Statistics / social science folks:
When authors of an observational study claim they "controlled for" various confounding factors, how much should I trust that they actually successfully did?
Never? Only sometimes? (If so, when? Do you have heuristics you use?)
Julia Galef
Julia Galef (; born July 4, 1983) is an American writer, speaker and co-founder of the Center for Applied Rationality. From 2010 to 2021, she hosted Rationally Speaking, the official podcast of New York City Skeptics, sharing the show with co-host and philosopher Massimo Pigliucci and produced by Benny Pollak until 2015. More on Wikipedia
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
-
Julia Galef reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Five Lessons from @juliagalef 's ‘The Scout Mindset." (Julia was a guest on the most recent episode of my BBC podcast series "Think with Pinker" www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0011lt1) quillette.com/2022/02/04/five-lessons-from-julia-galefs-t…
-
Julia Galef reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
The evidence strongly suggests that pre-K is just day care.
noahpinion.substack.com/p/pre-k-is-day-care -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
People tend to have a simple rule (e.g. "cancel culture = bad," or "race in hiring = bad") and get reflexively angry at anything that pattern-matches to that
So I really appreciate the rare people who reflect on the specifics of each case to decide if it's actually bad 👇
Coleman Hughes
@coldxman
1/ I'm not angry about Biden basing his supreme court decision on race & gender. And I've put my finger on why.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I had an interesting disagreement yesterday that seemed to come down to what counts as "genetic determinism" (click through for thread)
I'm still confused though... (cont.)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
i.e., are you saying that only *neurological* explanations (for the relationship between genes and EA ) constitute genetic determinism?
Maybe that's the piece of your model I was missing
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
People who talk about genetics, like @kph3k, are often criticized for promoting "genetic determinism," but what is that?
The APA definition is below. But a lot hinges on what you mean by behavior being "controlled by" genes...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What people like @kph3k say is our genes affect various aspects of how our brains work, and then interactions between (1) how our brains work, + (2) parents/society/school, cause differences in e.g. educational attainment
Does this count as genes "controlling" our outcomes?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Seems like "yes" in the weak sense (genes are an input into our outcomes), but "no" in the strong deterministic sense (genes aren't the only thing that matters -- it's an interaction between genes + our environment that determines our outcomes)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Thing is, the scientists who accuse @kph3k of "genetic determinism" don't seem to be disagreeing with her that genes + environment interact to determine our life outcomes.
So when they accuse her of "genetic determinism," what is the actual disagreement there?
So confused -
Julia Galef reposted
Dan Luu
@danluu
Workarounds people use to overcome "technical" limitations intended to prevent name changes:
www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/sbmbvy/oc_tryin… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Yes, the media & scientific establishment often misrepresent things
But "...therefore we can't trust ANYTHING they say" is the wrong conclusion
So what's the right conclusion?
It's tricky, but @slatestarcodex has a characteristically great take: astralcodexten.substack.com/p/bounded-distrustPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2) The Lancet letter made an argument of the form, "There is NO reason to believe X!"
... whereas the global warming petition made an argument of the form "There IS reason to believe X!"
I think scientists are more willing to mislead in the former way than the latter way
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Of course, these are subtle subjective distinctions I'm making and someone else could disagree about how much they matter. Thinking through this example just highlighted how tricky it is to figure out where your boundaries of distrust should be.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Maybe @Graham_Coop or @molly_przew could explain why you felt the book was "nudging the reader towards genetic determinism"?
Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
i.e., are you saying that only *neurological* explanations (for the relationship between genes and EA ) constitute genetic determinism?
Maybe that's the piece of your model I was missing -
Julia Galef reposted
Stuart Ritchie
@StuartJRitchie
Thread! Everyone's talking about this new study showing cash transfers "speed up brain activity" in babies (www.pnas.org/content/pnas/119/5/e2115649119.full.pdf).
It must be a big deal, because it was announced with a "Breaking News" tweet by no less than the New York Times:
The New York Times
@nytimes
Breaking News: Cash payments for low-income mothers increased brain function in babies, a study found, with potential implications for U.S. safety net policy. www.nytimes.com/2022/01/24/us/politics/child-tax-credit-b…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The movie "Monsters University" sounds like a refreshing exception of a kids' movie, in that it
- Rejects the common trope of "You should never give up on irrational dreams!"
- Is still heartwarming and inspiring
blog.plover.com/movie/self-esteem.html -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I feel really grateful for people who take the trouble to provide what I think of as “services to the epistemic commons,” contributions that make our collective maps more accurate
A thread of some examples:Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2. People who collect and summarize important data
Example: @OurWorldInData's pages on child mortality, energy use, depression, etc. across countries and over time ourworldindata.org
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3. People who summarize the scientific evidence on a topic
Example: @slatestarcodex reads & evaluates all the studies on ivermectin astralcodexten.substack.com/p/ivermectin-much-more-than-y…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
4. People who fact check popular books
Example: @alexeyguzey pointing out serious errors in “Why We Sleep” guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
5. People who fact check popular beliefs
Example: @acesounderglass investigating whether it’s true that eating dirt boosts kids’ immune systems: acesounderglass.com/2021/09/30/eating-dirt-benefits-kids-… -
Julia Galef reposted
Timothy B. Lee
@binarybits
A bunch of responses saying that people don't have kids because it's too expensive. Which sounds plausible until you remember that both families and countries with lower incomes tend to have more kids.
Timothy B. Lee
@binarybits
One of the worst aspects of current politics is the bipartisan consensus that America kind of sucks. On the left you have the relentless negativity of woke politics. On the right you have the relentless negativity of Trumpism.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So that famous 2011 "judges give harsher sentences right before lunchtime" paper was heavily criticized
In response to criticism, the authors defended their paper: www.pnas.org/content/108/42/E834
Has anyone discussed the authors' defense? I can't find anything. Does it have any merit?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Maybe @lakens, @jonatanpallesen, @uri_sohn, or @jasonacollins happen to know
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Lol @ "I always consume psychology research well salted"
David R. MacIver
@DRMacIver
Well, the hungry judges one among others! I didn't check too carefully because I always consume psychology research well salted, but the things I remember going "Hmm" about other than the judges were a bunch of survey-based happiness studies and some of Haidt's work.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This paper supports the YIMBY argument of "moving chains," in which new luxury housing indirectly benefits poorer people (because it frees up cheaper housing, as rich people move out of older buildings and into the new ones)...
ideas.repec.org/p/fer/wpaper/146.html
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
That's been studied before, but what makes this paper unusual is how fine-grained it is
They have data on who lives in each building (in Helsinki) and where each tenant moves to -- so we can actually see the moving chains! Rather than just inferring them from aggregate data
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The analogy that occurred to me while reading:
It's like doing neuroscience using a connectome, a map of the connections between actual neurons, rather than using fMRIs -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A cool list compiled by @arbesman, of research organizations that don't fit neatly into the conventional categories:
arbesman.net/overedge/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I applaud the trend of people talking publicly about their desire for a relationship, and what they're looking for, specifically
And I highly recommend Chris Olah -- he's not only brilliant but a lovely person:
Chris Olah
@ch402
Five of my close friends will soon be parents. I feel very excited for them. I also feel a bit sad: I really want to have a family myself someday and it feels far away.
We don’t talk very much about men wanting to have children, so I thought a thread might be positive.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You might know Chris already as the co-creator of Google's DeepDream, and the terrifying fever-dream images it produced that haunted your timeline for several years
But I've forgiven him for that by now
www.wired.com/2015/12/inside-deep-dreams-how-google-made-… -
Julia Galef reposted
Spencer Greenberg 🔍
@SpencrGreenberg
I keep thinking about what it would be like if Trump considered the possibility that he's the bad guy in the story and if that thought gave him a panic attack
is one of the things the A.I. GPT-3 came up with when I attempted to get it to generate a tweet that would go viral -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I was happy to learn that some science funders have started to experiment with random lotteries -- this could save scientists a lot of time:
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-03572-7
I hope they're also testing whether the random process does a better/worse job than the traditional process!
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
As an aside, this article's attempt to show both sides of the issue made me laugh
ON ONE HAND: Studies showing the traditional grantmaking process is unreliable
ON THE OTHER HAND: A grantmaker who says he "likes to think" they do a good job -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I don't like this, personally, but I like that it exists! I wish more rich people built weird/fun houses
Like one I saw in Pittsburgh, where the guy put in
- secret passages
- an observatory
- a mural of illustrations from his favorite childhood books
He was clearly having fun
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And I agree with @Meaningness, mocking stuff like this is just a way to enforce overly-rigid, overly-boring standards of "good taste"
David Chapman
@Meaningness
I love this place. It is exuberant, unrestrained fun.
Mocking it for bad taste seems mean-spirited and narrow-minded to me. This critique is propaganda for the upper middle class value system (status through rigid taste norms) I reject that. x.com/rebeccamakkai/status/1482049099717386240 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You might expect me to applaud this neat little experiment showing motivated reasoning... but instead I'm ambivalent
The problem is that it's not a very clean experiment...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When someone makes a statement like the one above, people reasonably assume he's talking about a specific topical issue, and criticizing [the current president] for overreach on that issue
And it's quite possible for that implied criticism to be fair in one case & not in another
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A cleaner experiment would be a poll, like "Do you think it's fair for a president to ___?" ... and if the responses were different under Trump vs. Biden, I'd consider that more compelling evidence of motivated reasoning
-
Julia Galef reposted
Chana
@ChanaMessinger
I hate hate hate the way that we've just abandoned the idea that alarms are for reacting to. There are weekly fire alarm tests at my school, monthly fire drills at my last, and zero reaction to an alarm that just went off in an airport.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I sometimes see people argue that we shouldn't criticize entrepreneurs’ plans, lest we disincentivize entrepreneurship
I agree entrepreneurship has big positive externalities and we should incentivize it
But the solution *can’t* be “Never criticize entrepreneurs”...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What a terribly distorted information ecosystem that would create!
Instead IMO the right policy is that people should feel free to honestly say “I don’t expect X idea to work," but without the common added implication "...and you're an idiot for trying X" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I was wondering the same thing as @kdrum: Why does the CDC warn Americans to avoid Canada due to the risk of catching COVID there -- when the risk is actually *lower* in Canada than in the US?
I have a possible answer I didn't see mentioned, though...
jabberwocking.com/travel-restrictions-are-crazy-now-that-…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Maybe their assumption is that an American tourist in another country is probably going to be doing more high-risk things (restaurants, crowds, etc.) than they would have done at home?
Idk, maybe I'm being too charitable to the CDC here, but this seems plausible at least -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This measure of "denial" in a widely-cited psychology paper raised my eyebrows...
You're classified as engaging in denial if you agree with the statement, "The earth has plenty of natural resources if we just learn how to develop them"
journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167209351435
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I guess the researchers don't consider it reasonable for someone to think that, as we innovate, we'll get better at using our resources efficiently?
I mean, you can argue against that view, I guess, but to treat it as so obviously wrong that it constitutes "denial" is weird
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And yeah, the other measures of denial aren't much better. They're all vague enough that it's easy to see how a reasonable person could agree with them (even if you disagree)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love looking at this guy's colorful homemade pasta
Though I wonder what it looks like after boiling? I once bought crimson red fettuccine to make my boyfriend a romantic Valentine's dinner and discovered that once boiled, it was just a wan orange
www.instagram.com/david_rivillo/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I've seen this claim in a bunch of places -- that Norway's prisons work better than ours, because their recidivism rate is only 20% compared to our 76.6% recidivism
I looked into it and... it's not accuratePost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When you compare apples to apples, it looks like the equivalent number in the US (the closest measure to Norway's "re-sentenced within 2 years") is either 36.3% or 28.8%
Which is still higher than Norway's 20%, but much less dramatically so
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And of course there are other factors that can make these stats hard to compare, as well
e.g. the author of the Norway study noted that their 20% recidivism is partly due to Norway's unusual choice to incarcerate people for speeding:
(From nytimes.com/2015/03/29/magazine/the-radical-humaneness-of…) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
An exception: @mattyglesias' excellent Slow Boring, which I did take the trouble to opt back into
www.slowboring.com
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Probably the most financially responsible thing I do is misplace my credit card every year or two
Because after I get a new card, all the subscriptions I forgot I signed up for have to ask me to opt back in (which I often do not) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Probably the most financially responsible thing I do is misplace my credit card every year or two
Because after I get a new card, all the subscriptions I forgot I signed up for have to ask me to opt back in (which I often do not) -
Julia Galef reposted
Amanda Askell
@AmandaAskell
“Value of information!” is what I usually say before doing something reckless.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A lot of people dislike the idea of helping the poor by just giving them cash -- but it's usually the best way.
On my new Rationally Speaking episode @MichaelLFaye of @GiveDirectly makes the case for cash transfers. Audio + transcript: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/263-is-cash-the-best-way-to…
A quote I like: -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
On my new podcast episode, I talk to the brilliant philosopher Toby Ord about all the ways humanity could wreck our future, why he came to take this issue more seriously, and which existential risks are overrated vs. underrated
Audio + full transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/262-humanity-on-the-precipi… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is happening in an hour! I'll be chatting with @kylesebvitale from Heterodox Academy about reasoning and truth-seeking, and there'll be plenty of time for audience Q&A
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
Tomorrow, 7 pm ET! 📣
Join us for a conversation with @JuliaGalef, author of the Scout Mindset, as we discuss the ways our brains are wired for tribalism and confirmation bias—and the habits we can form to overcome these tendencies and see the world more clearly 👇 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I often see people cite that first paper ("people would rather endure electric shocks than be alone with their thoughts")
But IMO it's yet another example of a sensational conclusion that's not supported by the actual data in the study...
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
I am haunted by two papers on how much we hate hard thinking:
⚡️2/3 of men & 1/4 of women choose to shock themselves rather than sit & think for 6-15 minutes
🔥28% of people chose pain they rated as "extremely intense" for 20 seconds over spending 20 seconds solving a hard puzzlePost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So we have a group of people, reporting that they somewhat enjoyed being alone with their thoughts, & some of them chose to self-administer a small shock out of curiosity
I wouldn't summarize that as "People would rather shock themselves than be alone with their thoughts"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's @ferrisjabr making these points in the New Yorker at the time:
www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/thinking-alone -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here’s a tricksy motte-and-bailey I keep noticing:
“Group X is so Y” [where Y is a bad trait]
The provocative implied meaning is "Group X is unusually Y, relative to other groups"
But if pressed, people can claim they only meant “Group X is more Y than it should be”
Example:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's another example.
(I know some people did actually defend the stronger interpretation here ("Silicon Valley is more sexist than other industries"), but I also heard people claim it only meant the weaker thing ("Silicon Valley is more sexist than it should be")) -
Julia Galef reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
Tomorrow, 7 pm ET! 📣
Join us for a conversation with @JuliaGalef, author of the Scout Mindset, as we discuss the ways our brains are wired for tribalism and confirmation bias—and the habits we can form to overcome these tendencies and see the world more clearly 👇 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I found @kesvelt's argument in my podcast compelling and disturbing.
Now I'm wondering if anyone is making the opposing case. If others are genuinely NOT worried about scientists telling the world how to engineer terrible pandemics, I want to hear why not.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
New Rationally Speaking episode!
Pandemic prediction research is supposed to make us safer, but is actually giving thousands of people access to weapons of mass destruction.
MIT scientist @kesvelt makes the case:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/261-dangerous-biological-re…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Kevin explains why pandemic prediction research isn't worth it, EVEN IF it could help us avoid natural pandemics:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My dad has taken some photos lately that remind me so much of particular painters / schools of painting. Some examples:
1) Edward Hopper (this is a house in our neighborhood, in early morning light)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2) Maxfield Parrish (the sky on our street, at sunset)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3) The Hudson River School
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hudson_River_School
(Dad took this on a walk in Rock Creek Park, near DC) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's something I wish existed... For each scientific field, a ELI5-style summary of the
- most important progress made in the last 50 years
- biggest open questions people are working on
- typical methodology used (e.g. case studies, surveys, looking for correlations in data)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm also very interested in the epistemic status of each field. (The methodology question is a way of getting at this.)
Like, how much can I trust a random paper in field X? How much can I trust a consensus in field X? etc. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
There's a rare kind of paper I love, which makes an important contribution to a field not with new evidence, but with *clever reasoning*
Basically saying "You guys, we've been thinking about this all wrong"
Two examples that come to mind:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1) "Could a neuroscientist understand a microprocessor?"
The authors perform a reductio ad absurdum on common methods of understanding the brain, by applying them to a microprocessor and showing that they fail
journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?id=10.1371/journal…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2) "Dissolving the Fermi paradox"
Shows that Fermi paradox ("Why haven't we encountered aliens yet?") kinda goes away when you properly incorporate uncertainty into your model, which people hadn't been doing
arxiv.org/abs/1806.02404 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Love to see truth winning out over social rules / status hierarchies.
Thread:
Michael Nielsen
@michael_nielsen
Fascinating to see King Charles explicitly grant the Royal Society (in 1660) liberty to discuss pretty much whatever they want, with whoever they want, "without molestation, interruption, or disturbance whatsoever", in the first charter of the Royal Society:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
New Rationally Speaking episode!
Pandemic prediction research is supposed to make us safer, but is actually giving thousands of people access to weapons of mass destruction.
MIT scientist @kesvelt makes the case:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/261-dangerous-biological-re…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
We also talk about Kevin's own research, which is about using CRISPR to edit the genomes of wild animal species (e.g. altering mosquito populations so they don't spread malaria).
Do the benefits justify the risks?
Kevin argues yes, and I found his logic pretty compelling -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This little street in Pittsburgh (Roslyn Place) is paved with wooden blocks -- one of only a few remaining examples left in the United States
-
Julia Galef reposted
Amanda Askell
@AmandaAskell
Doctor: Avoid a diet containing X and see if your symptoms improve.
Me: Wouldn’t it be better if I spent 2 weeks avoiding X and 2 weeks consuming lots of X and monitored my symptoms?
Doctor:…
Me: Actually, let me see if I can get a friend to spike my food with X. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you were interested in reading my book, THE SCOUT MINDSET, but didn't want to spend much money, good news -- the UK Kindle edition is on sale this month for only 99p:
www.amazon.co.uk/Scout-Mindset-People-Things-Clearly-eboo… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Examples from @danluu where the psychology research doesn't say what people think it says, such as:
- Dunning Kruger
- "Money doesn't make you happy, above X amount"
- "People's happiness bounces back to a set point after positive and negative events"
danluu.com/dunning-kruger -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Walking with my mom, admiring an old house:
ME: Wow, that house is so beautiful, I wonder when it was built. Probably like 100 years ago
MOM: No way, I don't think it's that old, it's probably from 1920 or so
ME: ...Mom
MOM: Oh god -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you have a potentially high-impact idea for making the world better, consider filling out a quick (~15 minute) application for a grant from @slatestarcodex:
astralcodexten.substack.com/p/apply-for-an-acx-grant
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some examples of the kind of thing he's looking for:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you find a vulnerability in a Dutch government computer system, they send you this T-shirt:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm biased of course, but this is my all-time favorite wedding centerpiece idea (from my brother @JesseGalef & @donovanable):
Instead of flowers, each table had a little bookshelf of books that are special to the bride & groom, with bookmarks explaining why they picked each one
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
That's a lazy Susan the books are sitting on, so anyone could spin it around and read the titles
The book centerpieces doubled as conversation-starters -- encouraging people to visit other tables and see the other picks -- as well as wedding favors -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you don't enjoy scrolling through a food blogger's entire life history before you get to the actual recipe, you'll appreciate this:
www.justtherecipe.com -
Julia Galef reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
~@juliagalef "outlines how best to understand the world as it is, rather than how we wish it to be, and argues that this allows us to achieve our goals and dreams more fully" writes @razibkhan for @Quillette
quillette.com/2021/11/10/the-scout-mindset-a-review/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love this turn of phrase from @curiouswavefn, describing his friend, the late Freeman Dyson:
"the guy who always had his hand raised in a room full of nodding heads"
wavefunction.fieldofscience.com/2020/02/freeman-dyson-192… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A timeline of technologies described in science fiction through the years:
www.technovelgy.com/ct/ctnlistPubDate.asp
I like this description of a speed cam, from 1894 (!) -
Julia Galef reposted
Agnes Callard
@AgnesCallard
Enjoying Wittgenstein’s refusal to believe all the hype about Shakespeare
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I finally read @ezraklein's book "Why We're Polarized," and really enjoyed it!
