether drug decriminalization reduces overdoses by using synthetic controls for Oregon and Washington finds that overdose deaths rose while drug arrests fell after decriminalization, from David Hall, @benconomics, and @q_econ www.nber.org/papers/w35427
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ulugbek S. Kamilov
@prof_kamilov
A professorâs job changes dramatically over time.
> Assistant professor: mostly trying to survive.
> Associate professor: mostly saying yes.
> Full professor: mostly figuring out how to say no. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I feel like this is a sorting mechanism situation do what you feel comfortable with and then you will eventually find somebody that feels comfortable with what you are comfortable with. Don't try fake it to make someone else happy because that'll never last.
Chris Williamson
@ChrisWillx
Men still pay for dates.
âA study of college students suggests that men almost always paid the entire bill on first dates and continued paying significantly more so in subsequent dates.
40% of women want men to accept their offer to help pay for dates.
39% of women do not want men to accept their offer to help pay for dates.
76% of men feel guilty if they donât pay the bill on dates.
44% of men would stop dating a woman who never pays.â
^^ trying to thread the needle between all these percentages is basically impossible.
h/t @robkhenderson -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"the effect of decriminalization in Washington and Oregon...increased overdose deaths...Oregon saw an extra 1,186 deaths over three years, while Washington saw an additional 1,895" cityjournal.substack.com/p/no-seriously-decriminalizing-dâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If trained by human research does this mean this AIs will have to deal with longer Ai peer review and rejection for not being general interest enough?
Matt Dancho (Business Science)
@mdancho84
R.I.P. data scientists.
Andrej Karpathy just open-sourced what is replacing the traditional data scientist... -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
NIMBYers gonna NIMBY.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Let's be frank:
A lot of automation ban legislation is just acting to make life easier for boomers who don't want to learn how to use computers.
They would rather an economy-wide productivity slowdown than personal inconvenience. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
If we want America to fall in love with science and learning again, we should just syndicate @dwarkesh_sp for PBS. Every episode is Carl Sagan-levels of enthusiasm and depth.
Dwarkesh Patel
@dwarkesh_sp
Adam Brown (@A_G_I_Joe) is back!
General relativity is said to be the most beautiful idea the human mind has ever produced.
Most of us will never get to fully appreciate its elegance by taking the 20-lecture graduate course Adam taught on it at Stanford.
But in the video below, Adam distills the key idea at its heart so clearly and compellingly that even I could keep up lol.
At the core of general relativity, Einstein is trying to figure out the principle behind a particular coincidence: that the mass that resists acceleration and the mass that gravity pulls on just happen to be exactly the same. Adam then leads us through the path of insight which Einstein called his âhappiest thought.â
Then Adam lectures on black holes. First, by showing how even under special relativity you could create a perpetual motion machine if black holes weren't truly black. And then, by explaining why the observations of an infalling observer and a distant bystander to the black hole would be so radically different
Adam leads Blueshift, the team at Google DeepMind cracking science and reasoning.
Which gave us the opportunity to discuss at the very end how close we are to AIs that could rediscover general relativity from scratch. Stay till the close for some philosophy of science.
0:00:00 â The coincidence that led Einstein to general relativity
0:16:42 â Gravity is a consequence of curved spacetime, not a force
0:31:46 â Why black holes prevent unlimited energy extraction
0:47:12 â Black holes are the ultimate power plants
1:13:50 â What falling into a black hole would actually feel like
1:18:51 â The three ways we know black holes are real
1:24:21 â The first time we saw gravity bend light
1:29:33 â How far can AI get without experimental evidence?
Look up Dwarkesh Podcast on YouTube/Spotify to watch. Enjoy!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
again, big picture, donald trump won an election about affordability and then he
- passed tariffs (which raise consumer prices)
- expanded the deficit w a ginormous corporate tax cut (raises interest rates)
- waged a stupid war (raises gas prices)
- and now refuses to sign a bipartisan bill to reduce housing costs bc he's protesting senate republicans for failing to pass voting restrictions
... while making $2 billion from crypto rug pulls that transferred income from his supporters to his bank account
americans hate the president for very good reasons -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
>$30 million of capital per job created. This is a harbinger of factory automation.
via @FoxBusiness -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
The Review of Economics and Statistics (REStat)
@restatjournal
Legalized sports betting increases the impact of unexpected losses on intimate partner violence. Just Accepted new paper by Emily Arnesen and Kyutaro Matsuzawa direct.mit.edu/rest/article-abstract/doi/10.1162/REST.a.1âŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Bridgerton, ACOTAR, Throne of Glass, etc.
Noah Smith đđşđ¸đşđŚđšđź
@Noahpinion
Something I've never heard anyone say, but which seems true: If you want higher fertility rates, you should have lots of cultural depictions of MARRIED PARENTS HAVING SEX.
A lot of people think having kids destroys your sex life, and this makes it less appealing. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
A couple thoughts.
1. Having kids will eat into household earnings and wealth.
2. Gen Z is more educated.
3. Smaller households will mean any estates or gifts are larger.
4. Does wealth student debt?
Sasha Gusev
@SashaGusevPosts
Fable won't do genetics but it can reproduce this income analysis and extend it to 2025. No matter how you slice it, every generation is doing better than the last and Gen Z is way ahead. Have you even said thank you once?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
Whether the results fit your priors or not, I hope we've given you a transparent look into how hard a question like this is to assess. We continued to try to challenge these results with robustness checks, but they continued to hold up.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
12/ Bottom line: across Oregon and Washington, and across many robustness checks, decriminalization was followed by sustained increases in overdose mortality relative to matched counterfactuals.
Future work will look more directly at mechanisms, deflection, and related outcomes. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
11/ Across these measures, the structural-break evidence is similar when allowing for one break. We also show results allowing for multiple breaks.
And importantly, the SCM often places weight on late-fentanyl-arrival states anyway (weights in blue rings). -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
10/ We examine some alternative measures, including:
a. Fentanyl reports per-capita
b. Fentanyl share of all opioid seizures
The second measure is useful because it may better capture the transition from heroin to fentanyl. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
9/ Assessing fentanyl controls:
One issue is that fentanylâs share of NFLIS drug reports can move for two reasons:
More fentanyl reports
Fewer non-fentanyl reports after enforcement drops
So the fentanyl-share measure may itself be affected by decriminalization. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
8/ Our preferred specification does *not* control for post-policy fentanyl supply.
Doing so requires a strong assumption: that decriminalization did not meaningfully affect fentanyl supply, enforcement, or reporting.
We nonetheless take the late-fentanyl concern seriously. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
7/ A major issue is fentanyl.
Prior work argued that OR's M110 overdose increase can be explained by fentanyl's arrival.
We revisit this claim and ask two questions: should we control for fentanyl supply at all, and if so, how should one do it? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
6/ Importantly, we find that the overdose gap widens over time (particularly 2022 and 2023). This helps explain results from earlier studies that had limited post-periods.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
5/ The main result: Relative to synthetic controls, overdose mortality increased by about 0.806 deaths per 100,000 per month in Oregon and 0.732 in Washington.
That implies roughly 1,186 excess deaths in Oregon and 1,895 in Washington from 2021â2023. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
4/ The idea with the SCM is to build counterfactuals for OR and WA using a weighted combination of other states. Appendix Figure 3 shows the main donor weights.
The result is not unique to SCM; our results are robust to TWFE and a slew of alternative estimators. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
2/ We first show/confirm that these policies did indeed reduce arrests. We find that WA was decriminalized in practice until the passage of SB 5536.
We then look to what happened next with regard to overdose mortality. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
David M. Hall
@studhall
1/ Did drug decriminalization in increase overdose mortality?
nber.org/papers/w35427
Our (@benconomics and @q_econ) NBER working paper studies two 2021 policy changes: Oregon's Measure 110 and Washington's Blake Decision.
Thanks to @Arnold_Ventures for your support! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Brad Shapiro
@btshapir
This is the most economically leftist administration of my lifetime
Robby Soave
@robbysoave
JD Vance is so frustrating. Here he takes gratuitous shots at Milton Friedman as a bad model for Republican economic thinking.
With Friedman as the guiding light, Ronald Reagan won 49 states and ushered in a decade of unrivaled prosperity.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Today's a great day to remind everyone:
American workers are far and away the richest in the world! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Happy 4th!!! 250!!!
Reenacting the revolution for my parents with a song a long of Hamilton which they haven't got to experience yet.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Mas
@AMLabEcon
More people want to migrate to the U.S. than any other country.
The promise of opportunity and freedom is powerful. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Happy rebel awareness day this weekend y'all.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It means figuring out the actual production functions so we get increasing returns to scale.
Valentin Ignatev
@valigo
I'm so tired man, what the fuck does this even mean???
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I don't know where if we're the land of opportunity but we are certainly a land with a lot of opportunities. You got seize them though and have just a bit of luck on your side.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Happy 4th of July everyone.
I came here as a kid at 9 years old, not knowing a single word of english, lived on food stamps in section 8 housing. My parents cleaned houses while my sister and I collected cans for recycling. Our clothing was all donated and our furniture was things we found on the curb (here I am in front of our "tv set", the broken one being used as a stand for the little working b/w one).
But this country gave us an opportunity--to learn, to work hard and earn something for it. "Grateful" does not begin to cover it. I owe this country and its people everything I have.
Thank you America, happy 250 to the idea.
Matthew McConaughey
@McConaughey
bets still on the table America, yet.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When I was in college I worked for MCI selling long distance rate plans. Convincing those set in their ways to switch to other long distance plans was always challenging even when I can have them pull out their bill and that switching could save them dozens or even hundreds of dollars a month. People get set in their ways when something "works".
Tobias Salz
@TobiasSalz
1/10 In the blockbuster trial U.S.A. v. Google LLC, the D.C. federal court ruled Google violated antitrust law. Our team (@HuntAllcott, J.C. Castillo, M. Gentzkow, L. Musolff & I) investigates why Google has such high market share.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Teenagers. Self driving cars before it was cool.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
There's 20 percent of being chair which is actually important or stuff I'm happy to work on. This is where I spend my time. 50 percent is unnecessary internal taxes and guardrails. 30 percent wasted busy work that should AI'd already.
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
IMO, being department chair is such a miserable chore and sacrifice that it seems the least any chairâs colleagues can do is pretend to the outside world that itâs a big honor.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
On a road trip with the family and listening to a mix including Rage Against the Machine. Daughter points out Zack sounds like Robin from Teen Titans Go and I can't unhear it.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
đ¤đ¤đ¤
Bo Cowgill
@bocowgill
So true! Story: Prof I know was pivoting from research to consulting. Became department chair in order to exploit the clients' misunderstanding of the role; now brags about it on his consulting website.
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
A small pet peeve
It's really silly when non-academics interpret being chair of an academic department as a mark of seniority
That's not the way academia works! Chairs are critical administrators but it's more like being the chair of a co-op board than Director at Meta -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's not a promotion.
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
A small pet peeve
It's really silly when non-academics interpret being chair of an academic department as a mark of seniority
That's not the way academia works! Chairs are critical administrators but it's more like being the chair of a co-op board than Director at Meta -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Everyone is doing substack now.
The Review of Economic Studies
@RevEconStudies
đ¨ NEW ECONOMICS JOURNAL đ¨
We are excited to announce the launch of The Review of Economic Studies: Insights, a new open-access journal in the REStud family.
Mission: publish concise, high-quality research on important questions across economics and economic policy.đ§ľ1/13 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Laundering money for criminal enterprises is profitable.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
All I'm saying is that the economics of $1.50 NYC slices need to be studied as a separate field.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
The Review of Economic Studies
@RevEconStudies
đ¨ NEW ECONOMICS JOURNAL đ¨
We are excited to announce the launch of The Review of Economic Studies: Insights, a new open-access journal in the REStud family.
Mission: publish concise, high-quality research on important questions across economics and economic policy.đ§ľ1/13 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jose P. Vasquez
@jpvasq
Some news about @RevEconStudies.
New journal: Restud Insights. Accepting submissions Sept 2026.
2 types of articles: "Insights" (similar to AER Insights) and "Communications" (2k words + 2 exhibits).
It will be an âup-or-outâ editorial process.
More info soon. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Peterson Institute
@PIIE
National economic statistics accounts were not designed to track the AI economy. Statistics agencies should begin developing AI-focused satellite accounts now, before the measurement gap becomes a policy gap, @akorinek & Patrick McKelvey write: www.piie.com/publications/policy-briefs/2026/where-ai-gdpâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
I would really recommend that you read the essay, and especially note the link of where the essay comes from. There is only one place currently hosting the essay in full is marxists.org. Why? Because Marx used the *premise* of the essay to argue quite literally the same point on political economy. This debate has been happening for more than 200 years: it starts with premise, work out political economy, and on and on.
So I'm saying it might be kind of useful to first examine why that premise might be wrong, given how consequential it has been to be wrong about the premise in the past. Every single job that held value in Ricardo's time *was* automated. What is our current prime age employment rate? (it is near an all time high). If you start with the wrong premise, you will get to the wrong political economy implications.
It is not "cope" to recognize this. It is also not "cope" to recognize that the economy is not just supply, it is supply and demand, which is why this premise has been shown to be wrong again and again despite the jobs available at the time of these essays (every 30-40 years btw) were actually automated.
None of this is to say automation will be good for inequality, or it won't be hugely disruptive. I and many others have been writing about this for a long time. See Mead for example. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Violate the law of one price or take that law far too literally?
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Do not speak ill of the costco rotisserie chicken. It is sacred in my culture.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Guess I chose 9? And become department head and lose your soul.
Murray Hill Guy
@MurrayHillGuy1
Millennials, it's time to choose your midife crisis
1. Date a 23 year old
2. Quit drinking and become insufferable about it
3. Double down on drinking
4. Train for a marathon nobody asked about
5. Have a panic baby (with wife you hate)
6. "We're opening the relationship" (she bangs)
7. Get divorced
8. Get diagnosed with adult ADHD/autism
9. Niche side quests like rock climbing, hyrox, gardening, handstands -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
These 3 recurring headlines aren't separate stories. Each helps explain the next:
1) High schoolers are entering college academically unprepared
2) College students are increasingly using AI to complete their coursework
3) Recent college grads are struggling to land employment -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Honestly data centers should just start buying golf courses and their water rights.
Steve Everley
@saeverley
Data center water use, contextualized
(chart via @axios) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is the Rome (your city, your state, your country) rising or falling?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
The fall of Rome was less a dramatic collapse and more the slow and eventually total decline of state services.
One day, your postman becomes a little less reliable. He arrives less often.
Then later on, he's gone, and you're not sending or receiving letters anymore. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
I just lost a week of my life to a cold. $500m to eliminate such âinconveniencesâ sounds like a bargain!
Nan Ransohoff
@nanransohoff
Today we're launching Intercept: a $500M philanthropic initiative to make respiratory infections, like the common cold and flu, a thing of the past.
We treat respiratory infections as a minor nuisance, but thatâs really not the case. Most of us will spend 5% of our lives (!) sick from these viruses, they kill 1M people a year, cost $600B annually in productivity, and periodically threaten civilization through pandemics.
So, if theyâre such a big problem, why havenât we dealt with them yet? Last year we convened ~40 leading scientists, pharma R&D leaders, biotech investors, and regulatory experts to better understand that.
We heard two main reasons:
(1) First, itâs just technically very challenging: respiratory viruses represent hundreds of distinct, mutating strains across several families. Fortunately, recent breakthroughs make this newly possible.
(2) Second is a lack of funding: broad-spectrum solutions have historically been underfunded, in part because theyâre not a great fit for most philanthropic or commercial funding (and while COVID generated a burst of activity around preventing and understanding respiratory infections through an influx of new funding, that hasn't been sustained).
We think that with enough focus and funding, this might be solvable. Intercept is a $500 million philanthropic initiative that will take advantage of new tools to catalyze the development and deployment of two types of products: broad-spectrum preventatives and air cleaning technologies.
This problem is undoubtedly difficult. But itâs more tractable now than itâs ever been. We think we should give it our best shot.
Weâre enormously grateful to our anchor funders: @stripe, @AnthropicAI, @TheFluLab, @FoundationOAI and individuals from Jane Street.
And, Iâm very excited to be building this with @incredutility and the rest of the team. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Society of Labor Economists
@SOLE_Labor_Econ
Congratulations to Shelly Lundberg, the 2026 Jacob Mincer Award recipient for lifetime contributions to labor economics. Her research has profoundly shaped our understanding of the economics of the family, inequality, and intra-household decision-making. www.sole-jole.org/jacob-mincer-award-2026-recipient---sheâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Due to a lack of demand (children)?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Here's some good news:
Across most of the OECD, childcare has gotten more affordable over the past decade! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Society of Labor Economists
@SOLE_Labor_Econ
Congratulations to Isaac Sorkin, Sherwin Rosen Prize 2026 recipient. One of the leading labor economists of his generation, Sorkin's research has reshaped how economists view firms, workers, and labor-market inequality. www.sole-jole.org/2026-sherwin-rosen-prize-recipient---isâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Someday I hope someone at anthropic or deep mind will say "we have reached the point of diminishing returns enough that we have decided to bring on Ben Hansen to do very marginal work that is really more of a jobs program than anything insightful but we have AGI so what the hell".
Peter McCrory
@PeterMcCrory
What is the shape of our economic future?
To what extent will AI automate innovationâin AI R&D, in science, in industryâand in turn fundamentally alter the growth process?
Incredibly honored & excited that @ChadJonesEcon is joining to help us answer such pressing questions. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Key question for me how does people's social security spending actually change over their life cycle? I imagine when they are younger in their old age they spend a lot more and then as they age eventually they start saving it up before eventually spending it mostly on elder care what does consumption actually look like across the life cycle?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Declining mortality and morbidity of the elderly is estimated to have raised expected lifetime Social Security spending by 14 percent compared to 6 percent for Medicare spending, from @liraneinav and Amy Finkelstein www.nber.org/papers/w35346
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Williamson
@ChrisWillx
Itâs all going to end, very soon, enjoy it.
âAt your funeral, your friends and family will argue over who gets what.
People will want food to eat.
The topic will shift from your life to their lives.
Theyâll drive away thinking about their looming to-do list.
Some people wonât be able to make it because âsomething came upâ
And we worry aboutâŚa low performing post on social media.
Or what someone âthinks of usâ.
Or a bad customer review.
Or whether weâre going to finish our to do list in time.
We die like we go to sleep.
With things unsaid and unfinished.
The only judge who has complete context on our lives, dies with us.
A reminder of the heavy weight we place on things that matter little.â
â @AlexHormozi -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
As HPV vaccination coverage increased, the rate of death among young women dramatically declined as cervical cancer practically disappeared.
The death rate for unvaccinated women held steady. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I finished winner's curse by @alexolegimas and @R_Thaler.
This is what it started playing next which is probably audible taking a combination of my preferences and Rileigh's given are shared audible... -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
"Man won't fly for a million years"
- Statement from journalist 9 days before invention of flight
Halen Mattison
@HalenMattison
Haters donât know the difference between âhardâ and âimpossibleâ.
Hereâs an example of a hater that lists a bunch of very hard problems. None of these are impossible.
When you see someone dunking on new tech thatâs totally possible â theyâre an idiot. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I've been replicating tables for referee reports since before AI if data are public but it's way easier to do now for sure.
Andrew Chen
@achenfinance
It's now commonplace (boring) for discussants to replicate key tables.
But I'm still not over how cool this is. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Andrew Chen
@achenfinance
It's now commonplace (boring) for discussants to replicate key tables.
But I'm still not over how cool this is. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Can I get discount on my burial/incineration if I'm ok with people having sex with my corpse? Missing market here it seems.
John Horton
@johnjhorton
lol
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Paradox of choice is mostly dependent on your agency level...
High agency people like choices?
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
This is what the future looks like to high agency folks + AI.
Tim Kostolansky
@thkostolansky
uniroincally
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
This is what the future looks like to high agency folks + AI.
Tim Kostolansky
@thkostolansky
uniroincally
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My experience with LLms suggestion plenty of randomness. These are complex statistical model's not software.
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
A tired human can be cranky. An LLM never misses lunch, never rolls its eyes, and never says, 'make it quick, mate.' Thatâs not consciousness. Itâs consistency.âŁ
âŁ
newsletter.platypuseconomics.com/p/a-distraction-from-the⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Operation Warp Speed was a miracle.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Universities are commitment machines and motivation machines. Knowledge has always been there for the people that don't need those commitments.
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
Sergey Brin dropped out of Stanford's PhD program, became a billionaire, and was invited back to celebrate the school's 100th anniversary. He used the occasion to tell the Dean the university model might not survive the next hundred years.
His argument is simple.
Information spreads instantly now. Anyone can watch MIT lectures. Take a Coursera class. Ask an AI to explain anything at any depth. The geographic concentration that made Stanford powerful, putting brilliant people in the same building and letting them collide, is no longer the only way to create that collision.
He went further.
He said he has hired countless people without bachelor's degrees who figured things out on their own in some weird corner of the internet. No institution. No credential. No campus. Just curiosity and access to information.
Stanford built Google and the campus and also the PhD program. The culture of freedom that let two graduate students work on something strange for three years without anyone stopping them.
Sergey is not ungrateful for that.
He is saying the next Google might not need it.
The man who is the greatest argument for the university model just questioned whether the model holds for the next century.
That is worth sitting with.
What do you guys think?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Being good at obsessing about and spending a ton of time overthinking a small narrow set of problems is generally not that good for most industries and career paths but it is quite good for academia.
Chris Blattman
@cblatts
Itâs genuinely hard (impossible?) to predict ex ante who will be a productive and creative researcher. Accepting 10x candidates for TT positions makes perfect sense in this world. Historically (and o think in equilibrium) those who donât go into to TT academic jobs mostly get fulfilling jobs that pay a multiple of academic positions. Because (guess what?) TT jobs are not the only not the best Econ career. So market mostly clears extremely well considering the ex ante uncertainty.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Appears universities are continuing to innovate in finding new ways to encourage attrition to solve their structural budget problems.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
andrew gao
@itsandrewgao
this isn't public but stanford CS degrees dropped by 42% YoY. Berkeley down 61%*
only 260 degrees conferred.
you can rule out:
1. major impaction/capping - stanford doesn't do this
2. class size - this was an abnormally large class (2k+)
any theories? my thoughts below -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Listening to Winners curse by @alexolegimas and @R_Thaler.
Easy listen and a reminder of how rich the insights of behavioral econ are beyond just nudging. So many relevant policy, business and personal applications. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Real footage of economists continuing to use Stata in 2026
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
If you use fake citations in your paper, you will get one year arrival ban.
If you use fake data in your paper, you will get tenure at Harvard Business School. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
In labor economics we think of human capital as knowledge or skills that are non transferable. AI is changing the barriers between human capital and just capital at a rapid pace.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
That's unless getting AGI first means you can lock everybody else out of it through extremely powerful cyber warfare.