Ezra came on my podcast to discuss his model of how Republicans & Democrats became so ideologically & demographically different over the years
Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/260-why-were-polarized-ezra…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One useful takeaway for me was just teasing apart a bunch of related phenomena so we can think more clearly
1. Opinion polarization: People becoming more strongly PRO or CON on an issue
2. Sorting: The PRO people going to one party, the CON people going to another party
...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3. Sorting by identity: People of one race / education level / gender / etc going disproportionately to one party over the other
4. Affective polarization: People in one party hating or fearing the other party
5. Partisanship: People reflexively agreeing with their own party
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
As Ezra recognizes, the conversation around "polarization" gets really muddied because people use that word to refer to any / all of these things. But they each have different effects, and not all are inherently bad
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Since my dad’s pumpkin art got a nice reception the other day, here's another of my favorites by him
One year someone requested a pumpkin about 20th century physics. Here’s the result, showing Schrödinger’s cat & Einstein’s famous quote “God does not play dice with the universe”
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Dad's hidden joke is that God's dice all have a single pip on every face. So even though God seems to be rolling the dice, the outcome is not actually left up to chance
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My dad's been carving pumpkins for 50 years! You can see some more examples (plus his painting and other artwork) on his website:
barrygalef.com -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Every Halloween for 50 years, my dad's carved a story into a pumpkin
This year it's the man-against-machine tale of John Henry, a steel-driver who raced against the newfangled steam drill. He won, but the strain killed him.
He "died with a hammer in his hand," as the song goes -
Julia Galef reposted
Ben Kuhn
@benkuhn
If you're like me, you probably see the title and think "oh yeah I'm totally willing to look stupid." You should read the post to realize how much stupider you could be willing to look
Dan Luu
@danluu
Willingness to look stupid
danluu.com/look-stupid/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My brother @JesseGalef's wedding vows involved an elaborate math joke about Taylor Series.
Miraculously, @donovanable still married him.
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
Kate and I got married!
My wedding vows involved using a mathematical Taylor Series to describe our relationship.
Reactions varied.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(That pic is basically the wedding equivalent of the famous Dad Joke photo)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
BTW, Jesse shares the joke in his thread, if you're a masochist
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hey philosophers, what metaethical view would this count as:
"Doing good" = increasing utility. But there are no rules about how MUCH good you're obliged to do.
(i.e., it's not utilitarianism, right? Because that word implies an obligation to do as much good as possible) -
Julia Galef reposted
Jeremy Horpedahl 🥚📉
@jmhorp
Amazon is on it: deadline.com/2021/06/amazon-movie-steal-away-malcolm-m-ma…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The classic fable of the scorpion and the frog, but fractured into many philosophically different variations
sadoeuphemist.tumblr.com/post/615521935528460288/a-scorpi… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It's crazy to me that @kph3k has been accused of being "no better than a Holocaust denier" for her work on genetics! I read her new book and thought it was great.
We discussed the book - and why it makes people angry - on the latest episode of my podcast:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/259-the-genetic-lottery-kat…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Paige's book: www.amazon.com/Genetic-Lottery-Matters-Social-Equality-eb…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of the interesting parts of the episode, IMO, is at the end when we're talking about a disagreement between Paige & her PhD mentor Eric Turkheimer, over whether it's "unscientific" to ask about genetic causes of differences in IQ between populations
Turkheimer (in Vox): -
Julia Galef reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
Three years ago, I quit my job in tech and became a journalist! It's worked out great. I think Future Perfect is genuinely doing something different from the rest of media - and something that the world needs more of.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting paper, but does it really support the "value of university = learning" story?
My guess would be: Reducing the coursework required for an econ degree -> different people choose to become econ majors -> those people are less desirable on job market
Thoughts @Noahpinion?
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Another paper that shows that value of university is not just a diploma, but also learning: An elite Colombian university suddenly lowered credits required by 20%, and students there for the change, with less education but the same high status degree, had 10-20% lower wages.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Whoa how did I miss that you can actually play the game from Community's "Digital Estate Planning" episode?? Some fans faithfully re-created it. It's very authentic!
projecthawkthorne.com
Here I am as Jeff in the study room about to fight a hippie -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(1/2) As you might've heard on my last podcast, I have a new sponsor: @GiveDirectly, which gives cash to extremely poor people: www.givedirectly.org
I really like them, and they're one of only a few charities endorsed by effective altruist org @GiveWell (my other sponsor).
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(2/2) One random thing I appreciate about @GiveDirectly (besides their mission!) is their page of recipient stories: live.givedirectly.org
Usually such stories are very cherry-picked, but these are not -- GD surveys a random sample of recipients & posts all responses, unedited
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You can donate at givedirectly.org/rationallyspeaking
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Happy 10th birthday to Stripe!! 🥳
I'm not the most unbiased source here but it really does strike me as a rare company at the intersection of (1) great work culture, (2) well-run, and (3) adding a lot of value to the world
Patrick Collison
@patrickc
Stripe launched 10 years ago today! Still jump out of the bed as enthusiastically as I did at the outset. (Actually somewhat more so -- wasn't really a morning person back then.)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My recent tweet mentioning Dragonlance sparked a big nostalgia-fest in the comments, so I thought you all might appreciate a funny anecdote about the books.
Thread:Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Jesse replied: "No, that was me! I'm sure of it!" and I insisted back "No, it was me!"
And then a nearby wedding guest piped up: "Hey, that happened to me! I read Tolkien and thought it was copying Dragonlance!"
And then ANOTHER nearby guest chimed in: "Wait, me too!"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... and that's how I learned that a whole generation of kids apparently read LoTR after Dragonlance and thought to themselves "Orcs? Dragons? Elves? Pfft, Tolkien is so unoriginal"
/end -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"Writing a book" was admittedly a very time-consuming, effortful way to achieve my #1 life goal: Being reviewed by @slatestarcodex. But hey, at least it worked!
astralcodexten.substack.com/p/book-review-the-scout-mindset -
Julia Galef reposted
Divia Eden 🔍
@diviacaroline
And my other assignment from vgr is 100 opinions on mainstream parenting, whether anyone likes this or not :-). I probably can’t do them all in one sitting, but I’ll start anyway.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
The case against ivermectin isn't that it's horse goo. The case against ivermectin is that we really don't have reason to think it works against Covid-19: www.vox.com/future-perfect/22663127/ivermectin-covid-trea…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
In my interview w/@JordanHarbinger he pushed back (refreshingly!) on the idea that you shouldn't feel bad about errors
jordanharbinger.com/536
Indeed, one can swing too far from "Being wrong ALWAYS means you screwed up" to "Being wrong NEVER means you screwed up"
Both are false
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My response to Jordan:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You can check out the rest of the interview, and transcript + links, here: jordanharbinger.com/536
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
If you're trying to make sense of the ivermectin evidence base, one thing I recommend is briefly researching a drug that works well against Covid, like dexamethasone.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kanjun 🐙
@kanjun
Does anyone know how people explained why cannons and guns had recoil before Newton's laws of motion?
I'm so curious about what kinds of (odd, I imagine) explanations were given! Like spontaneous generation and other explanations before Darwin. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Just thinking about how weird it is that the cultural messaging I absorbed as a kid was all, "Reading books is inherently Virtuous!"
... and that as a result I felt like I acquired a shiny halo for reading, like, freakin' Dragonlance -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I like essays that first dismantle the weak case for X, before making the strong case for X
This one by @jasoncrawford on why he changed his mind about technological stagnation is a great example:
rootsofprogress.org/technological-stagnation
(Lots more interesting posts at Roots of Progress, btw!) -
Julia Galef reposted
Mason
@webdevMason
Yesterday's @Rspodcast with @juliagalef & @KelseyTuoc on COVID-19 covered ivermectin, and included a pretty shocking final twist. Thread:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
An ongoing thread of elegant (physical) design solutions:
1) How to store your wedding/engagement ring safely on your person, when you need to take it off temporarily? This pendant: Take off the necklace, thread your ring onto the chain, put the necklace back onPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The shared bathrooms in the former Hotel Louis XIV.
Tied to each doorknob was a 3.5' leather thong with a hook. When you're in the bathroom you link the hooks together, holding both doors shut. No way to get back into your own room w/out unlocking the door for the other guest.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(pic + description of bathrooms from "By Design" by Ralph Caplan)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This "sorting by size" system:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Highly recommend listening to the insightful @kelseytuoc discuss how to reason about COVID and other hard things, on my podcast:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/258-how-to-reason-about-cov…
As a sample, here’s Kelsey’s characteristically nuanced response to my question, “Do you trust the FDA/CDC?” (and my reply) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Bryan argues that utilitarians should be pro-life, because the (+) utility of creating a new life generally outweighs the (-) utility of a person being forced to give birth
An interesting argument, but I disagree…
Bryan Caplan
@bryan_caplan
“While I’m not a utilitarian, the utilitarian case against abortion seems very strong.”
www.econlib.org/archives/2015/04/where_are_the_p.htmlPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So, suppose you're a pure utilitarian. Under utilitarianism, there’s nothing wrong with violating other people’s autonomy (e.g. by forcing them to have babies against their will), as long as the net result is still positive utility.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
But under other common moral theories, violating people’s autonomy *is* a bad thing
So IMO, it makes perfect sense for utilitarians to prioritize the many other ways of increasing utility that *don’t* violate people’s autonomy as much as forced birth does -
Julia Galef reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Degrowth is practically impossible, politically impossible, morally untenable, and environmentally unnecessary.
There are crusades worth fighting for. This isn't one of them.
noahpinion.substack.com/p/people-are-realizing-that-degrowth -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I've wondered about this
A related thing I was wondering today: Why are pupusas so popular in the US but tlacoyos are vanishingly rare? They're so similar! And tlacoyos are common street food in Mexico, just like pupusas are common in El Salvador
Zach Weinersmith
@ZachWeiner
Do you think there's anything objective about why some food cultures go worldwide, or does it have to do either more economic factors, like having a large diaspora or being culturally hegemonic.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Druthers Haver
@6thgrade4ever
the most consequential figures in the tech world are half guys like steve jobs and bill gates and half some guy named ronald who maintains a unix tool called 'runk' which stands for Ronald's Universal Number Kounter and handles all math for every machine on earth
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Don't try to persuade people your belief is true; instead, explain how you came to believe it (to whatever extent you do believe it):
www.lesswrong.com/posts/Psr9tnQFuEXiuqGcR/how-to-write-qu…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This post also has a great example of why it's important to describe your actual process of investigating some claim X
(and why that's relevant to the epistemic status of X) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My cousin Jimmy, when he was ~5 yrs old
JIMMY: "When I grow up I will be an omniologist."
PARENTS: "What’s that?"
JIMMY: "They study everything."
PARENTS: "Everything? That’s a lot of things! How are you going to study them all?"
JIMMY [unfazed]: "I will study them in groups." -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A testament to @albrgr: I saw he shared a study on the effect of affirmative action & I realized, "I don't have a confident prediction about the study's finding"
Usually when people share a study about [controversial topic] you can infer the study's finding from their worldview -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I liked @StuartJRitchie's take on the Ariely affair because he focused on a problem with social science that doesn't get enough attention, IMO: the often-shoddy record-keeping
unherd.com/2021/08/never-trust-a-scientist/Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm honestly kind of insulted that many researchers seem to expect us to just trust their finding without being able to see the details for ourselves
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: I should add that I think this problem is not as bad in recent papers as it is in, say, pre-2005 papers. (But people are still widely citing the pre-2005 papers today!)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm helping pick out readings for a wedding. Anyone have any favorite essays, poems, or other texts that talk about love in an intellectually honest* (but still romantic) way?
*e.g., no "one true soulmate" stuff
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This tribute Ann Druyan wrote to her husband Carl Sagan after he died is lovely, and kind of fits the spirit of what I'm looking for, except that it's a little sad for a wedding
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Another interesting point raised by a listener in response to my podcast on price gouging:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Saw a bunch of interesting points in response to my podcast on price gouging (in which I wondered whether price controls in emergencies might make poor people better off)
eg. this paper in Econometrica arguing for price controls under certain conditions: web.stanford.edu/~mohamwad/Inequality.pdf
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's a thread by one of the authors, @skominers:
Scott Kominers
@skominers
Great questions! Here's an attempt to answer both parts at once: price controls can also be used for redistribution on the buyer side, but they have a slightly different structure.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A good way to stay calm when people are being unreasonable to you online is just to ask yourself “Will it be obvious to most readers that this person is being unreasonable?” The answer is often “yes” and realizing that makes it easier to simply ignore the person
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Earlier this year I did a podcast with @mattyglesias in which he argued for boosting the US’s population to 1 billion (via immigration & increased birth rates). And that this was worth doing even though it would worsen climate change.
(LINK: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/251-the-case-for-one-billio…)Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I mean, it depends partly on your philosophical commitments (e.g. if you create 1 happy person who wouldn’t otherwise have existed, how good is that?). But it also depends on facts about the relationship between population & climate change impacts that seem very hard to estimate.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
… Idk, maybe someone actually could do a Fermi estimate on that. I’d certainly be interested to see it.
But at least, if you’re going to say Matt is wrong to believe that A > B, it’s not enough to simply argue that B is a big deal. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Does anyone know the story on why Whole Foods still doesn't carry @ImpossibleFoods beef? You'd think their customers would be the perfect demographic for it, right? And it's been available in other big chains (Safeway, Giant, etc.) for a long time now.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My dad suggests that Beyond Meat has Kompromat on John Mackey
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
PSA: If your nonprofit is focused on humanity's long-term future, you should apply for a grant from the Survival & Flourishing Fund (backed by Jaan Tallinn & Jed McCaleb):
survivalandflourishing.fund/sff-2021-h2-announcement
They’re giving out $8-12 million this round (but the deadline is Monday!) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A little story about finding common ground in unexpected ways:
Last month @lukeprog and I were in central PA and ended up hanging out with an Amish couple (we had watched a documentary on them which piqued our curiosity, so we reached out to ask if they'd be up for chatting)Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
ME: "Yeah! People so often try to pretend all views are equally valid. Which is, like, a pretty thought. But not realistic."
AMISH GUY: "I know! It frustrates me when people say everyone can be right. Everyone can't be right if they disagree."
ME: "I totally agree!"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... It was the most simpatico moment of our visit.
I just found it so amusing, & kind of lovely, that even though we disagreed *completely* about the object level question, we still bonded over our enthusiastic agreement on the meta point that at least one of us had to be wrong -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You know those op-eds that economists write during emergencies (like COVID), saying: “Price gouging is actually good, because it prevents shortages” ?
They’ve always kinda bugged me so I did a podcast about why
Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/257-price-gouging-in-emerge… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What do you all think of the new podcast website?
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org
... I am a grouchy minimalist when it comes to website design (basically I wish all websites looked like this motherfuckingwebsite.com) so that's what I went with -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Want to be a good "data detective"? On the latest episode of Rationally Speaking, I interview economist & author @TimHarford about his guidelines for how to evaluate statistical claims you read or hear: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/256-how-to-be-a-data-detect…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Tim's book, The Data Detective: Ten Easy Rules To Make Sense of Statistics
timharford.com/books/datadetective/ -
Julia Galef reposted
Rutger Bregman
@rutgerbregman
Just finished this one by @juliagalef. Highly recommended. It's not easy to become (more of) a scout, but it's hard not to be inspired by this book.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You've heard of @PTetlock's hedgehogs (who use one lens to analyze everything) and foxes (who use many lenses).
But @ChanaMessinger breaks those down further into:
1. Low level hedgehogs
2. Low level foxes
3. High level hedgehogs
4. High level foxes
themerelyreal.wordpress.com/2013/08/25/oh-the-hedgehogs-y…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... Chana's post came up in the context of an interesting thread today about foxes vs. hedgehogs:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(The closest I've come to reading a convincing defense of hedgehogging is more like... a serial monogomy approach to hedgehogging, where you immerse yourself in one model/worldview at a time)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My Conversation with @Coldxman: www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNdttEHDTQU
(full episode is subscribers-only)
As you'd expect, he asked some very probing questions! I also asked him something I've been curious about -- whether trying to be intellectual honest has had any downsides for his career
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Something that occurred to me during our chat:
A nice perk of trying to be intellectually honest - i.e., not overstating your case, acknowledging its weak points - is that it's so *relaxing*
I don't have to be stressed out about not being able to defend a claim I've made -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(The closest I've come to reading a convincing defense of hedgehogging is more like... a serial monogomy approach to hedgehogging, where you immerse yourself in one model/worldview at a time)
-
Julia Galef reposted
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
NEW Prestigious Awards: My book of the month goes to @juliagalef’s The Scout Mindset: Why Some People See Clearly & Others Don’t, a book with powerful tools for fighting self-deception! 1/9
thefire.org/the-scout-mindset-by-julia-galef-reminds-us-t… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Dylan and I discussed my book for Vox Conversations! He made me sweat at the end by insisting I give him constructive criticism on how he was falling short of scout mindset 😬
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ I've noticed that a lot of people who pride themselves on being "rigorous" or "critical thinkers" have this simple heuristic that anecdotes = weak evidence.
But I disagree! It depends on what claim those anecdotes are being used to support.Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
4/ But that's not the claim I was making. Instead, I was claiming (b) "It is possible to be a successful leader and express uncertainty (contra the common wisdom, which says it isn't)."
That's a weaker claim and one which actually only needs a handful of anecdotes to justify it
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
5/ It's true, my claim wasn't strictly about *possibility* of X -- for that I would only have needed one example
My claim was more like "Some successful leaders do X" And I think a handful of (prominent) examples = decent evidence that X isn't super rare
Daeyoung Choi
@daeyoungchoi
I agree with your point. But I think what you are really saying is that you in fact want your claim to be slightly stronger than it is merely "possible." If the claim really was only about "possibility," one anecdote would suffice. But such a claim may not be terribly useful.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
Shit. Guys, this is why we instituted the buddy system.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting answer to the question "What is Miami's message?"
(re: @paulg's observation that different cities have different messages, e.g. NYC: "You should be richer," Boston: "You should be smarter")
Andy Matuschak
@andy_matuschak
So far, the suggestion for Miami's "message" which seems most apt is @devonzuegel's "you should be more entertaining / flamboyant." devonzuegel.com/post/field-notes-miami
It's a very unfamiliar message! Not yet sure if/how it'll prove compatible with others' ambitions for a new high-tech hub. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I was interviewed by one of my favorite science writers, @cragcrest:
www.lastwordonnothing.com/2021/04/28/learning-to-think-li…
One of the interesting questions she asked was about how thinking like a "scout" differs from thinking like a "scientist":
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is just one of the reasons I was drawn to the scout metaphor, by the way
Another is that I like the "map / territory" metaphor --the awareness that what you're doing as you form judgments about the world is editing your "map," which is a simplified representation of reality -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Every day, Kira (our neighbor's dog) comes in to greet us in our living room
When we happen to be sitting out on the porch instead, she greets us there... and then runs into the living room to see if we are ALSO in there
<3 dogs' lack of object permanence -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Whenever a journalist writes that someone "ADMITTED" something I mentally sub in a more neutral word like "SAID" and re-read the sentence to myself
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... y'all are a buncha wise guys
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a great list... and follow up tweet
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Scout mindset <3
Leah Libresco Sargeant
@LeahLibresco
Got to practice dying to self when I got a fact-checking question from @CaitrinKeiper for an upcoming @Plough piece and my initial source didn’t measure up.
Had to take a little walk away from the computer and remind myself that I have to earnestly want the truth above all. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ This week I was on @seanmcarroll's excellent Mindscape podcast: www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2021/04/19/143-julia…
He asked tough but fun questions! For example: How open should we be to weird ideas (e.g. scientific theories)? Like, where do you draw the line & say, "No, that's too weird to entertain"?Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
4/ To generalize the previous point... does the guy with the weird idea seem to understand why people would be skeptical of it? Or is he just like, "People don't want to hear the TRUTH!!" ? The latter makes me less optimistic about his idea being worth the time to entertain.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
5/ Finally... there is a difference between "This idea is worth MY time to entertain" and "This idea is worth SOMEONE's time to entertain." The set of ideas in the latter category should be a lot bigger.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Now I know how restaurant owners feel when people are like “Zero stars, Grubhub driver was rude to me”
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... Reading other people's stories of unfair reviews is filling me with equal parts validation and vicarious anger
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
UPDATE: Oh, looks like Amazon removed the review after all! Thanks to those of you who reported it -- I actually didn't expect that to work
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Ever since Devon moved to Miami I've been hoping she would write about the city -- and she did, and it's even better than I'd hoped!
devonzuegel.com/post/field-notes-miami
A must-read if you are at all curious about Miami, or how to look at cities in general, or you just like beautiful photos
Devon ☀️
@devonzuegel
Since moving to Miami a few months ago, I've had a lot of fun exploring my new stomping grounds.
I wanted to share what I've found, so I wrote some field notes to give you a peek into what life is like here: devonzuegel.com/post/field-notes-miami
Questions/additions welcome! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I was on The Weeds last weekend! Had a fun conversation with @mattyglesias about, e.g.
- Meta-uncertainty (is P=1/6 of a die roll different from other P=1/6 forecasts?)
- When scout mindset persuades & when it doesn't
- Why moderating comments is hard
podcasts.apple.com/ni/podcast/think-like-a-scout/id104243… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of the harder types of questions for me to answer is "Why are you interested in X?"
The only answer that my brain can manage to produce is "Well, because X is objectively interesting"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: OK so this is one of those illusion of transparency cases... I thought it was obvious that "objectively interesting" is a silly concept, but I read some comments and I guess it's not obvious?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Such a great question, and some great responses in the thread
Devon ☀️
@devonzuegel
What are the criticisms of your work that you find most interesting?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
An unexpected and wonderful side effect of my book is that people have started tagging me when they spot someone exhibiting scout mindset
A+ quality of life improvement
ltownZag
@LtownZag
@juliagalef
Scout Mindset sighting in the wild. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I find Darwin's anxiety so relatable
(from a section of my book about ways of comforting yourself without resorting to self-deception)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Link to the book, which has more Darwin anecdotes in it (I had to restrain myself or it would've been like 1/2 Darwin)
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love when people get what I'm trying to say *and* manage to express it more clearly and succinctly than me :)
(Thread)
Andy Matuschak
@andy_matuschak
The Scout Mindset (@juliagalef’s new book) sharply distills many key ideas from the rationalist world, but the framing is unusual and (I think) better! It presents motivated reasoning as rooted in important emotional functions which truth-seeking advocates must address/provide.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Tim Urban
@waitbutwhy
A book on thinking by one of the best thinkers I know. @juliagalef
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I subscribe to only a handful of Substacks, but @Noahpinion's is one of them!
Today he interviewed me about my new book, THE SCOUT MINDSET. Here's an excerpt from one of my responses, about how scout mindset can help you persuade others:
noahpinion.substack.com/p/interview-julia-galef -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
In my latest video I share one of the ideas from my new book, and tell the story of activists who fought the AIDS crisis using scout mindset
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzkWqpsPqho -
Julia Galef reposted
Stuart Ritchie
@StuartJRitchie
I’m a couple of hours into the audiobook of @juliagalef’s Scout Mindset, and it’s GREAT so far. A guide to open-mindedness, with a real understanding of why people so often *don’t* change their views. Strong recommendation! www.amazon.co.uk/dp/034942764X
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
Lots of stories about employers who are trying to find employees and can't, but I have close friends looking for jobs that don't require a college degree in the Bay and it's the usual story: 50 apps for one callback, applications to be allowed to fill out other applications...
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
BROKE: Not citing studies
WOKE: Citing lots of studies
BESPOKE: Not citing studies, because actually it turns out they're all badPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Good question. What I mostly did was to make more limited claims, e.g. "Here's a technique many people have found helpful, here are some examples" instead of "Here is a technique that Science Proves will work"
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I also rely to some extent just on reasoning. For example in Chapter 3 I point out some basic facts about human psychology and why those imply that we probably use scout mindset less than we should.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I wouldn't pick on Spock so much if he didn't give rationality such a bad name
www.wired.com/2021/04/geeks-guide-spock-logic/
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Link to my book, if you want to see Spock's embarrassing calibration curve: www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Saw a black bear in the wild for the first time today - he ambled across the road right in front of our car
I didn't expect it to look so... derpy
It's like a drawing by one of those medieval European artists trying to depict an animal based off third-hand accounts they'd heard -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Sharing a point from my book THE SCOUT MINDSET:
I sometimes hear people claim, "Identity doesn't affect my reasoning, because I don't identify with any group"
But they're ignoring *oppositional identities*, which distort your reasoning just as much despite not having a label
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Want to read more? You can pick up a copy of THE SCOUT MINDSET here: www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset…
-
Julia Galef reposted
Philip E. Tetlock
@PTetlock
The scouts in @juliagalef's superb new book, Scout Mindset, are the heroes—just as the superforecasters were in Superforecasting.
But, as Julia recognizes, the “soldiers” are also essential players in human minds.
There's more than a bit of dogmatic twit in each of us.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(That's in contrast to "soldier mindset," in which our aim is to defend our beliefs against evidence that might threaten them)
The book is an easy read with lots of examples, stories, and little charts and diagrams to illustrate the ideas -
Julia Galef reposted
Spencer Greenberg 🔍
@SpencrGreenberg
It was really exciting to have @juliagalef on the Clearer Thinking podcast! She makes the best case I've ever heard for truth-seeking. You can hear the rest of the conversation at:
clearerthinkingpodcast.com?ep=036&time=8m52s
I also highly recommend checking out her new book, the Scout Mindset! -
Julia Galef reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
I just listened to the Scout Mindset audiobook and it's great!
It's a rare kind of book, a real-world referent of the phrase "learning how to learn".
Has the best explanation I've seen of why you don't have to build fake confidence to succeed.
Thanks for writing it @juliagalef
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
🍾Happy book-day to me! 🎉
My debut book THE SCOUT MINDSET just came out and I'm savoring the surreal experience of seeing my own thoughts on the page, like some kind of *author* or something -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I got to talk about my book with @SpencrGreenberg on his excellent podcast Clearer Thinking:
clearerthinkingpodcast.com?ep=036
One thing we discussed is how to cope psychologically with risky bets, like starting a company.
tl;dr: Make lots of positive expected value bets in your life.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Paging @AnnieDuke
-
Julia Galef reposted
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hey, thanks @jonathanchait!
He does do a good job of capturing my pathological obsession with epistemic rigor :) -
Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hey, thanks @jonathanchait!
He does do a good job of capturing my pathological obsession with epistemic rigor :) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
🍾Happy book-day to me! 🎉
My debut book THE SCOUT MINDSET just came out and I'm savoring the surreal experience of seeing my own thoughts on the page, like some kind of *author* or something
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It's about (unsurprisingly) the "scout mindset," my term for the motivation to see things as they are, not as you wish they were; trying to be intellectually honest, objective and curious about what's actually true.
You can get a copy here: www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(That's in contrast to "soldier mindset," in which our aim is to defend our beliefs against evidence that might threaten them)
The book is an easy read with lots of examples, stories, and little charts and diagrams to illustrate the ideas -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hunny the golden retriever, checking out a review copy of my book
Her verdict: Inedible. 1/5 stars -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting point from @Noahpinion about a potential downside of high speed rail (HSR), which I hadn't considered
noahpinion.substack.com/p/i-dont-get-the-high-speed-rail-… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Really enjoyed this conversation on @thedispatch podcast on Friday!
We covered the relationship between scout mindset and persuasion, Barry Goldwater's independence of mind, @whignewtons's defense of the honor of press secretaries (contra my criticisms of them) and lots more
Stephen Hayes
@stephenfhayes
We hosted @juliagalef on the Friday Dispatch Pod to discuss her forthcoming book, "The Scout Mindset: Why Some People See Things Clearly and Others Don't." Great book, fascinating discussion. @whignewtons
podcast.thedispatch.com/p/the-treasure-of-the-scout-mindset -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Are Uber and Lyft drivers being exploited?
This is a question I've been interested in for a while, and I explore the debate in the latest episode of Rationally Speaking, via interviews with three guests who disagree with each other.
Audio + transcript: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-255-are-uber-a… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ My fiancé and I have been living out of AirBnBs for the last nine months and it's just insane how much better it is than renting from a landlord
Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
7/ Also loved this place in Carolina Beach, with a balcony overlooking the ocean
... as you can tell I love being on bodies of water
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
8/ It does help a lot to be minimalist, which fortunately we both are... our belongings fit in three suitcases
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
9/ From reading the comments I guess I should emphasize two things...
First, I'm not rich, and I'm not spending a lot of money on this! I'm just location-flexible, and finding good deals
And second...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
10/ It's true that Airbnbs cost more than renting, on average. But my point about the better UX of Airbnb is true even if you hold $ constant
i.e., if you compare a $2K/month Airbnb to a $2K (or even $4K)/month apartment, the former has much better transparency. That's the point -
Julia Galef reposted
eigenrobot
@eigenrobot
just noticed a weird thing
there used to be a ton of leftist cause areas. you could be a cool leftist by protesting china occupying tibet or by supporting gay marriage or by sending shoes to honduras or opposing the middle east or destroying the sun (long term cause of coal) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm enjoying Elsinore, a point & click game where you're stuck in a time loop
You play as Ophelia, going through the events of Hamlet and trying to change them
It's fun, puzzling... and as you learn more about what's happening to you, surprisingly creepy
store.steampowered.com/app/512890/Elsinore/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you claim that some point is "obvious" despite the fact that lots of smart and knowledgeable people either (1) express surprise at it, or (2) disagree with it, then... you're just empirically wrong
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hello! I'm a youthful mistake made at Ellis Island
Paul Sheppard, PhD🧠
@PaulSheppardPhD
Introduce yourself as your name's meaning:
Hello! I'm Small Guy Who Looks After Sheep! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ Something that can help you stay zen when people misunderstand or get angry at you online, is to try and view it all mechanistically
Like, "Huh, if I do X then Z tends to result. Interesting... I wonder what happens if I try Y instead?" etc.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2/ i.e, viewing communication or human nature as this complex thing you can learn about by poking it in different ways to see how it operates
That's not to say there's a perfect solution that makes 0 people mad. But the fun challenge is figuring out the limits of what's possible -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm interested in this, but even more interested in a variant on this question... Which two languages, A and B, score highest on this ratio:
[ease of learning A if you already know B]
-----------------------------------------------
[similarity between A and B]
?
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Question for linguists: If we made a matrix of all language pairs (i,j), with each value representing the average required time for a speaker of language i to become proficient in language j, what row of that matrix would have the lowest sum of values?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm very sympathetic to @MaxCRoser and I know how frustrating it is when people seem to be willfully, uncharitably misunderstanding you
The main thing that helps me is noticing this happens to ~everyone in the public eye, so it's not actually a sign you're doing something wrong
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
This thread is more personal than most of the things I share here, but I’m at my limit with Jason Hickel.
I want to explain why I dislike him so much and how we got here.
This is a personal story over several years so it’ll take a bit of time.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It also helps to keep in mind "What is the group of people whose good opinion I actually care about?" If people outside that group hate you, that's not necessarily a bad thing.
Still, this isn't easy and I wish I could give @MaxCRoser a hug. -
Julia Galef reposted
“paula”
@paularambles
swedes make up the best reasons to eat sweets
-
Julia Galef reposted
Ben Kuhn
@benkuhn
A lot of managers (including me!) find it hard/scary to give critical feedback.
I realized recently that this is often downstream of a less obvious blindspot—giving people enough *positive* feedback! If you've done that, critical feedback "magically" becomes much less fraught. -
Julia Galef reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Today's Substack post is about when and why the experts lie.
noahpinion.substack.com/p/yes-experts-will-lie-to-you-som… -
Julia Galef reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
The greatest-ever name for a think tank has been identified, thank you
(via @ranjanxroy) -
Julia Galef reposted
Dominik Liebl
@domliebl
When you had the same research idea, but your application is lacking relevance.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Never realized this before but "meadow in a mountain valley" might be one of my favorite kinds of place
An early spring day in Cade's Cove: -
Julia Galef reposted
Elizabeth Van Nostrand
@acesounderglass
1/ sometimes your friend will be in a relationship/job/cult etc that you think is really bad for them. And sometimes when you bring it up, they will agree that it pattern matches bad things quite well, but is an exception for reasons they may or may not be able to explain.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Henry Shevlin
@dioscuri
The best new single serving website, in case anyone is wondering If That Ship Is Still Stuck. istheshipstillstuck.com
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ There's something that bugs me about the "virtue signaling" discourse, which goes like this
GROUP A: "Ugh, those people are virtue signaling -- they're just saying that stuff to seem like good people"
GROUP B: "What's wrong with wanting to show you're a good person??"Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3/ Group B's response seems to be defending people who say things they truly believe, out of a motivation to look good (e.g., decrying injustices)
But Group A's complaint was about people who say bullshit they don't really believe, out of a motivation to look good.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: I'm no longer confident in my original read on what is meant by "virtue signaling" / when it is used
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This doesn't directly resolve my confusion about what's going on with the "virtue signaling" discourse, but I thought it was a useful breakdown nonetheless:
(thread)
Dan Donnelly
@DanDonnelly
I think there are at least 3 different phenomena that get grouped together as VS, which is part of the problem.
1) The version you mention, where people are insincere but say X to fit in because of social pressure -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Drove past a herd of elk this morning
-
Julia Galef reposted
Visakan Veerasamy
@visakanv
hehe
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It occurred to me that a subtle-but-important source of disagreement between me & others is:
We have different priors on "How likely is it that one political side is entirely / mostly right, & the other side entirely / mostly wrong?"
Just a priori, this seems unlikely to me...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Like, it could turn out to be the case! I'd just find it kind of surprising.
I'm not exactly sure why I have this prior. Maybe because I just don't think the process by which people end up being sorted into political parties is especially truth-tracking.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: I'm realizing from the replies that many people think I'm saying "On a given issue, the truth is probably in the middle"
But what I meant is that it would be surprising to me if a given political side is right on *all* the issues they have opinions about -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I just backed this three-volume set of photography, "Vanishing Asia": www.kickstarter.com/projects/kk-org/vanishing-asia
@kevin2kelly's photos are absolutely stunning and cover so much underexplored ground. And $200 is a steal for three volumes of original photos (West Asia, Central Asia, and East Asia) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I had this same realization a couple years ago and it's been honestly very calming
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(part of a thread)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
.@dingding_peng, Twitter's algorithms are getting so good they're pairing your retweets with ads for a dessert called "Colliders"
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
In my new video I share one of the ideas from my upcoming book, THE SCOUT MINDSET.
Common wisdom says people want leaders who speak with 100% certainty. I explain why this is mistaken, and how to be influential while speaking frankly about uncertainty:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-DfX3_CO2bU -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Like many people I've been exploring the outdoors a lot more since Covid, and am discovering certain features of a trail that I especially love
1) Skinny boardwalks snaking their way through forests or bogsPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
4) Trails that are almost hidden in residential neighborhoods - so, there are houses nearby, but once you enter you can't detect them and it feels like you're in the wild
Like this one in Greenville, SC - it's wedged between two streets but it's a separate world
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(This thread partially inspired by @patrick_oshag's thread of his walks in the woods: x.com/patrick_oshag/status/1112350444154695691)
Patrick OShaughnessy
@patrick_oshag
Woods thread to be added to the rest of the year.
Hopefully these will cause a few people go to the woods that wouldn’t have otherwise.
Found a tree down over the river. Great spot to sit and not think. -
Julia Galef reposted
Spencer Greenberg 🔍
@SpencrGreenberg
2 ways fear can be "irrational":
1. the strength of emotion is not calibrated to the level of danger (eg extreme fear of planes)
2. the emotion produces unhelpful outcomes (eg avoiding social interaction due to anxiety)
But even then, notice it. It contains very useful info. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This thread captures why I'm often reluctant to give up my preferred jargon
(even though I acknowledge jargon has its downsides too)
Nate Soares ⏹️
@So8res
"Stop using phrases that meticulously track uncommon distinctions you've made; we already have perfectly good phrases that ignore those distinctions, and your audience won't be able to tell the difference!" No.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ In this week's podcast I sputter incredulously about unfair laws like qualified immunity and asset forfeiture, and constitutional scholar @WilliamBaude gamely tries to steel man them (and explain why they exist in the first place)
Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-254-unfair-law…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2/ Also! I spent half an hour talking to Will about originalism and it was incredibly enlightening.
I have such a clearer picture now of why people disagree over the question "Should judges base their rulings on the original meaning of the Constitution?" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Railroad tracks over the water. Taken a few months ago, near the border of NH/ME
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
All of you who were mad at me for not trespassing into the "Enchanted Forest" ruins a few weeks ago will be happy to know that there *was* a "No Trespassing" sign on these tracks and I ignored it
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
How do I decide what [words, etc.] to avoid as offensive?