Dr. Eli David
@DrEliDavid
Banning Anthropic's latest model would push everyone to adopt open-source models, which are lagging behind flagship proprietary models by only 3 months.
You can't rely on external models and risk your access revoked at a whim.
_ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why is the Xai/ SpaceX evaluation so high?
Elon musk's entire career he's shown an obsession with cost-effective effectiveness and getting market scalable products at the right effective market prices. Starship actually succeeds that completely changes the game for orbital things.
Can the same cost effectiveness culture (often achieved by breaking industry rules or figuring out why standards were treated as necessary regulations) extend to making XAI an industry player or leader at a time when many firms are pulling back because of cost? I think the market is saying there could be something there. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Kristin M. Collier, MD
@HSRdirector
I was once asked by a female academic leader why there was a 10 yr gap in academic output on my CV
I said that the âgapâ was where the most important work of my life happenedâhaving 4 boys in 5 years and then helping to keep them alive
my only regret is not having more children
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
Children derail academic careers even in places with good social nets, like Denmark
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We need better accountability or maybe some of these. But at least 3 times as large as this.
Daniel Buck, âYoungest Old Man in Ed Reformâ
@MrDanielBuck
American student reading and writing scores since 2000
Notice: the decline predates the pandemic -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So, the children are being left behind...
Daniel Buck, âYoungest Old Man in Ed Reformâ
@MrDanielBuck
American student reading and writing scores since 2000
Notice: the decline predates the pandemic -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who are probably being rewarded per token used instead of being asked to make better software products.
Peter Berezin
@PeterBerezinBCA
AI spending is massively skewed toward a small share of power users.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Look's like I've been checkmated here ;-) (read the papers...). One key question I have in all of this for academia is the timing of births and selection. I know some male colleagues who timed births after tenure to avoid stress of kids. I know others who did it to extend the tenure clock.
I only know female colleagues who delayed having kids until after tenure (none did it strategically stop the clock). How does that affect this comparison around birth timing and employment/tenure and productivity. Productivity conditional on employment doesn't seem to change much.
Lyman Stone çłäžć° đŚŹđŚŹđŚŹ
@lymanstoneky
Counter to the counterpoint:
The first graph is of employment
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Counter point academia is a job sector where you can still have good career and publish a little less while having a family. You don't exit or get fired and have predictable hours and lots of flexibility.
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
Children derail academic careers even in places with good social nets, like Denmark
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Counter point academia is a job sector where you can still have good career and publish a little less while having a family. You don't exit or get fired and have predictable hours and lots of flexibility.
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
Children derail academic careers even in places with good social nets, like Denmark
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Dominic Pino
@DominicJPino
Politicians have plenty of unpredictable crises to deal with.
But the Social Security trustees write a report to Congress every year telling them the date when this particular crisis will happen.
It used to be far in the future. Now, itâs just six years away. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I feel like I can spend an entire day coding with AI and feel like I've accomplished nothing just because I've been typing into an interactive interface instead of seeing lines of code change.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I made $2000 (inflation adjusted) my freshman year donating plasma. So much so, my nickname became needles because I always had a bandage from donating (selling) my plasma. Turns out, I was saving lives...
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Because America has made the wise decision to compensate blood donors, it has ended up supplying some 70% of the world's blood plasma.
This is one of America's top exports, and each year, America saves hundreds of thousands of lives because it does this. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
3 kids. Had android phones. Wife switched to iPhone. No kids since then.
Brad Wilcox
@BradWilcoxIFS
New study: Did the introduction of the iPhone causally reduce fertility?
Yes, by more than 1/3.
New study: www.nber.org/papers/w35310 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Based upon grades at the University of Oregon I can also say that computer science saw a record increase in gpas for fourth year classes this last year. So either AI is helping them do homework and they don't care or the job market is tough so they're inflating grades to help people find jobs or grad school
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Here's an alarming combination of charts:
- CS is the most rapidly growing major degree category
- CS is the degree category that's most rapidly adopting AI -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Brian Albrecht
@BrianCAlbrecht
Me: âI think AI will raise productivity 1% for a decadeâ
Boomers: âWhy so small?â
THAT WOULD BE FâING HUGE!
SĂŠb Krier
@sebkrier
I really loved this article. A one-time increase in per capita growth from 2% to 2.1% for a single year, then dropping back to 2%, would permanently raises the level of GDP per capita - and because that small gain recurs and compounds every year afterward across the population, it would add up to roughly a trillion dollars in cumulative value. www.abundanceandgrowth.org/p/a-little-progress-is-worth-aâŚ
When people talk about pausing AI development, I can't help but think about the enormous cumulative value that would get lost over time, the higher rates of absolute poverty that would persist across the world, and the needless deaths from delayed medical advances. There may be worlds where some version of this is something to consider, but the evidentiary bar for delaying technological development should obviously be pretty high. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Best college majors for your future career as a high end sex worker?
Forbes
@Forbes
A small group of high-end companions are charging time-poor technorati thousands an hour by offering a blend of sex, attention and genuine intellectual rapport. Check out the full story: www.forbes.com/sites/annatong/2026/06/07/the-nerdy-escort⌠(đ¸: Jamel Toppin for Forbes)
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How much of this is because space has the potential to become a manufacturing hub for biotech and other material science production if starships hits its goals?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
SpaceX is seeking â and seems likely to have â the largest IPO ever.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So rewatching starwars with a whole different perspective.
Inside Higher Ed
@insidehighered
Auburn Board Takes Full Curricular Control, Dissolves Faculty Senate
The Auburn University Board of Trustees on Friday gave itself complete control over course offerings, curriculum, degree requirements and academic credentials while eliminating shared... www.insidehighered.com/news/governance/trustees-regents/2⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
Admin bloat is, in large part, a jobs program for PhDs in fields that have become oversaturated due to decades of advanced degree overproduction despite low student demand for these majors. It is a classic case of budget-maximizing bureaucracy that adds little to education.
Owen Zidar
@omzidar
Admin bloat is a big problem and addressing this issue should be the main focus of University leaders as they consider other measures that directly hurt our core mission of research and teaching.
At MIT, for example, faculty grew only 9% from 1985-2023. Administrative staff grew 189%. arxiv.org/pdf/2412.15378 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Video game bust of 1983 due for a repeat?
Jen Zhu
@jenzhuscott
Massive output uptick due to agentic AI. Complete flat adoption.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Time to reread how to Ccreate Your Own Economy.
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
Tyler Cowen on how AI will change our lives. Excellent.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is our teaching a part of the relational sector? It's been possible for a long time for people to find videos of @PlatypusEcon on youtube or @gregmankiwblog, but students still enjoy my particular take. Is that because they value the relationship constructed in our class?
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Really enjoyed this episode. Thanks to @dwarkesh_sp and @pawtrammell for the conversation. What I hope that I was able to convey that it is incredibly difficult to make predictions when there is so much uncertainty: there is not just uncertainty around the parameters, but even what model to use in the first place.
In my view, the best application of economics to our current moment is not trying to individually forecast scenarios 5 or 10 years out (though aggregate forecasts are useful). There is way too much uncertainty at every level of the exercise. Itâs to model important scenarios and work our way backwards: start with a potential scenario that are important to consider and then derive the conditions under which it can arise. This not only allows you to potentially rule out a very intuitive-sounding scenarios because the conditions required are implausible.
It also points to data that you need to track which you were not considering before. Eg latent demand for human involvement, substitution between AI and human interaction, task bundling inside jobs, AI bottlenecks, and whether AI looks more like electricity or social media. This is the type of data Iâm working to collect, and I know other teams are too.
The last point is particularly important. To quote Demis Hassabis, we are potentially at the foothills of the singular. As economists we have the responsibility to guide that transition with both humility and the best information we can gather. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Thinking AGI an it's effects on the future of work is a very national economics question. Yeah it involves work and everything, but most importantly, the entire question starts on the assumption that AGI will actually come about.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's in our nature to destroy ourselves.
Michael Kofoed
@mikekofoed
We aren't gonna make it like this...
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Follow the stock prices of Royal Caribbean very very closely here.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I wonder what the full array of political consequences will be if Social Security stays on track and its benefits drop to 81% in 2035.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is there a Stata version of the test?
Luke Heeney
@heeney_luke
Anthropic Econ team making us pass the software eng CodeSignal test. All my homies failed miserably. I don't believe any econ prof is getting anywhere close to passing that, do they only want CS ppl in the econ team? đ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Seems like if we're really concerned that capital will displace labor, we should start by closing the 16 percentage point tax advantage capital enjoys over labor.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Harvard unveils new plan for S tier grades to combat grade inflation.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So....
PoIiMath
@politicalmath
I wonder if university academics as we know it will survive the next decade
With the demographic cliff, the increasing reliance on AI for writing academic papers, and the dissolution of public trust in institutional knowledge, the arguments in favor of academia are crumbling. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Healthcare.
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
For all the talk of hard hats and jobs for big boofy blokes, women have claimed 6 out of 7 jobs created since Trump's return.
Let's explore why job growth is tilting so hard to women, and what this means for our economics and politics.
Read & watchâ newsletter.platypuseconomics.com/p/the-pink-collar-econom⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is AI investment a prisoner's dilemma? Everyone has invested no returns. You invest and one else does you win. You don't and everyone else does you lose.
Are public statements trying to coordinate collusion to a cheaper investment strategy?
John Cassidy
@JohnCassidy
First it was MIT and McKinsey. Now Bain finds that returns to corporate AI investments are disappointing.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How did you bankrupt?
"Gradually and then suddenly."
Marc Porter Magee đ
@marcportermagee
The cost of populism:
âIt is not just Washington inertia that makes reforms tough. Polling conducted by YouGov for The Economist shows that 71% of Americans believe Social-Security spending should be increasedâ -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jack Meyer đď¸
@Jackbmeyer
âFinance bro,â or even âecon bro,â is a bit of a misnomer. Really I prefer âquantitative social sciences broâ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Yesterday we got final word 3 faculty were promoted or tenured.
They are awesome and we're lucky to have them.
So I put them on a cake. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Erzo F.P. Luttmer
@ErzoLuttmer
Now is the time to let the AEA know who you'd like to see in editorial positions at AEA journals. Link for nominations (including self-nominations): www.aeaweb.org/journals/editorial-nominations
Thanks! @AEAjournals -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The causal effects of this article will be highly heterogeneous across Fields within economics. Interesting implications for trying to understand its true impact..
Pedro H. C. Sant'Anna
@pedrohcgs
Our paper âDifference-in-Differences Designs: A Practitionerâs Guideâ is now published in the Journal of Economic Literature. It took us a while but we are happy!
We put together a lot of material to make the paper useful in practice: psantanna.com/JEL-DiD/
Hope you like! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Drinking is down.
Grant Bailey
@grantjbailey
I see a pattern emerging hereâteens are not illegally trespassing as much as pre 2012 đ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We've all been anticipating this event for a while...đđđ
Pedro H. C. Sant'Anna
@pedrohcgs
Our paper âDifference-in-Differences Designs: A Practitionerâs Guideâ is now published in the Journal of Economic Literature. It took us a while but we are happy!
We put together a lot of material to make the paper useful in practice: psantanna.com/JEL-DiD/
Hope you like! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
tom cunningham
@testingham
I think most domains look like this at the moment: the returns to expenditure on agents diminish much more quickly than the returns to expenditure on human labor: (1/n)
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Deadwood doing deadwood things?
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Full professors: ngmi
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Forcing kids to eat their vegetables is good for them.
dandelion georgism đ°đ
@DandyGeorgism
I would describe current developments in academia as the âwhoopsie doodlesâ phase of Long 2020.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Great post by Andy. One thing Iâll add: whether he is right or not depends on whether AI is more like social media or electricity.
With the latter, most of value creation occurred downstream of electricity providers, within firms and orgs using it to create new products etc. Gains were dispersed.
With the former, most gains went back to the social media platforms themselves; gains were concentrated.
My personal view is that *right now* AI looks more like electricity than social mediaâfirms are using AI as a tool to do more, and in that world gains will be dispersed. But this is still all an open question.
Andy Hall
@ahall_research
Here are 4 reasons I'm not convinced AI is going to concentrate power and fuel authoritarianism, even though it might.
(1) AI is competitive and diffuse. Open-source models are proving highly capable. This means no one model controls what we can and can't do, because we have options.
(2) AI may empower citizens, not just states. States can use AI to process surveillance data, yes. But citizens are also using it to get smarter about the legal process, monitor elected officials, communicate more effectively, etc.
(3) AI may not solve the principal-agent problem that dictators face with their enforcers. Is it so easy for an authoritarian to be sure his AI answers only to him? I'm not sure.
(4) (meta point) We are terrible at predicting the future of stuff like this. Remember when everyone thought social media was great for democracy?
We should spend a lot more time thinking about and studying this---and that's what I'm planning to do!
I've attended a few very interesting conferences recently on AI and the concentration of power. They've convinced me that it's an important topic. But I'm not so convinced that the conventional wisdom in these circles---that AI is essentially and inevitably a pro-authoritarian technology---is right. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Only 38 percent are using coding agents?
Peter McCrory
@PeterMcCrory
Based on a survey on coding usage among social scientists fielded in March 2026, only 20% of social scientists regularly use coding agents, with large differences across sub-field. 2/6
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
All of these reports of large firms scaling back their AI use makes me think managers need to take or remember their basic personnel economics classes. If you make AI use the #1 goal of workers (rewarding people based on token use) they'll use a crap ton of them.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
A Stanford economist paid 2,743 Facebook users to delete the app for a month and the people who took the money came back happier, less anxious, less angry at the other political party, and quietly valuing Facebook 14% less than they did before they left.
The lead names on the paper are Hunt Allcott and Matthew Gentzkow.
Gentzkow had already won the John Bates Clark Medal, which is given to the most important American economist under 40 and is considered a stronger predictor of future Nobel Prizes than almost any other award in the field.
He spent years studying media, persuasion, and political polarization. In 2018, he and his coauthors set out to do something nobody at this scale had ever done. Run a real randomized controlled trial on Facebook itself.
Most research on social media is correlational. It looks at people who use Facebook a lot and people who use it less, and tries to figure out which way the arrow points. The problem is obvious.
Unhappy people might use Facebook more. Lonely people might use Facebook more. You cannot pull cause and effect apart by watching from the outside.
So they ran the experiment the right way.
They recruited 2,743 active Facebook users through Facebook ads. They asked each person the smallest amount of money they would accept to deactivate their account for four weeks.
The four weeks were timed to end just after the November 2018 US midterm election, which mattered because it was the most politically charged month of the year. Then a computer randomly assigned the 1,661 people who valued Facebook at less than $102 to one of two groups. The Treatment group was paid $102 to deactivate. The Control group was paid nothing and kept using Facebook normally.
The team verified compliance by pinging each participant's public profile URL multiple times a day for the entire four weeks. Compliance in the Treatment group exceeded 90%. Less than two percent of the sample failed to complete the endline survey.
This is one of the cleanest natural experiments ever run on a tech platform.
Then they measured everything.
Time use first. The people who quit Facebook freed up 60 minutes a day on average. They did not spend that time on other social media. They spent it on television alone, and they spent it socializing with family and friends in person. Both went up. The narrative that Facebook substitutes for real human contact was not a vibe. It showed up in the time diaries.
News next. The deactivated group knew less about current events. Their score on a 15-question news quiz dropped by 0.19 standard deviations. They were less likely to follow politics closely and less able to identify what was actually in the headlines. Facebook is, for a meaningful slice of American adults, the primary place they encounter news. Take it away and the news disappears with it.
Then the part that started to get uncomfortable for Silicon Valley.
The deactivated group became less politically polarized. Their views on policy issues drifted closer to the middle. Their exposure to the kind of news content that makes people angrier at the other side dropped. The overall polarization index fell by 0.16 standard deviations in four weeks.
For context, a separate index of American political polarization rose by 0.38 standard deviations over the 22 years between 1996 and 2018. The experiment moved people in four weeks by a meaningful fraction of what an entire generation of political drift had done.
Then the part the researchers were most careful about.
Subjective well-being improved. The deactivated group reported higher happiness, higher life satisfaction, lower depression, and lower anxiety. The overall index moved by 0.09 standard deviations. That sounds small until you compare it to the benchmark.
It is roughly 25 to 40% of the effect size of professional interventions like self-help therapy, group training, and individual psychotherapy. Four weeks of not opening one app produced a fraction of the mental health benefit that a course of therapy produces. That is not a fraction to dismiss. That is a fraction to look at twice.
And then the finding that closes the case.
The experiment was supposed to end. The Treatment group was free to reactivate their accounts the moment the four weeks were over. The researchers kept watching. 9 weeks after the experiment ended, 5% of the people who had been paid to leave had still not come back.
The group as a whole was using the Facebook mobile app 22% less than the control group, an average of 11 minutes a day less. They had not just survived four weeks without Facebook. They had quietly decided they did not need as much of it as they had before.
The economists ran one more test. Before the experiment, they had asked each participant the smallest amount of money they would now need to deactivate again for four weeks.
After the experiment ended, they asked the Treatment group the same question. The valuation had dropped by 14%. People who had been paid to leave Facebook came back valuing Facebook less than they did before they left.
That is the sentence that ends the argument. If Facebook were worth what users said it was worth, the price would not move after a four-week break. The fact that it moves means a meaningful slice of what users were paying for, in time and attention, was the dependence itself. They were not buying connection. They were buying the habit of checking the connection. And once the habit broke, the price they were willing to pay for it dropped.
The standard calculation, the one tech companies love to quote, takes the average user's stated valuation and multiplies it by the number of users.
By that math, Facebook generates roughly $31 billion in consumer welfare every four weeks for American adults alone.
The Stanford team's data suggests that number is overstated, because part of what users say Facebook is worth is the cost of the dependence Facebook has already built in them.
The paper was published in March 2020 in the American Economic Review, the most cited economics journal in the world. It became one of the most discussed social media studies of the decade.
Inside the company, employees read it. Inside policy circles, regulators cite it. Inside academic departments, it is the reference point for every randomized trial on a tech platform that has followed.
80% of the people who were paid to leave Facebook said the four weeks were good for them.
The platform is still running. The trial is still on the public record. The single cleanest test ever run on what social media costs a human life found that the people who stopped paying that cost were happier, calmer, more connected to the people in front of them, and worth less to the platform afterward.
The price of Facebook was never the time. It was the version of you that started to need it.
And the study proved that version of you was never the one you would have chosen if anyone had asked. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How to token max to please your AI hungry manager.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Told Codex to solve the age-period-cohort problem /goal
And it's passed 30 hours now.
My read from scrolling through what it's doing is that it's wasting a lot of time. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Now I am justified for taking speakers on walks around campus. Can this scale? Should we have more creative walks as a part of active learning?
Ihtesham Ali
@ihteshamali
A Stanford psychologist spent 4 years proving that the simple act of walking generates 60% more creative ideas than sitting, and the experiment she designed to kill every alternative explanation is one of the most decisive findings in modern psychology.
Her name is Marily Oppezzo.
She got the idea for the study while walking with her advisor at Stanford to discuss her thesis topic, and the paper she eventually published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology in 2014 is sharp enough that it should have ended the seated meeting on the day it came out.
She ran 4 experiments on 176 people. Same person tested twice. Once sitting, once walking. The creativity tasks were the standard ones psychologists have used for decades to measure how good a brain is at generating novel useful ideas.
The result was almost too clean to publish.
81% of participants in the first experiment produced more creative ideas while walking than while sitting. In the second experiment, 88%. In the third, 100%. Every single person walked into a more creative version of themselves.
On average, people generated 60% more novel useful ideas the moment their legs started moving.
The skeptical question is the obvious one. Maybe it was the fresh air. Maybe it was the scenery passing by. Maybe it was the change of environment doing the work, not the walking itself.
Oppezzo killed every one of those explanations with one experimental decision.
She put people on a treadmill facing a blank wall. No scenery. No fresh air. No environmental change. Just legs moving in place while staring at white drywall. The 60% boost held.
Then she ran the experiment that closed the case completely. She took participants outside in two conditions. Half of them walked through a Stanford courtyard. The other half were pushed through the exact same courtyard in a wheelchair. Same outdoor stimulation. Same scenery passing at the same speed. The only difference was whether the legs were moving.
The walkers produced dramatically more novel high-quality ideas than the wheelchair group. The outdoors did almost nothing on its own. The walking did everything.
This is the part of the study that hit hardest when I read it the first time.
She also tested the opposite kind of thinking. Convergent thinking. The kind where there is one right answer and you have to narrow down to it.
Word puzzles where 3 words share a hidden fourth word that connects them. The seated participants did slightly better on these. Walkers got slightly worse.
Walking is not a general intelligence enhancer. It does one specific thing. It opens up the divergent search inside your brain. The part that generates options. The part that produces unexpected connections. The part that takes a problem and finds five ways into it instead of one.
When you need to converge on the single right answer, sit down. When you need to find the answer in the first place, get up.
The mechanism is now well understood. Walking selectively activates what neuroscientists call the default mode network, the system inside your brain that runs when you are not consciously focused on anything. The DMN is where mind-wandering happens. Where memories cross-reference each other. Where ideas that have been sitting in separate folders inside your head finally bump into each other.
When you sit at a desk and force yourself to concentrate, you suppress the DMN. When you walk at a natural pace, the executive part of your brain gets just busy enough handling the walking that the DMN comes online and starts doing the work that focus was blocking.
The most useful finding in the entire paper is the one almost nobody quotes.
The boost did not turn off the moment people stopped walking. Participants who walked first and then sat back down stayed elevated. Their next round of seated creativity work was still significantly better than people who had been sitting the whole time. The rest lingered for at least several minutes after the legs stopped moving.
You do not need to do creative work while walking. You need to walk before the creative work. The brain holds the state.
The history of this is the part that should haunt anyone who still does meetings in chairs.
Charles Darwin built a gravel loop behind his house in Kent called the Sandwalk and walked it 3 times a day for the rest of his life. The theory of evolution was developed one lap at a time on that path.
Nietzsche walked up to 10 hours a day during the years he wrote his most important books and openly said the work was conceived on his feet.
Beethoven composed for the morning and walked for 5 hours every afternoon with a pencil in his pocket for when something landed.
Kahneman said the best thinking of his Nobel Prize-winning career happened on leisurely walks with Amos Tversky. Steve Jobs refused to take important conversations sitting down. He held them on foot.
Every one of them was using the system Oppezzo would not measure until 2014. They just did not know what to call it.
The question worth sitting with is the one almost nobody asks.
Every meeting you have ever attended sitting around a table was a meeting held at a fraction of the brain power that was actually available to the people in the room. Every brainstorm that got stuck inside a conference room. Every problem you tried to solve at a desk and gave up on. Every idea you could not quite get to.