I think my algorithm's roughly, avoid it if any one of these criteria is met:
1. It feels offensive to me
2. I predict most of my peer group thinks it's offensive
3. I predict >25% of the relevant group would be offended
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Basically I'm trying to err on the safe side, but also not be vulnerable to the problem where "If anyone claims X is offensive, then we can't use it, no matter how unrepresentative or insincere they are"
-
Julia Galef reposted
Byrne Hobart
@ByrneHobart
It's possible that bioethicists save millions of lives in the aggregate. It's also possible that they cost millions of lives in the aggregate. Would a bioethicist permit bioethics to exist if it were a drug rather than an academic discipline?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of my favorite fonts is the "National Forest" font (and color scheme, etc.) It just instantly conjures up trails, and camping, and feels so wholesome and retro
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I agree! This norm (creating open and honest "Date me" sites) is great, and @uncatherio is great too, I highly recommend her:
Chana
@ChanaMessinger
Oh man, @uncatherio's Date Me website is so excellent. I love this genre of thing: people putting themselves out there, saying clearly and publicly that they want a partner, and knowing who they are and what they're looking for.
paper.dropbox.com/doc/catherios-dating-profile-Wt2wu19F4z…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Also, did you know that she's behind the excellent microCOVID project, which uses the most up-to-date data + information you supply about your situation, to estimate the COVID risk of that specific situation?
www.wired.com/story/group-house-covid-risk-points/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I went on The Wright Show (on @bloggingheads) to talk about the rationalist community and last month's Slate Star Codex / New York Times controversy: youtu.be/FL7tyTYoE38
-
Julia Galef reposted
Amanda Askell
@AmandaAskell
Prediction markets are legally questionable but stock markets aren't. Proposal: create companies A and B. People agree to give A n dollars if at any time an adjudicator says P is true (0 otherwise), and to give B n dollars if it's false (0 otherwise). Others buy stock in A and B.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ Last week I got into a debate in which several people argued that billionaires giving away $$ is bad because it "legitimizes" their wealth.
... which struck me as implausible. So now I'm wondering: What kind of evidence would tell us something about that hypothesis?Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3/ But maybe I'm wrong? Or maybe there's some other type of compelling evidence I'm missing, for the "Billionaires giving away $$ --> society is significantly more accepting of inequality, less interested in taxing the rich, etc." hypothesis?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
4/ Though I have to admit, even *if* that causal link existed, it would still seem perverse to me to respond to that by discouraging billionaire philanthropy.
Far more direct to simply lobby for "We should raise taxes on the rich" (and point out that's true despite philanthropy) -
Julia Galef reposted
А. Z. Fоrеmаn: Seriouѕ Рhіlоlοgy, Ѕіlly Веhаvіоr
@azforeman
I once was sitting in O’Hare airport reading a book of Latin poetry when a guy looking like a monk walks up to me looking utterly lost and asks “Loquerisne Latine”? (Do you speak Latin?) To which I answer “Ita, possumne te adiuvare?” (Yes, can I help you?.)
Ellen is at the Grammar Table
@GrammarTable
People who studied Latin, can you tell me any stories about your Latin-studying experiences? Funny or nonfunny.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I kinda wish people would stop using famous pseudonyms on Twitter... just because I get really excited when I see a notification like "David Hume followed you," in the split second before I remember he's dead
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... ok who's the joker
-
Julia Galef reposted
John Myles White
@johnmyleswhite
So many arguments carry on because both sides discuss things at a level of abstraction at which every statement is at best half-true and half-false and the each side fixates on the half-false parts of the other side's claims.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of the more surreal places I've visited recently: The Desert of Maine, golden sand dunes in the middle of a pine forest.
(Not technically a desert since rainfall is too high. But still, naturally occurring! The sand is silt, created by glaciers moving across the land) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Making a list of “ways of thinking” dichotomies, e.g.
Prickles / goo (Simler)
Convex / concave (Buterin)
Scout / soldier (me)
Maximizing / satisficing (Simon)
Elephant / rider (Haidt)
Growth / fixed (Dweck)
Near / far (Hanson)
Outside view / inside view (Kahneman?)
…what else? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Part of a great thread on retaining "beginner's eyes"
Patrick McKenzie
@patio11
I don't know whether this is helpful, but "Self-modify to be more fascinated with how things work, how people behave, how decisions are made, how systems interact, etc etc."
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I often hear the thought experiment, "What would you tell a friend in this situation?" intended to show people they're being too hard on themselves
But I suspect it overcompensates. We may have a bias to be hard on ourselves, but we also have a bias *against* criticizing friends
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So I prefer something more detached, e.g. "What would you think if you saw a random other person in your same situation? How harshly would you judge them?"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: To be clear(er), the bias I'm thinking about is in answering questions with truth-value, like
- Did I screw up?
- Am I failing at X?
- Was I irresponsible?
etc.
The goal is to answer these objectively, but that doesn't preclude you taking a kind *attitude* towards yourself -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is cool! A prediction market search engine, where you can search for a topic (e.g. "COVID," in the example below) and find forecasts about that topic, across many different prediction markets
It's called Metaforecast: www.lesswrong.com/posts/cWSDKWDFcGA2Bzyni/introducing-met… -
Julia Galef reposted
Luke Muehlhauser
@lukeprog
"How likely is that really? I wonder if there's a prediction market on that question somewhere." Cool new search engine for prediction markets and other forecasting platforms: www.lesswrong.com/posts/cWSDKWDFcGA2Bzyni/introducing-met…
-
Julia Galef reposted
Catherine Olsson
@catherineols
Fantastic question ("Is there a good reason why many basic laws of physics are linear or quadratic (for example, F=ma), not much more complex?") and fantastic answer!
Kurt Barry
@Kurt_M_Barry
Linear or quadratic laws often come from a Taylor series expansion around an equilibrium point. Usually the first derivative is non-zero, so you get a linear law. If the first derivative vanishes (e.g. due to a symmetry), you get a quadratic law instead. Rare for both to be zero.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Devon ☀️
@devonzuegel
I wish there were an equivalent of a disapproving glare on the internet devonzuegel.com/post/the-silence-is-deafening
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I played a lot of Oregon Trail as a kid, so was fascinated to read this detailed account from the game designer of how he set up the "river crossing" part of the game to be as complex and realistic as possible:
www.died-of-dysentery.com/stories/crossing-rivers.html -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I made a video responding to a common critique of "Bayesian thinking":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=55L7w2Vwkuk -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Welp, things have escalated... the game just upgraded me from the "Introvert Award" to the "Recluse Award"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The game I've been playing on Steam just awarded me an "Introvert Award" for playing an impressive number of solo games...😒jeez
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ Hey guys, I’m excited to announce my first book is coming out April 13!
It’s about something I call “scout mindset” - the motivation to see things as they are, not as you wish they were; to be intellectually honest & curious about what's actually true
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2/ The central metaphor of the book is that we’re often in “soldier mindset,” motivated to defend our ideas against threatening evidence or arguments. And scout mindset is an alternative to that - a scout’s goal isn’t to defend, but to go out and get an accurate map of reality.
Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
5/ It’s an easy read, but packed with lots of ideas and anecdotes. I cover the founding of Amazon, identity battles over breastfeeding and Bayesianism, Star Trek, AIDS activism, baseball, politics, and plenty of everyday examples from life & work
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
6/ If this sounds interesting to you, I think you’ll enjoy the book!
Here’s the link again so you can pre-order a copy (they tell me pre-orders are especially helpful for a first-time author): www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/555240/the-scout-mindset…
Can’t wait for you guys to read it! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ My pitch for a TV show: A pair of brilliant & eccentric detectives travel around the world consulting on unusual cases
Each story arc is ~6 episodes long and takes place in a different beautiful or interesting setting: A research base in the Galapagos...Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3/ Also one of the detectives is a foodie so their conversations about the case take place over meals at local eateries or while walking & eating street food
He keeps getting distracted & calling over the cook ("This is sensational! What am I tasting here, is this lemongrass??")
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
4/ And the detectives have a comfortable, friendly-grumpy banter-y dynamic with each other, like Frasier and Niles
So basically this would be all my favorite things rolled into one: Detective show, travel show, food show, buddy comedy
Somebody make it please 🙏 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love this approach to running a classroom, from Duncan Sabien: Instead of punishments, set up costs. Kids get to make choices for themselves about which actions are worth which costs.
(From @SpencrGreenberg's Clearer Thinking Podcast: clearerthinkingpodcast.com?ep=021)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(thanks to @robbensinger for the transcription)
I love this because it treats kids with dignity. But also, it's just a more efficient solution, allowing the important disruptions and preventing the unimportant disruptions. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Had a fascinating conversation w/@VitalikButerin on my podcast, about:
- Why prediction markets favor Trump
- Concave vs. convex thinking
- The case for life extension
- Why Vitalik tries to be an intellectually honest leader
...& more. Audio + transcript: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-253-intellectu…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I swear I'm not secretly trying to propagandize for rationalists by having cool people come on the show and talk about how they value rationality
... It just so happens to be the case that cool people ARE more likely to value rationality :) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm confused about the "Is an engineer making $150K a year rich?" debate, which goes
"Of course $150K = rich, it's much higher than the median"
"But $150K doesn't go as far in a city like SF"
"Living in SF is a luxury good. Making that choice doesn't mean you're not rich"
...Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So maybe the engineer's "adjusted" salary is whatever they would've earned in the median city?
But that doesn't seem quite right; the fact that the engineer is choosing (high salary + expensive rent) over (lower salary + cheap rent) means those bundles aren't equivalent
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: I'm still reading the replies, but just wanted to note that of course drawing a line between "rich" vs. "not rich" is kind of arbitrary.
The interesting question IMO is how to think about the relationship between (a) salary and (b) how well-off you are -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Oh yeah, and how could I forget Impossible beef nachos!
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some of the delicious and not-particularly-healthful things I've made recently with Impossible beef: Tacos, green chile cheeseburgers, dumplings, meatball subs, baked ziti, tamale pie
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I swear I'm not a paid shill for Impossible
... although, honestly, if there was one product I *would* be willing to shill for, it might be Impossible beef -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Passed this overgrown sign, in an empty lot, advertising "The Enchanted Forest of Rhode Island."
I looked it up; it was an amusement park built in 1971 and long since closed. Apparently the ruins of the park are still in the woods past the sign, but I didn't want to trespass. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It's kind of interesting how 3 is an especially pleasing number in visual art (e.g. the "rule of thirds") and fiction (the "rule of three") yet not in music (the most naturally pleasing time signature being 4/4)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
ME: Hey Luke, 4/4 time is the most naturally pleasing time signature right?
LUKE: I wouldn’t say that, no
ME: Oh, so that’s why I’m kinda getting ratioed on Twitter
LUKE: ... maybe if you want to tweet about music you should, uh, check with me first? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Is subtweeting actually a bad thing?
I know it seems kind of... shifty, or craven, or something... but maybe it's just a good solution to the problem "I want to comment on [situation] to people who are already aware of it but I don't want to increase the # of people aware of it"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... huh I guess people have different understandings of what "subtweeting" is!
I was thinking of a veiled comment on, usually, a specific person or group, or some recent drama.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Also interesting to discover (from multiple responses in the thread) that it's annoying to people when they don't know the context of the subtweet. I suppose that makes sense, it just hadn't occurred to me.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Are there any good examples of a mystery -- a novel, TV show, or movie -- where the answer to "whodunit" is technically possible (but hard) for you to figure out from clues dropped?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I feel like I am sometimes pretty good at guessing whodunit, but my strategy is almost entirely based on genre-savvyness -- or, like, meta-knowledge about "how stories like this tend to be written" e.g. when the twists happen and what makes a good twist
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This thread inspired me to binge-watch the 2015 miniseries of "And Then There Were None"
It's a great adaptation! And I do think the solution is somewhat guessable -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The scenic overlook as it appeared online vs. when we got there
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It was like being enclosed in a white room
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
True, what it lacked in scenic-ness it made up for in surreal-ness
Jonathan Mannhart 🔎
@JMannhart
Have to say, I think I like yours more!
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I agree, it's not a good idea to make plant-based meat substitutes healthier!
Out of all the possible ways to promote healthy diets, "making meat substitutes taste worse" is one of the most costly (in terms of the hit to the environment & animal welfare)
www.fastcompany.com/90606065/plant-based-burgers-arent-a-…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some of the delicious and not-particularly-healthful things I've made recently with Impossible beef: Tacos, green chile cheeseburgers, dumplings, meatball subs, baked ziti, tamale pie
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Also I just want to give kudos to @BrianKateman (the author of the article and the promoter of the "Reducetarian" movement) for his pragmatism and focus on how to actually reduce animal suffering.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
I would like to apologize to the wonderful team designing the Decision Tree format in Wolfram Mathematica. The disappointment you saw in my face was nothing personal.
I put the event on my calendar weeks ago and had since forgotten what I meant by "Meet the tree folk" -
Julia Galef reposted
kevin simler
@kevinsimler
Exceptional.
IMO this is the best (clearest eyed) writeup on the SSC/NYT kerfuffle -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What makes a good "unpopular opinion" tweet? IMO, it should be
1) something you sincerely believe, not just saying for shock value / attention
2) something you actually expect a lot of *your* readers to disagree with, not just something unpopular with your outgroup -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting thread on what you can learn from visiting McDonalds in different countries
aidanechols
@harridanechoes
I traveled a good amount in the 3 years before COVID. Very quickly I made it a point to eat at a McDonald's at least once in every new country I visited because I learned so much every time I did. Here's some things I learned:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Recently learned there is a giant mansion hidden in plain sight near my apartment in SF!
I saw this photo, then read the address -- 47 Chenery St. -- and did a double-take. "What? I walk down that block every day, it's a boring residential street, definitely no mansions"...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's what 47 Chenery St. looks like -- this is what I would see on my walk each morning. So where is the mansion?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Turns out the mansion takes up the whole city block but is camouflaged on all sides by ordinary houses + trees.
I guess you enter through what appears to be a garage door in 47 Chenery (you can see it in the previous pic), and emerge in the gardens of this palatial hidden wonder -
Julia Galef reposted
Aella
@Aella_Girl
Lots of ppl hate sex workers, which sometimes tempts me to underplay the negative aspects of my job - stuff they'd use to reinforce their position.
But me being dishonest about my reality also reinforces them. I have much more hope in persistent, nuanced honesty. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The original song ("It was Agatha all along") is great, the remix is even better, but best of all is watching this guy's irrepressible glee as he plays it
Leland Philpot
@lelandphilpot
AGATHA ALL ALONG TRAP/HIPHOP REMIX by Leland Philpot 😏
YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST!
#babelscatter #wandavision #comics #anime -
Julia Galef reposted
Devon ☀️
@devonzuegel
1/5
Hey @airbnb, a recent stay really hurt my trust in your platform, and your support team's answers to my questions about what the heck happened have been disappointingly evasive. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A useful feature of my psychology: When there's something I want to do that's a bit socially unacceptable - but shouldn't be, IMO - my nervousness about doing it tends to be counterbalanced by indignation ("I shouldn't HAVE to feel nervous about this!") and so I end up doing it
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(For example, saying no to unreasonable requests)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What's your favorite funny/clever experiment design?
One of mine is the one where scientists wanted to test the hypothesis that ants navigate by counting their own steps. So they glued stilts to ants' legs -- and yup, the ants heading back to their nest overshot the distance -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It never stops being funny to me that when I see a gauzily-lit photo of a woman in a long skirt baking bread, it's roughly
50% probability: Christian tradwife propaganda
50% probability: Lesbian cottagecore propaganda -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Abbott & Costello for the modern age! I can totally hear this sketch in their voices
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
C: I wanna be a day trader. All this working from home, I bet fewer people buy pants.
A: Ah, you think trousers will drop?
C: No, just that the stock goes down.
A: So short pants.
C: No, long pants.
A: Are you crazy? Short pants and long underwear!
C: I'll look pretty ridiculous. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is really true for me. I think Twitter makes me not just a better communicator but a better thinker, by forcing me to be precise and anticipate objections to my views
(Blogging and other public writing can do the same, but on Twitter the feedback loops are especially tight)
Ben Landau-Taylor
@benlandautaylor
Obsessive precision and pedantic clarity isn’t just good for your own thinking. On social media, it’s also an incantation to ward off the fuzzy-headed. When I get sloppy, I am justly punished with sloppy replies.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Chana
@ChanaMessinger
Sometimes you know there's a joke but it's not quite fully formed.
You know, a pun in the oven. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My new, updated-for-COVID list of places I visit while traveling around the US (i.e. the keywords I always search for):
1. Trails
2. Parks / nature preserves
3. Gardens
4. Scenic drives
5. Scenic overlooks
6. Ruins / ghost towns
7. Farms / farmstands
8. Historic districts
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My trusty list of places I visit in any new city (excluding food):
1. Gardens/parks
2. Public transit
3. Unique bookstores (eg Powell's, Strand)
4. Hotel with a rooftop lounge (great view for the price of a drink)
5. Central library (often has cool architecture)
6. College campus -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Most of the time when someone says to me, "Ugh, why do you have to use jargon like 'X'?? There's already a word for that, just say 'Y'"
... my reaction is: wow, no, Y is very different from what I mean -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Like a lot of the commenters, I dislike how the "sealioning!" accusation is often used to mock sincere (and justified) questioning of a claim
That said, I think it's generally better to let people *opt in* to debates over their views, not to pressure them...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This morning I'm thinking about this old comic, which gave rise to the term "sealioning", i.e., "a type of trolling or harassment that consists of pursuing people with persistent requests for evidence or repeated questions, while maintaining a pretense of civility and sincerity."
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If someone is *never* willing to address objections to their views, that's not great. But in any *particular* case, preferring not to debate is perfectly acceptable.
(This is why when I start a disagreement with someone I often add caveats like "No obligation to reply, but...") -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love a good disambiguation of an over-loaded term like "self-control"
Spencer Greenberg 🔍
@SpencrGreenberg
Why do some people appear to have better self-control than others?
I think it’s hard to answer this question if we treat self-control like an indivisible black box.
So let’s split apart.
Here is my list of traits that can appear to be “self-control” from the outside:
[thread] -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What's your favorite animated music video? Mine might be "Ghost of Stephen Foster" by Squirrel Nut Zippers
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJzWGkgFcTU
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: Lots of great nominations in the thread! I'm having fun going through these.
Another one I've been enjoying is www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RHFFeQ2tu4 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This morning I'm thinking about this old comic, which gave rise to the term "sealioning", i.e., "a type of trolling or harassment that consists of pursuing people with persistent requests for evidence or repeated questions, while maintaining a pretense of civility and sincerity."
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It's weird -- I agree sealioning is a real thing, but this comic is such a bad example!
1. The woman's dig on sea lions reads like a dig on a demographic group of people. Which is an uncomfortable example to choose, when you're complaining about people objecting to a statement
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2. Usually in real cases of sealioning, what happens is someone does give at least a little evidence or explanation for their claim, and then the "sea lions" keep pestering them anyway. But in the comic the couple never does
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Insightful post by @MarcNovicoff in today's Slow Boring, pointing out that Dems often frame social welfare policies as racial equity policies, and that this is not just unnecessary but actually counterproductive
www.slowboring.com/p/race-blind-policies-racial-equity
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This ties in with what @davidshor was saying on my podcast: Dem politicians / staffers are much more left-wing than their voters are, and have a hard time overcoming that bias when thinking about what kind of message the public will find appealing
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... and relatedly, that Dem politicians / staffers are incentivized to appeal to the media, which produces messaging that's not optimal for appealing to the public.
Such as, in this case, a "Helping minorities" frame instead of a "Helping people who need help" frame -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
In 2010 I threw a party for my friend Ames (@AmesCG) to celebrate him passing the bar, and I'm honestly still proud of the name I gave to the party on the invites:
"Ames Grawert et al. v. State of sobriety"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The prosecution won easily
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Ha, oh yeah I forgot:
x.com/AmesCG/status/1362874195387043844 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I think it's a genuinely hard problem to decide when it's fair to blame some group X for having bad property P
For example, is it fair if
- P is true of many Xs, but not the leaders of X?
- P is true of a small minority of Xs, but it's still a higher rate than in other groups?Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My own solution to all this difficulty is often just to be very *specific* when assigning blame.
(I also do a lot of thought experiments of the form "If X was another group I liked/disliked more, would this seem like a fair generalization?" etc.)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: To be clear, the problem that prompted my tweet wasn't so much "Should I blame group X for P" but more "Is it fair for me to object when other people blame group X for P"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Thanks! Though it still doesn't solve the problem of how I should react when other people make a generalization like "Group X has bad property P!"
Often my first reaction is "That's unfair, because [reasons]" but then I end up uncertain about how to think about whether it's fairPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Thanks! Though it still doesn't solve the problem of how I should react when other people make a generalization like "Group X has bad property P!"
Often my first reaction is "That's unfair, because [reasons]" but then I end up uncertain about how to think about whether it's fair -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I think about this a lot.
One change in my thinking is I've lowered my standards for judging someone's "good faith"; I'm trying to make more allowance for (1) people are human, (2) I may be misreading them, & (3) others may disagree in good faith about what counts as good faith
Zach Weinersmith
@ZachWeiner
What are your criteria for "good faith participation" in an argument?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So I used to judge people on things like: Are they straw-manning the other side? Are they using ad hominems? etc.
I still think that stuff is bad, but I'm less inclined to write people off for it. Now I tend to focus on more "bare minimum" criteria like
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some people asked what I do consider signs of bad faith disagreement... I'd say:
- Never conceding even minor points, e.g. that you might've misunderstood someone's meaning
- Dodging questions asked & just pivoting to your talking points
- Other cheap rhetorical tricks -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I had a fun & spirited conversation w/@JonHaidt in my latest @rspodcast episode, in which I try to wrap my mind around the “conservative” moral foundations (sanctity, authority, loyalty) and Jon compares me to a square in Flatland
Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-252-understand… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A rule I follow when reading articles (especially ones that are critical of their subjects):
When the journalist *paraphrases* someone, and it sounds like that person is saying something bad or dumb, I don't trust it. It's just way too easy to paraphrase uncharitably.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Even direct quotes can be used to mislead, ofc, but when you're just paraphrasing someone it's 10x easier to misrepresent them if that's what you want to do (consciously or not)
It's like that saying, "It's easy to lie with statistics, but it's even easier to lie without it" -
Julia Galef reposted
Chana
@ChanaMessinger
Well, that's just not true.
Mara Wilson
@MaraWilson
Just remembered that instead of replying to a tweet I think is wrong I can just say “well that’s just not true” out loud to myself and move on with my life
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Whenever I'm tempted to be annoyed at [the thing often called mansplaining], I remember the time I was 21 and explained to a development economist at a party what "microfinance" was, as if he'd never heard of it🤦♀️
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A thing I’ve changed my mind about: I used to take rudeness as a sign someone was arguing in bad faith. But now I think those two things are less correlated than I assumed
I still hate rudeness but try to tolerate it unless someone's showing other signs of bad faith disagreement
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some people asked what I do consider signs of bad faith disagreement... I'd say:
- Never conceding even minor points, e.g. that you might've misunderstood someone's meaning
- Dodging questions asked & just pivoting to your talking points
- Other cheap rhetorical tricks
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So basically, I noticed that some people are rude (sarcastic, making accusations about my motives, etc) but still do okay on these other metrics -- e.g., they're willing to concede points sometimes, and actually answer my questions -- so I decided I shouldn't dismiss them
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
To be clear I do think rudeness is bad for discourse, I don't want to "excuse" it, and I don't fault anyone else for choosing to avoid it.
I'm just saying it's not as predictive as I thought it was, of whether I'll be able to get something useful out of engaging with someone -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The game I've been playing on Steam just awarded me an "Introvert Award" for playing an impressive number of solo games...😒jeez
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting take on why neoreaction fizzled out:
discoursedrome.tumblr.com/post/643238351656386560/inverte…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I guess I would've put it a little differently... that the rise of the actually reactionary MAGA / alt-right crowd has made it less appealing for neo-reactionaries (who consider themselves much classier) to talk about similar ideas
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A hill I will die on: Referring to humans as "monkeys" instead of the more accurate "apes" is perfectly justified, due to it being way funnier
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
see, for example:
im on the ither sight
@jon_snow_420
god: i have made Mankind
angels: you fucked up a perfectly good monkey is what you did. look at it. it's got anxiety -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One "social justice" idea I've become more sympathetic to is the idea of trigger warnings, thanks to @slatestarcodex's defense of them:
slatestarcodex.com/2014/05/30/the-wonderful-thing-about-t…
... I'm still not fully sold on them, but Scott did move me in that direction, at least -
Julia Galef reposted
Amanda Askell
@AmandaAskell
There's evidence that psychadelics, ketamine, and mdma help with depression. But can we be certain they're treating the depression and not just giving people good experiences? It's very important to avoid a situation in which we're just giving depressed people good experiences.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
In honor of V-day: What "weird" dating strategies do you think would help more people find love, if only those strategies were more socially acceptable? Ideas I've seen:
- Travel / live together early (in a "fail fast" spirit)
- Make "date me" questionnaires w/your key priorities -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a great discussion of @slatestarcodex, the rationalist community, and norms of discourse
I don't agree with 100% of it, but it's a lot more well-informed & perceptive than average, and even the criticisms of the rationalists are pretty fair IMO
www.slowboring.com/p/slate-star-codex -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I was talking to a friend of mine who grew up in Ireland in the 90's, and she casually mentioned "One time when I was closing the store I worked in, this guy came & robbed us by holding a syringe to my arm. Said it was full of HIV-infected blood & he'd stab me if I didn't pay up"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
ME: "Oh god, you must've been traumatized!"
HER: "Nah, this happened to all my friends who worked in the service industry"
ME: "... what"
I was incredulous so I looked it up. And, wow: This article says there were 2,200 syringe attacks in Dublin in 1996:
www.independent.co.uk/news/dublin-muggers-bring-terror-to… -
Julia Galef reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
A New York Times article about Slate Star Codex advanced the stereotype that Silicon Valley is full of fascists.
That stereotype is wrong. Almost everyone out here is just a standard liberal nerd.
noahpinion.substack.com/p/silicon-valley-isnt-full-of-fas… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
For no particular reason, today seems like a good day to remind people about the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect
Nice explainer by @heyitsnoah: www.noahbrier.com/archives/2018/04/the-gell-mann-amnesia-… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
View out the back window this morning... love it when it's so misty the river + sky melt together into one seamless void
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Rob Bensinger's stellar proposal for a history of science class:
"[You're] taught every pre-modern view of the physical world as though it were true, in historical sequence, and you get to work through and live the process of updating to each new model."
www.facebook.com/robbensinger/posts/10164478039400447 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Oof, the casual anti-male sexism in pop culture really makes my jaw drop sometimes
e.g. in a recent episode of Superstore, Garrett is giving dating advice to a young guy and he says:
"Their stuff is nice. Our stuff, disgusting. So be a gentleman, go with the lights out"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Like, can you imagine a popular TV show having a woman say that women's genitalia is so disgusting to look at, that we shouldn't subject men to the sight of it? And that line passing without contradiction?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(To pre-empt the replies: No, I'm not saying this is the WORST THING IN THE WORLD, or that men are more oppressed than women, or that there's no anti-female sexism on TV. But I do think the anti-male sexism is more blatant, at least on otherwise progressive shows like Superstore)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Seems like @kdrum deserves credit for arriving relatively early to the "send kids back to school" position... he's been pointing out that this is the way the evidence points since May 23, 2020 (and got a lot of scathing criticism for it)
www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2020/05/todays-unpopular-o…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Full disclosure, I remember reading that post at the time and thinking he was updating too much on the available evidence and neglecting the common sense prior (that opening schools will make things worse)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I basically agree with this. (And you should read Ezra's column in the NYT on this subject, too: www.nytimes.com/2021/02/11/opinion/california-san-francis…).
Still, I wonder: Are citizens of any other state MORE willing than Californians are to make genuine sacrifices in the name of progressivism?
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
I think California is world leading on progressivism that doesn't ask anyone to give anything up, or accept any major change, right now.
That's what I mean by symbolically progressive, operationally conservative.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Like, is the point that California liberals are actually *worse* at making sacrifices in the name of progressivism than others are -- or are they simply *better, but not as much better as they fancy themselves to be* ?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What's the consensus among my wonky urbanist friends on whether Manhattan is unusually bad at garbage collection?
I used to assume "yes" (having lived there) but I can't actually find a city with comparable size & density that seems to be doing better than Manhattan
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(The comparison is complicated of course by the fact that cities with comparable size & density to Manhattan are much poorer)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... actually maybe I should be comparing to the downtown districts of other rich cities. e.g. Tokyo is only 1/4 as dense as Manhattan, but *downtown* Toyko is probably comparable to Manhattan. So if they're doing much better at trash collection, that's damning for Manhattan.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So, uh... how weirded out should I be that a random password generator just spat out the following suggested password:
" muslim-hijack-armenia-wee "
??? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you tell people you like to put a couple Tbsps of heavy cream in your coffee, you sound indulgent... yet it's the same # of calories as a skim latte, which nobody blinks at (and IMO tastes a lot better)
-
Julia Galef reposted
Eliezer Yudkowsky ⏹️
@ESYudkowsky
It has only *just* now occurred to me that, in many businesses, the people who decide how many tellers or cashiers or call-takers to send out / hire, may not realize this fact. Like they literally might not know how queuing works.
Alexander Kruel
@XiXiDu
"The maths of queuing are absolutely brutal and counter-intuitive." www.johndcook.com/blog/2008/10/21/what-happens-when-you-a…
-
Julia Galef reposted
orthonormal
@renormalized
Real life isn't Econ 101. However:
I can trust someone who can explain the Econ 101 analysis when they go on to say "and here's why that doesn't apply here".
I can't trust someone who can't, or won't, explain the Econ 101 analysis at all. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I’ve been happy to see so many people I follow condemn the unfair firings of both (1) Will Wilkinson and (2) Nathan Robinson, even though they (the people I follow) have strong ideological disagreements with both men. Yay intellectual consistency!
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(I mean, I’m not surprised, since the people I follow are strongly selected for intellectual consistency. But still, happy to see it confirmed.)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Does anyone else find that, when you're anxious or depressed about something, explicitly TRYING to reassure yourself (e.g. "It'll be fine...") doesn't work as well as simply asking yourself, "Okay, what is my honest best prediction about what is true / what will happen?"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It feels like "trying to reassure myself" fails because I simply discount what I tell myself, in the same way I discount the opinion of another person who I know is just trying to say reassuring things to me regardless of the truth
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting thread on how people become cult leaders
Kaj Sotala
@xuenay
It's not just that the cultists are getting "brainwashed" by their leader; it's also that the leader is getting brainwashed _by their cultists_ to take the role that they want the leader to take.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
LOL at this kid responding to one of his critics 😄
(From the Youtube comments on a community theater production of something called "Tarzan, the stage musical" www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2GOweJMK04&lc)Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The only comment on the post was from the screenwriter himself, who said: "Hey, I wrote this movie! I came here hoping I could answer some of your questions about it... but I realized I have no idea what the answers are, sorry"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
...Which I found so endearing I friended him on FB. He was delighted someone had watched his movie and we still chat about Snowglobe every couple of years around Christmas time :)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Something I’d love to read: A list of the biggest advances in all sorts of random industries in the last 40 years. Like: Trucking. Forestry. Fast food. Shoe manufacturing. etc.
What are the main innovations (to physical tech, or to processes) each industry has seen since 1980? -
Julia Galef reposted
Saloni
@salonium
⚡ Hyped to announce a new issue of Works in Progress! A magazine co-founded by myself, @s8mb, @bswud, @ns_whit in August
Feat. writing on progress & the best ideas you haven't heard of – this issue puts a spotlight on the state of modern science worksinprogress.co (1/
🧵) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Thanks for the input yesterday on quote tweets!
My main takeaway -- aside from “don’t be a jerk / don’t just preach to the choir”, which I was already trying to practice -- is that I should maybe do something like the following (cont.)...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I see lots of people complaining about quote-tweets, but I'm not sure I 100% get when/why they're bad?
What should you do if you want to make a point like, "Here is a prominent, or commonly-held, view that I think is wrong, and here's why..."
?Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(If my example of someone saying X comes from a person with few followers, then I’d go for a screenshot instead of a quote tweet, to protect them)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Oh, another reason to have real examples of the argument I'm criticizing (aside from proving it's not a straw man I invented) is that when I don't, I get replies like:
"People who say X are just saying that ___"
... and I know that's wrong bc it doesn't fit the examples I've seen -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It's pretty hard to get me interested in sports, but my brother @JesseGalef's analysis of football through a *game design* lens is a rare exception!
jessegalef.com/2021/02/05/things-nerds-can-appreciate-abo…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... actually, @JesseGalef's post makes me wish someone would do an analysis comparing different sports on different dimensions of good game design -- e.g., how good are the catch-up mechanics in football vs. soccer vs. basketball...?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One thing I admire about @eschwitz is that he actually does adversarial collaborations -- i.e. working with someone else you disagree with about H, to test H
He just wrote a nice post with some lessons on how to make adversarial collaborations go better: schwitzsplinters.blogspot.com/2021/02/adversarial-collabo… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I see lots of people complaining about quote-tweets, but I'm not sure I 100% get when/why they're bad?
What should you do if you want to make a point like, "Here is a prominent, or commonly-held, view that I think is wrong, and here's why..."
?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Maybe you might say "Well, you should just comment on the person's tweet, if you want to disagree with it"
...but what I generally want is to spark a discussion with *my* followers (who I find much more reasonable than average!), not their followers -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love this photo by u/Maxsposure, taken in San Francisco.
www.reddit.com/r/sanfrancisco/comments/l9gay8/one_of_my_f… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Another entry in the "If you thought I was naturally smart" files:
Once when I was little, I couldn't reach a shelf, so I got a stool to stand on. Still couldn't reach.
So I got a 2nd stool, put it NEXT TO the 1st, & got back on the 1st stool. Baffled that I still couldn't reach.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When I was a little kid and refused to brush my teeth, my dad’s trick was to walk away saying, “Fine, I’ll just go brush your teeth without you,” which made me run after him shrieking “No! Don’t do that!”
… just in case anyone thought I was naturally smart or anything
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
These stories put me in mind of Charles Babbage's comment (about someone asking him "If you put the wrong figures into the calculator, will the right answers come out?"):
"I am not able rightly to apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question" -
Julia Galef reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
If you're looking for some weird aesthetic exploration to fight off the COVID boredom blues, can I recommend: avant-garde perfume. No, really. First:
1. Not all perfume is cloying mall crap. There's world of indie, experimental weird-ass perfume.
2. It's cheap.
Thread: -
Julia Galef reposted
Steven Kaas
@stevenkaas
You are not the king of your brain. You are the creepy guy standing next to the king going "a most judicious choice, sire".
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some cleverly-named streets I spotted in McClean, VA:
Macbeth St. ends when Birnam Wood comes to Dunsinane...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... Ha, and nearby there's "Agin Ct."
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
By popular request, my latest podcast guest is Matt Yglesias (@mattyglesias)! Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-251-the-case-f…
I had a blast with this one. Some highlights:
1. Matt talking about how he is trying to be a better rationalist (be still my heart!) ...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2. I got at least a partial answer to a puzzle that's bugged me for a while: Why hasn't the US boosted high-skill immigration, given that it would be really beneficial to the country, AND is a broadly popular policy?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
3. Matt & I reflect on why we both supported the Iraq War, and where our reasoning processes failed. We talk about updates both to (1) our views of foreign policy experts, and (2) our views about how to think, in general
-
Julia Galef reposted
Steven Kaas
@stevenkaas
Psychology should study the future threat of robots spreading across the planet. Not to understand them, but so they'll fail to replicate.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You gotta click the image to see the drawing the kid did
-
Julia Galef reposted
Chana
@ChanaMessinger
Underdiscussed harm of grade inflation is that assessments become asymmetrically something that can crush you rather than help you, making each of them more painful and stressful.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Been watching the TV show Shetland, and from now on I am erasing the word "lying" from my vocabulary, and replacing it with the far superior "telling porky pies"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... or "telling porkies," for short
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Playing Zork.
I was stuck in a room with a few objects including a bucket. Couldn't get out. Tried every combination of VERB + OBJECT I could think of. Nothing worked.
Finally in frustration I typed "KICK BUCKET"
The game replied "Okay, if you insist" and to my shock, I died. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Spotted this street sign driving through North Carolina w/@lukeprog
ME: “Wait, did we have a president Davis?”
LUKE: “I don’t think so? The only Davis that comes to mind is Jefferson Davis, but he wasn’t…”
[pause]
BOTH OF US: “… Oh no” -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
These Malaysian cakes (kek lapis Sarawak) reveal intricate kaleidoscopic patterns when you slice into them
mymodernmet.com/kek-lapis-sarawak/
Now if only these were made with almond paste, like seven layer cookies, they would be perfect 💯 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
TIL that President John Tyler -- born in 1790! -- still has one living grandson, Harrison Ruffin Tyler (age 93) 🤯
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
In-person debates are very overrated (in some circles).
One reason is because you can "win" a debate through slick arguing tactics (e.g. the Gish gallop).
But another is that, in person, when one side cites evidence, the other side can't scrutinize that evidence on the spot.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Which of course incentivizes people to, e.g. cite papers that make strong claims but actually have terrible methodology. And all the other side can do is say "Well, I suspect if I read that paper it would not be as strong evidence as you claim, but I can't prove that now"
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You had me at "A taxonomy" 😍
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
On my list of "maps I wish existed": For a given city, streets color-coded by how pleasant they are to walk down
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A taxonomy of "60 different kinds of urbanism": www.uc.edu/cdc/urban_database/urban_imaging/60_Newest_Urb…
I would love it if more articles were just taxonomies of a field / movement / ideology / etc.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(admittedly, some of the "urbanisms" in his taxonomy seem kinda weak -- like, a phrase used by one author, rather than a whole sub-field -- but it's still fun to see them all listed)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When I was a little kid and refused to brush my teeth, my dad’s trick was to walk away saying, “Fine, I’ll just go brush your teeth without you,” which made me run after him shrieking “No! Don’t do that!”