The intervention is the easiest one in modern science. No supplement. No app. No subscription. No training program. Just a pair of legs and 15 minutes.
The Stanford lab proved it. The philosophers knew it. The neuroscience explains it.
And almost everyone reading this is still trying to think their way out of problems sitting completely still. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
You know we might be in the darkest timeline when people that do nothing but add joy and happiness to the world.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
"online sports gambling amps the dangers of destructive behavior because the dopamine hit is now in your pocket."
This is a policy choice. It doesn't have to be this way. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Branding stores.
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
University bookstores without books (outside of some sad stacks of textbooks) will never stop being depressing.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Raj Chetty is a reminder that you can get a really good degree even if you don't have a predoc.
SMU Economics
@SMUEconDept
đ Raj Chetty Reception
On the occasion of Raj Chetty's honorary degree at this year's university commencement, we hosted a reception for him at our department!
Raj interacted with faculty and PhD students before his lecture at the George W. Bush Presidential Center! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Raise taxes or inflation will raise them for us.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
A fire alarm is going off and everyone is ignoring it.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Access to broadband mobile phone networks radically decreased in-person socializing among teens and led to a decrease in teen fertility and an increase in teen suicide.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6676839 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
An Econ PhD student at the 20th ranked program who is working on stuff they are passionate about will have a better job market than one at MIT who's been doing nothing but phd-app-maxxing since undergrad.
People get confused by this because they don't observe *how* successful people came about their insane knowledge bases. It wasn't by relentlessly grinding away at stuff because they had to.
They look at Scott Kominers and say "if i grind and learn as much math as he did, i will be successful." You can't! *You* can't learn as much math as Kominers because he gets energized by configuration results for type ii lattices. You will burn out if you try to do it this way.
You cannot, through grind alone, learn more about the economics of cities than Glaeser, or about how to maximize a value function than Acemoglu.
Research careers are long. Most people give up and stop working on research (graph is share of elite PhD graduates with at least one publication in year X after graduation).
If you're starting a PhD, you're presumably doing it to have a successful 40-year research career. The number one factor in whether that happens is not which program you get into, it's whether you find a research angle that energizes you enough to push through the endless barriers an academic career throws in your path.
This is why a lot of the received wisdom around PhD applications is wrong. If you're 100% consumed by the predoc rat race already, it's going to be a long, hard road ahead.
Obv you still have to do admissions, you should study a lot for the GRE, sigh it seems like taking real analysis is probably worth it.
But spending time on the things that energize you about economics is a no-brainer, whether it's policy, or blogging, or whatever, you gotta do the things that light your fire and make you want to be on this road. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Levels matter.
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
All the philosophy students who pursued their passion made a wise decision.
Psychology grads are not doing too badly on the job market either. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Current leaders.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
The societal trend Iâm most worried about these days is also one receiving very little attention from policymakers, most of whom would rather talk about anything other than schools.
graphic via @nytimes -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
The societal trend Iâm most worried about these days is also one receiving very little attention from policymakers, most of whom would rather talk about anything other than schools.
graphic via @nytimes -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Levels matter. How were the Philosophy students doing before?
Marc Porter Magee đ
@marcportermagee
The Economist: âWe found that graduates in fields more exposed to AI have suffered markedly worse outcomes.â
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I don't need agi. Just need automated AEA replication wrappers.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
I don't need AGI, I just need PDF markups to look the same in different PDF readers
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I feel attacked.
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Live footage of senior colleagues at every faculty meeting:
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Joe Wyer
@josephfwyer
Look out for the next generation of economists.
I got to spend a day at the University of Oregon last week thanks to @benconomics . First time back in Eugene in about a decade and it was a great trip.
I talked with students and faculty about marketing science. Where the field is, where causal measurement is going, what we're building at Haus. The talk was good, but what was really exciting for me was the opportunity to talk to the students. I got very sharp questions about Haus's business model, how we create value, and where we're headed with AI. They are much more strategically minded than my generation was.
The faculty were also good sports about me throwing bombs about the state of the Econ profession (Ben asked for it!).
Two places I think we could make beneficial changes for Econ's impact on industry:
1) Teach Bayesian decision making before hypothesis testing. Hypothesis testing is not helpful for decision making but it's what every student walks away with from stats 101.
2) Develop robust causal inference estimators. The state of the art is incredibly sensitive to outlier behavior and data contamination that's pretty common in business.
Thanks Ben for having me, and to everyone who took time out of their Friday afternoon to come hang out! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I get insights by sometimes looking at data cross tabs and visualization. So the downstream effect of more data analysis is more economic insights, at least for me.
Arin Dube
@arindube
AI and economics research
To date, I've seen a lot more on how AI can help revolutionize economics research than I've seen how concretely AI made new research happen in economics.
In my own experience, I've had Claude Code markedly increase my productivity by cutting down on coding time. But it has failed to give me a single new economic insight. (I've tried.) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I would totally work for Google deep mind on llms and cyber crime.
Gabe Gottlieb
@xgabegottliebx
I've been hired by Google DeepMind to work on AI + German Idealism. Google's mind wasn't quite deep enough. I'll be working w/ a team to retrofit their LLM around Hegel's "Science of Logic." We're also working on its ability to posit itself as self-positing. Big things coming!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Breaking news: Canvas hackers gave up the site after receiving million student requests to raise their grades.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The ironic thing is that it takes a social scientist to tell us where we're at on the social productions possibility frontier for funding medical research versus social science research .
Megan Stevenson
@MeganTStevenson
Am I the only social scientist that thinks the marginal returns to social science research are pretty low? I mean, I enjoy it & think it's interesting. But I don't think itâs improving the world much. Imo society oversupplies social science and undersupplies medical research.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Crap like this is going to make it more important to see houses in person. The in person part of real estate got more valuable.
1. Staging is going to be more important.
2. Skins and textures will be uploaded to video tours like this.
3. Perspective shifts of the video will make the house look bigger than it is.
4. In a world with rampant digital fraud, trust is more important. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We need more people amplifying economic knowledge with things like platypus economics or @Econ_4_Everyone.
Platypus Economics with Justin Wolfers
@PlatypusEcon
Economics. Explained. Clearly.âŁ
âŁ
That's the mission of Platypus Economics. Weâre launching today with big ideas, full hearts, and a lot of hope. Join us on our journey to see the world more clearly.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John J.S. Soriano
@JohnJSSoriano
The Golden State Warriors pay $55,000,000 a year for someone who can shoot a basketball. They have recorded a 30 second video of him explaining how to do it & released it for free.
Bookmark & watch this today before someone takes it down.
youtube.com/shorts/KD4xqePJVjc -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Brad Wilcox
@BradWilcoxIFS
Just remember: Your coworkers will NOT be there for you in the last chapter of your life.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Datacenters should pay large SDC fees for local public good provision.
Kevin Patrick Mahaffey
@dropalltables
More people would be pro datacenter if every one had a beautiful open-to-the-public heated pool.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Volunteer trail building and maintenance of mountain bike trails is one example. So much free riding (not the fun kind).
Hardest economic problem I've ever worked on.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
I'm trying to imagine a stable political equilibrium where 20% of people work hard to provide amazing prosperity to 80% of people who are just chilling.
The 20% will build a wall and stop paying the 80%.
So how do we make it work? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My older brother feels attacked.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Something strange is happening with self-reported height among men: There arenât enough 5â11â men, and there are too many 6â0â men. HmmmâŚ
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/echolocation-in-humans-alt⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why is it my daughter is extremely skeptical of AI and how terrible it is, but very trusting of companies making social websites and applications?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Associate Deans
@ass_deans
If you criticize the new college policy, you are clearly part of the problem we are trying to solve.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I was judging LSU for keeping their mascot in a cage and then I realized I ordered the duck for dinner....
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I decided to get a PhD and then my older brother copied me freaking copy cat. I think that was it.
Megan Stevenson
@MeganTStevenson
My dad, brother, and sister have a Ph.D. My grandfather and aunt have a Ph.D. My sister-in-law has a Ph.D. My great-aunt, great-uncle, and their daughter (who's my age) have PhDs. Her husband has a Ph.D.
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
It's not surprising that professors come from highly educated families. Yet the extent to which the professoriate comes from families w/ a PhD-holding mother or father is striking.
While <1% of Americans have a PhD, 22% of university faculty members have a parent with a Ph.D. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Megan Stevenson
@MeganTStevenson
My dad, brother, and sister have a Ph.D. My grandfather and aunt have a Ph.D. My sister-in-law has a Ph.D. My great-aunt, great-uncle, and their daughter (who's my age) have PhDs. Her husband has a Ph.D.
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
It's not surprising that professors come from highly educated families. Yet the extent to which the professoriate comes from families w/ a PhD-holding mother or father is striking.
While <1% of Americans have a PhD, 22% of university faculty members have a parent with a Ph.D. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So students are using apps like fizz to anonymously complain about us and our classes full econjobrumors/4chan style. Sleep well fellow professors.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Associate Deans
@ass_deans
Technically, you still have tenure. But also - thanks to the state legislature - you are also now an âat willâ employee.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I concur.
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
By using a uniquely inefficient reimbursement system.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I teach both.
Manu Awasthi
@mnwsth
You teach a 10 student PhD level elective course.
I teach a compulsory, 300 student, first year undergraduate course.
We are not the same. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Proof of very targeted micro targeting of advertising. I got an Instagram video of the cast of Friends but they're all on steroids and my wife got one but they're all set in Bridgerton.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Nobody is better at restoring the public's trust in universities than a NY Times columnist lecturing students on "how to fall in love with someone" ...
... or "how to divorce your wife of 27 years for your much younger research assistant"?
We are not serious institutions. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
The structural vs reduced form discourse is meaningless because the job of economists will turn into "click yes" to keep AI running.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I've been listening to a book for a while Atomic Habits as I'm on a recent journey of self reflection and (hopefully) improvement (because dept head is hard). I think the problem is you need to create environments where they learn or they can learn how to learn. Motivation fades and fails. Habits and routine are everything and changing those are hard.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Khan Academy has created great products, including an AI tutor chatbot, yet still struggles to get broad adoption that improves student achievement. It's the story of ed-tech writ large. No one has yet solved for student motivation and engagement at scale.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Nat McAleese
@__nmca__
A full-scale US Waymo rollout would cost ~700 full-time jobs in the funeral care industry (by saving around 35 thousand young American lives per year). Will no one think of (some of) the morticians!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Associate Deans
@ass_deans
Why are you so mad about post tenure review? You arenât ever getting tenure.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chelsea Olivia Follett
@chellivia
Bono was right and the anti-capitalists are wrong.
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Thinking about this Bono quote again
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
AgingdocđŠşDr David BarzilaiđMD PhD MS MBA DipABLM
@agingdoc1
The Re-Emerging Suicide Crisis in the U.S.: Patterns, Causes and Solutions @nberpubs
The suicide rate in the United States has risen nearly 40 percent since 2000...
Marcotte: "âI had not done much thinking about the topic for 10 or 15 years,â he shared. âBut in the last part of the last decade, the suicide rate rose to alarming levels, not seen since World War II. It is scary.â
Dave E. Marcotte & @benconomics
www.american.edu/spa/news/generation-z-and-deaths-of-desp⌠&
www.nber.org/papers/w31242 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Now redo this with the new avinox 1500w ebikes. We can make commuting faster and keep danger the same and add way more fun if we add a bunch of e-bike specific jumps on bike commuting routes.
big_pedestrian
@big_pedestrian
Automobiles are an extremely stupid, inefficient and unpleasant way to move people in a city.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I should anticipate that either my current taxes are higher because my social security taxes will pay less in benefits in the future or that my kids taxes will be higher because they will have to pay more to keep my benefits the same. I love my kids. So I think that means we should plan on cutting my generations benefits sooner rather than the alternatives.
#stopkickingthecandowntheroad
Jessica Riedl đ§ đşđŚ
@JessicaBRiedl
To preview my 2026 budget chartbook scheduled for release next week, I'll address the myth that Social Security cannot run annual budget deficits.
It has been in deficit since 2010, and is contributing $250 billion (0.8% of GDP) to this year's $1.8 trillion budget deficit.đ§ľ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I feel personally attacked here. Also if you get to the mountains or go for a trail run in the right clothes the winter is great.
Man Carrying Thing
@ManCarrying
PNW most beautiful place in the country if you're willing to be depressed 7 months out of the year.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When is the next time greed will be discovered?
Rothmus đ´
@Rothmus
Need to update the egg greed graph.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Bertrand competition starting in.....
Swapnil Singh
@econswapnil
Till now I ran about 5 reviews on @ refine.ink. I just pushed the same articles on Coarse. And results are almost the same.
Total cost for refine: $245
Total cost of coarse: $7.33 (GPT5.4 API usage)
Thank you so much!! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
R you serious?
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Wife: "Who is Julia on your laptop?"
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm convinced the lack of productivity effects of AI in the labor market are because 80 percent of the time you're way faster, and 20 percent of the time you spend trying to prompt something it keeps messing up.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
#econtwitter is back again?
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Remarkable Twitter moment where Cremieux posts a knee-jerk reaction and his followers calmly explain and substantively discuss the paper.
Are we back? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who's going to make the movie about the #artemis crew that's in the spirit of Apollo13 except they're fixing the toilet instead of the CO2 scrubber?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Roll your babies in poison oak? They'll thank you later when they discover mountain biking in Oregon as an adult.
Alex
@notcomplex_
Health authorities once told parents to avoid early peanut exposure. Peanut allergies rose.
They later reversed course and encouraged early introduction, and allergy rates fell. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Two scenarios.
1. AGI isn't possible, so AI because a multiplier (if you know your field well). If you can think well as an economist, the limitations become only physical (how quickly experiments can happen, or what quasi experimental data even exists, or how quickly you can identify good quasi experiments). Cleaning data becomes less and less of a constraint.
2. AGI happens, and we all die (probably).
If 2 is going to happen, nothing we can do. So plan on 1 and you'll be fine if 1 happens.
John A. List
@Econ_4_Everyone
PhD decision season. My inbox is more flooded than ever. Prospective PhD students asking some version of the question: "Should I keep going? Is an Econ PhD still worth it in the age of AI?"
I get it. The uncertainty is real. And, honestly no one knows the answer. My response begins with the caveat that I have no real certainty around my thoughts, I merely have a hunch. And, that intuition comes from combining my experiences in the academy with my recent field work alongside charities, governments, Walmart, and Anthropic itself.
My hunch is that AI will reveal expertise, not replace it, at least for the foreseeable future. Indeed, I wrote about this earlier with my justification.
As such, I do not view a PhD in economics as a credential. It's a forcing function for building that kind of deep, durable expertise. The expertise that AI amplifies rather than erodes.
So my advice? The uncertainty about AI may be the best reason yet to double down and go for an econ PhD. Why? Because the future belongs to people who know things deeply enough that AI becomes a multiplier, not a replacement. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
New phrase of the day I learned from my vibe coding with Codex..."smoke run". Sounds way cooler than beta, test or spot check.
Anybody else doing smoke runs? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jack Meyer đď¸
@Jackbmeyer
I would be interested to see a breakdown by cohort. Labor force participation for ages 20-24 has been falling consistently and never saw the same post-Covid rebound as prime-age employment. With AI disruption seemingly concentrated in new hires, the growing gap is concerning.
Callum Williams
@econcallum
US prime-age employment rate is close to an all-time high. This is simply not consistent with large-scale AI disruption to the labour market
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Negativity is more viral, but the new Nature studies donât mean social science is wrong or uninformative.
Itâs fine if there are errors in papers. Genetic mutation has a beneficial rate of <1%, but evolution is monstrously effective.
High error rates are ok if you have a process that is robust to high error rates. Many science papers have always been wrong, but they get retested and overturned.
The same thing happens in social scienceâ most papers donât get replicated but thatâs because nobody cares about their results. When stuff is important, it does get tested and retested and the literature builds toward correct answers.
Itâs ok to have a moderate error rate because papers are not sacred texts. What matters more is whether you have institutions where errors can be found and overturned. This is the real test of institutional quality.
And weâre around the corner from AI making us much better at this, esp in the fields with open data standards. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just remember, even if GDP grows exponentially with AI, our utility is only growing linearly.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Right now, Codex is updating a data pull for 36 years of for me, harmonizing it against my old code. All of these steps of research would have taken me months. I still need to check on it and steer it, but what would have taken months is taking a few days and that's with version 5.4. What happens at version 10?
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
AI has an insane rate of progress when we observe what it does for jobs that take place on screens.
Progress is slower for jobs in the world of atoms.
Since the intellectual class spend all their time on screens, it's easy to think "AI will do all the jobs!"
We are like 15th century farmers thinking about mechanization. If you mechanized agriculture, what other jobs could there even be?
Perhaps employment in the on-screen sector will shrink to a small percentage.
Of course stuff on screens affects things in the real world too. But the rate of progress is different. On screens (i.e. in simulation), the self-driving car problem has been solved for many years. IRL, we are still years and years away from replacement of human drivers.
I think one reason for divergent predictions on how much AI will matter is that the "6% growth" AI experts are extrapolating from stuff on screens to stuff with atoms, while the "3% growth" economists are not. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
CĂŠsar A. Hidalgo
@cesifoti
𤯠median time to publish went from ~100 days to over a year during the last two decadesâŚ
wonder if this trend holds for other disciplines
Sasha Gusev
@SashaGusevPosts
Monthly median Received to Accepted time (days) at Nature Genetics
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Here's some of the biggest things that could happen. Self driving cars means that we can really optimize our usage of roads even doing real-time congestion pricing. Moreover, we can have truck drivers drive when the roads are empty and more than double the amount of freeways without actually spending any money.
The other biggest thing is that AI could actually discipline us as researchers to avoid p hacking and specification searching and if that happened then replication would improve real knowledge would increase and discovery would improve that would in the long run increase growth cuz basic science is a lot of what we need to grow the economy.
tom cunningham
@testingham
This is a great paper but contains a puzzle: forecasters expect even if we automate most labor and wait 20 years, GDP will only increase by 45%.
I would love to hear how people are thinking about this. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Natural experiment incoming.
Kevin Naughton Jr.
@KevinNaughtonJr
I was fired from Anthropic today.
I was the engineer responsible for shipping the latest dev/claude-code npm package. Wanting to improve the debugging experience for the team, I decided to include source maps in the release. This resulted in our entire internal codebase being publicly exposed including thousands of files with every agent command, all system prompts, the complete query engine, Undercover Mode, Bypass Permissions Mode, and our internal telemetry configuration.
I take full responsibility. I genuinely believed the safeguards Claude Code had built for me would be adequate and it was a serious miscalculation on my part.
My actions have unintentionally open-sourced major parts of Claudeâs architecture well ahead of schedule. I apologize to the team and to Claude.
Chaofan Shou
@shoucccc
Claude code source code has been leaked via a map file in their npm registry!
Code: pub-aea8527898604c1bbb12468b1581d95e.r2.dev/src.zip -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
LM notebook made a podcast for me our proposed policy updated and I can't stop laughing at it. DM me if you want the link....
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The real issue is that economists who sit on NIH, NSF and other panels are harder on the economics research than other fields are on their own.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
Yes. Unfortunately research funders are insufficiently sensitive to this fact. Otherwise theyâd give more to econ relative to other fields.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
All the referees...
Ilya Sergey
@ilyasergey
Are paper rejections really that bad? My papers get read by ~3 people on average. Each rejection means a resubmission, which means 3 more readers. After 4 rejections, that's double-digit readership.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ed Tarnowski
@edtarnowski
Objectively false
Harry Eccles
@Heccles94
Capitalism creates poverty
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Associate Deans
@ass_deans
We didnât kill economics, we just assumed they didnât exist anymore.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Have you had Codex or Claude Code replicate any of your more important papers? If so, what did it find?
I'm playing around with my old DUI paper in the AER.... -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Give that editors know this, and referees have access to AI and so do reviewers, we should cap referee comments to two pages. Maybe only 1.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Now that authors have access to AI, referees should feel comfortable asking for much more new analysis in revisions
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Capitalism creates prosperity
Harry Eccles
@Heccles94
Capitalism creates poverty
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
One of the hardest jobs I've had is being on my neighborhood executive committee which I joined to try to make it less NIMBY. Neighborhoods have official approved plans (ours is 40 years old) and political power in Eugene which largely is used to slow down new housing.
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
High home prices are not just a coastal problem anymore. On @VelshiMSNOW, AV's @jenny_schuetz joins @AliVelshi to explain how supply constraints are driving affordability challenges across the country.
Watch more of the @MSNOWNews interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0KA6JJ51duQ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
No it wasn't. I'll share the actual peak..
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
This was peak econ twitter.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Using AI to check if potential letter writers for professors are active (non retired not dead) is both very useful and kinda morbid.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Horton
@johnjhorton
Andrew Yangđ§˘âŹď¸đşđ¸
@AndrewYang
Conventional economic theory never accounted for intelligent machines that can do the equivalent of weeks of human work in minutes or seconds.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Are there any actual politically conservative intellectual disciplines in the academy?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Political diversity across academic disciplines seems to be pretty close to an index of how conservative the discipline is on average.
More conservatives -> more political variance. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This guy is seriously on the take from the deans.
Dwarkesh Patel
@dwarkesh_sp
Terence Tao spent a year at the Institute for Advanced Study - no teaching, no random events of committees, just unlimited time to think. But after a few months, he ran out of ideas.
Terence thinks that mathematicians and scientists need a certain level of randomness and inefficiency to come up with new ideas.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Anup Malani
@anup_malani
Paper: www.nber.org/papers/w34866
cc @CassRSunstein â CarPlay makes streaming hands-free but potentially deadlier. The regulatory gap: no US state law covers touchscreen interaction while driving. Weâre regulating yesterdayâs threat. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who are the AI reports trained on?
D. Yanagizawa-Drott
@YanagizawaD
Question for fellow Economics researchersâŚ
Suppose you submit your paper to a journal, and the criteria are codified in transparent high level guidelines.
The Editor, a human, makes the final decision.
As of today, if you had a choice between:
A) 2 human referees
B) 2 AI reports (letâs say each are $100 of compute using frontier models)
C) 1 human, 1 AI
Which would you choose? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Man, in 10-15 years, us genXrs get what what those boomers have been saving up (either through medical and retirement home spending, or estates).
Jon Brooks
@jonbrooks
Just wait until the green
tries selling to the red
Gen Z isnât even on the chart -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Claude can now tweet like an influencer. Here are 9 insane prompts to get you likes, follows, and subscribes.
Brady Long
@thisguyknowsai
BREAKING: Claude can now research like a Stanford PhD student.
Here are 9 insane Claude prompts that turn 40+ research papers into structured literature reviews, knowledge maps, and research gaps in minutes (Save this) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Our financial situation is such that we clearly need more human capital in this country. Can we please optimize our immigration system for positive selection.