… just in case anyone thought I was naturally smart or anything -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One frustrating thing about the "cancel culture" debate is that it's typically framed as being about "Should people get cancelled for having bad views?" but the real disagreement is more about which views are bad
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Curious about how @everytstudies would analyze this disagreement, if you're free :)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Has anyone ever studied the strong correlation between
(1) Having crank theories about science, and
(2) Writing in lots of different fonts & colors at once?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(This isn't just a joke, I really think this is an interesting puzzle that probably says something about how brains work)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Random thing I'm wondering about today:
What would be the best possible way of simulating, for a human, what it's like to have vision like a hawk's?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My current idea: A wide-screen hi-res monitor showing video of a landscape, that detects where your gaze is falling and automatically zooms in on that area
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When I CTRL-click a link to read it later, I always end up wondering *why* my past self wanted me to read it -- what was the context??
I wish I could, e.g., highlight the context around a link, then CTRL-click the link, & the context would get added to the new tab like a comment -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I don't know what it is about eel scientists, but they do have a way with a pithy quote
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1/ A reddit thread asking "What's a surreal experience you've had?" reminded me of one of mine, from a few years ago:
I was dining in a busy, bustling restaurant with friends. I left to go to the bathroom, which was in a back hallway...Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
ANSWER: Yes, lots of you were very close! Unbeknownst to me there was a defunct store next door with the exact same dimensions. Restaurant owners had bought it & were in the process of renovating to make it match theirs - same paint, furniture, etc. - so they could expand
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
That's why it looked identical to my restaurant (only abandoned)
I had turned left instead of right when leaving the bathroom.
Part of why it was surreal for me was that I hadn't realized there WAS anything next door -- I thought I knew that block like the back of my hand -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Why you should make bets with your kids: www.jefftk.com/p/bets-bonds-and-kindergarteners
I like this approach to parenting because it both (1) encourages accuracy-oriented thinking, and (2) respects your kids' autonomy -
Julia Galef reposted
Keith Frankish
@keithfrankish
Gigapixel image of Vermeer's Girl with Pearl Earring. Zoom in to see astonishingly fine detail of the paintwork. www.micro-pano.com/pearl/index.html
-
Julia Galef reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
If someone asks you how much the government can safely borrow, the correct answer is: "No one knows."
Here's why no one knows, and why almost no one is even trying to answer the question:
noahpinion.substack.com/p/no-one-knows-how-much-the-gover… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Catching up on Episode 1 of @devonzuegel's delightful podcast "Order Without Design," in which she interviews Marie-Agnes & Alain Bertaud about urbanism, and I love the questions she asks.
For example: "What's your process for understanding a new city?"
devonzuegel.com/post/owd-1-tea-time-in-yemen -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love garlic but hate peeling & mincing it. So now I:
1) Buy a big bag of pre-peeled garlic cloves
2) Puree them all at once with my immersion blender
3) Freeze the garlic puree (flattened out, in a ziploc)
4) Break off a piece of garlic puree whenever I need it for a recipe
Eliezer Yudkowsky ⏹️
@ESYudkowsky
Name an uncommon life-tweak, making a small but noticeable difference, that you've used within the past 24 hours.
Example: I feel much drier if I use 2 shower towels, one main bath sheet that ends up damp, and a smaller towel that I use only after I'm almost fully dry.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I have a similar Ziploc of frozen garlic + ginger puree, which comes in very handy for curries
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Very happy @slatestarcodex is back!
astralcodexten.substack.com -
Julia Galef reposted
Alan Cole
@AlanMCole
My answer:
I was surprised by the public placing a much, much lower value on lives than they usually seem to. Normally they're all about preserving and extending life even at very high costs.
Lately they have been extremely open to balancing that with other priorities. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My mom's idea for a "Washington, D.C." snow globe:
When you shake it, a few measly flakes of snow drift down, and a sign pops up saying "CLOSED FOR SNOWSTORM" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Do you ever judge someone negatively for posting about X but not Y? Examples:
- "I notice you post a lot about intellectual dishonesty from conservatives but never from liberals..."
- "I notice you post a lot about protestors being violent but never about cops being violent..."
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I've been trying to think about when this kind of criticism is fair, if ever.
On the one hand, I do think that someone's choice of what to focus on tends to reveal something about their priorities. But on the other hand...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... there are lots of reasons someone might not post about a topic Y even if they think it's true and important -- e.g., maybe they think their audience already agrees with Y, or maybe they don't feel like they have anything original to say about Y.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
TIL Mozart was a catboy
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I find a lot of the discourse on “censorship” by tech companies frustratingly simplistic.
So for my latest @rspodcast episode I turned to @normative, expert on tech & civil liberties at Cato Institute, for a more nuanced conversation.
Audio + transcript: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-250-whats-wron…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One reason I get more nervous about bans/censorship than others do -- even when the thing being banned is obviously bad -- is that I keep thinking "OK, but what is the underlying principle that produced this specific ban?" and I'm not as confident I would be ok with the principle
-
Julia Galef reposted
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
Regrifting (noun): When you need a presidential pardon for selling your boss' presidential pardons for $2,000,000
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Found a cluster of venus flytraps in the wild
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Getting one to snap shut:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
To my surprise the natural habitat of venus flytraps is tiny -- they only grow within ~60 miles of Wilmington, North Carolina
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I've listened to this many times now and it still gives me goosebumps
Even cooler to know that it's a collaboration between strangers -- each successive person adding their voice to the previous track -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a great list of some of the "principles of good disagreement" I try to follow in my interviews! It makes me happy to see people picking up on them 😊
Brendan Miller
@brenkjm
I love @juliagalef 's interviewing style on @Rspodcast. Here's some of what I'm learning from listening to her in action:
1. Learn to present the best case for the position you disagree with - "Steel-man" vs "straw man"
... -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I generally don't tweet about current events unless I feel like I have something interesting or original to say about them
But today all I can think is "WTF?!??" and I still want to say it -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Add me to the long list of people impressed with @coldxman's thinking!
For the latest @rspodcast episode we had a great conversation about why he supports a "colorblind" approach to race, and why many people disagree with him:
Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-249-the-case-f…Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Another example of Coleman being charitable to people who disagree with him:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm also very curious to hear listeners' thoughts on the question I posed to Coleman near the end of the episode:
What criteria should determine if something is racist/offensive?
We both consider this a hard problem. My question: -
Julia Galef reposted
Stuart Ritchie
@StuartJRitchie
I meant to do this yesterday: a thread of my favourite stuff I wrote on COVID in 2020!
1) Written in a flash of rage at psychologists (and psychology writers) who told everyone they were worrying far too much, even as the deaths ticked into the thousands: unherd.com/2020/03/dont-trust-the-psychologists-on-corona… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My family's annual gingerbread house (well, chapel, this time). Happy New Year, everyone! 🍾
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kaj Sotala
@xuenay
At a water plant in Poland, there are eight clams with sensors attached to their shells. If the clams close because they don’t like the taste of the water, the city’s supply is automatically shut off.
www.boredpanda.com/clams-measure-water-quality-poland-fat… -
Julia Galef reposted
Matt Levine
@matt_levine
i hope if teachers still make kids diagram sentences they make them diagram this one www.nytimes.com/2020/12/30/style/hilaria-baldwin-intervie…
-
Julia Galef reposted
Stuart Ritchie
@StuartJRitchie
A related (and underdiscussed) lesson is that some people just absolutely love conformity. What else could explain all the doctors/academics getting behind the 100% definite "masks don't work" stuff in Feb/March? They're not daft. They knew there wasn't a good case for that.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
What insights has urbanism as a field produced, about how cities work / how to do good urban planning?
(I'm looking for insights that are supported by strong evidence. A lot of urbanist insights are intuitively plausible but only backed up by, like, a couple case studies.) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I enthusiastically greeted Julia Stiles at my college dorm vending machine late one night -- because I had mistaken her for a classmate of mine. She of course thought I was being a starstruck fan, & she looked uncomfortable and walked off. I realized who she was a minute later.
elizabeth lowder gallo
@getlowder
quote tweet this with a mundane experience you’ve shared with someone who is more famous than you
(but you obviously have enough chill to leave it out of your twitter bio) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
As someone who talks a lot about rationality, you might expect I'd be very inclined to judge people's behavior as "irrational"
But in fact I think I'm much less inclined than most people are to call a particular behavior "irrational"...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Because in any given case, there are so many other things that could be going on besides irrationality -- e.g. a person could have different goals than I realize, or different priors, or different information than I have
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So I believe both
(1) irrationality is very common, and
(2) In any given case, it's hard to say with confidence that a person is being irrational (i.e., sometimes it's pretty clear, but not often) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It's so much harder to criticize someone online when you've already met them IRL.
It reminds me of this scene from Alice Through the Looking Glass, where they introduce the foods & then forbid her from eating because "it isn't etiquette to cut anyone you've been introduced to"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Heh, I realize now that this sounds like I'm saying "Wouldn't it be nice if everyone stopped criticizing everyone else?"
But I actually meant: If someone is being, e.g., intellectually dishonest, I might want to call them out for it, but can't if I've been introduced to them IRL -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Just fondly remembering an exhibit I saw years ago at the Guggenheim:
The theme was "1900" and it was just artwork that had been displayed in galleries in that year. Some works by artists who are now famous, others by artists who have since fallen into obscurity...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And because the famous and not-famous paintings were all jumbled together, you weren't anchored on "Oh of course this painting is Excellent because it is by a Great Artist" the way you are in a typical exhibit
So it was like experiencing history forward, not backwards -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It unnerves me a bit the way idly scrolling Twitter can give me the impression "Wow, everyone's saying X"
& then I realize, wait, those are all retweets from one guy I follow who really cares about X
yet still that doesn't stop my brain from kinda-updating "Everyone's saying X"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
To clarify, A is what's actually happening and B is what my brain intuitively *thinks* is happening:
A) Today, one person I follow shared 20 examples he collected of people saying X
B) Today, 20 different people I follow said X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
As a side note, I am realizing it's probably bad that my "To clarify..." tweets usually involve me defining additional variables :-/
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"Anyone can say 'we should be more welcoming to feminists!' But only someone who actually cares will say 'here are specific valuable ideas which I have worked to make accessible to you'."
-@KelseyTuoc (in 2015) on "translation" as a hard-to-fake signal:
theunitofcaring.tumblr.com/post/126528545931/translation -
Julia Galef reposted
Spencer Greenberg 🔍
@SpencrGreenberg
When people learn just a little about game theory, decision theory, economics, or even evolutionary theory, they sometimes come away thinking that altruism is somehow “irrational,” or that rational agents are selfish. Here are reasons why altruism is often rational:
[thread] -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
UPDATE: I found it!!!
The comic was called "Headcase" and it was by Sam Chivers.
Wow, that is a weird relief. I've been trying to find this thing intermittently for like a decade now...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Random query: I read a webcomic ~15 years ago that I've been unable to find since, even with my best google-fu
It involved a robot living a bleak life as a working stiff. At the end he cracked open his "skull" and there was a small dying creature inside
Anyone recognize this??
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The comic doesn't appear to be online anymore, but I was able to find one page.
(My memory was pretty accurate! Wordless, art resembling Moebius, robot looks like a crash-test dummy)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Credit for helping me find it goes to @bilcorry who mentioned the old-school comics website zark.com
I got the idea that they probably had a list of links, from around the right year (2005) -- and they did! So I skimmed it until I found something that rang a bell -
Julia Galef reposted
Jason Fagone
@jfagone
Fox News: We will broadcast any false claim on air to millions of people until we get sued.
Quanta Magazine: We were off by 5 one-billionths in reporting a measurement of a physical quantity. We regret the error. www.quantamagazine.org/physicists-measure-the-magic-fine-… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
TIL that the American Sign Language way to sign "pasteurized milk" is this:
Make the sign for "milk," while moving your hand... past your eyes -
Julia Galef reposted
Liam Bright
@lastpositivist
I made a flow chart to help people decide what sort of philosopher they want to be. Start at the blue box, end at one of the red boxes. Hope it helps!
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Just remembered how my brother @jessegalef delightfully organized his books according to Harry Potter houses
(or rather, the steel-manned, rationality-focused versions of Harry Potter houses)
jessegalef.com/2013/03/18/what-would-a-rational-gryffindo…Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The SLYTHERIN shelf is of course full of books on persuasion, rhetoric, and political machinations
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And the HUFFLEPUFF shelf features books on productivity, happiness, and the game theory of cooperation
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Interesting post from @lukeprog pointing out some ways it's harder / more frustrating being a classical music fan than a rock music fan.
Some key points (thread):
lukemuehlhauser.com/different-challenges-faced-by-consume…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1) Availability: Classical music pieces are often not recorded for *years* after they're performed, so you read a glowing review and then can't actually find a way to listen to the piece
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
2) Genres: Rock has hundreds of genres -- "e.g. not just 'metal' but 'death metal' and even 'technical death metal...'"
whereas for classical and jazz, "Only a couple dozen genre tags are in wide use, so it can be very hard to know from genre tags what a piece will sound like" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Random query: I read a webcomic ~15 years ago that I've been unable to find since, even with my best google-fu
It involved a robot living a bleak life as a working stiff. At the end he cracked open his "skull" and there was a small dying creature inside
Anyone recognize this??Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And, sorry, it wasn't a "webcomic" in the sense of a long-running thing. It was a self-contained story, maybe 15 pages long?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The art looked a little like this (but this is way too recent):
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Are Democrats being irrational?
My latest podcast episode features political data scientist @davidshor with a characteristically brilliant dissection of that topic - are Dems making unforced errors in campaigning, and if so why?
Audio + full transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-248-are-democr…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I swear, talking to David is like having a complex causal graph materialize in my mind
-
Julia Galef reposted
Nick Clark
@Clark5Nick
Love that. He’s one of mine from a few years ago.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
New video! In 1860, Charles Darwin wrote a letter to another scientist who had criticized his book, On the Origin of Species. Here I explain why I love this letter so much, and what it tells us about Darwin: youtu.be/KOZnI0v87RA
-
Julia Galef reposted
Gurwinder
@G_S_Bhogal
“The Flying Train.” A grand tour of life around the Wupper river, Germany, 1902. Old footage taken from a suspension railway, upscaled using neural networks.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EQs5VxNPhzkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I like roundup posts like this one by @Noahpinion -- i.e., when someone notices a pattern/trend of writers exploring the same topic, & gives you a tour of their different takes
Also, exciting futuristic vistas!!
noahpinion.substack.com/p/techno-optimism-roundup -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Since my podcast w/Michael Sandel I've been thinking about how to adjudicate between people like him, who take sanctity into account in morality (e.g. "it is immoral to violate your own human dignity") & people like me, who do not
My thoughts on FB: www.facebook.com/julia.galef/posts/10105591729750552
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A good comment thread ensued.
I should point out that after writing this, I realized my actual beef was specifically with people who say "I believe X violates your human dignity, therefore you should be prohibited from doing X even if you want to do it"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(it is to those people my thought experiment, in the screenshot, is directed)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Maybe a dumb question, but it's been awhile since 9th grade physics:
When my parents visited me in SF, I helped my mom up the hills by pushing her - jokingly, but she said it helped.
Yet I also felt like hills were easier for *me* when I was pushing her!
My q: Is this possible??
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I asked a couple people and their off-the-cuff answers were both "That doesn't seem possible"
Like, shouldn't there be some kind of conservation of work law in play or something?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: Just want to clarify that I did not in fact push my mom off a cliff
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... OK, this was very helpful! After reading replies I now think the effect came from (1) using different muscles (quads > hamstrings?), and (2) shifting my center of gravity forward (I was basically leaning forward, pushing off against the ground)
Thanks everyone! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Katja captures a lot of why quantitative methods are so *heartwarming* to me.
"there are these slow-accreting tragedies... And where this is for lack of good algorithms, it feels like it is for absolutely nothing. Just unforced error."
worldspiritsockpuppet.com/2020/12/12/heartwarming-quantit… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I am very impressed with this person's ability to unconsciously simulate Werner Herzog
Also now I really want to watch this documentary
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... oh and if you haven't seen this yet, you need to hear Herzog talk about why he hates chickens:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=QhMo4WlBmGM
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
UPDATE: Likely inspired by this video, last night I dreamed that I followed Herzog's advice and stared into the eyes of a chicken -- except contra Herzog, the chicken stared back at me with love and we hung out happily for a while 🥰
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... I've been thinking wistfully about my dream chicken-friend all day
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This brilliantly-designed billboard for "Dracula" has a bunch of stakes in it, which gradually -- as the sun goes down -- cast a shadow in the shape of Dracula himself
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
@flexport shipped more than 100million units of PPE in a disaster response effort that started Jan 27th, when Silicon Valley was being *mocked* for taking covid seriously. @patrickc and Stripe helped launch FastGrants, which got scientists money to study covid w/ 48 hr turnaround
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kaj Sotala
@xuenay
Great post: To listen well, get curious about the other person's problem, and try to understand it and its relation to the person in as much detail as possible.
www.lesswrong.com/posts/4K5pJnKBGkqqTbyxx/to-listen-well-… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Feature idea for recipe sites:
When someone is about to review a recipe, they must first check a box indicating their answer to: "Did you (1) follow the recipe as written, or (2) make some changes?"
Then when you're reading reviews, you could filter by that criterion -
Julia Galef reposted
New Liberals
@CNLiberalism
The reply guys who get mad at me, illustrated
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Another way to explain my point last night:
Suppose you give your class a test you think is reasonable, but most people flunk. You would update: "I guess these problems aren't as easy as I thought, for students at this level"
My point: Same thing holds for tests of character.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If 90% of the world fails your test of willpower, compassion, self-awareness, altruism, etc., you should update: "I guess this is actually not an easy thing for humans to do"
-- even if it feels to you like it "should" be easy
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Of course that doesn't mean we shouldn't keep pushing people (& ourselves) to be better. But we should also be updating on the evidence about what comes naturally to humans and what doesn't.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(My point was also about the proper use of labels like "lazy," "weak," "selfish," etc. - I don't think it's that useful to define them in such a way that they apply to 90% of the population. But that's a judgment call about the most useful way to define words; you could disagree)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One underappreciated difference in worldviews:
When judging other people's virtue (or lack thereof), do you grade on a curve?
For me it's "yes" - I think it's almost-by-definition impossible for 90% of the population to be horrible peoplePost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Or, hmm, I guess it might be more accurate to say it's a disagreement about the proper use of judgmental categories like "lazy" or "selfish" or "despicable"
- I'm saying it doesn't make sense to me to use those words for someone unless they're well below the 50th percentile...
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... whereas the way I see some people using those words, it seems like they've got an implicit benchmark in their mind, representing how humans *should* be, and they're judging people relative to that. Rather than the median.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you listened to my podcast w/Michael Sandel, you know we have very different views on whether markets are "degrading"
One thing I didn't mention to him: This bit in his book cracked me up -- because I remember my friends & I found this aspect of Moneyball SO HEARTWARMING <3
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(Passage from Sandel's "What Money Can't Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets")
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
There are some great fusion cuisines like Indian-Chinese, and Peruvian-Japanese, which resulted naturally from proximity or immigration.
But I feel like we've only scratched the surface of amazing cuisine mashups possible!
What cuisines would pair well together? Some proposals:Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
#2: ETHIOPIAN + INDIAN: All of those flavorful Ethiopian dishes like Doro Wat or spiced red / yellow lentils are great with injera -- but picture them instead on basmati, or stuffed into a paratha, with chutneys on the side
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
#3: TURKISH + SZECHUAN: The creamy, cooling element of yogurt is central to Turkish cuisine and would go so well with the numbing heat of Szechuan. As would Turkey's grilled meats. Imagine a pita stuffed with lamb kebab, yogurt, chili oil, and Chinese celery
-
Julia Galef reposted
Kaj Sotala
@xuenay
You might have heard of the Bystander Effect, but have you heard of the Knows Psychologists To Be Liars Effect?
(source: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022103120303930 ) -
Julia Galef reposted
Luke Muehlhauser
@lukeprog
I'm 35yo, and IIRC @mattyglesias' newsletter is the first publication of any kind I've paid to subscribe to. Consistently great so far. slowboring.com
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
If you've been thinking "Why doesn't Julia ever share her thoughts on consensual cannibalism" then today's your lucky day
In my new @rspodcast I argue w/philosopher Michael Sandel about that, + whether "human dignity" is real & his critique of meritocracy
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-247-the-moral-…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: Just a reminder that I'm still doing full transcripts for each episode! static1.1.sqspcdn.com/static/f/468275/28380496/1607401570…
-
Julia Galef reposted
Eric Nakagawa (Actually a 🍕)
@ericnakagawa
Website idea: you input the year you graduated high school and the website generates a list of outdated “facts” and concepts you were taught in school that have since been disproven.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
ABC News
@ABC
📸: William Shakespeare, 81, becomes the second person to receive the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine, at University Hospital Coventry, England. abcn.ws/36Sq4GW
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
OK, who had "inspires a rom-com" in their "Nick Bostrom's effect on world events" bingo cards?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
From Alyssa Vance www.facebook.com/alyssamvance/posts/10224611536745554
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
EDIT: The creator of this meme is actually @KellerScholl
-
Julia Galef reposted
Alex Naka
@gottapatchemall
Looking at some old code and was initially puzzled by a variable named 'feet'
I have now worked out that this was at one point called 'legend_handles', which then became 'leg_hands', which then became 'feet'
sometimes I truly hate my past self -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Randomly stumbled across this amazing dance from 1937 to Duke Ellington's "East St. Louis Toodle-Oo"
The choreographer is the guy in the suit - Roger Pryor Dodge. I wish I could find more film of him but this seems to be the only one
youtu.be/oVSm_dX8Jqs -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Good advice for fiction writers: if your character is supposed to be an expert in some field, they'll probably have Strong Opinions about something seemingly minute
From keuhkopussirotta.tumblr.com/post/633030489336414208/hey-t… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The great irony about my addiction to Reddit is that it came about after someone wrote me, years ago: "Your talks about rationality inspired me to stop wasting hours on Reddit!"
and I thought "Huh, this Reddit thing sounds interesting, I should check it out"
...and here we are -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of my favorite Weird Subreddits is r/backrooms
It's a group of people committed to the premise that they're trapped in a world called "The Backrooms" consisting of long hallways and dimly lit rooms that might(?) go on forever, and they're desperately trying to find a way outPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"I'm still going down, it's been hours since I've seen a door and the light isn't getting closer"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
People also chime in with advice and compare notes with their fellow travelers:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
An underrated quality in a friend: The ability to help you reason about your problems, *conditional on* your values and priors, even if they disagree with those values / priors
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Driving through Rhode Island last month, it was interesting to see these signs dotting the highways. Apparently they're the result of the RI government pre-committing to post their success (or failure) at infrastructure planning.
Kind of a cool accountability mechanism! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is such a fun thread, if you enjoy well-curated book pairings as much as I do:
David R. MacIver
@DRMacIver
One like = one* interesting book pairing
* with an option to give up any time after 100 tweets -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Congrats to @salonium for a well-deserved spot in the "smartest minds of 2020" list!
My podcast with Saloni last year was one of my favorites, featuring an unusually clarifying conversation about gender & the brain:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-239-saloni-dattani-…
Saloni
@salonium
Genuinely speechless at being included in WIRED's "smartest minds of 2020" list. Thank you @patrickc! 🥺
www.wired.co.uk/article/change-everything-smart-list-2021 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A food puzzle I noticed -- how can both of the following be true?
(1) To make homemade yogurt: Leave it out in a hot room (>90 degrees) for a day
(2) Official food safety guidelines on yogurt: If it sits unrefrigerated for more than a couple hours, throw it away
? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a longshot, but can anyone help find a job -- e.g. in intelligence -- for the extremely clever Redditor who deduced the location of the monolith?
He's a construction worker right now, but says he'd love a job where his talents would be useful
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Remember that mysterious monolith found in the Utah desert? Authorities wouldn't reveal its location, but a Redditor managed to locate it on Google Earth. I thought his explanation of *how* he did it was pretty impressive: www.reddit.com/r/geoguessr/comments/jzw628/help_me_find_t…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
UPDATE: It turns out the Extremely Clever Redditor is @tim_slane (kudos, Tim!) and you can reply to him directly with ideas. Thanks everyone!
Tim Slane
@EvilBill_wx
Since I already "Outed" myself as "bear__fucker" in a few news articles, I'll join the conversation. I've had many people suggest Bellingcat - however they deal more with object identification. I'm also not as familiar with identifying European landscapes and I am in the US.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
"The Europeans bring disease! What can we do?"
"Don't worry; I'm hosting a celebratory feast."
"..."
"A tradition will grow. In 400 years, during a deadly pandemic they will feel *compelled* to gather, causing untold suffering!
... It's the long game. Sorry about your wife." -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some impressive epistemic hygiene from @kdrum here
(From a post on how people shouldn't be drawing conclusions from our unreliable exit poll data)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Link to the full post: www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2020/11/please-stop-lookin…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I have a Doppler joke, but I always turn red after I tell it because the humor is rather blue
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Remember that mysterious monolith found in the Utah desert? Authorities wouldn't reveal its location, but a Redditor managed to locate it on Google Earth. I thought his explanation of *how* he did it was pretty impressive: www.reddit.com/r/geoguessr/comments/jzw628/help_me_find_t…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Screenshot of his explanation:
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... OK, maybe I shouldn't have shared the location of the mysterious monolith the other day -- which one of my followers went and stole it??
The New York Times
@nytimes
The mysterious metal monolith that was found last week in the Utah desert has vanished. www.nytimes.com/2020/11/28/us/monolith-utah-disappeared.h…
-
Julia Galef reposted
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I have a Gödel joke, but it's
Jordan Ellenberg
@JSEllenberg
I have a Bayesian inference joke but the first three people I told it to didn't laugh and now I'm not so sure it's funny.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Jesse Galef
@JesseGalef
My friend's hosting a "Best Fake Academic Paper Title" contest. Mine:
'Why Won't You Be My Neighbor?' Inherent Racism in Mr. Rogers' Urban Design
Precommitted Human Anthropic Correlation Kludge: The P-HACK Method to Statistical Significance via P-Value Dependent Suicide Pacts -
Julia Galef reposted
Patrick Collison
@patrickc
“When the boy cried wolf, the village committed Type I and Type II errors, in that order” remains the best hypothesis testing mnemonic.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
TREES. YOU'VE INVENTED TREES.
WAY TO GO, TECHBROS
... j/k, this is awesome and I'm delighted @stripe is doing it
www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2020/11/stripe-climat…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Man, it's always harder than I expect to come up with satire that doesn't overlap with people's actual views
x.com/Mario_Gibney/status/1332434340949553152 -
Julia Galef reposted
Devon ☀️
@devonzuegel
What lists do you keep? For example:
- words you like
- unexpected tragedies of the commons
- people to notify when you're traveling to other cities
- people to introduce to each other because you predict they'd hit it off -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm normally kind of lukewarm about photography, but I absolutely love photos like this. What would you call this category? I want to say... "high-concept"
Gurwinder
@G_S_Bhogal
A man feeding swans in the snow. Photo taken from Grunwald bridge, Poland, by Marcin Ryczek.
www.lensculture.com/articles/marcin-ryczek-a-man-feeding-… -
Julia Galef reposted
Rachel McCartney
@RachelMComedy
So was it a boy or a girl
-
Julia Galef reposted
Gordon Mohr ꧁👁️👁️꧂
@gojomo
Recent Events Initially Surprised Me To The Core, But Upon Further Reflection I Realize They Just Prove I've Been Right All Along
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
On the latest @rspodcast episode, I argue with economist & Nobel Laureate Angus Deaton about
(1) What's causing "deaths of despair" and
(2) Is effective altruism a good thing?
Our conversation got... lively :)
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-246-deaths-of-…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... y'know, @meaningness, Angus is a great example of why "Bayesian epistemology" isn't an empty term. A Bayesian wouldn't insist, as Angus does, that "1,000 well-done studies in different contexts, all finding the same result" tells him literally nothing
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
To be clear, I know you've already agreed about that. Not trying to beat a dead horse here. But I thought of you when it happened :)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Stay tuned for my latest podcast episode, coming out today, to find out which Nobel prize-winner told me I was making his hair stand on end
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(1/2)
I once gave a talk & had this conversation with a guy afterwards:
GUY: "What was your talk about? I missed it"
ME: "The anti-vax movement"
GUY: "Cool, glad you're spreading the word"
ME: "Yeah this is a public health crisis"
GUY: "I know! ppl are so gullible"
ME: "I know!"
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(2/2)
... Only after several minutes of conversation in this vein did we discover we were on opposite sides of the issue -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a great example of the wrong way to think about changing minds.
Basically "I monologued about my anti-Trump views to Trump supporters and they didn't immediately abandon him --> Trump supporters are a lost cause"
www.nytimes.com/2020/11/19/opinion/trump-supporters.html -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I used to be baffled by this pattern:
PERSON: [claim]
ME: [explains why claim isn't true]
PERSON: "Oh yeah, you're right"
... later ...
PERSON: [exact same claim again]
But now I think I understand why this happens --
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When I explain why their claim isn't true, they don't feel convinced by my argument, but they also can't think of a good counter-argument on the spot. So they just agree with me. But their belief in [claim] never actually went away.
-
Julia Galef reposted
Owain Evans
@OwainEvans_UK
1/ Why did Wikipedia succeed when 7 similar online encyclopedia projects (mostly started around the same time) all failed? This cool paper investigates and gives surprising answers...
citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.706.577… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is the entirety of the website for Elon Musk's charitable foundation, muskfoundation.org:
-
Julia Galef reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The more I think about it, the more weird it is to subscribe to the following discourse norms:
1. Anybody has a right to raise any question without significant cognitive investigation.
2. All people must put serious thought into answering any raised questions. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I know I don't get points for this, but I made a prediction privately two days ago that this story was exaggerated:
www.wired.com/story/are-covid-patients-gasping-it-isnt-re…Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Worth noting btw that unlike me, @jon_stokes made this prediction publicly:
Jon Stokes
@jon_stokes
I really do not believe this, or stories like it. I think they're ideologically motivated ugliness. I'm from Southwest Louisiana, & my parents still live there. Statistically the Trumpiest place in the country. Also a COVID hotspot. Skeptics there that get it change their tune.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A heuristic that I use: When someone claims that X "happens all the time" -- and when X is convenient to whatever narrative that person believes in -- I have a healthy amount of skepticism
It's just too easy to see one or two examples of X and jump to "X happens all the time" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I wince every time I see someone begin "Genuinely curious..." and then proceed to ask an extremely biased, loaded question
C'mon guys, your fake open-mindedness makes it harder for anyone to credibly signal real open-mindedness
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... actually, asking a loaded question (e.g. "Genuinely curious how you libs can be so gullible") isn't the worst.
The worst is asking a neutral-sounding question & then just arguing with the people who reply, and showing zero interest in understanding their view
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(The latter is what really destroys trust that people who claim to be genuinely curious actually are)
-
Julia Galef reposted
Julian Sanchez
@normative
Here’s a depressing dynamic I’ve seen a bunch the past two weeks:
(1) Crackpot conspiracy claim X is asserted, on the basis of supposed evidence Y.
(2) Y is decisively shown to be wrong.
(3) “OK, we can dismiss the claim that X.”
(4) No, you haven’t PROVEN not-X! It’s 50/50! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Physicist Paul Dirac's wife Manci used to write him long and heartfelt letters.
Here's what he sent back: an itemized list of his responses to the questions she raised
(Source: The Strangest Man, by Graham Farmelo, p 262)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Farmelo reports that although Manci was hurt at first, she eventually decided it was "quite funny"
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Yeah, fans of loan forgiveness act like opponents are just being vindictive.
That makes sense if you see it as a free good that opponents are refusing to let people have.
It doesn't if you see it as a transfer of $ from people who already paid loans ->people who didn't pay
Damon Linker
@DamonLinker
I think Dems are wildly underestimating the intensity of anger college loan cancelation is going to provoke. Those with college debt will be thrilled, of course. But lots and lots of people who didn't go to college or who worked to pay off their debts? Gonna be bad.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
See the original tweet's comments for lots of examples, e.g.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
And maybe loan forgiveness is still justified on utilitarian grounds, overall? My point here is simply that I think it's understandable why it violates people's sense of fairness.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Over on @Pairagraph I'm having a friendly debate with @EconTalker about whether surveys asking parents / non-parents how happy they are could help other people decide whether to have kids -- I say "yes," he says "no."
The conversation so far: www.pairagraph.com/dialogue/6facba6cd4744d0584385842c7f9b… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"I struggle with perfectionism. Well, not so much “struggle with” — I’m f*cking great at it. It comes naturally."
- My brother @JesseGalef wrote a thing about perfectionism, full of insightful graphs and helpful advice: jessegalef.com/2020/08/09/a-pretty-good-mathematical-mode… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Me in a conversation, trying to clarify my reference to (Bayesian) priors:
"Oh sorry, I don't mean 'priors' as in 'prior convictions' -- well... actually, I guess I do mean that."
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(Sorry guys, but I have a whole year's worth of dumb Bayes jokes to catch up on)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I just realized where the "Women don't go for nice guys" trope might come from:
If women, when rejecting a guy, tend to try and soften the blow by saying "You're such a nice guy, but..."
Then we end up in a situation where... (cont.)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... the category "Guys who have been told they're nice" is heavily skewed towards guys who aren't desirable to many women -- EVEN IF niceness and desirability-to-women are positively correlated in general.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One point I didn't get around to making in my latest podcast on Boomers is that I've noticed some... creative accounting in the "Boomers wrecked the country" critiques. (Not talking about my guests specifically. This is a general phenomenon.)
For example (cont.):
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Clinton's bad policy choices are blamed on Boomers because Clinton is a Boomer;
Reagan's bad policy choices are also blamed on Boomers because they voted for him (even though he himself is not a Boomer)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Or to take an example from Gibney's "Generation of Sociopaths":
Test scores went down when Boomers were in HS -> Boomers are undisciplined
Test scores stagnated when later generations were in HS -> Boomers messed up education policy -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Anyone know why Biden's odds on Predictit have basically not changed since Nov. 4th? I get that prediction markets have systematic biases in one direction or another... but how can they not have *updated on* the election being called for Biden?
www.predictit.org/markets/detail/3698 -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Been gone all year, anything happen in 2020?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... Guys it's honestly warming my heart to read the welcome back replies! I hadn't expected my absence to be all that noticeable; seeing people say they missed me is a touching surprise. And I'm sorry to have caused anyone alarm!
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I see a number of people want to know why I was offline so long. It's a totally understandable question, but I'd rather not talk about it at the moment. Just... dealing with some stuff this year.
Happy to be back, though! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Happy to announce the return of Rationally Speaking!
I'm kicking things off with an episode on whether it's fair to blame Boomers for the economic difficulties of Millennials (stagnant wages, student loans, etc):
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/episode-245-are-boomer…
Featuring three excellent guests (cont.):Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(2) Joseph C. Sternberg, columnist for the WSJ and author of "The Theft of a Decade: How Baby Boomers Stole Millennials' Economic Future,"
www.amazon.com/Theft-Decade-Boomers-Millennials-Economic/…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
and (3) Patrick Fisher, political scientist at Seton Hall University and author of Demographic Gaps in American Political Behavior.
www.amazon.com/Demographic-Gaps-American-Political-Behavi… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Do I have any antifa-adjacent, or antifa-sympathetic followers?
If so, I'm curious whether you would endorse this explanation of (one reason for) your skepticism of liberals?
From theunitofcaring.tumblr.com/post/159880144956/im-boggling-… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
It was interesting to wrestle with my views on open borders, with @bryan_caplan on the latest episode of Rationally Speaking - episode sparked by his & @ZachWeiner's new NYT bestseller, "Open Borders."
Audio & transcript: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-243-bryan-caplan-on…
To summarize my hesitations... 1/Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Needless to say, Bryan has interesting answers to all of these! Check out the podcast / transcript to see what they are (we cover other mysteries too, like "Why does the US restrict high-skill immigration?"): rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-243-bryan-caplan-on…
/6
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... and kudos to @bryan_caplan and @ZachWeiner for an excellent book:
www.amazon.com/Open-Borders-Science-Ethics-Immigration-eb… -
Julia Galef reposted
Dr. Jenn Veilleux
@JennCVeilleux
Jeopardy had a clue about p- hacking today! (And kinda screwed up p-values all at the same time.)
-
Julia Galef reposted
Devon ☀️
@devonzuegel
Broke: Most people are too sensitive to receive feedback.
Woke: Most relationships don't have sufficient context, investment, or trust for feedback to be taken in good faith. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I've never met economics Nobel laureate Abhijit Banerjee, but I can tell I would like him because of how long he thinks about questions before answering
www.theguardian.com/books/2012/apr/22/abhijit-banerjee-po… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A corollary to Gell-Mann amnesia:
In dialogue with people I often realize they've misunderstood my point the 1st (or 2nd, or 3rd) time I try to express it
But then when I'm writing a talk / article / etc. I just blithely assume everyone will understand the whole thing perfectly -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
oh, so google is taking sides in the probability wars now ??
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Something heartwarming about the internet: How it can be a lifeline for kids in abusive families who didn’t know enough to object, until they saw people online discussing abuse.
Hate to think what it must’ve been like 200 years ago without that lifeline.
www.reddit.com/r/raisedbynarcissists/comments/76sup5/when… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I really have to start checking the name of the account *before* I react to the tweet
Second World War tweets from 1941
@RealTimeWWII
Serbia: Nazi occupiers announce that as "reprisal" for 10 Germans killed by partisans, they will shoot 2300 civilians in town of Kragujevac.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A habit I'm starting to pick up: When you realize someone you disagreed with in the past was actually right, email them and let them know (even if the disagreement was months / years ago)
Benefits:
(1) It's nice for them to hear it
(2) It makes the update stickier for you -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Some of the responses to this thread don’t seem to appreciate that this isn’t just another case of “Oh, social science doesn’t replicate, what else is new”
This is different. Zimbardo has been actively misrepresenting his “experiment” for decades. (cont...)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My latest podcast, in which I am dumbfounded at how much of a sham the Stanford Prison Experiment turned out to be: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-241-thibault-le-tex… (audio & transcript)
How did this remain reputable for decades??