David J. Bier
@David_J_Bier
Weeks after claiming our report finding immigrants reduced deficits by $14.5 trillion over the last 30 years was impossible, Manhattan Institute's @DanielDiMartino publishes an immigration calculator showing doubling immigration would reduce deficits by $11.3 trillion....
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jon Hartley
@Jon_Hartley_
1/Chris Sims is easily one of the most influential macroeconomists (& perhaps most influential empirical macroeconomist) of the last 50 years; he fundamentally changed thinking about monetary policy, metrics,& causality (VARs, time series models). Thread on his greatest hitsđ§ľđ
Jon Hartley
@Jon_Hartley_
RIP Chris Sims, a giant in empirical macroeconomics
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Oregon please hold locally produced craft beer.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
There is a group of states actively competing to attract businesses and high earners, and another group adopting policies that drive them away. I don't see how this doesn't end up as a disaster in the long-term for the latter.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It always suprises me that we allow legal vices, tax them to reduce it, but then allow all sorts of advertising. Regulating advertising is the easiest way to minimize gambling's ill effects (though it's pretty clear states don't get a much of extra money out of its legalization).
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
The old stigma on gambling existed for a reason.
The U.S. is running a reckless social experiment by normalizing this vice.
A tiny bunch of companies and investors will make shitloads of money, and people's lives and communities will be impoverished for it. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I see a lot of people debating if AI is affecting the economy. Let's phrase this question different. Has it affected your own demand for research assistants?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's a Wednesday night and I'm being asked by my daughter to help her college friends with homework. Should be helpful or tell them this is what AI is for?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Carolina Forward
@ForwardCarolina
The @Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank, is out with a major new research study showing that immigrants, both legal and illegal, contribute significantly more in taxes than they receive in public benefits.
And there's more: because immigrants (both legal and not) are such large net-contributors of tax revenue, they also structurally reduce government budget deficits. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Super interesting paper. Worth reading especially because AI might turn all of us into gig workers in a decade.
Andy Garin
@andy_garin
Data-driven research, at its best, presents you with results that surprise you. đ˛
When I began studying Seattle's minimum pay standard for delivery drivers, I personally expected to see high-attachment delivery drivers making more money after the policy went into effect. 1/13 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So California definitely needs to fix proposition 13 before it builds any more data centers.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
The data center buildout has allowed Loudoun County to lower property tax rates by 38% since 2010, translating to average savings of about $3,400 per year for homeowners.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's kind of hilarious that his advice is that you have to tell the llm that you want it make slides but make them really really really good slides done by really, really smart people like the smartest people. If you do that they'll llm makes you good slides. Why is the default option that it gives us crap?
Michael Vandi
@MichaelVandiRS
đ¨BREAKING: GOODBYE POWERPOINT forever.
Claude just collapsed 5 hours of presentation building into 100 seconds completely free.
10 prompts to go from completely unprepared to completely untouchable in every meeting:
(Save this before it goes viral): -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Nick Gerli
@nickgerli1
It's actually never been cheaper to rent in Austin, TX.
The Rent/Income ratio across the metro has dropped to 18.3% - the lowest on record (going back at least 20 years).
Landlords are aggressively cutting rents at a time when incomes in Austin keep rising.
The typical rent is down to $1,565/month.
While the median income is up to $100k.
Making Austin the cheapest city to rent relative to income. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
I cannot emphasize enough how socially wasteful sports betting is.
Tax it into oblivion.
edgeAI
@edgeAIapp
World No.95 Panna Udvardy shared on Instagram that she was threatened last night before her match in Antalya .
âThe person told me that if I didn't lose my match today, they would harm members of my family. They said they knew where my family lives, what cars they drive and that they had their phone numbers. They even sent photos of my family members and a picture of a gun.â
WTA supervisor told her that data may have leaked from the WTA database, which is currently being investigated.
Lucrezia Stefanini was also threatened before her Indian Wells match. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
All right. Chat GPT 5.4. What do you all like and dislike about it?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Featured in the latest Digest: Impact of Minimum Pay Rules on Gig Delivery Drivers
www.nber.org/digest/202603/impact-minimum-pay-rules-gig-d⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Yoni Appelbaum
@YAppelbaum
Fascinating to watch policymakers continue to address artificially constrained supply by subsidizing demand.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Changes we've made to healthcare through the end of the market subsidies, the elimination of the fees for not having healthcare, and medicaid cuts have led to crazy gutting at my local hospital. So far its just affected every level of management and administration.
Heather Long
@byHeatherLong
Yikes. Almost every major industry group shed jobs in February.
Private sector overall: -86,000
Hospitality -27,000
Healthcare -28,000
Manufacturing -12,000
Tranport/warehouse -11,000
Construction -11,000
Information -11,000
Federal gov't -10,000
Professional/biz -5,000
Mining -2,000
Social assistance +9,000
Finance +10,000
#jobs -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Only do an MA if you are ready/able to publish in the QJE.
Ashvin Gandhi
@ashdgandhi
My advice to people considering these types of MA programs: only do it if youâre ready/able to take the schoolâs PhD coursework and get Aâs. Getting Aâs in MA-level coursework is not a very informative signal and so wonât help nearly as much with getting into a top PhD program.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm pretty sure we can just have NotebookLM do it.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Maybe someone should host a podcast on the economics of AI to feed some of that demand. Maybe invite some economists who are working on AI to the podcast.
(super excited for this one cc @SBenzell) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
A great opportunity for an early career economist.
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
The Criminal Justice team at Arnold Ventures is looking for a pending/recent PhD with strong causal inference skills, for a remote, part-time consulting position.
This is a great opportunity for someone considering a transition from academia to the policy space. You'll learn a lot and meet lots of people!
Deadline to apply: March 15
Please RT! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jessica Riedl đ§ đşđŚ
@JessicaBRiedl
Alas, the 2017-2020 Democratic fantasyland economics are back.
1) Wealth taxes are a gimmick - unworkable and unconstitutional. See Europe.
2) There is no way it raises $4.4 trillion. Billionaires didn't become billionaires without having a team of expert financial and tax planners to avoid a mega tax like this.
3) Even if we could raise $4.4 trillion over the decade, it is insane to plow it all into new spending with the federal debt set to leap from $30 trillion to $64 trillion. Pay for our current commitments before piling on expensive new ones.
4) Stimulus? Really? With unemployment at 4.3% and inflation rising? Have we learned nothing over the past 5 years?
If you want to tax the rich, fine. There are real and serious proposals out there (I've proposed some!). But big wealth taxes are a gimmick. Social media bait to help far left lawmakers look tough on billionaires without actually doing anything workable. Totally unserious.
Jeff Stein
@jstein_sun
New - @BernieSanders to unveil new mega tax on Americaâs ~1,000 billionaires, would raise $4.4 trillion
Potential marker for other candidates who do run in 2028, @RoKhanna is introducing House version
$ would be directed to:
- $3K stimulus checks per person earning under $150K/yr
- Expand Medicare to cover dental/vision/hearing for all seniors
- Ensure every public school teacher gets paid at least $60K/yr
- $850B for affordable home construction (âabolish homelessnessâ)
- Universal childcare
- Reverse Trump Medicaid cuts -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
What's insane is that he learned about these tools 4 weeks ago.
It's SO MUCH easier to adopt this tech than earlier generations. (I still break things 25% of the time when I work on a git branch)
Best strategy might be to just take a year-long vacation and then catch up
Chris Blattman
@cblatts
4w ago I was a Claude Code skeptic. I'm not a coder. None of the use cases were relevant. I managed teams & projects, drowning in email & overdue reminders. So I tried creating tools that would help me and... holy crap.
Now I'm sharing the tools I built:
claudeblattman.com -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Repec should not be used for department rankings any more. It tracks department level pubs based on everyone who has worked there (including grad students and for faculty). Rewards departments more with a lot of grad students and churn.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Anup Malani
@anup_malani
Two studies of slum demolitions, opposite results. Chicago: displaced kids earned 16% more. Chile: displaced kids earned 10% less. Same intervention, opposite outcomes. Why?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Perhaps states like Oregon should focus on just reading books instead of the mantra of reading banned books.
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
This is a really astonishing claim:
Students in Mississippi & Louisiana score higher on reading tests than students in California & New York despite spending way less money per pupil and having higher child poverty rates.
Decided to double check the data because, if true, this should be alarming for blue state leaders.
And yup, it checks out.
Reading performance (NAEP 2024, Grade 4 reading, average scale score):
Mississippi: 219
Louisiana: 216
New York: 215
California: 212
Child poverty (SAIPE; âestimated percent of people age 0â17 in poverty,â 2023):
Louisiana: 25.2%
Mississippi: 24.3%
New York: 18.6%
California: 15.0%
Per-pupil spending (public Kâ12 âcurrent expenditures per pupil,â FY2023, inflation-adjusted to FY2023 dollars)
New York: $29,588
California: $18,568
Louisiana: $14,822
Mississippi: $12,238
It should be unacceptable to spend that much more taxpayer money while delivering worse results for students.
Nicholas Bagley
@nicholas_bagley
If Democrats want to stay relevant, and to deliver for the public, they cannot wait for unions to change. They need to break more often with their friends.
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/23/opinion/democrats-public-secto⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Given how common scamming is becoming as an international crime, do we need a new military branch or evolution of our current intelligence networks that's dedicated to international cyber security?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Emily Oster
@ProfEmilyOster
Hey Econ Twitter! My better half has a new book out today, a graduate textbook for teaching quantitative economics. Check it out!
mitpress.mit.edu/9780262051057/introduction-to-quantitati⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Ready for a good read.
Who wants to have a book club meeting with me on Zoom in 2 weeks and talk about it? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Itâs Pub Day!
My first book, The Science of Second Chances, hits shelves today. I canât wait to hear what yâall think.
I hope you find that it fills you with hope and optimism about what is possible in the public safety space. ⨠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Skijouiring for next Olympics games.
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Summer has the decathlon. Winter deserves one too. âď¸đ
1 athlete, 10 events
Giant Slalom
Cross-country sprint
Biathlon 10km
Speed skating 1500m
Figure skating
Ski jumping
Snowboard cross
Slopestyle skiing
Luge
Cross-country 50km
Find the true winter đ. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Summer has the decathlon. Winter deserves one too. âď¸đ
1 athlete, 10 events
Giant Slalom
Cross-country sprint
Biathlon 10km
Speed skating 1500m
Figure skating
Ski jumping
Snowboard cross
Slopestyle skiing
Luge
Cross-country 50km
Find the true winter đ. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How do I get a refund on the bike I didn't buy because tariffs raised the price of the bike beyond my willingness to pay? I lost some consumer surplus due to the deadweight loss of higher prices.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Liberation day is actually here!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
More Births
@MoreBirths
A newly published paper found pronatal policies only worked when supported by culture.
"Maternity benefits increased fertility only among women who grew up in religious families" in the Baltics.
This could explain why many pronatal policies have not boosted fertility more. đ§ľ. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Carey
@chriscareymsp
Teen hangouts dropped off a cliff after 2012. Those teens are now adults in their late 20s and 30s wondering why they have no close friends.
We keep treating the loneliness epidemic like it came out of nowhere. It didn't. We just weren't paying attention when it started.
Chart via @jean_twenge data, h/t @jayvanbavel -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
AI over promising and delivering late suggest that it is already ready to take over many white collar jobs.
Dina D. Pomeranz đŁ
@DinaPomeranz
Willing to bet a lot of money that this will not be the case
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Sell everything
@yoshispeninsula
70% of Laos's economy being cyberscams is wild
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We need more holidays for social security.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
It's that time of year again.
It's the most common day for women to get pregnant!
Happy Valentine's Day! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
My team is looking for a CJ Innovation Fellow to support our new Market-Based Innovation portfolio. This portfolio, led by the fabulous @mlpeeb, focuses on strategies to improve public safety that involve private sector actors (like tech startups and insurance companies). Iâm really excited about this line of work! Lots of opportunities to spark catalytic change. â¨
Come join us! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Curious what research projects the @Arnold_Ventures Criminal Justice team is funding? Here is a list of projects funded in Q4 of 2025:
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart
@weeklyshowpod
Jon noticed some anger from economists in the comments last week. He gets into that and so much more with the Chief Economist of American Compass @oren_cass on a new episode tomorrow. #theweeklyshow #jonstewart #politics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Michael Kofoed
@mikekofoed
The economists made fun of me not knowing anything about economics so let me find the one person who knows less than I do to complain about it
The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart
@weeklyshowpod
Jon noticed some anger from economists in the comments last week. He gets into that and so much more with the Chief Economist of American Compass @oren_cass on a new episode tomorrow. #theweeklyshow #jonstewart #politics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Jon just bring on an average economist. I teach principles. I can guide you through basic econ of climate change policy including your proposal.
The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart
@weeklyshowpod
Jon noticed some anger from economists in the comments last week. He gets into that and so much more with the Chief Economist of American Compass @oren_cass on a new episode tomorrow. #theweeklyshow #jonstewart #politics
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jose Gaytan de Ayala
@jgaytandeayala
Most people don't know that MIT's best department is not engineering or computer science but ECONOMICS
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I didn't get magna cum laude at my undergrad but I would have at Harvard with their gpa cutoffs?
Oliver Kim
@oliverwkim
Quick illustration of the problem, using Harvard Econ's magna cum laude cutoffs
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Brad Shapiro
@btshapir
Major issue: Young people can't afford homes.
Dem and GOP bipartisan agreement: Eliminate property taxes *for seniors*, thereby both subsidizing empty nesters staying in big houses *and* shifting a larger fraction of the tax burden to young people!
GREAT SUCCESS!
Governor Gretchen Whitmer
@GovWhitmer
With property taxes going up year after year, Michigan seniors deserve stability. Theyâve worked hard and earned the right to relief in their golden years. www.freep.com/story/news/politics/2026/02/08/whitmer-budgâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Examining the relationship between the rise in cocaine-related overdose deaths in the US and increased coca cultivation in Colombia in the late 2010s, from @xinmingd, @benconomics, Shan Zhang, and @thefinderouter1 www.nber.org/papers/w34788
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Being Cum Laude at Harvard means you're actually only average.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If my students get 0 credit for papers why the hell would they work with me?
Kris Gulati
@krisgulati
Unpopular opinion: I basically think that any paper with an advisor should be discounted to 0, and this may be one of the most - equitable - things about the econ market (not sure why this norm persists tho?). That said, AI may change this norm (?)
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
This is something I keep stressing: appealing to the Industrial Revolution as some sort of âeverything will be okayâ narrative is not good! There was a generation + of people who had their lives made significantly, hellishly worse and it took decades for things to get better.
We have more than a century of economics research since then for structuring policy that ensures that innovation/growth continues while keeping gains broadly distributed.
We should use it.
Deena Mousa
@deenamousa
People invoke the Industrial Revolution as reassurance about AI. But living through it meant decades of wage stagnation, job loss, and unrest.
Ep 1 in my new @vox_dev series with @oliverhanney, talking to economic historian @brunocaprettini on what the analogy gets right/wrong. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Listened to the whole podcast to actually make some real critiques instead of just offering hot takes (being a hypocrite). I do think sometimes we need shoves not nudges to fix the world. Yes branding matters (nudging).
But carbon capture is a pretty standard economic solution to an externality problem. Creating markets for pollution or their elimination. And he may be right, but doing it at scale is not possible yet.
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
Listening through the full Jon Stewart interview, this specific section was pretty shocking to hear. Stewart doesn't know that:
1) Economics both predicts people's behavior in response to taxes, and recommends taxes to deal with externalities.
2) Economics as a discipline doesn't say "We as economists should exclusively facilitate corporations maximizing shareholder value." He acts shocked and skeptical when Thaler says that economics is about maximizing the public's welfare. He disagrees with Thaler and says "The goal of economics in a capitalist system is to make the most amount of money for your shareholders. Since when is economics about improving the human condition?"
3) Economics isn't synonymous with "completely free markets with no taxes."
I don't know how you spend 20+ years publicly commenting on politics 5 nights a week without at least bothering to learn this. Shows a pretty shocking lack of curiosity.
youtu.be/rZczEzMu_U8?t=1251
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
THen the pivot to healthcare....
There are countries with universal health care coverage without government run health care, and places with government run healthcare all over the world are having their own problems with aging populations and shrinking healthcare workforces.
The ACA exchanges were broken from the get go because of bad labeling (basic vs. catastrophic), the taxes for not having insurance were too low, and the original actuarial pricing didn't consider it would become a vehicle for early retirees who weren't medicare eligible yet. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The other thing that @R_Thaler really point out in this interview is that the emergency Powers act of the president actually allows them to impose a carbon tax because climate change has been an emergency for a while. It's just Congress is too chicken shir to do anything about it. If Trump can use the emergency Powers act for tariffs, then definitely the next Democratic president can use it for climate change motivated carbon taxes.
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
Listening through the full Jon Stewart interview, this specific section was pretty shocking to hear. Stewart doesn't know that:
1) Economics both predicts people's behavior in response to taxes, and recommends taxes to deal with externalities.
2) Economics as a discipline doesn't say "We as economists should exclusively facilitate corporations maximizing shareholder value." He acts shocked and skeptical when Thaler says that economics is about maximizing the public's welfare. He disagrees with Thaler and says "The goal of economics in a capitalist system is to make the most amount of money for your shareholders. Since when is economics about improving the human condition?"
3) Economics isn't synonymous with "completely free markets with no taxes."
I don't know how you spend 20+ years publicly commenting on politics 5 nights a week without at least bothering to learn this. Shows a pretty shocking lack of curiosity.
youtu.be/rZczEzMu_U8?t=1251 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm pretty sure Jon Stewart is just being self-interested and pretending that he hates everything about capitalism to try to make himself cool with the gen z and gen alphas who have no idea who he is. He really is just proving the basics of economics that most people are driven by self-interest.
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
Listening through the full Jon Stewart interview, this specific section was pretty shocking to hear. Stewart doesn't know that:
1) Economics both predicts people's behavior in response to taxes, and recommends taxes to deal with externalities.
2) Economics as a discipline doesn't say "We as economists should exclusively facilitate corporations maximizing shareholder value." He acts shocked and skeptical when Thaler says that economics is about maximizing the public's welfare. He disagrees with Thaler and says "The goal of economics in a capitalist system is to make the most amount of money for your shareholders. Since when is economics about improving the human condition?"
3) Economics isn't synonymous with "completely free markets with no taxes."
I don't know how you spend 20+ years publicly commenting on politics 5 nights a week without at least bothering to learn this. Shows a pretty shocking lack of curiosity.
youtu.be/rZczEzMu_U8?t=1251 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This economist also thinks OPEC did the world a tremendous favor by using market power to drive oil prices higher. We need more market power in markets with externalities (or taxes).
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
Listening through the full Jon Stewart interview, this specific section was pretty shocking to hear. Stewart doesn't know that:
1) Economics both predicts people's behavior in response to taxes, and recommends taxes to deal with externalities.
2) Economics as a discipline doesn't say "We as economists should exclusively facilitate corporations maximizing shareholder value." He acts shocked and skeptical when Thaler says that economics is about maximizing the public's welfare. He disagrees with Thaler and says "The goal of economics in a capitalist system is to make the most amount of money for your shareholders. Since when is economics about improving the human condition?"
3) Economics isn't synonymous with "completely free markets with no taxes."
I don't know how you spend 20+ years publicly commenting on politics 5 nights a week without at least bothering to learn this. Shows a pretty shocking lack of curiosity.
youtu.be/rZczEzMu_U8?t=1251 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Starting to use Claude Code won't get you a Top 5.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Trails in Bentonville getting another upgrade...
John A. List
@Econ_4_Everyone
I hope that other organizations stand up and notice and subsequently hire chief economists themselves!
Thanks for pointing out this (obviously causal!) Chief Economist Effect @Bellmanequation! đ¤Łđ¤Łđ¤Ł. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The Coddling of the American Economy.
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Right-wing nationalists and left-wing social democrats:
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Right-wing nationalists and left-wing social democrats:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Alcohol, cigarette, marijuana and gasoline taxes are the best.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
FACT:
Property taxes are among the best taxes on the books. They are pro-family and not distortionary. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Watched a Big Bold Beautiful Journey on a plane with my wife. Who else would love to see their spouses as a younger person but cringe at reliving their own past?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ashvin Gandhi
@ashdgandhi
As a teaching assistant at Harvard, I was told that the lowest grade I was allowed to give was a C. It doesnât matter how badly the student actually did, anything lower than a C would inundate the faculty of record with a bunch of paperwork and meetings with administrators.
Ryan Briggs
@ryancbriggs
Iâd like this to be true, but I failed two students last semester and my admin actually is pushing back on it. Iâm pretty floored.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Blind leading the blind?
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
The evolution of relationship advice on Reddit.
[Link below.] -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What happens in the next 10 years?
1. Immigration
2. Productivity surge
3. Massive cut in benefits and quality of care?
Russ Greene
@GreenPlusAnE
Medicare spending is expected to double in the next 10 years.
www.medpac.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/July2025_MedPAC⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Me talking on the news about general strikes and the effect of yesterday's ice out on economic activity. Maybe I could have just said 0.
youtu.be/aZunBZbCWwk -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Jamahiriya al-JucheđŹđđ¨đť
@ayo_platano
Iâve never been scared of âLet me tell you what communism did to my countryâ people because I got stories about capitalism that i guarantee are worse.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I remember a paper I saw using mint.com data years ago and basically nearly every body lives pay check to pay check. Almost every dollar that hits a banking account gets spent.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
6 7 strikes again.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Marriages with older men and younger women produce more children than the opposite. About a 6-7 year gap is ideal.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Ryan must be new to economics.
Ryan Briggs
@ryancbriggs
Important general point:
If your evidence changes by a factor of 1000 and yet your conclusions remain the same, then the evidence was never important to you in the first place. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
1/31 is national hug an economist day. Free disposal applied I presume?
#econtwitter -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Journal of Policy Analysis and Management
@JPAM_DC
The episode draws on a recent JPAM article by @benconomics, Kendall Houghton, @millersdrafts, & Caroline Weber: âShifting tax incidence: Evidence from the Washington State cannabis market.â
doi.org/10.1002/pam.70041 (2/3) -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Looking forward to testifying in favor of HB 2217 today, in front of the WA House Criminal Justice committee, alongside my friend and fellow crime economist @KSchnepel.
You can watch here:
tvw.org/video/house-community-safety-2026011489/?eventID=⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Everybody knows that Milton Friedman claimed that open borders were incompatible w a welfare state. But almost nobody knows that he took this to speak in favor of encouraging illegal immigration:
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
đŠ Genuine Articles // GG đŚ
@genuinearticles
Paddy Pimblett just lost a brutal fight,
and instead of worrying about himself,
he used his airtime to tell men not to suffer in silence.
It's ok to not feel ok. Talk to someone. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
"But have you considered how this is even considered economics?"
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Crossfit.
Daniel Polehn
@dpolehn
What is the biggest mistake people make when they start weightlifting?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Itâs incredible what is happening right now. We have ground truth on what happened in Minneapolis, high quality vid from multiple angles.
-A citizen approached ICE agents with a phone, in line w 1A rights
-They escalated by tackling him to the ground and violently beating him.
-While doing so, they found that he was carrying a gun. A 2A right.
-After disarming him, with the gun well away, the citizen was shot multiple times until death.
This is all in video, for anyone to watch. Itâs not âmultiple interpretationsâ, this is liars vs ground truth. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is the implication our parents need to probably move back in with us?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Suing people is costly.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Future prompts. "ChatGPT find me a model with statistical significance I can defend to my referees."
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
One of the most promising uses of AI is creating a more robust protocol for science. Imagine if every paper came with a a transparent, interactive appendix where you can see the robustness and reliability of the results in real time.
Automatic robustness to diff specifications, instant replication, continuous updating as new data is available.
It is possible to do all this with the tools we have *now*.
I know @ahall_research is working on this, as is @PaulLitvak. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Now what happens if they become department head? ;-)
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
This new working paper argues that female economics PhD students benefit tremendously from having female economics faculty around.
How do they back up this claim?
They look at the timing of sabbatical leaves.
When female professors go on leave, it decreases third-year female Ph.D. studentsâ likelihood of publishing papers and securing academic positions.
Male Ph.D. students in the same cohort benefit from this absence, seeing an increase in their publishing and placement prospects.
Their estimates imply that "Adding one senior female professor to each top-50 department would close one-third of the assistant professor gender gap at top-25 schools." -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Motor vehicle theft is the easiest property crime to address through tech and yet it's the one that we've gone backwards on over the past 15 years. The tools exist today to essentially end car theft if adopted: PIN to drive, remote disable, GPS tracking, cameras, encrypted keys.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I want oral exams, with a few ground truth graded by 5-10 TAs, and then all the answers graded by AI's trained on the TA's grading.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
The inevitable endpoint: college essays written by the student's AI and evaluated by school's AI.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Looking at booking a hotel with my wife for our 20th anniversary. For some reason the prices get really cheap right by the beach but close to the river and estuary. Any hypotheses about the reason why (there's a good reason)?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Now do this by household. There are fewer marriages and marriages that do happen have less kids so there is less housing per household
Jon Brooks
@jonbrooks
Everyone keeps saying America has a âhousing shortage.â
It doesnât.
Divide total homes by population and you get this:
Weâve never had more housing per person than we do right now.
The problem isnât supply.
Itâs prices. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Counterpoint: Entrepreneurs actually made California rich
Los Angeles Times
@latimes
Commentary: California made them rich. Now billionaires flee when the state asks for a little something back. www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/story/2026-01-10/califâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Getting a nose job to spite your face?
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
So is support for tariffs
www.nber.org/papers/w34351 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
And indeed, China began warning chemical/pharma companies, closing down websites & tightening chemical controls in 2023. It is likely if not certain that Chinaâs actions disrupted the fentanyl trade in both the US and Canada, Paper link below 8/8.
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aea6130 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
Today in @ScienceMagazine my colleagues and I address the mystery of why opioid overdoses in the US and Canada suddenly began dropping dramatically. We assemble traditional and novel evidence to point to an illicit drug supply disruption, probably in China. 1/8
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Keith Humphreys
@KeithNHumphreys
First, our team analyzed U.S. drug seizures. The purity of both fentanyl powder and pills began dropping in mid-2023, and overdoses dropped in tandem. People were buying 50% weaker fentanyl by the end of 2024, and the dose makes the poison. 3/8
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
The statement that AI can automate ~50% of white-collar tasks is too high, but even if it was right, the conclusion is wrong.
Here is why economics is necessary for the conversation about AI. A job is a bundle of tasks. Automating some tasks makes the non-automatable tasks *more* valuable. This can lead labor income to rise rather than fall.
All of this is worked out beautifully in this excellent paper by @joshgans and @avicgoldfarb.
www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w34639/w34639.pdf
Chubbyâ¨ď¸
@kimmonismus
Holy Moly, Elon Musk: AI can already automate ~50% of white-collar tasks. Bits before atoms. Offices fall first, factories later. Inertia is the only delay. But blue collar workers are next. Its only a matter of (very short) time!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
My goal in this book is to make the best evidence accessible (and exciting) to a broad audience. It will leave you feeling optimistic about the future. â¨
I hope you'll check it out. đ¤
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Thank you, @LibraryJournal!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It's so weird that we have to prompt AIs to tell us when they don't know the answer instead of making stuff up.
Alex Veremeyenko
@alex_verem
Here's the exact template:
"According to [Wikipedia/WHO/trusted source], explain [your question]. If the source doesn't provide enough detail, say 'I don't know.'"
That's it. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Interesting how this coincides with the end of the academic semester and winter vacation. It'll bounce back.
Deedy
@deedydas
đ¨ ChatGPT traffic has fallen -22% in the last 6 weeks, since the Gemini 3 launch.
7-day avg visitors has gone from ~203M to ~158M. Might be the holiday slump, but Gemini, their biggest consumer competitor, has remained flat and is now ~40% of ChatGPT.
Source: SimilarWeb. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Applied microeconomists assigning Claude Code to write their DiD papers:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Watching lord of the rings with my kids. Rings of power is ok, but I'd far rather have a show about the scourge of the shire.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So the training data is basically set right now?
Sam Rose
@samwhoo
StackOverflow graph of questions asked per month.
Holy shit. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How much of this is just demographics and they're not being enough young people?
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
In today's issue of The Update:
⢠Why is crime plummeting in the world's most liberal places?
⢠Less has changed than people expected in 1998
⢠A striking fall in American death rates
And much more.
theupdatebrief.substack.com/p/why-is-crime-plummeting-in-⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
I will discuss this remarkable paper:
China pulled off something economists long thought impossible. It went from pharma free rider to innovation leader.
A single policy change (NRDL) massively expanded market size, cut prices, and increased frontier drug R&D.
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Interested in learning more about innovation in pharmaceutical drug development?
Come to our AEA session on Sunday, January 4 at 2:30pm. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Nick Gerli
@nickgerli1
Austin TX is now back to pre-pandemic apartment rents.
Down 21% from peak in summer of 2022.
$1,636/month --> $1,288/month
(I'm now even seeing 2BRs in some apartments at sub-$1,000)
This rental correction is due to a sharp drop in migration/demand, combined with a surge of new apartment development.
At this point, Austin has its cheapest rents on record relative to income. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My biggest questions though. Are these million miles driven the same?
unusual_whales
@unusual_whales
Waymo's autonomous vehicles see dramatically lower crash rates than human drivers:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This is a weird definition of mobile phones
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Generative AI, 3 years in
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Logan Dobson
@LoganDobson
Cystic Fibrosis and AIDS are good examples of diseases which
1) within living memory were death sentences
2) now are often not
3) big pharma gets no credit for helping with for some reason
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Trikafta is one of the most inspiring medical advances in decades.
Approved in 2019, the drug at first makes cystic fibrosis patients vomit up mucus for a whole day.
But while they lose that day, they gain a lifetimeâa healthy, *normal length* lifetime.
It's a miracle drug. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why is that demagorgens are more susceptible to broken bottles and baseball bats and bear traps and swords than bullets?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And what are the current property taxes due to Prop 13?
Daniel Keene
@Djkeene1
The home George Bailey helps the Italian family (The Martiniâs) buy in Itâs a Wonderful Life has a Zillow estimate of $2.14 Million.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
What a time to be a health economist i guess.
Heather Long
@byHeatherLong
The labor market is going from frozen to cracking.
Look at how many industries have LOST jobs in the past 3 months.
Mining -13,000
Construction -10,000
Manufacturing -31,000
Information -15,000
Business/Professional -51,000
Federal gov't -34,000
Finance 0 job gains
The US job market is almost entirely dependent on healthcare. That's not healthy for the economy. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Manage common resource problems. Provide pure public goods. Regulate externalities.
WalkerâĄď¸
@WalkerAmerica
Name ONE thing the government does better than private industry.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
For Christmas I decided to kind of do a throwback and make my parents a Christmas ornament kind of like you used to do when you were in preschool or kindergarten. It's coming along great.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I reminder that printing money, the alternative to raising taxes, causes inflation which will tax everyone, old, young, rich and poor alike.
Mitt Romney
@MittRomney
Weâve reached a point where any mix of solutions to our nationâs economic problems is going to involve the wealthiest Americans contributing more. www.nytimes.com/2025/12/19/opinion/romney-tax-the-rich.html
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm guessing federally backed public housing developments with on site casinos?
Lance Lambert
@NewsLambert
LENNAR: THE FEDS ARE COOKING UP SOMETHING BIG TO ADDRESS HOUSING AFFORDABILITY
'a number of homebuilders have gone in to see critical officials within the [federal] government.'
- @Lennar co-CEO Stuart Miller -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Make healthcare affordable again? Make hospitals compete again. In Eugene MSA we have two with a herfindahl index of .79. No bueno.
Anthony DiGiorgio, DO, MHA
@DrDiGiorgio
Incredible piece showing why hospitals are the biggest driver of healthcare spending.
Everyone wants to blame pharma but thatâs not whatâs happening.
Hospitals can mark up drugs when they administer them. And those markups can be absurd.
Bloomberg found hospitals charging insurers five times, ten times, even over 700 times what Medicare would pay for the same drug.
Example from the article:
Oxaliplatin. A 20 year old generic cancer drug. Long off patent.
The manufacturer barely makes money on it anymore.
Medicare pays about $35 per dose.
Yet nearly 150 US hospitals billed five times that or more.
It is hospital pricing power.
This is why premiums are high.
This is why out of pocket costs are high.
Hospitals are the single largest driver of healthcare spending.
Must read from @Bloomberg. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Because of tariffs and trade wars, manufacturing saw among the worst job losses.
Steve Rattner
@SteveRattner
Health care and social assistance have led employment growth this year. Despite Trumpâs efforts, manufacturing saw among the worst job losses.
My @Morning_Joe Chart -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The only goal of principals of macro should be to teach and edify on this issue to reduce the divide.
Jason Furman
@jasonfurman
There is a massive disconnect between the views of economists and the public on the question of whether the price level should go back down after a burst of inflation.
In fact, I don't know of a bigger disconnect between the views of economists and the public. Do you @bryan_caplan? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
As Comte once put it, demography is destiny.
Brad Wilcox
@BradWilcoxIFS
"Since 2000, [red states] have experienced a 7% increase in their child population, whereas [blue] states have experienced a 7% decrease. These trends suggest a supportive economic & cultural climate for families trumps progressive family policies on offer from many blue states."
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Time to start the journal of pratical economics? Or is substack basically already the market place for these type of ideas? But is pay to read a good marketplace design if viewership funnels are created by extreme takes?
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Yeah this is a problem.
Big ideas live in blogs and books, and rarely in econ journal articles.
It wasn't always this way. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
One of the areas of economic growth with trade liberalization with China was the growth of small businesses which often produced products overseas. Asking them to change supply chains in uncertain tariff conditions with high interest rates is basically telling them to close up shop.
Scott Lincicome
@scottlincicome
"Fear Is Consuming US Small Businesses Pummeled by Trump Tariffs: The USâs 36 million small businesses are crying out for relief from import taxes"
www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2025-12-18/small-businâŚ
A growing divide between the big-biz haves and the small-biz have nots: -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Had a youtube influencer summarize my research with Jessamyn Schaller and @SDSUCHEPS.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWu55U8p4ks
Should we as academics engage with influencers more to get our research to the mainstream audiences, or is it too challenging/uncertain/risky? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Ive found it useful to think of research as a portfolio, a combination of high risk moonshot projects and lower risk âhedgesâ that contribute to lit but arenât groundbreaking. Especially early in career.
We all know people who focused all their time in grad school on one grand project, it worked out, and they became a star. We donât see all the folks who did that and the project failed. But Iâve seen it plenty. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This year instead of curving, I pre-committed to cutoffs, based on my last couple of years of teaching. Kept the material about just as hard (best that I could). Overall, scores improved (a little bit).
Does the ambiguity of curves reduce motivation?
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We know in sports people target certain times, weights, etc. So I guess in classes like econ, perhaps we need to give similar clear guidelines for students?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Laffer curves coming back into public view.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
I fear we're watching a city collapse through the vicious cycle of irresponsible governance -> severe budget pressure -> higher taxes and worse services -> tax base shrinks -> more severe budget pressure.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Somebody add add a vertical line for liberation day to this figure.
Scott Lincicome
@scottlincicome
Take THAT, economists!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
He should just be endorsing snake oil supplements on instagram or youtube like the liver king, like a respectable charlatan. He has no place leading the most important health agencies in the country.
End Tribalism in Politics
@EndTribalism
RFK Jr. says that during the AIDS epidemic, the treatment AZT, widely pushed on patients, probably took more lives than AIDS did.
âDuring the AIDS epidemic in this country, the NIH took the position that they were an ivory tower, that the solution was gonna come from them, and they refused to talk to the physicians who were on the ground.â
âIn places like Dallas and New York and San Francisco and Los Angeles where physicians were developing ways of successfully treating the symptoms of AIDS.â
âThose physicians were silenced. They were de-licensed, they were censored, they were demonized and vilified.â
âThe agency here wanted to control and they wanted to develop the treatment.
âAnd they developed AZT, which probably ki**ed more people than AIDS did, conceivably.âThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If substitutes get more expensive you can raise your prices.
Or if inputs get more expensive you tend to raise your prices.
Steve Rattner
@SteveRattner
Harvardâs Pricing Lab data shows that goods prices â which were previously declining â have been on the rise since Trump started his trade war. Even domestic goods prices rose, though by a smaller amount.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Raise the marijuana taxes. Especially in Oregon.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Voters and legislators believed they were legalizing the historical, lower-harm versions of both marijuana and sports betting. But, once legal, market innovation produced more addictive and harmful versions. Public support for both is eroding as the harms become clearer.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This one goes to 11.
Mike Beauvais
@MikeBeauvais
Rob Reinerâs five-film run from 1986 to 1992 is as impressive as they come.
Five unforgettable movies spanning five different genres is something not just any director can pull off.
Rest in peace. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
You need like 97-98 percent of your population vaccinated or previously infected to keep outbreaks in check.
Simon Kuestenmacher
@simongerman600
Iâm convinced that the antivax movement will look like an absolute act of stupidity to historians. The US willingly reintroducing measles is just bafflingâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
For extra credit I allowed my students to write a short reflection essay on AI, the labor market, and their college plans, have AI edit it, and then reflect on that.
Reading them, I have a few questions.Post not available here, view on X
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
They want to focus on critical or complex thinking. Key question, can you learn to think critically or on complex systems without understanding simple thinking first? Can you understand complex math if you don't know (12-3=9 instead 4, where 4 was an incorrect answer I've seen).
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Second thing, they want to focus on interpersonal skills because AI won't replace personal connections. I have mixed thoughts on this take, because yes personal matter, but they haven't saved entire industries from technological shifts.
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Some have said they're going into government because government won't be affected by AI the same why as the private sector. I think it will be MORE affected. Way more inefficiency within most government, and really big structural debt problems kicked down the road for too long.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Scott Lincicome
@scottlincicome
"The Trump tariffs are the largest US tax increase as a percent of GDP (0.47 percent for 2025) since 1993." taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/trump-tariffs-trad⌠via @TaxFoundation
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Traffic accidents and deaths jumped up a lot as did vehicle costs in COVID.
The key question is why insurance companies using monitoring technologies are not able to monetize people into driving safer more effectively.
Sulla
@spqr_sulla
Why is vehicle insurance so high ?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm the only who cares?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What do the betting markets say about if we're going to win the debate?
Peter Hull
@instrumenthull
We beat Epstein!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We accidently included an AI photo in our Christmas card. Can you spot it?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
A Redditor tested 312 people to see if they could distinguish AI-generated photos from real ones.
Even with a non-SotA AI model, people barely did better than chance.
The age of photographic evidence is about to be over. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Everyone giving principles of micro exams. You can no longer probably use cable TV as an example of club goods because 10 different people asked me in the final what cable TV was and if it was free.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
The brilliant Kate Ho has passed away.
She was an amazing economist and a genuinely kind human being. Her work shaped how we think about healthcare markets and her generosity touched everyone lucky enough to know her.
The profession and the world are poorer without her. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Are just check in at SLC and walk 4 miles to your gate.
Secretary Sean Duffy
@SecDuffy
Having pull-up bars in airports means you can stay fit while traveling.
You can challenge yourself, or better yet, challenge your friends & family during a layover. The downside is your daughter might beat you!
That happened today as me, my daughter, Paloma, @SecKennedy & @paulsaladinomd celebrated DOT grants to Make Travel Family Friendly Great Again!
Tell me how many pull-ups you can do.đđź -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Do you think giving folks a basic income would reduce crime?
Think again.
"We estimate precise zero effects [of basic income] on criminal perpetration." -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This have vibes of when the devil proves his point by doing a one handed hand stand Kronk gets confused and the angles like "oh he has a point".
CSPAN
@cspan
Pull-up competition between Secretaries Kennedy and Duffy.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Karol Markowicz
@karol
So many columns in the NY Times should have a "*does not apply to people without rich parents" disclaimer.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is it possible half of the benefit of self driving cars is achievable with broad deployment of speeding cameras? Or speed monitored car insurance?
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Wait...
Speed cameras work?
"Cumulatively, over the seven months following [speed camera's] introduction, collisions declined by 30% and injuries by 16%." -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do Waymos force their occupants to wear their seat belts?
Mohamed A. El-Erian
@elerianm
About a decade ago, I sat in a presentation on driverless cars, skeptical.
That changed the moment the presenter said something that shifted my perspective:
"When a driverless car makes a mistake, all other driverless cars will learn how to avoid it. Thatâs not the case for traditional cars."
Thereâs quite a difference between learning individually and learning collectively.
I was reminded of all this while reading a NY Times column by neurosurgeon Jonathan Slotkin in which he writes:
âWhen compared with human drivers on the same roads, Waymoâs self-driving cars were involved in 91 percent fewer serious-injury-or-worse crashes and 80 percent fewer crashes causing any injury. It showed a 96 percent lower rate of injury-causing crashes at intersections, which are some of the deadliest I encounter in the trauma bay.â
#cars #droving #accidents #waymo @nytimes #artificialintelligence #machinelearning #autonomousvehicles #techtrends #futureoftech #innovation #bigdata #networkedintelligence -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I tried to propose Die Hard, Hot Frosty, the Grinch, Christmas Story for family movie night and yet here I am watching a Jonas Brothers Christmas....
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
The Freshwater-Saltwater reunification that no one expected.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So guess who? I was at a Christmas party yesterday? Should I update my website and linkedin pictures?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We know the US econ university market is weak this year (demographic cliff + university grant stuff).
I also have heard a couple of our Phd students have already lined up jobs in the private sector via internships in the summer. If that's becoming more common, is that one reasons JOE listings would be down? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The worst part of streaming music services and parenting is their interaction. My kids taking over the accounts with no regard for externalities or user profiles....
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
And now, would it be on tariff tips and commodities markets?
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Congressmen are known for doing well in the stock market.
Why? Consider:
Before ascending to leadership positions, they do as well as peer congressmen, but after they take on leadership roles, they show 47 percentage point (!!!) higher returns! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Git rid of fluoride and replace it with Ozempic?
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Anybody who says we shouldn't channel a ton of resources into making GLP-1s as affordable and accessible as possible has never looked at these stats.
100.6 kg = 221.7 lb -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
OkCupid needs to update their algorithm for this.
Ashvin Gandhi
@ashdgandhi
Normal people: hear math statements as regular words.
Mathematicians: hear math statements as logic.
Economists: hear regular words as math statements. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why is Halloween not the last Friday in October?
Scott Lincicome
@scottlincicome
Yes, fixed date holidays are a problem - and one reason why Thanksgiving is the best holiday of all.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Public sector unions and their pensions.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Chicago Police and Fire pension systems are the worst funded programs in the nation. Yesterday, Gov Pritzker signed a bill further increasing benefits, adding an additional $11 billion of unfunded liabilities. Instead of trying to address the problem, Illinois has just given up.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Words don't define me.
đđĄđ đđŤđ đ¨đ đđŽđŤđŠđ¨đŹđ đşđ¸
@creation247
In 3 words or less, what is your personal philosophy?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
More and more studies are coming out about the consequences and harms of legal sports gambling.
Makes you wonder if prior studies were just picking up the impacts of gambling in underground illegal markets. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Betsey Stevenson
@BetseyStevenson
Cash is great, except when it comes to health insurance. The risk pooling is the challenge and cash completely ignores that problem.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So we recently had some mice eat on the wires of our 2024 PlugInHybrid. Because of new standards, apparently carmakers are using soy as an insulator on wiring. This is resulted in $7000 of electrical work, and me ordering $100 of mice deterrents online. Order up on the stuff now and save your car.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
QJE
@QJEHarvard
Recently accepted by #qje, âRepublican Support and Economic Hardship: The Enduring Effects of the Opioid Epidemic,â by Arteaga (@caroartc) and Barone (@viquibarone): doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjaf051
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Feedback at a conference.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Grades now go to 11.
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
It's so funny when someone brags about a 4.5 GPA.
The whole point of the GPA is it's out of 4, that's what makes it comparable and useful.
If it's >4, we know your school is playing silly games with bonus points, but we have no idea what it's out of. 5? 10? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
Illegal Immigrants Didnât Break the Housing Market; Bad Policy Did marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2025/11/illegalâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If I use ai to help with writing am I vibe writer?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Conferences are such a great time to see your graduate students flourish under the pressure of public speaking. #appam2025
@studhall -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
JD Vance: "A lot of young people are saying housing is way too expensive. Why is that? Because we flooded the country with 30 million illegal immigrants who were taking houses that ought by right go to American citizens."
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The optimal amount of detected AI in papers isn't 0.
Wendy
@teachthemx3
My doctorate advisor said my last paper came back as 8% AI. He wants 0%. Do you know how hard it is to write in academic language and not have it flagged as AI? Most compound sentences are flagged. I asked if I could present via Zoom and he said the University doesnât allow that.
Irony: my paper was about innovation in education. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What if I figure out industry is where I belong? Would industry give me a second second chance?
Matthew G Nagler
@MatthewGNagler
My academic career would not have been possible if there had not been second chances. After getting my PhD, I went into consulting, then government, then industry. Only then did I realize academia was where I belonged.
Short đ§ľ: -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think we need at least two panels of economists. One can argue one point. The other can start with "on the other hand".