Thanks to my guest Thibault Le Texier for his stellar investigative work.Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Even as recently as last year, on the Tim Ferris show, Zimbardo was talking about the SPE as if the guards' behavior (which he directed!) was surprising to him:
tim.blog/2018/06/05/the-tim-ferriss-show-transcripts-dr-p…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's a pre-print of Le Texier's paper, with lots of quotes from the experiment:
www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/2019-letexier.pdf -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My latest podcast, in which I am dumbfounded at how much of a sham the Stanford Prison Experiment turned out to be: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-241-thibault-le-tex… (audio & transcript)
How did this remain reputable for decades??
Thanks to my guest Thibault Le Texier for his stellar investigative work.Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I hate accusing Zimbardo (or anyone) of lying, but I don't see how else to interpret this.
He has described the SPE, for decades, as revealing something about human nature, about how easily good people can behave badly.
But it's... more like a dramatic play he wrote & directed?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When challenged Zimbardo has fallen back on "sure, fine, it's not technically an experiment" -- but he still doesn't seem to be acknowledging that he predetermined the results!
From a 2018 Vox interview w/@B_resnick:
www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/6/28/17509470/stanfor… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"Within four months we shall in all probability have completed the most terrible weapon ever known in human history, one bomb of which could destroy a whole city."
... a hell of a way to begin a memo
Luke Muehlhauser
@lukeprog
Possibly the most succinct statement of the "atomic bomb deployment problem" is this remarkable memo from Secretary of War Henry Stimson to President Truman in April 1945: www.doug-long.com/stim425.htm.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Have you ever thought "That person / company / etc. is being irrational"
... and then when you dug into the details, realized you were wrong -- that their strategy actually made sense, or that their goals were different than you assumed?
I'd be interested to hear examples! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Does anyone have a charitable explanation for why PETA ran this campaign against "anti-animal idioms" last year?
It's hard for me to see why they would have thought this would be net effective for their goals, even indirectly. Any ideas?
mashable.com/article/peta-anti-animal-language-twitter/
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(NOTE: Lots of people offering *uncharitable* explanations, but that's not very helpful. My default was already to suspect an uncharitable explanation; I'm trying to see what I'm missing, if anything)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My friend Hjalti makes these amazingly clever Lego puzzle boxes, for his nephew:
Hjalti Hjálmarsson🔸
@hjalti
The 4th #lego #puzzle box I made has three clues: Icelandic flag, number 19 and a 6-digit combination of colors.
Solution: Iceland got its independence in 1944 so you need to write the number 44 in binary using the black (0/off) and white (1/on) colors which would be “101100” -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Great analysis of the backlash to plant-based burgers, by @KelseyTuoc:
www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/10/7/20880318/meatless-me… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Every one of my attempts to fairly paraphrase this writer's argument against Impossible Burgers came out sounding like a straw man
"Killing animals is good because it forces you to grapple with the morality of killing animals" ?
gah
heated.medium.com/the-absurdity-of-alternative-meats-9d54… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A type of claim that makes me instantly discount a speaker:
"... I've observed many different cases, and *every single one* turned out to support my thesis"
(Example: "I've talked with many conservatives about this issue, and every single one has said that their opinion is X")
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(Another example: "Here's my thesis about what makes an entrepreneur succeed. I've observed many entrepreneurs and every single one that succeeds has this trait; every single one that fails does not")
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Here's one of several examples I've noticed recently, this one from Jim Collins in "Good to Great", talking about how literally all of the best leaders he studied had this rare trait of what he calls Level 5 leadership (humble, basically):
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
After my suspicions were raised, I found this paper arguing that the pattern Collins found was likely to be just a result of data mining (I haven't checked their argument closely): www.jstor.org/stable/27747475
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Is this photo caption throwing shade at Mirren for making a dumb point, or am I imagining it?? I can't tell
HED: "Helen Mirren: nobody is all male or female"
CAPTION: "Helen Mirren... says she has lots of male qualities, such as being good at map-reading"
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/helen-mirren-nobody-is-all-mal…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hey @mattmoorek -- what's the answer?? Please tell us
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I'm becoming increasingly depressed at how many respectable institutions are willing to sell their credibility to Amway and other MLMs.
Another example: Harvard's school of government, @kennedy_school, which has been helping Amway gain China's trust:
www.washingtonpost.com/business/amway-thrives-in-china-wi… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Hey @CBSNews why do you let your columnists promote an exploitative pyramid scheme like Amway?
(Article from 2011, but it still comes up in search results)
There’s not even any indication this is sponsored content.
www.cbsnews.com/news/why-you-should-join-amway/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A researcher spends ~116 hrs applying for each federal grant. Do grant applications need to be so long?
If I were head of NSF/NIH I'd try a pilot w/applications that take only ~8 hrs, then see if the research it funds turns out any less valuable than normal. Has that been tried?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Citation for my "116 hours" claim: journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone…
I'm sure the exact number of hours varies from field to field, but it's definitely a LOT in generalPost not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
-- and the answer to that question depends on how good the NSF / NIH funders are at predicting which research projects are going to be most valuable.
(And how much funders' prediction accuracy increases with the # of researcher hours spent preparing their applications)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I mean, who knows, maybe the current tradeoff we're making IS pretty close to optimal. But I'm surprised at the # of people who are so confident that it's optimal that it doesn't even strike them as worth checking to find out.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Does anyone know of any good companies in NYC looking for a systems administrator?
Someone involved with my podcast is a sysadmin looking for a job; I can strongly vouch for their character and reliability. DMs are open if you have any leads for me - thanks! -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"People call politicians flip-floppers if they change their mind" is a standard example of how society discourages mind-changing
But I wonder what % of "flip-flopper" accusations are actually cases of *good* mind changes, vs just politically expedient mind changes
Might be low
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
... OK, this wasn't as clear as I thought.
My point was that the "It's good to change your mind!" crowd (which I count myself in) has maybe been unfair to the people who complain about flip-flopping politicians
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Note to Self: *If you want your followers to understand you, maybe do fewer tweets in which you object to a common objection to a common objection to a common phenomenon*
-
Julia Galef reposted
Mason
@webdevMason
I'd like to invite parents + kids to have a chat with me for up to 60 min — specifically, I'd love to chat with kids who are having trouble fitting into school. You don't have to agree with me, and I won't try to sway your kids. Just listen and brainstorm. calendly.com/masonhartman
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
ME, reading: "What a nice quote, I wonder who is the paragon of intellectual honesty who said thi-- oh god"
-
Julia Galef reposted
Mason
@webdevMason
We've gotta confront the fact that a lot of people want the thing they call Science (popular narrative convergence on academic work, actually) to tell them how to do life, and for the prescription to be roughly what they expected all along, while also fully relevant to the moment
-
Julia Galef reposted
Christopher Sebela
@xtophersebela
The smithsonian offers free downloads of 3D scans of objects in their collection and that’s why I now have a Lidded Ewer from 1050 BCE to put my weed in.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I don't get recognized irl by a Twitter follower all that often, but when I do it's invariably someone cool
... and sometimes they even give me a sticker of the Reverend Bayes: -
Julia Galef reposted
Brian Wecht
@bwecht
Audrey (5yo) just did a little science experiment and then screamed “No scientists know this! I *am* science!!!” so I’m like 90% sure we’re raising a supervillain
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I find the "Are male & female brains different?" debate so frustrating. It's a refreshing change to discuss it with a really smart, careful thinker like @salonium!
Audio + transcript of our episode on gender & the brain, and what makes this debate so bad: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-239-saloni-dattani-…
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Come for the hot button topic, stay for Julia trying to draw causal diagrams in the air
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is @salonium's great article that inspired the discussion -- a review of the recent book *The Gendered Brain*, and the broader cluster of books trying to debunk "neurosexism"
unherd.com/2019/08/the-truth-about-the-female-brain/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of my favorite ways to learn about a field, or a thinker, is to discuss what they've changed their mind about.
New podcast episode, with the always-interesting @razibkhan:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-238-razib-khan-on-s…
(Audio and transcript at the link) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This New York-style hotel was built in Minecraft 🤯
www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/clirw6/a_new_york_sty… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Razib Khan (@razibkhan) lists some of the things he's changed his mind about over the years:
www.gnxp.com/WordPress/2019/08/05/stuff-i-was-wrong-about -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
.@Noahpinion jokes that the game of Monopoly is about the dysfunction of land use economics in San Francisco, turns out to be accidentally correct
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Huh. I thought I was joking but I turned out not to be joking.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Landlord's_Game -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I spoke w/@ShuhBillSkee who thinks concerns about social media & smartphones are unfounded.
Audio + transcript:
rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-237-andy-przybylski…
We discuss:
- Studies showing ppl are happier after deactivating FB
- Rise in depression since smartphones took over
- Is Tech at fault at all? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love UC Berkeley's prominent "warnings" that they don't endorse the use of Sci Hub :)
Reminds me of the Prohibition-era merchants who sold bricks of concentrated grape juice w/labels like "Warning: do not dissolve in 1 gallon of water & ferment for 20 days, or wine may result" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Instead of an "edit" button, how about an "annotate" button?
It would let you correct an error by adding a note on top of the original tweet
(and it wouldn't have the edit button's potential for mischief, where people could change a tweet to something bad after others share it) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I like this idea for improving on funerals.
In general I think situations where the status quo is to spend $ to buy a sense of meaning, or to show we care, tend to have a lot of low-hanging fruit like this.
acritch.com/effective-funerals/ -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I agree. IMO the elephant in the room is that @Superhuman could easily add a signature to emails saying "This email has tracking turned on" or something like that, right? The fact that they're still unwilling to do so seems pretty damning.
Josh Constine 📶🔥
@JoshConstine
I appreciate Superhuman’s changes, but the problem is recipients don’t know they’re tracked, and it’s still not going to warn them
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Superhuman CEO @rahulvohra says the best solution for recipients who don't want to be tracked is to turn off remote image loading. But many (most?) people aren't even aware email tracking is a thing, or that this is a way to protect themselves from it.
blog.superhuman.com/read-statuses-bdf0cc34b6a5
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
So why not inform recipients in the emails?? eg
"This email uses tracking by @Superhuman. To opt out of being tracked, you can turn off image loading. Learn more here."
or something like that -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I wish there were more blog posts / columns doing what @kdrum did in this 2004 post -- i.e., thinking out loud to try to figure out your views on a topic:
washingtonmonthly.com/2004/06/10/torture-13/
(Also this really made me miss the golden age of blogging) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Do your part! File a claim for your $125 in the Equifax settlement, whether or not you care about the money: www.equifaxbreachsettlement.com
I hate filling out forms online, but this one was very easy -- took me less than 2 minutes.
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
Anyway, be spiteful, claim your money from the Equifax data breach even if you don't need the money: slate.com/technology/2019/07/equifax-settlement-money-how….
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
When you share/retweet some news that outrages you:
Do you usually do so bc you expect it to be good for the world if more people like your followers are made aware of that news?
Or do you usually share it for some other reason (e.g. the pleasure of shared venting)? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a very silly definition of "irrational"
(from the Guru Guide to Entrepreneurship, in a chapter on the importance of being irrationally confident in your plans) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Any of my friends know of interesting job opportunities in the Boston area, for a talented data scientist with an MS in machine learning and ~one year of work experience?
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
(DM's temporarily open)
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I figured out why I dislike the redesign:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Nightmare fuel Wallace & Gromit
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Wondering why the escalator at 24th Mission BART was closed for weeks?
A pigeon nested in it, & BART thought (wrongly!) they couldn't legally move a nest.
(The ban on moving nests doesn't apply to pigeons, as a 5-minute google search would've revealed)
www.kqed.org/news/11762715/bart-nesting-pigeons-got-in-th… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Why have prices of health care & education gone up SO much? (~200% in just 20 years)
My latest podcast is with economist @ATabarrok who blames a phenomenon called the Baumol Effect. Audio + transcript: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-236-alex-tabarrok-o…
Lots of interesting questions here! Thread: (1/n)Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
We also discussed Scott's (@slatestarcodex) disagreement with Alex's thesis, which was over whether there has in fact been a dramatic rise in wages in health care and education (6/n)
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My realization in the podcast (tell me if you think this is right, @slatestarcodex) is that they disagree bc Alex is counting more things as part of the Baumol Effect than Scott is, like hiring more teachers, aides, etc (7/n)
Scott's disagreement w/Alex: slatestarcodex.com/2019/06/17/followup-on-the-baumol-effe… -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
You know you live in San Francisco when you spot a coffee stirrer on the floor, and your brain instantly goes "NEEDLE!"
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
How is it possible that fewer people agree with 1 than 2:
1) "If DeepNudes were 99% accurate, they would be unethical"
2) "DeepNudes are unethical" ??
Do people think current DeepNudes are > 99% accurate??
I'm so confused. Someone who said no to 1, yes to 2, please explain
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
To clarify, my confusion isn't because I expected the two poll outcomes to be identical.
It's because I expected the % saying "unethical" in the 99% accurate case to be *much higher,* so the fact that it's *slightly lower* is very surprising. -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Imagine DeepNudes were known to be 99% predictive* of what people actually look like nude.
*Meaning, if judges are shown a mix of real photos of someone nude, & DeepNudes, they can't tell the difference
In such a world, would it be unethical to publish DeepNudes of someone? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Do you consider it unethical to publish DeepNudes of someone?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
How do you feel about people using email read receipts? (i.e., invisible pixel in the email detects when you open it, and notifies sender of the time it was opened)
Let's assume
- email from individuals, not mass mailings
- they don't disclose they're using read receipts -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Is any architect out there trying to bring ornamentation back? I love all the elaborate detail on these pre-war facades. Even the most architecturally creative buildings nowadays never seem to have detail at this small scale -- did literally everyone decide it's bad?
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Things to ask yourself if you think someone's wrong (1/n)
1. Is there another interpretation of their words?
EXAMPLE: A sign said “No human is illegal.” I thought it meant it was wrong to enforce immigration law. But it meant labeling people “illegals” was stigmatizing language. -
Post not available here, view on X
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This feels like a sensible a priori hypothesis to have, but one that doesn’t actually survive the real-world evidence
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Three different things people mean by "I'm an optimist"
1) "I try to perceive the world accurately, and my honest assessment is that things are great"
2) "I try to perceive the world positively, regardless of whether that's accurate"
3) "I am cheerful and like solving problems" -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My favorite solution to the Marshmallow Test: A friend-of-a-friend's kid, who picked up the marshmallow, carefully scooped out its insides, ate them, and replaced the hollowed-out marshmallow back on its plate as if nothing had happened. A+
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
"The reason the stock market is hard to predict is because it is a prediction."
(Andrew Critch, source: futureoflife.org/2017/07/31/podcast-art-predicting-anthon…) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
My trusty list of places I visit in any new city (excluding food):
1. Gardens/parks
2. Public transit
3. Unique bookstores (eg Powell's, Strand)
4. Hotel with a rooftop lounge (great view for the price of a drink)
5. Central library (often has cool architecture)
6. College campus -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
New podcast episode with one of my favorite scientists, @eboyden3, about his two innovations that revolutionized neuroscience, & how to generate original ideas: rationallyspeakingpodcast.org/show/rs-212-ed-boyden-on-ho…
Transcript available! In the excerpt below, Ed explains a technique he calls "Tiling Trees": -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
OK, I'll say it: I think most people are bad at optimizing bread & butter
Most people could double their portion of butter & halve their portion of bread and end up better off w/r/t to both healthfulness AND tastiness
Y'all are far from the pareto frontier & it hurts me -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
One of my new favorite questions to ask researchers/authors:
"What are the main ways people misunderstand your thesis?"
A surprisingly quick way to hone in on the interesting and non-obvious bits of their model. Plus, their answer is always so animated :) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
We're hiring! @open_phil is a small team deciding how to give away billions of $; working here is a very high-leverage way to impact humanity. If you're analytical, truth-seeking, & comfortable making EV estimates, you should join us. More about the job: medium.com/@acotra2017/hiring-analytical-thinkers-to-help…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Nerdiest joke I've heard all month:
"Did you know that Jesus was pro-choice?
You try explaining the loaves and the fishes without using Banach-Tarski."
(From: etirabys.tumblr.com/post/171671498592/frosty-mage-stuff-s…) -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Great, insight-dense interview with Holden Karnofsky, co-founder of @GiveWell and @open_phil, on the @80000Hours podcast: 80000hours.org/2018/02/holden-karnofsky-open-philanthropy/
I excerpted one of Holden's points, about how there just isn't a home in academia for some really valuable kinds of research: -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Yikes, Wikipedia 😕
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Atherton, an especially posh suburb in Silicon Valley, has the most entertaining police blotter www.mercurynews.com/2011/08/27/the-best-of-atherton-polic…
Some of my favorite items: -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I don't know who first referred to Bitcoins as "Dunning-Krugerrands" but I love it
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
1) "Pink elephants on parade," the dream sequence in Dumbo, is 100% nightmare fuel, full of grinning, mutating grotesques: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pl3YXl_m0uk
Did you ever wonder what it was doing in the middle of Dumbo? Not just tonally but stylistically anomalous in a Disney kids' movie? -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Aquarium rewards dolphins w/a fish if they bring a piece of litter or dead gull (to help keep pool clean)
One dolphin starts (1) tearing pieces of litter into smaller pieces & trading each piece in for a reward & (2) stockpiling fish to lure & kill gulls
www.theguardian.com/science/2003/jul/03/research.science -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I love this idea! Wish I'd had it in my math textbooks in college.
Jan Willem Tulp
@JanWillemTulp
colorized math equations makes it easier to understand. Great idea!! #ux #math betterexplained.com/articles/colorized-math-equations/
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Time travelers at the art museum. More here: etirabys.tumblr.com/post/167880181384/cosetteskywalker-my…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Venn diagram of shared/unshared letters between Latin, Greek, and Cyrillic alphabets:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
A very dishonest misrepresentation of Charles Koch's point - 1st pic is TIME's pull quote, 2nd is Koch's quote in context (in article):
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Adorable article from 1984, about this new & exciting tool called a "spreadsheet" www.wired.com/2014/10/a-spreadsheet-way-of-knowledge/
So many good quotes: -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Stuff I can't believe isn't taught in HS:
1. Basic stats
2. Basic econ
3. Personal finance (eg, credit scores)
4. First aid /emergency prep -
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
I really wish it was easier to say "That's a bad argument against X" without people hearing "I support X"
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Still my favorite headline of all time:
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
This is a very ominous first paragraph of a textbook (States of Matter, by David Goodstein):
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
Maybe psychology should quit trying to *explain* things, and just try to *predict* them instead. From @talyarkoni: figshare.com/articles/Choosing_prediction_over_explanatio…
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
The 2005 tape isn’t costing Trump support bc it’s surprising, but bc it creates common knowledge. His supporters lose plausible deniability.
-
Julia Galef
@juliagalef
New video: A visual guide to Bayesian thinking
www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrK7X_XlGB8




















































































































































































































