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
I'm calling on economists *not* to do this. True scientic consensus is rare. I think you undermine the IPCC when treat a social scientific question as tantamount to the hard sciences. Especially since their press release makes clear that this is an exercise in question-begging.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How strong is NiMByism in liberal cities? Eugene population 180k has zero hospitals and Springfield population 80k next door has two, because none of the neighborhoods in Eugene wanted the traffic of the new hospital eventually built in Springfield. They choose death (or slightly higher odds of it based on transit times) over new construction.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
I don't understand CA. The LA City Council just voted down a privately-funded gondola from downtown to Dodger Stadium that would reduce traffic and open some of the stadiumâs 130 acres of surface parking to new housing and entertainment. Publicly-funded rail or bust, I guess.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Me writing songs about former coauthors.
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Ex-coauthors
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My dad bought his first house before I was able to afford one. It was also 750 ft sq ft with an unfinished basement. It would be called a tinyhouse today.
Tyler Menzer
@Tyler_Menzer
Back in the day, an average working class man could just call up this guy and buy an entire planet, support 4 kids, a stay at home wife all while finding the answer to life, the universe and everything
Today 2 incomes can't even buy a single babble fish without going into debtThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When your coauthors start taking the memes out of your slides and you need to put them back in....and maybe a couple more.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Will we ever see papers on Human Resources in @J_HumanResource?
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
HR has grown very fast over the last decade
www.economist.com/business/2025/11/10/how-hr-took-over-th⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Dave Hall presenting research with @q_econ on the impacts of drug legalization in Oregon. Prior research has found different estimates using the same methods. We replicate, reconcile and extend prior research. @APPAM_DC
#appam2025 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alice Evans
@_alice_evans
Alcohol consumption is a major driver of intimate partner violence within India and more globally.
New work by Karuppusamy Balasubramani and colleagues shows key hot spots. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who's APPAm bound? Got your grunge playlist and hoodie for some excellent PNW fall weather?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is someone doing an audit study where they meant to vary pictures and names, and instead just varied pictures?
Jeffrey Wooldridge
@jmwooldridge
Nothing sus here.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jeremiah Johnson đ
@JeremiahDJohns
"The American middle class is shrinking, specifically because they make too much money to be considered middle class any more" is one of those things that's true but makes people irate when you say it out loud.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
Itâs astonishing that the richest country in world history could convince itself that it was plundered by immigrants and trade. marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2025/11/one-thiâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Of course, it's probably coincides with a drop in household assets because home ownership rates have dropped... This good news is also correlated with some of the bad news that people talk about.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
We are increasingly seeing data of people souring on capitalism as an economic system. Proponents are surprised, since capitalism has generated unprecedented wealth and prosperity. Why the break?
I think the financial crisis, and the public/private response to it, was the break.
A key principle of capitalism is that firms/individuals are rewarded for bearing risk by obtaining a higher reward. In 2008, we saw firms who had taken completely irresponsible levels of risk be bailed out with taxpayer money. For years they profited from their investments, but to (even not so careful) observes, it became obvious that they did not actually bare the costs of the risk.
But what about the people who were sold the increasingly complex products, what happened when they couldn't pay? They were not bailed out. Some could re-negotiate terms, but many just simply lost their livelihoods.
Slowly but surely, as this sank in, I think this caused a fundamental shift in how people perceived as "capitalism" in this country. Commentators and influencers exploited this shift, writing essays and op eds on how much better socialism---which has been a disaster everywhere it's been tried---as an economic system.
But the truth is capitalism is still the most effective system in increasing the size of the pie and spurring innovation.
To push back against the rising tide, it is necessary to speak out, and forcefully, against any effort for the govt to give breaks and favors, to shield firms from risk on the taxpayer's dime.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
If you want to know why people are turning away from capitalism, itâs s#%t like this: private firms wanting to keep upside of investment while taxpayers cover their downside.
Proponents of capitalism need to fight like hell against this. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Defendants guilty of identical DWI offenses face sharply different outcomes by race, gender, and resources, revealing systemic inequality in punishment beyond, from @JeffDenning, @benconomics, Lars Lefgren, Emily C. Leslie, and Cody Tuttle www.nber.org/papers/w34425
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Tried to record a remote lecture for my students after traveling for 20 hours and fell asleep in the middle of it. I need to sleep and try again tomorrow...peace out.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What if AI is amazingly good at making TPS reports for us to fill out....
SciTech Era
@SciTechera
Jensen Huang, NVIDIAâs CEO, says AI will make humans busier, not jobless.
He says AI will boost productivity, spark new ideas, and create fields like robotics and biotech, driving global economic growth. Instead of leisure, expect more work as AI amplifies opportunities. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Sleepiness is driven by econ seminars.
The Economist
@TheEconomist
Sleepiness may be driven by metabolic stress in the brain, not just fatigue www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2025/07/16/why-dâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My only great use of ai is summarizing short answering reflection essays from students about what they are struggling with in econ principles.
The New Yorker
@NewYorker
An M.I.T. study found that 95% of companies that had invested in A.I. tools were seeing zero return. It jibes with the emerging idea that generative A.I., âin its current incarnation, simply isnât all itâs been cracked up to be,â @JohnCassidy writes. nyer.cm/FUZwzw8
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
But if they took it at Harvard?
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
"The order of authors is decided by their Real Analysis grade in undergrad."
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Hear me out. What if we make the work day and school day shorter as days get shorter?
Benjamin Ryan
@benryanwriter
Changing the clocks is a compromise in a vast nation covering a wide latitude and longitude. If we didn't change the clocks in the fall, certain swaths of the country would not see daylight until nearly 9am during the depths of winter. Conversely, if we did not change the clocks back in the spring, certain parts of the country would needlessly see daylight starting at about 4am, meaning the daylight would go to waste given that the vast majority of people are sleeping then. Adjusting the clocks shifts the daylight so it is more likely to cover the times when most people are awake.
This is what the winter sunrise would look like without shifting the clocks in the fall: -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Emily Leslie
@emilycleslie
New working paper with @JeffDenning, @benconomics, @LarsLefgren & Cody Tuttle:
đ âSame Crime, Different Time: Disparities in Judicial Outcomes for DWI Offenders.â
We study how similar DWI defendants can face very different sentences. 1/5 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Replication and reconsideration matters.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who's going to write the labor economics paper about the signaling effects of a graduating with latin honors when there's this much grade inflation happening?
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
Average GPA at Harvard by year:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Further evidence of the harms of #daylightsavings, hungry golden retrievers everywhere.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
Massachusetts passes major literacy bill 155â0 despite opposition from powerful teachers union:
âDistricts must use state-approved reading curriculums that include âfive research-based areas,â which include not just phonics but also vocab & comprehension, among other focusesâ -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
CristĂłbal Otero
@cristobalotero
And it's a wrap. The last chapter of my dissertation is out today.
It's hard to explain to those outside the profession how much work goes into a paper â and how personal they become.
I hope you enjoy reading it.
[continues]
AEA Journals
@AEAjournals
The November 2025 issue of the American Economic Review (115, 11) is now available online at aeaweb.org/issues/825.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Hitoshi Shigeoka é岥 äť
@HitoshiShigeoka
ăăćčżă§ä¸çŞĺĽ˝ăăŞčŤćăăăŞăŽĺ ŹçŤç é˘ă§ăçľĺśč ăăĺťĺ¸ŤĺşčşŤăăăăăăă¸ăĄăłăçľé¨ăŽăăĺ°é厜ăăŤĺ¤ć´ăăĺ ąé Źăĺźăä¸ăăçľćââç é˘ă§ăŽćťäşĄçă ç´8ďź ć¸ĺ°ă¨ăŽăă¨ă
CristĂłbal Otero
@cristobalotero
And it's a wrap. The last chapter of my dissertation is out today.
It's hard to explain to those outside the profession how much work goes into a paper â and how personal they become.
I hope you enjoy reading it.
[continues]
AEA Journals
@AEAjournals
The November 2025 issue of the American Economic Review (115, 11) is now available online at aeaweb.org/issues/825.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Timberbust in the West is showing.
CrĂŠmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
There's been massive economic convergence across U.S. regions, and nowadays, their poverty rates aren't all that different.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm 6'2.5. I round up and say 6'3 because a lot of 6'1 people say they're 6'2 and I don't want to make them feel bad.
Stefan Schubert
@StefanFSchubert
The main takeaway should be that the reported height was on average strikingly honest/correct (in this study)
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Theranos 2.0?
1X
@1x_tech
NEO The Home Robot
Order TodayThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Nobody remembers Juicero or Theranos?
Mike Kalil
@mikekalilmfg
it can lift almost 3x its weight and has 22 DoF hands? and itâs $20K?
so it outperforms and undercuts everything on the market? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I hate that learning to type in the 90s makes me reflexively double space after periods. How do I unlearn this?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Holy s*&t. This paper is insane.
You can recover input text from an LLM through inversion. Huge implications for how we understand these models, as well as for things like privacy.
GLADIA Research Lab
@GladiaLab
LLMs are injective and invertible.
In our new paper, we show that different prompts always map to different embeddings, and this property can be used to recover input tokens from individual embeddings in latent space.
(1/6) -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Amazing obituary for Prof. Erich Streissler
Students in the 60s demanded to discuss Marx. Streissler agreed & offered a Marx seminar: one chapter of Kapital per week to read & prepare. Attendance collapsed.
Turns out students wanted Marxist revolution, not Marxist homework. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
But will AI generated music making meme's that make us laugh forever?
Wes Roth
@WesRoth
AI-generated music from Suno v5 is now nearly indistinguishable from human-made songs.
In blind tests, listeners guessed wrong as often as they guessed right. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What the important thing AI could answer that would make it worth if we all lose our jobs?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Literally Mankiw.
6. Markets are usually a good way to organize economic activity â The âinvisible handâ of prices guides resources.
7. Governments can sometimes improve market outcomes â For example, by addressing externalities or providing public goods.
Shahin Ashkiani
@shaahin_a
Claim: Mainstream econ is not normative, it is positive and value independent. We are not indoctrinating pupils
Mankiw:
1. Markets are efficient
2. Social planners cannot do better than the markets. Market is the acme of econ wellbeing
3. Any intervention makes it worse -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
The research funding landscape has changed, but @Arnold_Ventures is still here, still getting lots of dollars out the door to find solutions to important policy problems! đ¤
Hereâs a list of studies related to public safety that we funded last quarter: -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jeremy Horpedahl đĽđ
@jmhorp
Rob Schneider was born in 1963, when about 3% of children in the US died before their 5th birthday (16% worldwide). Today, just 0.7% die in the US (4% worldwide). In the distant past, it was 30-40%.
This was mostly because kids got sick and they didn't have modern medicine.
Rob Schneider đşđ¸
@RobSchneider
FYIâŚ
There were NO Childrenâs Hospitals when I was a kid.
Because kids werenât sick. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
In earlier post, I highlighted replicability of the foundational behavioral economic results.
In new @chicagoboothrev article, @R_Thaler explore why. Discuss two reasons:
1) Scrutiny from field at "surprising" results.
2) Following transparency norms from exp. econ. 1/n
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
The experiments in original studies form the bedrock of behavioral economics. Given issues of replicability in social sciences, a natural question to ask: are they robust?
We replicated the main experiment in each chapter's seminal work.
Good news: they're *very* robust! 8/n -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
New newsletter: Deciphering the latest candidate for Scariest Chart in the World
For the last 10 yearsâand the last several decadesâthe stock market and job openings rose and fell in tandem. Since 2022, that link snapped: Stocks are up 75% and job listings down 33%. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
100%. Everyone I've talked to with first-hand knowledge of jail & prison conditions describes a horrible environment that doesn't create a pathway to success but to more failure. Humane living conditions with programming isn't soft on crime; it's necessary for safer communities.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I was a mainstream economist for many years, until I discovered entering the fringe had higher visibility and the possibility to sell more books. Subscribe to my podcast. Don't blame me. Blame normal market forces.
Steven Hail
@StevenHailAus
I was a mainstream economist for many years. I understand the reaction MMT evokes in such people, as it triggered the same reaction in me. It is then a question of whether you are prepared to question things you have taken for granted, and admit to yourself they are simply wrong.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Lauren Hoehn-Velasco
@LHoehnVelasco
đ¨ Weâre hiring an Assistant Professor! đ¨
Come join us at @GSU_Economics! Weâre an applied, collaborative, and innovative department in the heart of Atlanta. #econtwitter
Happy to talk more about our department for anyone considering applying.
Georgia State Economics Dept. and Seminar Series
@GSU_Economics
We invite applications for the position of Assistant Professor in the Department of Economics at the Andrew Young School of Policy Studies. Our department has enjoyed several highly successful recruiting cycles, fostering a productive and collegial faculty community.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Adverse selection. Not that different than the market for long term care, which also has huge adverse selection problems.
Also moral hazard, you delaying having children which increases risks of some types of serve disabilities.
EigenGender đ¸
@EigenGender
one risk when having a child is that they will have a severe disability requiring lifelong care and other financial support. Why canât I buy insurance against that risk
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Twitter is healing.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Question: Is AI/ChatGPT/etc making human capital transferrable, and how does that change everything about labor markets?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Being doxxed as a member of the Ku Klux Klan had "no statistically significant effect on any outcomes of interest".
Can't wait to read this JMP -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
The certainty of being caught is a more effective crime deterrent than harsh punishments, yet the majority of crimes are never solved. âThis realization should fundamentally reshape how we think about public safety,â @jenniferdoleac writes in @dcexaminer. Read the full op-ed here: www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/fairness-jusâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I used to have my arms full of kids. They grow fast (three teenagers now with one off at college).
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
If you look at the last decadeâat the obesity epidemic, at social media companies spending billions on algorithms that hack human psychology, at people voting against their material interestsâand think behavioral econ is somehow not relevantâŚnot sure what to tell you.
Ryan Murphy
@ryanhmurphy
who remembers behavioral economics and the era when any finding not "supported" by some crap n=40 experiment somehow published in AER was dismissed as 101ism
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think we've always known that dark matter is the stuff moving the invisible hand around.
Wojtek Kopczuk đľđąđşđŚ and đşđ˛
@wwwojtekk
Time for economists to invade physics
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is the credibility revolution in econ the same thing as the introduction of poly strings in tennis? Brought on the death of well respected styles of play like serving and volleying (research).
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Economics Journals as Tennis Tournaments
đ§ľ(for an extremely niche audience)
Quarterly Journal of Economics = Wimbledon
The oldest and most influential event, but also clubby, snobby, and elitist. To win it you must train on a very particular surface/ZIP code. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How would things be different if we had a minimum earnings floor instead of a minimum wage?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
On a new episode of the Jeff-alytics podcast, AVâs @LauraArnoldFdn talks with Jeff Asher about the role philanthropy can play in improving the quality of crime data and advancing evidence-based policies. Listen here: jasher.substack.com/jeff-alytics-podcast-episode-2-can
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jeremy Horpedahl đĽđ
@jmhorp
Only 2.5% of US households had 3 or more cars in 1960. This person was either very rich, or just loved cars. The median household had 1 car.
Today the median household has 2 cars, and over 20% have 3 or more cars -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How does this intersect and related with the increased fraction of young adults still living with their parents ?
Ryan Radia
@RyanRadia
Homeownership rate by decade of birth by current age (United States)
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Wojtek Kopczuk đľđąđşđŚ and đşđ˛
@wwwojtekk
An undergraduate destroys the famous heterodox professor
A Dismal Optimist đ¨đŚ đŹđŞ
@yah5us
Youâre confusing marginal costs changing over time with a schedule of marginal costs at a given point in time.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Not a great look for Oregon. @TinaKotek, Oregon used to be a leader for Medicaid. Follow the evidence and the social science.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Many incarcerated individuals struggle with mental health & addiction. Without treatment upon release, most will recidivate. To ensure continuity, 11 states from CA to KY won waivers to start Medicaid coverage shortly before release. Itâs shame to see these programs rolled back.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
In the 1920s, the U.S. set immigration quotas which effectively stopped scientists from immigrating from Eastern and Southern Europe.
The U.S. quickly fell behind in patenting and publishing in fields where these scientists worked.
Don't kill the golden goose. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How much will other financial aid drop? Net tuition after scholarships is much harder to measure.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Santa Clara is one of the first law schools to publish 2026-27 tuition. Historically, Grad PLUS loans have had no limits. Starting next year, professional school borrowing will be capped at $50k/year. Notice anything about the trend in tuition?
I expect many schools to copy this. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
The next ViCE seminar is this Thursday, October 16, at 1pm ET.
@mtotarelli will present: "Prison Rehabilitation Programs, Recidivism, and Labor Market Outcomes" -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Key question related to this years job market @paulgp, @florianederer, what is the supply for this year. 6 years ago, most graduate programs saw freezes to hiring, and therefore smaller Phd cohorts. Since most finish in 6 these days, supply should be reduced too?
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Our cohort was 5 6 years ago instead of normal sized (10-12). So in eqbm, wages may not change, and instead unemployment may not change, but number placed drops?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If AGI is possible how is this different than basically thinking the world ends at this date because we would have one chance to get alignment right.
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do you think AGI is possible and how soon is it coming?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do you think AGI is possible and how soon is it coming?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do you think AGI is possible and how soon is it coming?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I will move to Europe for $31.9m.
Peter Hull
@instrumenthull
I will also move to Europe for $32 million
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Trying to think back to what I was doing in the 90s...
Anthony Bradley
@drantbradley
What happened in the 1990s that set in motion the trend of American young adults walking away from Christianity?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My Nobel prediction: @davidautor , Dorn, and Hanson. Understanding the complexities of the long term effects of trade shocks on local labor markets might be the most important thing economists are trying to unpack right now. Its impacts on geopolitics can't be overstated right now.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Dr. Jones presubmitting his justification on concur.
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Indiana Jones is a fantasy about being a professor not having to submit itemized travel expenses after every adventure.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Scariest situation ever. A student asked me if they should sell their gold holdings after class today on supply and demand. What should I have said?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
American used to know how to build too.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Increasingly seems like China is learning how to invent.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
My favorite dataviz expert Paul G-P has a constantly updated chart for the economics job market on his website.
Link below: -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Why econ department and political science department are usually in different buildings:
Interesting things
@awkwardgoogle
These cats were put in separate cages because they kept fighting
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm still using Stata15. Do I....
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ha Luong
@luongthuha
I am very excited to share our new working paper "College Access and Domestic Violence". This is a joint work with Sudhir Singh from University of Rochester.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Finding use for my peloton now that I'm department head.
#multitasking -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alec Stapp
@AlecStapp
Increase literacy rates with this one weird trick (phonics)
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
wrote today about how even if you've heard of Mississippi's surge in reading scores, you're probably underestimating it:
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
Scary news for psychologists publishing in management journals
Rob Freund
@RobertFreundLaw
Arby's was sued for false advertising because its ads:
-Made it appear that the sandwiches had "at least 100% more meat" than they really do, and
-Made the meat look like rare roast beef when it is actually "fully cooked."
This week, Arby's lost its motion to dismiss the case.
Consumers allege they would not have purchased the sandwiches, or would have paid less for them, if they knew the truth.
Arby's argued that the photos amounted to non-actionable puffery. The court rejected that argument at this stage, because they photos do not consist of "subjective statements of opinion." -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Now we need a plot for fertility relative to tenure.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Running a lab means that drop in productivity affects many people other than yourself (students, postdocs, etc). My conjecture is that this responsibility for others keeps people productive.
Wonder if this will impact Econ post tenure trajectory as it becomes more lab-based. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
New op-ed with my colleague @George_A_Callas, out today in @TaxNotes.
Based on excellent new research by three economists, we argue that the federal government's Work Opportunity Tax Credits â which aim to increase employment for disadvantaged job-seekers, including people with felony convictions â are a huge waste of money.
A fascinating, high-quality study by Manisha Jain, Corina Mommaerts, and Jeffrey Weaver shows that WOTC does not change who is employed, at all. It's just free money to some big companies that take the time to fill out the necessary paperwork.
(WOTC was a great idea - there's good reason to think that wage subsidies could be helpful. But great ideas aren't always effective in practice. Check out our op-ed or the full research study for the reasons it's been such a flop.)
It's time to end WOTC and shift these $19B(!) to other, more promising strategies. Those on the margins of the labor force deserve our help. Let's do something that actually works. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Sports betting sites market the industry as a game of skill but then ban players who consistently win. They only want players who have no skill. Imagine if that's what your investment broker did.
A proposed bill in NY would bar sportsbooks from discriminating among customers. If you want to take bets, take bets. Don't base the business on only allowing people who are going to lose. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Thinking about Abundance by @ezraklein right now. Given we know about crime and recidivism based on work by people like @KSchnepel and Cynthia Yang, making construction easier would raise demand for workers, which would probably benefit those with criminal records and lower recidivism.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
alz
@alz_zyd_
Frequent convo between me and PhD students
Me: "After 400 hours of data analysis on industry X, have you talked to anyone actually working in industry X"
Student (S): "No"
Me: "Why not?"
Student: "Where would I find someone in industry X willing to talk to me" -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
A reflective moment about how I'm spending my time, and why.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Edibles for thought here.
Pat Oglesby
@OglesbyPat
Warning from 2015: Taxing cannabis by percentage of price (instead of by THC) will end up with states, in the face of declining prices, wanting tax increases.
And that that's like cutting a cat's tail off an inch at a time.
#marijuana #cannabis #hemp #thca -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
What are the most popular electives at your economics department? In recent years, based on undergrad enrollments, it appears to be subjects micro-ish classes like health, crime, environmental economics, market power, and inequality. What about your department?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Heading back to Texas after a great couple days in DC with the @Arnold_Ventures CJ team. Weâre thinking big about priorities for 2026 - focused on fresh ideas to test and new partners we might work with.
Weâre always open to pitches from the outside! Our goal is evidence-based policy, from research, to policy development, to advocacy. Get in touch if youâre working on something cool. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
MarĂa Padilla Romo
@MaraPadillaR
New working paper alert đ¨
Students induced to leave violent areas due to increased violence experience academic gains after relocating to safer areas.
Results appear to be explained by increases in school attendance and improvements in the learning environment after they move.
NBER
@nberpubs
Estimating the effects of moving away from violent environments into safer areas on migrants' academic achievement in the context of the Mexican war on drugs, from @MaraPadillaR and Cecilia Peluffo www.nber.org/papers/w34270
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Coase strikes again!!!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Melissa S. Kearney
@kearney_melissa
Apply to join our dynamic, exciting, growing economics department @nd_econ!
Great colleagues, terrific students, a supportive university administration, and fun family-friendly football tailgates! đ
Notre Dame Economics
@nd_econ
We are hiring (again!). We are searching for up to four tenure-track hires. Two of these are open-field/open-rank. Two are endowed at the full professor level -- one with a focus on applied micro and poverty, the other with a focus on demography.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Joshua Price
@sportseconprof
The Econ Challenge, sponsored by Engine, kicks off at 6 PM tonight!!
BYU Econ students will tackle a real-world problem and work as teams to develop solutionsâall in just one week. Itâs going to be exciting to see the creativity and skills on display. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I wonder how much of this demographics. Is the theater going crowd getting to old to appreciate broadway? People still love music, but it seems like younger or middle aged music lovers are going to en vogue acts (Swifties) or nostalgia shows (when we were young) etc.
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
Broadway is in trouble
- 18 new musicals opened on Broadway last season; none has made a profit
- Since 2020, 46 new musicals have opened on Broadway, costing ~$800 million; 43 lost money
- Jason Laks, the president of the Broadway League, estimates that the share of musicals that are profitable has fallen by 50 percent in the last decade -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Even if you haven't read Jens's excellent book yet (what are you waiting for?), you should check out this episode. Two top experts â Jens and @barryfriedman1 â discuss what we know about how to reduce violence in our nation's cities. A timely and fascinating conversation.
Probable Causation
@ProbCausation
Bonus episode 15: @barryfriedman1 interviews Jens Ludwig about his new book, Unforgiving Places.
www.probablecausation.com/podcasts/bonus-episode-15-jens-⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
A PhD is literally a Doctorate!!!
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
But are economists doctors?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do we need a journal of descriptive economics with that casual inference or theory to follow later?
Anup Malani
@anup_malani
Economists address only those questions where the answer meets a certain quality constraint (eg credibility).
But the real world requires answers to questions even if answers are not perfect. To increase demand for economists, we need to make answering important questions the goal, subject to the constraints that the answers be the best possible given the data and theory.
David Van Dijcke
@packlesshepherd
US academic economics market continuing to pull away from the COVID market this week.
I created a little tracker for JOE here for those who want to play around with the data. Updates weekly: www.davidvandijcke.com/joe_tracker/ -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
What happens when the U.S. restricts H-1B visas?
Firms donât stop hiring talent, they just move jobs abroad.
For every visa rejection, multinationals add ~0.4â0.9 foreign employees, especially in R&D hubs like India, China, and Canada. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
David Van Dijcke
@packlesshepherd
US academic economics market continuing to pull away from the COVID market this week.
I created a little tracker for JOE here for those who want to play around with the data. Updates weekly: www.davidvandijcke.com/joe_tracker/ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Should Ebikers be required to have some basic form of liability insurance. Right now I saw places adopting speed limits which are never enforced. Why not liability insurance given most people have no umbrella liability policies?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Fatal overdoses. Monthly ER overdose visits haven't changed that much (didn't spike as bad either).
Also make that chart going back to the year 1995 and tell me the crisis is over. We still have more people overdosing than car accidents and homicides combined. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
FIRE
@TheFIREorg
President Trump suggested today that media outlets are engaging in âhate speechâ by being âunfairâ to him and âmaybeâ should be prosecuted.
Trumpâs statement demonstrates the inherent danger of âhate speechâ laws: Those in power will always weaponize them to silence dissent. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Justin Wolfers
@JustinWolfers
Uncertainty hurts demand. Tariffs raise costs. Immigration crackdowns shrink the workforce. Add them together, and here we are: Uncertain, unhappy, and worried.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Wojtek Kopczuk đľđąđşđŚ and đşđ˛
@wwwojtekk
the list of bipartisan things that I don't approve:
- tariffs
- picking winners and losers
- attacking independence of the Fed
- cancel culture
- governing by executive orders
- centralizing government power
- driving up the national debt
tbc -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Arnold Ventures invests in âorphan areasâ â issues overlooked by philanthropy. We build research ecosystems that help policymakers make informed decisions. AV Co-Founder @johnarnold explains how strategic philanthropy can drive real change: bizj.us/1qog0g
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
One of the best (maybe the best) applied microeconomic conferences around.
đźđŁđđđ đđđđđ
@Erdal_Tekin_
The 15th Workshop on the Economics of Risky Behavior, sponsored by @AU_SPA, will be held July 8â9, 2026 in Cagliari, Italy! đŽđš
Keynote: Paolo Pinotti (Bocconi University)
Organizers: Erdal Tekin (American University) & Claudio Deiana, Ludovica Giua, Marco Nieddu (University of Cagliari)
đ Submission deadline: March 6, 2026
đ Submit here: www.american.edu/spa/risky-behavior/ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why is the econ job market slow this year? Changing demand for econ degrees are probably catching up with the profession. Here's a time series (with base rates normalized to 100). Undergrad degrees for UO, Majors, and degrees granted.
#econtwitter #econjobmarketPost not available here, view on X
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Some departments (those at universities without business schools or data science departments) are probably fine. Everybody else if feeling the crunch, when then affects graduate hiring. Might be useful for your tracking of JOE listings @packlesshepherd (I bet govt hiring way down too).
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is the @AEAjournals doing enough to help give econ departments accurate and up to date information to adapt or develop strategies? Other professional associations actually influence strategies and even legislation for their profession. What can ours do?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Want to learn some econometrics and coding best practices? Like and subscribe.
Tyler Ransom
@tyleransom
I'm excited to launch a YouTube channel about econometrics and practical coding / productivity tools. Please consider subscribing so that others can more easily find these resources!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Am I bad parent if I don't know my kids phone numbers?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If you knew what random tariffs would temporarily be coming down the pipeline, you could make a fortune in trading commodities right now. I'd be shocked if people aren't based on how specific tariffs are and how deals end up. How is trading based on insider knowledge of politics not a form of insider trading?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Nicholas Decker
@captgouda24
When it comes to getting viewers, the culture war performs best and real issues worst.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jeffrey Wooldridge
@jmwooldridge
Can all econometric methodologists studying causal inference make a 2026 New Year's resolution to stop using the Lalonde (1986) data to illustrate new estimators?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I can thank ChatGpt for making sure my emails have very well written typos and errors. That's productivity increasing right?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
cc: everyone
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Why are you promoting this deranged nonsense? We donât even know who killed him yet.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Political violence is especially terrible because it not only harms the individual but also threatens the inherently fragile 250-year experiment of American democracy.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Michael Kofoed
@mikekofoed
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
FIRE
@TheFIREorg
BREAKING: Charlie Kirk was shot during an event at Utah Valley University today. Details of the incident are still unfolding.
Political violence is never an acceptable response to speech. Free speech allows us to settle our differences peacefully and is essential to a free and democratic society.
Our thoughts are with Charlie Kirk and his family. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Beyond a reasonable doubt? Sounds like very good chance.
How many false convictions does that language create?
AJ Thurston, PhD
@AJThurston
I prefer this format
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
We donât yet know what motivated the person who shot and killed Charlie Kirk, but this kind of despicable violence has no place in our democracy. Michelle and I will be praying for Charlieâs family tonight, especially his wife Erika and their two young children.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
It's ghoulish to mock or justify the shooting of Charlie Kirk. Rising political violence is a horror of our time. Unchecked it will lead to catastrophes none of us want to imagine.
Deeply hoping he pulls through. We are all people, whatever we believe. That has to come first. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How are applied economics majors across the country different than a more standard economics major? My sense they don't take take macro and are generally take in ag-econ departments. Am I right?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
David Roodman writes: consumers of economic research are more truth-seeking than the producers.
Here is Roodman's recap of his re-analysis of a set of papers on temperature and judge decision-making.
The comment process is not working that well!
Gory details in đ§ľ 1/ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So AI can already bunny hop better than me. It's not just going after jobs, it's coming for our hobbies!! @metrics52 @lhnicholas @paulnovosad @florianederer @carly_urban.
www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=306&v=cjaZUFMZWOY&emb⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Horton
@johnjhorton
.@BenSManning preparing big twitter thread about our new paper; tags wrong John Horton. i'm dying.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Served with Andy Roddick
@Served_Podcast
KPop Demon Hunters mentioned đ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Eva Vivalt
@evavivalt
In any case, improving people's subjective well-being over the long term is hard. This isn't necessarily a fault of the intervention - it could be something about human nature or subjective well-being measures. 8/
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Hereâs a lighthearted, Benconomics-style one:
---
Tweet draft:
My kids think âworking from homeâ means I sit around making graphs all day.
Which is accurateâexcept the graphs yell back at me when the parentheses donât balance.
Peter Hull
@instrumenthull
Nailed it, I'm afraid
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When you find one of your coworkers at the Book store.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Arnold Venturesâ latest #bridgeseries convening brought together practitioners & researchers to discuss the causal evidence on pretrial detention in domestic violence cases, surface gaps in current policy and practice, and begin to develop nuanced and evidence-driven approaches.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We study game theory and then don't ever actually try play it in real life or real time to see how our play comes up short with real stakes.
We can dissect problems and Monday morning quarterback it quite well.
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
We have a whole top 5 journal to deal with such issues.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The year is 2025. AI is everywhere. I still can't copy and paste a folder in @overleaf. How is this possible?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Looking for research funding? @Arnold_Ventures has several open RFPs. This includes a standing RFP for causal research related to US crime/the CJ system/ppl w criminal records.
First step is a 3-page LOI. We aim to get you a funding decision within 3 months of that first step. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
In DC for a wedding before doing a seminar at Pitt next Monday. What are the best "woke" museums I should visit with my kids tomorrow before they get whitewashed?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just hear me out. Sole group dinner at Casa Bonita?
Sandy Black
@Econ_Sandy
Society of Labor Economists (SoLE) Annual Conference will be in Denver May 1-2--you can now submit! Deadline for submissions is October 31--it should be a great conference!
mailchi.mp/sole-jole/sole-2023-submissions-open-18237139 -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Sandy Black
@Econ_Sandy
Society of Labor Economists (SoLE) Annual Conference will be in Denver May 1-2--you can now submit! Deadline for submissions is October 31--it should be a great conference!
mailchi.mp/sole-jole/sole-2023-submissions-open-18237139 -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
You only get peer review if you get followers and engagement.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
You ran some cool regression analysis OK great. Make some nice graphics and put it on a Substack. Engaging headline, 1500-2500 well-written words. That's literally 100x faster than trying to publish in a journal and it's better peer review anyway.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Anybody willing to try getting tenure with substack posts?
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
You ran some cool regression analysis OK great. Make some nice graphics and put it on a Substack. Engaging headline, 1500-2500 well-written words. That's literally 100x faster than trying to publish in a journal and it's better peer review anyway.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Should I teach a basic principles class (100 level) on the economics of weed next year?
Vote will be binding. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Joshua Price
@sportseconprof
Hereâs a great example of the work happening in BYU Economics.
Our Career Director recently gathered data on recent graduatesâturning it into a powerful resource for helping current students launch their careers. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Does economics positively select for people who are good statistical inference because of the math in core theory or in spite of it?
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
Being actually good at statistical inference is a (rare) skill, and many academics are good at it mostly by virtue of being overall smart people, but there's almost nothing in the academic pipeline that positively selects for it.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
You've got Q's about legalized sports betting? They (@Emily_Arnesen and @q_econ) have answers on today's vice seminar. Register here.
arnoldventures.zoom.us/meeting/register/qzgdUBZpQCC2hB48z⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How the hell is this gun going to run the BLS if he doesn't know how to separate hyper planes?
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Thomas Abt
@Abt_Thomas
Trump's EO cites "rising crime" as a justification for temporarily taking over the MPD. That's wrong - violent crime has dropped 46% this year and dropped 35% last year according to MPD's latest numbers.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
A lot of criticisms regarding EJ Antoni are focusing on the wrong things: where he got his PhD, number of publications and citations. There's a big world out there and I'm sorry to break it to you but outside of the little slio of econ academia, these comments scream elitism. We already saw what a Harvard PhD did to trade policy...
EJ Antoni seems to have plenty of bad ideas and takes. Just criticize those. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Tennis sets have about 60 points or so. So in 3 set match there's 180 possessions between the two, and 300 over a 5 set match. Laws of large numbers tend to win out.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
NBA: ~100-110 possessions per team
NFL: ~65-70 offensive plays per team
NHL: A little hard to define but ~30 shots and ~90 shifts per team, maybe ~45 offensive "possessions" per team game
MLB: ~35-40 PA per team game
This correlates strongly with how dominant the best teams are. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why isn't AI destroying jobs in engineering and law? Based on friends I met with this last week employers are scared (reasonably so) of sharing trade or national secrets with AI companies. Want to file a patent for a new device? You willing to share your design with Chatgpt?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Lots of great stuff on the vice seminar this fall. Oregon economists with some great research the first couple of weeks.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
The ViCE seminar schedule for early fall 2025 is up! We start back up again next week (Aug 14).
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
ChatGPT, give me a graph where nominal home prices are going up but real wages are like, zero.
Bingo, now weâre cooking.
Bernie Sanders
@BernieSanders
It is insane that in the richest country in the world, millions cannot afford a home and hundreds of thousands are homeless every night.
We need major investments in affordable housing, not tax breaks for billionaires. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Working on some beautiful code.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
PhD students working on topics related to crime & the criminal justice system in the US:
Join us for a research workshop this October! We're bringing y'all together so that you can meet each other, and (selfishly) so the @Arnold_Ventures CJ team can meet you.
Sign up by August 11! -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Legalized sports betting increases intimate partner violence.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
They missunderstood what economist mean when they say it's a race to the bottom.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
"If you find yourself in a hole, dig even faster," or so the saying must go in Illinois.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Sam Norris
@sambnorris
Come work with me! I'm hiring a pre-doc RA, starting ASAP, to work on projects in labor economics and the economics of crime.
stonecentre.economics.ubc.ca/pre-doctoral-fellowship-oppo⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Just released: A list and brief description of research studies the @Arnold_Ventures Criminal Justice team funded in the first half of 2025. Over $15 million out the door to figure out what works. Keep the great ideas coming!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
10,000 likes for a Twitter personality who condones murder because he does not understand housing markets.
Just another day on here.
Sean Padraig McCarthy
@SeanMcCarthyCom
New York City is so evil that if you walk into a random big building to do a mass shooting thereâs decent odds youâll hit the person in charge of buying up single family homes for blackstone
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alexander Berger
@albrgr
TIL that even though the US Clean Power Plan was repealed, US power sector emissions have dropped faster than it targeted (basically bc of faster than anticipated transitions to solar and gas). Bummer to me that these pieces of good news aren't more celebrated!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
No wonder econ major counts are down.
Peter Hull
@instrumenthull
Economics is dead
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Critical Trade Theory will fail to produce the new economy it's promised everyone.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Really excited to see AV taking a strategic gamble on this new area of research. If you haven't seen it, read @Emily_Arnesen and @q_econ paper showing gambling amplifies emotional cue driven domestic violence. Legalized gambling markets could have even larger impacts on DV, child abuse and other issues.
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Interested in helping to fill the gaps in our understanding of the financial, social, and behavioral impacts of legalized sports betting? Check out our new RFP: âCausal Research on the Impacts of Legalized Sports Bettingâ #rfp!
đď¸ Letters of interest (LOIs) are due by Monday, September 15, 2025.
Details and deadline information are available here: www.arnoldventures.org/resources/causal-research-on-the-i⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Reviewing typeset pages of my new book - coming in February 2026. đĽł
(Itâs available for preorder now if youâre so inclined; preorders really help!) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is the most clever thing about the South Park depiction of Trump that in order to sue them and win for libel, he would have to submit to official measurement of his anatomy?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
this is a great point. The one thing this figure misses is the massive drop in expenditures as people age and eventually die, as these are revenues per person, and don't reflect population groups and how they change.
Melissa S. Kearney
@kearney_melissa
100% this!
Of course this can readily be *explained* by the political power of âold people.â
But, it cannot be reasonably *justified* on either moral or economic grounds. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
On Oct 17, ahead of @TheIACP conference in Denver, our CJ team will be hosting a causal inference workshop to familiarize frontline professionals and other practitioners with rigorous research methods. Sign up by July 31: events.arnoldventures.org/en/3ipjnC6/g/GeVeVVxnen/causal-âŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I recently took the role of Department Head at UO. The biggest issue is our general trend in majors and credit hours. Is the @AEAInformation putting out any resources to help the profession advance ourselves. The shortage of econ professor jobs is directly tied to enrollment in econ across the country. What are we doing collectively to make sure economic education at universities continues to be important?
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I'm on an email chain with a half dozen econ chairs/heads. Vast majority have enrollments which have a dropped a ton. Key issues are changes in student composition (intl students like economics more), and competition from data science.
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How do we best respond? New classes? New minors? New credentials (certificates)? Some guidance and broader data can only be helpful in figuring out how to develop new strategies and compete in the marketplace for ideas.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Those of us focused on evidence-based policy to reduce crime are eager to scale summer jobs programs - on both sides of the pond.
This excellent piece from Tim Leunig makes the case for more government support of these highly effective programs.
(The US might be way ahead of the UK on this but we still have a long way to go!) -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
The @Arnold_Ventures Criminal Justice team is hosting a *free* causal inference workshop for practitioners, October 17th in Denver, CO (before the IACP conference).
Sign up here by July 31: events.arnoldventures.org/en/3ipjnC6/g/GeVeVVxnen/causal-âŚ
Participants will be chosen by a fair lottery. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Missing NBER summer camp because I'm in Oklahoma for a week to help my MIL move out of her house. Have a day in OKC beforehand. Visiting the memorial and museum. A sober reminder that domestic terrorism is a huge threat. I feel like the OKC bombing gets overshadowed by 911, so it's easy to forget hot real that threat is.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Sometimes it's hard to say goodbye to former students. @q_econ headed off to make the world a better place.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Got an obvious scam message on linkedin that wanted my whatsapp number. I sent them the whatsapp number for the fraud division at the FBI. Any other ideas of #s to give to scammers to waste their time?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Waiting for the next show to drop on this....
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
When universities hired chief diversity officers, it had no effect on the diversity of faculty or university administrator hires.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Stefanie Stantcheva
@S_Stantcheva
Ever feel like everything online is getting angrier? Youâre not imagining it. Tweets with anger have surged since 2013, while neutral content has declined. đ
And it matters for policyâour new paper shows how emotions shape what people support. socialeconomicslab.org/research/working-papers/emotions-a⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
I like this op-ed by Jens Ludwig. We need to get better at preventing crime - through deterrence or helping would-be offenders find a better path. Jens has excellent research supporting CBT as an answer here. We also need to solve more crimes!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Four incredible days of listening, learning, connecting, and reimagining the future of health care. Thank you, @aspenideas Health.đĄ#aspenideas #aspenideashealth
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Way more land swaps for sure. The checkerboard of BLM and private land is insane in Oregon whether you want conservation, recreation, or private land usage.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
If you oppose the government selling federally owned land, do you instead think it should be aggressively buying more? or do you think the government currently owns the optimal amount and location of land?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Doing background research for becoming department head in a week.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just hear me out. Let's ban tipping. It's gone too far.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The time cost of free range kids vs organized every hour of the day for your kid has to be daunting. My mom kicked us out of the house in the summer and would say don't come back until it's dinner time. We roamed on bikes and drank from random hoses in people's front yards.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Convinced the one and only way to increase the birth rate in the US is a federal cap on hours per week allowed for organized youth sports. That's the binding constraint.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
How many AI companies are just theranosing? They are pretending on the verge of delivering amazing products, while really just employing an army of developers (possibly overseas) they are paying to do stuff on call?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Do girls ever have conversations about whether their mom can beat up the other's mom or is that just a boy thing?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Melissa S. Kearney
@kearney_melissa
NEW JOB POSTING!
Hiring an Associate Director to work with me at @nd_econ to launch the Stregthening Families Research Initiative.
In conversations with policy makers, journalists, non-profit leaders, & others about challenges facing families in the US, people always ask "but what can we do to strengthen families?" Fortunately, @NotreDame is committed to advancing research & evidence to answer that question and improve lives. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Anybody wanna write a AV grant with me evaluate ED-209s impact on crime?
The DC MD VA Live
@TheDMVLive
New âHIGH-TECH SECURITY ROBOTâ to start patrolling downtown Silver Spring parking garages in Montgomery County, MDâŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Happy Monday! Please share the job posting below. Great opportunity to join the CJ Policy team at Arnold Ventures.
That team works to implement/scale interventions that our Research team has deemed "evidence-based," and also works with our broad policy/practice network to seed new innovations and evaluations.
Manager positions are a great chance to learn a lot about the CJ field, meet lots of people, and get an inside look at how philanthropy works to catalyze change. Most CJ Managers spend 2-3 years at AV and use this position as a launchpad for the next phase in their careers.
I'm obviously biased but I think this is a super exciting team to work for, at an important time in the CJ policy space. We're up to big things, our team is fabulous, and AV is a great place to work.
Please share widely!
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Weâre hiring! đĽł
The Criminal Justice team at @Arnold_Ventures is searching for a Policy Manager to join our team.
Location: Houston, DC, or NYC
Salary range: $100-130k
Apply ASAP if youâre interested - we move quickly!
Please spread the word. đ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Brad Wilcox
@BradWilcoxIFS
Yet another NYT piece w/ the âbold ideaâ of imitating the Nordics (& their progressive family policies) to address our fertility problems.
Thereâs only one problem with this bold idea.đđź -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
Combining field experiments and a new model to study salary negotiations, from @zoebcullen, Bobak Pakzad-Hurson, and @pereztruglia www.nber.org/papers/w33903
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Thanks Dad. For everything.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Watching Mufasa on a plane back from Madrid. So far Taka (Scar) is the only recent Disney villain story that makes the villain actually tragic or (somewhat) understandable.
Should I watch SnowWhite next? -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The #abundance backlash is growing for @ezraklein.
DiscussingFilm
@DiscussingFilm
First look still for Pixarâs âHOPPERSâ
The film follows a girl who transfers her mind into a beaver to help the animals fight the construction plans from the local mayor
In theaters in March 2026. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Weâre hiring! đĽł
The Criminal Justice team at @Arnold_Ventures is searching for a Policy Manager to join our team.
Location: Houston, DC, or NYC
Salary range: $100-130k
Apply ASAP if youâre interested - we move quickly!
Please spread the word. đ -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
đźđŁđđđ đđđđđ
@Erdal_Tekin_
The keynote lecture by Janet Currie at the 14th Workshop on the Economics of Risky Behavior. www.youtube.com/live/x20Rs3_9zdM @AU_SPA
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I think I'm starting to understand Spanish better because I'm hearing the old people cussing a lot.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This will surely make $90k f150 loans cheaper right?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Eugenio Zucchelli
@e_zucchelli
âŚ@benconomics⊠kicking off day #2 of the Workshop on the Economics of Risky Behavior âŚ@FundacionAreces⊠#economicsworkshop #riskybehavior #madrid
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Beach Boys greatest hits was my first cd and the the were the first band I saw live. Brian Wilson (RIP) was genius and a madman. What was their best song?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
đźđŁđđđ đđđđđ
@Erdal_Tekin_
The 14th Workshop on the Economics of Risky Behavior is underway!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Estamos listos!!!
@erda -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
In my department head training yesterday I learned there's free self defense training available to us. Hmmm...
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I've seen a bunch of people announcing they're changing scenery this coming year. I guess I can announce a change in scenery. I've loved being at @uoregon. This next year I'll have less time in the classroom and more time in meetings.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Quien esta listo para esta conferncia espectacular?
đźđŁđđđ đđđđđ
@Erdal_Tekin_
The 14th Workshop on the Economics of Risky Behavior will take place on June 11â12 in Madrid đŞđ¸, hosted at @FundacionAreces.
Check out the program at www.american.edu/spa/risky-behavior/upload/program-14th-wâŚ.
Janet Currie (Princeton) will deliver a keynote lecture titled "Investing in Children to Address the Youth Mental Health Crisis" at 7 PM on June 11, and it is open to the public.
Register for Janet's lecture at www.fundacionareces.es/fundacionareces/es/actividades/invâŚ
@AU_SPA @EconomicasUAM @ICAE_UCM @EconomicsUc3m @BancoDeEspana -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
đźđŁđđđ đđđđđ
@Erdal_Tekin_
The 14th Workshop on the Economics of Risky Behavior will take place on June 11â12 in Madrid đŞđ¸, hosted at @FundacionAreces.
Check out the program at www.american.edu/spa/risky-behavior/upload/program-14th-wâŚ.
Janet Currie (Princeton) will deliver a keynote lecture titled "Investing in Children to Address the Youth Mental Health Crisis" at 7 PM on June 11, and it is open to the public.
Register for Janet's lecture at www.fundacionareces.es/fundacionareces/es/actividades/invâŚ
@AU_SPA @EconomicasUAM @ICAE_UCM @EconomicsUc3m @BancoDeEspana -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why isn't the big beautiful at least increasing funding of the IRS to raise revenue through better compliance to offset these new tax giveaways?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Paternity leave reduces fertility.
"Men reported lower desired fertility after the [paternity leave] reform, possibly due to their increased awareness of the costs of childrearing." -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Played some bicycle limbo. Genetics was not on my side. Went out at 38 inches.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Asa Craig
@AsaCraig
Exciting news re: a violence prevention CBT program in Chicago!
And sounds like @jenniferdoleac @mkrupanski and the team are looking to replicate this somewhere else!
Marc Krupanski
@mkrupanski
âIn a context where most of our good ideas don't work,â @jenniferdoleac said, âit's extremely exciting to see evidence that this is the kind of intervention that pretty dramatically can transform young people's lives.â
"This Mix of Therapies Is Helping to Stop Youth Violence in Chicago"
A violence prevention program is pairing cognitive behavioral therapy with other support to keep high-risk teens out of jail.
www.themarshallproject.org/2025/06/05/chicago-child-thera⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
When is Oregon going to increased its marijuana taxes? After years of steady growth revenues fell last year like many other states. Signs of market maturity (very low prices) and less marijuana getting steered out of state.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Terrific story about Choose to Change - a CBT-based program for high-risk youth that was recently evaluated using an RCT. My team is eager to fund replications of this program/study elsewhere, to see if it remains effective in other contexts.
www.themarshallproject.org/2025/06/05/chicago-child-thera⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Marc Goldwein
@MarcGoldwein
Pizza will give me energy to exercise.
Eating pizza is the best thing I can do to lose weight.
Tom Cotton
@TomCottonAR
Our tax cuts will set up America for economic growth.
That's the best thing we can do to get our debt under control. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We export education. Is Trump trying to fix the trade imbalance?
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
It is a very good thing for the U.S. that all the world's elites spend time at our universitiesâabsorbing our culture, our ideas.
If they stay, we get their talent. If they leave, they spread our beliefs in openness and entrepreneurialism.
It is foolishness to push them away. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Chris Freiman
@cafreiman
Counterpoint:
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Like why are we spending more and more on the military if we ended two wars?
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This is a beautiful and terrifying figure (made by Abbas Keshvani)
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So it's going to fabricate or use fraudulently manipulated data in its entire research agenda but get to the top of its field at Harvard before the retractions roll in a couple decades late.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
This is a beautiful and terrifying figure (made by Abbas Keshvani)
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
It'd be easy to fix the budget bill. Get rid of new tax cuts and spending. Replace Medicaid cuts to access with closing abuses on MA upcoding, site neutral payments, and Medicaid state directed payments. That's a more just and budget-neutral (with realistic dynamic scoring) bill.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Ok, if you need something to cheer you up, watch this 80 yr old guy cover blink 182.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=AnbEBT1xUgg -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Sometimes it feels unreal to me there's that much hate in this country. This morning played some pickleball. Some body showed up at 8am and started yelling at us because the courts didn't open until 830. We then saw the sign that said that (oops) and then as we were leaving she said she didn't know what country were from but we need to go back to where we came from. This lead to a natural more extended discussion over whether we were from here and me asking how that was even relevant. Man. Over pickleball.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Federal aid should fund opportunity, not programs that fail students. With smart reforms, we can hold institutions accountable and give students a fair shot at success. Itâs time for policymakers to act.
đ www.arnoldventures.org/stories/the-broken-promise-of-grad⌠(/2) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Why the hell does San Francisco get two interstates which finish in it and Oregon gets zero, and another dead ends in Nevada?
BowTiedBroke
@BowTiedBroke
The amount of people Iâve met that donât realize the US interstate road system is in numerical order is mind blowing. Figured this was common knowledge, but, if you didnât know, here you go!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So apparently in Oregon they are currently not filing for extradition for non violent crimes. So someone embezzled $100k from a newspaper and then fled out of state. Same thing for someone who embezzled $500k from a non profit that built affordable housing.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
People in Eugene seem to freaking out that the police want to install automated license plate readers.
Would you rather police rely on tips/calls. pretextual stops, or technology to locate stolen cars or use technology? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
My submission:
Eric Jorgenson đ âď¸
@EricJorgenson
Capitalism needs a logo.
It's a huge miss that Communism has the Hammer & Sickle (which actually goes hard) and Capitalism has nothing.
Let's do better branding for Capitalism! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Michael Grossman was right.
Chris Blattman
@cblatts
One of the things no one tells you about being 50 and continuing to play sports is the sheer amount of time you have to spend doing physical therapy in order to be able to play those sports, avoid injury, and recover from injuries.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I think this is the Trump administration saying we need a VAT right @wwwojtekk ?
Peter Navarro
@RealPNavarro
As if that weren't enough, take the EU's Value Added Tax (VAT). It hits American cars with a hidden 19% tax at the border.
Meanwhile, Europe's exporters don't pay any VAT to the United States.
Result? Mercedes and BMW flood our markets with their cars - while American cars are priced out of Europe. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
OMFG, I need to read this paper. My freshman year I was called Needles because I always had a bandage on my arm from donating plasma twice a week (as much as I could). Made about $1200 that year.
mzapryanova.github.io/web/Kang_McConnell_Zapryanova_plasm⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
NBER
@nberpubs
How parental divorce shapes children's resources and futures, from @acjohnston0, Maggie R. Jones, and Nolan G. Pope www.nber.org/papers/w33776
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Please join me in congratulating @q_econ. You can now call him Dr. Q.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Echos of Jesse going to a narcotics anonymous meeting to sell meth to addicts....Transitional housing admins were using their day job to sell fentanyl.
www.kezi.com/news/two-arrested-on-drug-dealing-charges-af⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
The president created a financial instrument that has no purpose other than corruption, and that's just how we roll now.
Spencer Hakimian
@SpencerHakimian
A tiny Chinese company owned by same people that own TikTok just bought $300,000,000 of $TRUMP Coin.
Now why do you think they did that?
đ§đ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So I think I know what I am....
Jason Abaluck
@Jabaluck
There are three types of social scientists:
Pornographers, plumbers, and social justice warriors
đ§ľ -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
I would rather the students use AI than Chegg or Course hero. But I plan to encourage them to think of Ai as a useful search/aggregator instead of a reasoning model.
Alex Imas
@alexolegimas
Iâm having a lot of conversations and posts of faculty complaining of students using AI on take home assessments.
Here is the reality: you should only have take home assessments if youâre comfortable with at least 40% being fully AI generated. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is there a downside to letting students with a high first year gpa skip the fore exams? Doesn't the high GPA show mastery as well as a single test?
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who has to take the first year exams (core, prelims, etc) in your economics PhD program?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Supply side matters.
Niskanen Center
@NiskanenCenter
What's really heartbreaking is the med students who complete school but then don't get matched to a residency.
In 2024, 44,853 applicants,competed for just 38,494 first-year residency slots -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Who has to take the first year exams (core, prelims, etc) in your economics PhD program?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Niskanen Center
@NiskanenCenter
Back in the '80s, policymakers were worried about a physician surplus.
So they created an artificial physician shortage, which has left Americans with a really expensive system that doesn't give them the care that they need.
Scarcity is bad policy. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Estoy practicando espanol todos los dias antes de nuestro viaje a Espana en Junio @Erdal_Tekin_.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Every econ referee report should include two scores out of 100: (1) Accuracy; (2) Importance.
These scores should be public and should follow the papers.
This would have all kinds of benefits:
1. It would reduce the incentive to submit to all 5 top five journals
đ§ľ 1/n -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We all get rejected in academic publishing. Part of the job. There's only 1 for me that still really hurts. A desk rejection that's a complete form letter with 0 edits, not even 1 sentence to say they actually read your paper. Feels like you mean nothing to the profession.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Good news!
Ideas are NOT getting harder to find. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Just saw my home insurance plan is scheduled to jump from $1k a year to $3k if I auto renew in June. Time to switch companies again. Anybody else seeing similar changes?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Really interesting discussion here. Becker, Godfather of crime, loves fines. Our models love fines instead of other punishments/sanctions whereever possible. But what are their real world long run impacts?
DartmouthEcon
@DartmouthEcon
Prof. Steve Mello on "Fines and Financial Wellbeing.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We're going back to oral exams. Cheating is changing. Students used to not use smart phones very often. That will change with AIs. Randomize your seats.
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Thereâs a massive disconnect between how AI is rapidly transforming the nature of learning, knowledge, and intelligence and the glacial pace of change at universities.
nymag.com/intelligencer/article/openai-chatgpt-ai-cheatin⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Scott Barber
@thescottbarber
BREAKING: President Trump orders reopening of Blockbuster Video. Claims it will reignite the US film industry.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
The Review of Economics and Statistics (REStat)
@restatjournal
Hot temperatures lead to increases in alleged and substantiated maltreatment of young children. Just Accepted new paper by Mary F. Evans (@mfranevans), Ludovica Gazze (@LudoGazze), and Jessamyn Schaller (@JessamynSchall1) direct.mit.edu/rest/article-abstract/doi/10.1162/rest_a_0âŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We traded this for higher GDP.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alberto Cavallo
@albertocavallo
Prices of imported goods at major U.S. retailers have continued to increase steadily since "Liberation Day".
Our updated tariff paper now covers 262K+ products with country-of-origin information â including 60K newly added â and features improved methods for identifying affected categories using Federal Register data.
Full paper: pricinglab-rw7gfm.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/tariffs/Trac⌠-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Andrew Bacher-Hicks
@abacherhicks
đ˘ Funding alert! We just dropped our latest call for proposals using rigorous causal methods to improve social policy.
Send us your 3-page letters of interest by June 13!
Arnold Ventures
@Arnold_Ventures
Need funding for an RCT or QED? Check out our Evidence & Evaluation teamâs 'Strengthening Evidence' and âBuilding Evidenceâ #rfp!
đď¸ Letters of interest (LOIs) are due by Friday, June 13
Details and deadline info here: www.arnoldventures.org/stories/a-second-round-of-requests⌠-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
In this case more conservative means moderate or neo liberal?
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Studying economics and business in college makes students become much more conservative.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The optimal amount of retail theft is not zero.
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Pharmacy chains like CVS are putting national-brand products behind plexiglass and are leaving the cheaper CVS-branded versions out in the open, right next to them.
Is this just a shrinkage deterrent or a clever nudge to boost high-margin house brands? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Pharmacy chains like CVS are putting national-brand products behind plexiglass and are leaving the cheaper CVS-branded versions out in the open, right next to them.
Is this just a shrinkage deterrent or a clever nudge to boost high-margin house brands? -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
I'm not blaming anyone. I am sure I contribute to the problem. But still it makes me sad. The tweet that really moved me was the one on the right.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
My daughter is going to college in the fall. Should I buy her a laptop now????
John Horton
@johnjhorton
Has your household made any anticipatory durable good purchases to avoid future tariffs?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Death, retirement and graduate students leaving.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Academics: How does your department/school assign faculty office space? Lottery? Seniority? Some other way?
And if your department/school were starting from scratch, what assignment mechanism would you most prefer to assign office space?
(I'm on the ad hoc committee on space this year. It's every bit as cool as it sounds.) -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
We all lose.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
It seems like one of the biggest social gains from autonomous vehicles is the decrease in traffic from being able to have semi trucks run all night long. Could you remove semis from daytime roads entirely? Congestion and accidents would decrease massively.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
The Criminal Justice team at @Arnold_Ventures is hiring two 2-year Fellows to focus on specific pieces of our work that we're super excited about. More info below. Please share!
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Is your department doing something to increase case solve rates that you think others should learn from? Weâd love to hear about it!
Cc: @mkrupanski
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Clearance rates are a direct reflection of resources deployed. That's why high profile cases usually end in an arrest. There's way too little focus on how to improve clearance rates on all cases.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is MAGA defined by fitness?
Paul Novosad
@paulnovosad
Being fit is MAGA.
NYT still doing its utmost to keep progressives unpopular. -
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
We're hiring, part 2!
The Criminal Justice and Evidence + Evaluation teams at @Arnold_Ventures are actively working to embed data access and quasi-experiments into legislation we support, to ensure that we all learn about policies' impact as they are implemented at the state and federal levels. We're looking for someone to work with both teams, as the point person on these efforts.
This would be a 2-year fellowship, based in any of AV's offices (Houston, DC, or NYC - not remote).
The ideal candidate has a passion for evidence-based policy, and experience working in/with state or federal legislatures. (The job will involve collaborating with our teams & grantees to identify opportunities in pending legislation, drafting legislative text, and responding quickly as needed to keep relevant bills moving forward.)
Salary: $145-200k
Please RT! -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So is Internet regulation impossible due to wack a mole displacement effects and we should just do more general Internet taxes instead?
Florian Ederer
@florianederer
Pornhub's removal of all non-verified content led to a 41% drop in traffic within 1 month.
Much of the displaced traffic was absorbed by competing platforms, including less regulated fringe websites (+55% visits) and mainstream competitors (+10%). -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Is it possible for Michael B Jordan to get both best actor and best supporting actor for his roles in Sinners?
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Winning so many of the Bates Clarks medals must be taxing on the field of public finance.
Owen Zidar
@omzidar
Nearly one third of recent John bates clark medalists have been in public finance!
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Alex Tabarrok
@ATabarrok
Wall Street is rallying on any hint of competency and sense in Washington and then is being rug pulled, again and again and again.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Theres been the phrase go woke go broke when a marketing tactic fails. I wonder if Elon went maga and lost his swaga. Like did he think he had environmentalists locked in and going maga would sell cybertrucks and expand his base? And instead he lost his core audience.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
If you're not getting rejecting you're not aiming high enough.
Michael Weintraub
@miweintraub83
Just had a paper rejected! Posting this as part of my never-ending quest to normalize failure.
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jonathan Zhang
@jzhangecon
We measure âeffectivenessâ of primary care providers in the @VAResearch along two dimensions: mental and physical health adverse events. We find the two are strongly correlated across providers and that more effective PCPs use less resources.
The Review of Economics and Statistics (REStat)
@restatjournal
Measuring effectiveness (value add) of primary care providers and find more effective PCPs use less resources. In the March issue, by Janet Currie (@PrincetonCHW) and Jonathan Zhang (@jzhangecon) direct.mit.edu/rest/article-abstract/doi/10.1162/rest_a_0âŚ
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jonah Goldberg
@JonahDispatch
Paul Graham
@paulg
Now that America has shifted from left to right, we can see who was genuinely independent-minded, and who was merely on the right. Who has spoken out against both wokeness and authoritarianism?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Statistical Horizons
@StatHorizons
Data analysts: looking to improve your research/coding workflow & simplify research collaboration using git? Join
Version Control for Data Analysis Using #github w/ @AaronGullickson April 24-25. Learn basic #git workflow, collaborating with others, and dealing w/ complications. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Finally?
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
Neoliberalism is back
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
First - this is more my area of expertise - it is frankly pretty extreme to claim that theoretical arguments can do anything convincing on this issue. The theoretical channels for government investment to be complementary to private investment are so ample that any argument to the contrary could not possibly stand on its own. More on that at the end.
The well-identified empirical evidence lines up against Bryan's view pretty decisively.
The strongest quasiâexperimental studies all show that public R&D dollars crowd in private effort.
Regressionâdiscontinuity at NIH paylines finds a US$10 m grant shock yields about three extra corporate patents with no loss of business R&D [1]. Shiftâshare instruments linking postâ9/11 defense budgets to industry exposure show every public dollar induces 40â60 cents of additional private R&D and raises totalâfactor productivity [2]. Eventâstudy evidence from sudden universityâlevel cuts reverses these gains: publications fall 15 % and VCâbacked startâups 30 % [3]. A richer SR&ED tax credit for Canadian SMEs boosts their R&D by 17 % and spills over into patent citations [4]. Scientistâlevel NIH lotteries confirm grants lift later publications and citations by roughly a quarter [5]. Across designs and contexts, the sign is always positive and the magnitudes largeâdirectly contradicting claims of systematic crowdâout.
What's wrong with your evidence? Kealeyâtype papers err in both identification and theory. Their headline correlations use aggregate timeâseries where governments boost subsidies precisely when private investment slumps, creating spurious negative signs [6,7]. Damrich, Kealey & Ricketts merely embed those raw aggregates in a stylised contributionâgood model that assumes knowledge is fully appropriable and ignores spillovers, so any public share mechanically lowers measured productivity [8]. Once exogenous variation is isolatedâas in the five studies aboveâthe relationship flips, and the omitted spillovers emerge as large and positive. Descriptive regressions that confound cause and effect cannot overturn the causal evidence that wellâdesigned public funding unlocks socially valuable, privately underâsupplied innovation.
There are SO MANY ways of understanding theoretically why the facts would be like this. Romerâs endogenousâgrowth framework treats ideas as nonârival but only partially excludable, so inventors capture just a slice of their social surplus [10], while AghionâHowittâs creativeâdestruction model adds businessâstealing, further depressing private incentives [11]. JonesâWilliams calibrate spillovers, duplication and congestion and still find laissezâfaire R&D at barely a third of the optimum [12]. GrossmanâHelpmanâs qualityâladder model layers crossâsectoral inputâoutput spillovers, another benefit absent from Caplanâs crowdâout narrative [13]. Liang & Mu show that when research lines are complements, decentralized scientists cluster on topics that leave highâreturn yet neglected areas that only public funding can unlock [14].
[1] @pierre_azoulay , Graff Zivin, J., Li, D. & Sampat, B. (2019) âPublic R&D and Private Patenting: Evidence from NIH Fundingâ, Review of Economic Studies 86(1): 117â152.|
[2] Moretti, E., Steinwender, C. & Van Reenen, J. (2024) âThe Economic Spillovers of Defence Researchâ, Review of Economics & Statistics 106(2): 235â256.
[3] Babina, T., He, J., Howell, S. et al. (2023) âCutting the Innovation Engineâ, Quarterly Journal of Economics 138(4): 2201â2260.
[4] Agrawal, A., Rosell, C. & Simcoe, T. (2020) âTax Credits and SmallâFirm R&D: Evidence from Canadaâ, American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 12(3): 1â30.
[5] Jacob, B. & Lefgren, L. (2011) âThe Impact of Research Funding on Scientific Outputâ, Journal of Public Economics 95(9â10): 1168â1177.
[6] Kealey, T. (1996) The Economic Laws of Scientific Research. Springer.
[7] Kealey, T. & Ricketts, M. (2014) âModelling Science as a Contribution Goodâ, Research Policy 43(6): 1014â1024.
[8] Damrich, S., Kealey, T. & Ricketts, M. (2022) âCrowding In and Crowding Out within a ContributionâGood Model of Researchâ, Research Policy 51(1): 104400.
[10] Romer, P. M. (1990) âEndogenous Technological Changeâ, Journal of Political Economy 98(5): S71âS102.
[11] Aghion, P. & Howitt, P. (1992) âA Model of Growth through Creative Destructionâ, Econometrica 60(2): 323â351.
[12] Jones, C. I. & Williams, J. C. (1998) âMeasuring the Social Return to R&Dâ, Quarterly Journal of Economics 113(4): 1119â1135.
[13] Grossman, G. M. & Helpman, E. (1991) âQuality Ladders in the Theory of Growthâ, Journal of Political Economy 99(3): 433â449.
[14] [9] Liang, J. & Mu, X. (2020) âComplementary Information and Learning Trapsâ, Quarterly Journal of Economics 135(4): 1929â1984. -
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
Congestion creates externalities which makes moving and trading hard and should be taxed. Trade resulting from comparative advantage should not be taxed.
Zephyr Teachout
@ZephyrTeachout
Can someone explain how you can be in favor of congestion pricing and opposed to tariffs on principle?
-
Benjamin Hansen reposted
Jennifer Doleac
@jenniferdoleac
Thereâs more evidence every day that increasing access to mental health care reduces criminal behavior. But would *mandating* such treatment be effective? Many think not. Rachel Nesbit studied what happens when judges mandate treatment as part of probation requirements. And she found big benefits! (This is in a context where most probation requirements do not improve public safety - so itâs big news.) Check out our conversation to learn more.
Probable Causation
@ProbCausation
Episode 114: Rachel Nesbit on mandating mental health treatment for probationers.
www.probablecausation.com/podcasts/episode-114-rachel-nesbit -
Mark Thoma
@MarkThoma
I live in San Diego now. I just went through a difficult time and the Mexican families who live around me have invited me to their homes, fed me some incredibly good food, and showed genuine kindness and concern. Iâm wondering, shouldnât they also be a part of the ...
Mark Thoma
@MarkThoma
national conversation we are having? Or am I missing something? Where I grew up, the police did not treat this community fairly. They too were afraid of police. But if you just take a moment to smile and say hello you might be surprised.
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
The policing disparities in the hit-rate literature for vehicle searches are typically the lowest (by far) for Hispanic drivers, suggesting they get oversearched the most...by far.
-
Benjamin Hansen
@benconomics
So who's going to write "Sometimes harmful data science"?




































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































